diff options
| author | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 05:22:46 -0700 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 05:22:46 -0700 |
| commit | 031c33ea4f3938f536691847cf8319223fbb3016 (patch) | |
| tree | 5059d6ee2e396bd10cf4b5397ae3513e7b904ae9 /old | |
Diffstat (limited to 'old')
| -rw-r--r-- | old/7awae10.txt | 6922 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/7awae10.zip | bin | 0 -> 153822 bytes | |||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/8awae10.txt | 6922 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/8awae10.zip | bin | 0 -> 153939 bytes |
4 files changed, 13844 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/old/7awae10.txt b/old/7awae10.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7494b3e --- /dev/null +++ b/old/7awae10.txt @@ -0,0 +1,6922 @@ +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Appreciations, With An Essay on Style +by Walter Horatio Pater +(#5 in our series by Walter Horatio Pater) + +Copyright laws are changing all over the world, be sure to check +the laws for your country before redistributing these files!!! + +Please take a look at the important information in this header. +We encourage you to keep this file on your own disk, keeping an +electronic path open for the next readers. + +Please do not remove this. + +This should be the first thing seen when anyone opens the book. +Do not change or edit it without written permission. The words +are carefully chosen to provide users with the information they +need about what they can legally do with the texts. + + +**Welcome To The World of Free Plain Vanilla Electronic Texts** + +**Etexts Readable By Both Humans and By Computers, Since 1971** + +*****These Etexts Are Prepared By Thousands of Volunteers!***** + +Information on contacting Project Gutenberg to get Etexts, and +further information is included below, including for donations. + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a 501(c)(3) +organization with EIN [Employee Identification Number] 64-6221541 + +Title: Appreciations, With An Essay on Style + +Author: Walter Horatio Pater + +Release Date: May, 2003 [Etext #4037] +[Yes, we are about one year ahead of schedule] +[The actual date this file first posted = 10/19/01] + +Edition: 10 + +Language: English + +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Appreciations, With An Essay on Style +by Walter Horatio Pater +******This file should be named 7awae10.txt or 7awae10.zip****** + +Corrected EDITIONS of our etexts get a new NUMBER, 7awae11.txt +VERSIONS based on separate sources get new LETTER, 7awae10a.txt + +Produced by Alfred J. Drake, Ph.D. + +Project Gutenberg Etexts are usually created from multiple editions, +all of which are in the Public Domain in the United States, unless a +copyright notice is included. Therefore, we usually do NOT keep any +of these books in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +We are now trying to release all our books one year in advance +of the official release dates, leaving time for better editing. +Please be encouraged to send us error messages even years after +the official publication date. + +Please note neither this listing nor its contents are final til +midnight of the last day of the month of any such announcement. +The official release date of all Project Gutenberg Etexts is at +Midnight, Central Time, of the last day of the stated month. A +preliminary version may often be posted for suggestion, comment +and editing by those who wish to do so. + +Most people start at our sites at: +http://gutenberg.net +http://promo.net/pg + + +Those of you who want to download any Etext before announcement +can surf to them as follows, and just download by date; this is +also a good way to get them instantly upon announcement, as the +indexes our cataloguers produce obviously take a while after an +announcement goes out in the Project Gutenberg Newsletter. + +http://www.ibiblio.org/gutenberg/etext03 +or +ftp://ftp.ibiblio.org/pub/docs/books/gutenberg/etext03 + +Or /etext02, 01, 00, 99, 98, 97, 96, 95, 94, 93, 92, 92, 91 or 90 + +Just search by the first five letters of the filename you want, +as it appears in our Newsletters. + + +Information about Project Gutenberg (one page) + +We produce about two million dollars for each hour we work. The +time it takes us, a rather conservative estimate, is fifty hours +to get any etext selected, entered, proofread, edited, copyright +searched and analyzed, the copyright letters written, etc. This +projected audience is one hundred million readers. If our value +per text is nominally estimated at one dollar then we produce $2 +million dollars per hour this year as we release fifty new Etext +files per month, or 500 more Etexts in 2000 for a total of 3000+ +If they reach just 1-2% of the world's population then the total +should reach over 300 billion Etexts given away by year's end. + +The Goal of Project Gutenberg is to Give Away One Trillion Etext +Files by December 31, 2001. [10,000 x 100,000,000 = 1 Trillion] +This is ten thousand titles each to one hundred million readers, +which is only about 4% of the present number of computer users. + +At our revised rates of production, we will reach only one-third +of that goal by the end of 2001, or about 4,000 Etexts unless we +manage to get some real funding. + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation has been created +to secure a future for Project Gutenberg into the next millennium. + +We need your donations more than ever! + +As of July 12, 2001 contributions are only being solicited from people in: +Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, +Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, +Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, New Mexico, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, North +Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, +Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, +Wisconsin, and Wyoming. + +We have filed in about 45 states now, but these are the only ones +that have responded. + +As the requirements for other states are met, +additions to this list will be made and fund raising +will begin in the additional states. Please feel +free to ask to check the status of your state. + +In answer to various questions we have received on this: + +We are constantly working on finishing the paperwork +to legally request donations in all 50 states. If +your state is not listed and you would like to know +if we have added it since the list you have, just ask. + +While we cannot solicit donations from people in +states where we are not yet registered, we know +of no prohibition against accepting donations +from donors in these states who approach us with +an offer to donate. + + +International donations are accepted, +but we don't know ANYTHING about how +to make them tax-deductible, or +even if they CAN be made deductible, +and don't have the staff to handle it +even if there are ways. + +All donations should be made to: + +Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +PMB 113 +1739 University Ave. +Oxford, MS 38655-4109 + + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a 501(c)(3) +organization with EIN [Employee Identification Number] 64-6221541, +and has been approved as a 501(c)(3) organization by the US Internal +Revenue Service (IRS). Donations are tax-deductible to the maximum +extent permitted by law. As the requirements for other states are met, +additions to this list will be made and fund raising will begin in the +additional states. + +We need your donations more than ever! + +You can get up to date donation information at: + +http://www.gutenberg.net/donation.html + + +*** + +If you can't reach Project Gutenberg, +you can always email directly to: + +Michael S. Hart <hart@pobox.com> + +hart@pobox.com forwards to hart@prairienet.org and archive.org +if your mail bounces from archive.org, I will still see it, if +it bounces from prairienet.org, better resend later on. . . . + +Prof. Hart will answer or forward your message. + +We would prefer to send you information by email. + + +*** + + +Example command-line FTP session: + +ftp ftp.ibiblio.org +login: anonymous +password: your@login +cd pub/docs/books/gutenberg +cd etext90 through etext99 or etext00 through etext02, etc. +dir [to see files] +get or mget [to get files. . .set bin for zip files] +GET GUTINDEX.?? [to get a year's listing of books, e.g., GUTINDEX.99] +GET GUTINDEX.ALL [to get a listing of ALL books] + + +**The Legal Small Print** + + +(Three Pages) + +***START**THE SMALL PRINT!**FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN ETEXTS**START*** +Why is this "Small Print!" statement here? You know: lawyers. +They tell us you might sue us if there is something wrong with +your copy of this etext, even if you got it for free from +someone other than us, and even if what's wrong is not our +fault. So, among other things, this "Small Print!" statement +disclaims most of our liability to you. It also tells you how +you may distribute copies of this etext if you want to. + +*BEFORE!* YOU USE OR READ THIS ETEXT +By using or reading any part of this PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm +etext, you indicate that you understand, agree to and accept +this "Small Print!" statement. If you do not, you can receive +a refund of the money (if any) you paid for this etext by +sending a request within 30 days of receiving it to the person +you got it from. If you received this etext on a physical +medium (such as a disk), you must return it with your request. + +ABOUT PROJECT GUTENBERG-TM ETEXTS +This PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm etext, like most PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm etexts, +is a "public domain" work distributed by Professor Michael S. Hart +through the Project Gutenberg Association (the "Project"). +Among other things, this means that no one owns a United States copyright +on or for this work, so the Project (and you!) can copy and +distribute it in the United States without permission and +without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, set forth +below, apply if you wish to copy and distribute this etext +under the "PROJECT GUTENBERG" trademark. + +Please do not use the "PROJECT GUTENBERG" trademark to market +any commercial products without permission. + +To create these etexts, the Project expends considerable +efforts to identify, transcribe and proofread public domain +works. Despite these efforts, the Project's etexts and any +medium they may be on may contain "Defects". Among other +things, Defects may take the form of incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other +intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged +disk or other etext medium, a computer virus, or computer +codes that damage or cannot be read by your equipment. + +LIMITED WARRANTY; DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES +But for the "Right of Replacement or Refund" described below, +[1] Michael Hart and the Foundation (and any other party you may +receive this etext from as a PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm etext) disclaims +all liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including +legal fees, and [2] YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE OR +UNDER STRICT LIABILITY, OR FOR BREACH OF WARRANTY OR CONTRACT, +INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE +OR INCIDENTAL DAMAGES, EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE +POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES. + +If you discover a Defect in this etext within 90 days of +receiving it, you can receive a refund of the money (if any) +you paid for it by sending an explanatory note within that +time to the person you received it from. If you received it +on a physical medium, you must return it with your note, and +such person may choose to alternatively give you a replacement +copy. If you received it electronically, such person may +choose to alternatively give you a second opportunity to +receive it electronically. + +THIS ETEXT IS OTHERWISE PROVIDED TO YOU "AS-IS". NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, ARE MADE TO YOU AS +TO THE ETEXT OR ANY MEDIUM IT MAY BE ON, INCLUDING BUT NOT +LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A +PARTICULAR PURPOSE. + +Some states do not allow disclaimers of implied warranties or +the exclusion or limitation of consequential damages, so the +above disclaimers and exclusions may not apply to you, and you +may have other legal rights. + +INDEMNITY +You will indemnify and hold Michael Hart, the Foundation, +and its trustees and agents, and any volunteers associated +with the production and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm +texts harmless, from all liability, cost and expense, including +legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of the +following that you do or cause: [1] distribution of this etext, +[2] alteration, modification, or addition to the etext, +or [3] any Defect. + +DISTRIBUTION UNDER "PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm" +You may distribute copies of this etext electronically, or by +disk, book or any other medium if you either delete this +"Small Print!" and all other references to Project Gutenberg, +or: + +[1] Only give exact copies of it. Among other things, this + requires that you do not remove, alter or modify the + etext or this "small print!" statement. You may however, + if you wish, distribute this etext in machine readable + binary, compressed, mark-up, or proprietary form, + including any form resulting from conversion by word + processing or hypertext software, but only so long as + *EITHER*: + + [*] The etext, when displayed, is clearly readable, and + does *not* contain characters other than those + intended by the author of the work, although tilde + (~), asterisk (*) and underline (_) characters may + be used to convey punctuation intended by the + author, and additional characters may be used to + indicate hypertext links; OR + + [*] The etext may be readily converted by the reader at + no expense into plain ASCII, EBCDIC or equivalent + form by the program that displays the etext (as is + the case, for instance, with most word processors); + OR + + [*] You provide, or agree to also provide on request at + no additional cost, fee or expense, a copy of the + etext in its original plain ASCII form (or in EBCDIC + or other equivalent proprietary form). + +[2] Honor the etext refund and replacement provisions of this + "Small Print!" statement. + +[3] Pay a trademark license fee to the Foundation of 20% of the + gross profits you derive calculated using the method you + already use to calculate your applicable taxes. If you + don't derive profits, no royalty is due. Royalties are + payable to "Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation" + the 60 days following each date you prepare (or were + legally required to prepare) your annual (or equivalent + periodic) tax return. Please contact us beforehand to + let us know your plans and to work out the details. + +WHAT IF YOU *WANT* TO SEND MONEY EVEN IF YOU DON'T HAVE TO? +Project Gutenberg is dedicated to increasing the number of +public domain and licensed works that can be freely distributed +in machine readable form. + +The Project gratefully accepts contributions of money, time, +public domain materials, or royalty free copyright licenses. +Money should be paid to the: +"Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +If you are interested in contributing scanning equipment or +software or other items, please contact Michael Hart at: +hart@pobox.com + +[Portions of this header are copyright (C) 2001 by Michael S. Hart +and may be reprinted only when these Etexts are free of all fees.] +[Project Gutenberg is a TradeMark and may not be used in any sales +of Project Gutenberg Etexts or other materials be they hardware or +software or any other related product without express permission.] + +*END THE SMALL PRINT! FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN ETEXTS*Ver.07/27/01*END* + + + + + + + + + + + +Produced by Alfred J. Drake, Ph.D. + + + + + +APPRECIATIONS, WITH AN ESSAY ON STYLE + +By WALTER HORATIO PATER + +E-text Editor: Alfred J. Drake, Ph.D. +Electronic Version 1.0 / Date 10-12-01 + + +DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES + +[1] I DISCLAIM ALL LIABILITY TO YOU FOR DAMAGES, COSTS AND EXPENSES, +INCLUDING LEGAL FEES, AND + +[2] YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE OR UNDER STRICT LIABILITY, OR +FOR BREACH OF WARRANTY OR CONTRACT, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR INCIDENTAL DAMAGES, EVEN IF YOU +GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES. + +THE E-TEXTS ON THIS SITE ARE PROVIDED TO YOU "AS-IS". NO WARRANTIES +OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, ARE MADE TO YOU AS TO THE E-TEXTS OR +ANY MEDIUM THEY MAY BE ON, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF +MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. + +Some states do not allow disclaimers of implied warranties or the +exclusion or limitation of consequential damages, so the above +disclaimers and exclusions may not apply to you, and you may have +other legal rights. + + + +APPRECIATIONS, WITH AN ESSAY ON STYLE + + +NOTES BY THE E-TEXT EDITOR: + +Reliability: Although I have done my best to ensure that the text +you read is error-free in comparison with an exact reprint of the +standard edition--Macmillan's 1910 Library Edition--please exercise +scholarly caution in using it. It is not intended as a substitute +for the printed original but rather as a searchable supplement. +My e-texts may prove convenient substitutes for hard-to-get works in +a course where both instructor and students accept the possibility +of some imperfections in the text, but if you are writing a scholarly +article, dissertation, or book, you should use the standard hard- +copy editions of any works you cite. + +Pagination and Paragraphing: To avoid an unwieldy electronic copy, +I have transferred original pagination to brackets. A bracketed +numeral such as [22] indicates that the material immediately +following the number marks the beginning of the relevant page. I +have preserved paragraph structure except for first-line indentation. + +Hyphenation: I have not preserved original hyphenation since an +e-text does not require line-end or page-end hyphenation. + +Greek typeface: For this full-text edition, I have transliterated +Pater's Greek quotations. If there is a need for the original Greek, +it can be viewed at my site, http://www.ajdrake.com/etexts, a +Victorianist archive that contains the complete works of Walter Pater +and many other nineteenth-century texts, mostly in first editions. + + +CONTENTS + +Style: 5-38 + +Wordsworth: 39-64 + +Coleridge: 65-104 + +Charles Lamb: 105-123 + +Sir Thomas Browne: 124-160 + +"Love's Labours Lost": 161-169 + +"Measure for Measure": 170-184 + +Shakespeare's English Kings: 185-204 + +Dante Gabriel Rossetti: 205-218 + +Feuillet's "La Morte": 219-240 + +Postscript: 241-261 + + + +APPRECIATIONS + + +STYLE + +[5] SINCE all progress of mind consists for the most part in +differentiation, in the resolution of an obscure and complex object +into its component aspects, it is surely the stupidest of losses to +confuse things which right reason has put asunder, to lose the sense +of achieved distinctions, the distinction between poetry and prose, +for instance, or, to speak more exactly, between the laws and +characteristic excellences of verse and prose composition. On the +other hand, those who have dwelt most emphatically on the distinction +between prose and verse, prose and poetry, may sometimes have been +tempted to limit the proper functions of prose too narrowly; and this +again is at least false economy, as being, in effect, the +renunciation of a certain means or faculty, in a world where after +all we must needs make the most of things. Critical efforts to limit +art a priori, by anticipations regarding the natural incapacity of +the material with which this or that artist works, as the sculptor +with solid form, or the prose-writer with the ordinary [6] language +of men, are always liable to be discredited by the facts of artistic +production; and while prose is actually found to be a coloured thing +with Bacon, picturesque with Livy and Carlyle, musical with Cicero +and Newman, mystical and intimate with Plato and Michelet and Sir +Thomas Browne, exalted or florid, it may be, with Milton and Taylor, +it will be useless to protest that it can be nothing at all, except +something very tamely and narrowly confined to mainly practical ends- +-a kind of "good round-hand;" as useless as the protest that poetry +might not touch prosaic subjects as with Wordsworth, or an abstruse +matter as with Browning, or treat contemporary life nobly as with +Tennyson. In subordination to one essential beauty in all good +literary style, in all literature as a fine art, as there are many +beauties of poetry so the beauties of prose are many, and it is the +business of criticism to estimate them as such; as it is good in the +criticism of verse to look for those hard, logical, and quasi-prosaic +excellences which that too has, or needs. To find in the poem, amid +the flowers, the allusions, the mixed perspectives, of Lycidas for +instance, the thought, the logical structure:--how wholesome! how +delightful! as to identify in prose what we call the poetry, the +imaginative power, not treating it as out of place and a kind of +vagrant intruder, but by way of an estimate of its rights, that is, +of its achieved powers, there. + +[7] Dryden, with the characteristic instinct of his age, loved to +emphasise the distinction between poetry and prose, the protest +against their confusion with each other, coming with somewhat +diminished effect from one whose poetry was so prosaic. In truth, +his sense of prosaic excellence affected his verse rather than his +prose, which is not only fervid, richly figured, poetic, as we say, +but vitiated, all unconsciously, by many a scanning line. Setting up +correctness, that humble merit of prose, as the central literary +excellence, he is really a less correct writer than he may seem, +still with an imperfect mastery of the relative pronoun. It might +have been foreseen that, in the rotations of mind, the province of +poetry in prose would find its assertor; and, a century after Dryden, +amid very different intellectual needs, and with the need therefore +of great modifications in literary form, the range of the poetic +force in literature was effectively enlarged by Wordsworth. The true +distinction between prose and poetry he regarded as the almost +technical or accidental one of the absence or presence of metrical +beauty, or, say! metrical restraint; and for him the opposition came +to be between verse and prose of course; but, as the essential +dichotomy in this matter, between imaginative and unimaginative +writing, parallel to De Quincey's distinction between "the literature +of power and the literature of knowledge," in the former of which the +composer gives us [8] not fact, but his peculiar sense of fact, +whether past or present. + +Dismissing then, under sanction of Wordsworth, that harsher +opposition of poetry to prose, as savouring in fact of the arbitrary +psychology of the last century, and with it the prejudice that there +can be but one only beauty of prose style, I propose here to point +out certain qualities of all literature as a fine art, which, if they +apply to the literature of fact, apply still more to the literature +of the imaginative sense of fact, while they apply indifferently to +verse and prose, so far as either is really imaginative--certain +conditions of true art in both alike, which conditions may also +contain in them the secret of the proper discrimination and +guardianship of the peculiar excellences of either. + +The line between fact and something quite different from external +fact is, indeed, hard to draw. In Pascal, for instance, in the +persuasive writers generally, how difficult to define the point +where, from time to time, argument which, if it is to be worth +anything at all, must consist of facts or groups of facts, becomes a +pleading--a theorem no longer, but essentially an appeal to the +reader to catch the writer's spirit, to think with him, if one can or +will--an expression no longer of fact but of his sense of it, his +peculiar intuition of a world, prospective, or discerned below the +faulty conditions of the present, in either case changed somewhat +from the actual [9] world. In science, on the other hand, in history +so far as it conforms to scientific rule, we have a literary domain +where the imagination may be thought to be always an intruder. And +as, in all science, the functions of literature reduce themselves +eventually to the transcribing of fact, so all the excellences of +literary form in regard to science are reducible to various kinds of +pains-taking; this good quality being involved in all "skilled work" +whatever, in the drafting of an act of parliament, as in sewing. Yet +here again, the writer's sense of fact, in history especially, and in +all those complex subjects which do but lie on the borders of +science, will still take the place of fact, in various degrees. Your +historian, for instance, with absolutely truthful intention, amid the +multitude of facts presented to him must needs select, and in +selecting assert something of his own humour, something that comes +not of the world without but of a vision within. So Gibbon moulds +his unwieldy material to a preconceived view. Livy, Tacitus, +Michelet, moving full of poignant sensibility amid the records of the +past, each, after his own sense, modifies--who can tell where and to +what degree?--and becomes something else than a transcriber; each, as +he thus modifies, passing into the domain of art proper. For just in +proportion as the writer's aim, consciously or unconsciously, comes +to be the transcribing, not of the world, not of mere fact, but of +his sense [10] of it, he becomes an artist, his work fine art; and +good art (as I hope ultimately to show) in proportion to the truth of +his presentment of that sense; as in those humbler or plainer +functions of literature also, truth--truth to bare fact, there--is +the essence of such artistic quality as they may have. Truth! there +can be no merit, no craft at all, without that. And further, all +beauty is in the long run only fineness of truth, or what we call +expression, the finer accommodation of speech to that vision within. + +--The transcript of his sense of fact rather than the fact, as being +preferable, pleasanter, more beautiful to the writer himself. In +literature, as in every other product of human skill, in the moulding +of a bell or a platter for instance, wherever this sense asserts +itself, wherever the producer so modifies his work as, over and above +its primary use or intention, to make it pleasing (to himself, of +course, in the first instance) there, "fine" as opposed to merely +serviceable art, exists. Literary art, that is, like all art which +is in any way imitative or reproductive of fact--form, or colour, or +incident--is the representation of such fact as connected with soul, +of a specific personality, in its preferences, its volition and +power. + +Such is the matter of imaginative or artistic literature--this +transcript, not of mere fact, but of fact in its infinite variety, as +modified by human preference in all its infinitely varied [11] forms. +It will be good literary art not because it is brilliant or sober, or +rich, or impulsive, or severe, but just in proportion as its +representation of that sense, that soul-fact, is true, verse being +only one department of such literature, and imaginative prose, it may +be thought, being the special art of the modern world. That +imaginative prose should be the special and opportune art of the +modern world results from two important facts about the latter: +first, the chaotic variety and complexity of its interests, making +the intellectual issue, the really master currents of the present +time incalculable--a condition of mind little susceptible of the +restraint proper to verse form, so that the most characteristic verse +of the nineteenth century has been lawless verse; and secondly, an +all-pervading naturalism, a curiosity about everything whatever as it +really is, involving a certain humility of attitude, cognate to what +must, after all, be the less ambitious form of literature. And prose +thus asserting itself as the special and privileged artistic faculty +of the present day, will be, however critics may try to narrow its +scope, as varied in its excellence as humanity itself reflecting on +the facts of its latest experience--an instrument of many stops, +meditative, observant, descriptive, eloquent, analytic, plaintive, +fervid. Its beauties will be not exclusively "pedestrian": it will +exert, in due measure, all the varied charms of poetry, down to the +rhythm which, as in Cicero, [12] or Michelet, or Newman, at their +best, gives its musical value to every syllable.* + +The literary artist is of necessity a scholar, and in what he . +proposes to do will have in mind, first of all, the scholar and the +scholarly conscience--the male conscience in this matter, as we must +think it, under a system of education which still to so large an +extent limits real scholarship to men. In his self-criticism, he +supposes always that sort of reader who will go (full of eyes) +warily, considerately, though without consideration for him, over the +ground which the female conscience traverses so lightly, so amiably. +For the material in which he works is no more a creation of his own +than the sculptor's marble. Product of a myriad various minds and +contending tongues, compact of obscure and minute association, a +language has its own abundant and often recondite laws, in the +habitual and summary recognition of which scholarship consists. A +writer, full of a matter he is before all things anxious to express, +may think of those laws, the limitations of vocabulary, structure, +and the like, as a restriction, but if a [13] real artist will find +in them an opportunity. His punctilious observance of the proprieties +of his medium will diffuse through all he writes a general air of +sensibility, of refined usage. Exclusiones debitae--the exclusions, +or rejections, which nature demands--we know how large a part these +play, according to Bacon, in the science of nature. In a somewhat +changed sense, we might say that the art of the scholar is summed up +in the observance of those rejections demanded by the nature of his +medium, the material he must use. Alive to the value of an +atmosphere in which every term finds its utmost degree of expression, +and with all the jealousy of a lover of words, he will resist a +constant tendency on the part of the majority of those who use them +to efface the distinctions of language, the facility of writers often +reinforcing in this respect the work of the vulgar. He will feel the +obligation not of the laws only, but of those affinities, avoidances, +those mere preferences, of his language, which through the +associations of literary history have become a part of its nature, +prescribing the rejection of many a neology, many a license, many a +gipsy phrase which might present itself as actually expressive. His +appeal, again, is to the scholar, who has great experience in +literature, and will show no favour to short-cuts, or hackneyed +illustration, or an affectation of learning designed for the +unlearned. Hence a contention, a sense [14] of self-restraint and +renunciation, having for the susceptible reader the effect of a +challenge for minute consideration; the attention of the writer, in +every minutest detail, being a pledge that it is worth the reader's +while to be attentive too, that the writer is dealing scrupulously +with his instrument, and therefore, indirectly, with the reader +himself also, that he has the science of the instrument he plays on, +perhaps, after all, with a freedom which in such case will be the +freedom of a master. + +For meanwhile, braced only by those restraints, he is really +vindicating his liberty in the making of a vocabulary, an entire +system of composition, for himself, his own true manner; and when we +speak of the manner of a true master we mean what is essential in his +art. Pedantry being only the scholarship of le cuistre (we have no +English equivalent) he is no pedant, and does but show his +intelligence of the rules of language in his freedoms with it, +addition or expansion, which like the spontaneities of manner in a +well-bred person will still further illustrate good taste.--The right +vocabulary! Translators have not invariably seen how all-important +that is in the work of translation, driving for the most part at +idiom or construction; whereas, if the original be first-rate, one's +first care should be with its elementary particles, Plato, for +instance, being often reproducible by an exact following, with no +variation in structure, of word after word, as [15] the pencil +follows a drawing under tracing-paper, so only each word or syllable +be not of false colour, to change my illustration a little. + +Well! that is because any writer worth translating at all has +winnowed and searched through his vocabulary, is conscious of the +words he would select in systematic reading of a dictionary, and +still more of the words he would reject were the dictionary other +than Johnson's; and doing this with his peculiar sense of the world +ever in view, in search of an instrument for the adequate expression +of that, he begets a vocabulary faithful to the colouring of his own +spirit, and in the strictest sense original. That living authority +which language needs lies, in truth, in its scholars, who recognising +always that every language possesses a genius, a very fastidious +genius, of its own, expand at once and purify its very elements, +which must needs change along with the changing thoughts of living +people. Ninety years ago, for instance, great mental force, +certainly, was needed by Wordsworth, to break through the consecrated +poetic associations of a century, and speak the language that was +his, that was to become in a measure the language of the next +generation. But he did it with the tact of a scholar also. English, +for a quarter of a century past, has been assimilating the +phraseology of pictorial art; for half a century, the phraseology of +the great German metaphysical movement of eighty years ago; in part +also the [16] language of mystical theology: and none but pedants +will regret a great consequent increase of its resources. For many +years to come its enterprise may well lie in the naturalisation of +the vocabulary of science, so only it be under the eye of a sensitive +scholarship--in a liberal naturalisation of the ideas of science too, +for after all the chief stimulus of good style is to possess a full, +rich, complex matter to grapple with. The literary artist, +therefore, will be well aware of physical science; science also +attaining, in its turn, its true literary ideal. And then, as the +scholar is nothing without the historic sense, he will be apt to +restore not really obsolete or really worn-out words, but the finer +edge of words still in use: ascertain, communicate, discover--words +like these it has been part of our "business" to misuse. And still, +as language was made for man, he will be no authority for +correctnesses which, limiting freedom of utterance, were yet but +accidents in their origin; as if one vowed not to say "its," which +ought to have been in Shakespeare; "his" "hers," for inanimate +objects, being but a barbarous and really inexpressive survival. Yet +we have known many things like this. Racy Saxon monosyllables, close +to us as touch and sight, he will intermix readily with those long, +savoursome, Latin words, rich in "second intention." In this late +day certainly, no critical process can be conducted reasonably +without eclecticism. Of [17] such eclecticism we have a justifying +example in one of the first poets of our time. How illustrative of +monosyllabic effect, of sonorous Latin, of the phraseology of +science, of metaphysic, of colloquialism even, are the writings of +Tennyson; yet with what a fine, fastidious scholarship throughout! + +A scholar writing for the scholarly, he will of course leave +something to the willing intelligence of his reader. "To go preach +to the first passer-by," says Montaigne, "to become tutor to the +ignorance of the first I meet, is a thing I abhor;" a thing, in fact, +naturally distressing to the scholar, who will therefore ever be shy +of offering uncomplimentary assistance to the reader's wit. To +really strenuous minds there is a pleasurable stimulus in the +challenge for a continuous effort on their part, to be rewarded by +securer and more intimate grasp of the author's sense. Self- +restraint, a skilful economy of means, ascesis, that too has a beauty +of its own; and for the reader supposed there will be an aesthetic +satisfaction in that frugal closeness of style which makes the most +of a word, in the exaction from every sentence of a precise relief, +in the just spacing out of word to thought, in the logically filled +space connected always with the delightful sense of difficulty +overcome. + +Different classes of persons, at different times, make, of course, +very various demands upon literature. Still, scholars, I suppose, +and not [18] only scholars, but all disinterested lovers of books, +will always look to it, as to all other fine art, for a refuge, a +sort of cloistral refuge, from a certain vulgarity in the actual +world. A perfect poem like Lycidas, a perfect fiction like Esmond, +the perfect handling of a theory like Newman's Idea of a University, +has for them something of the uses of a religious "retreat." Here, +then, with a view to the central need of a select few, those "men of +a finer thread" who have formed and maintain the literary ideal, +everything, every component element, will have undergone exact trial, +and, above all, there will be no uncharacteristic or tarnished or +vulgar decoration, permissible ornament being for the most part +structural, or necessary. As the painter in his picture, so the +artist in his book, aims at the production by honourable artifice of +a peculiar atmosphere. "The artist," says Schiller, "may be known +rather by what he omits"; and in literature, too, the true artist may +be best recognised by his tact of omission. For to the grave reader +words too are grave; and the ornamental word, the figure, the +accessory form or colour or reference, is rarely content to die to +thought precisely at the right moment, but will inevitably linger +awhile, stirring a long "brain-wave" behind it of perhaps quite alien +associations. + +Just there, it may be, is the detrimental tendency of the sort of +scholarly attentiveness [19] of mind I am recommending. But the true +artist allows for it. He will remember that, as the very word +ornament indicates what is in itself non-essential, so the "one +beauty" of all literary style is of its very essence, and +independent, in prose and verse alike, of all removable decoration; +that it may exist in its fullest lustre, as in Flaubert's Madame +Bovary, for instance, or in Stendhal's Le Rouge et Le Noir, in a +composition utterly unadorned, with hardly a single suggestion of +visibly beautiful things. Parallel, allusion, the allusive way +generally, the flowers in the garden:--he knows the narcotic force of +these upon the negligent intelligence to which any diversion, +literally, is welcome, any vagrant intruder, because one can go +wandering away with it from the immediate subject. Jealous, if he +have a really quickening motive within, of all that does not hold +directly to that, of the facile, the otiose, he will never depart +from the strictly pedestrian process, unless he gains a ponderable +something thereby. Even assured of its congruity, he will still +question its serviceableness. Is it worth while, can we afford, to +attend to just that, to just that figure or literary reference, just +then?--Surplusage! he will dread that, as the runner on his muscles. +For in truth all art does but consist in the removal of surplusage, +from the last finish of the gem-engraver blowing away the last +particle of invisible dust, back to the earliest divination of [20] +the finished work to be, lying somewhere, according to Michelangelo's +fancy, in the rough-hewn block of stone. + +And what applies to figure or flower must be understood of all other +accidental or removable ornaments of writing whatever; and not of +specific ornament only, but of all that latent colour and imagery +which language as such carries in it. A lover of words for their own +sake, to whom nothing about them is unimportant, a minute and +constant observer of their physiognomy, he will be on the alert not +only for obviously mixed metaphors of course, but for the metaphor +that is mixed in all our speech, though a rapid use may involve no +cognition of it. Currently recognising the incident, the colour, the +physical elements or particles in words like absorb, consider, +extract, to take the first that occur, he will avail himself of them, +as further adding to the resources of expression. The elementary +particles of language will be realised as colour and light and shade +through his scholarly living in the full sense of them. Still +opposing the constant degradation of language by those who use it +carelessly, he will not treat coloured glass as if it were clear; and +while half the world is using figure unconsciously, will be fully +aware not only of all that latent figurative texture in speech, but +of the vague, lazy, half-formed personification--a rhetoric, +depressing, and worse than nothing, [21] because it has no really +rhetorical motive--which plays so large a part there, and, as in the +case of more ostentatious ornament, scrupulously exact of it, from +syllable to syllable, its precise value. + +So far I have been speaking of certain conditions of the literary art +arising out of the medium or material in or upon which it works, the +essential qualities of language and its aptitudes for contingent +ornamentation, matters which define scholarship as science and good +taste respectively. They are both subservient to a more intimate +quality of good style: more intimate, as coming nearer to the artist +himself. The otiose, the facile, surplusage: why are these abhorrent +to the true literary artist, except because, in literary as in all +other art, structure is all-important, felt, or painfully missed, +everywhere?--that architectural conception of work, which foresees +the end in the beginning and never loses sight of it, and in every +part is conscious of all the rest, till the last sentence does but, +with undiminished vigour, unfold and justify the first--a condition +of literary art, which, in contradistinction to another quality of +the artist himself, to be spoken of later, I shall call the necessity +of mind in style. + +An acute philosophical writer, the late Dean Mansel (a writer whose +works illustrate the literary beauty there may be in closeness, and +with obvious repression or economy of a fine [22] rhetorical gift) +wrote a book, of fascinating precision in a very obscure subject, to +show that all the technical laws of logic are but means of securing, +in each and all of its apprehensions, the unity, the strict identity +with itself, of the apprehending mind. All the laws of good writing +aim at a similar unity or identity of the mind in all the processes +by which the word is associated to its import. The term is right, +and has its essential beauty, when it becomes, in a manner, what it +signifies, as with the names of simple sensations. To give the +phrase, the sentence, the structural member, the entire composition, +song, or essay, a similar unity with its subject and with itself:-- +style is in the right way when it tends towards that. All depends +upon the original unity, the vital wholeness and identity, of the +initiatory apprehension or view. So much is true of all art, which +therefore requires always its logic, its comprehensive reason-- +insight, foresight, retrospect, in simultaneous action--true, most of +all, of the literary art, as being of all the arts most closely +cognate to the abstract intelligence. Such logical coherency may be +evidenced not merely in the lines of composition as a whole, but in +the choice of a single word, while it by no means interferes with, +but may even prescribe, much variety, in the building of the sentence +for instance, or in the manner, argumentative, descriptive, +discursive, of this or that [23] part or member of the entire design. +The blithe, crisp sentence, decisive as a child's expression of its +needs, may alternate with the long-contending, victoriously intricate +sentence; the sentence, born with the integrity of a single word, +relieving the sort of sentence in which, if you look closely, you can +see much contrivance, much adjustment, to bring a highly qualified +matter into compass at one view. For the literary architecture, if +it is to be rich and expressive, involves not only foresight of the +end in the beginning, but also development or growth of design, in +the process of execution, with many irregularities, surprises, and +afterthoughts; the contingent as well as the necessary being subsumed +under the unity of the whole. As truly, to the lack of such +architectural design, of a single, almost visual, image, vigorously +informing an entire, perhaps very intricate, composition, which shall +be austere, ornate, argumentative, fanciful, yet true from first to +last to that vision within, may be attributed those weaknesses of +conscious or unconscious repetition of word, phrase, motive, or +member of the whole matter, indicating, as Flaubert was aware, an +original structure in thought not organically complete. With such +foresight, the actual conclusion will most often get itself written +out of hand, before, in the more obvious sense, the work is finished. +With some strong and leading sense of the world, the [24] tight hold +of which secures true composition and not mere loose accretion, the +literary artist, I suppose, goes on considerately, setting joint to +joint, sustained by yet restraining the productive ardour, retracing +the negligences of his first sketch, repeating his steps only that he +may give the reader a sense of secure and restful progress, +readjusting mere assonances even, that they may soothe the reader, or +at least not interrupt him on his way; and then, somewhere before the +end comes, is burdened, inspired, with his conclusion, and betimes +delivered of it, leaving off, not in weariness and because he finds +himself at an end, but in all the freshness of volition. His work +now structurally complete, with all the accumulating effect of +secondary shades of meaning, he finishes the whole up to the just +proportion of that ante-penultimate conclusion, and all becomes +expressive. The house he has built is rather a body he has informed. +And so it happens, to its greater credit, that the better interest +even of a narrative to be recounted, a story to be told, will often +be in its second reading. And though there are instances of great +writers who have been no artists, an unconscious tact sometimes +directing work in which we may detect, very pleasurably, many of the +effects of conscious art, yet one of the greatest pleasures of really +good prose literature is in the critical tracing out of that +conscious artistic structure, and the pervading sense of it [25] as +we read. Yet of poetic literature too; for, in truth, the kind of +constructive intelligence here supposed is one of the forms of the +imagination. + +That is the special function of mind, in style. Mind and soul:--hard +to ascertain philosophically, the distinction is real enough +practically, for they often interfere, are sometimes in conflict, +with each other. Blake, in the last century, is an instance of +preponderating soul, embarrassed, at a loss, in an era of +preponderating mind. As a quality of style, at all events, soul is a +fact, in certain writers--the way they have of absorbing language, of +attracting it into the peculiar spirit they are of, with a subtlety +which makes the actual result seem like some inexplicable +inspiration. By mind, the literary artist reaches us, through static +and objective indications of design in his work, legible to all. By +soul, he reaches us, somewhat capriciously perhaps, one and not +another, through vagrant sympathy and a kind of immediate contact. +Mind we cannot choose but approve where we recognise it; soul may +repel us, not because we misunderstand it. The way in which +theological interests sometimes avail themselves of language is +perhaps the best illustration of the force I mean to indicate +generally in literature, by the word soul. Ardent religious +persuasion may exist, may make its way, without finding any +equivalent heat in language: or, again, it may enkindle [26] words to +various degrees, and when it really takes hold of them doubles its +force. Religious history presents many remarkable instances in +which, through no mere phrase-worship, an unconscious literary tact +has, for the sensitive, laid open a privileged pathway from one to +another. "The altar-fire," people say, "has touched those lips!" +The Vulgate, the English Bible, the English Prayer-Book, the writings +of Swedenborg, the Tracts for the Times:--there, we have instances of +widely different and largely diffused phases of religious feeling in +operation as soul in style. But something of the same kind acts with +similar power in certain writers of quite other than theological +literature, on behalf of some wholly personal and peculiar sense of +theirs. Most easily illustrated by theological literature, this +quality lends to profane writers a kind of religious influence. At +their best, these writers become, as we say sometimes, "prophets"; +such character depending on the effect not merely of their matter, +but of their matter as allied to, in "electric affinity" with, +peculiar form, and working in all cases by an immediate sympathetic +contact, on which account it is that it may be called soul, as +opposed to mind, in style. And this too is a faculty of choosing and +rejecting what is congruous or otherwise, with a drift towards unity- +-unity of atmosphere here, as there of design--soul securing colour +(or perfume, might [27] we say?) as mind secures form, the latter +being essentially finite, the former vague or infinite, as the +influence of a living person is practically infinite. There are some +to whom nothing has any real interest, or real meaning, except as +operative in a given person; and it is they who best appreciate the +quality of soul in literary art. They seem to know a person, in a +book, and make way by intuition: yet, although they thus enjoy the +completeness of a personal information, it is still a characteristic +of soul, in this sense of the word, that it does but suggest what can +never be uttered, not as being different from, or more obscure than, +what actually gets said, but as containing that plenary substance of +which there is only one phase or facet in what is there expressed. + +If all high things have their martyrs, Gustave Flaubert might perhaps +rank as the martyr of literary style. In his printed correspondence, +a curious series of letters, written in his twenty-fifth year, +records what seems to have been his one other passion--a series of +letters which, with its fine casuistries, its firmly repressed +anguish, its tone of harmonious grey, and the sense of disillusion in +which the whole matter ends, might have been, a few slight changes +supposed, one of his own fictions. Writing to Madame X. certainly he +does display, by "taking thought" mainly, by constant and delicate +pondering, as in his love for literature, a heart really moved, but +[28] still more, and as the pledge of that emotion, a loyalty to his +work. Madame X., too, is a literary artist, and the best gifts he +can send her are precepts of perfection in art, counsels for the +effectual pursuit of that better love. In his love-letters it is the +pains and pleasures of art he insists on, its solaces: he +communicates secrets, reproves, encourages, with a view to that. +Whether the lady was dissatisfied with such divided or indirect +service, the reader is not enabled to see; but sees that, on +Flaubert's part at least, a living person could be no rival of what +was, from first to last, his leading passion, a somewhat solitary and +exclusive one. + +I must scold you (he writes) for one thing, which shocks, +scandalises me, the small concern, namely, you show for art +just now. As regards glory be it so: there, I approve. But +for art!--the one thing in life that is good and real--can you +compare with it an earthly love?--prefer the adoration of a +relative beauty to the cultus of the true beauty? Well! I tell +you the truth. That is the one thing good in me: the one thing +I have, to me estimable. For yourself, you blend with the +beautiful a heap of alien things, the useful, the agreeable, +what not?-- + +The only way not to be unhappy is to shut yourself up in art, +and count everything else as nothing. Pride takes the place of +all beside when it is established on a large basis. Work! God +wills it. That, it seems to me, is clear.--+ + +I am reading over again the Aeneid, certain verses of which I +repeat to myself to satiety. There are phrases there which stay +in one's head, by which I find myself beset, as with those musical +airs which are for ever returning, and cause you pain, you love +them so much. I observe that I no longer laugh much, and am no +longer depressed. I am ripe. You talk of my serenity, and envy +me. It may well surprise you. Sick, [29] irritated, the prey +a thousand times a day of cruel pain, I continue my labour like +a true working-man, who, with sleeves turned up, in the sweat of +his brow, beats away at his anvil, never troubling himself whether +it rains or blows, for hail or thunder. I was not like that +formerly. The change has taken place naturally, though my will +has counted for something in the matter.-- + +Those who write in good style are sometimes accused of a neglect +of ideas, and of the moral end, as if the end of the physician +were something else than healing, of the painter than painting- +as if the end of art were not, before all else, the beautiful. + +What, then, did Flaubert understand by beauty, in the art he pursued +with so much fervour, with so much self-command? Let us hear a +sympathetic commentator :-- + +Possessed of an absolute belief that there exists but one way of +expressing one thing, one word to call it by, one adjective to +qualify, one verb to animate it, he gave himself to superhuman +labour for the discovery, in every phrase, of that word, that +verb, that epithet. In this way, he believed in some mysterious +harmony of expression, and when a true word seemed to him to +lack euphony still went on seeking another, with invincible +patience, certain that he had not yet got hold of the unique +word.... A thousand preoccupations would beset him at the +same moment, always with this desperate certitude fixed in his +spirit: Among all the expressions in the world, all forms and +turns of expression, there is but one--one form, one mode--to +express what I want to say. + +The one word for the one thing, the one thought, amid the multitude +of words, terms, that might just do: the problem of style was there!- +-the unique word, phrase, sentence, paragraph, essay, or song, +absolutely proper to the single mental presentation or vision within. + +[30] In that perfect justice, over and above the many contingent and +removable beauties with which beautiful style may charm us, but which +it can exist without, independent of them yet dexterously availing +itself of them, omnipresent in good work, in function at every point, +from single epithets to the rhythm of a whole book, lay the specific, +indispensable, very intellectual, beauty of literature, the +possibility of which constitutes it a fine art. + +One seems to detect the influence of a philosophic idea there, the +idea of a natural economy, of some pre-existent adaptation, between a +relative, somewhere in the world of thought, and its correlative, +somewhere in the world of language--both alike, rather, somewhere in +the mind of the artist, desiderative, expectant, inventive--meeting +each other with the readiness of "soul and body reunited," in Blake's +rapturous design; and, in fact, Flaubert was fond of giving his +theory philosophical expression.-- + +There are no beautiful thoughts (he would say) without beautiful +forms, and conversely. As it is impossible to extract from a +physical body the qualities which really constitute it--colour, +extension, and the like--without reducing it to a hollow +abstraction, in a word, without destroying it; just so it is +impossible to detach the form from the idea, for the idea only +exists by virtue of the form. + +All, the recognised flowers, the removable ornaments of literature +(including harmony and ease in reading aloud, very carefully +considered [31] by him) counted, certainly; for these too are part +of the actual value of what one says. But still, after all, with +Flaubert, the search, the unwearied research, was not for the smooth, +or winsome, or forcible word, as such, as with false Ciceronians, but +quite simply and honestly, for the word's adjustment to its meaning. +The first condition of this must be, of course, to know yourself, to +have ascertained your own sense exactly. Then, if we suppose an +artist, he says to the reader,--I want you to see precisely what I +see. Into the mind sensitive to "form," a flood of random sounds, +colours, incidents, is ever penetrating from the world without, to +become, by sympathetic selection, a part of its very structure, and, +in turn, the visible vesture and expression of that other world it +sees so steadily within, nay, already with a partial conformity +thereto, to be refined, enlarged, corrected, at a hundred points; and +it is just there, just at those doubtful points that the function of +style, as tact or taste, intervenes. The unique term will come more +quickly to one than another, at one time than another, according also +to the kind of matter in question. Quickness and slowness, ease and +closeness alike, have nothing to do with the artistic character of +the true word found at last. As there is a charm of ease, so there +is also a special charm in the signs of discovery, of effort and +contention towards a due end, as so often with Flaubert himself--in +the style which has [32] been pliant, as only obstinate, durable +metal can be, to the inherent perplexities and recusancy of a certain +difficult thought. + +If Flaubert had not told us, perhaps we should never have guessed how +tardy and painful his own procedure really was, and after reading his +confession may think that his almost endless hesitation had much to +do with diseased nerves. Often, perhaps, the felicity supposed will +be the product of a happier, a more exuberant nature than Flaubert's. +Aggravated, certainly, by a morbid physical condition, that anxiety +in "seeking the phrase," which gathered all the other small ennuis of +a really quiet existence into a kind of battle, was connected with +his lifelong contention against facile poetry, facile art--art, +facile and flimsy; and what constitutes the true artist is not the +slowness or quickness of the process, but the absolute success of the +result. As with those labourers in the parable, the prize is +independent of the mere length of the actual day's work. "You talk," +he writes, odd, trying lover, to Madame X.