diff options
| author | nfenwick <nfenwick@pglaf.org> | 2025-03-07 13:55:42 -0800 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | nfenwick <nfenwick@pglaf.org> | 2025-03-07 13:55:42 -0800 |
| commit | 0c7f599b645980b72a1c896b6d66c12d30158f3d (patch) | |
| tree | b72abafb8d1886641cd268f0bfc638f3bb52d6d6 /43874-0.txt | |
| parent | 83982fa98c77b0fc1c0346e2ba1088680d4a2c7c (diff) | |
Diffstat (limited to '43874-0.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | 43874-0.txt | 4142 |
1 files changed, 4142 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/43874-0.txt b/43874-0.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bfeb86e --- /dev/null +++ b/43874-0.txt @@ -0,0 +1,4142 @@ +*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK 43874 *** + +DEDICATED + +TO + +THE LADY KATHERINE HARDY. + +[Illustration: A WOODLAND STREAM.] + + + + +CHATS ON ANGLING. + + BY + + CAPTAIN H. V. HART-DAVIS, + Author of "Stalking Sketches." + + WITH ILLUSTRATIONS BY THE AUTHOR. + + LONDON: + HORACE COX, + WINDSOR HOUSE, BREAM'S BUILDINGS, E.C. + + 1906. + + + LONDON: + + PRINTED BY HORACE COX, WINDSOR HOUSE, BREAM'S BUILDINGS, E.C. + + + + +LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS. + + + A WOODLAND STREAM _Frontispiece._ + WAITING FOR A RISE _Facing page_ 5 + BRINGING HIM DOWN TO THE NET " 25 + THE SEDGE HOUR " 35 + A DRY FLY DAY ON LOCH ARD " 47 + LUNCHEON " 61 + NEARING THE END " 72 + GET THE GAFF READY " 79 + HE MEANS GOING DOWN " 88 + THE FALL'S POOL " 101 + + + + +CONTENTS. + + + INTRODUCTORY _page_ 1 + + CHAPTER I. + IN PRAISE OF THE DRY FLY " 3 + + CHAPTER II. + DRY FLY TACKLE AND EQUIPMENT " 7 + + CHAPTER III. + DRY FLY MAXIMS " 13 + + CHAPTER IV. + EDUCATION OF THE SOUTH COUNTRY TROUT " 23 + + CHAPTER V. + THE MAY FLY " 27 + + CHAPTER VI. + THE EVENING RISE " 33 + + CHAPTER VII. + "JACK" " 37 + + CHAPTER VIII. + WEED CUTTING " 40 + + CHAPTER IX. + THE ANGLER AND AMBIDEXTERITY " 43 + + CHAPTER X. + LOCH FISHING " 46 + + CHAPTER XI. + DAPPING FOR TROUT " 53 + + CHAPTER XII. + GRAYLING FISHING " 57 + + CHAPTER XIII. + NOTES ON RAINBOW TROUT " 61 + + CHAPTER XIV. + SALMON FISHING " 66 + + CHAPTER XV. + A TRIP TO IRELAND " 79 + + CHAPTER XVI. + SALMON AND FLIES " 86 + + CHAPTER XVII. + SALMON OF THE AWE " 91 + + CHAPTER XVIII. + DISAPPOINTING DAYS " 97 + + CHAPTER XIX. + SEA TROUT FISHING AND ITS CHANCES " 106 + + L'ENVOI " 113 + + + + +CHATS ON ANGLING + + + + +INTRODUCTORY. + + +TO those who love angling, with all its associations and surroundings, +no apology may be needed for inflicting on them in book form certain +short articles which have mainly appeared in the columns of the +_Field_. They are "Chats" rather than didactic deliverances, and are +offered in the belief that much will be forgiven to a brother angler, +since all that pertains to the beloved pastime has some interest, and +the experiences of the poorest writer that ever recorded his views and +fancies may haply strike some responsive note. + +But to the outside world, to those who care nought for all we hold +so dear, to those who would rank all fishermen as fools, and would +classify them as Dr. Johnson was said to have done--to such these notes +cannot appeal; they will regard them, not unnaturally perhaps, as yet +one more addition, of a desultory kind, to an already overladen subject. + +No form of sport has so enduring a charm to its votaries as angling. +Its praises have been sung for centuries, from Dame Julia Berners +to the present day. Once an angler, always an angler; years roll by +only to increase the fervour of our devotion. It is a quiet, simple, +unassuming kind of madness, without any of the excitement or the +glamour of the race meeting or of the hunting field, and the love and +the madness are incomprehensible and inexplicable to those who neither +share them nor know them. + +The quiet stroll by the stream or river bank, the constant communing +with nature, the watching of bird and insect life, appeal with +irresistible force and power to the angler. As the short winter days +draw out, and spring begins to assert her revivifying powers, the +longing, intense as ever, comes over us, and we yearn for the river +side. And the lessons that we learn from our love for it are not +without value; patience and self-control come naturally to those who +have the real angling instinct. + +How widely spread this natural instinct is we may gather from observing +the long lines of fishermen, each with his few feet of bank pegged +out, engaged in some competition, and watching with intense interest +for long hours the quiet float in front of him. Give him but a better +chance of following up his instinct, and doubtless he would take with +increased zeal to those higher branches of the sport that appeal more +directly to most of us--the keenness is there, the opportunity alone is +wanting. + +Seeing that fishing and its charms have been so amply extolled and set +forth by such able and various pens, from Father Walton, the merchant, +prince of all writers on this subject, down to later days in continuous +line, through such names as Kingsley (man of letters), or Sir Edward +Grey (man of affairs)--writers whose works will live, and who can +inspire in us the enthusiasm of sympathetic feeling--why, it may be +asked, is it that we are not content, and that so many of us cannot +refrain from publishing our impressions? There can be no answer to this +query except it be as in my own case, the confession of a desire to +record some of the experiences, gained through many years, in the hope +that some crumb of information may be gleaned therefrom, and that the +pleasure taken in recording them may find a responsive echo in some +breast. + +I would wish at once to disarm possible criticism by candidly admitting +that this little work has no literary, or indeed any other pretensions. +It is merely what it purports to be--a series of articles strung +together, with the object that I have already described. + +I would desire also to thank the proprietors of the _Field_ for their +permission to reprint such articles as have already appeared in that +paper. My thanks are also due to my old friend Mr. W. Senior and to Mr. +Sheringham for having been kind enough to glance through my MSS. and +give me the benefit of their most valued criticism. + + WARDLEY HALL, _August, 1905_. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER I. + +IN PRAISE OF THE DRY FLY. + + +THE methods of the "Dry Fly" Fisherman, as compared with those of +his brother of the "Wet Fly," are absolutely distinct, and demand +totally different characteristics. It is idle to compare them, or to +praise one to the disparagement of the other. The sooner this kind +of carping criticism is entirely abandoned the better. The dry fly +purist may argue until he is black in the face; he will never convert +the wet fly devotee. Nor, on the other hand, is there the slightest +chance of the South Country chalk stream Angler being induced to +give up his favourite form of sport. Quite apart from the fact that +different waters require different treatment, the two methods appeal to +absolutely different temperaments. Take for example the wet fly man. +He wends his way, probably down stream, fishing all the fishable water +before him, carefully searching with his flies all the quick water and +stickles; placing his flies deftly near the eddy by that half-sunken +rock, round which the swirl comes, forming a convenient resting-place +for a goodly trout; or with careful underhand cast searches under the +overhanging branches of yonder tree; always alert and on the move, +leaving untried no likely holt, keeping as far as possible out of +sight, and showing himself to be a master of his art. But he has always +a roving commission. He may, of course, elect to fish up stream, and +many an expert in that line may be met with; but, even then, his art +differs radically from that of the angler with the floating fly. + +[Illustration: WAITING FOR A RISE.] + +From the latter are required in a special degree a quick and accurate +eye, great delicacy and accuracy in the actual cast, and above all, a +quiet, watchful disposition; he cannot whip the water on the chance of +catching an unseen trout. His _rôle_ is to scan the water, to watch +the duns and ascertain their identity, to spot at once the dimple of +a rising fish, and to differentiate between such a rise and the swirl +made by a tailing fish. He will note the flow of the stream, and +whether he will have to counteract the fateful drag. Having made up +his mind, arranged his plan of action, and selected his fly, he will +crawl up as near as may be desirable below his fish, taking care not to +alarm in his approach any other that may lie between him and it; then, +after one or two preliminary casts to regulate his distance, he will +despatch his fly, to alight, as lightly as may be, some three or four +inches above his fish. His field glasses will have told him, even if +his natural eyesight could not, the quality of the fish he is trying +for, and for good or evil his cast is made. + +Perhaps he has under-estimated the distance, and if it be a bank +fish he is attacking his fly may float down some twelve inches from +the bank under which the fish is lying. In that case he will not +withdraw it until it is well past the trout, but he may have noted +that half-defined, but encouraging, movement which the trout made as +the fly sailed past. His next cast is a better one, and, guided by the +stream under the bank, the fly, jauntily cocking, an olive quill of +the right size and shade, will pass over the trout's nose. A natural +dun comes along abreast of his; will his poor imitation be taken in +preference to the Simon pure? By the powers, it is! A confident upward +tilt of the trout, a pink mouth opens, and the 000 hook is sucked in; +one turn of the wrist, and he is hooked. Despite a mad dash up stream +the bonnie two-pounder--in the lusty vigour of high condition--is soon +controlled and steadied by the even strain of the ten-foot cane-built +rod. Down stream now he rushes; he will soon exhaust himself at that +game. Keep quietly below him, and keep the rod-point up. That was a +narrow squeak! He nearly gained that weed-bank! Had he effected his +purpose, nothing but hand-lining would have had the slightest chance +of extricating him, but the rod strain being applied at the right +moment and in the right direction, the gallant fish is turned back. +That effort, happily counteracted, has beaten him; he soon begins to +flop upon the surface and show evident signs of surrendering. The +landing net is quietly disengaged and half submerged in the stream +below him--for if he sees it he will be nerved to fresh efforts--and +his head being kept up, he is guided without fuss into its embrace. And +after he is given his instant and humane quietus with one tap, rightly +placed, of the "Priest," the pipe is lit, tackle is adjusted, and there +is leisure to admire the beautiful proportions of a newly caught trout, +the glorious colouring of his spots and golden belly. Something has +been accomplished, something done. A fair stalk has been rewarded, and +it is no chance success. + +Those happy days when there is a good rise of fly, when the fish are +in their stations, heads up, and lying near the top of the water, and +the wind is not too contrary, should indeed be gratefully remembered. A +short length of water will suffice for the dry fly man--a few hundred +yards. For him there need be no restless rushing from place to place. +Quiet watching and waiting, constant observation of what is going on in +the river beneath him, these are his requirements. + +But on the days when the rise is scant and short, and the trout seem +to be all glued to the bottom, or when a strong down stream wind +nearly baffles the angler, then his patience will be somewhat sorely +tested; even under these discouraging conditions there are places in +the river unswept by wind, most rivers having a serpentine course; on +one of these our angler will take up his position, and his patience and +perseverance will be rewarded. And if the trout be, as I have said, +glued to the bed of the river, and there is no rise of fly to tempt +them to the surface, he will wait patiently. It will not be always so; +a change of temperature will come or some subtle atmospheric change +about which we know so little, but which effects a wonderful change +in the trout. They begin, as it were, at such changes to wake up from +their lethargy, to come nearer to the surface and to re-assume their +favourite positions--at the tail of yonder weed bank--or in the oily +glide under the bank side. The first few flies of the hatch may be +allowed to pass by them, apparently unheeded or unnoticed, but before +long they settle down to feeding in a serious manner. Now is your +opportunity, make the most of it; and if you keep well down and make +no bungling cast, your creel will soon be somewhat weightier than it +promised to be a short hour ago. Our friend the chalk stream trout will +brook no bungling; he is easily put down and scared, and the delicate +accuracy needed in securing him forms the most potent of the many +charms of this most beautiful of sports. + +Should, as may often prove to be the case, the unpropitious conditions +continue without improvement, our angler is not without resource. His +surroundings are so entirely congenial; he lies on the fresh green +meadow-grass, the hedgerows ablaze with blossom, the copses in their +newly-donned green mantles, blue with the shimmering sheen of countless +blue-bells, are full of rejoicing and of promise. The birds, instinct +with their love-making and nesting operations, are full of life; all +nature seems to be vigorous with new-born hope. The true angler can +rejoice with them all, sharing their pleasure and delight, drinking +in pure draughts of ozone, and adding, perchance, to his store of +knowledge of insect and animal life. His field glasses, as he lies +prone and sheltered, bring him within touch and range of many sights +that otherwise would have passed unnoticed. That water vole coasting +along the bank side, pausing incontinently to sit up and look around, +those rabbits playing near the burrow mouth, the moorhens cruising +round the flags and sedges, all afford interest and instruction. In the +very grass on which he lies he will find ample scope for observation +and amusement in his enforced leisure should he care to watch the +teeming multitudes of insects that throng it, his ears meanwhile being +solaced and refreshed by countless woodland songsters. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER II. + +DRY FLY TACKLE AND EQUIPMENT. + + +MODERN glued-up cane rods have practically done away with hickory, blue +gum, or other wooden rods--at any rate, as far as dry fly angling is +concerned. Their action when well made is so true and quick, they pick +up the line from the water in the way their forerunners never could; +they are not liable to snap or break, and if tended carefully are very +long-lived. Most of us have old favourite greenheart or other rods, +companions in many a pleasant hour. We would not part with them, but on +the other hand would leave them lying in their cases, taking out our +cane rods in preference. The big grip on the butt, whether of cork, +leather, or wood, prevents to a great extent the cramp to the fingers +that would be certain to come from using our former small-butted rods +in dry fly work. + +Built-up cane rods vary, of course, greatly in quality and durability. +Cheap ones may be bought, and they will certainly turn out a dear +purchase. It is best to buy one from the very best makers only, and +eschew as worthless all cheap imitations. Having decided to purchase +a built-up rod, we have to consider its length, etc. It is, I think, +generally agreed that a length of from 9 ft. 6 in. to 10 ft. 6 in. +is ample--the latter, in my opinion, for choice. Messrs. Hardy, of +Alnwick and London, have devoted so much labour and attention to +built-up rods as to deserve a somewhat pre-eminent position amongst +the many successful firms that make them. This firm produces many +forms of rods suitable for dry fly work. Their "Perfection" rod is a +very sweet weapon for the purpose, quick in its action, true as steel, +has great power of recovery, and is light in the hand; but for choice +I would pin my faith to one of their 10 ft. 6 in. "Pope" rods in two +pieces. Such a one has been my constant companion for some seasons, +and, though other makers may be able to turn out as good a rod, I feel +convinced that none could turn out a better. The old attachments of +the ferrules of former days have also gone by the board, and a bayonet +joint has superseded them, to our great advantage. The upper ring on +the point should be of the Bickerdyke pattern, the other rod rings of +the ordinary snake pattern and made of German silver. The reel fittings +should be of the "Universal" type, a conical socket taking one end of +the reel base, the other end being secured by a loose ring. Personally, +I do not care for a spear; I find them awkward at times, their only +advantage being that your rod may be spiked when putting on a fly or +when hand-lining a "weeded" fish. If one is desired, it should be +carried inside the handle of the butt, the button screwing over it and +holding it in its place. + +I would not advocate a steel-centred rod, at any rate for a +single-handed trout rod. The absolute union of metal and cane can never +be secured, nor can the action of the two be precisely identical. +Besides, how are you advantaged? The hexagonal form of the built-up rod +is ideal for strength, and a rod without a steel centre can be made +with perfect action, able to do all that may be required of it. + +Reels also have undergone great improvements of late years. They are +lighter, more easily cleaned, the check action is better regulated; a +double check spring that allows the line to be reeled up quickly and +easily, and at the same time offers a stronger resistance to an outward +pull, is now almost universally employed. Aluminium, thin-brazed steel, +have replaced brass and even ebonite. The air is admitted to the coils +of line, and reeling up is rendered more rapid and effective. The +"Moscrop" reel is excellent in many ways, and fulfils many of the chief +requirements of modern reels, it has, moreover, a screw drag, which can +be used to regulate the retarding action of the check. Messrs. Hardy +produce an altogether admirable reel, which they have patented and call +the "Perfect." Such a reel for an ordinary cane-built rod of the length +we have chosen should be three inches in diameter, and will carry +forty yards of tapered line, with some backing, if thought necessary or +desirable. + +Avoid for choice patent aluminium American reels. I have one by me +whilst writing. The check action is outside, and can be taken off +at pleasure and the line allowed to run freely without hindrance. +The perforated face of the drum which carries the handle is +counter-balanced, so that it may be used as a Nottingham reel. But the +main advantage claimed is that the rim, within which the drum revolves +freely, is springy, and by pressing the thumb upon it the drum is at +once arrested and its revolution stopped. Of course, by this means +your line can be absolutely stopped at any moment should a fish make +a determined rush into any obstacle, but at the expense of your fly +and cast. I am told that experts with this reel cast with a free line, +arresting the fly at the precise moment required by the thumb pressure, +and thereby assisting themselves in judging the length of the cast, and +that the check is never clicked into action until the fish is hooked. +I have often tried it, and found that the inadvertent pressure of the +thumb or wrist upon the rim has cost me several good fish. In fixing +your reel, I would counsel its being so placed that the handle is on +the left side of the rod. In playing the fish it will be necessary, +therefore, to reverse your rod; the line will then run near the rod and +avoid the friction against the rings, and the strain will be taken off +your rod, or, rather, applied in a contrary direction to that which it +so constantly receives when casting. + +The line should be tapered, and should be of oil-dressed silk, such +as is now supplied by all good tackle makers. The taper should be +five or six yards in length, and when in use, in order to obviate the +constant shortening process it receives from attaching it to your +cast, I invariably whip a length of stoutish grilse gut to its end, +to which I attach my cast. This upper length can always be renewed at +pleasure. This plan I find better than a loop. The weight of the line +is a most important point; it should be as heavy in its centre part +beyond the taper as will bring out the best casting powers of your rod. +The balance of the line to the rod is all important; a little trouble +in selecting a suitable line will be amply repaid. Do not forget, after +using it, to draw off many coils of line to dry before finally putting +your reel away, and, as it is important that your line should float +well, do not forget to take some deer's fat with you with which to +anoint it. + +We next come to the cast. Two and a half yards of tapered gut are all +that is necessary, tapered from stout to the finest undrawn procurable. +I would discard drawn gut altogether, possibly because I am too clumsy +to use it to my satisfaction. It is generally, however, easy to procure +real undrawn gut of sufficient fineness from such firms as Ramsbottom, +and a hank of such gut, in fifteen or sixteen-inch strands, should +always be acquired when found. If kept out of the light, wrapped +preferably in chamois leather, it will keep a long time. Take with +you some dozen or so of such strands and a spare made-up cast in your +damping box, and you will have all you will require in a day's fishing. + +Your landing-net should be ample in circumference. The net itself deep +and commodious; the ring should be solid, of bent wood, with a knuckle +joint of gunmetal to attach it to the handle. The net should be of +dressed cord, so that the fly will not become fixed in the knots. It +is a great mistake to have too short a handle; you may have to reach +far over sedges to get at your fish to land him. If you sling your +landing-net on your left side, as is usually done, a long handle is +very inconvenient in kneeling; therefore, use a telescope handle for +choice. Wading trousers or stockings and brogues will complete your +equipment, though, of course, some kind of basket or bag will be needed +to enable you to carry your luncheon, your tackle, and your fish. All +tackle makers will supply you with an ample assortment for choice in +this matter. Possibly a waterproof bag with partitions and an outside +net to place the fish in is the most convenient. Small linen bags in +which to place the fish or linen cloths in which to wrap them are not +out of place. One further article I should advise you to take with +you, and that is a good pair of field glasses. They will multiply the +pleasure of your stalk tenfold. With them you can search the water +before you can spot effectively the most desirable fish, and ascertain +more exactly what flies the fish are taking; whilst, if nothing is +doing and the fish are lying like stones on the river bed or huddled +away in the recesses of the weeds, you can amuse yourself with watching +bird life and while away the time to your infinite pleasure. + +Having fully equipped ourselves so far, we have now to consider our +flies. I take it that no one who fishes with the floating fly nowadays +clings to the use of flies mounted upon gut. Eyed flies have no doubt +replaced them for all time. The very drying of your fly is too severe +upon the heads of gut-mounted flies. Eyed hooks have, however, had +to fight their way to the front, so prejudiced are we all, and I can +picture to myself now a prominent legislator, a great angler and the +author of one of the best sporting books published of late, standing by +me on Test side, on a meadow near Longparish, his cap literally covered +with artificial flies attached to strands of gut--a most extraordinary +sight. The fish were most unkind, taking greedily some kind of small +black insect, or fisherman's curse. We had offered them every kind of +midge fly or black gnat we could think of, with scant success. Our +friend, in gazing for the twentieth time at his fly-bedecked cap, saw a +group of black ants, on gut, amongst others. The first one put on not +only procured a rise, but hooked the fish; one run, and he was gone, +the fly remaining in his mouth. So with the next. In vain we soaked the +gut; each fly met with the same result--it was at once taken and the +fish was at once lost. The gut was absolutely rotten, and that pattern +of ant was apparently the only medicine. Our friend fairly danced +upon the bank in rage and disappointment. And it was all he could +do to restrain himself from dancing on his rod and from using very +unparliamentary language. I believe that even he is a convert to eyed +flies now. + +Whether the flies should have turned up or turned down eyes is a matter +of controversy. Personally, I prefer the latter. In any case, the eye +should not be too small, or much mental anguish will result. It is +needless to say that they should be well tempered and with sound barbs. +They should be tested in a piece of soft wood. + +Have a reserve box of flies, made in compartments, so that you can +replenish from time to time the little box you carry with you. This +pocket box may be quite small. I like one three inches square and +one inch deep, with rounded corners, and with bars of cork across it +inside. It will carry all you need. My pliers I always attach to one +of the buttons of my coat, as otherwise I am always misplacing them. +Nothing beats Major Turle's Knot as an attachment of the gut collar to +the fly. + +If you should be fishing the evening rise at a time when it is +difficult to thread the eye of a fly, even with the expenditure of +many matches, do not forget before you go out to mount some sedges or +large red quills upon fairly stout gut points and put them in your cap. +They will come in most usefully, and save a strain upon your temper. + +The use of deodorised mineral oil for anointing your flies has been +greatly decried of late. I can only say that it is a great assistance, +especially on a pouring wet day, and I should be sorry to be without +it. I do not like, however, the inconvenient bottle generally carried +for this purpose. I use a common metal matchbox, in which I have +placed a piece of spungeo-piline, on which I have poured a few drops +of the oil. The hackles of the fly can be pressed against this, and +so anointed with the greatest ease. Fish do not appear to mind the +appearance of the oil that, of course, appears to float round your fly; +and, as they do not mind and it enables you better to keep your fly +floating and cocked under adverse conditions, why not use it? + +As to the flies to be used, as I have said in another chapter, the +fewer the better. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER III. + +SOME DRY FLY MAXIMS. + + +IT would ill become a humble follower of the art to enter into a +minute description of the various methods of casting, seeing that the +subject has been so fully thrashed out by Mr. Halford, in his "Dry Fly +Fishing"; mere repetition would be both wearisome and valueless. If +anyone needs instruction on the subject, let him turn to that volume, +and read, mark, and learn. It seems to me, however, that a correct +style can best be obtained by accompanying and watching a really +competent fisherman. No amount of book reading will secure this, and +as in all kindred sports, practice, and intelligent practice, is +absolutely necessary if the tyro would aspire to any excellence. The +art of fishing the floating fly is not one that will admit of any +mediocrity. It requires and demands such accuracy, such co-ordination +of delicacy and strength, that mediocrity is impossible. + +A few points may, however, be discussed with advantage. First, and +foremost, do not be ambitious as to the length of line you can cast, +or the amount of water you can cover. Be content, rather, to fish +with just that length of line that you can control with ease and +accuracy. In the actual act of casting never sway the body; keep the +trunk rigidly still, never let your hand, in the backward cast, go +beyond a vertical point above your shoulder; keeping the elbow near +the side, get all the work you can out of the rod; it will do all that +is required of it so long as you do not over-cast with it. Watch the +expert angler; how easily he works his twenty yards of line; there is +an entire absence of all effort; it looks as easy as shelling peas. +The beginner or duffer will invariably put too much effort into his +cast; he will not allow time for the line to extend itself behind him; +he will bring his hand so far back that the fly will be hung up in +the grasses or bushes behind him, and the force of his forward cast +will make the line cut the water like a knife, and the fly will be +delivered in the midst of a series of curls of gut, presenting anything +but an attractive appearance to the fish. The movement of the hand in +an accomplished fisherman is singularly slight; I doubt if it ever +traverses much more than twelve inches from the vertical position. + +Rest content with the ordinary overhead cast until you are an absolute +master of it. When this desirable result is accomplished, there are one +or two casts well deserving of care and attention. One in particular +you should seek to accomplish--viz., the cast into the teeth of an +adverse wind. Recollect that, under those circumstances, you can +usually approach much nearer to fish than when the wind is up stream or +non-existent; therefore you can use a shorter line. The cast is called +the "downward" cast, and is really very simple. The backward part is +the same as in ordinary casting, but in the forward delivery the hand +traverses a much greater angle, and at the finish the rod point is near +to the water. At the moment of delivery the elbow is brought up level +with the shoulder, the thumb is depressed, the knuckles being kept +uppermost. The resultant effect is that the line cuts straight into +the wind, and is little affected by it. In a foul wind flies cock and +float more easily than in a down stream wind; so this, at any rate, +is in your favour. Yet one more style of casting should be practised. +I have found it invaluable when awkward trees have been overhanging +my own bank. It is what is called by salmon anglers the "Spey Cast." +Inasmuch as it avoids the necessity of bringing your line behind you, +its value is self-evident. This is the method of the cast: Having got +out as much line as you think you will need, get it out up stream of +you, bring the fly quickly towards you out of the water, allow the fly +just to kiss the water when it is just level with you, the curve of the +line being down stream of you, then, with a similar kind of action to +that advocated for the downward cast, your line will be sent forward +in a series of coils to the desired spot. It is always worth trying +and may secure you a good fish, one perhaps that others have passed by +as unapproachable, and which may thereby have acquired a confidence +that may be misplaced. This form of casting is much easier in salmon +fishing, as you are then fishing down stream, and the water extends +and straightens your line for you. It is, however, quite easy of +accomplishment, with a moderately short line, in up stream fishing. + +Mr. Halford, in "Dry Fly Angling," p. 62, describes a cast which +he terms the "Switch Cast," and it is one which, though difficult +of acquisition, will accomplish the same object. He says, "It is +accomplished by drawing the line towards you on the water, and throwing +the fly with a kind of roll outwards on the water--in fact, a sort of +downward cast; the possibility of making the cast depending upon the +fly being in the water at the moment the rod point is brought down," +&c. Personally, I should prefer the Spey cast, and inasmuch as most +salmon fishermen know something of that peculiar cast, I would urge its +occasional use in dry fly work, more especially having regard to the +fact that fish in such positions have acquired a confidence through +never having been angled for, and therefore there is greater chance +of a somewhat bungling presentment of the dry fly being overlooked. +To describe the Spey cast accurately so as to convey the desired +instruction in such a way that all who run may read, is not by any +means easy; but, as I have before said, it is probably familiar to many +anglers from salmon fishing experiences. + +One more thing deserves to be borne in mind: always imagine that the +plane of the water is some foot or so higher than it really is--that +is to say, cast as if the fish, and the water in which it lies, were a +foot higher than in reality. The result will be that your collar will +fall as lightly as gossamer. One of the most proficient manipulators of +the rod and line I have ever seen can pitch a fly, cocked and floating, +almost anywhere within reasonable limits, but his line invariably cuts +the water from point to fly, straight and accurate enough may be, but +like whip-cord. Consequently, he is not the successful angler that his +qualifications entitle him to be. An ordinary fisherman casting a less +straight, but lighter, line will frequently beat him in catching fish. +Our friend would beat most opponents in a casting tournament, but I +would back many that I know against him in filling a creel. + +Keep down out of sight, walk and crawl warily, and above all things +avoid walking near the bank edge and unnecessarily scaring fish that +others following you might otherwise have secured. + +When trout are "bulging" (that is to say, as every angler knows, when +they are taking the "nymphæ" just below the surface), it is almost +hopeless to endeavour to secure them with a dry, floating fly. The fish +are intent on another kind of game, and are best left severely alone. + +Unfortunately, even experienced anglers are apt to be deceived by such +a fish; the rise is often apparently that of a trout at a surface fly; +a little careful observation will, however, convince you that such is +not the case, for no floating flies are passing near him at the time of +his rise. Don't waste another moment upon him, but try to find another +in a more reasonable frame of mind. If all the fish on your stretch of +water seem to be similarly occupied, and you are not willing to wait +until they have decided to make a change of diet, then a gold ribbed +hare's ear may, if fished wet, entice an odd fish, as it somewhat +resembles a nympha. + +It is, however, very chance work, as is that of endeavouring to secure +a "tailing" fish with a down stream fly sunk below the surface, and +jerked about in front of where his nose should be. No keen angler would +call this serious fishing--it is a mere travesty of the real sport; but +it may serve to pass the time, and perchance to wile a trout into your +basket. The angler's patience will, however, be far more severely tried +when fish are "smutting." What prophet is there who can tell us what we +should do then? Those abominable "curses," so well named, appear to be +able to baffle entirely the skill of the ablest of our entomologists, +and the ability of our most capable of fly dressers. No lure has yet +been discovered that can have any reasonable hope of imitating them. +To watch a big trout slowly and majestically sail here and there on +a still, hot day, barely dimpling the surface as he sucks down one +after another of these little insignificant "curses," is quite enough +to satisfy you as to the remoteness of your chance of deceiving him. +Nothing that human hands could tie could simulate them. Place in the +track of one of these fish the smallest gnat in your box, attached to +the finest of undrawn gut, delivered with the lightest and truest cast +of which the human hand is capable and, as you watch the fish fade +slowly down into the depths in disgust at the evident deception, you +will realise the hopelessness of your endeavour. + +It is an old accusation against fishermen that they are apt to overload +themselves with multitudinous flies, of which perhaps they never try +half; and in this accusation there is a good deal of truth. I recollect +one occasion in particular, when five men sallied forth to fish, and +on their return all more or less bewailed the shyness of the trout, +and each declared that, though he had tried many changes of fly, he +had only found one to succeed. Oddly enough, each man had pitched on a +different fly: they were the Driffield dun, the pale olive, the hare's +ear and yellow, the ginger quill, and the red quill. In each case the +size was similar, viz., 000; but the fact is, that most men have a +favourite fly to which they pin their faith, and to which they give ten +chances for one to the others. There are occasions, of course, where +one fly and only one will succeed. + +I well remember one day, on the Tichbourne water on the Itchen, when +that fine stretch of water was simply alive with olives, coming in +droves and batches over the fish, and when it seemed hopeless for +one's poor imitation to succeed, even when put correctly cocked in +front of a batch, or behind a drove, or by itself. The trout were +rising slowly and methodically, letting many flies pass scatheless, +but now and then picking out one without moving an inch from their +position. I tried vainly to discover the method of their madness, and +at last realised that they were selecting from amongst the myriads +of toothsome _ephemeridæ_ floating over their heads a redder-looking +fly. I could not wade, I could not manage to get one with my landing +net, so I put on at hazard a small red quill, with no response; then +a Hawker's yellow got a rise or two, and even deluded a brace of fish +into my creel, and then the glorious rise was over. Next morning, when +whirling back to town, I found myself in a carriage with four or five +anglers who had been fishing the next beat, and the murder was out. +One fortunate man had ascertained that they were taking the ginger +quills, which were very sparsely scattered amongst the olives, and that +information resulted in his taking nine brace of beautiful fish. + +But as a rule, it is far more a question of the correct delivery of the +fly than anything else, provided the size be right. For myself, I never +leave a rising fish that I have not scared, unless I am convinced there +is some objectionable and unavoidable drag; sooner or later you will +get him, possibly with the same fly that has been over his head a dozen +or so of times. We are all too ready to resort to a change of fly, and +to leave a non-responsive fish in disgust, in the hope of finding an +easier quarry. My advice is to stick to your fish unless, or until, he +is scared. Possibly the most annoying fish is the one that drops slowly +down, with his nose in close proximity to the fly, evidently uncertain +as to whether or no it is the Simon Pure, until he gets perilously near +to you. Even his scruples may be overcome if he gets back into position +without being alarmed. One of the most successful anglers I ever knew +on the upper Test, who owned a well-known stretch of water, was wont to +sally forth with two rods put up, one of which he carried, while the +other was carried by his keeper. On one was mounted a hare's ear, on +the other a blue dun; and that these flies answered their purpose his +records could testify. + +A difficulty that presents itself to the chalk stream angler is the +tendency of fish when hooked and when scared by seeing the angler +to bury themselves in the heavy masses of weed. This has now been +discounted by the modern method of hand lining--_i.e._, spiking the rod +and taking a good deal of slack line off the reel, and then holding +the line in the hand and using a gentle pressure on the fish in the +direction contrary to that in which he went. He usually responds very +readily, and the rod may then be resumed. Indeed, it is astonishing how +fish can be led and coaxed under this influence--the fact being that, +the upward play of the rod always tending to lift the fish out of his +own element and so drown him, he naturally plays hard to avoid this; +take the upward strain off him and he becomes another creature. + +Yet another difficulty encountered by the dry fly fisherman is caused +by fish coming short. What angler is there who has not experienced +this annoyance, and how often, as Mr. Halford in his work on Dry Fly +Fishing has noticed, does the angler find that after the first rush is +over and the hook comes away there is a small scale firmly fixed on +the barb, showing that the fish has been foul-hooked? My observations +on this class of rise would lead me to believe that the fish moved to +the fly in the ordinary manner, but that something arose to excite his +mistrust, and that he closed his mouth while the impetus of his rise +broke the water, making the angler think that it was a real rise, so +that he struck, and on his striking the hook took a light hold on the +outside--a hold seldom effective, though most fishermen have landed +fish hooked in such a way. I have generally found in such cases that +a smaller hook has produced a more confident rise, and my experience +would not lead me to endorse Mr. Halford's view that the use of a 000 +hook handicaps the angler very heavily. It may do so with the heavy +Houghton water fish, but I have not found it a severe handicap with the +smaller trout--1 lb. to 2½ lb.--of the upper Test and similar waters. + +A very keen and expert dry fly fisherman, the late Mr. Harry Maxwell, +one of the best of friends and anglers, once showed me a method of +taking fish lying with their tails against a wire fencing that crossed +the Test at right-angles, the wire moreover being barbed. I was fishing +in Hurstbourne Park, and he was accompanying me, as he often did, +with his field-glass. Below the "cascade" a four or five-stranded +barbed wire fence went straight across the water. Just above it, in +mid-stream, in the stickle, a plump, transparent-looking Test fish of +about 1½ lb. had taken up his position, and was boldly taking every +dun within reach. My friend told me to catch him, and I said at once I +did not know how to do it without getting hung up. He then explained +his dodge, which may be carried out as follows:--Having waded in below +the fish, take some loose coils of line off the reel in the left hand, +then cast well above, and let the dry well-cocked fly float down to +him. If he accepts it and comes down under the fence slack off the +loose coils, get up to the fence as quickly as possible, pass the rod +under and over, and then you are free to play the trout below you. If, +on the other hand, he refuses the fly, do not attempt to recover the +line in the usual manner or you will inevitably be hung up. Simply +lower your rod point to the water, and then the quiet drag of the +stream will bring your cast and fly slowly up and over the fence, even +although the fly had floated a foot or two down-stream and under the +wire. The action is so slow and even that there is no chance of being +entangled in the wires, and as a fish in such a position thinks he +is in possession of a vantage-point, and is seldom fished for, he is +generally a bold feeder. Having explained the method, my friend made me +try the cast myself, and the first fly floating near enough to tempt +the fish was taken boldly; the whole manoeuvre succeeded, and I was +able to land my trout below me. Since then I have frequently made use +of my experience, and with invariable success. If any anglers who are +not aware of this method care to try the experiment they will see how +sweetly the line travels over the fence without the slightest risk of +entanglement. + +There is but little doubt that the fly that is kept going catches most +fish. On a seemingly hopeless day an odd fish here and there can be +picked up if really sought for; and on these days the rise, if any, is +so inconstant and so short-lived that it may easily be missed. On such +a day, on the wide shallows of the Longparish water of the Test, three +of us were struggling with the adverse conditions of a lowish river, a +bright sun, and a great lack of duns. We had agreed to meet at luncheon +at about 1 p.m. in the hut on the river's bank. I had found a seat upon +the upturned stump of a tree in mid-stream. There were fish all round +me in the shallows, but all on the bottom, apparently asleep. I knew +that if I left my place and waded ashore I should move them all. I was +enjoying my pipe, and so sat on. The whistles and calls from the hut +passed unheeded, for I had noticed that my friends the trout showed +more signs of animation. An olive or two came down, and gradually the +fish seemed to rise from the bottom and take up their positions. More +calls from the shore. I shouted back to them not to wait, and at length +they gave me up as a bad job. + +Soon a fish on my left front took an obvious olive, a pale one, and I +had a pale olive on my cast. Still I waited, and soon the first few +olives were followed by quite a little procession. I then cast over my +fish, and at the first offer he took it. I got him down below me, and +soon netted him out, wading up again most carefully and slowly to my +seat; and from that position, in about twenty minutes, got seven fish +in succession, all taken with the same fly and from the same spot. +They were none of them very big, it is true, but they were all over a +pound in weight. By this time my friends had finished their luncheon, +and came out of the hut just as I was netting my seventh fish. Hastily +getting their rods, they were just in time to get a fish apiece from +the bankside, and the rise was over. Moreover, it was the only rise +vouchsafed to us that morning or afternoon. So that the moral is that +you can never tell when the psychological moment may arrive, and may +easily miss it when it does come if you are lying on your back reading +a novel, or with your eyes anywhere but on the water. One must lunch, +no doubt, but it can generally be best enjoyed in the outer air, where +you can watch the water and the fish whilst enjoying your luncheon and +your rest. And on such inauspicious days do not relax your precautions +in approaching the water, or from nonchalance or weariness allow +yourself to cast carelessly. Your field glasses will often reveal to +you a more likely fish--at the tail of the weed, maybe, or under the +thorn bush on the opposite bank--and it may be worth while to float a +fly over him and give him a trial. If he accepts the offer he is worth +to you several got out under more favourable conditions. + +When fish are really smutting, and the water is almost boiling with +rises, the angler's patience is most sorely tried. Nothing seems to +tempt them; the smallest gnats ever tied are far too big. Who will +tell us what to do in such a case? In truth, I know not. All I can say +is that they are in a peculiarly aggravating humour. How vexatious, +too, are the tailing fish, boring their heads into the weeds and +breaking the water with their broad tails--and their tails always look +particularly broad at such times. I have at times caught them with a +big alder, fished wet, and jerked past them when they have finished +for the moment their diving operations, and their heads are up. It is +chance work, and, if not productive of much use of the landing-net, +will serve to pass the time and amuse you; for if you don't succeed in +hooking many you will certainly get an occasional one to run at your +fly, his back fin breaking the water and making as big a wave as if +he were twice the size. In the quick water by the hatch holes on such +a day you may find a rising fish, though when hooked he will probably +prove unsizeable. + +Never despair or give it up, unless you are one of the fortunate +individuals who live by their water side, and who can therefore pick +and choose. Where all days are yours it would be folly to persevere on +really bad ones; but most of us are not so favourably situated, and we +have to make the most of the odd chances we get. Therefore my counsel +is to examine and watch the water, and be ever on the alert. + +Where Sunday fishing is not permitted, the day of rest always seems +to be the best angling day of the week, and you are tempted to be +annoyed and objurgate Dame Fortune. Even then, if you are a wise man, +you can turn such a day to your advantage by stalking up the water as +carefully as if you were fishing, and by making mental notes that will +very materially assist you on the following day. And if Sunday fishing +is allowed, do not give umbrage to many of the parishioners going to +church by making a parade of your waders and fishing rod. Either get +to your water before church time or else wait till the church bells +are over before you walk along the village street. Busy City men get +scant leisure for sport, and may fairly be excused for utilising their +week-end holiday to the full. Much latitude may be allowed to them in +this respect, provided they are careful not to outrage the religious +feelings of others. A walk along the river bank, enjoying and drinking +in to the full the beauties of Nature and of God's creation, may be as +productive of good to yourself as an indifferent sermon. It depends +upon your temperament and the power that the beauties of Nature have +over your mind. They can preach as eloquent a sermon as was ever +delivered from the pulpit, and may produce in you a frame of mind that +may be of real and lasting benefit to you. No man should be judged +hastily by narrow-minded bigots, or be termed a Sabbath-breaker for so +acting. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER IV. + +EDUCATION OF THE SOUTH-COUNTRY TROUT. + + +SURELY angling with the dry fly can be claimed as the highest branch +of the gentle craft? It cannot be doubted that those who have once +experienced the fascination of "spotting" and stalking a well-fed +and highly-educated south-country trout are bitten for life, and +are, especially at first, rendered somewhat unappreciative of the +sister art. The best fisherman is he who can best adapt himself to +his environment and is ready to adopt the method most likely to be +successful on the water he happens to be fishing. But undoubtedly +dry-fishing labours under one serious disadvantage that does not affect +the wet-fly fisherman, namely, the much dreaded drag, so sadly familiar +to those who fish the rise with the floating fly. Who is there, +however, who has not experienced legitimate pride and pleasure when, by +change of position or by deft casting, its baleful effects have been +overcome and discounted? + +It is not given to everyone to command the sleight of hand of a master +and to be able at will to pitch a fly, cocked and floating exactly +right, whilst a bag of the line has been simultaneously sent up stream, +so that for a short few moments whilst passing over the fateful spot +the fly may float truly with the stream, out of the influence of the +more rapid water between the fish and the fisherman. In streams where +wading is allowed the fisherman has undoubtedly an advantage, as he +can get more directly behind the fish, and so avoid the heavy current. +But wading is not always feasible in waters such as those of the lower +Test, where the depth of the stream precludes it. Even then, skill and +local knowledge will often overcome the difficulty, and a fish in such +a position usually falls a ready victim to the fly that floats truly, +as he has been lulled into a sense of false security by his previous +experience that dangerous flies leave a trailing mark behind them. But +what a revelation it is of the education that trout have received, and +how capable they are of absorbing and profiting by it! It seems almost +as if the constant catching and destruction of the freest rising fish +must be having effect in leaving those only to propagate their species +which are either past masters in cunning or which are more coarsely +organised fish, that devote their time and energies to bottom feeding +and avoid surface feeding, except, possibly, at night; the universally +acknowledged fact that fish are far more difficult to catch than they +formerly were may thus be explained. Certainly, nowadays, an angler +would be somewhat out of it who tried to emulate the far-famed Colonel +Hawker, of Long Parish, and to catch the wily trout in that beautiful +stretch of the Test while fishing off a horse's back. Nor could any +modern angler hope or expect to approach the baskets that were formerly +creeled. So is it everywhere. On the beautiful Driffield Beck, in +Yorkshire, a paradise for the dry-fly angler, the club limit of ten +brace of sizeable fish in one day used to be constantly attained, and +that, too, with the wet fly up or even down stream. Now, with split +cane rods, the finest gut, and the deftest of floating duns, five or +six brace is about the best basket obtainable by experienced and most +skilful anglers. + +[Illustration: BRINGING HIM DOWN TO THE NET.] + +The natural question that perplexes and worries chalk-stream anglers is +whether this "advanced" education of brook and river trout is to go on +increasing. If we can only hope to catch half the amount of fish our +progenitors did, what are the prospects of the next generation? Shall +we have to fall back on black bass or rainbow trout to secure a race +of free-rising fish? Or does the fault lie in over-cutting of weeds +and bad river farming? I am inclined to think it does. Riverside mills +are in an almost hopeless position commercially. The miller requires a +heavier head of water than formerly, and with a decaying industry it is +hard to refuse him, the result being that to maintain his head of water +the weeds are ruthlessly and unscientifically cut over vast stretches +of water, shallows are bared, and the holts or refuges of trout are +done away with, and as a natural consequence trout become less +confiding and far more easily alarmed. Modern agricultural drainage +has, moreover, increased the difficulty by carrying off the water +too rapidly. It behoves votaries of the gentle art to consider most +carefully whether anything can be done to remedy the seriousness of the +future outlook, and to disseminate the results of their inquiry; and if +the Fly Fishers' Club, or some well-known leaders of repute, would take +the matter up and tackle it seriously they would earn the blessings of +the angling world. + +It is considered to be undoubtedly a disadvantage in a club water to +include one or two pre-eminently brilliant anglers, as it seems to +breed a fear of their always being able to catch the easy fish, so +that the more difficult ones only are left for the ordinary angler to +attack. Not long ago I was invited to fish a certain well-known beat on +the Itchen, but my host, in inviting me, said, "I don't know if it is +much use, for So-and-So fishes our water, and has caught all the easy +fish." This may be true in a sense, but favourite positions are always +re-taken by other fish if the former occupant is killed. Just as a +house in Grosvenor Square, or some well-known centre of fashion, will +always secure a tenant, so a position where the trend of the current +brings the flies quietly and steadily over a fish will never remain +unoccupied. It is not so much the fish that is easy as his position, +and therefore the ordinary duffer need never despond. One thing is +certain--that the brilliant angler will never scare fish unnecessarily, +and I would rather fish behind such an one than a so-called angler who, +having successfully put his fish down by bad angling, proceeds to stand +upright and possibly walk along the bankside close to the water's edge, +scaring many a fish on his way up, utterly regardless of his brother +anglers. Indeed, in this respect I think the etiquette of angling is +hardly sufficiently considered in these modern days. Who is there that +has not met, on club waters, the ardent and unsuccessful angler who +wanders up and down, covering vast stretches of water, and effectually +scaring many otherwise takeable fish, in the vain hope that he may +find some purblind trout idiotic enough to take his proffered fly? I +consider that unwritten etiquette demands that the utmost care should +be taken by fishermen to do all in their power to prevent spoiling the +sport of those who may be following. I can well recollect a day when +the wind was foul, and there was one stretch of water sheltered on +the windward side by a thick belt of trees, and in this stretch were +located many heavy fish. Working up to that water, I found an ardent +ignoramus doing "sentry-go" up and down the stream, walking on the very +edge of the water. I presume he thought that if he only persevered he +would eventually find the "fool of the family," but the result--the +inevitable result--was that the fish were scared throughout that whole +length for the rest of that day, as that stretch was bare and sadly +lacking in shelter. + +In considering the merits and demerits of dry-fly fishing, one +cannot be altogether blind to the fact that down-stream fishing must +inevitably prick and therefore educate many more fish than the floating +fly. This being so, it is still more inexplicable that in former days, +in chalk-stream waters, our forerunners were able to account for far +heavier baskets of trout than we are, despite the heavy restocking +our streams now receive, to their great advantage; and we necessarily +come back to the old point, what can we do to secure an adequacy of +free-rising fish? Is our system of fishing the rise wrong? Or does the +mischief lie more in our river, water, and weed management? And can we +so improve these as to obtain the desired results? Angling is now so +much sought after, chalk-stream and other similar waters command such +high rents, that surely it is worth the while of those interested in +the sport to initiate and carry through some exhaustive inquiry into +the subject. + + + + +CHAPTER V. + +THE MAY FLY. + + +THE May fly is up! Every year, about the first week in June, telegrams +to this effect are hurriedly despatched to those favoured few who own +or rent water where this member of the _ephemeridæ_ disports himself. +It used to be called the May fly Carnival. There are, however, grave +disadvantages in connection with our friend that greatly discount the +apparent advantages. Fish gorged with this luscious food are wont to +try a course of semi-starvation after their over-indulgence, and for a +long time will not look at smaller and more wholesome diet. Then, to +my thinking, a May fly is a horrible thing to cast with. It is not at +all like casting with the more delicate duns or quill gnats. There is a +clumsy feeling about it; it is exceedingly difficult to dry, and if you +catch a fish a change of fly is at once necessary, the old chawed-up +imitation being rendered useless. It is also not easy to get exactly +the right pattern to suit, though for choice the small dark-winged May +fly has given me the best results. It is, unless you live near your +water, very difficult to hit off the precise day--you are always too +early or too late; you are told "You should have been there yesterday; +there was a grand rise of fly, and the fish were simply mad after them, +and no one was on the water"--and so on. Cheery news, no doubt, when +you find the fish all lying near the bottom. When they really are on, +there is excitement enough; mad splashes all round you, frequently made +by the smaller fish. Your proffered imitation may produce a rise or +two, but somehow or other the fish don't take hold as you think they +ought. You