diff options
| author | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 05:28:38 -0700 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 05:28:38 -0700 |
| commit | 0d7ed7dfa92e125f1fdbfd45b43c15ffafac5c81 (patch) | |
| tree | cdbf07a841e39b24daf3c8965d57860da5b773f5 /6967-8.txt | |
Diffstat (limited to '6967-8.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | 6967-8.txt | 15927 |
1 files changed, 15927 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/6967-8.txt b/6967-8.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..83d39ec --- /dev/null +++ b/6967-8.txt @@ -0,0 +1,15927 @@ +The Project Gutenberg EBook of The History of the Reign of Ferdinand +and Isabella The Catholic, Vol. 2, by William H. Prescott +#3 in our series by William H. Prescott + +Copyright laws are changing all over the world. Be sure to check the +copyright laws for your country before downloading or redistributing +this or any other Project Gutenberg eBook. + +This header should be the first thing seen when viewing this Project +Gutenberg file. Please do not remove it. Do not change or edit the +header without written permission. + +Please read the "legal small print," and other information about the +eBook and Project Gutenberg at the bottom of this file. Included is +important information about your specific rights and restrictions in +how the file may be used. You can also find out about how to make a +donation to Project Gutenberg, and how to get involved. + + +**Welcome To The World of Free Plain Vanilla Electronic Texts** + +**eBooks Readable By Both Humans and By Computers, Since 1971** + +*****These eBooks Were Prepared By Thousands of Volunteers!***** + + +Title: The History of the Reign of Ferdinand and Isabella The Catholic, V2 + +Author: William H. Prescott + +Release Date: November, 2004 [EBook #6967] +[Yes, we are more than one year ahead of schedule] +[This file was first posted on February 18, 2003] + +Edition: 10 + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: Latin-1 + +*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK FERDINAND AND ISABELLA, VOL. 2 *** + + + + +This eBook was produced by: Anne Soulard, Tiffany Vergon, +Charles Aldarondo and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team. + + + + +HISTORY OF THE REIGN OF FERDINAND AND ISABELLA, THE CATHOLIC. + +BY +WILLIAM H. PRESCOTT. + +IN THREE VOLUMES. +VOL. II. + + + + +CONTENTS OF VOLUME II. + + +PART FIRST. [CONTINUED.] + +CHAPTER XII. + INTERNAL AFFAIRS OF THE KINGDOM.--INQUISITION IN ARAGON. + ISABELLA ENFORCES THE LAWS + CHASTISEMENT OF CERTAIN ECCLESIASTICS + MARRIAGE OF CATHARINE OF NAVARRE + LIBERATION OF CATALAN SERFS + INQUISITION IN ARAGON + REMONSTRANCES OF CORTES + CONSPIRACY FORMED + ASSASSINATION OF ARBUES + CRUEL PERSECUTIONS + INQUISITION THROUGHOUT FERDINAND'S DOMINIONS + +CHAPTER XIII. + WAR OF GRANADA.--SURRENDER OF VELEZ MALAGA.--SIEGE AND CONQUEST + OF MALAGA. + POSITION OF VELEZ MALAGA + ARMY BEFORE VELEZ + DEFEAT OF EL ZAGAL + NARROW ESCAPE OF FERDINAND + SURRENDER OF VELEZ + DESCRIPTION OF MALAGA + SHARP RECONTRE + MALAGA INVESTED BY SEA AND LAND + BRILLIANT SPECTACLE + EXTENSIVE PREPARATIONS + THE QUEEN VISITS THE CAMP + SUMMONS OF THE TOWN + DANGER OF THE MARQUIS OF CADIZ + CIVIL FEUDS OF THE MOORS + ATTEMPT TO ASSASSINATE THE SOVEREIGNS + DISTRESS AND RESOLUTION OF THE BESIEGED + ENTHUSIASM OF THE CHRISTIANS + DISCIPLINE OF THE ARMY + GENERAL SALLY + GENEROSITY OF A MOORISH KNIGHT + OUTWORKS CARRIED + GRIEVOUS FAMINE + PROPOSALS FOR SURRENDER + HAUGHTY DEMEANOR OF FERDINAND + MALAGA SURRENDERS AT DISCRETION + PURIFICATION OF THE CITY + ENTRANCE OF THE SOVEREIGNS + RELEASE OF CHRISTIAN CAPTIVES + LAMENT OF THE MALAGANS + SENTENCE PASSED ON THEM + WARY DEVICE OF FERDINAND + CRUEL POLICY OF THE VICTORS + MEASURES FOR REPEOPLING MALAGA + +CHAPTER XIV. + WAR OF GRANADA.--CONQUEST OF BAZA.--SUBMISSION OF EL ZAGAL. + THE SOVEREIGNS VISIT ARAGON + INROADS INTO GRANADA + BORDER WAR + EMBASSY FROM MAXIMILIAN + PREPARATIONS FOR THE SIEGE OF BAZA + THE KING TAKES COMMAND OF THE ARMY + POSITION AND STRENGTH OF BAZA + ASSAULT ON THE GARDEN + DESPONDENCY OF THE SPANISH CHIEFS + DISPELLED BY ISABELLA + GARDENS CLEARED OF THEIR TIMBER + CITY CLOSELY INVESTED + MISSION FROM THE SULTAN OF EGYPT + HOUSES ERECTED FOB THE ARMY + ITS STRICT DISCIPLINE + HEAVY TEMPEST + ISABELLA'S ENERGY + HER PATRIOTIC SACRIFICES + RESOLUTION OF THE BESIEGED + ISABELLA VISITS THE CAMP + SUSPENSION OF ARMS + BAZA SURRENDERS + CONDITIONS + OCCUPATION OF THE CITY + TREATY OF SURRENDER WITH EL ZAGAL + PAINFUL MARCH OF THE SPANISH ARMY + INTERVIEW BETWEEN FERDINAND AND EL ZAGAL + OCCUPATION OF EL ZAGAL'S DOMAIN + EQUIVALENT ASSIGNED TO HIM + DIFFICULTIES OF THIS CAMPAIGN + ISABELLA'S POPULARITY AND INFLUENCE + NOTICE OF PETER MARTYR + +CHAPTER XV. + WAR OF GRANADA.-SIEGE AND SURRENDER OF THE CITY OF GRANADA. + THE INFANTA ISABELLA + PUBLIC FESTIVITIES + GRANADA SUMMONED IN VAIN + KNIGHTHOOD OF DON JUAN + FERDINAND'S POLICY + ISABELLA DEPOSES THE JUDGES OF CHANCERY + FERDINAND MUSTERS HIS FORCES + ENCAMPS IN THE VEGA + POSITION OF GRANADA + MOSLEM AND CHRISTIAN CHIVALRY + THE QUEEN SURVEYS THE CITY + SKIRMISH WITH THE ENEMY + CONFLAGRATION OF THE CHRISTIAN CAMP + ERECTION OF SANTA FE + NEGOTIATIONS FOR SURRENDER + CAPITULATION OF GRANADA + COMMOTIONS IN GRANADA + PREPARATIONS FOR OCCUPYING THE CITY + THE CROSS RAISED ON THE ALHAMBRA + FATE OF ABDALLAH + RESULTS OF THE WAR OF GRANADA + ITS MORAL INFLUENCE + ITS MILITARY INFLUENCE + DESTINY OF THE MOORS + DEATH AND CHARACTER OF THE MARQUIS OF CADIZ + NOTICE OF BERNALDEZ, CURATE OF LOS PALACIOS + IRVING'S CHRONICLE OF GRANADA + +CHAPTER XVI. + APPLICATION OF CHRISTOPHER COLUMBUS AT THE SPANISH COURT. + MARITIME ENTERPRISE OF THE PORTUGUESE + EARLY SPANISH DISCOVERIES + EARLY HISTORY OF COLUMBUS + BELIEF OF LAND IN THE WEST + COLUMBUS APPLIES TO PORTUGAL + TO THE COURT OF CASTILE + REFERRED TO A COUNCIL + HIS APPLICATION REJECTED + HE PREPARES TO LEAVE SPAIN + INTERPOSITION IN HIS BEHALF + COLUMBUS AT SANTA FE + NEGOTIATIONS AGAIN BROKEN OFF + THE QUEEN'S FAVORABLE DISPOSITION + FINAL ARRANGEMENT WITH COLUMBUS + HE SAILS ON HIS FIRST VOYAGE + INDIFFERENCE TO HIS ENTERPRISE + ACKNOWLEDGMENTS DUE TO ISABELLA + NOTICE OF NAVARRETE + +CHAPTER XVII. + EXPULSION OF THE JEWS FROM SPAIN. + EXCITEMENT AGAINST THE JEWS + FOMENTED BY THE CLERGY + VIOLENT CONDUCT OF TORQUEMADA + EDICT OF EXPULSION + ITS SEVERE OPERATION + CONSTANCY OF THE JEWS + ROUTES OF THE EMIGRANTS + THEIR SUFFERINGS IN AFRICA + IN OTHER COUNTRIES + WHOLE NUMBER OF EXILES + DISASTROUS RESULTS + TRUE MOTIVES OF THE EDICT + CONTEMPORARY JUDGMENTS + MISTAKEN PIETY OF THE QUEEN + +CHAPTER XVIII. + ATTEMPTED ASSASSINATION OF FERDINAND.--RETURN AND SECOND VOYAGE OF + COLUMBUS. + THE SOVEREIGNS VISIT ARAGON + ATTEMPT ON FERDINAND'S LIFE + GENERAL CONSTERNATION + LOYALTY OF THE PEOPLE + SLOW RECOVERY OF THE KING + PUNISHMENT OF THE ASSASSIN + RETURN OF COLUMBUS + DISCOVERY OF THE WEST INDIES + JOYOUS RECEPTION OF COLUMBUS + HIS PROGRESS TO BARCELONA + INTERVIEW WITH THE SOVEREIGNS + SENSATIONS CAUSED BY THE DISCOVERY + BOARD FOR INDIAN AFFAIRS + REGULATIONS OF TRADE + PREPARATIONS FOR A SECOND VOYAGE + CONVERSION OF THE NATIVES + NEW POWERS GRANTED TO COLUMBUS + APPLICATION TO ROME + FAMOUS BULLS OF ALEXANDER VI + JEALOUSY OF THE COURT OF LISBON + WARY DIPLOMACY + SECOND VOYAGE OF COLUMBUS + MISSION TO PORTUGAL + DISGUST OF JOHN II + TREATY OF TORDESILLAS + +CHAPTER XIX. + CASTILIAN LITERATURE.--CULTIVATION OF THE COURT.--CLASSICAL LEARNING.-- + SCIENCE. + FERDINAND'S EDUCATION NEGLECTED + INSTRUCTION OF ISABELLA + HER COLLECTION OF BOOKS + TUITION OF THE INFANTAS + OF PRINCE JOHN + THE QUEEN'S CARE FOR THE EDUCATION OF HER NOBLES + LABORS OF MARTYR + OF LUCIO MARINEO + SCHOLARSHIP OF THE NOBLES + ACCOMPLISHED WOMEN + CLASSICAL LEARNING + LEBRIJA + ARIAS BARBOSA + MERITS OF THE SPANISH SCHOLARS + UNIVERSITIES + SACRED STUDIES + OTHER SCIENCES + PRINTING INTRODUCED + THE QUEEN ENCOURAGES IT + ITS RAPID DIFFUSION + ACTUAL PROGRESS OF SCIENCE + +CHAPTER XX. + CASTILIAN LITERATURE.--ROMANCES OF CHIVALRY.--LYRICAL POETRY.-- + THE DRAMA. + THIS REIGN AN EPOCH IN POLITE LETTERS + ROMANCES OF CHIVALRY + THEIR PERNICIOUS EFFECTS + BALLADS OR ROMANCES + EARLY CULTIVATION IN SPAIN + RESEMBLANCE TO THE ENGLISH + MOORISH MINSTRELSY + ITS DATE AND ORIGIN + ITS HIGH REPUTE + NUMEROUS EDITIONS OF THE BALLADS + LYRIC POETRY + CANCIONERO GENERAL + ITS LITERARY VALUE + LOW STATE OF LYRIC POETRY + COPLAS OF MANRIQUE + RISE OF THE SPANISH DRAMA + TRAGICOMEDY OF CELESTINA + CRITICISM ON IT + IT OPENED THE WAY TO DRAMATIC WRITING + NUMEROUS EDITIONS OF IT + JUAN DE LA ENCINA + HIS DRAMATIC ECLOGUES + TORRES DE NAHARRO + HIS COMEDIES + SIMILAR IN SPIRIT WITH THE LATER DRAMAS + NOT ACTED IN SPAIN + LOW CONDITION OF THE STAGE + TRAGIC DRAMA + OLIVA'S CLASSIC IMITATIONS + NOT POPULAR + NATIONAL SPIRIT OF THE LITERATURE OF THIS EPOCH + MORATIN'S DRAMATIC CRITICISM + +PART SECOND. + +THE PERIOD WHEN, THE INTERIOR ORGANIZATION OF THE MONARCHY HAVING BEEN +COMPLETED, THE SPANISH NATION ENTERED ON ITS SCHEMES OF DISCOVERY AND +CONQUEST; OR THE PERIOD ILLUSTRATING MORE PARTICULARLY THE FOREIGN POLICY +OF FERDINAND AND ISABELLA. + +CHAPTER I. + ITALIAN WARS.--GENERAL VIEW OF EUROPE.--INVASION OF ITALY BY CHARLES + VIII., OF FRANCE. + FOREIGN POLITICS DIRECTED BY FERDINAND + EUROPE AT THE CLOSE OF THE FIFTEENTH CENTURY + CHARACTER OF THE REIGNING SOVEREIGNS + IMPROVED POLITICAL AND MORAL CONDITION + MORE INTIMATE RELATIONS BETWEEN STATES + FOREIGN RELATIONS CONDUCTED BY THE SOVEREIGN + ITALY THE SCHOOL OF POLITICS + HER MOST POWERFUL STATES + CHARACTER OF ITALIAN POLITICS + INTERNAL PROSPERITY + INTRIGUES OF SFORZA + CHARLES VIII., OF FRANCE + HIS PRETENSIONS TO NAPLES + NEGOTIATIONS RESPECTING ROUSSILLON + CHARLES'S COUNSELLORS IN THE PAY OP FERDINAND + TREATY OF BARCELONA + ITS IMPORTANCE TO SPAIN + ALARM AT THE FRENCH INVASION, IN ITALY + IN EUROPE, ESPECIALLY SPAIN + PREPARATIONS OF CHARLES + AN ENVOY SENT TO THE FRENCH COURT + ANNOUNCES FERDINAND'S VIEWS + CHARLES'S DISSATISFACTION + THE FRENCH CROSS THE ALPS + ITALIAN TACTICS + THE SWISS INFANTRY + FRENCH ARTILLERY + SFORZA JEALOUS OF THE FRENCH + THE POPE CONFERS THE TITLE OF CATHOLIC + NAVAL PREPARATIONS IN SPAIN + SECOND MISSION TO CHARLES VIII + BOLD CONDUCT OF THE ENVOYS + THE KING OF NAPLES FLIES TO SICILY + THE FRENCH ENTER NAPLES + GENERAL HOSTILITY TO THEM + LEAGUE OF VENICE + ZURITA'S LIFE AND WRITINGS + +CHAPTER II. + ITALIAN WARS.--RETREAT OF CHARLES VIII.--CAMPAIGNS OF GONSALVO DE + CORDOVA.--FINAL EXPULSION OF THE FRENCH. + CONDUCT OF CHARLES + PLUNDERS THE WORKS OF ART + RETREAT OF THE FRENCH GONSALVO DE CORDOVA + HIS EARLY LIFE + HIS BRILLIANT QUALITIES + RAISED TO THE ITALIAN COMMAND + ARRIVES IN ITALY + LANDS IN CALABRIA + MARCHES ON SEMINARA + GONSALVO'S PRUDENCE + BATTLE OF SEMINARA + DEFEAT OF THE NEAPOLITANS + GONSALVO RETREATS TO REGGIO + FERDINAND RECOVERS HIS CAPITAL + GONSALVO IN CALABRIA + HIS SUCCESSES + DECLINE OF THE FRENCH + BESIEGED IN ATELLA + GONSALVO SURPRISES LAINO + ARRIVES BEFORE ATELLA + RECEIVES THE TITLE OF GREAT CAPTAIN + BEATS A DETACHMENT OF SWISS + CAPITULATION OF MONTPENSIER + MISERABLE STATE OF THE FRENCH + DEATH OF FERDINAND OF NAPLES + ACCESSION OF FREDERIC II + TOTAL EXPULSION OF THE FRENCH + REMARKS ON GUICCIARDINI AND GIOVIO + SISMONDI + +CHAPTER III. + ITALIAN WARS.--GONSALVO SUCCORS THE POPE.--TREATY WITH FRANCE.-- + ORGANIZATION OF THE SPANISH MILITIA. + WAR ON THE SIDE OF ROUSSILLON + THE POPE ASKS THE AID OF GONSALVO + STORMING AND CAPTURE OF OSTIA + GONSALVO ENTERS ROME + HIS RECEPTION BY THE POPE + RETURNS TO SPAIN + PEACE WITH FRANCE + FERDINAND'S VIEWS RESPECTING NAPLES + HIS FAME ACQUIRED BY THE WAR + INFLUENCE OF THE WAR ON SPAIN + ORGANIZATION OF THE MILITIA + +CHAPTER IV. + ALLIANCES OF THE ROYAL FAMILY.--DEATH OF PRINCE JOHN AND PRINCESS + ISABELLA. + ROYAL FAMILY OF CASTILE + JOANNA BELTRANEJA + MARRIAGE OF THE PRINCESS ISABELLA + DEATH OF HER HUSBAND + ALLIANCES WITH THE HOUSE OF AUSTRIA + AND THAT OF ENGLAND + JOANNA EMBARKS + THE QUEEN'S ANXIETY + MARGARET OF AUSTRIA + RETURNS IN THE FLEET + MARRIAGE OF JOHN AND MARGARET + SECOND MARRIAGE OF PRINCESS ISABELLA + SUDDEN ILLNESS OF PRINCE JOHN + HIS DEATH + HIS AMIABLE CHARACTER + THE KING AND QUEEN OF PORTUGAL VISIT SPAIN + OBJECTIONS TO THEIR RECOGNITION + ISABELLA DISPLEASED + HER DAUGHTER'S DEATH + ITS EFFECTS ON ISABELLA + PRINCE MIGUEL'S RECOGNITION + +CHAPTER V. + DEATH OF CARDINAL MENDOZA.--RISE OF XIMENES.--ECCLESIASTICAL REFORM. + DEATH OF MENDOZA + HIS EARLY LIFE + AND CHARACTER + HIS AMOURS + THE QUEEN HIS EXECUTOR + BIRTH OF XIMENES + HE VISITS ROME + HIS RETURN AND IMPRISONMENT + ESTABLISHED AT SIGUENZA + ENTERS THE FRANCISCAN ORDER + HIS SEVERE PENANCE + HIS ASCETIC LIFE + HE IS MADE GUARDIAN OF SALZEDA + INTRODUCED TO THE QUEEN + MADE HER CONFESSOR + ELECTED PROVINCIAL + CORRUPTION OF THE MONASTERIES + ATTEMPTS AT REFORM + SEE OF TOLEDO VACANT + OFFERED TO XIMENES + HE RELUCTANTLY ACCEPTS + CHARACTERISTIC ANECDOTES OF XIMENES + HIS AUSTERE LIFE + REFORM IN HIS DIOCESE + EXAMPLE OF HIS SEVERITY + REFORM OF THE MONASTIC ORDERS + GREAT EXCITEMENT CAUSED BY IT + VISIT OF THE FRANCISCAN GENERAL + INSULTS THE QUEEN + THE POPE'S INTERFERENCE + CONSENTS TO THE REFORM + ITS OPERATION AND EFFECTS + ALVARO GOMEZ, AND BIOGRAPHERS OF XIMENES + +CHAPTER VI. + XIMENES IN GRANADA.--PERSECUTION, INSURRECTION, AND CONVERSION OF THE + MOORS. + INTRODUCTORY REMARKS + XIMENES, HIS CONSTANCY OF PURPOSE + TRANQUIL STATE OF GRANADA + TENDILLA + TALAVERA + ARCHBISHOP OF GRANADA + HIS MILD POLICY + THE CLERGY DISSATISFIED WITH IT + TEMPERATE SWAY OF THE SOVEREIGNS + XIMENES IN GRANADA + HIS VIOLENT MEASURES + DESTROYS ARABIC BOOKS + MISCHIEVOUS EFFECTS + REVOLT OF THE ALBAYCIN + XIMENES BESIEGED IN HIS PALACE + THE INSURGENTS APPEASED BY TALAVERA + DISPLEASURE OF THE SOVEREIGNS + XIMENES HASTENS TO COURT + CONVERSION OP GRANADA + APPLAUDED BY THE SPANIARDS + +CHAPTER VII. + RISING IN THE ALPUXARRAS.--DEATH OF ALONSO DE AGUILAR.--EDICT AGAINST + THE MOORS. + THE ALPUXARRAS + RISING OF THE MOORS + HUEJA SACKED + FERDINAND MARCHES INTO THE MOUNTAINS + CARRIES LANJARON + PUNISHMENT OF THE REBELS + REVOLT OF THE SIERRA VERMEJA + RENDEZVOUS AT RONDA + EXPEDITION INTO THE SIERRA + THE MOORS RETREAT UP THE MOUNTAINS + RETURN ON THE SPANIARDS + ALONSO DE AGUILAR + HIS GALLANTRY AND DEATH + HIS NOBLE CHARACTER + BLOODY ROUT OF THE SPANIARDS + DISMAY OF THE NATION + THE REBELS SUBMIT TO FERDINAND + BANISHMENT OR CONVERSION + COMMEMORATIVE BALLADS + MELANCHOLY REMINISCENCES + EDICT AGAINST THE MOORS OF CASTILE + CHRISTIANITY AND MAHOMETANISM + CAUSES OF INTOLERANCE + AGGRAVATED IN THE FIFTEENTH CENTURY + EFFECTS OF THE INQUISITION + DEFECTS OF THE TREATY OF GRANADA + EVASION OF IT BY THE CHRISTIANS + PRIESTLY CASUISTRY + LAST NOTICE OF THE MOORS IN THE PRESENT REIGN + +CHAPTER VIII. + COLUMBUS.--PROSECUTION OF DISCOVERY.--HIS TREATMENT BY THE COURT. + PROGRESS OF DISCOVERY + MISCONDUCT OF THE COLONISTS + COMPLAINTS AGAINST COLUMBUS + HIS SECOND RETURN + THE QUEEN'S CONFIDENCE IN HIM UNSHAKEN + HONORS CONFERRED ON HIM + HIS THIRD VOYAGE + DISCOVERS TERRA FIRMA + MUTINY IN THE COLONY + LOUD COMPLAINTS AGAINST COLUMBUS + BIGOTED VIEWS IN REGARD TO THE HEATHEN + MORE LIBERAL SENTIMENTS OF ISABELLA + SHE SENDS BACK THE INDIAN SLAVES + AUTHORITY TO BOBADILLA + OUTRAGE ON COLUMBUS + DEEP REGRET OF THE SOVEREIGNS + RECEPTION OF COLUMBUS + VINDICATION OF THE SOVEREIGNS + COMMISSION TO OVANDO + GROUNDLESS IMPUTATIONS ON THE GOVERNMENT + THE ADMIRAL'S DESPONDENCY + HIS FOURTH AND LAST VOYAGE + REMARKABLE FATE OF HIS ENEMIES + +CHAPTER IX. + SPANISH COLONIAL POLICY. + CAREFUL PROVISION FOR THE COLONIES + LIBERAL GRANTS + LICENSE FOR PRIVATE VOYAGES + THEIR SUCCESS + INDIAN DEPARTMENT + CASA DE CONTRATACION + IMPORTANT PAPAL CONCESSIONS + SPIRIT OF THE COLONIAL LEGISLATION + THE QUEEN'S ZEAL FOB CONVERTING THE NATIVES + UNHAPPILY DEFEATED + IMMEDIATE PROFITS FROM THE DISCOVERIES + ORIGIN OF THE VENEREAL DISEASE + MORAL CONSEQUENCES OP THE DISCOVERIES + THEIR GEOGRAPHICAL EXTENT + HISTORIANS OF THE NEW WORLD + PETER MARTYR + HERRERA AND MUÑOZ + + + + +PART FIRST. [CONTINUED.] + + +CHAPTER XII. + +INTERNAL AFFAIRS OF THE KINGDOM.--INQUISITION IN ARAGON. + +1483-1487. + +Isabella enforces the Laws.--Punishment of Ecclesiastics.--Inquisition in +Aragon.--Remonstrances of the Cortes.--Conspiracy.--Assassination of the +Inquisitor Arbues.--Cruel Persecutions.--Inquisition throughout +Ferdinand's Dominions. + + +In such intervals of leisure as occurred amid their military operations, +Ferdinand and Isabella were diligently occupied with the interior +government of the kingdom, and especially with the rigid administration of +justice, the most difficult of all duties in an imperfectly civilized +state of society. The queen found especial demand for this in the northern +provinces, whose rude inhabitants were little used to subordination. She +compelled the great nobles to lay aside their arms, and refer their +disputes to legal arbitration. She caused a number of the fortresses, +which were still garrisoned by the baronial banditti, to be razed to the +ground; and she enforced the utmost severity of the law against such +inferior criminals as violated the public peace. [1] + +Even ecclesiastical immunities, which proved so effectual a protection in +most countries at this period, were not permitted to screen the offender. +A remarkable instance of this occurred at the city of Truxillo, in 1486. +An inhabitant of that place had been committed to prison for some offence +by order of the civil magistrate. Certain priests, relations of the +offender, alleged that his religious profession exempted him from all but +ecclesiastical jurisdiction; and, as the authorities refused to deliver +him up, they inflamed the populace to such a degree, by their +representations of the insult offered to the church, that they rose in a +body, and, forcing the prison, set at liberty not only the malefactor in +question, but all those confined there. The queen no sooner heard of this +outrage on the royal authority, than she sent a detachment of her guard to +Truxillo, which secured the persons of the principal rioters, some of whom +were capitally punished, while the ecclesiastics, who had stirred up the +sedition, were banished the realm. Isabella, while by her example she +inculcated the deepest reverence for the sacred profession, uniformly +resisted every attempt from that quarter to encroach on the royal +prerogative. The tendency of her administration was decidedly, as there +will be occasion more particularly to notice, to abridge the authority +which that body had exercised in civil matters under preceding reigns. [2] + +Nothing of interest occurred in the foreign relations of the kingdom, +during the period embraced by the preceding chapter; except perhaps the +marriage of Catharine, the young queen of Navarre, with Jean d'Albret, a +French nobleman, whose extensive hereditary domains, in the southwest +corner of France, lay adjacent to her kingdom. This connection was +extremely distasteful to the Spanish sovereigns, and indeed to many of the +Navarrese, who were desirous of the alliance with Castile. This was +ultimately defeated by the queen-mother, an artful woman, who, being of +the blood royal of France, was naturally disposed to a union with that +kingdom. Ferdinand did not neglect to maintain such an understanding with +the malcontents of Navarre, as should enable him to counteract any undue +advantage which the French monarch might derive from the possession of +this key, as it were, to the Castilian territory. [3] + +In Aragon, two circumstances took place in the period under review, +deserving historical notice. The first relates to an order of the Catalan +peasantry, denominated vassals _de remenza_. These persons were subjected +to a feudal bondage, which had its origin in very remote ages, but which +had become in no degree mitigated, while the peasantry of every other part +of Europe had been gradually rising to the rank of freemen. The grievous +nature of the impositions had led to repeated rebellions in preceding +reigns. At length, Ferdinand, after many fruitless attempts at a mediation +between these unfortunate people and their arrogant masters, prevailed on +the latter, rather by force of authority than argument, to relinquish the +extraordinary seignorial rights, which they had hitherto enjoyed, in +consideration of a stipulated annual payment from their vassals. [4] + +The other circumstance worthy of record, but not in like manner creditable +to the character of the sovereign, is the introduction of the modern +Inquisition into Aragon. The ancient tribunal had existed there, as has +been stated in a previous chapter, since the middle of the thirteenth +century, but seems to have lost all its venom in the atmosphere of that +free country; scarcely assuming a jurisdiction beyond that of an ordinary +ecclesiastical court. No sooner, however, was the institution organized on +its new basis in Castile, than Ferdinand resolved on its introduction, in +a similar form, in his own dominions. + +Measures were accordingly taken to that effect in a meeting of a privy +council convened by the king at Taraçona, during the session of the cortes +in that place, in April, 1484; and a royal order was issued, requiring all +the constituted authorities throughout the kingdom to support the new +tribunal in the exercise of its functions. A Dominican monk, Fray Gaspard +Juglar, and Pedro Arbues de Epila, a canon of the metropolitan church, +were appointed by the general, Torquemada, inquisitors over the diocese of +Saragossa; and, in the month of September following, the chief justiciary +and the other great officers of the realm took the prescribed oaths. [5] + +The new institution, opposed to the ideas of independence common to all +the Aragonese, was particularly offensive to the higher orders, many of +whose members, including persons filling the most considerable official +stations, were of Jewish descent, and of course precisely the class +exposed to the scrutiny of the Inquisition. Without difficulty, therefore, +the cortes was persuaded in the following year to send a deputation to the +court of Rome, and another to Ferdinand, representing the repugnance of +the new tribunal to the liberties of the nation, as well as to their +settled opinions and habits, and praying that its operation might be +suspended for the present, so far at least as concerned the confiscation +of property, which it rightly regarded as the moving power of the whole +terrible machinery. [6] + +Both the pope and the king, as may be imagined, turned a deaf ear to these +remonstrances. In the mean while the Inquisition commenced operations, and +autos da fe were celebrated at Saragossa, with all their usual horrors, in +the months of May and June, in 1485. The discontented Aragonese, +despairing of redress in any regular way, resolved to intimidate their +oppressors by some appalling act of violence. They formed a conspiracy for +the assassination of Arbues, the most odious of the inquisitors +established over the diocese of Saragossa. The conspiracy, set on foot by +some of the principal nobility, was entered into by most of the new +Christians, or persons of Jewish extraction in the district. A sum of ten +thousand reals was subscribed to defray the necessary expenses for the +execution of their project. This was not easy, however, since Arbues, +conscious of the popular odium that he had incurred, protected his person +by wearing under his monastic robes a suit of mail, complete even to the +helmet beneath his hood. With similar vigilance, he defended, also, every +avenue to his sleeping apartment. [7] + +At length, however, the conspirators found an opportunity of surprising +him while at his devotions. Arbues was on his knees before the great altar +of the cathedral, near midnight, when his enemies, who had entered the +church in two separate bodies, suddenly surrounded him, and one of them +wounded him in the arm with a dagger, while another dealt him a fatal blow +in the back of his neck. The priests, who were preparing to celebrate +matins in the choir of the church, hastened to the spot; but not before +the assassins had effected their escape. They transported the bleeding +body of the inquisitor to his apartment, where he survived only two days, +blessing the Lord that he had been permitted to seal so good a cause with +his blood. The whole scene will readily remind the English reader of the +assassination of Thomas à Becket. [8] + +The event did not correspond with the expectations of the conspirators. +Sectarian jealousy proved stronger than hatred of the Inquisition. The +populace, ignorant of the extent or ultimate object of the conspiracy, +were filled with vague apprehensions of an insurrection of the new +Christians, who had so often been the objects of outrage; and they could +only be appeased by the archbishop of Saragossa, riding through the +streets, and proclaiming that no time should be lost in detecting and +punishing the assassins. + +This promise was abundantly fulfilled; and wide was the ruin occasioned by +the indefatigable zeal, with which the bloodhounds of the tribunal +followed up the scent. In the course of this persecution, two hundred +individuals perished at the stake, and a still greater number in the +dungeons of the Inquisition; and there was scarcely a noble family in +Aragon but witnessed one or more of its members condemned to humiliating +penance in the autos da fe. The immediate perpetrators of the murder were +all hanged, after suffering the amputation of their right hands. One, who +had appeared as evidence against the rest, under assurance of pardon, had +his sentence so far commuted, that his hand was not cut off till after he +had been hanged. It was thus that the Holy Office interpreted its promises +of grace. [9] + +Arbues received all the honors of a martyr. His ashes were interred on the +spot where he had been assassinated. [10] A superb mausoleum was erected +over them, and, beneath his effigy, a bas-relief was sculptured +representing his tragical death, with an inscription containing a suitable +denunciation of the race of Israel. And at length, when the lapse of +nearly two centuries had supplied the requisite amount of miracles, the +Spanish Inquisition had the glory of adding a new saint to the calendar, +by the canonization of the martyr under Pope Alexander the Seventh, in +1664. [11] + +The failure of the attempt to shake off the tribunal served only, as usual +in such cases, to establish it more firmly than before. Efforts at +resistance were subsequently, but ineffectually, made in other parts of +Aragon, and in Valencia and Catalonia. It was not established in the +latter province till 1487, and some years later in Sicily, Sardinia, and +the Balearic Isles. Thus Ferdinand had the melancholy satisfaction of +riveting the most galling yoke ever devised by fanaticism, round the necks +of a people, who till that period had enjoyed probably the greatest degree +of constitutional freedom which the world had witnessed. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Lebrija, Rerum Gestarum Decades, iii. lib. 1, cap. 10.--Pulgar, Reyes +Católicos, part. 3, cap. 27, 39, 67, et alibi.--L. Marineo, Cosas +Memorables, fol. 175.--Zurita, Anales, tom. iv. fol. 348. + +[2] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 66.--A pertinent example of this +occurred, December, 1485, at Alcalá de Henares, where the court was +detained during the queen's illness, who there gave birth to her youngest +child, Doña Catalina, afterwards so celebrated in English history as +Catharine of Aragon. A collision took place in this city between the royal +judges and those of the archbishop of Toledo, to whose diocese it +belonged. The later stoutly maintained the pretensions of the church. The +queen with equal pertinacity asserted the supremacy of the royal +jurisdiction over every other in the kingdom, secular or ecclesiastical. +The affair was ultimately referred to the arbitration of certain learned +men, named conjointly by the adverse parties. It was not then determined, +however, and Pulgar has neglected to acquaint us with the award. Reyes +Católicos, cap. 53.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1485. + +[3] Aleson, Annales de Navarra, tom. v. lib. 35, cap. 2. + +[4] Zurita, Anales, tom. iv. cap. 52, 67.--Mariana, Hist. de España, lib. +25, cap. 8. + +[5] Llorente, Hist. de l'Inquisition, tom. i. chap. 6, art. 2.--Zurita, +Anales, lib. 20, cap. 65. + +At this cortes, convened at Taraçona, Ferdinand and Isabella experienced +an instance of the haughty spirit of their Catalan subjects, who refused +to attend, alleging it to be a violation of their liberties to be summoned +to a place without the limits of their principality. The Valencians also +protested, that their attendance should not operate as a precedent to +their prejudice. It was usual to convene a central or general cortes at +Fraga, or Monzon, or some town, which the Catalans, who were peculiarly +jealous of their privileges, claimed to be within their territory. It was +still more usual, to hold separate cortes of the three kingdoms +simultaneously in such contiguous places in each, as would permit the +royal presence in all during their session. See Blancas, Mode de Proceder +en Cortes de Aragon, (Zaragoza, 1641,) cap. 4. + +[6] By one of the articles in the Privilegium Generale, the Magna Charta +of Aragon, it is declared, "Que turment: ni inquisicion; no sian en Aragon +como sian contra Fuero el qual dize que alguna pesquisa no hauemos: et +contra el privilegio general, el qual vieda que inquisicion so sia feyta." +(Fueros y Observancias, fol. 11.) The tenor of this clause (although the +term _inquisicion_ must not be confounded with the name of the modern +institution) was sufficiently precise, one might have thought, to secure +the Aragonese from the fangs of this terrible tribunal. + +[7] Llorente, Hist. de l'Inquisition, chap. 6, art. 2, 3. + +[8] Llorente, ubi supra.--Paramo, De Origine Inquisitionis, pp. 182, 183. +--Ferreras, Hist. d'Espagne, tom. viii. pp. 37, 38. + +[9] Llorente, Hist. de l'Inquisition, tom. i. chap. 6, art. 5.--Blancas, +Aragonensium Rerum Commentarii, (Caesaraugustae, 1588,) p. 266. Among +those, who after a tedious imprisonment were condemned to do penance in an +auto da fe, was a nephew of King Ferdinand, Don James of Navarre. Mariana, +willing to point the tale with a suitable moral, informs us, that, +although none of the conspirators were ever brought to trial, they all +perished miserably within a year, in different ways, by the judgment of +God. (Hist. de España, tom. ii. p. 368.) Unfortunately for the effect of +this moral, Llorente, who consulted the original processes, must be +received as the better authority of the two. + +[10] According to Paramo, when the corpse of the inquisitor was brought to +the place where he had been assassinated, the blood, which had been +coagulated on the pavement, smoked up and boiled with most miraculous +fervor! De Origine Inquisitionis, p. 382. + +[11] Paramo, De Origine Inquisitionis, p. 183.--Llorente, Hist. de +l'Inquisition, chap. 6, art. 4. France and Italy also, according to +Llorente, could each boast a saint inquisitor. Their renown, however, has +been, eclipsed by the superior splendors of their great master, St. +Dominic; + + --"Fils inconnus d'un si glorieux père." + + + + +CHAPTER XIII. + +WAR OF GRANADA.--SURRENDER OF VELEZ MALAGA.--SIEGE AND CONQUEST OF MALAGA. + +1487. + +Narrow Escape of Ferdinand before Velez.--Malaga invested by Sea and +Land.--Brilliant Spectacle.--The Queen visits the Camp.--Attempt to +Assassinate the Sovereigns.--Distress and Resolution of the Besieged.-- +Enthusiasm of the Christians.--Outworks Carried by them.--Proposals for +Surrender.--Haughty Demeanor of Ferdinand.--Malaga Surrenders at +Discretion.--Cruel Policy of the Victors. + + +Before commencing operations against Malaga, it was thought expedient by +the Spanish council of war to obtain possession of Velez Malaga, situated +about five leagues distant from the former. This strong town stood along +the southern extremity of a range of mountains that extend to Granada. Its +position afforded an easy communication with that capital, and obvious +means of annoyance to an enemy interposed between itself and the adjacent +city of Malaga. The reduction of this place, therefore, became the first +object of the campaign. + +The forces assembled at Cordova, consisting of the levies of the +Andalusian cities principally, of the retainers of the great nobility, and +of the well-appointed chivalry which thronged from all quarters of the +kingdom, amounted on this occasion to twelve thousand horse and forty +thousand foot; a number, which sufficiently attests the unslackened ardor +of the nation in the prosecution of the war. On the 7th of April, King +Ferdinand, putting himself at the head of this formidable host, quitted +the fair city of Cordova amid the cheering acclamations of its +inhabitants, although these were somewhat damped by the ominous occurrence +of an earthquake, which demolished a part of the royal residence, among +other edifices, during the preceding night. The route, after traversing +the Yeguas and the old town of Antequera, struck into a wild, hilly +country, that stretches towards Velez. The rivers were so much swollen by +excessive rains, and the passes so rough and difficult, that the army in +part of its march advanced only a league a day; and on one occasion, when +no suitable place occurred for encampment for the space of five leagues, +the men fainted with exhaustion, and the beasts dropped down dead in the +harness. At length, on the 17th of April, the Spanish army sat down before +Velez Malaga, where in a few days they were joined by the lighter pieces +of their battering ordnance; the roads, notwithstanding the immense labor +expended on them, being found impracticable for the heavier. [1] + +The Moors were aware of the importance of Velez to the security of Malaga. +The sensation excited in Granada by the tidings of its danger was so +strong, that the old chief, El Zagal, found it necessary to make an effort +to relieve the beleaguered city, notwithstanding the critical posture in +which his absence would leave his affairs in the capital. Dark clouds of +the enemy were seen throughout the day mustering along the heights, which +by night were illumined with a hundred fires. Ferdinand's utmost vigilance +was required for the protection of his camp against the ambuscades and +nocturnal sallies of his wily foe. At length, however, El Zagal, having +been foiled in a well-concerted attempt to surprise the Christian quarters +by night, was driven across the mountains by the marquis of Cadiz, and +compelled to retreat on his capital, completely baffled in his enterprise. +There the tidings of his disaster had preceded him. The fickle populace, +with whom misfortune passes for misconduct, unmindful of his former +successes, now hastened to transfer their allegiance to his rival, +Abdallah, and closed the gates against him; and the unfortunate chief +withdrew to Guadix, which, with Almeria, Baza, and some less considerable +places, still remained faithful. [2] + +Ferdinand conducted the siege all the while with his usual vigor, and +spared no exposure of his person to peril or fatigue. On one occasion, +seeing a party of Christians retreating in disorder before a squadron of +the enemy, who had surprised them while fortifying an eminence near the +city, the king, who was at dinner in his tent, rushed out with no other +defensive armor than his cuirass, and, leaping on his horse, charged +briskly into the midst of the enemy, and succeeded in rallying his own +men. In the midst of the rencontre, however, when he had discharged his +lance, he found himself unable to extricate his sword from the scabbard +which hung from the saddle-bow. At this moment he was assaulted by several +Moors, and must have been either slain or taken, but for the timely rescue +of the marquis of Cadiz, and a brave cavalier, Garcilasso de la Vega, who, +galloping up to the spot with their attendants, succeeded after a sharp +skirmish in beating off the enemy. Ferdinand's nobles remonstrated with +him on this wanton exposure of his person, representing that he could +serve them more effectually with his head than his hand. But he answered, +that "he could not stop to calculate chances, when his subjects were +perilling their lives for his sake;" a reply, says Pulgar, which endeared +him to the whole army. [3] + +At length, the inhabitants of Velez, seeing the ruin impending from the +bombardment of the Christians, whose rigorous blockade both by sea and +land excluded all hopes of relief from without, consented to capitulate on +the usual conditions of security to persons, property, and religion. The +capitulation of this place, April 27th, 1487, was followed by that of more +than twenty places of inferior note lying between it and Malaga, so that +the approaches to this latter city were now left open to the victorious +Spaniards. [4] + +This ancient city, which, under the Spanish Arabs in the twelfth and +thirteenth centuries, formed the capital of an independent principality, +was second only to the metropolis itself, in the kingdom of Granada. Its +fruitful environs furnished abundant articles of export, while its +commodious port on the Mediterranean opened a traffic with the various +countries washed by that inland sea, and with the remoter regions of +India. Owing to these advantages, the inhabitants acquired unbounded +opulence, which showed itself in the embellishments of their city, whose +light forms of architecture, mingling after the eastern fashion with +odoriferous gardens and fountains of sparkling water, presented an +appearance most refreshing to the senses in this sultry climate. [5] + +The city was encompassed by fortifications of great strength, and in +perfect repair. It was commanded by a citadel, connected by a covered way +with a second fortress impregnable from its position, denominated +Gebalfaro, which stood along the declivities of the bold sierra of the +Axarquia, whose defiles had proved so disastrous to the Christians. The +city lay between two spacious suburbs, the one on the land side being also +encircled by a formidable wall; and the other declining towards the sea, +showing an expanse of olive, orange, and pomegranate gardens, intermingled +with the rich vineyards that furnished the celebrated staple for its +export. + +Malaga was well prepared for a siege by supplies of artillery and +ammunition. Its ordinary garrison was reinforced by volunteers from the +neighboring towns, and by a corps of African mercenaries, Gomeres, as they +were called, men of ferocious temper, but of tried valor and military +discipline. The command of this important post had been intrusted by El +Zagal to a noble Moor, named Hamet Zeli, whose renown in the present war +had been established by his resolute defence of Ronda. [6] + +Ferdinand, while lying before Velez, received intelligence that many of +the wealthy burghers of Malaga were inclined to capitulate at once, rather +than hazard the demolition of their city by an obstinate resistance. He +instructed the marquis of Cadiz, therefore, to open a negotiation with +Hamet Zeli, authorizing him to make the most liberal offers to the alcayde +himself, as well as his garrison, and the principal citizens of the place, +on condition of immediate surrender. The sturdy chief, however, rejected +the proposal with disdain, replying, that he had been commissioned by his +master to defend the place to the last extremity, and that the Christian +king could not offer a bribe large enough to make him betray his trust. +Ferdinand, finding little prospect of operating on this Spartan temper, +broke up his camp before Velez, on the 7th of May, and advanced with his +whole army as far as Bezmillana, a place on the seaboard about two leagues +distant from Malaga. [7] + +The line of march now lay through a valley commanded at the extremity +nearest the city by two eminences; the one on the sea-coast, the other +facing the fortress of the Gebalfaro, and forming part of the wild sierra +which overshadowed Malaga on the north. The enemy occupied both these +important positions. A corps of Galicians were sent forward to dislodge +them from the eminence towards the sea. But it failed in the assault, and, +notwithstanding it was led up a second time by the commander of Leon and +the brave Garcilasso de la Vega, [8] was again repulsed by the intrepid +foe. + +A similar fate attended the assault on the sierra, which was conducted by +the troops of the royal household. They were driven back on the vanguard, +which had halted in the valley under command of the grand master of St. +James, prepared to support the attack on either side. Being reinforced, +the Spaniards returned to the charge with the most determined resolution. +They were encountered by the enemy with equal spirit. The latter, throwing +away their lances, precipitated themselves on the ranks of the assailants, +making use only of their daggers, grappling closely man to man, till both +rolled promiscuously together down the steep sides of the ravine. No mercy +was asked or shown. None thought of sparing or of spoiling, for hatred, +says the chronicler, was stronger than avarice. The main body of the army, +in the mean while, pent up in the valley, were compelled to witness the +mortal conflict, and listen to the exulting cries of the enemy, which, +after the Moorish custom, rose high and shrill above the din of battle, +without being able to advance a step in support of their companions, who +were again forced to give way before their impetuous adversaries, and fall +back on the vanguard under the grand master of St. James. Here, however, +they speedily rallied; and, being reinforced, advanced to the charge a +third time, with such inflexible courage as bore down all opposition, and +compelled the enemy, exhausted, or rather overpowered by superior numbers, +to abandon his position. At the same time the rising ground on the seaside +was carried by the Spaniards under the commander of Leon and Garcilasso de +la Vega, who, dividing their forces, charged the Moors so briskly in front +and rear, that they were compelled to retreat on the neighboring fortress +of Gebalfaro. [9] + +As it was evening before these advantages were obtained, the army did not +defile into the plains around Malaga before the following morning, when +dispositions were made for its encampment. The eminence on the sierra, so +bravely contested, was assigned as the post of greatest danger to the +marquis duke of Cadiz. It was protected by strong works lined with +artillery, and a corps of two thousand five hundred horse and fourteen +thousand foot was placed under the immediate command of that nobleman. A +line of defence was constructed along the declivity from this redoubt to +the seashore. Similar works, consisting of a deep trench and palisades, +or, where the soil was too rocky to admit of them, of an embankment or +mound of earth, were formed in front of the encampment, which embraced the +whole circuit of the city; and the blockade was completed by a fleet of +armed vessels, galleys and caravels, which rode in the harbor under the +command of the Catalan admiral, Requesens, and effectually cut off all +communication by water. [10] + +The old chronicler Bernaldez warms at the aspect of the fair city of +Malaga, thus encompassed by Christian legions, whose deep lines, +stretching far over hill and valley, reached quite round from one arm of +the sea to the other. In the midst of this brilliant encampment was seen +the royal pavilion, proudly displaying the united banners of Castile and +Aragon, and forming so conspicuous a mark for the enemy's artillery, that +Ferdinand, after imminent hazard, was at length compelled to shift his +quarters. The Christians were not slow in erecting counter-batteries; but +the work was obliged to be carried on at night, in order to screen them +from the fire of the besieged. [11] + +The first operations of the Spaniards were directed against the suburb, on +the land side of the city. The attack was intrusted to the count of +Cifuentes, the nobleman who had been made prisoner in the affair of the +Axarquia, and subsequently ransomed. The Spanish ordnance was served with +such effect, that a practicable breach was soon made in the wall. The +combatants now poured their murderous volleys on each other through the +opening, and at length met on the ruins of the breach. After a desperate +struggle the Moors gave way. The Christians rushed into the enclosure, at +the same time effecting a lodgment on the rampart; and, although a part of +it, undermined by the enemy, gave way with a terrible crash, they still +kept possession of the remainder, and at length drove their antagonists, +who sullenly retreated step by step, within the fortifications of the +city. The lines were then drawn close around the place. Every avenue of +communication was strictly guarded, and every preparation was made for +reducing the town by regular blockade. [12] + +In addition to the cannon brought round by water from Velez, the heavier +lombards, which from the difficulty of transportation had been left during +the late Siege at Antequera, were now conducted across roads, levelled for +the purpose, to the camp. Supplies of marble bullets were also brought +from the ancient and depopulated city of Algezira, where they had lain +ever since its capture in the preceding century by Alfonso the Eleventh. +The camp was filled with operatives, employed in the manufacture of balls +and powder, which were stored in subterranean magazines, and in the +fabrication of those various kinds of battering enginery, which continued +in use long after the introduction of gunpowder. [13] + +During the early part of the siege, the camp experienced some temporary +inconvenience from the occasional interruption of the supplies transported +by water. Rumors of the appearance of the plague in some of the adjacent +villages caused additional uneasiness; and deserters, who passed into +Malaga, reported these particulars with the usual exaggeration, and +encouraged the besieged to persevere, by the assurance that Ferdinand +could not much longer keep the field, and that the queen had actually +written to advise his breaking up the camp. Under these circumstances, +Ferdinand saw at once the importance of the queen's presence in order to +dispel the delusion of the enemy, and to give new heart to his soldiers. +He accordingly sent a message to Cordova, where she was holding her court, +requesting her appearance in the camp. + +Isabella had proposed to join her husband before Velez, on receiving +tidings of El Zagal's march from Granada, and had actually enforced levies +of all persons capable of bearing arms, between twenty and seventy years +of age, throughout Andalusia, but subsequently disbanded them, on learning +the discomfiture of the Moorish army. Without hesitation, she now set +forward, accompanied by the cardinal of Spain and other dignitaries of the +church, together with the infanta Isabella, and a courtly train of ladies +and cavaliers in attendance on her person. She was received at a short +distance from the camp by the marquis of Cadiz and the grand master of St. +James, and escorted to her quarters amidst the enthusiastic greetings of +the soldiery. Hope now brightened every countenance. A grace seemed to be +shed over the rugged features of war; and the young gallants thronged from +all quarters to the camp, eager to win the guerdon of valor from the hands +of those from whom it is most grateful to receive it. [14] + +Ferdinand, who had hitherto brought into action only the lighter pieces of +ordnance, from a willingness to spare the noble edifices of the city, now +pointed his heaviest guns against its walls. Before opening his fire, +however, he again summoned the place, offering the usual liberal terms in +case of immediate, compliance, and engaging otherwise, "with the blessing +of God, to make them all slaves"! But the heart of the alcayde was +hardened like that of Pharaoh, says the Andalusian chronicler, and the +people were swelled with vain hopes, so that their ears were closed +against the proposal; orders were even issued to punish with death any +attempt at a parley. On the contrary, they made answer by a more lively +cannonade than before, along the whole line of ramparts and fortresses +which overhung the city. Sallies were also made at almost every hour of +the day and night on every assailable point of the Christian lines, so +that the camp was kept in perpetual alarm. In one of the nocturnal +sallies, a body of two thousand men from the castle of Gebalfaro succeeded +in surprising the quarters of the marquis of Cadiz, who, with his +followers, was exhausted by fatigue and watching, during the two preceding +nights. The Christians, bewildered with the sudden tumult which broke +their slumber, were thrown into the greatest confusion; and the marquis, +who rushed half armed from his tent, found no little difficulty in +bringing them to order, and beating off the assailants, after receiving a +wound in the arm from an arrow; while he had a still narrower escape from +the ball of an arquebus, that penetrated his buckler and hit him below the +cuirass, but fortunately so much spent as to do him no injury. [15] + +The Moors were not unmindful of the importance of Malaga, or the gallantry +with which it was defended. They made several attempts to relieve it, +whose failure was less owing to the Christians than to treachery and their +own miserable feuds. A body of cavalry, which El Zagal despatched from +Guadix to throw succors into the beleaguered city, was encountered and cut +to pieces by a superior force of the young king Abdallah, who consummated +his baseness by sending an embassy to the Christian camp, charged with a +present of Arabian horses sumptuously caparisoned to Ferdinand, and of +costly silks and Oriental perfumes to the queen; at the same time +complimenting them on their successes, and soliciting the continuance of +their friendly dispositions towards himself. Ferdinand and Isabella +requited this act of humiliation by securing to Abdallah's subjects the +right of cultivating their fields in quiet, and of trafficking with the +Spaniards in every commodity, save military stores. At this paltry price +did the dastard prince consent to stay his arm, at the only moment when it +could be used effectually for his country. [16] + +More serious consequences were like to have resulted from an attempt made +by another party of Moors from Guadix to penetrate the Christian lines. +Part of them succeeded, and threw themselves into the besieged city. The +remainder were cut in pieces. There was one, however, who, making no show +of resistance, was made prisoner without harm to his person. Being brought +before the marquis of Cadiz, he informed that nobleman, that he could make +some important disclosures to the sovereigns. He was accordingly conducted +to the royal tent; but, as Ferdinand was taking his siesta, in the sultry +hour of the day, the queen, moved by divine inspiration, according to the +Castilian historian, deferred the audience till her husband should awake, +and commanded the prisoner to be detained in the adjoining tent. This was +occupied by Doña Beatrix de Bobadilla, marchioness of Moya, Isabella's +early friend, who happened to be at that time engaged in discourse with a +Portuguese nobleman, Don Alvaro, son of the duke of Braganza. [17] + +The Moor did not understand the Castilian language, and, deceived by the +rich attire and courtly bearing of these personages, he mistook them for +the king and queen. While in the act of refreshing himself with a glass of +water, he suddenly drew a dagger from beneath the broad folds of his +_albornoz_, or Moorish mantle, which he had been incautiously suffered to +retain, and, darting on the Portuguese prince, gave him a deep wound on +the head; and then, turning like lightning on the marchioness, aimed a +stroke at her, which fortunately glanced without injury, the point of the +weapon being turned by the heavy embroidery of her robes. Before he could +repeat his blow, the Moorish Scaevola, with a fate very different from +that of his Roman prototype, was pierced with a hundred wounds by the +attendants, who rushed to the spot, alarmed by the cries of the +marchioness, and his mangled remains were soon after discharged from a +catapult into the city; a foolish bravado, which the besieged requited by +slaying a Galician gentleman, and sending his corpse astride upon a mule +through the gates of the town into the Christian camp. [18] + +This daring attempt on the lives of the king and queen spread general +consternation throughout the army. Precautions were taken for the future, +by ordinances prohibiting the introduction of any unknown person armed, or +any Moor whatever, into the royal quarters; and the bodyguard was +augmented by the addition of two hundred hidalgos of Castile and Aragon, +who, with their retainers, were to keep constant watch over the persons of +the sovereigns. + +Meanwhile, the city of Malaga, whose natural population was greatly +swelled by the influx of its foreign auxiliaries, began to be straitened +for supplies, while its distress was aggravated by the spectacle of +abundance which reigned throughout the Spanish camp. Still, however, the +people, overawed by the soldiery, did not break out into murmurs, nor did +they relax in any degree the pertinacity of their resistance. Their +drooping spirits were cheered by the predictions of a fanatic, who +promised that they should eat the grain which they saw in the Christian +camp; a prediction, which came to be verified, like most others that are +verified at all, in a very different sense from that intended or +understood. + +The incessant cannonade kept up by the besieging army, in the mean time, +so far exhausted their ammunition, that they were constrained to seek +supplies from the most distant parts of the kingdom, and from foreign +countries. The arrival of two Flemish transports at this juncture, from +the emperor of Germany, whose interest had been roused in the crusade, +afforded a seasonable reinforcement of military stores and munitions. + +The obstinate defence of Malaga had given the siege such celebrity, that +volunteers, eager to share in it, flocked from all parts of the Peninsula +to the royal standard. Among others, the duke of Medina Sidonia, who had +furnished his quota of troops at the opening of the campaign, now arrived +in person with a reinforcement, together with a hundred galleys freighted +with supplies, and a loan of twenty thousand doblas of gold to the +sovereigns for the expenses of the war. Such was the deep interest in it +excited throughout the nation, and the alacrity which every order of men +exhibited in supporting its enormous burdens. [19] + +The Castilian army, swelled by these daily augmentations, varied in its +amount, according to different estimates, from sixty to ninety thousand +men. Throughout this immense host, the most perfect discipline was +maintained. Gaming was restrained by ordinances interdicting the use of +dice and cards, of which the lower orders were passionately fond. +Blasphemy was severely punished. Prostitutes, the common pest of a camp, +were excluded; and so entire was the subordination, that not a knife was +drawn, and scarcely a brawl occurred, says the historian, among the motley +multitude. Besides the higher ecclesiastics who attended the court, the +camp was well supplied with holy men, priests, friars, and the chaplains +of the great nobility, who performed the exercises of religion in their +respective quarters with all the pomp and splendor of the Roman Catholic +worship; exalting the imaginations of the soldiers into the high +devotional feeling, which became those who were fighting the battles of +the Cross. [20] + +Hitherto, Ferdinand, relying on the blockade, and yielding to the queen's +desire to spare the lives of her soldiers, had formed no regular plan of +assault upon the town. But, as the season rolled on without the least +demonstration of submission on the part of the besieged, he resolved to +storm the works, which, if attended by no other consequences, might at +least serve to distress the enemy, and hasten the hour of surrender. Large +wooden towers on rollers were accordingly constructed, and provided with +an apparatus of drawbridges and ladders, which, when brought near to the +ramparts, would open a descent into the city. Galleries were also wrought, +some for the purpose of penetrating into the place, and others to sap the +foundations of the walls. The whole of these operations was placed under +the direction of Francisco Ramirez, the celebrated engineer of Madrid. + +But the Moors anticipated the completion of these formidable preparations +by a brisk, well-concerted attack on all points of the Spanish lines. They +countermined the assailants, and, encountering them in the subterraneous +passages, drove them back, and demolished the frame-work of the galleries. +At the same time, a little squadron of armed vessels, which had been +riding in safety under the guns of the city, pushed out and engaged the +Spanish fleet. Thus the battle raged with fire and sword, above and under +ground, along the ramparts, the ocean, and the land, at the same time. +Even Pulgar cannot withhold his tribute of admiration to this +unconquerable spirit in an enemy, wasted by all the extremities of famine +and fatigue. "Who does not marvel," he says, "at the bold heart of these +infidels in battle, their prompt obedience to their chiefs, their +dexterity in the wiles of war, their patience under privation, and +undaunted perseverance in their purposes?" [21] + +A circumstance occurred in a sortie from the city, indicating a trait of +character worth recording. A noble Moor, named Abrahen Zenete, fell in +with a number of Spanish children who had wandered from their quarters. +Without injuring them, he touched them gently with the handle of his +lance, saying, "Get ye gone, varlets, to your mothers." On being rebuked +by his comrades, who inquired why he had let them escape so easily, he +replied, "Because I saw no beard upon their chins." "An example of +magnanimity," says the Curate of Los Palacios, "truly wonderful in a +heathen, and which might have reflected credit on a Christian hidalgo." +[22] + +But no virtue nor valor could avail the unfortunate Malagans against the +overwhelming force of their enemies, who, driving them back from every +point, compelled them, after a desperate struggle of six hours, to shelter +themselves within the defences of the town. The Christians followed up +their success. A mine was sprung near a tower, connected by a bridge of +four arches with the main works of the place. The Moors, scattered and +intimidated by the explosion, retreated across the bridge, and the +Spaniards, carrying the tower, whose guns completely enfiladed it, +obtained possession of this important pass into the beleaguered city. For +these and other signal services during the siege, Francisco Ramirez, the +master of the ordnance, received the honors of knighthood from the hand of +King Ferdinand. [23] + +The citizens of Malaga, dismayed at beholding the enemy established in +their defences, and fainting under exhaustion from a siege which had +already lasted more than three months, now began to murmur at the +obstinacy of the garrison, and to demand a capitulation. Their magazines +of grain were emptied, and for some weeks they had been compelled to +devour the flesh of horses, dogs, cats, and even the boiled hides of these +animals, or, in default of other nutriment, vine leaves dressed with oil, +and leaves of the palm tree, pounded fine, and baked into a sort of cake. +In consequence of this loathsome and unwholesome diet, diseases were +engendered. Multitudes were seen dying about the streets. Many deserted to +the Spanish camp, eager to barter their liberty for bread; and the city +exhibited all the extremes of squalid and disgusting wretchedness, bred by +pestilence and famine among an overcrowded population. The sufferings of +the citizens softened the stern heart of the alcayde, Hamet Zeli, who at +length yielded to their importunities, and, withdrawing his forces into +the Gebalfaro, consented that the Malagans should make the best terms they +could with their conqueror. + +A deputation of the principal inhabitants, with an eminent merchant named +Ali Dordux at their head, was then despatched to the Christian quarters, +with the offer of the city to capitulate, on the same liberal conditions +which had been uniformly granted by the Spaniards. The king refused to +admit the embassy into his presence, and haughtily answered through the +commander of Leon, "that these terms had been twice offered to the people +of Malaga, and rejected; that it was too late for them to stipulate +conditions, and nothing now remained but to abide by those which he, as +their conqueror, should vouchsafe to them." [24] + +Ferdinand's answer spread general consternation throughout Malaga. The +inhabitants saw too plainly that nothing was to be hoped from an appeal to +sentiments of humanity. After a tumultuous debate, the deputies were +despatched a second time to the Christian camp, charged with propositions +in which concession was mingled with menace. They represented that the +severe response of King Ferdinand to the citizens had rendered them +desperate. That, however, they were willing to resign to him their +fortifications, their city, in short, their property of every description, +on his assurance of their personal security and freedom. If he refused +this, they would take their Christian captives, amounting to five or six +hundred, from the dungeons in which they lay, and hang them like dogs over +the battlements; and then, placing their old men, women, and children in +the fortress, they would set fire to the town, and cut a way for +themselves through their enemies, or fall in the attempt. "So," they +continued, "if you gain a victory, it shall be such a one as shall make +the name of Malaga ring throughout the world, and to ages yet unborn!" +Ferdinand, unmoved by these menaces, coolly replied, that he saw no +occasion to change his former determination; but they might rest assured, +if they harmed a single hair of a Christian, he would put every soul in +the place, man, woman, and child, to the sword. + +The anxious people, who thronged forth to meet the embassy on its return +to the city, were overwhelmed with the deepest gloom at its ominous +tidings. Their fate was now sealed. Every avenue to hope seemed closed by +the stern response of the victor. Yet hope will still linger; and, +although there were some frantic enough to urge the execution of their +desperate menaces, the greater number of the inhabitants, and among them +those most considerable for wealth and influence, preferred the chance of +Ferdinand's clemency to certain, irretrievable ruin. + +For the last time, therefore, the deputies issued from the gates of the +city, charged with an epistle to the sovereigns from their unfortunate +countrymen, in which, after deprecating their anger, and lamenting their +own blind obstinacy, they reminded their highnesses of the liberal terms +which their ancestors had granted to Cordova, Antequera, and other cities, +after a defence as pertinacious as their own. They expatiated on the fame +which the sovereigns had established by the generous policy of their past +conquests, and, appealing to their magnanimity, concluded with submitting +themselves, their families, and their fortunes to their disposal. Twenty +of the principal citizens were then delivered up as hostages for the +peaceable demeanor of the city until its occupation by the Spaniards. +"Thus," says the Curate of Los Palacios, "did the Almighty harden the +hearts of these heathen, like to those of the Egyptians, in order that +they might receive the full wages of the manifold oppressions which they +had wrought on his people, from the days of King Roderic to the present +time." [25] + +On the appointed day, the commander of Leon rode through the gates of +Malaga, at the head of his well-appointed chivalry, and took possession of +the _alcazaba_, or lower citadel. The troops were then posted on their +respective stations along the fortifications, and the banners of Christian +Spain triumphantly unfurled from the towers of the city, where the +crescent had been displayed for an uninterrupted period of nearly eight +centuries. + +The first act was to purify the town from the numerous dead bodies, and +other offensive matter, which had accumulated during this long siege, and +lay festering in the streets, poisoning the atmosphere. The principal +mosque was next consecrated with due solemnity to the service of Santa +Maria de la Encarnacion. Crosses and bells, the symbols of Christian +worship, were distributed in profusion among the sacred edifices; where, +says the Catholic chronicler last quoted, "the celestial music of their +chimes, sounding at every hour of the day and night, caused perpetual +torment to the ears of the infidel." [26] + +On the eighteenth day of August, being somewhat more than three months +from the date of opening trenches, Ferdinand and Isabella made their +entrance into the conquered city, attended by the court, the clergy, and +the whole of their military array. The procession moved in solemn state up +the principal streets, now deserted, and hushed in ominous silence, to the +new cathedral of St. Mary, where mass was performed; and as the glorious +anthem of the Te Deum rose for the first time within its ancient walls, +the sovereigns, together with the whole army, prostrated themselves in +grateful adoration of the Lord of hosts, who had thus reinstated them in +the domains of their ancestors. + +The most affecting incident was afforded by the multitude of Christian +captives, who were rescued from the Moorish dungeons. They were brought +before the sovereigns, with their limbs heavily manacled, their beards +descending to their waists, and their sallow visages emaciated by +captivity and famine. Every eye was suffused with tears at the spectacle. +Many recognized their ancient friends, of whose fate they had long been +ignorant. Some, had lingered in captivity ten or fifteen years; and among +them were several belonging to the best families in Spain. On entering the +presence, they would have testified their gratitude by throwing themselves +at the feet of the sovereigns; but the latter, raising them up and +mingling their tears with those of the liberated captives, caused their +fetters to be removed, and, after administering to their necessities, +dismissed them with liberal presents. [27] + + The fortress of Gebalfaro surrendered on the day after the occupation of +Malaga by the Spaniards. The gallant Zegri chieftain, Hamet Zeli, was +loaded with chains; and, being asked why he had persisted so obstinately +in his _rebellion_, boldly answered, "Because I was commissioned to +defend the place to the last extremity; and, if I had been properly +supported, I would have died sooner than surrender now!" + +The doom of the vanquished was now to be pronounced. On entering the city, +orders had been issued to the Spanish soldiery, prohibiting them under the +severest penalties from molesting either the persons or property of the +inhabitants. These latter were directed to remain in their respective +mansions with a guard set over them, while the cravings of appetite were +supplied by a liberal distribution of food. At length, the whole +population of the city, comprehending every age and sex, was commanded to +repair to the great courtyard of the alcazaba, which was overlooked on all +sides by lofty ramparts garrisoned by the Spanish soldiery. To this place, +the scene of many a Moorish triumph, where the spoil of the border foray +had been often displayed, and which still might be emblazoned with the +trophy of many a Christian banner, the people of Malaga now directed their +steps. As the multitude swarmed through the streets, filled with boding +apprehensions of their fate, they wrung their hands, and, raising their +eyes to heaven, uttered the most piteous lamentations. "Oh, Malaga," they +cried, "renowned and beautiful city, how are thy sons about to forsake +thee! Could not thy soil, on which they first drew breath, be suffered to +cover them in death? Where is now the strength of thy towers, where the +beauty of thy edifices? The strength of thy walls, alas, could not avail +thy children, for they had sorely displeased their Creator. What shall +become of thy old men and thy matrons, or of thy young maidens delicately +nurtured within thy halls, when they shall feel the iron yoke of bondage? +Can thy barbarous conquerors without remorse thus tear asunder the dearest +ties of life?" Such are the melancholy strains, in which the Castilian +chronicler has given utterance to the sorrows of the captive city. [28] + +The dreadful doom of slavery was denounced on the assembled multitude. +One-third was to be transported into Africa in exchange for an equal +number of Christian captives detained there; and all, who had relatives or +friends in this predicament, were required to furnish a specification of +them. Another third was appropriated to reimburse the state for the +expenses of the war. The remainder were to be distributed as presents at +home and abroad. Thus, one hundred of the flower of the African warriors +were sent to the pope, who incorporated them into his guard, and converted +them all in the course of the year, says the Curate of Los Palacios, into +very good Christians. Fifty of the most beautiful Moorish girls were +presented by Isabella to the queen of Naples, thirty to the queen of +Portugal, others to the ladies of her court; and the residue of both sexes +were apportioned among the nobles, cavaliers, and inferior members of the +army, according to their respective rank and services. [29] + +As it was apprehended that the Malagans, rendered desperate by the +prospect of a hopeless, interminable captivity, might destroy or secrete +their jewels, plate, and other precious effects, in which this wealthy +city abounded, rather than suffer them to fall into the hands of their +enemies, Ferdinand devised a politic expedient for preventing it. He +proclaimed that he would receive a certain sum, if paid within nine +months, as the ransom of the whole population, and that their personal +effects should be admitted in part payment. This sum averaged about thirty +doblas a head, including in the estimate all those who might die before +the determination of the period assigned. The ransom, thus stipulated, +proved more than the unhappy people could raise, either by themselves, or +agents employed to solicit contributions among their brethren of Granada +and Africa; at the same time, it so far deluded their hopes, that they +gave in a full inventory of their effects to the treasury. By this shrewd +device, Ferdinand obtained complete possession both of the persons and +property of his victims. [30] + +Malaga was computed to contain from eleven to fifteen thousand +inhabitants, exclusive of several thousand foreign auxiliaries, within its +gates at the time of surrender. One cannot, at this day, read the +melancholy details of its story, without feelings of horror and +indignation. It is impossible to vindicate the dreadful sentence passed on +this unfortunate people for a display of heroism, which should have +excited admiration in every generous bosom. It was obviously most +repugnant to Isabella's natural disposition, and must be admitted to leave +a stain on her memory, which no coloring of history can conceal. It may +find some palliation, however, in the bigotry of the age, the more +excusable in a woman whom education, general example, and natural distrust +of herself accustomed to rely, in matters of conscience, on the spiritual +guides, whose piety and professional learning seemed to qualify them for +the trust. Even in this very transaction, she fell far short of the +suggestions of some of her counsellors, who urged her to put every +inhabitant without exception to the sword; which, they affirmed, would be +a just requital of their obstinate _rebellion_, and would prove a +wholesome warning to others! We are not told who the advisers of this +precious measure were; but the whole experience of this reign shows, that +we shall scarcely wrong the clergy much by imputing it to them. That their +arguments could warp so enlightened a mind, as that of Isabella, from the +natural principles of justice and humanity, furnishes a remarkable proof +of the ascendency which the priesthood usurped over the most gifted +intellects, and of their gross abuse of it, before the Reformation, by +breaking the seals set on the sacred volume, opened to mankind the +uncorrupted channel of divine truth. [31] + +The fate of Malaga may be said to have decided that of Granada. The latter +was now shut out from the most important ports along her coast; and she +was environed on every point of her territory by her warlike foe, so that +she could hardly hope more from subsequent efforts, however strenuous and +united, than to postpone the inevitable hour of dissolution. The cruel +treatment of Malaga was the prelude to the long series of persecutions, +which awaited the wretched Moslems in the land of their ancestors; in that +land, over which the "star of Islamism," to borrow their own metaphor, had +shone in full brightness for nearly eight centuries, but where it was now +fast descending amid clouds and tempests to the horizon. + +The first care of the sovereigns was directed towards repeopling the +depopulated city with their own subjects. Houses and lands were freely +granted to such as would settle there. Numerous towns and villages with a +wide circuit of territory were placed under its civil jurisdiction, and it +was made the head of a diocese embracing most of the recent conquests in +the south and west of Granada. These inducements, combined with the +natural advantages of position and climate, soon caused the tide of +Christian population to flow into the deserted city; but it was very long +before it again reached the degree of commercial consequence to which it +had been raised by the Moors. [32] + +After these salutary arrangements, the Spanish sovereigns led back their +victorious legions in triumph to Cordova, whence dispersing to their +various homes, they prepared, by a winter's repose, for new campaigns and +more brilliant conquests. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Vedmar, Antiguedad y Grandezas de la Ciudad de Velez, (Granada, 1652,) +fol. 148.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. lib. 27, cap. 10.--Pulgar, +Reyes Católicos, part. iii. cap. 70.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1487.-- +Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 14. + +[2] Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique et d'Espagne, tom. iii. pp. 292-294.-- +Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, ubi supra.--Vedmar, Antiguedad de Velez, fol. +151. + +[3] L. Marineo, Cosas Memorables, fol. 175.--Vedmar, Antiguedad.--de +Velez, fol. 150, 151.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 14. + +In commemoration of this event, the city incorporated into its escutcheon +the figure of a king on horseback, in the act of piercing a Moor with his +javelin. Vedmar, Antiguedad de Velez, fol. 12. + +[4] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 52.--Marmol, Rebelion de +Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 14. + +[5] Conde doubts whether the name of Malaga is derived from the Greek +_malakè_, signifying "agreeable," or the Arabic _malka_, meaning "royal." +Either etymology is sufficiently pertinent. (See El Nubiense, Descripcion +de España, p. 186, not.) For notices of sovereigns who swayed the sceptre +of Malaga, see Casiri, Bibliotheca Escurialensis, tom. ii. pp. 41, 56, 99, +et alibi. + +[6] Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. p. 237.--Pulgar, Reyes +Católicos, cap. 74.--El Nubiense, Descripcion de España, not., p. 144. + +[7] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 82.--Vedmar, Antiguedad de +Velez, fol. 154.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 74. + +[8] This cavalier, who took a conspicuous part both in the military and +civil transactions of this reign, was descended from one of the most +ancient and honorable houses in Castile. Hyta, (Guerras Civiles de +Granada, tom. i. p. 399,) with more effrontery than usual, has imputed to +him a chivalrous rencontre with a Saracen, which is recorded of an +ancestor, in the ancient Chronicle of Alonso XI. + + "Garcilaso de la Vega + desde alli se ha intitulado, + porque en la Vega hiciera + campo con aquel pagano." + +Oviedo, however, with good reason, distrusts the etymology and the story, +as he traces both the cognomen and the peculiar device of the family to a +much older date than the period assigned in the Chronicle. Quincuagenas, +MS., bat. 1, quinc. 3, dial. 43. + +[9] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 75.--Salazar de Mendoza, Crón. del Gran +Cardenal, lib. 1, cap. 64. + +[10] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 83.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, +cap. 76.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1487. + +[11] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, ubi supra.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., +ubi supra. + +[12] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 1, epist. 83--Pulgar, Reyes +Católicos, cap. 76.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, cap. 83.--Oviedo, +Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, dial. 36. + +[13] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 76. + +[14] Salazar de Mendoza, Crón. del Gran Cardenal, lib. 1, cap. 64.-- +Zurita, Anales, tom. iv. cap. 70.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. +83. + +[15] Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 15.--Conde, Dominacion, tom. iv. pp. +237, 238.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 83.--Pulgar, Reyes +Católicos, cap. 79. + +[16] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, ubi supra. + +During the siege, ambassadors arrived from an African potentate, the king +of Tremecen, bearing a magnificent present to the Castilian sovereigns, +interceding for the Malagans, and at the same time asking protection for +his subjects from the Spanish cruisers in the Mediterranean. The +sovereigns graciously complied with the latter request, and complimented +the African monarch with a plate of gold, on which the royal arms were +curiously embossed, says Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, cap. 84. + +[17] This nobleman, Don Alvaro de Portugal, had fled his native country, +and sought an asylum in Castile from the vindictive enmity of John II, who +had been put to death by the duke of Braganza, his elder brother. He was +kindly received by Isabella, to whom he was nearly related, and +subsequently preferred to several important offices of state. His son, the +count of Gelves, married a granddaughter of Christopher Columbus. Oviedo, +Quincuagenas, MS. + +[18] Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, dial. 23.--Peter Martyr, +Opus Epist., lib. 1, epist. 63.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. +84.--Bleda, Corónica de los Moros, lib. 5, cap. 15.--L. Marineo, Cosas +Memorables, fol. 175, 176. + +[19] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 87-89.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, +MS., cap. 84. + +[20] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 87.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, +cap. 71. + +[21] Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. pp. 237, 238.--Pulgar, +Reyes Católicos, cap. 80.--Caro de Torres, Ordenes Militares, fol. 82, 83. + +[22] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 9l.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., +cap. 84. The honest exclamation of the Curate brings to mind the similar +encomium of the old Moorish ballad, + + "Caballeros Granadinos, Aunque Moros, hijosdalgo." + +Hyta, Guerras de Granada, tom. i., p. 257. + +[23] There is no older well-authenticated account of the employment of +gunpowder in mining in European warfare, so far as I am aware, than this +by Ramirez. Tiraboschi, indeed, refers, on the authority of another +writer, to a work in the library of the Academy of Siena, composed by one +Francesco Giorgio, architect of the duke of Urbino, about 1480, in which +that person claims the merit of the invention. (Letteratura Italiana, tom. +vi. p. 370.) The whole statement is obviously too loose to warrant any +such conclusion. The Italian historians notice the use of gunpowder mines +at the siege of the little town of Serezanello in Tuscany, by the Genoese, +in 1487, precisely contemporaneous with the siege of Malaga. (Machiavelli, +Istorie Fiorentine, lib. 8.--Guicciardini, Istoria d'Italia, (Milano, +1803,) tom. iii. lib. 6.) This singular coincidence, in nations having +then but little intercourse, would seem to infer some common origin of +greater antiquity. However this may be, the writers of both nations are +agreed in ascribing the first successful use of such mines on any extended +scale to the celebrated Spanish engineer, Pedro Navarro, when serving +under Gonsalvo of Cordova, in his Italian campaigns at the beginning of +the sixteenth century. Guicciardini, ubi supra.--Paolo Giovio, de Vitâ +Magni Gonsalvi, (Vitae Illustrium Virorum, Basiliae, 1578,) lib. 2.-- +Aleson, Annales de Navarra, tom. v. lib. 35, cap. 12. + +[24] Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique et d'Espagne, tom. iii. p. 296.--L. +Marineo, Cosas Memorables, fol. 175.--Rades y Andrada, Las Tres Ordenes, +fol. 54.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 92.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, +MS., cap. 85. + +[25] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 93.--Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique et +d'Espagne, tom. iii. p. 296. + +The Arabic historians state that Malaga was betrayed by Ali Dordux, who +admitted the Spaniards into the castle, while the citizens were debating +on Ferdinand's terms. (See Conde, Domination de los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. +39.) The letter of the inhabitants, quoted at length by Pulgar, would seem +to be a refutation of this. And yet there are good grounds for suspecting +false play on the part of the ambassador Dordux, since the Castilian +writers admit that he was exempted, with forty of his friends, from the +doom of slavery and forfeiture of property, passed upon his fellow- +citizens. + +[26] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 85. + +[27] Carbajal, whose meagre annals have scarcely any merit beyond that of +a mere chronological table, postpones the surrender till September. +Anales, año 1487.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 14. + +[28] Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 15. + +As a counterpart to the above scene, twelve Christian renegades, found in +the city, were transfixed with canes, _acañavereados_, a barbarous +punishment derived from the Moors, which was inflicted by horsemen at full +gallop, who discharged pointed reeds at the criminal, until he expired +under repeated wounds. A number of relapsed Jews were at the same time +condemned to the flames. "These," says Father Abarca, "were the _fêtes_ +and illuminations most grateful to the Catholic piety of our sovereigns"! +Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, tom. ii. rey 30, cap. 3. + +[29] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, ubi supra.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., +ubi supra.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 62. + +[30] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 87.--L. Marineo, Cosas +Memorables, fol. 176.--Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. p. 238. +--Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique et d'Espagne, tom. iii. p. 296.--Carbajal, +Anales, MS., año 1487. + +Not a word of comment escapes the Castilian historians on this merciless +rigor of the conqueror towards the vanquished. It is evident that +Ferdinand did no violence to the feelings of his orthodox subjects. +_Tacendo clamant._ + +[31] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 87.--Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, +cap. 15. + +About four hundred and fifty Moorish Jews were ransomed by a wealthy +Israelite of Castile for 27,000 doblas of gold. A proof that the Jewish +stock was one which thrived amidst persecution. + +It is scarcely possible that the circumstantial Pulgar should have omitted +to notice so important a fact as the scheme of the Moorish ransom, had it +occurred. It is still more improbable, that the honest Curate of Los +Palacios should have fabricated it. Any one who attempts to reconcile the +discrepancies of contemporary historians even, will have Lord Orford's +exclamation to his son Horace brought to his mind ten times a day; "Oh! +read me not history, for that I know to be false." + +[32] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 94.--Col. de Céd., tom. vi. no. 321. + + + + +CHAPTER XIV. + +WAR OF GRANADA.--CONQUEST OF BAZA.--SUBMISSION OF EL ZAGAL. + +1487-1489. + +The Sovereigns visit Aragon.--The King lays Siege to Baza.--Its Great +Strength.--Gardens Cleared of their Timber.--The Queen Raises the Spirits +of her Troops.--Her Patriotic Sacrifices.--Suspension of Arms.--Baza +Surrenders.--Treaty with Zagal.--Difficulties of the Campaign.--Isabella's +Popularity and Influence. + + +In the autumn of 1487, Ferdinand and Isabella, accompanied by the younger +branches of the royal family, visited Aragon, to obtain the recognition +from the cortes of Prince John's succession, now in his tenth year, as +well as to repress the disorders into which the country had fallen during +the long absence of its sovereigns. To this end, the principal cities and +communities of Aragon had recently adopted the institution of the +hermandad, organized on similar principles to that of Castile. Ferdinand, +on his arrival at Saragossa in the month of November, gave his royal +sanction to the association, extending the term of its duration to five +years, a measure extremely unpalatable to the great feudal nobility, whose +power, or rather abuse of power, was considerably abridged by this popular +military force. [1] + +The sovereigns, after accomplishing the objects of their visit, and +obtaining an appropriation from the cortes for the Moorish war, passed +into Valencia, where measures of like efficiency were adopted for +restoring the authority of the law, which was exposed to such perpetual +lapses in this turbulent age, even in the best constituted governments, as +required for its protection the utmost vigilance, on the part of those +intrusted with the supreme executive power. From Valencia the court +proceeded to Murcia, where Ferdinand, in the month of June, 1488, assumed +the command of an army amounting to less than twenty thousand men, a small +force compared with those usually levied on these occasions; it being +thought advisable to suffer the nation to breathe a while, after the +exhausting efforts in which it had been unintermittingly engaged for so +many years. + +Ferdinand, crossing the eastern borders of Granada, at no great distance +from Vera, which speedily opened its gates, kept along the southern slant +of the coast as far as Almeria; whence, after experiencing some rough +treatment from a sortie of the garrison, he marched by a northerly circuit +on Baza, for the purpose of reconnoitring its position, as his numbers +were altogether inadequate to its siege. A division of the army under the +marquis duke of Cadiz suffered itself to be drawn here into an ambuscade +by the wily old monarch El Zagal, who lay in Baza with a strong force. +After extricating his troops with some difficulty and loss from this +perilous predicament, Ferdinand retreated on his own dominions by the way +of Huescar, where he disbanded his army, and withdrew to offer up his +devotions at the cross of Caravaca. The campaign, though signalized by no +brilliant achievement, and indeed clouded with some slight reverses, +secured the surrender of a considerable number of fortresses and towns of +inferior note. [2] + +The Moorish chief, El Zagal, elated by his recent success, made frequent +forays into the Christian territories, sweeping off the flocks, herds, and +growing crops of the husbandman; while the garrisons of Almeria and +Salobrena, and the bold inhabitants of the valley of Purchena, poured a +similar devastating warfare over the eastern borders of Granada into +Murcia. To meet this pressure, the Spanish sovereigns reinforced the +frontier with additional levies under Juan de Benavides and Garcilasso de +la Vega; while Christian knights, whose prowess is attested in many a +Moorish lay, flocked there from all quarters, as to the theatre of war. + +During the following winter, of 1488, Ferdinand and Isabella occupied +themselves with the interior government of Castile, and particularly the +administration of justice. A commission was specially appointed to +supervise the conduct of the corregidors and subordinate magistrates, "so +that every one," says Pulgar, "was most careful to discharge his duty +faithfully, in order to escape the penalty, which was otherwise sure to +overtake him." [3] + +While at Valladolid, the sovereigns received an embassy from Maximilian, +son of the emperor Frederic the Fourth, of Germany, soliciting their co- +operation in his designs against France for the restitution of his late +wife's rightful inheritance, the duchy of Burgundy, and engaging in turn +to support them in their claims on Roussillon and Cerdagne. The Spanish +monarchs had long entertained many causes of discontent with the French +court, both with regard to the mortgaged territory of Roussillon, and the +kingdom of Navarre; and they watched with jealous eye the daily increasing +authority of their formidable neighbor on their own frontier. They had +been induced, in the preceding summer, to equip an armanent at Biscay and +Guipuscoa, to support the duke of Brittany in his wars with the French +regent, the celebrated Anne de Beaujeu. This expedition, which proved +disastrous, was followed by another in the spring of the succeeding year. +[4] But, notwithstanding these occasional episodes to the great work in +which they were engaged, they had little leisure for extended operations; +and, although they entered into the proposed treaty of alliance with +Maximilian, they do not seem to have contemplated any movement of +importance before the termination of the Moorish war. The Flemish +ambassadors, after being entertained for forty days in a style suited to +impress them with high ideas of the magnificence of the Spanish court, and +of its friendly disposition towards their master, were dismissed with +costly presents, and returned to their own country. [5] + +These negotiations show the increasing intimacy growing up between the +European states, who, as they settled their domestic feuds, had leisure to +turn their eyes abroad, and enter into the more extended field of +international politics. The tenor of this treaty indicates also the +direction which affairs were to take, when the great powers should be +brought into collision with each other on a common theatre of action. + +All thoughts were now concentrated on the prosecution of the war with +Granada, which, it was determined, should be conducted on a more enlarged +scale than it had yet been; notwithstanding the fearful pest which had +desolated the country during the past year, and the extreme scarcity of +grain, owing to the inundations caused by excessive rains in the fruitful +provinces of the south. The great object proposed in this campaign was the +reduction of Baza, the capital of that division of the empire which +belonged to El Zagal. Besides this important city, that monarch's +dominions embraced the wealthy sea-port of Almeria, Guadix, and numerous +other towns and villages of less consequence, together with the mountain +region of the Alpuxarras, rich in mineral wealth; whose inhabitants, +famous for the perfection to which they had carried the silk manufacture, +were equally known for their enterprise and courage in war, so that El +Zagal's division comprehended the most potent and opulent portion of the +empire. [6] In the spring of 1489, the Castilian court passed to Jaen, at +which place the queen was to establish her residence, as presenting the +most favorable point of communication with the invading army. Ferdinand +advanced as far as Sotogordo, where, on the 27th of May, he put himself at +the head of a numerous force, amounting to about fifteen thousand horse +and eighty thousand foot, including persons of every description; among +whom was gathered, as usual, that chivalrous array of nobility and +knighthood, who, with stately and well-appointed retinues, were accustomed +to follow the royal standard in these crusades. [8] + +The first point, against which operations were directed, was the strong +post of Cuxar, two leagues only from Baza, which surrendered after a brief +but desperate resistance. The occupation of this place, and some adjacent +fortresses, left the approaches open to El Zagal's capital. As the Spanish +army toiled up the heights of the mountain barrier, which towers above +Baza on the west, their advance was menaced by clouds of Moorish light +troops, who poured down a tempest of musket-balls and arrows on their +heads. These however were quickly dispersed by the advancing vanguard; and +the Spaniards, as they gained the summits of the hills, beheld the lordly +city of Baza, reposing in the shadows of the bold sierra that stretches +towards the coast, and lying in the bosom of a fruitful valley, extending +eight leagues in length, and three in breadth. Through this valley flowed +the waters of the Guadalentin and the Guadalquiton, whose streams were +conducted by a thousand canals over the surface of the vega. In the midst +of the plain, adjoining the suburbs, might be descried the orchard or +garden, as it was termed, of Baza, a league in length, covered with a +thick growth of wood, and with numerous villas and pleasure-houses of the +wealthy citizens, now converted into garrisoned fortresses. The suburbs +were encompassed by a low mud wall; but the fortifications of the city +were of uncommon strength. The place, in addition to ten thousand troops +of its own, was garrisoned by an equal number from Almeria; picked men, +under the command of the Moorish prince Cidi Yahye, a relative of El +Zagal, who lay at this time in Guadix, prepared to cover his own dominions +against any hostile movement of his rival in Granada. These veterans were +commissioned to defend the place to the last extremity; and, as due time +had been given for preparation, the town was victualled with fifteen +months' provisions, and even the crops growing in the vega had been +garnered before their prime, to save them from the hands of the enemy. [8] + +The first operation, after the Christian army had encamped before the +walls of Baza, was to get possession of the garden, without which it would +be impossible to enforce a thorough blockade, since its labyrinth of +avenues afforded the inhabitants abundant facilities of communication with +the surrounding country. The assault was intrusted to the grand master of +St. James, supported by the principal cavaliers, and the king in person. +Their reception by the enemy was such as gave them a foretaste of the +perils and desperate daring they were to encounter in the present siege. +The broken surface of the ground, bewildered with intricate passes, and +thickly studded with trees and edifices, was peculiarly favorable to the +desultory and illusory tactics of the Moors. The Spanish cavalry was +brought at once to a stand; the ground proving impracticable for it, it +was dismounted, and led to the charge by its officers on foot. The men, +however, were soon scattered far asunder from their banners and their +leaders. Ferdinand, who from a central position endeavored to overlook the +field, with the design of supporting the attack on the points most +requiring it, soon lost sight of his columns amid the precipitous ravines, +and the dense masses of foliage which everywhere intercepted the view. The +combat was carried on, hand to hand, in the utmost confusion. Still the +Spaniards pressed forward, and, after a desperate struggle for twelve +hours, in which many of the bravest on both sides fell, and the Moslem +chief Reduan Zafarga had four horses successively killed under him, the +enemy were beaten back behind the intrenchments that covered the suburbs, +and the Spaniards, hastily constructing a defence of palisades, pitched +their tents on the field of battle. [9] + +The following morning Ferdinand had the mortification to observe, that the +ground was too much broken and obstructed with wood, to afford a suitable +place for a general encampment. To evacuate his position, however, in the +face of the enemy, was a delicate manoeuvre, and must necessarily expose +him to severe loss. This he obviated, in a great measure, by a fortunate +stratagem. He commanded the tents nearest the town to be left standing, +and thus succeeded in drawing off the greater part of his forces, before +the enemy was aware of his intention. + +After regaining his former position, a council of war was summoned to +deliberate on the course next to be pursued. The chiefs were filled with +despondency, as they revolved the difficulties of their situation. They +almost despaired of enforcing the blockade of a place, whose peculiar +situation gave it such advantages. Even could this be effected, the camp +would be exposed, they argued, to the assaults of a desperate garrison on +the one hand, and of the populous city of Guadix, hardly twenty miles +distant, on the other; while the good faith of Granada could scarcely be +expected to outlive a single reverse of fortune; so that, instead of +besieging, they might be more properly regarded as themselves besieged. In +addition to these evils, the winter frequently set in with much rigor in +this quarter; and the torrents, descending from the mountains, and +mingling with the waters of the valley, might overwhelm the camp with an +inundation, which, if it did not sweep it away at once, would expose it to +the perils of famine by cutting off all external communication. Under +these gloomy impressions, many of the council urged Ferdinand to break up +his position at once, and postpone all operations on Baza, until the +reduction of the surrounding country should make it comparatively easy. +Even the marquis of Cadiz gave in to this opinion; and Gutierre de +Cardenas, commander of Leon, a cavalier deservedly high in the confidence +of the king, was almost the only person of consideration decidedly opposed +to it. In this perplexity, Ferdinand, as usual in similar exigencies, +resolved to take counsel of the queen. [10] + +Isabella received her husband's despatches a few hours after they were +written, by means of the regular line of posts maintained between the camp +and her station at Jaen. She was filled with chagrin at their import, from +which she plainly saw, that all her mighty preparations were about to +vanish into air. Without assuming the responsibility of deciding the +proposed question, however, she besought her husband not to distrust the +providence of God, which had conducted them through so many perils towards +the consummation of their wishes. She reminded him, that the Moorish +fortunes were never at so low an ebb as at present, and that their own +operations could probably never be resumed on such a formidable scale or +under so favorable auspices as now, when their arms had not been stained +with a single important reverse. She concluded with the assurance, that, +if his soldiers would be true to their duty, they might rely on her for +the faithful discharge of hers in furnishing them with all the requisite +supplies. + +The exhilarating tone of this letter had an instantaneous effect, +silencing the scruples of the most timid, and confirming the confidence of +the others. The soldiers, in particular, who had received with +dissatisfaction some intimation of what was passing in the council, +welcomed it with general enthusiasm; and every heart seemed now intent on +furthering the wishes of their heroic queen by prosecuting the siege with +the utmost vigor. + +The army was accordingly distributed into two encampments; one under the +marquis duke of Cadiz, supported by the artillery, the other under King +Ferdinand on the opposite side of the city. Between the two lay the garden +or orchard before mentioned, extending a league in length; so that, in +order to connect the works of the two camps, it became necessary to get +possession of this contested ground, and to clear it of the heavy timber +with which it was covered. + +This laborious operation was intrusted to the commander of Leon, and the +work was covered by a detachment of seven thousand troops, posted in such +a manner as to check the sallies of the garrison. Notwithstanding four +thousand _taladores_, or pioneers, were employed in the task, the +forest was so dense, and the sorties from the city so annoying, that the +work of devastation did not advance more than ten paces a day, and was not +completed before the expiration of seven weeks. When the ancient groves, +so long the ornament and protection of the city, were levelled to the +ground, preparations were made for connecting the two camps, by a deep +trench, through which the mountain waters were made to flow; while the +borders were fortified with palisades, constructed of the timber lately +hewn, together with strong towers of mud or clay, arranged at regular +intervals. In this manner, the investment of the city was complete on the +side of the vega. [11] + +As means of communication still remained open, however, by the opposite +sierra, defences of similar strength, consisting of two stone walls +separated by a deep trench, were made to run along the rocky heights and +ravines of the mountains until they touched the extremities of the +fortifications on the plain; and thus Baza was encompassed by an unbroken +line of circumvallation. + +In the progress of the laborious work, which occupied ten thousand men, +under the indefatigable commander of Leon, for the space of two months, it +would have been easy for the people of Guadix, or of Granada, by co- +operation with the sallies of the besieged, to place the Christian army in +great peril. Some feeble demonstration of such a movement was made at +Guadix, but it was easily disconcerted. Indeed, El Zagal was kept in check +by the fear of leaving his own territory open to his rival, should he +march against the Christians. Abdallah, in the mean while, lay inactive in +Granada, incurring the odium and contempt of his people, who stigmatized +him as a Christian in heart, and a pensioner of the Spanish sovereigns. +Their discontent gradually swelled into a rebellion, which was suppressed +by him with a severity, that at length induced a sullen acquiescence in a +rule, which, however inglorious, was at least attended with temporary +security. [12] + +While the camp lay before Baza, a singular mission was received from the +sultan of Egypt, who had been solicited by the Moors of Granada to +interpose in their behalf with the Spanish sovereigns. Two Franciscan +friars, members of a religious community in Palestine, were bearers of +despatches; which, after remonstrating with the sovereigns on. their +persecution of the Moors, contrasted it with the protection uniformly +extended by the sultan to the Christians in his dominions. The +communication concluded with menacing a retaliation of similar severities +on these latter, unless the sovereigns desisted from their hostilities +towards Granada. + +From the camp, the two ambassadors proceeded to Jaen, where they were +received by the queen with all the deference due to their holy profession, +which seemed to derive additional sanctity from the spot in which it was +exercised. The menacing import of the sultan's communication, however, had +no power to shake the purposes of Ferdinand and Isabella, who made answer, +that they had uniformly observed the same policy in regard to their +Mahometan, as to their Christian subjects; but that they could no longer +submit to see their ancient and rightful inheritance in the hands of +strangers; and that, if these latter would consent to live under their +rule, as true and loyal subjects, they should experience the same paternal +indulgence which had been shown to their brethren. With this answer the +reverend emissaries returned to the Holy Land, accompanied by substantial +marks of the royal favor, in a yearly pension of one thousand ducats, +which the queen settled in perpetuity on their monastery, together with a +richly embroidered veil, the work of her own fair hands, to be suspended +over the Holy Sepulchre. The sovereigns subsequently despatched the +learned Peter Martyr as their envoy to the Moslem court, in order to +explain their proceedings more at length, and avert any disastrous +consequences from the Christian residents. [13] + +In the mean while, the siege went forward with spirit; skirmishes and +single rencontres taking place every day between the high-mettled +cavaliers on both sides. These chivalrous combats, however, were +discouraged by Ferdinand, who would have confined his operations to strict +blockade, and avoided the unnecessary effusion of blood; especially as the +advantage was most commonly on the side of the enemy, from the peculiar +adaptation of their tactics to this desultory warfare. Although some +months had elapsed, the besieged rejected with scorn every summons to +surrender; relying on their own resources, and still more on the +tempestuous season of autumn, now fast advancing, which, if it did not +break up the encampment at once, would at least, by demolishing the roads, +cut off all external communication. + +In order to guard against these impending evils, Ferdinand caused more +than a thousand houses, or rather huts, to be erected, with walls of earth +or clay, and roofs made of timber and tiles; while the common soldiers +constructed cabins by means of palisades loosely thatched with the +branches of trees. The whole work was accomplished in four days; and the +inhabitants of Baza beheld with amazement a city of solid edifices, with +all its streets and squares in regular order, springing as it were by +magic out of the ground, which had before been covered with the light and +airy pavilions of the camp. The new city was well supplied, owing to the +providence of the queen, not merely with the necessaries, but the luxuries +of life. Traders flocked there as to a fair, from Aragon, Valencia, +Catalonia, and even Sicily, freighted with costly merchandise, and with +jewelry and other articles of luxury; such as, in the indignant lament of +an old chronicler, "too often corrupt the souls of the soldiery, and bring +waste and dissipation into a camp." + +That this was not the result, however, in the present instance, is +attested by more than one historian. Among others, Peter Martyr, the +Italian scholar before mentioned, who was present at this siege, dwells +with astonishment on the severe decorum and military discipline, which +everywhere obtained among this motley congregation of soldiers. "Who would +have believed," says he, "that the Galician, the fierce Asturian, and the +rude inhabitant of the Pyrenees, men accustomed to deeds of atrocious +violence, and to brawl and battle on the lightest occasions at home, +should mingle amicably, not only with one another, but with the Toledans, +La-Manchans, and the wily and jealous Andalusian; all living together in +harmonious subordination to authority, like members of one family, +speaking one tongue, and nurtured under a common discipline; so that the +camp seemed like a community modelled on the principles of Plato's +republic!" In another part of this letter, which was addressed to a +Milanese prelate, he panegyrizes the camp hospital of the queen, then a +novelty in war; which, he says, "is so profusely supplied with medical +attendants, apparatus, and whatever may contribute to the restoration or +solace of the sick, that it is scarcely surpassed in these respects by the +magnificent establishments of Milan." [14] + +During the five months which the siege had now lasted, the weather had +proved uncommonly propitious to the Spaniards, being for the most part of +a bland and equal temperature, while the sultry heats of midsummer were +mitigated by cool and moderate showers. As the autumnal season advanced, +however, the clouds began to settle heavily around the mountains; and at +length one of those storms, predicted by the people of Baza, burst forth +with incredible fury, pouring a volume of waters down the rocky sides of +the sierra, which, mingling with those of the vega, inundated the camp of +the besiegers, and swept away most of the frail edifices constructed for +the use of the common soldiery. A still greater calamity befell them in +the dilapidation of the roads, which, broken up or worn into deep gullies +by the force of the waters, were rendered perfectly impassable. All +communication was of course suspended with Jaen, and a temporary +interruption of the convoys filled the camp with consternation. This +disaster, however, was speedily repaired by the queen, who, with an energy +always equal to the occasion, caused six thousand pioneers to be at once +employed in reconstructing the roads; the rivers were bridged over, +causeways new laid, and two separate passes opened through the mountains, +by which the convoys might visit the camp, and return without interrupting +each other. At the same time, the queen bought up immense quantities of +grain from all parts of Andalusia, which she caused to be ground in her +own mills; and, when the roads, which extended more than seven leagues in +length, were completed, fourteen thousand mules might be seen daily +traversing the sierra, laden with supplies, which from that time forward +were poured abundantly, and with the most perfect regularity, into the +camp. [15] + +Isabella's next care was to assemble new levies of troops, to relieve or +reinforce those now in the camp; and the alacrity with which all orders of +men from every quarter of the kingdom answered her summons is worthy of +remark. But her chief solicitude was to devise expedients for meeting the +enormous expenditures incurred by the protracted operations of the year. +For this purpose, she had recourse to loans from individuals and religious +corporations, which were obtained without much difficulty, from the +general confidence in her good faith. As the sum thus raised, although +exceedingly large for that period, proved inadequate to the expenses, +further supplies were obtained from wealthy individuals, whose loans were +secured by mortgage of the royal demesne; and, as a deficiency still +remained in the treasury, the queen, as a last resource, pawned the crown +jewels and her own personal ornaments to the merchants of Barcelona and +Valencia, for such sums as they were willing to advance on them. [16] Such +were the efforts made by this high-spirited woman, for the furtherance of +her patriotic enterprise. The extraordinary results, which she was enabled +to effect, are less to be ascribed to the authority of her station, than +to that perfect confidence in her wisdom and virtue, with which she had +inspired the whole nation, and which secured their earnest co-operation in +all her undertakings. The empire, which she thus exercised, indeed, was +far more extended than any station, however exalted, or any authority, +however despotic, can confer; for it was over the hearts of her people. + +Notwithstanding the vigor with which the siege was pressed, Baza made no +demonstration of submission. The garrison was indeed greatly reduced in +number; the ammunition was nearly expended; yet there still remained +abundant supplies of provisions in the town, and no signs of despondency +appeared among the people. Even the women of the place, with a spirit +emulating that of the dames of ancient Carthage, freely gave up their +jewels, bracelets, necklaces, and other personal ornaments, of which the +Moorish ladies were exceedingly fond, in order to defray the charges of +the mercenaries. + +The camp of the besiegers, in the mean while, was also greatly wasted both +by sickness and the sword. Many, desponding under perils and fatigues, +which seemed to have no end, would even at this late hour have abandoned +the siege; and they earnestly solicited the queen's appearance in the +camp, in the hope that she would herself countenance this measure, on +witnessing their sufferings. Others, and by far the larger part, anxiously +desired the queen's visit, as likely to quicken the operations of the +siege, and bring it to a favorable issue. There seemed to be a virtue in +her presence, which, on some account or other, made it earnestly desired +by all. + +Isabella yielded to the general wish, and on the 7th of November arrived +before the camp, attended by the infanta Isabella, the cardinal of Spain, +her friend, the marchioness of Moya, and other ladies of the royal +household. The inhabitants of Baza, says Bernaldez, lined the battlements +and housetops, to gaze at the glittering cavalcade as it emerged from the +depths of the mountains, amidst flaunting banners and strains of martial +music, while the Spanish cavaliers thronged forth in a body from the camp +to receive their beloved mistress, and gave her the most animated welcome. +"She came," says Martyr, "surrounded by a choir of nymphs, as if to +celebrate the nuptials of her child; and her presence seemed at once to +gladden and reanimate our spirits, drooping under long vigils, dangers, +and fatigue." Another writer, also present, remarks that, from the moment +of her appearance, a change seemed to come over the scene. No more of the +cruel skirmishes, which had before occurred every day; no report of +artillery, or clashing of arms, or any of the rude sounds of war, was to +be heard, but all seemed disposed to reconciliation and peace. [17] + +The Moors probably interpreted Isabella's visit into an assurance, that +the Christian army would never rise from before the place until its +surrender. Whatever hopes they had once entertained of wearying out the +besiegers, were therefore now dispelled. Accordingly, a few days after the +queen's arrival, we find them proposing a parley for arranging terms of +capitulation. + +On the third day after her arrival, Isabella reviewed her army, stretched +out in order of battle along the slope of the western hills; after which, +she proceeded to reconnoitre the beleaguered city, accompanied by the king +and the cardinal of Spain, together with a brilliant escort of the Spanish +chivalry. On the same day, a conference was opened with the enemy through +the _comendador_ of Leon; and an armistice arranged, to continue until the +old monarch, El Zagal, who then lay at Guadix, could be informed of the +real condition of the besieged, and his instructions be received, +determining the course to be adopted. + +The alcayde of Baza represented to his master the low state to which the +garrison was reduced by the loss of lives and the failure of ammunition. +Still, he expressed such confidence in the spirit of his people, that he +undertook to make good his defence some time longer, provided any +reasonable expectation of succor could be afforded; otherwise, it would be +a mere waste of life, and must deprive him of such vantage ground as he +now possessed, for enforcing an honorable capitulation. The Moslem prince +acquiesced in the reasonableness of these representations. He paid a just +tribute to his brave kinsman Cidi Yahye's loyalty, and the gallantry of +his defence; but, confessing at the same time his own inability to relieve +him, authorized him to negotiate the best terms of surrender which he +could, for himself and garrison. [18] + +A mutual desire of terminating the protracted hostilities infused a spirit +of moderation into both parties, which greatly facilitated the adjustment +of the articles. Ferdinand showed none of the arrogant bearing, which +marked his conduct towards the unfortunate people of Malaga, whether from +a conviction of its impolicy, or, as is more probable, because the city of +Baza was itself in a condition to assume a more imposing attitude. The +principal stipulations of the treaty were, that the foreign mercenaries +employed in the defence of the place should be allowed to march out with +the honors of war; that the city should be delivered up to the Christians; +but that the natives might have the choice of retiring with their personal +effects where they listed; or of occupying the suburbs, as subjects of the +Castilian crown, liable only to the same tribute which they paid to their +Moslem rulers, and secured in the enjoyment of their property, religion, +laws, and usages. [19] + +On the fourth day of December, 1489, Ferdinand and Isabella took +possession of Baza, at the head of their legions, amid the ringing of +bells, the peals of artillery, and all the other usual accompaniments of +this triumphant ceremony; while the standard of the Cross, floating from +the ancient battlements of the city, proclaimed the triumph of the +Christian arms. The brave alcayde, Cidi Yahye, experienced a reception +from the sovereigns very different from that of the bold defender of +Malaga. He was loaded with civilities and presents; and these acts of +courtesy so won upon his heart, that he expressed a willingness to enter +into their service. "Isabella's compliments," says the Arabian historian, +dryly, "were repaid in more substantial coin." + +Cidi Yahye was soon prevailed on to visit his royal kinsman El Zagal, at +Guadix, for the purpose of urging his submission to the Christian +sovereigns. In his interview with that prince, he represented the +fruitlessness of any attempt to withstand the accumulated forces of the +Spanish monarchies; that he would only see town after town pared away from +his territory, until no ground was left for him to stand on, and make +terms with the victor. He reminded him, that the baleful horoscope of +Abdallah had predicted the downfall of Granada, and that experience had +abundantly shown how vain it was to struggle against the tide of destiny. +The unfortunate monarch listened, says the Arabian annalist, without so +much as moving an eyelid; and, after a long and deep meditation, replied +with the resignation characteristic of the Moslems, "What Allah wills, he +brings to pass in his own way. Had he not decreed the fall of Granada, +this good sword might have saved it; but his will be done!" It was then +arranged, that the principal cities of Almeria, Guadix, and their +dependencies, constituting the domain of El Zagal, should be formally +surrendered by that prince to Ferdinand and Isabella, who should instantly +proceed at the head of their army to take possession of them. [20] + +On the seventh day of December, therefore, the Spanish sovereigns, without +allowing themselves or their jaded troops any time for repose, marched out +of the gates of Baza, King Ferdinand occupying the centre, and the queen +the rear of the army. Their route lay across the most savage district of +the long sierra, which stretches towards Almeria; leading through many a +narrow pass, which a handful of resolute Moors, says an eye-witness, might +have made good against the whole Christian army, over mountains whose +peaks were lost in clouds, and valleys whose depths were never warmed by a +sun. The winds were exceedingly bleak, and the weather inclement, so that +men, as well as horses, exhausted by the fatigues of previous service, +were benumbed by the intense cold, and many of them frozen to death. Many +more, losing their way in the intricacies of the sierra, would have +experienced the same miserable fate, had it not been for the marquis of +Cadiz, whose tent was pitched on one of the loftiest hills, and who caused +beacon fires to be lighted around it, in order to guide the stragglers +back to their quarters. + +At no great distance from Almeria, Ferdinand was met, conformably to the +previous arrangement, by El Zagal, escorted by a numerous body of Moslem +cavaliers. Ferdinand commanded his nobles to ride forward and receive the +Moorish prince. "His appearance," says Martyr, who was in the royal +retinue, "touched my soul with compassion; for, although a lawless +barbarian, he was a king, and had given signal proofs of heroism." El +Zagal, without waiting to receive the courtesies of the Spanish nobles, +threw himself from his horse, and advanced towards Ferdinand with the +design of kissing his hand; but the latter, rebuking his followers for +their "rusticity," in allowing such an act of humiliation in the +unfortunate monarch, prevailed on him to remount, and then rode by his +side towards Almeria. [21] + +This city was one of the most precious jewels in the diadem of Granada. It +had amassed great wealth by its extensive commerce with Syria, Egypt, and +Africa; and its corsairs had for ages been the terror of the Catalan and +Pisan marine. It might have stood a siege as long as that of Baza, but it +was now surrendered without a blow, on conditions similar to those granted +to the former city. After allowing some days for the refreshment of their +wearied forces in this pleasant region, which, sheltered from the bleak +winds of the north by the sierra they had lately traversed, and fanned by +the gentle breezes of the Mediterranean, is compared by Martyr to the +gardens of the Hesperides, the sovereigns established a strong garrison +there, under the commander of Leon, and then, striking again into the +recesses of the mountains, marched on Guadix, which, after some opposition +on the part of the populace, threw open its gates to them. The surrender +of these principal cities was followed by that of all the subordinate +dependencies belonging to El Zagal's territory, comprehending a multitude +of hamlets scattered along the green sides of the mountain chain that +stretched from Granada to the coast. To all these places the same liberal +terms, in regard to personal rights and property, were secured, as to +Baza. + +As an equivalent for these broad domains, the Moorish chief was placed in +possession of the _taha_, or district, of Andaraz, the vale of Alhaurin, +and half the salt-pits of Maleha, together with a considerable revenue in +money. He was, moreover, to receive the title of King of Andaraz, and to +render homage for his estates to the crown of Castile. + +This shadow of royalty could not long amuse the mind of the unfortunate +prince. He pined away amid the scenes of his ancient empire; and, after +experiencing some insubordination on the part of his new vassals, he +determined to relinquish his petty principality, and withdraw for ever +from his native land. Having received a large sum of money, as an +indemnification for the entire cession of his territorial rights and +possessions to the Castilian crown, he passed over to Africa, where, it is +reported, he was plundered of his property by the barbarians, and +condemned to starve out the remainder of his days in miserable indigence. +[22] + +The suspicious circumstances attending this prince's accession to the +throne throw a dark cloud over his fame, which would otherwise seem, at +least as far as his public life is concerned, to be unstained by any +opprobrious act. He possessed such energy, talent, and military science, +as, had he been fortunate enough to unite the Moorish nation under him by +an undisputed title, might have postponed the fall of Granada for many +years. As it was, these very talents, by dividing the state in his favor, +served only to precipitate its ruin. + +The Spanish sovereigns, having accomplished the object of the campaign, +after stationing part of their forces on such points as would secure the +permanence of their conquests, returned with the remainder to Jaen, where +they disbanded the army on the 4th of January, 1490. The losses sustained +by the troops, during the whole period of their prolonged service, greatly +exceeded those of any former year, amounting to not less than twenty +thousand men, by far the larger portion of whom are said to have fallen +victims to diseases incident to severe and long-continued hardships and +exposure. [23] + +Thus terminated the eighth year of the war of Granada, a year more +glorious to the Christian arms, and more important in its results, than +any of the preceding. During this period, an army of eighty thousand men +had kept the field, amid all the inclemencies of winter, for more than +seven months; an effort scarcely paralleled in these times, when both the +amount of levies, and period of service, were on the limited scale adapted +to the exigencies of feudal warfare. [24] Supplies for this immense host, +notwithstanding the severe famine of the preceding year, were punctually +furnished, in spite of every embarrassment presented by the want of +navigable rivers, and the interposition of a precipitous and pathless +sierra. + +The history of this campaign is, indeed, most honorable to the courage, +constancy, and thorough discipline of the Spanish soldier, and to the +patriotism and general resources of the nation; but most of all to +Isabella. She it was, who fortified the timid councils of the leaders, +after the disasters of the garden, and encouraged them to persevere in the +siege. She procured all the supplies, constructed the roads, took charge +of the sick, and furnished, at no little personal sacrifice, the immense +sums demanded for carrying on the war; and when at last the hearts of the +soldiers were fainting under long-protracted sufferings, she appeared +among them, like some celestial visitant, to cheer their faltering +spirits, and inspire them with her own energy. The attachment to Isabella +seemed to be a pervading principle, which animated the whole nation by one +common impulse, impressing a unity of design on all its movements. This +attachment was imputable to her sex as well as character. The sympathy and +tender care, with which she regarded her people, naturally raised a +reciprocal sentiment in their bosoms. But when they beheld her directing +their counsels, sharing their fatigues and dangers, and displaying all the +comprehensive intellectual powers of the other sex, they looked up to her +as to some superior being, with feelings far more exalted than those of +mere loyalty. The chivalrous heart of the Spaniard did homage to her, as +to his tutelar saint; and she held a control over her people, such as no +man could have acquired in any age,--and probably no woman, in an age and +country less romantic. + + * * * * * + +Pietro Martire, or, as he is called in English, Peter Martyr, so often +quoted in the present chapter, and who will constitute one of our best +authorities during the remainder of the history, was a native of Arona +(not of Anghiera, as commonly supposed), a place situated on the borders +of Lake Maggiore in Italy. (Mazzuchelli, Scrittori d'ltalia, (Brescia, +1753-63,) tom. ii. _voce_ Anghiera.) He was of noble Milanese extraction. +In 1477, at twenty-two years of age, he was sent to complete his education +at Rome, where he continued ten years, and formed an intimacy with the +most distinguished literary characters of that cultivated capital. In +1487, he was persuaded by the Castilian ambassador, the count of Tendilla, +to accompany him to Spain, where he was received with marked distinction +by the queen, who would have at once engaged him in the tuition of the +young nobility of the court, but, Martyr having expressed a preference of +a military life, she, with her usual delicacy, declined to press him on +the point. He was present, as we have seen, at the siege of Baza, and +continued with the army during the subsequent campaigns of the Moorish +war. Many passages of his correspondence, at this period, show a whimsical +mixture of self-complacency with a consciousness of the ludicrous figure +which he made in "exchanging the Muses for Mars." + +At the close of the war, he entered the ecclesiastical profession, for +which he had been originally destined, and was persuaded to resume his +literary vocation. He opened his school at Valladolid, Saragossa, +Barcelona, Alcalá de Henares, and other places; and it was thronged with +the principal young nobility from all parts of Spain, who, as he boasts in +one of his letters, drew their literary nourishment from him. "Suxerunt +mea literalia ubera Castellae principes fere omnes." His important +services were fully estimated by the queen, and, after her death, by +Ferdinand and Charles V., and he was recompensed with high ecclesiastical +preferment as well as civil dignities. He died about the year 1525, at the +age of seventy, and his remains were interred beneath a monument in the +cathedral church of Granada, of which he was prior. + +Among Martyr's principal works is a treatise "De Legatione Babylonica," +being an account of a visit to the sultan of Egypt, in 1501, for the +purpose of deprecating the retaliation with which he had menaced the +Christian residents in Palestine, for the injuries inflicted on the +Spanish Moslems. Peter Martyr conducted his negotiation with such address, +that he not only appeased the sultan's resentment, but obtained several +important immunities for his Christian subjects, in addition to those +previously enjoyed by them. + +He also wrote an account of the discoveries of the New World, entitled "De +Rebus Oceanicis et Novo Orbe," (Coloniae, 1574,) a book largely consulted +and commended by subsequent historians. But the work of principal value in +our researches is his "Opus Epistolarum," being a collection of his +multifarious correspondence with the most considerable persons of his +time, whether in political or literary life. The letters are in Latin, and +extend from the year 1488 to the time of his death. Although not +conspicuous for elegance of diction, they are most valuable to the +historian, from the fidelity and general accuracy of the details, as well +as for the intelligent criticism in which they abound, for all which, +uncommon facilities were afforded by the writer's intimacy with the +leading actors, and the most recondite sources of information of the +period. + +This high character is fully authorized by the judgments of those best +qualified to pronounce on their merits,--Martyr's own contemporaries. +Among these, Dr. Galindez de Carbajal, a counsellor of King Ferdinand, and +constantly employed in the highest concerns of state, commends these +epistles as "the work of a learned and upright man, well calculated to +throw light on the transactions of the period." (Anales, MS., prólogo.) +Alvaro Gomez, another contemporary who survived Martyr, in the Life of +Ximenes, which he was selected to write by the University of Alcalá, +declares, that "Martyr's Letters abundantly compensate by their fidelity +for the unpolished style in which they are written." (De Rebus Gestis, +fol. 6.) And John de Vergara, a name of the highest celebrity in the +literary annals of the period, expresses himself in the following emphatic +terms. "I know no record of the time more accurate and valuable. I myself +have often witnessed the promptness with which he put down things the +moment they occurred. I have sometimes seen him write one or two letters, +while they were setting the table. For, as he did not pay much attention +to style and mere finish of expression, his composition required but +little time, and experienced no interruption from his ordinary +avocations." (See his letter to Florian de Ocampo, apud Quintanilla y +Mendoza, Archetypo de Virtudes, Espejo de Prelados, el Venerable Padre y +Siervo de Dios, F. Francisco Ximenez de Cisneros, (Palermo, 1653,) +Archivo, p. 4.) This account of the precipitate manner in which the +epistles were composed, may help to explain the cause of the occasional +inconsistencies and anachronisms, that are to be found in them; and which +their author, had he been more patient of the labor of revision, would +doubtless have corrected. But he seems to have had little relish for this, +even in his more elaborate works, composed with a view to publication. +(See his own honest confessions in his book "De Rebus Oceanicis," dec. 8, +cap. 8, 9.) After all, the errors, such as they are, in his Epistles, may +probably be chiefly charged on the publisher. The first edition appeared +at Alcalá de Henares, in 1530, about four years after the author's death. +It has now become exceedingly rare. The second and last, being the one +used in the present History, came out in a more beautiful form from the +Elzevir press, Amsterdam, in 1670, folio. Of this also but a small number +of copies were struck off. The learned editor takes much credit to himself +for having purified the work from many errors, which had flowed from the +heedlessness of his predecessor. It will not be difficult to detect +several yet remaining. Such, for example, as a memorable letter on the +_lues venerea_, (No. 68,) obviously misplaced, even according to its +own date; and that numbered 168, in which two letters are evidently +blended into one. But it is unnecessary to multiply examples.