-- + +"You talk of the exclusiveness of my literary tastes. That +might have enabled you to divine what kind of a person I am in +the matter of love. I grow so hard to please as a literary +artist, that I am driven to despair. I shall end by not +writing another line." + +"Happy," he cries, in a moment of discouragement at that patient labour, +which for him, certainly, was the condition of a great success--[33] + +Happy those who have no doubts of themselves! who lengthen out, +as the pen runs on, all that flows forth from their brains. As +for me, I hesitate, I disappoint myself, turn round upon myself +in despite: my taste is augmented in proportion as my natural +vigour decreases, and I afflict my soul over some dubious word +out of all proportion to the pleasure I get from a whole page +of good writing. One would have to live two centuries to attain +a true idea of any matter whatever. What Buffon said is a big +blasphemy: genius is not long-continued patience. Still, there +is some truth in the statement, and more than people think, +especially as regards our own day. Art! art! art! bitter +deception! phantom that glows with light, only to lead one on +to destruction... + +Again-- + +I am growing so peevish about my writing. I am like a man whose +ear is true but who plays falsely on the violin: his fingers +refuse to reproduce precisely those sounds of which he has the +inward sense. Then the tears come rolling down from the poor +scraper's eyes and the bow falls from his hand. + +Coming slowly or quickly, when it comes, as it came with so much +labour of mind, but also with so much lustre, to Gustave Flaubert, +this discovery of the word will be, like all artistic success and +felicity, incapable of strict analysis: effect of an intuitive +condition of mind, it must be recognised by like intuition on the +part of the reader, and a sort of immediate sense. In every one of +those masterly sentences of Flaubert there was, below all mere +contrivance, shaping and afterthought, by some happy instantaneous +concourse of the various faculties of the mind with each other, the +exact apprehension of what was needed to carry the meaning. And that +it fits with absolute justice will be a judgment of [34] immediate +sense in the appreciative reader. We all feel this in what may be +called inspired translation. Well! all language involves translation +from inward to outward. In literature, as in all forms of art, there +are the absolute and the merely relative or accessory beauties; and +precisely in that exact proportion of the term to its purpose is the +absolute beauty of style, prose or verse. All the good qualities, +the beauties, of verse also, are such, only as precise expression. + +In the highest as in the lowliest literature, then, the one +indispensable beauty is, after all, truth:--truth to bare fact in the +latter, as to some personal sense of fact, diverted somewhat from +men's ordinary sense of it, in the former; truth there as accuracy, +truth here as expression, that finest and most intimate form of +truth, the vraie verite. And what an eclectic principle this really +is! employing for its one sole purpose--that absolute accordance of +expression to idea--all other literary beauties and excellences +whatever: how many kinds of style it covers, explains, justifies, and +at the same time safeguards! Scott's facility, Flaubert's deeply +pondered evocation of "the phrase," are equally good art. Say what +you have to say, what you have a will to say, in the simplest, the +most direct and exact manner possible, with no surplusage:--there, is +the justification of the sentence so fortunately born, "entire, +smooth, and round," that it needs no punctuation, and also [35] (that +is the point!) of the most elaborate period, if it be right in its +elaboration. Here is the office of ornament: here also the purpose +of restraint in ornament. As the exponent of truth, that austerity +(the beauty, the function, of which in literature Flaubert understood +so well) becomes not the correctness or purism of the mere scholar, +but a security against the otiose, a jealous exclusion of what does +not really tell towards the pursuit of relief, of life and vigour in +the portraiture of one's sense. License again, the making free with +rule, if it be indeed, as people fancy, a habit of genius, flinging +aside or transforming all that opposes the liberty of beautiful +production, will be but faith to one's own meaning. The seeming +baldness of Le Rouge et Le Noir is nothing in itself; the wild +ornament of Les Miserables is nothing in itself; and the restraint of +Flaubert, amid a real natural opulence, only redoubled beauty--the +phrase so large and so precise at the same time, hard as bronze, in +service to the more perfect adaptation of words to their matter. +Afterthoughts, retouchings, finish, will be of profit only so far as +they too really serve to bring out the original, initiative, +generative, sense in them. + +In this way, according to the well-known saying, "The style is the +man," complex or simple, in his individuality, his plenary sense of +what he really has to say, his sense of the world; all cautions +regarding style arising out of so many [36] natural scruples as to +the medium through which alone he can expose that inward sense of +things, the purity of this medium, its laws or tricks of refraction: +nothing is to be left there which might give conveyance to any matter +save that. Style in all its varieties, reserved or opulent, terse, +abundant, musical, stimulant, academic, so long as each is really +characteristic or expressive, finds thus its justification, the +sumptuous good taste of Cicero being as truly the man himself, and +not another, justified, yet insured inalienably to him, thereby, as +would have been his portrait by Raffaelle, in full consular +splendour, on his ivory chair. + +A relegation, you may say perhaps--a relegation of style to the +subjectivity, the mere caprice, of the individual, which must soon +transform it into mannerism. Not so! since there is, under the +conditions supposed, for those elements of the man, for every +lineament of the vision within, the one word, the one acceptable +word, recognisable by the sensitive, by others "who have +intelligence" in the matter, as absolutely as ever anything can be in +the evanescent and delicate region of human language. The style, the +manner, would be the man, not in his unreasoned and really +uncharacteristic caprices, involuntary or affected, but in absolutely +sincere apprehension of what is most real to him. But let us hear +our French guide again.-- + +Styles (says Flaubert's commentator), Styles, as so many [37] +peculiar moulds, each of which bears the mark of a particular +writer, who is to pour into it the whole content of his ideas, +were no part of his theory. What he believed in was Style: +that is to say, a certain absolute and unique manner of +expressing a thing, in all its intensity and colour. For him +the form was the work itself. As in living creatures, the +blood, nourishing the body, determines its very contour and +external aspect, just so, to his mind, the matter, the basis, +in a work of art, imposed, necessarily, the unique, the just +expression, the measure, the rhythm--the form in all its +characteristics. + +If the style be the man, in all the colour and intensity of a +veritable apprehension, it will be in a real sense "impersonal." + +I said, thinking of books like Victor Hugo's Les Miserables, that +prose literature was the characteristic art of the nineteenth +century, as others, thinking of its triumphs since the youth of Bach, +have assigned that place to music. Music and prose literature are, +in one sense, the opposite terms of art; the art of literature +presenting to the imagination, through the intelligence, a range of +interests, as free and various as those which music presents to it +through sense. And certainly the tendency of what has been here said +is to bring literature too under those conditions, by conformity to +which music takes rank as the typically perfect art. If music be the +ideal of all art whatever, precisely because in music it is +impossible to distinguish the form from the substance or matter, the +subject from the expression, then, literature, by finding its +specific excellence in the absolute correspondence of the term to its +import, will be [38] but fulfilling the condition of all artistic +quality in things everywhere, of all good art. + +Good art, but not necessarily great art; the distinction between +great art and good art depending immediately, as regards literature +at all events, not on its form, but on the matter. Thackeray's +Esmond, surely, is greater art than Vanity Fair, by the greater +dignity of its interests. It is on the quality of the matter it +informs or controls, its compass, its variety, its alliance to great +ends, or the depth of the note of revolt, or the largeness of hope in +it, that the greatness of literary art depends, as The Divine Comedy, +Paradise Lost, Les Miserables, The English Bible, are great art. +Given the conditions I have tried to explain as constituting good +art;--then, if it be devoted further to the increase of men's +happiness, to the redemption of the oppressed, or the enlargement of +our sympathies with each other, or to such presentment of new or old +truth about ourselves and our relation to the world as may ennoble +and fortify us in our sojourn here, or immediately, as with Dante, to +the glory of God, it will be also great art; if, over and above those +qualities I summed up as mind and soul--that colour and mystic +perfume, and that reasonable structure, it has something of the soul +of humanity in it, and finds its logical, its architectural place, in +the great structure of human life. + +1888. + +NOTES + +12. *Mr. Saintsbury, in his Specimens of English Prose, from Malory +to Macaulay, has succeeded in tracing, through successive English +prose-writers, the tradition of that severer beauty in them, of which +this admirable scholar of our literature is known to be a lover. +English Prose, from Mandeville to Thackeray, more recently "chosen +and edited" by a younger scholar, Mr. Arthur Galton, of New College, +Oxford, a lover of our literature at once enthusiastic and discreet, +aims at a more various illustration of the eloquent powers of English +prose, and is a delightful companion. + +28. +In the original, the quoted material is not indented but instead +appears in a smaller typeface; I have chosen to indent the material +half an inch to make it easier to read. + + + +WORDSWORTH + +[39] SOME English critics at the beginning of the present century had +a great deal to say concerning a distinction, of much importance, as +they thought, in the true estimate of poetry, between the Fancy, and +another more powerful faculty--the Imagination. This metaphysical +distinction, borrowed originally from the writings of German +philosophers, and perhaps not always clearly apprehended by those who +talked of it, involved a far deeper and more vital distinction, with +which indeed all true criticism more or less directly has to do, the +distinction, namely, between higher and lower degrees of intensity in +the poet's perception of his subject, and in his concentration of +himself upon his work. Of those who dwelt upon the metaphysical +distinction between the Fancy and the Imagination, it was Wordsworth +who made the most of it, assuming it as the basis for the final +classification of his poetical writings; and it is in these writings +that the deeper and more vital distinction, which, as I have said, +underlies the metaphysical [40] distinction, is most needed, and may +best be illustrated. + +For nowhere is there so perplexed a mixture as in Wordsworth's own +poetry, of work touched with intense and individual power, with work +of almost no character at all. He has much conventional sentiment, +and some of that insincere poetic diction, against which his most +serious critical efforts were directed: the reaction in his political +ideas, consequent on the excesses of 1795, makes him, at times, a +mere declaimer on moral and social topics; and he seems, sometimes, +to force an unwilling pen, and write by rule. By making the most of +these blemishes it is possible to obscure the true aesthetic value of +his work, just as his life also, a life of much quiet delicacy and +independence, might easily be placed in a false focus, and made to +appear a somewhat tame theme in illustration of the more obvious +parochial virtues. And those who wish to understand his influence, +and experience his peculiar savour, must bear with patience the +presence of an alien element in Wordsworth's work, which never +coalesced with what is really delightful in it, nor underwent his +special power. Who that values his writings most has not felt the +intrusion there, from time to time, of something tedious and prosaic? +Of all poets equally great, he would gain most by a skilfully made +anthology. Such a selection would show, in truth, not so much what +he was, or to himself or others [41] seemed to be, as what, by the +more energetic and fertile quality in his writings, he was ever +tending to become. And the mixture in his work, as it actually +stands, is so perplexed, that one fears to miss the least promising +composition even, lest some precious morsel should be lying hidden +within--the few perfect lines, the phrase, the single word perhaps, +to which he often works up mechanically through a poem, almost the +whole of which may be tame enough. He who thought that in all +creative work the larger part was given passively, to the recipient +mind, who waited so dutifully upon the gift, to whom so large a +measure was sometimes given, had his times also of desertion and +relapse; and he has permitted the impress of these too to remain in +his work. And this duality there--the fitfulness with which the +higher qualities manifest themselves in it, gives the effect in his +poetry of a power not altogether his own, or under his control, which +comes and goes when it will, lifting or lowering a matter, poor in +itself; so that that old fancy which made the poet's art an +enthusiasm, a form of divine possession, seems almost literally true +of him. + +This constant suggestion of an absolute duality between higher and +lower moods, and the work done in them, stimulating one always to +look below the surface, makes the reading of Wordsworth an excellent +sort of training towards the things of art and poetry. It begets in +those, [42] who, coming across him in youth, can bear him at all, a +habit of reading between the lines, a faith in the effect of +concentration and collectedness of mind in the right appreciation of +poetry, an expectation of things, in this order, coming to one by +means of a right discipline of the temper as well as of the +intellect. He meets us with the promise that he has much, and +something very peculiar, to give us, if we will follow a certain +difficult way, and seems to have the secret of a special and +privileged state of mind. And those who have undergone his +influence, and followed this difficult way, are like people who have +passed through some initiation, a disciplina arcani, by submitting to +which they become able constantly to distinguish in art, speech, +feeling, manners, that which is organic, animated, expressive, from +that which is only conventional, derivative, inexpressive. + +But although the necessity of selecting these precious morsels for +oneself is an opportunity for the exercise of Wordsworth's peculiar +influence, and induces a kind of just criticism and true estimate of +it, yet the purely literary product would have been more excellent, +had the writer himself purged away that alien element. How perfect +would have been the little treasury, shut between the covers of how +thin a book! Let us suppose the desired separation made, the +electric thread untwined, the golden pieces, [43] great and small, +lying apart together.* What are the peculiarities of this residue? +What special sense does Wordsworth exercise, and what instincts does +he satisfy? What are the subjects and the motives which in him +excite the imaginative faculty? What are the qualities in things and +persons which he values, the impression and sense of which he can +convey to others, in an extraordinary way? + +An intimate consciousness of the expression of natural things, which +weighs, listens, penetrates, where the earlier mind passed roughly +by, is a large element in the complexion of modern poetry. It has +been remarked as a fact in mental history again and again. It +reveals itself in many forms; but is strongest and most attractive in +what is strongest and most attractive in modern literature. It is +exemplified, almost equally, by writers as unlike each other as +Senancour and Theophile Gautier: as a singular chapter in the history +of the human mind, its growth might be traced from Rousseau to +Chateaubriand, from Chateaubriand to Victor Hugo: it has doubtless +some latent connexion with those pantheistic theories which locate an +intelligent soul in material things, and have largely exercised men's +minds in some modern systems of philosophy: it is traceable even in +[44] the graver writings of historians: it makes as much difference +between ancient and modern landscape art, as there is between the +rough masks of an early mosaic and a portrait by Reynolds or +Gainsborough. Of this new sense, the writings of Wordsworth are the +central and elementary expression: he is more simply and entirely +occupied with it than any other poet, though there are fine +expressions of precisely the same thing in so different a poet as +Shelley. There was in his own character a certain contentment, a +sort of inborn religious placidity, seldom found united with a +sensibility so mobile as his, which was favourable to the quiet, +habitual observation of inanimate, or imperfectly animate, existence. +His life of eighty years is divided by no very profoundly felt +incidents: its changes are almost wholly inward, and it falls into +broad, untroubled, perhaps somewhat monotonous spaces. What it most +resembles is the life of one of those early Italian or Flemish +painters, who, just because their minds were full of heavenly +visions, passed, some of them, the better part of sixty years in +quiet, systematic industry. This placid life matured a quite unusual +sensibility, really innate in him, to the sights and sounds of the +natural world--the flower and its shadow on the stone, the cuckoo and +its echo. The poem of Resolution and Independence is a storehouse of +such records: for its fulness of imagery it may be compared to +Keats's Saint Agnes' Eve. To [45] read one of his longer pastoral +poems for the first time, is like a day spent in a new country: the +memory is crowded for a while with its precise and vivid incidents-- + +The pliant harebell swinging in the breeze +On some grey rock ;-- + +The single sheep and the one blasted tree +And the bleak music from that old stone wall;-- + +In the meadows and the lower ground +Was all the sweetness of a common dawn;-- + +And that green corn all day is rustling in thine ears. + +Clear and delicate at once, as he is in the outlining of visible +imagery, he is more clear and delicate still, and finely scrupulous, +in the noting of sounds; so that he conceives of noble sound as even +moulding the human countenance to nobler types, and as something +actually "profaned" by colour, by visible form, or image. + +He has a power likewise of realising, and conveying to the +consciousness of the reader, abstract and elementary impressions-- +silence, darkness, absolute motionlessness: or, again, the whole +complex sentiment of a particular place, the abstract expression of +desolation in the long white road, of peacefulness in a particular +folding of the hills. In the airy building of the brain, a special +day or hour even, comes to have for him a sort of personal identity, +a spirit or angel given to it, by which, for its exceptional [46] +insight, or the happy light upon it, it has a presence in one's +history, and acts there, as a separate power or accomplishment; and +he has celebrated in many of his poems the "efficacious spirit," +which, as he says, resides in these "particular spots" of time. + +It is to such a world, and to a world of congruous meditation +thereon, that we see him retiring in his but lately published poem of +The Recluse--taking leave, without much count of costs, of the world +of business, of action and ambition; as also of all that for the +majority of mankind counts as sensuous enjoyment.* + +And so it came about that this sense of a life in natural objects, +which in most poetry is but a rhetorical artifice, is with Wordsworth +the assertion of what for him is almost literal fact. To him every +natural object seemed to possess more or less of a moral or spiritual +life, to be [47] capable of a companionship with man, full of +expression, of inexplicable affinities and delicacies of intercourse. +An emanation, a particular spirit, belonged, not to the moving leaves +or water only, but to the distant peak of the hills arising suddenly, +by some change of perspective, above the nearer horizon, to the +passing space of light across the plain, to the lichened Druidic +stone even, for a certain weird fellowship in it with the moods of +men. It was like a "survival," in the peculiar intellectual +temperament of a man of letters at the end of the eighteenth century, +of that primitive condition, which some philosophers have traced in +the general history of human culture, wherein all outward objects +[48] alike, including even the works of men's hands, were believed to +be endowed with animation, and the world was "full of souls"--that +mood in which the old Greek gods were first begotten, and which had +many strange aftergrowths. + +In the early ages, this belief, delightful as its effects on poetry +often are, was but the result of a crude intelligence. But, in +Wordsworth, such power of seeing life, such perception of a soul, in +inanimate things, came of an exceptional susceptibility to the +impressions of eye and ear, and was, in its essence, a kind of +sensuousness. At least, it is only in a temperament exceptionally +susceptible on the sensuous side, that this sense of the +expressiveness of outward things comes to be so large a part of life. +That he awakened "a sort of thought in sense," is Shelley's just +estimate of this element in Wordsworth's poetry. + +And it was through nature, thus ennobled by a semblance of passion +and thought, that he approached the spectacle of human life. Human +life, indeed, is for him, at first, only an additional, accidental +grace on an expressive landscape. When he thought of man, it was of +man as in the presence and under the influence of these effective +natural objects, and linked to them by many associations. The close +connexion of man with natural objects, the habitual association of +his thoughts and feelings with a particular spot of earth, has +sometimes seemed to [49] degrade those who are subject to its +influence, as if it did but reinforce that physical connexion of our +nature with the actual lime and clay of the soil, which is always +drawing us nearer to our end. But for Wordsworth, these influences +tended to the dignity of human nature, because they tended to +tranquillise it. By raising nature to the level of human thought he +gives it power and expression: he subdues man to the level of nature, +and gives him thereby a certain breadth and coolness and solemnity. +The leech-gatherer on the moor, the woman "stepping westward," are +for him natural objects, almost in the same sense as the aged thorn, +or the lichened rock on the heath. In this sense the leader of the +"Lake School," in spite of an earnest preoccupation with man, his +thoughts, his destiny, is the poet of nature. And of nature, after +all, in its modesty. The English lake country has, of course, its +grandeurs. But the peculiar function of Wordsworth's genius, as +carrying in it a power to open out the soul of apparently little or +familiar things, would have found its true test had he become the +poet of Surrey, say! and the prophet of its life. The glories of +Italy and Switzerland, though he did write a little about them, had +too potent a material life of their own to serve greatly his poetic +purpose. + +Religious sentiment, consecrating the affections and natural regrets +of the human heart, above all, that pitiful awe and care for the [50] +perishing human clay, of which relic-worship is but the corruption, +has always had much to do with localities, with the thoughts which +attach themselves to actual scenes and places. Now what is true of +it everywhere, is truest of it in those secluded valleys where one +generation after another maintains the same abiding-place; and it was +on this side, that Wordsworth apprehended religion most strongly. +Consisting, as it did so much, in the recognition of local +sanctities, in the habit of connecting the stones and trees of a +particular spot of earth with the great events of life, till the low +walls, the green mounds, the half-obliterated epitaphs seemed full of +voices, and a sort of natural oracles, the very religion of these +people of the dales appeared but as another link between them and the +earth, and was literally a religion of nature. It tranquillised them +by bringing them under the placid rule of traditional and narrowly +localised observances. "Grave livers," they seemed to him, under +this aspect, with stately speech, and something of that natural +dignity of manners, which underlies the highest courtesy. + +And, seeing man thus as a part of nature, elevated and solemnised in +proportion as his daily life and occupations brought him into +companionship with permanent natural objects, his very religion +forming new links for him with the narrow limits of the valley, the +low vaults of his church, the rough stones of his [51] home, made +intense for him now with profound sentiment, Wordsworth was able to +appreciate passion in the lowly. He chooses to depict people from +humble life, because, being nearer to nature than others, they are on +the whole more impassioned, certainly more direct in their expression +of passion, than other men: it is for this direct expression of +passion, that he values their humble words. In much that he said in +exaltation of rural life, he was but pleading indirectly for that +sincerity, that perfect fidelity to one's own inward presentations, +to the precise features of the picture within, without which any +profound poetry is impossible. It was not for their tameness, but +for this passionate sincerity, that he chose incidents and situations +from common life, "related in a selection of language really used by +men." He constantly endeavours to bring his language near to the +real language of men: to the real language of men, however, not on +the dead level of their ordinary intercourse, but in select moments +of vivid sensation, when this language is winnowed and ennobled by +excitement. There are poets who have chosen rural life as their +subject, for the sake of its passionless repose, and times when +Wordsworth himself extols the mere calm and dispassionate survey of +things as the highest aim of poetical culture. But it was not for +such passionless calm that he preferred the scenes of pastoral life; +and the meditative poet, sheltering [52] himself, as it might seem, +from the agitations of the outward world, is in reality only clearing +the scene for the great exhibitions of emotion, and what he values +most is the almost elementary expression of elementary feelings. + +And so he has much for those who value highly the concentrated +presentment of passion, who appraise men and women by their +susceptibility to it, and art and poetry as they afford the spectacle +of it. Breaking from time to time into the pensive spectacle of +their daily toil, their occupations near to nature, come those great +elementary feelings, lifting and solemnising their language and +giving it a natural music. The great, distinguishing passion came to +Michael by the sheepfold, to Ruth by the wayside, adding these humble +children of the furrow to the true aristocracy of passionate souls. +In this respect, Wordsworth's work resembles most that of George +Sand, in those of her novels which depict country life. With a +penetrative pathos, which puts him in the same rank with the masters +of the sentiment of pity in literature, with Meinhold and Victor +Hugo, he collects all the traces of vivid excitement which were to be +found in that pastoral world--the girl who rung her father's knell; +the unborn infant feeling about its mother's heart; the instinctive +touches of children; the sorrows of the wild creatures, even--their +home-sickness, their strange yearnings; the tales of passionate +regret that hang [53] by a ruined farm-building, a heap of stones, a +deserted sheepfold; that gay, false, adventurous, outer world, which +breaks in from time to time to bewilder and deflower these quiet +homes; not "passionate sorrow" only, for the overthrow of the soul's +beauty, but the loss of, or carelessness for personal beauty even, in +those whom men have wronged--their pathetic wanness; the sailor "who, +in his heart, was half a shepherd on the stormy seas"; the wild woman +teaching her child to pray for her betrayer; incidents like the +making of the shepherd's staff, or that of the young boy laying the +first stone of the sheepfold;--all the pathetic episodes of their +humble existence, their longing, their wonder at fortune, their poor +pathetic pleasures, like the pleasures of children, won so hardly in +the struggle for bare existence; their yearning towards each other, +in their darkened houses, or at their early toil. A sort of biblical +depth and solemnity hangs over this strange, new, passionate, +pastoral world, of which he first raised the image, and the +reflection of which some of our best modern fiction has caught from +him. + +He pondered much over the philosophy of his poetry, and reading +deeply in the history of his own mind, seems at times to have passed +the borders of a world of strange speculations, inconsistent enough, +had he cared to note such inconsistencies, with those traditional +beliefs, which [54] were otherwise the object of his devout +acceptance. Thinking of the high value he set upon customariness, +upon all that is habitual, local, rooted in the ground, in matters of +religious sentiment, you might sometimes regard him as one tethered +down to a world, refined and peaceful indeed, but with no broad +outlook, a world protected, but somewhat narrowed, by the influence +of received ideas. But he is at times also something very different +from this, and something much bolder. A chance expression is +overheard and placed in a new connexion, the sudden memory of a thing +long past occurs to him, a distant object is relieved for a while by +a random gleam of light--accidents turning up for a moment what lies +below the surface of our immediate experience--and he passes from the +humble graves and lowly arches of "the little rock-like pile" of a +Westmoreland church, on bold trains of speculative thought, and +comes, from point to point, into strange contact with thoughts which +have visited, from time to time, far more venturesome, perhaps +errant, spirits. + +He had pondered deeply, for instance, on those strange reminiscences +and forebodings, which seem to make our lives stretch before and +behind us, beyond where we can see or touch anything, or trace the +lines of connexion. Following the soul, backwards and forwards, on +these endless ways, his sense of man's dim, potential powers became a +pledge to him, indeed, of a future life, [55] but carried him back +also to that mysterious notion of an earlier state of existence--the +fancy of the Platonists--the old heresy of Origen. It was in this +mood that he conceived those oft-reiterated regrets for a half-ideal +childhood, when the relics of Paradise still clung about the soul--a +childhood, as it seemed, full of the fruits of old age, lost for all, +in a degree, in the passing away of the youth of the world, lost for +each one, over again, in the passing away of actual youth. It is +this ideal childhood which he celebrates in his famous Ode on the +Recollections of Childhood, and some other poems which may be grouped +around it, such as the lines on Tintern Abbey, and something like +what he describes was actually truer of himself than he seems to have +understood; for his own most delightful poems were really the +instinctive productions of earlier life, and most surely for him, +"the first diviner influence of this world" passed away, more and +more completely, in his contact with experience. + +Sometimes as he dwelt upon those moments of profound, imaginative +power, in which the outward object appears to take colour and +expression, a new nature almost, from the prompting of the observant +mind, the actual world would, as it were, dissolve and detach itself, +flake by flake, and he himself seemed to be the creator, and when he +would the destroyer, of the world in which he lived--that old +isolating thought of many a brain-sick mystic of ancient and modern +times. + +[56] At other times, again, in those periods of intense +susceptibility, in which he appeared to himself as but the passive +recipient of external influences, he was attracted by the thought of +a spirit of life in outward things, a single, all-pervading mind in +them, of which man, and even the poet's imaginative energy, are but +moments--that old dream of the anima mundi, the mother of all things +and their grave, in which some had desired to lose themselves, and +others had become indifferent to the distinctions of good and evil. +It would come, sometimes, like the sign of the macrocosm to Faust in +his cell: the network of man and nature was seen to be pervaded by a +common, universal life: a new, bold thought lifted him above the +furrow, above the green turf of the Westmoreland churchyard, to a +world altogether different in its vagueness and vastness, and the +narrow glen was full of the brooding power of one universal spirit. + +And so he has something, also, for those who feel the fascination of +bold speculative ideas, who are really capable of rising upon them to +conditions of poetical thought. He uses them, indeed, always with a +very fine apprehension of the limits within which alone philosophical +imaginings have any place in true poetry; and using them only for +poetical purposes, is not too careful even to make them consistent +with each other. To him, theories which for other men [57] bring a +world of technical diction, brought perfect form and expression, as +in those two lofty books of The Prelude, which describe the decay and +the restoration of Imagination and Taste. Skirting the borders of +this world of bewildering heights and depths, he got but the first +exciting influence of it, that joyful enthusiasm which great +imaginative theories prompt, when the mind first comes to have an +understanding of them; and it is not under the influence of these +thoughts that his poetry becomes tedious or loses its blitheness. He +keeps them, too, always within certain ethical bounds, so that no +word of his could offend the simplest of those simple souls which are +always the largest portion of mankind. But it is, nevertheless, the +contact of these thoughts, the speculative boldness in them, which +constitutes, at least for some minds, the secret attraction of much +of his best poetry--the sudden passage from lowly thoughts and places +to the majestic forms of philosophical imagination, the play of these +forms over a world so different, enlarging so strangely the bounds of +its humble churchyards, and breaking such a wild light on the graves +of christened children. + +And these moods always brought with them faultless expression. In +regard to expression, as with feeling and thought, the duality of the +higher and lower moods was absolute. It belonged to the higher, the +imaginative mood, and was the pledge of its reality, to bring the +[58] appropriate language with it. In him, when the really poetical +motive worked at all, it united, with absolute justice, the word and +the idea; each, in the imaginative flame, becoming inseparably one +with the other, by that fusion of matter and form, which is the +characteristic of the highest poetical expression. His words are +themselves thought and feeling; not eloquent, or musical words +merely, but that sort of creative language which carries the reality +of what it depicts, directly, to the consciousness. + +The music of mere metre performs but a limited, yet a very peculiar +and subtly ascertained function, in Wordsworth's poetry. With him, +metre is but an additional grace, accessory to that deeper music of +words and sounds, that moving power, which they exercise in the +nobler prose no less than in formal poetry. It is a sedative to that +excitement, an excitement sometimes almost painful, under which the +language, alike of poetry and prose, attains a rhythmical power, +independent of metrical combination, and dependent rather on some +subtle adjustment of the elementary sounds of words themselves to the +image or feeling they convey. Yet some of his pieces, pieces +prompted by a sort of half-playful mysticism, like the Daffodils and +The Two April Mornings, are distinguished by a certain quaint gaiety +of metre, and rival by their perfect execution, in this respect, +similar pieces among our own Elizabethan, or contemporary French +poetry. + +[59] And those who take up these poems after an interval of months, +or years perhaps, may be surprised at finding how well old favourites +wear, how their strange, inventive turns of diction or thought still +send through them the old feeling of surprise. Those who lived about +Wordsworth were all great lovers of the older English literature, and +oftentimes there came out in him a noticeable likeness to our earlier +poets. He quotes unconsciously, but with new power of meaning, a +clause from one of Shakespeare's sonnets; and, as with some other +men's most famous work, the Ode on the Recollections of Childhood had +its anticipator.* He drew something too from the unconscious +mysticism of the old English language itself, drawing out the inward +significance of its racy idiom, and the not wholly unconscious poetry +of the language used by the simplest people under strong excitement-- +language, therefore, at its origin. + +The office of the poet is not that of the moralist, and the first aim +of Wordsworth's poetry is to give the reader a peculiar kind of +pleasure. But through his poetry, and through this pleasure in it, +he does actually convey to the reader an extraordinary wisdom in the +things of practice. One lesson, if men must have lessons, he conveys +more clearly than all, the supreme importance of contemplation in the +conduct of life. + +[60] Contemplation--impassioned contemplation--that, is with +Wordsworth the end-in-itself, the perfect end. We see the majority +of mankind going most often to definite ends, lower or higher ends, +as their own instincts may determine; but the end may never be +attained, and the means not be quite the right means, great ends and +little ones alike being, for the most part, distant, and the ways to +them, in this dim world, somewhat vague. Meantime, to higher or +lower ends, they move too often with something of a sad countenance, +with hurried and ignoble gait, becoming, unconsciously, something +like thorns, in their anxiety to bear grapes; it being possible for +people, in the pursuit of even great ends, to become themselves thin +and impoverished in spirit and temper, thus diminishing the sum of +perfection in the world, at its very sources. We understand this +when it is a question of mean, or of intensely selfish ends--of +Grandet, or Javert. We think it bad morality to say that the end +justifies the means, and we know how false to all higher conceptions +of the religious life is the type of one who is ready to do evil that +good may come. We contrast with such dark, mistaken eagerness, a +type like that of Saint Catherine of Siena, who made the means to her +ends so attractive, that she has won for herself an undying place in +the House Beautiful, not by her rectitude of soul only, but by its +"fairness"--by those quite different qualities [61] which commend +themselves to the poet and the artist. + +Yet, for most of us, the conception of means and ends covers the +whole of life, and is the exclusive type or figure under which we +represent our lives to ourselves. Such a figure, reducing all things +to machinery, though it has on its side the authority of that old +Greek moralist who has fixed for succeeding generations the outline +of the theory of right living, is too like a mere picture or +description of men's lives as we actually find them, to be the basis +of the higher ethics. It covers the meanness of men's daily lives, +and much of the dexterity with which they pursue what may seem to +them the good of themselves or of others; but not the intangible +perfection of those whose ideal is rather in being than in doing--not +those manners which are, in the deepest as in the simplest sense, +morals, and without which one cannot so much as offer a cup of water +to a poor man without offence--not the part of "antique Rachel," +sitting in the company of Beatrice; and even the moralist might well +endeavour rather to withdraw men from the too exclusive consideration +of means and ends, in life. + +Against this predominance of machinery in our existence, Wordsworth's +poetry, like all great art and poetry, is a continual protest. +Justify rather the end by the means, it seems to say: whatever may +become of the fruit, make sure of [62] the flowers and the leaves. +It was justly said, therefore, by one who had meditated very +profoundly on the true relation of means to ends in life, and on the +distinction between what is desirable in itself and what is desirable +only as machinery, that when the battle which he and his friends were +waging had been won, the world would need more than ever those +qualities which Wordsworth was keeping alive and nourishing.* + +That the end of life is not action but contemplation--being as +distinct from doing--a certain disposition of the mind: is, in some +shape or other, the principle of all the higher morality. In poetry, +in art, if you enter into their true spirit at all; you touch this +principle, in a measure: these, by their very sterility, are a type +of beholding for the mere joy of beholding. To treat life in the +spirit of art, is to make life a thing in which means and ends are +identified: to encourage such treatment, the true moral significance +of art and poetry. Wordsworth, and other poets who have been like +him in ancient or more recent times, are the masters, the experts, in +this art of impassioned contemplation. Their work is, not to teach +lessons, or enforce rules, or even to stimulate us to noble ends; but +to withdraw the thoughts for a little while from the mere machinery +of life, to fix [63] them, with appropriate emotions, on the +spectacle of those great facts in man's existence which no machinery +affects, "on the great and universal passions of men, the most +general and interesting of their occupations, and the entire world of +nature,"--on "the operations of the elements and the appearances of +the visible universe, on storm and sunshine, on the revolutions of +the seasons, on cold and heat, on loss of friends and kindred, on +injuries and resentments, on gratitude and hope, on fear and +sorrow." To witness this spectacle with appropriate emotions is the +aim of all culture; and of these emotions poetry like Wordsworth's is +a great nourisher and stimulant. He sees nature full of sentiment +and excitement; he sees men and women as parts of nature, passionate, +excited, in strange grouping and connexion with the grandeur and +beauty of the natural world:--images, in his own words, "of man +suffering, amid awful forms and powers." + +Such is the figure of the more powerful and original poet, hidden +away, in part, under those weaker elements in Wordsworth's poetry, +which for some minds determine their entire character; a poet +somewhat bolder and more passionate than might at first sight be +supposed, but not too bold for true poetical taste; an unimpassioned +writer, you might sometimes fancy, yet thinking the chief aim, in +life and art alike, to be a certain deep emotion; seeking most often +the great [64] elementary passions in lowly places; having at least +this condition of all impassioned work, that he aims always at an +absolute sincerity of feeling and diction, so that he is the true +forerunner of the deepest and most passionate poetry of our own day; +yet going back also, with something of a protest against the +conventional fervour of much of the poetry popular in his own time, +to those older English poets, whose unconscious likeness often comes +out in him. + +1874. + +NOTES + +43. *Since this essay was written, such selections have been made, +with excellent taste, by Matthew Arnold and Professor Knight. + +46-47. *In Wordsworth's prefatory advertisement to the first edition +of The Prelude, published in 1850, it is stated that that work was +intended to be introductory to The Recluse; and that The Recluse, if +completed, would have consisted of three parts. The second part is +The Excursion. The third part was only planned; but the first book +of the first part was left in manuscript by Wordsworth--though in +manuscript, it is said, in no great condition of forwardness for the +printers. This book, now for the first time printed in extenso (a +very noble passage from it found place in that prose advertisement to +The Excursion), is included in the latest edition of Wordsworth by +Mr. John Morley. It was well worth adding to the poet's great +bequest to English literature. A true student of his work, who has +formulated for himself what he supposes to be the leading +characteristics of Wordsworth's genius, will feel, we think, lively +interest in testing them by the various fine passages in what is +here presented for the first time. Let the following serve for +a sample:-- + +Thickets full of songsters, and the voice +Of lordly birds, an unexpected sound +Heard now and then from morn to latest eve, +Admonishing the man who walks below +Of solitude and silence in the sky:-- +These have we, and a thousand nooks of earth +Have also these, but nowhere else is found, +Nowhere (or is it fancy?) can be found +The one sensation that is here; 'tis here, +Here as it found its way into my heart +In childhood, here as it abides by day, +By night, here only; or in chosen minds +That take it with them hence, where'er they go. +--'Tis, but I cannot name it, 'tis the sense +Of majesty, and beauty, and repose, +A blended holiness of earth and sky, +Something that makes this individual spot, +This small abiding-place of many men, +A termination, and a last retreat, +A centre, come from wheresoe'er you will, +A whole without dependence or defect, +Made for itself, and happy in itself, +Perfect contentment, Unity entire. + +59. *Henry Vaughan, in The Retreat. + +62. *See an interesting paper, by Mr. John Morley, on "The Death of +Mr. Mill," Fortnightly Review, June 1873. + + + +COLERIDGE* + +[65] FORMS of intellectual and spiritual culture sometimes exercise +their subtlest and most artful charm when life is already passing +from them. Searching and irresistible as are the changes of the human +spirit on its way to perfection, there is yet so much elasticity of +temper that what must pass away sooner or later is not disengaged all +at once, even from the highest order of minds. Nature, which by one +law of development evolves ideas, hypotheses, modes of inward life, +and represses them in turn, has in this way provided that the earlier +growth should propel its fibres into the later, and so transmit the +whole of its forces in an unbroken continuity of life. Then comes the +spectacle of the reserve of the elder generation exquisitely refined +by the antagonism of the new. That current of new life chastens them +while they contend against it. Weaker minds fail to perceive the +change: the clearest minds abandon themselves to it. To [66] feel +the change everywhere, yet not abandon oneself to it, is a situation +of difficulty and contention. Communicating, in this way, to the +passing stage of culture, the charm of what is chastened, high- +strung, athletic, they yet detach the highest minds from the past, by +pressing home its difficulties and finally proving it impossible. +Such has been the charm of many leaders of lost causes in philosophy +and in religion. It is the special charm of Coleridge, in connexion +with those older methods of philosophic inquiry, over which the +empirical philosophy of our day has triumphed. + +Modern thought is distinguished from ancient by its cultivation of +the "relative" spirit in place of the "absolute." Ancient philosophy +sought to arrest every object in an eternal outline, to fix thought +in a necessary formula, and the varieties of life in a classification +by "kinds," or genera. To the modern spirit nothing is, or can be +rightly known, except relatively and under conditions. The +philosophical conception of the relative has been developed in modern +times through the influence of the sciences of observation. Those +sciences reveal types of life evanescing into each other by +inexpressible refinements of change. Things pass into their +opposites by accumulation of undefinable quantities. The growth of +those sciences consists in a continual analysis of facts of rough and +general observation into groups of facts more precise and minute. + +[67] The faculty for truth is recognised as a power of distinguishing +and fixing delicate and fugitive detail. The moral world is ever in +contact with the physical, and the relative spirit has invaded moral +philosophy from the ground of the inductive sciences. There it has +started a new analysis of the relations of body and mind, good and +evil, freedom and necessity. Hard and abstract moralities are +yielding to a more exact estimate of the subtlety and complexity of +our life. Always, as an organism increases in perfection, the +conditions of its life become more complex. Man is the most complex +of the products of nature. Character merges into temperament: the +nervous system refines itself into intellect. Man's physical +organism is played upon not only by the physical conditions about it, +but by remote laws of inheritance, the vibration of long-past acts +reaching him in the midst of the new order of things in which he +lives. When we have estimated these conditions he is still not yet +simple and isolated; for the mind of the race, the character of the +age, sway him this way or that through the medium of language and +current ideas. It seems as if the most opposite statements about him +were alike true: he is so receptive, all the influences of nature and +of society ceaselessly playing upon him, so that every hour in his +life is unique, changed altogether by a stray word, or glance, or +touch. It is the truth of these relations that experience [68] gives +us, not the truth of eternal outlines ascertained once for all, but a +world of fine gradations and subtly linked conditions, shifting +intricately as we ourselves change--and bids us, by a constant +clearing of the organs of observation and perfecting of analysis, to +make what we can of these. To the intellect, the critical spirit, +just these subtleties of effect are more precious than anything else. +What is lost in precision of form is gained in intricacy of +expression. It is no vague scholastic abstraction that will satisfy +the speculative instinct in our modern minds. Who would change the +colour or curve of a rose-leaf for that ousia akhromatos, +askhematistos, anaphes+--that colourless, formless, intangible, +being--Plato put so high? For the true illustration of the +speculative temper is not the Hindoo mystic, lost to sense, +understanding, individuality, but one such as Goethe, to whom every +moment of life brought its contribution of experimental, individual +knowledge; by whom no touch of the world of form, colour, and passion +was disregarded. + +Now the literary life of Coleridge was a disinterested struggle +against the relative spirit. With a strong native bent towards the +tracking of all questions, critical or practical, to first +principles, he is ever restlessly scheming to "apprehend the +absolute," to affirm it effectively, to get it acknowledged. It was +an effort, surely, an effort of sickly thought, that saddened his +[69] mind, and limited the operation of his unique poetic gift. + +So what the reader of our own generation will least find in +Coleridge's prose writings is the excitement of the literary sense. +And yet, in those grey volumes, we have the larger part of the +production of one who made way ever by a charm, the charm of voice, +of aspect, of language, above all by the intellectual charm of new, +moving, luminous ideas. Perhaps the chief offence in Coleridge is an +excess of seriousness, a seriousness arising not from any moral +principle, but from a misconception of the perfect manner. There is +a certain shade of unconcern, the perfect manner of the eighteenth +century, which may be thought to mark complete culture in the +handling of abstract questions. The humanist, the possessor of that +complete culture, does not "weep" over the failure of "a theory of +the quantification of the predicate," nor "shriek" over the fall of a +philosophical formula. A kind of humour is, in truth, one of the +conditions of the just mental attitude, in the criticism of by-past +stages of thought. Humanity cannot afford to be too serious about +them, any more than a man of good sense can afford to be too serious +in looking back upon his own childhood. Plato, whom Coleridge claims +as the first of his spiritual ancestors, Plato, as we remember him, a +true humanist, holds his theories lightly, glances with a somewhat +blithe and naive inconsequence from [70] one view to another, not +anticipating the burden of importance "views" will one day have for +men. In reading him one feels how lately it was that Croesus thought +it a paradox to say that external prosperity was not necessarily +happiness. But on Coleridge lies the whole weight of the sad +reflection that has since come into the world, with which for us the +air is full, which the "children in the market-place" repeat to each +other. His very language is forced and broken lest some saving +formula should be lost--distinctities, enucleation, pentad of +operative Christianity; he has a whole armoury of these terms, and +expects to turn the tide of human thought by fixing the sense of such +expressions as "reason," "understanding," "idea." Again, he lacks +the jealousy of a true artist in excluding all associations that have +no colour, or charm, or gladness in them; and everywhere allows the +impress of a somewhat inferior theological literature. + +"I was driven from life in motion to life in thought and sensation:" +so Coleridge sums up his childhood, with its delicacy, its +sensitiveness, and passion. But at twenty-five he was exercising a +wonderful charm, and had already defined for himself his peculiar +line of intellectual activity. He had an odd, attractive gift of +conversation, or rather of monologue, as Madame de Stael observed of +him, full of bizarreries, with the rapid alternations of a dream, and +here or there an unexpected summons into a world [71] strange to the +hearer, abounding in images drawn from a sort of divided imperfect +life, the consciousness of the opium-eater, as of one to whom the +external world penetrated only in part, and, blent with all this, +passages of deep obscurity, precious, if at all, only for their +musical cadence, echoes in Coleridge of the eloquence of those older +English writers of whom he was so ardent a lover. And all through +this brilliant early manhood we may discern the power of the +"Asiatic" temperament, of that voluptuousness, which is connected +perhaps with his appreciation of the intimacy, the almost mystical +communion of touch, between nature and man. "I am much better," he +writes, "and my new and tender health is all over me like a +voluptuous feeling." And whatever fame, or charm, or life-inspiring +gift he has had as a speculative thinker, is the vibration of the +interest he excited then, the propulsion into years which clouded his +early promise of that first buoyant, irresistible, self-assertion. +So great is even the indirect power of a sincere effort towards the +ideal life, of even a temporary escape of the spirit from routine. + +In 1798 he visited Germany, then, the only half-known, "promised +land," of the metaphysical, the "absolute," philosophy. A beautiful +fragment of this period remains, describing a spring excursion to the +Brocken. His excitement still vibrates in it. Love, all joyful +states [72] of mind, are self-expressive: they loosen the tongue, +they fill the thoughts with sensuous images, they harmonise one with +the world of sight. We hear of the "rich graciousness and courtesy" +of Coleridge's manner, of the white and delicate skin, the abundant +black hair, the full, almost animal lips--that whole physiognomy of +the dreamer, already touched with narcotism. One says, of the +beginning of one of his Unitarian sermons: "His voice rose like a +stream