diff options
| author | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-14 18:36:49 -0700 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-14 18:36:49 -0700 |
| commit | 748d015190ce03fc797b883f2a8e8e3c22de679d (patch) | |
| tree | c300bb3ee7717de0c7b8172b020268be055b5d13 /44183-0.txt | |
Diffstat (limited to '44183-0.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | 44183-0.txt | 9476 |
1 files changed, 9476 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/44183-0.txt b/44183-0.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..eb4ddd4 --- /dev/null +++ b/44183-0.txt @@ -0,0 +1,9476 @@ +*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK 44183 *** + +Transcriber's note: + +Text enclosed by underscores is in italics (_italics_). + +Small capital text has been replaced with all capitals. + + * * * * * + + + + + BLACKWOOD'S + + EDINBURGH MAGAZINE. + + + + +PRINTED BY WILLIAM BLACKWOOD AND SONS, EDINBURGH. + + + + + BLACKWOOD'S + + Edinburgh + + MAGAZINE. + + VOL. LXV. + + JANUARY--JUNE, 1849. + + [Illustration: Buchanan] + + WILLIAM BLACKWOOD & SONS, EDINBURGH; + + AND + + 37, PATERNOSTER ROW, LONDON. + + 1849. + + + + + BLACKWOOD'S + + EDINBURGH MAGAZINE. + + NO. CCCXCIX. JANUARY, 1849. VOL. LXV. + + + + +CONTENTS. + + + THE YEAR OF REVOLUTIONS, 1 + + FRENCH CONQUERORS AND COLONISTS, 20 + + THE CAXTONS. PART IX., 33 + + THE WHITE NILE, 47 + + ART AND ARTISTS IN SPAIN, 63 + + THE DODO AND ITS KINDRED, 81 + + THE SWORD OF HONOUR: A TALE OF 1787, 98 + + MEMOIRS OF KIRKALDY OF GRANGE, 112 + + + EDINBURGH: + + WILLIAM BLACKWOOD AND SONS, 45, GEORGE STREET; + AND 37, PATERNOSTER ROW, LONDON. + + _To whom all Communications (post paid) must be addressed._ + + SOLD BY ALL THE BOOKSELLERS IN THE UNITED KINGDOM. + + PRINTED BY WILLIAM BLACKWOOD AND SONS, EDINBURGH. + + + + +BLACKWOOD'S + +EDINBURGH MAGAZINE + + NO. CCCXCIX. JANUARY, 1849. VOL. LXV. + + + + +THE YEAR OF REVOLUTIONS. + + +"No great state," says Hannibal, "can long remain quiet: if it +ceases to have enemies abroad, it will find them at home--as +powerful bodies resist all external attacks, but are wasted away +by their own internal strength."[1] What a commentary on the +words of the Carthaginian hero does the last year--THE YEAR OF +REVOLUTIONS,--afford! What enthusiasm has it witnessed, what +efforts engendered, what illusions dispelled, what misery produced! +How bitterly have nations, as well as individuals, within its +short bounds, learned wisdom by suffering--how many lessons has +experience taught--how much agony has wickedness brought in its +train. Among the foremost in all the periods of history, this +memorable year will ever stand forth, a subject of undying interest +to succeeding generations, a lasting beacon to mankind amidst the +folly or insanity of future times. To it the young and the ardent +will for ever turn, for the most singular scenes of social strife, +the most thrilling incidents of private suffering: to it the aged +will point as the most striking warning of the desperate effects of +general delusion, the most unanswerable demonstration of the moral +government of the world. + + [1] "Nulla magna civitas diu quiescere potest si foris hostem non + habet, _domi invenit_--ut prævalida corpora ab extremis causis tuta + videntur, sed suis ipsa viribas onerantur. Tantum, nimirum, ex + publicis malis sentimus, quantum ad res privatas pertmet; nec in eis + quicquam aerius, quam pecuniæ damnun, stimulat."--LIVY, xxx. 44. + +That God will visit the sins of the fathers upon the children was +proclaimed to the Israelites amidst the thunders of Mount Sinai, +and has been felt by every succeeding generation of men. But +it is not now upon the third or the fourth generation that the +punishment of transgression falls--it is felt in its full bitterness +by the transgressors themselves. The extension of knowledge, the +diffusion of education, the art of printing, the increased rapidity +of travelling, the long duration of peace in consequence of the +exhaustion of former wars, have so accelerated the march of events, +that what was slowly effected in former times, daring several +successive generations, by the gradual development of national +passions, is now at once brought to maturity by the fervent spirit +which is generally awakened, and the vehement passions which are +everywhere brought into action. + +Everything now goes on at the gallop. There is a railway speed in +the stirring of the mind, not less than in the movement of the +bodies of men. The social and political passions have acquired +such intensity, and been so widely diffused, that their inevitable +results are almost immediately produced. The period of seed-time and +harvest has become as short in political as it is in agricultural +labour. A single year brings its appropriate fruits to maturity in +the moral as in the physical world. Eighty years elapsed in Rome +from the time when the political passions were first stirred by +Tiberius Gracchus, before its unruly citizens were finally subdued +by the art, or decimated by the cruelty of Octavius. England +underwent six years of civil war and suffering, before the ambition +and madness of the Long Parliament were expelled by the purge of +Pride, or crushed by the sword of Cromwell: twelve years elapsed +between the convocation of the States-general in 1789, and the +extinction of the license of the French Revolution by the arm of +Napoleon. But, on this occasion, in one year, all, in the meantime +at least, has been accomplished. Ere the leaves, which unfolded +in spring amidst the overthrow of thrones, and the transports of +revolutionists over the world, had fallen in autumn, the passions +which had convulsed mankind were crushed for the time, and the +triumphs of democracy were arrested. A terrible reaction had set in; +experience of suffering had done its work; and swift as the shades +of night before the rays of the ascending sun, had disappeared +the ferment of revolution before the aroused indignation of the +uncorrupted part of mankind. The same passions may again arise; the +same delusions again spread, as sin springs up afresh in successive +generations of men; but we know the result. They will, like the ways +of the unrighteous, be again crushed. + +So rapid was the succession of revolutions, when the tempest +assailed the world last spring, that no human power seemed capable +of arresting it; and the thoughtful looked on in mournful and +impotent silence, as they would have done on the decay of nature +or the ruin of the world. The Pope began the career of innovation: +decrees of change issued from the Vatican; and men beheld with +amazement the prodigy of the Supreme Pontiff--the head of the +unchangeable Church--standing forth as the leader of political +reform. Naples quickly caught the flame: a Sicilian revolution +threatened to sever one-half of their dominions from the Neapolitan +Bourbon; and internal revolt seemed to render his authority merely +nominal in his own metropolis. Paris, the cradle in every age of +new ideas, and the centre of revolutionary action, next felt the +shock: a reform banquet was prepared as the signal for assembling +the democratic forces; the national guard, as usual, failed at the +decisive moment: the King of the Barricades quailed before the +power which had created him; the Orleans dynasty was overthrown, +and France delivered over to the dreams of the Socialists and the +ferocity of the Red Republicans. Prussia soon shared the madness: +the population of Berlin, all trained to arms, according to the +custom of that country, rose against the government; the king had +not energy enough to permit his faithful troops to act with the +vigour requisite to uphold the throne against such assailants, and +the monarchy of Frederick the Great was overthrown. Austria, even, +could not withstand the contagion: neither its proud nobility, nor +its light-hearted sensual people, nor its colossal army, nor its +centuries of glory, could maintain the throne in its moment of +peril. The Emperor was weak, the citizens of Vienna were infatuated; +and an insurrection, headed by the boys at the university and the +haberdashers' apprentices in the streets, overturned the imperial +government, and drove the Emperor to seek refuge in the Tyrol. All +Germany caught the flame: the dreams of a few hot-headed enthusiasts +and professors seemed to prevail alike over the dictates of wisdom +and the lessons of experience; and, amidst the transports of +millions the chimera or German unity seemed about to be realised by +the sacrifice of all its means of independence. The balance of power +in Europe appeared irrevocably destroyed by the breaking up of its +central and most important powers,--and England, in the midst of the +general ruin, seemed rocking to its foundation. The Chartists were +in raptures, the Irish rebels in ecstasy: threatening meetings were +held in every town in Great Britain; armed clubs were organised in +the whole south and west of Ireland; revolution was openly talked of +in both islands, and the close of harvest announced as the time when +the British empire was to be broken up, and Anglian and Hibernian +republics established, in close alliance with the great parent +democracy in France. Amidst such extraordinary and unprecedented +convulsions, it was with difficulty that a few courageous or +far-seeing minds preserved their equilibrium; and even those who +were least disposed to despair of the fortunes of the species, could +see no end to the succession of disasters with which the world +was menaced but in a great exertion of the renovating powers of +nature, similar to that predicted, in a similar catastrophe, for the +material world, by the imagination of the poet. + + "Roll on, ye stars! exult in youthful prime, + Mark with bright curves the printless steps of Time! + Near and more near your beaming cars approach, + And lessening orbs on lessening orbs encroach. + Flowers of the sky! ye, too, to Fate must yield, + Frail as your silken sisters of the field; + Star after star, from heaven's high arch shall rush, + Suns sink on suns, and systems systems crush; + Headlong, extinct, to one dark centre fall, + And Dark, and Night, and Chaos, mingle all; + Till, o'er the wreck, emerging from the storm, + Immortal Nature lifts her changeful form, + Mounts from her funeral pyre on wings of flame, + And soars and shines, another and the same."[2] + + [2] DARWIN, _Botanic Garden_. + +But the destiny of man, not less than that of the material world, +is balanced action and reaction, not restoration from ruin. Order +is preserved in a way which the imagination of the poet could +not have conceived. Even in the brief space which has elapsed +since the convulsions began in Italy in January last, the reality +and ceaseless action of the preserving laws of nature have been +demonstrated. The balance is preserved in social life by contending +passions and interests, as in the physical world by opposite +forces, under circumstances when, to all human appearance, remedy +is impossible and hope extinguished. The orbit of nations is traced +out by the Wisdom of Providence not less clearly than that of the +planets; there are centripetal and centrifugal forces in the moral +as well as in the material world. As much as the vehement passions, +the selfish desires, the inexperienced zeal, the expanding energy, +the rapacious indigence, the mingled virtues and vices of man, lead +at stated periods to the explosions of revolution,--do the desire +of tranquillity, the interests of property, the horror at cruelty, +the lessons of experience, the force of religion, the bitterness of +suffering, reinduce the desire of order, and restore the influence +of its organ, government. If we contemplate the awful force of the +expansive powers which, issuing from the great mass of central heat, +find vent in the fiery channels of the volcano, and have so often +rent asunder the solid crust of the earth, we may well tremble to +think that we stand suspended, as it were, over such an abyss, +and that at no great distance beneath our feet the elements of +universal conflagration are to be found.[3] But, strong as are the +expansive powers of nature, the coercive are still stronger. The +ocean exists to bridle with its weight the fiery gulf; the arch of +the earth has been solidly constructed by its Divine architect; and +the only traces we now discover, in most parts of this globe, of +the yet raging war of the elements, are the twisted strata, which +mark, as it were, the former writhings of matter in the terrible +grasp of its tormentors, or the splintered pinnacles of mountains, +which add beauty to the landscape, or the smiling plains, which +bring happiness to the abodes of man. It is the same in the moral +world. Action and reaction are the law of mind as well as matter, +and the equilibrium of social life is preserved by the opposite +tendency of the interests which are brought into collision, and +the counter-acting force of the passions which are successively +awakened by the very convulsions which seem to menace society with +dissolution. + + [3] "Thirty-five miles below the surface of the earth, the central + heat is everywhere so great, that granite itself is held in + fusion."--HUMBOLDT, _Cosmos_, i. 273. + +A year has not elapsed since the revolutionary earthquake began to +heave in Italy, since the volcano burst forth in Paris; and how +marvellous is the change which already has taken place in the state +of Europe! The star of Austria, at first defeated, and apparently +about to be extinguished in Italy, is again in the ascendant. +Refluent from the Mincio to the Ticino, her armies have again +entered Milan,--the revolutionary usurpation of Charles Emanuel has +been checked almost as soon as it commenced; and the revolutionary +rabble of Lombardy and Tuscany has fled, as it was wont, before +the bayonets of Germany. Radetzky has extinguished revolution in +northern Italy. If it still lingers in the south of the peninsula, +it is only because the strange and tortuous policy of France and +England has interfered to arrest the victorious arms of Naples +on the Sicilian shores. Paris has been the theatre of a dreadful +struggle, blood has flowed in torrents in its streets, slaughter +unheard-of stained its pavements, but order has in the end prevailed +over anarchy. A dynasty has been subverted, but the Red Republicans +have been defeated, more generals have perished in a conflict of +three days than at Waterloo; but the Faubourg St Antoine has been +subdued, the socialists have been overthrown, the state of siege +has been proclaimed; and, amidst universal suffering, anguish, and +woe, with three hundred thousand persons out of employment in Paris, +and a deficit of £20,000,000 in the income of the year, the dreams +of equality have disappeared in the reality of military despotism. +It is immaterial whether the head of the government is called a +president, a dictator, or an emperor--whether the civic crown is +worn by a Napoleon or a Cavaignac--in either case the ascendant of +the army is established, and France, after a brief struggle for a +constitutional monarchy, has terminated, like ancient Rome, in an +elective military despotism. + +Frankfort has been disgraced by frightful atrocities. The chief seat +of German unity and freedom has been stained by cruelties which +find a parallel only in the inhuman usages of the American savages; +but the terrible lesson has not been read in vain. It produced a +reaction over the world; it opened the eyes of men to the real +tendency and abominable iniquity of the votaries of revolution in +Germany; and to the sufferings of the martyrs of revolutionary +tortures on the banks of the Maine, the subsequent overthrow of +anarchy in Vienna and Berlin is in a great degree to be ascribed. +They roused the vacillating cabinets of Austria and Prussia--they +sharpened the swords of Windischgratz and Jellachich--they nerved +the souls and strengthened the arms of Brandenberg and Wrangel--they +awakened anew the chord of honour and loyalty in the Fatherland. +The national airs have been again heard in Berlin; Vienna has been +regained after a desperate conflict; the state of siege has been +proclaimed in both capitals; and order re-established in both +monarchies, amidst an amount of private suffering and general +misery--the necessary result of revolutions--which absolutely +sickens the heart to contemplate. England has emerged comparatively +unscathed from the strife; her time-honoured institutions have +been preserved, her monarchy saved amidst the crash of nations. +Queen Victoria is still upon the throne; our mixed constitution +is intact; the dreams of the Chartists have been dispelled; the +rebellion of the Irish rendered ridiculous; the loyalty of the +great body of the people in Great Britain made manifest. The period +of immediate danger is over; for the attack of the populace is +like the spring of a wild beast--if the first onset fails, the +savage animal slinks away into its den. General suffering indeed +prevails, industry languishes, credit is all but destroyed, a woful +deficiency of exports has taken place--but that is the inevitable +result of popular commotions; and we are suffering, in part at +least, under the effects of the insanity of nations less free and +more inexperienced than ourselves. Though last, not least in the +political lessons of this marvellous year, the papal government +has been subverted--a second Rienzi has appeared in Rome; and the +Supreme Pontiff, _who began the movement_, now a fugitive from his +dominions, has exhibited a memorable warning to future ages, of the +peril of commencing reforms in high places, and the impossibility +of reconciling the Roman Catholic religion with political +innovation. + +But let it not be imagined that, because the immediate danger is +over, and because military power has, after a fierce struggle, +prevailed in the principal capitals of Europe, that therefore the +ultimate peril is past, and that men have only to sit down, under +the shadow of their fig-tree, to cultivate the arts and enjoy the +blessings of peace. Such is not the destiny of man in any, least of +all in a revolutionary age. We are rather on the verge of an era +similar to that deplored by the poet:-- + + "Bella per Emathios plusquam civilia campos, + Jusque datum sceleri canimus, populumque potentem + In sua victrici conversum viscera dextrâ; + Cognatasque acies; et rupto f[oe]dera regni + Certatum totis concussi viribus orbis, + In commune nefas."[4] + + [4] LUCAN, i. 1-6. + +Who can tell the immeasurable extent of misery and wretchedness, +of destruction of property among the rich, and ruin of industry +among the poor, that must take place before the fierce passions, +now so generally awakened, are allayed--before the visions of a +virtuous republic by Lamartine, or the dreams of communism by +Louis Blanc and Ledru-Rollin, or the insane ideas of the Frankfort +enthusiasts have ceased to move mankind? The fire they have let +loose will burn fiercely for centuries; it will alter the destiny +of nations for ages; it will neither be quenched, like ordinary +flames, by water, nor subdued, like the Greek fire, by vinegar: +blood alone will extinguish its fury. The coming convulsions may +well be prefigured from the past, as they have been recently drawn +by the hand of a master:--"All around us, the world is convulsed +by the agonies of great nations; governments which lately seemed +likely to stand during ages, have been on a sudden shaken and +overthrown. The proudest capitals of western Europe have streamed +with civil blood. All evil passions--the thirst of gain and the +thirst of vengeance--the antipathy of class to class, of race to +race--have broken loose from the control of divine and human laws. +Fear and anxiety have clouded the faces, and depressed the hearts +of millions; trade has been suspended, and industry paralysed; +the rich have become poor, and the poor poorer. Doctrines hostile +to all sciences, to all arts, to all industry, to all domestic +charity--doctrines which, if carried into effect, would in thirty +years undo all that thirty centuries have done for mankind, and +would make the fairest provinces of France or Germany as savage +as Guiana or Patagonia--have been avowed from the tribune, and +defended by the sword. Europe has been threatened with subjugation +by barbarians, compared with whom the barbarians who marched under +Attila or Alboin were enlightened and humane. The truest friends of +the people have with deep sorrow owned, that interests more precious +than any political privileges were in jeopardy, and that it might be +necessary to sacrifice even liberty to save civilisation."[5] + + [5] MACAULAY's _History of England_, vol. ii. p. 669. + +It is now just a year since Mr Cobden announced, to an admiring +and believing audience at Manchester, that the age of warfare +had ceased; that the contests of nations had passed, like the +age of the mastodon and the mammoth; that the steam-engine had +caused the arms to drop from her hands, and the interests of free +trade extinguished the rivalries of nations; and that nothing now +remained but to sell our ships of war, disband our troops, cut +twenty millions off our taxation, and set ourselves unanimously to +the great work of cheapening everything, and underselling foreign +competitors in the market of the world. Scarcely were the words +spoken, when conflicts more dire, battles more bloody, dissensions +more inextinguishable than had ever arisen from the rivalry of +kings, or the ambition of ministers, broke out in almost every +country of Europe. The social supplanted the national passions. +Within the bosom of society itself, the volcano had burst forth. It +was no longer general that was matched against general, as in the +wars of Marlborough, nor nation that rose up against nation, as in +those of Napoleon. The desire of robbery, the love of dominion, the +lust of conquest, the passion for plunder, were directed to domestic +acquisitions. Human iniquity reappeared in worse, because less +suspected and more delusive colours. Robbery assumed the guise of +philanthropy; spoliation was attempted, under colour of law; plunder +was systematically set about, by means of legislative enactments. +Revolution resumed its old policy--that of rousing the passions by +the language of virtue, and directing them to the purposes of vice. +The original devil was expelled; but straightway he returned with +seven other devils, and the last state of the man was worse than the +first. Society was armed against itself; the devastating passions +burned in its own bosom; class rose against class, race against +race, interest against interest. Capital fancied its interest was +to be promoted by grinding down labour; labour, that its rights +extended to the spoliation of capital. A more attractive object +than the reduction of a city, or the conquest of a province, was +presented to indigent cupidity. Easier conquests than over rival +industry were anticipated by moneyed selfishness. The spoliation of +the rich at their own door--the division of the property of which +they were jealous, became the dream of popular ambition; the beating +down of their own labourers by free-trade, the forcible reduction +of prices by a contraction of the currency--the great object of the +commercial aristocracy. War reassumed its pristine ferocity. In the +nineteenth century, the ruthless maxim--_Væ victis!_ became the +war-cry on both sides in the terrible civil war which burst forth in +an age of general philanthropy. It may be conceived what passions +must have been awakened, what terrors inspired, what indignation +aroused by such projects. But though we have seen the commencement +of the _era of social conflicts_, is there any man now alive who is +likely to see its end? + +Experience has now completely demonstrated the wisdom of the Allied +powers, who placed the lawful monarchs of France on the throne in +1815, and the enormous error of the liberal party in France, which +conspired with the republicans to overthrow the Bourbon dynasty in +1830. That fatal step has bequeathed a host of evils to Europe: it +has loosened the authority of government in all countries; it has +put the very existence of freedom in peril by the enormity of the +calamities which it has brought in its train. All parties in France +are now agreed that the period of the Restoration was the happiest, +and the least corrupted, that has been known since the first +Revolution. The republicans of the present day tell us, with a sigh, +that the average budgets of the three last years of Charles X. were +900,000,000 francs, (£36,000,000;) that the expenditure was raised +by Louis Philippe at once to 1500,000,000 francs, (£60,000,000;) +and that under the Republic it will exceed 1800,000,000 francs, +(£72,000,000.) There can be no doubt of the fact; and there can +be as little, that if the Red Republicans had succeeded in the +insurrection of June last, the annual expenditure would have +increased to £100,000,000--or rather, a universal spoliation of +property would have ensued. Louis Blanc has given the world, in +his powerful historical work, a graphic picture of the universal +corruption, selfishness, and immorality, in public and private +life, which pervaded France during the reign of Louis Philippe.[6] +Though drawn by the hand of a partisan, there can be no doubt that +the picture is too faithful in most of its details, and exhibits +an awful proof of the effects of a successful revolution. But the +misery which Louis Blanc has so ably depicted, the corruptions he +has brought to light, under the revolutionary monarchy, have been +multiplied fourfold by those which have prevailed during the last +year in the republic established by Louis Blanc, himself! + + [6] LOUIS BLANC, _Histoire de Dix Ans de Louis Philippe_, iii. 321, + _et seq._ + +Paris, ever since the suppression of the great insurrection in +June last, has been in such a state, that it is the most utter +mockery to call it freedom. In truth, it is nothing but the most +unmitigated military despotism. A huge statue of liberty is placed +in the National Assembly; but at every six paces bayonets are to be +seen, to remind the bystanders of the rule of the sword. "Liberté, +Egalité, Fraternité," meet the eye at every turn in the streets; but +the Champs Elysées, the Place de Grève, the Carrousel, and Place +Vendôme, are crowded with soldiers; and the Champ de Mars is white +with tents, to cover part of the 40,000 regular troops which form +the ordinary garrison of Paris. Universal freedom of discussion has +been proclaimed by the constitution; but dozens of journals have +been suppressed by the authority of the dictator; and imprisonment +notoriously hangs over the head of every one who indulges in the +freedom of discussion, which in England and America is universal. +The state of siege has been raised, after having continued four +months; but the military preparations for _another siege_ continue +with unabated vigour on both sides. The constitution has been +adopted by a great majority in the Assembly; but the forts are all +armed, and prepared to rain down the tempest of death on the devoted +city. Universal suffrage is established; but menacing crowds are in +the streets, threatening any one who votes against their favourite +candidates. The Faubourg St Antoine, during the late election, was +in a frightful state of agitation; infantry, cavalry, and artillery, +were traversing the streets in all directions; and conflicts not +less bloody than those of June last were anticipated in the struggle +for the presidency, and prevented only by the presence of _ninety +thousand soldiers_ in the capital: a force greater than that +which fought on either side at Austerlitz or Jena. It is evident +that republican institutions, in such a state of society, are a +mere name; and that supreme despotic power is really invested in +France, as in ancient Rome under the emperors, in the nominee of a +victorious body of soldiery. The Prætorian guards will dispose of +the French as they did of the Roman diadem; and ere long, gratuities +to the troops will perhaps be the passport to power in Paris, as +they were in the Eternal City. + +Nor have the social evils, which in France have followed in the +wake of successful revolution, been less deplorable than the entire +destruction of the rights of freemen and security of property which +has ensued. To show that this statement is not overcharged, we +extract from a noted liberal journal of Paris, _La Reforme_, of +November 17, 1848, the following statement:-- + + "Property, manufactures, and commerce are utterly destroyed in + Paris. Of the population of that great city, the capital of + France, there are 300,000 individuals wanting the necessaries + of life. One half at least of those earned from 3f. to 5f. a + day previous to the revolution, and occupied a number of houses + in the faubourgs. The proprietors of those houses receiving no + rent, and having taxes and other charges to pay, are reduced + to nearly as deep distress as their tenants. In the centre of + Paris, the same distress exists under another form. The large + and sumptuous apartments of the fashionable quarters were + occupied before the revolution by wealthy proprietors, or by + persons holding lucrative employments in the public offices, + or by extensive manufacturers, but nearly all those have + disappeared, and the few who remain have insisted upon such a + reduction of rent that the proprietor does not receive one-half + of the amount to which he is entitled. Should a proprietor of + house property endeavour to raise a sum of money by a first + mortgage, to defray his most urgent expenses, he finds it + impossible to do so, even at a most exorbitant rate of interest. + Those who possess ready money refuse to part with it, either + through fear, or because they expect to purchase house property + when it must be sold at 50 per cent less than the value."--_La + Reforme_, November 17, 1848. + +It is certainly a most remarkable thing, in the history of the +aberrations of the human mind, that a system of policy which has +produced, and is producing, such disastrous results--and, above +all, which is inflicting such deadly and irreparable wounds on +the interests of the poor, and the cause of freedom throughout +the world--should have been, during the last eighteen years, the +object of unceasing eulogy by the liberal party on both sides of the +Channel; and that the present disastrous state of affairs, both in +this country and on the Continent, is nothing more than the natural +and inevitable result of the principles that party has everywhere +laboured to establish. The revolution of 1830 was hailed with +enthusiasm in this country by the whole liberal party: the Irish are +not more enamoured now of the revolution of 1848, than the Whigs +were, eighteen years ago, of that of 1830. The liberal government +of England did all in their power to spread far and wide the +glorious example. Flanders was attacked--an English fleet and French +army besieged Antwerp; and, by a coalition of the two powers, a +revolutionary throne was established in Belgium, and the king of the +Netherlands prevented from re-establishing the kingdom guaranteed +to him by all the powers of Europe. The Quadruple Alliance was +formed to revolutionise Spain and Portugal; a sanguinary civil +war was nourished for long in both kingdoms; and at length, after +years of frightful warfare, the legitimate monarch, and legal order +of succession, were set aside in both countries; queens were put +on the thrones of both instead of kings, and England enjoyed the +satisfaction, for the diffusion of her revolutionary propagandism, +of destroying the securities provided for the liberties of Europe by +the treaty of Utrecht, and preparing a Spanish princess for the hand +of a Bourbon prince. + +Not content with this memorable and politic step, and even after +the recent disasters of France were actually before their eyes, our +rulers were so enamoured of revolutions, that they could not refrain +from encouraging it in every _small_ state within their reach. +Lord Palmerston counseled the Pope, in a too celebrated letter, to +plunge into the career which has terminated so fatally for himself +and for Italy. Admiral Parker long prevented the Neapolitan force +from embarking for Sicily, to do there what Lord Hardinge was nearly +at the same time sent to do in Ireland. We beheld the Imperial +standards with complacency driven behind the Mincio; but no sooner +did Radetzky disperse the revolutionary army, and advance to Milan, +than British and French diplomacy interfered to arrest his march, +and save their revolutionary protégé, the King of Piedmont, from the +chastisement which his perfidious attack on Austria in the moment of +her distress merited. The Ministerial journals are never weary of +referring to the revolutions on the Continent as the cause of all +the distress which has prevailed in England, since they broke out +in last spring: they forget that it was England herself which first +unfurled the standard of revolution, and that, if we are suffering +under its effects, it is under the effects of our own measures and +policy. + +Strange and unaccountable as this perverted and diseased state +of opinion, in a large part of the people of this country, +undoubtedly is, it is easily explained when the state of society, +and the channel into which political contests have run, are taken +into consideration. In truth, our present errors are the direct +consequence of our former wisdom; our present weakness, of our +former strength; our present misery, of our former prosperity. + +In the feudal ages, and over the whole Asiatic world at the present +time, the contests of parties are carried on for _individuals_. No +change of national policy, or of the system of internal government, +is contemplated on either side. It is for one prince or another +prince, for one sultaun or another sultaun, that men draw their +swords. "Under which King, Bezonian?--speak or die!" is there +the watch-word of all civil conflict. It was the same in this +country during the feudal ages, and down to a very recent period. +No man in the civil wars between Stephen and Henry II., or of the +Plantagenet princes, or in the wars of the Roses, contemplated or +desired any change of government or policy in the conflict in which +they were engaged. The one party struck for the Red, the other for +the White Rose. Great civil and social interests were at issue in +the conflict; but the people cared little or nothing for these. +The contest between the Yorkists and the Lancastrians was a great +feud between two clans which divided the state; and the attachment +to their chiefs was the blind devotion of the Highlanders to the +Pretender. + +The Reformation, which first brought the dearest objects of thought +and interest home to all classes, made a great change in this +respect, and substituted in large proportion general questions for +the adherence to particular men, or fidelity to particular families. +Still, however, the old and natural instinct of the human race to +attach themselves to men, not things, continued, in a great degree, +to influence the minds of the people, and as many buckled on their +armour for the man as the cause. The old Cavaliers, who periled +life and lands in defence of Charles I., were as much influenced +by attachment to the dignified monarch, who is immortalised in the +canvass of Vandyke, as by the feelings of hereditary loyalty; and +the iron bands which overthrew their ranks at Marston Moor, were as +devoted to Cromwell as the tenth legion to Cæsar, or the Old Guard +to Napoleon. In truth, such individual influences are so strongly +founded in human nature, that they will continue to the end of the +world, from whatever cause a contest may have arisen, as soon as +it has continued for a certain time, and will always stand forth +in prominent importance when a social has turned into a military +conflict, and the perils and animosities of war have endeared their +leaders to the soldiers on either side. The Vendeans soon became +devoted to Henri Larochjaquelein, the Republicans to Napoleon; +and in our own times, the great social conflict of the nineteenth +century has been determined by the fidelity of the Austrian +soldiers to Radetzky, of the French to Cavaignac, of the German to +Windischgratz. + +But in the British empire, for a century past, it has been +thoroughly understood, by men of sense of all parties, that a change +of dynasty is out of the question, and that there is no reform worth +contending for in the state, which is not to be effected by the +means which the constitution itself has provided. This conviction, +long impressed upon the nation, and interwoven as it were with the +very framework of the British mind, having come to coincide with the +passions incident to party divisions in a free state, has in process +of time produced the strange and tortuous policy which, for above a +quarter of a century, has now been followed in this country by the +government, and lauded to the skies by the whole liberal party on +the Continent. Deprived of the watchwords of men, the parties have +come to assume those of things. Organic or social change have become +the war-cry of faction, instead of change of dynasty. The nation is +no longer drenched with blood by armies fighting for the Red or the +White Rose, by parties striving for the mastery between the Stuart +and Hanover families, but it was not less thoroughly divided by +the cry of "The bill, the whole bill, and nothing but the bill," +at one time, and that of "Free-trade and cheap corn" at another. +Social change, alterations of policy, have thus come to be the great +objects which divide the nation; and, as it is ever the policy of +Opposition to represent the conduct of Government as erroneous, +it follows, as a necessary consequence, that the main efforts of +the party opposed to administration always have been, since the +suppression of the Rebellion in 1745, to effect, when in opposition, +a change in general opinion, and, when in power, to carry that +change into effect by a change of policy. The old law of nature +is still in operation. Action and reaction rule mankind; and in +the efforts of parties mutually to supplant each other in power, a +foundation is laid for an entire change of policy at stated periods, +and an alteration, as great as from night to day, in the opinions +and policy of the ruling party in the same state at different times. + +The old policy of England--that policy under which, in the words +of Macaulay, "The authority of law and the security of property +were found to be compatible with a liberty of discussion and +of individual action never known before; under which form, the +auspicious union of order and freedom, sprang a prosperity of which +the annals of human affairs had furnished no example; under which +our country, from a state of ignominious vassalage, rapidly rose to +the place of umpire among European powers; under which her opulence +and martial glory grew together; under which, by wise and resolute +good faith, was gradually established a public credit, fruitful +of marvels which, to the statesmen of any former age, would have +appeared incredible; under which a gigantic commerce gave birth to +a maritime power, compared with which every other maritime power, +ancient or modern, sinks into insignificance; under which Scotland, +after ages of enmity, was at length united to England, not mere by +legal bonds, but by indissoluble ties of interest and affection; +under which, in America, the British colonies rapidly became far +mightier and wealthier than the realms which Cortes and Pizarro +added to the dominions of Charles V.; under which, in Asia, British +adventurers founded an empire not less splendid, and more durable, +than that of Alexander,"[7]--was not the policy of any particular +party or section of the community, and thence its long duration and +unexampled success. + + [7] MACAULAY's _History_, i. 1-2. + +It was not introduced--it grew. Like the old constitution, of which +it was the emanation, it arose from the wants and necessities of +all classes of men during a long series of ages. It was first +proclaimed in energetic terms by the vigour of Cromwell; the cry of +the national representatives for markets to native industry, of the +merchants, for protection to their ships, produced the Navigation +Laws, and laid the foundation of the colonial empire of England. +Amidst all his _insouciance_ and folly in the drawing-room of the +Duchess of Portsmouth, and the boudoirs of the Duchess of Cleveland, +it was steadily pursued by Charles II. James II. did not lose sight +of this same system, amidst all his infatuation and cruelty; when +directing the campaign of Jeffreys in the west, he was as steadily +bent on upholding and extending the navy as when, amidst the +thunders of war, he combated de Ruyter and van Tromp on the coast +of Holland. William III., Anne, and the Georges, pursued the same +system. It directed the policy of Somers and Godolphin; it ruled the +diplomacy of Walpole and Chatham; it guided the measures of Bute +and North; it directed the genius of Pitt and Fox. It was for it +that Marlborough conquered, and Wolfe fell; that Blake combated, and +Hawke destroyed; that Nelson launched the thunderbolt of war, and +Wellington carried the British standard to Madrid and Paris. + +It was the peculiar structure of the English constitution, during +this century and a half of prosperity and glory, that produced so +remarkable a uniformity in the objects of the national policy. These +objects were pursued alike by the Republicans and the Royalists; by +the Roundheads and the Cavaliers; by the Whigs, during the seventy +years of their rule that followed the Revolution, and the Tories, +during the sixty years that succeeded the accession of George III. +The policy was that of _protection to all the national interests, +whether landed, commercial, colonial, or manufacturing_. Under this +system they all grew and prospered, _alike and abreast_, in the +marvellous manner which the pencil of Macaulay has sketched in the +opening of his History. It was hard to say whether agriculture, +manufactures, colonies, or shipping throve and prospered most +during that unique period. The world had never seen anything like +it before: it is doubtful if it will ever see anything like it +again. Under its shelter, the various interests of the empire were +knit together in so close a manner, that they not only all grew +and prospered together, but it was universally felt that their +interests were entirely dependent on each other. The toast "The +plough, the loom, and the sail," was drunk with as much enthusiasm +in the farmers' club as in the merchant's saloon. As varied as the +interests with which they were charged, the policy of government was +yet perfectly steady in following out one principle--the protection +of the _productive classes_, whether by land or water, whether at +home or abroad. + +The legislature represented and embodied all these interests, and +carried out this policy. It gave them a stability and consistency +which had never been seen in the world before. Nominally the +representatives of certain towns and counties in the British +islands, the House of Commons gradually became really the +representatives of the varied interests of the whole British empire. +The nomination boroughs afforded an inlet alike to native talent +and foreign interests. Gatton and Old Sarum, or similar close +boroughs, afforded an entrance to the legislature, not only to the +genius of Pitt and Fox, of Burke and Sheridan, but to the wealth +of Jamaica, the rising energy of Canada, the aged civilisation of +Hindostan. Experienced protection reconciled all interests to a +government under which all prospered; mutual dependence made all +sensible of the necessity of common unanimity. The statute-book +and national treaties, from the Revolution in 1688 to the close +of the war with Napoleon in 1815, exhibit the most decisive proof +of the working of these varied, but not conflicting interests, in +the national councils. If you contemplate the general protection +afforded to agriculture and the landed interest, you would imagine +the House of Commons had been entirely composed of squires. If you +examine the innumerable enactments, fiscal and prohibitory, for the +protection of manufactures, you would suppose it had been entirely +under the government of manufacturers. If you contemplate the steady +protection invariably given to the mercantile navy, you would +suppose it had been chiefly directed by shipowners. If you cast your +eyes on the protection constantly given by discriminating fiscal +duties to colonial industry, and the vast efforts made, both by sea +and land, in the field and in the cabinet, to encourage and extend +our colonial dependencies, you would conclude, not only that they +were represented, but that their representatives had a majority in +the legislature. + +The reason of this prodigy was, that all interests had, in the +course of ages, and the silent effects of time, worked their +way into the legislature, and all enjoyed in fair proportion a +reasonable influence on government. Human wisdom could no more _ab +ante_ have framed such a system, than it could have framed the +British constitution. By accident, or rather the good providence +of God, it grew up from the wants of men during a series of +generations; and its effects appeared in this, that--except in the +cases of the American war, where unfortunate circumstances produced +a departure from the system; of the Irish Celts, whom it seems +impracticable to amalgamate with Saxon institutions; and of the +Scottish Highlanders, whom chivalrous honour for a short period +alienated from the established government--unanimity unprecedented +during the whole period pervaded the British empire. All foreign +colonies were desirous to be admitted into the great protecting +confederacy; the French and Dutch planters in secret prayed for +the defeat of their defenders when the standard of St George +approached their shores. The Hindoos, with heroic constancy, alike +in prosperous and adverse fortune, maintained their fidelity: Canada +stood firm during the most dangerous crisis of our history; and the +flame of loyalty burned as steadily on the banks of the St Lawrence, +on the mountains of Jamaica, and on the shores of the Ganges, as in +the crowded emporiums of London, or the smiling fields of Yorkshire. + +But there is a limit imposed by nature to all earthly things. +The growth of empires is restrained, after they have reached a +certain stature, by laws as certain as those which arrest that of +individuals. If a state does not find the causes of its ruin in +foreign disaster, it will inevitably find it in internal opinion. +This arises so naturally and evidently from the constitution of the +human mind, that it may be regarded as a fixed law of nature in all +countries where intellectual activity has been called forth, and +as one of the most powerful agents in the government, by supreme +Wisdom, of human affairs. This principle is to be found in the +tendency of _original_ thought to differ from the current opinion +with which it is surrounded, and of party ambition to decry the +system of those by whom it is excluded from power. + +Universally it will be found that the greatest exertions of human +intellect have been made in _direct opposition_ to the current of +general opinion; and that public thought in one age is in general +but the echo of solitary meditation in that which has preceded +it. Illustrations of this crowd on the reflecting mind from every +period of history. The instances of Luther standing forth alone to +shake down, Samson-like, the pillar of the corrupted Romish faith; +of Bacon's opening, amid all the despotism of the Aristotelian +philosophy, his inductive philosophy; of Galileo maintaining the +motion of the earth even when surrounded by the terrors of the +Italian Inquisition; of Copernicus asserting the true system of +the heavens in opposition to the belief of two thousand years; +of Malthus bringing forward the paradox of the danger of human +increase in opposition to the previous general opinion of mankind; +of Voltaire combating alone the giant power of the Roman Catholic +hierarchy; of Rousseau running a course against the whole ideas +of his age--will immediately occur to every reader. Many of these +great men adopted erroneous opinions, and, in consequence, did as +much evil to their own or the next age as others did good; but they +were all characterised by one mark. Their opinions were _original_, +and directly adverse to public opinion around them. The close of +the nineteenth century was no exception to the general principle. +Following out those doctrines of freedom from restraint of every +kind, which in France had arisen from the natural resistance of +men to the numerous fetters of the monarchy, and which had been +brought forward by Turgot and the Economists, in the boudoirs of +Madame Pompadour and the coteries of Paris,--Adam Smith broached the +principle of Free Trade, with the exceptions of grain and shipping. +The first he excepted, because it was essential to national +subsistence; the second, because it was the pillar of national +defence. The new philosophy was ardently embraced by the liberal +party, who, chagrined by long exclusion from office, were rejoiced +to find a tangible and plausible ground whereon to attack the whole +existing system of government. From them it gradually extended to +nearly all the ardent part of the community, ever eager to embrace +doctrines at variance with previous and vulgar belief, and not yet +enlightened by experience as to the effect of the new system. It was +soon discovered that for a century and a half we had been proceeding +on false principles. The whole policy of government since the days +of Cromwell had been erroneous; in politics, in social government, +in diplomacy, in the colonies, in war, in peace, at home and abroad, +we had been running blindfold to destruction. True, we had become +great, and glorious, and free under this abominable system; true, it +had been accompanied by a growth of national strength, and an amount +of national happiness, unparalleled in any former age or country; +but that was all by accident. Philosophy had marked it with the +sign of reprobation--prosperity had poured upon us by chance in the +midst of universal misgovernment. By all the rules of calculation +we should have been destroyed, though, strange to say, no symptoms +of destruction had yet appeared amongst us. According to every +principle of philosophy, the patient should long ago have been dead +of the mortal disease under which he laboured: the only provoking +thing was, that he was still walking about in robust and florid +health. + +Circumstances occurred at the same time, early in this century, +which had the most powerful effect in exasperating the Opposition +party throughout the country, and inducing them to embrace, +universally and ardently, the new philosophy, which condemned in +such unmeasured terms the whole system of government pursued by +their antagonists. For half a century, since the long dominion of +the Whigs was terminated in 1761 by George III., the Tories had +been, with the exception of a few months, constantly in office. +Though their system of government in religion, in social affairs, +in foreign relations, was nothing but a continuation of that which +the Whigs had introduced, and according to which the government had +been conducted from 1688 to 1760, yet, in the ardour of their zeal +for the overthrow of their adversaries, the liberal party embraced +on every point the opposite side. The descendants of Lord Russel +became the advocates of Roman Catholic emancipation; the followers +of Marlborough and Godolphin, the partisans of submission to France; +the successors of Walpole and Chatham, the advocates of free trade +and colonial neglect. These feelings, embraced from the influence of +a determination to find fault with government in every particular, +were worked up to the highest pitch by the glorious result of the +war with France, and the apparently interminable lease of power +acquired by their adversaries from the overthrow of Napoleon. That +memorable event, so opposite to that which they had all so long +in public predicted, so entirely the reverse of that which many +had in secret wished, produced a profound impression on the Whig +party. Their feelings were only the more acute, that, amidst the +tumult of national exultation, they were forced to suppress them, +and to wear the countenance of satisfaction, when the bitterness of +disappointment was in their hearts. To the extreme asperity of these +feelings, and the universal twist which they gave to the minds of +the whole liberal party in Great Britain, the subsequent general +change in their political principles is to be ascribed; and, in the +practical application of these principles, the real cause of our +present distressed condition is to be found. + +While one set of causes thus prepared, in the triumph of +Conservative and protective principles, the strongest possible +reaction against them, and prognosticated, at no distant period, +their general banishment from popular thought, another, and a +not less powerful set, flowing from the same cause, gave these +principles the means of acquiring a political supremacy, and ruling +the government of the state. The old policy of England, it has +been already observed, for a hundred and fifty years, had been to +take care of the producers, and let the consumers take care of +themselves. Such had been the effects of this protective policy, +that, before the close of the Revolutionary war, during which it +received its full development, the producing classes, both in town +and country, had become so rich and powerful, that it was easy +to see they would ere long give a preponderance to urban over +rural industry. The vast flood of agricultural riches poured for +expenditure into towns; that of the manufacturers and merchants +seldom left it. The great manufacturing and mercantile places, +during a century, had advanced in population tenfold, in wealth +thirty-fold. The result of this change was very curious, and in +the highest degree important. Under the _shadow of protection_ to +industry in all its branches, riches, both in town and country, had +increased so prodigiously, that the holders of it had _acquired +a preponderance over the classes in the state yet engaged in the +toilsome and hazardous work of production_. The owners of realised +capital had become so numerous and weighty, from the beneficial +effects of the protective system under which the country had so long +flourished, that they formed an important _class apart, which began +to look to its separate interests_. The consumers had become so +numerous and affluent, that they were enabled to bid defiance to the +producers. The maxim became prevalent, "Take care of the consumer, +and let the producer take care of himself." Thence the clamour for +free trade. Having passed the labour of production, during which +they, or their fathers, had strenuously supported the protective +principles, by which they were making their money, the next thing +was to support the opposite principles, by which the value of the +_made money might be augmented_. This was to be done by free trade +and a contracted currency. Having made millions by protection, the +object now was to add a half to every million by raising its value. +The way to do this seemed to be by cheapening the price of every +other article, and raising the price of money: in other words, the +system of cheapening everything without reference to its effect on +the interests of production. + +Parliamentary reform, for which the Whigs, disappointed by long +exclusion from office, laboured strenuously, in conjunction with +the commercial and moneyed classes, enriched by protection, gave +them the means of carrying both objects into execution, because +it made two-thirds of the House of Commons the representatives of +burghs. The cry of cheap bread was seductive to all classes in +towns:--to the employer, because it opened the prospect of reducing +the price of labour, and to the operative, because it presents that +of lowering that of provisions. To these two objects, accordingly, +of raising the value of money and lowering the remuneration of +industry, the Reform parliament, the organ of the moneyed interest +and consuming classes, has, through all the changes of party, been +perfectly steady. It is no wonder it has been so, for it was the +first-born of those interests. Twenty years before the cry for +reform convulsed the nation--in 1810--the Bullion Committee brought +forward the principle of a metallic, and, consequently, a contracted +currency; and they recommended its adoption in the very crisis of +the war, when Wellington lay at Torres Vedras, and when the monetary +crisis to which it must have led would have made us a province of +France. Reform was the consequence of the change in the currency, +not its cause. The whole time from 1819 to 1831, with the exception +of 1824 and 1825, was one uninterrupted period of suffering. Such +was the misery it produced that the minds of men were prepared +for any change. A chaos of unanimity was produced by a chaos of +suffering. + +Thus, by a singular and most interesting chain of causes and +effects, it was the triumph of Conservative and protective +principles in the latter years of the war, and the entire +demonstration thus afforded of their justice and expedience, +which was the immediate cause of their subsequent abandonment, +and all the misery which has thence arisen, and with which we +are still everywhere surrounded. For it at once turned all the +intellectual energies of the great liberal party to oppose, in +every particular, the system by which their opponents had been +glorified, and concentrated all the energies of the now powerful +moneyed classes to swell, by a change of policy, the fortunes on +which their consequence depended, and which had arisen from the +long prevalence of the opposite system. For such is the tendency to +action and reaction, in all vigorous and intellectual communities, +that truth itself is for long no security against their occurrence. +On the contrary, so vehement are the passions excited by a great +and lasting triumph of one party, even though in the right, that +the victory of truth, whether in politics or religion, is often +the immediate cause of the subsequent triumph of error. The great +Roman Catholic reaction against the Reformation, which Ranke has so +clearly elucidated, and Macaulay has so powerfully illustrated, has +its exact counterpart in the great political reaction of the Whig +party, of which Macaulay is himself the brightest ornament. + +That this is the true explanation of the strange and tortuous +policy, both in domestic and foreign affairs, under which the +nation has so long suffered, is apparent on the slightest survey of +political affairs in the last and present century. + +The old principle of the English constitution, which had worked +itself into existence, or grown up from the necessities of men, +during a long course of years, was, that the whole _interests_ of +the state should be represented, and that the House of Commons +was the assembly in which the representatives of all those varied +interests were to be found. For the admission of these varied +interests, a varied system of electoral qualifications, admitting +all interests, noble, mercantile, industrial, popular, landed, and +colonial, was indispensable. In the old House of Commons, all these +classes found a place for their representatives, and thence the +commercial protection it afforded to industry. According to the new +system, a vast majority of seats was to be allotted to _one class +only_, the householders and shopkeepers of towns. That class was the +moneyed and consuming class; and thence the whole subsequent course +of British policy, which has been to sacrifice everything to their +interests. + +The old maxim of government, alike with Whigs and Tories, was, that +native industry of all sorts, and especially agricultural industry, +was to be protected, and that foreign competition was to be admitted +only in so far as was not inconsistent with this primary object. +The new philosophy taught, and the modern liberals carried into +execution, a different principle. They went on the maxim that the +interests of the consumers alone were to be considered: that to +cheapen everything was the great object; and that it mattered not +how severely the producers of articles suffered, provided those +who purchased them were enabled to do so at a reduced rate. This +policy, long lauded in abstract writings and reviews, was at length +carried into execution by Sir R. Peel, by the tariff of 1842 and +the free-trade measures of 1846. + +To protect and extend our colonial dependencies was the great object +of British policy, alike with Whigs and Tories, from the time of +Cromwell to the fall of Napoleon. In them, it was thought our +manufacturers would find a lasting and rapidly increasing market for +their produce, which would, in the end, enable us equally to defy +the hostility, and withstand the rivalry of foreign states. The new +school held that this was an antiquated prejudice: that colonies +were a burden rather than a blessing to the mother country: that the +independence of America was the greatest blessing that ever befell +Great Britain; and that, provided we could buy colonial produce a +little cheaper, it signified nothing though our colonies perished by +the want of remuneration for their industry, or were led to revolt +from exasperation at the cruel and unnatural conduct of the mother +country. + +The navy was regarded by all our statesmen, without exception, from +Cromwell to Pitt, as the main security of the British empire; its +bulwark in war; the bridge which united its far-distant provinces +during peace. To feed it with skilled seamen, the Navigation +Laws were upheld even by Adam Smith and the first free-traders, +as the wisest enactments which were to be found in the British +statute-book. But here, too, it was discovered that our ancestors +had been in error: the system under which had flourished for two +centuries the greatest naval power that ever existed, was found to +have been an entire mistake; and provided freights could be had ten +per cent cheaper, it was of no consequence though the fleets of +France and Russia blockaded the Thames and Mersey, and two-thirds of +our trade was carried on in foreign bottoms. + +To provide a CURRENCY equal to the wants of the nation, and +capable of growth in proportion to the amount of their numbers +and transactions, was one main object of the old policy of Great +Britain. Thence the establishment of banks in such numbers in +every part of the empire during the eighteenth century, and the +introduction of the suspension of the obligation to pay in gold in +1797, when the necessities of war had drained nearly all that part +of the currency out of the country, and it was evident that, unless +a substitute for it in sufficient quantities was provided, the +nation itself, and all the individuals in it, would speedily become +bankrupt. The marvels of British finance from that time till 1815, +which excited the deserved astonishment of the whole world, had no +effect in convincing the impassioned opponents of Mr Pitt, that +this was the true system adapted for that or any similar crisis. On +the contrary, it left no doubt in their minds that it was entirely +wrong. The whole philosophers and liberal school of politicians +discovered that the very opposite was the right principle; that +gold, the most variable in price and evanescent, because the +most desired and portable of earthly things, was the only safe +foundation for a currency; that paper was worthless and perilous, +unless in so far as it could be instantly converted into that +incomparable metal; and that, consequently, the more the precious +metals were withdrawn from the country, by the necessities of war +or the effects of adverse exchanges, the more the paper circulation +should be contracted. If the last sovereign went out, they held +it clear the last note should be drawn in. The new system was +brought into practice by Sir R. Peel, by the acts of 1844 and 1845, +simultaneously with a vast importation of grain under the free-trade +system--and we know the consequence. We were speedily near our last +sovereign and last note also. + +To establish a sinking fund, which should secure to the nation +during peace the means of discharging the debt contracted amidst +the necessities of war, was one of the greatest objects of the old +English policy, which was supported with equal earnestness by Mr +Pitt and Mr Fox, by Mr Addington and Lord Henry Petty. So steadily +was this admirable system adhered to through all the dangers +and necessities of the war, that we had a clear sinking fund of +£15,000,000 a-year, when the contest terminated in 1815, which, if +kept up at that amount, from the indirect taxes from which it was +levied during peace, would, beyond all question, as the loans had +ceased, have discharged the whole debt by the year 1845. But the +liberals soon discovered that this was the greatest of all errors: +it was all a delusion; the mathematical demonstration, on which it +was founded, was a fallacy; and the only wisdom was to repeal the +indirect taxes, from which the sinking fund was maintained, and +leave posterity to dispose of the debt as they best could, without +any fund for its discharge. This system was gradually carried into +effect by the successive repeal of the indirect taxes by different +administrations; until at length, after thirty-three years of peace, +we have, instead of the surplus of fifteen millions bequeathed to us +by the war, an average _deficit_ of fifteen hundred thousand pounds; +and the debt, after the longest peace recorded in British history, +has undergone scarcely any diminution. + +Indirect taxation was the main basis of the British finance in +old times--equally when directed by the Whigs as the Tories. +Direct taxes were a last and painful resource, to be reserved for +a period during war, when it had become absolutely unavoidable. +So efficacious was this system proved to be by the event, when +acting on a nation enjoying protected industry, and an adequate and +irremovable currency, that, before the end of the war, £72,000,000 +was, amidst universal prosperity, with ease raised from eighteen +millions of people in Great Britain and Ireland. This astonishing +result, unparalleled in the previous history of the world, had no +influence in convincing the modern liberals that the system which +produced it was right. On the contrary, it left no doubt in their +minds that it was entirely wrong. They introduced the opposite +system: in twenty-five years, they repealed £40,000,000 of indirect +taxes; and they reintroduced the income tax as a permanent burden +during peace. We see the result. The sinking fund has disappeared; +the income tax is fixed about our necks; a deficit of from a million +and a half to two millions annually incurred; and it is now more +difficult to extract fifty-two millions annually from twenty-nine +millions of souls, than, at the close of the war, it was to raise +seventy-two millions from eighteen millions of inhabitants. + +To discourage revolution, both abroad and at home, and enable +industry, in peace and tranquillity, to reap the fruits of its +toil, was the grand object of the great contest which Pitt's wisdom +bequeathed to his successors, and Wellington's arm brought to a +glorious termination. This, however, was ere long discovered to be +the greatest error of all. England, it was found out, had a decided +interest in promoting the cause of revolution all over the world. +So enamoured did we soon become of the propagandist mania, that we +pursued it in direct opposition to our planned national interests, +and with the entire abrogation of our whole previous policy, for +which we had engaged in the greatest and most costly wars, alike +under Whig and Tory administrations. We supported revolutions in +the South American states, though thereby we reduced to a half of +its former amount the supply of the precious metals throughout the +globe; and, in consequence, increased immensely the embarrassment +which a contracted paper currency had brought upon the nation: +we supported revolution in Belgium, though thereby we brought +the tricolor standard down to Antwerp, and surrendered to French +influence the barrier fortresses won by the victories of Marlborough +and Wellington: we supported it during four years of carnage and +atrocity in Spain, though thereby we undid the work of our own +hands, in the treaty of Utrecht, surrendered the whole objects +gained by the War of the Succession, and placed the female line upon +the throne, as if to invite the French princes to come and carry off +the glittering prize: we supported revolutions in Sicily and Italy, +though thereby we gave such a blow to our export trade, that it sank +£1,400,000 in the single month of last May, and above £5,000,000 in +the course of the year 1848. + +To abolish the slave trade was one of the objects which Whigs and +Tories had most at heart in the latter years of the old system; +and in that great and glorious contest Mr Pitt, Mr Fox, and Mr +Wilberforce stood side by side. But this object, so important +in its results, so interesting to humanity from its tendency to +alleviate human suffering, ere long yielded to the enlightened +views of modern liberals. It was discovered that it was much more +important to cheapen sugar _for a time_[8] than to rescue the +African race from perdition. Free trade in sugar was introduced, +although it was demonstrated, and, indeed, confessed, that the +effect of it would be to ruin all the free-labour colonies, +and throw the supply of the world into the hands of the slave +states. Provided, for a few years, you succeeded in reducing the +average retail price of sugar a penny a pound, it was deemed of +no consequence though we extinguished the growth of free-labour +sugar--destroyed colonies in which a hundred millions of British +capital were invested, and doubled the slave trade in extent, and +quadrupled it in horror, throughout the globe. + + [8] Observe, _for a time_! We shall see anon what the price of + sugar will be when the English colonies are destroyed and the slave + plantations have the monopoly of the market in their hands. + +It had been the constant policy of the British government, under all +administrations, for above a century and a half, to endeavour to +reclaim the Irish population by introducing among them colonies of +English who might teach them industry, and Protestant missionaries +who might reclaim them from barbarism. The Irish landlords and +boroughs were the outposts of civilisation among a race of savages; +the Irish Church the station of Christianity amidst the darkness +of Romish slavery. So effectual was this system, and so perfectly +adapted to the character of the Celtic race--capable of great +things when led by others, but utterly unfit for self-government, +and incapable of improvement when left to itself,--that even in +the ruthless hands of Cromwell, yet reeking with the slaughter of +stormed cities, it soon spread a degree of prosperity through the +country then unknown, and rarely if ever since equalled in that +ill-starred land.