diff options
| -rw-r--r-- | .gitattributes | 4 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | LICENSE.txt | 11 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | README.md | 2 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/62618-0.txt | 10586 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/62618-0.zip | bin | 238795 -> 0 bytes | |||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/62618-h.zip | bin | 481534 -> 0 bytes | |||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/62618-h/62618-h.htm | 12562 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/62618-h/images/cover.jpg | bin | 236236 -> 0 bytes |
8 files changed, 17 insertions, 23148 deletions
diff --git a/.gitattributes b/.gitattributes new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d7b82bc --- /dev/null +++ b/.gitattributes @@ -0,0 +1,4 @@ +*.txt text eol=lf +*.htm text eol=lf +*.html text eol=lf +*.md text eol=lf diff --git a/LICENSE.txt b/LICENSE.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6312041 --- /dev/null +++ b/LICENSE.txt @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +This eBook, including all associated images, markup, improvements, +metadata, and any other content or labor, has been confirmed to be +in the PUBLIC DOMAIN IN THE UNITED STATES. + +Procedures for determining public domain status are described in +the "Copyright How-To" at https://www.gutenberg.org. + +No investigation has been made concerning possible copyrights in +jurisdictions other than the United States. Anyone seeking to utilize +this eBook outside of the United States should confirm copyright +status under the laws that apply to them. diff --git a/README.md b/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..15287c1 --- /dev/null +++ b/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ +Project Gutenberg (https://www.gutenberg.org) public repository for +eBook #62618 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/62618) diff --git a/old/62618-0.txt b/old/62618-0.txt deleted file mode 100644 index be687b3..0000000 --- a/old/62618-0.txt +++ /dev/null @@ -1,10586 +0,0 @@ -Project Gutenberg's Selected Essays of Plutarch, Vol. I., by Plutarch - -This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and -most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions -whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms -of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at -www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you'll -have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using -this ebook. - - - -Title: Selected Essays of Plutarch, Vol. I. - -Author: Plutarch - -Translator: Thomas George Tucker - -Release Date: July 11, 2020 [EBook #62618] - -Language: English - -Character set encoding: UTF-8 - -*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK SELECTED ESSAYS OF PLUTARCH *** - - - - -Produced by Turgut Dincer, David King, and the Online -Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net. (This -file was produced from images generously made available -by The Internet Archive.) - - - - - - - Selected Essays of Plutarch - - - - - SELECTED ESSAYS OF PLUTARCH - - TRANSLATED WITH INTRODUCTION - - BY - - T. G. TUCKER - - LITT.D. (CAMB.), HON. LITT.D. (DUBLIN) - PROFESSOR OF CLASSICAL PHILOLOGY IN THE UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE - - Volume I. - - OXFORD - AT THE CLARENDON PRESS - 1913 - - HENRY FROWDE, M.A. - PUBLISHER TO THE UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD - LONDON, EDINBURGH, NEW YORK, TORONTO - MELBOURNE AND BOMBAY - - - - - PREFACE - - -The essays here rendered into English have not been selected as the very -best pieces in Plutarch’s _Moralia_, but, first, as typical examples of -his writing in that kind, and, second, as covering between them a -tolerably large field of interesting matter. The _Moralia_ offer us -perhaps the best of all extant material for judging the civilization of -the middle classes of society just before and after the year 100 of our -era. From them and from Pliny’s _Letters_ we are able to form a fairly -complete picture of a large part of that sounder social element which -lay between the froth and the dregs. - -In the Introduction some remarks are offered concerning Plutarch’s -literary style. Here it will suffice to say that the English version -does not seek to be either more formal or more vivacious, either more -imposing or more humorous, than the original. An attempt has been made -to preserve the tone as faithfully as the substance. In making Plutarch -write as he does in the following pages the translator hopes that _il ne -luy a au moins rien presté qui le desmente ou qui le desdie_. It is fair -to add that no modern version of the _Moralia_ has been consulted for -the purposes of this rendering. In the Introduction, however, one cannot -fail to owe much suggestion to Gréard and Volkmann. - -In the spelling of Greek proper names every modern scholar must follow -his own best judgement. It does not follow that, because it is necessary -to say ‘Plato’ and usual to say ‘Parmenio’, it is equally judicious to -say ‘Chilo’. Nor can any safe rule be laid down for a choice between -‘Pisistratus’ and ‘Peisistratus’. Perhaps the most advisable course is -to safeguard, as far as possible, the pronunciation of those who are -unfamiliar with Greek, and the spelling ‘Pheidias’ may do something -towards correcting the common English tendency to pronounce the first -syllable as it is pronounced in ‘fiddle’. Notes upon the proper names -will be found after the text by readers who may require them. - -The text generally adopted is that of Bernardakis in the Teubner series, -but recourse has been had throughout to Wyttenbach, and in a number of -places which are commonly acknowledged to be corrupt the translator has -ventured on a modest emendation of his own. These places are marked in -the translation by an asterisk in the margin, and the readings adopted -will be found at the end of the book in an appendix on the Greek text. -Critics would have saved themselves much trouble if they had observed -that, though hiatus is regularly avoided in the genuine writings of -Plutarch, no hiatus is created by a word ending in iota or upsilon, -vowels which carry a semi-vowel glide in themselves. - -The orthodox order, Greek and Latin titles, and sectional references of -the pieces here chosen are as follows. The English titles belong to the -present version. - - ON BRINGING UP A BOY (περὶ παίδων ἀγωγῆς: _De liberis educandis_), - 1-14 C. - - ON THE STUDENT AT LECTURES (περὶ τοῦ ἀκούειν: _De recta ratione - audiendi_), 37 C-48 D - - ON FAWNER AND FRIEND (πῶς ἄν τις διακρίνειε τὸν κόλακα τοῦ φίλου: - _Quomodo adulator ab amico internoscatur_), 48 E-74 E. - - ADVICE TO MARRIED COUPLES (γαμικὰ παραγγέλματα: _Coniugalia - praecepta_), 138 B-146. - - DINNER-PARTY OF THE SEVEN SAGES (τῶν ἑπτὰ σοφῶν συμπόσιον: _Septem - sapientum convivium_), 146 B-164 D. - - ON GARRULOUSNESS (περί ἀδολεσχίας: _De garrulitate_), 502 B-515. - - CONCERNING BUSYBODIES (περὶ πολυπραγμοσύνης: _De curiositate_), 515 - B-523 B. - - ON MORAL IGNORANCE IN HIGH PLACES (πρὸς ἡγεμόνα ἀπαίδευ τον: _Ad - principem ineruditum_), 779 D-782 F. - - ON OLD MEN IN PUBLIC LIFE (εἰ πρεσβυτέρῳ πολιτευτέον: _An seni - respublica gerenda sit_), 783 B-797 F. - - - INTRODUCTION - - -The age in which Plutarch was educated and in which he wrote his -_Ethica_ is, from the literary point of view, closely similar to the -so-called ‘Augustan’ age of English writing. Of all the periods of -English style and thought, he would probably have found himself most at -home in that of Pope, Addison, and Steele, or in its continuation with -Goldsmith and Johnson. He flourished at a time when intellectual -interests were remarkably keen, if not very profound; when literature, -if for the most part it ventured on no high imaginative flights, did at -least aim at some practical bearing upon the conduct of life; when men -found entertainment, and probably some measure of moral or social help, -in the readable essay or the friendly epistle; when facts, merely as -such, were accepted as interesting if interestingly set forth; and when -Philosophy, if she deigned to keep her feet upon the ground and to speak -as one of the mortals, met with a due welcome from either sex. An -eighteenth-century Plutarch might conceivably have written the moral -papers of Johnson without Johnson’s ponderousness, or have contributed -to the _Spectator_ papers more full than Addison’s of those ‘ideas’ in -which Matthew Arnold found that writer so deficient. He might have -written, though in a prose form, the _Essay on Man_, being meanwhile as -willing as Pope to owe the bulk of his matter to other minds, but not so -willing as Pope to play the expositor without first playing the earnest -and critical student. Plutarch did not, so far as we are aware, try his -hand at verse. To judge by his comments upon poetic duty and by his -quotations—which are regularly taken from the best writers of a -classical age already far remote—his conception of the poetic office was -too exalted to permit of his dabbling in that domain. Had he done so, -and had he followed the fashion of his times, he would perhaps have come -nearer to our ‘Augustans’ even than in his prose. In poetry it was the -age of description, reflection, satire, and moralizing, in the highest -degree sensible, studiously informed with ‘wit’—in the broader Queen -Anne sense of that word—and characterized by extreme deftness of pointed -and quotable phrase, but in no sense creative, imaginative, or inspired. -Its ideal contents consisted of ‘what oft was thought, but ne’er so well -expressed’. The attitudes of both prose-writer and poet belonged to the -intellectual and aesthetic spirit of the period, and so far as that -spirit finds an individual embodiment in the Greek half of the Roman -Empire, it finds him in Plutarch of Chaeronea. - -It would be difficult to suggest with any precision the place which -Plutarch might have filled in Victorian literature. A distinguished and -popular ‘man of letters’ and an educator of public opinion he assuredly -would have been. Given a width of reading, a persistent self-culture, -and a careful but unpedantic style, corresponding to those which he -practised in his own generation, he might have made—as he did then—an -admirable biographer and essayist. He might have been a contributor of -substantial papers to the quarterlies and other higher reviews. He -might, and probably would, have been an eminent lecturer; possibly, with -a broad practical Christianity substituted for his broad practical -Platonism, a preacher not only eminent but also in the best sense -popular. He would certainly have made a brilliant expositor of whatever -he undertook to expound. He was no Plato or Aristotle; he would have -been no Carlyle or Herbert Spencer; but he might have been much that -Macaulay was outside of politics. - -As to the date of Plutarch’s birth there can be no certainty. -Approximately it may be put down as A. D. 48. It is accepted that his -death did not occur before the year 120; it may have taken place -somewhat, though not much, later. Born in the days of Claudius, he lived -through the reigns of Nero, Galba, Otho, Vitellius, Vespasian, Titus, -Domitian, Nerva, and Trajan, and saw at least the first three years of -the rule of Hadrian. He must have been nearly fifty before the last -tyrant of the early Empire fell, but the remainder of his life was spent -under the most beneficent régime, and amid the greatest peace and -prosperity, ever experienced in the ancient world. The _pax Romana_ was -at its profoundest, the sense of security at its fullest; the fact of -general well-being was everywhere most palpable. There was at the same -time, or in consequence, a vigorous revival of intellectual life. At no -period of antiquity would it have been possible for a man of studious -habits and of mild and genial disposition to enjoy a leisure so -undisturbed or a society so free from those forms of preoccupation which -preclude an engrossing interest in things purely of the mind. For the -orator who is fired by the natural heat of democratic politics, for the -patriotic poet from whom thrilling verse must be wrung by the wrongs, -the decline, or the yet unrealized aspirations of his country, there was -indeed no stimulation or scope. But for the cultivation of the -humanities, for the indulgence of a taste for art and _belles-lettres_, -for the satisfaction of intellectual curiosity, for the search after -interesting knowledge—physical, mathematical, antiquarian, historical, -philological—and for the thoughtful observation of men and manners, the -time was almost ideal. In the absence of anxious and absorbing problems -of the present there was leisure for a contemplative and critical survey -of the past, and for making acquaintance with ‘the best that had been -thought and said’ by it. Since the immediate human environment was no -longer distracted and distracting with the clamorous urgencies of -external or internal strife and danger, it was possible to look abroad -over a wider field, to contemplate the more spacious world of man and -his work, of Nature and her facts, beauties, and marvels. It was -therefore the age of the encyclopaedist, the traveller, the commentator, -the describer, the collector—collector of curiosities, of objects of -art, of books, of stories from history, of apophthegms, of pointed and -interesting quotations. The prevailing aim was mental and social -culture. This was the one object of education, however much its -professors might dissent from each other according to the degrees of -philistinism in their respective temperaments. - -The aim of contemporary education—generally realized with more -definiteness than educational aims are wont to be in modern times—was to -turn the pupil into a gentleman, to equip him for the art of living and -conducting himself as such. There could, of course, hardly fail to be -those who regarded this _kalokagathia_ too much from the exterior point -of view, while others fixed their attention more decidedly, and often -perhaps too exclusively, upon the inward and spiritual grace. There were -also considerable differences between the Greek and Roman conceptions of -a gentleman. But in the main this end was universally avowed—to turn the -raw material of the boy into a man both capable and clubbable, whether -from a public or a private standpoint. The things to be sought were the -right accomplishments, the right morals, and the right manners. The -accomplishments included, beyond all else, literary information and -culture, argumentative dexterity, and a capacity for speech. The right -morals were based mainly upon reasoned self-command. The right manners -were chiefly those of urbanity, dignity, and that care of the person, -the voice, the dress, and the deportment upon which all ages have -insisted according to their several lights or tastes. It might be that -the teaching ‘philosopher’, whose concern was with the soundness of the -morals, had his quarrel with the teaching ‘sophist’, whose business was -with the rhetoric and its excellence for exhibition purposes or for the -gaining of various forms of influence. The philosopher might think the -sophist superficial, showy, and often actually pernicious, while the -sophist might look upon the philosopher as visionary, pedantic, and -often a positive clog upon practical efficiency. Nevertheless no -typically cultured person of the day would have questioned that, in -order to be complete—or, as Coleridge calls it, ‘orbicular’—education -must include its due measure of both forms of teaching. - -After his years of infancy the boy, under the supervision of his -_paedagogus_—ideally a slave of superior character, but too often a -person who was merely useless for harder work—passed into a school, -where he was first taught his letters and then proceeded to the reading, -learning, and recital of classical poetry, to the study of music, and to -some acquaintance with elementary arithmetic and geometry. Next, taken -in hand by the rhetorical teacher in a higher school, he was made to -write and deliver descriptions and essays, mostly on trite and unreal -themes of a historical or pseudo-historical nature, to develop his -powers of invention on either side of a chosen topic, and to cultivate a -fastidious diction, pointed phrase, and the elocutionary arts and -graces. From artificial harangues and the ‘speaking of a piece’ he -advanced to the imaginary pleading of forensic cases, in which the law -was often as fictitious as the facts. When, upon reaching the age for -assuming the _toga virilis_, he was emancipated from the custody of the -_paedagogus_ and the discipline of the school, his formal education -commonly ceased. If he proceeded further, as many did, to what may be -considered as the equivalent of a university course, he might elect to -study philosophy, to study ‘sophistic’, or to dally with both in such -measure as seemed likely to set off the abilities or consolidate the -culture of a gentleman. Even in the more mature years of life the -intellectually-disposed grandee had a habit of maintaining near his -person a salaried philosopher as a kind of domestic monitor, and -audiences of wealth and fashion readily gathered in Rome and elsewhere -to listen to lectures on philosophy by professors who properly -understood the art of clear and pleasant exposition. For the most part -the typical Roman, less genuinely impassioned than the Greek for thought -pure and simple, looked upon any ‘specializing’ in philosophy as likely -to lead either to too cloistered a virtue or to the acquisition of -eccentric, if not dangerous, views. A certain modicum of philosophical -knowledge might be an adornment to life, and a certain modicum of -philosophical training might impart a steadiness to character, but the -study must not be pursued to the point at which the student himself -stood in danger of becoming a ‘philosopher’. With the Greeks -philosophical specializing was commonly subject to no such reprehension, -partly because of the inborn Hellenic ardour for study and esteem of -learning, partly because in this domain, even more than in the -rhetorical, the Greeks were the accepted teachers throughout the Roman -sphere. - -This, or nearly this, was the attitude of the educational world in the -first decades of the second century, and it was in this world that -Plutarch of Chaeronea became a figure of special eminence and -distinction. For in whatever light the modern reader may regard Plutarch -as a man of letters, to his own times he was first and foremost an -educator. It is from this point of view that we must consider both his -_Parallel Lives_ and his _Moral Essays_, if we are to perceive in them -that unity of character and purpose which he intended all his work to -possess. - -Plutarch, then, was born about A. D. 48 in the very heart of Greece, at -the comparatively small town of Chaeronea, famous as the scene of the -decisive victory of the Macedonians over the southern Greeks, and also -of that in which the forces of Mithridates were routed by Sulla. His -family must have been of high local standing, and the fact that his -father—a man of cultivated tastes and refined manners—was the owner of -the ‘finest kind of horses’ is enough to show, to those who appreciate -the significance of the word _hippotrophia_, that he must have been -possessed of considerable means. The same conclusion may be drawn both -from what Plutarch himself incidentally reveals concerning his brothers, -Lamprias and Timon, as well as other members of the family circle, and -also from what is known of his own life and upbringing. That as a boy he -passed through the orthodox curriculum, is obvious from his wide -acquaintance with literature and his intelligent, if not particularly -profound, references to both music and mathematics. When of an age to -receive an education in philosophy, he was placed, or placed himself, -chiefly under the distinguished Ammonius, an Alexandrian philosopher of -a broad semi-Platonist, semi-Peripatetic school, who had become -established in a prominent intellectual and public position at Athens. -It was the accepted rule for the student to attend, but not necessarily -to confine himself to, the lectures of a selected teacher. Often he -lived in that teacher’s house, or at least, in intimate connexion -therewith. If the philosopher was strictly conscientious he felt it his -duty to watch over the developing character of his pupil, to visit him -with any deserved reproof,[1] to serve as his father confessor, to -answer his questions, and to meet his moral and intellectual -difficulties. The familiar phrase ‘guide, philosopher, and friend’ -perhaps describes the relations with unusual exactness. We find both -Plutarch and his brother in the company of Ammonius at Delphi when Nero, -in the year 66, graced that city with his imperial and artistic -presence. - -His formal education completed, we discover little of the younger -manhood of Plutarch, except that he must have been in high local -estimation, partly, perhaps, from the position of his family, but -doubtless no less on account of his own conspicuous gifts. Had this not -been the case, he would hardly have been appointed as one of a -delegation of two sent on a mission to the Roman proconsul of the -province. At what age he was first entrusted with civic functions as -aedile, or with a Delphic priesthood (then merely a ceremonial office -open to any layman), or with other public positions, we cannot say. We -can only be sure that to his learning he added a recognizable capacity -for public business. However many hours he may have devoted to study and -to the compilation of those ample commonplace-books which evidently -served him in such good stead, he prided himself on carrying his -philosophic attainments into the local Chamber or on to the local -platform. In his judgement this procedure was not only a vindication of -philosophy and a method of keeping the faculties energetic; it was also -a patriotic duty. - -As has been already said, this was an age of travel. Facilities of -transport were plentiful; the seas and main roads were secure from -pirate or enemy; journeys were at least as expeditious as at any modern -time until the employment of steam. We know of visits made by Plutarch -to Alexandria, various parts of Greece, Rome, and the north of Italy. -Rome he must have visited at least twice, and in this metropolis and -‘epitome of the world’ he made acquaintance with a large circle of men -of distinction, transacted public business (presumably on behalf of his -native town, of which he may have been sent as representative), -delivered lectures,[2] and apparently acted as a sort of consulting -physician to morally perturbed members of Roman society. He must have -spoken always in Greek, for he confesses that—like most other Greek -writers—he had given almost no attention to Latin; nor is any such -avowal needed from a person who, even after looking into the language, -believed _sine patris_ to be the Latin for ‘without a father’. Greek, -however, was then as much the universal language of the cultured as, -until recently, French was the universal accomplishment of fashion, -diplomacy, and the traveller. - -The Rome with which Plutarch was immediately acquainted was the Rome of -Vespasian and of the earlier half of Domitian’s reign. Had his sojourn -in the capital taken place some fifteen or twenty years later, it is in -the highest degree probable that he would have been further known to us -through an acquaintance with Pliny or some other Roman writer of that -date. That a Greek, and especially one who had a difficulty in reading -Latin, should make no mention of contemporary Latin authors—that in his -heart he should rather despise them—is only characteristic of the -Hellenic attitude of the time. But that the amiable Pliny, who has an -appreciative word to say of almost every one within his social horizon, -including comparatively obscure philosophers like Euphrates, should say -nothing of so eminent a figure as Plutarch, amounts to evidence that the -two had never met. A man who could make close friends of consulars like -Sosius Senecio and Mestrius Florus, and who enjoyed an intimacy with -Paccius and Fundanus, could not have failed to win the notice of the -Horace Walpole of his day. Quintilian, Silius, Statius, Martial, Pliny, -Suetonius, and Juvenal were all writing when Plutarch was already the -coryphaeus of Greek culture, and if not one of them mentions his name, -it is because he was living in remote Chaeronea and forgathering only -with his chosen circle of philosophers, men of letters, artists, or -musicians in that town or in Athens, Corinth, and other Greek centres -near at hand. - -To Chaeronea Plutarch must have retired by middle life. There he married -Timoxena, a lady of position, but of quiet tastes, had issue four sons -and a daughter, identified himself with the civic and religious concerns -of his town, delivered lectures, imparted instruction on the lines of a -modified or latitudinarian Platonic philosophy, industriously read the -books in his moderate but useful library, made copious extracts -therefrom, wrote his _Lives_ and those occasional papers known as his -_Ethica_ or _Moral Essays_, and enjoyed the discussion of many a knotty -question—often perhaps of little or no importance beyond the fact of its -forming a problem—in the agreeable society of his relatives or his -cultivated friends and guests. At such gatherings he was the leader, -doubtless dominating the conversation—though in his more courteous -way—somewhat as Johnson dominated the coterie described by Boswell. -Often, we gather, he varied this quiet course of life by means of -excursions to other Greek cities—Athens, Sparta, Aedepsus—where he most -probably delivered an occasional lecture, and where, as we are certain, -he thoroughly enjoyed himself in table-talk.[3] - -That he gave philosophical education, though apparently not of a -systematic and pedagogic kind, to persons of both sexes is known from -his own references to the practice. Whether he did so for money or not, -we cannot tell. The later Platonists by no means felt bound to adopt the -attitude of Socrates and Plato towards the taking of fees. The world had -changed, and the _res angusta_ was often more powerful than a principle -which had ceased to appear entirely rational. But there is every reason -to suppose that Plutarch was a man of independent means; we know further -that a genial frugality was the rule of his household, and that he -entertained a becoming contempt for the obsequious or the advertiser. -The day of the endowed professor, whether of philosophy or sophistic, -was still to dawn for Greece under Marcus Aurelius, and it never dawned -at all for so small a town as Chaeronea. We may take it therefore that, -whether with or without fee or present, Plutarch was able to choose his -own pupils—in all likelihood the sons and daughters of his friends—and -that, in dealing with them or with a wider audience, he maintained the -fullest dignity and independence, and practised all the amiable candour -which he explicitly recommends. - -For any lack of originality, of speculative audacity, of profundity (or -the obscurity which is so often mistaken for that virtue), Plutarch -fully compensates. To his generation he served as a milch-cow of -practical philosophy on its ethical side. He browsed on literature and -thought, secreted the most valuable constituents, and yielded the cream -to his hearers or readers. So far as he belonged to a philosophic -school, it was that of the Old Academy. In other words, he would have -labelled himself a Platonist. It is probable that he was as much -attracted by the superb literary style of Plato, the nature of the man, -and the nobility of his conceptions, as by anything capable of -crystallization into a philosophy. These qualities attracted even the -dilettante, while in the more specially philosophic world time had done -much to refract the real Plato, to extract dogma from him, and to create -a large _Aberglaube_ about his writings. Be that as it may, there is -much in Plato that Plutarch does not accept, and there is much outside -of Plato to which he gives a welcome. Towards Stoics and -Epicureans—whose doctrines, like those of the Christians, would -logically withhold men from public activity—he is distinctly, though -never virulently, hostile, and when his pen ranges itself against -particular schools, it is against these.[4] It is easier, in fact, to -say to what sect Plutarch did not belong than to associate him -definitively with any other. Nevertheless it is as a Platonist that he -would have classed himself, and it is especially by the later -Neo-Platonists that he was quoted as a divinely gifted writer who lent -literary charm and potency to wisdom. So broad, however, was his -teaching, and in many respects so adaptable even to Christianity, that -early writers of the Church had no scruple in borrowing liberally from -him.[5] - -Into whatever shape he may have systematized his views, and however -popular his treatment of them, Plutarch ranked with the philosophers. If -he was opposed to Stoicism and Epicureanism, he was, like other -philosophers, no less opposed to sophistic. To him the representatives -of that art were apt to seem shallow and showy.[6] - -He held, with the Socratics in general, that the basis of right action -is knowledge, and he had no belief in empiricism. Not that he rejected -either established moral views or established religion. He was no -sceptic, still less an atheist. As Friedländer has well argued, there -was no ancient cult of atheism. Plutarch, indeed, is remarkably -receptive in the matter of deities. The Egyptian worship of Isis and -Osiris, which had made great progress throughout the Roman Empire, -appeared to him equally tenable with the worship practised by his own -ancestors. In the polytheism in which he acquiesced, such divinities -were only other forms of those known in Hellas, and he found no -difficulty in reconciling and combining the two sets of notions and -cults. He was deeply tinged with Orientalism, though his culture and his -natural good taste made him despise corybantic demonstrations and what -Friedländer has called ‘dirty mortifications’. He held the Eranian -belief in daemonic agencies, which acted upon mankind from the one side -as the gods did from the other. If he appears to rise to the conception -of ‘God’ in the singular, the word is rather to be taken as denoting the -sum of divine wisdom and beneficent dispensation. Like all the best -minds of his own and many a previous generation, he found moral -difficulties in accepting the characters ascribed to the deities in the -best literature of earlier Greece, and therefore, while approving of the -established education in poetry, he necessarily felt some qualms as to -the possible effects. Poetry served in the schools ‘as introduction to -philosophy, history, geography, and astronomy’, and it had much to do -with the formation of religious and ethical notions. Homer, Pindar, -Sophocles, and Menander were ‘learned and wise’, and boys were brought -to regard them as inspired. Hence Plutarch’s treatise on _Poets as Moral -Teachers of the Young_. The point of view in that essay is not, indeed, -entirely rational. It was not so easy for Plutarch as it is for us to -realize that moral and religious ideas in Greek literature had passed -through an evolution corresponding to the development of intellect and -society. Instead of frankly recognizing the limitations of Homer or the -inconsistencies of the dramatists in this respect, he puts a highly -ingenious constraint upon the connexion between any dubious sentiment -and its context. It is only when he fails in such a _tour de force_ that -he consents to censure the poet. In this procedure he was by no means -the first. The battle of the ‘takers of objection’ (προβληματικοί) and -the ‘solvers of difficulties’ (λυτικοί) was centuries old. That Plutarch -should range himself as far as possible with the solvers is a -circumstance which would naturally follow both from his love of -literature and from his constitutionally reverential temperament. - -As has been often observed, the purpose running through the _Parallel -Lives_ and the _Moral Essays_ is one and the same. The philosophy of -Plutarch was ethical. For logic and dialectic he shows no liking. His -object was to relate philosophy to life, to bring home a philosophy -which could be lived. By philosophy he meant the best conduct of life, -based on an understanding of the nature of virtue—τὸ καλόν, the right, -the honourable, the becoming. From philosophy we are to learn not only -what is due to ourselves, but what is due to the gods, to the laws, to -parents, children, friends, enemies, fellow-citizens, and strangers. The -_Essays_, like those of Seneca or Bacon, deal with separable components -or manifestations of right and wrong character, with duties and -circumstances: the _Lives_ meanwhile afford us concrete examples or -object lessons from history.[7] Yet life, even that of a philosopher, is -not made up entirely of preaching and exhortation, least of all when the -philosopher is at the same time a man of the world and a man of letters. -Plutarch felt a lively interest in all such posers as were mooted in the -talk of the table or of the loungers’ club. He therefore includes among -his occasional papers—whether written by request or under the -fashionable fiction of a request—a number of treatises on physical, -antiquarian, literary, and artistic topics which can hardly be said to -bear with any immediateness upon the ethical perfection of the reader. -As a change, therefore, from the treatment of _Superstition_ or -_Inquisitiveness_ or _The Restraint of Anger_, of _Rules for Married -Couples_ and _Rules of Health_ and rules for _The Student at Lecture_, -he may in a spare moment discuss such matters as _The Face in the Moon_ -or questions in Roman custom. - -The majority of the pieces in the present selection speak for -themselves. With the one exception to be mentioned immediately, they all -bear the impress of the man. There is the same moral broadmindedness and -sobriety, the same shrewd sense of _le bonhomme Plutarque_, the same -faculty for popularizing[8] without descending to vapidity, the same -knack of relieving the sermon by means of anecdote, quotation, or -interesting item of information at the point where the discourse -threatens to become tedious. It is true that the German critic, in his -indefatigable search for the _unecht_, has impugned the authorship of -the _Dinner-Party of the Seven Sages_[9] on grounds unintelligible to -those who do not expect a dinner-table conversation to be a systematic -treatise, and who are satisfied to believe that a mixture of serious -talk, banter, and narrative, and a frequent transition of subject, are -precisely the things for which one would look on such an occasion. Every -feature of the style is Plutarchan, and, if Plutarch did not write the -piece, we can only feel unmixed regret that he did not, and unmixed -surprise that its real author should sacrifice the credit of his -performance. With the article on _The Bringing-up of a Boy_ the case is -different. Wyttenbach has sufficiently pointed out its frequent -feebleness of argument, its turbid arrangement, the exceeding triteness -of its ideas, and its unaccountable omissions. To us moderns it is of -great interest for the light which it throws on the education of the -period, and for its incidental revelations of the conditions of domestic -life and the domestic affections. Otherwise it is a puerile performance -and savours of nothing but the student essay. If it be argued that it is -one of Plutarch’s juvenile works, the answer is that it is unlike him to -be disingenuous; and disingenuous he must be, if in his early youth he -pretends to have ‘often impressed upon parents’ this or that. Antiquity -produced far too many amateur essays in imitation of great -authors—imitations actually ascribed to those authors by a recognized -fiction of the schools—for us to do an injustice to Plutarch when an -easier solution lies so close to our hands. Perhaps, again, the piece on -_Fawner and Friend_[10] suffers from an occasional _longueur_, but there -are few writers who do not at some less felicitous moment perpetrate -paragraphs less vivacious than their average. - -As a stylist Plutarch is apt to be underrated. He is, it is true, no -laborious atticist, and makes no point of writing like a purist in the -classic manner of a Plato or a Lysias. But this does not mean that he is -in the least negligent in either word or sentence. On the contrary, his -words are selected with extreme care, and his sentences—where the text -is sound, as for the most part it is—are rounded off and interlinked as -watchfully as any natural writing need require. It is true that his -vocabulary is large and his expression full, but, when his words are -properly weighed and their metaphorical and other differentiations duly -perceived, no understanding reader will call him verbose.[11] He -displays an immense command of language, but no word plays an idle part, -and if (like Cicero, whom in many respects he resembles) he is fond of -joining what are erroneously called synonyms, it needs but little -appreciation of verbal values to realize that the added words invariably -carry some amplification, some more precise definition, or some emphasis -helpful to a full grasp upon the sense. It is true also that his -sentences are apt to appear—like the sentences of Ruskin’s earlier -days—somewhat lengthy; nevertheless they commonly atone by lucidity of -construction for any demand they may make upon sustained attention.[12] -In a modern English dress they must necessarily be broken up, but a -practised reader of Plutarch finds no more difficulty with them in the -original than he would find with a passage of Demosthenes or Plato. To -one who becomes familiar with them they are at least as agreeable as the -staccato brevities of Seneca. What chiefly exacts some effort from the -reader of Plutarchan Greek is the fact that its words are -extraordinarily charged with metaphor and allusion.[13] His choice of -one word rather than another is always nicely calculated. This truth -once recognized, a reader cannot fail to admire both the consistency -with which the writer maintains his similitude while he is upon it, and -also the copious resources of vocabulary upon which he draws for the -purpose. Meanwhile, despite any length of sentence and fullness of -praise, Plutarch neither irritates with tricks and mannerisms nor -wearies with pedantry and ponderousness. A pedant he could not be. He is -no writer of Johnsonese. To him the best words are those which best suit -their context, and he has no objection whatever to a dash of the -colloquial or a touch of the homely or naïve. It is one of his -characteristic merits that he knows when to take the higher and when the -lower road of diction. He also knows when he is in danger of stylistic -monotony. Plutarch was a teacher, but, like all truly intelligent -members of that profession, he recognized that the most uninspiring -attitude to adopt is the severely and unremittingly pedagogic. ‘The -knack of style,’ it has been said, ‘is to write like a human being,’ and -Plutarch, a professor of humanity without a chair, is always and -entirely human. That his pen must have moved with extraordinary facility -is evident from the number of his publications. Apart from his _Lives_ -(of which not all are extant), his _Moralia_ include over eighty pieces, -long or short, and it is certain that many others had disappeared[14] -before the present collection became available in its eleventh-century -MS. - -It is not here implied that he is never culpable, never over-loaded. -There are times, though rare ones, at which we feel that his memory or -his notebook has been unduly exploited. We feel that he might have -spared us an illustration which does not illustrate or a similitude -which is deficient in similarity. To a certain extent he is a Euphuist, -and though Guevara perhaps owed nothing directly to him (as he did to -Seneca[15]), it is manifest that Plutarch sometimes strains a point in -order to achieve an over-ingenious comparison. The contagion of the -thing, like that of Euphuism in the Elizabethan age, was in the air, and -Plutarch assuredly does not err more often or more heinously with one -generation than Shakespeare did with another. Wide reading and natural -fecundity easily slip into sins which narrow resources and slow -invention are impotent to commit. - - * * * * * - -There are numerous signs that the pendulum of classical interest is -swinging in the direction of the literature of the early Empire. The -exclusive _toujours perdrix_ of the Attic and Ciceronian periods has -apparently begun to jade the palate, and writers like Seneca and -Plutarch are coming into their own once more. There was a time when -these authors were perhaps better known than any others. That they were -worthy of prime consideration is manifest from the immense influence -which they exercised upon the ardent and inquiring spirits of the -sixteenth and following centuries, in England no less than on the -Continent. Authors who could make such an appeal to Montaigne, to the -Elizabethan dramatists, to Bacon, or to Jeremy Taylor,[16] are surely -not to be despised because they belong stylistically to a ‘silver’ age, -or because their strength lies mostly in the fact that they are a mine -of ideas, wise saws, and pointed moral instances. Seneca, as being a -writer of Latin, was naturally the earlier and more widely read,[17] but -from the publication of the _editio princeps_ of Plutarch by Aldus in -1509 our author sprang into peculiar estimation among the recovered -spirits of antiquity. It was, however, due to Amyot that both his -_Lives_ and his _Essays_ became accessible to those who had little or no -Greek. The _Essays_ were rendered into idiomatic French by that -admirable translator in the year 1572,[18] and Montaigne was by no means -the only reader among _nous autres ignorans_ who made the Plutarch of -Amyot his breviary, and who ‘drew his water incessantly’ from him. It -was not the literary etiquette of the Elizabethan age to acknowledge all -the obligations one might owe even to a contemporary, much less to the -ancients, and the stores of Plutarch might be rifled without much fear -of detection, and certainly with no fear of reproach. When Lyly, in -_Euphues and his Ephoebus_,[19] takes it in hand to bring up a child in -the way he should go, he is in a large measure simply translating, -expanding, and emphasizing the pseudo-Plutarch on the _Bringing-up of a -Boy_ and interspersing the discourse with pickings from other essays, -particularly that on _Garrulousness_.[20] Montaigne, of course, with his -bland unreserve, credits Plutarch via Amyot with a multitude of -observations, while Bacon, when following the new vogue of the essay, -sometimes refers us to ‘Plutarke’, and at least on one occasion informs -us that ‘Mountaigny saith’ a thing which on reference to the said -‘Mountaigny’ we find to be Plutarchan. - -Though it is no part of the present Introduction to examine in detail -the influence of the philosopher of Chaeronea upon modern writers, or to -make an inventory of his contributions to English literature, it is at -least worth asking whether an author whom genius once delighted to -exploit, and from whom so many good things have filtered down to us -through various channels, may not be well worth reading at first hand. -To Professor Mahaffy[21] Plutarch ‘is a pure and elevating writer, full -of precious information, and breathing a lofty moral tone’, and to -Professor Gilbert Murray[22] he is ‘one of the most tactful and charming -of writers, and one of the most lovable characters in antiquity’. Said -Emerson[23]: ‘Plutarch will be perpetually rediscovered from time to -time as long as books last.’ - -Footnote 1: - - The reproof might ostensibly be general, but its particular - application was readily felt. Musonius, we are told by Epictetus, made - all his hearers feel ‘as if some one had been talking to him about - them’. - -Footnote 2: - - See _Concerning Busybodies_, 522 E. - -Footnote 3: - - Over and above his resemblances to Macaulay as a writer of essays and - biographical history, there is a distinct similarity between their - conversational tastes. We can imagine a Plutarch fully at home with - Macaulay at one of those astonishing early Victorian breakfast-parties - where a man might be asked if he ‘knew his Popes’, and where he might - be endured while he recited them. Plutarch’s _Table-Talk_, like his - _Dinner-Party of the Seven Sages_, reveals for contemporary Greek - society the same deliberate cult of intellectual conversation - sharpened by challenge and debate. In such conversation he must - himself have played a conspicuous part. Nevertheless, it may fairly be - gathered that the Greek or Graeco-Roman interlocutors in the reign of - Trajan were the more ingenuously athirst for reciprocal enlightenment, - however dubiously we may regard the value of the information or - misinformation actually gained. Nor is it easy to believe that - Plutarch would have thought it etiquette to indulge in the protracted - monologues to which the more modern society submitted with such grace - as it best could. - -Footnote 4: - - e.g. in his _De repugnantiis Stoicorum_ and his _Non posse suaviter - vivi secundum Epicurum_. Yet, as Mahaffy says, ‘it would be hard to - say whether the number of Stoic dogmas which he rejects exceeds that - which he quotes with approval’ (_The Greek World under Roman Sway_, - pp. 300 sqq.). - -Footnote 5: - - Volkmann names in particular Clement of Alexandria and Basil. - -Footnote 6: - - This does not mean that he had no friends among the rhetorical - teachers (the contrary is shown by his reference to ‘our Niger’ in - _praec. san._, § 16), but only that he distrusted the type. He refused - to approve of a fluent and polished style as an end in itself. Pliny - describes how the amazingly voluble Isaeus would offer his audience a - choice of subject and allow it to dictate the side which he should - take. He would then rise and demonstrate his extemporizing powers with - much show of rhetorical ornament. - -Footnote 7: - - Volkmann says of the _Lives_, ‘Das Werthvolle an ihnen sind nicht die - historischen Details, die er giebt, sondern die eingestreuten - Reflexionen, die ethischen Betrachtungen, das Eingehen auf - individuelle Stimmungen und Leidenschaften der grossen Männer.’ - -Footnote 8: - - _Aulicis tantum scripsit, non doctis_, says Scaliger. - -Footnote 9: - - Volkmann guesses that it is _ein Produkt der späteren Sophistik_. If - so, we may congratulate the Sophist on his perfect reproduction of - Plutarch’s style and of his non-sophistic tone. - -Footnote 10: - - Bacon’s Essay _Of Followers and Friends_ owes almost nothing to - Plutarch beyond the title. We do, however, find him borrowing the - words ‘for there is no such Flatterer as a Man’s selfe’. - -Footnote 11: - - As Volkmann happily puts it, he writes ‘with comfortable breadth’. - -Footnote 12: - - The sentences would doubtless have been easier still if Plutarch had - not felt bound to follow the fashion of the time and elaborately avoid - hiatus. - -Footnote 13: - - Perhaps this is why Plutarch, as seen through Amyot, appeared to - Montaigne ‘close and thorny,’ while his sense was nevertheless - ‘closely-jointed and pithily-continued’. - -Footnote 14: - - Stobaeus (sixth century) had access to much of Plutarch that is now - lost. - -Footnote 15: - - See an observation of Professor Summers, _Seneca Select Letters_, - Introduction, p. lxxiv. - -Footnote 16: - - Plutarch ‘is the theme of more than 230 allusions or direct references - on the part of Jeremy Taylor’ (Sandys, _A History of Classical - Scholarship_, i. 300). - -Footnote 17: - - He was familiar reading of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, and - appears in the _Gesta Romanorum_. Later the _Adagia_ of Erasmus draw - freely upon him. - -Footnote 18: - - ‘Il a en quelque sorte créé Plutarque,’ says Demogeot. - -Footnote 19: - - _Euphues_ appeared in 1579. Jusserand (_The English Novel in the Time - of Shakespeare_, p. 127) remarks that Euphues ‘addresses moral - epistles to his fellow men to guide them through life’, but he appears - to be unaware that Lyly borrowed this object, as well as so large a - quantity of his matter, from Plutarch. - -Footnote 20: - - We meet, for example, with the story of Zeno, ‘the olde man in Athens - that amiddest the pottes could hold his peace.’ - -Footnote 21: - - _History of Greek Classical Literature_, ii. 427. - -Footnote 22: - - _The Literature of Ancient Greece_, p. 396. - -Footnote 23: - - Quoted by Sandys (_A History of Classical Scholarship_, i. 300). - - - - - CONTENTS - - - Dinner-Party of the Seven Sages 27 - - On Old Men in Public Life 65 - - Advice to Married Couples 96 - - Concerning Busybodies 113 - - On Garrulousness 130 - - On the Student at Lectures 157 - - On Moral Ignorance in High Places 180 - - Fawner and Friend 187 - - On Bringing up a Boy 241 - - Notes on Persons and Places 267 - - - Appendix: Notes on the Greek Text 295 - - - - -_In the following imaginary ‘Dinner-Party of the Seven Sages’ the -supposed narrator is a certain Diocles of Corinth, a professional -diviner and expiator of omens connected with the court of Periander, who -was despot of Corinth from 625_ B. C. _to 585_ B. C. _The dramatic date -is towards the close of that period. It must not be assumed that -Plutarch is pretending to be historical, and anachronisms must be -disregarded._ - -_The Seven Sages are here Thales, Bias, Pittacus, Solon, Chilon, -Cleobulus, Anacharsis (see Notes on Persons and Places). The list varies -with different writers, but Thales, Bias, Pittacus, and Solon are -invariably, and Chilon is regularly, included in the canon. Periander is -himself sometimes made one of the number, and a certain Myson also -appears._ - -_The qualities which constituted a ‘sage’ in this connexion were those -of keen practical sense and insight, and a power of crystallizing the -results into pithy maxims. He was not a ‘philosopher’ in the later sense -of that word._ - - - - - DINNER-PARTY OF THE SEVEN SAGES - - -We [Sidenote: 146 B] may be sure, Nicarchus, that in process of time -facts will become so obscured as to be altogether beyond ascertainment, -seeing that in the present instance, where they are so fresh and recent, -the world accepts accounts of them which are pure concoctions. In the -first place, the party at dinner did not consist—as you have been -told—merely of seven, but of [Sidenote: C] more than twice that number. -I was myself included, both as being professionally intimate with -Periander and as the host of Thales, who had taken up his quarters with -me by Periander’s directions. In the second place, whoever related the -conversation to you, reported it incorrectly. Presumably he was not one -of the company. Inasmuch, therefore, as I have plenty of spare time and -my years do not warrant me in putting off the narrative with any -confidence, I will—since you are all so eager—tell you the whole story -from the beginning. - -Periander [Sidenote: D] had prepared his entertainment, not in the city, -but in the banquet-hall at Lechaeum, close to the temple of Aphrodite, -the festival being in her honour. For after having refused to sacrifice -to Aphrodite since the love-affair which led to his mother’s suicide, he -was now for the first time, thanks to certain dreams on the part of -Melissa, induced to pay honour and court to that goddess. - -Inasmuch as it was summer-time and the road all the way to the sea was -crowded with people and vehicles, and therefore full of dust and a -confusion of traffic, each of the invited guests was supplied with a -carriage and pair handsomely caparisoned. Thales, however, on seeing the -carriage at the door, simply [Sidenote: E] smiled and sent it away. -Accordingly we turned off the road and proceeded to walk quietly through -the fields, a third member of our party being Niloxenus of Naucratis, a -man of high character who had formed a close acquaintance with Solon and -Thales in Egypt. His presence was due to his having been sent on another -mission to Bias. Of its purpose he was himself unaware, although he -suspected that the sealed document of which he was the bearer contained -a second problem for solution. He had been instructed, in case Bias -could do nothing, to show the missive to the wisest of the Greeks. ‘It -is a godsend to me,’ [Sidenote: F] said Niloxenus, ‘to find you all -here, and, as you perceive’—showing us the paper—‘I am bringing the -letter to the dinner.’ At this Thales remarked with a laugh, ‘In case of -trouble, once more to Priene![24] For Bias will solve the difficulty, as -he did the first, without assistance.’ ‘What do you mean,’ said I, ‘by -“the first”?’ ‘The king,’ replied Thales, ‘sent him an animal for -sacrifice, and bade him pick out and send back the worst and best -portion of the meat. Thereupon our friend, with excellent judgement, -took out and sent the tongue; and he is manifestly held in high repute -and admiration in consequence.’ [Sidenote: 147] ‘That is not the only -reason,’ said Niloxenus, ‘Bias does not object—as you do—to be, and to -be called, a friend of kings. In your own case the king not only admires -you on general grounds, but he was hugely delighted with your method of -measuring the pyramid. Without any fuss or the need of any instrument, -you stood your stick at the end of the shadow thrown by the pyramid, and -the fall of the sunlight making two triangles, you showed that the -pyramid stood in the same ratio to the stick as the one shadow to the -other.[25] But, as I observed, you were charged with being a king-hater, -and [Sidenote: B] certain outrageous expressions of yours concerning -despots were reported to him. For example, when asked by the Ionian -Molpagoras what was the strangest sight you had seen, you answered, “An -aged despot.” Again, at a drinking-party, when the talk fell upon -animals, you stated that among wild animals the worst was the despot, -and among tame animals the sycophant. However much a king may claim to -differ from a despot, he does not welcome language of that kind.’ ‘Nay,’ -said Thales, ‘the former remark belongs to Pittacus, who once made it in -a playful attack on Myrsilus. My own observation [Sidenote: C] was that -I should regard as a strange sight, not an aged despot, but an aged -navigator. None the less, my feelings at the altered version are those -of the young fellow who, after throwing at the dog and hitting his -step-mother, remarked, “Not so bad, after all.” Yes, I regarded Solon as -very wise in refusing to act the despot. Our Pittacus also, if he had -kept clear of monarchy, would not have said that “_it is hard to be -good_”. As for Periander, his despotism may be regarded as an inherited -disease, from which he is making a creditable recovery, inasmuch as up -to the present he keeps wholesome company, cultivates the society of -sensible men, and will have nothing to say to that “cutting down of the -tall poppies” suggested by my fellow-countryman [Sidenote: D] -Thrasybulus. A despot who desires to rule over slaves rather than men is -no better than a farmer who is ready to reap a harvest of darnel and -cammock in preference to wheat and barley. Among the many undesirable -features of despotic rule, the one desirable element is the honour and -glory, in a case where the subjects are good but the ruler is better, -and where they are great but he is regarded as greater. If he is -satisfied with safety without honour, his right course would be to rule -over a herd of sheep, horses, or oxen, not over human beings. However, -[Sidenote: E] your visitor here has launched us upon an inopportune -topic. We are walking to a dinner, and he should have remembered to moot -questions suited to the occasion. For you will doubtless admit that -there is a certain preparation necessary for the guest as well as for -the host. The people of Sybaris, I understand, send their invitations to -the women a year in advance, so that they may have plenty of time to -prepare their dress and their jewelry before coming to dinner. In my own -opinion one who is to play the diner in the proper way requires still -more time for real and true preparation, inasmuch as it is harder to -arrive at the appropriate adornment of character than at the useless and -superfluous adornment of the person. When a man of sense comes to -[Sidenote: F] dinner, he does not bring himself to be filled like a -vessel, but to contribute something either serious or sportive. He is to -listen or talk about such matters as the occasion asks of the company, -if they are to find pleasure in each other’s society. An inferior dish -may be put aside, and if a wine is poor, one may take refuge with the -Nymphs.[26] But when your table-companion is an ill-bred bore who gives -you a headache, he utterly ruins the enjoyment of any wine or dish or -musical entertainment. [Sidenote: 148] Nor have you the resource of an -emetic for that kind of annoyance, but in some cases the mutual -antipathy lasts all your life, an insulting or angry incident at your -wine having resulted in a kind of nausea. Chilon was therefore quite -right when, on receiving his invitation yesterday, he only accepted -after ascertaining the full list of the guests. As he remarked, when -people cannot help going to sea or on a campaign, and a shipmate or -tentmate proves disagreeable, they are obliged to put up with him; but -no sensible man will form one of an indiscriminate wine-party. The mummy -which the Egyptians regularly bring in and exhibit at their parties, -bidding you [Sidenote: B] remember that you will very soon be like it, -may be an unwelcome and unseasonable boon-companion; yet the custom is -not without its point. Even if it may not incite you to drink and enjoy -yourself, it does incite to mutual liking and regard. “Life,” it urges, -“is short in duration; do not make it long by vexations.”’ - -After talk of this nature on the way we arrived at the house. As we had -anointed ourselves, Thales decided not to take a bath, but proceeded to -visit and inspect the race-tracks, the wrestling-grounds, and the -handsomely decorated park along the shore. Not that he was greatly taken -with anything of that kind, but he would not appear to despise or slight -Periander’s display [Sidenote: C] of public spirit. The other guests, as -soon as each had anointed himself or bathed, were being led by the -servants through the cloister into the dining-room. Anacharsis, however, -was seated in the cloister, and in front of him stood a girl, who was -parting his hair with her hands. Upon her running to meet Thales in the -frankest possible manner, he kissed her and said with a laugh, ‘That’s -right: make our foreign visitor beautiful, so that he may not frighten -us by looking like a savage, when he is really a most civilized person.’ -Upon my asking him who the child was, he replied, ‘Don’t you know the -wise and far-famed [Sidenote: D] Eumetis? That, by the way, is her -father’s name for her, though most people call her Cleobuline, after -him.’ ‘I presume,’ said Niloxenus, ‘your compliment refers to the girl’s -cleverness in constructing riddles. Some of her puzzles have found their -way as far as Egypt.’ ‘Not at all,’ rejoined Thales. ‘Those are merely -the dice with which, on occasion, she plays a match for fun in -conversation. There is more in her than that: an admirable spirit, a -practical intellect, and an amiable character, by which she renders her -father’s rule over his fellow country-men more gentle and popular.’ -‘Yes,’ remarked Niloxenus, ‘one [Sidenote: E] can see it by looking at -her simplicity and unpretentiousness. But how is it she is attending to -Anacharsis so affectionately?’ ‘Because,’ was the answer, ‘he is a man -of virtue and learning, and has given her zealous and ungrudging -instruction in the Scythian manner of dieting and purging the sick. I -should say that at the present moment, while looking after the gentleman -so amiably, she is getting some lesson and talking it over.’ - -As we were just approaching the dining-room, we were met by Alexidemus -of Miletus, the natural son of the despot Thrasybulus. [Sidenote: F] He -was coming out in a state of excitement and angrily muttering something -which conveyed no meaning to us. When he saw Thales he collected himself -a little, stopped, and said: ‘Look how we have been insulted by -Periander! He would not allow me to take ship home when I was anxious to -do so, but begged me to stay for the dinner; and, when I come to it, he -assigns me a degrading place at table, and lets Aeolians, islanders, and -goodness knows whom, take precedence of Thrasybulus. For since I was -commissioned by Thrasybulus, it is evident that, in my person, he means -to insult and humiliate [Sidenote: 149] him, by treating him as if he -were nobody.’ ‘I see,’ said Thales, ‘what you are afraid of. In Egypt -they say of the stars, according to their increase or decrease of -altitude in the regions they traverse, that they become ‘better’ or -‘worse’ than themselves. You are afraid that in your own case your place -at table may mean a similar loss of brightness and eminence, and you -propose to show less spirit than the Lacedaemonian, who, upon being put -by the director in the last place in a chorus, remarked, “A capital way -of making even this place one of honour.” When we take our places,’ -continued Thales, ‘we should not ask who have seats above us, but how we -are to make ourselves agreeable to our immediate neighbours. As a means -of immediately securing a beginning of friendly feeling on their part, -we should cultivate, [Sidenote: B] or rather bring with us, instead of -irritation, a tone of satisfaction at being placed in such good company. -The man who is annoyed with his place at table is more annoyed with his -next neighbour than with his host, and he earns the dislike of both.’ -‘That,’ retorted Alexidemus, ‘is mere talk. In practice I notice that -even you sages are greedy for precedence’—and therewith he passed us and -went off. Upon our expressing surprise at the man’s peculiar behaviour, -Thales said, ‘A crazy person, constitutionally wrong-headed. When he was -still a mere lad and a quantity of valuable perfume had been presented -to Thrasybulus, he emptied it into a big wine-cooler, poured in some -neat wine, and drank it off, thereby bringing ill-odour upon [Sidenote: -C] Thrasybulus instead of the contrary.’ - -At this point an attendant came up and said, ‘Periander requests you to -take Thales here along with you and examine an object which has just -been brought to him, to see whether it is a mere matter of accident or -signifies something portentous. He appears himself to be greatly -agitated, regarding it as a pollution, and as a smirch upon the -festival.’ Whereupon he proceeded to lead us to one of the apartments -off the garden. Here a youth, apparently a herdsman, still beardless and -with considerable handsomeness of person, opened a leather wrapper and -displayed a baby thing which he told us was the offspring of a mare. The -upper parts, as far as the neck and arms, were human, the lower parts -equine; its voice when it cried was that [Sidenote: D] of a new-born -child. Niloxenus, exclaiming ‘Heaven help us!’ turned away from the -sight; but Thales took a prolonged look at the young fellow, and with a -smile remarked—in accordance with his regular habit of twitting me in -connexion with my profession—‘I suppose, Diocles, you are thinking of -setting your purifications to work and giving trouble to the averting -powers, in the belief that a great and terrible thing has happened?’ ‘Of -course I am, Thales,’ said I, ‘for the token indicates strife and -discord, and I am afraid it may affect no less a matter than marriage -and its issue. As you see, before we have expiated the original offence, -the goddess is giving warning of a second.’ [Sidenote: E] To this Thales -made no answer, but began to move off—laughing. Upon Periander coming to -the door to meet us, and putting questions as to what we had seen, -Thales turned from me, took him by the hand, and said: ‘Anything Diocles -bids you do, you will perform at your leisure. My own advice is to be -more careful as to your herdsmen.’ On hearing this speech Periander -appeared to be greatly delighted, for he burst out laughing and hugged -and kissed Thales, who observed: ‘I should say, Diocles, that the sign -has found its fulfilment already; for you see what a serious misfortune -has befallen us in the [Sidenote: F] refusal of Alexidemus to be present -at dinner.’ - -When we had actually entered the room, Thales, speaking in a louder -tone, said: ‘And where was the seat to which the gentleman objected?’ -Upon the place being pointed out, he went round and occupied it himself, -taking me with him, and remarking: ‘Why, I would have paid something for -the [Sidenote: 150] privilege of sharing the same table with Ardalus.’ -The Ardalus in question was a Troezenian, a flute-player and priest of -the Ardalian Muses, whose worship was established by the original -Ardalus of Troezen. Thereupon Aesop—who happened to have arrived -recently on a simultaneous mission from Croesus to Periander and to the -god at Delphi, and was present on a low stool close to where Solon was -reclining above—said, ‘A Lydian mule, having caught sight of his -reflection in a river and conceived an admiration for the size and -beauty of his body, gave a toss of his mane and set out to run like a -horse; but after a while, reflecting that he was the son of an ass, he -quickly [Sidenote: B] stopped his career and dropped his pride and -conceit.’ At this Chilon, speaking in broad Laconian, observed: ‘Ye’re -slow yersel, an’ ye’re running the mule’s gait.’ - -At this point Melissa came in and reclined beside Periander, whereas -Eumetis sat at her dinner. - -Thales, addressing me—I was on the couch above Bias—said: ‘Diocles, why -don’t you inform Bias that our visitor from Naucratis has come to him -again with royal problems to solve, so that he may be sober and capable -of looking after himself when he receives the communication?’ Bias -replied: ‘Nay, our friend here has been trying for a long time to -frighten me with that warning. But I am aware that, besides his other -capacities, Dionysus is styled _Solver_[27] in right of wisdom. I feel -[Sidenote: C] no fear, therefore, that my being “filled with the god” -will cause me to make a less hopeful fight of it.’ - -While jokes of this kind were passing between these great men over their -dinner, I was noticing that the meal was unusually frugal, and I was led -to meditate on the fact that to invite and entertain wise and good men -means no additional expense, but rather a curtailment of it, since it -eliminates fancy dishes, out-of-the-way perfumes and sweetmeats, and -lavish decantings of costly wines. Though Periander, being a despot and -a person [Sidenote: D] of wealth and power, indulged in such things -pretty nearly every day, on this occasion he was trying to impress the -company with a show of simplicity and modest expenditure. He put aside -and out of sight not only the display usually made in other things, but -also that used by his wife, whom he made present herself in modest and -inexpensive attire. - -The tables were removed; Melissa caused garlands to be distributed; and -we poured libations. After the flute-girl had played a short piece to -accompany them, and had then withdrawn, Ardalus, addressing Anacharsis, -asked if there were any flute-girls among the Scythians. Instantly he -replied, ‘No, nor [Sidenote: E] yet vines.’ When Ardalus rejoined: -‘Well, but the Scythians have gods;’ ‘Quite true,’ said he: ‘gods who -understand human language. We are not like the Greeks, who imagine they -speak better than the Scythians, and yet believe that the gods would -rather listen to pieces of bone and wood.’ ‘Ah,’ said Aesop, ‘what if -you knew, Sir Visitor, that the present-day flute-makers have given up -using the bones of fawns and have taken to those of asses? They maintain -that these sound better—a fact which explains Cleobuline’s riddle upon -the Phrygian flute: [Sidenote: F] - - _With a shin that was horned - Did an ass that was dead - Deal a blow on my ear._ - -It is a wonderful thing that the ass, who is otherwise particularly -crass and unmusical, should supply us with a bone particularly fine and -melodious.’ ‘Now that,’ said Niloxenus, ‘is precisely the objection -which the Busirites bring against us of Naucratis; for asses’ bones for -flutes are already in use with us. With them, on the contrary, it is -profanation even to listen to a trumpet, because it sounds like the bray -of an ass. You know, I presume, that the ass is treated contemptuously -by the Egyptians because of Typhon?’ - -A silence here occurred, and, as Periander perceived that Niloxenus, -though eager to enter upon the subject, was shy [Sidenote: 151] of doing -so, he said: ‘To my mind, gentlemen, it is a commendable practice, -whether of community or ruler, to take the business of strangers first -and of citizens afterwards. On the present occasion, therefore, I -propose that for a short time we suspend any topics of our own, as being -local and familiar, and that we treat ourselves as an Assembly and -‘grant an audience’ to those royal communications from Egypt, of which -our excellent friend Niloxenus is the bearer to Bias, and which Bias -desires that you should join him in considering.’ ‘Yes,’ said Bias: ‘for -where, or with whom, could one more readily face the risk—if it must be -faced—of answering in a case like this, especially when the king’s -instructions are that, though [Sidenote: B] the matter is to begin with -me, it is to go the round of you all?’ Niloxenus thereupon offered him -the document, but Bias bade him open it himself and read every word to -the whole company. The contents of the letter were to the following -effect: - - AMASIS, KING OF EGYPT, TO BIAS, WISEST OF THE GREEKS - - _The King of Ethiopia is engaged in matching his wits against mine. - Hitherto he has had the worst of it, but has finally concocted a - terrible poser in the shape of a command that I should ‘drink up the - sea’. If I meet it with a solution, I am to have a number of his - villages and towns. If not, I am to surrender the cities in the - neighbourhood of Elephantine. Do you, therefore, take the matter - [Sidenote: C] in hand and send Niloxenus back to me at once. Any - return which friends or countrymen of yours require from me will be - made without hesitation on my part._ - -This part of the letter having been read, Bias was not long in -answering. After a few moments of meditation and a brief conversation -with Cleobulus, who was close to him at table, he said: ‘Do you mean to -say, my friend from Naucratis, that Amasis, though reigning over so many -subjects and possessed of so large and excellent a country, will be -ready to drink up the sea in order to win a few miserable insignificant -villages?’ ‘Take it that he will, Bias,’ replied Niloxenus, ‘and -consider how it can be done.’ ‘Very well then,’ said he: ‘let him tell -[Sidenote: D] the Ethiopian _to stop the rivers that run into the ocean, -while he is himself drinking up the sea at present existing_. The -command applies to the sea as it is, not as it is to be later on.’ Bias -no sooner made this speech than Niloxenus was so delighted that he -rushed to embrace and kiss him. After the rest of the company had -cheered and applauded, Chilon said with a laugh, ‘Sir Visitor from -Naucratis, before the sea is all drunk up and lost, set sail and tell -Amasis not to be asking how to make away with all that brine, but rather -how to render his kingship sweet and drinkable for his subjects. Bias is -a past master at teaching [Sidenote: E] such a lesson, and, if Amasis -learns it, he will have no further occasion for his golden footpan[28] -in dealing with the Egyptians. They will all be courting and making much -of him for his goodness, even if he is declared to be of a thousand -times lower birth than he actually is.’ ‘Yes, and by the way,’ said -Periander, ‘it would be a good thing if all—“man after man”, as Homer -has it—were to contribute a similar offering to His Majesty. A bonus of -the kind thrown in would not only make the returns on his venture more -valuable to him, but would also be the best thing in the world for us.’ - -Chilon thereupon asserted that Solon was the right man to [Sidenote: F] -make a beginning on the subject, not only because he was senior to all -the rest and was in the place of honour at the table, but because, -having legislated for the Athenians, he held the greatest and completest -position as a ruler. At this Niloxenus remarked quietly to me, ‘People -believe a good deal that is false, Diocles; and they mostly take a -delight in inventing for themselves, and in accepting with avidity from -others, mischievous stories about wise men. For instance, it was -reported [Sidenote: 152] to us in Egypt that Chilon had cancelled his -friendship and his relations of hospitality with Solon, because Solon -declared that laws were alterable.’ At this I answered, ‘The story is -ridiculous; for in that case Chilon ought to begin by disclaiming -Lycurgus and all his laws, as having altered the whole Lacedaemonian -constitution.’ - -After a brief delay Solon said: ‘In my opinion a king or despot would -win most renown _by furnishing his fellow-citizens with a popular, in -place of a monarchical, government_.’ The second to speak was Bias, who -said: ‘_By identifying his behaviour with the laws of his country._’ -Thales came next with the statement that he considered a ruler happy -‘_if he died naturally of old age_‘. Fourth Anacharsis: ‘_If good sense -never failed him._’ [Sidenote: *] Fifth Cleobulus: ‘_If he trusted none -of those about him._’ Sixth Pittacus: ‘_If the ruler could get his -subjects to fear, not him, but [Sidenote: B] for him._’ Next Chilon said -that ‘_the ruler’s conceptions should never be mortal, but always -immortal_‘. - -After hearing these dicta, we claimed that Periander himself should -express an opinion. With anything but cheerfulness, and pulling a -serious face, he replied: ‘Well, the opinion I have to add is that every -one of the views stated practically disqualifies a man of sense from -being a ruler.’ Whereupon Aesop, as if in a spirit of reproof, said, -‘You ought, of course, to have discussed this subject by yourselves, and -not to have delivered an attack upon rulers under pretence of being -their advisers and friends.’ [Sidenote: C] ‘Don’t you think,’ said -Solon, taking him by the head and smiling, ‘that one can make a ruler -more moderate and a despot more reasonable by persuading him that it is -better to decline such a position than to hold it?’ ‘And pray who,’ he -replied, ‘is likely to follow you in the matter rather than the God, -whose opinion is given in the oracle delivered to yourself: - - _Blessèd the city that hearkens to one commander’s proclaiming._’ - -‘True,’ said Solon, ‘but, as a matter of fact, the Athenians, though -with a popular government, do listen to one proclaimer [Sidenote: D] and -ruler in the shape of the law. You have a wonderful gift at -understanding ravens and jackdaws, but your hearing of the [Sidenote: *] -voice of modesty is indistinct. While you think that a state is best off -when it listens, as the God says, to “one”, you believe that the best -convivial party is that in which everybody talks on every subject.’ -‘Yes,’ said Aesop, ‘for you have not yet legislated to the effect that -“_a slave shall not get tipsy_” is to stand on the same footing with -those Athenian ordinances of yours which say “_a slave shall not indulge -in love or in dry-rubbing with oil_”.’[29] At this Solon broke into a -laugh, and Cleodorus the physician remarked: ‘But, in one respect, -talking when the wine is taking effect does stand on the same footing -with dry-rubbing—it is very pleasant.’ ‘Consequently,’ [Sidenote: E] -broke in Chilon, ‘it is the more to be avoided.’ ‘Yes,’ said Aesop -again,[30] ‘Thales did appear to recommend getting old as quickly as -possible.’ Periander laughed, and said: ‘Aesop, we have been properly -punished for dropping into other questions before bringing forward the -whole of those from Amasis, as we proposed. Pray look at the rest of the -letter, Niloxenus, and take advantage of the gentlemen being all here -together.’ ‘As for that,’ replied Niloxenus, ‘whereas the command sent -by the Ethiopian can only be called a “doleful [Sidenote: F] -dispatch”—as Archilochus would say—your friend Amasis has shown a fine -and more civilized taste in setting such problems. He bade him name the -oldest thing, the most beautiful, the greatest, the wisest, the most -universal, and—not stopping there—the most beneficent, the most harmful, -the most powerful, and the easiest.’ ‘Well, and did his answers give the -solution in each case?’ ‘His replies were these,’ said Niloxenus. ‘It is -[Sidenote: 153] for you to listen and judge; for the king is very -anxious neither to be guilty of pettifogging with the answers, nor to -let any slip on the part of the answerer escape without refutation. I -will read you the replies as given. _What is the oldest thing?_—_Time._ -_What the greatest?_—_The universe._ _What the wisest?_—_Truth._ _What -the most beautiful?_—_Light._ _What the most universal?_—_Death._ _What -the most beneficent?_—_God._ _What the most harmful?_—_Evil genius._ -_What the strongest?_—_Fortune._ _What the easiest?_—_That which is -pleasant._’ - -Well, Nicarchus, after the reading of this second passage there was a -silence. Then Thales asked Niloxenus if Amasis was satisfied with the -solutions. Upon his replying that he had [Sidenote: B] accepted some, -but was dissatisfied with others, Thales said, ‘And yet not one of them -is unassailable. There are great blunders and signs of ignorance all -through. For instance, how can Time be the oldest thing, seeing that, -while some of it is past and some present, some of it is future? Time -which is to come after us must be regarded as younger than the events -and persons of the present. Again, to call Truth wisdom appears to me as -bad as making out that the light is the eye. Next, if he considered -Light beautiful—as indeed it is—how came he to ignore the sun? As for -the rest, the answer concerning gods and evil spirits is bold and -dangerous, while in that [Sidenote: C] concerning Fortune the logic is -exceedingly bad. Fortune would not be so readily upset if it was the -strongest and most powerful thing in existence. Nor yet again is Death -the most universal thing, for in the case of the living it has no -existence. However, to avoid seeming merely to criticize the work of -others, let us express views of our own and compare them with his. I am -ready to be the first to be questioned point by point, if Niloxenus so -desires.’ - -In relating the questions and answers I will put them exactly as they -occurred. _What is the oldest thing?_ ‘_God_,’ said Thales: ‘for He is -without birth.’ _What is greatest?_ ‘_Space_: for [Sidenote: D] while -the universe contains everything else, it is space that contains the -universe.’ _What is most beautiful?_ ‘_The cosmos_: for everything duly -ordered is part of it.’ _What is wisest?_ ‘_Time_: for it is Time that -has either discovered things or will discover them.’ _What most -universal?_ ‘_Expectation_: for those who have nothing else have that.’ -_What most beneficent?_ ‘_Virtue_: for it makes other things beneficent -by using them rightly.’ _What most harmful?_ ‘_Vice_: for most things -suffer from its presence.’ _What most powerful?_ ‘_Necessity_: for it is -invincible.’ _What most easy?_ ‘_The natural_; not pleasure, for people -often fail to cope with that.’ - -The whole company being satisfied with Thales and his [Sidenote: E] -acumen, Cleodorus observed: ‘It is questions and answers of this kind, -Niloxenus, that are proper for kings. On the other hand, the barbarian -who gave Amasis the sea to drink, required the short answer made by -Pittacus to Alyattes, when he wrote the Lesbians a letter containing an -arrogant command. The reply was merely a recommendation to eat onions -and hot bread.’[31] - -Here Periander joined in; ‘I may remind you, Cleodorus, that even in old -times the Greeks had a habit of posing each [Sidenote: F] other with -similar difficulties. We are told, for instance, that there was a -gathering at Chalcis of the most distinguished poets among the wise men -of the day, in order to celebrate the funeral of Amphidamas—a great -warrior who had given much trouble to the Eretrians and had fallen in -the fighting for Lelantum. The verses composed by the poets were so well -matched, that it became a difficult and troublesome matter to judge -between them, and the reputation of the competitors—Homer and -Hesiod—caused the jury much diffidence and [Sidenote: 154] -embarrassment. Thereupon they had recourse to questions of the present -kind, and Homer—as Lesches tells us—propounded the following: - - _Tell me, Muse, of such things as neither before have befallen, - Nor shall hereafter befall?_ - -To which Hesiod instantly replied: - - _When in eager pursuit of the prize the chariots, one ’gainst the - other - Are dashed by the ringing-hoof’d steeds round the tomb where Zeus - lieth buried._ - -This answer, it is said, won particular admiration and secured him the -tripod.’ - -‘But pray what is the difference,’ asked Cleodorus, ‘between such -questions and Eumetis’s riddles? It is no doubt right [Sidenote: B] -enough for her to set women such puzzles by way of amusement, -constructing them as other women plait their bits of girdles or -hair-nets. But for sensible men to treat them with any seriousness is -absurd.’ Eumetis would apparently have liked to make some retort, but -she was too shy, and checked herself, her face mantled with blushes. -‘Nay,’ said Aesop, by way of championing her, ‘it is surely more absurd -to be unable to solve them. Take for example the one she set us just -before dinner: - - _I saw a man glue bronze on a man; with fire did he glue it._ - -Can you tell me what that means?’ ‘No, and I don’t want [Sidenote: C] to -be told either,’ answered Cleodorus. ‘And yet,’ said Aesop, ‘no one is -so familiar with the thing, or does it so well, as you. If you deny it, -cupping-glasses[32] will bear me out.’ At this Cleodorus laughed, for he -made more use of cupping-glasses than any medical man of the day, and -the estimation in which that remedy is held is especially due to him. ‘I -beg to ask, Periander,’ said Mnesiphilus the Athenian, a close friend -and admirer of Solon, ‘that the conversation, like the wine, shall not -be limited to wealth or rank, but shall be put on a democratic footing -and made to concern all alike. In what has just been [Sidenote: D] said -about wealth and kingship there is nothing for us commoners. We think, -therefore, that you should take a government with equal rights, and each -of you again contribute some opinion, beginning once more with Solon.’ -It was decided that this should be done. First came Solon. ‘Well, -Mnesiphilus, you, like every other Athenian, have heard what opinion I -hold about such a government. But if you desire to hear it again now, it -seems to me that a community is in the soundest condition, and its -popular government most securely maintained, _when the wrongdoer is -accused and punished quite as much by those who [Sidenote: E] have not -been wronged as by the man that has_.’ The second to speak was Bias, who -said that the best popular government is ‘_that in which every one fears -the law as he would a despot_.’ Next came Thales with ‘_that in which -there are no citizens either too rich or too poor_.’ Anacharsis followed -with ‘_that in which, while everything else is treated as equal, -superiority is determined by virtue and inferiority by vice_.’ In the -fifth place Cleobulus affirmed that a democracy is most soundly -conducted ‘_when its public men are more afraid of blame than of the -law_‘. Sixth, Pittacus: ‘_Where the bad are not permitted to hold office -and the [Sidenote: F] good are not permitted to decline it._’ Last of -all Chilon expressed the view that the best free government is ‘_that -which pays least attention to the orators and most to the laws_.’ -Periander once more summed up at the end by saying that they all -appeared to him to be praising ‘that democratic government which most -resembled an aristocratic.’ - -Upon the conclusion of this second discussion I begged that they would -also tell us the proper way to deal with a household; ‘for while there -are few who are at the helm of a kingdom or a commonwealth, we all play -our parts in the hearth and home.’ [Sidenote: 155] At this Aesop said -with a laugh: ‘No! not if in “all” you include Anacharsis. He has no -home, but actually prides himself on being homeless, and on using a -wagon—in the same way as they tell us the sun roams about in a chariot, -occupying first one and then another region of the sky.’ ‘Yes,’ retorted -Anacharsis, ‘and that is why, unlike any other—or more than any -other—god, he is free and independent, ruling all and ruled by none, but -always playing the king and holding the reins. You, however, fail to -realize the surpassing beauty and marvellous [Sidenote: B] size of his -car, otherwise you would not have tried to raise a laugh by jocosely -comparing it with ours. It seems to me, Aesop, that to you a home means -those coverings of yours made by clay and wood and tiles. You might as -well regard a “snail” as meaning the shell instead of the animal. It is -therefore natural that you should find cause to laugh at Solon, when he -beheld all the costly splendour in the house of Croesus and yet refused -to declare off-hand that its possessor was happy and blessed in his -home; “for”—he argued—“I am more desirous of looking at the fine things -in the man than at those in his house.” It appears, moreover, that you -have forgotten your own fox. That animal, when she and the leopard were -engaged in a dispute as to which was the more “cunningly marked”, begged -the judge to examine her on the inside, inasmuch as she would be found -to possess more “marks of cunning” from that point of view. But you go -inspecting the productions of carpenters [Sidenote: C] and stone-masons, -and regarding those as the “home”, instead of the inward and domestic -constituents in the case—the children, wife, friends, and servants. If -these have good sense and good morals, a man who shares his best means -with them possesses a good and happy home, even if it be but an ant-hill -or a bird’s-nest.’ ‘That,’ he continued, ‘is my answer to Aesop and my -contribution to Diocles. But it is only fair that each of the others -should express his own views.’ - -Thereupon Solon said that in his opinion the best household was ‘_that -in which the resources are acquired without dishonesty, [Sidenote: D] -watched over without distrust, and expended without repentance_‘. -According to Bias it was ‘_that inside which the master behaves for his -own sake as well as he does outside for the law’s sake_‘. According to -Thales, ‘_that in which the master can find most time to himself_‘. -According to Cleobulus, ‘_where the master has more who love than fear -him_.’ Pittacus would have it that the best house is ‘_that which wants -no luxury and lacks no necessity_‘. Chilon’s view was that the house -should be ‘_as like as possible to a state ruled by a king_‘, and he -went on to observe that when some one urged Lycurgus to establish a -republic at Sparta, he [Sidenote: E] answered: ‘You begin by creating a -republic at home.’ - -This topic also having been dealt with, Eumetis left the room in company -with Melissa. Periander then pledged Chilon in a capacious goblet, and -Chilon in turn pledged Bias. At this Ardalus got up, and, addressing -Aesop, said: ‘Perhaps you will be good enough to pass yonder cup on to -us, seeing that these gentlemen are passing theirs to each other, as if -it were a Bathycles’s goblet,[33] and are giving no one else a turn.’ -‘Nay,’ [Sidenote: F] replied Aesop, ‘there is to be nothing democratic -about this cup either, for Solon has been keeping it all to himself for -quite an age.’ Thereupon Pittacus, addressing Mnesiphilus, asked why -Solon, by not drinking, was testifying against the verses in which he -had written - - _Now do I welcome the tasks of the Cyprus-born goddess and Bacchus, - And tasks of the Muses that bring cheer to the heart of mankind._ - -‘Because,’ said Anacharsis, before Mnesiphilus could speak, ‘he is -frightened at that cruel law of your own, Pittacus, where the words run, -_If any one commit any offence when drunk, the penalty to be double that -paid by a man who was sober._’ ‘And you,’ retorted Pittacus, ‘showed -such wanton contempt of the law that last year, when you had got -intoxicated at that [Sidenote: 156] party at Delphi, you asked for a -prize and a victor’s wreath.’ ‘And why not?’ asked Anacharsis. ‘A prize -was offered to him who drank most, and, since I was the first to get -tipsy, I, of course, claimed the reward of victory. Otherwise will you -gentlemen tell me what is the end and aim of drinking a large quantity -of unmixed wine, if it is not to get intoxicated?’ Pittacus laughed, -while Aesop told the following story. ‘A wolf, having seen some -shepherds eating a sheep in a tent, came close up to them, and said: -“What a to-do you would have made if _I_ had been doing that!”’ At this -Chilon remarked, ‘Aesop has properly taken his revenge. A moment ago we -put the muzzle on him, and now he sees that others have taken the words -out of Mnesiphilus’ mouth. It was Mnesiphilus who was requested to -answer on behalf of Solon.’ ‘Well, in doing so,’ said Mnesiphilus, ‘I -speak with knowledge. In Solon’s opinion [Sidenote: B] the concern of -every art and faculty of man or God is with results rather than with -agencies, the end rather than the means. A weaver, I take it, would -consider his object to be a cloak or mantle rather than the arrangement -of his shuttle-rods or the picking-up of his straightening-stones. To a -blacksmith it is rather the welding of iron and putting an edge on an -axe than any of the processes necessary thereto, such as the kindling of -his charcoal or the preparation of lime. Still more would a -master-builder object if, instead of a ship or a house, we declared his -object to be the boring of wood or the mixing of mortar. The Muses would -utterly scout the notion that their [Sidenote: C] concern is with a harp -or flute, instead of with the cultivation of character and the soothing -of the emotions of their votaries by means of melodies properly attuned. -So—to come to the point—the object of Aphrodite is not sexual -intercourse, nor that of Dionysus wine and tipsiness, but the friendly -feeling, the longing, the companionship, and the close mutual -understanding which they produce in us by those agencies. These are what -Solon calls divine “tasks”, and he means that these are the objects -which he appreciates and cultivates in his old age. Of reciprocal -affection between men and women Aphrodite is the creator, using pleasure -as the means of melting and commingling their souls at the same time -with their bodies; while in ordinary cases, where persons are not very -intimate or particularly acquainted, Dionysus uses wine as a kind of -fire to soften and supple their dispositions, and so provides a -starting-point towards a blending in mutual friendship. - -‘But when such men meet together as Periander has invited in your -persons, there is no need, I take it, of the goblet and the wine-ladle. -The Muses set before you all, in the form of conversation, a mixing-bowl -containing no intoxicant and yet abundance of pleasure, grave or gay. In -this they stir friendly feeling, blend it, and pour it forth, while for -the most part the [Sidenote: E] ladle is allowed to lie undisturbed -“above the bowl”—a thing which Hesiod forbids where the company is -better qualified for drinking than for conversation.’ - -‘As for pledging one another,’ he continued, ‘I gather that with the -ancients the ceremony consisted of one large goblet going the round, -each man drinking a measured “allowance” (as Homer tells us), and then -letting his neighbour take his share, as he would do with a sacrificial -portion.’ - -When Mnesiphilus had finished, the poet Chersias—who had ceased to be -under censure and had lately been reconciled to [Sidenote: F] Periander -through Chilon’s intercession—remarked, ‘Are we also to understand that, -when the gods were the guests of Zeus and were pledging each other, he -poured in their drink by measure, as Agamemnon did for his chieftains?’ -‘And pray, Chersias,’ said Cleodorus, ‘if Zeus has his ambrosia -brought—as you poets say he does—by doves which find the greatest -difficulty in flying over the Clashing Rocks, don’t you think [Sidenote: -157] that his nectar is also scarce and hard to get, and that -consequently he is sparing of it and doles it out economically?’ -‘Perhaps so,’ replied Chersias. ‘Since, however, the question of -household economy has again been mooted, perhaps some one will deal with -the remainder of the question. And that, I take it, is to discover what -amount of property will be sufficient to meet all needs.’ ‘To the wise -man,’ said Cleobulus, ‘the law has supplied the standard; but in -reference to weak characters I will repeat a story which my daughter -told her brother. The Moon, she said, asked her mother to weave a tunic -to fit her; whereat the mother answered, “How can I possibly [Sidenote: -B] weave one to fit? At one time I see you as a full moon, at another as -a crescent, and at another gibbous.” Similarly, my dear Chersias, there -is no way of determining the amount of means requisite for a weak and -foolish person. His wants vary with his appetites and experiences, his -case being that of Aesop’s dog, of whom our friend says that in winter -he huddled and curled himself up with the cold, and contemplated making -a house; but in summer it was different; he stretched himself out when -he slept, thought himself a big fellow, and decided that it was both a -laborious and an unnecessary task to build so large a house to cover -him. Don’t you observe, Chersias’—he went on—‘that even insignificant -people, though they will at one moment draw themselves into a very -modest compass, with the idea of living a close and simple Spartan life, -at another [Sidenote: C] time will fancy they are going to die of want -unless they have all the money in the world—all the king’s and all the -private people’s?’ - -Chersias having nothing to say, Cleodorus joined in. ‘Well, but,’ he -said, ‘I perceive that there is no equal distribution in the properties -which even you sages respectively possess.’ ‘Yes, my dear sir,’ said -Cleobulus, ‘because the law, like a weaver, allots us the amount which -properly and reasonably fits each case. In your own profession, -substituting reason for law, you feed [Sidenote: D] and diet and physic -the sick by prescribing, not the same quantity for everybody, but the -proper quantity for each case.’ Here Ardalus interposed. ‘I suppose, -then,’ he asked, ‘it is at the bidding of some law that Epimenides—the -friend of you gentlemen and the guest of Solon—abstains from other kinds -of food and passes the day without breakfast or dinner by merely putting -in his mouth a little of that “anti-hunger essence” which he makes up -for himself?’ This remark having arrested the attention of the party, -Thales mockingly observed that Epimenides was a sensible man for -refusing to be troubled—as [Sidenote: E] Pittacus was—with grinding and -cooking his own food. ‘You must know,’ he said, ‘that when I was at -Eresus, I heard my hostess singing to the mill: - - _Grind, mill, grind; - For Pittacus is grinding, - As he kings it over great Mytilene._’ - -Then Solon expressed his surprise that Ardalus had not read the law -ordaining the diet in question, seeing that it was written in the verses -of Hesiod. ‘For it is he who first supplied Epimenides with hints for -that form of nourishment, by teaching him to make trial [Sidenote: F] - - _How great and sustaining the food that in mallow and asphodel - lieth._ - -‘Nay,’ said Periander, ‘do you imagine Hesiod conceived of anything of -the kind? Don’t you suppose that, with his habitual praise of economy, -he is merely urging us to try the most frugal dishes as being the most -agreeable? The mallow makes good eating, and asphodel-stalk is sweet; -but I am told that anti-hunger and anti-thirst drugs—for they are drugs -rather than foods—include among their ingredients some sort of foreign -honey and cheese, and a large number of seeds which are difficult to -procure. Most certainly, therefore, Hesiod would find that the -“_rudder_” hung “_above the smoke_” and - - _The works of the drudging mules and the oxen’s labour would - perish_, - -[Sidenote: 158] if all that provision is to be made. I am surprised, -Solon, if your guest, on recently making his great purification of -Delos, failed to note how they present to the temple—as commemorative -samples of the earliest form of food—mallow and asphodel-stalk along -with other cheap and self-grown produce. The natural reason for which -Hesiod also recommends them to us is that they are simple and frugal.’ -‘Not only so,’ remarked Anacharsis, ‘but both vegetables bear the -highest possible character for wholesomeness.’ ‘You are quite right,’ -said Cleodorus. ‘That Hesiod possessed medical knowledge is manifest -from the careful and well-informed manner in which he speaks about diet, -the mixing of wine, good quality in water, [Sidenote: B] bathing, women, -and the way to seat infants. But it seems to me that there is more -reason for Aesop to declare himself a pupil of Hesiod than there is for -Epimenides. It is to the speech of the hawk to the nightingale that our -friend owes the first promptings to his admirably subtle wisdom in many -tongues. But for my part I should be glad to hear what Solon has to say. -We may assume that, in his long association with Epimenides at Athens, -he asked him what motive or subtle purpose he had in adopting such a -diet.’ - -‘What need was there to ask him that question?’ replied Solon. ‘It was -self-evident that the next best thing to the [Sidenote: C] supreme and -greatest good is to require the least possible food. You allow, I -suppose, that the greatest good is to require no food at all?’ ‘Not I, -by any means,’ answered Cleodorus, ‘if I am to say what I think, -especially with a table in front of us. Take away food, and you take -away the table—that is to say, the altar of the Gods of Friendship and -Hospitality. As Thales tells us that, if you do away with the earth, the -whole cosmos will fall into confusion, so the abolition of food means -the dissolution of house and home. For with it you do away with the -hearth-fire, the hearth, the wine-bowl, all entertainment and -hospitality—the most humanizing and essential elements in our mutual -relations. Or rather you do away with the whole of life, if life is “_a -passing of the time on the part [Sidenote: D] of a human being involving -a series of actions_”, most of those actions being evoked by the need, -and in the acquirement, of food. Of immense importance, my good friend, -is the question [Sidenote: *] of mere agriculture. Let agriculture -perish, and the earth that it leaves us becomes unsightly and foul, a -corrupt wilderness of barren forest and vagabond streams. The ruin of -agriculture means the ruin of all arts and crafts as well; for she takes -the lead of them, and provides them with their basis and their -[Sidenote: E] material. Do away with her, and they count for nothing. -There is an end also to our honouring the gods. Men will thank the Sun -but little, and the Moon still less, for mere light and warmth. Where -will you find altar or sacrifice to Zeus of the Rain, Demeter of the -Plough, or Poseidon the Fosterer of Plants? How can Dionysus be -Boon-Giver, if we need nothing that he gives? What sacrifice or libation -shall we make? What offering of firstfruits? All this means the -overthrow and confounding of our most important interests. Though to -cling to every pleasure in every case is to be a madman, to avoid every -pleasure in every case is to be a block. By all means let the soul have -[Sidenote: F] other pleasures of a superior kind to enjoy; the body can -find no pleasure more right and proper than that derived from taking -food. All the world recognizes the fact, for this pleasure people take -openly, sharing with each other in the table and the banquet, whereas -their amorous pleasure is screened by night and all the darkness -possible. To share that pleasure with others is considered as shameless -and brutelike as it is not to share in the case of the table.’ - -Here, as Cleodorus paused for a moment, I joined in: ‘And is there not -another point—that in discarding food we also [Sidenote: 159] discard -sleep? If there is no sleep, there is no dreaming either, and we lose -our most important means of divination. Moreover, life will be all -alike, and there will be practically no purpose in wearing a body round -our soul. Most of its parts, and the most important, are provided as -instruments to feeding—the tongue, teeth, stomach, and liver. None of -them is without its work, and none has other business to attend to. -Consequently any one who has no need of food has no need of a body -either. Which means that a person has no need of himself; for it is -thanks to the body that each of us is a “self”.’ ‘Such,’ I added, ‘are -our contributions on behalf of the belly. If Solon or any one else has -objections to bring, we will listen.’ - -‘Of course I have objections,’ replied Solon. ‘I have no [Sidenote: B] -wish to be thought a poorer judge than the Egyptians. After cutting open -a dead body, they take out the entrails and expose them to the sunlight. -They then throw those parts into the river and proceed to attend to the -rest of the body, which is now regarded as purified. Yes, therein in -truth lies the pollution of our flesh. It is its Tartarus—like that in -Hades—full of “dreadful streams”, a confused medley of wind and fire and -of dead things. For while itself lives, nothing that feeds it can be -alive. We commit the wrong of murdering animate things and of destroying -plants, which can claim to have life through the fact that they feed and -grow. I say destroying, because [Sidenote: C] anything that changes from -what nature has made it into something else, is destroyed; it must -perish utterly in order to become the other’s sustenance. To abstain -from eating flesh, as we are told Orpheus did in ancient times, is more -a quibble than an avoidance of crime in the matter of food. The only way -of avoiding it, and the only way of attaining to justice by a complete -purification, is to become self-sufficing and free of external needs. If -God has made it impossible for a thing to secure its own preservation -without injury to another, He has also endowed it with the principle of -injustice in the shape of its own nature. Would it not, therefore, be a -good thing, my dear friend, if, when cutting out injustice, we could cut -out the belly, the gullet, and the liver, which impart to us no -perception [Sidenote: D] of anything noble and no appetite for it, but -partly resemble the utensils for cooking butcher’s meat—such as choppers -and stew-pans—and partly the apparatus for a bakery—ovens, water-tanks, -and kneading-troughs? Indeed, in the case of most [Sidenote: *] people -you can see their soul shut up in their body as if in a baker’s mill, -and perpetually going round and round at the business of getting food. -Take ourselves, for example. Just now we were neither looking at nor -listening to one another, but we all had our heads down, slaving at the -business of feeding. But now that the tables have been removed, we -have—as you perceive—become free, and with garlands on our heads we are -[Sidenote: E] engaged in sociable and leisurely conversation together, -because we have arrived at the state of not requiring food. Well then, -if the state in which we now find ourselves remains as a permanence all -our lives, shall we not be at perpetual leisure to enjoy each other’s -society? We shall have no fear of poverty. Nor shall we know the meaning -of wealth, since the quest for luxuries is but the immediate consequence -and concomitant of the use of necessaries. - -‘But, thinks Cleodorus, there must be food so that there may be tables -and wine-bowls and sacrifices to Demeter and the Maid. Then let some one -else demand that there shall be war and fighting, so that we may have -fortifications and arsenals and [Sidenote: F] armouries, and also -sacrifices in honour of slaying our hundreds, such as they say are the -law in Messenia. Another, I suppose, is aggrieved at the prospect of the -healthfulness which would follow. A terrible thing if, because there is -no illness, there is no more use in soft bedclothes, and no more -sacrificing to Asclepius or the Averting Powers, and if medical skill, -with all its drugs and implements, must be put away into inglorious -hiding! What is the difference between these arguments and the other? -Food is, in fact, “taken” as a “remedy” for hunger, and all who use food -are said to be “taking care” of [Sidenote: 160] themselves and using -some “diet”; and this implies that the act is not a pleasant and -agreeable performance, but one which Nature renders compulsory. -Certainly one can enumerate more pains than pleasures arising from -feeding. Further still; whereas the pleasure affects but a small region -of the body, and lasts but a short time, it needs no telling how full we -become of ugly and painful experiences through the worry and difficulty -of digesting. - -Homer had these in view, I suppose, when he used as a proof that the -gods do not die the fact that they do not feed: - - _For they eat not the bread of corn, nor drink they the wine that is - ruddy, - And therefore blood have they none in their veins, and are called - the Immortals._ - -Food, he gives us to understand, is the necessary means not only -[Sidenote: B] for living, but for dying. From it come our diseases, -feeding themselves with the feeding of our bodies, which suffer quite as -much from repletion as from want. Very often it is an easier business to -get together our supply of victuals than to make away with them and get -quit of them again when once they are in the body. Just suppose it were -a question with the Danaids what sort of life they would live and what -they would do if they could get rid of their menial labour at filling -the cask. When we raise the question, “Supposing it possible to cease -from heaping into this unconscionable flesh all these things from -[Sidenote: C] land and sea, what are we going to do?” it is because in -our ignorance of noble things we are content with the life which our -necessities impose. Well, as those who have been in slavery, when they -are emancipated, do for themselves and on their own account what they -used formerly to do in the service of their masters, so is it with the -soul. As things are, it feeds the body with continual toil and trouble; -but let it get quit of its menial service, and it will presumably feed -itself in the enjoyment of freedom, and will live with an eye to itself -and the truth, with nothing to distract and deter it.’ - -This, Nicarchus, concluded the discussion as to food. - -While Solon was still speaking, Gorgos, Periander’s brother, entered the -room. It happened that, in consequence of certain [Sidenote: D] oracles, -he had been sent on a mission to Taenarum in charge of a sacrificial -embassy. After we had welcomed him, and Periander had taken him to his -arms and kissed him, he sat down by his brother on the couch and gave -him a private account of some occurrence which appeared to cause -Periander various emotions as he listened to it. At one part he was -manifestly vexed, at another indignant; often he showed incredulity, and -this was followed by amazement. Finally he laughed and said to us, ‘I -should like to tell the company the news; but I have [Sidenote: E] -scruples about it, because I heard Thales once say that when a thing is -probable we should speak of it, but when it is impossible we should say -nothing about it.’ At this Bias interposed, ‘Yes, but here is another -wise saying of Thales, that “while we should disbelieve our enemies even -in matters believable, we should believe our friends even when the thing -is unbelievable”. By enemies I presume he meant the wicked and foolish, -and by friends the good and wise.’ ‘Very well then,’ said Periander, -‘you must let every one hear it; or rather you must pit the story you -have brought us against those new-fangled dithyrambs and overcrow them.’ - -Gorgos then told us his story. - -His sacrificial ceremony had occupied three days, and on the [Sidenote: -F] last there was an all-night festival with dancing and frolic by the -sea-shore. The sea was covered with the light of the moon, and, though -there was no wind, but a dead calm, there appeared in the distance a -ripple coming in past the promontory, accompanied by foam and a very -appreciable noise of surge. At this they all ran in astonishment down to -the place where it was [Sidenote: *] coming to land. This happened so -quickly that, before they could guess what was approaching, dolphins -were seen, some of them massed together and moving in a ring, some -leading the way to the levellest part of the shore, and others as it -were [Sidenote: 161] bringing up the rear. In the middle there stood out -above the sea, dim and indistinct, the shape of a body being carried. So -they came on, until, gathering together and coming to land at the same -moment, they put ashore a human being, alive and moving; after which -they themselves retired in the direction of the promontory, leaping out -of the water more than ever and for some reason, apparently, frolicking -and bounding for joy. ‘Many of our number,’ continued Gorgos, ‘fled from -the sea in a panic, but a few found the courage to approach along with -myself, and discovered that it was Arion, the harp-player. Not only did -he utter his own name, but his dress spoke for itself, [Sidenote: B] for -he was actually wearing the festal robes which he adopted when -performing at the competitions. Well, we brought him to a tent, and, -inasmuch as there was nothing the matter with him except that he was -evidently tired and overstrained from the rushing motion, we heard him -tell a story which no one would believe except us who actually saw the -end of it. - -‘What Arion told us was this. He had for some time made up his mind to -leave Italy, and had been made the more eager to do so by a letter from -Periander. Accordingly, when a Corinthian merchant-vessel appeared on -the scene, he at once went on board and put to sea. They had a moderate -wind for three days, when he perceived that the sailors were forming a -plot to make away with him, and was afterwards secretly informed -[Sidenote: C] by the pilot that they had resolved to do the deed that -night. At this, being helpless and at a loss what to do, he acted upon a -kind of heaven-sent impulse. He decided that he would adorn his person -and—while still alive—put on his own shroud in the shape of his festal -attire. Then, in meeting his death, he would sing a _finale_ to life, -and in that respect show no less spirit than the swan does. Accordingly, -having dressed himself and given notice that he felt moved to perform -the Pythian hymn on behalf of the safety of himself and the ship and -crew, [Sidenote: D] he took his stand on the poop by the bulwarks. After -some prelude invoking the gods of the sea, he began to sing the piece. -Just before he was half-way through, the sun began to set into the sea -and the Peloponnese to come into sight. Thereupon the sailors no longer -waited for night, but advanced to their murderous deed. Arion, seeing -their knives unsheathed and the pilot beginning to cover his face from -the sight, ran back and hurled himself as far as possible from the -vessel. Before, however, his body had all sunk into the water, a number -of dolphins ran under him and bore him up. At first he was filled with -bewilderment, distress, and alarm; but when he found himself riding -easily, and saw many of them gathering about [Sidenote: E] him in a -friendly way, and taking turns at the work as if it were a necessary -duty belonging to them all; and when the long distance at which the -vessel was left behind showed how great was their speed; he said that -what he felt was not so much fear of death or desire of life, as -eagerness to be rescued, so that he might become recognized as the -object of divine favour, and might have his reputation as a religious -man assured. - -At the same time, observing that the sky was full of stars, and that the -moon was rising bright and clear, while the sea [Sidenote: F] on all -sides was waveless and a kind of path was being cut for his course, he -was led to reflect that Justice has more eyes than one, and that God -looks abroad with all those orbs upon whatever deeds are done by land or -sea. By these reflections (he told us) he found relief from the -weariness which was by this time beginning to weigh upon his body, and -when at last, dexterously avoiding and rounding the lofty and -precipitous headland which ran out to meet them, they swam close in by -the shore and [Sidenote: 162] brought him safely to land like a ship -into harbour, he realized beyond doubt that he had been steered on his -voyage by the hand of God. ‘When Arion had told us this story,’ -continued Gorgos, ‘I asked him where he thought the ship would put in. -He answered that it would certainly be at Corinth, but that it was left -far behind; for, after throwing himself off it in the evening, he -believed he had been carried over sixty miles and a calm had fallen -immediately.’ Gorgos added, however, that after ascertaining the names -of the captain and pilot, and also the ship’s flag, he had sent out -vessels and soldiers to the various landing-places to keep a watch. -Moreover, he had Arion with [Sidenote: B] him in hiding, so that they -might not hear of his rescue beforehand and make their escape. ‘The -event,’ he said, ‘has proved truly miraculous; for no sooner did we -arrive here than we learned that the ship had been seized by the -soldiers, and the traders and sailors arrested.’ - -Thereupon Periander ordered Gorgos to get up and go out at once and -place the men in custody where no one would approach them or tell them -of Arion’s escape. - -‘Well now,’ said Aesop, ‘you gentlemen make fun of my jackdaws and crows -for talking. Do dolphins behave in this outrageous way?’ To which I -replied, ‘A different matter, [Sidenote: C] Aesop! A story to the same -effect as this has been believed and written among us for more than a -thousand years, ever since the times of Ino and Athamas.’ - -Solon here interposed: ‘Well, Diodes; let us grant that these events are -in the sphere of the divine and beyond us. But what happened to Hesiod -is on our own human plane. You have probably heard the story.’ ‘For my -part, no,’ I answered. ‘Well, it is worth hearing. Hesiod and a -Milesian—I think it was—shared the same room as guests in a house at -[Sidenote: D] Locri. The Milesian having been found out in a secret -intrigue with the host’s daughter, Hesiod fell under suspicion of having -all along known of the offence and helped in concealing it. Though in no -way guilty, he fell a victim to cruel circumstance at a critical time of -anger and misrepresentation. For the girl’s brothers lay in wait for him -at the Nemeum in Locris and killed him, together with his servant, whose -name was Troilus. Their bodies having been pushed into the sea, that of -Troilus, which was carried out into the current of the river Daphnus, -was caught by a low wave-washed rock projecting a little above the -water. The rock still bears his name. Meanwhile the [Sidenote: E] dead -body of Hesiod was picked up immediately off the shore by a shoal of -dolphins, who proceeded to carry it to Rhium, close to Molycrea. It -happened that the Locrians were engaged in the Rhian festival and fair, -which is still a notable celebration in those parts. At sight of the -body being borne towards them they were naturally amazed, and when, on -running down to the shore, they recognized the corpse—for it was still -fresh—they could think of nothing but tracking out the murder, so high -was the renown of Hesiod. Their object was soon achieved. They -discovered the murderers, threw them into the sea, and razed their house -to the ground. Meanwhile Hesiod was buried near the Nemeum. Most -strangers, however, are ignorant of his tomb, which has been concealed -because the people of [Sidenote: F] Orchomenus are in quest of it, from -a desire, it is said, to recover the remains and bury them in their own -country in accordance with an oracle. - -‘If, then, dolphins show such affectionate interest in the dead, it is -still more natural for them to render help to the living, especially if -they have been charmed by the flute or the singing of tunes. For, of -course, we are all aware that music is a thing which these animals enjoy -and court, swimming and gambolling beside a ship as its oarsmen row to -the tune of song and flute in calm weather. They take a delight also in -children when [Sidenote: 163] swimming, and they have diving matches -with them. Hence there is an unwritten law that they shall not be -harmed. No one hunts them or injures them; the only exception being -that, when they get into the nets and do mischief to the catch, they are -punished with a beating, like naughty children. I further remember -hearing some Lesbians tell of a girl having been rescued from the sea by -a dolphin. I am not, however, sure as to the exact details, and, since -Pittacus knows them, he is the right person to tell us about them.’ - -Pittacus thereupon assured us that the story had good warrant and was -mentioned by many authorities. ‘An oracle was given to the colonizers of -Lesbos that, when on the voyage they came across the reef known as -Mesogeum, they should then and [Sidenote: B] there throw a bull into the -water as an offering to Poseidon, and a live virgin to Amphitrite and -the Nereids. There were seven chiefs, all of whom were kings, -Echelaus—whom the Pythian oracle had assigned as leader of the -colony—making an eighth. Echelaus was still a bachelor. When as many of -the seven as had unmarried girls cast lots, the lot fell upon the -daughter of Smintheus. Upon getting near the place, they decked her in -fine clothes and gold ornaments, and, after offering prayer, were on the -point of lowering her into the water. Now it happened that one of the -party on the ship—assuredly a gallant young man—was in love with her. -His name has been preserved to us as Enalus. This youth, in the passion -of the [Sidenote: C] moment, seized by an eager but utterly hopeless -desire to succour the girl, darted forward at the right instant and, -throwing his arms about her, cast himself along with her into the sea. -Now from the first there was spread among the contingent a rumour, -lacking certainty, but nevertheless widely believed, that they were safe -and had been rescued; and at a later date, it is said, Enalus appeared -in Lesbos and told how they had been carried by dolphins through the sea -and cast ashore without harm upon the mainland. He had other still more -miraculous experiences to tell, which held the crowd spellbound with -amazement, but for all of which he gave actual evidence. For when an -enormous wave was rushing sheer round [Sidenote: D] the island and -people were terrified, he alone ventured to face it. [Sidenote: *] On -its retiring, a number of polypi followed him to the temple of Poseidon. -From the largest of these he took a stone which it was carrying, and -offered it as a dedication. That stone we call Enalus. - -‘Speaking generally, the man who knows the difference between impossible -and unfamiliar, between unreasonable and unexpected, will be most a man -after your own heart, Chilon; he will neither believe nor disbelieve -without discrimination, but will carefully observe your own rule of -“_nothing in excess_”.’ - -Anacharsis next made the remark that, as Thales believed [Sidenote: E] -all the greatest and most important components of the universe to -contain soul, there was no reason to wonder if the most splendid actions -were brought to pass by the will of God. ‘For the body is the instrument -of the soul, and soul is the instrument of God. And as, though many of -the motions of the body proceed from itself, the most and the finest are -produced by the soul, so again is it with the soul. While it performs -many actions on its own motion, in other cases it is but lending itself, -as the aptest of all instruments, to the use of God, for Him to direct -and apply it as He chooses. It would,’ said he, ‘be [Sidenote: F] a very -strange thing if, while fire, wind, water, clouds, and rain are God’s -instruments, by which He often preserves and nourishes and often kills -and destroys, He has never on any occasion at all used animals as His -agents. On the contrary, it is natural that, in their dependence upon -the divine power, they should lend themselves more responsively to -motions from God than does the bow to the Scythian or the lyre and flute -to the Greek.’ - -After this the poet Chersias mentioned, among other cases of persons -rescued in hopeless situations, that of Cypselus, Periander’s father. -When he was a newborn babe, the men who had been sent to make away with -him were turned from their purpose because he smiled at them. When they -changed their minds and came back to look for him, he was not to be -found, his mother having hidden him in a chest. ‘It is for this reason -[Sidenote: 164] that Cypselus built the house at Delphi, believing that -the god had then stopped him from crying so that he might elude the -search.’ - -At this Pittacus, addressing Periander, observed, ‘I have to thank -Chersias, Periander, for mentioning that house; for I have often wanted -to ask you the meaning of those frogs which are carved in such large -size at the base of the palm-tree. What reference have they to the god -or to the dedication?’ Periander having bidden him ask Chersias, who -knew the reason and was present when Cypselus consecrated the house, -Chersias said with [Sidenote: B] a smile, ‘No: I will give no -information until these gentlemen have told me the meaning of their -_Nothing in excess_ and _Know thyself_, and of those words which have -kept many people from marrying, made many distrustful, and reduced some -to positive dumbness—the words _Give a pledge, and Mischief is nigh._’ -‘Why do you need us to tell you that,’ said Pittacus, ‘seeing that you -have so long admired the stories in which Aesop practically deals with -each of those maxims?’ ‘Nay,’ replied Aesop, ‘he does need it, when he -is joking at me. But when he is in earnest, he proves that Homer was -their inventor. He says that Hector “knew himself”, inasmuch as, though -[Sidenote: C] he attacked the rest, - - _Ajax, Telamon’s son, he would not fight, but he shunned him_, - -and that Odysseus recommends “nothing in excess” since he urges Diomede - - _Nay, prithee, Tydeus’ son; nor praise me much nor reprove me_. - -As for a pledge, not only is it the general opinion that he is -reprobating it as a misguided and futile thing when he says - - _Sorry, I trow, to take are the pledges that sorry folk offer_, - -but our friend Chersias here tells us how “Mischief” was hurled from -heaven by Zeus because she was present when he was tripped [Sidenote: D] -up through pledging his word in connexion with the birth of Heracles.’ - -Here Solon interposed. ‘Well, Homer was a very wise man, and we should -do well to take his advice: - - _Already the night is here; night bids, and ’tis good to obey her._ - -Let us therefore pour an offering to the Muses and to Poseidon and -Amphitrite, and then—with your permission—break up the party.’ - -This, Nicarchus, terminated the party on that occasion. - -Footnote 24: - - The home of Bias. - -Footnote 25: - - According to another account he waited till the shadow was equal in - length to the stick. The pyramid was then also equal in height to the - length of its shadow. - -Footnote 26: - - The divinities of spring-water. - -Footnote 27: - - The title _Lusios_ or _Luaios_ was popularly interpreted Deliverer - (from care or difficulty). - -Footnote 28: - - See note on _Amasis_. - -Footnote 29: - - i.e. anointing himself, not in connexion with bathing, but with - exercise in the wrestling-schools. - -Footnote 30: - - The precise remark is uncertain, the text here being corrupt. - -Footnote 31: - - Equivalent to a command to ‘go weep’. - -Footnote 32: - - In antiquity these vessels were of bronze. - -Footnote 33: - - Which was bequeathed ‘to the wisest’. It was given to Thales, who - passed it on to another, and the process was repeated till it came - back to Thales, whereupon he dedicated it to Apollo. - - - - - ON OLD MEN IN PUBLIC LIFE - - -It is well known, Euphanes, that as an admirer of Pindar you [Sidenote: -783 B] are fond of quoting his ‘fine and forcible words’: - - _When struggle is afoot, excuses - Cast a deep cloud on valour._ - -In connexion with the struggles of public life timidity and weakness can -find plenty of excuses, but as a last and most desperate plea they urge -‘advancing years’. This is their pretext _par excellence_ for blunting -ambition and putting it out of countenance. They argue that there is a -fitting close to a public, as much as to an athletic, career. For these -reasons [Sidenote: C] I think it well to take my own ordinary -reflections upon ‘old men in public life’ and lay them before yourself. -They may prevent either of us from deserting that long companionship -which has hitherto followed a common path, and from abandoning that -public life which may be regarded as a familiar friend from youth up, in -order to adopt another which is unfamiliar, and with which there is no -time for us to become thoroughly intimate. I would have us abide by our -original principle, and determine that life and the worthy life shall -end together. It is not for us to convert the brief remainder into a -confession that the bulk of our time has been wastefully applied to no -good purpose. [Sidenote: D] - -It is not, indeed, true—as some one told Dionysius—that ‘despotism is a -fine shroud’. In his case the combination of absolutism with injustice -was only made all the more complete a calamity by the fact that it never -ceased. It was therefore a shrewd remark of Diogenes, when at a later -date he saw Dionysius’ son in a humble private station at Corinth. -‘Dionysius,’ said he, ‘you are far from receiving your deserts. Instead -of living a free and fearless life here with us, you ought to have been -there, housed in the despot’s palace and made to live in it, like your -father, till old age.’ It is different with constitutional and -democratic statesmanship. When a man has learned to show himself a -profitable subject as well as a profitable ruler, he [Sidenote: E] does -indeed obtain at death a ‘fine shroud’, in the shape of the good name -earned by his life. For this—to quote Simonides— - - _Is the last thing to sink beneath the ground_, - -except in cases where high human interests and noble zeal are earlier to -fail and die than natural desires. - -Are the active and divine elements of our being more evanescent than the -passionate and corporeal? That were an unworthy view to hold; as -unworthy as to accept the doctrine that the [Sidenote: F] only thing of -which we never weary is making gain. On the contrary, we should improve -upon Thucydides, and regard as ‘_the only thing that never ages_’ not -‘_the love of honour_‘, but that public spirit and activity which even -ants and bees maintain till the end. No one has ever seen old age -convert a bee into a drone. Yet there are some who claim that public men -who have passed their prime should sit and be fed in seclusion at home, -allowing their practical abilities to rust away in idleness. [Sidenote: -784] Cato used to say that, to the many plagues of its own from which -old age suffers, there is no justification for deliberately adding the -disgrace of vice. There are many vices, but none can do more than weak -and cowardly inactivity to disgrace a man in years—a man who skulks away -from the public offices to look after a houseful of women, or to -supervise gleaners and reapers in the country. - - _Where now - Is Oedipus? Where the famed riddles now?_ - -It is one thing to wait till old age before commencing public life, and -to be like Epimenides, who—so they say—fell asleep a youth and fifty -years afterwards awoke an old man. If, in [Sidenote: B] such a case, one -were to divest himself of that quiet habit which has lasted all his -life, and were to plunge into struggles and worries with which he was -unfamiliar, and for which he was not trained by intercourse with public -affairs or with mankind, there would be room for remonstrance. We might -say, as the Pythian priestess said, ‘_You come too late_’ in your quest -of office and leadership. You are past the time for knocking at the door -of the Presidency. You are like some blundering reveller whose surprise -visit is not made till night; or like some stranger who is in quest, not -of a new district or country, but of a new life, about which you know -nothing. If Simonides says - - _The State is a man’s teacher_, - -it is true only of those who have the time to change their teacher and -learn a new lesson—a lesson slowly and laboriously acquired by means of -many a struggle and experience, and only when it [Sidenote: C] can take -its hold sufficiently early on a natural genius for bearing toils and -troubles with equanimity. - -To resume. We find that, on the contrary, it is striplings and youths -whom sensible men do their best to keep out of public business. Witness -our laws, under which the crier in the Assembly, when inviting speech -and advice, calls upon the platform in the first instance not an -Alcibiades or a Pytheas, but persons over fifty. Foolish audacity and -lack of experience [Sidenote: D] are nowhere so out of place as in a -deliberator or a judge.[34] Cato, when past eighty and on his defence, -said it was hard to have to defend himself before one set of people -after having lived with another. It is agreed on all hands that the -measures of Caesar—the conqueror of Antony—became considerably more -regal and good for the public towards the end of his life. Once, when by -stern application of custom and law he was correcting the rising -generation, and they made an outcry, his own words were: ‘Young men, -listen to an old man to whom old men listened [Sidenote: E] when he was -young.’ It was in old age, too, that the statesmanship of Pericles -reached its greatest influence. This was the time when he induced the -Athenians to enter upon the war, and when he successfully opposed their -ill-timed eagerness to fight a battle against sixty thousand -men-at-arms, by all but sealing up the public armouries and the locks of -the gates. As for what Xenophon writes of Agesilaus, it is best to quote -verbatim. _‘Is there any youth with whom this old man did not compare to -advantage? Who in the prime of life was so formidable to an enemy as -Agesilaus was at the most advanced age? Of whom was the foe so glad to -be rid as of Agesilaus, though he was old [Sidenote: F] when his end -came? Who inspired such courage in his own side as Agesilaus, although -close upon the end of life? What young man was more regretted by his -friends than Agesilaus, though he died when full of years?_’ - -Well, if time was no hindrance to the great actions of men like these, -what of us, who nowadays enjoy the luxury of a public life which admits -of no despots, no fighting, no sieges, but only of warless contests and -of ambitions which are for the most part settled by just means according -to law and reason? Are we [Sidenote: 785] to play the coward? Must we -confess that we are the inferiors, not merely of the commanders and -popular leaders of those days, but of the poets, leaders of thought, and -actors? Take Simonides. He won choric victories in old age, as is -evident from the last lines of the epigram: - - _And withal to Simonides fell the glory and prize of the poet; - Fell to Leoprepes’ son, come to his eightieth year._ - -Take Sophocles. It is said that, when his sons charged him with being in -his dotage, he read in his defence the entrance ode of the _Oedipus at -Colonus_, beginning: - - _To this land of the steed, O stranger, - To the goodliest homes on earth, - Thou hast come—to the white Colonus, - Fond haunt of the nightingale, - Where her clear voice trills its sorrow - In the green of the leafy dell...._ - -a lyric which won such admiration that he left the court, as it -[Sidenote: B] might have been the theatre, amid the applause and cheers -of the audience. A little epigram, admitted to be by Sophocles, contains -the words: - - _Five years and fifty Sophocles had seen, - Ere for Herodotus he wrought a song._ - -Take Philemon, the comic poet, and Alexis. They were still putting plays -upon the stage, still winning crowns, when death overtook them. Take -Polus, the tragedian. Eratosthenes and Philochorus inform us that, -shortly before his end, and when [Sidenote: C] he was seventy, he acted -eight tragedies in four days. - -Is it, I say, creditable that old men of the platform should show a -poorer spirit than old men of the stage? That they should retire from -the sacred contests—for ‘sacred’ these veritably are—and give up the -rôle of the public man in exchange for goodness knows what other part? -From king, say, to farmer is a descent indeed. Demosthenes calls it -cruel treatment of the _Paralus_, to make that sacred warship carry -cargoes of timber, vine-stakes, and cattle for Meidias. But suppose a -public man abandons the Presidentship of Games, his seat on the Federal -Board, his high place in the Sacred League, and is found [Sidenote: D] -measuring out barley-meal and olive-cake, or shearing sheep. It cannot -but look as if he were needlessly courting the status of ‘old worn-out -horse’. As for leaving a public career to engage in vulgar and petty -trade, one might as well take some self-respecting lady, strip off her -gown, give her an apron, and keep her in a tavern. Turn public ability -to mere business and money-making, and its rank and character [Sidenote: -E] are lost. - -Or if, as a last alternative, people choose to talk of ‘ease and -enjoyment’, when they mean luxurious self-indulgence; if they recommend -the public man to adopt that process of idle senile decay, I hardly know -which of two ugly comparisons will best hit off such a life. Shall I say -it is a case of sailors taking ‘Aphrodite-holiday’ and keeping it up for -ever, without waiting till their ship is berthed, but deserting it while -still on the voyage? Or is it a case of ‘Heracles-chez-Omphale’—as some -sorry humourists depict him—wearing a saffron gown and quietly allowing -Lydian handmaids to fan him and braid his hair? Are we to treat our -public man in that way? To strip off his [Sidenote: F] lion’s-skin, lay -him on a couch, and feast him, with lute and flute lulling him all the -while? Or should we not take warning by the retort of Pompey the Great -to Lucullus? The latter, after his campaigns and public services, had -given himself up to baths, dinners, social entertainments in the -daytime, profound indolence, and new-fangled notions in the way of -house-building. Meanwhile he accused Pompey of a fondness for place and -power unsuited to his years. Pompey replied that for an old man -effeminacy was more unseasonable than office. When he was [Sidenote: -786] ill and the doctor ordered him fieldfares—the bird being then out -of season and difficult to procure—and when some one told him that -Lucullus had a large number in his preserves, he refused to send for or -receive one, exclaiming, ‘What? Pompey could not live but for the luxury -of Lucullus?’ - -It may be true that nature ordinarily seeks pleasure and delight. But, -with an old man, the body has become incapable of all pleasures except a -few which are essential. Not only is it the case that - - _The Queen of Love turns weary from the old_, - -[Sidenote: B] as Euripides has it. Though they may retain the appetite -for eating and drinking—generally in a dulled or toothless form—they -find a difficulty in whetting the edge or sharpening the teeth even of -that. It is in the mind that one must lay up a stock of pleasures, -though not of the mean and ignoble kind indicated by Simonides, when he -told those who reproached him with avarice that, though age had robbed -him of other joys, he had still one left to support his declining -years—the joy of money-making. In public activity there are pleasures of -the greatest and noblest sort, such as we may believe to be the only, or -the chief, enjoyment of the gods themselves—I mean those which result -from a beneficent deed or a fine achievement. - -Nicias the painter was so taken up with his artistic work that he was -often obliged to ask his servants whether he had had his [Sidenote: C] -bath or his breakfast. Archimedes stuck so closely to his drawing-board -that, in order to anoint him, his attendants had to drag him away and -strip him by force. He then went on drawing his diagrams in the ointment -on his body. Carus the flutist (an acquaintance of your own) used to say -that people did not know how much more pleasure he himself got from -playing than he gave to others; otherwise an audience would be paid to -listen instead of paying. Can we fail to perceive how great are the -pleasures derived from fine actions and public-spirited achievements by -those who put high qualities to use? Nor is it by means of those -effeminate titillations which soft and agreeable movements exert upon -the flesh. The ticklings of the flesh [Sidenote: D] are spasmodic, -fickle, intermittent, whereas the pleasures of noble deeds—the creations -of the true statesman’s art—will bear the soul aloft in grandeur and -pride and joy, as if, I will not say upon the ‘_golden wings_’ of -Euripides, but upon those ‘_celestial pinions_’ described by Plato. - -Remember the instances of which you have so often heard. Epaminondas, -when asked what had been his most pleasurable experience, replied, -‘Having been victorious at Leuctra while [Sidenote: E] my father and -mother were still alive.’ When Sulla first reached Rome after purging -Italy of its civil wars, he could not sleep a wink that night. As he has -written in his own _Notes and Recollections_, so elated was his mind -with the greatness of his joy and happiness, that it seemed to walk on -air. If we admit, with Xenophon, that ‘_no hearing is so agreeable as -praise_‘, no sight, recollection, or reflection is so fraught with -gratification as the contemplation of exploits of our own in the -conspicuous public arena of office and statesmanship. Not but what, when -[Sidenote: F] a grateful goodwill testifies to our achievements, and -when there is a rivalry of commendation productive of well-earned -popularity, our merit acquires a gloss and brilliance which adds to our -sense of pleasure. - -Therefore, instead of permitting our reputation to wither in our old age -like an athlete’s crown, we must be constantly adopting new devices and -making fresh efforts to enliven the sense of past obligation, to enhance -it, and to make it permanent. We must act like the craftsmen who were -required to provide for the security of the Delian ship. They used to -replace unsound timbers by others, and, by means of insertions and -repairs, were regarded as keeping the vessel immortal and indestructible -from [Sidenote: 787] the oldest times. Reputation is like flame. There -is no difficulty in keeping it alive; it merely requires a little -feeding with fuel. But let either of them become extinct and cold, and -it will take some trouble to rekindle. - -Lampis, the shipowner, was once asked how he made his fortune. ‘Making -the big one,’ he answered, ‘was easy enough; but it was a long and hard -business to make the little one.’ So with political power and -reputation. Though not easy to get in the first instance, anything will -suffice to maintain and increase them when once they are great. It is as -with a friend, when once he becomes such. He does not look for a large -number of important services in order to retain his friendship; -[Sidenote: B] small tokens, consistently shown, will keep his constant -affection. Nor are the confidence and friendship of the people -perpetually calling for you to open your purse, to play the champion, or -to hold an office. They are retained by mere public spirit—by being in -no haste to desert or shirk the burden of care and watchfulness. - -Campaigns are not matters of everlastingly facing the enemy, fighting, -and besieging. They have also their times of sacrifice, their occasional -social gatherings, their periods of ample leisure, when jest and -nonsense are toward. And why should one look upon public life with -dread, as being laborious, wearisome, and devoid of consolations, seeing -that the theatre, processions, awards, ‘_dances of the Muses and -Gladsomeness_,’ and honour [Sidenote: C] after honour to the gods relax -the stern brow of the Bureau or the Chamber, and yield a manifold return -of inviting entertainment? - -In the next place jealousy, the greatest bane of public life, is less -severe upon old age. For, to quote Heracleitus, ‘_dogs bark at the man -they do not know_.’ Though jealousy may fight with the beginner at the -doors of the platform and refuse him access, no savageness or fierceness -is shown to a man of familiar and established reputation, but he finds -friendly admittance. For this reason some have compared jealousy to -smoke. In the case of beginners, during the process of kindling, it -pours forth in clouds; when they are in full blaze, it disappears. And -while [Sidenote: D] people resist and dispute other forms of -superiority—in merit, birth, or public spirit—through a belief that any -acknowledgement to others means so much derogation to themselves, the -primacy which is due to time—‘seniority’ in the proper sense—is conceded -without a grudge. Respect paid to the aged has the unique quality of -doing more honour to the giver than to the recipient. - -Moreover it is not every one who expects to attain to the power derived -from wealth, eloquence, or wisdom; whereas no public man despairs of -winning the esteem and distinction to which age gradually leads. - -Imagine a navigator, who has managed his ship safely in the face of -contrary winds and waves, and then, when the weather [Sidenote: E] -becomes fair and calm, wishes to lay her to. It is just as strange when -a man has fought his ship in a long battle with jealousies, and then, -after they are quietly laid, backs out of public life, and, in -abandoning his activities, abandons his partners and associates. The -more time there has been, the more friends and fellow-workers he has -made; but he is neither in a position to lead them with him off the -stage, as a poet does his chorus, [Sidenote: F] nor has he the right to -leave them in the lurch. A long public life is like an old tree. To pull -it up is no easy task, because of its many roots and its entanglement -with many interests, which involve worse wrenching and disturbance when -you leave them than when you stay. - -And if political conflict does leave you some remnant of jealousy or -antagonism to face when you are old, it is better to quell it by means -of your position than to turn your back and retire without armour or -weapons of defence. People are not so ready to attack you out of -jealousy when you are still in action as they are out of contempt when -you give it up. - -[Sidenote: 788] We may also appeal to the great Epaminondas and his -remark to the Thebans. It was winter at the time, and the Arcadians were -inviting them to enter the city and live in the houses. This he refused -to allow, observing: ‘At the present time they come to look at you and -admire your wrestling and military exercises; but if they see you -sitting by the fire and chewing your beans, they will regard you as no -better than themselves.’ So with an aged man. When making a speech, -transacting business, or receiving honours, he is a dignified spectacle; -but when he lies all day on a couch or sits in the corner of a public -[Sidenote: B] resort talking drivel and wiping his nose, he is an object -of contempt. This is precisely what Homer teaches, if you read him -rightly. Nestor, who was campaigning at Troy, received high respect and -honour; whereas Peleus and Laertes, the stay-at-homes, were despised, -and counted for nothing. - -Nay, even intellectual power begins to fail those who have let -themselves relax. Idleness gradually renders it feeble and flaccid, in -the absence of some necessary exercise of thought to keep the logical -and practical faculty perpetually alive and in trim. - - _Like glossy bronze, ’tis use that makes it shine._ - -Bodily weakness may be a drawback to public activity in the [Sidenote: -C] case of those who, in spite of their years, make the platform or the -Cabinet their goal. But it is more than compensated by the advantage of -their caution and prudence. They do not dash into public affairs with -the expression of opinions prompted by error or vanity as the case may -be, and carrying the mob with them in as excited a condition as a stormy -sea; but they deal in a mild and reasonable fashion with such matters as -arise. It is for this reason that, in times of disaster or alarm, -communities feel the need of a Board of Government consisting of senior -men. Often they have fetched back from the country [Sidenote: D] an old -man who neither asked nor wished it, and have compelled him to put his -hand to the helm and steer the ship of State into safety, while they -thrust aside generals and popular leaders, despite all their ability to -shout, to talk without taking breath, and also, no doubt, to make -‘_sturdy stand and doughty fight_’ against the enemy. When Chares, the -son of Theochares—a man in the prime of bodily strength and -condition—was brought into the ring in opposition to Timotheus and -Iphicrates by the public speakers of Athens, with the claim that ‘this -is the kind of general the Athenians should have’, Timotheus [Sidenote: -E] replied: ‘By no manner of means. No doubt that is the sort needed to -carry the general’s baggage; but the general should be one who “_sees -before and after_”, and whose calculations as to policy no distractions -can disturb.’ Sophocles said ‘he was glad that old age had enabled him -to escape from sexual passion—a fierce and mad master.’ But in public -life we have to escape, not from one master—the love of women—but from -many madder still; from contentiousness, vanity, and the desire to be -first and greatest—a malady most fertile in envy, jealousy, and -[Sidenote: F] feud. Some of these feelings are abated or dulled, some -are altogether chilled and quenched, by old age. And though old age may -do something to diminish our zest for action, it does more to guard us -from the intemperate heat of passion, so that we can bring a sober and -steady reason to bear upon our thoughts. - -By all means, in dealing with one who begins to play the youth when his -hair is grey, let it be—as it is considered—sound warning to say: - - _Misguided man, stay quiet in thy bed._ - -[Sidenote: 789] Let us remonstrate with an old man when he rises from a -long privacy, as from a bed of sickness, and bestirs himself to obtain a -command or an official post. But suppose a man has lived a life of -public action and thoroughly played the part. To prevent him from going -on till ‘finis and the torch’, to call him back and bid him change the -road he has long followed, is utterly unfeeling, and bears no -resemblance to the case just given. If an old man has his wreath on and -is scenting himself in readiness to marry, there is nothing unreasonable -in trying to dissuade him by quoting the lines addressed to Philoctetes: - - _But, pray, where is the bride, where the young maid, - Would welcome thee? Rare bridegroom thou, poor soul!_ - -Nay, they are fond of making jests of the kind at their own [Sidenote: -B] expense: - - _I’m marrying old, and for the neighbours’ good: - I know it._ - -But when a man has been long married, and has lived with his wife for -years without a fault to find, to tell him that he should divorce her -because he is old, and that he should live by himself or get a wretched -concubine in place of his lawful spouse, is the very extreme of -absurdity. In the same way when an aged man seeks to enter -politics—Chlidon the farmer, Lampon the ship’s captain, or some -philosopher from the Garden[35]—there is some reason in admonishing him, -and keeping him to the state of inactivity to which he has been used. -But it is urging a public man to act [Sidenote: C] with injustice and -ingratitude, when we take hold of a Phocion, a Cato, or a Pericles, and -say, ‘Sir Athenian—or Sir Roman— - - _Thine age is wither’d and thy head o’erfrosted_; - -therefore sue for a divorce from statesmanship, have done with the -worrying business of the platform and the Board of War, and make haste -into the country, to live with farming “for a waiting-maid” or to occupy -the rest of your days with thrift and the keeping of accounts.’ - -Well, but (it may be asked) what of the soldier in the comedy with his - - _Discharged! No pay! because of my white hair?_ - -Quite true, my friend. The War-God’s servants must be in the prime of -manly vigour. Their business is with - - _War and war’s baleful work_, - -in which, though an old man’s grey hair may be hidden by his [Sidenote: -D] helmet, - - _Yet in secret his thews are aweary_, - -and, though the spirit be willing, the strength can no longer respond. - -But the ministers of Zeus—the God of Council, of Assembly, of the -State—are not asked for deeds of hand and foot, but for counsel and -foresight. We ask them for advice, not such as to evoke roars of mere -noise in the Assembly, but full of sense and shrewdness, and safe to -follow. In their case the despised white hair and wrinkles become the -visible tokens of experience. They suggest moral force, and are -therefore a help to persuasion. [Sidenote: E] It is the part of youth to -obey; of old age to guide; and that state is safest where - - _Best are the old men’s counsels, - And best the young man’s spear._ - -Homer’s - - _And first he summon’d to council the old men mighty-hearted - By the side of the ship of Nestor_, - -is a touch greatly admired. For the same reason the Select Board -associated with the kings at Sparta was called by the Pythian oracle -‘elder-born’, but by Lycurgus ‘old men’ _sans phrase_, while the Roman -Council is called _Senatus_ down to the present time. The law crowns a -man with the circlet and the wreath, Nature crowns him with grey hair, -and both are the venerable emblems of sovereign rank. Moreover, the -words [Sidenote: F] _geras_, ‘prerogative,’ and _gerairein_, ‘honour -with prerogative’—derived from _geron_, ‘old man’—retain a dignified -sense, not because the old man’s bath is warmed and his bed a softer -one, but because he amounts to a king in the state by virtue of his -wisdom; and wisdom is like a late-fruiting plant, it is only in old age -that nature brings out its special excellence and perfect quality. - -When the king of kings prayed to the gods - - _Would that among the Achaeans were ten such as he to advise me!_ - -[Sidenote: 790] —meaning Nestor—not one of the ‘_valorous_’ and -‘_prowess-breathing_’ Achaeans complained. They all admitted that not -only in statesmanship, but in war also, age was of great moment, since - - _More worth is one sage thought than many a hand_, - -and one rational and cogent judgement achieves the finest and most -important results in public affairs. - -Now kingship, the most complete and comprehensive form of public -activity, is full of cares, labours, and preoccupations. Seleucus, it -was said, used to declare that if ordinary people knew what a business -it was merely to write and read so many letters, they would not pick up -the crown if they found it [Sidenote: B] lying in the street. And the -story goes that, when Philip was proposing to encamp in an excellent -position, but was told that there was no fodder for the pack-animals, he -exclaimed: ‘Good Heavens! what is our life worth, when we are obliged to -suit it to the convenience of our asses?’ Ought we then to give the same -advice to a king when he has grown old? Bid him lay aside the crown and -the purple, take to a cloak and a crutched stick, and live in the -country, for fear people should think it officious and unseasonable of -him to be reigning when he is grey? - -But we have no right to talk in this way about an Agesilaus, or a Numa, -or a Darius. Neither then should we compel a Solon [Sidenote: C] to -leave the Council of the Areopagus, nor a Cato the Senate, nor yet urge -a Pericles to leave popular government to look after itself. It is -contrary to reason that in our youth we should bounce upon the platform, -spend upon the public all the passionate licence of our ambition, and -then, when age arrives and brings the wisdom of experience, desert and -betray our public standing like a woman whom we have used at our -pleasure. - -In Aesop, when the hedgehog wanted to pick off his ticks, the fox would -not let him. ‘These are glutted,’ said he, ‘and [Sidenote: D] if you get -rid of them, hungry ones will be at you in their place.’ So with public -life. If it is perpetually shedding the old men, it will necessarily be -plagued with young ones, who are thirsting for notoriety and power but -devoid of political sense. How can they be otherwise, if they are to -have no elderly statesman to watch and learn from? A ship’s captain is -not made by treatises on navigation. He must often have stood upon the -quarter-deck and watched the struggle with wave and wind and stormy -nights, when - - _The sailor on the brine longs sore - For Tyndareus’ twin sons._ - -And can the handling of a State and the persuading of Assembly -[Sidenote: E] or Council be rightly left to a young man because he has -read a book or taken down a lecture on statesmanship in the Lyceum? -Though he has not taken his stand many a time beside rudder-rope and -tiller, leaned first to this side and then to that, while generals and -public leaders were pitting their knowledge and experience against each -other, and so learned his lesson in the midst of dangers and -difficulties? Beyond question, No! For the education and training of the -young, if for no other reason, old men should play a public part. A -teacher of letters or of music himself reads or plays a passage over -first by way of example [Sidenote: F] to his pupils. So the authority on -statesmanship must guide a young man, not simply by talking or -suggesting from outside, but by the practical administration of public -business. It is by deeds as well as by words that he will mould him to -the true shape, filled with the breath of life. It is training of this -kind—not in the schools where you practise safe forms of wrestling under -mannerly professors, but in contests truly Olympian and Pythian—that -makes one, as Simonides puts it, - - _Keep pace, as with the steed the wearied colt_; - -[Sidenote: 791] —Aristeides with Cleisthenes, Cimon with Aristeides, -Phocion with Chabrias, Cato with Fabius Maximus, Pompeius with Sulla, -Polybius with Philopoemen. It was by attaching themselves when young to -older men, by using them as supports to their own growth, by being -raised to their standard of statesmanlike achievement, that they -acquired the political experience which brought them fame and power. - -When certain professors declared that the claim of Aeschines, the -Academic philosopher, to have been a pupil of Carneades was contrary to -fact, he replied, ‘O yes: I was a disciple of Carneades at the time when -age had taken all the fuss and noise [Sidenote: B] out of his teaching -and reduced it to practical and serviceable shape.’ With the -statesmanship of an old man, however, it is not merely the talking, but -the deeds, that lose all ostentation and itch for notoriety. They tell -us that, when the iris has grown old and exhausted all crude exuberance -of perfume, its fragrance gains in sweetness. So with the views and -suggestions of the old. There is no crudeness in them, but always a -quality of quiet solidity. For this reason, as I have said, we must have -elderly men in public life. Plato speaks of mixing water with neat wine -as the bringing of a ‘frenzied god’ to sanity by the [Sidenote: C] -‘chastening of another who is sober’. So when young spirits in the -Assembly are a-boil with the intoxication of glory and ambition, we need -the old men’s caution to qualify them and to eliminate their mad excess -of fire. - -There is another consideration. It is an error to suppose that -statesmanship is like a voyage or a campaign—carried on for an ulterior -object and discontinued when that is attained. Statesmanship is not a -public burden, to be borne only so long as needs must. It is the career -of a civilized being with a gift for citizenship and society, and with a -natural disposition to live a life of public influence, worthy aims, and -social helpfulness for as long as occasion calls. - -The right course therefore is to _be_ a public man, not to _have_ been -one; just as it is right to speak the truth, not to [Sidenote: D] _have_ -spoken it; to act honestly, not to _have_ so acted; to love one’s -country and fellow-citizens, not to _have_ loved them. Those are -Nature’s objects, and where men are not utterly demoralized by idleness -and effeminacy, her promptings are such as these: - - _Thy sire begat thee for rich use to men_, - -and - - _Ne’er let us cease from service to mankind._ - -To urge the plea of ill-health or disablement is to blame disease and -injury, not old age. Young men are often sickly, old men often vigorous. -It is therefore not the old whom we should discourage, but the -incapable. It is the capable whom [Sidenote: E] we should encourage, not -the young. Aridaeus was young, and Antigonus old; but while Antigonus -annexed nearly the whole of Asia, Aridaeus was like the ‘super’ upon the -stage—a king with nothing to say, and a butt for whoever happened to be -in power. To demand of the sophist Prodicus or the poet Philetas—who, -young though they might be, were thin, sickly, and constantly taking to -their beds through ill-health—that they should take up public life, were -folly. But it were folly also to hinder old men like Phocion, or -Masinissa the African, or the Roman Cato, from holding office or -military command. The [Sidenote: F] Athenians being set upon an -ill-timed war, Phocion ordered that every man under sixty should take up -arms and serve. When this made them angry, he said, ‘There is no -hardship. I, who am to be with you in command, am over eighty.’ And of -Masinissa Polybius relates that he died when he was ninety, leaving a -child of four, of whom he was the father. Shortly before his death he -beat the Carthaginians in a great battle, [Sidenote: 792] and the next -day was seen in front of his tent eating a loaf of cheap coarse bread. -To expressions of surprise he answered that he did so to keep himself in -training. - - _For like to goodly bronze, it shines in use, - While a house crumbles, if left idle long_, - -says Sophocles. We may say the same of that glossy brightness of the -mind, to which we owe calculation, memory, and sound judgement. - -For the same reason it is said that wars and campaigns make better kings -than inactivity. Attalus, the brother of Eumenes, was so thoroughly -enervated by long peace and [Sidenote: B] idleness that Philopoemen, one -of his intimates, had simply to shepherd him and keep him fat. In fact, -the Romans used to inquire of arrivals from Asia, whether ‘the king had -any influence with Philopoemen’. It would be hard to find a Roman -general more able than Lucullus, so long as he kept his intellect braced -with action. But he surrendered himself to a life of inactivity, stayed -at home, thought of nothing, and became as lifeless and shrunken as a -sponge in a calm. Afterwards, in his old age, he so tamely accepted a -certain freedman, Callisthenes, for his keeper, that the man [Sidenote: -C] was thought to be bewitching him with spells and drugs, till at last -his brother Marcus drove the fellow away and himself took to managing -and tutoring him for the short remainder of his life. On the other hand, -Darius, the father of Xerxes, used to say that he became his wisest in -times of danger; and Ateas the Scythian declared that, when he had -nothing to do, he could see nothing to distinguish him from his grooms. -When some one asked the elder Dionysius if he had time to spare, he -replied: ‘Heaven forbid I ever should!’ Whereas a bow, they tell us, is -broken by stringing it tight, a mind is broken by leaving it loose. If a -musician gives up listening [Sidenote: D] for pitch, a geometrician the -solving of problems, an arithmetician the constant habit of calculation, -old age will enfeeble the ability along with the loss of its exercise, -although the art in these cases is not a ‘practic’ one, but a -‘theoretic’. In the case of the special ability of the statesman—his -caution, wisdom, and justice, together with an experienced knack of -hitting the right language at the right time; that is to say, a faculty -for creating persuasion—it is kept in good condition by constant speech, -action, calculation, and judicial decision. It would be a dire mistake -for it to abandon such activities [Sidenote: E] and permit all those -important virtues to leak away from the mind. For it naturally means a -decline of kindly interest in man and society—a thing which should be -without limit or end. - -Suppose your father had been Tithonus. Suppose, though he was immortal, -old age had made him require close and constant care. You would not, I -imagine, have run away and repudiated the task of tending him, talking -to him, and helping him, just because you had ‘borne the burden for a -long time’. Well, your fatherland—or ‘motherland’ as it is called in -Crete—has claims prior to those of parents, and greater. Your country’s -life has been a long one, but she is not without old age. She is -[Sidenote: F] not sufficient to herself, but is in perpetual need of -watchful and considerate help. She therefore grasps at the statesman and -holds him back: - - _Clutching his garment she stays him, though eager he be for - departure._ - -You are aware that I have performed my public duty at many a Pythian -festival. But you would not say ‘Plutarch, you have done enough in the -way of sacrifices, processions, and choruses. You are now in years; it -is time to put off your wreath; age entitles you to leave the shrine -alone’. Well, look at your own duty in the same way. In the sacred -service of the State you are coryphaeus and prophet, and it is not for -you to abandon that worship of Zeus, God of State and Assembly, in which -you have been so long initiated and are so thoroughly versed. - -[Sidenote: 793] Permit me now to leave the arguments for quitting public -life, and to examine another point. We must beware of inflicting upon -our old age an unbecoming or exacting task, when so many portions of -public work are so well suited to that time of life. If it had been -proper for us to go on singing all our days, there are at our disposal -many keys and modes, or, as the musicians call them, ‘systems.’ Our -right course in our old age would have been to cultivate, not a mode -both high and sharp, but one combining ease with appropriate character. -And since Nature prompts mankind to act and speak—even more [Sidenote: -B] than it prompts the swan to sing—until the end, our duty is not to -lay action aside, like a lyre of too high a pitch, but to lower the key -and adapt it to such forms of public effort as are light, unexacting, -and within an old man’s compass. We do not leave our bodies entirely -without muscular exercise because we cannot use the spade and the -jumping-weights, or hurl the discus, or practise fencing, as we used to -do. We swing or walk, and in some cases the breathing is exercised and -warmth stimulated by playing a gentle game of ball, or by conversation. - -On the one hand, then, do not let us allow ourselves to become -[Sidenote: C] stiff and torpid from inactivity. On the other, let us not -undertake any and every official position, clutch at any and every kind -of public work, and bring such an exposure upon old age that it is -driven to exclaim in despair: - - _Right hand, how fain art thou to grasp the spear! - How vain thy longing, in thy strengthlessness!_ - -Even in the prime of strength a man wins no credit if he tries to take -on his shoulders the whole pack of public business, and [Sidenote: D] -refuses—like Zeus, according to the Stoics—to leave anything to others; -if he insinuates himself everywhere and has his finger in everything, -through an insatiable greed for notoriety or through jealousy of any one -who contrives to get a share of honour and power in the community. But -when a man is quite old, then, apart from the discredit, wretchedly hard -work is entailed by that itch for office which is always courting every -ballot-box, that meddlesomeness which lies in wait for every opportunity -of acting on a jury or a committee, that ambition which snaps up every -appointment as delegate or proctor. [Sidenote: E] Such work is a heavy -tax on an old man, even when people are well-disposed. But the opposite -may very well be the case. For young men hate him because he leaves them -no opportunities and prevents them from coming to the front; while the -rest of the community looks upon his itch for office and precedence with -the same disapproval as upon the itch of other old men for money and -pleasure. - -When Bucephalus was growing old, Alexander, being unwilling to overwork -him, used to ride some other horse while reviewing the phalanx and -getting it into position before the [Sidenote: F] battle. Then, after -giving the word for the day, he changed his mount to Bucephalus, and at -once led the charge and tried the fortunes of war. In the same way a -sensible public man—in this case handling his own reins—will, when in -years, hold aloof from unnecessary effort, leaving more vigorous persons -to deal with the minor matters of state, but himself playing a zealous -part in great ones. - -Athletes keep their bodies from all contact with necessary labours and -in perfect trim for useless ones. We, on the contrary, will leave petty -little details alone, and will keep ourselves in reserve for matters of -moment. No doubt, as Homer says, - - _To the young all labours are seemly_, - -and the world gives consent and approval, calling them ‘public-spirited’ -and ‘energetic’ when they do a large number of little things, and -‘noble’ and ‘lofty-minded’ when they do brilliant and distinguished -things. At that time of life there are [Sidenote: 794] occasions when a -venturesome aggressiveness is more or less in season and wears a grace -of its own. But what when an elderly man consents to perform routine -services to the public, such as letting out taxes, or superintending -harbours and markets? What when he seizes opportunities of being sent on -a mission to some governor or other powerful personage—a position for -which there is no necessity, which contains no dignity, and which -necessitates time-serving and complaisance? To my mind, my friend, his -case is one for regret and commiseration; some may even think it -distressingly vulgar. - -Not even positions of authority are any longer a suitable [Sidenote: B] -sphere for him, unless they are of high rank and importance; such a -position, for example, as you now hold in the Presidentship of the -Areopagite Council, not to mention the distinguished rank of -Amphictyon,[36] which your country has imposed upon you all your life, -with its - - _Welcome toil and labour sweet to bear._ - -Even these honours we should not seek, but should make from holding -them. We should ask, not for them, but to be excused from them. It -should seem, not that we are taking office to ourselves, but that we are -surrendering ourselves to office. The Emperor Tiberius used to say that -a man over sixty should be ashamed of holding out his wrist to a -physician. But he should [Sidenote: C] be more ashamed of holding out -his hand to the public in solicitation of its ‘vote and influence’. That -situation is as humiliating and ignoble as the contrary is honourable -and dignified—I mean when your country chooses you, calls you, and waits -for you, and when you come down amidst respect and welcome, a ‘reverend -signior’ indeed, to meet your distinction with gracious acceptance. - -Similarly with speaking in the Assembly. A man of advanced age should -not be perpetually springing upon the platform and crowing back to every -cock that crows. Young men are like horses, and he should not, by -constantly grappling with [Sidenote: D] them and irritating them, lose -control of their respect, or encourage the practice and habit of -resistance to the reins. He should sometimes leave them to make a -restive plunge for distinction, keeping out of the way and not -interfering, unless the matter at stake is vital to the public safety or -to decency and honour. In that case he should not wait to be called, but -should let some one take him by the hand, or carry him in his chair, and -push his way at more than full speed, like Appius Claudius in Roman -history. The Romans had been defeated by Pyrrhus in a great battle, and -Appius heard that the Senate [Sidenote: E] was listening to proposals -for a truce and a peace. This was more than he could bear, and, though -blind of both eyes, along he came in his chair through the Forum to the -Senate House. He went in, planted himself before them, and said: -‘Hitherto I have been distressed at the loss of my sight; now I could -pray to be also unable to hear—that you are meditating so ignoble and -disgraceful a transaction.’ Thereupon, partly by reproaches, partly by -advice and encouragement, he persuaded them to have [Sidenote: F] -immediate recourse to arms and to fight Pyrrhus to a finish for the -prize of Italy. - -Again, when it became manifest that, in acting the demagogue, -Peisistratus was aiming at absolutism, and yet no one ventured to resist -or prevent it, Solon brought out his weapons with his own hands, piled -them in front of his house, and called upon the citizens to help. And -when Peisistratus sent and asked him what gave him the confidence to do -so, he replied, ‘My age.’ - -Things so vital as these, it is true, are rousing enough to fire even -the most worn-out of old men, so long as he possesses the breath of life -at all. Otherwise he will sometimes, as I have said, be showing good -taste if he declines to perform paltry and menial tasks which bring more -worry to the doer than good [Sidenote: 793] to the persons for whom they -are done. There are also occasions when he will wait for the citizens to -call for him, feel the need of him, and come to his house to fetch him. -He is wanted, and therefore his appearance on the scene will carry more -weight. But for the most part, though present, he will be silent and -will leave the younger generation to do the speaking, while he acts as -umpire to the match of political ambition. And if it goes beyond bounds, -he will offer a mild reproof and courteously put an end to outbreaks of -self-assertion, recrimination, or ill-temper. When a motion is wrong, he -will reason with and correct the mover, but without blaming him. When it -is right, he will commend it without reserve and will cheerfully -acquiesce, often surrendering an argumentative victory in order that -[Sidenote: B] a young man may get on in the world and be in good heart. -In some cases he will supply a deficiency while paying a compliment, -like Nestor with his - - _No man, I trow, will find fault with thy words among all the - Achaeans: - None say thee nay. Yet not to an end hast thou brought all the - matter. - True ’tis, thou art yet but young, and myself might be thine own - father._ - -There is a practice still more statesmanlike. One may not merely teach a -lesson openly in public by means of a reproval unaccompanied by any -sting of humiliation or injury to prestige. Still more may be done in -private for persons with good political abilities. We may offer them -kindly suggestions and assistance [Sidenote: C] towards the bringing -forward of useful arguments and public measures, encourage them to high -aims, help them to acquire a distinguished tone of mind, and—as -riding-masters do with their horses—see that at first the people shall -be gentle and docile for them to mount. And if so be a young man should -make a failure, instead of leaving him to despond, we may rouse and -comfort him. It was in this way that the spirits and courage of Cimon -were revived by Aristeides, and those of Themistocles by Mnesiphilus, -when they began by incurring ill-odour and a bad name for forwardness -and recklessness. It is also said of Demosthenes that, when he was in -great distress at his failure [Sidenote: D] in the Assembly, he was -taken to task by a very old man who had heard Pericles, and who told him -that he had no right to despair of himself, seeing that he possessed -gifts so much like those of that eminent person. So when Timotheus was -hissed for his innovations and treated as guilty of an outrage on music, -Euripides bade him keep up his courage, since he would soon be dictating -to his audience. - -At Rome the term of the Vestal Virgins is divided into three stages—one -for learning, one for the performance of the ceremonies, and the third -for teaching. So with the votaries of [Sidenote: E] Artemis at Ephesus; -each is called first a novice, next a priestess, and then a -past-priestess. In the same way the complete statesman is during the -first part of his public career still engaged in learning the mysteries; -during the last part he is engaged in teaching and initiating. - -Whereas to superintend the athletics of others is to take no part in -them oneself, it is otherwise with those who train a youth in public -business and the political arena, and who make sure that for the good of -his country he shall - - _Be speaker of words and eke doer of deeds._ - -They perform good service, not in some petty inconsiderable [Sidenote: -F] part of public life, but in one to which Lycurgus devoted his first -and foremost attention—training the young to give to every old man the -same unfailing obedience as to a lawgiver. What had Lysander in his -mind, when he declared that the finest form of old age is to be found at -Lacedaemon? Did he mean that at Lacedaemon elderly people had the best -opportunities of doing nothing, of lending money, of sitting together -and playing dice, or of meeting together at an early hour to drink? -Surely not. He meant that all persons at that time of life hold, as it -were, a magisterial position; that they are, in a sense, public fathers -or guardians, who not only look after matters of state, but take active -cognisance of everything a young [Sidenote: 796] man may do in connexion -with his training-school, his pastimes, or his style of living. Such a -position makes them an object of fear to wrong-doers, and of respect and -affection to the well-behaved. For young men make a point of cultivating -their society, because of the way in which they encourage steadiness and -nobility of character by sympathy and approbation and without jealousy. - -The last-named feeling is not a becoming one at any time of life. But -whereas in the case of a young man it finds plenty of respectable -names—‘rivalry’, ‘emulation’, ‘ambition’—in an old man it is a coarse -and vulgar sentiment altogether out of place. The aged statesman should -therefore be entirely free from jealousy. He should be no malignant old -tree, [Sidenote: B] unequivocally snubbing the shoots and checking the -growth of plants which spring up beside or beneath it, but should give -them a kindly welcome and every opportunity to cling to him and twine -about him. He should hold young people upright, lead them by the hand, -and foster them, not only by wise suggestion and advice, but by -surrendering to them political tasks which bring honour and distinction, -or which afford scope for services of an innocent nature and yet welcome -and gratifying to the public. - -When a task is a stubborn and arduous one, or when it is like a medicine -which stings and gives pain at the moment, while its beneficial effects -are not produced till afterwards, he [Sidenote: C] should not prescribe -it for young people. Instead of subjecting them in their inexperienced -state to the uproars of an unreasonable mob, he should himself accept -the unpopularity attaching to salutary measures. By this means he will -render a youth both more well-disposed and also more zealous in other -duties. - -Meanwhile it must be remembered that statesmanship does not consist -solely in holding office, acting as envoy, shouting loudly in the -Assembly, and indulging in a fine frenzy of speeches and motions on the -platform. The generality of people may think that these make a -statesman, just as they think that talking [Sidenote: D] from a chair -and delivering lectures based on books make a philosopher. But they fail -to discern the sustained statesmanship or philosophy which is revealed -consistently day after day in actions and conduct. As Dicaearchus used -to say, the word _peripatein_, ‘walk’, has now come to be used of -persons taking a turn in the colonnades rather than of those who are -walking into the country or to see a friend. It is the same with acting -the statesman as it is with acting the philosopher. For Socrates to play -the philosopher there was no arranging of forms, seating himself in a -chair, or observing a fixed time—arranged with his associates—for a -discussion or discourse. He played the philosopher while joking with -you, perhaps, or drinking with you, [Sidenote: E] or possibly -campaigning with you, or at market with you, and finally when he was in -prison and drinking the poison. He was thus the first to show that life -affords scope for philosophy at every moment, in every detail, in every -feeling and circumstance whatsoever. Statesmanship should be regarded in -the same light. Foolish persons, even if they are Ministers of War, or -Secretaries, or platform-speakers, should not be considered as acting -the statesman, but as courting the mob, or making a display, or creating -dissension, or doing public service because they must. But when a man -possesses public spirit and broad interests, and is a keen patriot and a -‘state’s man’ in the literal sense, even if he has never worn official -garb, he is playing the statesman all the time. He does so by -stimulating men of [Sidenote: F] ability, giving advice to those who -need it, lending his help to deliberation, discouraging bunglers, and -fortifying persons of sense. And this does not mean that he goes to the -Assembly Theatre or Senate House out of pride of place when canvassed or -pressed, and, when he gets there, merely puts in an appearance—if he -does so—by way of pastime, as he might at a show or entertainment. It -means that, even if not present in body, he [Sidenote: 797] is present -in spirit; that he asks how the business goes, and is pleased or vexed -as the case may be. - -Aristeides at Athens and Cato at Rome held few public offices; but they -made their whole life a perpetual service to their country. Though -Epaminondas won many a distinguished success as commander-in-chief, he -is no less famous for what he did in Thessaly at a time when he held no -command or office. The generals had plunged the phalanx into a difficult -situation. The enemy was attacking them with his missiles, [Sidenote: B] -and they were in confusion. Epaminondas was therefore summoned from the -ranks, and, after allaying the panic of the army by words of -encouragement, he proceeded to make an orderly disposition of the -phalanx—which was in a state of turmoil—extricated it with ease, posted -it so as to confront the enemy, and compelled him to change his tactics -and retire. - -Once when King Agis was in Arcadia, and was in the act of leading his -army into action in full order of battle, one of the elder Spartans -shouted out that he was proposing to ‘mend one error by another’, -meaning (as Thucydides says) that ‘his [Sidenote: C] present -unseasonable ardour was intended to repair the discredit of his retreat’ -from Argos. Agis listened, took the advice, and retired. Menecrates -actually had a seat placed for him every day at the doors of the -Government Office, and the Ephors frequently rose and consulted him upon -questions of the first importance; so great was his reputation for -wisdom and shrewdness. The story goes that, when he had completely lost -all physical strength and was for the most part confined all day to his -bed, upon the Ephors sending for him to the Agora, he got up and set out -to walk. As he was toiling slowly along, he met [Sidenote: D] some -children on the way, and asked them: ‘Do you know anything more binding -than to obey a master?’ Upon their replying, ‘Lack of the power,’ his -reason told him that this brought his service to an end, and he turned -back home. For though zeal should not fail so long as ability lasts, we -must not put pressure upon it when left helpless. - -Once more, Scipio, whether in the field or in politics, constantly -sought the advice of Gaius Laelius to such an extent as to make some -people say of his achievements that Scipio was the actor, but the author -was Gaius. And Cicero himself acknowledges that the greatest and finest -of the successful measures of his consulship were devised with the help -of the philosopher Publius Nigidius. - -[Sidenote: E] There is, then, nothing to prevent an aged man from -advancing the public good in many a department of statesmanship. He has -the best of means thereto: reason, judgement, plain-speaking, and -‘_thought discreet_‘, as the poets say. It is not merely our hands and -feet or the strength of our bodies that are part and parcel of the -possessions of the State. Most important are the mind and the beauties -of the mind—temperance, justice, and wisdom. It is monstrous that, as -these come late and [Sidenote: F] slowly to their own, our house and -farm and other goods and chattels should get the benefit of them, while, -in a public way, to our country and our fellow-citizens, we make -ourselves of no further use because of ‘time’. For what time takes away -from our powers of active effort is less than what it adds to those of -guidance and statesmanship. It is for this reason that, when Hermes is -represented in an elderly form, though he has no hands or feet, his -virile parts are tense—an indirect way of saying that there is little -need for old men’s bodies to be hard at work, so long as their power of -reasoned speech is—as it ought to be—vigorous and generative. - -Footnote 34: - - The text here is corrupt. - -Footnote 35: - - i.e. Epicurean. - -Footnote 36: - - Member of a religious council which met at Delphi and represented the - chief states of all Greece. - - - - - ADVICE TO MARRIED COUPLES - - -[Sidenote: 138 B] TO POLLIANUS AND EURYDICE WITH PLUTARCH’S BEST WISHES. - -When they were shutting you in your bridal chamber, the ancestral ritual -was duly applied to you by the priestess of Demeter. I believe that now, -if reason also were to take you in hand and join in the nuptial song, it -would prove of some service, and would support the tune as prescribed. - -In the musical world they used to call one of the modes for the flute -‘the Horse-and-Mare’, because, apparently, the strains in that key were -provocative of union between those animals. Well, philosophy has many -excellent sermons to give, but none [Sidenote: C] more worthy of serious -attention than that upon marriage. By it she exerts a spell upon those -who come together as partners in life, and renders them gentle and -tractable to each other. I have, therefore, taken the main points of the -lessons which you have repeatedly heard, brought up as you have been in -the company of Philosophy. I have arranged them in a series of brief -comparisons to make them easier to remember, and am sending them as a -present to you both. In doing so I pray that the Muses may graciously -lend aid to Aphrodite, since, if it is their province to see that a lyre -or a harp shall be in tune, it is no less so to provide that the music -of the married home shall be harmonized by reason and philosophy. When -people in olden times assigned a seat with Aphrodite to Hermes, it was -because [Sidenote: D] the pleasure of marriage stands in special need of -reason; when to Persuasion and the Graces, it was in order that the -married pair might obtain their wishes from each other by means of -persuasion, and not by contention and strife. - - - THE RULES: - - -1. Solon bade the bride eat a piece of quince before coming to the -bridegroom’s arms—apparently an enigmatical suggestion that, as a first -requirement, a pleasant and inviting impression should be gathered from -an agreeable mouth and speech. - -2. In Boeotia, after veiling the bride, they crown her with a wreath of -thorny asparagus. As that plant yields the sweetest eating from among -the roughest prickles, so a bride, if the groom does not run away in -disgust because he finds her difficult and vexatious at first, will -afford him a sweet and gentle companionship. One who shows no patience -with the girl’s first [Sidenote: E] bickerings is as bad as those who -let the ripe grapes go because once they were sour. Many a young bride -is affected in the same way. First experiences disgust her with the -bridegroom, and she makes as great a mistake as if, after enduring the -sting of the bee, she were to abandon the honeycomb. - -3. It is especially at the beginning that married people should beware -of quarrel and friction. Let them note how vessels which have been -mended will at first easily pull to pieces on the slightest occasion, -but as time goes on and they become solid at the seams, it is as much as -fire and iron can do to separate [Sidenote: F] the parts. - -4. Fire is readily kindled in chaff, dry rushes, or hare’s fur, but -quickly goes out unless it gets a further hold upon something capable -both of keeping it in and feeding it. So with that fierce blaze of -passion which is produced in the newly-married by physical enjoyment. -You must not rely upon it nor expect it to last, unless it is built -round the moral character, gets a hold upon your rational part, and so -obtains a permanent vitality. - -5. Doctoring the water is no doubt a quick and easy way of [Sidenote: -139] catching fish, but it renders them bad and uneatable. So when women -work artificially upon their husbands with philtres and spells, and -control them by the agency of pleasure, they have but crazy simpletons -and dotards for their partners. While Circe derived no good from the men -she had bewitched, and made no use of them when turned into swine and -asses, she found the greatest pleasure in the rational companionship of -the wise Odysseus. - -6. A woman who is more desirous of ruling a foolish husband than of -obeying a wise one, is like a traveller who would rather lead a blind -man than follow one who possesses sight and knowledge. - -[Sidenote: B] 7. Why should people disbelieve that Pasiphae, though -consort to a king, fell in love with an ox, when they see that some -women find a strict and continent husband wearisome, and prefer to live -with one who is as much a mass of ungoverned sensuality as a dog or a -goat? - -8. When a rider is too weak or effeminate to vault upon a horse, he -teaches the animal itself to bend its legs and crouch. In the same way -some men who marry high-born or wealthy women, instead of improving -themselves, put indignities upon their wives, in the belief that they -will be more easily ruled when humbled. The proper course is, while -using the rein, to maintain the dignity of the wife, as one would the -full height of the horse. - -[Sidenote: C] 9. When the moon is at a distance from the sun, we see it -bright and luminous. When it comes near him, it fades and is lost to -view. With a properly conducted woman it is the contrary. She should be -most visible when with her husband; in his absence she should keep at -home and out of sight. - -10. Herodotus was wrong in saying that when a woman lays aside her tunic -she lays aside her modesty. On the contrary, a chaste wife puts on -modesty in its place. Between married persons the token of greatest -regard is greatest modesty. - -11. If two notes are taken in accord, the lower of the two is [Sidenote: -D] the dominant. So, though every action in a well-conducted house is -performed by both parties in tune, it will reveal the husband’s -leadership and priority of choice. - -12. The Sun vanquished the North Wind. When the wind endeavoured to take -off the man’s cloak by violence and blowing a gale, he only tightened -his mantle the more and held it the closer. But when, after the wind, -the sun became hot, the man began to grow warm. When at last he -sweltered, he took off not only his cloak but his tunic. The parable -applies to the generality of women. When their husbands take violent -measures to do away with extravagant indulgence, they show [Sidenote: E] -fight and temper; but if you reason with them, they give it up peaceably -and practise moderation. - -13. Cato expelled from the Senate a man who had kissed his own wife in -the presence of his daughter. This, perhaps, was too severe a step. But -if—as is the case—it is unseemly to be fondling and kissing and -embracing each other in company, it is surely more unseemly to be -scolding and quarrelling in company, and, while treating your -love-passages as a sacred secret between you and your wife, to make an -open display of fault-finding [Sidenote: F] and reproach. - -14. A mirror,[37] though decorated with gold and precious stones, is of -no use unless it shows you your form true to life. Similarly there is no -advantage in a rich wife, if her conduct does not represent that of her -husband and harmonize with it in character. If the reflection which it -offers is glum when you are joyful, but wears a merry grin when you are -gloomy and distressed, the mirror is faulty and bad. A wife is a poor -thing and out of place if she is in the dumps when her husband is -disposed for frolic or love-making, but is all fun and laughter when he -is serious. In the former case she is disagreeable; in [Sidenote: 140] -the latter, she slights you. Geometers tell us that lines and surfaces -make no movement by themselves, but only in conjunction with the bodies -to which they belong. In the same way a woman should be free from -peculiar states of mind of her own, but should act as the husband’s -partner in his earnestness and his jest, in his preoccupation and his -laughter. - -15. A man who dislikes to see his wife eating with him, teaches her to -satisfy her appetite when she gets by herself. Similarly one who is -never a merry companion to her, nor shares in her sport and laughter, -teaches her to look for private pleasures apart from him. - -[Sidenote: B] 16. When the Persian kings are dining or feasting, their -legitimate wives sit at their side. But when they wish to amuse -themselves or get tipsy, they send those wives away and summon their -minstrel-women and concubines. The practice is a right one, at least to -the extent that they do not permit their wives to take part in wanton -and licentious scenes. So, if a private man, who lacks self-control or -good-breeding in his pleasures, is guilty of a lapse with a common woman -or a menial, the wife should not be indignant and resentful, but should -reflect that, out of respect for her, he finds some other woman to share -his riot and lasciviousness. - -[Sidenote: C] 17. When kings are fond of music, they make many -musicians; when of learning, learned men; when of athletics, gymnasts. -So when the love of a husband is for the person, his wife will be all -for dress; when for pleasure, she becomes lewd and wanton; when for -goodness and virtue, she shows herself discreet and chaste. - -18. When a Lacedaemonian girl was once asked whether she had already -embraced a man, she answered, ‘No, indeed; but _he_ has embraced _me_.’ -Such, I believe, is the right attitude for a lady—not to shun or dislike -caresses, when the husband begins them, nor yet to begin them of her own -accord. The one course is bold and immodest, the other disdainful and -[Sidenote: D] unaffectionate. - -19. The woman ought not to possess private friends, but to share those -of the man. But first and greatest are the gods, and it is therefore -right for the wife to reverence or acknowledge only those gods who are -recognized by the husband. Her street-door should be kept shut to -out-of-the-way forms of worship and alien superstitions. No deity finds -gratification in ceremonies which a woman performs in secret and by -stealth. - -20. Plato holds that a community is in a state of blissful well-being -when the expressions ‘_mine_’ and ‘_not mine_’ are scarcely ever heard, -inasmuch as the citizens enjoy, as far as [Sidenote: E] possible, the -common use of everything worth considering. Much more ought such -language to be abolished from the married state. In the same way, -however, in which medical men tell us that a blow on the left side -produces an answering sensation in the right, it is proper for a wife to -sympathize with her husband’s concerns and the husband with the wife’s. -In this way, just as ropes, when interwoven, lend each other strength, -so, through each party reciprocating the other’s goodwill, the -partnership will be maintained by both combined. Nature blends us -through the body in such a way as to take [Sidenote: F] a portion from -each, and by commingling produce an offspring common to both, so that -neither can define or distinguish an ‘own’ part from ‘another’s’. The -same sort of partnership between married persons should assuredly exist -in respect of money also. They should pour it all into a single fund, -and blend it in such a way that they never think of one part as ‘own’ -and one as ‘another’s’, but treat it all as ‘own’ and none of it as -‘another’s’. And as we call a mixture ‘wine’, though it may contain a -greater proportion of water, so the property of the house should be said -to belong to the man, even though the wife may contribute the larger -share. - -21. Helen loved wealth, and Paris loved pleasure: Odysseus was wise, and -Penelope discreet. Hence the union of the latter [Sidenote: 141] pair -was happy and enviable, while that of the former brought upon Greeks and -Asiatics an ‘Iliad of Woes’. - -22. When the Roman was admonished by his friends for having divorced a -wife who was chaste, rich, and beautiful, he stretched out his shoe and -remarked: ‘Yes, and this looks fine and new, but no one knows where it -chafes me.’ The wife must not rely upon her dowry, her birth, or her -beauty. The matters in which she touches her husband most closely are -conversation, character, and companionship. Instead of making these -harsh and vexatious day after day, she must render them [Sidenote: B] -compatible, soothing, and grateful. Physicians are more afraid of fevers -which spring from vague causes gradually accumulating, than of those for -which there is a great and manifest reason. So it is these little, -continual, daily frictions between man and wife, which the world knows -nothing of, that do most to create the rifts which ruin married life. - -23. King Philip was once enamoured of a Thessalian woman who was charged -with bewitching him. Olympias thereupon became eager to get this person -into her power. When, upon presenting herself, she not only turned out -to be a handsome woman, but spoke with considerable nobility and good -sense, [Sidenote: C] Olympias said: ‘Those calumnies are all nonsense! -Your witchcraft lies in yourself.’ How irresistible a thing is a married -and lawful wife, if, by treating everything—dowry, birth, philtres, the -very girdle[38] of Aphrodite—as lying in herself, she conquers affection -by means of character and virtue! - -24. On another occasion, when a youthful courtier had married a handsome -woman of bad repute, Olympias remarked, ‘The fellow has no judgement; -otherwise he would not have married with his eyes.’ Marriage should not -be made with the eyes; neither should it with the fingers, as it is in -the case of some, who reckon up the amount of the dower, instead of -calculating the companionable quality, of the wife they are [Sidenote: -D] marrying. - -25. To young men who are fond of looking at themselves in the mirror -Socrates recommended that the ugly should correct their defects by -virtue, while the handsome should avoid spoiling their beauty by vice. -It is a good thing for the married woman also, while she is holding the -mirror, to talk to herself, and, if she is plain, to ask, ‘And what if I -show myself indiscreet?’ if beautiful, ‘And what if I show myself -discreet as well?’ The plain woman may pride herself on being loved for -her character, and the handsome woman on being loved more for her -character than her beauty. - -26. When the Sicilian despot sent Lysander’s daughters a set of costly -mantles and chains, he refused to accept them. ‘These bits of -ornaments,’ said he, ‘will rather take from my [Sidenote: E] daughters’ -beauty than set it off.’ Lysander, however, was anticipated by Sophocles -in the lines: - - _Nay, ’twould not seem, poor fool, to beautify, - But to unbeautify, and prove thee wanton._ - -As Crates used to say, ‘Adornment is that which adorns,’ and that which -adorns is that which adds to a woman’s seemliness. This is not done by -gold or jewels or scarlet, but by whatever invests her with the badges -of dignity, decorum, and modesty. - -27. In sacrificing to Hera as goddess of marriage, the gall is not -burned with the other portions of the sacrifice, but is [Sidenote: F] -taken out and thrown down at the side of the altar—an indirect -injunction of the legislator that gall and anger should have no place in -the married state. The austerity of the lady of the house, like the -dryness of wine, should be wholesome and palatable, not bitter like -aloes or unpleasant like a drug. - -28. Xenocrates being somewhat harsh in character, though otherwise a -high type of man, Plato recommended him to _sacrifice to the Graces_. -Now I take it that a woman of strict morals stands in special need of -the graces in dealing with her [Sidenote: 142] husband, so that—as -Metrodorus used to say—she may live with him on pleasant terms and not -‘in a temper because she is chaste’. A woman should no more forget to be -amiable because she is faithful, than to be neat because she is thrifty. -Decorum in a woman is rendered as disagreeable by harshness as frugality -is by sluttishness. - -29. A wife who is afraid to laugh and joke with her husband for fear of -seeming bold and wanton, is as bad as the woman who, from fear of being -thought to use ointments on her head, does not even oil it,[39] and, to -avoid seeming to rouge her face, does not even wash it. We find that -when poets and orators avoid appealing to the vulgar by bad taste and -affectation in [Sidenote: B] respect of their diction, they practise -every art to attract and stir the hearer with their matter, their -treatment, and their moral quality. So the lady of the house, because -she avoids and deprecates—as she is quite right to do—extravagant or -meretricious demonstration, ought all the more to bring the graces of -character and conduct into play in dealing with her husband, thus -habituating him to proper ways, but in a pleasurable manner. If, -however, a wife shows herself strait-laced and rigidly austere, her -husband must put the best face upon it. When Antipater required Phocion -to perform an improper and [Sidenote: C] degrading action, he answered, -‘I cannot serve you both as your friend and your toady.’ In the same -way, when a woman is staid and strait-laced, our reflection should be, -‘The same woman cannot behave to me as both a wife and a mistress.’ - -30. By a national custom the Egyptian women wore no shoes, so that they -might keep at home all day. In the case of most women, to deprive them -of gold-worked shoes, bangles, anklets, purple, and pearls, is to make -them stay indoors. - -31. Theano, in putting on her mantle, once showed a glimpse of her arm. -Upon some one saying, ‘A beautiful forearm!’ she retorted, ‘But not for -the public!’ A well-conducted woman will keep, not only her forearm, but -her speech, from [Sidenote: D] publicity. She will be as shy and -cautious about her utterances to the outside world as if they were an -exposure of her person, inasmuch as, when she talks, they are a -revelation of feelings, character, and disposition. - -32. Pheidias, in representing the Elean Aphrodite with her foot upon a -tortoise, meant women to take it as a symbol of home-keeping and -silence. A woman should talk either to, or through the medium of, her -husband; nor should she resent it if, like a player on the clarinet, she -finds a more impressive utterance through another tongue than through -her own. - -33. When rich or royal persons pay respect to a philosopher, they do -honour both to themselves and to him. But when a philosopher pays court -to rich people, he is not conferring [Sidenote: E] distinction upon -them, but lowering his own. The same is the case with women. By -submission to their husbands they win regard; by seeking to govern them -they demean themselves worse than the men so governed. Meanwhile it is -only right that the husband, in controlling the wife, should not be like -an owner dealing with a chattel, but like the mind dealing with the -body—sympathetic with the sympathy of organic union. It is possible to -care for the body without being a slave to its pleasures and desires, -and it is possible to rule a wife and yet do things to please and -gratify her. - -34. Compound objects are classified by philosophers as follows. In some -the parts are distinct, as in a fleet or army. [Sidenote: F] In some -they are conjoined, as in a house or ship. In others they form an -organic unity, as in all living creatures. We may say much the same of -marriage. The marriage of love is the ‘organic unity’; the marriage for -a dowry or for children is that of persons ‘conjoined’; marriage without -sharing the same couch is that of persons ‘distinct’, who may be said to -[Sidenote: 143] dwell together, but not to live together. With persons -marrying, there should be a mutual blending of bodies, means, friends, -and relations, in the same way as, according to the scientists, when -liquids are mixed, the mixture runs through the whole. When the Roman -legislator forbade married couples to exchange presents, he did not mean -that they should not impart to each other, but that they should look -upon everything as joint property. - -35. At Leptis in Africa it is a traditional custom for the bride, on the -day after marriage, to send to the bridegroom’s mother to borrow a pot. -The latter refuses, saying she has none. The intention is that the bride -may realize from the first the ‘step-mother’ attitude of her -mother-in-law, so that, if anything more disagreeable happens -afterwards, she may not be vexed or irritated. The wife should -understand this fact and apply [Sidenote: B] treatment to its cause, -which is, that the mother is jealous of her son’s affections. There is -but one treatment for this state of mind. While winning the special -affection of her husband for herself, she must avoid detaching or -lessening his affection for his mother. - -36. Mothers appear to be more fond of their sons, because those sons are -able to help them, and fathers of their daughters, because daughters -need their help. Maybe also it is out of compliment to each other that -both parties desire to be seen making much of that which is more akin to -the other. This, perhaps, is a trait of no importance, but there is -another which is charming. I mean, when the wife’s respect is seen to -incline rather to the husband’s parents than to her own, and when, -[Sidenote: C] in case of anything troubling her, she refers it to them -and conceals it from her own people. If you are thought to trust, you -are trusted; if you are thought to love, you are loved. - -37. The Greeks who accompanied Cyrus received the following order from -their commanders: ‘If the enemy come shouting to the attack, await them -in silence; if they come in silence, charge to meet them with a shout.’ -When a husband has his fits of anger, if he raises his voice, a sensible -wife keeps quiet; if he is silent, she soothes him by talking to him in -a coaxing way. - -38. Euripides is right in blaming those who have the lyre [Sidenote: D] -played to them at their wine. Music is more properly called in to cure -anger and grief than to encourage further abandonment on the part of -those who are taking their pleasure. So I would have you believe that it -is a wrong principle to share the same bed for the sake of pleasure, and -yet, when you are angry or fall out, to sleep apart. That is exactly the -time to call in the Goddess of Love, who is the best physician for such -cases. This is practically the teaching of the poet, when he makes Hera -say: - - _And their tangled strife will I loosen, - When to their couch I bring them, to meet in love and in union._ - -[Sidenote: E] 39. At all times and everywhere a wife should avoid -offending the husband, and a husband the wife; but especially should -they beware of doing so when together at night. In the story, the wife, -in the vexation of her throes, used to say to those who were putting her -to bed: ‘How can this couch cure a trouble which befell me upon it?’ So -quarrels, recriminations, and tempers which are begotten in the chamber -are not easily got over in another place or at another time. - -40. There appears to be a truth in Hermione’s plea: [Sidenote: F] - - ‘_Tis wicked women’s visits have undone me._ - -This occurs in more than one way, but especially when connubial quarrels -and jealousies offer to such women not only an open door, but an open -ear. At such a time, therefore, should a sensible woman shut her ears, -keep out of the way of slanderous whispers which add fuel to the fire, -and be ready to apply the well-known saying of Philip. We are told that -when his friends were trying to exasperate that monarch against the -Greeks—on the ground that, though he treated them well, they abused -him—he remarked, ‘Well, and what, pray, if we treat them badly?’ So, -when the scandalizers say, ‘Your husband grieves you, in spite of all -your affection and chastity,’ you [Sidenote: 144] should retort, ‘And -what, pray, if I begin to hate and wrong him?’ - -41. A man caught sight of a slave who had run away some time before, and -gave chase. When the slave was too quick, and took refuge in a mill, he -observed, ‘And in what better place could I have wished to find you than -where you are?‘[40] So let a woman who is declaring for a divorce -through jealousy say to herself, ‘And where would my rival be more glad -to see me? And what would she be more pleased to see me doing, than -harbouring a grievance, at feud with my husband, and actually abandoning -the house and the marriage-chamber?’ - -[Sidenote: B] 42. The Athenians observe three sacred ploughings; the -first at Sciron, in memory of the oldest sowing of crops; the second in -the Rharian district; and the third—known as the Buzygian festival—close -to the Acropolis. More sacred than all of these is the connubial -ploughing and sowing for the procreation of children. It is a happy -expression of Sophocles, when he calls Aphrodite ‘_fair-fruited -Cytherea_‘. Man and wife should therefore be especially scrupulous in -this connexion, keeping pure from unholy and unlawful intercourse with -others, and forbearing to sow where they desire no crop to grow, or, if -it does, are ashamed of it and seek to conceal it. - -43. When Gorgias the rhetorician once read to the Greeks at Olympia a -discourse upon peace and harmony, Melanthius exclaimed, ‘Here is a man -giving us advice about peace and [Sidenote: C] harmony, when in private -life he has failed to harmonize three people—himself, his wife, and his -maidservant.’ For Gorgias, it appears, was enamoured, and his wife -jealous, of the domestic. A man’s house ought to be in tune before he -offers to set in tune a state, a public meeting, or friends. The public -is more likely to hear of offences against a wife than of offences -committed by her. - -44. They say that the cat is driven frantic by the smell of unguents. If -it had been the case that women were provoked [Sidenote: D] out of their -senses by the same means, it would have been a monstrous thing for men -not to abstain from unguents, and to let their wives suffer so cruelly -for the sake of a trifling gratification of their own. Now since, though -the husband’s use of unguents does not so afflict them, his dealings -with other women do, it is unjust to cause such vexation and distress to -a wife for the sake of a little pleasure. On the contrary, husbands -should come to their wives pure and untainted by other intercourse, just -as they would approach bees, who are said to show disgust and hostility -towards any one who has been so engaged. - -45. People never dress in bright clothes when approaching [Sidenote: E] -an elephant, nor in red when approaching a bull, since the animals in -question are particularly infuriated by those colours. Of tigers it is -said that, if you beat drums all round them, they go mad and tear -themselves to pieces. Surely, then, inasmuch as some men cannot bear to -see scarlet or purple clothes, and some are irritated at cymbals and -tambourines, it is not asking too much for women to leave such things -alone, and not harass or exasperate their husbands, but practise -quietude and consideration in their society. - -[Sidenote: F] 46. When Philip was once seizing upon a woman against her -will, she said, ‘Let me go. All women are the same when you take away -the light.’ While this applies well enough to adulterers and -sensualists, it is particularly when the light is taken away that a wife -should _not_ be the same as any ordinary female. Her person may not be -visible, but her modesty, chastity, decorum, and natural affection -should make themselves palpable. - -47. Plato used to recommend that respect should rather be paid by -elderly men to the young, so that the latter might behave modestly to -them in return. For, said he, ‘where old men are shameless,’ the young -acquire no modesty or scruple. A husband should bear this in mind, and -show more respect [Sidenote: 145] to his wife than to any one else, -since the nuptial chamber will prove to be her school of propriety or -its opposite. The husband who indulges himself in certain pleasures, -while warning her against the same, is as bad as the man who bids his -wife fight on against an enemy to whom he has himself surrendered. - -48. As to love of display, do you, Eurydice, read and endeavour to -remember what Timoxena wrote to Aristylla. And you, Pollianus, must not -expect your wife to refrain from showy extravagance, if she sees that -you do not despise it in other [Sidenote: B] matters, but that you take -a pleasure in cups with gilding, rooms with painted walls, mules with -decorated harness, and horses with neck-trappings. You cannot banish -extravagance from the women’s quarters when it has the free run of the -men’s. You are at the right age to cultivate philosophy. Adorn your -character, therefore, by listening to careful reasoning and -demonstration in improving company and conversation. Be like the bees. -Gather valuable matter from every source. Carry it home in yourself, and -share it with your wife by discussing it and making all the best -principles agreeable and familiar to her. While [Sidenote: C] - - _Thou unto her art father, and honoured mother, and brother_, - -it is no less a matter of pride to hear a wife say, ‘Husband, thou unto -me art guide, philosopher, and teacher of the noblest and divinest -lessons.’ It is studies of this kind that tend to keep a woman from -foolish practices. She will be ashamed to be dancing, when she is -learning geometry. She will lend no ear to the incantations of sorcery, -when she is listening to those of Plato and Xenophon. When any one -promises to fetch down the moon,[41] she will laugh at the ignorance and -silliness of women who believe such things; for she will possess a -knowledge of astronomy, and will have heard how Aglaonice, the daughter -of Hegetor of Thessaly, thoroughly understood [Sidenote: D] eclipses of -the full moon, how she knew beforehand the date at which it must be -caught in the shadow, and how she thereby cheated the women into -believing that she was fetching it down herself. - -We are told that no woman produces a child without the participation of -the man, though there are shapeless and fleshlike growths—called -‘millstones’—which form themselves spontaneously from corrupted matter. -We must beware of this occurring in women’s minds. If they are not -impregnated with sound doctrines by sharing in the culture of their -husbands, [Sidenote: E] they will of their own accord conceive many an -ill-advised intention or irrational state of feeling. - -As for you, Eurydice, above all things do your best to keep touch with -the sayings of wise and good men, and to have continually in your mouth -those utterances which you learned by heart in my school when a girl. By -so doing, you will not only be a joy to your husband, but the admiration -of other women, when they see how, at no expense, you can adorn yourself -with so much distinction and dignity. - -This rich woman’s pearls, that foreign lady’s silks, are not to be worn -without paying a large price for them. But the ornaments [Sidenote: F] -of Theano, of Cleobuline, of Gorgo the wife of Leonidas, of Timoclea the -sister of Theagenes, of the Claudia of ancient history, and of Cornelia -the daughter of Scipio, you may wear for nothing; and with this -adornment your life may be as happy as it is distinguished. - -[Sidenote: 146] Sappho thought so much of her skill as a lyrist that she -wrote—addressing a wealthy woman— - - _When thou art dead, thou shalt lie with none to remember thy name: - For no portion hast thou in the roses Pierian...._ - -You will assuredly have more occasion to think highly and proudly of -yourself, if you have a portion, not only in the roses, but also in the -fruits, which the Muses bring as free gifts to those who prize culture -and philosophy. - -Footnote 37: - - Made of polished bronze. - -Footnote 38: - - Which contained ‘every charm: love, desire, and sweet converse’ - (Homer, _Il._ xiv. 214). - -Footnote 39: - - The use of oil to soften the hair was practically universal. - -Footnote 40: - - A common punishment for a slave was to put him to hard labour in - turning the mill, in place of a horse or ass. - -Footnote 41: - - A frequent pretence of ancient witches. - - - - - CONCERNING BUSYBODIES - - -If a house is stuffy, dark, chilly, or unhealthy, it is perhaps -[Sidenote: 515 B] best to get out of it. But if long association makes -you fond of the place, you may alter the lights, shift the stairs, open -a door here and close one there, and so make it brighter, fresher, and -more wholesome. Even cities have sometimes been improved [Sidenote: C] -by such rearrangement. For instance, it is said that my own native town, -which used to face the west and receive the full force of the afternoon -sun from Parnassus, was turned by Chairon so as to front the east. -Empedocles, the natural philosopher, once blocked up a mountain gorge, -which sent a destructive and pestilential south wind blowing down upon -the plains. By this means, it was thought, he shut the plague out of the -district. - -Well, since there are certain injurious and unhealthy states of mind -which chill and darken the soul, it would be best to get rid of them—to -make a clean sweep to the foundations, and give ourselves the benefit of -a clear sky, light, and pure air [Sidenote: D] to breathe. If not, we -should reform and readjust them by turning them some other way about. - -We may take the vice of the busybody as an instance in point. It is a -love of prying into other people’s troubles, a disease tainted—we may -believe—with both envy and malice. - - _Why so sharp-eyed, my most malignant Sir, - For others’ faults, yet overlook your own?_ - -Pray turn your pryingness the other way about, and make it face inwards. -If you are so fond of the business of inquiring into defects, you will -find plenty to occupy you at home. - -[Sidenote: *] _Abundant as leaves on the oak or the water that rolls -from Alizon_ will you find the errors in your conduct, the disorders in -your heart and mind, and the lapses in your duty. - -[Sidenote: E] According to Xenophon, a good householder has a special -place for the utensils of sacrifice, and a special place for those of -the table; agricultural implements are stored in one room, weapons of -war in another. In your own case you have one stock of faults arising -from envy, another from jealousy, another from cowardice, another from -meanness. These are the faults for you to inspect and examine. Block up -the windows [Sidenote: F] and alleys of your inquisitiveness on the side -towards your neighbours, and open others which look into your own -house—the male quarters, the female quarters, the living-rooms of the -servants. Our busy curiosity will find occupation of a profitable and -salutary, instead of a useless and malicious, kind, if each one will say -to himself: - - _How have I err’d? What deed have I done? What duty neglected?_ - -As it is, we are all of us like the Lamia in the fable, of whom -[Sidenote: 516] we are told that at home she is asleep and blind, with -her eyes stowed away in a jar, but that when she comes abroad she puts -them in and can see. Outside, and in dealing with others, we furnish our -malice with an eye in the shape of our meddlesomeness, but we are -continually being tripped up by our own misdeeds and vices, of which we -are unaware, because we provide ourselves with no light or vision to -perceive them. It follows that the busybody is a better friend to his -enemies than to himself. While censoriously reproving their shortcomings -and showing them what they ought to avoid or amend, he is so taken up -with faults outside that he overlooks most of those at home. - -[Sidenote: B] Odysseus refused even to talk to his mother, until he had -got his answer from the seer concerning the business which had brought -him to Hades. When he had received the information, he turned to her, -and also began to put questions to the other women, asking who Tyro was, -and the beautiful Chloris, and why Epicaste met her death by - - _Tying a sheer-hung noose from the height of the lofty roof-tree_. - -Not so we. While treating our own concerns with the greatest -indifference, ignorance, and neglect, we begin discussing other people’s -pedigrees—how our neighbour’s grandfather was a Syrian and his -grandmother a Thracian. ‘So-and-So owes more than seven hundred pounds, -and cannot pay the interest.’ We also make it our business to inquire -about such matters as where So-and-So got his wife from, and what -private talk was that between A and B in the corner. Socrates, on the -other [Sidenote: C] hand, went about inquiring, ‘By what arguments did -Pythagoras carry conviction?’ So Aristippus, when he met Ischomachus at -Olympia, proceeded to ask by what kind of conversation Socrates affected -the Athenians as he did. When he had gleaned a few seeds or samples of -his talk, he was so moved that he suffered a physical collapse, and -became quite pale and thin. In the end he set sail for Athens, and -slaked his thirst with draughts from the fountain-head, studying the -man, his discourses and his philosophy, of which the aim was to -recognize one’s own vices and get rid of them. - -But there are some to whom their own life is a most distressing -[Sidenote: D] spectacle, and who therefore cannot bear to look at it nor -to reflect the light of reason upon themselves. Their soul is so fraught -with all manner of vices, that, shuddering with horror at what lies -within, it darts away from home, and goes prowling round other men’s -concerns, where it lets its malice batten and grow fat. - -It often happens that a domestic fowl, though there is plenty of food -lying at its disposal, will slink into a corner and scratch - - _Where so appeareth, mayhap, one barley-grain in a dunghill._ - -It is much the same with the busybody. Ignoring the topics and questions -which are open to all, and which no one prevents him from asking about -or is annoyed with him if he does ask, [Sidenote: E] he goes picking out -of every house the troubles which it is endeavouring to bury out of -sight. But surely it was a neat answer which the Egyptian made to the -man who asked him what he was carrying in that wrapper. ‘That,’ said he, -‘is why it _is_ in a wrapper.’ And why, pray, are you so inquisitive -about a thing which is being concealed? If it had not been something -undesirable, there would have been no concealment. It is not usual to -walk into another man’s house without knocking at the door. Nowadays -there are doorkeepers—formerly knockers were beaten upon the doors in -order to give warning—the intention being that the stranger shall not -surprise the lady of the [Sidenote: F] house or her daughter in the -open, or come upon a slave receiving punishment, or the handmaids -screaming. But these are exactly the things which the busybody steals in -to see. At a staid and quiet household he would have no pleasure in -looking, even if he were invited. His object is to uncover and make -public those things to which keys, bolts, and the street-door owe their -existence. ‘The winds which vex us most,’ says Ariston, ‘are those which -pull up our cloaks.’ But the busybody strips off not only our mantles -and tunics, but our walls; he spreads our doors wide open, and makes his -way like a piercing wind through the ‘_maiden of tender skin_‘, prying -and sneaking into [Sidenote: 517] her bacchic revels, her dances, and -her all-night festivals. - -As Cleon in the comedy had - - _His hands in Askthorpe and his thoughts in Thefton_, - -so the busybody’s thoughts are at one and the same time in the houses of -the rich and the hovels of the poor, in the courts of kings and the -chambers of the newly-wed. He searches into everybody’s -business—business of strangers, and business of potentates. Nor is his -search without danger. If one were to take a taste of aconite because he -was inquisitive as to its properties, he would find that he had killed -the learner before he got his lesson. So those who pry into the troubles -of the [Sidenote: B] great destroy themselves before discovering what -they seek. If any one is not satisfied with the beams which the sun -lavishes so abundantly upon all, but audaciously insists upon gazing -unabashed at the orb itself and probing the light to its heart, the -result is blindness. It was therefore wise of Philippides, the comic -poet, when King Lysimachus once asked him, ‘What can I give you of -mine?’ to reply, ‘Anything, Sire, but your secrets.’ The finest and most -pleasant aspects of royalty are those displayed outwardly—its banquets, -wealth, pomps and shows, graces and favours. But if a king has any -secret, keep away from it and leave it alone. A king does not conceal -his [Sidenote: C] joy when prosperous, nor his laughter when jocose, nor -his intention to do a kindness or confer a boon. When he hides a thing, -when he is glum, unsmiling, unapproachable, it is time for alarm. It -means that he has been storing up anger, and that it is festering; or -that he is sullenly meditating a severe punishment; or that he is -jealous of his wife, or suspicious of his son, or distrustful of a -friend. Run, run from that cloud which is gathering so black! You cannot -possibly miss the thunder and lightning, when the matter which is now a -secret bursts out in storm. - -How, then, are we to escape this vice? By turning our inquisitiveness—as -we have said—the other way round, and, as far as possible, directing our -minds to better and more interesting objects. If you are to pry, pry -into questions [Sidenote: D] connected with sky, earth, air, or sea. You -are by nature fond of looking either at little things or at big things. -If at big things, apply your curiosity to the sun; ask where he sets and -whence he rises. Inquire into the changes of the moon, as if she were a -human being. Ask where she loses so much of her light, and whence she -gets it back; how - - _Once dim, she first comes forth and makes - Her young face beauteous, gathering to the full, - And, when her greatest splendours she hath shown, - Fades out, and passes into naught again._ - -These, too, are secrets—the secrets of Nature; but Nature has [Sidenote: -E] no grievance against those who find them out. Are the big things -beyond you? Then pry into the smaller ones. Ask how it is that some -plants are always flourishing and green, proudly displaying their wealth -at every season, while others are at one moment as good as these, but at -another have squandered their abundance all at once, like some human -spendthrift, and are left bare and beggared. Why, again, do some plants -produce elongated fruits, some angular, some round and globelike? - -But perhaps you will have no curiosity for such concerns, [Sidenote: F] -because there is nothing wrong about them. Well, if inquisitiveness -absolutely must be always browsing and passing its time among things -sordid, like a maggot among dead matter, let us introduce it to history -and story, and supply it with bad things in abundance and without stint. -For there it will find - - _Fallings of men and spurnings-off of life_, - -seductions of women, assaults by slaves, slanderings of friends, -concoctions of poisons, envies, jealousies, shipwrecks of homes, -overthrows of rulers. Take your fill, enjoy yourself, and cause no -annoyance or pain to any of those with whom you come in contact. - -Apparently, however, inquisitiveness finds no pleasure in scandals which -are stale; it wants them hot and fresh. And [Sidenote: 518] while it -enjoys the spectacle of a novel tragedy, it takes no sort of interest in -the comedy or more cheerful side of life. Consequently the busybody -lends but a careless and indifferent ear to the account of a wedding, a -sacrifice, or a complimentary ‘farewell’. He says he has already heard -most of the details, and urges the narrator to cut them short or omit -them. But if any one will sit by him and tell him the news about the -corruption of a girl or the unfaithfulness of a wife or an impending -action at law or a quarrel between brothers, there is no sleepiness or -hurry about him, but - - _More words still doth he ask, and proffers his ears to receive - them._ - -As applied to the busybody, the words - - _How much more apt to reach the ear of man - An ill thing than a happy!_ - -are a true saying. As a cupping-glass sucks from the flesh what -[Sidenote: B] is worst in it, so the inquisitive ear draws to itself the -most undesirable topics. To vary the figure: cities have certain -‘Accursed’ or ‘Dismal’ gates, through which they take out criminals on -their way to death and throw the refuse and offscourings of -purification, while nothing sacred or undefiled goes in or out through -them. So with the ears of the busybody. They give passage to nothing -fine or useful, but serve only as the pathway of gruesome -communications, with their load of foul and polluted gossip. - - _No chance brings other minstrel to my roof, - But always Lamentation._ - -[Sidenote: C] That is the one Muse and Siren of the busybody, the most -pleasant of all music to his ear. For his vice is a love of finding out -whatever is secret and concealed, and no one conceals a good thing when -he has one; on the contrary, he will pretend to one which has no -existence. Since therefore it is troubles that the busybody is eager to -discover, the disease from which he suffers is malignant gloating—own -brother to envy and spite. For envy is pain at another’s good; malignity -is pleasure at another’s harm; and the parent of both is ill-nature—the -[Sidenote: D] feeling of a savage or a brute beast. - -So painful do we all find it to have our troubles revealed, that there -are many who would rather die than tell a physician of a secret disease. -Imagine Herophilus or Erasistratus, or Asclepius himself—when he was a -mortal man—calling from house to house with his drugs and his -instruments, and asking whether a man had a fistula or a woman a cancer -in the womb! Inquisitiveness in their profession may, it is true, save a -life. None the less, I presume, every one would have scouted such a -person, [Sidenote: E] for coming to investigate other people’s ailments -without waiting till he was required and sent for. Yet our busybody -searches out precisely these, or even worse, ailments; and, since he -does so not by way of curing them, but merely of disclosing them, he -deserves the hatred he gets. - -We are annoyed and indignant with the collector of customs,[42] not when -he picks out and levies on those articles which we import openly, but -when, in the search for hidden goods, he ransacks among baggage and -merchandise which are not in [Sidenote: F] question. Yet the law permits -him to do so, and he is the loser if he does not. On the other hand, the -busybody lets his own concerns go to ruin, while he is occupying himself -with those of other people. He rarely takes a walk to the farm; it is -too lonely, and he cannot bear the quiet and silence. And if, after a -time, he does chance along, he has a keener eye for his neighbour’s -vines than for his own. He proceeds to ask how many of his neighbour’s -cattle have died, or how much of his wine turned sour. After a good meal -of such news he is quickly off and away. - -Your true and genuine type of farmer has no desire to hear even the news -which finds its own way from the city. Says he: - - _Then, while he digs, he’ll tell - The terms o’the treaty. He must now, confound him, - Go round and poke his nose in things like that!_ - -[Sidenote: 519] But to your busybody country life is a stale and -uninteresting thing with nothing to fuss about. He therefore flees from -it, and pushes into the Exchange, the Market, or the Harbour. ‘Is there -any news?’ ‘Why, weren’t you at market early this morning? Do you -imagine there has been a revolution in three hours?’ If, however, any -one has a piece of news to tell, down he gets from his horse, grasps the -man’s hand, kisses him, and stands there listening. But if some one -meets him and says there is nothing fresh, he exclaims, as if he were -annoyed: ‘What? Haven’t you been at market? Haven’t you been near the -Board-Room? And haven’t you met the new arrivals from [Sidenote: B] -Italy?’ - -The Locrian magistrates therefore did right in fining any one who, after -being out of town, came up and asked, ‘Is there any news?’ As the -butchers pray for a good supply of animals, and fishermen for a good -supply of fish, so busybodies pray for a good supply of calamities, for -plenty of troubles, for novelties and changes. They must always have -their fish to catch or carcass to cut up. - -Another good rule was that of the legislator of Thurii, who forbade the -lampooning of citizens on the stage, with the exception of adulterers -and busybodies. The one class bears a resemblance to the other, adultery -being a sort of inquisitiveness into [Sidenote: C] another’s pleasure, -and a prying search into matters protected from the general eye, while -inquisitiveness is the illicit denuding and corrupting of a secret. -While a natural consequence of much learning is having much to say, and -therefore Pythagoras enjoined upon the young a five years’ silence, -which he called ‘Truce to Speech’, the necessary concomitant of -curiosity is speaking evil. What the curious delight to hear, they -delight to talk about; what they take pains to gather from others, they -joy in giving out to new hearers. It follows that, besides its -[Sidenote: D] other drawbacks, their disease actually stands in the way -of its own desires. For every one is on his guard to hide things from -them, and is reluctant to do anything when the busybody is looking, or -to say anything when he is listening. People put off a consultation and -postpone the consideration of business until such persons are out of the -way. If, when a secret matter is towards, or an important action is in -the doing, a busybody appears upon the scene, they take it away and hide -it, as they [Sidenote: E] would a piece of victuals when the cat comes -past. Often, therefore, he is the only person not permitted to hear or -see what others may see and hear. - -For the same reason the busybody can find no one to trust him. We would -rather trust our letters, papers, or seals to a slave or a stranger than -to an inquisitive relation or friend. Bellerophon, though the writing -which he carried was about himself, would not broach it, but showed the -same continence in keeping his hands off the king’s letter as in keeping -them off his wife. - -Yes, inquisitiveness is as incontinent as adultery, and not only -incontinent, but terribly silly and foolish. To pass by so many women -who are public property, and to struggle to get at one [Sidenote: F] who -is kept under lock and key, who is expensive, and perhaps ugly to boot, -is the very height of insanity. The busybody is just as bad. He passes -by much that is admirable to see and hear, many an excellent discourse -or discussion, to dig into another man’s poor little letter or clap his -ear to his neighbour’s wall, listening to slaves and womenfolk -whispering together, and incurring danger often, and discredit always. - -[Sidenote: 520] Well, if he wishes to get rid of his vice, the busybody -will find nothing so helpful as to think over the discoveries he has -hitherto made. Simonides used to say that, in opening his boxes after a -lapse of time, he found the fee-box always full and the thanks-box -always empty. So, if one were to open the store-room of inquisitiveness -after an interval, and to contemplate all the useless, futile, and -uninviting things with which it is filled, he would probably become sick -of the business, so nauseating and senseless would it appear. - -Suppose a person to run over the works of our old writers and pick out -their faultiest passages, compiling and keeping a book full of such -things as ‘headless’ lines of Homer, solecisms [Sidenote: B] in the -tragedians, the indecent and licentious language to women by which -Archilochus makes a sorry show of himself. Does he not deserve the -execration in the tragedy: - - _Perish, thou picker-up of miseries!_ - -Execration apart, his treasury, filled with other men’s faults, -possesses neither beauty nor use. It is like the town which Philip -founded with the rudest riff-raff, and which he called Knaveborough. - -With the busybody, however, it is not from lines of poetry, but from -lives, that he goes gleaning and gathering blunders and slips and -solecisms, till the memory which he carries about is the dullest and -dreariest record-box, crammed with ugly things. [Sidenote: C] - -At Rome there are those who set no store by the paintings, the statues, -or—failing these—the handsome children or women on sale, but who haunt -the monster-market, examining specimens with no calves to their legs, or -with weasel-elbows, three eyes, or ostrich-heads, and looking out for -the appearance of any - - _Commingled shape and misformed prodigy._ - -Yet if you keep on showing them such sights, they will soon become -surfeited and sick of it all. In the same way those who make it their -business to pry into other people’s failures in their affairs, blots on -their pedigree, disturbances and delinquencies in their homes, will do -well to remind themselves how thankless [Sidenote: D] and unprofitable -their previous discoveries have proved. - -The most effective way, however, of preventing this weakness is to form -a habit—to begin at an early stage and train ourselves systematically to -acquire the necessary self-control. It is by habit that the vice -increases, the advance of the disease being gradual. How this is, we -shall see, in discussing the proper method of practice. - -Let us make a beginning with comparatively trifling and insignificant -matters. - -On the roads it can be no difficult matter to abstain from reading -[Sidenote: E] the inscriptions on the tombs. Nor in the promenades can -there be any hardship in refusing to let the eye linger upon the -writings on the walls. You have only to tell yourself that they contain -nothing useful or entertaining. There is A expressing his ‘kind -sentiments’ towards B; So-and-So described as ‘the best of friends’; and -much mere twaddle of the same kind. No doubt it seems as if the reading -of them does you no harm; but harm you it does, without your knowing it, -by inducing a habit of inquiring into things which do not concern you. -Hunters do not permit young hounds to turn aside and [Sidenote: F] -follow up every scent, but pull them sharply back with the leash, so as -to keep their power of smell in perfectly clean condition for their -proper work, and make it stick more keenly to the tracks: - - _With nostril a-search for the trail that the beast gives forth from - its body_. - -The same watchfulness must be shown in suppressing, or in diverting to -useful ends, the tendency of an inquisitive person to run off the track -and wander after everything that he can see or hear. An eagle or a lion -gathers its talons in when it [Sidenote: 521] walks, so as not to wear -the sharp edge from their tips. Similarly let us treat the inquiring -spirit as the keen edge to our love of learning, and refrain from -wasting or blunting it upon objects of no value. - -In the next place let us train ourselves, when passing another’s door, -to refrain from looking in, or from letting our inquisitive gaze clutch -at what is passing inside. Xenocrates said—and we shall do well to keep -the remark in mind—that whether we set foot or set eyes in another man’s -house makes no difference. Not only is such prying unfair and improper; -we get no pleasure from the spectacle. - - _Unsightly, stranger, are the sights within_, - -is a saying which is generally true of what we see inside—a litter of -pots and pans, or servant-girls sitting about, but nothing of [Sidenote: -B] any importance or interest. This furtive throwing of sidelong -glances, which at the same time gives a kind of squint to the mind, is -ugly, and the habit is demoralizing. When the Olympian victor Dioxippus -was making a triumphal entry in a chariot, and could not drag his eyes -from a beautiful woman among the spectators, but kept turning half round -and throwing side glances in her direction, Diogenes—who saw it -all—remarked, ‘See how a bit of a girl gets the neck-grip on our great -athlete!’ Inquisitive people, however, are to be seen gripped by the -neck and twisted about by any kind of sight, when they once develop a -habit of squandering their glances in all directions. - -This is assuredly no right use of the faculty of vision. It should -[Sidenote: C] not go gadding about like some ill-trained maidservant; -but when the mind sends it upon an errand, it should make haste to reach -its destination, deliver its message, and then come quietly home again -to wait upon the commands of the reason. Instead of this, the case is as -in Sophocles: - - _Thereon the Aenean driver’s hard-mouthed colts - Break from control._ - -When the faculty of vision has not been tutored and trained in the -proper manner as above described, it runs away, drags [Sidenote: D] the -mind with it, and often brings it into disastrous collisions. - -There is a story that Democritus deliberately destroyed his sight by -fixing his eyes upon a red-hot mirror and allowing its heat to be -focussed upon them. His object, it is said, was to block up the windows -toward the street, and thus prevent the disturbance of his intellect by -repeated calls from outside, enabling it to stay at home and devote -itself to pure thinking. Though the story is a fiction, nothing is more -true than that those who make most use of their mind make few calls upon -the senses. Note how our halls of learning are built far out from the -towns, and how night has been styled the ‘_well-minded_‘, from a belief -[Sidenote: E] that quiet and the absence of distraction are a powerful -aid to intellectual discovery and research. - -Suppose, again, that people are quarrelling and abusing each other in -the market-place. It requires no great effort of self-denial to keep at -a distance. When a crowd is running towards a certain spot, it is easy -for you to remain seated, or else, if you lack the necessary strength of -mind, to get up and go away. There is no advantage to be got from mixing -yourself with busybodies, whereas you will derive great benefit from -putting a forcible check upon your curiosity and training it to obey the -commands of the reason. - -[Sidenote: F] We may now go a step further, and tax ourselves more -severely. It is good practice, when a successful entertainment is going -on in a public hall, to pass it by; when our friends invite us to a -performance by a dancer or comedian, to decline; when there is a roar in -the race-ground or the circus, to take no notice. Socrates used to urge -the avoidance of all foods and drinks which tempt one to eat when he is -not hungry or to drink when he is not thirsty. In the same way we shall -do well to shun carefully all appeals to eye or ear, when, though they -are no business of ours, their attractions prove too much for us. - -Cyrus refused to see Panthea, and when Araspes talked of her [Sidenote: -522] remarkable beauty, his answer was: ‘All the more reason for keeping -away from her. If I took your advice and went to see her, she might -perhaps tempt me to be visiting her again when I could not spare the -time, and to be sitting and looking at her to the neglect of much -important business.’ In the same way Alexander refused to set eyes on -Darius’ wife, who was said to be strikingly handsome. Though he visited -the mother—an elderly woman—he would not bring himself to see her young -and beautiful daughter. But what we do is to peep into women’s litters -and hang about their windows, finding nothing improper in encouraging -our curiosity and allowing it such dangerous [Sidenote: B] and unchecked -play. - -Note how you may train yourself for other virtues. To learn justice you -should sometimes forgo an honest gain, and so accustom yourself to keep -aloof from dishonest ones. Similarly, to learn continence, you should -sometimes hold aloof from your own wife, and so secure yourself against -temptation from another’s. Apply this habit to inquisitiveness. -Endeavour occasionally to miss hearing or seeing things which concern -yourself. When something happens at home, and a person wishes to tell -you of it, put the matter off; and when things have been said which -appear to affect yourself, refuse to hear them. Remember how Oedipus was -brought into the direst disasters by over-curiosity. Finding he was no -Corinthian, but an alien, he set to work [Sidenote: C] to discover who -he was, and so he met with Laius. He killed him, married his own mother, -with the throne for dowry, and then, while apparently blessed by -fortune, began his search once more. The endeavours of his wife to -prevent him only made him question still more closely, and in the most -peremptory way, the old man who was in the secret. And at last, when -circumstances are already bringing him to suspect, and the old man -cries: - - _Alas! I stand on the dread brink of speech!_ - -he is nevertheless in such a blaze or spasm of passion that he replies: - - _And I of hearing; and yet hear I must._ - -[Sidenote: D] So bitter-sweet, so uncontrollable, is the excitement of -curiosity—like the tickling of a wound, at which one tears till he makes -it bleed. Meanwhile if we are free from that malady, and mild by nature, -we shall ignore a disagreeable thing and say: - - _Sovran Oblivion, how wise art thou!_ - -We must therefore train ourselves to this end. If a letter is brought to -us, we must not show all that hurry and eagerness to open it which most -people display, when they bite the fastenings through with their teeth, -if their hands are too slow. When a messenger arrives from somewhere or -other, we must not run to meet him, nor get up from our seats. If a -friend [Sidenote: E] says, ‘I have something new to tell you,’ let us -reply: ‘Better, if you have something useful or profitable.’ When I was -once lecturing at Rome, the famous Rusticus—who was afterwards put to -death by Domitian out of jealousy at his reputation—was among my -hearers. A soldier came through the audience and handed him a note from -the emperor. There was a hush, and I made a pause, to allow of his -reading the letter. This, however, he refused to do, nor would he open -it, until I had finished my discourse and the audience broke up. The -incident caused universal admiration at his dignified behaviour. - -But when one feeds his inquisitiveness upon permissible material until -he makes it robust and headstrong, he no longer [Sidenote: F] finds it -easy to master, when force of habit urges it towards forbidden ground. -Such persons will stealthily open their friends’ missives, will push -their way into a confidential meeting, will get a view of rites which it -is an impiety to see, will tread in hallowed places, and will pry into -the doings and sayings of a king. - -Now with a despot—who is compelled to know everything—there is nothing -that makes him so detested as the crew known as his ‘ears’ and -‘jackals’. ‘Listeners’ were first instituted by Darius the Younger, who -had no confidence in himself and looked upon every one with fear and -suspicion. ‘Jackals’ were [Sidenote: 523] the creation of the Dionysii, -who distributed them among the people of Syracuse. Naturally, when the -revolution came, these were the first to be seized and cudgelled to -death by the Syracusans. - -Blackmailers and informers are a breed belonging to the Busybody clan; -they are members of the family. But, whereas the informer looks to see -if his neighbours have done or plotted any mischief, the busybody brings -to book and drags into public even the misfortunes for which they are -not responsible. It is said that the outcast derived his name of -_aliterios_ in the first instance from being a busybody. It appears that -when a severe famine once occurred at Athens, and when those who were in -possession of wheat, instead of bringing it in to the public [Sidenote: -B] stock, used to grind it (_alein_) secretly by night in their houses, -certain persons, who went round watching for the noise of the mills, -were in consequence called _aliterioi_. It was in the same way, we are -told, that the informer won his name of _sukophantes_. The export of -figs (_suka_) being prohibited, those who gave information (_phainein_) -and impeached the offenders were called _sukophantai_. Busybodies would -do well to reflect upon this fact. It may make them ashamed of the -family likeness between their own practices and those of a class which -is a special object of loathing and anger. - -Footnote 42: - - These were farmed. - - - - - ON GARRULOUSNESS - - -[Sidenote: 502 B] When philosophy undertakes to cure garrulity it has a -difficult and intractable case in hand. The remedy is reason, which -requires that the patient should listen. But the garrulous person -[Sidenote: C] does not listen, for he is always talking. Herein lies the -first trouble with an inability to keep silent; it means an inability to -listen. It is the deliberate deafness of a person who appears to find -fault with nature for giving him two ears and only one tongue. Euripides -is, of course, right when he says of the unintelligent hearer: - - _I cannot fill a man who cannot hold - My wise words, poured and poured in unwise ears._ - -But there is more reason to say of the babbler: - - _I cannot fill a man who takes not in - My wise words, poured and poured in unwise ears_, - -—or rather poured over them, since he talks though you do [Sidenote: D] -not listen, and refuses to listen when you talk. For even if, thanks to -some ebb in his loquacity, he does listen for a moment, he immediately -makes up for it several times over. - -There is a colonnade at Olympia which reverberates a single utterance -time after time, and is therefore known as the ‘Seven-Voiced’. Say but -the least thing to set garrulity sounding, and it immediately dins you -with its echoes: - - _Stirring the strings o’ the mind that none should stir._ - -The passage through the babbler’s ears leads, apparently, not to his -mind, but to his tongue. Consequently, while others [Sidenote: E] retain -what is said, the loquacious person lets it all leak away, and goes -about like a vessel full of noise but void of sense. Nevertheless, if we -are resolved to leave no stone unturned, let us say to the babbler: - - _Hush, boy: in silence many a virtue lies_, - -and, first and foremost, the two virtues of hearing and being heard. The -garrulous person can get the benefit of neither, and makes a miserable -failure of the very thing he is aiming at. - -In other mental maladies—love of money, love of glory, love of -pleasure—there is at least a chance of gaining the object pursued. But -with the babbler that result can hardly happen. [Sidenote: F] What he -desires is listeners, and listeners he cannot get, for they all run -headlong away. If, when they are sitting in a lounge or taking a walk -together, they catch sight of him approaching, they promptly pass each -other the word to shift camp. - -When a silence occurs at some meeting, it is said that _Hermes has -appeared upon the scene_. Similarly, when a chatterer comes in to a -wine-party or a social circle, everybody grows mum, for [Sidenote: 503] -fear of giving him an opportunity. And if he begins of his own accord to -open his lips, then - - _As ere the storm, when the North wind blows - By the headland that juts to the deep_, - -the prospect of being tossed and seasick is so distressing that up they -get and out they go. - -For the same reason he finds no welcome from neighbours at a dinner or -from messmates on a journey or a voyage. They merely tolerate him -because they must. For he sticks to you anywhere and everywhere, seizing -you by the clothes or the beard, and slapping you in the ribs. - - _Then are your feet most precious_, - -as Archilochus would say—and not only Archilochus, but that wise man -Aristotle. When the latter was himself once worried [Sidenote: B] by a -chatterer, who bored him with a number of silly stories and kept -repeating, ‘Isn’t it wonderful, Aristotle?’ he retorted, ‘The wonder is -not at that, but at any one tolerating you, when he owns a pair of -legs.’ To another person of the kind, who, after a great deal of talk, -remarked, ‘Master, I have wearied you with my chatter,’ he replied, ‘Not -at all; I was not listening.’ Precisely so. If a chatterer insists on -talking, the mind surrenders the ears to him and lets the stream pour -over them on the outside, while inwardly it goes its own way, opening -[Sidenote: C] and reading to itself a book of quite different thoughts. -It follows that he can get no hearer either to attend to him or to -believe him. A babbler’s talk is as barren of effect as the seed of a -person over-prone to sexualities is said to be. - -And yet there is no part of us which Nature has fenced with so excellent -a barricade as the tongue. In front of that organ it has planted a guard -in the shape of the teeth, so that, if it will not obey orders and pull -itself together inside when reason tightens the ‘_silence-working -reins_‘,[43] we may check its rashness by biting it till it bleeds. The -phrase of Euripides is that ‘_disaster is the end_’ not of an -‘unchained’ treasury or storeroom, but of an ‘_unchained mouth_‘. To -recognize that a storeroom without a door, or a purse without a -fastening, is of no use to the owner, and yet to possess a mouth without -lock or door, but with as perpetual an outflow as the mouth of the -[Sidenote: D] Black Sea, is to set the lowest possible value on speech. - -The result is that such a person meets with no belief, though all speech -has that object, its final cause being to create precisely such credence -in the hearer. A chatterer is disbelieved even when he tells the truth. -For as wheat, when shut in a bin, is found to increase in bulk but to -deteriorate in quality, so, when a story finds its way into a chatterer, -it generates a large addition of falsehood and its credibility is -thereby corrupted. - -Again, any self-respecting and well-behaved person will beware of -drunkenness. For while—as some put it—anger lives next door to madness, -drunkenness lives in the same house. [Sidenote: E] Or rather it _is_ -madness, of shorter duration, it is true, but more culpable, as being in -a measure voluntary. But the charge most seriously urged against -drunkenness is its intemperate and irresponsible language: - - _For though right shrewd be a man, wine eggs him on till he singeth; - It loosens him that he laughs with a feeble laughter, and danceth._ - -Yet if this were the worst—singing, laughing, and dancing—there would -be, so far, nothing very terrible. - - _And he letteth slip some speech, the which were better unspoken_:— - -[Sidenote: F] that is where the mischief and danger begin. - -We may, indeed, believe that these lines of the poet give the solution -of the question discussed in the philosophic schools as to the -distinction between mellowness and intoxication: mellowness produces -unbending, but drunkenness foolish twaddling. As the proverb-makers put -it, ‘_What is in the sober man’s heart is on the drunken man’s tongue._’ -Hence when Bias once kept silent at a carousal, and a chatterer taunted -him with stupidity, he retorted: ‘And, pray, who could keep silent over -his wine, if he were a fool?’ A certain person at Athens was [Sidenote: -504] once entertaining envoys from a king, and, as they were eager for -him to get together the philosophic teachers, he made every effort to -gratify them. While the rest took part in general discussion, to which -each contributed his quota, Zeno said nothing. At this the visitors, -pledging him in friendly and courteous terms, asked him, ‘And what are -we to say to the king about you, Zeno?’ ‘Merely,’ replied he, ‘that -there is one old man at Athens who is capable of holding his tongue -[Sidenote: *] when drinking.’ - -Silence, then, goes with depth, the capacity to keep a secret, -[Sidenote: B] and sobriety. Drunkenness, on the other hand, will be -talking, for it means folly and witlessness, and therefore loquacity. In -fact, the philosophic definition of intoxication calls it ‘_silly talk -in one’s cups_‘. The blame, therefore, is not for drinking, if one can -drink and yet at the same time hold his tongue. It is the foolish talk -that converts mellowness into drunkenness. - -Well, while the drunken man talks nonsense at his wine, the babbler -talks it everywhere—in the market-place, in the theatre, when walking, -when tipsy, by day and by night. As your doctor, he is a greater -infliction than the disease; as your shipmate, more disagreeable than -the sea-sickness; his praises are more annoying than another person’s -blame. A tactful rogue is more pleasant company than an honest -chatterer. In Sophocles, when [Sidenote: C] Ajax is beginning to use -rough language, Nestor, in endeavouring to soothe him, says politely: - - _I blame thee not; for though thy words are wrong, - Thine acts are right._ - -But those are not our feelings towards the twaddler. On the contrary, -the tactlessness of his talk spoils and nullifies anything acceptable in -what he may do. - -Lysias once gave a litigant a speech which he had composed for him. -After reading it several times the man came back. In a despondent tone -he told Lysias that, when he first went through the speech, it appeared -wonderfully good, but on taking it up a second and third time, he found -it extremely weak and ineffective. ‘Well,’ said Lysias laughing, ‘isn’t -it only once [Sidenote: D] that you have to speak it before the jury?’ -And consider how persuasive and charming Lysias is! For he is another -who - - _Hath goodly portion, I trow, - Of the Muses violet-tress’d._ - -Of all things that are said about the great bard the truest is this—that -Homer alone manages never to cloy the appetite, since he is always new, -and his charm always at its height. Nevertheless, exclaiming on his own -account in the words of Odysseus: [Sidenote: *] - - _But to me it is hateful - To tell o’er a story again, when once right plainly ’tis told you_, - -he is continually avoiding that tendency to surfeit which threatens talk -of every kind, carrying his hearers from one story to another, and -relieving their satiety by his constant freshness. - -Our babblers, on the contrary, bore us to death with their repetitions, -as if our ears were palimpsests for them to scrawl rubbish upon. - -Let this, then, be the first thing of which we remind them. [Sidenote: -E] It is with talking as it is with wine. The purpose of wine is to -create pleasure and friendly feeling; but to insist upon our drinking it -in great quantities and without qualifying it, is to lead us into -offensive and wanton behaviour. So, while talk plays the most pleasant -and human part in our intercourse, those who make a wrong and rash use -of it render it inhuman and insufferable. The means by which they -imagine they are ingratiating themselves and gaining admiration and -friendship, only makes them a nuisance and wins them ridicule and -dislike. - -How destitute of charm would be a person who alienated his company and -drove them away with the very ‘girdle of charm’! And how destitute of -culture and tact is the man [Sidenote: F] who arouses annoyance and -hostility by means of speech! - -Other infirmities and disorders may be dangerous or detestable or -ridiculous. Garrulity is all three at once. It is derided for relating -what everybody knows; it is hated for bearing bad news; it is endangered -through blabbing secrets. This is the [Sidenote: 505] reason why, when -Anacharsis went to sleep after being entertained at dinner at Solon’s -house, he was seen to be holding his right hand over his mouth. He -believed—quite rightly—that the tongue requires a firmer control than -any other member. It would be difficult, for instance, to count up as -many persons who have been ruined by sensuality, as cities and dominions -which have been brought to destruction by the divulgence of a secret. -When Sulla was besieging Athens, he could not afford to spend much time -upon it, - - _Since other labour was urging_, - -Mithridates having seized upon Asia, and the Marian party [Sidenote: B] -being again masters of Rome. It happened, however, that a number of old -men were talking at a barber’s, to the effect that no watch was kept -upon the Heptachalcon and that the town was in danger of capture at that -point. They were overheard by spies, who gave information to Sulla; and -he promptly brought up his forces at midnight, led in his army, and -almost razed the city to the ground, filling it with carnage till the -Cerameicus flowed with blood. His anger with the Athenians was, however, -due more to their words than to their deeds. They would leap on to the -walls, and abuse him and Metella, and by jeering at him with [Sidenote: -C] - - _A mulberry is Sulla, sprinkled o’er with barley-meal_, - -and a number of similar scurrilities, they brought upon themselves—to -use a phrase of Plato—‘_a very heavy penalty_’ for that ‘_very light_’ -thing, their words. - -It was, again, the talkativeness of one man that prevented Rome from -obtaining its freedom by the removal of Nero. All preparations had been -made, and only a single night was left before the despot was to perish. -It happened, however, that the man who was to perform the assassination, -when on his way to the theatre, saw a prisoner at the palace doors on -the point of being brought before Nero. As he was bewailing his fate, -our friend came up close and whispered to him, ‘My good [Sidenote: D] -man, only pray that to-day may pass, and to-morrow you will be offering -me thanks.’ The prisoner grasped the meaning of the hint, and -reflecting, I suppose, that - - _’Tis a fool who forgoes what he holds, to pursue what is out of his - keeping_, - -chose the surer rather than the more righteous way of saving himself. -That is to say, he informed Nero of the expression used. The man was -thereupon promptly seized, and underwent rack, fire, and lash while -denying, in the face of constraint, what he had betrayed without any -constraint. - -The philosopher Zeno, for fear that bodily suffering might force him to -reveal some secret in spite of himself, bit through his tongue and spat -it out at the despot. Leaena, again, has been gloriously rewarded for -her self-command. She was the [Sidenote: E] mistress of Harmodius and -Aristogeiton, and she shared in their plot against the despots—to the -best of her hopes, which was all a woman could do. For she also was -inspired with the bacchic frenzy of that glorious ‘_bowl of love_‘, and -the God had caused her also to be initiated into the secret. Well, after -they had failed and met their death, she was put to the question and -ordered to inform against those who still escaped detection. She -refused, and the firmness with which she bore her sufferings [Sidenote: -F] proved that, in the love of those heroes for such a woman, there was -nothing unworthy of themselves. The Athenians therefore had a bronze -lioness made without a tongue, and set it up in the gates of the -Acropolis, that courageous animal representing her indomitable firmness, -and the absence of a tongue her power of silence in keeping a solemn -secret. - -No uttered word has ever done such service as many which have been -unuttered. You may some day utter what you have kept silent, but you -cannot unsay what has been said; it has been poured out, and has run -abroad. Hence, I take it, we have mankind to teach us how to speak, but -gods to teach us how to keep silent, our lesson in that art being -received at initiatory [Sidenote: 506] rites and mysteries. Odysseus, -who possessed most eloquence, the poet has made most reticent; he has -done the same with his son, his wife, and his nurse. You hear how she -says: - - _Like stubborn oak or like iron will I hold your secret and keep - it._ - -In the case of Odysseus himself, as he sat beside Penelope, - - _Though in his heart he pitied his wife, and was sore at her - weeping, - Steady within their lids stood his eyes as horn or as iron._ - -[Sidenote: B] So full of self-command was his body in every part, under -such perfect discipline and control did reason hold it, that it forbade -the eyes to shed a tear, the tongue to utter a sound, the heart to -tremble or cry out with rage; - - _And his heart once more did obey, and endure with a patient - enduring_, - -inasmuch as reason had extended even to his irrational movements and -made his very breath and blood amenable to its authority. Most of his -comrades also were of the same character. Self-command and loyalty could -no further go than in their case. Though harried and dashed upon the -ground by the Cyclops, they would not denounce Odysseus to him. They -would not betray the plot against his eye and the implement which had -[Sidenote: C] been sharpened in the fire for that purpose; but they -chose to be eaten raw rather than tell a word of the secret. - -Pittacus, therefore, was not far out, when, upon the King of Egypt -sending him a sacrificial victim and bidding him pick out the ‘fairest -and foulest’ part of the meat, he took out and sent him the tongue, as -being the instrument of both the greatest good and the greatest evil. - -Euripides’ Ino, making bold to speak for herself, says that she knows -how to be - - _Silent in season, speak where speech is safe._ - -Those, indeed, who are blessed with a noble and a truly royal education, -know first how to be silent and then how to talk. The famous king -Antigonus, when his son asked him at what [Sidenote: D] hour they were -to break camp, replied, ‘What are you afraid of? That you may be the -only one to miss hearing the trumpet?’ Was it that he did not trust with -a secret the man to whom he intended to bequeath his throne? Rather he -meant to teach him self-mastery and caution in dealing with such -matters. The aged Metellus, on being asked a similar question during a -campaign, answered, ‘If I thought my shirt knew that secret, I would -take it off and put it on the fire.’ When Eumenes heard that Craterus -was advancing, he told the fact to none of his friends, but pretended -that it was Neoptolemus, whom his [Sidenote: E] soldiers despised, -whereas they entertained a great respect for the reputation of Craterus -and a high esteem of his ability. As, however, no one else found out the -truth, they joined battle, won the victory, killed Craterus without -knowing him, and only discovered who he was from his corpse. So good a -general was the silence of Eumenes in the battle, and so formidable the -opponent whose presence it disguised, that his friends admired instead -of blaming him for not forewarning them. Even if some one does find -fault, it is better to be accused when mistrust has saved you than to be -the accuser when trust proves your undoing. - -What excuse can one possibly find for himself when blaming another for -not holding his tongue? If the matter ought not to [Sidenote: F] have -been known, it was wrong to tell it to any one else. If you let the -secret slip from yourself, and yet ask another person to keep it, you -take refuge in the loyalty of some one else while abandoning loyalty to -yourself. And if he turns out as bad as you, you are deservedly undone; -if better, you are saved by a miracle, through finding another person -more faithful to you than yourself. ‘But So-and-So is my friend.’ So is -a second person _his_ friend, whom _he_ again will trust as _I_ trust -_him_. So with that person and a third, and thus the talk will go on -[Sidenote: 507] increasing and extending in link after link of weak -betrayal. The Unit never goes beyond its own limit, but is, once and for -all, ‘oneness’—whence its name. But the number ‘two’ is the indefinite -beginning of difference, for by the duplication it at once shifts in the -direction of multitude. In the same way, so long as a piece of -information is confined to the first possessor, it is really and truly a -‘secret’. But if it passes by him to a second, it must be classed as a -‘report’. ‘_Winged words_,’ says the poet. If you let go from your hand -a thing with wings, it is not easy to get it back into your grasp; and -if you let an observation slip from your lips, it is impossible to seize -and secure it, but away it flies - - _on nimbly-whirling wing_, - -and circulates in all directions from one set of people to another. - -When a ship is caught by a wind, they put a check upon it [Sidenote: B] -and deaden its speed with cables and anchors; but let a speech run—so to -speak—out of port, and it finds no place to cast and ride at anchor. It -is carried away with a roar, till he who has uttered it is dashed and -sunk upon some great and terrible danger. - - _From but a little torch-light Ida’s heights - May all be set ablaze; so, tell but one, - And all the town will know it._ - -The Roman Senate had been engaged for a number of days [Sidenote: C] in -debating a secret matter of policy. As it gave rise to much -mystification and conjecture, a woman—otherwise irreproachable, but -still a woman—kept pestering her husband and imploring him to tell her -the secret. On her oath, she would be silent: if not, might a curse fall -upon her. She wept and wailed because she was ‘not trusted’. From a -desire to bring home her folly by a proof, the Roman said, ‘Have your -way, wife. But the news is terribly ominous. We have been informed by -the priests that a lark has been seen flying about with a gold helmet -and a spear. We are therefore discussing the portent, and are inquiring, -with the help of the augurs, whether it is good or bad. But mind you -tell nobody.’ With these words he went off to the Forum. The wife at -once seized hold of [Sidenote: D] the first maid-servant to enter the -room, and, beating her own breast and tearing her hair, exclaimed, ‘O my -poor husband and country! What will become of us?‘, her wish being to -give the maid the opportunity of asking ‘Why, what has happened?’ At any -rate she took the question as put, and told the tale, adding the -invariable refrain of every babbler, ‘Tell no one about it, but hold -your tongue.’ The girl no sooner left her than she looked for the -fellow-servant who had least to do, and [Sidenote: E] imparted it to -her. She in turn told it to her lover, who was paying her a visit. The -story went rolling on so rapidly that it reached the Forum before the -man who had invented it, and he was met by an acquaintance, who said, -‘Have you just come down from home?’ ‘This minute,’ he replied. ‘Then -you haven’t heard anything?’ ‘No. Why? Is there any news?’ ‘A lark has -been seen flying about with a gold helmet and a spear, and the -magistrates are about to hold a Senate meeting on the matter.’ At this -the man exclaimed with a laugh, ‘O wife, wife! What a speed! To think -the story has got to the Forum ahead of me!’ First he interviewed the -magistrates and relieved their anxiety; then, on going home, [Sidenote: -F] he proceeded to punish his wife by saying, ‘Wife, you have been the -ruin of me. The secret is public property, and the fault has been traced -to my house. And so I am to be exiled, all because of your loose -tongue.’ Upon her attempting to deny it by arguing ‘But there were three -hundred who heard it as well as you’, he retorted ‘Pooh for your three -hundred! I invented it to try you, all because of your persistence’. - -In this case the man took safe precautions in putting his wife -[Sidenote: 508] to the test, by pouring into the leaky vessel not wine -or oil, but water. It was otherwise with Fulvius, the close friend of -Augustus. The emperor in his old age was lamenting to him over his -desolate home and grieving because, two of his daughter’s children being -dead, and Postumius, the only one left, being in exile on some -calumnious charge, he was being driven to adopt his wife’s son as his -successor, although he felt compassion [Sidenote: B] for his grandson -and was considering the question of recalling him from abroad. Fulvius -divulged what he had heard to his wife, and she to Livia; whereupon -Livia took Caesar bitterly to task, asking why, if he had been so long -of this mind, he did not send for his grandson, instead of putting her -in a position of enmity and strife with the successor to the throne. -Accordingly, when Fulvius came to him—as he regularly did—in the morning -and said ‘Good morning, Caesar’, he replied ‘Good-bye, Fulvius’. Fulvius -took the hint, went away home at once, sent for his wife, and said, -‘Caesar knows that I have betrayed his secret, and I propose therefore -to put myself to death.’ ‘Rightly too,’ answered his wife, ‘seeing that, -after living with [Sidenote: C] me so long, you failed to discover the -looseness of my tongue and to guard against it. But after me, if you -please’—and seizing the sword she despatched herself first. - -The comic poet Philippides therefore acted rightly when, in answer to -the friendly civilities of King Lysimachus and his question ‘What is -there of mine that I can share with you?‘, he replied ‘What you choose, -Sire, except your secrets.’ - -On the other hand garrulity goes with the equally objectionable vice of -inquisitiveness. The babbler must find much to hear, so that he may have -much to tell. Especially must he go round tracking and hunting out -hidden secrets, so as to provide himself with a miscellaneous -stock-in-trade for his foolish [Sidenote: D] talk. Then, like a child -with a piece of ice, he neither likes to keep hold nor wants to let go. -Or rather, the secrets are reptiles, which he grasps and puts in his -bosom, but which he cannot hold tight, and so is devoured by them. -Garfish and vipers—so we are told—burst in giving birth to their young. -So the escape of a secret is ruin and destruction to him who lets it -out. - -Seleucus the Victorious, having lost all his army and resources in his -fight with the Gauls, tore off his royal circlet with his own hands, and -fled away on horseback with three or four attendants. After a long and -circuitous ride away from the highroads, he was at last so overcome by -want that he approached a homestead, and being fortunate enough to find -the owner in [Sidenote: E] person, asked him for bread and water. The -man not only gave him these, but supplied him liberally and in the most -friendly way with whatever else he had upon his farm. In doing so he -recognized the king’s face. So overjoyed was he at his fortunate -opportunity of rendering him service, that, instead of restraining -himself and playing up to the king’s desire to be unknown, he -accompanied him as far as the road, and, on taking his leave, said, -‘Good-bye, King Seleucus.’ At this the king, holding out his right hand -and drawing the man towards him as if to kiss him, gave a sign to one of -the attendants to cut off his head with a sword; - - _And so, with the word on his lips, his head in the dust lay - mingled_,— - -whereas, if he had then had the patience to hold his tongue [Sidenote: -F] for a little while, he would in all probability, when the king -subsequently won success and power, have earned a larger return for his -silence than for his hospitality. - -In this case, it is true, the man’s hopes and kindly feeling formed some -excuse for his lack of self-command. Most babblers, however, have no -excuse at all for their own undoing. For example, people were once -talking in a barber’s shop about the despotism of Dionysius, and saying -how firmly established it was against all assault. At this the barber -remarked laughingly, ‘How can you say that, when every few days I have -my [Sidenote: 509] razor at his throat?’ No sooner did Dionysius hear of -this speech than he impaled the barber. - -Barbers, by the way, are generally a garrulous crew. Their chairs being -the resort of the greatest chatterers, they catch the bad habit -themselves. It was a neat quip that Archelaus once gave to a loquacious -barber. After putting the towel round him, the man asked, ‘How shall I -cut your hair, Sire?’ ‘In silence,’ he replied. It was a barber also who -reported the great disaster of the Athenians in Sicily, he having been -the first to hear it at the Peiraeus from a slave, who had run away -[Sidenote: B] from the spot. Abandoning his shop, he hurried at full -speed to town, - - _Lest another the glory might win_ - -by imparting the news to the capital, - - _while he might come but the second_. - -A panic naturally ensued, and the people were gathered to an assembly, -where they set to work to trace the rumour to its source. When, however, -the barber was brought forward and questioned, he did not even know the -name of his informant, but could only give as his authority a person -unnamed and unknown. Thereupon the audience shouted in anger: ‘To the -rack and the wheel with the wretch! The thing is a pure concoction! Who -else has heard it? Who believes it?’ The wheel [Sidenote: C] had been -brought, and the man had been stretched upon it, when there appeared -upon the scene the bearers of the disastrous news, who had escaped from -the very midst of the action. At this they all dispersed, to occupy -themselves with their private griefs, leaving the poor wretch bound upon -the wheel. When at a late hour towards evening he was set free, he -proceeded to ask the executioner ‘whether they had also heard in what -manner Nicias, the commander, had met his death’. Such a hopeless and -incorrigible failing does garrulity become through force of habit. - -After drinking a bitter and evil-smelling medicine, we are disgusted -with the cup as well. In the same way, if you are the bearer of bad -news, you are regarded with disgust and hatred by those who hear it. -Hence a pretty discussion in Sophocles: [Sidenote: D] - - A. _Is it in ear or heart that thou art stung?_ - - B. _Why seek thus to define where lies my pain?_ - - A. _’Tis the doer grieves thine heart, I but thine ears._ - -Be that as it may, a speaker causes pain as well as a doer. Nevertheless -there is no stopping or chastening a loose, glib tongue. - -On one occasion it was discovered that the temple of Athena ‘Of the -Bronze House’ at Sparta had been pillaged, and an empty flask was found -lying inside. The crowd which had run together could make nothing of it, -when one of their number said, ‘If you like, I will tell you my notion -as to the flask. I fancy the robbers, realizing all the danger they were -to run, first drank hemlock, and then brought wine with them. If they -managed to escape detection, they were to neutralize [Sidenote: E] the -effects of the poison by drinking the unmixed wine, and so get away in -safety. If they were caught, they were to die an easy and painless death -from the poison, before they could be put to torture.’ The theory was so -ingenious and acute that it appeared to come of knowledge rather than -conjecture. He was therefore surrounded and questioned on every -side—‘Who are [Sidenote: F] you? Who knows you? How do you get to know -all that?‘—till finally, under this searching examination, he confessed -that he was one of the thieves. - -Were not the murderers of Ibycus found out in the same way? As they were -sitting in the theatre, a number of cranes happened to come in sight, -and they whispered laughingly to one another, ‘Here are the avengers of -Ibycus!’ They were overheard by persons sitting near them, and as a -search was being made for Ibycus, who had been missing for a -considerable time, the words were seized upon and reported to the -magistrates. By this means the matter was brought home, and the -assassins carried off to prison, where their punishment was due, not to -the cranes, but to their own garrulity, which played the part [Sidenote: -510] of an Erinys or Spirit of Vengeance in compelling them to divulge -the murder. For as in the body, when a part is diseased or in pain, the -neighbouring matter gathers towards it by attraction; so is it with the -babbler’s tongue. Perpetually throbbing and inflamed, it must keep -drawing towards itself some secret or other which ought to be concealed. - -We must therefore make ourselves secure. Let Reason lie like a barrier -in the way of the tongue, to restrain its flow or prevent its slipping. -And let us show that we possess no less [Sidenote: B] sense than certain -geese of which we are told. It is said that, when they cross from -Cilicia over the Taurus Range—which is full of eagles—they clap a bolt -or bit upon their utterance. That is to say, they take in their mouths a -good-sized stone, and so fly over at night without being discovered. - -Now if it were asked - - _Who it is that is the vilest, who most unredeemed of men_, - -it is the traitor who would always be named before any one else. Well, -Euthycrates (as Demosthenes puts it) ‘_roofed his house with the timber -got from Macedon_‘. Philocrates received a large sum of gold and -proceeded to buy ‘_strumpets and fish_‘. Euphorbus and Philagrus, who -betrayed Eretria, received lands [Sidenote: C] from the Persian king. -But the babbler is a traitor who volunteers his services without pay, -not in the way of betraying horses or fortresses, but of divulging -secrets connected with lawsuits, party feuds, or political manœuvres. -Instead of any one thanking him, he actually has to thank people for -listening to him. The line addressed to a man who was recklessly -squandering his money by giving indiscriminate presents— - - _Not generous, you: ’tis your disease; you love to be a-giving_— - -fits the prater also. ‘You do not give this information out of -friendliness and goodwill. ’Tis your disease; you love to be a-talking -and a-babbling.’ - -These remarks are not to be regarded as simply an indictment of -garrulity. They are an attempt to cure it. An ailment is [Sidenote: D] -overcome by diagnosis and treatment, but diagnosis comes first. No one -can be trained to avoid or to rid his mental constitution of a thing -which causes him no distress. That distress we learn to feel at our -disorders, when reason leads us to perceive the injury and shame which -result from them. Thus in the present instance we perceive that the -babbler is hated where he desires to be liked, annoys where he wishes to -ingratiate himself, is derided where he thinks he is admired, and spends -without gaining anything by it. He wrongs his friends, assists his -[Sidenote: E] enemies, and ruins himself. The first step, therefore, in -physicing this disorder, is to reflect upon the disgrace and pain which -it causes. The second is to consider the advantages of the contrary -behaviour, constantly hearing, remembering, and keeping at our call the -praises of reticence, the solemn and sacramental associations of -silence, and the fact that it is not by your unbridled talker at large -that admiration, regard, and reputation for wisdom are won, but by the -man of short and pithy speech, who can pack much sense into few words. - -We find Plato commending such persons, and saying that, in [Sidenote: F] -their deliverance of crisp, terse, and compact utterances, they resemble -a skilful javelineer. Lycurgus, again, forced his fellow-citizens to -acquire this gift of compression and solidity by applying the pressure -of silence from their earliest childhood. - -The Celtiberians produce steel from iron by first burying it in the -ground and then clearing away the earthy surplusage. So is it with -Lacedaemonian speech. It has no surplusage, but is steadily hardened -down to absolute effectiveness by the removal of everything unessential. -And this knack of theirs of saying a pithy thing, or making a keen and -nimble retort, is the result of a great habit of silence. - -[Sidenote: 511] We must not omit to give our chatterer examples of such -brevities, in order to show how pretty and effective they are. For -instance: - - _The Lacedaemonians to Philip_: _Dionysius at Corinth_; - -and, again, when Philip wrote to them ‘_If I enter Laconia, I will turn -you out_‘, they wrote back, ‘_If._’ When King Demetrius shouted in his -indignation, ‘Have the Lacedaemonians sent only one envoy to _me_?‘, the -envoy replied undismayed, ‘One to one.’ Among our ancient worthies also -we admire [Sidenote: B] the men of few words. It was not the _Iliad_ or -the _Odyssey_ or the paeans of Pindar that the Amphictyons inscribed -upon the temple of the Pythian Apollo, but the maxims _Know Thyself_: -_Nothing in Excess_: _Give pledge, and Mischief is nigh_, which they -admired for their simple and compact expression, with its -closely-hammered thought in small compass. And does not the god himself -show a love of conciseness and brevity in his oracles, deriving his name -of ‘Loxias’ from the fact that he would rather be obscure than -garrulous? - -Do we not also particularly praise and admire those who can say, by -means of a symbol and without speaking a word, all that [Sidenote: C] is -necessary? For instance, when his fellow-citizens insisted upon -Heracleitus proposing some measure for the promotion of concord, he -mounted the platform, took a cup of cold water, sprinkled it with -barley-meal, stirred it with a slip of pennyroyal, drank it off, and -went home. This was his way of intimating that to be satisfied with the -commonest things, and to have no expensive wants, is the way to maintain -a community in peace and concord. Another case is that of Scilurus, the -Scythian king, who left behind him eighty sons. When he was dying, he -called for a bundle of small spears, and bade them take and break it in -pieces, tied together as it was, and in the mass. When they gave up the -task, he himself drew the spears out one by one and snapped them all -with ease, thereby demonstrating [Sidenote: D] how invincible was their -strength if harmoniously united, how weak and short-lived if they did -not hold together. - -Any one, I believe, who constantly recalls these and the like examples, -will cease to take a pleasure in chattering. But—speaking for -myself—there is a story of a certain slave which greatly discourages me, -when I reflect how hard it is to be so careful of our words as to make -sure of our purpose. The orator Pupius Piso, not wishing to be troubled, -ordered his slaves to talk only in answer to questions, and not a word -more. Subsequently, being anxious to welcome Clodius in his official -position, he gave orders for him to be invited to dinner, and prepared -what was, of course, a splendid banquet. When the hour arrived, the -other guests were all present and waiting for [Sidenote: E] Clodius. The -slave who regularly carried the invitations was repeatedly sent out to -see whether he was on his way. When evening came and he was given up in -despair, Piso said to the slave, ‘Of course you took him the -invitation?’ ‘I did,’ he answered. ‘Then why has he not appeared?’ -‘Because he refused.’ ‘Then why did you not tell me so at once?’ -‘Because you did not ask me that question.’ - -So much for the slave at Rome, whereas at Athens he will tell his master -while digging - - _What terms are named i’ the treaty_, - -so great in all things is the force of habituation. To habituation let -us now turn. - -[Sidenote: F] We cannot check the babbler by taking, as it were, a grip -on the reins. The malady can only be overcome by habit. - -In the first place, therefore, when questions are asked of your -neighbours, train yourself to keep silent until they have all failed to -answer. - - _Counsel hath other ends than running hath_, - -says Sophocles, and so has speech or answer. In running, the victor is -the man who comes in first, but here the case is different. If another -makes a satisfactory reply, the proper course is to lend approval and a -word of support, and so win credit for good [Sidenote: 512] feeling. If -he fails, there is nothing invidious or inopportune in giving the -information which he does not possess, or in supplementing his -deficiencies. But above all things let us be on our guard, when a -question is put to another person, that we do not anticipate him and -take the answer out of his mouth. In any case in which a request is made -of another it is, of course, improper for us to push him aside and offer -our own services. By doing so we shall appear to be casting a slur on -both parties; as if the one were incapable of performing what is asked, -and as if the other did not know the right quarter from which to get -what he asks for. But it is especially in connexion with answers to -questions that such impudent forwardness is an outrage on [Sidenote: B] -manners. To give the answer before the person questioned has time, -implies the remark, ‘What do you want _him_ for?‘, or ‘What does _he_ -know?‘, or, ‘When _I_ am present, nobody else should be asked that -question.’ - -Yet we often put a question to a person, not because we need the -information, but by way of eliciting from him a few words of a friendly -nature, or from a wish to lead him on to converse, as Socrates did with -Theaetetus and Charmides. To take the answer out of another’s mouth, to -divert attention to yourself and wrest it from another, is as bad as if, -when a person desired to be kissed by some one else, you ran forward and -kissed him yourself, or as if, when he was looking at another, you -twisted him round in your own direction. The right and proper [Sidenote: -C] course, even if the person who is asked for information cannot give -it, is to wait, to take your cue to answer from the wish of the -questioner—his invitation not having been addressed to you—and then to -meet the situation in a modest and mannerly way. If a person of whom a -question is asked makes a mistake in answering it, he meets with a due -measure of indulgence; but one who pushes himself forward and insists on -answering first, receives no welcome if he is right, while, if he is -wrong, he becomes an object of positive exultation and derision. - -The second item of our regimen concerns the answering of questions put -to ourselves. Our garrulous friend must be particularly careful with -these. In the first place he must not be deceived into giving serious -replies to those who merely provoke him into a discussion in order to -make a laughing-stock of him. [Sidenote: D] Sometimes persons who -require no information simply concoct a question for the amusement and -fun of the thing, and submit it to a character of this kind in order to -set his foolish tongue wagging. Against this trick he must be on his -guard. Instead of promptly jumping at the subject as if he were -grateful, he should consider both the character of the questioner and -the necessity for the question. And when it is clear that information is -really desired, he must make a habit of waiting and leaving some -interval between question and answer. There will then be time for the -inquirer to add anything he wishes, and for himself to reflect upon his -reply, instead of overrunning and muddling the question, hurriedly -giving [Sidenote: E] first one answer and then another while the -question is still going on. - -The Pythian priestess, of course, is accustomed to deliver oracles on -the instant, even before the question is asked, inasmuch as the God whom -she serves - - _Understandeth the dumb, and heareth a man though he speak not._ - -But if you wish your answer to be to the purpose, you must wait for the -questioner’s thought to be expressed, and discover [Sidenote: F] -precisely what he is aiming at. Otherwise it will be a case of the old -saying: - - _Asked for a bucket, they refused a tub._ - -In any case that ravenous greed to be talking must be checked. Otherwise -it will seem as if a stream, which has long been banked up at the -tongue, is taking joyful advantage of the question to disgorge itself. -Socrates used to control his thirst on the same principle. He would not -permit himself to drink after exercise without pouring away the first -jugful drawn from the well, thereby training his irrational part to wait -until reason named the time. - -[Sidenote: 513] There are three possible kinds of answer to a -question—the barely necessary, the polite, and the superfluous. For -instance, to the inquiry, ‘Is Socrates at home?‘, one person may reply, -in an offhand and apparently grudging way, ‘Not at home;’ or, if he is -disposed to adopt the Laconian style, he will omit the ‘at home’ and -merely utter the negative. Thus the Lacedaemonians, when Philip had -written to ask, ‘Do you [Sidenote: *] receive me into your city?‘, wrote -a large _No_ on a piece of paper and sent it back. Another, with more -politeness, answers, ‘No, but you will find him at the bankers’ -tables’—going so far, perhaps, as to add, ‘waiting for some strangers.’ -But, [Sidenote: B] third, our inordinate chatterbox—at any rate, if he -happens also to have read Antimachus of Colophon—will say, ‘No; but you -will find him at the bankers’ tables, waiting for some strangers from -Ionia, concerning whom he has had a letter from Alcibiades, who is near -Miletus, staying with Tissaphernes, the Great King’s Satrap, the same -who used formerly to help the Lacedaemonians, but who is now attaching -himself to the Athenians, thanks to Alcibiades; for Alcibiades is -anxious to be recalled from exile, and is therefore working upon -Tissaphernes to change sides.’ In fact he will talk the whole eighth -book of Thucydides and will deluge the questioner with it, until, before -he has done, there is war with Miletus and Alcibiades has been exiled -for [Sidenote: C] the second time. - -Here especially should loquacity be repressed. It should be forced to -follow in the footsteps of the question, and to confine the answer -within the circle of which the questioner’s requirement gives the centre -and radius. When Carneades, before he became famous, was once -discoursing in the gymnasium, the superintendent sent and requested him -to lower his voice, which was a very loud one. Upon his replying ‘Give -me my limit for reach of voice’, the officer aptly rejoined ‘The person -who is speaking with you’. So, in making an answer, let the limit -[Sidenote: D] be the wishes of the questioner. - -In the next place remember how Socrates used to urge the avoidance of -those foods and drinks which induce you to eat when you are not hungry -and to drink when you are not thirsty. So those subjects in which he -most delights, and in which he indulges most immoderately, are the -subjects which the babbler should shun, and whose advances he should -resist. For example, military men are given to prosing about wars. Homer -introduces Nestor in that character, making him relate his own deeds of -prowess time after time. Take, again, those who have scored a victory in -the law-courts, or who have met with surprising success at the courts of -governors or kings. Generally [Sidenote: E] speaking, they are chronic -sufferers from an itch to talk about it, and to describe over and over -again how they came in, how they were introduced, how they played their -parts, how they talked, how they confuted some opponent or accuser, and -what eulogies they won. Their delight is more loquacious than that -‘sleepless night’ in the comedy, and is perpetually fanning itself into -new flame and keeping itself fresh by telling over the tale. They are -therefore prone to slip into such subjects at every pretext. For not -only - - _Where the pain is, there also goes the hand_; - -[Sidenote: F] no less does the part which feels pleasure draw the voice -and twist the tongue in its own direction, from a desire to dwell -perpetually on the theme. It is the same also with amorous persons, who -chiefly occupy themselves with such conversation as brings up some -mention of the object of their passion. If they cannot talk to human -beings about it, they do so to inanimate things: - - _O bed most dear!_ - -or - - _Bacchis thought thee a god, thou blessed lamp; - And greatest god thou art, methinks, through her._ - -No doubt it makes not a pin’s difference to the chatterer [Sidenote: -514] what subject of conversation may arise. Nevertheless, if he has a -greater predilection for one class of subjects than for another, he -ought to be on his guard against that class and force himself to hold -aloof from it, since those are the subjects which can always tempt him -furthest into prolixity for the pleasure of the thing. It is the same -with those matters in which the talker thinks that his experience or -ability gives him a superiority over other people. Through egotism and -vanity such a person - - _Giveth the most part of the day to that - Wherein he showeth to the most advantage._ - -With the much-read man it is general information; with the [Sidenote: B] -expert in letters, the rules of literary art; with the much-travelled -man, accounts of foreign parts. These subjects also must therefore be -shunned. They are an enticement to loquacity, which is led on to them -like an animal towards its wonted fodder. One admirable feature in the -conduct of Cyrus was that, in his matches with his mates, he challenged -them to compete at something in which he was not more, but less, expert -than they. Thus, while he caused no pain by eclipsing them, he also -derived advantage from a lesson. With the chatterer it is the other way -about. If any subject is mooted which gives him the opportunity of -asking and learning something he does not know, he cannot even pay so -small a fee [Sidenote: C] for it as merely holding his tongue, but he -blocks the topic and elbows it aside, working steadily round till he -drives the conversation into the well-worn track of stale old twaddle. - -We have had an example of this among ourselves, where a person who -happened to have read two or three books of Ephorus used to weary every -one to death, and put any convivial party to rout, by everlastingly -describing the battle of Leuctra and its sequel, until he earned the -nickname of ‘Epaminondas’. If, however, we are to choose between evils, -this is the least, and we must divert loquacity into this channel. -Talkativeness will be [Sidenote: D] less disagreeable when its excess is -in an expert connexion. - -In the next place such persons should habituate themselves to putting -things in a written or conversational form when alone. The case is not -as with Antipater the Stoic. He gained his sobriquet of ‘Pen-Valiant’ -because, being—as it would appear—unable and unwilling to come out and -meet the vehement attacks made by Carneades upon the Porch, he kept -filling his books with written disputations against him. But if the -babbler turns to writing and valiantly fights shadows with his pen, the -occupation will keep him from attacking people at large and will render -him daily more bearable to his company. It will be as with dogs. Let -them vent their anger on sticks and stones, and they are less ferocious -to human beings. [Sidenote: E] - -Another extremely beneficial course for talkers to adopt is to associate -continually with their superiors and elders, out of respect for whose -standing they will develop a habit of holding their tongues. - -As part and parcel of this training we should always vigilantly apply -the following reflection, when we are on the point of talking and the -words begin running to our mouths: ‘What _is_ this remark that is so -pressing and importunate? With what object is my tongue so impatient? -What honour do I get by speaking, or what harm by keeping quiet?’ If the -thought were an oppressive weight to be got rid of, the matter would be -[Sidenote: F] different; but it remains with you just as much, even if -it is spoken. When men talk, it is either for their own sake, because -they want something, or it is to help the hearer; or else they seek to -ingratiate themselves with each other by seasoning with the salt of -rational conversation the pastime or business in which they happen to be -engaged. But if a remark is neither of advantage to the speaker nor of -importance to the hearer, if it contains nothing pleasant or -interesting, why is it made? The [Sidenote: *] meaningless and futile is -as much to be avoided in words as it is in deeds. - -Over and above all this, we should keep in lively recollection -[Sidenote: 515] the saying of Simonides that he ‘had often repented of -talking, but never of holding his tongue’. We should remember also that -practice is a potent thing and overcomes all difficulties. People get -rid even of the hiccoughs or a cough by resolutely resisting them. Yet -this involves trouble and pain, whereas silence not only, as Hippocrates -says, ‘prevents thirst;’ it also prevents pain and suffering. - -Footnote 43: - - The Homeric σιγαλόεντα (‘glossy’) is brought, either in error or by a - deliberate pun, into relation with σιγή (‘silence’). - - - - - ON THE STUDENT AT LECTURES - - -MY DEAR NICANDER, [Sidenote: 37 C] - -This is an article upon ‘The Attitude of the Student’, which I have -written and am sending to you. Its purpose is to teach you the right -attitude towards your philosophic teacher, now that you are a grown-up -man and are no longer obliged merely to obey orders. - -Some young men are so ill-informed as to suppose that absence of -restraint is the same thing as freedom, whereas, by unchaining -[Sidenote: D] the passions, it makes them slaves to a set of masters -more tyrannical than all the teachers and mentors of childhood. -Herodotus says that when women take off the tunic they also take off -shame. It is the same with some young men. In laying aside the garb of -childhood they also lay aside shame and fear. No sooner do they unloose -the cloak which controlled their conduct than they indulge in the utmost -misbehaviour. With you it should be otherwise. You have been told over -and over again that to ‘follow God’ and to ‘obey reason’ are the same -thing. Understand, therefore, that with right-minded persons a coming of -age does not mean rejection of rule, but change of ruler. For the hired -or purchased[44] director of conduct they [Sidenote: E] substitute one -that is divine—namely, reason. Only those who follow reason deserve to -be considered free; for they alone live as they choose, because they -alone have learned to make the right choice, whereas ignorant and -irrational desires and actions give small and paltry scope to the will, -but great scope to repentance. - -Note what happens in the case of naturalized citizens. Entire [Sidenote: -F] foreigners from another country will often grumble irritably at their -experiences, whereas those who have previously been denizens of the -state, and have therefore lived in intimate touch with the laws, will -accept their obligations with cheerful readiness. So with yourself. For -a long time you have been growing up in the company of philosophy. From -the first you have been accustomed to a taste of philosophic reason in -everything that you have been taught or told as a child. It should -therefore be in a well-disposed and congenial spirit that you come to -Philosophy, who alone can adorn a youth with that finish of manhood -which genuinely and rationally deserves the name. - -You will not, I believe, object to a prefatory remark upon [Sidenote: -38] the sense of hearing. Theophrastus asserts that it is the most -susceptible of all the senses, inasmuch as nothing that can be seen, -tasted, or touched, is the cause of such strong emotional disturbance -and excitement as takes hold upon the mind when certain sounds of -beating, clashing, or ringing fall upon the ear. It is, however, more -rational, rather than more emotional, than the other senses. Vice can -find many places and parts of the body open for it to enter and seize -upon the soul. But the only hold that virtue can take is upon pure young -ears [Sidenote: B] which have at all times been protected from the -corruptions of flattery or the touch of low communications. Hence the -advice of Xenocrates, that ear-guards should be worn by boys more than -by athletes, inasmuch as the latter merely have their ears disfigured by -blows, while the former have their characters disfigured by words. Not -that he would wed us to inattention or deafness. It is but a warning to -beware of wrong communications, and to see that others of the right -nature have first been fostered in our character by philosophy and have -mounted guard in that quarter which is most open to influence and -persuasion. - -Bias, the ancient sage, was once bidden by Amasis to send him that piece -of meat from a sacrificial victim which was at the same time the best -and the worst. He replied by taking out and sending the tongue, on the -ground that speech can do both the greatest harm and the greatest good. -It is a general practice in fondling little children to take them by the -ears, and to bid [Sidenote: C] them do the same to us—an indirect and -playful way of suggesting that we should be especially fond of those who -make our ears the instruments to our advantage. - -It is, of course, obvious that a youth cannot be debarred from any or -every kind of hearing, or from tasting any discourse at all. Otherwise -not only will he remain entirely without fruit or growth in the way of -virtue; he will actually be perverted in the direction of vice, his mind -being an idle and uncultivated patch producing a plentiful crop of -weeds. Propensity to pleasure and dislike of labour—the springs of -innumerable forms of trouble and disease—are not of external origin, nor -imported [Sidenote: D] from teaching, but they well up naturally from -the soil. If therefore they are left free to take their natural course; -if they are not done away with, or turned aside, by sound instruction; -if nature is not thus brought under control, man will prove more -unreclaimed than any brute beast. - -The hearing of lectures, then, may be of great profit, but at the same -time of great danger, to a young man. This being so, I believe it a good -thing to make the matter one of constant discussion, both with oneself -and with others. In most cases [Sidenote: E] we may notice a false -procedure—that of cultivating the art of speaking before being trained -to the art of listening. It is thought that, while speaking requires -instruction and practice, any kind of listening is attended with profit. -But not so. Whereas in ball-play one learns simultaneously how to throw -and how to catch, in the business of speech the right taking in is prior -to the giving out, just as conception is prior to parturition. We are -told that in the case of a hen laying a wind-egg her labour and travail -end in nothing but an abortive and lifeless piece of refuse. So when a -young man lacks the ability to listen, [Sidenote: F] or the training to -gather profit through the ear, the speech which he lets fall is -wind-begotten indeed: - - _Sans all regard and sans note it is lost in the clouds and - dispersèd._ - -He will take a vessel and tilt it in the right direction for receiving -anything to be poured into it, and so ensure a real ‘in-pouring’ instead -of a pouring to waste. But he does not learn to lend his own attention -to a speaker and meet the lecture half-way, so as to miss no valuable -point. On the contrary, his behaviour is in the last degree ridiculous. -If he happens upon a person [Sidenote: 39] describing a dinner, a -procession, a dream, or a brawling-match in which he has been engaged, -he listens in silence and is eager for more. But if a teacher to whom he -has attached himself tries to impart something useful, or to urge him to -some duty, to admonish him when wrong, or to soothe him when angry, he -is out of all patience. If possible, he shows fight, and is ambitious to -get the best of the argument. Otherwise he is off and away to discourses -of a different and a rubbishy kind, filling his ears—the poor leaky -vessels—with anything rather than the thing they need. - -[Sidenote: B] From the right kind of breeder a horse obtains a good -mouth for the bit, and a lad a good ear for reason. He is taught to do -much listening, but to avoid much speaking. We may quote the remark of -Spintharus in praise of Epaminondas, that he had scarcely ever met with -any man either of greater judgement or of fewer words. Moreover, we are -told, the reason why nature gave each of us two ears, but only one -tongue, was that we should do less speaking than hearing. - -A youth is at all times sure to find silence a credit to him; but in one -case it is especially so—when he can listen to another without becoming -excited and continually yelping; when, even [Sidenote: C] if what is -being said is little to his liking, he waits patiently for the speaker -to finish; when, at the close, he does not immediately come to the -attack with his contradiction, but (to quote Aeschines) waits a while, -in case the speaker might wish to supplement his remarks, or perhaps to -adjust or qualify his position. To take instant objection, neither party -listening to the other but both talking at once, is an unseemly -performance. On the other hand, those who have been trained to listen -with modest self-control will accept a valuable argument and make it -their own, while they will be in a better position to see through a -worthless or false one and to expose it, thereby [Sidenote: D] showing -that they are lovers of truth, and not merely contentious, headstrong, -or quarrelsome persons. It is therefore not a bad remark of some, that -there is more need to expel the wind of vanity and self-conceit from the -young, than to expel the air from a skin, when you wish to pour in -anything of value: otherwise they are too swollen and flatulent to -receive it. - -The presence of envious and malicious jealousy is, of course, never to -good purpose, but always an impediment to proper action. In the case of -a student at lectures it is the most perverse of prompters. Words which -ought to do him good are rendered vexing, distasteful, and unwelcome by -the fact that there is nothing which an envious man likes so little as -an [Sidenote: E] excellent piece of reasoning. And note that, when a man -is piqued by fame or beauty belonging to others, he is envious and -nothing more; what annoys him is another’s good fortune. But when he is -irritated by admirable argument, his vexation is at his own good, since -reason—if he has a mind to accept it—is as much to the good of one who -hears as light is to the good of one who sees. - -Envy in other matters is the result of various coarse or low attitudes -of mind; envy of a speaker is born of inordinate love of glory and -unfair ambition. A person so disposed is prevented [Sidenote: F] from -listening to reason. His mind is perturbed and distracted. At one and -the same time it is looking at its own endowments, to see if they are -inferior to those of the speaker, and at the rest of the company, to see -if they are wondering and admiring. It is disgusted at their applause, -and exasperated at their approval. The previous portions of the speech -it forgets and ignores, because the recollection is irksome. The parts -yet to come it awaits with trembling anxiety, for fear they may prove -better still. When the speaker is at his best, it is most [Sidenote: 40] -eager for him to stop. When the lecture is over, it thinks of nothing -that was said, but takes count of the expressions and attitudes of the -audience. From those who give praise it dances away in a frenzy; and to -those who carp and distort it runs to form one of the herd. If there is -nothing to distort, it makes comparisons with others who have spoken -‘better and more eloquently to the same purpose’. In the end our friend -has so cruelly mishandled the lecture that he has made it of no use or -profit to himself. - -[Sidenote: B] Let the love of glory, then, be brought to terms with the -love of learning. Let us listen to a speaker with friendly courtesy, -regarding ourselves as guests at a sacred banquet or sacrificial -offering. Let us praise his ability when he makes a hit, or be satisfied -with the mere goodwill of a man who is making the public a present of -his views and endeavouring to convince others by means of the arguments -which have convinced himself. When he goes right, let us consider that -his rightness is due not to chance or accident, but to painstaking -effort and learning. Let us take a pattern by it, and not only admire -it, but emulate it. When he is at fault, let us stop and think for what -reasons he is so, and at what point he began to go astray. [Sidenote: C] -Xenophon observes that good managers derive profit from their enemies as -well as from their friends. In the same way those who are attentive and -alert derive benefit from a speaker not only when he is in the right, -but also when he is in the wrong. Paltry thought, empty phrase, affected -bearing, vulgar delight and excitement at applause, and the like, are -more palpable to a listener in another’s case than to a speaker in his -own. It is well, therefore, to take the criticism which we apply to him, -and apply it to ourselves, asking whether we commit any mistake of the -kind without being aware of it. It is the easiest thing in [Sidenote: D] -the world to find fault with our neighbour, but it is a futile and -meaningless proceeding, unless made to bear in some way upon the -correction or prevention of similar faults. When lapses are committed, -let us always be prompt to exclaim to ourselves in the phrase of Plato, -‘Am I, perhaps, as bad?’ As in the eyes of our neighbour we see the -reflection of our own, so we should find a picture of our own speech in -that of another. In that way we shall avoid treating others with -over-confident contempt, and shall also look more carefully to our own -deliverances. - -There is another way in which comparison serves this useful [Sidenote: -E] purpose. I mean if, when we get by ourselves after the lecture, we -take some point which appears to have been wrongly or unsatisfactorily -treated, and attack the same theme, doing our best to fill in, to -correct, to re-word, or to attempt an entirely original contribution to -the subject, as the case may be—doing, in fact, as Plato did[45] with -the speech of Lysias. While to argue against a certain deliverance is -not difficult, but, on the contrary, very easy, to set up a better in -its stead is an extremely hard matter. As the Lacedaemonian said on -hearing that Philip had razed Olynthus to the ground: ‘Yes, but to -create a city as good is beyond the man’s power’. Accordingly, -[Sidenote: F] when we find that in dealing with the same subject we can -do but little better than the speaker in the case, we make a large -reduction in our contempt and speedily prune down that self-satisfied -conceit which has been exposed during such process of comparison. - -Nevertheless, though admiration, as opposed to contempt, certainly -betokens a fairer and gentler nature, it is a thing which, in its own -turn, requires no little—perhaps greater—caution. [Sidenote: 41] For -while a contemptuous and over-confident person derives too little -benefit from a speaker, an enthusiastic and guileless admirer derives -too much injury. He forms no exception to the rule of Heracleitus that -‘_Any dictum will flutter a fool_‘. One should be frank in yielding -praise to the speaker, but cautious in yielding belief to the assertion; -a kindly and candid observer of the diction and delivery of the arguer, -but a sharp and exacting critic of the truth and value of his argument. -[Sidenote: B] While we thus escape dislike from the speaker, we escape -harm from the speech. How many false and pernicious doctrines we -unawares accept through esteeming and trusting their exponent! The -Lacedaemonian authorities, after examining a measure suggested by a man -of evil life, instructed another person, famous for his conduct and -character, to move it—a very proper and statesmanlike encouragement to -the people to be led more by the character of an adviser than by his -speech. But in philosophy we must put aside the reputation of the -speaker and examine the speech in and by itself. In lecturing, as in -war, there is much that is mere show. The speaker’s grey hairs, his -vocal [Sidenote: C] affectations, his supercilious airs, his -self-glorification; above all, the shouting, applauding, and dancing of -the audience overwhelm the young and inexperienced student and sweep him -along with the current. There is deception in the language also, when it -streams upon the question in a delightful flood, and when it contains a -measure of studied art and the grandiose. As, in singing to the -accompaniment of the flageolet, mistakes are generally undetected by an -audience, so an elaborate and pretentious diction dazzles the hearer and -blinds him to the sense. I believe it was Melanthius who, when asked -about [Sidenote: D] Diogenes’ tragedy, replied: ‘I could not get a sight -of it; it was hidden behind the words.’ But with the discourses and -declamations of the majority of our professors it is not merely a case -of using the words to screen the thoughts. They also dulcify the -voice—modulating, smoothing, and intoning—till the hearer is carried -away with a perfect intoxication. They give an empty pleasure, and are -paid with an emptier fame. Their case, in fact, is one for the quip -given by Dionysius. It was he, I think, who, during the performance of a -distinguished harp-player, promised him a liberal reward, but -subsequently gave [Sidenote: E] him nothing, on the ground that he had -made a sufficient return. ‘For as long a time as I was enjoying your -singing’, said he, ‘you were enjoying your expectations.’ The deliverer -of the lectures in question finds that they represent a joint -contribution of the same kind. He receives admiration as long as his -entertainment lasts. As soon as no more pleasure is forthcoming for the -ear, there is no more glory left for him. The one party has wasted his -time, the other his professional life. - -Let us, then, strip aside all this empty show of language, and make for -the actual fruit. It is better to imitate the bee than [Sidenote: F] the -garland-maker. The latter looks for the bright-coloured fragrant petals, -and, by twining and plaiting them together, produces an object which is -pleasant enough, but short-lived and fruitless. Bees, on the contrary, -frequently skim through meadows of violets, roses, or hyacinths, to -settle upon the coarsest and bitterest thyme. To this they devote -themselves - - _Contriving yellow honey_, - -and then fly home to their proper business with something worth the -getting. So a student who takes his work in real earnest will pay no -regard to dainty flowery words nor to showy [Sidenote: 42] theatrical -matter. These he will consider as fodder for drones who play the -sophist. For his own part he will probe with keen attention into the -sense of a speech and the quality of the speaker. Therefrom he will suck -such part as will be of service and profit. He will remember that he has -not come to a theatre or concert-hall, but to a classroom in the -schools, and that his object is to get his life corrected by means of -reason. Hence he should form a critical judgement of the lecture from -his own case, that is to say, from a calculation of its effect upon -himself. Has it been the chastening of a passion, the lightening -[Sidenote: B] of a grief? Has it been courage, firmness of spirit, -enthusiasm for excellence and virtue? Upon rising from the barber’s -chair he will stand at the glass and put his hands to his head, -inspecting the trim and arrangement of the hair. No less should he, -immediately on leaving a lecture in the philosophic school, look at -himself and examine his own mind, to see if it has got rid of any -useless and uncomfortable growth and become lighter and more at ease. -‘There is no use’, says Aristo, ‘in either a bath or a speech, unless it -cleanses.’ - -[Sidenote: C] By all means let a young man, while profiting from a -discourse, find pleasure in the process. But he must not treat the -pleasure of the lecture as its end, nor expect to come out of the -philosopher’s school with a beaming face and humming a tune. He must not -ask for scented unguents when what he needs is a lotion or a poultice. -On the contrary, he should be grateful if a pungent argument acts upon -his mind like smoke upon a hive, and clears out all the darkness and -mistiness that fill it. Though it is quite right for a speaker not to be -altogether without concern for an attractive and persuasive style of -language, that should be a matter least regarded by the young student, -at any rate in the first instance. Later, no doubt, the case may be -[Sidenote: D] different. It is when they are no longer thirsty that -persons engaged in drinking will turn a cup about and inspect the -chasing upon it. Similarly during a breathing-time, after taking our -fill of the lesson, we may be permitted to examine any uncommon elegance -in the language. But if from the very first, instead of taking a grip -upon the substance, you insist upon ‘good pure Attic’ expression, you -are like a person who refuses to take an antidote unless the vessel is -made of the best Attic earthenware; or who declines to put on a thick -cloak in winter unless the wool is from Attic sheep, preferring to sit, -stubborn and impracticable, in the thin napless mantle of the ‘style of -Lysias’. Perversities of this kind are responsible for a plentiful -[Sidenote: E] lack of good sense and an abundance of loquacious claptrap -in the schools. Young fellows keep no watch upon the life, the practical -action, or the public services of a philosopher, but make a great merit -of diction, phrase, and fine method of statement, while they possess -neither the ability nor the desire to find out whether the statement is -valuable or worthless, whether it is vital or a mere futility. - -The next rule concerns the propounding of difficulties. A guest at a -dinner is bound to accept what is put upon the [Sidenote: F] table, and -neither to ask for anything else nor to find fault. When the feast -consists of a discourse, any one who comes to it should listen and say -nothing, if there is an understanding to that effect. Persons who cannot -listen in a pleasant and sociable manner, but keep drawing the speaker -off to other topics, interposing questions and mooting side-issues, get -no benefit themselves and confuse both the speaker and the speech. When, -however, he invites the audience to ask questions and advance -difficulties, any that are proposed should prove to be useful and -important. Odysseus, when in the suitors’ company, incurs ridicule -through - - _Begging for morsels and scraps, and not for a sword or a cauldron._ - -[Sidenote: 43] regard it as a sign of lofty-mindedness not only to give, -but to ask for, something of value. It is, however, more a case for -ridicule when a hearer poses a speaker with petty little problems of the -kind often propounded by young men, when they are talking claptrap in -order to make a show of attainments in logic or mathematics—for example, -concerning ‘division of the indeterminate’ and the nature of ‘lateral’ -or ‘diagonal’ [Sidenote: B] motion. The proper answer to such persons is -the remark of Philotimus to a man who was suffering with abscesses and -consumption, but who had been talking to him for some time about -requiring ‘some little thing to cure a whitlow’. Perceiving the man’s -condition from his complexion and breathing, Philotimus observed: ‘My -good sir, a whitlow is not the question with you.’ Nor in your case, -young sir, is it worth while to be discussing such questions as yours, -but how you are to get rid of conceit, swaggering about love-affairs, -and such-like nonsense, and how you are to plant your feet on the way to -a healthy and sober-minded life. - -Especially are you bound, in putting your questions, to accommodate -yourself to a speaker’s range of knowledge or natural [Sidenote: C] -ability—to his special _forte_. A philosopher who is more concerned with -ethics should not be attacked with difficulties in natural science or -mathematics, nor should one who prides himself upon his scientific -knowledge be dragged into determining hypothetical syllogisms or solving -fallacies. If you attempted to chop your wood with the key and to open -your door with the axe, it would not be thought that you were making -sport of these implements, but that you were depriving yourself of their -respective powers and uses. In the same way, if you ask of a speaker a -thing for which he has no gift or training, while you make no harvest of -what he possesses and offers, [Sidenote: D] you not only do yourself -harm to that extent, but you incur condemnation for malicious -ill-nature. - -Be careful also not to propound difficulties yourself in too great -numbers or too frequently. This is, in a sense, another way of showing -off. Meanwhile, to listen equably when some one else is mooting them, -shows that you are a clubbable person and a student. This is assuming -you have no harassing and urgent trouble of your own, no mental -disturbance to be controlled or malady to be comforted. It may not, -after all, be (as Heracleitus says) ‘better to conceal ignorance’, but -to bring it into the open and cure it. If your mind is upset by a fit of -anger, an attack of superstition, a violent quarrel with your friends, -or a mad amorous passion which - - _Stirreth the heart-strings that should rest unstirred_, - -[Sidenote: E] you must not run away from a discourse which searches it -home, and fly to others of a different nature. On the contrary, these -are the very topics to which you should listen, both at lectures and -also by privately approaching the lecturer afterwards and asking for -further light. - -The opposite course is the one too generally followed. So long as the -philosopher is dealing with other persons, his hearers are all delight -and admiration. But when he leaves those others alone and frankly -administers some important reminder to themselves personally, they are -disgusted with him for not minding his own business. Generally speaking, -they think [Sidenote: F] a philosopher is entitled to a hearing inside -his school, as the tragedian is in the theatre; but in matters beyond it -they do not consider him in any way superior to themselves. Towards a -sophist their attitude is natural enough; for when he rises from his -chair, lays aside his books and his introductory manuals, and makes his -appearance in the practical departments of life, he ranks in the popular -mind as an unimportant and inferior person. But towards a philosopher in -the real sense their attitude is wrong. They do not recognize that a -tone of earnestness or jest, a sign of approval or disapproval, a smile -or a frown, [Sidenote: 44] on his part—and, above all, his direct -handling of their individual cases—are fruitful in good to those who -have learned the art of listening with submission. - -Applause, again, has its duties, which call for a certain caution and -moderation. A gentleman bestows neither too little nor too much of it. A -hearer shows churlishly bad taste when nothing whatever in a lecture -will make him thaw or unbend; when he is diseased with festering conceit -and chronic self-complacency, and is all the time thinking he could -improve upon the deliverance; when he neither makes any appropriate -movement of the brow nor utters any sound to prove that he is [Sidenote: -B] a considerate and willing listener; when he is seeking a reputation -for solidity and depth by means of silence, an affected gravity, and -attitudes of pose, under the notion that applause is like money, and -that whatever amount you give to another you take from yourself. The -fact is that there are many who take up the well-known saying of -Pythagoras and sing it to a false tune. His own gain from philosophy, he -said, was to ‘_wonder at [Sidenote: *] nothing_‘; whereas theirs is to -‘praise nothing’ or to ‘honour nothing’. With them wisdom lies in -contempt, and the way to be dignified is to be disdainful. While, by -means of knowledge [Sidenote: C] and the ascertainment of the cause in a -given case, philosophic reason does away with the wonder and awe due to -unenlightenment and ignorance, it does not destroy a generous -appreciation. Those whose excellence is genuine and firmly seated find -it the highest honour to bestow honour, the highest distinction to -bestow distinction, where honour and distinction are due. Such conduct -implies that they have fame enough and to spare, and are free from -jealousy, whereas those who are niggards of praise to others are in all -probability pinched and hungry for praise of their own. - -On the other hand, the opposite type of hearer is the fluttering -feather-head who uses no discrimination, but punctuates with loud cheers -at every word and syllable. While he is frequently obnoxious to the -disputant himself, he is invariably a nuisance [Sidenote: D] to the -hearers. He worries them on to their feet against their judgement, and -drags them willy-nilly to join in the chorus because they are ashamed to -refuse. Thanks to his applause deranging the lecture and making an -imbroglio of it, he gets no good from it, but goes home with one of -three descriptions to his credit—fleerer, sycophant, or ignoramus. - -It is true that, when hearing a case in court, we must lean [Sidenote: -E] neither towards hostility nor towards favour, but towards justice as -we best understand it. But at a lecture on a subject of learning there -is neither law nor oath to debar us from granting the speaker an -indulgent reception. The reason why the ancients placed the statue of -Hermes in the company of the Graces was that speaking has a special -claim to a gracious friendliness. It is impossible for any one to be so -complete a failure or so utterly astray as to offer us nothing deserving -of a cheer, in the shape of a thought, a reference to others, the mere -choice of theme or purpose, or, possibly, in the wording or arrangement -of the matter, - - _As among urchin-foot or mid coarse broom - The tender snowflake springeth into bloom._ - -[Sidenote: F] There are persons who, for exhibition purposes, can lend a -fair measure of plausibility to a panegyric upon vomiting or fever, or -even a pot; and surely a deliverance by a man who has some sort of claim -to be thought, or to call himself, a philosopher cannot absolutely fail -to afford a well-disposed or courteous audience some opportunity of -finding relief in applause. - -According to Plato young persons in the bloom of life can always manage -somehow to excite a lover’s passion. If they are white he calls them -‘saint-like’; if swarthy, ‘virile’. [Sidenote: 45] A hook-nose is -‘regal’, a snub nose ‘piquant’; a sallow skin is a ‘complexion of -honey’. He uses these pretty names, and is pleased and satisfied. Love -has, indeed, an ivy-like gift for clinging to any pretext. Much less -will an eager and earnest student of letters ever fail in inventiveness. -In every speaker he will discover some grounds for reasonable applause. -In the speech of Lysias, though Plato objects to its want of -arrangement, and though he has no praise for its inventiveness, he -nevertheless commends him for his manner of statement, and because there -is ‘a clear round finish in the chiselling of every word’. [Sidenote: B] -We might find fault with Archilochus for his subject-matter, Parmenides -for his versification, Phocylides for his commonplaceness, Euripides for -his garrulity, Sophocles for his inequality. Similarly one of the -orators has no characterization, another exerts no passion, a third is -lacking in grace and charm. Nevertheless each wins praise for a power to -move and sway us in his own peculiar way. - -The hearer, then, has ample scope for showing good feeling to a speaker. -In some instances it is sufficient if, without further declaration by -word of mouth, we contribute a kindly eye, a genial expression, a -friendly and agreeable mood. There are certain things for which even the -man who is a total failure may [Sidenote: C] look, and which are but -ordinary items of common etiquette for any and every audience. I mean an -upright posture in our chairs, with no lolling or lounging; eyes kept -directly upon the speaker; an air of businesslike attention; composure -of countenance, with no sign, I need not say of insolence or -peevishness, but of being taken up with other thoughts. - -If in every exacting task beauty is made up of a number of factors -happily combined in a due proportion and harmony, ugliness is the prompt -and immediate outcome of the faulty [Sidenote: D] omission or addition -of this or that one element. And in this particular matter of listening, -not only is there impropriety in a scowling brow, a disagreeable -expression, a roving glance, a twisting of the body, and a crossing of -the legs; but nodding or whispering to a neighbour, smiling, yawning -sleepily, looking at the ground, and actions of a similar nature, are -censurable and should be studiously avoided. - -There are some who think that, though the speaker has a duty, the hearer -has none. They expect the former to present himself with his thoughts -studiously prepared; yet, without a thought or care for their own -obligations, they drop casually in and take their seats, for all the -world as if they had come to a dinner to enjoy themselves while others -are doing the work. Yet even a polite table-companion has his part to -play, much [Sidenote: E] more a polite hearer. He is a partner in the -speech and a coadjutor of the speaker; and he has no right to be sharply -criticizing the mistakes, and taking every phrase and fact to task, -while himself free from responsibility for the impropriety and the -frequent solecisms which he commits as a hearer. In ball-play the -catcher has to regulate his movements according to those of the thrower. -So, in the case of a speech, there is a certain consonance of action in -which both speaker and listener are concerned, if each is to sustain his -proper part. [Sidenote: F] - -Our expressions in applauding must not, however, be used without -discrimination. It is an unpleasing phrase of Epicurus when, in speaking -of the little epistles from his friends, he says, ‘We give them a -rattling clapping.’ But what of those who nowadays introduce such -_outré_ expressions into our lecture-rooms? The _Capital!_ _Well said!_ -and _Very true!_ which were the terms of commendation used by the -hearers of Plato, Socrates, and Hypereides, are not enough for these -persons. With their exclamations _Divine!_ _An inspiration!_ or -_Unapproachable!_ they commit a gross impropriety, libellously making -out that the speaker requires far-fetched eulogies of an [Sidenote: 46] -outrageous kind. Highly obnoxious also are those who accompany their -attestations with an oath, as if they were in a court of law. And -equally so those who blunder in their descriptive terms; for instance, -when the lecturer is a philosopher and they call out, _A shrewd hit!_, -or an old man and they exclaim _Cleverly put!_ or _Brilliant!_, thus -misapplying to a philosopher the expressions used at academic exercises, -where the speaking is not serious but merely an exhibition of -adroitness. To offer [Sidenote: B] to a sober discourse such -meretricious praise is like crowning an athlete with a wreath of lilies -or roses instead of laurel or wild olive. Once when the poet Euripides -was going over a song [Sidenote: *] with an original setting for the -benefit of the members of his chorus, and one of them happened to laugh, -he observed: ‘If you had not been an ignorant dolt, you could not have -laughed while I was teaching you a mixolydian[46] piece.’ So, I take it, -a serious and practical philosopher might very well make short work of -the airs and affectations of a hearer by saying, ‘I presume your case is -one of foolishness or ill breeding; otherwise you would not have been -piping out and jigging about at my remarks, when I was teaching, or -admonishing, or arguing concerning religion, statesmanship, or the -duties of [Sidenote: C] office.’ Just frankly consider what it means, -when a philosopher is speaking, and the shouting and hurrahing inside -the building make people outside wonder whether it is a flute-player, a -harpist, or a dancer who is being applauded. - -Meanwhile, in listening to admonition and reproof, the pupil must be -neither insensible nor unmanly. There are some who bear the -philosopher’s reproaches with an easy-going indifference, laughing under -the correction and applauding the corrector, just as parasites applaud -in sheer impudence and recklessness when they are abused by those who -keep them. The shamelessness which such persons display is no proper or -genuine proof of courage. When a jibe containing no insult, and uttered -in [Sidenote: D] a playful and tactful way, is borne cheerfully and -without annoyance, it shows neither a want of spirit nor a want of -breeding. On the contrary, it is exactly what a gentleman of the true -Spartan style would do. But it is different when admonition takes in -hand the correction of character by means of a stinging remedy in the -shape of rational reproof. If a young man does not cower under the -lesson and feel his soul burning with shame, till he breaks into a sweat -and is ready to faint; if, on the contrary, he is unperturbed, gives a -broad grin of self-depreciation, and refuses to take the matter -seriously, then he is an extremely vulgar creature beyond all sense of -shame, a constant habituation to misconduct having made his soul no more -capable of a bruise than a thick callus in the flesh. - -These form the one class. Youths of the opposite disposition, [Sidenote: -E] if a single hard word is said to them, turn deserters from philosophy -and run away without a glance behind them. While nature has given them, -in the shape of modesty, an excellent start towards moral salvation, -they are so squeamish and timid that they throw their chance away. -Unable to put up with reproof or to accept correction with spirit, they -turn away to listen to the soft and agreeable utterances of some -time-server or sophist, who charms them with melodious phrases as -useless and futile as they are pleasing. If a man runs away from the -surgeon after the operation and objects to be bandaged, he is submitting -to the pain of the treatment but refusing to put up with its benefit. So -when a lesson has lanced and probed his [Sidenote: F] folly, if he will -not permit it to close and dress the wound, he is abandoning philosophy -after feeling the sting and the pain but before deriving any advantage -therefrom. - -Euripides says that the wound of Telephus was - - _Soothed by the filings ground from the same spear._ - -It is no less true that the sting implanted by philosophy in [Sidenote: -47] a youth of parts is cured by the same reasoning that caused the -wound. While, therefore, it is right that the subject of reproof should -feel some pain from the sting, he must not be crushed or dispirited, -but, after undergoing the first discomposing rites of purification, he -should look for some sweet and splendid revelation to follow the -distress and confusion of the moment. For though the reproof may appear -to be unjust, the proper course is to endure it with all patience until -the speaker concludes. Then he may be met by a plea in self-defence, and -by [Sidenote: B] a request to reserve for some real fault all the -vigorous candour which he has shown in the present instance. - -To proceed to the next consideration. In reading and writing, playing -the lyre, or wrestling, the first lessons are very harassing, laborious, -and unsure; but, as we advance step by step, it is much as in dealing -with mankind. By dint of frequent and familiar acquaintance we find that -it all becomes pleasant and manageable, and every word or action easy. -It is the same with philosophy. No doubt the language and matter, as -first met with, contain something both hard and strange. But we must not -take fright at the rudiments and prove so timid and spiritless -[Sidenote: C] as to abandon the study. On the contrary, our duty is to -grapple with every question, to persevere, to be resolved on making -progress, and then to wait for that familiarity which converts all right -action into a pleasure. It will not be long before it arrives, casting -upon the study a flood of light, and inspiring an ardent passion for -excellence. To be without such passion and to put up with the ordinary -type of life because one is driven from philosophy by a lack of mettle, -is to be a miserable or cowardly creature. - -We may also expect that at first the argumentation will prove somewhat -difficult for young and inexperienced students to understand. For the -most part, however, the obscurity and want of comprehension are due to -themselves. Opposite dispositions [Sidenote: D] lead to the same -mistake. Thus one class, through bashfulness and a desire to spare the -teacher, will shrink from putting questions and making sure of the -argument, and will ostensibly assent as if they quite understood. The -others, led by misplaced ambition and meaningless rivalry to make a show -of cleverness and quickness, pretend to have mastered a thing before -they take it in, and so will not take it in at all. The consequence is -that when the former—the modest and silent kind—go home, they will worry -themselves with their perplexities, and in the end they will be driven -perforce to trouble the speaker by harking back with their questions at -a later date, when they will feel still more ashamed. Meanwhile the bold -and ambitious kind will be perpetually cloaking their ignorance and -hiding the fact that it haunts them. - -Let us then thrust aside all this pretentious silliness, and march -[Sidenote: E] on towards learning. Let our business be to get an -intelligent grasp upon valuable instruction. And let us put up with the -laughter of those who are thought to be clever. Remember how Cleanthes -and Xenocrates, though to all appearance slower than their -fellow-pupils, refused to give up or run away from their studies. On the -contrary, they were the first to joke at their own expense, comparing -themselves to a narrow-necked bottle or a brass tablet, inasmuch as, -though slow at taking their instruction in, they were safe and sure at -retaining it. Not only must we, as Phocylides puts it, - - _Oft-times be baulked of our hope while seeking to come unto - goodness_; - -we must also ‘oft-times’ be laughed at, and bear with scoffing -[Sidenote: F] and jeering, meanwhile putting all our heart and energy -into winning the struggle against our ignorance. - -We must, however, be quite as careful not to err in the opposite -direction. Some do so from sloth, which makes them a wearisome -infliction. Unwilling to trouble themselves when [Sidenote: 48] alone, -they keep troubling the teacher by repeatedly asking for information on -the same questions. Like unfledged birds in the nest, they are -perpetually agape to be fed from another’s mouth, and expect to receive -everything ready masticated by someone else. - -Another kind, in the misplaced quest of a reputation for alertness and -acumen, worry the lecturer with their fussy garrulity, perpetually -mooting some unimportant difficulty or demanding some unnecessary -demonstration, - - _Till a short journey so becometh long_ - -[Sidenote: B] —as Sophocles says—not only to themselves but to every one -else. By continually arresting the teacher with superfluous and futile -questions, as if they were merely chatting with a companion, they -interfere with the continuity of the lesson by a series of checks and -delays. Persons of this class are (to quote Hieronymus) like wretched -cowardly puppies, who bite the skins and tear the odds and ends of wild -animals at home, but who never touch the animals themselves. - -As for the former and lazy class, let us give them this advice. When -they have managed to comprehend the main points, let them piece the rest -together for themselves, using their [Sidenote: C] memory as a guide to -independent thought. And let them take the reasoning they hear from -another as a beginning—a seed which they are to make grow and thrive. - -The mind is not a vessel which calls for filling. It is a pile, which -simply requires kindling-wood to start the flame of eagerness for -original thought and ardour for truth. Suppose someone goes to borrow -from his neighbour’s fire, and then, on finding a large bright blaze, -persists in staying and basking on the spot. It is the same when a man -comes to another to borrow reason, and does not realize that he must -kindle a light of his own in the shape of thinking for himself, but sits -enchanted with enjoyment of the lecture. He derives from the lesson -[Sidenote: D] a ruddy glow or outward brilliance, but he fails to drive -out the mould and darkness from within by the warming power of -philosophy. - -If therefore any advice is needed for the hearing of lectures, it is to -remember the rule just given—to practise independent thought along with -learning. We shall thus attain, not to the ability of a sophist or the -‘well-informed’ man, but to a deep-seated philosophic power. Right -listening will be for us the introduction to right living. - -Footnote 44: - - The _paedagogus_, an attendant slave, who accompanied the boy and - watched over his conduct. - -Footnote 45: - - In his _Phaedrus_. - -Footnote 46: - - i. e. in the mixolydian mode, which was of a sad and dirgelike - character. - - - - - ON MORAL IGNORANCE IN HIGH PLACES - - -[Sidenote: 779 D] When Plato was invited by the Cyrenaeans to draw up a -code of laws for their use and to organize their constitution, he begged -to be excused, on the ground that it was difficult to legislate for so -prosperous a people: - - _For nought so arrogant_— - -nor so impracticable and headstrong— - - _as human kind_, - -when prosperity—or what is so considered—lies within its grasp. - -[Sidenote: E] No less difficult is the task of advising a ruler how to -rule. To admit reason, he fears, is to admit a ruler, whose law of duty -will make a slave of him and curtail the advantage he derives from -power. He has yet to learn a lesson from Theopompus, the Spartan king, -who was the first to modify the powers of the throne by means of that of -the Ephors. When his wife reproached him for proposing to leave to his -children less authority than he had inherited, he replied: ‘Nay, -greater, because more assured.’ By relaxing its excessive absolutism he -escaped the [Sidenote: F] consequent ill-feeling, and therewith its -dangers. But note. Theopompus, in diverting into other channels a -portion of the full stream of power, deprived himself of just so much as -he gave away. But when philosophic reason becomes the established -colleague and protector of a ruler, it merely removes the perilous -element and leaves the healthy—a process as necessary to power as to -sound health. - -In most cases, however, monarchs or rulers show as little wisdom as a -tasteless sculptor, who fancies that to represent a figure with a huge -stride, strained muscles, and gaping mouth, is to make it appear massive -and imposing. They imagine that [Sidenote: 780] an arrogant tone, harsh -looks, short temper, and exclusiveness give them the true regal air of -awe and majesty. In reality they are not a bit better than a colossal -statue with the outward shape and form of a god or demigod, while the -inside is a mass of earth, stone, or lead. Indeed, in the case of the -statue, these heavy materials serve to keep it erect and prevent it from -warping; whereas, with an unschooled governor or chief, the unreason -within is often the cause of instability and collapse. [Sidenote: B] His -foundation being out of plumb, the lofty power which he builds upon it -is correspondingly unstable. Now it is only when the builder’s square is -itself faultless in line and angle, that it can make other things true -to line by adjustment to, and comparison with, itself. So a ruler must -begin by acquiring rule within himself. Let him set his own soul -straight, and make his own character firm, and then begin adjusting his -subjects thereto. You cannot set upright, when you are falling; teach, -when you are ignorant; discipline, when unruly; command, when -disobedient; govern, when ungoverned. And yet it is a common error to -suppose that the chief blessing of authority [Sidenote: C] is to be -above authority. To the King of Persia every one was a slave except his -own wife, the very person whose master he ought to have been. - -By whom, then, is the ruler to be ruled? By the - - _Law, - Sovereign of mortals and immortals all_, - -as Pindar says; not a law written outwardly in books or on wooden -tables, but a living law of reason in himself, abiding with him, -watching him, and never leaving his soul destitute of guidance. The King -of Persia kept one chamberlain whose special function was to enter in -the morning and say to him: ‘Rise, Sire, and attend to matters which -Great Oromazdes [Sidenote: D] meant for your concern.’ The ruler who has -learned wisdom and self-control hears the same voice of exhortation from -within. It was a saying of Polemo that love is ‘_serving the Gods in the -care and protection of the young_‘. With more truth it might be said -that a ruler serves God in the care and protection of men, by -dispensing, or safeguarding, the blessings which God gives to mankind. - - _See’st thou yon boundless sky and air aloft, - How in soft arms it clasps the world about?_ - -From it descend the first principles of seeds in due kind; earth brings -them forth; their growth is fostered by rains or winds or the warmth of -moon and stars; while the sun brings everything [Sidenote: E] to beauty -and tinctures all creation with that peculiar love-spell which is his. -But though the Gods may lavish these great boons and blessings, who can -enjoy or use them rightly, if there be no law, justice, or ruler? -Justice is the end of law; law is the work of the ruler; and a ruler is -an image of the God who orders all things. He needs no Pheidias or -Polycleitus or Myro to fashion him, but brings himself into likeness -with deity [Sidenote: F] by means of virtue, and so creates the fairest -and most divine of effigies. In the heavens the sun and moon were set by -God as His own beauteous image; and, in a state, the same shining -embodiment is to be found in the ruler - - _Godfearing, who justice upholdeth_, - -—that is to say, when he holds, not a sceptre, but a mind which is the -reason of God; not when he holds the thunderbolt or trident with which -some represent themselves in statue or picture, rendering their folly -odious to Heaven by such impossible assertion. For God visits with -righteous wrath him who makes pretence of thunder or thunderbolt or -darting sun-ray; but when a man studies to emulate His goodness, and to -take [Sidenote: 781] a pattern by His virtue and benevolence, He -delights in furthering him and bestowing a portion of His own -righteousness, justice, truth, and mercy. Not fire or light, not the -course of the sun, the risings and settings of the stars, -everlastingness and immortality, are more divine that these attributes. -For it is not by reason of length of life that God is happy, but by -reason of the virtue which rules. This is ‘divine’. ‘Noble’, however, is -the virtue whose part it is only to obey. - -When Alexander was in sore distress at killing Cleitus, Anaxarchus told -him, by way of comfort, that Right and Justice were [Sidenote: B] but -the ‘assessors’ of Zeus—making out that any act was right and lawful for -a king. A false and pernicious salve for his repentance at his sin, this -encouragement to repeat it! If we are to use such figures of speech, -Right is no ‘assessor’ of Zeus, but He himself is Right and Justice, the -oldest and most consummate Law. What the ancients tell and write and -teach is that, without Justice, not even Zeus can properly rule. -According to Hesiod - - _A virgin is she_, - -the incorruptible partner of feeling, self-control, and beneficence. -[Sidenote: C] Hence are kings called ‘merciful’, for mercy best becomes -those who are least afraid. A ruler’s fear should be of doing harm -rather than of suffering it; for the former action is the cause of the -latter, and this kind of fear on the part of a ruler is creditable to -humanity. There is nothing ignoble in a fear for his subjects and of -possible injury to them. Such rulers are like - - _Dogs that keep ward o’er the sheep in the farmstead, anxiously - watching - At sound of a fierce wild beast_— - -their anxiety being not for themselves, but for their charges. - -Once when the Thebans had recklessly abandoned themselves [Sidenote: D] -to feasting and carousal, Epaminondas went the round of the walls and -the military posts all by himself, remarking that he was keeping sober -and wakeful so that the rest might be drunk and asleep. When Cato, after -the defeat at Utica, gave orders that every one else should be sent to -sea, saw them on board, prayed that they might have a prosperous voyage, -and then went back home and stabbed himself, it was a lesson on the -text, ‘For whose sake should a ruler feel fear, and for what should he -feel contempt?’ On the other hand, Clearchus, despot of Pontus, used at -bedtime to crawl like a snake into a chest. [Sidenote: E] Similarly, -Aristodemus of Argos crept into an upper room entered by a trap-door. -Over this he would put the couch upon which he passed the night with his -mistress. Meanwhile her mother dragged away the ladder from below, -bringing it back and putting it in place in the morning. How, think you, -must he have shuddered at the theatre, at the Government offices, at the -Senate-House, at the banquet, when he turned his own bedchamber into a -prison? Yes, kings are afraid _for_ their subjects, despots are afraid -_of_ them. It follows that, as they add to their power, they add to -their alarms; the more people they rule, the more people they fear. - -[Sidenote: F] It is an improbable and unworthy view to hold of God—as -some philosophers do—that He exists as an element in matter to which all -sorts of things may happen, and in entities which are subject to -innumerable accidents, chances and changes. In reality He is stablished -somewhere aloft ‘_on holy pedestal_’ (as Plato puts it) in the realm of -nature uniform and constant, and there ‘_moves according to Nature in a -straight line towards the accomplishment of His end_‘. And as in heaven -the sun, His beauteous counterfeit, shows itself as His reflection in a -mirror to those who have the power to see Him through it, so, in the -justice and reason which shine in a state, He sets up a likeness of that -which is in Himself, and, by copying that likeness, men [Sidenote: 782] -whom philosophy has gifted and chastened model themselves after the -highest pattern. - -This condition of mind nothing can implant except reason acquired from -philosophy. Otherwise we are in the position of Alexander, when he went -to see Diogenes at Corinth. In delight at his talent, and in admiration -of his proud and lofty spirit, he exclaimed: ‘If I had not been -Alexander, I would have been Diogenes.’ And what did this virtually -mean? That he was vexed at his own high fortune, splendour, and -[Sidenote: B] power, because they were an obstacle to the virtue for -which he could find no time, and that he envied the cloak and the -wallet, which made Diogenes as invincible and unassailable as he himself -was made by armour and horses and spears. And yet by the practice of -philosophy he might have secured the moral character of a Diogenes while -retaining the position of an Alexander. Nay, he should have become all -the more a Diogenes for being an Alexander, since his high fortune, so -liable to be tossed by stormy winds, required ample ballast and a master -hand at the helm. - -In the case of private men without strength or standing, folly is so -qualified by impotence that in the end no mischief is done. It is as -with a bad dream, in which, though the mind is excited with passion, no -harm results, inasmuch as it is unable to rise and act in accordance -with the desires. When, on the other [Sidenote: C] hand, vice is adopted -by power, the passions acquire sinew and strength. Dionysius spoke truly -when he said that the highest advantage of power was to give speedy -effect to a wish. A most parlous thing, if you can give effect to a -wish, and yet wish what is wrong! - - _No sooner the word had been utter’d, than straightway the deed was - accomplish’d._ - -Vice, when enabled by power to run rapid course, forces every passion -into action, converting anger into murder, love into adultery, greed -into confiscation. - - _No sooner the word hath been utter’d_, - -than your opponent has met his doom. No sooner a suspicion, than the -victim of slander is a dead man. - -[Sidenote: D] Scientists tell us that, whereas lightning really follows -and issues from thunder like blood from a wound, it is perceived first -because, while the hearing waits for the sound, the vision goes out to -meet the light. So with rulers. The punishment outstrips the charge; the -condemnation does not wait for the proof. - - _For forthwith anger slips and loses hold, - Like anchor’s tooth in sand when seas swell high_, - -unless reason with all its weight puts a heavy drag on power; unless, -that is, the ruler acts like the sun, whose motion is least [Sidenote: -E] when its height is greatest, namely, at the time of its northern -altitude, its course being steadied by the diminished speed. - -Vice in high places cannot be hid. When an epileptic is placed upon a -height and made to turn round, he is seized with giddiness and begins to -totter, his malady being betrayed thereby. So with an unschooled and -ignorant person. After a brief uplifting by wealth or fame or place, the -same fortune which raised him up immediately reveals how ready he is to -fall. To put it another way; when a vessel is empty, you cannot detect -the crack or flaw, but when you begin to fill it, the leak appears. -[Sidenote: F] So with a mind which is too unsound to hold power and -authority; its leaks are to be seen in its exhibitions of lust, anger, -pretentiousness, and ignorance. Yet why speak of this, when holes are -picked in eminent and distinguished men for the merest peccadilloes? -Cimon was reproached for his addiction to wine, Scipio for his addiction -to sleep, and Lucullus for his extravagance at table[47].... - -Footnote 47: - - The rest of the essay is missing. - - - - - FAWNER AND FRIEND - (WITH AN EXCURSUS ON CANDOUR) - - -MY DEAR ANTIOCHUS PHILOPAPPUS, [Sidenote: 48 E] - -‘Every one,’ says Plato, ‘will pardon a man for admitting that he has a -strong affection for himself,’ but—not to mention [Sidenote: F] numerous -other defects to which he is subject—there is one chief weakness which -precludes him from giving a just and incorruptible verdict in his own -case. ‘The lover is blind where the beloved object is concerned,’ unless -he has learned the habit of prizing things, not because they are his own -or related to himself, but because they are beautiful. Hence, there is -ample opportunity for the flatterer to obtain a place among our friends. -He delivers his attack from an excellent point of vantage in the shape -of that self-love which makes every man his own [Sidenote: 49] first and -greatest flatterer, ready and willing to welcome such external testimony -as will endorse his own conceits and desires. For the man who is -reprobated as a lover of toadies is an ardent lover of himself. Out of -fondness for himself he not only entertains the wish to possess, but -also the conceit that he possesses, all manner of qualities; and though -the desire may be natural enough, the conceit is fallacious and calls -for the greatest watchfulness. - -And if truth is divine, and—as Plato asserts—the first principle -[Sidenote: B] of ‘all good things both with Gods and men’, the toady -must be an enemy of the Gods, and especially of the Pythian. For, in -perpetual antagonism to the doctrine of _Know Thyself_, he produces -self-deception in a man, self-ignorance, and error as to his virtues and -vices. The virtues he renders defective and abortive; the vices he -renders incorrigible. - -Now if the flatterer had been like most other mischievous things, and -had solely or chiefly attacked mean and petty victims, the harm would -have been neither so great nor so difficult to prevent. But it is into -soft and sweet kinds of wood that worms prefer to bore, and it is -estimable and capable characters—characters with a love of -approbation—that give access and supply nourishment to the flatterer who -fastens upon [Sidenote: C] them. ‘_The breeding of the steed_,’ says -Simonides, ‘_sorts not with Zacynthus,[48] but with wheat-bearing -plains_.’ Similarly we do not find toadyism in attendance upon the poor, -the insignificant, or the uninfluential, but sapping and debilitating -great houses and great fortunes, and frequently subverting rulers and -thrones. Consequently no slight effort or common precaution is required -in considering how it can be most readily detected and so prevented from -doing injury and discredit to friendship. - -[Sidenote: D] Vermin quit a dying man and desert the body when the blood -which feeds them becomes exhausted. So with the time-server. You will -never find him approaching a person whose fortune is destitute of sap -and warmth. It is the famous and influential whom he attacks; it is out -of them that he makes capital; and when their circumstances change he -promptly beats a retreat. We should not, however, wait for that test; it -is then not merely useless but fraught with injury and danger. It is a -grievous thing to find out who is not your friend only at the moment -when a friend is needed, since the discovery does not enable you to -exchange the uncertain and counterfeit for the genuine and certain. You -should possess friends as you possess coin—tested [Sidenote: E] before -the occasion, not waiting to be proved by the occasion. Discovery should -not come through injury, but injury should be prevented by our acquiring -a scientific insight into the nature of the toady. Otherwise we shall be -in the position of those who distinguish a deadly poison by tasting it; -we shall meet our death in the effort of judging. - -One can neither approve of such a course, nor yet of those who, because -they regard a ‘friend’ as implying a high and wholesome influence, -imagine that an agreeable associate is immediately and manifestly proved -to be a time-server. For there is nothing disagreeable or -uncompromisingly severe about a friend, nor does the high respect we pay -to friendship depend upon harshness or austerity. Nay, its high -influence and claim to respect are actually an agreeable and desirable -thing in themselves, [Sidenote: F] - - _And close at its side do the Graces and Longing Desire set their - dwellings._ - -Not only may the unfortunate man say, with Euripides, - - _’Tis sweet to look into a friend’s fond eyes_, - -but friendship is a comrade who adds as much pleasure and gratification -to our blessings as it brings relief to the pains and perplexities of -our mishaps. According to Euenus ‘_the best of [Sidenote: 50] seasonings -is fire_‘. So, by making friendship an ingredient of life, God has -rendered all things bright and sweet and enjoyable through its presence -and participation. How, indeed, could the fawner have wormed himself -into our pleasures, if he had seen that friendship refuses all -admittance to what is pleasant? The thing is absurd. No; the toady is -like the mock-gilt and tinsel which merely mimic the sheen and lustre of -gold. It is in order to imitate the attractiveness and charm of a friend -that he makes a constant show of agreeableness and amiability, and never -opposes or contradicts you. It is therefore wrong, [Sidenote: B] when a -person praises you, to suspect at once that he is simply a flatterer. -Friendship is quite as much called upon to praise in season as it is to -blame. In fact, perpetual peevishness and fault-finding is the negation -of friendship and sociability; whereas, when affection bestows zealous -and ungrudging praise upon our good deeds, we also submit readily and -cheerfully to its candid remonstrances, being satisfied with the belief -that the man who is glad to praise will only blame because he must. - -[Sidenote: C] ‘It is a hard matter then,’ we may be told, ‘to -distinguish between flatterer and friend, if they are equally pleasant -and equally laudatory, especially when we find that toadyism is often -more than a match for friendship in the tendering of services.’ -Naturally so, we reply, if the object of our search is the genuine -toady, with a past-master’s skill at the business; if, that is, we do -not adopt the common view and mean by ‘toady’ your poverty-stricken -trencherman, who ‘begins’—as some one has said—‘to declare himself with -the first course,’ and whose lickspittle character betrays itself by -gross and vulgar [Sidenote: D] buffoonery at the first dish and the -first glass. It needed no test to expose Melanthius, the parasite of -Pherae. It was enough that, when asked ‘how Alexander was stabbed,’ he -replied, ‘Through the ribs, into my belly.’ Nor is there any such need -with those who besiege ‘an opulent table’, and whom - - _Not fire, nor steel, nor bronze can keep_ - -from making their way to a dinner. Nor yet with those female toadies of -Cyprus, who, after their transference to Syria, were [Sidenote: E] -called ‘pair o’ steps’ from the fact that they used to allow the king’s -wife to mount her carriage over their bent backs. - -Against whom, then, are we to be on our guard? Against the man who is -not confessedly or apparently a toady; one who is not to be found -hanging about the kitchen, nor to be caught watching the dial with a -dinner in prospect; one who is not to be made tipsy and then pitched -into any corner; but one who for the most part keeps sober and bustling, -thinking it his business to take part in all your doings, and to be -privy to your confidential talk—the man, in short, who acts the rôle of -friend, not in the satyric[49] or comic style, but in the high tragic. -According to Plato, ‘the extreme of dishonesty is to appear honest when -you are not.’ So with time-serving. It is [Sidenote: F] to be regarded -as dangerous, not when confessed, but when undetected; when it wears a -serious, not an amusing, air. In this form, unless we are careful, it -casts a slur of discredit even upon genuine friendship, the points of -coincidence being numerous. When the Mage was trying to escape and -Gobryes had plunged with him into a dark room and was grappling with -him, Darius stood at a loss what to do. ‘Stab,’ said Gobryes, ‘though -you stab both.’ With us it is not so easy, inasmuch as we can by no -means give any sanction to the maxim: ‘_Perish friend, if so perish -foe._’ There are so many points of similarity to complicate the fawner -with the friend that we must find it a most parlous business to tear the -one from the other. We may either be casting out the good thing along -with the bad, [Sidenote: 51] or, in trying to spare the right thing, we -may let the wrong one bring us to grief. There are wild plants of which -the seeds are similar in shape and size to those of wheat. When the two -are mixed it is difficult to sift these out; they will not fall through -smaller holes, and, if the holes are wider, one falls through as much as -the other. No less difficult is it to separate time-serving from -friendship, when it blends itself with every feeling, every movement, -need, and habit. - -Friendship being the most pleasant and delightful thing in the world, it -follows that the toady also uses pleasure for his [Sidenote: B] bait. To -give pleasure is his main concern. And since agreeableness and -usefulness are concomitants of friendship—whence the saying that ‘_a -friend is more indispensable than fire and water_‘—it follows that the -toady insists on rendering services, and is all eagerness to show -unfaltering promptitude and zeal. But the surest foundation of -friendship is similarity of pursuits and character. The foremost agent -in mutual attraction is similarity of temperament—the liking and -disliking of the same things. This the time-server perceives, and -therefore he adapts himself [Sidenote: C] like wax to the proper shape -and form, endeavouring by imitation to mould himself so as exactly to -fit his victim. His supple versatility, his genius for mimicry, is so -great that it is a case of - - _Thou art - Achilles’ self, and not Achilles’ son._ - -And note his craftiest device. He observes that candour is called (what -it appears to be) ‘the characteristic note of friendship’, while lack of -candour is the negation of friendship and spirit. He does not fail, -therefore, to imitate this quality also. As a skilful _chef_ will use -some bitter or piquant juice for a sauce in order to prevent sweets from -cloying, so with the candour [Sidenote: D] of the toady. It is not -genuine, nor is it useful; it is given, as it were, with a wink, and -serves simply as an excitant. The result is that he is as hard to detect -as one of those creatures which possess the natural power of altering -their colour so as to match the spot on which they happen to lie. Since, -therefore, it is under cover of resemblances that he deceives us, our -proper course is to find in the non-resemblances a means of stripping -off his disguise and showing that—as Plato puts it—he is ‘beautifying -himself with borrowed forms and colours through lack of any of his own’. - -Let us begin at the very beginning. In most instances, we remarked, -friendship commences with similarity of temperament [Sidenote: E] and -disposition, a taste for very much the same habits and principles, and a -delight in the same pursuits, occupations, and pastimes. Such a -similarity is implied in the lines: - - _Most welcome to the old is old men’s speech; - Child pleaseth child, and woman pleaseth woman, - Sick men the sick, and one who meets disaste - Brings solace to another suffering it._ - -The toady knows that it is natural to find pleasure in one’s like and to -be fond of his society. This, therefore, is his first device [Sidenote: -F] for approaching you and getting neighbours with you. He acts like -herdsmen on a pasture. He works gently up to you and rubs shoulders with -you in the same pursuits, amusements, tastes, and way of life, until you -give him his chance and let yourself grow tame and accustomed to his -touch. He condemns such circumstances, such conduct, and such persons as -he notices you dislike; while of those that please you he cannot say too -much in praise, exhibiting boundless delight and admiration [Sidenote: -52] for them. He thus confirms you in your loves and hatreds, as being -the results, not of feelings, but of judgement. - -How, then, is he to be exposed? By what points of difference are we to -prove that he is not, nor is on the way to be, our like, but only a -pretender thereto? In the first place we must look for consistency and -permanence in his principles. We must see whether he takes pleasure in, -and gives praise to, the same things at all times; whether he directs -and establishes his own life after one pattern, as a frank and free -lover of single-minded friendship and fellowship ought to do. A friend -does act in this manner. On the other hand, the time-server possesses no -one fixed hearthstone to his character. He does not live a life -[Sidenote: B] chosen for himself, but a life chosen for another. -Moulding and adapting himself to suit others, he possesses no singleness -or unity, but adopts all manner of varying shapes. Like water poured -from one vessel into another, he is perpetually flowing hither and -thither and accommodating himself to the form of the receptacle. - -The ape, we are told, is captured through endeavouring to imitate man by -copying his motions in dancing. The time-server, on the contrary, is one -who allures and decoys others. Nor does his mimicry take the same form -in all cases. One person he will help to dance and sing: with another he -will share a taste for wrestling and athletics. If he gets hold of a -sportsman devoted to hunting, he follows his lead, and all but shouts, -in the words of Phaedra, [Sidenote: C] - - _I long, ye Gods, to cheer the hounds - Close-pressing on the dappled deer_, - -whereas he feels no interest whatever in the animal, but is setting his -toils to catch the huntsman himself. If his next quarry is a young man -with a taste for study and intellectual improvement, he is all for -books, and grows a beard down to his feet; it is a case of wearing the -philosopher’s cloak and his air of ‘indifference’,[50] and of prating -about Plato’s ‘numbers’ and ‘right-angled triangles’. If, next, there -happens along some easy-going bibulous person with plenty of money, - - _Then forthwith are his rags cast off by the wily Odysseus._ - -[Sidenote: D] Away goes the cloak; shorn off is the beard—’tis a crop -that bears no corn: to the fore are wine-coolers and wine-cups, laughter -in the streets and mockery of the philosophic student. - -We are told, for instance, that at Syracuse, when Plato visited the -place and Dionysius was seized with a mania for philosophy, the host of -geometricians turned the palace into a perfect whirl of dust.[51] But -when Dionysius came to logger-heads with Plato, had had enough of -philosophy, and abandoned himself to drink and women and to silly talk -and wanton [Sidenote: E] behaviour, in a moment it was as if Circe had -transformed them every one, and there came a reign of vulgarity, -oblivion, and folly. Examples are also to be found in the conduct of -time-servers on a large scale, such as demagogues. Greatest was -Alcibiades. At Athens he joked, kept horses, and lived like a wit and a -man of the world. At Lacedaemon he cropped his hair close, wore a short -cloak, and bathed in cold water. In Thrace he fought and drank. But when -he attached himself to Tissaphernes, he indulged in luxury, effeminacy, -and ostentation, and sought to win the good graces of his company by -adapting himself in all cases to their likeness and becoming one of -them. Not so Epaminondas or Agesilaus. Despite [Sidenote: F] all their -intercourse with so many persons, communities, and standards of conduct, -they everywhere maintained—in dress, way of life, speech, and -behaviour—their own proper character. So with Plato. He was the same at -Syracuse as at Athens, the same to Dionysius as to Dion. - -Our easiest method of exposing the polypus-like changes of the -time-server is to make a show of frequent changes on our own part, -finding fault with conduct of which we formerly approved, and all of a -sudden countenancing actions, conduct, [Sidenote: 53] or talk which used -to fill us with disgust. We shall then perceive that he has no sort of -settled and specific character; that his loves, hatreds, pleasures, and -pains are not matters of his own feeling; that he is merely a mirror -reflecting extraneous moods, principles, and emotions. For observe the -man’s ways. Should you speak disparagingly to him of one of your -friends, he will remark: ‘You have been slow in finding the fellow out; -_I_ never did like him.’ If, on the contrary, you change your tone and -speak in his praise, he will declare that he is ‘right glad and thankful -on the man’s behalf’, because he ‘believes in him’. If you propose to -adopt a different mode of life—if, for example, [Sidenote: B] you are -converted from a political career to a life of quiet inactivity—he will -say, ‘We ought to have got quit of brawlings and jealousies long before -this.’ If, on the other hand, you appear eager for office and the -platform, he seconds you with, ‘A very proper spirit! A quiet life is -pleasant, no doubt, but it lacks honour and distinction.’ We ought -immediately to answer that kind of man with the words: - - ‘_Different, sir, dost thou show thyself now from the man thou wert - erstwhile._ - -I do not want a friend who shifts his ground when I do and who nods when -I nod—my shadow can do that better—but one who helps me to truth and -sound judgement.’ - -[Sidenote: C] Such is one way of applying a test. There is a second -point of difference to be watched, as against the points of resemblance. -It is not in all matters that a genuine friend is prompt to copy or -commend us, but only in the best. - - _Not his to share our hates, but share our loves_, - -as Sophocles has it. Yes, and to share our right conduct and high -principles, not our wrong and wanton deeds, unless perhaps—as a result -of familiar association—some contaminating effluence, like that of -ophthalmia, affects him to some extent with a blemish or a fault against -his will. For instance, it is said that [Sidenote: D] Plato’s stoop, -Aristotle’s lisp, King Alexander’s crook of the neck and harshness of -voice in conversation, were tricks borrowed by their respective -intimates. There are persons who, without knowing it, pick up from both -the temperament and conduct of their friends most of what is -characteristic of them. The time-server, however, is exactly like the -chameleon. As the latter assimilates himself to every colour but white, -so the time-server, though utterly unable to arrive at a likeness to -your valuable qualities, leaves no discreditable one uncopied. He is -like a bad painter, who, because beauty lies beyond the reach of his -weak capacity, makes the strikingness of his portraiture [Sidenote: E] a -matter of wrinkles, moles, and scars. So the toady becomes an imitator -of dissoluteness, superstition, irascibility, harshness to servants, and -distrust of friends and relatives. Not only is he by nature and of his -own accord prone to the lower course; it is by imitating a baseness that -he appears to be farthest from blaming it. A man who takes the higher -line, and shows distress and vexation at his friends’ misdeeds, is -dubiously regarded—a fact which accounts for the ruin of Dion with -Dionysius, of Samius with Philip, and of Cleomenes with Ptolemy. But -when a man desires to be, and to be thought, agreeable and to be -depended upon, the worse the thing is, the more display he makes of -liking it, as if the strength of his affection will not permit him to -dislike even your vices, but makes him your [Sidenote: F] natural -sympathizer in all circumstances. Such persons therefore insist upon -sharing even involuntary and accidental shortcomings. When toadying an -invalid, they pretend to suffer with the same complaint. In company with -a person who is somewhat blind or deaf, they pretend to be dim-sighted -and hard of hearing, like the flatterers of Dionysius, whose sight was -so dull that they stumbled against each other and knocked over the -dishes at dinner. - -Sometimes they work themselves into closer and more intimate touch with -a trouble or a malady, till they come to participate in afflictions of -the most secret kind. If they see [Sidenote: 54] that the patron is -unhappy in his marriage or on bad terms with his sons or his relatives, -they do not spare themselves, but make lamentations about their own -children, or wife, or relatives, or friends, on certain alleged grounds -which they divulge as a miserable secret. Such similarity creates a -closer understanding with their patron. He has received a sort of -hostage, thereupon betrays to them some secret or other, and, because of -that betrayal, keeps friends with them and is afraid to leave his -confidence to its fate. I know of one time-server who, when the patron -divorced his wife, turned his own wife also out of doors. It was, -however, found out—through a discovery [Sidenote: B] of the patron’s -wife—that he was visiting and sending messages to her in secret. The -toady must have been but little known to the man who thought that the -lines: - - _Body all belly, and an eye that looks - All round; a thing that crawls upon its teeth_, - -were as apt a description for a crab as they are for the flatterer. The -picture is that of the parasite: - - _The friend of saucepan-time and dinner-hour_, - -as Eupolis expresses it. - -This point, however, we will reserve till its proper place. Meanwhile we -must not omit to mention another shrewd trick played by the time-server -when he imitates you. If he goes so far as to copy some good quality in -the person whom he [Sidenote: C] toadies, he is careful to leave the -advantage with him. Friends in the true sense are neither jealous nor -envious of each other, and, whether they reach or fail to reach the same -degree of excellence, they accept the situation fairly and without a -grudge. But the toady—who never forgets to play second rôle—lets his -resemblance fall short of equality, and owns to being distanced at -everything but vices. In vices, however, he insists on first prize. If -the patron is irritable, he says, ‘_I_ am all bile;’ if superstitious, -‘_I_ am a mass of fears;’ if love-sick, ‘_I_ am frantic.’ [Sidenote: D] -‘It was wrong of you to laugh,’ he will say, ‘but _I_ was absolutely -dying with laughter.’ But where virtues are concerned it is the other -way about. ‘I am a fast runner, but _you_ positively fly.’ ‘I am a -tolerable horseman, but nothing to a centaur like our friend here.’ ‘I -have a neat turn for poetry, and can write a line better than some, but - - _Thunder is not for me, ’tis work for Zeus._’ - -He thus appears to do two things at once—to give an air of merit to his -patron’s tastes by imitating them, and of unapproachableness to his -ability by failing to match it. - -So much for the differences between fawner and friend in the midst of -their resemblances. - -Since, as we have observed, pleasure is another point in common—a good -type of man taking as much delight in his friends as a weak man does in -his flatterers—we may proceed to make a distinction here also. The -distinction lies in the relation between the pleasure and its end. Thus, -not only unguents [Sidenote: E] have an agreeable smell; a medicine may -have it also. But there is the difference that the object of the former -is pleasure and nothing else, while in the other case the purgative, -warming, or flesh-making quality happens to be combined with fragrance. -Again, a painter mixes engaging colours and dyes, and there are also -certain medical preparations with a taking appearance and an attractive -colour. Where is the difference? Clearly our distinction will lie in the -end for which they are used. Just so with the case before us. In the -agreeable relations of [Sidenote: F] friend with friend the -pleasant-giving element is a kind of gloss upon a substance of high -value and utility. Sometimes sportiveness, the table, wine, and even -mockery and nonsense are used by them as a seasoning to high and serious -purposes. Hence such expressions as: - - _Then had they joyance in talk and in speaking the one to the - other_; - -or: - - _Nor should aught else have parted us twain in our love and our - joyance._ - -But, with the time-server, it is his function and end to be [Sidenote: -55] perpetually dishing up in a spicy form something amusing, something -done or something said which pleases and is meant to please. - -To put it briefly, the toady thinks the purpose of his every action -should be to make himself agreeable, whereas the friend will only do -what is right, and therefore, though often agreeable, he is often the -contrary, not because he wishes it, but because, when it is the proper -course, he does not avoid it. It is as with the physician. When it helps -matters he will throw in a pinch of saffron or spikenard, and will -frequently order a pleasant bath and an inviting diet. But there are -times when he will have none of these, but will shake in a dash of -castor - - _Or polium foul of odor, that men e’en shudder to smell it._ - -[Sidenote: B] Or he will pound a dose of hellebore and make you drink it -off. Neither the unpleasantness in the one case nor the pleasantness in -the other is the end in his mind, but in both cases he has only one -object in view for the patient, and that object is his good. In the same -way there are times when a friend will lead you in the path of duty by -inspiriting you with praise or gratifying you with courtesies, as the -speaker does in - - _Teucer, Telamon’s son, dear prince of a warrior people, - Shoot as now thou dost_, - -or in: - - _How then should I, if ’tis so, be forgetful of godlike Odysseus?_ - -But when, on the contrary, you need calling to attention, he will -upbraid you in biting terms and with the plain-speaking of a guardian: -[Sidenote: C] - - _Foolish art thou, Menelaus Zeus-foster’d: no time is this present - For folly like thine._ - -There are also times when he makes the deed accompany the word, like -Menedemus, when he taught the prodigal and dissolute son of his friend -Asclepiades a wholesome lesson by shutting the door in his face and -refusing to speak to him. Similarly Arcesilaus forbade Bato the -lecture-room for having attacked Cleanthes in a verse of a comedy. He -was reconciled to him, however, when he repented and made his peace with -Cleanthes. For though one must give a friend pain when it does him good, -one must not, while giving the pain, make an end of the friendship. The -sting should be used only as a medicine, for the care and salvation of -the patient. A friend is therefore [Sidenote: D] like a musician. In -converting us to right and salutary courses he will sometimes loosen and -sometimes tighten the strings. Pleasure you will get from him often, -profit always. On the other hand, the time-server, who harps in a single -key and is accustomed to strike no note but that of your pleasure and -gratification, has no notion of any action to check you or word to pain -you. He merely plays the accompaniment to your wishes, with which both -his time and his words are invariably in accord. Xenophon says of -Agesilaus that he welcomed praise from those who were no less ready to -blame. So we should regard that which gives pleasure and gratification -as in the category of ‘friend’, if it can also on occasion oppose us and -give us pain. But a companionship which is uniformly pleasurable and -maintains [Sidenote: E] a perpetual graciousness unqualified by any -sting, calls for suspicion. We ought, in fact, to be ready to ask, like -the Laconian on hearing praise of King Charillus, ‘How can a man be -honest, when he cannot be angry even with a rascal?’ - -It is close to the ear, we are told, that the gadfly gets into a bull -and the tick into a dog. In the case of a man of ambition, the -time-server with his flatteries takes hold of his ears and sticks so -fast that it is hard to rub him off. Particularly, therefore, in such -circumstances must we keep our judgement vigilant. It must be on the -alert to see whether the praise is given to the [Sidenote: F] thing or -to the man. It is given to the thing when men praise us in our absence -more than in our presence; when they wish and strive for the same -objects themselves, and praise not only us but every one else who does -the like; when we do not find them doing and saying first one thing and -then the opposite; and—most important of all—when our sense does not -tell us that we are repenting or ashamed of the things for which we are -praised, or wishing that we had rather done and said the [Sidenote: 56] -contrary. This inward judgement, which testifies against a flattery and -refuses to accept it, is immune from contamination, and proof against -the time-server. - -It is a strange thing that most men, when they meet with a misfortune, -cannot bear to be consoled, but are better pleased with those who will -join in the lamentations; but when they are guilty of a blunder or a -fault, if you make them feel the sting of repentance by means of a -reproof or a reprimand, they think you an enemy and an accuser; whereas, -if you eulogize their conduct, they regard you as a loyal friend and -receive you with open arms. - -Now when people give you praise and applause for something [Sidenote: B] -you do or say, whether in sober earnest or in careless jest, the harm -they do is only for the moment, and only affects the matter in hand. But -when their praises go so far as to influence your moral being, and their -flatteries to affect your character, they are as bad as servants who -pilfer ‘_not from the stack, but from the seed_‘. For the moral -disposition and the moral character—first principle and fountain-head of -conduct—are the seed of actions, and these they corrupt by clothing vice -in the titles of virtue. Thucydides tells us that in the midst of war -and faction ‘_the customary acceptation of words was arbitrarily changed -to suit an end. Reckless daring came to be thought devoted courage; -[Sidenote: C] cautious hesitation, an excuse for cowardice; moderation, -weakness in disguise; complete insight, complete inertia_‘. So, when -flattery is at work, we should warily note how prodigality is called -‘generosity’; cowardice, ‘caution’; light-headed caprice, ‘life and -vigour’; meanness, ‘moderation’; the amorous man, ‘amiable and -affectionate’; the arrogant and irascible person, ‘a man of spirit’; a -poor meek creature, ‘civil and obliging’. [Sidenote: D] Remember, how -Plato tells us that the lover—the flatterer of the beloved—calls a snub -nose ‘piquant’, a hook-nose ‘regal’, a swarthy face ‘virile’, a white -face ‘saint-like’, while ‘honey-colour’ is simply the coinage of a lover -who indulgently invents a pretty name for pallor. Yet when an ugly man -is persuaded that he is beautiful, or a little man that he is tall, his -deception is short-lived, and the harm which he sustains is slight and -easily repaired. But flattery may teach him to treat vices as if they -[Sidenote: E] were virtues, and to rejoice in them instead of sorrowing. -It may remove all sense of shame at misconduct. Such flattery spelled -destruction to the Siceliots, when it called the cruelty of Dionysius -and Phalaris a ‘hatred of wickedness’. It spelled ruin to Egypt, when it -gave to Ptolemy’s effeminacy, to his hysterical superstition, to his -shriekings and bangings of tambourines, the name of piety and worship. -It came once within an ace of utterly subverting Roman morals, when it -glossed over Antony’s dissolute and ostentatious self-indulgence with -pretty terms as a ‘festive and genial appreciation of the boons of -unstinted [Sidenote: F] power and fortune’. What made Ptolemy tie on the -mouth-strap and its pair of flutes? What made Nero cultivate the tragic -stage and don the mask and buskin? What else but praise from flatterers? -Is not a king regularly called an Apollo if he warbles, a Dionysius if -he gets drunk, a Hercules if he wrestles? And is he not so pleased with -it, that there is no way of disgracing himself to which flattery will -not lead him? It is therefore in the matter of praise that we should -chiefly beware of the time-server. He is himself alive to the fact, and -[Sidenote: 57] is deft at avoiding suspicion. If therefore he gets hold -of some dull-witted and thick-skinned grandee, he fools him to the top -of his bent. Remember how Strouthias makes a hobby-horse of Bias and -dances his fling upon the man’s stupidity by praising him with: - - _You have drunk more than royal Alexander_, - -or: - - _I laugh to think o’ the quip you gave the Cyprian._ - -But with persons of more discernment he perceives that in this direction -they are particularly on the alert, that in this quarter they keep a -special watch. He does not therefore adopt a direct line of attack with -his flattery, but fetches a circuitous course from a distance, and - - _Advances noiselessly, as when a beast_ - -[Sidenote: B] is tentatively approached and fingered. At one moment he -will describe how you have been praised by some one else, using the -public speaker’s device of putting the words in another person’s mouth. -He will say, for instance, that he had the great pleasure of being -present in the market-place when some ‘visitors’—or some ‘elderly -people’—were relating a good many admiring and complimentary stories -about you. At another time he will concoct a number of trivial and -fictitious charges against you, which he purports to have heard from -others, and he will say that he has hastened to find you and desires to -know where you said such-and-such a thing or did so-and-so. If you deny -them—as you naturally will—he at [Sidenote: C] once has you in the trap -for his compliments: ‘It did surprise me that you should speak ill of a -friend, seeing that it is not your nature to do so even of an enemy;’ or -‘that you should have designs on other people’s property, when you are -so liberal with your own’. - -Others, again, are like a painter who brings the light and bright parts -into relief by the juxtaposition of dark and shaded portions. By -blaming, abusing, belittling, and ridiculing the opposite qualities, -they give a concealed praise and encouragement to the defects of the -person flattered. To a spendthrift they disparage economy and call it -stinginess. To a grasping knave [Sidenote: D] who makes money by mean -and shabby practices they depreciate honest self-support and call it -want of enterprise and business capacity. When they associate with some -careless idler who shuns the busy centres of affairs, they are not -ashamed to style public life a ‘meddling with other people’s business’, -and public spirit a ‘sterile vanity’. Sometimes, in order to flatter a -public speaker, a philosopher is belittled, or the favour of profligate -women is won by miscalling faithful and loving wives ‘provincial and -unattractive’. Most pitiful in its baseness is the fact that the toady -does not even spare himself. As a wrestler crouches his body in order to -throw another, so he insidiously contrives to compliment his neighbour -by disparaging himself. [Sidenote: E] ‘I am a nervous wretch at sea,’ -says he. ‘I cannot face trouble. Hard words make me frantically angry. -But our friend here has no nerves; nothing troubles him. He is a -peculiar person, always good-tempered, never ruffled.’ But if a man -thinks himself particularly sensible, and is so desirous of being -severely matter-of-fact that—out of what he calls straightforwardness—he -is always on the defensive with - - _Tydeus’ son, bepraise me not much, nor, prithee, upbraid me_, - -the artist in flattery will not adopt this manner of approaching -[Sidenote: F] him. Such cases are met by another device. He will come -and consult him, as a person of superior wisdom, about affairs of his -own. ‘Though,’ he will say, ‘there are others with whom I am more -intimate, I am compelled to trouble you. For where are we to take refuge -when we need advice? In whom are we to put confidence?’ Then, after -listening to what he has to say, he will take his leave with the remark -that what he has received is ‘not an opinion; it is an oracle’. And if -he sees that you make pretensions to being a judge of literature, he -gives you something he has [Sidenote: 58] written himself, and asks you -to read and correct it. When King Mithridates had a fancy for doctoring, -some of his courtiers actually put themselves in his hands to be lanced -and cauterized. This was flattery by deeds in place of words, since he -accepted their confidence as a sufficient voucher for his skill. - - _Of many shapes are means divine_, - -and this negative class of praise requires to be countered with some -craftiness. The way to confute it is by deliberately offering counsel -and suggestion which are nonsensical, and making corrections [Sidenote: -B] which are absurd. If your man objects to nothing, says ‘Yes’ to -everything, and exclaims ‘Good!’ ‘Capital!’ at every item, he exposes -himself as one who - - _The watchword asks, while other are his aims_, - -—those aims being to encourage your self-conceit with his laudations. - -Take another case. Painting has been styled ‘silent poetry’. So there is -a way of praising by silent flattery. The sportsman’s purpose is better -concealed from the game when he pretends to be upon other -business—walking, tending cattle, or tilling the soil. In the same way a -toady drives home his eulogies most effectively when the eulogy is -disguised under some different form of action. It may be by giving up -his seat, or his place [Sidenote: C] at table, when you appear upon the -scene. Or if he is addressing the Assembly or Council, and notices that -some wealthy man desires to speak, he may stop his speech and yield him -the platform. His silence indicates more clearly than the loudest -acclamation that he regards the person in question as a better man and -his intellectual superior. Such persons may therefore be seen taking -possession of the front seats at an entertainment or in the -meeting-hall, not because they claim any right to them, but in order -that they may play the toady by giving up their places to rich people. -Or you may see them begin the discussion at a congress or a -board-meeting, and subsequently give way to ‘superior argument’ and -shift round with the [Sidenote: D] greatest readiness to the opposite -view, if their opponent is a person of influence, wealth, or note. The -clearest exposure of such complaisances and concessions is to be sought -in the fact that it is not to knowledge or high abilities or age that -the deference is paid, but to riches and reputations. When Megabyzus -took a seat at Apelles’ side and wanted to prate to him about ‘line’ and -‘shading’, the painter remarked, ‘Do you see those boys yonder grinding -my mixing-earth? When you were silent, they were all eyes of admiration -for your purple and your jewels. But now that you have begun to talk -about things [Sidenote: E] you do not understand, they are laughing at -you.’ Similarly Solon, when Croesus questioned him about ‘happiness’, -declared that Tellus, an Athenian of humble rank, as well as Cleobis and -Biton, were more favoured by fortune. A flatterer, on the contrary, not -only avers that a king, a rich man, or a man in power, is prosperous and -fortunate; he also declares that he is pre-eminent in wisdom, art, and -every form of excellence. Hence while there are persons who have no -patience to listen when the Stoics describe the sage as at the same time -‘rich, beautiful, noble, and king’, a toady will make out that the rich -man is at the same time an orator, a poet, and—if he so wishes—a painter -and a musician. He makes him out swift of foot and [Sidenote: F] strong -of thew by letting himself be thrown in wrestling and outstripped in -running, as Criso of Himera did in a race against Alexander—much to -Alexander’s disgust when he detected it. Carneades used to say that the -only thing that kings’ and rich men’s sons understand is how to ride; -they receive no proper instruction in anything else. For their teacher -flatters them in school with his praises, and their antagonists in the -wrestling-ring by courting defeat; whereas a horse, who neither knows -nor cares whether you are in or out of office, poor or rich, pitches you -head first if you cannot keep your seat. It was therefore a silly and -stupid thing for Bion to say: ‘If by [Sidenote: 59] eulogizing a field -we could make it bear a prolific crop, would it not be a mistake for a -man to go digging and moiling instead? Neither, then, is it irrational -for you to praise a human being, if your praise is productive of good -fruit.’ A field suffers no injury from being praised, whereas insincere -and undeserved compliment puffs a man up and ruins him. - -On this point we have said enough. The next consideration is that of -candour. - -[Sidenote: B] When Patroclus, on going out to fight, dressed himself in -Achilles’ armour and drove his team, the one thing he let alone and did -not venture to touch was the Pelian spear. So it might have been -expected of the flatterer that, when dressing himself up carefully for -the part of ‘friend’, with its proper tokens and badges, the one thing -he would leave untouched and uncopied would be plain-speaking—a special -attribute, - - _Heavy and huge and stubborn_, - -to be wielded only by friendship. But in his fear that laughter, strong -drink, jest, and fun may mean his betrayal, we find him [Sidenote: C] -putting a solemn face on the business, flattering with a frown and -administering dashes of blame and admonition. Here again, therefore, we -must apply our tests. In a comedy of Menander, the Mock-Hercules comes -in carrying a club which has no strength or solidity, but is merely a -hollow sham. So, I take it, with the flatterer’s plain-speaking. On -trial you will find that it is soft and without weight or vigour; that -it behaves like a woman’s cushion, which, while seeming to offer a firm -support to the head, actually yields it more of its own way. [Sidenote: -D] This spurious candour, with its hollow fullness, its false and -superficial puffiness, is merely meant to shrink and collapse, so as to -induce the person who leans upon it to make himself more comfortable. -The genuine candour of a friend attacks only our misdeeds; it hurts only -out of care and protection; like honey, it merely stings our sores in -cleansing them, its general uses being grateful and sweet. This, -however, is a theme for special discussion. - -With the flatterer it is different. In the first place, when he displays -sharpness or heat or inflexibility, it is in dealing with others than -yourself. He is severe upon his own servants; he is terribly hard upon -the misdeeds of his own relations; he shows no admiration or respect for -a stranger, but treats [Sidenote: E] him with contempt; his scandalizing -is merciless when exacerbating other people. His object is to make it -appear that he detests low practices, and that he would not consent to -abate a jot of his candour in your behalf, or to do or say anything to -curry favour. In the next place, when there is something really and -seriously wrong, he pretends to be completely ignorant and unconscious -of it, while he will pounce upon some little immaterial shortcoming and -take it rigorously and vehemently to task—if, for instance, he sees an -implement carelessly placed, or a fault of domestic management, or -negligence in the cut of your hair or the wearing of your clothes, or -lack of [Sidenote: F] proper attention to a dog or a horse. But should -you slight your parents, neglect your children, humiliate your wife, -despise your relatives, and waste your money, it becomes no business of -his. In such circumstances not a word does he venture to utter, but he -is like a trainer who permits an athlete to get drunk and dissipated, -while he is severe upon him in the matter of an oil-flask or a -scraping-iron; or like a grammar-master who scolds a boy for the state -of his slate and pencil, but pretends not to hear his slips of grammar -and expression. The toady is the kind of man who, in dealing with a -ridiculously incompetent public speaker, has nothing to say about his -matter, but finds fault with his voice-production, and blames him -severely for spoiling [Sidenote: 60] his larynx by drinking cold drinks; -or who, when requested to peruse some miserable composition, finds fault -with the roughness of the paper and calls the copyist a slovenly wretch. -It was so in the case of Ptolemy, when he made pretence to literary -tastes. They would fight with him about some out-of-the-way word or bit -of a verse or point of information, and would keep it up till midnight. -But to his indulgence in cruelty and outrage, to his tambourine-playing -and initiating, not one of [Sidenote: B] all their number offered any -opposition. Imagine a man suffering with tumours and abscesses, and some -one taking a surgeon’s knife and cutting—his hair or his nails! That is -what the flatterer does. He employs his candour upon those parts which -feel no pain or soreness. - -There is a still craftier species, who make their plain-speaking and -fault-finding an actual means of pleasing. When Alexander was once -making large gifts to a jester, envy and vexation drove Agis, the -Argive, to bawl out, ‘How utterly absurd!’ The king turned upon him -angrily and asked, ‘_What_ is that you say?’ ‘I confess,’ was the reply, -‘to being annoyed and [Sidenote: C] indignant when I see how much alike -all you sons of Zeus are in your fondness for flatterers and ridiculous -persons. Heracles found pleasure in his Cercopes, Dionysus in Sileni, -and we can see what a high regard you have yourself for people of the -kind.’ One day when the emperor Tiberius entered the Senate, one of his -flatterers got up and said that, as free men, they were bound to speak -frankly and to treat important interests without reticence or -reservation. When he had thus aroused every one’s interest and had -secured silence and the attention of Tiberius, he said, ‘Listen, Caesar, -to the charge which we all make against you, but which no one dares to -utter openly. You are neglecting yourself, sacrificing your health and -wearing it out by perpetually working and thinking for us, and giving -yourself [Sidenote: D] no rest day or night.’ As he continued with a -good deal more in the same strain, the orator Cassius Severus is said to -have exclaimed, ‘Such plain-speaking will be the man’s death!’ - -These devices, however, are of minor moment. The matter becomes grave—as -meaning ruin to foolish people—when a man is accused of the opposite -disorders to those with which he is afflicted; as when the parasite -Himerius used to scold the meanest and most avaricious plutocrat in -Athens by calling him a reckless prodigal, bent on bringing himself and -his children to starvation; or when, on the contrary, a toady reproaches -[Sidenote: E] a prodigal spendthrift with sordid parsimony, as Titus -Petronius did Nero; or when he urges a ruler who behaves with savage -cruelty towards his subjects to divests himself of ‘all that gentleness -and ill-timed and mistaken clemency’. - -To the same class belongs the man who pretends to look upon some silly -nincompoop as a clever rogue of whom he is afraid and wary. Or if an -ill-conditioned person who delights in perpetual fault-finding and -scandalizing does happen to be led into praising some distinguished man, -he may take him to task and raise objections, for ‘it is a weakness of -yours, this praising [Sidenote: F] of even quite insignificant people. -What remarkable thing has he ever said or done?’ - -Love-affairs are favourite ground for the flatterer to play upon his -victim by further inflaming his passion. If he sees you at variance with -your brothers, or neglecting your parents, or contemptuous towards your -wife, he offers neither remonstrance nor reproach, but actually -intensifies the bad feeling. ‘No: you don’t appreciate yourself,’ or, -‘It is you that are to blame, for always playing the humble servant.’ -But if anger [Sidenote: 61] and jealousy provoke a tiff with a mistress -of whom you are enamoured, in comes flattery at once with a fine blaze -of frankness, and adds fuel to the fire by pleading cause and accusing -the lover of all sorts of unloverlike, unfeeling, and unforgivable -conduct: - - _O ingrate! after all that rain of kisses!_ - -Thus, when Antony was becoming passionately enamoured of the Egyptian -queen, his friends did their best to persuade him that the love was on -her side, and they upbraided him with being ‘cold and supercilious’. -‘The lady has forsaken all that royal state and that life of delightful -enjoyments to go wandering [Sidenote: B] about on the march with you, -like any concubine. - - _But, for thee, the heart in thy breast is past all moving or - charming_, - -and you leave her to suffer as she will.’ It gratified Antony to be thus -put in the wrong; no praise could please him like these accusations; and -unconsciously he became perverted to the standard of the man who -pretended to be reproving him. For candour of this kind is like the bite -of a lascivious woman; while pretending to give pain, it arouses a -provoking sensation of pleasure. - -Though unmixed wine is, generally speaking, a corrective of hemlock, -yet, if you add it to that drug in the form of a mixture, [Sidenote: C] -you make it impossible to counteract the power of the poison, the heat -driving it rapidly to the heart. So, while aware that candour is a -potent corrective of flattery, your rogue actually uses ‘candour’ as his -instrument for flattering you. Bias was therefore wrong in his answer to -the question: ‘What animal is the most dangerous?’ when he replied, -‘Among wild animals, the despot, among tame animals, the toady.’ It -would have been truer to say that, among toadies, those who merely -frequent your bath and your table are tame, while those who thrust the -[Sidenote: D] tentacles of their slanderous and malicious meddling into -bedchamber and boudoir are savage and unmanageable beasts. - -The one method of protecting ourselves appears to lie in recognizing and -never forgetting that our mental being is made up of two parts—one -high-principled and rational, the other irrational, mendacious and -passionate—and that a friend is the unfailing supporter and champion of -the better part—a physician who promotes and watches over good -health—while a flatterer acts as prompter to the passionate and -irrational part, exciting, titillating, coaxing, and divorcing it from -reason by inventing [Sidenote: E] low forms of self-indulgence on its -behalf. There are some kinds of food which yield no benefit to blood or -breath, and put no vigour into muscle or marrow, but simply excite the -sensual appetites and make the flesh flabby and unsound. So with the -advice of a fawner. If does nothing to help sane thought and judgement; -but watch it, and you will find it cosseting an amorous pleasure, -aggravating a foolish fit of anger or provoking an attack of envy, -puffing you up with vulgar and empty pride, encouraging your doleful -dumps, or, where there is a tendency to be ill-natured or mean-spirited -or mistrustful, making the [Sidenote: F] feeling more bitter or shy or -suspicious by constantly suggesting and anticipating evil. For he is -perpetually in wait for some passion or other, which he proceeds to feed -up; and whenever there is a festering or inflammation of your mental -state, you will always find him a kind of bubo, bringing it to a head. -Are you angry? ‘Then punish.’ Do you crave a thing? ‘Then buy it.’ Are -you afraid? ‘Then let us run away.’ Are you suspicious? ‘Then trust the -feeling.’ - -If it is hard to catch him in connexion with such affections as -these—their strength being so overpowering as to baffle the reason—he -will give you a better opening in smaller matters; for he will be just -the same with them. If you are apprehensive [Sidenote: 62] of a headache -or a surfeit, and are doubtful as to bathing or taking food, a friend -will try to check you and will urge you to be cautious, whereas the -toady will drag you to the bath, or ask them to put some novel dish on -the table, begging you not ‘to keep so tight a hand upon your body as to -be cruel to it’. If he sees you inclined to shirk a journey, a voyage, -or a piece of work, he will say that there is no immediate hurry, and -that it will do just as well if you postpone the matter or send someone -else. If, after promising a friend to make him a loan or a present of a -sum of money, you repent, but have your scruples, the toady [Sidenote: -B] throws his weight into the less honourable scale; he corroborates -‘the argument of the purse’, and makes short work of your sense of shame -by urging you to be economical, ‘seeing that you have so many expenses -and so many persons to support.’ - -If, therefore, we are able to perceive our own covetousness, -shamelessness, or cowardice, we shall also be able to see when a man is -a toady. Such he is when he is always playing the advocate to those -passions and ‘speaking his mind’ when we deviate from them. - -Enough having been said upon this topic, we may next proceed to the -question of the practical services rendered. In this [Sidenote: C] -respect the flatterer makes his distinction from the friend a very -obscure and perplexing matter; he always appears so prompt and -indefatigable in his zeal. While a friend’s way, like the ‘speech of -truth’ as described by Euripides, is ‘single’, open, and unaffected, -that of the flatterer - - _Sick in itself, needs antidotes full shrewd_ - -—uncommonly so, indeed, and plenty of them. When you meet a friend, he -sometimes passes on without uttering or receiving a word, and with no -more than a glance or a smile; he simply manifests by his expression, -and gathers from yours, the kindly [Sidenote: D] understanding within. -But the toady is on the run to overtake you, greets you from a long way -off, and, if you catch sight of him and speak to him first, he excuses -himself over and over again, calling his witnesses and taking his oath. -So in the matter of actions. A friend will neglect many a trifle; he is -no precisian and makes no fuss; he does not insist upon serving you at -every turn. But the other is persistent, unremitting, unwearied; he -leaves no opportunity or room for any one else to serve you; he is eager -to receive your orders, and, if he does not get them, he is piqued, nay, -absolutely heart-broken with disappointment. A sensible man, then, may -take these as some indications that a friendship is not sincere and -single-minded, [Sidenote: E] but is like a harlot who forces her -embraces upon you before they are asked for. - -The first place, however, in which to look for the difference is in -promises. It has already been well said by previous writers that a -friend will put his promise in the form familiar in - - _If I have power to achieve it, and if ’tis a thing for - achievement_, - -while a time-server will put it in this: - - _Voice me the thought in thy mind._ - -The comedians present us with such characters: - - _Nicomachus, pit me against the soldier. - I’ll make ripe pulp of him; I’ll make his face - Softer than sponge: if not, then flog me soundly._ - -In the next place no friend will be a party to your actions [Sidenote: -F] unless he has first been a party to planning them. He must first have -looked into the business and helped to put it on a right and proper -footing. Not so the flatterer. Even if you do grant him a share in -weighing the matter and expressing an opinion about it, he is not only -so anxious to gratify you with his complaisance, but is in such dread of -leading you to suspect him of unreadiness to face the action, that he -leaves you to take your course, or only lends spurs to your desire. It -is not easy to find a rich man or a grandee who is ready to say: -[Sidenote: 63] - - _Give me a man, a beggar—nay, no matter, - Lower than beggar, if he means me well— - To put fear by, and speak his heart to me._ - -Like the tragedian, he must have the support of a chorus of friends who -keep his tune, or of an audience who give applause. Merope in the -tragedy advises: - - _Get thee for friends such men as, when they speak, - Yield not; but when a man will for thy pleasure - Make himself knave, lock thou thy door against him._ - -[Sidenote: B] But such persons do the opposite. If, ‘when you speak’ you -‘yield not’, but oppose them for their good, they abominate you; but if -‘for their pleasure’ you are a ‘knave’ and a servile charlatan, they -receive you not merely inside their locked doors but inside their most -secret passions and concerns. The simple kind of flatterer, it is true, -does not aim at so much. What he asks in such important matters is not -to be your adviser, but your minister and servant. But the more crafty -person will stand still—puzzling over the question with puckered brow -and appropriate changes of countenance—but will say nothing. And if you -give your own idea, he will exclaim, ‘How strange! You just managed to -anticipate me. I was about to make exactly your suggestion.’ - -[Sidenote: C] Mathematicians tell us that lines and surfaces, being -mental perceptions and incorporeal, have in themselves no such thing as -bending, stretching, or motion, but that they are bent, stretched, and -changed in position along with the bodies of which they are the -boundaries. So you will discover that, with the time-server, his assent, -his opinion, even his pleasure and anger, are always dependent. Here, -therefore, it is perfectly easy to detect the difference. It is still -more apparent in the manner in which a service is rendered. With the -good feeling of a friend, as with a living creature, its most vital -functions lie [Sidenote: D] deep. It is marked by no ostentatious -display; but very often, like a physician who conceals the fact that he -is doctoring you, a friend does you a good turn by a word of -intercession or by bringing about an understanding, and so consults your -interests without your knowing it. Arcesilaus was a man of this type. -Not to mention other instances, when Apelles the Chian was ill and -Arcesilaus had discovered how poor he was, he came back later with -twenty drachmae. Taking a seat close to him, he exclaimed, ‘There is -nothing here beyond Empedocles’ four elements: - - _Fire and water and earth and the gentle air of the heavens._ - -Why, even your bed is made all askew.’ With that he moved his pillow and -meanwhile slipped the coins under it. When the [Sidenote: E] old woman -in attendance found them and told Apelles in amazement, he laughed and -said, ‘It is that thief Arcesilaus.’[52] - -And here we may note how philosophy produces ‘_children like unto their -sires_‘. Cephisocrates, who had been impeached, was on his trial, and -beside him, with the rest of his friends, stood Lacudes, one of the -coterie of Arcesilaus. The accuser having asked for his ring, -Cephisocrates quietly dropped it at his side, and Lacudes, who noticed -the action, put his foot upon it and hid it. On that ring depended the -proof of the charge. When Cephisocrates, after his acquittal, went -shaking hands with members of the jury, one of them, who had apparently -[Sidenote: F] seen what occurred, bade him thank Lacudes, and gave an -account of the affair, which Lacudes had mentioned to no one. We may -believe that it is the same with the Gods, and that for the most part -they confer their benefits unperceived, it being their nature to find -pleasure in the mere act of bestowing favours and doing good. But in a -deed done by a flatterer there is nothing honest, sincere, -single-minded, or generous. It is a case of sweating, bawling, bustling, -and of a tense look upon the face, intended to convey the impression of -arduous and urgent business. The thing resembles, in fact, an overdone -painting, [Sidenote: 64] which strives to secure realistic effect by the -use of blatant colours and affected folds, wrinkles, and angles. - -He is also offensive enough to relate how the business has meant running -about and anxiety, and he goes on to describe how he has got into -trouble with other people and had no end of worry and some terrible -experiences, until you declare that the thing was not worth it all. Any -obligation thrown in your teeth will cause an unbearable and distressing -sense of annoyance, but with an obligation from a time-server your sense -of reproach and shame is felt at once, from the very moment that the -service [Sidenote: B] is being rendered. A friend, on the other hand, if -he has occasion to speak of the matter, qualifies his account of it, and -about himself he says nothing. For example, the Lacedaemonians once sent -the people of Smyrna some corn at a time of need, and, to their -expressions of admiration of the kindness, they replied, ‘Not at all! To -scrape this together we had only to vote the forgoing of one day’s -dinner for ourselves and our beasts.’ A favour so rendered is not only a -generous one; it is made the more welcome to the recipients by the -thought that no great harm is done to the benefactor. - -It is not, however, by the flatterer’s offensive way of rendering his -services nor by the recklessness of his promises that one [Sidenote: C] -can best recognize the breed; an easier criterion consists in the -creditable or discreditable nature of the service, and in the different -character of the pleasure or benefit. A friend will not, as Gorgias -asserted, expect his friend to render him honest services and yet -himself oblige that friend in many ways which are not honest: - - _’Tis his to share the wisdom, not the folly._ - -Rather, therefore, he will dissuade him also from improper courses. And, -if he fails, there is virtue in Phocion’s answer to Antipater, ‘You -cannot use me both as friend and toady’—that is to say, both as friend -and not friend. We must help a friend in his need, not in his knavery; -in his planning, not in his plotting; with testimony, not conspiracy. -Yes, and we must share in his misfortunes, though not in his misdeeds. -We [Sidenote: D] should not choose even to be privy to the baseness of -our friends; how then to be a party to their misbehaviour? When the -Lacedaemonians, after their defeat by Antipater, were making terms, they -stipulated that, though he might impose any penalty he liked, he should -impose no disgrace. It is the same with a friend. Should occasion call -for expense or danger or hard work, he is foremost in his claim to be -summoned and take a prompt and zealous part; but when disgrace attaches -to it, he will as promptly beg to be spared and left alone. But with the -fawner it is the reverse. In services of difficulty and danger he cries -off, and, if you give him a tap to sound him, his excuse—whatever -[Sidenote: E] it may be—rings false and mean. But in vile and degrading -little jobs, do as you like with him; trample on him; nothing shocks or -insults him. - -Look at the ape. He cannot watch the house like a dog, nor carry like a -horse, nor plough the ground like an ox. He is therefore the bearer of -scurrilous insult and buffoonery and the butt of sport, his function -being to serve as a tool for laughter. Precisely so with the toady. He -is unequal to any form of labour and serious effort, and incapable of -helping you by a speech, with a contribution, or in a fight; but in -business which shuns the light he is promptitude itself—a most competent -[Sidenote: F] agent in an amour, an adept at ransoming a strumpet, alert -at checking the bill for a drinking-bout, no sloven in the ordering of -your dinner, deft at attentions to your mistress, and, if you bid him -show insolence to your wife’s relations or bundle her out of doors, he -is beyond all pity or shame. - -This, therefore, is another easy means of finding him out. Order him to -do any disreputable and discreditable thing you [Sidenote: 65] choose, -and he is ready to spare no pains in gratifying you accordingly. - -A very good indication of the wide difference between our fawner and a -friend may be found in his attitude towards your other friends. The one -is delighted to have many others giving and receiving affection with -him, and his constant aim is to make his friend widely loved and -honoured. He holds that ‘_friends have all things in common_‘, and their -friends, he thinks, [Sidenote: B] should be more ‘in common’ than -anything else. But the other—the false, bastard, and spurious -article—realizes, better than any one, how he is himself sinning against -friendship by—so to speak—debasing its coinage. While, therefore, he is -jealous by nature, it is only against his like that he gives his -jealousy play, by striving to surpass them in grovelling and lickspittle -tricks. Of his betters he stands in fear and dread, we cannot say -because he is - - _Plodding on foot against a Lydian car_, - -but because, as Simonides has it, he - - _Hath not e’en lead - To match the pure refinèd gold._ - -If, therefore, light in weight, surface-gilt and counterfeit, he finds -himself put in close comparison with genuine friendship, [Sidenote: C] -full-carat and mint-made, he cannot bear the test, and must be detected. -Consequently he acts like the painter whose cocks in a picture were -wretchedly done, and who therefore ordered his slave to drive any real -cocks as far from his canvas as possible. In the same way the flatterer -drives away real friends and prevents them coming near. If he fails, -while openly he will fawn upon them and pay them court and deference as -being his betters, in secret he will throw out calumnious hints and -suggestions. And if the word in secret has given a scratch without at -once absolutely producing a wound, he never forgets Medius’s maxim. This -Medius was what may be called the [Sidenote: D] fugleman or expert -conductor of the chorus of toadies who surrounded Alexander, and was at -daggers drawn with the highest characters. His maxim was, ‘Be bold in -laying on and biting with your slanders, for even if the man who is -bitten salves the wound, the slander will leave its scar.’ It was -through these scars, or rather because he was eaten up with gangrenes -and ulcers, that Alexander put Callisthenes, Parmenio, and Philotas to -death. Meanwhile he surrendered himself unreservedly to a Hagnon, a -Bagoas, an Agesias, or a Demetrius, and allowed them to give him a fall -by salaaming to him and dressing him up after the fashion of an oriental -idol. So powerful an effect [Sidenote: E] has complaisance, and -apparently most of all with those who think most of themselves. Their -wish for the finest qualities goes with the belief that they possess -them, and so the flatterer acquires both credit and confidence. For -while lofty places are difficult of approach or assault for all who have -designs upon them, the lofty conceit produced in a foolish mind by the -gifts of fortune or talent offers the readiest footing to those who are -small and petty. - -As therefore we urged at the beginning of this treatise, so we urge -again here; ‘Let us make a clearance of self-love and self-conceit.’ -These, by flattering us in advance, render us more [Sidenote: F] -amenable to flattery from outside: we come prepared. But if, in -obedience to the God, we recognize how all-important the maxim _Know -Thyself_ is to each of us; if we therefore examine our own nature, -training, and education, and observe how all alike fall short of -excellence in countless ways, and how they all contain a large admixture -of weakness in the things we do or say or feel, we shall be very slow in -allowing the flatterer to abuse us at his pleasure. Alexander remarked -that what made him give least credence to those who called him a God was -his sleep and his sexualities, his excesses in those things falling -below his own standard. On our own part we shall [Sidenote: 66] always -discover that at many a point and in many a way our qualities are ugly -or a source of pain, defective or misdirected. We shall see ourselves in -our true light, and find that what we need is not a friend who will pay -us compliments and eulogies, but one who will bring us to book when we -are really doing wrong. But only then. There are in any case very few -with the courage to treat a friend with candour rather than -complaisance; yet among these few it will be hard to find such as -understand their business. It will be easier to find persons who imagine -that they are using candour because they abuse and scold. Yet it is with -plain-speaking as with any other medicine. [Sidenote: B] When it is -given at the wrong time the effect is to upset and pain you to no -purpose. In a certain sense it does painfully what flattery does -pleasantly, inasmuch as unseasonable blame works as much harm as -unseasonable praise. More than anything else it is a thing which drives -a man headlong into the arms of the flatterer. Like water, he turns from -the steep unyielding surface and glides away into the receptive -shallows. Candour, therefore, must be tempered by rational courtesy, -which will divest it of excess and over-severity. The light must not be -so strong that in our pain and distress at the invariable reproving and -fault-finding we turn away to escape discomfort and fly to find shade -with the flatterer. - -[Sidenote: C] In shunning a vice, Philopappus, our object should always -be virtue, not the contrary vice. Some people think they escape being -shamefaced by being shameless; that they escape being rustic by being -ribald; that their behaviour becomes furthest from timidity and -cowardice when they appear nearest to impudence and insolence. Some -plead to themselves that they would rather be irreligious than -superstitious, rather [Sidenote: D] knaves than simpletons. Their -character may be likened to a piece of wood, which, through lack of the -skill to straighten it, they crook to the opposite side. The ugliest way -of refusing to flatter is to give useless pain. Our social intercourse -must be boorishly ignorant of all the rules of good feeling when it is -by being harsh and disagreeable that we avoid any creeping humbleness in -our friendship, just as if we were the freedman in the comedy, who -thinks that, to be properly enjoyed, ‘speech on equal terms’ means -abusive speech. - -Since, therefore, it as an ugly thing when our striving to be agreeable -lands us in flattery, and an ugly thing when, in the avoidance of -flattery, all the spirit of friendly sympathy is ruined by immoderate -plain-speaking; and since we ought to commit neither mistake, but—in -candour as in other things—draw ‘success from moderation’, mere logical -sequence seems to [Sidenote: E] dictate the conclusion to our treatise. - -Plain-speaking, we find, is liable to be, as it were, tainted in various -ways. The first thing is to divest it of its selfish aspect, by taking -the greatest care not to let it appear as if your reproaches were due to -a kind of injury or grievance of your own. When the speaker is concerned -about himself, we regard his words as the outcome of anger, not of -goodwill; as grumbling, not as reproof. For whereas candour is a mark of -friendliness which compels respect, grumbling is petty and selfish. We -therefore respect and admire the person who is frank, while a -fault-finder provokes recrimination and contempt. Though Achilles -[Sidenote: F] imagined he was speaking with but reasonable frankness, -Agamemnon lost his temper; but when Odysseus attacked him bitterly in -the words - - _Madman, thou shouldst have commanded some other, some pitiful - army_, - -he patiently gave way, the friendly purpose and good sense of the speech -causing him to draw in his horns. The reason was that, while the -plain-speaking of Odysseus, who had no private [Sidenote: 67] grounds -for anger, was only for the sake of Greece, the vexation of Achilles was -thought to be chiefly on his own account. Nay, Achilles himself, though -possessed of no sweet or gentle temper, but - - _A terrible man, who must blame, e’en though it be blaming the - blameless_, - -silently permitted Patroclus to give him many such hard blows: - - _Man of no pity, no father of thine was Peleus the horseman, - Thetis no mother of thine; from the green-grey sea wert thou gotten - By beetling crags; so comes it thy heart is void of all mercy._ - -[Sidenote: B] The orator Hypereides used to urge the Athenians to -consider not merely whether he was angry, but whether his anger was -gratuitous. So with the admonition of a friend. When pure from any -private feeling, it is a thing of awe, which we cannot face unabashed. -And if, when a man is speaking his mind, it is manifest that he is -casting aside any wrongs his friend may have done to himself; that it is -other misdemeanours on his part which he is bringing home—other reasons -for which he does not shrink from giving him pain—such candour produces -an irresistible effect, the sharpness and severity of the admonition -being intensified by the kindliness of the admonisher. Doubtless, -[Sidenote: C] as has been well said, ‘it is most of all when we are -angry or at variance with our friends that we should do or devise -something to their advantage or credit’; but we show no less true a -friendliness if, when we think ourselves slighted or neglected, it is on -behalf of other victims of neglect that we give them a plain-spoken -reminder. Plato, at a time when his relations with Dionysius were -strained and dubious, asked for an interview. Dionysius granted it, in -the belief that Plato was coming with a tale of grievance of his own. -The conversation, however, took the following shape. ‘Suppose, -Dionysius, you discovered [Sidenote: D] that some ill-disposed person -had made a voyage to Sicily with the intention of doing you an injury, -but that he could find no opportunity. Would you allow him to leave the -country and get away scot-free?’ ‘Certainly not, Plato,’ said Dionysius: -‘enemies must be hated and punished not only for what they do, but for -what they propose to do.’ ‘Then suppose,’ said Plato, ‘some one comes -here in a friendly spirit, with the intention of rendering you a -service, but that you afford him no chance. Is it a proper thing to cast -him aside with ingratitude and contempt?’ Upon Dionysius asking who it -was, he answered, ‘Aeschines, a man who, in rightness of character, will -compare with any of Socrates’ associates, and whose teaching cannot fail -to set any hearer firmly on his feet. Though he has [Sidenote: E] made a -long voyage for the sake of philosophic intercourse with you, he has -been left in neglect.’ These words stirred Dionysius so deeply that, in -admiration of his kindliness and magnanimity, he promptly embraced Plato -with effusion and proceeded to pay to Aeschines the most distinguished -attentions. - -In the second place, our candour must be cleared of all excrescences, so -to speak. We must allow it no coarse flavourings in the shape of -insulting ridicule or buffoonish mockery. When a surgeon is performing -an operation, a certain ease and neatness [Sidenote: F] should be -incidentally apparent in his work, but there should be no supple -juggleries of the hand in the way of fantastic and risky _fioriture_. In -the same way candour admits of a dexterous touch of wit, so long as it -is so prettily put as to maintain our respect; but impertinent and -insolent buffoonery utterly destroys that feeling. Hence the harpist -chose a polite as well as a forcible way of stopping Philip’s mouth, -when that monarch attempted to argue with him on a question of musical -note. ‘Sire,’ said he, ‘Heaven forbid you should ever become so badly -off as to know more about these things than I do!’ [Sidenote: 68] -Epicharmus, on the other hand, chose the wrong way, when Hiero, a few -days after putting some of his familiars to death, invited him to -dinner. ‘Nay, but,’ said he, ‘the other day there was no invitation to -your sacrifice of your friends.’[53] It was also a mistake for Antiphon, -when the question: ‘What sort of bronze is the best?’ was under -discussion in the presence of Dionysius, to say, ‘That kind out of which -they made the statues of Harmodius and Aristogeiton at Athens.’ No good -is done by the stinging bitterness of such speeches, nor is any pleasure -given by their scurrilous pleasantry. Language of the [Sidenote: B] kind -comes only from a want of self-command—which is partly insolent -ill-nature—combined with enmity. Those who use it are courting their own -destruction as well; they are veritably dancing a ‘dance at the well’s -edge’. Antiphon was put to death by Dionysius; Timagenes was banished -from Caesar’s friendship, not because of any free word he ever uttered, -but because, at dinner-parties or when walking, he would perpetually and -with no serious purpose whatever, but - - _For whatsoever him thought might move the Argives to laughter_, - -advance some charge against his conduct as a friend, merely by way of -pretext for upbraiding him. - -It is the same with the comic poets. Their work contained many serious -and statesmanlike appeals to the audience; but [Sidenote: C] these were -so much mixed up with farce and ribaldry—like good food in a hotch-potch -of greenstuff—that their plain-speaking lost all nutritive power and -use, with the result that the speaker was looked upon as an ill-natured -buffoon, and the hearer derived no benefit from the speech. - -In other cases by all means have your fun and laugh with your friends, -but when you give them a piece of your mind, let it be done with -earnestness and with courtesy. And if the matter is one of importance, -impart a cogent and moving effect to your words by your emotions, -gestures, and tone of voice. - -There is also the question of the right moment. To disregard it is in -all cases a serious mistake, but is particularly ruinous to good results -when you are ‘speaking your mind’. That we should beware of doing -anything of the kind when wine and inebriation are to the fore, is -obvious. It is to bring a cloud [Sidenote: D] over the bright sky, if, -in the midst of fun and gaiety, you moot a topic which puckers the brow -and stiffens the face, as if to defeat the ‘Relaxing God’, who—to quote -Pindar— - - _Unbends the harassed brow of care._ - -Nay, there is actually great danger in such unseasonableness. Wine -renders the mind perilously testy, and tipsiness often takes command of -candour and converts it into enmity. Moreover, instead of showing spirit -and courage, it shows a want of manliness for a person who dare not -speak his mind when sober to become bold at table, like a cowardly dog. - -There is, however, no need to dwell further upon this theme. Let us -proceed. - -There are many who, when affairs are going well with their [Sidenote: E] -friends, neither make any claim nor possess the courage to put restraint -upon them. Prosperity, they think, lies quite beyond the reach of -admonition. But should one stumble and come to grief, they set upon him. -He is tame and humbled, and they trample upon him. The stream of their -candour has been unnaturally dammed up, and now they let the whole flood -loose upon him. He was once so disdainful, and they so feeble, that they -thoroughly enjoy his change of fortune and make the most of it. It is as -well, therefore, to discuss this class also. - -If Euripides asks: - - _When fortune blesses, what the need of friends?_ - -the answer must be that it is the prosperous man who has most [Sidenote: -F] need of friends to speak their minds and take down any excess of -pride. There are few who can be both prosperous and wise at the same -time. Most men require to import wisdom from abroad; they require that -reasoning from outside should put compression upon them when fortune -puffs them up and sets them swaying in the wind. But when fortune -reduces their inflated bulk, the situation itself carries its own lesson -and brings repentance home. There is consequently no occasion for -friendly candour or for language which bites and distresses. When such -reverses happen, verily [Sidenote: 69] - - _’Tis sweet to look into a friend’s fond eyes_, - -while he gives us solace and encouragement. Xenophon says of Clearchus -that in battle and danger there appeared upon his face a look of -geniality which put greater heart into those who were in peril. But to -employ your mordant candour upon a man who is in trouble, is like -administering ‘sharp-sight drops’ to an eye suffering with inflammation. -It does nothing to cure or relieve the pain, but only adds anger to it -by exasperating [Sidenote: B] the sufferer. For instance, when a man is -in health he is not in the least angry or furious with a friend for -blaming his looseness with the other sex, his drinking, his shirking of -work and exercise, his continual bathings and ill-timed gorgings. But -when he is sick, the thing is intolerable. It is more sickening than the -disease to be told, ‘This is the result of your reckless -self-indulgence, your laziness, your rich dishes, and your women.’ ‘What -an unseasonable man you are! I am writing my will; the doctors are -getting castor and scammony ready for me; and you come preaching and -philosophizing!’ So, when a man is in trouble, the situation is not one -for speaking your mind and moralizing. What it requires is sweet -reasonableness [Sidenote: C] and help. When a little child has a fall, -the nurse does not rush up in order to scold it. She picks it up, washes -off the dirt, and straightens its dress. It is afterwards that she -proceeds to reprimand and punish. - -An apposite story is told of Demetrius Phalereus, when he was in -banishment and was living at Thebes in mean and obscure circumstances. -It was with no pleasure that he saw Crates coming towards him, inasmuch -as he expected to hear some plain-spoken cynic abuse. Crates, however, -accosted him gently, and then spoke upon the subject of exile—how there -was no calamity in it, and how little need there was to be distressed, -[Sidenote: D] since it meant getting rid of cares, with their dangers -and uncertainties. At the same time he urged him to have confidence in -himself and his inner man. Cheered and heartened by such language, -Demetrius exclaimed to his friends: ‘Alas, for all that engrossing -business which prevented me from getting to know a man like this!’ - - _To one in grief a friend should speak kind words, - But to great folly words of admonition._ - -Such is the way of a noble friend. But the mean and ignoble flatterer of -the prosperous man is like those ‘ruptures and [Sidenote: E] sprains’ of -which Demosthenes tells us that ‘when the body meets with an injury, -then you begin to feel them’. He seizes upon your change of fortune with -every appearance of delight and enjoyment. If you do require any -reminder when your own ill-advised conduct has brought you to the -ground, it should suffice to say: - - _’Twas not with approval of mine: full oft did I seek to dissuade - thee._ - -In what cases, then, ought a friend to be uncompromising? When should he -exert his candour to the full? It is when the proper moment calls for -him to stem the vehement course of pleasure, anger, or insolence; to put -the curb on avarice; to [Sidenote: F] restrain a reckless folly. It was -in this way that, when the precarious favours of fortune had corrupted -Croesus with the pride of luxury, Solon spoke his mind to him, bidding -him wait and see the end. It was in this way that Socrates was wont to -put control on Alcibiades, to wrench his heart and draw genuine tears -from him by bringing his errors home. Such was the method of Cyrus with -Cyaxares. Such too, when Dion’s splendour was at its height and he was -drawing all men’s eyes upon him by the brilliance and greatness of his -exploits, was [Sidenote: 70] the method of Plato, who bade him keep -anxious watch against - - _Self-will, house-mate of Solitude._ - -Speusippus also urged Dion in his letters not to be proud because he had -a great name among children and women-folk, but to take care and ‘make -glorious’ the Academy by adorning Sicily with piety and justice and the -best of laws. But not so Euctus and Eulaeus, the associates of Perseus. -In his prosperity they followed him like the rest, always assenting, -always complaisant. But when he met the Romans at Pydna, was defeated, -and fled, they attacked him with bitter censure, reminding him of his -errors and oversights and throwing them one after the other in his -teeth, until the man became so utterly sore and [Sidenote: B] angry that -he made an end of both by stabbing them with his dagger. - -This, then, may serve for the general rule as to place and time. - -But opportunities are often offered by a man himself, and no one who -cares for his friend should let these occasions slip or omit to use -them. Sometimes a question asked, a story told, blame or praise of a -similar action in the case of other people, gives you the cue for a -piece of plain-speaking. For instance, the story goes that Demaratus -visited Macedonia at a time when [Sidenote: C] Philip was at variance -with his wife and son. Upon Philip welcoming him and inquiring how far -the Greeks were in harmony with each other, Demaratus—who was his -well-wisher and intimate friend—remarked, ‘It becomes you excellently, -Philip, to be asking about the harmonious relations of Athens and the -Peloponnese, while you allow your own house to be so full of feud and -discord.’ A good hit was also made by Diogenes. Philip was on his way to -fight the Greeks, and Diogenes, who had entered the camp, was brought -before him. Philip, being unacquainted with him, asked him if he was a -spy. ‘Certainly I am,’ he replied. ‘I am a spy upon the short-sighted -foolishness which induces you to come, without any compulsion, and risk -[Sidenote: D] your throne and person upon the cast of a single hour.’ -This, however, was perhaps somewhat too forcible. - -Another good opportunity for admonition occurs when a man has been -abused for his mistakes by some one else and is feeling small and -humbled. A person of discretion will make a happy use of the occasion by -sending the abusive parties to the right about and himself taking his -friend in hand, reminding him that, if there is no other reason for -being careful, he should at least give his enemies no encouragement. -‘How can they open their mouths or say another word, if you cast aside -once for [Sidenote: E] all these faults for which they abuse you?’ By -this means the abuser gets the credit of the pain, and the admonisher -that of the benefit. - -Some are more subtle. They convert their familiar friends by blaming -some one else, accusing others of the things they know that those -friends do. Once at a lecture in the afternoon our professor, Ammonius, -aware that some of his class had not lunched as simply as they might, -ordered his freedman to give his own boy a whipping, on the charge that -‘he must have vinegar with his lunch’. Meanwhile the glance he threw at -us brought the reproach home to the guilty parties. - -In the next place, we should be cautious of speaking plainly to a friend -before company. Remember the case of Plato. [Sidenote: F] Socrates -having handled one of his associates somewhat vigorously in conversation -at table, Plato remarked, ‘Would it not have been better if this had -been said in private?’ ‘And,’ retorted Socrates, ‘would you not have -done better if you had said that to _me_ in private?’ The story goes -that, when Pythagoras once dealt rather roughly with a pupil before a -number of persons, the youth hanged himself, and from that time -Pythagoras never again reproved anyone in another’s presence. A fault -should be treated like a humiliating complaint. The uncovering and -[Sidenote: 71] prescribing should be secret, not an ostentatious display -to a gathering of witnesses or spectators. It is not the act of a -friend, but of a sophist, to use another’s slips to glorify oneself, -showing off before the company like those medical men who perform -surgical operations in the theatre in order to advertise themselves. And -apart from the insult—which has no right to accompany any curative -treatment—we have to consider the contentiousness and obstinacy of a man -in the wrong. Not merely is it the case that—as Euripides has it— - - _Love, when reproved, - Is but more tyrannous_, - -[Sidenote: B] but if you make no scruple about offering reproof in -public, you drive any moral disease or passion into becoming shameless. -Plato insists that, if old men are to inculcate reverence in the young, -they must themselves first show reverence towards the young. In the same -way the friendly candour which most abashes is that which itself feels -abashed. Let it be gently and considerately that you approach and handle -the offender; then you undermine and destroy his vice, since regard is -contagiously felt where regard is shown. Excellent, therefore, is the -notion: - - _Putting his head close down, to the end that the rest should not - hear it._ - -[Sidenote: C] Least propriety of all is there in exposing a husband in -the hearing of the wife, a father before the eyes of his children, a -lover in the presence of the beloved, or a teacher in that of his -pupils. He becomes frantic; so sore and angry is he at being set right -before persons in whose eyes he is all anxiety to shine. When Cleitus -enraged Alexander, it was, I imagine, not so much the fault of the wine -as that he appeared to be humbling him before a large company. Another -case is that of Aristomenes, the tutor[54] of Ptolemy. Once, when an -embassy was in the room, Ptolemy fell asleep and Aristomenes gave him a -hit to wake him up. The flatterers seized the opportunity, and affected -to be indignant on the king’s behalf. ‘If,’ said [Sidenote: D] they, -‘you did drop off, thanks to hard work and want of sleep, we ought to -set you right privately, not lay hands on you before so many people.’ As -the result, he sent Aristomenes a cup of poison and ordered him to drink -it off. Aristophanes also tells us how Cleon tried to exasperate the -Athenians against him by making it a charge that he - - _Abused the country before foreigners._ - -This, then, is another of the mistakes to be avoided, if your desire is -not so much to make a self-advertising display as to make your candour -produce helpful and healing results. - -In the next place, your plain-speaker ought to bear in mind [Sidenote: -E] the principle which Thucydides makes the Corinthians so properly -express, in saying that they ‘had a right to find fault’ with others. It -was Lysander, I believe, who said to the man from Megara, when he was -delivering himself at the Federal Council concerning the interests of -Greece, ‘You need a country to back your talk.’ In any case, doubtless, -you need character for plain-speaking, but in no case is this so true as -when you are admonishing and lecturing other people. Plato used to say -that it was by his life he admonished Speusippus, and the mere sight of -Xenocrates at lecture, and a glance from him, [Sidenote: F] sufficed to -convert Polemon to better ways. When we lack weight and strength of -character the result of any attempt at plain-speaking on our part is to -draw upon ourselves the words: - - _Why physic us, thyself one mass of sores?_ - -Nevertheless it often happens that, though a man’s own character is as -weak as that of his neighbour, circumstances drive him to administer -reproof. In that case the civillest behaviour is to contrive somehow to -imply that the speaker is included in the reproach. In this tone are the -words: - - _Tydeus’ son, what ails us, forgetting our prowess and valour?_ - -[Sidenote: 72] and: - - _But no match are we now for Hector alone...._ - -Socrates’ way of quietly setting young men right was of the same kind. -He would not be taken as being himself free from ignorance, but as -feeling it a duty to share with them in the cultivation of virtue and -the quest of truth. We inspire affection and confidence when it is -thought that, being equally to blame, we are applying to our friends the -same correction as to ourselves. But if, when rebuking your neighbour, -you put on the superior air of a flawless and passionless being, unless -you are much the senior or possess an acknowledged eminence of character -and reputation, you do no good and only make yourself [Sidenote: B] -offensive and a nuisance. For this reason, when Phoenix introduced the -story of his own misfortunes—how in anger he set to work to kill his -father, but speedily repented: - - _Lest the Achaeans should name me ‘the man who murdered his - father’_— - -it was of set purpose, that it might not seem as if, in reproving -Achilles, he claimed to be an impeccable person whom anger had no power -to corrupt. In such cases the moral effect sinks in, since we yield more -readily to a show of fellow-feeling than to one of contempt. - -Another point. Since a mind diseased can no more bear unqualified -candour and reproof than an inflamed eye can [Sidenote: C] be submitted -to a brilliant light, one most useful resource among our remedies is to -add a slight tincture of praise. For example: - - _Ugly is this that ye do, to cease from your valour and prowess, - All ye best of the host! I would not move me to quarrel, - If ’twere some other who thus might hold his hand from the fighting, - Some craven man; but with you is my heart exceedingly anger’d_: - -or: - - _Pandarus, where is thy bow, and where thy feathery arrows? - Where thy glory, the which no man among us doth challenge?_ - -If a man is giving way, there is also a vigorous rallying power in such -language as - - _Where now - Is Oedipus and all his far-famed rede?_ - -or: - - _Is ‘t Heracles, - He who hath borne so many a brunt, speaks thus?_ - -Not only does it temper the harshness of the punishment [Sidenote: D] -inflicted by the reproach; it sets a man at rivalry with himself. When -reminded of the things which stand to his credit, he is ashamed of those -which degrade him, and he finds an elevating example in his own person. -But when we make comparisons with others—with mates, fellow citizens, or -kinsmen—the contentiousness which belongs to his failings is piqued and -exacerbated. It has a habit of retorting angrily, ‘Then why don’t you go -to my betters, instead of harassing _me_?’ We must therefore beware of -belauding one person while we are speaking our minds to another—always, -of course, with the exception of his parents. Thus Agamemnon can say: - - _Truly, a son little like to himself hath Tydeus begotten_; - -[Sidenote: E] or Odysseus, when in Scyrus: - - _But thou o’ersham’st the brilliance of thy race, - Wool-spinner! thou, whose sire was Greece’s hero!_ - -By no means should we use reproof to answer reproof, or plain-speaking -in counter-attack to plain-speaking. Otherwise we quickly produce heat -and create a quarrel. Moreover, such disputatiousness is naturally -regarded, not as a return of candour, [Sidenote: F] but as intolerance -of it. It is better, therefore, to listen with a good grace when a -friend believes he is reproving you. For this, if at a later time some -offence of his own calls for reprobation, is the very thing which gives -your plain-speaking its right—as it were—to speak. When, without bearing -any grudge, you remind him that it has not been his own habit to let his -friends go wrong, but to teach them better and set them right, he will -be the more ready to give in and accept the proffered correction; for he -will believe that it is good feeling and good intention, not anger and -fault-finding, which prompt this payment in return. - -[Sidenote: 73] In the next place, remember the saying of Thucydides: -‘Well advised is he who accepts unpopularity in a great cause.’ It is -the duty of a friend to accept the odium of reproof when questions of -great moment are at stake. But if he is everywhere and always being -displeased; if he behaves to his intimates as if he were their tutor and -not their friend, his reproofs will possess no edge and produce no -effect when it comes to matters of importance. He will have frittered -away his candour, after the manner of a physician who takes a pungent or -bitter drug [Sidenote: B] of a sovereign and costly character, and -parcels it out in a large number of petty doses for which there is no -necessity. No! while a friend will, for his own part, carefully avoid -such unremitting censoriousness, the incessant niggling and pettifogging -of some other person will afford him an opening to attack those faults -which are more serious. Once when a man with an ulcerated liver showed -the physician Philotimus a sore on his finger, the doctor observed, ‘My -good sir, your case is not a matter of a whitlow!’ So when some one is -finding fault with a number of insignificant peccadilloes, the real -friend will be offered the opportunity of saying to him, ‘What have his -tippling and foolery to do with us? My good sir, let our friend here -dismiss his mistress or stop dicing, and he is otherwise an admirable -fellow.’ If a man finds that allowance is made [Sidenote: C] for his -trifling errors, he will take it in good part when a friend speaks his -mind against those which are of more moment. But to be everlastingly -girding, to be bitter and harsh on all occasions, to be continually -meddling and taking cognisance of every action, is intolerable even to a -child or a brother, nay, unendurable even to a slave. - -Again, it is no more true of the folly of our friends than it is—despite -Euripides—of old age, that - - _All things are wrong with it._ - -Our friends have their right actions, and we should keep an eye upon -these no less than upon their errors. We should, in fact, begin by -zealously praising them. In dealing with iron we have first to soften it -with heat before the chilling process [Sidenote: D] can impart to it the -consistency and hardness of steel. So with our friends. First we warm -and fuse them with praise; then a quiet application of candour serves as -a tempering douche. We have, for instance, the opportunity of saying, -‘Is there any comparison between the other conduct and this? Do you see -what good fruit comes of doing the right thing? This is what your -friends expect of you; it is like you, and what nature meant you for. -The other conduct is abominable; away with it - - _To the mountain or to the wave of the surging tumultuous ocean!_‘ - -A sensible physician will always rather cure a sick man with sleep and -feeding than with castor and scammony; and a right-minded friend, or a -kind father or teacher, prefers to use praise [Sidenote: E] rather than -blame as his means of moral correction. For a candid friend to cause -least pain and work most benefit, there is nothing like showing the -least possible anger and treating the offender with polite good feeling. -We must not, therefore, sharply confute him if he denies a thing, nor -try to stop him if he defends himself. On the contrary, we must help him -to contrive some kind of plausible excuse; and, when he refuses to own -to the more discreditable motive, we must ourselves concede him a less -heinous one. Thus Hector says to his brother: - - _Not well is this wrath, foolish man, that thus thou hast stored in - thy bosom_, - -[Sidenote: F] as if his retirement from the battle, instead of being a -dastardly running away, was an exhibition of temper. So Nestor to -Agamemnon: - - _Thou didst yield to the pride of thy spirit._ - -It is manifestly more courteous to say, ‘You did not stop to think,’ or, -‘You failed to perceive,’ than ‘You behaved badly’, or ‘You behaved -unfairly’; to say, ‘Do not be hard upon [Sidenote: 74] your brother,’ -than ‘Do not be jealous of your brother’; to say, ‘Flee from the woman’s -seductions,’ than ‘Stop trying to seduce the woman’. This is the manner -cultivated by curative [Sidenote: *] candour; the other belongs to -vexatious candour. - -Suppose a person is about to do wrong and that we are called upon to -check him—to stem the current of some vehement impulse. Or suppose that -he is inclined to be unready in the performance of duty, and we wish to -brace him up and stimulate him. We should do so by making charges which -put the matter in an outrageously unbecoming light. For instance, in -Sophocles, when Odysseus is working upon Achilles, he makes out, not -that Achilles is angry at the affair of the banquet, but [Sidenote: B] - - _Now that thou hast the Trojan burghs in sight, - Thou art afraid._ - -And when, in answer to this, Achilles is so enraged that he declares he -is off home: - - _I know what ’tis thou flyest—not reproach: - Hector is nigh, and ’tis not well to stay._ - -In inciting to high courses and dissuading from low ones, we may -frighten a man with the reputation he will win: a man of courage and -spirit with that of coward; a man of temperance and self-control with -that of profligate; a man of magnificent generosity with that of miser -and cheeseparer. Where a thing is past cure, we must show ourselves -reasonable; our candour [Sidenote: C] must display more sorrow and -sympathy than blame. But when we are preventing a misdeed or fighting -against a passion, we must be vigorous, inflexible, and insistent. Then -is the right moment for incorruptible affection and genuine frankness. - -To blame an action when it is done is no more than we find enemies doing -to each other. Diogenes used to say that, if you are to be kept right, -you must possess either good friends or red-hot enemies. The one will -warn you, the other will expose you. But it is better to avoid errors by -taking advice than to repent of an error because of abuse. For this -reason [Sidenote: D] we must study tact even in the matter of candour. -As it is the most effective drug that can be employed in friendship, so -it stands in most need of unfailing discretion as to time and moderation -as to strength. - -And, finally, since, as I have said, it is in the nature of -plain-speaking that it should often cause pain to the person under -treatment, we must take a pattern by the medical man. He does not use -his lancet and then leave the part to suffer; he eases it with gentle -lotions and fomentations. Similarly, if our admonitions are to be -tactful, we do not administer a sharp sting and then run away. We adopt -a different strain, and soothe [Sidenote: E] and calm the patient with -courteous language, much as sculptors put smoothness and gloss upon a -statue where they have chipped it with hammer and chisel. If we strike -and gash a man with plain-speaking and then leave him in the rough—lumpy -and uneven with anger—it is a hard matter afterwards to call him back -and smooth him over. This, therefore, is a result against which the -admonisher must be especially on his guard. He must not leave the -patient too soon, nor allow the last words of his conversation to be -such as pain and exasperate his intimate friend. - -Footnote 48: - - i.e. a rough and mountainous island. - -Footnote 49: - - A ‘satyric’ drama was a half-comic interlude or sequel to tragedies. - -Footnote 50: - - In the Stoic sense of _adiaphoria_. - -Footnote 51: - - Since diagrams were often drawn with sticks in the dust. - -Footnote 52: - - The Greek jest does not admit of translation. The same word may mean - both ‘theft’ and a ‘stealthy act’. - -Footnote 53: - - The point lies in an ambiguity which is possible only in the Greek. - The words may equally mean: ‘You issued no invitation when sacrificing - your friends,’ and ‘when sacrificing, you did not invite your - friends’. - -Footnote 54: - - Or what French would call the _gouverneur_. - - - - - ON BRINGING UP A BOY[55] - - -I propose to offer some remarks upon the bringing-up of [Sidenote: 1] -free-born children, as a means of securing soundness of character. - -Perhaps the best starting-point is that at which they are brought into -existence. - -Upon one who desires to become the father of reputable [Sidenote: B] -children I would urge that he should be careful as to his consort. She -must be no mistress or concubine. Base birth, whether on mother’s or -father’s side, is an indelible reproach. It sticks to a man all the days -of his life; it offers a handle to those who are minded to discredit or -vilify him; and it is a wise saying of the poet that - - _When the foundation of a stock is laid - Amiss, needs must the issue be unhappy_. - -A sure fund of confidence for facing the world lies therefore in -honourable birth, and this must be a first consideration with all who -are anxious for a right and proper procreation of children. - -It is quite natural that those whose birth is of base metal which will -not bear scrutiny should tend to be weak-spirited and abject. The poet -is quite right in saying: [Sidenote: C] - - _It slaves a man, stout-hearted though he be, - To know his mother or his father base._ - -It is no doubt equally the case that persons of distinguished parentage -become full of pride and self-assertion. Thus Themistocles’ son, -Diophantus, is reported to have said on many occasions and to many -persons that he had only to wish for a thing and the Athenian people -voted for it. ‘What he liked, [Sidenote: D] his mother liked; what his -mother liked, Themistocles liked; and what Themistocles liked, all -Athens liked.’ - -A most praiseworthy pride was that exhibited by the Lacedaemonians, when -they mulcted their own king Archidamus for condescending to marry a -woman of small stature, their plea being that he intended to provide -them with kinglets instead of kings. - -In this connexion there is one observation which my predecessors also -have duly made. It is that those who approach their wives with a view to -offspring should do so either while wholly abstaining from wine or at -least after tasting it in moderation. [Sidenote: 2] This explains the -remark of Diogenes on seeing a youth in a state of mad excitement: -‘Young fellow, your father begat you when he was drunk.’ - -So much for the question of birth. We will now turn to that of -upbringing. - -Speaking generally, we must say of virtue what it is customary to say of -the arts and sciences—that for right action three things must go -together, namely, nature, reason, and habit. By reason I mean -instruction; by habit I mean exercise. The [Sidenote: B] first elements -come from nature; progress, from instruction; the actual use, from -practice; the consummation, from all combined. In so far as any of these -is defective, character must necessarily be maimed. Nature without -instruction is blind; instruction without nature is futile; practice -without both is abortive. In farming, the soil must first be good; next, -the farmer must know his business; third, the seeds must be sound. -Similarly with education. Nature is the soil, the teacher is the farmer, -[Sidenote: C] the lessons and precepts are the seed. It may be -confidently asserted that all three were harmoniously blended in the -souls of those men whose renown is universal—Pythagoras, Socrates, -Plato, and others who have won imperishable glory. - -Blest indeed, and divinely favoured, is the man on whom Heaven has -bestowed each and all. Yet it would be a great, or rather a total, -mistake to suppose that, when natural gift is defective, no right moral -instruction and practice will lead one to improve his faulty nature in -some attainable degree. For while neglect will ruin an excellent natural -gift, teaching will correct an inferior one. Be careless, and you miss a -thing, however easy: take pains, and you secure it, however difficult. -You have only to glance at a number of everyday facts in order -[Sidenote: D] to perceive how complete is the success of persistent -effort. Drops of water will hollow a rock; iron and bronze are worn away -by the touch of the hands; wood bent by pressure into a carriage-wheel -can never recover its original straightness. To straighten the curved -sticks used by actors is impossible, the unnatural form having become, -by dint of straining, stronger than the natural. - -Nor are these the only examples to prove the efficacy of painstaking. -Instances are countless. Soil may be naturally [Sidenote: E] good; but -neglect it, and it becomes a waste. Indeed, the better it is by nature, -the more hopeless a wilderness will your neglect make of it. On the -other hand, it may be too hard and rugged; yet cultivation will speedily -cause it to produce excellent crops. Is there any tree which will not -grow crooked and cease to bear fruit if left untended, whereas, when -properly trained, it bears well and brings its fruit to perfection? Does -not bodily strength invariably become effete when you take your ease and -neglect to keep in good condition, whereas a feeble physique gains -immensely in strength through gymnastic and athletic exercise? Is there -any horse which a rider cannot render obedient by [Sidenote: F] a -thorough breaking-in, whereas, if left unbroken, it will prove -stiff-necked and full of temper? - -But why dwell longer on such cases, when there are so many examples of -the most savage creatures being tamed and made amenable to hard work? - -When a Thessalian was asked which of his countrymen were the gentlest in -manner, his answer was a good one: _Those who are giving up war._ But it -is useless to multiply instances. Character is long-standing habit, and -it would scarcely be beside [Sidenote: 3] the mark to speak of the -virtues of the mind as the virtues ‘of minding’.[56] One more -illustration, and we will dispense with further elaboration of the -subject. The Spartan legislator Lycurgus once took two puppies belonging -to the same parents and brought them up in entirely different ways. The -one he turned into a gluttonous good-for-nothing, the other into a keen -and capable hunting-dog. Subsequently he got the Lacedaemonians together -and said to them: ‘A great factor [Sidenote: B] in engendering virtue -consists of habit and education—of instruction in the conduct of life—as -I am about to prove to you here and now.’ He then brought forward the -two young dogs, put down directly in front of them a plate of food and a -hare, and let the dogs loose; whereupon the one darted after the hare, -while the other made for the plate. The Lacedaemonians, who were not yet -in the secret, failed to perceive the meaning of his demonstration, -until he told them: ‘Both these dogs come from the same parents, but the -difference in their education has turned the one into a glutton and the -other into a hunter.’ - -No more need be said of habit and conduct of life. We may [Sidenote: C] -proceed to the question of nurture. - -In my opinion mothers should nurse their own children and offer them the -breast; for their nursing will be of a more sympathetic and painstaking -kind, since their love is from the heart, or, as the saying goes, ‘down -to the finger-tips,’ whereas the affection of professional nurses and -foster-mothers—who are paid for it—can only be spurious and factitious. -That it is the duty of the mother herself to suckle and nurse her -offspring is evident from the arrangement of nature, which has supplied -every animal after parturition with the necessary provision of milk. -Here Providence further shows its wisdom, inasmuch as it has furnished a -woman with a pair of breasts, [Sidenote: D] so that, even if she bears -twins, there may be a double source for them to draw upon. Moreover she -will by so acting become more tender and affectionate to her child. It -can, indeed, scarcely be otherwise; the connexion of nurse and nursling -is the means of raising affection to its highest pitch. One can see how -even a brute beast will yearn for its nursling, if you tear them apart. - -If possible, then, the mother should endeavour to nurse the child -herself. But if—as may sometimes happen—she is prevented by physical -weakness, or if other children are speedily on the way, it is at least -desirable not to accept as foster-mother or nurse the first that offers, -but to choose the best possible. [Sidenote: E] To begin with, her -character should be Greek. It is as with the treatment of the body. As -soon as children are born, we have to mould their limbs in order that -they may grow straight and shapely. Similarly their characters ought to -be regulated from the first. For youth is supple and plastic, and it is -while the mind is still soft and yielding that it acts as a mould for -instruction, whereas it is always difficult to knead into shape -[Sidenote: F] anything hard. As it is in soft wax that we make the -impression of a seal, so it is in the minds of those who are still -little children that we imprint a lesson. - -That great thinker Plato is right, it seems to me, in exhorting a nurse -to use discretion in the tales she tells to young children; otherwise -their minds may become infected from the first with folly and -corruption. It is also sound advice which the poet Phocylides gives in -the words: - - _While yet but a child, it behoveth - To learn such deeds as are good._ - -Another point which we cannot afford to omit concerns the slave children -who are to serve the young master and to be brought up with him. Pains -must be taken, first, of course, that [Sidenote: 4] they shall be -well-behaved, but also that they shall talk Greek, and talk it with good -articulation. Otherwise, through rubbing against barbarians and bad -characters, he will pick up something of their vices. The proverb-makers -have good reason for saying: _If you have a lame man for a neighbour, -you will learn to limp._ - -When children reach the age to be put under a mentor, it becomes -especially necessary to take pains in the appointment of such a person. -Otherwise we shall have them entrusted to some uncivilized or rascally -fellow. What actually happens [Sidenote: B] is often in the highest -degree absurd. Respectable slaves are made into farmers, skippers, -traders, stewards, or money-lenders, while any low specimen who is found -to be a glutton and a tippler and of no use in any kind of business is -taken and put in charge of the sons. A fit and proper attendant should -possess the same qualities of mind as Phoenix, the attendant of -Achilles. - -We now reach a topic more important and vital than any yet treated—that -of the right teachers for our children. The kind to be sought for are -those whose lives are irreproachable, whose characters are unimpugned, -and whose skill and experience [Sidenote: C] are of the best. The root -or fountain-head of character as a man and a gentleman lies in receiving -the proper education. As farmers put stakes beside their plants, so the -right kind of teacher provides firm support for the young in the shape -of lessons and admonitions, carefully chosen so as to produce an upright -growth of character. - -As things are, the behaviour of some fathers is contemptible. Before -making inquiry as to the proposed teachers, they put their children into -the hands of frauds and charlatans, without knowing what they are about, -or, maybe, because they are not competent to judge. In the latter case -their behaviour is not so ridiculous, but there is another case in which -it is in the last degree absurd. I mean, when they know, either from -their own [Sidenote: D] observation or from the accounts of others, how -ignorant and [Sidenote: *] bad certain educators are, and yet entrust -their children to them. Sometimes this is because they cannot resist the -fawning of some obsequious flatterer; sometimes it is done to gratify -the whim of a friend. It would be just as reasonable for a sick man to -gratify a friend by rejecting the doctor whose science could save him, -and preferring the ignoramus who will kill him; or for a man to dismiss -the best ship’s-captain and appoint the worst, because a friend asked -for it. In the name of all that is sacred, can any one called a ‘father’ -set the pleasing of [Sidenote: E] somebody who asks a favour above the -education of his children? There was good sense in a frequent saying of -famous old Socrates, ‘If it could be done, one ought to mount the -loftiest part of the city and shout: _Good people, what are you after? -Why in such deadly earnest about making money, while troubling so little -about the sons to whom you are to leave it?_’ We may add that the -conduct of such fathers is like that of a man who is anxious as to his -shoe, while his foot may look after itself. Many fathers go to such -lengths in the way of fondness for their money and [Sidenote: F] want of -fondness for their children, that, to avoid paying a larger fee, they -choose utterly worthless persons to educate their sons, their object -being an inexpensive ignorance. This reminds one of Aristippus and his -neat and witty repartee to a foolish father. Questioned as to what fee -he asked for educating the child, he replied, ‘Forty pounds.’ ‘Good -heavens!’ said the father: ‘What an extravagant demand! For forty pounds -I can buy a slave.’ ‘Very well,’ was the answer: ‘then you [Sidenote: 5] -will have two slaves—your son, and the one you buy.’ - -To put it shortly, it is surely absurd to train little children to -receive their food with the right hand, and to scold them if they put -out the left, and yet to take no precautions that they shall be taught -moral lessons of a sound and proper kind. - -What the consequence is to these admirable fathers, when they bring up -their sons badly and educate them badly, is soon told. On coming of age -and taking rank as men, the sons show an utter disregard of a wholesome -and orderly life, and throw themselves headlong into low and irregular -pleasures. Then [Sidenote: B] at last, when it is of no use, and when -their wrongdoing has brought him to his wits’ end, the father repents of -having sacrificed his children’s education. Some of them take up with -toadies and parasites, wretched nondescripts who are the ruin and bane -of youth; others with haughty and expensive mistresses and strumpets, -whom they ransom from their employers. Some spend recklessly on -gormandizing; some are wrecked upon dice and carousals; some go so far -as to venture on the more daring vices—they commit adultery, and think -death not too much [Sidenote: C] to pay for a single pleasure. Had these -last studied philosophy, they would in all probability not have -succumbed to temptation of this kind. They would have been told of the -advice of Diogenes—who, however coarse in his language, is right in his -facts—‘Go to a brothel, my boy, and you will find that the [Sidenote: *] -expensive article is not a bit better than the cheap one.’ - -In brief, then, I assert—and it would be fairer to regard me as -repeating an oracle than as giving advice—that in these matters the one -and essential thing, the first, middle, and last, is a sound upbringing -and right education. It is this, I say, which leads to virtue and -happiness. - -[Sidenote: D] Other blessings are on the human plane; they are slight -and not worth serious pursuit. Good birth is a distinction, but the boon -depends on one’s ancestors. Wealth is a prize, but its possession -depends on fortune, which often carries it off from those who have it -and bestows it on those who never hoped for it. Moreover, great wealth -is a target exposed to any rogue of a servant or blackmailer who is -minded to ‘aim a purse’ at it. And, worst of all, even the basest of men -have their share of it. Fame, again, is imposing, but uncertain. Beauty, -though greatly courted, is short-lived; health, though highly prized, is -unstable; strength is a thing to be envied, but it falls an easy prey to -disease and age. Let us tell any one who prides himself [Sidenote: E] on -his bodily strength that he is manifestly under a delusion. How small a -fraction is human strength of the might of other animals, such as the -elephant, the bull, and the lion! - -Meanwhile culture is the only thing in us that is immortal and divine. -In the nature of man there are two sovereign elements—understanding and -reason. It is the place of the understanding to direct the reason and of -the reason to serve the understanding. Fortune cannot overcome them, -calumny cannot rob us of them, disease cannot corrupt them, old age -cannot impair them. The understanding is the only thing that renews its -youth as it grows old, and, while time carries off everything else, it -brings old age one gift—that of knowledge. When, again, war comes like a -torrent, tearing and sweeping everything away, it is of our mental -culture alone that it cannot rob us. Stilpo, the Megarian philosopher, -made what seems a memorable answer when Demetrius, after enslaving the -city and razing it to the ground, asked him if he had lost anything. ‘O -no!’ said he, ‘for virtue is not made spoil of war.’ The reply of -Socrates is evidently to the same tune and purpose. [Sidenote: 6] It was -Gorgias, I believe, who asked him his opinion of the Great King, and -whether he considered him happy. ‘I have no knowledge,’ said Socrates, -‘as to the state of his character and culture.’ He assumed that -happiness depended upon these, and not upon the gifts of fortune. - -Not only should the education of our children be treated as of the very -first importance, but I once more urge that we should insist upon its -being of the sound and genuine kind. From pretentious nonsense our sons -should be kept as far aloof [Sidenote: B] as possible. To please the -many is to displease the wise, an assertion in which I have the support -of Euripides: - - _I am not deft of words before the crowd, - More skilled when with my compeers and the few. - ’Tis compensation: they who ‘mid the wise - Are naught, surpass in gift of speech to mobs._ - -My own observation tells me that persons who make a business of speaking -in a way to please and curry favour with the rabble, generally prove -correspondingly dissolute and pleasure-loving in their lives. Nor, -indeed, should we expect anything else; for if they have no regard to -propriety when catering for the [Sidenote: C] gratification of other -people, it is not likely that they will permit right and sound -principles to have the upper hand of their own voluptuous -self-indulgence, nor that they will cultivate self-control rather than -enjoyment. - -[Sidenote: *] And how can children learn from them anything admirable? -Among admirable things is the practice of neither saying nor doing -anything at random; and, as the proverb goes, ‘admirable things are -difficult.’ Meanwhile, speeches made offhand are a mass of reckless -slovenliness, without a notion where to begin or where to end. - -Apart from other faults, extempore speakers drop into a terrible -prolixity and verbiage, whereas premeditation keeps [Sidenote: D] a -speech safe within the lines of due proportion. When Pericles, ‘as -tradition informs us,’ was called upon by the assembly, he frequently -refused the call, on the ground that his thoughts were ‘not arranged’. -Demosthenes, who took him for his own political model, acted in the same -way. If the Athenians called upon him to address them, he would resist, -with the words, ‘I have not arranged my thoughts.’ This, it is true, may -be unauthentic and a fabrication; but in the speech against Meidias we -have an explicit statement as to the advantage of preparation. His words -are: ‘_I admit, gentlemen, that I come prepared; and I have no wish to -deny it. I have even conned over my speech to the best of my poor -ability. It would have been insane conduct, if, after and amid such -harsh treatment, I had paid no regard to what I meant to say to you on -the subject._’ - -That impromptu speaking should be rejected altogether, or, [Sidenote: E] -failing this, that it should be practised only on unimportant subjects, -I do not say. I am recommending a tonic regimen. Before manhood, I claim -that there should be no speaking on the spur of the moment. But when the -ability has taken firm root, it is only right for speech to enjoy free -play as occasion invites. Though persons who have been in prison for a -long time may subsequently be liberated, they are unsteady on their -feet, [Sidenote: F] a protracted habit of wearing chains making them -unable to step out. Similarly if those who have for a long time kept -their speaking under close constraint some day find it necessary to -speak offhand, they nevertheless retain the same style of expression. -But to let mere children make extempore speeches is to become -responsible for the worst of twaddle and futility. There is a story of a -wretched painter who showed Apelles a picture, with the remark, ‘I have -just painted this at one [Sidenote: 7] sitting.’ ‘I can see,’ said -Apelles, ‘without your telling me, that it has been quick work. But my -wonder is that you haven’t painted more than one as good.’ - -While (to return to the original matter in hand) we must be careful to -avoid a style which is theatrical and bombastic, we must be equally on -our guard against one which is low and trivial. If the turgid style is -unbusinesslike, too thin a style is ineffective. Just as the body should -be not only healthy but also in good condition, so language must be full -of strength [Sidenote: B] and not simply free from disease. Keep on the -safe side, and you are merely commended: face some risk, and you are -admired. I take the same view of the mental disposition also. One should -neither be over-bold, and so become brazen, nor yet timid and bashful, -and so become mean-spirited. The rule of art and taste is _The middle -course in all things_. - -[Sidenote: *] While I am still upon the subject of this part of -education there is an opinion which I desire to express. A style -consisting of single clauses I regard in the first instance as no slight -evidence of poor taste, and, in the next, as too finical a thing ever to -[Sidenote: C] be maintained in practice. Here, as in everything else -that caters for ear or eye, monotony is as cloying and irksome as -variety is delightful. - -There is no subject in the ‘regular curriculum’ of which the eye or ear -of a freeborn boy should be permitted to remain uninformed. But while he -receives a cursory education in those subjects in order to taste their -quality, the most important place—complete all-round proficiency being -impossible—must belong to philosophy. We may explain by a comparison -with [Sidenote: D] travel, in which it is an excellent thing to visit a -large number of cities, but good policy to settle in the best. As the -philosopher Bion wittily remarked, when the suitors could obtain no -access to Penelope they satisfied themselves with her handmaids, and -when a man is unable to get hold of philosophy he makes dry bones of -himself upon the remaining subjects, which are of no account. - -Philosophy, then, should be put at the head of all mental culture. The -services which have been invented for the care of the body are -two—medicine and gymnastics—the one imparting health, the other good -condition. But for the weaknesses and ailments of the soul philosophy is -the only thing to be prescribed. It is from and with philosophy that we -can tell what is becoming or disgraceful, what is just or unjust, -[Sidenote: E] what course, in short, is to be chosen or shunned. It -teaches us how to behave towards the Gods, our parents, our elders, the -laws, our rulers, friends, wives, children, and servants: that we should -worship the Gods, honour our parents, respect our elders, obey the laws, -give way to our rulers, love our friends, be continent towards our -wives, show affection to our children, and abstain from cruelty to our -slaves. Above all, it warns us against excess of joy when prosperous and -excess of grief when unfortunate; against dissoluteness in our -pleasures, or fury and brutality in our anger. These I judge to be chief -among [Sidenote: F] the blessings conferred by philosophy. To bear -adversity nobly is to act the brave man,[57] to bear prosperity -unassumingly, the [Sidenote: *] modest mortal. To get the better of -pleasures by reason needs wisdom; to master anger requires no ordinary -character. - -Perfect men I take to be those who can blend practical ability -[Sidenote: 8] with philosophy, and who can achieve both of two best and -greatest ends—the life of public utility as men of affairs, and the calm -and tranquil life as students of philosophy. For there are three kinds -of life: the life of action, the life of thought, and the life of -enjoyment. When life is dissolute and enslaved to pleasure, it is mean -and animal; when it is all thought and fails to act, it is futile; when -it is all action and destitute of philosophy, it is crude and -blundering. We should therefore do our best to engage both in public -business and in the pursuit [Sidenote: B] of philosophy, as occasion -offers. Of this kind was the public career of Pericles, of Archytas of -Tarentum, of Dion of Syracuse, and of Epaminondas of Thebes. Of these -Dion actually attached himself to Plato as his pupil. - -There is no need, I think, to deal at any greater length with mental -cultivation. It is, however, further desirable—or rather it is -essential—that we should not neglect to possess the standard treatises, -but should collect a stock of them, with the result of keeping our -knowledge from starvation.[58] Farmers stock [Sidenote: *] [their -fertilizers], and the employment of books is instrumental to culture in -the same way. - -[Sidenote: C] Meanwhile we must not omit to exercise the body also. Our -boys must be sent to the teacher of gymnastics and receive a sufficient -amount of physical training, both to secure a good carriage and also to -develop strength. Good condition is the foundation laid in childhood for -a hale old age, and, just as our preparations for wintry weather should -be made while it is fine, so we should store up provision for age in the -shape of regular and temperate behaviour in youth. Physical exertion -should, however, be so regulated that a boy does not become too -exhausted to devote himself sufficiently to mental culture. [Sidenote: -D] As Plato observes, sleep and weariness are the enemies of study. - -Upon this topic I need not dwell, but will pass on at once to the most -important consideration of all—the necessity of training a boy for -service as a fighting-man. For this he must go through hard drill in -hurling the javelin, in shooting with the bow, and in hunting. ‘The -goods of the vanquished,’ it has been said, ‘are prizes offered to the -victor.’ There is no place in war for the physical condition of the -cloister, and a lean soldier accustomed to warlike exercises will break -through [Sidenote: *] a phalanx of fleshy prize-fighters. - -[Sidenote: E] ‘Well but,’ some one may urge, ‘while you promised us a -set of rules for the upbringing of free men, it turns out that you have -nothing to say concerning that of poor and common people, but are -satisfied to confine your suggestions to the rich.’ There is a ready -reply to the objection. If possible, I should desire the proposed -education to be applicable to all alike. But if there are cases in which -limited private circumstances make it impossible to carry my rules into -practice, the blame should be laid upon fortune, not upon him who offers -the advice. Though a man is poor, he should make every possible effort -to bring up his children in the ideal way. Failing this, he must come as -near to it as he can. - -After thus encumbering our discussion with this side-issue, [Sidenote: -F] I will now proceed with the connected account of such other -[Sidenote: *] matters as contribute to the right upbringing of the -young. - -And first, children should be led into right practices of persuasion and -reasoning: flogging and bodily injury should be out of the question. -Such treatment is surely more fit for slaves than for the free, whom the -smart, or even the humiliation, of a beating deprives of all life and -spirit, making their tasks a horror to them. The freeborn find praise a -more effective [Sidenote: 9] stimulus to the right conduct, and blame a -more effective deterrent from the wrong, than any kind of bodily -assault. In the use of such praise and reprimand there should be a -subtle alternation. When a child is too bold, it should first be shamed -by reproof and then encouraged by a word of praise. We may take a -pattern by nurses, who may have to make an infant cry, but who -afterwards comfort it by offering it the breast. We must, however, avoid -puffing children up with eulogies, the consequence of excessive praise -being vanity and conceit. - -I have noticed more than one instance in which the over-fondness -[Sidenote: B] of a father has proved to be a lack of fondness. To make -my meaning clear, I will use an illustration. Being in too great haste -for their children to take first place in everything, they impose -extravagant tasks, which prove too great for their strength and end in -failure, besides causing them such weariness and distress that they -refuse to submit patiently to instruction. Water in moderation will make -a plant grow, while a flood of water will choke it. In the same way the -mind will thrive under [Sidenote: C] reasonably hard work, but will -drown if the work is excessive. We must therefore allow children -breathing-time from perpetual tasks, and remember that all our life -there is a division of relaxation and effort. Hence the existence of -sleep as well as waking, of peace as well as war, of fine weather as -well as bad, of holidays as well as business. In a word, it is rest that -seasons toil. The fact is obvious, not merely in the case of living -things, but in that of the inanimate world. We loosen a bow or a lyre, -so that we may be able to tighten it. In fine, the body is kept sound by -want and its satisfaction, the mind by relaxation and labour. - -[Sidenote: D] There are some fathers who have a culpable way of -entrusting their sons to attendants and teachers, and then entirely -omitting to keep the instruction of such persons under their own eye or -ear. This is a most serious failure in their duty. Every few days they -should personally examine their children, instead of confiding in the -character of a hireling, whose attention to his pupils will be more -conscientious if he is to be brought continually to book. In this -connexion there is aptness in the groom’s dictum that _nothing is so -fattening to a horse as the eye of the king_. - -[Sidenote: E] Above all things one should train and exercise a child’s -memory. Memory serves as the storehouse of culture, and hence the fable -that Recollection is the mother of the Muses—an indirect way of saying -that memory is the best thing in the world to beget and foster wisdom. -Whether children are naturally gifted with a good memory, or, on the -contrary, are naturally forgetful, the memory should be trained in -either case. The natural advantage will be strengthened, or the natural -shortcoming made up. The former class will excel others, the latter will -excel themselves. As Hesiod well puts it: [Sidenote: F] - - _If to the thing that is little you further add but a little, - And do the same oft and again, full soon it becometh a great thing._ - -This, then, is another fact for fathers to recognize—that the mnemonic -element in education plays a most important part, not only in culture, -but also in the business of life, inasmuch as the recollection of past -experience serves as a guide to wise policy for the future. - -Our sons must also be kept from the use of foul language. ‘The word,’ -says Democritus, ‘is the shadow of the deed.’ More than that, we must -render them polite and courteous, [Sidenote: 10] for there is nothing so -detestable as a boorish character. One way in which children may avoid -becoming disagreeable to their company is by refraining from absolute -stubbornness in discussion. Credit is to be gained not merely by -victory, but also by knowing how to accept defeat where victory is -harmful. There is unquestionably such a thing as a ‘Cadmean victory’. _À -propos_ I may quote the testimony of that wise poet Euripides: -[Sidenote: B] - - _When two men speak, and one is full of anger, - Wiser the one who strives not to reply._ - -This is the time to remember certain other habits quite as necessary—and -more so—for the young to cultivate as any yet mentioned. These are -modesty of behaviour, restraint of the tongue, mastery of the temper, -and control of the hands. Let us see how important each of them is. We -may take an illustration to bring home the notion more clearly. And we -will begin with the last. There have been those who, by lowering their -hands to ill-gotten gains, have thrown away all the reputation won by -their previous career. This was the case with the Lacedaemonian, -Gylippus, who was driven into exile from Sparta [Sidenote: C] for -secretly broaching the money-bags. Absence of anger, again, is a quality -of wisdom. Socrates once received a kick from a very impudent and gross -young buffoon, but on seeing that his own friends were in such a violent -state of indignation that they wanted to prosecute him, he remarked: ‘If -a donkey had kicked me, would you have condescended to kick him back?’ -The fellow did not, however, get off scot-free, but finding himself -universally reproached and nicknamed ‘Kicker’, he hanged himself. When -Aristophanes brought out the _Clouds_, and poured all manner of abuse -upon Socrates, one of those present asked: ‘Pray, are you not indignant -at his ridiculing you in this manner?’ [Sidenote: D] ‘Not I, indeed,’ -replied Socrates; ‘this banter in the theatre is only in a big convivial -party.’ A close counterpart of this attitude will be found in the -behaviour of Plato and of Archytas of Tarentum. When the latter, on his -return from the war in which he had held command, found that his land -had gone out of cultivation, he summoned his manager and remarked: ‘You -would have suffered for this, if I had not been too angry.’ When Plato, -again, was once worked into a passion with a greedy and impudent slave, -he called his sister’s son Speusippus and said, ‘Go and give this fellow -a thrashing: I am myself in a great passion.’ - -But, it may be argued, it is difficult to reach so high a standard -[Sidenote: E] as this. I am well aware of it. We can therefore only do -our best to take a pattern by such conduct, and minimize any tendency to -ungovernable rage. As in other matters, we are no match for either the -moral mastery or the finished character of those great models. -Nevertheless we may act towards them as we might towards the Gods, -serving as hierophants and torch-bearers of their wisdom and -endeavouring to imitate in our nibbling way as much as lies in our -power. - -As for the control of the tongue—the remaining point to be considered -according to our promise—any one who regards it as of trivial moment is -very much in the wrong. In a timely [Sidenote: F] silence there is a -wisdom superior to any speech. It is apparently for this reason that men -in old times invented our mystic rites and ceremonies. The notion was -that, through being trained to silence in connexion with these, we -should secure the keeping of human secrets by carrying into them the -same religious fear. Moreover, though multitudes have repented of -talking, no man has repented of silence, and while it is easy to utter -what has been kept back, it is impossible to recall what has been -uttered. - -My own reading affords countless instances of the greatest disasters -resulting from an ungoverned tongue. I will content [Sidenote: 11] -myself with mentioning one or two typical examples. When, upon the -marriage of Philadelphus with his sister, Sotades composed a scurrilous -verse, he paid ample atonement for talking out of season by rotting for -a long time in prison. He thus purchased a laugh in others by long -weeping of his own. The [Sidenote: *] story is closely matched by that -of the sophist Theocritus, who endured similar, but much more terrible, -consequences for a similar remark. Alexander had ordered the Greeks to -provide a stock of purple garments, with a view to the thanksgiving -[Sidenote: B] sacrifice on his return from his Persian victories, and -the various peoples were contributing at so much per head. Hereupon -Theocritus observed: ‘I have now become clear upon a point which used to -puzzle me. This is what is meant by Homer’s “purple death”‘—words which -earned him the enmity of Alexander. Antigonus, the Macedonian king, had -but one eye, and Theocritus made him excessively angry by a taunt at -this disfigurement. Eutropion, the chief cook, who had become a person -of importance, was sent to him by the king with a request that he would -come to court and engage him in argument. On receiving repeated visits -from Eutropion with this message, he [Sidenote: C] remarked, ‘I am well -aware that you want to dish me up raw to the Cyclops,’ thus twitting the -one with being disfigured, the other with being a cook. ‘Then,’ replied -Eutropion, ‘it will be without your head, for you shall be punished for -such mad and reckless language.’ Thereupon he reported the words to the -king, who sent and put Theocritus to death. - -The last and most sacred requirement is that children should be trained -to speak the truth. Lying is a servile habit; it deserves universal -detestation and is unpardonable even in a decent slave. - -[Sidenote: D] So far I have had no doubt or hesitation in what I have -said of the modesty and good behaviour of children. But upon the matter -which now calls for mention I am dubious and undecided, my judgement -swaying in the balance first one way and then the other, without finding -it possible to turn the scale in either direction. It concerns a -practice which I can neither recommend nor discountenance without great -reluctance. Nevertheless one must venture a word upon it. The question -is whether a man who is enamoured of a boy is to be allowed to keep -intimate [Sidenote: E] company with him, or whether, on the contrary, -association with such a person is to be tabooed. When I look at fathers -whose disposition is uncompromisingly harsh and austere, and who regard -such association as an intolerable insult to their children, I have many -scruples in recommending it or speaking in its favour. When, on the -other hand, I think of Socrates, Plato, Xenophon, Aeschines, Cebes, and -all those great men who have with one accord approved of love between -males, while they have led youths on to culture, to public leadership, -and to [Sidenote: F] a virtuous character, I change my mind and am -inclined to copy those great exemplars. Euripides is on their side, when -he says: - - _Nay, men may feel passion of other sort, - Love of a just, chaste, virtuous mind and soul._ - -Nor must we omit the saying of Plato, partly serious and partly -humorous, that those who have shown special excellence should have the -right to kiss any beautiful person they choose. The proper course is to -drive away those who are enamoured of the person, but, generally -speaking, give a sanction to those who are in love with the mind and -soul. While we must have nothing to say to the connexions in vogue at -Thebes or in Elis, or to the so-called ‘abduction’ of Crete, we may well -imitate that kind [Sidenote: 12] which is usual at Athens or in -Lacedaemon. - -On this matter it is for every man to hold such convictions as he has -formed for himself. I will now leave it, and, having spoken of the -discipline and good behaviour of the boy, will pass on to deal with the -age of adolescence. I shall do so in very few words, for I have often -expressed my disapproval of those who encourage vicious habits by -proposing to put a boy under the charge of tutors and teachers, whereas, -with a stripling, they would permit his inclinations to range at will. -As a matter of [Sidenote: B] fact, there is need of more anxious -precautions in the case of the stripling than in that of the boy. Every -one is aware that the faults committed by a boy are small matters, which -can be cured without difficulty—such as paying no heed to his tutor, or -trickery and inattention in school. But the sins of adolescence often -reach a flagrant and shocking pitch—stealing the father’s money, -gormandizing, dicing, roistering, drinking, loose passion for young -girls, or corruption of married women. The propensities of young manhood -ought therefore to be carefully watched and kept closely under the -chain. When capacity for [Sidenote: C] pleasure is at its prime, it -rejects control, kicks over the traces, and requires the curb. If -therefore we do not take a firm hold upon this time of life, we are -giving folly a licence to sin. This is the moment when wise fathers -should be most watchful and alert; when they should bring their lads -within bounds by warnings, threats, or entreaties, and by pointing out -instances of disaster caused by devotion to pleasure, and of praise and -good repute won by continence. These two things form what may be called -first principles of virtue, namely, hope of honour and fear of -punishment, the one producing a greater eagerness [Sidenote: D] for the -noblest pursuits, the other a shrinking from bad actions. - -One general rule of duty is to keep boys from associating with vicious -persons; otherwise they will pick up something of their vice. This has -been urged by Pythagoras among a number of dark sayings. Since these -also possess great value as aids to the attainment of virtue, I will -proceed to quote them, adding their explanation. _Do not taste -black-tails_[59]—keep no company with persons who are malignant and -therefore ‘black’. _Do not [Sidenote: E] step over a beam_—justice must -be scrupulously respected and not ‘overstepped’. _Do not sit on a -quart-measure_—beware of idleness, and see to the providing of daily -bread. _Do not clasp hands with every man_—we should form no sudden -connexions. _Do not wear a tight ring_—one should carry out the practice -of [Sidenote: *] life, and not fasten it to any chain. _Do not poke a -fire with iron_—do not irritate a wrathful man (the right course being -to let angry men go their own way). _Do not eat the heart_—do not injure -[Sidenote: F] the mind with worry and brooding. _Abstain from -beans_—avoid public life (office in former times being determined by -voting with beans). _Do not put victuals in a chamber-vessel_—clever -speech ought not to be put into a wicked mind, since speech, which is -the food of thought, is polluted by the wickedness in a man. _Do not -turn back on coming to the border_—when about to die, and with the end -of life close in sight, behave calmly and without losing heart. - -To return to the topic with which we were dealing before this -digression. While, as I observed, boys should be kept from every kind of -vicious company, especially should they be kept [Sidenote: 13] from -parasites. I venture to repeat here what I am continually urging upon -fathers. There is no set of creatures so pernicious—none which so -quickly and completely brings youth to headlong destruction—as -parasites. They are utter ruin to both father and son, filling the old -age of the one and the youth of the other with vexation. To gain their -purpose they offer an irresistible bait in the shape of pleasure. In the -case of rich men’s sons, the father preaches sobriety, the parasite -drunkenness. The father urges temperance and economy, the parasite -profligacy and extravagance. The father says: ‘Be industrious’; the -parasite says: ‘Be idle; for life is only a moment altogether. -[Sidenote: B] One ought to live, not merely exist. Why trouble about -your father’s threats? He is an old driveller with one foot in the -coffin, and we will promptly pick him up on our shoulders and carry him -off to his grave.’ One person tempts him with a drab, or with the -seduction of a married woman, plundering and stripping the father of all -the provision for his old age. They are an abominable crew; their -friendship is a sham; of candour they have no idea; they toady the rich -and despise the poor. They are drawn to young men like puppets on a -string; they [Sidenote: *] grin, when those who feed them laugh; they -counterfeit the possession of a mind, and give a spurious imitation of -details of real life. They live at the rich man’s beck, and though -fortune [Sidenote: C] has made them free, their own choice makes them -slaves. If they are not insulted, they regard it as an insult, their -maintenance in that case being without a motive. If, therefore, a father -is concerned for the obedient conduct of his children, he must keep -these abominable creatures at a distance. And he must by all means do -the same with vicious fellow-pupils, who are capable of corrupting the -most moral of natures. - -While these principles are right and expedient, I have a word to say -upon a human aspect of the matter. I have no desire, all this time, that -a father’s disposition should be altogether [Sidenote: D] harsh and -unyielding. I would have him frequently condone a fault in his junior -and recollect that he was once young himself. The physician mixes his -bitter drugs with syrup, and so finds a way to work benefit through the -medium of enjoyment. In the same way a father should blend his severe -reprimande with kindliness, at one time giving the boy’s desires a loose -or easy rein, at another time tightening it. If possible, he should -[Sidenote: E] take misdeeds calmly; failing that, his anger should be -seasonable and should quickly cool down. It is better for a father to be -sharp-tempered than sullen-tempered; to sulk and bear malice goes far to -prove a lack of parental affection. Sometimes, when a fault is -committed, it is a good thing to pretend ignorance, turning to advantage -the dim sight and defective hearing of old age, and refusing to see or -hear certain occurrences which one hears and sees. We put up with the -lapses of a friend. Is it strange to do so with those of a child? A -slave is often heavy-headed from a debauch, without our taking him to -task. The other day you refused the boy money; there are times to meet -his requests. The other day you were indignant; there are times to be -lenient. Perhaps he has cozened you through a servant; [Sidenote: F] -restrain your anger. Has he borrowed the team from the farm? Does he -come reeking of yesterday’s bout? Do not notice it. Smelling of -perfumes? Say nothing. Such is the way to manage the restiveness of -youth. - -A son who cannot resist pleasure and is deaf to remonstrance should be -put into matrimonial harness, that being the surest way of tying a young -man down. The woman who becomes his wife should not, however, be to any -great extent his superior either in birth or means. _Keep to your own -level_ is a sound maxim, and a man who marries much above him finds -himself, [Sidenote: 14] not the husband of the woman, but the slave of -the dowry. - -A few words more, and I will conclude my list of principles. - -Above all things a father should set an example to his children in his -own person, by avoiding all faults of commission or omission. His life -should be the glass by which they form themselves and are put out of -conceit with all ugliness of act or speech. For him to rebuke his erring -sons when guilty of the same errors himself, is to become his own -accuser while ostensibly theirs. Indeed, if his life is bad, he is -disqualified from reproving even a slave, much more his son. Moreover, -he will naturally [Sidenote: B] become their guide and teacher in -wrongdoing. Where there are old men without shame, inevitably there are -quite shameless young ones also. To obtain good behaviour from our -children we should therefore strive to carry out every moral duty. An -example to follow is that of Eurydice, who, though belonging to a -thoroughly barbarous country like Illyria, nevertheless took to study -and self-improvement late in life for the sake of her children’s -education. Her maternal affection finds apt expression in the lines -inscribed upon her offering to the Muses: [Sidenote: C] - - _In that, when mother to grown boys, she won - Her soul’s well-known desire—the skill to use - The lore of letters—this Eurydice - From Hierapolis sends to each Muse._[60] - -To compass the whole of the foregoing elements of success is [Sidenote: -*] perhaps visionary—a counsel of perfection. But to cultivate the -majority of them, though itself requiring good fortune as well as much -care, is at any rate a thing within the reach of a human being. - -Footnote 55: - - This article is in all probability not the work of Plutarch. See the - Introduction. - -Footnote 56: - - The play upon words (_ēthikas_, ‘moral’ and _ĕthikas_, ‘of habit’) is - not adequately translatable. - -Footnote 57: - - The Greek text is here corrupt; the translation represents the - probable sense. - -Footnote 58: - - The Greek text is again faulty. The sense here given is approximate. - -Footnote 59: - - These maxims were probably in the first instance merely hygienic, or - even popular superstitions, but subsequently they received recondite - interpretations. - -Footnote 60: - - The Greek verse is doggerel, and no attempt is made to better it in - the English. - - - - - NOTES ON PERSONS AND PLACES - - -The following brief notes are intended to supply the bare amount of -information necessary for an understanding of the text. The -pronunciation marks are, of course, added only for the sake of those who -have no Greek. An accent marks the syllable which should bear the stress -in the English pronunciation, and the signs [ă ĕ ĭ ŏ ŭ] and [ā ē ī ō ū], -imply that the vowels are short or long respectively. q.v. = see the -note on that name. - -=Ábaris=: a legendary Scythian or ‘Hyperborean’ priest of Apollo, to -whom miraculous powers were attributed in the way of cures and prophecy. - -=Aeolians=: inhabitants of Aeolis, the NE. coast of the Aegean, with the -island of Lesbos. - -=Aeschĭnes=: (1) a philosopher, pupil of Socrates (hence Aeschines -Socraticus). In the eyes of Plato he was a sophist, for the reason that -he took fees. His character was not of the highest. Like Plato, he -visited Syracuse during the philosophic pose of the elder Dionysius. - -(2) Athenian orator, constant opponent of Demosthenes, who charged him -with being bribed by Philip. Died in exile 314 B.C. - -=Aeschylus=: the first in date and most severe in style of the three -great Attic tragedians, 525-466 B.C. A master of condensed and sonorous -language and of powerful situations. - -=Aesop=: the famous writer (or promulgator) of fables, _c._ 620-564 B.C. -Said to have been an emancipated slave, who spent some time at the court -of Croesus and was sent by him on a mission to Delphi to distribute -largess. Practically nothing definite is known of him. His fables were -most probably of Indo-Persian origin. Those which now pass under his -name are a comparatively late compilation from various sources. - -=Agésilāus=: Agesilaus II, king of Sparta, 398-361 B.C.; the most -important man in the Greek world of his day. His wars were numerous, the -most important being with the Thebans. His character was noble, his -ability great, but his physique and appearance poor. - -=Agis=: (1) Agis II, king of Sparta, 427-399 B.C.; commander against the -Athenians in the Peloponnesian War, his greatest exploit being the -victory of Mantinea. - -(2) Base and toadying poet of Argos, who accompanied Alexander into -Asia. The histories of the expedition agree with Plutarch as to his -character. - -=Alcibíades=: a handsome noble of Athens; a type of ostentatious, -ambitious, and unscrupulous brilliancy. After a measure of military and -political prominence he was banished from Athens for sacrilege (415 -B.C.). Becoming hostile to his country he first found a home at Sparta, -thence migrated to Asia Minor and joined the Persian satrap, -Tissaphernes, whom he endeavoured to bring over to the Athenian side as -a means to his own recall. He returned to Athens for a brief space in -407 B.C., then removed to Thrace, and thence again to the Persian -satrap. - -=Alcméōn=: son of Amphiaraus (q.v.), who avenged his father by putting -to death his mother Eriphyle. - -=Alexander=: (1) the Great, of Macedon. - -(2) of Pherae, a despot who dominated Thessaly from 369 B.C. A cruel -tyrant, assassinated through the agency of his wife. - -=Alexis=: poet of the ‘Middle Comedy’, who had migrated from South Italy -to Athens. Plutarch says that he lived to the age of 106, and Suidas -that his plays numbered 245. - -=Alyáttes=: king of Lydia and father of Croesus, carried on wars with -the Greeks of the Aegean coast of Asia Minor and had apparently some -designs upon the islands. - -=Amásis=: an insurgent Egyptian general who secured the throne (569 -B.C.). His rule was beneficent and prosperous, and he cultivated the -friendship of the Greeks, handing over to them the town of Naucratis (q. -v.). When reproached with his humble origin he converted his bronze -foot-pan into the effigy of a deity by way of instructive parable. He -was visited by Solon and had amicable relations with Croesus. - -=Ammónius=: Peripatetic philosopher from Attica, teacher of Plutarch, -who speaks elsewhere of his great erudition. - -=Amphiaráus=: legendary seer of Argos, who accompanied the ‘Seven’ in -their expedition against Thebes. A pious and just man, who was led into -this false step by the persuasions of his wife, who had been bribed. - -=Amphíctyons=: members of a religious Council meeting at Delphi and -representing the older Greek communities. - -=Amphídămas=: ‘hero’ (i. e. demigod) of Chalcis in Euboea, conceived as -a historical personage. - -=Amphitrítë=: wife of Poseidon and queen-goddess of the sea. - -=Anacharsis=: Scythian prince (of N. Thrace). To Greek literature he is -the type of the observant and critical visitor from abroad. A pattern of -the simple life and direct thinking. Said to have visited Athens about -600 B.C. - -=Anaxarchus=: an easy-going and witty philosopher of the school of -Democritus (q. v.); in the suite of Alexander on his Asiatic expedition. - -=Antígŏnus=: a general of Alexander. On the partition of the empire he -received Phrygia, Lycia, and Pamphylia, but afterwards extended his rule -over all the Asiatic portion. He fell before a combination of the other -Diadochi in 301 B.C. - -=Antímăchus=: epic poet of Colophon, who wrote at great length on the -story of Thebes. He also composed a voluminous elegy on ‘Lyde’. Both -pieces were crammed with mythological and other learning, and Plutarch -appears to treat him as a type of the diffuse. He was a contemporary of -Plato. - -=Antípăter=: (1) regent of Macedonia during the Asiatic expedition of -Alexander and after his death (334-320 B.C.). A war with a Greek league -headed by Athens ended in the submission of the latter. - -(2) A Stoic philosopher of Tyre; a friend of Cato the younger, about the -middle of the first century B.C. - -=Antiphōn=: several persons were so named, e. g.: - -(1) an orator of the fifth century B.C. - -(2) An Athenian tragic poet, put to death by the elder Dionysius at -Syracuse. - -(3) A sophist, epic poet, and antagonist of Socrates. - -=Apéllēs=: (1) of Colophon or Cos, _fl._ _c._ 335-305 B.C. The greatest -painter of antiquity, especially favoured by Alexander the Great. His -maxim for draughtsmen _nulla dies sine linea_ is famous. - -(2) Of Chios, apparently unknown beyond Plutarch. - -=Appius Claudius= (=Caecus=): Roman censor 312 B.C., originator of the -Appian Way. - -=Aráspēs=: a Mede, friend of Cyrus, who became enamoured of Panthea (q. -v.). - -=Arcĕsiláus=: latter part of third century B.C.; first a disciple of -Theophrastus (q. v.), but took an independent line in philosophy as -founder of the sceptical New Academy. A man of amiable character and a -wit. - -=Archeláus=: king of Macedonia 413-399 B.C.; a lover of art and -literature and a patron of Euripides and other Athenian men of letters. - -=Archidámus=: Archidamus II, king of Sparta, 469-427 B.C. There were -several other kings of the name. - -=Archílŏchus=: of Paros, _fl._ _c._ 710-675 B.C. A lyrist of whom only -fragments are extant; particularly famous for his iambic lampoons. - -=Archimédes=: the Newton of antiquity; an eminent scientist of Syracuse -287-212 B.C.; student of astronomy, applied mathematics, and -engineering. He served as mechanical engineer in defending his city from -the Romans, by whose soldiers he was killed in ignorance. - -=Archytas=: of Tarentum, in the early part of the fourth century B.C., -noted as a mathematician and philosophic statesman of the Pythagorean -order. Both in generalship and civil business of state he was eminently -successful and was trusted with extraordinary powers. - -=Arēs=: the Greek War-God, answering generally to the Roman Mars. - -=Arȋdaeus= (=Arrhidaeus=): (1) feeble half-witted king of Macedonia -after his brother Alexander’s death. - -(2) A general of Alexander, joint regent in 321 B.C., afterwards -governor on the Hellespont. - -=Aríōn=: _c._ 600 B.C.; the famous bard and harp-player of Lesbos, and -supposed inventor of the dithyramb. His favourite abode was at the court -of Periander. - -=Aristarchus=: the prince of Greek grammarians and critics; flourished -at Alexandria 181-146 B.C. Chiefly known for his commentaries on the -language and matter of Homer, and his recension of the divergent -manuscripts. - -=Aristeides= (=Aristídes=): with the sobriquet of ‘the Just’; a noble of -Athens, statesman and general, who figures in the stirring times of the -war with Persia. Died _c._ 470 B.C. - -=Aristíppus=: of Cyrene, disciple, but not imitator, of Socrates. A -student and teacher of ethics, and founder of the Cyrenaic philosophy -and its cult of pleasure: _fl._ _c._ 380-366 B.C. For a time he was at -the court of Dionysius (q. v.) of Syracuse. - -=Arísto=: (1) the chief bearer of the name was a philosopher who became -head of the Peripatetic school about 230 B.C. Anciently considered a -writer of more elegance than weight. - -(2) A son of Sophocles, and probably himself a tragedian. - -=Aristómĕnes=: practically regent of Egypt from 202 B.C.; a sound -adviser of the young Ptolemy Epiphanes (q. v.), who put him to death for -his frankness in 192 B.C. - -=Aristóphănes=: of Athens, 444-380 B.C.; by far the greatest comic poet -of antiquity. His comedy was of the ‘Old’, or personal-political type. -Eleven of his plays are extant. - -=Arístŏphōn=: painter, brother of Polygnotus (who _fl._ _c._ 420 B.C.). - -=Aristotle=: of Stageira, but commonly domiciled in Athens or in -Macedonia. Pupil of Plato and subsequently tutor of Alexander. Founder -of the Peripatetic school, with its head-quarters in the Lyceum (q. v.). -His whole tone of mind is strikingly unlike that of his teacher, being -eminently precise, logical, and scientific. His writing is without -literary charm. He aimed at sound and comprehensive knowledge as the -basis of right principles in society, conduct, and the arts (384-322 -B.C.). - -=Asclépius=: (= Aesculapius), the Greek ‘hero’ of medicine, converted by -legend into a son of Apollo and ultimately into a god. - -=Atreides= (=Atrídes=): = ‘son of Atreus’, a title of Agamemnon and -Menelaus. - -=Áttălus= (brother of Eumenes): Attalus Philadelphus, king of Pergamus, -allied with the Romans in the middle of the second century B.C. -Philopoemen was his controlling minister. - -=Bacchýlȋdes=: lyric poet of Ceos, _fl._ _c._ 470 B.C., principally at -the court of Hiero of Syracuse. In general he may be called a smoother -and weaker Pindar. - -=Bagóas=: a handsome young eunuch of Darius, afterwards taken into the -service and affections of Alexander. - -=Báthycles=: an artist in metal-work, of uncertain date, but probably to -be placed in the early part of the age of the Seven Sages. - -=Bato=: comic poet of Athens, _fl._ _c._ 280 B.C.; satirized -philosophers. - -=Bias=: of Priene; precise date unknown, but _fl._ _c._ 550 B.C. He is -invariably included in the list of the Seven Sages. - -=Biōn=: _fl._ _c._ 250 B.C., a philosopher from Olbia on the Black Sea, -who settled at Athens, tried various systems, and ended by being a -Peripatetic. He was noted for his keen sententious sayings, but was of -dissolute character. Has been called ‘the Greek Voltaire’. - -=Brīséïs=: captive woman assigned to Achilles, but taken from him by -Agamemnon when he surrendered Chryseis. - -=Busírites=: the people of Busiris (modern Abousir), about the middle of -the Delta; one of the traditional birthplaces of Osiris. - -=Calchas=: the seer of the Achaean army before Troy. - -=Callísthĕnes=: philosopher and rhetorician; accompanied Alexander into -Asia, where he used over-bold language in reproving him. Put to death -328 B.C. He wrote an account of the expedition and other historical -works. - -=Calýpso=: nymph, on whose island the shipwrecked Odysseus was detained -for seven years. - -=Carnĕădes=: of Cyrene, 213(?)-129 B.C.; a student of Stoicism, but -leader of the Academics. He was ambassador on behalf of Athens (155 -B.C.) to Rome, where he delivered striking discourses on ethics. His -cardinal doctrine was the ‘withholding of assent’ to doctrines. - -=Cato=: (1) the elder (or ‘the Censor’), 234-149 B.C. The type of severe -old-fashioned Roman morality; soldier, statesman, orator, and writer. - -(2) The younger (or ‘Uticensis’), 95-46 B.C.; modelled himself on his -great-grandfather in respect of the moral and simple life, but was much -inferior in gifts. Committed suicide 46 B.C., when the struggle against -the domination of Julius Caesar had become hopeless. - -=Cĕbēs=: of Thebes, a pupil of Socrates and a _persona_ in Plato’s -_Phaedo_. He is chiefly known for his (if it is his) symbolic picture or -‘table’ of human life. - -=Cĕrămeicus (-í-)=: a suburb without, and a broad street within, the -west walls of Athens. - -=Cercópes=: mythical gnomes, mischievous and thievish, who annoyed -Heracles by their monkey-like tricks. - -=Chábrȋas=: Athenian commander at various times between 392 and 357 -B.C., gaining some successes by land and sea against the Spartans. An -able tactician, adventurous, but of somewhat dissolute life. - -=Chalcis=: chief town of Euboea (Negropont), once a most important -commercial centre. - -=Charēs=: Athenian general, of whose various operations we have records -for 367-333 B.C. A man of little principle. He effected little against -the Macedonians, and often followed independent and useless lines of -action. - -=Chármȋdes=: uncle of Plato, who names one of his Socratic dialogues -after him. At the supposed date he was a beautiful and charming youth, -and the discussion is upon ‘self-control’. - -=Chīlōn=: of Lacedaemon: _fl._ _c._ 600-570 B.C. Poet and coiner of -maxims, and shrewd man of affairs. - -=Chryséïs=: captive woman assigned to Agamemnon; surrendered by him at -the bidding of Apollo, in order to check a pestilence. - -=Cimōn=: son of Miltiades, became prominent as a commander against the -Persians in 477 B.C. His chief exploit was the victory of Eurymedon, 466 -B.C. A handsome, liberal, affable, but somewhat self-indulgent person. - -=Cīnésias=: Athenian dithyrambic poet, much satirized by Aristophanes -and others. His verse, music, and character appear all to have been of -an inferior order. - -=Claudia=: Roman maiden, who, in full vindication of her chastity, was -enabled to move the vessel containing the image of Cybele when it stuck -fast in the Tiber. - -=Cleánthes=: Stoic philosopher, pupil and successor of Zeno (q. v.) 263 -B.C. The only fragment of his writing still extant is from a Hymn to -Zeus. - -=Cleárchus=: (1) of Heraclea on the Black Sea; availed himself of -faction to make himself despot and tyrant (365 B.C.). Despite the -precautions described by Plutarch he was assassinated in 353 B.C. - -(2) Of Sparta, leader of the 10,000 Greeks in the expedition of Cyrus -the Younger against Babylon; decoyed and put to death by the Persians, -401 B.C. The retreat was led by Xenophon (q.v.). - -=Cleisthĕnes=: Athenian noble, who adopted the popular cause and made -important democratic changes in the constitution; _fl._ from 510 B.C. - -=Cleitus= (=Clītus=): a Macedonian commander under Alexander, whose life -he saved at the battle of Granícus (334 B.C.). He was killed (328 B.C.) -by Alexander with a spear-thrust, after a quarrel at a carousal, in -which he had spoken with excessive freedom to his chief. - -=Cleobulínë=: daughter (as the name implies) of Cleobulus (q.v.). Though -her father is said to have named her Eumetis (‘sagacious’), the word may -be suspected of being an afterthought. - -=Cleobúlus=: _c._ 610-560 B.C. A citizen of Lindus in Rhodes, who became -its despot. His position may have been similar to that of Pittacus -(q.v.). - -=Cleómĕnes=: Cleomenes III, high-minded king of Sparta, 240-222 B.C. On -his defeat by the Achaeans he fled to Ptolemy Euergetes, with whom he -was in alliance. The next Ptolemy (Philopator) suspected and imprisoned -him. - -=Cleōn=: a tanner of Athens; an able but coarse-grained leader of the -popular party 428-422 B.C. A special enemy of Aristophanes (q.v.), whose -fiercest political attacks are delivered against him. A self-sufficient -amateur in military operations, in one of which he was slain. - -=Clódius=: P. Clodius Pulcher; a daring and unscrupulous person, who -became quaestor in 61 B.C. and tribune of the plebs in 59 B.C. The -notorious and relentless enemy of Cicero. Killed by Milo on the high -road 52 B.C. - -=Colónus=: a suburb of Athens outside the north wall, with a small hill, -grove, and sanctuary. - -=Cólophōn=: Greek town of Asia Minor, near the Aegean coast, about ten -miles north of Ephesus. - -=Cornelia=: daughter of Scipio Africanus; the famous ‘mother of the -Gracchi’; the type of matronly virtue, dignity, cultivation, and high -example. - -=Crátĕrus=: a noble type of Macedonian; one of Alexander’s generals. -After the death of his chief (323 B.C.) he became colleague with -Antipater in the Graeco-Macedonian portion of the empire. See also under -Eumenes. - -=Cratēs=: of Thebes; pupil of Diogenes (q.v.) at Athens; _fl._ _c._ 320 -B.C. A Cynic philosopher in practice as well as theory, he renounced his -wealth and led the simple life in a cheerful manner. A philosophic -writer and a tragic poet. - -=Croesus=: king of Lydia 560-546 B.C. A wealthy and powerful ruler, who -made war upon the Persians when their empire was growing rapidly under -Cyrus. Was defeated and carried off in the train of the conqueror. While -in power he was in friendly or hostile relations with various Greek -states, and was particularly noted for his liberality to the Delphian -oracle. Whether Solon ever actually had the famous interview with -Croesus is chronologically doubtful, but it is not impossible. - -=Cyáxares=: king of Media, appears in Xenophon’s _Cyropaedia_ as uncle -of Cyrus the Great, but the whole book is something of a romance. - -=Cýpsĕlus=: father of Periander, established himself as despot of -Corinth _c._ 656 B.C. His name was commonly associated with _cypsele_ -(‘chest’). The designs upon him in his infancy were those of a -Corinthian noble house, and were made in consequence of an oracle -foretelling danger from the child. - -=Cyrus=: (1) the elder: the famous Persian monarch, founder of the -empire, and subjugator of Babylon. The stories told of him in the -_Cyropaedia_ of Xenophon are largely romance. - -(2) the younger: satrap of Lydia, Phrygia, &c., who sought, but failed, -to dispossess his brother Artaxerxes with the assistance of a Greek -force (401 B.C.). This was the expedition related in Xenophon’s -_Anabasis_. - -=Daphnūs=: a river running into the Corinthian Gulf on the north side -not far from the entrance. - -=Dāríus=: (1) Darius I; strong and able king of Persia (521-485 B.C.), -previously satrap under Cyrus the Great. This is the Darius mentioned in -connexion with Gobryas. - -(2) Darius II (Ochus or Nothus), or Darius the Younger, a weak monarch -endangered by perpetual rebellions, 424-405 B.C. - -(3) Darius Codomannus, overthrown by Alexander. Died 330 B.C. - -=Délos=: central island of the south half of the Aegean, with a temple -of Apollo, the gathering-place of a great religious confederacy of -Ionians. - -=Dēmarátus=: of Corinth, in friendly relations with Philip and a -mediator between him and Alexander after their quarrel in 337 B.C. - -=Dēmétrius=: (1) Demetrius I (or Poliorcetes), king of Macedonia. His -father Antigonus, king of Asia, sent him in 307 B.C. to annex Greece, -then under Cassander and Ptolemy. It was at this time that he took -Megara and met with Stilpo (q. v.). - -(2) Demetrius Phaléreus: Athenian orator and writer (345-283 B.C.); an -able and cultivated man, put in charge of Athens by the Macedonians, 317 -B.C. First highly honoured, then expelled, he made his way to Thebes and -subsequently to Alexandria. - -(3) The name of several Macedonian officers in the army of Alexander. - -=Dēmócrȋtus=: _c._ 460-360 B.C. Of Abdēra in Thrace. A great traveller -and student, who developed (though he did not invent) the ‘Atomic -Theory’. Ethically his aim was cheerfulness of mind (hence ‘the laughing -philosopher’). His character was of the highest for truth and -simplicity. - -=Dicaeárchus=: philosopher from Massana in Sicily; writer on history and -geography. A follower of Aristotle, _fl._ _c._ 300 B.C. - -=Díŏcles=: the narrator of the Dinner of the Seven Sages: professional -seer, and interpreter and expiator of omens and dreams. Nothing is known -of such a person outside Plutarch. - -=Diógĕnes=: (1) the Cynic philosopher of Sinope, who migrated to Athens, -and after being captured by pirates was sold as a slave to a Corinthian. -Whether or not he ever lived in the famous (earthenware) ‘tub’ is -doubtful. He was distinguished for his plainness of life, his shrewd -good sense, his independence, and his caustic tongue. - -(2) Tragic poet of Athens, _c._ 404 B.C. - -=Diōn=: of Syracuse, brother-in-law of the elder Dionysius (q. v.). On -the visit of Plato to Sicily he became a disciple of that philosopher. -The younger Dionysius resented his reputation and his harshness. Dion -therefore removed to Athens and other parts of Greece, whence he -returned with a force, expelled Dionysius, and was himself appointed -practically dictator. Assassinated 353 B.C. - -=Dionysius=: (i) the elder: despot of Syracuse (‘sole general’) 405-367 -B.C. He extended its power over a great part of Sicily, and strongly -fortified the city itself. In the end he became a veritable tyrant. Like -many other despots he affected literature and philosophy, and himself -wrote bad verses. After inviting Plato to Syracuse he quarrelled with -and dismissed that philosopher. - -(2) the younger, who succeeded his father. For a time he was under the -influence of Dion (q.v.) assisted by Plato. Of weaker character and more -licentious than his father, he was compelled to abandon Syracuse after a -rule of eleven years. Insecurely restored ten years later he was again -driven out by Timoleon (343 B.C.). The remainder of his life was spent -in poverty at Corinth, where he is said to have taught an elementary -school. - -=Dōdóna=: in Epirus, near the modern Janina; a very ancient seat of the -worship of Zeus. - -=Dolōn=: a Trojan in the _Iliad_, who undertakes to penetrate the -Achaean camp as a spy, but is slain in the attempt. - -=Dryópians=: a people of Central Greece. - -=Elephantínë= = Djesiret-el-Sag; a garrisoned island in the Nile (First -Cataract) opposite the modern Assouan; the frontier town of Egypt -towards Ethiopia. - -=Empédŏcles=: Sicilian physical and practical philosopher of Acragas (= -Girgenti); _fl._ _c._ 450 B.C. His studies of nature specially qualified -him for the cure or ‘purification’ of epidemics due to insanitary -conditions. His travels took him to Athens and other parts of Greece. -The legend went that he threw himself into the crater of Etna. - -=Eōs=: = Aurora, dawn-goddess; wife of Tithonus; mother of Memnon, the -opponent of Achilles. - -=Epáminōndas=: a type of patriotism, particularly to his compatriot -Plutarch. The greatest of Theban commanders and statesmen, especially -famous for his victory over the Spartans at Leuctra (371 B.C.). So far -as he applied any philosophy to life, it was that of Pythagoras. - -=Éphŏrus=: historian of Cumae, _fl._ _c._ 340 B.C. His history, once -very famous and much discussed, covered a period of 750 years. - -=Epichármus=: _c._ 540-450 B.C.; the great comic poet of Sicily, chiefly -associated with the court of Hiero I (q.v.) at Syracuse. - -=Epicúrus=: 342-270 B.C. Athenian philosopher and founder of the -Epicurean school, of which the aim was ‘peace of mind’ or ‘freedom from -emotional disturbance’. His own life (as his tenets required) was simple -and wholesome, and the self-indulgence of the sect in later days was -either a parody or a misconception of his teachings. A voluminous writer -on physics and ethics, but with a bad style. - -=Epiménȋdes=: priest-prophet and bard of Crete, with peculiar knowledge -of medicine and methods of purification. Many fables were current -concerning him (e.g. of his sleep of fifty-seven years). He was called -in by the Athenians (_c._ 596 B.C.) to cleanse their city of a plague. - -=Epimétheus=: brother of Prometheus (q.v.). The name was taken to mean -‘After-thinker’, and hence arose a notion that he ‘thought too late’. - -=Erasístrătus=: a very distinguished physician in the earlier part of -the third century B.C. He practised and taught in Syria and Alexandria. -An eminent student of anatomy. - -=Eratósthĕnes=: librarian of Alexandria under the Ptolemies; a writer on -mathematical geography, history, and grammar. Died about 196 B.C. - -=Érĕsus=: a town on the south-west coast of Lesbos (Mytilene); -birthplace of Theophrastus. - -=Erétria=: the second town of Euboea, a little south of Chalcis. See -Lelantum. - -=Erínys=: a spirit of vengeance sent up from the underworld to punish -unnatural crimes and offences. - -=Éteŏcles=: (legendary): son of Oedipus, joint king of Thebes with -Polyneices, whom he expelled through a selfish desire to rule alone. - -=Euénus=: two poets of Paros are so named, one of the date of Socrates -and one earlier. It is, and was anciently, difficult to distinguish -between the two. - -=Eúmĕnes=: an eminent and very able general (and also secretary) of -Alexander, after whose death he obtained (322 B.C.) the chief command in -Asia. His subordinate Neoptolemus, governor of Armenia, made head -against him with the help of Craterus. Their defeat, mentioned in the -article on Garrulity, took place in Cappadocia in 321 B.C. - -=Eúpŏlis=: one of the three chief poets of the ‘old’ comedy of Athens, a -contemporary of Aristophanes (q.v.). - -=Eurípides=: 480-406 B.C.; third in date of the three great Athenian -tragedians. His works were numerous and uneven. His poetical merits were -(and are) variously estimated. - -=Fabius Maximus=: the best known person of the name was Q. Fabius -Maximus Cunctator, who saved Rome by his waiting tactics against -Hannibal; but the one who was associated with Polybius, as pupil and -patron, was Q. F. M. Aemilianus, consul in 145 B.C., who served against -Macedonia and in Spain. - -=Góbryes=: one of the seven Persian nobles (Darius being another) who -conspired against the usurper Smerdis the Mage. Darius was raised to the -throne and Gobryes became one of his lieutenants. - -=Górgȋas=: of Leontini in Sicily: orator, rhetorical teacher, and -sophist, who visited Athens 427 B.C. and subsequently. His style, which -was highly artificial, was widely imitated. He is the Gorgias of Plato’s -dialogue. - -=Gorgo=: of Sparta; wife of Leonidas and daughter of Cleomenes I. -Stories of her wisdom and sagacity are told by Herodotus (6. 49, 7. -239). - -=Gylippus=: Spartan general who came to the rescue of Syracuse and -chiefly caused the utter collapse of the Athenian attack upon that city. -After the fall of Athens (404 B.C.) it was his business to convey to -Sparta the 1,500 talents of booty. He opened the seams of the sacks, -filched about one-fifth of the amount, but was betrayed by the -inventories enclosed. - -=Harmódius=: a handsome youth of Athens associated with Aristogeiton -(the older man) in the assassination of Hipparchus, brother of the -despot Hippias in 514 B.C. Though Athens was not liberated till four -years later, these tyrannicides were canonized as saviours of their -country. - -=Hecuba=: the aged wife of Priam, and mother of Hector. - -=Hephaestus=: practically the Greek equivalent of the Latin Vulcan or -Fire-God. He is represented as a lame, but sturdy and somewhat humorous -deity, a master of smithcraft. - -=Hēracleides= (=Héraclides=): It is not clear to which person of the -name Plutarch refers. The best known was Heracleides Ponticus, a pupil -of Plato and a miscellaneous writer. - -=Hēracleitus= (=Hēraclítus=): physical philosopher of Ephesus, _fl._ -_c._ 515 B.C. Famous for the compression of his style, which became so -cryptic that he earned the title of the ‘Obscure’. He was something of a -hermit and favoured the simple vegetarian life. The ‘weeping -philosopher’. - -=Hermíŏne=: daughter of Menelaus and Helen; married to Neoptolemus (son -of Achilles) and jealous of Andromache, whom she tried to put to death. - -=Hēródŏtus=: _c._ 484-400 B.C.; the so-called ‘Father of History’. He -travelled widely in the East and in the Grecian world, and wrote on -Lydia, Babylonia, Egypt, Persia, and the great Persian war. His desire -is to get at the facts, but he displays a naïve fondness for -story-telling and for wonders and miracles. - -=Hēróphȋlus=: of Chalcedon; a most eminent physician and a discoverer in -anatomy and physiology; _fl._ _c._ 300 B.C. - -=Hiero I=: or the Magnificent, despot of Gelon and Syracuse (478-467 -B.C.), and most powerful Sicilian of his day. Poets at one time or other -associated with his court were Epicharmus, Xenophanes, Simonides, -Aeschylus, Pindar, and Bacchylides. - -=Hierónymus=: tragic and dithyrambic poet of Athens and apparently a -writer on poets. - -=Hippócrătes=: of Cos; the ‘father of medicine’; the most renowned -physician and medical teacher and writer of antiquity: _c._ 460-357 B.C. - -=Hypereides= (=Hyperídes=): Attic orator; patriot, contemporary and, for -the most part, supporter of Demosthenes in his anti-Macedonian policy. -Put to death by Antipater (q.v.), 322 B.C. An elegant speaker, of -dubious private life. - -=Íbycus=: of Rhegium, _fl._ _c._ 540 B.C. at the court of the despot of -Samos; a lyric poet of the erotic type. The proverb, ‘the cranes of -Ibycus’, arose from the story that, when being murdered by brigands near -Corinth, he invoked a flock of cranes, then flying past, to avenge his -death. Plutarch tells the sequel (_Garrulity_). - -=īno=: or Leucóthea; a mythological personage, daughter of Cadmus and -wife of Athamas. One story went that, when she leapt into the sea, she -was carried to Corinth by a dolphin. Hence the allusion in the story of -Arion. - -=īphícrătes=: Athenian general in early part of the fourth century B.C. -An innovator in tactics and military equipment, noted for his prudence -and foresight. - -=Ischómăchus=: a character of the name appears in Xenophon’s -_Oeconomicus_ as lecturing his wife upon the principles of domestic -management. Such a philosophically disposed person may be the associate -of Socrates mentioned by Plutarch. - -=Ithacans=: the people of Odysseus, king of Ithaca, one of the Ionian -islands, south of Corfu. - -=Ixíon=: mythical Thessalian king, who made illicit love to Hera, wife -of Zeus, and was punished by being fastened to a perpetually revolving -wheel in Hades. - -=Laelius=: C. Laelius Sapiens, friend of Scipio Africanus Minor. Consul -140 B.C. Cicero’s _De Amicitia_ is otherwise named his _Laelius_. -Philosopher, orator, and scholar. - -=Laértes=: aged father of Odysseus; superannuated king of Ithaca. - -=Lĕchaeum=: the port of Old Corinth, with which it was connected by -walls one and a half miles in length. - -=Lēlántum=: a river of Euboea, flowing through the fertile Lelantine -plain (between Chalcis and Eretria), which was long a bone of contention -between the two cities. - -=Leónȋdas=: the famous Spartan king, who so stubbornly held the pass of -Thermopylae against the Persians with his ‘Three Hundred’, 480 B.C. - -=Leptis=: a town in Africa near the modern Tripoli; a Phoenician -settlement and afterwards a Roman colony. - -=Lesches=: one of the post-Homeric (‘Cyclic’) poets, and writer of the -_Little Iliad_; a native of Lesbos, _fl._ _c._ 705 B.C. - -=Leuctra=: Boeotian village; the scene of the great defeat of the -Spartans by Epaminondas, 371 B.C. - -=Livia=: Livia Drusilla, 56 B.C.-A.D. 29. Her first husband was Tiberius -Claudius Nero, by whom she was the mother of Tiberius, the future -emperor. Married to Augustus (then Octavianus) in 38 B.C., and having no -children by him, she was anxious to keep the succession in her own -family. A woman of strong character, she exerted a tactful control over -Augustus and attempted one more imperious over Tiberius, but failed. - -=Locri=: Locri Epizephyrii, an important Greek town of South Italy, -about the modern Gerace. Its constitutional code was often regarded as a -model. - -=Locris=: a Greek community lying along the north side of the middle of -the Corinthian Gulf. - -=Loxias=: Apollo as God of Oracles. The name was commonly interpreted as -‘Riddling’ or ‘Indirect’. - -=Lucullus=: Roman conqueror of Mithridates, succeeded in his command by -Pompey, 66 B.C. Famous for his wealth and luxury, and particularly for -his lavish feasts. A byword for self-indulgence. - -=Lycéum=: an exercise ground with terraces (‘walks’) and colonnades just -outside the wall to the east of Athens. It was here that Aristotle -discoursed on the ‘Walk’ (_peripatos_), whence the name ‘Peripatetic’ -became applied to his school. - -=Lycurgus=: (1) the more or less legendary lawgiver and -constitution-maker of Sparta. His date and personality are quite -uncertain, and he is not improbably as mythical as Heracles. - -(2) son of Dryas, a legendary Thracian king who resisted the worship of -Dionysius and hacked down his sacred plant, the vine. Dionysius punished -him with madness, during which he killed his own son, thinking him a -vine. The story is much varied in particulars. - -=Lysander=: Spartan admiral, who won the battle of Aegospotami against -the Athenians and concluded the reduction of Athens in 404 B.C. He was -afterwards distinguished for his ostentation and arrogance. - -=Lysias=: orator and professional rhetorician of Athens, distinguished -for the purity and lucidity of his diction and his grace of style: _fl._ -_c._ 403 B.C. The majority of his 230 speeches were written for -litigants. - -=Lysímăchus=: of Macedonia; became king of Thrace on the partition of -Alexander’s empire. A man of powerful physique and an able soldier. -Later his territory included the western half of Asia Minor. Killed in -battle 281 B.C. - -=Masinissa=: king of Numidia; first a supporter, then an enemy, of -Carthage, he lent great assistance to the Romans from 204 B.C. to 148. -His reign was long and he died at ninety. - -=Meidias= (=Mídias=): an Athenian citizen and bitter enemy of -Demosthenes, one of whose best known speeches is a violent, and possibly -a rather scurrilous, attack upon him. - -=Melánthius=: of Athens: an inferior tragic and elegiac poet of -worthless character: a contemporary of Aristophanes and Plato. - -=Meleáger=: legendary prince of Calydon. Having slain his mother’s -brothers, he was cursed by her, and thereupon refused to take further -part in the war against the Curetes. No offers could induce him to leave -his chamber and rout the enemy, until he yielded to the prayers of his -wife Cleopatra. - -=Menander=: chief poet of the Athenian New Comedy (or comedy of -manners), 342-291 B.C.; a polished and easy-tempered man of the world. -His sententious writings lent themselves to quotation and were much read -in schools. To moralizing critics of a later age he was to comedy what -Homer was to epic. - -=Mĕnedémus=: philosopher and statesman of Euboea, of the ‘Megarian’ -school. Died _c._ 277 B.C. - -=Méropë=: the name of several mythological semi-goddesses, mostly -connected with the heavenly bodies. - -=Metellus=: Q. Caecilius Metellus, who successfully conducted the -Numidian War against Jugurtha (109 B.C.) until superseded by Marius. A -man of high character, military ability, and intellectual culture. - -=Mētrodórus=: favourite pupil of Epicurus (q.v.) and almost co-master of -his school. Died 277 B.C. - -=Mithridátes=: Mithridates VI, or the Great, king of Pontus 120-63 B.C., -a Hellenized oriental famed for his physical and intellectual ability, -his ambition and daring; of importance in history for his wars with the -Romans under Lucullus and Pompey. He made a special study of poisons and -their antidotes. - -=Mnēsíphȋlus=: Athenian statesman of sound practical ability, taken by -Themistocles as his model. It was he who urged Themistocles to force on -the battle of Salamis (480 B.C.). In the _Dinner-Party_ Plutarch borrows -the name for an imaginary friend of Solon. - -=Molycréa=: a town just inside the entrance to the Corinthian Gulf on -the north side. - -=Myrōn=: Boeotian sculptor; _fl._ 430 B.C. Best known by his Discobolus -and his ‘Cow’. His work included animal forms, and human figures in a -state of muscular activity or tension. - -=Mýrsȋlus=: see Pittacus. - -=Naucrătis=: a Greek town in the Delta of Egypt, thirty miles from the -sea. At first only a trading-station, it was granted privileges of -internal self-government by Amasis (q.v.). - -=Neoptólĕmus=: see Eumenes. - -=Nestor=: the typical wise old man of the _Iliad_. - -=Nicander=: poet and physician of Colophon; _fl._ in earlier half of -second century B.C. Two of his poems are extant: the _Theriaca_ on -venomous animals, and the _Alexipharmaca_ (or ‘_Antidotes_‘) on poisons -and their remedies. The verse in itself is poor. - -=Nícias=: (1) Athenian general in the calamitous expedition against -Syracuse (415-413 B.C.). A man of wealth, but religious to the point of -disastrous superstition; a commander of experience, though wanting in -promptitude and self-reliance. He was put to death by the victors. - -(2) painter of Athens, _fl._ _c._ 310 B.C., particularly noted for his -chiaroscuro and for improvements in encaustic painting. - -=Nilóxĕnus=: a character probably invented by Plutarch, with a name -geographically suitable. - -=Numa=: Numa Pompilius, second king of Rome, famed for his piety and the -excellence of his legislation. Much of his history is legendary. - -=Olympias=: wife of Philip (q.v.) and mother of Alexander. An imperious -and vindictive woman, with good reasons for jealousy, who often figures -in Macedonian feuds. - -=Olynthus=: a Greek town on the Chalcidic peninsula, south of -Thessalonica. - -=Ómphălë=: queen of Lydia, to whom Heracles was for a time enslaved and -for whom he played an effeminate part. In a sense she played the Delilah -to his Samson. - -=Orchómĕnus=: a very ancient town in Boeotia. - -=Oromazdes=: = Ahuramazda, the great God of the Zoroastrians; deity of -light and good, as opposed to Ahrimanes. - -=Pándărus=: a Lycian warrior on the Trojan side, famous for his skill as -an archer. - -=Panthéa=: beautiful wife of Abradatas, king of Susa. Cyrus, who had -captured her, showed her such respect that Abradatas came over to his -side. - -=Parménȋdes=: philosopher and legislator of Elea, _fl._ _c._ 476 B.C. -His writings were in the hexameter verse then usual as the vehicle of -literary philosophy. - -=Parménio=: general under Philip and Alexander, and right-hand -lieutenant of the latter. Accused of taking part in a conspiracy against -his chief, he was assassinated at the age of seventy in 330 B.C. - -=Parrhásius=: painter of Ephesus, domiciled at Athens, _c._ 400 B.C.; -famed for his accurate drawing and proportion. As a man he was arrogant -and luxurious. - -=Pāsíphaë=: (legendary): wife of Minos of Crete; enamoured of a bull and -mother of the Minotaur. - -=Patróclus=: the ‘squire’ and beloved friend of Achilles. Killed by -Hector in battle, and avenged by Achilles. - -=Peísistrătus=: a younger relative of Solon; intrigued himself into the -position of despot of Athens 560 B.C. He was twice expelled, but -re-established himself. A highly capable ruler, beautifier of Athens, -and a lover of literature. - -=Pēleides= (-=ī=-): (i.e. ‘son of Peleus’) = Achilles. - -=Péleus=: aged father of Achilles; superannuated king in Thessaly. - -=Periander=: despot of Corinth, _c._ 625-585 B.C. An able and powerful -ruler, patron of literature and art, generally (but not invariably) -included among the Seven Sages. His early mildness is commonly reported -to have passed into tyranny (see Thrasybulus). His wife was Melissa. - -Pericles: the highest name among what may be called ‘Prime Ministers’ of -Athens. His career may be dated 470-429 B.C., but his leadership became -most pronounced about 444 B.C. A man of large conceptions, brilliant -oratorical powers, and philosophic tastes, but of an aristocratic and -exclusive temperament. - -=Perséphŏnë=: daughter of Demeter, wife of Pluto, and therefore, in one -of her aspects, Queen of the Dead. - -=Perseus=: king of Macedonia, on whom the Romans made war in 171 B.C. At -first victorious or equal, he was defeated at Pydna by L. Aemilius -Paulus 168 B.C. He was carried to Rome and lived for some years at Alba. -A weak, vacillating and parsimonious monarch. - -=Petrónius=: Titus (or Gaius) Petronius, the famous ‘arbiter of taste’ -under Nero and director of his pleasures. Whether he was the author of -the famous _Satyricon_ is doubtful. - -=Phaeácians=: seafaring inhabitants of the rich and fertile island of -Phaeacia, traditionally identified with Corfu, but possibly Crete. When -Odysseus arrived at the island on his raft he was hospitably entertained -by King Alcinous and sent home to Ithaca by him on a ship. - -=Phaedra=: wife of Theseus and step-mother of Hippolytus, of whom she -became enamoured. The allusion in Plutarch refers to the fondness of -Hippolytus for hunting. - -=Phálăris=: despot of Agrigentum in Sicily _c._ 570 B.C. His name was in -some legends proverbial for cruelty, and with him is associated the -legend of roasting his victims in a brazen bull. Put he is sometimes -represented otherwise and as a student of letters and philosophy. - -=Pheidias= (=Phíd=-) of Athens, the most eminent sculptor of antiquity: -died 432 B.C. He is best known for his work upon the Parthenon and his -colossal statue of Zeus at Olympia. - -=Phérae=: a town in Thessaly, somewhat west of the modern Volo, which -became dominant under the despots Jason and Alexander (q.v.). - -=Philadolphus=: see Ptolemy (1). - -=Philémōn=: Athenian poet of the New Comedy, reckoned second only to -Menander. Lived _c._ 360-262 B.C., and wrote ninety-seven plays. - -=Philétas=: of Cos, _c._ 300 B.C.; elegiac poet and critic, tutor of -Ptolemy II. His thinness was a matter of jest for the comedians. - -=Philip=: 382-336 B.C. king of Macedon, father of Alexander, and, in a -large measure, conqueror of Greece. Demosthenes’ _Philippics_ and other -speeches were directed against him. An able, hard-working, ambitious, -and rather unscrupulous man; a hard drinker and a sensualist, especially -fond of rude jest, but with intellectual tastes. - -=Philíppȋdes=: one of the better Athenian poets of the New Comedy; _fl._ -_c._ 335 B.C. At first he attacked the Macedonian rulers, but later -became a friend of Lysimachus (q.v.). - -=Philóchŏrus=: Athenian writer on the history, antiquities, and legends -of his country, and on miscellaneous subjects: _fl._ _c._ 300-260 B.C. - -=Philócrătes=: Athenian orator, first a supporter, then an opponent, of -Demosthenes. His policy was consistently to abet the pretensions of -Philip of Macedon, who had bribed him lavishly, to the detriment of -Athens. He was ultimately impeached and compelled to go into exile, 330 -B.C. - -=Philoctétos=: Greek hero (in the expedition to Troy) left desolate on -the island of Lemnos, where he suffered deprivations and the agonies of -a gangrened foot. - -=Philopoemen=: (1) the most distinguished Greek soldier of his day; head -of the Achaean League several times from 208 B.C.; a man of culture and -high character. - -(2) controlling minister of Attalus II (q.v.). - -=Philótas=: there were several Macedonians of the name in the service of -Alexander. The two chief were (1) the son of Parmenio, a favourite of -Alexander, but found guilty of conspiracy and executed; (2) a general -who subsequently became governor of Cilicia. - -=Philotímus=: a distinguished physician and writer on medicine of the -date of Erasistratus and Herophilus (q.v.), _c._ 300 B.C. - -=Philóxĕnus=: a dithyrambic poet of high repute: _fl._ at Athens 400 -B.C. He thence moved to the court of Dionysius (q.v.), by whom he is -said to have been imprisoned for his scathing criticism on the despot’s -verses. - -=Phóciōn=: 402-317 B.C. An upright Athenian general and statesman, who -favoured, though probably not in an unpatriotic spirit, the submission -of Athens to the Macedonian power under Alexander (335) and Antipater -(q.v.). He was frequently opposed to Demosthenes, and was put to death -by his countrymen on a charge of treason. - -=Phōcýlȋdes=: epic and elegiac poet of Miletus, _fl._ _c._ 530 B.C. Many -of his lines passed into current maxims, and were so intended. - -=Phoenix=: a fugitive kindly received by Peleus and entrusted with the -bringing-up of his son Achilles. He had quarrelled with his own father, -whose young mistress he had corrupted at the request of his jealous -mother. - -=Pindar=: of Thebes, the most eminent lyrist of Greece, composer of -songs, choral and processional odes, dirges, &c.; lived _c._ 522-442 -B.C. - -=Píttăcus=: of Mytilene, _c._ 650-569. Contemporary of Sappho. During -the struggles of the oligarchical and popular parties he was appointed -by the latter ‘elective autocrat’ and legislator. The chief -representative on the other side had been Myrsilus. A philosophic poet -and the originator of moral maxims. - -=Plato=: the aristocratic and cultured philosopher of Athens, follower -of Socrates, founder of the Academy, and writer of the Dialogues which -go under his name. - -=Pólĕmo=: (1) of Athens, who in his youth abandoned profligate habits -for the cult of the Platonic philosophy under the influence of -Xenocrates (q.v.), whom he succeeded 315 B.C. - -(2) a Stoic philosopher, traveller, and geographer, who wrote copiously -on inscriptions, &c.; _fl._ _c._ 195 B.C. - -=Polýbius=: Greek historian from Arcadia, carried to Italy by the Romans -167 B.C., and taken under the patronage of Q. Fabius Maximus and Scipio -Aemilianus. He accompanied Scipio against Carthage and in Spain. Wrote a -sound, useful, unimaginative history of the years 220-146 B.C. A -practical statesman and a student of the military art. - -=Polycleitus= (-=clít=-): of Argos, _fl._ _c._ 450-412 B.C.; a sculptor -of the first rank, particularly distinguished for his representation of -human forms, to which he imparted his ideals of strength and beauty -according to a ‘canon of proportions’. These were best typified in his -_Doryphorus_ (‘spear-bearer’), which was itself sometimes called ‘the -Canon’. His chief colossal statue was the chryselephantine Hera of -Argos. - -=Pontus=: in two senses: (1) the Black Sea; (2) a province or region on -the eastern half of the south coast of that sea. - -=Praxítĕles=: the second greatest name in Athenian sculpture; _fl._ _c._ -365 B.C. He is the head of the ‘later’ (or more graceful) Attic school, -Pheidias (q.v.) representing the earlier, more massive and majestic. He -particularly excelled with his statues of Aphrodite (e.g. the ‘Venus of -Cnidos’). - -=Priam=: aged king of Troy, father of Hector, whose dead body he came to -Achilles to ransom. - -=Priénë=: an Ionian Greek town in Asia Minor a little south of Ephesus; -the home of Bias. - -=Pródȋcus=: of Ceos, sophist and rhetorical teacher; a contemporary of -Plato and a frequent visitor to Athens. His bodily weakness was -notorious. - -=Prométheus=: mythical semi-deity, gifted with great foresight; a -benefactor of mankind by giving them fire stolen from heaven (an offence -for which he was cruelly punished by Zeus), and by the invention of the -civilizing arts. His name was commonly interpreted ‘Fore-thinker’. - -=Ptolemy=: (1) Ptolemy II (Philadelphus), king of Egypt 285-247 B.C. - -(2) Ptolemy III (Euergetes), king of Egypt 247-222 B.C. - -(3) Ptolemy IV (Philopator), king 222-205 B.C.; a vicious and sensual -monarch, ruled by his minister Sosibius. - -(4) Ptolemy V (Epiphanes), king 205-181 B.C. See _Aristomenes_. It was -in the early part of his reign that Egypt became a Roman protectorate. -He came to the throne at the age of four. - -=Publius Nigidius=: contemporary of Cicero; a man of great scientific -and mathematical learning, as became a Pythagorean. - -=Pūpius Piso=: Roman orator, and consul in 61 B.C.; a supporter of -Clodius and therefore hostile to Cicero. - -=Pyrrhus=: king of Epirus, called in by the people of Tarentum against -the Romans. After a dearly won victory in 280 B.C. he sent his eloquent -minister to Rome to offer humiliating terms of peace. These were -rejected, and after a practically equal contest he retired from Italy. - -=Pythagoras=: of Samos, _fl._ _c._ 540-520 B.C. He had apparently -travelled in the East and acquired, besides mathematical knowledge (in -which he made some advances), mystical theological views and probably -also his doctrine of the transmigration of souls. He migrated to Croton -in South Italy, and there became the founder of a close and aristocratic -philosophical brotherhood, to whom the word of the master was sufficient -(_ipse dixit_). Many legends gathered about him and a mystical -interpretation was put upon his rather compressed maxims. - -=Pythian=: = ‘belonging to Pytho’, i.e. to Delphi, the seat of the chief -oracle of Apollo. - -=Rhium=: the promontory on the south side of the mouth of the Corinthian -Gulf, the north promontory being Antirrhium. - -=Rusticus=: L. Junius Arulenus Rusticus, a Roman noble of the Stoic -school and champion of liberty, so far as that was possible under the -Roman emperors. Put to death by Domitian (emperor A.D. 81-96). - -=Samius=: lyrist and writer of epigrams at the Macedonian court, _c._ -300 B.C. - -=Scipio=: (1) P. Cornelius Scipio Africanus Major; the brilliant and -almost ideal Roman general who conquered Hannibal in 202 B.C. - -(2) P. Cornelius Scipio Aemilianus Africanus Minor, who completed the -conquest of Carthage 146 B.C.; a student of letters and philosophy. - -=Scirōn=: a spot on the Sacred Way from Athens to Eleusis. - -=Scyros=: island in the Aegean off north-east of Euboea. Here Achilles -was for a time hidden by his mother in woman’s dress, and occupied in -feminine tasks to keep him from the dangers of Troy. - -=Seleucus=: called Callinicus (the ‘Victorious’); king of Syria 246-226 -B.C. He was defeated by Antiochus with the help of Gauls (= Galatians) -at Ancyra, and it was for a time thought that he had perished in the -rout. He managed, however, to retain his kingdom. - -=Silániōn=: Athenian portrait sculptor _c._ 324 B.C. His _Jocasta_ -represented her as dying, her pallor being realistically rendered by the -unworthy device of mixing silver with bronze. - -=Siléni=: a class of tipsy satyrs associated with Dionysus. _The_ -Silenus was in a sense the Falstaff of Greek legend. - -=Simónȋdes=: a most distinguished poet of Ceos, writer of elegies, -choral and processional odes, epigrams, and drinking songs (556-467 -B.C.). He spent part of his life as a kind of court poet in Thessaly and -at Syracuse, and visited Athens. His compositions were of a high order, -and his moral maxims much in vogue, but he was notorious for worldliness -and a love of money. - -=Sísyphus=: legendary king of Corinth; type of fraudulent and criminal -cunning; punished in Hades by being compelled to roll a stone up a hill -for ever and never establishing it at the top. - -=Socrates=: the Athenian philosopher (468-399 B.C.), from whose thinking -most of the later schools were in some way descended. His object was to -bring philosophy down to earth, and to arrive at true and universal -definitions. His simple character, his whimsical irony, and his -dialectical skill formed the groundwork for many stories. His method was -conversational and non-didactic. He wrote nothing, and what we know of -him is due to his disciples Plato and Xenophon, and to later writers. - -=Solōn=: of Athens, _c._ 638-558 B.C.; aristocrat, trader, traveller, -poet and thinker. Chosen at a time of political and financial crisis as -mediator between parties in Attica, and as constitution-maker, he -behaved with strict impartiality and self-effacement. We may believe -that he visited Egypt, but his intercourse with Croesus (q.v.) is of -doubtful warrant. Author of much proverbial wisdom. - -=Sophocles=: 496-406 B.C.; second in date, and perhaps in merit, of -three great Athenian tragedians; a genial and practical man of the -world. - -=Sótădes=: a poet at Alexandria _c._ 280 B.C. He wrote songs and satires -of a lascivious kind. One account states that in consequence of his -abuse he was thrown into the sea in a leaden chest. - -=Speusippus=: of Athens, nephew and disciple of Plato, and his successor -as head of the Academy (347-339 B.C.); a writer on ethical and -dialectical subjects. His character is said to have excelled his -intellect. - -=Spínthărus=: the best known person of the name was an inferior tragic -poet of Heraclea on the Black Sea satirized by Aristophanes and other -comedians. - -=Stilpo=: a high-minded and sane philosopher of great dialectical -acuteness. Founder of the Megarian school, which made a cult of virtue -while denying the possibility of knowledge. See also under Demetrius. - -=Sulla=: the distinguished Roman general, 138-78 B.C. He took charge of -the war against Mithridates in 87 B.C., his capture of Athens taking -place in the next year. His love of pleasure resulted in the pimpled -face referred to in Plutarch’s article on _Garrulity_. Caecilia Metella -was his fourth wife. - -=Sýbăris=: the oldest Greek settlement in the southernmost part of -Italy, once large, prosperous, and a by-word for effeminate luxury -(whence ‘sybarite’); afterwards completely overthrown and destroyed, its -place being taken by Thurii (q.v.). - -=Taenărum=: now Matapan; cape at the end of the middle prong of the -Peloponnese. - -=Télĕphus=: king of Mysia at the time of the Trojan war. He was wounded -by Achilles, and could only be cured by ‘that which had wounded him’. -The remedy turned out to be the rust of Achilles’ spear. - -=Tháïs=: a witty and beautiful courtesan of Athens, first associated -with Alexander during his Asiatic campaigns and then with Ptolemy in -Egypt. - -=Thales=: of Miletus, _c._ 635-555 B.C. Famous as a physical -philosopher, mathematician, and shrewd practical man. He is regularly -mentioned first among the Seven Sages. - -=Theaetétus=: a high-minded Athenian youth, eager for knowledge, who -plays his part in Plato’s dialogue of that name. - -=Theágĕnes=: Theban general at Chaeronea (338 B.C.). - -=Theánō=: wife or pupil (or both) of Pythagoras (q.v.), herself a writer -on philosophy and a pattern of virtue. - -=Themistŏcles=: became political leader at Athens 483 B.C., and -commanded the Athenian contingent at the battle of Salamis. Subsequently -(471 B.C.) this extremely able, but apparently not extremely honest, man -was ostracised. His last days were spent in the service of Persia. His -son Diophantus is of no note. - -=Theócritus=: of Chios, rhetorician and sophist, noted for his caustic -wit. The Antigonus who put him to death was Antigonus the ‘One-Eyed’. - -=Theógnis=: elegiac poet of the sententious order. He flourished at -Megara _c._ 550-540 B.C. Amid the feuds of his country he sides with the -aristocrats, and allusions to political injustice are frequent. Many -current maxims of proverbial wisdom were fathered on ‘Theognis’ as a -matter of course. - -=Theōn=: painter of Samos, contemporary of Apelles (q.v.) and Alexander; -spoken of by Pliny as ‘next to the first’. - -=Theophrastus=: of Lesbos and afterwards of Athens; disciple and -successor of Aristotle as head of the Peripatetics (322 B.C.). An -encyclopaedic writer on logic, physics, history, biology, zoology, &c. -His best-known work is his _Characters_. - -=Theopompus=: king of Sparta, _fl._ _c._ 750 B.C. To his reign belonged -the change of the form of government by the establishment of the popular -‘ephors’ to control the royal power. - -=Thersítes=: misshapen and virulent demagogue in the Greek army before -Troy. - -=Thĕtis=: sea-goddess; mother of Achilles. - -=Thrasybúlus=: despot of Miletus, contemporary and friend of Periander -(q.v.), over whom he exercised a bad influence, as in advising him to -‘cut down the tall poppies’. - -=Thúrii=: Greek city in South Italy on the west side of the Gulf of -Tarentum, noted for its special democratic system. - -=Tīmágĕnes=: an Alexandrian or Syrian rhetorician and historian. He -taught and wrote at Rome under Augustus, whose friendship he obtained, -losing it, however, through his caustic freedom. - -=Tīmocléa=: of Thebes. Plutarch tells of her noble and daring spirit in -his _Life of Alexander_ (c. 12). - -=Tīmomăchus=: painter of Byzantium, first century B.C.; particularly -famed for his _Ajax_ and _Medea_, which were bought by Julius Caesar. -Medea was represented meditating the murder of her children. - -=Timóthëus=: (1) an able and spirited Athenian general, who obtained -several rather roving successes, chiefly against the Lacedaemonians. -Something of a free lance; of popular character and considerable -culture; _fl._ 378-354 B.C. - -(2) poet and musician of Miletus, settled at Athens; _fl._ _c._ 400-360 -B.C. His poems were mainly dithyrambs (high-flown and wordy -compositions) or cognate lyrics. His music, at first ill received on -account of its vulgarizing innovations, became immensely popular. - -=Tissaphernes=: Persian satrap of lower Asia Minor. See Alcibiades. - -=Tīthónus=: a mortal beloved of Eos (Aurora), who obtained for him -immortality, but forgot to obtain him immortal youth. - -=Troezen=: a town in the east of the Peloponnese near the entrance of -the Saronic Gulf. - -=Tyndareus’ sons=: Castor and Pollux, the traditional preservers of -seamen. - -=Typhōn=: = Set; Egyptian malignant deity; brother, enemy, and slayer of -Osiris. - -=Xenócrătes=: 396-314 B.C.: philosopher from Chalcedon, disciple of -Plato, and philosophic teacher and writer. His earnestness of character -and application to study atoned for his lack of the Graces. Became head -of the Academic school next but one after Plato. - -=Xenóphănes=: philosopher of Colophon, and afterwards of Elea in Italy, -in later part of sixth century B.C. Noted for his high conception of a -Deity as neither anthropomorphic nor subject to human passions. His -doctrines were embodied in hexameter verse. - -=Xenophōn=: of Athens; the well-known historian, and leader of the -retreat of the ‘Ten Thousand’ as recorded in his _Anabasis_. A -philosophical adherent of Socrates and a voluminous writer. Lived _c._ -444-359 B.C. - -=Zacýnthus= = Zante, the southernmost of the Ionian islands. - -=Zéno=: (1) of Citium in Cyprus and subsequently of Athens; founder of -the Stoic philosophy; a man of simple, if rather dour, character, and -capable of an apt retort: _fl._ _c._ 270 B.C. A writer on ethical, -physical, and other philosophic subjects. - -(2) Philosopher of Elea; disciple of Parmenides (q.v.); upholder of -popular liberty against a usurping despot. - - - - - APPENDIX - NOTES ON THE GREEK TEXT - - -4 D ἐνίοτε γὰρ εἰδότες αἰσθομένοις μᾶλλον αὐτοῖς τοῦτο λεγόντων. Read -... εἰδότες, (ἢ) αἰσθόμενοι ἢ καὶ ἄλλων αὐτοῖς τοῦτο λεγόντων. - -5 C ἵνα μάθῃς ὅτι τῶν ἀναξίων τὰ τίμια οὐδὲν διαφέρει. The sense -requires ἀξίων ‘cheap’. - -6 C πρὸς δὲ τούτοις τί ἄν τοὺς παῖδας ... καλὸν γάρ τοι κτλ. The cause -of the lacuna is obvious if we read τί ἄν τοὺς παῖδας (καλὸν -διδάσκοιεν;) καλὸν γάρ τοι κτλ. - -7 B ἕως ἔτι μέμνημαι τῆς παιδείας. Rather ... (ταύτης) τῆς παιδείας. - -7 F τὸ μὲν γὰρ εὐγενῶς εὐτυχεῖν ἀνδρός, τὸ δ᾽ ἀνεπιφθόνως εὐηνίου -ἀνθρώπου. Read τὸ μὲν γὰρ εὐγενῶς ἀτυχεῖν ἀνδρός, τὸ δ᾽ ἀνεπιφθόνως -εὐθηνεῖν ἀνθρώπου. - -8 B καὶ ἀπὸ πηγῆς τὴν ἐπιστήμην τηρεῖν συμβέβηκεν. Read ἀπὸ πείνης ... - -8 D ἰσχνὸς δὲ στρατιώτης πολεμικῶν ἀγώνων ἐθὰς ἀθλητῶν καὶ πολεμίων -φάλαγγας διωθεῖ. Read ... ἀθλητῶν καταπιμέλων ... - -8 F καὶ ταῦτα μὲν δὴ τῷ λόγῳ παρεφορτισάμην, ἵν᾽ ἐφεξῆς καὶ τἄλλα ... -συνάψω. Read ... νῦν δ᾽ ἐφεξῆς. - -11 A ἵνα δὲ γέλωτα παράσχῃ τοῖς ἄλλοις, αὐτὸς πολὺν χρόνον ἔκλαυσεν. We -require the antithesis γέλωτα (βραχὺν) παράσχῃ. - -12 E ὅτι δεῖ τὸν βίον ἐπιτηδεύειν καὶ μὴ δεῖν δεσμῷ προσάπτειν. Read ... -καὶ μηδενὶ δεσμῷ ... - -13 B ὡς ἐκ λυρικῆς τέχνης. The sense requires νευροσπαστικῆς, to which -νευρικῆς may be equivalent. - -14 C τὸ μὲν οὖν πάσας τὰς προειρημένας ... συμπεριλαβεῖν εὐχῆς ἴσως ἢ -παραινέσεως ἔργον ἐστί. The word most easily lost would be (εὐημερίας). -Also (μἂλλον) is to be supplied. - -44 B ἐν τῷ καταφρονεῖν τιθέμενοι καὶ τὸ σεμνὸν ὑπεροψίᾳ διὼκοντες. Read -ἐν τῷ καταφρονεῖν (τὸ φρονεῖν) τιθέμενοι ... - -46 B ᾠδήν τινα πεποιημένην ἐφ᾽ ἁρμονίας. Read ἐφ᾽ ἁρμονίας (νέας) or the -like. - -74 A τοιοῦτον γὰρ ἡ θεραπευτικὴ παρρησία ζητεῖ τρόπον, ἡ δὲ πρακτικὴ τὸν -ἐναντίον. The sense requires ἡ δὲ ταρακτικὴ ... - -152 A εἰ μὴ μόνος εἴη φρόνιμος. Probably εἰ ἐμμόνως εἴη ... - -152 D σὺ δὲ δεινὸς εἶ κοράκων ἐπαΐειν καὶ κολοιῶν, τῆς δὲ σοῦ φωνῆς οὐκ -ἀκριβῶς ἐξακούεις. For τῆς δὲ σοῦ (δεσου) read τῆς (δεδουσ i.e.) δ᾽ -Αἰδοῦς ... - -158 D δεινὸν μὲν οὖν ... καὶ τὸ γεωργίας αὐτῇ. The sense requires αὐτῆς. - -159 D ὥσπερ ἐν μυλῶνι τῷ σώματι τὴν ψυχὴν ἐγκεκαλυμμένην. Read -ἐγκεκλῃμένην. - -160 F ἐπὶ τὸν τόπον οἷ προσέμελλε. Read προσέκελλε. - -163 D ... ἀπαντῆσαι μόνον ... θαλάττῃ ἕπεσθαι κτλ. The sense would be -given by ... ἀπαντῆσαι μόνον (θαρρῆσαι, τὸ δ᾽ ἀπαλλάττεσθαι, καὶ ἐκ τῆς) -θαλάττης ἕπεσθαι κτλ. - -504 B ὅτι πρεσβύτης ἐστὶν ἐν Ἀθήναις παρὰ πότον σιωπᾶν δυνάμενος. Rather -... πρεσβύτης (εἷς) ... - -504 C ἀλλ᾽ ὅμως εἰπὼν καὶ ἀναφωνήσας ἐκεῖνο περὶ αὑτοῦ τὸ ... Probably -ἀλλ᾽ ὅμως (τὸ τοῦ Ὀδυσσέως) εἰπὼν κτλ. - -513 A Φιλίππου γράψαντος εἰ δέχονται τῇ πόλει αὐτόν, εἰς χάρτην ΟΥ μέγα -γράψαντες ἀπέστειλαν. There would be more point in ... εἰς χάρτην (τὴν -αὐτὴν) ... Moreover, what they wrote was simply Ο. - -514 F τὸ γὰρ μάτην καὶ διακενῆς οὐχ ἧττον ἐν τοῖς λόγοις ἢ τοῖς ἔργοις -ἔστιν. Read ... οὐχ ἧττον (εὐλαβητέον) ἐν ... - -515 D ὅσσον ὕδωρ κατ᾽ Ἀλίζονος ἢ δρυὸς ἀμφὶ πέτηλα. Perhaps ὅσσον ὕδωρ -καταχεῖ νότος ἦ ... - - - - - ● Transcriber’s Notes: - ○ Missing or obscured punctuation was silently corrected. - ○ Typographical errors were silently corrected. - ○ Inconsistent spelling and hyphenation were made consistent only - when a predominant form was found in this book. - ○ Text that was in italics is enclosed by underscores (_italics_). - ○ Text that was in bold face is enclosed by equals signs (=bold=). - ○ Page references printed in the margin of the book have been moved - into the paragraphs near where they appear, contained in square - brackets, and begun with the word "Sidenote". - ○ Footnotes have been moved to follow the chapters in which they are - referenced. - - - - - -End of Project Gutenberg's Selected Essays of Plutarch, Vol. I., by Plutarch - -*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK SELECTED ESSAYS OF PLUTARCH *** - -***** This file should be named 62618-0.txt or 62618-0.zip ***** -This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: - http://www.gutenberg.org/6/2/6/1/62618/ - -Produced by Turgut Dincer, David King, and the Online -Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net. (This -file was produced from images generously made available -by The Internet Archive.) - - -Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions will -be renamed. - -Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright -law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works, -so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United -States without permission and without paying copyright -royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part -of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project -Gutenberg-tm electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm -concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark, -and may not be used if you charge for the eBooks, unless you receive -specific permission. If you do not charge anything for copies of this -eBook, complying with the rules is very easy. You may use this eBook -for nearly any purpose such as creation of derivative works, reports, -performances and research. They may be modified and printed and given -away--you may do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks -not protected by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the -trademark license, especially commercial redistribution. - -START: FULL LICENSE - -THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE -PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK - -To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free -distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work -(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project -Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full -Project Gutenberg-tm License available with this file or online at -www.gutenberg.org/license. - -Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project -Gutenberg-tm electronic works - -1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm -electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to -and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property -(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all -the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or -destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your -possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a -Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound -by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the -person or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph -1.E.8. - -1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be -used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who -agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few -things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works -even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See -paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project -Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this -agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm -electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below. - -1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the -Foundation" or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection -of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual -works in the collection are in the public domain in the United -States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the -United States and you are located in the United States, we do not -claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing, -displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as -all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope -that you will support the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting -free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm -works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the -Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with the work. You can easily -comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the -same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg-tm License when -you share it without charge with others. - -1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern -what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are -in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, -check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this -agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, -distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any -other Project Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no -representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any -country outside the United States. - -1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: - -1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other -immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear -prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work -on which the phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the -phrase "Project Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, -performed, viewed, copied or distributed: - - This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and - most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no - restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it - under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this - eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the - United States, you'll have to check the laws of the country where you - are located before using this ebook. - -1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is -derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not -contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the -copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in -the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are -redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase "Project -Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply -either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or -obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg-tm -trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. - -1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted -with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution -must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any -additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms -will be linked to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works -posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the -beginning of this work. - -1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm -License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this -work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. - -1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this -electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without -prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with -active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project -Gutenberg-tm License. - -1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, -compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including -any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access -to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format -other than "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official -version posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site -(www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense -to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means -of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original "Plain -Vanilla ASCII" or other form. Any alternate format must include the -full Project Gutenberg-tm License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. - -1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, -performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works -unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. - -1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing -access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works -provided that - -* You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from - the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method - you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed - to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he has - agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project - Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid - within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are - legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty - payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project - Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in - Section 4, "Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg - Literary Archive Foundation." - -* You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies - you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he - does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm - License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all - copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue - all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg-tm - works. - -* You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of - any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the - electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of - receipt of the work. - -* You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free - distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. - -1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project -Gutenberg-tm electronic work or group of works on different terms than -are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing -from both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and The -Project Gutenberg Trademark LLC, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm -trademark. Contact the Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. - -1.F. - -1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable -effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread -works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project -Gutenberg-tm collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm -electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may -contain "Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate -or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other -intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or -other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or -cannot be read by your equipment. - -1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right -of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project -Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project -Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project -Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all -liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal -fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT -LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE -PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE -TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE -LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR -INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH -DAMAGE. - -1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a -defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can -receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a -written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you -received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium -with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you -with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in -lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person -or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second -opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If -the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing -without further opportunities to fix the problem. - -1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth -in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS', WITH NO -OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT -LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. - -1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied -warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of -damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement -violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the -agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or -limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or -unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the -remaining provisions. - -1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the -trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone -providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in -accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the -production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm -electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, -including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of -the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this -or any Project Gutenberg-tm work, (b) alteration, modification, or -additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any -Defect you cause. - -Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm - -Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of -electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of -computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It -exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations -from people in all walks of life. - -Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the -assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's -goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will -remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project -Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure -and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future -generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary -Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see -Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at -www.gutenberg.org Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg -Literary Archive Foundation - -The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit -501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the -state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal -Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification -number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary -Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by -U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. - -The Foundation's principal office is in Fairbanks, Alaska, with the -mailing address: PO Box 750175, Fairbanks, AK 99775, but its -volunteers and employees are scattered throughout numerous -locations. Its business office is located at 809 North 1500 West, Salt -Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887. Email contact links and up to -date contact information can be found at the Foundation's web site and -official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact - -For additional contact information: - - Dr. Gregory B. Newby - Chief Executive and Director - gbnewby@pglaf.org - -Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg -Literary Archive Foundation - -Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide -spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of -increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be -freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest -array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations -($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt -status with the IRS. - -The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating -charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United -States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a -considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up -with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations -where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND -DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular -state visit www.gutenberg.org/donate - -While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we -have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition -against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who -approach us with offers to donate. - -International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make -any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from -outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. - -Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation -methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other -ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To -donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate - -Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works. - -Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project -Gutenberg-tm concept of a library of electronic works that could be -freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and -distributed Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of -volunteer support. - -Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed -editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in -the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not -necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper -edition. - -Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search -facility: www.gutenberg.org - -This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, -including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary -Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to -subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. - diff --git a/old/62618-0.zip b/old/62618-0.zip Binary files differdeleted file mode 100644 index eaf029b..0000000 --- a/old/62618-0.zip +++ /dev/null diff --git a/old/62618-h.zip b/old/62618-h.zip Binary files differdeleted file mode 100644 index 2984500..0000000 --- a/old/62618-h.zip +++ /dev/null diff --git a/old/62618-h/62618-h.htm b/old/62618-h/62618-h.htm deleted file mode 100644 index f70645c..0000000 --- a/old/62618-h/62618-h.htm +++ /dev/null @@ -1,12562 +0,0 @@ -<!DOCTYPE html PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD XHTML 1.0 Strict//EN" - "http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/DTD/xhtml1-strict.dtd"> -<html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" xml:lang="en" lang="en"> - <head> - <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html;charset=UTF-8" /> - <title>The Project Gutenberg eBook of Selected Essays of Plutarch, Vol. I.</title> - <link rel="coverpage" href="images/cover.jpg" /> - <style type="text/css"> - body { margin-left: 8%; margin-right: 10%; } - h1 { text-align: center; font-weight: normal; font-size: 1.4em; } - h2 { text-align: center; font-weight: normal; font-size: 1.2em; } - h3 { text-align: center; font-weight: normal; font-size: 1.2em; } - .pageno { right: 1%; font-size: x-small; background-color: inherit; color: silver; - text-indent: 0em; text-align: right; position: absolute; - border: thin solid silver; padding: .1em .2em; font-style: normal; - font-variant: normal; font-weight: normal; text-decoration: none; } - p { text-indent: 0; margin-top: 0.5em; margin-bottom: 0.5em; text-align: justify; } - sup { vertical-align: top; font-size: 0.6em; } - .fss { font-size: 75%; } - .sc { font-variant: small-caps; } - .large { font-size: large; } - .xlarge { font-size: x-large; } - .xxlarge { font-size: xx-large; } - .lg-container-b { text-align: center; } - @media handheld { .lg-container-b { clear: both; } } - .linegroup { display: inline-block; text-align: left; } - @media handheld { .linegroup { display: block; margin-left: 1.5em; } } - .linegroup .group { margin: 1em auto; } - .linegroup .line { text-indent: -3em; padding-left: 3em; } - div.linegroup > :first-child { margin-top: 0; } - .linegroup .in10 { padding-left: 8.0em; } - .linegroup .in12 { padding-left: 9.0em; } - .linegroup .in16 { padding-left: 11.0em; } - .linegroup .in18 { padding-left: 12.0em; } - .linegroup .in2 { padding-left: 4.0em; } - .linegroup .in20 { padding-left: 13.0em; } - .linegroup .in24 { padding-left: 15.0em; } - .linegroup .in26 { padding-left: 16.0em; } - .linegroup .in6 { padding-left: 6.0em; } - .linegroup .in8 { padding-left: 7.0em; } - ul.ul_1 {padding-left: 0; margin-left: 2.78%; margin-top: .5em; - margin-bottom: .5em; list-style-type: disc; } - ul.ul_2 {padding-left: 0; margin-left: 6.94%; margin-top: .5em; - margin-bottom: .5em; list-style-type: circle; } - div.footnote {margin-left: 2.5em; } - div.footnote > :first-child { margin-top: 1em; } - div.footnote .label { display: inline-block; width: 0em; text-indent: -2.5em; - text-align: right; } - div.pbb { page-break-before: always; } - hr.pb { border: none; border-bottom: thin solid; margin-bottom: 1em; } - @media handheld { hr.pb { display: none; } } - .sidenote, .sni { text-indent: 0; text-align: left; width: 9em; min-width: 9em; - max-width: 9em; padding-bottom: .1em; padding-top: .1em; - padding-left: .3em; padding-right: .3em; margin-right: 3.5em; float: left; - clear: left; margin-top: 0em; margin-bottom: 0em; font-size: small; - color: black; background-color: #eeeeee; border: thin dotted gray; - font-style: normal; font-weight: normal; font-variant: normal; - letter-spacing: 0em; text-decoration: none; } - @media handheld { .sidenote, .sni { float: left; clear: none; font-weight: bold; - } } - .sni { text-indent: -.2em; } - .hidev { visibility: hidden; } - .chapter { clear: both; page-break-before: always; } - .figcenter { clear: both; max-width: 100%; margin: 2em auto; text-align: center; } - .figcenter img { max-width: 100%; height: auto; } - .id001 { width:80%; } - @media handheld { .id001 { margin-left:10%; width:80%; } } - .ig001 { width:100%; } - .table0 { margin: auto; margin-top: 2em; margin-left: 12%; margin-right: 13%; - width: 75%; } - .nf-center { text-align: center; } - .nf-center-c1 { text-align: left; margin: 1em 0; } - .c000 { margin-top: 1em; } - .c001 { page-break-before: always; margin-top: 1em; } - .c002 { margin-top: 4em; } - .c003 { page-break-before:auto; margin-top: 4em; } - .c004 { margin-top: 2em; margin-bottom: 0.5em; } - .c005 { margin-top: 0.5em; margin-bottom: 0.5em; } - .c006 { margin-left: 5.56%; margin-top: 1em; margin-bottom: 0.5em; } - .c007 { margin-left: 5.56%; margin-top: 0.5em; margin-bottom: 0.5em; } - .c008 { page-break-before:auto; margin-top: 2em; } - .c009 { text-decoration: none; } - .c010 { border: none; border-bottom: thin solid; margin-top: 0.8em; - margin-bottom: 0.8em; margin-left: 35%; margin-right: 35%; width: 30%; } - .c011 { vertical-align: top; text-align: left; padding-right: 1em; } - .c012 { vertical-align: top; text-align: right; } - .c013 { margin-top: 4em; margin-bottom: 0.5em; } - .c014 { margin-left: 5.56%; margin-top: 1em; font-size: 95%; } - .c015 { margin-top: 1em; margin-bottom: 0.5em; } - .c016 { page-break-before: always; margin-top: 2em; } - div.tnotes { padding-left:1em;padding-right:1em;background-color:#E3E4FA; - border:1px solid silver;margin:1em 5% 0 5%;text-align:justify; } - .sidenote, .sni { margin-left: 1em; margin-right: 0; float: right; clear: right; - width: 3.5em; min-width: 3.5em; max-width: 3.5em; } - </style> - </head> - <body> - - -<pre> - -Project Gutenberg's Selected Essays of Plutarch, Vol. I., by Plutarch - -This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and -most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no restrictions -whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it under the terms -of the Project Gutenberg License included with this eBook or online at -www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the United States, you'll -have to check the laws of the country where you are located before using -this ebook. - - - -Title: Selected Essays of Plutarch, Vol. I. - -Author: Plutarch - -Translator: Thomas George Tucker - -Release Date: July 11, 2020 [EBook #62618] - -Language: English - -Character set encoding: UTF-8 - -*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK SELECTED ESSAYS OF PLUTARCH *** - - - - -Produced by Turgut Dincer, David King, and the Online -Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net. (This -file was produced from images generously made available -by The Internet Archive.) - - - - - - -</pre> - - -<div class='figcenter id001'> -<span class='pageno' id='Page_on'>on</span> -<img src='images/cover.jpg' alt='' class='ig001' /> -</div> -<div class='pbb'> - <hr class='pb c000' /> -</div> -<div> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_1'>1</span> - <h1 class='c001'>Selected Essays of Plutarch</h1> -</div> - -<div class='nf-center-c1'> -<div class='nf-center c002'> - <div><span class='xxlarge'><b>SELECTED ESSAYS OF PLUTARCH</b></span></div> - <div class='c000'><span class='large'><b>TRANSLATED WITH INTRODUCTION</b></span></div> - <div class='c000'><span class='large'><b>BY</b></span></div> - <div class='c000'><span class='xxlarge'><b>T. G. TUCKER</b></span></div> - <div class='c000'><span class='large'><b>LITT.D. (CAMB.), HON. LITT.D. (DUBLIN)</b></span></div> - <div><span class='large'><b>PROFESSOR OF CLASSICAL PHILOLOGY IN THE UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE</b></span></div> - <div class='c000'><span class='xlarge'><b>Volume I.</b></span></div> - <div class='c000'>OXFORD</div> - <div>AT THE CLARENDON PRESS</div> - <div>1913</div> - </div> -</div> - -<div class='nf-center-c1'> - <div class='nf-center'> - <div><span class='pageno' id='Page_2'>2</span>HENRY FROWDE, M.A.</div> - <div>PUBLISHER TO THE UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD</div> - <div>LONDON, EDINBURGH, NEW YORK, TORONTO</div> - <div>MELBOURNE AND BOMBAY</div> - </div> -</div> - -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_3'>3</span> - <h2 class='c003'>PREFACE</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'>The essays here rendered into English have not been selected -as the very best pieces in Plutarch’s <i>Moralia</i>, but, first, as typical -examples of his writing in that kind, and, second, as covering -between them a tolerably large field of interesting matter. The -<i>Moralia</i> offer us perhaps the best of all extant material for -judging the civilization of the middle classes of society just -before and after the year 100 of our era. From them and from -Pliny’s <i>Letters</i> we are able to form a fairly complete picture of -a large part of that sounder social element which lay between -the froth and the dregs.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the Introduction some remarks are offered concerning -Plutarch’s literary style. Here it will suffice to say that the -English version does not seek to be either more formal or more -vivacious, either more imposing or more humorous, than the -original. An attempt has been made to preserve the tone as -faithfully as the substance. In making Plutarch write as he -does in the following pages the translator hopes that <i>il ne luy -a au moins rien presté qui le desmente ou qui le desdie</i>. It is fair -to add that no modern version of the <i>Moralia</i> has been consulted -for the purposes of this rendering. In the Introduction, however, -one cannot fail to owe much suggestion to Gréard and -Volkmann.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the spelling of Greek proper names every modern scholar -must follow his own best judgement. It does not follow that, -because it is necessary to say ‘Plato’ and usual to say ‘Parmenio’, -it is equally judicious to say ‘Chilo’. Nor can any -safe rule be laid down for a choice between ‘Pisistratus’ and -‘Peisistratus’. Perhaps the most advisable course is to safeguard, -as far as possible, the pronunciation of those who are -unfamiliar with Greek, and the spelling ‘Pheidias’ may do -something towards correcting the common English tendency to -pronounce the first syllable as it is pronounced in ‘fiddle’. -Notes upon the proper names will be found after the text by -readers who may require them.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_4'>4</span>The text generally adopted is that of Bernardakis in the -Teubner series, but recourse has been had throughout to -Wyttenbach, and in a number of places which are commonly -acknowledged to be corrupt the translator has ventured on -a modest emendation of his own. These places are marked -in the translation by an asterisk in the margin, and the readings -adopted will be found at the end of the book in an appendix -on the Greek text. Critics would have saved themselves much -trouble if they had observed that, though hiatus is regularly -avoided in the genuine writings of Plutarch, no hiatus is created -by a word ending in iota or upsilon, vowels which carry a semi-vowel -glide in themselves.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The orthodox order, Greek and Latin titles, and sectional -references of the pieces here chosen are as follows. The English -titles belong to the present version.</p> - -<p class='c006'><span class='sc'>On Bringing up a Boy</span> (περὶ παίδων ἀγωγῆς: <i>De liberis -educandis</i>), 1-14 <span class='fss'>C</span>.</p> - -<p class='c007'><span class='sc'>On the Student at Lectures</span> (περὶ τοῦ ἀκούειν: <i>De recta -ratione audiendi</i>), 37 <span class='fss'>C</span>-48 <span class='fss'>D</span></p> - -<p class='c007'><span class='sc'>On Fawner and Friend</span> (πῶς ἄν τις διακρίνειε τὸν κόλακα τοῦ -φίλου: <i>Quomodo adulator ab amico internoscatur</i>), 48 <span class='fss'>E</span>-74 <span class='fss'>E</span>.</p> - -<p class='c007'><span class='sc'>Advice to Married Couples</span> (γαμικὰ παραγγέλματα: <i>Coniugalia -praecepta</i>), 138 <span class='fss'>B</span>-146.</p> - -<p class='c007'><span class='sc'>Dinner-Party of the Seven Sages</span> (τῶν ἑπτὰ σοφῶν συμπόσιον: -<i>Septem sapientum convivium</i>), 146 <span class='fss'>B</span>-164 <span class='fss'>D</span>.</p> - -<p class='c007'><span class='sc'>On Garrulousness</span> (περί ἀδολεσχίας: <i>De garrulitate</i>), 502 <span class='fss'>B</span>-515.</p> - -<p class='c007'><span class='sc'>Concerning Busybodies</span> (περὶ πολυπραγμοσύνης: <i>De curiositate</i>), -515 <span class='fss'>B</span>-523 <span class='fss'>B</span>.</p> - -<p class='c007'><span class='sc'>On Moral Ignorance in High Places</span> (πρὸς ἡγεμόνα ἀπαίδευ -τον: <i>Ad principem ineruditum</i>), 779 <span class='fss'>D</span>-782 <span class='fss'>F</span>.</p> - -<p class='c007'><span class='sc'>On Old Men in Public Life</span> (εἰ πρεσβυτέρῳ πολιτευτέον: <i>An -seni respublica gerenda sit</i>), 783 <span class='fss'>B</span>-797 <span class='fss'>F</span>.</p> -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_5'>5</span> - <h2 class='c008'>INTRODUCTION</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'>The age in which Plutarch was educated and in which he -wrote his <i>Ethica</i> is, from the literary point of view, closely -similar to the so-called ‘Augustan’ age of English writing. Of -all the periods of English style and thought, he would probably -have found himself most at home in that of Pope, Addison, and -Steele, or in its continuation with Goldsmith and Johnson. -He flourished at a time when intellectual interests were remarkably -keen, if not very profound; when literature, if for the -most part it ventured on no high imaginative flights, did at -least aim at some practical bearing upon the conduct of life; -when men found entertainment, and probably some measure -of moral or social help, in the readable essay or the friendly -epistle; when facts, merely as such, were accepted as interesting -if interestingly set forth; and when Philosophy, if she deigned -to keep her feet upon the ground and to speak as one of the -mortals, met with a due welcome from either sex. An eighteenth-century -Plutarch might conceivably have written the moral -papers of Johnson without Johnson’s ponderousness, or have -contributed to the <i>Spectator</i> papers more full than Addison’s -of those ‘ideas’ in which Matthew Arnold found that writer -so deficient. He might have written, though in a prose form, -the <i>Essay on Man</i>, being meanwhile as willing as Pope to owe -the bulk of his matter to other minds, but not so willing as -Pope to play the expositor without first playing the earnest and -critical student. Plutarch did not, so far as we are aware, try -his hand at verse. To judge by his comments upon poetic -duty and by his quotations—which are regularly taken from the -best writers of a classical age already far remote—his conception -<span class='pageno' id='Page_6'>6</span>of the poetic office was too exalted to permit of his dabbling -in that domain. Had he done so, and had he followed the -fashion of his times, he would perhaps have come nearer to our -‘Augustans’ even than in his prose. In poetry it was the age -of description, reflection, satire, and moralizing, in the highest -degree sensible, studiously informed with ‘wit’—in the broader -Queen Anne sense of that word—and characterized by extreme -deftness of pointed and quotable phrase, but in no sense creative, -imaginative, or inspired. Its ideal contents consisted of ‘what -oft was thought, but ne’er so well expressed’. The attitudes -of both prose-writer and poet belonged to the intellectual and -aesthetic spirit of the period, and so far as that spirit finds an -individual embodiment in the Greek half of the Roman Empire, -it finds him in Plutarch of Chaeronea.</p> - -<p class='c005'>It would be difficult to suggest with any precision the place -which Plutarch might have filled in Victorian literature. A distinguished -and popular ‘man of letters’ and an educator of -public opinion he assuredly would have been. Given a width -of reading, a persistent self-culture, and a careful but unpedantic -style, corresponding to those which he practised in his own -generation, he might have made—as he did then—an admirable -biographer and essayist. He might have been a contributor -of substantial papers to the quarterlies and other higher reviews. -He might, and probably would, have been an eminent lecturer; -possibly, with a broad practical Christianity substituted for his -broad practical Platonism, a preacher not only eminent but also -in the best sense popular. He would certainly have made -a brilliant expositor of whatever he undertook to expound. He -was no Plato or Aristotle; he would have been no Carlyle or -Herbert Spencer; but he might have been much that Macaulay -was outside of politics.</p> - -<p class='c005'>As to the date of Plutarch’s birth there can be no certainty. -Approximately it may be put down as <span class='fss'>A. D.</span> 48. It is accepted -<span class='pageno' id='Page_7'>7</span>that his death did not occur before the year 120; it may have -taken place somewhat, though not much, later. Born in the days -of Claudius, he lived through the reigns of Nero, Galba, Otho, -Vitellius, Vespasian, Titus, Domitian, Nerva, and Trajan, and -saw at least the first three years of the rule of Hadrian. He -must have been nearly fifty before the last tyrant of the early -Empire fell, but the remainder of his life was spent under the -most beneficent régime, and amid the greatest peace and prosperity, -ever experienced in the ancient world. The <i>pax Romana</i> -was at its profoundest, the sense of security at its fullest; the -fact of general well-being was everywhere most palpable. There -was at the same time, or in consequence, a vigorous revival of -intellectual life. At no period of antiquity would it have been -possible for a man of studious habits and of mild and genial -disposition to enjoy a leisure so undisturbed or a society so -free from those forms of preoccupation which preclude an -engrossing interest in things purely of the mind. For the orator -who is fired by the natural heat of democratic politics, for the -patriotic poet from whom thrilling verse must be wrung by the -wrongs, the decline, or the yet unrealized aspirations of his -country, there was indeed no stimulation or scope. But for -the cultivation of the humanities, for the indulgence of a taste -for art and <i>belles-lettres</i>, for the satisfaction of intellectual -curiosity, for the search after interesting knowledge—physical, -mathematical, antiquarian, historical, philological—and for the -thoughtful observation of men and manners, the time was -almost ideal. In the absence of anxious and absorbing problems -of the present there was leisure for a contemplative and critical -survey of the past, and for making acquaintance with ‘the best -that had been thought and said’ by it. Since the immediate -human environment was no longer distracted and distracting -with the clamorous urgencies of external or internal strife and -danger, it was possible to look abroad over a wider field, to -<span class='pageno' id='Page_8'>8</span>contemplate the more spacious world of man and his work, -of Nature and her facts, beauties, and marvels. It was therefore -the age of the encyclopaedist, the traveller, the commentator, -the describer, the collector—collector of curiosities, of objects -of art, of books, of stories from history, of apophthegms, of -pointed and interesting quotations. The prevailing aim was -mental and social culture. This was the one object of education, -however much its professors might dissent from each other -according to the degrees of philistinism in their respective -temperaments.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The aim of contemporary education—generally realized with -more definiteness than educational aims are wont to be in -modern times—was to turn the pupil into a gentleman, to equip -him for the art of living and conducting himself as such. There -could, of course, hardly fail to be those who regarded this -<i>kalokagathia</i> too much from the exterior point of view, while -others fixed their attention more decidedly, and often perhaps -too exclusively, upon the inward and spiritual grace. There -were also considerable differences between the Greek and Roman -conceptions of a gentleman. But in the main this end was -universally avowed—to turn the raw material of the boy into -a man both capable and clubbable, whether from a public or -a private standpoint. The things to be sought were the right -accomplishments, the right morals, and the right manners. -The accomplishments included, beyond all else, literary information -and culture, argumentative dexterity, and a capacity for -speech. The right morals were based mainly upon reasoned -self-command. The right manners were chiefly those of -urbanity, dignity, and that care of the person, the voice, the -dress, and the deportment upon which all ages have insisted -according to their several lights or tastes. It might be that -the teaching ‘philosopher’, whose concern was with the -soundness of the morals, had his quarrel with the teaching -<span class='pageno' id='Page_9'>9</span>‘sophist’, whose business was with the rhetoric and its excellence -for exhibition purposes or for the gaining of various forms of -influence. The philosopher might think the sophist superficial, -showy, and often actually pernicious, while the sophist might -look upon the philosopher as visionary, pedantic, and often -a positive clog upon practical efficiency. Nevertheless no -typically cultured person of the day would have questioned -that, in order to be complete—or, as Coleridge calls it, -‘orbicular’—education must include its due measure of both -forms of teaching.</p> - -<p class='c005'>After his years of infancy the boy, under the supervision of his -<i>paedagogus</i>—ideally a slave of superior character, but too often -a person who was merely useless for harder work—passed into -a school, where he was first taught his letters and then proceeded -to the reading, learning, and recital of classical poetry, to the -study of music, and to some acquaintance with elementary -arithmetic and geometry. Next, taken in hand by the rhetorical -teacher in a higher school, he was made to write and deliver -descriptions and essays, mostly on trite and unreal themes of -a historical or pseudo-historical nature, to develop his powers -of invention on either side of a chosen topic, and to cultivate -a fastidious diction, pointed phrase, and the elocutionary -arts and graces. From artificial harangues and the ‘speaking -of a piece’ he advanced to the imaginary pleading of forensic -cases, in which the law was often as fictitious as the facts. -When, upon reaching the age for assuming the <i>toga virilis</i>, he -was emancipated from the custody of the <i>paedagogus</i> and the -discipline of the school, his formal education commonly ceased. -If he proceeded further, as many did, to what may be considered -as the equivalent of a university course, he might elect to study -philosophy, to study ‘sophistic’, or to dally with both in such -measure as seemed likely to set off the abilities or consolidate the -culture of a gentleman. Even in the more mature years of life -<span class='pageno' id='Page_10'>10</span>the intellectually-disposed grandee had a habit of maintaining -near his person a salaried philosopher as a kind of domestic -monitor, and audiences of wealth and fashion readily gathered -in Rome and elsewhere to listen to lectures on philosophy by -professors who properly understood the art of clear and pleasant -exposition. For the most part the typical Roman, less genuinely -impassioned than the Greek for thought pure and simple, -looked upon any ‘specializing’ in philosophy as likely to lead -either to too cloistered a virtue or to the acquisition of eccentric, -if not dangerous, views. A certain modicum of philosophical -knowledge might be an adornment to life, and a certain modicum -of philosophical training might impart a steadiness to character, -but the study must not be pursued to the point at which the -student himself stood in danger of becoming a ‘philosopher’. -With the Greeks philosophical specializing was commonly -subject to no such reprehension, partly because of the inborn -Hellenic ardour for study and esteem of learning, partly because -in this domain, even more than in the rhetorical, the Greeks were -the accepted teachers throughout the Roman sphere.</p> - -<p class='c005'>This, or nearly this, was the attitude of the educational world -in the first decades of the second century, and it was in this -world that Plutarch of Chaeronea became a figure of special -eminence and distinction. For in whatever light the modern -reader may regard Plutarch as a man of letters, to his own times -he was first and foremost an educator. It is from this point of -view that we must consider both his <i>Parallel Lives</i> and his -<i>Moral Essays</i>, if we are to perceive in them that unity of character -and purpose which he intended all his work to possess.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Plutarch, then, was born about <span class='fss'>A. D.</span> 48 in the very heart -of Greece, at the comparatively small town of Chaeronea, -famous as the scene of the decisive victory of the Macedonians -over the southern Greeks, and also of that in which the forces -of Mithridates were routed by Sulla. His family must have -<span class='pageno' id='Page_11'>11</span>been of high local standing, and the fact that his father—a man -of cultivated tastes and refined manners—was the owner of the -‘finest kind of horses’ is enough to show, to those who appreciate -the significance of the word <i>hippotrophia</i>, that he must -have been possessed of considerable means. The same conclusion -may be drawn both from what Plutarch himself incidentally -reveals concerning his brothers, Lamprias and Timon, as well -as other members of the family circle, and also from what is -known of his own life and upbringing. That as a boy he passed -through the orthodox curriculum, is obvious from his wide -acquaintance with literature and his intelligent, if not particularly -profound, references to both music and mathematics. -When of an age to receive an education in philosophy, he was -placed, or placed himself, chiefly under the distinguished -Ammonius, an Alexandrian philosopher of a broad semi-Platonist, -semi-Peripatetic school, who had become established -in a prominent intellectual and public position at Athens. -It was the accepted rule for the student to attend, but not -necessarily to confine himself to, the lectures of a selected -teacher. Often he lived in that teacher’s house, or at least, in -intimate connexion therewith. If the philosopher was strictly -conscientious he felt it his duty to watch over the developing -character of his pupil, to visit him with any deserved reproof,<a id='r1' /><a href='#f1' class='c009'><sup>[1]</sup></a> -to serve as his father confessor, to answer his questions, and to -meet his moral and intellectual difficulties. The familiar phrase -‘guide, philosopher, and friend’ perhaps describes the relations -with unusual exactness. We find both Plutarch and his brother -in the company of Ammonius at Delphi when Nero, in the -year 66, graced that city with his imperial and artistic presence.</p> - -<p class='c005'>His formal education completed, we discover little of the -<span class='pageno' id='Page_12'>12</span>younger manhood of Plutarch, except that he must have been -in high local estimation, partly, perhaps, from the position of -his family, but doubtless no less on account of his own conspicuous -gifts. Had this not been the case, he would hardly -have been appointed as one of a delegation of two sent on a -mission to the Roman proconsul of the province. At what age -he was first entrusted with civic functions as aedile, or with -a Delphic priesthood (then merely a ceremonial office open to -any layman), or with other public positions, we cannot say. -We can only be sure that to his learning he added a recognizable -capacity for public business. However many hours he may -have devoted to study and to the compilation of those -ample commonplace-books which evidently served him in such -good stead, he prided himself on carrying his philosophic attainments -into the local Chamber or on to the local platform. -In his judgement this procedure was not only a vindication of -philosophy and a method of keeping the faculties energetic; -it was also a patriotic duty.</p> - -<p class='c005'>As has been already said, this was an age of travel. Facilities -of transport were plentiful; the seas and main roads were secure -from pirate or enemy; journeys were at least as expeditious as -at any modern time until the employment of steam. We know -of visits made by Plutarch to Alexandria, various parts of Greece, -Rome, and the north of Italy. Rome he must have visited at -least twice, and in this metropolis and ‘epitome of the world’ -he made acquaintance with a large circle of men of distinction, -transacted public business (presumably on behalf of his native -town, of which he may have been sent as representative), -delivered lectures,<a id='r2' /><a href='#f2' class='c009'><sup>[2]</sup></a> and apparently acted as a sort of consulting -physician to morally perturbed members of Roman society. -He must have spoken always in Greek, for he confesses that—like -most other Greek writers—he had given almost no attention -<span class='pageno' id='Page_13'>13</span>to Latin; nor is any such avowal needed from a person who, -even after looking into the language, believed <i>sine patris</i> to be -the Latin for ‘without a father’. Greek, however, was then -as much the universal language of the cultured as, until recently, -French was the universal accomplishment of fashion, diplomacy, -and the traveller.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The Rome with which Plutarch was immediately acquainted -was the Rome of Vespasian and of the earlier half of Domitian’s -reign. Had his sojourn in the capital taken place some fifteen -or twenty years later, it is in the highest degree probable that -he would have been further known to us through an acquaintance -with Pliny or some other Roman writer of that date. That -a Greek, and especially one who had a difficulty in reading Latin, -should make no mention of contemporary Latin authors—that -in his heart he should rather despise them—is only characteristic -of the Hellenic attitude of the time. But that the amiable -Pliny, who has an appreciative word to say of almost every one -within his social horizon, including comparatively obscure -philosophers like Euphrates, should say nothing of so eminent -a figure as Plutarch, amounts to evidence that the two had never -met. A man who could make close friends of consulars like -Sosius Senecio and Mestrius Florus, and who enjoyed an -intimacy with Paccius and Fundanus, could not have failed to -win the notice of the Horace Walpole of his day. Quintilian, -Silius, Statius, Martial, Pliny, Suetonius, and Juvenal were all -writing when Plutarch was already the coryphaeus of Greek -culture, and if not one of them mentions his name, it is because -he was living in remote Chaeronea and forgathering only with -his chosen circle of philosophers, men of letters, artists, or -musicians in that town or in Athens, Corinth, and other Greek -centres near at hand.</p> - -<p class='c005'>To Chaeronea Plutarch must have retired by middle life. -There he married Timoxena, a lady of position, but of quiet -<span class='pageno' id='Page_14'>14</span>tastes, had issue four sons and a daughter, identified himself -with the civic and religious concerns of his town, delivered -lectures, imparted instruction on the lines of a modified or -latitudinarian Platonic philosophy, industriously read the books -in his moderate but useful library, made copious extracts therefrom, -wrote his <i>Lives</i> and those occasional papers known as his -<i>Ethica</i> or <i>Moral Essays</i>, and enjoyed the discussion of many -a knotty question—often perhaps of little or no importance -beyond the fact of its forming a problem—in the agreeable -society of his relatives or his cultivated friends and guests. -At such gatherings he was the leader, doubtless dominating the -conversation—though in his more courteous way—somewhat as -Johnson dominated the coterie described by Boswell. Often, we -gather, he varied this quiet course of life by means of excursions -to other Greek cities—Athens, Sparta, Aedepsus—where he -most probably delivered an occasional lecture, and where, as -we are certain, he thoroughly enjoyed himself in table-talk.<a id='r3' /><a href='#f3' class='c009'><sup>[3]</sup></a></p> - -<p class='c005'>That he gave philosophical education, though apparently not -of a systematic and pedagogic kind, to persons of both sexes -is known from his own references to the practice. Whether -<span class='pageno' id='Page_15'>15</span>he did so for money or not, we cannot tell. The later Platonists -by no means felt bound to adopt the attitude of Socrates and -Plato towards the taking of fees. The world had changed, and -the <i>res angusta</i> was often more powerful than a principle which -had ceased to appear entirely rational. But there is every reason -to suppose that Plutarch was a man of independent means; -we know further that a genial frugality was the rule of his -household, and that he entertained a becoming contempt for -the obsequious or the advertiser. The day of the endowed -professor, whether of philosophy or sophistic, was still to dawn -for Greece under Marcus Aurelius, and it never dawned at all -for so small a town as Chaeronea. We may take it therefore -that, whether with or without fee or present, Plutarch was able -to choose his own pupils—in all likelihood the sons and daughters -of his friends—and that, in dealing with them or with a wider -audience, he maintained the fullest dignity and independence, -and practised all the amiable candour which he explicitly -recommends.</p> - -<p class='c005'>For any lack of originality, of speculative audacity, of profundity -(or the obscurity which is so often mistaken for that -virtue), Plutarch fully compensates. To his generation he served -as a milch-cow of practical philosophy on its ethical side. He -browsed on literature and thought, secreted the most valuable -constituents, and yielded the cream to his hearers or readers. -So far as he belonged to a philosophic school, it was that of the -Old Academy. In other words, he would have labelled himself -a Platonist. It is probable that he was as much attracted by the -superb literary style of Plato, the nature of the man, and the -nobility of his conceptions, as by anything capable of crystallization -into a philosophy. These qualities attracted even the -dilettante, while in the more specially philosophic world time -had done much to refract the real Plato, to extract dogma from -him, and to create a large <i>Aberglaube</i> about his writings. Be -<span class='pageno' id='Page_16'>16</span>that as it may, there is much in Plato that Plutarch does not -accept, and there is much outside of Plato to which he gives a -welcome. Towards Stoics and Epicureans—whose doctrines, like -those of the Christians, would logically withhold men from public -activity—he is distinctly, though never virulently, hostile, and -when his pen ranges itself against particular schools, it is against -these.<a id='r4' /><a href='#f4' class='c009'><sup>[4]</sup></a> It is easier, in fact, to say to what sect Plutarch did not -belong than to associate him definitively with any other. Nevertheless -it is as a Platonist that he would have classed himself, -and it is especially by the later Neo-Platonists that he was quoted -as a divinely gifted writer who lent literary charm and potency -to wisdom. So broad, however, was his teaching, and in many -respects so adaptable even to Christianity, that early writers of -the Church had no scruple in borrowing liberally from him.<a id='r5' /><a href='#f5' class='c009'><sup>[5]</sup></a></p> - -<p class='c005'>Into whatever shape he may have systematized his views, and -however popular his treatment of them, Plutarch ranked with -the philosophers. If he was opposed to Stoicism and Epicureanism, -he was, like other philosophers, no less opposed to -sophistic. To him the representatives of that art were apt to -seem shallow and showy.<a id='r6' /><a href='#f6' class='c009'><sup>[6]</sup></a></p> - -<p class='c005'>He held, with the Socratics in general, that the basis of right -action is knowledge, and he had no belief in empiricism. Not -<span class='pageno' id='Page_17'>17</span>that he rejected either established moral views or established -religion. He was no sceptic, still less an atheist. As Friedländer -has well argued, there was no ancient cult of atheism. Plutarch, -indeed, is remarkably receptive in the matter of deities. The -Egyptian worship of Isis and Osiris, which had made great -progress throughout the Roman Empire, appeared to him -equally tenable with the worship practised by his own ancestors. -In the polytheism in which he acquiesced, such divinities were -only other forms of those known in Hellas, and he found no -difficulty in reconciling and combining the two sets of notions -and cults. He was deeply tinged with Orientalism, though his -culture and his natural good taste made him despise corybantic -demonstrations and what Friedländer has called ‘dirty mortifications’. -He held the Eranian belief in daemonic agencies, which -acted upon mankind from the one side as the gods did from the -other. If he appears to rise to the conception of ‘God’ in the -singular, the word is rather to be taken as denoting the sum of -divine wisdom and beneficent dispensation. Like all the best -minds of his own and many a previous generation, he found -moral difficulties in accepting the characters ascribed to the -deities in the best literature of earlier Greece, and therefore, -while approving of the established education in poetry, he -necessarily felt some qualms as to the possible effects. Poetry -served in the schools ‘as introduction to philosophy, history, -geography, and astronomy’, and it had much to do with the -formation of religious and ethical notions. Homer, Pindar, -Sophocles, and Menander were ‘learned and wise’, and boys -were brought to regard them as inspired. Hence Plutarch’s -treatise on <i>Poets as Moral Teachers of the Young</i>. The point -of view in that essay is not, indeed, entirely rational. It was -not so easy for Plutarch as it is for us to realize that moral and -religious ideas in Greek literature had passed through an -evolution corresponding to the development of intellect and -society. Instead of frankly recognizing the limitations of Homer -<span class='pageno' id='Page_18'>18</span>or the inconsistencies of the dramatists in this respect, he puts -a highly ingenious constraint upon the connexion between any -dubious sentiment and its context. It is only when he fails in -such a <i>tour de force</i> that he consents to censure the poet. In this -procedure he was by no means the first. The battle of the -‘takers of objection’ (προβληματικοί) and the ‘solvers of -difficulties’ (λυτικοί) was centuries old. That Plutarch should -range himself as far as possible with the solvers is a circumstance -which would naturally follow both from his love of literature -and from his constitutionally reverential temperament.</p> - -<p class='c005'>As has been often observed, the purpose running through the -<i>Parallel Lives</i> and the <i>Moral Essays</i> is one and the same. The -philosophy of Plutarch was ethical. For logic and dialectic he -shows no liking. His object was to relate philosophy to life, -to bring home a philosophy which could be lived. By philosophy -he meant the best conduct of life, based on an understanding -of the nature of virtue—τὸ καλόν, the right, the honourable, -the becoming. From philosophy we are to learn not only what -is due to ourselves, but what is due to the gods, to the laws, -to parents, children, friends, enemies, fellow-citizens, and -strangers. The <i>Essays</i>, like those of Seneca or Bacon, deal with -separable components or manifestations of right and wrong -character, with duties and circumstances: the <i>Lives</i> meanwhile -afford us concrete examples or object lessons from history.<a id='r7' /><a href='#f7' class='c009'><sup>[7]</sup></a> -Yet life, even that of a philosopher, is not made up entirely of -preaching and exhortation, least of all when the philosopher is -at the same time a man of the world and a man of letters. -Plutarch felt a lively interest in all such posers as were mooted -in the talk of the table or of the loungers’ club. He therefore -includes among his occasional papers—whether written by -<span class='pageno' id='Page_19'>19</span>request or under the fashionable fiction of a request—a number -of treatises on physical, antiquarian, literary, and artistic topics -which can hardly be said to bear with any immediateness upon -the ethical perfection of the reader. As a change, therefore, -from the treatment of <i>Superstition</i> or <i>Inquisitiveness</i> or <i>The -Restraint of Anger</i>, of <i>Rules for Married Couples</i> and <i>Rules of -Health</i> and rules for <i>The Student at Lecture</i>, he may in a spare -moment discuss such matters as <i>The Face in the Moon</i> or questions -in Roman custom.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The majority of the pieces in the present selection speak for -themselves. With the one exception to be mentioned immediately, -they all bear the impress of the man. There is the same -moral broadmindedness and sobriety, the same shrewd sense of -<i>le bonhomme Plutarque</i>, the same faculty for popularizing<a id='r8' /><a href='#f8' class='c009'><sup>[8]</sup></a> -without descending to vapidity, the same knack of relieving the -sermon by means of anecdote, quotation, or interesting item of -information at the point where the discourse threatens to become -tedious. It is true that the German critic, in his indefatigable -search for the <i>unecht</i>, has impugned the authorship of the -<i>Dinner-Party of the Seven Sages</i><a id='r9' /><a href='#f9' class='c009'><sup>[9]</sup></a> on grounds unintelligible to -those who do not expect a dinner-table conversation to be -a systematic treatise, and who are satisfied to believe that a -mixture of serious talk, banter, and narrative, and a frequent -transition of subject, are precisely the things for which one -would look on such an occasion. Every feature of the style -is Plutarchan, and, if Plutarch did not write the piece, we can -only feel unmixed regret that he did not, and unmixed surprise -that its real author should sacrifice the credit of his performance. -With the article on <i>The Bringing-up of a Boy</i> the case is different. -Wyttenbach has sufficiently pointed out its frequent feebleness -<span class='pageno' id='Page_20'>20</span>of argument, its turbid arrangement, the exceeding triteness -of its ideas, and its unaccountable omissions. To us moderns -it is of great interest for the light which it throws on the education -of the period, and for its incidental revelations of the conditions -of domestic life and the domestic affections. Otherwise -it is a puerile performance and savours of nothing but the -student essay. If it be argued that it is one of Plutarch’s juvenile -works, the answer is that it is unlike him to be disingenuous; -and disingenuous he must be, if in his early youth he pretends -to have ‘often impressed upon parents’ this or that. Antiquity -produced far too many amateur essays in imitation of great -authors—imitations actually ascribed to those authors by a -recognized fiction of the schools—for us to do an injustice to -Plutarch when an easier solution lies so close to our hands. -Perhaps, again, the piece on <i>Fawner and Friend</i><a id='r10' /><a href='#f10' class='c009'><sup>[10]</sup></a> suffers from an -occasional <i>longueur</i>, but there are few writers who do not at -some less felicitous moment perpetrate paragraphs less vivacious -than their average.</p> - -<p class='c005'>As a stylist Plutarch is apt to be underrated. He is, it is true, -no laborious atticist, and makes no point of writing like a purist -in the classic manner of a Plato or a Lysias. But this does not -mean that he is in the least negligent in either word or sentence. -On the contrary, his words are selected with extreme care, and -his sentences—where the text is sound, as for the most part -it is—are rounded off and interlinked as watchfully as any -natural writing need require. It is true that his vocabulary -is large and his expression full, but, when his words are properly -weighed and their metaphorical and other differentiations duly -perceived, no understanding reader will call him verbose.<a id='r11' /><a href='#f11' class='c009'><sup>[11]</sup></a> He -displays an immense command of language, but no word plays -<span class='pageno' id='Page_21'>21</span>an idle part, and if (like Cicero, whom in many respects he -resembles) he is fond of joining what are erroneously called -synonyms, it needs but little appreciation of verbal values to -realize that the added words invariably carry some amplification, -some more precise definition, or some emphasis helpful to -a full grasp upon the sense. It is true also that his sentences -are apt to appear—like the sentences of Ruskin’s earlier days—somewhat -lengthy; nevertheless they commonly atone by -lucidity of construction for any demand they may make upon -sustained attention.<a id='r12' /><a href='#f12' class='c009'><sup>[12]</sup></a> In a modern English dress they must -necessarily be broken up, but a practised reader of Plutarch -finds no more difficulty with them in the original than he would -find with a passage of Demosthenes or Plato. To one who -becomes familiar with them they are at least as agreeable as the -staccato brevities of Seneca. What chiefly exacts some effort -from the reader of Plutarchan Greek is the fact that its words -are extraordinarily charged with metaphor and allusion.<a id='r13' /><a href='#f13' class='c009'><sup>[13]</sup></a> His -choice of one word rather than another is always nicely calculated. -This truth once recognized, a reader cannot fail to admire both -the consistency with which the writer maintains his similitude -while he is upon it, and also the copious resources of vocabulary -upon which he draws for the purpose. Meanwhile, despite any -length of sentence and fullness of praise, Plutarch neither -irritates with tricks and mannerisms nor wearies with pedantry -and ponderousness. A pedant he could not be. He is no writer -of Johnsonese. To him the best words are those which best -suit their context, and he has no objection whatever to a dash -of the colloquial or a touch of the homely or naïve. It is one -<span class='pageno' id='Page_22'>22</span>of his characteristic merits that he knows when to take the -higher and when the lower road of diction. He also knows when -he is in danger of stylistic monotony. Plutarch was a teacher, -but, like all truly intelligent members of that profession, he -recognized that the most uninspiring attitude to adopt is the -severely and unremittingly pedagogic. ‘The knack of style,’ -it has been said, ‘is to write like a human being,’ and Plutarch, -a professor of humanity without a chair, is always and entirely -human. That his pen must have moved with extraordinary -facility is evident from the number of his publications. Apart -from his <i>Lives</i> (of which not all are extant), his <i>Moralia</i> include -over eighty pieces, long or short, and it is certain that many -others had disappeared<a id='r14' /><a href='#f14' class='c009'><sup>[14]</sup></a> before the present collection became -available in its eleventh-century MS.</p> - -<p class='c005'>It is not here implied that he is never culpable, never over-loaded. -There are times, though rare ones, at which we feel -that his memory or his notebook has been unduly exploited. -We feel that he might have spared us an illustration which does -not illustrate or a similitude which is deficient in similarity. -To a certain extent he is a Euphuist, and though Guevara -perhaps owed nothing directly to him (as he did to Seneca<a id='r15' /><a href='#f15' class='c009'><sup>[15]</sup></a>), -it is manifest that Plutarch sometimes strains a point in order -to achieve an over-ingenious comparison. The contagion of the -thing, like that of Euphuism in the Elizabethan age, was in -the air, and Plutarch assuredly does not err more often or more -heinously with one generation than Shakespeare did with another. -Wide reading and natural fecundity easily slip into sins which -narrow resources and slow invention are impotent to commit.</p> - -<hr class='c010' /> - -<p class='c005'>There are numerous signs that the pendulum of classical interest -is swinging in the direction of the literature of the early Empire. -<span class='pageno' id='Page_23'>23</span>The exclusive <i>toujours perdrix</i> of the Attic and Ciceronian -periods has apparently begun to jade the palate, and writers -like Seneca and Plutarch are coming into their own once more. -There was a time when these authors were perhaps better -known than any others. That they were worthy of prime -consideration is manifest from the immense influence which they -exercised upon the ardent and inquiring spirits of the sixteenth -and following centuries, in England no less than on the Continent. -Authors who could make such an appeal to Montaigne, to the -Elizabethan dramatists, to Bacon, or to Jeremy Taylor,<a id='r16' /><a href='#f16' class='c009'><sup>[16]</sup></a> are -surely not to be despised because they belong stylistically to -a ‘silver’ age, or because their strength lies mostly in the fact -that they are a mine of ideas, wise saws, and pointed moral -instances. Seneca, as being a writer of Latin, was naturally the -earlier and more widely read,<a id='r17' /><a href='#f17' class='c009'><sup>[17]</sup></a> but from the publication of the -<i>editio princeps</i> of Plutarch by Aldus in 1509 our author sprang into -peculiar estimation among the recovered spirits of antiquity. -It was, however, due to Amyot that both his <i>Lives</i> and his -<i>Essays</i> became accessible to those who had little or no Greek. -The <i>Essays</i> were rendered into idiomatic French by that admirable -translator in the year 1572,<a id='r18' /><a href='#f18' class='c009'><sup>[18]</sup></a> and Montaigne was by no -means the only reader among <i>nous autres ignorans</i> who made -the Plutarch of Amyot his breviary, and who ‘drew his water -incessantly’ from him. It was not the literary etiquette of the -Elizabethan age to acknowledge all the obligations one might -owe even to a contemporary, much less to the ancients, and -the stores of Plutarch might be rifled without much fear of -detection, and certainly with no fear of reproach. When Lyly, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_24'>24</span>in <i>Euphues and his Ephoebus</i>,<a id='r19' /><a href='#f19' class='c009'><sup>[19]</sup></a> takes it in hand to bring up a child -in the way he should go, he is in a large measure simply translating, -expanding, and emphasizing the pseudo-Plutarch on the -<i>Bringing-up of a Boy</i> and interspersing the discourse with -pickings from other essays, particularly that on <i>Garrulousness</i>.<a id='r20' /><a href='#f20' class='c009'><sup>[20]</sup></a> -Montaigne, of course, with his bland unreserve, credits Plutarch -via Amyot with a multitude of observations, while Bacon, -when following the new vogue of the essay, sometimes refers -us to ‘Plutarke’, and at least on one occasion informs us -that ‘Mountaigny saith’ a thing which on reference to the -said ‘Mountaigny’ we find to be Plutarchan.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Though it is no part of the present Introduction to examine -in detail the influence of the philosopher of Chaeronea upon -modern writers, or to make an inventory of his contributions to -English literature, it is at least worth asking whether an author -whom genius once delighted to exploit, and from whom so -many good things have filtered down to us through various -channels, may not be well worth reading at first hand. To Professor -Mahaffy<a id='r21' /><a href='#f21' class='c009'><sup>[21]</sup></a> Plutarch ‘is a pure and elevating writer, full -of precious information, and breathing a lofty moral tone’, -and to Professor Gilbert Murray<a id='r22' /><a href='#f22' class='c009'><sup>[22]</sup></a> he is ‘one of the most -tactful and charming of writers, and one of the most lovable -characters in antiquity’. Said Emerson<a id='r23' /><a href='#f23' class='c009'><sup>[23]</sup></a>: ‘Plutarch will be -perpetually rediscovered from time to time as long as books last.’</p> - -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_25'>25</span> - <h2 class='c003'>CONTENTS</h2> -</div> -<table class='table0' summary=''> -<colgroup> -<col width='88%' /> -<col width='11%' /> -</colgroup> - <tr> - <td class='c011'>Dinner-Party of the Seven Sages</td> - <td class='c012'><a href='#chap01'>27</a></td> - </tr> - <tr><td> </td></tr> - <tr> - <td class='c011'>On Old Men in Public Life</td> - <td class='c012'><a href='#chap02'>65</a></td> - </tr> - <tr><td> </td></tr> - <tr> - <td class='c011'>Advice to Married Couples</td> - <td class='c012'><a href='#chap03'>96</a></td> - </tr> - <tr><td> </td></tr> - <tr> - <td class='c011'>Concerning Busybodies</td> - <td class='c012'><a href='#chap04'>113</a></td> - </tr> - <tr><td> </td></tr> - <tr> - <td class='c011'>On Garrulousness</td> - <td class='c012'><a href='#chap05'>130</a></td> - </tr> - <tr><td> </td></tr> - <tr> - <td class='c011'>On the Student at Lectures</td> - <td class='c012'><a href='#chap06'>157</a></td> - </tr> - <tr><td> </td></tr> - <tr> - <td class='c011'>On Moral Ignorance in High Places</td> - <td class='c012'><a href='#chap07'>180</a></td> - </tr> - <tr><td> </td></tr> - <tr> - <td class='c011'>Fawner and Friend</td> - <td class='c012'><a href='#chap08'>187</a></td> - </tr> - <tr><td> </td></tr> - <tr> - <td class='c011'>On Bringing up a Boy</td> - <td class='c012'><a href='#chap09'>241</a></td> - </tr> - <tr><td> </td></tr> - <tr> - <td class='c011'>Notes on Persons and Places</td> - <td class='c012'><a href='#chap10'>267</a></td> - </tr> - <tr><td> </td></tr> - <tr><td> </td></tr> - <tr> - <td class='c011'>Appendix: Notes on the Greek Text</td> - <td class='c012'><a href='#appendix'>295</a></td> - </tr> -</table> -<p class='c013'><span class='pageno' id='Page_26'>26</span><i>In the following imaginary ‘Dinner-Party of the Seven Sages’ -the supposed narrator is a certain Diocles of Corinth, a professional -diviner and expiator of omens connected with the court of Periander, -who was despot of Corinth from 625</i> <span class='fss'>B. C.</span> <i>to 585</i> <span class='fss'>B. C.</span> <i>The dramatic -date is towards the close of that period. It must not be assumed -that Plutarch is pretending to be historical, and anachronisms must -be disregarded.</i></p> - -<p class='c005'><i>The Seven Sages are here Thales, Bias, Pittacus, Solon, Chilon, -Cleobulus, Anacharsis (see Notes on Persons and Places). The -list varies with different writers, but Thales, Bias, Pittacus, and -Solon are invariably, and Chilon is regularly, included in the -canon. Periander is himself sometimes made one of the number, and -a certain Myson also appears.</i></p> - -<p class='c005'><i>The qualities which constituted a ‘sage’ in this connexion were -those of keen practical sense and insight, and a power of crystallizing -the results into pithy maxims. He was not a ‘philosopher’ in -the later sense of that word.</i></p> -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_27'>27</span> - <h2 id='chap01' class='c003'>DINNER-PARTY OF THE SEVEN SAGES</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'>We <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>146 <span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> may be sure, Nicarchus, that in process of time facts -will become so obscured as to be altogether beyond ascertainment, -seeing that in the present instance, where they are so -fresh and recent, the world accepts accounts of them which are -pure concoctions. In the first place, the party at dinner did -not consist—as you have been told—merely of seven, but of -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -more than twice that number. I was myself included, both as -being professionally intimate with Periander and as the host -of Thales, who had taken up his quarters with me by Periander’s -directions. In the second place, whoever related the conversation -to you, reported it incorrectly. Presumably he was not -one of the company. Inasmuch, therefore, as I have plenty of -spare time and my years do not warrant me in putting off the -narrative with any confidence, I will—since you are all so -eager—tell you the whole story from the beginning.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Periander <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> had prepared his entertainment, not in the city, -but in the banquet-hall at Lechaeum, close to the temple of -Aphrodite, the festival being in her honour. For after having -refused to sacrifice to Aphrodite since the love-affair which led -to his mother’s suicide, he was now for the first time, thanks to -certain dreams on the part of Melissa, induced to pay honour -and court to that goddess.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Inasmuch as it was summer-time and the road all the way -to the sea was crowded with people and vehicles, and therefore -full of dust and a confusion of traffic, each of the invited guests -was supplied with a carriage and pair handsomely caparisoned. -Thales, however, on seeing the carriage at the door, simply -<span class='pageno' id='Page_28'>28</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> smiled and sent it away. Accordingly we turned off the road -and proceeded to walk quietly through the fields, a third member -of our party being Niloxenus of Naucratis, a man of high -character who had formed a close acquaintance with Solon and -Thales in Egypt. His presence was due to his having been sent -on another mission to Bias. Of its purpose he was himself -unaware, although he suspected that the sealed document of -which he was the bearer contained a second problem for solution. -He had been instructed, in case Bias could do nothing, to show -the missive to the wisest of the Greeks. ‘It is a godsend to me,’ -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> said Niloxenus, ‘to find you all here, and, as you perceive’—showing -us the paper—‘I am bringing the letter to the dinner.’ -At this Thales remarked with a laugh, ‘In case of trouble, once -more to Priene!<a id='r24' /><a href='#f24' class='c009'><sup>[24]</sup></a> For Bias will solve the difficulty, as he did -the first, without assistance.’ ‘What do you mean,’ said I, -‘by “the first”?’ ‘The king,’ replied Thales, ‘sent him an -animal for sacrifice, and bade him pick out and send back the -worst and best portion of the meat. Thereupon our friend, -with excellent judgement, took out and sent the tongue; and -he is manifestly held in high repute and admiration in consequence.’ -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>147<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> ‘That is not the only reason,’ said Niloxenus, -‘Bias does not object—as you do—to be, and to be called, a -friend of kings. In your own case the king not only admires -you on general grounds, but he was hugely delighted with your -method of measuring the pyramid. Without any fuss or the -need of any instrument, you stood your stick at the end of the -shadow thrown by the pyramid, and the fall of the sunlight -making two triangles, you showed that the pyramid stood in the -same ratio to the stick as the one shadow to the other.<a id='r25' /><a href='#f25' class='c009'><sup>[25]</sup></a> But, as -<span class='pageno' id='Page_29'>29</span>I observed, you were charged with being a king-hater, and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -certain outrageous expressions of yours concerning despots were -reported to him. For example, when asked by the Ionian -Molpagoras what was the strangest sight you had seen, you -answered, “An aged despot.” Again, at a drinking-party, -when the talk fell upon animals, you stated that among wild -animals the worst was the despot, and among tame animals -the sycophant. However much a king may claim to differ from -a despot, he does not welcome language of that kind.’ ‘Nay,’ -said Thales, ‘the former remark belongs to Pittacus, who once -made it in a playful attack on Myrsilus. My own observation <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -was that I should regard as a strange sight, not an aged despot, -but an aged navigator. None the less, my feelings at the altered -version are those of the young fellow who, after throwing at -the dog and hitting his step-mother, remarked, “Not so bad, -after all.” Yes, I regarded Solon as very wise in refusing to -act the despot. Our Pittacus also, if he had kept clear of monarchy, -would not have said that “<i>it is hard to be good</i>”. As for -Periander, his despotism may be regarded as an inherited disease, -from which he is making a creditable recovery, inasmuch as up -to the present he keeps wholesome company, cultivates the -society of sensible men, and will have nothing to say to that -“cutting down of the tall poppies” suggested by my fellow-countryman <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Thrasybulus. A despot who desires to rule over -slaves rather than men is no better than a farmer who is ready -to reap a harvest of darnel and cammock in preference to wheat -and barley. Among the many undesirable features of despotic -rule, the one desirable element is the honour and glory, in a case -where the subjects are good but the ruler is better, and where -they are great but he is regarded as greater. If he is satisfied with -safety without honour, his right course would be to rule over a -herd of sheep, horses, or oxen, not over human beings. However, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -your visitor here has launched us upon an inopportune topic. We -<span class='pageno' id='Page_30'>30</span>are walking to a dinner, and he should have remembered to moot -questions suited to the occasion. For you will doubtless admit -that there is a certain preparation necessary for the guest as well -as for the host. The people of Sybaris, I understand, send their -invitations to the women a year in advance, so that they may have -plenty of time to prepare their dress and their jewelry before -coming to dinner. In my own opinion one who is to play the -diner in the proper way requires still more time for real and true -preparation, inasmuch as it is harder to arrive at the appropriate -adornment of character than at the useless and superfluous -adornment of the person. When a man of sense comes to -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> dinner, he does not bring himself to be filled like a vessel, but -to contribute something either serious or sportive. He is to -listen or talk about such matters as the occasion asks of the -company, if they are to find pleasure in each other’s society. -An inferior dish may be put aside, and if a wine is poor, one may -take refuge with the Nymphs.<a id='r26' /><a href='#f26' class='c009'><sup>[26]</sup></a> But when your table-companion -is an ill-bred bore who gives you a headache, he utterly ruins -the enjoyment of any wine or dish or musical entertainment. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>148<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Nor have you the resource of an emetic for that kind of annoyance, -but in some cases the mutual antipathy lasts all your life, -an insulting or angry incident at your wine having resulted in -a kind of nausea. Chilon was therefore quite right when, on -receiving his invitation yesterday, he only accepted after -ascertaining the full list of the guests. As he remarked, when -people cannot help going to sea or on a campaign, and a shipmate -or tentmate proves disagreeable, they are obliged to put -up with him; but no sensible man will form one of an indiscriminate -wine-party. The mummy which the Egyptians -regularly bring in and exhibit at their parties, bidding you -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> remember that you will very soon be like it, may be an unwelcome -and unseasonable boon-companion; yet the custom -<span class='pageno' id='Page_31'>31</span>is not without its point. Even if it may not incite you to drink -and enjoy yourself, it does incite to mutual liking and regard. -“Life,” it urges, “is short in duration; do not make it long by -vexations.”’