--It is very +desirable, that an edition of this valuable correspondence should be +published, under the care of some one qualified to illustrate it by his +intimacy with the history of the period, as well as to correct the various +inaccuracies which have crept into it, whether through the carelessness of +the author or of his editors. + +I have been led into this length of remark by some strictures which met my +eye in the recent work of Mr. Hallam; who intimates his belief, that the +Epistles of Martyr, instead of being written at their respective dates, +were produced by him at some later period; (Introduction to the Literature +of Europe, (London, 1837,) vol. i. pp. 439-441;) a conclusion which I +suspect this acute and candid critic would have been slow to adopt, had he +perused the correspondence in connection with the history of the times, or +weighed the unqualified testimony borne by contemporaries to its minute +accuracy. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Zurita, Anales, tom. iv. fol. 351, 352, 356.--Mariana, Hist. de +España, tom. ii. lib. 25, cap. 12.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, part. 3, +cap. 95. + +[2] Ferreras, Hist. d'Espagne, tom. viii. p. 76.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, +cap. 98.--Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, p. 402.--Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique +et d'Espagne, tom. iii. pp. 298, 299.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1488. + +[3] Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. pp. 239, 240.--Pulgar, +Reyes Católicos, cap. 100, 101.--During the preceding year, while the +court was at Murcia, we find one of the examples of prompt and severe +exercise of justice, which sometimes occur in this reign. One of the royal +collectors having been resisted and personally maltreated by the alcayde +of Salvatierra, a place belonging to the crown, and by the alcalde of a +territorial court of the duke of Alva, the queen caused one of the royal +judges privately to enter into the place, and take cognizance of the +affair. The latter, after a brief investigation, commanded the alcayde to +be hung up over his fortress, and the alcalde to be delivered over to the +court of chancery at Valladolid, who ordered his right hand to be +amputated, and banished him the realm. This summary justice was perhaps +necessary in a community, that might be said to be in transition from a +state of barbarism to that of civilization, and had a salutary effect in +proving to the people that no rank was elevated enough to raise the +offender above the law. Pulgar, cap. 99. + +[4] Ialigny, Hist. de Charles VIII., pp. 92, 94.--Sismondi, Hist. des +Français, tom. xv. p. 77.--Aleson, Annales de Navarra, tom. v. p. 61.-- +Histoire du Royaume de Navarre, pp. 578, 579.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, +cap. 102. + +In the first of these expeditions, more than a thousand Spaniards were +slain or taken at the disastrous battle of St. Aubin, in 1488, being the +same in which Lord Rivers, the English noble, who made such a gallant +figure at the siege of Loja, lost his life. In the spring of 1489, the +levies sent into France amounted to two thousand in number. These efforts +abroad, simultaneous with the great operations of the Moorish war, show +the resources as well as energy of the sovereigns. + +[5] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, ubi supra. + +[6] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 91.--Zurita, Anales, tom. iv. +fol. 354.--Bleda, Corónica, fol. 607.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, tom. ii. +fol. 307. + +Such was the scarcity of grain that the prices in 1489, quoted by +Bernaldez, are double those of the preceding year.--Both Abarca and Zurita +mention the report, that four-fifths of the whole population were swept +away by the pestilence of 1488. Zurita finds more difficulty in swallowing +this monstrous statement than Father Abarca, whose appetite for the +marvellous appears to have been fully equal to that of most of his calling +in Spain. + +[7] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 2, epist. 70.--Pulgar, Reyes +Católicos, cap. 104. + +It may not be amiss to specify the names of the most distinguished +cavaliers who usually attended the king in these Moorish wars; the heroic +ancestors of many a noble house still extant in Spain. + + Alonso de Cardenas, master of Saint Jago. + Juan de Zuñiga, master of Alcantara. + Juan Garcia de Padilla, master of Calatrava. + Rodrigo Ponce de Leon, marquis duke of Cadiz. + Enrique de Guzman, duke of Medina Sidonia. + Pedro Manrique, duke of Najera. + Juan Pacheco, duke of Escalona, marquis of Villena. + Juan Pimentel, count of Benavente. + Fadrique de Toledo, son of the duke of Alva. + Diego Fernandez de Cordova, count of Cabra. + Gomez Alvarez de Figueroa, count of Feria. + Alvaro Tellez Giron, count of Ureña. + Juan de Silva, count of Cifuentes. + Fadrique Enriquez, adelantado of Andalusia. + Alonso Fernandez de Cordova, lord of Aguilar. + Gonsalvo de Cordova, brother of the last, known afterwards as the Great + Captain. + Luis Porto-Carrero, lord of Palma. + Gutierre de Cardenas, first commander of Leon. + Pedro Fernandez de Velasco, count of Haro, constable of Castile. + Beltran de la Cueva, duke of Albuquerque. + Diego Fernandez de Cordova, alcayde of the royal pages, afterwards + marquis of Comaras. + Alvaro de Zuñiga, duke of Bejar. + Iñigo Lopez de Mendoza, count of Tendilla, afterwards marquis of + Mondejar. + Luis de Cerda, duke of Medina Celi. + Iñigo Lopez de Mendoza, marquis of Santillana, second duke of Infantado. + Garcilasso de la Vega, lord of Batras. + +[8] Zurita, Anales, tom. iv. fol. 360.--Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, +tom. iii. p. 241.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 2, epist. 70.--Estrada, +Poblacion de España, tom. ii. fol. 239.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, +lib. 1, cap. 16. + +[9] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 106, 107.--Conde, Dominacion de los +Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 40.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 71. Pulgar +relates these particulars with a perspicuity very different from his +entangled narrative of some of the preceding operations in this war. Both +he and Martyr were present during the whole siege of Baza. + +[10] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 92.--Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique +et d'Espagne, tom. iii. pp. 299, 300.--Bleda, Corónica, p. 611.--Garibay, +Compendio, tom. ii. p. 664. + +Don Gutierre de Cardenas, who possessed so high a place in the confidence +of the sovereigns, occupied a station in the queen's household, as we have +seen, at the time of her marriage with Ferdinand. His discretion and +general ability enabled him to retain the influence which he had early +acquired, as is shown by a popular distich of that time. + + "Cardenas, y el Cardenal, y Chacon, y Fray Mortero, + Traen la Corte al retortero." + +Fray Mortero was Don Alonso de Burgos, bishop of Palencia, confessor of +the sovereigns. Don Juan Chacon was the son of Gonsalvo, who had the care +of Don Alfonso and the queen during her minority, when he was induced by +the liberal largesses of John II., of Aragon, to promote her marriage with +his son Ferdinand. The elder Chacon was treated by the sovereigns with the +greatest deference and respect, being usually called by them "father." +After his death, they continued to manifest a similar regard towards Don +Juan, his eldest son, and heir of his ample honors and estates. Salazar de +Mendoza, Dignidades, lib. 4, cap. 1.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, +quinc. 2, dial. 1, 2. + +[11] Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique et d'Espagne, tom. iii. p. 304.--Pulgar, +Reyes Católicos, cap. 109.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 2, epist. 73. +--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 92. + +[12] Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 40.--Mariana, Hist. +de España, tom. ii. lib. 25, cap. 12.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 111. + +[13] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 112.--Ferreras, Hist. d'Espagne, tom. +viii. p. 86. + +[14] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 2, +epist. 73, 80.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 113, 114, 117.--Garibay, +Compendio, tom. ii. p. 667.--Bleda, Corónica, p. 64. + +The plague, which fell heavily this year on some parts of Andalusia, does +not appear to have attacked the camp, which Bleda imputes to the healing +influence of the Spanish sovereigns, "whose good faith, religion, and +virtue banished the contagion from their army, where it must otherwise +have prevailed." Personal comforts and cleanliness of the soldiers, though +not quite so miraculous a cause, may be considered perhaps full as +efficacious. + +[15] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 2, epist. 73.--Pulgar, Reyes +Católicos, cap. 116. + +[16] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 118.--Archivo de Simancas, in Mem. de +la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. p. 311. + +The city of Valencia lent 35,000 florins on the crown and 20,000 on a +collar of rubies. They were not wholly redeemed till 1495. Señor Clemencin +has given a catalogue of the royal jewels, (see Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., +tom. vi. Ilustracion 6,) which appear to have been extremely rich and +numerous, for a period anterior to the discovery of those countries, whose +mines have since furnished Europe with its _bijouterie_. Isabella, +however, set so little value on them, that she divested herself of most of +them in favor of her daughters. + +[17] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 92.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, +cap. 120, 121.--Ferreras, Hist. d'Espagne, tom. viii. p. 93.--Peter +Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 3, epist. 80. + +[18] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 3, epist. 80.--Conde, Dominacion de +los Arabes, tom. iii. p. 242.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1489.--Cardonne, +Hist. d'Afrique et d'Espagne, tom. iii. p. 305. + +[19] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 124.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, +lib. 1, cap. 16. + +[20] Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 40.--Bleda, Corónica, +p. 612.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 92.--Marmol, Rebelion de +Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 16. + +[21] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 3, epist. 81.--Cardonne, Hist. +d'Afrique et d'Espagne, tom. iii. p. 340.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, loc. +cit.--Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 40. + +[22] El Nubiense, Descripcion de España, p. 160, not.--Carbajal, Anales, +MS., año 1488.--Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique et d'Espagne, tom. iii. p. 304. +--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 3, epist. 81.--Conde, Dominacion de los +Arabes, tom. iii. pp. 245, 246.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 93. + +[23] Zurita, Anales, tom. iv. fol. 360.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, tom. ii. +fol. 308. + +[24] The city of Seville alone maintained 600 horse and 8000 foot under +the count of Cifuentes, for the space of eight months during this siege. +See Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, p. 404. + + + + +CHAPTER XV. + +WAR OF GRANADA.--SIEGE AND SURRENDER OF THE CITY OF GRANADA. + +1490-1492. + +The Infanta Isabella Affianced to the Prince of Portugal.--Isabella +Deposes Judges at Valladolid.--Encampment before Granada.--The Queen +Surveys the City.--Moslem and Christian Chivalry.--Conflagration of the +Christian Camp.--Erection of Santa Fe.--Capitulation of Granada.--Results +of the War.--Its Moral Influence.--Its Military Influence.--Fate of the +Moors.--Death and Character of the Marquis of Cadiz. + + +In the spring of 1490, ambassadors arrived from Lisbon for the purpose of +carrying into effect the treaty of marriage, which had been arranged +between Alonso, heir of the Portuguese monarchy, and Isabella, infanta of +Castile. An alliance with this kingdom, which from its contiguity +possessed such ready means of annoyance to Castile, and which had shown +such willingness to employ them in enforcing the pretensions of Joanna +Beltraneja, was an object of importance to Ferdinand and Isabella. No +inferior consideration could have reconciled the queen to a separation +from this beloved daughter, her eldest child, whose gentle and uncommonly +amiable disposition seems to have endeared her beyond their other children +to her parents. + +The ceremony of the affiancing took place at Seville, in the month of +April, Don Fernando de Silveira appearing as the representative of the +prince of Portugal; and it was followed by a succession of splendid +_fêtes_ and tourneys. Lists were enclosed, at some distance from the +city on the shores of the Guadalquivir, and surrounded with galleries hung +with silk and cloth of gold, and protected from the noontide heat by +canopies or awnings richly embroidered with the armorial bearings of the +ancient houses of Castile. The spectacle was graced by all the rank and +beauty of the court, with the infanta Isabella in the midst, attended by +seventy noble ladies, and a hundred pages of the royal household. The +cavaliers of Spain, young and old, thronged to the tournament, as eager to +win laurels on the mimic theatre of war, in the presence of so brilliant +an assemblage, as they had shown themselves in the sterner contests with +the Moors. King Ferdinand, who broke several lances on the occasion, was +among the most distinguished of the combatants for personal dexterity and +horsemanship. The martial exercises of the day were relieved by the more +effeminate recreations of dancing and music in the evening; and every one +seemed willing to welcome the season of hilarity, after the long- +protracted fatigues of war. [1] + +In the following autumn, the infanta was escorted into Portugal by the +cardinal of Spain, the grand master of St. James, and a numerous and +magnificent retinue. Her dowry exceeded that usually assigned to the +infantas of Castile, by five hundred marks of gold and a thousand of +silver; and her wardrobe was estimated at one hundred and twenty thousand +gold florins. The contemporary chroniclers dwell with much complacency on +these evidences of the stateliness and splendor of the Castilian court. +Unfortunately, these fair auspices were destined to be clouded too soon by +the death of the prince, her husband. [2] + +No sooner had the campaign of the preceding year been brought to a close, +than Ferdinand and Isabella sent an embassy to the king of Granada, +requiring a surrender of his capital, conformably to his stipulations at +Loja, which guaranteed this, on the capitulation of Baza, Almeria, and +Guadix. That time had now arrived; King Abdallah, however, excused himself +from obeying the summons of the Spanish sovereigns; replying that he was +no longer his own master, and that, although he had all the inclination to +keep his engagements, he was prevented by the inhabitants of the city, now +swollen much beyond its natural population, who resolutely insisted on its +defence. [3] + +It is not probable that the Moorish king did any great violence to his +feelings, in this evasion of a promise extorted from him in captivity. At +least, it would seem so from the hostile movements which immediately +succeeded. The people of Granada resumed all at once their ancient +activity, foraying into the Christian territories, surprising Alhendin and +some other places of less importance, and stirring up the spirit of revolt +in Guadix and other conquered cities. Granada, which had slept through the +heat of the struggle, seemed to revive at the very moment when exertion +became hopeless. + +Ferdinand was not slow in retaliating these acts of aggression. In the +spring of 1490, he marched with a strong force into the cultivated plain +of Granada, sweeping off, as usual, the crops and cattle, and rolling the +tide of devastation up to the very walls of the city. In this campaign he +conferred the honor of knighthood on his son, prince John, then only +twelve years of age, whom he had brought with him, after the ancient usage +of the Castilian nobles, of training up their children from very tender +years in the Moorish wars. The ceremony was performed on the banks of the +grand canal, under the battlements almost of the beleaguered city. The +dukes of Cadiz and Medina Sidonia were prince John's sponsors; and, after +the completion of the ceremony, the new knight conferred the honors of +chivalry in like manner on several of his young companions in arms. [4] + +In the following autumn, Ferdinand repeated his ravages in the vega, and, +at the same time appearing before the disaffected city of Guadix with a +force large enough to awe it into submission, proposed an immediate +investigation of the conspiracy. He promised to inflict summary justice on +all who had been in any degree concerned in it; at the same time offering +permission to the inhabitants, in the abundance of his clemency, to depart +with all their personal effects wherever they would, provided they should +prefer this to a judicial investigation of their conduct. This politic +proffer had its effect. There were few, if any, of the citizens who had +not been either directly concerned in the conspiracy, or privy to it. With +one accord, therefore, they preferred exile to trusting to the tender +mercies of their judges. In this way, says the Curate of Los Palacios, by +the mystery of our Lord, was the ancient city of Guadix brought again +within the Christian fold; the mosques converted into Christian temples, +filled with the harmonies of Catholic worship, and the pleasant places, +which for nearly eight centuries had been trampled under the foot of the +infidel, were once more restored to the followers of the Cross. + +A similar policy produced similar results in the cities of Almeria and +Baza, whose inhabitants, evacuating their ancient homes, transported +themselves, with such personal effects as they could carry, to the city of +Granada, or the coast of Africa. The space thus opened by the fugitive +population was quickly filled by the rushing tide of Spaniards. [5] + +It is impossible at this day to contemplate these events with the +triumphant swell of exultation, with which they are recorded by +contemporary chroniclers. That the Moors were guilty (though not so +generally as pretended) of the alleged conspiracy, is not in itself +improbable, and is corroborated indeed by the Arabic statements. But the +punishment was altogether disproportionate to the offence. Justice might +surely have been satisfied by a selection of the authors and principal +agents of the meditated insurrection;--for no overt act appears to have +occurred. But avarice was too strong for justice; and this act, which is +in perfect conformity to the policy systematically pursued by the Spanish +crown for more than a century afterwards, may be considered as one of the +first links in the long chain of persecution, which terminated in the +expulsion of the Moriscoes. + +During the following year, 1491, a circumstance occurred illustrative of +the policy of the present government in reference to ecclesiastical +matters. The chancery of Valladolid having appealed to the pope in a case +coming within its own exclusive jurisdiction, the queen commanded Alonso +de Valdivieso, bishop of Leon, the president of the court, together with +all the auditors, to be removed from their respective offices, which she +delivered to a new board, having the bishop of Oviedo at its head. This is +one among many examples of the constancy with which Isabella, +notwithstanding her reverence for religion, and respect for its ministers, +refused to compromise the national independence by recognizing in any +degree the usurpations of Rome. From this dignified attitude, so often +abandoned by her successors, she never swerved for a moment during the +course of her long reign. [6] + +The winter of 1490 was busily occupied with preparations for the closing +campaign against Granada. Ferdinand took command of the army in the month +of April, 1491, with the purpose of sitting down before the Moorish +capital, not to rise until its final surrender. The troops, which mustered +in the Val de Velillos, are computed by most historians at fifty thousand +horse and foot, although Martyr, who served as a volunteer, swells the +number to eighty thousand. They were drawn from the different cities, +chiefly, as usual, from Andalusia, which had been stimulated to truly +gigantic efforts throughout this protracted war, [7] and from the nobility +of every quarter, many of whom, wearied out with the contest, contented +themselves with sending their quotas, while many others, as the marquises +of Cadiz, Villena, the counts of Tendilla, Cabra, Ureña, and Alonso de +Aguilar, appeared in person, eager, as they had borne the brunt of so many +hard campaigns, to share in the closing scene of triumph. + +On the 26th of the month, the army encamped near the fountain of Ojos de +Huescar, in the vega, about two leagues distant from Granada. Ferdinand's +first movement was to detach a considerable force, under the marquis of +Villena, which he subsequently supported in person with the remainder of +the army, for the purpose of scouring the fruitful regions of the +Alpuxarras, which served as the granary of the capital. This service was +performed with such unsparing rigor, that no less than twenty-four towns +and hamlets in the mountains were ransacked, and razed to the ground. +After this, Ferdinand returned loaded with spoil to his former position on +the banks of the Xenil, in full view of the Moorish metropolis, which +seemed to stand alone, like some sturdy oak, the last of the forest, +bidding defiance to the storm which had prostrated all its brethren. + +Notwithstanding the failure of all external resources, Granada was still +formidable from its local position and its defences. On the east it was +fenced in by a wild mountain barrier, the _Sierra Nevada_, whose snow-clad +summits diffused a grateful coolness over the city through the sultry +heats of summer. The side towards the vega, facing the Christian +encampment, was encircled by walls and towers of massive strength and +solidity. The population, swelled to two hundred thousand by the +immigration from the surrounding country, was likely, indeed, to be a +burden in a protracted siege; but among them were twenty thousand, the +flower of the Moslem chivalry, who had escaped the edge of the Christian +sword. In front of the city, for an extent of nearly ten leagues, lay +unrolled the magnificent vega, + + "Fresca y regalada vega, + Dulce recreacion de damas + Y de hombres gloria immensa," + +whose prolific beauties could scarcely be exaggerated in the most florid +strains of the Arabian minstrel, and which still bloomed luxuriant, +notwithstanding the repeated ravages of the preceding season. [8] + +The inhabitants of Granada were filled with indignation at the sight of +their enemy, thus encamped under the shadow, as it were, of their +battlements. They sallied forth in small bodies, or singly, challenging +the Spaniards to equal encounter. Numerous were the combats which took +place between the high-mettled cavaliers on both sides, who met on the +level arena, as on a tilting-ground, where they might display their +prowess in the presence of the assembled beauty and chivalry of their +respective nations; for the Spanish camp was graced, as usual, by the +presence of Queen Isabella and the infantas, with the courtly train of +ladies who had accompanied their royal mistress from Alcalá la Real. The +Spanish ballads glow with picturesque details of these knightly tourneys, +forming the most attractive portion of this romantic minstrelsy, which, +celebrating the prowess of Moslem, as well as Christian warriors, sheds a +dying glory round the last hours of Granada. [9] + +The festivity, which reigned throughout the camp on the arrival of +Isabella, did not divert her attention from the stern business of war. She +superintended the military preparations, and personally inspected every +part of the encampment. She appeared on the field superbly mounted, and +dressed in complete armor; and, as she visited the different quarters and +reviewed her troops, she administered words of commendation or sympathy, +suited to the condition of the soldier. [10] + +On one occasion, she expressed a desire to take a nearer survey of the +city. For this purpose, a house was selected, affording the best point of +view, in the little village of Zubia, at no great distance from Granada. +The king and queen stationed themselves before a window, which commanded +an unbroken prospect of the Alhambra, and the most beautiful quarter of +the town. In the mean while, a considerable force, under the marquis duke +of Cadiz, had been ordered, for the protection of the royal persons, to +take up a position between the village and the city of Granada, with +strict injunctions on no account to engage the enemy, as Isabella was +unwilling to stain the pleasures of the day with unnecessary effusion of +blood. + +The people of Granada, however, were too impatient long to endure the +presence, and, as they deemed it, the bravado of their enemy. They burst +forth from the gates of the capital, dragging along with them several +pieces of ordnance, and commenced a brisk assault on the Spanish lines. +The latter sustained the shock with firmness, till the marquis of Cadiz, +seeing them thrown into some disorder, found it necessary to assume the +offensive, and, mustering his followers around him, made one of those +desperate charges, which had so often broken the enemy. The Moorish +cavalry faltered; but might have disputed the ground, had it not been for +the infantry, which, composed of the rabble population of the city, was +easily thrown into confusion, and hurried the horse along with it. The +rout now became general. The Spanish cavaliers, whose blood was up, +pursued to the very gates of Granada, "and not a lance," says Bernaldez, +"that day, but was dyed in the blood of the infidel." Two thousand of the +enemy were slain and taken in the engagement, which lasted only a short +time; and the slaughter was stopped only by the escape of the fugitives +within the walls of the city. [11] + +About the middle of July, an accident occurred in the camp, which had like +to have been attended with fatal consequences. The queen was lodged in a +superb pavilion, belonging to the marquis of Cadiz, and always used by him +in the Moorish war. By the carelessness of one of her attendants, a lamp +was placed in such a situation, that, during the night, perhaps owing to a +gust of wind, it set fire to the drapery or loose hangings of the +pavilion, which was instantly in a blaze. The flame communicated with +fearful rapidity to the neighboring tents, made of light, combustible +materials, and the camp was menaced with general conflagration. This +occurred at the dead of night, when all but the sentinels were buried in +sleep. The queen and her children, whose apartments were near hers, were +in great peril, and escaped with difficulty, though fortunately without +injury. The alarm soon spread. The trumpets sounded to arms, for it was +supposed to be some night attack of the enemy. Ferdinand, snatching up his +arms hastily, put himself at the head of his troops; but, soon +ascertaining the nature of the disaster, contented himself with posting +the marquis of Cadiz, with a strong body of horse, over against the city, +in order to repel any sally from that quarter. None, however, was +attempted, and the fire was at length extinguished without personal +injury, though not without loss of much valuable property, in jewels, +plate, brocade, and other costly decorations of the tents of the nobility. +[12] + +In order to guard against a similar disaster, as well as to provide +comfortable winter quarters for the army, should the siege be so long +protracted as to require it, it was resolved to build a town of +substantial edifices on the place of the present encampment. The plan was +immediately put in execution. The work was distributed in due proportions +among the troops of the several cities and of the great nobility; the +soldier was on a sudden converted into an artisan, and, instead of war, +the camp echoed with the sounds of peaceful labor. + +In less than three months, this stupendous task was accomplished. The spot +so recently occupied by light, fluttering pavilions, was thickly covered +with solid structures of stone and mortar, comprehending, besides +dwelling-houses, stables for a thousand horses. The town was thrown into a +quadrangular form, traversed by two spacious avenues, intersecting each +other at right angles in the centre, in the form of a cross, with stately +portals at each of the four extremities. Inscriptions on blocks of marble +in the various quarters, recorded the respective shares of the several +cities in the execution of the work. When it was completed, the whole army +was desirous that the new city should bear the name of their illustrious +queen, but Isabella modestly declined this tribute, and bestowed on the +place the title of _Santa Fe_, in token of the unshaken trust, manifested +by her people throughout this war, in Divine Providence. With this name it +still stands as it was erected in 1491, a monument of the constancy and +enduring patience of the Spaniards, "the only city in Spain," in the words +of a Castilian writer, "that has never been contaminated by the Moslem +heresy." [13] + +The erection of Santa Fe by the Spaniards struck a greater damp into the +people of Granada, than the most successful military achievement could +have done. They beheld the enemy setting foot on their soil, with a +resolution never more to resign it. They already began to suffer from the +rigorous blockade, which effectually excluded supplies from their own +territories, while all communication with Africa was jealously +intercepted. Symptoms of insubordination had begun to show themselves +among the overgrown population of the city, as it felt more and more the +pressure of famine. In this crisis, the unfortunate Abdallah and his +principal counsellors became convinced, that the place could not be +maintained much longer; and at length, in the month of October, +propositions were made through the vizier Abul Cazim Abdelmalic, to open a +negotiation for the surrender of the place. The affair was to be conducted +with the utmost caution; since the people of Granada, notwithstanding +their precarious condition, and their disquietude, were buoyed up by +indefinite expectations of relief from Africa, or some other quarter. + +The Spanish sovereigns intrusted the negotiation to their secretary +Fernando de Zafra, and to Gonsalvo de Cordova, the latter of whom was +selected for this delicate business, from his uncommon address, and his +familiarity with the Moorish habits and language. Thus the capitulation of +Granada was referred to the man, who acquired in her long wars the +military science, which enabled him, at a later period, to foil the most +distinguished generals of Europe. + +The conferences were conducted by night with the utmost secrecy, sometimes +within the walls of Granada, and at others, in the little hamlet of +Churriana, about a league distant from it. At length, after large +discussion on both sides, the terms of capitulation were definitively +settled, and ratified by the respective monarchs on the 25th of November, +1491. [14] + +The conditions were of similar, though somewhat more liberal import, than +those granted to Baza. The inhabitants of Granada were to retain +possession of their mosques, with the free exercise of their religion, +with all its peculiar rites and ceremonies; they were to be judged by +their own laws, under their own cadis or magistrates, subject to the +general control of the Castilian governor; they were to be unmolested in +their ancient usages, manners, language, and dress; to be protected in the +full enjoyment of their property, with the right of disposing of it on +their own account, and of migrating when and where they would; and to be +furnished with vessels for the conveyance of such as chose within three +years to pass into Africa. No heavier taxes were to be imposed than those +customarily paid to their Arabian sovereigns, and none whatever before the +expiration of three years. King Abdallah was to reign over a specified +territory in the Alpuxarras, for which he was to do homage to the +Castilian crown. The artillery and the fortifications were to be delivered +into the hands of the Christians, and the city was to be surrendered in +sixty days from the date of the capitulation. Such were the principal +terms of the surrender of Granada, as authenticated by the most accredited +Castilian and Arabian authorities; which I have stated the more precisely, +as affording the best data for estimating the extent of Spanish perfidy in +later times. [15] + +The conferences could not be conducted so secretly, but that some report +of them got air among the populace of the city, who now regarded Abdallah +with an evil eye for his connection with the Christians. When the fact of +the capitulation became known, the agitation speedily mounted into an open +insurrection, which menaced the safety of the city, as well as of +Abdallah's person. In this alarming state of things, it was thought best +by that monarch's counsellors, to anticipate the appointed day of +surrender; and the 2d of January, 1492, was accordingly fixed on for that +purpose. + +Every preparation was made by the Spaniards for performing this last act +of the drama with suitable pomp and effect. The mourning which the court +had put on for the death of Prince Alonso of Portugal, occasioned by a +fall from his horse a few months after his marriage with the infanta +Isabella, was exchanged for gay and magnificent apparel. On the morning of +the 2d, the whole Christian camp exhibited a scene of the most animating +bustle. The grand cardinal Mendoza was sent forward at the head of a large +detachment, comprehending his household troops, and the veteran infantry +grown grey in the Moorish wars, to occupy the Alhambra preparatory to the +entrance of the sovereigns. [16] Ferdinand stationed himself at some +distance in the rear, near an Arabian mosque, since consecrated as the +hermitage of St. Sebastian. He was surrounded by his courtiers, with their +stately retinues, glittering in gorgeous panoply, and proudly displaying +the armorial bearings of their ancient houses. The queen halted still +farther in the rear, at the village of Armilla. [17] + +As the column under the grand cardinal advanced up the Hill of Martyrs, +over which a road had been constructed for the passage of the artillery, +he was met by the Moorish prince Abdallah, attended by fifty cavaliers, +who, descending the hill, rode up to the position occupied by Ferdinand on +the banks of the Xenil. As the Moor approached the Spanish king, he would +have thrown himself from his horse, and saluted his hand in token of +homage, but Ferdinand hastily prevented him, embracing him with every mark +of sympathy and regard. Abdallah then delivered up the keys of the +Alhambra to his conqueror, saying, "They are thine, O king, since Allah so +decrees it; use thy success with clemency and moderation." Ferdinand would +have uttered some words of consolation to the unfortunate prince, but he +moved forward with dejected air to the spot occupied by Isabella, and, +after similar acts of obeisance, passed on to join his family, who had +preceded him with his most valuable effects on the route to the +Alpuxarras. [18] + +The sovereigns during this time waited with impatience the signal of the +occupation of the city by the cardinal's troops, which, winding slowly +along the outer circuit of the walls, as previously arranged, in order to +spare the feelings of the citizens as far as possible, entered by what is +now called the gate of Los Molinos. In a short time, the large silver +cross, borne by Ferdinand throughout the crusade, was seen sparkling in +the sunbeams, while the standards of Castile and St. Jago waved +triumphantly from the red towers of the Alhambra. At this glorious +spectacle, the choir of the royal chapel broke forth into the solemn +anthem of the Te Deum, and the whole army, penetrated with deep emotion, +prostrated themselves on their knees in adoration of the Lord of hosts, +who had at length granted the consummation of their wishes, in this last +and glorious triumph of the Cross. [19] The grandees who surrounded +Ferdinand then advanced towards the queen, and kneeling down saluted her +hand in token of homage to her as sovereign of Granada. The procession +took up its march towards the city, "the king and queen moving in the +midst," says an historian, "emblazoned with royal magnificence; and, as +they were in the prime of life, and had now achieved the completion of +this glorious conquest, they seemed to represent even more than their +wonted majesty. Equal with each other, they were raised far above the rest +of the world. They appeared, indeed, more than mortal, and as if sent by +Heaven for the salvation of Spain." [20] + +In the mean while the Moorish king, traversing the route of the +Alpuxarras, reached a rocky eminence which commanded a last view of +Granada. He checked his horse, and, as his eye for the last time wandered +over the scenes of his departed greatness, his heart swelled, and he burst +into tears. "You do well," said his more masculine mother, "to weep like a +woman, for what you could not defend like a man!" "Alas!" exclaimed the +unhappy exile, "when were woes ever equal to mine!" The scene of this +event is still pointed out to the traveller by the people of the district; +and the rocky height, from which the Moorish chief took his sad farewell +of the princely abodes of his youth, is commemorated by the poetical title +of _El Ultimo Sospiro del Moro_, "The Last Sigh of the Moor." + +The sequel of Abdallah's history is soon told. Like his uncle, El Zagal, +he pined away in his barren domain of the Alpuxarras, under the shadow, as +it were, of his ancient palaces. In the following year, he passed over to +Fez with his family, having commuted his petty sovereignty for a +considerable sum of money paid him by Ferdinand and Isabella, and soon +after fell in battle in the service of an African prince, his kinsman. +"Wretched man," exclaims a caustic chronicler of his nation, "who could +lose his life in another's cause, though he did not dare to die in his +own. Such," continues the Arabian, with characteristic resignation, "was +the immutable decree of destiny. Blessed be Allah, who exalteth and +debaseth the kings of the earth, according to his divine will, in whose +fulfilment consists that eternal justice, which regulates all human +affairs." The portal, through which King Abdallah for the last time issued +from his capital, was at his request walled up, that none other might +again pass through it. In this condition it remains to this day, a +memorial of the sad destiny of the last of the kings of Granada. [21] + +The fall of Granada excited general sensation throughout Christendom, +where it was received as counterbalancing, in a manner, the loss of +Constantinople, nearly half a century before. At Rome, the event was +commemorated by a solemn procession of the pope and cardinals to St. +Peter's, where high mass was celebrated, and the public rejoicing +continued for several days. [22] The intelligence was welcomed with no +less satisfaction in England, where Henry the Seventh was seated on the +throne. The circumstances attending it, as related by Lord Bacon, will not +be devoid of interest for the reader. [23] + +Thus ended the war of Granada, which is often compared by the Castilian +chroniclers to that of Troy in its duration, and which certainly fully +equalled the latter in variety of picturesque and romantic incidents, and +in circumstances of poetical interest. With the surrender of its capital, +terminated the Arabian empire in the Peninsula, after an existence of +seven hundred and forty-one years from the date of the original conquest. +The consequences of this closing war were of the highest moment to Spain. +The most obvious, was the recovery of an extensive territory, hitherto +held by a people, whose difference of religion, language, and general +habits, made them not only incapable of assimilating with their Christian +neighbors, but almost their natural enemies; while their local position +was a matter of just concern, as interposed between the great divisions of +the Spanish monarchy, and opening an obvious avenue to invasion from +Africa. By the new conquest, moreover, the Spaniards gained a large extent +of country, possessing the highest capacities for production, in its +natural fruitfulness of soil, temperature of climate, and in the state of +cultivation to which it had been brought by its ancient occupants; while +its shores were lined with commodious havens, that afforded every facility +for commerce. The scattered fragments of the ancient Visigothic empire +were now again, with the exception of the little state of Navarre, +combined into one great monarchy, as originally destined by nature; and +Christian Spain gradually rose by means of her new acquisitions from a +subordinate situation, to the level of a first-rate European power. + +The moral influence of the Moorish war, its influence on the Spanish +character, was highly important. The inhabitants of the great divisions of +the country, as in most countries during the feudal ages, had been brought +too frequently into collision with each other to allow the existence of a +pervading national feeling. This was particularly the case in Spain, where +independent states insensibly grew out of the detached fragments of +territory recovered at different times from the Moorish monarchy. The war +of Granada subjected all the various sections of the country to one common +action, under the influence of common motives of the most exciting +interest; while it brought them in conflict with a race, the extreme +repugnance of whose institutions and character to their own, served +greatly to nourish the nationality of sentiment. In this way, the spark of +patriotism was kindled throughout the whole nation, and the most distant +provinces of the Peninsula were knit together by a bond of union, which +has remained indissoluble. + +The consequences of these wars in a military aspect are also worthy of +notice. Up to this period, war had been carried on by irregular levies, +extremely limited in numerical amount and in period of service; under +little subordination, except to their own immediate chiefs, and wholly +unprovided with the apparatus required for extended operations. The +Spaniards were even lower than most of the European nations in military +science, as is apparent from the infinite pains of Isabella to avail +herself of all foreign resources for their improvement. In the war of +Granada, masses of men were brought together, far greater than had +hitherto been known in modern warfare. They were kept in the field not +only through long campaigns, but far into the winter; a thing altogether +unprecedented. They were made to act in concert, and the numerous petty +chiefs brought in complete subjection to one common head, whose personal +character enforced the authority of station. Lastly, they were supplied +with all the requisite munitions, through the providence of Isabella, who +introduced into the service the most skilful engineers from other +countries, and kept in pay bodies of mercenaries, as the Swiss for +example, reputed the best disciplined troops of that day. In this +admirable school, the Spanish soldier was gradually trained to patient +endurance, fortitude, and thorough subordination; and those celebrated +captains were formed, with that invincible infantry, which in the +beginning of the sixteenth century spread the military fame of their +country over all Christendom. + +But, with all our sympathy for the conquerors, it is impossible, without a +deep feeling of regret, to contemplate the decay and final extinction of a +race, who had made such high advances in civilization as the Spanish +Arabs; to see them driven from the stately palaces reared by their own +hands, wandering as exiles over the lands, which still blossomed with the +fruits of their industry, and wasting away under persecution, until their +very name as a nation was blotted out from the map of history. [24] It +must be admitted, however, that they had long since reached their utmost +limit of advancement as a people. The light shed over their history shines +from distant ages; for, during the later period of their existence, they +appear to have reposed in a state of torpid, luxurious indulgence, which +would seem to argue, that, when causes of external excitement were +withdrawn, the inherent vices of their social institutions had +incapacitated them for the further production of excellence. In this +impotent condition, it was wisely ordered, that their territory should be +occupied by a people, whose religion and more liberal form of government, +however frequently misunderstood or perverted, qualified them for +advancing still higher the interests of humanity. + +It will not be amiss to terminate the narrative of the war of Granada with +some notice of the fate of Rodrigo Ponce de Leon, marquis duke of Cadiz; +for he may be regarded in a peculiar manner as the hero of it, having +struck the first stroke by the surprise of Alhama, and witnessed every +campaign till the surrender of Granada. A circumstantial account of his +last moments is afforded by the pen of his worthy countryman, the +Andalusian Curate of Los Palacios. The gallant marquis survived the close +of the war only a short time, terminating his days at his mansion in +Seville, on the 28th of August, 1492, with a disorder brought on by +fatigue and incessant exposure. He had reached the forty-ninth year of his +age, and, although twice married, left no legitimate issue. In his person, +he was of about the middle stature, of a compact, symmetrical frame, a +fair complexion, with light hair inclining to red. He was an excellent +horseman, and well skilled indeed in most of the exercises of chivalry. He +had the rare merit of combining sagacity with intrepidity in action. +Though somewhat impatient, and slow to forgive, he was frank and generous, +a warm friend, and a kind master to his vassals. [25] + +He was strict in his observance of the Catholic worship, punctilious in +keeping all the church festivals and in enforcing their observance +throughout his domains; and, in war, he was a most devout champion of the +Virgin. He was ambitious of acquisitions, but lavish of expenditure, +especially in the embellishment and fortification of his towns and +castles; spending on Alcalá de Guadaira, Xerez, and Alanis, the enormous +sum of seventeen million maravedies. To the ladies he was courteous, as +became a true knight. At his death, the king and queen with the whole +court went into mourning; "for he was a much-loved cavalier," says the +Curate, "and was esteemed, like the Cid, both by friend and foe; and no +Moor durst abide in that quarter of the field where his banner was +displayed." + +His body, after lying in state for several days in his palace at Seville, +with his trusty sword by his side, with which he had fought all his +battles, was borne in solemn procession by night through the streets of +the city, which was everywhere filled with the deepest lamentation; and +was finally deposited in the great chapel of the Augustine church, in the +tomb of his ancestors. Ten Moorish banners, which he had taken in battle +with the infidel, before the war of Granada, were borne along at his +funeral, "and still wave over his sepulchre," says Bernaldez, "keeping +alive the memory of his exploits, as undying as his soul." The banners +have long since mouldered into dust; the very tomb which contained his +ashes has been sacrilegiously demolished; but the fame of the hero will +survive as long as anything like respect for valor, courtesy, unblemished +honor, or any other attribute of chivalry, shall be found in Spain. [26] + + * * * * * + +One of the chief authorities on which the account of the Moorish war +rests, is Andres Bernaldez, Curate of Los Palacios. He was a native of +Fuente in Leon, and appears to have received his early education under the +care of his grandfather, a notary of that place, whose commendations of a +juvenile essay in historical writing led him later in life, according to +his own account, to record the events of his time in the extended and +regular form of a chronicle. After admission to orders, he was made +chaplain to Deza, archbishop of Seville, and curate of Los Palacios, an +Andalusian town not far from Seville, where he discharged his +ecclesiastical functions with credit, from 1488 to 1513, at which time, as +we find no later mention of him, he probably closed his life with his +labors. Bernaldez had ample opportunities for accurate information +relative to the Moorish war, since he lived, as it were, in the theatre of +action, and was personally intimate with the most considerable men of +Andalusia, especially the marquis of Cadiz, whom he has made the Achilles +of his epic, assigning him a much more important part in the principal +transactions, than is always warranted by other authorities. His Chronicle +is just such as might have been anticipated from a person of lively +imagination, and competent scholarship for the time, deeply dyed with the +bigotry and superstition of the Spanish clergy in that century. There is +no great discrimination apparent in the work of the worthy curate, who +dwells with goggle-eyed credulity on the most absurd marvels, and expends +more pages on an empty court show, than on the most important schemes of +policy. But if he is no philosopher, he has, perhaps for that very reason, +succeeded in making us completely master of the popular feelings and +prejudices of the time; while he gives a most vivid portraiture of the +principal scenes and actors in this stirring war, with all their +chivalrous exploit, and rich theatrical accompaniment. His credulity and +fanaticism, moreover, are well compensated by a simplicity and loyalty of +purpose, which secure much more credit to his narrative than attaches to +those of more ambitious writers, whose judgment is perpetually swayed by +personal or party interests. The chronicle descends as late as 1513, +although, as might be expected from the author's character, it is entitled +to much less confidence in the discussion of events which fell without the +scope of his personal observation. Notwithstanding its historical value is +fully recognized by the Castilian critics, it has never been admitted to +the press, but still remains ingulfed in the ocean of manuscripts, with +which the Spanish libraries are deluged. + +It is remarkable that the war of Granada, which is so admirably suited in +all its circumstances to poetical purposes, should not have been more +frequently commemorated by the epic muse. The only successful attempt in +this way, with which I am acquainted, is the "Conquisto di Granata," by +the Florentine Girolamo Gratiani, Modena, 1650. The author has taken the +license, independently of his machinery, of deviating very freely from the +historic track; among other things, introducing Columbus and the Great +Captain as principal actors in the drama, in which they played at most but +a very subordinate part. The poem, which swells into twenty-six cantos, is +in such repute with the Italian critics, that Quadrio does not hesitate to +rank it "among the best epical productions of the age." A translation of +this work has recently appeared at Nuremberg, from the pen of C. M. +Winterling, which is much commended by the German critics. + +Mr. Irving's late publication, the "Chronicle of the Conquest of Granada," +has superseded all further necessity for poetry, and, unfortunately for +me, for history. He has fully availed himself of all the picturesque and +animating movements of this romantic era; and the reader who will take the +trouble to compare his Chronicle with the present more prosaic and literal +narrative, will see how little he has been seduced from historic accuracy +by the poetical aspect of his subject. The fictitious and romantic dress +of his work has enabled him to make it the medium for reflecting more +vividly the floating opinions and chimerical fancies of the age, while he +has illuminated the picture with the dramatic brilliancy of coloring +denied to sober history. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1490.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., +cap. 95.--Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, pp. 404, 405.--Pulgar, Reyes +Católicos, part. 3, cap. 127.--La Clède, Hist. de Portugal, tom. iv. p. +19.--Faria y Sousa, Europa Portuguesa, tom. ii. p. 452. + +[2] Faria y Sousa, Europa Portuguesa, tom. ii. pp. 452-456.--Florez, +Reynas Cathólicas, p. 845.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 129.--Oviedo, +Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 2, dial. 3. + +[3] Conde, Domination de los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 41.--Bernaldez, Reyes +Católicos, MS., cap. 90. + +Neither the Arabic nor Castilian authorities impeach the justice of the +summons made by the Spanish sovereigns. I do not, however, find any other +foundation for the obligation imputed to Abdallah in them, than that +monarch's agreement during his captivity at Loja, in 1486, to surrender +his capital in exchange for Guadix, provided the latter should be +conquered within six months. Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, p. 275.--Garibay, +Compendio, tom. iv. p. 418. + +[4] L. Marineo, Cosas Memorables, fol. 176.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. +130.--Zurita, Anales, tom. iv. cap. 85.--Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique et +d'Espagne, tom. iii. p. 309. + +[5] Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 131, 132.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, +MS., cap. 97.--Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 41.--Peter +Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 3, epist. 84.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. iv. p. +424.--Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique et d'Espagne, tom. iii. pp. 309, 310. + +[6] Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1491. + +[7] According to Zuñiga, the quota furnished by Seville this season +amounted to 6000 foot and 500 horse, who were recruited by fresh +reinforcements no less than five times during the campaign. Annales de +Sevilla, p. 406.--See also Col. de Cédulas, tom. iii. no. 3. + +[8] Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 42.--Bernaldez, Reyes +Católicos, MS., cap. 100.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 3, epist. 89.-- +Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 18.--L. Marineo, Cosas +Memorables, fol. 177. + +Martyr remarks, that the Genoese merchants, "voyagers to every clime, +declare this to be the largest fortified city in the world." Casiri has +collected a body of interesting particulars respecting the wealth, +population, and social habits of Granada, from various Arabic authorities. +Bibliotheca Escurialensis, tom. ii. pp. 247-260. + +The French work of Laborde, Voyage Pittoresque, (Paris, 1807,) and the +English one of Murphy, Engravings of Arabian Antiquities of Spain, +(London, 1816,) do ample justice in their finished designs to the general +topography and architectural magnificence of Granada. + +[9] On one occasion, a Christian knight having discomfited with a handful +of men a much superior body of Moslem chivalry, King Abdallah testified +his admiration of his prowess by sending him on the following day a +magnificent present, together with his own sword superbly mounted. (Mem. +de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. p. 178.) The Moorish ballad beginning + + "Al Rey Chico de Granada" + +describes the panic occasioned in the city by the Christian encampment on +the Xenil. + + "For ese fresco Genil + un campo viene marchando, + todo de lucida gente, + las armas van relumbrando. + + "Las vanderas traen tendidas, + y un estandarte dorado; + el General de esta gente + es el invicto Fernando. + Y tambien viene la Reyna, + Muger del Hey don Fernando, + la qual tiene tanto esfuerzo + que anima a qualquier soldado." + +[10] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 101. + +[11] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 101.--Conde, Dominacion de los +Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 42.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 4, epist. 90. +--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, cap. 133.--Zurita, Anales, tom. iv. cap. 88. + +Isabella afterwards caused a Franciscan monastery to be built in +commemoration of this event at Zubia, where, according to Mr. Irving, the +house from which she witnessed the action is to be seen at the present +day. See Conquest of Granada, chap. 90, note. + +[12] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 4, epist. 91.--Bernaldez, Reyes +Católicos, MS., cap. 101.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. p. 673.--Bleda, +Corónica, p. 619.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 18. + +[13] Estrada, Poblacion de España, tom. ii. pp. 344, 348.--Peter Martyr, +Opus Epist., lib. 4, epist. 91.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, +cap. 18. + +Hyta, who embellishes his florid prose with occasional extracts from the +beautiful ballad poetry of Spain, gives one commemorating the erection of +Santa Fe. + + "Cercada esta Santa Fe + con mucho lienzo encerado + al rededor muchas tiendas + de seda, oro, y brocado. + + "Donde estan Duques, y Condes, + Señores de gran estado," etc. + +Guerras de Granada, p. 515. + +[14] Pedraza, Antiguedad de Granada, fol. 74.--Giovio, De Vita Gonsalvi, +apud Vitae Illust. Virorum, pp. 211, 212.--Salazar de Mendoza, Crón. del +Gran Cardenal, p. 236.--Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique et d'Espagne, tom. iii. +pp. 316, 317.--Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 42.--L. +Marineo, Cosas Memorables, fol. 178.--Marmol, however, assigns the date in +the text to a separate capitulation respecting Abdallah, dating that made +in behalf of the city three days later. (Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, +cap. 19.) This author has given the articles of the treaty with greater +fulness and precision than any other Spanish historian. + +[15] Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 19.--Conde, Dominacion de +los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 42.--Zurita, Anales, tom. ii. cap. 90.-- +Cardonne, Hist. d'Afrique et d'Espagne, tom. iii. pp. 317, 318.--Oviedo, +Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, dial. 28. Martyr adds, that the +principal Moorish nobility were to remove from the city. (Opus Epist., +lib. 4, epist. 92.) Pedraza, who has devoted a volume to the history of +Granada, does not seem to think the capitulations worth specifying. Most +of the modern Castilians pass very lightly over them. They furnish too +bitter a comment on the conduct of subsequent Spanish monarchs. Marmol and +the judicious Zurita agree in every substantial particular with Conde, and +this coincidence may be considered as establishing the actual terms of the +treaty. + +[16] Oviedo, whose narrative exhibits many discrepancies with those of +other contemporaries, assigns this part to the count of Tendilla, the +first captain-general of Granada. Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, +dial. 28. But, as this writer, though an eye-witness, was but thirteen or +fourteen years of age at the time of the capture, and wrote some sixty +years later from his early recollections, his authority cannot be +considered of equal weight with that of persons who, like Martyr, +described events as they were passing before them. + +[17] Pedraza, Antiguedad de Granada, fol. 75.--Salazar de Mendoza, Crón. +del Gran Cardenal, p. 238.--Zurita, Anales, tom. iv. cap. 90.--Peter +Martyr, Opus Epist., lib. 4, epist. 92.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, tom. ii. +fol. 309.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 20. + +[18] Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, ubi supra.--Conde, Dominacion de los +Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 43.--Pedraza, Antiguedad de Granada, fol. 76.-- +Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 102.--Zurita, Anales, tom. iv. cap. +90.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, dial. 28. + +[19] Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., ubi supra.--One is reminded of Tasso's +description of the somewhat similar feelings exhibited by the crusaders on +their entrance into Jerusalem. + + "Ecco apparir Gerusalem si vede, + Ecco additar Gerusalem si scorge; + Ecco da mille voci unitamente + Gerusalemme salutar si sente. + + * * * * * + + "Al gran placer che quella prima vista + Dolcemente spirò nell' altruì petto, + Alta contrizion successe, mista + Di timoroso e riverente affetto, + Osano appena d'innalzar la vista + Ver la città." + +Gerusalemme Liberata,--Cant. iii. st. 3, 5. + +[20] Mariana, Hist. de España tom. ii. p. 597.--Pedraza, Antiguedad de +Granada, fol. 76.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1492.--Conde, Dominacion de +los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 43.--Bleda, Corónica, pp. 621, 622.--Zurita, +Anales, tom. iv. cap. 90.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. i. cap. 20. +--L. Marineo, and indeed most of the Spanish authorities, represent the +sovereigns as having postponed their entrance into the city until the 5th +or 6th of January. A letter transcribed by Pedraza, addressed by the queen +to the prior of Guadalupe, one of her council, dated from the city of +Granada on the 2d of January, 1492, shows the inaccuracy of this +statement. See folio 76. + +In Mr. Lockhart's picturesque version of the Moorish ballads, the reader +may find an animated description of the triumphant entry of the Christian +army into Granada. + + "There was crying in Granada when the sun was going down, + Some calling on the Trinity, some calling on Mahoun; + Here passed away the Koran, there in the cross was borne, + And here was heard the Christian bell, and there the Moorish horn; + _Te Deum laudamus_ was up the Alcala sung, + Down from the Alhambra's minarets were all the crescents flung; + The arms thereon of Aragon and Castile they display; + One king comes in in triumph, one weeping goes away." + +[21] Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. 90.--Cardonne, Hist. +d'Afrique et d'Espagne, tom. ii. pp. 319, 320.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. +iv. lib. 40, cap. 42.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 20. + +Mr. Irving, in his beautiful Spanish Sketch-book, "The Alhambra," devotes +a chapter to mementos of Boabdil, in which he traces minutely the route of +the deposed monarch after quitting the gates of his capital. The same +author, in the Appendix to his Chronicle of Granada, concludes a notice of +Abdallah's fate with the following description of his person. "A portrait +of Boabdil el Chico is to be seen in the picture gallery of the +Generalife. He is represented with a mild, handsome face, a fair +complexion, and yellow hair. His dress is of yellow brocade, relieved with +black velvet; and he has a black velvet cap, surmounted with a crown. In +the armory of Madrid are two suits of armor said to have belonged to him, +one of solid steel, with very little ornament; the morion closed. From the +proportions of these suits of armor, he must have been of full stature and +vigorous form." Note, p. 398. + +[22] Senarega, Commentarii de Rebus Genuensibus, apud Muratori, Rerum +Italicarum Scriptores, (Mediolani, 1723-51,) tom. xxiv. p. 531.--It formed +the subject of a theatrical representation before the court at Naples, in +the same year. This drama, or _Farsa_, as it is called by its +distinguished author, Sannazaro, is an allegorical medley, in which Faith, +Joy, and the false prophet Mahomet play the principal parts. The +difficulty of a precise classification of this piece, has given rise to +warmer discussion among Italian critics, than the subject may be thought +to warrant. See Signorelli, Vicende della Coltura nelle due Sicilie, +(Napoli, 1810,) tom. iii. pp. 543 et seq. + +[23] "Somewhat about this time, came letters from Ferdinando and Isabella, +king and queen of Spain; signifying the final conquest of Granada from the +Moors; which action, in itself so worthy, King Ferdinando, whose manner +was, never to lose any virtue for the showing, had expressed and displayed +in his letters, at large, with all the particularities and religious +punctos and ceremonies, that were observed in the reception of that city +and kingdom; showing amongst other things, that the king would not by any +means in person enter the city until he had first aloof seen the Cross set +up upon the greater tower of Granada, whereby it became Christian ground. +That likewise, before he would enter, he did homage to God above, +pronouncing by an herald from the height of that tower, that he did +acknowledge to have recovered that kingdom by the help of God Almighty, +and the glorious Virgin, and the virtuous apostle St. James, and the holy +father Innocent VIII., together with the aids and services of his +prelates, nobles, and commons. That yet he stirred not from his camp, till +he had seen a little army of martyrs, to the number of seven hundred and +more Christians, that had lived in bonds and servitude, as slaves to the +Moors, pass before his eyes, singing a psalm for their redemption; and +that he had given tribute unto God, by alms and relief extended to them +all, for his admission into the city. These things were in the letters, +with many more ceremonies of a kind of holy ostentation. + +"The king, ever willing to put himself into the consort or quire of all +religious actions, and naturally affecting much the king of Spain, as far +as one king can affect another, partly for his virtues, and partly for a +counterpoise to France; upon the receipt of these letters, sent all his +nobles and prelates that were about the court, together with the mayor and +aldermen of London, in great solemnity to the church of Paul; there to +hear a declaration from the lord chancellor, now cardinal. When they were +assembled, the cardinal, standing upon the uppermost step, or halfpace, +before the quire, and all the nobles, prelates, and governors of the city +at the foot of the stairs, made a speech to them; letting them know that +they were assembled in that consecrated place to sing unto God a new song. +For that, said he, these many years the Christians have not gained new +ground or territory upon the infidels, nor enlarged and set farther the +bounds of the Christian world. But this is now done by the prowess and +devotion of Ferdinando and Isabella, kings of Spain; who have, to their +immortal honor, recovered the great and rich kingdom of Granada, and the +populous and mighty city of the same name from the Moors, having been in +possession thereof by the space of seven hundred years, and more; for +which this assembly and all Christians are to render laud and thanks to +God, and to celebrate this noble act of the king of Spain; who in this is +not only victorious but apostolical, in the gaining of new provinces to +the Christian faith. And the rather for that this victory and conquest is +obtained without much effusion of blood. Whereby it is to be hoped, that +there shall be gained not only new territory, but infinite souls to the +Church of Christ, whom the Almighty, as it seems, would have live to be +converted. Herewithal he did relate some of the most memorable particulars +of the war and victory. And, after his speech ended, the whole assembly +went solemnly in procession, and Te Deum was sung." Lord Bacon, History of +the Reign of King Henry VII., in his Works, (ed. London, 1819,) vol. v. +pp. 85, 86.--See also Hall, Chronicle, p. 453. + +[24] The African descendants of the Spanish Moors, unable wholly to +relinquish the hope of restoration to the delicious abodes of their +ancestors, continued for many generations, and perhaps still continue, to +put up a petition to that effect in their mosques every Friday. Pedraza, +Antiguedad de Granada, fol. 7. + +[25] Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1492. + +Don Henrique de Guzman, duke of Medina Sidonia, the ancient enemy, and, +since the commencement of the Moorish war, the firm friend of the marquis +of Cadiz, died the 28th of August, on the same day with the latter. + +[26] Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, p. 411.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., +cap. 104. + +The marquis left three illegitimate daughters by a noble Spanish lady, who +all formed high connections. He was succeeded in his titles and estates, +by the permission of Ferdinand and Isabella, by Don Rodrigo Ponce de Leon, +the son of his eldest daughter, who had married with one of her kinsmen. +Cadiz was subsequently annexed by the Spanish sovereigns to the crown, +from which it had been detached in Henry IV.'s time, and considerable +estates were given as an equivalent, together with the title of Duke of +Arcos, to the family of Ponce de Leon. + + + + +CHAPTER XVI. + +APPLICATION OF CHRISTOPHER COLUMBUS AT THE SPANISH COURT. + +1492. + +Early Discoveries of the Portuguese.--Of the Spaniards.--Columbus.--His +Application at the Castilian Court.--Rejected.--Negotiations Resumed.-- +Favorable Disposition of the Queen.--Arrangement with Columbus.--He Sails +on his First Voyage.--Indifference to the Enterprise.--Acknowledgments due +to Isabella. + + +While Ferdinand and Isabella were at Santa Fe, the capitulation was +signed, that opened the way to an extent of empire, compared with which +their recent conquests, and indeed all their present dominions, were +insignificant. The extraordinary intellectual activity of the Europeans in +the fifteenth century, after the torpor of ages, carried them forward to +high advancement in almost every department of science, but especially +nautical, whose surprising results have acquired for the age, the glory of +being designated as peculiarly that of maritime discovery. This was +eminently favored by the political condition of modern Europe. Under the +Roman empire, the traffic with the east naturally centred in Rome, the +commercial capital of the west. After the dismemberment of the empire, it +continued to be conducted principally through the channel of the Italian +ports, whence it was diffused over the remoter regions of Christendom. But +these countries, which had now risen from the rank of subordinate +provinces to that of separate independent states, viewed with jealousy +this monopoly of the Italian cities, by means of which these latter were +rapidly advancing beyond them in power and opulence. This was especially +the case with Portugal and Castile, [1] which, placed on the remote +frontiers of the European continent, were far removed from the great +routes of Asiatic intercourse; while this disadvantage was not compensated +by such an extent of territory, as secured consideration to some other of +the European states, equally unfavorably situated for commercial purposes +with themselves. Thus circumstanced, the two nations of Castile and +Portugal were naturally led to turn their eyes on the great ocean which +washed their western borders, and to seek in its hitherto unexplored +recesses for new domains, and if possible strike out some undiscovered +track towards the opulent regions of the east. + +The spirit of maritime enterprise was fomented, and greatly facilitated in +its operation, by the invention of the astrolabe, and the important +discovery of the polarity of the magnet, whose first application to the +purposes of navigation on an extended scale may be referred to the +fifteenth century. [2] The Portuguese were the first to enter on the +brilliant path of nautical discovery, which they pursued under the infant +Don Henry with such activity, that, before the middle of the fifteenth +century, they had penetrated as far as Cape de Verd, doubling many a +fearful headland, which had shut in the timid navigator of former days; +until at length, in 1486, they descried the lofty promontory which +terminates Africa on the south, and which, hailed by King John the Second, +under whom it was discovered, as the harbinger of the long-sought passage +to the east, received the cheering appellation of the Cape of Good Hope. + +The Spaniards, in the mean while, did not languish in the career of +maritime enterprise. Certain adventurers from the northern provinces of +Biscay and Guipuscoa, in 1393, had made themselves masters of one of the +smallest of the group of islands, supposed to be the Fortunate Isles of +the ancients, since known as the Canaries. Other private adventurers from +Seville extended their conquests over these islands in the beginning of +the following century. These were completed in behalf of the crown under +Ferdinand and Isabella, who equipped several fleets for their reduction, +which at length terminated in 1495 with that of Teneriffe. [3] From the +commencement of their reign, Ferdinand and Isabella had shown an earnest +solicitude for the encouragement of commerce and nautical science, as is +evinced by a variety of regulations which, however imperfect, from the +misconception of the true principles of trade in that day, are +sufficiently indicative of the dispositions of the government. [4] Under +them, and indeed under their predecessors as far back as Henry the Third, +a considerable traffic had been carried on with the western coast of +Africa, from which gold dust and slaves were imported into the city of +Seville. The annalist of that city notices the repeated interference of +Isabella in behalf of these unfortunate beings, by ordinances tending to +secure them a more equal protection of the laws, or opening such social +indulgences as might mitigate the hardships of their condition. A +misunderstanding gradually arose between the subjects of Castile and +Portugal, in relation to their respective rights of discovery and commerce +on the African coast, which promised a fruitful source of collision +between the two crowns; but which was happily adjusted by an article in +the treaty of 1479, that terminated the war of the succession. By this it +was settled, that the right of traffic and of discovery on the western +coast of Africa should be exclusively reserved to the Portuguese, who in +their turn should resign all claims on the Canaries to the crown of +Castile. The Spaniards, thus excluded from further progress to the south, +seemed to have no other opening left for naval adventure than the hitherto +untravelled regions of the great western ocean. Fortunately, at this +juncture, an individual appeared among them, in the person of Christopher +Columbus, endowed with capacity for stimulating them to this heroic +enterprise, and conducting it to a glorious issue. [5] + +This extraordinary man was a native of Genoa, of humble parentage, though +perhaps honorable descent. [6] He was instructed in his early youth at +Pavia, where he acquired a strong relish for the mathematical sciences, in +which he subsequently excelled. At the age of fourteen, he engaged in a +seafaring life, which he followed with little intermission till 1470; +when, probably little more than thirty years of age, [7] he landed in +Portugal, the country to which adventurous spirits from all parts of the +world then resorted, as the great theatre of maritime enterprise. After +his arrival, he continued to make voyages to the then known parts of the +world, and, when on shore, occupied himself with the construction and sale +of charts and maps; while his geographical researches were considerably +aided by the possession of papers belonging to an eminent Portuguese +navigator, a deceased relative of his wife. Thus stored with all that +nautical science in that day could supply, and fortified by large +practical experience, the reflecting mind of Columbus was naturally led to +speculate on the existence of some other land beyond the western waters; +and he conceived the possibility of reaching the eastern shores of Asia, +whose provinces of Zipango and Cathay were emblazoned in such gorgeous +colors in the narratives of Mandeville and the Poli, by a more direct and +commodious route than that which traversed the eastern continent. [8] + +The existence of land beyond the Atlantic, which was not discredited by +some of the most enlightened ancients, [9] had become matter of common +speculation at the close of the fifteenth century; when maritime adventure +was daily disclosing the mysteries of the deep, and bringing to light new +regions, that had hitherto existed only in fancy. A proof of this popular +belief occurs in a curious passage of the "Morgante Maggiore" of the +Florentine poet Palci, a man of letters, but not distinguished for +scientific attainments beyond his day. [10] The passage is remarkable, +independently of the cosmographical knowledge it implies, for its allusion +to phenomena in physical science, not established till more than a century +later. The Devil, alluding to the vulgar superstition respecting the +pillars of Hercules, thus addresses his companion Rinaldo: + + "Know that this theory is false; his bark + The daring mariner shall urge far o'er + The western wave, a smooth and level plain, + Albeit the earth is fashioned like a wheel. + Man was in ancient days of grosser mould, + And Hercules might blush to learn how far + Beyond the limits he had vainly set, + The dullest sea-boat soon shall wing her way. + Men shall descry another hemisphere, + Since to one common centre all things tend; + So earth, by curious mystery divine + Well balanced, hangs amid the starry spheres. + At our antipodes are cities, states, + And thronged empires, ne'er divined of yore. + But see, the Sun speeds on his western path + To glad the nations with expected light." [11] + +Columbus's hypothesis rested on much higher ground than mere popular +belief. What indeed was credulity with the vulgar, and speculation with +the learned, amounted in his mind to a settled practical conviction, that +made him ready to peril life and fortune on the result of the experiment. +He was fortified still further in his conclusions by a correspondence with +the learned Italian Toscanelli, who furnished him with a map of his own +projection, in which the eastern coast of Asia was delineated opposite to +the western frontier of Europe. [12] + +Filled with lofty anticipations of achieving a discovery, which would +settle a question of such moment, so long involved in obscurity, Columbus +submitted the theory on which he had founded his belief in the existence +of a western route to King John the Second, of Portugal. Here he was +doomed to encounter for the first time the embarrassments and +mortifications, which so often obstruct the conceptions of genius, too +sublime for the age in which they are formed. After a long and fruitless +negotiation, and a dishonorable attempt on the part of the Portuguese to +avail themselves clandestinely of his information, he quitted Lisbon in +disgust, determined to submit his proposals to the Spanish sovereigns, +relying on their reputed character for wisdom and enterprise. [13] + +The period of his arrival in Spain, being the latter part of 1484, would +seem to have been the most unpropitious possible to his design. The nation +was then in the heat of the Moorish war, and the sovereigns were +unintermittingly engaged, as we have seen, in prosecuting their campaigns, +or in active preparation for them. The large expenditure, incident to +this, exhausted all their resources; and indeed the engrossing character +of this domestic conquest left them little leisure for indulging in dreams +of distant and doubtful discovery. Columbus, moreover, was unfortunate in +his first channel of communication with the court. He was furnished by +Fray Juan Perez de Marchena, guardian of the convent of La Rabida in +Andalusia, who had early taken a deep interest in his plans, with an +introduction to Fernando de Talavera, prior of Prado, and confessor of the +queen, a person high in the royal confidence, and gradually raised through +a succession of ecclesiastical dignities to the archiepiscopal see of +Granada. He was a man of irreproachable morals, and of comprehensive +benevolence for that day, as is shown in his subsequent treatment of the +unfortunate Moriscoes. [14] He was also learned; although his learning was +that of the cloister, deeply tinctured with pedantry and superstition, and +debased by such servile deference even to the errors of antiquity, as at +once led him to discountenance everything like innovation or enterprise. +[15] + +With these timid and exclusive views, Talavera was so far from +comprehending the vast conceptions of Columbus, that he seems to have +regarded him as a mere visionary, and his hypothesis as involving +principles not altogether orthodox. Ferdinand and Isabella, desirous of +obtaining the opinion of the most competent judges on the merits of +Columbus's theory, referred him to a council selected by Talavera from the +most eminent scholars of the kingdom, chiefly ecclesiastics, whose +profession embodied most of the science of that day. Such was the apathy +exhibited by this learned conclave, and so numerous the impediments +suggested by dulness, prejudice, or skepticism, that years glided away +before it came to a decision. During this time, Columbus appears to have +remained in attendance on the court, bearing arms occasionally in the +campaigns, and experiencing from the sovereigns an unusual degree of +deference and personal attention; an evidence of which is afforded in the +disbursements repeatedly made by the royal order for his private expenses, +and in the instructions, issued to the municipalities of the different +towns in Andalusia, to supply him gratuitously with lodging and other +personal accommodations. [16] + +At length, however, Columbus, wearied out by this painful procrastination, +pressed the court for a definite answer to his propositions; when he was +informed, that the council of Salamanca pronounced his scheme to be "vain, +impracticable, and resting on grounds too weak to merit the support of the +government." Many in the council, however, were too enlightened to +acquiesce in this sentence of the majority. Some of the most considerable +persons of the court, indeed, moved by the cogency of Columbus's +arguments, and affected by the elevation and grandeur of his views, not +only cordially embraced his scheme, but extended their personal intimacy +and friendship to him. Such, among others, were the grand cardinal +Mendoza, a man whose enlarged capacity and acquaintance with affairs +raised him above many of the narrow prejudices of his order, and Deza, +archbishop of Seville, a Dominican friar, whose commanding talents were +afterwards unhappily perverted in the service of the Holy Office, over +which he presided as successor to Torquemada. [17] The authority of these +individuals had undoubtedly great weight with the sovereigns, who softened +the verdict of the junto, by an assurance to Columbus, that, "although +they were too much occupied at present to embark in his undertaking, yet, +at the conclusion of the war, they should find both time and inclination +to treat with him." Such was the ineffectual result of Columbus's long and +painful solicitation; and, far from receiving the qualified assurance of +the sovereigns in mitigation of their refusal, he seems to have considered +it as peremptory and final. In great dejection of mind, therefore, but +without further delay, he quitted the court, and bent his way to the +south, with the apparently almost desperate intent of seeking out some +other patron to his undertaking. [18] + +Columbus had already visited his native city of Genoa, for the purpose of +interesting it in his scheme of discovery; but the attempt proved +unsuccessful. He now made application, it would seem, to the dukes of +Medina Sidonia and Medina Celi, successively, from the latter of whom he +experienced much kindness and hospitality; but neither of these nobles, +whose large estates lying along the sea-shore had often invited them to +maritime adventure, was disposed to assume one which seemed too hazardous +for the resources of the crown. Without wasting time in further +solicitation, Columbus prepared with a heavy heart to bid adieu to Spain, +and carry his proposals to the king of France, from whom he had received a +letter of encouragement while detained in Andalusia. [19] + +His progress, however, was arrested at the convent of La Rabida, which he +visited previous to his departure, by his friend the guardian, who +prevailed on him to postpone his journey till another effort had been made +to move the Spanish court in his favor. For this purpose the worthy +ecclesiastic undertook an expedition in person to the newly erected city +of Santa Fe, where the sovereigns lay encamped before Granada. Juan Perez +had formerly been confessor of Isabella, and was held in great +consideration by her for his excellent qualities. On arriving at the camp, +he was readily admitted to an audience, when he pressed the suit of +Columbus with all the earnestness and reasoning of which he was capable. +The friar's eloquence was supported by that of several eminent persons, +whom Columbus during his long residence in the country had interested in +his project, and who viewed with sincere regret the prospect of its +abandonment. Among these individuals are particularly mentioned Alonso de +Quintanilla, comptroller general of Castile, Louis de St. Angel, a fiscal +officer of the crown of Aragon, and the marchioness of Moya, the personal +friend of Isabella, all of whom exercised considerable influence over her +counsels. Their representations, combined with the opportune season of the +application, occurring at the moment when the approaching termination of +the Moorish war allowed room for interest in other objects, wrought so +favorable a change in the dispositions of the sovereigns, that they +consented to resume the negotiation with Columbus. An invitation was +accordingly sent to him to repair to Santa Fe, and a considerable sum +provided for his suitable equipment, and his expenses on the road. [20] + +Columbus, who lost no time in availing himself of this welcome +intelligence, arrived at the camp in season to witness the surrender of +Granada, when every heart, swelling with exultation at the triumphant +termination of the war, was naturally disposed to enter with greater +confidence on a new career of adventure. At his interview with the king +and queen, he once more exhibited the arguments on which his hypothesis +was founded. He then endeavored to stimulate the cupidity of his audience, +by picturing the realms of Mangi and Cathay, which he confidently expected +to reach by this western route, in all the barbaric splendors which had +been shed over them by the lively fancy of Marco Polo and other travellers +of the Middle Ages; and he concluded with appealing to a higher principle, +by holding out the prospect of extending the empire of the Cross over +nations of benighted heathen, while he proposed to devote the profits of +his enterprise to the recovery of the Holy Sepulchre. This last +ebullition, which might well have passed for fanaticism in a later day, +and given a visionary tinge to his whole project, was not quite so +preposterous in an age, in which the spirit of the crusades might be said +still to linger, and the romance of religion had not yet been dispelled by +sober reason. The more temperate suggestion of the diffusion of the gospel +was well suited to affect Isabella, in whose heart the principle of +devotion was deeply seated, and who, in all her undertakings, seems to +have been far less sensible to the vulgar impulses of avarice or ambition, +than to any argument connected, however remotely, with the interests of +religion. [21] + +Amidst all these propitious demonstrations towards Columbus, an obstacle +unexpectedly arose in the nature of his demands, which stipulated for +himself and heirs the title and authority of Admiral and Viceroy over all +lands discovered by him, with one-tenth of the profits. This was deemed +wholly inadmissible. Ferdinand, who had looked with cold distrust on the +expedition from the first, was supported by the remonstrances of Talavera, +the new archbishop of Granada; who declared, that "such demands savored of +the highest degree of arrogance, and would be unbecoming in their +Highnesses to grant to a needy foreign adventurer." Columbus, however, +steadily resisted every attempt to induce him to modify his propositions. +On this ground, the conferences were abruptly broken off, and he once more +turned his back upon the Spanish court, resolved rather to forego his +splendid anticipations of discovery, at the very moment when the career so +long sought was thrown open to him, than surrender one of the honorable +distinctions due to his services. This last act is perhaps the most +remarkable exhibition in his whole life, of that proud, unyielding spirit, +which sustained him through so many years of trial, and enabled him at +length to achieve his great enterprise, in the face of every obstacle +which man and nature had opposed to it. [22] + +The misunderstanding was not suffered to be of long duration. Columbus's +friends, and especially Louis de St. Angel, remonstrated with the queen on +these proceedings in the most earnest manner. He frankly told her, that +Columbus's demands, if high, were at least contingent on success, when +they would be well deserved; that, if he failed, he required nothing. He +expatiated on his qualifications for the undertaking, so signal as to +insure in all probability the patronage of some other monarch, who would +reap the fruits of his discoveries; and he ventured to remind the queen, +that her present policy was not in accordance with the magnanimous spirit, +which had hitherto made her the ready patron of great and heroic +enterprise. Far from being displeased, Isabella was moved by his honest +eloquence. She contemplated the proposals of Columbus in their true light; +and, refusing to hearken any longer to the suggestions of cold and timid +counsellors, she gave way to the natural impulses of her own noble and +generous heart; "I will assume the undertaking," said she, "for my own +crown of Castile, and am ready to pawn my jewels to defray the expenses of +it, if the funds in the treasury shall be found inadequate." The treasury +had been reduced to the lowest ebb by the late war, but the receiver, St. +Angel, advanced the sums required, from the Aragonese revenues deposited +in his hands. Aragon however was not considered as adventuring in the +expedition, the charges and emoluments of which were reserved exclusively +for Castile. [23] + +Columbus, who was overtaken by the royal messenger at a few leagues' +distance only from Granada, experienced the most courteous reception on +his return to Santa Fe, where a definitive arrangement was concluded with +the Spanish sovereigns, April 17th, 1492. By the terms of the +capitulation, Ferdinand and Isabella, as lords of the ocean-seas, +constituted Christopher Columbus their admiral, viceroy, and governor- +general of all such islands and continents as he should discover in the +western ocean, with the privilege of nominating three candidates, for the +selection of one by the crown, for the government of each of these +territories. He was to be vested with exclusive right of jurisdiction over +all commercial transactions within his admiralty. He was to be entitled to +one-tenth of all the products and profits within the limits of his +discoveries, and an additional eighth, provided he should contribute one- +eighth part of the expense. By a subsequent ordinance, the official +dignities above enumerated were settled on him and his heirs for ever, +with the privilege of prefixing the title of Don to their names, which had +not then degenerated into an appellation of mere courtesy. [24] + +No sooner were the arrangements completed, than Isabella prepared with her +characteristic promptness to forward the expedition by the most efficient +measures. Orders were sent to Seville and the other ports of Andalusia, to +furnish stores and other articles requisite for the voyage, free of duty, +and at as low rates as possible. The fleet, consisting of three vessels, +was to sail from the little port of Palos in Andalusia, which had been +condemned for some delinquency to maintain two caravels for a twelvemonth +for the public service. The third vessel was furnished by the admiral, +aided, as it would seem, in defraying the charges, by his friend the +guardian of La Rabida, and the Pinzons, a family in Palos long +distinguished for its enterprise among the mariners of that active +community. With their assistance, Columbus was enabled to surmount the +disinclination, and indeed open opposition, manifested by the Andalusian +mariners to his perilous voyage; so that in less than three months his +little squadron was equipped for sea. A sufficient evidence of the extreme +unpopularity of the expedition is afforded by a royal ordinance of the +30th of April, promising protection to all persons, who should embark in +it, from criminal prosecution of whatever kind, until two months after +their return. The armament consisted of two caravels, or light vessels +without decks, and a third of larger burden. The total number of persons +who embarked amounted to one hundred and twenty; and the whole charges of +the crown for the expedition did not exceed seventeen thousand florins, +The fleet was instructed to keep clear of the African coast, and other +maritime possessions of Portugal. At length, all things being in +readiness, Columbus and his whole crew partook of the sacrament, and +confessed themselves, after the devout manner of the ancient Spanish +voyagers, when engaged in any important enterprise; and on the morning of +the 3d of August, 1492, the intrepid navigator, bidding adieu to the Old +World, launched forth on that unfathomed waste of waters where no sail had +been ever spread before. [25] + +It is impossible to peruse the story of Columbus without assigning to him +almost exclusively the glory of his great discovery; for, from the first +moment of its conception to that of its final execution, he was +encountered by every species of mortification and embarrassment, with +scarcely a heart to cheer, or a hand to help him. [26] Those more +enlightened persons whom, during his long residence in Spain, he succeeded +in interesting in his expedition, looked to it probably as the means of +solving a dubious problem, with the same sort of vague and skeptical +curiosity as to its successful result, with which we contemplate, in our +day, an attempt to arrive at the Northwest passage. How feeble was the +interest excited, even among those who from their science and situation +would seem to have their attention most naturally drawn towards it, may be +inferred from the infrequency of allusion to it in the correspondence and +other writings of that time, previous to the actual discovery. Peter +Martyr, one of the most accomplished scholars of the period, whose +residence at the Castilian court must have fully instructed him in the +designs of Columbus, and whose inquisitive mind led him subsequently to +take the deepest interest in the results of his discoveries, does not, so +far as I am aware, allude to him in any part of his voluminous +correspondence with the learned men of his time, previous to the first +expedition. The common people regarded, not merely with apathy, but with +terror, the prospect of a voyage, that was to take the mariner from the +safe and pleasant seas which he was accustomed to navigate, and send him +roving on the boundless wilderness of waters, which tradition and +superstitious fancy had peopled with innumerable forms of horror. + +It is true that Columbus experienced a most honorable reception at the +Castilian court; such as naturally flowed from the benevolent spirit of +Isabella, and her just appreciation of his pure and elevated character. +But the queen was too little of a proficient in science to be able to +estimate the merits of his hypothesis; and, as many of those, on whose +judgment she leaned, deemed it chimerical, it is probable that she never +entertained a deep conviction of its truth; at least not enough to warrant +the liberal expenditure, which she never refused to schemes of real +importance. This is certainly inferred by the paltry amount actually +expended on the armament, far inferior to that appropriated to the +equipment of two several fleets in the course of the late war for a +foreign expedition, as well as to that, with which in the ensuing year she +followed up Columbus's discoveries. + +But while, on a review of the circumstances, we are led more and more to +admire the constancy and unconquerable spirit, which carried Columbus +victorious through all the difficulties of his undertaking, we must +remember, in justice to Isabella, that, although tardily, she did in fact +furnish the resources essential to its execution; that she undertook the +enterprise when it had been explicitly declined by other powers, and when +probably none other of that age would have been found to countenance it; +and that, after once plighting her faith to Columbus, she became his +steady friend, shielding him against the calumnies of his enemies, +reposing in him the most generous confidence, and serving him in the most +acceptable manner, by supplying ample resources for the prosecution of his +glorious discoveries. [27] + + * * * * * + +It is now more than thirty years since the Spanish government intrusted +Don Martin Fernandez de Navarrete, one of the most eminent scholars of the +country, with the care of exploring the public archives, for the purpose +of collecting information relative to the voyages and discoveries of the +early Spanish navigators. In 1825, Señor Navarrete gave to the world the +first fruits of his indefatigable researches, in two volumes, the +commencement of a series, comprehending letters, private journals, royal +ordinances, and other original documents, illustrative of the discovery of +America. These two volumes are devoted exclusively to the adventures and +personal history of Columbus, and must be regarded as the only authentic +basis, on which any notice of the great navigator can hereafter rest. +Fortunately, Mr. Irving's visit to Spain, at this period, enabled the +world to derive the full benefit of Señor Navarrete's researches, by +presenting their results in connection with whatever had been before known +of Columbus, in the lucid and attractive form, which engages the interest +of every reader. It would seem highly proper, that the fortunes of the +discoverer of America should engage the pen of an inhabitant of her most +favored and enlightened region; and it is unnecessary to add, that the +task has been executed in a manner which must secure to the historian a +share in the imperishable renown of his subject. The adventures of +Columbus, which form so splendid an episode to the reign of Ferdinand and +Isabella, cannot properly come within the scope of its historian, except +so far as relates to his personal intercourse with the government, or +their results on the fortunes of the Spanish monarchy. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Aragon, or rather Catalonia, maintained an extensive commerce with the +Levant, and the remote regions of the east, during the Middle Ages, +through the flourishing port of Barcelona. See Capmany y Montpalau, +Memorias Históricas sobre la Marina, Comercio y Artes de Barcelona, +(Madrid, 1779-92,) passim. + +[2] A council of mathematicians in the court of John II., of Portugal, +first devised the application of the ancient astrolabe to navigation, thus +affording to the mariner the essential advantages appertaining to the +modern quadrant. The discovery of the polarity of the needle, which vulgar +tradition assigned to the Amalfite Flavio Gioja, and which Robertson has +sanctioned without scruple, is clearly proved to have occurred more than a +century earlier. Tiraboschi, who investigates the matter with his usual +erudition, passing by the doubtful reference of Guiot de Provins, whose +age and personal identity even are contested, traces the familiar use of +the magnetic needle as far back as the first half of the thirteenth +century, by a pertinent passage from Cardinal Vitri, who died 1244; and +sustains this by several similar references to other authors of the same +century. Capmany finds no notice of its use by the Castilian navigators +earlier than 1403. It was not until considerably later in the fifteenth +century, that the Portuguese voyagers, trusting to its guidance, ventured +to quit the Mediterranean and African coasts, and extend their navigation +to Madeira and the Azores. See Navarrete, Coleccion de los Viages y +Descubrimientos que hicieron por Mar los Españoles, (Madrid, 1825-29,) +tom. i. Int. sec. 33.--Tiraboschi, Letteratura Italiana, tom. iv. pp. 173, +174.--Capmany, Mem. de Barcelona, tom. iii. part. 1, cap. 4.--Koch, +Tableau des Révolutions de l'Europe, (Paris, 1814,) tom. i. pp. 358-360. + +[3] Four of the islands were conquered on behalf of private adventurers, +chiefly from Andalusia, before the accession of Ferdinand and Isabella, +and under their reign were held as the property of a noble Castilian +family, named Peraza. The sovereigns sent a considerable armament from +Seville in 1480, which subdued the great island of Canary on behalf of the +crown, and another in 1493, which effected the reduction of Palma and +Teneriffe after a sturdy resistance from the natives. Bernaldez postpones +the last conquest to 1495. Salazar de Mendoza, Monarquía, tom. i. pp. 347- +349.--Pulgar, Reyes Católicos, pp. 136, 203.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, +MS., cap. 64, 65, 66, 133.--Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i. +Introd., sec. 28. + +[4] Among the provisions of the sovereigns enacted previous to the present +date, may be noted those for regulating the coin and weights; for opening +a free trade between Castile and Aragon; for security to Genoese and +Venetian trading vessels; for safe conduct to mariners and fishermen; for +privileges to the seamen of Palos; for prohibiting the plunder of vessels +wrecked on the coast; and an ordinance of the very last year, requiring +foreigners to take their return cargoes in the products of the country. +See these laws as extracted from the Ordenanças Reales and the various +public archives, in Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 11. + +[5] Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, pp. 373, 374, 398.--Zurita, Anales, tom. +iv. lib. 20, cap. 30, 34.--Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages. + +[6] Spotorno, Memorials of Columbus, (London, 1823,) p. 14.--Senarega, +apud Muratori, Rerum Ital. Script., tom. xxiv. p. 535.