[9] But the experience of the utter futility of +all attempts, during a century and a half, to leave the native +Irish Celts to themselves or their own direction, had no effect +whatever in convincing our modern liberals that they were incapable +of self-direction, and would only be ruined by Saxon institutions. +On the contrary, it left no doubt in their minds that the absence +of self-government was the sole cause of the wretchedness of the +country, and that nothing was wanting but an entire participation in +the privileges of British subjects, to render them as industrious, +prosperous, and loyal as the yeomen of Kent or Surrey. In pursuance +of those principles, Catholic Emancipation was granted: the Whigs +had effected one revolution in 1688, by coalescing with the whole +Tories to exclude the Catholics from the government; they brought +about another revolution, in 1829, by coalescing with a section +of the Tories to bring them in. In furtherance of the new system, +so plausible in theory, so dangerous in practice, of extending to +all men, of all races, and in all stages of political advancement, +the same privileges, the liberals successively gave the Irish +the command of their boroughs, the abridgment of the Protestant +Church, and the abolition of tithes as a burden on the tenant. +They encouraged agitation, allowed treason to be openly spoken in +every part of the country, and winked at monster meetings, till +the community was wellnigh thrown into convulsions. Meanwhile, +agriculture was neglected--industry disappeared--capital was +scared away. The land was run out, and became unfit for anything +but lazy-beds of potatoes. The people became agitators, not +cultivators: they were always running about to meetings--not +frequenting fairs. The potato-blight fell on a country thus prepared +for ruin, and the unparalleled misery of 1847, and the rebellion of +1848, were the consequence. + + [9] "Cromwell supplied the void made by his conquering sword, + by pouring in numerous colonies of the Anglo-Saxon blood and of + the Calvinistic faith. Strange to say, under that iron rule the + conquered country began to wear an outward face of prosperity. + Districts, which had recently been as wild as those where the + first white settlers of Connecticut were contending with the + Red Men, _were in a few years transformed into the likeness of + Kent and Norfolk_. New buildings, roads, and plantations were + everywhere begun. The rent of estates rose fast: and some of the + English landowners began to complain that they were met in every + market by the products of Ireland, and to clamour for protecting + laws."--MACAULAY'S _History_, i., 130. + +It would be easy to carry these illustrations farther, and to trace +the working of the principles we have mentioned through the whole +modern system of government in Great Britain. Enough has been +said to show that the system is neither founded on the principles +contended for by the old Whigs, nor on any appreciation of, or +attention to, the national interests, or the dictates of experience +in any respect. It has arisen entirely from a blind desire of +change, and an opposition to the old system of government, whether +of Whig or Tory origin, and a selfish thirst for aggrandisement on +the part of the moneyed and commercial classes, whom that system +had elevated to riches and power. Experience was not disregarded +by this school of politicians; on the contrary, it was sedulously +attended to, its lessons carefully marked. But it was considered +as a beacon to be avoided, not a light to be followed. Against its +conclusions the whole weight of declamation and shafts of irony +were directed. It had been the _cri de guerre_ of their enemies, +the standard of Mr Pitt's policy; therefore the opposite system +was to be inscribed on their banners. It was the ruling principle +of their political opponents; and, worst of all, it was the system +which, though it had raised the country to power and greatness, had +for twenty years excluded themselves from power. Thence the modern +system, under which the nation has suffered, and is suffering, such +incalculable misfortunes. It has been said, by an enlightened Whig +of the old school, that "this age appears to be one in which _every +conceivable folly_ must be believed and _reduced to practice_ before +it is abandoned." It is really so; and the reason is, it is an age +in which the former system of government, founded on experience and +brought about by necessity, has been supplanted by one based on a +systematic and invariable determination to change the old system in +every particular. The liberals, whether factious or moneyed, of the +new school, flattered themselves they were making great advances in +political science, when they were merely yielding to the same spirit +which made the Calvinists stand up when they prayed, because all +the world before them had knelt down, and sit still during psalms, +because the Roman Catholics had stood up. + +But truth is great, and will prevail; experience is its test, +and is perpetually contradicting the theories of man. The year +1848 has been no exception to the maxims of Tacitus and Burke. +Dreadful indeed in suffering, appalling in form, are the lessons +which it has read to mankind! Ten months have not elapsed, since, +by a well-concerted urban tumult, seconded by the treachery of +the national guard, the throne of the Barricades was overturned +in France--and what do we already see on the continent of Europe? +Vienna petitioning for a _continuation_ of the state of siege, as +the only security against the tyranny of democracy: Berlin hailing +with rapture the dissolution of the Assembly, and reappearance +of the king in the capital: Milan restored to the sway of the +Austrians: France seeking, in the _quasi_ imperial crown of Prince +Louis Napoleon, with 90,000 soldiers in its capital, a refuge from +the insupportable evils of a democratic republic. The year 1848 has +added another to the numerous proofs which history affords, that +popular convulsions, from whatever cause arising, can terminate +only in the rule of the sword; but it has taught two other lessons +of incalculable importance to the present and future tranquillity +of mankind. These are, that soldiers who in civil convulsions +fraternise with the insurgents, and violate their oaths, are the +_worst enemies_ of the people, for they inevitably induce a military +despotism, which extinguishes all hopes of freedom. The other is, +that the institution of a national guard is in troubled times of all +others the most absurd; and that, to put arms into the hands of the +people, when warmed by revolutionary passions, is only to light the +torch of civil discord with your own hand, and hand over the country +to anarchy, ruin, and slavery. + +Nor has the year been less fruitful of civil premonitions or lessons +of the last importance to the future tranquillity and prosperity of +Great Britain. Numerous popular delusions have been dispelled during +that period. The dreams of Irish independence have been broken; +English Chartism has been crushed. The revolutionists see that the +people of Great Britain are not disposed to yield their property +to the spoiler, their throats to the murderer, their homes to the +incendiary. Free trade and a fettered currency have brought forth +their natural fruits--national embarrassment, general suffering, +popular misery. One half of the wealth of our manufacturing towns +has been destroyed since the new system began. Two years of free +trade and a contracted currency have undone nearly all that twenty +years of protection and a sufficient currency had done. The great +mercantile class have suffered so dreadfully under the effect of +their own measures, that their power for good or for evil has +been essentially abridged. The colossus which, for a quarter of a +century, has bestrode the nation, has been shaken by the earthquake +which itself had prepared. Abroad and at home, in peace and in +war, delusion has brought forth suffering. The year of revolutions +has been the NINTH OF THERMIDOR, OF LIBERAL PRINCIPLES, for it has +brought them to the test of experience. + + + + +FRENCH CONQUERORS AND COLONISTS. + + +The extraordinary deficiency recently exhibited by a great +Continental nation in two qualities eminently prized by +Englishmen--in common consistency, namely, and in common sense--has +cast into the shade all previous shortcomings of the kind, making +them appear remote and trivial. A people of serfs, ruled for +centuries with an iron rod, pillaged for their masters' profit, +and lashed at the slightest murmur, were excusable if, on sudden +emancipation from such galling thraldom, their joyful gambols +exceeded the limits prescribed by public decorum, and by a due +regard to their own future prosperity. They might be forgiven +for dancing round maypoles, and dreaming of social perfection. +It would not be wonderful if they had difficulty in immediately +replacing their expelled tyrants by a capable and stable government, +and if their brief exhilaration were succeeded by a period of +disorganisation and weakness. Such allowances cannot be made for the +mad capers of republican France. The deliverance is inadequate to +account for the ensuing delirium. The grievances swept away by the +February revolution, and which patience, prudence, and moderation, +could not have failed ultimately to remove--as thoroughly, if less +rapidly--were not so terrible as to justify lunacy upon redress. +Nevertheless, since then, the absurdities committed by France, or +at least by Paris, are scarcely explicable save on the supposition +of temporary aberration of intellect. Unimaginative persons have +difficulty in realising the panorama of events, alternately +sanguinary and grotesque, lamentable and ludicrous, spread over the +last ten months. Europe--the portion of it, that is to say, which +has not been bitten by the same rabid and mischievous demon--has +looked on, in utter astonishment, at the painful spectacle of a +leader of its civilisation galloping, with Folly on its crupper, +after mad theories and empty names, and riding down, in the furious +chase, its own prosperity and respectability. + +We repeat, then, that these great follies of to-day eclipse the +minor ones of yesterday. When we see France destroying, in a few +weeks, her commerce and her credit, and doing herself more harm +than as many years will repair, we overlook the fact, that for +upwards of fifteen years she has annually squandered from three +to five millions sterling upon an unproductive colony in North +Africa. France used not to be petty in her wars, or paltry in her +enterprises. If she was sometimes quarrelsome and aggressive, +she was wont at least to fasten on foes worthy of her power and +resources. Since 1830 she has derogated in this particular. A +complication of causes--the most prominent being the vanity +characteristic of the nation, the crooked policy of the sovereign, +and the morbid love of fighting bequeathed by the warlike period of +the Empire--has kept France engaged in a costly and discreditable +contest, whose most triumphant results could be but inglorious, +and in which she has decimated her best troops, and deteriorated +her ancient fame, whilst pursuing, with unworthy ferocity and +ruthlessness, a feeble and inoffensive foe. This is no partial or +malicious view of the character of the Algerine war. Deliberately, +and after due reflection, we repeat, that France has gravely +compromised in Africa her reputation as a chivalrous and clement +nation, and that she no longer can claim--as once she was wont to +do--to be as humane in victory as she is valiant in the fight. For +proof of this we need seek no further than in the speeches and +despatches of French generals, of men who themselves have served +and commanded in Africa. We will judge France by the voices of her +own sons, of those she has selected as worthiest to govern her +half-conquered colony, and to marshal her legions against a handful +of Arabs. More than one of these officers testify, voluntarily or +unwittingly, to the barbarity of the system pursued in Africa. What +said General Castellane, in his well-known speech in the Chamber +of Peers, on the 4th July 1845? "We have reduced the country by an +arsenal of axes and phosphorus matches. The trees were cut down, +the crops were burned, and soon the mastery was obtained of a +population reduced to famine and despair." And elsewhere in the same +speech: "Few soldiers perish by the hand of the enemy in this war--a +sort of _man-hunt_ on a large scale, in which the Arabs, ignorant +of European tactics, having no cannon-balls to exchange against +ours, do not fight with equal arms." Monsieur A. Desjobert, long a +deputy for the department of the Lower Seine, is the author of a +volume, and of several pamphlets, upon the Algerine question. In the +most recent of these we find the following remarkable note:--"In +February 1837, General Bugeaud said to the Arabs, 'You shall not +plough, you shall not sow, nor lead your cattle to the pasture, +without our permission.' Later, he gives the following definition +of a razzia: 'A sudden irruption, having for its object to surprise +the tribes, in order to kill the men, and to carry off the women, +children, and cattle.' In 1844, he completes this theory, by saying +to the Kabyles, 'I will penetrate into your mountains, I will burn +your villages and your crops, I will cut down your fruit-trees.' +(Proclamation of the 30th March.) In 1846, rendering an account of +his operations against Abd-el-Kader, he says to the authorities of +Algiers, 'The power of Abd-el-Kader consists in the resources of +the tribes; hence, to ruin his power, we must first ruin the Arabs; +therefore have we burned much, destroyed much.' (From the _Akhbar_ +newspaper of February 1846.)" These are significant passages in the +mouth of a general-in-chief. Presently, when we come to details, +we shall show they were not thrown away upon his subordinates. +The extermination of the Arabs was always the real aim of Marshal +Bugeaud; he took little pains to cloak his system, and is too +great a blunderer to have succeeded, had he taken more. A man of +greater presumption than capacity, his audacity, obstinacy, and +unscrupulousness knew no bounds. Before this African _man-hunt_, as +M. Castellane calls it, he was unknown, except as the Duchess de +Berry's jailer, as the slayer of poor Dulong, and as a turbulent +debater, whose noisy declamation, and occasional offences against +the French language, were a standing joke with the newspapers. A +few years elapse, and we find him opposing his stubborn will to +that of Soult, then minister at war, and successfully thwarting +Napoleon's old lieutenant. This he was enabled to do mainly by the +position he had made himself in Africa. He had ridden into power and +importance on the shoulders of the persecuted Arabs, by a system of +razzias and village-burning, of wholesale slaughter and relentless +oppression. Brighter far were the laurels gathered by the lieutenant +of the Empire, than those plucked by Louis Philippe's marshal +amidst the ashes of Bedouin douars and the corpses of miserable +Mussulmans, slain in defence of their scanty birthright, of their +tents, their flocks, and the free range of the desert. Poor was +the defence they could make against their skilful and disciplined +invaders; slight the loss they could inflict in requital of the +heavy one they suffered. Again we are obliged to M. Desjobert for +statistics, gathered from reports to the Commission of Credits, and +from Marshal Bugeaud's own bulletins. From these we learn that the +loss in battle of the French armies, during the first ten years +of the occupation of Algeria, was an average of one hundred and +forty men per annum. In the four following years, eight hundred +and eighty-five men perished. The capture of Constantine cost one +hundred men, the much-vaunted affair of the Smala _nine_, the battle +of Isly TWENTY-SEVEN! We well remember, for we chanced to be in +Paris at the time, the stir produced in that excitable capital by +the battle of Isly. No one, unacquainted with the facts, would have +doubted that the victory was over a most valiant and formidable +foe. People's mouths were filled with this revival of the military +glories of Gaul. Newspapers and picture-shops, poets and painters, +combined to celebrate the exploit and sound the victors' praise. +One engraving _de circonstance_, we remember, represented a sturdy +French foot-soldier, trampling, like Gulliver, a host of Lilliputian +Moors, and carrying a score of them over his shoulder, spitted +on his bayonet. "Out of my way!" was the inscription beneath the +print--"_Les Français seront toujours les Français._" Horace +Vernet, colourist, by special appointment, to the African campaign, +pictorial chronicler of the heroic feats of the house militant of +Orleans, prepared his best brushes, and stretched his broadest +canvass, to immortalise the marshal and his men. After a few days, +two dingy tents and an enormous umbrella were exhibited in the +gardens of the Tuileries; these were trophies of the fight--the +private property of Mohammed-Abderrhaman, the vanquished prince of +Morocco, the real merit of whose conquerors was about as great as +that of an active tiger who gloriously scatters a numerous flock +of sheep. From one of several books relating to Algeria, now upon +our table, we will take a French officer's account of the affair of +Isly. The story of Escoffier, a trumpeter who generously resigned +his horse to his dismounted captain, himself falling into the hands +of the Arabs, whose prisoner he remained for about eighteen months, +is told by M. Alby, an officer of the African army. Although a +little vivid in the colouring, and comprising two or three very +tough "yarns,"--due, we apprehend, to the imagination of trumpeter +or author--its historical portion professes to be, and probably is, +correct; and, at any rate, there can be no reason for suspecting +the writer of depreciating his countrymen's achievements, and +understating their merits. The account of the battle, or rather of +the chase, for fighting there was none, is given by a deserter from +the Spahis, who, after the defeat of the Moors, joined Abd-el-Kader. +The Emir and his Arabs took no part in the affair.[10] + + [10] _A Campaign in the Kabylie._ By DAWSON BORRER, F.R.G.S., &c. + London, 1848. + + _La Kabylie._ Par un Colon. Paris, 1846. + + _La Captivité du Trompette Escoffier._ Par ERNEST ALBY. 2 vols. + Brussels, 1848. + +"I deserted, with several of my comrades, during the night-march +stolen by the French upon the Moors. We sought the emperor's son +in his camp, and informed him of the movement making by the French +column. The emperor's son had our horses taken away, and gave orders +not to lose sight of us. Then he said to us:-- + +"'Let them come, those dogs of Christians; they are but thirteen +thousand strong, and we a hundred and sixty thousand: we will +receive them well.' + +"The day was well advanced before the Moors perceived the French. +Then the emperor's son ordered his horsemen to mount and advance. +The French marched in a square. They unmasked their artillery, and +the guns sent their deadly charge of grape into the ranks of the +Moors, who immediately took to flight, and the French had nothing to +do but to sabre them." + +"The Moors," says M. Alby, "had fine horses and good sabres; but +their muskets were bad; and the men, softened by centuries of peace +and prosperity, smoking keef[11] and eating copiously, might be +expected to run, as they did, at the first cannon-shot." + + [11] The Moors smoke the leaves of hemp instead of tobacco. This + _keef_, as it is called, easily intoxicates, and renders the + head giddy. Abd-el-Kader forbade the use of it, and if one of + his soldiers was caught smoking keef, he received the bastinado. + _Captivité d'Escoffier_, vol. i. p. 221. + +It is hard to understand how the loss of the French should have +amounted to even the twenty-seven men at which it is stated in their +general's bulletin. Did M. Bugeaud, unwilling to admit the facility +of his triumph, slay the score and seven with his goosequill? But +if the victory was easily won, on the other hand, it was largely +rewarded. For having driven before him, by the very first volley +from his guns, a horde of overfed barbarians, enervated by sloth +and narcotics, and total strangers to the tactics of civilised +warfare, the marshal was created a duke! Shade of Napoleon! whether +proudly lingering within the trophy-clad walls of the Invalides, +or passing in spectral review the dead of Austerlitz and Borodino, +suspend your lonely walk, curb your shadowy charger, and contemplate +this pitiable spectacle! You, too, gave dukedoms, and lavished even +crowns, but you gave them for services worth the naming. Ney and the +Moskwa, Massena and Essling, Lannes and Montebello, are words that +bear the coupling, and grace a coronet. The names of the places, +although all three recall brilliant victories, are far less glorious +in their associations than the names of the men. But Bugeaud and +Isly! What can we say of them? Truly, thus much--they, too, are +worthy of each other. + +When reviewing, about two years ago, Captain Kennedy's narrative of +travel and adventure in Algeria, we regretted he did not speak out +about the mode of carrying on the war, and about the prospects of +Algerine colonisation; and we hinted a suspicion that the amenities +of French military hospitality, largely extended to a British +fellow-soldier, had induced him, if not exactly to cloak, at least +to shun laying bare, the errors and mishaps of his entertainers. +We cannot make the same complaint of the very pretty book, rich in +vignettes and cream-colour, entitled, _A Campaign in the Kabylie_. +Mr Borrer, whom the Cockneys, contemptuous of terminations, will +assuredly confound with his great gipsy cotemporary, George Borrow +of the Bible, has, like Captain Kennedy, dipped his spoon in French +messes. He has ridden with their regiments, and sat at their board, +and been quartered with their officers, and received kindness and +good treatment on all hands; and therefore any thing that could +be construed into malicious comment would come with an ill grace +from his pen. But it were exaggerated delicacy to abstain from +stating facts, and these he gives in all their nakedness; generally, +however, allowing them to speak for themselves, and adding little +in the way of remark or opinion. In pursuance of this system, he +relates the most horrible instances of outrage and cruelty with a +matter-of-fact coolness, and an absence alike of blame and sympathy, +that may give an unfavourable notion of his heart, to those who do +not accept our lenient interpretation of his cold-blooded style. The +traits he sets down, and which are no more than will be found in +many French narratives, despatches, and bulletins, show how well the +Franco-African army carry out the merciful maxims of Bugeaud. + +Mr Borrer, a geographer and antiquary, passed seventeen months in +Algeria; and during his residence there, in May 1846, a column of +eight thousand French troops, commanded by the Duke of Isly in +person, marched against the Kabyles, "that mysterious, bare-headed, +leathern-aproned race, whose chief accomplishment was said to +be that of being 'crack-shots,' their chief art that of neatly +roasting their prisoners alive, and their chief virtue that of +loving their homes." It may interest the reader to hear a rather +more explicit account of this singular people, who dwell in the +mountains that traverse Algeria from Tunis to Morocco--an irregular +domain, whose limits it is difficult exactly to define in words. +The Kabyles are, in fact, the highlanders of North Africa, and they +hold themselves aloof from the Arabs and Europeans that surround +them. Concerning them, we find some diversity in the statements +of Mr Borrer, and of an anonymous Colonist, twelve years resident +at Bougie, whose pamphlet is before us. Of the two, the Frenchman +gives them the best character, but both agree as to their industry +and intelligence, their frugality and skill in agriculture. They +are not nomadic like the Arabs, but live in villages, till the +land, and tend flocks. Dwelling in the mountains, they have few +horses, and fight chiefly on foot. Divided into many tribes, they +are constantly quarreling and fighting amongst themselves, but +they forget their feuds and quickly unite to repel a foreign foe. +"Predisposed by his character," says the Colonist, "to draw near +to civilisation, the Kabyle attaches himself sincerely to the +civilised man when circumstances establish a friendly connexion +between them. He is still inclined to certain vices inherent in +the savage: but of all the Africans, he is the best disposed to +live in friendship and harmony with us, which he will do when +he shall find himself in permanent contact with the European +population." This is not the general opinion, and it differs widely +from that expressed by Mr Borrer. But the Colonist had his own +views, perhaps his own interests, to further. He wrote some months +previous to the expedition which Mr Borrer accompanied, and which +was then not likely to take place, and he strongly advocated its +propriety--admitting, however, that public opinion in France was +greatly opposed to a military incursion into Kabylia. Himself +established at Bougie, of course in some description of commerce, +the necessity of roads connecting the coast and the interior was to +him quite evident. A good many of his countrymen, whose personal +benefit was not so likely to be promoted by causeway-cutting in +Algeria, strongly deprecated any sort of road-making that was likely +to bring on war with the Kabyles. France began to think she was +paying too dear for her whistle. She looked back to the early days +of the Orleans dynasty, when Marshal Clausel promised to found a +rich and powerful colony with only 10,000 men. She glanced at the +pages of the _Moniteur_ of 1837, and there she found words uttered +by the great Bugeaud in the Chamber of Deputies. "Forty-five +thousand men and one good campaign," said the white-headed +warrior, as the Arabs call him, "and in six months the country +is pacified, and you may reduce the army to twenty thousand men, +to be paid by imposts levied on the colony, consequently costing +France nothing." Words, and nothing more--mere wind; the greatest +_bosh_ that ever was uttered, even by Bugeaud, who is proverbial +for dealing largely in that flatulent commodity. Nine years passed +away, and the Commission of the Budget "deplored a situation which +compelled France to maintain an army of more than 100,000 men upon +that African territory." (Report of M. Bignon of the 15th April +1846, p. 237.) Bugeaud himself had mightily changed his tone, and +declared that, to keep Algiers, as large an army would be essential +as had been required to conquer it. Lamoricière, a great authority +in such matters, confirmed the opinion of his senior. Monsieur +Desjobert, and a variety of pamphleteers and newspaper writers, +attacked, with argument, ridicule, and statistics, the party known +as the _Algérophiles_, who made light of difficulties, scoffed +at expense, and predicted the prosperity and splendour of French +Africa. Algeria, according to them, was to become the brightest +gem in the citizen-crown of France. These sanguine gentlemen were +met with facts and figures. During 1846, said the anti-Algerines, +your precious colony will have cost France 125,000,000 of francs. +And they proved it in black and white. There was little chance +of the expense being less in following years. Then came the loss +of men. In 1840, said M. Desjobert, giving chapter and verse for +his statements, 9567 men perished in the African hospitals, out +of an effective army of 63,000. Add those invalids who died in +French hospitals, or in their homes, from the results of African +campaigning, and the total loss is moderately stated at 11,000 men, +or more than one-sixth of the whole force employed. Out of these, +only 227 died in action. The thing seemed hopeless and endless. +What do we get for our money? was the cry. What is our compensation +for the decimation of our young men? France can better employ her +sons, than in sending them to perish by African fevers. What do we +gain by all this expenditure of gold and blood?--The unreasonable +mortals! Had they not gained a Duke of Isly and a Moorish pavilion? +M. Desjobert surely forgets these inestimable acquisitions when he +asks and answers the question--"What remains of all our victories? A +thousand bulletins, and Horace Vernet's big pictures." + +"How many times," says the same writer, "has not the subjection of +the Arabs been proclaimed! In 1844, General Bugeaud gains the battle +of Isly. Are the Arabs subdued? + +"When the Arabs appear before the judges who dispose of life and +death, they confess their faith, and proclaim their hatred of us; +and when we are simple enough to tell them that some of their race +are devoted to us, they reply, 'Those lie to you, through fear, or +for their own interest; and as often as a scheriff shall come whom +they believe able to conquer you, they will follow him, even into +the streets of Algiers.' (Examination of Bou Maza's brother, 12th +November 1845.) Thus spoke the chief. The common Arab had already +said to the Christian, "If my head and thine were boiled in the same +vessel, my broth would separate itself from thy broth." + +This was discouraging to those who had dreamed of the taming of the +Arab; and the more sanguinary mooted ideas of extermination. Such a +project, clearly written down, and printed, and placed on Parisian +breakfast tables, might be startling; in Algeria it had long been +put in practice. What said General Duvivier in his _Solution de +la Question d'Algérie_, p. 285? "For eleven years they have razed +buildings, burned crops, destroyed trees, massacred men, women, +and children, with a still-increasing fury." We have already shown +that this work of extermination was not carried on with perfect +impunity. Here is further confirmation of the fact. "Every Arab +killed," says M. Leblanc de Prébois, another officer, who wrote on +the Algerian war, and wrote from personal experience, "costs us the +death of thirty-three men, and 150,000 francs." Supposing a vast +deal of exaggeration in this statement, the balance still remains +ugly against the French, for whom there is evidently very little +difference between catching an Arab and catching a Tartar. Whilst +upon the subject of extermination, Mr Borrer gives an opinion more +decidedly unfavourable to his French friends than is expressed in +any other part of his book. His estimate of Kabyle virtues differs +considerably, it will be observed, from that of the Colonist, and of +the two is much nearest the truth. + +"The abominable vices and debaucheries of the Kabyle race, the +inhuman barbarities they are continually guilty of towards such +as may be cast by tempest, or other misfortune, upon their rugged +shores; the atrocious cruelties and refined tortures they, in common +with the Arab, delight in exercising upon any such enemies as may +be so unhappy as to fall alive into their hands, must render the +hearts of those acquainted with this people perfectly callous as +to what misfortunes may befall them or their country; and many +may think that, as far as the advancement of civilisation is +concerned, the wiping off of the Kabyle and Arab races of Northern +Africa from the face of the earth, would be the greatest boon to +humanity. Though, however, they may be fraught with all the vices +of the Canaanitish tribes of old, yet the command, 'Go ye after +him through the city and smite; let not your eye spare, neither +have ye pity; slay utterly old and young, both maids, and little +children, and women,' is not justifiably issued at the pleasure of +man; and we can but lament to see a great and gallant nation engaged +in a warfare exasperating both parties to indulge in sanguinary +atrocities,--atrocities to be attributed on one side to the +barbarous and savage state of those having recourse to them; but on +the other, proceeding only from a thirst for retaliation and bloody +revenge, unworthy of those enjoying a high position as a civilised +people. War is, as we all know, ever productive of horrors: but such +horrors may be greatly restrained and diminished by the exertions +and example of those in command." + +The hoary-headed hero of Isly is not the man to make the exertion, +or set the example. At the beginning of 1847, rumours of a projected +inroad amongst the Kabyles caused uneasiness and dissatisfaction +in Algeria, when such a movement was highly unpopular, as likely +to lead to a long and expensive war. The "Commission of Credits," +a board appointed by the French Chamber for the particular +investigation and regulation of Algerine affairs, applied to the +minister of war to know if the rumours were well founded. The +minister confessed they were; adding, however, that the expedition +would be quite peaceable; but at the same time laying before the +commission letters from Bugeaud, "expressing regret that force of +arms was not to be resorted to more than was absolutely necessary, +the submission of the aborigines being never certain _until powder +had spoken_." The marshal evidently "felt like fighting." The +Commission protested; the minister rebuked them, bidding them mind +their credits, and not meddle with the royal prerogative. Thus +unjustly snubbed--for they certainly were minding their credits, +by opposing increase of expenditure--the Commission were mute, one +of the members merely observing, by way of a last shot, that it +was easier to refuse to listen than to reply satisfactorily. In +France, public opinion, the Chamber of Deputies, and Marshal Soult, +had, on various occasions, declared against attacking the Kabyles. +"Nevertheless, a proclamation was issued by Marshal Bugeaud to +the inhabitants of the Kabylie, to warn them that the French army +was upon the point of entering their territory, 'to cleanse it of +those adventurers who there preached the war against France.' The +proclamation then went on to state, that the marshal had no desire +to fight with them, or to devastate their property; but that, if +there were amongst them any who wished for war, they would find +him ready to accept it." If a hard-favoured stranger, armed with a +horsewhip, walked uninvited into M. Bugeaud's private residence, +loudly proclaiming he would thrash nobody unless provoked, the +marshal would be likely to resist the intrusion. The Kabyles, +doubtless, thought his advance into their territory an equally +unjustifiable proceeding. As to the pretext of "the adventurers who +preached war," it was unfounded and ridiculous. Such propagandists +have never been listened to in Kabylia. "The voice of the Emir +Abd-el-Kader himself," says the Colonist, "would not obtain a +hearing. Did he not go in person, in 1839, when preparing to break +his treaty of peace with us, and preach the holy war? Did he not +traverse the valley of the Souman, from one end to the other, +to recruit combatants? And what did he obtain from the Kabyles? +Hospitality for a few days, coupled with the formal invitation to +evacuate the country as soon as possible. Did he succeed better +when he lately again tried to raise Kabylia against us?" Mr Borrer +confirms this. Marshal Bugeaud himself had said in the Chamber of +Deputies, "The Kabyles are neither aggressive nor hostile; they +defend themselves vigorously when intruded upon, but they do not +attack." The marshal, whose whole public life has been full of +contradictions, was the first to intrude upon them, although but +a very few years had elapsed since he said in a pamphlet, "The +Kabyles are numerous and very warlike; they have villages, and their +agriculture is sedentary; already there is too little land to supply +their wants; there is no room, therefore, for Europeans in the +mountains of Kabylia, and they would cut a very poor figure there." +This last prophetic sentence was realised by M. Bugeaud himself, who +certainly made no very brilliant appearance when, forgetting his +former theory, he hazarded himself in May 1847, at the head of eight +thousand men, and with Mr Borrer in his train, amongst the hardy +mountaineers of Kabylia. + +Hereabouts Mr Borrer quotes, in French, the statement of a member of +the Commission already referred to. It is worth extracting, as fully +confirming our conviction that the conduct of France in Algeria +has been throughout characterised by an utter want of judgment and +justice. "The native towns have been invaded, ruined, sacked, by +our administration, more even than by our arms. In time of peace, +a great number of private estates have been ravaged and destroyed. +A multitude of title-deeds delivered to us for verification have +never been restored. Even in the environs of Algiers, fertile +lands have been taken from the Arabs and given to Europeans, who, +unable or unwilling to cultivate their new possessions, have +farmed them out to their former owners, who have thus become the +mere stewards of the inheritance of their fathers. Elsewhere, +tribes, or fractions of tribes, not hostile to us, but who, on the +contrary, had fought for us, have been driven from their territory. +Conditions have been accepted from them, and not kept--indemnities +promised, and never paid--until we have compromised our honour even +more than their interests." Such a statement, proceeding from a +Frenchman--from one, too, delegated by his government, to examine +the state of the colony--is quite conclusive as to administrative +proceedings in Algeria. It would be superfluous and impertinent to +add another line of evidence. A comment may be appropriate. "Is it +not Montesquieu," says Mr Borrer, "in his _Esprit des Lois_, who +observes--'The right of conquest, though a necessary and legitimate +right, is an unhappy one, bequeathing to the conqueror a heavy debt +to humanity, only to be acquitted by repairing, as far as possible, +those evils of which he has been the cause'?--and Montesquieu was a +wise man, and a Frenchman!" + +Dismissing this branch of the subject, let us see how the Duke +of Isly made "the powder speak" in Kabylia, and try our hand +at a rough sketch, taking the loan of Mr Borrer's colours. A +strong body of French troops--the 8000 have been increased, since +departure, by several battalions and some spahis--are encamped in +a rich valley, cutting down the unripe wheat for the use of their +horses, whilst, from the surrounding heights, the Kabyles gloomily +watch the unscrupulous foragers. "Now 'soft-winged evening,'" as +Mr Dawson Borrer poetically expresses himself, "hovers o'er the +scene, chasing from woodlands and sand-rock heights the gilded +tints of the setting sun." In other words, it gets dark--and shots +are heard. The natives, vexed at the liberties taken with their +crops, harass the outposts. Their bad powder and overloaded guns +have no chance against French muskets. "In the name of the Prophet, +HEADS!" Bugeaud the Merciful pays for them ten francs a-piece. Four +are presented to him before breakfast. The premium is to make the +soldiers alert against horse-stealers. Ten francs being a little +fortune to a French soldier, whose pay in hard cash is two or three +farthings a-day, Mr Borrer suspects the heads are sometimes taken +from shoulders where they have a right to remain. An Arab is always +an Arab, whether a horse-stealer or a mere idler. But no matter--a +few more or less. Day returns; the column marches; the Kabyles +show little of the intrepidity, in defence of their hearths and +altars, attributed to them by M. Bugeaud and others. Their horsemen +fly before a platoon of French cavalry; the infantry limit their +offensive operations to cowardly long shots at the rear-guard. Four +venerable elders bring two yoked oxen in token of submission. In +general, the inhabitants have disappeared. Their deserted towns +appear, in the distance, by no means inferior to many French and +Italian villages. The marshal will not permit exploring parties +for fear of ambuscade. Night arrives, and passes without incident +of note. At three in the morning, the camp is aroused by hideous +yells. A sentinel has fired at a horse-thief and broken his leg, +and now, mindful of the ten francs, tries to cut off the head of +the wounded man, who objects and screams. A bayonet-thrust stops +his mouth, and the _bill on Bugeaud_ is duly severed. The next day +is passed in skirmishing with the Beni-Abbez, the most numerous +tribe of the valley of the Souman, but not a very warlike one--so +says the Colonist; and, indeed, they offer but slight resistance, +although they, or some other tribes, make a firm and determined +attack upon the French outposts in the course of that night. There +is more smoke than bloodshed; but the Kabyles show considerable +pluck, burn a prodigious number of cartridges, and make no doubt +they have nearly "rubbed out" the Christians; in which particular +they are rather mistaken--the French, not choosing to leave their +camp, having quietly lain down, and allowed the Berber lead to fly +over them. At last the assailants' ammunition runs low, and they +retire, leaving a sprinkling of dead. Mr Borrer quotes the Koran. +"'Those of our brothers who fall in defence of the true faith, +are not dead, but live invisible, receiving their nourriture from +the hand of the Most High,' says the Prophet." _Nourriture_ is +not quite English, at least with that orthography; but no matter +for Mr Borrer's Gallicisms, which are many. We rush with him into +the Kabyle fire. Here he sits, halted amongst the olive-trees, +philosophically lighting his pipe, the bullets whistling about his +ears, whilst he admires the _sang froid_ of a pretty _vivandière_, +seated astride upon her horse, and jesting at the danger. The column +advances--the Kabyles retreat, fighting, pursued by the French +shells, which they hold in particular horror, and call the howitzer +the _twice-firing cannon_. The object of the advance is to destroy +the towns and villages of the Beni-Abbez, the night-attack upon his +bivouac affording the marshal a pretext. The villages are surrounded +with stiff walls of stones and mud, crowned with strong thorny +fences, and having hedges of prickly pear growing at their base; and +the gaunt burnoosed warriors make good fight through loop-holes and +from the terraces of their houses. But resistance is soon overcome, +and the narrow streets are crowded with Frenchmen, ravishing, +massacring, plundering; no regard to sex or age; outrage for every +woman--the edge of the sword for all. + +"Upon the floor of one of the chambers lay a little girl of twelve +or fourteen years of age, weltering in gore, and in the agonies of +death: an accursed ruffian thrust his bayonet into her. God will +requite him.... When the soldiers had ransacked the dwellings, and +smashed to atoms all they could not carry off, or did not think +worth seizing as spoil, they heaped the remnants and the mattings +together and fired them. As I was hastily traversing the streets +to regain the outside of the village, disgusted with the horrors I +witnessed, flames burst forth on all sides, and torrents of fire +came swiftly gliding down the thoroughfares, for the flames had +gained the oil. An instant I turned--the fearful doom of the poor +concealed child and the decrepid mother flashing on my mind. It was +too late.... The unfortunate Kabyle child was doubtless consumed +with her aged parent. How many others may have shared her fate!" + +At noon, the atmosphere is laden with smoke arising from the +numerous burning villages. From one spot nine may be counted, +wrapped in flames. There is merry-making in the French camp. +Innumerable goatskins, full of milk, butter, figs, and flour, are +produced and opened. Some are consumed; more are squandered and +strewn upon the ground. Let the Kabyle dogs starve! Have they not +audaciously levelled their long guns at the white-headed warrior +and his followers, who asked nothing but submission, free passage +through the country, corn-fields for their horses, and the fat +of the land for themselves? But stay--there is still a town to +take, the last, the strongest, the refuge of the women and of the +aged. Its defence is resolute, but at last it falls. "Ravished, +murdered, burnt, hardly a child escaped to tell the tale. A few of +the women fled to the ravines around the village; but troops swept +the brushwood; and the stripped and mangled bodies of females might +there be seen.... One vast sheet of flame crowned the height, which +an hour or two before was ornamented with an extensive and opulent +village, crowded with inhabitants. It seemed to have been the very +emporium of commerce of the Beni-Abbez; fabrics of gunpowder, of +arms, of haïks, burnooses, and different stuffs, were there. The +streets boasted of numerous shops of workers in silver, workers in +cord, venders of silk, &c." All this the soldiers pillaged, or the +fire devoured; then the insatiable flames gained the corn and olive +trees, and converted a smiling and prosperous district into a black +and barren waste. Bugeaud looked on and pronounced it good, and +his men declared the country "well cleaned out," and vaunted their +deeds of rapine and violence. "I heard two ruffians relating, with +great gusto, how many young girls had been burned in one house, +after being abused by their brutal comrades and themselves." Out +of consideration for his readers, Mr Borrer says, he writes down +but the least shocking of the crimes and atrocities he that day +witnessed. We have no inclination to transcribe a tithe of the +horrors he records, and at sight of which, he assures us, the blood +of many a gallant French officer boiled in his veins. He mentions +no attempt on the part of these compassionate officers to curb the +ferocity of their men, who had not the excuse of previous severe +sufferings, of a long and obstinate resistance, and of the loss of +many of their comrades, to allege in extenuation of their savage +violence. History teaches us that, in certain circumstances, as, +for instance, after protracted sieges, great exposure, and a long +and bloody fight, soldiers of all nations are liable to forget +discipline, and, maddened by fury, by suffering and excitement, to +despise the admonitions and reprimands of the chiefs--nay, even +to turn their weapons against those whom for years they have been +accustomed to respect and implicitly obey. But there is no such +excuse in the instance before us. A pleasant military promenade +through a rich country, fine weather, abundant rations, and just +enough skirmishing to give zest to the whole affair, whose fighting +part was exceeding brief, as might be expected, when French bayonets +and artillery were opposed to the clumsy guns and irregular tactics +of the Beni-Abbez--we find nothing in this picture to extenuate +the horrible cruelties enacted by the conquerors after their +easily achieved victory. Their whole loss, according to their +marshal's bulletin, amounted to fifty-seven killed and wounded. +This included the loss in the night-attack on the camp. In fact, +it was mere child's play for the disciplined French soldiery; and +Mr Borrer virtually admits this, by applying to the affair General +Castellane's expression of a _man-hunt_. He then, with no good +grace, endeavours to find an excuse for his campaigning comrades. +"The ranks of the French army in Africa are composed, in great +measure, of the very scum of France." They have condemned regiments +in Africa, certainly; the Foreign Legion are reckless and reprobate +enough; we dare say the Zouaves, a mixed corps of wild Frenchmen and +tamed Arabs, are neither tender nor scrupulous; but these form a +very small portion of the hundred thousand French troops in Africa, +and there is little picking and choosing amongst the line regiments, +who take their turn of service pretty regularly, neither is there +reason for considering the men who go to Algeria to be greater +scamps than those who remain in France. So this will not do, Mr +Borrer: try another tack. "The only sort of excuse for the horrors +committed by the soldiery in Algeria, is their untamed passions, +and the fire added to their natural ferocity by the atrocious +cruelties so often committed by the Arabs upon their comrades in +arms, who have been so unhappy as to fall into their power." This +is more plausible, although it is a query who began the system of +murderous reprisals. Arab treatment of prisoners is not mild. On the +evening of the 1st June, some men straggled from the French bivouac, +and were captured. "It was said that from one of the outposts the +Kabyles were seen busily engaged, in roasting their victims before +a large fire upon a neighbouring slope; but whether this was a fact +or not, I never learned." It was possibly true. Escoffier tells +us how one of his fellow-prisoners, a Jew named Wolf, who fell +into the hands of Moorish shepherds, was thrown upon a blazing +pile of faggots; and although we suspect the brave trumpeter, or +his historian, of occasional exaggeration, there are grounds for +crediting the authenticity of this statement. As to Mr Borrer, he +guarantees nothing but what he sees with his own eyes, the camp +being, he says, full of _blagueurs_, or tellers of white lies. The +inventions of these mendacious gentry are not always as innocent +as he appears to think them. Imaginary cruelties, attributed to +an enemy, are very apt to impose upon credulous soldiers, and to +stimulate them to unnecessary bloodshed, and to acts of lawless +revenge. Many a village has been burned, and many an inoffensive +peasant sabred, on the strength of such lying fabrications. In +Africa especially, where the _lex talionis_ seems fully recognised, +and its enforcement confided to the first straggler who chooses to +fire a house or stick an Arab, the _blagueurs_ should be handed +over, in our opinion, to summary punishment. On the advance of the +French column, a soldier or two, straying from the bivouac to bathe +or fish, had here and there been shot by the lurking Kabyles. On its +return, "I was somewhat surprised," Mr Borrer remarks, "to observe, +in the wake of the column, flames bursting forth from the gourbies +(villages) left in our rear. It was well known that the tribe upon +whose territory we were riding had submitted, and that their sheikh +was even riding at the head of the column." None could explain the +firing of the villages. The sheikh, indignant at the treachery of +the French, set spurs to his mare, and was off like the wind. The +conflagration was traced to soldiers of the rear-guard, desirous +to revenge their comrades, picked off on the previous march. We +are not told that the crime was brought home to the perpetrators, +or visited upon them. If it was, Mr Borrer makes no mention of the +fact, but passes on, as if the burning of a few villages were a +trifle scarce worth notice. How were the Kabyles to distinguish +between the acts of the private soldier and of the epauleted +chief? Their submission had just been accepted, and friendly words +spoken to them: their sheikh rode beside the gray-haired leader +of the Christians, and marked the apparent subordination of the +white-faced soldiery. Suddenly a gross violation occurred of the +amicable understanding so recently come to. How persuade them that +the submissive and disciplined soldiers they saw around them would +venture such breach of faith without the sanction or connivance of +their commander? The offence is that of an insignificant sentinel, +but the dirt falls upon the beard of Bugeaud; and confidence in the +promises of the lying European is thoroughly and for ever destroyed. + +A colony, whose mode of acquisition and of government, up to the +present time, reflects so little credit upon French arms and +administrators, ought certainly to yield pecuniary results or +advantages of some kind, which, in a mercenary point of view, might +balance the account. France surely did not place her reputation +for humanity and justice in the hands of Marshal Bugeaud and of +others of his stamp, without anticipating some sort of compensation +for its probable deterioration. Such expectations have hitherto +been wholly unfulfilled; and we really see little chance of their +probable or speedy realisation. The colony is as unpromising, as +the colonists are inapt to improve it. The fact is, the work of +colonisation has not begun. The French are utterly at a loss how to +set about it. All kinds of systems have been proposed. Bugeaud has +had his--that of military colonisation, which he maintained, with +characteristic stubbornness, in the teeth of public opinion, of the +French government, of common sense, and even of possibility. He +proposed to take, during ten years, one hundred and twenty thousand +recruits from the conscription, and to settle them in Africa, with +their wives. He estimated the expense of this scheme at twelve +millions sterling. His opponents stated its probable cost at four +times that sum. Whichever estimate was correct, it is not worth +while examining the plan, which for a moment was entertained by a +government commission, but has since been completely abandoned. +It presupposes an extraordinary and arbitrary stretch of power +on the part of the government that should adopt such a system +of compulsory colonisation. We are surprised to find Mr Borrer +inclined to favour the exploded plan. General Lamoricière (the +terrible _Bour-à-boi_ of the Arabs,[12]) proposed to give premiums +to agriculturists settling in Algeria, at the rate of twenty-five +per cent of their expenses of clearing, irrigation, construction, +and plantation. But M. Lamoricière--a very practical man indeed, +with his sabre in his fist, and at the head of his Zouaves--is a +shallow theorist in matters of colonisation. The staff of surveyors, +valuers, and referees essential to carry out his project, would +alone have been a heavy additional charge on the unprofitable +colony. "M. Lamoricière," says M. Desjobert, "was one of the warmest +advocates of the occupation of Bougie," (a seaport of Kabylie,) +"and partly directed, in 1833, that fatal expedition." (Fatal, M. +Desjobert means, by reason of its subsequent cost in men and money. +The town was taken by a small force on the 29th September 1833.) +"The soldiers were then told that their mission was agricultural +rather than military, that they would have to handle the pick and +the spade more frequently than the musket. The unfortunates have +certainly handled pick and spade; but it was to dig in that immense +cemetery which, each day, swallows up their comrades. Already, +in 1836, General d'Erlon, ex-governor of Algiers, demanded the +evacuation of Bougie, which had devoured, in three years, three +thousand men and seven millions of francs." The demand was not +complied with, and Bougie has continued to consume more than its +quota of the six thousand men at which M. Desjobert estimates the +average annual loss, by disease alone, of the African army. Bougie +has not flourished under the tricolor. In former times a city of +great riches and importance, it still contained several thousand +inhabitants when taken by the French. At the period of Mr Borrer's +visit, it reckoned a population of five hundred, exclusive of the +garrison of twelve hundred men. To return, however, to the systems +of colonisation. When the generals had had their say, it was the +turn of the commissions; the commission of Africa, that of the +Chamber of Deputies, &c. There was no lack of projects; but none of +them answered. The colonial policy of the Orleans government was +eminently short-sighted. This is strikingly shown in Mr Borrer's +14th chapter, "A Word upon the Colony." Of the fertile plain +of the Metidja, containing about a million and a half acres of +arable and pasture land, a very small portion is cultivated. The +French found a garden; they have made a desert. "Before the French +occupation, vast tracts which now lie waste, sacrificed to palmetta +and squills, were cultivated by the Arabs, who grew far more corn +than was required for their own consumption; whereas now, they grow +barely sufficient: the consequence of which is, that the price of +corn is enormous in Algeria at present." Land is cheap enough, but +labour is dear, because the necessaries of life are so. Instead of +making Algiers a free port, protection to French manufactures is +the order of the day, and this has driven Arab commerce to Tunis +and Morocco. Rivalry with England--the feverish desire for colonies +and for the supremacy of the seas--must unquestionably be ranked +amongst the motives of the tenacious retention of such an expensive +possession as Algeria. And now the odious English cottons are +an obstacle to the prosperity of the colony. To sell a few more +bales of French calicoes and crates of French hardware, the wise +men at Paris put an effectual check upon the progress of African +agriculture. Here, if anywhere, free-trade might be introduced +with advantage; in common necessaries, at any rate, and for a few +years, till the country became peopled, and the colonists had +overcome the first difficulties of their position. It would make +very little difference to Rouen and Lyons, whilst to the settlers +it would practically work more good than would have been done them +by M. Lamoricière's _subvention_, supposing this to have been +adopted, and that the heavily-taxed agriculturist of France--in +many parts of which country land pays but two and a half or three +per cent--had consented to pay additional imposts for the benefit +of the agriculturist of Algeria. In the beginning, the notion of +the French government was, that its new conquest would colonise +itself unassisted; that there would be a natural and steady flow +of emigrants from the mother country. In any case this expectation +would probably have proved fallacious--at least it would never have +been realised to the extent anticipated; but the small encouragement +given to such emigration, rendered it utterly abortive. The +"stream" of settlers proved a mere dribble. Security and justice, +Mr Thiers said, were all that France owed her colony. Even these +two things were not obtained, in the full sense of the words. The +centralisation system weighed upon Algeria. Everything was referred +to Paris. Hence interminable correspondence, and delays innumerable. +In the year 1846, Mr Borrer says, twenty-four thousand despatches +were received by the civil administration from the chief _bureau_ +in the French capital, in exchange for twenty-eight thousand sent. +Instead of imparting all possible celerity to the administrative +forms requisite to the establishment of emigrants, these must +often wait a year or more before they are put in possession of +the land granted. Meanwhile they expend their resources, and are +enervated by idleness and disease. The climate of North Africa +is ill-adapted to French constitutions. M. Desjobert has already +told us the average loss of the army, and General Duvivier, in +his _Solution de la Question d'Algérie_, fully corroborated his +statements. "A man," said the general, "whose constitution is not +in harmony with the climate of Africa, never adapts himself to it; +he suffers, wastes away, and dies. The expression, that a mass of +men who have been for some time in Africa have become inured to +the climate, is inexact. They have not become inured to it; they +have been _decimated by death_. _The climate is a great sieve, +which allows a rapid passage to everything that is not of a certain +force._" Supposing 100,000 men sent from France to Algeria for six +years' service. At the end of that time, their loss by disease +alone, at the rate of six per cent--proved by M. Desjobert to be +the annual average--would amount to upwards of 30,000, or to more +than three-tenths of the whole. The emigrants fare no better. +"They look for milk and honey," says Borrer: "they find palmetta +and disease. The villages scattered about the Sahel or Massif of +Algiers (a high ground at the back of the city, forming a rampart +between the Metidja and the Mediterranean) are, with one or two +exceptions, a type of desolation. Perched upon the most arid spots, +distant from water, the poor tenants lie sweltering between sun +and sirocco." A Mississippi swamp must be as eligible "squatting" +ground as this--Arabs instead of alligators, and the Algerine fever +in place of Yellow Jack. "At the gates of Algiers, in the villages +of the Sahel," said the "_Algérie_" newspaper of the 22d December +1845, "the colonists desert, driven away by hunger. If any remain, +it is because they have no strength to move. In the plain of the +Metidja, the misery and desolation are greater still. At Fondouck, +in the last five months, 120 persons have died, out of a population +of 280." The reporter to the Commission of the French budget of 1837 +(Monsieur Bignon) admitted that "the results of the colonisation are +almost negative." He could not obtain, he said, an estimate of the +agricultural population. At the same period, an Algiers newspaper +(_La France Algérienne_) estimated the European agriculturists at +7000, two-thirds of whom were mere market-gardeners. + + [12] "General Lamoricière habitually carries a stick. This has + procured him, from the Arabs, the name of the _Père-au-bâton_, (the + father with the stick:) _Bour-à-boi_. One of his orderly officers, + my friend and comrade Captain Bentzman, gives _Araouah_ as the + proper orthography of _Bour-à-boi_. We have followed Escoffier's + pronunciation."--_Captivité d'Escoffier_, vol. i. p. 30. + +It is unnecessary to multiply proofs; and we will here conclude this +imperfect sketch of Franco-African colonisation, of its crimes, its +errors, and its cost, by extracting a rather remarkable passage +from a writer we have more than once referred to, and who, although +perhaps disposed to view things in Algeria upon the black side, is +yet deserving of credit, as well by his position as by reason of his +painstaking research and, so far as we have verified them, accurate +statistics. + +"The colonists cannot deny," says Monsieur Desjobert in his _Algérie +en_ 1846, "and they admit: + +"1º. That Europe alone maintains the 200,000 Europeans in Algeria. +In 1846 we are compelled to repeat what General Bernard, minister +of war, said in 1838: 'Algeria resembles a naked rock, which it is +necessary to supply with everything, except air and water.' + +"2º. That so long as we remain in this precarious situation, a naval +war, by interrupting the communications, would compromise the safety +of our army. In 1846 we repeat M. Thiers' words, uttered in 1837: +'If war surprises you in the state of indecision in which you are, I +say that the disgraceful evacuation of Africa will be inevitable.' + +"M. Thiers did not speak the whole truth when he talked of +evacuation. In such an extremity, evacuation would be impossible. +Our army would perish of misery, and its remnant would fall into the +hands of the enemy." + +Another enemy than the Arabs is here evidently pointed at; that +possible foe is now a friend to France, and we trust will long +remain so. But on many accounts the sentences we have just quoted +are significant, as proceeding from the pen of a French deputy. They +need no comment, and we shall offer none. We wait with interest to +see if France's African colony prospers better under the Republic of +1848 than it did under the Monarchy of 1830. + + + + +THE CAXTONS. + + +PART IX.