of rich, distilled perfumes;" another, "He talks like an +angel, and does--nothing!" + +The Aids to Reflection, The Friend, The Biographia Literaria: those +books came from one whose vocation was in the world of the +imagination, the theory and practice of poetry. And yet, perhaps, of +all books that have been influential in modern times, they are +furthest from artistic form--bundles of notes; the original matter +inseparably mixed up with that borrowed from others; the whole, just +that mere preparation for an artistic effect which the finished +literary artist would be careful one day to destroy. Here, again, we +have a trait profoundly characteristic of Coleridge. He sometimes +attempts to reduce a phase of thought, subtle and exquisite, to +conditions too rough for it. He uses a purely speculative gift for +direct moral edification. Scientific truth is a thing fugitive, +relative, full of fine gradations: he tries to fix it in absolute +formulas. The Aids to Reflection, The Friend, are [73] efforts to +propagate the volatile spirit of conversation into the less ethereal +fabric of a written book; and it is only here or there that the +poorer matter becomes vibrant, is really lifted by the spirit. + +De Quincey said of him that "he wanted better bread than can be made +with wheat:" Lamb, that from childhood he had "hungered for +eternity." Yet the faintness, the continuous dissolution, whatever +its cause, which soon supplanted the buoyancy of his first wonderful +years, had its own consumptive refinements, and even brought, as to +the "Beautiful Soul" in Wilhelm Meister, a faint religious ecstasy-- +that "singing in the sails" which is not of the breeze. Here again +is one of his occasional notes:-- + +"In looking at objects of nature while I am thinking, as at yonder +moon, dim-glimmering through the window-pane, I seem rather to be +seeking, as it were asking, a symbolical language for something +within me, that already and for ever exists, than observing anything +new. Even when the latter is the case, yet still I have always an +obscure feeling, as if that new phenomenon were the dim awaking of a +forgotten or hidden truth of my inner nature. While I was preparing +the pen to make this remark, I lost the train of thought which had +led me to it." + +What a distemper of the eye of the mind! What an almost bodily +distemper there is in that! + +Coleridge's intellectual sorrows were many; [74] but he had one +singular intellectual happiness. With an inborn taste for +transcendental philosophy, he lived just at the time when that +philosophy took an immense spring in Germany, and connected itself +with an impressive literary movement. He had the good luck to light +upon it in its freshness, and introduce it to his countrymen. What +an opportunity for one reared on the colourless analytic English +philosophies of the last century, but who feels an irresistible +attraction towards bold metaphysical synthesis! How rare are such +occasions of intellectual contentment! This transcendental +philosophy, chiefly as systematised by the mystic Schelling, +Coleridge applied with an eager, unwearied subtlety, to the questions +of theology, and poetic or artistic criticism. It is in his theory +of poetry, of art, that he comes nearest to principles of permanent +truth and importance: that is the least fugitive part of his prose +work. What, then, is the essence of his philosophy of art--of +imaginative production? + +Generally, it may be described as an attempt to reclaim the world of +art as a world of fixed laws, to show that the creative activity of +genius and the simplest act of thought are but higher and lower +products of the laws of a universal logic. Criticism, feeling its +own inadequacy in dealing with the greater works of art, is sometimes +tempted to make too much of those dark and capricious suggestions of +genius, which even [75] the intellect possessed by them is unable to +explain or recall. It has seemed due to the half-sacred character of +those works to ignore all analogy between the productive process by +which they had their birth, and the simpler processes of mind. +Coleridge, on the other hand, assumes that the highest phases of +thought must be more, not less, than the lower, subject to law. + +With this interest, in the Biographia Literaria, he refines +Schelling's "Philosophy of Nature" into a theory of art. "There can +be no plagiarism in philosophy," says Heine:--Es giebt kein Plagiat +in der Philosophie, in reference to the charge brought against +Schelling of unacknowledged borrowing from Bruno; and certainly that +which is common to Coleridge and Schelling and Bruno alike is of far +earlier origin than any of them. Schellingism, the "Philosophy of +Nature," is indeed a constant tradition in the history of thought: it +embodies a permanent type of the speculative temper. That mode of +conceiving nature as a mirror or reflex of the intelligence of man +may be traced up to the first beginnings of Greek speculation. There +are two ways of envisaging those aspects of nature which seem to bear +the impress of reason or intelligence. There is the deist's way, +which regards them merely as marks of design, which separates the +informing mind from its result in nature, as the mechanist from the +machine; and there is the pantheistic way, which identifies the two, +which [76] regards nature itself as the living energy of an +intelligence of the same kind as though vaster in scope than the +human. Partly through the influence of mythology, the Greek mind +became early possessed with the conception of nature as living, +thinking, almost speaking to the mind of man. This unfixed poetical +prepossession, reduced to an abstract form, petrified into an idea, +is the force which gives unity of aim to Greek philosophy. Little by +little, it works out the substance of the Hegelian formula: "Whatever +is, is according to reason: whatever is according to reason, that +is." Experience, which has gradually saddened the earth's colours +for us, stiffened its motions, withdrawn from it some blithe and +debonair presence, has quite changed the character of the science of +nature, as we understand it. The "positive" method, in truth, makes +very little account of marks of intelligence in nature: in its wider +view of phenomena, it sees that those instances are a minority, and +may rank as happy coincidences: it absorbs them in the larger +conception of universal mechanical law. But the suspicion of a mind +latent in nature, struggling for release, and intercourse with the +intellect of man through true ideas, has never ceased to haunt a +certain class of minds. Started again and again in successive +periods by enthusiasts on the antique pattern, in each case the +thought may have seemed paler and more fantastic amid the growing +[77] consistency and sharpness of outline of other and more positive +forms of knowledge. Still, wherever the speculative instinct has +been united with a certain poetic inwardness of temperament, as in +Bruno, in Schelling, there that old Greek conception, like some seed +floating in the air, has taken root and sprung up anew. Coleridge, +thrust inward upon himself, driven from "life in thought and +sensation" to life in thought only, feels already, in his dark London +school, a thread of the Greek mind on this matter vibrating strongly +in him. At fifteen he is discoursing on Plotinus, as in later years +he reflects from Schelling that flitting intellectual tradition. He +supposes a subtle, sympathetic co-ordination between the ideas of the +human reason and the laws of the natural world. Science, the real +knowledge of that natural world, is to be attained, not by +observation, experiment, analysis, patient generalisation, but by the +evolution or recovery of those ideas directly from within, by a sort +of Platonic "recollection"; every group of observed facts remaining +an enigma until the appropriate idea is struck upon them from the +mind of a Newton, or a Cuvier, the genius in whom sympathy with the +universal reason becomes entire. In the next place, he conceives +that this reason or intelligence in nature becomes reflective, or +self-conscious. He fancies he can trace, through all the simpler +forms of life, fragments of an eloquent prophecy about the [78] human +mind. The whole of nature he regards as a development of higher +forms out of the lower, through shade after shade of systematic +change. The dim stir of chemical atoms towards the axis of crystal +form, the trance-like life of plants, the animal troubled by strange +irritabilities, are stages which anticipate consciousness. All +through the ever-increasing movement of life that was shaping itself; +every successive phase of life, in its unsatisfied susceptibilities, +seeming to be drawn out of its own limits by the more pronounced +current of life on its confines, the "shadow of approaching humanity" +gradually deepening, the latent intelligence winning a way to the +surface. And at this point the law of development does not lose +itself in caprice: rather it becomes more constraining and incisive. +From the lowest to the very highest acts of the conscious +intelligence, there is another series of refining shades. Gradually +the mind concentrates itself, frees itself from the limitations of +the particular, the individual, attains a strange power of modifying +and centralising what it receives from without, according to the +pattern of an inward ideal. At last, in imaginative genius, ideas +become effective: the intelligence of nature, all its discursive +elements now connected and justified, is clearly reflected; the +interpretation of its latent purposes being embodied in the great +central products of creative art. The secret of creative [79] genius +would be an exquisitely purged sympathy with nature, with the +reasonable soul antecedent there. Those associative conceptions of +the imagination, those eternally fixed types of action and passion, +would come, not so much from the conscious invention of the artist, +as from his self-surrender to the suggestions of an abstract reason +or ideality in things: they would be evolved by the stir of nature +itself, realising the highest reach of its dormant reason: they would +have a kind of prevenient necessity to rise at some time to the +surface of the human mind. + +It is natural that Shakespeare should be the favourite illustration +of such criticism, whether in England or Germany. The first +suggestion in Shakespeare is that of capricious detail, of a +waywardness that plays with the parts careless of the impression of +the whole; what supervenes is the constraining unity of effect, the +ineffaceable impression, of Hamlet or Macbeth. His hand moving +freely is curved round as if by some law of gravitation from within: +an energetic unity or identity makes itself visible amid an abounding +variety. This unity or identity Coleridge exaggerates into something +like the identity of a natural organism, and the associative act +which effected it into something closely akin to the primitive power +of nature itself. "In the Shakespearian drama," he says, "there is a +vitality which grows and evolves itself from within." + +[80] Again-- + +He, too, worked in the spirit of nature, by evolving the germ +from within, by the imaginative power, according to the idea. +For as the power of seeing is to light, so is an idea in mind +to a law in nature. They are correlatives which suppose +each other. + +Again-- + +The organic form is innate: it shapes, as it develops, itself from +within, and the fulness of its development is one and the same with +the perfection of its outward form. Such as the life is, such is the +form. Nature, the prime, genial artist, inexhaustible in diverse +powers, is equally inexhaustible in forms: each exterior is the +physiognomy of the being within, and even such is the appropriate +excellence of Shakespeare, himself a nature humanised, a genial +understanding, directing self-consciously a power and an implicit +wisdom deeper even than our consciousness.+ + +In this late age we are become so familiarised with the greater works +of art as to be little sensitive of the act of creation in them: they +do not impress us as a new presence in the world. Only sometimes, in +productions which realise immediately a profound influence and +enforce a change in taste, we are actual witnesses of the moulding of +an unforeseen type by some new principle of association; and to that +phenomenon Coleridge wisely recalls our attention. What makes his +view a one-sided one is, that in it the artist has become almost a +mechanical agent: instead of the most luminous and self-possessed +phase of consciousness, the associative act in art or poetry is made +to look like some blindly organic process of assimilation. The work +of art is likened to a living organism. That expresses [81] truly +the sense of a self-delighting, independent life which the finished +work of art gives us: it hardly figures the process by which such +work was produced. Here there is no blind ferment of lifeless +elements towards the realisation of a type. By exquisite analysis +the artist attains clearness of idea; then, through many stages of +refining, clearness of expression. He moves slowly over his work, +calculating the tenderest tone, and restraining the subtlest curve, +never letting hand or fancy move at large, gradually enforcing +flaccid spaces to the higher degree of expressiveness. The +philosophic critic, at least, will value, even in works of +imagination, seemingly the most intuitive, the power of the +understanding in them, their logical process of construction, the +spectacle of a supreme intellectual dexterity which they afford. + +Coleridge's prose writings on philosophy, politics, religion, and +criticism, were, in truth, but one element in a whole lifetime of +endeavours to present the then recent metaphysics of Germany to +English readers, as a legitimate expansion of the older, classical +and native masters of what has been variously called the a priori, or +absolute, or spiritual, or Platonic, view of things. His criticism, +his challenge for recognition in the concrete, visible, finite work +of art, of the dim, unseen, comparatively infinite, soul or power of +the artist, may well be [82] remembered as part of the long pleading +of German culture for the things "behind the veil." To introduce +that spiritual philosophy, as represented by the more transcendental +parts of Kant, and by Schelling, into all subjects, as a system of +reason in them, one and ever identical with itself, however various +the matter through which it was diffused, became with him the motive +of an unflagging enthusiasm, which seems to have been the one thread +of continuity in a life otherwise singularly wanting in unity of +purpose, and in which he was certainly far from uniformly at his +best. Fragmentary and obscure, but often eloquent, and always at +once earnest and ingenious, those writings, supplementing his +remarkable gift of conversation, were directly and indirectly +influential, even on some the furthest removed from Coleridge's own +masters; on John Stuart Mill, for instance, and some of the earlier +writers of the "high-church" school. Like his verse, they display +him also in two other characters--as a student of words, and as a +psychologist, that is, as a more minute observer or student than +other men of the phenomena of mind. To note the recondite +associations of words, old or new; to expound the logic, the +reasonable soul, of their various uses; to recover the interest of +older writers who had had a phraseology of their own--this was a vein +of inquiry allied to his undoubted gift of tracking out and analysing +curious modes of thought. A [83] quaint fragment of verse on Human +Life might serve to illustrate his study of the earlier English +philosophical poetry. The latter gift, that power of the "subtle- +souled psychologist," as Shelley calls him, seems to have been +connected with some tendency to disease in the physical temperament, +something of a morbid want of balance in those parts where the +physical and intellectual elements mix most closely together, with a +kind of languid visionariness, deep-seated in the very constitution +of the "narcotist," who had quite a gift for "plucking the poisons of +self-harm," and which the actual habit of taking opium, accidentally +acquired, did but reinforce. This morbid languor of nature, +connected both with his fitfulness of purpose and his rich delicate +dreaminess, qualifies Coleridge's poetic composition even more than +his prose; his verse, with the exception of his avowedly political +poems, being, unlike that of the "Lake School," to which in some +respects he belongs, singularly unaffected by any moral, or +professional, or personal effort or ambition,--"written," as he says, +"after the more violent emotions of sorrow, to give him pleasure, +when perhaps nothing else could;" but coming thus, indeed, very close +to his own most intimately personal characteristics, and having a +certain languidly soothing grace or cadence, for its most fixed +quality, from first to last. After some Platonic soliloquy on a +flower opening on a fine day in February, he goes on-- [84] + +Dim similitudes +Weaving in mortal strains, I've stolen one hour +From anxious self, life's cruel taskmaster! +And the warm wooings of this sunny day +Tremble along my frame and harmonise +The attempered organ, that even saddest thoughts +Mix with some sweet sensations, like harsh tunes +Played deftly on a sweet-toned instrument. + +The expression of two opposed, yet allied, elements of sensibility in +these lines, is very true to Coleridge:--the grievous agitation, the +grievous listlessness, almost never entirely relieved, together with +a certain physical voluptuousness. He has spoken several times of +the scent of the bean-field in the air:--the tropical touches in a +chilly climate; his is a nature that will make the most of these, +which finds a sort of caress in such things. Kubla Khan, the +fragment of a poem actually composed in some certainly not quite +healthy sleep, is perhaps chiefly of interest as showing, by the mode +of its composition, how physical, how much of a diseased or +valetudinarian temperament, in its moments of relief, Coleridge's +happiest gift really was; and side by side with Kubla Khan should be +read, as Coleridge placed it, the Pains of Sleep, to illustrate that +retarding physical burden in his temperament, that "unimpassioned +grief," the source of which lay so near the source of those +pleasures. Connected also with this, and again in contrast with +Wordsworth, is the limited quantity of his poetical performance, as +he himself [85] regrets so eloquently in the lines addressed to +Wordsworth after his recitation of The Prelude. It is like some +exotic plant, just managing to blossom a little in the somewhat un- +english air of Coleridge's own south-western birthplace, but never +quite well there. + +In 1798 he joined Wordsworth in the composition of a volume of poems- +-the Lyrical Ballads. What Wordsworth then wrote already vibrates +with that blithe impulse which carried him to final happiness and +self-possession. In Coleridge we feel already that faintness and +obscure dejection which clung like some contagious damp to all his +work. Wordsworth was to be distinguished by a joyful and penetrative +conviction of the existence of certain latent affinities between +nature and the human mind, which reciprocally gild the mind and +nature with a kind of "heavenly alchemy." + +My voice proclaims +How exquisitely the individual mind +(And the progressive powers, perhaps, no less +Of the whole species) to the external world +Is fitted; and how exquisitely, too, +The external world is fitted to the mind; +And the creation, by no lower name +Can it be called, which they with blended might +Accomplish. + +In Wordsworth this took the form of an unbroken dreaming over the +aspects and transitions of nature--a reflective, though altogether +unformulated, analysis of them. + +[86] There are in Coleridge's poems expressions of this conviction as +deep as Wordsworth's. But Coleridge could never have abandoned +himself to the dream, the vision, as Wordsworth did, because the +first condition of such abandonment must be an unvexed quietness of +heart. No one can read the Lines composed above Tintern without +feeling how potent the physical element was among the conditions of +Wordsworth's genius--"felt in the blood and felt along the heart." + +My whole life I have lived in quiet thought! + +The stimulus which most artists require of nature he can renounce. +He leaves the ready-made glory of the Swiss mountains that he may +reflect glory on a mouldering leaf. He loves best to watch the +floating thistledown, because of its hint at an unseen life in the +air. Coleridge's temperament, aei en sphodra orexei,+ with its +faintness, its grieved dejection, could never have been like that. + +My genial spirits fail; +And what can these avail +To lift the smothering weight from off my breast? +It were a vain endeavour, +Though I should gaze for ever +On that green light that lingers in the west +I may not hope from outward forms to win +The passion and the life whose fountains are within. + +Wordsworth's flawless temperament, his fine mountain atmosphere of +mind, that calm, sabbatic, mystic, wellbeing which De Quincey, [87] a +little cynically, connected with worldly (that is to say, pecuniary) +good fortune, kept his conviction of a latent intelligence in nature +within the limits of sentiment or instinct, and confined it to those +delicate and subdued shades of expression which alone perfect art +allows. In Coleridge's sadder, more purely intellectual, cast of +genius, what with Wordsworth was sentiment or instinct became a +philosophical idea, or philosophical formula, developed, as much as +possible, after the abstract and metaphysical fashion of the +transcendental schools of Germany. + +The period of Coleridge's residence at Nether Stowey, 1797-1798, was +for him the annus mirabilis. Nearly all the chief works by which his +poetic fame will live were then composed or planned. What shapes +itself for criticism as the main phenomenon of Coleridge's poetic +life, is not, as with most true poets, the gradual development of a +poetic gift, determined, enriched, retarded, by the actual +circumstances of the poet's life, but the sudden blossoming, through +one short season, of such a gift already perfect in its kind, which +thereafter deteriorates as suddenly, with something like premature +old age. Connecting this phenomenon with the leading motive of his +prose writings, we might note it as the deterioration of a productive +or creative power into one merely metaphysical or discursive. In his +unambitious conception of his function as a poet, and in the very +limited quantity of his [88] poetical performance, as I have said, he +was a contrast to his friend Wordsworth. That friendship with +Wordsworth, the chief "developing" circumstance of his poetic life, +comprehended a very close intellectual sympathy; and in such +association chiefly, lies whatever truth there may be in the popular +classification of Coleridge as a member of what is called the "Lake +School." Coleridge's philosophical speculations do really turn on +the ideas which underlay Wordsworth's poetical practice. His prose +works are one long explanation of all that is involved in that famous +distinction between the Fancy and the Imagination. Of what is +understood by both writers as the imaginative quality in the use +of poetic figures, we may take some words of Shakespeare as an +example.-- + +My cousin Suffolk, +My soul shall thine keep company to heaven +Tarry, sweet soul, for mine, then fly abreast. + +The complete infusion here of the figure into the thought, so vividly +realised, that, though birds are not actually mentioned, yet the +sense of their flight, conveyed to us by the single word "abreast," +comes to be more than half of the thought itself:--this, as the +expression of exalted feeling, is an instance of what Coleridge meant +by Imagination. And this sort of identification of the poet's +thought, of himself, with the image or figure which serves him, is +the secret, sometimes, [89] of a singularly entire realisation of +that image, such as makes these lines of Coleridge, for instance, +"imaginative"-- + +Amid the howl of more than wintry storms, +The halcyon hears the voice of vernal hours +Already on the wing. + +There are many such figures both in Coleridge's verse and prose. He +has, too, his passages of that sort of impassioned contemplation on +the permanent and elementary conditions of nature and humanity, which +Wordsworth held to be the essence of a poet; as it would be his +proper function to awaken such contemplation in other men--those +"moments," as Coleridge says, addressing him-- + +Moments awful, +Now in thy inner life, and now abroad, +When power streamed from thee, and thy soul received +The light reflected, as a light bestowed. + +The entire poem from which these lines are taken, "composed on the +night after Wordsworth's recitation of a poem on the growth of an +individual mind," is, in its high-pitched strain of meditation, and +in the combined justice and elevation of its philosophical +expression-- + +high and passionate thoughts +To their own music chanted; + +wholly sympathetic with The Prelude which it celebrates, and of +which the subject is, in effect, the generation of the spirit of +the "Lake poetry." [90] The Lines to Joseph Cottle have the same +philosophically imaginative character; the Ode to Dejection being +Coleridge's most sustained effort of this kind. + +It is in a highly sensitive apprehension of the aspects of external +nature that Coleridge identifies himself most closely with one of the +main tendencies of the "Lake School"; a tendency instinctive, and no +mere matter of theory, in him as in Wordsworth. That record of the + +green light +Which lingers in the west, + +and again, of + +the western sky, +And its peculiar tint of yellow green, + +which Byron found ludicrously untrue, but which surely needs no +defence, is a characteristic example of a singular watchfulness for +the minute fact and expression of natural scenery pervading all he +wrote--a closeness to the exact physiognomy of nature, having +something to do with that idealistic philosophy which sees in the +external world no mere concurrence of mechanical agencies, but an +animated body, informed and made expressive, like the body of man, by +an indwelling intelligence. It was a tendency, doubtless, in the +air, for Shelley too is affected by it, and Turner, with the school +of landscape which followed him. "I had found," Coleridge tells us, + +[91] + +That outward forms, the loftiest, still receive +Their finer influence from the world within; +Fair ciphers of vague import, where the eye +Traces no spot, in which the heart may read +History and prophecy:... + +and this induces in him no indifference to actual colour and form and +process, but such minute realism as this-- + +The thin grey cloud is spread on high, +It covers but not hides the sky. +The moon is behind and at the full; +And yet she looks both small and dull; + +or this, which has a touch of "romantic" weirdness-- + +Nought was green upon the oak +But moss and rarest misletoe + +or this-- + +There is not wind enough to twirl +The one red leaf, the last of its clan, +That dances as often as dance it can, +Hanging so light, and hanging so high, +On the topmost twig that looks up at the sky + +or this, with a weirdness, again, like that of some wild French +etcher-- + +Lo! the new-moon winter-bright! +And overspread with phantom light +(With swimming phantom light o'erspread, +But rimmed and circled with a silver thread) +I see the old moon in her lap, foretelling +The coming on of rain and squally blast. + +He has a like imaginative apprehension of the silent and unseen +processes of nature, its "ministries" [92] of dew and frost, for +instance; as when he writes, in April-- + +A balmy night! and though the stars be dim, +Yet let us think upon the vernal showers +That gladden the green earth, and we shall find +A pleasure in the dimness of the stars. + +Of such imaginative treatment of landscape there is no better +instance than the description of The Dell, in Fears in Solitude-- + +A green and silent spot amid the hills, +A small and silent dell! O'er stiller place +No singing skylark ever poised himself-- +But the dell, +Bathed by the mist is fresh and delicate +As vernal cornfield, or the unripe flax +When, through its half-transparent stalks, at eve, +The level sunshine glimmers with green light:-- + +The gust that roared and died away +To the distant tree-- + +heard and only heard +In this low dell, bowed not the delicate grass. + +This curious insistence of the mind on one particular spot, till it +seems to attain actual expression and a sort of soul in it--a mood so +characteristic of the "Lake School"--occurs in an earnest political +poem, "written in April 1798, during the alarm of an invasion"; and +that silent dell is the background against which the tumultuous fears +of the poet are in strong relief, while the quiet sense of the place, +maintained all through them, gives a true poetic unity to the piece. +Good political poetry--[93] political poetry that shall be +permanently moving--can, perhaps, only be written on motives which, +for those they concern, have ceased to be open questions, and are +really beyond argument; while Coleridge's political poems are for the +most part on open questions. For although it was a great part of his +intellectual ambition to subject political questions to the action of +the fundamental ideas of his philosophy, he was nevertheless an +ardent partisan, first on one side, then on the other, of the actual +politics proper to the end of the last and the beginning of the +present century, where there is still room for much difference of +opinion. Yet The Destiny of Nations, though formless as a whole, and +unfinished, presents many traces of his most elevated manner of +speculation, cast into that sort of imaginative philosophical +expression, in which, in effect, the language itself is inseparable +from, or essentially a part of, the thought. France, an Ode, begins +with a famous apostrophe to Liberty-- + +Ye Clouds! that far above me float and pause, +Whose pathless march no mortal may control! +Ye Ocean-waves! that wheresoe'er ye roll, +Yield homage only to eternal laws! +Ye Woods! that listen to the night-bird's singing, +Midway the smooth and perilous slope reclined, +Save when your own imperious branches swinging, +Have made a solemn music of the wind! +Where like a man beloved of God, +Through glooms which never woodman trod, +How oft, pursuing fancies holy, + +[94] + +My moonlight way o'er flowering weeds I wound, +Inspired, beyond the guess of folly, +By each rude shape and wild unconquerable sound! +O ye loud Waves! and O ye Forests high! +And O ye Clouds that far above me soar'd! + +Thou rising Sun! thou blue rejoicing Sky! +Yea, everything that is and will be free! +Bear witness for me, wheresoe'er ye be, +With what deep worship I have still adored +The spirit of divinest liberty. + +And the whole ode, though, after Coleridge's way, not quite equal to +that exordium, is an example of strong national sentiment, partly in +indignant reaction against his own earlier sympathy with the French +Republic, inspiring a composition which, in spite of some turgid +lines, really justifies itself as poetry, and has that true unity of +effect which the ode requires. Liberty, after all his hopes of young +France, is only to be found in nature:-- + +Thou speedest on thy subtle pinions, +The guide of homeless winds, and playmate of the waves! + +In his changes of political sentiment, Coleridge was associated with +the "Lake School"; and there is yet one other very different sort of +sentiment in which he is one with that school, yet all himself, his +sympathy, namely, with the animal world. That was a sentiment +connected at once with the love of outward nature in himself and in +the "Lake School," and its assertion of the natural affections in +their simplicity; with the homeliness and pity, consequent upon [95] +that assertion. The Lines to a Young Ass, tethered-- + +Where the close-eaten grass is scarcely seen, +While sweet around her waves the tempting green, + +which had seemed merely whimsical in their day, indicate a vein of +interest constant in Coleridge's poems, and at its height in his +greatest poems--in Christabel, where it has its effect, as it were +antipathetically, in the vivid realisation of the serpentine element +in Geraldine's nature; and in The Ancient Mariner, whose fate is +interwoven with that of the wonderful bird, at whose blessing of the +water-snakes the curse for the death of the albatross passes away, +and where the moral of the love of all creatures, as a sort of +religious duty, is definitely expressed. + +Christabel, though not printed till 1816, was written mainly in the +year 1797: The Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner was printed as a +contribution to the Lyrical Ballads in 1798; and these two poems +belong to the great year of Coleridge's poetic production, his +twenty-fifth year. In poetic quality, above all in that most poetic +of all qualities, a keen sense of, and delight in beauty, the +infection of which lays hold upon the reader, they are quite out of +proportion to all his other compositions. The form in both is that +of the ballad, with some of its terminology, and some also of its +quaint conceits. They connect themselves with that revival of ballad +literature, of which Percy's Relics, and, in another [96] way, +Macpherson's Ossian are monuments, and which afterwards so powerfully +affected Scott-- + +Young-eyed poesy +All deftly masked as hoar antiquity. + +The Ancient Mariner, as also, in its measure, Christabel, is a +"romantic" poem, impressing us by bold invention, and appealing to +that taste for the supernatural, that longing for le frisson, a +shudder, to which the "romantic" school in Germany, and its +derivations in England and France, directly ministered. In +Coleridge, personally, this taste had been encouraged by his odd and +out-of-the-way reading in the old-fashioned literature of the +marvellous--books like Purchas's Pilgrims, early voyages like +Hakluyt's, old naturalists and visionary moralists, like Thomas +Burnet, from whom he quotes the motto of "The Ancient Mariner, Facile +credo, plures esse naturas invisibiles quam visibiles in rerum +universitate, etc." Fancies of the strange things which may very +well happen, even in broad daylight, to men shut up alone in ships +far off on the sea, seem to have occurred to the human mind in all +ages with a peculiar readiness, and often have about them, from the +story of the stealing of Dionysus downwards, the fascination of a +certain dreamy grace, which distinguishes them from other kinds of +marvellous inventions. This sort of fascination The Ancient Mariner +brings to its highest degree: it is the delicacy, the dreamy [97] +grace, in his presentation of the marvellous, which makes Coleridge's +work so remarkable. The too palpable intruders from a spiritual +world in almost all ghost literature, in Scott and Shakespeare even, +have a kind of crudity or coarseness. Coleridge's power is in the +very fineness with which, as by some really ghostly finger, he brings +home to our inmost sense his inventions, daring as they are--the +skeleton ship, the polar spirit, the inspiriting of the dead corpses +of the ship's crew. The Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner has the +plausibility, the perfect adaptation to reason and the general aspect +of life, which belongs to the marvellous, when actually presented as +part of a credible experience in our dreams. Doubtless, the mere +experience of the opium-eater, the habit he must almost necessarily +fall into of noting the more elusive phenomena of dreams, had +something to do with that: in its essence, however, it is connected +with a more purely intellectual circumstance in the development of +Coleridge's poetic gift. Some one once asked William Blake, to whom +Coleridge has many resemblances, when either is at his best (that +whole episode of the re-inspiriting of the ship's crew in The Ancient +Mariner being comparable to Blake's well-known design of the "Morning +Stars singing together") whether he had ever seen a ghost, and was +surprised when the famous seer, who ought, one might think, to have +seen so many, answered frankly, "Only [98] once!" His "spirits," at +once more delicate, and so much more real, than any ghost--the +burden, as they were the privilege, of his temperament--like it, were +an integral element in his everyday life. And the difference of mood +expressed in that question and its answer, is indicative of a change +of temper in regard to the supernatural which has passed over the +whole modern mind, and of which the true measure is the influence of +the writings of Swedenborg. What that change is we may see if we +compare the vision by which Swedenborg was "called," as he thought, +to his work, with the ghost which called Hamlet, or the spells of +Marlowe's Faust with those of Goethe's. The modern mind, so minutely +self-scrutinising, if it is to be affected at all by a sense of the +supernatural, needs to be more finely touched than was possible in +the older, romantic presentment of it. The spectral object, so +crude, so impossible, has become plausible, as + +The blot upon the brain, +That will show itself without; + +and is understood to be but a condition of one's own mind, for which, +according to the scepticism, latent at least, in so much of our +modern philosophy, the so-called real things themselves are but +spectra after all. + +It is this finer, more delicately marvellous supernaturalism, fruit +of his more delicate [99] psychology, that Coleridge infuses into +romantic adventure, itself also then a new or revived thing in +English literature; and with a fineness of weird effect in The +Ancient Mariner, unknown in those older, more simple, romantic +legends and ballads. It is a flower of medieval or later German +romance, growing up in the peculiarly compounded atmosphere of modern +psychological speculation, and putting forth in it wholly new +qualities. The quaint prose commentary, which runs side by side with +the verse of The Ancient Mariner, illustrates this--a composition of +quite a different shade of beauty and merit from that of the verse +which it accompanies, connecting this, the chief poem of Coleridge, +with his philosophy, and emphasising therein that psychological +interest of which I have spoken, its curious soul-lore. + +Completeness, the perfectly rounded wholeness and unity of the +impression it leaves on the mind of a reader who fairly gives himself +to it--that, too, is one of the characteristics of a really excellent +work, in the poetic as in every other kind of art; and by this +completeness, The Ancient Mariner certainly gains upon Christabel--a +completeness, entire as that of Wordsworth's Leech-gatherer, or +Keats's Saint Agnes' Eve, each typical in its way of such wholeness +or entirety of effect on a careful reader. It is Coleridge's one +great complete work, the one really finished thing, in a life of many +beginnings. Christabel remained a fragment. In The Ancient Mariner +[100] this unity is secured in part by the skill with which the +incidents of the marriage-feast are made to break in dreamily from +time to time upon the main story. And then, how pleasantly, how +reassuringly, the whole nightmare story itself is made to end, among +the clear fresh sounds and lights of the bay, where it began, with + +The moon-light steeped in silentness, +The steady weather-cock. + +So different from The Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner in regard to this +completeness of effect, Christabel illustrates the same complexion of +motives, a like intellectual situation. Here, too, the work is of a +kind peculiar to one who touches the characteristic motives of the +old romantic ballad, with a spirit made subtle and fine by modern +reflection; as we feel, I think, in such passages as-- + +But though my slumber had gone by, +This dream it would not pass away-- +It seems to live upon mine eye; + +and-- + +For she, belike, hath drunken deep +Of all the blessedness of sleep; + +and again-- + +With such perplexity of mind +As dreams too lively leave behind. + +And that gift of handling the finer passages of human feeling, at +once with power and delicacy, which was another result of his finer +psychology, [101] of his exquisitely refined habit of self- +reflection, is illustrated by a passage on Friendship in the Second +Part-- + +Alas! they had been friends in youth; +But whispering tongues can poison truth; +And constancy lives in realms above; +And life is thorny; and youth is vain; +And to be wroth with one we love, +Doth work like madness in the brain. +And thus it chanced, as I divine, +With Roland and Sir Leoline. +Each spake words of high disdain +And insult to his heart's best brother +They parted--ne'er to meet again! +But never either found another +To free the hollow heart from paining-- +They stood aloof the scars remaining, +Like cliffs which had been rent asunder; +A dreary sea now flows between; +But neither heat, nor frost, nor thunder, +Shall wholly do away, I ween, +The marks of that which once hath been. + +I suppose these lines leave almost every reader with a quickened +sense of the beauty and compass of human feeling; and it is the sense +of such richness and beauty which, in spite of his "dejection," in +spite of that burden of his morbid lassitude, accompanies Coleridge +himself through life. A warm poetic joy in everything beautiful, +whether it be a moral sentiment, like the friendship of Roland and +Leoline, or only the flakes of falling light from the water-snakes-- +this joy, visiting him, now and again, after sickly dreams, in sleep +or waking, as a relief not to be forgotten, [102] and with such a +power of felicitous expression that the infection of it passes +irresistibly to the reader--such is the predominant element in the +matter of his poetry, as cadence is the predominant quality of its +form. "We bless thee for our creation!" he might have said, in his +later period of definite religious assent, "because the world is so +beautiful: the world of ideas--living spirits, detached from the +divine nature itself, to inform and lift the heavy mass of material +things; the world of man, above all in his melodious and intelligible +speech; the world of living creatures and natural scenery; the world +of dreams." What he really did say, by way of A Tombless Epitaph, is +true enough of himself-- + +Sickness, 'tis true, +Whole years of weary days, besieged him close, +Even to the gates and inlets of his life! +But it is true, no less, that strenuous, firm, +And with a natural gladness, he maintained +The citadel unconquered, and in joy +Was strong to follow the delightful Muse. +For not a hidden path, that to the shades +Of the beloved Parnassian forest leads, +Lurked undiscovered by him; not a rill +There issues from the fount of Hippocrene, +But he had traced it upward to its source, +Through open glade, dark glen, and secret dell, +Knew the gay wild flowers on its banks, and culled +Its med'cinable herbs. Yea, oft alone, +Piercing the long-neglected holy cave, +The haunt obscure of old Philosophy, +He bade with lifted torch its starry walls +Sparkle, as erst they sparkled to the flame + +[103] + +Of odorous lamps tended by saint and sage. +O framed for calmer times and nobler hearts! +O studious Poet, eloquent for truth! +Philosopher! contemning wealth and death, +Yet docile, childlike, full of Life and Love. + +The student of empirical science asks, Are absolute principles +attainable? What are the limits of knowledge? The answer he +receives from science itself is not ambiguous. What the moralist +asks is, Shall we gain or lose by surrendering human life to the +relative spirit? Experience answers that the dominant tendency of +life is to turn ascertained truth into a dead letter, to make us all +the phlegmatic servants of routine. The relative spirit, by its +constant dwelling on the more fugitive conditions or circumstances of +things, breaking through a thousand rough and brutal classifications, +and giving elasticity to inflexible principles, begets an +intellectual finesse of which the ethical result is a delicate and +tender justice in the criticism of human life. Who would gain more +than Coleridge by criticism in such a spirit? We know how his life +has appeared when judged by absolute standards. We see him trying to +apprehend the "absolute," to stereotype forms of faith and +philosophy, to attain, as he says, "fixed principles" in politics, +morals, and religion, to fix one mode of life as the essence of life, +refusing to see the parts as parts only; and all the time his own +pathetic history pleads for a more [104] elastic moral philosophy +than his, and cries out against every formula less living and +flexible than life itself. + +"From his childhood he hungered for eternity." There, after all, is +the incontestable claim of Coleridge. The perfect flower of any +elementary type of life must always be precious to humanity, and +Coleridge is a true flower of the ennuye, of the type of Rene. More +than Childe Harold, more than Werther, more than Rene himself, +Coleridge, by what he did, what he was, and what he failed to do, +represents that inexhaustible discontent, languor, and homesickness, +that endless regret, the chords of which ring all through our modern +literature. It is to the romantic element in literature that those +qualities belong. One day, perhaps, we may come to forget the +distant horizon, with full knowledge of the situation, to be content +with "what is here and now"; and herein is the essence of classical +feeling. But by us of the present moment, certainly--by us for whom +the Greek spirit, with its engaging naturalness, simple, chastened, +debonair, tryphes, habrotetos, khlides, khariton, himerou, pothou +pater+, is itself the Sangrail of an endless pilgrimage, Coleridge, +with his passion for the absolute, for something fixed where all is +moving, his faintness, his broken memory, his intellectual disquiet, +may still be ranked among the interpreters of one of the constituent +elements of our life. + +1865, 1880. + +NOTES + +65. *The latter part of this paper, like that on Dante Gabriel +Rossetti, was contributed to Mr. T. H. Ward's English Poets. + +68. +Transliteration: ousia akhromatos, askhematistos, anaphes. +Translation: "the colorless, utterly formless, intangible essence." +Phaedrus 247C. + +80. +The two passages are not indented in the original; they are in +smaller typeface that makes for difficult reading. + +86. +Transliteration: aei en sphodra orexei. Translation: "always +greatly yearning." + +104. +Transliteration: tryphes, habrotetos, khlides, khariton, +himerou, pothou pater. Translation: "Of daintiness, delicacy, +luxury, graces, father of desire." + + + +CHARLES LAMB + +[105] THOSE English critics who at the beginning of the present +century introduced from Germany, together with some other subtleties +of thought transplanted hither not without advantage, the distinction +between the Fancy and the Imagination, made much also of the cognate +distinction between Wit and Humour, between that unreal and +transitory mirth, which is as the crackling of thorns under the pot, +and the laughter which blends with tears and even with the +sublimities of the imagination, and which, in its most exquisite +motives, is one with pity--the laughter of the comedies of +Shakespeare, hardly less expressive than his moods of seriousness or +solemnity, of that deeply stirred soul of sympathy in him, as flowing +from which both tears and laughter are alike genuine and contagious. + +This distinction between wit and humour, Coleridge and other kindred +critics applied, with much effect, in their studies of some of our +older English writers. And as the distinction between imagination +and fancy, made popular by Wordsworth, [106] found its best +justification in certain essential differences of stuff in +Wordsworth's own writings, so this other critical distinction, +between wit and humour, finds a sort of visible interpretation and +instance in the character and writings of Charles Lamb;--one who +lived more consistently than most writers among subtle literary +theories, and whose remains are still full of curious interest for +the student of literature as a fine art. + +The author of the English Humourists of the Eighteenth Century, +coming to the humourists of the nineteenth, would have found, as is +true preeminently of Thackeray himself, the springs of pity in them +deepened by the deeper subjectivity, the intenser and closer living +with itself, which is characteristic of the temper of the later +generation; and therewith, the mirth also, from the amalgam of which +with pity humour proceeds, has become, in Charles Dickens, for +example, freer and more boisterous. + +To this more high-pitched feeling, since predominant in our +literature, the writings of Charles Lamb, whose life occupies the +last quarter of the eighteenth century and the first quarter of the +nineteenth, are a transition; and such union of grave, of terrible +even, with gay, we may note in the circumstances of his life, as +reflected thence into his work. We catch the aroma of a singular, +homely sweetness about his first years, spent on Thames' side, amid +the red [107] bricks and terraced gardens, with their rich historical +memories of old-fashioned legal London. Just above the poorer class, +deprived, as he says, of the "sweet food of academic institution," he +is fortunate enough to be reared in the classical languages at an +ancient school, where he becomes the companion of Coleridge, as at a +later period he was his enthusiastic disciple. So far, the years go +by with less than the usual share of boyish difficulties; protected, +one fancies, seeing what he was afterwards, by some attraction of +temper in the quaint child, small and delicate, with a certain Jewish +expression in his clear, brown complexion, eyes not precisely of the +same colour, and a slow walk adding to the staidness of his figure; +and whose infirmity of speech, increased by agitation, is partly +engaging. + +And the cheerfulness of all this, of the mere aspect of Lamb's quiet +subsequent life also, might make the more superficial reader think of +him as in himself something slight, and of his mirth as cheaply +bought. Yet we know that beneath this blithe surface there was +something of the fateful domestic horror, of the beautiful heroism +and devotedness too, of old Greek tragedy. His sister Mary, ten +years his senior, in a sudden paroxysm of madness, caused the death +of her mother, and was brought to trial for what an overstrained +justice might have construed as the greatest of crimes. She was +[108] released on the brother's pledging himself to watch over her; +and to this sister, from the age of twenty-one, Charles Lamb +sacrificed himself, "seeking thenceforth," says his earliest +biographer, "no connexion which could interfere with her supremacy in +his affections, or impair his ability to sustain and comfort her." +The "feverish, romantic tie of love," he cast away in exchange for +the "charities of home." Only, from time to time, the madness +returned, affecting him too, once; and we see the brother and sister +voluntarily yielding to restraint. In estimating the humour of Elia, +we must no more forget the strong undercurrent of this great +misfortune and pity, than one could forget it in his actual story. +So he becomes the best critic, almost the discoverer, of Webster, a +dramatist of genius so sombre, so heavily coloured, so macabre. +Rosamund Grey, written in his twenty-third year, a story with +something bitter and exaggerated, an almost insane fixedness of gloom +perceptible in it, strikes clearly this note in his work. + +For himself, and from his own point of view, the exercise of his +gift, of his literary art, came to gild or sweeten a life of +monotonous labour, and seemed, as far as regarded others, no very +important thing; availing to give them a little pleasure, and inform +them a little, chiefly in a retrospective manner, but in no way +concerned with the turning of the tides of the great world. And yet +this very modesty, this unambitious [109] way of conceiving his work, +has impressed upon it a certain exceptional enduringness. For of the +remarkable English writers contemporary with Lamb, many were greatly +preoccupied with ideas of practice--religious, moral, political-- +ideas which have since, in some sense or other, entered permanently +into the general consciousness; and, these having no longer any +stimulus for a generation provided with a different stock of ideas, +the writings of those who spent so much of themselves in their +propagation have lost, with posterity, something of what they gained +by them in immediate influence. Coleridge, Wordsworth, Shelley even- +-sharing so largely in the unrest of their own age, and made +personally more interesting thereby, yet, of their actual work, +surrender more to the mere course of time than some of those who may +have seemed to exercise themselves hardly at all in great matters, to +have been little serious, or a little indifferent, regarding them. + +Of this number of the disinterested servants of literature, smaller +in England than in France, Charles Lamb is one. In the making of +prose he realises the principle of art for its own sake, as +completely as Keats in the making of verse. And, working ever close +to the concrete, to the details, great or small, of actual things, +books, persons, and with no part of them blurred to his vision by the +intervention of mere abstract theories, he has reached an enduring +moral effect [l10] also, in a sort of boundless sympathy. +Unoccupied, as he might seem, with great matters, he is in immediate +contact with what is real, especially in its caressing littleness, +that littleness in which there is much of the whole woeful heart of +things, and meets it more than half-way with a perfect understanding +of it. What sudden, unexpected touches of pathos in him!