--Antonio Gallo, De +Navigatione Columbi, apud Muratori, Rerum Ital. Script., tom. xxiii. p. +202. + +It is very generally agreed that the father of Columbus exercised the +craft of a wool-carder, or weaver. The admiral's son Ferdinand, after some +speculation on the genealogy of his illustrious parent, concludes with +remarking, that, after all, a noble descent would confer less lustre on +him than to have sprung from such a father; a philosophical sentiment, +indicating pretty strongly that he had no great ancestry to boast of. +Ferdinand finds something extremely mysterious and typical in his father's +name of _Columbus_, signifying a _dove_, in token of his being ordained to +"carry the olive-branch and oil of baptism over the ocean, like Noah's +dove, to denote the peace and union of the heathen people with the church, +after they had been shut up in the ark of darkness and confusion." +Fernando Colon, Historia del Almirante, cap. 1, 2, apud Barcia, +Historiadores Primitivos de las Indian Occidentals, (Madrid, 1749,) tom. +i., tom. i. Introd., sec. 21, 24.--Ferreras, Hist. d'Espagne, tom. vii. p. +548. + +[7] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 131.--Muñoz, Historia del Nuevo- +Mundo, (Madrid, 1793,) lib. 2, sec. 13. + +There are no sufficient data for determining the period of Columbus's +birth. The learned Muñoz places it in 1446. (Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. +2, sec. 12.) Navarrete, who has weighed the various authorities with +caution, seems inclined to remove it back eight or ten years further, +resting chiefly on a remark of Bernaldez, that he died in 1506, "in a good +old age, at the age of seventy, a little more or less." (Cap. 131.) The +expression is somewhat vague. In order to reconcile the facts with this +hypothesis, Navarrete is compelled to reject, as a chirographical blunder, +a passage in a letter of the admiral, placing his birth in 1456, and to +distort another passage in his book of "Prophecies," which, if literally +taken, would seem to establish his birth near the time assigned by Muñoz. +Incidental allusions in some other authorities, speaking of Columbus's old +age at or near the time of his death, strongly corroborate Navarrete's +inference. (See Coleccion de Viages, tom. i. Introd., sec. 54.)--Mr. +Irving seems willing to rely exclusively on the authority of Bernaldez. + +[8] Antonio de Herrera, Historia General de las Indias Occidentales, +(Amberes, 1728,) tom. i. dec. 1, lib. 1, cap. 7.--Gomara, Historia de las +Indias, cap. 14, apud Barcia, Hist. Primitivos, tom. ii.--Bernaldez, Reyes +Católicos, MS., cap. 118.--Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i. +Introd., sec. 30. + +Ferdinand Columbus enumerates three grounds on which his father's +conviction of land in the west was founded. First, natural reason,--or +conclusions drawn from science; secondly, authority of writers,--amounting +to little more than vague speculations of the ancients; thirdly, testimony +of sailors, comprehending, in addition to popular rumors of land described +in western voyages, such relics as appeared to have floated to the +European shores from the other side of the Atlantic. Hist. del Almirante, +cap. 6-8. + +[9] None of the intimations are so precise as that contained in the well- +known lines of Seneca's Medea, + + "Venient annuis saecula," etc., + +although, when regarded as a mere poetical vagary, it has not the weight +which belongs to more serious suggestions, of similar import, in the +writings of Aristotle and Strabo. The various allusions in the ancient +classic writers to an undiscovered world form the subject of an elaborate +essay in the Memorias da Acad. Real das Sciencias de Lisboa, (tom. v. pp. +101-112,) and are embodied, in much greater detail, in the first section +of Hnmboldt's "Histoire de la Géographie du Nouveau Continent;" a work in +which the author, with his usual acuteness, has successfully applied the +vast stores of his erudition and experience to the illustration of many +interesting points connected with the discovery of the New World, and the +personal history of Columbus. + +[10] It is probably the knowledge of this which has led some writers to +impute part of his work to the learned Marsilio Ficino, and others, with +still less charity and probability, to refer the authorship of the whole +to Politian. Comp. Tasso, Opere, (Venezia, 1735-42,) tom. x. p. 129.--and +Crescimbeni, Istoria della Volgar Poesia, (Venezia, 1731,) tom. iii. pp. +273, 274. + +[11] Pulci, Morgante Maggiore, canto 25, st. 229, 230.--I have used blank +verse, as affording facility for a more literal version than the +corresponding _ottava rima_ of the original. This passage of Pulci, +which has not fallen under the notice of Humboldt, or any other writer on +the same subject whom I have consulted, affords, probably, the most +circumstantial prediction that is to be found of the existence of a +western world. Dante, two centuries before, had intimated more vaguely his +belief in an undiscovered quarter of the globe. + + "De' vostri sensi, ch' è del rimanente, + Non vogliate negar l'esperienza, + Diretro al sol, del mondo senza gente." + +Inferno, cant. 26, v. 115. + +[12] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Col. Dipl., no. 1.--Muñoz, +Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 2, sec. 17.--It is singular that Columbus, in +his visit to Iceland, in 1477, (see Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, +cap. 4,) should have learned nothing of the Scandinavian voyages to the +northern shores of America in the tenth and following centuries; yet if he +was acquainted with them, it appears equally surprising that he should not +have adduced the fact in support of his own hypothesis of the existence of +land in the west; and that he should have taken a route so different from +that of his predecessors in the path of discovery. It may be, however, as +M. de Humboldt has well remarked, that the information he obtained in +Iceland was too vague to suggest the idea, that the lands thus discovered +by the Northmen had any connection with the Indies, of which he was in +pursuit. In Columbus's day, indeed, so little was understood of the true +position of these countries, that Greenland is laid down on the maps in +the European seas, and as a peninsular prolongation of Scandinavia. See +Humboldt, Géographie du Nouveau Continent, tom. ii. pp. 118, 125. + +[13] Herrera, Indias Occidentals, tom. i. dec. 1, lib. 1, cap. 7.--Muñoz, +Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 2, sec. 19.--Gomara, Hist. de las Indias, cap. +15.--Benzoni, Novi Orbis Historia, lib. 1, cap. 6.--Fernando Colon, Hist. +del Almirante, cap. 10.--Faria y Sousa, Europa Portuguesa, tom. ii. part. +3, cap. 4. + +[14] Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., dial. de Talavera. + +[15] Salazar de Mendoza, Crón. del Gran Cardenal, p. 214.--Herrera, Indias +Occidentales, tom. i. dec. 1, lib. 1, cap. 8.--Fernando Colon, Hist. del +Almirante, cap. 11. + +[16] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 1, cap. 8.--Zuñiga, +Annales de Sevilla, p. 104.--Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i. sec. +60, 61, tom. ii., Col. Dipl., nos. 2, 4. + +[17] This prelate, Diego de Deza, was born of poor but respectable +parents, at Toro. He early entered the Dominican order, where his learning +and exemplary life recommended him to the notice of the sovereigns, who +called him to court to take charge of Prince John's education. He was +afterwards raised, through the usual course of episcopal preferment, to +the metropolitan see of Seville. His situation, as confessor of Ferdinand, +gave him great influence over that monarch, with whom he appears to have +maintained an intimate correspondence, to the day of his death. Oviedo, +Quincuagenas, MS., dial. de Deza. + +[18] Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 11.--Salazar de Mendoza, +Crón. del Gran Cardenal, p. 215.--Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 2, +sec. 25, 29.--Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i., Introd., sec. 60. + +[19] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 1, cap. 8.--Muñoz, Hist. +del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 2, sec. 27.--Spotorno, Memorials of Columbus, pp. +31-33.--The last dates the application to Genoa prior to that to Portugal. + +A letter from the duke of Medina Celi to the cardinal of Spain, dated 19th +March, 1493, refers to his entertaining Columbus as his guest for two +years. It is very difficult to determine the date of these two years. If +Herrera is correct in the statement, that, after a five years' residence +at court, whose commencement he had previously referred to 1484, he +carried his proposals to the duke of Medina Celi, (see cap. 7, 8.) the two +years may have intervened between 1489-1491. Navarrete places them between +the departure from Portugal and the first application to the court of +Castile, in 1486. Some other writers, and among them Muñoz and Irving, +referring his application to Genoa to 1485, and his first appearance in +Spain to a subsequent period, make no provision for the residence with the +duke of Medina Celi. Mr. Irving indeed is betrayed into a chronological +inaccuracy, in speaking of a seven years' residence at the court in 1491, +which he had previously noticed as having before begun in 1486. (Life of +Columbus, (London, 1828,) comp. vol. i. pp. 109, 141.) In fact, the +discrepancies among the earliest authorities are such as to render +hopeless any attempt to settle with precision the chronology of Columbus's +movements previous to his first voyage. + +[20] Ferreras, Hist. d'Espagne, tom. viii. pp. 129, 130.--Muñoz, Hist. del +Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 2, sec. 31.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. +1, cap. 8.--Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i., Introd., sec. 60. + +[21] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 1, cap. 8.--Primer Viage +de Colon, apud Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i. pp. 2, 117.-- +Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 13. + +[22] Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 2, sec. 28, 29.--Fernando Colon, +Hist. del Almirante, ubi supra. + +[23] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 1, cap. 8.--Muñoz, Hist. +del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 2, sec. 32, 33.--Fernando Colon, Hist. del +Almirante, cap. 14.--Gomara, Hist. de las Indias, cap. 15. + +[24] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Col. Diplomat., nos. 5, 6. +--Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, p. 412.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. +p. 605. + +[25] Peter Martyr, De Rebus Oceanicis et Novo Orbe, (Coloniae, 1574,) dec. +1, lib. 1.--Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Col. Diplomat., nos. +7, 8, 9, 10, 12.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 1, cap. 9.-- +Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 14.--Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo- +Mundo, lib. 2, sec. 33.--Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., lib. 1, cap. 6.-- +Gomara, Hist. de las Indias, cap. 15. + +The expression in the text will not seem too strong, even admitting the +previous discoveries of the Northmen, which were made in so much higher +latitudes. Humboldt has well shown the probability, _a priori_, of +such discoveries, made in a narrow part of the Atlantic, where the +Orcades, the Feroe Islands, Iceland, and Greenland afforded the voyager so +many intermediate stations, at moderate distances from each other. +(Géographie du Nouveau Continent, tom. ii. pp. 183 et seq.) The +publication of the original Scandinavian MSS., (of which imperfect notices +and selections, only, have hitherto found their way into the world,) by +the Royal Society of Northern Antiquaries, at Copenhagen, is a matter of +the deepest interest; and it is fortunate that it is to be conducted under +auspices, which must insure its execution in the most faithful and able +manner. It may be doubted, however, whether the declaration of the +Prospectus, that "it was the knowledge of the Scandinavian voyages, in all +probability, which prompted the expedition of Columbus," can ever be +established. His personal history furnishes strong internal evidence to +the contrary. + +[26] How strikingly are the forlorn condition and indomitable energy of +Columbus depicted in the following noble verses of Chiabrera; + + "Certo da cor, ch' alto destin non scelse, + Son l' imprese magnanime neglette; + Ma le bell' alme alle bell' opre elette + Sanno gioir nelle fatiche eccelse; + Nè biasnio popolar, frale catena, + Spirto d'onore, il suo cammin reffrena. + Così lunga stagion per modi indegni + Europa disprezzò l'inclita speme, + Schernendo il vulgo, e seco i Regi insieme, + _Nudo nocchier, promettitor di Regni._" + +Rime, parte 1, canzone 12. + +[27] Columbus, in a letter written on his third voyage, pays an honest, +heartfelt tribute to the effectual patronage which he experienced from the +queen. "In the midst of the general incredulity," says he, "the Almighty +infused into the queen, my lady, the spirit of intelligence and energy; +and, whilst every one else, in his ignorance, was expatiating only on the +inconvenience and cost, her Highness approved it, on the contrary, and +gave it all the support in her power." See Carta al Ama del Principe D. +Juan, apud Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i. p. 266. + + + + +CHAPTER XVII. + +EXPULSION OF THE JEWS FROM SPAIN. + +1492. + +Excitement against the Jews.--Edict of Expulsion.--Dreadful Sufferings of +the Emigrants.--Whole Number of Exiles.--Disastrous Results.--True Motives +of the Edict.--Contemporary Judgments. + + +While the Spanish sovereigns were detained before Granada, they published +their memorable and most disastrous edict against the Jews; inscribing it, +as it were, with the same pen which drew up the glorious capitulation of +Granada and the treaty with Columbus. The reader has been made acquainted +in a preceding chapter with the prosperous condition of the Jews in the +Peninsula, and the pre-eminent consideration, which they attained there +beyond any other part of Christendom. The envy raised by their prosperity, +combined with the high religious excitement kindled in the long war with +the infidel, directed the terrible arm of the Inquisition, as has been +already stated, against this unfortunate people; but the result showed the +failure of the experiment, since comparatively few conversions, and those +frequently of a suspicious character, were effected, while the great mass +still maintained a pertinacious attachment to ancient errors. [1] + +Under these circumstances, the popular odium, inflamed by the discontent +of the clergy at the resistance which they encountered in the work of +proselytism, gradually grew stronger and stronger against the unhappy +Israelites. Old traditions, as old indeed as the thirteenth and fourteenth +centuries, were revived, and charged on the present generation, with all +the details of place and action. Christian children were said to be +kidnapped, in order to be crucified in derision of the Saviour; the host, +it was rumored, was exposed to the grossest indignities; and physicians +and apothecaries, whose science was particularly cultivated by the Jews in +the Middle Ages, were accused of poisoning their Christian patients. No +rumor was too absurd for the easy credulity of the people. The Israelites +were charged with the more probable offence of attempting to convert to +their own faith the _ancient Christians_, as well as to reclaim such +of their own race as had recently embraced Christianity. A great scandal +was occasioned also by the inter-marriages, which still occasionally took +place between Jews and Christians; the latter condescending to repair +their dilapidated fortunes by these wealthy alliances, though at the +expense of their vaunted purity of blood. [2] + +These various offences were urged against the Jews with great pertinacity +by their enemies, and the sovereigns were importuned to adopt a more +rigorous policy. The inquisitors, in particular, to whom the work of +conversion had been specially intrusted, represented the incompetence of +all lenient measures to the end proposed. They asserted, that the only +mode left for the extirpation of the Jewish heresy, was to eradicate the +seed; and they boldly demanded the immediate and total banishment of every +unbaptized Israelite from the land. [3] + +The Jews, who had obtained an intimation of these proceedings, resorted to +their usual crafty policy for propitiating the sovereigns. They +commissioned one of their body to tender a donative of thirty thousand +ducats towards defraying the expenses of the Moorish war. The negotiation, +however, was suddenly interrupted by the inquisitor-general, Torquemada, +who burst into the apartment of the palace, where the sovereigns were +giving audience to the Jewish deputy, and, drawing forth a crucifix from +beneath his mantle, held it up, exclaiming, "Judas Iscariot sold his +master for thirty pieces of silver. Your Highnesses would sell him anew +for thirty thousand; here he is, take him, and barter him away." So +saying, the frantic priest threw the crucifix on the table, and left the +apartment. The sovereigns, instead of chastising this presumption, or +despising it as a mere freak of insanity, were overawed by it. Neither +Ferdinand nor Isabella, had they been left to the unbiassed dictates of +their own reason, could have sanctioned for a moment so impolitic a +measure, which involved the loss of the most industrious and skilful +portion of their subjects. Its extreme injustice and cruelty rendered it +especially repugnant to the naturally humane disposition of the queen. [4] +But she had been early schooled to distrust her own reason, and indeed the +natural suggestions of humanity, in cases of conscience. Among the +reverend counsellors, on whom she most relied in these matters, was the +Dominican Torquemada. The situation which this man enjoyed as the queen's +confessor, during the tender years of her youth, gave him an ascendency +over her mind, which must have been denied to a person of his savage, +fanatical temper, even with the advantages of this spiritual connection, +had it been formed at a riper period of her life. Without opposing further +resistance to the representations, so emphatically expressed, of the holy +persons in whom she most confided, Isabella, at length, silenced her own +scruples, and consented to the fatal measure of proscription. + +The edict for the expulsion of the Jews was signed by the Spanish +sovereigns at Granada, March 30th, 1492. The preamble alleges, in +vindication of the measure, the danger of allowing further intercourse +between the Jews and their Christian subjects, in consequence of the +incorrigible obstinacy, with which the former persisted in their attempts +to make converts of the latter to their own faith, and to instruct them in +their heretical rites, in open defiance of every legal prohibition and +penalty. When a college or corporation of any kind,--the instrument goes +on to state,--is convicted of any great or detestable crime, it is right +that it should be disfranchised, the less suffering with the greater, the +innocent with the guilty. If this be the case in temporal concerns, it is +much more so in those which affect the eternal welfare of the soul. It +finally decrees, that all unbaptized Jews, of whatever sex, age, or +condition, should depart from the realm by the end of July next ensuing; +prohibiting them from revisiting it, on any pretext whatever, under +penalty of death and confiscation of property. It was, moreover, +interdicted to every subject, to harbor, succor, or minister to the +necessities of any Jew, after the expiration of the term limited for his +departure. The persons and property of the Jews, in the mean time, were +taken under the royal protection. They were allowed to dispose of their +effects of every kind on their own account, and to carry the proceeds +along with them, in bills of exchange, or merchandise not prohibited, but +neither in gold nor silver. [5] + +The doom of exile fell like a thunderbolt on the heads of the Israelites. +A large proportion of them had hitherto succeeded in shielding themselves +from the searching eye of the Inquisition, by an affectation of reverence +for the forms of Catholic worship, and a discreet forbearance of whatever +might offend the prejudices of their Christian brethren. They had even +hoped, that their steady loyalty, and a quiet and orderly discharge of +their social duties, would in time secure them higher immunities. Many had +risen to a degree of opulence, by means of the thrift and dexterity +peculiar to the race, which gave them a still deeper interest in the land +of their residence. [6] Their families were reared in all the elegant +refinements of life; and their wealth and education often disposed them to +turn their attention to liberal pursuits, which ennobled the character, +indeed, but rendered them personally more sensible to physical annoyance, +and less fitted to encounter the perils and privations of their dreary +pilgrimage. Even the mass of the common people possessed a dexterity in +various handicrafts, which afforded a comfortable livelihood, raising them +far above similar classes in most other nations, who might readily be +detached from the soil on which they happened to be cast, with +comparatively little sacrifice of local interests. [7] These ties were now +severed at a blow. They were to go forth as exiles from the land of their +birth; the land where all whom they ever loved had lived or died; the +land, not so much of their adoption, as of inheritance; which had been the +home of their ancestors for centuries, and with whose prosperity and glory +they were of course as intimately associated, as was any ancient Spaniard. +They were to be cast out helpless and defenceless, with a brand of infamy +set on them, among nations who had always held them in derision and +hatred. + +Those provisions of the edict, which affected a show of kindness to the +Jews, were contrived so artfully, as to be nearly nugatory. As they were +excluded from the use of gold and silver, the only medium for representing +their property was bills of exchange. But commerce was too limited and +imperfect to allow of these being promptly obtained to any very +considerable, much less to the enormous amount required in the present +instance. It was impossible, moreover, to negotiate a sale of their +effects under existing circumstances, since the market was soon glutted +with commodities; and few would be found willing to give anything like an +equivalent for what, if not disposed of within the prescribed term, the +proprietors must relinquish at any rate. So deplorable, indeed, was the +sacrifice of property, that a chronicler of the day mentions, that he had +seen a house exchanged for an ass, and a vineyard for a suit of clothes! +In Aragon, matters were still worse. The government there discovered, that +the Jews were largely indebted to individuals and to certain corporations. +It accordingly caused their property to be sequestrated for the benefit of +their creditors, until their debts should be liquidated. Strange, indeed, +that the balance should be found against the people, who have been +everywhere conspicuous for their commercial sagacity and resources, and +who, as factors of the great nobility and farmers of the revenue, enjoyed +at least equal advantages in Spain with those possessed in other +countries, for the accumulation of wealth. [8] + +While the gloomy aspect of their fortunes pressed heavily on the hearts of +the Israelites, the Spanish clergy were indefatigable in the work of +conversion. They lectured in the synagogues and public squares, expounding +the doctrines of Christianity, and thundering forth both argument and +invective against the Hebrew heresy. But their laudable endeavors were in +a great measure counteracted by the more authoritative rhetoric of the +Jewish Rabbins, who compared the persecutions of their brethren to those +which their ancestors had suffered under Pharaoh. They encouraged them to +persevere, representing that the present afflictions were intended as a +trial of their faith by the Almighty, who designed in this way to guide +them to the promised land, by opening a path through the waters, as he had +done to their fathers of old. The more wealthy Israelites enforced their +exhortations by liberal contributions for the relief of their indigent +brethren. Thus strengthened, there were found but very few, when the day +of departure arrived, who were not prepared to abandon their country +rather than their religion. The extraordinary act of self-devotion by a +whole people for conscience' sake may be thought, in the nineteenth +century, to merit other epithets than those of "perfidy, incredulity, and +stiff-necked obstinacy," with which the worthy Curate of Los Palacios, in +the charitable feeling of that day, has seen fit to stigmatize it. [9] + +When the period of departure arrived, all the principal routes through the +country might be seen swarming with emigrants, old and young, the sick and +the helpless, men, women, and children, mingled promiscuously together, +some mounted on horses or mules, but far the greater part undertaking +their painful pilgrimage on foot. The sight of so much misery touched even +the Spaniards with pity, though none might succor them; for the grand +inquisitor, Torquemada, enforced the ordinance to that effect, by +denouncing heavy ecclesiastical censures on all who should presume to +violate it. The fugitives were distributed along various routes, being +determined in their destination by accidental circumstances, much more +than any knowledge of the respective countries to which they were bound. +Much the largest division, amounting according to some estimates to eighty +thousand souls, passed into Portugal; whose monarch, John the Second, +dispensed with his scruples of conscience so far as to give them a free +passage through his dominions on their way to Africa, in consideration of +a tax of a _cruzado_ a head. He is even said to have silenced his +scruples so far as to allow certain ingenious artisans to establish +themselves permanently in the kingdom. [10] + +A considerable number found their way to the ports of Santa Maria and +Cadiz, where, after lingering some time in the vain hope of seeing the +waters open for their egress, according to the promises of the Rabbins, +they embarked on board a Spanish fleet for the Barbary coast. Having +crossed over to Ercilla, a Christian settlement in Africa, whence they +proceeded by land towards Fez, where a considerable body of their +countrymen resided, they were assaulted on their route by the roving +tribes of the desert, in quest of plunder. Notwithstanding the interdict, +the Jews had contrived to secrete small sums of money, sewed up in their +garments or the linings of their saddles. These did not escape the +avaricious eyes of their spoilers, who are even said to have ripped open +the bodies of their victims, in search of gold, which they were supposed +to have swallowed. The lawless barbarians, mingling lust with avarice, +abandoned themselves to still more frightful excesses, violating the wives +and daughters of the unresisting Jews, or massacring in cold blood such as +offered resistance. But without pursuing these loathsome details further, +it need only be added, that the miserable exiles endured such extremity of +famine, that they were glad to force a nourishment from the grass which +grew scantily among the sands of the desert; until at length great numbers +of them, wasted by disease, and broken in spirit, retraced their steps to +Ercilla, and consented to be baptized, in the hope of being permitted to +revisit their native land. The number, indeed, was so considerable, that +the priest who officiated was obliged to make use of the mop, or hyssop, +with which the Roman Catholic missionaries were wont to scatter the holy +drops, whose mystic virtue could cleanse the soul in a moment from the +foulest stains of infidelity. "Thus," says a Castilian historian, "the +calamities of these poor blind creatures proved in the end an excellent +remedy, that God made use of to unseal their eyes, which they now opened +to the vain promises of the Rabbins; so that, renouncing their ancient +heresies, they became faithful followers of the Cross!" [11] + +Many of the emigrants took the direction of Italy. Those who landed at +Naples brought with them an infectious disorder, contracted by long +confinement in small, crowded, and ill-provided vessels. The disorder was +so malignant, and spread with such frightful celerity, as to sweep off +more than twenty thousand inhabitants of the city, in the course of the +year, whence it extended its devastation over the whole Italian peninsula. + +A graphic picture of these horrors is thus given by a Genoese historian, +an eye-witness of the scenes he describes. "No one," he says, "could +behold the sufferings of the Jewish exiles unmoved. A great many perished +of hunger, especially those of tender years. Mothers, with scarcely +strength to support themselves, carried their famished infants in their +arms, and died with them. Many fell victims to the cold, others to intense +thirst, while the unaccustomed distresses incident to a sea-voyage +aggravated their maladies. I will not enlarge on the cruelty and the +avarice which they frequently experienced from the masters of the ships +which transported them from Spain. Some were murdered to gratify their +cupidity, others forced to sell their children for the expenses of the +passage. They arrived in Genoa in crowds, but were not suffered to tarry +there long, by reason of the ancient law which interdicted the Jewish +traveller from a longer residence than three days. They were allowed, +however, to refit their vessels, and to recruit themselves for some days +from the fatigues of their voyage. One might have taken them for spectres, +so emaciated were they, so cadaverous in their aspect, and with eyes so +sunken; they differed in nothing from the dead, except in the power of +motion, which indeed they scarcely retained. Many fainted and expired on +the mole, which, being completely surrounded by the sea, was the only +quarter vouchsafed to the wretched emigrants. The infection bred by such a +swarm of dead and dying persons was not at once perceived; but, when the +winter broke up, ulcers began to make their appearance, and the malady, +which lurked for a long time in the city, broke out into the plague in the +following year." [12] + +Many of the exiles passed into Turkey, and to different parts of the +Levant, where their descendants continued to speak the Castilian language +far into the following century. Others found their way to France, and even +England. Part of their religious services is recited to this day in +Spanish, in one or more of the London synagogues; and the modern Jew still +reverts with fond partiality to Spain, as the cherished land of his +fathers, illustrated by the most glorious recollections in their eventful +history. [13] + +The whole number of Jews expelled from Spain by Ferdinand and Isabella is +variously computed from one hundred and sixty thousand to eight hundred +thousand souls; a discrepancy sufficiently indicating the paucity of +authentic data. Most modern writers, with the usual predilection for +startling results, have assumed the latter estimate; and Llorente has made +it the basis of some important calculations, in his History of the +Inquisition. A view of all the circumstances will lead us without much +hesitation to adopt the more moderate computation. [14] This, moreover, is +placed beyond reasonable doubt by the direct testimony of the Curate of +Los Palacios. He reports, that a Jewish Rabbin, one of the exiles, +subsequently returned to Spain, where he was baptized by him. This person, +whom Bernaldez commends for his intelligence, estimated the whole number +of his unbaptized countrymen in the dominions of Ferdinand and Isabella, +at the publication of the edict, at thirty-six thousand families. Another +Jewish authority, quoted by the Curate, reckoned them at thirty-five +thousand. This, assuming an average of four and a half to a family, gives +the sum total of about one hundred and sixty thousand individuals, +agreeably to the computation of Bernaldez. There is little reason for +supposing, that the actual amount would suffer diminution in the hands of +either the Jewish or Castilian authority; since the one might naturally be +led to exaggerate, in order to heighten sympathy with the calamities of +his nation, and the other, to magnify as far as possible the glorious +triumphs of the Cross. [15] + +The detriment incurred by the state, however, is not founded so much on +any numerical estimate, as on the subtraction of the mechanical skill, +intelligence, and general resources of an orderly, industrious population. +In this view, the mischief was incalculably greater than that inferred by +the mere number of the exiled; and, although even this might have been +gradually repaired in a country allowed the free and healthful development +of its energies, yet in Spain this was so effectually counteracted by the +Inquisition, and other causes in the following century, that the loss may +be deemed irretrievable. + +The expulsion of so numerous a class of subjects by an independent act of +the sovereign, might well be regarded as an enormous stretch of +prerogative, altogether incompatible with anything like a free government. +But to judge the matter rightly, we must take into view the actual +position of the Jews at that time. Far from forming an integral part of +the commonwealth, they were regarded as alien to it, as a mere +excrescence, which, so far from contributing to the healthful action of +the body politic, was nourished by its vicious humors, and might be lopped +off at any time, when the health of the system demanded it. Far from being +protected by the laws, the only aim of the laws, in reference to them, was +to define more precisely their civil incapacities, and to draw the line of +division more broadly between them and the Christians. Even this +humiliation by no means satisfied the national prejudices, as is evinced +by the great number of tumults and massacres of which they were the +victims. In these circumstances, it seemed to be no great assumption of +authority, to pronounce sentence of exile against those whom public +opinion had so long proscribed as enemies to the state. It was only +carrying into effect that opinion, expressed as it had been in a great +variety of ways; and, as far as the rights of the nation were concerned, +the banishment of a single Spaniard would have been held a grosser +violation of them, than that of the whole race of Israelites. + +It has been common with modern historians to detect a principal motive for +the expulsion of the Jews, in the avarice of the government. It is only +necessary, however, to transport ourselves back to those times, to find it +in perfect accordance with their spirit, at least in Spain. It is indeed +incredible, that persons possessing the political sagacity of Ferdinand +and Isabella could indulge a temporary cupidity at the sacrifice of the +most important and permanent interests, converting their wealthiest +districts into a wilderness, and dispeopling them of a class of citizens +who contributed beyond all others, not only to the general resources, but +the direct revenues of the crown; a measure so manifestly unsound, as to +lead even a barbarian monarch of that day to exclaim, "Do they call this +Ferdinand a politic prince, who can thus impoverish his own kingdom and +enrich ours!" [16] It would seem, indeed, when the measure had been +determined on, that the Aragonese monarch was willing, by his expedient of +sequestration, to control its operation in such a manner as to secure to +his own subjects the full pecuniary benefit of it. [17] No imputation of +this kind attaches to Castile. The clause of the ordinance, which might +imply such a design, by interdicting the exportation of gold and silver, +was only enforcing a law, which had been already twice enacted by cortes +in the present reign, and which was deemed of such moment, that the +offence was made capital. [18] + +We need look no further for the principle of action, in this case, than +the spirit of religious bigotry, which led to a similar expulsion of the +Jews from England, France, and other parts of Europe, as well as from +Portugal, under circumstances of peculiar atrocity, a few years later. +[19] Indeed, the spirit of persecution did not expire with the fifteenth +century, but extended far into the more luminous periods of the +seventeenth and eighteenth; and that, too, under a ruler of the enlarged +capacity of Frederic the Great, whose intolerance could not plead in +excuse the blindness of fanaticism. [20] How far the banishment of the +Jews was conformable to the opinions of the most enlightened +contemporaries, may be gathered from the encomiums lavished on its authors +from more than one quarter. Spanish writers, without exception, celebrate +it as a sublime sacrifice of all temporal interests to religious +principle. The best instructed foreigners, in like manner, however they +may condemn the details of its execution, or commiserate the sufferings of +the Jews, commend the act, as evincing the most lively and laudable zeal +for the true faith. [21] + +It cannot be denied, that Spain at this period surpassed most of the +nations of Christendom in religious enthusiasm, or, to speak more +correctly, in bigotry. This is doubtless imputable to the long war with +the Moslems, and its recent glorious issue, which swelled every heart with +exultation, disposing it to consummate the triumphs of the Cross by +purging the land from a heresy, which, strange as it may seem, was +scarcely less detested than that of Mahomet. Both the sovereigns partook +largely of these feelings. With regard to Isabella, moreover, it must be +borne constantly in mind, as has been repeatedly remarked in the course of +this History, that she had been used to surrender her own judgment, in +matters of conscience, to those spiritual guardians, who were supposed in +that age to be its rightful depositaries, and the only casuists who could +safely determine the doubtful line of duty. Isabella's pious disposition, +and her trembling solicitude to discharge her duty, at whatever cost of +personal inclination, greatly enforced the precepts of education. In this +way, her very virtues became the source of her errors. Unfortunately, she +lived in an age and station, which attached to these errors the most +momentous consequences. [22]--But we gladly turn from these dark prospects +to a brighter page of her history. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] It is a proof of the high consideration in which such Israelites as +were willing to embrace Christianity were held, that three of that number, +Alvarez, Avila, and Pulgar, were private secretaries of the queen. (Mem. +de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 18.) + +An incidental expression of Martyr's, among many similar ones by +contemporaries, affords the true key to the popular odium against the +Jews. "Cum namque viderent, Judaeorum tabido commercio, qui hac horâ sunt +in Hispaniâ _innumeri Christianis ditiores_, plurimorum animos corrumpi ac +seduci," etc. Opus Epist., epist. 92. + +[2] Paramo, De Origine Inquisitionis, p. 164.--Llorente, Hist. de +l'Inquisition, tom. i. cap. 7, sec. 3.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. +94.--Ferreras, Hist. d'Espagne, tom. viii. p. 128. + +[3] Paramo, De Origine Inquisitionis, p. 163. + +Salazar de Mendoza refers the sovereign's consent to the banishment of the +Jews, in a great measure, to the urgent remonstrances of the cardinal of +Spain. The bigotry of the biographer makes him claim the credit of every +fanatical act for his illustrious hero. See Crón. del Gran Cardenal, p. +250. + +[4] Llorente, Hist. de l'Inquisition, tom. i. chap. 7, sect. 5. + +Pulgar, in a letter to the cardinal of Spain, animadverting with much +severity on the tenor of certain municipal ordinances against the Jews in +Guipuscoa and Toledo, in 1482, plainly intimates, that they were not at +all to the taste of the queen. See Letras, (Amstelodami, 1670,) let. 31. + +[5] Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1492.--Recep. de las Leyes, lib. 8, tit. 2, +ley 2.--Pragmáticas del Reyno, ed. 1520, fol. 3. + +[6] The Curate of Los Palacios speaks of several Israelites worth one or +two millions of maravedies, and another even as having amassed ten. He +mentions one in particular, by the name of Abraham, as renting the +_greater part of Castile_! It will hardly do to take the good Curate's +statement _à la lettre_. See Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 112. + +[7] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, ubi supra. + +[8] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 10.--Zurita, Analos, tom. v. +fol. 9. + +Capmany notices the number of synagogues existing in Aragon, in 1428, as +amounting to nineteen. In Galicia at the same time there were but three, +and in Catalonia but one. See Mem. de Barcelona, tom. iv. Apend. num. 11. + +[9] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 10, 113.--Ferreras, Hist. +d'Espagne, tom. viii. p. 131. + +[10] Zurita, Anales, tom. v. fol. 9.--Ferreras, Hist. d'Espagne, tom. +viii. p. 133.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, ubi supra.--La Clède, Hist. de +Portugal, tom. iv. p. 95.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. p. 602. + +[11] Ferreras, Hist. d'Espagne, tom. viii. p. 133.--Bernaldez, Reyes +Católicos, MS., cap. 113. + +[12] Senarega, apud Muratori, Rerum Ital. Script., tom. xxiv. pp. 531, +532. + +[13] See a sensible notice of Hebrew literature in Spain, in the +Retrospective Review, vol. iii. p. 209.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. +ii. lib. 26, cap. 1.--Zurita, Anales, tom. v. fol. 9. + +Not a few of the learned exiles attained to eminence in those countries of +Europe where they transferred their residence. One is mentioned by Castro +as a leading practitioner of medicine in Genoa; another, as filling the +posts of astronomer and chronicler, under King Emanuel of Portugal. Many +of them published works in various departments of science, which were +translated into the Spanish and other European languages. Biblioteca +Española, tom. i. pp. 359-372. + +[14] From a curious document in the _Archives of Simancas_, consisting of +a report made to the Spanish sovereigns by their accountant general, +Quintanilla, in 1492, it would appear, that the population of the kingdom +of Castile, exclusive of Granada, was then estimated at 1,500,000 +_vecinos_, or householders. (See Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., Apend. +no. 12.) This, allowing four and a half to a family, would make the whole +population 6,750,000. It appears from the statement of Bernaldez, that the +kingdom of Castile contained five-sixths of the whole amount of Jews in +the Spanish monarchy. This proportion, if 800,000 be received as the +total, would amount in round numbers to 670,000, or ten per cent, of the +whole population of the kingdom. Now, it is manifestly improbable that so +large a portion of the whole nation, conspicuous moreover for wealth and +intelligence, could have been held so light in a political aspect, as the +Jews certainly were, or have tamely submitted for so many years to the +most wanton indignities without resistance; or finally, that the Spanish +government would have ventured on so bold a measure as the banishment of +so numerous and powerful a class, and that too with as few precautions, +apparently, as would be required for driving out of the country a roving +gang of gypsies. + +[15] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 110.--Llorente, Hist. de +l'Inquisition, tom. i. chap. 7, sect. 7.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. +ii. lib. 26.--Zurita, Anales, tom. v. fol. 9. + +[16] Bajazet. See Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, tom. ii. p. 310.--Paramo, De +Origine Inquisitionis, p. 168. + +[17] "In truth," Father Abarca somewhat innocently remarks, "King +Ferdinand was a politic Christian, making the interests of church and +state mutually subservient to each other"! Reyes de Aragon, tom. ii. fol. +310. + +[18] Once at Toledo, 1480, and at Murcia, 1488. See Recop. de las Leyes, +lib. 6, tit. 18, ley 1. + +[19] The Portuguese government caused all children of fourteen years of +age, or under, to be taken from their parents and retained in the country, +as fit subjects for a Christian education. The distress occasioned by this +cruel provision may be well imagined. Many of the unhappy parents murdered +their children to defeat the ordinance; and many laid violent hands on +themselves. Faria y Sousa coolly remarks, that "It was a great mistake in +King Emanuel to think of converting any Jew to Christianity, old enough to +pronounce the name of Moses!" He fixes three years of age as the utmost +limit. (Europa Portuguesa, tom. ii. p. 496.) + +Mr. Turner has condensed, with his usual industry, the most essential +chronological facts relative to modern Jewish history, into a note +contained in the second volume of his History of England, pp. 114-120. + +[20] They were also rejected from Vienna, in 1669. The illiberal, and +indeed most cruel legislation of Frederic II., in reference to his Jewish +subjects, transports us back to the darkest periods of the Visigothic +monarchy. The reader will find a summary of these enactments in the third +volume of Milman's agreeable History of the Jews. + +[21] The accomplished and amiable Florentine, Pico di Mirandola, in his +treatise on Judicial Astrology, remarks that, "the sufferings of the Jews, +_in which the glory of divine justice delighted_, were so extreme as +to fill us Christians with commiseration." The Genoese historian, +Senarega, indeed admits that the measure savored _of some slight degree +of cruelty_. "Res haec primo conspectu laudabilis visa est, quia decus +nostrae Religionis respiceret, sed aliquantulum in se crudelitatis +continere, si eos non belluas, sed homines a Deo creatos, consideravimus." +De Rebus Genuensibus, apud Muratori, Rerum Ital. Script., tom. xxiv.-- +Illescas, Hist. Pontif., apud Paramo, De Origine Inquisitionis, p. 167. + +[22] Llorente sums up his account of the expulsion, by assigning the +following motives to the principal agents in the business. "The measure," +he says, "may be referred to the fanaticism of Torquemada, to the avarice +and superstition of Ferdinand, to the false ideas and inconsiderate zeal +with which they had inspired Isabella, to whom history cannot refuse the +praise of great sweetness of disposition, and an enlightened mind." Hist. +de l'Inquisition, tom. i. ch. 7, sec. 10. + + + + +CHAPTER XVIII. + +ATTEMPTED ASSASSINATION OF FERDINAND.--RETURN AND SECOND VOYAGE OF +COLUMBUS. + +1492-1493. + +Attempt on Ferdinand's Life.--Consternation and Loyalty of the People.-- +Return of Columbus.--His Progress to Barcelona.--Interviews with the +Sovereigns.--Sensations caused by the Discovery.--Regulations of Trade.-- +Conversion of the Natives.--Famous Bulls of Alexander VI.--Jealousy of +Portugal.--Second Voyage of Columbus.--Treaty of Tordesillas. + + +Towards the latter end of May, 1492, the Spanish sovereigns quitted +Granada, between which and Santa Fe they had divided their time since the +surrender of the Moorish metropolis. They were occupied during the two +following months with the affairs of Castile. In August they visited +Aragon, proposing to establish their winter residence there in order to +provide for its internal administration, and conclude the negotiations for +the final surrender of Roussillon and Cerdagne by France, to which these +provinces had been mortgaged by Ferdinand's father, John the Second; +proving ever since a fruitful source of diplomacy, which threatened more +than once to terminate in open rupture. + +Ferdinand and Isabella arrived in Aragon on the 8th of August, accompanied +by Prince John and the infantas, and a brilliant train of Castilian +nobles. In their progress through the country they were everywhere +received with the most lively enthusiasm. The whole nation seemed to +abandon itself to jubilee, at the approach of its illustrious sovereigns, +whose heroic constancy had rescued Spain from the detested empire of the +Saracens. After devoting some months to the internal police of the +kingdom, the court transferred its residence to Catalonia, whose capital +it reached about the middle of October. During its detention in this +place, Ferdinand's career was wellnigh brought to an untimely close. [1] + +It was a good old custom of Catalonia, long since fallen into desuetude, +for the monarch to preside in the tribunals of justice, at least once a +week, for the purpose of determining the suits of the poorer classes +especially, who could not afford the more expensive forms of litigation. +King Ferdinand, in conformity with this usage, held a court in the house +of deputation, on the 7th of December, being the vigil of the conception +of the Virgin. At noon, as he was preparing to quit the palace, after the +conclusion of business, he lingered in the rear of his retinue, conversing +with some of the officers of the court. As the party was issuing from a +little chapel contiguous to the royal saloon, and just as the king was +descending a flight of stairs, a ruffian darted from an obscure recess in +which he had concealed himself early in the morning, and aimed a blow with +a short sword, or knife, at the back of Ferdinand's neck. Fortunately the +edge of the weapon was turned by a gold chain or collar which he was in +the habit of wearing. It inflicted, however, a deep wound between the +shoulders. Ferdinand instantly cried out, "St. Mary preserve us! treason, +treason!" and his attendants, rushing on the assassin, stabbed him in +three places with their poniards, and would have despatched him on the +spot, had not the king, with his usual presence of mind, commanded them to +desist, and take the man alive, that they might ascertain the real authors +of the conspiracy. This was done accordingly, and Ferdinand, fainting with +loss of blood, was carefully removed to his apartments in the royal +palace. [2] + +The report of the catastrophe spread like wildfire through the city. All +classes were thrown into consternation by so foul an act, which seemed to +cast a stain on the honor and good faith of the Catalans. Some suspected +it to be the work of a vindictive Moor, others of a disappointed courtier. +The queen, who had swooned on first receiving intelligence of the event, +suspected the ancient enmity of the Catalans, who had shown such +determined opposition to her husband in his early youth. She gave instant +orders to hold in readiness one of the galleys lying in the port, in order +to transport her children from the place, as she feared the conspiracy +might be designed to embrace other victims. [3] + +The populace, in the mean while, assembled in great numbers round the +palace where the king lay. All feelings of hostility had long since given +way to devoted loyalty towards a government, which had uniformly respected +the liberties of its subjects, and whose paternal sway had secured similar +blessings to Barcelona with the rest of the empire. They thronged round +the building, crying out that the king was slain, and demanding that his +murderers should be delivered up to them. Ferdinand, exhausted as he was, +would have presented himself at the window of his apartment, but was +prevented from making the effort by his physicians. It was with great +difficulty that the people were at length satisfied that he was still +living, and that they finally consented to disperse, on the assurance, +that the assassin should be brought to condign punishment. + +The king's wound, which did not appear dangerous at first, gradually +exhibited more alarming symptoms. One of the bones was found to be +fractured, and a part of it was removed by the surgeons. On the seventh +day his situation was considered extremely critical. During this time, the +queen was constantly by his side, watching with him day and night, and +administering all his medicines with her own hand. At length, the +unfavorable symptoms yielded; and his excellent constitution enabled him +so far to recover, that in less than three weeks he was able to show +himself to the eyes of his anxious subjects, who gave themselves up to a +delirium of joy, offering thanksgivings and grateful oblations in the +churches; while many a pilgrimage, which had been vowed for his +restoration to health, was performed by the good people of Barcelona, with +naked feet, and even on their knees, among the wild sierras that surround +the city. + +The author of the crime proved to be a peasant, about sixty years of age, +of that humble class, _de remensa_, as it was termed, which Ferdinand +had been so instrumental some few years since in releasing from the baser +and more grinding pains of servitude. The man appeared to be insane; +alleging, in vindication of his conduct, that he was the rightful +proprietor of the crown, which he expected to obtain by Ferdinand's death. +He declared himself willing, however, to give up his pretensions, on +condition of being set at liberty. The king, convinced of his alienation +of mind, would have discharged him; but the Catalans, indignant at the +reproach which such a crime seemed to attach to their own honor, and +perhaps distrusting the plea of insanity, thought it necessary to expiate +it by the blood of the offender, and condemned the unhappy wretch to the +dreadful doom of a traitor; the preliminary barbarities of the sentence, +however, were remitted, at the intercession of the queen. [4] + +In the spring of 1493, while the court was still at Barcelona, letters +were received from Christopher Columbus, announcing his return to Spain, +and the successful achievement of his great enterprise, by the discovery +of land beyond the western ocean. The delight and astonishment, raised by +this intelligence, were proportioned to the skepticism, with which his +project had been originally viewed. The sovereigns were now filled with a +natural impatience to ascertain the extent and other particulars of the +important discovery; and they transmitted instant instructions to the +admiral to repair to Barcelona, as soon as he should have made the +preliminary arrangements for the further prosecution of his enterprise. +[5] + +The great navigator had succeeded, as is well known, after a voyage the +natural difficulties of which had been much augmented by the distrust and +mutinous spirit of his followers, in descrying land on Friday, the 12th of +October, 1492. After some months spent in exploring the delightful +regions, now for the first time thrown open to the eyes of a European, he +embarked in the month of January, 1493, for Spain. One of his vessels had +previously foundered, and another had deserted him; so that he was left +alone to retrace his course across the Atlantic. After a most tempestuous +voyage, he was compelled to take shelter in the Tagus, sorely against his +inclination. [6] He experienced, however, the most honorable reception +from the Portuguese monarch, John the Second, who did ample justice to the +great qualities of Columbus, although he had failed to profit by them. [7] +After a brief delay, the admiral resumed his voyage, and crossing the bar +of Saltes entered the harbor of Palos about noon, on the 15th of March, +1493, being exactly seven months and eleven days since his departure from +that port. [8] + +Great was the agitation in the little community of Palos, as they beheld +the well-known vessel of the admiral re-entering their harbor. Their +desponding imaginations had long since consigned him to a watery grave; +for, in addition to the preternatural horrors which hung over the voyage, +they had experienced the most stormy and disastrous winter within the +recollection of the oldest mariners. [9] Most of them had relatives or +friends on board. They thronged immediately to the shore, to assure +themselves with their own eyes of the truth of their return. When they +beheld their faces once more, and saw them accompanied by the numerous +evidences which they brought back of the success of the expedition, they +burst forth in acclamations of joy and gratulation. They awaited the +landing of Columbus, when the whole population of the place accompanied +him and his crew to the principal church, where solemn thanksgivings were +offered up for their return; while every bell in the village sent forth a +joyous peal in honor of the glorious event. The admiral was too desirous +of presenting himself before the sovereigns, to protract his stay long at +Palos. He took with him on his journey specimens of the multifarious +products of the newly discovered regions. He was accompanied by several of +the native islanders, arrayed in their simple barbaric costume, and +decorated, as he passed through the principal cities, with collars, +bracelets, and other ornaments of gold, rudely fashioned; he exhibited +also considerable quantities of the same metal in dust, or in crude +masses, [10] numerous vegetable exotics, possessed of aromatic or +medicinal virtue, and several kinds of quadrupeds unknown in Europe, and +birds, whose varieties of gaudy plumage gave a brilliant effect to the +pageant. The admiral's progress through the country was everywhere impeded +by the multitudes thronging forth to gaze at the extraordinary spectacle, +and the more extraordinary man, who, in the emphatic language of that +time, which has now lost its force from its familiarity, first revealed +the existence of a "New World." As he passed through the busy, populous +city of Seville, every window, balcony, and housetop, which could afford a +glimpse of him, is described to have been crowded with spectators. It was +the middle of April before Columbus reached Barcelona. The nobility and +cavaliers in attendance on the court, together with the authorities of the +city, came to the gates to receive him, and escorted him to the royal +presence. Ferdinand and Isabella were seated, with their son, Prince John, +under a superb canopy of state, awaiting his arrival. On his approach, +they rose from their seats, and, extending their hands to him to salute, +caused him to be seated before them. These were unprecedented marks of +condescension to a person of Columbus's rank, in the haughty and +ceremonious court of Castile. It was, indeed, the proudest moment in the +life of Columbus. He had fully established the truth of his long-contested +theory, in the face of argument, sophistry, sneer, skepticism, and +contempt. He had achieved this, not by chance, but by calculation, +supported through the most adverse circumstances by consummate conduct. +The honors paid him, which had hitherto been reserved only for rank, or +fortune, or military success, purchased by the blood and tears of +thousands, were, in his case, a homage to intellectual power, successfully +exerted in behalf of the noblest interests of humanity. [11] + +After a brief interval, the sovereigns requested from Columbus a recital +of his adventures. His manner was sedate and dignified, but warmed by the +glow of natural enthusiasm. He enumerated the several islands which he had +visited, expatiated on the temperate character of the climate, and the +capacity of the soil for every variety of agricultural production, +appealing to the samples imported by him, as evidence of their natural +fruitfulness. He dwelt more at large on the precious metals to be found in +these islands, which he inferred, less from the specimens actually +obtained, than from the uniform testimony of the natives to their +abundance in the unexplored regions of the interior. Lastly, he pointed +out the wide scope afforded to Christian zeal, in the illumination of a +race of men, whose minds, far from being wedded to any system of idolatry, +were prepared by their extreme simplicity for the reception of pure and +uncorrupted doctrine. The last consideration touched Isabella's heart most +sensibly; and the whole audience, kindled with various emotions by the +speaker's eloquence, filled up the perspective with the gorgeous coloring +of their own fancies, as ambition, or avarice, or devotional feeling +predominated in their bosoms. When Columbus ceased, the king and queen, +together with all present, prostrated themselves on their knees in +grateful thanksgivings, while the solemn strains of the Te Deum were +poured forth by the choir of the royal chapel, as in commemoration of some +glorious victory. [12] + +The discoveries of Columbus excited a sensation, particularly among men of +science, in the most distant parts of Europe, strongly contrasting with +the apathy which had preceded them. They congratulated one another on +being reserved for an age which had witnessed the consummation of so grand +an event. The learned Martyr, who, in his multifarious correspondence, had +not even deigned to notice the preparations for the voyage of discovery, +now lavished the most unbounded panegyric on its results; which he +contemplated with the eye of a philosopher, having far less reference to +considerations of profit or policy, than to the prospect which they +unfolded of enlarging the boundaries of knowledge. [12] + +Most of the scholars of the day, however, adopted the erroneous hypothesis +of Columbus, who considered the lands he had discovered, as bordering on +the eastern shores of Asia, and lying adjacent to the vast and opulent +regions depicted in such golden colors by Mandeville and the Poli. This +conjecture, which was conformable to the admiral's opinions before +undertaking the voyage, was corroborated by the apparent similarity +between various natural productions of these islands, and of the east. +From this misapprehension, the new dominions soon came to be distinguished +as the West Indies, an appellation by which they are still recognized in +the titles of the Spanish. crown. [13] + +Columbus, during his residence at Barcelona, continued to receive from the +Spanish sovereigns the most honorable distinctions which royal bounty +could confer. When Ferdinand rode abroad, he was accompanied by the +admiral at his side. The courtiers, in emulation of their master, made +frequent entertainments, at which he was treated with the punctilious +deference paid to a noble of the highest class. [14] But the attentions +most grateful to his lofty spirit were the preparations of the Spanish +court for prosecuting his discoveries, on a scale commensurate with their +importance. A board was established for the direction of Indian affairs, +consisting of a superintendent and two subordinate functionaries. The +first of these officers was Juan de Fonseca, archdeacon of Seville, an +active, ambitious prelate, subsequently raised to high episcopal +preferment, whose shrewdness, and capacity for business, enabled him to +maintain the control of the Indian department during the whole of the +present reign. An office for the transaction of business was instituted at +Seville, and a custom-house placed under its direction at Cadiz. This was +the origin of the important establishment of the _Casa de la Contratacion +de las Indias_, or India House. [15] + +The commercial regulations adopted exhibit a narrow policy in some of +their features, for which a justification may be found in the spirit of +the age, and in the practice of the Portuguese particularly, but which +entered still more largely into the colonial legislation of Spain under +later princes. The new territories, far from being permitted free +intercourse with foreign nations, were opened only under strict +limitations to Spanish subjects, and were reserved, as forming, in some +sort, part of the exclusive revenue of the crown. All persons of whatever +description were interdicted, under the severest penalties, from trading +with, or even visiting the Indies, without license from the constituted +authorities. It was impossible to evade this, as a minute specification of +the ships; cargoes, crews, with the property appertaining to each +individual, was required to be taken at the office in Cadiz, and a +corresponding registration in a similar office established at Hispaniola. +A more sagacious spirit was manifested in the ample provision made of +whatever could contribute to the support or permanent prosperity of the +infant colony. Grain, plants, the seeds of numerous vegetable products, +which in the genial climate of the Indies might be made valuable articles +for domestic consumption or export, were liberally furnished. Commodities +of every description for the supply of the fleet were exempted from duty. +The owners of all vessels throughout the ports of Andalusia were required, +by an ordinance somewhat arbitrary, to hold them in readiness for the +expedition. Still further authority was given to impress both officers and +men, if necessary, into the service. Artisans of every sort, provided with +the implements of their various crafts, including a great number of miners +for exploring the subterraneous treasures of the new regions, were +enrolled in the expedition; in order to defray the heavy charges of which, +the government, in addition to the regular resources, had recourse to a +loan, and to the sequestrated property of the exiled Jews. [16] + +Amid their own temporal concerns, the Spanish sovereigns did not forget +the spiritual interests of their new subjects. The Indians, who +accompanied Columbus to Barcelona, had been all of them baptized, being +offered up, in the language of a Castilian writer, as the first-fruits of +the gentiles. King Ferdinand, and his son, Prince John, stood as sponsors +to two of them, who were permitted to take their names. One of the Indians +remained attached to the prince's establishment; the residue were sent to +Seville, whence, after suitable religious instruction, they were to be +returned as missionaries for the propagation of the faith among their own +countrymen. Twelve Spanish ecclesiastics were also destined to this +service; among whom was the celebrated Las Casas, so conspicuous +afterwards for his benevolent exertions in behalf of the unfortunate +natives. The most explicit directions were given to the admiral, to use +every effort for the illumination of the poor heathen, which was set forth +as the primary object of the expedition. He was particularly enjoined "to +abstain from all means of annoyance, and to treat them well and lovingly, +maintaining a familiar intercourse with them, rendering them all the kind +offices in his power, distributing presents of the merchandise and various +commodities, which their Highnesses had caused to be embarked on board the +fleet for that purpose; and finally, to chastise, in the most exemplary +manner, all who should offer the natives the slightest molestation." Such +were the instructions emphatically urged on Columbus for the regulation of +his intercourse with the savages; and their indulgent tenor sufficiently +attests the benevolent and rational views of Isabella, in religious +matters, when not warped by any foreign influence. [17] + +Towards the last of May, Columbus quitted Barcelona for the purpose of +superintending and expediting the preparations for departure on his second +voyage. He was accompanied to the gates of the city by all the nobility +and cavaliers of the court. Orders were issued to the different towns to +provide him and his suite with lodgings free of expense. His former +commission was not only confirmed in its full extent, but considerably +enlarged. For the sake of despatch, he was authorized to nominate to all +offices, without application to government; and ordinances and letters +patent, bearing the royal seal, were to be issued by him, subscribed by +himself or his deputy. He was intrusted, in fine, with such unlimited +jurisdiction, as showed, that, however tardy the sovereigns may have been +in granting him their confidence, they were not disposed to stint the +measure of it, when his deserts were once established. [18] + +Soon after Columbus's return to Spain, Ferdinand and Isabella applied to +the court of Rome, to confirm them in the possession of their recent +discoveries, and invest them with similar extent of jurisdiction with that +formerly conferred on the kings of Portugal. It was an opinion, as ancient +perhaps as the crusades, that the pope, as vicar of Christ, had competent +authority to dispose of all countries inhabited by heathen nations, in +favor of Christian potentates. Although Ferdinand and Isabella do not seem +to have been fully satisfied of this right, yet they were willing to +acquiesce in its assumption in the present instance, from the conviction +that the papal sanction would most effectually exclude the pretensions of +all others, and especially their Portuguese rivals. In their application +to the Holy See, they were careful to represent their own discoveries as +in no way interfering with the rights formerly conceded by it to their +neighbors. They enlarged on their services in the propagation of the +faith, which they affirmed to be a principal motive of their present +operations. They intimated, finally, that, although many competent persons +deemed their application to the court of Rome, for a title to territories +already in their possession, to be unnecessary, yet, as pious princes, and +dutiful children of the church, they were unwilling to proceed further +without the sanction of him, to whose keeping its highest interests were +intrusted. [19] + +The pontifical throne was at that time filled by Alexander the Sixth; a +man who, although degraded by unrestrained indulgence of the most sordid +appetites, was endowed by nature with singular acuteness, as well as +energy of character. He lent a willing ear to the application of the +Spanish government, and made no hesitation in granting what cost him +nothing, while it recognized the assumption of powers, which had already +begun to totter in the opinion of mankind. + +On the 3d of May, 1493, he published a bull, in which, taking into +consideration the eminent services of the Spanish monarchs in the cause of +the church, especially in the subversion of the Mahometan empire in Spain, +and willing to afford still wider scope for the prosecution of their pious +labors, he, "out of his pure liberality, infallible knowledge, and +plenitude of apostolic power," confirmed them in the possession of all +lands discovered or hereafter to be discovered by them in the western +ocean, comprehending the same extensive rights of jurisdiction with those +formerly conceded to the kings of Portugal. + +This bull he supported by another, dated on the following day, in which +the pope, in order to obviate any misunderstanding with the Portuguese, +and acting no doubt on the suggestion of the Spanish sovereigns, defined +with greater precision the intention of his original grant to the latter, +by bestowing on them all such lands as they should discover to the west +and south of an imaginary line, to be drawn from pole to pole, at the +distance of one hundred leagues to the west of the Azores and Cape de Verd +Islands. [20] It seems to have escaped his Holiness, that the Spaniards, +by pursuing a western route, might in time reach the eastern limits of +countries previously granted to the Portuguese. At least this would appear +from the import of a third bull, issued September 25th of the same year, +which invested the sovereigns with plenary authority over all countries +discovered by them, whether in the east, or within the boundaries of +India, all previous concessions to the contrary notwithstanding. With the +title derived from actual possession, thus fortified by the highest +ecclesiastical sanction, the Spaniards might have promised themselves an +uninterrupted career of discovery, but for the jealousy of their rivals, +the Portuguese. [21] + +The court of Lisbon viewed with secret disquietude the increasing maritime +enterprise of its neighbors. While the Portuguese were timidly creeping +along the barren shores of Africa, the Spaniards had boldly launched into +the deep, and rescued unknown realms from its embraces, which teemed in +their fancies with treasures of inestimable wealth. Their mortification +was greatly enhanced by the reflection, that all this might have been +achieved for themselves, had they but known how to profit by the proposals +of Columbus. [22] From the first moment in which the success of the +admiral's enterprise was established, John the Second, a politic and +ambitious prince, had sought some pretence to check the career of +discovery, or at least to share in the spoils of it. [23] + +In his interview with Columbus, at Lisbon, he suggested, that the +discoveries of the Spaniards might interfere with the rights secured to +the Portuguese by repeated papal sanctions since the beginning of the +present century, and guaranteed by the treaty with Spain, in 1479. +Columbus, without entering into the discussion, contented himself with +declaring, that he had been instructed by his own government to steer +clear of all Portuguese settlements on the African coast, and that his +course indeed had led him in an entirely different direction. Although +John professed himself satisfied with the explanation, he soon after +despatched an ambassador to Barcelona, who, after dwelling on some +irrelevant topics, touched, as it were, incidentally on the real object of +his mission, the late voyage of discovery. He congratulated the Spanish +sovereigns on its success; expatiated on the civilities shown by the court +of Lisbon to Columbus, on his late arrival there; and acknowledged the +satisfaction felt by his master at the orders given to the admiral, to +hold a western course from the Canaries, expressing a hope that the same +course would be pursued in future, without interfering with the rights of +Portugal by deviation to the south. This was the first occasion, on which +the existence of such claims had been intimated by the Portuguese. + +In the mean while, Ferdinand and Isabella received intelligence that King +John was equipping a considerable armament in order to anticipate or +defeat their discoveries in the west. They instantly sent one of their +household, Don Lope de Herrera, as ambassador to Lisbon, with instructions +to make their acknowledgments to the king for his hospitable reception of +Columbus, accompanied with a request that he would prohibit his subjects +from interference with the discoveries of the Spaniards in the west, in +the same manner as these latter had been excluded from the Portuguese +possessions in Africa. The ambassador was furnished with orders of a +different import, provided he should find the reports correct, respecting +the equipment and probable destination of a Portuguese armada. Instead of +a conciliatory deportment, he was, in that case, to assume a tone of +remonstrance, and to demand a full explanation from King John, of his +designs. The cautious prince, who had received, through his secret agents +in Castile, intelligence of these latter instructions, managed matters so +discreetly as to give no occasion for their exercise. He abandoned, or at +least postponed, his meditated expedition, in the hope of adjusting the +dispute by negotiation, in which he excelled. In order to quiet the +apprehensions of the Spanish court, he engaged to fit out no fleet from +his dominions within sixty days; at the same time he sent a fresh mission +to Barcelona, with directions to propose an amicable adjustment of the +conflicting claims of the two nations, by making the parallel of the +Canaries a line of partition between them; the right of discovery to the +north being reserved to the Spaniards, and that to the south to the +Portuguese. [24] + +While this game of diplomacy was going on, the Castilian court availed +itself of the interval afforded by its rival, to expedite preparations for +the second voyage of discovery; which, through the personal activity of +the admiral, and the facilities everywhere afforded him, were fully +completed before the close of September. Instead of the reluctance, and +indeed avowed disgust, which had been manifested by all classes to his +former voyage, the only embarrassment now arose from the difficulty of +selection among the multitude of competitors, who pressed to be enrolled +in the present expedition. The reports and sanguine speculations of the +first adventurers had inflamed the cupidity of many, which was still +further heightened by the exhibition of the rich and curious products +which Columbus had brought back with him, and by the popular belief that +the new discoveries formed part of that gorgeous east, + + "whose caverns teem + With diamond flaming, and with seeds of gold," + +and which tradition and romance had alike invested with the supernatural +splendors of enchantment. Many others were stimulated by the wild love of +adventure, kindled in the long Moorish war, but which, now excluded from +that career, sought other objects in the vast, untravelled regions of the +New World. The complement of the fleet was originally fixed at twelve +hundred souls, which, through importunity or various pretences of the +applicants, was eventually swelled to fifteen hundred. Among these were +many who enlisted without compensation, including several persons of rank, +hidalgos, and members of the royal household. The whole squadron amounted +to seventeen vessels, three of them of one hundred tons' burden each. With +this gallant navy, Columbus, dropping down the Guadalquivir, took his +departure from the bay of Cadiz, on the 25th of September, 1493; +presenting a striking contrast to the melancholy plight, in which, but the +year previous, he sallied forth like some forlorn knight-errant, on a +desperate and chimerical enterprise. [25] + +No sooner had the fleet weighed anchor, than Ferdinand and Isabella +despatched an embassy in solemn state to advise the king of Portugal of +it. This embassy was composed of two persons of distinguished rank, Don +Pedro de Ayala, and Don Garci Lopez de Carbajal. Agreeably to their +instructions, they represented to the Portuguese monarch the +inadmissibility of his propositions respecting the boundary line of +navigation; they argued that the grants of the Holy See, and the treaty +with Spain in 1479, had reference merely to the actual possessions of +Portugal, and the right of discovery by an eastern route along the coasts +of Africa to the Indies; that these rights had been invariably respected +by Spain; that the late voyage of Columbus struck into a directly opposite +track; and that the several bulls of Pope Alexander the Sixth, prescribing +the line of partition, not from east to west, but from the north to the +south pole, were intended to secure to the Spaniards the exclusive right +of discovery in the western ocean. The ambassadors concluded with +offering, in the name of their sovereigns, to refer the whole matter in +dispute to the arbitration of the court of Rome, or of any common umpire. + +King John was deeply chagrined at learning the departure of the Spanish +expedition. He saw that his rivals had been acting while he had been +amused with negotiation. He at first threw out hints of an immediate +rupture; and endeavored, it is said, to intimidate the Castilian +ambassadors, by bringing them accidentally, as it were, in presence of a +splendid array of cavalry, mounted and ready for immediate service. He +vented his spleen on the embassy, by declaring, that "it was a mere +abortion; having neither head nor feet;" alluding to the personal +infirmity of Ayala, who was lame, and to the light, frivolous character of +the other envoy. [26] + +These symptoms of discontent were duly notified to the Spanish government; +who commanded the superintendent, Fonseca, to keep a vigilant eye on the +movements of the Portuguese, and, in case any hostile armament should quit +their ports, to be in readiness to act against it with one double its +force. King John, however, was too shrewd a prince to be drawn into so +impolitic a measure as war with a powerful adversary, quite as likely to +baffle him in the field, as in the council. Neither did he relish the +suggestion of deciding the dispute by arbitration; since he well knew, +that his claim rested on too unsound a basis, to authorize the expectation +of a favorable award from any impartial umpire. He had already failed in +an application for redress to the court of Rome, which answered him by +reference to its bulls, recently published. In this emergency, he came to +the resolution at last, which should have been first adopted, of deciding +the matter by a fair and open conference. It was not until the following +year, however, that his discontent so far subsided as to allow his +acquiescence in this measure. + +At length, commissioners named by the two crowns convened at Tordesillas, +and on the 7th of June, 1494, subscribed articles of agreement, which were +ratified, in the course of the same year, by the respective powers. In +this treaty, the Spaniards were secured in the exclusive right of +navigation and discovery in the western ocean. At the urgent remonstrance +of the Portuguese, however, who complained that the papal line of +demarcation cooped up their enterprises within too narrow limits, they +consented, that instead of one hundred, it should be removed three hundred +and seventy leagues west of the Cape de Verd islands, beyond which all +discoveries should appertain to the Spanish nation. It was agreed that one +or two caravels should be provided by each nation, to meet at the Grand +Canary, and proceed due west, the appointed distance, with a number of +scientific men on board, for the purpose of accurately determining the +longitude; and if any lands should fall under the meridian, the direction +of the line should be ascertained by the erection of beacons at suitable +distances. The proposed meeting never took place. But the removal of the +partition line was followed by important consequences to the Portuguese, +who derived from it their pretensions to the noble empire of Brazil. [27] + +Thus this singular misunderstanding, which menaced an open rupture at one +time, was happily adjusted. Fortunately, the accomplishment of the passage +round the Cape of Good Hope, which occurred soon afterwards, led the +Portuguese in an opposite direction to their Spanish rivals, their +Brazilian possessions having too little attractions, at first, to turn +them from the splendid path of discovery thrown open in the east. It was +not many years, however, before the two nations, by pursuing opposite +routes of circumnavigation, were brought into collision on the other side +of the globe; a circumstance never contemplated, apparently, by the treaty +of Tordesillas. Their mutual pretensions were founded, however, on the +provisions of that treaty, which, as the reader is aware, was itself only +supplementary to the original bull of demarcation of Alexander the Sixth. +[28] + +Thus this bold stretch of papal authority, so often ridiculed as +chimerical and absurd, was in a measure justified by the event, since it +did, in fact, determine the principles on which the vast extent of +unappropriated empire in the eastern and western hemispheres was +ultimately divided between two petty states of Europe. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Zurita, Anales, tom. v. fol. 13.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, +quinc. 1, dial. 28. + +[2] Zurita, Anales, tom. v. fol. 15.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., +cap. 116.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. pp. 678, 679.--Abarca, Reyes de +Aragon, tom. ii. fol. 315.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1492.--Oviedo, +Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 4, dial. 9. + +[3] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 125.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, +MS., cap. 116.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, ubi supra. + +The great bell of Velilla, whose miraculous tolling always announced some +disaster to the monarchy, was heard to strike at the time of this assault +on Ferdinand, being the fifth time since the subversion of the kingdom by +the Moors. The fourth was on the assassination of the inquisitor Arbues. +All which is established by a score of good orthodox witnesses, as +reported by Dr. Diego Dormer, in his Discursos Varies, pp. 206, 207. + +[4] L. Marineo, Cosas Memorables, fol. 136.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., +epist. 125, 127, 131.--Zurita, Anales, tom. v. fol. 16.--Bernaldez, Reyes +Católicos, MS., loc. cit.--Garibay, after harrowing the reader's feelings +with half a column of inhuman cruelties inflicted on the miserable man, +concludes with the comfortable assurance, "Pero abogaronle primero por +clemencia y misericordia de la Reyna." (Compendio, tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. +1.) + +A letter written by Isabella to her confessor, Fernando de Talavera, +during her husband's illness, shows the deep anxiety of her own mind, as +well as that of the citizens of Barcelona, at his critical situation, +furnishing abundant evidence, if it were needed, of her tenderness of +heart, and the warmth of her conjugal attachment. See Correspondencia +Epistolar, apud Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 13. + +[5] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 2, cap. 3.--Muñoz, Hist. +del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 4, sect. 13, 14. + +Columbus concludes a letter addressed, on his arrival at Lisbon, to the +treasurer Sanchez, in the following glowing terms; "Let processions be +made, festivals held, temples be filled with branches and flowers, for +Christ rejoices on earth as in Heaven, seeing the future redemption of +souls. Let us rejoice, also, for the temporal benefit likely to result, +not merely to Spain, but to all Christendom." See Primer Viage de Colon, +apud Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i. + +[6] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, tom. i. dec. 1, lib. 2, cap. 2.--Primer +Viage de Colon, apud Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i.--Fernando +Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 39. + +The Portuguese historian, Faria y Sousa, appears to be nettled at the +prosperous issue of the voyage; for he testily remarks, that "the admiral +entered Lisbon with a vainglorious exultation, in order to make Portugal +feel, by displaying the tokens of his discovery, how much she had erred in +not acceding to his propositions." Europa Portuguesa, tom. ii. pp. 462, +463. + +[7] My learned friend, Mr. John Pickering, has pointed out to me a passage +in a Portuguese author, giving some particulars of Columbus's visit to +Portugal. The passage, which I have not seen noticed by any writer, is +extremely interesting, coming, as it does, from a person high in the royal +confidence, and an eye-witness of what he relates. "In the year 1493, on +the sixth day of March, arrived in Lisbon Christopher Columbus, an +Italian, who came from the discovery, made under the authority of the +sovereigns of Castile, of the islands of Cipango and Antilia; from which +countries he brought with him the first specimens of the people, as well +as of the gold and other things to be found there; and he was entitled +admiral of them. The king, being forthwith informed of this, commanded him +into his presence; and appeared to be annoyed and vexed, as well from the +belief that the said discovery was made within the seas and boundaries of +his seigniory of Guinea,--which might give rise to disputes,--as because +the said admiral, having become somewhat haughty by his situation, and in +the relation of his adventures always exceeding the bounds of truth, made +this affair, as to gold, silver, and riches, much greater than it was. +Especially did the king accuse himself of negligence, in having declined +this enterprise, when Columbus first came to ask his assistance, from want +of credit and confidence in it. And, notwithstanding the king was +importuned to kill kim on the spot; since with his death the prosecution +of the undertaking, so far as the sovereigns of Castile were concerned, +would cease, from want of a suitable person to take charge of it; and +notwithstanding this might be done without suspicion of the king's being +privy to it,--for inasmuch as the admiral was overbearing and puffed up by +his success, they could easily bring it about, that his own indiscretion +should appear the occasion of his death,--yet the king, as he was a prince +greatly fearing God, not only forbade this, but even showed the, admiral +honor and much favor, and therewith dismissed him." Ruy de Pina, Chronica +d'el Rei Dom Joaõ II., cap. 66, apud Collecçaõ de Livros Ineditos de +Historia Portugueza, (Lisboa, 1790-93,) tom. ii. + +[8] Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 40, 41.--Charlevoix, +Histoire de S. Domingue, (Paris, 1730,) tom. i. pp. 84-90.--Primer Viage +de Colon, apud Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i.--La Clède, Hist. de +Portugal, tom. iv. pp. 53-58. + +Columbus sailed from Spain on Friday, discovered land on Friday, and re- +entered the port of Palos on Friday. These curious coincidences should +have sufficed, one might think, to dispel, especially with American +mariners, the superstitions dread, still so prevalent, of commencing a +voyage on that ominous day. + +[9] Primer Viage de Colon, Let 2. + +[10] Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 4, sec. 14.--Fernando Colon, Hist. +del Almirante, cap. 41. + +Among other specimens, was a lump of gold, of sufficient magnitude to be +fashioned into a vessel for containing the host; "thus," says Salazar de +Mendoza, "converting the first fruits of the new dominions to pious uses." +Monarquía, pp. 351, 352. + +[11] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 133, 134, 140.--Bernaldez, Reyes +Católicos, MS., cap. 118.--Ferreras, Hist. d'Espagne, tom. viii. pp. 141, +142.--Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, ubi supra.--Zuñiga, Annales de +Sevilla, p. 413.--Gomara, Hist. de las Indias, cap. 17.--Benzoni, Novi +Orbis Hist., lib. 1, cap. 8, 9.--Gallo, apud Muratori, Rerum Ital. +Script., tom. xxiii. p. 203. + +[12] Herrera, Indias Occidental., tom. i. dec. 1, lib. 2, cap. 3.--Muñoz, +Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 4, sec. 15, 16, 17.--Fernando Colon, Hist. del +Almirante, ubi supra. + +[12] In a letter, written soon after the admiral's return, Martyr +announces the discovery to his correspondent, Cardinal Sforza, in the +following manner. "Mira res ex eo terrarum orbe, quem sol horarum quatuor +et viginti spatio circuit, ad nostra usque tempora, quod minime te latet, +trita cognitaque dimidia taptum pars, ab Aurea utpote Chersoneso, ad Gades +nostras Hispanas, reliqua vero a cosmographis pro incognitâ relicta est. +Et si quae mentio facta, ea tenuis et incerta. Nunc autem, o beatum +facinus! meorum regum auspiciis, quod latuit hactenus a rerum primordio, +intelligi coeptum est." In a subsequent epistle to the learned Pomponio +Leto, he breaks out in a strain of warm and generous sentiment. "Prae +laetitia prosiliisse te, vixque a lachrymis prae gaudio temperasse, quando +literas adspexisti meas, quibus de Antipodum Orbe latenti hactenus, te +certiorem feci, mi suavissime Pomponi, insinuasti. Ex tuis ipse literis +colligo, quid senseris. Sensisti autem, tantique rem fecisti, quanti virum +summâ doctrinâ insignitum decuit. Quis namque cibus sublimibus praestari +potest ingeniis isto suavior? quod condimentum gravius? a me facio +conjecturam. Beari sentio spiritus meos, quando accitos alloquor prudentes +aliquos ex his qui ab eâ redeunt provinciâ. Implicent animos pecuniarum +cumulis augendis miseri avari, libidinibus obscoeni; noetras nos mentes, +postquam Deo pleni aliquandiu fuerimus, contemplando, hujuscemodi rerum +notitiâ demulceamus." Opus Epist., epist. 124, 152. + +[13] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 118.--Gallo, apud Muratori, +Rerum Ital. Script., tom. xxiii. p. 203.--Gomara, Hist. de las Indias, +cap. 18. + +Peter Martyr seems to have received the popular inference, respecting the +identity of the new discoveries with the East Indies, with some distrust. +"Insulas reperit plures; has esse, de quibus fit apud cosmographos mentio +extra Oceanum Orientalem, adjacentes Indiae arbitrantur. Nec inficior ego +penitus, quamvis sphaerae magnitudo aliter sentire videatur; neque enim +desunt qui parvo tractu a finibus Hispanis distare littus Indicum, +putent." Opus Epist., epist. 135. + +[14] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 2, cap. 3.--Benzoni, Novi +Orbis Hist., lib. 1, cap. 8.--Gomara, Hist. de las Indias, cap. 17.-- +Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, p. 413.--Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, +ubi supra. + +He was permitted to quarter the royal arms with his own, which consisted +of a group of golden islands amid azure billows. To these were afterwards +added five anchors, with the celebrated motto, well known as being carved +on his sepulchre. (See Part II. Chap. 18.) He received besides, soon after +his return, the substantial gratuity of a thousand doblas of gold, from +the royal treasury, and the premium of 10,000 maravedies, promised to the +person who first descried land. See Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, Col. +Diplom., nos. 20, 32, 38. + +[15] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii. Col. Diplom., no. 45.-- +Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 4, sec. 21. + +[16] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, Col. Diplom., nos. 33, 35, 45.-- +Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 2, cap. 4.--Muñoz, Hist. del +Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 4, sec. 21. + +[17] See the original instructions, apud Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, +Col. Diplom., no. 45.--Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 4, sec. 22.-- +Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, p. 413. + +L. Marineo eagerly claims the conversion of the natives, as the prime +object of the expedition with the sovereigns, far outweighing all temporal +considerations. The passage is worth quoting, if only to show what +egregious blunders a contemporary may make in the relation of events +passing, as it were, under his own eyes. "The Catholic sovereigns having +subjugated the Canaries, and established Christian worship there, sent +_Peter Colon_, with _thirty-five_ ships, called caravels, and _a great +number of men_ to other much larger islands abounding in mines of gold, +not so much, however, for the sake of the gold, as for the salvation of +the poor heathen natives." Cosas Memorables, fol. 161. + +[18] See copies of the original documents, apud Navarrete, Coleccion de +Viages, tom. ii., Col. Diplom., nos. 39, 41, 42, 43. + +[19] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 2, cap. 4.--Muñoz, Hist. +del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 4, sec. 18. + +[20] A point south of the meridian is something new in geometry; yet so +says the bull of his Holiness. "Omnes insulas et terras firmas inventas et +inveniendas, detectas et detegendas, versus Occidentem et meridiem, +fabricando et constituendo unam lineam a Polo Arctico, scilicet +septentrione, ad Polum Antarcticum, scilicet meridiem." + +[21] See the original papal grants, transcribed by Navarrete, Coleccion de +Viages, tom. ii., Col. Diplom., nos. 17, 18. Appendice al Col. Diplom., +no. 11. + +[22] Padre Abarca considers "that the discovery of a new world, first +offered to the kings of Portugal and England, was reserved by Heaven for +Spain, being forced, in a manner, on Ferdinand, in recompense for the +subjugation of the Moors, and the expulsion of the Jews!" Reyes de Aragon, +fol. 310, 311. + +[23] La Clède, Hist. de Portugal, tom. iv. pp. 53-58. + +[24] Faria y Sousa, Europa Portuguesa, tom. ii. p. 463.--Herrera, Indias +Occidentales, loc. cit.--Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 4, sec. 27, +28.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. pp. 606, 607.--La Clède, Hist. de +Portugal, tom. iv. pp. 53-58. + +[25] Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, p. 413.--Fernando Colon, Hist. del +Almirante, cap. 44.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 118.--Peter +Martyr, De Rebus Oceanicis, dec. 1, lib. 1.--Benzoni, Novi Orbis Historia, +lib. 1, cap. 9.--Gomara, Hist. de las Indias, cap. 20. + +[26] La Clède, Hist. de Portugal, tom. iv. pp. 53-58.--Muñoz, Hist. del +Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 4, sec. 27, 28. + +[27] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, Doc. Diplom., no. 75.--Faria y Sousa, +Europa Portuguesa, tom. ii. p. 463.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, +lib. 2, cap. 8, 10.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. pp. 606, 607.--La +Clède, Hist. de Portugal, tom. iv. pp. 60-62.--Zurita, Anales, tom. v. +fol. 31. + +[28] The contested territory was the Molucca Islands, which each party +claimed for itself, by virtue of the treaty of Tordesillas. After more +than one congress, in which all the cosmographical science of the day was +put in requisition, the affair was terminated _à l'amiable_ by the Spanish +government's relinquishing its pretensions, in consideration of 350,000 +ducats, paid by the court of Lisbon. See La Clède, Hist. De Portugal, tom. +iv. pp. 309, 401, 402, 480.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. pp. 607, +875.--Salazar de Mendoza, Monarquía, tom. ii. pp. 205, 206. + + + + +CHAPTER XIX. + +CASTILIAN LITERATURE.--CULTIVATION OF THE COURT.--CLASSICAL LEARNING.-- +SCIENCE. + +Early Education of Ferdinand.--Of Isabella.--Her Library.--Early Promise +of Prince John.--Scholarship of the Nobles.--Accomplished Women.-- +Classical Learning.--Universities.--Printing Introduced.--Encouraged by +the Queen.--Actual Progress of Science. + + +We have now arrived at the period, when the history of Spain becomes +incorporated with that of the other states of Europe. Before embarking on +the wide sea of European politics, however, and bidding adieu, for a +season, to the shores of Spain, it will be necessary, in order to complete +the view of the internal administration of Ferdinand and Isabella, to show +its operation on the intellectual culture of the nation. This, as it +constitutes, when taken in its broadest sense, a principal end of all +government, should never be altogether divorced from any history. It is +particularly deserving of note in the present reign, which stimulated the +active development of the national energies in every department of +science, and which forms a leading epoch in the ornamental literature of +the country. The present and the following chapter will embrace the mental +progress of the kingdom, not merely down to the period at which we have +arrived, but through the whole of Isabella's reign, in order to exhibit as +far as possible its entire results, at a single glance, to the eye of the +reader. + +We have beheld, in a preceding chapter, the auspicious literary promise +afforded by the reign of Isabella's father, John the Second, of Castile. +Under the anarchical sway of his son, Henry the Fourth, the court, as we +have seen, was abandoned to unbounded license, and the whole nation sunk +into a mental torpor, from which it was roused only by the tumults of +civil war. In this deplorable state of things, the few blossoms of +literature, which had begun to open under the benign influence of the +preceding reign, were speedily trampled under foot, and every vestige of +civilization seemed in a fair way to be effaced from the land. + +The first years of Ferdinand and Isabella's government were too much +clouded by civil dissensions, to afford a much more cheering prospect. +Ferdinand's early education, moreover, had been greatly neglected. Before +the age of ten, he was called to take part in the Catalan wars. His +boyhood was spent among soldiers, in camps instead of schools, and the +wisdom which he so eminently displayed in later life, was drawn far more +from his own resources, than from books. [1] + +Isabella was reared under more favorable auspices; at least more favorable +to mental culture. She was allowed to pass her youth in retirement, and +indeed oblivion, as far as the world was concerned, under her mother's +care, at Arevalo. In this modest seclusion, free from the engrossing +vanities and vexations of court life, she had full leisure to indulge the +habits of study and reflection to which her temper naturally disposed her. +She was acquainted with several modern languages, and both wrote and +discoursed in her own with great precision and elegance. No great expense +or solicitude, however, appears to have been lavished on her education. +She was uninstructed in the Latin, which in that day was of greater +importance than at present; since it was not only the common medium of +communication between learned men, and the language in which the most +familiar treatises were often composed, but was frequently used by well- +educated foreigners at court, and especially employed in diplomatic +intercourse and negotiation. [2] + +Isabella resolved to repair the defects of education, by devoting herself +to the acquisition of the Latin tongue, so soon as the distracting wars +with Portugal, which attended her accession, were terminated. We have a +letter from Pulgar, addressed to the queen soon after that event, in which +he inquires concerning her progress, intimating his surprise, that she can +find time for study amidst her multitude of engrossing occupations, and +expressing his confidence that she will acquire the Latin with the same +facility with which she had already mastered other languages. The result +justified his prediction; for "in less than a year," observes another +contemporary, "her admirable genius enabled her to obtain a good knowledge +of the Latin language, so that she could understand without much +difficulty whatever was written or spoken in it." [3] + +Isabella inherited the taste of her father, John the Second, for the +collecting of books. She endowed the convent of San Juan de los Reyes at +Toledo, at the time of its foundation, 1477, with a library consisting +principally of manuscripts. [4] The archives of Simancas contain +catalogues of part of two separate collections, belonging to her, whose +broken remains have contributed to swell the magnificent library of the +Escurial. Most of them are in manuscript; the richly colored and highly +decorated binding of these volumes (an art which the Spaniards derived +from the Arabs) show how highly they were prized, and the worn and +battered condition of some of them prove that they were not kept merely +for show. [5] + +The queen manifested the most earnest solicitude for the instruction of +her own children. Her daughters were endowed by nature with amiable +dispositions, that seconded her maternal efforts. The most competent +masters, native and foreign, especially from Italy, then so active in the +revival of ancient learning, were employed in their tuition. This was +particularly intrusted to two brothers, Antonio and Alessandro Geraldino, +natives of that country. Both were conspicuous for their abilities and +classical erudition, and the latter, who survived his brother Antonio, was +subsequently raised to high ecclesiastical preferments. [6] Under these +masters, the infantas made attainments rarely permitted to the sex, and +acquired such familiarity with the Latin tongue especially, as excited +lively admiration among those over whom they were called to preside in +riper years. [7] + +A still deeper anxiety was shown in the education of her only son, Prince +John, heir of the united Spanish monarchies. Every precaution was taken to +train him up in a manner that might tend to the formation of the character +suited to his exalted station. He was placed in a class consisting of ten +youths, selected from the sons of the principal nobility. Five of them +were of his own age, and five of riper years, and they were all brought to +reside with him in the palace. By this means it was hoped to combine the +advantages of public with those of private education; which last, from its +solitary character, necessarily excludes the subject of it from the +wholesome influence exerted by bringing the powers into daily collision +with antagonists of a similar age. [8] + +A mimic council was also formed on the model of a council of state, +composed of suitable persons of more advanced standing, whose province it +was to deliberate on, and to discuss, topics connected with government and +public policy. Over this body the prince presided, and here he was +initiated into a practical acquaintance with the important duties, which +were to devolve on him at a future period of life. The pages, in +attendance on his person, were also selected with great care from the +cavaliers and young nobility of the court, many of whom afterwards filled +with credit the most considerable posts in the state. The severer +discipline of the prince was relieved by attention to more light and +elegant accomplishments. He devoted many of his leisure hours to music, +for which he had a fine natural taste, and in which he attained sufficient +proficiency to perform with skill on a variety of instruments. In short, +his education was happily designed to produce that combination of mental +and moral excellence, which should fit him for reigning over his subjects +with benevolence and wisdom. How well the scheme succeeded is abundantly +attested by the commendations of contemporary writers, both at home and +abroad, who enlarge on his fondness for letters, and for the society of +learned men, on his various attainments, and more especially his Latin +scholarship, and above all on his disposition, so amiable as to give +promise of the highest excellence in maturer life,--a promise, alas! most +unfortunately for his own nation, destined never to be realized. [9] + +Next to her family, there was no object which the queen had so much at +heart, as the improvement of the young nobility. During the troubled reign +of her predecessor, they had abandoned themselves to frivolous pleasure, +or to a sullen apathy, from which nothing was potent enough to arouse +them, but the voice of war. [10] She was obliged to relinquish her plans +of amelioration, during the all-engrossing struggle with Granada, when it +would have been esteemed a reproach for a Spanish knight to have exchanged +the post of danger in the field for the effeminate pursuit of letters. But +no sooner was the war brought to a close, than Isabella resumed her +purpose. She requested the learned Peter Martyr, who had come into Spain +with the count of Tendilla, a few years previous, to repair to the court, +and open a school there for the instruction of the young nobility. [11] In +an epistle addressed by Martyr to Cardinal Mendoza, dated at Granada, +April, 1492, he alludes to the promise of a liberal recompense from the +queen, if he would assist in reclaiming the young cavaliers of the court +from the idle and unprofitable pursuits, in which, to her great +mortification, they consumed their hours. The prejudices to be encountered +seem to have filled him with natural distrust of his success; for he +remarks, "Like their ancestors, they hold the pursuit of letters in light +estimation, considering them an obstacle to success in the profession of +arms, which alone they esteem worthy of honor." He however expresses his +confidence, that the generous nature of the Spaniards will make it easy to +infuse into them a more liberal taste; and, in a subsequent letter, he +enlarges on the "good effects likely to result from the literary ambition +exhibited by the heir apparent, on whom the eyes of the nation were +naturally turned." [12] Martyr, in obedience to the royal summons, +instantly repaired to court, and in the month of September following, we +have a letter dated from Saragossa, in which he thus speaks of his +success. "My house, all day long, swarms with noble youths, who, reclaimed +from ignoble pursuits to those of letters, are now convinced that these, +so far from being a hindrance, are rather a help in the profession of +arms. I earnestly inculcate on them, that consummate excellence in any +department, whether of war or peace, is unattainable without science. It +has pleased our royal mistress, the pattern of every exalted virtue, that +her own near kinsman, the duke of Guimaraena, as well as the young duke of +Villahermosa, the king's nephew, should remain under my roof during the +whole day; an example which has been imitated by the principal cavaliers +of the court, who, after attending my lectures in company with their +private tutors, retire at evening to review them with these latter in +their own quarters." [13] Another Italian scholar, often cited as +authority in the preceding portion of this work, Lucio Marineo Siculo, co- +operated with Martyr in the introduction of a more liberal scholarship +among the Castilian nobles. He was born at Bedino in Sicily, and, after +completing his studies at Rome under the celebrated Pomponio Leto, opened +a school in his native island, where he continued to teach for five years. +He was then induced to visit Spain, in 1486, with the admiral Henriquez, +and soon took his place among the professors of Salamanca, where he filled +the chairs of poetry and grammar with great applause for twelve years. He +was subsequently transferred to the court, which he helped to illumine, by +his exposition of the ancient classics, particularly the Latin. [14] Under +the auspices of these and other eminent scholars, both native and foreign, +the young nobility of Castile shook off the indolence in which they had so +long rusted, and applied with generous ardor to the cultivation of +science; so that, in the language of a contemporary, "while it was a most +rare occurrence, to meet with a person of illustrious birth, before the +present reign, who had even studied Latin in his youth, there were now to +be seen numbers every day, who sought to shed the lustre of letters over +the martial glory inherited from their ancestors." [15] + +The extent of this generous emulation may be gathered from the large +correspondence both of Martyr and Marineo with their disciples, including +the most considerable persons of the Castilian court; it may be still +further inferred from the numerous dedications to these persons, of +contemporary publications, attesting their munificent patronage of +literary enterprise; [16] and, still more unequivocally, from the zeal +with which many of the highest rank entered on such severe literary labor +as few, from the mere love of letters, are found willing to encounter. Don +Gutierre de Toledo, son of the duke of Alva, and a cousin of the king, +taught in the university of Salamanca. At the same place, Don Pedro +Fernandez de Velasco, son of the count of Haro, who subsequently succeeded +his father in the hereditary dignity of grand constable of Castile, read +lectures on Pliny and Ovid. Don Alfonso de Manrique, son of the count of +Paredes, was professor of Greek in the university of Alcalá. All ages +seemed to catch the generous enthusiasm; and the marquis of Denia, +although turned of sixty, made amends for the sins of his youth, by +learning the elements of the Latin tongue, at this late period. In short, +as Giovio remarks in his eulogium on Lebrija, "No Spaniard was accounted +noble who held science in indifference." From a very early period, a +courtly stamp was impressed on the poetic literature of Spain. A similar +character was now imparted to its erudition; and men of the most +illustrious birth seemed eager to lead the way in the difficult career of +science, which was thrown open to the nation. [17] + +In this brilliant exhibition, those of the other sex must not be omitted, +who contributed by their intellectual endowments to the general +illumination of the period. Among them, the writers of that day lavish +their panegyrics on the marchioness of Monteagudo, and Doña Maria Pacheco, +of the ancient house of Mendoza, sisters of the historian, Don Diego +Hurtado, [18] and daughters of the accomplished count of Tendilla, [19] +who, while ambassador at Rome, induced Martyr to visit Spain, and who was +grandson of the famous marquis of Santillana, and nephew of the grand +cardinal. [20] This illustrious family, rendered yet more illustrious by +its merits than its birth, is worthy of specification, as affording +altogether the most remarkable combination of literary talent in the +enlightened court of Castile. The queen's instructor in the Latin language +was a lady named Doña Beatriz de Galindo, called from her peculiar +attainments _la Latina_. Another lady, Doña Lucia de Medrano, publicly +lectured on the Latin classics in the university of Salamanca. And +another, Doña Francisca de Lebrija, daughter of the historian of that +name, filled the chair of rhetoric with applause at Alcalá. But our limits +will not allow a further enumeration of names, which should never be +permitted to sink into oblivion, were it only for the rare scholarship, +peculiarly rare in the female sex, which they displayed, in an age +comparatively unenlightened. [21] Female education in that day embraced a +wider compass of erudition, in reference to the ancient languages, than is +common at present; a circumstance attributable, probably, to the poverty +of modern literature at that time, and the new and general appetite +excited by the revival of classical learning in Italy. I am not aware, +however, that it was usual for learned ladies, in any other country than +Spain, to take part in the public exercises of the gymnasium, and deliver +lectures from the chairs of the universities. This peculiarity, which may +be referred in part to the queen's influence, who encouraged the love of +study by her own example, as well as by personal attendance on the +academic examinations, may have been also suggested by a similar usage, +already noticed, among the Spanish Arabs. [22] + +While the study of the ancient tongues came thus into fashion with persons +of both sexes, and of the highest rank, it was widely and most thoroughly +cultivated by professed scholars. Men of letters, some of whom have been +already noticed, were invited into Spain from Italy, the theatre, at that +time, on which, from obvious local advantages, classical discovery was +pursued with greatest ardor and success. To this country it was usual also +for Spanish students to repair, in order to complete their discipline in +classical literature, especially the Greek, as first taught on sound +principles of criticism, by the learned exiles from Constantinople. The +most remarkable of the Spanish scholars, who made this literary pilgrimage +to Italy, was Antonio de Lebrija, or Nebrissensis, as he is more +frequently called from his Latin name. [23] After ten years passed at +Bologna and other seminaries of repute, with particular attention to their +interior discipline, he returned, in 1473, to his native land, richly +laden with the stores of various erudition. He was invited to fill the +Latin chair at Seville, whence he was successively transferred to +Salamanca and Alcalá, both of which places he long continued to enlighten +by his oral instruction and publications. The earliest of these was his +_Introducciones Latinas_, the third edition of which was printed in +1485, being four years only from the date of the first; a remarkable +evidence of the growing taste for classical learning. A translation in the +vernacular accompanied the last edition, arranged, at the queen's +suggestion, in columns parallel with those of the original text; a form +which, since become common, was then a novelty. [24] The publication of +his Castilian grammar, "_Grammatica Castillana_," followed in 1492; a +treatise designed particularly for the instruction of the ladies of the +court. The other productions of this indefatigable scholar embrace a large +circle of topics, independently of his various treatises on philology and +criticism. Some were translated into French and Italian, and their +republication has been continued to the last century. No man of his own, +or of later times, contributed more essentially than Lebrija to the +introduction of a pure and healthful erudition into Spain. It is not too +much to say, that there was scarcely an eminent Spanish scholar in the +beginning of the sixteenth century, who had not formed himself on the +instructions of this master. [25] + +Another name worthy of commemoration, is that of Arias Barbosa, a learned +Portuguese, who, after passing some years, like Lebrija, in the schools of +Italy, where he studied the ancient tongues under the guidance of +Politiano, was induced to establish his residence in Spain. In 1489, we +find him at Salamanca, where he continued for twenty, or, according to +some accounts, forty years, teaching in the departments of Greek and +rhetoric. At the close of that period he returned to Portugal, where he +superintended the education of some of the members of the royal family, +and survived to a good old age. Barbosa was esteemed inferior to Lebrija +in extent of various erudition, but to have surpassed him in an accurate +knowledge of the Greek and poetical criticism. In the former, indeed, he +seems to have obtained a greater repute than any Spanish scholar of the +time. He composed some valuable works, especially on ancient prosody. The +unwearied assiduity and complete success of his academic labors have +secured to him a high reputation among the restorers of ancient learning, +and especially that of reviving a livelier relish for the study of the +Greek, by conducting it on principles of pure criticism, in the same +manner as Lebrija did with the Latin. [26] + +The scope of the present work precludes the possibility of a copious +enumeration of the pioneers of ancient learning, to whom Spain owes so +large a debt of gratitude. [27] + +The Castilian scholars of the close of the fifteenth, and the beginning of +the sixteenth century, may take rank with their illustrious contemporaries +of Italy. They could not indeed achieve such brilliant results in the +discovery of the remains of antiquity, for such remains had been long +scattered and lost amid the centuries of exile and disastrous warfare +consequent on the Saracen invasion. But they were unwearied in their +illustrations, both oral and written, of the ancient authors; and their +numerous commentaries, translations, dictionaries, grammars, and various +works of criticism, many of which, though now obsolete, passed into +repeated editions in their own day, bear ample testimony to the generous +zeal with which they conspired to raise their contemporaries to a proper +level for contemplating the works of the great masters of antiquity; and +well entitled them to the high eulogium of Erasmus, that "liberal studies +were brought, in the course of a few years, in Spain to so flourishing a +condition, as might not only excite the admiration, but serve as a model +to the most cultivated nations of Europe." [28] + +The Spanish universities were the theatre on which this classical +erudition was more especially displayed. Previous to Isabella's reign, +there were but few schools in the kingdom; not one indeed of any note, +except in Salamanca; and this did not escape the blight which fell on +every generous study. But under the cheering patronage of the present +government, they were soon filled, and widely multiplied. Academies of +repute were to be found in Seville, Toledo, Salamanca, Granada, and +Alcalá; and learned teachers were drawn from abroad by the most liberal +emoluments. At the head of these establishments stood "the illustrious +city of Salamanca," as Marineo fondly terms it, "mother of all liberal +arts and virtues, alike renowned for noble cavaliers and learned men." +[29] Such was its reputation, that foreigners as well as natives were +attracted to its schools, and at one time, according to the authority of +the same professor, seven thousand students were assembled within its +walls. A letter of Peter Martyr, to his patron the count of Tendilla, +gives a whimsical picture of the literary enthusiasm of this place. The +throng was so great to hear his introductory lecture on one of the Satires +of Juvenal, that every avenue to the hall was blockaded, and the professor +was borne in on the shoulders of the students. Professorships in every +department of science then studied, as well as of polite letters, were +established at the university, the "new Athens," as Martyr somewhere +styles it. Before the close of Isabella's reign, however, its glories were +rivalled, if not eclipsed, by those of Alcalá; [30] which combined higher +advantages for ecclesiastical with civil education, and which, under the +splendid patronage of Cardinal Ximenes, executed the famous polyglot +version of the Scriptures, the most stupendous literary enterprise of that +age. [31] + +This active cultivation was not confined to the dead languages, but spread +more or less over every department of knowledge. Theological science, in +particular, received a large share of attention. It had always formed a +principal object of academic instruction, though suffered to languish +under the universal corruption of the preceding reign. It was so common +for the clergy to be ignorant of the most elementary knowledge, that the +council of Aranda found it necessary to pass an ordinance, the year before +Isabella's accession, that no person should be admitted to orders who was +ignorant of Latin. The queen took the most effectual means for correcting +this abuse, by raising only competent persons to ecclesiastical dignities. +The highest stations in the church were reserved for those who combined +the highest intellectual endowments with unblemished piety. Cardinal +Mendoza, whose acute and comprehensive mind entered with interest into +every scheme for the promotion of science, was archbishop of Toledo; +Talavera, whose hospitable mansion was itself an academy for men of +letters, and whose princely revenues were liberally dispensed for their +support, was raised to the see of Granada; and Ximenes, whose splendid +literary projects will require more particular notice hereafter, succeeded +Mendoza in the primacy of Spain. Under the protection of these enlightened +patrons, theological studies were pursued with ardor, the Scriptures +copiously illustrated, and sacred eloquence cultivated with success. + +A similar impulse was felt in the other walks of science. Jurisprudence +assumed a new aspect, under the learned labors of Montalvo. [32] The +mathematics formed a principal branch of education, and were successfully +applied to astronomy and geography. Valuable treatises were produced on +medicine, and on the more familiar practical arts, as husbandry, for +example. [33] History, which since the time of Alfonso the Tenth had been +held in higher honor and more widely Cultivated in Castile than in any +other European state, began to lay aside the garb of chronicle, and to be +studied on more scientific principles. Charters and diplomas were +consulted, manuscripts collated, coins and lapidary inscriptions +deciphered, and collections made of these materials, the true basis of +authentic history; and an office of public archives, like that now +existing at Simancas, was established at Burgos, and placed under the care +of Alonso de Mota, as keeper, with a liberal salary. [34] + +Nothing could have been more opportune for the enlightened purposes of +Isabella, than the introduction of the art of printing into Spain, at the +commencement, indeed in the very first year, of her reign. She saw, from +the first moment, all the advantages which it promised for diffusing and +perpetuating the discoveries of science. She encouraged its establishment +by large privileges to those who exercised it, whether natives or +foreigners, and by causing many of the works, composed by her subjects, to +be printed at her own charge. [35] + +Among the earlier printers we frequently find the names of Germans; a +people, who to the original merits of the discovery may justly add that of +its propagation among every nation of Europe. We meet with a +_pragmática_, or royal ordinance, dated in 1477, exempting a German, +named Theodoric, from taxation, on the ground of being "one of the +principal persons in the discovery and practice of the art of printing +books, which he had brought with him into Spain at great risk and expense, +with the design of ennobling the libraries of the kingdom." [36] +Monopolies for printing and selling books for a limited period, answering +to the modern copyright, were granted to certain persons, in consideration +of their doing so at a reasonable rate. [37] It seems to have been usual +for the printers to be also the publishers and venders of books. These +exclusive privileges, however, do not appear to have been carried to a +mischievous extent. Foreign books, of every description, by a law of 1480, +were allowed to be imported into the kingdom, free of all duty whatever; +an enlightened provision, which might furnish a useful hint to legislators +of the nineteenth century. [38] + +The first press appears to have been erected at Valencia, in 1474; +although the glory of precedence is stoutly contested by several places, +and especially by Barcelona. [39] The first work printed was a collection +of songs, composed for a poetical contest in honor of the Virgin, for the +most part in the Limousin or Valencian dialect. [40] In the following year +the first ancient classic, being the works of Sallust, was printed; and, +in 1478, there appeared from the same press a translation of the +Scriptures, in the Limousin, by Father Boniface Ferrer, brother of the +famous Dominican, St. Vincent Ferrer. [41] Through the liberal patronage +of the government, the art was widely diffused; and before the end of the +fifteenth century, presses were established and in active operation in the +principal cities of the united kingdom; in Toledo, Seville, Ciudad Real, +Granada, Valladolid, Burgos, Salamanca, Zamora, Saragossa, Valencia, +Barcelona, Monte Rey, Lerida, Murcia, Tolosa, Tarragona, Alcalá de +Henares, and Madrid. + +It is painful to notice amidst the judicious provisions for the +encouragement of science, one so entirely repugnant to their spirit as the +establishment of the censorship. By an ordinance, dated at Toledo, July +8th, 1502, it was decreed, that, "as many of the books sold in the kingdom +were defective, or false, or apocryphal, or pregnant with vain and +superstitious novelties, it was therefore ordered that no book should +hereafter be printed without special license from the king, or some person +regularly commissioned by him for the purpose." The names of the +commissioners then follow, consisting mostly of ecclesiastics, archbishops +and bishops, with authority respectively over their several dioceses. [42] +This authority was devolved in later times, under Charles the Fifth and +his successors, on the Council of the Supreme, over which the inquisitor- +general presided _ex-officio_. The immediate agents employed in the +examination were also drawn from the Inquisition, who exercised this +important trust, as is well known, in a manner most fatal to the interests +of letters and humanity. Thus a provision, destined in its origin for the +advancement of science, by purifying it from the crudities and corruptions +which naturally infect it in a primitive age, contributed more effectually +to its discouragement, than any other which could have been devised, by +interdicting the freedom of expression, so indispensable to freedom of +inquiry. [43] + +While endeavoring to do justice to the progress of civilization in this +reign, I should regret to present to the reader an over-colored picture of +its results. Indeed, less emphasis should be laid on any actual results, +than on the spirit of improvement, which they imply in the nation, and the +liberal dispositions of the government. The fifteenth century was +distinguished by a zeal for research and laborious acquisition, especially +in ancient literature, throughout Europe, which showed itself in Italy in +the beginning of the age, and in Spain, and some other countries, towards +the close. It was natural that men should explore the long-buried +treasures descended from their ancestors, before venturing on anything of +their own creation. Their efforts were eminently successful; and, by +opening an acquaintance with the immortal productions of ancient +literature, they laid the best foundation for the cultivation of the +modern. + +In the sciences, their success was more equivocal. A blind reverence for +authority, a habit of speculation, instead of experiment, so pernicious in +physics, in short, an ignorance of the true principles of philosophy, +often led the scholars of that day in a wrong direction. Even when they +took a right one, their attainments, under all these impediments, were +necessarily so small, as to be scarcely perceptible, when viewed from the +brilliant heights to which science has arrived in our own age. +Unfortunately for Spain, its subsequent advancement has been so retarded, +that a comparison of the fifteenth century with those which succeeded it, +is by no means so humiliating to the former as in some other countries of +Europe; and, it is certain, that in general intellectual fermentation, no +period has surpassed, if it can be said to have rivalled, the age of +Isabella. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] L. Marineo, Cosas Memorables, fol. 153. + +[2] L. Marineo, Cosas Memorables, fol. 154, 182. + +[3] Carro de las Doñas, lib. 2, cap. 62 et seq., apud Mem. de la Acad. de +Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 21.--Pulgar, Letras, (Amstelodami, 1670,) let. 11. +--L. Marineo, Cosas Memorables, fol. 182.--It is sufficient evidence of +her familiarity with the Latin, that the letters addressed to her by her +confessor seem to have been written in that language and the Castilian +indifferently, exhibiting occasionally a curious patchwork in the +alternate use of each in the same epistle. See Correspondencia Epistolar, +apud Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 13. + +[4] Previous to the introduction of printing, collections of books were +necessarily very small and thinly scattered, owing to the extreme cost of +manuscripts. The learned Saez has collected some curious particulars +relative to this matter. The most copious library which he could find any +account of, in the middle of the fifteenth century, was owned by the +counts of Benavente, and contained not more than one hundred and twenty +volumes. Many of these were duplicates; of Livy alone there were eight +copies. The cathedral churches in Spain rented their books every year by +auction to the highest bidders, whence they derived a considerable +revenue. + +It would appear from a copy of Gratian's Canons, preserved in the +Celestine monastery in Paris, that the copyist was engaged twenty-one +months in transcribing that manuscript. At this rate, the production of +four thousand copies by one hand would require nearly eight thousand +years, a work now easily performed in less than four months. Such was the +tardiness in multiplying copies before the invention of printing. Two +thousand volumes may be procured now at a price, which in those days would +hardly have sufficed to purchase fifty. See Tratado de Monedas de Enrique +III., apud Moratin, Obras, ed. de la Acad., (Madrid, 1830,) tom. i. pp. +91, 92. Moratin argues from extreme cases. + +[5] Navagiero, Viaggio fatto in Spagna et in Francia, (Vinegia, 1563,) +fol. 23.--Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust, 17. The largest +collection comprised about two hundred and one articles, or distinct +works. Of these, about a third is taken up with theology, comprehending +Bibles, psalters, missals, lives of saints, and works of the fathers; one- +fifth, civil law and the municipal code of Spain; one-fourth, ancient +classics, modern literature, and romances of chivalry; one-tenth, history; +the residue is devoted to ethics, medicine, grammar, astrology, etc. The +only Italian author, besides Leonardo Bruno d'Arezzo, is Boccaccio. The +works of the latter writer consisted of the "Fiammetta," the treatises "De +Casibus Illustrium Virorum," and "De Claris Mulieribus," and probably the +"Decameron;" the first in the Italian, and the three last translated into +the Spanish. It is singular, that neither of Boccaccio's great +contemporaries, Dante and Petrarch, the former of whom had been translated +by Villena, and imitated by Juan de Mena, half a century before, should +have found a place in the collection. + +[6] Antonio, the eldest, died in 1488. Part of his Latin poetical works, +entitled "Sacred Bucolics," was printed in 1505, at Salamanca. The younger +brother, Alessandro, after bearing arms in the Portuguese war, was +subsequently employed in the instruction of the infantas, finally embraced +the ecclesiastical state, and died bishop of St. Domingo, in 1525. Mem. de +la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 16.--Tiraboschi, Letteratura Italiana, +tom. vi. part. 2, p. 285. + +[7] The learned Valencian, Luis Vives, in his treatise "De Christianâ +Feminâ," remarks, "Aetas noster quatuor illas Isabellae reginae filias, +quas paullo ante memoravi, eruditas vidit. Non sine laudibus et +admiratione refertur mihi passim in hae terrâ Joannam, Philippi conjugem, +Caroli hujus matrem, extempore latinis orationibus, quae de more apud +novos principes oppidatim habentur, latine respondisse. Idem de reginâ +suâ, Joannae sorore, Britanni praedicant; idem omnes de duabus aliis, quae +in Lusitaniâ fato concessere." (De Christianâ Feminâ, cap. 4, apud Mem. de +la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 16.)--It appears, however, that +Isabella was not inattentive to the more humble accomplishments, in the +education of her daughters. "Regina," says the same author, "nere, suere, +acu pingere quatuor filias auas doctas esse voluit." Another contemporary, +the author of the Carro de las Doñas, (lib. 2, cap. 62, apud Mem. de la +Acad. de Hist., Ilust. 21,) says, "she educated her son and daughters, +giving them masters of life and letters, and surrounding them with such +persons as tended to make them vessels of election, and kings in Heaven." + +Erasmus notices the literary attainments of the youngest daughter of the +sovereigns, the unfortunate Catharine of Aragon, with unqualified +admiration. In one of his letters, he styles her "egregie doctam;" and in +another he remarks, "Regina non tantum in sexus miraculum literata est; +nec minus pietate suspicienda, quam eruditione." Epistolae, (Londini, +1642,) lib. 19, epist. 31; lib. 2, epist. 24. + +[8] Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., dial. de Deza.--Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., +tom. vi. Ilust. 14. + +[9] Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 14. + +Juan de la Eucina, in the dedication to the prince, of his translation of +Virgil's Bucolics, pays the following compliment to the enlightened and +liberal taste of Prince John. "Favoresceis tanto la sciencia andando +acompañado de tantos e tan doctísimos varones, que no menos dejareis +perdurable memoria de haber alargado e estendido los límites e términos de +la sciencia que los del imperio." The extraordinary promise of this young +prince made his name known in distant parts of Europe, and his untimely +death, which occurred in the twentieth year of his age, was commemorated +by an epitaph of the learned Greek exile, Constantine Lascaris. + +[10] "Aficionados á la guerra," says Oviedo, speaking of some young nobles +of his time, "_por su Española y natural inclinacion_." Quincuagenas, +MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, dial. 36. + +[11] For some account of this eminent Italian scholar, see the postscript +to Part I. Chap. 14, of this History. + +[12] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 102, 103. + +Lucio Marineo, in a discourse addressed to Charles V., thus notices the +queen's solicitude for the instruction of her young nobility. "Isabella +praesertim Regina magnanima, virtutum omnium maxima cultrix. Quae quidem +multis et magnis occupata negotiis, ut aliis exemplum praeberet, a primis +grammaticae rudimentis studere coepit, et omnes suae domûs adolescentes +utriusque sexûs nobilium liberos, praeceptoribus liberaliter et honorifice +conductis erudiendos commendabat." Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. +Apend. 16.--See also Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, dial. +36. + +[13] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 115. + +[14] A particular account of Marineo's writings may be found in Nic. +Antonio. (Bibliotheca Nova, tom. ii. Apend. p. 369.) The most important of +these is his work "De Rebus Hispaniae Memorabilibus," often cited, in the +Castilian, in this History. It is a rich repository of details respecting +the geography, statistics, and manners of the Peninsula, with a copious +historical notice of events in Ferdinand and Isabella's reign. The +author's insatiable curiosity, during a long residence in the country, +enabled him to collect many facts, of a kind that do not fall within the +ordinary compass of history; while his extensive learning, and his +familiarity with foreign models, peculiarly qualified him for estimating +the institutions he describes. It must be confessed he is sufficiently +partial to the land of his adoption. The edition, referred to in this +work, is in black letter, printed before, or soon after, the author's +death (the date of which is uncertain), in 1539, at Alcalá de Henares, by +Juan Brocar, one of a family long celebrated in the annals of Castilian +printing. Marineo's prologue concludes with the following noble tribute to +letters. "Porque todos los otros bienes son subjectos a la fortuna y +mudables y en poco tiempo mudan muchos dueños passando de unos señores en +otros, mas los dones de letras y hystorias que se ofrescen para +perpetuidad de memoria y fama son immortales y prorogan y guardan para +siempre la memoria assi de los que los reciben, como de los que los +ofrescen." + +[15] Sepulveda, Democrites, apud Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. +Ilust. 16.--Signorelli, Coltura nelle Sicilie, tom. iv. p. 318.-- +Tiraboschi, Letteratura Italiana, tom. vii. part. 3, lib. 3, cap. 4.-- +Comp. Lampillas, Saggio Storico-Apologetico de la Letteratura Spagnuola, +(Genova, 1778,) tom. ii. dis. 2, sect. 5.--The patriotic Abate is greatly +scandalized by the degree of influence which Tiraboschi and other Italian +critics ascribe to their own language over the Castilian, especially at +this period. The seven volumes, in which he has discharged his bile on the +heads of the offenders, afford valuable materials for the historian of +Spanish literature. Tiraboschi must be admitted to have the better of his +antagonist in temper, if not in argument. + +[16] Among these we find copious translations from the ancient classics, +as Caesar, Appian, Plutarch, Plautus, Sallust, Aesop, Justin, Boëthius, +Apulius, Herodian, affording strong evidence of the activity of the +Castilian scholars in this department. Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. +pp. 406, 407.--Mendez, Typographia Española, pp. 133, 139. + +[17] Salazar de Mendoza, Dignidades, cap. 21. + +Lucio Marineo Siculo, in his discourse above alluded to, in which he +exhibits the condition of letters under the reign of Ferdinand and +Isabella, enumerates the names of the nobility most conspicuous for their +scholarship. This valuable document was to be found only in the edition of +Marineo's work, "De Rebus Hispaniae Memorabilibus," printed at Alcalá, in +1630, whence it has been transferred by Clemencin to the sixth volume of +the Memoirs of the Royal Academy of History. + +[18] His work "Guerra de Granada," was first published at Madrid, in 1610, +and "may be compared," says Nic. Antonio, in a judgment which has been +ratified by the general consent of his countrymen, "with the compositions +of Sallust, or any other ancient historian." His poetry and his celebrated +_picaresco_ novel "Lazarillo de Tormes," have made an epoch in the +ornamental literature of Spain. + +[19] Oviedo has devoted one of his dialogues to this nobleman, equally +distinguished by his successes in arms, letters, and love; the last of +which, according to that writer, he had not entirely resigned at the age +of seventy.--Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, dial. 28. + +[20] For an account of Santillana, see the First Chapter of this History. +The cardinal, in early life, is said to have translated for his father the +Aeneid, the Odyssey, Ovid, Valerius Maximus, and Sallust. (Mem. de la +Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 16.) This Herculean feat would put modern +school-boys to shame, and we may suppose that partial versions only of +these authors are intended. + +[21] Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 16.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, +MS., dial. de Grizio. + +Señor Clemencin has examined with much care the intellectual culture of +the nation under Isabella, in the sixteenth _Ilustracion_ of his work. He +has touched lightly on its poetical character, considering, no doubt, that +this had been sufficiently developed by other critics. His essay, however, +is rich in information in regard to the scholarship and severer studies of +the period. The reader, who would pursue the inquiry still further, may +find abundant materials in Nic. Antonio, Bibliotheca Vetus, tom. ii. lib. +10, cap. 13 et seq.--Idem, Bibliotheca Hispana Nova, (Matriti, 1783-8,) +tom. i. ii. passim. + +[22] See Part I. Chap. 8, of this History. + +[23] For a notice of this scholar, see the postscript to Part I. Chap. 11, +of this History. + +[24] Mendez, Typographia Española, pp. 271, 272. In the second edition, +published 1482, the author states, that no work of the time had a greater +circulation, more than a thousand copies of it, at a high price, having +been disposed of in the preceding year. Ibid., p. 237. + +[25] Nic. Antonio, Bibliotheca Nova, tom. i. pp. 132-139.--Lampillas, +Letteratura Spagnuola, tom. ii. dis. 2, sec. 3.--Dialogo de las Lenguas, +apud Mayans y Siscar, Orígenes, (Madrid, 1737,) tom. ii. pp. 46, 47. + +Lucio Marineo pays the following elegant compliment to this learned +Spaniard, in his discourse before quoted. "Amisit nuper Hispania maximum +sui cultorem in re litterariâ, Antonium Nebrissensem, qui primus ex Italiâ +in Hispaniam Musas adduxit, quibuscum barbariem ex suâ patriâ fugavit, et +Hispaniam totam linguae Latinae lectionibus illustravit." "Meruerat id," +says Gomez de Castro of Lebrija, "et multo majora hominis eruditio, cui +Hispania debet, quicquid habet bonarum literarum." + +The acute author of the "Dialogo de las Lenguas," while he renders ample +homage to Lebrija's Latin erudition, disputes his critical acquaintance +with his own language, from his being a native of Andalusia, where the +Castilian was not spoken with purity. "Hablaba y escrivia como en el +Andalucia y no como en la Castilla." P. 92. See also pp. 9, 10, 46, 53. + +[26] Barbosa, Bibliotheca Lusitana, (Lisboa Occidental, 1741,) tom. i. pp. +76-78.--Signorelli, Coltura nelle Sicilie, tom. iv. pp. 315-321.--Mayans y +Siscar, Origenes, tom. i. p. 173.--Lampillas, Letteratura Spagnuola, tom. +ii. dis. 2, sect. 5.--Nic. Antonio, Bibliotheca Nova, tom. i. pp. 170, +171. + +[27] Among these are particularly deserving of attention the brothers John +and Francis Vergara, professors at Alcalá, the latter of whom was esteemed +one of the most accomplished scholars of the age; Nuñez de Guzman, of the +ancient house of that name, professor for many years at Salamanca and +Alcalá, and the author of the Latin version in the famous Polyglot of +Cardinal Ximenes; he left behind him numerous works, especially +commentaries on the classics; Olivario, whose curious erudition was +abundantly exhibited in his illustrations of Cicero and other Latin +authors; and lastly Vives, whose fame rather belongs to Europe than his +own country, who, when only twenty-six years old, drew from Erasmus the +encomium, that "there was scarcely any one of the age whom he could +venture to compare with him in philosophy, eloquence, and liberal +learning." But the most unequivocal testimony to the deep and various +scholarship of the period is afforded by that stupendous literary work of +Cardinal Ximenes, the Polyglot Bible, whose versions in the Greek, Latin, +and Oriental tongues were collated, with a single exception, by Spanish +scholars. Erasmus, Epistolae, lib. 19, epist. 101.--Lampillas, Letteratura +Spagnuola, tom. ii. pp. 382-384, 495, 792-794; tom. ii. p. 208 et seq.-- +Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 37. + +[28] Erasmus, Epistolae, p. 977. + +[29] "La muy esclarecida ciudad de Salamanca, madre de las artes +liberales, y todas virtudes, y ansi de cavalleros como de letrados +varones, muy ilustre." Cosas Memorables, fol. 11.--Chacon, Hist. de la +Universidad de Salamanca, apud Semanario Erudito, tom. xviii. pp. 1-61. + +[30] "Academia Complutensis," says Erasmus of this university, "non +aliunde celebritatem nominis auspicata est quàm a complectendo linguae ac +bonas literas. Cujus praecipuum oramentum est egregius ille senex, +planéque dignus qui multos vincat Nestoras, Antonius Nebrissensis." Epist. +ad Ludovicum Vivem, 1521. Epistolae, p. 755. + +[31] Cosas Memorables, ubi supra.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 57.-- +Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, lib. 4.--Chacon, Universidad de Salamanca, ubi +supra. + +It appears that the practice of scraping with the feet as an expression of +disapprobation, familiar in our universities, is of venerable antiquity; +for Martyr mentions, that he was saluted with it before finishing his +discourse by one or two idle youths, dissatisfied with its length. The +lecturer, however, seems to have given general satisfaction, for he was +escorted back in triumph to his lodgings, to use his own language, "like a +victor in the Olympic games," after the conclusion of the exercise. + +[32] For some remarks on the labors of this distinguished jurisconsult, +see Part I. Chap. 6, and Part II. Chap. 26, of the present work. + +[33] The most remarkable of these latter is Herrera's treatise on +Agriculture, which since its publication in Toledo, in 1520, has passed +through a variety of editions at home and translations abroad. Nic. +Antonio, Bibliotheca Nova, tom. i. p. 503. + +[34] This collection, with the ill luck which has too often befallen such +repositories in Spain, was burnt in the war of the Communities, in the +time of Charles V. Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 16.-- +Morales, Obras, tom. vii. p. 18.--Informe de Ríol, who particularly +notices the solicitude of Ferdinand and Isabella for preserving the public +documents. + +[35] Mendez, Typographia Española, p. 51. + +[36] Archivo de Murcia, apud Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. p. 244. + +[37] Mendez, Typographia Española, pp. 52, 332. + +[38] Ordenanças Reales, lib. 4, tit. 4, ley 22.--The preamble of this +statute is expressed in the following enlightened terms; "Considerando los +Reyes de gloriosa memoria quanto era provechoso y honroso, que a estos sus +reynos se truxessen libros de otras partes para que con ellos se hiziessen +los hombres letrados, quisieron y ordenaron, que de los libros no se +pagasse el alcavala.... Lo qual parece que redunda en provecho universal +de todos, y en ennoblecimiento de nuestros Reynos." + +[39] Capmany, Mem. de Barcelona, tom. i. part. 2, lib. 2, cap. 6.--Mendez, +Typographia Española, pp. 55, 93. + +Bouterwek intimates, that the art of printing was first practised in Spain +by German printers at Seville, _in the beginning of the sixteenth +century_. (Bouterwek, Geschichte der Poesie und Beredsamkeit, (Göttingen, +1801-17,) band iii. p. 98.)--He appears to have been misled by a solitary +example quoted from Mayans y Siscar. The want of materials has more than +once led this eminent critic to build sweeping conclusions on slender +premises. + +[40] The title of the book is "Certamen poetich en lohor de la Concecio," +Valencia, 1474, 4to. The name of the printer is wanting. Mendez, +Typographia Española, p. 56. + +[41] Ibid., pp. 61-63. + +[42] Mendez, Typographia Española, pp. 52, 53.--Pragmáticas del Reyno, +fol. 138, 139. + +[43] Llorente, Hist. de l'Inquisition, tom. i. chap. 13, art. 1. + +"Adempto per _inquisitiones_," says Tacitus of the gloomy times of +Domitian, "et loquendi audiendique commercio." (Vita Agricolae, sec. 2.) +Beaumarchais, in a merrier vein, indeed, makes the same bitter +reflections. "Il s'est établi dans Madrid un système de liberté sur la +vente des productions, qui s'étend même a celles de la presse; et que, +pourvu que je ne parle en mes écrits ni de l'autorité, ni de culte, ni de +la politique, ni de la morale, ni des gens en place, ni des corps en +crédit, ni de l'Opéra, ni des autres spectacles, ni de personne qui tienne +à quelque chose, je puis tout imprimer librement, sous l'inspection de +deux ou trois censeurs," Mariage de Figaro, acte 5, sc. 3. + + + + +CHAPTER XX. + +CASTILIAN LITERATURE.--ROMANCES OF CHIVALRY.--LYRICAL POETRY.-THE DRAMA. + +This Reign an Epoch in Polite Letters.--Romances of Chivalry.--Ballads or +_Romances_.--Moorish Minstrelsy.--"Cancionero General."--Its Literary +Value.--Rise of the Spanish Drama.--Criticism on "Celestina."--Encina.-- +Naharro.--Low Condition of the Stage.--National Spirit of the Literature +of this Epoch. + + +Ornamental or polite literature, which, emanating from the taste and +sensibility of a nation, readily exhibits its various fluctuations of +fashion and feeling, was stamped in Spain with the distinguishing +characteristics of this revolutionary age. The Provencal, which reached +such high perfection in Catalonia, and subsequently in Aragon, as noticed +in an introductory chapter, [1] expired with the union of this monarchy +with Castile, and the dialect ceased to be applied to literary purposes +altogether, after the Castilian became the language of the court in the +united kingdoms. The poetry of Castile, which throughout the present reign +continued to breathe the same patriotic spirit, and to exhibit the same +national peculiarities that had distinguished it from the time of the Cid, +submitted soon after Ferdinand's death to the influence of the more +polished Tuscan, and henceforth, losing somewhat of its distinctive +physiognomy, assumed many of the prevalent features of continental +literature. Thus the reign of Ferdinand and Isabella becomes an epoch as +memorable in literary, as in civil history. + +The most copious vein of fancy, in that day, was turned in the direction +of the prose romance of chivalry; now seldom disturbed, even in its own +country, except by the antiquary. The circumstances of the age naturally +led to its production. The romantic Moorish wars, teeming with adventurous +exploit and picturesque incident, carried on with the natural enemies of +the Christian knight, and opening moreover all the legendary stores of +Oriental fable,--the stirring adventures by sea as well as land,--above +all, the discovery of a world beyond the waters, whose unknown regions +gave full scope to the play of the imagination, all contributed to +stimulate the appetite for the incredible chimeras, the _magnanime +menzogne_, of chivalry. The publication of "Amadis de Gaula" gave a +decided impulse to this popular feeling. This romance, which seems now +well ascertained to be the production of a Portuguese in the latter half +of the fourteenth century, [2] was first printed in a Spanish version, +probably not far from 1490. [3] Its editor, Garci Ordoñez de Montalvo, +states, in his prologue, that "he corrected it from the ancient originals, +pruning it of all superfluous phrases, and substituting others of a more +polished and elegant style." [4] How far its character was benefited by +this work of purification may be doubted; although it is probable it did +not suffer so much by such a process as it would have done in a later and +more cultivated period. The simple beauties of this fine old romance, its +bustling incidents, relieved by the delicate play of Oriental machinery, +its general truth of portraiture, above all, the knightly character of the +hero, who graced the prowess of chivalry with a courtesy, modesty, and +fidelity unrivalled in the creations of romance, soon recommended it to +popular favor and imitation. A continuation, bearing the title of "Las +Sergas de Esplandian," was given to the world by Montalvo himself, and +grafted on the original stock, as the fifth book of the Amadis, before +1510. A sixth, containing the adventures of his nephew, was printed at +Salamanca in the course of the last-mentioned year; and thus the idle +writers of the day continued to propagate dulness through a series of +heavy tomes, amounting in all to four and twenty books, until the much- +abused public would no longer suffer the name of Amadis to cloak the +manifold sins of his posterity. [5] Other knights-errant were sent roving +about the world at the same time, whose exploits would fill a library; but +fortunately they have been permitted to pass into oblivion, from which a +few of their names only have been rescued by the caustic criticism of the +curate in Don Quixote; who, it will be remembered, after declaring that +the virtues of the parent shall not avail his posterity, condemns them and +their companions, with one or two exceptions only, to the fatal funeral +pile. [6] + +These romances of chivalry must have undoubtedly contributed to nourish +those exaggerated sentiments, which from a very early period entered into +the Spanish character. Their evil influence, in a literary view, resulted +less from their improbabilities of situation, which they possessed in +common with the inimitable Italian epics, than from the false pictures +which they presented of human character, familiarizing the eye of the +reader with such models as debauched the taste, and rendered him incapable +of relishing the chaste and sober productions of art. It is remarkable +that the chivalrous romance, which was so copiously cultivated through the +greater part of the sixteenth century, should not have assumed the poetic +form, as in Italy, and indeed among our Norman ancestors; and that, in its +prose dress, no name of note appears to raise it to a high degree of +literary merit. Perhaps such a result might have been achieved, but for +the sublime parody of Cervantes, which cut short the whole race of +knights-errant, and by the fine irony, which it threw around the mock +heroes of chivalry, extinguished them for ever. [7] + +The most popular poetry of this period, that springing from the body of +the people, and most intimately addressed to it, is the ballads, or +_romances_, as they are termed in Spain. These indeed were familiar +to the Peninsula as far back as the twelfth and thirteenth centuries; but +in the present reign they received a fresh impulse from the war with +Granada, and composed, under the name of the Moorish ballads, what may +perhaps be regarded, without too high praise, as the most exquisite +popular minstrelsy of any age or country. + +The humble narrative lyrics making up the mass of ballad poetry, and +forming the natural expression of a simple state of society, would seem to +be most abundant in nations endowed with keen sensibilities, and placed in +situations of excitement and powerful interest, fitted to develop them. +The light and lively French have little to boast of in this way. [8] The +Italians, with a deeper poetic feeling, were too early absorbed in the +gross business habits of trade, and their literature received too high a +direction from its master spirits, at its very commencement, to allow any +considerable deviation in this track. The countries where it has most +thriven, are probably Great Britain and Spain. The English and the Scotch, +whose constitutionally pensive and even melancholy temperament has been +deepened by the sober complexion of the climate, were led to the +cultivation of this poetry still further by the stirring scenes of feudal +warfare in which they were engaged, especially along the borders. The +Spaniards, to similar sources of excitement, added that of high religious +feeling in their struggles with the Saracens, which gave a somewhat +loftier character to their effusions. Fortunately for them, their early +annals gave birth, in the Cid, to a hero whose personal renown was +identified with that of his country, round whose name might be +concentrated all the scattered lights of song, thus enabling the nation to +build up its poetry on the proudest historic recollections. [9] The feats +of many other heroes, fabulous as well as real, were permitted to swell +the stream of traditionary verse; and thus a body of poetical annals, +springing up as it were from the depths of the people, was bequeathed from +sire to son, contributing, perhaps, more powerfully than any real history +could have done, to infuse a common principle of patriotism into the +scattered members of the nation. + +There is considerable resemblance between the early Spanish ballad and the +British. The latter affords more situations of pathos and deep tenderness, +particularly those of suffering, uncomplaining love, a favorite theme with +old English poets of every description. [10] We do not find, either, in +the ballads of the Peninsula, the wild, romantic adventures of the roving +outlaw, of the Robin Hood genus, which enter so largely into English +minstrelsy. The former are in general of a more sustained and chivalrous +character, less gloomy, and although fierce not so ferocious, nor so +decidedly tragical in their aspect, as the latter. The ballads of the Cid, +however, have many points in common with the border poetry; the same free +and cordial manner, the same love of military exploit, relieved by a +certain tone of generous gallantry, and accompanied by a strong expression +of national feeling. + +The resemblance between the minstrelsy of the two countries vanishes, +however, as we approach the Moorish ballads. The Moorish wars had always +afforded abundant themes of interest for the Castilian muse; but it was +not till the fall of the capital, that the very fountains of song were +broken up, and those beautiful ballads were produced, which seem like the +echoes of departed glory, lingering round the ruins of Granada. +Incompetent as these pieces may be as historical records, they are +doubtless sufficiently true to manners. [11] They present a most +remarkable combination, of not merely the exterior form, but the noble +spirit of European chivalry, with the gorgeousness and effeminate luxury +of the east. They are brief, seizing single situations of the highest +poetic interest, and striking the eye of the reader with a brilliancy of +execution, so artless in appearance withal as to seem rather the effect of +accident than study. We are transported to the gay seat of Moorish power, +and witness the animating bustle, its pomp and its revelry, prolonged to +the last hour of its existence. The bull-fight of the Vivarrambla, the +graceful tilt of reeds, the amorous knights with their quaint significant +devices, the dark Zegris, or Gomeres, and the royal, self-devoted +Abencerrages, the Moorish maiden radiant at the tourney, the moonlight +serenade, the stolen interview, where the lover gives vent to all the +intoxication of passion in the burning language of Arabian metaphor and +hyperbole, [12]--these, and a thousand similar scenes, are brought before +the eye, by a succession of rapid and animated touches, like the lights +and shadows of a landscape. The light trochaic structure of the +_redondilla_ [13], as the Spanish ballad measure is called, rolling +on its graceful, negligent _asonante_, [14] whose continued repetition +seems by its monotonous melody to prolong the note of feeling originally +struck, is admirably suited by its flexibility to the most varied and +opposite expression; a circumstance which has recommended it as the +ordinary measure of dramatic dialogue. + +Nothing can be more agreeable than the general effect of the Moorish +ballads, which combine the elegance of a riper period of literature, with +the natural sweetness and simplicity, savoring sometimes even of the +rudeness, of a primitive age. Their merits have raised them to a sort of +classical dignity in Spain, and have led to their cultivation by a higher +order of writers, and down to a far later period, than in any other +country in Europe. The most successful specimens of this imitation may be +assigned to the early part of the seventeenth century; but the age was too +late to enable the artist, with all his skill, to seize the true coloring +of the antique. It is impossible, at this period, to ascertain the authors +of these venerable lyrics, nor can the exact time of their production be +now determined; although, as their subjects are chiefly taken from the +last days of the Spanish Arabian empire, the larger part of them was +probably posterior, and, as they were printed in collections at the +beginning of the sixteenth century, could not have been long posterior, to +the capture of Granada. How far they may be referred to the conquered +Moors, is uncertain. Many of these wrote and spoke the Castilian with +elegance, and there is nothing improbable in the supposition, that they +should seek some solace under present evils in the splendid visions of the +past. The bulk of this poetry, however, was in all probability the +creation of the Spaniards themselves, naturally attracted by the +picturesque circumstances in the character and condition of the conquered +nation to invest them with poetic interest. + +The Moorish _romances_ fortunately appeared after the introduction of +printing into the Peninsula, so that they were secured a permanent +existence, instead of perishing with the breath that made them, like so +many of their predecessors. This misfortune, which attaches to so much of +popular poetry in all nations, is not imputable to any insensibility in +the Spaniards to the excellence of their own. Men of more erudition than +taste may have held them light, in comparison with more ostentatious and +learned productions. This fate has befallen them in other countries than +Spain. [15] But persons of finer poetic feeling, and more enlarged spirit +of criticism, have estimated them as a most essential and characteristic +portion of Castilian literature. Such was the judgment of the great Lope +de Vega, who, after expatiating on the extraordinary compass and sweetness +of the _romance_, and its adaptation to the highest subjects, commends it +as worthy of all estimation for its peculiar national character. [16] The +modern Spanish writers have adopted a similar tone of criticism, insisting +on its study, as essential to a correct appreciation and comprehension of +the genius of the language. [17] + +The Castilian ballads were first printed in the "Cancionero General" of +Fernando del Castillo, in 1511. They were first incorporated into a +separate work, by Sepulveda, under the name of "Romances sacados de +Historias Antiguas," printed at Antwerp, in 1551. [18] Since that period, +they have passed into repeated editions, at home and abroad, especially in +Germany, where they have been illustrated by able critics. [19] Ignorance +of their authors, and of the era of their production, has prevented any +attempt at exact chronological arrangement; a circumstance rendered, +moreover, nearly impossible, by the perpetual modification which the +original style of the more ancient ballads has experienced, in their +transition through successive generations; so that, with one or two +exceptions, no earlier date should probably be assigned to the oldest of +them, in their present form, than the fifteenth century. [20] Another +system of classification has been adopted, of distributing them according +to their subjects; and independent collections also of the separate +departments, as ballads of the Cid, of the Twelve Peers, the Morisco +ballads, and the like, have been repeatedly published, both at home and +abroad. [21] + +The higher and educated classes of the nation were not insensible to the +poetic spirit, which drew forth such excellent minstrelsy from the body of +the people. Indeed, Castilian poetry bore the same patrician stamp through +the whole of the present reign, which had been impressed on it in its +infancy. Fortunately, the new art of printing was employed here, as in the +case of the _romances_, to arrest those fugitive sallies of imagination, +which in other countries were permitted, from want of this care, to pass +into oblivion; and _cancioneros_, or collections of lyrics, were +published, embodying the productions of this reign and that of John the +Second, thus bringing under one view the poetic culture of the fifteenth +century. + +The earliest _cancionero_ printed was at Saragossa, in 1492. It +comprehended the works of Mena, Manrique, and six or seven other bards of +less note. [22] A far more copious collection was made by Fernando del +Castillo, and first published at Valencia, in 1511, under the title of +"Cancionero General," since which period it has passed into repeated +editions. This compilation is certainly more creditable to Castillo's +industry, than to his discrimination or power of arrangement. Indeed, in +this latter respect it is so defective, that it would almost seem to have +been put together fortuitously, as the pieces came to hand. A large +portion of the authors appear to have been persons of rank; a circumstance +to which perhaps they were indebted, more than to any poetic merit, for a +place in the miscellany, which might have been decidedly increased in +value by being diminished in bulk. [23] + +The _works of devotion_ with which the collection opens, are on the +whole the feeblest portion of it. We discern none of the inspiration and +lyric glow, which were to have been anticipated from the devout, +enthusiastic Spaniard. We meet with anagrams on the Virgin, glosses on the +creed and pater noster, _canciones_ on original sin and the like +unpromising topics, all discussed in the most bald, prosaic manner, with +abundance of Latin phrase, scriptural allusion, and commonplace precept, +unenlivened by a single spark of true poetic fire, and presenting +altogether a farrago of the most fantastic pedantry. + +The lighter, especially the amatory poems, are much more successfully +executed, and the primitive forms of the old Castilian versification are +developed with considerable variety and beauty. Among the most agreeable +effusions in this way, may be noticed those of Diego Lopez de Haro, who, +to borrow the encomium of a contemporary, was "the mirror of gallantry for +the young cavaliers of the time." There are few verses in the collection +composed with more facility and grace. [24] Among the more elaborate +pieces, Diego de San Pedro's "Desprecio de la Fortuna" may be +distinguished, not so much for any poetic talent which it exhibits, as for +its mercurial and somewhat sarcastic tone of sentiment. [25] The +similarity of subject may suggest a parallel between it and the Italian +poet Guidi's celebrated ode on Fortune; and the different styles of +execution may perhaps be taken, as indicating pretty fairly the +distinctive peculiarities of the Tuscan and the old Spanish school of +poetry. The Italian, introducing the fickle goddess, in person, on the +scene, describes her triumphant march over the ruins of empires and +dynasties, from the earliest time, in a flow of lofty dithyrambic +eloquence, adorned with all the brilliant coloring of a stimulated fancy +and a highly finished language. The Castilian, on the other hand, instead +of this splendid personification, deepens his verse into a moral tone, +and, dwelling on the vicissitudes and vanities of human life, points his +reflections with some caustic warning, often conveyed with enchanting +simplicity, but without the least approach to lyric exaltation, or indeed +the affectation of it. + +This proneness to moralize the song is in truth a characteristic of the +old Spanish bard. He rarely abandons himself, without reserve, to the +frolic puerilities so common with the sister Muse of Italy, + + "Scritta così come la penna getta, + Per fuggir l'ozio, e non per cercar gloria." + +It is true, he is occasionally betrayed by verbal subtilties and other +affectations of the age; [26] but even his liveliest sallies are apt to be +seasoned with a moral, or sharpened by a satiric sentiment. His defects, +indeed, are of the kind most opposed to those of the Italian poet, showing +themselves, especially in the more elaborate pieces, in a certain tumid +stateliness and overstrained energy of diction. + +On the whole, one cannot survey the "Cancionero General" without some +disappointment at the little progress of the poetic art, since the reign +of John the Second, at the beginning of the century. The best pieces in +the collection are of that date, and no rival subsequently arose to +compete with the masculine strength of Mena, or the delicacy and +fascinating graces of Santillana. One cause of this tardy progress may +have been the direction to utility manifested in this active reign, which +led such as had leisure for intellectual pursuits to cultivate science, +rather than abandon themselves to the mere revels of the imagination. + +Another cause may be found in the rudeness of the language, whose delicate +finish is so essential to the purposes of the poet, but which was so +imperfect at this period that Juan de la Encina, a popular writer of the +time, complained that he was obliged, in his version of Virgil's Eclogues, +to coin, as it were, a new vocabulary, from the want of terms +corresponding with the original, in the old one. [27] It was not until the +close of the present reign, when the nation began to breathe awhile from +its tumultuous career, that the fruits of the patient cultivation which it +had been steadily, though silently experiencing, began to manifest +themselves in the improved condition of the language, and its adaptation +to the highest poetical uses. The intercourse with Italy, moreover, by +naturalizing new and more finished forms of versification, afforded a +scope for the nobler efforts of the poet, to which the old Castilian +measures, however well suited to the wild and artless movements of the +popular minstrelsy, were altogether inadequate. + +We must not dismiss the miscellaneous poetry of this period, without some +notice of the "Coplas" of Don Jorge Manrique, [28] on the death of his +father, the count of Paredes, in 1474 [29]. The elegy is of considerable +length, and is sustained throughout in a tone of the highest moral +dignity, while the poet leads us up from the transitory objects of this +lower world to the contemplation of that imperishable existence, which +Christianity has opened beyond the grave. A tenderness pervades the piece, +which may remind us of the best manner of Petrarch; while, with the +exception of a slight taint of pedantry, it is exempt from the +meretricious vices that belong to the poetry of the age. The effect of the +sentiment is heightened by the simple turns and broken melody of the old +Castilian verse, of which perhaps this may be accounted the most finished +specimen; such would seem to be the judgment of his own countrymen, [30] +whose glosses and commentaries on it have swelled into a separate volume. +[31] + +I shall close this survey with a brief notice of the drama, whose +foundations may be said to have been laid during this reign. The sacred +plays, or mysteries, so popular throughout Europe in the Middle Ages, may +be traced in Spain to an ancient date. Their familiar performance in the +churches, by the clergy, is recognized in the middle of the thirteenth +century, by a law of Alfonso the Tenth, which, while it interdicted +certain profane mummeries that had come into vogue, prescribed the +legitimate topics for exhibition. [32] + +The transition from these rude spectacles to more regular dramatic +efforts, was very slow and gradual. In 1414, an allegorical comedy, +composed by the celebrated Henry, marquis of Villena, was performed at +Saragossa, in the presence of the court. [33] In 1469, a dramatic eclogue +by an anonymous author was exhibited in the palace of the count of Ureña, +in the presence of Ferdinand, on his coming into Castile to espouse the +infanta Isabella. [34] These pieces may be regarded as the earliest +theatrical attempts, after the religious dramas and popular pantomimes +already noticed; but unfortunately they have not come down to us. The next +production deserving attention is a "Dialogue between Love and an Old +Man," imputed to Rodrigo Cota, a poet of whose history nothing seems to be +known, and little conjectured, but that he flourished during the reigns of +John the Second, and Henry the Fourth. The dialogue is written with much +vivacity and grace, and with as much dramatic movement as is compatible +with only two interlocutors. [35] + +A much more memorable production is referred to the same author, the +tragicomedy of "Celestina," or "Calisto and Melibea," as it is frequently +called. The first act, indeed, constituting nearly one-third of the piece, +is all that is ascribed to Cota. The remaining twenty, which however +should rather be denominated scenes, were continued by another hand, some, +though to judge from the internal evidence afforded by the style, not many +years later. The second author was Fernando de Roxas, bachelor of law, as +he informs us, who composed this work as a sort of intellectual +relaxation, during one of his vacations. The time was certainly not +misspent. The continuation, however, is not esteemed by the Castilian +critics to have risen quite to the level of the original act. [36] + +The story turns on a love intrigue. A Spanish youth of rank is enamoured +of a lady, whose affections he gains with some difficulty, but whom he +finally seduces, through the arts of an accomplished courtesan, whom the +author has introduced under the romantic name of Celestina. The piece, +although comic, or rather sentimental in its progress, terminates in the +most tragical catastrophe, in which all the principal actors are involved. +The general texture, of the plot is exceedingly clumsy, yet it affords +many situations of deep and varied interest in its progress. The principal +characters are delineated in the piece with considerable skill. The part +of Celestina, in particular, in which a veil of plausible hypocrisy is +thrown over the deepest profligacy of conduct, is managed with much +address. The subordinate parts are brought into brisk comic action, with +natural dialogue, though sufficiently obscene; and an interest of a graver +complexion is raised by the passion of the lovers, the timid, confiding +tenderness of the lady, and the sorrows of the broken-hearted parent. The +execution of the play reminds us on the whole less of the Spanish, than of +the old English theatre, in many of its defects, as well as beauties; in +the contrasted strength and imbecility of various passages; its +intermixture of broad farce and deep tragedy; the unseasonable +introduction of frigid metaphor and pedantic allusion in the midst of the +most passionate discourses; in the unveiled voluptuousness of its +coloring, occasionally too gross for any public exhibition; but, above +all, in the general strength and fidelity of its portraiture. + +The tragicomedy, as it is styled, of Celestina, was obviously never +intended for representation, to which, not merely the grossness of some of +the details, but the length and arrangement of the piece, are unsuitable. +But, notwithstanding this, and its approximation to the character of a +romance, it must be admitted to contain within itself the essential +elements of dramatic composition; and, as such, is extolled by the Spanish +critics, as opening the theatrical career of Europe. A similar claim has +been maintained for nearly contemporaneous productions in other countries, +and especially for Politian's "Orfeo," which, there is little doubt, was +publicly acted before 1483. Notwithstanding its representation, however, +the "Orfeo," presenting a combination of the eclogue and the ode, without +any proper theatrical movement, or attempt at development of character, +cannot fairly come within the limits of dramatic writing. A more ancient +example than either, at least as far as the exterior forms are concerned, +may be probably found in the celebrated French farce of Pierre Pathelin, +printed as early as 1474, having been repeatedly played during the +preceding century, and which, with the requisite modifications, still +keeps possession of the stage. The pretensions of this piece, however, as +a work of art, are comparatively humble; and it seems fair to admit, that +in the higher and more important elements of dramatic composition, and +especially in the delicate, and at the same time powerful delineation of +character and passion, the Spanish critics may be justified in regarding +the "Celestina" as having led the way in modern Europe. [37] + +Without deciding on its proper classification as a work of art, however, +its real merits are settled by its wide popularity, both at home and +abroad. It has been translated into most of the European languages, and +the preface to the last edition, published in Madrid, so recently as 1822, +enumerates thirty editions of it in Spain alone, in the course of the +sixteenth century. Impressions were multiplied in Italy, and at the very +time when it was interdicted at home on the score of its immoral tendency. +A popularity thus extending through distant ages and nations, shows how +faithfully it is built on the principles of human nature. [38] + +The drama assumed the pastoral form, in its early stages, in Spain, as in +Italy. The oldest specimens in this way, which have come down to us, are +the productions of Juan de la Encina, a contemporary of Roxas. He was born +in 1469, and, after completing his education at Salamanca, was received +into the family of the duke of Alva. He continued there several years, +employed in the composition of various poetical works, among others, a +version of Virgil's Eclogues, which he so altered as to accommodate them +to the principal events in the reign of Ferdinand and Isabella. He visited +Italy in the beginning of the following century, and was attracted by the +munificent patronage of Leo the Tenth to fix his residence at the papal +court. While there, he continued his literary labors. He embraced the +ecclesiastical profession; and his skill in music recommended him to the +office of principal director of the pontifical chapel. He was subsequently +presented with the priory of Leon, and returned to Spain, where he died in +1534. [39] + +Encina's works first appeared at Salamanca, in 1496, collected into one +volume, folio. [40] Besides other poetry, they comprehend a number of +dramatic eclogues, sacred and profane; the former, suggested by topics +drawn from Scripture, like the ancient mysteries; the latter, chiefly +amatory. They were performed in the palace of his patron, the duke of +Alva, in the presence of Prince John, the duke of Infantado, and other +eminent persons of the court; and the poet himself occasionally assisted +at the representation. [41] + + Encina's eclogues are simple compositions, with little pretence to +dramatic artifice. The story is too meagre to admit of much ingenuity or +contrivance, or to excite any depth of interest. There are few +interlocutors, seldom more than three or four, although on one occasion +rising to as many as seven; of course, there is little scope for +theatrical action. The characters are of the humble class belonging to +pastoral life, and the dialogue, which is extremely appropriate, is +conducted with facility; but the rustic condition of the speakers +precludes anything like literary elegance or finish, in which respect they +are doubtless surpassed by some of his more ambitious compositions. There +is a comic air imparted to them, however, and a lively colloquial turn, +which renders them very agreeable. Still, whatever be their merit as +pastorals, they are entitled to little consideration as specimens of +dramatic art; and, in the vital spirit of dramatic composition, must be +regarded as far inferior to the "Celestina." The simplicity of these +productions, and the facility of their exhibition, which required little +theatrical decoration or costume, recommended them to popular imitation, +which continued long after the regular forms of the drama were introduced +into Spain. [42] + +The credit of this introduction belongs to Bartholomeo Torres de Naharro, +often confounded by the Castilian writers themselves with a player of the +same name, who flourished half a century later. [43] Few particulars have +been ascertained of his personal history. He was born at Torre, in the +province of Estremadura. In the early part of his life he fell into the +hands of the Algerines, and was finally released from captivity by the +exertions of certain benevolent Italians, who generously paid his ransom. +He then established his residence in Italy, at the court of Leo the Tenth. +Under the genial influence of that patronage, which quickened so many of +the seeds of genius to production in every department, he composed his +"Propaladia," a work embracing a variety of lyrical and dramatic poetry, +first published at Rome, in 1517. Unfortunately, the caustic satire, +levelled in some of the higher pieces of this collection at the license of +the pontifical court, brought such obloquy on the head of the author as +compelled him to take refuge in Naples, where he remained under the +protection of the noble family of Colonna. No further particulars are +recorded of him except that he embraced the ecclesiastical profession; and +the time and place of his death are alike uncertain. In person he is said +to have been comely, with an amiable disposition, and sedate and dignified +demeanor. [44] + +His "Propaladia," first published at Rome, passed through several editions +subsequently in Spain, where it was alternately prohibited, or permitted, +according to the caprice of the Holy Office. It contains, among other +things, eight comedies, written in the native _redondillas_; which +continue to be regarded as the suitable measure for the drama. They afford +the earliest example of the division into _jornadas_, or days, and of +the _intróito_, or prologue, in which the author, after propitiating +the audience by suitable compliment, and witticisms not over delicate, +gives a view of the length and general scope of his play. [45] + +The scenes of Naharro's comedies, with a single exception, are laid in +Spain and Italy; those in the latter country probably being selected with +reference to the audiences before whom they were acted. The diction is +easy and correct, without much affectation of refinement or rhetorical +ornament. The dialogue, especially in the lower parts, is sustained with +much comic vivacity; indeed, Naharro seems to have had a nicer perception +of character as it is found in lower life, than as it exists in the +higher; and more than one of his plays are devoted exclusively to its +illustration. On some occasions, however, the author assumes a more +elevated tone, and his verse rises to a degree of poetic beauty, deepened +by the moral reflection so characteristic of the Spaniards. At other +times, his pieces are disfigured by such a Babel-like confusion of +tongues, as makes it doubtful which may be the poet's vernacular. French, +Spanish, Italian, with a variety of barbarous _patois_, and mongrel +Latin, are all brought into play at the same time, and all comprehended, +apparently with equal facility, by each one of the _dramatis personae_. +But it is difficult to conceive how such a jargon could have been +comprehended, far more relished, by an Italian audience. [46] + +Naharro's comedies are not much to be commended for the intrigue, which +generally excites but a languid interest, and shows little power or +adroitness in the contrivance. With every defect, however, they must be +allowed to have given the first forms to Spanish comedy, and to exhibit +many of the features which continued to be characteristic of it in a state +of more perfect development under Lope de Vega and Calderon. Such, for +instance, is the amorous jealousy, and especially the point of honor, so +conspicuous on the Spanish theatre; and such, too, the moral confusion too +often produced by blending the foulest crimes with zeal for religion. [47] + +These comedies, moreover, far from blind conformity with the ancients, +discovered much of the spirit of independence, and deviated into many of +the eccentricities which distinguish the national theatre in later times; +and which the criticism of our own day has so successfully explained and +defended on philosophical principles. + +Naharro's plays were represented, as appears from his prologue, in Italy, +probably not at Rome, which he quitted soon after their publication, but +at Naples, which, then forming a part of the Spanish dominions, might more +easily furnish an audience capable of comprehending them. [48] It is +remarkable that, notwithstanding their repeated editions in Spain, they do +not appear to have ever been performed there. The cause of this, probably, +was the low state of the histrionic art, and the total deficiency in +theatrical costume and decoration; yet it was not easy to dispense with +these in the representation of pieces, which brought more than a score of +persons occasionally, and these crowned heads, at the same time, upon the +stage. [49] + +Some conception may be afforded of the lamentable poverty of the +theatrical equipment, from the account given of its condition, half a +century later, by Cervantes. "The whole wardrobe of a manager of the +theatre, at that time," says he, "was contained in a single sack, and +amounted only to four dresses of white fur trimmed, with gilt leather, +four beards, four wigs, and four crooks, more or less. There were no +trapdoors, movable clouds, or machinery of any kind. The stage itself +consisted only of four or six planks, placed across as many benches, +arranged in the form of a square, and elevated but four palms from the +ground. The only decoration of the theatre was an old coverlet, drawn from +side to side by cords, behind which the musicians sang some ancient +_romance_, without the guitar." [50] In fact, no further apparatus +was employed than that demanded for the exhibition of mysteries, or the +pastoral dialogues which succeeded them. The Spaniards, notwithstanding +their precocity, compared with most of the nations of Europe, in dramatic +art, were unaccountably tardy in all its histrionic accompaniments. The +public remained content with such poor mummeries, as could be got up by +strolling players and mountebanks. There was no fixed theatre in Madrid +until the latter part of the sixteenth century; and that consisted of a +courtyard, with only a roof to shelter it, while the spectators sat on +benches ranged around, or at the windows of the surrounding houses. [51] + +A similar impulse with that experienced by comic writing, was given to +tragedy. The first that entered on this department were professed +scholars, who adopted the error of the Italian dramatists, in fashioning +their pieces servilely after the antique, instead of seizing the +expression of their own age. The most conspicuous attempts in this way +were made by Fernan Perez de Oliva. [52] He was born at Cordova, in 1494, +and, after many years passed in the various schools of Spain, France, and +Italy, returned to his native land, and became a lecturer in the +university of Salamanca. He instructed in moral philosophy and +mathematics, and established the highest reputation for his critical +acquaintance with the ancient languages and his own. He died young, at the +age of thirty-nine, deeply lamented for his moral, no less than for his +intellectual worth. [53] + +His various works were published by the learned Morales, his nephew, some +fifty years after his death. Among them are translations in prose of the +Electra of Sophocles, and the Hecuba of Euripides. They may with more +propriety be termed imitations, and those too of the freest kind. Although +they conform, in the general arrangement and progress of the story, to +their originals, yet characters, nay whole scenes and dialogues, are +occasionally omitted; and in those retained, it is not always easy to +recognize the hand of the Grecian artist, whose modest beauties are thrown +into shade by the ambitious ones of his imitator. [54] But with all this, +Oliva's tragedies must be admitted to be executed, on the whole, with +vigor; and the diction, notwithstanding the national tendency to +exaggeration above alluded to, may be generally commended for decorum and +an imposing dignity, quite worthy of the tragic drama; indeed, they may be +selected as affording probably the best specimen of the progress of prose +composition during the present reign. [55] + +Oliva's reputation led to a similar imitation of the antique. But the +Spaniards were too national in all their tastes to sanction it. These +classical compositions did not obtain possession of the stage, but were +confined to the closet, serving only as a relaxation for the man of +letters; while the voice of the people compelled all who courted it, to +accommodate their inventions to those romantic forms, which were +subsequently developed in such variety of beauty by the great Spanish +dramatists. [56] + +We have now surveyed the different kinds of poetic culture familiar to +Spain under Ferdinand and Isabella. Their most conspicuous element is the +national spirit which pervades them, and the exclusive attachment which +they manifest to the primitive forms of versification peculiar to the +Peninsula. The most remarkable portion of this body of poetry may +doubtless be considered the Spanish _romances_, or ballads; that +popular minstrelsy, which, commemorating the picturesque and chivalrous +incidents of the age, reflects most faithfully the romantic genius of the +people who gave it utterance. The lyric efforts of the period were less +successful. There were few elaborate attempts in this field, indeed, by +men of decided genius. But the great obstacle may be found in the +imperfection of the language and the deficiency of the more exact and +finished metrical forms, indispensable to high poetic execution. + +The whole period, however, comprehending, as it does, the first decided +approaches to a regular drama, may be regarded as very important in a +literary aspect; since it exhibits the indigenous peculiarities of +Castilian literature in all their freshness, and shows to what a degree of +excellence it could attain, while untouched by any foreign influence. The +present reign may be regarded as the epoch which divides the ancient from +the modern school of Spanish poetry; in which the language was slowly but +steadily undergoing the process of refinement, that "made the knowledge of +it," to borrow the words of a contemporary critic, "pass for an elegant +accomplishment, even with the cavaliers and dames of cultivated Italy;" +[57] and which finally gave full scope to the poetic talent, that raised +the literature of the country to such brilliant heights in the sixteenth +century. + + * * * * * + +I have had occasion to advert more than once in the course of this chapter +to the superficial acquaintance of the Spanish critics with the early +history of their own drama, authentic materials for which are so extremely +rare and difficult of access, as to preclude the expectation of anything +like a satisfactory account of it out of the Peninsula. The nearest +approach to this within my knowledge is made in an article in the eighth +number of the American Quarterly Review, ascribed to Mr. Ticknor, late +Professor of Modern Literature in Harvard University. This gentleman, +during a residence in the Peninsula, had every facility for replenishing +his library with the most curious and valuable works, both printed and +manuscript, in this department; and his essay embodies in a brief compass +the results of a well-directed industry, which he has expanded in greater +detail in his lectures on Spanish literature, delivered before the classes +of the University. The subject is discussed with his usual elegance and +perspicuity of style; and the foreign, and indeed Castilian scholar, may +find much novel information there, in the views presented of the early +progress of the dramatic and the histrionic art in the Peninsula. + +Since the publication of this article, Moratin's treatise, so long and +anxiously expected, "Orígenes del Teatro Español," has made its appearance +under the auspices of the Royal Academy of History, which has enriched the +national literature with so many admirable editions of its ancient +authors. Moratin states in his Preface, that he was employed from his +earliest youth in collecting notices, both at home and abroad, of whatever +might illustrate the origin of the Spanish drama. The results have been +two volumes, containing in the First Part an historical discussion, with +ample explanatory notes, and a catalogue of dramatic pieces from the +earliest epoch down to the time of Lope de Vega, chronologically arranged, +and accompanied with critical analyses, and copious illustrative extracts +from pieces of the greatest merit. The Second Part is devoted to the +publication of entire pieces of various authors, which from their extreme +rarity, or their existence only in manuscript, have had but little +circulation. The selections throughout are made with that careful +discrimination, which resulted from poetic talent combined with extensive +and thorough erudition. The criticisms, although sometimes warped by the +peculiar dramatic principles of the author, are conducted in general with +great fairness; and ample, but not extravagant, commendation is bestowed +on productions, whose merit, to be properly appreciated, must be weighed +by one conversant with the character and intellectual culture of the +period. The work unfortunately did not receive the last touches of its +author, and undoubtedly something may be found wanting to the full +completion of his design. On the whole, it must be considered as a rich +repertory of old Castilian literature, much of it of the most rare and +recondite nature, directed to the illustration of a department, that has +hitherto been suffered to languish in the lowest obscurity, but which is +now so arranged that it may be contemplated, as it were, under one aspect, +and its real merits accurately determined. + +It was not till some time after the publication of this History, that my +attention was called to that portion of the writings of Don Martinez de la +Rosa, in which he criticizes the various departments of the national +literature. This criticism is embodied in the annotations and appendix to +his elegant "Poetica" (Obras Literarias, (Paris, 1827,) tom. i. ii.) The +former discuss the general laws, by which the various kinds of poetry are +to be regulated; the latter presents a very searching and scientific +analysis of the principal productions of the Spanish poets, down to the +close of the last century. The critic exemplifies his own views by copious +extracts from the subjects of his criticism, and throws much collateral +light on the argument by illustrations borrowed from foreign literature. +In the examination of the Spanish drama, especially comedy, which he +modestly qualifies as a "succinct notice, not very exact," he is very +elaborate; and discovers the same taste and sagacity in estimating the +merits of individual writers, which he had shown in discussing the general +principles of the art. Had I read his work sooner, it would have greatly +facilitated my own inquiries in the same obscure path; and I should have +recognized, at least, one brilliant exception to my sweeping remark on the +apathy manifested by the Castilian scholars to the antiquities of the +national drama. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Eichhorn, Geschichte der Kultur und Litteratur der Neueren Europa, +(Göttingen, 1796-1811,) pp. 129, 130.--See also the conclusion of the +Introduction, Sec. 2, of this History. + +[2] Nic. Antonio seems unwilling to relinquish the pretensions of his own +nation to the authorship of this romance. (See Bibliotheca Nova, tom. ii. +p. 394.) Later critics, and among them Lampillas, (Ensayo Historico- +Apologético de la Literatura Española, (Madrid, 1789,) tom. v. p. 168,) +who resigns no more than he is compelled to do, are less disposed to +contest the claims of the Portuguese. Mr. Southey has cited two documents, +one historical, the other poetical, which seem to place its composition by +Lobeira in the latter part of the fourteenth century beyond any reasonable +doubt. (See Amadis of Gaul, pref.,--also Sarmiento, Memorias para la +Historia de la Poesía y Poetas Españoles, Obras Posthumas, (Madrid, 1775,) +tom. i. p. 239.) Bouterwek, and after him Sismondi, without adducing any +authority, have fixed the era of Lobeira's death at 1325. Dante, who died +but four years previous to that date, furnishes a negative argument, at +least, against this, since, in his notice of some doughty names of +chivalry then popular, he makes no allusion to Amadis, the best of all. +Inferno, cantos v., xxxi. + +[3] The excellent old romance "Tirante the White," _Tirant lo Blanch_, was +printed at Valencia in 1490. (See Mendez, Typographia Española, tom. i. +pp. 72-75.) If, as Cervantes asserts, the "Amadis" was the first book of +chivalry printed in Spain, it must have been anterior to this date. This +is rendered probable by Montalvo's prologue to his edition at Saragossa, +in 1521, still preserved in the royal library at Madrid, where he alludes +to his former publication of it in the time of Ferdinand and Isabella. +(Cervantes, Don Quixote, ed. Pellicer, Discurso Prelim.) + +Mr. Dunlop, who has analyzed these romances with a patience that more will +be disposed to commend than imitate, has been led into the error of +supposing that the first edition of the "Amadis" was printed at Seville, +in 1526, from detached fragments appearing in the time of Ferdinand and +Isabella, and subsequently by Montalvo, at Salamanca, in 1547. See History +of Prose Fiction, vol. ii. chap. 10. + +[4] The following is Montalvo's brief prologue to the introduction of the +first book. "Aqvi comiença el primero libro del esforçado et virtuoso +cauallero Amadis hijo del rey Perion de Gaula; y dela reyna Elisena: el +qual fue coregido y emendado por el honrado y virtuoso cauallero +Garciordoñes de Montalvo, regidor dela noble uilla de Medina del campo; et +corregiole delos antiguos originales que estauan corruptos, et compuestos +en antiguo estilo: por falta delos diferentes escriptores. Quitando muchas +palabras superfluas; et poniendo otras de mas polido y elegante estilo: +tocantes ala caualleria et actos della, animando los coraçones gentiles de +manzebos belicosos que con grandissimo affetto abrazan el arte dela +milicia corporal animando la immortal memoria del arte de caualleria no +menos honestissimo que glorioso." Amadis de Gaula, (Venecia, 1533,) fol. +1. + +[5] Nic. Antonio enumerates the editions of thirteen of this doughty +family of knights-errant. (Bibliotheca Nova, tom. ii. pp. 394, 395.) He +dismisses his notice with the reflection, somewhat more charitable than +that of Don Quixote's curate, that "he had felt little interest in +investigating these fables, yet was willing to admit, with others, that +their reading was not wholly useless." + +Moratin has collected an appalling catalogue of _part_ of the books +of chivalry published in Spain at the close of the fifteenth and the +following century. The first on the list is the _Carcel de Amor_, por +Diego Hernandez de San Pedro, en Burgos, año de 1496. Obras, tom. i. pp. +93-98. + +[6] Cervantes, Don Quixote, tom. i. part. 1, cap. 6. + +The curate's wrath is very emphatically expressed. "Pues vayan todos al +corral, dixo el Cura, que a trueco de quemar a la reyna Pintiquïniestra, y +al pastor Darinel y a sus eglogas, y a las endiabladas y revueltas razones +de su autor, quemara con ellos al padre que me engendro si andubiera en +figura de caballero andante." The author of the "Dialogo de las Lenguas" +chimes in with the same tone of criticism. "Los quales," he says, speaking +of books of chivalry, "de mas de ser mentirossissimos, son tal mal +compuestos, assi por dezir las mentiras tan desvergonçadas, como por tener +el estilo desbaraçado, que no ay buen estomago que lo pueda leer." Apud +Mayans y Siscar, Orígenes, tom. ii. p. 158. + +[7] The labors of Bowles, Rios, Arrieta, Pellicer, and Navarrete would +seem to have left little to desire in regard to the illustration of +Cervantes. But the commentaries of Clemencin, published since this chapter +was written, in 1833, show how much yet remained to be supplied. They +afford the most copious illustrations, both literary and historical, of +his author, and exhibit that nice taste in verbal criticism, which is not +always joined with such extensive erudition. Unfortunately, the premature +death of Clemencin has left the work unfinished; but the fragment +completed, which reaches to the close of the First Part, is of sufficient +value permanently to associate the name of its author with that of the +greatest genius of his country. + +[8] The fabliaux cannot fairly be considered as an exception to this. +These graceful little performances, the work of professed bards, who had +nothing further in view than the amusement of a listless audience, have +little claim to be considered as the expression of national feeling or +sentiment. The poetry of the south of France, more impassioned and lyrical +in its character, wears the stamp, not merely of patrician elegance, but +refined artifice, which must not be confounded with the natural flow of +popular minstrelsy. + +[9] How far the achievements claimed for the Campeador are strictly true, +is little to the purpose. It is enough that they were received as true, +throughout the Peninsula, as far back as the twelfth, or, at latest, the +thirteenth century. + +[10] One exception, among others, readily occurs in the pathetic old +ballad of the Conde Alarcos, whose woful catastrophe, with the unresisting +suffering of the countess, suggests many points of coincidence with the +English minstrelsy. The English reader will find a version of it in the +"Ancient Poetry and Romances of Spain," from the pen of Mr. Bowring, to +whom the literary world is so largely indebted for an acquaintance with +the popular minstrelsy of Europe. + +[11] I have already noticed the insufficiency of the _romances_ to +authentic history, Part I. Chap. 8, Note 30. My conclusions there have +been confirmed by Mr. Irving, (whose researches have led him in a similar +direction,) in his "Alhambra," published nearly a year after the above +note was written. + +The great source of the popular misconceptions respecting the domestic +history of Granada is Gines Perez de Hyta, whose work, under the title of +"Historia de los Vandos de los Zegries y Abencerrages, Cavalleros Moros de +Granada, y las Guerras Civiles que huvo en ella," was published at Alcalá +in 1604. This romance, written in prose, embodied many of the old Moorish +ballads in it, whose singular beauty, combined with the romantic and +picturesque character of the work itself, soon made it extremely popular, +until at length it seems to have acquired a degree of the historical +credit claimed for it by its author as a translation from an Arabian +chronicle; a credit which has stood it in good stead with the tribe of +travel-mongers and _raconteurs_, persons always of easy faith, who +have propagated its fables far and wide. Their credulity, however, may be +pardoned in what has imposed on the perspicacity of so cautions an +historian as Müller. Allgemeine Geschichte, (1817,) band ii. p. 504. + +[12] Thus, in one of their _romances_, we have a Moorish lady "shedding +drops of liquid silver, and scattering her hair of Arabian gold" over the +corpse of her murdered husband! + + "Sobre el cuerpo de Albencayde + Destila liquida plata, + Y convertida en cabellos + Esparce el oro de Arabia." + +Can anything be more Oriental than this imagery? In another we have "an +hour of years of impatient hopes;" a passionate sally, that can scarcely +be outmatched by Scriblerus. This taint of exaggeration, however, so far +from being peculiar to the popular minstrelsy, has found its way, probably +through this channel in part, into most of the poetry of the Peninsula. + +[13] The _redondilla_ may be considered as the basis of Spanish +versification. It is of great antiquity, and compositions in it are still +extant, as old as the time of the infante Don Manuel, at the close of the +thirteenth century. (See Cancionero General, fol. 207.) The redondilla +admits of great variety; but in the romances it is most frequently found +to consist of eight syllables, the last foot, and some or all of the +preceding, as the case may be, being trochees. (Rengifo, Arte Poetica +Espanola, (Barcelona, 1727,) cap. 9, 44.) Critics have derived this +delightful measure from various sources. Sarmiento traces it to the +hexameter of the ancient Romans, which may be bisected into something +analogous to the redondillas. (Memorias, pp. 168-171.) Bouterwek thinks it +may have been suggested by the songs of the Roman soldiery. (Geschichte +der Poesie und Beredsamkeit, band iii., Einleitung, p. 20.)--Velazquez +borrows it from the rhyming hexameters of the Spanish Latin poets, of +which he gives specimens of the beginning of the fourteenth century. +(Poesía Castellana, pp. 77, 78.) Later critics refer its derivation to the +Arabic. Conde has given a translation of certain Spanish-Arabian poems, in +the measure of the original, from which it is evident, that the hemistich +of an Arabian verse corresponds perfectly with the redondilla. (See his +Dominacion de los Arabes, passim.) The same author, in a treatise, which +he never published, on the "poesía oriental," shows more precisely the +intimate affinity subsisting between the metrical form of the Arabian and +the old Castilian verse. The reader will find an analysis of his +manuscript in Part I. Chap. 8, Note 49, of this History. + +This theory is rendered the more plausible by the influence which the +Arabic has exercised on Castilian versification in other respects, as in +the prolonged repetition of the rhyme, for example, which is wholly +borrowed from the Spanish Arabs; whose superior cultivation naturally +affected the unformed literature of their neighbors, and through no +channel more obviously than its popular minstrelsy. + +[14] The _asonante_ is a rhyme made by uniformity of the vowels, without +reference to the consonants; the regular rhyme, which obtains in other +European literatures, is distinguished in Spain by the term _consonante_. +Thus the four following words, taken at random from a Spanish ballad, are +consecutive _asonantes_; _regozijo_, _pellico_, _luzido_, _amarillo_. In +this example, the two last syllables have the assonance; although this is +not invariable, it sometimes falling on the antepenultima and the final +syllable. (See Rengifo, Arte Poética Española, pp. 214, 215, 218.) There +is a wild, artless melody in the _asonante_, and a graceful movement +coming somewhere, as it does, betwixt regular rhyme and blank verse, which +would make its introduction very desirable, but not very feasible, in our +own language. An attempt of the kind has been made by a clever writer, in +the Retrospective Review. (Vol. iv. art. 2.) If it has failed, it is from +the impediments presented by the language, which has not nearly the same +amount of vowel terminations, nor of simple uniform vowel sounds, as the +Spanish; the double termination, however full of grace and beauty in the +Castilian, assumes, perhaps from the effect of association, rather a +doggerel air in the English. + +[15] This may be still further inferred from the tenor of a humorous, +satirical old _romance_, in which the writer implores the justice of +Apollo on the heads of the swarm of traitor poets, who have deserted the +ancient themes of song, the Cids, the Laras, the Gonzalez, to celebrate +the Ganzuls and Abderrahmans and the fantastical fables of the Moors. + + "Tanta Zayda y Adalifa, + tanta Draguta y Daraxa, + tanto Azarque y tanto Adulce, + tanto Gazul, y Abenamar, + tanto alquizer y marlota, + tanto almayzar, y almalafa, + tantas emprisas y plumas, + tantas cifras y medallas, + tanta roperia Mora. + Y en vanderillas y adargas, + tanto mote, y tantas motas + muera yo sino me cansan." + + * * * * * + + "Los Alfonsos, los Henricos, + los Sanchos, y los de Lara, + que es dellos, y que es del Cid? + tanto olvido en glorias tantas? + ninguna pluma las buela, + ninguna Musa las canta? + Justicia, Apollo, justicia, + vengadores rayos lança + contra Poetas Moriscos." + +Dr. Johnson's opinions are well known, in regard to this department of +English literature, which, by his ridiculous parodies, he succeeded for a +time in throwing into the shade, or, in the language of his admiring +biographer, made "perfectly contemptible." + +Petrarch, with like pedantry, rested his hopes of fame on his Latin epic, +and gave away his lyrics, as alms to ballad-singers. Posterity, deciding +on surer principles of taste, has reversed both these decisions. + +[16] "Algunos quieren que sean la cartilla de los Poetas; yo no lo siento +assi; antes bien los hallo capaces, no solo de exprimir y declarar +qualquier concepto con facil dulzura, pero de prosequir toda grave accion +de numeroso Poema. Y soy tan de veras Español, que por ser en nuestro +idioma natural este genero, no me puedo persuadir que no sea digno de toda +estimacion."(Coleccion de Obras Sueltas, (Madrid, 1776-9,) tom. iv. p. +176, Prólogo.) In another place he finely styles them "Iliads without a +Homer." + +[17] See, among others, the encomiastic and animated criticism of +Fernandez and Quintana. Fernandez, Poesías Escogidas, de Nuestros +Cancioneros y Romanceros Antiguos, (Madrid, 1796,) tom. xvi., Prólogo.-- +Quintana, Poesías Selectas Castellanas, Introd. art. 4. + +[18] Nic. Antonio, Bibliotheca Nova, tom. ii. p. 10.--The Spanish +translators of Bouterwek have noticed the principal "collections and +earliest editions" of the _Romances_. This original edition of Sepulveda +has escaped their notice. See Literatura Española, pp. 217, 218. + +[19] See Grimm, Depping, Herder, etc. This last poet has embraced a +selection of the Cid ballads, chronologically arranged, and translated +with eminent simplicity and spirit, if not with the scrupulous fidelity +usually aimed at by the Germans. See his Sämmtliche Werke, (Wien, 1813,) +band iii. + +[20] Sarmiento, Memorias, pp. 242, 243.--Moratin considers that none have +come down to us, in their original costume, of an earlier date than John +II.'s reign, the first half of the fifteenth century. (Obras, tom. i. p. +84.) The Spanish translators of Bouterwek transcribe a _romance_, +relating to the Cid, from the fathers Berganza and Merino, purporting to +exhibit the primitive, uncorrupted diction of the thirteenth century. +Native critics are of course the only ones competent to questions of this +sort; but, to the less experienced eye of a foreigner, the style of this +ballad would seem to resemble much less that genuine specimen of the +versification of the preceding age, the poem of the Cid, than the +compositions of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. + +[21] The principle of philosophical arrangement, if it may so be called, +is pursued still further in the latest Spanish publications of the +_romances_, where the Moorish minstrelsy is embodied in a separate +volume, and distributed with reference to its topics. This system is the +more practicable with this class of ballads, since it far exceeds in +number any other. See Duran, Romancero de Romances Moriscos. + +The Romancero I have used is the ancient edition of Medina del Campo, +1602. It is divided into nine parts, though it is not easy to see on what +principle, since the productions of most opposite date and tenor are +brought into juxtaposition. The collection contains nearly a thousand +ballads, which, however, fall far short of the entire number preserved, as +may easily be seen by reference to other compilations. When to this is +added the consideration of the large number which insensibly glided into +oblivion without ever coming to the press, one may form a notion of the +immense mass of these humble lyrics, which floated among the common people +of Spain; and we shall be the less disposed to wonder at the proud and +chivalrous bearing that marks even the peasantry of a nation, which seems +to breathe the very air of romantic song. + +[22] The title of this work was "Coplas de Vita Christi, de la Cena con la +Pasion, y de la Veronica con la Resurreccion de nuestro Redemtor. E las +siete Angustias e siete Gozos de nuestra Señora, con otras obras mucho +provechosas." It concludes with the following notice, "Fue la presente +obra emprentada en la insigne Ciudad de Zaragoza de Aragon por industria e +expensas de Paulo Hurus de Constancia aleman. A 27 dias de Noviembre, +1492." (Mendez, Typographia Española, pp. 134, 136.) It appears there were +two or three other cancioneros compiled, none of which, however, were +admitted to the honors of the press. (Bouterwek, Literatura Española, +nota.) The learned Castro, some fifty years since, published an analysis +with copious extracts from one of these made by Baena, the Jewish +physician of John II., a copy of which existed in the royal library of the +Escurial. Bibliotheca Española, tom. i. p. 265 et seq. + +[23] Cancionero General, passim.--Moratin has given a list of the men of +rank who contributed to this miscellany; it contains the names of the +highest nobility of Spain. (Orig. del Teatro Español, Obras, tom. i. pp. +85, 86.) Castillo's Cancionero passed through several editions, the latest +of which appeared in 1573. See a catalogue, not entirely complete, of the +different Spanish Cancioneros in Bouterwek, Literatura Española, trad., p. +217. + +[24] Cancionero General, pp. 83-89.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS. + +[25] Cancionero General, pp. 158-161.--Some meagre information of this +person is given by Nic. Antonio, whose biographical notices may be often +charged with deficiency in chronological data; a circumstance perhaps +unavoidable from the obscurity of their subjects. Biblioteca Vetus, tom. +ii. lib. 10, cap. 6. + +[26] There are probably more direct puns in Petrarch's lyrics alone, than +in all the Cancionero General. There is another kind of _niaiserie_, +however, to which the Spanish poets were much addicted, being the +transposition of the word in every variety of sense and combination; as, +for example, + + "Acordad Vuestros olvidos + Y olvida vuestros acuerdos + Porque tales desacuerdos + Acuerden vuestros sentidos," etc. + +Cancionero General, fol. 226. + +It was such subtilties as these, _entricadas razones_, as Cervantes +calls them, that addled the brains of poor Don Quixote. Tom. i. cap. 1. + +[27] Velasquez, Poesía Castellana, p. 122.--More than half a century +later, the learned Ambrosio Morales complained of the barrenness of the +Castilian, which he imputed to the too exclusive adoption of the Latin +upon all subjects of dignity and importance. Obras, tom. xiv. pp. 147, +148. + +[28] L. Marineo, speaking of this accomplished nobleman, styles him "virum +satis illustrem.--Eum enim poetam et philosophum natura formavit ac +peperit." He unfortunately fell in a skirmish, five years after his +father's death, in 1479. Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. p. 531. + +[29] An elaborate character of this Quixotic old cavalier may be found in +Pulgar, Claros Varones, tit. 13. + +[30] "Don Jorge Manrique," says Lope de Vega, "cuyas coplas Castellanas +admiren los ingenios estrangeros y merecen estar escritas con letras de +oro." Obras Sueltas, tom. xii. Prólogo. + +[31] Coplas de Don Jorge Manrique, ed. Madrid, 1779.--Diálogo de las +Lenguas, apud Mayans y Siscar, Orígenes, tom. ii. p. 149.--Manrique's +Coplas have also been the subject of a separate publication in the United +States. Professor Longfellow's version, accompanying it, is well +calculated to give the English reader a correct notion of the Castilian +bard, and, of course, a very exaggerated one of the literary culture of +the age. + +[32] After proscribing certain profane mummeries, the law confines the +clergy to the representation of such subjects as "the birth of our +Saviour, in which is shown how the angels appeared, announcing his +nativity; also his advent, and the coming of the three Magi kings to +worship him; and his resurrection, showing his crucifixion and ascension +on the third day; and other such things leading men to do well and live +constant in the faith." (Siete Partidas, tit. 6, ley 34.) It is worth +noting, that similar abuses continued common among the ecclesiastics, down +to Isabella's reign, as may be inferred from a decree, very similar to the +law of the Partidas above cited, published by the council of Aranda, in +1473. (Apud Moratin, Obras, tom. i. p. 87.) Moratin considers it certain, +that the representation of the mysteries existed in Spain, as far back as +the eleventh century. The principal grounds for this conjecture appear to +be, the fact that such notorious abuses had crept into practice by the +middle of the thirteenth century, as to require the intervention of the +law. (Ibid., pp. 11, 13.) The circumstance would seem compatible with a +much more recent origin. + +[33] Cervantes, Comedias y Entremeses, (Madrid, 1749,) tom. i. prólogo de +Nasarre.--Velazquez, Poesía Castellana, p. 86.--The fifth volume of the +Memoirs of the Spanish Royal Academy of History contains a dissertation on +the "national diversions," by Don Gaspar Melchor de Jovellanos, replete +with curious erudition, and exhibiting the discriminating taste to have +been expected from its accomplished author. Among these antiquarian +researches, the writer has included a brief view of the first theatrical +attempts in Spain. See Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. v. Mem. 6. + +[34] Moratin, Obras, tom. i. p. 115.--Nasarre (Cervantes, Comedias, +pról.), Jovellanos (Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. v. Memor. 6), Pellicer +(Orígen y Progreso de la Comedia, (1804,) tom. i. p. 12), and others, +refer the authorship of this little piece, without hesitation, to Juan de +la Encina, although the year of its representation corresponds precisely +with that of his birth. The prevalence of so gross a blunder among the +Spanish scholars, shows how little the antiquities of their theatre were +studied before the time of Moratin. + +[35] This little piece has been published at length by Moratin, in the +first volume of his works. (See Orígenes del Teatro Español, Obras, tom. +i. pp. 303-314.) + +The celebrated marquis of Santillana's poetical dialogue, "Comedieta da +Ponza," has no pretensions to rank as a dramatic composition, +notwithstanding its title, which is indeed as little significant of its +real character, as the term "Commedia" is of Dante's epic. It is a +discourse on the vicissitudes of human life, suggested by a sea-fight near +Ponza, in 1435. It is conducted without any attempt at dramatic action or +character, or, indeed, dramatic development of any sort. The same remarks +may be made of the political satire, "Mingo Revulgo," which appeared in +Henry IV.'s reign. Dialogue was selected by these authors as a more +popular and spirited medium than direct narrative for conveying their +sentiments. The "Comedieta da Ponza" has never appeared in print; the copy +which I have used is a transcript from the one in the royal library at +Madrid, and belongs to Mr. George Ticknor. + +[36] Tragicomedia de Calisto y Melibea, (Alcalá, 1586,) Introd.--Nothing +is positively ascertained respecting the authorship of the first act of +the Celestina. Some impute it to Juan de Mena; others with more +probability to Rodrigo Cota el Tio, of Toledo, a person who, although +literally nothing is known of him, has in some way or other obtained the +credit of the authorship of some of the most popular effusions of the +fifteenth century; such, for example, as the Dialogue above cited of "Love +and an Old Man," the Coplas of "Mingo Revulgo," and this first act of the +"Celestina." The principal foundation of these imputations would appear to +be the bare assertion of an editor of the "Dialogue between Love and an +Old Man," which appeared at Medina del Campo, in 1569, nearly a century, +probably, after Cota's death; another example of the obscurity which +involves the history of the early Spanish drama. Many of the Castilian +critics detect a flavor of antiquity in the first act which should carry +back its composition as far as John II.'s reign. Moratin does not discern +this, however, and is inclined to refer its production to a date not much +more distant, if any, than Isabella's time. To the unpractised eye of a +foreigner, as far as style is concerned, the whole work might well seem +the production of the same period. Moratin, Obras, tom. i. pp. 88, 115, +116.--Diálogo de las Lenguas, apud Mayans y Siscar, Orígenes, pp. 165- +167.--Nic. Antonio, Bibliotheca Nova, tom. ii. p. 263. + +[37] Such is the high encomium of the Abate Andres, (Letteratura, tom. v. +part. 2, lib. 1.)--Cervantes does not hesitate to call it "libro divino;" +and the acute author of the "Diálogo de las Lenguas" concludes a criticism +upon it with the remark, that "there is no book in the Castilian which +surpasses it in the propriety and elegance of its diction." (Don Quixote, +ed. de Pellicer, tom. i., p. 239.--Mayans y Siscar, tom. ii. p. 167.) + +Its merits indeed seem in some degree to have disarmed even the severity +of foreign critics; and Signorelli, after standing up stoutly in defence +of the precedence of the "Orfeo" as a dramatic composition, admits the +"Celestina" to be a "work, rich in various beauties, and meriting +undoubted applause. In fact," he continues, "the vivacity of the +description of character, and faithful portraiture of manners, have made +it immortal." Storia Critica de' Teatri Antichi e Moderni, (Napoli, 1813,) +tom. vi. pp. 146, 147. + +[38] Bouterwek, Literatura Española, notas de traductores, p. 234.-- +Andres, Letteratura, tom. v. pp. 170, 171.--Lampillas, Letteratura +Spagnuola, tom. vi. pp. 57-59. + +[39] Rojas, Viage Entretenido, (1614,) fol. 46.--Nic. Antonio, Bibliotheca +Nova, tom. i. p. 684.--Moratin, Obras, tom. i. pp. 126, 127.--Pellicer, +Orígen de la Comedia, tom. i. pp. 11, 12. + +[40] They were published under the title "Cancionero de todas las Obras de +Juan de la Encina con otras añadidas." (Mendez, Typographia Española, p. +247.) Subsequent impressions of his works, more or less complete, appeared +at Salamanca in 1509, and at Saragossa in 1512 and 1516.--Moratin, Obras, +tom. i. p. 127, nota. + +[41] The comedian Rojas, who flourished in the beginning of the following +century, and whose "Viage Entretenido" is so essential to the knowledge of +the early histrionic art in Spain, identifies the appearance of Encina's +Eclogues with the dawn of the Castilian drama. His verses may be worth +quoting. + + "Que es en nuestra madre España, + porque en la dichosa era, + que aquellos gloriosos Reyes + dignos de memoria eterna + Don Fernando e Ysabel + (que ya con los santos reynan) + de echar de España acabavan + todos los Moriscos, que eran + De aquel Reyno de Granada, + y entonces se dava en ella + princípio a la Inquisicion, + se le dio a nuestra comedia. + Juan de la Encina el primero, + aquel insigne poeta, + que tanto bien empezo + de quien tenemos tres eglogas + Que el mismo represento + al Almirante y Duquessa + de Castilla, y de Infantado + que estas fueron las primeras + Y para mas honra suya, + y de la comedia nuestra, + en los dias que Colon + descubrio la gran riqueza + De Indias y nuevo mundo, + y el gran Capitan empieza, + a sugetar aquel Reyno + de Napoles, y su tierra. + A descubrirse empezo + el uso de la comedia + porque todos se animassen + a emprender cosas tan buenas." + +Fol. 46, 47. + +[42] Signorelli, correcting what he denominates the "romance" of +Lampillas, considers Encina to have composed only one pastoral drama, and +that, on occasion of Ferdinand's entrance into Castile. The critic should +have been more charitable, as he has made two blunders himself in +correcting one. Storia Critica de' Teatri, tom. iv. pp. 192, 193. + +[43] Andres, confounding Torres de Naharro, the poet, with Naharro the +comedian, who flourished about half a century later, is led into a +ludicrous train of errors in controverting Cervantes, whose criticism of +the actor is perpetually misapplied by Andres to the poet. Velasquez seems +to have confounded them in like manner. Another evidence of the extremely +superficial acquaintance of the Spanish critics with their early drama. +Comp. Cervantes, Comedias y Entremeses, tom. i. prólogo.--Andres, +Letteratura, tom. v. p. 179.--Velazquez, Poesía Castellana, p. 88. + +[44] Nic. Antonio, Bibliotheca Nova, tom. i. p. 202.--Cervantes, Comedias, +tom. i. pról. de Nasarre.--Pellicer, Orígen de la Comedia, tom. ii. p. +17.--Moratin, Obras, tom. i. p. 48. + +[45] Bartolomé Torres de Naharro, Propaladia, (Madrid, 1573.)--The +deficiency of the earlier Spanish books, of which Bouterwek repeatedly +complains, has led him into an error respecting the "Propaladia," which he +had never seen. He states that Naharro was the first to distribute the +play into three jornadas or acts, and takes Cervantes roundly to task for +assuming the original merit of this distribution to himself. In fact, +Naharro did introduce the division into _five_ jornadas, and Cervantes +assumes only the credit of having been the first to _reduce them to +three_. Comp. Bouterwek, Geschichte der Poesie und Beredsamkeit, band iii. +p. 285,--and Cervantes, Comedias, tom. i. pról. + +[46] In the argument to the "Seraphina," he thus prepares the audience for +this colloquial _olla podrida_. + + "Mas haveis de estar alerta + por sentir los personages + que hablan quatro lenguages, + hasta acabar su rehyerta + no salen de cuenta cierta + por Latin e Italiano + Castellano y Valenciano + que ninguno desconcierta." + +Propaladia, p. 50. + +[47] The following is an example of the precious reasoning with which +Floristan, in the play above quoted, reconciles his conscience to the +murder of his wife Orfea, in order to gratify the jealousy of his mistress +Seraphina. Floristan is addressing himself to a priest. + + "Y por mas daño escusar + no lo quiero hora hazer, + sino que es menester, + que yo mate luego a Orfea + do Serafina lo vea + porque lo pueda creer. + Que yo bien me mataria, + pues toda razon me inclina; + pero se de Serafina + que se desesperaría. + y Orfea, pues que haria? + quando mi muerte supiesse; + que creo que no pudiesse + sostener la vida un dia. + Pues hablando aca entre nos + a Orfea cabe la suerte; + porque con su sola muerte + se escusaran otras dos: + de modo que padre vos + si llamar me la quereys, + a mi merced me hareys + y tambien servicio a dios. + + * * * * * + + porque si yo la matare + morira christianamente; + yo morire penitente, + quando mi suerte llegare." + +Propaladia, fol. 68. + +[48] Signorelli waxes exceedingly wroth with Don Blas Nasarre for the +assertion, that Naharro first taught the Italians to write comedy, taxing +him with downright mendacity; and he stoutly denies the probability of +Naharro's comedies ever having been performed on the Italian boards. The +critic seems to be in the right, as far as regards the influence of the +Spanish dramatist; but he might have been spared all doubts respecting +their representation in the country, had he consulted the prologue of +Naharro himself, where he asserts the fact in the most explicit manner. +Comp. Propaladia, pról., and Signorelli, Storia Critica de' Teatri, tom. +vi. pp. 171-179.--See also Moratin, Orígenes, Obras, tom. i. pp. 149, 150. + +[49] Propaladia; see the comedies of "Trofea" and "Tinelaria."-- +Jovellanos, Memoria sobre las Diversiones Públicas, apud Mem. de la Acad. +de Hist., tom. v. + +[50] Cervantes, Comedias, tom. i. pról. + +[51] Pellicer, Orígen de la Comedia, tom. ii. pp. 58-62.--See also +American Quarterly Review, no. viii. art. 3. + +[52] Oliva, Obras, (Madrid, 1787.)--Vasco Diaz Tanco, a native of +Estremadura, who flourished in the first half of the sixteenth century, +mentions in one of his works three tragedies composed by himself on +Scripture subjects. As there is no evidence, however, of their having been +printed, or performed, or even read in manuscript by any one, they hardly +deserve to be included in the catalogue of dramatic compositions. +(Moratin, Obras, tom. i. pp. 150, 151.--Lampillas, Letteratura Spagnuola, +tom. v. dis. 1, sec. 5.) This patriotic _littérateur_ endeavors to +establish the production of Oliva's tragedies in the year 1515, in the +hope of antedating that of Trissino's "Sophonisba," composed a year later, +and thus securing to his nation the palm of precedence, in time at least, +though it should be only for a few months, on the tragic theatre of modern +Europe. Letteratura Spagnuola, ubi supra. + +[53] Nic. Antonio, Bibliotheca Nova, tom. i. p. 386.--Oliva, Obras, pref. +de Morales. + +[54] The following passage, for example, in the "Venganza de Agamemnon," +imitated from the Electra of Sophocles, will hardly be charged on the +Greek dramatist. + +"Habed, yo os ruego, de mi compassion, no querais atapar con vuestros +consejos los respiraderos de las hornazas de fuego, que dentro me +atormentan." See Oliva, Obras, p. 185. + +[55] Compare the diction of these tragedies with that of the "Centon +Epistolario," for instance, esteemed one of the best literary compositions +of John II.'s reign, and see the advance made, not only in orthography, +but in the verbal arrangement generally, and the whole complexion of the +style. + +[56] Notwithstanding some Spanish critics, as Cueva, for example, have +vindicated the romantic forms of the drama on scientific principles, it is +apparent that the most successful writers in this department have been +constrained to adopt them by public opinion, rather than their own, which +would have suggested a nearer imitation of the classical models of +antiquity, so generally followed by the Italians, and which naturally +recommends itself to the scholar. See the canon's discourse in Cervantes, +Don Quixote, ed. de Pellicer, tom. iii. pp. 207-220,--and, more +explicitly, Lope de Vega, Obras Sueltas, tom. iv. p. 406. + +[57] "Ya en Italia, assi entre Damas, como entre Caballeros, se tiene por +gentileza y galania, saber hablar Castellano." Diálogo de las Lenguas, +apud Mayans y Siscar, Orígenes, tom. ii. p. 4. + + + + +PART SECOND. + +1493-1517. + +THE PERIOD WHEN, THE INTERIOR ORGANIZATION OF THE MONARCHY HAVING BEEN +COMPLETED, THE SPANISH NATION ENTERED ON ITS SCHEMES OF DISCOVERY AND +CONQUEST; OR THE PERIOD ILLUSTRATING MORE PARTICULARLY THE FOREIGN POLICY +OF FERDINAND AND ISABELLA. + + +CHAPTER I. + +ITALIAN WARS.--GENERAL VIEW OF EUROPE.--INVASION OF ITALY BY CHARLES VIII. +OF FRANCE. + +1493-1495. + +Europe at the Close of the Fifteenth Century.--More Intimate Relations +between States.--Italy the School of Politics.--Pretensions of Charles +VIII. to Naples.--Treaty of Barcelona.--The French Invade Naples.-- +Ferdinand's Dissatisfaction.--Tactics and Arms of the Different Nations.-- +Preparations of Spain.--Mission to Charles VIII.--Bold Conduct of the +Envoys.