</p> - -<p class='c005'>After talk of this nature on the way we arrived at the house. -As we had anointed ourselves, Thales decided not to take a bath, -but proceeded to visit and inspect the race-tracks, the wrestling-grounds, -and the handsomely decorated park along the shore. -Not that he was greatly taken with anything of that kind, but -he would not appear to despise or slight Periander’s display <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -of public spirit. The other guests, as soon as each had anointed -himself or bathed, were being led by the servants through the -cloister into the dining-room. Anacharsis, however, was seated -in the cloister, and in front of him stood a girl, who was parting -his hair with her hands. Upon her running to meet Thales -in the frankest possible manner, he kissed her and said with -a laugh, ‘That’s right: make our foreign visitor beautiful, -so that he may not frighten us by looking like a savage, when he -is really a most civilized person.’ Upon my asking him who the -child was, he replied, ‘Don’t you know the wise and far-famed <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Eumetis? That, by the way, is her father’s name for her, -though most people call her Cleobuline, after him.’ ‘I presume,’ -said Niloxenus, ‘your compliment refers to the girl’s cleverness -in constructing riddles. Some of her puzzles have found their -way as far as Egypt.’ ‘Not at all,’ rejoined Thales. ‘Those -are merely the dice with which, on occasion, she plays a match -for fun in conversation. There is more in her than that: an -admirable spirit, a practical intellect, and an amiable character, -by which she renders her father’s rule over his fellow country-men -more gentle and popular.’ ‘Yes,’ remarked Niloxenus, ‘one <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -can see it by looking at her simplicity and unpretentiousness. -But how is it she is attending to Anacharsis so affectionately?’ -‘Because,’ was the answer, ‘he is a man of virtue and learning, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_32'>32</span>and has given her zealous and ungrudging instruction in the -Scythian manner of dieting and purging the sick. I should say -that at the present moment, while looking after the gentleman -so amiably, she is getting some lesson and talking it over.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>As we were just approaching the dining-room, we were met -by Alexidemus of Miletus, the natural son of the despot Thrasybulus. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> He was coming out in a state of excitement and angrily -muttering something which conveyed no meaning to us. When -he saw Thales he collected himself a little, stopped, and said: -‘Look how we have been insulted by Periander! He would -not allow me to take ship home when I was anxious to do so, -but begged me to stay for the dinner; and, when I come to it, -he assigns me a degrading place at table, and lets Aeolians, -islanders, and goodness knows whom, take precedence of -Thrasybulus. For since I was commissioned by Thrasybulus, it -is evident that, in my person, he means to insult and humiliate -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>149<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> him, by treating him as if he were nobody.’ ‘I see,’ said Thales, -‘what you are afraid of. In Egypt they say of the stars, according -to their increase or decrease of altitude in the regions they -traverse, that they become ‘better’ or ‘worse’ than themselves. -You are afraid that in your own case your place at table may mean -a similar loss of brightness and eminence, and you propose to -show less spirit than the Lacedaemonian, who, upon being put -by the director in the last place in a chorus, remarked, “A capital -way of making even this place one of honour.” When we take -our places,’ continued Thales, ‘we should not ask who have -seats above us, but how we are to make ourselves agreeable to -our immediate neighbours. As a means of immediately securing -a beginning of friendly feeling on their part, we should cultivate, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> or rather bring with us, instead of irritation, a tone of satisfaction -at being placed in such good company. The man who is annoyed -with his place at table is more annoyed with his next neighbour -than with his host, and he earns the dislike of both.’ ‘That,’ -<span class='pageno' id='Page_33'>33</span>retorted Alexidemus, ‘is mere talk. In practice I notice that -even you sages are greedy for precedence’—and therewith he -passed us and went off. Upon our expressing surprise at the -man’s peculiar behaviour, Thales said, ‘A crazy person, constitutionally -wrong-headed. When he was still a mere lad and -a quantity of valuable perfume had been presented to Thrasybulus, -he emptied it into a big wine-cooler, poured in some -neat wine, and drank it off, thereby bringing ill-odour upon <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Thrasybulus instead of the contrary.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>At this point an attendant came up and said, ‘Periander -requests you to take Thales here along with you and examine -an object which has just been brought to him, to see whether -it is a mere matter of accident or signifies something portentous. -He appears himself to be greatly agitated, regarding it as a -pollution, and as a smirch upon the festival.’ Whereupon he -proceeded to lead us to one of the apartments off the garden. -Here a youth, apparently a herdsman, still beardless and with -considerable handsomeness of person, opened a leather wrapper -and displayed a baby thing which he told us was the offspring -of a mare. The upper parts, as far as the neck and arms, were -human, the lower parts equine; its voice when it cried was that <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -of a new-born child. Niloxenus, exclaiming ‘Heaven help us!’ -turned away from the sight; but Thales took a prolonged look -at the young fellow, and with a smile remarked—in accordance -with his regular habit of twitting me in connexion with my -profession—‘I suppose, Diocles, you are thinking of setting your -purifications to work and giving trouble to the averting powers, -in the belief that a great and terrible thing has happened?’ -‘Of course I am, Thales,’ said I, ‘for the token indicates strife -and discord, and I am afraid it may affect no less a matter -than marriage and its issue. As you see, before we have expiated -the original offence, the goddess is giving warning of a second.’ -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> To this Thales made no answer, but began to move off—laughing. -<span class='pageno' id='Page_34'>34</span>Upon Periander coming to the door to meet us, and putting -questions as to what we had seen, Thales turned from me, -took him by the hand, and said: ‘Anything Diocles bids you -do, you will perform at your leisure. My own advice is to be -more careful as to your herdsmen.’ On hearing this speech -Periander appeared to be greatly delighted, for he burst out -laughing and hugged and kissed Thales, who observed: ‘I should -say, Diocles, that the sign has found its fulfilment already; -for you see what a serious misfortune has befallen us in the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> refusal of Alexidemus to be present at dinner.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>When we had actually entered the room, Thales, speaking -in a louder tone, said: ‘And where was the seat to which the -gentleman objected?’ Upon the place being pointed out, he -went round and occupied it himself, taking me with him, and -remarking: ‘Why, I would have paid something for the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>150<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> privilege of sharing the same table with Ardalus.’ The Ardalus -in question was a Troezenian, a flute-player and priest of the -Ardalian Muses, whose worship was established by the original -Ardalus of Troezen. Thereupon Aesop—who happened to have -arrived recently on a simultaneous mission from Croesus to -Periander and to the god at Delphi, and was present on a low -stool close to where Solon was reclining above—said, ‘A Lydian -mule, having caught sight of his reflection in a river and conceived -an admiration for the size and beauty of his body, gave -a toss of his mane and set out to run like a horse; but after -a while, reflecting that he was the son of an ass, he quickly -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> stopped his career and dropped his pride and conceit.’ At this -Chilon, speaking in broad Laconian, observed: ‘Ye’re slow -yersel, an’ ye’re running the mule’s gait.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>At this point Melissa came in and reclined beside Periander, -whereas Eumetis sat at her dinner.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Thales, addressing me—I was on the couch above Bias—said: -‘Diocles, why don’t you inform Bias that our visitor from -<span class='pageno' id='Page_35'>35</span>Naucratis has come to him again with royal problems to solve, -so that he may be sober and capable of looking after himself -when he receives the communication?’ Bias replied: ‘Nay, -our friend here has been trying for a long time to frighten me -with that warning. But I am aware that, besides his other -capacities, Dionysus is styled <i>Solver</i><a id='r27' /><a href='#f27' class='c009'><sup>[27]</sup></a> in right of wisdom. I feel <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -no fear, therefore, that my being “filled with the god” will -cause me to make a less hopeful fight of it.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>While jokes of this kind were passing between these great -men over their dinner, I was noticing that the meal was unusually -frugal, and I was led to meditate on the fact that to invite and -entertain wise and good men means no additional expense, but -rather a curtailment of it, since it eliminates fancy dishes, -out-of-the-way perfumes and sweetmeats, and lavish decantings -of costly wines. Though Periander, being a despot and a person <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -of wealth and power, indulged in such things pretty nearly -every day, on this occasion he was trying to impress the company -with a show of simplicity and modest expenditure. He put -aside and out of sight not only the display usually made in other -things, but also that used by his wife, whom he made present -herself in modest and inexpensive attire.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The tables were removed; Melissa caused garlands to be -distributed; and we poured libations. After the flute-girl had -played a short piece to accompany them, and had then withdrawn, -Ardalus, addressing Anacharsis, asked if there were any -flute-girls among the Scythians. Instantly he replied, ‘No, nor <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -yet vines.’ When Ardalus rejoined: ‘Well, but the Scythians -have gods;’ ‘Quite true,’ said he: ‘gods who understand -human language. We are not like the Greeks, who imagine they -speak better than the Scythians, and yet believe that the gods -would rather listen to pieces of bone and wood.’ ‘Ah,’ said -<span class='pageno' id='Page_36'>36</span>Aesop, ‘what if you knew, Sir Visitor, that the present-day -flute-makers have given up using the bones of fawns and have -taken to those of asses? They maintain that these sound better—a -fact which explains Cleobuline’s riddle upon the Phrygian -flute: <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>With a shin that was horned</i></div> - <div class='line in2'><i>Did an ass that was dead</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Deal a blow on my ear.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>It is a wonderful thing that the ass, who is otherwise particularly -crass and unmusical, should supply us with a bone particularly -fine and melodious.’ ‘Now that,’ said Niloxenus, ‘is precisely -the objection which the Busirites bring against us of Naucratis; -for asses’ bones for flutes are already in use with us. With them, -on the contrary, it is profanation even to listen to a trumpet, -because it sounds like the bray of an ass. You know, I presume, -that the ass is treated contemptuously by the Egyptians because -of Typhon?’</p> - -<p class='c005'>A silence here occurred, and, as Periander perceived that -Niloxenus, though eager to enter upon the subject, was shy -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>151<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> of doing so, he said: ‘To my mind, gentlemen, it is a commendable -practice, whether of community or ruler, to take the -business of strangers first and of citizens afterwards. On the -present occasion, therefore, I propose that for a short time we -suspend any topics of our own, as being local and familiar, and -that we treat ourselves as an Assembly and ‘grant an audience’ -to those royal communications from Egypt, of which our -excellent friend Niloxenus is the bearer to Bias, and which -Bias desires that you should join him in considering.’ ‘Yes,’ -said Bias: ‘for where, or with whom, could one more readily -face the risk—if it must be faced—of answering in a case like -this, especially when the king’s instructions are that, though -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the matter is to begin with me, it is to go the round of you all?’ -Niloxenus thereupon offered him the document, but Bias bade -<span class='pageno' id='Page_37'>37</span>him open it himself and read every word to the whole company. -The contents of the letter were to the following effect:</p> - -<p class='c006'><span class='sc'>Amasis, King of Egypt, to Bias, wisest of the Greeks</span></p> - -<p class='c007'><i>The King of Ethiopia is engaged in matching his wits against -mine. Hitherto he has had the worst of it, but has finally concocted -a terrible poser in the shape of a command that I should ‘drink -up the sea’. If I meet it with a solution, I am to have a number -of his villages and towns. If not, I am to surrender the cities in the -neighbourhood of Elephantine. Do you, therefore, take the matter <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -in hand and send Niloxenus back to me at once. Any return which -friends or countrymen of yours require from me will be made without -hesitation on my part.</i></p> - -<p class='c015'>This part of the letter having been read, Bias was not long in -answering. After a few moments of meditation and a brief -conversation with Cleobulus, who was close to him at table, he -said: ‘Do you mean to say, my friend from Naucratis, that -Amasis, though reigning over so many subjects and possessed -of so large and excellent a country, will be ready to drink up -the sea in order to win a few miserable insignificant villages?’ -‘Take it that he will, Bias,’ replied Niloxenus, ‘and consider -how it can be done.’ ‘Very well then,’ said he: ‘let him tell <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the Ethiopian <i>to stop the rivers that run into the ocean, while -he is himself drinking up the sea at present existing</i>. The command -applies to the sea as it is, not as it is to be later on.’ Bias no -sooner made this speech than Niloxenus was so delighted that -he rushed to embrace and kiss him. After the rest of the company -had cheered and applauded, Chilon said with a laugh, -‘Sir Visitor from Naucratis, before the sea is all drunk up and -lost, set sail and tell Amasis not to be asking how to make away -with all that brine, but rather how to render his kingship sweet -and drinkable for his subjects. Bias is a past master at teaching <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -such a lesson, and, if Amasis learns it, he will have no further -<span class='pageno' id='Page_38'>38</span>occasion for his golden footpan<a id='r28' /><a href='#f28' class='c009'><sup>[28]</sup></a> in dealing with the Egyptians. -They will all be courting and making much of him for his -goodness, even if he is declared to be of a thousand times lower -birth than he actually is.’ ‘Yes, and by the way,’ said Periander, -‘it would be a good thing if all—“man after man”, as Homer -has it—were to contribute a similar offering to His Majesty. -A bonus of the kind thrown in would not only make the returns -on his venture more valuable to him, but would also be the best -thing in the world for us.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Chilon thereupon asserted that Solon was the right man to -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> make a beginning on the subject, not only because he was -senior to all the rest and was in the place of honour at the table, -but because, having legislated for the Athenians, he held the -greatest and completest position as a ruler. At this Niloxenus -remarked quietly to me, ‘People believe a good deal that is -false, Diocles; and they mostly take a delight in inventing for -themselves, and in accepting with avidity from others, mischievous -stories about wise men. For instance, it was reported -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>152<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> to us in Egypt that Chilon had cancelled his friendship and -his relations of hospitality with Solon, because Solon declared -that laws were alterable.’ At this I answered, ‘The story is -ridiculous; for in that case Chilon ought to begin by disclaiming -Lycurgus and all his laws, as having altered the whole -Lacedaemonian constitution.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>After a brief delay Solon said: ‘In my opinion a king or -despot would win most renown <i>by furnishing his fellow-citizens -with a popular, in place of a monarchical, government</i>.’ The -second to speak was Bias, who said: ‘<i>By identifying his behaviour -with the laws of his country.</i>’ Thales came next with the statement -that he considered a ruler happy ‘<i>if he died naturally -of old age</i>‘. Fourth Anacharsis: ‘<i>If good sense never failed him.</i>’ -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Fifth Cleobulus: ‘<i>If he trusted none of those about him.</i>’ Sixth -<span class='pageno' id='Page_39'>39</span>Pittacus: ‘<i>If the ruler could get his subjects to fear, not him, but <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for him.</i>’ Next Chilon said that ‘<i>the ruler’s conceptions should -never be mortal, but always immortal</i>‘.</p> - -<p class='c005'>After hearing these dicta, we claimed that Periander himself -should express an opinion. With anything but cheerfulness, -and pulling a serious face, he replied: ‘Well, the opinion I have -to add is that every one of the views stated practically disqualifies -a man of sense from being a ruler.’ Whereupon Aesop, as if in a -spirit of reproof, said, ‘You ought, of course, to have discussed -this subject by yourselves, and not to have delivered an attack -upon rulers under pretence of being their advisers and friends.’ <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -‘Don’t you think,’ said Solon, taking him by the head and -smiling, ‘that one can make a ruler more moderate and a despot -more reasonable by persuading him that it is better to decline -such a position than to hold it?’ ‘And pray who,’ he replied, -‘is likely to follow you in the matter rather than the God, whose -opinion is given in the oracle delivered to yourself:</p> - -<p class='c006'><i>Blessèd the city that hearkens to one commander’s proclaiming.</i>’</p> - -<p class='c015'>‘True,’ said Solon, ‘but, as a matter of fact, the Athenians, -though with a popular government, do listen to one proclaimer <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -and ruler in the shape of the law. You have a wonderful gift -at understanding ravens and jackdaws, but your hearing of the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -voice of modesty is indistinct. While you think that a state -is best off when it listens, as the God says, to “one”, you believe -that the best convivial party is that in which everybody talks -on every subject.’ ‘Yes,’ said Aesop, ‘for you have not yet -legislated to the effect that “<i>a slave shall not get tipsy</i>” is to -stand on the same footing with those Athenian ordinances of -yours which say “<i>a slave shall not indulge in love or in dry-rubbing -with oil</i>”.’<a id='r29' /><a href='#f29' class='c009'><sup>[29]</sup></a> At this Solon broke into a laugh, and -<span class='pageno' id='Page_40'>40</span>Cleodorus the physician remarked: ‘But, in one respect, -talking when the wine is taking effect does stand on the same -footing with dry-rubbing—it is very pleasant.’ ‘Consequently,’ -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> broke in Chilon, ‘it is the more to be avoided.’ ‘Yes,’ said -Aesop again,<a id='r30' /><a href='#f30' class='c009'><sup>[30]</sup></a> ‘Thales did appear to recommend getting old -as quickly as possible.’ Periander laughed, and said: ‘Aesop, -we have been properly punished for dropping into other -questions before bringing forward the whole of those from -Amasis, as we proposed. Pray look at the rest of the letter, -Niloxenus, and take advantage of the gentlemen being all here -together.’ ‘As for that,’ replied Niloxenus, ‘whereas the command -sent by the Ethiopian can only be called a “doleful -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> dispatch”—as Archilochus would say—your friend Amasis has -shown a fine and more civilized taste in setting such problems. -He bade him name the oldest thing, the most beautiful, the -greatest, the wisest, the most universal, and—not stopping there—the -most beneficent, the most harmful, the most powerful, and -the easiest.’ ‘Well, and did his answers give the solution in -each case?’ ‘His replies were these,’ said Niloxenus. ‘It is -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>153<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> for you to listen and judge; for the king is very anxious neither -to be guilty of pettifogging with the answers, nor to let any -slip on the part of the answerer escape without refutation. -I will read you the replies as given. <i>What is the oldest thing?</i>—<i>Time.</i> -<i>What the greatest?</i>—<i>The universe.</i> <i>What the wisest?</i>—<i>Truth.</i> -<i>What the most beautiful?</i>—<i>Light.</i> <i>What the most -universal?</i>—<i>Death.</i> <i>What the most beneficent?</i>—<i>God.</i> <i>What the -most harmful?</i>—<i>Evil genius.</i> <i>What the strongest?</i>—<i>Fortune.</i> -<i>What the easiest?</i>—<i>That which is pleasant.</i>’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Well, Nicarchus, after the reading of this second passage -there was a silence. Then Thales asked Niloxenus if Amasis -was satisfied with the solutions. Upon his replying that he had -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> accepted some, but was dissatisfied with others, Thales said, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_41'>41</span>‘And yet not one of them is unassailable. There are great -blunders and signs of ignorance all through. For instance, -how can Time be the oldest thing, seeing that, while some of it -is past and some present, some of it is future? Time which is -to come after us must be regarded as younger than the events -and persons of the present. Again, to call Truth wisdom -appears to me as bad as making out that the light is the eye. -Next, if he considered Light beautiful—as indeed it is—how -came he to ignore the sun? As for the rest, the answer concerning -gods and evil spirits is bold and dangerous, while in that <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -concerning Fortune the logic is exceedingly bad. Fortune -would not be so readily upset if it was the strongest and most -powerful thing in existence. Nor yet again is Death the most -universal thing, for in the case of the living it has no existence. -However, to avoid seeming merely to criticize the work of others, -let us express views of our own and compare them with his. -I am ready to be the first to be questioned point by point, if -Niloxenus so desires.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>In relating the questions and answers I will put them exactly -as they occurred. <i>What is the oldest thing?</i> ‘<i>God</i>,’ said Thales: -‘for He is without birth.’ <i>What is greatest?</i> ‘<i>Space</i>: for <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -while the universe contains everything else, it is space that -contains the universe.’ <i>What is most beautiful?</i> ‘<i>The cosmos</i>: -for everything duly ordered is part of it.’ <i>What is wisest?</i> -‘<i>Time</i>: for it is Time that has either discovered things or will -discover them.’ <i>What most universal?</i> ‘<i>Expectation</i>: for -those who have nothing else have that.’ <i>What most beneficent?</i> -‘<i>Virtue</i>: for it makes other things beneficent by using them -rightly.’ <i>What most harmful?</i> ‘<i>Vice</i>: for most things suffer -from its presence.’ <i>What most powerful?</i> ‘<i>Necessity</i>: for it is -invincible.’ <i>What most easy?</i> ‘<i>The natural</i>; not pleasure, for -people often fail to cope with that.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>The whole company being satisfied with Thales and his <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -<span class='pageno' id='Page_42'>42</span>acumen, Cleodorus observed: ‘It is questions and answers of -this kind, Niloxenus, that are proper for kings. On the other -hand, the barbarian who gave Amasis the sea to drink, required -the short answer made by Pittacus to Alyattes, when he wrote -the Lesbians a letter containing an arrogant command. The -reply was merely a recommendation to eat onions and hot -bread.’<a id='r31' /><a href='#f31' class='c009'><sup>[31]</sup></a></p> - -<p class='c005'>Here Periander joined in; ‘I may remind you, Cleodorus, -that even in old times the Greeks had a habit of posing each -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> other with similar difficulties. We are told, for instance, -that there was a gathering at Chalcis of the most distinguished -poets among the wise men of the day, in order to celebrate -the funeral of Amphidamas—a great warrior who had given -much trouble to the Eretrians and had fallen in the fighting for -Lelantum. The verses composed by the poets were so well -matched, that it became a difficult and troublesome matter to -judge between them, and the reputation of the competitors—Homer -and Hesiod—caused the jury much diffidence and -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>154<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> embarrassment. Thereupon they had recourse to questions of -the present kind, and Homer—as Lesches tells us—propounded -the following:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Tell me, Muse, of such things as neither before have befallen,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Nor shall hereafter befall?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>To which Hesiod instantly replied:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>When in eager pursuit of the prize the chariots, one ’gainst the other</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Are dashed by the ringing-hoof’d steeds round the tomb where Zeus lieth buried.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>This answer, it is said, won particular admiration and secured -him the tripod.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>‘But pray what is the difference,’ asked Cleodorus, ‘between -<span class='pageno' id='Page_43'>43</span>such questions and Eumetis’s riddles? It is no doubt right <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -enough for her to set women such puzzles by way of amusement, -constructing them as other women plait their bits of girdles or -hair-nets. But for sensible men to treat them with any seriousness -is absurd.’ Eumetis would apparently have liked to make -some retort, but she was too shy, and checked herself, her face -mantled with blushes. ‘Nay,’ said Aesop, by way of championing -her, ‘it is surely more absurd to be unable to solve them. -Take for example the one she set us just before dinner:</p> - -<p class='c006'><i>I saw a man glue bronze on a man; with fire did he glue it.</i></p> - -<p class='c015'>Can you tell me what that means?’ ‘No, and I don’t want <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -to be told either,’ answered Cleodorus. ‘And yet,’ said Aesop, -‘no one is so familiar with the thing, or does it so well, as you. -If you deny it, cupping-glasses<a id='r32' /><a href='#f32' class='c009'><sup>[32]</sup></a> will bear me out.’ At this -Cleodorus laughed, for he made more use of cupping-glasses -than any medical man of the day, and the estimation in which -that remedy is held is especially due to him. ‘I beg to ask, -Periander,’ said Mnesiphilus the Athenian, a close friend and -admirer of Solon, ‘that the conversation, like the wine, shall -not be limited to wealth or rank, but shall be put on a democratic -footing and made to concern all alike. In what has just been <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -said about wealth and kingship there is nothing for us commoners. -We think, therefore, that you should take a government with -equal rights, and each of you again contribute some opinion, -beginning once more with Solon.’ It was decided that this -should be done. First came Solon. ‘Well, Mnesiphilus, you, -like every other Athenian, have heard what opinion I hold -about such a government. But if you desire to hear it again now, -it seems to me that a community is in the soundest condition, -and its popular government most securely maintained, <i>when the -wrongdoer is accused and punished quite as much by those who <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -<span class='pageno' id='Page_44'>44</span>have not been wronged as by the man that has</i>.’ The second to -speak was Bias, who said that the best popular government is -‘<i>that in which every one fears the law as he would a despot</i>.’ -Next came Thales with ‘<i>that in which there are no citizens either -too rich or too poor</i>.’ Anacharsis followed with ‘<i>that in which, -while everything else is treated as equal, superiority is determined -by virtue and inferiority by vice</i>.’ In the fifth place Cleobulus -affirmed that a democracy is most soundly conducted ‘<i>when its -public men are more afraid of blame than of the law</i>‘. Sixth, -Pittacus: ‘<i>Where the bad are not permitted to hold office and the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> good are not permitted to decline it.</i>’ Last of all Chilon expressed -the view that the best free government is ‘<i>that which pays least -attention to the orators and most to the laws</i>.’ Periander once more -summed up at the end by saying that they all appeared to him -to be praising ‘that democratic government which most -resembled an aristocratic.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Upon the conclusion of this second discussion I begged that -they would also tell us the proper way to deal with a household; -‘for while there are few who are at the helm of a kingdom or -a commonwealth, we all play our parts in the hearth and home.’ -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>155<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> At this Aesop said with a laugh: ‘No! not if in “all” you -include Anacharsis. He has no home, but actually prides himself -on being homeless, and on using a wagon—in the same way -as they tell us the sun roams about in a chariot, occupying first -one and then another region of the sky.’ ‘Yes,’ retorted -Anacharsis, ‘and that is why, unlike any other—or more than -any other—god, he is free and independent, ruling all and ruled -by none, but always playing the king and holding the reins. -You, however, fail to realize the surpassing beauty and marvellous -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> size of his car, otherwise you would not have tried to raise a -laugh by jocosely comparing it with ours. It seems to me, -Aesop, that to you a home means those coverings of yours made -by clay and wood and tiles. You might as well regard a “snail” -<span class='pageno' id='Page_45'>45</span>as meaning the shell instead of the animal. It is therefore natural -that you should find cause to laugh at Solon, when he beheld -all the costly splendour in the house of Croesus and yet refused -to declare off-hand that its possessor was happy and blessed -in his home; “for”—he argued—“I am more desirous of -looking at the fine things in the man than at those in his house.” -It appears, moreover, that you have forgotten your own fox. -That animal, when she and the leopard were engaged in a dispute -as to which was the more “cunningly marked”, begged the -judge to examine her on the inside, inasmuch as she would be -found to possess more “marks of cunning” from that point -of view. But you go inspecting the productions of carpenters <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -and stone-masons, and regarding those as the “home”, instead -of the inward and domestic constituents in the case—the -children, wife, friends, and servants. If these have good sense -and good morals, a man who shares his best means with them -possesses a good and happy home, even if it be but an ant-hill -or a bird’s-nest.’ ‘That,’ he continued, ‘is my answer to Aesop -and my contribution to Diocles. But it is only fair that each -of the others should express his own views.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Thereupon Solon said that in his opinion the best household -was ‘<i>that in which the resources are acquired without dishonesty, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -watched over without distrust, and expended without repentance</i>‘. -According to Bias it was ‘<i>that inside which the master behaves -for his own sake as well as he does outside for the law’s sake</i>‘. -According to Thales, ‘<i>that in which the master can find most time -to himself</i>‘. According to Cleobulus, ‘<i>where the master has more -who love than fear him</i>.’ Pittacus would have it that the best -house is ‘<i>that which wants no luxury and lacks no necessity</i>‘. -Chilon’s view was that the house should be ‘<i>as like as possible -to a state ruled by a king</i>‘, and he went on to observe that when -some one urged Lycurgus to establish a republic at Sparta, he <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -answered: ‘You begin by creating a republic at home.’</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_46'>46</span>This topic also having been dealt with, Eumetis left the room -in company with Melissa. Periander then pledged Chilon in -a capacious goblet, and Chilon in turn pledged Bias. At this -Ardalus got up, and, addressing Aesop, said: ‘Perhaps you -will be good enough to pass yonder cup on to us, seeing that -these gentlemen are passing theirs to each other, as if it were -a Bathycles’s goblet,<a id='r33' /><a href='#f33' class='c009'><sup>[33]</sup></a> and are giving no one else a turn.’ ‘Nay,’ -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>F<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> replied Aesop, ‘there is to be nothing democratic about this -cup either, for Solon has been keeping it all to himself for quite -an age.’ Thereupon Pittacus, addressing Mnesiphilus, asked -why Solon, by not drinking, was testifying against the verses -in which he had written</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Now do I welcome the tasks of the Cyprus-born goddess and Bacchus,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>And tasks of the Muses that bring cheer to the heart of mankind.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>‘Because,’ said Anacharsis, before Mnesiphilus could speak, -‘he is frightened at that cruel law of your own, Pittacus, where -the words run, <i>If any one commit any offence when drunk, the -penalty to be double that paid by a man who was sober.</i>’ ‘And -you,’ retorted Pittacus, ‘showed such wanton contempt of -the law that last year, when you had got intoxicated at that -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>156<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> party at Delphi, you asked for a prize and a victor’s wreath.’ -‘And why not?’ asked Anacharsis. ‘A prize was offered to -him who drank most, and, since I was the first to get tipsy, -I, of course, claimed the reward of victory. Otherwise will you -gentlemen tell me what is the end and aim of drinking a large -quantity of unmixed wine, if it is not to get intoxicated?’ -Pittacus laughed, while Aesop told the following story. ‘A wolf, -having seen some shepherds eating a sheep in a tent, came close -up to them, and said: “What a to-do you would have made -<span class='pageno' id='Page_47'>47</span>if <i>I</i> had been doing that!”’ At this Chilon remarked, ‘Aesop -has properly taken his revenge. A moment ago we put the -muzzle on him, and now he sees that others have taken the words -out of Mnesiphilus’ mouth. It was Mnesiphilus who was -requested to answer on behalf of Solon.’ ‘Well, in doing so,’ -said Mnesiphilus, ‘I speak with knowledge. In Solon’s opinion <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the concern of every art and faculty of man or God is with -results rather than with agencies, the end rather than the -means. A weaver, I take it, would consider his object to be -a cloak or mantle rather than the arrangement of his shuttle-rods -or the picking-up of his straightening-stones. To a blacksmith -it is rather the welding of iron and putting an edge on an -axe than any of the processes necessary thereto, such as the -kindling of his charcoal or the preparation of lime. Still more -would a master-builder object if, instead of a ship or a house, -we declared his object to be the boring of wood or the mixing -of mortar. The Muses would utterly scout the notion that their <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -concern is with a harp or flute, instead of with the cultivation -of character and the soothing of the emotions of their votaries -by means of melodies properly attuned. So—to come to the -point—the object of Aphrodite is not sexual intercourse, nor -that of Dionysus wine and tipsiness, but the friendly feeling, -the longing, the companionship, and the close mutual understanding -which they produce in us by those agencies. These -are what Solon calls divine “tasks”, and he means that these -are the objects which he appreciates and cultivates in his -old age. Of reciprocal affection between men and women -Aphrodite is the creator, using pleasure as the means of melting -and commingling their souls at the same time with their bodies; -while in ordinary cases, where persons are not very intimate or -particularly acquainted, Dionysus uses wine as a kind of fire -to soften and supple their dispositions, and so provides a starting-point -towards a blending in mutual friendship.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_48'>48</span>‘But when such men meet together as Periander has invited -in your persons, there is no need, I take it, of the goblet and the -wine-ladle. The Muses set before you all, in the form of conversation, -a mixing-bowl containing no intoxicant and yet -abundance of pleasure, grave or gay. In this they stir friendly -feeling, blend it, and pour it forth, while for the most part the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> ladle is allowed to lie undisturbed “above the bowl”—a thing -which Hesiod forbids where the company is better qualified -for drinking than for conversation.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>‘As for pledging one another,’ he continued, ‘I gather that -with the ancients the ceremony consisted of one large goblet -going the round, each man drinking a measured “allowance” -(as Homer tells us), and then letting his neighbour take his -share, as he would do with a sacrificial portion.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>When Mnesiphilus had finished, the poet Chersias—who had -ceased to be under censure and had lately been reconciled to -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Periander through Chilon’s intercession—remarked, ‘Are we -also to understand that, when the gods were the guests of Zeus -and were pledging each other, he poured in their drink by -measure, as Agamemnon did for his chieftains?’ ‘And pray, -Chersias,’ said Cleodorus, ‘if Zeus has his ambrosia brought—as -you poets say he does—by doves which find the greatest -difficulty in flying over the Clashing Rocks, don’t you think -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>157<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> that his nectar is also scarce and hard to get, and that consequently -he is sparing of it and doles it out economically?’ -‘Perhaps so,’ replied Chersias. ‘Since, however, the question of -household economy has again been mooted, perhaps some one -will deal with the remainder of the question. And that, I take -it, is to discover what amount of property will be sufficient to -meet all needs.’ ‘To the wise man,’ said Cleobulus, ‘the law -has supplied the standard; but in reference to weak characters -I will repeat a story which my daughter told her brother. -The Moon, she said, asked her mother to weave a tunic to fit -<span class='pageno' id='Page_49'>49</span>her; whereat the mother answered, “How can I possibly <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -weave one to fit? At one time I see you as a full moon, at -another as a crescent, and at another gibbous.” Similarly, my -dear Chersias, there is no way of determining the amount of -means requisite for a weak and foolish person. His wants vary -with his appetites and experiences, his case being that of -Aesop’s dog, of whom our friend says that in winter he huddled -and curled himself up with the cold, and contemplated making -a house; but in summer it was different; he stretched himself -out when he slept, thought himself a big fellow, and decided -that it was both a laborious and an unnecessary task to build so -large a house to cover him. Don’t you observe, Chersias’—he -went on—‘that even insignificant people, though they will at -one moment draw themselves into a very modest compass, with -the idea of living a close and simple Spartan life, at another <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -time will fancy they are going to die of want unless they have -all the money in the world—all the king’s and all the private -people’s?’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Chersias having nothing to say, Cleodorus joined in. ‘Well, -but,’ he said, ‘I perceive that there is no equal distribution in -the properties which even you sages respectively possess.’ ‘Yes, -my dear sir,’ said Cleobulus, ‘because the law, like a weaver, -allots us the amount which properly and reasonably fits each case. -In your own profession, substituting reason for law, you feed <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -and diet and physic the sick by prescribing, not the same -quantity for everybody, but the proper quantity for each case.’ -Here Ardalus interposed. ‘I suppose, then,’ he asked, ‘it is at -the bidding of some law that Epimenides—the friend of you -gentlemen and the guest of Solon—abstains from other kinds -of food and passes the day without breakfast or dinner by merely -putting in his mouth a little of that “anti-hunger essence” -which he makes up for himself?’ This remark having arrested -the attention of the party, Thales mockingly observed that -<span class='pageno' id='Page_50'>50</span>Epimenides was a sensible man for refusing to be troubled—as -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Pittacus was—with grinding and cooking his own food. -‘You must know,’ he said, ‘that when I was at Eresus, I heard -my hostess singing to the mill:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Grind, mill, grind;</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>For Pittacus is grinding,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>As he kings it over great Mytilene.</i>’</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Then Solon expressed his surprise that Ardalus had not read the -law ordaining the diet in question, seeing that it was written -in the verses of Hesiod. ‘For it is he who first supplied -Epimenides with hints for that form of nourishment, by -teaching him to make trial <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<p class='c006'><i>How great and sustaining the food that in mallow and asphodel lieth.</i></p> - -<p class='c015'>‘Nay,’ said Periander, ‘do you imagine Hesiod conceived of -anything of the kind? Don’t you suppose that, with his habitual -praise of economy, he is merely urging us to try the most frugal -dishes as being the most agreeable? The mallow makes good -eating, and asphodel-stalk is sweet; but I am told that anti-hunger -and anti-thirst drugs—for they are drugs rather than -foods—include among their ingredients some sort of foreign -honey and cheese, and a large number of seeds which are -difficult to procure. Most certainly, therefore, Hesiod would -find that the “<i>rudder</i>” hung “<i>above the smoke</i>” and</p> - -<p class='c006'><i>The works of the drudging mules and the oxen’s labour would perish</i>,</p> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>158<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> if all that provision is to be made. I am surprised, Solon, if -your guest, on recently making his great purification of Delos, -failed to note how they present to the temple—as commemorative -samples of the earliest form of food—mallow and asphodel-stalk -along with other cheap and self-grown produce. The -natural reason for which Hesiod also recommends them to us -<span class='pageno' id='Page_51'>51</span>is that they are simple and frugal.’ ‘Not only so,’ remarked -Anacharsis, ‘but both vegetables bear the highest possible -character for wholesomeness.’ ‘You are quite right,’ said -Cleodorus. ‘That Hesiod possessed medical knowledge is -manifest from the careful and well-informed manner in which -he speaks about diet, the mixing of wine, good quality in water, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -bathing, women, and the way to seat infants. But it seems to -me that there is more reason for Aesop to declare himself -a pupil of Hesiod than there is for Epimenides. It is to the -speech of the hawk to the nightingale that our friend owes -the first promptings to his admirably subtle wisdom in many -tongues. But for my part I should be glad to hear what Solon -has to say. We may assume that, in his long association with -Epimenides at Athens, he asked him what motive or subtle -purpose he had in adopting such a diet.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>‘What need was there to ask him that question?’ replied -Solon. ‘It was self-evident that the next best thing to the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -supreme and greatest good is to require the least possible food. -You allow, I suppose, that the greatest good is to require no -food at all?’ ‘Not I, by any means,’ answered Cleodorus, -‘if I am to say what I think, especially with a table in front of -us. Take away food, and you take away the table—that is to -say, the altar of the Gods of Friendship and Hospitality. As -Thales tells us that, if you do away with the earth, the whole -cosmos will fall into confusion, so the abolition of food means -the dissolution of house and home. For with it you do away -with the hearth-fire, the hearth, the wine-bowl, all entertainment -and hospitality—the most humanizing and essential -elements in our mutual relations. Or rather you do away -with the whole of life, if life is “<i>a passing of the time on the part <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -of a human being involving a series of actions</i>”, most of those -actions being evoked by the need, and in the acquirement, of -food. Of immense importance, my good friend, is the question -<span class='pageno' id='Page_52'>52</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> of mere agriculture. Let agriculture perish, and the earth -that it leaves us becomes unsightly and foul, a corrupt wilderness -of barren forest and vagabond streams. The ruin of agriculture -means the ruin of all arts and crafts as well; for she takes the -lead of them, and provides them with their basis and their -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> material. Do away with her, and they count for nothing. There -is an end also to our honouring the gods. Men will thank the -Sun but little, and the Moon still less, for mere light and warmth. -Where will you find altar or sacrifice to Zeus of the Rain, -Demeter of the Plough, or Poseidon the Fosterer of Plants? -How can Dionysus be Boon-Giver, if we need nothing that he -gives? What sacrifice or libation shall we make? What offering -of firstfruits? All this means the overthrow and confounding -of our most important interests. Though to cling to every -pleasure in every case is to be a madman, to avoid every pleasure -in every case is to be a block. By all means let the soul have -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> other pleasures of a superior kind to enjoy; the body can find -no pleasure more right and proper than that derived from -taking food. All the world recognizes the fact, for this pleasure -people take openly, sharing with each other in the table and the -banquet, whereas their amorous pleasure is screened by night -and all the darkness possible. To share that pleasure with others -is considered as shameless and brutelike as it is not to share in -the case of the table.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Here, as Cleodorus paused for a moment, I joined in: ‘And -is there not another point—that in discarding food we also -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>159<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> discard sleep? If there is no sleep, there is no dreaming either, -and we lose our most important means of divination. Moreover, -life will be all alike, and there will be practically no purpose -in wearing a body round our soul. Most of its parts, and the -most important, are provided as instruments to feeding—the -tongue, teeth, stomach, and liver. None of them is without its -work, and none has other business to attend to. Consequently -<span class='pageno' id='Page_53'>53</span>any one who has no need of food has no need of a body -either. Which means that a person has no need of himself; -for it is thanks to the body that each of us is a “self”.’ ‘Such,’ -I added, ‘are our contributions on behalf of the belly. If Solon -or any one else has objections to bring, we will listen.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>‘Of course I have objections,’ replied Solon. ‘I have no <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -wish to be thought a poorer judge than the Egyptians. After -cutting open a dead body, they take out the entrails and expose -them to the sunlight. They then throw those parts into the -river and proceed to attend to the rest of the body, which is -now regarded as purified. Yes, therein in truth lies the pollution -of our flesh. It is its Tartarus—like that in Hades—full of -“dreadful streams”, a confused medley of wind and fire and -of dead things. For while itself lives, nothing that feeds it can -be alive. We commit the wrong of murdering animate things -and of destroying plants, which can claim to have life through -the fact that they feed and grow. I say destroying, because <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -anything that changes from what nature has made it into -something else, is destroyed; it must perish utterly in order -to become the other’s sustenance. To abstain from eating flesh, -as we are told Orpheus did in ancient times, is more a quibble -than an avoidance of crime in the matter of food. The only -way of avoiding it, and the only way of attaining to justice by -a complete purification, is to become self-sufficing and free of -external needs. If God has made it impossible for a thing to -secure its own preservation without injury to another, He has -also endowed it with the principle of injustice in the shape of its -own nature. Would it not, therefore, be a good thing, my dear -friend, if, when cutting out injustice, we could cut out the -belly, the gullet, and the liver, which impart to us no perception <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -of anything noble and no appetite for it, but partly resemble -the utensils for cooking butcher’s meat—such as choppers and -stew-pans—and partly the apparatus for a bakery—ovens, water-tanks, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_54'>54</span>and kneading-troughs? Indeed, in the case of most -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> people you can see their soul shut up in their body as if in -a baker’s mill, and perpetually going round and round at the -business of getting food. Take ourselves, for example. Just -now we were neither looking at nor listening to one another, -but we all had our heads down, slaving at the business of feeding. -But now that the tables have been removed, we have—as you -perceive—become free, and with garlands on our heads we are -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> engaged in sociable and leisurely conversation together, because -we have arrived at the state of not requiring food. Well then, -if the state in which we now find ourselves remains as a permanence -all our lives, shall we not be at perpetual leisure to enjoy -each other’s society? We shall have no fear of poverty. Nor -shall we know the meaning of wealth, since the quest for -luxuries is but the immediate consequence and concomitant of -the use of necessaries.</p> - -<p class='c005'>‘But, thinks Cleodorus, there must be food so that there may -be tables and wine-bowls and sacrifices to Demeter and the -Maid. Then let some one else demand that there shall be war -and fighting, so that we may have fortifications and arsenals and -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> armouries, and also sacrifices in honour of slaying our hundreds, -such as they say are the law in Messenia. Another, I suppose, -is aggrieved at the prospect of the healthfulness which would -follow. A terrible thing if, because there is no illness, there is -no more use in soft bedclothes, and no more sacrificing to -Asclepius or the Averting Powers, and if medical skill, with all -its drugs and implements, must be put away into inglorious -hiding! What is the difference between these arguments and -the other? Food is, in fact, “taken” as a “remedy” for -hunger, and all who use food are said to be “taking care” of -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>160<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> themselves and using some “diet”; and this implies that the -act is not a pleasant and agreeable performance, but one which -Nature renders compulsory. Certainly one can enumerate more -<span class='pageno' id='Page_55'>55</span>pains than pleasures arising from feeding. Further still; whereas -the pleasure affects but a small region of the body, and lasts -but a short time, it needs no telling how full we become of -ugly and painful experiences through the worry and difficulty -of digesting.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Homer had these in view, I suppose, when he used as a proof -that the gods do not die the fact that they do not feed:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>For they eat not the bread of corn, nor drink they the wine that is ruddy,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>And therefore blood have they none in their veins, and are called the Immortals.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Food, he gives us to understand, is the necessary means not only <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for living, but for dying. From it come our diseases, feeding -themselves with the feeding of our bodies, which suffer quite as -much from repletion as from want. Very often it is an easier -business to get together our supply of victuals than to make -away with them and get quit of them again when once they are -in the body. Just suppose it were a question with the Danaids -what sort of life they would live and what they would do if -they could get rid of their menial labour at filling the cask. -When we raise the question, “Supposing it possible to cease -from heaping into this unconscionable flesh all these things from <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -land and sea, what are we going to do?” it is because in our -ignorance of noble things we are content with the life which our -necessities impose. Well, as those who have been in slavery, -when they are emancipated, do for themselves and on their own -account what they used formerly to do in the service of their -masters, so is it with the soul. As things are, it feeds the body -with continual toil and trouble; but let it get quit of its menial -service, and it will presumably feed itself in the enjoyment of -freedom, and will live with an eye to itself and the truth, with -nothing to distract and deter it.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>This, Nicarchus, concluded the discussion as to food.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_56'>56</span>While Solon was still speaking, Gorgos, Periander’s brother, -entered the room. It happened that, in consequence of certain -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> oracles, he had been sent on a mission to Taenarum in charge -of a sacrificial embassy. After we had welcomed him, and -Periander had taken him to his arms and kissed him, he sat down -by his brother on the couch and gave him a private account -of some occurrence which appeared to cause Periander various -emotions as he listened to it. At one part he was manifestly -vexed, at another indignant; often he showed incredulity, and -this was followed by amazement. Finally he laughed and said -to us, ‘I should like to tell the company the news; but I have -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> scruples about it, because I heard Thales once say that when a -thing is probable we should speak of it, but when it is impossible -we should say nothing about it.’ At this Bias interposed, ‘Yes, -but here is another wise saying of Thales, that “while we should -disbelieve our enemies even in matters believable, we should -believe our friends even when the thing is unbelievable”. By -enemies I presume he meant the wicked and foolish, and by -friends the good and wise.’ ‘Very well then,’ said Periander, -‘you must let every one hear it; or rather you must pit the -story you have brought us against those new-fangled dithyrambs -and overcrow them.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Gorgos then told us his story.</p> - -<p class='c005'>His sacrificial ceremony had occupied three days, and on the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> last there was an all-night festival with dancing and frolic by -the sea-shore. The sea was covered with the light of the moon, -and, though there was no wind, but a dead calm, there appeared -in the distance a ripple coming in past the promontory, accompanied -by foam and a very appreciable noise of surge. At this -they all ran in astonishment down to the place where it was -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> coming to land. This happened so quickly that, before they -could guess what was approaching, dolphins were seen, some -of them massed together and moving in a ring, some leading -<span class='pageno' id='Page_57'>57</span>the way to the levellest part of the shore, and others as it were <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>161<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -bringing up the rear. In the middle there stood out above -the sea, dim and indistinct, the shape of a body being carried. -So they came on, until, gathering together and coming to land -at the same moment, they put ashore a human being, alive and -moving; after which they themselves retired in the direction -of the promontory, leaping out of the water more than ever -and for some reason, apparently, frolicking and bounding for -joy. ‘Many of our number,’ continued Gorgos, ‘fled from the -sea in a panic, but a few found the courage to approach along -with myself, and discovered that it was Arion, the harp-player. -Not only did he utter his own name, but his dress spoke for itself, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for he was actually wearing the festal robes which he adopted -when performing at the competitions. Well, we brought him -to a tent, and, inasmuch as there was nothing the matter with -him except that he was evidently tired and overstrained from -the rushing motion, we heard him tell a story which no one -would believe except us who actually saw the end of it.</p> - -<p class='c005'>‘What Arion told us was this. He had for some time made -up his mind to leave Italy, and had been made the more eager -to do so by a letter from Periander. Accordingly, when a Corinthian -merchant-vessel appeared on the scene, he at once went -on board and put to sea. They had a moderate wind for three -days, when he perceived that the sailors were forming a plot -to make away with him, and was afterwards secretly informed <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -by the pilot that they had resolved to do the deed that night. -At this, being helpless and at a loss what to do, he acted upon -a kind of heaven-sent impulse. He decided that he would -adorn his person and—while still alive—put on his own shroud -in the shape of his festal attire. Then, in meeting his death, -he would sing a <i>finale</i> to life, and in that respect show no less -spirit than the swan does. Accordingly, having dressed himself -and given notice that he felt moved to perform the Pythian -<span class='pageno' id='Page_58'>58</span>hymn on behalf of the safety of himself and the ship and crew, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> he took his stand on the poop by the bulwarks. After some -prelude invoking the gods of the sea, he began to sing the piece. -Just before he was half-way through, the sun began to set into -the sea and the Peloponnese to come into sight. Thereupon -the sailors no longer waited for night, but advanced to their -murderous deed. Arion, seeing their knives unsheathed and -the pilot beginning to cover his face from the sight, ran back -and hurled himself as far as possible from the vessel. Before, -however, his body had all sunk into the water, a number of -dolphins ran under him and bore him up. At first he was filled -with bewilderment, distress, and alarm; but when he found -himself riding easily, and saw many of them gathering about -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> him in a friendly way, and taking turns at the work as if it were -a necessary duty belonging to them all; and when the long -distance at which the vessel was left behind showed how great -was their speed; he said that what he felt was not so much -fear of death or desire of life, as eagerness to be rescued, so that -he might become recognized as the object of divine favour, and -might have his reputation as a religious man assured.</p> - -<p class='c005'>At the same time, observing that the sky was full of stars, -and that the moon was rising bright and clear, while the sea -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> on all sides was waveless and a kind of path was being cut for his -course, he was led to reflect that Justice has more eyes than one, -and that God looks abroad with all those orbs upon whatever -deeds are done by land or sea. By these reflections (he told us) -he found relief from the weariness which was by this time -beginning to weigh upon his body, and when at last, dexterously -avoiding and rounding the lofty and precipitous headland which -ran out to meet them, they swam close in by the shore and -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>162<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> brought him safely to land like a ship into harbour, he realized -beyond doubt that he had been steered on his voyage by the -hand of God. ‘When Arion had told us this story,’ continued -<span class='pageno' id='Page_59'>59</span>Gorgos, ‘I asked him where he thought the ship would put in. -He answered that it would certainly be at Corinth, but that -it was left far behind; for, after throwing himself off it in the -evening, he believed he had been carried over sixty miles and -a calm had fallen immediately.’ Gorgos added, however, that -after ascertaining the names of the captain and pilot, and also -the ship’s flag, he had sent out vessels and soldiers to the various -landing-places to keep a watch. Moreover, he had Arion with <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -him in hiding, so that they might not hear of his rescue beforehand -and make their escape. ‘The event,’ he said, ‘has proved -truly miraculous; for no sooner did we arrive here than we -learned that the ship had been seized by the soldiers, and the -traders and sailors arrested.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Thereupon Periander ordered Gorgos to get up and go out -at once and place the men in custody where no one would -approach them or tell them of Arion’s escape.</p> - -<p class='c005'>‘Well now,’ said Aesop, ‘you gentlemen make fun of my -jackdaws and crows for talking. Do dolphins behave in this -outrageous way?’ To which I replied, ‘A different matter, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Aesop! A story to the same effect as this has been believed and -written among us for more than a thousand years, ever since the -times of Ino and Athamas.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Solon here interposed: ‘Well, Diodes; let us grant that -these events are in the sphere of the divine and beyond us. -But what happened to Hesiod is on our own human plane. -You have probably heard the story.’ ‘For my part, no,’ I -answered. ‘Well, it is worth hearing. Hesiod and a Milesian—I -think it was—shared the same room as guests in a house at <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Locri. The Milesian having been found out in a secret intrigue -with the host’s daughter, Hesiod fell under suspicion of having -all along known of the offence and helped in concealing it. -Though in no way guilty, he fell a victim to cruel circumstance -at a critical time of anger and misrepresentation. For the girl’s -<span class='pageno' id='Page_60'>60</span>brothers lay in wait for him at the Nemeum in Locris and killed -him, together with his servant, whose name was Troilus. Their -bodies having been pushed into the sea, that of Troilus, which -was carried out into the current of the river Daphnus, was -caught by a low wave-washed rock projecting a little above -the water. The rock still bears his name. Meanwhile the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> dead body of Hesiod was picked up immediately off the shore -by a shoal of dolphins, who proceeded to carry it to Rhium, -close to Molycrea. It happened that the Locrians were engaged -in the Rhian festival and fair, which is still a notable celebration -in those parts. At sight of the body being borne towards them -they were naturally amazed, and when, on running down to -the shore, they recognized the corpse—for it was still fresh—they -could think of nothing but tracking out the murder, so -high was the renown of Hesiod. Their object was soon achieved. -They discovered the murderers, threw them into the sea, and -razed their house to the ground. Meanwhile Hesiod was -buried near the Nemeum. Most strangers, however, are ignorant -of his tomb, which has been concealed because the people of -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Orchomenus are in quest of it, from a desire, it is said, to recover -the remains and bury them in their own country in accordance -with an oracle.</p> - -<p class='c005'>‘If, then, dolphins show such affectionate interest in the -dead, it is still more natural for them to render help to the living, -especially if they have been charmed by the flute or the singing -of tunes. For, of course, we are all aware that music is a thing -which these animals enjoy and court, swimming and gambolling -beside a ship as its oarsmen row to the tune of song and flute -in calm weather. They take a delight also in children when -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>163<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> swimming, and they have diving matches with them. Hence -there is an unwritten law that they shall not be harmed. No -one hunts them or injures them; the only exception being that, -when they get into the nets and do mischief to the catch, they -<span class='pageno' id='Page_61'>61</span>are punished with a beating, like naughty children. I further -remember hearing some Lesbians tell of a girl having been -rescued from the sea by a dolphin. I am not, however, sure -as to the exact details, and, since Pittacus knows them, he is -the right person to tell us about them.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Pittacus thereupon assured us that the story had good warrant -and was mentioned by many authorities. ‘An oracle was -given to the colonizers of Lesbos that, when on the voyage they -came across the reef known as Mesogeum, they should then and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -there throw a bull into the water as an offering to Poseidon, -and a live virgin to Amphitrite and the Nereids. There were -seven chiefs, all of whom were kings, Echelaus—whom the -Pythian oracle had assigned as leader of the colony—making -an eighth. Echelaus was still a bachelor. When as many of the -seven as had unmarried girls cast lots, the lot fell upon the -daughter of Smintheus. Upon getting near the place, they -decked her in fine clothes and gold ornaments, and, after -offering prayer, were on the point of lowering her into the water. -Now it happened that one of the party on the ship—assuredly -a gallant young man—was in love with her. His name has been -preserved to us as Enalus. This youth, in the passion of the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -moment, seized by an eager but utterly hopeless desire to succour -the girl, darted forward at the right instant and, throwing -his arms about her, cast himself along with her into the sea. -Now from the first there was spread among the contingent -a rumour, lacking certainty, but nevertheless widely believed, -that they were safe and had been rescued; and at a later date, -it is said, Enalus appeared in Lesbos and told how they had -been carried by dolphins through the sea and cast ashore -without harm upon the mainland. He had other still more -miraculous experiences to tell, which held the crowd spellbound -with amazement, but for all of which he gave actual -evidence. For when an enormous wave was rushing sheer round <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -<span class='pageno' id='Page_62'>62</span>the island and people were terrified, he alone ventured to face it. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> On its retiring, a number of polypi followed him to the temple -of Poseidon. From the largest of these he took a stone which -it was carrying, and offered it as a dedication. That stone we -call Enalus.</p> - -<p class='c005'>‘Speaking generally, the man who knows the difference -between impossible and unfamiliar, between unreasonable and -unexpected, will be most a man after your own heart, Chilon; -he will neither believe nor disbelieve without discrimination, -but will carefully observe your own rule of “<i>nothing in excess</i>”.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Anacharsis next made the remark that, as Thales believed -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> all the greatest and most important components of the universe -to contain soul, there was no reason to wonder if the most -splendid actions were brought to pass by the will of God. -‘For the body is the instrument of the soul, and soul is the -instrument of God. And as, though many of the motions of -the body proceed from itself, the most and the finest are produced -by the soul, so again is it with the soul. While it performs -many actions on its own motion, in other cases it is but lending -itself, as the aptest of all instruments, to the use of God, for Him -to direct and apply it as He chooses. It would,’ said he, ‘be -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> a very strange thing if, while fire, wind, water, clouds, and -rain are God’s instruments, by which He often preserves and -nourishes and often kills and destroys, He has never on any -occasion at all used animals as His agents. On the contrary, -it is natural that, in their dependence upon the divine power, -they should lend themselves more responsively to motions from -God than does the bow to the Scythian or the lyre and flute -to the Greek.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>After this the poet Chersias mentioned, among other cases -of persons rescued in hopeless situations, that of Cypselus, -Periander’s father. When he was a newborn babe, the men who -had been sent to make away with him were turned from their -<span class='pageno' id='Page_63'>63</span>purpose because he smiled at them. When they changed their -minds and came back to look for him, he was not to be found, -his mother having hidden him in a chest. ‘It is for this reason <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>164<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -that Cypselus built the house at Delphi, believing that the -god had then stopped him from crying so that he might -elude the search.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>At this Pittacus, addressing Periander, observed, ‘I have to -thank Chersias, Periander, for mentioning that house; for I have -often wanted to ask you the meaning of those frogs which are -carved in such large size at the base of the palm-tree. What -reference have they to the god or to the dedication?’ Periander -having bidden him ask Chersias, who knew the reason and was -present when Cypselus consecrated the house, Chersias said with <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -a smile, ‘No: I will give no information until these gentlemen -have told me the meaning of their <i>Nothing in excess</i> and <i>Know -thyself</i>, and of those words which have kept many people from -marrying, made many distrustful, and reduced some to positive -dumbness—the words <i>Give a pledge, and Mischief is nigh.</i>’ -‘Why do you need us to tell you that,’ said Pittacus, ‘seeing -that you have so long admired the stories in which Aesop -practically deals with each of those maxims?’ ‘Nay,’ replied -Aesop, ‘he does need it, when he is joking at me. But when -he is in earnest, he proves that Homer was their inventor. -He says that Hector “knew himself”, inasmuch as, though <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -he attacked the rest,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Ajax, Telamon’s son, he would not fight, but he shunned him</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and that Odysseus recommends “nothing in excess” since he -urges Diomede</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Nay, prithee, Tydeus’ son; nor praise me much nor reprove me</i>.</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>As for a pledge, not only is it the general opinion that he is -reprobating it as a misguided and futile thing when he says</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Sorry, I trow, to take are the pledges that sorry folk offer</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_64'>64</span>but our friend Chersias here tells us how “Mischief” was hurled -from heaven by Zeus because she was present when he was tripped -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> up through pledging his word in connexion with the birth of -Heracles.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Here Solon interposed. ‘Well, Homer was a very wise man, -and we should do well to take his advice:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Already the night is here; night bids, and ’tis good to obey her.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Let us therefore pour an offering to the Muses and to Poseidon -and Amphitrite, and then—with your permission—break up the -party.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>This, Nicarchus, terminated the party on that occasion.</p> - -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_65'>65</span> - <h2 id='chap02' class='c003'>ON OLD MEN IN PUBLIC LIFE</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'>It is well known, Euphanes, that as an admirer of Pindar you <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>783 <span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -are fond of quoting his ‘fine and forcible words’:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>When struggle is afoot, excuses</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Cast a deep cloud on valour.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>In connexion with the struggles of public life timidity and -weakness can find plenty of excuses, but as a last and most -desperate plea they urge ‘advancing years’. This is their -pretext <i>par excellence</i> for blunting ambition and putting it out -of countenance. They argue that there is a fitting close to -a public, as much as to an athletic, career. For these reasons <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -I think it well to take my own ordinary reflections upon ‘old -men in public life’ and lay them before yourself. They may -prevent either of us from deserting that long companionship -which has hitherto followed a common path, and from abandoning -that public life which may be regarded as a familiar friend -from youth up, in order to adopt another which is unfamiliar, -and with which there is no time for us to become thoroughly -intimate. I would have us abide by our original principle, and -determine that life and the worthy life shall end together. It is -not for us to convert the brief remainder into a confession that the -bulk of our time has been wastefully applied to no good purpose. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<p class='c005'>It is not, indeed, true—as some one told Dionysius—that -‘despotism is a fine shroud’. In his case the combination of -absolutism with injustice was only made all the more complete -a calamity by the fact that it never ceased. It was therefore -a shrewd remark of Diogenes, when at a later date he saw -Dionysius’ son in a humble private station at Corinth. ‘Dionysius,’ -said he, ‘you are far from receiving your deserts. Instead -<span class='pageno' id='Page_66'>66</span>of living a free and fearless life here with us, you ought to have -been there, housed in the despot’s palace and made to live in it, -like your father, till old age.’ It is different with constitutional -and democratic statesmanship. When a man has learned to -show himself a profitable subject as well as a profitable ruler, he -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> does indeed obtain at death a ‘fine shroud’, in the shape of the -good name earned by his life. For this—to quote Simonides—</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Is the last thing to sink beneath the ground</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>except in cases where high human interests and noble zeal are -earlier to fail and die than natural desires.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Are the active and divine elements of our being more evanescent -than the passionate and corporeal? That were an unworthy -view to hold; as unworthy as to accept the doctrine that the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> only thing of which we never weary is making gain. On the -contrary, we should improve upon Thucydides, and regard as -‘<i>the only thing that never ages</i>’ not ‘<i>the love of honour</i>‘, but that -public spirit and activity which even ants and bees maintain -till the end. No one has ever seen old age convert a bee into -a drone. Yet there are some who claim that public men who -have passed their prime should sit and be fed in seclusion at -home, allowing their practical abilities to rust away in idleness. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>784<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Cato used to say that, to the many plagues of its own from which -old age suffers, there is no justification for deliberately adding -the disgrace of vice. There are many vices, but none can do -more than weak and cowardly inactivity to disgrace a man in -years—a man who skulks away from the public offices to look -after a houseful of women, or to supervise gleaners and reapers -in the country.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in16'><i>Where now</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Is Oedipus? Where the famed riddles now?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>It is one thing to wait till old age before commencing public -life, and to be like Epimenides, who—so they say—fell asleep -<span class='pageno' id='Page_67'>67</span>a youth and fifty years afterwards awoke an old man. If, in <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -such a case, one were to divest himself of that quiet habit which -has lasted all his life, and were to plunge into struggles and -worries with which he was unfamiliar, and for which he was -not trained by intercourse with public affairs or with mankind, -there would be room for remonstrance. We might say, as the -Pythian priestess said, ‘<i>You come too late</i>’ in your quest of office -and leadership. You are past the time for knocking at the door -of the Presidency. You are like some blundering reveller whose -surprise visit is not made till night; or like some stranger who -is in quest, not of a new district or country, but of a new life, -about which you know nothing. If Simonides says</p> - -<p class='c006'><i>The State is a man’s teacher</i>,</p> - -<p class='c015'>it is true only of those who have the time to change their teacher -and learn a new lesson—a lesson slowly and laboriously acquired -by means of many a struggle and experience, and only when it <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -can take its hold sufficiently early on a natural genius for bearing -toils and troubles with equanimity.</p> - -<p class='c005'>To resume. We find that, on the contrary, it is striplings and -youths whom sensible men do their best to keep out of public -business. Witness our laws, under which the crier in the -Assembly, when inviting speech and advice, calls upon the -platform in the first instance not an Alcibiades or a Pytheas, -but persons over fifty. Foolish audacity and lack of experience <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -are nowhere so out of place as in a deliberator or a judge.<a id='r34' /><a href='#f34' class='c009'><sup>[34]</sup></a> Cato, -when past eighty and on his defence, said it was hard to have to -defend himself before one set of people after having lived with -another. It is agreed on all hands that the measures of Caesar—the -conqueror of Antony—became considerably more regal and -good for the public towards the end of his life. Once, when by -stern application of custom and law he was correcting the rising -<span class='pageno' id='Page_68'>68</span>generation, and they made an outcry, his own words were: -‘Young men, listen to an old man to whom old men listened -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> when he was young.’ It was in old age, too, that the statesmanship -of Pericles reached its greatest influence. This was the -time when he induced the Athenians to enter upon the war, -and when he successfully opposed their ill-timed eagerness to -fight a battle against sixty thousand men-at-arms, by all but -sealing up the public armouries and the locks of the gates. -As for what Xenophon writes of Agesilaus, it is best to quote -verbatim. <i>‘Is there any youth with whom this old man did not -compare to advantage? Who in the prime of life was so formidable -to an enemy as Agesilaus was at the most advanced age? Of whom -was the foe so glad to be rid as of Agesilaus, though he was old -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> when his end came? Who inspired such courage in his own side -as Agesilaus, although close upon the end of life? What young -man was more regretted by his friends than Agesilaus, though he -died when full of years?</i>’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Well, if time was no hindrance to the great actions of men like -these, what of us, who nowadays enjoy the luxury of a public -life which admits of no despots, no fighting, no sieges, but only -of warless contests and of ambitions which are for the most part -settled by just means according to law and reason? Are we -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>785<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> to play the coward? Must we confess that we are the inferiors, -not merely of the commanders and popular leaders of those -days, but of the poets, leaders of thought, and actors? Take -Simonides. He won choric victories in old age, as is evident -from the last lines of the epigram:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>And withal to Simonides fell the glory and prize of the poet;</i></div> - <div class='line in2'><i>Fell to Leoprepes’ son, come to his eightieth year.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Take Sophocles. It is said that, when his sons charged him -with being in his dotage, he read in his defence the entrance -ode of the <i>Oedipus at Colonus</i>, beginning:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><span class='pageno' id='Page_69'>69</span><i>To this land of the steed, O stranger,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>To the goodliest homes on earth,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Thou hast come—to the white Colonus,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Fond haunt of the nightingale,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Where her clear voice trills its sorrow</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>In the green of the leafy dell....</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>a lyric which won such admiration that he left the court, as it <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -might have been the theatre, amid the applause and cheers of -the audience. A little epigram, admitted to be by Sophocles, -contains the words:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Five years and fifty Sophocles had seen,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Ere for Herodotus he wrought a song.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Take Philemon, the comic poet, and Alexis. They were still -putting plays upon the stage, still winning crowns, when death -overtook them. Take Polus, the tragedian. Eratosthenes and -Philochorus inform us that, shortly before his end, and when <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -he was seventy, he acted eight tragedies in four days.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Is it, I say, creditable that old men of the platform should -show a poorer spirit than old men of the stage? That they -should retire from the sacred contests—for ‘sacred’ these veritably -are—and give up the rôle of the public man in exchange -for goodness knows what other part? From king, say, to farmer -is a descent indeed. Demosthenes calls it cruel treatment of the -<i>Paralus</i>, to make that sacred warship carry cargoes of timber, -vine-stakes, and cattle for Meidias. But suppose a public man -abandons the Presidentship of Games, his seat on the Federal -Board, his high place in the Sacred League, and is found <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -measuring out barley-meal and olive-cake, or shearing sheep. -It cannot but look as if he were needlessly courting the status -of ‘old worn-out horse’. As for leaving a public career to -engage in vulgar and petty trade, one might as well take -some self-respecting lady, strip off her gown, give her an -apron, and keep her in a tavern. Turn public ability to -<span class='pageno' id='Page_70'>70</span>mere business and money-making, and its rank and character -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> are lost.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Or if, as a last alternative, people choose to talk of ‘ease and -enjoyment’, when they mean luxurious self-indulgence; if they -recommend the public man to adopt that process of idle senile -decay, I hardly know which of two ugly comparisons will best -hit off such a life. Shall I say it is a case of sailors taking ‘Aphrodite-holiday’ -and keeping it up for ever, without waiting till -their ship is berthed, but deserting it while still on the voyage? -Or is it a case of ‘Heracles-chez-Omphale’—as some sorry -humourists depict him—wearing a saffron gown and quietly -allowing Lydian handmaids to fan him and braid his hair? -Are we to treat our public man in that way? To strip off his -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> lion’s-skin, lay him on a couch, and feast him, with lute and flute -lulling him all the while? Or should we not take warning by -the retort of Pompey the Great to Lucullus? The latter, after -his campaigns and public services, had given himself up to -baths, dinners, social entertainments in the daytime, profound -indolence, and new-fangled notions in the way of house-building. -Meanwhile he accused Pompey of a fondness for place and power -unsuited to his years. Pompey replied that for an old man -effeminacy was more unseasonable than office. When he was -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>786<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> ill and the doctor ordered him fieldfares—the bird being then -out of season and difficult to procure—and when some one told -him that Lucullus had a large number in his preserves, he refused -to send for or receive one, exclaiming, ‘What? Pompey could -not live but for the luxury of Lucullus?’</p> - -<p class='c005'>It may be true that nature ordinarily seeks pleasure and -delight. But, with an old man, the body has become incapable -of all pleasures except a few which are essential. Not only -is it the case that</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>The Queen of Love turns weary from the old</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> as Euripides has it. Though they may retain the appetite for -<span class='pageno' id='Page_71'>71</span>eating and drinking—generally in a dulled or toothless form—they -find a difficulty in whetting the edge or sharpening the -teeth even of that. It is in the mind that one must lay up -a stock of pleasures, though not of the mean and ignoble kind -indicated by Simonides, when he told those who reproached -him with avarice that, though age had robbed him of other -joys, he had still one left to support his declining years—the -joy of money-making. In public activity there are pleasures -of the greatest and noblest sort, such as we may believe to be -the only, or the chief, enjoyment of the gods themselves—I -mean those which result from a beneficent deed or a fine -achievement.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Nicias the painter was so taken up with his artistic work that -he was often obliged to ask his servants whether he had had his <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -bath or his breakfast. Archimedes stuck so closely to his drawing-board -that, in order to anoint him, his attendants had to drag -him away and strip him by force. He then went on drawing -his diagrams in the ointment on his body. Carus the flutist -(an acquaintance of your own) used to say that people did not -know how much more pleasure he himself got from playing than -he gave to others; otherwise an audience would be paid to -listen instead of paying. Can we fail to perceive how great are -the pleasures derived from fine actions and public-spirited -achievements by those who put high qualities to use? Nor is -it by means of those effeminate titillations which soft and agreeable -movements exert upon the flesh. The ticklings of the flesh <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -are spasmodic, fickle, intermittent, whereas the pleasures of -noble deeds—the creations of the true statesman’s art—will -bear the soul aloft in grandeur and pride and joy, as if, I will -not say upon the ‘<i>golden wings</i>’ of Euripides, but upon those -‘<i>celestial pinions</i>’ described by Plato.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Remember the instances of which you have so often heard. -Epaminondas, when asked what had been his most pleasurable -<span class='pageno' id='Page_72'>72</span>experience, replied, ‘Having been victorious at Leuctra while -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> my father and mother were still alive.’ When Sulla first reached -Rome after purging Italy of its civil wars, he could not sleep -a wink that night. As he has written in his own <i>Notes and -Recollections</i>, so elated was his mind with the greatness of his -joy and happiness, that it seemed to walk on air. If we admit, -with Xenophon, that ‘<i>no hearing is so agreeable as praise</i>‘, no -sight, recollection, or reflection is so fraught with gratification -as the contemplation of exploits of our own in the conspicuous -public arena of office and statesmanship. Not but what, when -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> a grateful goodwill testifies to our achievements, and when -there is a rivalry of commendation productive of well-earned -popularity, our merit acquires a gloss and brilliance which adds -to our sense of pleasure.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Therefore, instead of permitting our reputation to wither -in our old age like an athlete’s crown, we must be constantly -adopting new devices and making fresh efforts to enliven the -sense of past obligation, to enhance it, and to make it permanent. -We must act like the craftsmen who were required to provide for -the security of the Delian ship. They used to replace unsound -timbers by others, and, by means of insertions and repairs, were -regarded as keeping the vessel immortal and indestructible from -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>787<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the oldest times. Reputation is like flame. There is no difficulty -in keeping it alive; it merely requires a little feeding with fuel. -But let either of them become extinct and cold, and it will -take some trouble to rekindle.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Lampis, the shipowner, was once asked how he made his -fortune. ‘Making the big one,’ he answered, ‘was easy enough; -but it was a long and hard business to make the little one.’ -So with political power and reputation. Though not easy to -get in the first instance, anything will suffice to maintain and -increase them when once they are great. It is as with a friend, -when once he becomes such. He does not look for a large -<span class='pageno' id='Page_73'>73</span>number of important services in order to retain his friendship; <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -small tokens, consistently shown, will keep his constant affection. -Nor are the confidence and friendship of the people perpetually -calling for you to open your purse, to play the champion, or to -hold an office. They are retained by mere public spirit—by -being in no haste to desert or shirk the burden of care and -watchfulness.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Campaigns are not matters of everlastingly facing the enemy, -fighting, and besieging. They have also their times of sacrifice, -their occasional social gatherings, their periods of ample leisure, -when jest and nonsense are toward. And why should one look -upon public life with dread, as being laborious, wearisome, and -devoid of consolations, seeing that the theatre, processions, -awards, ‘<i>dances of the Muses and Gladsomeness</i>,’ and honour <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -after honour to the gods relax the stern brow of the Bureau -or the Chamber, and yield a manifold return of inviting -entertainment?</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the next place jealousy, the greatest bane of public life, is -less severe upon old age. For, to quote Heracleitus, ‘<i>dogs bark -at the man they do not know</i>.’ Though jealousy may fight with -the beginner at the doors of the platform and refuse him access, -no savageness or fierceness is shown to a man of familiar and -established reputation, but he finds friendly admittance. For -this reason some have compared jealousy to smoke. In the case -of beginners, during the process of kindling, it pours forth -in clouds; when they are in full blaze, it disappears. And while <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -people resist and dispute other forms of superiority—in merit, -birth, or public spirit—through a belief that any acknowledgement -to others means so much derogation to themselves, the -primacy which is due to time—‘seniority’ in the proper sense—is -conceded without a grudge. Respect paid to the aged has -the unique quality of doing more honour to the giver than -to the recipient.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_74'>74</span>Moreover it is not every one who expects to attain to the -power derived from wealth, eloquence, or wisdom; whereas -no public man despairs of winning the esteem and distinction -to which age gradually leads.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Imagine a navigator, who has managed his ship safely in the -face of contrary winds and waves, and then, when the weather -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> becomes fair and calm, wishes to lay her to. It is just as strange -when a man has fought his ship in a long battle with jealousies, -and then, after they are quietly laid, backs out of public life, -and, in abandoning his activities, abandons his partners and -associates. The more time there has been, the more friends -and fellow-workers he has made; but he is neither in a position -to lead them with him off the stage, as a poet does his chorus, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> nor has he the right to leave them in the lurch. A long public -life is like an old tree. To pull it up is no easy task, because -of its many roots and its entanglement with many interests, -which involve worse wrenching and disturbance when you leave -them than when you stay.</p> - -<p class='c005'>And if political conflict does leave you some remnant of -jealousy or antagonism to face when you are old, it is better -to quell it by means of your position than to turn your back -and retire without armour or weapons of defence. People are -not so ready to attack you out of jealousy when you are still -in action as they are out of contempt when you give it up.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>788<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> We may also appeal to the great Epaminondas and his remark -to the Thebans. It was winter at the time, and the Arcadians -were inviting them to enter the city and live in the houses. -This he refused to allow, observing: ‘At the present time they -come to look at you and admire your wrestling and military -exercises; but if they see you sitting by the fire and chewing -your beans, they will regard you as no better than themselves.’ -So with an aged man. When making a speech, transacting -business, or receiving honours, he is a dignified spectacle; but -<span class='pageno' id='Page_75'>75</span>when he lies all day on a couch or sits in the corner of a public <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -resort talking drivel and wiping his nose, he is an object of -contempt. This is precisely what Homer teaches, if you read -him rightly. Nestor, who was campaigning at Troy, received -high respect and honour; whereas Peleus and Laertes, the -stay-at-homes, were despised, and counted for nothing.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Nay, even intellectual power begins to fail those who have -let themselves relax. Idleness gradually renders it feeble and -flaccid, in the absence of some necessary exercise of thought -to keep the logical and practical faculty perpetually alive and -in trim.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Like glossy bronze, ’tis use that makes it shine.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Bodily weakness may be a drawback to public activity in the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -case of those who, in spite of their years, make the platform -or the Cabinet their goal. But it is more than compensated -by the advantage of their caution and prudence. They do not -dash into public affairs with the expression of opinions prompted -by error or vanity as the case may be, and carrying the mob with -them in as excited a condition as a stormy sea; but they deal -in a mild and reasonable fashion with such matters as arise. -It is for this reason that, in times of disaster or alarm, communities -feel the need of a Board of Government consisting of -senior men. Often they have fetched back from the country <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -an old man who neither asked nor wished it, and have compelled -him to put his hand to the helm and steer the ship of State -into safety, while they thrust aside generals and popular leaders, -despite all their ability to shout, to talk without taking breath, -and also, no doubt, to make ‘<i>sturdy stand and doughty fight</i>’ -against the enemy. When Chares, the son of Theochares—a -man in the prime of bodily strength and condition—was -brought into the ring in opposition to Timotheus and Iphicrates -by the public speakers of Athens, with the claim that ‘this is -<span class='pageno' id='Page_76'>76</span>the kind of general the Athenians should have’, Timotheus -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> replied: ‘By no manner of means. No doubt that is the sort -needed to carry the general’s baggage; but the general should -be one who “<i>sees before and after</i>”, and whose calculations as -to policy no distractions can disturb.’ Sophocles said ‘he was -glad that old age had enabled him to escape from sexual passion—a -fierce and mad master.’ But in public life we have to escape, -not from one master—the love of women—but from many -madder still; from contentiousness, vanity, and the desire to be -first and greatest—a malady most fertile in envy, jealousy, and -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> feud. Some of these feelings are abated or dulled, some are -altogether chilled and quenched, by old age. And though old -age may do something to diminish our zest for action, it does -more to guard us from the intemperate heat of passion, so -that we can bring a sober and steady reason to bear upon our -thoughts.</p> - -<p class='c005'>By all means, in dealing with one who begins to play the youth -when his hair is grey, let it be—as it is considered—sound -warning to say:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Misguided man, stay quiet in thy bed.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>789<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Let us remonstrate with an old man when he rises from a long -privacy, as from a bed of sickness, and bestirs himself to obtain -a command or an official post. But suppose a man has lived -a life of public action and thoroughly played the part. To -prevent him from going on till ‘finis and the torch’, to call -him back and bid him change the road he has long followed, is -utterly unfeeling, and bears no resemblance to the case just -given. If an old man has his wreath on and is scenting himself -in readiness to marry, there is nothing unreasonable in trying -to dissuade him by quoting the lines addressed to Philoctetes:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>But, pray, where is the bride, where the young maid,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Would welcome thee? Rare bridegroom thou, poor soul!</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_77'>77</span>Nay, they are fond of making jests of the kind at their own <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -expense:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>I’m marrying old, and for the neighbours’ good:</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>I know it.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>But when a man has been long married, and has lived with his -wife for years without a fault to find, to tell him that he should -divorce her because he is old, and that he should live by himself or -get a wretched concubine in place of his lawful spouse, is the very -extreme of absurdity. In the same way when an aged man seeks to -enter politics—Chlidon the farmer, Lampon the ship’s captain, -or some philosopher from the Garden<a id='r35' /><a href='#f35' class='c009'><sup>[35]</sup></a>—there is some reason in -admonishing him, and keeping him to the state of inactivity to -which he has been used. But it is urging a public man to act <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -with injustice and ingratitude, when we take hold of a Phocion, -a Cato, or a Pericles, and say, ‘Sir Athenian—or Sir Roman—</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Thine age is wither’d and thy head o’erfrosted</i>;</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>therefore sue for a divorce from statesmanship, have done with -the worrying business of the platform and the Board of War, -and make haste into the country, to live with farming “for -a waiting-maid” or to occupy the rest of your days with thrift -and the keeping of accounts.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Well, but (it may be asked) what of the soldier in the comedy -with his</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Discharged! No pay! because of my white hair?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Quite true, my friend. The War-God’s servants must be in the -prime of manly vigour. Their business is with</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>War and war’s baleful work</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>in which, though an old man’s grey hair may be hidden by his <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -helmet,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Yet in secret his thews are aweary</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and, though the spirit be willing, the strength can no longer -respond.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_78'>78</span>But the ministers of Zeus—the God of Council, of Assembly, -of the State—are not asked for deeds of hand and foot, but for -counsel and foresight. We ask them for advice, not such as -to evoke roars of mere noise in the Assembly, but full of sense -and shrewdness, and safe to follow. In their case the despised -white hair and wrinkles become the visible tokens of experience. -They suggest moral force, and are therefore a help to persuasion. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> It is the part of youth to obey; of old age to guide; and that -state is safest where</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Best are the old men’s counsels,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>And best the young man’s spear.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Homer’s</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>And first he summon’d to council the old men mighty-hearted</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>By the side of the ship of Nestor</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>is a touch greatly admired. For the same reason the Select -Board associated with the kings at Sparta was called by the -Pythian oracle ‘elder-born’, but by Lycurgus ‘old men’ -<i>sans phrase</i>, while the Roman Council is called <i>Senatus</i> down to -the present time. The law crowns a man with the circlet and -the wreath, Nature crowns him with grey hair, and both are -the venerable emblems of sovereign rank. Moreover, the words -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> <i>geras</i>, ‘prerogative,’ and <i>gerairein</i>, ‘honour with prerogative’—derived -from <i>geron</i>, ‘old man’—retain a dignified sense, not -because the old man’s bath is warmed and his bed a softer one, -but because he amounts to a king in the state by virtue of his -wisdom; and wisdom is like a late-fruiting plant, it is only in old -age that nature brings out its special excellence and perfect -quality.</p> - -<p class='c005'>When the king of kings prayed to the gods</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Would that among the Achaeans were ten such as he to advise me!</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>790<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> —meaning Nestor—not one of the ‘<i>valorous</i>’ and ‘<i>prowess-breathing</i>’ -Achaeans complained. They all admitted that not -<span class='pageno' id='Page_79'>79</span>only in statesmanship, but in war also, age was of great moment, -since</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>More worth is one sage thought than many a hand</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and one rational and cogent judgement achieves the finest and -most important results in public affairs.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Now kingship, the most complete and comprehensive form -of public activity, is full of cares, labours, and preoccupations. -Seleucus, it was said, used to declare that if ordinary people -knew what a business it was merely to write and read so many -letters, they would not pick up the crown if they found it <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -lying in the street. And the story goes that, when Philip was -proposing to encamp in an excellent position, but was told that -there was no fodder for the pack-animals, he exclaimed: ‘Good -Heavens! what is our life worth, when we are obliged to suit it -to the convenience of our asses?’ Ought we then to give the -same advice to a king when he has grown old? Bid him lay -aside the crown and the purple, take to a cloak and a crutched -stick, and live in the country, for fear people should think it -officious and unseasonable of him to be reigning when he is -grey?</p> - -<p class='c005'>But we have no right to talk in this way about an Agesilaus, -or a Numa, or a Darius. Neither then should we compel a Solon <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -to leave the Council of the Areopagus, nor a Cato the Senate, -nor yet urge a Pericles to leave popular government to look after -itself. It is contrary to reason that in our youth we should -bounce upon the platform, spend upon the public all the -passionate licence of our ambition, and then, when age arrives -and brings the wisdom of experience, desert and betray our -public standing like a woman whom we have used at our -pleasure.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In Aesop, when the hedgehog wanted to pick off his ticks, -the fox would not let him. ‘These are glutted,’ said he, ‘and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -if you get rid of them, hungry ones will be at you in their place.’ -<span class='pageno' id='Page_80'>80</span>So with public life. If it is perpetually shedding the old men, -it will necessarily be plagued with young ones, who are thirsting -for notoriety and power but devoid of political sense. How -can they be otherwise, if they are to have no elderly statesman -to watch and learn from? A ship’s captain is not made by -treatises on navigation. He must often have stood upon the -quarter-deck and watched the struggle with wave and wind -and stormy nights, when</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>The sailor on the brine longs sore</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>For Tyndareus’ twin sons.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>And can the handling of a State and the persuading of Assembly -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> or Council be rightly left to a young man because he has read -a book or taken down a lecture on statesmanship in the Lyceum? -Though he has not taken his stand many a time beside rudder-rope -and tiller, leaned first to this side and then to that, while -generals and public leaders were pitting their knowledge and -experience against each other, and so learned his lesson in the -midst of dangers and difficulties? Beyond question, No! For -the education and training of the young, if for no other reason, -old men should play a public part. A teacher of letters or of -music himself reads or plays a passage over first by way of example -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> to his pupils. So the authority on statesmanship must guide -a young man, not simply by talking or suggesting from outside, -but by the practical administration of public business. It is -by deeds as well as by words that he will mould him to the true -shape, filled with the breath of life. It is training of this kind—not -in the schools where you practise safe forms of wrestling -under mannerly professors, but in contests truly Olympian and -Pythian—that makes one, as Simonides puts it,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Keep pace, as with the steed the wearied colt</i>;</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>791<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> —Aristeides with Cleisthenes, Cimon with Aristeides, Phocion -with Chabrias, Cato with Fabius Maximus, Pompeius with -<span class='pageno' id='Page_81'>81</span>Sulla, Polybius with Philopoemen. It was by attaching themselves -when young to older men, by using them as supports to -their own growth, by being raised to their standard of statesmanlike -achievement, that they acquired the political experience -which brought them fame and power.</p> - -<p class='c005'>When certain professors declared that the claim of Aeschines, -the Academic philosopher, to have been a pupil of Carneades -was contrary to fact, he replied, ‘O yes: I was a disciple of -Carneades at the time when age had taken all the fuss and noise <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -out of his teaching and reduced it to practical and serviceable -shape.’ With the statesmanship of an old man, however, it is -not merely the talking, but the deeds, that lose all ostentation -and itch for notoriety. They tell us that, when the iris has -grown old and exhausted all crude exuberance of perfume, its -fragrance gains in sweetness. So with the views and suggestions -of the old. There is no crudeness in them, but always a quality -of quiet solidity. For this reason, as I have said, we must have -elderly men in public life. Plato speaks of mixing water with -neat wine as the bringing of a ‘frenzied god’ to sanity by the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -‘chastening of another who is sober’. So when young spirits -in the Assembly are a-boil with the intoxication of glory and -ambition, we need the old men’s caution to qualify them and -to eliminate their mad excess of fire.</p> - -<p class='c005'>There is another consideration. It is an error to suppose that -statesmanship is like a voyage or a campaign—carried on for -an ulterior object and discontinued when that is attained. -Statesmanship is not a public burden, to be borne only so long -as needs must. It is the career of a civilized being with a gift -for citizenship and society, and with a natural disposition to live -a life of public influence, worthy aims, and social helpfulness -for as long as occasion calls.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The right course therefore is to <i>be</i> a public man, not to -<i>have</i> been one; just as it is right to speak the truth, not to -<span class='pageno' id='Page_82'>82</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> <i>have</i> spoken it; to act honestly, not to <i>have</i> so acted; to love one’s -country and fellow-citizens, not to <i>have</i> loved them. Those are -Nature’s objects, and where men are not utterly demoralized by -idleness and effeminacy, her promptings are such as these:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Thy sire begat thee for rich use to men</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Ne’er let us cease from service to mankind.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>To urge the plea of ill-health or disablement is to blame -disease and injury, not old age. Young men are often sickly, -old men often vigorous. It is therefore not the old whom we -should discourage, but the incapable. It is the capable whom -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> we should encourage, not the young. Aridaeus was young, and -Antigonus old; but while Antigonus annexed nearly the whole -of Asia, Aridaeus was like the ‘super’ upon the stage—a king -with nothing to say, and a butt for whoever happened to be in -power. To demand of the sophist Prodicus or the poet Philetas—who, -young though they might be, were thin, sickly, and -constantly taking to their beds through ill-health—that they -should take up public life, were folly. But it were folly also to -hinder old men like Phocion, or Masinissa the African, or the -Roman Cato, from holding office or military command. The -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Athenians being set upon an ill-timed war, Phocion ordered -that every man under sixty should take up arms and serve. -When this made them angry, he said, ‘There is no hardship. -I, who am to be with you in command, am over eighty.’ And of -Masinissa Polybius relates that he died when he was ninety, -leaving a child of four, of whom he was the father. Shortly -before his death he beat the Carthaginians in a great battle, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>792<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> and the next day was seen in front of his tent eating a loaf of -cheap coarse bread. To expressions of surprise he answered that -he did so to keep himself in training.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>For like to goodly bronze, it shines in use,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>While a house crumbles, if left idle long</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_83'>83</span>says Sophocles. We may say the same of that glossy brightness -of the mind, to which we owe calculation, memory, and sound -judgement.</p> - -<p class='c005'>For the same reason it is said that wars and campaigns -make better kings than inactivity. Attalus, the brother of -Eumenes, was so thoroughly enervated by long peace and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -idleness that Philopoemen, one of his intimates, had simply -to shepherd him and keep him fat. In fact, the Romans -used to inquire of arrivals from Asia, whether ‘the king -had any influence with Philopoemen’. It would be hard to -find a Roman general more able than Lucullus, so long as he -kept his intellect braced with action. But he surrendered -himself to a life of inactivity, stayed at home, thought of -nothing, and became as lifeless and shrunken as a sponge in -a calm. Afterwards, in his old age, he so tamely accepted -a certain freedman, Callisthenes, for his keeper, that the man <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -was thought to be bewitching him with spells and drugs, -till at last his brother Marcus drove the fellow away and -himself took to managing and tutoring him for the short -remainder of his life. On the other hand, Darius, the father -of Xerxes, used to say that he became his wisest in times of -danger; and Ateas the Scythian declared that, when he had -nothing to do, he could see nothing to distinguish him from his -grooms. When some one asked the elder Dionysius if he had -time to spare, he replied: ‘Heaven forbid I ever should!’ -Whereas a bow, they tell us, is broken by stringing it tight, a -mind is broken by leaving it loose. If a musician gives up listening <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for pitch, a geometrician the solving of problems, an arithmetician -the constant habit of calculation, old age will enfeeble -the ability along with the loss of its exercise, although the art -in these cases is not a ‘practic’ one, but a ‘theoretic’. In the -case of the special ability of the statesman—his caution, wisdom, -and justice, together with an experienced knack of hitting the -<span class='pageno' id='Page_84'>84</span>right language at the right time; that is to say, a faculty -for creating persuasion—it is kept in good condition by -constant speech, action, calculation, and judicial decision. -It would be a dire mistake for it to abandon such activities -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> and permit all those important virtues to leak away from -the mind. For it naturally means a decline of kindly interest -in man and society—a thing which should be without limit -or end.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Suppose your father had been Tithonus. Suppose, though -he was immortal, old age had made him require close and constant -care. You would not, I imagine, have run away and -repudiated the task of tending him, talking to him, and helping -him, just because you had ‘borne the burden for a long time’. -Well, your fatherland—or ‘motherland’ as it is called in Crete—has -claims prior to those of parents, and greater. Your country’s -life has been a long one, but she is not without old age. She is -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> not sufficient to herself, but is in perpetual need of watchful -and considerate help. She therefore grasps at the statesman -and holds him back:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Clutching his garment she stays him, though eager he be for departure.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>You are aware that I have performed my public duty at many -a Pythian festival. But you would not say ‘Plutarch, you have -done enough in the way of sacrifices, processions, and choruses. -You are now in years; it is time to put off your wreath; age -entitles you to leave the shrine alone’. Well, look at your own -duty in the same way. In the sacred service of the State -you are coryphaeus and prophet, and it is not for you to -abandon that worship of Zeus, God of State and Assembly, in -which you have been so long initiated and are so thoroughly -versed.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>793<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Permit me now to leave the arguments for quitting public -<span class='pageno' id='Page_85'>85</span>life, and to examine another point. We must beware of inflicting -upon our old age an unbecoming or exacting task, when so -many portions of public work are so well suited to that time of -life. If it had been proper for us to go on singing all our days, -there are at our disposal many keys and modes, or, as the -musicians call them, ‘systems.’ Our right course in our old -age would have been to cultivate, not a mode both high and -sharp, but one combining ease with appropriate character. -And since Nature prompts mankind to act and speak—even more <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -than it prompts the swan to sing—until the end, our duty is -not to lay action aside, like a lyre of too high a pitch, but to -lower the key and adapt it to such forms of public effort as -are light, unexacting, and within an old man’s compass. We -do not leave our bodies entirely without muscular exercise -because we cannot use the spade and the jumping-weights, -or hurl the discus, or practise fencing, as we used to do. -We swing or walk, and in some cases the breathing is exercised -and warmth stimulated by playing a gentle game of ball, or -by conversation.</p> - -<p class='c005'>On the one hand, then, do not let us allow ourselves to become <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -stiff and torpid from inactivity. On the other, let us not undertake -any and every official position, clutch at any and every kind -of public work, and bring such an exposure upon old age that -it is driven to exclaim in despair:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Right hand, how fain art thou to grasp the spear!</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>How vain thy longing, in thy strengthlessness!</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Even in the prime of strength a man wins no credit if he tries to -take on his shoulders the whole pack of public business, and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -refuses—like Zeus, according to the Stoics—to leave anything -to others; if he insinuates himself everywhere and has his -finger in everything, through an insatiable greed for notoriety -or through jealousy of any one who contrives to get a share -<span class='pageno' id='Page_86'>86</span>of honour and power in the community. But when a man is -quite old, then, apart from the discredit, wretchedly hard work -is entailed by that itch for office which is always courting every -ballot-box, that meddlesomeness which lies in wait for every -opportunity of acting on a jury or a committee, that ambition -which snaps up every appointment as delegate or proctor. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Such work is a heavy tax on an old man, even when people are -well-disposed. But the opposite may very well be the case. -For young men hate him because he leaves them no opportunities -and prevents them from coming to the front; while -the rest of the community looks upon his itch for office and -precedence with the same disapproval as upon the itch of other -old men for money and pleasure.</p> - -<p class='c005'>When Bucephalus was growing old, Alexander, being unwilling -to overwork him, used to ride some other horse while -reviewing the phalanx and getting it into position before the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> battle. Then, after giving the word for the day, he changed -his mount to Bucephalus, and at once led the charge and tried -the fortunes of war. In the same way a sensible public man—in -this case handling his own reins—will, when in years, hold -aloof from unnecessary effort, leaving more vigorous persons -to deal with the minor matters of state, but himself playing -a zealous part in great ones.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Athletes keep their bodies from all contact with necessary -labours and in perfect trim for useless ones. We, on the -contrary, will leave petty little details alone, and will keep -ourselves in reserve for matters of moment. No doubt, as -Homer says,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>To the young all labours are seemly</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and the world gives consent and approval, calling them ‘public-spirited’ -and ‘energetic’ when they do a large number of little -things, and ‘noble’ and ‘lofty-minded’ when they do brilliant -<span class='pageno' id='Page_87'>87</span>and distinguished things. At that time of life there are <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>794<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -occasions when a venturesome aggressiveness is more or less in -season and wears a grace of its own. But what when an -elderly man consents to perform routine services to the -public, such as letting out taxes, or superintending harbours -and markets? What when he seizes opportunities of being -sent on a mission to some governor or other powerful personage—a -position for which there is no necessity, which -contains no dignity, and which necessitates time-serving and -complaisance? To my mind, my friend, his case is one for -regret and commiseration; some may even think it distressingly -vulgar.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Not even positions of authority are any longer a suitable <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -sphere for him, unless they are of high rank and importance; -such a position, for example, as you now hold in the Presidentship -of the Areopagite Council, not to mention the distinguished -rank of Amphictyon,<a id='r36' /><a href='#f36' class='c009'><sup>[36]</sup></a> which your country has imposed upon -you all your life, with its</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Welcome toil and labour sweet to bear.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Even these honours we should not seek, but should make from -holding them. We should ask, not for them, but to be excused -from them. It should seem, not that we are taking office to -ourselves, but that we are surrendering ourselves to office. The -Emperor Tiberius used to say that a man over sixty should be -ashamed of holding out his wrist to a physician. But he should <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -be more ashamed of holding out his hand to the public in -solicitation of its ‘vote and influence’. That situation is as -humiliating and ignoble as the contrary is honourable and -dignified—I mean when your country chooses you, calls you, -and waits for you, and when you come down amidst respect -<span class='pageno' id='Page_88'>88</span>and welcome, a ‘reverend signior’ indeed, to meet your distinction -with gracious acceptance.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Similarly with speaking in the Assembly. A man of advanced -age should not be perpetually springing upon the platform -and crowing back to every cock that crows. Young men are -like horses, and he should not, by constantly grappling with -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> them and irritating them, lose control of their respect, or -encourage the practice and habit of resistance to the reins. -He should sometimes leave them to make a restive plunge for -distinction, keeping out of the way and not interfering, unless -the matter at stake is vital to the public safety or to decency -and honour. In that case he should not wait to be called, but -should let some one take him by the hand, or carry him in his -chair, and push his way at more than full speed, like Appius -Claudius in Roman history. The Romans had been defeated -by Pyrrhus in a great battle, and Appius heard that the Senate -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> was listening to proposals for a truce and a peace. This was -more than he could bear, and, though blind of both eyes, along -he came in his chair through the Forum to the Senate House. -He went in, planted himself before them, and said: ‘Hitherto -I have been distressed at the loss of my sight; now I could pray -to be also unable to hear—that you are meditating so ignoble -and disgraceful a transaction.’ Thereupon, partly by reproaches, -partly by advice and encouragement, he persuaded them to have -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> immediate recourse to arms and to fight Pyrrhus to a finish -for the prize of Italy.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Again, when it became manifest that, in acting the demagogue, -Peisistratus was aiming at absolutism, and yet no one ventured -to resist or prevent it, Solon brought out his weapons with -his own hands, piled them in front of his house, and called upon -the citizens to help. And when Peisistratus sent and asked -him what gave him the confidence to do so, he replied, ‘My age.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Things so vital as these, it is true, are rousing enough to fire -<span class='pageno' id='Page_89'>89</span>even the most worn-out of old men, so long as he possesses -the breath of life at all. Otherwise he will sometimes, as I have -said, be showing good taste if he declines to perform paltry -and menial tasks which bring more worry to the doer than good <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>793<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -to the persons for whom they are done. There are also occasions -when he will wait for the citizens to call for him, feel the need -of him, and come to his house to fetch him. He is wanted, and -therefore his appearance on the scene will carry more weight. -But for the most part, though present, he will be silent and will -leave the younger generation to do the speaking, while he acts -as umpire to the match of political ambition. And if it goes -beyond bounds, he will offer a mild reproof and courteously -put an end to outbreaks of self-assertion, recrimination, or -ill-temper. When a motion is wrong, he will reason with and -correct the mover, but without blaming him. When it is right, -he will commend it without reserve and will cheerfully acquiesce, -often surrendering an argumentative victory in order that <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -a young man may get on in the world and be in good heart. -In some cases he will supply a deficiency while paying a compliment, -like Nestor with his</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>No man, I trow, will find fault with thy words among all the Achaeans:</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>None say thee nay. Yet not to an end hast thou brought all the matter.</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>True ’tis, thou art yet but young, and myself might be thine own father.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>There is a practice still more statesmanlike. One may not -merely teach a lesson openly in public by means of a reproval -unaccompanied by any sting of humiliation or injury to prestige. -Still more may be done in private for persons with good political -abilities. We may offer them kindly suggestions and assistance <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -towards the bringing forward of useful arguments and public -measures, encourage them to high aims, help them to acquire -<span class='pageno' id='Page_90'>90</span>a distinguished tone of mind, and—as riding-masters do with -their horses—see that at first the people shall be gentle and -docile for them to mount. And if so be a young man should -make a failure, instead of leaving him to despond, we may rouse -and comfort him. It was in this way that the spirits and courage -of Cimon were revived by Aristeides, and those of Themistocles -by Mnesiphilus, when they began by incurring ill-odour and -a bad name for forwardness and recklessness. It is also said -of Demosthenes that, when he was in great distress at his failure -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> in the Assembly, he was taken to task by a very old man who had -heard Pericles, and who told him that he had no right to despair -of himself, seeing that he possessed gifts so much like those -of that eminent person. So when Timotheus was hissed for -his innovations and treated as guilty of an outrage on music, -Euripides bade him keep up his courage, since he would soon -be dictating to his audience.</p> - -<p class='c005'>At Rome the term of the Vestal Virgins is divided into three -stages—one for learning, one for the performance of the ceremonies, -and the third for teaching. So with the votaries of -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Artemis at Ephesus; each is called first a novice, next a priestess, -and then a past-priestess. In the same way the complete -statesman is during the first part of his public career still -engaged in learning the mysteries; during the last part he is -engaged in teaching and initiating.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Whereas to superintend the athletics of others is to take -no part in them oneself, it is otherwise with those who train -a youth in public business and the political arena, and who make -sure that for the good of his country he shall</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Be speaker of words and eke doer of deeds.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>They perform good service, not in some petty inconsiderable -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> part of public life, but in one to which Lycurgus devoted his -first and foremost attention—training the young to give to -<span class='pageno' id='Page_91'>91</span>every old man the same unfailing obedience as to a lawgiver. -What had Lysander in his mind, when he declared that the -finest form of old age is to be found at Lacedaemon? Did he -mean that at Lacedaemon elderly people had the best opportunities -of doing nothing, of lending money, of sitting together -and playing dice, or of meeting together at an early hour to -drink? Surely not. He meant that all persons at that time of -life hold, as it were, a magisterial position; that they are, in -a sense, public fathers or guardians, who not only look after -matters of state, but take active cognisance of everything a young <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>796<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -man may do in connexion with his training-school, his pastimes, -or his style of living. Such a position makes them an object -of fear to wrong-doers, and of respect and affection to the well-behaved. -For young men make a point of cultivating their -society, because of the way in which they encourage steadiness -and nobility of character by sympathy and approbation and -without jealousy.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The last-named feeling is not a becoming one at any time -of life. But whereas in the case of a young man it finds plenty -of respectable names—‘rivalry’, ‘emulation’, ‘ambition’—in -an old man it is a coarse and vulgar sentiment altogether out -of place. The aged statesman should therefore be entirely -free from jealousy. He should be no malignant old tree, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -unequivocally snubbing the shoots and checking the growth of -plants which spring up beside or beneath it, but should give -them a kindly welcome and every opportunity to cling to him -and twine about him. He should hold young people upright, -lead them by the hand, and foster them, not only by wise -suggestion and advice, but by surrendering to them political -tasks which bring honour and distinction, or which afford scope -for services of an innocent nature and yet welcome and gratifying -to the public.</p> - -<p class='c005'>When a task is a stubborn and arduous one, or when it is -<span class='pageno' id='Page_92'>92</span>like a medicine which stings and gives pain at the moment, -while its beneficial effects are not produced till afterwards, he -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> should not prescribe it for young people. Instead of subjecting -them in their inexperienced state to the uproars of an unreasonable -mob, he should himself accept the unpopularity -attaching to salutary measures. By this means he will render -a youth both more well-disposed and also more zealous in other -duties.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Meanwhile it must be remembered that statesmanship does -not consist solely in holding office, acting as envoy, shouting -loudly in the Assembly, and indulging in a fine frenzy of speeches -and motions on the platform. The generality of people may -think that these make a statesman, just as they think that talking -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> from a chair and delivering lectures based on books make a -philosopher. But they fail to discern the sustained statesmanship -or philosophy which is revealed consistently day after day -in actions and conduct. As Dicaearchus used to say, the word -<i>peripatein</i>, ‘walk’, has now come to be used of persons taking -a turn in the colonnades rather than of those who are walking -into the country or to see a friend. It is the same with acting -the statesman as it is with acting the philosopher. For Socrates -to play the philosopher there was no arranging of forms, seating -himself in a chair, or observing a fixed time—arranged with -his associates—for a discussion or discourse. He played the -philosopher while joking with you, perhaps, or drinking with you, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> or possibly campaigning with you, or at market with you, and -finally when he was in prison and drinking the poison. He was -thus the first to show that life affords scope for philosophy at -every moment, in every detail, in every feeling and circumstance -whatsoever. Statesmanship should be regarded in the same -light. Foolish persons, even if they are Ministers of War, or -Secretaries, or platform-speakers, should not be considered as -acting the statesman, but as courting the mob, or making a -<span class='pageno' id='Page_93'>93</span>display, or creating dissension, or doing public service because -they must. But when a man possesses public spirit and broad -interests, and is a keen patriot and a ‘state’s man’ in the literal -sense, even if he has never worn official garb, he is playing the -statesman all the time. He does so by stimulating men of <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -ability, giving advice to those who need it, lending his help to -deliberation, discouraging bunglers, and fortifying persons of -sense. And this does not mean that he goes to the Assembly -Theatre or Senate House out of pride of place when canvassed -or pressed, and, when he gets there, merely puts in an appearance—if -he does so—by way of pastime, as he might at a show or -entertainment. It means that, even if not present in body, he <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>797<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -is present in spirit; that he asks how the business goes, and is -pleased or vexed as the case may be.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Aristeides at Athens and Cato at Rome held few public -offices; but they made their whole life a perpetual service to -their country. Though Epaminondas won many a distinguished -success as commander-in-chief, he is no less famous for what -he did in Thessaly at a time when he held no command or -office. The generals had plunged the phalanx into a difficult -situation. The enemy was attacking them with his missiles, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -and they were in confusion. Epaminondas was therefore summoned -from the ranks, and, after allaying the panic of the army -by words of encouragement, he proceeded to make an orderly -disposition of the phalanx—which was in a state of turmoil—extricated -it with ease, posted it so as to confront the enemy, -and compelled him to change his tactics and retire.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Once when King Agis was in Arcadia, and was in the act of -leading his army into action in full order of battle, one of the -elder Spartans shouted out that he was proposing to ‘mend one -error by another’, meaning (as Thucydides says) that ‘his <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -present unseasonable ardour was intended to repair the discredit -of his retreat’ from Argos. Agis listened, took the advice, and -<span class='pageno' id='Page_94'>94</span>retired. Menecrates actually had a seat placed for him every -day at the doors of the Government Office, and the Ephors -frequently rose and consulted him upon questions of the first -importance; so great was his reputation for wisdom and shrewdness. -The story goes that, when he had completely lost all -physical strength and was for the most part confined all day to -his bed, upon the Ephors sending for him to the Agora, he got -up and set out to walk. As he was toiling slowly along, he met -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> some children on the way, and asked them: ‘Do you know -anything more binding than to obey a master?’ Upon their -replying, ‘Lack of the power,’ his reason told him that this -brought his service to an end, and he turned back home. For -though zeal should not fail so long as ability lasts, we must not -put pressure upon it when left helpless.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Once more, Scipio, whether in the field or in politics, constantly -sought the advice of Gaius Laelius to such an extent -as to make some people say of his achievements that Scipio -was the actor, but the author was Gaius. And Cicero himself -acknowledges that the greatest and finest of the successful -measures of his consulship were devised with the help of the -philosopher Publius Nigidius.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> There is, then, nothing to prevent an aged man from advancing -the public good in many a department of statesmanship. -He has the best of means thereto: reason, judgement, plain-speaking, -and ‘<i>thought discreet</i>‘, as the poets say. It is not -merely our hands and feet or the strength of our bodies that -are part and parcel of the possessions of the State. Most important -are the mind and the beauties of the mind—temperance, -justice, and wisdom. It is monstrous that, as these come late and -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> slowly to their own, our house and farm and other goods and -chattels should get the benefit of them, while, in a public way, -to our country and our fellow-citizens, we make ourselves of no -further use because of ‘time’. For what time takes away from -<span class='pageno' id='Page_95'>95</span>our powers of active effort is less than what it adds to those of -guidance and statesmanship. It is for this reason that, when -Hermes is represented in an elderly form, though he has no -hands or feet, his virile parts are tense—an indirect way of saying -that there is little need for old men’s bodies to be hard at work, -so long as their power of reasoned speech is—as it ought to be—vigorous -and generative.</p> - -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_96'>96</span> - <h2 id='chap03' class='c003'>ADVICE TO MARRIED COUPLES</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>138 <span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> <span class='sc'>To Pollianus and Eurydice with Plutarch’s best wishes.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'>When they were shutting you in your bridal chamber, the -ancestral ritual was duly applied to you by the priestess of -Demeter. I believe that now, if reason also were to take you -in hand and join in the nuptial song, it would prove of some -service, and would support the tune as prescribed.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the musical world they used to call one of the modes for -the flute ‘the Horse-and-Mare’, because, apparently, the strains -in that key were provocative of union between those animals. -Well, philosophy has many excellent sermons to give, but none -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> more worthy of serious attention than that upon marriage. By -it she exerts a spell upon those who come together as partners -in life, and renders them gentle and tractable to each other. -I have, therefore, taken the main points of the lessons which you -have repeatedly heard, brought up as you have been in the company -of Philosophy. I have arranged them in a series of brief -comparisons to make them easier to remember, and am sending -them as a present to you both. In doing so I pray that the -Muses may graciously lend aid to Aphrodite, since, if it is their -province to see that a lyre or a harp shall be in tune, it is no -less so to provide that the music of the married home shall be -harmonized by reason and philosophy. When people in olden -times assigned a seat with Aphrodite to Hermes, it was because -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the pleasure of marriage stands in special need of reason; when -to Persuasion and the Graces, it was in order that the married -pair might obtain their wishes from each other by means of -persuasion, and not by contention and strife.</p> -<div> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_97'>97</span> - <h3 class='c016'><span class='sc'>The Rules</span>:</h3> -</div> -<p class='c004'>1. Solon bade the bride eat a piece of quince before coming -to the bridegroom’s arms—apparently an enigmatical suggestion -that, as a first requirement, a pleasant and inviting impression -should be gathered from an agreeable mouth and speech.</p> - -<p class='c005'>2. In Boeotia, after veiling the bride, they crown her with -a wreath of thorny asparagus. As that plant yields the sweetest -eating from among the roughest prickles, so a bride, if the -groom does not run away in disgust because he finds her difficult -and vexatious at first, will afford him a sweet and gentle companionship. -One who shows no patience with the girl’s first <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -bickerings is as bad as those who let the ripe grapes go because -once they were sour. Many a young bride is affected in the -same way. First experiences disgust her with the bridegroom, -and she makes as great a mistake as if, after enduring the sting -of the bee, she were to abandon the honeycomb.</p> - -<p class='c005'>3. It is especially at the beginning that married people should -beware of quarrel and friction. Let them note how vessels -which have been mended will at first easily pull to pieces on the -slightest occasion, but as time goes on and they become solid -at the seams, it is as much as fire and iron can do to separate <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the parts.</p> - -<p class='c005'>4. Fire is readily kindled in chaff, dry rushes, or hare’s fur, -but quickly goes out unless it gets a further hold upon something -capable both of keeping it in and feeding it. So with -that fierce blaze of passion which is produced in the newly-married -by physical enjoyment. You must not rely upon it -nor expect it to last, unless it is built round the moral character, -gets a hold upon your rational part, and so obtains a permanent -vitality.</p> - -<p class='c005'>5. Doctoring the water is no doubt a quick and easy way of <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>139<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -catching fish, but it renders them bad and uneatable. So when -<span class='pageno' id='Page_98'>98</span>women work artificially upon their husbands with philtres and -spells, and control them by the agency of pleasure, they have -but crazy simpletons and dotards for their partners. While -Circe derived no good from the men she had bewitched, and -made no use of them when turned into swine and asses, she -found the greatest pleasure in the rational companionship of -the wise Odysseus.</p> - -<p class='c005'>6. A woman who is more desirous of ruling a foolish husband -than of obeying a wise one, is like a traveller who would rather -lead a blind man than follow one who possesses sight and -knowledge.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> 7. Why should people disbelieve that Pasiphae, though -consort to a king, fell in love with an ox, when they see that -some women find a strict and continent husband wearisome, and -prefer to live with one who is as much a mass of ungoverned -sensuality as a dog or a goat?</p> - -<p class='c005'>8. When a rider is too weak or effeminate to vault upon a horse, -he teaches the animal itself to bend its legs and crouch. In the -same way some men who marry high-born or wealthy women, -instead of improving themselves, put indignities upon their -wives, in the belief that they will be more easily ruled when -humbled. The proper course is, while using the rein, to maintain -the dignity of the wife, as one would the full height of the -horse.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> 9. When the moon is at a distance from the sun, we see it -bright and luminous. When it comes near him, it fades and is -lost to view. With a properly conducted woman it is the contrary. -She should be most visible when with her husband; -in his absence she should keep at home and out of sight.</p> - -<p class='c005'>10. Herodotus was wrong in saying that when a woman lays -aside her tunic she lays aside her modesty. On the contrary, -a chaste wife puts on modesty in its place. Between married -persons the token of greatest regard is greatest modesty.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_99'>99</span>11. If two notes are taken in accord, the lower of the two is <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the dominant. So, though every action in a well-conducted -house is performed by both parties in tune, it will reveal the -husband’s leadership and priority of choice.</p> - -<p class='c005'>12. The Sun vanquished the North Wind. When the wind -endeavoured to take off the man’s cloak by violence and blowing -a gale, he only tightened his mantle the more and held it the -closer. But when, after the wind, the sun became hot, the man -began to grow warm. When at last he sweltered, he took off -not only his cloak but his tunic. The parable applies to the -generality of women. When their husbands take violent -measures to do away with extravagant indulgence, they show <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -fight and temper; but if you reason with them, they give it -up peaceably and practise moderation.</p> - -<p class='c005'>13. Cato expelled from the Senate a man who had kissed his -own wife in the presence of his daughter. This, perhaps, was -too severe a step. But if—as is the case—it is unseemly to be -fondling and kissing and embracing each other in company, it -is surely more unseemly to be scolding and quarrelling in company, -and, while treating your love-passages as a sacred secret -between you and your wife, to make an open display of fault-finding <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -and reproach.</p> - -<p class='c005'>14. A mirror,<a id='r37' /><a href='#f37' class='c009'><sup>[37]</sup></a> though decorated with gold and precious -stones, is of no use unless it shows you your form true to life. -Similarly there is no advantage in a rich wife, if her conduct -does not represent that of her husband and harmonize with -it in character. If the reflection which it offers is glum when -you are joyful, but wears a merry grin when you are gloomy and -distressed, the mirror is faulty and bad. A wife is a poor thing -and out of place if she is in the dumps when her husband is -disposed for frolic or love-making, but is all fun and laughter -when he is serious. In the former case she is disagreeable; in -<span class='pageno' id='Page_100'>100</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>140<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the latter, she slights you. Geometers tell us that lines and -surfaces make no movement by themselves, but only in conjunction -with the bodies to which they belong. In the same way -a woman should be free from peculiar states of mind of her -own, but should act as the husband’s partner in his earnestness -and his jest, in his preoccupation and his laughter.</p> - -<p class='c005'>15. A man who dislikes to see his wife eating with him, -teaches her to satisfy her appetite when she gets by herself. -Similarly one who is never a merry companion to her, nor -shares in her sport and laughter, teaches her to look for private -pleasures apart from him.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> 16. When the Persian kings are dining or feasting, their -legitimate wives sit at their side. But when they wish to amuse -themselves or get tipsy, they send those wives away and summon -their minstrel-women and concubines. The practice is a right -one, at least to the extent that they do not permit their wives -to take part in wanton and licentious scenes. So, if a private -man, who lacks self-control or good-breeding in his pleasures, -is guilty of a lapse with a common woman or a menial, the wife -should not be indignant and resentful, but should reflect that, -out of respect for her, he finds some other woman to share his -riot and lasciviousness.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> 17. When kings are fond of music, they make many musicians; -when of learning, learned men; when of athletics, gymnasts. -So when the love of a husband is for the person, his wife will -be all for dress; when for pleasure, she becomes lewd and -wanton; when for goodness and virtue, she shows herself -discreet and chaste.</p> - -<p class='c005'>18. When a Lacedaemonian girl was once asked whether she -had already embraced a man, she answered, ‘No, indeed; but -<i>he</i> has embraced <i>me</i>.’ Such, I believe, is the right attitude for -a lady—not to shun or dislike caresses, when the husband -begins them, nor yet to begin them of her own accord. The -<span class='pageno' id='Page_101'>101</span>one course is bold and immodest, the other disdainful and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -unaffectionate.</p> - -<p class='c005'>19. The woman ought not to possess private friends, but to -share those of the man. But first and greatest are the gods, -and it is therefore right for the wife to reverence or acknowledge -only those gods who are recognized by the husband. Her -street-door should be kept shut to out-of-the-way forms of -worship and alien superstitions. No deity finds gratification -in ceremonies which a woman performs in secret and by stealth.</p> - -<p class='c005'>20. Plato holds that a community is in a state of blissful -well-being when the expressions ‘<i>mine</i>’ and ‘<i>not mine</i>’ are -scarcely ever heard, inasmuch as the citizens enjoy, as far as <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -possible, the common use of everything worth considering. -Much more ought such language to be abolished from the -married state. In the same way, however, in which medical -men tell us that a blow on the left side produces an answering -sensation in the right, it is proper for a wife to sympathize with -her husband’s concerns and the husband with the wife’s. In -this way, just as ropes, when interwoven, lend each other -strength, so, through each party reciprocating the other’s -goodwill, the partnership will be maintained by both combined. -Nature blends us through the body in such a way as to take <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -a portion from each, and by commingling produce an offspring -common to both, so that neither can define or distinguish an -‘own’ part from ‘another’s’. The same sort of partnership -between married persons should assuredly exist in respect of -money also. They should pour it all into a single fund, and -blend it in such a way that they never think of one part as -‘own’ and one as ‘another’s’, but treat it all as ‘own’ and -none of it as ‘another’s’. And as we call a mixture ‘wine’, -though it may contain a greater proportion of water, so the -property of the house should be said to belong to the man, -even though the wife may contribute the larger share.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_102'>102</span>21. Helen loved wealth, and Paris loved pleasure: Odysseus -was wise, and Penelope discreet. Hence the union of the latter -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>141<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> pair was happy and enviable, while that of the former brought -upon Greeks and Asiatics an ‘Iliad of Woes’.</p> - -<p class='c005'>22. When the Roman was admonished by his friends for -having divorced a wife who was chaste, rich, and beautiful, he -stretched out his shoe and remarked: ‘Yes, and this looks -fine and new, but no one knows where it chafes me.’ The wife -must not rely upon her dowry, her birth, or her beauty. The -matters in which she touches her husband most closely are -conversation, character, and companionship. Instead of making -these harsh and vexatious day after day, she must render them -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> compatible, soothing, and grateful. Physicians are more afraid -of fevers which spring from vague causes gradually accumulating, -than of those for which there is a great and manifest reason. -So it is these little, continual, daily frictions between man and -wife, which the world knows nothing of, that do most to create -the rifts which ruin married life.</p> - -<p class='c005'>23. King Philip was once enamoured of a Thessalian woman -who was charged with bewitching him. Olympias thereupon -became eager to get this person into her power. When, upon -presenting herself, she not only turned out to be a handsome -woman, but spoke with considerable nobility and good sense, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Olympias said: ‘Those calumnies are all nonsense! Your -witchcraft lies in yourself.’ How irresistible a thing is a married -and lawful wife, if, by treating everything—dowry, birth, -philtres, the very girdle<a id='r38' /><a href='#f38' class='c009'><sup>[38]</sup></a> of Aphrodite—as lying in herself, she -conquers affection by means of character and virtue!</p> - -<p class='c005'>24. On another occasion, when a youthful courtier had -married a handsome woman of bad repute, Olympias remarked, -‘The fellow has no judgement; otherwise he would not have -<span class='pageno' id='Page_103'>103</span>married with his eyes.’ Marriage should not be made with -the eyes; neither should it with the fingers, as it is in the case -of some, who reckon up the amount of the dower, instead of -calculating the companionable quality, of the wife they are <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -marrying.</p> - -<p class='c005'>25. To young men who are fond of looking at themselves -in the mirror Socrates recommended that the ugly should -correct their defects by virtue, while the handsome should -avoid spoiling their beauty by vice. It is a good thing for the -married woman also, while she is holding the mirror, to talk -to herself, and, if she is plain, to ask, ‘And what if I show -myself indiscreet?’ if beautiful, ‘And what if I show myself -discreet as well?’ The plain woman may pride herself on being -loved for her character, and the handsome woman on being -loved more for her character than her beauty.</p> - -<p class='c005'>26. When the Sicilian despot sent Lysander’s daughters -a set of costly mantles and chains, he refused to accept them. -‘These bits of ornaments,’ said he, ‘will rather take from my <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -daughters’ beauty than set it off.’ Lysander, however, was -anticipated by Sophocles in the lines:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Nay, ’twould not seem, poor fool, to beautify,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>But to unbeautify, and prove thee wanton.