are inclined to lose your calmness of mental balance, to +cast without sufficient care and with a half-dried fly. In desperation +you put on a fair-sized red quill, fish more carefully, and probably +get better results. + +The main charm, however, lies in the fact that the advent of _Ephemera +Danica_ does bring up the big fish of the water in a way that no other +fly food does or can. Hence its popularity, and in waters where the +May fly is hatched in quantity, and there are heavy, big fish that as +a rule find cannibalism pay better than duns, then the May fly has a +real value. In other waters, however, were these big monsters taken out +in order to secure a larger numerical stock of comparatively small but +sizeable fish, I would have none of it; I would prefer to extend my +angling season rather than take a large bulk of it condensed into one +week of questionable pleasure. + +Certainly, the May fly season comes at about the best time of the year +to enjoy angling. A fine week about the commencement of June is most +enjoyable on any river. All nature is at its best--leafy June, when +sauntering by the riverside, even with scanty sport, is in itself a +pleasure not to be despised. + +Mr. Sidney Buxton, in his admirable "Fishing and Shooting," graphically +describes a day in the Carnival time, when he grassed thirty fish +from two pounds down, and of another when he creeled forty; but, good +sportsman as he is, I rather fancy he would have enjoyed even more a +day with half to a third of the basket when each fish had been stalked +and picked out with a small fly. Not for a moment would I suggest or +imply that equal care is not needed in casting with the May fly if +you wish to fill your creel; but, all said and done, a bungling cast +will often secure a good fish with that lure which would inevitably +have put him down and scared him had he been feeding upon the ordinary +flies. It is very noticeable nowadays how capricious the rise is. +Indiscriminate weed cutting has almost entirely eradicated the May fly +from some waters, and quite entirely on others--a boon to some minds, +my own included, but a boon that bears sour fruit in other ways, for +irregular and injudicious weed-cutting hits other fly food hard. It is +curious, also, that in places where more judicious weed farming has +been resorted to of late the May fly has begun to return, patchily and +scantily enough, but nevertheless in increasing quantities every year. +I would fain leave them to hatch out upon the Kennet and the Colne and +similar waters, and leave our bonnie streams alone, but here there is +no choice; if they come, they come, and we must make the best of them. + +A big rise of May fly is indeed a wonderful sight, the drakes flopping +into your face, covering everything, seeming almost like a plague of +locusts. Fat, luscious insects, enjoying to the full their brief spell +of winged life, after having spent months in the larval state. See that +one floating down-stream, airing and drying his wings, floating on his +nymphal envelope. He is floating dangerously near that trout that has +already annexed a goodly number of his fellows. Will he be taken too? +No; he flutters off, clumsily enough, making for the shore, only to be +swallowed by a hungry chaffinch. So his brief period of air life is +over. And what a feast he and his congeners provide for the swallows, +the finches, and other birds. Towards sunset, males and females of the +green drake tribe float and flutter about in the air, make love and +pair, then the female deposits her eggs on the water, and at last both +fall on the river with outspread wings, forming what we call the spent +gnat. + +The trout take heavy toll of the nymphæ rising upwards before they +reach the water surface, and will not then look at a floating +imitation; and when the act of reproduction is completed they feed +greedily upon the empty shucks and the spent gnats. Altogether, our +friend the May fly seems to spend a hazardous and somewhat inglorious +life. Could he but see himself in his larval state, I feel sure he +would lose his self-respect. He is then no beauty, and to grovel and +lie low in the mud at the bed of the river for, as some say, two years, +cannot form a very exciting kind of life; whilst if he escapes in +the imago state, countless enemies lie in wait for him, and his very +love-making costs him his life. + +The return of the May fly to a certain well-known chalk stream in +Yorkshire seems to be an accomplished fact, though one not altogether +to the satisfaction of the members of the club that fish its waters. +This stream, known as the Driffield Beck, ranks high amongst kindred +waters, the dry fly reigns supreme, the stream is as swift and even, +the water as crystal clear, and the trout as fully educated as those +of their brothers of the Itchen or Test. In former times the May fly +hatched in countless numbers on this stream, and the Carnival used in +those days to be reserved strictly for the members of the club; but +whether it were attributable to over-cutting of the weeds, or to some +other cause, the May fly died away entirely from the stream, and for +many a season not a fly was hatched. We members of the club--a very +old one, by the way--rather congratulated ourselves on this change, +as, instead of gorged fish who would not look at a dun for weeks after +the May fly period, we were treated to an even rise at the small fly +throughout all the angling months. But two seasons before we had +noticed, to our surprise, the advent of a few May flies. I recollect +impaling one upon a hook and drifting it down cunningly over a good 2½ +lb. fish who had taken up his position under a thorn bush on my side +of the river, and the scared bolt he made when it got to him and he +had had a good look at it was a thing to remember. And, in fact, the +few May flies which that year floated over fish in position made them +all bolt as if they had been shot. Then in the next season there was a +more considerable hatching of the fly, and in one spot in particular +a few fish were taken with the green drake. The third year we arrived +at the right time for the hatch, then a very local one on our stream; +but in that particular part of the river there was a rise of May fly +to satisfy the most gluttonous of those who love that form of angling. +But the curious thing was the way in which the fish treated the fly. +Every now and again the ½ lb. and ¾ lb. fish would take them boldly, +and here and there a fish of that size would settle down to a regular +feed, taking all within reach; but the heavier fish seemed to be +thoroughly disinclined to take them. The bolder young ones now and +again paid the penalty of their temerity, being consigned to the basket +if fully 11 inches in length, or returned to the water if, as was too +frequently the case, they were not sizeable. I do not pretend to any +great experience of May fly fishing, though I have been a devoted +dry-fly angler for many years; but I do not remember to have seen fish +act so capriciously in my previous experiences. The birds, however--the +warblers, chaffinches, &c.--were quite equal to the occasion, and took +heavy toll of the _ephemeridæ_. I particularly noticed what I never +remember to have seen before, _i.e._, a cock blackbird darting out of +the bushes at intervals to secure a fluttering _Ephemera Danica_, and +returning to his shelter to pick the luscious morsel to pieces at his +leisure. + +My luck was not considerable; the rise of dun was insignificant, the +wind was simply abhorrent, and my baskets, naturally, were not as +heavy as I could have wished. The water was in perfect order, the fish +abundant, but sport indifferent. One day I went up one of the upper +feeding streams, where I had often, poor performer though I may be, +secured a really good basket of good fish. After rising and pricking +more than a dozen fish, all of which rose short, and turning over and +getting a short run out of a three-pounder which had permanently taken +up his position above a bridge by a garden-side under some sedges in +a difficult position--rendered more difficult by the violence of the +wind--I had to content myself with a poor brace of 1¼ pounders, going +home feeling regretfully that I had done that day a good deal in the +way of educating fish! + +The last day of my visit (June 10) I had somewhat of a more interesting +experience. The wind was still high, though warmer, and, though no rain +fell, there was a feeling that rain was not far off. The report that +the May fly was up and in quantity had brought out a number of anglers, +and when I got to the water-side, armed with a box of May flies given +me by a prince among anglers, I found all the 'vantage spots (in the +small extent of the water where the fly hatched in any quantity) duly +occupied by an ardent angler ready for the fray. So I quietly gave that +game up and retired to a small island between two branches of the river +near the keeper's cottage. I had but a couple of hundred yards to fish, +while the ground where I was standing was sedge covered elbow-high with +charmingly and conveniently placed bushes here and there behind me, +ready to hitch up any fly that, in the backward cast, should be driven +by the wind into their embrace. The only chance was to keep up a kind +of steeple cast, as the stream was a fair width across. The charm of +the position, however, was that on the other side was a high bank with +a plantation on it, which shed a welcome shade over the bank fish on +that side. It was very difficult to locate a rise, but the stream was +even and there was no drag. Nor was it an easy matter to land a fish, +as the fringe of sedges was wide and thick, and the water deep; my +landing-net was also over-short--a bad fault--and caused me to lose +three good fish, one well over 2 lb. I spent nearly all the day on this +place, and managed to hook every fish I saw rise, and that was not a +great number, the rise of dun being so small and the wind blowing them +off the river almost as soon as they started on their swim down-stream. +However, I managed to land five fish, all on a 000 gold-ribbed hare's +ear, the best one 1 lb. 9 oz. and the smallest a little over a pound; +but as they were all in the pink of condition, and each fish was a +problem to get, I enjoyed the day far more than a more prolific one, +when the duns might be sailing steadily, the fish all in position, and +where catching them would be far more of a certainty, and where even a +duffer could not have failed to score. + +Perhaps I may have been somewhat unfortunate in my May fly experiences, +and most anglers would be disinclined to agree with my faint +appreciation of this insect and of the sport he assists to produce. +Most of my friends speak of this form of angling in a totally different +strain, therefore, presumably, I must be wrong in my view. To me, +however, the May fly (as a means to an end) is of great value in +tempting up the bigger cannibal fish, but as an adjunct to sport, I am +inclined to consider him overrated. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER VI. + +THE EVENING RISE. + + +HAVING recorded my heterodox views about May fly fishing, I fear I +shall run counter to the opinions of many if I venture to state my +ideas relative to the evening rise. For my part I find it, in the main, +vanity and vexation of spirit. + +Doubtless, in the hot days of July and August, when rivers appear, +under sultry conditions, to be almost tenantless, when after, say, 3 +p.m., you may watch for all you are worth without seeing a dimple or +a rise, it is some consolation to go home for a little rest and an +early meal, intending to avail yourself of the evening chances with +a possible brace or so of fish to save, maybe, coming in clean. Eyes +tired with the glare of the water are grateful for the rest, and with +the proverbial hope rising freely in the angler's bosom, you mentally +reckon up the big captures you are going to make in the short time +afforded by the evening rise. + +Refreshed in mind and body, you regain your favourite spot at 7 or 7.30 +p.m., and the evening seems to promise well. It does not look as if +those cruel mists would begin to rise at sundown; there is little or +no wind; the hatch of fly throughout the day has been insignificant; +surely there must be a good rise this evening, everything seems to +foreshadow it. You take up your station and watch the water carefully, +especially the one or two spots near the opposite bank that you know +full well ought to be occupied by good fish. A few spinners hatch out +and dance merrily about; the gnats hover purposely up and down; an +odd dun sails down ignored, as far as the fish are concerned, and at +length, freeing himself from the water, gains the bank side. Surely +that was a rising fish by the bank of rushes yonder? But the shadow of +the rushes thrown by the lowered sun prevents you from locating him +exactly. It was a floppy rise, probably caused by some small fish. +Something must be done, for the time is short; so, letting out your +line to the required length, you despatch your olive to sail down the +bank of rushes. No response. Another trial provokes a rise, and you are +fast in the fish; but, as anticipated, he proves to be a half-pounder, +and, handling him gently, after having removed the fly, which was +provokingly well fixed in his tongue, you carefully hold him in the +water until he has regained his wind and recovered from his exhaustion. +Whilst so engaged you hear a heavy splash to your right. Hastily +glancing up, you cannot locate that rise either, but it is something +that they are beginning. No sedges have appeared, so you retain your +olive. A good quiet mid-stream boil above you attracts your attention. +That fellow means business, anyhow. Your olive, however, though deftly +offered, sails over his position unnoticed and despised. You change +to a bigger fly, a 00 red quill; the light is still good. He refuses +that equally, and whilst you are doubting whether to change or no, up +he comes again. What is he taking? Some small fly, no doubt, but none +that you can see. Try him with a hare's ear. You change, and whilst +you are tying on the fly you hear a succession of floppy rises below +you. You somewhat undecidedly give the trout one more chance, but +half-heartedly, as you want to get down to those other fish--result, a +bad cast, effectually putting down our friend. + +[Illustration: THE SEDGE HOUR.] + +The light is beginning to go, so you re-change to your bigger red +quill and try your luck with those below you. Fly after fly, carefully +placed, cocked and floating, produces but little result, one pounder +succumbing. You see he is not a big one, and give him scant grace, +meaning to get him into the net as soon as possible, and so bring him +in half done. The net somewhat too hurriedly shown him produces an +effort on his part, and he has weeded you. You spike your rod and try +hand-lining; he does not seem to yield, and you are impatient, and +resume your rod. Something must go; you have no time to lose. Suddenly +with a wriggle he extricates himself from the weed, to your infinite +astonishment, and he is then soon brought to book. But many precious +minutes have been wasted; the fly has got itself fixed in one of the +knots in your landing net. Never mind, break it off; you must get to +sterner business. So you take some few more minutes in threading the +eye of a small, dark sedge fly, as the fish by now must be at work +upon the larger flies. Flop! flop! on the opposite side, under the +shadow of the reeds. See that your fly is dry and cocks well; keep out +of sight--an absolute essential in evening fishing--and go for that +uppermost fish. That was a good rise; was it at your fly? It is hard +to see by the waning light. Evidently not. Try him again. This time he +rises well, and you are fast in him; but you struck too heavily; he was +a good fish, and you have left your fly in him, bad luck to it! + +This time you have to make use of a match to enable you to thread the +eye, but after some fumbling struggles you at last succeed. One more +try. Pity you had not put on a somewhat stouter cast, but it is too +late now. You must be a bit more gentle with them; a slight turn of the +wrist is all you want. There is a good rise, just beyond mid-stream, +and a good cast just four inches above the rise. You can see your fly, +and also the neb of a good trout as he breaks the water to suck him in. +Now gently does it! He is hooked, and goes careering up stream to the +tune of the song of the reel. Steady him now; don't let him get into +the rushes. The light is fast going, and you are inclined to hurry him. +Better be cautious; his tail looked broad as he turned over that time; +he is fat and in lusty condition, and has no intention of surrendering +his life without a good struggle. Don't show him the net; that last run +must have settled him; he flops on the surface; he is gently led into +the mouth of the net, and is yours. Not so big as you fancied, by any +means; might be 1½ lb.; you put him down as well over 2 lb. He is well +hooked, and after taking the fly from his mouth you grip him well and +give his head a good hard tap against the handle of your landing net; +in so doing he slips from your grasp and nearly flops into the river. +Hurriedly you put yourself between him and the water and get hold of +him, making sure of him this time, and he goes into your bag. Is there +still light for one more? Hardly, and it is no pleasure when you cannot +see your fly. + +You take up your rod again, and pass your hand down the line and cast. +Where is that fly? Caught up somewhere in your struggles with the +trout. It is engagingly fixed in your coat, about the small of your +back. So you lay your rod down again, take off your coat, and extricate +your fly with your knife at the cost of some of the cloth of your coat. +Pack up your things and trudge home somewhat annoyed with yourself +and thinking of the opportunities you had lost, and determining next +evening to have some points of gut attached to suitable flies in your +cap, ready for the fray--no more threading eyes under such adverse +conditions for you. + +Next evening you repair to the place where you know the big trout +lie and are sure to rise well. Fully equipped in every detail, and +determined not to be induced to hurry, but to take things quietly and +composedly, you reach your station. What is that in the meadow over +there? A mist, by Jove! And soon the aforesaid mist begins to rise on +the water, most effectually stopping all hope of sport; so reluctantly +you leave the water side, a sadder and a wiser man, reflecting that the +evening rise is by no means the certainty you had fondly hoped. + +Of course it is not always so. I recollect one evening on the Test, +when, after a hot day with scarce a semblance of a feeding fish, except +tailers, there was a grand evening rise, and on a big red quill I got +seven fish, almost from the same spot, in little over a quarter of an +hour; but these days are too infrequent to alter my stated opinion +that the evening rise is an overrated pleasure, and generally produces +vexation of spirit. + +If you do fish in the evening hours, recollect that you must be just +as cautious in approaching fish as if it were broad daylight; that any +sign of drag will as effectually put a fish down as in the earlier +hours. Your fly must float and cock as jauntily as in the morning, but +you lose the chief charm of fishing the floating fly, namely, that +you cannot spot your fish in the water and watch their movements; you +have to cast at a rise, or where you imagine a rise to have been. +Use a small fly at first and then a little later change to a big red +quill, or, if the sedge flies are out, to a small dark sedge. You can +afford to have a point of stronger gut, for you will have often to +play a fish pretty hard, and they don't appear to be so gut shy as the +evening closes in. But as soon as you can no longer see your sedge fly +on the water, reel up. Fishing in the dark is no true sport, and it is +uncommonly near to poaching. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER VII. + +"JACK." + + +THE upper waters of the Bourne and Test flow through Hurstbourne, Lord +Portsmouth's beautiful park, and were tenanted until a few years ago by +portly trout of aldermanic weight and size. It was found, however, that +they proved too costly to be retained, as the toll they took of the +smaller fish was prodigious, and out of proportion to their value. They +were accordingly captured by degrees, and replaced by a more numerous +colony of smaller fish. It used to be a grand sight to watch the big +fellows lying in the quick water near the big stone bridge, or chasing +the pounders with angry rushes. + +When I knew the water, some ten or twelve years ago, there were still a +few of these goodly-proportioned fish remaining. They were well-known, +and each one had his nickname. Thus one was known as "Jack"; he +almost invariably lay in a narrow outlet to a culvert that led the +surplus water from the pool above under the roadway into the pool +below the bridge. For the greater portion of its length the water ran +underground, emerging from the culvert some two or three yards from the +river. The ground on either side at the end of the culvert was fully +three feet above the water, the banks being nearly vertical, while +the stream at the culvert's mouth was only about a foot wide. In this +narrow gully or channel lay Jack, his nose being only a few inches from +the masonry. Any unwary footfall speedily dislodged him from his little +bay into the main stream, but by crawling up warily he could be seen +and admired. + +Many had tried to secure him by fair fishing, but though once or twice +hooked he had so far got off scot free. Nor was his post an easy one to +attack; the water was, of course, gin-clear, very narrow, and also very +shallow. The slightest sign of gut--and he was off. + +On a lovely summer morning--to be accurate, the 26th of June, 1893--my +dear old friend Harry Maxwell and I had fished up from the bee-hive, +past the cascade, and were nearing the bridge with rather more than +average success, and had decided to eat our luncheon on the bankside, +under the friendly shade of the bridge. It was, however, barely +half-past twelve--too early, we agreed, for lunch--so Maxwell went up a +little to fish the shallow above, and I elected to have a try for Jack, +as I had reconnoitred and found him to be occupying his accustomed +corner. As the river was rather low, and as bright as only a chalk +stream can be, I decided to break through my general rule and put on +two lengths of the finest drawn gut, feeling that in this instance any +natural gut, however fine, would be out of the question. + +I was careful to draw the gut through a bunch of weed, to diminish the +glare; the Whitchurch dun was on the water, and its counterfeit had +already secured us some fair fish, but for some reason or other I was +impelled to select a small 000 pale watery dun, called the Driffield +dun, for my lure. After carefully testing my line and cast I waded out +into the heavy stream, opposite to and commanding the outlet of Jack's +bay. + +Knowing that there was little hope of dropping my fly at the desired +spot without giving my friend a glimpse of the gut, after a preliminary +cast or two, to make sure of my distance, I sent off my fly on its +errand, intending to pitch it on the grass just above the culvert. The +first cast, fortunately, went right, and by a gentle tap or two on the +butt of my rod I dislodged the fly from the grass, and it fluttered +down airily in front of Master Jack, the fine gut never having touched +the water. No sooner had it done so than Jack had it. Fortunately +I did not strike too hard, as one is so liable to do under such +circumstances; just the requisite turn of the wrist and the small hook +went home. + +Before I had time to realise fully what had happened the fish had +bolted from his holt into the main stream, a bag of unavoidable line +behind him as he charged straight towards me. On regaining touch with +him I found that the hook had still firm hold, and that Jack was +boring up for the bridge in the heavy water. Naturally, I had no idea +of allowing him to thread his way up through the arch, as I could ill +follow him there, so I had to keep up as steady and strong a strain as +I dared. He soon had enough of that fun, and down he came at express +speed past me, leaving me to get in my line by hand as best I could. +By good luck, I was able to get the slack reeled up whilst Jack was +careering about in the broader water below me. Hardly had I done so +when, at the end of his run, he gave a grand leap, after the fashion of +a sea trout; a dip of rod-point to his majesty saved a catastrophe, and +I now began to try to reach terra firma. My friend, however, was not +at all disposed to give me much time for such an operation, and just +as I was trying to regain the bank--a sufficiently ticklish operation +with a wild fish held only by the finest of drawn gut--he made a most +determined rush for the big bed of flags below the bridge. Once let him +attain that stronghold and I was fairly done; so I had once more to +test my gut, and resolutely to determine that he should obey my will. +Better be broke at once than lose him in that weed bed. Once more he +gave way, and I was able to regain the bank. At that moment Maxwell +turned up for luncheon, and the fish, now absolutely beaten, was +successfully netted out. I found that in his mad rushes and gyrations +he had managed to get two full turns of the gut round his gills. This +no doubt accounted for his coming to bank so speedily. He weighed just +over 3¼ lb.--no great monster after all, you may ejaculate, but he was +about the most perfect specimen of a trout I have ever seen, and was +in the pink of condition. He now graces my study in a glass case, the +only specimen of a fish that I have ever set up. But there was some +justification for this temporary mental aberration, and I often now +look at him and recall his sporting end, and the difficult conditions +under which I managed to capture him. He carries back my mind to the +fond recollections of my old friend, now no more, one of the best and +most unselfish of anglers, whose untimely loss has left a blank among +his many friends that cannot be filled. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER VIII. + +WEED CUTTING. + + +ALL dry fly anglers owe a deep grudge to modern sub-soil drainage, +which hurries, helter skelter, all the rain that falls into the +river, thus doing away with the former gentle soakage into the soil, +which served to feed our springs and keep up an even flow and an even +head of water. Now we have but alternations of flood and emptiness; +the millers, moreover, suffering from these alterations, and sadly +lacking water in most seasons, cry out loudly against any obstacle +in the river-bed; consequently the river weeds are ruthlessly and +unscientifically cut away. The weeds, the natural nurseries of +fish food, being thus reduced in quantity, the supply of food is +seriously compromised, holts for the fish are destroyed, bare areas +of river bed--on which moving one fish means possibly the moving of +scores--afford neither refuge nor shelter, and become practically +impossible to fish. All fish need shelter in the hot weather from the +summer sun, all need refuges to which to resort if scared; take these +away and the result must be deplorable. + +Those amongst us who have had the privilege of fishing in waters +where the cutting of the weeds has been scientifically and wisely +performed will have realised the difference this point alone can make +to a fishery. All the details of weed and water-farming have been so +exhaustively treated by Mr. Halford in his various works on "Dry fly +fishing," that they need not be described here. No better mentor could +be chosen. But some of the chief points that ought to be had in mind +may be touched upon. The chief desiderata, where there is an ample +supply of weed, are, to put the matter very shortly, to cut in the +deeper parts of the river lanes along both banks some ten feet wide, +and in the shallower parts to cut bars or lanes across the water at +right angles to the banks. At the same time lanes should, also, be cut +parallel to the banks, to encourage the bank fish. Where weed is not +in abundance recourse must be had to artificial shelters, or hides, +under which the fish can obtain the shelter that they require. Stakes +driven into the river bed soon attract a clinging mass of floating +weed, the only drawback to their being used is that hooked fish may be +lost through their bolting for and round them. Piles driven into the +shallows afford a welcome rest to fish, and it will be found that a +trout will nearly always take up his position behind them. Similarly, +big stones placed in the shallows will have a beneficial effect. + +The constant and irregular cutting of weeds has, moreover, a very +trying effect both upon the sport and the temper of an angler. Huge +masses of weed floating down, just at the moment when the hatch of fly, +so patiently waited for, is in full swing, and the fish in the mood +to take them, will sorely tax our powers of self-control. How often +has such a state of things extracted from us a "swear word"! These +very weeds may, nevertheless, be made to serve a useful purpose. There +is a fine fish lying a yard or so from the opposite bank; the stream +between us is heavy and quick; over the fish is an oily glide of water, +the pace of the stream being checked by friction with the river bank. +On this the duns float steadily, led by the stream into its embrace. +Our friend the trout knows this full well, and therefore persistently +takes up his station at that spot. We have often tried for him, but the +pace of the stream between us, stand where we will, has always beaten +us: no sooner has our well-cocked fly sailed into the head of the +glide than it is hurried across it, leaving a most unnatural trail, or +wake, behind it such as no living insect ever made. This trail of the +serpent, or "drag" as it is called, is one of the greatest difficulties +that we have to cope with in angling with the floating fly. It is, +like the poor, always with us. But the very weeds we have been so +persistently abusing may be brought into our service to overcome it. +Watch a mass of floating weed that is about to be carried over the +position of your fish, throw your fly so that the gut lies on the +advancing weed; the fly, with some inches of free gut, should rest upon +the water in front of the weed; the rest of your cast, being supported +by the weed, will be freed from the drag of the stream, and the fly +will float proudly over the fish. Unsuspecting he rises, sucks the fly +down in absolute confidence, and at last he is yours. Backwaters may +be overcome in a similar manner, and to this slight extent the curse +of the floating masses of weed may be converted into a real boon. This +slight advantage cannot be considered as counterbalancing the drawback +of indiscriminate weed cutting, it is merely an attempt to turn to our +use an otherwise unmitigated evil. + +Proprietors of valuable fishing rights are strangely unappreciative of +the advantages of scientific weed cutting and weed growing; they seem +to be inclined to let matters take their course, and in consequence +suffer considerably, and until they realise what this carelessness +means to them things will be allowed to go on in the old groove. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER IX. + +THE ANGLER AND AMBIDEXTERITY. + + +IT has always been an enigma to me why, having been endowed by +Providence with two hands, we should knowingly and deliberately +minimise the boon. All ranks and conditions of men, be their +occupations what they may, are affected. The nerves, sinews, and powers +of our left hands are equally as efficient and valuable as those of our +right hands; or, more strictly speaking, would be so if we only gave +them half a chance. Who has not experienced the difficulty of folding +a tie, tying a knot, or even buttoning a collar or a boot, &c., when +the right hand has been temporarily incapacitated? And who, except +the ambidextrous man, would be bold enough to shave himself entirely +with the left hand? Injure a man's right hand, and you render him +practically useless. Of all the arts, music alone trains both hands +equally; in some trades, such as cotton weaving, spinning, &c., the +left hands do their proper share of the work. + +Consider for a moment the amount of wastage there is in manual work +alone through this premeditated reduction of effective power! We +seem to be content, apparently, to halve our powers, and this for no +useful purpose whatever. The very children, who naturally would be +ambidextrous, are chidden and checked by their parents if, following a +natural instinct, they take up a pencil or a spoon in their left hands; +and so on through their school days, and even after, each and every +attempt to make a proper use of their left hand is sternly reproved, +until at last the poor unused and untaught left hands and arms become +of very secondary importance. Is there any phase of life in which +ambidexterity would not be a factor of the greatest value? Would it not +be a priceless boon equally to the soldier, the surgeon, the engineer, +the craftsman, the clerk, or the artisan? And does not the same apply +in the domain of sport? In shooting, would you not be at an advantage +if you could shoot equally from either shoulder? The fisherman--how +would it favour him? I unhesitatingly answer that it would aid him in +every branch of his sport. + +What angler amongst us could tie a Turle knot, or even thread an eyed +fly, left-handed? We should fumble and fume, and probably give it up +in despair. To the dry-fly fisherman the advantage that would accrue +through equality of arms and hands would simply mean a duplication of +effective power. Think of the countless occasions when an overhanging +tree or obtrusive bush has rendered a right-hand cast difficult, if +not impossible. In one position in particular a left-hand cast is of +extreme value. It enables you to command the water under your own bank +without having recourse to an awkward and always precarious back-handed +cast. + +You are carefully stalking your way up stream, the wind perhaps blowing +towards your own bank, the left bank of the river. About twenty yards +above you there is an overhanging tussock of grass with fringing blades +hanging over the stream. Near this tussock, or a little above it, you +note the dimple of a feeding trout; he is in a position where all the +duns are brought quietly sailing past his vantage post. A well-cocked +fly must inevitably secure him. You watch the duns one by one taken by +him; he is feeding steadily, and seems to be a good fish. To reach him +you have to cast with the right hand over the left shoulder. It is ten +to one that, if the length of cast is correct, the fly will be guided, +partly by the wind and partly by your arm, into the fringing grasses. +If it can be snatched off without scaring your trout, well and good; +but sooner or later, unless a particularly happy cast overcomes the +difficulty, you are bound to be hung up in the aforesaid tussock so +firmly as to necessitate a careful crawl to try and disengage your fly. +If you can free the fly without scaring the trout, well, you are so +far a lucky man. You either then recommence your struggle with adverse +circumstances, or more probably give him up as a bad job. Use your +left hand and arm, if you can, and the cast becomes a perfectly simple +one. Every dry-fly angler, moreover, knows full well how soon constant +casting and drying the fly tires and cramps the wrist and arm. What a +relief, then, to rest your right hand and give your left a chance. + +Nature has a wonderful recuperative power, and will reassert herself +provided you allow her to do so. The reacquisition of normal left-hand +dexterity is by no means difficult; a little assiduous practice, +despite the first feeling of awkwardness, will soon encourage you +to persevere. Practise on the lawn at a saucer, and in varying +conditions of wind, before the season commences; you will not only gain +additional interest in your casting, but will have acquired an asset of +considerable value. + +Not long ago, commenting upon what it was pleased to call the "latest +craze," viz., ambidexterity, an evening paper made merry over the +subject, and declared that there were enough awkward single-handed +men in the world without seeking to add an army of still more awkward +double-handed men. Such chaff may provoke a passing smile, but no chaff +will ever detract one iota from the value of double-handedness, and I +most strongly urge all anglers, old or young, to devote some little +time and attention to the acquirement of this most useful, though so +long neglected, bi-manual dexterity. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER X. + +LOCH FISHING. + + +LOCH fishing for trout is carried on for the most part amidst glorious +and romantic scenery. There is a sense of repose in the drifting boat +and the rhythmical cast. As a means of recreation and enjoyment it has +a distinct place in the affections of many of its votaries, and that +they are numbered by thousands the records of Loch Leven will amply +testify. To the overworked man, to those who are debarred from active +pedestrian exercise, this method of angling has a peculiar charm. To +the thronging multitudes of big Scottish cities (such as Glasgow, for +instance) the frequent competitions upon Loch Lomond or Loch Ard offer +a change of scene and environment that is simply invaluable, whilst +the ozone imbibed in such surroundings acts as an antidote to the +smoke-laden air to which their lungs are ordinarily subjected. + +[Illustration: A DRY FLY DAY ON LOCH ARD.] + +But when all is said and done, to the ardent angler it forms but a +monotonous kind of enjoyment. There is something so mechanical in the +constant casting of your collar of three or four flies on the chance +that some fish may take one of them. The row across the loch, the drift +over the same ground, repeated constantly are apt to pall. Doubtless +skill will assert itself in the long run, and every Scottish or Irish +loch has its record breakers, men who can be relied upon to hold their +own against all comers; but the novice and the bungler will often +succeed where more experienced anglers fail. Perhaps the stream angler +is too apt to work his flies to the top of the water, whilst the +novice, perforce, lets them sink; and, as a rule, the deeper you sink +your flies, within reason, and the less you play them, the better. +There is yet one more drawback to loch fishing, and that is, that you +are entirely at the mercy of the wind--or, rather, of the want of wind. +A still, glassy surface, and your boat fisherman is done. May that not +be because he is wedded to his three or four flies fished wet? Let him +try a dry fly under such circumstances; not necessarily on the ordinary +banks he is wont to fish so sedulously, but rather in the bays and +creeks and shallowing water amongst the rushes. + +On one occasion, about four years ago, I was in Perthshire, on the +side of Loch Ard--that sweet loch, more beautiful in some respects +than far-famed Loch Katrine. It was in early May. A big competition +from busy Glasgow had put fourteen boats upon the loch, and some +eight-and-twenty men were ready with double-handed and single-handed +rods to measure their skill against each other. It was a lovely day, +not a ripple upon the water. Ben Lomond's tops were reflected in the +glassy mirror, so that it was hard to tell which was the original and +which the mirrored counterfeit. For some hours these boats had, with +precise and repeated regularity, drifted across the best ground without +the semblance of a rise, only to be rowed round again to follow in the +same procession. There is no doubt that their occupants were sternly +in earnest, and would leave no chance untried. A faint catspaw of a +ripple might secure a rise, or perchance a fish, but catspaws were +few and far between. Hour after hour the rods were plied with stolid +monotony, responseless and unnoticed. And, as the day wore on to noon, +the conditions remained unvaried, and the catspaws even ceased to add a +temporary and evanescent interest. + +About that time--noon--I, having nothing in particular to do, took one +of the gillies with me in a boat across the loch. He was astonished to +see me take a rod, and no doubt put me down as a mad-brained Sassenach. +Nevertheless I took my little cane-built Pope rod and a box of Test +flies I happened to have with me, and we pulled up the loch and into +one of the bays at the far end. There I bade him rest on his oars, as +we were slowly drifting along the scanty rushes that grew out of the +bed of the loch. I soon saw a fish or two move--at what I could not +make out--so, taking an oar and gently using it as a paddle, I moved +along until I could locate an exact rise, and I noticed a small fly +near where the rise had been. Using the blade of my oar as a ladle I +annexed the insect, and found it to be a small green beetle. In my box +I found a small Coch-y-bondhu, which had a red tag and a peacock herl +body. My scissors soon removed the red tag, and then I fancied it might +do as a coarse representation of the Simon Pure. Having tied it on, I +cast it dry at the ring of the next rise. It was instantly taken, and +a plump ¾ lb. Loch Leven trout was soon in the net. And so it went on; +a cast here or there at the rises amidst the rushes, and in a short +hour and a quarter seven good trout had paid the penalty. We then rowed +home for luncheon, and, on inquiry, I found afterwards that the united +efforts of some twenty-eight men, all as keen as mustard, had produced +three fish. + +Does not this tell a tale of lost opportunities, and of the folly of +being wedded to one style of angling? Had there been a good fresh +breeze my dry fly would have been nowhere in competition with my +eight-and-twenty friends. The best fisherman is the best all-round +fisherman, able and willing to adapt himself to the circumstances in +which he may be placed. But how little of this dry-fly work is tried +upon our numerous lochs?--not a breath of wind, no good to fish! Yet +ripples here and there are breaking the surface, showing that the fish +are feeding. + +Many pleasant half-hours have I had on the same loch, after dinner, +under the rising moon, at the season when the main object of life is +the grouse shooting. On a mid-August evening, after a hot day, the +loch looks deliciously cool. Let us try our luck after dinner. We +take our rods, and put up for choice a small gold-ribbed hare's ear. +Let us get into that bay, in our boat, with our backs to the shelving +shore and the moon before us. There is a good rise. Paddle gently, but +quickly, near it; judge your distance accurately, keeping your eye on +the very centre of the now expanded rings. You pitch it accurately, and +it floats like a cork. Don't hurry to take it off--loch fish cruise +about--he may see it. I thought so; a good rise and well hooked, and +the pound Loch Leven fish merrily runs out your line. Now you've turned +him. Don't let him get under the boat. He has run past you into the +shadows, as that splash fully indicated. You can't see your line, nor +where he is. Never mind, keep his head up, and, above all things, +keep him away from the boat until he is done. He fights well, but the +contest is a very one-sided one; he cannot beat you as his brother of +the river often can, and in due course he is netted. + +Now dry your fly well; or, better still, put on that other hare's ear +you have already mounted upon a point of gut. We have rather disturbed +this water; let us move a bit further up the bank. The rises are +sadly infrequent, perhaps, but a brace of good fish taken under such +circumstances is worth catching, especially as the loch is generally +considered to be an early one, and the fishing to end in June for all +practical purposes. If only you will try it, this floating fly work +will add a very great interest to your enjoyment of your lovely loch. + +Perhaps I may be treating this subject somewhat too cavalierly, and +unduly emphasising my own views and predilections. Certainly I am free +to admit that I have enjoyed many pleasant days on our Scottish lochs. +One particular day stands out pre-eminently in my recollections. I was +staying at a shooting lodge near Pitlochry, and the famous Loch Broom +was within the precincts of our moor. To reach it we had a longish walk +and stiff climb, as it lies on the far side of a high, saddle-backed +line of hills. There were three boats on the loch, and one of them +belonged to my host. + +I was told that it was heavily stocked with good fish, but that a +strong breeze was necessary if good results were to be obtained. In +due course a gillie and I sallied forth one morning, somewhat late +in the season, armed with rods, tackle, and flies, to see what Loch +Broom would do for us. There certainly promised to be an ample supply +of wind to start with, and, as the day wore on, it had no tendency +whatever to go down, but rather to increase unduly; and when we reached +the loch side after our six or seven mile walk, we found miniature +foam-crested billows on its surface; in fact, rather more than we had +bargained for. The boat had been merely grounded in the rushes at the +loch side, and required baling out and adjusting. Intending to lose no +time, I speedily put up my rod and my cast of three flies and placed +it in the stern of the boat in order to soak the cast, then devoting +my attention to the assistance of the gillie, who was getting the +boat in readiness. Whilst I was doing so my reel began to screech, and +I found I had hooked a good trout, my cast of flies having apparently +been dancing over the wind-swept waves. It was certainly a good augury +of what was to come. After a good deal of trouble we got our boat +launched, and, though leaking a bit, it was in a floatable state. The +wind was too high to admit of a slow drift across the little loch, but +it did not much matter. + +At every cast there were rises, not at one of the flies, but often at +all three--no skill was required. The fish were rampant, and would be +hooked. In fact, the main part of the fun lay in seeing how often one +could land two fish hooked simultaneously. We only made three drifts in +all, for it is easy to be surfeited with such sport. After our third +drift was finished and the boat was hauled up again into its place we +had leisure to count the slain; they were certainly very numerous. I +somewhat reluctantly transcribe the entry in my fishing diary lest the +tale may be set down as a "fisherman's story." They amounted in all to +ninety-two, and weighed between 40 and 50 lb. It certainly was a record +day for even that prolific loch. There is yet one more entry in the +same fishing log to the effect that the 15 odd pounds weight of trout +that I personally carried home that afternoon formed a considerable +addition to the labour of the walk over the hills and against the gale, +and that I frequently wished them at Jericho. + +But you might go to Loch Broom on a still day and you would be almost +inclined to declare that it was untenanted, so fickle in their +behaviour are these selfsame trout. + +There is a little loch--Loch Dhu--in Forfarshire, high up in the hollow +of the hills, tenanted by many little black trout, who refuse to be +beguiled by the artificial fly. I tried it once or twice whilst grouse +shooting at Rottal, but with the poorest results. One day, very early +in the morning, I was going up the hill with my rifle and glass in the +hope of getting a stalk at a red deer before our grouse drive began. +On my way up I passed within half to three-quarters of a mile of Loch +Dhu, and happened to notice a strange turmoil on its usually unruffled +surface. Bringing my glass to bear upon it, I discovered the cause. A +swarm of bees was crossing the loch, a few inches above the surface, +and apparently every one of the little black tenants of the water was +engaged in gymnastic attempts to secure some of the bees by leaping +bodily out of the water. The constant rising of the fish followed the +swarm accurately across the loch, and only ceased when it reached terra +firma. Then all again was silence and solitude. I certainly never tried +afterwards to catch them with a solitary bee as a lure, and I fear +that it would have required a whole swarm of artificial bees to arouse +sufficiently the predatory instincts of these particular fish. + +There exists in Perthshire, on Ben Venue side, snugly ensconced in a +beautiful hollow below the lower tops, a lochan, or small loch, by +name Loch Tinkler--why so called this deponent knoweth not. Round +its heather-covered sides I have shot many a grouse, and enjoyed the +great pleasure of watching favourite setters and pointers--those +delightful companions of the now somewhat old-fashioned form of grouse +shooting--point and back, with unfailing accuracy. Hither I have not +infrequently resorted with my rod for an hour or so of fishing along +its shores. The loch is very irregular in shape, and has frequent +heather-clad promontories jutting out into its waters, which permit +the angler to cover the fish more effectually, and seldom have I gone +unrewarded. Of no great size or weight, a half-pounder being perhaps +above the average, the Loch Leven trout that tenant it attain wonderful +condition and brilliancy of colouring. They play well, and I should be +more than ungrateful were I not to record the pleasant hours I have +spent there. But, after all, a small loch such as this is, commanded as +it is for all practical purposes from the shore, hardly falls under the +category of loch fishing, a branch of angling which presupposes the use +of a boat. + +Owing, no doubt, to my peculiar temperament, I fear that I am not +worthy of loch fishing proper. The thraldom of being confined for long +periods in a boat, the unvarying monotony of the cast, are apt to pall +upon me; and sooner or later, or, to be strictly accurate, sooner +rather than later, I long to be ashore again, even though it be only to +fish up a small Highland burn. + +And perhaps I am not quite alone in this respect, for I note that my +friend who has given us those pleasant "Autumns in Argyleshire" asserts +(p. 182) that he would prefer "indifferent sport in a river or burn to +fishing the finest loch in the Highlands." So that if I err I do so in +the very best of company. + +And this same burn fishing has always had a charm for me. It is passing +pleasant to wander with a small 9 ft. rod up the rocky bed, casting +your fly into that miniature salmon pool or into that quaint stickle, +whose larger stones shelter the little denizens of the stream, which, +for their size, fight like little demons, sportive, hungry, diminutive +specimens of the race that produces their bulky Test and Itchen +brethren. One makes one's way over the rocky bed, under the birches +and the rowan trees, watching the grouse, the black game, or maybe the +roe deer silently creeping up, at peace with all the world, just as +intent upon the capture of the little fellows as if they were salmon. +The creel soon fills if the day be at all suitable. Their rocky home +affords little enough of insect food, as their miniature forms testify; +but look at them closely; how perfect their form, how beautiful their +colouring. + +A sandwich and a pipe give you all you require in the way of lunch; the +whole day is your own, to do as you like with. Freed from all care, you +are intent only on enjoying to the full the beauties of Nature that +so lavishly surround you. Such quiet, gentle sport cannot but have +a purifying and ennobling influence if you interpret aright all the +beauty of creation. And it may be that interpretation is not needed; it +is enough to _feel_ that one has a place in so fair a world. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER XI. + +DAPPING FOR TROUT. + + +THIS form of angling has been brought to a fine art in Ireland, and +on many Irish loughs, in the May fly season, the heaviest trout are +brought to book by means of the natural insect and the blow line. The +columns of the _Field_ newspaper testify every year to the efficacy of +dapping, and, without doubt, many a heavy fish that otherwise would +only live to prey upon its smaller brethren is thus accounted for. + +We do not all of us have leisure or opportunity to test these Irish +waters, or this particular form of sport with the blow line; but many +of us come across deep, heavy runs of water, overhung with continuous +branches, where the heavy trout lie, unapproachable and unvanquished, +to become gross and even pike-like in the carnivorous and cannibalistic +form of life. + +Such fish are well worth catching, if you can get them, and far better +out of the stream than in it. Wise in their own generation, they take +up their holt in places where casting is impossible with an ordinary +fly, and where, could you by any possibility get one out, your fly +would remain almost immovable in the sluggish deeps and overhung holes. +The problem is then presented to you as to how their capture can best +be effected. This is your opportunity for trying dapping; and although, +to my unorthodox mind, such fishing is parlously near akin to poaching, +yet the accomplishment of their capture is so eminently desirable that +the end fully justifies the means. + +'Twas in the lower reaches of such a stream, not many miles from +Bassenthwaite Water, that a certain number of leviathan cannibals had +taken up their station. The stream was so tortuous and overhung that no +boat could be manoeuvred through it, and a carefully constructed raft, +with anchor astern, had been tried and come to signal grief, pitching +its unfortunate occupant unceremoniously into an unsolicited cold bath, +from which he emerged with some difficulty. We then decided that it was +impracticable for fishing purposes of the ordinary kind. + +Walking home along this bush-covered length we could see the fish +clearly in its waters, calculate their weight, and wonder how their +natural fortifications could be sapped and overcome. We nicknamed all +the fish, so constant and regular were they in their places. One, an +ugly, ill-shapen fish, with a heavy head, was called "Bradlaugh"; +another veteran, solemn and heavy, was dubbed "Gladstone"; a third, +more dashing and combative, we christened "Randolph Churchill." There +were about seven that we knew and named, and to the heaviest and +thickest of all we gave the name of "Lord Salisbury." + +It was a constant source of interest to us, in going up and down the +stream, to note what our named friends were doing and how they were +faring. Notes were compared when we came in after fishing, and they +gradually became an integral portion of our life and party. One evening +I noticed "Randolph Churchill" greatly on the move, darting hither and +thither in quest of some article of food. Peering through the bushes, I +made out that he was taking something that was falling from the trees +and bushes above, but what that something was I could not precisely +make out. A poor bumble bee that had fallen into the stream was buzzing +about, trying to free himself from his watery toils, and floating +slowly over "Churchill"; the latter came up to look at the buzzer, and +then bolted as if he had been shot. Evidently that disturbed even his +equanimity. I had contemplated dapping with a palmer or Marlow buzz; +and I sat down to cogitate. I called to mind the incident, referred to +on page 50, of the bold rises of the trout in Loch Dhu at the swarm +of bees crossing its surface. Whilst trying to reconcile their action +with that of "Churchill" I was reclining on the grass, and happened to +espy a green grasshopper. That might do, thought I, and rising, with +the captured insect in my fingers, I again approached the water side. +The bumble bee had most effectually scared "Randolph," so I walked down +to where "Gladstone" had taken up his abode. Nipping the grasshopper +with my fingers so as to kill it, I managed to flick it over the bushes +towards my friend. It happened to light on the water at the proper +place, and I had the pleasure of watching "Gladstone" sail slowly and +majestically up to the floating insect, open a huge pink mouth, and +swallow it. That was quite good enough for me, and after dinner I +retailed to my friend my evening's experiences. + +We were soon busily engaged in hunting up bare hooks and stiff rods. +Fortunately for us there were some long cane-bottom fishing rods in the +lodge, which evidently had been used in former times for bait fishing; +the joints were indifferent, the whippings rotten, but the rods were, +in the main, sound. + +A little waxed thread and varnish soon put them into workable trim, and +before going to bed we pledged a parting glass that some of our friends +should gain a new experience on the morrow. And so it fell out. We knew +that playing fish in such overgrown haunts was out of the question, +and that if we had the luck to hook them it would be a question of +pull devil, pull baker. Towards evening we met at our trysting-place. +Green grasshoppers were numerous, so there was no lack of bait. As I +anticipated, "Randolph Churchill's" inquisitiveness and audacity caused +him to become our first victim. The bushes were far too thick to let +us drop our bait near him in the ordinary manner. Our only chance was +to roll the line round our rods, poke it through the bushes, unroll it +carefully, dangle it before his nose, and then, if we had the luck to +hook him, to give him no law, but to trust to our tackle and to hold on +like grim death. + +The next victim that evening was "Bradlaugh," a bold riser, who fought +well, and who thoroughly justified his cognomen when on the bank. +"Disraeli" was for some time our master; he knew a trick or two, and +was by no means easily beguiled, though often pricked and once lightly +hooked. Even his caution was at length overcome, and hardly an evening +passed but that one or more of these, relatively speaking, monsters of +some 2½ to 5 lb. in weight was landed. + +"Lord Salisbury," however, proved to be a very difficult nut to crack, +and beyond our powers of persuasion. He would solemnly inspect our +lure, sniff round it, as it were, and then sink slowly down to his +accustomed place. He seemed to know all about it, so, intent on other +sport with the gun, we at last let him severely alone, telling the +river keeper to get him out if he could. + +One evening, as we were at dinner, there came a pressing message from +the keeper to be allowed to see us; so, on ordering him in, a smiling +rubicund visage appeared at the door, that of our friend the keeper, +bearing in his hands a dish, on which reposed the vast proportions +of "Lord Sallusberry," as he termed him, a tardy victim to the wiles +of patience, combined with the reiterated attractions of a green +grasshopper. + +Possibly this kind of dapping may be deemed to be a poor kind of sport, +and, speaking from a strictly orthodox point of view, the accusation +cannot be denied. But, after all, it has its merits. It enables you, +in waters where there are no May flies, to seduce the heavy fish into +unwonted activity, and into taking surface flies. Thus you remove what +are little short of pests in a trout stream, and you gain an interest +in overcoming the difficulties of an otherwise impossible situation. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER XII. + +GRAYLING FISHING. + + +GRAYLING have one advantage over trout in that they extend your fishing +season by at least three months. Whereas trout may be called spring +and summer fish, grayling are autumn and winter fish. While trout +love positions under overhanging banks, or in the side runs by the +bank side, grayling, on the other hand, generally occupy positions in +mid-stream, lying near, or on, the bottom. In rivers that contain both +fish, a bank rise may be generally put down to a trout. I would have +substituted the word "confidently" for "generally," had not a very +competent critic placed a marginal note to my MS., stating that "he +would it were so." + +I can well recall a day on lower Testwater when, in October, on a +wild, squally day, with gusty rain, I was endeavouring to beguile some +imprudent grayling into taking my fly. The river keeper accompanied +me, and together we descried a nice dimpling rise against the far +bank, above a plank bridge. I at once put it down as a trout, and was +for leaving it alone; but my keeper friend would not have it so, and +on persuasion I proffered the fish the fly that happened to be on my +line. As luck would have it the fly pitched fairly accurately, and, +nicely cocked, sailed down the bank side just where the rise had been. +A confident rise produced an equally confident turn of the wrist; our +friend was well hooked, and a merry five minutes we had before he +could be beguiled into the landing net. He proved to be a fine trout, +over 3 lb. in weight and in magnificent condition, but the month was +against us, and we had to replace him with all due care in his native +element before resuming our search for the grayling, who were not at +all inclined to favour us, on that occasion at any rate. + +This particular fish certainly endorsed my view, for I felt confident +in my first opinion, viz., that it was the rise of a trout, and not +that of a grayling. The keeper, however, was equally confident until he +was proved wrong, and, as his experiences were a hundredfold greater +than mine, I would certainly not attempt to advance my own as against +his. It is so terribly easy to generalise from inadequate experience. + +One thing I certainly have learned with regard to grayling fishing +with a hackle fly, fished wet and up stream, and that is, how easily +one may miss them through want of rapidity in the strike. I remember a +friend of mine dancing with laughter on the river bank as he watched me +miss rise after rise under such circumstances. I seemed to be always a +little after the fair. It was blind kind of work, casting at the rises, +the fish having to come up from the bottom to the fly, and somehow +or other they seemed always to take the wrong psychological moment +for their rise as far as I was concerned. Occasionally, of course, I +hooked what I fancied to be a silly idiot of a fish, and it was not +until my friend had a turn at them and then declared they were rising +disgracefully short that I was able to turn the laugh against him. When +I was angling it was always the fault of the angler that the fish were +not hooked; when his turn came it was entirely the fault of the fish. +At the same time it is undeniable that to secure grayling, especially +heavy ones, by this manner of angling requires great alertness, and, as +it were, sympathy of touch in hooking them. + +I cannot pretend to any considerable experiences in grayling fishing, +but I do not agree with Mr. G. A. B. Dewar, who, in his "Book of +the Dry Fly," p. 54 (Lawrence & Bullen, 1897), states confidently +that angling for the grayling with the dry fly is "poor fun." On the +contrary, I have found him a bold riser, and a really free fighter +in his own style. He will take a dry fly in hot, bright weather, +though his real value comes in on frosty days, after the trout have +earned their well-deserved rest from the plague of artificial flies. A +grayling, moreover, is in his element in deep pools and quiet hollows, +where one would hardly expect to see the dimple of a rising trout. At +the same time the fish loves rapid streams and shallows, retiring for +rest to the deeper pools. + +To be absolutely candid, I would always prefer to fish for trout +rather than to fish for grayling. This may possibly be through lack +of experience and opportunity; but no one can gainsay the fact that +grayling are in condition when trout are not, that they are a worthy +quarry and gamesome, despite (Brother) Cotton's condemnation of them as +"dead-hearted" fish. To be able to defer putting away one's favourite +rods until October, November, and even December have passed away is +no mean advantage, and I, for one, would be indeed sorry to decry the +grayling in any way whatever. + +Grayling do not, as a rule, rise as freely as trout will do during +heavy rain, nor does muggy weather suit them; the best time for +grayling fishing in late autumn or early winter is from about twelve +to two, on a bright day, after a sharp and crisp frost. As they lie so +low in the water and have to come to the surface to take a fly, they +frequently miss their object, whether real or artificial; and after +they have taken the fly, or missed it, as the case may be, they dive +downwards to the bottom again, often breaking the water with their +forked tails in so doing. They are, therefore, more easy of approach +than trout, as there is a larger intervening amount of water to screen +you. As they take surface food, and yet lie so deep, their quaint +lozenge-shaped eyes have an upward turn. They are peculiarly gut shy, +and any undue coarseness in this respect or glistening glare in your +cast will effectually choke them off from their intended rise. They may +be taken by almost any of the ordinary surface flies, by a red tag, or +by means of many of the pale watery hackle flies fished wet. The depth +of the water in which they love to lie renders them less susceptible to +continued flogging than trout. Remember, if you hook a good grayling, +that the corners of his mouth are very tender compared with those of a +trout, and that, salmon-like, he takes a header downwards after taking +your fly, thus tending to hook himself; therefore the quickest and +gentlest of wrist turns is sufficient to cement the attachment between +you. And although grayling fishermen will not admit that the mouth of a +grayling is more tender, generally speaking, than that of a trout, it +is extraordinary how often the fly happens to attach itself to those +particularly tender spots. In playing him, this fact should not be +forgotten, nor the fact that the appearance of the landing net seems to +produce in him the wildest and most frantic efforts for freedom. + +Grayling receive universal condemnation for poaching trout and salmon +ova, and it is only right to own that they are grave delinquents in +this respect. The unfortunate ova have, however, a multitude of enemies +in the shape of various water birds, ducks, swans, &c., and the toll +taken by the grayling in proportion cannot be so very heavy after +all, or they would not be permitted to continue to populate our south +country streams, where the trout is the chief object of worship. At any +rate, they have no other cannibal proclivities, which is more than can +be said for the noble trout himself, who is a marked sinner in both +respects. + +Grayling will not thrive in all streams; they love alternate shallows +and deeps, and are particularly partial to quiet backwaters. They +are very migratory, and will frequently shift their quarters. The +character of the river appears to be all-important in their case, and +many streams suitable for trout will not hold grayling. But where the +surrounding circumstances are suitable, and the temperature of the +water is neither too cold nor too hot, it seems a pity that they should +not be given a trial. They spawn in April, and recover their condition +more rapidly than trout. I do not know whether the origin of these +fish in British waters has ever been ascertained. They may have been +brought to these islands by the monks in former time, who so carefully +husbanded all resources in the shape of fish food; but I have never +seen or read any authentic statement to this effect, and would prefer +to consider them as indigenous. + +[Illustration] + +[Illustration: LUNCHEON.] + + + + +CHAPTER XIII. + +NOTES ON RAINBOW TROUT. + + +RAINBOWS are a comparatively recent importation into our native +waters, and appeared just at the time when they were most needed. It +is but a few years since our British waters, neglected, except in a +few instances, began to receive the attention they deserved, in view +of their intrinsic value. Steps were then taken to diminish, if not +entirely to remove, the terribly universal pollution of our streams +and rivers. From that time trout fishing prospects in river and stream +began to look up and improve; but our ponds and reservoirs, if stocked +with fish at all, contained only the coarse fish of former times. By +a happy coincidence the rainbow trout, which we owe to our cousins of +the United States, began to be talked about and known. Speedily our +fish-culturists took them up and established them in their hatcheries, +with the best results. A more sporting or gamer fish does not exist. He +rises most freely to the fly--up to a certain weight--and, when hooked, +plays as gamely as any sea trout. He grows with astonishing rapidity. +In our local waters, two-year-old fish, 8 in. long in February, have +grown to ¾ lb. fish and even to pounders in September. There is +therefore no excuse for leaving our ponds untenanted by these gamesome +fish. Moreover, their edible qualities are quite first-rate; they are +shapely, beautiful in colouring, and thrive in any kind of water. One +point, however, should be carefully guarded against. Rainbows are great +travellers; they will push up, especially before spawning, and it is +therefore necessary to confine them by a grid at the head and foot of +your water. + +The spawning time for these fish in their natural habitat is rather +late in the spring; but, as might be expected from analogy, rainbows +bred and reared in this country appear to be adapting themselves to +their environment, and to be gradually assimilating their time for +spawning to that of our local trout. The bulk of rainbows spawn in +British waters about February and March, many retain their old times +of May and June, whilst a proportion have adapted themselves to their +surroundings and spawn as early as brook trout. I think that the date +is more or less influenced by the amount of fish food obtainable. Thus, +for instance, with hand-fed fish the old later dates are maintained; +but it is still doubtful, as far as my experience goes, as to whether +the ova of the fish that are dependent entirely upon natural food +is ever vivified. My fish undoubtedly have spawned on the prepared +beds, but, so far, I have not been able to establish any evidence +of matured fry. The edges of the water this summer were filled with +multitudinous small fry no doubt, but on careful inspection they proved +to be entirely the fry of sticklebacks, perch, &c. I have found hen +fish gravid with ova as early as November and as late as April. In +time, no doubt, their spawning season will coincide with that of our +brown trout. And herein lies a field for investigation and careful +watching. It is held in many quarters that rainbows do not breed in +Great Britain. My experience hardly tallies with this belief. On our +waters in Lancashire, where we had no gravel beds suitable for the +deposit of ova, I found late last year several hen fish, of from 1½ lb. +to 2 lb. in weight, dead in the water; they were full of ripe ova, and +had undoubtedly died through being egg-bound. I then made some spawning +redds suitable for the deposit and fertilisation of the ova, and it +has been highly interesting to see the fish elbowing each other to +secure a spot for themselves. Since then I have caught many spent fish, +both cock and hen, showing that the ova, at any rate, have been duly +deposited; but so far I have not been able to identify the fry. A large +quantity of fry of sorts I have secured this season, but they proved to +be the fry of stickleback. The "Trinity" two-year-old fish I restocked +with seem to be growing admirably. This form of rainbow trout have +the reputation of being, if possible, freer risers, quicker growers, +and harder fighters than the ordinary kind; so far they seem to act up +to their reputation. The few I have caught fought like little demons, +and it was almost difficult to be able to restore them to the water +and free the hook before they had been practically exhausted by their +frantic efforts for freedom. + +The proper amount of fish with which to stock a given area of water +depends several circumstances. First and foremost, of course, it +depends upon the amount of fish food in it. Many pools and ponds are +full of fresh-water shrimps, snails, and the like, all of which are +of very great value in developing and fattening your fish. But as you +do not want to depend upon bottom feeding for their whole stock of +food, admirable adjunct though it may be, it is well to place round +the margins of your waters all plants that encourage the increase +of fly food. Beds of the ordinary watercress are not only valuable +in this respect, but afford welcome shelter. Water lilies, if kept +within bounds, are equally valuable, and it must never be forgotten +that, especially in shallow water, shelter from the summer sun is an +absolute necessity if you wish your stock to improve. Other aquatic +and semi-aquatic plants should also be utilised freely, such as marsh +marigolds, starworts, bulrushes, &c. Nor should it be forgotten +to plant alders and fringing willows here and there. All trout, +particularly rainbows, take an alder fly readily. + +A certain area of water will not support more than a certain weight +of fish life. You can therefore either have that weight made up by a +large quantity of small fish or by a correspondingly smaller number of +larger fish. It is not prudent, therefore, to overstock. This question +has necessarily very considerable bearing upon your calculations. Nor +is it possible to fix arbitrarily any precise number of fish as being +capable of being supported by a given area of water; an examination of +the water itself would be needed to determine this with any degree of +accuracy. + +Having, however, once determined upon the proper stock required--and, +in my opinion, it pays better to stock with two-year-old fish than +with yearlings--then an accurate account should be kept of the fish +taken out of the water each season, and a corresponding number should +be turned in each November for restocking, a few being added for +contingencies. + +As I have already stated, when rainbows grow into really big fish--say +over 2½ lb.--they appear, in our British waters, to develop lazy, +bottom-feeding proclivities. It will be necessary, therefore, or at +any rate advisable, to take these fish out by using a bright salmon +fly, fished deep, or a minnow, fished as deep as the water will admit. +When the fish are first placed in their fresh home it is customary +to feed them with artificial food until they get accustomed to their +surroundings. For this purpose liver is often used, and it is quite an +amusing sight to see them "boil" when such food is distributed. It is +very doubtful whether it is wise to feed with such fat-producing foods. +Some authorities hold that fatty foods of any kind produce disease of +the liver and fatty degeneration, and condemn absolutely all red meat. +If this be so--and it appears to be not only probable, but proved by +expert experience--it is better to let the fish take care of themselves +and eschew all kinds of artificial food stuffs. + +When stocking, every care should be taken to see that when the fish +arrive they are placed as soon as possible where the water is most +lively and broken, so that they may, at the earliest practicable +moment, obtain the air they so much need after their journey. The water +in the cans should never be allowed to stagnate. One more precaution +is indispensable, viz., to see, by means of a thermometer, that the +temperature of the water in the stream or pond is the same as that in +the cans. If there should be any difference--and there will almost +certainly be--it can easily be adjusted by letting some water out of +the cans and substituting that of the stream. By doing this gradually +the fish will become acclimatised to the change. The cans on the cart, +meanwhile, should be agitated, and therefore aerated, by keeping the +cart on the move. Neglect of this will cause serious risk of loss. +Once safely deposited in their new home, the fish will speedily spread +over your whole water, even if all were put in at one spot. Perhaps +it is unnecessary to add that fish should never be handled when being +put into the water. A small flat net will pick up any that may have +fallen on the ground during the change of water. It is surprising +how thoughtless many people are about handling and treating fish. +Thus, for instance, if an undersized fish is caught it is, in common +parlance, "thrown back," and is often in reality so treated. Too much +care cannot be taken in replacing fish. If put back gently and held for +a few seconds in a proper position, back up, they will soon recover +from their exhaustion and glide away unharmed; whereas, if "thrown +in," or dropped in in a careless manner, they will turn belly up, and +probably never recover. + +When all precautions are taken, and your waters have been intelligently +treated, and suitable spawning redds are provided, you will never +regret having stocked with rainbows, for the sport you will obtain from +them will more than amply repay you for the trouble you may have taken. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER XIV. + +SALMON FISHING. + + +FORMERLY, and indeed not so very long ago, no one in the Highlands of +Scotland was considered free of the hill, or indeed of any account, +unless and until he had slain a stag, a salmon, and an eagle. Nowadays, +matters are somewhat different. The two former, inhabiting as they do +the forests and rivers, are in great request, and have a considerable +money value, and, in consequence, have passed into the hands of those +who have the deepest purses, saving and except where some few Highland +lairds and noblemen retain their ancient rights in their own hands, and +dispense their hospitality amongst their friends as of yore. As for +the golden eagle, few would attempt, or even wish, to shoot so noble a +bird. The ordinary forest fine of £500 is a sufficient deterrent, if, +indeed, any is necessary. Every effort is now being made, and should be +made, to keep the (now, alas! scarce) king of the birds amongst us. + +But if, as we have said, the large majority of the forests and +salmon rivers are rented by those who are able and willing to pay +almost any price for the dignity of being lessees of such tempting +and highly-prized sporting grounds, the general appetite and desire +have developed and grown enormously. Ever-increasing facilities for +travelling have brought with them an ever-growing army of men, all +eager to get good salmon fishing, and searching high and low to secure +it. Norway, Sweden, Iceland, Canada, British Columbia, and a host of +other portions of the globe have been brought into requisition in +order to satisfy some portion of this craving. Small wonder, then, that +rents for rivers, spring or autumn, continue to increase, and that +the Government of the day is being constantly and consistently urged +to increase the close time for net fishing, in order that the upper +riparian owners may have some chance of replenishing their pools. + +A man who has once hooked and played a clean-run salmon, and has +experienced the thrill of excitement that continues from the rise until +the salmon is safely landed, is not at all likely to forget it, or to +miss any chance of renewing his acquaintance with _Salmo salar_. + +The contest is such a fair one, there are so many chances in favour +of the fish, that no element of sport is wanting. He is so strong +in the water, so perfectly built for speed, that unless you handle +him both carefully and skilfully you may easily lose him, even if +you have brought him exhausted to the gaff. In that perilous moment, +when flopping and surging near the top of the water, how many a fish +effects his escape! And who is there amongst us but has experienced the +sickening feeling of the straightened rod, and the fly released from +the worn hold in the fish's mouth? It is just the uncertainty of the +sport, added to the strength and vigour of a hooked fish, that form the +great allurement to salmon anglers. + +Whilst in trout fishing--more especially with the dry fly--great +accuracy and delicacy of cast are required, the actual fishing for +salmon with the fly makes no such demands upon the angler. Provided +that he can throw a tolerably straight line of reasonable length, +so as to cover the places in the pools where the salmon are wont to +rise, many faults that would entail failure with the dry fly will pass +unnoticed, owing to the fly having been cast into swiftly running +water, which brawling water straightens out in the kindest manner the +kinks formed in the line by the incompetency of the wielder of the rod. + +To this extent, therefore, a novice may have the good fortune to beat +the more experienced hand. Once hooked, however, the novice is out +of it, unless he has at hand an experienced mentor, and the odds are +largely in favour of the fish. It is then that the accomplished angler +asserts himself. I have heard of men who consider that the excitement +of salmon fishing begins and ends with the hooking of the fish, who +are willing to hand over to their attendant, or gillie, the duty which +they consider to be monotonous and fatiguing--of playing the fish. + +For my part, I look at the matter from an entirely different point of +view. The combat between the fisherman and the fish is essentially a +gallant one. In the water, a clean-run fish of, say, 18 lb. really +plays the angler for some space of time, and you recognise that +although your experience and intelligence may enable you, within a +reasonable time, to be the victor, yet that you have attached to you a +quarry well worthy of your skill, and one, moreover, who may yet call +forth all your activity and resource, and who cannot be accounted as +caught until he is absolutely on the grass beside you. + +I, on the contrary, always consider that playing a salmon is the most +exciting and interesting part of the sport. In playing a fish, whether +it be a heavy trout on a light, single-handed rod, or a clean-run +active salmon on a proportionately suitable rod, a sense of touch is +needed that bears some resemblance to that necessary for the proper +handling of the reins in riding a keen young thoroughbred horse. You +require a keen appreciation of when to allow a certain latitude and +when to exercise all the pressure that the occasion demands. + +A heavy-handed man will soon render a sensitive-mouthed young horse +half demented, whilst at the same time quiet, strong hands exert just +that influence that is needed to control his vagaries. Some men are +born with the requisite sensitiveness of touch, others will be clumsy +and heavy-handed to the end of their days. Some will give undue licence +to a fish, will allow him to play for an inordinate length of time, +triplicating thereby the risk of losing him. + +It is not possible to lay down on paper any regulations for playing +fish beyond what may be termed the "A B C" of the game. You should +never allow your rod point to be dragged down below an angle of 45° +with the vertical, or a smash of your casting line will be risked. On +the other hand, if the rod be kept too vertical an unfair tax is placed +upon the strength of your middle joint. Another cardinal point, as +every angler knows, is that you should never allow more line off your +reel than you can avoid; that is to say, if your fish means running +either up or down stream, and you feel instinctively that it would be +neither prudent nor practicable to hold him too hard, then you must try +to keep on terms with him by means of your own movements on the bank +side; for it is to be presumed that, although you may have hooked your +fish when wading in mid-stream, you have taken the earliest opportunity +of wading ashore. + +Keep nearly level with him, or down stream of him if you can, and get +the weight of the water acting against him as well as the weight of +the line. Never try to force a fish up a heavy stream unless such a +course is absolutely necessary, for the weight of the water, added +to that of the fish, may unduly strain your tackle. That you may be +compelled to try to prevent his going down stream at times goes without +saying, for it may be absolutely necessary to do so; but to endeavour +to force a fresh and strong fish up stream against his will is to court +disaster. Should you have decided that your fish, if it is to be killed +at all, must be kept in the pool in which he then is at all hazards, +by judiciously giving him his head, by means of taking off the strain, +may frequently induce him to abandon his attempt to force his way +down stream, and, under the impression that he has already gained his +freedom, he may often, of his own free will, head up stream once again. +It is a risky, but often the only, course to adopt, if you cannot or +will not follow a fish down. + +Mr. Sidney Buxton, in that most charming of books, "Fishing and +Shooting" (John Murray, 1902), sums up the whole matter admirably when +he describes catching and playing salmon as "living moments." + +I have seen stalwart soldiers, and I have one V.C. particularly +before my eyes at the moment of writing, covered with perspiration +and quivering in every limb after a long and successful duel with +a clean-run fish. In this respect salmon fishing is ahead of trout +fishing, for the contest is a more even one; though in my opinion the +two, being distinct and incomparable, ought never to be put into the +scales and weighed the one against the other. + +Watch an old hand at the game, and observe how easily he controls the +most determined and vigorous rushes of his worthy antagonist; take out +your watch and see how long it will be before the 18 or 20 pounder is +brought alongside for the gaff; and then watch the poor performer, +hesitating and uncertain as to when pressure should be applied or +licence given; see how long it takes him to land the 8 lb. or 10 lb. +fish; count the number of times that he has to thank a beneficent +providence that he has not lost him; and if, after so doing, you still +incline to your statement that there is nothing in landing a fish, that +the whole pleasurable excitement is concentrated in hooking him, then +I can only reply that I don't agree. The contest between the hooked +salmon and the fisherman is no uneven one--witness the number of hooked +fish that escape--and it is one that is still capable of giving a +thrill of real excitement to those who really love angling. + +A salmon hooked from a boat in a large loch is, of course, a different +matter; here the odds are so largely in favour of the rod holder as to +unduly diminish the chances of escape to the fish. Such salmon fishing +is outside the scope of our present argument, and falls into a totally +different category. With river-bank fishing, and it is with that that +we are dealing, it would be a bold fisherman indeed that would count a +fish hooked as a fish landed, and a half-hearted angler that would be +content to hand over to the gillie the cream of the contest between the +fish and the man. + +_Apropos_ of this nervous excitement, in October, 1900, I formed one +of a shooting party on Don side. The river Don ran within half a mile +from the house, forming as perfect a series of natural pools as the +heart of man could desire. My mouth watered when I saw it, and I longed +to wet a line in it. I found, however, that my host not only loathed +fishing, but was absolutely devoted to bridge. We had but short days +out shooting, everyone rushing back to the lodge to get a rubber or +two before dinner. Professing ignorance of bridge, I begged my host +to let me try the river, as, having been lately fishing on the Dee, I +had my rods and waders with me. With a pitying smile he told me that I +could, of course, amuse myself as I thought best. With no loss of time +I made my way down to the river side, and found it in grand ply. I was +fully aware that the particular part of the Don that we were on was not +popularly supposed to contain many fish at that time of the year, but +it was well worth a trial, and I knew that a ship laden with lime had +lately been sunk at the mouth of the Dee, and I fancied and hoped that +some of the autumn fish might be finding their way into and up the Don. +The pools were so perfect in shape that no gillie was needed to point +me out the best rising-places; they spoke for themselves and told their +own tale. + +My first evening produced two clean-run fish of 16½ lb. and 8 lb., and +my host, when he saw them later, began to think that, after all, there +might be something in angling. The second evening the river was up and +unfishable, but by the third evening it had fined down into order, +and I got a beauty of 20 lb. and a small salmon of 7½ lb. The glowing +accounts I gave of the play of these fish at length excited my host, +and, even at the cost of his rubber of bridge, the next evening saw +him by my side, carefully fishing a leg of mutton pool near the house, +where I had seen and risen a fish the night before. I had to hold the +rod with him and show him how to cast, but I knew pretty well where +my fish lay, and that he was within easy reach. We worked down to the +spot, and, sure enough, up he came with a grand head and tail rise, +hooking himself handsomely. Leaving the rod in my friend's hands, I +told him that he had to do the rest. The first rush nearly pulled the +rod down to the water