--CHAPTER XXXIX. + +And my father pushed aside his books. + +O young reader, whoever thou art,--or reader, at least, who hast +been young,--canst thou not remember some time when, with thy wild +troubles and sorrows as yet borne in secret, thou hast come back +from that hard, stern world which opens on thee when thou puttest +thy foot out of the threshold of home--come back to the four quiet +walls, wherein thine elders sit in peace--and seen, with a sort of +sad amaze, how calm and undisturbed all is there? That generation +which has gone before thee in the path of the passions--the +generation of thy parents--(not so many years, perchance, remote +from thine own)--how immovably far off, in its still repose, it +seems from thy turbulent youth! It has in it a stillness as of a +classic age, antique as the statues of the Greeks. That tranquil +monotony of routine into which those lives that preceded thee have +merged--the occupations that they have found sufficing for their +happiness, by the fireside--in the armchair and corner appropriated +to each--how strangely they contrast thine own feverish excitement! +And they make room for thee, and bid thee welcome, and then resettle +to their hushed pursuits, as if nothing had happened! Nothing had +happened! while in thy heart, perhaps, the whole world seems to have +shot from its axis, all the elements to be at war! And you sit down, +crushed by that quiet happiness which you can share no more, and +smile mechanically, and look into the fire; and, ten to one, you say +nothing till the time comes for bed, and you take up your candle, +and creep miserably to your lonely room. + +Now, if in a stage coach in the depth of winter, when three +passengers are warm and snug, a fourth, all besnowed and frozen, +descends from the outside and takes place amongst them, straightway +all the three passengers shift their places, uneasily pull up their +cloak collars, re-arrange their "comforters," feel indignantly +a sensible loss of caloric--the intruder has at least made a +sensation. But if you had all the snows of the Grampians in your +heart, you might enter unnoticed: take care not to tread on the +toes of your opposite neighbour, and not a soul is disturbed, not a +"comforter" stirs an inch! I had not slept a wink, I had not even +laid down all that night--the night in which I had said farewell +to Fanny Trevanion--and the next morning, when the sun rose, I +wandered out--where I know not. I have a dim recollection of long, +gray, solitary streets--of the river, that seemed flowing in dull +silence, away, far away, into some invisible eternity--trees and +turf, and the gay voices of children. I must have gone from one end +of the great Babel to the other: but my memory only became clear +and distinct when I knocked, somewhere before noon, at the door of +my father's house, and, passing heavily up the stairs, came into +the drawing-room, which was the rendezvous of the little family; +for, since we had been in London, my father had ceased to have his +study apart, and contented himself with what he called "a corner"--a +corner wide enough to contain two tables and a dumb waiter, with +chairs _à discretion_ all littered with books. On the opposite side +of this capacious corner sat my uncle, now nearly convalescent, and +he was jotting down, in his stiff military hand, certain figures in +a little red account-book--for you know already that my uncle Roland +was, in his expenses, the most methodical of men. + +My father's face was more benign than usual, for, before him lay a +proof--the first proof of his first work--his one work--the Great +Book! Yes! it had positively found a press. And the first proof of +your first work--ask any author what _that_ is! My mother was out, +with the faithful Mrs Primmins, shopping or marketing no doubt; +so, while the brothers were thus engaged, it was natural that my +entrance should not make as much noise as if it had been a bomb, +or a singer, or a clap of thunder, or the last "great novel of +the season," or anything else that made a noise in those days. For +what makes a noise now? Now, when the most astonishing thing of all +is in our easy familiarity with things astounding--when we say, +listlessly, "Another revolution at Paris," or, "By the bye, there +is the deuce to do at Vienna!"--when De Joinville is catching fish +in the ponds at Claremont, and you hardly turn back to look at +Metternich on the pier at Brighton! + +My uncle nodded, and growled indistinctly; my father-- + +"Put aside his books; you have told us that already." + +Sir, you are very much mistaken, he did not put aside his books, for +he was not engaged in them--he was reading his proof. And he smiled, +and pointed to it (the proof I mean) pathetically, and with a kind +of humour, as much as to say--"What can you expect, Pisistratus?--my +new baby! in short clothes--or long primer, which is all the same +thing!" + +I took a chair between the two, and looked first at one, then at +the other, and--heaven forgive me!--I felt a rebellious, ungrateful +spite against both. The bitterness of my soul must have been deep +indeed to have overflowed in that direction, but it did. The grief +of youth is an abominable egotist, and that is the truth. I got up +from the chair, and walked towards the window; it was open, and +outside the window was Mrs Primmins' canary, in its cage. London +air had agreed with it, and it was singing lustily. Now, when the +canary saw me standing opposite to its cage, and regarding it +seriously, and, I have no doubt, with a very sombre aspect, the +creature stopped short, and hung its head on one side, looking at +me obliquely and suspiciously. Finding that I did it no harm, it +began to hazard a few broken notes, timidly and interrogatively, as +it were, pausing between each; and at length, as I made no reply, +it evidently thought it had solved the doubt, and ascertained that +I was more to be pitied than feared--for it stole gradually into +so soft and silvery a strain that, I verily believe, it did it on +purpose to comfort me!--me, its old friend, whom it had unjustly +suspected. Never did any music touch me so home as did that long, +plaintive cadence. And when the bird ceased, it perched itself close +to the bars of the cage, and looked at me steadily with its bright +intelligent eyes. I felt mine water, and I turned back and stood +in the centre of the room, irresolute what to do, where to go. My +father had done with the proof, and was deep in his folios. Roland +had clasped his red account book, restored it to his pocket, wiped +his pen carefully, and now watched me from under his great beetle +brows. Suddenly he rose, and, stamping on the hearth with his cork +leg, exclaimed, "Look up from those cursed books, brother Austin! +What is there in that lad's face? Construe _that_, if you can!" + + +CHAPTER XL. + +And my father pushed aside his books, and rose hastily. He took off +his spectacles, and rubbed them mechanically, but he said nothing; +and my uncle, staring at him for a moment, in surprise at his +silence, burst out,-- + +"Oh! I see--he has been getting into some scrape, and you are angry! +Fie! young blood will have its way, Austin--it will. I don't blame +that--it is only when--come here, Sisty! Zounds! man, come here." + +My father gently brushed off the captain's hand, and, advancing +towards me, opened his arms. The next moment I was sobbing on his +breast. + +"But what is the matter?" cried Captain Roland, "will nobody +say what is the matter? Money, I suppose--money, you confounded +extravagant young dog. Luckily you have got an uncle who has more +than he knows what to do with. How much?--fifty?--a hundred? two +hundred? How can I write the cheque, if you'll not speak?" + +"Hush, brother! it is no money you can give that will set this +right. My poor boy! have I guessed truly? Did I guess truly the +other evening, when--" + +"Yes, sir, yes! I have been so wretched. But I am better now--I can +tell you all." + +My uncle moved slowly towards the door: his fine sense of delicacy +made him think that even he was out of place in the confidence +between son and father. + +"No, uncle," I said, holding out my hand to him, "stay; you too can +advise me--strengthen me. I have kept my honour yet--help me to keep +it still." + +At the sound of the word honour Captain Roland stood mute, and +raised his head quickly. + +So I told all--incoherently enough at first, but clearly and +manfully as I went on. Now I know that it is not the custom of +lovers to confide in fathers and uncles. Judging by those mirrors +of life, plays and novels, they choose better;--valets and +chambermaids, and friends whom they have picked up in the street, +as I had picked up poor Francis Vivian--to these they make clean +breasts of their troubles. But fathers and uncles--to them they are +close, impregnable, "buttoned to the chin." The Caxtons were an +eccentric family, and never did anything like other people. When I +had ended, I lifted my eyes, and said pleadingly, "Now, tell me, is +there no hope--none?" + +"Why should there be none?" cried Captain Roland hastily--"the De +Caxtons are as good a family as the Trevanions; and as for yourself, +all I will say is, that the young lady might choose worse for her +own happiness." + +I wrung my uncles hand, and turned to my father in anxious fear--for +I knew that, in spite of his secluded habits, few men ever formed +a sounder judgment on worldly matters, when he was fairly drawn to +look at them. A thing wonderful is that plain wisdom which scholars +and poets often have for others, though they rarely deign to use it +for themselves. And how on earth do they get at it? I looked at my +father, and the vague hope Roland had excited fell as I looked. + +"Brother," said he slowly, and shaking his head, "the world, which +gives codes and laws to those who live in it, does not care much for +a pedigree, unless it goes with a title-deed to estates." + +"Trevanion was not richer than Pisistratus when he married Lady +Ellinor," said my uncle. + +"True; but Lady Ellinor was not then an heiress, and her father +viewed these matters as no other peer in England perhaps would. +As for Trevanion himself, I dare say he has no prejudices about +station, but he is strong in common sense. He values himself on +being a practical man. It would be folly to talk to him of love, and +the affections of youth. He would see in the son of Austin Caxton, +living on the interest of some fifteen or sixteen thousand pounds, +such a match for his daughter as no prudent man in his position +could approve. And as for Lady Ellinor"-- + +"She owes us much, Austin!" exclaimed Roland, his face darkening. + +"Lady Ellinor is now what, if we had known her better, she promised +always to be--the ambitious, brilliant, scheming woman of the world. +Is it not so, Pisistratus?" + +I said nothing. I felt too much. + +"And does the girl like you?--but I think it is clear she does!" +exclaimed Roland. "Fate--fate; it has been a fatal family to us! +Zounds, Austin, it was your fault. Why did you let him go there?" + +"My son is now a man--at least in heart, if not in years--can man +be shut from danger and trial? They found me in the old parsonage, +brother!" said my father mildly. + +My uncle walked, or rather stumped, three times up and down the +room; and he then stopped short, folded his arms, and came to a +decision-- + +"If the girl likes you, your duty is doubly clear--you can't take +advantage of it. You have done right to leave the house, for the +temptation might be too strong." + +"But what excuse shall I make to Mr Trevanion?" said I feebly--"what +story can I invent? So careless as he is while he trusts, so +penetrating if he once suspects, he will see through all my +subterfuges, and--and--" + +"It is as plain as a pike-staff," said my uncle abruptly--"and +there need be no subterfuge in the matter. 'I must leave you, Mr +Trevanion.' 'Why?' says he. 'Don't ask me.' He insists. 'Well then, +sir, if you must know, I love your daughter. I have nothing--she +is a great heiress. You will not approve of that love, and +therefore I leave you!' That is the course that becomes an English +gentleman--eh, Austin?" + +"You are never wrong when your instincts speak, Roland," said my +father. "Can you say this, Pisistratus, or shall I say it for you?" + +"Let him say it himself," said Roland; "and let him judge himself of +the answer. He is young, he is clever, he may make a figure in the +world. Trevanion _may_ answer, 'Win the lady after you have won the +laurel, like the knights of old.' At all events, you will hear the +worst." + +"I will go," said I, firmly; and I took my hat, and left the room. +As I was passing the landing-place, a light step stole down the +upper flight of stairs, and a little hand seized my own. I turned +quickly, and met the full, dark, seriously sweet eyes of my cousin +Blanche. + +"Don't go away yet, Sisty," said she coaxingly. "I have been waiting +for you, for I heard your voice, and did not like to come in and +disturb you." + +"And why did you wait for me, my little Blanche?" + +"Why! only to see you. But your eyes are red. Oh, cousin!"--and, +before I was aware of her childish impulse, she had sprung to my +neck and kissed me. Now Blanche was not like most children, and +was very sparing of her caresses. So it was out of the deeps of +a kind heart that that kiss came. I returned it without a word; +and, putting her down gently, ran down the stairs, and was in the +streets. But I had not got far before I heard my father's voice; and +he came up, and, hooking his arm into mine, said, "Are there not +two of us that suffer?--let us be together!" I pressed his arm, and +we walked on in silence. But when we were near Trevanion's house, +I said hesitatingly, "Would it not be better, sir, that I went in +alone. If there is to be an explanation between Mr Trevanion and +myself, would it not seem as if your presence implied either a +request to him that would lower us both, or a doubt of me that--" + +"You will go in alone, of course: I will wait for you--" + +"Not in the streets--oh no, father," cried I, touched inexpressibly. +For all this was so unlike my father's habits, that I felt remorse +to have so communicated my young griefs to the calm dignity of his +serene life. + +"My son, you do not know how I love you. I have only known it myself +lately. Look you, I am living in you now, my first-born; not in my +other son--the great book: I must have my way. Go in; that is the +door, is it not?" + +I pressed my father's hand, and I felt then, that, while that hand +could reply to mine, even the loss of Fanny Trevanion could not +leave the world a blank. How much we have before us in life, while +we retain our parents! How much to strive and to hope for! What a +motive in the conquest of our sorrow--that they may not sorrow with +us! + + +CHAPTER XLI. + +I entered Trevanion's study. It was an hour in which he was rarely +at home, but I had not thought of that; and I saw without surprise +that, contrary to his custom, he was in his armchair, reading one of +his favourite classic authors, instead of being in some committee +room of the House of Commons. + +"A pretty fellow you are," said he, looking up, "to leave me +all the morning, without rhyme or reason. And my committee is +postponed--chairman ill--people who get ill should not go into the +House of Commons. So here I am, looking into Propertius: Parr is +right; not so elegant a writer as Tibullus. But what the deuce are +you about?--why don't you sit down? Humph! you look grave--you have +something to say,--say it!" + +And, putting down Propertius, the acute, sharp face of Trevanion +instantly became earnest and attentive. + +"My dear Mr Trevanion," said I, with as much steadiness as I could +assume, "you have been most kind to me; and, out of my own family, +there is no man I love and respect more." + +TREVANION.--Humph! What's all this! (_In an under tone_)--Am I going +to be taken in? + +PISISTRATUS.--Do not think me ungrateful, then, when I say I come to +resign my office--to leave the house where I have been so happy. + +TREVANION.--Leave the house!--Pooh!--I have overtasked you. I +will be more merciful in future. You must forgive a political +economist--it is the fault of my sect to look upon men as machines. + +PISISTRATUS--(_smiling faintly_.)--No, indeed--that is not it! I +have nothing to complain of--nothing I could wish altered--could I +stay. + +TREVANION (_examining me thoughtfully_.)--And does your father +approve of your leaving me thus? + +PISISTRATUS--Yes, fully. + +TREVANION (_musing a moment_.)--I see, he would send you to the +University, make you a book-worm like himself: pooh! that will not +do--you will never become wholly a man of books,--it is not in you. +Young man, though I may seem careless, I read characters, when I +please it, pretty quickly. You do wrong to leave me; you are made +for the great world--I can open to you a high career. I wish to do +so! Lady Ellinor wishes it--nay, insists on it--for your father's +sake as well as yours. I never ask a favour from ministers, and I +never will. But (here Trevanion rose suddenly, and, with an erect +mien and a quick gesture of his arm, he added)--but a minister +himself can dispose as he pleases of his patronage. Look you, it +is a secret yet, and I trust to your honour. But, before the year +is out, I must be in the cabinet. Stay with me, I guarantee your +fortunes--three months ago I would not have said that. By-and-by +I will open parliament for you--you are not of age yet--work till +then. And now sit down and write my letters--a sad arrear!" + +"My dear, dear Mr Trevanion!" said I, so affected that I could +scarcely speak, and seizing his hand, which I pressed between +both mine--"I dare not thank you--I cannot! But you don't know my +heart--it is not ambition. No! if I could but stay here on the same +terms for ever--_here_--(looking ruefully on that spot where Fanny +had stood the night before,) but it is impossible! If you knew all, +you would be the first to bid me go!" + +"You are in debt," said the man of the world, coldly. "Bad, very +bad--still--" + +"No, sir; no! worse--" + +"Hardly possible to be worse, young man--hardly! But, just as you +will; you leave me, and will not say why. Good-by. Why do you +linger? shake hands, and go!" + +"I cannot leave you thus: I--I--sir, the truth shall out. I am rash +and mad enough not to see Miss Trevanion without forgetting that I +am poor, and--" + +"Ha!" interrupted Trevanion softly, and growing pale, "this is a +misfortune indeed! And I, who talked of reading characters! Truly, +truly, we would-be practical men are fools--fools! And you have made +love to my daughter!" + +"Sir! Mr Trevanion! I--no--never, never so base! In your house, +trusted by you,--how could you think it? I dared, it may be, to +love--at all events, to feel that I could not be insensible to a +temptation too strong for me. But to say it to your daughter--to ask +love in return--I would as soon have broken open your desk! Frankly +I tell you my folly: it is a folly, not a disgrace." + +Trevanion came up to me abruptly, as I leant against the book-case, +and, grasping my hand with a cordial kindness, said,--"Pardon me! +You have behaved as your father's son should--I envy him such a son! +Now, listen to me--I cannot give you my daughter--" + +"Believe me, sir, I never--" + +"Tut, listen! I cannot give you my daughter. I say nothing of +inequality--all gentlemen are equal; and if not, all impertinent +affectation of superiority, in such a case, would come ill from +one who owes his own fortune to his wife! But, as it is, I have a +stake in the world, won not by fortune only, but the labour of a +life, the suppression of half my nature--the drudging, squaring, +taming down--all that made the glory and joy of my youth--to be +that hard matter-of-fact thing which the English world expect in +a--_statesman_! This station has gradually opened into its natural +result--power! I tell you I shall soon have high office in the +administration: I hope to render great services to England--for we +English politicians, whatever the mob and the press say of us, are +not selfish placehunters. I refused office, as high as I look for +now, ten years ago. We believe in our opinions, and we hail the +power that may carry them into effect. In this cabinet I shall have +enemies. Oh, don't think we leave jealousy behind us, at the doors +of Downing Street! I shall be one of a minority. I know well what +must happen: like all men in power, I must strengthen myself by +other heads and hands than my own. My daughter should bring to me +the alliance of that house in England which is most necessary to me. +My life falls to the ground, like a house of cards, if I waste--I +do not say on you, but on men of ten times your fortune (whatever +that be,)--the means of strength which are at my disposal in the +hand of Fanny Trevanion. To this end I have looked; but to this end +her mother has schemed--for these household matters are within a +man's hopes, but belong to a woman's policy. So much for us. But +for you, my dear, and frank, and high-souled young friend--for you, +if I were not Fanny's father--if I were your nearest relation, and +Fanny could be had for the asking, with all her princely dower, (for +it is princely,)--for you I should say, fly from a load upon the +heart, on the genius, the energy, the pride, and the spirit, which +not one man in ten thousand can bear; fly from the curse of owing +every thing to a wife!--it is a reversal of all natural position, it +is a blow to all the manhood within us. You know not what it is: I +do! My wife's fortune came not till after marriage--so far, so well; +it saved my reputation from the charge of fortune-hunting. But, I +tell you fairly, that if it had never come at all, I should be a +prouder, and a greater, and a happier man than I have ever been, +or ever can be, with all its advantages; it has been a millstone +round my neck. And yet Ellinor has never breathed a word that could +wound my pride. Would her daughter be as forbearing? Much as I love +Fanny, I doubt if she has the great heart of her mother. You look +incredulous;--naturally. Oh, you think I shall sacrifice my child's +happiness to a politician's ambition! Folly of youth! Fanny would be +wretched with you. She might not think so now; she would five years +hence! Fanny will make an admirable duchess, countess, great lady; +but wife to a man who owes all to her!--no, no, don't dream it! I +shall not sacrifice her happiness, depend on it. I speak plainly, as +man to man--man of the world to a man just entering it--but still +man to man! What say you?" + +"I will think over all you tell me. I know that you are speaking to +me most generously--as a father would. Now let me go, and may God +keep you and yours!" + +"Go--I return your blessing--go! I don't insult you now with offers +of service; but, remember, you have a right to command them--in all +ways, in all times. Stop!--take this comfort away with you--a sorry +comfort now, a great one hereafter. In a position that might have +moved anger, scorn, pity, you have made a barren-hearted man honour +and admire you. You, a boy, have made me, with my gray hairs, think +better of the whole world: tell your father that." + +I closed the door, and stole out softly--softly. But when I got into +the hall, Fanny suddenly opened the door of the breakfast parlour, +and seemed, by her look, her gesture, to invite me in. Her face was +very pale, and there were traces of tears on the heavy lids. + +I stood still a moment, and my heart beat violently. I then muttered +something inarticulately, and, bowing low, hastened to the door. + +I thought, but my ears might deceive me, that I heard my name +pronounced; but fortunately the tall porter started from his +newspaper and his leather chair, and the entrance stood open. I +joined my father. + +"It is all over," said I, with a resolute smile. "And now, my +dear father, I feel how grateful I should be for all that your +lessons--your life--have, taught me;--for, believe me, I am not +unhappy." + + +CHAPTER XLII. + +We came back to my father's house, and on the stairs we met my +mother, whom Roland's grave looks, and her Austin's strange absence, +had alarmed. My father quietly led the way to a little room, which +my mother had appropriated to Blanche and herself; and then, placing +my hand in that which had helped his own steps from the stony path, +down the quiet vales of life, he said to me,--"Nature gives you here +the soother;"--and, so saying, he left the room. + +And it was true, O my mother! that in thy simple loving breast +nature did place the deep wells of comfort! We come to men for +philosophy--to women for consolation. And the thousand weaknesses +and regrets--the sharp sands of the minutiæ that make up +_sorrow_--all these, which I could have betrayed to no _man_--not +even to him, the dearest and tenderest of all men--I showed without +shame to thee! And thy tears, that fell on my cheek, had the balm +of Araby; and my heart, at length, lay lulled and soothed under thy +moist gentle eyes. + +I made an effort, and joined the little circle at dinner; and +I felt grateful that no violent attempt was made to raise my +spirits--nothing but affection, more subdued, and soft, and +tranquil. Even little Blanche, as if by the intuition of sympathy, +ceased her babble, and seemed to hush her footstep as she crept +to my side. But after dinner, when we had reassembled in the +drawing-room, and the lights shone bright, and the curtains were +let down--and only the quick roll of some passing wheels reminded +us that there was a world without--my father began to talk. He had +laid aside all his work; the younger, but less perishable child was +forgotten,--and my father began to talk. + +"It is," said he musingly, "a well-known thing, that particular +drugs or herbs suit the body according to its particular diseases. +When we are ill, we don't open our medicinechest at random, and take +out any powder or phial that comes to hand. The skilful doctor is he +who adjusts the dose to the malady." + +"Of that there can be no doubt," quoth Captain Roland. "I remember +a notable instance of the justice of what you say. When I was in +Spain, both my horse and I fell ill at the same time; a dose was +sent for each; and, by some infernal mistake, I swallowed the +horse's physic, and the horse, poor thing, swallowed mine!" + +"And what was the result?" asked my father. + +"The horse died!", answered Roland mournfully--"a valuable +beast--bright bay, with a star!" + +"And you?" + +"Why, the doctor said it ought to have killed me; but it took a +great deal more than a paltry bottle of physic to kill a man in my +regiment." + +"Nevertheless, we arrive at the same conclusion," pursued my +father,--"I with my theory, you with your experience,--that the +physic we take must not be chosen hap-hazard; and that a mistake +in the bottle may kill a horse. But when we come to the medicine +for the mind, how little do we think of the golden rule which +common-sense applies to the body." + +"Anon," said the Captain, "what medicine is there for the mind? +Shakspeare has said something on that subject, which, if I recollect +right, implies that there is no ministering to a mind diseased." + +"I think not, brother; he only said physic (meaning boluses and +black draughts) would not do it. And Shakspeare was the last man +to find fault with his own art; for, verily, he has been a great +physician to the mind." + +"Ah! I take you now, brother,--books again! So you think that, +when a man breaks his heart, or loses his fortune, or his +daughter--(Blanche, child, come here)--that you have only to clap +a plaster of print on the sore place, and all is well. I wish you +would find me such a cure." + +"Will you try it?" + +"If it is not Greek," said my uncle. + + +CHAPTER XLIII. + +MY FATHER'S CROTCHET ON THE HYGEIENIC CHEMISTRY OF BOOKS. + +"If," said my father--and here his hand was deep in his +waistcoat--"if we accept the authority of Diodorus, as to the +inscription on the great Egyptian library--and I don't see why +Diodorus should not be as near the mark as any one else?" added my +father interrogatively, turning round. + +My mother thought herself the person addressed, and nodded her +gracious assent to the authority of Diodorus. His opinion thus +fortified, my father continued,--"If, I say, we accept the authority +of Diodorus, the inscription on the Egyptian library was--'The +Medicine of the Mind.' Now, that phrase has become notoriously trite +and hackneyed, and people repeat vaguely that books are the medicine +of the mind. Yes; but to apply the medicine is the thing!" + +"So you have told us at least twice before, brother," quoth the +Captain, bluffly. "And what Diodorus has to do with it, I know no +more than the man of the moon." + +"I shall never get on at this rate," said my father, in a tone +between reproach and entreaty. + +"Be good children, Roland and Blanche both," said my mother, +stopping from her work, and holding up her needle threateningly--and +indeed inflicting a slight puncture upon the Captain's shoulder. + +"Rem _acu_ tetigisti, my dear," said my father, borrowing Cicero's +pun on the occasion.[13] "And now we shall go upon velvet. I say, +then, that books, taken indiscriminately, are no cure to the +diseases and afflictions of the mind. There is a world of science +necessary in the taking them. I have known some people in great +sorrow fly to a novel, or the last light book in fashion. One +might as well take a rose-draught for the plague! Light reading +does not do when the heart is really heavy. I am told that Goethe, +when he lost his son, took to study a science that was new to +him. Ah! Goethe was a physician who knew what he was about. In a +great grief like that, you cannot tickle and divert the mind; you +must wrench it away, abstract, absorb--bury it in an abyss, hurry +it into a labyrinth. Therefore, for the irremediable sorrows of +middle life and old age, I recommend a strict chronic, course of +science and hard reasoning--Counter-irritation. Bring the brain to +act upon the heart! If science is too much against the grain, (for +we have not all got mathematical heads,) something in the reach +of the humblest understanding, but sufficiently searching to the +highest--a new language--Greek, Arabic, Scandinavian, Chinese, or +Welch! For the loss of fortune, the dose should be applied less +directly to the understanding.--I would administer something elegant +and cordial. For as the heart is crushed and lacerated by a loss in +the affections, so it is rather the head that aches and suffers by +the loss of money. Here we find the higher class of poets a very +valuable remedy. For observe, that poets of the grander and more +comprehensive kind of genius have in them two separate men, quite +distinct from each other--the imaginative man, and the practical, +circumstantial man; and it is the happy mixture of these that suits +diseases of the mind, half imaginative and half practical. There +is Homer, now lost with the gods, now at home with the homeliest, +the very 'poet of circumstance,' as Gray has finely called him; and +yet with imagination enough to seduce and coax the dullest into +forgetting, for a while, that little spot on his desk which his +banker's book can cover. There is Virgil, far below him, indeed. + + [13] Cicero's joke on a senator who was the son of a tailor--"Thou + hast touched the thing sharply;" (or with a needle--_acu_.) + + --'Virgil the wise, + Whose verse walks highest, but not flies.' + +as Cowley expresses it. But Virgil still has genius enough to +be two men--to lead you into the fields, not only to listen to +the pastoral reed, and to hear the bees hum, but to note how you +can make the most of the glebe and the vineyard. There is Horace, +charming man of the world, who will condole with you feelingly +on the loss of your fortune, and by no means undervalue the good +things of this life; but who will yet show you that a man may be +happy with a _vile modicum_, or _parva rura_. There is Shakspeare, +who, above all poets, is the mysterious dual of hard sense and +empyreal fancy--and a great many more, whom I need not name; but +who, if you take to them gently and quietly, will not, like your +mere philosopher, your unreasonable stoic, tell you that you have +lost nothing; but who will insensibly steal you out of this world, +with its losses and crosses, and slip you into another world, before +you know where you are!--a world where you are just as welcome, +though you carry no more earth of your lost acres with you than +covers the sole of your shoe. Then, for hypochondria and satiety, +what is better than a brisk alterative course of travels--especially +early, out of the way, marvellous, legendary travels! How they +freshen up the spirits! How they take you out of the humdrum yawning +state you are in. See, with Herodotus, young Greece spring up into +life; or note with him how already the wondrous old Orient world +is crumbling into giant decay; or go with Carpini and Rubruquis to +Tartary, meet 'the carts of Zagathai laden with houses, and think +that a great city is travelling towards you.'[14] Gaze on that +vast wild empire of the Tartar, where the descendants of Jenghis +'multiply and disperse over the immense waste desert, which is as +boundless as the ocean.' Sail with the early northern discoverers, +and penetrate to the heart of winter, among sea-serpents and bears, +and tusked morses, with the faces of men. Then, what think you of +Columbus, and the stern soul of Cortes, and the kingdom of Mexico, +and the strange gold city of the Peruvians, with that audacious +brute Pizarro? and the Polynesians, just for all the world like +the ancient Britons? and the American Indians, and the South-Sea +Islanders? how petulant, and young, and adventurous, and frisky your +hypochondriac must get upon a regimen like that! Then, for that +vice of the mind which I call sectarianism--not in the religious +sense of the word, but little, narrow prejudices, that make you +hate your next-door neighbour, because he has his eggs roasted +when you have yours boiled; and gossiping and prying into people's +affairs, and back-biting, and thinking heaven and earth are coming +together, if some broom touch a cobweb that you have let grow over +the window-sill of your brains--what like a large and generous, +mildly aperient (I beg your pardon, my dear) course of history! How +it clears away all the fumes of the head!--better than the hellebore +with which the old leeches of the middle ages purged the cerebellum. +There, amidst all that great whirl and _sturmbad_ (storm-bath), as +the Germans say, of kingdoms and empires, and races and ages, how +your mind enlarges beyond that little, feverish animosity to John +Styles; or that unfortunate prepossession of yours, that all the +world is interested in your grievances against Tom Stokes and his +wife! + + [14] RUBRUQUIS, sect. xii. + +"I can only touch, you see, on a few ingredients in this magnificent +pharmacy--its resources are boundless, but require the nicest +discretion. I remember to have cured a disconsolate widower, who +obstinately refused every other medicament, by a strict course of +geology. I dipped him deep into gneiss and mica schist. Amidst the +first strata, I suffered the watery action to expend itself upon +cooling crystallised masses; and, by the time I had got him into +the tertiary period, amongst the transition chalks of Maestricht, +and the conchiferous marls of Gosau, he was ready for a new wife. +Kitty, my dear! it is no laughing matter. I made no less notable +a cure of a young scholar at Cambridge, who was meant for the +church, when he suddenly caught a cold fit of freethinking, with +great shiverings, from wading over his depth in Spinosa. None of +the divines, whom I first tried, did him the least good in that +state; so I turned over a new leaf, and doctored him gently upon the +chapters of faith in Abraham Tucker's book, (you should read, it, +Sisty;) then I threw in strong doses of Fichté; after that I put him +on the Scotch metaphysicians, with plunge baths into certain German +transcendentalists; and having convinced him that faith is not an +unphilosophical state of mind, and that he might believe without +compromising his understanding--for he was mightily conceited on +that score--I threw in my divines, which he was now fit to digest; +and his theological constitution, since then, has become so robust, +that he has eaten up two livings and a deanery! In fact, I have +a plan for a library that, instead of heading its compartments, +'Philology, Natural Science, Poetry,' &c., one shall head them +according to the diseases for which they are severally good, bodily +and mental--up from a dire calamity, or the pangs of the gout, down +to a fit of the spleen, or a slight catarrh; for which last your +light reading comes in with a whey posset and barley-water. But," +continued my father more gravely, "when some one sorrow, that is +yet reparable, gets hold of your mind like a monomania--when you +think, because heaven has denied you this or that, on which you had +set your heart, that all your life must be a blank--oh, then diet +yourself well on biography--the biography of good and great men. +See how little a space one sorrow really makes in life. See scarce +a page, perhaps, given to some grief similar to your own; and how +triumphantly the life sails on, beyond it! You thought the wing was +broken!--Tut-tut--it was but a bruised feather! See what life leaves +behind it, when all is, done!--a summary of positive facts far out +of the region of sorrow and suffering, linking themselves with the +being of the world. Yes, biography is the medicine here! Roland, you +said you would try my prescription--here it is,"--and my father took +up a book, and reached it to the Captain. + +My uncle looked over it--_Life of the Reverend Robert Hall_. +"Brother, he was a Dissenter, and, thank heaven, I am a +church-and-state man, back and bone!" + +"Robert Hall was a brave man, and a true soldier under the great +commander," said my father artfully. + +The Captain mechanically carried his forefinger to his forehead in +military fashion, and saluted the book respectfully. + +"I have another copy for you, Pisistratus--that is mine which I have +lent Roland. This, which I bought for you to-day, you will keep." + +"Thank you, sir," said I listlessly, not seeing what great good the +_Life of Robert Hall_ could do me, or why the same medicine should +suit the old weatherbeaten uncle, and the nephew yet in his teens. + +"I have said nothing," resumed my father, slightly bowing his broad +temples, "of the Book of Books, for that is the _lignum vitæ_, the +cardinal medicine for all. These are but the subsidiaries: for, +as you may remember, my dear Kitty, that I have said before--we +can never keep the system quite right unless we place just in the +centre of the great ganglionic system, whence the nerves carry its +influence gently and smoothly through the whole frame--THE SAFFRON +BAG!" + + +CHAPTER XLIV. + +After breakfast the next morning, I took my hat to go out, when my +father, looking at me, and seeing by my countenance that I had not +slept, said gently-- + +"My dear Pisistratus, you have not tried my medicine yet." + +"What medicine, sir?" + +"Robert Hall." + +"No, indeed, not yet," said I, smiling. + +"Do so, my son, before you go out; depend on it, you will enjoy your +walk more." + +I confess that it was, with some reluctance I obeyed. I went back to +my own room, and sate resolutely down to my task. Are there any of +you, my readers, who have not read the _Life of Robert Hall_? If so, +in the words of the great Captain Cuttle, "When found, make a note +of it." Never mind what your theological opinion is--Episcopalian, +Presbyterian, Baptist, Pædobaptist, Independent, Quaker, Unitarian, +Philosopher, Freethinker--send for Robert Hall! Yea, if there exist +yet on earth descendants of the arch-heresies, which made such a +noise in their day--men who believe with Saturnians that the world +was made by seven angels; or with Basilides, that there are as many +heavens as there are days in the year; or with the Nicolaitanes, +that men ought to have their wives in common, (plenty of that sect +still, especially in the Red Republic;) or with their successors, +the Gnostics, who believed in Jaldaboath; or with the Carpacratians, +that the world was made by the devil; or with the Cerinthians, and +Ebionites, and Nazarites, (which last discovered that the name of +Noah's wife was Ouria, and that she set the ark on fire;) or with +the Valentinians, who taught that there were thirty Æones, ages, or +worlds, born out of Profundity, (Bathos,) male, and Silence, female; +or with the Marcites, Colarbasii, and Heracleonites, (who still +kept up that bother about Æones, Mr Profundity, and Mrs Silence;) +or with the Ophites, who are said to have worshipped the serpent; +or the Cainites, who ingeniously found out a reason for honouring +Judas, because he foresaw what good would come to men by betraying +our Saviour; or with the Sethites, who made Seth a part of the +Divine substance; or with the Archonticks, Ascothyptæ, Cerdonians, +Marcionites, the disciples of Apelles, and Severus, (the last was +a teetotaller, and said wine was begot by Satan!) or of Tatian, +who thought all the descendants of Adam were irretrievably damned +except themselves, (some of those Tatiani are certainly extant!) or +the Cataphrygians, who were also called Tascodragitæ, because they +thrust their forefingers up their nostrils to show their devotion; +or the Pepuzians, Quintilians, and Artotyrites; or--but no matter. +If I go through all the follies of men in search of the truth, I +shall never get to the end of my chapter, or back to Robert Hall: +whatever, then, thou art, orthodox or heterodox, send for the _Life +of Robert Hall_. It is the life of a man that it does good to +manhood itself to contemplate. + +I had finished the biography, which is not long, and was musing over +it, when I heard the Captain's cork-leg upon the stairs. I opened +the door for him, and he entered, book in hand, as I, also book in +hand, stood ready to receive him. + +"Well, sir," said Roland, seating himself, "has the prescription +done you any good?" + +"Yes, uncle--great." + +"And me too. By Jupiter, Sisty, that same Hall was a fine fellow! I +wonder if the medicine has gone through the same channels in both? +Tell me, first, how it has affected you." + +"_Imprimis_, then, my dear uncle, I fancy that a book like this must +do good to all who live in the world in the ordinary manner, by +admitting us into a circle of life of which I suspect we think but +little. Here is a man connecting himself directly with a heavenly +purpose, and cultivating considerable faculties to that one end; +seeking to accomplish his soul as far as he can, that he may do +most good on earth, and take a higher existence up to heaven; a man +intent upon a sublime and spiritual duty: in short, living as it +were in it, and so filled with the consciousness of immortality, +and so strong in the link between God and man, that, without any +affected stoicism, without being insensible to pain--rather, +perhaps, from a nervous temperament, acutely feeling it--he yet +has a happiness wholly independent of it. It is impossible not to +be thrilled with an admiration that elevates while it awes you, in +reading that solemn 'Dedication of himself to God.' This offering of +'soul and body, time, health, reputation, talents,' to the divine +and invisible Principle of Good, calls us suddenly to contemplate +the selfishness of our own views and hopes, and awakens us from the +egotism that exacts all and resigns nothing. + +"But this book has mostly struck upon the chord in my own heart, +in that characteristic which my father indicated as belonging to +all biography. Here is a life of remarkable _fulness_, great study, +great thought, and great action; and yet," said I, colouring, +"how small a place those feelings, which have tyrannised over me, +and made all else seem blank and void, hold in that life. It is +not as if the man were a cold and hard ascetic; it is easy to see +in him not only remarkable tenderness and warm affections, but +strong self-will, and the passion of all vigorous natures. Yes, I +understand better now what existence in a true man should be." + +"All that is very well said," quoth the Captain, "but it did not +strike me. What I have seen in this book is courage. Here is a +poor creature rolling on the carpet with agony; from childhood to +death tortured by a mysterious incurable malady--a malady that is +described as 'an internal apparatus of torture;' and who does, by +his heroism, more than _bear_ it--he puts it out of power to affect +him; and though (here is the passage) 'his appointment by day and by +night was incessant pain, yet high enjoyment was, notwithstanding, +the law of his existence.' Robert Hall reads me a lesson--me, an old +soldier, who thought myself above taking lessons--in courage, at +least. And, as I came to that passage when, in the sharp paroxysms +before death, he says, 'I have not complained, have I, sir?--and +I won't complain,'--when I came to that passage I started up, and +cried, 'Roland de Caxton, thou hast been a coward! and, an thou +hadst had thy deserts, thou hadst been cashiered, broken, and +drummed out of the regiment long ago!" + +"After all, then, my father was not so wrong--he placed his guns +right, and fired a good shot." + +"He must have been from 6° to 9° above the crest of the parapet," +said my uncle, thoughtfully--"which, I take it, is the best +elevation, both for shot and shells, in enfilading a work." + +"What say you, then, Captain? up with our knapsacks, and on with the +march!" + +"Right about--face!" cried my uncle, as erect as a column. + +"No looking back, if we can help it." + +"Full in the front of the enemy--'Up, guards, and at 'em!'" + +"'England expects every man to do his duty!"' + +"Cypress or laurel!" cried my uncle, waving the book over his head. + + +CHAPTER XLV. + +I went out--and to see Francis Vivian; for, on leaving Mr Trevanion, +I was not without anxiety for my new friend's future provision. +But Vivian was from home, and I strolled from his lodgings, into +the suburbs on the other side of the river, and began to meditate +seriously on the best course now to pursue. In quitting my present +occupations, I resigned prospects far more brilliant, and fortunes +far more rapid than I could ever hope to realise in any other +entrance into life. But I felt the necessity, if I desired to keep +steadfast to that more healthful frame of mind I had obtained, +of some manly and continuous labour--some earnest employment. +My thoughts flew back to the university; and the quiet of its +cloisters--which, until I had been blinded by the glare of the +London world, and grief had somewhat dulled the edge of my quick +desires and hopes, had seemed to me cheerless and unaltering--took +an inviting aspect. They presented what I needed most--a new scene, +a new arena, a partial return into boyhood; repose for passions +prematurely raised; activity for the reasoning powers in fresh +directions. I had not lost my time in London: I had kept up, if not +studies purely classical, at least the habits of application; I had +sharpened my general comprehension, and augmented my resources. +Accordingly, when I returned home, I resolved to speak to my father. +But I found he had forestalled me; and, on entering, my mother drew +me up stairs into her room, with a smile kindled by my smile, and +told me that she and her Austin had been thinking that it was best +that I should leave London as soon as possible; that my father +found he could now dispense with the library of the Museum for some +months; that the time for which they had taken their lodgings would +be up in a few days; that the summer was far advanced, town odious, +the country beautiful--in a word, we were to go home. There I could +prepare myself for Cambridge, till the long vacation was over; and, +my mother added hesitatingly, and with a prefatory caution to +spare my health, that my father, whose income could ill afford the +requisite allowance to me, counted on my soon lightening his burden, +by getting a scholarship. I felt how much provident kindness there +was in all this--even in that hint of a scholarship, which was meant +to rouse my faculties, and spur me, by affectionate incentives, to a +new ambition. I was not less delighted than grateful. + +"But poor Roland," said I, "and little Blanche--will they come with +us?" + +"I fear not," said my mother, "for Roland is anxious to get back to +his tower; and, in a day or two, he will be well enough to move." + +"Do you not think, my dear mother, that, somehow or other, this lost +son of his had something to do with his illness,--that the illness +was as much mental as physical?" + +"I have no doubt of it, Sisty. What a sad, bad heart that young man +must have!" + +"My uncle seems to have abandoned all hope of finding him in London; +otherwise, ill as he has been, I am sure we could not have kept him +at home. So he goes back to the old tower. Poor man, he must be dull +enough there!--we must contrive to pay him a visit. Does Blanche +ever speak of her brother?" + +"No, for it seems they were not brought up much together--at all +events, she does not remember him. How lovely she is! Her mother +must surely have been very handsome." + +"She is a pretty child, certainly, though in a strange style of +beauty--such immense eyes!--and affectionate, and loves Roland as +she ought." + +And here the conversation dropped. + +Our plans being thus decided, it was necessary that I should lose no +time in seeing Vivian, and making some arrangement for the future. +His manner had lost so much of its abruptness, that I thought I +could venture to recommend him personally to Trevanion; and I knew, +after what had passed, that Trevanion would make a point to oblige +me. I resolved to consult my father about it. As yet I had either +never forced, or never made the opportunity to talk to my father +on the subject, he had been so occupied; and, if he had proposed +to see my new friend, what answer could I have made, in the teeth +of Vivian's cynic objections? However, as we were now going away, +that last consideration ceased to be of importance; and, for the +first, the student had not yet entirely settled back to his books. I +therefore watched the time when my father walked down to the Museum, +and, slipping my arm in his, I told him, briefly and rapidly, as +we went along, how I had formed this strange acquaintance, and how +I was now situated. The story did not interest my father quite as +much as I expected, and he did not understand all the complexities +of Vivian's character--how could he?--for he answered briefly, "I +should think that, for a young man, apparently without a sixpence, +and whose education seems so imperfect, any resource in Trevanion +must be most temporary and uncertain. Speak to your uncle Jack--he +can find him some place, I have no doubt--perhaps a readership in +a printer's office, or a reporter's place on some journal, if he +is fit for it. But if you want to steady him, let it be something +regular." + +Therewith my father dismissed the matter, and vanished through the +gates of the Museum.--Readership to a printer, reportership on a +journal, for a young gentleman with the high notions and arrogant +vanity of Francis Vivian--his ambition already soaring far beyond +kid gloves and a cabriolet! The idea was hopeless; and, perplexed +and doubtful, I took my way to Vivian's lodgings. I found him at +home, and unemployed, standing by his window, with folded arms, and +in a state of such reverie that he was not aware of my entrance till +I had touched him on the shoulder. + +"Ha!" said he then, with one of his short, quick, impatient sighs, +"I thought you had given me up, and forgotten me--but you look pale +and harassed. I could almost think you had grown thinner within the +last few days." + +"Oh! never mind me, Vivian: I have come to speak of yourself. +I have left Trevanion; it is settled that I should go to the +university--and we all quit town in a few days." + +"In a few days!--all!--who are all?" + +"My family--father, mother, uncle cousin, and myself. But, my dear +fellow, now let us think seriously what is best to be done for you? +I can present you to Trevanion." + +"Ha!" + +"But Trevanion is a hard, though an excellent man; and, moreover, as +he is always changing the subjects that engross him, in a month or +so, he may have nothing to give you. You said you would work--will +you consent not to complain if the work cannot be done in kid +gloves? Young men who have risen high in the world have begun, it +is well known, as reporters to the press. It is a situation of +respectability, and in request, and not easy to obtain, I fancy; but +still--" + +Vivian interrupted me hastily-- + +"Thank you a thousand times! but what you say confirms a resolution +I had taken before you came. I shall make it up with my family, and +return home." + +"Oh! I am so really glad. How wise in you!" + +Vivian turned away his head abruptly-- + +"Your pictures of family life and domestic peace, you see," he said, +"seduced me more than you thought. When do you leave town?" + +"Why, I believe, early next week." + +"So soon!" said Vivian, thoughtfully. "Well, perhaps I may ask you +yet to introduce me to Mr Trevanion; for--who knows?--my family and +I may fall out again. But I will consider. I think I have heard you +say that this Trevanion is a very old friend of your father's, or +uncle's?" + +"He, or rather Lady Ellinor, is an old friend of both." + +"And therefore would listen to your recommendations of me. But +perhaps I may not need them. So you have left--left of your own +accord--a situation that seemed more enjoyable, I should think, than +rooms in a college;--left--why did you leave?" + +And Vivian fixed his bright eyes, full and piercingly, on mine. + +"It was only for a time, for a trial, that I was there," said I, +evasively: "out at nurse, as it were, till the Alma Mater opened her +arms--_alma_ indeed she ought to be to my father's son." + +Vivian looked unsatisfied with my explanation, but did not question +me farther. He himself was the first to turn the conversation, and +he did this with more affectionate cordiality than was common to +him. He inquired into our general plans, into the probabilities of +our return to town, and drew from me a description of our rural +Tusculum. He was quiet and subdued; and once or twice I thought +there was a moisture in those luminous eyes. We parted with more +of the unreserve and fondness of youthful friendship--at least on +my part, and seemingly on his--than had yet endeared our singular +intimacy; for the cement of cordial attachment had been wanting to +an intercourse in which one party refused all confidence, and the +other mingled distrust and fear with keen interest and compassionate +admiration. + +That evening, before lights were brought in, my father, turning to +me, abruptly asked if I had seen my friend, and what he was about to +do? + +"He thinks of returning to his family," said I. + +Roland, who had seemed dozing, winced uneasily. + +"Who returns to his family?" asked the Captain. + +"Why, you must know," said my father, "that Sisty has fished up +a friend of whom he can give no account that would satisfy a +policeman, and whose fortunes he thinks himself under the necessity +of protecting. You are very lucky that he has not picked your +pockets, Sisty; but I daresay he has? What's his name?" + +"Vivian," said I--"Francis Vivian." + +"A good name, and a Cornish," said my father. "Some derive it from +the Romans--Vivianus; others from a Celtic word, which means"-- + +"Vivian!" interrupted Roland--"Vivian!--I wonder if it be the son of +Colonel Vivian?" + +"He is certainly a gentleman's son," said I; "but he never told me +what his family and connexions were." + +"Vivian," repeated my uncle--"poor Colonel Vivian. So the young man +is going to his father. I have no doubt it is the same. Ah!"-- + +"What do you know of Colonel Vivian, or his son?" said I. "Pray, +tell me, I am so interested in this young man." + +"I know nothing of either, except by gossip," said my uncle, +moodily. "I did hear that Colonel Vivian, an excellent officer, +and honourable man, had been in--in--(Roland's voice faltered)--in +great grief about his son, whom, a mere boy, he had prevented from +some improper marriage, and who had run away and left him--it was +supposed for America. The story affected me at the time," added my +uncle, trying to speak calmly. + +We were all silent, for we felt why Roland was so disturbed, and why +Colonel Vivian's grief should have touched him home. Similarity in +affliction makes us brothers even to the unknown. + +"You say he is going home to his family--I am heartily glad of it!" +said the envying old soldier, gallantly. + +The lights came in then, and, two minutes after, uncle Roland and I +were nestled close to each other, side by side; and I was reading +over his shoulder, and his finger was silently resting on that +passage that had so struck him--"I have not complained--have I, +sir?--and I won't complain!" + + + + +THE WHITE NILE.[15] + + [15] _Expedition zur Entdeckung der Quellen des Weissen Nil_, + (1840-1841,) von FERDINAND WERNE. Mit einem Vorwort von CARL RITTER. + Berlin, 1848. + + +Fifty years since, the book before us would have earned for its +author the sneers of critics and the reputation of a Munchausen: +at the present more tolerant and more enlightened day, it not only +obtains credit, but excites well-merited admiration of the writer's +enterprise, energy, and perseverance. "The rich contents and great +originality of the following work," says Professor Carl Ritter, +in his preface to Mr Werne's narrative, "will escape no one who +bestows a glance, however hasty, upon its pages. It gives vivid and +life-like pictures of tribes and territories previously unvisited, +and is welcome as a most acceptable addition to our literature of +travel, often so monotonous." We quite coincide with the learned +professor, whose laudatory and long-winded sentences we have thus +freely rendered. His friend, Mr Ferdinand Werne, has made good +use of his opportunities, and has produced a very interesting and +praiseworthy book. + +It is, perhaps, hardly necessary to remind the reader, that the +river Nile is formed of two confluent streams, the Blue and the +White, whose junction is in South Nubia, between 15° and 16° of +North Latitude. The source of the Blue Nile was ascertained by +Bruce, and by subsequent travellers, to be in the mountains of +Abyssinia; but the course of the other branch, which is by far the +longest, had been followed, until very lately, only as far south +as 10° or 11° N. L. Even now the river has not been traced to its +origin, although Mr Werne and his companions penetrated to 4° N. +L. Further they could not go, owing to the rapid subsidence of the +waters. The expedition had been delayed six weeks by the culpable +dilatoriness of one of its members; and this was fatal to the +realisation of its object. + +We can conceive few things more exciting than such a voyage as Mr +Werne has accomplished and recorded. Starting from the outposts of +civilisation, he sailed into the very heart of Africa, up a stream +whose upper waters were then for the first time furrowed by vessels +larger than a savage's canoe--a stream of such gigantic proportions, +that its width, at a thousand miles from the sea, gave it the +aspect of a lake rather than of a river. The brute creation were in +proportion with the magnitude of the water-course. The hippopotamus +reared his huge snout above the surface, and wallowed in the gullies +that on either hand run down to the stream; enormous crocodiles +gaped along the shore; elephants played in herds upon the pastures; +the tall giraffe amongst the lofty palms; snakes thick as trees lay +coiled in the slimy swamps; and ant-hills, ten feet high, towered +above the rushes. Along the thickly-peopled banks hordes of savages +showed themselves, gazing in wonder at the strange ships, and making +ambiguous gestures, variously construed by the adventurers as +signs of friendship or hostility. Alternately sailing and towing, +as the wind served or not; constantly in sight of natives, but +rarely communicating with them; often cut off for days from land by +interminable fields of tangled weeds,--the expedition pursued its +course through innumerable perils, guaranteed from most of them by +the liquid rampart on which it floated. Lions looked hungry, and +savages shook their spears, but neither showed a disposition to swim +off and board the flotilla. + +The cause of science has countless obligations to the cupidity of +potentates and adventurers. May it not be part of the scheme of +Providence, that gold is placed in the most remote and barbarous +regions, as a magnet to draw thither the children of civilisation? +The expedition shared in by Mr Werne is an argument in favour +of the hypothesis. It originated in appetite for lucre, not in +thirst for knowledge. Mehemet Ali, viceroy of Egypt, finding the +lands within his control unable to meet his lavish expenditure and +constant cry for gold, projected working mines supposed to exist +in the districts of Kordovan and Fazogl. At heavy cost he procured +Austrian miners from Trieste, a portion of whom proceeded in 1836 +to the land of promise, to open those veins of gold whence it was +reported the old Venetian ducats had been extracted. Already, in +imagination, the viceroy beheld an ingot-laden fleet sailing merrily +down the Nile. He was disappointed in his glowing expectations. +Russegger, the German chief of the expedition, pocketed the pay of +a Bey, ate and drank in conformity with his rank, rambled about the +country, and wrote a book for the amusement and Information of his +countrymen. Then he demanded thirty thousand dollars to begin the +works. An Italian, who had accompanied him, offered to do it for +less; mistrust and disputes arose, and at last their employer would +rely on neither of them, but resolved to go and see for himself. +This was in the autumn of 1838; and it might well be that the old +fox was not sorry to get out of the way of certain diplomatic +personages at Alexandria, and thus to postpone for a while his reply +to troublesome inquiries and demands. + +"It was on the 15th October 1838," Mr Werne says, "that I--for some +time past an anchorite in the wilderness by Tura, and just returned +from a hunt in the ruins of Memphis--saw, from the left shore of +the Nile, the Abu Dagn, (Father of the Beard,) as Mohammed Ali was +designated to me by a Fellah standing by, steam past in his yacht, +in the direction of those regions to which I would then so gladly +have proceeded. Already in Alexandria I had gathered, over a glass +of wine, from frigate-captain Achmet, (a Swiss, named Baumgartner,) +the secret plan of the expedition to the White Stream, (Bach'r el +Abiat,) and I had made every effort to obtain leave to join it, +but in vain, because, as a Christian, my discretion was not to be +depended upon." + +The Swiss, whom some odd caprice of fate, here unexplained, had +converted into an Egyptian naval captain, and to whom the scientific +duties of the expedition were confided, died in the following +spring, and his place was taken by Captain Selim. Mr Werne and his +brother, who had long ardently desired to accompany one of these +expeditions up the Nile, were greatly discouraged at this change, +which they looked upon as destructive to their hopes. At the town +of Chartum, at the confluence of the White and Blue streams, they +witnessed, in the month of November 1839, the departure of the first +flotilla; and, although sick and weak, from the effects of the +climate, their hearts were wrung with regret at being left behind. +This expedition got no further than 6° 35' N. L.; although, either +from mistakes in their astronomical reckoning or wishing to give +themselves more importance, and not anticipating that others would +soon follow to check their statements, they pretended to have gone +three degrees further south. But Mehemet Ali, not satisfied with the +result of their voyage, immediately ordered a second expedition to +be fitted out. Mr Werne, who is a most adventurous person, had been +for several months in the Taka country, in a district previously +untrodden by Europeans, with an army commanded by Achmet Bascha, +governor-general of Sudan, who was operating against some rebellious +tribes. Here news reached him of the projected expedition; and, to +his great joy, he obtained from Achmet permission to accompany it in +the quality of passenger. His brother, then body-physician to the +Bascha, could not be spared, by reason of the great mortality in the +camp. + +At Chartum the waters were high, the wind was favourable, and all +was ready for a start early in October, but for the non-appearance +of two French engineers, who lingered six weeks in Korusko, under +one pretext or other, but in reality, M. Werne affirms, because +one of them, Arnaud by name, who has since written an account of +the expedition, was desirous to prolong the receipt of his pay +as _bimbaschi_, or major, which rank he temporarily held in the +Egyptian service. At last he and his companion, Sabatier, arrived: +on the 23rd November 1840 a start was made; and, on that day Mr +Werne began a journal, regularly kept, and most minute in its +details, which he continued till the 22d April 1841, the date of +his return to Chartum. He commences by stating the composition +of the expedition. "It consists of four dahabies from Kahira, +(vessels with two masts and with cabins, about a hundred feet +long, and twelve to fifteen broad,) each with two cannon; three +dahabies from Chartum, one of which has also two guns; then two +kaias, one-masted vessels, to carry goods, and a sàndal, or skiff, +for intercommunication; the crews are composed of two hundred and +fifty soldiers, (Negroes, Egyptians, and Surians,) and a hundred +and twenty sailors and boatmen from Alexandria, Nubia, and the +land of Sudàn." Soliman Kaschef (a Circassian of considerable +energy and courage, who, like Mr Werne himself, was protected by +Achmet Bascha) commanded the troops. Captain Selim had charge of +the ships, and a sort of general direction of the expedition, of +which, however, Soliman was the virtual chief; the second captain +was Feizulla Effendi of Constantinople; the other officers were +two Kurds, a Russian, an Albanian, and a Persian. Of Europeans, +there were the two Frenchmen, already mentioned, as engineers; a +third, named Thibaut, as collector; and Mr Werne, as an independent +passenger at his own charges. The ships were to follow each other +in two lines, one led by Soliman, the other by Selim; but this +order of sailing was abandoned the very first day; and so, indeed, +was nearly all order of every kind. Each man sailed his bark as he +pleased, without nautical skill or unity of movement; and, as to +one general and energetic supervision of the whole flotilla and +its progress, no one dreamed of such a thing. Mr Werne indulged in +gloomy reflections as to the probable results of an enterprise, at +whose very outset such want of zeal and discipline was displayed. +It does not appear to have struck him that not the least of his +dangers upon the strange voyage he had so eagerly undertaken, was +from his shipmates, many of them bigoted Mahometans and reckless, +ferocious fellows, ready with the knife, and who would have thought +little of burthening their conscience with so small a matter as a +Christian's blood. He is evidently a cool, courageous man, prompt +in action; and his knowledge of the slavish, treacherous character +of the people he had to deal with, doubtless taught him the best +line of conduct to pursue with them. This, as appears from various +passages of his journal, was the rough and ready style--a blow +for the slightest impertinence, and his arms, which he well knew +how to use, always at hand. He did not scruple to interfere when +he saw cruelty or oppression practised, and soon he made himself +respected, if not feared, by all on board; so much so, that +Feizulla, the captain of the vessel in which he sailed, a drunken +old Turk, who passed his time in drinking spirits and mending his +own clothes, appointed him his _locum tenens_ during his occasional +absences on shore. During his five months' voyage, Mr Werne had +a fine opportunity of studying the peculiarities of the different +nations with individuals of which he sailed; and, although his long +residence in Africa and the East had made him regard such matters +with comparative indifference, the occasional glimpses he gives +of Turkish and Egyptian habits are amongst the most interesting +passages in his book. Already, on the third day of the voyage, the +expiration of the Rhamadan, or fasting month, and the setting in +of the little feast of Bairam, gave rise to a singular scene. The +flotilla was passing through the country governed by Achmet Bascha, +in which Soliman was a man of great importance. By his desire, a +herd of oxen and a large flock of sheep were driven down to the +shore, for the use of the expedition. The preference was for the +mutton, the beef in those regions being usually tough and coarse, +and consequently despised by the Turks. "This quality of the meat +is owing to the nature of the fodder, the tender grass and herbs of +our marsh-lands and pastures being here unknown--and to the climate, +which hardens the animal texture, a fact perceived by the surgeon +when operating upon the human body. Our Arabs, who, like the Greeks +and Jews, born butchers and flayers, know no mercy with beasts or +men, fell upon the unfortunate animals, hamstrung them in all haste, +to obviate any chance of resumption of the gift, and the hecatomb +sank upon the ground, pitiful to behold. During the flaying and +quartering, every man tried to secrete a sippet of meat, cutting it +off by stealth, or stealing it from the back of the bearers. These +coveted morsels were stuck upon skewers, broiled at the nearest +watch-fire, and ravenously devoured, to prepare the stomach for +the approaching banquet. Although they know how to cook the liver +excellently well, upon this occasion they preferred eating it raw, +cut up in a wooden dish, and with the gall of the slaughtered beast +poured over it. Thus prepared, and eaten with salt and pepper, it +has much the flavour of a good raw beefsteak." The celebration of +the Bairam was a scene of gluttony and gross revelry. Arrack was +served out instead of the customary ration of coffee; and many a +Mussulman drank more than did him good, or than the Prophet's law +allows. In the night, Captain Feizulla tumbled out of bed; and, +having spoiled his subordinates by over-indulgence, not one of +them stirred to his assistance. Mr Werne picked him up, found him +in an epileptic fit, and learned, with no great pleasure, Feizulla +being his cabin-mate, that the thirsty skipper was subject to such +attacks. He foresaw a comfortless voyage on board the narrow bark, +and with such queer companions; but the daily increasing interest of +the scenery and surrounding objects again distracted his thoughts +from considerations of personal ease. He had greater difficulty +in reconciling himself to the negligence and indolence of his +associates. So long as food was abundant and work scanty, all went +well enough; but when liquor ran low, and the flesh-pots of Egypt +were empty, grumbling began, and the thoughts of the majority were +fixed upon a speedy return. Their chiefs set them a poor example. +Soliman Kaschef lay in bed till an hour after sunrise, and the +signal to sail could not be given till he awoke; and Feizulla, when +his and Mr Werne's stock of brandy was out, passed one half his +time in distilling spirits from stale dates, and the other moiety +in getting intoxicated on the turbid extract thus obtained. Then +the officers had female slaves on board; and there was a licensed +jester, Abu Haschis, who supplied the expedition with buffoonery +and ribaldry; and the most odious practices prevailed amongst the +crews; for further details concerning all which matters we refer the +curious to Mr Werne himself. A more singularly composed expedition +was perhaps never fitted out, nor one less adapted effectually to +perform the services required of it. Cleanliness and sobriety, so +incumbent upon men cooped up in small craft, in a climate teeming +with pestilence and vermin, were little regarded; and subordination +and vigilance, essential to safety amidst the perils of an unknown +navigation, and in the close vicinity of hostile savages, were +utterly neglected,--at first to the great uneasiness of Mr Werne. +But after a while, seeing no chance of amendment, and having no +power to rebuke or correct deficiencies, he repeated the eternal +_Allah Kerim!