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>As Crates used to say, ‘Adornment is that which adorns,’ and -that which adorns is that which adds to a woman’s seemliness. -This is not done by gold or jewels or scarlet, but by whatever -invests her with the badges of dignity, decorum, and -modesty.</p> - -<p class='c005'>27. In sacrificing to Hera as goddess of marriage, the gall -is not burned with the other portions of the sacrifice, but is <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -taken out and thrown down at the side of the altar—an indirect -injunction of the legislator that gall and anger should have no -place in the married state. The austerity of the lady of the house, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_104'>104</span>like the dryness of wine, should be wholesome and palatable, -not bitter like aloes or unpleasant like a drug.</p> - -<p class='c005'>28. Xenocrates being somewhat harsh in character, though -otherwise a high type of man, Plato recommended him to -<i>sacrifice to the Graces</i>. Now I take it that a woman of strict -morals stands in special need of the graces in dealing with her -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>142<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> husband, so that—as Metrodorus used to say—she may live -with him on pleasant terms and not ‘in a temper because she -is chaste’. A woman should no more forget to be amiable -because she is faithful, than to be neat because she is thrifty. -Decorum in a woman is rendered as disagreeable by harshness -as frugality is by sluttishness.</p> - -<p class='c005'>29. A wife who is afraid to laugh and joke with her husband -for fear of seeming bold and wanton, is as bad as the woman -who, from fear of being thought to use ointments on her head, -does not even oil it,<a id='r39' /><a href='#f39' class='c009'><sup>[39]</sup></a> and, to avoid seeming to rouge her face, -does not even wash it. We find that when poets and orators -avoid appealing to the vulgar by bad taste and affectation in -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> respect of their diction, they practise every art to attract and -stir the hearer with their matter, their treatment, and their -moral quality. So the lady of the house, because she avoids -and deprecates—as she is quite right to do—extravagant or -meretricious demonstration, ought all the more to bring the -graces of character and conduct into play in dealing with her -husband, thus habituating him to proper ways, but in a pleasurable -manner. If, however, a wife shows herself strait-laced and -rigidly austere, her husband must put the best face upon it. -When Antipater required Phocion to perform an improper and -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> degrading action, he answered, ‘I cannot serve you both as your -friend and your toady.’ In the same way, when a woman is -staid and strait-laced, our reflection should be, ‘The same -woman cannot behave to me as both a wife and a mistress.’</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_105'>105</span>30. By a national custom the Egyptian women wore no shoes, -so that they might keep at home all day. In the case of most -women, to deprive them of gold-worked shoes, bangles, anklets, -purple, and pearls, is to make them stay indoors.</p> - -<p class='c005'>31. Theano, in putting on her mantle, once showed a glimpse -of her arm. Upon some one saying, ‘A beautiful forearm!’ -she retorted, ‘But not for the public!’ A well-conducted -woman will keep, not only her forearm, but her speech, from <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -publicity. She will be as shy and cautious about her utterances -to the outside world as if they were an exposure of her person, -inasmuch as, when she talks, they are a revelation of feelings, -character, and disposition.</p> - -<p class='c005'>32. Pheidias, in representing the Elean Aphrodite with her -foot upon a tortoise, meant women to take it as a symbol of -home-keeping and silence. A woman should talk either to, -or through the medium of, her husband; nor should she resent -it if, like a player on the clarinet, she finds a more impressive -utterance through another tongue than through her own.</p> - -<p class='c005'>33. When rich or royal persons pay respect to a philosopher, -they do honour both to themselves and to him. But when -a philosopher pays court to rich people, he is not conferring <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -distinction upon them, but lowering his own. The same is the -case with women. By submission to their husbands they win -regard; by seeking to govern them they demean themselves -worse than the men so governed. Meanwhile it is only right -that the husband, in controlling the wife, should not be like -an owner dealing with a chattel, but like the mind dealing with -the body—sympathetic with the sympathy of organic union. -It is possible to care for the body without being a slave to its -pleasures and desires, and it is possible to rule a wife and yet -do things to please and gratify her.</p> - -<p class='c005'>34. Compound objects are classified by philosophers as -follows. In some the parts are distinct, as in a fleet or army. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -<span class='pageno' id='Page_106'>106</span>In some they are conjoined, as in a house or ship. In others -they form an organic unity, as in all living creatures. We may -say much the same of marriage. The marriage of love is the -‘organic unity’; the marriage for a dowry or for children -is that of persons ‘conjoined’; marriage without sharing the -same couch is that of persons ‘distinct’, who may be said to -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>143<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> dwell together, but not to live together. With persons marrying, -there should be a mutual blending of bodies, means, friends, -and relations, in the same way as, according to the scientists, -when liquids are mixed, the mixture runs through the whole. -When the Roman legislator forbade married couples to exchange -presents, he did not mean that they should not impart to each -other, but that they should look upon everything as joint -property.</p> - -<p class='c005'>35. At Leptis in Africa it is a traditional custom for the bride, -on the day after marriage, to send to the bridegroom’s mother -to borrow a pot. The latter refuses, saying she has none. The -intention is that the bride may realize from the first the ‘step-mother’ -attitude of her mother-in-law, so that, if anything -more disagreeable happens afterwards, she may not be vexed -or irritated. The wife should understand this fact and apply -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> treatment to its cause, which is, that the mother is jealous of -her son’s affections. There is but one treatment for this state -of mind. While winning the special affection of her husband -for herself, she must avoid detaching or lessening his affection -for his mother.</p> - -<p class='c005'>36. Mothers appear to be more fond of their sons, because -those sons are able to help them, and fathers of their daughters, -because daughters need their help. Maybe also it is out of -compliment to each other that both parties desire to be seen -making much of that which is more akin to the other. This, -perhaps, is a trait of no importance, but there is another which -is charming. I mean, when the wife’s respect is seen to incline -<span class='pageno' id='Page_107'>107</span>rather to the husband’s parents than to her own, and when, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -in case of anything troubling her, she refers it to them and -conceals it from her own people. If you are thought to trust, -you are trusted; if you are thought to love, you are loved.</p> - -<p class='c005'>37. The Greeks who accompanied Cyrus received the following -order from their commanders: ‘If the enemy come shouting -to the attack, await them in silence; if they come in silence, -charge to meet them with a shout.’ When a husband has his -fits of anger, if he raises his voice, a sensible wife keeps quiet; -if he is silent, she soothes him by talking to him in a coaxing way.</p> - -<p class='c005'>38. Euripides is right in blaming those who have the lyre <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -played to them at their wine. Music is more properly called -in to cure anger and grief than to encourage further abandonment -on the part of those who are taking their pleasure. So -I would have you believe that it is a wrong principle to share -the same bed for the sake of pleasure, and yet, when you are -angry or fall out, to sleep apart. That is exactly the time to -call in the Goddess of Love, who is the best physician for such -cases. This is practically the teaching of the poet, when he -makes Hera say:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in18'><i>And their tangled strife will I loosen,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>When to their couch I bring them, to meet in love and in union.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> 39. At all times and everywhere a wife should avoid offending -the husband, and a husband the wife; but especially should they -beware of doing so when together at night. In the story, the -wife, in the vexation of her throes, used to say to those who were -putting her to bed: ‘How can this couch cure a trouble which -befell me upon it?’ So quarrels, recriminations, and tempers -which are begotten in the chamber are not easily got over in -another place or at another time.</p> - -<p class='c005'>40. There appears to be a truth in Hermione’s plea: <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'>‘<i>Tis wicked women’s visits have undone me.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_108'>108</span>This occurs in more than one way, but especially when connubial -quarrels and jealousies offer to such women not only an open -door, but an open ear. At such a time, therefore, should a -sensible woman shut her ears, keep out of the way of slanderous -whispers which add fuel to the fire, and be ready to apply the -well-known saying of Philip. We are told that when his friends -were trying to exasperate that monarch against the Greeks—on -the ground that, though he treated them well, they abused -him—he remarked, ‘Well, and what, pray, if we treat them -badly?’ So, when the scandalizers say, ‘Your husband -grieves you, in spite of all your affection and chastity,’ you -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>144<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> should retort, ‘And what, pray, if I begin to hate and wrong -him?’</p> - -<p class='c005'>41. A man caught sight of a slave who had run away some time -before, and gave chase. When the slave was too quick, and -took refuge in a mill, he observed, ‘And in what better place -could I have wished to find you than where you are?‘<a id='r40' /><a href='#f40' class='c009'><sup>[40]</sup></a> So -let a woman who is declaring for a divorce through jealousy -say to herself, ‘And where would my rival be more glad to see -me? And what would she be more pleased to see me doing, than -harbouring a grievance, at feud with my husband, and actually -abandoning the house and the marriage-chamber?’</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> 42. The Athenians observe three sacred ploughings; the -first at Sciron, in memory of the oldest sowing of crops; the -second in the Rharian district; and the third—known as the -Buzygian festival—close to the Acropolis. More sacred than -all of these is the connubial ploughing and sowing for the procreation -of children. It is a happy expression of Sophocles, -when he calls Aphrodite ‘<i>fair-fruited Cytherea</i>‘. Man and -wife should therefore be especially scrupulous in this connexion, -keeping pure from unholy and unlawful intercourse with others, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_109'>109</span>and forbearing to sow where they desire no crop to grow, or, -if it does, are ashamed of it and seek to conceal it.</p> - -<p class='c005'>43. When Gorgias the rhetorician once read to the Greeks -at Olympia a discourse upon peace and harmony, Melanthius -exclaimed, ‘Here is a man giving us advice about peace and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -harmony, when in private life he has failed to harmonize three -people—himself, his wife, and his maidservant.’ For Gorgias, -it appears, was enamoured, and his wife jealous, of the domestic. -A man’s house ought to be in tune before he offers to set in tune -a state, a public meeting, or friends. The public is more likely -to hear of offences against a wife than of offences committed -by her.</p> - -<p class='c005'>44. They say that the cat is driven frantic by the smell of -unguents. If it had been the case that women were provoked <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -out of their senses by the same means, it would have been a -monstrous thing for men not to abstain from unguents, and to -let their wives suffer so cruelly for the sake of a trifling gratification -of their own. Now since, though the husband’s use of -unguents does not so afflict them, his dealings with other women -do, it is unjust to cause such vexation and distress to a wife -for the sake of a little pleasure. On the contrary, husbands -should come to their wives pure and untainted by other -intercourse, just as they would approach bees, who are said -to show disgust and hostility towards any one who has been so -engaged.</p> - -<p class='c005'>45. People never dress in bright clothes when approaching <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -an elephant, nor in red when approaching a bull, since the -animals in question are particularly infuriated by those colours. -Of tigers it is said that, if you beat drums all round them, they -go mad and tear themselves to pieces. Surely, then, inasmuch -as some men cannot bear to see scarlet or purple clothes, and -some are irritated at cymbals and tambourines, it is not asking -too much for women to leave such things alone, and not harass -<span class='pageno' id='Page_110'>110</span>or exasperate their husbands, but practise quietude and consideration -in their society.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> 46. When Philip was once seizing upon a woman against her -will, she said, ‘Let me go. All women are the same when you -take away the light.’ While this applies well enough to adulterers -and sensualists, it is particularly when the light is taken away -that a wife should <i>not</i> be the same as any ordinary female. -Her person may not be visible, but her modesty, chastity, -decorum, and natural affection should make themselves palpable.</p> - -<p class='c005'>47. Plato used to recommend that respect should rather be -paid by elderly men to the young, so that the latter might -behave modestly to them in return. For, said he, ‘where old -men are shameless,’ the young acquire no modesty or scruple. -A husband should bear this in mind, and show more respect -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>145<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> to his wife than to any one else, since the nuptial chamber -will prove to be her school of propriety or its opposite. The -husband who indulges himself in certain pleasures, while -warning her against the same, is as bad as the man who bids -his wife fight on against an enemy to whom he has himself -surrendered.</p> - -<p class='c005'>48. As to love of display, do you, Eurydice, read and endeavour -to remember what Timoxena wrote to Aristylla. And you, -Pollianus, must not expect your wife to refrain from showy -extravagance, if she sees that you do not despise it in other -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> matters, but that you take a pleasure in cups with gilding, -rooms with painted walls, mules with decorated harness, and -horses with neck-trappings. You cannot banish extravagance -from the women’s quarters when it has the free run of the -men’s. You are at the right age to cultivate philosophy. -Adorn your character, therefore, by listening to careful reasoning -and demonstration in improving company and conversation. -Be like the bees. Gather valuable matter from every source. -Carry it home in yourself, and share it with your wife by -<span class='pageno' id='Page_111'>111</span>discussing it and making all the best principles agreeable and -familiar to her. While <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Thou unto her art father, and honoured mother, and brother</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>it is no less a matter of pride to hear a wife say, ‘Husband, thou -unto me art guide, philosopher, and teacher of the noblest -and divinest lessons.’ It is studies of this kind that tend to -keep a woman from foolish practices. She will be ashamed -to be dancing, when she is learning geometry. She will lend -no ear to the incantations of sorcery, when she is listening -to those of Plato and Xenophon. When any one promises to -fetch down the moon,<a id='r41' /><a href='#f41' class='c009'><sup>[41]</sup></a> she will laugh at the ignorance and -silliness of women who believe such things; for she will possess -a knowledge of astronomy, and will have heard how Aglaonice, -the daughter of Hegetor of Thessaly, thoroughly understood <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -eclipses of the full moon, how she knew beforehand the date -at which it must be caught in the shadow, and how she -thereby cheated the women into believing that she was fetching -it down herself.</p> - -<p class='c005'>We are told that no woman produces a child without the -participation of the man, though there are shapeless and fleshlike -growths—called ‘millstones’—which form themselves spontaneously -from corrupted matter. We must beware of this -occurring in women’s minds. If they are not impregnated -with sound doctrines by sharing in the culture of their husbands, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -they will of their own accord conceive many an ill-advised -intention or irrational state of feeling.</p> - -<p class='c005'>As for you, Eurydice, above all things do your best to keep -touch with the sayings of wise and good men, and to have -continually in your mouth those utterances which you learned -by heart in my school when a girl. By so doing, you will not -only be a joy to your husband, but the admiration of other -<span class='pageno' id='Page_112'>112</span>women, when they see how, at no expense, you can adorn -yourself with so much distinction and dignity.</p> - -<p class='c005'>This rich woman’s pearls, that foreign lady’s silks, are not to -be worn without paying a large price for them. But the ornaments -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> of Theano, of Cleobuline, of Gorgo the wife of Leonidas, -of Timoclea the sister of Theagenes, of the Claudia of ancient -history, and of Cornelia the daughter of Scipio, you may wear -for nothing; and with this adornment your life may be as happy -as it is distinguished.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>146<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Sappho thought so much of her skill as a lyrist that she wrote—addressing -a wealthy woman—</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>When thou art dead, thou shalt lie with none to remember thy name:</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>For no portion hast thou in the roses Pierian....</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>You will assuredly have more occasion to think highly and -proudly of yourself, if you have a portion, not only in the roses, -but also in the fruits, which the Muses bring as free gifts to -those who prize culture and philosophy.</p> - -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_113'>113</span> - <h2 id='chap04' class='c003'>CONCERNING BUSYBODIES</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'>If a house is stuffy, dark, chilly, or unhealthy, it is perhaps <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>515 <span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -best to get out of it. But if long association makes you fond -of the place, you may alter the lights, shift the stairs, open -a door here and close one there, and so make it brighter, fresher, -and more wholesome. Even cities have sometimes been improved <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -by such rearrangement. For instance, it is said that -my own native town, which used to face the west and receive -the full force of the afternoon sun from Parnassus, was turned -by Chairon so as to front the east. Empedocles, the natural -philosopher, once blocked up a mountain gorge, which sent -a destructive and pestilential south wind blowing down upon -the plains. By this means, it was thought, he shut the plague -out of the district.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Well, since there are certain injurious and unhealthy states -of mind which chill and darken the soul, it would be best -to get rid of them—to make a clean sweep to the foundations, -and give ourselves the benefit of a clear sky, light, and pure air <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -to breathe. If not, we should reform and readjust them by -turning them some other way about.</p> - -<p class='c005'>We may take the vice of the busybody as an instance in point. -It is a love of prying into other people’s troubles, a disease -tainted—we may believe—with both envy and malice.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Why so sharp-eyed, my most malignant Sir,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>For others’ faults, yet overlook your own?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Pray turn your pryingness the other way about, and make it -face inwards. If you are so fond of the business of inquiring -into defects, you will find plenty to occupy you at home.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_114'>114</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> <i>Abundant as leaves on the oak or the water that rolls from Alizon</i> -will you find the errors in your conduct, the disorders in your -heart and mind, and the lapses in your duty.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> According to Xenophon, a good householder has a special -place for the utensils of sacrifice, and a special place for those -of the table; agricultural implements are stored in one room, -weapons of war in another. In your own case you have one -stock of faults arising from envy, another from jealousy, -another from cowardice, another from meanness. These are the -faults for you to inspect and examine. Block up the windows -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> and alleys of your inquisitiveness on the side towards your -neighbours, and open others which look into your own house—the -male quarters, the female quarters, the living-rooms of the -servants. Our busy curiosity will find occupation of a profitable -and salutary, instead of a useless and malicious, kind, if each -one will say to himself:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>How have I err’d? What deed have I done? What duty neglected?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>As it is, we are all of us like the Lamia in the fable, of whom -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>516<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> we are told that at home she is asleep and blind, with her eyes -stowed away in a jar, but that when she comes abroad she puts -them in and can see. Outside, and in dealing with others, we furnish -our malice with an eye in the shape of our meddlesomeness, -but we are continually being tripped up by our own misdeeds -and vices, of which we are unaware, because we provide ourselves -with no light or vision to perceive them. It follows that the -busybody is a better friend to his enemies than to himself. -While censoriously reproving their shortcomings and showing -them what they ought to avoid or amend, he is so taken up with -faults outside that he overlooks most of those at home.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Odysseus refused even to talk to his mother, until he had got -his answer from the seer concerning the business which had -<span class='pageno' id='Page_115'>115</span>brought him to Hades. When he had received the information, -he turned to her, and also began to put questions to the other -women, asking who Tyro was, and the beautiful Chloris, and -why Epicaste met her death by</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Tying a sheer-hung noose from the height of the lofty roof-tree</i>.</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Not so we. While treating our own concerns with the greatest -indifference, ignorance, and neglect, we begin discussing other -people’s pedigrees—how our neighbour’s grandfather was -a Syrian and his grandmother a Thracian. ‘So-and-So owes -more than seven hundred pounds, and cannot pay the interest.’ -We also make it our business to inquire about such matters as -where So-and-So got his wife from, and what private talk was -that between A and B in the corner. Socrates, on the other <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -hand, went about inquiring, ‘By what arguments did Pythagoras -carry conviction?’ So Aristippus, when he met Ischomachus -at Olympia, proceeded to ask by what kind of conversation -Socrates affected the Athenians as he did. When he had -gleaned a few seeds or samples of his talk, he was so moved -that he suffered a physical collapse, and became quite pale and -thin. In the end he set sail for Athens, and slaked his thirst -with draughts from the fountain-head, studying the man, his -discourses and his philosophy, of which the aim was to recognize -one’s own vices and get rid of them.</p> - -<p class='c005'>But there are some to whom their own life is a most distressing <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -spectacle, and who therefore cannot bear to look at it nor to reflect -the light of reason upon themselves. Their soul is so fraught with -all manner of vices, that, shuddering with horror at what lies -within, it darts away from home, and goes prowling round other -men’s concerns, where it lets its malice batten and grow fat.</p> - -<p class='c005'>It often happens that a domestic fowl, though there is plenty -of food lying at its disposal, will slink into a corner and scratch</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Where so appeareth, mayhap, one barley-grain in a dunghill.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_116'>116</span>It is much the same with the busybody. Ignoring the topics -and questions which are open to all, and which no one prevents -him from asking about or is annoyed with him if he does ask, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> he goes picking out of every house the troubles which it is -endeavouring to bury out of sight. But surely it was a neat -answer which the Egyptian made to the man who asked him -what he was carrying in that wrapper. ‘That,’ said he, ‘is why -it <i>is</i> in a wrapper.’ And why, pray, are you so inquisitive about -a thing which is being concealed? If it had not been something -undesirable, there would have been no concealment. It is not -usual to walk into another man’s house without knocking at -the door. Nowadays there are doorkeepers—formerly knockers -were beaten upon the doors in order to give warning—the intention -being that the stranger shall not surprise the lady of the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> house or her daughter in the open, or come upon a slave receiving -punishment, or the handmaids screaming. But these are exactly -the things which the busybody steals in to see. At a staid and -quiet household he would have no pleasure in looking, even -if he were invited. His object is to uncover and make public -those things to which keys, bolts, and the street-door owe -their existence. ‘The winds which vex us most,’ says Ariston, -‘are those which pull up our cloaks.’ But the busybody strips -off not only our mantles and tunics, but our walls; he spreads -our doors wide open, and makes his way like a piercing wind -through the ‘<i>maiden of tender skin</i>‘, prying and sneaking into -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>517<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> her bacchic revels, her dances, and her all-night festivals.</p> - -<p class='c005'>As Cleon in the comedy had</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>His hands in Askthorpe and his thoughts in Thefton</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>so the busybody’s thoughts are at one and the same time in the -houses of the rich and the hovels of the poor, in the courts -of kings and the chambers of the newly-wed. He searches into -everybody’s business—business of strangers, and business of -<span class='pageno' id='Page_117'>117</span>potentates. Nor is his search without danger. If one were -to take a taste of aconite because he was inquisitive as to its -properties, he would find that he had killed the learner before -he got his lesson. So those who pry into the troubles of the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -great destroy themselves before discovering what they seek. -If any one is not satisfied with the beams which the sun lavishes -so abundantly upon all, but audaciously insists upon gazing -unabashed at the orb itself and probing the light to its heart, -the result is blindness. It was therefore wise of Philippides, the -comic poet, when King Lysimachus once asked him, ‘What -can I give you of mine?’ to reply, ‘Anything, Sire, but your -secrets.’ The finest and most pleasant aspects of royalty are -those displayed outwardly—its banquets, wealth, pomps and -shows, graces and favours. But if a king has any secret, keep -away from it and leave it alone. A king does not conceal his <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -joy when prosperous, nor his laughter when jocose, nor his -intention to do a kindness or confer a boon. When he hides -a thing, when he is glum, unsmiling, unapproachable, it is -time for alarm. It means that he has been storing up anger, -and that it is festering; or that he is sullenly meditating a severe -punishment; or that he is jealous of his wife, or suspicious of -his son, or distrustful of a friend. Run, run from that cloud -which is gathering so black! You cannot possibly miss the -thunder and lightning, when the matter which is now a secret -bursts out in storm.</p> - -<p class='c005'>How, then, are we to escape this vice? By turning our -inquisitiveness—as we have said—the other way round, and, -as far as possible, directing our minds to better and more -interesting objects. If you are to pry, pry into questions <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -connected with sky, earth, air, or sea. You are by nature fond -of looking either at little things or at big things. If at big -things, apply your curiosity to the sun; ask where he sets and -whence he rises. Inquire into the changes of the moon, as if -<span class='pageno' id='Page_118'>118</span>she were a human being. Ask where she loses so much of her -light, and whence she gets it back; how</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in2'><i>Once dim, she first comes forth and makes</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Her young face beauteous, gathering to the full,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>And, when her greatest splendours she hath shown,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Fades out, and passes into naught again.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>These, too, are secrets—the secrets of Nature; but Nature has -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> no grievance against those who find them out. Are the big -things beyond you? Then pry into the smaller ones. Ask how -it is that some plants are always flourishing and green, proudly -displaying their wealth at every season, while others are at one -moment as good as these, but at another have squandered their -abundance all at once, like some human spendthrift, and are -left bare and beggared. Why, again, do some plants produce -elongated fruits, some angular, some round and globelike?</p> - -<p class='c005'>But perhaps you will have no curiosity for such concerns, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> because there is nothing wrong about them. Well, if inquisitiveness -absolutely must be always browsing and passing its time -among things sordid, like a maggot among dead matter, let us -introduce it to history and story, and supply it with bad things -in abundance and without stint. For there it will find</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Fallings of men and spurnings-off of life</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>seductions of women, assaults by slaves, slanderings of friends, -concoctions of poisons, envies, jealousies, shipwrecks of homes, -overthrows of rulers. Take your fill, enjoy yourself, and cause no -annoyance or pain to any of those with whom you come in contact.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Apparently, however, inquisitiveness finds no pleasure in -scandals which are stale; it wants them hot and fresh. And -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>518<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> while it enjoys the spectacle of a novel tragedy, it takes no sort -of interest in the comedy or more cheerful side of life. Consequently -the busybody lends but a careless and indifferent ear -to the account of a wedding, a sacrifice, or a complimentary -<span class='pageno' id='Page_119'>119</span>‘farewell’. He says he has already heard most of the details, -and urges the narrator to cut them short or omit them. But -if any one will sit by him and tell him the news about the corruption -of a girl or the unfaithfulness of a wife or an impending -action at law or a quarrel between brothers, there is no sleepiness -or hurry about him, but</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>More words still doth he ask, and proffers his ears to receive them.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>As applied to the busybody, the words</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>How much more apt to reach the ear of man</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>An ill thing than a happy!</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>are a true saying. As a cupping-glass sucks from the flesh what <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -is worst in it, so the inquisitive ear draws to itself the most -undesirable topics. To vary the figure: cities have certain -‘Accursed’ or ‘Dismal’ gates, through which they take out -criminals on their way to death and throw the refuse and -offscourings of purification, while nothing sacred or undefiled -goes in or out through them. So with the ears of the busybody. -They give passage to nothing fine or useful, but serve only as -the pathway of gruesome communications, with their load of -foul and polluted gossip.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>No chance brings other minstrel to my roof,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>But always Lamentation.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> That is the one Muse and Siren of the busybody, the most -pleasant of all music to his ear. For his vice is a love of finding -out whatever is secret and concealed, and no one conceals a good -thing when he has one; on the contrary, he will pretend to -one which has no existence. Since therefore it is troubles that -the busybody is eager to discover, the disease from which he -suffers is malignant gloating—own brother to envy and spite. -For envy is pain at another’s good; malignity is pleasure at -another’s harm; and the parent of both is ill-nature—the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -feeling of a savage or a brute beast.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_120'>120</span>So painful do we all find it to have our troubles revealed, that -there are many who would rather die than tell a physician of -a secret disease. Imagine Herophilus or Erasistratus, or Asclepius -himself—when he was a mortal man—calling from house to -house with his drugs and his instruments, and asking whether -a man had a fistula or a woman a cancer in the womb! Inquisitiveness -in their profession may, it is true, save a life. None the -less, I presume, every one would have scouted such a person, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> for coming to investigate other people’s ailments without -waiting till he was required and sent for. Yet our busybody -searches out precisely these, or even worse, ailments; and, since -he does so not by way of curing them, but merely of disclosing -them, he deserves the hatred he gets.</p> - -<p class='c005'>We are annoyed and indignant with the collector of customs,<a id='r42' /><a href='#f42' class='c009'><sup>[42]</sup></a> -not when he picks out and levies on those articles which we -import openly, but when, in the search for hidden goods, he -ransacks among baggage and merchandise which are not in -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> question. Yet the law permits him to do so, and he is the -loser if he does not. On the other hand, the busybody lets his -own concerns go to ruin, while he is occupying himself with -those of other people. He rarely takes a walk to the farm; it is -too lonely, and he cannot bear the quiet and silence. And if, -after a time, he does chance along, he has a keener eye for his -neighbour’s vines than for his own. He proceeds to ask how -many of his neighbour’s cattle have died, or how much of his -wine turned sour. After a good meal of such news he is quickly -off and away.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Your true and genuine type of farmer has no desire to hear -even the news which finds its own way from the city. Says he:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in6'><i>Then, while he digs, he’ll tell</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>The terms o’the treaty. He must now, confound him,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Go round and poke his nose in things like that!</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_121'>121</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>519<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> But to your busybody country life is a stale and uninteresting -thing with nothing to fuss about. He therefore flees from it, -and pushes into the Exchange, the Market, or the Harbour. -‘Is there any news?’ ‘Why, weren’t you at market early this -morning? Do you imagine there has been a revolution in three -hours?’ If, however, any one has a piece of news to tell, down -he gets from his horse, grasps the man’s hand, kisses him, and -stands there listening. But if some one meets him and says -there is nothing fresh, he exclaims, as if he were annoyed: -‘What? Haven’t you been at market? Haven’t you been near -the Board-Room? And haven’t you met the new arrivals from <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Italy?’</p> - -<p class='c005'>The Locrian magistrates therefore did right in fining any one -who, after being out of town, came up and asked, ‘Is there any -news?’ As the butchers pray for a good supply of animals, and -fishermen for a good supply of fish, so busybodies pray for a good -supply of calamities, for plenty of troubles, for novelties and -changes. They must always have their fish to catch or carcass -to cut up.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Another good rule was that of the legislator of Thurii, who -forbade the lampooning of citizens on the stage, with the exception -of adulterers and busybodies. The one class bears a resemblance -to the other, adultery being a sort of inquisitiveness into <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -another’s pleasure, and a prying search into matters protected -from the general eye, while inquisitiveness is the illicit denuding -and corrupting of a secret. While a natural consequence of -much learning is having much to say, and therefore Pythagoras -enjoined upon the young a five years’ silence, which he called -‘Truce to Speech’, the necessary concomitant of curiosity is -speaking evil. What the curious delight to hear, they delight -to talk about; what they take pains to gather from others, they -joy in giving out to new hearers. It follows that, besides its <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -other drawbacks, their disease actually stands in the way of its -<span class='pageno' id='Page_122'>122</span>own desires. For every one is on his guard to hide things from -them, and is reluctant to do anything when the busybody is -looking, or to say anything when he is listening. People put off -a consultation and postpone the consideration of business until -such persons are out of the way. If, when a secret matter is -towards, or an important action is in the doing, a busybody -appears upon the scene, they take it away and hide it, as they -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> would a piece of victuals when the cat comes past. Often, -therefore, he is the only person not permitted to hear or see -what others may see and hear.</p> - -<p class='c005'>For the same reason the busybody can find no one to trust -him. We would rather trust our letters, papers, or seals to -a slave or a stranger than to an inquisitive relation or friend. -Bellerophon, though the writing which he carried was about -himself, would not broach it, but showed the same continence -in keeping his hands off the king’s letter as in keeping them off -his wife.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Yes, inquisitiveness is as incontinent as adultery, and not only -incontinent, but terribly silly and foolish. To pass by so many -women who are public property, and to struggle to get at one -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> who is kept under lock and key, who is expensive, and perhaps -ugly to boot, is the very height of insanity. The busybody is just -as bad. He passes by much that is admirable to see and hear, -many an excellent discourse or discussion, to dig into another -man’s poor little letter or clap his ear to his neighbour’s wall, -listening to slaves and womenfolk whispering together, and -incurring danger often, and discredit always.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>520<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Well, if he wishes to get rid of his vice, the busybody will find -nothing so helpful as to think over the discoveries he has hitherto -made. Simonides used to say that, in opening his boxes after -a lapse of time, he found the fee-box always full and the thanks-box -always empty. So, if one were to open the store-room of -inquisitiveness after an interval, and to contemplate all the -<span class='pageno' id='Page_123'>123</span>useless, futile, and uninviting things with which it is filled, -he would probably become sick of the business, so nauseating -and senseless would it appear.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Suppose a person to run over the works of our old writers -and pick out their faultiest passages, compiling and keeping a -book full of such things as ‘headless’ lines of Homer, solecisms <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -in the tragedians, the indecent and licentious language to -women by which Archilochus makes a sorry show of himself. -Does he not deserve the execration in the tragedy:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Perish, thou picker-up of miseries!</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Execration apart, his treasury, filled with other men’s faults, -possesses neither beauty nor use. It is like the town which -Philip founded with the rudest riff-raff, and which he called -Knaveborough.</p> - -<p class='c005'>With the busybody, however, it is not from lines of poetry, but -from lives, that he goes gleaning and gathering blunders and -slips and solecisms, till the memory which he carries about is -the dullest and dreariest record-box, crammed with ugly things. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<p class='c005'>At Rome there are those who set no store by the paintings, -the statues, or—failing these—the handsome children or women -on sale, but who haunt the monster-market, examining specimens -with no calves to their legs, or with weasel-elbows, three -eyes, or ostrich-heads, and looking out for the appearance of any</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Commingled shape and misformed prodigy.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Yet if you keep on showing them such sights, they will soon -become surfeited and sick of it all. In the same way those who -make it their business to pry into other people’s failures in their -affairs, blots on their pedigree, disturbances and delinquencies -in their homes, will do well to remind themselves how thankless <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -and unprofitable their previous discoveries have proved.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The most effective way, however, of preventing this weakness -is to form a habit—to begin at an early stage and train ourselves -<span class='pageno' id='Page_124'>124</span>systematically to acquire the necessary self-control. It is by -habit that the vice increases, the advance of the disease being -gradual. How this is, we shall see, in discussing the proper -method of practice.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Let us make a beginning with comparatively trifling and -insignificant matters.</p> - -<p class='c005'>On the roads it can be no difficult matter to abstain from reading -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the inscriptions on the tombs. Nor in the promenades can -there be any hardship in refusing to let the eye linger upon -the writings on the walls. You have only to tell yourself that -they contain nothing useful or entertaining. There is A expressing -his ‘kind sentiments’ towards B; So-and-So described -as ‘the best of friends’; and much mere twaddle of the same -kind. No doubt it seems as if the reading of them does you no -harm; but harm you it does, without your knowing it, by inducing -a habit of inquiring into things which do not concern -you. Hunters do not permit young hounds to turn aside and -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> follow up every scent, but pull them sharply back with the leash, -so as to keep their power of smell in perfectly clean condition for -their proper work, and make it stick more keenly to the tracks:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>With nostril a-search for the trail that the beast gives forth from its body</i>.</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>The same watchfulness must be shown in suppressing, or in -diverting to useful ends, the tendency of an inquisitive person -to run off the track and wander after everything that he can -see or hear. An eagle or a lion gathers its talons in when it -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>521<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> walks, so as not to wear the sharp edge from their tips. Similarly -let us treat the inquiring spirit as the keen edge to our love of -learning, and refrain from wasting or blunting it upon objects -of no value.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the next place let us train ourselves, when passing another’s -door, to refrain from looking in, or from letting our inquisitive -<span class='pageno' id='Page_125'>125</span>gaze clutch at what is passing inside. Xenocrates said—and we -shall do well to keep the remark in mind—that whether we set -foot or set eyes in another man’s house makes no difference. -Not only is such prying unfair and improper; we get no pleasure -from the spectacle.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Unsightly, stranger, are the sights within</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>is a saying which is generally true of what we see inside—a litter -of pots and pans, or servant-girls sitting about, but nothing of <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -any importance or interest. This furtive throwing of sidelong -glances, which at the same time gives a kind of squint to the -mind, is ugly, and the habit is demoralizing. When the Olympian -victor Dioxippus was making a triumphal entry in a chariot, -and could not drag his eyes from a beautiful woman among the -spectators, but kept turning half round and throwing side -glances in her direction, Diogenes—who saw it all—remarked, -‘See how a bit of a girl gets the neck-grip on our great athlete!’ -Inquisitive people, however, are to be seen gripped by the neck -and twisted about by any kind of sight, when they once develop -a habit of squandering their glances in all directions.</p> - -<p class='c005'>This is assuredly no right use of the faculty of vision. It should <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -not go gadding about like some ill-trained maidservant; but -when the mind sends it upon an errand, it should make haste -to reach its destination, deliver its message, and then come -quietly home again to wait upon the commands of the reason. -Instead of this, the case is as in Sophocles:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Thereon the Aenean driver’s hard-mouthed colts</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Break from control.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>When the faculty of vision has not been tutored and trained -in the proper manner as above described, it runs away, drags <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the mind with it, and often brings it into disastrous collisions.</p> - -<p class='c005'>There is a story that Democritus deliberately destroyed his sight -by fixing his eyes upon a red-hot mirror and allowing its heat -<span class='pageno' id='Page_126'>126</span>to be focussed upon them. His object, it is said, was to block -up the windows toward the street, and thus prevent the disturbance -of his intellect by repeated calls from outside, enabling -it to stay at home and devote itself to pure thinking. Though -the story is a fiction, nothing is more true than that those who -make most use of their mind make few calls upon the senses. -Note how our halls of learning are built far out from the towns, -and how night has been styled the ‘<i>well-minded</i>‘, from a belief -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> that quiet and the absence of distraction are a powerful aid to -intellectual discovery and research.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Suppose, again, that people are quarrelling and abusing each -other in the market-place. It requires no great effort of self-denial -to keep at a distance. When a crowd is running towards -a certain spot, it is easy for you to remain seated, or else, if you -lack the necessary strength of mind, to get up and go away. -There is no advantage to be got from mixing yourself with -busybodies, whereas you will derive great benefit from putting -a forcible check upon your curiosity and training it to obey -the commands of the reason.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> We may now go a step further, and tax ourselves more severely. -It is good practice, when a successful entertainment is going -on in a public hall, to pass it by; when our friends invite us -to a performance by a dancer or comedian, to decline; when -there is a roar in the race-ground or the circus, to take no notice. -Socrates used to urge the avoidance of all foods and drinks -which tempt one to eat when he is not hungry or to drink when -he is not thirsty. In the same way we shall do well to shun -carefully all appeals to eye or ear, when, though they are no -business of ours, their attractions prove too much for us.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Cyrus refused to see Panthea, and when Araspes talked of her -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>522<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> remarkable beauty, his answer was: ‘All the more reason for -keeping away from her. If I took your advice and went to see -her, she might perhaps tempt me to be visiting her again when -<span class='pageno' id='Page_127'>127</span>I could not spare the time, and to be sitting and looking at her -to the neglect of much important business.’ In the same way -Alexander refused to set eyes on Darius’ wife, who was said to -be strikingly handsome. Though he visited the mother—an -elderly woman—he would not bring himself to see her young -and beautiful daughter. But what we do is to peep into women’s -litters and hang about their windows, finding nothing improper -in encouraging our curiosity and allowing it such dangerous <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -and unchecked play.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Note how you may train yourself for other virtues. To learn -justice you should sometimes forgo an honest gain, and so -accustom yourself to keep aloof from dishonest ones. Similarly, to -learn continence, you should sometimes hold aloof from your own -wife, and so secure yourself against temptation from another’s. -Apply this habit to inquisitiveness. Endeavour occasionally to -miss hearing or seeing things which concern yourself. When -something happens at home, and a person wishes to tell you of -it, put the matter off; and when things have been said which -appear to affect yourself, refuse to hear them. Remember how -Oedipus was brought into the direst disasters by over-curiosity. -Finding he was no Corinthian, but an alien, he set to work <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -to discover who he was, and so he met with Laius. He killed -him, married his own mother, with the throne for dowry, and -then, while apparently blessed by fortune, began his search once -more. The endeavours of his wife to prevent him only made -him question still more closely, and in the most peremptory way, -the old man who was in the secret. And at last, when circumstances -are already bringing him to suspect, and the old man cries:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Alas! I stand on the dread brink of speech!</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>he is nevertheless in such a blaze or spasm of passion that he -replies:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>And I of hearing; and yet hear I must.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_128'>128</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> So bitter-sweet, so uncontrollable, is the excitement of curiosity—like -the tickling of a wound, at which one tears till he makes it -bleed. Meanwhile if we are free from that malady, and mild -by nature, we shall ignore a disagreeable thing and say:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Sovran Oblivion, how wise art thou!</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>We must therefore train ourselves to this end. If a letter is -brought to us, we must not show all that hurry and eagerness -to open it which most people display, when they bite the -fastenings through with their teeth, if their hands are too slow. -When a messenger arrives from somewhere or other, we must -not run to meet him, nor get up from our seats. If a friend -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> says, ‘I have something new to tell you,’ let us reply: ‘Better, -if you have something useful or profitable.’ When I was once -lecturing at Rome, the famous Rusticus—who was afterwards -put to death by Domitian out of jealousy at his reputation—was -among my hearers. A soldier came through the audience -and handed him a note from the emperor. There was a hush, -and I made a pause, to allow of his reading the letter. This, -however, he refused to do, nor would he open it, until I had -finished my discourse and the audience broke up. The incident -caused universal admiration at his dignified behaviour.</p> - -<p class='c005'>But when one feeds his inquisitiveness upon permissible -material until he makes it robust and headstrong, he no longer -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> finds it easy to master, when force of habit urges it towards -forbidden ground. Such persons will stealthily open their -friends’ missives, will push their way into a confidential meeting, -will get a view of rites which it is an impiety to see, will tread -in hallowed places, and will pry into the doings and sayings of -a king.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Now with a despot—who is compelled to know everything—there -is nothing that makes him so detested as the crew known -as his ‘ears’ and ‘jackals’. ‘Listeners’ were first instituted -<span class='pageno' id='Page_129'>129</span>by Darius the Younger, who had no confidence in himself and -looked upon every one with fear and suspicion. ‘Jackals’ were <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>523<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the creation of the Dionysii, who distributed them among the -people of Syracuse. Naturally, when the revolution came, -these were the first to be seized and cudgelled to death by the -Syracusans.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Blackmailers and informers are a breed belonging to the Busybody -clan; they are members of the family. But, whereas the -informer looks to see if his neighbours have done or plotted any -mischief, the busybody brings to book and drags into public -even the misfortunes for which they are not responsible. It -is said that the outcast derived his name of <i>aliterios</i> in the -first instance from being a busybody. It appears that when -a severe famine once occurred at Athens, and when those who -were in possession of wheat, instead of bringing it in to the public <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -stock, used to grind it (<i>alein</i>) secretly by night in their houses, -certain persons, who went round watching for the noise of the -mills, were in consequence called <i>aliterioi</i>. It was in the same -way, we are told, that the informer won his name of <i>sukophantes</i>. -The export of figs (<i>suka</i>) being prohibited, those who gave -information (<i>phainein</i>) and impeached the offenders were called -<i>sukophantai</i>. Busybodies would do well to reflect upon this -fact. It may make them ashamed of the family likeness between -their own practices and those of a class which is a special object -of loathing and anger.</p> - -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_130'>130</span> - <h2 id='chap05' class='c003'>ON GARRULOUSNESS</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>502 <span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> When philosophy undertakes to cure garrulity it has a difficult -and intractable case in hand. The remedy is reason, which -requires that the patient should listen. But the garrulous person -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> does not listen, for he is always talking. Herein lies the first -trouble with an inability to keep silent; it means an inability -to listen. It is the deliberate deafness of a person who appears -to find fault with nature for giving him two ears and only one -tongue. Euripides is, of course, right when he says of the -unintelligent hearer:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>I cannot fill a man who cannot hold</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>My wise words, poured and poured in unwise ears.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>But there is more reason to say of the babbler:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>I cannot fill a man who takes not in</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>My wise words, poured and poured in unwise ears</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>—or rather poured over them, since he talks though you do -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> not listen, and refuses to listen when you talk. For even if, -thanks to some ebb in his loquacity, he does listen for a -moment, he immediately makes up for it several times over.</p> - -<p class='c005'>There is a colonnade at Olympia which reverberates a single -utterance time after time, and is therefore known as the ‘Seven-Voiced’. -Say but the least thing to set garrulity sounding, and -it immediately dins you with its echoes:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Stirring the strings o’ the mind that none should stir.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>The passage through the babbler’s ears leads, apparently, not -to his mind, but to his tongue. Consequently, while others -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> retain what is said, the loquacious person lets it all leak away, -and goes about like a vessel full of noise but void of sense. -<span class='pageno' id='Page_131'>131</span>Nevertheless, if we are resolved to leave no stone unturned, -let us say to the babbler:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Hush, boy: in silence many a virtue lies</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and, first and foremost, the two virtues of hearing and being -heard. The garrulous person can get the benefit of neither, and -makes a miserable failure of the very thing he is aiming at.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In other mental maladies—love of money, love of glory, love -of pleasure—there is at least a chance of gaining the object -pursued. But with the babbler that result can hardly happen. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -What he desires is listeners, and listeners he cannot get, for they -all run headlong away. If, when they are sitting in a lounge -or taking a walk together, they catch sight of him approaching, -they promptly pass each other the word to shift camp.</p> - -<p class='c005'>When a silence occurs at some meeting, it is said that <i>Hermes -has appeared upon the scene</i>. Similarly, when a chatterer comes -in to a wine-party or a social circle, everybody grows mum, for <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>503<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -fear of giving him an opportunity. And if he begins of his own -accord to open his lips, then</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>As ere the storm, when the North wind blows</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>By the headland that juts to the deep</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>the prospect of being tossed and seasick is so distressing that -up they get and out they go.</p> - -<p class='c005'>For the same reason he finds no welcome from neighbours -at a dinner or from messmates on a journey or a voyage. They -merely tolerate him because they must. For he sticks to you -anywhere and everywhere, seizing you by the clothes or the -beard, and slapping you in the ribs.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Then are your feet most precious</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>as Archilochus would say—and not only Archilochus, but that -wise man Aristotle. When the latter was himself once worried <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -by a chatterer, who bored him with a number of silly stories -<span class='pageno' id='Page_132'>132</span>and kept repeating, ‘Isn’t it wonderful, Aristotle?’ he retorted, -‘The wonder is not at that, but at any one tolerating you, when -he owns a pair of legs.’ To another person of the kind, who, -after a great deal of talk, remarked, ‘Master, I have wearied -you with my chatter,’ he replied, ‘Not at all; I was not -listening.’ Precisely so. If a chatterer insists on talking, the -mind surrenders the ears to him and lets the stream pour over -them on the outside, while inwardly it goes its own way, opening -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> and reading to itself a book of quite different thoughts. It -follows that he can get no hearer either to attend to him or to -believe him. A babbler’s talk is as barren of effect as the seed -of a person over-prone to sexualities is said to be.</p> - -<p class='c005'>And yet there is no part of us which Nature has fenced with -so excellent a barricade as the tongue. In front of that organ -it has planted a guard in the shape of the teeth, so that, if it -will not obey orders and pull itself together inside when reason -tightens the ‘<i>silence-working reins</i>‘,<a id='r43' /><a href='#f43' class='c009'><sup>[43]</sup></a> we may check its rashness -by biting it till it bleeds. The phrase of Euripides is that -‘<i>disaster is the end</i>’ not of an ‘unchained’ treasury or storeroom, -but of an ‘<i>unchained mouth</i>‘. To recognize that a storeroom -without a door, or a purse without a fastening, is of no -use to the owner, and yet to possess a mouth without lock or -door, but with as perpetual an outflow as the mouth of the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Black Sea, is to set the lowest possible value on speech.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The result is that such a person meets with no belief, though -all speech has that object, its final cause being to create precisely -such credence in the hearer. A chatterer is disbelieved even -when he tells the truth. For as wheat, when shut in a bin, is -found to increase in bulk but to deteriorate in quality, so, when -a story finds its way into a chatterer, it generates a large addition -of falsehood and its credibility is thereby corrupted.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_133'>133</span>Again, any self-respecting and well-behaved person will -beware of drunkenness. For while—as some put it—anger lives -next door to madness, drunkenness lives in the same house. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Or rather it <i>is</i> madness, of shorter duration, it is true, but more -culpable, as being in a measure voluntary. But the charge most -seriously urged against drunkenness is its intemperate and irresponsible -language:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>For though right shrewd be a man, wine eggs him on till he singeth;</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>It loosens him that he laughs with a feeble laughter, and danceth.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Yet if this were the worst—singing, laughing, and dancing—there -would be, so far, nothing very terrible.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>And he letteth slip some speech, the which were better unspoken</i>:—</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> that is where the mischief and danger begin.</p> - -<p class='c005'>We may, indeed, believe that these lines of the poet give -the solution of the question discussed in the philosophic schools -as to the distinction between mellowness and intoxication: -mellowness produces unbending, but drunkenness foolish twaddling. -As the proverb-makers put it, ‘<i>What is in the sober -man’s heart is on the drunken man’s tongue.</i>’ Hence when Bias -once kept silent at a carousal, and a chatterer taunted him with -stupidity, he retorted: ‘And, pray, who could keep silent over -his wine, if he were a fool?’ A certain person at Athens was <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>504<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -once entertaining envoys from a king, and, as they were eager -for him to get together the philosophic teachers, he made -every effort to gratify them. While the rest took part in general -discussion, to which each contributed his quota, Zeno said -nothing. At this the visitors, pledging him in friendly and -courteous terms, asked him, ‘And what are we to say to the -king about you, Zeno?’ ‘Merely,’ replied he, ‘that there is -one old man at Athens who is capable of holding his tongue <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -when drinking.’</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_134'>134</span>Silence, then, goes with depth, the capacity to keep a secret, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> and sobriety. Drunkenness, on the other hand, will be talking, -for it means folly and witlessness, and therefore loquacity. In -fact, the philosophic definition of intoxication calls it ‘<i>silly -talk in one’s cups</i>‘. The blame, therefore, is not for drinking, -if one can drink and yet at the same time hold his tongue. -It is the foolish talk that converts mellowness into drunkenness.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Well, while the drunken man talks nonsense at his wine, the -babbler talks it everywhere—in the market-place, in the theatre, -when walking, when tipsy, by day and by night. As your doctor, -he is a greater infliction than the disease; as your shipmate, -more disagreeable than the sea-sickness; his praises are more -annoying than another person’s blame. A tactful rogue is more -pleasant company than an honest chatterer. In Sophocles, when -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Ajax is beginning to use rough language, Nestor, in endeavouring -to soothe him, says politely:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>I blame thee not; for though thy words are wrong,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Thine acts are right.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>But those are not our feelings towards the twaddler. On the -contrary, the tactlessness of his talk spoils and nullifies anything -acceptable in what he may do.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Lysias once gave a litigant a speech which he had composed -for him. After reading it several times the man came back. -In a despondent tone he told Lysias that, when he first went -through the speech, it appeared wonderfully good, but on taking -it up a second and third time, he found it extremely weak and -ineffective. ‘Well,’ said Lysias laughing, ‘isn’t it only once -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> that you have to speak it before the jury?’ And consider how -persuasive and charming Lysias is! For he is another who</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Hath goodly portion, I trow,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Of the Muses violet-tress’d.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Of all things that are said about the great bard the truest is -<span class='pageno' id='Page_135'>135</span>this—that Homer alone manages never to cloy the appetite, -since he is always new, and his charm always at its height. -Nevertheless, exclaiming on his own account in the words of -Odysseus: <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in20'><i>But to me it is hateful</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>To tell o’er a story again, when once right plainly ’tis told you</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>he is continually avoiding that tendency to surfeit which threatens -talk of every kind, carrying his hearers from one story to another, -and relieving their satiety by his constant freshness.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Our babblers, on the contrary, bore us to death with their -repetitions, as if our ears were palimpsests for them to scrawl -rubbish upon.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Let this, then, be the first thing of which we remind them. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -It is with talking as it is with wine. The purpose of wine is to -create pleasure and friendly feeling; but to insist upon our -drinking it in great quantities and without qualifying it, is to -lead us into offensive and wanton behaviour. So, while talk -plays the most pleasant and human part in our intercourse, -those who make a wrong and rash use of it render it inhuman -and insufferable. The means by which they imagine they are -ingratiating themselves and gaining admiration and friendship, -only makes them a nuisance and wins them ridicule and dislike.</p> - -<p class='c005'>How destitute of charm would be a person who alienated -his company and drove them away with the very ‘girdle of -charm’! And how destitute of culture and tact is the man <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -who arouses annoyance and hostility by means of speech!</p> - -<p class='c005'>Other infirmities and disorders may be dangerous or detestable -or ridiculous. Garrulity is all three at once. It is derided for -relating what everybody knows; it is hated for bearing bad -news; it is endangered through blabbing secrets. This is the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>505<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -reason why, when Anacharsis went to sleep after being entertained -at dinner at Solon’s house, he was seen to be holding -his right hand over his mouth. He believed—quite rightly—that -<span class='pageno' id='Page_136'>136</span>the tongue requires a firmer control than any other member. -It would be difficult, for instance, to count up as many persons -who have been ruined by sensuality, as cities and dominions -which have been brought to destruction by the divulgence of a -secret. When Sulla was besieging Athens, he could not afford -to spend much time upon it,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Since other labour was urging</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Mithridates having seized upon Asia, and the Marian party -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> being again masters of Rome. It happened, however, that -a number of old men were talking at a barber’s, to the effect -that no watch was kept upon the Heptachalcon and that the -town was in danger of capture at that point. They were overheard -by spies, who gave information to Sulla; and he promptly -brought up his forces at midnight, led in his army, and almost -razed the city to the ground, filling it with carnage till the -Cerameicus flowed with blood. His anger with the Athenians -was, however, due more to their words than to their deeds. -They would leap on to the walls, and abuse him and Metella, -and by jeering at him with <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>A mulberry is Sulla, sprinkled o’er with barley-meal</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and a number of similar scurrilities, they brought upon themselves—to -use a phrase of Plato—‘<i>a very heavy penalty</i>’ for -that ‘<i>very light</i>’ thing, their words.</p> - -<p class='c005'>It was, again, the talkativeness of one man that prevented -Rome from obtaining its freedom by the removal of Nero. -All preparations had been made, and only a single night was -left before the despot was to perish. It happened, however, -that the man who was to perform the assassination, when on -his way to the theatre, saw a prisoner at the palace doors on the -point of being brought before Nero. As he was bewailing his -fate, our friend came up close and whispered to him, ‘My good -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> man, only pray that to-day may pass, and to-morrow you will -<span class='pageno' id='Page_137'>137</span>be offering me thanks.’ The prisoner grasped the meaning of -the hint, and reflecting, I suppose, that</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>’Tis a fool who forgoes what he holds, to pursue what is out of his keeping</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>chose the surer rather than the more righteous way of saving -himself. That is to say, he informed Nero of the expression -used. The man was thereupon promptly seized, and underwent -rack, fire, and lash while denying, in the face of constraint, -what he had betrayed without any constraint.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The philosopher Zeno, for fear that bodily suffering might -force him to reveal some secret in spite of himself, bit through -his tongue and spat it out at the despot. Leaena, again, has -been gloriously rewarded for her self-command. She was the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -mistress of Harmodius and Aristogeiton, and she shared in their -plot against the despots—to the best of her hopes, which was -all a woman could do. For she also was inspired with the -bacchic frenzy of that glorious ‘<i>bowl of love</i>‘, and the God had -caused her also to be initiated into the secret. Well, after they -had failed and met their death, she was put to the question and -ordered to inform against those who still escaped detection. -She refused, and the firmness with which she bore her sufferings <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -proved that, in the love of those heroes for such a woman, -there was nothing unworthy of themselves. The Athenians -therefore had a bronze lioness made without a tongue, and set -it up in the gates of the Acropolis, that courageous animal -representing her indomitable firmness, and the absence of a -tongue her power of silence in keeping a solemn secret.</p> - -<p class='c005'>No uttered word has ever done such service as many which -have been unuttered. You may some day utter what you have -kept silent, but you cannot unsay what has been said; it has -been poured out, and has run abroad. Hence, I take it, we have -mankind to teach us how to speak, but gods to teach us how to -<span class='pageno' id='Page_138'>138</span>keep silent, our lesson in that art being received at initiatory -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>506<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> rites and mysteries. Odysseus, who possessed most eloquence, -the poet has made most reticent; he has done the same with -his son, his wife, and his nurse. You hear how she says:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Like stubborn oak or like iron will I hold your secret and keep it.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>In the case of Odysseus himself, as he sat beside Penelope,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Though in his heart he pitied his wife, and was sore at her weeping,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Steady within their lids stood his eyes as horn or as iron.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> So full of self-command was his body in every part, under such -perfect discipline and control did reason hold it, that it forbade -the eyes to shed a tear, the tongue to utter a sound, the heart -to tremble or cry out with rage;</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>And his heart once more did obey, and endure with a patient enduring</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>inasmuch as reason had extended even to his irrational movements -and made his very breath and blood amenable to its -authority. Most of his comrades also were of the same character. -Self-command and loyalty could no further go than in their case. -Though harried and dashed upon the ground by the Cyclops, -they would not denounce Odysseus to him. They would not -betray the plot against his eye and the implement which had -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> been sharpened in the fire for that purpose; but they chose -to be eaten raw rather than tell a word of the secret.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Pittacus, therefore, was not far out, when, upon the King of -Egypt sending him a sacrificial victim and bidding him pick -out the ‘fairest and foulest’ part of the meat, he took out and -sent him the tongue, as being the instrument of both the -greatest good and the greatest evil.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Euripides’ Ino, making bold to speak for herself, says that she -knows how to be</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Silent in season, speak where speech is safe.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_139'>139</span>Those, indeed, who are blessed with a noble and a truly royal -education, know first how to be silent and then how to talk. -The famous king Antigonus, when his son asked him at what <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -hour they were to break camp, replied, ‘What are you afraid of? -That you may be the only one to miss hearing the trumpet?’ -Was it that he did not trust with a secret the man to whom he -intended to bequeath his throne? Rather he meant to teach -him self-mastery and caution in dealing with such matters. -The aged Metellus, on being asked a similar question during -a campaign, answered, ‘If I thought my shirt knew that secret, -I would take it off and put it on the fire.’ When Eumenes -heard that Craterus was advancing, he told the fact to none of -his friends, but pretended that it was Neoptolemus, whom his <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -soldiers despised, whereas they entertained a great respect for -the reputation of Craterus and a high esteem of his ability. -As, however, no one else found out the truth, they joined battle, -won the victory, killed Craterus without knowing him, and only -discovered who he was from his corpse. So good a general was -the silence of Eumenes in the battle, and so formidable the -opponent whose presence it disguised, that his friends admired -instead of blaming him for not forewarning them. Even if -some one does find fault, it is better to be accused when mistrust -has saved you than to be the accuser when trust proves your -undoing.</p> - -<p class='c005'>What excuse can one possibly find for himself when blaming -another for not holding his tongue? If the matter ought not to <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -have been known, it was wrong to tell it to any one else. If you -let the secret slip from yourself, and yet ask another person to -keep it, you take refuge in the loyalty of some one else while -abandoning loyalty to yourself. And if he turns out as bad as -you, you are deservedly undone; if better, you are saved by -a miracle, through finding another person more faithful to you -than yourself. ‘But So-and-So is my friend.’ So is a second -<span class='pageno' id='Page_140'>140</span>person <i>his</i> friend, whom <i>he</i> again will trust as <i>I</i> trust <i>him</i>. -So with that person and a third, and thus the talk will go on -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>507<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> increasing and extending in link after link of weak betrayal. The -Unit never goes beyond its own limit, but is, once and for all, -‘oneness’—whence its name. But the number ‘two’ is the -indefinite beginning of difference, for by the duplication it at -once shifts in the direction of multitude. In the same way, so -long as a piece of information is confined to the first possessor, it is -really and truly a ‘secret’. But if it passes by him to a second, -it must be classed as a ‘report’. ‘<i>Winged words</i>,’ says the poet. -If you let go from your hand a thing with wings, it is not easy -to get it back into your grasp; and if you let an observation -slip from your lips, it is impossible to seize and secure it, but -away it flies</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>on nimbly-whirling wing</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and circulates in all directions from one set of people to another.</p> - -<p class='c005'>When a ship is caught by a wind, they put a check upon it -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> and deaden its speed with cables and anchors; but let a speech -run—so to speak—out of port, and it finds no place to cast and -ride at anchor. It is carried away with a roar, till he who has -uttered it is dashed and sunk upon some great and terrible -danger.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>From but a little torch-light Ida’s heights</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>May all be set ablaze; so, tell but one,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>And all the town will know it.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>The Roman Senate had been engaged for a number of days -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> in debating a secret matter of policy. As it gave rise to much -mystification and conjecture, a woman—otherwise irreproachable, -but still a woman—kept pestering her husband and -imploring him to tell her the secret. On her oath, she would -be silent: if not, might a curse fall upon her. She wept and -wailed because she was ‘not trusted’. From a desire to bring -home her folly by a proof, the Roman said, ‘Have your way, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_141'>141</span>wife. But the news is terribly ominous. We have been informed -by the priests that a lark has been seen flying about with a gold -helmet and a spear. We are therefore discussing the portent, -and are inquiring, with the help of the augurs, whether it is -good or bad. But mind you tell nobody.’ With these words -he went off to the Forum. The wife at once seized hold of <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the first maid-servant to enter the room, and, beating her own -breast and tearing her hair, exclaimed, ‘O my poor husband -and country! What will become of us?‘, her wish being to -give the maid the opportunity of asking ‘Why, what has happened?’ -At any rate she took the question as put, and told the -tale, adding the invariable refrain of every babbler, ‘Tell no one -about it, but hold your tongue.’ The girl no sooner left her -than she looked for the fellow-servant who had least to do, and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -imparted it to her. She in turn told it to her lover, who was -paying her a visit. The story went rolling on so rapidly that it -reached the Forum before the man who had invented it, and -he was met by an acquaintance, who said, ‘Have you just -come down from home?’ ‘This minute,’ he replied. ‘Then -you haven’t heard anything?’ ‘No. Why? Is there any -news?’ ‘A lark has been seen flying about with a gold helmet -and a spear, and the magistrates are about to hold a Senate -meeting on the matter.’ At this the man exclaimed with -a laugh, ‘O wife, wife! What a speed! To think the story -has got to the Forum ahead of me!’ First he interviewed the -magistrates and relieved their anxiety; then, on going home, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -he proceeded to punish his wife by saying, ‘Wife, you have been -the ruin of me. The secret is public property, and the fault -has been traced to my house. And so I am to be exiled, all -because of your loose tongue.’ Upon her attempting to deny -it by arguing ‘But there were three hundred who heard it as -well as you’, he retorted ‘Pooh for your three hundred! I -invented it to try you, all because of your persistence’.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_142'>142</span>In this case the man took safe precautions in putting his wife -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>508<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> to the test, by pouring into the leaky vessel not wine or oil, but -water. It was otherwise with Fulvius, the close friend of -Augustus. The emperor in his old age was lamenting to him -over his desolate home and grieving because, two of his daughter’s -children being dead, and Postumius, the only one left, being -in exile on some calumnious charge, he was being driven to -adopt his wife’s son as his successor, although he felt compassion -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> for his grandson and was considering the question of recalling -him from abroad. Fulvius divulged what he had heard to his -wife, and she to Livia; whereupon Livia took Caesar bitterly -to task, asking why, if he had been so long of this mind, he did -not send for his grandson, instead of putting her in a position -of enmity and strife with the successor to the throne. Accordingly, -when Fulvius came to him—as he regularly did—in the -morning and said ‘Good morning, Caesar’, he replied ‘Good-bye, -Fulvius’. Fulvius took the hint, went away home at once, -sent for his wife, and said, ‘Caesar knows that I have betrayed -his secret, and I propose therefore to put myself to death.’ -‘Rightly too,’ answered his wife, ‘seeing that, after living with -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> me so long, you failed to discover the looseness of my tongue -and to guard against it. But after me, if you please’—and seizing -the sword she despatched herself first.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The comic poet Philippides therefore acted rightly when, in -answer to the friendly civilities of King Lysimachus and his -question ‘What is there of mine that I can share with you?‘, -he replied ‘What you choose, Sire, except your secrets.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>On the other hand garrulity goes with the equally objectionable -vice of inquisitiveness. The babbler must find much to -hear, so that he may have much to tell. Especially must he -go round tracking and hunting out hidden secrets, so as to provide -himself with a miscellaneous stock-in-trade for his foolish -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> talk. Then, like a child with a piece of ice, he neither likes to -<span class='pageno' id='Page_143'>143</span>keep hold nor wants to let go. Or rather, the secrets are reptiles, -which he grasps and puts in his bosom, but which he cannot -hold tight, and so is devoured by them. Garfish and vipers—so -we are told—burst in giving birth to their young. So the escape -of a secret is ruin and destruction to him who lets it out.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Seleucus the Victorious, having lost all his army and resources -in his fight with the Gauls, tore off his royal circlet with his -own hands, and fled away on horseback with three or four -attendants. After a long and circuitous ride away from the -highroads, he was at last so overcome by want that he approached -a homestead, and being fortunate enough to find the owner in <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -person, asked him for bread and water. The man not only -gave him these, but supplied him liberally and in the most -friendly way with whatever else he had upon his farm. In doing -so he recognized the king’s face. So overjoyed was he at his -fortunate opportunity of rendering him service, that, instead of -restraining himself and playing up to the king’s desire to be -unknown, he accompanied him as far as the road, and, on taking -his leave, said, ‘Good-bye, King Seleucus.’ At this the king, -holding out his right hand and drawing the man towards him -as if to kiss him, gave a sign to one of the attendants to cut off -his head with a sword;</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>And so, with the word on his lips, his head in the dust lay mingled</i>,—</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>whereas, if he had then had the patience to hold his tongue <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for a little while, he would in all probability, when the king -subsequently won success and power, have earned a larger -return for his silence than for his hospitality.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In this case, it is true, the man’s hopes and kindly feeling -formed some excuse for his lack of self-command. Most -babblers, however, have no excuse at all for their own undoing. -For example, people were once talking in a barber’s shop about -<span class='pageno' id='Page_144'>144</span>the despotism of Dionysius, and saying how firmly established -it was against all assault. At this the barber remarked laughingly, -‘How can you say that, when every few days I have my -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>509<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> razor at his throat?’ No sooner did Dionysius hear of this -speech than he impaled the barber.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Barbers, by the way, are generally a garrulous crew. Their -chairs being the resort of the greatest chatterers, they catch -the bad habit themselves. It was a neat quip that Archelaus -once gave to a loquacious barber. After putting the towel -round him, the man asked, ‘How shall I cut your hair, Sire?’ -‘In silence,’ he replied. It was a barber also who reported the -great disaster of the Athenians in Sicily, he having been the -first to hear it at the Peiraeus from a slave, who had run away -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> from the spot. Abandoning his shop, he hurried at full speed -to town,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Lest another the glory might win</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>by imparting the news to the capital,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>while he might come but the second</i>.</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>A panic naturally ensued, and the people were gathered to an -assembly, where they set to work to trace the rumour to its -source. When, however, the barber was brought forward and -questioned, he did not even know the name of his informant, -but could only give as his authority a person unnamed and unknown. -Thereupon the audience shouted in anger: ‘To the -rack and the wheel with the wretch! The thing is a pure concoction! -Who else has heard it? Who believes it?’ The wheel -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> had been brought, and the man had been stretched upon it, -when there appeared upon the scene the bearers of the disastrous -news, who had escaped from the very midst of the action. -At this they all dispersed, to occupy themselves with their private -griefs, leaving the poor wretch bound upon the wheel. When -at a late hour towards evening he was set free, he proceeded to -<span class='pageno' id='Page_145'>145</span>ask the executioner ‘whether they had also heard in what manner -Nicias, the commander, had met his death’. Such a hopeless and -incorrigible failing does garrulity become through force of habit.</p> - -<p class='c005'>After drinking a bitter and evil-smelling medicine, we are -disgusted with the cup as well. In the same way, if you are the -bearer of bad news, you are regarded with disgust and hatred -by those who hear it. Hence a pretty discussion in Sophocles: <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'>A. <i>Is it in ear or heart that thou art stung?</i></div> - </div> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'>B. <i>Why seek thus to define where lies my pain?</i></div> - </div> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'>A. <i>’Tis the doer grieves thine heart, I but thine ears.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Be that as it may, a speaker causes pain as well as a doer. Nevertheless -there is no stopping or chastening a loose, glib tongue.</p> - -<p class='c005'>On one occasion it was discovered that the temple of Athena -‘Of the Bronze House’ at Sparta had been pillaged, and an -empty flask was found lying inside. The crowd which had -run together could make nothing of it, when one of their -number said, ‘If you like, I will tell you my notion as to the -flask. I fancy the robbers, realizing all the danger they were to -run, first drank hemlock, and then brought wine with them. -If they managed to escape detection, they were to neutralize <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the effects of the poison by drinking the unmixed wine, and so -get away in safety. If they were caught, they were to die an -easy and painless death from the poison, before they could be -put to torture.’ The theory was so ingenious and acute that it -appeared to come of knowledge rather than conjecture. He was -therefore surrounded and questioned on every side—‘Who are <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -you? Who knows you? How do you get to know all that?‘—till -finally, under this searching examination, he confessed that -he was one of the thieves.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Were not the murderers of Ibycus found out in the same way? -As they were sitting in the theatre, a number of cranes happened -to come in sight, and they whispered laughingly to one another, -‘Here are the avengers of Ibycus!’ They were overheard by -<span class='pageno' id='Page_146'>146</span>persons sitting near them, and as a search was being made for -Ibycus, who had been missing for a considerable time, the -words were seized upon and reported to the magistrates. By -this means the matter was brought home, and the assassins -carried off to prison, where their punishment was due, not to -the cranes, but to their own garrulity, which played the part -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>510<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> of an Erinys or Spirit of Vengeance in compelling them to -divulge the murder. For as in the body, when a part is diseased -or in pain, the neighbouring matter gathers towards it by -attraction; so is it with the babbler’s tongue. Perpetually -throbbing and inflamed, it must keep drawing towards itself -some secret or other which ought to be concealed.</p> - -<p class='c005'>We must therefore make ourselves secure. Let Reason lie -like a barrier in the way of the tongue, to restrain its flow or -prevent its slipping. And let us show that we possess no less -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> sense than certain geese of which we are told. It is said that, -when they cross from Cilicia over the Taurus Range—which is -full of eagles—they clap a bolt or bit upon their utterance. -That is to say, they take in their mouths a good-sized stone, -and so fly over at night without being discovered.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Now if it were asked</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Who it is that is the vilest, who most unredeemed of men</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>it is the traitor who would always be named before any one -else. Well, Euthycrates (as Demosthenes puts it) ‘<i>roofed his -house with the timber got from Macedon</i>‘. Philocrates received -a large sum of gold and proceeded to buy ‘<i>strumpets and fish</i>‘. -Euphorbus and Philagrus, who betrayed Eretria, received lands -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> from the Persian king. But the babbler is a traitor who volunteers -his services without pay, not in the way of betraying -horses or fortresses, but of divulging secrets connected with -lawsuits, party feuds, or political manœuvres. Instead of -any one thanking him, he actually has to thank people for -<span class='pageno' id='Page_147'>147</span>listening to him. The line addressed to a man who was recklessly -squandering his money by giving indiscriminate presents—</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Not generous, you: ’tis your disease; you love to be a-giving</i>—</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>fits the prater also. ‘You do not give this information out of -friendliness and goodwill. ’Tis your disease; you love to be -a-talking and a-babbling.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>These remarks are not to be regarded as simply an indictment -of garrulity. They are an attempt to cure it. An ailment is <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -overcome by diagnosis and treatment, but diagnosis comes first. -No one can be trained to avoid or to rid his mental constitution -of a thing which causes him no distress. That distress we learn -to feel at our disorders, when reason leads us to perceive the -injury and shame which result from them. Thus in the present -instance we perceive that the babbler is hated where he desires -to be liked, annoys where he wishes to ingratiate himself, is -derided where he thinks he is admired, and spends without -gaining anything by it. He wrongs his friends, assists his <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -enemies, and ruins himself. The first step, therefore, in physicing -this disorder, is to reflect upon the disgrace and pain which -it causes. The second is to consider the advantages of the -contrary behaviour, constantly hearing, remembering, and -keeping at our call the praises of reticence, the solemn and -sacramental associations of silence, and the fact that it is not -by your unbridled talker at large that admiration, regard, and -reputation for wisdom are won, but by the man of short and -pithy speech, who can pack much sense into few words.</p> - -<p class='c005'>We find Plato commending such persons, and saying that, in <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -their deliverance of crisp, terse, and compact utterances, they -resemble a skilful javelineer. Lycurgus, again, forced his fellow-citizens -to acquire this gift of compression and solidity by -applying the pressure of silence from their earliest childhood.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The Celtiberians produce steel from iron by first burying -<span class='pageno' id='Page_148'>148</span>it in the ground and then clearing away the earthy surplusage. -So is it with Lacedaemonian speech. It has no surplusage, but -is steadily hardened down to absolute effectiveness by the -removal of everything unessential. And this knack of theirs of -saying a pithy thing, or making a keen and nimble retort, is the -result of a great habit of silence.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>511<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> We must not omit to give our chatterer examples of such -brevities, in order to show how pretty and effective they are. -For instance:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>The Lacedaemonians to Philip</i>: <i>Dionysius at Corinth</i>;</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and, again, when Philip wrote to them ‘<i>If I enter Laconia, -I will turn you out</i>‘, they wrote back, ‘<i>If.</i>’ When King Demetrius -shouted in his indignation, ‘Have the Lacedaemonians -sent only one envoy to <i>me</i>?‘, the envoy replied undismayed, -‘One to one.’ Among our ancient worthies also we admire -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the men of few words. It was not the <i>Iliad</i> or the <i>Odyssey</i> -or the paeans of Pindar that the Amphictyons inscribed upon -the temple of the Pythian Apollo, but the maxims <i>Know -Thyself</i>: <i>Nothing in Excess</i>: <i>Give pledge, and Mischief is nigh</i>, -which they admired for their simple and compact expression, -with its closely-hammered thought in small compass. And does -not the god himself show a love of conciseness and brevity in -his oracles, deriving his name of ‘Loxias’ from the fact that he -would rather be obscure than garrulous?</p> - -<p class='c005'>Do we not also particularly praise and admire those who can -say, by means of a symbol and without speaking a word, all that -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> is necessary? For instance, when his fellow-citizens insisted -upon Heracleitus proposing some measure for the promotion -of concord, he mounted the platform, took a cup of cold water, -sprinkled it with barley-meal, stirred it with a slip of pennyroyal, -drank it off, and went home. This was his way of intimating -that to be satisfied with the commonest things, and to have no -<span class='pageno' id='Page_149'>149</span>expensive wants, is the way to maintain a community in peace -and concord. Another case is that of Scilurus, the Scythian -king, who left behind him eighty sons. When he was dying, -he called for a bundle of small spears, and bade them take and -break it in pieces, tied together as it was, and in the mass. -When they gave up the task, he himself drew the spears out one -by one and snapped them all with ease, thereby demonstrating <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -how invincible was their strength if harmoniously united, how -weak and short-lived if they did not hold together.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Any one, I believe, who constantly recalls these and the like -examples, will cease to take a pleasure in chattering. But—speaking -for myself—there is a story of a certain slave which -greatly discourages me, when I reflect how hard it is to be so -careful of our words as to make sure of our purpose. The orator -Pupius Piso, not wishing to be troubled, ordered his slaves to -talk only in answer to questions, and not a word more. Subsequently, -being anxious to welcome Clodius in his official -position, he gave orders for him to be invited to dinner, and -prepared what was, of course, a splendid banquet. When the -hour arrived, the other guests were all present and waiting for <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Clodius. The slave who regularly carried the invitations was -repeatedly sent out to see whether he was on his way. When -evening came and he was given up in despair, Piso said to the -slave, ‘Of course you took him the invitation?’ ‘I did,’ he -answered. ‘Then why has he not appeared?’ ‘Because he -refused.’ ‘Then why did you not tell me so at once?’ ‘Because -you did not ask me that question.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>So much for the slave at Rome, whereas at Athens he will tell -his master while digging</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>What terms are named i’ the treaty</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>so great in all things is the force of habituation. To habituation -let us now turn.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_150'>150</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> We cannot check the babbler by taking, as it were, a grip -on the reins. The malady can only be overcome by habit.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the first place, therefore, when questions are asked of your -neighbours, train yourself to keep silent until they have all -failed to answer.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Counsel hath other ends than running hath</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>says Sophocles, and so has speech or answer. In running, the -victor is the man who comes in first, but here the case is different. -If another makes a satisfactory reply, the proper course is to -lend approval and a word of support, and so win credit for good -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>512<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> feeling. If he fails, there is nothing invidious or inopportune in -giving the information which he does not possess, or in supplementing -his deficiencies. But above all things let us be on our -guard, when a question is put to another person, that we do -not anticipate him and take the answer out of his mouth. -In any case in which a request is made of another it is, of course, -improper for us to push him aside and offer our own services. -By doing so we shall appear to be casting a slur on both parties; -as if the one were incapable of performing what is asked, and as -if the other did not know the right quarter from which to get -what he asks for. But it is especially in connexion with answers -to questions that such impudent forwardness is an outrage on -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>B<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> manners. To give the answer before the person questioned has -time, implies the remark, ‘What do you want <i>him</i> for?‘, or -‘What does <i>he</i> know?‘, or, ‘When <i>I</i> am present, nobody else -should be asked that question.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Yet we often put a question to a person, not because we need -the information, but by way of eliciting from him a few words -of a friendly nature, or from a wish to lead him on to converse, -as Socrates did with Theaetetus and Charmides. To take the -answer out of another’s mouth, to divert attention to yourself -and wrest it from another, is as bad as if, when a person desired -<span class='pageno' id='Page_151'>151</span>to be kissed by some one else, you ran forward and kissed him -yourself, or as if, when he was looking at another, you twisted -him round in your own direction. The right and proper <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -course, even if the person who is asked for information cannot -give it, is to wait, to take your cue to answer from the wish -of the questioner—his invitation not having been addressed -to you—and then to meet the situation in a modest and -mannerly way. If a person of whom a question is asked makes -a mistake in answering it, he meets with a due measure of -indulgence; but one who pushes himself forward and insists -on answering first, receives no welcome if he is right, while, -if he is wrong, he becomes an object of positive exultation and -derision.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The second item of our regimen concerns the answering of -questions put to ourselves. Our garrulous friend must be particularly -careful with these. In the first place he must not be -deceived into giving serious replies to those who merely provoke -him into a discussion in order to make a laughing-stock of him. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Sometimes persons who require no information simply concoct -a question for the amusement and fun of the thing, and submit -it to a character of this kind in order to set his foolish tongue -wagging. Against this trick he must be on his guard. Instead -of promptly jumping at the subject as if he were grateful, he -should consider both the character of the questioner and the -necessity for the question. And when it is clear that information -is really desired, he must make a habit of waiting and -leaving some interval between question and answer. There -will then be time for the inquirer to add anything he -wishes, and for himself to reflect upon his reply, instead of -overrunning and muddling the question, hurriedly giving <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -first one answer and then another while the question is still -going on.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The Pythian priestess, of course, is accustomed to deliver -<span class='pageno' id='Page_152'>152</span>oracles on the instant, even before the question is asked, inasmuch -as the God whom she serves</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Understandeth the dumb, and heareth a man though he speak not.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>But if you wish your answer to be to the purpose, you must -wait for the questioner’s thought to be expressed, and discover -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> precisely what he is aiming at. Otherwise it will be a case of -the old saying:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Asked for a bucket, they refused a tub.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>In any case that ravenous greed to be talking must be checked. -Otherwise it will seem as if a stream, which has long been banked -up at the tongue, is taking joyful advantage of the question to -disgorge itself. Socrates used to control his thirst on the same -principle. He would not permit himself to drink after exercise -without pouring away the first jugful drawn from the well, -thereby training his irrational part to wait until reason named -the time.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>513<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> There are three possible kinds of answer to a question—the -barely necessary, the polite, and the superfluous. For instance, -to the inquiry, ‘Is Socrates at home?‘, one person may reply, -in an offhand and apparently grudging way, ‘Not at home;’ -or, if he is disposed to adopt the Laconian style, he will omit -the ‘at home’ and merely utter the negative. Thus the -Lacedaemonians, when Philip had written to ask, ‘Do you -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> receive me into your city?‘, wrote a large <i>No</i> on a piece of paper -and sent it back. Another, with more politeness, answers, -‘No, but you will find him at the bankers’ tables’—going so -far, perhaps, as to add, ‘waiting for some strangers.’ But, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> third, our inordinate chatterbox—at any rate, if he happens also -to have read Antimachus of Colophon—will say, ‘No; but you -will find him at the bankers’ tables, waiting for some strangers -from Ionia, concerning whom he has had a letter from Alcibiades, -who is near Miletus, staying with Tissaphernes, the Great -<span class='pageno' id='Page_153'>153</span>King’s Satrap, the same who used formerly to help the Lacedaemonians, -but who is now attaching himself to the Athenians, -thanks to Alcibiades; for Alcibiades is anxious to be recalled -from exile, and is therefore working upon Tissaphernes to change -sides.’ In fact he will talk the whole eighth book of Thucydides -and will deluge the questioner with it, until, before he has done, -there is war with Miletus and Alcibiades has been exiled for <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the second time.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Here especially should loquacity be repressed. It should be -forced to follow in the footsteps of the question, and to confine -the answer within the circle of which the questioner’s requirement -gives the centre and radius. When Carneades, before he -became famous, was once discoursing in the gymnasium, the -superintendent sent and requested him to lower his voice, which -was a very loud one. Upon his replying ‘Give me my limit for -reach of voice’, the officer aptly rejoined ‘The person who is -speaking with you’. So, in making an answer, let the limit <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -be the wishes of the questioner.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the next place remember how Socrates used to urge the -avoidance of those foods and drinks which induce you to eat -when you are not hungry and to drink when you are not thirsty. -So those subjects in which he most delights, and in which he -indulges most immoderately, are the subjects which the babbler -should shun, and whose advances he should resist. For example, -military men are given to prosing about wars. Homer introduces -Nestor in that character, making him relate his own deeds -of prowess time after time. Take, again, those who have -scored a victory in the law-courts, or who have met with -surprising success at the courts of governors or kings. Generally <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -speaking, they are chronic sufferers from an itch to talk about it, -and to describe over and over again how they came in, how they -were introduced, how they played their parts, how they talked, -how they confuted some opponent or accuser, and what eulogies -<span class='pageno' id='Page_154'>154</span>they won. Their delight is more loquacious than that ‘sleepless -night’ in the comedy, and is perpetually fanning itself into new -flame and keeping itself fresh by telling over the tale. They are -therefore prone to slip into such subjects at every pretext. -For not only</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Where the pain is, there also goes the hand</i>;</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> no less does the part which feels pleasure draw the voice and -twist the tongue in its own direction, from a desire to dwell -perpetually on the theme. It is the same also with amorous -persons, who chiefly occupy themselves with such conversation -as brings up some mention of the object of their passion. If -they cannot talk to human beings about it, they do so to -inanimate things:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>O bed most dear!</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>or</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Bacchis thought thee a god, thou blessed lamp;</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>And greatest god thou art, methinks, through her.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>No doubt it makes not a pin’s difference to the chatterer -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>514<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> what subject of conversation may arise. Nevertheless, if he -has a greater predilection for one class of subjects than for -another, he ought to be on his guard against that class and -force himself to hold aloof from it, since those are the subjects -which can always tempt him furthest into prolixity for the -pleasure of the thing. It is the same with those matters in -which the talker thinks that his experience or ability gives him -a superiority over other people. Through egotism and vanity -such a person</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Giveth the most part of the day to that</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Wherein he showeth to the most advantage.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>With the much-read man it is general information; with the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> expert in letters, the rules of literary art; with the much-travelled -man, accounts of foreign parts. These subjects also -<span class='pageno' id='Page_155'>155</span>must therefore be shunned. They are an enticement to -loquacity, which is led on to them like an animal towards its -wonted fodder. One admirable feature in the conduct of Cyrus -was that, in his matches with his mates, he challenged them to -compete at something in which he was not more, but less, -expert than they. Thus, while he caused no pain by eclipsing -them, he also derived advantage from a lesson. With the -chatterer it is the other way about. If any subject is mooted -which gives him the opportunity of asking and learning something -he does not know, he cannot even pay so small a fee <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for it as merely holding his tongue, but he blocks the topic -and elbows it aside, working steadily round till he drives the -conversation into the well-worn track of stale old twaddle.</p> - -<p class='c005'>We have had an example of this among ourselves, where a -person who happened to have read two or three books of Ephorus -used to weary every one to death, and put any convivial party -to rout, by everlastingly describing the battle of Leuctra and its -sequel, until he earned the nickname of ‘Epaminondas’. If, -however, we are to choose between evils, this is the least, and we -must divert loquacity into this channel. Talkativeness will be <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -less disagreeable when its excess is in an expert connexion.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the next place such persons should habituate themselves -to putting things in a written or conversational form when alone. -The case is not as with Antipater the Stoic. He gained his -sobriquet of ‘Pen-Valiant’ because, being—as it would appear—unable -and unwilling to come out and meet the vehement -attacks made by Carneades upon the Porch, he kept filling his -books with written disputations against him. But if the babbler -turns to writing and valiantly fights shadows with his pen, the -occupation will keep him from attacking people at large and -will render him daily more bearable to his company. It will -be as with dogs. Let them vent their anger on sticks and stones, -and they are less ferocious to human beings. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_156'>156</span>Another extremely beneficial course for talkers to adopt is -to associate continually with their superiors and elders, out of -respect for whose standing they will develop a habit of holding -their tongues.</p> - -<p class='c005'>As part and parcel of this training we should always vigilantly -apply the following reflection, when we are on the point of -talking and the words begin running to our mouths: ‘What -<i>is</i> this remark that is so pressing and importunate? With what -object is my tongue so impatient? What honour do I get by -speaking, or what harm by keeping quiet?’ If the thought were -an oppressive weight to be got rid of, the matter would be -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> different; but it remains with you just as much, even if it is -spoken. When men talk, it is either for their own sake, because -they want something, or it is to help the hearer; or else they -seek to ingratiate themselves with each other by seasoning with -the salt of rational conversation the pastime or business in which -they happen to be engaged. But if a remark is neither of -advantage to the speaker nor of importance to the hearer, if it -contains nothing pleasant or interesting, why is it made? The -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> meaningless and futile is as much to be avoided in words as it is -in deeds.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Over and above all this, we should keep in lively recollection -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>515<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the saying of Simonides that he ‘had often repented of talking, -but never of holding his tongue’. We should remember also -that practice is a potent thing and overcomes all difficulties. -People get rid even of the hiccoughs or a cough by resolutely -resisting them. Yet this involves trouble and pain, whereas -silence not only, as Hippocrates says, ‘prevents thirst;’ it also -prevents pain and suffering.</p> - -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_157'>157</span> - <h2 id='chap06' class='c003'>ON THE STUDENT AT LECTURES</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'><span class='sc'>My dear Nicander</span>, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>37 <span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<p class='c005'>This is an article upon ‘The Attitude of the Student’, -which I have written and am sending to you. Its purpose is to -teach you the right attitude towards your philosophic teacher, -now that you are a grown-up man and are no longer obliged -merely to obey orders.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Some young men are so ill-informed as to suppose that absence -of restraint is the same thing as freedom, whereas, by unchaining <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the passions, it makes them slaves to a set of masters more -tyrannical than all the teachers and mentors of childhood. -Herodotus says that when women take off the tunic they also -take off shame. It is the same with some young men. In laying -aside the garb of childhood they also lay aside shame and fear. -No sooner do they unloose the cloak which controlled their -conduct than they indulge in the utmost misbehaviour. With -you it should be otherwise. You have been told over and over -again that to ‘follow God’ and to ‘obey reason’ are the same -thing. Understand, therefore, that with right-minded persons -a coming of age does not mean rejection of rule, but change -of ruler. For the hired or purchased<a id='r44' /><a href='#f44' class='c009'><sup>[44]</sup></a> director of conduct they <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -substitute one that is divine—namely, reason. Only those who -follow reason deserve to be considered free; for they alone live -as they choose, because they alone have learned to make the -right choice, whereas ignorant and irrational desires and actions -give small and paltry scope to the will, but great scope to -repentance.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_158'>158</span>Note what happens in the case of naturalized citizens. Entire -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> foreigners from another country will often grumble irritably -at their experiences, whereas those who have previously been -denizens of the state, and have therefore lived in intimate touch -with the laws, will accept their obligations with cheerful -readiness. So with yourself. For a long time you have been -growing up in the company of philosophy. From the first you -have been accustomed to a taste of philosophic reason in everything -that you have been taught or told as a child. It should -therefore be in a well-disposed and congenial spirit that you come -to Philosophy, who alone can adorn a youth with that finish -of manhood which genuinely and rationally deserves the name.</p> - -<p class='c005'>You will not, I believe, object to a prefatory remark upon -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>38<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the sense of hearing. Theophrastus asserts that it is the most -susceptible of all the senses, inasmuch as nothing that can be -seen, tasted, or touched, is the cause of such strong emotional -disturbance and excitement as takes hold upon the mind when -certain sounds of beating, clashing, or ringing fall upon the ear. -It is, however, more rational, rather than more emotional, -than the other senses. Vice can find many places and parts -of the body open for it to enter and seize upon the soul. But -the only hold that virtue can take is upon pure young ears -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> which have at all times been protected from the corruptions -of flattery or the touch of low communications. Hence the -advice of Xenocrates, that ear-guards should be worn by boys -more than by athletes, inasmuch as the latter merely have their -ears disfigured by blows, while the former have their characters -disfigured by words. Not that he would wed us to inattention -or deafness. It is but a warning to beware of wrong communications, -and to see that others of the right nature have first -been fostered in our character by philosophy and have mounted -guard in that quarter which is most open to influence and -persuasion.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_159'>159</span>Bias, the ancient sage, was once bidden by Amasis to send him -that piece of meat from a sacrificial victim which was at the -same time the best and the worst. He replied by taking out and -sending the tongue, on the ground that speech can do both the -greatest harm and the greatest good. It is a general practice -in fondling little children to take them by the ears, and to bid <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -them do the same to us—an indirect and playful way of suggesting -that we should be especially fond of those who make our -ears the instruments to our advantage.</p> - -<p class='c005'>It is, of course, obvious that a youth cannot be debarred from -any or every kind of hearing, or from tasting any discourse at -all. Otherwise not only will he remain entirely without fruit -or growth in the way of virtue; he will actually be perverted -in the direction of vice, his mind being an idle and uncultivated -patch producing a plentiful crop of weeds. Propensity to -pleasure and dislike of labour—the springs of innumerable forms -of trouble and disease—are not of external origin, nor imported <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -from teaching, but they well up naturally from the soil. If -therefore they are left free to take their natural course; if they -are not done away with, or turned aside, by sound instruction; -if nature is not thus brought under control, man will prove -more unreclaimed than any brute beast.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The hearing of lectures, then, may be of great profit, but at -the same time of great danger, to a young man. This being so, -I believe it a good thing to make the matter one of constant -discussion, both with oneself and with others. In most cases <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -we may notice a false procedure—that of cultivating the art of -speaking before being trained to the art of listening. It is -thought that, while speaking requires instruction and practice, -any kind of listening is attended with profit. But not so. -Whereas in ball-play one learns simultaneously how to throw -and how to catch, in the business of speech the right taking in is -prior to the giving out, just as conception is prior to parturition. -<span class='pageno' id='Page_160'>160</span>We are told that in the case of a hen laying a wind-egg her -labour and travail end in nothing but an abortive and lifeless -piece of refuse. So when a young man lacks the ability to listen, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> or the training to gather profit through the ear, the speech -which he lets fall is wind-begotten indeed:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Sans all regard and sans note it is lost in the clouds and dispersèd.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>He will take a vessel and tilt it in the right direction for receiving -anything to be poured into it, and so ensure a real ‘in-pouring’ -instead of a pouring to waste. But he does not learn to lend his -own attention to a speaker and meet the lecture half-way, so as -to miss no valuable point. On the contrary, his behaviour is -in the last degree ridiculous. If he happens upon a person -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>39<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> describing a dinner, a procession, a dream, or a brawling-match -in which he has been engaged, he listens in silence and is eager -for more. But if a teacher to whom he has attached himself -tries to impart something useful, or to urge him to some duty, -to admonish him when wrong, or to soothe him when angry, -he is out of all patience. If possible, he shows fight, and is -ambitious to get the best of the argument. Otherwise he is -off and away to discourses of a different and a rubbishy kind, -filling his ears—the poor leaky vessels—with anything rather than -the thing they need.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> From the right kind of breeder a horse obtains a good mouth -for the bit, and a lad a good ear for reason. He is taught to -do much listening, but to avoid much speaking. We may quote -the remark of Spintharus in praise of Epaminondas, that he had -scarcely ever met with any man either of greater judgement or -of fewer words. Moreover, we are told, the reason why nature -gave each of us two ears, but only one tongue, was that we should -do less speaking than hearing.</p> - -<p class='c005'>A youth is at all times sure to find silence a credit to him; -but in one case it is especially so—when he can listen to another -<span class='pageno' id='Page_161'>161</span>without becoming excited and continually yelping; when, even <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -if what is being said is little to his liking, he waits patiently -for the speaker to finish; when, at the close, he does not -immediately come to the attack with his contradiction, but -(to quote Aeschines) waits a while, in case the speaker might -wish to supplement his remarks, or perhaps to adjust or qualify -his position. To take instant objection, neither party listening -to the other but both talking at once, is an unseemly performance. -On the other hand, those who have been trained to -listen with modest self-control will accept a valuable argument -and make it their own, while they will be in a better position -to see through a worthless or false one and to expose it, thereby <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -showing that they are lovers of truth, and not merely contentious, -headstrong, or quarrelsome persons. It is therefore not -a bad remark of some, that there is more need to expel the wind -of vanity and self-conceit from the young, than to expel the air -from a skin, when you wish to pour in anything of value: otherwise -they are too swollen and flatulent to receive it.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The presence of envious and malicious jealousy is, of course, -never to good purpose, but always an impediment to proper -action. In the case of a student at lectures it is the most -perverse of prompters. Words which ought to do him good are -rendered vexing, distasteful, and unwelcome by the fact that -there is nothing which an envious man likes so little as an <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -excellent piece of reasoning. And note that, when a man is -piqued by fame or beauty belonging to others, he is envious -and nothing more; what annoys him is another’s good fortune. -But when he is irritated by admirable argument, his vexation -is at his own good, since reason—if he has a mind to accept it—is -as much to the good of one who hears as light is to the good -of one who sees.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Envy in other matters is the result of various coarse or low -attitudes of mind; envy of a speaker is born of inordinate love -<span class='pageno' id='Page_162'>162</span>of glory and unfair ambition. A person so disposed is prevented -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> from listening to reason. His mind is perturbed and distracted. -At one and the same time it is looking at its own endowments, -to see if they are inferior to those of the speaker, and at -the rest of the company, to see if they are wondering and -admiring. It is disgusted at their applause, and exasperated -at their approval. The previous portions of the speech it forgets -and ignores, because the recollection is irksome. The parts yet -to come it awaits with trembling anxiety, for fear they may -prove better still. When the speaker is at his best, it is most -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>40<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> eager for him to stop. When the lecture is over, it thinks of -nothing that was said, but takes count of the expressions and -attitudes of the audience. From those who give praise it dances -away in a frenzy; and to those who carp and distort it runs -to form one of the herd. If there is nothing to distort, it makes -comparisons with others who have spoken ‘better and more -eloquently to the same purpose’. In the end our friend has -so cruelly mishandled the lecture that he has made it of no use -or profit to himself.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Let the love of glory, then, be brought to terms with the love -of learning. Let us listen to a speaker with friendly courtesy, -regarding ourselves as guests at a sacred banquet or sacrificial -offering. Let us praise his ability when he makes a hit, or be -satisfied with the mere goodwill of a man who is making the -public a present of his views and endeavouring to convince -others by means of the arguments which have convinced himself. -When he goes right, let us consider that his rightness is -due not to chance or accident, but to painstaking effort and -learning. Let us take a pattern by it, and not only admire it, -but emulate it. When he is at fault, let us stop and think for -what reasons he is so, and at what point he began to go astray. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Xenophon observes that good managers derive profit from their -enemies as well as from their friends. In the same way those -<span class='pageno' id='Page_163'>163</span>who are attentive and alert derive benefit from a speaker not -only when he is in the right, but also when he is in the wrong. -Paltry thought, empty phrase, affected bearing, vulgar delight -and excitement at applause, and the like, are more palpable -to a listener in another’s case than to a speaker in his own. It is -well, therefore, to take the criticism which we apply to him, -and apply it to ourselves, asking whether we commit any mistake -of the kind without being aware of it. It is the easiest thing in <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the world to find fault with our neighbour, but it is a futile -and meaningless proceeding, unless made to bear in some way -upon the correction or prevention of similar faults. When -lapses are committed, let us always be prompt to exclaim to -ourselves in the phrase of Plato, ‘Am I, perhaps, as bad?’ -As in the eyes of our neighbour we see the reflection of our -own, so we should find a picture of our own speech in that of -another. In that way we shall avoid treating others with over-confident -contempt, and shall also look more carefully to our -own deliverances.</p> - -<p class='c005'>There is another way in which comparison serves this useful <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -purpose. I mean if, when we get by ourselves after the lecture, -we take some point which appears to have been wrongly or -unsatisfactorily treated, and attack the same theme, doing our -best to fill in, to correct, to re-word, or to attempt an entirely -original contribution to the subject, as the case may be—doing, -in fact, as Plato did<a id='r45' /><a href='#f45' class='c009'><sup>[45]</sup></a> with the speech of Lysias. While -to argue against a certain deliverance is not difficult, but, on -the contrary, very easy, to set up a better in its stead is an -extremely hard matter. As the Lacedaemonian said on hearing -that Philip had razed Olynthus to the ground: ‘Yes, but to -create a city as good is beyond the man’s power’. Accordingly, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -when we find that in dealing with the same subject we can do -but little better than the speaker in the case, we make a large -<span class='pageno' id='Page_164'>164</span>reduction in our contempt and speedily prune down that self-satisfied -conceit which has been exposed during such process of -comparison.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Nevertheless, though admiration, as opposed to contempt, -certainly betokens a fairer and gentler nature, it is a thing which, -in its own turn, requires no little—perhaps greater—caution. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>41<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> For while a contemptuous and over-confident person derives -too little benefit from a speaker, an enthusiastic and guileless -admirer derives too much injury. He forms no exception to -the rule of Heracleitus that ‘<i>Any dictum will flutter a fool</i>‘. -One should be frank in yielding praise to the speaker, but -cautious in yielding belief to the assertion; a kindly and candid -observer of the diction and delivery of the arguer, but a sharp -and exacting critic of the truth and value of his argument. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> While we thus escape dislike from the speaker, we escape harm -from the speech. How many false and pernicious doctrines we -unawares accept through esteeming and trusting their exponent! -The Lacedaemonian authorities, after examining a measure -suggested by a man of evil life, instructed another person, -famous for his conduct and character, to move it—a very proper -and statesmanlike encouragement to the people to be led more by -the character of an adviser than by his speech. But in philosophy -we must put aside the reputation of the speaker and examine -the speech in and by itself. In lecturing, as in war, there is -much that is mere show. The speaker’s grey hairs, his vocal -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> affectations, his supercilious airs, his self-glorification; above -all, the shouting, applauding, and dancing of the audience -overwhelm the young and inexperienced student and sweep -him along with the current. There is deception in the language -also, when it streams upon the question in a delightful flood, -and when it contains a measure of studied art and the grandiose. -As, in singing to the accompaniment of the flageolet, mistakes -are generally undetected by an audience, so an elaborate and -<span class='pageno' id='Page_165'>165</span>pretentious diction dazzles the hearer and blinds him to the -sense. I believe it was Melanthius who, when asked about <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Diogenes’ tragedy, replied: ‘I could not get a sight of it; -it was hidden behind the words.’ But with the discourses and -declamations of the majority of our professors it is not merely -a case of using the words to screen the thoughts. They also -dulcify the voice—modulating, smoothing, and intoning—till the -hearer is carried away with a perfect intoxication. They give -an empty pleasure, and are paid with an emptier fame. Their -case, in fact, is one for the quip given by Dionysius. It was he, -I think, who, during the performance of a distinguished harp-player, -promised him a liberal reward, but subsequently gave <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -him nothing, on the ground that he had made a sufficient -return. ‘For as long a time as I was enjoying your singing’, -said he, ‘you were enjoying your expectations.’ The deliverer -of the lectures in question finds that they represent a joint -contribution of the same kind. He receives admiration as long -as his entertainment lasts. As soon as no more pleasure is -forthcoming for the ear, there is no more glory left for him. -The one party has wasted his time, the other his professional life.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Let us, then, strip aside all this empty show of language, and -make for the actual fruit. It is better to imitate the bee than <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the garland-maker. The latter looks for the bright-coloured -fragrant petals, and, by twining and plaiting them together, -produces an object which is pleasant enough, but short-lived -and fruitless. Bees, on the contrary, frequently skim through -meadows of violets, roses, or hyacinths, to settle upon the -coarsest and bitterest thyme. To this they devote themselves</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Contriving yellow honey</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and then fly home to their proper business with something -worth the getting. So a student who takes his work in real -earnest will pay no regard to dainty flowery words nor to showy -<span class='pageno' id='Page_166'>166</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>42<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> theatrical matter. These he will consider as fodder for drones -who play the sophist. For his own part he will probe with keen -attention into the sense of a speech and the quality of the -speaker. Therefrom he will suck such part as will be of service -and profit. He will remember that he has not come to a theatre -or concert-hall, but to a classroom in the schools, and that his -object is to get his life corrected by means of reason. Hence -he should form a critical judgement of the lecture from his -own case, that is to say, from a calculation of its effect upon -himself. Has it been the chastening of a passion, the lightening -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> of a grief? Has it been courage, firmness of spirit, enthusiasm -for excellence and virtue? Upon rising from the barber’s chair -he will stand at the glass and put his hands to his head, inspecting -the trim and arrangement of the hair. No less should he, -immediately on leaving a lecture in the philosophic school, -look at himself and examine his own mind, to see if it has got -rid of any useless and uncomfortable growth and become lighter -and more at ease. ‘There is no use’, says Aristo, ‘in either -a bath or a speech, unless it cleanses.’</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> By all means let a young man, while profiting from a discourse, -find pleasure in the process. But he must not treat the -pleasure of the lecture as its end, nor expect to come out of the -philosopher’s school with a beaming face and humming a tune. -He must not ask for scented unguents when what he needs -is a lotion or a poultice. On the contrary, he should be grateful -if a pungent argument acts upon his mind like smoke upon a hive, -and clears out all the darkness and mistiness that fill it. Though -it is quite right for a speaker not to be altogether without -concern for an attractive and persuasive style of language, that -should be a matter least regarded by the young student, at any -rate in the first instance. Later, no doubt, the case may be -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> different. It is when they are no longer thirsty that persons -engaged in drinking will turn a cup about and inspect the chasing -<span class='pageno' id='Page_167'>167</span>upon it. Similarly during a breathing-time, after taking -our fill of the lesson, we may be permitted to examine any -uncommon elegance in the language. But if from the very first, -instead of taking a grip upon the substance, you insist upon -‘good pure Attic’ expression, you are like a person who refuses -to take an antidote unless the vessel is made of the best Attic -earthenware; or who declines to put on a thick cloak in winter -unless the wool is from Attic sheep, preferring to sit, stubborn -and impracticable, in the thin napless mantle of the ‘style of -Lysias’. Perversities of this kind are responsible for a plentiful <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -lack of good sense and an abundance of loquacious claptrap in -the schools. Young fellows keep no watch upon the life, the -practical action, or the public services of a philosopher, but -make a great merit of diction, phrase, and fine method of statement, -while they possess neither the ability nor the desire to -find out whether the statement is valuable or worthless, whether -it is vital or a mere futility.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The next rule concerns the propounding of difficulties. -A guest at a dinner is bound to accept what is put upon the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -table, and neither to ask for anything else nor to find fault. -When the feast consists of a discourse, any one who comes to -it should listen and say nothing, if there is an understanding -to that effect. Persons who cannot listen in a pleasant and -sociable manner, but keep drawing the speaker off to other -topics, interposing questions and mooting side-issues, get no -benefit themselves and confuse both the speaker and the speech. -When, however, he invites the audience to ask questions and -advance difficulties, any that are proposed should prove to be -useful and important. Odysseus, when in the suitors’ company, -incurs ridicule through</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Begging for morsels and scraps, and not for a sword or a cauldron.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>43<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> regard it as a sign of lofty-mindedness not only to give, but -<span class='pageno' id='Page_168'>168</span>to ask for, something of value. It is, however, more a case for -ridicule when a hearer poses a speaker with petty little problems -of the kind often propounded by young men, when they -are talking claptrap in order to make a show of attainments in -logic or mathematics—for example, concerning ‘division of the -indeterminate’ and the nature of ‘lateral’ or ‘diagonal’ -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> motion. The proper answer to such persons is the remark of -Philotimus to a man who was suffering with abscesses and -consumption, but who had been talking to him for some time -about requiring ‘some little thing to cure a whitlow’. Perceiving -the man’s condition from his complexion and breathing, -Philotimus observed: ‘My good sir, a whitlow is not the question -with you.’ Nor in your case, young sir, is it worth while -to be discussing such questions as yours, but how you are to -get rid of conceit, swaggering about love-affairs, and such-like -nonsense, and how you are to plant your feet on the way to -a healthy and sober-minded life.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Especially are you bound, in putting your questions, to accommodate -yourself to a speaker’s range of knowledge or natural -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> ability—to his special <i>forte</i>. A philosopher who is more concerned -with ethics should not be attacked with difficulties in -natural science or mathematics, nor should one who prides -himself upon his scientific knowledge be dragged into determining -hypothetical syllogisms or solving fallacies. If you -attempted to chop your wood with the key and to open your -door with the axe, it would not be thought that you were -making sport of these implements, but that you were depriving -yourself of their respective powers and uses. In the same way, -if you ask of a speaker a thing for which he has no gift or training, -while you make no harvest of what he possesses and offers, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> you not only do yourself harm to that extent, but you incur -condemnation for malicious ill-nature.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Be careful also not to propound difficulties yourself in too -<span class='pageno' id='Page_169'>169</span>great numbers or too frequently. This is, in a sense, another -way of showing off. Meanwhile, to listen equably when some one -else is mooting them, shows that you are a clubbable person -and a student. This is assuming you have no harassing and -urgent trouble of your own, no mental disturbance to be controlled -or malady to be comforted. It may not, after all, be -(as Heracleitus says) ‘better to conceal ignorance’, but to bring -it into the open and cure it. If your mind is upset by a fit of -anger, an attack of superstition, a violent quarrel with your -friends, or a mad amorous passion which</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Stirreth the heart-strings that should rest unstirred</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> you must not run away from a discourse which searches it home, -and fly to others of a different nature. On the contrary, these -are the very topics to which you should listen, both at lectures -and also by privately approaching the lecturer afterwards and -asking for further light.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The opposite course is the one too generally followed. So -long as the philosopher is dealing with other persons, his hearers -are all delight and admiration. But when he leaves those others -alone and frankly administers some important reminder to -themselves personally, they are disgusted with him for not -minding his own business. Generally speaking, they think <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -a philosopher is entitled to a hearing inside his school, as the -tragedian is in the theatre; but in matters beyond it they do -not consider him in any way superior to themselves. Towards -a sophist their attitude is natural enough; for when he rises -from his chair, lays aside his books and his introductory manuals, -and makes his appearance in the practical departments of life, -he ranks in the popular mind as an unimportant and inferior -person. But towards a philosopher in the real sense their -attitude is wrong. They do not recognize that a tone of earnestness -or jest, a sign of approval or disapproval, a smile or a frown, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_170'>170</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>44<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> on his part—and, above all, his direct handling of their individual -cases—are fruitful in good to those who have learned the art of -listening with submission.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Applause, again, has its duties, which call for a certain -caution and moderation. A gentleman bestows neither too -little nor too much of it. A hearer shows churlishly bad taste -when nothing whatever in a lecture will make him thaw or -unbend; when he is diseased with festering conceit and chronic -self-complacency, and is all the time thinking he could improve -upon the deliverance; when he neither makes any appropriate -movement of the brow nor utters any sound to prove that he is -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>B<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> a considerate and willing listener; when he is seeking a reputation -for solidity and depth by means of silence, an affected -gravity, and attitudes of pose, under the notion that applause -is like money, and that whatever amount you give to another -you take from yourself. The fact is that there are many who -take up the well-known saying of Pythagoras and sing it to a false -tune. His own gain from philosophy, he said, was to ‘<i>wonder at -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> nothing</i>‘; whereas theirs is to ‘praise nothing’ or to ‘honour -nothing’. With them wisdom lies in contempt, and the way to -be dignified is to be disdainful. While, by means of knowledge -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> and the ascertainment of the cause in a given case, philosophic -reason does away with the wonder and awe due to unenlightenment -and ignorance, it does not destroy a generous appreciation. -Those whose excellence is genuine and firmly seated find it the -highest honour to bestow honour, the highest distinction to -bestow distinction, where honour and distinction are due. -Such conduct implies that they have fame enough and to spare, -and are free from jealousy, whereas those who are niggards of -praise to others are in all probability pinched and hungry for -praise of their own.</p> - -<p class='c005'>On the other hand, the opposite type of hearer is the fluttering -feather-head who uses no discrimination, but punctuates with -<span class='pageno' id='Page_171'>171</span>loud cheers at every word and syllable. While he is frequently -obnoxious to the disputant himself, he is invariably a nuisance <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -to the hearers. He worries them on to their feet against their -judgement, and drags them willy-nilly to join in the chorus -because they are ashamed to refuse. Thanks to his applause -deranging the lecture and making an imbroglio of it, he gets no -good from it, but goes home with one of three descriptions -to his credit—fleerer, sycophant, or ignoramus.</p> - -<p class='c005'>It is true that, when hearing a case in court, we must lean <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -neither towards hostility nor towards favour, but towards -justice as we best understand it. But at a lecture on a subject -of learning there is neither law nor oath to debar us from -granting the speaker an indulgent reception. The reason why -the ancients placed the statue of Hermes in the company of the -Graces was that speaking has a special claim to a gracious -friendliness. It is impossible for any one to be so complete -a failure or so utterly astray as to offer us nothing deserving of -a cheer, in the shape of a thought, a reference to others, the mere -choice of theme or purpose, or, possibly, in the wording or -arrangement of the matter,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>As among urchin-foot or mid coarse broom</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>The tender snowflake springeth into bloom.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> There are persons who, for exhibition purposes, can lend a fair -measure of plausibility to a panegyric upon vomiting or fever, -or even a pot; and surely a deliverance by a man who has some -sort of claim to be thought, or to call himself, a philosopher -cannot absolutely fail to afford a well-disposed or courteous -audience some opportunity of finding relief in applause.</p> - -<p class='c005'>According to Plato young persons in the bloom of life can -always manage somehow to excite a lover’s passion. If they -are white he calls them ‘saint-like’; if swarthy, ‘virile’. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>45<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -A hook-nose is ‘regal’, a snub nose ‘piquant’; a sallow skin -<span class='pageno' id='Page_172'>172</span>is a ‘complexion of honey’. He uses these pretty names, and -is pleased and satisfied. Love has, indeed, an ivy-like gift for -clinging to any pretext. Much less will an eager and earnest -student of letters ever fail in inventiveness. In every speaker -he will discover some grounds for reasonable applause. In the -speech of Lysias, though Plato objects to its want of arrangement, -and though he has no praise for its inventiveness, he nevertheless -commends him for his manner of statement, and because -there is ‘a clear round finish in the chiselling of every word’. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> We might find fault with Archilochus for his subject-matter, -Parmenides for his versification, Phocylides for his commonplaceness, -Euripides for his garrulity, Sophocles for his inequality. -Similarly one of the orators has no characterization, another -exerts no passion, a third is lacking in grace and charm. Nevertheless -each wins praise for a power to move and sway us in his -own peculiar way.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The hearer, then, has ample scope for showing good feeling -to a speaker. In some instances it is sufficient if, without further -declaration by word of mouth, we contribute a kindly eye, -a genial expression, a friendly and agreeable mood. There are -certain things for which even the man who is a total failure may -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> look, and which are but ordinary items of common etiquette -for any and every audience. I mean an upright posture in -our chairs, with no lolling or lounging; eyes kept directly upon -the speaker; an air of businesslike attention; composure of -countenance, with no sign, I need not say of insolence or -peevishness, but of being taken up with other thoughts.</p> - -<p class='c005'>If in every exacting task beauty is made up of a number of -factors happily combined in a due proportion and harmony, -ugliness is the prompt and immediate outcome of the faulty -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> omission or addition of this or that one element. And in this -particular matter of listening, not only is there impropriety -in a scowling brow, a disagreeable expression, a roving glance, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_173'>173</span>a twisting of the body, and a crossing of the legs; but nodding -or whispering to a neighbour, smiling, yawning sleepily, looking -at the ground, and actions of a similar nature, are censurable -and should be studiously avoided.</p> - -<p class='c005'>There are some who think that, though the speaker has a duty, -the hearer has none. They expect the former to present -himself with his thoughts studiously prepared; yet, without -a thought or care for their own obligations, they drop casually -in and take their seats, for all the world as if they had come -to a dinner to enjoy themselves while others are doing the work. -Yet even a polite table-companion has his part to play, much <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -more a polite hearer. He is a partner in the speech and a coadjutor -of the speaker; and he has no right to be sharply criticizing the -mistakes, and taking every phrase and fact to task, while himself -free from responsibility for the impropriety and the frequent -solecisms which he commits as a hearer. In ball-play the catcher -has to regulate his movements according to those of the thrower. -So, in the case of a speech, there is a certain consonance of action -in which both speaker and listener are concerned, if each is to -sustain his proper part. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<p class='c005'>Our expressions in applauding must not, however, be used -without discrimination. It is an unpleasing phrase of Epicurus -when, in speaking of the little epistles from his friends, he says, -‘We give them a rattling clapping.’ But what of those who -nowadays introduce such <i>outré</i> expressions into our lecture-rooms? -The <i>Capital!</i> <i>Well said!</i> and <i>Very true!</i> which were -the terms of commendation used by the hearers of Plato, -Socrates, and Hypereides, are not enough for these persons. -With their exclamations <i>Divine!</i> <i>An inspiration!</i> or <i>Unapproachable!</i> -they commit a gross impropriety, libellously -making out that the speaker requires far-fetched eulogies of an <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>46<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -outrageous kind. Highly obnoxious also are those who accompany -their attestations with an oath, as if they were in a court -<span class='pageno' id='Page_174'>174</span>of law. And equally so those who blunder in their descriptive -terms; for instance, when the lecturer is a philosopher and they -call out, <i>A shrewd hit!</i>, or an old man and they exclaim <i>Cleverly -put!</i> or <i>Brilliant!</i>, thus misapplying to a philosopher the -expressions used at academic exercises, where the speaking is -not serious but merely an exhibition of adroitness. To offer -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> to a sober discourse such meretricious praise is like crowning an -athlete with a wreath of lilies or roses instead of laurel or wild -olive. Once when the poet Euripides was going over a song -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> with an original setting for the benefit of the members of his -chorus, and one of them happened to laugh, he observed: -‘If you had not been an ignorant dolt, you could not have -laughed while I was teaching you a mixolydian<a id='r46' /><a href='#f46' class='c009'><sup>[46]</sup></a> piece.’ So, -I take it, a serious and practical philosopher might very well -make short work of the airs and affectations of a hearer by saying, -‘I presume your case is one of foolishness or ill breeding; -otherwise you would not have been piping out and jigging -about at my remarks, when I was teaching, or admonishing, or -arguing concerning religion, statesmanship, or the duties of -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> office.’ Just frankly consider what it means, when a philosopher -is speaking, and the shouting and hurrahing inside the building -make people outside wonder whether it is a flute-player, a -harpist, or a dancer who is being applauded.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Meanwhile, in listening to admonition and reproof, the pupil -must be neither insensible nor unmanly. There are some who -bear the philosopher’s reproaches with an easy-going indifference, -laughing under the correction and applauding the corrector, -just as parasites applaud in sheer impudence and recklessness -when they are abused by those who keep them. The shamelessness -which such persons display is no proper or genuine proof -of courage. When a jibe containing no insult, and uttered in -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> a playful and tactful way, is borne cheerfully and without -<span class='pageno' id='Page_175'>175</span>annoyance, it shows neither a want of spirit nor a want of -breeding. On the contrary, it is exactly what a gentleman -of the true Spartan style would do. But it is different when -admonition takes in hand the correction of character by means -of a stinging remedy in the shape of rational reproof. If a young -man does not cower under the lesson and feel his soul burning -with shame, till he breaks into a sweat and is ready to faint; -if, on the contrary, he is unperturbed, gives a broad grin of -self-depreciation, and refuses to take the matter seriously, then -he is an extremely vulgar creature beyond all sense of shame, -a constant habituation to misconduct having made his soul no -more capable of a bruise than a thick callus in the flesh.