--bearing +witness how the sorrow of humanity, the Weltschmerz, the constant +aching of its wounds, is ever present with him: but what a gift also +for the enjoyment of life in its subtleties, of enjoyment actually +refined by the need of some thoughtful economies and making the most +of things! Little arts of happiness he is ready to teach to others. +The quaint remarks of children which another would scarcely have +heard, he preserves--little flies in the priceless amber of his Attic +wit--and has his "Praise of chimney-sweepers" (as William Blake has +written, with so much natural pathos, the Chimney-sweeper's Song) +valuing carefully their white teeth, and fine enjoyment of white +sheets in stolen sleep at Arundel Castle, as he tells the story, +anticipating something of the mood of our deep humourists of the last +generation. His simple mother-pity for those who suffer by accident, +or unkindness of nature, blindness for instance, or fateful disease +of mind like his sister's, has something primitive in its largeness; +and on behalf of ill-used animals he is early in composing a Pity's +Gift. + +[111] And if, in deeper or more superficial sense, the dead do care +at all for their name and fame, then how must the souls of +Shakespeare and Webster have been stirred, after so long converse +with things that stopped their ears, whether above or below the soil, +at his exquisite appreciations of them; the souls of Titian and of +Hogarth too; for, what has not been observed so generally as the +excellence of his literary criticism, Charles Lamb is a fine critic +of painting also. It was as loyal, self-forgetful work for others, +for Shakespeare's self first, for instance, and then for +Shakespeare's readers, that that too was done: he has the true +scholar's way of forgetting himself in his subject. For though +"defrauded," as we saw, in his young years, "of the sweet food of +academic institution," he is yet essentially a scholar, and all his +work mainly retrospective, as I said; his own sorrows, affections, +perceptions, being alone real to him of the present. "I cannot make +these present times," he says once, "present to me." + +Above all, he becomes not merely an expositor, permanently valuable, +but for Englishmen almost the discoverer of the old English drama. +"The book is such as I am glad there should be," he modestly says of +the Specimens of English Dramatic Poets who lived about the time of +Shakespeare; to which, however, he adds in a series of notes the very +quintessence of criticism, the choicest savour and perfume of +Elizabethan poetry being [112] sorted, and stored here, with a sort +of delicate intellectual epicureanism, which has had the effect of +winning for these, then almost forgotten, poets, one generation after +another of enthusiastic students. Could he but have known how fresh +a source of culture he was evoking there for other generations, +through all those years in which, a little wistfully, he would harp +on the limitation of his time by business, and sigh for a better +fortune in regard to literary opportunities! + +To feel strongly the charm of an old poet or moralist, the literary +charm of Burton, for instance, or Quarles, or The Duchess of +Newcastle; and then to interpret that charm, to convey it to others-- +he seeming to himself but to hand on to others, in mere humble +ministration, that of which for them he is really the creator--this +is the way of his criticism; cast off in a stray letter often, or +passing note, or lightest essay or conversation. It is in such a +letter, for instance, that we come upon a singularly penetrative +estimate of the genius and writings of Defoe. + +Tracking, with an attention always alert, the whole process of their +production to its starting-point in the deep places of the mind, he +seems to realise the but half-conscious intuitions of Hogarth or +Shakespeare, and develops the great ruling unities which have swayed +their actual work; or "puts up," and takes, the one morsel of good +stuff in an old, forgotten writer. Even [113] in what he says +casually there comes an aroma of old English; noticeable echoes, in +chance turn and phrase, of the great masters of style, the old +masters. Godwin, seeing in quotation a passage from John Woodvil, +takes it for a choice fragment of an old dramatist, and goes to Lamb +to assist him in finding the author. His power of delicate imitation +in prose and verse reaches the length of a fine mimicry even, as in +those last essays of Elia on Popular Fallacies, with their gentle +reproduction or caricature of Sir Thomas Browne, showing, the more +completely, his mastery, by disinterested study, of those elements of +the man which were the real source of style in that great, solemn +master of old English, who, ready to say what he has to say with +fearless homeliness, yet continually overawes one with touches of a +strange utterance from worlds afar. For it is with the delicacies of +fine literature especially, its gradations of expression, its fine +judgment, its pure sense of words, of vocabulary--things, alas! dying +out in the English literature of the present, together with the +appreciation of them in our literature of the past--that his literary +mission is chiefly concerned. And yet, delicate, refining, daintily +epicurean, as he may seem, when he writes of giants, such as Hogarth +or Shakespeare, though often but in a stray note, you catch the sense +of veneration with which those great names in past literature and art +brooded over his intelligence, his undiminished [114] impressibility +by the great effects in them. Reading, commenting on Shakespeare, he +is like a man who walks alone under a grand stormy sky, and among +unwonted tricks of light, when powerful spirits might seem to be +abroad upon the air; and the grim humour of Hogarth, as he analyses +it, rises into a kind of spectral grotesque; while he too knows the +secret of fine, significant touches like theirs. + +There are traits, customs, characteristics of houses and dress, +surviving morsels of old life, such as Hogarth has transferred so +vividly into The Rake's Progress, or Marriage a la Mode, concerning +which we well understand how, common, uninteresting, or even +worthless in themselves, they have come to please us at last as +things picturesque, being set in relief against the modes of our +different age. Customs, stiff to us, stiff dresses, stiff furniture- +-types of cast-off fashions, left by accident, and which no one ever +meant to preserve--we contemplate with more than good-nature, as +having in them the veritable accent of a time, not altogether to be +replaced by its more solemn and self-conscious deposits; like those +tricks of individuality which we find quite tolerable in persons, +because they convey to us the secret of lifelike expression, and with +regard to which we are all to some extent humourists. But it is part +of the privilege of the genuine humourist to anticipate this pensive +mood with regard to the ways and things [115] of his own day; to look +upon the tricks in manner of the life about him with that same +refined, purged sort of vision, which will come naturally to those of +a later generation, in observing whatever may have survived by chance +of its mere external habit. Seeing things always by the light of an +understanding more entire than is possible for ordinary minds, of the +whole mechanism of humanity, and seeing also the manner, the outward +mode or fashion, always in strict connexion with the spiritual +condition which determined it, a humourist such as Charles Lamb +anticipates the enchantment of distance; and the characteristics of +places, ranks, habits of life, are transfigured for him, even now and +in advance of time, by poetic light; justifying what some might +condemn as mere sentimentality, in the effort to hand on unbroken the +tradition of such fashion or accent. "The praise of beggars," "the +cries of London," the traits of actors just grown "old," the spots in +"town" where the country, its fresh green and fresh water, still +lingered on, one after another, amidst the bustle; the quaint, +dimmed, just played-out farces, he had relished so much, coming +partly through them to understand the earlier English theatre as a +thing once really alive; those fountains and sun-dials of old +gardens, of which he entertains such dainty discourse:--he feels the +poetry of these things, as the poetry of things old indeed, but +surviving [116] as an actual part of the life of the present; and as +something quite different from the poetry of things flatly gone from +us and antique, which come back to us, if at all, as entire +strangers, like Scott's old Scotch-border personages, their oaths and +armour. Such gift of appreciation depends, as I said, on the +habitual apprehension of men's life as a whole--its organic +wholeness, as extending even to the least things in it--of its +outward manner in connexion with its inward temper; and it involves a +fine perception of the congruities, the musical accordance between +humanity and its environment of custom, society, personal +intercourse; as if all this, with its meetings, partings, ceremonies, +gesture, tones of speech, were some delicate instrument on which an +expert performer is playing. + +These are some of the characteristics of Elia, one essentially an +essayist, and of the true family of Montaigne, "never judging," as he +says, "system-wise of things, but fastening on particulars;" saying +all things as it were on chance occasion only, and by way of pastime, +yet succeeding thus, "glimpse-wise," in catching and recording more +frequently than others "the gayest, happiest attitude of things;" a +casual writer for dreamy readers, yet always giving the reader so +much more than he seemed to propose. There is something of the +follower of George Fox about him, and the Quaker's belief in the +inward light coming to one passive, [117] to the mere wayfarer, who +will be sure at all events to lose no light which falls by the way-- +glimpses, suggestions, delightful half-apprehensions, profound +thoughts of old philosophers, hints of the innermost reason in +things, the full knowledge of which is held in reserve; all the +varied stuff, that is, of which genuine essays are made. + +And with him, as with Montaigne, the desire of self-portraiture is, +below all more superficial tendencies, the real motive in writing at +all--a desire closely connected with that intimacy, that modern +subjectivity, which may be called the Montaignesque element in +literature. What he designs is to give you himself, to acquaint you +with his likeness; but must do this, if at all, indirectly, being +indeed always more or less reserved, for himself and his friends; +friendship counting for so much in his life, that he is jealous of +anything that might jar or disturb it, even to the length of a sort +of insincerity, to which he assigns its quaint "praise"; this lover +of stage plays significantly welcoming a little touch of the +artificiality of play to sweeten the intercourse of actual life. + +And, in effect, a very delicate and expressive portrait of him does +put itself together for the duly meditative reader. In indirect +touches of his own work, scraps of faded old letters, what others +remembered of his talk, the man's likeness emerges; what he laughed +and wept at, [118] his sudden elevations, and longings after absent +friends, his fine casuistries of affection and devices to jog +sometimes, as he says, the lazy happiness of perfect love, his solemn +moments of higher discourse with the young, as they came across him +on occasion, and went along a little way with him, the sudden, +surprised apprehension of beauties in old literature, revealing anew +the deep soul of poetry in things, and withal the pure spirit of fun, +having its way again; laughter, that most short-lived of all things +(some of Shakespeare's even being grown hollow) wearing well with +him. Much of all this comes out through his letters, which may be +regarded as a department of his essays. He is an old-fashioned +letter-writer, the essence of the old fashion of letter-writing +lying, as with true essay-writing, in the dexterous availing oneself +of accident and circumstance, in the prosecution of deeper lines of +observation; although, just as with the record of his conversation, +one loses something, in losing the actual tones of the stammerer, +still graceful in his halting, as he halted also in composition, +composing slowly and by fits, "like a Flemish painter," as he tells +us, so "it is to be regretted," says the editor of his letters, "that +in the printed letters the reader will lose the curious varieties of +writing with which the originals abound, and which are scrupulously +adapted to the subject." + +Also, he was a true "collector," delighting [119] in the personal +finding of a thing, in the colour an old book or print gets for him +by the little accidents which attest previous ownership. Wither's +Emblems, "that old book and quaint," long-desired, when he finds it +at last, he values none the less because a child had coloured the +plates with his paints. A lover of household warmth everywhere, of +that tempered atmosphere which our various habitations get by men's +living within them, he "sticks to his favourite books as he did to +his friends," and loved the "town," with a jealous eye for all its +characteristics, "old houses" coming to have souls for him. The +yearning for mere warmth against him in another, makes him content, +all through life, with pure brotherliness, "the most kindly and +natural species of love," as he says, in place of the passion of +love. Brother and sister, sitting thus side by side, have, of +course, their anticipations how one of them must sit at last in the +faint sun alone, and set us speculating, as we read, as to precisely +what amount of melancholy really accompanied for him the approach of +old age, so steadily foreseen; make us note also, with pleasure, his +successive wakings up to cheerful realities, out of a too curious +musing over what is gone and what remains, of life. In his subtle +capacity for enjoying the more refined points of earth, of human +relationship, he could throw the gleam of poetry or humour on what +seemed common or threadbare; has a care for the [120] sighs, and the +weary, humdrum preoccupations of very weak people, down to their +little pathetic "gentilities," even; while, in the purely human +temper, he can write of death, almost like Shakespeare. + +And that care, through all his enthusiasm of discovery, for what is +accustomed, in literature, connected thus with his close clinging to +home and the earth, was congruous also with that love for the +accustomed in religion, which we may notice in him. He is one of the +last votaries of that old-world sentiment, based on the feelings of +hope and awe, which may be described as the religion of men of +letters (as Sir Thomas Browne has his Religion of the Physician) +religion as understood by the soberer men of letters in the last +century, Addison, Gray, and Johnson; by Jane Austen and Thackeray, +later. A high way of feeling developed largely by constant +intercourse with the great things of literature, and extended in its +turn to those matters greater still, this religion lives, in the main +retrospectively, in a system of received sentiments and beliefs; +received, like those great things of literature and art, in the first +instance, on the authority of a long tradition, in the course of +which they have linked themselves in a thousand complex ways to the +conditions of human life, and no more questioned now than the feeling +one keeps by one of the greatness--say! of Shakespeare. For Charles +Lamb, such form of religion becomes [121] the solemn background on +which the nearer and more exciting objects of his immediate +experience relieve themselves, borrowing from it an expression of +calm; its necessary atmosphere being indeed a profound quiet, that +quiet which has in it a kind of sacramental efficacy, working, we +might say, on the principle of the opus operatum, almost without any +co-operation of one's own, towards the assertion of the higher self. +And, in truth, to men of Lamb's delicately attuned temperament mere +physical stillness has its full value; such natures seeming to long +for it sometimes, as for no merely negative thing, with a sort of +mystical sensuality. + +The writings of Charles Lamb are an excellent illustration of the +value of reserve in literature. Below his quiet, his quaintness, his +humour, and what may seem the slightness, the occasional or +accidental character of his work, there lies, as I said at starting, +as in his life, a genuinely tragic element. The gloom, reflected at +its darkest in those hard shadows of Rosamund Grey, is always there, +though not always realised either for himself or his readers, and +restrained always in utterance. It gives to those lighter matters on +the surface of life and literature among which he for the most part +moved, a wonderful force of expression, as if at any moment these +slight words and fancies might pierce very far into the deeper soul +of things. In his writing, as in his [122] life, that quiet is not +the low-flying of one from the first drowsy by choice, and needing +the prick of some strong passion or worldly ambition, to stimulate +him into all the energy of which he is capable; but rather the +reaction of nature, after an escape from fate, dark and insane as in +old Greek tragedy, following upon which the sense of mere relief +becomes a kind of passion, as with one who, having narrowly escaped +earthquake or shipwreck, finds a thing for grateful tears in just +sitting quiet at home, under the wall, till the end of days. + +He felt the genius of places; and I sometimes think he resembles the +places he knew and liked best, and where his lot fell--London, sixty- +five years ago, with Covent Garden and the old theatres, and the +Temple gardens still unspoiled, Thames gliding down, and beyond to +north and south the fields at Enfield or Hampton, to which, "with +their living trees," the thoughts wander "from the hard wood of the +desk"--fields fresher, and coming nearer to town then, but in one of +which the present writer remembers, on a brooding early summer's day, +to have heard the cuckoo for the first time. Here, the surface of +things is certainly humdrum, the streets dingy, the green places, +where the child goes a-maying, tame enough. But nowhere are things +more apt to respond to the brighter weather, nowhere is there so much +difference between rain and sunshine, nowhere do the [123] clouds +roll together more grandly; those quaint suburban pastorals gathering +a certain quality of grandeur from the background of the great city, +with its weighty atmosphere, and portent of storm in the rapid light +on dome and bleached stone steeples. + +1878. + + + +SIR THOMAS BROWNE + +[124] ENGLISH prose literature towards the end of the seventeenth +century, in the hands of Dryden and Locke, was becoming, as that of +France had become at an earlier date, a matter of design and skilled +practice, highly conscious of itself as an art, and, above all, +correct. Up to that time it had been, on the whole, singularly +informal and unprofessional, and by no means the literature of the +"man of letters," as we understand him. Certain great instances +there had been of literary structure or architecture--The +Ecclesiastical Polity, The Leviathan--but for the most part that +earlier prose literature is eminently occasional, closely determined +by the eager practical aims of contemporary politics and theology, or +else due to a man's own native instinct to speak because he cannot +help speaking. Hardly aware of the habit, he likes talking to +himself; and when he writes (still in undress) he does but take the +"friendly reader" into his confidence. The type of this literature, +obviously, is not Locke or Gibbon, but, above all others, Sir Thomas +[125] Browne; as Jean Paul is a good instance of it in German +literature, always in its developments so much later than the +English; and as the best instance of it in French literature, in the +century preceding Browne, is Montaigne, from whom indeed, in a great +measure, all those tentative writers, or essayists, derive. + +It was a result, perhaps, of the individualism and liberty of +personal development, which, even for a Roman Catholic, were effects +of the Reformation, that there was so much in Montaigne of the +"subjective," as people say, of the singularities of personal +character. Browne, too, bookish as he really is claims to give his +readers a matter, "not picked from the leaves of any author, but bred +amongst the weeds and tares" of his own brain. The faults of such +literature are what we all recognise in it: unevenness, alike in +thought and style; lack of design; and caprice--the lack of +authority; after the full play of which, there is so much to refresh +one in the reasonable transparency of Hooker, representing thus early +the tradition of a classical clearness in English literature, +anticipated by Latimer and More, and to be fulfilled afterwards in +Butler and Hume. But then, in recompense for that looseness and +whim, in Sir Thomas Browne for instance, we have in those "quaint" +writers, as they themselves understood the term (coint, adorned, but +adorned with all the curious ornaments of their own predilection, +provincial [126] or archaic, certainly unfamiliar, and selected +without reference to the taste or usages of other people) the charm +of an absolute sincerity, with all the ingenuous and racy effect of +what is circumstantial and peculiar in their growth. + +The whole creation is a mystery and particularly that of man. +At the blast of His mouth were the rest of the creatures made, +and at His bare word they started out of nothing. But in the +frame of man He played the sensible operator, and seemed not +so much to create as to make him. When He had separated the +materials of other creatures, there consequently resulted a +form and soul: but having raised the walls of man, He was +driven to a second and harder creation--of a substance like +Himself, an incorruptible and immortal soul. + +There, we have the manner of Sir Thomas Browne, in exact expression +of his mind!--minute and curious in its thinking; but with an effect, +on the sudden, of a real sublimity or depth. His style is certainly +an unequal one. It has the monumental aim which charmed, and perhaps +influenced, Johnson--a dignity that can be attained only in such +mental calm as follows long and learned pondering on the high +subjects Browne loves to deal with. It has its garrulity, its +various levels of painstaking, its mannerism, pleasant of its kind or +tolerable, together with much, to us intolerable, but of which he was +capable on a lazy summer afternoon down at Norwich. And all is so +oddly mixed, showing, in its entire ignorance of self, how much he, +and the sort of literature he represents, really stood in need of +technique, [127] of a formed taste in literature, of a literary +architecture. + +And yet perhaps we could hardly wish the result different, in him, +any more than in the books of Burton and Fuller, or some other +similar writers of that age--mental abodes, we might liken, after +their own manner, to the little old private houses of some historic +town grouped about its grand public structures, which, when they have +survived at all, posterity is loth to part with. For, in their +absolute sincerity, not only do these authors clearly exhibit +themselves ("the unique peculiarity of the writer's mind," being, as +Johnson says of Browne, "faithfully reflected in the form and matter +of his work") but, even more than mere professionally instructed +writers, they belong to, and reflect, the age they lived in. In +essentials, of course, even Browne is by no means so unique among his +contemporaries, and so singular, as he looks. And then, as the very +condition of their work, there is an entire absence of personal +restraint in dealing with the public, whose humours they come at last +in a great measure to reproduce. To speak more properly, they have +no sense of a "public" to deal with, at all--only a full confidence +in the "friendly reader," as they love to call him. Hence their +amazing pleasantry, their indulgence in their own conceits; but hence +also those unpremeditated wildflowers of speech we should [128] never +have the good luck to find in any more formal kind of literature. + +It is, in truth, to the literary purpose of the humourist, in the +old-fashioned sense of the term, that this method of writing +naturally allies itself--of the humourist to whom all the world is +but a spectacle in which nothing is really alien from himself, who +has hardly a sense of the distinction between great and little among +things that are at all, and whose half-pitying, half-amused sympathy +is called out especially by the seemingly small interests and traits +of character in the things or the people around him. Certainly, in +an age stirred by great causes, like the age of Browne in England, of +Montaigne in France, that is not a type to which one would wish to +reduce all men of letters. Still, in an age apt also to become +severe, or even cruel (its eager interest in those great causes +turning sour on occasion) the character of the humourist may well +find its proper influence, through that serene power, and the leisure +it has for conceiving second thoughts, on the tendencies, conscious +or unconscious, of the fierce wills around it. Something of such a +humourist was Browne--not callous to men and their fortunes; +certainly not without opinions of his own about them; and yet, +undisturbed by the civil war, by the fall, and then the restoration, +of the monarchy, through that long quiet life (ending at last on the +day [129] himself had predicted, as if at the moment he had willed) +in which "all existence," as he says, "had been but food for +contemplation." + +Johnson, in beginning his Life of Browne, remarks that Browne "seems +to have had the fortune, common among men of letters, of raising +little curiosity after their private life." Whether or not, with the +example of Johnson himself before us, we can think just that, it is +certain that Browne's works are of a kind to directly stimulate +curiosity about himself--about himself, as being manifestly so large +a part of those works; and as a matter of fact we know a great deal +about his life, uneventful as in truth it was. To himself, indeed, +his life at Norwich, as he gives us to understand, seemed wonderful +enough. "Of these wonders," says Johnson, "the view that can now be +taken of his life offers no appearance." But "we carry with us," as +Browne writes, "the wonders we seek without us," and we may note on +the other hand, a circumstance which his daughter, Mrs. Lyttleton, +tells us of his childhood: "His father used to open his breast when +he was asleep, and kiss it in prayers over him, as 'tis said of +Origen's father, that the Holy Ghost would take possession there." +It was perhaps because the son inherited an aptitude for a like +profound kindling of sentiment in the taking of his life, that, +uneventful as it was, [130] commonplace as it seemed to Johnson, to +Browne himself it was so full of wonders, and so stimulates the +curiosity of his more careful reader of to-day. "What influence," +says Johnson again, "learning has had on its possessors may be +doubtful." Well! the influence of his great learning, of his +constant research on Browne, was its imaginative influence--that it +completed his outfit as a poetic visionary, stirring all the strange +"conceit" of his nature to its depths. + +Browne himself dwells, in connexion with the first publication +(extorted by circumstance) of the Religio Medici, on the natural +"inactivity of his disposition"; and he does, as I have said, pass +very quietly through an exciting time. Born in the year of the +Gunpowder Plot, he was not, in truth, one of those clear and +clarifying souls which, in an age alike of practical and mental +confusion, can anticipate and lay down the bases of reconstruction, +like Bacon or Hooker. His mind has much of the perplexity which was +part of the atmosphere of the time. Not that he is without his own +definite opinions on events. For him, Cromwell is a usurper, the +death of Charles an abominable murder. In spite of what is but an +affectation, perhaps, of the sceptical mood, he is a Churchman too; +one of those who entered fully into the Anglican position, so full of +sympathy with those ceremonies and observances [131] which "misguided +zeal terms superstition," that there were some Roman Catholics who +thought that nothing but custom and education kept him from their +communion. At the Restoration he rejoices to see the return of the +comely Anglican order in old episcopal Norwich, with its ancient +churches; the antiquity, in particular, of the English Church being, +characteristically, one of the things he most valued in it, +vindicating it, when occasion came, against the "unjust scandal" of +those who made that Church a creation of Henry the Eighth. As to +Romanists--he makes no scruple to "enter their churches in defect of +ours." He cannot laugh at, but rather pities, "the fruitless +journeys of pilgrims--for there is something in it of devotion." He +could never "hear the Ave Mary! bell without an oraison." At a +solemn procession he has "wept abundantly." How English, in truth, +all this really is! It reminds one how some of the most popular of +English writers, in many a half-conscious expression, have witnessed +to a susceptibility in the English mind itself, in spite of the +Reformation, to what is affecting in religious ceremony. Only, in +religion as in politics, Browne had no turn for disputes; was +suspicious of them, indeed; knowing, as he says with true acumen, +that "a man may be in as just possession of truth as of a city, and +yet be forced to surrender," even in controversies not [132] +necessarily maladroit--an image in which we may trace a little +contemporary colouring. + +The Enquiries into Vulgar Errors appeared in the year 1646; a year +which found him very hard on "the vulgar." His suspicion, in the +abstract, of what Bacon calls Idola Fori, the Idols of the Market- +place, takes a special emphasis from the course of events about him: +"being erroneous in their single numbers, once huddled together, they +will be error itself." And yet, congruously with a dreamy sweetness +of character we may find expressed in his very features, he seems not +greatly concerned at the temporary suppression of the institutions he +values so much. He seems to possess some inward Platonic reality of +them--church or monarchy--to hold by in idea, quite beyond the reach +of Roundhead or unworthy Cavalier. In the power of what is inward +and inviolable in his religion, he can still take note: "In my +solitary and retired imagination (neque enim cum porticus aut me +lectulus accepit, desum mihi) I remember I am not alone, and +therefore forget not to contemplate Him and His attributes who is +ever with me." + +His father, a merchant of London, with some claims to ancient +descent, left him early in possession of ample means. Educated at +Winchester and Oxford, he visited Ireland, France, and Italy; and in +the year 1633, at the age of twenty-eight, became Doctor of Medicine +at Leyden. Three years later he established himself as a physician +[133] at Norwich for the remainder of his life, having married a +lady, described as beautiful and attractive, and affectionate also, +as we may judge from her letters and postscripts to those of her +husband, in an orthography of a homeliness amazing even for that age. +Dorothy Browne bore him ten children, six of whom he survived. + +Their house at Norwich, even then an old one it would seem, must have +grown, through long years of acquisition, into an odd cabinet of +antiquities--antiquities properly so called; his old Roman, or +Romanised British urns, from Walsingham or Brampton, for instance, +and those natural objects which he studied somewhat in the temper of +a curiosity-hunter or antiquary. In one of the old churchyards of +Norwich he makes the first discovery of adipocere, of which grim +substance "a portion still remains with him." For his multifarious +experiments he must have had his laboratory. The old window- +stanchions had become magnetic, proving, as he thinks, that iron +"acquires verticity" from long lying in one position. Once we find +him re-tiling the place. It was then, perhaps, that he made the +observation that bricks and tiles also acquire "magnetic alliciency"- +-one's whole house, one might fancy; as indeed, he holds the earth +itself to be a vast lodestone. + +The very faults of his literary work, its desultoriness, the time it +costs his readers, that [134] slow Latinity which Johnson imitated +from him, those lengthy leisurely terminations which busy posterity +will abbreviate, all breathe of the long quiet of the place. Yet he +is by no means indolent. Besides wide book-learning, experimental +research at home, and indefatigable observation in the open air, he +prosecutes the ordinary duties of a physician; contrasting himself +indeed with other students, "whose quiet and unmolested doors afford +no such distractions." To most persons of mind sensitive as his, his +chosen studies would have seemed full of melancholy, turning always, +as they did, upon death and decay. It is well, perhaps, that life +should be something of a "meditation upon death": but to many, +certainly, Browne's would have seemed too like a lifelong following +of one's own funeral. A museum is seldom a cheerful place--oftenest +induces the feeling that nothing could ever have been young; and to +Browne the whole world is a museum; all the grace and beauty it has +being of a somewhat mortified kind. Only, for him (poetic dream, or +philosophic apprehension, it was this which never failed to evoke his +wonderful genius for exquisitely impassioned speech) over all those +ugly anatomical preparations, as though over miraculous saintly +relics, there was the perpetual flicker of a surviving spiritual +ardency, one day to reassert itself--stranger far than any fancied +odylic gravelights! + +[135] When Browne settled at Norwich, being then about thirty-six +years old, he had already completed the Religio Medici; a desultory +collection of observations designed for himself only and a few +friends, at all events with no purpose of immediate publication. It +had been lying by him for seven years, circulating privately in his +own extraordinarily perplexed manuscript, or in manuscript copies, +when, in 1642, an incorrect printed version from one of those copies, +"much corrupted by transcription at various hands," appeared +anonymously. Browne, decided royalist as he was in spite of seeming +indifference, connects this circumstance with the unscrupulous use of +the press for political purposes, and especially against the king, at +that time. Just here a romantic figure comes on the scene. Son of +the unfortunate young Everard Digby who perished on the scaffold for +some half-hearted participation in the Gunpowder Plot, Kenelm Digby, +brought up in the reformed religion, had returned in manhood to the +religion of his father. In his intellectual composition he had, in +common with Browne, a scientific interest, oddly tinged with both +poetry and scepticism: he had also a strong sympathy with religious +reaction, and a more than sentimental love for a seemingly vanishing +age of faith, which he, for one, would not think of as vanishing. A +copy of that surreptitious edition of the Religio Medici found him a +prisoner on suspicion of a too active [136] royalism, and with much +time on his hands. + +The Roman Catholic, although, secure in his definite orthodoxy, he +finds himself indifferent on many points (on the reality of +witchcraft, for instance) concerning which Browne's more timid, +personally grounded faith might indulge no scepticism, forced +himself, nevertheless, to detect a vein of rationalism in a book +which on the whole much attracted him, and hastily put forth his +"animadversions" upon it. Browne, with all his distaste for +controversy, thus found himself committed to a dispute, and his reply +came with the correct edition of the Religio Medici published at last +with his name. There have been many efforts to formulate the +"religion of the layman," which might be rightly understood, perhaps, +as something more than what is called "natural," yet less than +ecclesiastical, or "professional" religion. Though its habitual mode +of conceiving experience is on a different plane, yet it would +recognise the legitimacy of the traditional religious interpretation +of that experience, generally and by implication; only, with a marked +reserve as to religious particulars, both of thought and language, +out of a real reverence or awe, as proper only for a special place. +Such is the lay religion, as we may find it in Addison, in Gray, in +Thackeray; and there is something of a concession--a concession, on +second thoughts--about it. Browne's Religio Medici is designed as +the expression of a mind [137] more difficult of belief than that of +the mere "layman," as above described; it is meant for the religion +of the man of science. Actually, it is something less to the point, +in any balancing of the religious against the worldly view of things, +than the religion of the layman, as just now defined. For Browne, in +spite of his profession of boisterous doubt, has no real +difficulties, and his religion, certainly, nothing of the character +of a concession. He holds that there has never existed an atheist. +Not that he is credulous; but that his religion is only the +correlative of himself, his peculiar character and education, a +religion of manifold association. For him, the wonders of religion, +its supernatural events or agencies, are almost natural facts or +processes. "Even in this material fabric, the spirits walk as freely +exempt from the affection of time, place and motion, as beyond the +extremest circumference." Had not Divine interference designed to +raise the dead, nature herself is in act to do it--to lead out the +"incinerated soul" from the retreats of her dark laboratory. +Certainly Browne has not, like Pascal, made the "great resolution," +by the apprehension that it is just in the contrast of the moral +world to the world with which science deals that religion finds its +proper basis. It is from the homelessness of the world which science +analyses so victoriously, its dark unspirituality, wherein the soul +he is conscious of seems such a [138] stranger, that Pascal "turns +again to his rest," in the conception of a world of wholly reasonable +and moral agencies. For Browne, on the contrary, the light is full, +design everywhere obvious, its conclusion easy to draw, all small and +great things marked clearly with the signature of the "Word." The +adhesion, the difficult adhesion, of men such as Pascal, is an +immense contribution to religious controversy; the concession, again, +of a man like Addison, of great significance there. But in the +adhesion of Browne, in spite of his crusade against "vulgar errors," +there is no real significance. The Religio Medici is a contribution, +not to faith, but to piety; a refinement and correction, such as +piety often stands in need of; a help, not so much to religious +belief in a world of doubt, as to the maintenance of the religious +mood amid the interests of a secular calling. + +From about this time Browne's letters afford a pretty clear view of +his life as it passed in the house at Norwich. Many of these letters +represent him in correspondence with the singular men who shared his +own half poetic, half scientific turn of mind, with that +impressibility towards what one might call the thaumaturgic elements +in nature which has often made men dupes, and which is certainly an +element in the somewhat atrabiliar mental complexion of that age in +England. He corresponds seriously with William Lily, the astrologer; +is acquainted [139] with Dr. Dee, who had some connexion with +Norwich, and has "often heard him affirm, sometimes with oaths, that +he had seen transmutation of pewter dishes and flagons into silver +(at least) which the goldsmiths at Prague bought of him." Browne is +certainly an honest investigator; but it is still with a faint hope +of something like that upon fitting occasion, and on the alert always +for surprises in nature (as if nature had a rhetoric, at times, to +deliver to us, like those sudden and surprising flowers of his own +poetic style) that he listens to her everyday talk so attentively. +Of strange animals, strange cures, and the like, his correspondence +is full. The very errors he combats are, of course, the curiosities +of error--those fascinating, irresistible, popular, errors, which +various kinds of people have insisted on gliding into because they +like them. Even his heresies were old ones--the very fossils of +capricious opinion. + +It is as an industrious local naturalist that Browne comes before us +first, full of the fantastic minute life in the fens and "Broads" +around Norwich, its various sea and marsh birds. He is something of +a vivisectionist also, and we may not be surprised at it, perhaps, in +an age which, for the propagation of truth, was ready to cut off +men's ears. He finds one day "a Scarabaus capricornus odoratus," +which he takes "to be mentioned by Monfetus, folio 150. He saith, +'Nucem moschatam et cinnamomum vere spirat'--[140] but to me it smelt +like roses, santalum, and ambergris." "Musca tuliparum moschata," +again, "is a small bee-like fly of an excellent fragrant odour, which +I have often found at the bottom of the flowers of tulips." Is this +within the experience of modern entomologists? + +The Garden of Cyrus, though it ends indeed with a passage of +wonderful felicity, certainly emphasises (to say the least) the +defects of Browne's literary good qualities. His chimeric fancy +carries him here into a kind of frivolousness, as if he felt almost +too safe with his public, and were himself not quite serious, or +dealing fairly with it; and in a writer such as Browne levity must of +necessity be a little ponderous. Still, like one of those stiff +gardens, half-way between the medieval garden and the true "English" +garden of Temple or Walpole, actually to be seen in the background of +some of the conventional portraits of that day, the fantasies of this +indescribable exposition of the mysteries of the quincunx form part +of the complete portrait of Browne himself; and it is in connexion +with it that, once or twice, the quaintly delightful pen of Evelyn +comes into the correspondence--in connexion with the "hortulane +pleasure." "Norwich," he writes to Browne, "is a place, I +understand, much addicted to the flowery part." Professing himself a +believer in the operation "of the air and genius of gardens upon +human spirits, towards virtue and sanctity," he is all for [141] +natural gardens as against "those which appear like gardens of paste- +board and march-pane, and smell more of paint than of flowers and +verdure." Browne is in communication also with Ashmole and Dugdale, +the famous antiquaries; to the latter of whom, who had written a work +on the history of the embanking of fens, he communicates the +discovery of certain coins, on a piece of ground "in the nature of an +island in the fens." + +Far more interesting certainly than those curious scientific letters +is Browne's "domestic correspondence." Dobson, Charles the First's +"English Tintoret," would seem to have painted a life-sized picture +of Sir Thomas Browne and his family, after the manner of those big, +urbane, family groups, then coming into fashion with the Dutch +Masters. Of such a portrait nothing is now known. But in these old- +fashioned, affectionate letters, transmitted often, in those +troublous times, with so much difficulty, we have what is almost as +graphic--a numerous group, in which, although so many of Browne's +children died young, he was happy; with Dorothy Browne, occasionally +adding her charming, ill-spelt postscripts to her husband's letters; +the religious daughter who goes to daily prayers after the +Restoration, which brought Browne the honour of knighthood; and, +above all, two Toms, son and grandson of Sir Thomas, the latter being +the son of Dr. Edward Browne, [142] now become distinguished as a +physician in London (he attended John, Earl of Rochester, in his last +illness at Woodstock) and his childish existence as he lives away +from his proper home in London, in the old house at Norwich, two +hundred years ago, we see like a thing of to-day. + +At first the two brothers, Edward and Thomas (the elder) are together +in everything. Then Edward goes abroad for his studies, and Thomas, +quite early, into the navy, where he certainly develops into a +wonderfully gallant figure; passing away, however, from the +correspondence, it is uncertain how, before he was of full age. From +the first he is understood to be a lad of parts. "If you practise to +write, you will have a good pen and style:" and a delightful, boyish +journal of his remains, describing a tour the two brothers made in +September 1662 among the Derbyshire hills. "I received your two last +letters," he writes to his father from aboard the Marie Rose, "and +give you many thanks for the discourse you sent me out of Vossius: De +motu marium et ventorum. It seemed very hard to me at first; but I +have now beaten it, and I wish I had the book." His father is +pleased to think that he is "like to proceed not only a good +navigator, but a good scholar": and he finds the much exacting, old +classical prescription for the character of the brave man fulfilled +in him. On 16th July 1666 the young man writes--still from the Marie +Rose-- + +[143] If it were possible to get an opportunity to send as often +as I am desirous to write, you should hear more often from me, +being now so near the grand action, from which I would by no means +be absent. I extremely long for that thundering day: wherein I +hope you shall hear we have behaved ourselves like men, and to +the honour of our country. I thank you for your directions for +my ears against the noise of the guns, but I have found that I +could endure it; nor is it so intolerable as most conceive; +especially when men are earnest, and intent upon their business, +unto whom muskets sound but like pop-guns. It is impossible +to express unto another how a smart sea-fight elevates the spirits +of a man, and makes him despise all dangers. In and after all +sea-fights, I have been very thirsty. + +He died, as I said, early in life. We only hear of him later in +connexion with a trait of character observed in Tom the grandson, +whose winning ways, and tricks of bodily and mental growth, are duly +recorded in these letters: the reader will, I hope, pardon the +following extracts from them:-- + +Little Tom is lively.... Frank is fayne sometimes to play him +asleep with a fiddle. When we send away our letters he scribbles +a paper and will have it sent to his sister, and saith she doth +not know how many fine things there are in Norwich.... He +delights his grandfather when he comes home. + +Tom gives you many thanks for his clothes (from London). He +has appeared very fine this King's day with them. + +Tom presents his duty. A gentleman at our election asked Tom +who hee was for? and he answered, "For all four." The gentleman +replied that he answered like a physician's son. + +Tom would have his grandmother, his aunt Betty, and Frank, +valentines: but hee conditioned with them that they should give +him nothing of any kind that hee had ever had or seen before. + +[144] "Tom is just now gone to see two bears which are to be +shown." "Tom, his duty. He is begging books and reading of +them." "The players are at the Red Lion hard by; and Tom goes +sometimes to see a play." + +And then one day he stirs old memories-- + +The fairings were welcome to Tom. He finds about the house +divers things that were your brother's (the late Edward's), +and Betty sometimes tells him stories about him, so that he +was importunate with her to write his life in a quarter of +a sheet of paper, and read it unto him, and will have still +more added. + +Just as I am writing (learnedly about a comet, 7th January +1680-81) Tom comes and tells me the blazing star is in the +yard, and calls me to see it. It was but dim, and the sky +not clear.... I am very sensible of this sharp weather.+ + +He seems to have come to no good end, riding forth one stormy night. +Requiescat in pace! + +Of this long, leisurely existence the chief events were Browne's rare +literary publications; some of his writings indeed having been left +unprinted till after his death; while in the circumstances of the +issue of every one of them there is something accidental, as if the +world might have missed it altogether. Even the Discourse of Vulgar +Errors, the longest and most elaborate of his works, is entirely +discursive and occasional, coming to an end with no natural +conclusion, but only because the writer chose to leave off just +there; and few probably have been the readers of the book as a +consecutive whole. At times indeed we seem to have in it observations +only, or notes, preliminary to some more orderly composition. Dip +into it: read, for [145] instance, the chapter "Of the Ring-finger," +or the chapters "Of the Long Life of the Deer," and on the "Pictures +of Mermaids, Unicorns, and some Others," and the part will certainly +seem more than the whole. Try to read it through, and you will soon +feel cloyed;--miss very likely, its real worth to the fancy, the +literary fancy (which finds its pleasure in inventive word and +phrase) and become dull to the really vivid beauties of a book so +lengthy, but with no real evolution. Though there are words, +phrases, constructions innumerable, which remind one how much the +work initiated in France by Madame de Rambouillet--work, done for +England, we may think perhaps imperfectly, in the next century by +Johnson and others--was really needed; yet the capacities of Browne's +manner of writing, coming as it did so directly from the man, are +felt even in his treatment of matters of science. As with Buffon, +his full, ardent, sympathetic vocabulary, the poetry of his language, +a poetry inherent in its elementary particles--the word, the epithet- +-helps to keep his eye, and the eye of the reader, on the object +before it, and conduces directly to the purpose of the naturalist, +the observer. But, only one half observation, its other half +consisting of very out-of-the-way book-lore, this work displays +Browne still in the character of the antiquary, as that age +understood him. He is a kind of Elias Ashmole, but dealing with +natural objects; which are for him, in the first [146] place, and +apart from the remote religious hints and intimations they carry with +them, curiosities. He seems to have no true sense of natural law, as +Bacon understood it; nor even of that immanent reason in the natural +world, which the Platonic tradition supposes. "Things are really +true," he says, "as they correspond unto God's conception; and have +so much verity as they hold of conformity unto that intellect, in +whose idea they had their first determinations." But, actually, what +he is busy in the record of, are matters more or less of the nature +of caprices; as if things, after all, were significant of their +higher verity only at random, and in a sort of surprises, like music +in old instruments suddenly touched into sound by a wandering finger, +among the lumber of people's houses. Nature, "the art of God," as he +says, varying a little a phrase used also by Hobbes, in a work +printed later--Nature, he seems to protest, is only a little less +magical, its processes only a little less in the way of alchemy, than +you had supposed. We feel that, as with that disturbed age in +England generally (and it is here that he, with it, is so +interesting, curious, old-world, and unlike ourselves) his supposed +experience might at any moment be broken in upon by a hundred forms +of a natural magic, only not quite so marvellous as that older sort +of magic, or alchemy, he is at so much pains to expose; and the large +promises of which, its large words too, he still regretfully enjoys. + +[147] And yet the Discourse of Vulgar Errors, seeming, as it often +does, to be a serious refutation of fairy tales--arguing, for +instance, against the literal truth of the poetic statement that "The +pigeon hath no gall," and such questions as "Whether men weigh +heavier dead than alive?" being characteristic questions--is +designed, with much ambition, under its pedantic Greek title +Pseudodoxia Epidemica, as a criticism, a cathartic, an instrument for +the clarifying of the intellect. He begins from "that first error in +Paradise," wondering much at "man's deceivability in his +perfection,"--"at such gross deceit." He enters in this connexion, +with a kind of poetry of scholasticism which may interest the student +of Paradise Lost, into what we may call the intellectual and moral +by-play of the situation of the first man and woman in Paradise, with +strange queries about it. Did Adam, for instance, already know of +the fall of the Angels? Did he really believe in death, till Abel +died? It is from Julius Scaliger that he takes his motto, to the +effect that the true knowledge of things must be had from things +themselves, not from books; and he seems as seriously concerned as +Bacon to dissipate the crude impressions of a false "common sense," +of false science, and a fictitious authority. Inverting, oddly, +Plato's theory that all learning is but reminiscence, he reflects +with a sigh how much of oblivion must needs be involved in the +getting of any true knowledge. "Men that [148] adore times past, +consider not that those times were once present (that is, as our own +are) and ourselves unto those to come, as they unto us at present." +That, surely, coming from one both by temperament and habit so great +an antiquary, has the touch of something like an influence in the +atmosphere of the time. That there was any actual connexion between +Browne's work and Bacon's is but a surmise. Yet we almost seem to +hear Bacon when Browne discourses on the "use of doubts, and the +advantages which might be derived from drawing up a calendar of +doubts, falsehoods, and popular errors;" and, as from Bacon, one gets +the impression that men really have been very much the prisoners of +their own crude or pedantic terms, notions, associations; that they +have been very indolent in testing very simple matters--with a +wonderful kind of "supinity," as he calls it. In Browne's chapter on +the "Sources of Error," again, we may trace much resemblance to +Bacon's striking doctrine of the Idola, the "shams" men fall down and +worship. Taking source respectively, from the "common infirmity of +human nature," from the "erroneous disposition of the people," from +"confident adherence to authority," the errors which Browne chooses +to deal with may be registered as identical with Bacon's Idola +Tribus, Fori, Theatri; the idols of our common human nature; of the +vulgar, when they get together; and of the learned, when they get +together. + +[149] But of the fourth species of error noted by Bacon, the Idola +Specus, the Idols of the Cave, that whole tribe of illusions, which +are "bred amongst the weeds and tares of one's own brain," Browne +tells us nothing by way of criticism; was himself, rather, a lively +example of their operation. Throw those illusions, those "idols," +into concrete or personal form, suppose them introduced among the +other forces of an active intellect, and you have Sir Thomas Browne +himself. The sceptical inquirer who rises from his cathartic, his +purging of error, a believer in the supernatural character of pagan +oracles, and a cruel judge of supposed witches, must still need as +much as ever that elementary conception of the right method and the +just limitations of knowledge, by power of which he should not just +strain out a single error here or there, but make a final precipitate +of fallacy. + +And yet if the temperament had been deducted from Browne's work--that +inherent and strongly marked way of deciding things, which has guided +with so surprising effect the musings of the Letter to a Friend, and +the Urn-Burial--we should probably have remembered him little. Pity! +some may think, for himself at least, that he had not lived earlier, +and still believed in the mandrake, for instance; its fondness for +places of execution, and its human cries "on eradication, with hazard +of life to them that pull it up." "In philosophy," he observes, +meaning to contrast [150] his free-thinking in that department with +his orthodoxy in religion--in philosophy, "where truth seems double- +faced, there is no man more paradoxical than myself:" which is true, +we may think, in a further sense than he meant, and that it was the +"paradoxical" that he actually preferred. Happy, at all events, he +still remained--undisturbed and happy--in a hundred native +prepossessions, some certainly valueless, some of them perhaps +invaluable. And while one feels that no real logic of fallacies has +been achieved by him, one feels still more how little the +construction of that branch of logical inquiry really helps men's +minds; fallacy, like truth itself, being a matter so dependent on +innate gift of apprehension, so extra-logical and personal; the +original perception counting for almost everything, the mere +inference for so little! Yes! "A man may be in as just possession +of truth as of a city, and yet be forced to surrender," even in +controversies not necessarily maladroit. + +The really stirring poetry of science is not in guesses, or facile +divinations about it, but in its larger ascertained truths--the order +of infinite space, the slow method and vast results of infinite time. +For Browne, however, the sense of poetry which so overmasters his +scientific procedure, depends chiefly on its vaguer possibilities; +the empirical philosophy, even after Bacon, being still dominated by +a temper, resultant from the general unsettlement of men's [151] +minds at the Reformation, which may be summed up in the famous +question of Montaigne--Que scais-je? The cold-blooded method of +observation and experiment was creeping but slowly over the domain of +science; and such unreclaimed portions of it as the phenomena of +magnetism had an immense fascination for men like Browne and Digby. +Here, in those parts of natural philosophy "but yet in discovery," +"the America and untravelled parts of truth," lay for them the true +prospect of science, like the new world itself to a geographical +discoverer such as Raleigh. And welcome as one of the minute hints +of that country far ahead of them, the strange bird, or floating +fragment of unfamiliar vegetation, which met those early navigators, +there was a certain fantastic experiment, in which, as was alleged, +Paracelsus had been lucky. For Browne and others it became the +crucial type of the kind of agency in nature which, as they +conceived, it was the proper function of science to reveal in larger +operation. "The subject of my last letter," says Dr. Henry Power, +then a student, writing to Browne in 1648, the last year of Charles +the First, "being so high and noble a piece of chemistry, invites me +once more to request an experimental eviction of it from yourself; +and I hope you will not chide my importunity in this petition, or be +angry at my so frequent knockings at your door to obtain a grant of +so great and admirable a [152] mystery." What the enthusiastic young +student expected from Browne, so high and noble a piece of chemistry, +was the "re-individualling of an incinerated plant"--a violet, +turning to freshness, and smelling sweet again, out of its ashes, +under some genially fitted conditions of the chemic art. + +Palingenesis, resurrection, effected by orderly prescription--the +"re-individualling" of an "incinerated organism"--is a subject which +affords us a natural transition to the little book of the +Hydriotaphia, or Treatise of Urn-Burial--about fifty or sixty pages-- +which, together with a very singular letter not printed till after +Browne's death, is perhaps, after all, the best justification of +Browne's literary reputation, as it were his own curiously figured +urn, and treasure-place of immortal memory. + +In its first presentation to the public this letter was connected +with Browne's Christian Morals; but its proper and sympathetic +collocation would be rather with the Urn-Burial, of which it is a +kind of prelude, or strikes the keynote. He is writing in a very +complex situation--to a friend, upon occasion of the death of a +common friend. The deceased apparently had been little known to +Browne himself till his recent visits, while the intimate friend to +whom he is writing had been absent at the time; and the leading +motive of Browne's letter is the deep impression he has received +during those visits, of a sort of [153] physical beauty in the coming +of death, with which he still surprises and moves his reader. There +had been, in this case, a tardiness and reluctancy in the +circumstances of dissolution, which had permitted him, in the +character of a physician, as it were to assist at the spiritualising +of the bodily frame by natural process; a wonderful new type of a +kind of mortified grace being evolved by the way. The spiritual body +had anticipated the formal moment of death; the alert soul, in that +tardy decay, changing its vesture gradually, and as if piece by +piece. The infinite future had invaded this life perceptibly to the +senses, like the ocean felt far inland up a tidal river. Nowhere, +perhaps, is the attitude of questioning awe on the threshold of +another life displayed with the expressiveness of this unique morsel +of literature; though there is something of the same kind, in another +than the literary medium, in the delicate monumental sculpture of the +early Tuscan School, as also in many of the designs of William Blake, +often, though unconsciously, much in sympathy with those +unsophisticated Italian workmen. With him, as with them, and with +the writer of the Letter to a Friend upon the occasion of the death +of his intimate Friend,--so strangely! the visible function of death +is but to refine, to detach from aught that is vulgar. And this +elfin letter, really an impromptu epistle to a friend, affords the +best possible light on the general temper of the man [154] who could +be moved by the accidental discovery of those old urns at Walsingham- +-funeral relics of "Romans, or Britons Romanised which had learned +Roman customs"--to the composition of that wonderful book the +Hydriotaphia. He had drawn up a short account of the circumstance at +the moment; but it was after ten years' brooding that he put forth +the finished treatise, dedicated to an eminent collector of ancient +coins and other rarities, with congratulations that he "can daily +command the view of so many imperial faces," and (by way of +frontispiece) with one of the urns, "drawn with a coal taken out of +it and found among the burnt bones." The discovery had resuscitated +for him a whole world of latent observation, from life, from out-of- +the-way reading, from the natural world, and fused into a +composition, which with all its quaintness we may well pronounce +classical, all the heterogeneous elements of that singular mind. The +desire to "record these risen ashes and not to let them be buried +twice among us," had set free, in his manner of conceiving things, +something not wholly analysable, something that may be properly +called genius, which shapes his use of common words to stronger and +deeper senses, in a way unusual in prose writing. Let the reader, +for instance, trace his peculiarly sensitive use of the epithets thin +and dark, both here and in the Letter to a Friend. + +Upon what a grand note he can begin and end [155] chapter or +paragraph! "When the funeral pyre was out, and the last valediction +over:" "And a large part of the earth is still in the urn unto us." +Dealing with a very vague range of feelings, it is his skill to +associate them to very definite objects. Like the Soul, in Blake's +design, "exploring the recesses of the tomb," he carries a light, the +light of the poetic faith which he cannot put off him, into those +dark places, "the abode of worms and pismires," peering round with a +boundless curiosity and no fear; noting the various casuistical +considerations of men's last form of self-love; all those whims of +humanity as a "student of perpetuity," the mortuary customs of all +nations, which, from their very closeness to our human nature, arouse +in most minds only a strong feeling of distaste. There is something +congruous with the impassive piety of the man in his waiting on +accident from without to take start for the work, which, of all his +work, is most truly touched by the "divine spark." Delightsome as +its eloquence is actually found to be, that eloquence is attained out +of a certain difficulty and halting crabbedness of expression; the +wretched punctuation of the piece being not the only cause of its +impressing the reader with the notion that he is but dealing with a +collection of notes for a more finished composition, and of a +different kind; perhaps a purely erudite treatise on its subject, +with detachment of all personal colour now adhering [156] to it. Out +of an atmosphere of all-pervading oddity and quaintness--the +quaintness of mind which reflects that this disclosing of the urns of +the ancients hath "left unto our view some parts which they never +beheld themselves"--arises a work really ample and grand, nay! +classical, as I said, by virtue of the effectiveness with which it +fixes a type in literature; as, indeed, at its best, romantic +literature (and Browne is genuinely romantic) in every period attains +classical quality, giving true measure of the very limited value of +those well-worn critical distinctions. And though the Urn-Burial +certainly has much of the character of a poem, yet one is never +allowed to forget that it was designed, candidly, as a scientific +treatise on one department of ancient "culture" (as much so as +Guichard's curious old French book on Divers Manners of Burial) and +was the fruit of much labour, in the way especially of industrious +selection from remote and difficult writers; there being then few or +no handbooks, or anything like our modern shortcuts to varied +knowledge. Quite unaffectedly, a curious learning saturates, with a +kind of grey and aged colour most apt and congruous with the subject- +matter, all the thoughts that arise in him. His great store of +reading, so freely displayed, he uses almost as poetically as Milton; +like him, profiting often by the mere sonorous effect of some heroic +or ancient name, which he can adapt to that same sort of learned +sweetness of [157] cadence with which so many of his single sentences +are made to fall upon the ear. + +Pope Gregory, that great religious poet, requested by certain eminent +persons to send them some of those relics he sought for so devoutly +in all the lurking-places of old Rome, took up, it is said, a portion +of common earth, and delivered it to the messengers; and, on their +expressing surprise at such a gift, pressed the earth together in his +hand, whereupon the sacred blood of the Martyrs was beheld flowing +out between his fingers. The veneration of relics became a part of +Christian (as some may think it a part of natural) religion. All +over Rome we may count how much devotion in fine art is owing to it; +and, through all ugliness or superstition, its intention still speaks +clearly to serious minds. The poor dead bones, ghastly and +forbidding:--we know what Shakespeare would have felt about them.