_ (God is merciful) of his fatalist shipmates, and +slept soundly, when the musquitos permitted, under the good guard of +Providence. + +On the 29th November, the expedition passed the limit of +Turco-Egyptian domination. The land it had now reached paid no +tribute. "All slaves," was the reply of Turks and Arabs to Mr +Werne's inquiry who the inhabitants were. "I could not help +laughing, and proving to them, to their great vexation, that these +men were free, and much less slaves than themselves; that before +making slaves of them, they must first make them prisoners, a +process for which they had no particular fancy,--admitting, with +much _naiveté_, that the 'slaves' hereabout were both numerous +and brave. This contemptuously spoken _Kulo Abit_, (All slaves,) +is about equivalent to the 'barbarian' of the ancients--the same +classical word the modern Greeks have learned out of foreign +school-books." + +"The trees and branches preventing our vessels from lying alongside +the bank, I had myself carried through the water, to examine the +country and get some shooting. But I could not make up my mind to +use my gun, the only animals to aim at being large, long-tailed, +silver-gray apes. I had shot one on a former occasion, and the brute +had greatly excited my compassion by his resemblance to a human +being, and by his piteous gestures. M. Arnaud, on the contrary, took +particular pleasure in making the repeated observation that, on the +approach of death, the gums of these beasts turn white, like those +of a dying man. They live in families of several hundreds together, +and their territory is very circumscribed, even in the forest, as +I myself subsequently ascertained. Although fearful of water, and +swimming unwillingly, they always fled to the branches overhanging +the river, and not unfrequently fell in. When this occurred, their +first care on emerging was to wipe the water from their faces and +ears. However imminent their danger, only when this operation was +completed did they again climb the trees. Such a monkey republic +is really a droll enough sight; its members alternately fighting +and caressing each other, combing and vermin-hunting, stealing and +boxing each other's ears, and, in the midst of all these important +occupations, running down every moment to drink, but contenting +themselves with a single draught, for fear of becoming a mouthful +for the watchful crocodile. The tame monkeys on board our vessels +turned restless at sight of the joyous vagabond life of their +brethren in the bush. First-lieutenant Hussein Aga, of Kurdistan, +lay alongside us, and was in raptures with his monkey, shouting over +to me: '_Schuf! el naùti taïb!_' (See! the clever sailor!)--meaning +his pet ape, which ran about the rigging like mad, hanging on by +the ropes, and looking over the bulwarks into the water; until at +last he jumped on the back of a sailor who was wading on shore with +dirty linen to wash, and thence made a spring upon land to visit +his relations, compared to whom, however, he was a mere dwarf. +Overboard went the long Kurd, with his gun, to shoot the deserter; +but doubtless the little seaman, in his capacity of Turkish slave, +and on account of his diminutive figure, met a bad reception, for +Hussein was no sooner under the trees than his monkey dropped upon +his head. He came to visit me afterwards, brought his 'naùti taïb' +with him, and told me, what I had often heard before, how apes were +formerly men, whom God had cursed. It really is written in the Koran +that God and the prophet David had turned into monkeys the Jews who +did not keep the Sabbath holy. Therefore a good Moslem will seldom +kill or injure a monkey. Emin Bey of Fazogl was an exception to this +rule. Sitting at table with an Italian, and about to thrust into +his mouth a fragment of roast meat, his monkey snatched it from +between his thumb and fingers. Whereupon the Bey quietly ordered +the robber's hand to be cut off, which was instantly done. The poor +monkey came to his cruel master and showed him, with his peculiarly +doleful whine, the stump of his fore-paw. The Bey gave orders to +kill him, but the Italian begged him as a gift. Soon afterwards +the foolish brute came into my possession, and, on my journey back +to Egypt, contributed almost as much to cheer me, as did the filial +attentions of my freed man Hagar, whom my brother had received as a +present, and had bequeathed to me. My servants would not believe but +that the monkey was a transformed _gabir_, or caravan guide, since +even in the desert he was always in front and upon the right road, +availing himself of every rock and hillock to look about him, until +the birds of prey again drove him under the camels, to complain +to me with his 'Oehm-oehm;' which was also his custom when he had +been beaten in my absence by the servants, whose merissa (a sort of +spirit) he would steal and drink till he could neither go nor stand." + +During this halt, and whilst rambling along the bank, picking up +river-oysters and tracing the monstrous footsteps of hippopotami, +Mr Werne nearly walked into the jaws of the largest crocodile he +had ever seen. His Turkish servant, Sale, who attended him on such +occasions and carried his rifle, was not at hand, and he was glad +to beat a retreat, discharging one of his barrels, both of which +were laden with shot only, in the monster's face. On being scolded +for his absence, Sale very coolly replied, that it was not safe so +near shore; for that several times it had occurred to him, whilst +gazing up in the trees at the birds and monkeys, to find himself, +on a sudden, face to face with a crocodile, which stared at him +like a ghost, (Scheitan, Satan,) and which he dared not shoot, lest +he should slay his own father. Amongst the numerous Mahommedan +superstitions, there is a common belief in the transformation, +by witches and sorcerers, of men into beasts, especially into +crocodiles and hippopotami. + +"Towards evening, cartridges were served out and muskets loaded, +for we were now in a hostile country. The powder-magazine stood +open, and lighted pipes passed to and fro over the hatchway. _Allah +Kerim!_ I do my best to rouse my captain from his indolence, by +drawing constant comparisons with the English sea-service; then I +fall asleep myself whilst the powder is being distributed, and, +waking early in the morning, find the magazine still open, and the +sentry, whose duty it is to give an alarm should the water in the +hold increase overmuch, fast asleep, with his tobacco-pipe in his +hand and his musket in his lap. Feizulla Capitan begged me not to +report the poor devil." This being a fair specimen of the prudence +and discipline observed during the whole voyage, it is really +surprising that Mr Werne ever returned to write its history, and +that his corpse--drowned, blown up, or with a knife between the +ribs--has not long since been resolved into the elements through +the medium of a Nile crocodile. The next day the merciful Feizulla, +whose kindness must have sprung from a fellow-feeling, got mad-drunk +at a merry-making on an island, and had to be brought by force on +board his ship. He seemed disposed to "run amuck;" grasped at sabre +and pistols, and put his people in fear of their lives, until Mr +Werne seized him neck and heels, threw him on his bed, and held +him there whilst he struggled himself weary and fell asleep. The +ship's company were loud in praise and admiration of Mr Werne, who, +however, was not quite easy as to the possible results of his bold +interference. "Only yesterday, I incurred the hatred of the roughest +of our Egyptian sailors, as he sat with another at the hand-mill, +and repeatedly applied to his companion the word _Nasrani_, +(Christian,) using it as a term of insult, until the whole crew +came and looked down into the cabin where I sat, and laughed--the +captain not being on board at the time. At last I lost my patience, +jumped up, and dealt the fellow a severe blow with my fist. In his +fanatical horror at being struck by a Christian, he tried to throw +himself overboard, and vowed revenge, which my servants told me. +Now, whilst Feizulla Capitan lies senseless, I see from my bed this +tall sailor leave the fore-part of the ship and approach our cabin, +his comrades following him with their eyes. From a fanatic, who +might put his own construction upon my recent friendly constraint +of Captain Feizulla, and might convert it into a pretext, I had +everything to apprehend. But he paused at the door, apologised, and +thanked me for not having reported him to his commander. He then +kissed my right hand, whilst in my left I held a pistol concealed +under the blanket." + +Dangers, annoyances, and squabbles did not prevent Mr Werne +from writing up his log, and making minute observations of +the surrounding scenery. This was of ever-varying character. +Thickly-wooded banks were succeeded by a sea of grass, its +monotony unvaried by a single bush. Then came a crowd of islands, +composed of water-plants, knit together by creepers and parasites, +and alternately anchored to the shore, or floating slowly down +the stream, whose sluggish current was often imperceptible. The +extraordinary freshness and luxuriance of the vegetable creation +in that region of combined heat and moisture, excited Mr Werne's +enthusiastic admiration. At times he saw himself surrounded by a +vast tapestry of flowers, waving for miles in every direction, and +of countless varieties of tint and form. Upon land were bowers +and hills of blossom, groves of dark mimosa and gold-gleaming +tamarind; upon the water and swamps, interminable carpets of lilac +convolvulus, water-lilies, flowering-reeds, and red, blue, and white +lotus. The ambak tree, with its large yellow flowers and acacia-like +leaf, rose fifteen feet and more above the surface of the water out +of which it grew. This singular plant, a sort of link between the +forest-tree and the reed of the marshes, has its root in the bed of +the Nile, with which it each year rises, surpassing it in swiftness +of growth. Its stem is of a soft spungy nature, more like the pith +of a tree than like wood, but having, nevertheless, a pith of its +own. The lotus was one of the most striking features in these scenes +of floral magnificence; its brilliant white flower, which opens as +the sun rises, and closes when it sets, beaming, like a double lily, +in the shade it prefers. Mr Werne made the interesting observation, +that this beautiful flower, where it had not some kind of shelter, +closed when the sun approached the zenith, as though unable to +endure the too ardent rays of the luminary that called it into life. +Details of this kind, and fragments of eloquent description of the +gorgeous scenery of the Nile banks, occur frequently in the earlier +part of the "Expedition," during which there was little intercourse +with the natives, who were either hostile, uninteresting, or +concealed. Amongst other reasons for not remaining long near shore, +and especially for not anchoring there at night, was the torture the +voyagers experienced from gnats, camel-flies, and small wasps, which +not only forbade sleep, but rendered it almost impossible to eat and +drink. To escape this worse than Egyptian plague, the vessels lay in +the middle of the river, which, for some time after their departure, +was often three or four miles across. When the breeze was fresh, +there was some relief from insect persecution, but a lull made the +attacks insupportable. Doubtless a European complexion encouraged +these. Our German lifts up his voice in agony and malediction. + +"The 10th December.--A dead calm all night. Gnats!!! No use creeping +under the bed-clothes, at risk of stifling with heat, compelled as +one is by their penetrating sting to go to bed dressed. Leave only a +little hole to breathe at, and in they pour, attacking lips, nose, +and ears, and forcing themselves into the throat--thus provoking a +cough which is torture, since, at each inspiration, a fresh swarm +finds its way into the gullet. They penetrate to the most sensitive +part of the body, creeping in, like ants, at the smallest aperture. +In the morning my bed contained thousands of the small demons which +I had crushed and smothered by the perpetual rolling about of my +martyred body. As I had forgotten to bring a musquito net from +Chartum, there was nothing for it but submission. Neither had I +thought of providing myself with leather gloves, unbearable in that +hot climate, but which here, upon the Nile, would have been by far +the lesser evil, since I was compelled to have a servant opposite to +me at supper-time, waving a huge fan so close under my nose, that it +was necessary to watch my opportunity to get the food to my mouth. +One could not smoke one's pipe in peace, even though keeping one's +hands wrapped in a woollen burnous, for the vermin stung through +this, and crept up under it from the ground. The black and coloured +men on board were equally ill-treated; and all night long the word +'_Baùda_' resounded through the ship, with an accompaniment of +curses and flapping of cloths. The _baùda_ resemble our long-legged +gnats, but have a longer proboscis, with which they bore through a +triple fold of strong linen. Their head is blue, their back tawny, +and their legs are covered with white specks like small pearls, +Another sort has short, strong legs, a thick brown body, a red +head, and posteriors of varying hues." These parti-coloured and +persevering bloodsuckers caused boils by the severity of their +sting, and so exhausted the sailors by depriving them of sleep, +that the ships could hardly be worked. Bitterly and frequently does +Mr Werne recur to his sufferings from their ruthless attacks. At +last a strange auxiliary came to his relief. On Christmas-day he +writes:--"For the last two nights we have been greatly disturbed by +the gnats, but a small cat, which I have not yet seen by daylight, +seems to find particular pleasure in licking my face, pulling my +beard, and purring continually, thus keeping off the insects. +Generally the cats in Bellet-Sudan are of a very wild and fierce +nature, which seems the result of their indifferent treatment by the +inhabitants. They walk into the poultry-houses and carry off the +strongest fowls, but care little for rats and mice. The Barabras, +especially those of Dongola, often eat them; not so the Arabs, +who spare them persecution--the cat having been one of Mahomet's +favourite animals--but who, at the same time, hold them unclean." + +There is assuredly no river in the world whose banks, for so great +a distance, are so thickly peopled as those of the Nile. Day after +day the expedition passed an unbroken succession of populous +villages, until Mr Werne wondered whence the inhabitants drew +their nourishment, and a sapient officer from Kurdistan opined the +Schilluks to be a greater nation than the French. But what people, +and what habitations! The former scarce a degree above the brute, +the latter resembling dog-kennels, or more frequently thatched +bee-hives, with a round hole in the side, through which the inmates +creep. Stark-naked, these savages lay in the high grass, whose +seed forms part of their food, and gibbered and beckoned to the +passing Turks, who, for the most part, disregarded their gestures +of amity and invitation, shrewdly suspecting that their intentions +were treacherous and their lances hidden in the herbage. Wild rice, +fruits, and seeds, are eaten by these tribes, (the Schilluks, +Dinkas, and others,) who have also herds of cattle--oxen, sheep, and +goats, and who do not despise a hippopotamus chop or a crocodile +cutlet. Where the land is unproductive, fish is the chief article +of food. They have no horses or camels, and when they steal one of +these animals from the Turks, they do not kill it, probably not +liking its flesh, but they put out its eyes as a punishment for +having brought the enemy into their country. In one hour Mr Werne +counted seventeen villages, large or small; and Soliman Kaschef +assured him the Schilluks numbered two millions of souls, although +it is hard to say how he obtained the census. The _Bando_ or king, +although dwelling only two or three leagues from the river, did +not show himself. He mistrusted the Turks, and all night the great +war-drum was heard to beat. His savage majesty was quite right to be +on his guard. "I am well persuaded," says Mr Werne, "that if Soliman +Kaschef had once got the dreaded Bando of the Schilluks on board, +he would have sailed away with him. I read that in his face when +he was told the Bando would not appear. And gladly as I would have +seen this negro sovereign, I rejoiced that his caution frustrated +the projected shameful treachery. He had no particular grounds for +welcoming the Musselmans, those sworn foes of his people. Shortly +before our departure, he had sent three ambassadors to Chartum, to +put him on a friendly footing with the Turks, and so to check the +marauding expeditions of his Arab neighbours, of Soliman Kaschef +amongst the rest. The three Schilluks, who could not speak Arabic, +were treated in the Divan with customary contempt as _Abit_, +(slaves) and were handed over like common men to the care of Sheikh +el Bellet of Chartum. The Sheikh, who receives no pay, and performs +the duties of his office out of fear rather than for the sake of the +honour, showed them such excellent hospitality, that they came to +us Franks and begged a few piastres to buy bread and spirits." On +Mr Werne's representations to the Effendi, or chief man at Chartum, +dresses of honour (the customary presents) were prepared for them, +but they departed stealthily by night; and their master, the Bando, +was very indignant on learning the treatment they had received. + +A vast green meadow, a sort of elephant pasture, separates the +Schilluks from their neighbours the Jengähs, concerning whom Mr +Werne obtained some particulars from a Tschauss or sergeant, +named Marian of Mount Habila, the son of the Mak or King of the +mountains of Nuba. His father had been vanquished and murdered by +the Turks, and he had been made a slave. This sergeant-prince was +of middle height, with a black tatooed countenance, and with ten +holes in each ear, out of which his captors had taken the gold +rings. He was a sensible, well-behaved man, and had been thirteen +years in the service, but was hopeless of promotion, having none to +recommend him. Besides this man, there were two Dinkas and a Jengäh +on board; but from them it was impossible to extract information +with respect to the manners and usages of their countrymen. +They held it treachery to divulge such particulars. Many of the +soldiers and sailors composing the expedition being natives of the +countries through which it sailed, apprehensions of desertion were +entertained, and partially realised. On the 30th December, whilst +passing through the friendly land of the Keks, everybody slept on +shore, and in the night sixteen men on guard deserted. They were +from the distant country of Nuba, (a district of Nubia,) which it +seemed scarcely possible they should ever reach, with their scanty +store of ammunition, and exposed to the assaults of hunger, thirst, +and hostile tribes. Hussein Aga went after them with fifty ferocious +Egyptians, likely to show little mercy to the runaways, with whom, +however, they could not come up. And suddenly the drums beat to call +all hands on board, for there was a report that all the negroes +were planning escape. During this halt Mr Werne made ornithological +observations, ascertaining, amongst other things, the species of +certain white birds, which he had observed sitting impudently upon +the backs of the elephants, picking the vermin from their thick +hides, as crows do in Europe from the backs of pigs. The elephants +evidently disapproved the operation, and lashed with their trunks +at their tormentors, who then flew away, but instantly returned to +recommence what Mr Werne calls their "dry fishing." These birds +proved to be small herons. Shortly before this, a large pelican +had been shot, and its crop was found to contain twenty-four fresh +fish, the size of herrings. Its gluttony had caused its death, the +weight it carried impeding its flight. Prodigious swarms of birds +and water-fowl find their nourishment in the White Stream, and upon +its swampy banks. In some places the trees were white with their +excrements, whose accumulation destroyed vegetable life. There is no +lack of nourishment for the feathered tribes--water and earth are +prolific of vermin. Millions of glow-worms glimmer in the rushes, +the air resounds with the shrill cry of myriads of grasshoppers, +and with the croaking of countless frogs. But for the birds, which +act as scavengers and vermin-destroyers, those shores would be +uninhabitable. The scorching sun fecundates the sluggish waters +and rank fat marsh, causing a never-ceasing birth of reptiles and +insects. Monstrous fish and snakes of all sizes abound. Concerning +the latter, the Arabs have strange superstitions. They consider them +in some sort supernatural beings, having a king, Shach Maran by +name, who is supposed to dwell in Turkish Kurdistan, not far from +Adana, where two villages are exempted from tribute on condition of +supplying the snakes with milk. Abdul-Elliab, a Kurd officer of the +expedition, had himself offered the milk-sacrifice to the snakes; +and he swore that he had seen their king, or at any rate one of his +_Wokils_, or vicegerents, of whom his serpentine majesty has many. +He had no sooner poured his milky offering into one of the marble +basins nature has there hollowed out, than a great snake, with long +hair upon its head, stepped out of a hole in the rocks and drank. +It then retired, without, as in some other instances, speaking to +the sacrificer, a taciturnity contritely attributed by the latter +to his not having yet entirely abjured strong drinks. Two other +Kurds vouched for the truth of this statement, adding, that the +_Maran_ had a human face, for that otherwise he could not speak, +and that he never showed himself except to a sultan or to a very +holy man. To the latter character the said Abdul-Elliab had great +pretensions, and his bigotry, hypocrisy, and constant quotations +from the Koran procured him from his irreverent shipmates, from Mr +Werne amongst the number, the nickname of the _Paradise-Stormer_, +it being manifest that he reckoned on taking by assault the blessed +abode promised by Mahomet to the faithful. Pending his admission to +the society of the houris, he solaced himself with that of a young +female slave, who often experienced cruel treatment at the hands of +her saintly master. Having one day committed the heinous offence of +preparing _merissa_, a strong drink made from corn, for part of the +crew, the Kurd, formerly, according to his own admission, a stanch +toper, beat her with a thong as she knelt half-naked upon the deck. +"As he did not attend to my calls from the cabin," says Mr Werne, +"but continued striking her so furiously as to cut the skin and +draw streams of blood, I jumped out, and pulled him backwards, so +that his legs flew up in the air. He sprang to his feet, retreated +to the bulwark of the ship, drew his sabre, and shouted, with a +menacing countenance, 'Effendi!' instead of calling me Kawagi, +which signifies a merchant, and is the usual title for a Frank. I +had no sooner returned to the cabin than he seized his slave to +throw her overboard, whereupon I caught up my double-barrel and +levelled at him, calling out, '_Ana oedrup!_' (I fire.) Thereupon +he let the girl go, and with a pallid countenance protested she was +his property, and he could do as he liked with her. Subsequently +he complained of me to the commandant, who, knowing his malicious +and hypocritical character, sent him on board the skiff, to the +great delight of the whole flotilla. On our return to Chartum, +he was cringing enough to ask my pardon, and to want to kiss my +hand, (although he was then a captain) because he saw that the +Bascha distinguished me. A few days previously to this squabble, +I had gained the affection and confidence of our black soldiers, +one of whom, a Tokruri or pilgrim from Darfur, had quarrelled with +an Arab, and wounded him with his knife. He jumped overboard to +drown himself, and, being unable to swim, had nearly accomplished +his object, when he drifted to our ship and was lifted on board. +They wanted to make him stand on his head, but I had him laid +horizontally upon his side, and began to rub him with a woollen +cloth, but at first could get no one to help me because he was an +_Abit_, a slave, until I threatened the captain he should be made +to pay the Bascha for the loss of his soldier. After long-continued +rubbing, the Tokruri gave signs of life, and they raised him into +a sitting posture, whilst his head still hung down. One of the +soldiers, who, as a Faki, pretended to be a sort of awaker of the +dead, seized him from behind under the arms, lifted him, and let him +fall thrice violently upon his hinder end, shouting in his ear at +the same time passages from the Koran, to which the Tokruri at last +replied by similar quotations. The superstition of these people is +so gross, that they believe such a pilgrim may be completely and +thoroughly drowned, and yet retain power to float to any part of the +shore he pleases, and, once on dry land, to resume his vitality." + +A credulous traveller would have been misled by some of the strange +fables put forward, with great plausibility, by these Arabs and +other semi-savages, who have, moreover, a strong tendency to +exaggerate, and who, perceiving the avidity with which Mr Werne +investigated the animal and vegetable world around him, and his +desire for rare and curious specimens, occasionally got up a lie +for his benefit. Although kept awake many nights by the merciless +midges, his zeal for science would not suffer him to sleep in the +day, because he had no one he could trust to note the windings of +the river. One sultry noon, however, when the Arab rowers were +lazily impelling the craft against unfavourable breezes, and the +stream was straight for a long distance ahead, he indulged in a +siesta, during which visions of a happy German home hovered above +his pillow. On awaking, bathed in perspiration, to the dismal +realities of the pestilential Bach'r el Abiat, of incessant gnats +and barbarian society, his Arab companions had a yarn cut and dried +for him. During my sleep they had seen a swimming-bird as large as +a young camel, with a straight beak like a pelican, but without a +crop; they had not shot it for fear of awaking me, and because they +had no doubt of meeting with some more of these unknown birds. No +others appeared, and Mr Werne noted the camel-bird as an Egyptian +lie, not as a natural curiosity. + +A month's sail carried the expedition into the land of the Keks, +a numerous, but not a very prosperous tribe. Their _tokuls_ or +huts were entirely of straw, walls as well as roof. The men were +quite naked, and of a bluish-gray colour, from the slime of the +Nile, with which they smear themselves as a protection against the +gnats. "There was something melancholy in the way in which those +poor creatures raised their hands above their heads, and let them +slowly fall, by manner of greeting. They had ivory rings upon their +arms, and one of them turned towards his hut, as if inviting us +in. Another stood apart, lifted his arms, and danced round in a +circle. A Dinka on board, who is acquainted with their language, +said they wanted us to give them durra, (a sort of corn,) and +that their cows were far away and would not return till evening. +This Dinka positively asserted, as did also Marian, that the Keks +kill no animal, but live entirely on grain and milk. I could not +ascertain, with certainty, whether this respect for brute life +extended itself to game and fish, but it is universally affirmed +that they eat cattle that die a natural death. This is done to some +extent in the land of Sudan, although not by the genuine Arabs: +it is against the Koran to eat a beast even that has been slain +by a bullet, unless its throat has been cut whilst it yet lived, +to let the prohibited blood escape. At Chartum I saw, one morning +early, two dead camels lying on a public square; men cut off great +pieces to roast, and the dogs looked on longingly. I myself, with +Dr Fischer and Pruner, helped to consume, in Kahira, a roasted +fragment of Clot Bey's beautiful giraffe, which had eaten too much +white clover. The meat was very tender, and of tolerably fine grain. +The tongue was quite a delicacy. On the other hand, I never could +stomach the coarse-grained flesh of camels, even of the young ones." +Africa is the land of strong stomachs. The Arabs, when on short +rations, eat locusts; and some of the negro tribes devour the fruit +of the elephant-tree, an abominable species of pumpkin, coveted by +elephants, but rejected even by Arabs, and which Mr Werne found +wholly impracticable, although his general rule was to try all the +productions of the country. His gastronomical experiments are often +connected with curious details of the animals upon which he tried +his teeth. On the 12th January, whilst suffering from an attack of +Nile-fever, which left him scarcely strength enough to post up his +journal, he heard a shot, and was informed that Soliman Kaschef had +killed with a single bullet a large crocodile, as it lay basking on +a sandy promontory of the bank. The Circassian made a present of the +skin to M. Arnaud, an excellent excuse for an hour's pause, that +the Frenchman might get possession of the scaly trophy. Upon such +trifling pretexts was the valuable time of the expedition frittered +away. "Having enough of other meat at that moment, the people +neglected cutting off the tail for food. My servants, however, who +knew that I had already tasted that sort of meat at Chartum, and +that at Taka I had eaten part of a snake, prepared for me by a +dervish, brought me a slice of the crocodile. Even had I been in +health, I could not have touched it, on account of the strong smell +of musk it exhaled; but, ill as I was, they were obliged to throw +it overboard immediately. When first I was in crocodile countries, +it was incomprehensible to me how the boatmen scented from afar +the presence of these creatures; but on my journey from Kahira to +Sennaar, when they offered me in Korusko a young one for sale, I +found my own olfactories had become very sensitive to the peculiar +odour. When we entered the Blue Stream, I could smell the crocodiles +six hundred paces off, before I had seen them. The glands, +containing a secretion resembling musk, are situated in the hinder +part of the animal, as in the civet cats of Bellet Sudan, which are +kept in cages for the collection of the perfume." + +As the travellers ascended the river, their intercourse with the +natives became much more frequent, inasmuch as these, more remote +from Egyptian aggression, had less ground for mistrustful and +hostile feelings. Captain Selim had a stock of coloured shirts, +and an immense bale of beads, with which he might have purchased +the cattle, villages, goods and chattels, and even the bodies, of +an entire tribe, had he been so disposed. The value attached by +the savages of the White Stream to the most worthless objects of +European manufacture, enabled Mr Werne to obtain, in exchange for +a few glass beads, a large collection of their arms, ornaments, +household utensils, &c., now to be seen in the Royal Museum at +Berlin. The stolid simplicity of the natives of those regions +exceeds belief. One can hardly make up one's mind to consider them +as men. Even as the _ambak_ seems the link between useful timber +and worthless rushes, so does the Kek appear to partake as much +of brute as of human nature. He has at least as much affinity +with the big gray ape, whose dying agonies excited Mr Werne's +compassion at the commencement of his voyage, as with the civilised +and intellectual man who describes their strange appearance and +manners. A Kek, who had been sleeping in the ashes of a fire, a +common practice with that tribe, was found standing upon the shore +by some of the crew, who brought him on board Selim's vessel. +"Bending his body forward in an awkward ape-like manner, intended +perhaps to express submission, he approached the cabin, and, on +finding himself near it, dropped upon his knees and crept forward +upon them, uttering, in his gibberish, repeated exclamations of +greeting and wonderment. He had numerous holes through the rims +of his ears, which contained, however, no other ornament than one +little bar. They threw strings of beads over his neck, and there +was no end to his joy; he jumped and rolled upon the deck, kissed +the planks, doubled himself up, extended his hands over all our +heads, as if blessing us, and then began to sing. He was an angular, +high-shouldered figure, about thirty years of age. His attitude +and gestures were very constrained, which arose, perhaps, from the +novelty of his situation; his back was bent, big head hung forward, +his long legs, almost calf-less, were as if broken at the knees; in +his whole person, in short, he resembled an orang-outang. He was +perfectly naked, and his sole ornaments consisted of leathern rings +upon the right arm. How low a grade of humanity is this! The poor +natural touches one with his childish joy, in which he is assuredly +happier than any of us. By the help of the Dinka interpreter, he is +instructed to tell his countrymen they have no reason to retreat +before such _honest_ people as those who man the flotilla. Kneeling, +jumping, creeping, kissing the ground, he is then led away by the +hand like a child, and would assuredly take all he has seen for a +dream, but for the beads he bears with him." Many of these tribes +are composed of men of gigantic stature. On the 7th January, Mr +Werne, being on shore, would have measured some of the taller +savages, but they objected. He then gave his servants long reeds +and bade them stand beside the natives, thus ascertaining their +average height to be from six to seven Rhenish feet. The Egyptians +and Europeans looked like pigmies beside them. The women were in +proportion with the men. Mr Werne tells of one lady who looked clear +away over his head, although he describes himself as above the +middle height. + +At this date, (7th January) the flotilla reached a large lake, or +inlet of the river, near to which a host of elephants grazed, and +a multitude of light-brown antelopes stood still and stared at the +intruders. The sight of the antelopes, which were of a species +called _ariel_, whose flesh is particularly well-flavoured, was +too much for Soliman Kaschef to resist. There was no wind; he gave +orders to cease towing, and went on shore to shoot his supper. The +antelopes retreated when the ships grated against the bank; and as +the rush-jungle was by no means safe, beasts of prey being wont to +hide there to catch the antelopes as they go to water at sunset, +a few soldiers were sent forward to clear the way. Nevertheless, +"on our return from the chase, during which not a single shot +was fired, we lost two _báltaschi_, (carpenters or sappers,) and +all our signals were insufficient to bring them back. They were +Egyptians, steady fellows, and most unlikely to desert; but their +comrades did not trouble themselves to look for them, shrugged their +shoulders, and supposed they had been devoured by the _assad_ or +the _nimr_--the lion or tiger. The word _nimr_ is here improperly +applied, there being no tigers in Africa, but it is the general term +for panthers and leopards." Here, at four-and-twenty degrees of +latitude south of Alexandria, this extraordinary river was nearly +four hundred paces wide. Mr Werne speculates on the origin of this +astonishing water-course, and doubts the possibility that the +springs of the White Stream supply the innumerable lakes and creeks, +and the immense tracts of marsh contiguous to it; that, too, under +an African sun, which acts as a powerful and constant pump upon the +immense liquid surface. When he started on his voyage, the annual +rains had long terminated. What tremendous springs those must be, +that could keep this vast watery territory full and overflowing! +Then the sluggishness of the current is another puzzle. Were the +Nile _one_ stream, Mr Werne observes--referring, of course, to the +White Nile--it must flow faster than it does. And he concludes +it to have tributaries, which, owing to the level nature of the +ground, and to the resistance of the main stream, stagnate to a +certain extent, rising and falling with the river, and contributing +powerfully to its nourishment. But the notion of exploring all +these watery intricacies with a flotilla of heavy-sailing barges, +manned by lazy Turks and Arabs, and commanded by men who care more +for getting drunk on arrack and going a-birding, than for the great +results activity and intelligence might obtain, is essentially +absurd. The proper squadron to explore the Bach'r el Abiat, through +the continued windings, and up the numerous inlets depicted in +Mr Mahlmann's map, is one consisting of three small steamers, +drawing very little water, with steady well-disciplined English +crews, accustomed to hot climates, and commanded by experienced and +scientific officers. With the strongest interest should we watch +the departure and anticipate the return of such an expedition as +this. "Much might be done by a steam-boat," says Mr Werne; who then +enumerates the obstacles to its employment. To bring it over the +cataracts of the Nile, (below the junction of the Blue and White +Streams,) it would be necessary to take the paddles entirely out, +that it might be dragged up with ropes, like a sailing vessel. +Or else it might be built at Chartum, but for the want of proper +wood; the sunt-tree timber, although very strong, being exceedingly +brittle and ill-adapted for ship-building. The greatest difficulty +would be the fuel--the establishment and guard of coal stores; and +as to burning charcoal, although the lower portion of the White +Stream has forests enough, they are wanting on its middle and +upper banks; to say nothing of the loss of time in felling and +preparing the wood, of the danger of attacks from natives, &c., &c. +If some of these difficulties are really formidable, others, on +the contrary, might easily be overcome, and none are insuperable. +Mr Werne hardly makes sufficient allowance for the difference +between Soliman Kaschef and a European naval officer, who would +turn to profit the hours and days the gallant Circassian spent in +antelope-shooting, in laughing at Abu Haschis the jester, and in a +sort of travelling seraglio he had arranged in his inner cabin, a +dark nook with closely-shut jalousies, that served as prison to an +unfortunate slave-girl, who lay all day upon a carpet, with scarcely +space to turn herself, guarded by a eunuch. Not a glimpse of the +country did the poor thing obtain during the whole of the voyage; +and, even veiled, she was forbidden to go on deck. Besides these +oriental relaxations, an occasional practical joke beguiled for the +commodore the tedium of the voyage. Feizulla, the tailor-captain, +whose strange passion for thimble and thread made him frequently +neglect his nautical duties, chanced one day to bring to before his +superior gave the signal. "Soliman Kaschef had no sooner observed +this than he fired a couple of shots at Feizulla Capitan, so +that I myself, standing before the cabin door, heard the bullets +whistle. Feizulla, did not stir, although both he and the sailors +in the rigging afterwards affirmed that the balls went within a +hand's-breadth of his head: he merely said, '_Malesch--hue billab_,' +(It is nothing--he jests;) and he shot twice in return, pointing +the gun in the opposite direction, that Soliman might understand +he took the friendly greeting as a Turkish joke, and that he, as a +bad shot, dared not level at him." Soliman, on the other hand, was +far too good a shot for such a sharp jest to be pleasant. The Turks +account themselves the best marksmen and horsemen in the world, and +are never weary of vaunting their prowess. Mr Werne says he saw an +Arnaut of Soliman's shoot a running hare with a single ball, which +entered in the animal's rear, and came out in front. And it was a +common practice, during the voyage, to bring down the fruit from +lofty trees by cutting the twigs with bullets. All these pastimes, +however retarded the progress of the expedition. The wind was +frequently light or unfavourable, and the lazy Africans made little +way with the towing rope. Then a convenient place would often tempt +to a premature halt; and, notwithstanding Soliman's sharp practice +with poor Feizulla, if a leading member of the party felt lazily +disposed, inclined for a hunting-party, or for a visit to a negro +village, he seldom had much difficulty in bringing the flotilla to +an anchor. In a straight line from north to south, the expedition +traversed, between its departure from Chartum and its return +thither, about sixteen hundred miles. It is difficult to calculate +the distance gone over; and probably Mr Werne himself would be +puzzled exactly to estimate it; but adding 20 per cent for windings, +obliquities, and digressions, (a very liberal allowance,) we get a +total of nearly two thousand miles, accomplished in five months, +including stoppages, being at the very moderate rate of about 13 +miles a day. And this, we must remember, was on no rapid stream, but +up a river, whose current, rarely faster than one mile in an hour, +was more frequently only half a mile, and sometimes was so feeble +that it could not be ascertained. The result is not surprising, +bearing in mind the quality of ships, crews, and commanders: but +write "British" for "Egyptians," and the tale would be rather +different. + +The upshot of this ill-conducted expedition was its arrival in the +kingdom of Bari, whose capital city, Pelenja, is situated in 4° N. +L., and which is inhabited by an exceedingly numerous nation of tall +and powerful build; the men six and a-half to seven French feet in +height--equal to seven and seven and a-half English feet--athletic, +well-proportioned, and, although black, with nothing of the usual +negro character in their features. The men go naked, with the +exception of sandals and ornaments; the woman wear leathern aprons. +They cultivate tobacco and different kinds of grain: from the +iron found in their mountains they manufacture weapons and other +implements, and barter them with other tribes. They breed cattle +and poultry, and are addicted to the chase. About fifteen hundred +of these blacks came down to the shore, armed to the teeth--a sight +that inspired the Turks with some uneasiness, although they had +several of their chiefs on board the flotilla, besides which, the +frank cordiality and good-humoured intelligent countenances of the +men of Bari forbade the idea of hostile aggression. "It had been +a fine opportunity for a painter or sculptor to delineate these +colossal figures, admirably proportioned, no fat, all muscle, and +magnificently limbed. None of them have beards, and it would seem +they use a cosmetic to extirpate them. Captain Selim, whose chin +was smooth-shaven, pleased them far better than the long-bearded +Soliman Kaschef; and when the latter showed them his breast, +covered with a fell of hair, they exhibited a sort of disgust, +as at something more appropriate to a beast than to a man." Like +most of the tribes on the banks of the White Nile, they extract +the four lower incisors, a custom for which Mr Werne is greatly +puzzled to account, and concerning which he hazards many ingenious +conjectures. Amongst the ape-like Keks and Dinkas, he fancied it to +originate in a desire to distinguish themselves from the beasts of +the field--to which they in so many respects assimilate; but he was +shaken in this opinion, on finding the practice to prevail amongst +the intelligent Bari, who need no such mark to establish their +difference from the brute creation. The Dinkas on board confirmed +his first hypothesis, saying that the teeth are taken out that they +may not resemble the jackass--which in many other respects they +certainly do. The Turks take it to be a rite equivalent to Mahomedan +circumcision, or to Christian baptism. The Arabs have a much more +extravagant supposition, which we refrain from stating, the more so +as Mr Werne discredits it. He suggests the possibility of its being +an act of incorporation in a great Ethiopian nation, divided into +many tribes. The operation is performed at the age of puberty; it is +unaccompanied by any particular ceremonies; and women as well as men +undergo it. Its motive still remains a matter of doubt to Mr Werne. + +Before Lakono, sultan of the Bari, and his favourite sultana Ischok, +an ordinary-looking lady with two leathern aprons and a shaven head, +came on board Selim's vessel, the Turks made repeated attempts to +obtain information from some of the Sheiks concerning the gold +mines, whose discovery was the main object of the expedition. A +sensible sort of negro, one Lombé, replied to their questions, and +extinguished their hopes. There was not even copper, he said, in the +land of the Bari, although it was brought thither from a remoter +country, and Lakono had several specimens of it in his treasury. On +a gold bar being shown to him, he took it for copper, whence it was +inferred that the two metals were blended in the specimens possessed +by the sultan, and that the mountains of the copper country also +yielded the more precious ore. This country, however, lay many days' +journey distant from the Nile, and, had it even bordered on the +river, there would have been no possibility of reaching it. At a +very short distance above Palenja, the expedition encountered a bar +of rocks thrown across the stream. And although Mr Werne hints the +possibility of having tried the passage, the Turks were sick of the +voyage and were heartily glad to turn back. At the period of the +floods the river rises eighteen feet; and there then could be no +difficulty in surmounting the barrier. Now the waters were falling +fast. The six weeks lost by Arnaud's fault were again bitterly +deplored by the adventurous German--the only one of the party +who really desired to proceed. Twenty days sooner, and the rocks +could neither have hindered an advance nor afforded pretext for a +retreat. To Mr Werne's proposal, that they should wait two months +where they were, when the setting in of the rains would obviate +the difficulty, a deaf ear was turned--an insufficient stock of +provisions was objected; and although the flotilla had been stored +for a ten months' voyage, and had then been little more than two +months absent from Chartum, the wastefulness that had prevailed gave +some validity to the objection. One-and-twenty guns were fired, as +a farewell salute to the beautiful country Mr Werne would so gladly +have explored, and which, he is fully convinced, contains so much of +interest; and the sluggish Egyptian barks retraced their course down +stream. + +It is proper here to note a shrewd conjecture of Mr Werne's, +that above the point reached by himself and his companions, the +difficulties of ascending the river would greatly and rapidly +increase. The bed becomes rocky, and the Bach'r el Abiat, assuming +in some measure the character of a mountain stream, augments the +rapidity of its current: so much so, that Mr Werne insists on the +necessity of a strong north wind, believing that towing, however +willingly and vigorously attempted, would be found unavailing. This +is another strong argument in favour of employing steamboats. + +Although the narrative of the homeward voyage is by no means +uninteresting, and contains details of the river's course valuable +to the geographer and to the future explorer, it has not the +attraction of the up-stream narrative. The freshness is worn off; +the waters sink, and the writer's spirits seem disposed to follow +their example; there is all the difference between attack and +retreat--between a cheerful and hopeful advance, and a retrograde +movement before the work is half done. But, vexed as an enthusiastic +and intrepid man might naturally feel at seeing his hopes frustrated +by the indolent indifference of his companions, Mr Werne could +hardly deem his five months thrown away. We are quite sure those +who read his book will be of opinion that the time was most +industriously and profitably employed. + +A sorrowful welcome awaited our traveller, after his painful and +fatiguing voyage. There dwelt at Chartum a renegade physician, a +Palermitan named Pasquali, whose Turkish name was Soliman Effendi, +and who was notorious as a poisoner, and for the unscrupulous +promptness with which he removed persons in the slightest degree +unpleasing to himself or to his patron Achmet Bascha. In Arabia, it +was currently believed, he had once poisoned thirty-three soldiers, +with the sole view of bringing odium upon the physician and +apothecary, two Frenchmen, who attended them. In Chartum he was well +known to have committed various murders. + +"Although this man," says Mr Werne, "was most friendly and sociable +with me, I had everything to fear from him on account of my brother, +by whom the Bascha had declared his intention of replacing him in +the post of medical inspector of Bellet-Sudàn. It was therefore in +the most solemn earnest that I threatened him with death, if upon +my return I found my brother dead, and learned that they had come +at all in contact. '_Dio guarde, che affronto!_' was his reply; +and he quietly drank off his glass of rum, the same affront having +already been offered him in the Bascha's divan; the reference being +naturally to the poisonings laid to his charge in Arabia and here." + +At Chartum Mr Werne found his brother alive, but on the eleventh +day after his return he died in his arms. The renegade had had no +occasion to employ his venomous drugs; the work had been done as +surely by the fatal influence of the noxious climate. + + + + +ART AND ARTISTS IN SPAIN. + + +The accomplishments brought back by our grandfathers from the +Continent to grace the drawing-rooms of May Fair, or enliven the +solitudes of Yorkshire, were a favourite subject for satirists, some +"sixty years since." Admitting the descriptions to be correct, it +must be remembered that the grand tour had become at once monotonous +and deleterious,--from Calais to Paris, from Paris to Geneva, +from Geneva to Milan, from Milan to Florence, thence to Rome, and +thence to Naples, the English "my lord," with his bear-leader, +was conducted with regularity, if not with speed; and the same +course of sights and society was prescribed for, and taken by, +generation after generation of Oxonians and Cantabs. Then, again, +the Middle Ages, with their countless graceful vestiges, their +magnificent architecture, which even archaic Evelyn thought and +called "barbarous," their chivalrous customs, religious observances, +rude yet picturesque arts, and fanciful literature, were literally +blotted out from the note-book of the English tourist. Whatever +was classical or modern, that was worthy of regard; but whatever +belonged to "Europe's middle night," _that_ the descendants of +Saxon thanes or Norman knights disdained even to look at. Even had +there been no Pyrenees to cross, or no Bay of Biscay to encounter, +so Gothic a country as Spain was not likely to attract to its +dusky sierras, frequent monasteries, and mediæval towns, the fine +gentlemen and Mohawks of those enlightened days; nor need we be +surprised that the natural beauties of that romantic land--its +weird mountains, primæval forests, and fertile plains, fragrant +with orange groves, and bright with flowers of every hue, unknown +to English gardens--remained unexplored by the countrymen of Gray +and Goldsmith, who have put on record their marked disapprobation +of Nature in her wildest and most sublime mood. Thus, then, it was +that, with rare exceptions, the pleasant land of Spain was a sealed +book to Englishmen, until the Great Captain rivalled and eclipsed +the feats and triumphs of the Black Prince in every province of the +Peninsula, and enabled guardsmen and hussars to admire the treasures +of Spanish art in many a church and convent unspoiled by French +rapacity. Nor may we deny our obligations to Gallic plunderers. +Many a noble picture that now delights the eyes of thousands, +exalts and purifies the taste of youthful painters, and sends, +on the purple wings of European fame, the name of its Castilian, +or Valencian, or Andalusian creator down the stream of time, but +for Soult or Sebastiani, might still have continued to waste its +sweetness on desert air. Thenceforward, in spite of brigands and +captain-generals, rival constitutions and contending princes, have +adventurous Englishmen been found to delight in rambling, like +Inglis, in the footsteps of Don Quixote,--emulating the deeds of +Peterborough, like Ranelagh and Henningsen, or throwing themselves +into the actual life, and studying the historic manners of Spain, +like Carnarvon and Ford. Still, though soldier and statesman, +philosopher and littérateur, had put forth their best powers in +writing of the country that so worthily interested them, a void was +ever left for some new comer to fill; and right well, in his three +handsome, elaborate, and most agreeable volumes, has Mr Stirling +filled that void. Not one of the goodly band of Spanish painters now +lacks a "sacred poet" to inscribe his name in the temple of fame. +With indefatigable research, most discriminating taste, and happiest +success, has Mr Stirling pursued and completed his pleasant labour +of love, and presented to the world "Annals of the Artists of Spain" +worthy--can we say more?--of recording the triumphs of El Mudo and +El Greco, Murillo and Velasquez.