</p> - -<p class='c005'>These form the one class. Youths of the opposite disposition, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -if a single hard word is said to them, turn deserters from philosophy -and run away without a glance behind them. While -nature has given them, in the shape of modesty, an excellent -start towards moral salvation, they are so squeamish and timid -that they throw their chance away. Unable to put up with -reproof or to accept correction with spirit, they turn away to -listen to the soft and agreeable utterances of some time-server -or sophist, who charms them with melodious phrases as useless -and futile as they are pleasing. If a man runs away from the -surgeon after the operation and objects to be bandaged, he is -submitting to the pain of the treatment but refusing to put up -with its benefit. So when a lesson has lanced and probed his <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -folly, if he will not permit it to close and dress the wound, he -is abandoning philosophy after feeling the sting and the pain -but before deriving any advantage therefrom.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Euripides says that the wound of Telephus was</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Soothed by the filings ground from the same spear.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>It is no less true that the sting implanted by philosophy in <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>47<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -a youth of parts is cured by the same reasoning that caused the -<span class='pageno' id='Page_176'>176</span>wound. While, therefore, it is right that the subject of reproof -should feel some pain from the sting, he must not be crushed -or dispirited, but, after undergoing the first discomposing rites -of purification, he should look for some sweet and splendid -revelation to follow the distress and confusion of the moment. -For though the reproof may appear to be unjust, the proper -course is to endure it with all patience until the speaker concludes. -Then he may be met by a plea in self-defence, and by -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> a request to reserve for some real fault all the vigorous candour -which he has shown in the present instance.</p> - -<p class='c005'>To proceed to the next consideration. In reading and writing, -playing the lyre, or wrestling, the first lessons are very harassing, -laborious, and unsure; but, as we advance step by step, it is -much as in dealing with mankind. By dint of frequent and -familiar acquaintance we find that it all becomes pleasant and -manageable, and every word or action easy. It is the same with -philosophy. No doubt the language and matter, as first met -with, contain something both hard and strange. But we must -not take fright at the rudiments and prove so timid and spiritless -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> as to abandon the study. On the contrary, our duty is to grapple -with every question, to persevere, to be resolved on making -progress, and then to wait for that familiarity which converts -all right action into a pleasure. It will not be long before it -arrives, casting upon the study a flood of light, and inspiring -an ardent passion for excellence. To be without such passion -and to put up with the ordinary type of life because one is -driven from philosophy by a lack of mettle, is to be a miserable -or cowardly creature.</p> - -<p class='c005'>We may also expect that at first the argumentation will prove -somewhat difficult for young and inexperienced students to -understand. For the most part, however, the obscurity and want -of comprehension are due to themselves. Opposite dispositions -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> lead to the same mistake. Thus one class, through bashfulness -<span class='pageno' id='Page_177'>177</span>and a desire to spare the teacher, will shrink from putting -questions and making sure of the argument, and will ostensibly -assent as if they quite understood. The others, led by misplaced -ambition and meaningless rivalry to make a show of cleverness -and quickness, pretend to have mastered a thing before they take -it in, and so will not take it in at all. The consequence is that -when the former—the modest and silent kind—go home, they -will worry themselves with their perplexities, and in the end -they will be driven perforce to trouble the speaker by harking -back with their questions at a later date, when they will feel -still more ashamed. Meanwhile the bold and ambitious kind -will be perpetually cloaking their ignorance and hiding the fact -that it haunts them.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Let us then thrust aside all this pretentious silliness, and march <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -on towards learning. Let our business be to get an intelligent -grasp upon valuable instruction. And let us put up with the -laughter of those who are thought to be clever. Remember -how Cleanthes and Xenocrates, though to all appearance slower -than their fellow-pupils, refused to give up or run away from -their studies. On the contrary, they were the first to joke at -their own expense, comparing themselves to a narrow-necked -bottle or a brass tablet, inasmuch as, though slow at taking their -instruction in, they were safe and sure at retaining it. Not only -must we, as Phocylides puts it,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Oft-times be baulked of our hope while seeking to come unto goodness</i>;</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>we must also ‘oft-times’ be laughed at, and bear with scoffing <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -and jeering, meanwhile putting all our heart and energy into -winning the struggle against our ignorance.</p> - -<p class='c005'>We must, however, be quite as careful not to err in the opposite -direction. Some do so from sloth, which makes them a -wearisome infliction. Unwilling to trouble themselves when <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>48<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -<span class='pageno' id='Page_178'>178</span>alone, they keep troubling the teacher by repeatedly asking for -information on the same questions. Like unfledged birds in -the nest, they are perpetually agape to be fed from another’s -mouth, and expect to receive everything ready masticated by -someone else.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Another kind, in the misplaced quest of a reputation for -alertness and acumen, worry the lecturer with their fussy -garrulity, perpetually mooting some unimportant difficulty or -demanding some unnecessary demonstration,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Till a short journey so becometh long</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> —as Sophocles says—not only to themselves but to every one -else. By continually arresting the teacher with superfluous -and futile questions, as if they were merely chatting with a companion, -they interfere with the continuity of the lesson by a -series of checks and delays. Persons of this class are (to quote -Hieronymus) like wretched cowardly puppies, who bite the skins -and tear the odds and ends of wild animals at home, but who -never touch the animals themselves.</p> - -<p class='c005'>As for the former and lazy class, let us give them this advice. -When they have managed to comprehend the main points, -let them piece the rest together for themselves, using their -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> memory as a guide to independent thought. And let them -take the reasoning they hear from another as a beginning—a -seed which they are to make grow and thrive.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The mind is not a vessel which calls for filling. It is a pile, -which simply requires kindling-wood to start the flame of -eagerness for original thought and ardour for truth. Suppose -someone goes to borrow from his neighbour’s fire, and then, -on finding a large bright blaze, persists in staying and basking -on the spot. It is the same when a man comes to another to -borrow reason, and does not realize that he must kindle a light -of his own in the shape of thinking for himself, but sits enchanted -<span class='pageno' id='Page_179'>179</span>with enjoyment of the lecture. He derives from the lesson <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -a ruddy glow or outward brilliance, but he fails to drive out -the mould and darkness from within by the warming power of -philosophy.</p> - -<p class='c005'>If therefore any advice is needed for the hearing of lectures, -it is to remember the rule just given—to practise independent -thought along with learning. We shall thus attain, not to the -ability of a sophist or the ‘well-informed’ man, but to a deep-seated -philosophic power. Right listening will be for us the -introduction to right living.</p> - -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_180'>180</span> - <h2 id='chap07' class='c003'>ON MORAL IGNORANCE IN HIGH PLACES</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>779 <span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> When Plato was invited by the Cyrenaeans to draw up a code -of laws for their use and to organize their constitution, he begged -to be excused, on the ground that it was difficult to legislate -for so prosperous a people:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>For nought so arrogant</i>—</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>nor so impracticable and headstrong—</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in20'><i>as human kind</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>when prosperity—or what is so considered—lies within its -grasp.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>E<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> No less difficult is the task of advising a ruler how to rule. -To admit reason, he fears, is to admit a ruler, whose law of duty -will make a slave of him and curtail the advantage he derives -from power. He has yet to learn a lesson from Theopompus, -the Spartan king, who was the first to modify the powers of the -throne by means of that of the Ephors. When his wife reproached -him for proposing to leave to his children less authority -than he had inherited, he replied: ‘Nay, greater, because more -assured.’ By relaxing its excessive absolutism he escaped the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> consequent ill-feeling, and therewith its dangers. But note. -Theopompus, in diverting into other channels a portion of the -full stream of power, deprived himself of just so much as he -gave away. But when philosophic reason becomes the established -colleague and protector of a ruler, it merely removes the perilous -element and leaves the healthy—a process as necessary to power -as to sound health.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_181'>181</span>In most cases, however, monarchs or rulers show as little -wisdom as a tasteless sculptor, who fancies that to represent -a figure with a huge stride, strained muscles, and gaping mouth, -is to make it appear massive and imposing. They imagine that <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>780<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -an arrogant tone, harsh looks, short temper, and exclusiveness -give them the true regal air of awe and majesty. In reality -they are not a bit better than a colossal statue with the outward -shape and form of a god or demigod, while the inside is a mass -of earth, stone, or lead. Indeed, in the case of the statue, these -heavy materials serve to keep it erect and prevent it from -warping; whereas, with an unschooled governor or chief, the -unreason within is often the cause of instability and collapse. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -His foundation being out of plumb, the lofty power which -he builds upon it is correspondingly unstable. Now it is only -when the builder’s square is itself faultless in line and angle, -that it can make other things true to line by adjustment to, -and comparison with, itself. So a ruler must begin by acquiring -rule within himself. Let him set his own soul straight, and make -his own character firm, and then begin adjusting his subjects -thereto. You cannot set upright, when you are falling; teach, -when you are ignorant; discipline, when unruly; command, -when disobedient; govern, when ungoverned. And yet it is -a common error to suppose that the chief blessing of authority <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -is to be above authority. To the King of Persia every one was -a slave except his own wife, the very person whose master he -ought to have been.</p> - -<p class='c005'>By whom, then, is the ruler to be ruled? By the</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in26'><i>Law,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Sovereign of mortals and immortals all</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>as Pindar says; not a law written outwardly in books or on -wooden tables, but a living law of reason in himself, abiding -with him, watching him, and never leaving his soul destitute -<span class='pageno' id='Page_182'>182</span>of guidance. The King of Persia kept one chamberlain whose -special function was to enter in the morning and say to him: -‘Rise, Sire, and attend to matters which Great Oromazdes -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> meant for your concern.’ The ruler who has learned wisdom -and self-control hears the same voice of exhortation from within. -It was a saying of Polemo that love is ‘<i>serving the Gods in the -care and protection of the young</i>‘. With more truth it might -be said that a ruler serves God in the care and protection of -men, by dispensing, or safeguarding, the blessings which God -gives to mankind.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>See’st thou yon boundless sky and air aloft,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>How in soft arms it clasps the world about?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>From it descend the first principles of seeds in due kind; earth -brings them forth; their growth is fostered by rains or winds -or the warmth of moon and stars; while the sun brings everything -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> to beauty and tinctures all creation with that peculiar -love-spell which is his. But though the Gods may lavish these -great boons and blessings, who can enjoy or use them rightly, -if there be no law, justice, or ruler? Justice is the end of law; -law is the work of the ruler; and a ruler is an image of the God -who orders all things. He needs no Pheidias or Polycleitus or -Myro to fashion him, but brings himself into likeness with deity -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> by means of virtue, and so creates the fairest and most divine -of effigies. In the heavens the sun and moon were set by God -as His own beauteous image; and, in a state, the same shining -embodiment is to be found in the ruler</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Godfearing, who justice upholdeth</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>—that is to say, when he holds, not a sceptre, but a mind which -is the reason of God; not when he holds the thunderbolt or -trident with which some represent themselves in statue or -picture, rendering their folly odious to Heaven by such impossible -assertion. For God visits with righteous wrath him who -<span class='pageno' id='Page_183'>183</span>makes pretence of thunder or thunderbolt or darting sun-ray; -but when a man studies to emulate His goodness, and to take <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>781<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -a pattern by His virtue and benevolence, He delights in furthering -him and bestowing a portion of His own righteousness, -justice, truth, and mercy. Not fire or light, not the course of -the sun, the risings and settings of the stars, everlastingness -and immortality, are more divine that these attributes. For it -is not by reason of length of life that God is happy, but by -reason of the virtue which rules. This is ‘divine’. ‘Noble’, -however, is the virtue whose part it is only to obey.</p> - -<p class='c005'>When Alexander was in sore distress at killing Cleitus, Anaxarchus -told him, by way of comfort, that Right and Justice were <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -but the ‘assessors’ of Zeus—making out that any act was right -and lawful for a king. A false and pernicious salve for his repentance -at his sin, this encouragement to repeat it! If we are to -use such figures of speech, Right is no ‘assessor’ of Zeus, but -He himself is Right and Justice, the oldest and most consummate -Law. What the ancients tell and write and teach is that, -without Justice, not even Zeus can properly rule. According -to Hesiod</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>A virgin is she</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>the incorruptible partner of feeling, self-control, and beneficence. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Hence are kings called ‘merciful’, for mercy best becomes those -who are least afraid. A ruler’s fear should be of doing harm -rather than of suffering it; for the former action is the cause -of the latter, and this kind of fear on the part of a ruler is creditable -to humanity. There is nothing ignoble in a fear for his -subjects and of possible injury to them. Such rulers are like</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Dogs that keep ward o’er the sheep in the farmstead, anxiously watching</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>At sound of a fierce wild beast</i>—</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>their anxiety being not for themselves, but for their charges.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_184'>184</span>Once when the Thebans had recklessly abandoned themselves -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> to feasting and carousal, Epaminondas went the round of the -walls and the military posts all by himself, remarking that he -was keeping sober and wakeful so that the rest might be drunk -and asleep. When Cato, after the defeat at Utica, gave orders -that every one else should be sent to sea, saw them on board, -prayed that they might have a prosperous voyage, and then -went back home and stabbed himself, it was a lesson on the text, -‘For whose sake should a ruler feel fear, and for what should -he feel contempt?’ On the other hand, Clearchus, despot of -Pontus, used at bedtime to crawl like a snake into a chest. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Similarly, Aristodemus of Argos crept into an upper room entered -by a trap-door. Over this he would put the couch upon which -he passed the night with his mistress. Meanwhile her mother -dragged away the ladder from below, bringing it back and -putting it in place in the morning. How, think you, must he -have shuddered at the theatre, at the Government offices, at -the Senate-House, at the banquet, when he turned his own -bedchamber into a prison? Yes, kings are afraid <i>for</i> their subjects, -despots are afraid <i>of</i> them. It follows that, as they add -to their power, they add to their alarms; the more people -they rule, the more people they fear.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> It is an improbable and unworthy view to hold of God—as -some philosophers do—that He exists as an element in matter -to which all sorts of things may happen, and in entities which are -subject to innumerable accidents, chances and changes. In -reality He is stablished somewhere aloft ‘<i>on holy pedestal</i>’ (as -Plato puts it) in the realm of nature uniform and constant, and -there ‘<i>moves according to Nature in a straight line towards the -accomplishment of His end</i>‘. And as in heaven the sun, His -beauteous counterfeit, shows itself as His reflection in a mirror -to those who have the power to see Him through it, so, in the -justice and reason which shine in a state, He sets up a likeness -<span class='pageno' id='Page_185'>185</span>of that which is in Himself, and, by copying that likeness, men <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>782<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -whom philosophy has gifted and chastened model themselves -after the highest pattern.</p> - -<p class='c005'>This condition of mind nothing can implant except reason -acquired from philosophy. Otherwise we are in the position -of Alexander, when he went to see Diogenes at Corinth. In -delight at his talent, and in admiration of his proud and lofty -spirit, he exclaimed: ‘If I had not been Alexander, I would -have been Diogenes.’ And what did this virtually mean? -That he was vexed at his own high fortune, splendour, and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -power, because they were an obstacle to the virtue for which -he could find no time, and that he envied the cloak and the wallet, -which made Diogenes as invincible and unassailable as he himself -was made by armour and horses and spears. And yet by the -practice of philosophy he might have secured the moral character -of a Diogenes while retaining the position of an Alexander. -Nay, he should have become all the more a Diogenes for being -an Alexander, since his high fortune, so liable to be tossed by -stormy winds, required ample ballast and a master hand at the -helm.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the case of private men without strength or standing, folly -is so qualified by impotence that in the end no mischief is done. -It is as with a bad dream, in which, though the mind is excited -with passion, no harm results, inasmuch as it is unable to rise -and act in accordance with the desires. When, on the other <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -hand, vice is adopted by power, the passions acquire sinew and -strength. Dionysius spoke truly when he said that the highest -advantage of power was to give speedy effect to a wish. A most -parlous thing, if you can give effect to a wish, and yet wish what -is wrong!</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>No sooner the word had been utter’d, than straightway the deed was accomplish’d.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Vice, when enabled by power to run rapid course, forces every -<span class='pageno' id='Page_186'>186</span>passion into action, converting anger into murder, love into -adultery, greed into confiscation.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>No sooner the word hath been utter’d</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>than your opponent has met his doom. No sooner a suspicion, -than the victim of slander is a dead man.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Scientists tell us that, whereas lightning really follows and -issues from thunder like blood from a wound, it is perceived first -because, while the hearing waits for the sound, the vision goes -out to meet the light. So with rulers. The punishment outstrips -the charge; the condemnation does not wait for the proof.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>For forthwith anger slips and loses hold,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Like anchor’s tooth in sand when seas swell high</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>unless reason with all its weight puts a heavy drag on power; -unless, that is, the ruler acts like the sun, whose motion is least -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> when its height is greatest, namely, at the time of its northern -altitude, its course being steadied by the diminished speed.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Vice in high places cannot be hid. When an epileptic is -placed upon a height and made to turn round, he is seized with -giddiness and begins to totter, his malady being betrayed thereby. -So with an unschooled and ignorant person. After a brief -uplifting by wealth or fame or place, the same fortune which -raised him up immediately reveals how ready he is to fall. To -put it another way; when a vessel is empty, you cannot detect -the crack or flaw, but when you begin to fill it, the leak appears. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> So with a mind which is too unsound to hold power and -authority; its leaks are to be seen in its exhibitions of lust, -anger, pretentiousness, and ignorance. Yet why speak of this, -when holes are picked in eminent and distinguished men for -the merest peccadilloes? Cimon was reproached for his addiction -to wine, Scipio for his addiction to sleep, and Lucullus for his -extravagance at table<a id='r47' /><a href='#f47' class='c009'><sup>[47]</sup></a>....</p> - -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_187'>187</span> - <h2 id='chap08' class='c003'>FAWNER AND FRIEND <br /> (WITH AN EXCURSUS ON CANDOUR)</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'><span class='sc'>My dear Antiochus Philopappus</span>, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>48 <span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<p class='c005'>‘Every one,’ says Plato, ‘will pardon a man for admitting -that he has a strong affection for himself,’ but—not to mention <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -numerous other defects to which he is subject—there is one -chief weakness which precludes him from giving a just and -incorruptible verdict in his own case. ‘The lover is blind where -the beloved object is concerned,’ unless he has learned the habit -of prizing things, not because they are his own or related to -himself, but because they are beautiful. Hence, there is ample -opportunity for the flatterer to obtain a place among our friends. -He delivers his attack from an excellent point of vantage in -the shape of that self-love which makes every man his own <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>49<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -first and greatest flatterer, ready and willing to welcome such -external testimony as will endorse his own conceits and desires. -For the man who is reprobated as a lover of toadies is an ardent -lover of himself. Out of fondness for himself he not only entertains -the wish to possess, but also the conceit that he possesses, -all manner of qualities; and though the desire may be natural -enough, the conceit is fallacious and calls for the greatest -watchfulness.</p> - -<p class='c005'>And if truth is divine, and—as Plato asserts—the first principle <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -of ‘all good things both with Gods and men’, the toady must -be an enemy of the Gods, and especially of the Pythian. For, in -perpetual antagonism to the doctrine of <i>Know Thyself</i>, he produces -self-deception in a man, self-ignorance, and error as to his -<span class='pageno' id='Page_188'>188</span>virtues and vices. The virtues he renders defective and abortive; -the vices he renders incorrigible.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Now if the flatterer had been like most other mischievous -things, and had solely or chiefly attacked mean and petty -victims, the harm would have been neither so great nor so -difficult to prevent. But it is into soft and sweet kinds of wood -that worms prefer to bore, and it is estimable and capable -characters—characters with a love of approbation—that give -access and supply nourishment to the flatterer who fastens upon -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> them. ‘<i>The breeding of the steed</i>,’ says Simonides, ‘<i>sorts not with -Zacynthus,<a id='r48' /><a href='#f48' class='c009'><sup>[48]</sup></a> but with wheat-bearing plains</i>.’ Similarly we do not -find toadyism in attendance upon the poor, the insignificant, -or the uninfluential, but sapping and debilitating great houses -and great fortunes, and frequently subverting rulers and thrones. -Consequently no slight effort or common precaution is required -in considering how it can be most readily detected and so prevented -from doing injury and discredit to friendship.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Vermin quit a dying man and desert the body when the blood -which feeds them becomes exhausted. So with the time-server. -You will never find him approaching a person whose fortune is -destitute of sap and warmth. It is the famous and influential -whom he attacks; it is out of them that he makes capital; and -when their circumstances change he promptly beats a retreat. -We should not, however, wait for that test; it is then not -merely useless but fraught with injury and danger. It is a grievous -thing to find out who is not your friend only at the moment -when a friend is needed, since the discovery does not enable you -to exchange the uncertain and counterfeit for the genuine and -certain. You should possess friends as you possess coin—tested -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> before the occasion, not waiting to be proved by the occasion. -Discovery should not come through injury, but injury should -be prevented by our acquiring a scientific insight into the -<span class='pageno' id='Page_189'>189</span>nature of the toady. Otherwise we shall be in the position of -those who distinguish a deadly poison by tasting it; we shall -meet our death in the effort of judging.</p> - -<p class='c005'>One can neither approve of such a course, nor yet of those who, -because they regard a ‘friend’ as implying a high and wholesome -influence, imagine that an agreeable associate is immediately -and manifestly proved to be a time-server. For there is nothing -disagreeable or uncompromisingly severe about a friend, nor -does the high respect we pay to friendship depend upon harshness -or austerity. Nay, its high influence and claim to respect are -actually an agreeable and desirable thing in themselves, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>And close at its side do the Graces and Longing Desire set their dwellings.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Not only may the unfortunate man say, with Euripides,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>’Tis sweet to look into a friend’s fond eyes</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>but friendship is a comrade who adds as much pleasure and -gratification to our blessings as it brings relief to the pains and -perplexities of our mishaps. According to Euenus ‘<i>the best of <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>50<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -seasonings is fire</i>‘. So, by making friendship an ingredient of -life, God has rendered all things bright and sweet and enjoyable -through its presence and participation. How, indeed, could -the fawner have wormed himself into our pleasures, if he had -seen that friendship refuses all admittance to what is pleasant? -The thing is absurd. No; the toady is like the mock-gilt and -tinsel which merely mimic the sheen and lustre of gold. It is -in order to imitate the attractiveness and charm of a friend -that he makes a constant show of agreeableness and amiability, -and never opposes or contradicts you. It is therefore wrong, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -when a person praises you, to suspect at once that he is simply -a flatterer. Friendship is quite as much called upon to praise -in season as it is to blame. In fact, perpetual peevishness and -fault-finding is the negation of friendship and sociability; -<span class='pageno' id='Page_190'>190</span>whereas, when affection bestows zealous and ungrudging praise -upon our good deeds, we also submit readily and cheerfully -to its candid remonstrances, being satisfied with the belief that -the man who is glad to praise will only blame because he must.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> ‘It is a hard matter then,’ we may be told, ‘to distinguish -between flatterer and friend, if they are equally pleasant and -equally laudatory, especially when we find that toadyism is -often more than a match for friendship in the tendering of -services.’ Naturally so, we reply, if the object of our search -is the genuine toady, with a past-master’s skill at the business; -if, that is, we do not adopt the common view and mean by -‘toady’ your poverty-stricken trencherman, who ‘begins’—as -some one has said—‘to declare himself with the first course,’ and -whose lickspittle character betrays itself by gross and vulgar -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> buffoonery at the first dish and the first glass. It needed no test -to expose Melanthius, the parasite of Pherae. It was enough -that, when asked ‘how Alexander was stabbed,’ he replied, -‘Through the ribs, into my belly.’ Nor is there any such need -with those who besiege ‘an opulent table’, and whom</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Not fire, nor steel, nor bronze can keep</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>from making their way to a dinner. Nor yet with those female -toadies of Cyprus, who, after their transference to Syria, were -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> called ‘pair o’ steps’ from the fact that they used to allow the -king’s wife to mount her carriage over their bent backs.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Against whom, then, are we to be on our guard? Against -the man who is not confessedly or apparently a toady; one who -is not to be found hanging about the kitchen, nor to be caught -watching the dial with a dinner in prospect; one who is not -to be made tipsy and then pitched into any corner; but one -who for the most part keeps sober and bustling, thinking it -his business to take part in all your doings, and to be privy to -your confidential talk—the man, in short, who acts the rôle of -<span class='pageno' id='Page_191'>191</span>friend, not in the satyric<a id='r49' /><a href='#f49' class='c009'><sup>[49]</sup></a> or comic style, but in the high -tragic. According to Plato, ‘the extreme of dishonesty is to -appear honest when you are not.’ So with time-serving. It is <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -to be regarded as dangerous, not when confessed, but when -undetected; when it wears a serious, not an amusing, air. -In this form, unless we are careful, it casts a slur of discredit -even upon genuine friendship, the points of coincidence being -numerous. When the Mage was trying to escape and Gobryes -had plunged with him into a dark room and was grappling -with him, Darius stood at a loss what to do. ‘Stab,’ said -Gobryes, ‘though you stab both.’ With us it is not so easy, -inasmuch as we can by no means give any sanction to the maxim: -‘<i>Perish friend, if so perish foe.</i>’ There are so many points of -similarity to complicate the fawner with the friend that we must -find it a most parlous business to tear the one from the other. -We may either be casting out the good thing along with the bad, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>51<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -or, in trying to spare the right thing, we may let the wrong one -bring us to grief. There are wild plants of which the seeds -are similar in shape and size to those of wheat. When the two -are mixed it is difficult to sift these out; they will not fall -through smaller holes, and, if the holes are wider, one falls -through as much as the other. No less difficult is it to separate -time-serving from friendship, when it blends itself with every -feeling, every movement, need, and habit.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Friendship being the most pleasant and delightful thing in -the world, it follows that the toady also uses pleasure for his <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -bait. To give pleasure is his main concern. And since agreeableness -and usefulness are concomitants of friendship—whence -the saying that ‘<i>a friend is more indispensable than fire and water</i>‘—it -follows that the toady insists on rendering services, and is -all eagerness to show unfaltering promptitude and zeal. But -the surest foundation of friendship is similarity of pursuits and -<span class='pageno' id='Page_192'>192</span>character. The foremost agent in mutual attraction is similarity -of temperament—the liking and disliking of the same things. -This the time-server perceives, and therefore he adapts himself -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> like wax to the proper shape and form, endeavouring by imitation -to mould himself so as exactly to fit his victim. His supple -versatility, his genius for mimicry, is so great that it is a case of</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in24'><i>Thou art</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Achilles’ self, and not Achilles’ son.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>And note his craftiest device. He observes that candour is -called (what it appears to be) ‘the characteristic note of friendship’, -while lack of candour is the negation of friendship and -spirit. He does not fail, therefore, to imitate this quality also. -As a skilful <i>chef</i> will use some bitter or piquant juice for a sauce -in order to prevent sweets from cloying, so with the candour -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> of the toady. It is not genuine, nor is it useful; it is given, -as it were, with a wink, and serves simply as an excitant. The -result is that he is as hard to detect as one of those creatures which -possess the natural power of altering their colour so as to match -the spot on which they happen to lie. Since, therefore, it is under -cover of resemblances that he deceives us, our proper course is to -find in the non-resemblances a means of stripping off his disguise -and showing that—as Plato puts it—he is ‘beautifying himself -with borrowed forms and colours through lack of any of his own’.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Let us begin at the very beginning. In most instances, we -remarked, friendship commences with similarity of temperament -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> and disposition, a taste for very much the same habits and -principles, and a delight in the same pursuits, occupations, and -pastimes. Such a similarity is implied in the lines:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Most welcome to the old is old men’s speech;</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Child pleaseth child, and woman pleaseth woman,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Sick men the sick, and one who meets disaste</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Brings solace to another suffering it.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_193'>193</span>The toady knows that it is natural to find pleasure in one’s like -and to be fond of his society. This, therefore, is his first device <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for approaching you and getting neighbours with you. He acts -like herdsmen on a pasture. He works gently up to you and rubs -shoulders with you in the same pursuits, amusements, tastes, -and way of life, until you give him his chance and let yourself -grow tame and accustomed to his touch. He condemns such -circumstances, such conduct, and such persons as he notices -you dislike; while of those that please you he cannot say too -much in praise, exhibiting boundless delight and admiration <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>52<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for them. He thus confirms you in your loves and hatreds, as -being the results, not of feelings, but of judgement.</p> - -<p class='c005'>How, then, is he to be exposed? By what points of difference -are we to prove that he is not, nor is on the way to be, our like, -but only a pretender thereto? In the first place we must look -for consistency and permanence in his principles. We must -see whether he takes pleasure in, and gives praise to, the same -things at all times; whether he directs and establishes his own -life after one pattern, as a frank and free lover of single-minded -friendship and fellowship ought to do. A friend does act in this -manner. On the other hand, the time-server possesses no one -fixed hearthstone to his character. He does not live a life <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -chosen for himself, but a life chosen for another. Moulding -and adapting himself to suit others, he possesses no singleness -or unity, but adopts all manner of varying shapes. Like water -poured from one vessel into another, he is perpetually flowing -hither and thither and accommodating himself to the form of the -receptacle.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The ape, we are told, is captured through endeavouring to -imitate man by copying his motions in dancing. The time-server, -on the contrary, is one who allures and decoys others. -Nor does his mimicry take the same form in all cases. One person -he will help to dance and sing: with another he will share a taste -<span class='pageno' id='Page_194'>194</span>for wrestling and athletics. If he gets hold of a sportsman -devoted to hunting, he follows his lead, and all but shouts, in the -words of Phaedra, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>I long, ye Gods, to cheer the hounds</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Close-pressing on the dappled deer</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>whereas he feels no interest whatever in the animal, but is -setting his toils to catch the huntsman himself. If his next -quarry is a young man with a taste for study and intellectual -improvement, he is all for books, and grows a beard down to -his feet; it is a case of wearing the philosopher’s cloak -and his air of ‘indifference’,<a id='r50' /><a href='#f50' class='c009'><sup>[50]</sup></a> and of prating about Plato’s -‘numbers’ and ‘right-angled triangles’. If, next, there -happens along some easy-going bibulous person with plenty -of money,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Then forthwith are his rags cast off by the wily Odysseus.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Away goes the cloak; shorn off is the beard—’tis a crop -that bears no corn: to the fore are wine-coolers and wine-cups, -laughter in the streets and mockery of the philosophic -student.</p> - -<p class='c005'>We are told, for instance, that at Syracuse, when Plato -visited the place and Dionysius was seized with a mania for -philosophy, the host of geometricians turned the palace into -a perfect whirl of dust.<a id='r51' /><a href='#f51' class='c009'><sup>[51]</sup></a> But when Dionysius came to logger-heads -with Plato, had had enough of philosophy, and abandoned -himself to drink and women and to silly talk and wanton -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> behaviour, in a moment it was as if Circe had transformed them -every one, and there came a reign of vulgarity, oblivion, and -folly. Examples are also to be found in the conduct of time-servers -on a large scale, such as demagogues. Greatest was -<span class='pageno' id='Page_195'>195</span>Alcibiades. At Athens he joked, kept horses, and lived like -a wit and a man of the world. At Lacedaemon he cropped his -hair close, wore a short cloak, and bathed in cold water. In -Thrace he fought and drank. But when he attached himself -to Tissaphernes, he indulged in luxury, effeminacy, and ostentation, -and sought to win the good graces of his company by -adapting himself in all cases to their likeness and becoming -one of them. Not so Epaminondas or Agesilaus. Despite <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -all their intercourse with so many persons, communities, and -standards of conduct, they everywhere maintained—in dress, -way of life, speech, and behaviour—their own proper character. -So with Plato. He was the same at Syracuse as at Athens, the -same to Dionysius as to Dion.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Our easiest method of exposing the polypus-like changes of -the time-server is to make a show of frequent changes on our -own part, finding fault with conduct of which we formerly -approved, and all of a sudden countenancing actions, conduct, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>53<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -or talk which used to fill us with disgust. We shall then perceive -that he has no sort of settled and specific character; that his -loves, hatreds, pleasures, and pains are not matters of his own -feeling; that he is merely a mirror reflecting extraneous moods, -principles, and emotions. For observe the man’s ways. Should -you speak disparagingly to him of one of your friends, he will -remark: ‘You have been slow in finding the fellow out; <i>I</i> never -did like him.’ If, on the contrary, you change your tone and -speak in his praise, he will declare that he is ‘right glad and -thankful on the man’s behalf’, because he ‘believes in him’. -If you propose to adopt a different mode of life—if, for example, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -you are converted from a political career to a life of quiet -inactivity—he will say, ‘We ought to have got quit of brawlings -and jealousies long before this.’ If, on the other hand, you -appear eager for office and the platform, he seconds you with, -‘A very proper spirit! A quiet life is pleasant, no doubt, but -<span class='pageno' id='Page_196'>196</span>it lacks honour and distinction.’ We ought immediately to -answer that kind of man with the words:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'>‘<i>Different, sir, dost thou show thyself now from the man thou wert erstwhile.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>I do not want a friend who shifts his ground when I do and who -nods when I nod—my shadow can do that better—but one who -helps me to truth and sound judgement.’</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Such is one way of applying a test. There is a second point -of difference to be watched, as against the points of resemblance. -It is not in all matters that a genuine friend is prompt to copy -or commend us, but only in the best.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Not his to share our hates, but share our loves</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>as Sophocles has it. Yes, and to share our right conduct and high -principles, not our wrong and wanton deeds, unless perhaps—as -a result of familiar association—some contaminating effluence, -like that of ophthalmia, affects him to some extent with a -blemish or a fault against his will. For instance, it is said that -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Plato’s stoop, Aristotle’s lisp, King Alexander’s crook of the -neck and harshness of voice in conversation, were tricks borrowed -by their respective intimates. There are persons who, without -knowing it, pick up from both the temperament and conduct -of their friends most of what is characteristic of them. The -time-server, however, is exactly like the chameleon. As the -latter assimilates himself to every colour but white, so the time-server, -though utterly unable to arrive at a likeness to your -valuable qualities, leaves no discreditable one uncopied. He is -like a bad painter, who, because beauty lies beyond the reach -of his weak capacity, makes the strikingness of his portraiture -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> a matter of wrinkles, moles, and scars. So the toady becomes -an imitator of dissoluteness, superstition, irascibility, harshness -to servants, and distrust of friends and relatives. Not only is -<span class='pageno' id='Page_197'>197</span>he by nature and of his own accord prone to the lower course; -it is by imitating a baseness that he appears to be farthest from -blaming it. A man who takes the higher line, and shows distress -and vexation at his friends’ misdeeds, is dubiously regarded—a -fact which accounts for the ruin of Dion with Dionysius, of -Samius with Philip, and of Cleomenes with Ptolemy. But when -a man desires to be, and to be thought, agreeable and to be -depended upon, the worse the thing is, the more display he -makes of liking it, as if the strength of his affection will not -permit him to dislike even your vices, but makes him your <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -natural sympathizer in all circumstances. Such persons therefore -insist upon sharing even involuntary and accidental shortcomings. -When toadying an invalid, they pretend to suffer -with the same complaint. In company with a person who is -somewhat blind or deaf, they pretend to be dim-sighted and -hard of hearing, like the flatterers of Dionysius, whose sight was -so dull that they stumbled against each other and knocked over -the dishes at dinner.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Sometimes they work themselves into closer and more -intimate touch with a trouble or a malady, till they come to -participate in afflictions of the most secret kind. If they see <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>54<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -that the patron is unhappy in his marriage or on bad terms -with his sons or his relatives, they do not spare themselves, -but make lamentations about their own children, or wife, or -relatives, or friends, on certain alleged grounds which they -divulge as a miserable secret. Such similarity creates a closer -understanding with their patron. He has received a sort of -hostage, thereupon betrays to them some secret or other, and, -because of that betrayal, keeps friends with them and is afraid -to leave his confidence to its fate. I know of one time-server -who, when the patron divorced his wife, turned his own wife -also out of doors. It was, however, found out—through a discovery <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -of the patron’s wife—that he was visiting and sending -<span class='pageno' id='Page_198'>198</span>messages to her in secret. The toady must have been but -little known to the man who thought that the lines:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Body all belly, and an eye that looks</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>All round; a thing that crawls upon its teeth</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>were as apt a description for a crab as they are for the flatterer. -The picture is that of the parasite:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>The friend of saucepan-time and dinner-hour</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>as Eupolis expresses it.</p> - -<p class='c005'>This point, however, we will reserve till its proper place. -Meanwhile we must not omit to mention another shrewd -trick played by the time-server when he imitates you. If he -goes so far as to copy some good quality in the person whom he -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> toadies, he is careful to leave the advantage with him. Friends -in the true sense are neither jealous nor envious of each other, -and, whether they reach or fail to reach the same degree of -excellence, they accept the situation fairly and without a grudge. -But the toady—who never forgets to play second rôle—lets his -resemblance fall short of equality, and owns to being distanced -at everything but vices. In vices, however, he insists on first -prize. If the patron is irritable, he says, ‘<i>I</i> am all bile;’ if -superstitious, ‘<i>I</i> am a mass of fears;’ if love-sick, ‘<i>I</i> am frantic.’ -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> ‘It was wrong of you to laugh,’ he will say, ‘but <i>I</i> was absolutely -dying with laughter.’ But where virtues are concerned it is -the other way about. ‘I am a fast runner, but <i>you</i> positively -fly.’ ‘I am a tolerable horseman, but nothing to a centaur like -our friend here.’ ‘I have a neat turn for poetry, and can write -a line better than some, but</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Thunder is not for me, ’tis work for Zeus.</i>’</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>He thus appears to do two things at once—to give an air of -merit to his patron’s tastes by imitating them, and of unapproachableness -to his ability by failing to match it.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_199'>199</span>So much for the differences between fawner and friend in the -midst of their resemblances.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Since, as we have observed, pleasure is another point in -common—a good type of man taking as much delight in his -friends as a weak man does in his flatterers—we may proceed -to make a distinction here also. The distinction lies in the relation -between the pleasure and its end. Thus, not only unguents <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -have an agreeable smell; a medicine may have it also. But -there is the difference that the object of the former is pleasure -and nothing else, while in the other case the purgative, warming, -or flesh-making quality happens to be combined with fragrance. -Again, a painter mixes engaging colours and dyes, and there -are also certain medical preparations with a taking appearance -and an attractive colour. Where is the difference? Clearly -our distinction will lie in the end for which they are used. -Just so with the case before us. In the agreeable relations of <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -friend with friend the pleasant-giving element is a kind of gloss -upon a substance of high value and utility. Sometimes sportiveness, -the table, wine, and even mockery and nonsense are used -by them as a seasoning to high and serious purposes. Hence -such expressions as:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Then had they joyance in talk and in speaking the one to the other</i>;</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>or:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Nor should aught else have parted us twain in our love and our joyance.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>But, with the time-server, it is his function and end to be <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>55<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -perpetually dishing up in a spicy form something amusing, -something done or something said which pleases and is meant -to please.</p> - -<p class='c005'>To put it briefly, the toady thinks the purpose of his every -action should be to make himself agreeable, whereas the friend -<span class='pageno' id='Page_200'>200</span>will only do what is right, and therefore, though often agreeable, -he is often the contrary, not because he wishes it, but because, -when it is the proper course, he does not avoid it. It is as with -the physician. When it helps matters he will throw in a pinch -of saffron or spikenard, and will frequently order a pleasant -bath and an inviting diet. But there are times when he will -have none of these, but will shake in a dash of castor</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Or polium foul of odor, that men e’en shudder to smell it.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Or he will pound a dose of hellebore and make you drink it off. -Neither the unpleasantness in the one case nor the pleasantness -in the other is the end in his mind, but in both cases he has only -one object in view for the patient, and that object is his good. -In the same way there are times when a friend will lead you in -the path of duty by inspiriting you with praise or gratifying -you with courtesies, as the speaker does in</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Teucer, Telamon’s son, dear prince of a warrior people,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Shoot as now thou dost</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>or in:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>How then should I, if ’tis so, be forgetful of godlike Odysseus?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>But when, on the contrary, you need calling to attention, he -will upbraid you in biting terms and with the plain-speaking -of a guardian: <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Foolish art thou, Menelaus Zeus-foster’d: no time is this present</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>For folly like thine.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>There are also times when he makes the deed accompany the -word, like Menedemus, when he taught the prodigal and -dissolute son of his friend Asclepiades a wholesome lesson by -shutting the door in his face and refusing to speak to him. -Similarly Arcesilaus forbade Bato the lecture-room for having -attacked Cleanthes in a verse of a comedy. He was reconciled -to him, however, when he repented and made his peace with -<span class='pageno' id='Page_201'>201</span>Cleanthes. For though one must give a friend pain when it does -him good, one must not, while giving the pain, make an end -of the friendship. The sting should be used only as a medicine, -for the care and salvation of the patient. A friend is therefore <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -like a musician. In converting us to right and salutary courses -he will sometimes loosen and sometimes tighten the strings. -Pleasure you will get from him often, profit always. On the -other hand, the time-server, who harps in a single key and is -accustomed to strike no note but that of your pleasure and gratification, -has no notion of any action to check you or word to pain -you. He merely plays the accompaniment to your wishes, with -which both his time and his words are invariably in accord. -Xenophon says of Agesilaus that he welcomed praise from those -who were no less ready to blame. So we should regard that -which gives pleasure and gratification as in the category of -‘friend’, if it can also on occasion oppose us and give us pain. -But a companionship which is uniformly pleasurable and maintains <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -a perpetual graciousness unqualified by any sting, calls -for suspicion. We ought, in fact, to be ready to ask, like the -Laconian on hearing praise of King Charillus, ‘How can a man -be honest, when he cannot be angry even with a rascal?’</p> - -<p class='c005'>It is close to the ear, we are told, that the gadfly gets into -a bull and the tick into a dog. In the case of a man of ambition, -the time-server with his flatteries takes hold of his ears and sticks -so fast that it is hard to rub him off. Particularly, therefore, -in such circumstances must we keep our judgement vigilant. -It must be on the alert to see whether the praise is given to the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -thing or to the man. It is given to the thing when men praise -us in our absence more than in our presence; when they wish -and strive for the same objects themselves, and praise not only -us but every one else who does the like; when we do not find -them doing and saying first one thing and then the opposite; -and—most important of all—when our sense does not tell us -<span class='pageno' id='Page_202'>202</span>that we are repenting or ashamed of the things for which we -are praised, or wishing that we had rather done and said the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>56<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> contrary. This inward judgement, which testifies against a -flattery and refuses to accept it, is immune from contamination, -and proof against the time-server.</p> - -<p class='c005'>It is a strange thing that most men, when they meet with -a misfortune, cannot bear to be consoled, but are better pleased -with those who will join in the lamentations; but when they -are guilty of a blunder or a fault, if you make them feel the sting -of repentance by means of a reproof or a reprimand, they think -you an enemy and an accuser; whereas, if you eulogize their -conduct, they regard you as a loyal friend and receive you with -open arms.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Now when people give you praise and applause for something -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> you do or say, whether in sober earnest or in careless jest, the -harm they do is only for the moment, and only affects the -matter in hand. But when their praises go so far as to influence -your moral being, and their flatteries to affect your character, -they are as bad as servants who pilfer ‘<i>not from the stack, but -from the seed</i>‘. For the moral disposition and the moral character—first -principle and fountain-head of conduct—are the seed of -actions, and these they corrupt by clothing vice in the titles of -virtue. Thucydides tells us that in the midst of war and faction -‘<i>the customary acceptation of words was arbitrarily changed to suit -an end. Reckless daring came to be thought devoted courage; -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> cautious hesitation, an excuse for cowardice; moderation, weakness -in disguise; complete insight, complete inertia</i>‘. So, when -flattery is at work, we should warily note how prodigality is -called ‘generosity’; cowardice, ‘caution’; light-headed caprice, -‘life and vigour’; meanness, ‘moderation’; the amorous man, -‘amiable and affectionate’; the arrogant and irascible person, -‘a man of spirit’; a poor meek creature, ‘civil and obliging’. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Remember, how Plato tells us that the lover—the flatterer of -<span class='pageno' id='Page_203'>203</span>the beloved—calls a snub nose ‘piquant’, a hook-nose ‘regal’, -a swarthy face ‘virile’, a white face ‘saint-like’, while ‘honey-colour’ -is simply the coinage of a lover who indulgently invents -a pretty name for pallor. Yet when an ugly man is persuaded -that he is beautiful, or a little man that he is tall, his deception -is short-lived, and the harm which he sustains is slight and easily -repaired. But flattery may teach him to treat vices as if they <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -were virtues, and to rejoice in them instead of sorrowing. It -may remove all sense of shame at misconduct. Such flattery -spelled destruction to the Siceliots, when it called the cruelty -of Dionysius and Phalaris a ‘hatred of wickedness’. It spelled -ruin to Egypt, when it gave to Ptolemy’s effeminacy, to his -hysterical superstition, to his shriekings and bangings of tambourines, -the name of piety and worship. It came once within -an ace of utterly subverting Roman morals, when it glossed over -Antony’s dissolute and ostentatious self-indulgence with pretty -terms as a ‘festive and genial appreciation of the boons of unstinted <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -power and fortune’. What made Ptolemy tie on the -mouth-strap and its pair of flutes? What made Nero cultivate -the tragic stage and don the mask and buskin? What else but -praise from flatterers? Is not a king regularly called an Apollo -if he warbles, a Dionysius if he gets drunk, a Hercules if he -wrestles? And is he not so pleased with it, that there is no -way of disgracing himself to which flattery will not lead him? -It is therefore in the matter of praise that we should chiefly -beware of the time-server. He is himself alive to the fact, and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>57<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -is deft at avoiding suspicion. If therefore he gets hold of some -dull-witted and thick-skinned grandee, he fools him to the top of -his bent. Remember how Strouthias makes a hobby-horse of Bias -and dances his fling upon the man’s stupidity by praising him with:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>You have drunk more than royal Alexander</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>or:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>I laugh to think o’ the quip you gave the Cyprian.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_204'>204</span>But with persons of more discernment he perceives that in this -direction they are particularly on the alert, that in this quarter -they keep a special watch. He does not therefore adopt a direct -line of attack with his flattery, but fetches a circuitous course -from a distance, and</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Advances noiselessly, as when a beast</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> is tentatively approached and fingered. At one moment he -will describe how you have been praised by some one else, using -the public speaker’s device of putting the words in another -person’s mouth. He will say, for instance, that he had the great -pleasure of being present in the market-place when some -‘visitors’—or some ‘elderly people’—were relating a good -many admiring and complimentary stories about you. At -another time he will concoct a number of trivial and fictitious -charges against you, which he purports to have heard from -others, and he will say that he has hastened to find you and -desires to know where you said such-and-such a thing or did -so-and-so. If you deny them—as you naturally will—he at -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> once has you in the trap for his compliments: ‘It did surprise -me that you should speak ill of a friend, seeing that it is not -your nature to do so even of an enemy;’ or ‘that you should -have designs on other people’s property, when you are so liberal -with your own’.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Others, again, are like a painter who brings the light and bright -parts into relief by the juxtaposition of dark and shaded portions. -By blaming, abusing, belittling, and ridiculing the opposite -qualities, they give a concealed praise and encouragement -to the defects of the person flattered. To a spendthrift they -disparage economy and call it stinginess. To a grasping knave -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> who makes money by mean and shabby practices they depreciate -honest self-support and call it want of enterprise and business -capacity. When they associate with some careless idler who shuns -<span class='pageno' id='Page_205'>205</span>the busy centres of affairs, they are not ashamed to style public -life a ‘meddling with other people’s business’, and public spirit -a ‘sterile vanity’. Sometimes, in order to flatter a public -speaker, a philosopher is belittled, or the favour of profligate -women is won by miscalling faithful and loving wives ‘provincial -and unattractive’. Most pitiful in its baseness is the -fact that the toady does not even spare himself. As a wrestler -crouches his body in order to throw another, so he insidiously -contrives to compliment his neighbour by disparaging himself. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -‘I am a nervous wretch at sea,’ says he. ‘I cannot face trouble. -Hard words make me frantically angry. But our friend here -has no nerves; nothing troubles him. He is a peculiar person, -always good-tempered, never ruffled.’ But if a man thinks -himself particularly sensible, and is so desirous of being severely -matter-of-fact that—out of what he calls straightforwardness—he -is always on the defensive with</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Tydeus’ son, bepraise me not much, nor, prithee, upbraid me</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>the artist in flattery will not adopt this manner of approaching <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -him. Such cases are met by another device. He will come and -consult him, as a person of superior wisdom, about affairs of -his own. ‘Though,’ he will say, ‘there are others with -whom I am more intimate, I am compelled to trouble you. -For where are we to take refuge when we need advice? In -whom are we to put confidence?’ Then, after listening -to what he has to say, he will take his leave with the -remark that what he has received is ‘not an opinion; it -is an oracle’. And if he sees that you make pretensions to -being a judge of literature, he gives you something he has <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>58<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -written himself, and asks you to read and correct it. When -King Mithridates had a fancy for doctoring, some of his -courtiers actually put themselves in his hands to be lanced -and cauterized. This was flattery by deeds in place of words, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_206'>206</span>since he accepted their confidence as a sufficient voucher for -his skill.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Of many shapes are means divine</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and this negative class of praise requires to be countered with -some craftiness. The way to confute it is by deliberately offering -counsel and suggestion which are nonsensical, and making corrections -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> which are absurd. If your man objects to nothing, -says ‘Yes’ to everything, and exclaims ‘Good!’ ‘Capital!’ -at every item, he exposes himself as one who</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>The watchword asks, while other are his aims</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>—those aims being to encourage your self-conceit with his -laudations.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Take another case. Painting has been styled ‘silent poetry’. -So there is a way of praising by silent flattery. The sportsman’s -purpose is better concealed from the game when he pretends -to be upon other business—walking, tending cattle, or tilling -the soil. In the same way a toady drives home his eulogies most -effectively when the eulogy is disguised under some different -form of action. It may be by giving up his seat, or his place -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> at table, when you appear upon the scene. Or if he is addressing -the Assembly or Council, and notices that some wealthy man -desires to speak, he may stop his speech and yield him the -platform. His silence indicates more clearly than the loudest -acclamation that he regards the person in question as a better -man and his intellectual superior. Such persons may therefore -be seen taking possession of the front seats at an entertainment -or in the meeting-hall, not because they claim any right to -them, but in order that they may play the toady by giving up -their places to rich people. Or you may see them begin the -discussion at a congress or a board-meeting, and subsequently -give way to ‘superior argument’ and shift round with the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> greatest readiness to the opposite view, if their opponent is -<span class='pageno' id='Page_207'>207</span>a person of influence, wealth, or note. The clearest exposure of -such complaisances and concessions is to be sought in the fact -that it is not to knowledge or high abilities or age that the -deference is paid, but to riches and reputations. When Megabyzus -took a seat at Apelles’ side and wanted to prate to him -about ‘line’ and ‘shading’, the painter remarked, ‘Do you -see those boys yonder grinding my mixing-earth? When you -were silent, they were all eyes of admiration for your purple and -your jewels. But now that you have begun to talk about things <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -you do not understand, they are laughing at you.’ Similarly -Solon, when Croesus questioned him about ‘happiness’, -declared that Tellus, an Athenian of humble rank, as well as -Cleobis and Biton, were more favoured by fortune. A flatterer, -on the contrary, not only avers that a king, a rich man, or a man -in power, is prosperous and fortunate; he also declares that -he is pre-eminent in wisdom, art, and every form of excellence. -Hence while there are persons who have no patience to listen -when the Stoics describe the sage as at the same time ‘rich, -beautiful, noble, and king’, a toady will make out that the rich -man is at the same time an orator, a poet, and—if he so wishes—a -painter and a musician. He makes him out swift of foot and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -strong of thew by letting himself be thrown in wrestling and -outstripped in running, as Criso of Himera did in a race against -Alexander—much to Alexander’s disgust when he detected it. -Carneades used to say that the only thing that kings’ and rich -men’s sons understand is how to ride; they receive no proper -instruction in anything else. For their teacher flatters them in -school with his praises, and their antagonists in the wrestling-ring -by courting defeat; whereas a horse, who neither knows -nor cares whether you are in or out of office, poor or rich, -pitches you head first if you cannot keep your seat. It was -therefore a silly and stupid thing for Bion to say: ‘If by <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>59<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -eulogizing a field we could make it bear a prolific crop, would -<span class='pageno' id='Page_208'>208</span>it not be a mistake for a man to go digging and moiling instead? -Neither, then, is it irrational for you to praise a human being, -if your praise is productive of good fruit.’ A field suffers no -injury from being praised, whereas insincere and undeserved -compliment puffs a man up and ruins him.</p> - -<p class='c005'>On this point we have said enough. The next consideration -is that of candour.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> When Patroclus, on going out to fight, dressed himself in -Achilles’ armour and drove his team, the one thing he let alone -and did not venture to touch was the Pelian spear. So it might -have been expected of the flatterer that, when dressing himself -up carefully for the part of ‘friend’, with its proper tokens -and badges, the one thing he would leave untouched and -uncopied would be plain-speaking—a special attribute,</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Heavy and huge and stubborn</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>to be wielded only by friendship. But in his fear that laughter, -strong drink, jest, and fun may mean his betrayal, we find him -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> putting a solemn face on the business, flattering with a frown -and administering dashes of blame and admonition. Here -again, therefore, we must apply our tests. In a comedy of -Menander, the Mock-Hercules comes in carrying a club which -has no strength or solidity, but is merely a hollow sham. So, -I take it, with the flatterer’s plain-speaking. On trial you will -find that it is soft and without weight or vigour; that it behaves -like a woman’s cushion, which, while seeming to offer a firm -support to the head, actually yields it more of its own way. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> This spurious candour, with its hollow fullness, its false and -superficial puffiness, is merely meant to shrink and collapse, so -as to induce the person who leans upon it to make himself more -comfortable. The genuine candour of a friend attacks only our -misdeeds; it hurts only out of care and protection; like honey, -it merely stings our sores in cleansing them, its general uses -<span class='pageno' id='Page_209'>209</span>being grateful and sweet. This, however, is a theme for special -discussion.</p> - -<p class='c005'>With the flatterer it is different. In the first place, when he -displays sharpness or heat or inflexibility, it is in dealing with -others than yourself. He is severe upon his own servants; -he is terribly hard upon the misdeeds of his own relations; -he shows no admiration or respect for a stranger, but treats <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -him with contempt; his scandalizing is merciless when exacerbating -other people. His object is to make it appear that he -detests low practices, and that he would not consent to abate -a jot of his candour in your behalf, or to do or say anything -to curry favour. In the next place, when there is something -really and seriously wrong, he pretends to be completely -ignorant and unconscious of it, while he will pounce upon some -little immaterial shortcoming and take it rigorously and vehemently -to task—if, for instance, he sees an implement carelessly -placed, or a fault of domestic management, or negligence in -the cut of your hair or the wearing of your clothes, or lack of <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -proper attention to a dog or a horse. But should you slight -your parents, neglect your children, humiliate your wife, despise -your relatives, and waste your money, it becomes no business -of his. In such circumstances not a word does he venture to -utter, but he is like a trainer who permits an athlete to get drunk -and dissipated, while he is severe upon him in the matter of an -oil-flask or a scraping-iron; or like a grammar-master who scolds -a boy for the state of his slate and pencil, but pretends not to -hear his slips of grammar and expression. The toady is the kind -of man who, in dealing with a ridiculously incompetent public -speaker, has nothing to say about his matter, but finds fault -with his voice-production, and blames him severely for spoiling <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>60<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -his larynx by drinking cold drinks; or who, when requested -to peruse some miserable composition, finds fault with the roughness -of the paper and calls the copyist a slovenly wretch. It -<span class='pageno' id='Page_210'>210</span>was so in the case of Ptolemy, when he made pretence to literary -tastes. They would fight with him about some out-of-the-way -word or bit of a verse or point of information, and would keep -it up till midnight. But to his indulgence in cruelty and -outrage, to his tambourine-playing and initiating, not one of -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> all their number offered any opposition. Imagine a man suffering -with tumours and abscesses, and some one taking a surgeon’s -knife and cutting—his hair or his nails! That is what the -flatterer does. He employs his candour upon those parts which -feel no pain or soreness.</p> - -<p class='c005'>There is a still craftier species, who make their plain-speaking -and fault-finding an actual means of pleasing. When Alexander -was once making large gifts to a jester, envy and vexation -drove Agis, the Argive, to bawl out, ‘How utterly absurd!’ -The king turned upon him angrily and asked, ‘<i>What</i> is that -you say?’ ‘I confess,’ was the reply, ‘to being annoyed and -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> indignant when I see how much alike all you sons of Zeus are -in your fondness for flatterers and ridiculous persons. Heracles -found pleasure in his Cercopes, Dionysus in Sileni, and we can -see what a high regard you have yourself for people of the kind.’ -One day when the emperor Tiberius entered the Senate, one -of his flatterers got up and said that, as free men, they were -bound to speak frankly and to treat important interests without -reticence or reservation. When he had thus aroused every one’s -interest and had secured silence and the attention of Tiberius, -he said, ‘Listen, Caesar, to the charge which we all make -against you, but which no one dares to utter openly. You are -neglecting yourself, sacrificing your health and wearing it out -by perpetually working and thinking for us, and giving yourself -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> no rest day or night.’ As he continued with a good deal more -in the same strain, the orator Cassius Severus is said to have -exclaimed, ‘Such plain-speaking will be the man’s death!’</p> - -<p class='c005'>These devices, however, are of minor moment. The matter -<span class='pageno' id='Page_211'>211</span>becomes grave—as meaning ruin to foolish people—when a man -is accused of the opposite disorders to those with which he is -afflicted; as when the parasite Himerius used to scold the -meanest and most avaricious plutocrat in Athens by calling him -a reckless prodigal, bent on bringing himself and his children -to starvation; or when, on the contrary, a toady reproaches <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -a prodigal spendthrift with sordid parsimony, as Titus Petronius -did Nero; or when he urges a ruler who behaves with savage -cruelty towards his subjects to divests himself of ‘all that gentleness -and ill-timed and mistaken clemency’.</p> - -<p class='c005'>To the same class belongs the man who pretends to look upon -some silly nincompoop as a clever rogue of whom he is afraid -and wary. Or if an ill-conditioned person who delights in -perpetual fault-finding and scandalizing does happen to be led -into praising some distinguished man, he may take him to task -and raise objections, for ‘it is a weakness of yours, this praising <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -of even quite insignificant people. What remarkable thing has -he ever said or done?’</p> - -<p class='c005'>Love-affairs are favourite ground for the flatterer to play -upon his victim by further inflaming his passion. If he sees -you at variance with your brothers, or neglecting your parents, -or contemptuous towards your wife, he offers neither remonstrance -nor reproach, but actually intensifies the bad feeling. -‘No: you don’t appreciate yourself,’ or, ‘It is you that are -to blame, for always playing the humble servant.’ But if anger <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>61<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -and jealousy provoke a tiff with a mistress of whom you are -enamoured, in comes flattery at once with a fine blaze of frankness, -and adds fuel to the fire by pleading cause and accusing -the lover of all sorts of unloverlike, unfeeling, and unforgivable -conduct:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>O ingrate! after all that rain of kisses!</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Thus, when Antony was becoming passionately enamoured of -the Egyptian queen, his friends did their best to persuade him -<span class='pageno' id='Page_212'>212</span>that the love was on her side, and they upbraided him with -being ‘cold and supercilious’. ‘The lady has forsaken all that -royal state and that life of delightful enjoyments to go wandering -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> about on the march with you, like any concubine.</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>But, for thee, the heart in thy breast is past all moving or charming</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>and you leave her to suffer as she will.’ It gratified Antony -to be thus put in the wrong; no praise could please him like -these accusations; and unconsciously he became perverted to -the standard of the man who pretended to be reproving him. -For candour of this kind is like the bite of a lascivious woman; -while pretending to give pain, it arouses a provoking sensation of -pleasure.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Though unmixed wine is, generally speaking, a corrective of -hemlock, yet, if you add it to that drug in the form of a mixture, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> you make it impossible to counteract the power of the poison, -the heat driving it rapidly to the heart. So, while aware that -candour is a potent corrective of flattery, your rogue actually -uses ‘candour’ as his instrument for flattering you. Bias was -therefore wrong in his answer to the question: ‘What animal -is the most dangerous?’ when he replied, ‘Among wild animals, -the despot, among tame animals, the toady.’ It would have been -truer to say that, among toadies, those who merely frequent -your bath and your table are tame, while those who thrust the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> tentacles of their slanderous and malicious meddling into bedchamber -and boudoir are savage and unmanageable beasts.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The one method of protecting ourselves appears to lie in -recognizing and never forgetting that our mental being is made -up of two parts—one high-principled and rational, the other -irrational, mendacious and passionate—and that a friend is the -unfailing supporter and champion of the better part—a physician -who promotes and watches over good health—while a flatterer -acts as prompter to the passionate and irrational part, exciting, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_213'>213</span>titillating, coaxing, and divorcing it from reason by inventing <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -low forms of self-indulgence on its behalf. There are some kinds -of food which yield no benefit to blood or breath, and put no -vigour into muscle or marrow, but simply excite the sensual -appetites and make the flesh flabby and unsound. So with the -advice of a fawner. If does nothing to help sane thought and -judgement; but watch it, and you will find it cosseting an -amorous pleasure, aggravating a foolish fit of anger or provoking -an attack of envy, puffing you up with vulgar and empty pride, -encouraging your doleful dumps, or, where there is a tendency -to be ill-natured or mean-spirited or mistrustful, making the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -feeling more bitter or shy or suspicious by constantly suggesting -and anticipating evil. For he is perpetually in wait for some -passion or other, which he proceeds to feed up; and whenever -there is a festering or inflammation of your mental state, you -will always find him a kind of bubo, bringing it to a head. Are -you angry? ‘Then punish.’ Do you crave a thing? ‘Then buy -it.’ Are you afraid? ‘Then let us run away.’ Are you suspicious? -‘Then trust the feeling.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>If it is hard to catch him in connexion with such affections -as these—their strength being so overpowering as to baffle the -reason—he will give you a better opening in smaller matters; -for he will be just the same with them. If you are apprehensive <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>62<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -of a headache or a surfeit, and are doubtful as to bathing or -taking food, a friend will try to check you and will urge you to -be cautious, whereas the toady will drag you to the bath, or -ask them to put some novel dish on the table, begging you not -‘to keep so tight a hand upon your body as to be cruel to it’. -If he sees you inclined to shirk a journey, a voyage, or a piece -of work, he will say that there is no immediate hurry, and that -it will do just as well if you postpone the matter or send someone -else. If, after promising a friend to make him a loan or a present -of a sum of money, you repent, but have your scruples, the toady <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -<span class='pageno' id='Page_214'>214</span>throws his weight into the less honourable scale; he corroborates -‘the argument of the purse’, and makes short work of your -sense of shame by urging you to be economical, ‘seeing that -you have so many expenses and so many persons to support.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>If, therefore, we are able to perceive our own covetousness, -shamelessness, or cowardice, we shall also be able to see when -a man is a toady. Such he is when he is always playing the -advocate to those passions and ‘speaking his mind’ when we -deviate from them.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Enough having been said upon this topic, we may next proceed -to the question of the practical services rendered. In this -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> respect the flatterer makes his distinction from the friend a very -obscure and perplexing matter; he always appears so prompt -and indefatigable in his zeal. While a friend’s way, like the -‘speech of truth’ as described by Euripides, is ‘single’, open, -and unaffected, that of the flatterer</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Sick in itself, needs antidotes full shrewd</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>—uncommonly so, indeed, and plenty of them. When you meet -a friend, he sometimes passes on without uttering or receiving -a word, and with no more than a glance or a smile; he simply -manifests by his expression, and gathers from yours, the kindly -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> understanding within. But the toady is on the run to overtake -you, greets you from a long way off, and, if you catch sight of -him and speak to him first, he excuses himself over and over -again, calling his witnesses and taking his oath. So in the -matter of actions. A friend will neglect many a trifle; he is -no precisian and makes no fuss; he does not insist upon serving -you at every turn. But the other is persistent, unremitting, -unwearied; he leaves no opportunity or room for any one else -to serve you; he is eager to receive your orders, and, if he does -not get them, he is piqued, nay, absolutely heart-broken with -disappointment. A sensible man, then, may take these as some -<span class='pageno' id='Page_215'>215</span>indications that a friendship is not sincere and single-minded, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -but is like a harlot who forces her embraces upon you before -they are asked for.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The first place, however, in which to look for the difference -is in promises. It has already been well said by previous writers -that a friend will put his promise in the form familiar in</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>If I have power to achieve it, and if ’tis a thing for achievement</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>while a time-server will put it in this:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Voice me the thought in thy mind.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>The comedians present us with such characters:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Nicomachus, pit me against the soldier.</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>I’ll make ripe pulp of him; I’ll make his face</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Softer than sponge: if not, then flog me soundly.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>In the next place no friend will be a party to your actions <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -unless he has first been a party to planning them. He must -first have looked into the business and helped to put it on a right -and proper footing. Not so the flatterer. Even if you do grant -him a share in weighing the matter and expressing an opinion -about it, he is not only so anxious to gratify you with his complaisance, -but is in such dread of leading you to suspect him of -unreadiness to face the action, that he leaves you to take your -course, or only lends spurs to your desire. It is not easy to find -a rich man or a grandee who is ready to say: <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>63<span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Give me a man, a beggar—nay, no matter,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Lower than beggar, if he means me well—</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>To put fear by, and speak his heart to me.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Like the tragedian, he must have the support of a chorus of -friends who keep his tune, or of an audience who give applause. -Merope in the tragedy advises:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Get thee for friends such men as, when they speak,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Yield not; but when a man will for thy pleasure</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Make himself knave, lock thou thy door against him.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_216'>216</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> But such persons do the opposite. If, ‘when you speak’ you -‘yield not’, but oppose them for their good, they abominate -you; but if ‘for their pleasure’ you are a ‘knave’ and a servile -charlatan, they receive you not merely inside their locked doors -but inside their most secret passions and concerns. The simple -kind of flatterer, it is true, does not aim at so much. What he -asks in such important matters is not to be your adviser, but -your minister and servant. But the more crafty person will -stand still—puzzling over the question with puckered brow and -appropriate changes of countenance—but will say nothing. -And if you give your own idea, he will exclaim, ‘How strange! -You just managed to anticipate me. I was about to make -exactly your suggestion.’</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Mathematicians tell us that lines and surfaces, being mental -perceptions and incorporeal, have in themselves no such thing -as bending, stretching, or motion, but that they are bent, -stretched, and changed in position along with the bodies of -which they are the boundaries. So you will discover that, with -the time-server, his assent, his opinion, even his pleasure and -anger, are always dependent. Here, therefore, it is perfectly -easy to detect the difference. It is still more apparent in the -manner in which a service is rendered. With the good feeling -of a friend, as with a living creature, its most vital functions lie -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> deep. It is marked by no ostentatious display; but very often, -like a physician who conceals the fact that he is doctoring you, -a friend does you a good turn by a word of intercession or by -bringing about an understanding, and so consults your interests -without your knowing it. Arcesilaus was a man of this type. -Not to mention other instances, when Apelles the Chian was ill -and Arcesilaus had discovered how poor he was, he came back later -with twenty drachmae. Taking a seat close to him, he exclaimed, -‘There is nothing here beyond Empedocles’ four elements:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Fire and water and earth and the gentle air of the heavens.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_217'>217</span>Why, even your bed is made all askew.’ With that he moved -his pillow and meanwhile slipped the coins under it. When the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -old woman in attendance found them and told Apelles in amazement, -he laughed and said, ‘It is that thief Arcesilaus.’<a id='r52' /><a href='#f52' class='c009'><sup>[52]</sup></a></p> - -<p class='c005'>And here we may note how philosophy produces ‘<i>children -like unto their sires</i>‘. Cephisocrates, who had been impeached, -was on his trial, and beside him, with the rest of his friends, -stood Lacudes, one of the coterie of Arcesilaus. The accuser -having asked for his ring, Cephisocrates quietly dropped it at -his side, and Lacudes, who noticed the action, put his foot upon -it and hid it. On that ring depended the proof of the charge. -When Cephisocrates, after his acquittal, went shaking hands -with members of the jury, one of them, who had apparently <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -seen what occurred, bade him thank Lacudes, and gave an -account of the affair, which Lacudes had mentioned to no one. -We may believe that it is the same with the Gods, and that for -the most part they confer their benefits unperceived, it being -their nature to find pleasure in the mere act of bestowing favours -and doing good. But in a deed done by a flatterer there is -nothing honest, sincere, single-minded, or generous. It is a case -of sweating, bawling, bustling, and of a tense look upon the -face, intended to convey the impression of arduous and urgent -business. The thing resembles, in fact, an overdone painting, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>64<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -which strives to secure realistic effect by the use of blatant -colours and affected folds, wrinkles, and angles.</p> - -<p class='c005'>He is also offensive enough to relate how the business has -meant running about and anxiety, and he goes on to describe -how he has got into trouble with other people and had no end -of worry and some terrible experiences, until you declare that -the thing was not worth it all. Any obligation thrown in your -teeth will cause an unbearable and distressing sense of annoyance, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_218'>218</span>but with an obligation from a time-server your sense of reproach -and shame is felt at once, from the very moment that the service -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> is being rendered. A friend, on the other hand, if he has occasion -to speak of the matter, qualifies his account of it, and about -himself he says nothing. For example, the Lacedaemonians -once sent the people of Smyrna some corn at a time of need, -and, to their expressions of admiration of the kindness, they -replied, ‘Not at all! To scrape this together we had only to -vote the forgoing of one day’s dinner for ourselves and our -beasts.’ A favour so rendered is not only a generous one; it is -made the more welcome to the recipients by the thought that -no great harm is done to the benefactor.</p> - -<p class='c005'>It is not, however, by the flatterer’s offensive way of rendering -his services nor by the recklessness of his promises that one -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> can best recognize the breed; an easier criterion consists in -the creditable or discreditable nature of the service, and in the -different character of the pleasure or benefit. A friend will not, -as Gorgias asserted, expect his friend to render him honest -services and yet himself oblige that friend in many ways which -are not honest:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>’Tis his to share the wisdom, not the folly.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Rather, therefore, he will dissuade him also from improper -courses. And, if he fails, there is virtue in Phocion’s answer -to Antipater, ‘You cannot use me both as friend and toady’—that -is to say, both as friend and not friend. We must help a -friend in his need, not in his knavery; in his planning, not in -his plotting; with testimony, not conspiracy. Yes, and we must -share in his misfortunes, though not in his misdeeds. We -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> should not choose even to be privy to the baseness of our friends; -how then to be a party to their misbehaviour? When the -Lacedaemonians, after their defeat by Antipater, were making -terms, they stipulated that, though he might impose any penalty -<span class='pageno' id='Page_219'>219</span>he liked, he should impose no disgrace. It is the same with -a friend. Should occasion call for expense or danger or hard -work, he is foremost in his claim to be summoned and take a -prompt and zealous part; but when disgrace attaches to it, he -will as promptly beg to be spared and left alone. But with the -fawner it is the reverse. In services of difficulty and danger -he cries off, and, if you give him a tap to sound him, his excuse—whatever <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -it may be—rings false and mean. But in vile and -degrading little jobs, do as you like with him; trample on him; -nothing shocks or insults him.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Look at the ape. He cannot watch the house like a dog, -nor carry like a horse, nor plough the ground like an ox. He is -therefore the bearer of scurrilous insult and buffoonery and the -butt of sport, his function being to serve as a tool for laughter. -Precisely so with the toady. He is unequal to any form of -labour and serious effort, and incapable of helping you by -a speech, with a contribution, or in a fight; but in business -which shuns the light he is promptitude itself—a most competent <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -agent in an amour, an adept at ransoming a strumpet, alert -at checking the bill for a drinking-bout, no sloven in the ordering -of your dinner, deft at attentions to your mistress, and, if you -bid him show insolence to your wife’s relations or bundle her -out of doors, he is beyond all pity or shame.</p> - -<p class='c005'>This, therefore, is another easy means of finding him out. -Order him to do any disreputable and discreditable thing you <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>65<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -choose, and he is ready to spare no pains in gratifying you -accordingly.</p> - -<p class='c005'>A very good indication of the wide difference between our -fawner and a friend may be found in his attitude towards your -other friends. The one is delighted to have many others giving -and receiving affection with him, and his constant aim is to -make his friend widely loved and honoured. He holds that -‘<i>friends have all things in common</i>‘, and their friends, he thinks, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_220'>220</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> should be more ‘in common’ than anything else. But the -other—the false, bastard, and spurious article—realizes, better -than any one, how he is himself sinning against friendship by—so -to speak—debasing its coinage. While, therefore, he is -jealous by nature, it is only against his like that he gives his -jealousy play, by striving to surpass them in grovelling and -lickspittle tricks. Of his betters he stands in fear and dread, -we cannot say because he is</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Plodding on foot against a Lydian car</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>but because, as Simonides has it, he</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in8'><i>Hath not e’en lead</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>To match the pure refinèd gold.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>If, therefore, light in weight, surface-gilt and counterfeit, he -finds himself put in close comparison with genuine friendship, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> full-carat and mint-made, he cannot bear the test, and must -be detected. Consequently he acts like the painter whose cocks -in a picture were wretchedly done, and who therefore ordered -his slave to drive any real cocks as far from his canvas as possible. -In the same way the flatterer drives away real friends and -prevents them coming near. If he fails, while openly he will -fawn upon them and pay them court and deference as being -his betters, in secret he will throw out calumnious hints and -suggestions. And if the word in secret has given a scratch -without at once absolutely producing a wound, he never forgets -Medius’s maxim. This Medius was what may be called the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> fugleman or expert conductor of the chorus of toadies who -surrounded Alexander, and was at daggers drawn with the highest -characters. His maxim was, ‘Be bold in laying on and biting -with your slanders, for even if the man who is bitten salves the -wound, the slander will leave its scar.’ It was through these -scars, or rather because he was eaten up with gangrenes and -ulcers, that Alexander put Callisthenes, Parmenio, and Philotas -<span class='pageno' id='Page_221'>221</span>to death. Meanwhile he surrendered himself unreservedly to -a Hagnon, a Bagoas, an Agesias, or a Demetrius, and allowed -them to give him a fall by salaaming to him and dressing him -up after the fashion of an oriental idol. So powerful an effect <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -has complaisance, and apparently most of all with those who think -most of themselves. Their wish for the finest qualities goes -with the belief that they possess them, and so the flatterer -acquires both credit and confidence. For while lofty places -are difficult of approach or assault for all who have designs upon -them, the lofty conceit produced in a foolish mind by the gifts -of fortune or talent offers the readiest footing to those who are -small and petty.</p> - -<p class='c005'>As therefore we urged at the beginning of this treatise, so we -urge again here; ‘Let us make a clearance of self-love and self-conceit.’ -These, by flattering us in advance, render us more <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -amenable to flattery from outside: we come prepared. But -if, in obedience to the God, we recognize how all-important -the maxim <i>Know Thyself</i> is to each of us; if we therefore -examine our own nature, training, and education, and observe -how all alike fall short of excellence in countless ways, and how -they all contain a large admixture of weakness in the things -we do or say or feel, we shall be very slow in allowing the flatterer -to abuse us at his pleasure. Alexander remarked that what -made him give least credence to those who called him a God -was his sleep and his sexualities, his excesses in those things -falling below his own standard. On our own part we shall <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>66<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -always discover that at many a point and in many a way our -qualities are ugly or a source of pain, defective or misdirected. -We shall see ourselves in our true light, and find that what we -need is not a friend who will pay us compliments and eulogies, -but one who will bring us to book when we are really doing -wrong. But only then. There are in any case very few -with the courage to treat a friend with candour rather than -<span class='pageno' id='Page_222'>222</span>complaisance; yet among these few it will be hard to find such -as understand their business. It will be easier to find persons -who imagine that they are using candour because they abuse and -scold. Yet it is with plain-speaking as with any other medicine. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> When it is given at the wrong time the effect is to upset and pain -you to no purpose. In a certain sense it does painfully what -flattery does pleasantly, inasmuch as unseasonable blame works -as much harm as unseasonable praise. More than anything -else it is a thing which drives a man headlong into the arms -of the flatterer. Like water, he turns from the steep unyielding -surface and glides away into the receptive shallows. Candour, -therefore, must be tempered by rational courtesy, which will -divest it of excess and over-severity. The light must not be -so strong that in our pain and distress at the invariable reproving -and fault-finding we turn away to escape discomfort and fly -to find shade with the flatterer.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> In shunning a vice, Philopappus, our object should always -be virtue, not the contrary vice. Some people think they -escape being shamefaced by being shameless; that they escape -being rustic by being ribald; that their behaviour becomes -furthest from timidity and cowardice when they appear nearest -to impudence and insolence. Some plead to themselves that -they would rather be irreligious than superstitious, rather -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> knaves than simpletons. Their character may be likened to -a piece of wood, which, through lack of the skill to straighten -it, they crook to the opposite side. The ugliest way of -refusing to flatter is to give useless pain. Our social intercourse -must be boorishly ignorant of all the rules of good -feeling when it is by being harsh and disagreeable that we -avoid any creeping humbleness in our friendship, just as -if we were the freedman in the comedy, who thinks that, to -be properly enjoyed, ‘speech on equal terms’ means abusive -speech.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_223'>223</span>Since, therefore, it as an ugly thing when our striving to be -agreeable lands us in flattery, and an ugly thing when, in the -avoidance of flattery, all the spirit of friendly sympathy is ruined -by immoderate plain-speaking; and since we ought to commit -neither mistake, but—in candour as in other things—draw -‘success from moderation’, mere logical sequence seems to <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -dictate the conclusion to our treatise.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Plain-speaking, we find, is liable to be, as it were, tainted in -various ways. The first thing is to divest it of its selfish aspect, by -taking the greatest care not to let it appear as if your reproaches -were due to a kind of injury or grievance of your own. When -the speaker is concerned about himself, we regard his words -as the outcome of anger, not of goodwill; as grumbling, not as -reproof. For whereas candour is a mark of friendliness which -compels respect, grumbling is petty and selfish. We therefore -respect and admire the person who is frank, while a fault-finder -provokes recrimination and contempt. Though Achilles <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -imagined he was speaking with but reasonable frankness, -Agamemnon lost his temper; but when Odysseus attacked -him bitterly in the words</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Madman, thou shouldst have commanded some other, some pitiful army</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>he patiently gave way, the friendly purpose and good sense of -the speech causing him to draw in his horns. The reason was -that, while the plain-speaking of Odysseus, who had no private <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>67<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -grounds for anger, was only for the sake of Greece, the vexation -of Achilles was thought to be chiefly on his own account. Nay, -Achilles himself, though possessed of no sweet or gentle temper, -but</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>A terrible man, who must blame, e’en though it be blaming the blameless</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_224'>224</span>silently permitted Patroclus to give him many such hard blows:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Man of no pity, no father of thine was Peleus the horseman,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Thetis no mother of thine; from the green-grey sea wert thou gotten</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>By beetling crags; so comes it thy heart is void of all mercy.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> The orator Hypereides used to urge the Athenians to consider -not merely whether he was angry, but whether his anger was -gratuitous. So with the admonition of a friend. When pure -from any private feeling, it is a thing of awe, which we cannot -face unabashed. And if, when a man is speaking his mind, it is -manifest that he is casting aside any wrongs his friend may have -done to himself; that it is other misdemeanours on his part -which he is bringing home—other reasons for which he does -not shrink from giving him pain—such candour produces an -irresistible effect, the sharpness and severity of the admonition -being intensified by the kindliness of the admonisher. Doubtless, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> as has been well said, ‘it is most of all when we are angry or -at variance with our friends that we should do or devise something -to their advantage or credit’; but we show no less true -a friendliness if, when we think ourselves slighted or neglected, -it is on behalf of other victims of neglect that we give them a -plain-spoken reminder. Plato, at a time when his relations -with Dionysius were strained and dubious, asked for an interview. -Dionysius granted it, in the belief that Plato was coming -with a tale of grievance of his own. The conversation, however, -took the following shape. ‘Suppose, Dionysius, you discovered -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> that some ill-disposed person had made a voyage to Sicily with -the intention of doing you an injury, but that he could find no -opportunity. Would you allow him to leave the country and -get away scot-free?’ ‘Certainly not, Plato,’ said Dionysius: -‘enemies must be hated and punished not only for what they -do, but for what they propose to do.’ ‘Then suppose,’ said -Plato, ‘some one comes here in a friendly spirit, with the -<span class='pageno' id='Page_225'>225</span>intention of rendering you a service, but that you afford him -no chance. Is it a proper thing to cast him aside with ingratitude -and contempt?’ Upon Dionysius asking who it was, he -answered, ‘Aeschines, a man who, in rightness of character, -will compare with any of Socrates’ associates, and whose teaching -cannot fail to set any hearer firmly on his feet. Though he has <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -made a long voyage for the sake of philosophic intercourse -with you, he has been left in neglect.’ These words stirred -Dionysius so deeply that, in admiration of his kindliness and -magnanimity, he promptly embraced Plato with effusion and -proceeded to pay to Aeschines the most distinguished attentions.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the second place, our candour must be cleared of all excrescences, -so to speak. We must allow it no coarse flavourings in -the shape of insulting ridicule or buffoonish mockery. When -a surgeon is performing an operation, a certain ease and neatness <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -should be incidentally apparent in his work, but there should -be no supple juggleries of the hand in the way of fantastic and -risky <i>fioriture</i>. In the same way candour admits of a dexterous -touch of wit, so long as it is so prettily put as to maintain our -respect; but impertinent and insolent buffoonery utterly -destroys that feeling. Hence the harpist chose a polite as well -as a forcible way of stopping Philip’s mouth, when that monarch -attempted to argue with him on a question of musical note. -‘Sire,’ said he, ‘Heaven forbid you should ever become so -badly off as to know more about these things than I do!’ <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>68<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Epicharmus, on the other hand, chose the wrong way, when -Hiero, a few days after putting some of his familiars to death, -invited him to dinner. ‘Nay, but,’ said he, ‘the other day -there was no invitation to your sacrifice of your friends.’<a id='r53' /><a href='#f53' class='c009'><sup>[53]</sup></a> It -was also a mistake for Antiphon, when the question: ‘What -<span class='pageno' id='Page_226'>226</span>sort of bronze is the best?’ was under discussion in the presence -of Dionysius, to say, ‘That kind out of which they made the -statues of Harmodius and Aristogeiton at Athens.’ No good -is done by the stinging bitterness of such speeches, nor is any -pleasure given by their scurrilous pleasantry. Language of the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> kind comes only from a want of self-command—which is partly -insolent ill-nature—combined with enmity. Those who use it -are courting their own destruction as well; they are veritably -dancing a ‘dance at the well’s edge’. Antiphon was put to -death by Dionysius; Timagenes was banished from Caesar’s -friendship, not because of any free word he ever uttered, but -because, at dinner-parties or when walking, he would perpetually -and with no serious purpose whatever, but</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>For whatsoever him thought might move the Argives to laughter</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>advance some charge against his conduct as a friend, merely -by way of pretext for upbraiding him.</p> - -<p class='c005'>It is the same with the comic poets. Their work contained -many serious and statesmanlike appeals to the audience; but -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> these were so much mixed up with farce and ribaldry—like good -food in a hotch-potch of greenstuff—that their plain-speaking -lost all nutritive power and use, with the result that the speaker -was looked upon as an ill-natured buffoon, and the hearer -derived no benefit from the speech.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In other cases by all means have your fun and laugh with your -friends, but when you give them a piece of your mind, let it -be done with earnestness and with courtesy. And if the matter -is one of importance, impart a cogent and moving effect to your -words by your emotions, gestures, and tone of voice.</p> - -<p class='c005'>There is also the question of the right moment. To disregard -it is in all cases a serious mistake, but is particularly ruinous to -good results when you are ‘speaking your mind’. That we -should beware of doing anything of the kind when wine and -<span class='pageno' id='Page_227'>227</span>inebriation are to the fore, is obvious. It is to bring a cloud <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -over the bright sky, if, in the midst of fun and gaiety, you moot -a topic which puckers the brow and stiffens the face, as if to -defeat the ‘Relaxing God’, who—to quote Pindar—</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Unbends the harassed brow of care.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Nay, there is actually great danger in such unseasonableness. -Wine renders the mind perilously testy, and tipsiness often takes -command of candour and converts it into enmity. Moreover, -instead of showing spirit and courage, it shows a want of manliness -for a person who dare not speak his mind when sober to become -bold at table, like a cowardly dog.</p> - -<p class='c005'>There is, however, no need to dwell further upon this theme. -Let us proceed.</p> - -<p class='c005'>There are many who, when affairs are going well with their <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -friends, neither make any claim nor possess the courage to put -restraint upon them. Prosperity, they think, lies quite beyond -the reach of admonition. But should one stumble and come to -grief, they set upon him. He is tame and humbled, and they -trample upon him. The stream of their candour has been -unnaturally dammed up, and now they let the whole flood -loose upon him. He was once so disdainful, and they so feeble, -that they thoroughly enjoy his change of fortune and make -the most of it. It is as well, therefore, to discuss this class also.</p> - -<p class='c005'>If Euripides asks:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>When fortune blesses, what the need of friends?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>the answer must be that it is the prosperous man who has most <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -need of friends to speak their minds and take down any excess -of pride. There are few who can be both prosperous and wise -at the same time. Most men require to import wisdom from -abroad; they require that reasoning from outside should put -compression upon them when fortune puffs them up and sets -them swaying in the wind. But when fortune reduces their -<span class='pageno' id='Page_228'>228</span>inflated bulk, the situation itself carries its own lesson and brings -repentance home. There is consequently no occasion for -friendly candour or for language which bites and distresses. -When such reverses happen, verily <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>69<span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>’Tis sweet to look into a friend’s fond eyes</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>while he gives us solace and encouragement. Xenophon says -of Clearchus that in battle and danger there appeared upon his -face a look of geniality which put greater heart into those who -were in peril. But to employ your mordant candour upon a man -who is in trouble, is like administering ‘sharp-sight drops’ -to an eye suffering with inflammation. It does nothing to cure -or relieve the pain, but only adds anger to it by exasperating -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the sufferer. For instance, when a man is in health he is not -in the least angry or furious with a friend for blaming his -looseness with the other sex, his drinking, his shirking of work -and exercise, his continual bathings and ill-timed gorgings. -But when he is sick, the thing is intolerable. It is more sickening -than the disease to be told, ‘This is the result of your reckless -self-indulgence, your laziness, your rich dishes, and your -women.’ ‘What an unseasonable man you are! I am writing -my will; the doctors are getting castor and scammony ready -for me; and you come preaching and philosophizing!’ So, -when a man is in trouble, the situation is not one for speaking -your mind and moralizing. What it requires is sweet reasonableness -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> and help. When a little child has a fall, the nurse does not -rush up in order to scold it. She picks it up, washes off the dirt, -and straightens its dress. It is afterwards that she proceeds -to reprimand and punish.</p> - -<p class='c005'>An apposite story is told of Demetrius Phalereus, when he -was in banishment and was living at Thebes in mean and obscure -circumstances. It was with no pleasure that he saw Crates -coming towards him, inasmuch as he expected to hear some -<span class='pageno' id='Page_229'>229</span>plain-spoken cynic abuse. Crates, however, accosted him gently, -and then spoke upon the subject of exile—how there was no -calamity in it, and how little need there was to be distressed, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -since it meant getting rid of cares, with their dangers and -uncertainties. At the same time he urged him to have confidence -in himself and his inner man. Cheered and heartened -by such language, Demetrius exclaimed to his friends: ‘Alas, -for all that engrossing business which prevented me from getting -to know a man like this!’</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>To one in grief a friend should speak kind words,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>But to great folly words of admonition.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Such is the way of a noble friend. But the mean and ignoble -flatterer of the prosperous man is like those ‘ruptures and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -sprains’ of which Demosthenes tells us that ‘when the body -meets with an injury, then you begin to feel them’. He seizes -upon your change of fortune with every appearance of delight -and enjoyment. If you do require any reminder when your -own ill-advised conduct has brought you to the ground, it -should suffice to say:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>’Twas not with approval of mine: full oft did I seek to dissuade thee.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>In what cases, then, ought a friend to be uncompromising? -When should he exert his candour to the full? It is when the -proper moment calls for him to stem the vehement course of -pleasure, anger, or insolence; to put the curb on avarice; to <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -restrain a reckless folly. It was in this way that, when the -precarious favours of fortune had corrupted Croesus with the -pride of luxury, Solon spoke his mind to him, bidding him -wait and see the end. It was in this way that Socrates was -wont to put control on Alcibiades, to wrench his heart and draw -genuine tears from him by bringing his errors home. Such was -the method of Cyrus with Cyaxares. Such too, when Dion’s -<span class='pageno' id='Page_230'>230</span>splendour was at its height and he was drawing all men’s eyes -upon him by the brilliance and greatness of his exploits, was -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>70<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the method of Plato, who bade him keep anxious watch against</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Self-will, house-mate of Solitude.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Speusippus also urged Dion in his letters not to be proud -because he had a great name among children and women-folk, -but to take care and ‘make glorious’ the Academy by adorning -Sicily with piety and justice and the best of laws. But not so -Euctus and Eulaeus, the associates of Perseus. In his prosperity -they followed him like the rest, always assenting, always complaisant. -But when he met the Romans at Pydna, was defeated, -and fled, they attacked him with bitter censure, reminding him -of his errors and oversights and throwing them one after the -other in his teeth, until the man became so utterly sore and -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> angry that he made an end of both by stabbing them with his -dagger.</p> - -<p class='c005'>This, then, may serve for the general rule as to place and time.</p> - -<p class='c005'>But opportunities are often offered by a man himself, and -no one who cares for his friend should let these occasions slip -or omit to use them. Sometimes a question asked, a story told, -blame or praise of a similar action in the case of other people, -gives you the cue for a piece of plain-speaking. For instance, the -story goes that Demaratus visited Macedonia at a time when -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Philip was at variance with his wife and son. Upon Philip -welcoming him and inquiring how far the Greeks were in -harmony with each other, Demaratus—who was his well-wisher -and intimate friend—remarked, ‘It becomes you excellently, -Philip, to be asking about the harmonious relations of Athens -and the Peloponnese, while you allow your own house to be so -full of feud and discord.’ A good hit was also made by Diogenes. -Philip was on his way to fight the Greeks, and Diogenes, who -had entered the camp, was brought before him. Philip, being -<span class='pageno' id='Page_231'>231</span>unacquainted with him, asked him if he was a spy. ‘Certainly -I am,’ he replied. ‘I am a spy upon the short-sighted foolishness -which induces you to come, without any compulsion, and risk <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -your throne and person upon the cast of a single hour.’ This, -however, was perhaps somewhat too forcible.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Another good opportunity for admonition occurs when a man -has been abused for his mistakes by some one else and is feeling -small and humbled. A person of discretion will make a happy -use of the occasion by sending the abusive parties to the right -about and himself taking his friend in hand, reminding him -that, if there is no other reason for being careful, he should at -least give his enemies no encouragement. ‘How can they open -their mouths or say another word, if you cast aside once for <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -all these faults for which they abuse you?’ By this means the -abuser gets the credit of the pain, and the admonisher that of -the benefit.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Some are more subtle. They convert their familiar friends -by blaming some one else, accusing others of the things they -know that those friends do. Once at a lecture in the afternoon -our professor, Ammonius, aware that some of his class had not -lunched as simply as they might, ordered his freedman to give -his own boy a whipping, on the charge that ‘he must have -vinegar with his lunch’. Meanwhile the glance he threw at us -brought the reproach home to the guilty parties.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the next place, we should be cautious of speaking plainly -to a friend before company. Remember the case of Plato. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -Socrates having handled one of his associates somewhat vigorously -in conversation at table, Plato remarked, ‘Would it not have -been better if this had been said in private?’ ‘And,’ retorted -Socrates, ‘would you not have done better if you had said that -to <i>me</i> in private?’ The story goes that, when Pythagoras once -dealt rather roughly with a pupil before a number of persons, -the youth hanged himself, and from that time Pythagoras never -<span class='pageno' id='Page_232'>232</span>again reproved anyone in another’s presence. A fault should -be treated like a humiliating complaint. The uncovering and -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>71<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> prescribing should be secret, not an ostentatious display to -a gathering of witnesses or spectators. It is not the act of a -friend, but of a sophist, to use another’s slips to glorify oneself, -showing off before the company like those medical men who -perform surgical operations in the theatre in order to advertise -themselves. And apart from the insult—which has no right to -accompany any curative treatment—we have to consider the -contentiousness and obstinacy of a man in the wrong. Not -merely is it the case that—as Euripides has it—</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in12'><i>Love, when reproved,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Is but more tyrannous</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> but if you make no scruple about offering reproof in public, -you drive any moral disease or passion into becoming shameless. -Plato insists that, if old men are to inculcate reverence in the -young, they must themselves first show reverence towards the -young. In the same way the friendly candour which most -abashes is that which itself feels abashed. Let it be gently -and considerately that you approach and handle the offender; -then you undermine and destroy his vice, since regard is contagiously -felt where regard is shown. Excellent, therefore, is -the notion:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Putting his head close down, to the end that the rest should not hear it.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Least propriety of all is there in exposing a husband in the -hearing of the wife, a father before the eyes of his children, -a lover in the presence of the beloved, or a teacher in that of -his pupils. He becomes frantic; so sore and angry is he at -being set right before persons in whose eyes he is all anxiety -to shine. When Cleitus enraged Alexander, it was, I imagine, -not so much the fault of the wine as that he appeared to be -<span class='pageno' id='Page_233'>233</span>humbling him before a large company. Another case is that -of Aristomenes, the tutor<a id='r54' /><a href='#f54' class='c009'><sup>[54]</sup></a> of Ptolemy. Once, when an embassy -was in the room, Ptolemy fell asleep and Aristomenes gave him -a hit to wake him up. The flatterers seized the opportunity, -and affected to be indignant on the king’s behalf. ‘If,’ said <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -they, ‘you did drop off, thanks to hard work and want of sleep, -we ought to set you right privately, not lay hands on you before -so many people.’ As the result, he sent Aristomenes a cup of -poison and ordered him to drink it off. Aristophanes also tells -us how Cleon tried to exasperate the Athenians against him by -making it a charge that he</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Abused the country before foreigners.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>This, then, is another of the mistakes to be avoided, if your -desire is not so much to make a self-advertising display as to make -your candour produce helpful and healing results.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In the next place, your plain-speaker ought to bear in mind <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the principle which Thucydides makes the Corinthians so -properly express, in saying that they ‘had a right to find fault’ -with others. It was Lysander, I believe, who said to the man -from Megara, when he was delivering himself at the Federal -Council concerning the interests of Greece, ‘You need a country -to back your talk.’ In any case, doubtless, you need character -for plain-speaking, but in no case is this so true as when you -are admonishing and lecturing other people. Plato used to -say that it was by his life he admonished Speusippus, and the -mere sight of Xenocrates at lecture, and a glance from him, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -sufficed to convert Polemon to better ways. When we lack -weight and strength of character the result of any attempt at -plain-speaking on our part is to draw upon ourselves the words:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Why physic us, thyself one mass of sores?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Nevertheless it often happens that, though a man’s own -<span class='pageno' id='Page_234'>234</span>character is as weak as that of his neighbour, circumstances -drive him to administer reproof. In that case the civillest -behaviour is to contrive somehow to imply that the speaker -is included in the reproach. In this tone are the words:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Tydeus’ son, what ails us, forgetting our prowess and valour?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>72<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> and:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>But no match are we now for Hector alone....</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Socrates’ way of quietly setting young men right was of the same -kind. He would not be taken as being himself free from -ignorance, but as feeling it a duty to share with them in the -cultivation of virtue and the quest of truth. We inspire affection -and confidence when it is thought that, being equally to blame, -we are applying to our friends the same correction as to ourselves. -But if, when rebuking your neighbour, you put on the -superior air of a flawless and passionless being, unless you are -much the senior or possess an acknowledged eminence of -character and reputation, you do no good and only make yourself -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> offensive and a nuisance. For this reason, when Phoenix -introduced the story of his own misfortunes—how in anger he -set to work to kill his father, but speedily repented:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Lest the Achaeans should name me ‘the man who murdered his father’</i>—</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>it was of set purpose, that it might not seem as if, in reproving -Achilles, he claimed to be an impeccable person whom anger -had no power to corrupt. In such cases the moral effect sinks -in, since we yield more readily to a show of fellow-feeling than -to one of contempt.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Another point. Since a mind diseased can no more bear -unqualified candour and reproof than an inflamed eye can -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> be submitted to a brilliant light, one most useful resource -<span class='pageno' id='Page_235'>235</span>among our remedies is to add a slight tincture of praise. For -example:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Ugly is this that ye do, to cease from your valour and prowess,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>All ye best of the host! I would not move me to quarrel,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>If ’twere some other who thus might hold his hand from the fighting,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Some craven man; but with you is my heart exceedingly anger’d</i>:</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>or:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Pandarus, where is thy bow, and where thy feathery arrows?</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Where thy glory, the which no man among us doth challenge?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>If a man is giving way, there is also a vigorous rallying power -in such language as</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in24'><i>Where now</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Is Oedipus and all his far-famed rede?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>or:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in26'><i>Is ‘t Heracles,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>He who hath borne so many a brunt, speaks thus?</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Not only does it temper the harshness of the punishment <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -inflicted by the reproach; it sets a man at rivalry with himself. -When reminded of the things which stand to his credit, he is -ashamed of those which degrade him, and he finds an elevating -example in his own person. But when we make comparisons -with others—with mates, fellow citizens, or kinsmen—the contentiousness -which belongs to his failings is piqued and exacerbated. -It has a habit of retorting angrily, ‘Then why don’t -you go to my betters, instead of harassing <i>me</i>?’ We must -therefore beware of belauding one person while we are speaking -our minds to another—always, of course, with the exception -of his parents. Thus Agamemnon can say:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Truly, a son little like to himself hath Tydeus begotten</i>;</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> or Odysseus, when in Scyrus:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>But thou o’ersham’st the brilliance of thy race,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Wool-spinner! thou, whose sire was Greece’s hero!</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_236'>236</span>By no means should we use reproof to answer reproof, or -plain-speaking in counter-attack to plain-speaking. Otherwise -we quickly produce heat and create a quarrel. Moreover, such -disputatiousness is naturally regarded, not as a return of candour, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> but as intolerance of it. It is better, therefore, to listen with -a good grace when a friend believes he is reproving you. For -this, if at a later time some offence of his own calls for reprobation, -is the very thing which gives your plain-speaking its -right—as it were—to speak. When, without bearing any -grudge, you remind him that it has not been his own habit to -let his friends go wrong, but to teach them better and set them -right, he will be the more ready to give in and accept the -proffered correction; for he will believe that it is good feeling -and good intention, not anger and fault-finding, which prompt -this payment in return.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>73<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> In the next place, remember the saying of Thucydides: ‘Well -advised is he who accepts unpopularity in a great cause.’ It is -the duty of a friend to accept the odium of reproof when -questions of great moment are at stake. But if he is everywhere -and always being displeased; if he behaves to his intimates -as if he were their tutor and not their friend, his reproofs will -possess no edge and produce no effect when it comes to matters -of importance. He will have frittered away his candour, after -the manner of a physician who takes a pungent or bitter drug -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> of a sovereign and costly character, and parcels it out in a large -number of petty doses for which there is no necessity. No! -while a friend will, for his own part, carefully avoid such -unremitting censoriousness, the incessant niggling and pettifogging -of some other person will afford him an opening to -attack those faults which are more serious. Once when a man -with an ulcerated liver showed the physician Philotimus a sore -on his finger, the doctor observed, ‘My good sir, your case is -not a matter of a whitlow!’ So when some one is finding fault -<span class='pageno' id='Page_237'>237</span>with a number of insignificant peccadilloes, the real friend will -be offered the opportunity of saying to him, ‘What have his -tippling and foolery to do with us? My good sir, let our friend -here dismiss his mistress or stop dicing, and he is otherwise -an admirable fellow.’ If a man finds that allowance is made <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for his trifling errors, he will take it in good part when a friend -speaks his mind against those which are of more moment. But -to be everlastingly girding, to be bitter and harsh on all occasions, -to be continually meddling and taking cognisance of -every action, is intolerable even to a child or a brother, nay, -unendurable even to a slave.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Again, it is no more true of the folly of our friends than it is—despite -Euripides—of old age, that</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>All things are wrong with it.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Our friends have their right actions, and we should keep an -eye upon these no less than upon their errors. We should, -in fact, begin by zealously praising them. In dealing with iron -we have first to soften it with heat before the chilling process <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -can impart to it the consistency and hardness of steel. So with -our friends. First we warm and fuse them with praise; then -a quiet application of candour serves as a tempering douche. -We have, for instance, the opportunity of saying, ‘Is there any -comparison between the other conduct and this? Do you see -what good fruit comes of doing the right thing? This is what -your friends expect of you; it is like you, and what nature -meant you for. The other conduct is abominable; away -with it</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>To the mountain or to the wave of the surging tumultuous ocean!</i>‘</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>A sensible physician will always rather cure a sick man with -sleep and feeding than with castor and scammony; and a right-minded -friend, or a kind father or teacher, prefers to use praise <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -rather than blame as his means of moral correction. For a candid -<span class='pageno' id='Page_238'>238</span>friend to cause least pain and work most benefit, there is nothing -like showing the least possible anger and treating the offender -with polite good feeling. We must not, therefore, sharply -confute him if he denies a thing, nor try to stop him if he defends -himself. On the contrary, we must help him to contrive some -kind of plausible excuse; and, when he refuses to own to the -more discreditable motive, we must ourselves concede him a less -heinous one. Thus Hector says to his brother:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Not well is this wrath, foolish man, that thus thou hast stored in thy bosom</i>,</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> as if his retirement from the battle, instead of being a dastardly -running away, was an exhibition of temper. So Nestor to -Agamemnon:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Thou didst yield to the pride of thy spirit.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>It is manifestly more courteous to say, ‘You did not stop to -think,’ or, ‘You failed to perceive,’ than ‘You behaved badly’, -or ‘You behaved unfairly’; to say, ‘Do not be hard upon -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>74<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> your brother,’ than ‘Do not be jealous of your brother’; to -say, ‘Flee from the woman’s seductions,’ than ‘Stop trying to -seduce the woman’. This is the manner cultivated by curative -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> candour; the other belongs to vexatious candour.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Suppose a person is about to do wrong and that we are called -upon to check him—to stem the current of some vehement -impulse. Or suppose that he is inclined to be unready in the -performance of duty, and we wish to brace him up and stimulate -him. We should do so by making charges which put the matter -in an outrageously unbecoming light. For instance, in Sophocles, -when Odysseus is working upon Achilles, he makes out, not that -Achilles is angry at the affair of the banquet, but <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Now that thou hast the Trojan burghs in sight,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Thou art afraid.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_239'>239</span>And when, in answer to this, Achilles is so enraged that he -declares he is off home:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>I know what ’tis thou flyest—not reproach:</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Hector is nigh, and ’tis not well to stay.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>In inciting to high courses and dissuading from low ones, we -may frighten a man with the reputation he will win: a man -of courage and spirit with that of coward; a man of temperance -and self-control with that of profligate; a man of magnificent -generosity with that of miser and cheeseparer. Where a thing -is past cure, we must show ourselves reasonable; our candour <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -must display more sorrow and sympathy than blame. But when -we are preventing a misdeed or fighting against a passion, we -must be vigorous, inflexible, and insistent. Then is the right -moment for incorruptible affection and genuine frankness.</p> - -<p class='c005'>To blame an action when it is done is no more than we find -enemies doing to each other. Diogenes used to say that, if -you are to be kept right, you must possess either good friends -or red-hot enemies. The one will warn you, the other will -expose you. But it is better to avoid errors by taking advice -than to repent of an error because of abuse. For this reason <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -we must study tact even in the matter of candour. As it is -the most effective drug that can be employed in friendship, -so it stands in most need of unfailing discretion as to time and -moderation as to strength.</p> - -<p class='c005'>And, finally, since, as I have said, it is in the nature of plain-speaking -that it should often cause pain to the person under -treatment, we must take a pattern by the medical man. He -does not use his lancet and then leave the part to suffer; he eases -it with gentle lotions and fomentations. Similarly, if our -admonitions are to be tactful, we do not administer a sharp -sting and then run away. We adopt a different strain, and soothe <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -and calm the patient with courteous language, much as sculptors -<span class='pageno' id='Page_240'>240</span>put smoothness and gloss upon a statue where they have chipped -it with hammer and chisel. If we strike and gash a man with -plain-speaking and then leave him in the rough—lumpy and -uneven with anger—it is a hard matter afterwards to call him -back and smooth him over. This, therefore, is a result against -which the admonisher must be especially on his guard. He must -not leave the patient too soon, nor allow the last words of his -conversation to be such as pain and exasperate his intimate -friend.</p> - -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_241'>241</span> - <h2 id='chap09' class='c003'>ON BRINGING UP A BOY<a id='r55' /><a href='#f55' class='c009'><sup>[55]</sup></a></h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'>I propose to offer some remarks upon the bringing-up of <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>1<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -free-born children, as a means of securing soundness of character.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Perhaps the best starting-point is that at which they are -brought into existence.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Upon one who desires to become the father of reputable <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -children I would urge that he should be careful as to his consort. -She must be no mistress or concubine. Base birth, whether on -mother’s or father’s side, is an indelible reproach. It sticks to -a man all the days of his life; it offers a handle to those who are -minded to discredit or vilify him; and it is a wise saying of -the poet that</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>When the foundation of a stock is laid</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Amiss, needs must the issue be unhappy</i>.</div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>A sure fund of confidence for facing the world lies therefore in -honourable birth, and this must be a first consideration with all -who are anxious for a right and proper procreation of children.</p> - -<p class='c005'>It is quite natural that those whose birth is of base metal -which will not bear scrutiny should tend to be weak-spirited -and abject. The poet is quite right in saying: <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>It slaves a man, stout-hearted though he be,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>To know his mother or his father base.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>It is no doubt equally the case that persons of distinguished -parentage become full of pride and self-assertion. Thus -Themistocles’ son, Diophantus, is reported to have said on many -occasions and to many persons that he had only to wish for -a thing and the Athenian people voted for it. ‘What he liked, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_242'>242</span><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> his mother liked; what his mother liked, Themistocles liked; -and what Themistocles liked, all Athens liked.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>A most praiseworthy pride was that exhibited by the Lacedaemonians, -when they mulcted their own king Archidamus for -condescending to marry a woman of small stature, their plea -being that he intended to provide them with kinglets instead -of kings.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In this connexion there is one observation which my predecessors -also have duly made. It is that those who approach their -wives with a view to offspring should do so either while wholly -abstaining from wine or at least after tasting it in moderation. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>2<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> This explains the remark of Diogenes on seeing a youth in a state -of mad excitement: ‘Young fellow, your father begat you when -he was drunk.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>So much for the question of birth. We will now turn to that -of upbringing.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Speaking generally, we must say of virtue what it is customary -to say of the arts and sciences—that for right action three -things must go together, namely, nature, reason, and habit. -By reason I mean instruction; by habit I mean exercise. The -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> first elements come from nature; progress, from instruction; -the actual use, from practice; the consummation, from all -combined. In so far as any of these is defective, character must -necessarily be maimed. Nature without instruction is blind; -instruction without nature is futile; practice without both is -abortive. In farming, the soil must first be good; next, the farmer -must know his business; third, the seeds must be sound. Similarly -with education. Nature is the soil, the teacher is the farmer, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the lessons and precepts are the seed. It may be confidently -asserted that all three were harmoniously blended in the souls -of those men whose renown is universal—Pythagoras, Socrates, -Plato, and others who have won imperishable glory.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Blest indeed, and divinely favoured, is the man on whom -<span class='pageno' id='Page_243'>243</span>Heaven has bestowed each and all. Yet it would be a great, -or rather a total, mistake to suppose that, when natural gift -is defective, no right moral instruction and practice will lead -one to improve his faulty nature in some attainable degree. -For while neglect will ruin an excellent natural gift, teaching -will correct an inferior one. Be careless, and you miss a thing, -however easy: take pains, and you secure it, however difficult. -You have only to glance at a number of everyday facts in order <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -to perceive how complete is the success of persistent effort. -Drops of water will hollow a rock; iron and bronze are worn -away by the touch of the hands; wood bent by pressure into -a carriage-wheel can never recover its original straightness. -To straighten the curved sticks used by actors is impossible, the -unnatural form having become, by dint of straining, stronger -than the natural.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Nor are these the only examples to prove the efficacy of -painstaking. Instances are countless. Soil may be naturally <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -good; but neglect it, and it becomes a waste. Indeed, the better -it is by nature, the more hopeless a wilderness will your neglect -make of it. On the other hand, it may be too hard and rugged; -yet cultivation will speedily cause it to produce excellent crops. -Is there any tree which will not grow crooked and cease to bear -fruit if left untended, whereas, when properly trained, it bears -well and brings its fruit to perfection? Does not bodily strength -invariably become effete when you take your ease and neglect -to keep in good condition, whereas a feeble physique gains -immensely in strength through gymnastic and athletic exercise? -Is there any horse which a rider cannot render obedient by <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -a thorough breaking-in, whereas, if left unbroken, it will prove -stiff-necked and full of temper?</p> - -<p class='c005'>But why dwell longer on such cases, when there are so many -examples of the most savage creatures being tamed and made -amenable to hard work?</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_244'>244</span>When a Thessalian was asked which of his countrymen were -the gentlest in manner, his answer was a good one: <i>Those who -are giving up war.</i> But it is useless to multiply instances. -Character is long-standing habit, and it would scarcely be beside -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>3<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the mark to speak of the virtues of the mind as the virtues -‘of minding’.<a id='r56' /><a href='#f56' class='c009'><sup>[56]</sup></a> One more illustration, and we will dispense -with further elaboration of the subject. The Spartan legislator -Lycurgus once took two puppies belonging to the same parents -and brought them up in entirely different ways. The one he -turned into a gluttonous good-for-nothing, the other into -a keen and capable hunting-dog. Subsequently he got the -Lacedaemonians together and said to them: ‘A great factor -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> in engendering virtue consists of habit and education—of -instruction in the conduct of life—as I am about to prove to -you here and now.’ He then brought forward the two young -dogs, put down directly in front of them a plate of food and a -hare, and let the dogs loose; whereupon the one darted after -the hare, while the other made for the plate. The Lacedaemonians, -who were not yet in the secret, failed to perceive the -meaning of his demonstration, until he told them: ‘Both these -dogs come from the same parents, but the difference in their -education has turned the one into a glutton and the other into -a hunter.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>No more need be said of habit and conduct of life. We may -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> proceed to the question of nurture.</p> - -<p class='c005'>In my opinion mothers should nurse their own children and -offer them the breast; for their nursing will be of a more -sympathetic and painstaking kind, since their love is from the -heart, or, as the saying goes, ‘down to the finger-tips,’ whereas -the affection of professional nurses and foster-mothers—who -are paid for it—can only be spurious and factitious. That -<span class='pageno' id='Page_245'>245</span>it is the duty of the mother herself to suckle and nurse her -offspring is evident from the arrangement of nature, which has -supplied every animal after parturition with the necessary -provision of milk. Here Providence further shows its wisdom, -inasmuch as it has furnished a woman with a pair of breasts, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -so that, even if she bears twins, there may be a double source for -them to draw upon. Moreover she will by so acting become more -tender and affectionate to her child. It can, indeed, scarcely be -otherwise; the connexion of nurse and nursling is the means -of raising affection to its highest pitch. One can see how even -a brute beast will yearn for its nursling, if you tear them apart.</p> - -<p class='c005'>If possible, then, the mother should endeavour to nurse the -child herself. But if—as may sometimes happen—she is prevented -by physical weakness, or if other children are speedily -on the way, it is at least desirable not to accept as foster-mother -or nurse the first that offers, but to choose the best possible. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -To begin with, her character should be Greek. It is as with -the treatment of the body. As soon as children are born, we -have to mould their limbs in order that they may grow straight -and shapely. Similarly their characters ought to be regulated -from the first. For youth is supple and plastic, and it is while -the mind is still soft and yielding that it acts as a mould for -instruction, whereas it is always difficult to knead into shape <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -anything hard. As it is in soft wax that we make the impression -of a seal, so it is in the minds of those who are still little children -that we imprint a lesson.</p> - -<p class='c005'>That great thinker Plato is right, it seems to me, in exhorting -a nurse to use discretion in the tales she tells to young children; -otherwise their minds may become infected from the first with -folly and corruption. It is also sound advice which the poet -Phocylides gives in the words:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line in10'><i>While yet but a child, it behoveth</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>To learn such deeds as are good.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'><span class='pageno' id='Page_246'>246</span>Another point which we cannot afford to omit concerns the -slave children who are to serve the young master and to be -brought up with him. Pains must be taken, first, of course, that -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>4<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> they shall be well-behaved, but also that they shall talk Greek, -and talk it with good articulation. Otherwise, through rubbing -against barbarians and bad characters, he will pick up something -of their vices. The proverb-makers have good reason -for saying: <i>If you have a lame man for a neighbour, you will -learn to limp.</i></p> - -<p class='c005'>When children reach the age to be put under a mentor, it -becomes especially necessary to take pains in the appointment -of such a person. Otherwise we shall have them entrusted to -some uncivilized or rascally fellow. What actually happens -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> is often in the highest degree absurd. Respectable slaves are -made into farmers, skippers, traders, stewards, or money-lenders, -while any low specimen who is found to be a glutton and a tippler -and of no use in any kind of business is taken and put in charge -of the sons. A fit and proper attendant should possess the same -qualities of mind as Phoenix, the attendant of Achilles.</p> - -<p class='c005'>We now reach a topic more important and vital than any -yet treated—that of the right teachers for our children. The -kind to be sought for are those whose lives are irreproachable, -whose characters are unimpugned, and whose skill and experience -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> are of the best. The root or fountain-head of character as -a man and a gentleman lies in receiving the proper education. -As farmers put stakes beside their plants, so the right kind of -teacher provides firm support for the young in the shape of -lessons and admonitions, carefully chosen so as to produce an -upright growth of character.</p> - -<p class='c005'>As things are, the behaviour of some fathers is contemptible. -Before making inquiry as to the proposed teachers, they put -their children into the hands of frauds and charlatans, without -knowing what they are about, or, maybe, because they are not -<span class='pageno' id='Page_247'>247</span>competent to judge. In the latter case their behaviour is not -so ridiculous, but there is another case in which it is in the last -degree absurd. I mean, when they know, either from their own <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -observation or from the accounts of others, how ignorant and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -bad certain educators are, and yet entrust their children to -them. Sometimes this is because they cannot resist the fawning -of some obsequious flatterer; sometimes it is done to gratify -the whim of a friend. It would be just as reasonable for a sick -man to gratify a friend by rejecting the doctor whose science -could save him, and preferring the ignoramus who will kill -him; or for a man to dismiss the best ship’s-captain and appoint -the worst, because a friend asked for it. In the name of all -that is sacred, can any one called a ‘father’ set the pleasing of <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -somebody who asks a favour above the education of his children? -There was good sense in a frequent saying of famous old Socrates, -‘If it could be done, one ought to mount the loftiest part of the -city and shout: <i>Good people, what are you after? Why in such -deadly earnest about making money, while troubling so little about -the sons to whom you are to leave it?</i>’ We may add that the conduct -of such fathers is like that of a man who is anxious as to -his shoe, while his foot may look after itself. Many fathers -go to such lengths in the way of fondness for their money and <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -want of fondness for their children, that, to avoid paying -a larger fee, they choose utterly worthless persons to educate -their sons, their object being an inexpensive ignorance. This -reminds one of Aristippus and his neat and witty repartee to -a foolish father. Questioned as to what fee he asked for educating -the child, he replied, ‘Forty pounds.’ ‘Good heavens!’ said -the father: ‘What an extravagant demand! For forty pounds -I can buy a slave.’ ‘Very well,’ was the answer: ‘then you <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>5<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -will have two slaves—your son, and the one you buy.