-- +"Beat not the bones of the buried: when he breathed, he was a man!" +And it is with something of a similar feeling that Browne is full, on +the common and general ground of humanity; an awe-stricken sympathy +with those, whose bones "lie at the mercies of the living," strong +enough to unite all his various chords of feeling into a single +strain of impressive and genuine poetry. His real interest is in +what may be called the curiosities of our common humanity. As +another might be moved at the sight of Alexander's bones, or Saint +Edmund's, or Saint Cecilia's, [158] so he is full of a fine poetical +excitement at such lowly relics as the earth hides almost everywhere +beneath our feet. But it is hardly fair to take our leave amid these +grievous images of so happy a writer as Sir Thomas Browne; so great a +lover of the open air, under which much of his life was passed. His +work, late one night, draws to a natural close:--"To keep our eyes +open longer," he bethinks himself suddenly, "were but to act our +Antipodes. The huntsmen are up in America! " + +What a fund of open-air cheerfulness, there! in turning to sleep. +Still, even when we are dealing with a writer in whom mere style +counts for so much as with Browne, it is impossible to ignore his +matter; and it is with religion he is really occupied from first to +last, hardly less than Richard Hooker. And his religion, too, after +all, was a religion of cheerfulness: he has no great consciousness of +evil in things, and is no fighter. His religion, if one may say so, +was all profit to him; among other ways, in securing an absolute +staidness and placidity of temper, for the intellectual work which +was the proper business of his life. His contributions to +"evidence," in the Religio Medici, for instance, hardly tell, because +he writes out of view of a really philosophical criticism. What does +tell in him, in this direction, is the witness he brings to men's +instinct of survival--the "intimations of immortality," as Wordsworth +terms them, which [159] were natural with him in surprising force. +As was said of Jean Paul, his special subject was the immortality of +the soul; with an assurance as personal, as fresh and original, as it +was, on the one hand, in those old half-civilised people who had +deposited the urns; on the other hand, in the cynical French poet of +the nineteenth century, who did not think, but knew, that his soul +was imperishable. He lived in an age in which that philosophy made a +great stride which ends with Hume; and his lesson, if we may be +pardoned for taking away a "lesson" from so ethical a writer, is the +force of men's temperaments in the management of opinion, their own +or that of others;--that it is not merely different degrees of bare +intellectual power which cause men to approach in different degrees +to this or that intellectual programme. Could he have foreseen the +mature result of that mechanical analysis which Bacon had applied to +nature, and Hobbes to the mind of man, there is no reason to think +that he would have surrendered his own chosen hypothesis concerning +them. He represents, in an age, the intellectual powers of which +tend strongly to agnosticism, that class of minds to which the +supernatural view of things is still credible. The non-mechanical +theory of nature has had its grave adherents since: to the non- +mechanical theory of man--that he is in contact with a moral order on +a different plane from the [160] mechanical order--thousands, of the +most various types and degrees of intellectual power, always adhere; +a fact worth the consideration of all ingenuous thinkers, if (as is +certainly the case with colour, music, number, for instance) there +may be whole regions of fact, the recognition of which belongs to one +and not to another, which people may possess in various degrees; for +the knowledge of which, therefore, one person is dependent upon +another; and in relation to which the appropriate means of cognition +must lie among the elements of what we call individual temperament, +so that what looks like a pre-judgment may be really a legitimate +apprehension. "Men are what they are," and are not wholly at the +mercy of formal conclusions from their formally limited premises. +Browne passes his whole life in observation and inquiry: he is a +genuine investigator, with every opportunity: the mind of the age all +around him seems passively yielding to an almost foregone +intellectual result, to a philosophy of disillusion. But he thinks +all that a prejudice; and not from any want of intellectual power +certainly, but from some inward consideration, some afterthought, +from the antecedent gravitation of his own general character--or, +will you say? from that unprecipitated infusion of fallacy in him--he +fails to draw, unlike almost all the rest of the world, the +conclusion ready to hand. + +1886. + +NOTES + +144. +In the original, this quotation, like several above it, is not +indented; it is in smaller type. Return. + + + +"LOVE'S LABOURS LOST" + +[161] Love's Labours Lost is one of the earliest of Shakespeare's +dramas, and has many of the peculiarities of his poems, which are +also the work of his earlier life. The opening speech of the king on +the immortality of fame--on the triumph of fame over death--and the +nobler parts of Biron, display something of the monumental style of +Shakespeare's Sonnets, and are not without their concerts of thought +and expression. This connexion of Love's Labours Lost with +Shakespeare's poems is further enforced by the actual insertion in it +of three sonnets and a faultless song; which, in accordance with his +practice in other plays, are inwoven into the argument of the piece +and, like the golden ornaments of a fair woman, give it a peculiar +air of distinction. There is merriment in it also, with choice +illustrations of both wit and humour; a laughter, often exquisite, +ringing, if faintly, yet as genuine laughter still, though sometimes +sinking into mere burlesque, which has not lasted quite so well. And +Shakespeare [162] brings a serious effect out of the trifling of his +characters. A dainty love-making is interchanged with the more +cumbrous play: below the many artifices of Biron's amorous speeches +we may trace sometimes the "unutterable longing;" and the lines in +which Katherine describes the blighting through love of her younger +sister are one of the most touching things in older literature.* +Again, how many echoes seem awakened by those strange words, actually +said in jest! "The sweet war-man (Hector of Troy) is dead and +rotten; sweet chucks, beat not the bones of the buried: when he +breathed, he was a man!"--words which may remind us of Shakespeare's +own epitaph. In the last scene, an ingenious turn is given to the +action, so that the piece does not conclude after the manner of other +comedies.-- + +Our wooing doth not end like an old play; +Jack hath not Jill: + +and Shakespeare strikes a passionate note across it at last, in the +entrance of the messenger, who announces to the princess that the +king her father is suddenly dead. + +The merely dramatic interest of the piece is slight enough; only just +sufficient, indeed, to form the vehicle of its wit and poetry. The +scene--a park of the King of Navarre--is unaltered throughout; and +the unity of the [163] play is not so much the unity of a drama as +that of a series of pictorial groups, in which the same figures +reappear, in different combinations but on the same background. It +is as if Shakespeare had intended to bind together, by some inventive +conceit, the devices of an ancient tapestry, and give voices to its +figures. On one side, a fair palace; on the other, the tents of the +Princess of France, who has come on an embassy from her father to the +King of Navarre; in the midst, a wide space of smooth grass. + +The same personages are combined over and over again into a series of +gallant scenes--the princess, the three masked ladies, the quaint, +pedantic king; one of those amiable kings men have never loved +enough, whose serious occupation with the things of the mind seems, +by contrast with the more usual forms of kingship, like frivolity or +play. Some of the figures are grotesque merely, and all the male +ones at least, a little fantastic. Certain objects reappearing from +scene to scene--love-letters crammed with verses to the margin, and +lovers' toys--hint obscurely at some story of intrigue. Between +these groups, on a smaller scale, come the slighter and more homely +episodes, with Sir Nathaniel the curate, the country-maid Jaquenetta, +Moth or Mote the elfin-page, with Hiems and Ver, who recite "the +dialogue that the two learned men have compiled in praise of the owl +and the cuckoo." The ladies are [164] lodged in tents, because the +king, like the princess of the modern poet's fancy, has taken a vow + +to make his court a little Academe, + +and for three years' space no woman may come within a mile of it; and +the play shows how this artificial attempt was broken through. For +the king and his three fellow-scholars are of course soon forsworn, +and turn to writing sonnets, each to his chosen lady. These fellow- +scholars of the king--"quaint votaries of science" at first, +afterwards "affection's men-at-arms"--three youthful knights, +gallant, amorous, chivalrous, but also a little affected, sporting +always a curious foppery of language, are, throughout, the leading +figures in the foreground; one of them, in particular, being more +carefully depicted than the others, and in himself very noticeable--a +portrait with somewhat puzzling manner and expression, which at once +catches the eye irresistibly and keeps it fixed. + +Play is often that about which people are most serious; and the +humourist may observe how, under all love of playthings, there is +almost always hidden an appreciation of something really engaging and +delightful. This is true always of the toys of children: it is often +true of the playthings of grown-up people, their vanities, their +fopperies even, their lighter loves; the cynic would add their +pursuit of fame. Certainly, this is true without exception [165] of +the playthings of a past age, which to those who succeed it are +always full of a pensive interest--old manners, old dresses, old +houses. For what is called fashion in these matters occupies, in each +age, much of the care of many of the most discerning people, +furnishing them with a kind of mirror of their real inward +refinements, and their capacity for selection. Such modes or +fashions are, at their best, an example of the artistic predominance +of form over matter; of the manner of the doing of it over the thing +done; and have a beauty of their own. It is so with that old +euphuism of the Elizabethan age--that pride of dainty language and +curious expression, which it is very easy to ridicule, which often +made itself ridiculous, but which had below it a real sense of +fitness and nicety; and which, as we see in this very play, and still +more clearly in the Sonnets, had some fascination for the young +Shakespeare himself. It is this foppery of delicate language, this +fashionable plaything of his time, with which Shakespeare is occupied +in Love's Labours Lost. He shows us the manner in all its stages; +passing from the grotesque and vulgar pedantry of Holofernes, through +the extravagant but polished caricature of Armado, to become the +peculiar characteristic of a real though still quaint poetry in Biron +himself, who is still chargeable even at his best with just a little +affectation. As Shakespeare laughs broadly at it in Holofernes or +Armado, so he [166] is the analyst of its curious charm in Biron; and +this analysis involves a delicate raillery by Shakespeare himself at +his own chosen manner. + +This "foppery" of Shakespeare's day had, then, its really delightful +side, a quality in no sense "affected," by which it satisfies a real +instinct in our minds--the fancy so many of us have for an exquisite +and curious skill in the use of words. Biron is the perfect flower +of this manner: + +A man of fire-new words, fashion's own knight: + +--as he describes Armado, in terms which are really applicable to +himself. In him this manner blends with a true gallantry of nature, +and an affectionate complaisance and grace. He has at times some of +its extravagance or caricature also, but the shades of expression by +which he passes from this to the "golden cadence" of Shakespeare's +own most characteristic verse, are so fine, that it is sometimes +difficult to trace them. What is a vulgarity in Holofernes, and a +caricature in Armado, refines itself with him into the expression of +a nature truly and inwardly bent upon a form of delicate perfection, +and is accompanied by a real insight into the laws which determine +what is exquisite in language, and their root in the nature of +things. He can appreciate quite the opposite style-- + +In russet yeas, and honest kersey noes; + +he knows the first law of pathos, that + +Honest plain words best suit the ear of grief. + +[167] He delights in his own rapidity of intuition; and, in harmony +with the half-sensuous philosophy of the Sonnets, exalts, a little +scornfully, in many memorable expressions, the judgment of the +senses, above all slower, more toilsome means of knowledge, scorning +some who fail to see things only because they are so clear: + +So here you find where light in darkness lies, +Your light grows dark by losing of your eyes:-- + +as with some German commentators on Shakespeare. Appealing always to +actual sensation from men's affected theories, he might seem to +despise learning; as, indeed, he has taken up his deep studies partly +in sport, and demands always the profit of learning in renewed +enjoyment. Yet he surprises us from time to time by intuitions which +could come only from a deep experience and power of observation; and +men listen to him, old and young, in spite of themselves. He is +quickly impressible to the slightest clouding of the spirits in +social intercourse, and has his moments of extreme seriousness: his +trial-task may well be, as Rosaline puts it-- + +To enforce the pained impotent to smile. + +But still, through all, he is true to his chosen manner: that gloss +of dainty language is a second nature with him: even at his best he +is not without a certain artifice: the trick of playing on words +never deserts him; and [168] Shakespeare, in whose own genius there +is an element of this very quality, shows us in this graceful, and, +as it seems, studied, portrait, his enjoyment of it. + +As happens with every true dramatist, Shakespeare is for the most +part hidden behind the persons of his creation. Yet there are +certain of his characters in which we feel that there is something of +self-portraiture. And it is not so much in his grander, more subtle +and ingenious creations that we feel this--in Hamlet and King Lear-- +as in those slighter and more spontaneously developed figures, who, +while far from playing principal parts, are yet distinguished by a +peculiar happiness and delicate ease in the drawing of them; figures +which possess, above all, that winning attractiveness which there is +no man but would willingly exercise, and which resemble those works +of art which, though not meant to be very great or imposing, are yet +wrought of the choicest material. Mercutio, in Romeo and Juliet, +belongs to this group of Shakespeare's characters--versatile, +mercurial people, such as make good actors, and in whom the + +nimble spirits of the arteries, + +the finer but still merely animal elements of great wit, predominate. +A careful delineation of minor, yet expressive traits seems to mark +them out as the characters of his predilection; [169] and it is hard +not to identify him with these more than with others. Biron, in +Love's Labours Lost, is perhaps the most striking member of this +group. In this character, which is never quite in touch, never quite +on a perfect level of understanding, with the other persons of the +play, we see, perhaps, a reflex of Shakespeare himself, when he has +just become able to stand aside from and estimate the first period of +his poetry. + +1878. + +NOTES + +162. *Act V. Scene II. Return. + + + +"MEASURE FOR MEASURE" + +[170] IN Measure for Measure, as in some other of his plays, +Shakespeare has remodelled an earlier and somewhat rough composition +to "finer issues," suffering much to remain as it had come from the +less skilful hand, and not raising the whole of his work to an equal +degree of intensity. Hence perhaps some of that depth and +weightiness which make this play so impressive, as with the true seal +of experience, like a fragment of life itself, rough and disjointed +indeed, but forced to yield in places its profounder meaning. In +Measure for Measure, in contrast with the flawless execution of Romeo +and Juliet, Shakespeare has spent his art in just enough modification +of the scheme of the older play to make it exponent of this purpose, +adapting its terrible essential incidents, so that Coleridge found it +the only painful work among Shakespeare's dramas, and leaving for the +reader of to-day more than the usual number of difficult expressions; +but infusing a lavish colour and a profound significance into it, so +that under his [171] touch certain select portions of it rise far +above the level of all but his own best poetry, and working out of it +a morality so characteristic that the play might well pass for the +central expression of his moral judgments. It remains a comedy, as +indeed is congruous with the bland, half-humorous equity which +informs the whole composition, sinking from the heights of sorrow and +terror into the rough scheme of the earlier piece; yet it is hardly +less full of what is really tragic in man's existence than if Claudio +had indeed "stooped to death." Even the humorous concluding scenes +have traits of special grace, retaining in less emphatic passages a +stray lire or word of power, as it seems, so that we watch to the end +for the traces where the nobler hand has glanced along, leaving its +vestiges, as if accidentally or wastefully, in the rising of the +style. + +The interest of Measure for Measure, therefore, is partly that of an +old story told over again. We measure with curiosity that variety of +resources which has enabled Shakespeare to refashion the original +material with a higher motive; adding to the intricacy of the piece, +yet so modifying its structure as to give the whole almost the unity +of a single scene; lending, by the light of a philosophy which dwells +much on what is complex and subtle in our nature, a true human +propriety to its strange and unexpected turns of feeling and +character, to incidents so [172] difficult as the fall of Angelo, and +the subsequent reconciliation of Isabella, so that she pleads +successfully for his life. It was from Whetstone, a contemporary +English writer, that Shakespeare derived the outline of Cinthio's +"rare history" of Promos and Cassandra, one of that numerous class of +Italian stories, like Boccaccio's Tancred of Salerno, in which the +mere energy of southern passion has everything its own way, and +which, though they may repel many a northern reader by a certain +crudity in their colouring, seem to have been full of fascination for +the Elizabethan age. This story, as it appears in Whetstone's +endless comedy, is almost as rough as the roughest episode of actual +criminal life. But the play seems never to have been acted, and some +time after its publication Whetstone himself turned the thing into a +tale, included in his Heptameron of Civil Discourses, where it still +figures as a genuine piece, with touches of undesigned poetry, a +quaint field-flower here and there of diction or sentiment, the whole +strung up to an effective brevity, and with the fragrance of that +admirable age of literature all about it. Here, then, there is +something of the original Italian colour: in this narrative +Shakespeare may well have caught the first glimpse of a composition +with nobler proportions; and some artless sketch from his own hand, +perhaps, putting together his first impressions, insinuated itself +between Whetstone's work and the play as we actually read it. Out +[173] of these insignificant sources Shakespeare's play rises, full +of solemn expression, and with a profoundly designed beauty, the new +body of a higher, though sometimes remote and difficult poetry, +escaping from the imperfect relics of the old story, yet not wholly +transformed, and even as it stands but the preparation only, we might +think, of a still more imposing design. For once we have in it a +real example of that sort of writing which is sometimes described as +suggestive, and which by the help of certain subtly calculated hints +only, brings into distinct shape the reader's own half-developed +imaginings. Often the quality is attributed to writing merely vague +and unrealised, but in Measure for Measure, quite certainly, +Shakespeare has directed the attention of sympathetic readers along +certain channels of meditation beyond the immediate scope of his +work. + +Measure for Measure, therefore, by the quality of these higher +designs, woven by his strange magic on a texture of poorer quality, +is hardly less indicative than Hamlet even, of Shakespeare's reason, +of his power of moral interpretation. It deals, not like Hamlet with +the problems which beset one of exceptional temperament, but with +mere human nature. It brings before us a group of persons, +attractive, full of desire, vessels of the genial, seed-bearing +powers of nature, a gaudy existence flowering out over the old court +and city of Vienna, a spectacle of the fulness and [174] pride of +life which to some may seem to touch the verge of wantonness. Behind +this group of people, behind their various action, Shakespeare +inspires in us the sense of a strong tyranny of nature and +circumstance. Then what shall there be on this side of it--on our +side, the spectators' side, of this painted screen, with its puppets +who are really glad or sorry all the time? what philosophy of life, +what sort of equity? + +Stimulated to read more carefully by Shakespeare's own profounder +touches, the reader will note the vivid reality, the subtle +interchange of light and shade, the strongly contrasted characters of +this group of persons, passing across the stage so quickly. The +slightest of them is at least not ill-natured: the meanest of them +can put forth a plea for existence--Truly, sir, I am a poor fellow +that would live!--they are never sure of themselves, even in the +strong tower of a cold unimpressible nature: they are capable of many +friendships and of a true dignity in danger, giving each other a +sympathetic, if transitory, regret--one sorry that another "should be +foolishly lost at a game of tick-tack." Words which seem to exhaust +man's deepest sentiment concerning death and life are put on the lips +of a gilded, witless youth; and the saintly Isabella feels fire creep +along her, kindling her tongue to eloquence at the suggestion of +shame. In places the shadow deepens: death intrudes itself on the +scene, as among other [175] things "a great disguiser," blanching the +features of youth and spoiling its goodly hair, touching the fine +Claudio even with its disgraceful associations. As in Orcagna's +fresco at Pisa, it comes capriciously, giving many and long reprieves +to Barnardine, who has been waiting for it nine years in prison, +taking another thence by fever, another by mistake of judgment, +embracing others in the midst of their music and song. The little +mirror of existence, which reflects to each for a moment the stage on +which he plays, is broken at last by a capricious accident; while all +alike, in their yearning for untasted enjoyment, are really +discounting their days, grasping so hastily and accepting so +inexactly the precious pieces. The Duke's quaint but excellent +moralising at the beginning of the third act does but express, like +the chorus of a Greek play, the spirit of the passing incidents. To +him in Shakespeare's play, to a few here and there in the actual +world, this strange practical paradox of our life, so unwise in its +eager haste, reveals itself in all its clearness. + +The Duke disguised as a friar, with his curious moralising on life +and death, and Isabella in her first mood of renunciation, a thing +"ensky'd and sainted," come with the quiet of the cloister as a +relief to this lust and pride of life: like some grey monastic +picture hung on the wall of a gaudy room, their presence cools the +heated air of the piece. For a moment we [176] are within the placid +conventual walls, whither they fancy at first that the Duke has come +as a man crossed in love, with Friar Thomas and Friar Peter, calling +each other by their homely, English names, or at the nunnery among +the novices, with their little limited privileges, where + +If you speak you must not show your face, +Or if you show your face you must not speak. + +Not less precious for this relief in the general structure of the +piece, than for its own peculiar graces is the episode of Mariana, a +creature wholly of Shakespeare's invention, told, by way of +interlude, in subdued prose. The moated grange, with its dejected +mistress, its long, listless, discontented days, where we hear only +the voice of a boy broken off suddenly in the midst of one of the +loveliest songs of Shakespeare, or of Shakespeare's school,* is the +pleasantest of many glimpses we get here of pleasant places--the +field without the town, Angelo's garden-house, the consecrated +fountain. Indirectly it has suggested two of the most perfect +compositions among the poetry of our own generation. Again it is a +picture within a picture, but with fainter lines and a greyer +atmosphere: we have here the same passions, the same wrongs, the same +continuance of affection, the same crying out upon death, as in the +nearer and larger piece, though softened, and reduced to the mood of +a more dreamy scene. + +[177] Of Angelo we may feel at first sight inclined to say only +guarda e passa! or to ask whether he is indeed psychologically +possible. In the old story, he figures as an embodiment of pure and +unmodified evil, like "Hyliogabalus of Rome or Denis of Sicyll." But +the embodiment of pure evil is no proper subject of art, and +Shakespeare, in the spirit of a philosophy which dwells much on the +complications of outward circumstance with men's inclinations, turns +into a subtle study in casuistry this incident of the austere judge +fallen suddenly into utmost corruption by a momentary contact with +supreme purity. But the main interest in Measure for Measure is not, +as in Promos and Cassandra, in the relation of Isabella and Angelo, +but rather in the relation of Claudio and Isabella. + +Greek tragedy in some of its noblest products has taken for its theme +the love of a sister, a sentiment unimpassioned indeed, purifying by +the very spectacle of its passionlessness, but capable of a fierce +and almost animal strength if informed for a moment by pity and +regret. At first Isabella comes upon the scene as a tranquillising +influence in it. But Shakespeare, in the development of the action, +brings quite different and unexpected qualities out of her. It is +his characteristic poetry to expose this cold, chastened personality, +respected even by the worldly Lucio as "something ensky'd and +sainted, and almost an immortal spirit," to two [178] sharp, shameful +trials, and wring out of her a fiery, revealing eloquence. Thrown +into the terrible dilemma of the piece, called upon to sacrifice that +cloistral whiteness to sisterly affection, become in a moment the +ground of strong, contending passions, she develops a new character +and shows herself suddenly of kindred with those strangely conceived +women, like Webster's Vittoria, who unite to a seductive sweetness +something of a dangerous and tigerlike changefulness of feeling. The +swift, vindictive anger leaps, like a white flame, into this white +spirit, and, stripped in a moment of all convention, she stands +before us clear, detached, columnar, among the tender frailties of +the piece. Cassandra, the original of Isabella in Whetstone's tale, +with the purpose of the Roman Lucretia in her mind, yields gracefully +enough to the conditions of her brother's safety; and to the lighter +reader of Shakespeare there may seem something harshly conceived, or +psychologically impossible even, in the suddenness of the change +wrought in her, as Claudio welcomes for a moment the chance of life +through her compliance with Angelo's will, and he may have a sense +here of flagging skill, as in words less finely handled than in the +preceding scene. The play, though still not without traces of nobler +handiwork, sinks down, as we know, at last into almost homely comedy, +and it might be supposed that just here the grander manner [179] +deserted it. But the skill with which Isabella plays upon Claudio's +well-recognised sense of honour, and endeavours by means of that to +insure him beforehand from the acceptance of life on baser terms, +indicates no coming laxity of hand just in this place. It was rather +that there rose in Shakespeare's conception, as there may for the +reader, as there certainly would in any good acting of the part, +something of that terror, the seeking for which is one of the notes +of romanticism in Shakespeare and his circle. The stream of ardent +natural affection, poured as sudden hatred upon the youth condemned +to die, adds an additional note of expression to the horror of the +prison where so much of the scene takes place. It is not here only +that Shakespeare has conceived of such extreme anger and pity as +putting a sort of genius into simple women, so that their "lips drop +eloquence," and their intuitions interpret that which is often too +hard or fine for manlier reason; and it is Isabella with her grand +imaginative diction, and that poetry laid upon the "prone and +speechless dialect" there is in mere youth itself, who gives +utterance to the equity, the finer judgments of the piece on men and +things. + +From behind this group with its subtle lights and shades, its poetry, +its impressive contrasts, Shakespeare, as I said, conveys to us a +strong sense of the tyranny of nature and [180] circumstance over +human action. The most powerful expressions of this side of +experience might be found here. The bloodless, impassible +temperament does but wait for its opportunity, for the almost +accidental coherence of time with place, and place with wishing, to +annul its long and patient discipline, and become in a moment the +very opposite of that which under ordinary conditions it seemed to +be, even to itself. The mere resolute self-assertion of the blood +brings to others special temptations, temptations which, as defects +or over-growths, lie in the very qualities which make them otherwise +imposing or attractive; the very advantage of men's gifts of +intellect or sentiment being dependent on a balance in their use so +delicate that men hardly maintain it always. Something also must be +conceded to influences merely physical, to the complexion of the +heavens, the skyey influences, shifting as the stars shift; as +something also to the mere caprice of men exercised over each other +in the dispensations of social or political order, to the chance +which makes the life or death of Claudio dependent on Angelo's will. + +The many veins of thought which render the poetry of this play so +weighty and impressive unite in the image of Claudio, a flowerlike +young man, whom, prompted by a few hints from Shakespeare, the +imagination easily clothes with all the bravery of youth, as he +crosses the stage before us on his way to death, coming so [181] +hastily to the end of his pilgrimage. Set in the horrible blackness +of the prison, with its various forms of unsightly death, this flower +seems the braver. Fallen by "prompture of the blood," the victim of +a suddenly revived law against the common fault of youth like his, he +finds his life forfeited as if by the chance of a lottery. With that +instinctive clinging to life, which breaks through the subtlest +casuistries of monk or sage apologising for an early death, he +welcomes for a moment the chance of life through his sister's shame, +though he revolts hardly less from the notion of perpetual +imprisonment so repulsive to the buoyant energy of youth. +Familiarised, by the words alike of friends and the indifferent, to +the thought of death, he becomes gentle and subdued indeed, yet more +perhaps through pride than real resignation, and would go down to +darkness at last hard and unblinded. Called upon suddenly to +encounter his fate, looking with keen and resolute profile straight +before him, he gives utterance to some of the central truths of human +feeling, the sincere, concentrated expression of the recoiling flesh. +Thoughts as profound and poetical as Hamlet's arise in him; and but +for the accidental arrest of sentence he would descend into the dust, +a mere gilded, idle flower of youth indeed, but with what are perhaps +the most eloquent of all Shakespeare's words upon his lips. + +As Shakespeare in Measure for Measure has [182] refashioned, after a +nobler pattern, materials already at hand, so that the relics of +other men's poetry are incorporated into his perfect work, so traces +of the old "morality," that early form of dramatic composition which +had for its function the inculcating of some moral theme, survive in +it also, and give it a peculiar ethical interest. This ethical +interest, though it can escape no attentive reader, yet, in +accordance with that artistic law which demands the predominance of +form everywhere over the mere matter or subject handled, is not to be +wholly separated from the special circumstances, necessities, +embarrassments, of these particular dramatic persons. The old +"moralities" exemplified most often some rough-and-ready lesson. +Here the very intricacy and subtlety of the moral world itself, the +difficulty of seizing the true relations of so complex a material, +the difficulty of just judgment, of judgment that shall not be +unjust, are the lessons conveyed. Even in Whetstone's old story this +peculiar vein of moralising comes to the surface: even there, we +notice the tendency to dwell on mixed motives, the contending issues +of action, the presence of virtues and vices alike in unexpected +places, on "the hard choice of two evils," on the "imprisoning" of +men's "real intents." Measure for Measure is full of expressions +drawn from a profound experience of these casuistries, and that +ethical interest becomes predominant in it: it is no longer Promos +and [183] Cassandra, but Measure for Measure, its new name expressly +suggesting the subject of poetical justice. The action of the play, +like the action of life itself for the keener observer, develops in +us the conception of this poetical justice, and the yearning to +realise it, the true justice of which Angelo knows nothing, because +it lies for the most part beyond the limits of any acknowledged law. +The idea of justice involves the idea of rights. But at bottom +rights are equivalent to that which really is, to facts; and the +recognition of his rights therefore, the justice he requires of our +hands, or our thoughts, is the recognition of that which the person, +in his inmost nature, really is; and as sympathy alone can discover +that which really is in matters of feeling and thought, true justice +is in its essence a finer knowledge through love. + +'Tis very pregnant: +The jewel that we find we stoop and take it, +Because we see it; but what we do not see +We tread upon, and never think of it. + +It is for this finer justice, a justice based on a more delicate +appreciation of the true conditions of men and things, a true respect +of persons in our estimate of actions, that the people in Measure for +Measure cry out as they pass before us; and as the poetry of this +play is full of the peculiarities of Shakespeare's poetry, so in its +ethics it is an epitome of Shakespeare's moral judgments. They are +the moral judgments of [184] an observer, of one who sits as a +spectator, and knows how the threads in the design before him hold +together under the surface: they are the judgments of the humourist +also, who follows with a half-amused but always pitiful sympathy, the +various ways of human disposition, and sees less distance than +ordinary men between what are called respectively great and little +things. It is not always that poetry can be the exponent of +morality; but it is this aspect of morals which it represents most +naturally, for this true justice is dependent on just those finer +appreciations which poetry cultivates in us the power of making, +those peculiar valuations of action and its effect which poetry +actually requires. + +1874. + +NOTES + +176. *Fletcher, in the Bloody Brother, gives the rest of it. +Return. + + + +SHAKESPEARE'S ENGLISH KINGS + +[185] + +A brittle glory shineth in this face: +As brittle as the glory is the face. + +THE English plays of Shakespeare needed but the completion of one +unimportant interval to possess the unity of a popular chronicle from +Richard the Second to Henry the Eighth, and possess, as they actually +stand, the unity of a common motive in the handling of the various +events and persons which they bring before us. Certain of his +historic dramas, not English, display Shakespeare's mastery in the +development of the heroic nature amid heroic circumstances; and had +he chosen, from English history, to deal with Coeur-de-Lion or Edward +the First, the innate quality of his subject would doubtless have +called into play something of that profound and sombre power which in +Julius Caesar and Macbeth has sounded the depths of mighty character. +True, on the whole, to fact, it is another side of kingship which he +has made prominent in his English histories. The irony [186] of +kingship--average human nature, flung with a wonderfully pathetic +effect into the vortex of great events; tragedy of everyday quality +heightened in degree only by the conspicuous scene which does but +make those who play their parts there conspicuously unfortunate; the +utterance of common humanity straight from the heart, but refined +like other common things for kingly uses by Shakespeare's unfailing +eloquence: such, unconsciously for the most part, though palpably +enough to the careful reader, is the conception under which +Shakespeare has arranged the lights and shadows of the story of the +English kings, emphasising merely the light and shadow inherent in +it, and keeping very close to the original authorities, not simply in +the general outline of these dramatic histories but sometimes in +their very expression. Certainly the history itself, as he found it +in Hall, Holinshed, and Stowe, those somewhat picturesque old +chroniclers who had themselves an eye for the dramatic "effects" of +human life, has much of this sentiment already about it. What he did +not find there was the natural prerogative--such justification, in +kingly, that is to say, in exceptional, qualities, of the exceptional +position, as makes it practicable in the result. It is no Henriade +he writes, and no history of the English people, but the sad fortunes +of some English kings as conspicuous examples of the ordinary human +condition. As in a children's [187] story, all princes are in +extremes. Delightful in the sunshine above the wall into which +chance lifts the flower for a season, they can but plead somewhat +more touchingly than others their everyday weakness in the storm. +Such is the motive that gives unity to these unequal and intermittent +contributions toward a slowly evolved dramatic chronicle, which it +would have taken many days to rehearse; a not distant story from real +life still well remembered in its general course, to which people +might listen now and again, as long as they cared, finding human +nature at least wherever their attention struck ground in it. + +He begins with John, and allows indeed to the first of these English +kings a kind of greatness, making the development of the play centre +in the counteraction of his natural gifts--that something of heroic +force about him--by a madness which takes the shape of reckless +impiety, forced especially on men's attention by the terrible +circumstances of his end, in the delineation of which Shakespeare +triumphs, setting, with true poetic tact, this incident of the king's +death, in all the horror of a violent one, amid a scene delicately +suggestive of what is perennially peaceful and genial in the outward +world. Like the sensual humours of Falstaff in another play, the +presence of the bastard Faulconbridge, with his physical energy and +his unmistakable family likeness--"those limbs [188] which Sir Robert +never holp to make"* contributes to an almost coarse assertion of the +force of nature, of the somewhat ironic preponderance of nature and +circumstance over men's artificial arrangements, to, the recognition +of a certain potent natural aristocracy, which is far from being +always identical with that more formal, heraldic one. And what is a +coarse fact in the case of Faulconbridge becomes a motive of pathetic +appeal in the wan and babyish Arthur. The magic with which nature +models tiny and delicate children to the likeness of their rough +fathers is nowhere more justly expressed than in the words of King +Philip.-- + +Look here upon thy brother Geoffrey's face +These eyes, these brows were moulded out of his: +This little abstract doth contain that large +Which died in Geoffrey; and the hand of time +Shall draw this brief into as huge a volume. + +It was perhaps something of a boyish memory of the shocking end of +his father that had distorted the piety of Henry the Third into +superstitious terror. A frightened soul, himself touched with the +contrary sort of religious madness, doting on all that was alien from +his father's huge ferocity, on the genialities, the soft gilding, of +life, on the genuine interests of art and poetry, to be credited more +than any other person with the deep religious expression of [189] +Westminster Abbey, Henry the Third, picturesque though useless, but +certainly touching, might have furnished Shakespeare, had he filled +up this interval in his series, with precisely the kind of effect he +tends towards in his English plays. But he found it completer still +in the person and story of Richard the Second, a figure--"that sweet +lovely rose"--which haunts Shakespeare's mind, as it seems long to +have haunted the minds of the English people, as the most touching of +all examples of the irony of kingship. + +Henry the Fourth--to look for a moment beyond our immediate subject, +in pursuit of Shakespeare's thought--is presented, of course, in +general outline, as an impersonation of "surviving force:" he has a +certain amount of kingcraft also, a real fitness for great +opportunity. But still true to his leading motive, Shakespeare, in +King Henry the Fourth, has left the high-water mark of his poetry in +the soliloquy which represents royalty longing vainly for the +toiler's sleep; while the popularity, the showy heroism, of Henry the +Fifth, is used to give emphatic point to the old earthy commonplace +about "wild oats." The wealth of homely humour in these plays, the +fun coming straight home to all the world, of Fluellen especially in +his unconscious interview with the king, the boisterous earthiness of +Falstaff and his companions, contribute to the same effect. The +keynote of [190] Shakespeare's treatment is indeed expressed by Henry +the Fifth himself, the greatest of Shakespeare's kings.--"Though I +speak it to you," he says incognito, under cover of night, to a +common soldier on the field, "I think the king is but a man, as I am: +the violet smells to him as it doth to me: all his senses have but +human conditions; and though his affections be higher mounted than +ours yet when they stoop they stoop with like wing." And, in truth, +the really kingly speeches which Shakespeare assigns to him, as to +other kings weak enough in all but speech, are but a kind of flowers, +worn for, and effective only as personal embellishment. They combine +to one result with the merely outward and ceremonial ornaments of +royalty, its pageantries, flaunting so naively, so credulously, in +Shakespeare, as in that old medieval time. And then, the force of +Hotspur is but transient youth, the common heat of youth, in him. +The character of Henry the Sixth again, roi faineant, with La +Pucelle* for his counterfoil, lay in the direct course of +Shakespeare's design: he has done much to fix the sentiment of the +"holy Henry." Richard the Third, touched, like John, with an effect +of real heroism, is spoiled like him by something of criminal +madness, and reaches his highest level of tragic expression [191] +when circumstances reduce him to terms of mere human nature.-- + +A horse! A horse! My kingdom for a horse! + +The Princes in the Tower recall to mind the lot of young Arthur:-- + +I'll go with thee, +And find the inheritance of this poor child, +His little kingdom of a forced grave. + +And when Shakespeare comes to Henry the Eighth, it is not the +superficial though very English splendour of the king himself, but +the really potent and ascendant nature of the butcher's son on the +one hand, and Katharine's subdued reproduction of the sad fortunes of +Richard the Second on the other, that define his central interest.* + +With a prescience of the Wars of the Roses, of which his errors were +the original cause, it is Richard who best exposes Shakespeare's own +constant sentiment concerning war, and especially that sort of +civil war which was then recent in English memories. The soul of +Shakespeare, certainly, was not wanting in a sense of the magnanimity +of warriors. The grandiose aspects of war, its magnificent +apparelling, he records [192] monumentally enough--the "dressing of +the lists," the lion's heart, its unfaltering haste thither in all +the freshness of youth and morning.-- + +Not sick although I have to do with death-- +The sun doth gild our armour: Up, my Lords!-- +I saw young Harry with his beaver on, +His cuisses on his thighs, gallantly arm'd, +Rise from the ground like feather'd Mercury. + +Only, with Shakespeare, the afterthought is immediate:-- + +They come like sacrifices in their trim. + +--Will it never be to-day? I will trot to-morrow a mile, and my +way shall be paved with English faces. + +This sentiment Richard reiterates very plaintively, in association +with the delicate sweetness of the English fields, still sweet and +fresh, like London and her other fair towns in that England of +Chaucer, for whose soil the exiled Bolingbroke is made to long so +dangerously, while Richard on his return from Ireland salutes it-- + +That pale, that white-fac'd shore,-- +As a long-parted mother with her child.-- +So, weeping, smiling, greet I thee, my earth! +And do thee favour with my royal hands.-- + +Then (of Bolingbroke) + +Ere the crown he looks for live in peace, +Ten thousand bloody crowns of mothers' sons +Shall ill become the flower of England's face; +Change the complexion of her maid-pale peace +To scarlet indignation, and bedew +My pastures' grass with faithful English blood.-- + +[193] + +Why have they dared to march?-- + +asks York, + +So many miles upon her peaceful bosom, +Frighting her pale-fac'd visages with war?-- + +waking, according to Richard, + +Our peace, which in our country's cradle, +Draws the sweet infant breath of gentle sleep:-- + +bedrenching "with crimson tempest" + +The fresh green lap of fair king Richard's land:-- + +frighting "fair peace" from "our quiet confines," laying + +The summer's dust with showers of blood, +Rained from the wounds of slaughter'd Englishmen: + +bruising + +Her flowerets with the armed hoofs +Of hostile paces. + +Perhaps it is not too fanciful to note in this play a peculiar recoil +from the mere instruments of warfare, the contact of the "rude ribs," +the "flint bosom," of Barkloughly Castle or Pomfret or + +Julius Caesar's ill-erected tower: + +the + +Boisterous untun'd drums +With harsh-resounding trumpets' dreadful bray +And grating shock of wrathful iron arms. + +It is as if the lax, soft beauty of the king took effect, at least by +contrast, on everything beside. One gracious prerogative, certainly, +Shakespeare's [194] English kings possess: they are a very eloquent +company, and Richard is the most sweet-tongued of them all. In no +other play perhaps is there such a flush of those gay, fresh, +variegated flowers of speech--colour and figure, not lightly attached +to, but fused into, the very phrase itself--which Shakespeare cannot +help dispensing to his characters, as in this "play of the Deposing +of King Richard the Second," an exquisite poet if he is nothing else, +from first to last, in light and gloom alike, able to see all things +poetically, to give a poetic turn to his conduct of them, and +refreshing with his golden language the tritest aspects of that +ironic contrast between the pretensions of a king and the actual +necessities of his destiny. What a garden of words! With him, blank +verse, infinitely graceful, deliberate, musical in inflexion, becomes +indeed a true "verse royal," that rhyming lapse, which to the +Shakespearian ear, at least in youth, came as the last touch of +refinement on it, being here doubly appropriate. His eloquence +blends with that fatal beauty, of which he was so frankly aware, so +amiable to his friends, to his wife, of the effects of which on the +people his enemies were so much afraid, on which Shakespeare himself +dwells so attentively as the "royal blood" comes and goes in the face +with his rapid changes of temper. As happens with sensitive natures, +it attunes him to a congruous suavity of manners, by which anger +itself became flattering: [195] it blends with his merely youthful +hopefulness and high spirits, his sympathetic love for gay people, +things, apparel--"his cote of gold and stone, valued at thirty +thousand marks," the novel Italian fashions he preferred, as also +with those real amiabilities that made people forget the darker +touches of his character, but never tire of the pathetic rehearsal of +his fall, the meekness of which would have seemed merely abject in a +less graceful performer. + +Yet it is only fair to say that in the painstaking "revival" of King +Richard the Second, by the late Charles Kean, those who were very +young thirty years ago were afforded much more than Shakespeare's +play could ever have been before--the very person of the king based +on the stately old portrait in Westminster Abbey, "the earliest +extant contemporary likeness of any English sovereign," the grace, +the winning pathos, the sympathetic voice of the player, the tasteful +archaeology confronting vulgar modern London with a scenic +reproduction, for once really agreeable, of the London of Chaucer. +In the hands of Kean the play became like an exquisite performance on +the violin. + +The long agony of one so gaily painted by nature's self, from his +"tragic abdication" till the hour in which he + +Sluiced out his innocent soul thro' streams of blood, + +was for playwrights a subject ready to hand, and [196] became early +the theme of a popular drama, of which some have fancied surviving +favourite fragments in the rhymed parts of Shakespeare's work. + +The king Richard of Yngland +Was in his flowris then regnand: +But his flowris efter sone +Fadyt, and ware all undone:-- + +says the old chronicle. Strangely enough, Shakespeare supposes him +an over-confident believer in that divine right of kings, of which +people in Shakespeare's time were coming to hear so much; a general +right, sealed to him (so Richard is made to think) as an ineradicable +personal gift by the touch--stream rather, over head and breast and +shoulders--of the "holy oil" of his consecration at Westminster; not, +however, through some oversight, the genuine balm used at the +coronation of his successor, given, according to legend, by the +Blessed Virgin to Saint Thomas of Canterbury. Richard himself found +that, it was said, among other forgotten treasures, at the crisis of +his changing fortunes, and vainly sought reconsecration therewith-- +understood, wistfully, that it was reserved for his happier rival. +And yet his coronation, by the pageantry, the amplitude, the learned +care, of its order, so lengthy that the king, then only eleven years +of age, and fasting, as a communicant at the ceremony, was carried +away in a faint, fixed the type under which it has ever [197] since +continued. And nowhere is there so emphatic a reiteration as in +Richard the Second of the sentiment which those singular rites were +calculated to produce. + +Not all the water in the rough rude sea +Can wash the balm from an anointed king,-- + +as supplementing another, almost supernatural, right.