[16] + + [16] _Annals of the Artists of Spain._ By WILLIAM STIRLING, M. A. 3 + vols. London: Ollivier. + +At least a century and a half before Holbein was limning the burly +frame and gorgeous dress of bluff King Hal, and creating at once +a school and an appreciation of art in England, were the early +painters of Spain enriching their magnificent cathedrals, and +religious houses, with pictures displaying as correct a knowledge +of art, and as rich a tone of colour, as the works of that great +master. There is something singular and mysterious in the contrast +afforded by the early history of painting in the two countries. +While in poetry, in painting on glass, in science, in manufactures, +in architecture, England appears to have kept pace with other +countries, in painting and in sculpture she appears always to +have lagged far behind. Gower, Chaucer, Friar Bacon, William of +Wyckham, Waynfleete, the unknown builders of ten thousand churches +and convents, the manufacturers of the glass that still charms our +eyes, and baffles the rivalry of our Willements and Wailes, at York +and elsewhere--the illuminators of the missals and religious books, +whose delicate fancy and lustrous tints are even now teaching our +highborn ladies that long-forgotten art--yielded the palm to none of +their brethren in Europe; but where and who were our contemporaneous +painters and sculptors? In the luxurious and graceful court of +Edward IV., who represented that art which Dello and Juan de Castro, +under royal and ecclesiastical patronage, had carried to such +perfection in Spain? That no English painters of any note flourished +at that time, is evident from the silence of all historical +documents; nor does it appear that foreign artists were induced, by +the hope of gain or fame, to instruct our countrymen in the art to +which the discoveries of the Van Eycks had imparted such a lustre. +It is true that the desolating Wars of the Roses left scant time and +means to the sovereigns and nobility of England for fostering the +arts of peace; but still great progress was being made in nearly +all those arts, save those of which we speak; and, if we remember +rightly, Mr Pugin assigns the triumph of English architecture to +this troublous epoch. Nor, although Juan I., Pedro the Cruel, and +Juan II., were admirers and patrons of painting, was it to royal or +noble favour that Spanish art owed its chiefest obligations. The +church--which, after the great iconoclastic struggle of the eighth +century, had steadily acted on the Horatian maxim, + + "Segnius irritant animos demissa per aures, + Quam quæ sunt oculis subjecta fidelibus"-- + +in Spain embraced the young and diffident art with an ardour +and a munificence which, in its palmiest and most prosperous days, +that art never forgot, and was never wearied of requiting. Was it so +in England? and do we owe our lack of ancient English pictures to +the reforming zeal of our iconoclastic reformers? Did the religious +pictures of our Rincons, our Nuñez, and our Borgoñas, share the +fate of the libraries that were ruthlessly destroyed by the +ignorant myrmidons of royal rapacity? If so, it is almost certain +that the records which bewail and denounce the fate of books and +manuscripts, would not pass over the destruction of pictures; while +it is still more certain that the monarch and his courtiers would +have appropriated to themselves the pictured saints, no less than +the holy vessels, of monastery and convent. It cannot, therefore, +be said that the English Reformation deprived our national school +of painting of its most munificent patrons, and most ennobling and +purest subjects, in the destruction of the monasteries, and the +spoliation of churches. That the Church of England, had she remained +unreformed, might, in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, have +emulated her Spanish or Italian sister in her patronage of, and +beneficial influence upon, the arts of painting and sculpture, it +is needless either to deny or assert; we fear there is no room for +contending that, since the Reformation, she has in any way fostered, +guided, or exalted either of those religious arts. + +In Spain, on the contrary, as Mr Stirling well points out, it was +under the august shadow of the church that painting first raised her +head, gained her first triumphs, executed her most glorious works, +and is even now prolonging her miserable existence. + +The venerable cathedral of Toledo was, in effect, the cradle of +Spanish painting. Founded in 1226 by St Ferdinand, it remained, +to quote Mr Stirling's words, "for four hundred years a nucleus +and gathering-place for genius, where artists swarmed and +laboured like bees, and where splendid prelates--the popes of +the Peninsula--lavished their princely revenues to make fair and +glorious the temple of God intrusted to their care." Here Dolfin +introduced, in 1418, painting on glass; here the brothers Rodrigues +displayed their forceful skill as sculptors, in figures which +still surmount the great portal of that magnificent cathedral; +and here Rincon, the first Spanish painter who quitted the stiff +mediæval style, loved best to execute his graceful works. Nor +when, with the house of Austria, the genius of Spanish art quitted +the Bourbon-governed land, did the custodians of this august +temple forget to stimulate and reward the detestable conceits, and +burlesque sublimities, of such artists as the depraved taste of the +eighteenth century delighted to honour. Thus, in 1721, Narciso Tome +erected at the back of the choir an immense marble altar-piece, +called the Trasparente, by order of Archbishop Diego de Astorgo, +for which he received two hundred thousand ducats; and thus, fifty +years later, Bayeu and Maella were employed to paint in fresco +the cloisters that had once gloried in the venerable paintings of +Juan de Borgoña. At Toledo, then, under the auspices of the great +Castilian queen, Isabella, may be said to have risen the Castilian +school of art. The other great schools of Spanish painting were +those of Andalusia, of Valencia, and that of Arragon and Catalonia; +but, for the mass of English readers, the main interest lies in the +two first, the schools that produced or acquired El Mudo and El +Greco, Velasquez and Murillo. The works of the two last-mentioned +artists are now so well known, and so highly appreciated in England, +that we are tempted to postpone for the present any notice of that +most delightful part of Sir Stirling's book which treats of them, +and invite our readers to trace the course of art in that stern old +city to which we have already referred, Toledo. + +Before the grave had closed upon the cold remains of Rincon, Juan de +Borgoña had proved himself worthy of wielding the Castilian pencil, +and, under the patronage of the great Toledan archbishop, Ximenes de +Cisneros, produced works which still adorn the winter chapter-room +of that cathedral. These are interesting not only as specimens of +art, but as manifestations of the religious ἠθος of Spain at the +commencement of the sixteenth century: let Mr Stirling describe one +of the most remarkable of these early paintings:--"The lower end of +the finely-proportioned, but badly-lighted room, is occupied by the +'Last Judgment,' a large and remarkable composition. Immediately +beneath the figure of our Lord, a hideous fiend, in the shape of a +boar, roots a fair and reluctant woman out of her grave with his +snout, as if she were a trufle, twining his tusks in her long amber +locks. To the left are drawn up in a line a party of the wicked, +each figure being the incarnation of a sin, of which the name is +written on a label above in Gothic, letters, as 'Soberbia,' and the +like. On their shoulders sit little malicious imps, in the likeness +of monkeys, and round their lower limbs, flames climb and curl. +The forms of the good and faithful, on the right, display far less +vigour of fancy." So the good characters in modern works of fiction +are more feebly drawn, and excite less interest, than the Rob Roys +and Dirk Hattericks, the Conrads and the Manfreds. Nor was Toledo at +this time wanting in the sister art of sculpture: while the Rincons, +and Berruguete, and Borgoña, were enriching the cathedral with their +pictures and their frescoes, Vigarny was elaborating the famous high +altar of marble, and the stalls on the epistle side. In concluding +his notice of Vigarny, "the first great Castilian sculptor," Mr +Stirling gives a sketch of the style of sculpture popular in Spain. +Like nearly all the "Cosas d'Espana," it is peculiar, and owes +its peculiarity to the same cause that has impressed so marked a +character on Spanish painting and Spanish pharmacopeia--religion. + +Let not the English lover of the fine arts, invited to view the +masterpieces of Spanish sculpture, imagine that his eyes are to be +feasted on the nude, though hardly indecent forms of Venuses and +Apollos, Ganymedes and Andromedas. + +Beautiful, and breathing, and full of imagination, indeed, those +Spanish statues are--"idols," as our author generally terms +them; but the idolatry they represent or evoke is heavenly, not +earthly--spiritual, not sensuous. Chiselled out of a block of cedar +or lime-wood, with the most reverential care, the image of the +Queen of Heaven enjoyed the most exquisite and delicate services of +the rival sister arts, and, "copied from the loveliest models, was +presented to her adorers sweetly smiling, and gloriously apparelled +in clothing of wrought gold." But we doubt whether any Englishman +who has not seen can understand the marvellous beauty of these +painted wooden images. Thus Berruguete, who combined both arts in +perfection, executed in 1539 the archbishop's throne at Toledo, +"over which hovers an airy and graceful figure, carved in dark +walnut, representing our Lord on the Mount of Transfiguration, and +remarkable for its fine and floating drapery." + +Continuing our list of Toledan artists, "whose whole lives and +labours lay within the shadow of that great Toledan church, whose +genius was spent in its service, and whose names were hardly known +beyond its walls," (vol. i. p. 150,) we come to T. Comontes, who, +among other works for that munificent Alma Mater, executed from +the designs of Vigarny the retablo (reredos) for the chapel "de +los Reyes Nuevos," in 1533. It was at Toledo that El Mudo, the +Spanish Titian, died, and at Toledo that Blas del Prado was born. +When in 1593 the Emperor of Morocco asked that the best painter +of Spain might be sent to his court, Philip II. appointed Blas +del Prado to fulfil the Mussulman's artistic desires: previous to +this, the chapter of Toledo had named him their second painter, and +he had painted a large altar-piece, and other pictures, for their +cathedral. But perhaps the Toledan annals of art contain no loftier +name than that of El Greco. Domemis Theotocopuli, who, born, it is +surmised, at Venice in 1548, is found in 1577 painting at Toledo, +for the cathedral, his famous picture of The Parting of our Lord's +Garment, on which he bestowed the labour of a decade, and of which +we give Mr Stirling's picturesque description. + +"The august figure of the Saviour, arrayed in a red robe, occupies +the centre of the canvass; the head, with its long dark locks, is +superb; and the noble and beautiful countenance seems to mourn for +the madness of them who 'knew not what they did;' his right arm +is folded on his bosom, seemingly unconscious of the rope which +encircles his wrist, and is violently dragged downwards by two +executioners in front. Around and behind him appears a throng of +priests and warriors, amongst whom the Greek himself figures as the +centurion, in black armour. In drawing and composition, this picture +is truly admirable, and the colouring is, on the whole, rich and +effective--although it is here and there laid on in that spotted +streaky manner, which afterwards became the great and prominent +defect of El Greco's style." + +Summoned from the cathedral to the court, El Greco painted, by +royal command, a large altar-piece, for the church at the Escurial, +on the martyrdom of St Maurice; "little less extravagant and +atrocious," says our lively author, "than the massacre it recorded." +Neither king nor court painters could praise this performance, and +the effect of his failure at the Escurial appears to have been +his return to Toledo. Here, in 1584, he painted, by order of the +Archbishop Quiroga, "The Burial of the Count of Orgaz," a picture +then and now esteemed as his master-piece, and still to be seen +in the church of Santo Tomé. Warm is the encomium, and eloquently +expressed, which Mr Stirling bestows upon this gem of Toledan art. +"The artist, or lover of art, who has once beheld it, will never, +as he rambles among the winding streets of the ancient city, pass +the pretty brick belfry of that church--full of horse-shoe niches +and Moorish reticulations,--without turning aside to gaze upon +its superb picture once more. It hangs to your left, on the wall +opposite to the high altar. Gonzalo Ruiz, Count of Orgaz, head of +a house famous in romance, rebuilt the fabric of the church, and +was in all respects so religious and gracious a grandee, that, +when he was buried in 1323, within these very walls, St Stephen and +St Augustine came down from heaven, and laid his body in the tomb +with their own holy hands--an incident which forms the subject of +the picture. St Stephen, a dark-haired youth of noble countenance, +and St Augustine, a hoary old man wearing a mitre, both of them +arrayed in rich pontifical vestments of golden tissue, support the +dead Count in their arms, and gently lower him into the grave, +shrouded like a baron of Roslin 'in his iron panoply.' Nothing can +be finer than the execution and the contrast of these three heads; +never was the image of the peaceful death of 'the just man' more +happily conveyed, than in the placid face and powerless form of +the warrior: nor did Giorgione or Titian ever excel the splendid +colouring of his black armour, rich with gold damascening. To the +right of the picture, behind St Stephen, kneels a fair boy in a +dark dress, perhaps the son of the Count; beyond rises the stately +form of a gray friar; to the left, near St Augustine, stand two +priests in gorgeous vestments, holding, the one a book, and the +other a taper. Behind this principal group appear the noble company +of mourners, hidalgos and old Christians all, with olive faces and +beards of formal cut, looking on with true Castilian gravity and +phlegm, as if the transaction were an every-day occurrence. As they +were mostly portraits, perhaps some of the originals did actually +stand, a few years later, with the like awe in their hearts and +calm on their cheeks, in the royal presence-chamber, when the news +came to court that the proud Armada of Spain had been vanquished by +the galleys of Howard, and cast away on the rocks of the Hebrides." +We make no apology for thus freely quoting from Mr Stirling's +pages his description of this picture; the extract brings vividly +before our readers at once the merits of the old Toledan painter, +and his accomplished biographer and critic. After embellishing his +adopted city, not only with pictures such as this, but with works of +sculpture and architecture, and vindicating his graceful profession +from the unsparing exactions of the tax-gatherers--a class who +appear to have waged an unrelenting though intermittent war against +the fine arts in Spain--he died there at a green old age in 1625, +and was buried in the church of St Bartolemé. Even the painters +most employed at the munificent and art-loving court of the second +and third Philips, found time to paint for the venerable cathedral. +Thus, in 1615, Vincencio Carducho, the Florentine, painted, with +Eugenio Caxes, a series of frescoes in the chapel of the Sagrario; +and thus Eugenio Caxes, leaving the works at the Pardo and Madrid, +painted for the cathedral of Toledo the Adoration of the Magi, and +other independent pictures. + +Meanwhile the school of El Greco was producing worthy fruit; from +it, in the infancy of the seventeenth century, came forth Luis +Tristan, an artist even now almost unknown in London and Edinburgh, +but whose style Velasquez did not disdain to imitate, and whose +praises he was never tired of sounding. "Born, bred, and sped" +in Toledo, or its neighbourhood, as Morales was emphatically the +painter of Badajoz, so may Tristan be termed the painter of Toledo. +No foreign graces, no classical models, adorned or vitiated his +stern Spanish style; yet, in his portrait of Archbishop Sandoval, +he is said by Mr Stirling to have united the elaborate execution +of Sanchez Coello with much of the spirit of Titian. And of him is +the pleasant story recorded, that having, while yet a stripling, +painted for the Jeronymite convent at Toledo a Last Supper, for +which he asked two hundred ducats, and being denied payment by the +frugal friars, he appealed with them to the arbitration of his old +master, El Greco, who, having viewed the picture, called the young +painter a rogue and a novice, for asking only two for a painting +worth five hundred ducats. In the same Toledan church that contains +the ashes of his great master, lies the Murcian Pedro Orrente, +called by our author "the Bassano, or the Roos--the great sheep and +cattle master of Spain:" he too was employed by the art-encouraging +chapter, and the cathedral possessed several of his finest pictures. +But with Tristan and Orrente the glories of Toledan art paled and +waned; and, trusting that our readers have not been uninterested +in following our brief sketch of the remarkable men who for four +hundred years rendered this quaint old Gothic city famous for its +artistic splendours, we retrace our steps, halting and perplexed +among so many pleasant ways, blooming flowers, and brilliant bowers, +to the magnificent, albeit gloomy Escurial, where Philip II lavished +the wealth of his mighty empire in calling forth the most vigorous +energies of Spanish and of foreign art. + +For more than thirty years did the astonished shepherds of the +Guadaramas watch the mysterious pile growing under scaffolding alive +with armies of workmen; and often, while the cares of the Old World +and the New--to say nothing of that other World, which was seldom +out of Philip's thoughts, and to which his cruel fanaticism hurried +so many wretches before their time--might be supposed to demand +his attention at Madrid, were they privileged to see their mighty +monarch perched on a lofty ledge of rock, for hours, intently gazing +upon the rising walls and towers which were to redeem his vow to St +Laurence at the battle of Saint Quentin, and to hand down, through +all Spanish time, the name and fame of the royal and religious +founder. On the 23d of April 1563, the first stone of this Cyclopean +palace was laid, under the direction of Bautiste di Toledo, at +whose death, in 1567, the work was continued by Juan de Herrera, +and finally perfected by Leoni (as to the interior decorations) in +1597. Built in the quaint unshapely form of St Laurence's gridiron, +the Escurial is doubtless open to much severe criticism; but the +marvellous grandeur, the stern beauty, and the characteristic +effect of the gigantic pile, must for ever enchant the eyes of all +beholders, who are not doomed by perverse fate to look through the +green spectacles of gentle dulness. But it is not our purpose to +describe the Escurial; we only wish to bring before our readers the +names and merits of a few of the Spanish artists, who found among +its gloomy corridors or sumptuous halls niches in the temple of +fame, and in its saturnine founder the most gracious and munificent +of patrons. Suffice it, then, to say of the palace-convent, in Mr +Stirling's graceful words, that "Italy was ransacked for pictures +and statues, models and designs; the mountains of Sicily and +Sardinia for jaspers and agates; and every sierra of Spain furnished +its contribution of marble. Madrid, Florence, and Milan supplied +the sculptures of the altars; Guadalajara and Cuenca, gratings +and balconies; Saragossa the gates of brass; Toledo and the Low +Countries, lamps, candelabra, and bells; the New World, the finer +woods; and the Indies, both East and West, the gold and gems of the +custodia, and the five hundred reliquaries. The tapestries were +wrought in Flemish looms; and, for the sacerdotal vestments, there +was scarce a nunnery in the empire, from the rich and noble orders +of Brabant and Lombardy to the poor sisterhoods of the Apulian +highlands, but sent an offering of needlework to the honoured +fathers of the Escurial." + +We could wish to exclude from our paper all notice of the foreign +artists, whose genius assisted in decorating the new wonder of the +world; but how omit from any Escurialian or Philippian catalogue +the names of Titian and Cellini, Cambiaso and Tibaldi? For seven +long years did the great Venetian labour at his famous Last Supper, +painted for, and placed in the refectory; and countless portraits +by his fame-dealing pencil graced the halls and galleries of the +Palatian convents. In addition to these, the Pardo boasted eleven of +his portraits; among them, one of the hero Duke Emmanuel Philibert +of Savoy, who has received a second grant of renown--let us hope +a more lasting one[17]--from the poetic chisel of Marochetti, and +stands now in the great square of Turin, the very impersonation of +chivalry, horse and hero alike--κυδεί γαιῶν. + + [17] All these portraits were destroyed by fire in the reign of + Philip III. + +The magnificent Florentine contributed "the matchless marble +crucifix behind the prior's seat in the choir," of which Mr Stirling +says--"Never was marble shaped into a sublimer image of the great +sacrifice for man's atonement." Luca Cambiaso, the Genoese, painted +the Martyrdom of St Laurence for the high altar of the church--a +picture that must have been regarded, from its subject and position, +as the first of all the Escurial's religious pictures,--besides the +vault of the choir, and two great frescoes for the grand staircase. + +Pellegrino Tibaldi, a native of the Milanese, came at Philip's +request to the Escurial in 1586. He, too, painted a Martyrdom of +Saint Laurence for the high altar, but apparently with no better +success than his immediate predecessor, Zuccaro, whose work his +was to replace. But the ceiling of the library was Tibaldi's field +of fame; on it he painted a fresco 194 feet long by 30 wide, +which still speaks to his skill in composition and brilliancy in +colouring. Philip rewarded him with a Milanese marquisate and one +hundred thousand crowns. + +Morales, the first great devotional painter of Castile, on whom his +admiring countrymen bestowed the soubriquet of "divine"--with more +propriety, it must be confessed, than their descendants have shown +in conferring it upon Arguelles--contributed but one picture to +the court, and none to the Escurial; but in Alonzo Sanchez Coello, +born at Benifayrô, in Valencia, we find a famous native artist +decorating the superb walls of the new palace. While at Madrid he +was lodged in the Treasury, a building which communicated with the +palace by a door, of which the King kept a key; and often would the +royal Mæcenas slip thus, unobserved by the artist, into his studio. +Emperors and popes, kings and queens, princes and princesses, were +alike his friends and subjects; but we are now only concerned +to relate that, in 1582, he painted "five altar-pieces for the +Escurial, each containing a pair of saints." Far more of interest, +however, attaches itself to the name and memory of Juan Fernandez +Navarete, "whose genius was no less remarkable than his infirmities, +and whose name--El Mudo, the dumb painter--is as familiar to Europe +as his works are unknown," (vol. i. p. 250.) Born at Logroño in +1526, he went in his youth to Italy. Here he attracted the notice +of Don Luis Manrique, grand-almoner to Philip, who procured him +an invitation to Madrid. He was immediately set to work for the +Escurial; and in 1571 four pictures, the Assumption of the Virgin, +the Martyrdom of St James the Great, St Philip, and a Repenting St +Jerome, were hung in the sacristy of the convent, and brought him +five hundred ducats. In 1576 he painted, for the reception-hall of +the convent, a large picture representing Abraham receiving the +three Angels. "This picture," says Father Andres Ximenes, quoted +by Mr Stirling, (vol. i. p. 255) "so appropriate to the place it +fills, though the first of the master's works that usually meets +the eye, might, for its excellence, be viewed the last, and is well +worth coming many a league to see." An agreement, bearing date the +same year, between the painter and the prior, by which the former +covenanted to paint thirty-two large pictures for the side altars, +is preserved by Cean Bermudez; but El Mudo unfortunately died when +only eight of the series had been painted. On the 28th of March 1579 +this excellent and remarkable painter died in the 53d year of his +age. A few years later, Juan Gomez painted from a design of Tibaldi +a large picture of St Ursula, which replaced one of Cambiaso's least +satisfactory Escurialian performances. + +While acres of wall and ceiling were being thus painted in fresco, +or covered by large and fine pictures, the Escurial gave a ready +home to the most minute of the fine arts: illuminators of missals, +and painters of miniatures, embroiderers of vestments, and designers +of altar-cloths, found their labours appreciated, and their +genius called forth, no less than their more aspiring compeers. +Fray Andrez de Leon, and Fray Martin de Palencia, enriched the +Escurial with exquisite specimens of their skill in the arts of +miniature-painting and illuminating; and under the direction of Fray +Lorenzo di Monserrate, and Diego Rutiner, the conventual school of +embroidery produced frontals and dalmatics, copes, chasubles, and +altar-cloths, of rarest beauty and happiest designs. The goldsmiths +and silversmiths, too, lacked not encouragement in this greatest +of temples. Curious was the skill, and cunning the hand, which +fashioned the tower of gold and jasper to contain the Escurial's +holiest relique,--a muscle, singed and charred, of St Laurence--and +no doubt that skill was nobly rewarded. + +In 1598, clasping to his breast the veil of Our Lady of Monserrat, +in a little alcove hard by the church of the Escurial, died its +grim, magnificent founder. He had witnessed the completion of his +gigantic designs: palace and convent, there it stood--a monument +alike of his piety and his pride, and a proof of the grandeur and +resources of the mighty empire over which he ruled. But he appears +to have thought with the poet-- + + "Weighed in the balance, hero-dust + Is vile as mortal clay;" + +for he built no stately mausoleum, merely a common vault, to +receive the imperial dead. This omission, in 1617, Philip III. +undertook to supply; and Giovanni Battista Crescenzi, an Italian, +was selected as the architect. For thirty-four years did he and his +successors labour at this royal necropolis, which when finished +"became, under the name of the Pantheon, the most splendid chamber +of the Escurial."--(Vol. i. p. 412.) + +Mr Stirling's second volume opens with a graphic account of the +decay of Spanish power under Philip IV., and an equally graphic +description of this, the chief architectural triumph of his long +inglorious reign. The Pantheon was "an octagonal chamber 113 feet +in circumference, and 38 feet in height, from the pavement to the +centre of the domed vault. Each of its eight sides, excepting the +two which are occupied by its entrance, and the altar, contain +four niches and four marble urns; the walls, Corinthian pilasters, +cornices and dome, are formed of the finest marbles of Toledo and +Biscay, Tortosa and Genoa; and the bases, capitals, scrolls, and +other ornaments, are of gilt bronze. Placed beneath the presbytery +of the church, and approached by the long descent of a stately +marble staircase, this hall of royal tombs, gleaming with gold and +polished jasper, seems a creation of Eastern romance.... Hither +Philip IV. would come, when melancholy--the fatal taint of his blood +was strong upon him--to hear mass, and meditate on death, sitting in +the niche which was shortly to receive his bones." Yet this was the +monarch whose quick eye detected the early genius of Velasquez, and +who bore the palm as a patron from all the princes of his house, and +all the sovereigns of Europe. Well did the great painter repay the +discriminating friendship of the king, and so long as Spanish art +endures, will the features of Philip IV. be known in every European +country; and his fair hair, melancholy mien, impassive countenance +and cold eyes, reveal to all time the hereditary characteristics of +the phlegmatic house of Austria. + +Diego Rodriguez de Silva y Velasquez was born at Seville in 1599. +Here he entered the school of Herrera the Elder, a dashing painter, +and a violent man, who was for ever losing alike his temper and +his scholars. Velasquez soon left his turbulent rule for the +gentler instruction of Francisco Pacheco. In his studio the young +artist worked diligently, while he took lessons at the same time +of a yet more finished artist--nature; the nature of bright, +sunny, graceful Andalusia. Thus, while Velasquez cannot be called +a self-taught painter, he retained to the last that freedom from +mannerism, and that gay fidelity to nature, which so often--not in +his case--compensate for a departure from the highest rules and +requirements of art. + +While he was thus studying and painting the flowers and the fruits, +the damsels and the beggars, of sunny Seville, there arrived in that +beautiful city a collection of Italian and Spanish pictures. These +exercised no small influence on the taste and style of the young +artist; but, true to his country, and with the happy inspiration +of genius, it was to Luis Tristan of Toledo, rather than to any +foreign master, that he directed his chief attention; and hence the +future chief of the Castilian school was enabled to combine with its +merits the excellencies of both the other great divisions of Spanish +art. At the end of five years spent in this manner, he married +Pacheco's daughter, who witnessed all his forty years' labours and +successes, and closed his dying eyes. At the age of twenty-three, +Velasquez, anxious to enlarge his acquaintance with the masterpieces +of other schools, went to Madrid; but after spending a few months +there, and at the Escurial, he returned to Seville--soon, however, +to be recalled at the bidding of the great minister and Mæcenas, +Olivarez. Now, in 1623, set in the tide of favour and of fame, which +henceforward was not to flag or ebb till the great painter lay +stretched, out of its reach, on the cold bank of death. During this +summer he painted the noble portrait of the king on horseback, which +was exhibited by royal order in front of the church of San Felipe, +and which caused the all-powerful Count-duke to exclaim, that until +now his majesty had never been painted. Charmed and delighted with +the picture and the painter, Philip declared no other artist should +in future paint his royal face; and Mr Stirling maliciously adds +that "this resolution he kept far more religiously than his marriage +vows, for he appears to have departed from it during the life-time +of his chosen artist, in favour only of Rubens and Crayer." (Vol. +ii. p. 592.) On the 31st of October 1623, Velasquez was formally +appointed painter in ordinary to the king, and in 1626 was provided +with apartments in the Treasury. To this period Mr Stirling assigns +his best likeness of the equestrian monarch, of which he says--"Far +more pleasing than any other representation of the man, it is also +one of the finest portraits in the world. The king is in the glow +of youth and health, and in the full enjoyment of his fine horse, +and the breeze blowing freshly from the distant hills; he wears dark +armour, over which flutters a crimson scarf; a hat with black plumes +covers his head, and his right hand grasps a truncheon."--(P. 595.) + +In 1628, Velasquez had the pleasure of showing Rubens, who had come +to Madrid as envoy from the Low Countries, the galleries of that +city, and the wonders of the Escurial; and, following the advice +of that mighty master, he visited Italy the next year. On that +painter-producing soil, his steps were first turned to the city of +Titian; but the sun of art was going down over the quays and palaces +of once glorious Venice, and, hurrying through Ferrara and Bologna, +the eager pilgrim soon reached Rome. In this metropolis of religion, +learning, and art, the young Spaniard spent many a pleasant and +profitable month: nor, while feasting his eyes and storing his +memory with "its thousand forms of beauty and delight," did he allow +his pencil a perfect holiday. The Forge of Vulcan and Joseph's Coat +were painted in the Eternal City. After a few weeks at Naples, he +returned to Madrid in the spring of 1631. Portrait-painting for his +royal patron, who would visit his studio every day, and sit there +long hours, seems to have been now his main occupation; and now +was he able to requite the friendly aid he had received from the +Count-duke of Olivarez, whose image remains reflected on the stream +of time, not after the hideous caricature of Le Sage, but as limned +by the truthful--albeit grace-conferring--pencil of Velasquez. + +In 1639, leaving king and courtiers, lords and ladies, and soaring +above the earth on which he had made his step so sure, Velasquez +aspired to the grandest theme of poet, moralist, or painter, and +nobly did his genius justify the flight. His Crucifixion is one +of the sublimest representations conceived by the intellect, and +portrayed by the hand of man, of that stupendous event. "Unrelieved +by the usual dim landscape, or lowering clouds, the cross in this +picture has no footing upon earth, but is placed on a plain dark +ground, like an ivory carving on its velvet pall. Never was that +great agony more powerfully depicted. The head of our Lord drops +on his right shoulder, over which falls a mass of dark hair, while +drops of blood trickle from his thorn-pierced brows. The anatomy of +the naked body and limbs is executed with as much precision as in +Cellini's marble, which may have served Velasquez as a model; and +the linen cloth wrapped about the loins, and even the fir-wood of +the cross, display his accurate attention to the smallest details of +a great subject."--(Vol. ii. p. 619.) This masterpiece now hangs in +the Royal Gallery of Spain at Madrid. + +The all-powerful Olivarez underwent, in 1643, the fate of most +favourites, and experienced the doom denounced by the great English +satirist on "power too great to keep, or to resign." He had declared +his intention of making one Julianillo, an illegitimate child of no +one exactly knew who, his heir; had married him to the daughter of +the Constable of Castile, decked him with titles and honours, and +proposed to make him governor of the heir-apparent. The pencil of +Velasquez was employed to hand down to posterity the features of +this low-born cause of his great patron's downfall, and the portrait +of the ex-ballad singer in the streets of Madrid now graces the +collection of Bridgewater House. The disgrace of Olivarez served to +test the fine character of Velasquez, who not only sorrowed over his +patron's misfortunes, but had the courage to visit the disgraced +statesman in his retirement. + +The triumphal entrance of Philip IV. into Lerida, the surrender of +Breda, and portraits of the royal family, exercised the invention +and pencil of Velasquez till the year 1648, when he was sent by +the king on a roving mission into Italy--not to teach the puzzled +sovereigns the mysterious privileges of self-government, but to +collect such works of art as his fine taste might think worthy of +transportation to Madrid. Landing at Genoa, he found himself in +presence of a troop of Vandyck's gallant nobles: hence he went to +Milan, Padua, and Venice. At the latter city he purchased for his +royal master two or three pictures of Tintoret's, and the Venus and +Adonis of Paul Veronese. But Rome, as in his previous visit, was the +chief object of his pilgrimage. Innocent X. welcomed him gladly, +and commanded him to paint, not only his own coarse features, but +the more delicate ones of Donna Olympia, his "sister-in-law and +mistress." So, at least, says our author; for the sake of religion +and human nature, we hope he is mistaken. For more than a year did +Velasquez sojourn in Rome, purchasing works of art, and enjoying +the society of Bernini and Nicolas Poussin, Pietro da Cortona and +Algardi. "It would be pleasing, were it possible, to draw aside +the dark curtain of centuries, and follow him into the palaces and +studios--to see him standing by while Claude painted, or Algardi +modelled, (enjoying the hospitalities of Bentivoglio, perhaps in +that fair hall glorious with Guido's recent fresco of Aurora)--or +mingling in the group that accompanied Poussin in his evening walks +on the terrace of Trinità de Monte."--(Vol. ii. p. 643.) Meanwhile +the king was impatiently waiting his return, and at last insisted +upon its being no further delayed; so in 1651 the soil of Spain was +once more trod by her greatest painter. Five years later, Velasquez +produced his extraordinary picture, Las Meniñas--the Maids of +Honour, extraordinary alike in the composition, and in the skill +displayed by the painter in overcoming its many difficulties. Dwarfs +and maids of honour, hounds and children, lords and ladies, pictures +and furniture, are all introduced into this remarkable picture, with +such success as to make many judges pronounce it to be Velasquez's +masterpiece, and Luca Giordano to christen it "the theology of +painting." + +The Escurial, from whose galleries and cloisters we have been thus +lured by the greater glory of Velasquez, in 1656 demanded his +presence to arrange a large collection of pictures, forty-one of +which came from the dispersed and abused collection of the only +real lover of the fine arts who has sat on England's throne--that +martyr-monarch whom the pencil of Vandyck, and the pens of Lovelace, +Montrose, and Clarendon, have immortalised, though their swords +and counsels failed to preserve his life and crown. In 1659 the +cross of Santiago was formally conferred on this "king of painters, +and painter of kings;" and on St Prosper's day, in the Church of +the Carbonera, he was installed knight of that illustrious order, +the noblest grandees of Spain assisting at the solemn ceremonial. +The famous meeting on the Isle of Pheasants, so full of historic +interest, between the crowns and courts of Spain and France, +to celebrate the nuptials of Louis XIV. and Maria Theresa, was +destined to acquire an additional though melancholy fame, as the +last appearance of the great painter in public, and the possible +proximate cause of his death. To him, as aposentador-mayor, were +confided all the decorations and arrangements of this costly and +fatiguing pageant: he was also to find lodging on the road for +the king and the court; and some idea of the magnitude of his +official cares may be derived from the fact, that three thousand +five hundred mules, eighty-two horses, seventy coaches, and seventy +baggage-waggons, formed the train that followed the monarch out of +Madrid. On the 28th of June the court returned to Madrid, and on the +6th of August its inimitable painter expired. + +The merits of Velasquez are now generally appreciated in England; +and the popular voice would, we think, ratify the enthusiastic yet +sober dictum of Wilkie, "In painting an intelligent portrait he +is nearly unrivalled." Yet we have seen how he could rise to the +highest subject of mortal imagination in the Crucifixion; and the +one solitary naked Venus, which Spanish art in four hundred years +produced, is his. Mr Stirling, though he mentions this picture +in the body of his book, assigns it no place in his valuable and +laboriously compiled catalogue, probably because he was unable to +trace its later adventures. Brought to England in 1814, and sold +for £500 to Mr Morritt, it still remains the gem of the library +at Rokeby. Long may the Spanish queen of love preside over the +beautiful bowers of that now classic retreat! We sum up our notice +of Velasquez in Mr Stirling's words:--"No artist ever followed +nature with more catholic fidelity; his cavaliers are as natural +as his boors; he neither refined the vulgar, nor vulgarised +the refined.... We know the persons of Philip IV. and Olivarez +as familiarly as if we had paced the avenues of the Pardo with +Digby and Howell, and perhaps we think more favourably of their +characters. In the portraits of the monarch and the minister, + + 'The bounding steeds they pompously bestride, + Share with their lords the pleasure and the pride,' + +and enable us to judge of the Cordovese horse of that day, as +accurately as if we had lived with the horse-breeding Carthusians of +the Betis. And this painter of kings and horses has been compared, +as a painter of landscapes, to Claude; as a painter of low life, +to Teniers: his fruit-pieces equal those of Sanchez Cotan or Van +Kessel; his poultry might contest the prize with the fowls of +Hondekooter on their own dunghill; and his dogs might do battle with +the dogs of Sneyders."--(Vol. ii. p. 686.) + +While Velasquez, at the height of his glory, was painting his +magnificent Crucifixion, a young lad was displaying hasty sketches +and immature daubs to the venders of old clothes, pots, and +vegetables, the gipsies and mendicant friars that frequented the +Feria, or weekly fair held in the market-place of All Saints, in +the beautiful and religious city of Seville. This was Bartolemè +Estevan Murillo, who, having studied for some time under Juan +del Castillo, on that master's removal to Cadiz in 1640, betook +himself to this popular resource of all needy Sevillian painters. +Struck, however, by the great improvement which travel had wrought +in the style of Pedro de Moya, who revisited Seville in 1642, the +young painter scraped up money sufficient to carry him to Madrid, +and, as he hoped, to Rome. But the kindness of Velasquez provided +him a lodging in his own house, and opened the galleries of the +Alcazar and the Escurial to his view. Here he pursued his studies +unremittingly, and, as he thought, with a success that excused the +trouble and expense of an Italian pilgrimage. Returning, therefore, +in 1645 to Seville, he commenced that career which led him, among +the painters of Spain, to European renown, second only to that of +Velasquez. The Franciscans of his native city have the credit of +first employing his young genius, and the eleven large pictures +with which he adorned their convent-walls at once established his +reputation and success. These were painted in what is technically +called his first or cold style; this was changed before 1650 into +his second, or warm style, which in its turn yielded to his last, +or vapoury style. So warm, indeed, had his colouring become, that +a Spanish critic, in the nervous phraseology of Spain, declared +his flesh-tints were now painted with blood and milk. In this style +did he paint for the chapter The Nativity of the Blessed Virgin, in +which the ladies of Seville admired and envied the roundness of a +ministering maiden's naked arm; and a large picture of St Anthony +of Padua, which still adorns the walls of the cathedral baptistery. +Of this famous gem some curious stories are told: Don Fernando +Farfan, for instance, relates that birds had been seen attempting +to perch upon some lilies in a vase by the side of the kneeling +saint; and Monsieur Viardot (_Musées d'Espagne_, p. 146) informs us +that a reverend canon, who showed him the picture, recounted how +that, in 1813, the Duke of Wellington offered to purchase it for as +many gold onzas as would cover its surface; while, in 1843, Captain +Widdrington was assured that a lord had expressed his readiness +to give £40,000 for the bird-deluding picture. The belief in the +gullibility of travellers is truly remarkable and wide-spread; thus, +at Genoa, in 1839, our excellent cicerone gratified us with the +information, that, sixteen years before, the English Duke Balfour +had in vain offered £1600 for Canova's beautiful basso-relievo of +the Virgin Clasping the Corpse of our Saviour, which graces the +ugly church of the poor-house in that superb city. In 1658, Murillo +laboured to establish a public academy of art; and, in spite of the +jealousies and contentions of rival artists, on the 1st of January +1660, he witnessed its inauguration. The rules were few and simple; +but the declaration to be signed by each member on admission would +rather astonish the directors of the Royal Academy in London. We +would recommend it to the consideration of those Protestant divines +who are so anxious to devise a new test of heresy in the Church +of England: thus it ran--"Praised be the most holy sacrament, and +the pure conception of Our Lady." Nothing, perhaps, can show more +strongly the immense influence religion exercised on art in Spain +than the second clause of this declaration. It was the favourite +dogma of Seville: for hundreds of years sermons were preached, books +were written, pictures painted, legends recorded in honour of Our +Lady's spotless conception; and round many a picture by Cano, or +Vargas, or Joanes, is yet to be read the magic words that had power +to electrify a populace,--"Sin Pecado Concebida." The institution +thus commenced flourished for many years, and answered the generous +expectations of its illustrious founder. + +The attention of the pious Don Miguel Mañara de Leca, the +"benevolent Howard" of Seville, was attracted about 1661 to the +pitiable state of the brotherhood of the holy charity, and its +hospital of San Jorge: he resolved to restore it to its pristine +glory and usefulness; and, persevering against all discouragements +and difficulties, in less than twenty years, at an expense of +half-a-million of ducats, he accomplished his pious design. For the +restored church Murillo painted eleven pictures, of which eight, +according to Mr Stirling, are the finest works of the master. +Five of these were carried off by plundering Soult, but "the two +colossal compositions of Moses, and the Loaves and Fishes, still +hang beneath the cornices whence springs the dome of the church, +"like ripe oranges on the bough where they originally budded." Long +may they cover their native "walls, and enrich, as well as adorn, +the institution of Mañara! In the picture of the great miracle of +the Jewish dispensation, the Hebrew prophet stands beside the rock +in Horeb, with hands pressed together, and uplifted eyes, thanking +the Almighty for the stream which has just gushed forth at the +stroke of his mysterious rod.... As a composition, this wonderful +picture can hardly be surpassed. The rock, a huge, isolated, brown +crag, much resembles in form, size, and colour, that which is still +pointed out as the rock of Moses, by the Greek monks of the convent +of St Catherine, in the real wilderness of Horeb. It forms the +central object, rising to the top of the canvass, and dividing it +into two unequal portions. In front of the rock, the eye at once +singles out the erect figure of the prophet standing forward from +the throng; and the lofty emotion of that great leader, looking with +gratitude to heaven, is finely contrasted with the downward regards +of the multitude, forgetful of the Giver in the anticipation or +the enjoyment of the gift. Each head and figure is an elaborate +study; each countenance has a distinctive character, and even of +the sixteen vessels brought to the spring, no two are alike in +form."--(Vol. ii. p. 859.) But Cean Bermudez, who enjoyed the +privilege of seeing all these eight masterpieces hanging together +in their own sacred home, preferred The Prodigal's Return, and St +Elizabeth of Hungary--with whose touching history the eloquent +pens of the Count Montalembert and Mr A. Phillipps have made us +familiar--to all the rest. + +The Franciscan convent, without the city walls, was yet more +fortunate than the hospital of Mañara, for it possessed upwards +of twenty of this religious painter's works. Now, not one remains +to dignify the ruined halls and deserted cloisters of that once +magnificent convent: but seventeen of these pictures are preserved +in the Seville Museum; among them Murillo's own favourite--that +which he used to call "his own picture"--the charity of St Thomas +of Villanueva. In 1678, Murillo painted three pictures for the +Hospital de los Venerables, two of which, the Mystery of the +Immaculate Conception, and St Peter Weeping, were placed in the +chapel. "The third adorned the refectory, and presented to the +gaze of the Venerables, during their repasts, the blessed Virgin +enthroned on clouds, with her divine Babe, who, from a basket borne +by angels, bestowed bread on three aged priests." These were nearly +his last works; for the art he so loved was now about to destroy her +favourite son: he was mounting a scaffolding to paint the higher +parts of a great altar-piece for the Capuchin church at Cadiz, +representing the espousals of St Catherine, when he stumbled, and +ruptured himself so severely, as to die of the injury. On the 3d of +April 1682, he expired in the arms of his old and faithful friend, +Don Justino Neve, and was buried in the parish church of St. Cruz, a +stone slab with his name, a skeleton and "Vive moriturus," marking +the spot--until the "Vandal" French destroyed the last resting-place +of that great painter, whose works they so unscrupulously +appropriated. Was the last Lord of Petworth aware of this short +epitaph, when he caused to be inscribed on the beautiful memorial to +his ancestors which adorns St Thomas's Chapel in Petworth Church, +the prophetic,[18] solemn words--"Mortuis moriturus?" + + [18] He died the year following. + +We have ranked Murillo next to Velasquez: doubtless there are many +in England who would demur to this classification; and we own there +are charms in the style of the great religious painter, which it +would be vain to look for in any other master. In tenderness of +devotion, and a certain soft sublimity, his religious pictures are +unmatched; while in colouring, Cean Bermudez most justly says--"All +the peculiar beauties of the school of Andalusia--its happy use of +red and brown tints, the local colours of the region, its skill in +the management of drapery, its distant prospects of bare sierras +and smiling vales, its clouds, light and diaphanous as in nature, +its flowers and transparent waters, and its harmonious depth and +richness of tone--are to be found in full perfection in the works of +Murillo."--(Vol. ii. p. 903.) Mr Stirling draws a distinction, and +we think with reason, between the favourite Virgin of the Immaculate +Conception and the other Virgins of Murillo: the ἠθὸς of the former +is far more elevated and spiritualised than that of any of the +latter class; but, even in his most ordinary and mundane delineation +of the sinless Mary, how sweet, and pure, and holy, as well as +beautiful, does our Lord's mother appear! But perhaps it is as a +painter of children that Murillo is most appreciated in England; nor +can we wonder that such should be the case, when we remember what +the pictures are which have thus impressed Murillo on the English +mind. The St John Baptist with the Lamb, in the National Gallery; +Lord Westminster's picture of the same subject; the Baroness de +Rothschild's gem at Gunnersbury, Our Lord, the Good Shepherd, as a +Child: Lord Wemyss's hardly inferior repetition of it; the picture +of our Lord as a child, holding in his hands the crown of thorns, +in the College at Glasgow; with the other pictures, in private +collections, of our Lord and St John as children, have naturally +made Murillo to be regarded in England as emphatically the painter +of children: and how exquisite is his conception of the Divine Babe +and His saintly precursor! what a sublime consciousness of power, +what an expression of boundless love, are seen in the face of Him +who was yet + + "a little child, + Taught by degrees to pray + By father dear, and mother mild, + Instructed day by day." + +The religious school of Spanish painting reached its acmé in +Murillo; and, at the risk of being accounted heterodox, we must, +in summing up his merits, express our difference from Mr Stirling +in one respect, and decline to rank the great Sevillian after any +of the Italian masters. Few of Murillo's drawings are known to be +in existence. Mr Stirling gives a list of such as he has been able +to discover, nearly all of which are at the Louvre. We believe, +in addition to those possessed by the British Museum and Mr Ford, +there are two in the collection at Belvoir Castle: one, a Virgin +and Child; the other, an old man--possibly St Francis--receiving a +flower from a naked child. + +After Velasquez and Murillo, it may seem almost impertinent to talk +of the merits of other Spanish painters; yet Zurbaran and Cano, +Ribera and Coello, demand at least a passing notice. Francisco +de Zurbaran, often called the Caravaggio of Spain, was born in +Estremadura in 1598. His father, observing his turn for painting, +sent him to the school of Roelas, at Seville. Here, for nearly a +quarter of a century, he continued painting for the magnificent +cathedral, and the churches and religious houses of that fair city. +About 1625, he painted, for the college of St Thomas Aquinas, +an altar-piece, regarded by all judges as the finest of all his +works. It represents the angelic doctor ascending into the heavens, +where, on clouds of glory, the blessed Trinity and the Virgin wait +to receive him; below, in mid air, sit the four doctors of the +Church; and on the ground are kneeling the Emperor Charles V., +with the founder of the college, Archbishop Diego de Deza, and a +train of ecclesiastics. Mr Stirling says of this singular picture, +"The colouring throughout is rich and effective, and worthy the +school of Roelas; the heads are all of them admirable studies; +the draperies of the doctors and ecclesiastics are magnificent +in breadth and amplitude of fold; the imperial mantle is painted +with Venetian splendour; and the street view, receding in the +centre of the canvass, is admirable for its atmospheric depth and +distance."--(Vol. ii. p. 770.) In 1650, Philip IV. invited him to +Madrid, and commanded him to paint ten pictures, representing the +labours of Hercules, for a room at Buen-retiro. Almost numberless +were the productions of his facile pencil, which, however, chiefly +delighted to represent, the legends of the Carthusian cloister, +and portray the gloomy features and sombre vestments of monks and +friars; yet those who have seen his picture of the Virgin with the +Infant Saviour and St John, at Stafford House, will agree with Mr +Stirling that, "unrivalled in such subjects of dark fanaticism, +Zurbaran could also do ample justice to the purest and most lovely +of sacred themes."--(Vol. 11. p. 775) + +Alonzo Cano, born at Grenada in 1601, was, like Mrs Malaprop's +Cerberus, "three gentlemen in one;" that is, he was a great painter, +a great sculptor, and a great architect. As a painter, his powers +are shown in his full-length picture of the Blessed Virgin, with +the infant Saviour asleep on her knees, now in the Queen of Spain's +gallery; in six large works, representing passages in the life +of Mary Magdalene, which still adorn the great brick church of +Getafe, a small village near Madrid; and in his famous picture of +Our Lady of Belem, in the cathedral of Seville. Mr Stirling gives a +beautifully-executed print of this last Madonna, which, "in serene, +celestial beauty, is excelled by no image of the Blessed Virgin ever +devised in Spain."--(P. 803.) + +Cano was, perhaps, even greater in sculpture than in painting; +and so fond of the former art, that, when wearied of pencil and +brush, he would call for his chisel, and work at a statue by way +of rest to his hands. On one of these occasions, a pupil venturing +to remark, that to substitute a mallet for a pencil was an odd sort +of repose, was silenced by Cano's philosophical reply,--"Blockhead, +don't you perceive that to create form and relief on a flat surface +is a greater labour than to fashion one shape into another?" An +image of the Blessed Virgin in the parish church at Lebrija, and +another in the sacristy of the Grenada cathedral, are said to +be triumphs of Spanish painted statuary.--(Vol. iii., p. 805) +After a life of strange vicissitudes, in the course of which, on +suspicion of having murdered his wife, he underwent the examination +by torture, he died, honoured and beloved for his magnificent +charities, and religious hatred of the Jews, in his native city, on +the 3d of October 1667. + +The old Valencian town of Xativa claims the honour of producing +Josè de Ribera, el Spagnoletto; but though Spain gave him birth, +Italy gave him instruction, wealth, fame; and although in style he +is thoroughly Spanish, we feel some difficulty in writing of him as +belonging wholly to the Spanish school of art, so completely Italian +was he by nurture, long residence, and in his death. + +Bred up in squalid penury, he appears to have looked upon the world +as not his friend, and in his subsequent good fortunes to have +revelled in describing with ghastly minuteness, and repulsive force, +all "the worst ills that flesh is heir to." We well recollect the +horror with which we gazed spell-bound on a series of his horrors +in the Louvre--faugh! At Gosford House are a series of Franciscan +monks, such as only a Spanish cloister could contain, painted with +an evident fidelity to nature, and the minutest details of dress +that is almost offensive--even the black dirt under the unwashed +thumb nail is carefully represented by his odiously-accurate and +powerful pencil. + + "Non ragioniam di lor + Ma guada e passa." + +Had the bold buccaneers of the seventeenth century required the +services of a painter to perpetuate the memory of their inventive +brutality, and inconceivable atrocities, they would have found in El +Spagnoletto an artist capable of delineating the agonies of their +victims, and by taste and disposition not indisposed to their way of +life. Yet in his own peculiar line he was unequalled, and his merits +as a painter will always be recognised by every judge of art. He +died at Naples, the scene of his triumphs, in 1656. + +The name of Claudio Coello is associated with the Escurial, and +should have been introduced into the sketch we were giving of its +artists, when the mighty reputation of Velasquez and Murillo broke +in upon our order. He was born at Madrid about the middle of the +seventeenth century, and studied in the school of the younger Rigi. +In 1686 he succeeded Herrera as painter in ordinary to Charles +II. This monarch had erected an altar in the great sacristy of +the Escurial, to the miraculous bleeding wafer known as the Santa +Forma; and on the death of its designer, Rigi, Coello was called +upon to paint a picture that should serve as a veil for the host. On +a canvass six yards high, by three wide, he executed an excellent +work, representing the king and his court adoring the miraculous +wafer, which is held aloft by the prior. This picture established +his reputation, and in 1691 the chapter of Toledo, still the great +patrons of art, appointed him painter to their cathedral. Coello was +a most careful and painstaking painter, and his pictures, says our +author, (vol. iii., p. 1018) "with much of Cano's grace of drawing, +have also somewhat of the rich tones of Murillo, and the magical +effect of Velasquez." He died, it is said, of disappointment at the +success of his foreign rival, Luca Giordano, in 1693. + +With Charles II. passed away the Spanish sceptre from the house of +Austria, nor, according to Mr Stirling, would the Genius of Painting +remain to welcome the intrusive Bourbons:-- + + Old times were changed, old manners gone, + A stranger filled the Philips' throne; + And art, neglected and oppressed, + Wished to be with them, and at rest. + +But we must say that Mr Stirling, in his honest indignation against +France and Frenchmen, has exaggerated the demerits of the Bourbon +kings. Spanish art had been steadily declining for years before +they, with ill-omened feet, crossed the Pyrenees. It was no Bourbon +prince that brought Luca da Presto from Naples to teach the painters +of Spain "how to be content with their faults, and get rid of their +scruples;" and if the schools of Castile and Andalusia had ceased +to produce such artists as those whose praises Mr Stirling has so +worthily recorded, it appears scant justice to lay the blame on the +new royal family. _Pictor nascitur, non fit_--no, not even by the +wielders of the Spanish sceptre. In a desire to patronise art, and +in munificence towards its possessors, Philip V., Ferdinand VI., +and Charles III., fell little short of their Hapsburg predecessors, +but they had no longer the same material to work upon. The post +which Titian had filled could find no worthier holder under Charles +III., than Rafael Mengs, whom not only ignorant Bourbons, but the +_conoscenti_ of Europe regarded as the mighty Venetian's equal; +and Philip V. not only invited Hovasse, Vanloo, Procaccini, and +other foreign artists to his court, but added the famous collection +of marbles belonging to Christina of Sweden to those acquired by +Velasquez, at an expense of twelve thousand doubloons. To him, also, +is due the completion of the palace of Aranjuez, and the design +of La Granja; nor, when fire destroyed the Alcazar, did Philip V. +spare his diminished treasures, in raising up on its time-hallowed +site a palace which, in Mr Stirling's own words, "in spite of its +narrowed proportions, is still one of the largest and most imposing +in Europe."--(Vol. iii., p. 1163.) + +Ferdinand VI. built, at the enormous expense of nineteen millions +of reals the convent of nuns of the order of St Vincent de Sales, +and employed in its decoration all the artistic talent that Spain +then could boast of. Nor can he be blamed if that was but little; +for if royal patronage can produce painters of merit, this monarch, +by endowing the Academy of St Ferdinand with large revenues, and +housing it in a palace, would have revived the glories of Spanish +art. + +His successor, Charles III., an artist of some repute himself, +sincerely loved and generously fostered the arts. While King of the +Two Sicilies, he had dragged into the light of day the long-lost +wonders of Herculaneum and Pompeii; and when called to the throne +of Spain and the Indies, he manifested his sense of the obligations +due from royalty to art, by conferring fresh privileges on the +Academy of St Ferdinand, and founding two new academies, one in +Valencia, the other in Mexico. If Mengs and Tiepolo, and other +mediocrities, were the best living painters his patronage could +discover, it is evident from his ultra-protectionist decree against +the exportation of Murillo's, pictures, that he fully appreciated +the works of the mighty dead; and, had his spirit animated Spanish +officials, many a masterpiece that now mournfully, and without +meaning, graces the Hermitage at St Petersburg, or the Louvre at +Paris, would still be hanging over the altar, or adorning the +refectory for which it was painted, at Seville or Toledo. Even +Charles IV., "the drivelling tool of Godoy," was a collector of +pictures, and founder of an academy. In his disastrous reign +flourished Francisco Goya y Lucientes, the last Spanish painter who +has obtained a niche in the Temple of Fame. Though portraits and +caricatures were his forte, in that venerable museum of all that is +beautiful in Spanish Art--the cathedral at Toledo--is to be seen a +fine religious production of his pencil, representing the Betrayal +of our Lord. But he loved painting at, better than for the church; +and those who have examined and wondered at the grotesque satirical +carvings of the stalls in the cathedral at Manchester, will be +able to form some idea of Goya's anti-monkish caricatures. Not +Lord Mark Kerr, when giving the rein to his exuberant fancy, ever +devised more ludicrous or repulsive "monsters" than this strange +successor to the religious painters of orthodox Spain. But when +the vice, and intrigues, and imbecility of the royal knives and +fools, whom his ready graver had exposed to popular ridicule, had +yielded to the unsupportable tyranny of French invaders, the same +indignant spirit that hurried the water-carriers of Madrid into +unavailing conflict with the troops of Murat, guided his caustic +hand against the fierce oppressors of his country; and, while +Gilray was exciting the angry contempt of all true John Bulls at +the impudence of the little Corsican upstart, Goya was appealing +to his countrymen's bitter experience of the tender mercies of the +French invaders. He died at Bordeaux in 1828. Mr Stirling closes his +labours with a graceful tribute to those of Cean Bermudez, "the able +and indefatigable historian of Spanish art, to whose rich harvest of +valuable materials I have ventured to add the fruit of my own humble +gleanings--" a deserved tribute, and most handsomely rendered. But, +before we dismiss this pleasant theme of Spanish art, we would add +one artist more to the catalogue of Spanish painters--albeit, that +artist is a Bourbon! + +Near the little town of Azpeitia, in Biscay, stands the magnificent +college of the Jesuits, built on the birth-place of Ignatius Loyola. +Here, in a low room at the top of the building, are shown a piece +of the bed in which he died, and his autograph; and here among its +cool corridors and ever-playing fountains, in 1839, was living the +royal painter--the Infante Don Sebastian. A strange spectacle, +truly, did that religious house present in the summer of 1839: +wild Biscayan soldiers and dejected Jesuits, red boynas and black +cowls, muskets and crucifixes, oaths and benedictions, crossed and +mingled with each other in picturesque, though profane disorder; +and here, released from the cares of his military command, and free +to follow the bent of his disposition, the ex-commander-in-chief +of the Carlist forces was quietly painting altar-pieces, and +dashing off caricatures. In the circular church which, of exquisite +proportions, forms the centre of the vast pile, and is beautiful +with fawn-coloured marble and gold, hung a large and well-painted +picture of his production; and those who are curious in such matters +may see a worse specimen of his royal highness's skill in Pietro +di Cortona's church of St Luke at Rome. On one side of the altar +is Canova's beautiful statue of Religion preaching; on the other +the Spanish prince's large picture of the Crucifixion; but, alas! +it must be owned that the inspiration which guided Velasquez to +his conception of that sublime subject was denied to the royal +amateur. In the academy of St Luke, adjoining the church, is a +well-executed bust of Canova, by the Spanish sculptor Alvarez. We +suspect that, like Goya, the Infante would do better to stick to +caricature, in which branch of art many a pleasant story is told of +his proficiency. Seated on a rocky plateau, which, if commanding +a view of Bilbao and its defenders, was also exposed to their +fire, 'tis said the royal artist would amuse himself and his staff +with drawing the uneasy movements, and disturbed countenances, of +some unfortunate London reporters, who, attached to the Carlist +headquarters, were invited by the commander-in-chief to attend his +person, and enjoy the perilous honour of his company. Be this, +however, as it may, we think we have vindicated the claim of one +living Bourbon prince to be admitted into the roll of Spanish +painters in the next edition of the _Annals_. + +In these tumultuous days, when + + "Royal heads are haunted like a maukin," + +over half the Continent, and even in steady England grave +merchants and wealthy tradesmen are counselling together on how +little their sovereign can be clothed and fed, and all things are +being brought to the vulgar test of _L. s. d._, it is pleasant to +turn to the artistic annals of a once mighty empire like Spain, and +see how uniformly, for more than five hundred years, its monarchs +have been the patrons, always munificent, generally discriminating, +of the fine arts--how, from the days of Isabella the Catholic, to +those of Isabella the Innocent, the Spanish sceptre has courted, +not disdained, the companionship of the pencil and the chisel. +Mr Stirling has enriched his pages with many an amusing anecdote +illustrative of this royal love of art, and suggestive, alas! of +the painful reflection, that the future annalist of the artists of +England will find great difficulty in scraping together half-a-dozen +stories of a similar kind. With the one striking exception of +Charles I., we know not who among our sovereigns can be compared, +as a patron of art, to any of the Spanish sovereigns, from Charles +V. of the Austrian to Charles III. of the Bourbon race. Lord Hervey +has made notorious George II's ignorance and dislike of art. Among +the many noble and kingly qualities of his grandson, we fear a +love and appreciation of art may not be reckoned; and although, in +his intercourse with men of genius, George IV. was gracious and +generous, what can be said in favour of his taste and discernment? +The previous life of William IV., the mature age at which he +ascended the throne, and the troublous character of his reign, +explain why art received but slight countenance from the court of +the frank and noble-hearted Sailor Prince; but we turn with hope to +the future. The recent proceedings in the Court of Chancery have +made public a fact, already known to many, that her Majesty wields +with skilful hand a graceful graver, and the Christmas plays acted +at Windsor are a satisfactory proof that English art and genius are +not exiled from England's palaces. The professors, then, of that art +which Velasquez and Rubens, Murillo and Vandyck practised, shall yet +see that the Crown of England is not only in ancient legal phrase, +"the Fountain of Honour," but that it loves to direct its grateful +streams in their honoured direction. Free was the intercourse, +unfettered the conversation, independent the relations, between +Titian and Charles V., Velasquez and Philip IV.; let us hope that +Buckingham Palace and Windsor Castle, will yet witness a revival +of those palmy days of English art, when Inigo Jones, and Vandyck, +and Cowley, Waller, and Ben Jonson, shed a lustre on the art-loving +court of England! + +The extracts we have given from Mr Stirling's work will have +sufficiently shown the scope of the _Annals_, and the spirit and +style in which they are written. There is no tedious, inflexible, +though often unmanageable leading idea, or theory of art, running +through these lively volumes. In the introduction, whatever is to +be said on the philosophy of Spanish art is carefully collected, +and the reader is thenceforward left at liberty to carry on the +conclusions of the introduction with him in his perusal of the +_Annals_, or to drop them at the threshold. We would, however, +strongly recommend all who desire to appreciate Spanish art, never +to forget that she owes all her beauty and inspiration to Spanish +nature and Spanish religion. Remember this, O holyday tourist along +the Andalusian coast, or more adventurous explorer of Castile and +Estremadura, and you will not be disappointed with her productions. +Mr Stirling has not contented himself with doing ample justice to +the great painters, and slurring over the comparatively unknown +artists, whose merits are in advance of their fame, but has embraced +in his careful view the long line of Spanish artists who have +flourished or faded in the course of nearly eight hundred years; and +he has accomplished this difficult task, not in the plodding spirit +of a Dryasdust, or with the curt dulness of a catalogue-monger, +but with the discriminating good taste of an accomplished English +gentleman, and in a style at once racy and rhetorical. There are +whole pages in the _Annals_ as full of picturesque beauty as the +scenes or events they describe, and of melody, as an Andalusian +summer's eve; indeed, the vigorous fancy and genial humour of +the author have, on some few occasions, led him to stray from +those strict rules of ἀιδὼς, which we are old-fashioned enough +to wish always observed. But where the charms and merits are so +great, and so many, and the defects so few and so small, we may +safely leave the discovery of the latter to the critical reader, and +satisfy our conscience by expressing a hope that, when Mr Stirling +next appears in the character of author--a period not remote, we +sincerely trust--he will have discarded those few scentless flowers +from his literary garden, and present us with a bouquet-- + + "Full of sweet buds and roses, + A box where sweets compacted lie." + +But if he never again put pen to paper, in these annals of the +artists of Spain he has given to the reading public a work which, +for utility of design, patience of research, and grace of language, +merits and has won the highest honours of authorship. + + + + +THE DODO AND ITS KINDRED.