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>To put it shortly, it is surely absurd to train little children -to receive their food with the right hand, and to scold them -<span class='pageno' id='Page_248'>248</span>if they put out the left, and yet to take no precautions that they -shall be taught moral lessons of a sound and proper kind.</p> - -<p class='c005'>What the consequence is to these admirable fathers, when they -bring up their sons badly and educate them badly, is soon told. -On coming of age and taking rank as men, the sons show an -utter disregard of a wholesome and orderly life, and throw -themselves headlong into low and irregular pleasures. Then -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> at last, when it is of no use, and when their wrongdoing has -brought him to his wits’ end, the father repents of having -sacrificed his children’s education. Some of them take up with -toadies and parasites, wretched nondescripts who are the ruin -and bane of youth; others with haughty and expensive mistresses -and strumpets, whom they ransom from their employers. -Some spend recklessly on gormandizing; some are wrecked upon -dice and carousals; some go so far as to venture on the more daring -vices—they commit adultery, and think death not too much -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> to pay for a single pleasure. Had these last studied philosophy, -they would in all probability not have succumbed to temptation -of this kind. They would have been told of the advice of -Diogenes—who, however coarse in his language, is right in his -facts—‘Go to a brothel, my boy, and you will find that the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> expensive article is not a bit better than the cheap one.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>In brief, then, I assert—and it would be fairer to regard me -as repeating an oracle than as giving advice—that in these -matters the one and essential thing, the first, middle, and last, -is a sound upbringing and right education. It is this, I say, -which leads to virtue and happiness.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Other blessings are on the human plane; they are slight and -not worth serious pursuit. Good birth is a distinction, but -the boon depends on one’s ancestors. Wealth is a prize, but its -possession depends on fortune, which often carries it off from -those who have it and bestows it on those who never hoped -for it. Moreover, great wealth is a target exposed to any rogue -<span class='pageno' id='Page_249'>249</span>of a servant or blackmailer who is minded to ‘aim a purse’ at it. -And, worst of all, even the basest of men have their share -of it. Fame, again, is imposing, but uncertain. Beauty, though -greatly courted, is short-lived; health, though highly prized, -is unstable; strength is a thing to be envied, but it falls an easy -prey to disease and age. Let us tell any one who prides himself <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -on his bodily strength that he is manifestly under a delusion. -How small a fraction is human strength of the might of other -animals, such as the elephant, the bull, and the lion!</p> - -<p class='c005'>Meanwhile culture is the only thing in us that is immortal -and divine. In the nature of man there are two sovereign -elements—understanding and reason. It is the place of the -understanding to direct the reason and of the reason to serve -the understanding. Fortune cannot overcome them, calumny -cannot rob us of them, disease cannot corrupt them, old age -cannot impair them. The understanding is the only thing -that renews its youth as it grows old, and, while time carries -off everything else, it brings old age one gift—that of knowledge. -When, again, war comes like a torrent, tearing and sweeping -everything away, it is of our mental culture alone that it cannot -rob us. Stilpo, the Megarian philosopher, made what seems -a memorable answer when Demetrius, after enslaving the city -and razing it to the ground, asked him if he had lost anything. -‘O no!’ said he, ‘for virtue is not made spoil of war.’ The -reply of Socrates is evidently to the same tune and purpose. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>6<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -It was Gorgias, I believe, who asked him his opinion of the Great -King, and whether he considered him happy. ‘I have no -knowledge,’ said Socrates, ‘as to the state of his character and -culture.’ He assumed that happiness depended upon these, and -not upon the gifts of fortune.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Not only should the education of our children be treated -as of the very first importance, but I once more urge that -we should insist upon its being of the sound and genuine kind. -<span class='pageno' id='Page_250'>250</span>From pretentious nonsense our sons should be kept as far aloof -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> as possible. To please the many is to displease the wise, an -assertion in which I have the support of Euripides:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>I am not deft of words before the crowd,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>More skilled when with my compeers and the few.</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>’Tis compensation: they who ‘mid the wise</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Are naught, surpass in gift of speech to mobs.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>My own observation tells me that persons who make a business -of speaking in a way to please and curry favour with the rabble, -generally prove correspondingly dissolute and pleasure-loving -in their lives. Nor, indeed, should we expect anything else; -for if they have no regard to propriety when catering for the -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> gratification of other people, it is not likely that they will permit -right and sound principles to have the upper hand of their -own voluptuous self-indulgence, nor that they will cultivate -self-control rather than enjoyment.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> And how can children learn from them anything admirable? -Among admirable things is the practice of neither saying nor -doing anything at random; and, as the proverb goes, ‘admirable -things are difficult.’ Meanwhile, speeches made offhand are -a mass of reckless slovenliness, without a notion where to begin -or where to end.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Apart from other faults, extempore speakers drop into a -terrible prolixity and verbiage, whereas premeditation keeps -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> a speech safe within the lines of due proportion. When Pericles, -‘as tradition informs us,’ was called upon by the assembly, he -frequently refused the call, on the ground that his thoughts -were ‘not arranged’. Demosthenes, who took him for his own -political model, acted in the same way. If the Athenians -called upon him to address them, he would resist, with the words, -‘I have not arranged my thoughts.’ This, it is true, may be -unauthentic and a fabrication; but in the speech against -Meidias we have an explicit statement as to the advantage of -<span class='pageno' id='Page_251'>251</span>preparation. His words are: ‘<i>I admit, gentlemen, that I come -prepared; and I have no wish to deny it. I have even conned -over my speech to the best of my poor ability. It would have been -insane conduct, if, after and amid such harsh treatment, I had -paid no regard to what I meant to say to you on the subject.</i>’</p> - -<p class='c005'>That impromptu speaking should be rejected altogether, or, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -failing this, that it should be practised only on unimportant -subjects, I do not say. I am recommending a tonic regimen. -Before manhood, I claim that there should be no speaking on the -spur of the moment. But when the ability has taken firm root, -it is only right for speech to enjoy free play as occasion invites. -Though persons who have been in prison for a long time may -subsequently be liberated, they are unsteady on their feet, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -a protracted habit of wearing chains making them unable to -step out. Similarly if those who have for a long time kept their -speaking under close constraint some day find it necessary to -speak offhand, they nevertheless retain the same style of expression. -But to let mere children make extempore speeches is -to become responsible for the worst of twaddle and futility. -There is a story of a wretched painter who showed Apelles -a picture, with the remark, ‘I have just painted this at one <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>7<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -sitting.’ ‘I can see,’ said Apelles, ‘without your telling me, -that it has been quick work. But my wonder is that you haven’t -painted more than one as good.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>While (to return to the original matter in hand) we must -be careful to avoid a style which is theatrical and bombastic, -we must be equally on our guard against one which is low and -trivial. If the turgid style is unbusinesslike, too thin a style is -ineffective. Just as the body should be not only healthy but -also in good condition, so language must be full of strength <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -and not simply free from disease. Keep on the safe side, and you -are merely commended: face some risk, and you are admired. -I take the same view of the mental disposition also. One should -<span class='pageno' id='Page_252'>252</span>neither be over-bold, and so become brazen, nor yet timid and -bashful, and so become mean-spirited. The rule of art and taste -is <i>The middle course in all things</i>.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> While I am still upon the subject of this part of education -there is an opinion which I desire to express. A style consisting -of single clauses I regard in the first instance as no slight evidence -of poor taste, and, in the next, as too finical a thing ever to -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> be maintained in practice. Here, as in everything else that -caters for ear or eye, monotony is as cloying and irksome as -variety is delightful.</p> - -<p class='c005'>There is no subject in the ‘regular curriculum’ of which -the eye or ear of a freeborn boy should be permitted to remain -uninformed. But while he receives a cursory education in those -subjects in order to taste their quality, the most important -place—complete all-round proficiency being impossible—must -belong to philosophy. We may explain by a comparison with -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> travel, in which it is an excellent thing to visit a large number -of cities, but good policy to settle in the best. As the philosopher -Bion wittily remarked, when the suitors could obtain no access -to Penelope they satisfied themselves with her handmaids, and -when a man is unable to get hold of philosophy he makes dry -bones of himself upon the remaining subjects, which are of no -account.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Philosophy, then, should be put at the head of all mental -culture. The services which have been invented for the care -of the body are two—medicine and gymnastics—the one -imparting health, the other good condition. But for the -weaknesses and ailments of the soul philosophy is the only thing -to be prescribed. It is from and with philosophy that we can -tell what is becoming or disgraceful, what is just or unjust, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> what course, in short, is to be chosen or shunned. It teaches -us how to behave towards the Gods, our parents, our elders, -the laws, our rulers, friends, wives, children, and servants: that -<span class='pageno' id='Page_253'>253</span>we should worship the Gods, honour our parents, respect our -elders, obey the laws, give way to our rulers, love our friends, -be continent towards our wives, show affection to our children, -and abstain from cruelty to our slaves. Above all, it warns us -against excess of joy when prosperous and excess of grief when -unfortunate; against dissoluteness in our pleasures, or fury -and brutality in our anger. These I judge to be chief among <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -the blessings conferred by philosophy. To bear adversity nobly -is to act the brave man,<a id='r57' /><a href='#f57' class='c009'><sup>[57]</sup></a> to bear prosperity unassumingly, the <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -modest mortal. To get the better of pleasures by reason needs -wisdom; to master anger requires no ordinary character.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Perfect men I take to be those who can blend practical ability <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>8<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -with philosophy, and who can achieve both of two best and -greatest ends—the life of public utility as men of affairs, and -the calm and tranquil life as students of philosophy. For there -are three kinds of life: the life of action, the life of thought, -and the life of enjoyment. When life is dissolute and enslaved -to pleasure, it is mean and animal; when it is all thought and -fails to act, it is futile; when it is all action and destitute of -philosophy, it is crude and blundering. We should therefore -do our best to engage both in public business and in the pursuit <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -of philosophy, as occasion offers. Of this kind was the public -career of Pericles, of Archytas of Tarentum, of Dion of Syracuse, -and of Epaminondas of Thebes. Of these Dion actually attached -himself to Plato as his pupil.</p> - -<p class='c005'>There is no need, I think, to deal at any greater length with -mental cultivation. It is, however, further desirable—or rather -it is essential—that we should not neglect to possess the standard -treatises, but should collect a stock of them, with the result -of keeping our knowledge from starvation.<a id='r58' /><a href='#f58' class='c009'><sup>[58]</sup></a> Farmers stock <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -<span class='pageno' id='Page_254'>254</span>[their fertilizers], and the employment of books is instrumental -to culture in the same way.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Meanwhile we must not omit to exercise the body also. Our -boys must be sent to the teacher of gymnastics and receive -a sufficient amount of physical training, both to secure a good -carriage and also to develop strength. Good condition is the -foundation laid in childhood for a hale old age, and, just as our -preparations for wintry weather should be made while it is -fine, so we should store up provision for age in the shape of -regular and temperate behaviour in youth. Physical exertion -should, however, be so regulated that a boy does not become -too exhausted to devote himself sufficiently to mental culture. -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> As Plato observes, sleep and weariness are the enemies of -study.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Upon this topic I need not dwell, but will pass on at once -to the most important consideration of all—the necessity of -training a boy for service as a fighting-man. For this he must -go through hard drill in hurling the javelin, in shooting with the -bow, and in hunting. ‘The goods of the vanquished,’ it has -been said, ‘are prizes offered to the victor.’ There is no place -in war for the physical condition of the cloister, and a lean -soldier accustomed to warlike exercises will break through -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> a phalanx of fleshy prize-fighters.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> ‘Well but,’ some one may urge, ‘while you promised us a set -of rules for the upbringing of free men, it turns out that you -have nothing to say concerning that of poor and common people, -but are satisfied to confine your suggestions to the rich.’ There -is a ready reply to the objection. If possible, I should desire -the proposed education to be applicable to all alike. But if -there are cases in which limited private circumstances make it -impossible to carry my rules into practice, the blame should -be laid upon fortune, not upon him who offers the advice. -Though a man is poor, he should make every possible effort -<span class='pageno' id='Page_255'>255</span>to bring up his children in the ideal way. Failing this, he must -come as near to it as he can.</p> - -<p class='c005'>After thus encumbering our discussion with this side-issue, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -I will now proceed with the connected account of such other <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -matters as contribute to the right upbringing of the young.</p> - -<p class='c005'>And first, children should be led into right practices of -persuasion and reasoning: flogging and bodily injury should -be out of the question. Such treatment is surely more fit for -slaves than for the free, whom the smart, or even the humiliation, -of a beating deprives of all life and spirit, making their tasks -a horror to them. The freeborn find praise a more effective <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>9<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -stimulus to the right conduct, and blame a more effective -deterrent from the wrong, than any kind of bodily assault. In -the use of such praise and reprimand there should be a subtle -alternation. When a child is too bold, it should first be shamed -by reproof and then encouraged by a word of praise. We may -take a pattern by nurses, who may have to make an infant cry, -but who afterwards comfort it by offering it the breast. We -must, however, avoid puffing children up with eulogies, the -consequence of excessive praise being vanity and conceit.</p> - -<p class='c005'>I have noticed more than one instance in which the over-fondness <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -of a father has proved to be a lack of fondness. To -make my meaning clear, I will use an illustration. Being in too -great haste for their children to take first place in everything, -they impose extravagant tasks, which prove too great for their -strength and end in failure, besides causing them such weariness -and distress that they refuse to submit patiently to instruction. -Water in moderation will make a plant grow, while a flood of -water will choke it. In the same way the mind will thrive under <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -reasonably hard work, but will drown if the work is excessive. -We must therefore allow children breathing-time from perpetual -tasks, and remember that all our life there is a division of -relaxation and effort. Hence the existence of sleep as well as -<span class='pageno' id='Page_256'>256</span>waking, of peace as well as war, of fine weather as well as bad, -of holidays as well as business. In a word, it is rest that seasons -toil. The fact is obvious, not merely in the case of living things, -but in that of the inanimate world. We loosen a bow or a lyre, -so that we may be able to tighten it. In fine, the body is kept -sound by want and its satisfaction, the mind by relaxation and -labour.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> There are some fathers who have a culpable way of entrusting -their sons to attendants and teachers, and then entirely omitting -to keep the instruction of such persons under their own eye or -ear. This is a most serious failure in their duty. Every few days -they should personally examine their children, instead of confiding -in the character of a hireling, whose attention to his -pupils will be more conscientious if he is to be brought continually -to book. In this connexion there is aptness in the -groom’s dictum that <i>nothing is so fattening to a horse as the eye -of the king</i>.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> Above all things one should train and exercise a child’s -memory. Memory serves as the storehouse of culture, and hence -the fable that Recollection is the mother of the Muses—an -indirect way of saying that memory is the best thing in the world -to beget and foster wisdom. Whether children are naturally -gifted with a good memory, or, on the contrary, are naturally -forgetful, the memory should be trained in either case. The -natural advantage will be strengthened, or the natural shortcoming -made up. The former class will excel others, the latter -will excel themselves. As Hesiod well puts it: <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>If to the thing that is little you further add but a little,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>And do the same oft and again, full soon it becometh a great thing.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>This, then, is another fact for fathers to recognize—that the -mnemonic element in education plays a most important part, -not only in culture, but also in the business of life, inasmuch -<span class='pageno' id='Page_257'>257</span>as the recollection of past experience serves as a guide to wise -policy for the future.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Our sons must also be kept from the use of foul language. -‘The word,’ says Democritus, ‘is the shadow of the deed.’ -More than that, we must render them polite and courteous, <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>10<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for there is nothing so detestable as a boorish character. One -way in which children may avoid becoming disagreeable to their -company is by refraining from absolute stubbornness in discussion. -Credit is to be gained not merely by victory, but -also by knowing how to accept defeat where victory is harmful. -There is unquestionably such a thing as a ‘Cadmean -victory’. <i>À propos</i> I may quote the testimony of that wise -poet Euripides: <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>When two men speak, and one is full of anger,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Wiser the one who strives not to reply.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>This is the time to remember certain other habits quite as -necessary—and more so—for the young to cultivate as any yet -mentioned. These are modesty of behaviour, restraint of the -tongue, mastery of the temper, and control of the hands. Let -us see how important each of them is. We may take an illustration -to bring home the notion more clearly. And we will begin -with the last. There have been those who, by lowering their -hands to ill-gotten gains, have thrown away all the reputation -won by their previous career. This was the case with the -Lacedaemonian, Gylippus, who was driven into exile from Sparta <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for secretly broaching the money-bags. Absence of anger, again, -is a quality of wisdom. Socrates once received a kick from a very -impudent and gross young buffoon, but on seeing that his own -friends were in such a violent state of indignation that they -wanted to prosecute him, he remarked: ‘If a donkey had kicked -me, would you have condescended to kick him back?’ The -fellow did not, however, get off scot-free, but finding himself -<span class='pageno' id='Page_258'>258</span>universally reproached and nicknamed ‘Kicker’, he hanged -himself. When Aristophanes brought out the <i>Clouds</i>, and poured -all manner of abuse upon Socrates, one of those present asked: -‘Pray, are you not indignant at his ridiculing you in this manner?’ -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> ‘Not I, indeed,’ replied Socrates; ‘this banter in the theatre -is only in a big convivial party.’ A close counterpart of this -attitude will be found in the behaviour of Plato and of Archytas -of Tarentum. When the latter, on his return from the war in -which he had held command, found that his land had gone -out of cultivation, he summoned his manager and remarked: -‘You would have suffered for this, if I had not been too angry.’ -When Plato, again, was once worked into a passion with a greedy -and impudent slave, he called his sister’s son Speusippus and -said, ‘Go and give this fellow a thrashing: I am myself in a great -passion.’</p> - -<p class='c005'>But, it may be argued, it is difficult to reach so high a standard -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> as this. I am well aware of it. We can therefore only do our -best to take a pattern by such conduct, and minimize any -tendency to ungovernable rage. As in other matters, we are -no match for either the moral mastery or the finished character -of those great models. Nevertheless we may act towards them -as we might towards the Gods, serving as hierophants and torch-bearers -of their wisdom and endeavouring to imitate in our -nibbling way as much as lies in our power.</p> - -<p class='c005'>As for the control of the tongue—the remaining point to be -considered according to our promise—any one who regards it -as of trivial moment is very much in the wrong. In a timely -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> silence there is a wisdom superior to any speech. It is apparently -for this reason that men in old times invented our mystic rites -and ceremonies. The notion was that, through being trained -to silence in connexion with these, we should secure the keeping -of human secrets by carrying into them the same religious fear. -Moreover, though multitudes have repented of talking, no man -<span class='pageno' id='Page_259'>259</span>has repented of silence, and while it is easy to utter what -has been kept back, it is impossible to recall what has been -uttered.</p> - -<p class='c005'>My own reading affords countless instances of the greatest -disasters resulting from an ungoverned tongue. I will content <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>11<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -myself with mentioning one or two typical examples. When, -upon the marriage of Philadelphus with his sister, Sotades composed -a scurrilous verse, he paid ample atonement for talking -out of season by rotting for a long time in prison. He thus -purchased a laugh in others by long weeping of his own. The <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -story is closely matched by that of the sophist Theocritus, who -endured similar, but much more terrible, consequences for a -similar remark. Alexander had ordered the Greeks to provide -a stock of purple garments, with a view to the thanksgiving <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -sacrifice on his return from his Persian victories, and the various -peoples were contributing at so much per head. Hereupon -Theocritus observed: ‘I have now become clear upon a point -which used to puzzle me. This is what is meant by Homer’s -“purple death”‘—words which earned him the enmity of Alexander. -Antigonus, the Macedonian king, had but one eye, and -Theocritus made him excessively angry by a taunt at this disfigurement. -Eutropion, the chief cook, who had become a -person of importance, was sent to him by the king with a request -that he would come to court and engage him in argument. On -receiving repeated visits from Eutropion with this message, he <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -remarked, ‘I am well aware that you want to dish me up raw -to the Cyclops,’ thus twitting the one with being disfigured, -the other with being a cook. ‘Then,’ replied Eutropion, ‘it will -be without your head, for you shall be punished for such mad -and reckless language.’ Thereupon he reported the words to -the king, who sent and put Theocritus to death.</p> - -<p class='c005'>The last and most sacred requirement is that children should -be trained to speak the truth. Lying is a servile habit; it -<span class='pageno' id='Page_260'>260</span>deserves universal detestation and is unpardonable even in -a decent slave.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> So far I have had no doubt or hesitation in what I have said -of the modesty and good behaviour of children. But upon the -matter which now calls for mention I am dubious and undecided, -my judgement swaying in the balance first one way and then the -other, without finding it possible to turn the scale in either -direction. It concerns a practice which I can neither recommend -nor discountenance without great reluctance. Nevertheless one -must venture a word upon it. The question is whether a man -who is enamoured of a boy is to be allowed to keep intimate -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> company with him, or whether, on the contrary, association -with such a person is to be tabooed. When I look at fathers -whose disposition is uncompromisingly harsh and austere, and -who regard such association as an intolerable insult to their -children, I have many scruples in recommending it or speaking -in its favour. When, on the other hand, I think of Socrates, -Plato, Xenophon, Aeschines, Cebes, and all those great men -who have with one accord approved of love between males, while -they have led youths on to culture, to public leadership, and to -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> a virtuous character, I change my mind and am inclined to -copy those great exemplars. Euripides is on their side, when he -says:</p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>Nay, men may feel passion of other sort,</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Love of a just, chaste, virtuous mind and soul.</i></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>Nor must we omit the saying of Plato, partly serious and partly -humorous, that those who have shown special excellence should -have the right to kiss any beautiful person they choose. The -proper course is to drive away those who are enamoured of the -person, but, generally speaking, give a sanction to those who are -in love with the mind and soul. While we must have nothing -to say to the connexions in vogue at Thebes or in Elis, or to the -<span class='pageno' id='Page_261'>261</span>so-called ‘abduction’ of Crete, we may well imitate that kind <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>12<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -which is usual at Athens or in Lacedaemon.</p> - -<p class='c005'>On this matter it is for every man to hold such convictions -as he has formed for himself. I will now leave it, and, having -spoken of the discipline and good behaviour of the boy, will -pass on to deal with the age of adolescence. I shall do so in very -few words, for I have often expressed my disapproval of those -who encourage vicious habits by proposing to put a boy under -the charge of tutors and teachers, whereas, with a stripling, they -would permit his inclinations to range at will. As a matter of <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -fact, there is need of more anxious precautions in the case of -the stripling than in that of the boy. Every one is aware that -the faults committed by a boy are small matters, which can be -cured without difficulty—such as paying no heed to his tutor, -or trickery and inattention in school. But the sins of adolescence -often reach a flagrant and shocking pitch—stealing the father’s -money, gormandizing, dicing, roistering, drinking, loose passion -for young girls, or corruption of married women. The propensities -of young manhood ought therefore to be carefully -watched and kept closely under the chain. When capacity for <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -pleasure is at its prime, it rejects control, kicks over the traces, -and requires the curb. If therefore we do not take a firm hold -upon this time of life, we are giving folly a licence to sin. This -is the moment when wise fathers should be most watchful and -alert; when they should bring their lads within bounds by -warnings, threats, or entreaties, and by pointing out instances -of disaster caused by devotion to pleasure, and of praise and -good repute won by continence. These two things form what -may be called first principles of virtue, namely, hope of honour -and fear of punishment, the one producing a greater eagerness <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -for the noblest pursuits, the other a shrinking from bad actions.</p> - -<p class='c005'>One general rule of duty is to keep boys from associating with -vicious persons; otherwise they will pick up something of their -<span class='pageno' id='Page_262'>262</span>vice. This has been urged by Pythagoras among a number -of dark sayings. Since these also possess great value as aids to -the attainment of virtue, I will proceed to quote them, adding -their explanation. <i>Do not taste black-tails</i><a id='r59' /><a href='#f59' class='c009'><sup>[59]</sup></a>—keep no company -with persons who are malignant and therefore ‘black’. <i>Do not -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> step over a beam</i>—justice must be scrupulously respected and -not ‘overstepped’. <i>Do not sit on a quart-measure</i>—beware of -idleness, and see to the providing of daily bread. <i>Do not clasp -hands with every man</i>—we should form no sudden connexions. -<i>Do not wear a tight ring</i>—one should carry out the practice of -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> life, and not fasten it to any chain. <i>Do not poke a fire with iron</i>—do -not irritate a wrathful man (the right course being to let -angry men go their own way). <i>Do not eat the heart</i>—do not injure -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> the mind with worry and brooding. <i>Abstain from beans</i>—avoid -public life (office in former times being determined by voting -with beans). <i>Do not put victuals in a chamber-vessel</i>—clever -speech ought not to be put into a wicked mind, since speech, -which is the food of thought, is polluted by the wickedness in -a man. <i>Do not turn back on coming to the border</i>—when about to -die, and with the end of life close in sight, behave calmly and -without losing heart.</p> - -<p class='c005'>To return to the topic with which we were dealing before -this digression. While, as I observed, boys should be kept from -every kind of vicious company, especially should they be kept -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>13<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> from parasites. I venture to repeat here what I am continually -urging upon fathers. There is no set of creatures so pernicious—none -which so quickly and completely brings youth to headlong -destruction—as parasites. They are utter ruin to both father -and son, filling the old age of the one and the youth of the other -with vexation. To gain their purpose they offer an irresistible -<span class='pageno' id='Page_263'>263</span>bait in the shape of pleasure. In the case of rich men’s sons, -the father preaches sobriety, the parasite drunkenness. The -father urges temperance and economy, the parasite profligacy -and extravagance. The father says: ‘Be industrious’; the -parasite says: ‘Be idle; for life is only a moment altogether. <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -One ought to live, not merely exist. Why trouble about your -father’s threats? He is an old driveller with one foot in the -coffin, and we will promptly pick him up on our shoulders and -carry him off to his grave.’ One person tempts him with a drab, -or with the seduction of a married woman, plundering and -stripping the father of all the provision for his old age. They -are an abominable crew; their friendship is a sham; of candour -they have no idea; they toady the rich and despise the poor. -They are drawn to young men like puppets on a string; they <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -grin, when those who feed them laugh; they counterfeit the -possession of a mind, and give a spurious imitation of details -of real life. They live at the rich man’s beck, and though fortune <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -has made them free, their own choice makes them slaves. If -they are not insulted, they regard it as an insult, their maintenance -in that case being without a motive. If, therefore, -a father is concerned for the obedient conduct of his children, -he must keep these abominable creatures at a distance. And -he must by all means do the same with vicious fellow-pupils, -who are capable of corrupting the most moral of natures.</p> - -<p class='c005'>While these principles are right and expedient, I have a word -to say upon a human aspect of the matter. I have no desire, -all this time, that a father’s disposition should be altogether <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>D</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -harsh and unyielding. I would have him frequently condone -a fault in his junior and recollect that he was once young himself. -The physician mixes his bitter drugs with syrup, and so -finds a way to work benefit through the medium of enjoyment. -In the same way a father should blend his severe reprimande -with kindliness, at one time giving the boy’s desires a loose or -<span class='pageno' id='Page_264'>264</span>easy rein, at another time tightening it. If possible, he should -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>E</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> take misdeeds calmly; failing that, his anger should be seasonable -and should quickly cool down. It is better for a father to -be sharp-tempered than sullen-tempered; to sulk and bear -malice goes far to prove a lack of parental affection. Sometimes, -when a fault is committed, it is a good thing to pretend ignorance, -turning to advantage the dim sight and defective hearing -of old age, and refusing to see or hear certain occurrences which -one hears and sees. We put up with the lapses of a friend. Is it -strange to do so with those of a child? A slave is often heavy-headed -from a debauch, without our taking him to task. The -other day you refused the boy money; there are times to meet -his requests. The other day you were indignant; there are times -to be lenient. Perhaps he has cozened you through a servant; -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>F</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> restrain your anger. Has he borrowed the team from the farm? -Does he come reeking of yesterday’s bout? Do not notice it. -Smelling of perfumes? Say nothing. Such is the way to -manage the restiveness of youth.</p> - -<p class='c005'>A son who cannot resist pleasure and is deaf to remonstrance -should be put into matrimonial harness, that being the surest -way of tying a young man down. The woman who becomes -his wife should not, however, be to any great extent his superior -either in birth or means. <i>Keep to your own level</i> is a sound -maxim, and a man who marries much above him finds himself, -<span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>14<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> not the husband of the woman, but the slave of the dowry.</p> - -<p class='c005'>A few words more, and I will conclude my list of principles.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Above all things a father should set an example to his children -in his own person, by avoiding all faults of commission or -omission. His life should be the glass by which they form -themselves and are put out of conceit with all ugliness of act -or speech. For him to rebuke his erring sons when guilty of the -same errors himself, is to become his own accuser while ostensibly -theirs. Indeed, if his life is bad, he is disqualified from reproving -<span class='pageno' id='Page_265'>265</span>even a slave, much more his son. Moreover, he will naturally <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>B</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -become their guide and teacher in wrongdoing. Where there -are old men without shame, inevitably there are quite shameless -young ones also. To obtain good behaviour from our children -we should therefore strive to carry out every moral duty. An -example to follow is that of Eurydice, who, though belonging -to a thoroughly barbarous country like Illyria, nevertheless took -to study and self-improvement late in life for the sake of her -children’s education. Her maternal affection finds apt expression -in the lines inscribed upon her offering to the Muses: <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span><span class='fss'>C</span><span class='hidev'>|</span></span></p> - -<div class='lg-container-b c014'> - <div class='linegroup'> - <div class='group'> - <div class='line'><i>In that, when mother to grown boys, she won</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>Her soul’s well-known desire—the skill to use</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>The lore of letters—this Eurydice</i></div> - <div class='line'><i>From Hierapolis sends to each Muse.</i><a id='r60' /><a href='#f60' class='c009'><sup>[60]</sup></a></div> - </div> - </div> -</div> - -<p class='c015'>To compass the whole of the foregoing elements of success is <span class='sni'><span class='hidev'>|</span>*<span class='hidev'>|</span></span> -perhaps visionary—a counsel of perfection. But to cultivate -the majority of them, though itself requiring good fortune as -well as much care, is at any rate a thing within the reach of -a human being.</p> - -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_267'>267</span> - <h2 id='chap10' class='c003'>NOTES ON PERSONS AND PLACES</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'>The following brief notes are intended to supply the bare amount -of information necessary for an understanding of the text. The -pronunciation marks are, of course, added only for the sake of those -who have no Greek. An accent marks the syllable which should bear -the stress in the English pronunciation, and the signs [ă ĕ ĭ ŏ ŭ] and -[ā ē ī ō ū], imply -that the vowels are short or long respectively. q.v. = see the note -on that name.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Ábaris</b>: a legendary Scythian or ‘Hyperborean’ priest of Apollo, -to whom miraculous powers were attributed in the way of cures and -prophecy.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Aeolians</b>: inhabitants of Aeolis, the NE. coast of the Aegean, -with the island of Lesbos.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Aeschĭnes</b>: (1) a philosopher, pupil of Socrates (hence Aeschines -Socraticus). In the eyes of Plato he was a sophist, for the reason -that he took fees. His character was not of the highest. Like Plato, -he visited Syracuse during the philosophic pose of the elder Dionysius.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) Athenian orator, constant opponent of Demosthenes, who -charged him with being bribed by Philip. Died in exile 314 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Aeschylus</b>: the first in date and most severe in style of the three -great Attic tragedians, 525-466 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A master of condensed and -sonorous language and of powerful situations.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Aesop</b>: the famous writer (or promulgator) of fables, <i>c.</i> 620-564 -<span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Said to have been an emancipated slave, who spent some time -at the court of Croesus and was sent by him on a mission to Delphi -to distribute largess. Practically nothing definite is known of him. -His fables were most probably of Indo-Persian origin. Those which -now pass under his name are a comparatively late compilation from -various sources.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Agésilāus</b>: Agesilaus II, king of Sparta, 398-361 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; the most -important man in the Greek world of his day. His wars were numerous, -the most important being with the Thebans. His character was -noble, his ability great, but his physique and appearance poor.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_268'>268</span><b>Agis</b>: (1) Agis II, king of Sparta, 427-399 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; commander -against the Athenians in the Peloponnesian War, his greatest exploit -being the victory of Mantinea.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) Base and toadying poet of Argos, who accompanied Alexander -into Asia. The histories of the expedition agree with Plutarch as -to his character.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Alcibíades</b>: a handsome noble of Athens; a type of ostentatious, -ambitious, and unscrupulous brilliancy. After a measure of military -and political prominence he was banished from Athens for sacrilege -(415 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). Becoming hostile to his country he first found a home at -Sparta, thence migrated to Asia Minor and joined the Persian satrap, -Tissaphernes, whom he endeavoured to bring over to the Athenian -side as a means to his own recall. He returned to Athens for a brief -space in 407 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, then removed to Thrace, and thence again to the -Persian satrap.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Alcméōn</b>: son of Amphiaraus (q.v.), who avenged his father by -putting to death his mother Eriphyle.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Alexander</b>: (1) the Great, of Macedon.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) of Pherae, a despot who dominated Thessaly from 369 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A -cruel tyrant, assassinated through the agency of his wife.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Alexis</b>: poet of the ‘Middle Comedy’, who had migrated from -South Italy to Athens. Plutarch says that he lived to the age of 106, -and Suidas that his plays numbered 245.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Alyáttes</b>: king of Lydia and father of Croesus, carried on wars -with the Greeks of the Aegean coast of Asia Minor and had apparently -some designs upon the islands.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Amásis</b>: an insurgent Egyptian general who secured the throne -(569 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). His rule was beneficent and prosperous, and he cultivated -the friendship of the Greeks, handing over to them the town of -Naucratis (q. v.). When reproached with his humble origin he converted -his bronze foot-pan into the effigy of a deity by way of instructive -parable. He was visited by Solon and had amicable relations -with Croesus.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Ammónius</b>: Peripatetic philosopher from Attica, teacher of -Plutarch, who speaks elsewhere of his great erudition.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Amphiaráus</b>: legendary seer of Argos, who accompanied the -‘Seven’ in their expedition against Thebes. A pious and just man, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_269'>269</span>who was led into this false step by the persuasions of his wife, who -had been bribed.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Amphíctyons</b>: members of a religious Council meeting at Delphi -and representing the older Greek communities.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Amphídămas</b>: ‘hero’ (i. e. demigod) of Chalcis in Euboea, -conceived as a historical personage.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Amphitrítë</b>: wife of Poseidon and queen-goddess of the sea.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Anacharsis</b>: Scythian prince (of N. Thrace). To Greek literature -he is the type of the observant and critical visitor from abroad. A -pattern of the simple life and direct thinking. Said to have visited -Athens about 600 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Anaxarchus</b>: an easy-going and witty philosopher of the school -of Democritus (q. v.); in the suite of Alexander on his Asiatic -expedition.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Antígŏnus</b>: a general of Alexander. On the partition of the -empire he received Phrygia, Lycia, and Pamphylia, but afterwards -extended his rule over all the Asiatic portion. He fell before a combination -of the other Diadochi in 301 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Antímăchus</b>: epic poet of Colophon, who wrote at great length -on the story of Thebes. He also composed a voluminous elegy on -‘Lyde’. Both pieces were crammed with mythological and other -learning, and Plutarch appears to treat him as a type of the diffuse. -He was a contemporary of Plato.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Antípăter</b>: (1) regent of Macedonia during the Asiatic expedition -of Alexander and after his death (334-320 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). A war with a Greek -league headed by Athens ended in the submission of the latter.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) A Stoic philosopher of Tyre; a friend of Cato the younger, -about the middle of the first century <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Antiphōn</b>: several persons were so named, e. g.:</p> - -<p class='c005'>(1) an orator of the fifth century <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) An Athenian tragic poet, put to death by the elder Dionysius -at Syracuse.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(3) A sophist, epic poet, and antagonist of Socrates.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Apéllēs</b>: (1) of Colophon or Cos, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 335-305 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> The greatest -painter of antiquity, especially favoured by Alexander the Great. -His maxim for draughtsmen <i>nulla dies sine linea</i> is famous.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) Of Chios, apparently unknown beyond Plutarch.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_270'>270</span><b>Appius Claudius</b> (<b>Caecus</b>): Roman censor 312 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, originator -of the Appian Way.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Aráspēs</b>: a Mede, friend of Cyrus, who became enamoured of -Panthea (q. v.).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Arcĕsiláus</b>: latter part of third century <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; first a disciple of -Theophrastus (q. v.), but took an independent line in philosophy as -founder of the sceptical New Academy. A man of amiable character -and a wit.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Archeláus</b>: king of Macedonia 413-399 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; a lover of art and -literature and a patron of Euripides and other Athenian men of -letters.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Archidámus</b>: Archidamus II, king of Sparta, 469-427 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> -There were several other kings of the name.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Archílŏchus</b>: of Paros, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 710-675 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A lyrist of whom -only fragments are extant; particularly famous for his iambic -lampoons.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Archimédes</b>: the Newton of antiquity; an eminent scientist of -Syracuse 287-212 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; student of astronomy, applied mathematics, -and engineering. He served as mechanical engineer in defending -his city from the Romans, by whose soldiers he was killed in ignorance.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Archytas</b>: of Tarentum, in the early part of the fourth century <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, -noted as a mathematician and philosophic statesman of the Pythagorean -order. Both in generalship and civil business of state he was -eminently successful and was trusted with extraordinary powers.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Arēs</b>: the Greek War-God, answering generally to the Roman -Mars.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Arȋdaeus</b> (<b>Arrhidaeus</b>): (1) feeble half-witted king of Macedonia -after his brother Alexander’s death.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) A general of Alexander, joint regent in 321 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, afterwards -governor on the Hellespont.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Aríōn</b>: <i>c.</i> 600 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; the famous bard and harp-player of Lesbos, -and supposed inventor of the dithyramb. His favourite abode was -at the court of Periander.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Aristarchus</b>: the prince of Greek grammarians and critics; -flourished at Alexandria 181-146 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Chiefly known for his commentaries -on the language and matter of Homer, and his recension -of the divergent manuscripts.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_271'>271</span><b>Aristeides</b> (<b>Aristídes</b>): with the sobriquet of ‘the Just’; a -noble of Athens, statesman and general, who figures in the stirring -times of the war with Persia. Died <i>c.</i> 470 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Aristíppus</b>: of Cyrene, disciple, but not imitator, of Socrates. -A student and teacher of ethics, and founder of the Cyrenaic philosophy -and its cult of pleasure: <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 380-366 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> For a time he was -at the court of Dionysius (q. v.) of Syracuse.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Arísto</b>: (1) the chief bearer of the name was a philosopher who -became head of the Peripatetic school about 230 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Anciently -considered a writer of more elegance than weight.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) A son of Sophocles, and probably himself a tragedian.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Aristómĕnes</b>: practically regent of Egypt from 202 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; a sound -adviser of the young Ptolemy Epiphanes (q. v.), who put him to -death for his frankness in 192 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Aristóphănes</b>: of Athens, 444-380 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; by far the greatest comic -poet of antiquity. His comedy was of the ‘Old’, or personal-political -type. Eleven of his plays are extant.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Arístŏphōn</b>: painter, brother of Polygnotus (who <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 420 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Aristotle</b>: of Stageira, but commonly domiciled in Athens or in -Macedonia. Pupil of Plato and subsequently tutor of Alexander. -Founder of the Peripatetic school, with its head-quarters in the -Lyceum (q. v.). His whole tone of mind is strikingly unlike that of -his teacher, being eminently precise, logical, and scientific. His -writing is without literary charm. He aimed at sound and comprehensive -knowledge as the basis of right principles in society, -conduct, and the arts (384-322 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Asclépius</b>: (= Aesculapius), the Greek ‘hero’ of medicine, -converted by legend into a son of Apollo and ultimately into -a god.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Atreides</b> (<b>Atrídes</b>): = ‘son of Atreus’, a title of Agamemnon -and Menelaus.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Áttălus</b> (brother of Eumenes): Attalus Philadelphus, king of -Pergamus, allied with the Romans in the middle of the second -century <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Philopoemen was his controlling minister.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Bacchýlȋdes</b>: lyric poet of Ceos, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 470 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, principally at the -court of Hiero of Syracuse. In general he may be called a smoother -and weaker Pindar.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_272'>272</span><b>Bagóas</b>: a handsome young eunuch of Darius, afterwards taken -into the service and affections of Alexander.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Báthycles</b>: an artist in metal-work, of uncertain date, but -probably to be placed in the early part of the age of the Seven Sages.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Bato</b>: comic poet of Athens, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 280 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; satirized philosophers.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Bias</b>: of Priene; precise date unknown, but <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 550 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He is -invariably included in the list of the Seven Sages.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Biōn</b>: <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 250 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, a philosopher from Olbia on the Black Sea, -who settled at Athens, tried various systems, and ended by being -a Peripatetic. He was noted for his keen sententious sayings, but -was of dissolute character. Has been called ‘the Greek Voltaire’.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Brīséïs</b>: captive woman assigned to Achilles, but taken from -him by Agamemnon when he surrendered Chryseis.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Busírites</b>: the people of Busiris (modern Abousir), about the -middle of the Delta; one of the traditional birthplaces of Osiris.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Calchas</b>: the seer of the Achaean army before Troy.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Callísthĕnes</b>: philosopher and rhetorician; accompanied Alexander -into Asia, where he used over-bold language in reproving -him. Put to death 328 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He wrote an account of the expedition -and other historical works.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Calýpso</b>: nymph, on whose island the shipwrecked Odysseus was -detained for seven years.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Carnĕădes</b>: of Cyrene, 213(?)-129 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; a student of Stoicism, -but leader of the Academics. He was ambassador on behalf of Athens -(155 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>) to Rome, where he delivered striking discourses on ethics. -His cardinal doctrine was the ‘withholding of assent’ to doctrines.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cato</b>: (1) the elder (or ‘the Censor’), 234-149 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> The type -of severe old-fashioned Roman morality; soldier, statesman, orator, -and writer.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) The younger (or ‘Uticensis’), 95-46 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; modelled himself -on his great-grandfather in respect of the moral and simple life, but -was much inferior in gifts. Committed suicide 46 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, when the -struggle against the domination of Julius Caesar had become -hopeless.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cĕbēs</b>: of Thebes, a pupil of Socrates and a <i>persona</i> in Plato’s -<i>Phaedo</i>. He is chiefly known for his (if it is his) symbolic picture -or ‘table’ of human life.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_273'>273</span><b>Cĕrămeicus (-í-)</b>: a suburb without, and a broad street within, -the west walls of Athens.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cercópes</b>: mythical gnomes, mischievous and thievish, who -annoyed Heracles by their monkey-like tricks.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Chábrȋas</b>: Athenian commander at various times between 392 and -357 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, gaining some successes by land and sea against the Spartans. -An able tactician, adventurous, but of somewhat dissolute life.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Chalcis</b>: chief town of Euboea (Negropont), once a most important -commercial centre.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Charēs</b>: Athenian general, of whose various operations we have -records for 367-333 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A man of little principle. He effected little -against the Macedonians, and often followed independent and useless -lines of action.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Chármȋdes</b>: uncle of Plato, who names one of his Socratic -dialogues after him. At the supposed date he was a beautiful and -charming youth, and the discussion is upon ‘self-control’.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Chīlōn</b>: of Lacedaemon: <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 600-570 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Poet and coiner -of maxims, and shrewd man of affairs.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Chryséïs</b>: captive woman assigned to Agamemnon; surrendered -by him at the bidding of Apollo, in order to check a pestilence.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cimōn</b>: son of Miltiades, became prominent as a commander -against the Persians in 477 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> His chief exploit was the victory -of Eurymedon, 466 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A handsome, liberal, affable, but somewhat -self-indulgent person.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cīnésias</b>: Athenian dithyrambic poet, much satirized by Aristophanes -and others. His verse, music, and character appear all to -have been of an inferior order.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Claudia</b>: Roman maiden, who, in full vindication of her chastity, -was enabled to move the vessel containing the image of Cybele when -it stuck fast in the Tiber.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cleánthes</b>: Stoic philosopher, pupil and successor of Zeno (q. v.) -263 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> The only fragment of his writing still extant is from a Hymn -to Zeus.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cleárchus</b>: (1) of Heraclea on the Black Sea; availed himself -of faction to make himself despot and tyrant (365 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). Despite -the precautions described by Plutarch he was assassinated in 353 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) Of Sparta, leader of the 10,000 Greeks in the expedition of Cyrus -<span class='pageno' id='Page_274'>274</span>the Younger against Babylon; decoyed and put to death by the -Persians, 401 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> The retreat was led by Xenophon (q.v.).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cleisthĕnes</b>: Athenian noble, who adopted the popular cause -and made important democratic changes in the constitution; <i>fl.</i> from -510 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cleitus</b> (<b>Clītus</b>): a Macedonian commander under Alexander, -whose life he saved at the battle of Granícus (334 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). He was killed -(328 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>) by Alexander with a spear-thrust, after a quarrel at a carousal, -in which he had spoken with excessive freedom to his chief.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cleobulínë</b>: daughter (as the name implies) of Cleobulus (q.v.). -Though her father is said to have named her Eumetis (‘sagacious’), -the word may be suspected of being an afterthought.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cleobúlus</b>: <i>c.</i> 610-560 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A citizen of Lindus in Rhodes, who -became its despot. His position may have been similar to that of -Pittacus (q.v.).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cleómĕnes</b>: Cleomenes III, high-minded king of Sparta, 240-222 -<span class='fss'>B.C.</span> On his defeat by the Achaeans he fled to Ptolemy -Euergetes, with whom he was in alliance. The next Ptolemy -(Philopator) suspected and imprisoned him.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cleōn</b>: a tanner of Athens; an able but coarse-grained leader -of the popular party 428-422 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A special enemy of Aristophanes -(q.v.), whose fiercest political attacks are delivered against him. -A self-sufficient amateur in military operations, in one of which he -was slain.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Clódius</b>: P. Clodius Pulcher; a daring and unscrupulous person, -who became quaestor in 61 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> and tribune of the plebs in 59 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> -The notorious and relentless enemy of Cicero. Killed by Milo on -the high road 52 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Colónus</b>: a suburb of Athens outside the north wall, with a small -hill, grove, and sanctuary.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cólophōn</b>: Greek town of Asia Minor, near the Aegean coast, -about ten miles north of Ephesus.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cornelia</b>: daughter of Scipio Africanus; the famous ‘mother of -the Gracchi’; the type of matronly virtue, dignity, cultivation, and -high example.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Crátĕrus</b>: a noble type of Macedonian; one of Alexander’s -generals. After the death of his chief (323 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>) he became colleague -<span class='pageno' id='Page_275'>275</span>with Antipater in the Graeco-Macedonian portion of the empire. -See also under Eumenes.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cratēs</b>: of Thebes; pupil of Diogenes (q.v.) at Athens; <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> -320 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A Cynic philosopher in practice as well as theory, he -renounced his wealth and led the simple life in a cheerful manner. -A philosophic writer and a tragic poet.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Croesus</b>: king of Lydia 560-546 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A wealthy and powerful -ruler, who made war upon the Persians when their empire was -growing rapidly under Cyrus. Was defeated and carried off in the -train of the conqueror. While in power he was in friendly or hostile -relations with various Greek states, and was particularly noted for -his liberality to the Delphian oracle. Whether Solon ever actually -had the famous interview with Croesus is chronologically doubtful, -but it is not impossible.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cyáxares</b>: king of Media, appears in Xenophon’s <i>Cyropaedia</i> -as uncle of Cyrus the Great, but the whole book is something of -a romance.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cýpsĕlus</b>: father of Periander, established himself as despot of -Corinth <i>c.</i> 656 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> His name was commonly associated with -<i>cypsele</i> (‘chest’). The designs upon him in his infancy were those -of a Corinthian noble house, and were made in consequence of an -oracle foretelling danger from the child.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Cyrus</b>: (1) the elder: the famous Persian monarch, founder of -the empire, and subjugator of Babylon. The stories told of him in -the <i>Cyropaedia</i> of Xenophon are largely romance.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) the younger: satrap of Lydia, Phrygia, &c., who sought, but -failed, to dispossess his brother Artaxerxes with the assistance -of a Greek force (401 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). This was the expedition related in -Xenophon’s <i>Anabasis</i>.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Daphnūs</b>: a river running into the Corinthian Gulf on the north -side not far from the entrance.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Dāríus</b>: (1) Darius I; strong and able king of Persia (521-485 -<span class='fss'>B.C.</span>), previously satrap under Cyrus the Great. This is the Darius -mentioned in connexion with Gobryas.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) Darius II (Ochus or Nothus), or Darius the Younger, a weak -monarch endangered by perpetual rebellions, 424-405 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'>(3) Darius Codomannus, overthrown by Alexander. Died 330 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_276'>276</span><b>Délos</b>: central island of the south half of the Aegean, with a temple -of Apollo, the gathering-place of a great religious confederacy of -Ionians.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Dēmarátus</b>: of Corinth, in friendly relations with Philip and a -mediator between him and Alexander after their quarrel in 337 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Dēmétrius</b>: (1) Demetrius I (or Poliorcetes), king of Macedonia. -His father Antigonus, king of Asia, sent him in 307 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> to annex -Greece, then under Cassander and Ptolemy. It was at this time -that he took Megara and met with Stilpo (q. v.).</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) Demetrius Phaléreus: Athenian orator and writer (345-283 -<span class='fss'>B.C.</span>); an able and cultivated man, put in charge of Athens by the -Macedonians, 317 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> First highly honoured, then expelled, he -made his way to Thebes and subsequently to Alexandria.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(3) The name of several Macedonian officers in the army of -Alexander.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Dēmócrȋtus</b>: <i>c.</i> 460-360 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Of Abdēra in Thrace. A great -traveller and student, who developed (though he did not invent) -the ‘Atomic Theory’. Ethically his aim was cheerfulness of mind -(hence ‘the laughing philosopher’). His character was of the highest -for truth and simplicity.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Dicaeárchus</b>: philosopher from Massana in Sicily; writer on -history and geography. A follower of Aristotle, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 300 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Díŏcles</b>: the narrator of the Dinner of the Seven Sages: professional -seer, and interpreter and expiator of omens and dreams. -Nothing is known of such a person outside Plutarch.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Diógĕnes</b>: (1) the Cynic philosopher of Sinope, who migrated to -Athens, and after being captured by pirates was sold as a slave to -a Corinthian. Whether or not he ever lived in the famous (earthenware) -‘tub’ is doubtful. He was distinguished for his plainness of -life, his shrewd good sense, his independence, and his caustic tongue.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) Tragic poet of Athens, <i>c.</i> 404 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Diōn</b>: of Syracuse, brother-in-law of the elder Dionysius (q. v.). -On the visit of Plato to Sicily he became a disciple of that philosopher. -The younger Dionysius resented his reputation and his harshness. -Dion therefore removed to Athens and other parts of Greece, whence -he returned with a force, expelled Dionysius, and was himself -appointed practically dictator. Assassinated 353 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_277'>277</span><b>Dionysius</b>: (i) the elder: despot of Syracuse (‘sole general’) -405-367 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He extended its power over a great part of Sicily, and -strongly fortified the city itself. In the end he became a veritable -tyrant. Like many other despots he affected literature and philosophy, -and himself wrote bad verses. After inviting Plato to Syracuse -he quarrelled with and dismissed that philosopher.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) the younger, who succeeded his father. For a time he was -under the influence of Dion (q.v.) assisted by Plato. Of weaker -character and more licentious than his father, he was compelled to -abandon Syracuse after a rule of eleven years. Insecurely restored -ten years later he was again driven out by Timoleon (343 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). -The remainder of his life was spent in poverty at Corinth, where he -is said to have taught an elementary school.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Dōdóna</b>: in Epirus, near the modern Janina; a very ancient -seat of the worship of Zeus.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Dolōn</b>: a Trojan in the <i>Iliad</i>, who undertakes to penetrate the -Achaean camp as a spy, but is slain in the attempt.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Dryópians</b>: a people of Central Greece.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Elephantínë</b> = Djesiret-el-Sag; a garrisoned island in the Nile -(First Cataract) opposite the modern Assouan; the frontier town of -Egypt towards Ethiopia.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Empédŏcles</b>: Sicilian physical and practical philosopher of -Acragas (= Girgenti); <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 450 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> His studies of nature specially -qualified him for the cure or ‘purification’ of epidemics due to -insanitary conditions. His travels took him to Athens and other -parts of Greece. The legend went that he threw himself into the -crater of Etna.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Eōs</b>: = Aurora, dawn-goddess; wife of Tithonus; mother of -Memnon, the opponent of Achilles.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Epáminōndas</b>: a type of patriotism, particularly to his compatriot -Plutarch. The greatest of Theban commanders and statesmen, -especially famous for his victory over the Spartans at Leuctra -(371 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). So far as he applied any philosophy to life, it was that of -Pythagoras.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Éphŏrus</b>: historian of Cumae, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 340 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> His history, -once very famous and much discussed, covered a period of 750 -years.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_278'>278</span><b>Epichármus</b>: <i>c.</i> 540-450 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; the great comic poet of Sicily, -chiefly associated with the court of Hiero I (q.v.) at Syracuse.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Epicúrus</b>: 342-270 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Athenian philosopher and founder of -the Epicurean school, of which the aim was ‘peace of mind’ or -‘freedom from emotional disturbance’. His own life (as his tenets required) -was simple and wholesome, and the self-indulgence of the sect -in later days was either a parody or a misconception of his teachings. -A voluminous writer on physics and ethics, but with a bad style.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Epiménȋdes</b>: priest-prophet and bard of Crete, with peculiar -knowledge of medicine and methods of purification. Many fables -were current concerning him (e.g. of his sleep of fifty-seven years). -He was called in by the Athenians (<i>c.</i> 596 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>) to cleanse their city -of a plague.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Epimétheus</b>: brother of Prometheus (q.v.). The name was taken -to mean ‘After-thinker’, and hence arose a notion that he ‘thought -too late’.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Erasístrătus</b>: a very distinguished physician in the earlier part -of the third century <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He practised and taught in Syria and -Alexandria. An eminent student of anatomy.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Eratósthĕnes</b>: librarian of Alexandria under the Ptolemies; -a writer on mathematical geography, history, and grammar. Died -about 196 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Érĕsus</b>: a town on the south-west coast of Lesbos (Mytilene); -birthplace of Theophrastus.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Erétria</b>: the second town of Euboea, a little south of Chalcis. -See Lelantum.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Erínys</b>: a spirit of vengeance sent up from the underworld to -punish unnatural crimes and offences.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Éteŏcles</b>: (legendary): son of Oedipus, joint king of Thebes with -Polyneices, whom he expelled through a selfish desire to rule alone.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Euénus</b>: two poets of Paros are so named, one of the date of -Socrates and one earlier. It is, and was anciently, difficult to distinguish -between the two.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Eúmĕnes</b>: an eminent and very able general (and also secretary) of -Alexander, after whose death he obtained (322 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>) the chief command -in Asia. His subordinate Neoptolemus, governor of Armenia, -made head against him with the help of Craterus. Their defeat, -<span class='pageno' id='Page_279'>279</span>mentioned in the article on Garrulity, took place in Cappadocia in -321 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Eúpŏlis</b>: one of the three chief poets of the ‘old’ comedy of -Athens, a contemporary of Aristophanes (q.v.).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Eurípides</b>: 480-406 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; third in date of the three great Athenian -tragedians. His works were numerous and uneven. His poetical -merits were (and are) variously estimated.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Fabius Maximus</b>: the best known person of the name was -Q. Fabius Maximus Cunctator, who saved Rome by his waiting -tactics against Hannibal; but the one who was associated with -Polybius, as pupil and patron, was Q. F. M. Aemilianus, consul in -145 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, who served against Macedonia and in Spain.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Góbryes</b>: one of the seven Persian nobles (Darius being another) -who conspired against the usurper Smerdis the Mage. Darius was -raised to the throne and Gobryes became one of his lieutenants.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Górgȋas</b>: of Leontini in Sicily: orator, rhetorical teacher, and -sophist, who visited Athens 427 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> and subsequently. His style, -which was highly artificial, was widely imitated. He is the Gorgias -of Plato’s dialogue.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Gorgo</b>: of Sparta; wife of Leonidas and daughter of Cleomenes I. -Stories of her wisdom and sagacity are told by Herodotus (6. 49, -7. 239).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Gylippus</b>: Spartan general who came to the rescue of Syracuse -and chiefly caused the utter collapse of the Athenian attack upon -that city. After the fall of Athens (404 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>) it was his business to -convey to Sparta the 1,500 talents of booty. He opened the seams -of the sacks, filched about one-fifth of the amount, but was betrayed -by the inventories enclosed.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Harmódius</b>: a handsome youth of Athens associated with Aristogeiton -(the older man) in the assassination of Hipparchus, brother -of the despot Hippias in 514 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Though Athens was not liberated -till four years later, these tyrannicides were canonized as saviours -of their country.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Hecuba</b>: the aged wife of Priam, and mother of Hector.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Hephaestus</b>: practically the Greek equivalent of the Latin -Vulcan or Fire-God. He is represented as a lame, but sturdy and -somewhat humorous deity, a master of smithcraft.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_280'>280</span><b>Hēracleides</b> (<b>Héraclides</b>): It is not clear to which person of -the name Plutarch refers. The best known was Heracleides Ponticus, -a pupil of Plato and a miscellaneous writer.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Hēracleitus</b> (<b>Hēraclítus</b>): physical philosopher of Ephesus, -<i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 515 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Famous for the compression of his style, which -became so cryptic that he earned the title of the ‘Obscure’. He was -something of a hermit and favoured the simple vegetarian life. The -‘weeping philosopher’.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Hermíŏne</b>: daughter of Menelaus and Helen; married to Neoptolemus -(son of Achilles) and jealous of Andromache, whom she tried -to put to death.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Hēródŏtus</b>: <i>c.</i> 484-400 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; the so-called ‘Father of History’. -He travelled widely in the East and in the Grecian world, and wrote -on Lydia, Babylonia, Egypt, Persia, and the great Persian war. -His desire is to get at the facts, but he displays a naïve fondness for -story-telling and for wonders and miracles.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Hēróphȋlus</b>: of Chalcedon; a most eminent physician and a -discoverer in anatomy and physiology; <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 300 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Hiero I</b>: or the Magnificent, despot of Gelon and Syracuse -(478-467 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>), and most powerful Sicilian of his day. Poets at one -time or other associated with his court were Epicharmus, Xenophanes, -Simonides, Aeschylus, Pindar, and Bacchylides.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Hierónymus</b>: tragic and dithyrambic poet of Athens and -apparently a writer on poets.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Hippócrătes</b>: of Cos; the ‘father of medicine’; the most -renowned physician and medical teacher and writer of antiquity: -<i>c.</i> 460-357 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Hypereides</b> (<b>Hyperídes</b>): Attic orator; patriot, contemporary -and, for the most part, supporter of Demosthenes in his anti-Macedonian -policy. Put to death by Antipater (q.v.), 322 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> An elegant -speaker, of dubious private life.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Íbycus</b>: of Rhegium, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 540 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> at the court of the despot of -Samos; a lyric poet of the erotic type. The proverb, ‘the cranes of -Ibycus’, arose from the story that, when being murdered by brigands -near Corinth, he invoked a flock of cranes, then flying past, to avenge -his death. Plutarch tells the sequel (<i>Garrulity</i>).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>īno</b>: or Leucóthea; a mythological personage, daughter of -<span class='pageno' id='Page_281'>281</span>Cadmus and wife of Athamas. One story went that, when she leapt -into the sea, she was carried to Corinth by a dolphin. Hence the -allusion in the story of Arion.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>īphícrătes</b>: Athenian general in early part of the fourth century -<span class='fss'>B.C.</span> An innovator in tactics and military equipment, noted for his -prudence and foresight.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Ischómăchus</b>: a character of the name appears in Xenophon’s -<i>Oeconomicus</i> as lecturing his wife upon the principles of domestic -management. Such a philosophically disposed person may be the -associate of Socrates mentioned by Plutarch.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Ithacans</b>: the people of Odysseus, king of Ithaca, one of the -Ionian islands, south of Corfu.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Ixíon</b>: mythical Thessalian king, who made illicit love to Hera, -wife of Zeus, and was punished by being fastened to a perpetually -revolving wheel in Hades.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Laelius</b>: C. Laelius Sapiens, friend of Scipio Africanus Minor. -Consul 140 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Cicero’s <i>De Amicitia</i> is otherwise named his <i>Laelius</i>. -Philosopher, orator, and scholar.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Laértes</b>: aged father of Odysseus; superannuated king of -Ithaca.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Lĕchaeum</b>: the port of Old Corinth, with which it was connected -by walls one and a half miles in length.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Lēlántum</b>: a river of Euboea, flowing through the fertile Lelantine -plain (between Chalcis and Eretria), which was long a bone of -contention between the two cities.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Leónȋdas</b>: the famous Spartan king, who so stubbornly held the -pass of Thermopylae against the Persians with his ‘Three Hundred’, -480 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Leptis</b>: a town in Africa near the modern Tripoli; a Phoenician -settlement and afterwards a Roman colony.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Lesches</b>: one of the post-Homeric (‘Cyclic’) poets, and writer -of the <i>Little Iliad</i>; a native of Lesbos, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 705 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Leuctra</b>: Boeotian village; the scene of the great defeat of the -Spartans by Epaminondas, 371 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Livia</b>: Livia Drusilla, 56 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>-<span class='fss'>A.D.</span> 29. Her first husband was -Tiberius Claudius Nero, by whom she was the mother of Tiberius, -the future emperor. Married to Augustus (then Octavianus) in -<span class='pageno' id='Page_282'>282</span>38 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, and having no children by him, she was anxious to keep the -succession in her own family. A woman of strong character, she -exerted a tactful control over Augustus and attempted one more -imperious over Tiberius, but failed.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Locri</b>: Locri Epizephyrii, an important Greek town of South -Italy, about the modern Gerace. Its constitutional code was often -regarded as a model.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Locris</b>: a Greek community lying along the north side of the -middle of the Corinthian Gulf.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Loxias</b>: Apollo as God of Oracles. The name was commonly -interpreted as ‘Riddling’ or ‘Indirect’.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Lucullus</b>: Roman conqueror of Mithridates, succeeded in his -command by Pompey, 66 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Famous for his wealth and luxury, -and particularly for his lavish feasts. A byword for self-indulgence.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Lycéum</b>: an exercise ground with terraces (‘walks’) and colonnades -just outside the wall to the east of Athens. It was here that -Aristotle discoursed on the ‘Walk’ (<i>peripatos</i>), whence the name -‘Peripatetic’ became applied to his school.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Lycurgus</b>: (1) the more or less legendary lawgiver and constitution-maker -of Sparta. His date and personality are quite uncertain, -and he is not improbably as mythical as Heracles.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) son of Dryas, a legendary Thracian king who resisted the worship -of Dionysius and hacked down his sacred plant, the vine. Dionysius -punished him with madness, during which he killed his own son, -thinking him a vine. The story is much varied in particulars.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Lysander</b>: Spartan admiral, who won the battle of Aegospotami -against the Athenians and concluded the reduction of Athens in -404 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He was afterwards distinguished for his ostentation and -arrogance.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Lysias</b>: orator and professional rhetorician of Athens, distinguished -for the purity and lucidity of his diction and his grace of -style: <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 403 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> The majority of his 230 speeches were written -for litigants.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Lysímăchus</b>: of Macedonia; became king of Thrace on the -partition of Alexander’s empire. A man of powerful physique and -an able soldier. Later his territory included the western half of Asia -Minor. Killed in battle 281 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_283'>283</span><b>Masinissa</b>: king of Numidia; first a supporter, then an enemy, of -Carthage, he lent great assistance to the Romans from 204 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> to 148. -His reign was long and he died at ninety.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Meidias</b> (<b>Mídias</b>): an Athenian citizen and bitter enemy of -Demosthenes, one of whose best known speeches is a violent, and -possibly a rather scurrilous, attack upon him.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Melánthius</b>: of Athens: an inferior tragic and elegiac poet of -worthless character: a contemporary of Aristophanes and Plato.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Meleáger</b>: legendary prince of Calydon. Having slain his mother’s -brothers, he was cursed by her, and thereupon refused to take further -part in the war against the Curetes. No offers could induce him to -leave his chamber and rout the enemy, until he yielded to the prayers -of his wife Cleopatra.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Menander</b>: chief poet of the Athenian New Comedy (or comedy -of manners), 342-291 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; a polished and easy-tempered man of -the world. His sententious writings lent themselves to quotation -and were much read in schools. To moralizing critics of a later age -he was to comedy what Homer was to epic.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Mĕnedémus</b>: philosopher and statesman of Euboea, of the -‘Megarian’ school. Died <i>c.</i> 277 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Méropë</b>: the name of several mythological semi-goddesses, mostly -connected with the heavenly bodies.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Metellus</b>: Q. Caecilius Metellus, who successfully conducted the -Numidian War against Jugurtha (109 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>) until superseded by -Marius. A man of high character, military ability, and intellectual -culture.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Mētrodórus</b>: favourite pupil of Epicurus (q.v.) and almost -co-master of his school. Died 277 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Mithridátes</b>: Mithridates VI, or the Great, king of Pontus -120-63 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, a Hellenized oriental famed for his physical and -intellectual ability, his ambition and daring; of importance in history -for his wars with the Romans under Lucullus and Pompey. He made -a special study of poisons and their antidotes.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Mnēsíphȋlus</b>: Athenian statesman of sound practical ability, taken -by Themistocles as his model. It was he who urged Themistocles -to force on the battle of Salamis (480 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). In the <i>Dinner-Party</i> -Plutarch borrows the name for an imaginary friend of Solon.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_284'>284</span><b>Molycréa</b>: a town just inside the entrance to the Corinthian -Gulf on the north side.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Myrōn</b>: Boeotian sculptor; <i>fl.</i> 430 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Best known by his -Discobolus and his ‘Cow’. His work included animal forms, and -human figures in a state of muscular activity or tension.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Mýrsȋlus</b>: see Pittacus.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Naucrătis</b>: a Greek town in the Delta of Egypt, thirty miles -from the sea. At first only a trading-station, it was granted privileges -of internal self-government by Amasis (q.v.).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Neoptólĕmus</b>: see Eumenes.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Nestor</b>: the typical wise old man of the <i>Iliad</i>.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Nicander</b>: poet and physician of Colophon; <i>fl.</i> in earlier half of -second century <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Two of his poems are extant: the <i>Theriaca</i> on -venomous animals, and the <i>Alexipharmaca</i> (or ‘<i>Antidotes</i>‘) on poisons -and their remedies. The verse in itself is poor.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Nícias</b>: (1) Athenian general in the calamitous expedition against -Syracuse (415-413 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). A man of wealth, but religious to the point -of disastrous superstition; a commander of experience, though -wanting in promptitude and self-reliance. He was put to death by -the victors.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) painter of Athens, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 310 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, particularly noted for his -chiaroscuro and for improvements in encaustic painting.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Nilóxĕnus</b>: a character probably invented by Plutarch, with -a name geographically suitable.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Numa</b>: Numa Pompilius, second king of Rome, famed for his piety -and the excellence of his legislation. Much of his history is legendary.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Olympias</b>: wife of Philip (q.v.) and mother of Alexander. An -imperious and vindictive woman, with good reasons for jealousy, -who often figures in Macedonian feuds.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Olynthus</b>: a Greek town on the Chalcidic peninsula, south of -Thessalonica.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Ómphălë</b>: queen of Lydia, to whom Heracles was for a time -enslaved and for whom he played an effeminate part. In a sense -she played the Delilah to his Samson.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Orchómĕnus</b>: a very ancient town in Boeotia.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Oromazdes</b>: = Ahuramazda, the great God of the Zoroastrians; -deity of light and good, as opposed to Ahrimanes.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_285'>285</span><b>Pándărus</b>: a Lycian warrior on the Trojan side, famous for his -skill as an archer.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Panthéa</b>: beautiful wife of Abradatas, king of Susa. Cyrus, who -had captured her, showed her such respect that Abradatas came over -to his side.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Parménȋdes</b>: philosopher and legislator of Elea, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 476 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> -His writings were in the hexameter verse then usual as the vehicle -of literary philosophy.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Parménio</b>: general under Philip and Alexander, and right-hand -lieutenant of the latter. Accused of taking part in a conspiracy against -his chief, he was assassinated at the age of seventy in 330 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Parrhásius</b>: painter of Ephesus, domiciled at Athens, <i>c.</i> 400 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; -famed for his accurate drawing and proportion. As a man he was -arrogant and luxurious.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Pāsíphaë</b>: (legendary): wife of Minos of Crete; enamoured of -a bull and mother of the Minotaur.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Patróclus</b>: the ‘squire’ and beloved friend of Achilles. Killed -by Hector in battle, and avenged by Achilles.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Peísistrătus</b>: a younger relative of Solon; intrigued himself into -the position of despot of Athens 560 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He was twice expelled, -but re-established himself. A highly capable ruler, beautifier of -Athens, and a lover of literature.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Pēleides</b> (-<b>ī</b>-): (i.e. ‘son of Peleus’) = Achilles.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Péleus</b>: aged father of Achilles; superannuated king in Thessaly.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Periander</b>: despot of Corinth, <i>c.</i> 625-585 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> An able and powerful -ruler, patron of literature and art, generally (but not invariably) -included among the Seven Sages. His early mildness is commonly -reported to have passed into tyranny (see Thrasybulus). His wife -was Melissa.</p> - -<p class='c005'>Pericles: the highest name among what may be called ‘Prime -Ministers’ of Athens. His career may be dated 470-429 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, but his -leadership became most pronounced about 444 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A man of large -conceptions, brilliant oratorical powers, and philosophic tastes, but -of an aristocratic and exclusive temperament.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Perséphŏnë</b>: daughter of Demeter, wife of Pluto, and therefore, -in one of her aspects, Queen of the Dead.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Perseus</b>: king of Macedonia, on whom the Romans made war -<span class='pageno' id='Page_286'>286</span>in 171 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> At first victorious or equal, he was defeated at Pydna by -L. Aemilius Paulus 168 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He was carried to Rome and lived for -some years at Alba. A weak, vacillating and parsimonious monarch.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Petrónius</b>: Titus (or Gaius) Petronius, the famous ‘arbiter of -taste’ under Nero and director of his pleasures. Whether he was -the author of the famous <i>Satyricon</i> is doubtful.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Phaeácians</b>: seafaring inhabitants of the rich and fertile island -of Phaeacia, traditionally identified with Corfu, but possibly Crete. -When Odysseus arrived at the island on his raft he was hospitably -entertained by King Alcinous and sent home to Ithaca by him on -a ship.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Phaedra</b>: wife of Theseus and step-mother of Hippolytus, of -whom she became enamoured. The allusion in Plutarch refers to -the fondness of Hippolytus for hunting.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Phálăris</b>: despot of Agrigentum in Sicily <i>c.</i> 570 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> His name -was in some legends proverbial for cruelty, and with him is associated -the legend of roasting his victims in a brazen bull. Put he is sometimes -represented otherwise and as a student of letters and philosophy.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Pheidias</b> (<b>Phíd</b>-) of Athens, the most eminent sculptor of -antiquity: died 432 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He is best known for his work upon the -Parthenon and his colossal statue of Zeus at Olympia.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Phérae</b>: a town in Thessaly, somewhat west of the modern Volo, -which became dominant under the despots Jason and Alexander (q.v.).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Philadolphus</b>: see Ptolemy (1).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Philémōn</b>: Athenian poet of the New Comedy, reckoned second -only to Menander. Lived <i>c.</i> 360-262 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, and wrote ninety-seven -plays.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Philétas</b>: of Cos, <i>c.</i> 300 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; elegiac poet and critic, tutor of -Ptolemy II. His thinness was a matter of jest for the comedians.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Philip</b>: 382-336 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> king of Macedon, father of Alexander, and, -in a large measure, conqueror of Greece. Demosthenes’ <i>Philippics</i> -and other speeches were directed against him. An able, hard-working, -ambitious, and rather unscrupulous man; a hard drinker and a -sensualist, especially fond of rude jest, but with intellectual tastes.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Philíppȋdes</b>: one of the better Athenian poets of the New -Comedy; <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 335 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> At first he attacked the Macedonian rulers, -but later became a friend of Lysimachus (q.v.).</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_287'>287</span><b>Philóchŏrus</b>: Athenian writer on the history, antiquities, and -legends of his country, and on miscellaneous subjects: <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 300-260 -<span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Philócrătes</b>: Athenian orator, first a supporter, then an opponent, -of Demosthenes. His policy was consistently to abet the pretensions of -Philip of Macedon, who had bribed him lavishly, to the detriment -of Athens. He was ultimately impeached and compelled to go into -exile, 330 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Philoctétos</b>: Greek hero (in the expedition to Troy) left desolate -on the island of Lemnos, where he suffered deprivations and the -agonies of a gangrened foot.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Philopoemen</b>: (1) the most distinguished Greek soldier of his -day; head of the Achaean League several times from 208 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; -a man of culture and high character.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) controlling minister of Attalus II (q.v.).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Philótas</b>: there were several Macedonians of the name in the -service of Alexander. The two chief were (1) the son of Parmenio, -a favourite of Alexander, but found guilty of conspiracy and executed; -(2) a general who subsequently became governor of Cilicia.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Philotímus</b>: a distinguished physician and writer on medicine -of the date of Erasistratus and Herophilus (q.v.), <i>c.</i> 300 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Philóxĕnus</b>: a dithyrambic poet of high repute: <i>fl.</i> at Athens -400 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He thence moved to the court of Dionysius (q.v.), by whom -he is said to have been imprisoned for his scathing criticism on the -despot’s verses.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Phóciōn</b>: 402-317 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> An upright Athenian general and statesman, -who favoured, though probably not in an unpatriotic spirit, -the submission of Athens to the Macedonian power under Alexander -(335) and Antipater (q.v.). He was frequently opposed to Demosthenes, -and was put to death by his countrymen on a charge of -treason.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Phōcýlȋdes</b>: epic and elegiac poet of Miletus, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 530 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Many -of his lines passed into current maxims, and were so intended.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Phoenix</b>: a fugitive kindly received by Peleus and entrusted -with the bringing-up of his son Achilles. He had quarrelled with -his own father, whose young mistress he had corrupted at the request -of his jealous mother.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_288'>288</span><b>Pindar</b>: of Thebes, the most eminent lyrist of Greece, composer -of songs, choral and processional odes, dirges, &c.; lived <i>c.</i> 522-442 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Píttăcus</b>: of Mytilene, <i>c.</i> 650-569. Contemporary of Sappho. -During the struggles of the oligarchical and popular parties he was -appointed by the latter ‘elective autocrat’ and legislator. The chief -representative on the other side had been Myrsilus. A philosophic -poet and the originator of moral maxims.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Plato</b>: the aristocratic and cultured philosopher of Athens, -follower of Socrates, founder of the Academy, and writer of the -Dialogues which go under his name.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Pólĕmo</b>: (1) of Athens, who in his youth abandoned profligate -habits for the cult of the Platonic philosophy under the influence of -Xenocrates (q.v.), whom he succeeded 315 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) a Stoic philosopher, traveller, and geographer, who wrote -copiously on inscriptions, &c.; <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 195 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Polýbius</b>: Greek historian from Arcadia, carried to Italy by the -Romans 167 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, and taken under the patronage of Q. Fabius -Maximus and Scipio Aemilianus. He accompanied Scipio against -Carthage and in Spain. Wrote a sound, useful, unimaginative history -of the years 220-146 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A practical statesman and a student of the -military art.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Polycleitus</b> (-<b>clít</b>-): of Argos, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 450-412 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; a sculptor of the -first rank, particularly distinguished for his representation of human -forms, to which he imparted his ideals of strength and beauty -according to a ‘canon of proportions’. These were best typified -in his <i>Doryphorus</i> (‘spear-bearer’), which was itself sometimes called -‘the Canon’. His chief colossal statue was the chryselephantine -Hera of Argos.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Pontus</b>: in two senses: (1) the Black Sea; (2) a province or region -on the eastern half of the south coast of that sea.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Praxítĕles</b>: the second greatest name in Athenian sculpture; -<i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 365 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He is the head of the ‘later’ (or more graceful) Attic -school, Pheidias (q.v.) representing the earlier, more massive and -majestic. He particularly excelled with his statues of Aphrodite -(e.g. the ‘Venus of Cnidos’).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Priam</b>: aged king of Troy, father of Hector, whose dead body -he came to Achilles to ransom.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_289'>289</span><b>Priénë</b>: an Ionian Greek town in Asia Minor a little south of -Ephesus; the home of Bias.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Pródȋcus</b>: of Ceos, sophist and rhetorical teacher; a contemporary -of Plato and a frequent visitor to Athens. His bodily weakness was -notorious.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Prométheus</b>: mythical semi-deity, gifted with great foresight; -a benefactor of mankind by giving them fire stolen from heaven -(an offence for which he was cruelly punished by Zeus), and by the -invention of the civilizing arts. His name was commonly interpreted -‘Fore-thinker’.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Ptolemy</b>: (1) Ptolemy II (Philadelphus), king of Egypt 285-247 -<span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) Ptolemy III (Euergetes), king of Egypt 247-222 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'>(3) Ptolemy IV (Philopator), king 222-205 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; a vicious and -sensual monarch, ruled by his minister Sosibius.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(4) Ptolemy V (Epiphanes), king 205-181 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> See <i>Aristomenes</i>. -It was in the early part of his reign that Egypt became a Roman -protectorate. He came to the throne at the age of four.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Publius Nigidius</b>: contemporary of Cicero; a man of great -scientific and mathematical learning, as became a Pythagorean.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Pūpius Piso</b>: Roman orator, and consul in 61 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; a supporter -of Clodius and therefore hostile to Cicero.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Pyrrhus</b>: king of Epirus, called in by the people of Tarentum -against the Romans. After a dearly won victory in 280 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> he sent -his eloquent minister to Rome to offer humiliating terms of peace. -These were rejected, and after a practically equal contest he retired -from Italy.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Pythagoras</b>: of Samos, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 540-520 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He had apparently -travelled in the East and acquired, besides mathematical knowledge -(in which he made some advances), mystical theological views and probably -also his doctrine of the transmigration of souls. He migrated -to Croton in South Italy, and there became the founder of a close and -aristocratic philosophical brotherhood, to whom the word of the master -was sufficient (<i>ipse dixit</i>). Many legends gathered about him and a -mystical interpretation was put upon his rather compressed maxims.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Pythian</b>: = ‘belonging to Pytho’, i.e. to Delphi, the seat of the -chief oracle of Apollo.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_290'>290</span><b>Rhium</b>: the promontory on the south side of the mouth of the -Corinthian Gulf, the north promontory being Antirrhium.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Rusticus</b>: L. Junius Arulenus Rusticus, a Roman noble of the -Stoic school and champion of liberty, so far as that was possible under -the Roman emperors. Put to death by Domitian (emperor <span class='fss'>A.D.</span> -81-96).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Samius</b>: lyrist and writer of epigrams at the Macedonian court, -<i>c.</i> 300 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Scipio</b>: (1) P. Cornelius Scipio Africanus Major; the brilliant -and almost ideal Roman general who conquered Hannibal in 202 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) P. Cornelius Scipio Aemilianus Africanus Minor, who completed -the conquest of Carthage 146 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; a student of letters and philosophy.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Scirōn</b>: a spot on the Sacred Way from Athens to Eleusis.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Scyros</b>: island in the Aegean off north-east of Euboea. Here -Achilles was for a time hidden by his mother in woman’s dress, -and occupied in feminine tasks to keep him from the dangers of -Troy.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Seleucus</b>: called Callinicus (the ‘Victorious’); king of Syria -246-226 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He was defeated by Antiochus with the help of Gauls -(= Galatians) at Ancyra, and it was for a time thought that he had -perished in the rout. He managed, however, to retain his kingdom.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Silániōn</b>: Athenian portrait sculptor <i>c.</i> 324 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> His <i>Jocasta</i> -represented her as dying, her pallor being realistically rendered by -the unworthy device of mixing silver with bronze.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Siléni</b>: a class of tipsy satyrs associated with Dionysus. <i>The</i> -Silenus was in a sense the Falstaff of Greek legend.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Simónȋdes</b>: a most distinguished poet of Ceos, writer of elegies, -choral and processional odes, epigrams, and drinking songs (556-467 -<span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). He spent part of his life as a kind of court poet in Thessaly -and at Syracuse, and visited Athens. His compositions were of -a high order, and his moral maxims much in vogue, but he was -notorious for worldliness and a love of money.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Sísyphus</b>: legendary king of Corinth; type of fraudulent and -criminal cunning; punished in Hades by being compelled to roll -a stone up a hill for ever and never establishing it at the top.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Socrates</b>: the Athenian philosopher (468-399 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>), from whose -<span class='pageno' id='Page_291'>291</span>thinking most of the later schools were in some way descended. -His object was to bring philosophy down to earth, and to arrive at -true and universal definitions. His simple character, his whimsical -irony, and his dialectical skill formed the groundwork for many -stories. His method was conversational and non-didactic. He wrote -nothing, and what we know of him is due to his disciples Plato and -Xenophon, and to later writers.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Solōn</b>: of Athens, <i>c.</i> 638-558 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; aristocrat, trader, traveller, -poet and thinker. Chosen at a time of political and financial crisis -as mediator between parties in Attica, and as constitution-maker, -he behaved with strict impartiality and self-effacement. We may -believe that he visited Egypt, but his intercourse with Croesus (q.v.) -is of doubtful warrant. Author of much proverbial wisdom.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Sophocles</b>: 496-406 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; second in date, and perhaps in merit, -of three great Athenian tragedians; a genial and practical man of -the world.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Sótădes</b>: a poet at Alexandria <i>c.</i> 280 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He wrote songs and -satires of a lascivious kind. One account states that in consequence -of his abuse he was thrown into the sea in a leaden chest.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Speusippus</b>: of Athens, nephew and disciple of Plato, and his -successor as head of the Academy (347-339 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>); a writer on ethical -and dialectical subjects. His character is said to have excelled his -intellect.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Spínthărus</b>: the best known person of the name was an inferior -tragic poet of Heraclea on the Black Sea satirized by Aristophanes -and other comedians.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Stilpo</b>: a high-minded and sane philosopher of great dialectical -acuteness. Founder of the Megarian school, which made a cult of -virtue while denying the possibility of knowledge. See also under -Demetrius.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Sulla</b>: the distinguished Roman general, 138-78 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> He took -charge of the war against Mithridates in 87 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, his capture of Athens -taking place in the next year. His love of pleasure resulted in the -pimpled face referred to in Plutarch’s article on <i>Garrulity</i>. Caecilia -Metella was his fourth wife.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Sýbăris</b>: the oldest Greek settlement in the southernmost part -of Italy, once large, prosperous, and a by-word for effeminate luxury -<span class='pageno' id='Page_292'>292</span>(whence ‘sybarite’); afterwards completely overthrown and destroyed, -its place being taken by Thurii (q.v.).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Taenărum</b>: now Matapan; cape at the end of the middle prong -of the Peloponnese.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Télĕphus</b>: king of Mysia at the time of the Trojan war. He was -wounded by Achilles, and could only be cured by ‘that which had -wounded him’. The remedy turned out to be the rust of Achilles’ spear.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Tháïs</b>: a witty and beautiful courtesan of Athens, first associated -with Alexander during his Asiatic campaigns and then with Ptolemy -in Egypt.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Thales</b>: of Miletus, <i>c.</i> 635-555 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Famous as a physical philosopher, -mathematician, and shrewd practical man. He is regularly -mentioned first among the Seven Sages.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Theaetétus</b>: a high-minded Athenian youth, eager for knowledge, -who plays his part in Plato’s dialogue of that name.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Theágĕnes</b>: Theban general at Chaeronea (338 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Theánō</b>: wife or pupil (or both) of Pythagoras (q.v.), herself a -writer on philosophy and a pattern of virtue.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Themistŏcles</b>: became political leader at Athens 483 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>, and -commanded the Athenian contingent at the battle of Salamis. -Subsequently (471 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>) this extremely able, but apparently not -extremely honest, man was ostracised. His last days were spent -in the service of Persia. His son Diophantus is of no note.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Theócritus</b>: of Chios, rhetorician and sophist, noted for his caustic -wit. The Antigonus who put him to death was Antigonus the -‘One-Eyed’.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Theógnis</b>: elegiac poet of the sententious order. He flourished -at Megara <i>c.</i> 550-540 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Amid the feuds of his country he sides -with the aristocrats, and allusions to political injustice are frequent. -Many current maxims of proverbial wisdom were fathered on -‘Theognis’ as a matter of course.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Theōn</b>: painter of Samos, contemporary of Apelles (q.v.) and -Alexander; spoken of by Pliny as ‘next to the first’.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Theophrastus</b>: of Lesbos and afterwards of Athens; disciple -and successor of Aristotle as head of the Peripatetics (322 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>). An -encyclopaedic writer on logic, physics, history, biology, zoology, &c. -His best-known work is his <i>Characters</i>.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_293'>293</span><b>Theopompus</b>: king of Sparta, <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 750 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> To his reign -belonged the change of the form of government by the establishment -of the popular ‘ephors’ to control the royal power.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Thersítes</b>: misshapen and virulent demagogue in the Greek army -before Troy.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Thĕtis</b>: sea-goddess; mother of Achilles.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Thrasybúlus</b>: despot of Miletus, contemporary and friend of -Periander (q.v.), over whom he exercised a bad influence, as in advising -him to ‘cut down the tall poppies’.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Thúrii</b>: Greek city in South Italy on the west side of the Gulf -of Tarentum, noted for its special democratic system.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Tīmágĕnes</b>: an Alexandrian or Syrian rhetorician and historian. -He taught and wrote at Rome under Augustus, whose friendship -he obtained, losing it, however, through his caustic freedom.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Tīmocléa</b>: of Thebes. Plutarch tells of her noble and daring -spirit in his <i>Life of Alexander</i> (c. 12).</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Tīmomăchus</b>: painter of Byzantium, first century <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>; particularly -famed for his <i>Ajax</i> and <i>Medea</i>, which were bought by Julius -Caesar. Medea was represented meditating the murder of her children.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Timóthëus</b>: (1) an able and spirited Athenian general, who -obtained several rather roving successes, chiefly against the Lacedaemonians. -Something of a free lance; of popular character and -considerable culture; <i>fl.</i> 378-354 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) poet and musician of Miletus, settled at Athens; <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 400-360 -<span class='fss'>B.C.</span> His poems were mainly dithyrambs (high-flown and wordy -compositions) or cognate lyrics. His music, at first ill received on -account of its vulgarizing innovations, became immensely popular.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Tissaphernes</b>: Persian satrap of lower Asia Minor. See -Alcibiades.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Tīthónus</b>: a mortal beloved of Eos (Aurora), who obtained for -him immortality, but forgot to obtain him immortal youth.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Troezen</b>: a town in the east of the Peloponnese near the entrance -of the Saronic Gulf.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Tyndareus’ sons</b>: Castor and Pollux, the traditional preservers -of seamen.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Typhōn</b>: = Set; Egyptian malignant deity; brother, enemy, and -slayer of Osiris.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_294'>294</span><b>Xenócrătes</b>: 396-314 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span>: philosopher from Chalcedon, disciple -of Plato, and philosophic teacher and writer. His earnestness of -character and application to study atoned for his lack of the Graces. -Became head of the Academic school next but one after Plato.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Xenóphănes</b>: philosopher of Colophon, and afterwards of Elea in -Italy, in later part of sixth century <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> Noted for his high conception -of a Deity as neither anthropomorphic nor subject to human passions. -His doctrines were embodied in hexameter verse.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Xenophōn</b>: of Athens; the well-known historian, and leader of -the retreat of the ‘Ten Thousand’ as recorded in his <i>Anabasis</i>. -A philosophical adherent of Socrates and a voluminous writer. -Lived <i>c.</i> 444-359 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span></p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Zacýnthus</b> = Zante, the southernmost of the Ionian islands.</p> - -<p class='c005'><b>Zéno</b>: (1) of Citium in Cyprus and subsequently of Athens; -founder of the Stoic philosophy; a man of simple, if rather dour, -character, and capable of an apt retort: <i>fl.</i> <i>c.</i> 270 <span class='fss'>B.C.</span> A writer on -ethical, physical, and other philosophic subjects.</p> - -<p class='c005'>(2) Philosopher of Elea; disciple of Parmenides (q.v.); upholder -of popular liberty against a usurping despot.</p> -<div class='chapter'> - <span class='pageno' id='Page_295'>295</span> - <h2 id='appendix' class='c003'>APPENDIX <br /> NOTES ON THE GREEK TEXT</h2> -</div> -<p class='c004'>4 D ἐνίοτε γὰρ εἰδότες αἰσθομένοις μᾶλλον αὐτοῖς τοῦτο λεγόντων. -Read ... εἰδότες, (ἢ) αἰσθόμενοι ἢ καὶ ἄλλων αὐτοῖς τοῦτο λεγόντων.</p> - -<p class='c005'>5 C ἵνα μάθῃς ὅτι τῶν ἀναξίων τὰ τίμια οὐδὲν διαφέρει. The sense -requires ἀξίων ‘cheap’.</p> - -<p class='c005'>6 C πρὸς δὲ τούτοις τί ἄν τοὺς παῖδας ... καλὸν γάρ τοι κτλ. -The cause of the lacuna is obvious if we read τί ἄν τοὺς παῖδας -(καλὸν διδάσκοιεν;) καλὸν γάρ τοι κτλ.</p> - -<p class='c005'>7 B ἕως ἔτι μέμνημαι τῆς παιδείας. Rather ... (ταύτης) τῆς παιδείας.</p> - -<p class='c005'>7 F τὸ μὲν γὰρ εὐγενῶς εὐτυχεῖν ἀνδρός, τὸ δ᾽ ἀνεπιφθόνως εὐηνίου -ἀνθρώπου. Read τὸ μὲν γὰρ εὐγενῶς ἀτυχεῖν ἀνδρός, τὸ δ᾽ ἀνεπιφθόνως -εὐθηνεῖν ἀνθρώπου.</p> - -<p class='c005'>8 B καὶ ἀπὸ πηγῆς τὴν ἐπιστήμην τηρεῖν συμβέβηκεν. Read ἀπὸ -πείνης ...</p> - -<p class='c005'>8 D ἰσχνὸς δὲ στρατιώτης πολεμικῶν ἀγώνων ἐθὰς ἀθλητῶν καὶ -πολεμίων φάλαγγας διωθεῖ. Read ... ἀθλητῶν καταπιμέλων ...</p> - -<p class='c005'>8 F καὶ ταῦτα μὲν δὴ τῷ λόγῳ παρεφορτισάμην, ἵν᾽ ἐφεξῆς καὶ -τἄλλα ... συνάψω. Read ... νῦν δ᾽ ἐφεξῆς.</p> - -<p class='c005'>11 A ἵνα δὲ γέλωτα παράσχῃ τοῖς ἄλλοις, αὐτὸς πολὺν χρόνον -ἔκλαυσεν. We require the antithesis γέλωτα (βραχὺν) παράσχῃ.</p> - -<p class='c005'>12 E ὅτι δεῖ τὸν βίον ἐπιτηδεύειν καὶ μὴ δεῖν δεσμῷ προσάπτειν. -Read ... καὶ μηδενὶ δεσμῷ ...</p> - -<p class='c005'>13 B ὡς ἐκ λυρικῆς τέχνης. The sense requires νευροσπαστικῆς, -to which νευρικῆς may be equivalent.</p> - -<p class='c005'>14 C τὸ μὲν οὖν πάσας τὰς προειρημένας ... συμπεριλαβεῖν εὐχῆς -ἴσως ἢ παραινέσεως ἔργον ἐστί. The word most easily lost would -be (εὐημερίας). Also (μἂλλον) is to be supplied.</p> - -<p class='c005'>44 B ἐν τῷ καταφρονεῖν τιθέμενοι καὶ τὸ σεμνὸν ὑπεροψίᾳ διὼκοντες. -Read ἐν τῷ καταφρονεῖν (τὸ φρονεῖν) τιθέμενοι ...</p> - -<p class='c005'>46 B ᾠδήν τινα πεποιημένην ἐφ᾽ ἁρμονίας. Read ἐφ᾽ ἁρμονίας -(νέας) or the like.</p> - -<p class='c005'><span class='pageno' id='Page_296'>296</span>74 A τοιοῦτον γὰρ ἡ θεραπευτικὴ παρρησία ζητεῖ τρόπον, ἡ δὲ -πρακτικὴ τὸν ἐναντίον. The sense requires ἡ δὲ ταρακτικὴ ...</p> - -<p class='c005'>152 A εἰ μὴ μόνος εἴη φρόνιμος. Probably εἰ ἐμμόνως εἴη ...</p> - -<p class='c005'>152 D σὺ δὲ δεινὸς εἶ κοράκων ἐπαΐειν καὶ κολοιῶν, τῆς δὲ σοῦ -φωνῆς οὐκ ἀκριβῶς ἐξακούεις. For τῆς δὲ σοῦ (δεσου) read τῆς -(δεδουσ i.e.) δ᾽ Αἰδοῦς ...</p> - -<p class='c005'>158 D δεινὸν μὲν οὖν ... καὶ τὸ γεωργίας αὐτῇ. The sense -requires αὐτῆς.</p> - -<p class='c005'>159 D ὥσπερ ἐν μυλῶνι τῷ σώματι τὴν ψυχὴν ἐγκεκαλυμμένην. -Read ἐγκεκλῃμένην.</p> - -<p class='c005'>160 F ἐπὶ τὸν τόπον οἷ προσέμελλε. Read προσέκελλε.</p> - -<p class='c005'>163 D ... ἀπαντῆσαι μόνον ... θαλάττῃ ἕπεσθαι κτλ. The sense -would be given by ... ἀπαντῆσαι μόνον (θαρρῆσαι, τὸ δ᾽ ἀπαλλάττεσθαι, -καὶ ἐκ τῆς) θαλάττης ἕπεσθαι κτλ.</p> - -<p class='c005'>504 B ὅτι πρεσβύτης ἐστὶν ἐν Ἀθήναις παρὰ πότον σιωπᾶν δυνάμενος. -Rather ... πρεσβύτης (εἷς) ...</p> - -<p class='c005'>504 C ἀλλ᾽ ὅμως εἰπὼν καὶ ἀναφωνήσας ἐκεῖνο περὶ αὑτοῦ τὸ ... -Probably ἀλλ᾽ ὅμως (τὸ τοῦ Ὀδυσσέως) εἰπὼν κτλ.</p> - -<p class='c005'>513 A Φιλίππου γράψαντος εἰ δέχονται τῇ πόλει αὐτόν, εἰς χάρτην -ΟΥ μέγα γράψαντες ἀπέστειλαν. There would be more point in ... εἰς -χάρτην (τὴν αὐτὴν) ... Moreover, what they wrote was simply Ο.</p> - -<p class='c005'>514 F τὸ γὰρ μάτην καὶ διακενῆς οὐχ ἧττον ἐν τοῖς λόγοις ἢ τοῖς -ἔργοις ἔστιν. Read ... οὐχ ἧττον (εὐλαβητέον) ἐν ...</p> - -<p class='c005'>515 D ὅσσον ὕδωρ κατ᾽ Ἀλίζονος ἢ δρυὸς ἀμφὶ πέτηλα. Perhaps -ὅσσον ὕδωρ καταχεῖ νότος ἦ ...</p> - -<div class='nf-center-c1'> -<div class='nf-center c002'> - <div><span class='large'>Footnotes</span></div> - </div> -</div> - -<div class='footnote' id='f1'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r1'>1</a>. </span>The reproof might ostensibly be general, but its particular application -was readily felt. Musonius, we are told by Epictetus, made all his hearers -feel ‘as if some one had been talking to him about them’.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f2'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r2'>2</a>. </span>See <i>Concerning Busybodies</i>, 522 E.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f3'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r3'>3</a>. </span>Over and above his resemblances to Macaulay as a writer of essays and -biographical history, there is a distinct similarity between their conversational -tastes. We can imagine a Plutarch fully at home with -Macaulay at one of those astonishing early Victorian breakfast-parties -where a man might be asked if he ‘knew his Popes’, and where he might -be endured while he recited them. Plutarch’s <i>Table-Talk</i>, like his <i>Dinner-Party -of the Seven Sages</i>, reveals for contemporary Greek society the same -deliberate cult of intellectual conversation sharpened by challenge and -debate. In such conversation he must himself have played a conspicuous -part. Nevertheless, it may fairly be gathered that the Greek or Graeco-Roman -interlocutors in the reign of Trajan were the more ingenuously -athirst for reciprocal enlightenment, however dubiously we may regard -the value of the information or misinformation actually gained. Nor -is it easy to believe that Plutarch would have thought it etiquette to -indulge in the protracted monologues to which the more modern society -submitted with such grace as it best could.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f4'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r4'>4</a>. </span>e.g. in his <i>De repugnantiis Stoicorum</i> and his <i>Non posse suaviter vivi -secundum Epicurum</i>. Yet, as Mahaffy says, ‘it would be hard to say -whether the number of Stoic dogmas which he rejects exceeds that which -he quotes with approval’ (<i>The Greek World under Roman Sway</i>, pp. 300 sqq.).</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f5'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r5'>5</a>. </span>Volkmann names in particular Clement of Alexandria and Basil.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f6'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r6'>6</a>. </span>This does not mean that he had no friends among the rhetorical -teachers (the contrary is shown by his reference to ‘our Niger’ in <i>praec. -san.</i>, § 16), but only that he distrusted the type. He refused to approve -of a fluent and polished style as an end in itself. Pliny describes how -the amazingly voluble Isaeus would offer his audience a choice of subject -and allow it to dictate the side which he should take. He would then -rise and demonstrate his extemporizing powers with much show of -rhetorical ornament.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f7'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r7'>7</a>. </span>Volkmann says of the <i>Lives</i>, ‘Das Werthvolle an ihnen sind nicht die -historischen Details, die er giebt, sondern die eingestreuten Reflexionen, -die ethischen Betrachtungen, das Eingehen auf individuelle Stimmungen -und Leidenschaften der grossen Männer.’</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f8'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r8'>8</a>. </span><i>Aulicis tantum scripsit, non doctis</i>, says Scaliger.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f9'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r9'>9</a>. </span>Volkmann guesses that it is <i>ein Produkt der späteren Sophistik</i>. If so, -we may congratulate the Sophist on his perfect reproduction of Plutarch’s -style and of his non-sophistic tone.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f10'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r10'>10</a>. </span>Bacon’s Essay <i>Of Followers and Friends</i> owes almost nothing to -Plutarch beyond the title. We do, however, find him borrowing the words -‘for there is no such Flatterer as a Man’s selfe’.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f11'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r11'>11</a>. </span>As Volkmann happily puts it, he writes ‘with comfortable breadth’.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f12'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r12'>12</a>. </span>The sentences would doubtless have been easier still if Plutarch had -not felt bound to follow the fashion of the time and elaborately avoid -hiatus.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f13'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r13'>13</a>. </span>Perhaps this is why Plutarch, as seen through Amyot, appeared to -Montaigne ‘close and thorny,’ while his sense was nevertheless ‘closely-jointed -and pithily-continued’.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f14'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r14'>14</a>. </span>Stobaeus (sixth century) had access to much of Plutarch that is now -lost.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f15'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r15'>15</a>. </span>See an observation of Professor Summers, <i>Seneca Select Letters</i>, Introduction, -p. lxxiv.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f16'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r16'>16</a>. </span>Plutarch ‘is the theme of more than 230 allusions or direct references -on the part of Jeremy Taylor’ (Sandys, <i>A History of Classical Scholarship</i>, -i. 300).</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f17'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r17'>17</a>. </span>He was familiar reading of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, and -appears in the <i>Gesta Romanorum</i>. Later the <i>Adagia</i> of Erasmus draw -freely upon him.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f18'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r18'>18</a>. </span>‘Il a en quelque sorte créé Plutarque,’ says Demogeot.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f19'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r19'>19</a>. </span><i>Euphues</i> appeared in 1579. Jusserand (<i>The English Novel in the -Time of Shakespeare</i>, p. 127) remarks that Euphues ‘addresses moral -epistles to his fellow men to guide them through life’, but he appears to -be unaware that Lyly borrowed this object, as well as so large a quantity -of his matter, from Plutarch.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f20'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r20'>20</a>. </span>We meet, for example, with the story of Zeno, ‘the olde man in -Athens that amiddest the pottes could hold his peace.’</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f21'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r21'>21</a>. </span><i>History of Greek Classical Literature</i>, ii. 427.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f22'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r22'>22</a>. </span><i>The Literature of Ancient Greece</i>, p. 396.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f23'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r23'>23</a>. </span>Quoted by Sandys (<i>A History of Classical Scholarship</i>, i. 300).</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f24'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r24'>24</a>. </span>The home of Bias.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f25'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r25'>25</a>. </span>According to another account he waited till the shadow was equal -in length to the stick. The pyramid was then also equal in height to the -length of its shadow.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f26'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r26'>26</a>. </span>The divinities of spring-water.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f27'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r27'>27</a>. </span>The title <i>Lusios</i> or <i>Luaios</i> was popularly interpreted Deliverer (from -care or difficulty).</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f28'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r28'>28</a>. </span>See note on <i>Amasis</i>.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f29'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r29'>29</a>. </span>i.e. anointing himself, not in connexion with bathing, but with -exercise in the wrestling-schools.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f30'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r30'>30</a>. </span>The precise remark is uncertain, the text here being corrupt.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f31'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r31'>31</a>. </span>Equivalent to a command to ‘go weep’.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f32'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r32'>32</a>. </span>In antiquity these vessels were of bronze.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f33'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r33'>33</a>. </span>Which was bequeathed ‘to the wisest’. It was given to Thales, who -passed it on to another, and the process was repeated till it came back -to Thales, whereupon he dedicated it to Apollo.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f34'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r34'>34</a>. </span>The text here is corrupt.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f35'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r35'>35</a>. </span>i.e. Epicurean.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f36'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r36'>36</a>. </span>Member of a religious council which met at Delphi and represented -the chief states of all Greece.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f37'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r37'>37</a>. </span>Made of polished bronze.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f38'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r38'>38</a>. </span>Which contained ‘every charm: love, desire, and sweet converse’ -(Homer, <i>Il.</i> xiv. 214).</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f39'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r39'>39</a>. </span>The use of oil to soften the hair was practically universal.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f40'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r40'>40</a>. </span>A common punishment for a slave was to put him to hard labour -in turning the mill, in place of a horse or ass.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f41'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r41'>41</a>. </span>A frequent pretence of ancient witches.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f42'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r42'>42</a>. </span>These were farmed.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f43'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r43'>43</a>. </span>The Homeric σιγαλόεντα (‘glossy’) is brought, either in error or by -a deliberate pun, into relation with σιγή (‘silence’).</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f44'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r44'>44</a>. </span>The <i>paedagogus</i>, an attendant slave, who accompanied the boy and -watched over his conduct.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f45'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r45'>45</a>. </span>In his <i>Phaedrus</i>.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f46'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r46'>46</a>. </span>i. e. in the mixolydian mode, which was of a sad and dirgelike character.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f47'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r47'>47</a>. </span>The rest of the essay is missing.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f48'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r48'>48</a>. </span>i.e. a rough and mountainous island.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f49'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r49'>49</a>. </span>A ‘satyric’ drama was a half-comic interlude or sequel to tragedies.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f50'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r50'>50</a>. </span>In the Stoic sense of <i>adiaphoria</i>.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f51'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r51'>51</a>. </span>Since diagrams were often drawn with sticks in the dust.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f52'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r52'>52</a>. </span>The Greek jest does not admit of translation. The same word may -mean both ‘theft’ and a ‘stealthy act’.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f53'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r53'>53</a>. </span>The point lies in an ambiguity which is possible only in the Greek. -The words may equally mean: ‘You issued no invitation when sacrificing -your friends,’ and ‘when sacrificing, you did not invite your friends’.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f54'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r54'>54</a>. </span>Or what French would call the <i>gouverneur</i>.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f55'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r55'>55</a>. </span> This article is in all probability not the work of Plutarch. See the -Introduction.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f56'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r56'>56</a>. </span>The play upon words (<i>ēthikas</i>, ‘moral’ and <i>ĕthikas</i>, ‘of habit’) is not -adequately translatable.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f57'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r57'>57</a>. </span>The Greek text is here corrupt; the translation represents the -probable sense.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f58'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r58'>58</a>. </span>The Greek text is again faulty. The sense here given is approximate.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f59'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r59'>59</a>. </span>These maxims were probably in the first instance merely hygienic, -or even popular superstitions, but subsequently they received recondite -interpretations.</p> -</div> -<div class='footnote' id='f60'> -<p class='c005'><span class='label'><a href='#r60'>60</a>. </span>The Greek verse is doggerel, and no attempt is made to better it in -the English.</p> -</div> -<div> - - <ul class='ul_1 c002'> - <li>Transcriber’s Notes: - <ul class='ul_2'> - <li>Missing or obscured punctuation was silently corrected. - </li> - <li>Typographical errors were silently corrected. - </li> - <li>Inconsistent spelling and hyphenation were made consistent only when a predominant - form was found in this book. - </li> - <li>Footnotes have been collected at the end of the text, and are linked for ease of - reference. - </li> - </ul> - </li> - </ul> - -</div> - - - - - - - - -<pre> - - - - - -End of Project Gutenberg's Selected Essays of Plutarch, Vol. I., by Plutarch - -*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK SELECTED ESSAYS OF PLUTARCH *** - -***** This file should be named 62618-h.htm or 62618-h.zip ***** -This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: - http://www.gutenberg.org/6/2/6/1/62618/ - -Produced by Turgut Dincer, David King, and the Online -Distributed Proofreading Team at http://www.pgdp.net. (This -file was produced from images generously made available -by The Internet Archive.) - - -Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions will -be renamed. - -Creating the works from print editions not protected by U.S. copyright -law means that no one owns a United States copyright in these works, -so the Foundation (and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United -States without permission and without paying copyright -royalties. Special rules, set forth in the General Terms of Use part -of this license, apply to copying and distributing Project -Gutenberg-tm electronic works to protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm -concept and trademark. Project Gutenberg is a registered trademark, -and may not be used if you charge for the eBooks, unless you receive -specific permission. If you do not charge anything for copies of this -eBook, complying with the rules is very easy. You may use this eBook -for nearly any purpose such as creation of derivative works, reports, -performances and research. They may be modified and printed and given -away--you may do practically ANYTHING in the United States with eBooks -not protected by U.S. copyright law. Redistribution is subject to the -trademark license, especially commercial redistribution. - -START: FULL LICENSE - -THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE -PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK - -To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free -distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work -(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project -Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full -Project Gutenberg-tm License available with this file or online at -www.gutenberg.org/license. - -Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project -Gutenberg-tm electronic works - -1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm -electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to -and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property -(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all -the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or -destroy all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your -possession. If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a -Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound -by the terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the -person or entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph -1.E.8. - -1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be -used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who -agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few -things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works -even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See -paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project -Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this -agreement and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm -electronic works. See paragraph 1.E below. - -1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the -Foundation" or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection -of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual -works in the collection are in the public domain in the United -States. If an individual work is unprotected by copyright law in the -United States and you are located in the United States, we do not -claim a right to prevent you from copying, distributing, performing, -displaying or creating derivative works based on the work as long as -all references to Project Gutenberg are removed. Of course, we hope -that you will support the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting -free access to electronic works by freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm -works in compliance with the terms of this agreement for keeping the -Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with the work. You can easily -comply with the terms of this agreement by keeping this work in the -same format with its attached full Project Gutenberg-tm License when -you share it without charge with others. - -1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern -what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are -in a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, -check the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this -agreement before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, -distributing or creating derivative works based on this work or any -other Project Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no -representations concerning the copyright status of any work in any -country outside the United States. - -1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: - -1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other -immediate access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear -prominently whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work -on which the phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the -phrase "Project Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, -performed, viewed, copied or distributed: - - This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States and - most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no - restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it - under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this - eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the - United States, you'll have to check the laws of the country where you - are located before using this ebook. - -1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is -derived from texts not protected by U.S. copyright law (does not -contain a notice indicating that it is posted with permission of the -copyright holder), the work can be copied and distributed to anyone in -the United States without paying any fees or charges. If you are -redistributing or providing access to a work with the phrase "Project -Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the work, you must comply -either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 or -obtain permission for the use of the work and the Project Gutenberg-tm -trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. - -1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted -with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution -must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any -additional terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms -will be linked to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works -posted with the permission of the copyright holder found at the -beginning of this work. - -1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm -License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this -work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. - -1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this -electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without -prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with -active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project -Gutenberg-tm License. - -1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, -compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including -any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access -to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format -other than "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official -version posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site -(www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense -to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means -of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original "Plain -Vanilla ASCII" or other form. Any alternate format must include the -full Project Gutenberg-tm License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. - -1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, -performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works -unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. - -1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing -access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works -provided that - -* You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from - the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method - you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is owed - to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he has - agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the Project - Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments must be paid - within 60 days following each date on which you prepare (or are - legally required to prepare) your periodic tax returns. Royalty - payments should be clearly marked as such and sent to the Project - Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the address specified in - Section 4, "Information about donations to the Project Gutenberg - Literary Archive Foundation." - -* You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies - you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he - does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm - License. You must require such a user to return or destroy all - copies of the works possessed in a physical medium and discontinue - all use of and all access to other copies of Project Gutenberg-tm - works. - -* You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of - any money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the - electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days of - receipt of the work. - -* You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free - distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. - -1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project -Gutenberg-tm electronic work or group of works on different terms than -are set forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing -from both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and The -Project Gutenberg Trademark LLC, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm -trademark. Contact the Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. - -1.F. - -1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable -effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread -works not protected by U.S. copyright law in creating the Project -Gutenberg-tm collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm -electronic works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may -contain "Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate -or corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other -intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or -other medium, a computer virus, or computer codes that damage or -cannot be read by your equipment. - -1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right -of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project -Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project -Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project -Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all -liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal -fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT -LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE -PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE -TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE -LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR -INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH -DAMAGE. - -1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a -defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can -receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a -written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you -received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium -with your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you -with the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in -lieu of a refund. If you received the work electronically, the person -or entity providing it to you may choose to give you a second -opportunity to receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If -the second copy is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing -without further opportunities to fix the problem. - -1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth -in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS', WITH NO -OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT -LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. - -1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied -warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of -damages. If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement -violates the law of the state applicable to this agreement, the -agreement shall be interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or -limitation permitted by the applicable state law. The invalidity or -unenforceability of any provision of this agreement shall not void the -remaining provisions. - -1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the -trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone -providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in -accordance with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the -production, promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm -electronic works, harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, -including legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of -the following which you do or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this -or any Project Gutenberg-tm work, (b) alteration, modification, or -additions or deletions to any Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any -Defect you cause. - -Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm - -Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of -electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of -computers including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It -exists because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations -from people in all walks of life. - -Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the -assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's -goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will -remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project -Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure -and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future -generations. To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary -Archive Foundation and how your efforts and donations can help, see -Sections 3 and 4 and the Foundation information page at -www.gutenberg.org Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg -Literary Archive Foundation - -The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit -501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the -state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal -Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification -number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg Literary -Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent permitted by -U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. - -The Foundation's principal office is in Fairbanks, Alaska, with the -mailing address: PO Box 750175, Fairbanks, AK 99775, but its -volunteers and employees are scattered throughout numerous -locations. Its business office is located at 809 North 1500 West, Salt -Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887. Email contact links and up to -date contact information can be found at the Foundation's web site and -official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact - -For additional contact information: - - Dr. Gregory B. Newby - Chief Executive and Director - gbnewby@pglaf.org - -Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg -Literary Archive Foundation - -Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide -spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of -increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be -freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest -array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations -($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt -status with the IRS. - -The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating -charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United -States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a -considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up -with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations -where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To SEND -DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any particular -state visit www.gutenberg.org/donate - -While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we -have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition -against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who -approach us with offers to donate. - -International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make -any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from -outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. - -Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation -methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other -ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. To -donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate - -Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works. - -Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project -Gutenberg-tm concept of a library of electronic works that could be -freely shared with anyone. For forty years, he produced and -distributed Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of -volunteer support. - -Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed -editions, all of which are confirmed as not protected by copyright in -the U.S. unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not -necessarily keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper -edition. - -Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search -facility: www.gutenberg.org - -This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, -including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary -Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to -subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. - - - -</pre> - - </body> - <!-- created with ppgen.py 3.57c (with regex) on 2020-07-11 20:14:18 GMT --> -</html> diff --git a/old/62618-h/images/cover.jpg b/old/62618-h/images/cover.jpg Binary files differdeleted file mode 100644 index e318a0a..0000000 --- a/old/62618-h/images/cover.jpg +++ /dev/null |