--"Edward's +seven sons," of whom Richard's father was one, + +Were as seven phials of his sacred blood. + +But this, too, in the hands of Shakespeare, becomes for him, like any +other of those fantastic, ineffectual, easily discredited, personal +graces, as capricious in its operation on men's wills as merely +physical beauty, kindling himself to eloquence indeed, but only +giving double pathos to insults which "barbarism itself" might have +pitied--the dust in his face, as he returns, through the streets of +London, a prisoner in the train of his victorious enemy. + +How soon my sorrow hath destroyed my face! + +he cries, in that most poetic invention of the mirror scene, which +does but reinforce again that physical charm which all confessed. +The sense of "divine right" in kings is found to act not so much as a +secret of power over others, as of infatuation to themselves. And of +all those personal gifts the one which alone never altogether fails +him is just that royal utterance, his [198] appreciation of the +poetry of his own hapless lot, an eloquent self-pity, infecting +others in spite of themselves, till they too become irresistibly +eloquent about him. + +In the Roman Pontifical, of which the order of Coronation is really +a part, there is no form for the inverse process, no rite of +"degradation," such as that by which an offending priest or bishop +may be deprived, if not of the essential quality of "orders," yet, +one by one, of its outward dignities. It is as if Shakespeare had +had in mind some such inverted rite, like those old ecclesiastical or +military ones, by which human hardness, or human justice, adds the +last touch of unkindness to the execution of its sentences, in the +scene where Richard "deposes" himself, as in some long, agonising +ceremony, reflectively drawn out, with an extraordinary refinement of +intelligence and variety of piteous appeal, but also with a felicity +of poetic invention, which puts these pages into a very select class, +with the finest "vermeil and ivory" work of Chatterton or Keats. + +Fetch hither Richard that in common view +He may surrender!-- + +And Richard more than concurs: he throws himself into the part, +realises a type, falls gracefully as on the world's stage.--Why is he +sent for? + +To do that office of thine own good will +Which tired majesty did make thee offer.-- + +Now mark me! how I will undo myself. + +[199] "Hath Bolingbroke deposed thine intellect?" the Queen asks him, +on his way to the Tower:-- + +Hath Bolingbroke +Deposed thine intellect? hath he been in thy heart? + +And in truth, but for that adventitious poetic gold, it would be only +"plume-plucked Richard."-- + +I find myself a traitor with the rest, +For I have given here my soul's consent +To undeck the pompous body of a king. + +He is duly reminded, indeed, how + +That which in mean men we entitle patience +Is pale cold cowardice in noble breasts. + +Yet at least within the poetic bounds of Shakespeare's play, through +Shakespeare's bountiful gifts, his desire seems fulfilled.-- + +O! that I were as great +As is my grief. + +And his grief becomes nothing less than a central expression of all +that in the revolutions of Fortune's wheel goes down in the world. + +No! Shakespeare's kings are not, nor are meant to be, great men: +rather, little or quite ordinary humanity, thrust upon greatness, +with those pathetic results, the natural self-pity of the weak +heightened in them into irresistible appeal to others as the net +result of their royal prerogative. One after another, they seem to +lie composed in Shakespeare's embalming pages, with just that touch +of nature about them, [200] making the whole world akin, which has +infused into their tombs at Westminster a rare poetic grace. It is +that irony of kingship, the sense that it is in its happiness child's +play, in its sorrows, after all, but children's grief, which gives +its finer accent to all the changeful feeling of these wonderful +speeches:--the great meekness of the graceful, wild creature, tamed +at last.-- + +Give Richard leave to live till Richard die! + +his somewhat abject fear of death, turning to acquiescence at moments +of extreme weariness:-- + +My large kingdom for a little grave! +A little little grave, an obscure grave!-- + +his religious appeal in the last reserve, with its bold reference to +the judgment of Pilate, as he thinks once more of his "anointing." + +And as happens with children he attains contentment finally in the +merely passive recognition of superior strength, in the naturalness +of the result of the great battle as a matter of course, and +experiences something of the royal prerogative of poetry to obscure, +or at least to attune and soften men's griefs. As in some sweet +anthem of Handel, the sufferer, who put finger to the organ under the +utmost pressure of mental conflict, extracts a kind of peace at last +from the mere skill with which he sets his distress to music.-- + +Beshrew thee, Cousin, that didst lead me forth +Of that sweet way I was in to despair! + +[201] "With Cain go wander through the shades of night!" cries the +new king to the gaoler Exton, dissimulating his share in the murder +he is thought to have suggested; and in truth there is something of +the murdered Abel about Shakespeare's Richard. The fact seems to be +that he died of "waste and a broken heart:" it was by way of proof +that his end had been a natural one that, stifling a real fear of the +face, the face of Richard, on men's minds, with the added pleading +now of all dead faces, Henry exposed the corpse to general view; and +Shakespeare, in bringing it on the stage, in the last scene of his +play, does but follow out the motive with which he has emphasised +Richard's physical beauty all through it--that "most beauteous inn," +as the Queen says quaintly, meeting him on the way to death-- +residence, then soon to be deserted, of that wayward, frenzied, but +withal so affectionate soul. Though the body did not go to +Westminster immediately, his tomb, + +That small model of the barren earth +Which serves as paste and cover to our bones,* + +the effigy clasping the hand of his youthful consort, was already +prepared there, with "rich [202] gilding and ornaments," monument of +poetic regret, for Queen Anne of Bohemia, not of course the "Queen" +of Shakespeare, who however seems to have transferred to this second +wife something of Richard's wildly proclaimed affection for the +first. In this way, through the connecting link of that sacred spot, +our thoughts once more associate Richard's two fallacious +prerogatives, his personal beauty and his "anointing." + +According to Johnson, Richard the Second is one of those plays which +Shakespeare has "apparently revised;" and how doubly delightful +Shakespeare is where he seems to have revised! "Would that he had +blotted a thousand"--a thousand hasty phrases, we may venture once +more to say with his earlier critic, now that the tiresome German +superstition has passed away which challenged us to a dogmatic faith +in the plenary verbal inspiration of every one of Shakespeare's +clowns. Like some melodiously contending anthem of Handle's, I said, +of Richard's meek "undoing" of himself in the mirror-scene; and, in +fact, the play of Richard the Second does, like a musical +composition, possess a certain concentration of all its parts, a +simple continuity, an evenness in execution, which are rare in the +great dramatist. With Romeo and Juliet, that perfect symphony +(symphony of three independent poetic forms set in a grander one* +which it is the merit of German [203] criticism to have detected) it +belongs to a small group of plays, where, by happy birth and +consistent evolution, dramatic form approaches to something like the +unity of a lyrical ballad, a lyric, a song, a single strain of music. +Which sort of poetry we are to account the highest, is perhaps a +barren question. Yet if, in art generally, unity of impression is a +note of what is perfect, then lyric poetry, which in spite of complex +structure often preserves the unity of a single passionate +ejaculation, would rank higher than dramatic poetry, where, +especially to the reader, as distinguished from the spectator +assisting at a theatrical performance, there must always be a sense +of the effort necessary to keep the various parts from flying +asunder, a sense of imperfect continuity, such as the older criticism +vainly sought to obviate by the rule of the dramatic "unities." It +follows that a play attains artistic perfection just in proportion as +it approaches that unity of lyrical effect, as if a song or ballad +were still lying at the root of it, all the various expression of the +conflict of character and circumstance falling at last into the +compass of a single melody, or musical theme. As, historically, the +earliest classic drama arose out of the chorus, from which this or +that person, this or that episode, detached itself, so, into the +unity of a choric song the perfect drama ever tends to return, its +intellectual scope deepened, complicated, enlarged, but still with an +unmistakable [204] singleness, or identity, in its impression on the +mind. Just there, in that vivid single impression left on the mind +when all is over, not in any mechanical limitation of time and place, +is the secret of the "unities"--the true imaginative unity--of the +drama. + +1889. + +NOTES + +188. *Elinor. Do you not read some tokens of my son (Coeur-de-Lion) +/ In the large composition of this man? + +190. *Perhaps the one person of genius in these English plays. + +The spirit of deep prophecy she hath, +Exceeding the nine Sibyls of old Rome: +What's past and what's to come she can descry. + +191. *Proposing in this paper to trace the leading sentiment in +Shakespeare's English Plays as a sort of popular dramatic chronicle, +I have left untouched the question how much (or, in the case of Henry +the Sixth and Henry the Eighth, how little) of them may be really +his: how far inferior hands have contributed to a result, true on the +whole to the greater, that is to say, the Shakespearian elements in +them. + +201. *Perhaps a double entendre:--of any ordinary grave, as +comprising, in effect, the whole small earth now left to its occupant +or, of such a tomb as Richard's in particular, with its actual model, +or effigy, of the clay of him. Both senses are so characteristic +that it would be a pity to lose either. + +202. *The Sonnet: the Aubade: the Epithalamium. + + + +DANTE GABRIEL ROSSETTI + +[205] IT was characteristic of a poet who had ever something about +him of mystic isolation, and will still appeal perhaps, though with a +name it may seem now established in English literature, to a special +and limited audience, that some of his poems had won a kind of +exquisite fame before they were in the full sense published. The +Blessed Damozel, although actually printed twice before the year +1870, was eagerly circulated in manuscript; and the volume which it +now opens came at last to satisfy a long-standing curiosity as to the +poet, whose pictures also had become an object of the same peculiar +kind of interest. For those poems were the work of a painter, +understood to belong to, and to be indeed the leader, of a new school +then rising into note; and the reader of to-day may observe already, +in The Blessed Damozel, written at the age of eighteen, a +prefigurement of the chief characteristics of that school, as he will +recognise in it also, in proportion as he really knows Rossetti, many +of the characteristics which are most markedly personal and his own. +Common [206] to that school and to him, and in both alike of primary +significance, was the quality of sincerity, already felt as one of +the charms of that earliest poem--a perfect sincerity, taking effect +in the deliberate use of the most direct and unconventional +expression, for the conveyance of a poetic sense which recognised no +conventional standard of what poetry was called upon to be. At a +time when poetic originality in England might seem to have had its +utmost play, here was certainly one new poet more, with a structure +and music of verse, a vocabulary, an accent, unmistakably novel, yet +felt to be no mere tricks of manner adopted with a view to forcing +attention--an accent which might rather count as the very seal of +reality on one man's own proper speech; as that speech itself was the +wholly natural expression of certain wonderful things he really felt +and saw. Here was one, who had a matter to present to his readers, +to himself at least, in the first instance, so valuable, so real and +definite, that his primary aim, as regards form or expression in his +verse, would be but its exact equivalence to those data within. That +he had this gift of transparency in language--the control of a style +which did but obediently shift and shape itself to the mental motion, +as a well-trained hand can follow on the tracing-paper the outline of +an original drawing below it, was proved afterwards by a volume of +typically perfect translations from the delightful but difficult +[207] "early Italian poets:" such transparency being indeed the +secret of all genuine style, of all such style as can truly belong to +one man and not to another. His own meaning was always personal and +even recondite, in a certain sense learned and casuistical, sometimes +complex or obscure; but the term was always, one could see, +deliberately chosen from many competitors, as the just transcript of +that peculiar phase of soul which he alone knew, precisely as he knew +it. + +One of the peculiarities of The Blessed Damozel was a definiteness of +sensible imagery, which seemed almost grotesque to some, and was +strange, above all, in a theme so profoundly visionary. The gold bar +of heaven from which she leaned, her hair yellow like ripe corn, are +but examples of a general treatment, as naively detailed as the +pictures of those early painters contemporary with Dante, who has +shown a similar care for minute and definite imagery in his verse; +there, too, in the very midst of profoundly mystic vision. Such +definition of outline is indeed one among many points in which +Rossetti resembles the great Italian poet, of whom, led to him at +first by family circumstances, he was ever a lover--a "servant and +singer," faithful as Dante, "of Florence and of Beatrice"--with some +close inward conformities of genius also, independent of any mere +circumstances of education. It was said by a critic of the last +century, not wisely though agreeably to the practice of his time, +[208] that poetry rejoices in abstractions. For Rossetti, as for +Dante, without question on his part, the first condition of the +poetic way of seeing and presenting things is particularisation. +"Tell me now," he writes, for Villon's + +Dictes-moy ou, n'en quel pays, +Est Flora, la belle Romaine-- + +Tell me now, in what hidden way is +Lady Flora the lovely Roman: + +--"way," in which one might actually chance to meet her; the +unmistakably poetic effect of the couplet in English being dependent +on the definiteness of that single word (though actually lighted on +in the search after a difficult double rhyme) for which every one +else would have written, like Villon himself, a more general one, +just equivalent to place or region. + +And this delight in concrete definition is allied with another of his +conformities to Dante, the really imaginative vividness, namely, of +his personifications--his hold upon them, or rather their hold upon +him, with the force of a Frankenstein, when once they have taken life +from him. Not Death only and Sleep, for instance, and the winged +spirit of Love, but certain particular aspects of them, a whole +"populace" of special hours and places, "the hour" even "which might +have been, yet might not be," are living creatures, with hands and +eyes and articulate voices. + +[209] + +Stands it not by the door-- +Love's Hour--till she and I shall meet; +With bodiless form and unapparent feet +That cast no shadow yet before, +Though round its head the dawn begins to pour +The breath that makes day sweet?-- + +Nay, why +Name the dead hours? I mind them well: +Their ghosts in many darkened doorways dwell +With desolate eyes to know them by. + +Poetry as a mania--one of Plato's two higher forms of "divine" mania- +-has, in all its species, a mere insanity incidental to it, the +"defect of its quality," into which it may lapse in its moment of +weakness; and the insanity which follows a vivid poetic +anthropomorphism like that of Rossetti may be noted here and there in +his work, in a forced and almost grotesque materialising of +abstractions, as Dante also became at times a mere subject of the +scholastic realism of the Middle Age. + +In Love's Nocturn and The Stream's Secret, congruously perhaps with a +certain feverishness of soul in the moods they present, there is at +times a near approach (may it be said?) to such insanity of realism-- + +Pity and love shall burn +In her pressed cheek and cherishing hands; +And from the living spirit of love that stands +Between her lips to soothe and yearn, +Each separate breath shall clasp me round in turn +And loose my spirit's bands. + +[210] But even if we concede this; even if we allow, in the very plan +of those two compositions, something of the literary conceit--what +exquisite, what novel flowers of poetry, we must admit them to be, as +they stand! In the one, what a delight in all the natural beauty of +water, all its details for the eye of a painter; in the other, how +subtle and fine the imaginative hold upon all the secret ways of +sleep and dreams! In both of them, with much the same attitude and +tone, Love--sick and doubtful Love--would fain inquire of what lies +below the surface of sleep, and below the water; stream or dream +being forced to speak by Love's powerful "control"; and the poet +would have it foretell the fortune, issue, and event of his wasting +passion. Such artifices, indeed, were not unknown in the old +Provencal poetry of which Dante had learned something. Only, in +Rossetti at least, they are redeemed by a serious purpose, by that +sincerity of his, which allies itself readily to a serious beauty, a +sort of grandeur of literary workmanship, to a great style. One +seems to hear there a really new kind of poetic utterance, with +effects which have nothing else like them; as there is nothing else, +for instance, like the narrative of Jacob's Dream in Genesis, or +Blake's design of the Singing of the Morning Stars, or Addison's +Nineteenth Psalm. + +With him indeed, as in some revival of the old mythopoeic age, common +things--dawn, [211] noon, night--are full of human or personal +expression, full of sentiment. The lovely little sceneries scattered +up and down his poems, glimpses of a landscape, not indeed of broad +open-air effects, but rather that of a painter concentrated upon the +picturesque effect of one or two selected objects at a time--the +"hollow brimmed with mist," or the "ruined weir," as he sees it from +one of the windows, or reflected in one of the mirrors of his "house +of life" (the vignettes for instance seen by Rose Mary in the magic +beryl) attest, by their very freshness and simplicity, to a pictorial +or descriptive power in dealing with the inanimate world, which is +certainly also one half of the charm, in that other, more remote and +mystic, use of it. For with Rossetti this sense of lifeless nature, +after all, is translated to a higher service, in which it does but +incorporate itself with some phase of strong emotion. Every one +understands how this may happen at critical moments of life; what a +weirdly expressive soul may have crept, even in full noonday, into +"the white-flower'd elder-thicket," when Godiva saw it "gleam through +the Gothic archways in the wall," at the end of her terrible ride. +To Rossetti it is so always, because to him life is a crisis at every +moment. A sustained impressibility towards the mysterious conditions +of man's everyday life, towards the very mystery itself in it, gives +a singular gravity to all his work: those matters never became trite +[212] to him. But throughout, it is the ideal intensity of love--of +love based upon a perfect yet peculiar type of physical or material +beauty--which is enthroned in the midst of those mysterious powers; +Youth and Death, Destiny and Fortune, Fame, Poetic Fame, Memory, +Oblivion, and the like. Rossetti is one of those who, in the words +of Merimee, se passionnent pour la passion, one of Love's lovers. + +And yet, again as with Dante, to speak of his ideal type of beauty as +material, is partly misleading. Spirit and matter, indeed, have been +for the most part opposed, with a false contrast or antagonism by +schoolmen, whose artificial creation those abstractions really are. +In our actual concrete experience, the two trains of phenomena which +the words matter and spirit do but roughly distinguish, play +inextricably into each other. Practically, the church of the Middle +Age by its aesthetic worship, its sacramentalism, its real faith in +the resurrection of the flesh, had set itself against that Manichean +opposition of spirit and matter, and its results in men's way of +taking life; and in this, Dante is the central representative of its +spirit. To him, in the vehement and impassioned heat of his +conceptions, the material and the spiritual are fused and blent: if +the spiritual attains the definite visibility of a crystal, what is +material loses its earthiness and impurity. And here again, by force +of instinct, Rossetti [213] is one with him. His chosen type of +beauty is one, + +Whose speech Truth knows not from her thought, +Nor Love her body from her soul. + +Like Dante, he knows no region of spirit which shall not be sensuous +also, or material. The shadowy world, which he realises so +powerfully, has still the ways and houses, the land and water, the +light and darkness, the fire and flowers, that had so much to do in +the moulding of those bodily powers and aspects which counted for so +large a part of the soul, here. + +For Rossetti, then, the great affections of persons to each other, +swayed and determined, in the case of his highly pictorial genius, +mainly by that so-called material loveliness, formed the great +undeniable reality in things, the solid resisting substance, in a +world where all beside might be but shadow. The fortunes of those +affections--of the great love so determined; its casuistries, its +languor sometimes; above all, its sorrows; its fortunate or +unfortunate collisions with those other great matters; how it looks, +as the long day of life goes round, in the light and shadow of them: +all this, conceived with an abundant imagination, and a deep, a +philosophic, reflectiveness, is the matter of his verse, and +especially of what he designed as his chief poetic work, "a work to +be called The House of Life," towards which the majority of his +sonnets and songs were contributions. + +[214] The dwelling-place in which one finds oneself by chance or +destiny, yet can partly fashion for oneself; never properly one's own +at all, if it be changed too lightly; in which every object has its +associations--the dim mirrors, the portraits, the lamps, the books, +the hair-tresses of the dead and visionary magic crystals in the +secret drawers, the names and words scratched on the windows, windows +open upon prospects the saddest or the sweetest; the house one must +quit, yet taking perhaps, how much of its quietly active light and +colour along with us!--grown now to be a kind of raiment to one's +body, as the body, according to Swedenborg, is but the raiment of the +soul--under that image, the whole of Rossetti's work might count as a +House of Life, of which he is but the "Interpreter." And it is a +"haunted" house. A sense of power in love, defying distance, and +those barriers which are so much more than physical distance, of +unutterable desire penetrating into the world of sleep, however +"lead-bound," was one of those anticipative notes obscurely struck in +The Blessed Damozel, and, in his later work, makes him speak +sometimes almost like a believer in mesmerism. Dream-land, as we +said, with its "phantoms of the body," deftly coming and going on +love's service, is to him, in no mere fancy or figure of speech, a +real country, a veritable expansion of, or addition to, our waking +life; and he did well perhaps to wait carefully upon sleep, for the +lack [215] of it became mortal disease with him. One may even +recognise a sort of morbid and over-hasty making-ready for death +itself, which increases on him; thoughts concerning it, its +imageries, coming with a frequency and importunity, in excess, one +might think, of even the very saddest, quite wholesome wisdom. + +And indeed the publication of his second volume of Ballads and +Sonnets preceded his death by scarcely a twelvemonth. That volume +bears witness to the reverse of any failure of power, or falling-off +from his early standard of literary perfection, in every one of his +then accustomed forms of poetry--the song, the sonnet, and the +ballad. The newly printed sonnets, now completing The House of Life, +certainly advanced beyond those earlier ones, in clearness; his +dramatic power in the ballad, was here at its height; while one +monumental, gnomic piece, Soothsay, testifies, more clearly even than +the Nineveh of his first volume, to the reflective force, the dry +reason, always at work behind his imaginative creations, which at no +time dispensed with a genuine intellectual structure. For in matters +of pure reflection also, Rossetti maintained the painter's sensuous +clearness of conception; and this has something to do with the +capacity, largely illustrated by his ballads, of telling some red- +hearted story of impassioned action with effect. + +Have there, in very deed, been ages, in which [216] the external +conditions of poetry such as Rossetti's were of more spontaneous +growth than in our own? The archaic side of Rossetti's work, his +preferences in regard to earlier poetry, connect him with those who +have certainly thought so, who fancied they could have breathed more +largely in the age of Chaucer, or of Ronsard, in one of those ages, +in the words of Stendhal--ces siecles de passions ou les ames +pouvaient se livrer franchement a la plus haute exaltation, quand les +passions qui font la possibilite We may think, perhaps, that such old +time as that has never really existed except in the fancy of poets; +but it was to find it, that Rossetti turned so often from modern life +to the chronicle of the past. Old Scotch history, perhaps beyond any +other, is strong in the matter of heroic and vehement hatreds and +love, the tragic Mary herself being but the perfect blossom of them; +and it is from that history that Rossetti has taken the subjects of +the two longer ballads of his second volume: of the three admirable +ballads in it, The King's Tragedy (in which Rossetti has dexterously +interwoven some relics of James's own exquisite early verse) reaching +the highest level of dramatic success, and marking perfection, +perhaps, in this kind of poetry; which, in the earlier volume, gave +us, among other pieces, Troy Town, Sister Helen, and Eden Bower. + +Like those earlier pieces, the ballads of the [217] second volume +bring with them the question of the poetic value of the "refrain"-- + +Eden bower's in flower: +And O the bower and the hour! + +--and the like. Two of those ballads--Troy Town and Eden Bower, are +terrible in theme; and the refrain serves, perhaps, to relieve their +bold aim at the sentiment of terror. In Sister Helen again, the +refrain has a real, and sustained purpose (being here duly varied +also) and performs the part of a chorus, as the story proceeds. Yet +even in these cases, whatever its effect may be in actual recitation, +it may fairly be questioned, whether, to the mere reader their actual +effect is not that of a positive interruption and drawback, at least +in pieces so lengthy; and Rossetti himself, it would seem, came to +think so, for in the shortest of his later ballads, The White Ship-- +that old true history of the generosity with which a youth, worthless +in life, flung himself upon death--he was contented with a single +utterance of the refrain, "given out" like the keynote or tune of a +chant. + +In The King's Tragedy, Rossetti has worked upon motive, broadly human +(to adopt the phrase of popular criticism) such as one and all may +realise. Rossetti, indeed, with all his self-concentration upon his +own peculiar aim, by no means ignored those general interests which +are external to poetry as he conceived it; as he has [218] shown here +and there, in this poetic, as also in pictorial, work. It was but +that, in a life to be shorter even than the average, he found enough +to occupy him in the fulfilment of a task, plainly "given him to +do." Perhaps, if one had to name a single composition of his to +readers desiring to make acquaintance with him for the first time, +one would select: The King's Tragedy--that poem so moving, so +popularly dramatic, and lifelike. Notwithstanding this, his work, it +must be conceded, certainly through no narrowness or egotism, but in +the faithfulness of a true workman to a vocation so emphatic, was +mainly of the esoteric order. But poetry, at all times, exercises +two distinct functions: it may reveal, it may unveil to every eye, +the ideal aspects of common things, after Gray's way (though Gray +too, it is well to remember, seemed in his own day, seemed even to +Johnson, obscure) or it may actually add to the number of motives +poetic and uncommon in themselves, by the imaginative creation of +things that are ideal from their very birth. Rossetti did something, +something excellent, of the former kind; but his characteristic, his +really revealing work, lay in the adding to poetry of fresh poetic +material, of a new order of phenomena, in the creation of a new +ideal. + +1883. + + + +FEUILLET'S "LA MORTE" + +[219] IN his latest novel M. Octave Feuillet adds two charming people +to that chosen group of personages in which he loves to trace the +development of the more serious elements of character amid the +refinements and artifices of modern society, and which make such good +company. The proper function of fictitious literature in affording +us a refuge into a world slightly better--better conceived, or better +finished--than the real one, is effected in most instances less +through the imaginary events at which a novelist causes us to assist, +than by the imaginary persons to whom he introduces us. The +situations of M. Feuillet's novels are indeed of a real and intrinsic +importance:--tragic crises, inherent in the general conditions of +human nature itself, or which arise necessarily out of the special +conditions of modern society. Still, with him, in the actual result, +they become subordinate, as it is their tendency to do in real life, +to the characters they help to form. Often, his most attentive +reader will have forgotten the actual details of his plot; while +[220] the soul, tried, enlarged, shaped by it, remains as a well- +fixed type in the memory. He may return a second or third time to +Sibylle, or Le Journal d'une Femme, or Les Amours de Philippe, and +watch, surprised afresh, the clean, dainty, word-sparing literary +operation (word-sparing, yet with no loss of real grace or ease) +which, sometimes in a few pages, with the perfect logic of a problem +of Euclid, complicates and then unravels some moral embarrassment, +really worthy of a trained dramatic expert. But the characters +themselves, the agents in those difficult, revealing situations, such +a reader will recognise as old acquaintances after the first reading, +feeling for them as for some gifted and attractive persons he has +known in the actual world--Raoul de Chalys, Henri de Lerne, Madame de +Tecle, Jeanne de la Roche-Ermel, Maurice de Fremeuse, many others; to +whom must now be added Bernard and Aliette de Vaudricourt. + +"How I love those people!" cries Mademoiselle de Courteheuse, of +Madame de Sevigne and some other of her literary favourites in the +days of the Grand Monarch. "What good company! What pleasure they +took in high things! How much more worthy they were than the people +who live now!"--What good company! That is precisely what the +admirer of M. Feuillet's books feels as one by one he places them on +his book-shelf, to be sought again. What is proposed here is not to +tell his last story, [221] but to give the English reader specimens +of his most recent effort at characterisation. + +It is with the journal of Bernard himself that the story opens, +September 187-. Bernard-Maurice Hugon de Montauret, Vicomte de +Vaudricourt, is on a visit to his uncle, the head of his family, at +La Saviniere, a country-house somewhere between Normandy and +Brittany. This uncle, an artificial old Parisian in manner, but +honest in purpose, a good talker, and full of real affection for his +heir Bernard, is one of M. Feuillet's good minor characters--one of +the quietly humorous figures with which he relieves his more serious +company. Bernard, with whom the refinements of a man of fashion in +the Parisian world by no means disguise a powerful intelligence +cultivated by wide reading, has had thoughts during his tedious stay +at La Saviniere of writing a history of the reign of Louis the +Fourteenth, the library of a neighbouring chateau being rich in +memoirs of that period. Finally, he prefers to write his own story, +a story so much more interesting to himself; to write it at a +peculiar crisis in his life, the moment when his uncle, unmarried, +but anxious to perpetuate his race, is bent on providing him with a +wife, and indeed has one in view. + +The accomplished Bernard, with many graces of person, by his own +confession, takes nothing seriously. As to that matter of religious +beliefs, "the breeze of the age, and of science, has blown [222] over +him, as it has blown over his contemporaries, and left empty space +there." Still, when he saw his childish religious faith departing +from him, as he thinks it must necessarily depart from all +intelligent male Parisians, he wept. Since that moment, however, a +gaiety, serene and imperturbable, has been the mainstay of his +happily constituted character. The girl to whom his uncle desires to +see him united--odd, quixotic, intelligent, with a sort of pathetic +and delicate grace, and herself very religious--belongs to an old- +fashioned, devout family,. resident at Varaville, near by. M. +Feuillet, with half a dozen fine touches of his admirable pencil +makes us see the place. And the enterprise has at least sufficient +interest to keep Bernard in the country, which the young Parisian +detests. "This piquant episode of my life," he writes, "seems to me +to be really deserving of study; to be worth etching off, day by day, +by an observer well informed on the subject." + +Recognising in himself, though as his one real fault, that he can +take nothing seriously in heaven or earth, Bernard de Vaudricourt, +like all M. Feuillet's favourite young men, so often erring or +corrupt, is a man of scrupulous "honour." He has already shown +disinterestedness in wishing his rich uncle to marry again. His +friends at Varaville think so well-mannered a young man more of a +Christian than he really is; and, at all events, he will never owe +his happiness to a falsehood. If he has great faults, [223] +hypocrisy at least is no part of them. In oblique paths he finds +himself ill at ease. Decidedly, as he thinks, he was born for +straight ways, for loyalty in all his enterprises; and he +congratulates himself upon the fact. + +In truth, Bernard has merits which he ignores, at least in this first +part of his journal: merits which are necessary to explain the +influence he is able to exercise from the first over such a character +as Mademoiselle de Courteheuse. His charm, in fact, is in the union +of that gay and apparently wanton nature with a genuine power of +appreciating devotion in others, which becomes devotion in himself. +With all the much-cherished elegance and worldly glitter of his +personality, he is capable of apprehending, of understanding and +being touched by the presence of great matters. In spite of that +happy lightness of heart, so jealously fenced about, he is to be +wholly caught at last, as he is worthy to be, by the serious, the +generous influence of things. In proportion to his immense worldly +strength is his capacity for the immense pity which breaks his heart. + +In a few life-like touches M. Feuillet brings out, as if it were +indeed a thing of ordinary existence, the simple yet delicate life of +a French country-house, the ideal life in an ideal France. Bernard +is paying a morning visit at the old turreted home of the +"prehistoric" Courteheuse family. Mademoiselle Aliette de +Courteheuse, a studious girl, though a bold and excellent rider [224] +--Mademoiselle de Courteheuse, "with her hair of that strange colour +of fine ashes"--has conducted her visitor to see the library: + +One day she took me to see the library, rich in works of the +seventeenth century and in memoirs relating to that time. I +remarked there also a curious collection of engravings of the +same period. "Your father," I observed, "had a strong +predilection for the age of Louis the Fourteenth." + +"My father lived in that age," she answered gravely. And as +I looked at her with surprise, and a little embarrassed, she +added, "He made me live there too, in his company." + +And then the eyes of this singular girl filled with tears. +She turned away, took a few steps to suppress her emotion, and +returning, pointed me to a chair. Then seating herself on the +step of the book-case, she said, "I must explain my father +to you." + +She was half a minute collecting her thoughts: then, speaking +with an expansion of manner not habitual with her, hesitating, +and blushing deeply, whenever she was about to utter a word that +might seem a shade too serious for lips so youthful:--"My +father," she proceeded, "died of the consequences of a wound he +had received at Patay. That may show you that he loved his +country, but he was no lover of his own age. He possessed in +the highest degree the love of order; and order was a thing +nowhere to be seen. He had a horror of disorder; and he saw it +everywhere. In those last years, especially, his reverence, +his beliefs, his tastes, all alike were ruffled to the point of +actual suffering, by whatever was done and said and written +around him. Deeply saddened by the conditions of the present +time, he habituated himself to find a refuge in the past, and +the seventeenth century more particularly offered him the kind +of society in which he would have wished to live--a society, +well-ordered, polished, lettered, believing. More and more he +loved to shut himself up in it. More and more also he loved to +make the moral discipline and the literary tastes of that +favourite age prevail in his own household. You may even have +remarked that he carried his predilection into minute matters of +arrangement and decoration. You can see from this window the +straight paths, the box in [225] patterns, the yew trees and +clipped alleys of our garden. You may notice that in our garden- +beds we have none but flowers of the period--lilies, rose-mallows, +immortelles, rose-pinks, in short what people call parsonage +flowers--des fleurs de cure. Our old silvan tapestries, +similarly, are of that age. You see too that all our furniture, +from presses and sideboards, down to our little tables and our +arm-chairs, is in the severest style of Louis the Fourteenth. +My father did not appreciate the dainty research of our modern +luxury. He maintained that our excessive care for the comforts +of life weakened mind as well as body. That," added the girl +with a laugh,--"that is why you find your chair so hard when +you come to see us." + +Then, with resumed gravity--"It was thus that my father +endeavoured, by the very aspect and arrangement of outward +things, to promote in himself the imaginary presence of the +epoch in which his thoughts delighted. As for myself--need I +tell you that I was the confidant of that father, so well- +beloved: a confidant touched by his sorrows, full of +indignation at his disappointments, charmed by his consolations. +Here, precisely--surrounded by those books which we read +together, and which he taught me to love--it is here that I +have passed the pleasantest hours of my youth. In common we +indulged our enthusiasm for those days of faith; of the quiet +life; its blissful hours of leisure well-secured; for the +French language in its beauty and purity; the delicate, the +noble urbanity, which was then the honour and the special mark +of our country, but has ceased to be so." + +She paused, with a little confusion, as I thought, at the warmth +of her last words. + +And then, just to break the silence, "You have explained," I +said, "an impression which I have experienced again and again +in my visits here, and which has sometimes reached the intensity +of an actual illusion, though a very agreeable one. The look +of your house, its style, its tone and keeping, carried me two +centuries back so completely that I should hardly have been +surprised to hear Monsieur le Prince, Madame de la Fayette, +or Madame de Sevigne herself, announced at your drawing- +room door." + +"Would it might be!" said Mademoiselle de Courteheuse. [226] +"Ah! Monsieur, how I love those people! What good company! +What pleasure they took in high things! How much more worthy +they were than the people who live now!" I tried to calm a +little this retrospective enthusiasm, so much to the prejudice +of my contemporaries and of myself. "Most truly, +Mademoiselle," I said, "the age which you regret had its +rare merits--merits which I appreciate as you do. But then, +need one say that that society, so regular, so choice in +appearance, had, like our own, below the surface, its troubles, +its disorders? I see here many of the memoirs of that time. +I can't tell exactly which of them you may or may not have read, +and so I feel a certain difficulty in speaking." + +She interrupted me: "Ah!" she said, with entire simplicity, "I +understand you. I have not read all you see here. But I have +read enough of it to know that my friends in that past age had, +like those who live now, their passions, their weaknesses, +their mistakes. But, as my father used to say to me, all that +did but pass over a ground of what was solid and serious, which +always discovered itself again anew. There were great faults +then; but there were also great repentances. There was a +certain higher region to which everything conducted--even what +as evil." She blushed deeply: then rising a little suddenly, +"A long speech!" she said: "Forgive me! I am not usually so +very talkative. It is because my father was in question; and +I should wish his memory to be as dear and as venerable to all +the rest of the world as it is to me." + +We pass over the many little dramatic intrigues and misunderstandings, +with the more or less adroit interferences of the uncle, which raise +and lower alternately Bernard's hopes. M. Feuillet has more than once +tried his hand with striking success in the portraiture of French +ecclesiastics. He has drawn none better than the Bishop of Saint-Meen, +uncle of Mademoiselle de Courteheuse, to whose interests he is devoted. +Bernard feels that to gain the influence of this prelate [227] would +be to gain his cause; and the opportunity for an interview comes. + +Monseigneur de Courteheuse would seem to be little over fifty +years of age: he is rather tall, and very thin: the eyes, black +and full of life, are encircled by a ring of deep brown. His +speech and gesture are animated, and, at times, as if carried +away. He adopts frequently a sort of furious manner which +on a sudden melts into the smile of an honest man. He has +beautiful silvery hair, flying in vagrant locks over his +forehead, and beautiful bishop's hands. As he becomes calm +he has an imposing way of gently resettling himself in his +sacerdotal dignity. To sum up: his is a physiognomy full of +passion, consumed with zeal, yet still frank and sincere. + +I was hardly seated, when with a motion of the hand he invited +me to speak. + +"Monseigneur!" I said, "I come to you (you understand me?) as +to my last resource. What I am now doing is almost an act of +despair; for it might seem at first sight that no member of +the family of Mademoiselle de Courteheuse must show himself +more pitiless than yourself towards the faults with which I +am reproached. I am an unbeliever: you are an apostle! And +yet, Monseigneur, it is often at the hands of saintly priests, +such as yourself, that the guilty find most indulgence. And +then, I am not indeed guilty: I have but wandered. I am refused +the hand of your niece because I do not share her faith--your +own faith. But, Monseigneur, unbelief is not a crime, it is +a misfortune. I know people often say, a man denies God when +by his own conduct he has brought himself into a condition in +which he may well desire that God does not exist. In this +way he is made guilty, or, in a sense, responsible for his +incredulity. For myself, Monseigneur, I have consulted my +conscience with an entire sincerity; and although my youth has +been amiss, I am certain that my atheism proceeds from no +sentiment of personal interest. On the contrary, I may tell you +with truth that the day on which I perceived my faith come to +nought, the day on which I lost hope in God, I shed the bitterest +tears of my life. In spite of appearances, I am not so light a +spirit as people think. I am not one of those for whom God, +when He disappears, [228] leaves no sense of a void place. +Believe me!--a man may love sport, his club, his worldly +habits, and yet have his hours of thought, of self- +recollection. Do you suppose that in those hours one does +not feel the frightful discomfort of an existence with no +moral basis, without principles, with no outlook beyond this +world? And yet, what can one do? You would tell me forthwith, +in the goodness, the compassion, which I read in your eyes; +Confide to me your objections to religion, and I will try to +solve them. Monseigneur, I should hardly know how to answer +you. My objections are 'Legion!' They are without number, +like the stars in the sky: they come to us on all sides, from +every quarter of the horizon, as if on the wings of the wind; +and they leave in us, as they pass, ruins only, and darkness. +Such has been my experience, and that of many others; and it +has been as involuntary as it is irreparable." + +"And I--Monsieur!" said the bishop, suddenly, casting on me +one of his august looks, "Do you suppose that I am but a +play-actor in my cathedral church?" + +"Monseigneur!" + +"Yes! Listening to you, one would suppose that we were come +to a period of the world in which one must needs be either an +atheist or a hypocrite! Personally, I claim to be neither +one nor the other." + +"Need I defend myself on that point, Monseigneur? Need I say +that I did not come here to give you offence?" + +"Doubtless! doubtless! Well, Monsieur, I admit; not without +great reserves, mind! for one is always more or less responsible +for the atmosphere in which he lives, the influences to which +he is subject, for the habitual turn he gives to his thoughts; +still, I admit that you are the victim of the incredulity of the +age, that you are altogether guiltless in your scepticism, your +atheism! since you have no fear of hard words. Is it therefore +any the less certain that the union of a fervent believer, such +as my niece, with a man like yourself would be a moral disorder +of which the consequences might be disastrous? Do you think it +could be my duty, as a relative of Mademoiselle de Courteheuse, +her spiritual father, as a prelate of the Church, to lend my +hands to such disorder, to preside over the shocking union of +two souls separated by the whole width of heaven?" + +[229] The bishop, in proposing that question, kept his eyes +fixed ardently on mine. + +"Monseigneur," I answered, after a moment's embarrassment, "you +know as well as, and better than I, the condition of the world, +and of our country, at this time. You know that unhappily I +am not an exception: that men of faith are rare in it. And +permit me to tell you my whole mind. If I must needs suffer +the inconsolable misfortune of renouncing the happiness I had +hoped for, are you quite sure that the man to whom one of these +days you will give your niece may not be something more than +a sceptic, or even an atheist?" + +"What, Monsieur?" + +"A hypocrite, Monseigneur! Mademoiselle de Courteheuse is +beautiful enough, rich enough, to excite the ambition of those +who may be less scrupulous than I. As for me, if you now know +that I am a sceptic, you know also that I am a man of honour: +and there is something in that!" + +"A man of honour!" the bishop muttered to himself, with a +little petulance and hesitation. "A man of honour! Yes, I +believe it!" Then, after an interval, "Come, Monsieur," he +said gently, "your case is not as desperate as you suppose. +My Aliette is one of those young enthusiasts through whom +Heaven sometimes works miracles." And Bernard refusing any +encouragement of that hope (the "very roots of faith are +dead" in him for ever) "since you think that," the bishop +answers, "it is honest to say so. But God has His ways!" + +Soon after, the journal comes to an end with that peculiar crisis in +Bernard's life which had suggested the writing of it. Aliette, with +the approval of her family, has given him her hand. Bernard accepts +it with the full purpose of doing all he can to make his wife as +happy as she is charming and beloved. The virginal first period of +their married life in their dainty house in Paris--the pure and +beautiful picture of the mother, the father, and at last the child, a +little [230] girl, Jeanne--is presented with M. Feuillet's usual +grace. Certain embarrassments succeed; the development of what was +ill-matched in their union; but still with mutual loyalty. A far- +reaching acquaintance with, and reflection upon, the world and its +ways, especially the Parisian world, has gone into the apparently +slight texture of these pages. The accomplished playwright may be +recognised in the skilful touches with which M. Feuillet, unrivalled, +as his regular readers know, in his power of breathing higher notes +into the frivolous prattle of fashionable French life, develops the +tragic germ in the elegant, youthful household. Amid the +distractions of a society, frivolous, perhaps vulgar, Aliette's mind +is still set on greater things; and, in spite of a thousand rude +discouragements, she maintains her generous hope for Bernard's +restoration to faith. One day, a little roughly, he bids her +relinquish that dream finally. She looks at him with the moist, +suppliant eyes of some weak animal at bay. Then his native goodness +returns. In a softened tone he owns himself wrong. + +"As to conversions;--no one must be despaired of. Do you +remember M. de Rance? He lived in your favourite age;--M. de +Rance. Well! before he became the reformer of La Trappe he +had been a worldling like me, and a great sceptic--what +people called a libertine. Still he became a saint! It is +true he had a terrible reason for it. Do you know what it +was converted him?" + +Aliette gave a sign that she did not know. + +"Well! he returned to Paris after a few days' absence. He +[231] ran straight to the lady he loved; Madame Montbazon, +I think: he went up a little staircase of which he had the +key, and the first thing he saw on the table in the middle +of the room was the head of his mistress, of which the +doctors were about to make a post-mortem examination." + +"If I were sure," said Aliette, "that my head could have +such power, I would love to die." + +She said it in a low voice, but with such an accent of loving +sincerity that her husband had a sensation of a sort of painful +disquiet. He smiled, however, and tapping her cheek softly, +"Folly!" he said. "A head, charming as yours, has no need to +be dead that it may work miracles!" + +Certainly M. Feuillet has some weighty charges to bring against the +Parisian society of our day. When Aliette revolts from a world of +gossip, which reduces all minds alike to the same level of vulgar +mediocrity, Bernard, on his side, can perceive there a deterioration +of moral tone which shocks his sense of honour. As a man of honour, +he can hardly trust his wife to the gaieties of a society which +welcomes all the world "to amuse itself in undress." + +It happened that at this perplexed period in the youthful +household, one and the same person became the recipient both +of the tearful confidences of Madame de Vaudricourt and those +of her husband. It was the Duchess of Castel-Moret [she is +another of M. Feuillet's admirable minor sketches] an old +friend of the Vaudricourt family, and the only woman with +whom Aliette since her arrival in Paris had formed a kind +of intimacy. The Duchess was far from sharing, on points +of morality, and above all of religion, the severe and +impassioned orthodoxy of her young friend. She had lived, +it is true, an irreproachable life, but less in consequence +of defined principles than by instinct and natural taste. +She admitted to herself that she was an honest woman as a +result of her birth, and had no further merit in the matter. +She was old, very careful of [232] herself, and a pleasant +aroma floated about her, below her silvery hair. People +loved her for her grace--the grace of another time than ours-- +for her wit, and her worldly wisdom, which she placed freely +at the disposal of the public. Now and then she made a match: +but her special gift lay rather in the way in which she came +to the rescue when a marriage turned out ill. And she had no +sinecure: the result was that she passed the best part of her +time in repairing family rents. That might "last its time," +she would say. "And then we know that what has been well +mended sometimes lasts better than what is new." + +A little later, Bernard, in the interest of Aliette, has chivalrously +determined to quit Paris. At Valmoutiers, a fine old place in the +neighbourhood of Fontainebleau, they established themselves for a +country life. Here Aliette tastes the happiest days since her +marriage. Bernard, of course, after a little time is greatly bored. +But so far they have never seriously doubted of their great love for +each other. It is here that M. Feuillet brings on the scene a kind +of character new in his books; perhaps hardly worthy of the other +company there; a sort of female Monsieur de Camors, but without his +grace and tenderness, and who actually commits a crime. How would +the morbid charms of M. de Camors have vanished, if, as his wife once +suspected of him, he had ever contemplated crime! And surely, the +showy insolent charms of Sabine de Tallevaut, beautiful, +intellectually gifted, supremely Amazonian, yet withal not drawn with +M. Feuillet's usual fineness, scarcely hold out for the reader, any +more than for [233] Bernard himself, in the long run, against the +vulgarising touch of her cold wickedness. Living in the +neighbourhood of Valmoutiers, in a somewhat melancholy abode (the +mystery of which in the eyes of Bernard adds to her poetic charm) +with her guardian, an old, rich, freethinking doctor, devoted to +research, she comes to Valmoutiers one night in his company on the +occasion of the alarming illness of the only child. They arrive +escorted by Bernard himself. The little Jeanne, wrapped in her +coverlet, was placed upon the table of her play-room, which was +illuminated as if for a party. The illness, the operation (skilfully +performed by the old doctor) which restores her to life, are +described with that seemingly simple pathos in which M. Feuillet's +consummate art hides itself. Sabine remains to watch the child's +recovery, and becomes an intimate. In vain Bernard struggles against +the first real passion of his life;--does everything but send its +object out of his sight. Aliette has divined their secret. In the +fatal illness which follows soon after, Bernard watches over her with +tender solicitude; hoping against hope that the disease may take a +favourable turn. + +"My child," he said to her one day, taking the hand which +she abandoned to him, "I have just been scolding old Victoire. +She is losing her head. In spite of the repeated assurances +of the doctors, she is alarmed at seeing you a little worse +than usual to-day, and has had the Cure sent for. Do you +wish to see him?" + +"Pray let me see him!" + +[234] She sighed heavily, and fixed upon her husband her large +blue eyes, full of anguish--an anguish so sharp and so singular +that he felt frozen to the marrow. + +He could not help saying with deep emotion, "Do you love me no +longer, Aliette?" + +"For ever!" murmured the poor child. + +He leaned over her with a long kiss upon the forehead. She saw +tears stealing from the eyes of her husband, and seemed as if +surprised. + +Soon afterwards Aliette is dead, to the profound sorrow of Bernard. +Less than two years later he has become the husband of Mademoiselle +Tallevaut. It was about two years after his marriage with Sabine +that Bernard resumed the journal with which we began. In the pages +which he now adds he seems at first unchanged. How then as to that +story of M. de Rance, the reformer of La Trappe, finding the head of +his dead mistress; an incident which the reader of La Morte will +surely have taken as a "presentiment"? Aliette had so taken it. "A +head so charming as yours," Bernard had assured her tenderly, "does +not need to be dead that it may work miracles!"--How, in the few +pages that remain, will M. Feuillet justify that, and certain other +delicate touches of presentiment, and at the same time justify the +title of his book? + +The journal is recommenced in February. On the twentieth of April +Bernard writes, at Valmoutiers: + +Under pretext of certain urgently needed repairs I am come to +pass a week at Valmoutiers, and get a little pure air. By my +orders they have kept Aliette's room under lock and key since +[235] the day when she left it in her coffin. To-day I re- +entered it for the first time. There was a vague odour of her +favourite perfumes. My poor Aliette! why was I unable, as you +so ardently desired, to share your gentle creed, and associate +myself to the life of your dreams, the life of honesty and peace? +Compared with that which is mine to-day, it seems to me like +paradise. What a terrible scene it was, here in this room! What +a memory! I can still see the last look she fixed on me, a look +almost of terror! and how quickly she died! I have taken the room +for my own. But I shall not remain here long. I intend to go +for a few days to Varaville. I want to see my little girl: her +dear angel's face. + +VALMOUTIERS, April 22.