[19] + + [19] _The Dodo and its Kindred; or, the History, Affinities, and + Osteology of the Dodo, Solitaire, and other Extinct Birds of the + Islands Mauritius, Rodriguez, and Bourbon._ By H. E. STRICKLAND, + M.A. F.G.S., F.R.G.S., President of the Ashmolean Society, &c., and + A. G. MELVILLE, M.D., Edinburgh, M.R.C. One vol., royal quarto: + London, 1848. + + +What was the Dodo? When was the Dodo? Where is the Dodo? are all +questions, the first more especially, which it is fully more easy +to ask than answer. Whoever has looked through books on natural +history--for example, that noted but now scarce instructor of our +early youth, the _Three Hundred Animals_--must have observed a +somewhat ungainly creature, with a huge curved bill, a shortish +neck, scarcely any wings, a plumy tuft upon the back--considerably +on the off-side, though pretending to be a tail,--and a very +shapeless body, extraordinarily large and round about the hinder +end. This anomalous animal being covered with feathers, and having, +in addition to the other attributes above referred to, only two +legs, has been, we think justly, regarded as a bird, and has +accordingly been named the Dodo. But why it should be so named +is another of the many mysterious questions, which require to be +considered in the history of this unaccountable creature. No one +alleges, nor can we conceive it possible, that it claims kindred +with either of the only two human beings we ever heard of who +bore the name: "And after him (Adino the Eznite) was Eleazar the +son of Dodo, the Ahohite, one of the three mighty men with David, +when they defied the Philistines that were there gathered together +to battle, and the men of Israel were gone away." Our only other +human Dodo belonged to the fair sex, and was the mother of the +famous Zoroaster, who flourished in the days of Darius Hystaspes, +and brought back the Persians to their ancient fire-worship, from +the adoration of the twinkling stars. The name appears to have +been dropped by both families, as if they were somewhat ashamed of +it; and we feel assured that of such of our readers as admit that +Zoroaster must have had a mother of some sort, very few really +remember now-a-days that her name was Dodo. There were no baptismal +registers in those times; or, if such existed, they were doubtless +consumed in the "great fire"--a sort of periodical, it may be +providential, mode of shortening the record, which seems to occur +from time to time in all civilised countries. + +But while the creature in question,--we mean the feathered +biped--has been continuously presented to view in those "vain +repetitions" which unfortunately form the mass of our information in +all would-be popular works on natural history, we had actually long +been at a stand-still in relation to its essential attributes--the +few competent authorities who had given out their opinion upon this, +as many thought, stereotyped absurdity, being so disagreed among +themselves as to make confusion worse confounded. The case, indeed, +seemed desperate; and had it not been that we always entertained a +particular regard for old Clusius, (of whom by-and-by,) and could +not get over the fact that a Dodo's head existed in the Ashmolean +Museum, Oxford, and a Dodo's foot in the British Museum, London, +we would willingly have indulged the thought that the entire Dodo +was itself a dream. But, shaking off the cowardly indolence which +would seek to shirk the investigation of so great a question, let us +now inquire into a piece of ornithological biography, which seemed +so singularly to combine the familiar with the fabulous. Thanks +to an accomplished and persevering naturalist of our own day--one +of the most successful and assiduous inquirers of the younger +generation--we have now all the facts, and most of the fancies, +laid before us in a splendid royal quarto volume, just published, +with numerous plates, devoted to the history and illustration of +the "Dodo and its Kindred." It was, in truth, the latter term that +cheered our heart, and led us again towards a subject which had +previously produced the greatest despondency; for we had always, +though most erroneously, fancied that the great misformed lout of +our _Three Hundred Animals_ was all alone in the wide world, unable +to provide for himself, (and so, fortunately, without a family,) +and had never, in truth, had either predecessors or posterity. Mr +Strickland, however, has brought together the _disjecta membra_ of +a family group, showing not only fathers and mothers, sisters and +brothers, but cousins, and kindred of all degrees. Their sedate and +somewhat sedentary mode of life is probably to be accounted for, +not so much by their early habits as their latter end. Their legs +are short, their wings scarcely existant, but they are prodigiously +large and heavy in the hinder-quarters; and organs of flight would +have been but a vain thing for safety, as they could not, in such +wooded countries as these creatures inhabited, have been made +commensurate with the uplifting of such solid bulk, placed so far +behind that centre of gravity where other wings are worked. We can +now sit down in Mr Strickland's company, to discuss the subject, not +only tranquilly, but with a degree of cheerfulness which we have not +felt for many a day: thanks to his kindly consideration of the Dodo +and "its kindred." + +The geographical reader will remember that to the eastward of the +great, and to ourselves nearly unknown, island of Madagascar, there +lies a small group of islands of volcanic origin, which, though not +exactly contiguous among themselves, are yet nearer to each other +than to the greater island just named, and which is interposed +between them and the coast of Southern Africa. They are named +Rodriguez, Bourbon, and Mauritius, or the Isle of France. There is +proof that not fewer than four distinct species of large-bodied, +short-winged birds, of the Dodo type, were their inhabitants in +comparatively recent times, and have now become utterly extinct. We +say utterly, because neither proof nor vestige of their existence +elsewhere has been at any time afforded; and the comparatively +small extent, and now peopled state of the islands in question, +(where they are no longer known,) make the continuous and unobserved +existence of these birds, so conspicuous in size and slow of foot, +impossible. + +Now, it is this recent and total extinction which renders the +subject one of more than ordinary interest. Death is an admitted +law of nature, in respect to the _individuals_ of all species. +Geology, "dragging at each remove a lengthened chain" has shown how, +at different and distant eras, innumerable tribes have perished +and been supplanted, or at least replaced, by other groups of +species, entire races, better fitted for the great climatic and +other physical changes, which our earth's surface has undergone +from time to time. How these changes were brought about, many, +with more or less success, (generally less,) have tried to say. +Organic remains--that is, the fossilised remnants of ancient +species--sometimes indicate a long continuance of existence, +generation after generation living in tranquillity, and finally +sinking in a quiet grave; while other examples show a sudden and +violent death, in tortuous and excited action, as if they had been +almost instantaneously overwhelmed and destroyed by some great +catastrophe. + +Several local extinctions of elsewhere existing species are known +to naturalists--such as those of the beaver, the bear, and the +wolf, which no longer occur in Great Britain, though historically +known, as well as organically proved by recent remains, to have +lived and died among us. Their extinction was slow and gradual, +and resulted entirely from the inroads which the human race--that +is, the increase of population, and the progress of agriculture +and commerce--necessarily made upon their numbers, which thus +became "_few_ by degrees, and beautifully less." The beaver might +have carried on business well enough, in his own quiet way, +although frequently incommoded by the love of peltry on the part +of a hat-wearing people; but it is clear that no man with a small +family, and a few respectable farm-servants, could either permit +a large and hungry wolf to be continually peeping at midnight +through the key-hole of the nursery, or allow a brawny bruin to +snuff too frequently under the kitchen door, (after having hugged +the watch-dog to death,) when the serving-maids were at supper. The +extirpation, then, of at least two of those quondam British species +became a work of necessity and mercy, and might have been tolerated +even on a Sunday between sermons--especially as naturalists have it +still in their power to study the habits of similar wild beasts, by +no means yet extinct, in the neighbouring countries of France and +Germany. + +But the death of the Dodo and its kindred is a more affecting fact, +as involving the extinction of an entire race, root and branch, and +proving that death is a law of the _species_, as well as of the +individuals which compose it,--although the life of the one is so +much more prolonged than that of the other that we can seldom obtain +any positive proof of its extinction, except by the observance of +geological eras. Certain other still existing species, well known +to naturalists, may be said to be, as it were, just hovering on +the brink of destruction. One of the largest and most remarkable +of herbivorous animals--a species of wild cattle, the aurochs +or European bison (_B. priscus_)--exists now only in the forest +of Bialowicksa, from whence the Emperor of Russia has recently +transmitted a living pair to the Zoological Society of London. +Several kinds of birds are also evidently on their last legs. For +example, a singular species of parrot, (_Nestor productus_,) with +the termination of the upper mandible much attenuated, peculiar to +Phipps's Island, near Norfolk Island, has recently ceased to exist +there in the wild state, and is now known as a living species only +from a few surviving specimens kept in cages, and which refuse to +breed. The burrowing parrot from New Zealand is already on the road +to ruin; and more than one species of that singular and wingless +bird, called _Apteryx_, also from the last-named island, may be +placed in the same category. Even in our own country, if the landed +proprietors were to yield to the clamour of the Anti-Game-Law +League, the red grouse or moor-game might cease to be, as they occur +nowhere else on the known earth save in Britain and the Emerald Isle. + +The geographical distribution of animals, in general, has been +made conformable to laws which we cannot fathom. A mysterious +relationship exists between certain organic structures and those +districts of the earth's surface which they inhabit. Certain +extensive groups, in both the animal and vegetable kingdom, +are found to be restricted to particular continents, and their +neighbouring islands. Of some the distribution is very extensive, +while others are totally unknown except within a limited space, such +as some solitary isle, + + "Placed far amid the melancholy main." + + "In the present state of science," says Mr Strickland, "we must + be content to admit the existence of this law, without being + able to enunciate its preamble. It does _not_ imply that organic + distribution depends on soil and climate; for we often find a + perfect identity of these conditions in opposite hemispheres, + and in remote continents, whose faunæ and floræ are almost + wholly diverse. It does not imply that allied but distinct + organisms have been adduced, by generation or spontaneous + development, from the same original stock; for (to pass over + other objections) we find detached volcanic islets, which have + been ejected from beneath the ocean, (such as the Galapagos, + for instance,) inhabited by terrestrial forms allied to those + of the nearest continent, though hundreds of miles distant, and + evidently never connected with them. But this fact may indicate + that the Creator, in forming new organisms to discharge the + functions required from time to time by the ever vacillating + balance of nature, has thought fit to preserve the regularity + of the system by modifying the types of structure already + established in the adjacent localities, rather than to proceed + _per saltum_ by introducing forms of more foreign aspect." + +In conformity with this relation between geographical distribution +and organic structure, it has been ascertained that a small portion +of the indigenous animals and plants of the islands of Rodriguez, +Bourbon, and the Isle of France, are either allied to or identical +with the productions of continental Africa, a larger portion with +those of Madagascar, while certain species are altogether peculiar +to the insular group above named. + + "And as these three islands form a detached cluster, as compared + to other lands, so do we find in them a peculiar group of birds, + specifically different in each island, yet allied together in + their general characters, and remarkably isolated from any + known forms in other parts of the world. These birds were of + large size and grotesque proportions, the wings too short and + feeble for flight, the plumage loose and decomposed, and the + general aspect suggestive of gigantic immaturity. Their history + is as remarkable as their origin. About two centuries ago, + their native isles were first colonised by man, by whom these + strange creatures were speedily exterminated. So rapid and so + complete was their extinction, that the vague descriptions given + of them by early navigators were long regarded as fabulous or + exaggerated; and these birds, almost contemporaries of our + great-grandfathers, became associated in the minds of many + persons with the griffin and the phœnix of mythological + antiquity." + +The aim and object of Mr Strickland's work is to vindicate the +honesty of the rude voyagers of the seventeenth century; to collect +together the scattered evidence regarding the Dodo and its kindred; +to describe and depict the few anatomical fragments which are still +extant of those lost species; to invite scientific travellers to +further and more minute research; and to infer, from the authentic +data, now in hand, the probable rank and position of these creatures +in the scale of nature. We think he has achieved his object very +admirably, and has produced one of the best and most interesting +monographs with which it is our fortune to be acquainted. + +So far as we can see, the extension of man's more immediate +influence and agency is the sole cause of the disappearance of +species in modern times--at least we have no proof that any of these +species have perished by what can be called a catastrophe: this is +well exemplified by what we now know of the Dodo and its kindred. + +The islands of Mauritius and Bourbon were discovered in the +sixteenth century, (authorities differ as to the precise period, +which they vary from 1502 to 1545,) by Pedro Mascaregnas, a +Portuguese, who named the latter after himself; while he called +the former Cerne, a term applied by Pliny to an island in another +quarter. Of this Cerne nothing definite was ascertained till the +year 1598, when the Dutch, under Jacob Cornelius Neck, finding it +uninhabited, took possession, and changed its name to Mauritius. In +the narrative of the voyage, of which there are several accounts in +different tongues, we find the following notice:-- + + "This island, besides being very fertile in terrestrial + products, feeds vast numbers of birds, such as turtle-doves, + which occur in such plenty that three of our men sometimes + captured one hundred and fifty in half a day, and might easily + have taken more by hand, or killed them with sticks, if we + had not been overloaded with the burden of them. Grey parrots + are also common there, and other birds, besides a large kind + bigger than our swans, with large heads, half of which is + covered with skin like a hood. These birds want wings, in + place of which are three or four thickish feathers. The tail + consists of a few slender curved feathers of a gray colour. We + called them _Walckvogel_, for this reason, that, the longer + they were boiled, the tougher and more uneatable they became. + Their stomachs, however, and breasts, were easy to masticate. + Another reason for the name was that we had an abundance of + turtle-doves, of a much sweeter and more agreeable flavour."--De + Bry's _India Orientalis_, (1601,) pars v. p. 7. + +These walckvogel were the birds soon afterwards called Dodos. The +description given by Clusius, in his _Exotica_, (1605,) is chiefly +taken from one of the published accounts of Van Neck's voyage, but +he adds the following notice, as from personal observation:-- + + "After I had written down the history of this bird as well + as I could, I happened to see in the house of Peter Pauwius, + Professor of Medicine in the University of Leyden, a leg cut off + at the knee, and recently brought from the Mauritius. It was + not very long, but rather exceeded four inches from the knee + to the bend of the foot. Its thickness, however, was great, + being nearly four inches in circumference; and it was covered + with numerous scales, which in front were wider and yellow, but + smaller and dusky behind. The upper part of the toes was also + furnished with single broad scales, while the lower part was + wholly callous. The toes were rather short for so thick a leg: + the claws were all thick, hard, black, less than an inch long; + but the claw of the hind toe was longer than the rest, and + exceeded an inch." + +A Dutch navigator, Heemskerk, remained nearly three months in the +Mauritius, on his homeward voyage in 1602; and in a published +journal kept by Reyer Cornelisz, we read of _Wallichvogels_, and +a variety of other game. One of Heemskerk's captains, Willem van +West-Zanen by name, also left a journal--apparently not published +until 1648--at which time it was edited in an enlarged form by H. +Soeteboom. We there find repeated mention of _Dod-aarsen_ or Dodos; +and the sailors seem to have actually revelled in these birds, +without suffering from surfeit or nausea like Van Neck's crew. As +this tract is very rare, and has never appeared in an English form, +we shall avail ourselves of Mr Strickland's translation of a few +passages bearing on the subject in question:-- + + "The sailors went out every day to hunt for birds and other + game, such as they could find on land, while they became less + active with their nets, hooks, and other fishing-tackle. No + quadrupeds occur there except cats, though our countrymen have + subsequently introduced goats and swine. The herons were less + tame than the other birds, and were difficult to procure, + owing to their flying amongst the thick branches of the trees. + They also caught birds which some name _Dod-aarsen_, others + _Dronten_. When Jacob Van Neck was here, these birds were called + _Wallich-vogels_, because even a long boiling would scarcely + make them tender, but they remained tough and hard, with the + exception of the breast and belly, which were very good; and + also because, from the abundance of turtle-doves which the men + procured, they became disgusted with dodos. The figure of these + birds is given in the accompanying plate: they have great heads, + with hoods thereon; they are without wings or tail, and have + only little winglets on their sides, and four or five feathers + behind, more elevated than the rest; they have beaks and feet, + and commonly, in the stomach, a stone the size of a fist.... + + "The dodos, with their round sterns, (for they were well + fattened,) were also obliged to turn tail; everything that could + move was in a bustle; and the fish, which had lived in peace for + many a year, were pursued into the deepest water-pools.... + + "On the 25th July, William and his sailors brought some dodos, + which were very fat; the whole crew made an ample meal from + three or four of them, and a portion remained over.... They + sent on board smoked fish, salted dodos, land-tortoises, and + other game, which supply was very acceptable. They were busy + for some days bringing provisions to the ship. On the 4th of + August, William's men brought fifty large birds on board the + _Bruyn-Vis_; among them were twenty-four or twenty-five dodos, + so large and heavy, that they could not eat any two of them for + dinner, and all that remained over was salted. + + "Another day, Hoogeven (William's supercargo) set out from the + tent with four seamen, provided with sticks, nets, muskets, and + other necessaries for hunting. They climbed up mountain and + hill, roamed through forest and valley, and, during the three + days that they were out, they captured another half-hundred + of birds, including a matter of twenty dodos, all which they + brought on board and salted. Thus were they, and the other crews + in the fleet, occupied in fowling and fishing." + +In regard to the appellations of these birds, it is not altogether +easy to determine the precise date at which the synonymous term +_Dodars_, from which our name of Dodo is by some derived, was +introduced. It seems first to occur in the journal of Willem van +West-Zanen; but that journal, though written in 1603, appears to +have remained unpublished till 1648, and the name may have been +an interpolation by his editor, Soeteboom. Matelief's Journal, +also, which makes mention of _Dodaersen_, otherwise _Dronten_, was +written in 1606, and Van der Hagen's in 1607; but Mr Strickland has +been unable to find an edition of either work of earlier date than +1646, and so the occurrence of these words may be likewise due to +the officiousness of editors. Perhaps the earliest use of the word +Dodars may date from the publication of Verhuffen's voyage, (1613,) +where, however, it occurs under the corrupt form of _Totersten_. +There seems little doubt that the name of Dodo is derived from +the Dutch root, _Dodoor_, which signifies _sluggard_, and is +appropriate to the leisurely gait and heavy aspect of the creatures +in question. Dodars is probably a homely or familiar phrase among +Dutch sailors, and may be regarded as more expressive than elegant. +Our own Sir Thomas Herbert was the first to use the name of Dodo +in its modern form, and he tells us that it is a Portuguese word. +_Doudo_, in that language, certainly signifies "foolish," or +"simple," and might have been well applied to the unwary habits +and defenceless condition of these almost wingless and totally +inexperienced species; but, as none of the Portuguese voyagers seem +to have mentioned the Dodo by any name whatever, nor even to have +visited the Mauritius, after their first discovery of the island by +Pedro Mascaregnas already named, it appears far more probable that +Dodars is a genuine Dutch term, altered, and it may be amended, by +Sir Thomas Herbert, to suit his own philological fancies. + +The Dutch, indeed, seem to have been inspired with a genuine love +of Dodos, and never allowed even the cooing of the delicately +tender turtle-doves to prevent their laying in an ample store of +the more solid, if less sentimental species. Thus, Van der Hagen, +who commanded two ships which remained for some weeks at the +Mauritius in 1607, not only feasted his crews on great abundance of +"tortoises, _dodars_, gray parroquets, and other game," but salted +large quantities, for consumption during the voyage. Verhuffen +touched at the same island in 1611, and it is in his narrative +(published at Frankfort in 1613) that Dodos are called _Totersten_. +He describes them as having-- + + "A skin like a monk's cowl on the head, and no wings; but, in + place of them, about five or six yellow feathers: likewise, in + place of a tail, are four or five crested feathers. In colour + they are gray; men call them _Totersten_ or _Walckvögel_; + they occur there in great plenty, insomuch that the Dutch + daily caught and ate many of them. For not only these, but in + general all the birds there, are so tame that they killed the + turtle-doves, as well as the other wild pigeons and parrots, + with sticks, and caught them by the hand. They also captured the + totersten or walckvögel with their hands; but were obliged to + take good care that these birds did not bite them on the arms or + legs with their beaks, which are very strong, thick, and hooked; + for they are wont to bite desperately hard." + +We are glad to be informed, by the above, of this attempt at +independence, or something at least approaching to the defensive +system. It forms an additional title, on the part of the Dodo, to be +regarded, at all events by the Dutch _cuisiniers_, as "_une pièce de +resistance_." + +Sir Thomas Herbert, already named, visited the Mauritius in 1627, +and found it still uninhabited by man. In his _Relation of some +yeares' Travaile_, which, for the amusement of his later years, he +seems to have repeatedly rewritten for various editions, extending +from 1634 to 1677, he both figures and describes our fat friend. His +narration is as follows:-- + + "The dodo, a bird the Dutch call walckvögel or dod-eersen: + her body is round and fat, which occasions the slow pace, or + that her corpulencie; and so great as few of them weigh less + than fifty pound; meat it is with some, but better to the eye + than stomach, such as only a strong appetite can vanquish; but + otherwise, through its oyliness, it cannot chuse but quickly + cloy and nauseate the stomach, being indeed more pleasurable to + look than feed upon. It is of a melancholy visage, as sensible + of nature's injury in framing so massie a body to be directed + by complimental wings, such indeed as are unable to hoise her + from the ground, serving only to rank her amongst birds. Her + head is variously drest; for one half is hooded with down of a + dark colour, the other half naked, and of a white hue, as if + lawn were drawn over it; her bill hooks and bends downwards; the + thrill or breathing-place is in the midst, from which part to + the end the colour is of a light green, mixt with pale yellow; + her eyes are round and bright, and instead of feathers has a + most fine down; her train (like to a China beard) is no more + than three or four short feathers; her leggs are thick and + black; her talons great; her stomach fiery, so that as she can + easily digest stones; in that and shape not a little resembling + the ostrich."--(P. 383.) + +François Cauche, an account of whose voyage, made in 1638, is +published in the _Relations Véritables et Curieuses de l'Isle de +Madagascar_, (Paris, 1651) states that he saw in the Mauritius birds +called Oiseaux de Nazaret, larger than a swan, covered with black +down, with crested feathers on the rump, "as many in number as the +bird is years old." In place of wings there are some black curved +feathers, without webs. The cry is like that of a gosling. + + "They only lay one egg, which is white, the _size of a halfpenny + roll_; by the side of which they place a white stone, of the + dimensions of a hen's egg. They lay on grass, which they + collect, and make their nests in the forests; if one kills the + young one, a gray stone is found in the gizzard. We call them + Oiseaux de Nazaret. The fat is excellent to give ease to the + muscles and nerves." + +Here let us pause a moment, to consider what was the probable size +of a halfpenny roll in the year 1638. How many vast and various +elements must be taken to account in calculating the dimensions +of that "_pain d'un sol!_" Macculloch, Cobden, Joseph Hume, come +over and help us in this our hour of _knead_! Was corn high or +low? were wages up or down? were bakers honest or dishonest? was +there a fixed measure of quantity for these our matutinal baps? Did +town-councils regulate their weight and quality, or was conscience +left controller, from the quartern loaf downwards to the smallest +form assumed by yeast and flour? + + "Tell me where was fancy bread?" + +Does no one know precisely what was the size of a halfpenny roll in +the year 1638? In that case, we shall not mention the dimensions of +the Dodo's egg. + +There is no doubt that the bird recorded by Cauche was the true +Dodo, although it is probable that he either described it from +memory, or confused it with the descriptions then current of the +cassowary. Thus he adds that the legs were of considerable length, +that it had only three toes, and no tongue--characters (with the +exception of the last, inapplicable, of course, to either kind) +which truly indicate the latter species. This name of "bird of +Nazareth" has, moreover, given rise to a false or phantom species, +called _Didus Nazarenus_ in systematic works, and is supposed to +have been derived from the small island or sandbank of Nazareth, to +the north-east of Madagascar. Now Dr Hamel has recently rendered it +probable that no such island or sandbank is in existence, and so we +need not seek for its inhabitants: at all events, there is no such +bird as the Nazarene Dodo--_Didus Nazarenus_. + +The next piece of evidence regarding the Dodo is highly interesting +and important, as it shows that, at least in one instance, this +extraordinary bird was transported alive to Europe, and exhibited in +our own country. In a manuscript preserved in the British Museum, +Sir Hamon Lestrange, the father of the more celebrated Sir Roger, +in a commentary on Brown's _Vulgar Errors_, and _apropos_ of the +ostrich, records as follows:-- + + "About 1638, as I walked London streets, I saw the picture of a + strange fowle hong out upon a cloth, and myselfe, with one or + two more then in company, went in to see it. It was kept in a + chamber, and was a great fowle somewhat bigger than the largest + turkey-cock, and so legged and footed, but stouter and thicker, + and of a more erect shape; coloured before like the breast of a + young cock fesan, and, on the back, of dunn or deare coulour. + The keeper called it a Dodo; and in the end of a chimney in + the chamber there lay a heape of large pebble stones, whereof + hee gave it many in our sight, some as bigg as nutmegs, and + the keeper told us she eats them, (conducing to digestion); + and though I remember not how farr the keeper was questioned + therein, yet I am confident that afterwards shee cast them all + againe." + +It is curious that no confirmation can be obtained of this +exhibition from contemporary authorities. The period was prolific +in pamphlets and broadsides, but political excitement probably +engrossed the minds of the majority, and rendered them careless +of the wonders of nature. Yet the individual in question may in +all likelihood be traced down to the present day, and portions of +it seen and handled by the existing generation. In Tradescant's +catalogue of his "_Collection of Rarities preserved at South +Lambeth, near London_," 1656, we find an entry--"Dodar from the +island Mauritius; it is not able to flie, being so big." It is +enumerated under the head of "Whole birds;" and Willughby, whose +_Ornithologia_ appeared in 1676, says of the Dodo, "Exuvias hujusce +avis vidimus in museo Tradescantiano." The same specimen is +alluded to by Llhwyd in 1684, and by Hyde in 1700,--having passed, +meanwhile, into the Ashmolean Museum, at Oxford, with the rest of +the Tradescantian collection. As Tradescant was the most noted +collector of things natural in his day, and there were few, if +any, to enter into competition with him, it may be well supposed +that such a _rara avis_ as a living Dodo would attract his close +attention, and that it would, in all probability, find its way into +his cabinet on its decease. It may, therefore, be inferred that the +same individual which was exhibited in London, and described by +Lestrange in 1638, is that recorded as a stuffed specimen in the +catalogue of Tradescant's Museum, (1656,) and bequeathed by him, +with his other curiosities, to Elias Ashmole, the munificent founder +of the still existing museum at Oxford. + +The considerate reader will not unnaturally ask, Where is now that +last of Dodos? and echo answers, Where? Alas! it was destroyed, "by +order of the Visitors," in 1755. The following is the evidence of +that destruction, as given by Mr J. S. Duncan in the 3d volume of +the _Zoological Journal_, p. 559:-- + + "In the Ashmolean Catalogue, made by Ed. Llhwyd, musei + procustos, 1684, (Plott being then keeper,) the entry of the + bird is 'No. 29, Gallus gallinaceus peregrinus Clusii,' &c. In a + catalogue made subsequently to 1755, it is stated, 'The numbers + from 5 to 46, being decayed, were ordered to be removed at a + meeting of the majority of the Visitors, Jan. 8, 1755.' Among + these, of course, was included the Dodo, its number being 29. + This is further shown by a new catalogue, completed in 1756, in + which the order of the Visitors is recorded as follows:--'Illa + quibus nullus in margine assignatur numerus, a Musæo subducta + sunt cimelia, annuentibus Vice-Cancellario aliisque Curatoribus + ad ea lustranda convocatis, die Januarii 8vo, A.D. 1755.' The + Dodo is one of those which are here without the number." + +By some lucky accident, however, a small portion of "this last +descendant of an ancient race," as Mr Strickland terms it, escaped +the clutches of the destroyers. "The head and one of the feet were +saved from the flames, and are still preserved in the Ashmolean +Museum."[20] + + [20] The scientific value of these remnants, Mr Strickland informs + us, has been lately much increased by skilful dissection. Dr Acland, + the lecturer in anatomy, has divided the skin of the cranium down + the mesial line, and, by removing it from the left side, the entire + osteological structure of this extraordinary skull is exposed + to view, while on the other side the external covering remains + undisturbed. The solitary foot was formerly covered by decomposed + integuments, and presented few external characters. These have + been removed by Dr Kidd, the professor of medicine, who has made + an interesting preparation of both the osseous and tendinous + structures.--See _The Dodo and its Kindred_, p. 33. + +Let us now retrace our steps, for the sake of taking up, very +briefly, the history of the other known remnants of this now +extinct species. Among the printed books of the Ashmolean Museum, +there is a small tract, of which the second edition (the first is +without date) is entitled, "A Catalogue of many natural rarities, +with great industry, cost, and thirty years' travel in foreign +countries, collected by Robert Hubert, _alias_ Forges, gent. and +sworn servant to his majesty; and daily to be seen at the place +formerly called the Music House, near the west end of St Paul's +Church," 12mo, London, 1665. At page 11 is the following entry:--"A +legge of a Dodo, a great heavy bird that cannot fly: it is a bird +of the Maurcius island." This specimen is supposed to be that which +afterwards passed into the possession of the Royal Society, is +recorded in their catalogue of _Natural and Artificial Curiosities_, +published by Grew in 1681, and is now in the British Museum. It is +somewhat larger than the Ashmolean foot, and, from its excellent +state of preservation, finely exhibits the external characters of +the toes and tarsus. + +In Olearus's catalogue of the museum at Gottorf, (the seat of the +Dukes of Schleswig, and recently a less easy one than we have known +it,) of which the first edition was published in 1666, there is the +following notice of a Dodo's head:-- + + "No. 5 is the head of a foreign bird, which Clusius names + _Gallus peregrinus_, Mirenberg _Cygnus cucullatus_, and the + Dutch walghvögel, from the disgust which they are said to have + taken to its hard flesh. The Dutch seem to have first discovered + this bird in the island of Mauritius; and it is stated to have + no wings, but in place of them two winglets, like the emeu and + the penguins."--(P. 25.) + +This specimen, after having been disregarded, if not forgotten, +for nearly two centuries, was lately re-discovered, by Professor +C. Reinhardt, amongst a mass of ancient rubbish, and is now in the +public museum of Copenhagen, where it was examined by Mr Strickland +two years ago.[21] The integumentary portions have been all removed, +but it exhibits the same osteological characters as the Oxford head, +though less perfect, the base of the occiput being absent. It is of +somewhat smaller size. + + [21] The collection of the Dukes of Schleswig was removed about the + year 1720, by Frederic IV., from Gottorf to Copenhagen, where it + is now incorporated with the Royal "Kunstkammer" of that northern + capital. + +The remnants now noticed--three heads and two feet--are the only +ascertained existing portions of the famous Dodo; a bird which, +as we have seen in the preceding extracts, might have been well +enough known to such of our great great-grandfathers as were in the +sea-faring line. + +But when did the last Dodo die? We cannot answer that question +articulately, as to the very year, still less as to the season, or +time of day--and we believe that no intimations of the event were +sent to the kindred; but we do not hesitate to state our belief +that that affecting occurrence or bereavement took place some time +subsequent to the summer of 1681, and prior to 1693. The latest +evidence of the existence of Dodos in the Mauritius is contained +in a manuscript of the British Museum, entitled "A coppey of Mr +Benj. Harry's Journall when he was chief mate of the Shippe Berkley +Castle, Captn. Wm. Talbot commander, on voyage to the Coste and Bay, +1679, which voyage they wintered at the Maurrisshes." On the return +from India, being unable to weather the Cape of Good Hope, they +determined to make for "the Marushes," the 4th June 1681. They saw +the land on the 3d July, and on the 11th they began to build huts, +and with much labour spread out their cargo to dry:-- + + "Now, having a little respitt, I will make a little description + of the island, first of its producks, then of its parts; ffirst, + of winged and feathered ffowle, the less passant are _Dodos, + whose fflesh is very hard_, a small sort of Gees, reasonably + good Teele, Cuckoes, Pasca fflemingos, Turtle Doves, large + Batts, many small birds which are good.... Heer are many wild + hoggs and land-turtle which are very good, other small creators + on the Land, as Scorpions and Musketoes, these in small numbers, + Batts and ffleys a multitude, Munkeys of various sorts." + +After this all historical evidence of the existence of the Dodo +ceases, although we cannot doubt that they continued for yet a +few years. The Dutch first colonised the Mauritius in 1644. The +island is not above forty miles in length; and although, when first +discovered, it was found clothed with dense forests of palms, and +various other trees--among whose columnar stems and leafy umbrage +the native creatures might find a safe abode, with food and +shelter--how speedily would not the improvident rapacity of hungry +colonists, or of reckless fresh-flesh-bereaved mariners, diminish +the numbers of a large and heavy-bodied bird, of powerless wing +and slow of foot, and useful, moreover, in the way of culinary +consumption. Mr Strickland is of opinion that their destruction +would be further hastened, or might be mainly caused, by the dogs, +cats, and swine which accompany man in his migrations, and become +themselves emancipated in the forests. All these creatures are more +or less carnivorous, and are fond of eggs and young birds; and as +the Dodo is said to have hatched only one egg at a time, a single +savage mouthful might suffice to destroy the hope of a family for +many a day. + +That the destruction of Dodos was completed by 1693, Mr Strickland +thinks may be inferred from the narrative of Leguat, who, in +that year, remained several months in the Mauritius, and, while +enumerating its animal productions at considerable length, makes no +mention whatever of the bird in question. He adds,--"L'isle était +autrefois toute remplie d'oyes et de canards sauvages; de poules +d'eau, de gelinottes, de tortues de mer et de terre, _mais tout cela +est devenue fort rare_." And, while referring to the "hogs of the +China kind," he states that these beasts do a great deal of damage, +by devouring all the young animals they can catch. It is thus +sufficiently evident that civilisation was making aggressive inroads +on the natural state of the Mauritius even in 1693. + +The Dutch evacuated the island in 1712, and were succeeded by the +French, who colonised it under the name of Isle de France; and this +change in the population no doubt accounts for the almost entire +absence of any traditionary knowledge of this remarkable bird among +the later inhabitants. Baron Grant lived in the Mauritius for twenty +years from 1740; and his son, who compiled his papers into a history +of the island, states that no trace of such a bird was to be found +at that time. In the _Observations sur la Physique_ for the year +1778, there is a negative notice, by M. Morel, of the Dodo and its +kindred. "Ces oiseaux, si bien décrits dans le tome 2 de l'Histoire +des Oiseaux de M. le Comte de Buffon, n'ont jamais été vus aux Isles +de France, &c., depuis plus de 60 ans que ces parages sont habités +et visités par des colonies Françoises. Les plus anciens habitans +assurent tous que ces oiseaux monstrueux leur ont toujours été +inconnus." M. Bory St Vincent, who visited the Mauritius and Bourbon +in 1801, and has given us an account of the physical features of +those islands in his "Voyage," assures us (vol. ii. p. 306) that he +instituted all possible inquiries regarding the Dodo (or Dronte) and +its kindred, without being able to pick up the slightest information +on the subject; and although he advertised "une grande recompense a +qui pourrait lui donner la moindre indice de l'ancienne existence +de cet oiseau, un silence universel a prouvé que le souvenir même +du Dronte était perdu parmi les créoles." De Blainville informs us, +(_Nouv. Ann. Mus._ iv. 31,) that the subject was discussed at a +public dinner at the Mauritius in 1816, where were present several +persons from seventy to ninety years of age, none of whom had any +knowledge of any Dodo, either from recollection or tradition. +Finally, Mr J. V. Thompson, who resided for some years in Mauritius +prior to 1816, states, (_Mag. of Nat. Hist._, ii. 443,) that no more +traces could then be found of the Dodo than of the truth of the tale +of Paul and Virginia. + +But the historical evidence already adduced, as to the former +existence of this bird, is confirmed in a very interesting manner +by what may be called the pictorial proof. Besides the rude +delineations given by the earlier voyagers, there are several old +oil-paintings of the Dodo still extant, by skilful artists, who had +no other object in view than to represent with accuracy the forms +before them. These paintings are five in number, whereof one is +anonymous; three bear the name of Roland Savery, an eminent Dutch +animal-painter of the early portion of the seventeenth century, and +one is by John Savery, Roland's nephew. + +The first of these is the best known, and is that from which the +figure of the Dodo, in all modern compilations of ornithology, +has been copied. It once belonged to George Edwards, who, in his +work on birds, (vi. 294,) tells us, that "the original picture was +drawn in Holland _from the living bird_, brought from St Maurice's +island in the East Indies, in the early times of the discovery of +the Indies by the way of the Cape of Good Hope. It was the property +of the late Sir H. Sloane to the time of his death, and afterwards +becoming my property. I deposited it in the British Museum as a +great curiosity. The above history of the picture I had from Sir H. +Sloane, and the late Dr Mortimer, secretary to the Royal Society." +It is still preserved in the place to which Edwards had consigned +it, and may be seen in the bird gallery, along with the actual foot +already mentioned. Although without name or date, the similarity +both of design and execution, leads to the conclusion that it was by +one or other of the Saverys. It may be seen engraved in the _Penny +Cyclopædia_, in illustration of Mr Broderip's article _Dodo_ in that +work. + +The second painting, one of Roland Savery's, is in the royal +collection at the Hague, and may be regarded as a _chef-d'œuvre_. +It represents Orpheus charming the creation, and we there behold the +Dodo spell-bound with his other mute companions. All the ordinary +creatures there shown are depicted with the greatest truthfulness; +and why should the artist, delighting, as he seems to have done, in +tracing the most delicate features of familiar nature, have marred +the beautiful consistency of his design by introducing a feigned, +or even an exaggerated representation? We may here adduce the +invaluable evidence of Professor Owen. + + "While at the Hague, in the summer of 1838, I was much struck + with the minuteness and accuracy with which the exotic species + of animals had been painted by Savery and Breughel, in such + subjects as Orpheus charming the Beasts, &c., in which scope + was allowed for grouping together a great variety of animals. + Understanding that the celebrated menagerie of Prince Maurice + had afforded the living models to these artists, I sat down + one day before Savery's Orpheus and the Beasts, to make a list + of the species, which the picture sufficiently evinced that + the artist had had the opportunity to study alive. Judge of my + surprise and pleasure in detecting, in a dark corner of the + picture, (which is badly hung between two windows,) the _Dodo_, + beautifully finished, showing for example, though but three + inches long, the auricular circle of feathers, the scutation + of the tarsi, and the loose structure of the caudal plumes. In + the number and proportions of the toes, and in general form, it + accords with Edwards' oil-painting in the British Museum; and I + conclude that the miniature must have been copied from the study + of a living bird, which, it is most probable, formed part of + the Mauritian menagerie. The bird is standing in profile with a + lizard at its feet."--_Penny Cyclopædia_, xxiii. p. 143. + +Mr Strickland, in 1845, made a search through the Royal Gallery of +Berlin, which was known to contain several of Savery's pictures. +Among them, we are happy to say that he found one representing +the Dodo, with numerous other animals, "in Paradise!" It was very +conformable with the figure last mentioned; but what renders this, +our third portrait, of peculiar interest, is, that it affords +a date--the words "Roelandt Savery fe. 1626," being inscribed +on one corner. As the artist was born in 1576, he must have +been twenty-three years old when Van Neck's expedition returned +to Holland; and as we are told by De Bry, in reference to the +Mauritius, that "aliæ ibidem aves visæ sunt, quas walkvogel Batavi +nominarunt, et _unam secum in Hollandiam importarunt_," it is quite +possible that the portrait of this individual may have been taken at +the time, and afterwards recopied, both by himself and his nephew, +in their later pictures. Professor Owen leans to the belief that +Prince Maurice's collection afforded the living prototype,--an +opinion so far strengthened by Edwards's tradition, that the +painting in the British Museum was drawn in Holland from a "living +bird." Either view is preferable to Dr Hamel's suggestion, that +Savery's representation was taken from the Dodo exhibited in London, +as that individual was seen alive by Sir Hamon Lestrange in 1638, +and must therefore (by no means a likely occurrence) have lived, in +the event supposed, at least twelve years in captivity. + +Very recently Dr J. J. de Tchudi, the well-known Peruvian traveller, +transmitted to Mr Strickland an exact copy of another figure of +the Dodo, which forms part of a picture in the imperial collection +of the Belvedere at Vienna--by no means a safe location, in these +tempestuous times, for the treasures of either art or nature. But we +trust that Prince Windischgratz and the hanging committee will now +see that all is right, and that General Bem has not been allowed to +carry off this drawing of the Dodo in his carpet-bag. It is dated +1628. + + "There are two circumstances," says Mr Strickland, "which give + an especial interest to this painting. First, the novelty of + attitude in the Dodo, exhibiting an activity of character which + corroborates the supposition that the artist had living model + before him, and contrasting strongly with the aspect of passive + stolidity in the other pictures. And, secondly, the Dodo is + represented as watching, apparently with hungry looks, the + merry wriggling of an eel in the water! Are we hence to infer + that the Dodo fed upon eels? The advocates of the Raptorial + affinities of the Dodo, of whom we shall soon speak, will + doubtless reply in the affirmative; but, as I hope shortly + to demonstrate that it belongs to a family of birds all the + other members of which are frugivorous, I can only regard the + introduction of the eel as a pictorial license. In this, as + in all his other paintings, Savery brought into juxtaposition + animals from all countries, without regarding geographical + distribution. His delineations of birds and beasts were + wonderfully exact, but his knowledge of natural history probably + went no further; and although the Dodo is certainly _looking at_ + the eel, yet we have no proof that he is going to _eat_ it. The + mere collocation of animals in an artistic composition, cannot + be accepted as evidence against the positive truths revealed by + comparative anatomy."--(P. 30.) + +The fifth and last old painting of the Dodo, is that now in the +Ashmolean Museum at Oxford, and presented to it by Mr Darby in 1813. +Nothing is known of its previous history. It is the work of John +Savery, the nephew of Roland, and is dated 1651. Its most peculiar +character is the colossal scale on which it has been designed,--the +Dodo of this canvass standing about three feet and a half in height. + + "It is difficult," observes our author, "to assign a motive to + the artist for thus magnifying an object already sufficiently + uncouth in appearance. Were it not for the discrepancy of + dates, I should have conjectured that this was the identical + "picture of a strange fowle hong out upon a cloth," which + attracted the notice of Sir Hamon Lestrange and his friends, as + they "walked London streets" in 1638; the delineations used by + showmen being in general more remarkable for attractiveness than + veracity."--(P. 31.) + +We have now exhibited the leading facts which establish both the +existence and extinction of this extraordinary bird: the existence, +proved by the recorded testimony of the earlier navigators, the few +but peculiar portions of structure which still remain among us, and +the _vera effigies_ handed down by artists coeval with the period in +which the Dodo lived: the non-existence, deduced from the general +progress of events, and the absence of all knowledge of the species +since the close of the seventeenth century, although the natural +productions of the Mauritius are, in other respects, much better +known to us now than then. Why any particular creature should have +been so formed as to be unable to resist the progress of _humanity_, +and should in consequence have died, it is not for us to say. "There +are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in our +philosophy;" and of this we may feel assured, that if, as we doubt +not, the Dodo is extinct, then it has served its end, whatever that +might be. + +There is nothing imperfect in the productions of nature, although +there are many organisms in which certain forms and faculties are +less developed than in others. There are certainly, in particular +groups, such things as rudimentary organs, which belong, as it were, +not so much to the individual species, as to the general system +which prevails in the larger and more comprehensive class to which +such species belong; and in the majority of which these organs +fulfil a frequent and obvious function, and so are very properly +regarded as indispensable to the wellbeing of such as use them. +But there are many examples in animal life which indicate that +particular parts of structure remain, in certain species, for ever +in an undeveloped state. In respect to teeth, for instance, the +Greenland whale may be regarded as a _permanent suckling_; for that +huge creature having no occasion for these organs, they never pierce +the gums, although in early life they are distinctly traceable in +the dental groove of the jaws. So the Dodo was a kind of _permanent +nestling_, covered with down instead of feathers, and with wings +and tail (the oars and rudder of all aërial voyagers) so short and +feeble as to be altogether inefficient for the purposes of flight. +Why should such things be? We cannot say. Can any one say why they +should not be? The question is both wide and deep, and they are +most likely to plunge into it who can neither dive nor swim. We +agree with Mr Strickland, that these apparently anomalous facts +are, in reality, indications of laws which the great Creator has +been pleased to form and follow in the construction of organised +beings,--inscriptions in an unknown hieroglyphic, which we may rest +assured must have a meaning, but of which we have as yet scarcely +learned the alphabet. "There appear, however, reasonable grounds for +believing that the Creator has assigned to each class of animals a +definite type or structure, from which He has never departed, even +in the most exceptional or eccentric modifications of form." + +As to the true position of the Dodo in systematic ornithology, +various opinions have been emitted by various men. The majority seem +to have placed it in the great Rasorial or Gallinaceous order, as a +component part of the family _Struthionidæ_, or ostrich tribe. + + "The bird in question," says Mr Vigors, "from every account + which we have of its economy, and from the appearance of + its head and foot, is decidedly gallinaceous; and, from the + insufficiency of its wings for the purposes of flight, it may + with equal certainty be pronounced to be of the _Struthious_ + structure. But the foot has a strong hind-toe, and, with the + exception of its being more robust, in which character it still + adheres to the Struthionidæ, it corresponds to the Linnæan genus + _Crax_, that commences the succeeding family. The bird thus + becomes osculant, and forms a strong point of junction between + those two contiguous groups."--_Linn. Trans._ xiv. 484. + +M. de Blainville (in _Nouv. Ann. du Mus._ iv. 24,) contests this +opinion by various arguments, which we cannot here report, and +concludes that the Dodo is a raptorial bird, allied to the vultures. +Mr Broderip, in his article before referred to, sums up the +discussion as follows:-- + + "If the picture in the British Museum, and the cut in Bontius, + be faithful representations of a creature then living, to make + such a bird of prey--a vulture, in the ordinary acceptation + of the term--would be to set all the usual laws of adaptation + at defiance. A vulture without wings! How was it to be fed? + And not only without wings, but necessarily slow and heavy in + progression on its clumsy feet. The _Vulturidæ_ are, as we + know, among the most active agents for removing the decomposing + animal remains in tropical and inter-tropical climates, and they + are provided with a prodigal development of wing, to waft them + speedily to the spot tainted by the corrupt incumbrance. But no + such powers of wing would be required by a bird appointed to + clear away the decaying and decomposing masses of a luxuriant + tropical vegetation--a kind of vulture for vegetable impurities, + so to speak--and such an office would not be by any means + inconsistent with comparative slowness of pedestrian motion." + +Professor Owen, doubtless one of our greatest authorities, inclines +towards an affinity with the vultures, and considers the Dodo as an +extremely modified form of the raptorial order. + + "Devoid of the power of flight, it could have had small chance + of obtaining food by preying upon the members of its own class; + and, if it did not exclusively subsist on dead and decaying + organised matter, it most probably restricted its attacks to + the class of reptiles, and to the littoral fishes, _Crustacea_, + &c., which its well-developed back-toe and claw would enable it + to seize, and hold with a firm gripe."--_Transactions of the + Zoological Society_, iii. p. 331. + +We confess that, setting aside various other unconformable features +in the structure of the Dodo, the fact, testified by various +authorities, of its swallowing stones, and having stones in its +gizzard, for the mechanical triturition of its food, (a peculiarity +unknown among the raptorial order,) is sufficient to bar the +above view, supported though it be by the opinion of our most +distinguished living anatomist. + +In a recent memoir by Professor J. F. Brandt (of which an abstract +is given in the _Bulletin de la Class. Phys. de l'Acad. Imp. de St +Petersburg_, vol. viii. No. 3) we have the following statement:-- + + "The Dodo, a bird provided with divided toes and cursorial feet, + is best classed in the order of the Waders, among which it + appears, from its many peculiarities, (most of which, however, + are quite referable to forms in this order,) to be an anomalous + link connecting several groups,--a link which, for the reasons + above given, inclines towards the ostriches, and especially also + towards the pigeons." + +We doubt the direct affinity to any species of the grallatorial +order, an order which contains the cursorial or swift-running birds, +very dissimilar in their prevailing habits to anything we know of +the sluggish and sedentary Dodo. Professor Brandt may be regarded +as having mistaken analogy for affinity; and, in Mr Strickland's +opinion, he has in this instance wandered from the true method +of investigation, in his anxiety to discover a link connecting +dissevered groups. + +What then is, or rather was, the Dodo? The majority of inquirers +have no doubt been influenced, though unconsciously, by its colossal +size, and have consequently sought its actual analogies only among +such huge species as the ostrich, the vulture, and the albatross. +But the range in each order is often enormous, as, for example, +between the _Falco cærulescens_, or finch falcon of Bengal, an +accipitrine bird not bigger than a sparrow, and an eagle of the +largest size; or between the swallow-like stormy petrel and the +gigantic pelican of the wilderness. It appears that Professor J. +T. Rheinhardt of Copenhagen, who rediscovered the cranium of the +Gottorf Museum, was the first to indicate the direct relationship of +the Dodo to the _pigeons_. He has recently been engaged in a voyage +round the world, but it is known that, before he left Copenhagen in +1845, he had called the attention of his correspondents, both in +Sweden and Denmark, to "the striking affinity which exists between +this extinct bird and the pigeons, especially the Trerons." The +Columbine view is that taken up, and so admirably illustrated, by +Mr Strickland, the most recent as well as the best biographer of +the Dodo. He refers to the great strength and curvature of bill +exhibited by several groups of the tropical fruit-eating pigeons, +and adds: + + "If we now regard the Dodo as an extreme modification, not of + the vultures, but of those vulture-like frugivorous pigeons, + we shall, I think, class it in a group whose characters are + far more consistent with what we know of its structure and + habits. There is no _a priori_ reason why a pigeon should not + be so modified, in conformity with external circumstances, + as to be incapable of flight, just as we see a grallatorial + bird modified into an ostrich, and a diver into a penguin. Now + we are told that Mauritius, an island forty miles in length, + and about one hundred miles from the nearest land, was, when + discovered, clothed with dense forests of palms and various + other trees. A bird adapted to feed on the fruits produced by + these forests would, in that equable climate, have no occasion + to migrate to distant lands; it would revel in the perpetual + luxuries of tropical vegetation, and would have but little need + of locomotion. Why then should it have the means of flying? Such + a bird might wander from tree to tree, tearing with its powerful + beak the fruits which strewed the ground, and digesting their + stony kernels with its powerful gizzard, enjoying tranquillity + and abundance, until the arrival of man destroyed the balance + of animal life, and put a term to its existence. Such, in my + opinion, was the Dodo,--a colossal, brevipennate, frugivorous + pigeon."--(P. 40.) + +For the various osteological and other details by which the +Columbine character of the Dodo is maintained, and as we think +established, we must refer our readers to Mr Strickland's +volume,[22] where those parts of the subject are very skilfully +worked out by his able coadjutor, Dr Melville. + + [22] In regard to the figures by which it is illustrated, we beg + to call attention very specially to Plates VIII. and IX., as the + most beautiful examples of the lithographic art, applied to natural + history, which we have yet seen executed in this country. + +We shall now proceed to notice certain other extinct species +which form the dead relations of the Dodo, just as the pigeons +continue to represent the tribe from which they have departed. The +island Rodriguez, placed about three hundred miles eastward of the +Mauritius, though not more than fifteen miles long by six broad, +possessed in modern times a peculiar bird, also without effective +wings, and in several other respects resembling the Dodo. It was +named _Solitaire_ by the early voyagers, and forms the species +_Didus solitarius_ of systematic writers. The small island in +question seems to have remained in a desert and unpeopled state +until 1691, when a party of French Protestant refugees settled +upon it, and remained for a couple of years. The Solitaire is thus +described by their commander, Francois Leguat, who (in his _Voyage +et Avantures_, 1708) has given us an interesting account both of +his own doings in general, and of this species in particular. + + "Of all the birds in the island, the most remarkable is that + which goes by the name of the _Solitary_, because it is very + seldom seen in company, though there are abundance of them. The + feathers of the male are of a brown-gray colour, the feet and + beak are like a turkey's, but a little more crooked. They have + scarce any tail, but their hind part, covered with feathers, + is roundish like the crupper of a horse: they are taller + than turkeys; their neck is straight, and a little longer in + proportion than a turkey's, when it lifts up its head. Its eye + is black and lively, and its head without comb or cap. They + never fly; their wings are too little to support the weight of + their bodies; they serve only to beat themselves, and to flutter + when they call one another. They will whirl about for twenty or + thirty times together on the same side, during the space of four + or five minutes. The motion of their wings makes then a noise + very much like that of a rattle, and one may hear it two hundred + paces off. The bone of their wing grows greater towards the + extremity, and forms a little round mass under the feathers, as + big as a musket-ball. That and its beak are the chief defence of + this bird. 'Tis very hard to catch it in the woods, but easier + in open places, because we run faster than they, and sometimes + we approach them without much trouble. From March to September + they are extremely fat, and taste admirably well, especially + while they are young; some of the males weigh forty-five pounds. + + "The females" continues our enamoured author, "are wonderfully + beautiful, some fair, some brown,--I call them fair, because + they are of the colour of fair hair. They have a sort of peak + like a widow's upon their beak, which is of a dun colour. No + one feather is straggling from the other all over their bodies, + they being very careful to adjust themselves, and make them all + even with their beaks. The feathers on their thighs are round + like shells at the end, and, being there very thick, have an + agreeable effect. They have two risings on their crops, and the + feathers are whiter there than the rest, which lively represents + the fair neck of a beautiful woman. They walk with so much + stateliness and good grace, that one cannot help admiring and + loving them; by which means their fine mien often saves their + lives. Though these birds will sometimes very familiarly come + up near enough to one, when we do not run after them, yet they + will never grow tame. As soon as they are caught they shed + tears without crying, and refuse all manner of meat till they + die."--(P. 71.) + +Their natural food is the fruit of a species of plantain. When these +birds are about to build, they select a clean place, and then gather +together a quantity of palm-leaves, which they heap up about a foot +and a half high, and there they sit. They never lay but one egg, +which greatly exceeds that of a goose. Some days after the young +one has left the nest, a company of thirty or forty grown-up birds +brings another young one to it; and the new-fledged bird, with its +father and mother, joining with the band, they all march away to +some by-place. + + "We frequently followed them," says Leguat, "and found that + afterwards the old ones went each their way alone, or in + couples, and left the two young ones together, and this we + called a _marriage_. This particularity has something in it + which looks a little fabulous; nevertheless what I say is + sincere truth, and what I have more than once observed with care + and pleasure." + +Leguat gives a figure of this singular bird, which in his plate has +somewhat of the air and aspect of a Christmas goose, although, of +course, it wants the web-feet. Its neck and legs are proportionally +longer than those parts of the Dodo, and give it more of a +_struthious_ appearance: but the existing osteological evidence is +sufficient to show that it was closely allied to that bird, and +shared with it in some peculiar affinities to the pigeon tribe. It +is curious that, although Rodriguez is a British settlement, we +have scarcely any information regarding it beyond what is to be +found in the work last quoted, and all that we have since learned +of the Solitary is that it has become extinct. Of late years Mr +Telfair made inquiries of one of the colonists, who assured him +that no such bird now existed on the island; and the same negative +result was obtained by Mr Higgins, a Liverpool gentleman, who, after +suffering shipwreck on Rodriguez, resided there for a couple of +months. As far back as 1789, some bones incrusted by a stalagmite, +and erroneously supposed to belong to the Dodo, were found in a cave +in Rodriguez by a M. Labistour. They afterwards found their way to +Paris, where they may still be seen. We are informed (_Proceedings +of the Zoological Society_, Part I. p. 31) that Col. Dawkins +recently visited these caverns, and dug without finding any thing +but a small bone. But M. Eudes succeeded in disinterring various +bones, among others those of a large species of bird no longer found +alive upon the island. He adds that the Dutch, who first landed at +Rodriguez, left cats there to destroy the rats, which annoyed them. +These cats are now so numerous as to prove very destructive to the +poultry, and he thinks it probable that these feline wanderers +may have extirpated the bird in question, by devouring the young +ones as soon as they were hatched,--a destruction which may have +been effected even before the island became inhabited by the human +race. Be that as it may, Mr Telfair sent collections of the bones +to this country, one of which may be seen in the museum of the +Andersonian Institution, Glasgow. Mr Strickland mourns over the loss +or disappearance of those transmitted to the Zoological Society +of London. We have been informed within these few days that, like +the head of the Danish Dodo, they have been rediscovered, lying +in a stable or other outhouse, in the vicinity of the museum of +that Society. Both the Glasgow specimens, and those in Paris, have +been carefully examined and compared by Mr Strickland, and their +Columbine characters are minutely described by his skilful and +accurate coadjutor, Dr Melville, in the second portion of his work. +Mr S. very properly regards certain peculiarities, alluded to by +Leguat, such as the feeding on dates or plantains, as confirmatory +of his view of the natural affinities already mentioned. + +So much for the Solitaire of Rodriguez and its affinities.[23] +A singular fact, however, remains to be yet attended to in this +insular group. The volcanic island of Bourbon seems also to have +contained _brevi-pennate_ birds, whose inability to fly has likewise +led to their extinction. This island, which lies about a hundred +miles south-west of Mauritius, was discovered contemporaneously by +Pedro de Mascaregnas, in the sixteenth century. The earliest notice +which concerns our present inquiry, is by Captain Castleton, who +visited Bourbon in 1613. In the narrative, as given by Purchas, we +read as follows:-- + + "There is store of land-fowl, both small and great, plentie of + doves, great parrats, and suchlike, and a great fowl of the + bignesse of a turkie, very fat, and so short-winged that they + cannot flie, beeing white, and in a manner tame; and so are all + other fowles, as having not been troubled nor feared with shot. + Our men did beat them down with sticks and stones."--(Ed. 1625, + vol. i. p. 331.) + + [23] The companions of Vasco de Gama had, at an earlier period, + applied the name of _Solitaires_ to certain birds found in an + island near the Cape of Good Hope; but these must not be confounded + with those of the Didine group above referred to. They were, in + fact, penguins, and their wings were somewhat vaguely compared + to those of bats, by reason of the peculiar scaly or undeveloped + state of the feathers in these birds. Dr Hamel has shown that the + term _Solitaires_, as employed by the Portuguese sailors, was a + corruption of _sotilicairos_, an alleged Hottentot word, of which + we do not profess to know the meaning, being rather rusted in that + tongue. We know, however, that penguins are particularly gregarious, + and, therefore, by no means solitary, although they may be extremely + _sotilicairious_ for anything we can say to the contrary. + +Bontekoe van Hoorn, a Dutch voyager, spent twenty-one days in +Bourbon in 1618, and found the island to abound in pigeons, parrots, +and other species, among which "there were also _Dod-eersen_, which +have small wings; and so far from being able to fly, they were so +fat that they could scarcely walk, and when they tried to run, they +dragged their under side along the ground." There is no reason to +suppose that these birds were actual Dodos, of the existence of +which in Bourbon there is not the slightest proof. That Bontekoe's +account was compiled from recollection rather than from any journal +written at the time, is almost certain from this tragical fact, +that his ship was afterwards blown up, and he himself was the sole +survivor. There is no likelihood that he preserved his papers any +more than his portmanteau, and he no doubt wrote from remembrance of +a large _brevipennate_ bird, whose indolent and unfearing tameness +rendered it an easy prey. Knowing that a bird of a somewhat similar +nature inhabited the neighbouring island, he took it for the same, +and called it Dodo, by a corresponding term. + +A Frenchman of the name of Carré visited Bourbon in 1668, and in his +_Voyages des Indes Orientales_, he states as follows:-- + + "I have seen a kind of bird which I have not found elsewhere; it + is that which the inhabitants call the _oiseau solitaire_, for + in fact it loves solitude, and only frequents the most secluded + places. One never sees two or more of them together, they are + always alone. It is not unlike a turkey, were it not that its + legs are longer. The beauty of its plumage is delightful to + behold. The flesh is exquisite; it forms one of the best dishes + in this country, and might form a dainty at our tables. We + wished to keep two of these birds to send to France and present + them to his Majesty, but, as soon as they were on board ship, + they died of melancholy, having refused to eat or drink."