--The French enter Naples. + + +We have now reached that memorable epoch, when the different nations of +Europe, surmounting the barriers which had hitherto confined them within +their respective limits, brought their forces, as if by a simultaneous +impulse, against each other on a common theatre of action. In the +preceding part of this work, we have seen in what manner Spain was +prepared for the contest, by the concentration of her various states under +one government, and by such internal reforms, as enabled the government to +act with vigor. The genius of Ferdinand will appear as predominant in what +concerns the foreign relations of the country, as did that of Isabella in +its interior administration. So much so, indeed, that the accurate and +well-informed historian, who has most copiously illustrated this portion +of the national annals, does not even mention, in his introductory notice, +the name of Isabella, but refers the agency in these events exclusively to +her more ambitious consort. [1] In this he is abundantly justified, both +by the prevailing character of the policy pursued, widely differing from +that which distinguished the queen's measures, and by the circumstance +that the foreign conquests, although achieved by the united efforts of +both crowns, were undertaken on, behalf of Ferdinand's own dominions of +Aragon, to which in the end they exclusively appertained. + +The close of the fifteenth century presents, on the whole, the most +striking point of view in modern history; one from which we may +contemplate the consummation of an important revolution in the structure +of political society, and the first application of several inventions +destined to exercise the widest influence on human civilization. The +feudal institutions, or rather the feudal principle, which operated even +where the institutions, strictly speaking, did not exist, after having +wrought its appointed uses, had gradually fallen into decay; for it had +not the power of accommodating itself to the increased demands and +improved condition of society. However well suited to a barbarous age, it +was found that the distribution of power among the members of an +independent aristocracy was unfavorable to that degree of personal +security and tranquillity indispensable to great proficiency in the higher +arts of civilization. It was equally repugnant to the principle of +patriotism, so essential to national independence, but which must have +operated feebly among a people whose sympathies, instead of being +concentrated on the state, were claimed by a hundred masters, as was the +case in every feudal community. The conviction of this reconciled the +nation to the transfer of authority into other hands; not those of the +people, indeed, who were too ignorant, and too long accustomed to a +subordinate, dependent situation, to admit of it,--but into the hands of +the sovereign. It was not until three centuries more had elapsed, that the +condition of the great mass of the people was to be so far improved, as to +qualify them for asserting and maintaining the political consideration +which of right belongs to them. + +In whatever degree public opinion and the progress of events might favor +the transition of power from the aristocracy to the monarch, it is obvious +that much would depend on his personal character; since the advantages of +his station alone made him by no means a match for the combined forces of +his great nobility. The remarkable adaptation of the characters of the +principal sovereigns of Europe to this exigency, in the latter half of the +fifteenth century, would seem to have something providential in it. Henry +the Seventh of England, Louis the Eleventh of France, Ferdinand of Naples, +John the Second of Aragon, and his son Ferdinand, and John the Second of +Portugal, however differing in other respects, were all distinguished by a +sagacity, which enabled them to devise the most subtile and comprehensive +schemes of policy, and which was prolific in expedients for the +circumvention of enemies too potent to be encountered by open force. + +Their operations, all directed towards the same point, were attended with +similar success, resulting in the exaltation of the royal prerogative at +the expense of the aristocracy, with more or less deference to the rights +of the people, as the case might be; in France, for example, with almost +total indifference to them, while in Spain they were regarded, under the +parental administration of Isabella, which tempered the less scrupulous +policy of her husband, with tenderness and respect. In every country, +however, the nation at large gained greatly by the revolution, which came +on insensibly, at least without any violent shock to the fabric of +society, and which, by securing internal tranquillity and the ascendency +of law over brute force, gave ample scope for those intellectual pursuits, +that withdraw mankind from sensual indulgence, and too exclusive devotion +to the animal wants of our nature. + +No sooner was the internal organization of the different nations of Europe +placed on a secure basis, than they found leisure to direct their views, +hitherto confined within their own limits, to a bolder and more distant +sphere of action. Their international communication was greatly +facilitated by several useful inventions coincident with this period, or +then first extensively applied. Such was the art of printing, diffusing +knowledge with the speed and universality of light; the establishment of +posts, which, after its adoption by Louis the Eleventh, came into frequent +use in the beginning of the sixteenth century; and lastly, the compass, +which, guiding the mariner unerringly through the trackless wastes of the +ocean, brought the remotest regions into contact. With these increased +facilities for intercommunication, the different European states might be +said to be brought into as intimate relation with one another, as the +different provinces of the same kingdom were before. They now for the +first time regarded each other as members of one great community, in whose +action they were all mutually concerned. A greater anxiety was manifested +to detect the springs of every political movement of their neighbors. +Missions became frequent, and accredited agents were stationed, as a sort +of honorable spies, at the different courts. The science of diplomacy, on +narrower grounds, indeed, than it is now practised, began to be studied. +[2] Schemes of aggression and resistance, leading to political +combinations the most complex and extended, were gradually formed. We are +not to imagine, however, the existence of any well-defined ideas of a +balance of power at this early period. The object of these combinations +was some positive act of aggression or resistance, for purposes of +conquest or defence, not for the maintenance of any abstract theory of +political equilibrium. This was the result of much deeper reflection, and +of prolonged experience. + +The management of the foreign relations of the nation, at the close of the +fifteenth century, was resigned wholly to the sovereign. The people took +no further part or interest in the matter, than if it had concerned only +the disposition of his private property. His measures were, therefore, +often characterized by a degree of temerity and precipitation, that could +not have been permitted under the salutary checks afforded by popular +interposition. A strange insensibility, indeed, was shown to the rights +and interests of the nation. War was regarded as a game, in which the +sovereign parties engaged, not on behalf of their subjects, but +exclusively on their own. Like desperate gamblers, they contended for the +spoils or the honors of victory, with so much the more recklessness as +their own station was too elevated to be materially prejudiced by the +results. They contended with all the animosity of personal feeling; every +device, however paltry, was resorted to; and no advantage was deemed +unwarrantable, which could tend to secure the victory. The most profligate +maxims of state policy were openly avowed by men of reputed honor and +integrity. In short, the diplomacy of that day is very generally +characterized by a low cunning, subterfuge, and petty trickery, which +would leave an indelible stain on the transactions of private individuals. + +Italy was, doubtless, the great school where this political morality was +taught. That country was broken up into a number of small states, too +nearly equal to allow the absolute supremacy of any one; while, at the +same time, it demanded the most restless vigilance on the part of each to +maintain its independence against its neighbors. Hence such a complexity +of intrigues and combinations as the world had never before witnessed. A +subtile, refined policy was conformable to the genius of the Italians. It +was partly the result, moreover, of their higher cultivation, which +naturally led them to trust the settlement of their disputes to superior +intellectual dexterity, rather than to brute force, like the +_barbarians_ beyond the Alps. [3] From these and other causes, maxims +were gradually established, so monstrous in their nature as to give the +work, which first embodied them in a regular system, the air of a satire +rather than a serious performance, while the name of its author has been +converted into a by-word of political knavery. [4] + +At the period before us, the principal states of Italy were, the republics +of Venice and Florence, the duchy of Milan, the papal see, and the kingdom +of Naples. The others may be regarded merely as satellites, revolving +round some one or other of these superior powers, by whom their respective +movements were regulated and controlled. Venice may be considered as the +most formidable of the great powers, taking into consideration her wealth, +her powerful navy, her territory in the north, and princely colonial +domain. There was no government in that age which attracted such general +admiration, both from natives and foreigners; who seem to have looked upon +it as affording the very best model of political wisdom. [5] Yet there was +no country where the citizen enjoyed less positive freedom; none whose +foreign relations were conducted with more absolute selfishness, and with +a more narrow, bargaining spirit, savoring rather of a company of traders +than of a great and powerful state. But all this was compensated, in the +eyes of her contemporaries, by the stability of her institutions, which +still remained unshaken, amidst revolutions which had convulsed or +overturned every other social fabric in Italy. [6] + +The government of Milan was at this time under the direction of Lodovico +Sforza, or Lodovico the Moor, as he is commonly called; an epithet +suggested by his complexion, but which he willingly retained, as +indicating the superior craftiness on which he valued himself. [7] He held +the reins in the name of his nephew, then a minor, until a convenient +season should arrive for assuming them in his own. His cool, perfidious +character was stained with the worst vices of the most profligate class of +Italian statesmen of that period. + +The central parts of Italy were occupied by the republic of Florence, +which had ever been the rallying point of the friends of freedom, too +often of faction; but which had now resigned itself to the dominion of the +Medici, whose cultivated tastes and munificent patronage shed a splendid +illusion over their administration, which has blinded the eyes of +contemporaries, and even of posterity. + +The papal chair was filled by Alexander the Sixth, a pontiff whose +licentiousness, avarice, and unblushing effrontery have been the theme of +unmingled reproach, with Catholic as well as Protestant writers. His +preferment was effected by lavish bribery, and by his consummate address, +as well as energy of character. Although a native Spaniard, his election +was extremely unpalatable to Ferdinand and Isabella, who deprecated the +scandal it must bring upon the church, and who had little to hope for +themselves, in a political view, from the elevation of one of their own +subjects even, whose mercenary spirit placed him at the control of the +highest bidder. [8] + +The Neapolitan sceptre was swayed by Ferdinand the First, whose father, +Alfonso the Fifth, the uncle of Ferdinand of Aragon, had obtained the +crown by the adoption of Joanna of Naples, or rather by his own good +sword. Alfonso settled his conquest on his illegitimate son Ferdinand, to +the prejudice of the rights of Aragon, by whose blood and treasure he had +achieved it. Ferdinand's character, the very opposite of his noble +father's, was dark, wily, and ferocious. His life was spent in conflict +with his great feudal nobility, many of whom supported the pretensions of +the Angevin family. But his superior craft enabled him to foil every +attempt of his enemies. In effecting this, indeed, he shrunk from no deed +of treachery or violence, however atrocious, and in the end had the +satisfaction of establishing his authority, undisputed, on the fears of +his subjects. He was about seventy years of age at the period of which we +are treating, 1493. The heir apparent, Alfonso, was equally sanguinary in +his temper, though possessing less talent for dissimulation than his +father. + +Such was the character of the principal Italian courts at the close of the +fifteenth century. The politics of the country were necessarily regulated +by the temper and views of the leading powers. They were essentially +selfish and personal. The ancient republican forms had been gradually +effaced during this century, and more arbitrary ones introduced. The name +of freedom, indeed, was still inscribed on their banners, but the spirit +had disappeared. In almost every state, great or small, some military +adventurer, or crafty statesman, had succeeded in raising his own +authority on the liberties of his country; and his sole aim seemed to be +to enlarge it still further, and to secure it against the conspiracies and +revolutions, which the reminiscence of ancient independence naturally +called forth. Such was the case with Tuscany, Milan, Naples, and the +numerous subordinate states. In Rome, the pontiff proposed no higher +object than the concentration of wealth and public honors in the hands of +his own family. In short, the administration of every state seemed to be +managed with exclusive reference to the personal interests of its chief. +Venice was the only power of sufficient strength and stability to engage +in more extended schemes of policy, and even these were conducted, as has +been already noticed, in the narrow and calculating spirit of a trading +corporation. + +But, while no spark of generous patriotism seemed to warm the bosoms of +the Italians; while no sense of public good, or even menace of foreign +invasion, could bring them to act in concert with one another, [9] the +internal condition of the country was eminently prosperous. Italy had far +outstripped the rest of Europe in the various arts of civilized life; and +she everywhere afforded the evidence of faculties developed by unceasing +intellectual action. The face of the country itself was like a garden; +"cultivated through all its plains to the very tops of the mountains; +teeming with population, with riches, and an unlimited commerce; +illustrated by many munificent princes, by the splendor of many noble and +beautiful cities, and by the majesty of religion; and adorned with all +those rare and precious gifts, which render a name glorious among the +nations." [10] Such are the glowing strains in which the Tuscan historian +celebrates the prosperity of his country, ere yet the storm of war had +descended on her beautiful valleys. + +This scene of domestic tranquillity was destined to be changed by that +terrible invasion which the ambition of Lodovico Sforza brought upon his +country. He had already organized a coalition of the northern powers of +Italy, to defeat the interference of the king of Naples in behalf of his +grandson, the rightful duke of Milan, whom his uncle held in subjection +during a protracted minority, while he exercised all the real functions of +sovereignty in his name. Not feeling sufficiently secure from his Italian +confederacy, Sforza invited the king of France to revive the hereditary +claims of the house of Anjou to the crown of Naples, promising to aid him +in the enterprise with all his resources. In this way, this wily +politician proposed to divert the storm from his own head, by giving +Ferdinand sufficient occupation at home. + +The throne of France was at that time filled by Charles the Eighth, a +monarch scarcely twenty-two years of age. His father, Louis the Eleventh, +had given him an education unbecoming, not only a great prince, but even a +private gentleman. He would allow him to learn no other Latin, says +Brantôme, than his favorite maxim, "Qui nescit dissimulare, nescit +regnare." [11] Charles made some amends for this, though with little +judgment, in later life, when left to his own disposal. His favorite +studies were the exploits of celebrated conquerors, of Caesar and +Charlemagne particularly, which filled his young mind with vague and +visionary ideas of glory. These dreams were still further nourished by the +tourneys and other chivalrous spectacles of the age, in which he +delighted, until he seems to have imagined himself some doughty paladin of +romance, destined to the achievement of a grand and perilous enterprise. +It affords some proof of this exalted state of his imagination, that he +gave his only son the name of Orlando, after the celebrated hero of +Roncesvalles. [12] + +With a mind thus excited by chimerical visions of military glory, he lent +a willing ear to the artful propositions of Sforza. In the extravagance of +vanity, fed by the adulation of interested parasites, he affected to +regard the enterprise against Naples as only opening the way to a career +of more splendid conquests, which were to terminate in the capture of +Constantinople, and the recovery of the Holy Sepulchre. He even went so +far as to purchase of Andrew Paleologus, the nephew and heir of +Constantine, the last of the Caesars, his title to the Greek empire. [13] + +Nothing could be more unsound, according to the principles of the present +day, than Charles's claims to the crown of Naples. Without discussing the +original pretensions of the rival houses of Aragon and Anjou, it is +sufficient to state, that, at the time of Charles the Eighth's invasion, +the Neapolitan throne had been in the possession of the Aragonese family +more than half a century, under three successive princes solemnly +recognized by the people, sanctioned by repeated investitures of the papal +suzerain, and admitted by all the states of Europe. If all this did not +give validity to their title, when was the nation to expect repose? +Charles's claim, on the other hand, was derived originally from a +testamentary bequest of René, count of Provence, operating to the +exclusion of the son of his own daughter, the rightful heir of the house +of Anjou; Naples being too notoriously a female fief to afford any pretext +for the action of the Salic law. The pretensions of Ferdinand, of Spain, +as representative of the legitimate branch of Aragon, were far more +plausible. [14] + +Independently of the defects in Charles's title, his position was such as +to make the projected expedition every way impolitic. A misunderstanding +had for some time subsisted between him and the Spanish sovereigns, and he +was at open war with Germany and England; so that it was only by large +concessions that he could hope to secure their acquiescence in an +enterprise most precarious in its character, and where even complete +success could be of no permanent benefit to his kingdom. "He did not +understand," says Voltaire, "that a dozen villages adjacent to one's +territory, are of more value than a kingdom four hundred leagues distant." +[15] By the treaties of Etaples and Senlis, he purchased a reconciliation +with Henry the Seventh of England, and with Maximilian, the emperor elect; +and finally, by that of Barcelona, effected an amicable adjustment of his +difficulties with Spain. [16] + +This treaty, which involved the restoration of Roussillon and Cerdagne, +was of great importance to the crown of Aragon. These provinces, it will +be remembered, had been originally mortgaged by Ferdinand's father, King +John the Second, to Louis the Eleventh of France, for the sum of three +hundred thousand crowns, in consideration of aid to be afforded by the +latter monarch against the Catalan insurgents. Although the stipulated sum +had never been paid by Aragon, yet a plausible pretext for requiring the +restitution was afforded by Louis the Eleventh's incomplete performance of +his engagements, as well as by the ample reimbursement, which the French +government had already derived from the revenues of these countries. [17] +This treaty had long been a principal object of Ferdinand's policy. He had +not, indeed, confined himself to negotiation, but had made active +demonstrations more than once of occupying the contested territory by +force. Negotiation, however, was more consonant to his habitual policy; +and, after the termination of the Moorish war, he pressed it with the +utmost vigor, repairing with the queen to Barcelona, in order to watch +over the deliberations of the envoys of the two nations at Figueras. [18] + +The French historians accuse Ferdinand of bribing two ecclesiastics, in +high influence at their court, to make such a representation of the +affair, as should alarm the conscience of the young monarch. These holy +men insisted on the restoration of Roussillon as an act of justice; since +the sums for which it had been mortgaged, though not repaid, had been +spent in the common cause of Christendom, the Moorish war. The soul, they +said, could never hope to escape from purgatory, until restitution was +made of all property unlawfully held during life. His royal father, Louis +the Eleventh, was clearly in this predicament, as he himself would +hereafter be, unless the Spanish territories should be relinquished; a +measure, moreover, the more obligatory on him, since it was well known to +be the dying request of his parent. These arguments made a suitable +impression on the young monarch, and a still deeper on his sister, the +duchess of Beaujeu, who exercised great influence over him, and who +believed her own soul in peril of eternal damnation by deferring the act +of restoration any longer. The effect of this cogent reasoning was no +doubt greatly enhanced by the reckless impatience of Charles, who +calculated no cost in the prosecution of his chimerical enterprise. With +these amicable dispositions an arrangement was at length concluded, and +received the signatures of the respective monarchs on the same day, being +signed by Charles at Tours, and by Ferdinand and Isabella at Barcelona, +January 19th, 1493. [19] + +The principal articles of the treaty provided, that the contracting +parties should mutually aid each other against all enemies; that they +should reciprocally prefer this alliance to that with any other, _the +vicar of Christ excepted_; that the Spanish sovereigns should enter +into no understanding with any power, _the vicar of Christ excepted_, +prejudicial to the interests of France; that their children should not be +disposed of in marriage to the kings of England, or of the Romans, or to +any enemy of France, without the French king's consent. It was finally +stipulated that Roussillon and Cerdagne should be restored to Aragon; but +that, as doubts might be entertained to which power the possession of +these countries rightfully appertained, arbitrators _named by Ferdinand +and Isabella_ should be appointed, if requested by the French monarch, +with full power to decide the question, by whose judgment the contracting +parties mutually promised to abide. This last provision, obviously too +well guarded to jeopard the interests of the Spanish sovereigns, was +introduced to allay in some measure the discontents of the French, who +loudly inveighed against their cabinet, as sacrificing the interests of +the nation; accusing, indeed, the Cardinal D'Albi, the principal agent in +the negotiation, of being in the pay of Ferdinand. [20] + +The treaty excited equal surprise and satisfaction in Spain, where +Roussillon was regarded as of the last importance, not merely from the +extent of its resources, but from its local position, which made it the +key of Catalonia. The nation, says Zurita, looked on its recovery as +scarcely less important than the conquest of Granada; and they doubted +some sinister motive, or deeper policy than appeared in the conduct of the +French king. He was influenced, however, by no deeper policy than the +cravings of a puerile ambition. [21] + +The preparations of Charles, in the mean while, excited general alarm +throughout Italy. Ferdinand, the old king of Naples, who in vain +endeavored to arrest them by negotiation, had died in the beginning of +1494. He was succeeded by his son Alfonso, a prince of bolder but less +politic character, and equally odious, from the cruelty of his +disposition, with his father. He lost no time in putting his kingdom in a +posture of defence; but he wanted the best of all defences, the attachment +of his subjects. His interests were supported by the Florentine republic +and the pope, whose family had intermarried with the royal house of +Naples. Venice stood aloof, secure in her remoteness, unwilling to +compromise her interests by too precipitate a declaration in favor of +either party. + +The European powers regarded the expedition of Charles the Eighth with +somewhat different feelings; most of them were not unwilling to see so +formidable a prince waste his resources in a remote and chimerical +expedition; Ferdinand, however, contemplated with more anxiety an event, +which might terminate in the subversion of the Neapolitan branch of his +house, and bring a powerful and active neighbor in contact with his own +dominions in Sicily. He lost no time in fortifying the faltering courage +of the pope by assurances of support. His ambassador, then resident at the +papal court, was Garcilasso de la Vega, father of the illustrious poet of +that name, and familiar to the reader by his exploits in the Granadine +war. This personage with rare political sagacity combined an energy of +purpose, which could not fail to infuse courage into the hearts of others. +He urged the pope to rely on his master, the king of Aragon, who, he +assured him, would devote his whole resources, if necessary, to the +protection of his person, honor, and estate. Alexander would gladly have +had this promise under the hand of Ferdinand; but the latter did not think +it expedient, considering his delicate relations with France, to put +himself so far in the power of the wily pontiff. [22] + +In the mean time, Charles's preparations went forward with the languor and +vacillation resulting from divided councils and multiplied embarrassments. +"Nothing essential to the conduct of a war was at hand," says Comines. The +king was very young, weak in person, headstrong in will, surrounded by few +discreet counsellors, and wholly destitute of the requisite funds. [23] +His own impatience, however, was stimulated by that of the youthful +chivalry of his court, who burned for an opportunity of distinction; as +well as by the representations of the Neapolitan exiles, who hoped, under +his protection, to re-establish themselves in their own country. Several +of these, weary with the delay already experienced, made overtures to King +Ferdinand to undertake the enterprise on his own behalf, and to assert his +legitimate pretensions to the crown of Naples, which, they assured him, a +large party in the country was ready to sustain. The sagacious monarch, +however, knew how little reliance was to be placed on the reports of +exiles, whose imaginations readily exaggerated the amount of disaffection +in their own country. But, although the season had not yet arrived for +asserting his own paramount claims, he was determined to tolerate those of +no other potentate. [24] + +Charles entertained so little suspicion of this, that, in the month of +June, he despatched an envoy to the Spanish court, requiring Ferdinand's +fulfilment of the treaty of Barcelona, by aiding him with men and money, +and by throwing open his ports in Sicily for the French navy. "This +gracious proposition," says the Aragonese historian, "he accompanied with +information of his proposed expedition against the Turks; stating +incidentally, as a thing of no consequence, his intention to take Naples +by the way." [25] + +Ferdinand saw the time was arrived for coming to an explicit declaration +with the French court. He appointed a special mission, in order to do this +in the least offensive manner possible. The person selected for this +delicate task was Alonso de Silva, brother of the count of Cifuentes, and +_clavero_ of Calatrava, a cavalier possessed of the coolness and address +requisite for diplomatic success. [26] + +The ambassador, on arriving at the French court, found it at Vienne in all +the bustle of preparation for immediate departure. After seeking in vain a +private audience from King Charles, he explained to him the purport of his +mission in the presence of his courtiers. He assured him of the +satisfaction which the king of Aragon had experienced, at receiving +intelligence of his projected expedition against the infidel. Nothing gave +his master so great contentment, as to see his brother monarchs employing +their arms, and expending their revenues, against the enemies of the +Cross; where even failure was greater gain than success in other wars. He +offered Ferdinand's assistance in the prosecution of such wars, even +though they should be directed against the Mahometans of Africa, over whom +the papal sanction had given Spain exclusive rights of conquest. He +besought the king not to employ the forces destined to so glorious a +purpose against any one of the princes of Europe, but to reflect how great +a scandal this must necessarily bring on the Christian cause; above all, +he cautioned him against forming any designs on Naples, since that kingdom +was a fief of the church, in whose favor an exception was expressly made +by the treaty of Barcelona, which recognized her alliance and protection +as paramount to every other obligation. Silva's discourse was responded to +by the president of the parliament of Paris in a formal Latin oration, +asserting generally Charles's right to Naples, and his resolution to +enforce it previously to his crusade against the infidel. As soon as it +was concluded, the king rose and abruptly quitted the apartment. [27] + +Some days after, he interrogated the Spanish ambassador, whether his +master would not, in case of a war with Portugal, feel warranted by the +terms of the late treaty in requiring the co-operation of France, and on +what plea the latter power could pretend to withhold it. To the first of +these propositions the ambassador answered in the affirmative, if it were +a defensive war, but not, if an offensive one, of his own seeking; an +explanation by no means satisfactory to the French monarch. Indeed, he +seems not to have been at all prepared for this interpretation of the +compact. He had relied on this, as securing without any doubt the non- +interference of Ferdinand, if not his actual co-operation in his designs +against Naples. The clause touching the rights of the church was too +frequent in public treaties to excite any particular attention; and he was +astounded at the broad ground, which it was now made to cover, and which +defeated the sole object proposed by the cession of Roussillon. He could +not disguise his chagrin and indignation at what he deemed the perfidy of +the Spanish court. He refused all further intercourse with Silva, and even +stationed a sentinel at his gate, to prevent his communication with his +subjects; treating him as the envoy, not of an ally, but of an open enemy. +[28] + +The unexpected and menacing attitude, however, assumed by Ferdinand, +failed to arrest the operations of the French monarch, who, having +completed his preparations, left Vienne in the month of August, 1494, and +crossed the Alps at the head of the most formidable host which had scaled +that mountain barrier since the irruption of the northern barbarians. [29] +It will be unnecessary to follow his movements in detail. It is sufficient +to remark, that his conduct throughout was equally defective in principle +and in sound policy. He alienated his allies by the most signal acts of +perfidy, seizing their fortresses for himself, and entering their capitals +with all the vaunt and insolent port of a conquerer. On his approach to +Rome, the pope and the cardinals took refuge in the castle of St. Angelo, +and on the 31st of December, Charles defiled into the city at the head of +his victorious chivalry; if victorious they could be called, when, as an +Italian historian remarks, they had scarcely broken a lance, or spread a +tent, in the whole of their progress. [30] + +The Italians were panic-struck at the aspect of troops so different from +their own, and so superior to them in organization, science, and military +equipment; and still more in a remorseless ferocity of temper, which had +rarely been witnessed in their own feuds. Warfare was conducted on +peculiar principles in Italy, adapted to the character and circumstances +of the people. The business of fighting, in her thriving communities, +instead of forming part of the regular profession of a gentleman, as in +other countries at this period, was intrusted to the hands of a few +soldiers of fortune, _condottieri_, as they were called, who hired +themselves out, with the forces under their command, consisting +exclusively of heavy-armed cavalry, to whatever state would pay them best. +These forces constituted the capital, as it were, of the military chief, +whose obvious interest it was to economize as far as possible all +unnecessary expenditure of his resources. Hence, the science of defence +was almost exclusively studied. The object seemed to be, not so much the +annoyance of the enemy, as self-preservation. The common interests of the +_condottieri_ being paramount to every obligation towards the state +which they served, they easily came to an understanding with one another +to spare their troops as much as possible; until at length battles were +fought with little more personal hazard than would be incurred in an +ordinary tourney. The man-at-arms was riveted into plates of steel of +sufficient thickness to turn a musket-ball. The ease of the soldier was so +far consulted, that the artillery, in a siege, was not allowed to be fired +on either side from sunset to sunrise, for fear of disturbing his repose. +Prisoners were made for the sake of their ransom, and but little blood was +spilled in an action. Machiavelli records two engagements, at Anghiari and +Castracaro, among the most noted of the time for their important +consequences. The one lasted four hours, and the other half a day. The +reader is hurried along through all the bustle of a well-contested fight, +in the course of which the field is won and lost several times; but, when +he comes to the close, and looks for the list of killed and wounded, he +finds to his surprise not a single man slain, in the first of these +actions; and, in the second, only one, who, having tumbled from his horse, +and being unable to rise, from the weight of his armor, was suffocated in +the mud! Thus war became disarmed of its terrors. Courage was no longer +essential in a soldier; and the Italian, made effeminate, if not timid, +was incapable of encountering the adventurous daring and severe discipline +of the northern warrior. [31] + +The astonishing success of the French was still more imputable to the free +use and admirable organization of their infantry, whose strength lay in +the Swiss mercenaries. Machiavelli ascribes the misfortunes of his nation +chiefly to its exclusive reliance on cavalry. [32] This service, during +the whole of the Middle Ages, was considered among the European nations +the most important; the horse being styled by way of eminence "the +battle." The memorable conflict of Charles the Bold with the Swiss +mountaineers, however, in which the latter broke in pieces the celebrated +Burgundian _ordonnance_, constituting the finest body of chivalry of +the age, demonstrated the capacity of infantry; and the Italian wars, in +which we are now engaged, at length fully re-established its ancient +superiority. + +The Swiss were formed into battalions varying from three to eight thousand +men each. They wore little defensive armor, and their principal weapon was +the pike, eighteen feet long. Formed into these solid battalions, which, +bristling with spears all around, received the technical appellation of +the _hedgehog_, they presented an invulnerable front on every quarter. In +the level field, with free scope allowed for action, they bore down all +opposition, and received unshaken the most desperate charges of the steel- +clad cavalry on their terrible array of pikes. They were too unwieldy, +however, for rapid or complicated manoeuvres; they were easily +disconcerted by any unforseen impediment, or irregularity of the ground; +and the event proved, that the Spanish foot, armed with its short swords +and bucklers, by breaking in under the long pikes of its enemy, could +succeed in bringing him to close action, where his formidable weapon was +of no avail. It was repeating the ancient lesson of the Roman legion and +the Macedonian phalanx. [33] + +In artillery, the French were at this time in advance of the Italians, +perhaps of every nation in Europe. The Italians, indeed, were so +exceedingly defective in this department, that their best field-pieces +consisted of small copper tubes, covered with wood and hides. They were +mounted on unwieldy carriages drawn by oxen, and followed by cars or +wagons loaded with stone balls. These guns were worked so awkwardly, that +the besieged, says Guicciardini, had time between the discharges to repair +the mischief inflicted by them. From these circumstances, artillery was +held in so little repute, that some of the most competent Italian writers +thought it might be dispensed with altogether in field engagements. [34] + +The French, on the other hand, were provided with a beautiful train of +ordnance, consisting of bronze cannon about eight feet in length, and many +smaller pieces. [35] They were lightly mounted, drawn by horses, and +easily kept pace with the rapid movements of the army. They discharged +iron balls, and were served with admirable skill, intimidating their +enemies by the rapidity and accuracy of their fire, and easily demolishing +their fortifications, which, before this invasion, were constructed with +little strength or science. [36] + +The rapid successes of the French spread consternation among the Italian +states, who now for the first time seemed to feel the existence of a +common interest, and the necessity of efficient concert. Ferdinand was +active in promoting these dispositions, through his ministers, Garcilasso +de la Vega and Alonso de Silva. The latter had quitted the French court on +its entrance into Italy, and withdrawn to Genoa. From this point he opened +a correspondence with Lodovico Sforza, who now began to understand, that +he had brought a terrible engine into play, the movements of which, +however mischievous to himself, were beyond his strength to control. Silva +endeavored to inflame still further his jealousy of the French, who had +already given him many serious causes of disgust; and, in order to detach +him more effectually from Charles's interests, encouraged him with the +hopes of forming a matrimonial alliance for his son with one of the +infantas of Spain. At the same time, he used every effort to bring about a +co-operation between the duke and the republic of Venice, thus opening the +way to the celebrated league which was concluded in the following year. +[37] + +The Roman pontiff had lost no time, after the appearance of the French +army in Italy, in pressing the Spanish court to fulfil its engagements. He +endeavored to propitiate the good-will of the sovereigns by several +important concessions. He granted to them and their successors the +_tercias_, or two-ninths of the tithes, throughout the dominions of +Castile; an impost still forming part of the regular revenue of the crown. +[38] He caused bulls of crusade to be promulgated throughout Spain, +granting at the same time a tenth of the ecclesiastical rents, with the +understanding that the proceeds should be devoted to the protection of the +Holy See. Towards the close of this year, 1494, or the beginning of the +following, he conferred the title of Catholic on the Spanish sovereigns, +in consideration, as is stated, of their eminent virtues, their zeal in +defence of the true faith of the apostolic see, their reformation of +conventual discipline, their subjugation of the Moors of Granada, and the +purification of their dominions from the Jewish heresy. This orthodox +title, which still continues to be the jewel most prized in the Spanish +crown, has been appropriated in a peculiar manner to Ferdinand and +Isabella, who are universally recognized in history as _Los Reyes +Católicos_. [39] + +Ferdinand was too sensible of the peril, to which the occupation of Naples +by the French would expose his own interests, to require any stimulant to +action from the Roman pontiff. Naval preparations had been going forward +during the summer, in the ports of Galicia and Guipuscoa. A considerable +armament was made ready for sea by the latter part of December, at +Alicant, and placed under the command of Galceran de Requesens, count of +Trevento. The land forces were intrusted to Gonsalvo de Cordova, better +known in history as the Great Captain. Instructions were at the same time +sent to the viceroy of Sicily, to provide for the security of that island, +and to hold himself in readiness to act in concert with the Spanish fleet. +[40] + +Ferdinand, however, determined to send one more embassy to Charles the +Eighth, before coming to an open rupture with him. He selected for this +mission Juan de Albion and Antonio de Fonseca, brother of the bishop of +that name, whom we have already noticed as superintendent of the Indian +department. The two envoys reached Rome, January 28th, 1495, the same day +on which Charles set out on his march for Naples. They followed the army, +and on arriving at Veletri, about twenty miles from the capital, were +admitted to an audience by the monarch, who received them in the presence +of his officers. The ambassadors freely enumerated the various causes of +complaint entertained by their master against the French king; the insult +offered to him in the person of his minister Alonso de Silva; the +contumelious treatment of the pope, and forcible occupation of the +fortresses and estates of the church; and finally, the enterprise against +Naples, the claims to which as a papal fief could of right be determined +in no other way than by the arbitration of the pontiff himself. Should +King Charles consent to accept this arbitration, they tendered the good +offices of their master as mediator between the parties; should he decline +it, however, the king of Spain stood absolved from all further obligations +of amity with him, by the terms of the treaty of Barcelona, which +expressly recognized his right to interfere in defence of the church. [41] + +Charles, who could not dissemble his indignation during this discourse, +retorted with great acrimony, when it was concluded, on the conduct of +Ferdinand, which he stigmatized as perfidious, accusing him, at the same +time, of a deliberate design to circumvent him, by introducing into their +treaty the clause respecting the pope. As to the expedition against +Naples, he had now gone too far to recede; and it would be soon enough to +canvass the question of right, when he had got possession of it. His +courtiers, at the same time, with the impetuosity of their nation, +heightened by the insolence of success, told the envoys, that they knew +well enough how to defend their rights with their arms, and that King +Ferdinand would find the French chivalry enemies of quite another sort +from the holiday tilters of Granada. + +These taunts led to mutual recrimination, until at length Fonseca, though +naturally a sedate person, was so far transported with anger, that he +exclaimed, "The issue then must be left to God,--arms must decide it;" +and, producing the original treaty, bearing the signatures of the two +monarchs, he tore it in pieces before the eyes of Charles and his court. +At the same time he commanded two Spanish knights who served in the French +army to withdraw from it, under pain of incurring the penalties of +treason. The French cavaliers were so much incensed by this audacious +action, that they would have seized the envoys, and, in all probability, +offered violence to their persons, but for Charles's interposition, who +with more coolness caused them to be conducted from his presence, and sent +back under a safe escort to Rome. Such are the circumstances reported by +the French and Italian writers of this remarkable interview. They were not +aware that the dramatic exhibition, as far as the ambassadors were +concerned, was all previously concerted before their departure from Spain. +[42] + +Charles pressed forward on his march without further delay. Alfonso the +Second, losing his confidence and martial courage, the only virtues that +he possessed, at the crisis when they were most demanded, had +precipitately abandoned his kingdom while the French were at Rome, and +taken refuge in Sicily, where he formally abdicated the crown in favor of +his son, Ferdinand the Second. This prince, then twenty-five years of age, +whose amiable manners were rendered still more attractive by contrast with +the ferocious temper of his father, was possessed of talent and energy +competent to the present emergency, had he been sustained by his subjects. +But the latter, besides being struck with the same panic which had +paralyzed the other people of Italy, had too little interest in the +government to be willing to hazard much in its defence. A change of +dynasty was only a change of masters, by which they had little either to +gain or to lose. Though favorably inclined to Ferdinand, they refused to +stand by him in his perilous extremity. They gave way in every direction, +as the French advanced, rendering hopeless every attempt of their spirited +young monarch to rally them, till at length no alternative was left, but +to abandon his dominions to the enemy, without striking a blow in their +defence. He withdrew to the neighboring island of Ischia, whence he soon +after passed into Sicily, and occupied himself there in collecting the +fragments of his party, until the time should arrive for more decisive +action. [43] + +Charles the Eighth made his entrance into Naples at the head of his +legions, February 22d, 1495, having traversed this whole extent of hostile +territory in less time than would be occupied by a fashionable tourist of +the present day. The object of his expedition was now achieved. He seemed +to have reached the consummation of his wishes; and, although he assumed +the titles of King of Sicily and of Jerusalem, and affected the state and +authority of Emperor, he took no measures for prosecuting his chimerical +enterprise further. He even neglected to provide for the security of his +present conquest; and, without bestowing a thought on the government of +his new dominions, resigned himself to the licentious and effeminate +pleasures so congenial with the soft voluptuousness of the climate, and +his own character. [44] + +While Charles was thus wasting his time and resources in frivolous +amusements, a dark storm was gathering in the north. There was not a state +through which he had passed, however friendly to his cause, which had not +complaints to make of his insolence, his breach of faith, his infringement +of their rights, and his exorbitant exactions. His impolitic treatment of +Sforza had long since alienated that wily and restless politician, and +raised suspicions in his mind of Charles's designs against his own duchy +of Milan. The emperor elect, Maximilian, whom the French king thought to +have bound to his interests by the treaty of Senlis, took umbrage at his +assumption of the imperial title and dignity. The Spanish ambassadors, +Garcilasso de la Vega, and his brother Lorenzo Suarez, the latter of whom +resided at Venice, were indefatigable in stimulating the spirit of +discontent. Suarez, in particular, used every effort to secure the co- +operation of Venice, representing to the government, in the most urgent +terms, the necessity of general concert and instant action among the great +powers of Italy, if they would preserve their own liberties. [45] + +Venice, from its remote position, seemed to afford the best point for +coolly contemplating the general interests of Italy. Envoys of the +different European powers were assembled there, as if by common consent, +with the view of concerting some scheme of operation for their mutual +good. The conferences were conducted by night, and with such secrecy as to +elude for some time the vigilant eye of Comines, the sagacious minister of +Charles, then resident at the capital. The result was the celebrated +league of Venice. It was signed the last day of March, 1495, on the part +of Spain, Austria, Rome, Milan, and the Venetian republic. The ostensible +object of the treaty, which was to last twenty-five years, was the +preservation of the estates and rights of the confederates, especially of +the Roman see. A large force, amounting in all to thirty-four thousand +horse and twenty thousand foot, was to be assessed in stipulated +proportions on each of the contracting parties. The secret articles of the +treaty, however, went much further, providing a formidable plan of +offensive operations. It was agreed in these, that King Ferdinand should +employ the Spanish armament, now arrived in Sicily, in re-establishing his +kinsman on the throne of Naples; that a Venetian fleet of forty galleys +should attack the French positions on the Neapolitan coasts; that the duke +of Milan should expel the French from Asti, and blockade the passes of the +Alps, so as to intercept the passage of further reinforcements; and that +the emperor and the king of Spain should invade the French frontiers, and +their expenses be defrayed by subsidies from the allies. [46] Such were +the terms of this treaty, which may be regarded as forming an era in +modern political history, since it exhibits the first example of those +extensive combinations among European princes, for mutual defence, which +afterwards became so frequent. It shared the fate of many other +coalitions, where the name and authority of the whole have been made +subservient to the interests of some one of the parties, more powerful, or +more cunning, than the rest. + +The intelligence of the new treaty diffused general joy throughout Italy. +In Venice, in particular, it was greeted with _fêtes_, illuminations, +and the most emphatic public rejoicing, in the very eyes of the French +minister, who was compelled to witness this unequivocal testimony of the +detestation in which his countrymen were held. [47] The tidings fell +heavily on the ears of the French in Naples. It dispelled the dream of +idle dissipation in which they were dissolved. They felt little concern, +indeed, on the score of their Italian enemies, whom their easy victories +taught them to regard with the same insolent contempt, that the paladins +of romance are made to feel for the unknightly rabble, myriads of whom +they could overturn with a single lance. But they felt serious alarm as +they beheld the storm of war gathering from other quarters,--from Spain +and Germany, in defiance of the treaties by which they had hoped to secure +them. Charles saw the necessity of instant action. Two courses presented +themselves: either to strengthen himself in his new conquests, and prepare +to maintain them until he could receive fresh reinforcements from home, or +to abandon them altogether and retreat across the Alps, before the allies +could muster in sufficient strength to oppose him. With the indiscretion +characteristic of his whole enterprise, he embraced a middle course, and +lost the advantages which would have resulted from the exclusive adoption +of either. + + * * * * * + +The principal light, by which we are to be guided through the remainder of +this history, is the Aragonese annalist, Zurita, whose great work, +although less known abroad than those of some more recent Castilian +writers, sustains a reputation at home, unsurpassed by any other, in the +great, substantial qualities of an historian. The notice of his life and +writings has been swelled into a bulky quarto by Dr. Diego Dormer, in a +work entitled, "Progressos de la Historia en el Reyno de Aragon. Zaragoza, +1680;" from which I extract a few particulars. + +Gerónimo Zurita, descended from an ancient and noble family, was born at +Saragossa, December 4th, 1512. He was matriculated at an early age in the +university of Alcalá. He there made extraordinary proficiency, under the +immediate instruction of the learned Nuñez de Guzman, commonly called El +Pinciano. He became familiar with the ancient, and a variety of modern +tongues, and attracted particular attention by the purity and elegance of +his Latinity. His personal merits, and his father's influence, recommended +him, soon after quitting the university, to the notice of the emperor +Charles V. He was consulted and employed in affairs of public importance, +and subsequently raised to several posts of honor, attesting the entire +confidence reposed in his integrity and abilities. His most honorable +appointment, however, was that of national historiographer. + +In 1547, an act passed the cortes general of Aragon, providing for the +office of national chronicler, with a fixed salary, whose duty it should +be to compile, from authentic sources, a faithful history of the monarchy. +The talents and eminent qualifications of Zurita recommended him to this +post, and he was raised to it by the unanimous consent of the legislature, +in the following year, 1548. From this time he conscientiously devoted +himself to the execution of his great task. He visited every part of his +own country, as well as Sicily and Italy, for the purpose of collecting +materials. The public archives, and every accessible source of +information, were freely thrown open to his inspection, by order of the +government; and he returned from his literary pilgrimage with a large +accumulation of rare and original documents. The first portion of his +annals was published at Saragossa, in two volumes folio, 1562. The work +was not completed until nearly twenty years later, and the last two +volumes were printed under his own eye at Saragossa, in 1580, a few months +only before his death. This edition, being one of those used in the +present history, is in large folio, fairly executed, with double columns +on the page, in the fashion of most of the ancient Spanish historians. The +whole work was again published, as before, at the expense of the state, in +1585, by his son, amended and somewhat enlarged, from the manuscripts left +by his father. Bouterwek has fallen into the error of supposing, that no +edition of Zurita's Annals appeared till after the reign of Philip II., +who died in 1592. (Geschichte der Poesie und Beredsamkeit, band iii. p. +319.) + +No incidents worthy of note seem to have broken the peaceful tenor of +Zurita's life; which he terminated at Saragossa, in the sixty-eighth year +of his age, in the monastery of Santa Engracia, to which he had retired +during a temporary residence in the city, to superintend the publication +of his Annals. His rich collection of books and manuscripts was left to +the Carthusian monastery of Aula Dei; but from accident or neglect, the +greater part have long since perished. His remains were interred in the +convent where he died, and a monument, bearing a modest inscription, was +erected over them by his son. + +The best monument of Zurita, however, is his Annals. They take up the +history of Aragon from its first rise after the Arabic conquest, and +continue it to the death of Ferdinand the Catholic. The reign of this +prince, as possessing the largest interest and importance, is expanded +into two volumes folio; being one-third of the whole work. + +The minuteness of Zurita's investigations has laid him open to the charge +of prolixity, especially in the earlier and less important periods. It +should be remembered, however, that his work was to be the great national +repository of facts, interesting to his own countrymen, but which, from +difficulty of access to authentic sources, could never before be fully +exhibited to their inspection. But, whatever he thought of his redundancy, +in this or the subsequent parts of his narrative, it must be admitted that +he has uniformly and emphatically directed the attention of the reader to +the topics most worthy of it; sparing no pains to illustrate the +constitutional antiquities of the country, and to trace the gradual +formation of her liberal polity, instead of wasting his strength on mere +superficial gossip, like most of the chroniclers of the period. + +There is no Spanish historian less swayed by party or religious prejudice, +or by the feeling of nationality, which is so apt to overflow in the loyal +effusions of the Castilian writers. This laudable temperance, indeed, has +brought on him the rebuke of more than one of his patriotic countrymen. +There is a sobriety and coolness in his estimate of historical evidence, +equally removed from temerity on the one hand, and credulity on the other; +in short, his whole manner is that of a man conversant with public +business, and free from the closet pedantry which too often characterizes +the monkish annalists. The greater part of his life was passed under the +reign of Charles V., when the spirit of the nation was not yet broken by +arbitrary power, nor debased by the melancholy superstition which settled +on it under his successor; an age, in which the memory of ancient liberty +had not wholly faded away, and when, if men did not dare express all they +thought, they at least thought with a degree of independence which gave a +masculine character to their expression. In this, as well as in the +liberality of his religious sentiments, he may be compared favorably with +his celebrated countryman Mariana, who, educated in the cloister, and at a +period when the nation was schooled to maxims of despotism, exhibits few +glimpses of the sound criticism and reflection, which are to be found in +the writings of his Aragonese rival. The seductions of style, however, the +more fastidious selection of incidents, in short, the superior graces of +narration, have given a wider fame to the former, whose works have passed +into most of the cultivated languages of Europe, while those of Zurita +remain, as far as I am aware, still undisturbed in the vernacular. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Zurita, Historia del Rey Don Hernando el Cathólico, (Anales, tom. v. +vi., Zaragoza, 1580,) lib. 1, Introd. + +[2] The "Legazione," or official correspondence of Machiavelli, while +stationed at the different European courts, may be regarded as the most +complete manual of diplomacy as it existed at the beginning of the +sixteenth century. It affords more copious and curious information +respecting the interior workings of the governments with whom he resided, +than is to be found in any regular history; and it shows the variety and +extent of duties attached to the office of resident minister, from the +first moment of its creation. + +[3] "Sed diu," says Sallust, noticing the similar consequence of increased +refinement among the ancients, "magnum inter mortales certamen fuit, vine +corporis an virtute animi res militaris magis procederet. ***** Tum demum +periculo atque negotiis compertum est, in bello plurimum ingenium posse." +Bellum Catilinarium, cap. 1, 2. + +[4] Machiavelli's political treatises, his "Principe" and "Discorsi sopra +Tito Livio," which appeared after his death, excited no scandal at the +time of their publication. They came into the world, indeed, from the +pontifical press, under the privilege of the reigning pope, Clement VII. +It was not until thirty years later that they were placed on the Index; +and this not from any exceptions taken at the immorality of their +doctrines, as Ginguené has well proved, (Histoire Littéraire d'Italie, +(Paris, 1811-19,) tom. viii. pp. 32, 74,) but from the imputations they +contained on the court of Rome. + +[5] "Aquel Senado é Señoría de Venecianos," says Gonzalo de Oviedo, "donde +me parece á mi que esta recogido todo el saber é prudencia de los hombres +humanos; porque és la gente del mundo que mejor se sabe gobernar; é la +republica, que mas tiempo há durado en el mundo por la buena forma de su +regimiento, é donde con mejor manera hán los hombres vivido en comunidad +sin tener Rey;" etc. Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 3, dial. 44. + +[6] Of all the incense which poets and politicians have offered to the +Queen of the Adriatic, none is more exquisite than that conveyed in these +few lines, where Sannazaro notices her position as the bulwark of +Christendom. + + "Una Italum regina, altae pulcherrima Romae + Aemula, quae terris, quae dominaris aquis! + Tu tibi vel reges cives facis; O decus! O lux + Ausoniae, per quam libera turba sumus; + Per quam barbaries nobis non imperat, et Sol + Exoriens nostro clarius orbe micat!" + +Opera Latina, lib. 3, eleg. 1, 95. + +[7] Guicciardini, Istoria, tom. i. lib. 3, p. 147. + +[8] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 119, 123.--Fleury, Histoire +Ecclésiastique, contin. (Paris, 1722,) tom. xxiv. lib. 117, p. 545.--Peter +Martyr, whose residence and rank at the Spanish court gave him access to +the best sources of information as to the repute in which the new pontiff +was held there, expresses himself in one of his letters to Cardinal +Sforza, who had assisted at his election, in the following unequivocal +language. "Sed hoc habeto, princeps illustrissime, non placuisse meis +Regibus pontificatum ad Alexandrum, quamvis eorum ditionarium, pervenisse. +Verentur namque ne illius cupiditas, ne ambitio, ne (quod gravius) +mollities filialis Christianam religionem in praeceps trahat." Epist. 119. + +[9] A remarkable example of this occurred in the middle of the fifteenth +century, when the inundation of the Turks, which seemed ready to burst +upon them, after overwhelming the Arabian and Greek empires, had no power +to still the voice of faction, or to concentrate the attention of the +Italian states, even for a moment. + +[10] Guicciardini, Istoria, tom. i. lib. 1, p. 2. + +[11] Brantôme, Vies des Hommes Illustres, Oeuvres Complètes, (Paris, 1822- +3,) tom. ii. disc. i. pp. 2, 20. + +[12] Sismondi, Hist. des Français, tom. xv. p. 112.--Gaillard, Rivalité, +tom. iv. pp. 2, 3. + +[13] Daru, Histoire de la République de Venise, (Paris, 1821,) tom. iii. +liv. 20.--See the deed of cession, in the memoir of M. de Foncemagne. +(Mémoires de l'Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres, tom. xvii. pp. +539-579.) This document, as well as some others which appeared on the eve +of Charles's expedition, breathes a tone of Quixotic and religious +enthusiasm that transports us back to the days of the crusades. + +[14] The conflicting claims of Anjou and Aragon are stated at length by +Gaillard, with more candor and impartiality than were to be expected from +a French writer. (Histoire de François I., (Paris, 1769,) tom. i. pp. 71- +92.) They form the subject of a juvenile essay of Gibbon, in which we may +discern the germs of many of the peculiarities which afterwards +characterized the historian of the Decline and Fall. Miscellaneous Works, +(London, 1814.) vol. iii. pp. 206-222. + +[15] Essai sur les Moeurs, chap. 107.--His politic father, Louis XI., +acted on this principle, for he made no attempt to maintain his +pretensions to Naples; although Mably affects to doubt whether this were +not the result of necessity rather than policy. "Il est douteux si cette +modération fut l'ouvrage d'une connoissance approfondie de ses vrais +intérêts, ou seulement de cette défiance qu'il avoit des grands de son +royaume, et qu'il n'osoit perdre de vue." Observations sur l'Histoire de +France, Oeuvres, (Paris, 1794-5,) liv. 6, chap. 4. + +[16] Flassan, Histoire de la Diplomatic Française, (Paris, 1809,) tom. i. +pp. 254-259.--Dumont, Corps Universel Diplomatique du Droit des Gens, +(Amsterdam, 1726-31,) tom. iii. pp. 297-300. + +[17] See the narrative of these transactions in the Fifth and Sixth +Chapters of Part I. of this History. + +Most historians seem to take it for granted, that Louis XI. advanced a sum +of money to the king of Aragon; and some state, that payment of the debt, +for which the provinces were mortgaged, was subsequently tendered to the +French king. (See, among others, Sismondi, Républiques Italiennes, tom. +xii. p. 93.--Roscoe, Life and Pontificate of Leo X., (London, 1827,) vol. +i. p. 147.) The first of these statements is a palpable error; and I find +no evidence of the last in any Spanish authority, where, if true, it would +naturally have been noticed. I must, indeed, except Bernaldez, who says, +that Ferdinand having repaid the money, borrowed by his father from Louis +XI., to Charles VIII., the latter monarch returned it to Isabella, in +consideration of the great expenses incurred by the Moorish war. It is a +pity that this romantic piece of gallantry does not rest on any better +foundation than the Curate of Los Palacios, who shows a degree of +ignorance in the first part of his statement, that entitles him to little +credit in the last. Indeed, the worthy curate, although much to be relied +on for what passed in his own province, may be found frequently tripping +in the details of what passed out of it. Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., +cap. 117. + +[18] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 1, cap. 4, 7, 10. + +[19] Fleury, Histoire Ecclésiastique, contin., tom. xxiv. pp. 533-555.-- +Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 1, cap. 14.--Daru, Hist. de Venise, +tom. iii. pp. 51, 52.--Gaillard, Rivalité, tom. iv. p. 10.--Abarca, Reyes +de Aragon, tom. ii. rey 30, cap. 6. + +Comines, alluding to the affair of Roussillon, says that Ferdinand and +Isabella, whether from motives of economy or hypocrisy, always employed +priests in their negotiations. "Car toutes leurs oeuvres ont fait mener et +conduire par telles gens (religieux), ou par hypocrisie, ou afin de moins +despendre." (Mémoires, p. 211.) The French king, however, made more use of +the clergy in this very transaction than the Spanish. Zurita, Hist. del +Rey Hernando, lib. 1, cap. 10. + +[20] Paolo Giovio, Historia sui Temporis, (Basiliae, 1578,) lib. 1, p. +16.--The treaty of Barcelona is given at length by Dumont. (Corps +Diplomatique, tom. iii. pp. 297-300.) It is reported with sufficient +inaccuracy by many historians, who make no hesitation in saying, that +Ferdinand expressly bound himself, by one of the articles, not to +interfere with Charles's meditated attempt on Naples. (Gaillard, Rivalité, +tom. iv. p. 11.--Voltaire, Essai sur les Moeurs, chap. 107.--Comines, +Mémoires, liv. 8, chap. 23.--Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib. 1, p. 16.-- +Varillas, Politique d'Espagne, ou du Roi Ferdinand, (Amsterdam, 1688,) pp. +11, 12.--Roscoe, Life of Leo X., tom. i. chap. 3.) So far from this, there +is no allusion whatever to the proposed expedition in the treaty, nor is +the name of Naples once mentioned in it. + +[21] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 1, cap. 18.--Abarca, Reyes de +Aragon, ubi supra. + +[22] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 1, cap. 28.--Bembo, Istoria +Viniziana, (Milano, 1809,) tom. i. lib. 2, pp. 118, 119.--Oviedo, +Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 3, dial. 43. + +[23] Comines, Mémoires, liv. 7, introd. + +[24] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 1, cap. 20.--Peter Martyr, Opus +Epist., epist. 123.--Comines, Mémoires, liv. 7, chap. 3.--Mariana, Hist. +de España, tom. ii. lib. 26, cap. 6.--Zurita concludes the arguments which +decided Ferdinand against assuming the enterprise, with one which may be +considered the gist of the whole matter. "El Rey entendia bien que no era +tan facil la causa que se proponia." Lib. 1, cap. 20. + +[25] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 1, cap. 31. + +[26] Oviedo notices Silva as one of three brothers, all gentle cavaliers, +of unblemished honor, remarkable for the plainness of their persons, the +elegance and courtesy of their manners, and the magnificence of their +style of living. This one, Alonso, he describes as a man of a singularly +clear head. Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 4. + +[27] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, ubi supra. + +[28] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib, 1, cap. 31, 41. + +[29] Villeneuve, Mémoires, apud Petitot, Collection des Mémoires, tom. +xiv. pp. 255, 256. + +The French army consisted of 3600 gens d'armes, 20,000 French infantry, +and 8000 Swiss, without including the regular camp followers. (Sismondi, +Républiques Italiennes, tom. xii. p. 132.) + +The splendor and novelty of their appearance excited a degree of +admiration, which disarmed in some measure the terror of the Italians. +Peter Martyr, whose distance from the theatre of action enabled him to +contemplate more calmly the operation of events, beheld with a prophetic +eye the magnitude of the calamities impending over his country. In one of +his letters, he writes thus; "Scribitur exercitum visum fuisse nostra +tempestate nullum unquam nitidiorem. Et qui futuri sunt calamitatis +participes, Carolum aciesque illius ac peditum turmas laudibus extollunt; +sed Italorum impensâ instructas." (Opus Epist., epist. 143.) He concludes +another with this remarkable prediction; "Perimeris, Galle, ex majori +parte, nec in patriam redibis. Jacebis insepultus; sed tua non restituetur +strages, Italia." Epist. 123. + +[30] Guicciardini, Istoria, tom. i. lib. 1, p. 71.--Scipione Ammirato, +Istorie Fiorentine, (Firenze, 1647,) p. 205.--Giannone, Istoria di Napoli, +tom. iii. lib. 29, introd.--Comines, Mémoires, liv. 7, chap. 17.--Oviedo, +Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 3, dial. 43. + +[31] Du Bos, Histoire de la Ligue faite à Cambray, (Paris, 1728), tom. i. +dissert, prélim.--Machiavelli, Istorie Fiorentine, lib. 5.--Denina, +Rivoluzioni d'Italia, lib. 18, cap. 3. + +[32] Arte della Guerra, lib. 2. + +[33] Machiavelli, Arte della Guerra, lib. 3.--Du Bos, Ligue de Cambray, +tom. i. dis. prélim.--Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib. 2, p. 41. Polybius, +in his minute account of this celebrated military institution of the +Greeks, has recapitulated nearly all the advantages and defects imputed to +the Swiss _hérisson_, by modern European writers. (See lib. 17, sec. +25 et seq.) It is singular, that these exploded arms and tactics should be +revived, after the lapse of nearly seventeen centuries, to be foiled again +in the same manner as before. + +[34] Guicciardini, Istoria, tom. i. pp. 45, 46.--Machiavelli, Arte della +Guerra, lib. 3.--Du Bos, Ligue de Cambray, ubi supra. + +[35] Guicciardini speaks of the name of "cannon," which the French gave to +their pieces, as a novelty at that time in Italy. Istoria, pp. 45, 46. + +[36] Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib. 2, p. 42.--Machiavelli, Arte della +Guerra, lib. 7. + +[37] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 1, cap. 35.--Alonso da Silva +acquitted himself to the entire satisfaction of the sovereigns, in his +difficult mission. He was subsequently sent on various others to the +different Italian courts, and uniformly sustained his reputation for +ability and prudence. He did not live to be old. Oviedo, Quincuagenas, +MS., bat. 1, quinc. 4. + +[38] Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. lib. 26, cap. 6.--Salazar de +Mendoza, Monarquía, lib. 3, cap. 14. + +This branch of the revenue yields at the present day, according to +Laborde, about 6,000,000 reals, or 1,500,000 francs. Itinéraire, tom. vi. +p. 51. + +[39] Zurita, Abarca, and other Spanish historians, fix the date of +Alexander's grant at the close of 1496. (Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib, 2, +cap. 40.--Reyes de Aragon, rey 30, cap. 9.) Martyr notices it with great +particularity as already conferred, in a letter of February, 1495. (Opus +Epist., epist. 157.) The pope, according to Comines, designed to +compliment Ferdinand and Isabella for their conquest of Granada, by +transferring to them the title of Most Christian, hitherto enjoyed by the +kings of France. He had even gone so far as to address them thus in more +than one of his briefs. This produced a remonstrance from a number of the +cardinals; which led him to substitute the title of Most Catholic. The +epithet of Catholic was not new in the royal house of Castile, nor indeed +of Aragon; having been given to the Asturian prince Alfonso I. about the +middle of the eighth, and to Pedro II., of Aragon, at the beginning of the +thirteenth century. + +I will remark, in conclusion, that, although the phrase _Los Reyes +Católicos_, as applied to a female equally with a male, would have a +whimsical appearance literally translated into English, it is perfectly +consonant to the Spanish idiom, which requires that all words, having +reference to both a masculine and a feminine noun, should be expressed in +the former gender. So also in the ancient languages; _Aemen tyrannoi_, +says Queen Hecuba; (Euripides, _Troad_, v. 476.) But it is clearly +incorrect to render _Los Reyes Católicos_, as usually done by English +writers, by the corresponding term of "Catholic kings." + +[40] Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1495. + +[41] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 138.--Sismondi, Républiques +Italiennes, tom. xii. pp. 192-194.--Garibay, Compendio, lib. 19, cap. 4. + +[42] Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 3, dial. 43.--Zurita, Hist. +del Rey Hernando, lib. 1, cap. 43.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. +138.--Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib. 2, p. 46.--Lanuza, Historias, tom. +i. lib. 1, cap. 6. + +This appears from a letter of Martyr's, dated three months before the +interview; in which he says, "Antonius Fonseca, vir equestris ordinis, et +armis clarus, destinatus est orator, qui eum moneat, ne, priusquam de jure +inter ipsum et Alfonsum regem Neapolitanum decernatur, ulterius procedat. +Fert in mandatis Antonius Fonseca, ut Carolo capitulum id sonans ostendat, +anteque ipsius oculos (si detrectaverit) pacti veteris chirographum +laceret, atque indicat inimicitias." Opus Epist., epist. 144. + +[43] Comines, Mémoires, liv. 7, chap. 16.--Villeneuve, Mémoires, apud +Petitot, Collection des Mémoires, tom. xii., p. 260.--Ammirato, Istorie +Florentine, tom. iii. lib. 26.--Summonte, Hist. di Napoli, tom. iii. lib. +6, cap. 1, 2. + +[44] Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib. 2, p. 55.--Giannone, Istoria di +Napoli, lib. 29, cap. 1, 2.--André de la Vigne, Histoire de Charles VIII., +(Paris, 1617,) p. 201. + +[45] Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib. 2, p. 56.--Guicciardini, Istoria, +tom. i. pp. 86, 87.--Bembo, Istoria Viniziana, tom. i. lib. 2, p. 120-- +Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, chap. 3, 5.--Comines, Mémoires, +liv. 7, chap. 19. + +[46] Guicciardini, Istoria, tom. i. lib. 2, p. 88.--Comines, Mémoires, +liv. 7, chap. 20.--Bembo, Istoria Viniziana, tom. i. lib. 2, pp. 122, +123.--Daru, Hist. de Venise, tom. iii. pp. 255, 256.--Zurita, Hist. del +Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 5. + +[47] Comines, Mémoires, p. 96.--Comines takes great credit to himself for +his perspicacity in detecting the secret negotiations carried on at Venice +against his master. According to Bembo, however, the affair was managed +with such profound caution, as to escape his notice until it was +officially announced by the doge himself; when he was so much astounded by +the intelligence, that he was obliged to ask the secretary of the senate, +who accompanied him home, the particulars of what the doge had said, as +his ideas were so confused at the time, that he had not perfectly +comprehended it. Istoria Viniziana, lib. 2, pp. 128, 129. + + + + +CHAPTER II. + +ITALIAN WARS.--RETREAT OF CHARLES VIII.--CAMPAIGNS OF GONSALVO DE +CORDOVA.--FINAL EXPULSION OF THE FRENCH. + +1495-1496. + +Impolitic Conduct of Charles.--He Plunders the Works of Art.--Gonsalvo de +Cordova.--His Brilliant Qualities.--Raised to the Italian Command.--Battle +of Seminara.--Gonsalvo's Successes.--Decline of the French.--He Receives +the Title of Great Captain.--Expulsion of the French from Italy. + + +Charles the Eighth might have found abundant occupation, during his brief +residence at Naples, in placing the kingdom in a proper posture of +defence, and in conciliating the good-will of the inhabitants, without +which he could scarcely hope to maintain himself permanently in his +conquest. So far from this, however, he showed the utmost aversion to +business, wasting his hours, as has been already noticed, in the most +frivolous amusements. He treated the great feudal aristocracy of the +country with utter neglect; rendering himself difficult of access, and +lavishing all dignities and emoluments with partial prodigality on his +French subjects. His followers disgusted the nation still further by their +insolence and unbridled licentiousness. The people naturally called to +mind the virtues of the exiled Ferdinand, whose temperate rule they +contrasted with the rash and rapacious conduct of their new masters. The +spirit of discontent spread more widely, as the French were too thinly +scattered to enforce subordination. A correspondence was entered into with +Ferdinand in Sicily, and in a short time several of the most considerable +cities of the kingdom openly avowed their allegiance to the house of +Aragon. [1] + +In the mean time, Charles and his nobles, satiated with a life of +inactivity and pleasure, and feeling that they had accomplished the great +object of the expedition, began to look with longing eyes towards their +own country. Their impatience was converted into anxiety on receiving +tidings of the coalition mustering in the north. Charles, however, took +care to secure to himself some of the spoils of victory, in a manner which +we have seen practised, on a much greater scale, by his countrymen in our +day. He collected the various works of art with which Naples was adorned, +precious antiques, sculptured marble and alabaster, gates of bronze +curiously wrought, and such architectural ornaments as were capable of +transportation, and caused them to be embarked on board his fleet for the +south of France, "endeavoring," says the Curate of Los Palacios, "to build +up his own renown on the ruins of the kings of Naples, of glorious +memory." His vessels, however, did not reach their place of destination, +but were captured by a Biscayan and Genoese fleet off Pisa. [2] + +Charles had entirely failed in his application to Pope Alexander the Sixth +for a recognition of his right to Naples, by a formal act of investiture. +[3] He determined, however, to go through the ceremony of a coronation; +and, on the 12th of May, he made his public entrance into the city, +arrayed in splendid robes of scarlet and ermine, with the imperial diadem +on his head, a sceptre in one hand, and a globe, the symbol of universal +sovereignty, in the other; while the adulatory populace saluted his royal +ear with the august title of Emperor. After the conclusion of this farce, +he made preparations for his instant departure from Naples. On the 20th of +May, he set out on his homeward march, at the head of one-half of his +army, amounting in all to not more than nine thousand fighting men. The +other half was left for the defence of his new conquest. This arrangement +was highly impolitic, since he neither took with him enough to cover his +retreat, nor left enough to secure the preservation of Naples. [4] + +It is not necessary to follow the French army in its retrograde movement +through Italy. It is enough to say, that this was not conducted with +sufficient despatch to anticipate the junction of the allied forces, who +assembled to dispute its passage on the banks of the Taro, near Fornovo. +An action was there fought, in which King Charles, at the head of his +loyal chivalry, achieved such deeds of heroism, as shed a lustre over his +ill-concerted enterprise, and which, if they did not gain him an +undisputed victory, secured the fruits of it, by enabling him to effect +his retreat without further molestation. At Turin he entered into +negotiation with the calculating duke of Milan, which terminated in the +treaty of Vercelli, October 10th, 1495. By this treaty Charles obtained no +other advantage than that of detaching his cunning adversary from the +coalition. The Venetians, although refusing to accede to it, made no +opposition to any arrangement, which would expedite the removal of their +formidable foe beyond the Alps. This was speedily accomplished; and +Charles, yielding to his own impatience and that of his nobles, recrossed +that mountain rampart which nature has so ineffectually provided for the +security of Italy, and reached Grenoble with his army on the 27th of the +month. Once more restored to his own dominions, the young monarch +abandoned himself without reserve to the licentious pleasures to which he +was passionately addicted, forgetting alike his dreams of ambition, and +the brave companions in arms whom he had deserted in Italy. Thus ended +this memorable expedition, which, though crowned with complete success, +was attended with no other permanent result to its authors, than that of +opening the way to those disastrous wars, which wasted the resources of +their country for a great part of the sixteenth century. [5] + +Charles the Eighth had left as his viceroy in Naples Gilbert de Bourbon, +duke of Montpensier, a prince of the blood, and a brave and loyal +nobleman, but of slender military capacity, and so fond of his bed, says +Comines, that he seldom left it before noon. The command of the forces in +Calabria was intrusted to M. d'Aubigny, a Scottish cavalier of the house +of Stuart, raised by Charles to the dignity of grand constable of France. +He was so much esteemed for his noble and chivalrous qualities, that he +was styled by the annalists of that day, says Brantôme, "grand chevalier +sans reproche." He had large experience in military matters, and was +reputed one of the best officers in the French service. Besides these +principal commanders, there were others of subordinate rank stationed at +the head of small detachments on different points of the kingdom, and +especially in the fortified cities along the coasts. [6] + +Scarcely had Charles the Eighth quitted Naples, when his rival, Ferdinand, +who had already completed his preparations in Sicily, made a descent on +the southern extremity of Calabria. He was supported in this by the +Spanish levies under the admiral Requesens, and Gonsalvo of Cordova, who +reached Sicily in the month of May. As the latter of these commanders was +destined to act a most conspicuous part in the Italian wars, it may not be +amiss to give some account of his early life. + +Gonzalo Fernandez de Cordova, or Aguilar, as he is sometimes styled from +the territorial title assumed by his branch of the family, was born at +Montilla, in 1453. His father died early, leaving two sons, Alonso de +Aguilar, whose name occurs in some of the most brilliant passages of the +war of Granada, and Gonsalvo, three years younger than his brother. During +the troubled reigns of John the Second and Henry the Fourth, the city of +Cordova was divided by the feuds of the rival families of Cabra and +Aguilar; and it is reported that the citizens of the latter faction, after +the loss of their natural leader, Gonsalvo's father, used to testify their +loyalty to his house by bearing the infant children along with them in +their rencontres; thus Gonsalvo may be said to have been literally nursed +amid the din of battle. [7] + +On the breaking out of the civil wars, the two brothers attached +themselves to the fortunes of Alfonso and Isabella. At their court, the +young Gonsalvo soon attracted attention by the uncommon beauty of his +person, his polished manners, and proficiency in all knightly exercises. +He indulged in a profuse magnificence in his apparel, equipage, and +general style of living; a circumstance, which, accompanied with his +brilliant qualities, gave him the title at the court of _el príncipe de +los cavalleros_, the prince of cavaliers. This carelessness of expense, +indeed, called forth more than once the affectionate remonstrance of his +brother Alonso, who, as the elder son, had inherited the _mayorazgo_, +or family estate, and who provided liberally for Gonsalvo's support. He +served during the Portuguese war under Alonso de Cardenas, grand master of +St. James, and was honored with the public commendations of his general +for his signal display of valor at the battle of Albuera; where, it is +remarked, the young hero incurred an unnecessary degree of personal hazard +by the ostentatious splendor of his armor. Of this commander, and of the +count of Tendilla, Gonsalvo always spoke with the greatest deference, +acknowledging that he had learned the rudiments of war from them. [8] + +The long war of Granada, however, was the great school in which his +military discipline was perfected. He did not, it is true, occupy so +eminent a position in these campaigns as some other chiefs of riper years +and more enlarged experience; but on various occasions he displayed +uncommon proofs both of address and valor. He particularly distinguished +himself at the capture of Tajara, Illora, and Monte Frio. At the last +place, he headed the scaling party, and was the first to mount the walls +in the face of the enemy. He wellnigh closed his career in a midnight +skirmish before Granada, which occurred a short time before the end of the +war. In the heat of the struggle his horse was slain; and Gonsalvo, unable +to extricate himself from the morass in which he was entangled, would have +perished, but for the faithful servant of the family, who mounted him on +his own horse, briefly commending to his master the care of his wife and +children. Gonsalvo escaped, but his brave follower paid for his loyalty +with his life. At the conclusion of the war, he was selected, together +with Ferdinand's secretary Zafra, in consequence of his plausible address, +and his familiarity with the Arabic, to conduct the negotiation with the +Moorish government. He was secretly introduced for this purpose by night +into Granada, and finally succeeded in arranging the terms of capitulation +with the unfortunate Abdallah, as has been already stated. In +consideration of his various services, the Spanish sovereigns granted him +a pension, and a large landed estate in the conquered territory. [9] + +After the war, Gonsalvo remained with the court, and his high reputation +and brilliant exterior made him one of the most distinguished ornaments of +the royal circle. His manners displayed all the romantic gallantry +characteristic of the age, of which the following, among other instances, +is recorded. The queen accompanied her daughter Joanna on board the fleet +which was to bear her to Flanders, the country of her destined husband. +After bidding adieu to the infanta, Isabella returned in her boat to the +shore; but the waters were so swollen, that it was found difficult to make +good a footing for her on the beach. As the sailors were preparing to drag +the bark higher up the strand, Gonsalvo, who was present, and dressed, as +the Castilian historians are careful to inform us, in a rich suit of +brocade and crimson velvet, unwilling that the person of his royal +mistress should be profaned by the touch of such rude hands, waded into +the water, and bore the queen in his arms to the shore, amid the shouts +and plaudits of the spectators. The incident may form a counterpart to the +well-known anecdote of Sir Walter Raleigh. [10] + +Isabella's long and intimate acquaintance with Gonsalvo enabled her to +form a correct estimate of his great talents. When the Italian expedition +was resolved on, she instantly fixed her eyes on him as the most suitable +person to conduct it. She knew that he possessed the qualities essential +to success in a new and difficult enterprise,--courage, constancy, +singular prudence, dexterity in negotiation, and inexhaustible fertility +of resource. She accordingly recommended him, without hesitation, to her +husband, as the commander of the Italian army. He approved her choice, +although it seems to have caused no little surprise at the court, which, +notwithstanding the favor in which Gonsalvo was held by the sovereigns, +was not prepared to see him advanced over the heads of veterans, of so +much riper years and higher military renown than himself. The event proved +the sagacity of Isabella. [11] + +The part of the squadron destined to convey the new general to Sicily was +made ready for sea in the spring of 1495. After a tempestuous voyage, he +reached Messina on the 24th of May. He found that Ferdinand, of Naples, +had already begun operations in Calabria, where he had occupied Reggio +with the assistance of the admiral Requesens, who reached Sicily with a +part of the armament a short time previous to Gonsalvo's arrival. The +whole effective force of the Spaniards did not exceed six hundred lances +and fifteen hundred foot, besides those employed in the fleet, amounting +to about three thousand and five hundred more. The finances of Spain had +been too freely drained in the late Moorish war to authorize any +extraordinary expenditure; and Ferdinand designed to assist his kinsman +rather with his name, than with any great accession of numbers. +Preparations, however, were going forward for raising additional levies, +especially among the hardy peasantry of the Asturias and Galicia, on which +the war of Granada had fallen less heavily than on the south. [12.] + +On the 26th of May, Gonsalvo de Cordova crossed over to Reggio in +Calabria, where a plan of operation was concerted between him and the +Neapolitan monarch. Before opening the campaign, several strong places in +the province, which owed allegiance to the Aragonese family, were placed +in the hands of the Spanish general, as security for the reimbursement of +expenses incurred by his government in the war. As Gonsalvo placed little +reliance on his Calabrian or Sicilian recruits, he was obliged to detach a +considerable part of his Spanish forces to garrison these places. [13] + +The presence of their monarch revived the dormant loyalty of his Calabrian +subjects. They thronged to his standard, till at length he found himself +at the head of six thousand men, chiefly composed of the raw militia of +the country. He marched at once with Gonsalvo on St. Agatha, which opened +its gates without resistance. He then directed his course towards +Seminara, a place of some strength about eight leagues from Reggio. On his +way he cut in pieces a detachment of French on its march to reinforce the +garrison there. Seminara imitated the example of St. Agatha, and, +receiving the Neapolitan army without opposition, unfurled the standard of +Aragon on its walls. While this was going forward, Antonio Grimani, the +Venetian admiral, scoured the eastern coasts of the kingdom with a fleet +of four and twenty galleys, and, attacking the strong town of Monopoli, in +the possession of the French, put the greater part of the garrison to the +sword. + +D'Aubigny, who lay at this time with an inconsiderable body of French +troops in the south of Calabria, saw the necessity of some vigorous +movement to check the further progress of the enemy. He determined to +concentrate his forces, scattered through the province, and march against +Ferdinand, in the hope of bringing him to a decisive action. For this +purpose, in addition to the garrisons dispersed among the principal towns, +he summoned to his aid the forces, consisting principally of Swiss +infantry, stationed in the Basilicate under Précy, a, brave young +cavalier, esteemed one of the best officers in the French service. After +the arrival of this reinforcement, aided by the levies of the Angevin +barons, D'Aubigny, whose effective strength now greatly surpassed that of +his adversary, directed his march towards Seminara. [14] + +Ferdinand, who had received no intimation of his adversary's junction with +Précy, and who considered him much inferior to himself in numbers, no +sooner heard of his approach, than he determined to march out at once +before he could reach Seminara, and give him battle. Gonsalvo was of a +different opinion. His own troops had too little experience in war with +the French and Swiss veterans to make him willing to risk all on the +chances of a single battle. The Spanish heavy-armed cavalry, indeed, were +a match for any in Europe, and were even said to surpass every other in +the beauty and excellence of their appointments, at a period, when arms +were finished to luxury. [15] He had but a handful of these, however; by +far the greatest part of his cavalry consisting of _ginetes_, or +light-armed troops, of inestimable service in the wild guerilla warfare to +which they had been accustomed in Granada, but obviously incapable of +coping with the iron _gendarmerie_ of France. He felt some distrust, +too, in bringing his little corps of infantry without further preparation, +armed, as they were, only with short swords and bucklers, and much +reduced, as has been already stated, in number, to encounter the +formidable phalanx of Swiss pikes. As for the Calabrian levies, he did not +place the least reliance on them. At all events, he thought it prudent, +before coming to action, to obtain more accurate information than they now +possessed, of the actual strength of the enemy. [16] + +In all this, however, he was overruled by the impatience of Ferdinand and +his followers. The principal Spanish cavaliers, indeed, as well as the +Italian, among whom, may be found names which afterwards rose to high +distinction in these wars, urged Gonsalvo to lay aside his scruples; +representing the impolicy of showing any distrust of their own strength at +this crisis, and of balking the ardor of their soldiers, now hot for +action. The Spanish chief, though far from being convinced, yielded to +these earnest remonstrances, and King Ferdinand led out his little army +without further delay against the enemy. + +After traversing a chain of hills, stretching in an easterly direction +from Seminara, at the distance of about three miles he arrived before a +small stream, on the plains beyond which he discerned the French army in +rapid advance against him. He resolved to wait its approach; and, taking +position on the slope of the hills towards the river, he drew up his horse +on the right wing, and his infantry on the left. [17] + +The French generals, D'Aubigny and Précy, putting themselves at the head +of their cavalry on the left, consisting of about four hundred heavy- +armed, and twice as many light horse, dashed into the water without +hesitation. Their right was occupied by the bristling phalanx of Swiss +spearmen in close array; behind these were the militia of the country. The +Spanish _ginetes_ succeeded in throwing the French gendarmerie into +some disorder, before it could form after crossing the stream; but, no +sooner was this accomplished, than the Spaniards, incapable of +withstanding the charge of their enemy, suddenly wheeled about and +precipitately retreated with the intention of again returning on their +assailants, after the fashion of the Moorish tactics. The Calabrian +militia, not comprehending this manoeuvre, interpreted it into a defeat. +They thought the battle lost, and, seized with a panic, broke their ranks, +and fled to a man, before the Swiss infantry had time so much as to lower +its lances against them. + +King Ferdinand in vain attempted to rally the dastardly fugitives. The +French cavalry was soon upon them, making frightful slaughter in their +ranks. The young monarch, whose splendid arms and towering plumes made him +a conspicuous mark in the field, was exposed to imminent peril. He had +broken his lance in the body of one of the foremost of the French +cavaliers, when his horse fell under him, and as his feet were entangled +in the stirrups, he would inevitably have perished in the _mêlée_, but for +the prompt assistance of a young nobleman named Juan de Altavilla, who +mounted his master on his own horse, and calmly awaited the approach +of the enemy, by whom he was immediately slain. Instances of this +affecting loyalty and self-devotion not unfrequently occur in these wars, +throwing a melancholy grace over the darker and more ferocious features of +the time. [18] + +Gonsalvo was seen in the thickest of the fight, long after the king's +escape, charging the enemy briskly at the head of his handful of +Spaniards, not in the hope of retrieving the day, but of covering the +flight of the panic-struck Neapolitans. At length he was borne along by +the rushing tide, and succeeded in bringing off the greater part of his +cavalry safe to Seminara. Had the French followed up the blow, the greater +part of the royal army, with probably King Ferdinand and Gonsalvo at its +head, would have fallen into their hands, and thus not only the fate of +the campaign, but of Naples itself, would have been permanently decided by +this battle. Fortunately, the French did not understand so well how to use +a victory, as to gain it. They made no attempt to pursue. This is imputed +to the illness of their general, D'Aubigny, occasioned by the extreme +unhealthiness of the climate. He was too feeble to sit long on his horse, +and was removed into a litter as soon as the action was decided. Whatever +was the cause, the victors by this inaction suffered the golden fruits of +victory to escape them. Ferdinand made his escape on the same day on board +a vessel which conveyed him back to Sicily; and Gonsalvo, on the following +morning before break of day, effected his retreat across the mountains to +Reggio, at the head of four hundred Spanish lances. Thus terminated the +first battle of importance in which Gonsalvo of Cordova held a +distinguished command; the only one which he lost during his long and +fortunate career. Its loss, however, attached no discredit to him, since +it was entered into in manifest opposition to his judgment. On the +contrary, his conduct throughout this affair tended greatly to establish +his reputation by showing him to be no less prudent in council, than bold +in action. [19] + +King Ferdinand, far from being disheartened by this defeat, gained new +confidence from his experience of the favorable dispositions existing +towards him in Calabria. Relying on a similar feeling of loyalty in his +capital, he determined to hazard a bold stroke for its recovery; and that, +too, instantly, before his late discomfiture should have time to operate +on the spirits of his partisans. He accordingly embarked at Messina, with +a handful of troops only, on board the fleet of the Spanish admiral, +Requesens. It amounted in all to eighty vessels, most of them of +inconsiderable size. With this armament, which, notwithstanding its +formidable show, carried little effective force for land operations, the +adventurous young monarch appeared off the harbor of Naples before the end +of June. + +Charles's viceroy, the duke of Montpensier, at that time garrisoned Naples +with six thousand French troops. On the appearance of the Spanish navy, he +marched out to prevent Ferdinand's landing, leaving a few only of his +soldiers to keep the city in awe. But he had scarcely quitted it before +the inhabitants, who had waited with impatience an opportunity for +throwing off the yoke, sounded the tocsin, and, rising to arms through +every part of the city, and massacring the feeble remains of the garrison, +shut the gates against him; while Ferdinand, who had succeeded in drawing +off the French commander in another direction, no sooner presented himself +before the walls, than he was received with transports of joy by the +enthusiastic people. [20] + +The French, however, though excluded from the city, by making a circuit +effected an entrance into the fortresses which commanded it. From these +posts, Montpensier sorely annoyed the town, making frequent attacks on it, +day and night, at the head of his gendarmerie, until they were at length +checked in every direction by barricades which the citizens hastily +constructed with wagons, casks of stones, bags of sand, and whatever came +most readily to hand. At the same time, the windows, balconies, and house- +tops were crowded with combatants, who poured down such a deadly shower of +missiles on the heads of the French as finally compelled them to take +shelter in their defences. Montpensier was now closely besieged, till at +length, reduced by famine, he was compelled to capitulate. Before the term +prescribed for his surrender had arrived, however, he effected his escape +at night, by water, to Salerno, at the head of twenty-five hundred men. +The remaining garrison, with the fortresses, submitted to the victorious +Ferdinand, the beginning of the following year. And thus, by one of those +sudden turns which belong to the game of war, the exiled prince, whose +fortunes a few weeks before appeared perfectly desperate, was again +established in the palace of his ancestors. [21] + +Montpensier did not long remain in his new quarters. He saw the necessity +of immediate action, to counteract the alarming progress of the enemy. He +quitted Salerno before the end of winter, strengthening his army by such +reinforcements as he could collect from every quarter of the country. With +this body, he directed his course towards Apulia, with the intention of +bringing Ferdinand, who had already established his headquarters there, to +a decisive engagement. Ferdinand's force, however, was so far inferior to +that of his antagonist, as to compel him to act on the defensive, until he +had been reinforced by a considerable body of troops from Venice. The two +armies were then so equally matched, that neither cared to hazard all on +the fate of a battle; and the campaign wasted away in languid operations, +which led to no important result. + +In the mean time, Gonsalvo de Cordova was slowly fighting his way up +through southern Calabria. The character of the country, rough and +mountainous, like the Alpuxarras, and thickly sprinkled with fortified +places, enabled him to bring into play the tactics which he had learned in +the war of Granada. He made little use of heavy-armed troops, relying on +his _ginetes_, and still more on his foot; taking care, however, to +avoid any direct encounter with the dreaded Swiss battalions. He made +amends for paucity of numbers and want of real strength, by rapidity of +movement and the wily tactics of Moorish warfare; darting on the enemy +where least expected, surprising his strong-holds at dead of night, +entangling him in ambuscades, and desolating the country with those +terrible forays, whose effects he had so often witnessed on the fair vegas +of Granada. He adopted the policy practised by his master Ferdinand the +Catholic in the Moorish war, lenient to the submissive foe, but wreaking +terrible vengeance on such as resisted. [22] + +The French were sorely disconcerted by these irregular operations, so +unlike anything to which they were accustomed in European warfare. They +were further disheartened by the continued illness of D'Aubigny, and by +the growing disaffection of the Calabrians, who in the southern provinces +contiguous to Sicily were particularly well inclined to Spain. + +Gonsalvo, availing himself of these friendly dispositions, pushed forward +his successes, carrying one strong-hold after another, until by the end of +the year he had overrun the whole of Lower Calabria. His progress would +have been still more rapid but for the serious embarrassments which he +experienced from want of supplies. He had received some reinforcements +from Sicily, but very few from Spain; while the boasted Galician levies, +instead of fifteen hundred, had dwindled to scarcely three hundred men; +who arrived in the most miserable plight, destitute of clothing and +munitions of every kind. He was compelled to weaken still further his +inadequate force by garrisoning the conquered places, most of which, +however, he was obliged to leave without any defence at all. In addition +to this, he was so destitute of the necessary funds for the payment of his +troops, that he was detained nearly two months at Nicastro, until +February, 1496, when he received a remittance from Spain. After this, he +resumed operations with such vigor, that by the end of the following +spring he had reduced all Upper Calabria, with the exception of a small +corner of the province, in which D'Aubigny still maintained himself. At +this crisis, he was summoned from the scene of his conquests to the +support of the king of Naples, who lay encamped before Atella, a town +intrenched among the Apennines, on the western borders of the Basilicate. +[23] The campaign of the preceding winter had terminated without any +decisive results, the two armies of Montpensier and King Ferdinand having +continued in sight of each other, without ever coming to action. These +protracted operations were fatal to the French. Their few supplies were +intercepted by the peasantry of the country; their Swiss and German +mercenaries mutinied and deserted for want of pay; and the Neapolitans in +their service went off in great numbers, disgusted with the insolent and +overbearing manners of their new allies. Charles the Eighth, in the mean +while, was wasting his hours and health in the usual round of profligate +pleasures. From the moment of recrossing the Alps he seemed to have shut +out Italy from his thoughts. He was equally insensible to the +supplications of the few Italians at his court, and the remonstrances of +his French nobles, many of whom, although opposed to the first expedition, +would willingly have undertaken a second to support their brave comrades, +whom the heedless young monarch now abandoned to their fate. [24] + +At length Montpensier, finding no prospect of relief from home, and +straitened by the want of provisions, determined to draw off from the +neighborhood of Benevento, where the two armies lay encamped, and retreat +to the fruitful province of Apulia, whose principal places were still +garrisoned by the French. He broke up his camp secretly at dead of night, +and gained a day's march on his enemy, before the latter began his +pursuit. This Ferdinand pushed with such vigor, however, that he overtook +the retreating army at the town of Atella, and completely intercepted its +further progress. This town, which, as already noticed, is situated on, +the western skirts of the Basilicate, lies in a broad valley encompassed +by a lofty amphitheatre of hills, through which flows a little river, +tributary to the Ofanto, watering the town, and turning several mills +which supplied it with flour. At a few miles' distance was the strong +place of Ripa Candida, garrisoned by the French, through which Montpensier +hoped to maintain his communications with the fertile regions of the +interior. + +Ferdinand, desirous if possible to bring the war to a close, by the +capture of the whole French army, prepared for a vigorous blockade. He +disposed his forces so as to intercept supplies by commanding the avenues +to the town in every direction. He soon found, however, that his army, +though considerably stronger than his rival's, was incompetent to this +without further aid. He accordingly resolved to summon to his support +Gonsalvo de Cordova, the fame of whose exploits now resounded through +every part of the kingdom. [25] + +The Spanish general received Ferdinand's summons while encamped with his +army at Castrovillari, in the north of Upper Calabria. If he complied with +it, he saw himself in danger of losing all the fruits of his long campaign +of victories; for his active enemy would not fail to profit by his absence +to repair his losses. If he refused obedience, however, it might defeat +the most favorable opportunity which had yet presented itself for bringing +the war to a close. He resolved, therefore, at once to quit the field of +his triumphs, and march to King Ferdinand's relief. But, before his +departure, he prepared to strike such a blow as should, if possible, +incapacitate his enemy for any effectual movement during his absence. + +He received intelligence that a considerable number of Angevin lords, +mostly of the powerful house of San Severino, with their vassals and a +reinforcement of French troops, were assembled at the little town of +Laino, on the northwestern borders of Upper Calabria; where they lay +awaiting a junction with D'Aubigny. Gonsalvo determined to surprise this +place, and capture the rich spoils which it contained, before his +departure. His road lay through a wild and mountainous country. The passes +were occupied by the Calabrian peasantry in the interest of the Angevin +party. The Spanish general, however, found no difficulty in forcing a way +through this undisciplined rabble, a large body of whom he surrounded and +cut to pieces, as they lay in ambush for him in the valley of Murano. +Laino, whose base is washed by the waters of the Lao, was defended by a +strong castle built on the opposite side of the river, and connected by a +bridge with the town. All approach to the place by the high road was +commanded by this fortress. Gonsalvo obviated this difficulty, however, by +a circuitous route across the mountains. He marched all night, and, +fording the waters of the Lao about two miles above the town, entered it +with his little army before break of day, having previously detached a +small corps to take possession of the bridge. The inhabitants, startled +from their slumbers by the unexpected appearance of the enemy in their +streets, hastily seized their arms and made for the castle on the other +side of the river. The pass, however, was occupied by the Spaniards; and +the Neapolitans and French, hemmed in on every side, began a desperate +resistance, which terminated with the death of their chief, Americo San +Severino, and the capture of such of his followers as did not fall in the +mêlée. A rich booty fell into the hands of the victors. The most glorious +prize, however, was the Angevin barons, twenty in number, whom Gonsalvo, +after the action, sent prisoners to Naples. This decisive blow, whose +tidings spread like wildfire throughout the country, settled the fate of +Calabria. It struck terror into the hearts of the French, and crippled +them so far as to leave Gonsalvo little cause for anxiety during his +proposed absence. [26] + +The Spanish general lost no time in pressing forward on his march towards +Atella. Before quitting Calabria he had received a reinforcement of five +hundred soldiers from Spain, and his whole Spanish forces, according to +Giovio, amounted to one hundred men-at-arms, five hundred light cavalry, +and two thousand foot, picked men, and well schooled in the hardy service +of the late campaign. [27] Although a great part of his march lay through +a hostile country, he encountered little opposition; for the terror of his +name, says the writer last quoted, had everywhere gone before him. He +arrived before Atella at the beginning of July. The king of Naples was no +sooner advised of his approach, than he marched out of camp, attended by +the Venetian general, the marquis of Mantua, and the papal legate, Caesar +Borgia, to receive him. All were eager to do honor to the man who had +achieved such brilliant exploits; who, in less than a year, had made +himself master of the larger part of the kingdom of Naples, and that, with +the most limited resources, in defiance of the bravest and best +disciplined soldiery in Europe. It was then, according to the Spanish +writers, that he was by general consent greeted with the title of the +Great Captain; by which he is much more familiarly known in Spanish, and, +it may be added, in most histories of the period, than by his own name. +[28] + +Gonsalvo found the French sorely distressed by the blockade, which was so +strictly maintained as to allow few supplies from abroad to pass into the +town. His quick eye discovered at once, however, that in order to render +it perfectly effectual, it would be necessary to destroy the mills in the +vicinity, which supplied Atella with flour. He undertook this, on the day +of his arrival, at the head of his own corps. Montpensier, aware of the +importance of these mills, had stationed a strong guard for their defence, +consisting of a body of Gascon archers, and the Swiss pikemen. Although +the Spaniards had never been brought into direct collision with any large +masses of this formidable infantry, yet occasional rencontres with small +detachments, and increased familiarity with its tactics, had stripped it +of much of its terrors. Gonsalvo had even so far profited by the example +of the Swiss, as to strengthen his infantry by mingling the long pikes, +with the short swords and bucklers of the Spaniards. [29] + +He made two divisions of his cavalry, posting his handful of heavy-armed, +with some of the light horse, so as to check any sally from the town, +while he destined the remainder to support the infantry in the attack upon +the enemy. Having made these arrangements, the Spanish chieftain led on +his men confidently to the charge. The Gascon archery, however, seized +with a panic, scarcely awaited his approach, but fled shamefully, before +they had time to discharge a second volley of arrows, leaving the battle +to the Swiss. These latter, exhausted by the sufferings of the siege, and +dispirited by long reverses, and by the presence of a new and victorious +foe, did not behave with their wonted intrepidity, but, after a feeble +resistance, abandoned their position, and retreated towards the city. +Gonsalvo, having gained his object, did not care to pursue the fugitives, +but instantly set about demolishing the mills, every vestige of which, in +a few hours, was swept from the ground. Three days after, he supported the +Neapolitan troops in an assault on Ripa Candida, and carried that +important post, by means of which Atella maintained a communication with +the interior. [30] + +Thus cut off from all their resources, and no longer cheered by hopes of +succor from their own country, the French, after suffering the severest +privations, and being reduced to the most loathsome aliment for +subsistence, made overtures for a capitulation. The terms were soon +arranged with the king of Naples, who had no desire but to rid his country +of the invaders. It was agreed, that, if the French commander did not +receive assistance in thirty days, he should evacuate Atella, and cause +every place holding under him in the kingdom of Naples, with all its +artillery, to be surrendered to King Ferdinand; and that, on these +conditions, his soldiers should be furnished with vessels to transport +them back to France; that the foreign mercenaries should be permitted to +return to their own homes; and that a general amnesty should be extended +to such Neapolitans as returned to their allegiance in fifteen days. [31] + +Such were the articles of capitulation, signed on the 21st of July, 1496, +which Comines, who received the tidings at the court of France, does not +hesitate to denounce as "a most disgraceful treaty, without parallel, save +in that made by the Roman consuls at the Caudine Forks, which was too +dishonorable to be sanctioned by their countrymen." The reproach is +certainly unmerited; and comes with ill grace from a court, which was +wasting in riotous indulgence the very resources indispensable to the +brave and loyal subjects, who were endeavoring to maintain its honor in a +foreign land. [32] + +Unfortunately, Montpensier was unable to enforce the full performance of +his own treaty; as many of the French refused to deliver up the places +intrusted to them, under the pretence that their authority was derived, +not from the viceroy, but from the king himself. During the discussion of +this point, the French troops were removed to Baia and Pozzuolo, and the +adjacent places on the coast. The unhealthiness of the situation, together +with that of the autumnal season, and an intemperate indulgence in fruits +and wine, soon brought on an epidemic among the soldiers, which swept them +off in great numbers. The gallant Montpensier was one of the first +victims. He refused the earnest solicitations of his brother-in-law, the +marquis of Mantua, to quit his unfortunate companions, and retire to a +place of safety in the interior. The shore was literally strewed with the +bodies of the dying and the dead. Of the whole number of Frenchmen, +amounting to not less than five thousand, who marched out of Atella, not +more than five hundred ever reached their native country. The Swiss and +other mercenaries were scarcely more fortunate. "They made their way back +as they could through Italy," says a writer of the period, "in the most +deplorable state of destitution and suffering, the gaze of all, and a sad +example of the caprice of fortune." [33] Such was the miserable fate of +that brilliant and formidable array, which scarcely two years before had +poured down on the fair fields of Italy in all the insolence of expected +conquest. Well would it be, if the name of every conqueror, whose +successes, though built on human misery, are so dazzling to the +imagination, could be made to point a moral for the instruction of his +species, as effectually as that of Charles the Eighth. + +The young king of Naples did not live long to enjoy his triumphs. On his +return from Atella, he contracted an inauspicious marriage with his aunt, +a lady nearly of his own age, to whom he had been long attached. A +careless and somewhat intemperate indulgence in pleasure, succeeding the +hardy life which he had been lately leading, brought on a flux which +carried him off in the twenty-eighth year of his age, and second of his +reign. He was the fifth monarch, who, in the brief compass of three years, +had sat on the disastrous throne of Naples. + +Ferdinand possessed many qualities suited to the turbulent times in which +he lived. He was vigorous and prompt in action, and naturally of a high +and generous spirit. Still, however, he exhibited glimpses, even in his +last hours, of an obliquity, not to say ferocity of temper, which +characterized many of his line, and which led to ominous conjectures as to +what would have been his future policy. [34] + +He was succeeded on the throne by his uncle Frederic, a prince of gentle +disposition, endeared to the Neapolitans by repeated acts of benevolence, +and by a magnanimous regard for justice, of which the remarkable +fluctuations of his fortune had elicited more than one example. His +amiable virtues, however, required a kindlier soil and season for their +expansion; and, as the event proved, made him no match for the subtile and +unscrupulous politicians of the age. + +His first act was a general amnesty to the disaffected Neapolitans, who +felt such confidence in his good faith, that they returned, with scarcely +an exception, to their allegiance. His next measure was to request the aid +of Gonsalvo de Cordova in suppressing the hostile movements made by the +French during his absence from Calabria. At the name of the Great Captain, +the Italians flocked from all quarters, to serve without pay under a +banner which was sure to lead them to victory. Tower and town, as he +advanced, went down before him; and the French general, D'Aubigny, soon +saw himself reduced to the necessity of making the best terms he could +with his conqueror, and evacuating the province altogether. The submission +of Calabria was speedily followed by that of the few remaining cities in +other quarters, still garrisoned by the French; comprehending the last +rood of territory possessed by Charles the Eighth in the kingdom of +Naples. [35] + + * * * * * + +Our narrative now leads us on the beaten track of Italian history. I have +endeavored to make the reader acquainted with the peculiar character and +pretensions of the principal Spanish authorities, on whom I have relied in +the progress of the work. This would be superfluous in regard to the +Italian, who enjoy the rank of classics, not only in their own country, +but throughout Europe, and have furnished the earliest models among the +moderns of historic composition. Fortunately, two of the most eminent of +them, Guicciardini and Paolo Giovio, lived at the period of our narrative, +and have embraced the whole extent of it in their histories. These two +writers, besides the attractions of elegant scholarship, and talent, +occupied a position which enabled them to take a clear view of all the +principal political movements of their age; circumstances, which have made +their accounts of infinite value in respect to foreign transactions, as +well as domestic. Guicciardini was a conspicuous actor in the scenes he +describes; and a long residence at the court of Ferdinand the Catholic +opened to him the most authentic sources of information in regard to +Spain. Giovio, from his intimate relations with the principal persons of +his time, had also access to the best sources of knowledge, while in the +notice of foreign transactions he was but little exposed to those venal +influences, which led him too often to employ the golden or iron pen of +history as interest dictated. Unfortunately, a lamentable hiatus occurs in +his greatest work, "Historiae sui Temporis," embracing the whole period +intervening between the end of Charles VIII.'s expedition and the +accession of Leo X., in 1513. At the time of the memorable sack of Rome by +the duke of Bourbon, in 1527, Giovio deposited his manuscript, with a +quantity of plate, in an iron chest, which he hid in an obscure corner of +the church of Santa Maria sopra Minerva. The treasure, however, did not +escape the searching eyes of two Spanish soldiers, who broke open the +chest, and one of them seized on the plate, regarding the papers as of no +value. The other, not being quite such a fool, says Giovio, preserved such +of the manuscripts as were on vellum, and ornamented with rich bindings, +but threw away what was written on paper. + +The part thus thrown away contained six books, relating to the period +above mentioned, which were never afterwards recovered. The soldier +brought the remainder to their author, who bought them at the price of a +vacant benefice, which he persuaded the pope to confer on the freebooter, +in his native land of Cordova. It is not often that simony has found so +good an apology. The deficiency, although never repaired by Giovio, was in +some degree supplied by his biographies of eminent men, and, among others, +by that of Gonsalvo de Cordova, in which he has collected with great +industry all the events of any interest in the life of this great +commander. The narrative is in general corroborated by the Spanish +authorities, and contains some additional particulars, especially +respecting his early life, which Giovio's personal intimacy with the +principal characters of the period might easily have furnished. + +This portion of our story is, moreover, illustrated by the labors of M. +Sismondi, in his "Républiques Italiennes," which may undoubtedly claim to +be ranked among the most remarkable historical achievements of our time; +whether we consider the dexterous management of the narrative, or the +admirable spirit of philosophy by which it is illumined. It must be +admitted, that he has perfectly succeeded in unravelling the intricate web +of Italian politics; and, notwithstanding the complicated, and, indeed, +motley character of his subject, the historian has left a uniform and +harmonious impression on the mind of the reader. This he has accomplished, +by keeping constantly in view the principle which regulated all the +various movements of the complex machinery; so that his narrative becomes, +what he terms it in his English abridgment, a history of Italian liberty. +By keeping this principle steadily before him, he has been able to solve +much that hitherto was dark and problematical in his subject; and if he +has occasionally sacrificed something to theory, he has, on the whole, +pursued the investigation in a truly philosophical manner, and arrived at +results the most honorable and cheering to humanity. Fortunately, his own +mind was deeply penetrated with reverence for the free institutions which +he has analyzed. If it is too much to say that the historian of republics +should be himself a republican, it is at least true that his soul should +be penetrated to its very depths with the spirit which animates them. No +one, who is not smitten with the love of freedom, can furnish the key to +much that is enigmatical in her character, and reconcile his readers to +the harsh and repulsive features that she sometimes wears, by revealing +the beauty and grandeur of the soul within. + +That portion of our narrative which is incorporated with Italian story is +too small to occupy much space on Sismondi's plan. He has discussed it, +moreover, in a manner not very favorable to the Spaniards, whom he seems +to have regarded with somewhat of the aversion with which an Italian of +the sixteenth century viewed the ultramontane barbarians of Europe. +Perhaps the reader may find some advantage in contemplating another side +of the picture, and studying the less familiar details presented by the +Spanish authorities. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Comines, Mémoires, liv. 7, chap. 17.--Summonte, Hist. di Napoli, tom. +iii. lib. 6, cap. 2.--Giannone, Istoria di Napoli, lib. 29, cap. 2. + +[2] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 140-143. + +[3] Summonte, Hist. di Napoli, tom. iii. lib. 6, cap. 2. + +According to Giannone, (Istoria di Napoli, lib. 29, cap. 2,) he did obtain +the investiture from the pope; but this statement is contradicted by +several, and confirmed by none, of the authorities I have consulted. + +[4] Brantôme, Hommes Illustres, Oeuvres, tom. ii. pp. 3-5.--Comines, +Mémoires, liv. 8, chap. 2. + +The particulars of the coronation are recorded with punctilious precision +by André de la Vigne, secretary of Queen Anne. (Hist. de Charles VIII., p. +201.) Daru has confounded this farce with Charles's original entry into +Naples in February. Hist. de Venise, tom. iii. liv. 20, p. 247. + +[5] Villeneuve, Mémoires, apud Petitot, Collection de Mémoires, tom. xiv. +pp. 262, 263.--Flassan, Diplomatie Française, tom. i. pp. 267-269.-- +Comines, Mémoires, liv. 8, chap. 10-12, 18. + +[6] Comines, Mémoires, liv. 8, chap. 1.--Brantôme, Hommes Illustres, tom. +ii. p. 59. + +[7] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 7.--Giovio, Vita Magni +Gonsalvi, lib. 1, pp. 204, 205. + +[8] Pulgar, Sumario de las Hazañas del Gran Capitan, (Madrid, 1834,) p. +145.--Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, lib. 1, pp. 205 et seq. + +[9] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 90.--Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, +lib. 1, pp. 211, 212.--Conde, Dominacion de los Arabes, tom. iii. cap. +42.--Quintana, Españoles Célebres, tom. i. pp. 207-216.--Pulgar, Sumario, +p. 193. + +Florian has given circulation to a popular error by his romance of +"Gonsalve de Cordone," where the young warrior is made to play a part he +is by no means entitled to, as hero of the Granadine war. Graver writers, +who cannot lawfully plead the privilege of romancing, have committed the +same error. See, among others, Varillas, Politique de Ferdinand, p. 3. + +[10] Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, p. 214.--Chrónica del Gran Capitan +Gonzalo Hernandez de Cordova y Aguilar, (Alcalá de Henares, 1584,) cap. +23. + +Another example of his gallantry occurred during the Granadine war, when +the fire of Santa Fe had consumed the royal tent, with the greater part of +the queen's apparel and other valuable effects. Gonsalvo, on learning the +disaster, at his castle of Illora, supplied the queen so abundantly from +the magnificent wardrobe of his wife Doña Maria Manrique, as led Isabella +pleasantly to remark, that, "the fire had done more execution in his +quarters, than in her own." Pulgar, Sumario, p. 187. + +[11] Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, p. 214.--Chrónica del Gran Capitan, cap. +23. + +[12] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 7, 24.--Quintana, +Españoles Célebres, tom. i. p. 222.--Chrónica del Gran Capitan, ubi supra. + +Giovio, in his biography of Gonsalvo, estimates these forces at 5000 foot +and 600 horse, which last in his History he raises to 700. I have followed +Zurita, as presenting the more probable statement, and as generally more +accurate in all that relates to his own nation. It is a hopeless task to +attempt to reconcile the manifold inaccuracies, contradictions, and +discrepancies, which perplex the narratives of the writers on both sides, +in everything relating to numerical estimates. The difficulty is greatly +increased by the extremely vague application of the term _lance_, as +we meet with it, including six, four, three, or even a less number of +followers, as the case might be. + +[13] Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. lib. 26, cap. 10.--Zurita, Hist. +del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 7. + +The occupation of these places by Gonsalvo excited the pope's jealousy, as +to the designs of the Spanish sovereigns. In consequence of his +remonstrances, the Castilian envoy, Garcilasso de la Vega, was instructed +to direct Gonsalvo, that, "in case any inferior places had been since put +into his hands, he should restore them; if they were of importance, +however, he was first to confer with his own government." King Ferdinand, +as Abarca assures his readers, "was unwilling to give cause of complaint +to any one, _unless he were greatly a gainer by it_." Reyes de Aragon, rey +30, cap. 8.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, tom. v. lib. 2, cap. 8. + +[14] Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, pp. 215-217.--Idem, Hist. sui Temporis, +pp. 83-85.--Bembo, Istoria Viniziana, lib. 3, pp. 160, 185.--Zurita, Hist. +del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 8.--Guicciardini, Istoria, lib. 2, pp. 88, +92.--Chrónica del Gran Capitan, cap. 25. + +[15] Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, lib. 1.--Du Bos, Ligue de Cambray, +introd., p. 58. + +[16] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 7.--Giovio, Vita Magni +Gonsalvi, ubi supra. + +[17] Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, lib. 1, pp. 216, 217.--Chrónica del Gran +Capitan, cap. 24.--Quintana, Españoles Célebres, tom. i. pp. 223-227. + +[18] Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib. 3, pp. 83-85.--Chrónica del Gran +Capitan, cap. 24.--Summonte, Hist. di Napoli, tom. iii. lib. 6, cap. 2.-- +Guicciardini, Istoria, lib. 2, p. 112.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. lib. +19, p. 690. + +[19] Guicciardini, Istoria, lib. 1, p. 112.--Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, +lib. 3, p. 85.--Lanuza, Historias, tom. i. lib. 1, cap. 7. + +[20] Summonte, Hist. di Napoli, tom. vi. p. 519.--Guicciardini, Istoria, +lib. 2, pp. 113, 114.--Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib. 3, pp. 87, 88.-- +Villeneuve, Mémoires, apud Petitot, Collection des Mémoires, tom. xiv. pp. +264, 265. + +[21] Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib. 3, pp. 88-90, 114-119.-- +Guicciardini, Istoria, lib, 2, pp. 114-117.--Summonte, Hist. di Napoli, +tom. vi. pp. 520, 521. + +[22] Bembo, Istoria Viniziana, lib. 3, pp. 173, 174.--Chrónica del Gran +Capitan, cap. 26.--Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, lib. 1, p. 218.-- +Villeneuve, Mémoires, p. 313.--Sismondi, Républiques Italiennes, tom. xii. +p. 386. + +[23] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 11, 20.--Guicciardini, +Istoria, lib. 2, p. 140.--Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, lib. 1, pp. 219, +220.--Chrónica del Gran Capitan, cap. 25, 26. + +[24] Guicciardini, Istoria, lib. 3, pp. 140, 157, 158.--Comines, Mémoires, +liv. 8, chap. 23, 24.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 183. + +Du Bos discriminates between the character of the German levies or +landsknechts and the Swiss, in the following terms. "Les lansquenets +étoient même de beaucoup mieux faits, _généralement_ parlant, et de +bien meilleure mine sous les armes, que les fantassins Suisses; mais ils +étoient incapables de discipline. Au contraire des Suisses, ils étoient +sans obéissance pour leur chefs, et sans amitié pours leurs camarades." +(Ligue de Cambray, tom. i. dissert. prélim., p. 66.) Comines confirms the +distinction with a high tribute to the loyalty of the Swiss, which has +continued their honorable characteristic to the present day. Mémoires, +liv. 8, chap. 21. + +[25] Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, lib. 1, pp. 218, 219.--Chrónica del Gran +Capitan, cap. 28.--Quintana, Españoles Célebres, tom. i. p. 226.--Bembo, +Istoria Viniziana, lib. 3, p. 184.--Guicciardini, Istoria, lib. 3, p. 158. + +[26] Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, pp. 219, 220.--Chrónica del Gran +Capitan, cap. 27.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, tom. i. lib. 2, cap. +26.--Quintana, Españoles Célebres, tom. i. pp. 227, 228.--Guicciardini, +Istoria, lib. 3, pp. 158, 159.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. lib. +26, cap. 12. + +[27] Giovio, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 4, p. 132. + +[28] Quintana, Españoles Célebres, tom. i. p. 228.--Giovio, Vita Magni +Gonsalvi, lib. 1, p. 220. + +The Aragonese historians are much ruffled by the irreverent manner in +which Guicciardini notices the origin of the cognomen of the Great +Captain; which even his subsequent panegyric cannot atone for. "Era +capitano Gonsalvo Ernandes, di casa d'Aghilar, di patria Cordovese, uomo +di molto valore, ed esercitato lungamente nelle guerre di Granata, il +quale nel principio della venuta sua in Italia, cognominato _dalla +jattanza Spagnuola_ il Gran Capitano, per significare con questo titolo +la suprema podestà sopra loro, meritò per le preclare vittorie che ebbe +dipoi, che per consentimento universale gli fosse confermato e perpetuate +questo sopranome, per significazione di virtù grande, e di grande +eccellenza nella disciplina militare." (Istoria, tom. i. p. 112.) +According to Zurita, the title was not conferred till the Spanish +general's appearance before Atella, and the first example of its formal +recognition was in the instrument of capitulation at that place. (Hist. +del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 27.) This seems to derive support from the +fact that Gonsalvo's biographer and contemporary, Giovio, begins to +distinguish him by that epithet from this period. Abarca assigns a higher +antiquity to it, quoting the words of the royal grant of the duchy of +Sessa, made to Gonsalvo, as authority. (Reyes de Aragon, rey 39, cap. 9.) +In a former edition, I intimated my doubt of the historian's accuracy. A +subsequent inspection of the instrument itself, in a work since come into +my possession, shows this distrust to have been well founded; for it is +there simply said, that the title was conferred in Italy. Pulgar, Sumario, +p. 188. + +[29] This was improving on the somewhat similar expedient ascribed by +Polybius to King Pyrrhus, who mingled alternate cohorts, armed with short +weapons after the Roman fashion, with those of his Macedonian spearmen. +Lib. 17 sec. 24. + +[30] Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib. 4, p. 133.--Idem, Vita Magni +Gonsalvi, pp. 220, 221.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 27. +--Chrónica del Gran Capitan, cap. 28.--Quintana, Españoles Célebres, tom. +i. p. 229.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, rey 30, cap. 9. + +[31] Villeneuve, Mémoires, p. 318.--Comines, Mémoires, liv. 8, chap. 21.-- +Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib. 4, p. 136. + +[32] Comines, Mémoires, liv. 8, chap. 21. + +[33] Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, p. 137.--Comines, Mémoires, liv. 8, chap. +21.--Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, lib. 1, p. 221.--Guicciardini, Istoria, +lib. 3, p. 160.--Villeneuve, Mémoires, apud Petitot, tom. xiv. p. 318. + +[34] Giannone, Istoria di Napoli, lib. 29, cap. 2.--Summonte, Hist. di +Napoli, lib. 6, cap. 2.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 188. + +While stretched on his death-bed, Ferdinand, according to Bembo, caused +the head of his prisoner, the Bishop of Teano, to be brought to him, and +laid at the foot of his couch, that he might be assured with his own eyes +of the execution of the sentence. Istoria Viniziana, lib. 3, p. 189. + +[35] Giovio, Hist. sui Temporis, lib, 4, p. 139.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey +Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 30, 33.--Guicciardini, Istoria, lib. 3, p. 160.-- +Giannone, Istoria di Napoli, tom. iii. lib. 29, cap. 3. + + + + +CHAPTER III. + +ITALIAN WARS.--GONSALVO SUCCORS THE POPE.--TREATY WITH FRANCE.-- +ORGANIZATION OF THE SPANISH MILITIA. + +1496-1498. + +Gonsalvo Succors the Pope.--Storms Ostia.--Reception in Rome.--Peace with +France.--Ferdinand's Reputation advanced by his Conduct in the War.-- +Organization of the Militia. + + +It had been arranged by the treaty of Venice, that while the allies were +carrying on the war in Naples, the emperor elect and the king of Spain +should make a diversion in their favor, by invading the French frontiers. +Ferdinand had performed his part of the engagement. Ever since the +beginning of the war, he had maintained a large force along the borders +from Fontarabia to Perpignan. In 1496, the regular army kept in pay +amounted to ten thousand horse and fifteen thousand foot; which, together +with the Sicilian armament, necessarily involved an expenditure +exceedingly heavy under the financial pressure occasioned by the Moorish +war. The command of the levies in Roussillon was given to Don Enrique +Enriquez de Guzman, who, far from acting on the defensive, carried his men +repeatedly over the border, sweeping off fifteen or twenty thousand head +of cattle in a single foray, and ravaging the country as far as Carcassona +and Narbonne. [1] had concentrated a considerable force in the south, +retaliated by similar inroads, in one of which they succeeded in +surprising the fortified town of Salsas. The works, however, were in so +dilapidated a state, that the place was scarcely tenable, and it was +abandoned on the approach of the Spanish army. A truce soon followed, +which put an end to further operations in that quarter. [2] + +The submission of Calabria seemed to leave no further occupation for the +arms of the Great Captain in Italy. Before quitting that country, however, +he engaged in an adventure, which, as narrated by his biographers, forms a +brilliant episode to his regular campaigns. Ostia, the seaport of Rome, +was, among the places in the papal territory, forcibly occupied by Charles +the Eighth, and on his retreat had been left to a French garrison under +the command of a Biscayan adventurer named Menaldo Guerri. The place was +so situated as entirely to command the mouth of the Tiber, enabling the +piratical horde who garrisoned it almost wholly to destroy the commerce of +Rome, and even to reduce the city to great distress for want of +provisions. The imbecile government, incapable of defending itself, +implored Gonsalvo's aid in dislodging this nest of formidable freebooters. +The Spanish general, who was now at leisure, complied with the pontiff's +solicitations, and soon after presented himself before Ostia with his +little corps of troops, amounting in all to three hundred horse and +fifteen hundred foot. [3] + +Guerri, trusting to the strength of his defences, refused to surrender. +Gonsalvo, after coolly preparing his batteries, opened a heavy cannonade +on the place, which at the end of five days effected a practicable breach +in the walls. In the mean time, Garcilasso de la Vega, the Castilian +ambassador at the papal court, who could not bear to remain inactive so +near the field where laurels were to be won, arrived to Gonsalvo's +support, with a handful of his own countrymen resident in Rome. This +gallant little band, scaling the walls on the opposite side to that +assailed by Gonsalvo, effected an entrance into the town, while the +garrison was occupied with maintaining the breach against the main body of +the Spaniards. Thus surprised, and hemmed in on both sides, Guerri and his +associates made no further resistance, but surrendered themselves +prisoners of war; and Gonsalvo, with more clemency than was usually shown +on such occasions, stopped the carnage, and reserved his captives to grace +his entry into the capital. [4] + +This was made a few days after, with all the pomp of a Roman triumph. The +Spanish general entered by the gate of Ostia, at the head of his martial +squadrons in battle array, with colors flying and music playing, while the +rear was brought up by the captive chief and his confederates, so long the +terror, now the derision, of the populace. The balconies and windows were +crowded with spectators, and the streets, lined with multitudes, who +shouted forth the name of Gonsalvo de Cordova, the "deliverer of Rome!" +The procession took its way through the principal streets of the city +towards the Vatican, where Alexander the Sixth awaited its approach, +seated under a canopy of state in the chief saloon of the palace, +surrounded by his great ecclesiastics and nobility. On Gonsalvo's +entrance, the cardinals rose to receive him. The Spanish general knelt +down to receive the benediction of the pope; but the latter, raising him +up, kissed him on the forehead, and complimented him with the golden rose, +which the Holy See was accustomed to dispense as the reward of its most +devoted champions. + +In the conversation which ensued, Gonsalvo obtained the pardon of Guerri +and his associates, and an exemption from taxes for the oppressed +inhabitants of Ostia. In a subsequent part of the discourse, the pope +taking occasion most inopportunely to accuse the Spanish sovereigns of +unfavorable dispositions towards himself, Gonsalvo replied with much +warmth, enumerating the various good offices rendered by them to the +church; and, roundly taxing the pope with ingratitude, somewhat bluntly +advised him to reform his life and conversation, which brought scandal on +all Christendom. His Holiness testified no indignation at this unsavory +rebuke of the Great Captain, though, as the historians with some +simplicity inform us, he was greatly surprised to find the latter so +fluent in discourse, and so well instructed in matters foreign to his +profession. [5] + +Gonsalvo experienced the most honorable reception from King Frederic on +his return to Naples. During his continuance there, he was lodged and +sumptuously entertained in one of the royal fortresses; and the grateful +monarch requited his services with the title of Duke of St. Angelo, and an +estate in Abruzzo, containing three thousand vassals. He had before +pressed these honors on the victor, who declined accepting them till he +had obtained the consent of his own sovereigns. Soon after, Gonsalvo, +quitting Naples, revisited Sicily, where he adjusted certain differences +which had arisen betwixt the viceroy and the inhabitants respecting the +revenues of the island. Then embarking with his whole force, he reached +the shores of Spain in the month of August, 1498. His return to his native +land was greeted with a general enthusiasm far more grateful to his +patriotic heart, than any homage or honors conferred by foreign princes. +Isabella welcomed him with pride and satisfaction, as having fully +vindicated her preference of him to his more experienced rivals for the +difficult post of Italy; and Ferdinand did not hesitate to declare, that +the Calabrian campaigns reflected more lustre on his crown, than the +conquest of Granada. [6] + +The total expulsion of the French from Naples brought hostilities between +that nation and Spain to a close. The latter had gained her point, and the +former had little heart to resume so disastrous an enterprise. Before this +event, indeed, overtures had been made by the French court for a separate +treaty with Spain. The latter, however, was unwilling to enter into any +compact, without the participation of her allies. After the total +abandonment of the French enterprise, there seemed to exist no further +pretext for prolonging the war. The Spanish government, moreover, had +little cause for satisfaction with its confederates. The emperor had not +co-operated in the descent on the enemy's frontier, according to +agreement; nor had the allies ever reimbursed Spain for the heavy charges +incurred in fulfilling her part of the engagements. The Venetians were +taken up with securing to themselves as much of the Neapolitan territory +as they could, by way of indemnification for their own expenses. [7] The +duke of Milan had already made a separate treaty with King Charles. In +short, every member of the league, after the first alarm subsided, had +shown itself ready to sacrifice the common weal to its own private ends. +With these causes of disgust, the Spanish government consented to a truce +with France, to begin for itself on the 5th of March, and, for the allies, +if they chose to be included in it, seven weeks later, and to continue +till the end of October, 1497. This truce was subsequently prolonged, and, +after the death of Charles the Eighth, terminated in a definitive treaty +of peace, signed at Marcoussi, August 5th, 1498. [8] + +In the discussions to which these arrangements gave rise, the project is +said to have been broached for the conquest and division of the kingdom of +Naples by the combined powers of France and Spain, which was carried into +effect some years later. According to Comines, the proposition originated +with the Spanish court, although it saw fit, in a subsequent period of the +negotiations, to disavow the fact. [9] The Spanish writers, on the other +hand, impute the first suggestion of it to the French, who, they say, went +so far as to specify the details of the partition subsequently adopted, +according to which the two Calabrias were assigned to Spain. However this +may be, there is little doubt that Ferdinand had long since entertained +the idea of asserting his claim, at some time or other, to the crown of +Naples. He, as well as his father, and indeed the whole nation, had beheld +with dissatisfaction the transfer of what they deemed their rightful +inheritance, purchased by the blood and treasure of Aragon, to an +illegitimate branch of the family. The accession of Frederic, in +particular, who came to the throne with the support of the Angevin party, +the old enemies of Aragon, had given great umbrage to the Spanish monarch. + +The Castilian envoy, Garcilasso de la Vega, agreeably to the instructions +of his court, urged Alexander the Sixth to withhold the investiture of the +kingdom from Frederic, but unavailingly, as the pope's interests were too +closely connected, by marriage, with those of the royal family of Naples. +Under these circumstances, it was somewhat doubtful what course Gonsalvo +should be directed to pursue in the present exigency. That prudent +commander, however, found the new monarch too strong in the affections of +his people to be disturbed at present. All that now remained for +Ferdinand, therefore, was to rest contented with the possession of the +strong posts pledged for the reimbursement of his expenses in the war, and +to make such use of the correspondence which the late campaigns had opened +to him in Calabria, that, when the time arrived for action, he might act +with effect. [10] + +Ferdinand's conduct through the whole of the Italian war had greatly +enhanced his reputation throughout Europe for sagacity and prudence. It +afforded a most advantageous comparison with that of his rival, Charles +the Eighth, whose very first act had been the surrender of so important a +territory as Roussillon. The construction of the treaty relating to this, +indeed, laid the Spanish monarch open to the imputation of artifice. But +this, at least, did no violence to the political maxims of the age and +only made him regarded as the more shrewd and subtile diplomatist; while, +on the other hand, he appeared before the world in the imposing attitude +of the defender of the church, and of the rights of his injured kinsman. +His influence had been clearly discernible in every operation of moment, +whether civil or military. He had been most active, through his +ambassadors at Genoa, Venice, and Rome, in stirring up the great Italian +confederacy, which eventually broke the power of King Charles; and his +representations had tended, as much as any other cause, to alarm the +jealousy of Sforza, to fix the vacillating politics of Alexander, and to +quicken the cautious and dilatory movements of Venice. He had shown equal +vigor in action; and contributed mainly to the success of the war by his +operations on the side of Roussillon, and still more in Calabria. On the +latter, indeed, he had not lavished any extraordinary expenditure; a +circumstance partly attributable to the state of his finances, severely +taxed, as already noticed, by the Granadine war, as well as by the +operations in Roussillon, but in part, also, to his habitual frugality, +which, with a very different spirit from that of his illustrious consort, +always stinted the measure of his supplies to the bare exigency of the +occasion. Fortunately, the genius of the Great Captain was so fruitful in +resources, as to supply every deficiency; enabling him to accomplish such +brilliant results, as effectually concealed any poverty of preparation on +the part of his master. + +The Italian wars were of signal importance to the Spanish nation. Until +that time, they had been cooped up within the narrow limits of the +Peninsula, uninstructed and taking little interest in the concerns of the +rest of Europe. A new world was now opened to them. They were taught to +measure their own strength by collision with other powers on a common +scene of action; and, success inspiring them with greater confidence, +seemed to beckon them on towards the field, where they were destined to +achieve still more splendid triumphs. + +This war afforded them also a most useful lesson of tactics. The war of +Granada had insensibly trained up a hardy militia, patient and capable of +every privation and fatigue, and brought under strict subordination. This +was a great advance beyond the independent and disorderly habits of the +feudal service. A most valuable corps of light troops had been formed, +schooled in all the wild, irregular movements of guerilla warfare. But the +nation was still defective in that steady, well-disciplined infantry, +which, in the improved condition of military science, seemed destined to +decide the fate of battles in Europe thenceforward. + +The Calabrian campaigns, which were suited in some degree to the display +of their own tactics, fortunately gave the Spaniards opportunity for +studying at leisure those of their adversaries. The lesson was not lost. +Before the end of the war important innovations were made in the +discipline and arms of the Spanish soldier. The Swiss pike, or lance, +which, as has been already noticed, Gonsalvo de Cordova had mingled with +the short sword of his own legions, now became the regular weapon of one- +third of the infantry. The division of the various corps in the cavalry +and infantry services was arranged on more scientific principles, and the +whole, in short, completely reorganized. [11] + +Before the end of the war, preparations were made for embodying a national +militia, which should take the place of the ancient hermandad. Laws were +passed regulating the equipment of every individual according to his +property. A man's arms were declared not liable for debt, even to the +crown; and smiths and other artificers were restricted, under severe +penalties, from working them up into other articles. [12] In 1496, a +census was taken of all persons capable of bearing arms; and by an +ordinance, dated at Valladolid, February 22d, in the same year, it was +provided that one out of every twelve inhabitants, between twenty and +forty-five years of age, should be enlisted in the service of the state, +whether for foreign war, or the suppression of disorders at home. The +remaining eleven were liable to be called on in case of urgent necessity. +These recruits were to be paid during actual service, and excused from +taxes; the only legal exempts were the clergy, hidalgos, and paupers. A +general review and inspection of arms were to take place every year, in +the months of March and September, when prizes were to be awarded to those +best accoutred, and most expert in the use of their weapons. Such were the +judicious regulations by which every citizen, without being withdrawn from +his regular occupation, was gradually trained up for the national defence; +and which, without the oppressive incumbrance of a numerous standing army, +placed the whole effective force of the country, prompt and fit for +action, at the disposal of the government, whenever the public good should +call for it. [13] + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 12-14; 16, 24. + +Giovio says, in allusion to King Ferdinand's show of preparation on the +frontier, "Ferdinandus, maximè cautus et pecuniae tenax, speciem ingentis +coacti exercitus ad deterrendos hostes praebere, quam bellum gerere +mallet, quum id sine ingenti pecunià administrari non posse intelligeret." +Hist. sui Temporis, p. 140. + +[2] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 35, 36.--Abarca, Reyes de +Aragon, rey 30, cap. 9.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. 5.-- +Comines, Mémoires, liv. 8, chap. 23.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. +169. + +[3] Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, lib. 1, p. 221.--Chrónica del Gran +Capitan, cap. 30.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 3, cap. 1.-- +Villeneuve, Mémoires, p. 317. + +[4] Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, p. 222.--Quintana, Españoles Célebres, +tom. i. p. 234. + +[5] Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, p. 222.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, +lib. 3, cap. 1.--Guicciardini, Istoria, lib. 3, p. 175.--Chrónica del Gran +Capitan, cap. 30. + +[6] Giovio, Vita Magni Gonsalvi, p. 223.--Chrónica del Gran Capitan, cap. +31, 32.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 3, cap. 38. + +[7] Comines says, with some _naïveté_, in reference to the places in +Naples which the Venetians had got into their possession, "Je croy que +leur intention n'est point de les rendre; car ils ne l'ont point de +coustume quand elles leur sont bienséantes comme sont cellescy, qui sont +du costé de leur goufre de Venise." Mémoires, p. 194. + +[8] Guicciardini, Istoria, lib. 3, p. 178.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey +Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 44; lib. 3, cap. 13, 19, 21, 26.--Comines, +Mémoires, liv. 8, chap. 23. + +[9] Comines gives some curious details respecting the French embassy, +which he considers to have been completely outwitted by the superior +management of the Spanish government; who intended nothing further at this +time by the proposal of a division, than to amuse the French court until +the fate of Naples should be decided. Mémoires, liv. 8, chap. 23. + +[10] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 26, 33.--Mariana, Hist. +de España, lib. 26, cap. 16.--Salazar de Mendoza, Monarquía, tom. i. lib. +3, cap. 10. + +[11] Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 6.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey +Hernando, lib. 3, cap. 6. + +The ancient Spaniards, who were as noted as the modern for the temper and +finish of their blades, used short swords, in the management of which they +were very adroit. "Hispano," says Livy, "punctim magis, quam caesim, +adsueto petere hostem, brevitate habiles [gladii] et cum macronibus." +(Hist., lib. 22, cap. 47.) Sandoval notices the short sword, "cortas +espadas," as the peculiar weapon of the Spanish soldier in the twelfth +century. Historia de los Reyes de Castilla y de Leon, (Madrid, 1792,) tom. +ii. p. 240. + +[12] Pragmáticas del Reyno, fol. 83, 127, 129. + +The former of these ordinances, dated Taraçona, Sept. 18th, 1495, is +extremely precise in specifying the appointments required for each +individual. + +Among other improvements, introduced somewhat earlier, may be mentioned +that of organizing and thoroughly training a small corps of heavy-armed +cavalry, amounting to twenty-five hundred. The number of men-at-arms had +been greatly reduced in the kingdom of late years, in consequence of the +exclusive demand for the _ginetes_ in the Moorish war. Oviedo, +Quincuagenas, MS. + +Ordinances were also passed for encouraging the breed of horses, which had +suffered greatly from the preference very generally given by the Spaniards +to mules. This had been carried to such a length, that, while it was +nearly impossible, according to Bernaldez, to mount ten or twelve thousand +cavalry on horses, ten times that number could be provided with mules. +(Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 184.) "E porque si a esto se diesse lugar," +says one of the _pragmáticas_, adverting to this evil, "muy prestamente se +perderia en nuestros reynos la nobleza de la cauellería que en ellos suele +auer, e se oluidaria el exercicio militar de que en los tiempos passados +nuestra nacion de España ha alcançado gran fama e loor;" it was ordered +that no person in the kingdom should be allowed to keep a mule, unless he +owned a horse also; and that none but ecclesiastics and women should be +allowed the use of mules in the saddle. These edicts were enforced with +the utmost rigor, the king himself setting the example of conformity to +them. By these seasonable precautions, the breed of Spanish horses, so +long noted throughout Europe, was restored to its ancient credit, and the +mule consigned to the humble and appropriate offices of drudgery, or +raised only for exportation. For these and similar provisions, see +Pragmáticas del Reyno, fol. 127-132. + +Matéo Aleman's whimsical _picaresco_ novel, Guzman d'Alfarache, contains a +comic adventure, showing the excessive rigor with which the edict against +mules was enforced, as late as the close of Philip II.'s reign. The +passage is extracted in Roscoe's elegant version of the Spanish Novelists, +Vol. I. p. 132. + +[13] See a copy of the ordinance taken from the Archives of Simancas; apud +Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. apend. 13. + +When Francis I, who was destined to feel the effects of this careful +military discipline, beheld, during his detention in Spain in the +beginning of the following century, striplings with scarce down upon the +chin, all armed with swords at their sides, he is said to have cried out, +"O bienaventurada España, que pare y eria los hombres armados!" (L. +Marineo, Cosas Memorables, lib. 5.) An exclamation not unworthy of a +Napoleon,--or an Attila. + + + + +CHAPTER IV. + +ALLIANCES OF THE ROYAL FAMILY.--DEATH OF PRINCE JOHN AND PRINCESS +ISABELLA. + +Royal Family of Castile.--Matrimonial Alliances with Portugal.--With +Austria.--Marriage of John and Margaret.--Death of Prince John.--The +Queen's Resignation.--Independence of the Cortes of Aragon.--Death of the +Princess Isabella.--Recognition of her Infant Son Miguel. + + +The credit and authority which the Castilian sovereigns established by the +success of their arms, were greatly raised by the matrimonial connections +which they formed for their children. This was too important a spring of +their policy to be passed over in silence. Their family consisted of one +son and four daughters, whom they carefully educated in a manner befitting +their high rank; and who repaid their solicitude by exemplary filial +obedience, and the early manifestation of virtues rare even in a private +station. [1] They seem to have inherited many of the qualities which +distinguished their illustrious mother; great decorum and dignity of +manners, combined with ardent sensibilities, and unaffected piety, which, +at least in the eldest and favorite daughter, Isabella, was, unhappily, +strongly tinctured with bigotry. They could not, indeed, pretend to their +mother's comprehensive mind, and talent for business, although there seems +to have been no deficiency in these respects; or, if any, it was most +effectually supplied by their excellent education. [2] + +The marriage of the princess Isabella with Alonso, the heir of the +Portuguese crown, in 1490, has been already noticed. This had been eagerly +desired by her parents, not only for the possible contingency, which it +afforded, of bringing the various monarchies of the Peninsula under one +head, (a design of which they never wholly lost sight,) but from the wish +to conciliate a formidable neighbor, who possessed various means of +annoyance, which he had shown no reluctance to exert. The reigning +monarch, John the Second, a bold and crafty prince, had never forgotten +his ancient quarrel with the Spanish sovereigns in support of their rival +Joanna Beltraneja, or Joanna the Nun, as she was generally called in the +Castilian court after she had taken the veil. John, in open contempt of +the treaty of Alcantara, and indeed of all monastic rule, had not only +removed his relative from the convent of Santa Clara, but had permitted +her to assume a royal state, and subscribe herself "I the Queen." This +empty insult he accompanied with more serious efforts to form such a +foreign alliance for the liberated princess as should secure her the +support of some arm more powerful than his own, and enable her to renew +the struggle for her inheritance with better chance of success. [3] These +flagrant proceedings had provoked the admonitions of the Roman see, and +had formed the topic, as may be believed, of repeated, though ineffectual +remonstrance from the court of Castile. [4] + +It seemed probable that the union of the princess of the Asturias with the +heir of Portugal, as originally provided by the treaty of Alcantara, would +so far identify the interests of the respective parties as to remove all +further cause of disquietude. The new bride was received in Portugal in a +spirit which gave cordial assurance of these friendly relations for the +future; and the court of Lisbon celebrated the auspicious nuptials with +the gorgeous magnificence, for which, at this period of its successful +enterprise, it was distinguished above every other court in Christendom. +[5] + +Alonso's death, a few months after this event, however, blighted the fair +hopes which had begun to open of a more friendly feeling between the two +countries. His unfortunate widow, unable to endure the scenes of her +short-lived happiness, soon withdrew into her own country to seek such +consolation as she could find in the bosom of her family. There, +abandoning herself to the melancholy regrets to which her serious and +pensive temper naturally disposed her, she devoted her hours to works of +piety and benevolence, resolved to enter no more into engagements, which +had thrown so dark a cloud over the morning of her life. [6] + +On King John's death, in 1495, the crown of Portugal devolved on Emanuel, +that enlightened monarch, who had the glory in the very commencement of +his reign of solving the grand problem, which had so long perplexed the +world, of the existence of an undiscovered passage to the east. This +prince had conceived a passion for the young and beautiful Isabella during +her brief residence in Lisbon; and, soon after his accession to the +throne, he despatched an embassy to the Spanish court inviting her to +share it with him. But the princess, wedded to the memory of her early +love, declined the proposals, notwithstanding they were strongly seconded +by the wishes of her parents, who, however, were unwilling to constrain +their daughter's inclinations on so delicate a point, trusting perhaps to +the effects of time, and the perseverance of her royal suitor. [7] + +In the mean while, the Catholic sovereigns were occupied with negotiations +for the settlement of the other members of their family. The ambitious +schemes of Charles the Eighth established a community of interests among +the great European states, such as had never before existed, or, at least, +been understood; and the intimate relations thus introduced naturally led +to intermarriages between the principal powers, who, until this period, +seem to have been severed almost as far asunder as if oceans had rolled +between them. The Spanish monarchs, in particular, had rarely gone beyond +the limits of the Peninsula for their family alliances. The new +confederacy into which Spain had entered, now opened the way to more +remote connections, which were destined to exercise a permanent influence +on the future politics of Europe. It was while Charles the Eighth was +wasting his time at Naples, that the marriages were arranged between the +royal houses of Spain and Austria, by which the weight of these great +powers was thrown into the same scale, and the balance of Europe unsettled +for the greater part of the following century. [8] + +The treaty provided, that Prince John, the heir of the Spanish monarchies, +then in his eighteenth year, should be united with the princess Margaret, +daughter of the emperor Maximilian; and that the archduke Philip, his son +and heir, and sovereign of the Low Countries in his mother's right, should +marry Joanna, second daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella. No dowry was to +be required with either princess. [9] + +In the course of the following year, arrangements were also concluded for +the marriage of the youngest daughter of the Castilian sovereigns with a +prince of the royal house of England, the first example of the kind for +more than a century. [10] Ferdinand had cultivated the good-will of Henry +the Seventh, in the hope of drawing him into the confederacy against the +French monarch; and in this had not wholly failed, although the wary king +seems to have come into it rather as a silent partner, if we may so say, +than with the intention of affording any open or very active co-operation. +[11] The relations of amity between the two courts were still further +strengthened by the treaty of marriage above alluded to, finally adjusted +October 1st, 1496, and ratified the following year, between Arthur, prince +of Wales, and the infanta Doña Catalina, conspicuous in English history, +equally for her misfortunes and her virtues, as Catharine of Aragon. [12] +The French viewed with no little jealousy the progress of these various +negotiations, which they zealously endeavored to thwart by all the +artifices of diplomacy. But King Ferdinand had sufficient address to +secure in his interests persons of the highest credit at the courts of +Henry and Maximilian, who promptly acquainted him with the intrigues of +the French government, and effectually aided in counteracting them. [13] + +The English connection was necessarily deferred for some years, on account +of the youth of the parties, neither of whom exceeded eleven years of age. +No such impediment occurred in regard to the German alliances, and +measures were taken at once for providing a suitable conveyance for the +infanta Joanna into Flanders, which should bring back the princess +Margaret on its return. By the end of summer, in 1496, a fleet consisting +of one hundred and thirty vessels, large and small, strongly manned and +thoroughly equipped with all the means of defence against the French +cruisers, was got ready for sea in the ports of Guipuscoa and Biscay. [14] +The whole was placed under the direction of Don Fadrique Enriquez, admiral +of Castile, who carried with him a splendid show of chivalry, chiefly +drawn from the northern provinces of the kingdom. A more gallant and +beautiful armada never before quitted the shores of Spain. The infanta +Joanna, attended by a numerous suite, arrived on board the fleet towards +the end of August, at the port of Laredo, on the eastern borders of the +Asturias, where she took a last farewell of the queen her mother, who had +postponed the hour of separation as long as possible, by accompanying her +daughter to the place of embarkation. + +The weather soon after her departure became extremely rough and +tempestuous; and it was so long before any tidings of the squadron reached +the queen, that her affectionate heart was filled with the most +distressing apprehensions. She sent for the oldest and most experienced +navigators in these boisterous northern seas, consulting them, says +Martyr, day and night on the probable causes of delay, the prevalent +courses of the winds at that season, and the various difficulties and +dangers of the voyage; bitterly regretting that the troubles with France +prevented any other means of communication, than the treacherous element +to which she had trusted her daughter. [15] Her spirits were still further +depressed at this juncture by the death of her own mother, the dowager +Isabella, who, under the mental infirmity with which she had been visited +for many years, had always experienced the most devoted attention from her +daughter, who ministered to her necessities with her own hands, and +watched over her declining years with the most tender solicitude.[16] + +At length, the long-desired intelligence came of the arrival of the +Castilian fleet at its place of destination. It had been so grievously +shattered, however, by tempests, as to require being refitted in the ports +of England. Several of the vessels were lost, and many of Joanna's +attendants perished from the inclemency of the weather, and the numerous +hardships to which they were exposed. The infanta, however, happily +reached Flanders in safety, and, not long after, her nuptials with the +archduke Philip were celebrated in the city of Lisle with all suitable +pomp and solemnity. + +The fleet was detained until the ensuing winter, to transport the destined +bride of the young prince of the Asturias to Spain. This lady, who had +been affianced in her cradle to Charles the Eighth of France, had received +her education in the court of Paris. On her intended husband's marriage +with the heiress of Brittany, she had been returned to her native land +under circumstances of indignity never to be forgiven by the house of +Austria. She was now in the seventeenth year of her age, and had already +given ample promise of those uncommon powers of mind which distinguished +her in riper years, and of which she has left abundant evidence in various +written compositions. [17] + +On her passage to Spain, in midwinter, the fleet encountered such +tremendous gales, that part of it was ship-wrecked, and Margaret's vessel +had wellnigh foundered. She retained, however, sufficient composure amidst +the perils of her situation, to indite her own epitaph, in the form of a +pleasant distich, which Pontenelle has made the subject of one of his +amusing dialogues, where he affects to consider the fortitude displayed by +her at this awful moment as surpassing that of the philosophic Adrian in +his dying hour, or the vaunted heroism of Cato of Utica. [18] + +Fortunately, however, Margaret's epitaph was not needed; she arrived in +safety at the port of Santander in the Asturias, early in March, 1497. + +The young prince of the Asturias, accompanied by the king his father, +hastened towards the north to receive his royal mistress, whom they met +and escorted to Burgos, where she was received with the highest marks of +satisfaction by the queen and the whole court. Preparations were instantly +made for solemnizing the nuptials of the royal pair, after the expiration +of Lent, in a style of magnificence such as had never before been +witnessed under the present reign. The marriage ceremony took place on the +3d of April, and was performed by the archbishop of Toledo in the presence +of the grandees and principal nobility of Castile, the foreign +ambassadors, and the delegates from Aragon. Among these latter were the +magistrates of the principal cities, clothed in their municipal insignia +and crimson robes of office, who seem to have had quite as important parts +assigned them by their democratic communities, in this and all similar +pageants, as any of the nobility or gentry. The nuptials were followed by +a brilliant succession of fetes, tourneys, tilts of reeds, and other +warlike spectacles, in which the matchless chivalry of Spain poured into +the lists to display their magnificence and prowess in the presence of +their future queen. [19] The chronicles of the day remark on the striking +contrast, exhibited at these entertainments, between the gay and familiar +manners of Margaret and her Flemish nobles, and the pomp and stately +ceremonial of the Castilian court, to which, indeed, the Austrian +princess, nurtured as she had been in a Parisian atmosphere, could never +be wholly reconciled. [20] + +The marriage of the heir apparent could not have been celebrated at a more +auspicious period. It was in the midst of negotiations for a general +peace, when the nation might reasonably hope to taste the sweets of +repose, after so many uninterrupted years of war. Every bosom swelled with +exultation in contemplating the glorious destinies of their country under +the beneficent sway of a prince, the first heir of the hitherto divided +monarchies of Spain. Alas! at the moment when Ferdinand and Isabella, +blessed in the affections of their people, and surrounded by all the +trophies of a glorious reign, seemed to have reached the very zenith of +human felicity, they were doomed to receive one of those mournful lessons, +which admonish us that all earthly prosperity is but a dream. [21] + +Not long after Prince John's marriage, the sovereigns had the satisfaction +to witness that of their daughter Isabella, who, notwithstanding her +repugnance to a second union, had yielded at length to the urgent +entreaties of her parents to receive the addresses of her Portuguese +lover. She required as the price of this, however, that Emanuel should +first banish the Jews from his dominions, where they had bribed a resting- +place since their expulsion from Spain; a circumstance to which the +superstitious princess imputed the misfortunes which had fallen of late on +the royal house of Portugal. Emanuel, whose own liberal mind revolted at +this unjust and impolitic measure, was weak enough to allow his passion to +get the better of his principles, and passed sentence of exile on every +Israelite in his kingdom; furnishing, perhaps, the only example, in which +love has been made one of the thousand motives for persecuting this +unhappy race. [22] + +The marriage, ushered in under such ill-omened auspices, was celebrated at +the frontier town of Valencia de Alcantara, in the presence of the +Catholic sovereigns, without pomp or parade of any kind. While they were +detained there, an express arrived from Salamanca, bringing tidings of the +dangerous illness of their son, the prince of the Asturias. He had been +seized with a fever in the midst of the public rejoicings to which his +arrival with his youthful bride in that city had given rise. The symptoms +speedily assumed an alarming character. The prince's constitution, +naturally delicate, though strengthened by a life of habitual temperance, +sunk under the violence of the attack; and when his father, who posted +with all possible expedition to Salamanca, arrived there, no hopes were +entertained of his recovery. [23] + +Ferdinand, however, endeavored to cheer his son with hopes which he did +not feel himself; but the young prince told him that it was too late to be +deceived; that he was prepared to part with a world, which in its best +estate was filled with vanity and vexation; and that all he now desired +was, that his parents might feel the same sincere resignation to the +divine will, which he experienced himself. Ferdinand gathered new +fortitude from the example of his heroic son, whose presages were +unhappily too soon verified. He expired on the 4th of October, 1497, in +the twentieth year of his age, in the same spirit of Christian philosophy +which he had displayed during his whole illness. [24] + +Ferdinand, apprehensive of the effect which the abrupt intelligence of +this calamity might have on the queen, caused letters to be sent at brief +intervals, containing accounts of the gradual decline of the prince's +health, so as to prepare her for the inevitable stroke. Isabella, however, +who through all her long career of prosperous fortune may be said to have +kept her heart in constant training for the dark hour of adversity, +received the fatal tidings in a spirit of meek and humble acquiescence, +testifying her resignation in the beautiful language of Scripture, "The +Lord hath given, and the Lord hath taken away; blessed be his name!" [25] + +"Thus," says Martyr, who had the melancholy satisfaction of rendering the +last sad offices to his royal pupil, "was laid low the hope of all Spain." +"Never was there a death," says another chronicler, "which occasioned such +deep and general lamentation throughout the land." All the unavailing +honors which affection could devise were paid to his memory. His funeral +obsequies were celebrated with melancholy splendor, and his remains +deposited in the noble Dominican monastery of St. Thomas at Avila, which +had been erected by his parents. The court put on a new and deeper +mourning than that hitherto used, as if to testify their unwonted grief. +[26] All offices, public and private, were closed for forty days; and +sable-colored banners were suspended from the walls and portals of the +cities. Such extraordinary tokens of public sorrow bear strong testimony +to the interest felt in the young prince, independently of his exalted +station; similar, and perhaps more unequivocal evidence of his worth, is +afforded by abundance of contemporary notices, not merely in works +designed for the public, but in private correspondence. The learned +Martyr, in particular, whose situation, as Prince John's preceptor, +afforded him the best opportunities of observation, is unbounded in +commendations of his royal pupil, whose extraordinary promise of +intellectual and moral excellence had furnished him with the happiest, +alas! delusive auguries, for the future destiny of his country. [27] + +By the death of John without heirs, the succession devolved on his eldest +sister, the queen of Portugal. [28] Intelligence, however, was received +soon after that event, that the archduke Philip, with the restless +ambition which distinguished him in later life, had assumed for himself +and his wife Joanna the title of "princes of Castile." Ferdinand and +Isabella, disgusted with this proceeding, sent to request the attendance +of the king and queen of Portugal in Castile, in order to secure a +recognition of their rights by the national legislature. The royal pair, +accordingly, in obedience to the summons, quitted their capital of Lisbon, +early in the spring of 1498. In their progress through the country, they +were magnificently entertained at the castles of the great Castilian +lords, and towards the close of April reached the ancient city of Toledo, +where the cortes had been convened to receive them. [29] + +After the usual oaths of recognition had been tendered, without +opposition, by the different branches to the Portuguese princes, the court +adjourned to Saragossa, where the legislature of Aragon was assembled for +a similar purpose. + +Some apprehensions were entertained, however, of the unfavorable +disposition of that body, since the succession of females was not +countenanced by the ancient usage of the country; and the Aragonese, as +Martyr remarks in one of his Epistles, "were well known to be a +pertinacious race, who would leave no stone unturned, in the maintenance +of their constitutional rights." [30] + +These apprehensions were fully realized; for, no sooner was the object of +the present meeting laid before cortes in a speech from the throne, with +which parliamentary business in Aragon was always opened, than decided +opposition was manifested to a proceeding, which it was declared had no +precedent in their history. The succession of the crown, it was contended, +had been limited by repeated testaments of their princes to male heirs, +and practice and public sentiment had so far coincided with this, that the +attempted violation of the rule by Peter the Fourth, in favor of his own +daughters, had plunged the nation in a civil war. It was further urged +that by the will of the very last monarch, John the Second, it was +provided that the crown should descend to the male issue of his son +Ferdinand, and in default of such to the male issue of Ferdinand's +daughters, to the entire exclusion of the females. At all events, it was +better to postpone the consideration of this matter until the result of +the queen of Portugal's pregnancy, then far advanced, should be +ascertained; since, should it prove to be a son, all doubts of +constitutional validity would be removed. + +In answer to these objections, it was stated, that no express law existed +in Aragon excluding females from the succession; that an example had +already occurred, as far back indeed as the twelfth century, of a queen +who held the crown in her own right; that the acknowledged power of +females to transmit the right of succession necessarily inferred that +right existing in themselves; that the present monarch had doubtless as +competent authority as his predecessors to regulate the law of +inheritance, and that his act, supported by the supreme authority of +cortes, might set aside any former disposition of the crown; that this +interference was called for by the present opportunity of maintaining the +permanent union of Castile and Aragon; without which they must otherwise +return to their ancient divided state, and comparative insignificance. +[31] + +These arguments, however cogent, were far from being conclusive with the +opposite party; and the debate was protracted to such length, that +Isabella, impatient of an opposition to what the practice in her own +dominions had taught her to regard as the inalienable right of her +daughter, inconsiderately exclaimed, "It would be better to reduce the +country by arms at once, than endure this insolence of the cortes." To +which Antonio de Fonseca, the same cavalier who spoke his mind so +fearlessly to King Charles the Eighth, on his march to Naples, had the +independence to reply, "That the Aragonese had only acted as good and +loyal subjects, who, as they were accustomed to mind their oaths, +considered well before they took them; and that they must certainly stand +excused if they moved with caution in an affair, which they found so +difficult to justify by precedent in their history." [32] This blunt +expostulation of the honest courtier, equally creditable to the sovereign +who could endure, and the subject who could make it, was received in the +frank spirit in which it was given, and probably opened Isabella's eyes to +her own precipitancy, as we find no further allusion to coercive measures. + +Before anything was determined, the discussion was suddenly brought to a +close by an unforeseen and most melancholy event,--the death of the queen +of Portugal, the unfortunate subject of it. That princess had possessed a +feeble constitution from her birth, with a strong tendency to pulmonary +complaints. She had early felt a presentiment that she should not survive +the birth of her child; this feeling strengthened as she approached the +period of her delivery; and in less than one hour after that event, which +took place on the 23d of August, 1498, she expired in the arms of her +afflicted parents. [33] + +This blow was almost too much for the unhappy mother, whose spirits had +not yet had time to rally, since the death of her only son. She, indeed, +exhibited the outward marks of composure, testifying the entire +resignation of one who had learned to rest her hopes of happiness on a +better world. She schooled herself so far, as to continue to take an +interest in all her public duties, and to watch over the common weal with +the same maternal solicitude as before; but her health gradually sunk +under this accumulated load of sorrow, which threw a deep shade of +melancholy over the evening of her life. + +The infant, whose birth had cost so dear, proved a male, and received the +name of Miguel, in honor of the saint on whose day he first saw the light. +In order to dissipate, in some degree, the general gloom occasioned by the +late catastrophe, it was thought best to exhibit the young prince before +the eyes of his future subjects; and he was accordingly borne in the arms +of his nurse, in a magnificent litter, through the streets of the city, +escorted by the principal nobility. Measures were then taken for obtaining +the sanction of his legitimate claims to the crown. Whatever doubts had +been entertained of the validity of the mother's title, there could be +none whatever of the child's; since those who denied the right of females +to inherit for themselves, admitted their power of conveying such a right +to male issue. As a preliminary step to the public recognition of the +prince, it was necessary to name a guardian, who should be empowered to +make the requisite engagements, and to act in his behalf. The Justice of +Aragon, in his official capacity, after due examination, appointed the +grandparents, Ferdinand and Isabella, to the office of guardians during +his minority, which would expire by law at the age of fourteen. [34] + +On Saturday, the 22d of September, when the queen had sufficiently +recovered from a severe illness brought on by her late sufferings, the +four _arms_ of the cortes of Aragon assembled in the house of deputation +at Saragossa; and Ferdinand and Isabella made oath as guardians of the +heir apparent, before the Justice, not to exercise any jurisdiction +whatever in the name of the young prince during his minority; engaging, +moreover, as far as in their power, that, on his coming of age, he should +swear to respect the laws and liberties of the realm, before entering on +any of the rights of sovereignty himself. The four estates then took the +oath of fealty to Prince Miguel, as lawful heir and successor to the crown +of Aragon; with the protestation, that it should not be construed into a +precedent for exacting such an oath hereafter during the minority of the +heir apparent. With such watchful attention to constitutional forms of +procedure, did the people of Aragon endeavor to secure their liberties; +forms, which continued to be observed in later times, long after those +liberties had been swept away. [35] + +In the month of January, of the ensuing year, the young prince's +succession was duly confirmed by the cortes of Castile, and, in the +following March, by that of Portugal. Thus, for once, the crowns of the +three monarchies of Castile, Aragon, and Portugal were suspended over one +head. The Portuguese, retaining the bitterness of ancient rivalry, looked +with distrust at the prospect of a union, fearing, with some reason, that +the importance of the lesser state would be wholly merged in that of the +greater. But the untimely death of the destined heir of these honors, +which took place before he had completed his second year, removed the +causes of jealousy, and defeated the only chance, which had ever occurred, +of bringing under the same rule three independent nations, which, from +their common origin, their geographical position, and, above all, their +resemblance in manners, sentiments, and language, would seem to have +originally been intended to form but one. [36] + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] The princess Doña Isabel, the eldest daughter, was born at Dueñas, +October 1st, 1470. Their second child and only son, Juan, prince of the +Asturias, was not born until eight years later, June 30th, 1478, at +Seville. Doña Juana, whom the queen used playfully to call her "mother-in- +law," _suegra_, from her resemblance to King Ferdinand's mother, was +born at Toledo, November 6th, 1479. Doña Maria was born at Cordova, in +1482, and Doña Catalina, the fifth and last child, at Alcalá de Henares, +December 5th, 1485. The daughters all lived to reign; but their brilliant +destinies were clouded with domestic afflictions, from which royalty could +afford no refuge. Carbajal, Anales, MS., loc. mult. + +[2] The only exception to these remarks, was that afforded by the infanta +Joanna, whose unfortunate eccentricities, developed in later life, must be +imputed, indeed, to bodily infirmity. + +[3] Nine different matches were proposed for Joanna in the course of her +life; but they all vanished into air, and the "excellent lady," as she was +usually called by the Portuguese, died as she had lived, in single +blessedness, at the ripe age of sixty-eight. In the Mem. de la Acad. de +Hist., tom. vi., the 19th Ilustracion is devoted to this topic, in regard +to which Father Florez shows sufficient ignorance, or inaccuracy. Reynas +Cathólicas, tom. ii. p. 780. + +[4] Instructions relating to this matter, written with the queen's own +hand, still exist in the archives of Simancas. Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., +ubi supra. + +[5] La Clède, Histoire de Portugal, tom. iv. p. 100. + +The Portuguese historian, Faria y Sousa, expends half a dozen folio pages +on these royal revelries, which cost six months' preparation, and taxed +the wits of the most finished artists and artificers in France, England, +Flanders, Castile, and Portugal. (Europa Portuguesa, tom. ii. pp. 452 et +seq.) We see, throughout, the same luxury of spectacle, the same elegant +games of chivalry, as the tilt of reeds, the rings, and the like, which +the Castilians adopted from the Spanish Arabs. + +[6] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, tom. v. fol. 38.--Abarca, Reyes de +Aragon, tom. ii. fol. 312. + +[7] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, tom. v. fol. 78, 82.--La Clède, Hist. +de Portugal, tom. iv. p. 95.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 146. + +Martyr, in a letter written at the close of 1496, thus speaks of the +princess Isabella's faithful attachment to her husband's memory; "Mira +fuit hujus foeminae in abjiciendis secundis nuptiis constantia. Tanta est +ejus modestia, tanta vidualis castitas, ut neo mensa post mariti mortem +comederit, nec lauti quicquam degustaverit. Jejuniis sese vigiliisque ita +maceravit, ut sicco stipite siccior sit effecta. Suffulta rubore +perturbatur, quandocunque de jugali thalamo sermo intexitur. Parentum +tamen aliquando precibus, veluti olfacimus, inflectetur. Viget fama, +futuram vestri regis Emmanuelis uxorem." Epist. 171. + +[8] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, tom. v. fol. 63. + +[9] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, tom. v. lib. 2, cap. 5.--Ferreras, +Hist. d'Espagne, tom. viii. p. 160. + +[10] I believe there is no instance of such a union, save that of John of +Gaunt, duke of Lancaster, with Doña Constanza, daughter of Peter the +Cruel, in 1371, from whom Queen Isabella was lineally descended on the +father's side. The title of _Prince of the Asturias_, appropriated to +the heir apparent of Castile, was first created for the infant Don Henry, +afterwards Henry III., on occasion of his marriage with John of Gaunt's +daughter, in 1388. It was professedly in imitation of the English title of +Prince of Wales; and the Asturias were selected as that portion of the +ancient Gothic monarchy, which had never bowed beneath the Saracen yoke. +Florez, Reynas Cathólicas, tom. ii. pp. 708-715.--Mendoza, Dignidades, +lib. 3, cap. 23. + +[11] Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 25.--Rymer, Foedera, +(London, 1727,) vol. xii. pp. 638-642. + +Ferdinand used his good offices to mediate a peace between Henry VII. and +the king of Scots; and it is a proof of the respect entertained for him by +both these monarchs, that they agreed to refer their disputes to his +arbitration. (Rymer, Foedera, vol. xii. p. 671.) "And so," says the old +chronicler Hall, of the English prince, "beying confederate and alied by +treatie and league with al his neighbors, he gratefied with his moost +heartie thanks kyng Ferdinand and the quene his wife, to which woman none +other was comparable in her tyme, for that they were the mediators, +organes, and instrumentes by the which the truce was concluded betwene the +Scottish kynge and him, and rewarded his ambassadoure moost liberally and +bountefully." Chronicle, p. 483. + +[12] See the marriage treaty in Rymer. (Foedera, vol. xii. pp. 658-666.) +The marriage had been arranged between the Spanish and English courts as +far back as March, 1489, when the elder of the parties had not yet reached +the fifth year of her age. This was confirmed by another, more full and +definite, in the following year, 1490. By this treaty, it was stipulated, +that Catharine's portion should be 200,000 gold crowns, one-half to be +paid down at the date of her marriage, and the remainder in two equal +payments in the course of the two years ensuing. The prince of Wales was +to settle on her one-third of the revenues of the principality of Wales, +the dukedom of Cornwall, and earldom of Chester. Rymer, Foedera, vol. xii. +pp. 411-417. + +[13] "Procuro," says Zurita, "que se effectuassen los matrimonios de sus +hijos, no solo con promesas, pero con dadivas que se hizieron a los +privados de aquellos principes, que en ello entendian." Hist. del Rey +Hernando, lib. 2, cap. 3. + +[14] Historians differ, as usual, as to the strength of this armament. +Martyr makes it 110 vessels, and 10,000 soldiers, (Opus Epist., epist. +168;) while Bernaldez carries the number to 130 sail, and 25,000 soldiers, +(Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 153.) Ferreras adopts the latter estimate, +(tom. viii. p. 173.) Martyr may have intended only the galleys and regular +troops, while Bernaldez, more loosely, included vessels and seamen of +every description. See also the royal ordinances, ap. Coleccion de +Cédulas, (tom. i. nos. 79, 80, 82,) whose language implies a very large +number, without specifying it. + +[15] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 172.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año +1496.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. lib. 26, cap. 12. + +[16] Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1496.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. +172. + +[17] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 174.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. +lib. 19, cap. 6.--Gaillard, Rivalité, tom. iii. pp. 416, 423.--Sandoval, +Historia del Emperador Carlos V., (Amberes, 1681,) tom. i. p. 2. + +These, comprehending her verses, public addresses, and discourse on her +own life, have been collected into a single volume, under the title of "La +Couronne Margaritique," Lyons, 1549, by the French writer Jean la Maire de +Belges, her faithful follower, but whose greatest glory it is, to have +been the instructor of Clement Marot. + +[18] Fontenelle, Oeuvres, tom. i. dial. 4. + + "Ci gist Margot, la gentil' damoiselle + Qu'a deux maris, et encore est pucelle." + +It must be allowed that Margaret's quiet nonchalance was much more suited +to Fontenelle's habitual taste, than the imposing scene of Cato's death. +Indeed, the French satirist was so averse to scenes of all kinds, that he +has contrived to find a ridiculous side in this last act of the patriot +Roman. + +[19] That these were not mere holiday sports, was proved by the melancholy +death of Alonso de Cardenas, son of the comendador of Leon, who lost his +life in a tourney. Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 2, dial. 1. + +[20] Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1497.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. +lib. 26, cap. 16.--Lanuza, Historias, lib. 1, cap. 8.--Abarca, Reyes de +Aragon, tom. ii. fol. 330. + +"Y aunque," says the last author, "a la princessa se le dexaron todos sus +criados, estilos, y entretenimientos, se la advirtio, que en las +ceremonias no havia de tratar a las personas Reales, y Grandes con la +familiaridad y llaneza de las casas de Austria, Borgoñia, y Francia, sino +con la gravedad, y mesurada autoridad de los Reyes y naciones de España!" + +The sixth volume of the Spanish Academy of History contains an inventory, +taken from the archives of Simancas, of the rich plate and jewels, +presented to the princess Margaret on the day of her marriage. They are +said to be "of such value and perfect workmanship, that the like was never +before seen." (Ilust. 11, pp. 338-342.) Isabella had turned these baubles +to good account in the war of Granada. She was too simple in her taste to +attach much value to luxury of apparel. + +[21] It is precisely this period, or rather the whole period from 1493 to +1497, which Oviedo selects as that of the greatest splendor and festivity +at the court of the Catholic sovereigns. "El año de 1493, y uno ó dos +despues, y aun hasta el de 1497 años fué cuando la corte de los Reyes +Católicos Don Fernando é Doña Isabel de gloriosa memoria, mas alegres +tiempos é mas regozijados, vino en su corte, é mas encumbrada andubo la +gala é las fiestas é servicios de galanes é damas." Quincuagenas, MS., +bat. 1, quinc. 4, dial. 44. + +[22] Faria y Sousa, Europa Portuguesa, tom. ii. pp. 498, 499.--La Clède, +Hist. de Portugal, tom. iv. p. 95.--Zurita, tom. v, lib. 3, cap. 6.-- +Lanuza, Historias, ubi supra. + +[23] Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1497.--Florez, Reynas Cathólicas, tom. ii. +pp. 846, 848.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, tom. v. fol. 127, 128.--La +Clède, Hist. de Portugal, tom. iv. p. 101. + +The physicians recommended a temporary separation of John from his young +bride; a remedy, however, which the queen opposed from conscientious +scruples somewhat singular. "Hortantur medici Reginam, hortatur et Rex, ut +a principis latere Margaritam aliquando semoveat, interpellet. Inducias +precantur. Protestantur periculum ex frequenti copulâ ephebo imminere; +qualiter eum suxerit, quamve subtristis incedat, consideret iterum atque +iterum monent; medullas laedi, stomachum hebetari se sentire Reginae +renunciant. Intercidat, dum licet, obstetque principiis, instant. Nil +proficiunt. Respondet Regina, homines non oportere, quos Deus jugali +vinculo junxerit, separare." Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 176. + +[24] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 182.--L. Marineo, Cosas Memorables, +fol. 182.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1497.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., +dial. de Deza. + +Peter Martyr, in more of a classic than a Christian vein, refers Prince +John's composure in his latter hours to his familiarity with the divine +Aristotle. "Aetatem quae ferebat superabat; nec mirum tamen. Perlegerat +namque divini Aristotelis pleraque volumina," etc. Ubi supra. + +[25] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 183. + +Martyr draws an affecting picture of the anguish of the bereaved parents, +which betrayed itself in looks more eloquent than words. "Reges tantam +dissimulare aerumnam nituntur; ast nos prostratum in internis ipsorum +animum cernimus; oculos alter in faciem alterius crebro conjiciunt, in +propatulo sedentes. Unde quid lateat proditur. Nimirum tamen, desinerent +humanâ carne vestiti esse homines, essentque adamante duriores, nisi quid +amiserint sentirent." + +[26] Blancas, Coronaciones de los Serenissimos Reyes de Aragon, (Zaragoza, +1641,) lib. 3, cap. 18.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. 6.-- +Sackcloth was substituted for the white serge, which till this time had +been used as the mourning dress. + +[27] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 182.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. +lib. 19, cap. 6.--L. Marineo, Cosas Memorables, fol. 182.--Blancas, +Coronaciones, p. 248. + +It must be allowed to furnish no mean proof of the excellence of Prince +John's heart, that it was not corrupted by the liberal doses of flattery +with which his worthy tutor was in the habit of regaling him, from time to +time. Take the beginning of one of Martyr's letters to his pupil, in the +following modest strain. "Mirande in pueritiâ senex, salve. Quotquot tecum +versantur homines, sive genere polleant, sive ad obsequium fortunae +humiliores destinati ministri, te laudant, extollunt, admirantur." Opus +Epist., epist. 98. + +[28] Hopes were entertained of a male heir at the time of John's death, as +his widow was left pregnant; but these were frustrated by her being +delivered of a still-born infant at the end of a few months. Margaret did +not continue long in Spain. She experienced the most affectionate +treatment from the king and queen, who made her an extremely liberal +provision. (Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, tom. v. lib. 3, cap. 4.) But +her Flemish followers could not reconcile themselves to the reserve and +burdensome ceremonial of the Castilian court, so different from the free +and jocund life to which they had been accustomed at home; and they +prevailed on their mistress to return to her native land in the course of +the year 1499. She was subsequently married to the duke of Savoy, who died +without issue in less than three years, and Margaret passed the remainder +of her life in widowhood, being appointed by her father, the emperor, to +the government of the Netherlands, which she administered with ability. +She died in 1530. + +[29] Marina has transcribed from the archives of Toledo the writ of +summons to that city on this occasion. Teoría, tom. ii. p. 16.--Zurita, +Hist. del Rey Hernando, tom. v. lib. 3, cap. 18.--Bernaldez, Reyes +Católicos, MS., cap. 154.--La Clède, Hist. de Portugal, tom. iv. p. 101.-- +Carbajal, Anales. MS., año 1498.--Faria y Sousa, Europa Portuguesa, tom. +ii. pp. 500, 501. + +The last writer expatiates with great satisfaction on the stately +etiquette observed at the reception of the Portuguese monarchs and their +suite by the Spanish sovereigns. "Queen Isabella," he says, "appeared +leaning on the arm of her old favorite Gutierre de Cardenas, comendador of +Leon, and of a Portuguese noble, Don Juan de Sousa. The latter took care +to acquaint her with the rank and condition of each of his countrymen, as +they were presented, in order that she might the better adjust the measure +of condescension and courtesy due to each; a perilous obligation," he +continues, "with all nations, but with the Portuguese most perilous!" + +[30] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 194.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, tom. +ii. fol. 334.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. lib. 27, cap. 3. + +[31] Blancas, Commentarii, p. 273.--Idem, Coronaciones, lib. 1, cap. 18.-- +Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. lib. 27, cap. 3.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey +Hernando, tom. v. fol. 55, 56. + +It is remarkable that the Aragonese should so readily have acquiesced in +the right of females to convey a title to the crown which they could not +enjoy themselves. This was precisely the principle on which Edward III. +set up his claim to the throne of France, a principle too repugnant to the +commonest rules of inheritance to obtain any countenance. The exclusion of +females in Aragon could not pretend to be founded on any express law, as +in France, but the practice, with the exception of a single example three +centuries old, was quite as uniform. + +[32] Blancas, Coronaciones, lib. 3, cap. 18.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey +Hernando, tom. v. lib. 3, cap. 30. + +It is a proof of the high esteem in which Isabella held this independent +statesman, that we find his name mentioned in her testament among half a +dozen others, whom she particularly recommended to her successors for +their meritorious and loyal services. See the document in Dormer, +Discursos Varios, p. 354. + +[33] Carbajal, Anales, MS., años 1470, 1498.--Florez, Reynas Cathólicas, +tom. ii. pp. 846, 847.--Faria y Sousa, Europa Portuguesa, tom. ii. p. 504. + +[34] Blancas, Commentarii, pp. 510, 511.--Idem, Coronaciones, lib. 3, cap. +19.--Gerónimo Martel, Forma de Celebrar Cortes en Aragon, (Zaragoza, +1641,) cap. 44.--Alvaro Gomez, De Rebus Gestis a Francisco Ximenio +Cisnerio, (Compluti, 1569,) fol. 28.--Lanuza, Historias, lib. 1, cap. 9. + +[35] Blancas, Coronaciones, ubi supra.--Idem, Commentarii, pp. 510, 511. + +The reverence of the Aragonese for their institutions is shown in their +observance of the most insignificant ceremonies. A remarkable instance of +this occurred in the year 1481, at Saragossa, when, the queen having been +constituted _lieutenant general_ of the kingdom, and duly qualified +to hold a cortes in the absence of the king her husband, who, by the +ancient laws of the land, was required to preside over it in person, it +was deemed necessary to obtain a formal act of the legislature, for +opening the door for her admission. See Blancas, Modo de Proceder en +Cortes de Aragon, (Zaragoza, 1641,) fol. 82, 83. + +[36] Faria y Sousa, Europa Portuguesa, tom. ii. pp. 504, 507.--Bernaldez, +Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 154.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1499.--Zurita, +Hist. del Rey Hernando, tom. v. lib. 3, cap. 33--Sandoval, Hist. del Emp. +Carlos V., tom. i. p. 4. + + + + +CHAPTER V. + +DEATH OF CARDINAL MENDOZA.--RISE OF XIMENES.--ECCLESIASTICAL REFORM. + +Death of Mendoza.--His Early Life and Character.--The Queen his Executor. +--Origin of Ximenes.--He Enters the Franciscan Order.--His Ascetic Life.-- +Confessor to the Queen.--Made Archbishop of Toledo.--Austerity of his +Life.--Reform of the Monastic Orders.--Insults Offered to the Queen.--She +Consents to the Reform. + + +In the beginning of 1495, the sovereigns lost their old and faithful +minister, the grand cardinal of Spain, Don Pedro Gonzalez de Mendoza. He +was the fourth son of the celebrated marquis of Santillana, and was placed +by his talents at the head of a family, every member of which must be +allowed to have exhibited a rare union of public and private virtue. The +cardinal reached the age of sixty-six, when his days were terminated after +a long and painful illness, on the 11th of January, at his palace of +Guadalaxara. [1] + +In the unhappy feuds between Henry the Fourth and his younger brother +Alfonso, the cardinal had remained faithful to the former. But on the +death of that monarch, he threw his whole weight, with that of his +powerful family, into the scale of Isabella, whether influenced by a +conviction of her superior claims, or her capacity for government. This +was a most important acquisition to the royal cause; and Mendoza's +consummate talents for business, recommended by the most agreeable +address, secured him the confidence of both Ferdinand and Isabella, who +had long been disgusted with the rash and arrogant bearing of their old +minister, Carillo. + +On the death of that turbulent prelate, Mendoza succeeded to the +archiepiscopal see of Toledo. His new situation naturally led to still +more intimate relations with the sovereigns, who uniformly deferred to his +experience, consulting him on all important matters, not merely of a +public, but of a private nature. In short, he gained such ascendency in +the cabinet, during a long ministry of more than twenty years, that he was +pleasantly called by the courtiers the "third king of Spain." [2] + +The minister did not abuse the confidence so generously reposed in him. He +called the attention of his royal mistress to objects most deserving it. +His views were naturally grand and lofty; and, if he sometimes yielded to +the fanatical impulse of the age, he never failed to support her heartily +in every generous enterprise for the advancement of her people. When +raised to the rank of primate of Spain, he indulged his natural +inclination for pomp and magnificence. He filled his palace with pages, +selected from the noblest families in the kingdom, whom he carefully +educated. He maintained a numerous body of armed retainers, which, far +from being a mere empty pageant, formed a most effective corps for public +service on all requisite occasions. He dispensed the immense revenues of +his bishopric with the same munificent hand which has so frequently +distinguished the Spanish prelacy, encouraging learned men, and endowing +public institutions. The most remarkable of these were the college of +Santa Cruz at Valladolid, and the hospital of the same name for foundlings +at Toledo, the erection of which, completed at his sole charge, consumed +more than ten years each. [3] + +The cardinal, in his younger days, was occasionally seduced by those +amorous propensities, in which the Spanish clergy freely indulged, +contaminated, perhaps, by the example of their Mahometan neighbors. He +left several children by his amours with two ladies of rank, from whom +some of the best houses in the kingdom are descended. [4] A characteristic +anecdote is recorded of him in relation to this matter. An ecclesiastic, +who one day delivered a discourse in his presence, took occasion to advert +to the laxity of the age, in general terms, indeed, but bearing too +pertinent an application to the cardinal to be mistaken. The attendants of +the latter boiled with indignation at the preacher's freedom, whom they +determined to chastise for his presumption. They prudently, however, +postponed this until they should see what effect the discourse had on +their master. The cardinal, far from betraying any resentment, took no +other notice of the preacher than to send him a dish of choice game, which +had been served up at his own table, where he was entertaining a party of +friends that day, accompanying it at the same time, by way of sauce, with +a substantial donative of gold doblas; an act of Christian charity not at +all to the taste of his own servants. It wrought its effects on the worthy +divine, who at once saw the error of his ways, and, the next time he +mounted the pulpit, took care to frame his discourse in such a manner as +to counteract the former unfavorable impressions, to the entire +satisfaction, if not edification, of his audience. "Now-a-days," says the +honest biographer who reports the incident, himself a lineal descendant of +the cardinal, "the preacher would not have escaped so easily. And with +good reason; for the holy Gospel should be discreetly preached, 'cum grano +salis,' that is to say, with the decorum and deference due to majesty and +men of high estate." [5] + +When Cardinal Mendoza's illness assumed an alarming aspect, the court +removed to the neighborhood of Guadalaxara, where he was confined. The +king and queen, especially the latter, with the affectionate concern which +she manifested for more than one of her faithful subjects, used to visit +him in person, testifying her sympathy for his sufferings, and benefiting +by the lights of the sagacious mind, which had so long helped to guide +her. She still further showed her regard for her old minister by +condescending to accept the office of his executor, which she punctually +discharged, superintending the disposition of his effects according to his +testament, [6] and particularly the erection of the stately hospital of +Santa Cruz, before mentioned, not a stone of which was laid before his +death. [7] + +In one of her interviews with the dying minister, the queen requested his +advice respecting the nomination of his successor. The cardinal, in reply, +earnestly cautioned her against raising any one of the principal nobility +to this dignity, almost too exalted for any subject, and which, when +combined with powerful family connections, would enable a man of factious +disposition to defy the royal authority itself, as they had once bitter +experience in the case of Archbishop Carillo. On being pressed to name the +individual whom he thought best qualified, in every point of view, for the +office, he is said to have recommended Fray Francisco Ximenez de Cisneros, +a friar of the Franciscan order, and confessor of the queen. As this +extraordinary personage exercised a more important control over the +destinies of his country than any other subject, during the remainder of +the present reign, it will be necessary to put the reader in possession of +his history. [8] + +Ximenez de Cisneros, or Ximenes, as he is usually called, was born at the +little town of Tordelaguna, in the year 1436, [9] of an ancient but +decayed family. [10] He was early destined by his parents for the church, +and, after studying grammar at Alcalá, was removed at fourteen to the +university of Salamanca. Here he went through the regular course of +instruction then pursued, devoting himself assiduously to the civil and +canon law, and at the end of six years received the degree of bachelor in +each of them, a circumstance at that time of rare occurrence. [11] + +Three years after quitting the university, the young bachelor removed by +the advice of his parents to Rome, as affording a better field for +ecclesiastical preferment than he could find at home. Here he seems to +have attracted some notice by the diligence with which he devoted himself +to his professional studies and employments. But still he was far from +reaping the golden fruits presaged by his kindred; and at the expiration +of six years he was suddenly recalled to his native country by the death +of his father, who left his affairs in so embarrassed a condition, as to +require his immediate presence. [12] + +Before his return, Ximenes obtained a papal bull, or _expectative_, +preferring him to the first benefice of a specified value, which should +become vacant in the see of Toledo. Several years elapsed before such a +vacancy offered itself by the death of the archpriest of Uzeda; and +Ximenes took possession of that living by virtue of the apostolic grant. + +This assumption of the papal court to dispose of the church livings at its +own pleasure, had been long regarded by the Spaniards as a flagrant +imposition; and Carillo, the archbishop of Toledo, in whose diocese the +vacancy occurred, was not likely tamely to submit to it. He had, moreover, +promised this very place to one of his own followers. He determined, +accordingly, to compel Ximenes to surrender his pretensions in favor of +the latter, and, finding argument ineffectual, resorted to force, +confining him in the fortress of Uzeda, whence he was subsequently removed +to the strong tower of Santorcaz, then used as a prison for contumacious +ecclesiastics. But Carillo understood little of the temper of Ximenes, +which was too inflexible to be broken by persecution. The archbishop in +time became convinced of this, and was persuaded to release him, but not +till after an imprisonment of more than six years. [13] + +Ximenes, thus restored to freedom, and placed in undisturbed possession of +his benefice, was desirous of withdrawing from the jurisdiction of his +vindictive superior; and not long after effected an exchange for the +chaplainship of Siguenza. In this new situation he devoted himself with +renewed ardor to his theological studies, occupying himself diligently, +moreover, with Hebrew and Chaldee, his knowledge of which proved of no +little use in the concoction of his famous Polyglot. + +Mendoza was at that time bishop of Siguenza. It was impossible that a man +of his penetration should come in contact with a character like that of +Ximenes, without discerning its extraordinary qualities. It was not long +before he appointed him his vicar, with the administration of his diocese; +in which situation he displayed such capacity for business, that the count +of Cifuentes, on falling into the hands of the Moors, after the +unfortunate affair of the Axarquia, confided to him the sole management of +his vast estates during his captivity. [14] + +But these secular concerns grew more and more distasteful to Ximenes, +whose naturally austere and contemplative disposition had been deepened, +probably, by the melancholy incidents of his life, into stern religious +enthusiasm. He determined, therefore, to break at once from the shackles +which bound him to the world, and seek an asylum in some religious +establishment, where he might devote himself unreservedly to the service +of Heaven. He selected for this purpose the Observantines of the +Franciscan order, the most rigid of the monastic societies. He resigned +his various employments and benefices, with annual rents to the amount of +two thousand ducats, and, in defiance of the arguments and entreaties of +his friends, entered on his novitiate in the convent of San Juan de los +Reyes, at Toledo; a superb pile then erecting by the Spanish sovereigns, +in pursuance of a vow made during the war of Granada. [15] + +He distinguished his novitiate by practising every ingenious variety of +mortification with which superstition has contrived to swell the +inevitable catalogue of human sufferings. He slept on the ground, or on +the hard floor, with a billet of wood for his pillow. He wore hair-cloth +next his skin; and exercised himself with fasts, vigils, and stripes, to a +degree scarcely surpassed by the fanatical founder of his order. At the +end of the year, he regularly professed, adopting then for the first time +the name of Francisco, in compliment to his patron saint, instead of that +of Gonzalo, by which he had been baptized. + +No sooner had this taken place, than his reputation for sanctity, which +his late course of life had diffused far and wide, attracted multitudes of +all ages and conditions to his confessional; and he soon found himself +absorbed in the same vortex of worldly passions and interests, from which +he had been so anxious to escape. At his solicitation, therefore, he was +permitted to transfer his abode to the convent of our Lady of Castañar, so +called from a deep forest of chestnuts, in which it was embosomed. In the +midst of these dark mountain solitudes, he built with his own hands a +little hermitage or cabin, of dimensions barely sufficient to admit his +entrance. Here he passed his days and nights in prayer, and in meditations +on the sacred volume, sustaining life, like the ancient anchorites, on the +green herbs and running waters. In this state of self-mortification, with +a frame wasted by abstinence, and a mind exalted by spiritual +contemplation, it is no wonder that he should have indulged in ecstasies +and visions, until he fancied himself raised into communication with +celestial intelligences. It is more wonderful that his understanding was +not permanently impaired by these distempered fancies. This period of his +life, however, seems to have been always regarded by him with peculiar +satisfaction; for long after, as his biographer assures us, when reposing +in lordly palaces, and surrounded by all the appliances of luxury, he +looked back with fond regret on the hours which glided so peacefully in +the hermitage of Castañar. [16] + +Fortunately, his superiors, choosing to change his place of residence +according to custom, transferred him at the end of three years to the +convent of Salzeda. Here he practised, indeed, similar austerities, but it +was not long before his high reputation raised him to the post of guardian +of the convent. This situation necessarily imposed on him the management +of the institution; and thus the powers of his mind, so long wasted in +unprofitable reverie, were again called into exercise for the benefit of +others. An event which occurred some years later, in 1492, opened to him a +still wider sphere of action. + +By the elevation of Talavera to the metropolitan see of Granada, the +office of queen's confessor became vacant. Cardinal Mendoza, who was +consulted on the choice of a successor, well knew the importance of +selecting a man of the highest integrity and talent; since the queen's +tenderness of conscience led her to take counsel of her confessor, not +merely in regard to her own spiritual concerns, but all the great measures +of her administration. He at once fixed his eye on Ximenes, of whom he had +never lost sight, indeed, since his first acquaintance with him at +Siguenza. He was far from approving his adoption of the monastic life, and +had been heard to say, that "parts so extraordinary would not long be +buried in the shades of a convent." He is said, also, to have predicted +that Ximenes would one day succeed him in the chair of Toledo. A +prediction, which its author contributed more than any other to verify. +[17] + +He recommended Ximenes in such emphatic terms to the queen, as raised a +strong desire in her to see and converse with him herself. An invitation +was accordingly sent him from the cardinal to repair to the court at +Valladolid, without intimating the real purpose of it. Ximenes obeyed the +summons, and, after a short interview with his early patron, was +conducted, as if without any previous arrangement, to the queen's +apartment. On finding himself so unexpectedly in the royal presence, he +betrayed none of the agitation or embarrassment to have been expected from +the secluded inmate of a cloister, but exhibited a natural dignity of +manners, with such discretion and fervent piety, in his replies to +Isabella's various interrogatories, as confirmed the favorable +prepossessions she had derived from the cardinal. + +Not many days after, Ximenes was invited to take charge of the queen's +conscience. Far from appearing elated by this mark of royal favor, and the +prospects of advancement which it opened, he seemed to view it with +disquietude, as likely to interrupt the peaceful tenor of his religious +duties; and he accepted it only with the understanding, that he should be +allowed to conform in every respect to the obligations of his order, and +to remain in his own monastery when his official functions did not require +attendance at court. [18] + +Martyr, in more than one of his letters dated at this time, notices the +impression made on the courtiers by the remarkable appearance of the new +confessor, in whose wasted frame, and pallid, care-worn countenance, they +seemed to behold one of the primitive anchorites from the deserts of Syria +or Egypt. [19] The austerities and the blameless purity of Ximenes's life +had given him a reputation for sanctity throughout Spain; [20] and Martyr +indulges the regret, that a virtue, which had stood so many trials, should +be exposed to the worst of all, in the seductive blandishments of a court. +But Ximenes's heart had been steeled by too stern a discipline to be moved +by the fascinations of pleasure, however it might be by those of ambition. + +Two years after this event, he was elected provincial of his order in +Castile, which placed him at the head of its numerous religious +establishments. In his frequent journeys for their inspection he travelled +on foot, supporting himself by begging alms, conformably to the rules of +his order. On his return he made a very unfavorable report to the queen of +the condition of the various institutions, most of which he represented to +have grievously relaxed in discipline and virtue. Contemporary accounts +corroborate this unfavorable picture, and accuse the religious communities +of both sexes throughout Spain, at this period, of wasting their hours, +not merely in unprofitable sloth, but in luxury and licentiousness. The +Franciscans, in particular, had so far swerved from the obligations of +their institute, which interdicted the possession of property of any +description, that they owned large estates in town and country, living in +stately edifices, and in a style of prodigal expense not surpassed by any +of the monastic orders. Those who indulged in this latitude were called +_conventuals_, while the comparatively small number who put the strictest +construction on the rule of their founder were denominated +_observantines_, or brethren of the observance. Ximenes, it will be +remembered, was one of the latter. [21] + +The Spanish sovereigns had long witnessed with deep regret the scandalous +abuses which had crept into these ancient institutions, and had employed +commissioners for investigating and reforming them, but ineffectually. +Isabella now gladly availed herself of the assistance of her confessor in +bringing them into a better state of discipline. In the course of the same +year, 1494, she obtained a bull with full authority for this purpose from +Alexander the Sixth, the execution of which she intrusted to Ximenes. The +work of reform required all the energies of his powerful mind, backed by +the royal authority. For, in addition to the obvious difficulty of +persuading men to resign the good things of this world for a life of +penance and mortification, there were other impediments, arising from the +circumstance that the conventuals had been countenanced in their lax +interpretation of the rules of their order by many of their own superiors, +and even the popes themselves. They were besides sustained in their +opposition by many of the great lords, who were apprehensive that the rich +chapels and masses, which they or their ancestors had founded in the +various monasteries, would be neglected by the observantines, whose +scrupulous adherence to the vow of poverty excluded them from what, in +church as well as state, is too often found the most cogent incentive to +the performance of duty. [22] + +From these various causes, the work of reform went on slowly; but the +untiring exertions of Ximenes gradually effected its adoption in many +establishments; and, where fair means could not prevail, he sometimes +resorted to force. The monks of one of the convents in Toledo, being +ejected from their dwelling, in consequence of their pertinacious +resistance, marched out in solemn procession, with the crucifix before +them, chanting, at the same time, the psalm _De exitu Israel_, in +token of their persecution. Isabella resorted to milder methods. She +visited many of the nunneries in person, taking her needle or distaff with +her, and endeavoring by her conversation and example to withdraw their +inmates from the low and frivolous pleasures to which they were addicted. +[23] + +While the reformation was thus silently going forward, the vacancy in the +archbishopric of Toledo already noticed occurred by the death of the grand +cardinal. Isabella deeply felt the responsibility of providing a suitable +person to this dignity, the most considerable not merely in Spain, but +probably in Christendom, after the papacy; and which, moreover, raised its +possessor to eminent political rank, as high chancellor of Castile. [24] +The right of nomination to benefices was vested in the queen by the +original settlement of the crown. She had uniformly discharged this trust +with the most conscientious impartiality, conferring the honors of the +church on none but persons of approved piety and learning. [25] In the +present instance, she was strongly solicited by Ferdinand, in favor of his +natural son Alfonso, archbishop of Saragossa. But this prelate, although +not devoid of talent, had neither the age nor experience, and still less +the exemplary morals, demanded for this important station; and the queen +mildly, but unhesitatingly, resisted all entreaty and expostulation of her +husband on his behalf. [26] + +The post had always been filled by men of high family. The queen, loath to +depart from this usage, notwithstanding the dying admonition of Mendoza, +turned her eyes on various candidates before she determined in favor of +her own confessor, whose character presented so rare a combination of +talent and virtue, as amply compensated any deficiency of birth. + +As soon as the papal bull reached Castile, confirming the royal +nomination, Isabella summoned Ximenes to her presence, and, delivering to +him the parcel, requested him to open it before her. The confessor, who +had no suspicion of their real purport, took the letters and devoutly +pressed them to his lips; when his eye falling on the superscription, "To +our venerable brother Francisco Ximenez de Cisneros, archbishop elect of +Toledo," he changed color, and involuntarily dropped the packet from his +hands, exclaiming, "There is some mistake in this; it cannot be intended +for me;" and abruptly quitted the apartment. + +The queen, far from taking umbrage at this unceremonious proceeding, +waited a while, until the first emotions of surprise should have subsided. +Finding that he did not return, however, she despatched two of the +grandees, who she thought would have the most influence with him, to seek +him out and persuade him to accept the office. The nobles instantly +repaired to his convent in Madrid, in which city the queen then kept her +court. They found, however, that he had already left the place. Having +ascertained his route, they mounted their horses, and, following as fast +as possible, succeeded in overtaking him at three leagues' distance from +the city, as he was travelling on foot at a rapid rate, though in the +noontide heat, on his way to the Franciscan monastery at Ocana. + +After a brief expostulation with Ximenes on his abrupt departure, they +prevailed on him to retrace his steps to Madrid; but, upon his arrival +there, neither the arguments nor entreaties of his friends, backed as they +were by the avowed wishes of his sovereign, could overcome his scruples, +or induce him to accept an office, of which he professed himself unworthy. +"He had hoped," he said, "to pass the remainder of his days in the quiet +practice of his monastic duties; and it was too late now to call him into +public life, and impose a charge of such heavy responsibility on him, for +which he had neither capacity nor inclination." In this resolution he +pertinaciously persisted for more than six months, until a second bull was +obtained from the pope, commanding him no longer to decline an appointment +which the church had seen fit to sanction. This left no further room for +opposition, and Ximenes acquiesced, though with evident reluctance, in his +advancement to the first dignity in the kingdom. [27] + +There seems to be no good ground for charging Ximenes with hypocrisy in +this singular display of humility. The _nolo episcopal_, indeed, has +passed into a proverb; but his refusal was too long and sturdily +maintained to be reconciled with affectation or insincerity. He was, +moreover, at this time, in the sixtieth year of his age, when ambition, +though not extinguished, is usually chilled in the human heart. His habits +had been long accommodated to the ascetic duties of the cloister, and his +thoughts turned from the business of this world to that beyond the grave. +However gratifying the distinguished honor conferred on him might be to +his personal feelings, he might naturally hesitate to exchange the calm, +sequestered way of life, to which he had voluntarily devoted himself, for +the turmoil and vexations of the world. + +But, although Ximenes showed no craving for power, it must be confessed he +was by no means diffident in the use of it. One of the very first acts of +his administration is too characteristic to be omitted. The government of +Cazorla, the most considerable place in the gift of the archbishop of +Toledo, had been intrusted by the grand cardinal to his younger brother +Don Pedro Hurtado de Mendoza. The friends of this nobleman applied to +Ximenes to confirm the appointment, reminding him at the same time of his +own obligations to the cardinal, and enforcing their petition by the +recommendation which they had obtained from the queen. This was not the +way to approach Ximenes, who was jealous of any improper influence over +his own judgment, and, above all, of the too easy abuse of the royal +favor. He was determined, in the outset, effectually to discourage all +such applications; and he declared, that "the sovereigns might send him +back to the cloister again, but that no personal considerations should +ever operate with him in distributing the honors of the church." The +applicants, nettled at this response, returned to the queen, complaining +in the bitterest terms of the arrogance and ingratitude of the new +primate. Isabella, however, evinced no symptoms of disapprobation, not +altogether displeased, perhaps, with the honest independence of her +minister; at any rate, she took no further notice of the affair. [28] + +Some time after, the archbishop encountered Mendoza in one of the avenues +of the palace, and, as the latter was turning off to avoid the meeting, he +saluted him with the title of adelantado of Cazorla. Mendoza stared with +astonishment at the prelate, who repeated the salutation, assuring him, +"that, now he was at full liberty to consult his own judgment, without the +suspicion of any sinister influence, he was happy to restore him to a +station, for which he had shown himself well qualified." It is scarcely +necessary to say, that Ximenes was not importuned after this with +solicitations for office. Indeed, all personal application he affected to +regard as of itself sufficient ground for a denial, since it indicated +"the want either of merit or of humility in the applicant." [29] + +After his elevation to the primacy, he retained the same simple and +austere manners as before, dispensing his large revenues in public and +private charities, but regulating his domestic expenditure with the +severest economy, [30] until he was admonished by the Holy See to adopt a +state more consonant with the dignity of his office, if he would not +disparage it in popular estimation. In obedience to this, he so far +changed his habits, as to display the usual magnificence of his +predecessors, in all that met the public eye,--his general style of +living, equipage, and the number and pomp of his retainers; but he relaxed +nothing of his own personal mortifications. He maintained the same +abstemious diet, amidst all the luxuries of his table. Under his robes of +silk or costly furs he wore the coarse frock of St. Francis, which he used +to mend with his own hands. He used no linen about his person or bed; and +he slept on a miserable pallet like that used by the monks of his +fraternity, and so contrived as to be concealed from observation under the +luxurious couch in which he affected to repose. [31] + +As soon as Ximenes entered on the duties of his office, he bent all the +energies of his mind to the consummation of the schemes of reform which +his royal mistress, as well as himself, had so much at heart. His +attention was particularly directed to the clergy of his diocese, who had +widely departed from the rule of St. Augustine, by which they were bound. +His attempts at reform, however, excited such a lively dissatisfaction in +this reverend body, that they determined to send one of their own number +to Rome, to prefer their complaints against the archbishop at the papal +court. [32] + +The person selected for this delicate mission was a shrewd and intelligent +canon by the name of Albornoz. It could not be conducted so privately as +to escape the knowledge of Ximenes. He was no sooner acquainted with it, +than he despatched an officer to the coast, with orders to arrest the +emissary. In case he had already embarked, the officer was authorized to +fit out a fast sailing vessel, so as to reach Italy, if possible, before +him. He was at the same time fortified with despatches from the sovereigns +to the Spanish minister, Garcilasso de la Vega, to be delivered +immediately on his arrival. + +The affair turned out as had been foreseen. On arriving at the port, the +officer found the bird had flown. He followed, however, without delay, and +had the good fortune to reach Ostia several days before him. He forwarded +his instructions at once to the Spanish minister, who in pursuance of them +caused Albornoz to be arrested the moment he set foot on shore, and sent +him back as a prisoner of state to Spain; where a close confinement for +two and twenty mouths admonished the worthy canon of the inexpediency of +thwarting the plans of Ximenes. [33] + +His attempts at innovation among the regular clergy of his own order were +encountered with more serious opposition. The reform fell most heavily on +the Franciscans, who were interdicted by their rules from holding +property, whether as a community, or as individuals; while the members of +other fraternities found some compensation for the surrender of their +private fortunes, in the consequent augmentation of those of their +fraternity. There was no one of the religious orders, therefore, in which +the archbishop experienced such a dogged resistance to his plans, as in +his own. More than a thousand friars, according to some accounts, quitted +the country and passed over to Barbary, preferring rather to live with the +infidel, than conform to the strict letter of their founder's rules. [34] + +One account represents the migration as being to Italy and other Christian +countries, where the conventual order was protected; which would seem the +most probable, though not the best authenticated, statement of the two. + +The difficulties of the reform were perhaps augmented by the mode in which +it was conducted. Isabella, indeed, used all gentleness and persuasion; +[35] but Ximenes carried measures with a high and inexorable hand. He was +naturally of an austere and arbitrary temper, and the severe training +which he had undergone made him less charitable for the lapses of others; +especially of those, who, like himself, had voluntarily incurred the +obligations of monastic rule. He was conscious of the rectitude of his +intentions; and, as he identified his own interests with those of the +church, he regarded all opposition to himself as an offence against +religion, warranting the most peremptory exertion of power. + +The clamor raised against his proceedings became at length so alarming, +that the general of the Franciscans, who resided at Rome, determined to +anticipate the regular period of his visit to Castile for inspecting the +affairs of the order. As he was himself a conventual, his prejudices were +of course all enlisted against the measures of reform; and he came over +fully resolved to compel Ximenes to abandon it altogether, or to +undermine, if possible, his credit and influence at court. But this +functionary had neither the talent nor temper requisite for so arduous an +undertaking. + +He had not been long in Castile before he was convinced that all his own +power, as head of the order, would be incompetent to protect it against +the bold innovations of his provincial, while supported by royal +authority. He demanded, therefore, an audience of the queen, in which he +declared his sentiments with very little reserve. He expressed his +astonishment that she should have selected an individual for the highest +dignity in the church, who was destitute of nearly every qualification, +even that of birth; whose sanctity was a mere cloak to cover his ambition; +whose morose and melancholy temper made him an enemy not only of the +elegances, but the common courtesies of life; and whose rude manners were +not compensated by any tincture of liberal learning. He deplored the +magnitude of the evil, which his intemperate measures had brought on the +church, but which it was, perhaps, not yet too late to rectify; and he +concluded by admonishing her, that, if she valued her own fame, or the +interests of her soul, she would compel this man of yesterday to abdicate +the office, for which he had proved himself so incompetent, and return to +his original obscurity! + +The queen, who listened to this violent harangue with an indignation, that +prompted her more than once to order the speaker from her presence, put a +restraint on her feelings, and patiently waited to the end. When he had +finished, she calmly asked him, "If he was in his senses, and knew whom he +was thus addressing?" "Yes," replied the enraged friar, "I am in my +senses, and know very well whom I am speaking to;--the queen of Castile, a +mere handful of dust, like myself!" With these words, he rushed out of the +apartment, shutting the door after him with furious violence. [36] + +Such impotent bursts of passion could, of course, have no power to turn +the queen from her purpose. The general, however, on his return to Italy, +had sufficient address to obtain authority from His Holiness to send a +commission of conventuals to Castile, who should be associated with +Ximenes in the management of the reform. These individuals soon found +themselves mere ciphers; and, highly offended at the little account which +the archbishop made of their authority, they preferred such complaints of +his proceedings to the pontifical court, that Alexander the Sixth was +induced, with the advice of the college of cardinals, to issue a brief, +November 9th, 1496, peremptorily inhibiting the sovereigns from proceeding +further in the affair, until it had been regularly submitted for +examination to the head of the church. [37] + +Isabella, on receiving this unwelcome mandate, instantly sent it to +Ximenes. The spirit of the latter, however, rose in proportion to the +obstacles it had to encounter. He sought only to rally the queen's +courage, beseeching her not to faint in the good work, now that it was so +far advanced, and assuring her that it was already attended with such +beneficent fruits, as could not fail to secure the protection of Heaven. +Isabella, every act of whose administration may be said to have had +reference, more or less remote, to the interests of religion, was as +little likely as himself to falter in a matter which proposed these +interests as its direct and only object. She assured her minister that she +would support him in all that was practicable; and she lost no time in +presenting the affair, through her agents, in such a light to the court of +Rome, as might work a more favorable disposition in it. In this she +succeeded, though not till after multiplied delays and embarrassments; and +such ample powers were conceded to Ximenes, in conjunction with the +apostolic nuncio, as enabled him to consummate his grand scheme of reform, +in defiance of all the efforts of his enemies. [38] + +The reformation thus introduced extended to the religious institutions of +very order equally with his own. It was most searching in its operation, +reaching eventually to the moral conduct of the subjects of it, no less +than the mere points of monastic discipline. As regards the latter; it may +be thought of doubtful benefit to have enforced the rigid interpretation +of a rule, founded on the melancholy principle, that the amount of +happiness in the next world is to be regulated by that of self-inflicted +suffering in this. But it should be remembered, that, however +objectionable such a rule may be in itself, yet, where it is voluntarily +assumed as an imperative moral obligation, it cannot be disregarded +without throwing down the barrier to unbounded license; and that the +reassertion of it, under these circumstances, must be a necessary +preliminary to any effectual reform of morals. + +The beneficial changes wrought in this latter particular, which Isabella +had far more at heart than any exterior forms of discipline, are the theme +of unqualified panegyric with her contemporaries. [39] The Spanish clergy, +as I have before had occasion to remark, were early noted for their +dissolute way of life, which, to a certain extent, seemed to be +countenanced by the law itself. [40] This laxity of morals was carried to +a most lamentable extent under the last reign, when all orders of +ecclesiastics, whether regular or secular, infected probably by the +corrupt example of the court, are represented (we may hope it is an +exaggeration) as wallowing in all the excesses of sloth and sensuality. So +deplorable a pollution of the very sanctuaries of religion could not fail +to occasion sincere regret to a pure and virtuous mind like Isabella's. +The stain had sunk too deep, however, to be readily purged away. Her +personal example, indeed, and the scrupulous integrity with which she +reserved all ecclesiastical preferment for persons of unblemished piety, +contributed greatly to bring about an amelioration in the morals of the +secular clergy. But the secluded inmates of the cloister were less open to +these influences; and the work of reform could only be accomplished there, +by bringing them back to a reverence for their own institutions, and by +the slow operation of public opinion. + +Notwithstanding the queen's most earnest wishes, it may be doubted whether +this would have ever been achieved without the co-operation of a man like +Ximenes, whose character combined in itself all the essential elements of +a reformer. Happily, Isabella was permitted to see before her death, if +not the completion, at least the commencement, of a decided amendment in +the morals of the religious orders; an amendment, which, so far from being +transitory in its character calls forth the most emphatic eulogium from a +Castilian writer far in the following century; who, while he laments their +ancient laxity, boldly challenges comparison for the religious communities +of his own country, with those of any other, in temperance, chastity, and +exemplary purity of life and conversation. [41] + + * * * * * + +The authority on whom the life of Cardinal Ximenes mainly rests, is Alvaro +Gomez de Castro. He was born in the village of St. Eulalia, near Toledo, +in 1515, and received his education at Alcalá, where he obtained great +repute for his critical acquaintance with the ancient classics. He was +afterwards made professor of the humanities in the university; a situation +which he filled with credit, but subsequently exchanged for the rhetorical +chair in a school recently founded at Toledo. While thus occupied, he was +chosen by the university of Alcalá to pay the most distinguished honor, +which could be rendered to the memory of its illustrious founder, by a +faithful record of his extraordinary life. The most authentic sources of +information were thrown open to him. He obtained an intimate acquaintance +with the private life of the cardinal, from three of his principal +domestics, who furnished abundance of reminiscences from personal +observation, while the archives of the university supplied a mass of +documents relating to the public services of its patron. From these and +similar materials, Gomez prepared his biography, after many years of +patient labor. The work fully answered public expectation; and its merits +are such as to lead the learned Nic. Antonio to express a doubt, whether +anything more excellent or perfect in its way could be achieved; "quo +opere in eo genere an praestantius quidquam aut perfectius, esse possit, +non immerito saepe dubitavi." (Bibliotheca Nova, tom. i. p. 59.) The +encomium may be thought somewhat excessive; but it cannot be denied, that +the narrative is written in an easy and natural manner, with fidelity and +accuracy, with commendable liberality of opinion, though with a judgment +sometimes warped into an undue estimate of the qualities of his hero. It +is distinguished, moreover, by such beauty and correctness of Latinity, as +have made it a text-book in many of the schools and colleges of the +Peninsula. The first edition, being that used in the present work, was +published at Alcalá, in 1569. It has since been reprinted twice in +Germany, and perhaps elsewhere. Gomez was busily occupied with other +literary lucubrations during the remainder of his life, and published +several works in Latin prose and verse, both of which he wrote with ease +and elegance. He died of a catarrh, in 1580, in the sixty-sixth year of +his age, leaving behind him a reputation for disinterestedness and virtue, +which is sufficiently commemorated in two lines of his epitaph; + + "Nemini unquam sciens nocui, + Prodesse quam pluribus curavi." + +The work of Gomez has furnished the basis for all those biographies of +Ximenes which have since appeared in Spain. The most important of these, +probably, is Quintanilla's; which, with little merit of selection or +arrangement, presents a copious mass of details, drawn from every quarter +whence his patient industry could glean them. Its author was a Franciscan, +and employed in procuring the beatification of Cardinal Ximenes by the +court of Rome; a circumstance which probably disposed him to easier faith +in the _marvellous_ of his story, than most of his readers will be ready +to give. The work was published at Palermo in 1653. + +In addition to these authorities I have availed myself of a curious old +manuscript, presented to me by Mr. O. Rich, entitled "Suma de la Vida del +R. S. Cardenal Don Fr. Francisco Ximenez de Cisneros." It was written +within half a century after the cardinal's death, by "un criado de la casa +de Coruña." The original, in "very ancient letter," was extant in the +archives of that noble house in Quintanilla's time, and is often cited by +him. (Archetypo, apend., p. 77.) Its author evidently had access to those +contemporary notices, some of which furnished the basis of Castro's +narrative, from which, indeed, it exhibits no material discrepancy. + +The extraordinary character of Ximenes has naturally attracted the +attention of foreign writers, and especially the French, who have produced +repeated biographies of him. The most eminent of these is by Fléchier, the +eloquent bishop of Nismes. It is written with the simple elegance and +perspicuity, which characterize his other compositions; and in the general +tone of its sentiments, on all matters both of church and state, is quite +as orthodox as the most bigoted admirer of the cardinal could desire. +Another life, by Marsollier, has obtained a very undeserved repute. The +author, not content with the extraordinary qualities really appertaining +to his hero, makes him out a sort of universal genius, quite ridiculous, +rivalling Molière's Dr. Pancrace himself. One may form some idea of the +historian's accuracy from the fact, that he refers the commencement and +conduct of the war of Granada chiefly to the counsels of Ximenes, who, as +we have seen, was not even introduced at court till after the close of the +war. Marsollier reckoned largely on the ignorance and _gullibility_ +of his readers. The event proved he was not mistaken. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1495.--Salazar de Mendoza, Crón. del Gran +Cardenal, lib. 2, cap. 45, 46.--Zurita, Anales, tom. v. fol. 61.--Pulgar, +Claros Varones, tit. 4. + +His disorder was an abscess on the kidneys, which confined him to the +house nearly a year before his death. When this event happened, a white +cross of extraordinary magnitude and splendor, shaped precisely like that +on his arms, was seen in the heavens directly over his house, by a crowd +of spectators, for more than two hours; a full account of which was duly +transmitted to Rome by the Spanish court, and has obtained easy credit +with the principal Spanish historians. + +[2] Alvaro Gomez says of him, "Nam praeter clarissimum tum natalium, tum +fortunae, tum dignitatis splendorem, quae in ilio ornamenta summa erant, +incredibilem animi sublimitatem cum pari morum facilitate, elegantiâque +conjunxerat; ut merito locum in republicâ summo proximum ad supremum usque +diem tenuerit." (De Rebus Gestis, fol. 9.) Martyr, noticing the cardinal's +death, bestows the following brief but comprehensive panegyric on him. +"Periit Gonsalus Mendotiae, domûs splendor et lucida fax; periit quem +universa colebat Hispania, quem exteri etiam principes venerabantur, quem +ordo cardineus collegam sibi esse gloriabatur." Opus Epist., epist. 158. + +[3] Salazar de Mendoza, Crón. del Gran Cardenal, pp. 263-273, 381-410. + +[4] "Gran varon, y muy experimentado y prudente en negocios," says Oviedo +of the cardinal, "_pero a vueltas de las negociaciones desta vida_, +tuvo trés hijos varones," etc. Then follows a full notice of this +graceless progeny. Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, dial. 8. + +[5] Salazar de Mendoza, Crón. del Gran Cardenal, lib. 2, cap. 66. + +The doctor Pedro Salazar de Mendoza's biography of his illustrious +relative is a very fair specimen of the Spanish style of book-making in +ancient times. One event seems to suggest another with about as much +cohesion as the rhymes of "The House that Jack built." There is scarcely a +place or personage of note, that the grand cardinal was brought in contact +with in the course of his life, whose history is not made the theme of +profuse dissertation. Nearly fifty chapters are taken up, for example, +with the distinguished men, who graduated at the college of Santa Cruz. + +[6] "Non hoc," says Tacitus with truth, "praecipuum amicorum munus est, +prosequi defunctum ignavo questu; sed quae voluerit meminisse, quae +mandaverit exsequi." Annales, lib. 2, sect. 71. + +[7] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 143.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año +1494.--Salazar de Mendoza, Crón. del Gran Cardenal, lib. 2, cap. 45. + +A foundling hospital does not seem to have come amiss in Spain, where, +according to Salazar, the wretched parents frequently destroyed their +offspring by casting them into wells and pits, or exposing them in desert +places to die of famine. "_The more compassionate_," he observes, "laid +them at the doors of churches, where they were too often worried to +death by dogs and other animals." The grand cardinal's nephew, who founded +a similar institution, is said to have furnished an asylum in the course +of his life to no less than 13,000 of these little victims! Ibid., cap. +61. + +[8] Salazar de Mendoza, Crón, del Gran Cardenal, lib. 2, cap. 46.--Gomez, +De Rebus Gestis, fol. 8. + +The dying cardinal is said to have recommended, among other things, that +the queen should repair any wrong done to Joanna Beltraneja, by marrying +her with the young prince of the Asturias; which suggestion was so little +to Isabella's taste that she broke off the conversation, saying, "the good +man wandered and talked nonsense." + +[9] It is singular, that Fiddlier should have blundered some twenty years +in the date of Ximenes's birth, which he makes 1457. (Hist. de Ximenés, +liv. 1, p. 3.) It is not singular, that Marsollier should. Histoire du +Ministère du Cardinal Ximenez, (Toulouse, 1694,) liv. 1, p. 3. + +[10] The honorable extraction of Ximenes is intimated in Juan Vergara's +verses at the end of the Complutensian Polyglot: + + "Nomine Cisnerius clarâ de stirpe parentum, + Et meritis factus clarior ipse suis." + +Fray Pedro de Quintanilla y Mendoza makes a goodly genealogical tree for +his hero, of which King Pelayo, King Pepin, Charlemagne, and other royal +worthies are the respectable roots. (Proemia Dedicatoria, pp. 5-35.) +According to Gonzalo de Oviedo, his father was a poor hidalgo, who, having +spent his little substance on the education of his children, was obliged +to take up the profession of an advocate. Quincuagenas, MS. + +[11] Quintanilla, Archetypo, p. 6.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, Ximen., fol. +2.--Idem, Miscellanear., MS., ex Bibliothecâ, Regiâ Matritensi, tom. ii. +fol. 189. + +[12] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 2.--Idem, Miscellanear., MS., ubi +supra.--Eugenio de Robles, Compendio de la Vida y Hazañas del Cardenal Don +Fray Francisco Ximenez de Cisneros, (Toledo, 1604,) cap. 11. + +[13] Quintanilla, Archetype, pp. 8, 10.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 2.-- +Fléchier, Hist. de Ximenés, pp. 8-10.--Suma de la Vida del R. S. Cardenal +Don Fr. Francisco Ximenez de Cisneros, sacada de los Memoriales de Juan de +Vallejo, Paje de CEamara, è de algunas Personas que en su Tiempo lo +vieron: para la Ilustrisima Señora Doña Catalina de la Zerda, Condesa de +Coruña, a quien Dios guarde, y de su Gracia, por un Criado de su Casa, MS. + +[14] Suma de la Vida de Cisneros, MS.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 3.-- +Robles, Vida de Ximenez, cap. 11.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., dial, de +Ximeni. + +[15] Quintanilla, Archetypo, p. ll.--Gomez, Miscellanear., MS., ubi +supra.--Idem, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 4. + +This edifice, says Salazar de Mendoza, in respect to its sacristy, choir, +cloisters, library, etc., was the most sumptuous and noted of its time. It +was originally destined by the Catholic sovereigns for their place of +sepulture; an honor afterwards reserved for Granada, on its recovery from +the infidels. The great chapel was garnished with the fetters taken from +the dungeons of Malaga, in which the Moors confined their Christian +captives. Monarquía, tom. i. p. 410. + +[16] Fléchier, Hist. de Ximenés, p. 14.--Quintanilla, Archetype, pp. 13, +14.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 4.--Suma de la Vida de Cisneros, MS.-- +Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS. + +[17] Salazar de Mendoza, Crón. del Gran Cardenal, lib. 2, cap. 63.--Gomez, +De Rebus Gestis, fol. 4.--Suma de la Vida de Cisneros, MS.--Robles, Vida +de Ximenez, cap. 12. + +[18] Fléchier, Hist. de Ximenés, pp. 18, 19.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., +epist. 108.--Robles, Vida de Ximenez, ubi supra.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, +MS. + +[19] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 108. + +"Praeterea," says Martyr, in a letter to Don Fernando Alvarez, one of the +royal secretaries, "nonne tu sanotissimum quendam virum à, solitudine +abstrusisque silvis, macie ob abstinentiam confectum, relicti Granatensis +loco fuisse suffactum, scriptitasti? In istius facie obdnctâ, nonne +Hilarionis te imaginem aut primi Pauli vultum conspexisse fateris?" Opus +Epist., epist. 105. + +[20] "Todos hablaban," says Oviedo, "de la sanctimonia é vida de este +religioso." The same writer says, that he saw him at Medina del Campo, in +1494, in a solemn procession, on the day of Corpus Christi, his body much +emaciated, and walking barefooted in his coarse friar's dress. In the same +procession was the magnificent cardinal of Spain, little dreaming how soon +his proud honors were to descend on the head of his more humble companion. +Quincuagenas, MS. + +[21] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 201.--Suma de la Vida de +Cisneros, MS.--Mosheim, Ecclesiastical History, vol. iii. cent. 14, p. 2. +--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 163.--L. Marineo, Cosas Memorables, +fol. 165.--Oviedo, Epilogo Real, Imperial y Pontifical, MS., apud Mem. de +la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 8.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, +lib. 3, cap. 15. + +[22] Fléchier, Hist. de Ximenés, pp. 25, 26.--Quintanilla, Archetypo, pp. +21, 22.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 6, 7.--Robles, Vida de Ximenez, cap. +12. + +[23] Fléchier, Hist. de Ximenes, p. 25.--Quintanilla, Archetypo, lib. 1, +cap. ll.--Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 8--Robles, Vida de +Ximenez, ubi supra. + +[24] Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 2, dial. 1.--Ferdinand and +Isabella annexed the dignity of high chancellor in perpetuity to that of +archbishop of Toledo. It seems, however, at least in later times, to have +been a mere honorary title. (Mendoza, Dignidades, lib. 2, cap. 8.) The +revenues of the archbishopric at the beginning of the sixteenth century +amounted to 80,000 ducats, (Navagiero, Viaggio, fol. 9.--L. Marineo, Cosas +Memorables, fol. 23,) equivalent to about 702,200 dollars at the present +day. See Introd., Sect. I. Note 63, of this History. + +[25] "De mas desto," says Lucio Marineo, "tenia por costumbre que quando +avia de dar alguna dignidad, o obispado, mas mirava en virtud, honestidad, +y sciencia de las personas, que las riquezas, y generosidad, aun que +fuessen sus deudos. Lo qual fue causa que muchos de los que hablavan poco, +y tenian los cabellos mas cortos que las cejas; comenparon a traer los +ojos baxos mirando la tierra, y andar con mas gravedad, y hazer mejor +vida, zimulando por venture algunos mas la virtud, que exercitando la." +(Cosas Memorables, fol. 182.) "L'hypocrisie est l'hommage que le vice rend +à la vertu." The maxim is now somewhat stale, like most others of its +profound author. + +[26] Quintanilla, Archetype, lib. 1, cap. 16.--Salazar de Mendoza, Crón. +del Gran Cardenal, lib. 2, cap. 65. This prelate was at this time only +twenty-four years of age. He had been raised to the see of Saragossa when +only six. This strange abuse of preferring infants to the highest +dignities of the church seems to have prevailed in Castile as well as +Aragon; for the tombs of five archdeacons might be seen in the church of +Madre de Dios at Toledo, in Salazar's time, whose united ages amounted +only to thirty years. See Crón. del Gran Cardenal, ubi supra. + +[27] Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. 4.--Mariana, Hist. de +España, tom. ii. lib. 26, cap. 7.--Suma de la Vida de Cisneros, MS.-- +Quintanilla, Archetype, lib. 1, cap. 16.--Gomez, De rebus Gestis, fol. +11.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1495.--Robles, Vida de Ximenez, cap. 13.-- +Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS. + +[28] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 11. + +[29] Ibid., ubi supra.--Robles, Vida de Ximenez, cap. 13, 14. + +[30] "He kept five or six friars of his order," says Gonzalo de Oviedo, +"in his palace with him, and as many asses in his stables; but the latter +all grew sleek and fat, for the archbishop would not ride himself, nor +allow his brethren to ride either." Quincuagenas, MS. + +[31] Suma de la Vida de Cisneros, MS.--Quintanilla, Archetype, lib. 2, +cap. 8, 9.--Gomez, de Rebus Gestis, fol. 12.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS.-- +Robles, Vida de Ximenez, cap. 13. + +[32] Gomez de Rebus Gestis, fol. 16. The Venetian minister Navagiero, +noticing the condition of the canons of Toledo, some few years later, +celebrates them, as "lording it above all others in their own city, being +especial favorites with the ladies, dwelling in stately mansions, passing, +in short, the most agreeable lives in the world, without any one to +trouble them." Viaggio, fol. 9. + +[33] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 17. + +[34] Quintanilla, Archetype, pp. 22, 23.--Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. +vi. p. 201.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 3, cap. 15. + +[35] "Trataba las monjas," say Riol, "con un agrado y amor tan cariñoso, +que las robaba los corazones, y hecha dueña de ellas, las persuadia non +suavidad y eficacia á que votasen clausura. Y es cosa admirable, que raro +fue el conventu donde entró esta celebre heroina, donde no lograse en el +propio dia el efecto de su santo deseo." Informe, apud Semanario Erudito, +tom. iii. p. 110. + +[36] Fléchier, Hist. de Ximenes, pp. 56, 58.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. +14.--Zurita, Hist. del Rey Hernando, lib. 3, cap. 15.--Robles, Vida de +Ximenez, cap. 13. + +[37] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 23.--Quintanilla, Archetypo, lib. 1, +cap. 11. + +[38] Quintanilla, Archetypo, lib. 1, cap. 13-14.--Riol discusses the +various monastic reforms effected by Ximenes, in his Memorial to Philip +V., apud Semanario Erudito, tom. iii. pp. 102-110. + +[39] L. Marineo, Cosas Memorables, fol. 165.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, +MS., cap. 201.--et al. + +[40] The practice of concubinage by the clergy was fully recognized, and +the ancient _fueros_ of Castile permitted their issue to inherit the +estates of such parents as died intestate. (See Marina, Ensayo Histórico- +Crítico sobre la Antigua Legislacion de Castilla, (Madrid, 1808,) p. 154.) +The effrontery of these legalized strumpets, _barraganas_, as they +were called, was at length so intolerable as to call for repeated laws, +regulating their apparel, and prescribing a badge for distinguishing them +from honest women. (Sempere, Hist. del Luxo, tom. i. pp. 165-169.) Spain +is probably the only country in Christendom, where concubinage was ever +sanctioned by law; a circumstance doubtless imputable, in some measure, to +the influence of the Mahometans. + +[41] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 23. + + + + +CHAPTER VI. + +XIMENES IN GRANADA--PERSECUTION, INSURRECTION, AND CONVERSION OF THE +MOORS. + +1499-1500. + +Tranquil State of Granada.--Mild Policy of Talavera.--Clergy Dissatisfied +with it.--Violent Measures of Ximenes.--His Fanaticism.--Its Mischievous +Effects.--Insurrection in Granada.--Tranquillity Restored.--Baptism of the +Inhabitants. + + +Moral energy, or constancy of purpose, seems to be less properly an +independent power of the mind than a mode of action, by which its various +powers operate with effect. But, however this may be, it enters more +largely, perhaps, than mere talent, as commonly understood, into the +formation of what is called character, and is often confounded by the +vulgar with talent of the highest order. In the ordinary concerns of life, +indeed, it is more serviceable than brilliant parts; while, in the more +important, these latter are of little weight without it, evaporating only +in brief and barren flashes, which may dazzle the eye by their splendor, +but pass away and are forgotten. + +The importance of moral energy is felt not only, where it would be +expected, in the concerns of active life, but in those more exclusively of +an intellectual character, in deliberative assemblies, for example, where +talent, as usually understood, might be supposed to assert an absolute +supremacy, but where it is invariably made to bend to the controlling +influence of this principle. No man destitute of it can be the leader of a +party; while there are few leaders, probably, who do not number in their +ranks minds from which they would be compelled to shrink in a contest for +purely intellectual pre-eminence. + +This energy of purpose presents itself in a yet more imposing form when +stimulated by some intense passion, as ambition, or the nobler principle +of patriotism or religion; when the soul, spurning vulgar considerations +of interest, is ready to do and to dare all for conscience' sake; when, +insensible alike to all that this world can give or take away, it loosens +itself from the gross ties which bind it to earth, and, however humble its +powers in every other point of view, attains a grandeur and elevation, +which genius alone, however gifted, can never reach. + +But it is when associated with exalted genius, and under the action of the +potent principles above mentioned, that this moral energy conveys an image +of power, which approaches, nearer than anything else on earth, to that of +a divine intelligence. It is, indeed, such agents that Providence selects +for the accomplishment of those great revolutions, by which the world is +shaken to its foundations, new and more beautiful systems created, and the +human mind carried forward at a single stride, in the career of +improvement, further than it had advanced for centuries. It must, indeed, +be confessed, that this powerful agency is sometimes for evil, as well as +for good. It is this same impulse, which spurs guilty Ambition along his +bloody track, and which arms the hand of the patriot sternly to resist +him; which glows with holy fervor in the bosom of the martyr, and which +lights up the fires of persecution, by which he is to win his crown of +glory. The direction of the impulse, differing in the same individual +under different circumstances, can alone determine whether he shall be the +scourge or the benefactor of his species. + +These reflections have been suggested by the character of the +extraordinary person brought forward in the preceding chapter, Ximenes de +Cisneros, and the new and less advantageous aspect, in which he must now +appear to the reader. Inflexible constancy of purpose formed, perhaps, the +most prominent trait of his remarkable character. What direction it might +have received under other circumstances it is impossible to say. It would +be no great stretch of fancy to imagine, that the unyielding spirit, which +in its early days could voluntarily endure years of imprisonment, rather +than submit to an act of ecclesiastical oppression, might under similar +influences have been aroused, like Luther's, to shake down the ancient +pillars of Catholicism, instead of lending all its strength to uphold +them. The latter position, however, would seem better assimilated to the +constitution of his mind, whose sombre enthusiasm naturally prepared him +for the vague and mysterious in the Romish faith, as his inflexible temper +did for its bold and arrogant dogmas. At any rate, it was to this cause he +devoted the whole strength of his talents and commanding energies. + +We have seen, in the preceding chapter, with what promptness he entered on +the reform of religious discipline, as soon as he came into office, and +with what pertinacity he pursued it, in contempt of all personal interest +and popularity. We are now to see him with similar zeal devoting himself +to the extirpation of heresy; with contempt not merely of personal +consequences, but also of the most obvious principles of good faith and +national honor. + +Nearly eight years had elapsed since the conquest of Granada, and the +subjugated kingdom continued to repose in peaceful security under the +shadow of the treaty, which guaranteed the unmolested enjoyment of its +ancient laws and religion. This unbroken continuance of public +tranquillity, especially difficult to be maintained among the jarring +elements of the capital, whose motley population of Moors, renegades, and +Christians suggested perpetual points of collision, must be chiefly +referred to the discreet and temperate conduct of the two individuals whom +Isabella had charged with the civil and ecclesiastical government. These +were Mendoza, count of Tendilla, and Talavera, archbishop of Granada. + +The former, the brightest ornament of his illustrious house, has been +before made known to the reader by his various important services, both +military and diplomatic. Immediately after the conquest of Granada he was +made alcayde and captain general of the kingdom, a post for which he was +every way qualified by his prudence, firmness, enlightened views, and long +experience. [1] + +The latter personage, of more humble extraction, [2] was Fray Fernando de +Talavera, a Hieronymite monk, who, having been twenty years prior of the +monastery of Santa Maria del Prado, near Valladolid, was made confessor of +Queen Isabella, and afterwards of the king. This situation necessarily +gave him considerable influence in all public measures. If the keeping of +the royal conscience could be safely intrusted to any one, it might +certainly be to this estimable prelate, equally distinguished for his +learning, amiable manners, and unblemished piety; and, if his character +was somewhat tainted with bigotry, it was in so mild a form, so far +tempered by the natural benevolence of his disposition, as to make a +favorable contrast to the dominant spirit of the time. [3] + +After the conquest, he exchanged the bishopric of Avila for the +archiepiscopal see of Granada. Notwithstanding the wishes of the +sovereigns, he refused to accept any increase of emolument in this new and +more exalted station. His revenues, indeed, which amounted to two millions +of maravedies annually, were somewhat less than he before enjoyed. [4] The +greater part of this sum he liberally expended on public improvements and +works of charity; objects, which, to their credit be it spoken, have +rarely failed to engage a large share of the attention and resources of +the higher Spanish clergy. [5] + +The subject which pressed most seriously on the mind of the good +archbishop, was the conversion of the Moors, whose spiritual blindness he +regarded with feelings of tenderness and charity, very different from +those entertained by most of his reverend brethren. He proposed to +accomplish this by the most rational method possible. Though late in life, +he set about learning Arabic, that he might communicate with the Moors in +their own language, and commanded his clergy to do the same. [6] He caused +an Arabic vocabulary, grammar, and catechism to be compiled; and a version +in the same tongue to be made of the liturgy, comprehending the selections +from the Gospels; and proposed to extend this at some future time to the +whole body of the Scriptures. [7] Thus unsealing the sacred oracles which +had been hitherto shut out from their sight, he opened to them the only +true sources of Christian knowledge; and, by endeavoring to effect their +conversion through the medium of their understandings, instead of seducing +their imaginations with a vain show of ostentatious ceremonies, proposed +the only method by which conversion could be sincere and permanent. + +These wise and benevolent measures of the good prelate, recommended, as +they were, by the most exemplary purity of life, acquired him great +authority among the Moors, who, estimating the value of the doctrine by +its fruits, were well inclined to listen to it, and numbers were daily +added to the church. [8] + +The progress of proselytism, however, was necessarily slow and painful +among a people reared from the cradle, not merely in antipathy to, but +abhorrence of, Christianity; who were severed from the Christian community +by strong dissimilarity of language, habits, and institutions; and now +indissolubly knit together by a common sense of national misfortune. Many +of the more zealous clergy and religious persons, conceiving, indeed, this +barrier altogether insurmountable, were desirous of seeing it swept away +at once by the strong arm of power. They represented to the sovereigns, +that it seemed like insensibility to the goodness of Providence, which had +delivered the infidels into their hands, to allow them any longer to usurp +the fair inheritance of the Christians, and that the whole of the stiff- +necked race of Mahomet might justly be required to submit without +exception to instant baptism, or to sell their estates and remove to +Africa. This, they maintained, could be scarcely regarded as an +infringement of the treaty, since the Moors would be so great gainers on +the score of their eternal salvation; to say nothing of the +indispensableness of such a measure to the permanent tranquillity and +security of the kingdom. [9] + +But these considerations, "just and holy as they were," to borrow the +words of a devout Spaniard, [10] failed to convince the sovereigns, who +resolved to abide by their royal word, and to trust to the conciliatory +measures now in progress, and a longer and more intimate intercourse with +the Christians, as the only legitimate means for accomplishing their +object. Accordingly, we find the various public ordinances, as low down as +1499, recognizing this principle, by the respect which they show for the +most trivial usages of the Moors, [11] and by their sanctioning no other +stimulant to conversion than the amelioration of their condition. [12] +Among those in favor of more active measures was Ximenes, archbishop of +Toledo. Having followed the court to Granada in the autumn of 1499, he +took the occasion to communicate his views to Talavera, the archbishop, +requesting leave at the same time to participate with him in his labor of +love; to which the latter, willing to strengthen himself by so efficient +an ally, modestly assented. Ferdinand and Isabella soon after removed to +Seville; but, before their departure, enjoined on the prelates to observe +the temperate policy hitherto pursued, and to beware of giving any +occasion for discontent to the Moors. [13] + +No sooner had the sovereigns left the city, than Ximenes invited some of +the leading _alfaquies_, or Mussulman doctors, to a conference, in +which he expounded, with all the eloquence at his command, the true +foundations of the Christian faith, and the errors of their own; and, that +his teaching might be the more palatable, enforced it by liberal presents, +consisting mostly of rich and costly articles of dress, of which the Moors +were at all times exceedingly fond. This policy he pursued for some time, +till the effect became visible. Whether the preaching or presents of the +archbishop had most weight, does not appear. [14] It is probable, however, +that the Moorish doctors found conversion a much more pleasant and +profitable business than they had anticipated; for they one after another +declared their conviction of their errors, and their willingness to +receive baptism. The example of these learned persons was soon followed by +great numbers of their illiterate disciples, insomuch that no less than +four thousand are said to have presented themselves in one day for +baptism; and Ximenes, unable to administer the rite to each individually, +was obliged to adopt the expedient familiar to the Christian missionaries, +of christening them _en masse_ by aspersion; scattering the consecrated +drops from a mop, or hyssop, as it was called, which he twirled over the +heads of the multitude. [15] + +So far all went on prosperously; and the eloquence and largesses of the +archbishop, which latter he lavished so freely as to encumber his revenues +for several years to come, brought crowds of proselytes to the Christian +fold. [16] There were some, indeed, among the Mahometans, who regarded +these proceedings as repugnant, if not to the letter, at least to the +spirit of the original treaty of capitulation; which seemed intended to +provide, not only against the employment of force, but of any undue +incentive to conversion. [17] Several of the more sturdy, including some +of the principal citizens, exerted their efforts to stay the tide of +defection, which threatened soon to swallow up the whole population of the +city. But Ximenes, whose zeal had mounted up to fever heat in the +excitement of success, was not to be cooled by any opposition, however +formidable; and if he had hitherto respected the letter of the treaty, he +now showed himself to be prepared to trample on letter and spirit +indifferently, when they crossed his designs. + +Among those most active in the opposition was a noble Moor named Zegri, +well skilled in the learning of his countrymen, with whom he had great +consideration. Ximenes having exhausted all his usual artillery of +arguments and presents on this obdurate infidel, had him taken into +custody by one of his officers named Leon, "a lion," says a punning +historian, "by nature as well as by name," [18] and commanded the latter +to take such measures with his prisoner, as would clear the film from his +eyes. This faithful functionary executed his orders so effectually, that, +after a few days of fasting, fetters, and imprisonment, he was able to +present his charge to his employer, penitent to all outward appearance, +and with an humble mien strongly contreating with his former proud and +lofty bearing. After the most respectful obeisance to the archbishop, +Zegri informed him, that "on the preceding night he had had a revelation +from Allah, who had condescended to show him the error of his ways, and +commanded him to receive instant baptism;" at the same time, pointing to +his jailer, he "jocularly" remarked, "Your reverence has only to turn this +lion of yours loose among the people, and my word for it, there will not +be a Mussulman left many days within the walls of Granada." [19] "Thus," +exclaims the devout Ferreras, "did Providence avail itself of the darkness +of the dungeon to pour on the benighted minds of the infidel the light of +the true faith!" [20] + +The work of proselytism now went on apace; for terror was added to the +other stimulants. The zealous propagandist, in the mean while, flushed +with success, resolved not only to exterminate infidelity, but the very +characters in which its teachings were recorded. He accordingly caused all +the Arabic manuscripts which he could procure to be heaped together in a +common pile in one of the great squares of the city. The largest part were +copies of the Koran, or works in some way or other connected with +theology; with many others, however, on various scientific subjects. They +were beautifully executed, for the most part, as to their chirography, and +sumptuously bound and decorated; for, in all relating to the mechanical +finishing, the Spanish Arabs excelled every people in Europe. But neither +splendor of outward garniture, nor intrinsic merit of composition, could +atone for the taint of heresy in the eye of the stern inquisitor; he +reserved for his university of Alcalá three hundred works, indeed, +relating to medical science, in which the Moors were as pre-eminent in +that day as the Europeans were deficient; but all the rest, amounting to +many thousands, [21] he consigned to indiscriminate conflagration. [22] + +This melancholy _auto da fe_, it will be recollected, was celebrated, +not by an unlettered barbarian, but by a cultivated prelate, who was at +that very time actively employing his large revenues in the publication of +the most stupendous literary work of the age, and in the endowment of the +most learned university in Spain. [23] It took place, not in the darkness +of the Middle Ages, but in the dawn of the sixteenth century, and in the +midst of an enlightened nation, deeply indebted for its own progress to +these very stores of Arabian wisdom. It forms a counterpart to the imputed +sacrilege of Omar, [24] eight centuries before, and shows that bigotry is +the same in every faith and every age. + +The mischief occasioned by this act, far from being limited to the +immediate loss, continued to be felt still more severely in its +consequences. Such as could, secreted the manuscripts in their possession +till an opportunity occurred for conveying them out of the country; and +many thousands in this way were privately shipped over to Barbary. [25] +Thus Arabian literature became rare in the libraries of the very country +to which it was indigenous; the Arabic scholarship, once so flourishing in +Spain, and that too in far less polished ages, gradually fell into decay +from want of aliment to sustain it. Such were the melancholy results of +this literary persecution; more mischievous, in one view, than even that +directed against life; for the loss of an individual will scarcely be felt +beyond his own generation, while the annihilation of a valuable work, or, +in other words, of mind itself embodied in a permanent form, is a loss to +all future time. + +The high hand with which Ximenes now carried measures, excited serious +alarm in many of the more discreet and temperate Castilians in the city. +They besought him to use greater forbearance, remonstrating against his +obvious violations of the treaty, as well as against the expediency of +forced conversions, which could not, in the nature of things, be lasting. +But the pertinacious prelate only replied, that, "A tamer policy might, +indeed, suit temporal matters, but not those in which the interests of the +soul were at stake; that the unbeliever, if he could not be drawn, should +be driven, into the way of salvation; and that it was no time to stay the +hand, when the ruins of Mahometanism were tottering to their foundations." +He accordingly went on with unflinching resolution. [26] + +But the patience of the Moors themselves, which had held out so +marvellously under this system of oppression, began now to be exhausted. +Many signs of this might be discerned by much less acute optics than those +of the archbishop; but his were blinded by the arrogance of success. At +length, in this inflammable state of public feeling, an incident occurred +which led to a general explosion. + +Three of Ximenes's servants were sent on some business to the Albayein, a +quarter inhabited exclusively by Moors, and encompassed by walls which +separated it from the rest of the city. [27] These men had made themselves +peculiarly odious to the people by their activity in their master's +service. A dispute, having arisen between them and some inhabitants of the +quarter, came at last to blows, when two of the servants were massacred on +the spot, and their comrade escaped with difficulty from the infuriated +mob. [28] The affair operated as the signal for insurrection. The +inhabitants of the district ran to arms, got possession of the gates, +barricaded the streets, and in a few hours the whole Albayein was in +rebellion. [29] + +In the course of the following night, a large number of the enraged +populace made their way into the city to the quarters of Ximenes, with the +purpose of taking summary vengeance on his head for all his persecutions. +Fortunately, his palace was strong, and defended by numerous resolute and +well-armed attendants. The latter, at the approach of the rioters, +implored their master to make his escape, if possible, to the fortress of +the Alhambra, where the count of Tendilla was established. But the +intrepid prelate, who held life too cheap to be a coward, exclaimed, "God +forbid I should think of my own safety, when so many of the faithful are +perilling theirs! No, I will stand to my post and wait there, if Heaven +wills it, the crown of martyrdom." [30] It must be confessed he well +deserved it. + +The building, however, proved too strong for the utmost efforts of the +mob; and, at length, after some hours of awful suspense and agitation to +the beleaguered inmates, the count of Tendilla arrived in person at the +head of his guards, and succeeded in dispersing the insurgents, and +driving them back to their own quarters. But no exertions could restore +order to the tumultuous populace, or induce them to listen to terms; and +they even stoned the messenger charged with pacific proposals from the +count of Tendilla. They organized themselves under leaders, provided arms, +and took every possible means for maintaining their defence. It seemed as +if, smitten with the recollections of ancient liberty, they were resolved +to recover it again at all hazards. [31] At length, after this disorderly +state of things had lasted for several days, Talavera, the archbishop of +Granada, resolved to try the effect of his personal influence, hitherto so +great with the Moors, by visiting himself the disaffected quarter. This +noble purpose he put in execution, in spite of the most earnest +remonstrances of his friends. He was attended only by his chaplain, +bearing the crucifix before him, and a few of his domestics, on foot and +unarmed like himself. At the site of their venerable pastor, with his +countenance beaming with the same serene and benign expression with which +they were familiar when listening to his exhortations from the pulpit, the +passions of the multitude were stilled. Every one seemed willing to +abandon himself to the tender recollections of the past; and the simple +people crowded around the good man, kneeling down and kissing the hem of +his robe, as if to implore his benediction. The count of Tendilla no +sooner learned the issue, than he followed into the Albayein, attended by +a handful of soldiers. When he had reached the place where the mob was +gathered, he threw his bonnet into the midst of them, in token of his +pacific intentions. The action was received with acclamations, and the +people, whose feelings had now taken another direction, recalled by his +presence to the recollection of his uniformly mild and equitable rule, +treated him with similar respect to that shown the archbishop of Granada. +[32] + +These two individuals took advantage of this favorable change of feeling +to expostulate with the Moors on the folly and desperation of their +conduct, which must involve them in a struggle with such overwhelming odds +as that of the whole Spanish monarchy. They implored them to lay down +their arms and return to their duty, in which event they pledged +themselves, as far as in their power, to allow no further repetition of +the grievances complained of, and to intercede for their pardon with the +sovereigns. The count testified his sincerity, by leaving his wife and two +children as hostages in the heart of the Albayein; an act which must be +admitted to imply unbounded confidence in the integrity of the Moors. [33] +These various measures, backed, moreover, by the counsels and authority of +some of the chief alfaquis, had the effect to restore tranquillity among +the people, who, laying aside their hostile preparations, returned once +more to their regular employments. [34] + +The rumor of the insurrection, in the mean while, with the usual +exaggeration, reached Seville, where the court was then residing. In one +respect rumor did justice, by imputing the whole blame of the affair to +the intemperate zeal of Ximenes. That personage, with his usual +promptness, had sent early notice of the affair to the queen by a negro +slave uncommonly fleet of foot. But the fellow had become intoxicated by +the way, and the court were several days without any more authentic +tidings than general report. The king, who always regarded Ximenes's +elevation to the primacy, to the prejudice, as the reader may remember, of +his own son, with dissatisfaction, could not now restrain his indignation, +but was heard to exclaim tauntingly to the queen, "So we are like to pay +dear for your archbishop, whose rashness has lost us in a few hours what +we have been years in acquiring." [35] + +The queen, confounded at the tidings, and unable to comprehend the silence +of Ximenes, instantly wrote to him in the severest terms, demanding an +explanation of the whole proceeding. The archbishop saw his error in +committing affairs of moment to such hands as those of his sable +messenger; and the lesson stood him in good stead, according to his +moralizing biographer, for the remainder of his life. [36] He hastened to +repair his fault by proceeding to Seville in person, and presenting +himself before the sovereigns. He detailed to them the history of all the +past transactions; recapitulated his manifold services, the arguments and +exhortations he had used, the large sums he had expended, and his various +expedients, in short, for effecting conversion, before resorting to +severity. He boldly assumed the responsibility of the whole proceeding, +acknowledging that he had purposely avoided communicating his plans to the +sovereigns for fear of opposition. If he had erred, he said, it could be +imputed to no other motive, at worst, than too great zeal for the +interests of religion; but he concluded with assuring them, that the +present position of affairs was the best possible for their purposes, +since the late conduct of the Moors involved them in the guilt, and +consequently all the penalties of treason, and that it would be an act of +clemency to offer pardon on the alternatives of conversion or exile! [37] + +The archbishop's discourse, if we are to credit his enthusiastic +biographer, not only dispelled the clouds of royal indignation, but drew +forth the most emphatic expressions of approbation. [38] How far Ferdinand +and Isabella were moved to this by his final recommendation, or what, in +clerical language, may be called the "improvement of his discourse," does +not appear. They did not at any rate adopt it in its literal extent. In +due time, however, commissioners were sent to Granada, fully authorized to +inquire into the late disturbances and punish their guilty authors. In the +course of the investigation, many, including some of the principal +citizens, were imprisoned on suspicion. The greater part made their peace +by embracing Christianity. Many others sold their estates and migrated to +Barbary; and the remainder of the population, whether from fear of +punishment, or contagion of example, abjured their ancient superstition +and consented to receive baptism. The whole number of converts was +estimated at about fifty thousand, whose future relapses promised an +almost inexhaustible supply for the fiery labors of the Inquisition. From +this period the name of Moors, which had gradually superseded the +primitive one of Spanish Arabs, gave way to the title of Moriscoes, by +which this unfortunate people continued to be known through the remainder +of their protracted existence in the Peninsula. [39] + +The circumstances, under which this important revolution in religion was +effected in the whole population of this great city, will excite only +feelings of disgust at the present day, mingled, indeed, with compassion +for the unhappy beings, who so heedlessly incurred the heavy liabilities +attached to their new faith. Every Spaniard, doubtless, anticipated the +political advantages likely to result from a measure, which divested the +Moors of the peculiar immunities secured by the treaty of capitulation, +and subjected them at once to the law of the land. It is equally certain, +however, that they attached great value in a spiritual view to the mere +show of conversion, placing implicit confidence in the purifying influence +of the waters of baptism, to whomever and under whatever circumstances +administered. Even the philosophic Martyr, as little tinctured with +bigotry as any of the time, testifies his joy at the conversion, on the +ground, that, although it might not penetrate beneath the crust of +infidelity, which had formed over the mind of the older and of course +inveterate Mussulman, yet it would have full effect on his posterity, +subjected from the cradle to the searching operation of Christian +discipline. [40] + +With regard to Ximenes, the real author of the work, whatever doubts were +entertained of his discretion, in the outset, they were completely +dispelled by the results. All concurred in admiring the invincible energy +of the man, who, in the face of such mighty obstacles, had so speedily +effected this momentous revolution in the faith of a people, bred from +childhood in the deadliest hostility to Christianity; [41] and the good +archbishop Talavera was heard in the fulness of his heart to exclaim, that +"Ximenes had achieved greater triumphs than even Ferdinand and Isabella; +since they had conquered only the soil, while he had gained the souls of +Granada!" [42] + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] "Hombre," says his son, the historian, of him, "de prudencia en +negocios graves, de animo firme, asegurado con luenga experiencia de +rencuentros i battallas ganadas." (Guerra de Granada, lib. 1, p. 9.) +Oviedo dwells with sufficient amplification on the personal history and +merits of this distinguished individual, in his garrulous reminiscences. +Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, dial. 28. + +[2] Oviedo, at least, can find no better pedigree for him, than that of +Adam. "Quanto á su linage él fué del linage de todos los humanos ó de +aquel barro y subcesion de Adan." (Quincuagenas, MS. dial. de Talavera.) +It is a very hard case, when a Castilian cannot make out a better +genealogy for his hero. + +[3] Pedraza, Antiguedad de Granada, lib. 3, cap. 10.--Marmol, Rebelion de +Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 21. Talavera's correspondence with the queen, +published in various works, but most correctly, probably, in the sixth +volume of the Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., (Ilust. 13,) is not calculated to +raise his reputation. His letters are little else than homilies on the +love of company, dancing, and the like heinous offences. The whole savors +more of the sharp twang of Puritanism than that of the Roman Catholic +school. But bigotry is neutral ground, on which the most opposite sects +may meet. + +[4] Pedraza, Antiguedad de Granada, lib. 3, cap. 10.--Marmol, lib. 1, cap. +21. + +Equivalent to 56,000 dollars of the present day; a sum which Pedraza makes +do quite as hard duty, according to its magnitude, as the 500 pounds of +Pope's Man of Ross. + +[5] Pedraza, ubi supra.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., dial. de Talavera. + +The worthy archbishop's benefactions on some occasions were of rather an +extraordinary character. "Pidiendole limosna," says Pedraza, "Una muger +que no tenia camisa, se entró en una casa, y se desnudó la suya y se la +dio; diziendo con san Pedro, No tengo oro ni plata que darte, doyte lo que +tengo." Antiguedad de Granada, lib. 3, cap. 10. + +[6] Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 21.--Pedraza, Antiguedad de +Granada, ubi supra. + +[7] Fléchier, Hist. de Ximenes, p. 17.--Quintanilla, Archetypo, lib. 2, +cap. 2.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 32.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS. + +These tracts were published at Granada, in 1505, in the European +character, being the first books ever printed in the Arabic language, +according to Dr. M'Crie, (Reformation in Spain, p. 70,) who cites +Schnurrer, Bibl. Arabica, pp. 16-18. + +[8] Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 23.--Pedraza, Antiguedad de Granada, +lib. 3, cap. 10.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 21.--Gomez, +De Rebus Gestis, fol. 29.--"Hacia lo que predicaba, é predicó lo que +hizo," says Oviedo of the archbishop, briefly, "é así fué mucho provechoso +é util en aquella ciudad para la conversion de los Moros." Quincuagenas, +MS. + +[9] Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 23. + +[10] Ibid., ubi supra. + +[11] In the _pragmática_ dated Granada, October 30th, 1499, prohibiting +silk apparel of any description, an exception was made in favor of the +Moors, whose robes were usually of that material, among the wealthier +classes. Pragmáticas del Reyno, fol. 120. + +[12] Another law, October 31st, 1499, provided against the disinheritance +of Moorish children who had embraced Christianity, and secured, moreover, +to the female converts a portion of the property which had fallen to the +state on the conquest of Granada. (Pragmáticas del Reyno, fol. 5.)-- +Llorente has reported this pragmatic with some inaccuracy. Hist. de +l'Inquisition, tom. i. p. 334. + +[13] Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 23.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 29.-- +Quintanilla, Archetypo, lib. 2, p. 54.--Suma de la Vida de Cisneros, MS. +Ferdinand and Isabella, according to Ferreras, took counsel of sundry +learned theologians and jurists, whether they could lawfully compel the +Mahometans to become Christians, notwithstanding the treaty, which +guaranteed to them the exercise of their religion. After repeated +conferences of this erudite body, "il fut decidé," says the historian, +"qu'on solliciteroit la conversion des Mahometans de la Ville et du +Royaume de Grenade, en ordonnant à ceux qui ne voudroient pas embrasser la +religion Chrétienne, de vendre leurs biens et de sortir du royaume." +(Hist. d'Espagne, tom. viii. p. 194.) Such was the idea of solicitation +entertained by these reverend casuists! The story, however, wants a better +voucher than Ferreras. + +[14] The honest Robles appears to be of the latter opinion. "Alfin," says +he, with _naïveté_, "con halagos, dadivas, y caricias, los truxo a +conocimiento del verdadero Dios." Vida de Ximenez, p. 100. + +[15] Robles, Vida de Ximenez, cap. 14.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. +1, cap. 24.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 29.--Suma de la Vida de +Cisneros, MS. + +[16] Robles, Vida de Ximenez, cap. 14.--Quintanilla, Archetypo, fol. 55.-- +The sound of bells, so unusual to Mahometan ears, pealing day and night +from the newly consecrated mosques, gained Ximenes the appellation of +_alfaqui campanero_ from the Granadines. Suma de la Vida de Cisneros, +MS. + +[17] Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 25. + +Take for example the following provisions in the treaty. "Que si algun +Moro tuviere alguna renegada por muger, no será apremiada á ser Christiana +contra su voluntad, sino que será interrogada, en presencia de Christianos +y de Moros, y se siguirá su voluntad; y lo mesmo se entenderá con los +niños y niñas nacidos de Christiana y Moro. Que ningun Moro ni Mora serán +apremiados á ser Christianos contra su voluntad; y que si alguna doncella, +ó casada, ó viuda, por razon de algunos amores se quisiere tornar +Christiana, tampoco será recebida, hasta ser interrogada." The whole +treaty is given in _extenso_ by Marmol, and by no other author that I +have seen. + +[18] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, lib. 1, fol. 29. + +[19] Robles, Rebelion de Moriscos, cap. 14.--Suma de la Vida de Cisneros, +MS.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 30.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. +1, cap. 25. + +Zegri assumed the baptismal name of the Great Captain, Gonzalo Hernandez, +whose prowess he had experienced in a personal rencontre in the vega of +Granada. Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, ubi supra.--Suma de la Vida de +Cisneros, MS. + +[20] Hist. d'Espagne, tom. viii. p. 195. + +[21] According to Robles, (Rebelion de Moriscos, p. 104,) and the Suma de +la Vida de Cisneros, 1,005,000; to Conde, (El Nubiense, Descripcion +d'España, p. 4, note,) 80,000; to Gomez and others, 5000. There are +scarcely any data for arriving at probability in this monstrous +discrepancy. The famous library of the Ommeyades at Cordova was said to +contain 600,000 volumes. It had long since been dissipated; and no similar +collection had been attempted in Granada, where learning was never in that +palmy state which it reached under the Cordovan dynasty. Still, however, +learned men were to be found there, and the Moorish metropolis would +naturally be the depository of such literary treasures as had escaped the +general shipwreck of time and accident. On the whole, the estimate of +Gomez would appear much too small, and that of Robles as +disproportionately exaggerated. Conde, better instructed in Arabic lore +than any of his predecessors, may be found, perhaps, here, as elsewhere, +the best authority. + +[22] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, lib. 2, fol. 30.--Marmol, Rebelion de +Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 25.--Robles, Vida de Ximenez, cap. 14.--Suma de la +Vida de Cisneros, MS.--Quintanilla, Archetypo, p. 58. + +[23] Yet the archbishop might find some countenance for his fanaticism in +the most polite capital of Europe. The faculty of Theology in Paris, some +few years later, declared "que c'en était fait de la religion, si on +permettait l'etude du Grec et de l'Hebreu!" Villers, Essai sur l'Esprit et +l'Influence de la Réformation de Luther, (Paris, 1820,) p. 64, note. + +[24] Gibbon's argument, if it does not shake the foundations of the whole +story of the Alexandrian conflagration, may at least raise a natural +skepticism as to the pretended amount and value of the works destroyed. + +[25] The learned Granadine, Leo Africanus, who emigrated to Fez after the +fall of the capital, notices a single collection of 3000 manuscripts +belonging to an individual, which he saw in Algiers, whither they had been +secretly brought by the Moriscoes from Spain.--Conde, Dominacion de los +Arabes, prólogo.--Casiri, Bibliotheca Escurialensis, tom. i. p. 172. + +[26] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 30.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, rey 30, +cap. 10. + +[27] Casiri, Bibliotheca Escurialensis, tom. ii. p. 281.--Pedraza, +Antiguedad de Granada, lib. 3, cap. 10. + +[28] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 31. There are some discrepancies, not +important, however, between the narrative of Gomez and the other +authorities. Gomez, considering his uncommon opportunities of information, +is worth them all. + +[29] Suma de la Vida de Cisneros, MS.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, lib. 2, +fol. 31.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 26. + +[30] Robles, Vida de Ximenez, cap. 14.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. +lib. 27, cap. 5.--Quintanilla, Archetype, p. 56.--Peter Martyr, Opus +Epist., epist. 212. + +[31] Mariana, Hist. de España, ubi supra.--Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. +23.--Mendoza, Guerra de Granada, p. 11. + +[32] Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 25.--Peter Martyr, Opus +Epist., epist. 212.--Quintanilla, Archetype, p. 56.--Bleda, Corónica, ubi +supra. + +[33] Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, loc cit.--Mendoza, Guerra de Granada, +lib. 1, p. 11. That such confidence was justified, may be inferred from a +common saying of Archbishop Talavera, "That Moorish works and Spanish +faith were all that were wanting to make a good Christian." A bitter +sarcasm this on his own countrymen! Pedraza, Antiguedad de Granada, lib. +3, cap. 10. + +[34] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 212.--Bleda, Corónica, loc. cit.-- +Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, ubi supra. + +[35] Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. lib. 27, cap. 5.--Robles, Vida de +Ximenez, 14.--Suma de la Vida de Cisneros, MS. + +[36] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 32.--Robles, Vida de Ximenez, cap. 14. + +[37] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, ubi supra. + +[38] Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, fol. 33.--Suma de la Vida de Cisneros, MS. + +[39] Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 23.--Mariana, Hist. de España, tom. ii. +lib. 27, cap. 5.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 215.--Marmol, Rebelion +de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 27.--Gomez, De Rebus Gestis, lib. 2, fol. 32.-- +Lanuza, Historias, tom. i. lib. 1, cap. 11.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año +1500.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 159.--The last author carries +the number of converts in Granada and its _environs_ to 70,000. + +[40] "Tu vero inquies," he says, in a letter to the cardinal of Santa +Cruz, "hisdem in snum Mahometem vivent animis, atque id jure merito +suspicandum est. Durum namque majorum institute relinquere; attamen ego +existimo, consultum optime fuisse ipsorum admittere postulata: paulatim +namque nova superveniente disciplina, juvenun saltem et infantum atque eo +tutius nepotum, inanibus illis superstitionibus abrasis, novis imbuentur +ritibus. De senescentibus, qui callosis animis induruerunt, haud ego +quidem id futurum inficior." Opus Epist., epist. 215.--Also, Carta de +Gonzalo, MS. + +[41] "Magnae deinceps," says Gomez, "apud omnes veneration! Ximenius esse +cospit.--Porro plus mentis acie videre quam solent homines credebatur, +qufid re ancipiti, neque plane confirmata, barbara civitate adhoc suum +Mahumetum spirante, tanza animi contentione, ut Christi doctrinam +amplecterentur, laboraverat et effecerat." (De Rebus Gestis, fol. 33.) The +panegyric of the Spaniard is endorsed by Fléchier, (Histoire de Ximenes, +p. 119,) who, in the age of Louis XIV., displays all the bigotry of that +of Ferdinand and Isabella. + +[42] Talavera, as I have already noticed, had caused the offices, +catechisms, and other religious exercises to be translated into Arabic for +the use of the converts; proposing to extend the translation at some +future time to the great body of the Scriptures. That time had now +arrived, but Ximenes vehemently remonstrated against the measure. "It +would be throwing pearls before swine," said he, "to open the Scriptures +to persons in their low state of ignorance, who could not fail, as St. +Paul says, to wrest them to their own destruction. The word of God should +be wrapped in discreet mystery from the vulgar, who feel little reverence +for what is plain and obvious. It was for this reason, that our Saviour +himself clothed his doctrines in parables, when he addressed the people. +The Scriptures should be confined to the three ancient languages, which +God with mystic import permitted to be inscribed over the head of his +crucified Son; and the vernacular should be reserved for such devotional +and moral treatises, as holy men indite, in order to quicken the soul, and +turn it from the pursuit of worldly vanities to heavenly contemplation." +De Rebus Gestis, fol. 32, 33. + +The narrowest opinion, as usual, prevailed, and Talavera abandoned his +wise and benevolent purpose. The sagacious arguments of the primate lead +his biographer, Gomez, to conclude, that he had a prophetic knowledge of +the coming heresy of Luther, which owed so much of its success to the +vernacular versions of the Scriptures; in which probable opinion he is +faithfully echoed, as usual, by the good bishop of Nismes. Fléchier, Hist. +de Ximenés, pp. 117-119. + + + + +CHAPTER VII. + +RISING IN THE ALPUXARRAS.--DEATH OF ALONSO DE AGUILAR.--EDICT AGAINST THE +MOORS. + +1500-1502. + +Rising in the Alpuxarras.--Expedition to the Sierra Vermeja.--Alonso de +Aguilar.--His Noble Character, and Death.--Bloody Rout of the Spaniards.-- +Final Submission to Ferdinand.--Cruel Policy of the Victors.-- +Commemorative Ballads.--Edict against the Moors,--Causes of Intolerance.-- +Last Notice of the Moors under the Present Reign. + + +While affairs went forward so triumphantly in the capital of Granada, they +excited general discontent in other parts of that kingdom, especially the +wild regions of the Alpuxarras. This range of maritime Alps, which +stretches to the distance of seventeen leagues in a southeasterly +direction from the Moorish capital, sending out its sierras like so many +broad arms towards the Mediterranean, was thickly sprinkled with Moorish +villages, cresting the bald summits of the mountains, or checkering the +green slopes and valleys which lay between them. Its simple inhabitants, +locked up within the lonely recesses of their hills, and accustomed to a +life of penury and toil, had escaped the corruptions as well as +refinements of civilization. In ancient times they had afforded a hardy +militia for the princes of Granada; and they now exhibited an unshaken +attachment to their ancient institutions and religion, which had been +somewhat effaced in the great cities by more intimate intercourse with the +Europeans. [1] + +These warlike mountaineers beheld with gathering resentment the faithless +conduct pursued towards their countrymen, which, they had good reason to +fear, would soon be extended to themselves; and their fiery passions were +inflamed to an ungovernable height by the public apostasy of Granada. They +at length resolved to anticipate any similar attempt on themselves by a +general insurrection. They accordingly seized on the fortresses and strong +passes throughout the country, and began as usual with forays into the +lands of the Christians. + +These bold acts excited much alarm in the capital, and the count of +Tendilla took vigorous measures for quenching the rebellion in its birth. +Gonsalvo de Cordova, his early pupil, but who might now well be his master +in the art of war, was at that time residing in Granada; and Tendilla +availed himself of his assistance to enforce a hasty muster of levies, and +march at once against the enemy. + +His first movement was against Huejar, a fortified town situated in one of +the eastern ranges of the Alpuxarras, whose inhabitants had taken the lead +in the insurrection. The enterprise was attended with more difficulty than +was expected. "God's enemies," to borrow the charitable epithet of the +Castilian chroniclers, had ploughed up the lands in the neighborhood; and, +as the light cavalry of the Spaniards was working its way through the deep +furrows, the Moors opened the canals which intersected the fields, and in +a moment the horses were floundering up to their girths in the mire and +water. Thus embarrassed in their progress, the Spaniards presented a fatal +mark to the Moorish missiles, which rained on them with pitiless fury; and +it was not without great efforts and considerable loss, that they gained a +firm landing on the opposite side. Undismayed, however, they then charged +the enemy with such vivacity, as compelled him to give way and take refuge +within the defences of the town. + +No impediment could now check the ardor of the assailants. They threw +themselves from their horses, and, bringing forward the scaling-ladders, +planted them against the walls. Gonsalvo was the first to gain the summit; +and, as a powerful Moor endeavored to thrust him from the topmost round of +the ladder, he grasped the battlements firmly with his left hand and dealt +the infidel such a blow with the sword in his right, as brought him +headlong to the ground. He then leapt into the place, and was speedily +followed by his troops. The enemy made a brief and ineffectual resistance. +The greater part were put to the sword; the remainder, including the women +and children, were made slaves, and the town was delivered up to pillage. +[2] + +The severity of this military execution had not the effect of intimidating +the insurgents; and the revolt wore so serious an aspect, that King +Ferdinand found it necessary to take the field in person, which he did at +the head of as complete and beautiful a body of Castilian chivalry as ever +graced the campaigns of Granada. [3] Quitting Alhendin, the place of +rendezvous, in the latter end of February, 1500, he directed his march on +Lanjaron, one of the towns most active in the revolt, and perched high +among the inaccessible fastnesses of the sierra, southeast of Granada. + +The inhabitants, trusting to the natural strength of a situation, which +had once baffled the arms of the bold Moorish chief El Zagal, took no +precautions to secure the passes. Ferdinand, relying on this, avoided the +more direct avenue to the place; and, bringing his men by a circuitous +route over dangerous ravines and dark and dizzy precipices, where the foot +of the hunter had seldom ventured, succeeded at length, after incredible +toil and hazard, in reaching an elevated point, which entirely commanded +the Moorish fortress. + +Great was the dismay of the insurgents at the apparition of the Christian +banners, streaming in triumph in the upper air, from the very pinnacles of +the sierra. They stoutly persisted, however, in the refusal to surrender. +But their works were too feeble to stand the assault of men, who had +vanquished the more formidable obstacles of nature; and, after a short +struggle, the place was carried by storm, and its wretched inmates +experienced the same dreadful fate with those of Huejar. [4] + +At nearly the same time, the count of Lerin took several other fortified +places in the Alpuxarras, in one of which he blew up a mosque filled with +women and children. Hostilities were carried on with all the ferocity of a +civil, or rather servile war; and the Spaniards, repudiating all the +feelings of courtesy and generosity, which they had once shown to the same +men, when dealing with them as honorable enemies, now regarded them only +as rebellious vassals, or indeed slaves, whom the public safety required +to be not merely chastised, but exterminated. + +These severities, added to the conviction of their own impotence, at +length broke the spirit of the Moors, who were reduced to the most humble +concessions; and the Catholic king, "unwilling out of his great clemency," +says Abarca, "to stain his sword with the blood of all these wild beasts +of the Alpuxarras," consented to terms, which may be deemed reasonable, at +least in comparison with his previous policy. These were, the surrender of +their arms and fortresses and the payment of the round sum of fifty +thousand ducats. [5] + +As soon as tranquillity was re-established, measures were taken for +securing it permanently, by introducing Christianity among the natives, +without which they never could remain well affected to their present +government. Holy men were therefore sent as missionaries, to admonish +them, calmly and without violence, of their errors, and to instruct them +in the great truths of revelation. [6] Various immunities were also +proposed, as an additional incentive to conversion, including an entire +exemption to the party from the payment of his share of the heavy mulct +lately imposed. [7] The wisdom of these temperate measures became every +day more visible in the conversion, not merely of the simple mountaineers, +but of nearly all the population of the great cities of Baza, Guadix, and +Almeria, who consented before the end of the year to abjure their ancient +religion, and receive baptism. [8] + +This defection, however, caused great scandal among the more sturdy of +their countrymen, and a new insurrection broke out on the eastern confines +of the Alpuxarras, which was suppressed with similar circumstances of +stern severity,. and a similar exaction of a heavy sum of money;--money, +whose doubtful efficacy may be discerned, sometimes in staying, but more +frequently in stimulating, the arm of persecution. [9] + +But while the murmurs of rebellion died away in the east, they were heard +in thunders from the distant hills on the western borders of Granada. This +district, comprehending the sierras Vermeja and Villa Luenga, in the +neighborhood of Ronda, was peopled by a warlike race, among whom was the +African tribe of Gandules, whose blood boiled with the same tropical +fervor as that which glowed in the veins of their ancestors. They had +early shown symptoms of discontent at the late proceedings in the capital. +The duchess of Arcos, widow of the great marquis duke of Cadiz, whose +estates lay in that quarter, [10] used her personal exertions to appease +them; and the government made the most earnest assurances of its intention +to respect whatever had been guaranteed by the treaty of capitulation. +[11] But they had learned to place little trust in princes; and the +rapidly extending apostasy of their countrymen exasperated them to such a +degree, that they at length broke out in the most atrocious acts of +violence; murdering the Christian missionaries, and kidnapping, if report +be true, many Spaniards of both sexes, whom they sold as slaves in Africa. +They were accused, with far more probability, of entering into a secret +correspondence with their brethren on the opposite shore, in order to +secure their support in the meditated revolt. [12] + +The government displayed its usual promptness and energy on this occasion. +Orders were issued to the principal chiefs and cities of Andalusia, to +muster their forces with all possible despatch, and concentrate them on +Ronda. + +The summons was obeyed with such alacrity, that, in the course of a very +few weeks, the streets of that busy city were thronged with a shining +array of warriors drawn from all the principal towns of Andalusia. Seville +sent three hundred horse and two thousand foot. The principal leaders of +the expedition were the count of Cifuentes, who, as assistant of Seville, +commanded the troops of that city; the count of Ureña, and Alonso de +Aguilar, elder brother of the Great Captain, and distinguished like him +for the highest qualities of mind and person. + +It was determined by the chiefs to strike at once into the heart of the +Sierra Vermeja, or Red Sierra, as it was called from the color of its +rocks, rising to the east of Ronda, and the principal theatre of +insurrection. On the 18th of March, 1501, the little army encamped before +Monarda, on the skirts of a mountain, where the Moors were understood to +have assembled in considerable force. They had not been long in these +quarters before parties of the enemy were seen hovering along the slopes +of the mountain, from which the Christian camp was divided by a narrow +river,--the Rio Verde, probably, which has gained such mournful celebrity +in Spanish song. [13] Aguilar's troops, who occupied the van, were so much +roused by the sight of the enemy, that a small party, seizing a banner, +rushed across the stream without orders, in pursuit of them. + +The odds, however, were so great, that they would have been severely +handled, had not Aguilar, while he bitterly condemned their temerity, +advanced promptly to their support with the remainder of his corps. The +count of Ureña followed with the central division, leaving the count of +Cifuentes with the troops of Seville to protect the camp. [14] + +The Moors fell back as the Christians advanced, and, retreating nimbly +from point to point, led them up the rugged steeps far into the recesses +of the mountains. At length they reached an open level, encompassed on all +sides by a natural rampart of rocks, where they had deposited their +valuable effects, together with their wives and children. The latter, at +sight of the invaders, uttered dismal cries, and fled into the remoter +depths of the sierra. + +The Christians were too much attracted by the rich spoil before them to +think of following, and dispersed in every direction in quest of plunder, +with all the heedlessness and insubordination of raw, inexperienced +levies. It was in vain, that Alonso de Aguilar reminded them, that their +wily enemy was still unconquered; or that he endeavored to force them into +the ranks again, and restore order. No one heeded his call, or thought of +anything beyond the present moment, and of securing as much booty to +himself as he could carry. + +The Moors, in the mean while, finding themselves no longer pursued, were +aware of the occupation of the Christians, whom they not improbably had +purposely decoyed into the snare. They resolved to return to the scene of +action, and surprise their incautious enemy. Stealthily advancing, +therefore, under the shadows of night, now falling thick around, they +poured through the rocky defiles of the inclosure upon the astonished +Spaniards. An unlucky explosion, at this crisis, of a cask of powder, into +which a spark had accidentally fallen, threw a broad glare over the scene, +and revealed for a moment the situation of the hostile parties;--the +Spaniards in the utmost disorder, many of them without arms, and +staggering under the weight of their fatal booty; while their enemies were +seen gliding like so many demons of darkness through every crevice and +avenue of the inclosure, in the act of springing on their devoted victims. +This appalling spectacle, vanishing almost as soon as seen, and followed +by the hideous yells and war-cries of the assailants, struck a panic into +the hearts of the soldiers, who fled, scarcely offering any resistance. +The darkness of the night was as favorable to the Moors, familiar with all +the intricacies of the ground, as it was fatal to the Christians, who, +bewildered in the mazes of the sierra, and losing their footing at every +step, fell under the swords of their pursuers, or went down the dark gulfs +and precipices which yawned all around. [15] + +Amidst this dreadful confusion, the count of Ureña succeeded in gaining a +lower level of the sierra, where he halted and endeavored to rally his +panic-struck followers. His noble comrade, Alonso de Aguilar, still +maintained his position on the heights above, refusing all entreaties of +his followers to attempt a retreat. "When," said he proudly, "was the +banner of Aguilar ever known to fly from the field?" His eldest son, the +heir of his house and honors, Don Pedro de Cordova, a youth of great +promise, fought at his side. He had received a severe wound on the head +from a stone, and a javelin had pierced quite through his leg. With one +knee resting on the ground, however, he still made a brave defence with +his sword. The sight was too much for the father, and he implored him to +suffer himself to be removed from the field. "Let not the hopes of our +house be crushed at a single blow," said he; "go, my son, live as becomes +a Christian knight,--live, and cherish your desolate mother." All his +entreaties were fruitless, however; and the gallant boy refused to leave +his father's side, till he was forcibly borne away by the attendants, who +fortunately succeeded in bringing him in safety to the station occupied by +the count of Ureña. [16] + +Meantime the brave little band of cavaliers, who remained true to Aguilar, +had fallen one after another; and the chief, left almost alone, retreated +to a huge rock which rose in the middle of the plain, and, placing his +back against it, still made fight, though weakened by loss of blood, like +a lion at bay, against his enemies. [17] In this situation he was pressed +so hard by a Moor of uncommon size and strength, that he was compelled to +turn and close with him in single combat. The strife was long and +desperate, till Don Alonso, whose corselet had become unlaced in the +previous struggle, having--received a severe wound in the breast, followed +by another on the head, grappled closely with his adversary, and they came +rolling on the ground together. The Moor remained uppermost; but the +spirit of the Spanish cavalier had not sunk with his strength, and he +proudly exclaimed, as if to intimidate his enemy, "I am Don Alonso de +Aguilar;" to which the other rejoined, "And I am the Feri de Ben Estepar," +a well-known name of terror to the Christians. The sound of this detested +name roused all the vengeance of the dying hero; and, grasping his foe in +mortal agony, he rallied his strength for a final blow; but it was too +late,-his hand failed, and he was soon despatched by the dagger of his +more vigorous rival. [18] + +Thus fell Alonso Hernandez de Cordova, or Alonso de Aguilar, as he is +commonly called from the land where his family estates lay. [19] "He was +of the greatest authority among the grandees of his time," says Father +Abarca, "for his lineage, personal character, large domains, and the high +posts which he filled, both in peace and war. More than forty years of his +life he served against the infidel, under the banner of his house in +boyhood, and as leader of that same banner in later life, or as viceroy of +Andalusia and commander of the royal armies. He was the fifth lord of his +warlike and pious house who had fallen fighting for their country and +religion against the accursed sect of Mahomet. And there is good reason to +believe," continues the same orthodox authority, "that his soul has +received the glorious reward of the Christian soldier; since he was armed +on that very morning with the blessed sacraments of confession and +communion." [20] + +The victorious Moors, all this time, were driving the unresisting +Spaniards, like so many terrified deer, down the dark steeps of the +sierra. The count of Ureña, who had seen his son stretched by his side, +and received a severe wound himself, made the most desperate efforts to +rally the fugitives, but was at length swept away by the torrent. Trusting +himself to a faithful adalid, who knew the passes, he succeeded with much +difficulty in reaching the foot of the mountain, with such a small remnant +of his followers as could keep in his track. [21] Fortunately, he there +found the count of Cifuentes, who had crossed the river with the +rearguard, and encamped on a rising ground in the neighborhood. Under +favor of this strong position, the latter commander and his brave +Sevillians, all fresh for action, were enabled to cover the shattered +remains of the Spaniards, and beat off the assaults of their enemies till +the break of morn, when they vanished like so many foul birds of night +into the recesses of the mountains. + +The rising day, which dispersed their foes, now revealed to the Christians +the dreadful extent of their own losses. Few were to be seen of all that +proud array, which had marched up the heights so confidently under the +banners of their ill-fated chiefs the preceding evening. The bloody roll +of slaughter, besides the common file, was graced with the names of the +best and bravest of the Christian knighthood, Among the number was +Francisco Ramirez de Madrid, the distinguished engineer, who had +contributed so essentially to the success of the Granadine war. [22] + +The sad tidings of the defeat soon spread throughout the country, +occasioning a sensation such as had not been felt since the tragic affair +of the Axarquia. Men could scarcely credit that so much mischief could be +inflicted by an outcast race, who, whatever terror they once inspired, had +long since been regarded with indifference or contempt. Every Spaniard +seemed to consider himself in some way or other involved in the disgrace; +and the most spirited exertions were made on all sides to retrieve it. By +the beginning of April, King Ferdinand found himself at Ronda, at the head +of a strong body of troops, which he determined to lead in person, +notwithstanding the remonstrances of his courtiers, into the heart of the +Sierra, and take bloody vengeance on the rebels. + +These latter, however, far from being encouraged, were appalled by the +extent of their own success; and, as the note of warlike preparation +reached them in their fastnesses, they felt their temerity in thus +bringing the whole weight of the Castilian monarchy on their heads. They +accordingly abandoned all thoughts of further resistance, and lost no time +in sending deputies to the king's camp, to deprecate his anger, and sue in +the most submissive terms for pardon. + +Ferdinand, though far from vindictive, was less open to pity than the +queen; and in the present instance he indulged in a full measure of the +indignation, with which sovereigns, naturally identifying themselves with +the state, are wont to regard rebellion, by viewing it in the aggravated +light of a personal offence. After some hesitation, however, his prudence +got the better of his passions, as he reflected that he was in a situation +to dictate the terms of victory, without paying the usual price for it. +His past experience seems to have convinced him of the hopelessness of +infusing sentiments of loyalty in a Mussulman towards a Christian prince; +for, while he granted a general amnesty to those concerned in the +insurrection, it was only on the alternative of baptism or exile, engaging +at the same time to provide conveyance for such as chose to leave the +country, on the payment of ten doblas of gold a head. [23.] + +These engagements were punctually fulfilled. The Moorish emigrants were +transported in public galleys from Estepona to the Barbary coast. The +number, however, was probably small; by far the greater part being +obliged, however reluctantly, from want of funds, to remain and be +baptized. "They would never have stayed," says Bleda, "if they could have +mustered the ten doblas of gold; a circumstance," continues that +charitable writer, "which shows with what levity they received baptism, +and for what paltry considerations they could be guilty of such +sacrilegious hypocrisy!" [24] + +But, although every spark of insurrection was thus effectually +extinguished, it was long, very long, before the Spanish nation could +recover from the blow, or forget the sad story of its disaster in the Red +Sierra. It became the theme, not only of chronicle, but of song; the note +of sorrow was prolonged in many a plaintive _romance_, and the names +of Aguilar and his unfortunate companions were embalmed in that beautiful +minstrelsy, scarcely less imperishable, and far more touching, than the +stately and elaborate records of history. [25] The popular feeling was +displayed after another fashion in regard to the count of Ureña and his +followers, who were accused of deserting their posts in the hour of peril; +and more than one ballad of the time reproachfully demanded an account +from him of the brave companions in arms whom he had left in the Sierra. +[26] + +The imputation on this gallant nobleman appears wholly undeserved; for +certainly he was not called on to throw away his own life and those of his +brave followers, in a cause perfectly desperate, for a chimerical point of +honor. And, so far from forfeiting the favor of his sovereigns by his +conduct on this occasion, he was maintained by them in the same high +stations, which he before held, and which he continued to fill with +dignity to a good old age. [27] + +It was about seventy years after this event, in 1570, that the duke of +Arcos, descended from the great marquis of Cadiz, and from this same count +of Ureña, led an expedition into the Sierra Vermeja, in order to suppress +a similar insurrection of the Moriscoes. Among the party were many of the +descendants and kinsmen of those who had fought under Aguilar. It was the +first time since that these rude passes had been trodden by Christian +feet; but the traditions of early childhood had made every inch of ground +familiar to the soldiers. Some way up the eminence, they recognized the +point at which the count of Ureña had made his stand; and further still, +the fatal plain, belted round with its dark rampart of rocks, where the +strife had been hottest. Scattered fragments of arms and harness still lay +rusting on the ground, which was covered with the bones of the warriors, +that had lain for more than half a century unburied and bleaching in the +sun. [28] Here was the spot on which the brave son of Aguilar had fought +so sturdily by his father's side; and there the huge rock, at whose foot +the chieftain had fallen, throwing its dark shadow over the remains of the +noble dead, who lay sleeping around. The strongly marked features of the +ground called up all the circumstances, which the soldiers had gathered +from tradition; their hearts beat high, as they recapitulated them one to +another; and the tears, says the eloquent historian who tells the story, +fell fast down their iron cheeks, as they gazed on the sad relics, and +offered up a soldier's prayer for the heroic souls which once animated +them. [29] + +Tranquillity was now restored throughout the wide borders of Granada. The +banner of the Cross floated triumphantly over the whole extent of its wild +sierras, its broad valleys, and populous cities. Every Moor, in exterior +at least, had become a Christian. Every mosque had been converted into a +Christian church. Still the country was not entirely purified from the +stain of Islamism, since many professing their ancient faith were +scattered over different parts of the kingdom of Castile, where they had +been long resident before the surrender of their capital. The late events +seemed to have no other effect than to harden them in error; and the +Spanish government saw with alarm the pernicious influence of their +example and persuasion, in shaking the infirm faith of the new converts. + +To obviate this, an ordinance was published, in the summer of 1501, +prohibiting all intercourse between these Moors and the orthodox kingdom +of Granada. [30] At length, however, convinced that there was no other way +to save the precious seed from being choked by the thorns of infidelity +than to eradicate them altogether, the sovereigns came to the +extraordinary resolution of offering them the alternative of baptism or +exile. They issued a pragmática to that effect from Seville, February +12th, 1502. After a preamble, duly setting forth the obligations of +gratitude on the Castilians to drive God's enemies from the land, which he +in his good time had delivered into their hands, and the numerous +backslidings occasioned among the new converts by their intercourse with +their unbaptized brethren, the act goes on to state, in much the same +terms with the famous ordinance against the Jews, that all the unbaptized +Moors in the kingdoms of Castile and Leon, above fourteen years of age if +males, and twelve if females, must leave the country by the end of April +following; that they might sell their property in the mean time, and take +the proceeds in anything save gold and silver and merchandise regularly +prohibited; and, finally, that they might emigrate to any foreign country, +except the dominions of the Grand Turk, and such parts of Africa as Spain +was then at war with. Obedience to these severe provisions was enforced by +the penalties of death and confiscation of property. [31] + +This stern edict, so closely modelled on that against the Jews, must have +been even more grievous in its application. [32] For the Jews may be said +to have been denizens almost equally of every country; while the Moors, +excluded from a retreat among their countrymen on the African shore, were +sent into the lands of enemies or strangers. The former, moreover, were +far better qualified by their natural shrewdness and commercial habits for +disposing of their property advantageously, than the simple, inexperienced +Moors, skilled in little else than husbandry or rude mechanic arts. We +have nowhere met with any estimate of the number who migrated on this +occasion. The Castilian writers pass over the whole affair in a very few +words; not, indeed, as is too evident, from any feelings of +disapprobation, but from its insignificance in a political view. Their +silence implies a very inconsiderable amount of emigrants; a circumstance +not to-be wondered at, as there were very few, probably, who would not +sooner imitate their Granadine brethren, in assuming the mask of +Christianity, than encounter exile under all the aggravated miseries with +which it was accompanied. [33] + +Castile might now boast, the first time for eight centuries, that every +outward stain, at least, of infidelity, was purified from her bosom. But +how had this been accomplished? By the most detestable expedients which +sophistry could devise, and oppression execute; and that, too, under an +enlightened government, proposing to be guided solely by a conscientious +regard for duty. To comprehend this more fully, it will be necessary to +take a brief view of public sentiment in matters of religion at that time. + +It is a singular paradox, that Christianity, whose doctrines inculcate +unbounded charity, should have been made so often an engine of +persecution; while Mahometanism, whose principles are those of avowed +intolerance, should have exhibited, at least till later times, a truly +philosophical spirit of toleration. [34] Even the first victorious +disciples of the prophet, glowing with all the fiery zeal of proselytism, +were content with the exaction of tribute from the vanquished; at least, +more vindictive feelings were reserved only for idolaters, who did not, +like the Jews and Christians, acknowledge with themselves the unity of +God. With these latter denominations they had obvious sympathy, since it +was their creed which formed the basis of their own. [35] In Spain, where +the fiery temperament of the Arab was gradually softened under the +influence of a temperate climate and higher mental culture, the toleration +of the Jews and Christians, as we have already had occasion to notice, was +so remarkable, that, within a few years after the conquest, we find them +not only protected in the enjoyment of civil and religious freedom, but +mingling on terms almost of equality with their conquerors. + +It is not necessary to inquire here, how far the different policy of the +Christians was owing to the peculiar constitution of their hierarchy, +which, composed of a spiritual militia drawn from every country in Europe, +was cut off by its position from all human sympathies, and attached to no +interests but its own; which availed itself of the superior science and +reputed sanctity, that were supposed to have given it the key to the dread +mysteries of a future life, not to enlighten but to enslave the minds of a +credulous world; and which, making its own tenets the only standard of +faith, its own rites and ceremonial the only evidence of virtue, +obliterated the great laws of morality, written by the divine hand on +every heart, and gradually built up a system of exclusiveness and +intolerance most repugnant to the mild and charitable religion of Jesus +Christ. + +Before the close of the fifteenth century, several circumstances operated +to sharpen the edge of intolerance, especially against the Arabs. The +Turks, whose political consideration of late years had made them the +peculiar representatives and champions of Mahometanism, had shown a +ferocity and cruelty in their treatment of the Christians, which brought +general odium on all the professors of their faith, and on the Moors, of +course, though most undeservedly, in common with the rest. The bold, +heterodox doctrines, also, which had occasionally broken forth in +different parts of Europe in the fifteenth century, like so many faint +streaks of light ushering in the glorious morn of the Reformation, had +roused the alarm of the champions of the church, and kindled on more than +one occasion the fires of persecution; and, before the close of the +period, the Inquisition was introduced into Spain. + +From that disastrous hour, religion wore a new aspect in this unhappy +country. The spirit of intolerance, no longer hooded in the darkness of +the cloister, now stalked abroad in all his terrors. Zeal was exalted into +fanaticism, and a rational spirit of proselytism, into one of fiendish +persecution. It was not enough now, as formerly, to conform passively to +the doctrines of the church, but it was enjoined to make war on all who +refused them. The natural feelings of compunction in the discharge of this +sad duty was a crime; and the tear of sympathy, wrung out by the sight of +mortal agonies, was an offence to be expiated by humiliating penance. The +most frightful maxims were deliberately engrafted into the code of morals. +Any one, it was said, might conscientiously kill an apostate wherever he +could meet him. There was some doubt whether a man might slay his own +father, if a heretic or infidel, but none whatever as to his right, in +that event, to take away the life of his son or of his brother. [36] These +maxims were not a dead letter, but of most active operation, as the sad +records of the dread tribunal too well prove. The character of the nation +underwent a melancholy change. The milk of charity, nay of human feeling, +was soured in every bosom. The liberality of the old Spanish cavalier gave +way to the fiery fanaticism of the monk. The taste for blood, once +gratified, begat a cannibal appetite in the people, who, cheered on by the +frantic clergy, seemed to vie with one another in the eagerness with which +they ran down the miserable game of the Inquisition. + +It was at this very time, when the infernal monster, gorged but not sated +with human sacrifice, was crying aloud for fresh victims, that Granada +surrendered to the Spaniards, under the solemn guaranty of the full +enjoyment of civil and religious liberty. The treaty of capitulation +granted too much, or too little,--too little for an independent state, too +much for one whose existence was now merged in that of a greater; for it +secured to the Moors privileges in some respects superior to those of the +Castilians, and to the prejudice of the latter. Such, for example, was the +permission to trade with the Barbary coast, and with the various places in +Castile and Andalusia, without paying the duties imposed on the Spaniards +themselves; [37] and that article, again, by which runaway Moorish slaves +from other parts of the kingdom were made free and incapable of being +reclaimed by their masters, if they could reach Granada. [38] The former +of these provisions struck at the commercial profits of the Spaniards, the +latter directly at their property. + +It is not too much to say, that such a treaty, depending for its +observance on the good faith and forbearance of the stronger party, would +not hold together a year in any country of Christendom, even at the +present day, before some flaw or pretext would be devised to evade it. How +much greater was the probability of this in the present case, where the +weaker party was viewed with all the accumulated odium of long hereditary +hostility and religious rancor! + +The work of conversion, on which the Christians, no doubt, much relied, +was attended with greater difficulties than had been anticipated by the +conquerors. It was now found, that, while the Moors retained their present +faith, they would be much better affected towards their countrymen in +Africa, than to the nation with which they were incorporated. In short, +Spain still had enemies in her bosom; and reports were rife in every +quarter, of their secret intelligence with the Barbary states, and of +Christians kidnapped to be sold as slaves to Algerine corsairs. Such +tales, greedily circulated and swallowed, soon begat general alarm; and +men are not apt to be over-scrupulous as to measures which they deem +essential to their personal safety. + +The zealous attempt to bring about conversion by preaching and +expostulation was fair and commendable. The intervention of bribes and +promises, if it violated the spirit, did not, at least, the letter of the +treaty. The application of force to a few of the most refractory, who by +their blind obstinacy were excluding a whole nation from the benefits of +redemption, was to be defended on other grounds; and these were not +wanting to cunning theologians, who considered that the sanctity of the +end justified extraordinary means, and that, where the eternal interests +of the soul were at stake, the force of promises and the faith of treaties +were equally nugatory. [39] + +But the _chef-d'oeuvre_ of monkish casuistry was the argument imputed +to Ximenes for depriving the Moors of the benefits of the treaty, as a +legitimate consequence of the rebellion, into which they had been driven +by his own malpractices. This proposition, however, far from outraging the +feelings of the nation, well drilled by this time in the metaphysics of +the cloister, fell short of them, if we are to judge from recommendations +of a still more questionable import, urged, though ineffectually, on the +sovereigns at this very time, from the highest quarter. [40] + +Such are the frightful results to which the fairest mind may be led, when +it introduces the refinements of logic into the discussions of duty; when, +proposing to achieve some great good, whether in politics or religion, it +conceives that the importance of the object authorizes a departure from +the plain principles of morality, which regulate the ordinary affairs of +life; and when, blending these higher interests with those of a personal +nature, it becomes incapable of discriminating between them, and is led +insensibly to act from selfish motives, while it fondly imagines itself +obeying only the conscientious dictates of duty. [41] + +With these events may be said to terminate the history of the Moors, or +the Moriscoes, as henceforth called, under the present reign. Eight +centuries had elapsed since their first occupation of the country; during +which period they had exhibited all the various phases of civilization, +from its dawn to its decline. Ten years had sufficed to overturn the +splendid remains of this powerful empire; and ten more, for its nominal +conversion to Christianity. A long century of persecution, of unmitigated +and unmerited suffering, was to follow, before the whole was to be +consummated by the expulsion of this unhappy race from the Peninsula. +Their story, in this latter period, furnishes one of the most memorable +examples in history, of the impotence of persecution, even in support of a +good cause against a bad one. It is a lesson that cannot be too deeply +pondered through every succeeding age. The fires of the Inquisition are, +indeed, extinguished, probably to be lighted no more. But where is the +land which can boast that the spirit of intolerance, which forms the very +breath of persecution, is altogether extinct in its bosom? + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] Alpuxarras,--an Arabic word, signifying "land of warriors," according +to Salazar de Mendoza. (Monarquía, tom. ii. p. 138.) + +According to the more accurate and learned Conde, it is derived from an +Arabic term for "pasturage." (El Nubiense, Descripcion de España, p. 187.) + + "La Alpuxarra, aquessa sierra + que al Sol la cervis lavanta + y que poblada de Villas, + es Mar de peñas, y plantas, + adonde sus poblaciones + ondas navegan de plata." + +Calderon, (Comedias, (Madrid, 1760,) tom. i. p. 353,) whose gorgeous muse +sheds a blaze of glory over the rudest scenes. + +[2] Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, tom. i. lib. 1, cap. 28.--Quintana, +Españoles Célebres, tom. i. p. 239.--Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 23.-- +Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 159.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, tom. +ii. fol. 338.--Mendoza, Guerra de Granada, p. 12. + +[3] If we are to believe Martyr, the royal force amounted to 80,000 foot +and 15,000 horse; so large an army, so promptly brought into the field, +would suggest high ideas of the resources of the nation; too high indeed +to gain credit, even from Martyr, without confirmation. + +[4] Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 215.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, tom. +ii. fol. 338.--Zurita, Anales, tom. v. lib. 3, cap. 45.--Carbajal, Anales, +MS., año 1500. + +[5] Footnote: Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 28.--Abarca, +Reyes de Aragon, tom. ii. fol. 338.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. +159.--Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 24. + +[6] Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 24.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., +cap. 165. + +[7] Privilegios á los Moros de Valdelecrin y las Alpuxarras que se +convirtieren, á 30 de Julio de 1500. Archive de Simancas, apud Mem. de la +Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. apend. 14. + +[8] Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1500.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. lib. +19, cap. 10. + +[9] Footnote: Carbajal, Anales, MS., año 1501.--Zurita, Anales, tom. v. +lib. 4, cap. 27, 31. + +[10] The great marquis of Cadiz was third count of Arcos, from which his +descendants took their title on the resumption of Cadiz by the crown after +his death. Mendoza, Dignidades, lib. 3, cap. 8, 17. + +[11] See two letters dated Seville, January and February, 1500, addressed +by Ferdinand and Isabella to the inhabitants of the Serrania de Ronda, +preserved in the archives of Simancas, apud Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., +tom. vi. Ilust. 15. + +[12] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 165.--Bleda, Corónica, lib. +5, cap. 25.--Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 221. + +The complaints of the Spanish and African Moors to the Sultan of Egypt, or +of Babylon, as he was then usually styled, had drawn from that prince +sharp remonstrances to the Catholic sovereigns against their persecutions +of the Moslems, accompanied by menaces of strict retaliation on the +Christians in his dominions. In order to avert such calamitous +consequences, Peter Martyr was sent as ambassador to Egypt. He left +Granada in August, 1501, proceeded to Venice, and embarked there for +Alexandria, which place he reached in December. Though cautioned on his +arrival, that his mission, in the present exasperated state of feeling at +the court, might cost him his head, the dauntless envoy sailed up the Nile +under a Mameluke guard to Grand Cairo. Far from experiencing any outrage, +however, he was courteously received by the Sultan; although the +ambassador declined compromising the dignity of the court he represented, +by paying the usual humiliating mark of obeisance, in prostrating himself +on the ground in the royal presence; an independent bearing highly +satisfactory to the Castilian historians. (See Garibay, Compendio, tom. +ii. lib. 19, cap. 12.) He had three audiences, in which he succeeded so +completely in effacing the unfavorable impressions of the Moslem prince, +that the latter not only dismissed him with liberal presents, but granted, +at his request, several important privileges to the Christian residents, +and the pilgrims to the Holy Land, which lay within his dominions. +Martyr's account of this interesting visit, which gave him ample +opportunity for studying the manners of a nation, and seeing the +stupendous monuments of ancient art, then little familiar to Europeans, +was published in Latin, under the title of "De Legatione Babylonica," in +three books, appended to his more celebrated "Decades de Rebus Oceanicis +et Novo Orbe." Mazzuchelli, (Sorittori d'ltalia, race Anghiera,) notices +an edition which he had seen published separately, without date or name of +the printer. + +[13] + "Rio Verde, Rio Verde, + Tinto va en sangre viva;"-- + +Percy, in his well-known version of one of these agreeable +_romances_, adopts the tame epithet of "gentle river," from the +awkwardness, he says, of the literal translation of "verdant river." He +was not aware, it appears, that the Spanish was a proper name. (See +Reliques of Ancient English Poetry, (London, 1812,) vol. i. p. 357.) The +more faithful version of "green river," however, would have nothing very +unpoetical in it; though our gifted countryman, Bryant seems to intimate, +by his omission, somewhat of a similar difficulty, in his agreeable +stanzas on the beautiful stream of that name in New England. + +[14] Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, año 1501.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, tom. +ii. p. 340.--Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 26.--Bernaldez, Reyes +Católicos, MS., cap. 165. + +"Fue muy gentil capitan," says Oviedo, speaking of this latter nobleman, +"y valiente lanza; y rauchas vezes dio testimonio grande de su animoso +esfuerzo." Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, dial. 36. + +[15] Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, tom. ii. fol. 340.--Zurita, Anales, tom. v. +lib. 4, cap. 33.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. 10.-- +Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 165.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, +lib. 1, cap. 28. + +[16] Mendoza, Guerra de Granada, p. 13.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, tom. 2, +fol. 340.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 28.--Oviedo, +Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. 1, dial. 36. + +The boy, who lived to man's estate, was afterwards created marquis of +Priego by the Catholic sovereigns. Salazar de Mendoza, Dignidades, lib. 2, +cap. 13. + +[17] It is the simile of the fine old ballad: + + "Solo queda Don Alonso + Su campaña es acabada + Pelea como un Leon + Pero poco aprovechaba." + +[18] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., ubi supra.--Abarca, Reyes de Aragon, +tom. ii. ubi supra.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. 10.-- +Mendoza, Guerra de Granada, p. 13.--Sandoval, Hist. Del Emp. Carlos V., +tom. i. p. 5. + +According to Hyta's prose, Aguilar had first despatched more than thirty +Moors with his own hand. (Guerras de Granada, part. i. p. 568.) The +ballad, with more discretion, does not vouch for any particular number. + + "Don Alonso en este tiempo + Muy gran batalla hacia, + El cavallo le havian muerto, + Por muralla le tenia. + Y arrimado a un gran peñon + Con valor se defendia: + + Muchos Moros tiene muertos, + Pero poco le valia. + Porque sobre el cargan muchos, + Y le dan grandes heridas, + Tantas que cayó allí muerto + Entre la gente enemiga." + +The warrior's death is summed up with an artless brevity, that would be +affectation in more studied composition. + + "Muerto queda Don Alonso, + Y eterna fama ganada." + +[19] Paolo Giovio finds an etymology for the name in the eagle (aguila), +assumed as the device of the warlike ancestors of Don Alonso. St. +Ferdinand of Castile, in consideration of the services of this illustrious +house at the taking of Cordova, in 1236, allowed it to bear as a cognomen +the name of that city. This branch, however, still continued to be +distinguished by their territorial epithet of Aguilar, although Don +Alonso's brother, the Great Captain, as we have seen, was more generally +known by that of Cordova. Vita Magni Gonsalvi, fol. 204. + +[20] Reyes de Aragon, tom. ii. fol 340, 341. + +The hero's body, left on the field of battle, was treated with decent +respect by the Moors, who restored it to King Ferdinand; and the +sovereigns caused it to be interred with all suitable pomp in the church +of St. Hypolito at Cordova. Many years afterwards the marchioness of +Priego, his descendant, had the tomb opened; and, on examining the +mouldering remains, the iron head of a lance, received in his last mortal +struggle, was found buried in the bones. Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 26. + +[21] + "Tambien el Conde de Urena, + Mal herido en demasia, + Se sale de la batalla + Llevado por una guia. + "Que sabia bien la senda + Que de la Sierra salia: + Muchos Moros dexaba muertos + Por su grande valentia. + "Tambien algunos se escapan, + Que al buen Conde le seguian." + +Oviedo, speaking of this retreat of the good count and his followers, +says, "Volvieron las riendas a sus caballos, y se retiraron a mas que +galope por la multitud de los Infieles." Quincuagenas, MS., bat. 1, quinc. +1, dial. 36. + +[22] Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, año 1501.--Carbajal, Anales, MS., año +1501.--Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 26.--Oviedo, Quincuagenas, MS., bat. +1, quinc. 1, dial. 36. + +For a more particular notice of Ramirez, see Part I. Chapter 13, of this +History. + +[23] Bleda, Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 26, 27.--Robles, Vida de Ximenez, cap. +16.--Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 165.--Mariana, Hist. de España, +lib. 27, cap. 5.--Marmol, Rebelion de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 28. + +[24] Corónica, lib. 5, cap. 27. + +The Curate of Los Palacios disposes of the Moors rather summarily; "The +Christians stripped them, gave them a free passage, and sent them to the +devil!" Reyes Católicos, cap. 165. + +[25] According to one of the _romances_, cited by Hyta, the expedition of +Aguilar was a piece of romantic Quixotism, occasioned by King +Ferdinand's challenging the bravest of his knights to plant his banner on +the summits of the Alpuxarras. + + "Qual de vosotros, amigos, + Ira a la Sierra mañana, + A poner mi Real pendon + Encima de la Alpuxarra?" + +All shrunk from the perilous emprise, till Alonso de Aguilar stepped +forward and boldly assumed it for himself. + + "A todos tiembla la barba, + Sino fuera don Alonso, + Que de Aguilar se llamaba. + Levantose en pie ante el Rey + De esta manera le habla. + + "Aquesa empresa, Señor, + Para mi estaba guardada, + Que mi senora la reyna + Ya me la tiene mandada. + + "Alegrose mucho el Rey + Por la oferta que le daba, + Au no era amanecido + Don Alonso ya cavalga." + +These popular ditties, it cannot be denied, are slippery authorities for +any important fact, unless supported by more direct historic testimony. +When composed, however, by contemporaries, or those who lived near the +time, they may very naturally record many true details, too insignificant +in their consequences to attract the notice of history. The ballad +translated with so much elaborate simplicity by Percy, is chiefly taken +up, as the English reader may remember, with the exploits of a Sevillian +hero named Saavedra. No such personage is noticed, as far as I am aware, +by the Spanish chroniclers. The name of Saavedra, however, appears to have +been a familiar one in Seville, and occurs two or three times in the +muster-roll of nobles and cavaliers of that city, who joined King +Ferdinand's army in the preceding year, 1500. Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, +eodem anno. + +[26] Mendoza notices these splenetic effusions (Guerra de Granada, p. 13); +and Bleda (Corónica, p. 636) cites the following couplet from one of them. + + "Decid, conde de Ureña, + Don Alonso donde queda." + +[27] The Venetian ambassador, Navagiero, saw the count of Ureña at Ossuna, +in 1526. He was enjoying a green old age, or, as the minister expresses +it, "molto vecchio e gentil corteggiano però." "Diseases," said the +veteran good-humoredly, "sometimes visit me, but seldom tarry long; for my +body is like a crazy old inn, where travellers find such poor fare, that +they merely touch and go." Viaggio, fol. 17. + +[28] Guerra de Granada, p. 301.--Compare the similar painting of Tacitus, +in the scene where Germanicus pays the last sad offices to the remains of +Varus and his legions. "Dein semiruto vallo, humili fossa, accisae jam +reliquiae consedisse intelligebantur: medio campi albentia ossa, ut +fugerant, ut restiterant, disjecta vel aggerata; adjacebant fragmina +telorum, equorumque artus, simul truncis arborum antefixa ora."