--What a change there has been in the world +since my childhood: since my youth even! what a surprising change +in so short a period, in the moral atmosphere we are breathing! +Then we were, as it were, impregnated with the thought of God--a +just God, but benevolent and fatherlike. We really lived under +His eyes, as under the eyes of a parent, with respect and fear, +but with confidence. We felt sustained by His invisible but +undoubted presence. We spoke to Him, and it seemed that He +answered. And now we feel ourselves alone--as it were abandoned +in the immensity of the universe. We live in a world, hard, +savage, full of hatred; whose one cruel law is the struggle for +existence, and in which we are no more than those natural elements, +let loose to war with each other in fierce selfishness, without +pity, with no appeal beyond, no hope of final justice. And above +us, in place of the good God of our happy youth, nothing, any +more! or worse than nothing--a deity, barbarous and ironical, +who cares nothing at all about us. + +The aged mother of Aliette, hitherto the guardian of his daughter, +is lately dead. Bernard proposes to take the child away with +him to Paris. The child's old nurse objects. On April the twenty- +seventh, Bernard writes: + +For a moment--for a few moments--in that room where I have been +shutting myself up with the shadow of my poor [236] dead one, a +horrible thought had come to me. I had driven it away as an +insane fancy. But now, yes! it is becoming a reality. Shall I +write this? Yes! I will write it. It is my duty to do so; for +from this moment the journal, begun in so much gaiety of heart, +is but my last will and testament. If I should disappear from +the world, the secret must not die with me. It must be bequeathed +to the natural protectors of my child. Her interests, if not her +life, are concerned therein. + +Here, then, is what passed: I had not arrived in time to render +my last duty to Madame de Courteheuse. The family was already +dispersed. I found here only Aliette's brother. To him I +communicated my plan concerning the child, and he could but +approve. My intention was to bring away with Jeanne her nurse +Victoire, who had brought her up, as she brought up her mother. +But she is old, and in feeble health, and I feared some +difficulties on her part; the more as her attitude towards myself +since the death of my first wife has been marked by an ill grace +approaching to hostility. I took her aside while Jeanne was +playing in the garden. + +"My good Victoire," I said, "while Madame de Courteheuse was +living, I considered it a duty to leave her granddaughter in +her keeping. Besides, no one was better fitted to watch over +her education. At present my duty is to watch over it myself. +I propose therefore to take Jeanne with me to Paris; and I hope +that you may be willing to accompany her, and remain in her +service." When she understood my intention, the old woman, in +whose hands I had noticed a faint trembling, became suddenly +very pale. She fixed her firm, grey eyes upon me: "Monsieur +le Comte will not do that!" + +"Pardon me, my good Victoire, that I shall do. I appreciate +your good qualities of fidelity and devotion. I shall be very +grateful if you will continue to take care of my daughter, as +you have done so excellently. But for the rest, I intend to +be the only master in my own house, and the only master of my +child." She laid a hand upon my arm: "I implore you, Monsieur, +don't do this!" Her fixed look did not leave my face, and +seemed to be questioning me to the very bottom of my soul. +"I have never believed it," she murmured, "No! I [237] never +could believe it. But if you take the child away I shall." + +"Believe what, wretched woman? believe what?" + +Her voice sank lower still. "Believe that you knew how her +mother came by her death; and that you mean the daughter to +die as she did." + +"Die as her mother did?" + +"Yes! by the same hand!" + +The sweat came on my forehead. I felt as it were a breathing of +death upon me. But still I thrust away from me that terrible +light on things. + +"Victoire!" I said, "take care! You are no fool: you are +something worse. Your hatred of the woman who has taken the +place of my first wife--your blind hatred--has suggested to +you odious, nay! criminal words." + +"Ah! Ah! Monsieur", she cried with wild energy. "After +what I have just told you, take your daughter to live with +that woman if you dare." + +I walked up and down the room awhile to collect my senses. +Then, returning to the old woman, "Yet how can I believe you?" +I asked. "If you had had the shadow of a proof of what you +give me to understand, how could you have kept silence so long? +How could you have allowed me to contract that hateful marriage?" + +She seemed more confident, and her voice grew gentler. "Monsieur, +it is because Madame, before she went to God, made me take oath +on the crucifix to keep that secret for ever." + +"Yet not with me, in fact,--not with me!" And I, in turn, +questioned her; my eyes upon hers. She hesitated: then +stammered out, "True! not with you! because she believed, poor +little soul! that..." + +"What did she believe? That I knew it? That I was an accomplice? +Tell me!" Her eyes fell, and she made no answer. "Is it +possible, my God, is it possible? But come, sit by me here, and +tell me all you know, all you saw. At what time was it you +noticed anything--the precise moment?" For in truth she had +been suffering for a long time past. + +Victoire tells the miserable story of Sabine's [238] crime--we must +pardon what we think a not quite worthy addition to the imaginary +world M. Feuillet has called up round about him, for the sake of +fully knowing Bernard and Aliette. The old nurse had surprised her +in the very act, and did not credit her explanation. "When I +surprised her," she goes on: + +"It may already have been too late--be sure it was not the first +time she had been guilty--my first thought was to give you +information. But I had not the courage. Then I told Madame. +I thought I saw plainly that I had nothing to tell she was not +already aware of. Nevertheless she chided me almost harshly. +'You know very well,' she said, 'that my husband is always there +when Mademoiselle prepares the medicines. So that he too would +be guilty. Rather than believe that, I would accept death at +his hands a hundred times over!' And I remember, Monsieur, how +at the very moment when she told me that, you came out from +the little boudoir, and brought her a glass of valerian. She +cast on me a terrible look and drank. A few minutes afterwards +she was so ill that she thought the end was come. She begged +me to give her her crucifix, and made me swear never to utter +a word concerning our suspicions. It was then I sent for the +priest. I have told you, Monsieur, what I know; what I have +seen with my own eyes. I swear that I have said nothing but +what is absolutely true." She paused. I could not answer her. +I seized her old wrinkled and trembling hands and pressed them +to my forehead, and wept like a child. + +May 10.--She died believing me guilty! The thought is terrible +to me. I know not what to do. A creature so frail, so +delicate, so sweet. "Yes!" she said to herself, "my husband +is a murderer; what he is giving me is poison, and he knows +it." She died with that thought in her mind--her last thought. +And she will never, never know that it was not so; that I am +innocent; that the thought is torment to me: that I am the most +unhappy of men. Ah! God, all-powerful! if you indeed exist, +you see what I suffer. Have pity on me! + +Ah! how I wish I could believe that all is not over between +[239] her and me; that she sees and hears me; that she knew +the truth. But I find it impossible! impossible! + +June.--That I was a criminal was her last thought, and she +will never be undeceived. + +All seems so completely ended when one dies. All returns to +its first elements. How credit that miracle of a personal +resurrection? and yet in truth all is mystery,--miracle, +around us, about us, within ourselves. The entire universe +is but a continuous miracle. Man's new birth from the womb +of death--is it a mystery less comprehensible than his birth +from the womb of his mother? + +Those lines are the last written by Bernard de Vaudricourt. +His health, for some time past disturbed by grief, was +powerless against the emotions of the last terrible trial +imposed on him. A malady, the exact nature of which was +not determined, in a few days assumed a mortal character. +Perceiving that his end was come, he caused Monseigneur +de Courteheuse to be summoned--he desired to die in the +religion of Aliette. Living, the poor child had been +defeated: she prevailed in her death. + +Two distinguished souls! deux etres d'elite--M. Feuillet thinks-- +whose fine qualities properly brought them together. When +Mademoiselle de Courteheuse said of the heroes of her favourite age, +that their passions, their errors, did but pass over a ground of what +was solid and serious, and which always discovered itself afresh, she +was unconsciously describing Bernard. Singular young brother of +Monsieur de Camors--after all, certainly, more fortunate than he--he +belongs to the age, which, if it had great faults, had also great +repentances. In appearance, frivolous; with all the light charm of +the world, yet with that impressibility to great things, according to +the law which makes the best of M. Feuillet's [240] characters so +interesting; above all, with that capacity for pity which almost +everything around him tended to suppress; in real life, if he exists +there, and certainly in M. Feuillet's pages, it is a refreshment to +meet him. + +1886. + + + +POSTSCRIPT + +ainei de palaion men oinon, anthea d' hymnon neoteron+ + +[241] THE words, classical and romantic, although, like many other +critical expressions, sometimes abused by those who have understood +them too vaguely or too absolutely, yet define two real tendencies +in the history of art and literature. Used in an exaggerated sense, +to express a greater opposition between those tendencies than really +exists, they have at times tended to divide people of taste into +opposite camps. But in that House Beautiful, which the creative +minds of all generations--the artists and those who have treated +life in the spirit of art--are always building together, for the +refreshment of the human spirit, these oppositions cease; and the +Interpreter of the House Beautiful, the true aesthetic critic, uses +these divisions, only so far as they enable him to enter into the +peculiarities of the objects with which he has to do. The term +classical, fixed, as it is, to a well-defined literature, and a well- +defined group in art, is clear, indeed; but then it has often been +used in a hard, and merely scholastic [242] sense, by the praisers of +what is old and accustomed, at the expense of what is new, by critics +who would never have discovered for themselves the charm of any work, +whether new or old, who value what is old, in art or literature, for +its accessories, and chiefly for the conventional authority that has +gathered about it--people who would never really have been made glad +by any Venus fresh-risen from the sea, and who praise the Venus of +old Greece and Rome, only because they fancy her grown now into +something staid and tame. + +And as the term, classical, has been used in a too absolute, and +therefore in a misleading sense, so the term, romantic, has been used +much too vaguely, in various accidental senses. The sense in which +Scott is called a romantic writer is chiefly this; that, in +opposition to the literary tradition of the last century, he loved +strange adventure, and sought it in the Middle Age. Much later, in a +Yorkshire village, the spirit of romanticism bore a more really +characteristic fruit in the work of a young girl, Emily Bronte, the +romance of Wuthering Heights; the figures of Hareton Earnshaw, of +Catherine Linton, and of Heathcliffe--tearing open Catherine's grave, +removing one side of her coffin, that he may really lie beside her in +death--figures so passionate, yet woven on a background of delicately +beautiful, moorland scenery, being typical examples of that spirit. +In Germany, again, [243] that spirit is shown less in Tieck, its +professional representative, than in Meinhold, the author of Sidonia +the Sorceress and the Amber-Witch. In Germany and France, within the +last hundred years, the term has been used to describe a particular +school of writers; and, consequently, when Heine criticises the +Romantic School in Germany--that movement which culminated in +Goethe's Goetz von Berlichingen; or when Theophile Gautier criticises +the romantic movement in France, where, indeed, it bore its most +characteristic fruits, and its play is hardly yet over where, by a +certain audacity, or bizarrerie of motive, united with faultless +literary execution, it still shows itself in imaginative literature, +they use the word, with an exact sense of special artistic qualities, +indeed; but use it, nevertheless, with a limited application to the +manifestation of those qualities at a particular period. But the +romantic spirit is, in reality, an ever-present, an enduring +principle, in the artistic temperament; and the qualities of thought +and style which that, and other similar uses of the word romantic +really indicate, are indeed but symptoms of a very continuous and +widely working influence. + +Though the words classical and romantic, then, have acquired an +almost technical meaning, in application to certain developments of +German and French taste, yet this is but one variation of an old +opposition, which may be traced from the [244] very beginning of the +formation of European art and literature. From the first formation +of anything like a standard of taste in these things, the restless +curiosity of their more eager lovers necessarily made itself felt, in +the craving for new motives, new subjects of interest, new +modifications of style. Hence, the opposition between the +classicists and the romanticists--between the adherents, in the +culture of beauty, of the principles of liberty, and authority, +respectively--of strength, and order or what the Greeks called +kosmiotes.+ + +Sainte-Beuve, in the third volume of the Causeries du Lundi, has +discussed the question, What is meant by a classic? It was a +question he was well fitted to answer, having himself lived through +many phases of taste, and having been in earlier life an enthusiastic +member of the romantic school: he was also a great master of that +sort of "philosophy of literature," which delights in tracing +traditions in it, and the way in which various phases of thought and +sentiment maintain themselves, through successive modifications, from +epoch to epoch. His aim, then, is to give the word classic a wider +and, as he says, a more generous sense than it commonly bears, to +make it expressly grandiose et flottant; and, in doing this, he +develops, in a masterly manner, those qualities of measure, purity, +temperance, of which it is the especial function of classical art +[245] and literature, whatever meaning, narrower or wider, we attach +to the term, to take care. + +The charm, therefore, of what is classical, in art or literature, is +that of the well-known tale, to which we can, nevertheless, listen +over and over again, because it is told so well. To the absolute +beauty of its artistic form, is added the accidental, tranquil, charm +of familiarity. There are times, indeed, at which these charms fail +to work on our spirits at all, because they fail to excite us. +"Romanticism," says Stendhal, "is the art of presenting to people the +literary works which, in the actual state of their habits and +beliefs, are capable of giving them the greatest possible pleasure; +classicism, on the contrary, of presenting them with that which gave +the greatest possible pleasure to their grandfathers." But then, +beneath all changes of habits and beliefs, our love of that mere +abstract proportion--of music--which what is classical in literature +possesses, still maintains itself in the best of us, and what pleased +our grandparents may at least tranquillise us. The "classic" comes +to us out of the cool and quiet of other times; as the measure of +what a long experience has shown will at least never displease us. +And in the classical literature of Greece and Rome, as in the +classics of the last century, the essentially classical element is +that quality of order in beauty, which they possess, indeed, [246] in +a pre-eminent degree, and which impresses some minds to the exclusion +of everything else in them. + +It is the addition of strangeness to beauty, that constitutes the +romantic character in art; and the desire of beauty being a fixed +element in every artistic organisation, it is the addition of +curiosity to this desire of beauty, that constitutes the romantic +temper. Curiosity and the desire of beauty, have each their place in +art, as in all true criticism. When one's curiosity is deficient, +when one is not eager enough for new impressions, and new pleasures, +one is liable to value mere academical proprieties too highly, to be +satisfied with worn-out or conventional types, with the insipid +ornament of Racine, or the prettiness of that later Greek sculpture, +which passed so long for true Hellenic work; to miss those places +where the handiwork of nature, or of the artist, has been most +cunning; to find the most stimulating products of art a mere +irritation. And when one's curiosity is in excess, when it +overbalances the desire of beauty, then one is liable to value in +works of art what is inartistic in them; to be satisfied with what is +exaggerated in art, with productions like some of those of the +romantic school in Germany; not to distinguish, jealously enough, +between what is admirably done, and what is done not quite so well, +in the writings, for instance, of Jean Paul. And if I had to give +[247] instances of these defects, then I should say, that Pope, in +common with the age of literature to which he belonged, had too +little curiosity, so that there is always a certain insipidity in the +effect of his work, exquisite as it is; and, coming down to our own +time, that Balzac had an excess of curiosity--curiosity not duly +tempered with the desire of beauty. + +But, however falsely those two tendencies may be opposed by critics, +or exaggerated by artists themselves, they are tendencies really at +work at all times in art, moulding it, with the balance sometimes a +little on one side, sometimes a little on the other, generating, +respectively, as the balance inclines on this side or that, two +principles, two traditions, in art, and in literature so far as it +partakes of the spirit of art. If there is a great overbalance of +curiosity, then, we have the grotesque in art: if the union of +strangeness and beauty, under very difficult and complex conditions, +be a successful one, if the union be entire, then the resultant +beauty is very exquisite, very attractive. With a passionate care +for beauty, the romantic spirit refuses to have it, unless the +condition of strangeness be first fulfilled. Its desire is for a +beauty born of unlikely elements, by a profound alchemy, by a +difficult initiation, by the charm which wrings it even out of +terrible things; and a trace of distortion, of the grotesque, may +perhaps linger, as an additional element of expression, about its +[248] ultimate grace. Its eager, excited spirit will have strength, +the grotesque, first of all--the trees shrieking as you tear off the +leaves; for Jean Valjean, the long years of convict life; for +Redgauntlet, the quicksands of Solway Moss; then, incorporate with +this strangeness, and intensified by restraint, as much sweetness, as +much beauty, as is compatible with that. Energique, frais, et +dispos--these, according to Sainte-Beuve, are the characteristics of +a genuine classic--les ouvrages anciens ne sont pas classiques parce +qu'ils sont vieux, mais parce qu'ils sont energiques, frais, et +dispos. Energy, freshness, intelligent and masterly disposition:-- +these are characteristics of Victor Hugo when his alchemy is +complete, in certain figures, like Marius and Cosette, in certain +scenes, like that in the opening of Les Travailleurs de la Mer, where +Deruchette writes the name of Gilliatt in the snow, on Christmas +morning; but always there is a certain note of strangeness +discernible there, as well. + +The essential elements, then, of the romantic spirit are curiosity +and the love of beauty; and it is only as an illustration of these +qualities, that it seeks the Middle Age, because, in the over-charged +atmosphere of the Middle Age, there are unworked sources of romantic +effect, of a strange beauty, to be won, by strong imagination, out of +things unlikely or remote. + +Few, probably, now read Madame de Stael's [249] De l'Allemagne, +though it has its interest, the interest which never quite fades out +of work really touched with the enthusiasm of the spiritual +adventurer, the pioneer in culture. It was published in 1810, to +introduce to French readers a new school of writers--the romantic +school, from beyond the Rhine; and it was followed, twenty-three +years later, by Heine's Romantische Schule, as at once a supplement +and a correction. Both these books, then, connect romanticism with +Germany, with the names especially of Goethe and Tieck; and, to many +English readers, the idea of romanticism is still inseparably +connected with Germany--that Germany which, in its quaint old towns, +under the spire of Strasburg or the towers of Heidelberg, was always +listening in rapt inaction to the melodious, fascinating voices of +the Middle Age, and which, now that it has got Strasburg back again, +has, I suppose, almost ceased to exist. But neither Germany, with +its Goethe and Tieck, nor England, with its Byron and Scott, is +nearly so representative of the romantic temper as France, with +Murger, and Gautier, and Victor Hugo. It is in French literature +that its most characteristic expression is to be found; and that, as +most closely derivative, historically, from such peculiar conditions, +as ever reinforce it to the utmost. + +For, although temperament has much to do with the generation of the +romantic spirit, and [250] although this spirit, with its curiosity, +its thirst for a curious beauty, may be always traceable in excellent +art (traceable even in Sophocles) yet still, in a limited sense, it +may be said to be a product of special epochs. Outbreaks of this +spirit, that is, come naturally with particular periods--times, when, +in men's approaches towards art and poetry, curiosity may be noticed +to take the lead, when men come to art and poetry, with a deep thirst +for intellectual excitement, after a long ennui, or in reaction +against the strain of outward, practical things: in the later Middle +Age, for instance; so that medieval poetry, centering in Dante, is +often opposed to Greek and Roman poetry, as romantic poetry to the +classical. What the romanticism of Dante is, may be estimated, if we +compare the lines in which Virgil describes the hazel-wood, from +whose broken twigs flows the blood of Polydorus, not without the +expression of a real shudder at the ghastly incident, with the whole +canto of the Inferno, into which Dante has expanded them, beautifying +and softening it, meanwhile, by a sentiment of profound pity. And it +is especially in that period of intellectual disturbance, immediately +preceding Dante, amid which the romance languages define themselves +at last, that this temper is manifested. Here, in the literature of +Provence, the very name of romanticism is stamped with its true +signification: here we have indeed a romantic world, grotesque [251] +even, in the strength of its passions, almost insane in its curious +expression of them, drawing all things into its sphere, making the +birds, nay! lifeless things, its voices and messengers, yet so +penetrated with the desire for beauty and sweetness, that it begets a +wholly new species of poetry, in which the Renaissance may be said to +begin. The last century was pre-eminently a classical age, an age in +which, for art and literature, the element of a comely order was in +the ascendant; which, passing away, left a hard battle to be fought +between the classical and the romantic schools. Yet, it is in the +heart of this century, of Goldsmith and Stothard, of Watteau and the +Siecle de Louis XIV.--in one of its central, if not most +characteristic figures, in Rousseau--that the modern or French +romanticism really originates. But, what in the eighteenth century +is but an exceptional phenomenon, breaking through its fair reserve +and discretion only at rare intervals, is the habitual guise of the +nineteenth, breaking through it perpetually, with a feverishness, an +incomprehensible straining and excitement, which all experience to +some degree, but yearning also, in the genuine children of the +romantic school, to be energique, frais, et dispos--for those +qualities of energy, freshness, comely order; and often, in Murger, +in Gautier, in Victor Hugo, for instance, with singular felicity +attaining them. + +It is in the terrible tragedy of Rousseau, in [252] fact, that French +romanticism, with much else, begins: reading his Confessions we seem +actually to assist at the birth of this new, strong spirit in the +French mind. The wildness which has shocked so many, and the +fascination which has influenced almost every one, in the squalid, +yet eloquent figure, we see and hear so clearly in that book, +wandering under the apple-blossoms and among the vines of Neuchatel +or Vevey actually give it the quality of a very successful romantic +invention. His strangeness or distortion, his profound subjectivity, +his passionateness--the cor laceratum--Rousseau makes all men in love +with these. Je ne suis fait comme aucun de ceux que j'ai sus. Mais +si je ne vaux pas mieux, au moins je suis autre. "I am not made like +any one else I have ever known: yet, if I am not better, at least I +am different." These words, from the first page of the Confessions, +anticipate all the Werthers, Renes, Obermanns, of the last hundred +years. For Rousseau did but anticipate a trouble in the spirit of +the whole world; and thirty years afterwards, what in him was a +peculiarity, became part of the general consciousness. A storm was +coming: Rousseau, with others, felt it in the air, and they helped to +bring it down: they introduced a disturbing element into French +literature, then so trim and formal, like our own literature of the +age of Queen Anne. + +In 1815 the storm had come and gone, but had left, in the spirit of +"young France," the [253] ennui of an immense disillusion. In the +last chapter of Edgar Quinet's Revolution Francaise, a work itself +full of irony, of disillusion, he distinguishes two books, +Senancour's Obermann and Chateaubriand's Genie du Christianisme, as +characteristic of the first decade of the present century. In those +two books we detect already the disease and the cure--in Obermann the +irony, refined into a plaintive philosophy of "indifference"--in +Chateaubriand's Genie du Christianisme, the refuge from a tarnished +actual present, a present of disillusion, into a world of strength +and beauty in the Middle Age, as at an earlier period--in Rene and +Atala--into the free play of them in savage life. It is to minds in +this spiritual situation, weary of the present, but yearning for the +spectacle of beauty and strength, that the works of French +romanticism appeal. They set a positive value on the intense, the +exceptional; and a certain distortion is sometimes noticeable in +them, as in conceptions like Victor Hugo's Quasimodo, or Gwynplaine, +something of a terrible grotesque, of the macabre, as the French +themselves call it; though always combined with perfect literary +execution, as in Gautier's La Morte Amoureuse, or the scene of the +"maimed" burial-rites of the player, dead of the frost, in his +Capitaine Fracasse--true "flowers of the yew." It becomes grim +humour in Victor Hugo's combat of Gilliatt with the devil-fish, or +the incident, with all its ghastly comedy drawn [254] out at length, +of the great gun detached from its fastenings on shipboard, in +Quatre-Vingt-Trieze (perhaps the most terrible of all the accidents +that can happen by sea) and in the entire episode, in that book, of +the Convention. Not less surely does it reach a genuine pathos; for +the habit of noting and distinguishing one's own most intimate +passages of sentiment makes one sympathetic, begetting, as it must, +the power of entering, by all sorts of finer ways, into the intimate +recesses of other minds; so that pity is another quality of +romanticism, both Victor Hugo and Gautier being great lovers of +animals, and charming writers about them, and Murger being unrivalled +in the pathos of his Scenes de la Vie de Jeunesse. Penetrating so +finely into all situations which appeal to pity, above all, into the +special or exceptional phases of such feeling, the romantic humour is +not afraid of the quaintness or singularity of its circumstances or +expression, pity, indeed, being of the essence of humour; so that +Victor Hugo does but turn his romanticism into practice, in his +hunger and thirst after practical Justice!--a justice which shall no +longer wrong children, or animals, for instance, by ignoring in a +stupid, mere breadth of view, minute facts about them. Yet the +romanticists are antinomian, too, sometimes, because the love of +energy and beauty, of distinction in passion, tended naturally to +become a little bizarre, plunging into the [255] Middle Age, into the +secrets of old Italian story. Are we in the Inferno?--we are tempted +to ask, wondering at something malign in so much beauty. For over +all a care for the refreshment of the human spirit by fine art +manifests itself, a predominant sense of literary charm, so that, in +their search for the secret of exquisite expression, the romantic +school went back to the forgotten world of early French poetry, and +literature itself became the most delicate of the arts--like +"goldsmith's work," says Sainte-Beuve, of Bertrand's Gaspard de la +Nuit--and that peculiarly French gift, the gift of exquisite speech, +argute loqui, attained in them a perfection which it had never seen +before. + +Stendhal, a writer whom I have already quoted, and of whom English +readers might well know much more than they do, stands between the +earlier and later growths of the romantic spirit. His novels are +rich in romantic quality; and his other writings--partly criticism, +partly personal reminiscences--are a very curious and interesting +illustration of the needs out of which romanticism arose. In his +book on Racine and Shakespeare, Stendhal argues that all good art was +romantic in its day; and this is perhaps true in Stendhal's sense. +That little treatise, full of "dry light" and fertile ideas, was +published in the year 1823, and its object is to defend an entire +independence and liberty in the choice and treatment of subject, both +in [256] art and literature, against those who upheld the exclusive +authority of precedent. In pleading the cause of romanticism, +therefore, it is the novelty, both of form and of motive, in writings +like the Hernani of Victor Hugo (which soon followed it, raising a +storm of criticism) that he is chiefly concerned to justify. To be +interesting and really stimulating, to keep us from yawning even, art +and literature must follow the subtle movements of that nimbly- +shifting Time-Spirit, or Zeit-Geist, understood by French not less +than by German criticism, which is always modifying men's taste, as +it modifies their manners and their pleasures. This, he contends, is +what all great workmen had always understood. Dante, Shakespeare, +Moliere, had exercised an absolute independence in their choice of +subject and treatment. To turn always with that ever-changing +spirit, yet to retain the flavour of what was admirably done in past +generations, in the classics, as we say--is the problem of true +romanticism. "Dante," he observes, "was pre-eminently the romantic +poet. He adored Virgil, yet he wrote the Divine Comedy, with the +episode of Ugolino, which is as unlike the Aeneid as can possibly be. +And those who thus obey the fundamental principle of romanticism, one +by one become classical, and are joined to that ever-increasing +common league, formed by men of all countries, to approach nearer and +nearer to perfection." + +Romanticism, then, although it has its epochs, [257] is in its +essential characteristics rather a spirit which shows itself at all +times, in various degrees, in individual workmen and their work, and +the amount of which criticism has to estimate in them taken one by +one, than the peculiarity of a time or a school. Depending on the +varying proportion of curiosity and the desire of beauty, natural +tendencies of the artistic spirit at all times, it must always be +partly a matter of individual temperament. The eighteenth century in +England has been regarded as almost exclusively a classical period; +yet William Blake, a type of so much which breaks through what are +conventionally thought the influences of that century, is still a +noticeable phenomenon in it, and the reaction in favour of naturalism +in poetry begins in that century, early. There are, thus, the born +romanticists and the born classicists. There are the born +classicists who start with form, to whose minds the comeliness of the +old, immemorial, well-recognised types in art and literature, have +revealed themselves impressively; who will entertain no matter which +will not go easily and flexibly into them; whose work aspires only to +be a variation upon, or study from, the older masters. "'Tis art's +decline, my son!" they are always saying, to the progressive element +in their own generation; to those who care for that which in fifty +years' time every one will be caring for. On the other hand, there +are the born romanticists, who start with an original, [258] untried +matter, still in fusion; who conceive this vividly, and hold by it as +the essence of their work; who, by the very vividness and heat of +their conception, purge away, sooner or later, all that is not +organically appropriate to it, till the whole effect adjusts itself +in clear, orderly, proportionate form; which form, after a very +little time, becomes classical in its turn. + +The romantic or classical character of a picture, a poem, a literary +work, depends, then, on the balance of certain qualities in it; and +in this sense, a very real distinction may be drawn between good +classical and good romantic work. But all critical terms are +relative; and there is at least a valuable suggestion in that theory +of Stendhal's, that all good art was romantic in its day. In the +beauties of Homer and Pheidias, quiet as they now seem, there must +have been, for those who confronted them for the first time, +excitement and surprise, the sudden, unforeseen satisfaction of the +desire of beauty. Yet the Odyssey, with its marvellous adventure, is +more romantic than the Iliad, which nevertheless contains, among many +other romantic episodes, that of the immortal horses of Achilles, who +weep at the death of Patroclus. Aeschylus is more romantic than +Sophocles, whose Philoctetes, were it written now, might figure, for +the strangeness of its motive and the perfectness of its execution, +as typically romantic; while, of Euripides, it may be said, that his +method in [259] writing his plays is to sacrifice readily almost +everything else, so that he may attain the fulness of a single +romantic effect. These two tendencies, indeed, might be applied as a +measure or standard, all through Greek and Roman art and poetry, with +very illuminating results; and for an analyst of the romantic +principle in art, no exercise would be more profitable, than to walk +through the collection of classical antiquities at the Louvre, or the +British Museum, or to examine some representative collection of Greek +coins, and note how the element of curiosity, of the love of +strangeness, insinuates itself into classical design, and record the +effects of the romantic spirit there, the traces of struggle, of the +grotesque even, though over-balanced here by sweetness; as in the +sculpture of Chartres and Rheims, the real sweetness of mind in the +sculptor is often overbalanced by the grotesque, by the rudeness of +his strength. + +Classicism, then, means for Stendhal, for that younger enthusiastic +band of French writers whose unconscious method he formulated into +principles, the reign of what is pedantic, conventional, and narrowly +academical in art; for him, all good art is romantic. To Sainte- +Beuve, who understands the term in a more liberal sense, it is the +characteristic of certain epochs, of certain spirits in every epoch, +not given to the exercise of original imagination, but rather to the +working out of refinements of manner on some [260] authorised matter; +and who bring to their perfection, in this way, the elements of +sanity, of order and beauty in manner. In general criticism, again, +it means the spirit of Greece and Rome, of some phases in literature +and art that may seem of equal authority with Greece and Rome, the +age of Louis the Fourteenth, the age of Johnson; though this is at +best an uncritical use of the term, because in Greek and Roman work +there are typical examples of the romantic spirit. But explain the +terms as we may, in application to particular epochs, there are these +two elements always recognisable; united in perfect art--in +Sophocles, in Dante, in the highest work of Goethe, though not always +absolutely balanced there; and these two elements may be not +inappropriately termed the classical and romantic tendencies. + +Material for the artist, motives of inspiration, are not yet +exhausted: our curious, complex, aspiring age still abounds in +subjects for aesthetic manipulation by the literary as well as by +other forms of art. For the literary art, at all events, the problem +just now is, to induce order upon the contorted, proportionless +accumulation of our knowledge and experience, our science and +history, our hopes and disillusion, and, in effecting this, to do +consciously what has been done hitherto for the most part too +unconsciously, to write our English language as the Latins wrote +theirs, as the [261] French write, as scholars should write. +Appealing, as he may, to precedent in this matter, the scholar will +still remember that if "the style is the man" it is also the age: +that the nineteenth century too will be found to have had its style, +justified by necessity--a style very different, alike from the +baldness of an impossible "Queen Anne" revival, and an incorrect, +incondite exuberance, after the mode of Elizabeth: that we can only +return to either at the price of an impoverishment of form or matter, +or both, although, an intellectually rich age such as ours being +necessarily an eclectic one, we may well cultivate some of the +excellences of literary types so different as those: that in +literature as in other matters it is well to unite as many diverse +elements as may be: that the individual writer or artist, certainly, +is to be estimated by the number of graces he combines, and his power +of interpenetrating them in a given work. To discriminate schools, +of art, of literature, is, of course, part of the obvious business of +literary criticism: but, in the work of literary production, it is +easy to be overmuch occupied concerning them. For, in truth, the +legitimate contention is, not of one age or school of literary art +against another, but of all successive schools alike, against the +stupidity which is dead to the substance, and the vulgarity which is +dead to form. + + +NOTES + + +241. +Transliteration: ainei de palaion men oinon, anthea d' hymnon +neoteron. Translation: "Praise wine for its age, but the song in first +bloom. Pindar, Odes, Book O, Poem 9, Line 47. + +244. +Transliteration: kosmiotes. Liddell and Scott definition: +"propriety, decorum, orderly behavior." + + +End of The Project Gutenberg Etext of Appreciations, With An Essay on Style +by Walter Horatio Pater + diff --git a/old/7awae10.zip b/old/7awae10.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..7648686 --- /dev/null +++ b/old/7awae10.zip diff --git a/old/8awae10.txt b/old/8awae10.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c61927f --- /dev/null +++ b/old/8awae10.txt @@ -0,0 +1,6922 @@ +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Appreciations, With An Essay on Style +by Walter Horatio Pater +(#5 in our series by Walter Horatio Pater) + +Copyright laws are changing all over the world, be sure to check +the laws for your country before redistributing these files!!! + +Please take a look at the important information in this header. +We encourage you to keep this file on your own disk, keeping an +electronic path open for the next readers. + +Please do not remove this. + +This should be the first thing seen when anyone opens the book. +Do not change or edit it without written permission. The words +are carefully chosen to provide users with the information they +need about what they can legally do with the texts. + + +**Welcome To The World of Free Plain Vanilla Electronic Texts** + +**Etexts Readable By Both Humans and By Computers, Since 1971** + +*****These Etexts Are Prepared By Thousands of Volunteers!***** + +Information on contacting Project Gutenberg to get Etexts, and +further information is included below, including for donations. + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a 501(c)(3) +organization with EIN [Employee Identification Number] 64-6221541 + +Title: Appreciations, With An Essay on Style + +Author: Walter Horatio Pater + +Release Date: May, 2003 [Etext #4037] +[Yes, we are about one year ahead of schedule] +[The actual date this file first posted = 10/19/01] + +Edition: 10 + +Language: English + +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Appreciations, With An Essay on Style +by Walter Horatio Pater +******This file should be named 8awae10.txt or 8awae10.zip****** + +Corrected EDITIONS of our etexts get a new NUMBER, 8awae11.txt +VERSIONS based on separate sources get new LETTER, 8awae10a.txt + +Produced by Alfred J. Drake, Ph.D. + +Project Gutenberg Etexts are usually created from multiple editions, +all of which are in the Public Domain in the United States, unless a +copyright notice is included. Therefore, we usually do NOT keep any +of these books in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +We are now trying to release all our books one year in advance +of the official release dates, leaving time for better editing. +Please be encouraged to send us error messages even years after +the official publication date. + +Please note neither this listing nor its contents are final til +midnight of the last day of the month of any such announcement. +The official release date of all Project Gutenberg Etexts is at +Midnight, Central Time, of the last day of the stated month. A +preliminary version may often be posted for suggestion, comment +and editing by those who wish to do so. + +Most people start at our sites at: +http://gutenberg.net +http://promo.net/pg + + +Those of you who want to download any Etext before announcement +can surf to them as follows, and just download by date; this is +also a good way to get them instantly upon announcement, as the +indexes our cataloguers produce obviously take a while after an +announcement goes out in the Project Gutenberg Newsletter. + +http://www.ibiblio.org/gutenberg/etext03 +or +ftp://ftp.ibiblio.org/pub/docs/books/gutenberg/etext03 + +Or /etext02, 01, 00, 99, 98, 97, 96, 95, 94, 93, 92, 92, 91 or 90 + +Just search by the first five letters of the filename you want, +as it appears in our Newsletters. + + +Information about Project Gutenberg (one page) + +We produce about two million dollars for each hour we work. The +time it takes us, a rather conservative estimate, is fifty hours +to get any etext selected, entered, proofread, edited, copyright +searched and analyzed, the copyright letters written, etc. This +projected audience is one hundred million readers. If our value +per text is nominally estimated at one dollar then we produce $2 +million dollars per hour this year as we release fifty new Etext +files per month, or 500 more Etexts in 2000 for a total of 3000+ +If they reach just 1-2% of the world's population then the total +should reach over 300 billion Etexts given away by year's end. + +The Goal of Project Gutenberg is to Give Away One Trillion Etext +Files by December 31, 2001. [10,000 x 100,000,000 = 1 Trillion] +This is ten thousand titles each to one hundred million readers, +which is only about 4% of the present number of computer users. + +At our revised rates of production, we will reach only one-third +of that goal by the end of 2001, or about 4,000 Etexts unless we +manage to get some real funding. + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation has been created +to secure a future for Project Gutenberg into the next millennium. + +We need your donations more than ever! + +As of July 12, 2001 contributions are only being solicited from people in: +Arkansas, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, +Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Louisiana, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, +Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, New Mexico, Nevada, New Jersey, New York, North +Carolina, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, +Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, +Wisconsin, and Wyoming. + +We have filed in about 45 states now, but these are the only ones +that have responded. + +As the requirements for other states are met, +additions to this list will be made and fund raising +will begin in the additional states. Please feel +free to ask to check the status of your state. + +In answer to various questions we have received on this: + +We are constantly working on finishing the paperwork +to legally request donations in all 50 states. If +your state is not listed and you would like to know +if we have added it since the list you have, just ask. + +While we cannot solicit donations from people in +states where we are not yet registered, we know +of no prohibition against accepting donations +from donors in these states who approach us with +an offer to donate. + + +International donations are accepted, +but we don't know ANYTHING about how +to make them tax-deductible, or +even if they CAN be made deductible, +and don't have the staff to handle it +even if there are ways. + +All donations should be made to: + +Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +PMB 113 +1739 University Ave. +Oxford, MS 38655-4109 + + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a 501(c)(3) +organization with EIN [Employee Identification Number] 64-6221541, +and has been approved as a 501(c)(3) organization by the US Internal +Revenue Service (IRS). Donations are tax-deductible to the maximum +extent permitted by law. As the requirements for other states are met, +additions to this list will be made and fund raising will begin in the +additional states. + +We need your donations more than ever! + +You can get up to date donation information at: + +http://www.gutenberg.net/donation.html + + +*** + +If you can't reach Project Gutenberg, +you can always email directly to: + +Michael S. Hart <hart@pobox.com> + +hart@pobox.com forwards to hart@prairienet.org and archive.org +if your mail bounces from archive.org, I will still see it, if +it bounces from prairienet.org, better resend later on. . . . + +Prof. Hart will answer or forward your message. + +We would prefer to send you information by email. + + +*** + + +Example command-line FTP session: + +ftp ftp.ibiblio.org +login: anonymous +password: your@login +cd pub/docs/books/gutenberg +cd etext90 through etext99 or etext00 through etext02, etc. +dir [to see files] +get or mget [to get files. . .set bin for zip files] +GET GUTINDEX.?? [to get a year's listing of books, e.g., GUTINDEX.99] +GET GUTINDEX.ALL [to get a listing of ALL books] + + +**The Legal Small Print** + + +(Three Pages) + +***START**THE SMALL PRINT!**FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN ETEXTS**START*** +Why is this "Small Print!" statement here? You know: lawyers. +They tell us you might sue us if there is something wrong with +your copy of this etext, even if you got it for free from +someone other than us, and even if what's wrong is not our +fault. So, among other things, this "Small Print!" statement +disclaims most of our liability to you. It also tells you how +you may distribute copies of this etext if you want to. + +*BEFORE!* YOU USE OR READ THIS ETEXT +By using or reading any part of this PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm +etext, you indicate that you understand, agree to and accept +this "Small Print!" statement. If you do not, you can receive +a refund of the money (if any) you paid for this etext by +sending a request within 30 days of receiving it to the person +you got it from. If you received this etext on a physical +medium (such as a disk), you must return it with your request. + +ABOUT PROJECT GUTENBERG-TM ETEXTS +This PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm etext, like most PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm etexts, +is a "public domain" work distributed by Professor Michael S. Hart +through the Project Gutenberg Association (the "Project"). +Among other things, this means that no one owns a United States copyright +on or for this work, so the Project (and you!) can copy and +distribute it in the United States without permission and +without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, set forth +below, apply if you wish to copy and distribute this etext +under the "PROJECT GUTENBERG" trademark. + +Please do not use the "PROJECT GUTENBERG" trademark to market +any commercial products without permission. + +To create these etexts, the Project expends considerable +efforts to identify, transcribe and proofread public domain +works. Despite these efforts, the Project's etexts and any +medium they may be on may contain "Defects". Among other +things, Defects may take the form of incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other +intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged +disk or other etext medium, a computer virus, or computer +codes that damage or cannot be read by your equipment. + +LIMITED WARRANTY; DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES +But for the "Right of Replacement or Refund" described below, +[1] Michael Hart and the Foundation (and any other party you may +receive this etext from as a PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm etext) disclaims +all liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including +legal fees, and [2] YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE OR +UNDER STRICT LIABILITY, OR FOR BREACH OF WARRANTY OR CONTRACT, +INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE +OR INCIDENTAL DAMAGES, EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE +POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES. + +If you discover a Defect in this etext within 90 days of +receiving it, you can receive a refund of the money (if any) +you paid for it by sending an explanatory note within that +time to the person you received it from. If you received it +on a physical medium, you must return it with your note, and +such person may choose to alternatively give you a replacement +copy. If you received it electronically, such person may +choose to alternatively give you a second opportunity to +receive it electronically. + +THIS ETEXT IS OTHERWISE PROVIDED TO YOU "AS-IS". NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, ARE MADE TO YOU AS +TO THE ETEXT OR ANY MEDIUM IT MAY BE ON, INCLUDING BUT NOT +LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A +PARTICULAR PURPOSE. + +Some states do not allow disclaimers of implied warranties or +the exclusion or limitation of consequential damages, so the +above disclaimers and exclusions may not apply to you, and you +may have other legal rights. + +INDEMNITY +You will indemnify and hold Michael Hart, the Foundation, +and its trustees and agents, and any volunteers associated +with the production and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm +texts harmless, from all liability, cost and expense, including +legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of the +following that you do or cause: [1] distribution of this etext, +[2] alteration, modification, or addition to the etext, +or [3] any Defect. + +DISTRIBUTION UNDER "PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm" +You may distribute copies of this etext electronically, or by +disk, book or any other medium if you either delete this +"Small Print!" and all other references to Project Gutenberg, +or: + +[1] Only give exact copies of it. Among other things, this + requires that you do not remove, alter or modify the + etext or this "small print!" statement. You may however, + if you wish, distribute this etext in machine readable + binary, compressed, mark-up, or proprietary form, + including any form resulting from conversion by word + processing or hypertext software, but only so long as + *EITHER*: + + [*] The etext, when displayed, is clearly readable, and + does *not* contain characters other than those + intended by the author of the work, although tilde + (~), asterisk (*) and underline (_) characters may + be used to convey punctuation intended by the + author, and additional characters may be used to + indicate hypertext links; OR + + [*] The etext may be readily converted by the reader at + no expense into plain ASCII, EBCDIC or equivalent + form by the program that displays the etext (as is + the case, for instance, with most word processors); + OR + + [*] You provide, or agree to also provide on request at + no additional cost, fee or expense, a copy of the + etext in its original plain ASCII form (or in EBCDIC + or other equivalent proprietary form). + +[2] Honor the etext refund and replacement provisions of this + "Small Print!" statement. + +[3] Pay a trademark license fee to the Foundation of 20% of the + gross profits you derive calculated using the method you + already use to calculate your applicable taxes. If you + don't derive profits, no royalty is due. Royalties are + payable to "Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation" + the 60 days following each date you prepare (or were + legally required to prepare) your annual (or equivalent + periodic) tax return. Please contact us beforehand to + let us know your plans and to work out the details. + +WHAT IF YOU *WANT* TO SEND MONEY EVEN IF YOU DON'T HAVE TO? +Project Gutenberg is dedicated to increasing the number of +public domain and licensed works that can be freely distributed +in machine readable form. + +The Project gratefully accepts contributions of money, time, +public domain materials, or royalty free copyright licenses. +Money should be paid to the: +"Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +If you are interested in contributing scanning equipment or +software or other items, please contact Michael Hart at: +hart@pobox.com + +[Portions of this header are copyright (C) 2001 by Michael S. Hart +and may be reprinted only when these Etexts are free of all fees.] +[Project Gutenberg is a TradeMark and may not be used in any sales +of Project Gutenberg Etexts or other materials be they hardware or +software or any other related product without express permission.] + +*END THE SMALL PRINT! FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN ETEXTS*Ver.07/27/01*END* + + + + + + + + + + + +Produced by Alfred J. Drake, Ph.D. + + + + + +APPRECIATIONS, WITH AN ESSAY ON STYLE + +By WALTER HORATIO PATER + +E-text Editor: Alfred J. Drake, Ph.D. +Electronic Version 1.0 / Date 10-12-01 + + +DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES + +[1] I DISCLAIM ALL LIABILITY TO YOU FOR DAMAGES, COSTS AND EXPENSES, +INCLUDING LEGAL FEES, AND + +[2] YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE OR UNDER STRICT LIABILITY, OR +FOR BREACH OF WARRANTY OR CONTRACT, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR INCIDENTAL DAMAGES, EVEN IF YOU +GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES. + +THE E-TEXTS ON THIS SITE ARE PROVIDED TO YOU "AS-IS". NO WARRANTIES +OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, ARE MADE TO YOU AS TO THE E-TEXTS OR +ANY MEDIUM THEY MAY BE ON, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF +MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE. + +Some states do not allow disclaimers of implied warranties or the +exclusion or limitation of consequential damages, so the above +disclaimers and exclusions may not apply to you, and you may have +other legal rights. + + + +APPRECIATIONS, WITH AN ESSAY ON STYLE + + +NOTES BY THE E-TEXT EDITOR: + +Reliability: Although I have done my best to ensure that the text +you read is error-free in comparison with an exact reprint of the +standard edition--Macmillan's 1910 Library Edition--please exercise +scholarly caution in using it. It is not intended as a substitute +for the printed original but rather as a searchable supplement. +My e-texts may prove convenient substitutes for hard-to-get works in +a course where both instructor and students accept the possibility +of some imperfections in the text, but if you are writing a scholarly +article, dissertation, or book, you should use the standard hard- +copy editions of any works you cite. + +Pagination and Paragraphing: To avoid an unwieldy electronic copy, +I have transferred original pagination to brackets. A bracketed +numeral such as [22] indicates that the material immediately +following the number marks the beginning of the relevant page. I +have preserved paragraph structure except for first-line indentation. + +Hyphenation: I have not preserved original hyphenation since an +e-text does not require line-end or page-end hyphenation. + +Greek typeface: For this full-text edition, I have transliterated +Pater's Greek quotations. If there is a need for the original Greek, +it can be viewed at my site, http://www.ajdrake.com/etexts, a +Victorianist archive that contains the complete works of Walter Pater +and many other nineteenth-century texts, mostly in first editions. + + +CONTENTS + +Style: 5-38 + +Wordsworth: 39-64 + +Coleridge: 65-104 + +Charles Lamb: 105-123 + +Sir Thomas Browne: 124-160 + +"Love's Labours Lost": 161-169 + +"Measure for Measure": 170-184 + +Shakespeare's English Kings: 185-204 + +Dante Gabriel Rossetti: 205-218 + +Feuillet's "La Morte": 219-240 + +Postscript: 241-261 + + + +APPRECIATIONS + + +STYLE + +[5] SINCE all progress of mind consists for the most part in +differentiation, in the resolution of an obscure and complex object +into its component aspects, it is surely the stupidest of losses to +confuse things which right reason has put asunder, to lose the sense +of achieved distinctions, the distinction between poetry and prose, +for instance, or, to speak more exactly, between the laws and +characteristic excellences of verse and prose composition. On the +other hand, those who have dwelt most emphatically on the distinction +between prose and verse, prose and poetry, may sometimes have been +tempted to limit the proper functions of prose too narrowly; and this +again is at least false economy, as being, in effect, the +renunciation of a certain means or faculty, in a world where after +all we must needs make the most of things. Critical efforts to limit +art a priori, by anticipations regarding the natural incapacity of +the material with which this or that artist works, as the sculptor +with solid form, or the prose-writer with the ordinary [6] language +of men, are always liable to be discredited by the facts of artistic +production; and while prose is actually found to be a coloured thing +with Bacon, picturesque with Livy and Carlyle, musical with Cicero +and Newman, mystical and intimate with Plato and Michelet and Sir +Thomas Browne, exalted or florid, it may be, with Milton and Taylor, +it will be useless to protest that it can be nothing at all, except +something very tamely and narrowly confined to mainly practical ends- +-a kind of "good round-hand;" as useless as the protest that poetry +might not touch prosaic subjects as with Wordsworth, or an abstruse +matter as with Browning, or treat contemporary life nobly as with +Tennyson. In subordination to one essential beauty in all good +literary style, in all literature as a fine art, as there are many +beauties of poetry so the beauties of prose are many, and it is the +business of criticism to estimate them as such; as it is good in the +criticism of verse to look for those hard, logical, and quasi-prosaic +excellences which that too has, or needs. To find in the poem, amid +the flowers, the allusions, the mixed perspectives, of Lycidas for +instance, the thought, the logical structure:--how wholesome! how +delightful! as to identify in prose what we call the poetry, the +imaginative power, not treating it as out of place and a kind of +vagrant intruder, but by way of an estimate of its rights, that is, +of its achieved powers, there. + +[7] Dryden, with the characteristic instinct of his age, loved to +emphasise the distinction between poetry and prose, the protest +against their confusion with each other, coming with somewhat +diminished effect from one whose poetry was so prosaic. In truth, +his sense of prosaic excellence affected his verse rather than his +prose, which is not only fervid, richly figured, poetic, as we say, +but vitiated, all unconsciously, by many a scanning line. Setting up +correctness, that humble merit of prose, as the central literary +excellence, he is really a less correct writer than he may seem, +still with an imperfect mastery of the relative pronoun. It might +have been foreseen that, in the rotations of mind, the province of +poetry in prose would find its assertor; and, a century after Dryden, +amid very different intellectual needs, and with the need therefore +of great modifications in literary form, the range of the poetic +force in literature was effectively enlarged by Wordsworth. The true +distinction between prose and poetry he regarded as the almost +technical or accidental one of the absence or presence of metrical +beauty, or, say! metrical restraint; and for him the opposition came +to be between verse and prose of course; but, as the essential +dichotomy in this matter, between imaginative and unimaginative +writing, parallel to De Quincey's distinction between "the literature +of power and the literature of knowledge," in the former of which the +composer gives us [8] not fact, but his peculiar sense of fact, +whether past or present. + +Dismissing then, under sanction of Wordsworth, that harsher +opposition of poetry to prose, as savouring in fact of the arbitrary +psychology of the last century, and with it the prejudice that there +can be but one only beauty of prose style, I propose here to point +out certain qualities of all literature as a fine art, which, if they +apply to the literature of fact, apply still more to the literature +of the imaginative sense of fact, while they apply indifferently to +verse and prose, so far as either is really imaginative--certain +conditions of true art in both alike, which conditions may also +contain in them the secret of the proper discrimination and +guardianship of the peculiar excellences of either. + +The line between fact and something quite different from external +fact is, indeed, hard to draw. In Pascal, for instance, in the +persuasive writers generally, how difficult to define the point +where, from time to time, argument which, if it is to be worth +anything at all, must consist of facts or groups of facts, becomes a +pleading--a theorem no longer, but essentially an appeal to the +reader to catch the writer's spirit, to think with him, if one can or +will--an expression no longer of fact but of his sense of it, his +peculiar intuition of a world, prospective, or discerned below the +faulty conditions of the present, in either case changed somewhat +from the actual [9] world. In science, on the other hand, in history +so far as it conforms to scientific rule, we have a literary domain +where the imagination may be thought to be always an intruder. And +as, in all science, the functions of literature reduce themselves +eventually to the transcribing of fact, so all the excellences of +literary form in regard to science are reducible to various kinds of +pains-taking; this good quality being involved in all "skilled work" +whatever, in the drafting of an act of parliament, as in sewing. Yet +here again, the writer's sense of fact, in history especially, and in +all those complex subjects which do but lie on the borders of +science, will still take the place of fact, in various degrees. Your +historian, for instance, with absolutely truthful intention, amid the +multitude of facts presented to him must needs select, and in +selecting assert something of his own humour, something that comes +not of the world without but of a vision within. So Gibbon moulds +his unwieldy material to a preconceived view. Livy, Tacitus, +Michelet, moving full of poignant sensibility amid the records of the +past, each, after his own sense, modifies--who can tell where and to +what degree?