--(Vol. + i. p. 12.) + +Almost immediately after M. Carré's visit, a French colony was sent +from Madagascar to Bourbon, under the superintendence of M. de la +Haye. A certain Sieur D. B. (for this is all that is known of his +name or designation) was one of the party, and has left a narrative +of the expedition in an unpublished journal, acquired by Mr Telfair, +and presented by him to the Zoological Society of London. Besides +confirming the accounts given by preceding writers, this unknown +author affords a conclusive proof that a second species of the +same group inhabited the Island of Bourbon. We are indebted to Mr +Strickland for the original passages and the following translation:-- + + 1. "_Solitaires._--These birds are so called because they always + go alone. They are the size of a large goose, and are white, + with the tips of the wings and the tail black. The tail-feathers + resemble those of an ostrich; the neck is long, and the beak + is like that of a woodcock, but larger; the legs and feet like + those of turkeys." + + 2. "_Oiseaux bleus_, the size of _Solitaires_, have the plumage + wholly blue, the beak and feet red, resembling the feet of a + hen. They do not fly, but they run extremely fast, so that a dog + can hardly overtake them; they are very good eating." + +There is proof that one or other of these singular and now unknown +birds existed in Bourbon, at least till toward the middle of the +last century. M. Billiard, who resided there between 1817 and 1820, +states (in his _Voyages aux Colonies Orientales_) that, at the time +of the first colonisation of the island, "the woods were filled with +birds which were not alarmed at the approach of man. Among them was +the _Dodo_ or _Solitaire_, which was pursued on foot: they were +still to be seen in the time of M. de la Bourdonnaye, who sent a +specimen, as a curiosity, to one of the directors of the company." +As the gentleman last named was governor of the Isles of France and +Bourbon from 1735 to 1746, these birds, Mr Strickland observes, +_must_ have survived to the former, and _may_ have continued to the +latter date at least. But when M. Bory St Vincent made a careful +survey of the island in 1801, no such species were to be found. The +description of the bill and plumage shows that they were not genuine +Dodos, but merely entitled to be classed among their kindred. Not a +vestige of their remains is in the hands of naturalists, either in +this or any other country. + +We have now finished, under Mr Strickland's guidance, our exposition +of this curious group. The restriction, at any time, of such large +birds to islands of so small a size, is certainly singular. We +cannot, however, say what peculiar and unknown geological changes +these islands may have undergone, by which their extent has been +diminished, or their inter-connexion destroyed. Volcanic groups, +such as those in question, are no doubt generally of less ancient +origin than most others; but it is by no means unlikely that these +islands of Rodriguez, Bourbon, and Mauritius, may once have formed +a united group, or much more expanded mass of terra firma than they +now exhibit; and that, by their partial submergence and separation, +the dominions of the Dodo and its kindred have, like those of many +other heavy chieftains of high degree, been greatly diminished and +laid low. But into this question of ancient boundaries we cannot now +enter. + +How pleasant, on some resplendent summer evening, in such a +delicious clime as that of the Mauritius, the sun slowly sinking +amid a gorgeous blaze of light, and gilding in green and gold the +spreading summits of the towering palms,--the murmuring sea sending +its refreshing vesper-breathings through all the "pillared shades" +which stretch along that glittering shore,--how pleasant, we say, +for wearied man to sit in leafy umbrage, and sup on Dodos and their +kindred! Alas! we shall never see such days again. + +Dr Hamel, as native of a northern country, is fond of animal food, +and has his senses, naturally sharp enough, so whetted thereby, that +he becomes "sagacious of his _quarry_ from afar." He judiciously +observes, in his recent memoir, (_Der Dodo_, &c.,) that in Leguat's +map the place is accurately indicated where the common kitchen of +the settlers stood, and where the great tree grew under which they +used to sit, on a bench, to take their meals. Both tree and bench +are marked upon the map. "At these two spots," says Dr Hamel, "it is +probable that the bones of a complete skeleton of Leguat's solitaire +might be collected; those of the head and feet on the site of the +kitchen, and the sternum and other bones on that of the tree." + + "I feel confident," says Mr Strickland, "that if active + naturalists would make a series of excavations in the alluvial + deposits, in the beds of streams, and amid the ruins of old + institutions in Mauritius, Bourbon, and Rodriguez, he would + speedily discover the remains of the dodo, the two 'solitaires,' + or the 'oiseau bleu.' But I would especially direct attention + to the caves with which these volcanic islands abound. The + chief agents in the destruction of the brevipennate birds were + probably the runaway negroes, who for many years infested + the primeval forests of these islands, and inhabited the + caverns, where they would doubtless leave the scattered bones + of the animals on which they fed. Here, then, may we more + especially hope to find the osseous remains of these remarkable + animals."--(P. 61.) + + + + +THE SWORD OF HONOUR. + +A TALE OF 1787. + + +Any old directory of the latter half of the last century will still +show, to the curious in such matters, the address of Messrs. Hope +and Bullion, merchants and general dealers at No. 4, in a certain +high and narrow street in the city of London. Not that this, in +itself, is a very valuable part of history; but to those who look +up at the dirty windows of the house as it now stands, and compare +the narrow pavement and cit-like appearance of the whole locality +with the splendours of Oxford Square or Stanhope Place, where the +business occupant of the premises has now his residence, it will be +a subject of doubt, if not of unbelief, that Mr Bullion--who dwelt +in the upper portions of the building--was as happy, and nearly as +proud, as his successor at the present time. Yet so it is; and, +without making invidious comparisons with the distinguished-looking +lady who does the honours of the mansion in Oxford Square--her +father was a sugar baker, and lived in a magnificent country house +at Mussel hill. I will venture to state, that Mr Bullion had great +reason to be satisfied with the manners and appearance of the young +person who presided at his festive board. Such a rich laugh, and +such a sweet voice, were heard in no other house in the town. And +as to her face and figure, the only dispute among painters and +sculptors was, whether the ever-varying expression of her features +did not constitute her the true property of the Reynoldses and +Romneys,--or the ever-exquisite moulding of her shape did not bring +her within the province of the severer art. At the same time it must +be confessed, that the subject of these disputes took no interest +either in brush or chisel. A bright, happy, clever creature--but no +judge of sciences and arts--was Louise Bullion. Books she had read +a few, and music she had studied a little; yet, with her slender +knowledge of the circulating library, she talked more pleasantly +than Madame de Staël, and sang so sweetly, so naturally, and so +truly, that Mrs Billington was a fool to her. She was a parlour +Jenny Lind. But Mrs Billington was not the only person who was a +fool to her. Oh no!--that sort of insanity was epidemic, and seized +on all that came near her. Even Mr Cocker the book-keeper--a little +man of upwards of fifty, who was so simple, and knew so little of +anything but arithmetic, that he always considered himself, and was +considered by the people, a boy just getting on in his teens--even +Mr Cocker was a fool to her too. For when he was invited to tea, +and had his cups sweetened by her hand, and his whole heart turned, +by some of her pathetic ballads, into something so soft and oily +that it must have been just like one of the muffins she laid on his +plate, he used to go away with a very confused idea of cube roots, +and get into the most extraordinary puzzles in the rule of three. +Miss Louise, he said, would never go out of his head; whereas she +had never once got into it, having established her quarters very +comfortably in another place a little lower down, just inside of +the brass buttons on his left breast; and yet the poor old fellow +went down to his grave without the remotest suspicion that he had +ever been in love. The people used to say that his perplexities, on +those occasions, were principally remarkable after supper--for an +invitation to tea, in those hospitable times, included an afterpiece +in the shape of some roaring hot dishes, and various bowls of a +stout and jovial beverage, whose place, I beg to say, is poorly +supplied by any conceivable quantity of negus and jellies! Yes, +the people used to say that Cocker's difficulties in calculation +arose from other causes than his admiration of Miss Louise and her +songs; but this was a calumny--and, in fact, any few extra glasses +he took were for the express purpose of clearing his head, after it +had got bewildered by her smiles and music; and therefore how could +they possibly be the cause of his bewilderment? I repeat that Mr +Cocker was afflicted by the universal disease, and would have died +with the greatest happiness to give her a moment's satisfaction. +And so would all the clerks, except one, who was very short-sighted +and remarkably deaf, and who was afterwards tried on suspicion of +having poisoned his wife; and so would her aunt, Miss Lucretia +Smith, though her kindness was so wonderfully disguised that the +whole world would have been justified in considering it harshness +and ill-nature. It was only her way of bestowing it--as if you were +to pour out sugar from a vinegar cruet; and a good old, fussy, +scolding, grumbling, advising, tormenting, and very loving lady was +Miss Lucretia Smith--very loving, I say, not only of her niece, and +her brother-in-law, but of anybody that would agree to be loved. +Traditions existed that, in her youth, she had been a tremendous +creature for enthusiasms and romances; that she had flirted with all +the officers of the city militia, from the colonel downwards, and +with all the Lord Mayors' chaplains for an infinite series of years; +and that, though nothing came of all her praiseworthy efforts, time +had had a strengthening instead of a weakening effect on all these +passages--till now, in her fifty-third year, she actually believed +she had been in love with them all, and on the point of marriage +with more than half. + +And this constituted the whole of Mr Bullion's establishment--at +least all his establishment which was regularly on the books; +but there was a young man so constantly in the house--so much at +home there--so welcome when he came, so wondered at when he staid +away--in short, so much one of the family, that I will only say, if +he was not considered a member of it, he ought to have been. For +what, I pray you, constitutes membership, if intimacy, kindness, +perpetual presence, and filial and fraternal affection--filial to +the old man, fraternal to the young lady--do not constitute it? +You might have sworn till doomsday, but Mr Cecil Hope would never +have believed that his home was anywhere but at No. 4. Nay, when, +by some accident, he found himself for a day in a very pretty, very +tasteful, and very spacious house he had in Hertfordshire, with +a ring-fence of fourteen hundred acres round it, he felt quite +disconsolate, and as if he were in a strange place. The estate +had been bought, the house had been built--as the money had been +acquired, by his father, who was no less a person than the senior +partner in the firm of Hope and Bullion, but had withdrawn his +capital from the trade, laid it out in land, superintended the +erection of his mansion, pined for his mercantile activities, and +died in three years of having nothing to do. So Cecil was rich +and unencumbered; he was also as handsome as the Apollo, who, +they say, would be a very vulgar-looking fellow if he dressed +like a Christian; and he (not the Apollo, but Cecil Hope) was +four-and-twenty years of age, five feet eleven in height, and +as pleasant a fellow as it is possible to conceive. So you may +guess whether or not he was in love with Louise. Of course he +was,--haven't I said he was a young man of some sense, and for whom +I have a regard? He adored her. And now you will, perhaps, be asking +if the admiration was returned--and that is one of the occasions on +which an impertinent reader has a great advantage over the best and +cunningest of authors. They can ask such impudent questions,--which +they would not dare to do unless under the protection and in the +sanctuary, as it were, of print, and look so amazingly knowing while +pausing for a reply, that I have no patience with the fellows at +all; and, in answer to their demand whether Louise returned the +love of Cecil Hope, I will only say this--I will see them hanged +first, before I gratify their curiosity. Indeed, how could I hold +up my head in any decent society again, if I were to commit such +a breach of confidence as that? Imagine me confessing that she +looked always fifty times happier in his presence than when he was +away--imagine me confessing that her heart beat many thumps quicker +when anybody mentioned his name--imagine me, I say, confessing +all this, and fifty things more, and then calling myself a man of +honour and discretion! No: I say again I will see the reader hanged +first, before I will answer his insolent question; so let that be +an understood thing between us, that I will never reveal any secret +with which a young lady is kind enough to intrust me. + +And this, I think, is a catalogue of all the household above the +good old warehouse. Ah! no,--there is the excellent Mr Bullion +himself. He is now sixty; he has white hair, a noble, even a +_distingué_ figure: look into any page of any fashionable novel of +any year, for an explanation of what that means. On the present +occasion, you would perhaps conclude that the long-backed, +wide-tailed blue coat, the low-flapped waistcoat, tight-fitting +knee-br--ch--s, white cotton stockings in-doors, long gaiters out, +with bright-buckled square-toed shoes, may be a little inconsistent +with the epithet _distingué_. But this is a vulgar error, and +would argue that nobody could look _distingué_ without lace and +brocade. Now, only imagine Mr Bullion in a court-dress, with a +silk bag floating over his shoulder, to tie up long tresses which +have disappeared from his head for many years; a diamond-hilted +rapier that probably has no blade, and all the other portions of +that graceful and easy style of habiliment,--dress him in this way, +and look at him bowing gracefully by means of his three-cornered +hat, and you will surely grant he would be a _distingué_ figure +then,--and why not in his blue coat and smalls? + +But _distingué_-looking men, even in court-dresses, may be great +rascals, and even considerable fools. Then was Mr Bullion a +rascal?--no. A fool?--no. In short, he was one of the best of men, +and could have been recognised during his life, if any one had +described him in the words of his epitaph. + +Well,--we must get on. Day after day, for several months before +the date we have got to, a sort of mystery seemed to grow deeper +and deeper on the benevolent features of the father of Louise. +Something--nobody could tell what--had lifted him out of his +ordinary self. He dropt dark hints of some great change that was +shortly to take place in the position of the family: he even +took many opportunities of lecturing Cecil Hope on the miseries +of ill-assorted marriages, particularly where the lady was of a +family immeasurably superior to the man's. Miss Smith thought he was +going to be made Lord Mayor; Cecil Hope supposed he was about to be +appointed Chancellor of the Exchequer; and Louise thought he was +growing silly, and took no notice of all the airs he put on, and the +depreciatory observations he made on the rank of a country squire. +As to Mr Cocker, he was already fully persuaded that his master was +the greatest man in the world, and, if he had started for king, +would have voted him to the throne without a moment's hesitation. +At last the origin of all these proceedings on the part of Mr +Bullion began to be suspected. A little dark man, with the brightest +possible eyes, shrouded in a great cloak, with a broad-brimmed hat +carefully drawn over his brows, and just showing to the affrighted +maid who opened the door the aforesaid eyes, fixed on her with such +an expression of inquiry that they fully supplied the difficulty +he experienced in asking for Mr Bullion in words,--for he was a +foreigner, not much gifted with the graces of English pronunciation. +This little dark and inquisitive man came to the house two or +three times a-week, and spent several hours in close consultation +with Mr Bullion. On emerging from these councils, it was easy to +see, by that gentleman's countenance, whether the affair, whatever +it was, was in a prosperous condition or not. Sometimes he came +into the supper-room gloomy and silent, sometimes tripping in +like a sexagenarian Taglioni, and humming a French song,--for his +knowledge of that language was extraordinary,--and his whole idea +of a daughter's education seemed to be, to make her acquire the +true Parisian accent, and to read Molière and Corneille. So Louise, +to gratify the whim of her father, had made herself perfect in +the language, and could have entered into a correspondence with +Madame de Sevigné without a single false concord, or a mistake in +spelling. Who could this little man be, who had such influence +on her father's spirits? They watched him, but could see nothing +but the dark cloak and slouched hat, which disappeared down some +side street, and would have puzzled one of the detective police to +keep them in view. Her thoughts rested almost constantly on this +subject. Even at church--for they were regular church-goers, and +very decided Protestants, as far as their religious feelings could +be shown in hating the devil and the Pope--she used to watch her +father's face, but could read nothing there but a quiet devotion +during the prayers, and an amiable condescension while listening to +the sermon. Rustlings of papers as the little visitor slipt along +the passage, revealed the fact that there were various documents +required in their consultations; and on one particular occasion, +after an interview of unusual duration, Mr Bullion accompanied his +mysterious guest to the door, and was overheard, by the conclave +who were assembled in the little parlour for supper, very warm in +his protestations of obligation for the trouble he had taken, and +concluding with these remarkable words--"Assure his Excellency of +my highest consideration, and that I shall not lose a moment in +throwing myself at the feet of the King." Louise looked at Cecil on +hearing these words; and as Cecil would probably have been looking +at Louise, whether he had heard these words or not, their eyes +met with an expression of great bewilderment and surprise,--the +said bewilderment being by no means diminished when his visitor +replied--"His Excellency kisses your hands, and I leave your +Lordship in the holy keeping of the saints." + +"Papa is rather flighty--don't you think so, Cecil?" said Louise. + +"Both mad," answered that gentleman with a shake of the head. + +"Mr Bullion is going to be Lord Mayor," said Miss Lucretia, with +a vivid remembrance of the flirtations and grandeurs of the +Mansion-house. + +Mr Cocker said nothing aloud, and was sorely puzzled for a long +time, but ended with a confused notion, derived principally from the +protection of the saints, that his patron was likely to be Pope. +All, however, sank into a gaping silence of anticipation, when +Mr Bullion, after shutting the door, as soon as his visitor had +departed, began to whistle Malbrook, and came into the supper-room. + + +CHAPTER II. + +"Enjoy yourselves, _mes enfants_," said the old gentleman; "I have +not kept you waiting, I hope. Miss Smith, I kiss your hand--_ma +fille, embrassemoi_." + +"What's the matter with you, papa?" replied the young lady, and not +complying with the request; "you speak as if you were a foreigner. +Have you forgotten your mother-tongue?" + +And certainly it was not difficult to perceive that there was an +unusual tone assumed by Mr Bullion, with the slightest possible +broken English admitted into his language. + +"My mother-tongue?" said the senior. "Bah! 'tis not the time yet--I +have not forgot it--not quite--but kiss me, Louise." + +"Well, since you speak like a Christian, I won't refuse; but do be a +good, kind, communicative old man, and tell us what has kept you so +long. Do tell us who that hideous man is." + +"Hideous, my dear!--'tis plain you never saw him." + +"He's like the bravo of Venice," said Louise; "isn't he, Cecil?" + +"He's more like Guy Faux," said the gentleman appealed to. + +"He's like a gipsy fortune-teller," continued Miss Smith. + +"Uncommon like a 'ousebreaker," chimed in Mr Cocker: "I never see +such a rascally-looking countenance." + +"Are you aware, all this time, that you are giving these +descriptions of a friend of mine,--a most learned, lofty, +reverend--but, pshaw! what nonsense it is, getting angry with folks +like you. Eagles should fight with eagles." + +But the lofty assumptions of Mr Bullion made no impression on his +audience. One word, however, had stuck in the tympanum of Miss +Smith's ear, and was beating a tremendous tattoo in her heart-- + +"Reverend, did you say, brother-in-law. If that little man is +reverend, mark my words. I know very well what he's after. If we're +not all spirited off to the Disquisition in Spain, I wish I may +never be marr--I mean--saved." + +"Nonsense, aunt," said Louise. "You're not going to turn Dissenter, +father?" + +"Better that than be a Papist, anyhow," sulked out Lucretia. + +"Miss Smith," said Mr Bullion, "have the kindness, madam, to make +no observation on what I do, or what friends I visit or receive in +this house. If the gentleman who has now left me were a Mahommedan, +he should be sacred from your impertinent remarks. Give me another +potato, and hold your tongue." + +"To you, Mr Hope," continued the senior, "and to you, Mr Cocker, +and to you, Miss Lucretia, who are unmixed plebeians from your +remotest known ancestry, it may appear surprising that a man so +willingly undertakes the onerous duties entailed on him by his lofty +extraction, as to surrender the peace and contentment which he feels +to be the fitter accompaniments of your humble yet comfortable +position. For my daughter and me far other things are in store--we +sit on the mountain-top exposed to the tempest, though glorified by +the sunshine, and look without regret to the contemptible safety +and inglorious ease of the inhabitants of the vale. Take a glass of +wine, Mr Cocker. I shall always look on you with favour." + +Mr Cocker took the glass as ordered, and supposed his patron was +repeating a passage out of Enfield's _Speaker_. "Fine language, +sir, very fine language, indeed! particular that about sunshine on +the mountains. A remarkable clever man, Mr Enfield; and I can say +Ossian's Address to the Sun myself." + +But in the mean time Louisa walked round the table, and laid hold of +her father's hand, and putting her finger on his pulse, looked with +a face full of wisdom, while she counted the beats; and giving a +satisfied shake of the head, resumed her seat. + +"A day or two's quiet will do, without a strait waistcoat," she +said; "but I will certainly tell the porter never to admit that +slouch-faced muffled-up impostor, who puts such nonsense into his +head." + +But at this moment a violent pull at the bell startled them all. +When the door was opened a voice was heard in the hall which said, +"Pour un instant, Monseigneur;" whereupon Mr Bullion started up, +and replying, "Oui, mon père," hurried out of the room, and left his +party in more blank amazement than before. + +The surmises, the exclamations, the whispers and suspicions that +passed from one to the other, it is needless to record; it will +suffice to say that, after an animated conversation with the +mysterious visitor, Mr Bullion once more joined the circle and said, +"You will be ready, all of you, to start for France to-morrow. I +have business of importance that calls for my presence in Tours. Say +not a word, but obey." + + +CHAPTER III. + +So, in a week, they were all comfortably settled in a hotel at Tours. + +Mr Bullion was sitting in the parlour, apparently in deep and +pleasant contemplation; for the corners of his mouth were +involuntarily turned up, and he inspected the calf of his leg with +self-satisfied admiration. Mr Cocker was on a chair in the corner, +probably multiplying the squares in the table-cover by the flowers +in the paper. + +"How do you like France, Mr Cocker?" said Mr Bullion. + +"Not at all, sir; the folks has no sense; and no wonder we always +wallop them by sea or land." + +"Hem! Must I remind you, sir, that this is _my_ country; that the +French are my countrymen; and that you by no means wallop them +either by sea or land." + +"_You_ French! _you_ Frenchman!" replied Mr Cocker; "that _is_ +a joke! Bullion ain't altogether a French name, I think? No, +no; it smells of the bank; _it_ does. You ain't one of the +_parlevous_--_you_ ain't, that's certain." + +"How often have I to order you, sir, not to doubt my word?" said Mr +Bullion; and emphacised his speech with a form of expression that is +generally considered a clencher. + +"There! there!" cried Cocker, triumphant; "I told you so. Is there +ever a Frenchman could swear like that? They ain't Christians enough +to give such a jolly hearty curse as yourn; so you see, sir, it's no +go to pass yourself off for a _Mounseer_." + +"Leave the room, sir, and send Mr Hope to me at once!" + +Cocker obeyed, puzzled more and more at the fancy his master was +possessed with to deny his country. + +"It would, perhaps, have been wiser," thought Mr Bullion, "to +have left the plebeian fools at home till everything was formally +completed; but still, nothing, I suppose, would have satisfied them +but the evidence of their own eyes." + +"Mr Hope," he said, as that young gentleman entered the room, "sit +down beside me; nay, no ceremony, I shall always treat you with +condescension and regard." + +"You are very good, sir." + +"I am, sir; and I trust your conduct will continue such as to +justify me in remaining so. You may have observed, Mr Hope, a change +in my manner for some time past. You can't have been fool enough, +like Miss Smith and Mr Cocker, to doubt the reality of the fact I +stated, namely, that I am French by birth,--did you doubt it, sir?" + +"Why, sir,--in fact--since you insist on an answer--" + +"I see you did. Well, sir, I pity and pardon you. I will tell you +the whole tale, and then you will see that some alteration must take +place in our respective positions. In the neighbourhood of this +good city of Tours I was born. My father was chief of the younger +branch of one of the noblest houses in France,--the De Bouillons +of Chateau d'Or. He was wild, gay, thoughtless, and fell into +disgrace at court. He was imprisoned in the Bastille; his estates +confiscated; his name expunged from the book of nobility; and he +died poor, forgotten, and blackened in name and fame. I was fifteen +at the time. I took my father's sword into the Town Hall; I gave +it in solemn charge to the authorities, and vowed that when I had +succeeded in wiping off the blot from my father's name, and getting +it restored to its former rank, I would reclaim it at their hands, +and assume the state and dignity to which my birth entitled me. I +went to England; your father, my good Cecil, took me by the hand: +porter, clerk, partner, friend,--I rose through all the gradations +of the office; and when he died, he left me the highest trust he +could repose in anyone,--the guardianship of his son." + +"I know sir,--and if I have never sufficiently thanked you for your +care--" + +"Not that--no, no--I'm satisfied, my dear boy--and Louise--the +Lady Louise I must now call her--change of rank--duties of lofty +sphere--former friends--ill arranged engagements--" continued the +new-formed magnate in confusion, blurting out unconnected words, +that showed the train of his thoughts without expressing them +distinctly; while Mr Hope sat in amazement at what he had heard, but +no longer doubting the reality of what was said. + +"Well, sir?" he inquired. + +"I changed my name with my country, though retaining as much of the +sound of it as I could; and Louis Bullion was a complete disguise +for the expatriated Marquis de Bouillon de Chateau d'Or. I married +Miss Smith, and lost her shortly after Louise's birth. For years +I have been in treaty with the French ambassador through his +almoner, the Abbé, whose visits you thought so mysterious. At last +I succeeded, and to-morrow I claim my father's sword, resume the +hereditary titles of my house, and take my honoured place among the +peers and paladins of France." + +"And have you informed Louise?"--inquired Cecil. + +"Lady Louise," interrupted Mr Bullion. + +"Of this change in her position?" + +"Why, my dear Cecil, to tell you truth--it's not an easy matter to +get her to understand my meaning. Yesterday I attempted to explain +the thing, exactly as I have done to you; but instead of taking it +seriously, she began with one of her provoking chuckles, and chucked +me under the chin, and called me Marquy-darky. In fact, I wish the +explanation to come from you." + +"I feel myself very unfit for the task," said the young man, who +foresaw that this altered situation might interfere with certain +plans of his own. "I hope you will excuse me; you can tell her the +whole affair yourself, for here she comes." + +And the young lady accordingly made her appearance. After looking at +them for some time-- + +"What are you all so doleful about?" she began. "Has papa bitten +you too, Cecil? Pray don't be a duke--it makes people so very +ridiculous." + +"Miss Louise--mademoiselle, I ought to say," said Mr Bullion, "I +have communicated certain facts to Cecil Hope." + +"Which he doesn't believe--do you, Cecil?" interposed the daughter. + +"He does believe them, and I beg you will believe them too. They are +simply, that I am a nobleman of the highest rank, and you are my +right honourable daughter." + +"Oh, indeed! and how was our cousin Spain when you heard from +Madrid?--our uncle Austria, was he quite well?--was George of +England recovered of the gout?--and above all, how was uncle Smith, +the shipowner of Wapping?" + +"Girl! you will drive me mad," replied the Marquis, "with your +Smiths and Wappings. I tell you, what I have said is really the +case, and to-morrow you will see the inauguration with your own +eyes. Meantime, I must dress, to receive a deputation of the +nobility of the province, who come to congratulate me on my arrival." + +"Oh, what's this I hear," exclaimed Miss Smith, rushing into the +room, "are you a real marquis, Mr Bullion?" + +"Yes, madam, I have that honour." + +"And does the marriage with my sister stand good?" + +"To be sure, madam." + +"Then, I'm very glad of it. Oh how delightful!--to be my Lord this, +my Lady that. I am always devoted to the aristockicy; and now, only +to think I am one of them myself." + +"How can you be so foolish, aunt?--I'm ashamed of you," said Louise; +"what terrible things you were telling me, an hour ago, of the +wickedness of the nobility?" + +"Miss Smith, though she does not express herself in very correct +language, has more sensible ideas on this subject than you," said +the marquis, looking severely at his daughter, who was looking, from +time to time, with a malicious smile at the woe-begone countenance +of Cecil Hope. "Remember, madam, who it is you are," continued the +senior. + +"La, papa! don't talk such nonsense," replied the irreverent +daughter. "Do you think I am eighteen years of age, and don't know +perfectly well who and what I am?" + +"Three of your ancestors, madam, were Constables of France." + +"That's nothing to boast of," returned Louise; "no, not if they had +been inspectors of police." + +"You are incorrigible, girl, and have not sense enough to have a +proper feeling of family pride." + +"Haven't I? Am I not proud of all the stories uncle David tells +us of his courage, when he was mate of an Indiaman? and aunt +Jenkison--don't you remember, sir, how she dined with us at +Christmas, and had to walk in pattens through the snow, and tumbled +in Cheapside?" + +A laugh began to form itself round the eyes of the French magnate, +which made his countenance uncommonly like what it used to be when +it was that of an English merchant. Louise saw her success, and +proceeded. + +"And how you said, when the poor old lady was brought home in a +chair, that it was the punch that did it?" + +"He, he! and so it was. Didn't I caution her, all the time, that it +was old Jamaica rum?" broke out the father; but checked himself, as +if he were guilty of some indecorum. + +"And don't you remember how we all attended the launch of uncle +Peter's ship, the Hope's Return? Ah, they were happy days, father! +weren't they?" + +"No, madam; no--vulgar, miserable days: forget them as quick as you +can. I tell you, when you resume your proper sphere, every eye will +be turned to your beauty: nobles will be dying at your feet." + +"I trust not, sir," hurriedly burst in Mr Hope. "I don't see what +right any nobles will have to be dying at Louise's feet." + +"Don't you, sir?" said Louise. "Indeed! I beg to tell you, that as +many as choose shall die at my feet. I'll trouble you, Mr Hope, +not to interfere with the taste of any nobleman who has a fancy to +so queer a place for his death-bed." But while she said this, she +tapped him so playfully with her little white hand, and looked at +him so kindly with her beautiful blue eyes, that the young gentleman +seemed greatly reassured; and in a few minutes, as if tired of the +conversation, betook himself to the other room. + + +CHAPTER IV. + +Suddenly a great noise was heard in the street, and interrupted the +lectures of father and aunt on the dignity of position and the pride +of birth. Miss Lucretia and Louise ran to the window, and saw a +cavalcade of carriages, with outriders, and footmen on the rumble, +and all the stately accompaniments of the old-fashioned family +coach, which, after a slow progress along the causeway, stopped at +the hotel door. + +"My friends! my noble friends!" exclaimed the marquis; "and I in +this miserable dress!" + +"The noble men! the salts of the earth!" equally exclaimed Miss +Smith; "and I in my morning gownd!" + +Saying this, she hastily fled into her bed-room, which, according to +the fashion of French houses, opened on the sitting-room, and left +the father and Louise alone. + +The father certainly was in no fitting costume for the dignity +of his new character. He was dressed according to the fashion of +the respectable London trader of his time--a very fitting figure +for 'Change, but not appropriate to the Marquis de Bouillon de +Chateau d'Or. Nor, in fact, was his disposition much more fitted +for his exalted position than his clothes. To all intents and +purposes, he was a true John Bull: proud of his efforts to attain +wealth--proud of his success--proud of the freedom of his adopted +land--and, in his secret heart, thinking an English merchant +several hundred degrees superior in usefulness and worth to all the +marquises that ever lived on the smiles of the Grand Monarque. The +struggle, therefore, that went on within him was the most ludicrous +possible. To his family and friends he presented that phase of his +individuality that set his nobility in front; to the French nobles, +on the other hand, he was inclined to show only so much of himself +as presented the man of bills and invoices; and in both conditions, +by a wonderful process of reasoning, in which we are all adepts, +considered himself raised above the individuals he addressed. + +"Did they see you at the window?" he said, in some trepidation, +while the visitors were descending from their coaches. + +"To be sure," replied Louise; "and impudent-looking men they were." + +"Ah! that's a pity. Do, for heaven's sake, my dear, just slip in +beside your aunt. They are a very gay polite people, the nobles of +France--" + +"Well; and what then?" + +"And they might take ways of showing it, we are not used to in +England. Do hide yourself, my dear--there, that's a good girl." +And just as he had succeeded in pushing her into the bedroom, and +begged her to lock herself in, the landlord of the hotel ushered +four or five noblemen into the apartment, as visitors to the +Marquis de Bouillon. The eldest of the strangers--about forty years +old--bespangled with jewels, and ornamented with two or three stars +and ribbons, looked with some surprise on the plainly drest and +citizen-mannered man, who came forward to welcome them. + +"We came to pay our compliments to my lord the Marquis de Bouillon +de Chateau d'Or." + +"And very glad he is to see you, gentlemen," said their host. + +"You?--impossible! He speaks with an English accent." + +"An impostor!" replied another of the nobles, to whom the last +sentence had been addressed in a whisper." + +"I am, indeed,--and truly glad to make your acquaintance, I assure +you." + +"Well," resumed the Frenchman, "let me present to you the Viscount +de Lanoy--the Baron Beauvilliers--the Marquis de Croissy--for +myself, I'm Duc de Vieuxchateau." + +"Sit down, gentlemen--I beg," said De Bouillon, after bowing to the +personages named. "A charming place this Tours, and I'm very glad to +see you--fine weather, gentlemen." + +"I trust you have come with the intention of residing among us. Your +estates, I conclude, are restored along with your titles." + +"No, gentlemen, they're not. But we may manage to buy some of them +back again. How's land here?" + +"Land?" inquired the duke, rather bewildered with the question. + +"Yes--how is it, as to rent? How much an acre?" + +"'Pon my word, I don't know. When I want money I tell the steward, +and the people--the--serfs, I suppose, they are--who hold the plough +and manage the land--give him some, and he brings it to me." + +"Oh! but you don't know how many years' purchase it's worth?" + +To this there was no answer--statistics, at that time, not being a +favourite study in France. + +"But, marquis," inquired another, "hasn't the King restored you your +manorial rights--your _droits de seigneur_?" + +"No, sir." + +"Then what's the use of land without them?" was the very pertinent +rejoinder. + +"What are they, sir?" inquired the marquis. + +"Why, if a tenant of yours has a pretty daughter," said one. + +"Or a wife," said another. + +"Or even a niece," said a third. + +"Well, sir, what then? I don't take." + +"Oh, you're a wag, marquis!" replied the duke. "Didn't I see, as we +stopt before your window, a countenance radiant with beauty?" + +"Eyes like stars," chimed in another. + +"Cheeks like roses. Aha! Monsieur le Marquis--who was it?--come!" + +"Why, that,--oh, that,--that's a young lady under my protection, +gentlemen; and I must beg you to change the conversation." + +"Indeed! you're a lucky fellow! The old fool mustn't be allowed to +keep such beauty to himself." + +"Certainly not," returned the vicomte, also in a whisper. + +"Lucky!" said De Bouillon--"yes, gentlemen, I am lucky. If you knew +all, you would think so, I'm sure." + +"She loves you, then, old simpleton?" + +"I think she does--I know she does--" + +"May we not ask the honour of being presented?" + +"Some other time, gentlemen--not now--she's not here--she's gone out +for a walk." + +"Impossible, my dear lord; we must have met her as we came up +stairs." + +"She has a headache--she's gone to lie down for a few minutes," said +the marquis, getting more and more anxious to keep Louise from the +intrusion of his visitors. + +"I have an excellent cure for headaches of all kinds," exclaimed +the baron, and proceeded towards the bed-room door. The Marquis de +Bouillon, however, put himself between; but the duke and vicomte +pulled him aside, and the baron began to rat-tat on the door. + +"Come forth, madam!" he began, "we are dying for a sight of your +angelic charms. De Bouillon begs you to honour us with your +presence. Hark, she's coming!" he added, and drew back as he heard +the bolt withdrawn on the other side. + +"Stay where you are! don't come out!" shouted De Bouillon, still in +the hands of his friends. "I charge you, don't move a step!" But his +injunctions were vain; the door opened, and, sailing majestically +into the room, drest out in hoop and furbelow, and waving her fan +affectedly before her face, appeared Miss Lucretia Smith-- + +"Did you visit to see me, gentlemen? I'm always delighted to see any +one as is civil enough to give us a forenoon call." + +The French nobles, however, felt their ardour damped to an +extraordinary degree, and replied by a series of the most respectful +salaams. + +"Profound veneration," "deepest reverence," and other expressions +of the same kind, were muttered by each of the visiters; and in a +short time they succeeded, in spite of Miss Lucretia's reiterated +invitations, in bowing themselves out of the room. They were +accompanied by the marquis to their carriages, while Miss Smith was +gazing after them, astonished, more than pleased, at the wonderful +politeness of their manner. Louise slipt out of the bed-room, and +slapt her astonished aunt upon the shoulder-- + +"You've done it, aunt!--you've done it now! A word from you recalls +these foreigners to their senses." + +"It gives me a high opinion," replied Miss Smith, "of them French. +They stand in perfect awe of dignity and virtue." + + +CHAPTER V. + +Great were the discussions, all that day, among the English party in +the hotel--the father concealing his disappointment at the behaviour +of his fellow nobles, under an exaggerated admiration of rank, and +all its attributes; Louise professing to chime in with her father's +ideas, for the pleasant purpose of vexing Cecil Hope; Mr Cocker +still persuading himself the Frenchmanship of his old master was a +little bit of acting that would end as soon as the curtain fell; and +Miss Lucretia devising means of making up for her failures with so +many curates, by catching a veritable duke. With the next morning +new occupations began. The marquis, dressed in the fantastic apparel +of a French courtier, exchanged compliments with his daughter, +who was also magnificently attired, to do honour to the occasion. +Mr Hope tried in vain to get her to sink from the lofty style she +assumed, and had strong thoughts of setting off for Hertfordshire, +and marrying a farmer's daughter out of revenge. The father was so +carried away by family pride, and the daughter enjoyed the change +in her rank so heartily, that there seemed no room in the heart +of either for so prosaic a being as a plain English squire. And +yet, every now and then, there gleamed from the corner of Louise's +eye, or stole out in a merry tone of her voice, the old familiar +feeling, so that he could not altogether give way to despair, but +waited in patience what the chapter of accidents might bring. At +one o'clock the marquis set off for the town-hall, where he was to +go through the ceremony of reclaiming his father's sword, and have +the blot on the scutcheon formally removed; after which he was to +entertain the town authorities, and the neighbouring nobility, at +dinner; the evening to conclude with a ball, in the preparation for +which the ladies were to be left at home. Mr Hope accompanied him +to the door of the town-hall,--but there he professed to find his +feelings overpowered, and declined to witness the ceremony that, +he said, broke the connexion which had existed so long between the +names of Hope and Bullion; but, ere he could return to the hotel, +several things had occurred that had a material influence on his +prospects, and these we must now proceed to relate. Miss Lucretia +Smith continued her oratory in the ears of her devoted niece after +the gentlemen had gone, the burden thereof consisting, principally, +in a comparison between the nobles of France and the shopocracy +of London,--till that young lady betook herself to the bedroom +window already mentioned, to watch for Cecil's return. She had +not been long at her watch-post, when a carriage, with the blinds +drawn up, and escorted by seven or eight armed men, with masks on +their faces, pulled up at the door. Of this she took no particular +notice, but kept looking attentively down the street. But, a minute +or two after the closed carriage drove under the _porte cochère_, +a young gentleman was ushered into the presence of Miss Smith, and +was, by that young lady, received with the highest _empressement_ +possible. She had only had time to improve her toilette by putting +on Louise's shawl and bonnet, which happened to be lying on a chair; +and, in spite of the shortness of the view she had had of him the +day before, she immediately recognised him as one of her brother's +visiters, the Baron Beauvilliers. + +"Permit me, madam," he said, in very good English, "to apologise for +my intrusion, but I have the authority of my friend De Bouillon to +consider myself here at home." + +"Oh, sir, you are certainly the politest nation on the face of the +earth, you French--that I must say; but I may trust, I hope, to +the honour of a gent like you? You won't be rude to an unoffended +female? for there ain't a soul in the 'ouse that could give me the +least assistance." + +The baron bowed in a very assuring manner, and, taking a seat beside +her, "May I make bold, madam, to ask who the tawdry silly-looking +young person is who resides under De Bouillon's protection?" + +"Sir--under Mr Bull--I mean, under the marquee's protection? I don't +understand you." + +"Exactly as I suspected. I guessed, from the dignity of your +appearance, that such an infamous proceeding was entirely unknown +to you. Command my services, madam, in any way you can make them +available. Let me deliver you from the scandal of being in the same +house with a person of that description." + +"Oh, sir!" replied Miss Smith, "you are certainly most obliging. +When we are a little better acquainted perhaps--in a few days, +or even in one--I shall be happy to accept your offer; but, la! +what will my brother-in-law say if I accept a gentleman's offer at +minute's notice?" + +Miss Smith accompanied this speech with various blushes and pauses, +betokening the extent of her modest reluctance; but the baron either +did not perceive the mistake she had made, or did not think it worth +while to notice it. + +"I will convey the destroyer of your peace away from your sight. +Show me only the room she is in. And consider, madam, that you will +make me the proudest of men by allowing me to be your knight and +champion on this occasion." + +"Really, sir, I can't say at present where the gipsy can be. +Brother-in-law has been very sly; but if I can possibly ferret her +out, won't I send her on her travels? Wait but a minute, sir: I'll +come to you the moment she can be found." + +But the baron determined to accompany her in her search, and +together they left the room, two active members of the Society for +the Suppression of Vice. Louise had heard the noise of voices, +without distinguishing or attending to what was said, but a low and +hurried tap at the door now attracted her notice. + +"Miss Louise--ma'am--for heaven's sake, come out!" said the voice of +Mr Cocker through the key-hole; "for here's a whole regiment of them +French, and they wants to run away with YOU." + +"With me, Cocker!" exclaimed Louise, coming into the parlour. "What +is it you mean?" + +"What I say, miss--and your aunt is as bad as any on 'em. She's +searching the house, at this moment, to give you tip into their +hands. She can't refuse nothing to them noblesse, as she calls 'em. +The gentleman has gone down to the court-yard to see that nobody +escapes, and here we are, like mice in a trap." + +"Go for Cecil, Cocker; leave me to myself," said Louise--her +features dilating into tiger-like beauty, with rage and +self-confidence. "Go, I tell you--you'll find him returning from the +town-hall--and bid him lose not a moment in coming to my help." She +waved Mr Cocker impatiently from her, and returned for a moment into +the bed-room. + +"Madam, hist! I beg you will be quick!" exclaimed the baron, +entering the parlour; "I can't wait much longer. What a detestable +old fool it is!" he went on, in a lower voice; "she might have +found the girl long ere this. "Well, well, have you found her?" he +continued, addressing Louise, who issued from the bed-room in some +of the apparel of her aunt, and assuming as nearly as she could the +airs and graces of that individual. "Tell me, madam, where she is." + +"La! sir, how is one to find out these things in a moment--besides, +they ain't quite proper subjects for a young lady to be concerned +with," replied Louise, keeping her bashful cheek from the sight of +the baron with her enormous fan. + +"Then, madam, point with that lovely finger of yours, and I shall +make the discovery myself." + +Louise pointed, as required, to the gallery, along which, at that +moment, her quick eye caught the step of Miss Lucretia; and the +baron, going to the door, gave directions to his attendants to seize +the lady, and carry her without loss of time to the Parc d'Amour, +a hotel on the outskirts of Tours. He then closed the door, and +listened--no less than did Louise--to the execution of his commands. + +"There, madam," he said, as the scuffle of seizure and a very faint +scream were heard, "they've got her! Your pure presence shall never +more be polluted by her society. A naughty man old De Bouillon, and +unaccustomed to the strict morality of France. Adieu!" + +"Adieu, sir!" said Louise; but there was a tone in her voice, or +something in her manner, that called the attention of her visitor. +He went up to her, laid his hand upon the fan, and revealed before +him, beautiful from alarm and indignation, was the face of Louise de +Bouillon! "So, madam! this was an excellent device, but I have more +assistance at hand. Ho! Pierre! François!" he began to call. "I have +another carriage in the yard--you sha'nt escape me so." + +"Stop, sir!" exclaimed Louise, and placed herself between him and +the door. "These are not the arts of wooing we are used to in +England. I expected more softness and persuasion." + +"Alas, madam, 'tis only the shortness of the opportunity that +prevents me from making a thousand protestations. But, after all, +what is the use of them? Ho! François!" + +As he said this, he approached nearer to Louise, and even laid his +hand upon her arm. But with the quickness of lightning, she made +a dart at the diamond-covered hilt of her assailant's sword, and +pulling it from the sheath, stood with the glittering point within +an inch of the Frenchman's eyes. + +"Back, back!" she cried, "or you are a dead man--or frog--or +monkey--or whatever you are!" + +Each of these names was accompanied with a step in advance; and +there was too savage a lustre in her look to allow the unfortunate +baron to doubt for a moment that his life was in the highest peril. + +"Madam," he expostulated, "do be careful--'tis sharp as a needle." + +"Back, back!" she continued, advancing with each word upon his +retreating steps--"you thread-paper--you doll-at-a-fair--you stuffed +cockatoo--back, back!" And on arriving at the bed-room door, she +gave a prodigiously powerful lunge in advance, and drove her victim +fairly into the room, and, with an exclamation of pride and triumph, +locked him in. But, exhausted with the excitement, she had only time +to lay the sword on the table, wave the key three times round her +head in sign of victory, and fall fainting into the arms of Cecil +Hope, who at that moment rushed into the room. + + +CHAPTER VI. + +The ceremony in the town-hall passed off with the greatest _éclât_; +and the dinner was probably thought the finest part of the day's +entertainment by all but the newly re-established noble himself. +Flushed with the glories of the proceeding, and also with the wine +he had swallowed to his own health and happiness, he sallied forth +with his friends of the preceding day--except, of course, the +Baron Beauvilliers--and, as he himself expressed it, was awake for +anything, up to any lark. + +"A lark, says my lord?" inquired the Duke de Vieuxchateau. + +"Ay," replied the marquis, "if it's as big as a turkey, all the +better. That champaign is excellent tipple, and would be cheap at +eighty-four shillings per dozen." + +The French nobles did not quite understand their companion's +phraseology, but were quite willing to join him in any extravagance. + +"What shall we do?" cried one; "shall we break open the jail?" + +"No," said De Bouillon: "hang it! that's a serious matter. But I'll +tell you what, I've no objection to knock down a charley." + +"No, no! let's go to _Rouge et Noir_." + +"Boys, boys!" at last exclaimed the Vicomte de Lanoy, "I'll tell +you what we shall do,--Beauvilliers told me that, while we were all +engaged at the dinner, he was going to seize a beautiful creature, +and carry her off to the Parc d'Amour." + +"Wrong, decidedly wrong!" said De Bouillon at this proposition. "Who +is she?" + +"Why, the companion, you understand, of an old twaddling fool, who +has no right to so much beauty. Beauvilliers did not tell me his +name, but 'tis only one of the _bourgeoisie_, and we surely have a +right to do as we like with _them_." + +"Ah yes! of course," replied De Bouillon, "I did not think of that. +What then?" + +"Why, sir, we shall play as good a trick on Beauvilliers as he +designed for the ancient gentleman. Let's get there before him, and +carry her from him!" + +"Agreed, agreed!" + +"No, no, I must declare off," said the marquis. "'Tis a bad business +altogether, and this would make it worse." + +"But who is to carry the lady?" inquired the duke, without attending +to the scruples of his friend. + +"Toss for it," suggested the vicomte. A louis was thrown into the +air. "Heads! heads!" cried the nobleman. "Tails!" said De Bouillon. + +"'Tis tails!" exclaimed the vicomte. "Marquis, the chance is +yours--you've won." + +"Oh! have I?" replied the unwilling favourite of fortune; "I've won, +have I?" + +"You don't seem overpleased with your good luck," said the duke; +"give me your chance, and I shall know how to make better use of it." + +"No, gentlemen, I'll manage this affair myself." + +"Come on, then!--_vive la joie!_"--and with great joviality they +pursued their way to the Parc d'Amour. + +But they had been preceded in their journey to that hostelry by +Louise, attended by Cecil Hope and Mr Cocker. By the administration +of a douceur to the waiter, they obtained an _entrée_ to the +apartment designed for the baron and his prey, and had scarcely time +to ensconce themselves behind the window-curtain, when Miss Lucretia +was escorted into the room. There were no symptoms of any violent +resistance to her captors having been offered, and she took her seat +on the sofa without any perceptible alarm. + +"Well, them's curious people, them French!" she soliloquised when +the men had left her. "If that 'ere baron fell in love with a body, +couldn't he say so without all that rigmarole about Mr Bullion's +behaviour, and pulling a body nearly to pieces? I'm sure if he had +axed me in a civil way, I wouldn't have said no. But, lawkins! here +he comes." + +So saying, she enveloped herself in Louise's shawl, and pulled +Louise's bonnet farther on her face, and prepared to enact the part +of an offended, yet not altogether unforgiving beauty. But the +door, on being slowly opened, presented, not the countenance of the +baron, but the anxious face of Mr Bullion himself. The three French +nobles pushed him forward. "Go on," they said; "make the best use +of your eloquence. We will watch here, and guard the door against +Beauvilliers himself." + +The marquis, now thoroughly sobered, slowly advanced: "If I can save +this poor creature from the insolence of those _roués_, it will be +well worth the suffering it has cost. Trust to me, madam," he said, +in a very gentle voice, to the lady: "I will not suffer you to be +insulted while I live. Come with me, madam, and you shall not be +interrupted by ever a French profligate alive." On looking closely +at the still silent lady on the sofa, he was startled at recognising +a dress with which he was well acquainted. + +"In the name of heaven!" he said, "I adjure you to tell me who you +are. Are you--is it possible--can you be my Louise!" + +"No, Mr Bullion," replied Miss Lucretia, lifting up the veil, +and turning round to the trembling old man. "And I must say I'm +considerably surprised to find you in a situation like this." + +"And you, madam--yourself--how came you here?" + +"A young gentleman--nobleman, I should say--ran off with me here, +and I expected him every minute when you came in." + +"And Louise?" inquired the father, in an agitated voice--"when did +you leave her? Oh! my folly to let her a moment out of my sight!--to +reject Cecil Hope!--to bedizen myself in this ridiculous fashion! +Where, oh where is Louise?" + +"Here, sir," exclaimed that lady, coming forward from behind the +window-curtain. + +"And safe? Ah! but I need not ask. I see two honest Englishmen by +your side." + +"And one of them, sir, says he'll never leave it," said Louise. + +"Stop a moment," replied the marquis. "Ho! gentlemen, come in." + +At his request his companions entered the room. + +"Gentlemen," said the marquis, "when I determined to reclaim my +father's sword, I expected to find it bright as Bayard's, and +unstained with infamy or dishonour. When I wished to resume my +title, I hoped to find it a sign of the heroic virtues of my +ancestors, but not a cloak for falsehood and vice. I warn you, +sirs, your proceedings will be fatal to your order, and to your +country. For myself, I care not for this sword,"--he threw it on +the ground--"this filagree I despise,"--he took off his star and +ribbon--"and I advise you to leave this chamber as fast as you can +find it convenient." + +The French nobles obeyed. + +"Here, Cocker! off with all this silk and satin; get me my gaiters +and flaxen wig; and, please Heaven, one week will see us in the +little room above the warehouse." + +"Preparing, sir, to move into Hertfordshire?" inquired Louise, +leaning on Cecil's arm. + +"Ay, my child; and, in remembrance of this adventure, we shall hang +up among the pictures in the hall, + + THE SWORD OF HONOUR." + + + + +MEMOIRS OF KIRKALDY OF GRANGE.[24] + + [24] _Memoirs and Adventures of Sir Wm. Kirkaldy of Grange, Knight_, + &c. &c. WM. BLACKWOOD & SONS, Edinburgh and London. + + +It must be allowed that a perusal of Scottish history betrays more +anomalies than are to be found in the character of almost any other +people. It is not without reason that our southern neighbours +complain of the difficulty of thoroughly understanding our national +idiosyncrasy. At one time we appear to be the most peaceable race +upon the surface of the earth--quiet, patient, and enduring; +stubborn, perhaps, if interfered with, but, if let alone, in no way +anxious to pick a quarrel. Take us in another mood, and gunpowder is +not more inflammable. We are ready to go to the death, for a cause +about which an Englishman would not trouble himself; and amongst +ourselves, we divide into factions, debate, squabble, and fight with +an inveteracy far more than commensurate with the importance of the +quarrel. Sometimes we seem to have no romance; at other times we are +perfect Quixotes. The amalgamated blood of the Saxon and the Celt +seems, even in its union, to display the characteristics of either +race. We rush into extremes: one day we appear over-cautious, and on +the next, the _perfervidum ingenium Scotorum_ prevails. + +If these remarks be true as applied to the present times, they +become still more conspicuous when we regard the troublous days of +our ancestors. At one era, as in the reign of David I., we find +the Scottish nation engaged, heart and soul, in one peculiar phase +of religious excitement. Cathedrals and abbeys are starting up in +every town. All that infant art can do--and yet, why call it infant, +since, in architecture at least, it has never reached a higher +maturity?