(Annales, +lib. 1, sect. 61.) Mendoza falls nothing short of this celebrated +description of the Roman historian; + + "Pan etiam Arcadiâ dicat se judice victum." + +[29] Mendoza, Guerra de Granada, pp. 300-302. + +The Moorish insurrection of 1570 was attended with at least one good +result, in calling forth this historic masterpiece, the work of the +accomplished Diego Hurtado de Mendoza, accomplished alike as a statesman, +warrior, and historian. His "Guerra de Granada," confined as it is to a +barren fragment of Moorish history, displays such liberal sentiments, +(too liberal, indeed, to permit its publication till long after its +author's death,) profound reflection, and classic elegance of style, as +well entitled him to the appellation of the Spanish Sallust. + +[30] Pragmáticas del Reyno, fol. 6. + +[31] Pragmáticas del Reyno, fol. 7. + +[32] Bleda anxiously claims the credit of the act of expulsion for Fray +Thomas de Torquemada, of inquisitorial memory. (Corónica, p. 640.) That +eminent personage had, indeed, been dead some years; but this edict was so +obviously suggested by that against the Jews, that it may be considered as +the result of his principles, if not directly taught by him. Thus it is, +"the evil that men do lives after them." + +[33] The Castilian writers, especially the dramatic, have not been +insensible to the poetical situations afforded by the distresses of the +banished Moriscoes. Their sympathy for the exiles, however, is whimsically +enough contrasted by an orthodox anxiety to justify the conduct of their +own government. The reader may recollect a pertinent example in the story +of Sancho's Moorish friend, Ricote. Don Quixote, part. 2, cap. 54. + +[34] The _spirit of toleration_ professed by the Moors, indeed, was +made a principal argument against them in the archbishop of Valencia's +memorial to Philip III. The Mahometans would seem the better Christians of +the two. See Geddes, Miscellaneous Tracts, (London, 1702-6,) vol. i. p. +94. + +[35] Heeren seems willing to countenance the learned Pluquet in regarding +Islamism, in its ancient form, as one of the modifications of +Christianity; placing the principal difference between that and +Socinianism, for example, in the mere rites of circumcision and baptism. +(Essai sur l'Influence des Croisades, traduit par Villers, (Paris, 1808,) +p. 175, not.) "The Mussulmans," says Sir William Jones, "are a sort of +heterodox Christians, if Locke reasons justly, because they firmly believe +the immaculate conception, divine character, and miracles of the Messiah; +heterodox in denying vehemently his character of Son, and his equality, as +God, with the Father, of whose unity and attributes they entertain and +express the most awful ideas." See his Dissertation on the Gods of Greece, +Italy, and India; Works, (London, 1799,) vol. i. p. 279. + +[36] See the bishop of Orihuela's treatise, "De Bello Sacro," etc., cited +by the industrious Clemencin. (Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. +15.) The Moors and Jews, of course, stood no chance in this code; the +reverend father expresses an opinion, with which Bleda heartily coincides, +that the government would be perfectly justified in taking away the life +of every Moor in the kingdom, for their shameless infidelity. Ubi supra;-- +and Bleda, Corónica, p. 995. + +[37] The articles of the treaty are detailed at length by Marmol, Rebelion +de Moriscos, lib. 1, cap. 19. + +[38] Idem, ubi supra. + +[39] See the arguments of Ximenes, or of his enthusiastic biographer +Fléchier, for it is not always easy to discriminate between them. Hist. de +Ximenés, pp. 108, 109. + +[40] The duke of Medina Sidonia proposed to Ferdinand and Isabella to be +avenged on the Moors, in some way not explained, after their +disembarkation in Africa, on the ground that, the term of the royal safe- +conduct having elapsed, they might lawfully be treated as enemies. To this +proposal, which would have done honor to a college of Jesuits in the +sixteenth century, the sovereigns made a reply too creditable not to be +transcribed. "El Rei é la Réina. Fernando de Zafra, nuestro secretário. +Vimos vuestra letra, en que nos fecistes saber lo que el duque de +Medinasidónia tenia pensado que se podia facer contra los Moros de +Villaluenga después de desembarcados allende. Decide que le agradecemos y +tenemos en servício el buen deseo que tiene de nos servir: _pero porqué +nuestra, palabra y seguro real así se debe guardar á los infieles como á +los Oristianos_, y faciéndose lo que él dice pareceria cautela y engaño +armado sobre nuestro seguro para no le guardar, que en ninguna, manera se +haga eso, ni otra cosa de que pueda parecer que se quebranta nuestro +seguro. De Granada véinte y nueve de mayo de quiniéntos y un años.--Yo el +Rei.--Yo la Réina--Por mandado del Rei é del Réina, Miguel Perez Almazan." +Would that the suggestions of Isabella's own heart, instead of the clergy, +had always been the guide of her conduct in these matters! Mem. de la +Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 15, from the original in the archives of +the family of Medina Sidonia. + +[41] A memorial of the archbishop of Valencia to Philip III. affords an +example of this moral obliquity, that may make one laugh, or weep, +according to the temper of his philosophy. In this precious document he +says, "Your Majesty may, without any scruple of conscience, make slaves of +all the Moriscoes, and may put them into your own galleys or mines, or +sell them to strangers. And as to their children, they may be all sold at +good rates here in Spain; which will be so far from being a punishment, +that it will be a mercy to them; since by that means they will all become +Christians; which they would never have been, had they continued with +their parents. By the holy execution of which piece of justice, _a great +sum of money will flow into your Majesty's treasury_." (Geddes, +Miscellaneous Tracts, vol. i. p. 71.) "Il n'est point d'hostilité +excellente comme la Chrestienne," says old Montaigne; "nostre zele faict +merveilles, quand il va secondant nostre pente vers la haine, la cruanté, +l'ambition, l'avarice, la detraction, la rebellion. Nostre religion est +faicte pour extirper les vices; elle les couvre, les nourrit, les incite." +Essais, liv. 2, chap. 12. + + + + +CHAPTER VIII. + +COLUMBUS.--PROSECUTION OF DISCOVERY.--HIS TREATMENT BY THE COURT. + +1494-1503. + +Progress of Discovery.--Reaction of Public Feeling.--The Queen's +Confidence in Columbus.--He Discovers Terra Firma.--Isabella Sends Back +the Indian Slaves.--Complaints against Columbus.--Superseded in the +Government.--Vindication of the Sovereigns.--His Fourth and Last Voyage. + + +The reader will turn with satisfaction from the melancholy and mortifying +details of superstition, to the generous efforts, which the Spanish +government was making to enlarge the limits of science and dominion in the +west. "Amidst the storms and troubles of Italy, Spain was every day +stretching her wings over a wider sweep of empire, and extending the glory +of her name to the far Antipodes." Such is the swell of exultation with +which the enthusiastic Italian, Martyr, notices the brilliant progress of +discovery under his illustrious countryman Columbus. [1] The Spanish +sovereigns had never lost sight of the new domain, so unexpectedly opened +to them, as it were, from the depths of the ocean. The first accounts +transmitted by the great navigator and his companions, on his second +voyage, while their imaginations were warm with the beauty and novelty of +the scenes which met their eyes in the New World, served to keep alive the +tone of excitement, which their unexpected successes had kindled in the +nation. [2] The various specimens sent home in the return ships, of the +products of these unknown regions, confirmed the agreeable belief that +they formed part of the great Asiatic continent, which had so long excited +the cupidity of Europeans. The Spanish court, sharing in the general +enthusiasm, endeavored to promote the spirit of discovery and +colonization, by forwarding the requisite supplies, and complying promptly +with the most minute suggestions of Columbus. But, in less than two years +from the commencement of his second voyage, the face of things experienced +a melancholy change. Accounts were received at home of the most alarming +discontent and disaffection in the colony; while the actual returns from +these vaunted regions were so scanty, as to bear no proportion to the +expenses of the expedition. + +This unfortunate result was in a great measure imputable to the misconduct +of the colonists themselves. Most of them were adventurers, who had +embarked with no other expectation than that of getting together a fortune +as speedily as possible in the golden Indies. They were without +subordination, patience, industry, or any of the regular habits demanded +for success in such an enterprise. As soon as they had launched from their +native shore, they seemed to feel themselves released from the constraints +of all law. They harbored jealousy and distrust of the admiral as a +foreigner. The cavaliers and hidalgos, of whom there were too many in the +expedition, contemned him as an upstart, whom it was derogatory to obey. +From the first moment of their landing in Hispaniola, they indulged the +most wanton license in regard to the unoffending natives, who, in the +simplicity of their hearts, had received the white men as messengers from +Heaven. Their outrages, however, soon provoked a general resistance, which +led to such a war of extermination, that, in less than four years after +the Spaniards had set foot on the island, one-third of its population, +amounting, probably, to several hundred thousands, were sacrificed! Such +were the melancholy auspices, under which the intercourse was opened +between the civilized white man and the simple natives of the western +world. [3] + +These excesses, and a total neglect of agriculture,--for none would +condescend to turn up the earth for any other object than the gold they +could find in it,--at length occasioned an alarming scarcity of +provisions; while the poor Indians neglected their usual husbandry, being +willing to starve themselves, so that they could starve out their +oppressors. [4] In order to avoid the famine which menaced his little +colony, Columbus was obliged to resort to coercive measures, shortening +the allowance of food, and compelling all to work, without distinction of +rank. These unpalatable regulations soon bred general discontent. The +high-mettled hidalgos, especially, complained loudly of the indignity of +such mechanical drudgery, while Father Boil and his brethren were equally +outraged by the diminution of their regular rations. [5] + +The Spanish sovereigns were now daily assailed with complaints of the mal- +administration of Columbus, and of his impolitic and unjust severities to +both Spaniards and natives. They lent, however, an unwilling ear to these +vague accusations; they fully appreciated the difficulties of his +situation; and, although they sent out an agent to inquire into the nature +of the troubles which threatened the existence of the colony, they were +careful to select an individual who they thought would be most grateful to +the admiral; and when the latter in the following year, 1496, returned to +Spain, they received him with the most ample acknowledgments of regard. +"Come to us," they said, in a kind letter of congratulation, addressed to +him soon after his arrival, "when you can do it without inconvenience to +yourself, for you have endured too many vexations already." [6] + +The admiral brought with him, as before, such samples of the productions +of the western hemisphere, as would strike the public eye, and keep alive +the feeling of curiosity. On his journey through Andalusia, he passed some +days under the hospitable roof of the good curate, Bernaldez, who dwells +with much satisfaction on the remarkable appearance of the Indian chiefs, +following in the admiral's train, gorgeously decorated with golden collars +and coronets and various barbaric ornaments. Among these he particularly +notices certain "belts and masks of cotton and of wood, with figures of +the Devil embroidered and carved thereon, sometimes in his own proper +likeness, and at others in that _of a cat or an owl_. There is much +reason," he infers, "to believe that he appears to the islanders in this +guise, and that they are all idolaters, having Satan for their lord!" [7] + +But neither the attractions of the spectacle, nor the glowing +representations of Columbus, who fancied he had discovered in the mines of +Hispaniola the golden quarries of Ophir, from which King Solomon had +enriched the temple of Jerusalem, could rekindle the dormant enthusiasm of +the nation. The novelty of the thing had passed. They heard a different +tale, moreover, from the other voyagers, whose wan and sallow visages +provoked the bitter jest, that they had returned with more gold in their +faces than in their pockets. In short, the skepticism of the public seemed +now quite in proportion to its former overweening confidence; and the +returns were so meagre, says Bernaldez, "that it was very generally +believed there was little or no gold in the island." [8] + +Isabella was far from participating in this unreasonable distrust. She had +espoused the theory of Columbus, when others looked coldly or +contemptuously on it. [9] She firmly relied on his repeated assurances, +that the track of discovery would lead to other and more important +regions. She formed a higher estimate, moreover, of the value of the new +acquisitions than any founded on the actual proceeds in gold and silver; +keeping ever in view, as her letters and instructions abundantly show, the +glorious purpose of introducing the blessings of Christian civilization +among the heathen. [10] She entertained a deep sense of the merits of +Columbus, to whose serious and elevated character her own bore much +resemblance; although the enthusiasm, which distinguished each, was +naturally tempered in hers with somewhat more of benignity and discretion. + +But although the queen was willing to give the most effectual support to +his great enterprise, the situation of the country was such as made delay +in its immediate prosecution unavoidable. Large expense was necessarily +incurred for the actual maintenance of the colony; [11] the exchequer was +liberally drained, moreover, by the Italian war, as well as by the profuse +magnificence with which the nuptials of the royal family were now +celebrating. It was, indeed, in the midst of the courtly revelries +attending the marriage of Prince John, that the admiral presented himself +before the sovereigns at Burgos, after his second voyage. Such was the low +condition of the treasury from these causes, that Isabella was obliged to +defray the cost of an outfit to the colony, at this time, from funds +originally destined for the marriage of her daughter Isabella with the +king of Portugal. [12] + +This unwelcome delay, however, was softened to Columbus by the +distinguished marks which he daily received of the royal favor; and +various ordinances were passed, confirming and enlarging his great powers +and privileges in the most ample manner, to a greater extent, indeed, than +his modesty, or his prudence, would allow him to accept. [13] The language +in which these princely gratuities were conferred, rendered them doubly +grateful to his noble heart, containing, as they did, the most emphatic +acknowledgments of his "many good, loyal, distinguished, and continual +services," and thus testifying the unabated confidence of his sovereigns +in his integrity and prudence. [14] + +Among the impediments to the immediate completion of the arrangements for +the admiral's departure on his third voyage, may be also noticed the +hostility of Bishop Fonseca, who, at this period, had the control of the +Indian department; a man of an irritable, and, as it would seem, most +unforgiving temper, who, from some causes of disgust which he had +conceived with Columbus previous to his second voyage, lost no opportunity +of annoying and thwarting him, for which his official station +unfortunately afforded him too many facilities. [15] + +From these various circumstances the admiral's fleet was not ready before +the beginning of 1498. Even then further embarrassment occurred in manning +it, as few were found willing to embark in a service which had fallen into +such general discredit. This led to the ruinous expedient of substituting +convicts, whose regular punishments were commuted into transportation, for +a limited period, to the Indies. No measure could possibly have been +devised more effectual for the ruin of the infant settlement. The seeds of +corruption, which had been so long festering in the Old World, soon shot +up into a plentiful harvest in the New, and Columbus, who suggested the +measure, was the first to reap the fruits of it. + +At length, all being in readiness, the admiral embarked on board his +little squadron, consisting of six vessels, whose complement of men, +notwithstanding every exertion, was still deficient, and took his +departure from the port of St. Lucar, May 30th, 1498. He steered in a more +southerly direction than on his preceding voyages, and on the first of +August succeeded in reaching _terra firma_; thus entitling himself to +the glory of being the first to set foot on the great southern continent, +to which he had before opened the way. [16] + +It is not necessary to pursue the track of the illustrious voyager, whose +career, forming the most brilliant episode to the history of the present +reign, has been so recently traced by a hand which few will care to +follow. It will suffice briefly to notice his personal relations with the +Spanish government, and the principles on which the colonial +administration was conducted. + +On his arrival at Hispaniola, Columbus found the affairs of the colony in +the most deplorable confusion. An insurrection had been raised by the arts +of a few factious individuals against his brother Bartholomew, to whom he +had intrusted the government during his absence. In this desperate +rebellion all the interests of the community were neglected. The mines, +which were just beginning to yield a golden harvest, remained unwrought. +The unfortunate natives were subjected to the most inhuman oppression. +There was no law but that of the strongest. Columbus, on his arrival, in +vain endeavored to restore order. The very crews he brought with him, who +had been unfortunately reprieved from the gibbet in their own country, +served to swell the mass of mutiny. The admiral exhausted art, +negotiation, entreaty, force, and succeeded at length in patching up a +specious reconciliation by such concessions as essentially impaired his +own authority. Among these was the grant of large tracts of land to the +rebels, with permission to the proprietor to employ an allotted number of +the natives in its cultivation. This was the origin of the celebrated +system of repartimientos, which subsequently led to the foulest abuses +that ever disgraced humanity. [17] + +Nearly a year elapsed after the admiral's return to Hispaniola, before he +succeeded in allaying these intestine feuds. In the mean while, rumors +were every day reaching Spain of the distractions of the colony, +accompanied with most injurious imputations on the conduct of Columbus and +his brother, who were loudly accused of oppressing both Spaniards and +Indians, and of sacrificing the public interests, in the most unscrupulous +manner, to their own. These complaints were rung in the very ears of the +sovereigns by numbers of the disaffected colonists, who had returned to +Spain, and who surrounded the king, as he rode out on horseback, clamoring +loudly for the discharge of the arrears, of which they said the admiral +had defrauded them. [18] + +There were not wanting, even, persons of high consideration at the court, +to give credence and circulation to these calumnies. The recent discovery +of the pearl fisheries of Paria, as well as of more prolific veins of the +precious metals in Hispaniola, and the prospect of an indefinite extent of +unexplored country, opened by the late voyage of Columbus, made the +viceroyalty of the New World a tempting bait for the avarice and ambition +of the most potent grandee. They artfully endeavored, therefore, to +undermine the admiral's credit with the sovereigns, by raising in their +minds suspicions of his integrity, founded not merely on vague reports, +but on letters received from the colony, charging him with disloyalty, +with appropriating to his own use the revenues of the island, and with the +design of erecting an independent government for himself. [19] + +Whatever weight these absurd charges may have had with Ferdinand, they had +no power to shake the queen's confidence in Columbus, or lead her to +suspect his loyalty for a moment. But the long-continued distractions of +the colony made her feel a natural distrust of his capacity to govern it, +whether from the jealousy entertained of him as a foreigner, or from some +inherent deficiency in his own character. These doubts were mingled, it is +true, with sterner feelings towards the admiral, on the arrival, at this +juncture, of several of the rebels with the Indian slaves assigned to them +by his orders. [20] + +It was the received opinion among good Catholics of that period, that +heathen and barbarous nations were placed by the circumstance of their +infidelity without the pale both of spiritual and civil rights. Their +souls were doomed to eternal perdition. Their bodies were the property of +the Christian nation who should occupy their soil. [21] Such, in brief, +were the profession and the practice of the most enlightened Europeans of +the fifteenth century; and such the deplorable maxims which regulated the +intercourse of the Spanish and Portuguese navigators with the uncivilized +natives of the western world. [22] Columbus, agreeably to these views, +had, very soon after the occupation of Hispaniola, recommended a regular +exchange of slaves for the commodities required for the support of the +colony; representing, moreover, that in this way their conversion would be +more surely effected,--an object, it must be admitted, which he seems to +have ever had most earnestly at heart. Isabella, however, entertained +views on this matter far more liberal than those of her age. She had been +deeply interested by the accounts she had received from the admiral +himself of the gentle, unoffending character of the islanders; and she +revolted at the idea of consigning them to the horrors of slavery, without +even an effort for their conversion. She hesitated, therefore, to sanction +his proposal; and when a number of Indian captives were advertised to be +sold in the markets of Andalusia, she commanded the sale to be suspended, +till the opinion of a counsel of theologians and doctors, learned in such +matters, could be obtained, as to its conscientious lawfulness. She +yielded still further to the benevolent impulses of her nature, causing +holy men to be instructed as far as possible in the Indian languages, and +sent out as missionaries for the conversion of the natives. [23] Some of +them, as Father Boil and his brethren, seem, indeed, to have been more +concerned for the welfare of their own bodies, than for the souls of their +benighted flock. But others, imbued with a better spirit, wrought in the +good work with disinterested zeal, and, if we may credit their accounts, +with some efficacy. [24] + +In the same beneficent spirit, the royal letters and ordinances urged over +and over again the paramount obligation of the religious instruction of +the natives, and of observing the utmost gentleness and humanity in all +dealings with them. When, therefore, the queen learned the arrival of two +vessels from the Indies, with three hundred slaves on board, which the +admiral had granted to the mutineers, she could not repress her +indignation, but impatiently asked, "By what authority does Columbus +venture thus to dispose of my subjects?" She instantly caused proclamation +to be made in the southern provinces, that all who had Indian slaves in +their possession, granted by the admiral, should forthwith provide for +their return to their own country; while the few, still held by the crown, +were to be restored to freedom in like manner. [25] + +After a long and visible reluctance, the queen acquiesced in sending out a +commissioner to investigate the affairs of the colony. The person +appointed to this delicate trust was Don Francisco de Bobadilla, a poor +knight of Calatrava. He was invested with supreme powers of civil and +criminal jurisdiction. He was to bring to trial and pass sentence on all +such as had conspired against the authority of Columbus. He was authorized +to take possession of the fortresses, vessels, public stores, and property +of every description, to dispose of all offices, and to command whatever +persons he might deem expedient for the tranquillity of the island, +without distinction of rank, to return to Spain, and present themselves +before the sovereigns. Such, in brief, was the sum of the extraordinary +powers intrusted to Bobadilla. [26] + +It is impossible now to determine what motives could have led to the +selection of so incompetent an agent, for an office of such high +responsibility. He seems to have been a weak and arrogant man, swelled up +with immeasurable insolence by the brief authority thus undeservedly +bestowed on him. From the very first, he regarded Columbus in the light of +a convicted criminal, on whom it was his business to execute the sentence +of the law. Accordingly, on his arrival at the island, after an +ostentatious parade of his credentials, he commanded the admiral to appear +before him, and, without affecting the forms of a legal inquiry, at once +caused him to be manacled, and thrown into prison. Columbus submitted +without the least show of resistance, displaying in this sad reverse that +magnanimity of soul, which would have touched the heart of a generous +adversary. Bobadilla, however, discovered no such sensibility; and, after +raking together all the foul or frivolous calumnies, which hatred or the +hope of favor could extort, he caused the whole loathsome mass of +accusation to be sent back to Spain with the admiral, whom he commanded to +be kept strictly in irons during the passage; "afraid," says Ferdinand +Columbus bitterly, "lest he might by any chance swim back again to the +island." [27] + +This excess of malice served, as usual, however, to defeat itself. So +enormous an outrage shocked the minds of those most prejudiced against +Columbus. All seemed to feel it as a national dishonor, that such +indignities should be heaped on the man, who, whatever might be his +indiscretions, had done so much for Spain, and for the whole civilized +world; a man, who, in the honest language of an old writer, "had he lived +in the days of ancient Greece or Rome, would have had statues raised, and +temples and divine honors dedicated to him, as to a divinity!" [28] + +None partook of the general indignation more strongly than Ferdinand and +Isabella, who, in addition to their personal feelings of disgust at so +gross an act, readily comprehended the whole weight of obloquy, which its +perpetration must necessarily attach to them. They sent to Cadiz without +an instant's delay, and commanded the admiral to be released from his +ignominious fetters. They wrote to him in the most benignant terms, +expressing their sincere regret for the unworthy usage which he had +experienced, and requesting him to appear before them as speedily as +possible, at Granada, where the court was then staying. At the same time, +they furnished him a thousand ducats for his expenses, and a handsome +retinue to escort him on his journey. + +Columbus, revived by these assurances of the kind dispositions of his +sovereigns, proceeded without delay to Granada, which he reached on the +17th of December. Immediately on his arrival he obtained an audience. The +queen could not repress her tears at the sight of the man, whose +illustrious services had met with such ungenerous requital, as it were, at +her own hands. She endeavored to cheer his wounded spirit with the most +earnest assurances of her sympathy and sorrow for his misfortunes. +Columbus, from the first moment of his disgrace, had relied on the good +faith and kindness of Isabella; for, as an ancient Castilian writer +remarks, "she had ever favored him beyond the king her husband, protecting +his interests, and showing him especial kindness and good-will." When he +beheld the emotion of his royal mistress, and listened to her consolatory +language, it was too much for his loyal and generous heart; and, throwing +himself on his knees, he gave vent to his feelings, and sobbed aloud. The +sovereigns endeavored to soothe and tranquillize his mind, and, after +testifying their deep sense of his injuries, promised him, that impartial +justice should be done his enemies, and that he should be reinstated in +his emoluments and honors. [29] + +Much censure has attached to the Spanish government for its share in this +unfortunate transaction; both in the appointment of so unsuitable an agent +as Bobadilla, and the delegation of such broad and indefinite powers. With +regard to the first, it is now too late, as has already been remarked, to +ascertain on what grounds such a selection could have been made. There is +no evidence of his being indebted for his promotion to intrigue or any +undue influence. Indeed, according to the testimony of one of his +contemporaries, he was reputed "an extremely honest and religious man," +and the good bishop Las Casas expressly declares that "no imputation of +dishonesty or avarice had ever rested on his character." [30] It was an +error of judgment; a grave one, indeed, and must pass for as much as it is +worth. + +But in regard to the second charge, of delegating unwarrantable powers, it +should be remembered, that the grievances of the colony were represented +as of a most pressing nature, demanding a prompt and peremptory remedy; +that a more limited and partial authority, dependent for its exercise on +instructions from the government at home, might be attended with ruinous +delays; that this authority must necessarily be paramount to that of +Columbus, who was a party implicated, and that, although unlimited +jurisdiction was given over all offences committed against him, yet +neither he nor his friends were to be molested in any other way than by +temporary suspension from office, and a return to their own country, where +the merits of their case might be submitted to the sovereigns themselves. + +This view of the matter, indeed, is perfectly conformable to that of +Ferdinand Columbus, whose solicitude, so apparent in every page, for his +father's reputation, must have effectually counterbalanced any repugnance +he may have felt at impugning the conduct of his sovereigns. "The only +ground of complaint," he remarks, in summing up his narrative of the +transaction, "which I can bring against their Catholic Highnesses is, the +unfitness of the agent whom they employed, equally malicious and ignorant. +Had they sent out a suitable person, the admiral would have been highly +gratified; since he had more than once requested the appointment of some +one with full powers of jurisdiction in an affair, where he felt some +natural delicacy in moving, in consequence of his own brother having been +originally involved in it." And, as to the vast magnitude of the powers +intrusted to Bobadilla, he adds," It can scarcely be wondered at, +considering the manifold complaints against the admiral made to their +Highnesses." [31] + +Although the king and queen determined without hesitation on the complete +restoration of the admiral's honors, they thought it better to defer his +reappointment to the government of the colony, until the present +disturbances should be settled, and he might return there with personal +safety and advantage. In the mean time, they resolved to send out a +competent individual, and to support him with such a force as should +overawe faction, and enable him to place the tranquillity of the island on +a permanent basis. + +The person selected was Don Nicolas de Ovando, comendador of Lares, of the +military order of Alcantara. He was a man of acknowledged prudence and +sagacity, temperate in his habits, and plausible and politic in his +address. It is sufficient evidence of his standing at court, that he had +been one of the ten youths selected to be educated in the palace as +companions for the prince of the Asturias. He was furnished with a fleet +of two and thirty sail, carrying twenty-five hundred persons, many of them +of the best families in the kingdom, with every variety of article for the +nourishment and permanent prosperity of the colony; and the general +equipment was in a style of expense and magnificence, such as had never +before been lavished on any armada destined for the western waters. [32] + +The new governor was instructed immediately on his arrival to send +Bobadilla home for trial. Under his lax administration, abuses of every +kind had multiplied to an alarming extent, and the poor natives, in +particular, were rapidly wasting away under the new and most inhuman +arrangement of the _repartimientos_, which he established. Isabella +now declared the Indians free; and emphatically enjoined on the +authorities of Hispaniola to respect them as true and faithful vassals of +the crown. Ovando was especially to ascertain the amount of losses +sustained by Columbus and his brothers, to provide for their full +indemnification, and to secure the unmolested enjoyment in future of all +their lawful rights and pecuniary perquisites. [33] + +Fortified with the most ample instructions in regard to these and other +details of his administration, the governor embarked on board his +magnificent flotilla, and crossed the bar of St. Lucar, February 15th, +1502. A furious tempest dispersed the fleet, before it had been out a +week, and a report reached Spain that it had entirely perished. The +sovereigns, overwhelmed with sorrow at this fresh disaster, which +consigned so many of their best and bravest to a watery grave, shut +themselves up in their palace for several days. Fortunately, the report +proved ill-founded. The fleet rode out the storm in safety, one vessel +only having perished, and the remainder reached in due time its place of +destination. [34] + +The Spanish government has been roundly taxed with injustice and +ingratitude for its delay in restoring Columbus to the full possession of +his colonial authority; and that too by writers generally distinguished +for candor and impartiality. No such animadversion, however, as far as I +am aware, is countenanced by contemporary historians; and it appears to be +wholly undeserved. Independent of the obvious inexpediency of returning +him immediately to the theatre of disaffection, before the embers of +ancient animosity had had time to cool, there were several features in his +character, which make it doubtful whether he were the most competent +person, in any event, for an emergency demanding at once the greatest +coolness, consummate address, and acknowledged personal authority. His +sublime enthusiasm, which carried him victorious over every obstacle, +involved him also in numerous embarrassments, which men of more phlegmatic +temperament would have escaped. It led him to count too readily on a +similar spirit in others,--and to be disappointed. It gave an exaggerated +coloring to his views and descriptions, that inevitably led to a reaction +in the minds of such as embarked their all on the splendid dreams of a +fairy land, which they were never to realize. [35] Hence a fruitful source +of discontent and disaffection in his followers. It led him, in his +eagerness for the achievement of his great enterprises, to be less +scrupulous and politic as to the means, than a less ardent spirit would +have been. His pertinacious adherence to the scheme of Indian slavery, and +hhis impolitic regulation compelling the labor of the hidalgos, are +pertinent examples of this. [36] He was, moreover, a foreigner, without +rank, fortune, or powerful friends; and his high and sudden elevation +naturally raised him up a thousand enemies among a proud, punctilious, and +intensely national people. Under these multiplied embarrassments, +resulting from peculiarities of character and situation, the sovereigns +might well be excused for not intrusting Columbus, at this delicate +crisis, with disentangling the meshes of intrigue and faction, in which +the affairs of the colony were so unhappily involved. + +I trust these remarks will not be construed into an insensibility to the +merits and exalted services of Columbus. "A world," to borrow the words, +though not the application, of the Greek historian, "is his monument." His +virtues shine With too bright a lustre to be dimmed by a few natural +blemishes; but it becomes necessary to notice these, to vindicate the +Spanish government from the imputation of perfidy and ingratitude, where +it has been most freely urged, and apparently with the least foundation. + +It is more difficult to excuse the paltry equipment with which the admiral +was suffered to undertake his fourth and last voyage. The object proposed +by this expedition was the discovery of a passage to the great Indian +Ocean, which, he inferred sagaciously enough from his premises, though, as +it turned out, to the great inconvenience of the commercial world, most +erroneously, must open somewhere between Cuba and the coast of Paria. Four +caravels, only, were furnished for the expedition, the largest of which +did not exceed seventy tons' burden; a force forming a striking contrast +to the magnificent armada lately intrusted to Ovando, and altogether too +insignificant to be vindicated on the ground of the different objects +proposed by the two expeditions. [37] + +Columbus, oppressed with growing infirmities, and a consciousness, +perhaps, of the decline of popular favor, manifested unusual despondency +previously to his embarkation. He talked even of resigning the task of +further discovery to his brother Bartholomew. "I have established," said +he, "all that I proposed,--the existence of land in the west. I have +opened the gate, and others may enter at their pleasure; as indeed they +do, arrogating to themselves the title of discoverers, to which they can +have little claim, following as they do in my track." He little thought +the ingratitude of mankind would sanction the claims of these adventurers +so far as to confer the name of one of them on that world, which his +genius had revealed. [38] + +The great inclination, however, which the admiral had to serve the +Catholic sovereigns, and especially the most serene queen, says Ferdinand +Columbus, induced him to lay aside his scruples, and encounter the perils +and fatigues of another voyage. A few weeks before his departure, he +received a gracious letter from Ferdinand and Isabella, the last ever +addressed to him by his royal mistress, assuring him of their purpose to +maintain inviolate all their engagements with him, and to perpetuate the +inheritance of his honors in his family. [39] Comforted and cheered by +assurances, the veteran navigator, quitting the port of Cadiz, on the 9th +of March, 1502, once more spread his sails for those golden regions, which +he had approached so near, but was destined never to reach. + +It will not be necessary to pursue his course further than to notice a +single occurrence of most extraordinary nature. The admiral had received +instructions not to touch at Hispaniola on his outward voyage. The leaky +condition of one of his ships, however, and the signs of an approaching +storm, induced him to seek a temporary refuge there; at the same time, he +counselled Ovando to delay for a few days the departure of the fleet, then +riding in the harbor, which was destined to carry Bobadilla and the rebels +with their ill-gotten treasures back to Spain. The churlish governor, +however, not only refused Columbus admittance, but gave orders for the +instant departure of the vessels. The apprehensions of the experienced +mariner were fully justified by the event. Scarcely had the Spanish fleet +quitted its moorings, before one of those tremendous hurricanes came on, +which so often desolate these tropical regions, sweeping down everything +before it, and fell with such violence on the little navy, that out of +eighteen ships, of which it was composed, not more than three or four +escaped. The rest all foundered, including those which contained +Bobadilla, and the late enemies of Columbus. Two hundred thousand +_castellanos_ of gold, half of which belonged to the government, went +to the bottom with them. The only one of the fleet which made its way back +to Spain was a crazy, weather-beaten bark, which contained the admiral's +property, amounting to four thousand ounces of gold. To complete these +curious coincidences, Columbus with his little squadron rode out the storm +in safety under the lee of the island, where he had prudently taken +shelter, on being so rudely repulsed from the port. This even-handed +retribution of justice, so uncommon in human affairs, led many to discern +the immediate interposition of Providence. Others, in a less Christian +temper, referred it all to the necromancy of the admiral. [40] + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] "Inter has Italiae procellas magis indies ac magis alas protendit +Hispania, imperium auget, gloriam nomenque suum ad Antipodes porriget." +Peter Martyr, Opus Epist., epist. 146. + +[2] See, among others, a letter of Dr. Chanca, who accompanied Columbus on +his second voyage. It is addressed to the authorities of Seville. After +noticing the evidences of gold in Hispaniola, he says; "Ansi que de cierto +los Reyes nuestros Señores desde agora se pueden tener por los mas +prosperos e mas ricos Principes del mundo, porque tal cosa hasta agora no +se ha visto ni leido de ningnno en el mundo, porque verdaderamente a otro +camino que los navios vuelvan puedan llevar tanta cantidad de oro que se +pueden maravillar cualesquiera que lo supieren." In another part of the +letter, the Doctor is equally sanguine in regard to the fruitfulness of +the soil and climate. Letra de Dr. Chanca, apud Navarrete, Coleccion de +Viages, tom. i. pp. 198-224. + +[3] Fernando Colon, Hist. de Almirante, cap. 60, 62.--Muñoz, Hist. del +Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 5, sec. 25.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. +2, cap. 9.--Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., lib. 1, cap. 9. + +[4] The Indians had some grounds for relying on the efficacy of +starvation, if, as Las Casas gravely asserts, "one Spaniard consumed in a +single day as much as would suffice three families!" Llorente, Oeuvres de +Don Barthélemi de las Casas, precedées de sa Vie, (Paris, 1822,) tom. i. +p. 11. + +[5] Martyr, De Rebus Oceanicis, dec. 1, lib. 4.--Goinara, Hist. de las +Indias, cap. 20, tom. ii.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 2, +cap. 12. + +[6] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., no. 101.-- +Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 64.--Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo- +Mundo, lib. 5, sec. 31. + +[7] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 131.--Herrera expresses the same +charitable opinion. "Muy claramente se conocio que el demonio estava, +apoderado de aquella gente, y la traia ciega y engañada, hablandoles, y +mostrandoles en diversas figuras." Indias Occidentales, lib. 3, cap. 4. + +[8] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 131.--Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo- +Mundo, lib. 6, sec. 1. + +[9] Columbus, in his letter to Prince John's nurse, dated 1500, makes the +following ample acknowledgment of the queen's early protection of him. "En +todos hobo incredulidad, y a la Reina mi Señora dio Nuestro Señor el +espiritu de inteligencia y esfuerzo grande, y la hizo de todo heredera +como a cara y muy amada hija." "Su Alteza lo aprobaba al contrario, y lo +sostuvo fasta que pudo." Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i. p. 266. + +[10] See the letters to Columbus, dated May 14th, 1493, August, 1494, apud +Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii. pp. 66, 154, et mult. al. + +[11] The salaries alone, annually disbursed by the crown to persons +resident in the colony, amounted to six million maravedies. Muñoz, Hist. +del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 5, sec. 33. + +[12] Idem, lib. 6, sec. 2.--Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 64. +--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 3, cap. 1. + +[13] Such, for example, was the grant of an immense tract of land in +Hispaniola, with the title of count or duke, as the admiral might prefer. +Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 6, sec. 17. + +[14] The instrument establishing the _mayorazgo_, or perpetual entail +of Columbus's estates, contains an injunction, that "his heirs shall never +use any other signature than that of 'the Admiral, _el Almirante_, +whatever other titles and honors may belong to them." That title indicated +his peculiar achievements, and it was an honest pride which led him by +this simple expedient to perpetuate the remembrance of them in his +posterity. See the original document, apud Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, +tom. ii. pp. 221-235. + +[15] Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 6, sec. 20.--Fernando Colon, Hist. +del Almirante, cap. 64.--Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, año 1496. + +[16] Peter Martyr, De Rebus Oceanicis, dec. 1, lib. e.--Navarrete, +Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., nos. 116, 120.--Tercer Viage de +Colon, apud Navarrete, tom. i. p. 245.--Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., lib. 1, +cap. 10, ll.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 3, cap. 10, ll.-- +Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 6, sec. 19. + +[17] Gomara, Hist. de las Indias, cap. 20.--Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., +lib. 1, cap. 10, ll.--Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. 7.-- +Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 73-82.--Peter Martyr, De Rebus +Oceanicis, dec. 1, lib. 5.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 3, +cap. 16.--Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 6, sec. 40-42. + +[18] Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. 7.--Peter Martyr, De Rebus +Oceanicis, dec. 1, lib. 7.--Gomara, Hist. de las Indias, cap. 23.-- +Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., cap. 11. + +Ferdinand Columbus mentions that he and his brother, who were then pages +to the queen, could not stir out into the courtyard of the Alhambra, +without being followed by fifty of these vagabonds, who insulted them in +the grossest manner, "as the sons of the adventurer, who had led so many +brave Spanish hidalgos to seek their graves in the land of vanity and +delusion which he had found out." Hist. del Almirante, cap. 85. + +[19] Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., lib. 1, cap. 12.--National feeling +operated, no doubt, as well as avarice to sharpen the tooth of slander +against the admiral. "Aegre multi patiuntur," says Columbus's countryman, +with honest warmth, "peregrinum hominem, et quidem e nostrâ Italia ortum, +tantum honoris ac gloriae consequutum, ut non tantum Hispanicae gentis, +sed et cujusvis alterius homines superaverit." Benzoni, lib. 1, cap. 5. + +[20] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 4, cap. 7, 10, and more especially +lib. 6, cap. 13.--Las Casas, Oeuvres, ed. de Llorente, tom. i. p. 306. + +[21] "La qualité de Catholique Romain," says the philosophic Villers, +"avait tout-à-fait remplacé celle d'homme, et même de Chrétien. Qui +n'était pas Catholique Romain, n'était pas homme, était moins qu'homme; et +eût-il été un souverain, c'était une bonne action que de lui ôter la vie." +(Essai sur la Réformation, p. 56. ed. 1820.) Las Casas rests the title of +the Spanish crown to its American possessions on the original papal grant, +made on condition of converting the natives to Christianity. The pope, as +vicar of Jesns Christ, possesses plenary authority over all men for the +safety of their souls. He might, therefore, in furtherance of this, confer +on the Spanish sovereigns _imperial supremacy_ over all lands discovered +by them,--not, however, to the prejudice of authorities already existing +there, and over such nations only as voluntarily embraced Christianity. +Such is the sum of his thirty propositions, submitted to the council of +the Indies for the inspection of Charles V. (Oeuvres, ed. De Llorente, +tom. i. pp. 286-311.) One may see in these arbitrary and whimsical +limitations, the good bishop's desire to reconcile what reason told him +were the natural rights of man, with what faith prescribed as the +legitimate prerogative of the pope. Few Roman Catholics at the present day +will be found sturdy enough to maintain this lofty prerogative, however +carefully limited. Still fewer in the sixteenth century would have +challenged it. Indeed, it is but just to Las Casas, to admit, that the +general scope of his arguments, here and elsewhere, is very far in advance +of his age. + +[22] A Spanish casuist founds the right of his nation to enslave the +Indians, among other things, on their smoking tobacco, and not trimming +their beards _à l'Espagnole_. At least, this is Montesquieu's +interpretation of it. (Esprit des Loix, lib. 15, chap. 3.) The doctors of +the Inquisition could hardly have found a better reason. + +[23] 23 Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 5, sec. 34.--Navarrete, +Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., no. 92.--Herrera, Indias +Occidentales, lib. 3, cap. 4. + +[24] "Among other things that the holy fathers carried out," says Robles, +"was a little organ and several bells, which greatly delighted the simple +people, so that from one to two thousand persons were baptized every day." +(Vida de Ximenez, p. 120.) + +Ferdinand Columbus remarks with some _naïveté_, that "the Indians were so +obedient from their fear of the admiral, and at the same time so desirous +to oblige him, that they voluntarily became Christians!" Hist. del +Almirante, cap. 84. + +[25] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 4, cap. 7.--Navarrete, Coleccion +de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., no. 134. + +Las Casas observes, that "so great was the queen's indignation at the +admiral's misconduct in this particular, that nothing but the +consideration of his great public services saved him from immediate +disgrace." Oeuvres, ed. de Llorente, tom. i. p. 306. + +[26] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., nos. 127-130. +The original commission to Bobadilla was dated March 21st, and May 21st, +1499; the execution of it, however, was delayed until July, 1500, in the +hope, doubtless, of obtaining such tidings from Hispaniola as should +obviate the necessity of a measure so prejudicial to the admiral. + +[27] Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 86.--Garibay, Compendio, +tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. 7.--Peter Martyr, De Rebus Oceanicis, dec. 1, lib. +7.--Gomara, Hist. de las Indias, cap. 23.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, +lib. 4, cap. 10.--Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., lib. 1, cap. 12. + +[28] Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., lib. 1, cap. 12.--Herrera, Indias +Occidentales, lib. 6, cap. 15. + +Ferdinand Columbus tells us, that his father kept the fetters in which he +was brought home, hanging up in an apartment of his house, as a perpetual +memorial of national ingratitude, and, when he died, ordered them to be +buried in the same grave with himself. Hist. del Almirante, cap. 86. + +[29] Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. 7.--Peter Martyr, De Rebus +Oceanicis, dec. 1, lib. 7.--Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 86, +87.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. I, lib. 4, cap. 8-10.--Benzoni, +Novi Orbis Hist., lib. 1, cap. 12. + +[30] Oviedo, Hist. Gen. de las Ind., p. 1, lib. 3, cap. 6.--Las Casas, +lib. 2, cap. 6, apud Navarrete, tom. i., introd., p. 99. + +[31] Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 86. + +[32] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 4, cap. 11.--Fernando +Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 87.--Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., lib. 1, +cap. 12.--Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. p. 385. + +[33] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 4, cap. 11-13.--Navarrete, +Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., nos. 138,144.--Fernando Colon, +Hist. del Almirante, cap. 87. + +[34] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 5, cap. 1. + +[35] The high devotional feeling of Columbus led him to trace out +allusions in Scripture to the various circumstances and scenes of his +adventurous life. Thus he believed his great discovery announced in the +Apocalypse, and in Isaiah; he identified, as I have before stated, the +mines of Hispaniola with those which furnished Solomon with materials for +his temple; he fancied that he had determined the actual locality of the +garden of Eden in the newly discovered region of Paria. But his greatest +extravagance was his project of a crusade for the recovery of the Holy +Sepulchre. This he cherished from the first hour of his discovery, +pressing it in the most urgent manner on the sovereigns, and making actual +provision for it in his testament. This was a flight, however, beyond the +spirit even of this romantic age, and probably received as little serious +attention from the queen, as from her more cool and calculating husband. +Peter Martyr, De Rebus Oceanicis, dec. 1, lib. 6.--Tercer, Viage de Colon, +apud Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i. p. 259.--tom. ii., Doc. +Dipl., no. 140.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 6, cap. 15. + +[36] Another example was the injudicious punishment of delinquents by +diminishing their regular allowance of food, a measure so obnoxious as to +call for the interference of the sovereigns, who prohibited it altogether. +(Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., 97.) Herrera, who +must be admitted to have been in no degree insensible to the merits of +Columbus, closes his account of the various accusations urged against him +and his brothers, with the remark, that, "with every allowance for +calumny, they must be confessed not to have governed the Castilians with +the moderation that they ought to have done." Indias Occidentales, lib. 4, +cap. 9. + +[37] Garibay, Compendio, tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. 14.--Fernando Colon, Hist. +del Almirante, cap. 88.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 5, cap. 1.-- +Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., cap. 14. + +[38] It would be going out of our way to investigate the pretensions of +Amerigo Vespucci to the honor of first discovering the South American +continent. The reader will find them displayed with perspicuity and candor +by Mr. Irving, in his "Life of Columbus." (Appendix, No. 9.) Few will be +disposed to contest the author's conclusion respecting their fallacy, +though all may not have the same charity as he, in tracing its possible +origin to an editorial blunder, instead of wilful fabrication on the part +of Vespucci; in which light, indeed, it seems to have been regarded by the +two most ancient and honest historians of the event, Las Casas and +Herrera. + +Mr. Irving's conclusions, however, have since been confirmed, in the +fullest manner, by M. de Humboldt, in the fifth volume of his "Géographie +du Nouveau Continent," published in 1839, a year after the preceding +portion of this note was first printed; in which he has assembled a mass +of testimony, suggesting the most favorable impressions of Vespucci's +innocence of the various charges brought against him. + +Since the appearance of Mr. Irving's work, Señor Navarrete has published +the third volume of his "Coleccion de Viages y Descubrimientos," etc., +containing, among other things, the original letters recording Vespucci's +American voyages, illustrated by all the authorities and facts, that could +come within the scope of his indefatigable researches. The whole weight of +evidence leads irresistibly to the conviction, that Columbus is entitled +to the glory of being the original discoverer of the southern continent, +as well as islands, of the western hemisphere. (Coleccion de Viages, tom. +iii. pp. 183-334.) + +In addition to the preceding writers, the American reader will find the +claims of Vespucci discussed, with much ingenuity and careful examination +of authorities, by Mr. Cushing, in his "Reminiscences of Spain," vol. ii. +pp. 210 et seq. + +[39] Fernando Colon, Hist. del Almirante, cap. 87.--Herrera notices this +letter, written, he says, "con tanta humanidad, que parecia extraordinaria +de lo que usavan con otros, y no sin razon, pues jamas nadie les hizo tal +servicio," Indias Occidentales, lib. 5, cap. 1. + +Among other instances of the queen's personal regard for Columbus, may be +noticed her receiving his two sons, Diego and Fernando, as her own pages, +on the death of Prince John, in whose service they had formerly been. +(Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., 125.) + +By an ordinance of 1593, we find Diego Colon made _contino_ of the +royal household, with an annual salary of 50,000 maravedies. Ibid., Doc. +Dipl., no. 150. + +[40] Peter Martyr, De Rebus Oceanicis, dec. 1, lib. 10.--Garibay, +Compendio, tom. ii. lib. 19, cap. 14.--Fernando Colon, Hist. del +Almirante, cap. 88.--Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., cap. 12.--Herrera, Indias +Occidentals, lib. 5, cap. 2. + + + + +CHAPTER IX. + +SPANISH COLONIAL POLICY. + +Careful Provision for the Colonies.--License for Private Voyages.-- +Important Papal Concessions.--The Queen's Zeal for Conversion.--Immediate +Profits from the Discoveries.--Their Moral Consequences.--Their +Geographical Extent. + + +A consideration of the colonial policy pursued during Isabella's lifetime +has been hitherto deferred to avoid breaking the narrative of Columbus's +personal adventures. I shall now endeavor to present the reader with a +brief outline of it, as far as can be collected from imperfect and scanty +materials; for, however incomplete in itself, it becomes important as +containing the germ of the gigantic system developed in later ages. + +Ferdinand and Isabella manifested from the first an eager and enlightened +curiosity in reference to their new acquisitions, constantly interrogating +the admiral minutely as to their soil and climate, their various vegetable +and mineral products, and especially the character of the uncivilized +races who inhabited them. They paid the greatest deference to his +suggestions, as before remarked, and liberally supplied the infant +settlement with whatever could contribute to its nourishment and permanent +prosperity. [1] Through their provident attention, in a very few years +after its discovery, the island of Hispaniola was in possession of the +most important domestic animals, as well as fruits and vegetables of the +Old World, some of which have since continued to furnish the staple of a +far more lucrative commerce than was ever anticipated from its gold mines. +[2] + +Emigration to the new countries was encouraged by the liberal tenor of the +royal ordinances passed from time to time. The settlers in Hispaniola were +to have their passage free; to be excused from taxes; to have the absolute +property of such plantations on the island as they should engage to +cultivate for four years; and they were furnished with a gratuitous supply +of grain and stock for their farms. All exports and imports were exempted +from duty; a striking contrast to the narrow policy of later ages. Five +hundred persons, including scientific men and artisans of every +description, were sent out and maintained at the expense of government. To +provide for the greater security and quiet of the island, Ovando was +authorized to gather the residents into towns, which were endowed with the +privileges appertaining to similar corporations in the mother country; and +a number of married men, with their families, were encouraged to establish +themselves in them, with the view of giving greater solidity and +permanence to the settlement. [3] + +With these wise provisions were mingled others savoring too strongly of +the illiberal spirit of the age. Such were those prohibiting Jews, Moors, +or indeed any but Castilians, for whom the discovery was considered +exclusively to have been made, from inhabiting, or even visiting, the New +World. The government kept a most jealous eye upon what it regarded as its +own peculiar perquisites, reserving to itself the exclusive possession of +all minerals, dyewoods, and precious stones, that should be discovered; +and although private persons were allowed to search for gold, they were +subjected to the exorbitant tax of two-thirds, subsequently reduced to +one-fifth, of all they should obtain, for the crown. [4] + +The measure which contributed more effectually than any other, at this +period, to the progress of discovery and colonization, was the license +granted, under certain regulations, in 1495, for voyages undertaken by +private individuals. No use was made of this permission until some years +later, in 1499. The spirit of enterprise had flagged, and the nation had +experienced something like disappointment on contrasting the meagre +results of their own discoveries with the dazzling successes of the +Portuguese, who had struck at once into the very heart of the jewelled +east. The report of the admiral's third voyage, however, and the beautiful +specimens of pearls which he sent home from the coast of Paria, revived +the cupidity of the nation. Private adventurers now proposed to avail +themselves of the license already granted, and to follow up the track of +discovery on their own account. The government, drained by its late heavy +expenditures, and jealous of the spirit of maritime adventure beginning to +show itself in the other nations of Europe, [5] willingly acquiesced in a +measure, which, while it opened a wide field of enterprise for its +subjects, secured to itself all the substantial benefits of discovery, +without any of the burdens. + +The ships fitted out under the general license were required to reserve +one-tenth of their tonnage for the crown, as well as two-thirds of all the +gold, and ten per cent. of all other commodities which they should +procure. The government promoted these expeditions by a bounty on all +vessels of six hundred tons and upwards, engaged in them. [6] + +With this encouragement the more wealthy merchants of Seville, Cadiz, and +Palos, the old theatre of nautical enterprise, freighted and sent out +little squadrons of three or four vessels each, which they intrusted to +the experienced mariners, who had accompanied Columbus in his first +voyage, or since followed in his footsteps. They held in general the same +course pursued by the admiral on his last expedition, exploring the coasts +of the great southern continent. Some of the adventurers returned with +such rich freights of gold, pearls, and other precious commodities, as +well compensated the fatigues and perils of the voyage. But the greater +number were obliged to content themselves with the more enduring but +barren honors of discovery. [7] + +The active spirit of enterprise now awakened, and the more enlarged +commercial relations with the new colonies, required a more perfect +organization of the department for Indian affairs, the earliest vestiges +of which have been already noticed in a preceding chapter. [8] By an +ordinance dated at Alcalá, January 20th, 1503, it was provided that a +board should be established, consisting of three functionaries, with the +titles of treasurer, factor, and comptroller. Their permanent residence +was assigned in the old alcazar of Seville, where they were to meet every +day for the despatch of business. The board was expected to make itself +thoroughly acquainted with whatever concerned the colonies, and to afford +the government all information, that could be obtained, affecting their +interests and commercial prosperity. It was empowered to grant licenses +under the regular conditions, to provide for the equipment of fleets, to +determine their destination, and furnish them instructions on sailing. All +merchandise for exportation was to be deposited in the alcazar, where the +return cargoes were to be received, and contracts made for their sale. +Similar authority was given to it over the trade with the Barbary coast +and the Canary Islands. Its supervision was to extend in like manner over +all vessels which might take their departure from the port of Cadiz, as +well as from Seville. With these powers were combined others of a purely +judicial character, authorizing them to take cognizance of questions +arising out of particular voyages, and of the colonial trade in general. +In this latter capacity they were to be assisted by the advice of two +jurists, maintained by a regular salary from the government. [9] + +Such were the extensive powers intrusted to the famous _Casa de +Contratacion_, or House of Trade, on this its first definite +organization; and, although its authority was subsequently somewhat +circumscribed by the appellate jurisdiction of the Council of the Indies, +it has always continued the great organ by which the commercial +transactions with the colonies have been conducted and controlled. + +The Spanish government, while thus securing to itself the more easy and +exclusive management of the colonial trade, by confining it within one +narrow channel, discovered the most admirable foresight in providing for +its absolute supremacy in ecclesiastical affairs, where alone it could be +contested. By a bull of Alexander the Sixth, dated November 16th, 1501, +the sovereigns were empowered to receive all the tithes in the colonial +dominions. [10] Another bull, of Pope Julius the Second, July 28th, 1508, +granted them the right of collating to all benefices, of whatever +description, in the colonies, subject only to the approbation of the Holy +See. By these two concessions, the Spanish crown was placed at once at the +head of the church in its transatlantic dominions, with the absolute +disposal of all its dignities and emoluments. [11] + +It has excited the admiration of more than one historian, that Ferdinand +and Isabella, with their reverence for the Catholic church, should have +had the courage to assume an attitude of such entire independence of its +spiritual chief. [12] But whoever has studied their reign, will regard +this measure as perfectly conformable to their habitual policy, which +never suffered a zeal for religion, or a blind deference to the church, to +compromise in any degree the independence of the crown. It is much more +astonishing, that pontiffs could be found content to divest themselves of +such important prerogatives. It was deviating widely from the subtle and +tenacious spirit of their predecessors; and, as the consequences came to +be more fully disclosed, furnished ample subject of regret to those who +succeeded them. + +Such is a brief summary of the principal regulations adopted by Ferdinand +and Isabella for the administration of the colonies. Many of their +peculiarities, including most of their defects, are to be referred to the +peculiar circumstances under which the discovery of the New World was +effected. Unlike the settlements on the comparatively sterile shores of +North America, which were permitted to devise laws accommodated to their +necessities, and to gather strength in the habitual exercise of political +functions, the Spanish colonies were from the very first checked and +controlled by the over-legislation of the parent country. The original +project of discovery had been entered into with indefinite expectations of +gain. The verification of Columbus's theory of the existence of land in +the west gave popular credit to his conjecture, that that land was the +far-famed Indies. The specimens of gold and other precious commodities +found there, served to maintain the delusion. The Spanish government +regarded the expedition as its own private adventure, to whose benefits it +had exclusive pretensions. Hence those jealous regulations for securing to +itself a monopoly of the most obvious sources of profit, the dyewoods and +precious metals. + +These impolitic provisions were relieved by others better suited to the +permanent interests of the colony. Such was the bounty offered in various +ways on the occupation and culture of land; the erection of +municipalities; the right of inter-colonial traffic, and of exporting and +importing merchandise of every description free of duty. [13] These and +similar laws show that the government, far from regarding the colonies +merely as a foreign acquisition to be sacrificed to the interests of the +mother country, as at a later period, was disposed to legislate for them +on more generous principles, as an integral portion of the monarchy. + +Some of the measures, even, of a less liberal tenor, may be excused, as +sufficiently accommodated to existing circumstances. No regulation, for +example, was found eventually more mischievous in its operation than that +which confined the colonial trade to the single port of Seville, instead +of permitting it to find a free vent in the thousand avenues naturally +opened in every part of the kingdom; to say nothing of the grievous +monopolies and exactions, for which this concentration of a mighty traffic +on so small a point was found, in later times, to afford unbounded +facility. But the colonial trade was too limited in its extent, under +Ferdinand and Isabella, to involve such consequences. It was chiefly +confined to a few wealthy seaports of Andalusia, from the vicinity of +which the first adventurers had sallied forth on their career of +discovery. It was no inconvenience to them to have a common port of entry, +so central and accessible as Seville, which, moreover, by this arrangement +became a great mart for European trade, thus affording a convenient market +to the country for effecting its commercial exchanges with every quarter +of Christendom. [14] It was only when laws, adapted to the incipient +stages of commerce, were perpetuated to a period when that commerce had +swelled to such gigantic dimensions as to embrace every quarter of the +empire, that their gross impolicy became manifest. + +It would not be giving a fair view of the great objects proposed by the +Spanish sovereigns in their schemes of discovery, to omit one which was +paramount to all the rest, with the queen at least,--the propagation of +Christianity among the heathen. The conversion and civilization of this +simple people form, as has been already said, the burden of most of her +official communications from the earliest period. [15] She neglected no +means for the furtherance of this good work, through the agency of +missionaries exclusively devoted to it, who were to establish their +residence among the natives, and win them to the true faith by their +instructions, and the edifying example of their own lives. It was with the +design of ameliorating the condition of the natives, that she sanctioned +the introduction into the colonies of negro slaves born in Spain. This she +did on the representation that the physical constitution of the African +was much better fitted than that of the Indian to endure severe toil under +a tropical climate. To this false principle of economizing human +suffering, we are indebted for that foul stain on the New World, which has +grown deeper and darker with the lapse of years. [16] + +Isabella, however, was destined to have her benevolent designs, in regard +to the natives, defeated by her own subjects. The popular doctrine of the +absolute rights of the Christian over the heathen seemed to warrant the +exaction of labor from these unhappy beings to any degree, which avarice +on the one hand could demand, or human endurance concede on the other. The +device of the _repartimientos_ systematized and completed the whole +scheme of oppression. The queen, it is true, abolished them under Ovando's +administration, and declared the Indians "as free as her own subjects." +[17] But his representation, that the Indians, when no longer compelled to +work, withdrew from all intercourse with the Christians, thus annihilating +at once all hopes of their conversion, subsequently induced her to consent +that they should be required to labor moderately and for a reasonable +compensation. [18] This was construed with their usual latitude by the +Spaniards. They soon revived the old system of distribution on so terrific +a scale, that a letter of Columbus, written shortly after Isabella's +death, represents more than six-sevenths of the whole population of +Hispaniola to have melted away under it! [19] The queen was too far +removed to enforce the execution of her own beneficent measures; nor is it +probable, that she ever imagined the extent of their violation, for there +was no intrepid philanthropist, in that day, like Las Casas, to proclaim +to the world the wrongs and sorrows of the Indian. [20] A conviction, +however, of the unworthy treatment of the natives seems to have pressed +heavily on her heart; for in a codicil to her testament, dated a few days +only before her death, she invokes the kind offices of her successor in +their behalf in such strong and affectionate language, as plainly +indicates how intently her thoughts were occupied with their condition +down to the last hour of her existence. [21] + +The moral grandeur of the maritime discoveries under this reign must not +so far dazzle us, as to lead to a very high estimate of their immediate +results in an economical view. Most of those articles which have since +formed the great staples of South American commerce, as cocoa, indigo, +cochineal, tobacco, etc., were either not known in Isabella's time, or not +cultivated for exportation. Small quantities of cotton had been brought to +Spain, but it was doubted whether the profit would compensate the expense +of raising it. The sugar-cane had been transplanted into Hispaniola, and +thrived luxuriantly in its genial soil. But it required time to grow it to +any considerable amount as an article of commerce; and this was still +further delayed by the distractions as well as avarice of the colony, +which grasped at nothing less substantial than gold itself. The only +vegetable product extensively used in trade was the brazil-wood, whose +beautiful dye and application to various ornamental purposes made it, from +the first, one of the most important monopolies of the crown. + +The accounts are too vague to afford any probable estimate of the precious +metals obtained from the new territories previous to Ovando's mission. +Before the discovery of the mines of Hayna it was certainly very +inconsiderable. The size of some of the specimens of ore found there would +suggest magnificent ideas of their opulence. One piece of gold is reported +by the contemporary historians to have weighed three thousand two hundred +castellanos, and to have been so large, that the Spaniards served up a +roasted pig on it, boasting that no potentate in Europe could dine off so +costly a dish. [22] The admiral's own statement, that the miners obtained +from six gold castellanos to one hundred or even two hundred and fifty in +a day, allows a latitude too great to lead to any definite conclusion. +[23] More tangible evidence of the riches of the island is afforded by the +fact that two hundred thousand castellanos of gold went down in the ships +with Bobadilla. But this, it must be remembered, was the fruit of gigantic +efforts, continued, under a system of unexampled oppression, for more than +two years. To this testimony might be added that of the well-informed +historian of Seville, who infers from several royal ordinances that the +influx of the precious metals had been such, before the close of the +fifteenth century, as to affect the value of the currency, and the regular +prices of commodities. [24] These large estimates, however, are scarcely +reconcilable with the popular discontent at the meagreness of the returns +obtained from the New World, or with the assertion of Bernaldez, of the +same date with Zuñiga's reference, that, "so little gold had been brought +home as to raise a general belief that there was scarcely any in the +island." [25] This is still further confirmed by the frequent +representations of contemporary writers, that the expenses of the colonies +considerably exceeded the profits; and may account for the very limited +scale on which the Spanish government, at no time blind to its own +interests, pursued its schemes of discovery, as compared with its +Portuguese neighbors, who followed up theirs with a magnificent apparatus +of fleets and armies, that could have been supported only by the teeming +treasures of the Indies. [26] + +While the colonial, commerce failed to produce immediately the splendid +returns which were expected, it was generally believed to have introduced +a physical evil into Europe, which, in the language of an eminent writer, +"more than counterbalanced all the benefits that resulted from the +discovery of the New World." I allude to the loathsome disease, which +Heaven has sent as the severest scourge of licentious intercourse between +the sexes; and which broke out with all the virulence of an epidemic in +almost every quarter of Europe, in a very short time after the discovery +of America. The coincidence of these two events led to the popular belief +of their connection with each other, though it derived little support from +any other circumstance. The expedition of Charles the Eighth, against +Naples, which brought the Spaniards, soon after, in immediate contact with +the various nations of Christendom, suggested a plausible medium for the +rapid communication of the disorder; and this theory of its origin and +transmission, gaining credit with time, which made it more difficult to be +refuted, has passed with little examination from the mouth of one +historian to another to the present day. + +The extremely brief interval which elapsed, between the return of Columbus +and the simultaneous appearance of the disorder at the most distant points +of Europe, long since suggested a reasonable distrust of the correctness +of the hypothesis; and an American, naturally desirous of relieving his +own country from so melancholy a reproach, may feel satisfaction that the +more searching and judicious criticism of our own day has at length +established beyond a doubt that the disease, far from originating in the +New World, was never known there till introduced by Europeans. [27] + +Whatever be the amount of physical good or evil, immediately resulting to +Spain from her new discoveries, their moral consequences were inestimable. +The ancient limits of human thought and action were overleaped; the veil +which had covered the secrets of the deep for so many centuries was +removed; another hemisphere was thrown open; and a boundless expansion +promised to science, from the infinite varieties in which nature was +exhibited in these unexplored regions. The success of the Spaniards +kindled a generous emulation in their Portuguese rivals, who soon after +accomplished their long-sought passage into the Indian seas, and thus +completed the great circle of maritime discovery. [28] It would seem as if +Providence had postponed this grand event, until the possession of +America, with its stores of precious metals, might supply such materials +for a commerce with the east, as should bind together the most distant +quarters of the globe. The impression made on the enlightened minds of +that day is evinced by the tone of gratitude and exultation, in which they +indulge, at being permitted to witness the consummation of these glorious +events, which their fathers had so long, but in vain, desired to see. [29] + +The discoveries of Columbus occurred most opportunely for the Spanish +nation, at the moment when it was released from the tumultuous struggle in +which it had been engaged for so many years with the Moslems. The severe +schooling of these wars had prepared it for entering on a bolder theatre +of action, whose stirring and romantic perils raised still higher the +chivalrous spirit of the people. The operation of this spirit was shown in +the alacrity with which private adventurers embarked in expeditions to the +New World, under cover of the general license, during the last two years +of this century. Their efforts, combined with those of Columbus, extended +the range of discovery from its original limits, twenty-four degrees of +north latitude, to probably more than fifteen south, comprehending some of +the most important territories in the western hemisphere. Before the end +of 1500, the principal groups of the West Indian islands had been visited, +and the whole extent of the southern continent coasted, from the Bay of +Honduras to Cape St. Augustine. One adventurous mariner, indeed, named +Lepe, penetrated several degrees south of this, to a point not reached by +any other voyager for ten or twelve years after. A great part of the +kingdom of Brazil was embraced in this extent, and two successive +Castilian navigators landed and took formal possession of it for the crown +of Castile, previous to its reputed discovery by the Portuguese Cabral; +[30] although the claims to it were subsequently relinquished by the +Spanish Government, conformably to the famous line of demarkation +established by the treaty of Tordesillas. [31] + +While the colonial empire of Spain was thus every day enlarging, the man +to whom it was all due was never permitted to know the extent or the value +of it. He died in the conviction in which he lived, that the land he had +reached was the long-sought Indies. But it was a country far richer than +the Indies; and, had he on quitting Cuba struck into a westerly, instead +of southerly direction, it would have carried him into the very depths of +the golden regions, whose existence he had so long and vainly predicted. +As it was, he "only opened the gates," to use his own language, for others +more fortunate than himself; and before he quitted Hispaniola for the last +time, the young adventurer arrived there, who was destined, by the +conquest of Mexico, to realize all the magnificent visions, which had been +derided as only visions, in the lifetime of Columbus. + + * * * * * + +The discovery of the New World was fortunately reserved for a period when +the human race was sufficiently enlightened to form some conception of its +importance. Public attention was promptly and eagerly directed to this +momentous event, so that few facts worthy of note, during the whole +progress of discovery from its earliest epoch, escaped contemporary +record. Many of these notices have, indeed, perished through neglect, in +the various repositories in which they were scattered. The researches of +Navarrete have rescued many, and will, it is to be hoped, many more, from +their progress to oblivion. The first two volumes of his compilation, +containing the journals and letters of Columbus, the correspondence of the +sovereigns with him, and a vast quantity of public and private documents, +form, as I have elsewhere remarked, the most authentic basis for a history +of that great man. Next to these in importance is the "History of the +Admiral," by his son Ferdinand, whose own experience and opportunities, +combined with uncommon literary attainments, eminently qualified him for +recording his father's extraordinary life. It must be allowed, that he has +done this with a candor and good faith seldom warped by any overweening, +though natural, partiality for his subject. His work met with a whimsical +fate. The original was early lost, but happily not before it had been +translated into the Italian, from which a Spanish version was afterwards +made; and from this latter, thus reproduced in the same tongue in which it +originally appeared, are derived the various translations of it into the +other languages of Europe. The Spanish version, which is incorporated into +Barcia's collection, is executed in a slovenly manner, and is replete with +chronological inaccuracies; a circumstance not very wonderful, considering +the curious transmigration it has undergone. + +Another contemporary author of great value is Peter Martyr, who took so +deep an interest in the nautical enterprise of his day, as to make it, +independently of the abundant notices scattered through his +correspondence, the subject of a separate work. His history, "De Rebus +Oceanicis et Novo Orbe," has all the value which extensive learning, a +reflecting, philosophical mind, and intimate familiarity with the +principal actors in the scenes he describes, can give. Indeed, that no +source of information might be wanting to him, the sovereigns authorized +him to be present at the Council of the Indies, whenever any communication +was made to that body, respecting the progress of discovery. The principal +defects of his work arise from the precipitate manner in which the greater +part of it was put together, and the consequently imperfect and +occasionally contradictory statements which appear in it. But the honest +intentions of the author, who seems to have been fully sensible of his own +imperfections, and his liberal spirit, are so apparent, as to disarm +criticism in respect to comparatively venial errors. + +But the writer who has furnished the greatest supply of materials for the +modern historian is Antonio de Herrera. He did not flourish, indeed, until +near a century after the discovery of America; but the post which he +occupied of historiographer of the Indies gave him free access to the most +authentic and reserved sources of information. He has availed himself of +these with great freedom; transferring whole chapters from the unpublished +narratives of his predecessors, especially of the good bishop Las Casas, +whose great work, "Crónica de las Indias Occidentales," contained too much +that was offensive to national feeling to be allowed the honors of the +press. The Apostle of the Indians, however, lives in the pages of Herrera, +who, while he has omitted the tumid and overheated declamation of the +original, is allowed by the Castilian critics to have retained whatever is +of most value, and exhibited it in a dress far superior to that of his +predecessor. It must not be omitted, however, that he is also accused of +occasional inadvertence in stating as fact, what Las Casas only adduced as +tradition or conjecture. His "Historia General de las Indias +Occidentales," bringing down the narrative to 1554, was published in four +volumes, at Madrid, in 1601. Herrera left several other histories of the +different states of Europe, and closed his learned labors in 1625, at the +age of sixty. + +No Spanish historian had since arisen to contest the palm with Herrera on +his own ground, until, at the close of the last century, Don Juan Bautista +Muñoz was commissioned by the government to prepare a history of the New +World. The talents and liberal acquisitions of this scholar, the free +admission opened to him in every place of public and private deposit, and +the immense mass of materials collected by his indefatigable researches, +authorized the most favorable auguries of his success. These were +justified by the character of the first volume, which brought the +narrative of early discovery to the period of Bobadilla's mission, written +in a perspicuous and agreeable style, with such a discriminating selection +of incident and skilful arrangement, as convey the most distinct +impression to the mind of the reader. Unfortunately, the untimely death of +the author crushed his labors in the bud. Their fruits were not wholly +lost, however. Señor Navarrete, availing himself of them, in connection +with those derived from his own extensive investigations, is pursuing in +part the plan of Muñoz, by the publication of original documents; and Mr. +Irving has completed this design in regard to the early history of Spanish +discovery, by the use which he has made of these materials in constructing +out of them the noblest monument to the memory of Columbus. + + +FOOTNOTES + +[1] See, in particular, a letter to Columbus, dated August, 1494; (apud +Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., no. 79;) also an +elaborate memorial presented by the admiral in the same year, setting +forth the various necessities of the colony, every item of which is +particularly answered by the sovereigns, in a manner showing how +attentively they considered his suggestions.--Ibid., tom. i. pp. 226-241. + +[2] Abundant evidence of this is furnished by the long enumeration of +articles subjected to tithes, contained in an ordinance dated October 5th, +1501, showing with what indiscriminate severity this heavy burden was +imposed from the first on the most important products of human industry. +Recopilacion de Leyes de los Reynos de las Indias, (Madrid, 1774,) tom. i. +lib. 1, tit. 16, ley 2. + +[3] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., no. 86, April +10th, 1495.--Nos. 103, 105-108, April 23d, 1497.--No. 110, May 6th, 1497. +--No. 121, July 22d, 1497.--Herrera, Indias Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 4, +cap. 12. + +[4] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., nos. 86, 121.-- +Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 3, cap. 2.--Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo- +Mundo, lib. 5, sec. 34. + +The exclusion of foreigners, at least all but "Catholic Christians," is +particularly recommended by Columbus in his first communication to the +crown. Primer Viage de Colon. + +[5] Among the foreign adventurers were the two Cabots, who sailed in the +service of the English monarch, Henry VII., in 1497, and ran down the +whole coast of North America, from Newfoundland to within a few degrees of +Florida, thus encroaching, as it were, on the very field of discovery +preoccupied by the Spaniards. + +[6] Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 5, sect. 32.--Navarrete, Coleccion +de Viages, Doc. Dipl., no. 86. + +[7] Columbus seems to have taken exceptions at the license for private +voyages, as an infringement of his own prerogatives. It is difficult, +however, to understand in what way. There is nothing in his original +capitulations with the government having reference to the matter, (see +Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, Doc. Dipl., no. 5,) while, in the letters +patent made out previously to his second voyage, the right of granting +licenses is expressly reserved to the crown, and to the superintendent, +Fonseca, equally with the admiral. (Doc. Dipl., no. 35.) The only legal +claim which he could make in all such expeditions as were not conducted +under him, was to one-eighth of the tonnage, and this was regularly +provided for in the general license. (Doc. Dipl., no. 86.) The sovereigns, +indeed, in consequence of his remonstrances, published an ordinance, June +2d, 1497, in which, after expressing their unabated respect for all the +rights and privileges of the admiral, they declared, that whatever shall +be found in their previous license repugnant to these shall be null and +void. (Doc. Dipl., 113.) The hypothetical form in which this is stated +shows that the sovereigns, with an honest desire of keeping their +engagements with Columbus, had not a very clear perception in what manner +they had been violated. + +Peter Martyr, De Rebus Oceanicis, Dec. 1, lib. 9.--Herrera, Indias +Occidentales, lib. 4, cap. 11.--Benzoni, Novi Orbis Hist., cap. 13. + +[8] Part I. Chap. 18, of this History. + +[9] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., no. 148.-- +Solorzano y Pereyra, Política Indiana, (Madrid, 1776,) lib. 6, cap. 17.-- +Linage de Veitia, Norte de la Contratacion de las Indias Occidentales, +(Sevilla, 1672,) lib. 1, cap. 1.--Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, año 1503.-- +Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 5, cap. 12.--Navagiero, Viaggio, fol. +15. + +[10] See the original bull, apud Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii. +apend. 14, and a Spanish version of it, in Solorzano, Política Indiana, +lib. 4, cap. 1, sec. 7. + +[11] Solorzano, Política Indiana, tom. ii. lib. 4, cap. 2, sec. 9--Riol, +Informe, apud Semanario Erudite, tom. iii. pp. 160, 161. + +[12] Among others see Raynal, History of the East and West Indies, +translated by Justamond, (London, 1788,) vol. iv. p. 277.--Robertson, +History of America, (London, 1796,) vol. iii. p. 283. + +[13] Muñoz, Hist. del Nuevo-Mundo, lib. 5, sec. 32, 33.--Herrera, Indias +Occidentales, lib. 4, cap. 11, 12.--Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. +ii., Doc. Dipl., no. 86. + +[14] The historian of Seville mentions that it was the resort especially +of the merchants of Flanders, with whom a more intimate intercourse had +been opened by the intermarriages of the royal family with the house of +Burgundy. See Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, p. 415. + +[15] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., no. 45, et loc. +al.--Las Casas, amidst his unsparing condemnation of the guilty, does +ample justice to the pure and generous, though, alas! unavailing efforts +of the queen. See Oeuvres, ed. de Llorente, tom. i. pp. 21, 307, 395, et +alibi. + +[16] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 4, cap. 12.--A good account of the +introduction of negro slavery into the New World, comprehending the +material facts, and some little known, may be found in the fifth chapter +of Bancroft's "History of the United States;" a work in which the author +has shown singular address in creating a unity of interest out of a +subject which, in its early stages, would seem to want every other unity. +It is the deficiency of this, probably, which has prevented Mr. Grahame's +valuable History from attaining the popularity, to which its solid merits +justly entitle it. Should the remaining volumes of Mr. Bancroft's work be +conducted with the same spirit, scholarship, and impartiality as the +volume before us, it cannot fail to take a permanent rank in American +literature. + +[17] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 4, cap. 11. + +[18] Dec. 20th, 1503.--Ibid., lib. 5, cap. 11.--See the instructions to +Ovando in Navarrete, (Coleccion de Viages, tom. ii., Doc. Dipl., no. 153.) +"Pay them regular wages," says the ordinance, "for their labor," "como +personas libres como lo son, y no como siervos." Las Casas, who analyzes +these instructions, which Llorente, by the by, has misdated, exposes the +atrocious manner in which they were violated, in every particular, by +Ovando and his successors. Oeuvres, ed. de Llorente, tom. i. p. 309, et +seq. + +[19] Ibid., ubi supra.--Las Casas, Hist. Ind., lib. 2, cap. 36, MS., apud +Irving, vol. iii. p. 412.--The venerable bishop confirms this frightful +picture of desolation, in its full extent, in his various memorials +prepared for the Council of the Indies. Oeuvres, ed. de Llorente, tom. i. +passim. + +[20] Las Casas made his first voyage to the Indies, it is true, in 1498, +or at latest 1502; but there is no trace of his taking an active part in +denouncing the oppressions of the Spaniards earlier than 1510, when he +combined his efforts with those of the Dominican missionaries lately +arrived in St. Domingo, in the same good work. It was not until some years +later, 1515, that he returned to Spain and pleaded the cause of the +injured natives before the throne. Llorente, Oeuvres de Las Casas, tom. i. +pp. 1-23.--Nic. Antonio, Bibliotheca Nova, tom. i. pp. 191, 192. + +[21] See the will, apud Dormer, Discursos Varios, p. 381. + +[22] Herrera, Indias Occidentales, lib. 5, cap. 1.--Fernando Colon, Hist. +del Almirante, cap. 84.--Oviedo, Relacion Sumaria de la Historia Natural +de las Indias, cap. 84, apud Barcia, Historiadores Primitivos, tom. i. + +[23] Tercer Viage de Colon, apud Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. i. +p. 274. + +[24] Zuñiga, Annales de Sevilla, p. 415. The alteration was in the gold +currency; which continued to rise in value till 1497, when it gradually +sunk, in consequence of the importation from the mines of Hispaniola. +Clemencin has given its relative value as compared with silver, for +several different years; and the year he assigns for the commencement of +its depreciation, is precisely the same with that indicated by Zuñiga. +(Mem. de la Acad. de Hist., tom. vi. Ilust. 20.) The value of silver was +not materially affected till the discovery of the great mines of Potosí +and Zacatecas. + +[25] Bernaldez, Reyes Católicos, MS., cap. 131. + +[26] The estimates in the text, it will be noticed, apply only to the +period antecedent to Ovando's administration, in 1502. The operations +under him were conducted on a far more extensive and efficient plan. The +system of _repartimientos_ being revived, the whole physical force of +the island, aided by the best mechanical apparatus, was employed in +extorting from the soil all its hidden stores of wealth. The success was +such that in 1506, within two years after Isabella's death, the four +foundries established in the island yielded an annual amount, according to +Herrera, of 450,000 ounces of gold. It must be remarked, however, that +one-fifth only of the gross sum obtained from the mines was at that time +paid to the crown. It is a proof how far these returns exceeded the +expectations at the time of Ovando's appointment, that the person then +sent out, as marker of the gold, was to receive, as a reasonable +compensation, one per cent, of all the gold assayed. The perquisite, +however, was found to be so excessive, that the functionary was recalled, +and a new arrangement made with his successor. (See Herrera, Indias +Occidentales, dec. 1, lib. 6, cap. 18.) When Navagiero visited Seville, in +1520, the royal fifth of the gold, which passed through the mints, +amounted to about 100,000 ducats annually. Viaggio, fol. 15. + +[27] The curious reader is particularly referred to a late work, entitled +_Lettere sutta Storia de' Mali Venerei, di Domenico Thiene, Venezia_, +1823; for the knowledge and loan of which I am indebted to my friend, Dr. +Walter Channing. In this work, the author has assembled all the early +notices of the disease of any authority, and discussed their import with +great integrity and judgment. The following positions may be considered as +established by his researches. 1. That neither Columbus nor his son, in +their copious narratives and correspondence, allude in any way to the +existence of such a disease in the New World. I must add, that an +examination of the original documents, published by Navarrete since the +date of Dr. Thiene's work, fully confirms this statement. 2. That among +the frequent notices of the disease, during the twenty-five years +immediately following the discovery of America, there is not a single +intimation of its having been brought from that country; but, on the +contrary, a uniform derivation of it from some other source, generally +France. 3. That the disorder was known and circumstantially described +previous to the expedition of Charles VIII., and of course could not have +been introduced by the Spaniards in that way, as vulgarly supposed. 4. +That various contemporary authors trace its existence in a variety of +countries, as far back as 1493, and the beginning of 1494, showing a +rapidity and extent of diffusion perfectly irreconcilable with its +importation by Columbus in 1493. 5. Lastly, that it was not till after the +close of Ferdinand and Isabella's reigns, that the first work appeared +affecting to trace the origin of the disease to America; and this, +published 1517, was the production not of a Spaniard, but a foreigner. + +A letter of Peter Martyr to the learned Portuguese Arias Barbosa, +professor of Greek at Salamanca, noticing the symptoms of the disease in +the most unequivocal manner, will settle at once this much vexed question, +if we can rely on the genuineness of the date, the 5th of April, 1488, +about five years before the return of Columbus. Dr. Thiene, however, +rejects the date as apocryphal, on the ground, 1. That the name of "morbus +Gallicus," given to the disease by Martyr, was not in use till after the +French invasion, in 1494. 2. That the superscription of Greek professor at +Salamanca was premature, as no such professorship existed there till 1508. + +As to the first of these objections, it may be remarked, that there is but +one author prior to the French invasion, who notices the disease at all. +He derives it from Gaul, though not giving it the technical appellation of +_morbus Gallicus_; and Martyr, it may be observed, far from confining +himself to this, alludes to one or two other names, showing that its title +was then quite undetermined. In regard to the second objection, Dr. Thiene +does not cite his authority for limiting the introduction of Greek at +Salamanca to 1508. He may have found a plausible one in the account of +that university compiled by one of its officers, Pedro Chacon, in 1569, +inserted in the eighteenth volume of the Semanario Erudito, (Madrid, +1789.) The accuracy of the writer's chronology, however, may well be +doubted from a gross anachronism on the same page with the date referred +to, where he speaks of Queen Joanna as inheriting the crown in 1512. +(Hist. de la Universidad de Salamanca, p. 55.) Waiving this, however, the +fact of Barbosa being Greek professor at Salamanca in 1488 is directly +intimated by his pupil the celebrated Andrew Resendi. "Arias Lusitanus," +says he, "quadraginta, et eo plus annos Salmanticae tum Latinas litteras, +tum Graecas, magnâ cum laude professus est." (Responsio ad Quevedum, apud +Barbosa, Bibliotheca Lusitana, tom. i. p. 77.) Now, as Barbosa, by general +consent, passed several years in his native country, Portugal, before his +death in 1530, this assertion of Resendi necessarily places him at +Salamanca in the situation of Greek instructor some time before the date +of Martyr's letter. It may be added, indeed, that Nic. Antonio, than whom +a more competent critic could not be found, so far from suspecting the +date of the letter, cites it as settling the period when Barbosa filled +the Greek chair at Salamanca, (See Bibliotheca Nova, tom. i. p. 170.) + +Martyr's epistle, if we admit the genuineness of the date, must dispose at +once of the whole question of the American origin of the venereal disease. +But as this question is determined quite as conclusively, though not so +summarily, by the accumulated evidence from other sources, the reader will +probably think the matter not worth so much discussion. + +[28] This event occurred in 1497, Vasco de Gama doubling the Cape of Good +Hope, November 20th, in that year, and reaching Calicut in the following +May, 1498. La Clède, Hist. de Portugal, tom. iii. pp. 104-109. + +[29] See, among others, Peter Martyr, Opus Epist, epist. 181. + +[30] Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. iii. pp. 18-26.--Cabral's +pretensions to the discovery of Brazil appear not to have been doubted +until recently. They are sanctioned both by Robertson and Raynal. + +[31] The Portuguese court formed, probably, no very accurate idea of the +geographical position of Brazil. King Emanuel, in a letter to the Spanish +sovereigns acquainting them with Cabral's voyage, speaks of the newly +discovered region as not only convenient, but _necessary_, for the +navigation to India. (See the letter, apud Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, +tom. iii. no. 13.) The oldest maps of this country, whether from ignorance +or design, bring it twenty-two degrees east of its proper longitude, so +that the whole of the vast tract now comprehended under the name of +Brazil, would fall on the Portuguese side of the partition line agreed on +by the two governments, which, it will be remembered, was removed to 370 +leagues west of the Cape de Verd Islands. The Spanish court made some show +at first of resisting the pretensions of the Portuguese, by preparations +for establishing a colony on the northern extremity of the Brazilian +territory. (Navarrete, Coleccion de Viages, tom. iii. p. 39.) It is not +easy to understand how it came finally to admit these pretensions. Any +correct admeasurement with the Castilian league would only have included +the fringe, as it were, of the northeastern promontory of Brazil. The +Portuguese league, allowing seventeen to a degree, may have been adopted, +which would embrace nearly the whole territory which passed under the name +of Brazil, in the best ancient maps, extending from Para on the north, to +the great river of San Pedro on the south. (See Malte Brun, Universal +Geography, (Boston, 1824-9,) book 91.) Mariana seems willing to help the +Portuguese, by running the partition line one hundred leagues farther west +than they claimed themselves. Hist. de España, tom. ii. p. 607. + +END OF VOL. II. + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of The History of the Reign of Ferdinand +and Isabella The Catholic, Vol. 2, by William H. Prescott + +*** END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK FERDINAND AND ISABELLA, VOL. 2 *** + +This file should be named 6967-8.txt or 6967-8.zip + +This eBook was produced by: Anne Soulard, Tiffany Vergon, +Charles Aldarondo and the Online Distributed Proofreading Team. + +Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the US +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we usually do not +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +We are now trying to release all our eBooks one year in advance +of the official release dates, leaving time for better editing. +Please be encouraged to tell us about any error or corrections, +even years after the official publication date. + +Please note neither this listing nor its contents are final til +midnight of the last day of the month of any such announcement. +The official release date of all Project Gutenberg eBooks is at +Midnight, Central Time, of the last day of the stated month. A +preliminary version may often be posted for suggestion, comment +and editing by those who wish to do so. + +Most people start at our Web sites at: +https://gutenberg.org or +http://promo.net/pg + +These Web sites include award-winning information about Project +Gutenberg, including how to donate, how to help produce our new +eBooks, and how to subscribe to our email newsletter (free!). + + +Those of you who want to download any eBook before announcement +can get to them as follows, and just download by date. This is +also a good way to get them instantly upon announcement, as the +indexes our cataloguers produce obviously take a while after an +announcement goes out in the Project Gutenberg Newsletter. + +http://www.ibiblio.org/gutenberg/etext03 or +ftp://ftp.ibiblio.org/pub/docs/books/gutenberg/etext03 + +Or /etext02, 01, 00, 99, 98, 97, 96, 95, 94, 93, 92, 92, 91 or 90 + +Just search by the first five letters of the filename you want, +as it appears in our Newsletters. + + +Information about Project Gutenberg (one page) + +We produce about two million dollars for each hour we work. The +time it takes us, a rather conservative estimate, is fifty hours +to get any eBook selected, entered, proofread, edited, copyright +searched and analyzed, the copyright letters written, etc. Our +projected audience is one hundred million readers. If the value +per text is nominally estimated at one dollar then we produce $2 +million dollars per hour in 2002 as we release over 100 new text +files per month: 1240 more eBooks in 2001 for a total of 4000+ +We are already on our way to trying for 2000 more eBooks in 2002 +If they reach just 1-2% of the world's population then the total +will reach over half a trillion eBooks given away by year's end. + +The Goal of Project Gutenberg is to Give Away 1 Trillion eBooks! +This is ten thousand titles each to one hundred million readers, +which is only about 4% of the present number of computer users. + +Here is the briefest record of our progress (* means estimated): + +eBooks Year Month + + 1 1971 July + 10 1991 January + 100 1994 January + 1000 1997 August + 1500 1998 October + 2000 1999 December + 2500 2000 December + 3000 2001 November + 4000 2001 October/November + 6000 2002 December* + 9000 2003 November* +10000 2004 January* + + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation has been created +to secure a future for Project Gutenberg into the next millennium. + +We need your donations more than ever! + +As of February, 2002, contributions are being solicited from people +and organizations in: Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Connecticut, +Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, +Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Massachusetts, +Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New +Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, +Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South +Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West +Virginia, Wisconsin, and Wyoming. + +We have filed in all 50 states now, but these are the only ones +that have responded. + +As the requirements for other states are met, additions to this list +will be made and fund raising will begin in the additional states. +Please feel free to ask to check the status of your state. + +In answer to various questions we have received on this: + +We are constantly working on finishing the paperwork to legally +request donations in all 50 states. If your state is not listed and +you would like to know if we have added it since the list you have, +just ask. + +While we cannot solicit donations from people in states where we are +not yet registered, we know of no prohibition against accepting +donations from donors in these states who approach us with an offer to +donate. + +International donations are accepted, but we don't know ANYTHING about +how to make them tax-deductible, or even if they CAN be made +deductible, and don't have the staff to handle it even if there are +ways. + +Donations by check or money order may be sent to: + +Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +PMB 113 +1739 University Ave. +Oxford, MS 38655-4109 + +Contact us if you want to arrange for a wire transfer or payment +method other than by check or money order. + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation has been approved by +the US Internal Revenue Service as a 501(c)(3) organization with EIN +[Employee Identification Number] 64-622154. Donations are +tax-deductible to the maximum extent permitted by law. As fund-raising +requirements for other states are met, additions to this list will be +made and fund-raising will begin in the additional states. + +We need your donations more than ever! + +You can get up to date donation information online at: + +https://www.gutenberg.org/donation.html + + +*** + +If you can't reach Project Gutenberg, +you can always email directly to: + +Michael S. Hart <hart@pobox.com> + +Prof. Hart will answer or forward your message. + +We would prefer to send you information by email. + + +**The Legal Small Print** + + +(Three Pages) + +***START**THE SMALL PRINT!**FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN EBOOKS**START*** +Why is this "Small Print!" statement here? You know: lawyers. +They tell us you might sue us if there is something wrong with +your copy of this eBook, even if you got it for free from +someone other than us, and even if what's wrong is not our +fault. So, among other things, this "Small Print!" statement +disclaims most of our liability to you. It also tells you how +you may distribute copies of this eBook if you want to. + +*BEFORE!* YOU USE OR READ THIS EBOOK +By using or reading any part of this PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm +eBook, you indicate that you understand, agree to and accept +this "Small Print!" statement. If you do not, you can receive +a refund of the money (if any) you paid for this eBook by +sending a request within 30 days of receiving it to the person +you got it from. If you received this eBook on a physical +medium (such as a disk), you must return it with your request. + +ABOUT PROJECT GUTENBERG-TM EBOOKS +This PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm eBook, like most PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm eBooks, +is a "public domain" work distributed by Professor Michael S. Hart +through the Project Gutenberg Association (the "Project"). +Among other things, this means that no one owns a United States copyright +on or for this work, so the Project (and you!) can copy and +distribute it in the United States without permission and +without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, set forth +below, apply if you wish to copy and distribute this eBook +under the "PROJECT GUTENBERG" trademark. + +Please do not use the "PROJECT GUTENBERG" trademark to market +any commercial products without permission. + +To create these eBooks, the Project expends considerable +efforts to identify, transcribe and proofread public domain +works. Despite these efforts, the Project's eBooks and any +medium they may be on may contain "Defects". Among other +things, Defects may take the form of incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other +intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged +disk or other eBook medium, a computer virus, or computer +codes that damage or cannot be read by your equipment. + +LIMITED WARRANTY; DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES +But for the "Right of Replacement or Refund" described below, +[1] Michael Hart and the Foundation (and any other party you may +receive this eBook from as a PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm eBook) disclaims +all liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including +legal fees, and [2] YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE OR +UNDER STRICT LIABILITY, OR FOR BREACH OF WARRANTY OR CONTRACT, +INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE +OR INCIDENTAL DAMAGES, EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE +POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES. + +If you discover a Defect in this eBook within 90 days of +receiving it, you can receive a refund of the money (if any) +you paid for it by sending an explanatory note within that +time to the person you received it from. If you received it +on a physical medium, you must return it with your note, and +such person may choose to alternatively give you a replacement +copy. If you received it electronically, such person may +choose to alternatively give you a second opportunity to +receive it electronically. + +THIS EBOOK IS OTHERWISE PROVIDED TO YOU "AS-IS". NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, ARE MADE TO YOU AS +TO THE EBOOK OR ANY MEDIUM IT MAY BE ON, INCLUDING BUT NOT +LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A +PARTICULAR PURPOSE. + +Some states do not allow disclaimers of implied warranties or +the exclusion or limitation of consequential damages, so the +above disclaimers and exclusions may not apply to you, and you +may have other legal rights. + +INDEMNITY +You will indemnify and hold Michael Hart, the Foundation, +and its trustees and agents, and any volunteers associated +with the production and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm +texts harmless, from all liability, cost and expense, including +legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of the +following that you do or cause: [1] distribution of this eBook, +[2] alteration, modification, or addition to the eBook, +or [3] any Defect. + +DISTRIBUTION UNDER "PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm" +You may distribute copies of this eBook electronically, or by +disk, book or any other medium if you either delete this +"Small Print!" and all other references to Project Gutenberg, +or: + +[1] Only give exact copies of it. Among other things, this + requires that you do not remove, alter or modify the + eBook or this "small print!" statement. You may however, + if you wish, distribute this eBook in machine readable + binary, compressed, mark-up, or proprietary form, + including any form resulting from conversion by word + processing or hypertext software, but only so long as + *EITHER*: + + [*] The eBook, when displayed, is clearly readable, and + does *not* contain characters other than those + intended by the author of the work, although tilde + (~), asterisk (*) and underline (_) characters may + be used to convey punctuation intended by the + author, and additional characters may be used to + indicate hypertext links; OR + + [*] The eBook may be readily converted by the reader at + no expense into plain ASCII, EBCDIC or equivalent + form by the program that displays the eBook (as is + the case, for instance, with most word processors); + OR + + [*] You provide, or agree to also provide on request at + no additional cost, fee or expense, a copy of the + eBook in its original plain ASCII form (or in EBCDIC + or other equivalent proprietary form). + +[2] Honor the eBook refund and replacement provisions of this + "Small Print!" statement. + +[3] Pay a trademark license fee to the Foundation of 20% of the + gross profits you derive calculated using the method you + already use to calculate your applicable taxes. If you + don't derive profits, no royalty is due. Royalties are + payable to "Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation" + the 60 days following each date you prepare (or were + legally required to prepare) your annual (or equivalent + periodic) tax return. Please contact us beforehand to + let us know your plans and to work out the details. + +WHAT IF YOU *WANT* TO SEND MONEY EVEN IF YOU DON'T HAVE TO? +Project Gutenberg is dedicated to increasing the number of +public domain and licensed works that can be freely distributed +in machine readable form. + +The Project gratefully accepts contributions of money, time, +public domain materials, or royalty free copyright licenses. +Money should be paid to the: +"Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +If you are interested in contributing scanning equipment or +software or other items, please contact Michael Hart at: +hart@pobox.com + +[Portions of this eBook's header and trailer may be reprinted only +when distributed free of all fees. Copyright (C) 2001, 2002 by +Michael S. Hart. Project Gutenberg is a TradeMark and may not be +used in any sales of Project Gutenberg eBooks or other materials be +they hardware or software or any other related product without +express permission.] + +*END THE SMALL PRINT! FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN EBOOKS*Ver.02/11/02*END* + |