level, my friend hanging on like grim death. +Fortunately, the gut was sound and stood the strain. Nearly dying with +laughter at his frantic appeals for help and advice, I shouted to him +to keep his rod point up, thoroughly enjoying the fact that he was +having a taste of what he had characterised as a "poor and tame kind of +sport." + +As I particularly wanted him to catch that fish I went to his +assistance. Trembling with excitement and bathed in perspiration, he +was, shortly afterwards, delightedly examining his first salmon, a +clean-run hen fish of 16 lb. I never shall forget his shake of the hand +and his exclamation, "By Jupiter! you have taught me something, this +is worth living for!" Needless to say, he is now mad keen on salmon +angling, and a very capable performer to boot. + +Many of us, however, not quite so young as we were, are paying the +penalty of imprudent wading in the times when we scorned to put on +wading trousers. The rheumatic twinges, that hesitation about deep +wading in rivers with bad bottoms, all these are largely bred of our +former contempt for getting wet, and our ill-founded confidence in our +powers of resisting the effects of such very minor matters as wet legs +and feet. We therefore find our choice of fishing water still more +limited: we seek fishings where many of the pools can be commanded from +the bank side, or where, if wading be unavoidable, the bottom is sound +and shelving, and where there are no round slippery stones to trip us +up. Enough for most of us, if we are lucky enough to get into touch +with a good fish, is it that we may have a longish travel over very +rough ground, up and down, before we can call him ours. + +[Illustration: NEARING THE END.] + +One particularly bad-bottomed pool I remember very well in the +Aberdeenshire Dee, not very far below Aboyne. It was a long pool, the +head of water very heavy, the wading throughout simply vile. At the +bottom of the pool was a big rock, nearly in mid-stream, and by that +stone there generally lay a good fish. To reach him you had to wade +as deep as your waders would permit, your elbows almost in the water, +leaning your body against the swirl of the stream, and taking cautious +steps forward, inch by inch, to avoid being tripped up by the slippery +big round stones. Then the best cast you were able to produce with your +18 ft. Castleconnel would just about reach him. I never could resist +trying for him, though I knew he would go down stream if hooked, and it +seemed impossible to follow him down, so I always half wished that he +might not come. Wading back against that heavy stream, with a twenty or +thirty pounder making tracks round the corner into the next pool, would +have been no easy job; and, if you had succeeded in reaching terra +firma, there were some big overhanging trees at the corner, beneath +which the current had cut a deep hole. Mercifully for me, though I +often tried for him, he never did take hold, though I rose him several +times. It was always with a chastened spirit of thankfulness that I +gave him up and went further down to try the easier waters of the Boat +pool. + +There is a local story of a mighty fish, hooked in that self-same spot, +which took its captor down so that he was obliged, perforce, to swim +the deep water under the trees, and was afterwards taken down, as hard +as he could run, through pool after pool, until at length he managed +to steady it in the third pool of the next fishing water. Then, after +a period of sulks, during which both regained their wind, the fish ran +right away up again to his old haunts, where he succeeded in getting +rid of the hook against his favourite rock. All lost fish are big, +and the lapse of time has not in any way diminished his fabled weight. + +Perhaps the one drawback to salmon fishing as an art is that to which +I have already alluded, viz., that the friendly stream corrects of +itself all, or nearly all, errors of slovenly casting, and in that +respect places the duffer more on a par with the really competent. On +the other hand, knowledge and experience, and perhaps more particularly +local experience, will assert itself in the long run, even against the +adventitious success of the novice. + +The mere fact of having really fished a pool, whether success reward +your efforts or no, is of itself an element of enjoyment; the feeling +that you have fished, and fished with a really working fly every inch +of fishable water, is _per se_ a cause of satisfaction and pleasure. +Here you are master of the situation; on you depends your chance of +sport, if any is to be obtained. + +In grouse driving you may draw the worst butt; or, if you have the luck +to draw the best, the birds may unaccountably take an unusual line, +and, though you may have drawn the "King's butt," nearly every bird may +pass over the heads of your comrades to the right and left of you. You +are, as it were, a mere automaton, to shoot whatever may come within +range; you may be the victim of circumstances, and may get very few +chances. + +In hunting, unless you hunt the hounds yourself, you have little chance +of seeing, and none whatever of controlling, the best part of the game, +the working of the hounds. Your main object is to be with them; they +and the huntsman, or master, do the work, you are merely an accessory. + +In fishing, whether it be for trout or salmon, everything from start to +finish rests with yourself; you have to work out your own salvation; +and I venture to assert that it is in consequence of this individual +responsibility that fishing, apart from its other many merits, holds so +high a place in all our affections. + +I doubt whether there are many men who have not become aware, in +playing salmon (and perhaps more often when the fish is nearly played +out), of a second fish following the hooked one in all its movements +and stratagems to free itself from the unwelcome attachment of the rod +and line. It has several times happened to me personally, and on two +occasions that I can call to mind I was within an ace of being able to +gaff the free fish when bringing the exhausted and hooked fish past +me for the gaffing process. I feel confident that, had I not been too +much engaged in seeing that my hooked fish did not get free through +any unintentional slackening of my line at that most critical moment, +I could have done so successfully, so assiduous was the (apparently) +hen fish in attendance upon the fish at the end of my line. Is this a +mere matter of curiosity on his or her part, or may it be attributed +to a feeling of _camaraderie_ or friendship? I think no one can +seriously contend for the latter hypothesis, as instances of affection +between such cold-blooded animals as fish have never to my knowledge +been even suggested. We must therefore, I take it, assume that it +is mere curiosity, a desire to see why the hooked fish is acting so +capriciously; and, if this be so, has it not a tendency to modify +somewhat our views as to the necessity of resting pools after a fish +has disturbed them by his being played? The following fish will, of +course, have been taken out of the place where it would probably rise +at a fly, and, therefore, out of any danger for the time being; but +travelling fish are not infrequently hooked and landed. + +My observations of salmon, such as they have been, have rather tended +to inspire me with the belief that salmon, when resting in a pool, +take little or no notice of what is going on round them. They will +move just so far aside as to let a rampant fish pass them, gliding +back into their former position the moment he has passed. How often, +when fish are really "on the job," have fishermen caught their four, +five, or even more fish out of one pool of very moderate dimensions, +every square yard of which must have been disturbed by the vagaries of +those caught before them? It seems to me that we are all inclined to be +a bit too cautious and careful in this respect. When the water is in +order, then I should be inclined to say, seize the happy moment, often +short-lived enough, and don't waste time in going to other pools as +long as you have any reason to suppose that the fish are "up," and that +there are other occupants of the pool that you are fishing that may be +grassed. + +Somehow or other, if a fish be lightly hooked the information is +conveyed through the line, as through a telephone, to the wielder of +the rod. You obtain a kind of realisation that such is the case, no +matter how well you have endeavoured to drive the barb home. And his +subsequent play shows you how well-founded your feeling was. You are +in constant expectation of seeing your rod point come up--unwelcome +sight--and if you have the luck to get the gaff home, and the hook +drops out of his mouth, you are not one whit astonished, only thankful +that your luck for once was in the ascendant, and that you have not one +more to add to the very considerable number of fish hooked and lost. + +In the same way with a fish that "jiggers," I, rightly or wrongly, +always set him down as being lightly hooked, and invariably offer up a +thanksgiving if he be safely brought to bank. Can anyone tell us why a +fish so acts? It is undoubtedly most disconcerting to the angler, and +must assuredly have a tendency to wear the hold of the hook. But if it +is so effectual, why do not more fish adopt it? Is it not permissible +to think that my hypothesis is right, and that a lightly-hooked fish +is able to appreciate that if he can only enlarge the hold of the +fly he may get free? Or, if this is too much to attribute to fish +intelligence, what other suggestion can be made? Of course, all my +argument is upset if my premise is unsound, that it is lightly-hooked +fish that employ the manoeuvre of "jiggering" to free themselves. + +The question is, of course, difficult of solution; at the same time, I +have invariably found that it is just those fish that I have already +set down in my mind as being lightly hooked that have resorted to that +expedient. + +I have always found it very advantageous to keep a good yard of free +casting line in my left hand, letting this slack go at the end of the +cast. This is exceedingly useful in getting out a long line; indeed, +it has become such a part of my nature that I invariably do the same +in dry-fly fishing for trout. In that case I find it helps me to pitch +my fly more lightly, and to correct my length; it has one drawback in +trout fishing, in that it prevents you from striking from the reel, but +it does not inconvenience me, for I merely turn the wrist in striking +a trout, so that the fact of my fingers gripping the line against +the rod does not matter. It may not be quite orthodox, but I find it +convenient, and always practise it; in fact, it is so much a matter of +second nature with me that I could not give it up, even if I wished +to do so. It is of great advantage, in fishing any pool, to have seen +the river in all its various stages, so as to know as much as possible +of its bed. As everyone knows, the places where fish rise vary as the +river may be high or low; one place where, in high water, you might +reckon on getting a rise if anywhere, would be absolutely unlikely when +the river is low; and so also in the intermediate stages. Until you +have become fully acquainted with the bed of the various pools, you are +not in a position to make the best of them; that is why a gillie with +local knowledge is so necessary. Perhaps you have fished a pool when +it was in perfect order. The next time you try it the river has sunk a +foot; it may still be fishable, but if you get a rise it will be almost +certainly in a different spot from the time before. + +On the Awe, in Argyleshire, a few years ago, after a summer drought +the river had dwindled down to about half its normal volume. A rod had +been fishing very sedulously a favourite pool of mine called Arroch. I +watched him for some time, and at last suggested that I did not think +he was at all likely to get a fish in the tail of the pool, where he +was employing most of his energies. He replied that he had caught many +a fish in that very part. I told him that it was doubtless true when +the river was in proper order, but that it was most unlikely in its +then condition. Somewhat nettled, he asked me to show him where I would +propose to fish; and, having my rod with me, I commenced to fish at the +very top of the pool, in a narrow, deep neck. At about my fourth or +fifth cast with a very short line, I noticed below me the silvery glint +of a fish that my fly had evidently moved. Stepping back a little, I +began, with great deliberation, to fill and light a pipe, and then +began again where I had originally commenced. At my fourth cast I saw +the same glint, and also felt the fish, which had taken the fly when +it was well sunk and was swirling about in the quick and heavy stream. +It was, of course, a great piece of luck, yet it served to point my +moral and adorn my tale. My friend was good enough to say that it was a +revelation to him, that he would no more have thought of fishing that +neck of the pool than of flying. + +It is astonishing how many anglers are similarly constituted. They +are content to fish a pool in just the same way, no matter what the +state of the river may be. They never seem to fish from their heads, +nor to bring any intelligence to bear. In a really big river it is +possible to pick up an odd fish in the most extraordinary places. Once +on the Carlogie water of the Dee, the river was in big flood, full of +snow-brue, and apparently hopeless to fish; but the grilse had begun +to run, and my time on the water was drawing to a close. Something +must be done; it seemed foolish to stop at home and waste a day, so I +walked up to the top of the Long Pool and fished my own bank down with +a short line. My perseverance was rewarded, and I managed to secure +three grilse. The great thing is to keep going, and to try to bring all +your acquired experience to bear. A dry fly will never catch a salmon; +your fly must be kept in the water, and not on the bank. The assiduous +fisherman will beat the lazy one into fits. + +National interest is, undoubtedly, being more constantly directed to +the importance of our salmon fisheries. Thus, this very year, 1905, an +influential deputation, headed by the Duke of Abercorn, was received +at the Offices of the Board of Agriculture, the object being to obtain +Governmental support to a private Bill that had been drafted with the +idea of giving increased powers to the Central Board, and to boards +of Conservators generally. The Bill, mild and tentative though it was +in its provisions, met with but qualified support at headquarters, as +it involved questions of finance, and possible rate aid to boards of +Conservators in carrying out necessary improvements in cases where +the local authorities refused to act. The question is, however, too +vast and too important to be dealt with by piecemeal legislation of +any kind, and, in regard to the vast national asset that is being +squandered and frittered away, demands energetic legislation on a bold +scale. + +The salmon fishery industry is a factor in the prosperity of the +nation, and the whole issue, with all its branches and ramifications, +should be fairly and squarely tackled in a Government Bill, not in the +interests of a class, but in that of the nation. + +It is satisfactory to learn from Lord Onslow that the Government Bill +dealing with obstructions and fish passes, though temporarily withdrawn +last Session, still embodies the views of the present Administration. +We must be thankful for small mercies, but this Bill merely touches one +item of importance, and any Government that has the courage and wisdom +to deal with the question as a whole will certainly have done something +to merit the lasting gratitude of the whole country. + +Since these lines were penned, the Election of January, 1906, has come +and gone, and with it a vast change in the aspect of political matters. +The point, however, that we are advocating is not a party question. It +is a matter affecting the interests of all classes, and it is devoutly +to be hoped that the new Government will take a "liberal" view of this +important matter, and will bring forward a bill, in the interests of +the nation at large, dealing with the whole question of our salmon +harvest in the rivers as well as the sea. + +[Illustration] + +[Illustration: GET THE GAFF READY.] + + + + +CHAPTER XV. + +A TRIP TO IRELAND. + + +SOME years ago, when Ireland was greatly disturbed--it was the year +after Lord Leitrim's assassination--a party of three, of which I formed +one, decided to fish the Clady, in Co. Donegal. We went _viâ_ Belfast +and Letterkenny, bound for Gweedore. We had received many warnings +against our projected trip, and were told that the "Boys" would not +allow us to cross the mountains in our outside cars on our long drive +from Letterkenny. Death's heads and crossbones, however, did not deter +us, though our car drivers were sufficiently impressed and alarmed +to insist that, if they took us, we should undertake to keep them at +Gweedore until we returned. This we had to concede, and off we set. + +The reports of the Clady were most temptingly satisfactory. The +malcontents had burnt the nets at the mouth of the river at Dum-Dum, +as they were the property of our landlord; the fish had, therefore, a +clean run up the river. The talented author of "Three in Norway, by One +of Them," had taken a fabulous number of salmon shortly before--report +said fifty fish in one fortnight--so it was not likely that three +sturdy fishermen would be frightened by paper threats. As a proper +measure of protection we were each of us in possession of a revolver, +more for show, should occasion arise, than because we were likely to +need it for our protection. Our drive, if my memory serves me right, +was over fifty miles in length, and was satisfactorily accomplished +without any startling incident or need for the display of our lethal +weapons. We were not sorry when it was over, and we were able to get +off our cars and see what comforts the hotel could provide. + +The local peasantry, of course, were not inimical to us as individuals, +but were determined to score off our landlord, and to destroy or +diminish his profits from the fishing. We had, therefore, to house and +care for our gillies as well, in order to save them from maltreatment. +Fortunately the river, though on the low side, was in fair order, and +the pools were crammed full of fish--too full, indeed, for sport; and +though we did not exactly equal the totals credited to our predecessor, +still, we could not complain of the results. The fish, bright and +clean, were not heavy--averaging not more than 10 lb. to 11 lb.--but +they fought well. Neither were they by any means perfect in shape, +being long and narrow, altogether less good-looking than their cousins +of the Crolly, who use the same _embouchure_. These latter are perfect +in contour and shape, more like Awe or Avon fish. + +Sport throughout our fortnight's stay was distinctly good, though +not remarkable, but the visit gave rise to some, to me, interesting +experiences. Thus, in one pool, called the Pulpit pool, the usual cast +is from the top of some very high rocks, as the name implies, into the +cauldron below. The fish lie near the rocks on the pulpit side; from +there the fly would never hang or fish properly; do what you would, +it resembled a bunch of dead feathers. On the other hand, there was +a convenient run on that side, down which a fish could be taken into +the pool below; and, as the fish hooked there always would insist on +going down, this point was one of some importance. On the opposite side +of the pool there was a charming shelving beach, or bank, and if you +could find a fly so well tempered as to stand being thrown against the +rocks opposite to you, you were almost certain of a rise, as your fly +then played admirably over the taking part of the pool. The problem was +then how your fish could be played when hooked, for between you and the +before-mentioned run was a line of serrated rocks, and a fish hooked +that meant going down would inevitably cut you. He must, therefore, not +be allowed to go down. Luckily, between you and this line of rocks was +a deepish backwater, and this was our _deus ex machina_, and solved the +difficulty. In this backwater we stationed the gillie, gaff in hand, +and crouched down; no sooner was a fish hooked than, before he could +realise the situation, he was unceremoniously hurried across the pool +into the backwater, and there equally unceremoniously gaffed. After two +or three fish had been so treated our gillie remarked sadly, "Well, +sorr, you may call this fishing, but I call it murther"; and so it +really was. + +As an example of how a difficulty may be overcome it was not without +its value. The moral is that a fish, when first hooked and before +he has realised what is happening, can be readily persuaded to act +according to your will, as he will never consent to do later on. Just +as a heavy trout lying amongst a bank of weeds can, if you can get his +head up, be led holus-bolus over and across the weeds into reasonable +water directly you have hooked him, so, in a similar manner, a salmon +will often allow you a latitude in dealing with him at first that +he won't give you a second time. Frequently the heaviest fish take +some time after being hooked before they are roused to a sense of +their position, and exert themselves to the full to get rid of the +annoying restraint. The strong upward pull of a salmon rod, tending +to pull him out of his natural element, is what a fish girds against, +naturally enough, and I have frequently found it of advantage to take +the strain entirely off a fish that is making too determined an effort +to leave a pool. Give him his head and he will often stop his run and +save you from the risk of being cut or broken. There is necessarily a +considerable element of risk in so doing, but desperate cases often +require desperate remedies. As with trout, so with salmon, hand lining +can frequently be resorted to advantageously, and it is wonderful how +easily salmon can be led by that means out of dangerous places, and +even brought to the gaff; the strain being removed, they do not seem to +resist an insidious and horizontal pull. + +In the pool below the Pulpit I had my first experience in learning how +to deal with a clean-run fish, hooked fairly and firmly in the thick +part of the tail. I had, of course, had to play foul-hooked fish, but I +had never hooked one in that part before. I was casting a longish line, +and rose a fish at the tail of the pool. On my offering him the fly a +second time he made a big splashy rise; I struck, and was in him. Down +he went into the next pool like a mad thing. The travelling, for me, +was bad, and the gillie had to steady me by holding on to the band of +my Norfolk jacket. I held the fish as hard as I dared, but he was bent +on running, out of one pool into and through the next; race as I would +over the wet and slippery rocks, I never could get on terms with him, +and he led me by some forty or fifty yards of line. As he had never +shown so far and was playing so hard, both my gillie and I thought we +were into a real big one. We were now nearing the falls above the sea +pool; I was pretty near pumped out, so some resolute measures had to be +taken. I accordingly, whilst holding on for all I was worth, sent the +gillie ahead to stone him up. No sooner was he turned than he was done, +and the gaff in him, and then only did we find out how he was hooked. +He weighed no more than 14 lb., and had we known where the hook was, +and had we not put him down as a real big fish, he would have never +have been permitted to play such pranks and lead us such a dance. Had +I held him really hard, his down-stream rush would soon have finished +him, as the water running through his gills would have choked him. + +One day we decided to try the Crolly, wishing to sample some of those +beautiful fish, and, as it meant a seven-mile walk over the hills, +we left our salmon rods at home, taking instead only double-handed +trout rods. On arriving, we found the wind very foul, blowing partly +across and partly up the river, so that it was no easy matter to +command the pools at all properly with our small rods. One fish in +particular annoyed us by showing constantly in a part of the water we +could barely reach and could not command, so we instituted a kind of +angling tournament, each of us in turn trying to get over him properly. +Our gillies were watching intently and open-mouthed. One of them, Pat +by name, had a peculiarly ugly mouth, with heavy, protruding lips; +and whilst he was watching thus intently, the unkind wind brought my +friend's fly, a big Jock Scott, right into his mouth, fixed it firmly +into his lower lip, the forward cast sending it well home, and nearly +dragging poor Pat into the river. We none of us felt equal to attacking +the fly in its weird position, so we sent Pat down to the village, +a mile or more away, to get the local doctor to extract it. Down he +went, only to return an hour later with the fly still sticking in its +former position, and having received a severe drubbing with shillelahs +from the locals for having presumed to gillie for us. Pretty well black +and blue all over, his lower lip enormously swollen, he looked indeed +a sorry sight. Something had now to be done, so it then occurred to +one of us to strip the fly, which fortunately was not an eyed one, and +take it out the reverse way. This was done accordingly without delay, a +plug of tobacco was stuffed into the gaping hole, a good jorum of "the +craytur" was speedily administered, and Pat soon forgot all about his +thrashing and his sore lip in his keenness to gaff the fish we managed +to catch. + +Owing to our being so severely boycotted, we had to manage for food +at the hotel as best we could, and the monotonous diet of salmon in +every form or shape, varied with a ham or piece of bacon, disagreed +thoroughly with me, and somewhat marred the perfect enjoyment of my +trip. + +On Sundays we used to drive to the Protestant church in a big brake, +so as to take the servants with us and protect them from possible +violence; and one sermon we heard there amused us mightily. We were +sitting in the big square pew just under the pulpit. The parson +preached us an impassioned sermon on intolerance, and I must candidly +admit that I have seldom listened to a more intolerant one. He +launched forth into a tirade of abuse of most things, of absenteeism +in particular, bewailing the sorrows of his poor, distressful country, +and attributing the large majority of her troubles to a non-resident +gentry. "They come here," said he, "not to do their duty or to help us, +but merely to gratify their miserable sporting instincts" (and here we +began to feel very small); "but," he added, leaning over the side of +the pulpit in our direction, "not, gintlemen, that I allude to angling, +for that is a grand sport. One of the greatest of the apostles, Saint +Peter, was an ardent angler, and I am an angler myself." Mentally +bowing our acknowledgments, we left the church, grateful that so +eloquent a divine should be appreciative of our favourite sport. + +One more anecdote and I have done. We were going back to England on the +morrow, and were settling up generally, when my gillie Pat said to me, +"Your honour, would ye buy me a pig?" "And why should I do that, Pat? +Are you not content with your tip?" "Well, your honour, I don't want +ye to pay altogither for it, but only to buy it for me." After some +further conversation I consented to go up to the shanty on the hill +where his old mother lived. There I found her haggling over the price +of a sow; she averred that £3 was more than the sow was worth, the man +was holding out for £3 10_s._ Eventually I became the purchaser at +£3, and, paying the money, told Pat that as he had been a good gillie +to me he could have the pig for his own. All the blessings of heaven +were showered on my head by Pat and his mother; but no sooner had the +dealer departed than Pat, producing an old stocking, extracted three +sovereigns therefrom and solemnly handed them to me. Asked what all +this comedy meant, Pat at once replied, "Ach, sorr, would ye have me +let the praste know I'd got three sovereigns in my pocket?" + +Were the nets at the mouth of the Clady and the Crolly kept within +reasonable limits, few better rivers for summer angling could be found. +Having seen their capabilities when the nets were perforce removed +altogether, I gained an idea of what the sport might be in our sea-girt +island, with its innumerable rivers, were the angling not throttled by +the vast array of legalised nets that threaten to destroy, or at any +rate reduce very heavily, the sport and profit of riparian owners. + +That much has been done and that more is being done in this respect +cannot be gainsaid. The allowance of longer slaps, the purchase +outright of netting rights in individual cases, are undoubted steps in +the right direction. But until the process is more universally applied +its effect cannot be considerable. Salmon coast along such an extent +of our shores before reaching their destination that bag and coast +nets miles away may take heavy toll of the fish that are seeking your +estuary, even though they would have a free run up your river if once +they could attain it. + +Is it too much to hope that some day a wise Government may take +the matter in hand, not by piecemeal legislation, but with the +determination of so apportioning and circumscribing the respective +rights of all concerned and interested, that the price of salmon as an +article of food may not be increased, and the true rights of both net +fisherman and angler may be secured? + +These two are so much bound up together that over net fishing must +necessarily and improperly reduce the number of spawning fish, and +thus injure the rivers which, by furnishing the spawning grounds, are +the geese that lay the golden eggs. Kill the geese and you get no more +eggs of gold. Treat the rivers unfairly, either by pollution or by +over-netting, and not only will the net fishing industry suffer, but +the general public also, for salmon will rise to famine price. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER XVI. + +SALMON AND FLIES. + + +WHY does a salmon take a salmon fly, and what does it represent to him? +These are conundrums that are not readily answered. Obviously it cannot +be because it represents any particular article of food to which salmon +are accustomed when in the river. If one may presume to dogmatise at +all upon so abstruse a question, it must be because their curiosity and +predatory instincts are aroused by a queer object, moving with a series +of jerks and a somewhat lifelike movement of fibres. Any salmon angler +with the slightest experience will know what is meant by "hanging +a fly" properly, and its taking powers as compared with a bunch of +lifeless feathers floating down stream. So far we are all agreed; but +when we attempt to discuss the details of the fly itself we are prone +to differ amazingly. + +Some years ago, on the occasion before alluded to, when I was fishing +the River Clady, in Donegal, the nets having been removed for that +year, the river was full of fresh-run fish--it was in July. There was +a pool in which the fish lay in serried rows in the stream, which +at that point ran under a steep, high bank. I lay down on the bank +overlooking and a little behind the rows of salmon, and some twenty +feet above them. By shading my eyes I could make out all the fish as +clearly as if I were looking at them in an aquarium. I arranged a code +of signals with my fishing friend, and he went some thirty yards or +so up the river to fish the pool. As soon as his fly began to work +over the first line I signalled that he had got the length; there was, +however, no movement among the fish. I then signalled to cast again +with the same length of line. As the fly worked over the fish for the +second time they all seemed to shun it, dropping down stream a foot or +so, with the exception of one fish, which, separating from the others, +came up some three feet to follow the fly, eventually leaving it and +dropping back into his former position. A third passage of the fly +produced similar results, the same fish moving again. He made a break +in the water, which my friend saw, but he had come short. A fourth cast +secured him. + +I could come to no other conclusion but that the fish had been bored +into taking that fly. His curiosity had been excited at first, and +in ordinary circumstances the fisherman would have known nothing and +passed on. Does not this tend to show that many a fish may be moved +without our knowledge, and that a subsequent fly might secure him? + +It is often thought that the first fly over a pool stands the best +chance, provided, of course, that it is properly offered. Personally, +I would just as soon follow a good angler down a pool as precede him. +Unless a fish breaks the water in his rise, the fisherman can tell +little of what is happening below the water level, except when, by +chance, a glimpse of a silver flash is accorded him. But he may have +moved a fish with his fly, and, knowing nothing, will have moved a yard +down stream, his next cast being a yard below the fish. The next fly, +suitably offered, if it be about the same size, may lure our friend to +his destruction. Could we all know exactly what is going on under the +water out of our sight, many more fish would doubtless be brought to +bank. Of course, on those days when the temperature of both air and +water have attained that precise relative proportion that seems to +cause a simultaneous rise of fish in every pool, the first fly will pay +best, for on such happy occasions that fly, however ill delivered, may +secure the best fish. And what fisherman cannot recall instances of +"duffer's luck," the veriest tyro catching, perhaps, the fish of the +season? I remember once trying to teach a would be angler how to cast, +and in a most unlikely spot--the river being dead low--was endeavouring +to instil into him the rhythm of the cast, and trying to make him get +his line out well behind him. Holding the rod with him, I kept the +same length of line, steadily flogging the water to the tune of "one, +two," when, at about the ninth or tenth cast, a travelling fish seized +our fly, and eventually came to the gaff, a clean-run salmon of 18 lb. + +[Illustration: HE MEANS GOING DOWN.] + +But surely the precise pattern of the fly, within limits, is of small +moment; the size, coupled with the proper working of the fibres, is the +main thing. Every angler has, naturally, his own favourite shibboleth, +mainly, in my opinion, because he has succeeded with it, and therefore +perseveres with it far more steadily than with any other pattern. In +the same way local fetishes are set up, and when once adopted are hard +to shift. On the Beauly, years ago, fishing on that lovely water in the +spring, we were using the orthodox spring fly, a sort of exaggerated +Alexandra, and were mainly catching kelts. When one of us suggested +a Gordon (having lately used it on the Dee) the fishermen laughed us +to scorn, and said we might as well fish with it on the high road. +Nevertheless, the fly was tried, and nearly all the clean fish we got +that week were secured by it. When our time was up our gillies begged +for our worn specimens of the goodly Gordon, and the next lessee caught +all his fish upon flies of that pattern; and, for aught I know, that +fly may now be reckoned as one of the standard flies of the river. + +To revert to the original query. Can it be answered satisfactorily? +Surely it must represent some food taken whilst the salmon are in +their sea home; and yet, if this be the only probable answer, how +comes it that on some rivers, as is the case in Canada, salmon cannot +be persuaded to rise at any fly of the kind? After all, whether the +question is unanswerable or no, the glorious uncertainty of salmon +fishing forms one of its most potent fascinations. If every bungling +cast hooked a salmon, few people would care for the sport. + +All this said, then, what form of fly are we to use? Here we get upon +very debatable ground, and whatever conclusion we arrive at will +probably be strenuously opposed. The patterns of salmon flies are +legion, many differing but slightly from others. Are we to credit +salmon with such extraordinary intelligence as to believe them able to +differentiate between varieties of almost similar flies, and to have +such a correct eye for colour as to refuse a fly because the colour +of the body or hackle is a shade unorthodox? The size of the fly, no +doubt, is a most important factor, both as regards the size and +volume of the river and the time of the year. It would be the height +of absurdity to use in fine run water in the summer a three inch fly +that would be a suitable lure on the brawling Thurso in the spring, and +_vice versâ_. The finer the water the smaller the fly--within reason. + +So far, I think, we are all agreed. It is when we attempt to reduce +the vast number of flies now in vogue that differences of opinion will +begin to assert themselves. + +On the whole, perhaps, there will be less divergence of opinion about +that singularly fortunate combination of fur, feather, and tinsel, +termed the Jock Scott. It seems, to an extraordinary degree, to +be effective on most rivers where the artificial fly is used. The +combination of colour is most happy, and the fibres of its mixed wing +give it, in the water, a most life-like appearance. Few anglers would +care to be without Jock Scotts of sizes. Similarly, in bright water +the Silver Doctor is a universal favourite, and justly so. As a direct +contrast the Thunder and Lightning is bad to beat, and I should be +sorry to be without a Blue Doctor. + +Eagles, grey and yellow, hold their sway on the Dee, and the play of +the feathers seems to be alluring in the quick waters of that river. +How would such a fly suit the quiet waters of the Avon? You would +imagine that you might as well fish with a mop-head! The fibres of +Eagles require fast, fleet water to make them work, and to use an +Eagle as your lure in slow-running rivers would appear to be most +inappropriate. The play of the rod point may, however, be substituted +for the play of the water, and a tempting opening and closing of +fibrous and mixed winged flies can be obtained by a judicious +rhythmical raising and lowering of your rod point. Indeed, if you +watch an experienced salmon fisherman from a distance, you can tell at +once the kind of water his fly is working through. If the stream be +sufficiently broken and rapid to work his fly automatically, his rod +point will be still. If the water should be sluggish, you will note the +work of the rod top. It would, therefore, be folly to dogmatise on such +a matter, and I should be sorry to attempt to do so. + +Gordons, Butchers, Wilkinsons, and a host of others have their staunch +advocates. + +It is, however, unnecessary to run through the whole gamut; suffice +it to say that in my opinion, a good selection of, say four or five, +would be as effective as twenty or thirty. The main difficulty is local +prejudice, and the uncertain kind of feeling--that if you had not +discarded local favourites your blank day might have been fruitful. +Once, however, you have shaken yourself free from this feeling, you +will very soon gain full confidence in your theory. The blank day that +you are mourning would probably have been equally blank if you had been +equipped with all that local fancy could suggest. Can it be seriously +suggested that salmon can be credited with sufficient intelligence to +refuse a Silver Doctor or Silver Grey and to accept only a Wilkinson? +Is it not rather that the fly that was accepted was presented in a most +alluring manner, whilst the others which were rejected did not come +within the salmon's ken in such a way as to tempt him? Are we not all +too prone to change our flies on the slightest provocation, and are we +not all inclined to have our own favourite fetish--a fly that succeeds +with us simply because we give it ten chances to one of any other? The +vagaries of salmon are universally admitted; at one time they will +allow all lures to pass them unnoticed, and in the next half hour +may take any fly, of the proper size, suitably offered. The relative +temperatures of air and water have, I feel convinced, much to say with +regard to this. The fly in which an angler believes, and with which, +therefore, he perseveres most, will bring him more fish to bank than +any other. + +It goes without saying that the fly that is most in the water, in the +fishable parts of the pools, of course, will catch most fish. The +patient, persistent angler has that great advantage over his less +energetic brother of the angle. What angler is there, who ties his +own flies, who has not built up a combination of fur, feathers, and +silk by the river side, and, on trying the novelty, perhaps after days +of disappointment, has found it unexpectedly to succeed, and who has +thereupon fondly imagined that he has found a "medicine," only to be +equally disappointed the next time it is tried? Scrope, in his day, +seems to have been satisfied with five patterns. To come to later +times and later writers, Sir Edward Grey and Mr. Gathorne Hardy both +advocate four only. The colour of the bottom of the river, of the sky, +the brightness of the day, or its cloudiness, all these will affect our +choice of fly, whilst the size and volume of the water will affect our +choice of size. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER XVII. + +SALMON OF THE AWE. + + +THE River Awe, in Argyllshire, presents, to my mind, the perfection of +angling water. A fine brawling stream, a constant succession of pools, +some easy to fish, some only fishable by past masters, lovely, deep, +roach-backed salmon trout--all these are bad to beat, and when one adds +the fact that the run of the heavy fish takes place in June and July, +after the Orchy fish have run through, the two months of all others, +perhaps, when salmon fishing is enjoyable, I do not think any further +arguments need be urged to enforce my point. + +Were I a rich man--which I am not--I should feel inclined to do my best +to secure the fishing rights on that merry little river in preference +to many others of high repute. It is now many years since I first +wetted a line on the Awe. My old gillie, Black Peter, or the "Otter," +as he was frequently called, has, I fear, gaffed his last salmon and +drunk his last glass of whisky, and (save the mark!) he was mighty good +at both. I can see him now, in his somewhat tattered kilt, hanging +on to the porch of the Clachan, trying to steady himself, to give me +a right cordial welcome when I arrived. No more will he swim the Awe +when in spate to land a fish for the "Colonel" that had jumped itself +on the rocks on the opposite side of the river, some mile or two above +the bridge--a foolhardy feat in such water; but he was always full of +sport, and not infrequently, alas, equally full of whisky. + +The head of water in this bonnie little river is always maintained +fairly well by its being the affluent of Loch Awe. It is not, +therefore, so liable to the quick rises and falls of most rivers. The +loch is fed by the River Orchy, which flows into its north-eastern +end, whilst the Awe, after passing through the Pass of Brander, forms +its only outlet. All the Orchy fish, therefore, have to run up the Awe +to get to their own waters. These fish run early in the spring, never +dwelling for any length of time in the Awe; and, curiously enough, any +tyro could at once differentiate between the salmon of the two rivers, +though they have a common outlet to the sea. The Orchy fish are long, +lanky, and plain as compared with the short, thick-set beauties of the +Awe. I recollect once in Ireland coming across the same difference in +fish using the same _embouchure_. It was in Donegal, where the Crolly +and the Clady unite at Dum Drum. In this case also one lot of fish are +poor in shape, whilst the others are of totally different calibre. And, +moreover, in that case the fish never seem to lose their way. Seldom is +a Crolly fish found in the Clady, or _vice versâ_. How accurate are the +instincts of nature! + +The lower reaches of the river Awe are very varied and very beautiful. +The river has churned its way through the solid rock. The two Otter +Pools, Arroch and the Long Pool, are good examples of the rock-hewn +gorges. In the latter, a fine quiet stretch of water, where local +knowledge of the lie of fish is valuable, switching or spey casting is +necessary if you wish to avoid being constantly hung up in the trees +above. The Red Pool, just above the stepping stones, can only be fished +from a plank staging fixed high above the water, and should you hook a +heavy one at the tail end and he means going down you will be thankful +enough when you have safely negotiated the return journey on the high +plank and reached the shore. Even then you have plenty of excitement in +store before you can hope to see him on the bank. The rocky sides of +the chasm do not form a racing track. But get him once safely down to +the Stepping Stone Pool and he should be yours. + +This same pool, by the way, is not altogether the place for a beginner, +for when the river is in order the aforesaid stepping stones have about +two feet or more of fairly heavy water over them; and as they are +well-worn boulders, somewhat inclined to be rounded on the top, and +are placed at a rather inconvenient distance from one another, they are +apt to make a nervous man think. One friend, I can well remember, when +I asked him to fish the pool, absolutely declined, asking me if I took +him for a "blooming acrobat." Below again we come to the Cruive Pool, +a long cast from another staging, the fish lying on the far side, just +about as far as an 18 ft. rod will get you. But be there in July when +the sun is setting, the redder the better, behind the hills on the far +side, and suddenly the silent oily water becomes broken with countless +rises, also on the far side. Put on then a cast of sea trout flies and +use your salmon rod, otherwise you will never reach them. Do not bother +with a landing net, but run them ashore on the shelving bank below you +and let your gillie take them off the hooks, and get to casting again +as soon as you can. The rise, though a good one, lasts, I assure you, +but a tantalisingly short time, and then the pool is as quiet and oily +as ever, and you would feel inclined to stake your bottom dollar that +there was not a sea trout within miles. + +The Thunder and Lightning and the Blue Doctor are the local lures, and +kill well. One year, when the river was low and the fish as stiff as +pokers, I tied a "medicine" of my own that I fondly hoped would form a +standard fly on that water, for its effect was admirable at that time. +It was an olive fly, body olive silk ribbed with silver, tag a golden +pheasant, dark olive hackles, a light mixed wing with golden pheasant +topping. Having caught several fish that year with this fly, I got +Messrs. Eaton and Deller to dress me a stock, and must candidly admit +that never since then have I caught a single salmon with the "olives." + +There are two pools, however, above the Long Pool that I have not +attempted to describe--the lower one the Yellow Pool, an ideal, leg +of mutton-shaped piece of water, where a beginner could not well go +wrong, and above it the Bridge Pool, so called because the railway line +crosses the neck of it. It was in this pool that I once had a rare bit +of sport. The whole of the water I have attempted to describe was then +hotel water, the fishermen staying at the inn having the right to fish +for a nominal sum--5_s._ a day I think it was. But the river had been +in fair order, and several good fish had been got. It was then rapidly +getting on the small side. The records of the previous week having +been published in the columns of the _Field_, the inevitable result +was a rush of ardent anglers, and the dozen or so of good pools--nice +water for two rods--was perfectly inadequate to accommodate the six +keen fishermen who had arrived to try their luck. It was necessary, +therefore, to "straw" for the pools, and to my lot fell the Bridge and +Yellow Pools. The next morning, on reaching my little beat, I found the +Yellow Pool far too low to be fishable, and there remained only the +Bridge Pool. Fishing it down carefully twice produced no result, so I +lit a pipe and clambered up on to the railway bridge to scan the water +below me. + +I was able, after a careful search with shaded eyes, to locate three +fish, all low down on the far side, lying behind a big stone below the +water and upon a slab. I could see at once that to reach them I should +have to do my utmost in the casting way, and should have, moreover, +to bring my line up through the centre arch of the bridge above me to +get out the length I wanted; but it seemed to me that if I could get +my fly to travel and work well over the oily water formed by the stone +it ought to be irresistible to any well-conducted fish. So, putting on +a small Thunder, I regained the water side. The second cast brought +up the smallest of the three fish, who made no bones about it, but +hooked himself handsomely, and was shortly after disposed of in the +tail of the pool; he weighed a bare 9 lb. The other two I knew were +better fish; one I had seen should be over 20 lb., the other, a very +pale-coloured fish, I could not see distinctly enough to form any idea +as to his weight. Back I went to my spying point, only just missing +being caught on the narrow bridge by a passing train, to see, to my +delight, that the other two fish were there, apparently undisturbed. +After a few casts the fly went exactly as I could have wished, and +there was the answering boil. "By Jove! that is the big one I think; +anyway, he is hooked, and well hooked, too." After a long, splashy +fight in the pool I got on terms with him, and he began to flounder, +and then I could see I had the light-coloured fish on. The big one was +still there, I hoped. The pale fish soon came to the gaff, and, getting +it nicely home with the left hand, I hauled him on to the bank, a good +fish, and in good condition, turning the scale at barely 17 lb. + +By this time the pool had had a good doing, and I judged it advisable +to give it a rest. The Yellow Pool, which I had fished down more +for occupation than for anything else, yielding me no response--and, +indeed, it was all I expected--I ate my luncheon, lit my pipe, and +proceeded once more to my vantage spot. There, sure enough, was the +big fish, undisturbed and immutable. Unable to restrain my impatience, +I sent a fly (the same one that had accounted for the two other fish) +on its errand of quest. But there was no movement, no reply, nor was +there to two other changes of fly I put over him. Having nowhere else +to fish, and being disinclined to try the Yellow Pool again, as I felt +sure it would be hopeless, I sat me down to cogitate and look over +my fly box. The day had become sultry and heavy, and clouds had been +rolling up, and suddenly there broke a regular deluge of rain, turning +the pool into a seething mass of big drops. Instinctively I ran for +shelter under the bridge, but before I reached it changed my mind and +determined to try once more for the big one in the heavy rainstorm. + +Hastily putting on a Thunder and Lightning two sizes larger, I sent him +out, braving the ducking I was undergoing. The first fly that reached +the spot was answered by a fine head and tail rise, and I was fast in +the big one. For a short time he played sulkily, either through not +grasping the situation or through trying to induce me to believe him to +be a small one. But I was not to be deluded, and, as he kept edging up +into the big water coming down the centre arch of the railway bridge, I +let him have a bit of the butt of my 18 ft. Castleconnell. But, with a +savage shake of his head and strong whisk of his broad tail, he was now +thoroughly aroused, and, despite all I could do, up he went, carefully +threading the central arch and working up for all he was worth into +the heavy water round the corner. My running line was thus against the +buttress, but, despite the imminent danger of being cut, there was +nothing to do but give him "beans." Fortunately for me my lucky star +was in the ascendant. A convenient patch of moss between the courses +of the bricks saved my line from the grinding process; the strain of +my supple rod, combined with the weight of the water, did the trick. I +felt him yield, reeled up as hard as I could, but, as he turned tail +and came down (fortunately for me through the same arch), I soon had +to give up reeling in in order to haul in the line by hand to keep +touch with him in his downward rush. Steadying the line when he got +ahead of me, I felt he was still on. Ten minutes of the fight against +rod, water, and luck had been enough for him, and, rolling on his +side, he swung round into the slack below me. I had had no chance till +then of taking my gaff off my back; luckily it came off my shoulders +quite freely, and the steel went home. As I hauled him out with some +difficulty, the hook, which had worn a big hole, came out of his jaw; +so my luck continued to the last. I could not make him scale 30 lb.; he +was a good 29½ lb., and, inasmuch as I had never landed a fish of 30 +lb. or upwards, that part was somewhat aggravating. But, as I toiled +home that evening over the three miles of sleepers and rails to the inn +with the three fish weighing just about half-a-hundredweight, I several +times wished he had not been quite so heavy. + +The upper waters of the Awe, above Awe Bridge, formerly retained by the +Marquis of Breadalbane in his own hands, and therefore not open to the +general public, can nowadays be fished from Dalmally Hotel. Through +that nobleman's enterprise one of the two big cruives has been done +away with, and there is to be an additional slap nightly, between 6 +p.m. and 6 a.m. The results cannot but be both beneficial and prudent. +The characteristics of these upper waters are totally distinct from +those of the lower ones, being unusually broken and rapid, the pools +small, and not easily distinguishable. + +The pent up waters of Loch Awe, finding through the dark Pass of +Brander their only outlet to the sea, take full advantage of their +opportunity, and rush and boil over the boulder-bestrewn bed of the +river in a way that renders it imperative that your gut should be of +the best, your tackle sound, and your determination great that you will +not consent to be a mere follower of a hooked fish, but intend to give +him "beans" when necessary. + +The Black and Seal Pools and Verie are fairly typical of the upper Awe +waters; most of them are fished from planks rigged out on staging, +and wading is not generally practicable. A hooked fish can never be +reckoned on as caught, nor can you ever be certain of him until the +gaff has gone home and your fish lies on the bank beside you. This +remark, of course, applies in a greater or lesser degree to all salmon +fishing; but here the perils from heavy water, combined with the +rugged, rock-strewn bed, afford unusual chances of escape, and at the +same time add much to the sporting charms of a successful capture. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER XVIII. + +DISAPPOINTING DAYS. + + +DISAPPOINTING Days! How well we all know them, and how terribly +frequent they are. Full of ardour and keen as mustard, we anticipate +great things, only to find that another day of disappointment is to +be added to the many already recorded in our angling diary. And it is +sometimes so difficult to anticipate them; all the omens seem to be +propitious, and yet the fates are inexorable. + +There are days admittedly hopeless, when the river side is only sought +for its companionship, and for the unknown possibilities of fortune; +and others that are worse than hopeless, when to try to fish for +salmon with a fly would be the height of absurdity, as, for instance, +when the river is in high spate, or so full of snow brue or ice as to +render your chances almost ridiculous. These, in a sense, are certainly +disappointing; but it is not of them that I would write, but rather of +those inexplicable days when all seems to be fairly propitious and yet +we come home "blank." + +Fortunately, fishermen are not easily browbeaten by unkind fortune, +and these black letter days only serve to give a renewed zest to +the future, in anticipation of the more fortunate days that we all +confidently believe to be in store for us. + +Everything seems on some occasions to go unaccountably wrong. The water +may be in order, the fish up, and yet at the end of the day you have +nothing but mishaps to record, your confident expectations have been +rudely dissipated, and you have met with a series of misfortunes. + +Perhaps on starting you find that you have left your flask or your +tobacco pouch lying on your mantelpiece, and imprudently have turned +back to secure them. That circumstance alone, in the eyes of your +gillie, will prove amply sufficient to give you a "disappointing day." +You have already discounted your luck, and must not grumble at the +result. On reaching the water side you find that you have brought +with you the wrong box of flies, and only have with you the one you +had discarded overnight as containing those of a size too large. +Well, you must make the best of it, mount the least objectionable of +those at your disposal, and proceed to wade out into the stream with +half your confidence gone. You soon realise that your waders, which +had already given you warning indications of hard wear, are leaking +somewhat unpleasantly. After working your way half down the pool you +discover that your pipe is smoked out, and as you are in need of the +consoling influence of tobacco, you propose to refill it, proceeding +to knock out the ashes on the butt of your rod; in doing so the pipe +slips through your fingers and disappears in the stream at your feet. +It is impossible to recover it, so you are pipeless, and therefore +inconsolable all day. + +Some disappointments are sheer ill fortune; some we bring upon +ourselves. You are, for example, casting mechanically, and therefore +badly; moreover, you are not watching your fly, nevertheless you get +a rise. You step back a yard or so, in order to be sure of getting +the length right for the next cast, and in so doing forget the slimy +green boulder that you had just negotiated on your way down. An awkward +struggle, in which you have to use the butt of your rod as a stick to +avoid an upset, does not serve to mend matters, but rather to unsteady +you the more. At any rate, you have escaped a real ducking and are +proportionately thankful. + +Then, your mental balance being somewhat upset, you cast over your +rising fish; he comes up well, a good boil, but you are too anxious +and keen, and fairly pull the fly out of the fish's mouth. You have +pricked him, and you will hardly get another rise out of him. Still +there is a Will-o'-the-wisp kind of luck awaiting you, for near the +tail of the pool you get a fair head-and-tail rise, and are fast in a +good fish. He won't come up into your pool, but insists on making down, +through the broken water, into the pool below. Having guided him to the +best of your ability through the intricacies of the run, you hasten to +get ashore to get on terms with him, keeping your rod point well up. +More haste, less speed. The fact of your mental balance being upset +reacts upon your bodily balance, and you catch the toe of your brogue +on a submerged rock whilst working your way ashore, and this time you +go a real "howler." Thoroughly wet, with a big chunk cut out of your +wrist in your fall, you pick yourself up to find that you have broken +your favourite rod point. Disconsolately you begin to reel up, the +broken top meanwhile floating on your line in the water. + +Still a gleam of luck: the fish is on, and, moreover, is complacently +careering round the head of the new pool. Thoroughly aroused, you take +the greatest care in getting on to terms with him again. Your rod has +now a somewhat quaint appearance, like a dismasted yacht. Half the +play of it is gone, and the top swirls about on the water in a most +disconcerting manner. With set teeth, you grimly determine that, come +what may, you will land that salmon. And you meet with some measure of +reward, for after a somewhat prolonged duel, he begins to flop about on +the surface, and to show unmistakable signs of having had enough of it. + +With the greatest care you select the best spot for gaffing him, and +successfully get the gaff free from your shoulder. Your now stiff and +stodgy rod is, however, not best suited for bringing him in to the +gaff. It is some little time before you get anything, like a fair +chance. Then, with the rod in your left hand, your trusty gaff in +the right, he is led in, down stream, and he flops about. The hold, +alas, has been somewhat worn, and, just as you are making ready for +your stroke, the fish makes one more roll and surge and is free. A +wild scrape with the gaff only scores a scale or two from his side, +and, slowly gliding out of sight into the deep water, he disappears +for ever. You feel that you have only yourself to thank for such a +_dénouement_, but that is scant consolation. + +[Illustration: THE FALL'S POOL.] + +Damp and annoyed, you sit yourself down by the river side to try to +make matters straight. Where is that waxed silk? At home, of course. +So you have to content yourself with sacrificing a good length of the +taper of your line in order to make a temporary splice. + +Taking all things into consideration, your efforts to rig up a jury top +are reasonably successful, and it might yet kill a fish. If only you +had a pipe to console yourself with, things might look brighter and +better; but the loss of your pipe is an undeniably severe one. The pool +that you are now fishing has a shelving stone bank on your side, the +deep water being opposite to you. It is ideal water to fish, as the fly +works out of the heavy stream into the shallowing water on your side. +The wading, moreover, is easy, and the pool a long one, so that there +is every probability of your being able to yet retrieve your fortunes, +and of being able to account for a heavy fish before you have done with +it. + +Still keeping mounted the fly that, contrary to your expectations, +had already deluded the former fish, you wade out and recommence +operations. The cast, however, demands a certain length of line to +cover the fish, and your rod is hardly the man it was; the breeze has +increased a good deal, and is directly behind you; still, you manage to +cover the water fairly well, and are beginning to get on better terms +with yourself. A few yards down there is a good rise and a welcome +heavy "rugg." The fly, however, comes away, and you are left lamenting. +The long pool is steadily fished down, and some hundred yards or so +lower you get another bold and confident rise. You strike, and the fly +again comes back. Reeling up, sadly you wade ashore, and, on examining +your fly, find the barb gone. + +In all probability it was broken at the head of the pool on the +shelving bank behind you, the strong wind at your back and the long +cast with a weak rod having brought about the misfortune. Why, in the +name of goodness, had you not examined the fly when it came back after +your last rise? No doubt but that the barb had gone long before that. +Mentally cursing your carelessness, objurgating Dame Fortune, and +longing for the companionship of a pipe, there is nothing to be done +but to mount another fly and to fish, albeit somewhat mechanically, the +next stretch of water. But there is now no response. That inexplicable +co-relation between the temperature of the air and the water that seems +to cause salmon to rise has undergone some modification, the breeze has +dropped, and the mists are beginning to rise. Do what you will, not a +fish will move. + +Had your luck been in the ascendant, or had you paid more respect to +the superstitions of your attendant gillie, things might have been +so different. You have had three good chances, each of which, under +normal circumstances, might have been fairly expected to score, and +that with flies that, in your judgment, were a size too large. Fate had +determined that you were to have a "disappointing day," and you cannot +say that you have not scored one. + +In September, 1902, having received an invitation from an old friend to +fish one of the upper beats of the Spean, I journeyed up North, full of +eagerness. I had long wished to try that river. My host had informed me +that that river was low, but that everything pointed to broken weather +and rain; and though this forecast was true as regards some portions of +Great Britain, the change never came during the fortnight that I spent +on Spean side, that bonnie river getting finer and finer day by day, +until at last it became a mere shadow of its former self. At the time +of my arrival everything looked promising. Heavy clouds were gathering, +and it looked as if the promised rainfall could not be long delayed. +At the lodge I found, besides my host, another angler whom I am also +privileged to call an old friend, and in such company I knew that, +whether sport were good or no, we should at least have a jolly time. +That evening we discussed flies and angling details as only fishermen +can, and with a last look out of the window at the murky sky, and a tap +to my barometer as I turned in somewhat early, looking forward to the +morrow with the keenest anticipation. + +Early astir next morning, I drew up my blinds to find an almost +cloudless sky and a bright sun. All the evening promise had been +dissipated, and the rain-laden clouds had wandered out to sea to +discharge their precious stores where least required. The river, though +small, was, nevertheless, still fishable, and there were plenty of +salmon up. At the lowest pool on the beat I put up my rod and fixed +up the local "medicine"--a Thunder and Lightning--and, wading out, +fished the pool down carefully, without result. My host then fished it, +also blank. Several fish had shown at the tail, but we could not get a +rise out of them. Then we wandered up the beat, trying all the likely +pools in turn. In the mill pool I managed to get into a small salmon, +about 7 lb. in weight, and duly got him out; otherwise our efforts +were entirely unrewarded. It was a great thing to learn the pools, and +to know where it was safe to wade, etc., and so I felt that the day +was not a lost one as far as I was concerned, though of course less +interesting to my friend S. and to my host. As we came home the clouds +again began to gather, to lure us, Will-o'-the-wisp-like, on to further +baseless hope, as the following bright, hot morning amply testified. + +And so the days wore on, rocks gradually appearing where water had +flowed before, shallows becoming stony strands, and the fish more +pool-locked than ever. Finer grew the tackle used, smaller the flies. +We were really learning the geography of the bed of the river to some +weariness. After a few days S. gave up trying for the salmon, and +contented himself with trout waders and a trout rod as being more +productive of amusement. Being, however, of a more dogged temperament, +I stuck to the salmon, fishing with the smallest flies I could get, +and almost trout gut. By means of these allurements I did succeed in +amusing myself, rising and hooking quite a respectable number of fish, +but somehow or other I never could get a good hold of them; all were +lightly hooked, and got off in playing or eventually broke me. One fish +I was particularly annoyed with; he was a heavy one, well over 20 lb., +and might have been 30 lb. I had often seen him showing in the pool at +the end of the Red Bank. This formed really the head of the Mill Pool, +but was now cut off from the main part of the Mill Pool by a daily +lowering shallow some 1 ft. to 18 in. deep, through which sharp-cutting +rocks jutted at intervals. In mid-stream quite a highish bank of stones +was now disclosed, and on our side had quite cut off the flow of water +and formed a large backwater. The pool was fishable with a short line, +and the high, rocky bank behind formed a good shelter whilst working +down the very rough bank side. About four o'clock one afternoon I saw +my friend show twice in the head of the pool, and determined to give +him another trial with the little Popham that had already risen fish. +He took it grandly, with a head-and-tail rise, right up in the roughish +water in the neck, and then proceeded to sail round the diminished +proportions of the deep hole. He played very heavily, but did not +jigger or show any signs of being lightly hooked. After some time of +this kind of work, which was taking but little out of him, my light +cast forbidding any heroic measures on my part, I began to wonder how +I could manage to kill him. He could have got up into the pool above, +where it would have been an easier matter to deal with him, but no arts +of mine could induce him up stream. I thought that if I could get him +down into the backwater I could more readily manage to play and kill +him, so I walked him steadily down stream, and he followed for some +distance like a lamb. Suddenly, however, he made up his mind for a run, +or, realising the object of my manoeuvre, off he went, churning his +way across the wide shallow, his back fin almost showing, bound for +the main stream on the other side. Sixty yards of line were soon gone, +then seventy, then eighty, and, as I could not follow, it was merely +a question of when he would break me, when apparently he changed his +mind, turned clean round and ran back through the shallow towards me +for all he was worth. Holding the rod as high as I could to prevent +my line being cut by the half-submerged, jagged rocks, and paying in +line as hard as I could at the same time, I got him within twenty +yards of the spot where he was hooked, the little Popham holding well, +and with no slack line. Just as my gillie and I were congratulating +ourselves that we had him now, up came the point of my rod, and he was +gone. The light cast had been terribly frayed by his mad rush across +the shallow water, and he retained my Popham and left me lamenting. It +certainly was hard lines, when all the dangers of the run had been so +successfully overcome and hooked fish were so scarce. + +It is useless, however, to repine in such circumstances, and after all, +in a very dead time, he had given me a good twenty minutes to half an +hour of sport. My friend S. came up just as we parted company, and +condoled with me. That same afternoon my host managed to land a 21 lb. +fish on a stouter tackle, and he was not very red--the fish I mean, +not my host!--although he must have been up some time. + +The same thing went on all the next week. A few desultory showers did +not help us much, and at the end of a fortnight's solid work I could +only show two small salmon of 7 lb. apiece, my host one of 21 lb., and +S., who had confined his attention to the trout after the first few +days, had not landed any fish. And so it is--too often, alas!--that +our hopes are doomed to disappointment. There were the fish, plenty +of them; but also there were the gradually dwindling river and the +expanding river bed. Nothing was wanting save a kindly and copious fall +of rain--so much needed by three ardent anglers--rain that was falling +only too copiously down South, whilst the normally wet North-West coast +of Scotland was languishing for want of it. + +A dear fishing friend of mine took a rod for February one year, and +lived at Brawl Castle for the month at the rate of about £1 per day. +During the whole month the river and even Loch More were ice-bound, and +his rods reposed in the box. The trip must have cost him the best part +of £100. So our Spean experience was as nothing to his. + +And these disappointments make an admirable foil for those happy, +though not too frequent, times when, for a wonder, river, fish, and +weather are all we could desire them to be. How little we should value +them were they of constant recurrence. So, consoling ourselves with +these reflections, we enjoy to the full the pleasure of the company of +kindred spirits, tie flies, grease lines, and fettle up rods generally, +yarn away our fishermen's tales, drink nightly the toast of "Rain, and +lots of it," and retire at night, confident, despite all, of the morrow. + +Perchance your next holiday up North you may find your pet river in +sullen, heavy flood, the skies pouring down upon the devoted hills a +constant deluge. Each day you mark on the river bank the water level, +only to find your mark submerged the next day. Supposing even it were +to stop now. Could the river fine down sufficiently before the end of +your stay to enable you to have a glimmering hope of a fish? It is +possible, but doubtful. Next day's deluge settles the matter, and you +are done. But still, it is a poor heart that never rejoices. Next +time, after such a run of bad luck, you are bound to have an innings. +Men who have the instincts of sportsmen and who deserve the name have +a marvellous power of rising superior to adverse circumstances, and +consequently get their reward, whilst the dead-hearted give it up +as a bad job. Come good or bad luck, let your heart be in the right +place. You will be able to extract from either much enjoyment and some +experience, and will be just as keen to take the luck that comes the +very next opportunity you get of testing it. + +[Illustration] + + + + +CHAPTER XIX. + +SEA TROUT FISHING AND ITS CHANCES. + + +FOR his size and weight there is no more sporting fish in the wide +world than the sea trout. His play when hooked is so full of vivacity, +so strenuous, you never know what he is going to do next. Half the time +of the contest he spends out of the water in the air. He rushes hither +and thither in the most unexpected manner, and having no particular +stronghold or shelter to make for, such as his cousins, the brown +trout, possess in their rivers, he tries by resourceful activity to rid +himself of the irksome restraint of the rod and line. His rise, too, is +so determined and so dashing--no quiet sucking down of a dun without +much perceptible body movement, but rather a rapid dash to secure an +article of food before his comrades can get it. Not much need to strike +with him; he hooks himself pretty effectually by his own efforts. Given +a single-handed split cane rod, fine tackle, and plenty of fresh run +sea trout in a Highland river, and you have the prospect of as good a +day's sport as any you ever enjoyed. You never know what the next cast +will produce; it may be a half-pounder or something twelve times as big. + +The worst of sea trout, from the angler's point of view, is that they +are rather gregarious and keep in shoals; they are always anxious to +move up to the still deeps they love so well, and you may just miss the +shoal--they may be just above your water. But if you do happen to hit +them off, you will have no reason to regret it. Not many seasons ago I +was invited by a friend to shoot with him on one of the many Western +islands near Mull. Just before I reached the lodge, in my somewhat long +drive up from the landing place, I met my friend, rod in hand, by a +deep-looking, leg-of-mutton-shaped pool where his stream found its +outlet into the brackish waters of the arm of the sea that looked like +a land-locked loch. + +"Get out of the trap; I've got a treat for you," were his first words +of greeting; and then he explained that they had had, the evening +before, the first run of the sea trout, and that, standing on a little +rock in the brackish water, he had caught quantities of fine fish. +Nothing loth to stretch my arms and legs, I took the proffered rod +with many thanks, and fished the pool down carefully without a rise +of any kind, or a sign of a fish. Putting on another fly, I tried it +down again, and also the brackish water at its mouth, with similar +results. My friend had foreborne to throw a fly on it until my arrival, +and so he chaffed me unmercifully at my want of success after the +extraordinary sport he had experienced the afternoon before. I told him +that I did not believe there was a trout in the water, and as he had +the netting rights, and had come down in the boat with the nets in it, +we carefully netted the pool. My host was so convinced that the sea +trout were there, that he offered to bet me any odds against a blank +draw. He would, however, have lost had I taken his bet, for sure enough +there was not a single fish in the whole pool. Whilst I made my way up +to the lodge, he went up to try some of the higher pools, but not a +rise did he get. The whole big run, shoal like, had run clean up into a +small lochan, of which his stream was the outlet. + +But when you happen to find them just in the right place, where you +are, then you may congratulate yourself, if you have not too big a +rod with you, for half the pleasure of angling is to suit your rod +and tackle to the river and the fish. It is giving the show away and +discounting half your sport to be "over-rodded." To fish, for instance, +in the upper beats of, say, the Helmsdale, in Sutherland, with an 18 +ft. rod is absurd. A 16 ft. or 14 ft. grilse rod will enable you to +cover the water well, and the sport you will get from the 9 lb. to +14 lb. salmon in the well-stocked river will be greatly enhanced. A +powerful 18 ft. Castleconnel will choke the fish unadvisedly. You might +as well use a sledge hammer to crack an egg. So, too, with sea trout, +a 14 ft. double-handed rod robs you of the better part of the sport +and gives you no real satisfaction. On the other hand, if, as you may +well do, you happen to get into a grilse or small salmon with your +small rod and forty yards of line, then the sport you get will be worth +living for, and will often recur to your remembrance in after times. +You will need all your knowledge and resource not to be broken; you +will in all probability have no gaff with you, and will have to tail +him out, or, better still, persuade him to kick himself ashore on a +shelving beach when played out. And it is extraordinary how little +pressure of the rod is needed in such cases to keep his head the right +way, and each kick and wriggle sends him further up the beach. Then +getting between him and the river, having laid down your rod, you can +put him out of his misery and despatch him. + +A few seasons ago, when grouse shooting in the North, I was kindly +given an opportunity to fish the Glentana beats of the Dee. The river +was low, and as it was then early September, what fish were up were +red and ugly, but a change to the river side was welcome, and I had +never seen the pools in that part of the water. So, donning my waders, +I took with me a 10 ft. 6 in. rod, cane-built, by Walbran, some light +grilse and trout casts, and the smallest grilse flies I had by me. I +also fortunately put in my bag a small box of Test flies. Nothing had +been done for days in any of the Ballater waters, or indeed in any +part of that brawling river Dee. The few anglers who had gone out had +religiously kept to the orthodox salmon rod, salmon gut, and big flies, +and had caught nothing. When I got out of the dogcart and put up my +little rod I noticed a smile upon the river keeper's face, but nothing +daunted thereby, I followed him down the slopes to a beautiful pool +below. + +I put on a baby Jock Scott, and fished the pool most carefully. At +the tail of the pool a big red fish gave a sullen kind of plunge, but +not at my fly, for it was not near him at the time. I put the Jock +Scott over him without result, and then tried him with a tiny Silver +Doctor; but he ignored that also; and so I wandered down from pool to +pool, learning a good deal of the river bed, owing to the lowness of +the water. After a bit, I saw what I took to be the rise of a trout on +the far side, so taking off my "Doctor," I opened my Test fly box and +examined its contents. I hit off a gold-ribbed hare's ear, dressed on +a 00 hook, which I thought might do, and wading out, had to make my +little rod do all it could to reach the required spot. I fished the +water above first, in order to soak my fly and make it sink. When I +reached the place where I thought I had seen the rise, I fished with +more care, and soon as my fly was working round below me, I felt a +vigorous tug; something had taken it under water without showing. I +was soon convinced that it was no trout that had laid hold, and got +ashore as quickly as I could, but I had only forty yards of line and a +little backing, so was soon compelled to take to the water again, as +my fish was playing sullenly on the far side of the stream. I put on +what pressure I dare in order to get on better terms with him, and this +roused him a bit, for a vigorous run up to the head of the pool nearly +ran my line out, although I was wading as deep as I dared do. My friend +the keeper now became interested, and waded in alongside me. + +Though big, the fish was rather craven-hearted, and I was soon able to +get ashore again. However, his weight was great, and when he got into +the stream down he went into the next pool, I following, rod point up +and reel freely running. There were about forty minutes of this slow +kind of play and several incursions into the water, and then I began +to see my backing on the reel perilously diminishing. The 00 hook, +however, still held well, and at last I had the satisfaction of seeing +the big brute floundering on the surface. The keeper, meanwhile, had +gone lip to the house to get a gaff, and, walking backwards from the +river, I tried to drag the exhausted salmon within his reach; but, +although the rod point was about level with the reel, the dead weight +of the fish was more than I could manage. So my friend the keeper, +deploring the irreparable damage that must have been done to my rod, +waded in, thigh deep, and drove the steel into about as ugly and as red +an old cock fish as I have ever seen. His under jaw was crooked, and +he looked like an evil monster. He weighed just 17½ lb. As soon as the +strain was off my Walbran rod it sprang up as straight and as limber as +ever, to the great astonishment of the keeper, who had, oddly enough, +never come across a rod of that description. Burying our red fish in +the bracken, we went down a bit lower, and, two pools below the house, +got out another cock fish of 10 lb., and returning home secured a third +in the very same pool where I had caught the first; this proved to +be a hen fish of 12 lb. They were all red and ugly, but the last one +was, comparatively speaking, quite passable. As soon as she was gaffed +we looked up the first fish; he had turned quite black, and was a +gruesome sight. So, leaving the three fish with the keeper, to kipper +or do what he liked with, I got into the dogcart and drove home. Of +course, these fish would not have come to the gaff in the way they did +had they been spring fish, or lately arrived in the water; but, all the +circumstances being taken into account, the 21st September, 1900, will +always recur to my mind as a real sporting day. Sundry other salmon has +this little rod accounted for, and it is as true as steel and fit for +any fight. + +Such incidents as these add very materially to the interest of sea +trout fishing, for, as I have said, you never can tell what your next +cast may produce. It is small wonder, therefore, that good sea trout +angling is so eagerly sought after and so hard to get. Your best chance +of getting such sport is to go a bit further afield, to the Shetland +Isles, the Orkneys, or somewhere a little out of the beaten track. + +[Illustration: FINIS] + +[Illustration] + + + + +_L'ENVOI_ + + +_Seasons come and go, each in its turn bringing us nearer to the last, +those that remain for our enjoyment growing steadily and inevitably +fewer. But the instinct of sport, inbred in most of us, dies hard. I, +too, would echo Mr. Sydney Buxton's words, and hope that when my time +comes, and my loved rods hang useless in their cases, Old Charon will +permit me to loiter awhile on the Styx, and cast one last fly on its +dark and turgid waters._ + + + + +ALSO BY THE SAME AUTHOR. + +UNIFORM WITH "CHATS ON ANGLING." + +STALKING SKETCHES. + +With Numerous Illustrations by the Author. + + +CONTENTS. + + I.--INTRODUCTORY CHAPTER. + II.--THE FOREST AND SANCTUARY. + III.--THE STALKER. + IV.--PERSONAL EQUIPMENT. + V.--THE SHOT AND THE GRALLOCH. + VI.--DEER AND THEIR ANTLERS. + VII.--PECULIARITIES OF DEER. + VIII.--HIND SHOOTING. + IX.--DEERHOUNDS AND WOUNDED DEER. + X.--THE SPIRACULA OF DEER. + + +ILLUSTRATIONS. + + OVER THE PASS (Frontispiece). + BY THE LOCH SIDE. + BRINGING HIM IN. + THE POOL IN THE SANCTUARY. + A FAMILY PARTY. + A GOOD REST. + CREEPING DOWN THE HILL. + SPYING. A WET CRAWL. + A DOWN-HILL SHOT. + HEAD OF RED DEER STAG (44 Points). + CURIOUS ONE-HORNED STAG. + DEFIANCE. + THE HUMMEL AND THE HORNED STAG. + SENTINELS OF THE FOREST. + CHILDREN OF THE MIST. + THE LAST ACT. + + +_EXTRACTS FROM PRESS NOTICES._ + +"The book will be found a welcome addition to the sportsman's +library."--_Liverpool Mercury._ + +"The author's full-page illustrations are delightful things--pictures +in the best sense of the word."--_Newcastle Chronicle._ + +"Capt. Hart-Davis's delightfully breezy pages contain, besides a +quantity of advice to novices, and, for that matter, others besides +novices, a number of excellently written accounts of stalks and good +stories of the 'hull.' The writer's pencil sketches add not a little +to the attractiveness of a volume that is sure to take its place +on the shelves of the enthusiastic stalker.... Every page contains +sound and wholesome advice on the sport and everything connected with +it."--_County Gentleman._ + +"The seventeen full-page illustrations are a pleasure to look at, +filled as they are with the very breath and spaciousness of the lonely +haunts of the deer."--_Glasgow Herald._ + +"Such a compleat stalker is Capt. Hart-Davis, and many who +view his hardier craft with scant interest, or even with scant +sympathy, may spend a delightful hour in looking over his admirable +drawings."--_Yorkshire Observer._ + +"The prime essential to make a book worth reading is that the author +should have familiar knowledge of his subject; but when he adds +just that degree of enthusiasm which renders him eloquent as well, +the reader deems himself fortunate. Capt. Hart-Davis, however, adds +a third grace, for he is his own artist likewise, and has drawn a +series of beautiful illustrations, rich in the true atmosphere of the +Highlands."--_Notts Guardian._ + +"Without bringing Landseer into comparison, there are a number of +drawings here, which for their presentment of stag and hind, of +moor and fell, and misty mountain side may fairly be placed against +anything of the kind from the pencils of Ansdell or Frederick +Taylor."--_Bookseller._ + +"One great merit that the book possesses is originality, for although +the subject is by no means new, the author's treatment of it imparts +a freshness which carries the reader from page to page with sustained +interest."--_The Field._ + +"His chapters on 'Personal Equipment' and 'The Shot' are excellent, and +ought to be closely studied by all novices at this sport."--_Sporting +and Dramatic News._ + +"Capt. Hart-Davis deserves thanks not only for what he has written and +sketched, but also for what his book suggests of the sport which holds +the first place in Scotland."--_Land and Water._ + +"The surroundings of stags in the forests of Scotland are excellently +represented in 'Stalking Sketches,' a reprint of articles contributed +to _The Field_, illustrated by the author's drawings, which for the +most part have considerable artistic merit. The articles justify +republication, being pleasantly written and full of sound advice.... +The volume is attractively got up, and should please many besides +deerstalkers."--_Athenæum._ + +"Capt. Hart-Davis has now published in book form his very interesting +series of 'Stalking Sketches' which originally appeared in _The +Field_. The volume is very well illustrated with a number of full-page +original pictures by the author. Everyone interested in our forests and +stalking, whether through the good fortune of personal experience, or +merely through the literature of sport, will welcome these articles in +their present form."--_Dundee Advertiser._ + +"Sportsmen who love the red deer will give a ready welcome to this +readable book. It is on every page lively with the interest born of an +intimate practical knowledge of the sport, and is illustrated by many +drawings, which are not only noticeable from their artistic merits, +but have a didactic value of their own for naturalists and young +sportsmen. The work makes a valuable addition to the literature of its +subject."--_Scotsman._ + + + London: HORACE COX, Windsor House, Bream's Buildings, E.C. + + * * * * * + +Transcriber's Notes: + +Obvious punctuation errors repaired. All weights have a space between +the number and the "lb." This was also done with "ft." and "in." + +Page 56, duplicate word "a" removed from text. Original read (a a +smiling rubicund) + +Page 63, "circumstanses" changed to "circumstances" (upon several +circumstances) + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of Chats on Angling, by H. V. Hart-Davis + +*** END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK 43874 *** |