--is lavished upon the structure of our fanes. Melrose, and +Jedburgh, and Holyrood, and a hundred more magnificent edifices, +rise up like exhalations throughout a poor and barren country; the +people are proud in their faith, and perhaps even prouder in the +actual splendour of their altars. A few centuries roll by, and we +find the same nation deliberately undoing and demolishing the works +of their forefathers. Hewn stone and carved cornices, tracery, +mullions, and buttresses, have now become abominations in their +sight. Not only must the relics of the saints be scattered to the +winds of heaven, and their images ground into dust, but every church +in which these were deposited or displayed, must be dismantled as +the receptacle of pollution. The hammer swings again, but not with +the same pious purpose as of yore. Once it was used to build; now +it is heaved to destroy. Aisle and archway echo to the thunder of +its strokes, and, amidst a roar of iconoclastic wrath, the venerable +edifice goes down. Another short lapse of time, and we are lamenting +the violence of the past, and striving to prop, patch up, and +rebuild what little remnant has been spared of the older works of +devotion. + +The same anomalies will be found if we turn from the ecclesiastical +to the political picture. Sometimes there is a spirit of loyalty +manifested, for which it would be difficult to find a parallel. The +whole nation gathers round the person of James IV.; and earl and +yeoman, lord and peasant, chief and vassal, lay down their lives +at Flodden for their king. His successor James V., in no respect +unworthy of his crown, dies of a broken heart, deserted by his peers +and their retainers. The unfortunate Mary, welcomed to her country +with acclamation, is made the victim of the basest intrigues, and +forced to seek shelter, and find death in the dominions of her +treacherous enemy. The divine right, in its widest meaning and +acceptation, is formally recognised by the Scottish estates as the +attribute of James VII.; three years afterwards, a new convention +is prompt to recognise an alien. Half a century further on, we are +found offering the gage of battle to England in support of the +exiled family. + +This singular variety of mood, of which the foregoing are a +few instances, is no doubt partly attributable to the peculiar +relationship which existed between the crown and the principal +nobility. The latter were not cousins by courtesy only--they were +intimately connected with the royal family, and some of them were +near the succession. Hence arose jealousy amongst themselves, a +system of feud and intrigue, which was perpetuated for centuries, +and a constant effort, on the part of one or other of the +conflicting magnates, to gain possession and keep custody of the +royal person, whenever minority or weakness appeared to favour the +attempt. But we cannot help thinking, that the disposition of the +people ought also to be taken into account. Fierce when thwarted, +and with a memory keenly retentive of injury, the Scotsman is in +reality a much more impulsive being than his southern neighbour. His +sense of justice and order is not so strongly developed, but his +passion glows with a fire all the more intense because to outward +appearance it is smothered. His ideas of social duty are different +from those of the Englishman. Kindred is a closer tie--identity of +name and family is a bond of singular union. Clanship, in the broad +acceptation of the word, has died out for all practical purposes; +chieftainship is still a recognised and a living principle. The +feudal times, though gone, have left their traces on the national +character. Little as baronial sway, too often tantamount to sheer +oppression, can have contributed towards the happiness of the +people, we still recur to the history of these troublous days with a +relish and fondness which can hardly be explained, save through some +undefined and subtle sympathy of inheritance. Though the objects for +which they contended are now mere phantoms of speculation we yet +continue to feel and to speak as if we were partisans of the cause +of our ancestors, and to contest old points with as much ardour as +though they were new ones of living interest to ourselves. + +We have been led into this strain of thought by the perusal of a +work, strictly authentic as a history, and yet as absorbing in +interest as the most coloured and glowing romance. Sir William +Kirkaldy of Grange, the subject of these Memoirs, played a most +conspicuous part in the long and intricate struggles which convulsed +Scotland, from the death of James V. until the latter part of the +reign of Queen Mary. Foremost in battle and in council, we find his +name prominently connected with every leading event of the period, +and his influence and example held in higher estimation than those +of noblemen who were greatly his superiors in rank, following, +and fortune. In fact, Kirkaldy achieved, by his own talent and +indomitable valour, a higher reputation, and exercised, for a time, +a greater influence over the destinies of the nation, than was ever +before possessed by a private Scottish gentleman, with the glorious +exception of Wallace. In an age when the sword was the sole arbiter +of public contest and of private quarrel, it was a proud distinction +to be reputed, not only at home but abroad--not only by the voice of +Scotland, but by that of England and France--the best and bravest +soldier, and the most accomplished cavalier of his time. Mixed up in +the pages of general history, too often turbidly and incoherently +written, the Knight of Grange may not be estimated, in the scale of +importance, at the level of such personages as the subtle Moray, or +the vindictive and treacherous Morton: viewed as all individual, +through the medium of these truthful and most fascinating memoirs, +he will be found at least their equal as a leader and a politician, +and far their superior as a generous and heroic man. + +His father, Sir James Kirkaldy, was a person of no mean family or +reputation. He occupied, for a considerable time, the office of Lord +High Treasurer of Scotland, and, according to our author-- + + "Enjoyed, in a very high degree, the favour and confidence of + King James V.; and though innumerable efforts were made by his + mortal foe Cardinal Beatoun, and others, to bring him into + disgrace as a promoter of the Reformation, they all proved + ineffectual, and the wary old baron maintained his influence to + the last." + +Old Sir James seems to have been one of those individuals with whom +it is neither safe nor pleasant to differ in opinion. According +to his brother-in-law, Sir James Melville of Halhill, he was "a +stoute man, who always offered, by single combate, and at point of +the sword, to maintain whatever he said;" a testimonial which, we +observe, has been most fitly selected as the motto of this book, the +son having been quite as much addicted to the wager of battle as the +father; nor, though a strenuous supporter of the Reformation, does +he appear to have imbibed much of that meekness which is inculcated +by holy writ. He was not the sort of man whom John Bright would have +selected to second a motion at a Peace Congress; indeed, the mere +sight of him would have caused the voice of Elihu Burritt to subside +into a quaver of dismay. Cardinal Beatoun, that proud and licentious +prelate, to whose tragical end we shall presently have occasion to +advert, was the personal and bitter enemy of the Treasurer, as he +was of every other independent Scotsman who would not truckle to his +power. But James V., though at times too facile, would not allow +himself to be persuaded into so dangerous an act as countenancing +prosecutions for heresy against any of his martial subjects; and, +so long as he lived, the over-weening bigotry and arrogance of +the priesthood were held in check. But other troubles brought the +good king to an untimely end. James had mortally offended some of +his turbulent nobles, by causing the authority of the law to be +vindicated without respect to rank or person. He had deservedly won +for himself the title of King of the Commons; and was, in fact, even +in that early age, bent upon a thorough reform of the abuses of +the feudal system. But he had proud, jealous, and stubborn men to +deal with. They saw, not without apprehension for their own fate, +that title and birth were no longer accepted as palliatives of +sedition and crime; that the inroads, disturbances, and harryings +which they and their fathers had practised, were now regarded with +detestation by the crown, and threatened with merited punishment. +Some strong but necessary examples made them quail for their future +supremacy, and discontent soon ripened into something like absolute +treason. Add to this, that for a long time the nobility of Scotland +had fixed a covetous eye upon the great possessions of the church. +In no country of Europe, considering its extent and comparative +wealth, was the church better endowed than in Scotland; and the +endeavours of the monks, who, with all their faults, were not blind +to the advantages derivable from the arts of peace, had greatly +raised their property in point of value. The confiscations which +had taken place in Protestantised England, whereof Woburn Abbey may +be cited as a notable example, had aroused to the fullest extent +the cupidity of the rapacious nobles. They longed to see the day +when, unsupported by the regal power, the church lands in Scotland +could be annexed by each iron-handed baron to his own domain; when, +at the head of their armed and dissolute jackmen, they could oust +the feeble possessors of the soil from the heritages they had so +long enjoyed as a corporation, and enrich themselves by plundering +the consecrated stores of the abbeys. These were the feelings +and desires which led most of them to lend a willing ear to the +preaching of the fathers of the Reformation. They were desirous, not +only of lessening the royal authority, but of transferring the whole +property of the clergy to themselves; and this double object led to +a combination which resulted in the passive defeat of the Scottish +army at Solway Moss. + +Poor King James could not bear up against the shock of this shameful +desertion. Mr Tytler thus describes his latter moments:-- + + "When in this state, intelligence was brought him that his queen + had given birth to a daughter. At another time it would have + been happy news; but now, it seemed to the poor monarch the + last drop of bitterness which was reserved for him. Both his + sons were dead. Had this child been a boy, a ray of hope, he + seemed to feel, might yet have visited his heart; he received + the messenger and was informed of that event without welcome + or almost recognition; but wandering back in his thoughts to + the time when the daughter of Bruce brought to his ancestor + the dowry of the kingdom, observed with melancholy emphasis, + 'It came with a lass, and it will pass with a lass.' A few of + his most favoured friends and counsellers stood around his + couch; the monarch stretched out his hand for them to kiss; and + regarding them for some moments with a look of great sweetness + and placidity, turned himself upon the pillow and expired. He + died 13th December 1542, in the thirty-first year of his age, + and the twenty-ninth of his reign; leaving an only daughter, + Mary, an infant of six days old, who succeeded to the crown." + +Amongst those who stood around that memorable deathbed were the +Lord High Treasurer, young William Kirkaldy his son, and Cardinal +Beatoun. There was peace for a moment over the body of the anointed +dead! + +But even the death of a king makes a light impression on this busy +and intriguing world. The struggle for mastery now commenced in +right earnest--for the only wall which had hitherto separated the +contending factions of the nobility and the clergy had given way. +Beatoun and Arran were both candidates for the regency, which the +latter succeeded in gaining; and, after a temporary alienation, +these two combined against an influence which began to show itself +in a threatening form. Henry VIII. of England considered this an +excellent opportunity for carrying out those designs against the +independence of the northern country, which had been entertained +by several of his predecessors; and for that purpose he proposed +to negotiate a marriage between his son Edward and the Princess +Mary. Such an alliance was of course decidedly opposed to the views +of the Catholic party in Scotland, and, moreover, was calculated +to excite the utmost jealousy of the Scottish people, who well +understood the true but recondite motive of the proposal. So long as +Beatoun, whose interest was identified with that of France, existed, +Henry was fully aware that his scheme never could be carried into +execution; and accordingly, with that entire want of principle which +he exhibited on every occasion, he took advantage of their position +to tamper with the Scottish barons who had been made prisoners at +Solway Moss. In this he so far succeeded, that a regular conspiracy +was entered into for the destruction of the cardinal, and only +defeated by his extreme sagacity and caution. It will be seen +hereafter that the cardinal did not fall a victim to this dastardly +English plot, but to private revenge, no doubt augmented and +inflamed by the consideration of his arrogance and cruelty. + +Beatoun, one of the most able and also dissolute men of his day, +was a younger son of the Laird of Balfour--yet had, notwithstanding +every disadvantage, contrived very early to attain his high +position. He was hated, not only by the nobility, but by the +lesser barons, from whose own ranks he had risen, on account of +his intolerable pride, his rapacity, and the unscrupulous manner +in which he chose to exercise his power. Among the barons of Fife, +always a disunited and wrangling county, he had few adherents: and +with the Kirkaldys, and their relatives, the Melvilles, he had an +especial quarrel. Shortly after the death of James, the Treasurer +was dismissed from his office, an affront which the "stoute man" +was not likely to forget; and his son, then a mere youth, seems to +have participated in his feelings. But the cruelty of Beatoun was +at least the nominal cause which led to his destruction. Wishart, +the famous Reforming preacher, had fallen into the hands of the +cardinal, and was confined in his castle of St Andrews, of which our +author gives us the following faithful sketch:-- + + "On the rocky shore, to the northward of the venerable city of + St Andrews, stand the ruins of the ancient Episcopal palace, in + other years the residence of the primates of Scotland. Those + weatherbeaten remains, now pointed out to visitors by the + ciceroni of the place, present only the fragments of an edifice + erected by Archbishop Hamilton, the successor of Cardinal + Beatoun, and are somewhat in the style of an antique Scottish + manor-house; but very different was the aspect of that vast + bastille which had the proud cardinal for lord, and contained + within its massive walls all the appurtenances requisite for + ecclesiastical tyranny, epicurean luxury, lordly grandeur, + and military defence--at once a fortress, a monastery, an + inquisition, and a palace. + + "The sea-mews and cormorants screaming among the wave-beaten + rocks and bare walls now crumbling on that bleak promontory, + and echoing only to drenching surf, as it rolls up the rough + shelving shore, impart a peculiarly desolate effect to the + grassy ruins, worn with the blasts of the German Ocean, gray + with the storms of winter, and the damp mists of March and + April--an effect that is greatly increased by the venerable + aspect of the dark and old ecclesiastical city to the southward, + decaying, deserted, isolated, and forgotten, with its + magnificent cathedral, once one of the finest gothic structures + in the world, but now, shattered by the hands of man and time, + passing rapidly away. Of the grand spire which arose from the + cross, and of its five lofty towers, little more than the + foundations can now be traced, while a wilderness of ruins on + every hand attest the departed splendours of St Andrews." + +George Wishart, the unhappy preacher, was burned before the Castle +on the 28th March 1545, under circumstances of peculiar barbarity. +We refer to the book for a proper description of the death-scene of +the Martyr, whose sufferings were calmly witnessed by the ruthless +and implacable Cardinal. But the avenger of blood was at hand, in +the person of Norman Leslie, Master of Rothes. This young man, +who was of a most fiery and intractable spirit, had some personal +dispute with the cardinal, whom he accused of having attempted to +defraud him of an estate. High words followed, and Norman rode off +in wrath to the house of his uncle, John Leslie of Parkhill, a moody +and determined Reformer, who had already vowed bloody vengeance for +the execution of the unfortunate Wishart. Finding him apt for any +enterprise, Norman instantly despatched messengers to the Kirkaldys +of Grange, the Melvilles of Raith and Carnbee, and to Carmichael of +Kilmadie, desiring them to meet for an enterprise of great weight +and importance; and the summons having been responded to, these few +men determined to rid the country of one whom they considered a +murderer and an oppressor. + +The manner in which this act of terrible retribution was executed +is too well known to the student of history to require repetition. +Suffice it to say that, by a _coup-de-main_, sixteen armed men made +themselves masters of the castle of St Andrews, overpowered and +dispersed the retainers of the cardinal, and quenched the existence +of that haughty prelate in his blood. William Kirkaldy was not the +slayer, but, as an accomplice, he must bear whatever load of odium +is cast upon the perpetrators of the deed. We cannot help thinking +that our author exhibits an unnecessary degree of horror in this +instance. Far be it from us to palliate bloodshed, in any age or +under any provocation: neither do we agree with John Knox, that the +extermination of Beatoun was a "godly fact." But we doubt whether it +can be called a murder. In the first place, old Kirkaldy knew, on +the authority of James V., that a list of three hundred and sixty +names, including his own and those of his most immediate friends, +had been made out by the cardinal, as a catalogue of victims who +were to be burned for heresy. This contemplated atrocity, far worse +than the massacre of St Bartholomew, might not, indeed, have been +carried into effect, even on account of its magnitude; but the +mere knowledge that it had been planned, was enough to justify the +Kirkaldys, and those marked out for impeachment, in considering +Beatoun as their mortal foe. That the cardinal never departed from +his bloody design, is apparent from the fact, that, after his death, +a paper was found in his repositories, ordaining that "Norman +Leslie, sheriff of Fife, John Leslie, father's brother to Norman, +the Lairds of Grange, _elder and younger_, Sir James Learmonth of +Dairsie, and the Laird of Raith, should either have been slain or +else taken." The law at that period could afford no security against +such a design, so that Beatoun's assassination may have been an act +of necessary self-defence, which it would be extremely difficult to +blame. As to the sacrilege, we cannot regard that as an aggravation. +If a prelate of the Roman Church, like Beatoun, chose to make +himself notorious to the world by the number and scandal of his +profligacies; if, with a carnality and disregard of appearances not +often exhibited by laymen, he turned his palace into a seraglio; and +if his mistress was actually surprised, at the time of the attack, +in the act of escaping from his bedchamber,--great allowance must +be made for the obtuseness of the men who could not understand the +relevancy of the plea of priesthood which he offered, in order that +his holy calling might shield him from secular consequences. But +further, is the fate of Wishart to go for nothing? Setting the +natural influences of bigotry aside, and with every consideration +for the zeal which could hurry even so good a man as Sir Thomas More +to express, in words at least, a desire to see the faggot and the +stake in full operation--what shall we say to the individual who +could calmly issue his infernal orders, and, in the full pomp of +ecclesiastical vanity, become a pleased spectator of the sufferings +of a human being, undergoing the most hideous of all imaginable +deaths? Truly this, that the brute deserved to die in return; and +that we, at all events, shall not stigmatise those who killed him as +guilty of murder. Poor old Sharpe was murdered, if ever man was, in +a hideous and atrocious manner; but as for Beatoun, he deserved to +die, and his death was invested with a sort of judicial sanction, +having been perpetrated in presence of the sheriff of the bounds. + +The tidings of this act of vengeance spread, not only through +Scotland, but through Europe, like wildfire. According as men +differed in religious faith, they spoke of it either with horror or +exultation. Even the most moderate of the reforming party were slow +to blame the deed which freed them from a bloody persecutor; and Sir +David Lindesay of the Mount, the witty and satirical scholar, did +not characterise it more severely than as expressed in the following +verses:-- + + "As for the cardinal, I grant + He was the man we well might want; + God will forgive it soon. + But of a truth, the sooth to say, + Although the loon be well away, + The deed was _foully done_." + +Meanwhile the conspirators had conceived the daring scheme of +holding the castle of St Andrews against all comers, and of setting +the authority of the regent at defiance. They calculated upon +receiving support from England, in case France thought fit to +interfere; and perhaps they imagined that a steady resistance on +their part might excite general insurrection in Scotland. Besides +this, they had retained in custody the son and heir of the Regent +Arran, whom they had found in the castle, and who was a valuable +hostage in their hands. The force they could command was not great. +Amongst others, John Knox joined them with his three pupils; several +Fife barons espoused their cause; and altogether they mustered +about one hundred and fifty armed men. This was a small body, but +the defences of the place were more than usually complete, and they +were well munimented with artillery. Accordingly, though formally +summoned, they peremptorily refused to surrender. + +John Knox, when he entered the castle, was probably under the +impression that he was joining a company of men, serious in their +deportment, rigid in their conversation, and self-denying in their +habits. If so, he must very soon have discovered his mistake. The +young Reforming gentry were not one whit more scrupulous than +their Catholic coevals: Norman Leslie, though brave as steel, was +a thorough-paced desperado; and, from the account given by our +author of the doings at St Andrews, it may easily be understood how +uncongenial such quarters must have been to the stern and ascetic +Reformer. + +Arran had probably no intention of pushing matters to extremity, +though compelled, for appearance' sake, to invest the fortress. +After a siege of three weeks it remained unreduced; and a pestilence +which broke out in the town of St Andrews, afforded the regent a +pretext for agreeing to an armistice. Hitherto the conspirators had +received the countenance and support of Henry VIII., who remitted +them large sums from time to time, and promised even more active +assistance. But this never arrived. Death at last put a stop to +the bereavements of this unconscionable widower; and thereupon the +French court despatched a fleet of one-and-twenty vessels of war, +under the command of Leon Strozzio--a famous Florentine noble, +who had risen in the Order of the Hospital to the rank of Prior +of Capua--for the purpose of reducing the stubborn stronghold of +heresy. Strozzio's name was so well known as that of a most skilful +commander and tactician, and the weight of the ordnance he brought +with him was so great, that the besieged had no hope of escaping +this time; yet, on being summoned, they replied, with the most +undaunted bravery, that they would defend the castle against the +united powers of Scotland, England, and France. With such resolute +characters as these, it was no use to parley further; and the Prior +accordingly set about his task with a dexterity which put to shame +the feeble tactics of Arran. + + "By sea and land the siege was pressed with great fury. From the + ramparts of the Abbey Church, from the college, and other places + in the adjoining streets, the French and Scottish cannoneers + maintained a perpetual cannonade upon the castle. Those soldiers + who manned the steeples and St Salvador's tower occupied such + an elevation, that, by depressing their cannon, they shot down + into the inner quadrangle of the castle, the pavement of which + could be seen dabbled with the blood of the garrison; and, to + aggravate the increasing distress of the latter, the pestilence + found its way among them--many died, and all were dismayed. + Walter Melville, one of their bravest leaders, fell deadly sick; + while watching, warding, and scanty fare, were rapidly wearing + out the rest; and John Knox dinned continually in their ears, + that their present perils were the just reward of their former + corrupt lives and licentiousness, and reliance on England rather + than Heaven. + + "'For the first twenty days of this siege,' said he, 'ye + prospered bravely: but when ye triumphed at your victory, I + lamented, and ever said that ye saw not what I saw. When ye + boasted of the thickness of your walls, I said they would be + but as egg-shells: when ye vaunted, England will rescue us--I + said, ye shall not see it; but ye shall be delivered into your + enemies' hands, and carried afar off into a strange country.' + + "This gloomy prophesying was but cold comfort for those whom his + precepts and exhortations had urged to rebellion, to outlawry, + and to bloodshed; but their affairs were fast approaching a + crisis." + +If John Knox showed little judgment in adopting this tone of +vaticination, he is, at all events, entitled to some credit for his +courage--since Norman Leslie possessed a temper which it was rather +dangerous to aggravate, and must sometimes have been sorely tempted +to toss the querulous Reformer into the sea. + +The garrison finally surrendered to Leon Strozzio, but not until +battlement and wall had been breached, and an escalade rendered +practicable. + +The prisoners, including William Kirkaldy, were conveyed to France, +and there subjected to treatment which varied according to their +station. Those of knightly rank were incarcerated in separate +fortresses; the remainder were chained to oars in the galleys on +the Loire. John Knox was one of those who were forced to undergo +this ignominious punishment; and we quite agree with our author in +holding that, "it is not probable, that the lash of the tax-master +increased his goodwill towards popery." + +William Kirkaldy was shut up in the great castle of Mont Saint +Michel, along with Norman Leslie, his uncle of Parkhill, and Peter +Carmichael of Kilmadie. But, however strong the fortress, it +was imprudent in their gaolers to lodge four such fiery spirits +together. They resolved to break prison; and did so, having, by an +ingenious ruse, succeeded in overpowering the garrison, and, after +some vicissitudes and wanderings, made good their escape to England. + +After this event there is a blank of some years, during which we +hear little of Kirkaldy. It is, however, an important period in +northern history, for it includes the battle of Pinkie, the removal +of the child, Queen Mary, to France, and her betrothment to the +Dauphin. Kirkaldy seems not to have arrived in England until the +death of Edward VI., when the Romanist party attained a temporary +ascendency. We next find him in the service of Henry II. of France, +engaged in the wars between that monarch and the Emperor Charles V. +In these campaigns, says our author, by his bravery and conduct, he +soon attained that eminent distinction and reputation, as a skilful +and gallant soldier, which ceased only with his life. + +Kirkaldy was not the only member of the stout garrison of St Andrews +who found employment in the French service. Singularly enough, +Norman Leslie, the head of the conspirators, had also a command, and +was in high favour with the famous Constable Anne de Montmorencie. +His death, which occurred the day before the battle of Renti, is +thus graphically recounted in the Memoirs, and is a picture worth +preserving:-- + + "The day before the battle, the constable, perceiving by the + manœuvres of the Spanish troops that Charles meant to take + possession of certain heights, which sloped abruptly down to + the camp or bivouac of the French, sent up Leslie's Scottish + lances and other horsemen to skirmish with these Imperialists, + and drive them back. Melville, his fellow-soldier, thus + describes him:--In view of the whole French army, the Master + of Rothes, 'with thirty Scotsmen, rode up the hill upon a fair + gray gelding. He had, above his coat of black velvet, his coat + of armour, with two broad white crosses, one before and the + other behind, with sleeves of mail, and a red bonnet upon his + head, whereby he was seen and known afar off by the constable, + the Duke d'Enghien, and the Prince of Condé.' His party was + diminished to seven by the time he came within lance-length of + the Imperialists, who were sixty in number; but he burst upon + them with the force of a thunderbolt, escaping the fire of their + hand-culverins, which they discharged incessantly against him. + He struck five from their saddles with his long lance, before it + broke into splinters; then, drawing his sword, he rushed again + and again among them, with the heedless bravery for which he had + ever been distinguished. At the critical moment of this unequal + contest, of seven Scottish knights against sixty Spaniards, a + troop of Imperial spearmen were hastily riding along the hill to + join in the encounter. By this time Leslie had received several + bullets in his person; and, finding himself unable to continue + the conflict longer, he dashed spurs into his horse, galloped + back to the constable, and fell, faint and exhausted, from his + saddle, with the blood pouring through his burnished armour on + the turf. + + "By the king's desire he was immediately borne to the royal + tent, where the Duke d'Enghien and Prince Louis of Condé + remarked to Henry, that 'Hector of Troy had not behaved more + valiantly than Norman Leslie.' + + "So highly did that brave prince value Norman Leslie, and so + greatly did he deplore his death, that all the survivors of his + Scottish troop of lances were, under Crichton of Brunstane, + sent back to their own country, laden with rewards and honours; + and, by his influence, such as were exiles were restored by the + regent to their estates and possessions, as a recompense for + their valour on the frontiers of Flanders." + +Kirkaldy seems to have remained in France until the unfortunate +death of Henry II., who was accidentally killed in a tournament. +The estimation in which he was held, after his achievements in the +wars of Picardy, may be learned from the following contemporary +testimony:-- + +"I heard Henry II.," Melville states, "point unto him and +say--'Yonder is one of the most valiant men of our age.'" And the +same writer mentions "that the proud old Montmorencie, the great +constable of France, treated the exiled Kirkaldy with such deference +that he never addressed him with his head covered." This was high +tribute, when paid to a soldier then under thirty years of age. + +Ten years after he had been conveyed a prisoner from St Andrews on +board the French galley, Kirkaldy returned to Scotland, but not to +repose under the laurels he had already won. Soon after this we find +him married, in possession, through the death of his father, of his +ancestral estates, the intimate friend of Maitland of Lethington and +of Lord James, afterwards the Regent Moray, and a stanch supporter +of the Lords of the Congregation. This period furnishes to us one +of the most melancholy chapters of Scottish history. Mary of Guise, +the queen-regent, on the one hand, was resolute to put down the +growing heresy; on the other, the landed nobility were determined to +overthrow the Catholic church. Knox, who had by this time returned +from France, and other Reformed preachers, did their utmost to fan +the flame; and the result was that melancholy work of incendiarism +and ruin, which men of all parties must bitterly deplore. Then came +the French auxiliaries under D'Oisel, wasting the land, ravaging the +estates of the Protestants, and burning their houses and villages; +a savage mode of warfare, from which Kirkaldy suffered much--Fife +having been pillaged from one end to the other--but for which he +exacted an ample vengeance. The details of this partisan warfare are +given with much minuteness, but great spirit, by the chronicler; and +it did not cease until the death of Mary of Guise. + +A new victim was now to be offered to the distempered spirit of the +age: on the 19th August 1561, the young Queen Mary arrived at Leith. +She was then in the nineteenth year of her age, and endowed with +all that surpassing loveliness which was at once her dower and her +misfortune. Her arrival was dreaded by the preachers, who detested +the school in which she had been educated, and the influence she +might be enabled to exercise; but the great mass of the people +hailed her coming with acclamations of unfeigned delight:-- + + "Despite the efforts of these dark-browed Reformers, agitated + by the memory of her good and gallant father,--the king of + the poor--by that of her thirteen years' absence from them, + and stirred by that inborn spirit of loyalty which the Scots + possessed in so intense a degree, the people received their + beautiful queen with the utmost enthusiasm, and outvied each + other in her praise. + + "Her mother's dying advice to secure the support of the + Protestants, and to cultivate the friendship of their leaders, + particularly Maitland of Lethington and 'Kirkaldy of Grange, + whom the Constable de Montmorencie had named the first soldier + in Europe,' had been faithfully conveyed to Mary in France by + the handsome young Count de Martigues, the Sieur de la Brosse, + the Bishop of Amiens, and others, who had witnessed the last + moments of that dearly-loved mother in the castle of Edinburgh; + and Mary treasured that advice in her heart--but it availed her + not." + +Hurried on by her evil destiny, and persecuted by intrigues which +had their origin in the fertile brain of Elizabeth, Mary determined +to bestow her hand upon Darnley, a weak, dissolute, and foolish +boy, whose only recommendations were his birth and his personal +beauty. Such a marriage never could, under any circumstances, have +proved a happy one. At that juncture it was peculiarly unfortunate, +as it roused the jealousy of the house of Hamilton against that +of Lennox; and was further bitterly opposed by Moray, a cold, +calculating, selfish man, who concealed, under an appearance of +zeal for the Protestant faith, the most restless, unnatural, and +insatiable ambition. Talents he did possess, and of no ordinary +kind: above all, he was gifted with the faculty of imposing upon men +more open and honourable than himself. Knox was a mere tool in his +hands: Kirkaldy of Grange regarded him as a pattern of wisdom. For +years, this straightforward soldier surrendered his judgment to the +hypocrite, and, unfortunately, did not detect his mistake until the +Queen was involved in a mesh from which extrication was impossible. +Moray's first attempt at rebellion proved an arrant failure: the +people refused to join his standard, and he, with the other leading +insurgents, was compelled to seek refuge in England. + +All might have gone well but for the folly of the idiot Darnley. +No long period of domestic intercourse was requisite to convince +the unfortunate Queen that she had thrown away her affections, +and bestowed her hand upon an individual totally incapable of +appreciating the one, and utterly unworthy of the other. Darnley +was a low-minded, fickle, and imperious fool--vicious as a colt, +capricious as a monkey, and stubborn as an Andalusian mule. Instead +of showing the slightest gratitude to his wife and mistress, for +the preference which had raised him from obscurity to a position +for which kings were suitors, he repaid the vast boon by a series +of petty and unmanly persecutions. He aimed to be not only +prince-consort, but master; and because this was denied him, he +threw himself precipitately into the counsels of the enemies of +Mary. It was not difficult to sow the seeds of jealousy in a mind so +well prepared to receive them; and Riccio, the Italian secretary, +was marked out by Ruthven and Morton, the secret adherents of +Moray, as the victim. Even this scheme, though backed by Darnley, +might have miscarried, had not Mary been driven into an act which +roused, while it almost justified, the worst fears of the Protestant +party in Scotland. This was her adhesion to the celebrated Roman +Catholic League, arising from a coalition which had been concluded +between France, Spain, and the Emperor, for the destruction of +the Protestant cause in Europe. "It was," says Tytler, "a design +worthy of the dark and unscrupulous politicians by whom it had been +planned--Catherine of Medicis and the Duke of Alva. In the summer +of the preceding year, the queen-dowager of France and Alva had met +at Bayonne, during a progress in which she conducted her youthful +son and sovereign, Charles IX., through the southern provinces of +his kingdom; and there, whilst the court was dissolved in pleasure, +those secret conferences were held which issued in the resolution +that toleration must be at an end, and that the only safety for +the Roman Catholic faith was the extermination of its enemies." To +this document, Mary, at the instigation of Riccio, who was in the +interest of Rome, and who really possessed considerable influence +with his mistress, affixed her signature. The bond was abortive for +its ostensible purposes, but it was the death-warrant of the Italian +secretary, and ultimately of the Queen. + +It is not our province to usurp the functions of the historian, and +therefore we pass willingly over that intricate portion of history +which ends with the murder of Darnley. It was notoriously the +work of Bothwell, but not his alone, for Lethington, Huntly, and +Argyle, were also deeply implicated. Bothwell now stands forward +as a prominent character of the age. He was a bold, reckless, +desperate adventurer, with little to recommend him save personal +daring, and a fidelity to his mistress which hitherto had remained +unshaken. Lethington, in all probability, merely regarded him as an +instrument, but Bothwell had a higher aim. With daring ambition, he +aimed at the possession of the person of Mary, and actually achieved +his purpose. + +This unhappy and most unequal union roused the ire of the Scottish +nobles. Even such of them as, intimidated by the reckless character +of Bothwell, had sworn to defend him if impeached for the slaughter, +and had recommended him as a fitting match for Mary, now took +up arms, under the pretext that he had violently abducted their +sovereign. We fear it cannot be asserted with truth that much +violence was used. Poor Queen Mary had found, by bitter experience, +that she could hardly depend upon one of her principal subjects. +Darnley, Moray, Morton, Lethington, and Arran, each had betrayed +her in turn; everywhere her steps were surrounded by a net of the +blackest treachery: not one true heart seemed left to beat with +loyalty for its Queen. Elizabeth, with fiendish malice, was goading +on her subjects to rebellion. The Queen of England had determined to +ruin the power of her sister monarch; the elderly withered spinster +detested the young and blooming mother. Why, then, should it be +matter of great marvel to those who know the acuteness of female +sensibility, if, in the hour of desertion and desolation, Mary +should have allowed the weakness of the woman to overcome the pride +of the sovereign, and should have opposed but feeble resistance to +the advances of the only man who hitherto had remained stanch to her +cause, and whose arm seemed strong enough to insure her personal +protection? It is not the first time that a daring villain has been +taken for a hero by a distressed and persecuted woman. + +But Bothwell had no friends. The whole of the nobles were against +him; and the Commons, studiously taught to believe that Mary was a +consenting party to Darnley's death, were hostile to their Queen. +Kirkaldy, at the instance of Moray, came over from his patrimonial +estates to join the confederates, and his first feat in arms was +an attack on Borthwick Castle, from which Bothwell and the Queen +escaped with the utmost difficulty. Then came the action, if such +it can be called, of Carberry Hill, when Bothwell challenged his +accusers to single combat--a defiance which was accepted by Lord +Lindesay of the Byres, but prevented from being brought to the test +of combat by the voluntary submission of the Queen. Seeing that her +forces were utterly inadequate to oppose those of the assembled +nobles, she sent for Sir William Kirkaldy of Grange, as a knight +in whose honour she could thoroughly confide, and, after a long +interview, agreed to pass over to the troops of the confederates, +provided they would again acknowledge and obey her as their +sovereign. This being promised, she took her last leave of Bothwell, +and her first step on the road which ultimately brought her to +Lochleven. + +We must refer our readers to the volume for the spirited account +of these events, and of the expedition undertaken by Kirkaldy in +pursuit of Bothwell, his narrow escapes, and sea-fights among the +shores of Shetland, and the capture of the fugitive's vessel on the +coast of Norway. Neither will our space permit us to dwell upon the +particulars of the battle of Langside, that last action hazarded +and lost by the adherents of Queen Mary, just after her escape from +Lochleven, and before she quitted the Scottish soil for ever. But +for the tactics of Kirkaldy, the issue of that fight might have been +different; and deeply is it to be regretted that, before that time, +the eyes of the Knight of Grange had not been opened to the perfidy +of Moray, whom he loved too trustingly, and served far too well. It +was only after Mary was in the power of Elizabeth that he knew how +much she had been betrayed. + +Under the regency of Moray, Kirkaldy held the post of governor of +the castle of Edinburgh, and retained it until the fortress went +down before the battery of the English cannon. + +He was also elected Lord Provost of Edinburgh--a dignity which, +before that time, had been held by the highest nobles of the +land, but which has since deteriorated under the influence of the +Union, and bungled acts of corporation. He was in this position +when he seems first to have perceived that the queen had been made +the victim of a deep-laid plot of treachery--that Moray was the +arch-conspirator--and that he, along with other men, who wished +well both to their country and their sovereign, had been used as +instruments for his own advancement by the false and unscrupulous +statesman. The arrest of Chatelherault and of Lord Herries, both of +them declared partisans of Mary, and their committal to the castle +of Edinburgh, a measure against which Kirkaldy remonstrated, was the +earliest act which aroused his suspicions:-- + + "Upon this, Mr John Wood, a pious friend of the regent's, + observed to Kirkaldy, in the true spirit of his party,-- + + "'I marvel, sir, that you are offended at these two being + committed to ward; for how shall _we_, who are the defenders of + my lord regent, get rewards but by the ruin of such men?' + + "'Ha!' rejoined Kirkaldy sternly, 'is that your holiness? I see + naught among ye but envy, greed, and ambition, whereby ye will + wreck a good regent and ruin the realm!'--a retort which made + him many enemies among the train of Moray." + +But another event, which occurred soon afterwards, left no doubt in +the mind of Kirkaldy as to the nature of Moray's policy. Maitland of +Lethington, unquestionably the ablest Scottish diplomatist of his +time, but unstable and shifting, as diplomatists often are, had seen +cause to adopt very different views from those which he formerly +professed. Whilst Mary was in power, he had too often thrown the +weight of his influence and council against her: no sooner was +she a fugitive and prisoner, than his loyalty appeared to revive. +It is impossible now to say whether he was touched with remorse; +whether, on reflection, he became convinced that he had not acted +the part of a patriotic Scotsman; or whether he was merely led, +through excitement, to launch himself into a new sea of political +intrigue. This, at least, is certain, that he applied himself, heart +and soul, to baffle the machinations of Elizabeth, and to deliver +the unhappy Mary from the toils in which she was involved. It was +Lethington who conceived the project of restoring Mary to liberty, +by bringing about a marriage between her and the Duke of Norfolk; +and the knowledge of his zeal on that occasion incensed Elizabeth +to the utmost. That vindictive queen, who had always found Moray +most ready to obey her wishes, opened a negotiation with him for +the destruction of his former friend; and the regent, not daring to +thwart her, took measures to have Maitland charged, through a third +party, of direct participation in the death of Darnley, whereupon +his arrest followed. + +Kirkaldy, who loved Maitland, would not allow this manœuvre to +pass unnoticed. He remonstrated with the regent for taking such a +step; but Moray coldly informed him, that it was out of his power to +save Lethington from prison. The blunt soldier, on receiving this +reply, sent back a message, demanding that the same charge should +be preferred against the Earl of Morton and Archibald Douglas; and +he did more--for, Maitland having been detained a prisoner in the +town of Edinburgh, under custody of Lord Home, Kirkaldy despatched +at night a party of the garrison, and, by means of a counterfeited +order, got possession of the statesman's person, and brought him to +the castle, where Chatelherault and Herries were already residing +as guests. Next morning, to the consternation of Moray, a trumpeter +appeared at the cross, demanding, in name of Kirkaldy, that process +for regicide should instantly be commenced against Morton and +Douglas; and, says our author,-- + + "Remembering the precepts of the stout old knight his father, + who always offered 'the single combate' in maintenance of his + assertions, he offered himself, body for body, to fight Douglas + on foot or horseback; while his prisoner, the Lord Herries, + sent, as a peer of the realm, a similar cartel to the Earl of + Morton. The challenges bore, 'that they were in the council, and + consequently art and part in the king's murder.' + +In vain did Moray try to wheedle Kirkaldy from his stronghold--in +vain did the revengeful Morton lay plots and bribe assassins. The +castle of Edinburgh had become the rallying point for those who +loved their queen. An attempt was made to oust Kirkaldy from the +provostship; but the stout burghers, proud of their martial head, +turned a deaf ear to the insidious suggestions of the regent. Yet +still the banner of King James floated upon the walls of the castle, +nor was the authority of Mary again proclaimed by sound of trumpet +until after the shot of the injured Bothwellhaugh struck down the +false and dangerous Moray in the street of Linlithgow. Then the +whole faction of Chatelherault, the whole race of Hamilton, rose in +arms, and prepared to place themselves under the guidance of Sir +William Kirkaldy. The following is, we think, a noble trait in the +character of the man:-- + + "The latter mourned deeply the untimely fate of Moray: they + had been old comrades in the field, stanch friends in many a + rough political broil; and though they had quarrelled of late, + he had too much of the frankness of his profession to maintain + hostility to the dead, and so came to see him laid in his last + resting-place. Eight lords bore the body up St Anthony's lofty + aisle, in the great cathedral of St Giles; Kirkaldy preceded it, + bearing the paternal banner of Moray with the royal arms; the + Laird of Cleish, who bore the coat of armour, walked beside him. + Knox prayed solemnly and earnestly as the body was lowered into + the dust; a splendid tomb was erected over his remains, and long + marked the spot where they lay." + +Lennox succeeded Moray as regent of Scotland, but no salute +from the guns of the grim old fortress of Edinburgh greeted his +inauguration. Henceforward Kirkaldy had no common cause with +the confederates. Maitland had revealed to him the whole hidden +machinery of treason, the scandalous complexity of intrigues, by +which he had been made a dupe. He now saw that neither religion nor +patriotism, but simply selfishness and ambition, had actuated the +nobles in rebelling against their lawful sovereign, and that those +very acts which they fixed upon as apologies for their treason, +were in fact the direct consequences of their own deliberate guilt. +If any further corroboration of their baseness had been required +in order to satisfy the mind of Kirkaldy, it was afforded by +Morton, who, notwithstanding the defiance so lately hurled at him +from the castle, solicited, with a meanness and audacity almost +incredible, the assistance of the governor to drive Lennox out of +the kingdom, and procure his own acknowledgement as regent instead. +It is needless to say that his application was refused with scorn. +Kirkaldy now began to doubt the sincerity of Knox, who, although +with no selfish motive, had been deeply implicated in the cruel +plots of the time; some sharp correspondence took place, and the +veteran Reformer was pleased to denounce his former pupil from the +pulpit. + +Edinburgh now was made to suffer the inconveniences to which every +city threatened with a siege is exposed. The burghers began to +grumble against their provost, who, on one occasion, sent a party to +rescue a prisoner from the Tolbooth, and who always preferred the +character of military governor to that of civic magistrate. Knox +thundered at him every Sabbath, and doubtless contributed largely +to increase the differences between him and the uneasy citizens. +The later might well be pardoned for their apprehensions. Not only +were they commanded by the castle guns, but Kirkaldy, as if to show +them what they might expect in ease of difference of political +sentiment,-- + + "Hoisted cannon to the summit of St Giles's lofty spire, which + rises in the middle of the central hill on which the city + stands, and commands a view of it in every direction. He placed + the artillery on the stone bartizan beneath the flying arches + of the imperial crown that surmounts the tower, and thus turned + the cathedral into a garrison, to the great annoyance of Knox + and the citizens. The latter were also compelled, at their own + expense, to maintain the hundred harquebussiers of Captain + Melville, who were billeted in the Castlehill Street, for the + queen's service; and thus, amid preparations for war, closed the + year 1570." + +We may fairly suppose, that the cannon of the governor were more +obnoxious than a modern annuity-tax can possibly be; yet no citizen +seemed desirous of coming forward as a candidate for the crown of +martyrdom. The bailies very quietly and very properly succumbed to +the provost. + +It must be acknowledged that Edinburgh was, in those days, no +pleasant place of residence. + +Next, to the alarm of the citizens, came a mock fight and the roar +of cannon, intended to accustom the garrison to siege and war, +which latter calamity speedily commenced in earnest. No possible +precaution was omitted by Kirkaldy, whose situation was eminently +critical; and he had received a terrible warning. On the last day +of truce, the strong castle of Dumbarton was taken by surprise by +a party under Captain Crawford of Jordanhill. Lord Fleming was +fortunate enough to effect his escape, but Hamilton, archbishop of +St Andrews, was made prisoner, and immediately hanged by Lennox over +Stirling bridge. An archbishopric never was a comfortable tenure in +Scotland. + +Lennox and Morton now drew together. The former from Linlithgow, and +the latter from Dalkeith, advanced against the city, then occupied +by the Hamiltons: skirmishes went on under the walls and on the +Boroughmuir, and the unfortunate citizens were nearly driven to +distraction. The following dispositions of Provost Kirkaldy were by +no means calculated to restore a feeling of confidence, or to better +the prospects of trade:-- + + "He loop-holed the spacious vaults of the great cathedral, for + the purpose of sweeping with musketry its steep church-yard to + the south, the broad Lawnmarket to the west, and High Street to + the eastward; while his cannon from the spire commanded the long + line of street called the Canongate--even to the battlements of + the palace porch. He seized the ports of the city, placed guards + of his soldiers upon them, and retained the keys in his own + hands. He ordered a rampart and ditch to be formed at the Butter + Tron, for the additional defence of the castle; and another + for the same purpose at the head of the West Bow, a steep and + winding street of most picturesque aspect. His soldiers pillaged + the house of the regent, whose movables and valuables they + carried off; he broke into the Tolbooth and council-chamber, + drove forth the scribes and councillors, and finally deposed + the whole bench of magistrates, installing in the civic chair + the daring chief of Fermhirst, (who had now become the husband + of his daughter Janet, a young girl barely sixteen;) while a + council composed of his mosstrooping vassals, clad in their iron + jacks, steel caps, calivers, and two-handed whingers, officiated + as bailies, in lieu of the douce, paunchy, and well-fed + burgesses of the Craims and Luckenbooths." + +The Blue Blanket of Edinburgh--that banner which, according to +tradition, waved victoriously on the ramparts of Acre--had fallen +into singular custody! John Knox again fled, for in truth his life +was in danger. Kirkaldy, notwithstanding their differences, exerted +his authority to the utmost to protect him, but the Hamiltons +detested his very name; and one night a bullet fired through his +window, was taken as a significant hint that his absence from the +metropolis would be convenient. Scandal, even in those times, was +rife in Edinburgh; for we are told that-- + + "John Low, a carrier of letters to St Andrews, being in the + 'Castell of Edinburgh, the Ladie Home would neids threip in his + face, that Johne Knox was banist the toune, because in his yard + he had raisit some _sanctis_, amangis whome their came up the + devill with hornes, which when his servant Richart saw he ran + wud, and so deid.'" + +It is hardly credible, but it is a fact, that a meeting of the +Estates of Scotland, called by Lennox, was held in Edinburgh at +this very juncture. Kirkaldy occupied the upper part of the town, +whilst the lower was in the hands of the regent, protected, or +rather covered, by a battery which Morton had erected upon the +"Doo Craig," that bluff black precipice to the south of the Calton +Hill. The meeting, however, was a short one. "Mons Meg" and her +marrows belched forth fire and shot upon the town, and the scared +representatives fled, in terror of the falling ruins. A sortie from +the castle was made, and the place of assembly burned. + +Kirkaldy now summoned and actually held a parliament, in name of +Queen Mary, in Edinburgh. The possession of the Regalia gave this +assembly a show of legality at least equivalent to that pertaining +to its rival, the _Black Parliament_, which was then sitting at +Stirling. + +We must refer to the work itself for the details of the martial +exploits which followed. So very vividly and picturesquely are the +scenes described, that, in reading of them, the images arise to +our mind with that distinctness which constitutes the principal +charm of the splendid romances of Scott. We accompany, with the +deepest personal interest, the gallant Captain Melville and his +harquebussiers, on his expedition to dislodge grim Morton from +his Lion's Den at Dalkeith--we follow fiery Claud Hamilton in his +attack upon the Black Parliament at Stirling, when Lennox met his +death, and Morton, driven by the flames from his burning mansion, +surrendered his sword to Buccleugh--and, amidst the din and uproar +of the Douglas wars, we hear the cannon on the bastion of Edinburgh +castle battering to ruin the gray towers of Merchiston. + +The career of Kirkaldy was rapidly drawing towards its close. +During the life of Mar, who succeeded Lennox in the regency, the +brave governor succeeded in maintaining possession not only of the +castle, but of the city of Edinburgh, in spite of all opposition. +But Morton, the next regent, was a still more formidable foe. The +hatred between this man and Kirkaldy was mutual, and it was of the +most deadly kind. And no wonder. Morton, as profligate as cruel, had +seduced the fair and false Helen Leslie, wife of Sir James Kirkaldy, +the gallant brother of the governor, and thereby inflicted the +worst wound on the honour of an ancient family. A more awful story +than the betrayal of her husband, and the seizure of his castle of +Blackness, through the treachery of this wretched woman, is not to +be found in modern history. Tarpeia alone is her rival in infamy, +and the end of both was the same. The virulence of hereditary feud +is a marked feature in our Scottish annals; but no sentiment of the +kind could have kindled such a flame of enmity as burned between +Morton and Kirkaldy. From the hour when the former obtained the +regency, the war became one of extermination. + +Morton, it must be owned, showed much diplomatic skill in his +arrangements. His first step was to negotiate separately with the +country party of the loyalists, so as to detach them from Kirkaldy; +and in this he perfectly succeeded. The leading nobles, Huntley +and Argyle, were wearied with the war; Chatelherault, whom we have +already known as Arran, was broken down by age and infirmities; and +even those who had been the keenest partisans of the queen, Herries +and Seton, were not disinclined to transfer their allegiance to +her son. The treaty of Perth left Kirkaldy with no other adherents +save Lord Home, the Melvilles, Maitland, and his garrison. The city +had revolted, and was now under the provostship of fierce old Lord +Lindesay of the Byres, who was determined to humble his predecessor. +Save the castle rock of Edinburgh, and the hardy band that held it, +all Scotland had submitted to Morton. + +Killigrew, the English ambassador, advised him to yield. "No!" +replied Kirkaldy. "Though my friends have forsaken me, and the city +of Edinburgh hath done so too, yet I will defend this castle to the +last!" The man whom Moray thought a tool, had expanded to the bulk +of a hero. + +Meantime, English engineers were occupied in estimating the +capabilities of the castle as a place of defence. They reported +that, with sufficient artillery, it might be reduced in twenty days; +and, accordingly, Morton determined to besiege it so soon as the +period of truce agreed on by the treaty of Perth should expire. +Kirkaldy was not less resolute to maintain it. + +At six o'clock, on the morning of 1st January 1573, a warning gun +from the castle announced that the treaty had expired, and the +standard of the Queen was unfurled on the highest tower, amidst the +acclamations of the garrison. Four-and-twenty hours previously, +Kirkaldy had issued a proclamation, warning all loyal subjects of +the Queen to depart forthwith from the city; and terrible indeed was +the situation of those who neglected that seasonable warning. Morton +began the attack; and it was answered by an incessant discharge from +the batteries upon the town. + +Civil war had assumed its worst form. By day the cannon thundered; +at night the garrison made sorties, and fired the city: all was +wrack and ruin. Morton, bursting with fury, found that, unassisted, +he could not conquer Grange. + +English aid was asked from, and given by, the unscrupulous +Elizabeth. Drury, who had helped Morton in his dishonourable treason +at Restalrig, marched into Scotland with the English standard +displayed, bringing with him fifteen hundred harquebussiers, one +hundred and fifty pikemen, and a numerous troop of gentlemen +volunteers; while the train of cannon and baggage came round by sea +to Leith, where a fleet of English ships cruised, to cut off all +succour from the Continent. + +The English summons to surrender was treated by Kirkaldy with scorn. +Up went a scarlet banner, significant of death and defiance, on +the great tower of King David. Indomitable, as in the days of his +early youth, when the confederates of St Andrews defied the universe +in arms, the Scottish champion looked calmly from his rock on the +preparations for the terrible assault. + +Five batteries were erected around the castle, but not with +impunity. The cannon of Kirkaldy mowed down the pioneers when +engaged in their trenching operations; and it was not until Trinity +Sunday, the 17th of May, that the besiegers opened their fire. + + "At two o'clock in the afternoon, the five batteries opened a + simultaneous discharge upon the walls of the castle. Bravely + and briskly its cannoneers replied to them, and deep-mouthed + Mons Meg, with her vast bullets of black whin, the thundering + carthouns, basilisks, serpents, and culverins, amid fire + and smoke, belched their missiles from the old gray towers, + showering balls of iron, lead, and stone at the batteries; + while the incessant ringing of several thousand harquebusses, + calivers, and wheel-lock petronels, added to the din of the + double cannonade. From the calibre of the great Mons Meg, which + yet frowns _en barbe_ over the ramparts, one may easily imagine + the dismay her enormous bullets must have caused in the trenches + so far below her. + + "For ten days the furious cannonade continued, on both sides, + without a moment's cessation. On the 19th, three towers were + demolished, and enormous gaps appeared in the curtain walls; + many of the castle guns were dismounted, and destroyed by the + falling of the ancient masonry: a shot struck one of the largest + culverins fairly on the muzzle, shattering it to pieces, and + scattering the splinters around those who stood near. A very + heavy battery was discharged against King David's Tower, a great + square bastel-house, the walls of which were dark with the lapse + of four centuries. On the 23d, a great gap had been beaten in + its northern side, revealing the arched hall within; and as the + vast old tower, with its cannon, its steel-clad defenders, and + the red flag of defiance still waving above its machicolated + bartizan, sank with a mighty crash to shapeless ruin, the wild + shriek raised by the females in the castle, and the roar of the + masonry rolling like thunder down the perpendicular rocks, were + distinctly heard at the distant English camp." + +One hundred and fifty men constituted the whole force which Kirkaldy +could muster when he commenced his desperate defence. Ten times +that number would scarcely have sufficed to maintain an adequate +resistance; but high heroic valour in the face of death is +insensible to any odds. After a vigorous resistance, the besiegers +succeeded in gaining possession of the Spur or blockhouse--an outer +work which was constructed between the fortress and the town; but an +attempt to scale the rock on the west side utterly failed. + +The blockade had for some time been so strict, that the garrison +began to suffer from want of provisions; but their sorest privation +was the loss of water. Although there are large and deep wells in +the Castle of Edinburgh, a remarkable peculiarity renders them +useless in the time of siege. To this day, whenever the cannon are +fired, the water deserts the wells, oozing out of some fissures at +the bottom of the rock. There is, however, a lower spring on the +north side, called St Margaret's Well, and from this the garrison +for a time obtained a scanty supply. Under cloud of night a soldier +was let down by a rope from the fortifications, and in this manner +the wholesome element was drawn. This circumstance became known to +the besiegers; and they, with diabolical cruelty, had recourse to +the expedient of poisoning the well, and permitted the nocturnal +visitor to draw the deadly liquid without molestation. The +consequences, of course, were fearful. Many expired in great agony; +and those whose strength enabled them to throw off the more active +effects of the poison, were so enfeebled that they could hardly work +the heavy cannon, or support the fatigue of watching day and night +upon the battlements. + + "Maddened by the miseries they underwent, and rendered desperate + by all hopes of escape from torture and death being utterly cut + off, a frenzy seized the soldiers; they broke into a dangerous + mutiny, and threatened to hang Lethington over the walls, as + being the primary cause of all these dangers, from the great + influence he exercised over Kirkaldy, their governor. But + even now, when amid the sick, the dying, and the dead, and + the mutinous--surrounded by crumbling ramparts and dismounted + cannon, among which the shot of the besiegers were rebounding + every instant--with the lives, honour, and safety of his wife, + his brother, and numerous brave and faithful friends depending + on his efforts and example, the heart of the brave governor + appears never to have quailed even for an instant!" + +At length, as further resistance was useless, and as certain +movements on the part of the enemy indicated their intention of +proceeding to storm the castle by the breach which had been effected +on the eastern side, Kirkaldy requested an interview with his old +fellow-soldier Drury, the Marshal of Berwick. This being acceded to, +the governor and his uncle, "Sir Robert Melville of Murdocairnie, +were lowered over the ruins by cords, as there was no other mode +of egress, the flight of forty steps being completely buried in +the same ruin which had choked up the archways, and hidden both +gates and portcullis. The Castlehill, at that time, says Melville +of Kilrenny, in his Diary, was covered with stones, 'rinning like a +sandie bray;' but behind the breaches were the men-at-arms drawn up +in firm array, with their pikes and helmets gleaming in the setting +sun." + +Kirkaldy's requests were not unreasonable. He asked to have security +for the lives and property of those in the garrison, to have leave +for Lord Home and Maitland of Lethington to retire to England, and, +for himself, permission to live unmolested at the estate in Fife. +Drury might have consented, but Morton was obdurate. The thought of +having his enemy unconditionally in his hands, and the prospect of +a revenge delicious to his savage and unrelenting nature, made him +deaf to all applications; and the only terms he would grant were +these,-- + + "That if the soldiers marched forth without their armour, and + submitted to his clemency, he would grant them their lives; but + there were ten persons who must yield _unconditionally_ to him, + and whose fate he would leave to the decision of their umpire, + Elizabeth. The unfortunate exceptions were--the governor, Sir + James Kirkaldy, Lethington, Alexander Lord Home, the Bishop + of Dunkeld, Sir Robert Melville of Murdocairnie, Logan of + Restalrig, Alexander Crichton of Drylaw, Pitarrow the constable, + and Patrick Wishart. + +Kirkaldy returned to the castle, resolved to die in the breach, but +by this time the mutiny had begun. The soldiers insisted upon a +surrender even more clamorously than before, and several of them +took the opportunity of clambering over the ruins and deserting. It +would have been madness under such circumstances to hold out; yet +still Kirkaldy, jealous of his country's honour, could not brook the +idea of handing over the citadel of Scotland's metropolis to the +English. + + "Therefore, when compelled to adopt the expedient (which is + supposed to have originated in Lethington's fertile brain) of + admitting a party of the besiegers within the outworks, or + at least close to the walls, he sent privately in the night + a message to Hume and Jordanhill, to march their Scottish + companies between the English batteries and the fortress, lest + the old bands of Drury should have the honour of entering first." + +Next morning he came forth, and surrendered his sword to Drury, who +gave him the most solemn assurances that he should be restored to +his estates and liberty at the intercession of the Queen of England, +and that all his adherents should be pardoned. + +Drury, probably, was in earnest, but he had either overstepped his +commission, or misinterpreted the mind of his mistress. Morton had +most basely handed over to Elizabeth the person of the fugitive Earl +of Northumberland, whom she hurried to the block, nor could she well +refuse to the Scottish regent a similar favour in return. Morton +asked for the disposal of the prisoners, and the gift was readily +granted. + +Three of them were to die: for these there was no mercy. One, +William, Maitland of Lethington, disappointed the executioner by +swallowing poison, a draught more potent than that drawn from the +well of St. Margaret. The vengeance of Morton long kept his body +from the decencies of the grave. Of the two Kirkaldys, one was +the rival of the regent, who had foully wronged the other, and, +therefore, their doom was sealed. + +One hundred barons and gentlemen of rank and fortune, kinsmen to +the gallant Kirkaldy, offered, in exchange for his life, to bind +themselves by bond of manrent, as vassals to the house of Morton +for ever: money, jewels, lands, were tendered to the regent; but +all in vain. Nothing could induce him to depart from his revenge. +Nor were others wanting to urge on the execution. The Reformed +preachers, remembering the dying message of Knox, were clamorous for +the realisation of the prophecy through his death; the burghers, who +had suffered so much from his obstinate defence, shouted for his +execution; only stout old Lord Lindesay, fierce as he was, had the +magnanimity to plead on behalf of the unfortunate soldier. + +Then came the scaffold and the doom. Those who are conversant +with Scottish history cannot but be impressed with the remarkable +resemblance between the last closing scene of Kirkaldy, as related +in this work, and that of Montrose, which was exhibited on the same +spot, in another and a later age. + +So died this remarkable man, the last of Queen Mary's adherents. If, +in the course of his career, we can trace out some inconsistencies, +it is but fair to his memory to reflect how early he was thrown upon +the troubled ocean of politics, and how difficult it must have been, +in such an age of conflicting opinions and desperate intrigue, to +maintain a tangible principle. Kirkaldy seems to have selected Moray +as his guide--not penetrating certainly, at the time, the selfish +disposition of the man. But the instant he perceived that his own +aggrandisement, and not the welfare of Scotland, was the object of +the designing Earl, Grange drew off from his side, and valorously +upheld the cause of his injured and exiled sovereign. + +We now take leave of a work which, we are convinced, will prove of +deep and thrilling interest to every Scotsman. It is seldom indeed +that we find history so written--in a style at once vigorous, +perspicuous, and picturesque. The author's heart is thoroughly with +his subject; and he exhibits, ever and anon, flashes of the old +Scottish spirit, which we are glad to believe has not decayed from +the land. + + +_Printed by William Blackwood and Sons, Edinburgh._ + + * * * * * + +Transcriber's note: + +Minor typographical errors have been corrected without note. +Irregularities and inconsistencies in the text have been retained as +printed. + +Mismatched quotes are not fixed if it's not sufficiently clear where +the missing quote should be placed. + +The cover for the eBook version of this book was created by the +transcriber and is placed in the public domain. + +The transcriber has supplied footnote anchors for the following +footnotes: + +Page 20: Footnote 10 _A Campaign in the Kabylie._ By DAWSON BORRER, +F.R.G.S., &c. London, 1848. + +Page 47: Footnote 15 _Expedition zur Entdeckung der Quellen des +Weissen Nil_, (1840-1841,) von FERDINAND WERNE. Mit einem Vorwort +von CARL RITTER. Berlin, 1848. _La Kabylie._ Par un Colon. Paris, +1846. + +_La Captivité du Trompette Escoffier._ Par ERNEST ALBY. 2 vols. +Brussels, 1848." + +Page 63: Footnote 16 _Annals of the Artists of Spain._ By WILLIAM +STIRLING, M. A. 3 vols. London: Ollivier. + +Page 81: Footnote 19 _The Dodo and its Kindred; or, the History, +Affinities, and Osteology of the Dodo, Solitaire, and other Extinct +Birds of the Islands Mauritius, Rodriguez, and Bourbon._ By H. +E. STRICKLAND, M.A. F.G.S., F.R.G.S., President of the Ashmolean +Society, &c., and A. G. MELVILLE, M.D., Edinburgh, M.R.C. . One +vol., royal quarto: London, 1848. + +Page 112: Footnote 24 _Memoirs and Adventures of Sir Wm. Kirkaldy of +Grange, Knight, &c. &c._ WM. BLACKWOOD & SONS, Edinburgh and London. + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Volume +65, No. 399, January 1849, by Various + +*** END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK 44183 *** |