--and becomes something else than a transcriber; each, as +he thus modifies, passing into the domain of art proper. For just in +proportion as the writer's aim, consciously or unconsciously, comes +to be the transcribing, not of the world, not of mere fact, but of +his sense [10] of it, he becomes an artist, his work fine art; and +good art (as I hope ultimately to show) in proportion to the truth of +his presentment of that sense; as in those humbler or plainer +functions of literature also, truth--truth to bare fact, there--is +the essence of such artistic quality as they may have. Truth! there +can be no merit, no craft at all, without that. And further, all +beauty is in the long run only fineness of truth, or what we call +expression, the finer accommodation of speech to that vision within. + +--The transcript of his sense of fact rather than the fact, as being +preferable, pleasanter, more beautiful to the writer himself. In +literature, as in every other product of human skill, in the moulding +of a bell or a platter for instance, wherever this sense asserts +itself, wherever the producer so modifies his work as, over and above +its primary use or intention, to make it pleasing (to himself, of +course, in the first instance) there, "fine" as opposed to merely +serviceable art, exists. Literary art, that is, like all art which +is in any way imitative or reproductive of fact--form, or colour, or +incident--is the representation of such fact as connected with soul, +of a specific personality, in its preferences, its volition and +power. + +Such is the matter of imaginative or artistic literature--this +transcript, not of mere fact, but of fact in its infinite variety, as +modified by human preference in all its infinitely varied [11] forms. +It will be good literary art not because it is brilliant or sober, or +rich, or impulsive, or severe, but just in proportion as its +representation of that sense, that soul-fact, is true, verse being +only one department of such literature, and imaginative prose, it may +be thought, being the special art of the modern world. That +imaginative prose should be the special and opportune art of the +modern world results from two important facts about the latter: +first, the chaotic variety and complexity of its interests, making +the intellectual issue, the really master currents of the present +time incalculable--a condition of mind little susceptible of the +restraint proper to verse form, so that the most characteristic verse +of the nineteenth century has been lawless verse; and secondly, an +all-pervading naturalism, a curiosity about everything whatever as it +really is, involving a certain humility of attitude, cognate to what +must, after all, be the less ambitious form of literature. And prose +thus asserting itself as the special and privileged artistic faculty +of the present day, will be, however critics may try to narrow its +scope, as varied in its excellence as humanity itself reflecting on +the facts of its latest experience--an instrument of many stops, +meditative, observant, descriptive, eloquent, analytic, plaintive, +fervid. Its beauties will be not exclusively "pedestrian": it will +exert, in due measure, all the varied charms of poetry, down to the +rhythm which, as in Cicero, [12] or Michelet, or Newman, at their +best, gives its musical value to every syllable.* + +The literary artist is of necessity a scholar, and in what he . +proposes to do will have in mind, first of all, the scholar and the +scholarly conscience--the male conscience in this matter, as we must +think it, under a system of education which still to so large an +extent limits real scholarship to men. In his self-criticism, he +supposes always that sort of reader who will go (full of eyes) +warily, considerately, though without consideration for him, over the +ground which the female conscience traverses so lightly, so amiably. +For the material in which he works is no more a creation of his own +than the sculptor's marble. Product of a myriad various minds and +contending tongues, compact of obscure and minute association, a +language has its own abundant and often recondite laws, in the +habitual and summary recognition of which scholarship consists. A +writer, full of a matter he is before all things anxious to express, +may think of those laws, the limitations of vocabulary, structure, +and the like, as a restriction, but if a [13] real artist will find +in them an opportunity. His punctilious observance of the proprieties +of his medium will diffuse through all he writes a general air of +sensibility, of refined usage. Exclusiones debitae--the exclusions, +or rejections, which nature demands--we know how large a part these +play, according to Bacon, in the science of nature. In a somewhat +changed sense, we might say that the art of the scholar is summed up +in the observance of those rejections demanded by the nature of his +medium, the material he must use. Alive to the value of an +atmosphere in which every term finds its utmost degree of expression, +and with all the jealousy of a lover of words, he will resist a +constant tendency on the part of the majority of those who use them +to efface the distinctions of language, the facility of writers often +reinforcing in this respect the work of the vulgar. He will feel the +obligation not of the laws only, but of those affinities, avoidances, +those mere preferences, of his language, which through the +associations of literary history have become a part of its nature, +prescribing the rejection of many a neology, many a license, many a +gipsy phrase which might present itself as actually expressive. His +appeal, again, is to the scholar, who has great experience in +literature, and will show no favour to short-cuts, or hackneyed +illustration, or an affectation of learning designed for the +unlearned. Hence a contention, a sense [14] of self-restraint and +renunciation, having for the susceptible reader the effect of a +challenge for minute consideration; the attention of the writer, in +every minutest detail, being a pledge that it is worth the reader's +while to be attentive too, that the writer is dealing scrupulously +with his instrument, and therefore, indirectly, with the reader +himself also, that he has the science of the instrument he plays on, +perhaps, after all, with a freedom which in such case will be the +freedom of a master. + +For meanwhile, braced only by those restraints, he is really +vindicating his liberty in the making of a vocabulary, an entire +system of composition, for himself, his own true manner; and when we +speak of the manner of a true master we mean what is essential in his +art. Pedantry being only the scholarship of le cuistre (we have no +English equivalent) he is no pedant, and does but show his +intelligence of the rules of language in his freedoms with it, +addition or expansion, which like the spontaneities of manner in a +well-bred person will still further illustrate good taste.--The right +vocabulary! Translators have not invariably seen how all-important +that is in the work of translation, driving for the most part at +idiom or construction; whereas, if the original be first-rate, one's +first care should be with its elementary particles, Plato, for +instance, being often reproducible by an exact following, with no +variation in structure, of word after word, as [15] the pencil +follows a drawing under tracing-paper, so only each word or syllable +be not of false colour, to change my illustration a little. + +Well! that is because any writer worth translating at all has +winnowed and searched through his vocabulary, is conscious of the +words he would select in systematic reading of a dictionary, and +still more of the words he would reject were the dictionary other +than Johnson's; and doing this with his peculiar sense of the world +ever in view, in search of an instrument for the adequate expression +of that, he begets a vocabulary faithful to the colouring of his own +spirit, and in the strictest sense original. That living authority +which language needs lies, in truth, in its scholars, who recognising +always that every language possesses a genius, a very fastidious +genius, of its own, expand at once and purify its very elements, +which must needs change along with the changing thoughts of living +people. Ninety years ago, for instance, great mental force, +certainly, was needed by Wordsworth, to break through the consecrated +poetic associations of a century, and speak the language that was +his, that was to become in a measure the language of the next +generation. But he did it with the tact of a scholar also. English, +for a quarter of a century past, has been assimilating the +phraseology of pictorial art; for half a century, the phraseology of +the great German metaphysical movement of eighty years ago; in part +also the [16] language of mystical theology: and none but pedants +will regret a great consequent increase of its resources. For many +years to come its enterprise may well lie in the naturalisation of +the vocabulary of science, so only it be under the eye of a sensitive +scholarship--in a liberal naturalisation of the ideas of science too, +for after all the chief stimulus of good style is to possess a full, +rich, complex matter to grapple with. The literary artist, +therefore, will be well aware of physical science; science also +attaining, in its turn, its true literary ideal. And then, as the +scholar is nothing without the historic sense, he will be apt to +restore not really obsolete or really worn-out words, but the finer +edge of words still in use: ascertain, communicate, discover--words +like these it has been part of our "business" to misuse. And still, +as language was made for man, he will be no authority for +correctnesses which, limiting freedom of utterance, were yet but +accidents in their origin; as if one vowed not to say "its," which +ought to have been in Shakespeare; "his" "hers," for inanimate +objects, being but a barbarous and really inexpressive survival. Yet +we have known many things like this. Racy Saxon monosyllables, close +to us as touch and sight, he will intermix readily with those long, +savoursome, Latin words, rich in "second intention." In this late +day certainly, no critical process can be conducted reasonably +without eclecticism. Of [17] such eclecticism we have a justifying +example in one of the first poets of our time. How illustrative of +monosyllabic effect, of sonorous Latin, of the phraseology of +science, of metaphysic, of colloquialism even, are the writings of +Tennyson; yet with what a fine, fastidious scholarship throughout! + +A scholar writing for the scholarly, he will of course leave +something to the willing intelligence of his reader. "To go preach +to the first passer-by," says Montaigne, "to become tutor to the +ignorance of the first I meet, is a thing I abhor;" a thing, in fact, +naturally distressing to the scholar, who will therefore ever be shy +of offering uncomplimentary assistance to the reader's wit. To +really strenuous minds there is a pleasurable stimulus in the +challenge for a continuous effort on their part, to be rewarded by +securer and more intimate grasp of the author's sense. Self- +restraint, a skilful economy of means, ascêsis, that too has a beauty +of its own; and for the reader supposed there will be an aesthetic +satisfaction in that frugal closeness of style which makes the most +of a word, in the exaction from every sentence of a precise relief, +in the just spacing out of word to thought, in the logically filled +space connected always with the delightful sense of difficulty +overcome. + +Different classes of persons, at different times, make, of course, +very various demands upon literature. Still, scholars, I suppose, +and not [18] only scholars, but all disinterested lovers of books, +will always look to it, as to all other fine art, for a refuge, a +sort of cloistral refuge, from a certain vulgarity in the actual +world. A perfect poem like Lycidas, a perfect fiction like Esmond, +the perfect handling of a theory like Newman's Idea of a University, +has for them something of the uses of a religious "retreat." Here, +then, with a view to the central need of a select few, those "men of +a finer thread" who have formed and maintain the literary ideal, +everything, every component element, will have undergone exact trial, +and, above all, there will be no uncharacteristic or tarnished or +vulgar decoration, permissible ornament being for the most part +structural, or necessary. As the painter in his picture, so the +artist in his book, aims at the production by honourable artifice of +a peculiar atmosphere. "The artist," says Schiller, "may be known +rather by what he omits"; and in literature, too, the true artist may +be best recognised by his tact of omission. For to the grave reader +words too are grave; and the ornamental word, the figure, the +accessory form or colour or reference, is rarely content to die to +thought precisely at the right moment, but will inevitably linger +awhile, stirring a long "brain-wave" behind it of perhaps quite alien +associations. + +Just there, it may be, is the detrimental tendency of the sort of +scholarly attentiveness [19] of mind I am recommending. But the true +artist allows for it. He will remember that, as the very word +ornament indicates what is in itself non-essential, so the "one +beauty" of all literary style is of its very essence, and +independent, in prose and verse alike, of all removable decoration; +that it may exist in its fullest lustre, as in Flaubert's Madame +Bovary, for instance, or in Stendhal's Le Rouge et Le Noir, in a +composition utterly unadorned, with hardly a single suggestion of +visibly beautiful things. Parallel, allusion, the allusive way +generally, the flowers in the garden:--he knows the narcotic force of +these upon the negligent intelligence to which any diversion, +literally, is welcome, any vagrant intruder, because one can go +wandering away with it from the immediate subject. Jealous, if he +have a really quickening motive within, of all that does not hold +directly to that, of the facile, the otiose, he will never depart +from the strictly pedestrian process, unless he gains a ponderable +something thereby. Even assured of its congruity, he will still +question its serviceableness. Is it worth while, can we afford, to +attend to just that, to just that figure or literary reference, just +then?--Surplusage! he will dread that, as the runner on his muscles. +For in truth all art does but consist in the removal of surplusage, +from the last finish of the gem-engraver blowing away the last +particle of invisible dust, back to the earliest divination of [20] +the finished work to be, lying somewhere, according to Michelangelo's +fancy, in the rough-hewn block of stone. + +And what applies to figure or flower must be understood of all other +accidental or removable ornaments of writing whatever; and not of +specific ornament only, but of all that latent colour and imagery +which language as such carries in it. A lover of words for their own +sake, to whom nothing about them is unimportant, a minute and +constant observer of their physiognomy, he will be on the alert not +only for obviously mixed metaphors of course, but for the metaphor +that is mixed in all our speech, though a rapid use may involve no +cognition of it. Currently recognising the incident, the colour, the +physical elements or particles in words like absorb, consider, +extract, to take the first that occur, he will avail himself of them, +as further adding to the resources of expression. The elementary +particles of language will be realised as colour and light and shade +through his scholarly living in the full sense of them. Still +opposing the constant degradation of language by those who use it +carelessly, he will not treat coloured glass as if it were clear; and +while half the world is using figure unconsciously, will be fully +aware not only of all that latent figurative texture in speech, but +of the vague, lazy, half-formed personification--a rhetoric, +depressing, and worse than nothing, [21] because it has no really +rhetorical motive--which plays so large a part there, and, as in the +case of more ostentatious ornament, scrupulously exact of it, from +syllable to syllable, its precise value. + +So far I have been speaking of certain conditions of the literary art +arising out of the medium or material in or upon which it works, the +essential qualities of language and its aptitudes for contingent +ornamentation, matters which define scholarship as science and good +taste respectively. They are both subservient to a more intimate +quality of good style: more intimate, as coming nearer to the artist +himself. The otiose, the facile, surplusage: why are these abhorrent +to the true literary artist, except because, in literary as in all +other art, structure is all-important, felt, or painfully missed, +everywhere?--that architectural conception of work, which foresees +the end in the beginning and never loses sight of it, and in every +part is conscious of all the rest, till the last sentence does but, +with undiminished vigour, unfold and justify the first--a condition +of literary art, which, in contradistinction to another quality of +the artist himself, to be spoken of later, I shall call the necessity +of mind in style. + +An acute philosophical writer, the late Dean Mansel (a writer whose +works illustrate the literary beauty there may be in closeness, and +with obvious repression or economy of a fine [22] rhetorical gift) +wrote a book, of fascinating precision in a very obscure subject, to +show that all the technical laws of logic are but means of securing, +in each and all of its apprehensions, the unity, the strict identity +with itself, of the apprehending mind. All the laws of good writing +aim at a similar unity or identity of the mind in all the processes +by which the word is associated to its import. The term is right, +and has its essential beauty, when it becomes, in a manner, what it +signifies, as with the names of simple sensations. To give the +phrase, the sentence, the structural member, the entire composition, +song, or essay, a similar unity with its subject and with itself:-- +style is in the right way when it tends towards that. All depends +upon the original unity, the vital wholeness and identity, of the +initiatory apprehension or view. So much is true of all art, which +therefore requires always its logic, its comprehensive reason-- +insight, foresight, retrospect, in simultaneous action--true, most of +all, of the literary art, as being of all the arts most closely +cognate to the abstract intelligence. Such logical coherency may be +evidenced not merely in the lines of composition as a whole, but in +the choice of a single word, while it by no means interferes with, +but may even prescribe, much variety, in the building of the sentence +for instance, or in the manner, argumentative, descriptive, +discursive, of this or that [23] part or member of the entire design. +The blithe, crisp sentence, decisive as a child's expression of its +needs, may alternate with the long-contending, victoriously intricate +sentence; the sentence, born with the integrity of a single word, +relieving the sort of sentence in which, if you look closely, you can +see much contrivance, much adjustment, to bring a highly qualified +matter into compass at one view. For the literary architecture, if +it is to be rich and expressive, involves not only foresight of the +end in the beginning, but also development or growth of design, in +the process of execution, with many irregularities, surprises, and +afterthoughts; the contingent as well as the necessary being subsumed +under the unity of the whole. As truly, to the lack of such +architectural design, of a single, almost visual, image, vigorously +informing an entire, perhaps very intricate, composition, which shall +be austere, ornate, argumentative, fanciful, yet true from first to +last to that vision within, may be attributed those weaknesses of +conscious or unconscious repetition of word, phrase, motive, or +member of the whole matter, indicating, as Flaubert was aware, an +original structure in thought not organically complete. With such +foresight, the actual conclusion will most often get itself written +out of hand, before, in the more obvious sense, the work is finished. +With some strong and leading sense of the world, the [24] tight hold +of which secures true composition and not mere loose accretion, the +literary artist, I suppose, goes on considerately, setting joint to +joint, sustained by yet restraining the productive ardour, retracing +the negligences of his first sketch, repeating his steps only that he +may give the reader a sense of secure and restful progress, +readjusting mere assonances even, that they may soothe the reader, or +at least not interrupt him on his way; and then, somewhere before the +end comes, is burdened, inspired, with his conclusion, and betimes +delivered of it, leaving off, not in weariness and because he finds +himself at an end, but in all the freshness of volition. His work +now structurally complete, with all the accumulating effect of +secondary shades of meaning, he finishes the whole up to the just +proportion of that ante-penultimate conclusion, and all becomes +expressive. The house he has built is rather a body he has informed. +And so it happens, to its greater credit, that the better interest +even of a narrative to be recounted, a story to be told, will often +be in its second reading. And though there are instances of great +writers who have been no artists, an unconscious tact sometimes +directing work in which we may detect, very pleasurably, many of the +effects of conscious art, yet one of the greatest pleasures of really +good prose literature is in the critical tracing out of that +conscious artistic structure, and the pervading sense of it [25] as +we read. Yet of poetic literature too; for, in truth, the kind of +constructive intelligence here supposed is one of the forms of the +imagination. + +That is the special function of mind, in style. Mind and soul:--hard +to ascertain philosophically, the distinction is real enough +practically, for they often interfere, are sometimes in conflict, +with each other. Blake, in the last century, is an instance of +preponderating soul, embarrassed, at a loss, in an era of +preponderating mind. As a quality of style, at all events, soul is a +fact, in certain writers--the way they have of absorbing language, of +attracting it into the peculiar spirit they are of, with a subtlety +which makes the actual result seem like some inexplicable +inspiration. By mind, the literary artist reaches us, through static +and objective indications of design in his work, legible to all. By +soul, he reaches us, somewhat capriciously perhaps, one and not +another, through vagrant sympathy and a kind of immediate contact. +Mind we cannot choose but approve where we recognise it; soul may +repel us, not because we misunderstand it. The way in which +theological interests sometimes avail themselves of language is +perhaps the best illustration of the force I mean to indicate +generally in literature, by the word soul. Ardent religious +persuasion may exist, may make its way, without finding any +equivalent heat in language: or, again, it may enkindle [26] words to +various degrees, and when it really takes hold of them doubles its +force. Religious history presents many remarkable instances in +which, through no mere phrase-worship, an unconscious literary tact +has, for the sensitive, laid open a privileged pathway from one to +another. "The altar-fire," people say, "has touched those lips!" +The Vulgate, the English Bible, the English Prayer-Book, the writings +of Swedenborg, the Tracts for the Times:--there, we have instances of +widely different and largely diffused phases of religious feeling in +operation as soul in style. But something of the same kind acts with +similar power in certain writers of quite other than theological +literature, on behalf of some wholly personal and peculiar sense of +theirs. Most easily illustrated by theological literature, this +quality lends to profane writers a kind of religious influence. At +their best, these writers become, as we say sometimes, "prophets"; +such character depending on the effect not merely of their matter, +but of their matter as allied to, in "electric affinity" with, +peculiar form, and working in all cases by an immediate sympathetic +contact, on which account it is that it may be called soul, as +opposed to mind, in style. And this too is a faculty of choosing and +rejecting what is congruous or otherwise, with a drift towards unity- +-unity of atmosphere here, as there of design--soul securing colour +(or perfume, might [27] we say?) as mind secures form, the latter +being essentially finite, the former vague or infinite, as the +influence of a living person is practically infinite. There are some +to whom nothing has any real interest, or real meaning, except as +operative in a given person; and it is they who best appreciate the +quality of soul in literary art. They seem to know a person, in a +book, and make way by intuition: yet, although they thus enjoy the +completeness of a personal information, it is still a characteristic +of soul, in this sense of the word, that it does but suggest what can +never be uttered, not as being different from, or more obscure than, +what actually gets said, but as containing that plenary substance of +which there is only one phase or facet in what is there expressed. + +If all high things have their martyrs, Gustave Flaubert might perhaps +rank as the martyr of literary style. In his printed correspondence, +a curious series of letters, written in his twenty-fifth year, +records what seems to have been his one other passion--a series of +letters which, with its fine casuistries, its firmly repressed +anguish, its tone of harmonious grey, and the sense of disillusion in +which the whole matter ends, might have been, a few slight changes +supposed, one of his own fictions. Writing to Madame X. certainly he +does display, by "taking thought" mainly, by constant and delicate +pondering, as in his love for literature, a heart really moved, but +[28] still more, and as the pledge of that emotion, a loyalty to his +work. Madame X., too, is a literary artist, and the best gifts he +can send her are precepts of perfection in art, counsels for the +effectual pursuit of that better love. In his love-letters it is the +pains and pleasures of art he insists on, its solaces: he +communicates secrets, reproves, encourages, with a view to that. +Whether the lady was dissatisfied with such divided or indirect +service, the reader is not enabled to see; but sees that, on +Flaubert's part at least, a living person could be no rival of what +was, from first to last, his leading passion, a somewhat solitary and +exclusive one. + +I must scold you (he writes) for one thing, which shocks, +scandalises me, the small concern, namely, you show for art +just now. As regards glory be it so: there, I approve. But +for art!--the one thing in life that is good and real--can you +compare with it an earthly love?--prefer the adoration of a +relative beauty to the cultus of the true beauty? Well! I tell +you the truth. That is the one thing good in me: the one thing +I have, to me estimable. For yourself, you blend with the +beautiful a heap of alien things, the useful, the agreeable, +what not?-- + +The only way not to be unhappy is to shut yourself up in art, +and count everything else as nothing. Pride takes the place of +all beside when it is established on a large basis. Work! God +wills it. That, it seems to me, is clear.--+ + +I am reading over again the Aeneid, certain verses of which I +repeat to myself to satiety. There are phrases there which stay +in one's head, by which I find myself beset, as with those musical +airs which are for ever returning, and cause you pain, you love +them so much. I observe that I no longer laugh much, and am no +longer depressed. I am ripe. You talk of my serenity, and envy +me. It may well surprise you. Sick, [29] irritated, the prey +a thousand times a day of cruel pain, I continue my labour like +a true working-man, who, with sleeves turned up, in the sweat of +his brow, beats away at his anvil, never troubling himself whether +it rains or blows, for hail or thunder. I was not like that +formerly. The change has taken place naturally, though my will +has counted for something in the matter.-- + +Those who write in good style are sometimes accused of a neglect +of ideas, and of the moral end, as if the end of the physician +were something else than healing, of the painter than painting- +as if the end of art were not, before all else, the beautiful. + +What, then, did Flaubert understand by beauty, in the art he pursued +with so much fervour, with so much self-command? Let us hear a +sympathetic commentator :-- + +Possessed of an absolute belief that there exists but one way of +expressing one thing, one word to call it by, one adjective to +qualify, one verb to animate it, he gave himself to superhuman +labour for the discovery, in every phrase, of that word, that +verb, that epithet. In this way, he believed in some mysterious +harmony of expression, and when a true word seemed to him to +lack euphony still went on seeking another, with invincible +patience, certain that he had not yet got hold of the unique +word.... A thousand preoccupations would beset him at the +same moment, always with this desperate certitude fixed in his +spirit: Among all the expressions in the world, all forms and +turns of expression, there is but one--one form, one mode--to +express what I want to say. + +The one word for the one thing, the one thought, amid the multitude +of words, terms, that might just do: the problem of style was there!- +-the unique word, phrase, sentence, paragraph, essay, or song, +absolutely proper to the single mental presentation or vision within. + +[30] In that perfect justice, over and above the many contingent and +removable beauties with which beautiful style may charm us, but which +it can exist without, independent of them yet dexterously availing +itself of them, omnipresent in good work, in function at every point, +from single epithets to the rhythm of a whole book, lay the specific, +indispensable, very intellectual, beauty of literature, the +possibility of which constitutes it a fine art. + +One seems to detect the influence of a philosophic idea there, the +idea of a natural economy, of some pre-existent adaptation, between a +relative, somewhere in the world of thought, and its correlative, +somewhere in the world of language--both alike, rather, somewhere in +the mind of the artist, desiderative, expectant, inventive--meeting +each other with the readiness of "soul and body reunited," in Blake's +rapturous design; and, in fact, Flaubert was fond of giving his +theory philosophical expression.-- + +There are no beautiful thoughts (he would say) without beautiful +forms, and conversely. As it is impossible to extract from a +physical body the qualities which really constitute it--colour, +extension, and the like--without reducing it to a hollow +abstraction, in a word, without destroying it; just so it is +impossible to detach the form from the idea, for the idea only +exists by virtue of the form. + +All, the recognised flowers, the removable ornaments of literature +(including harmony and ease in reading aloud, very carefully +considered [31] by him) counted, certainly; for these too are part +of the actual value of what one says. But still, after all, with +Flaubert, the search, the unwearied research, was not for the smooth, +or winsome, or forcible word, as such, as with false Ciceronians, but +quite simply and honestly, for the word's adjustment to its meaning. +The first condition of this must be, of course, to know yourself, to +have ascertained your own sense exactly. Then, if we suppose an +artist, he says to the reader,--I want you to see precisely what I +see. Into the mind sensitive to "form," a flood of random sounds, +colours, incidents, is ever penetrating from the world without, to +become, by sympathetic selection, a part of its very structure, and, +in turn, the visible vesture and expression of that other world it +sees so steadily within, nay, already with a partial conformity +thereto, to be refined, enlarged, corrected, at a hundred points; and +it is just there, just at those doubtful points that the function of +style, as tact or taste, intervenes. The unique term will come more +quickly to one than another, at one time than another, according also +to the kind of matter in question. Quickness and slowness, ease and +closeness alike, have nothing to do with the artistic character of +the true word found at last. As there is a charm of ease, so there +is also a special charm in the signs of discovery, of effort and +contention towards a due end, as so often with Flaubert himself--in +the style which has [32] been pliant, as only obstinate, durable +metal can be, to the inherent perplexities and recusancy of a certain +difficult thought. + +If Flaubert had not told us, perhaps we should never have guessed how +tardy and painful his own procedure really was, and after reading his +confession may think that his almost endless hesitation had much to +do with diseased nerves. Often, perhaps, the felicity supposed will +be the product of a happier, a more exuberant nature than Flaubert's. +Aggravated, certainly, by a morbid physical condition, that anxiety +in "seeking the phrase," which gathered all the other small ennuis of +a really quiet existence into a kind of battle, was connected with +his lifelong contention against facile poetry, facile art--art, +facile and flimsy; and what constitutes the true artist is not the +slowness or quickness of the process, but the absolute success of the +result. As with those labourers in the parable, the prize is +independent of the mere length of the actual day's work. "You talk," +he writes, odd, trying lover, to Madame X.-- + +"You talk of the exclusiveness of my literary tastes. That +might have enabled you to divine what kind of a person I am in +the matter of love. I grow so hard to please as a literary +artist, that I am driven to despair. I shall end by not +writing another line." + +"Happy," he cries, in a moment of discouragement at that patient labour, +which for him, certainly, was the condition of a great success--[33] + +Happy those who have no doubts of themselves! who lengthen out, +as the pen runs on, all that flows forth from their brains. As +for me, I hesitate, I disappoint myself, turn round upon myself +in despite: my taste is augmented in proportion as my natural +vigour decreases, and I afflict my soul over some dubious word +out of all proportion to the pleasure I get from a whole page +of good writing. One would have to live two centuries to attain +a true idea of any matter whatever. What Buffon said is a big +blasphemy: genius is not long-continued patience. Still, there +is some truth in the statement, and more than people think, +especially as regards our own day. Art! art! art! bitter +deception! phantom that glows with light, only to lead one on +to destruction... + +Again-- + +I am growing so peevish about my writing. I am like a man whose +ear is true but who plays falsely on the violin: his fingers +refuse to reproduce precisely those sounds of which he has the +inward sense. Then the tears come rolling down from the poor +scraper's eyes and the bow falls from his hand. + +Coming slowly or quickly, when it comes, as it came with so much +labour of mind, but also with so much lustre, to Gustave Flaubert, +this discovery of the word will be, like all artistic success and +felicity, incapable of strict analysis: effect of an intuitive +condition of mind, it must be recognised by like intuition on the +part of the reader, and a sort of immediate sense. In every one of +those masterly sentences of Flaubert there was, below all mere +contrivance, shaping and afterthought, by some happy instantaneous +concourse of the various faculties of the mind with each other, the +exact apprehension of what was needed to carry the meaning. And that +it fits with absolute justice will be a judgment of [34] immediate +sense in the appreciative reader. We all feel this in what may be +called inspired translation. Well! all language involves translation +from inward to outward. In literature, as in all forms of art, there +are the absolute and the merely relative or accessory beauties; and +precisely in that exact proportion of the term to its purpose is the +absolute beauty of style, prose or verse. All the good qualities, +the beauties, of verse also, are such, only as precise expression. + +In the highest as in the lowliest literature, then, the one +indispensable beauty is, after all, truth:--truth to bare fact in the +latter, as to some personal sense of fact, diverted somewhat from +men's ordinary sense of it, in the former; truth there as accuracy, +truth here as expression, that finest and most intimate form of +truth, the vraie vérité. And what an eclectic principle this really +is! employing for its one sole purpose--that absolute accordance of +expression to idea--all other literary beauties and excellences +whatever: how many kinds of style it covers, explains, justifies, and +at the same time safeguards! Scott's facility, Flaubert's deeply +pondered evocation of "the phrase," are equally good art. Say what +you have to say, what you have a will to say, in the simplest, the +most direct and exact manner possible, with no surplusage:--there, is +the justification of the sentence so fortunately born, "entire, +smooth, and round," that it needs no punctuation, and also [35] (that +is the point!) of the most elaborate period, if it be right in its +elaboration. Here is the office of ornament: here also the purpose +of restraint in ornament. As the exponent of truth, that austerity +(the beauty, the function, of which in literature Flaubert understood +so well) becomes not the correctness or purism of the mere scholar, +but a security against the otiose, a jealous exclusion of what does +not really tell towards the pursuit of relief, of life and vigour in +the portraiture of one's sense. License again, the making free with +rule, if it be indeed, as people fancy, a habit of genius, flinging +aside or transforming all that opposes the liberty of beautiful +production, will be but faith to one's own meaning. The seeming +baldness of Le Rouge et Le Noir is nothing in itself; the wild +ornament of Les Misérables is nothing in itself; and the restraint of +Flaubert, amid a real natural opulence, only redoubled beauty--the +phrase so large and so precise at the same time, hard as bronze, in +service to the more perfect adaptation of words to their matter. +Afterthoughts, retouchings, finish, will be of profit only so far as +they too really serve to bring out the original, initiative, +generative, sense in them. + +In this way, according to the well-known saying, "The style is the +man," complex or simple, in his individuality, his plenary sense of +what he really has to say, his sense of the world; all cautions +regarding style arising out of so many [36] natural scruples as to +the medium through which alone he can expose that inward sense of +things, the purity of this medium, its laws or tricks of refraction: +nothing is to be left there which might give conveyance to any matter +save that. Style in all its varieties, reserved or opulent, terse, +abundant, musical, stimulant, academic, so long as each is really +characteristic or expressive, finds thus its justification, the +sumptuous good taste of Cicero being as truly the man himself, and +not another, justified, yet insured inalienably to him, thereby, as +would have been his portrait by Raffaelle, in full consular +splendour, on his ivory chair. + +A relegation, you may say perhaps--a relegation of style to the +subjectivity, the mere caprice, of the individual, which must soon +transform it into mannerism. Not so! since there is, under the +conditions supposed, for those elements of the man, for every +lineament of the vision within, the one word, the one acceptable +word, recognisable by the sensitive, by others "who have +intelligence" in the matter, as absolutely as ever anything can be in +the evanescent and delicate region of human language. The style, the +manner, would be the man, not in his unreasoned and really +uncharacteristic caprices, involuntary or affected, but in absolutely +sincere apprehension of what is most real to him. But let us hear +our French guide again.-- + +Styles (says Flaubert's commentator), Styles, as so many [37] +peculiar moulds, each of which bears the mark of a particular +writer, who is to pour into it the whole content of his ideas, +were no part of his theory. What he believed in was Style: +that is to say, a certain absolute and unique manner of +expressing a thing, in all its intensity and colour. For him +the form was the work itself. As in living creatures, the +blood, nourishing the body, determines its very contour and +external aspect, just so, to his mind, the matter, the basis, +in a work of art, imposed, necessarily, the unique, the just +expression, the measure, the rhythm--the form in all its +characteristics. + +If the style be the man, in all the colour and intensity of a +veritable apprehension, it will be in a real sense "impersonal." + +I said, thinking of books like Victor Hugo's Les Misérables, that +prose literature was the characteristic art of the nineteenth +century, as others, thinking of its triumphs since the youth of Bach, +have assigned that place to music. Music and prose literature are, +in one sense, the opposite terms of art; the art of literature +presenting to the imagination, through the intelligence, a range of +interests, as free and various as those which music presents to it +through sense. And certainly the tendency of what has been here said +is to bring literature too under those conditions, by conformity to +which music takes rank as the typically perfect art. If music be the +ideal of all art whatever, precisely because in music it is +impossible to distinguish the form from the substance or matter, the +subject from the expression, then, literature, by finding its +specific excellence in the absolute correspondence of the term to its +import, will be [38] but fulfilling the condition of all artistic +quality in things everywhere, of all good art. + +Good art, but not necessarily great art; the distinction between +great art and good art depending immediately, as regards literature +at all events, not on its form, but on the matter. Thackeray's +Esmond, surely, is greater art than Vanity Fair, by the greater +dignity of its interests. It is on the quality of the matter it +informs or controls, its compass, its variety, its alliance to great +ends, or the depth of the note of revolt, or the largeness of hope in +it, that the greatness of literary art depends, as The Divine Comedy, +Paradise Lost, Les Misérables, The English Bible, are great art. +Given the conditions I have tried to explain as constituting good +art;--then, if it be devoted further to the increase of men's +happiness, to the redemption of the oppressed, or the enlargement of +our sympathies with each other, or to such presentment of new or old +truth about ourselves and our relation to the world as may ennoble +and fortify us in our sojourn here, or immediately, as with Dante, to +the glory of God, it will be also great art; if, over and above those +qualities I summed up as mind and soul--that colour and mystic +perfume, and that reasonable structure, it has something of the soul +of humanity in it, and finds its logical, its architectural place, in +the great structure of human life. + +1888. + +NOTES + +12. *Mr. Saintsbury, in his Specimens of English Prose, from Malory +to Macaulay, has succeeded in tracing, through successive English +prose-writers, the tradition of that severer beauty in them, of which +this admirable scholar of our literature is known to be a lover. +English Prose, from Mandeville to Thackeray, more recently "chosen +and edited" by a younger scholar, Mr. Arthur Galton, of New College, +Oxford, a lover of our literature at once enthusiastic and discreet, +aims at a more various illustration of the eloquent powers of English +prose, and is a delightful companion. + +28. +In the original, the quoted material is not indented but instead +appears in a smaller typeface; I have chosen to indent the material +half an inch to make it easier to read. + + + +WORDSWORTH + +[39] SOME English critics at the beginning of the present century had +a great deal to say concerning a distinction, of much importance, as +they thought, in the true estimate of poetry, between the Fancy, and +another more powerful faculty--the Imagination. This metaphysical +distinction, borrowed originally from the writings of German +philosophers, and perhaps not always clearly apprehended by those who +talked of it, involved a far deeper and more vital distinction, with +which indeed all true criticism more or less directly has to do, the +distinction, namely, between higher and lower degrees of intensity in +the poet's perception of his subject, and in his concentration of +himself upon his work. Of those who dwelt upon the metaphysical +distinction between the Fancy and the Imagination, it was Wordsworth +who made the most of it, assuming it as the basis for the final +classification of his poetical writings; and it is in these writings +that the deeper and more vital distinction, which, as I have said, +underlies the metaphysical [40] distinction, is most needed, and may +best be illustrated. + +For nowhere is there so perplexed a mixture as in Wordsworth's own +poetry, of work touched with intense and individual power, with work +of almost no character at all. He has much conventional sentiment, +and some of that insincere poetic diction, against which his most +serious critical efforts were directed: the reaction in his political +ideas, consequent on the excesses of 1795, makes him, at times, a +mere declaimer on moral and social topics; and he seems, sometimes, +to force an unwilling pen, and write by rule. By making the most of +these blemishes it is possible to obscure the true aesthetic value of +his work, just as his life also, a life of much quiet delicacy and +independence, might easily be placed in a false focus, and made to +appear a somewhat tame theme in illustration of the more obvious +parochial virtues. And those who wish to understand his influence, +and experience his peculiar savour, must bear with patience the +presence of an alien element in Wordsworth's work, which never +coalesced with what is really delightful in it, nor underwent his +special power. Who that values his writings most has not felt the +intrusion there, from time to time, of something tedious and prosaic? +Of all poets equally great, he would gain most by a skilfully made +anthology. Such a selection would show, in truth, not so much what +he was, or to himself or others [41] seemed to be, as what, by the +more energetic and fertile quality in his writings, he was ever +tending to become. And the mixture in his work, as it actually +stands, is so perplexed, that one fears to miss the least promising +composition even, lest some precious morsel should be lying hidden +within--the few perfect lines, the phrase, the single word perhaps, +to which he often works up mechanically through a poem, almost the +whole of which may be tame enough. He who thought that in all +creative work the larger part was given passively, to the recipient +mind, who waited so dutifully upon the gift, to whom so large a +measure was sometimes given, had his times also of desertion and +relapse; and he has permitted the impress of these too to remain in +his work. And this duality there--the fitfulness with which the +higher qualities manifest themselves in it, gives the effect in his +poetry of a power not altogether his own, or under his control, which +comes and goes when it will, lifting or lowering a matter, poor in +itself; so that that old fancy which made the poet's art an +enthusiasm, a form of divine possession, seems almost literally true +of him. + +This constant suggestion of an absolute duality between higher and +lower moods, and the work done in them, stimulating one always to +look below the surface, makes the reading of Wordsworth an excellent +sort of training towards the things of art and poetry. It begets in +those, [42] who, coming across him in youth, can bear him at all, a +habit of reading between the lines, a faith in the effect of +concentration and collectedness of mind in the right appreciation of +poetry, an expectation of things, in this order, coming to one by +means of a right discipline of the temper as well as of the +intellect. He meets us with the promise that he has much, and +something very peculiar, to give us, if we will follow a certain +difficult way, and seems to have the secret of a special and +privileged state of mind. And those who have undergone his +influence, and followed this difficult way, are like people who have +passed through some initiation, a disciplina arcani, by submitting to +which they become able constantly to distinguish in art, speech, +feeling, manners, that which is organic, animated, expressive, from +that which is only conventional, derivative, inexpressive. + +But although the necessity of selecting these precious morsels for +oneself is an opportunity for the exercise of Wordsworth's peculiar +influence, and induces a kind of just criticism and true estimate of +it, yet the purely literary product would have been more excellent, +had the writer himself purged away that alien element. How perfect +would have been the little treasury, shut between the covers of how +thin a book! Let us suppose the desired separation made, the +electric thread untwined, the golden pieces, [43] great and small, +lying apart together.* What are the peculiarities of this residue? +What special sense does Wordsworth exercise, and what instincts does +he satisfy? What are the subjects and the motives which in him +excite the imaginative faculty? What are the qualities in things and +persons which he values, the impression and sense of which he can +convey to others, in an extraordinary way? + +An intimate consciousness of the expression of natural things, which +weighs, listens, penetrates, where the earlier mind passed roughly +by, is a large element in the complexion of modern poetry. It has +been remarked as a fact in mental history again and again. It +reveals itself in many forms; but is strongest and most attractive in +what is strongest and most attractive in modern literature. It is +exemplified, almost equally, by writers as unlike each other as +Senancour and Théophile Gautier: as a singular chapter in the history +of the human mind, its growth might be traced from Rousseau to +Chateaubriand, from Chateaubriand to Victor Hugo: it has doubtless +some latent connexion with those pantheistic theories which locate an +intelligent soul in material things, and have largely exercised men's +minds in some modern systems of philosophy: it is traceable even in +[44] the graver writings of historians: it makes as much difference +between ancient and modern landscape art, as there is between the +rough masks of an early mosaic and a portrait by Reynolds or +Gainsborough. Of this new sense, the writings of Wordsworth are the +central and elementary expression: he is more simply and entirely +occupied with it than any other poet, though there are fine +expressions of precisely the same thing in so different a poet as +Shelley. There was in his own character a certain contentment, a +sort of inborn religious placidity, seldom found united with a +sensibility so mobile as his, which was favourable to the quiet, +habitual observation of inanimate, or imperfectly animate, existence. +His life of eighty years is divided by no very profoundly felt +incidents: its changes are almost wholly inward, and it falls into +broad, untroubled, perhaps somewhat monotonous spaces. What it most +resembles is the life of one of those early Italian or Flemish +painters, who, just because their minds were full of heavenly +visions, passed, some of them, the better part of sixty years in +quiet, systematic industry. This placid life matured a quite unusual +sensibility, really innate in him, to the sights and sounds of the +natural world--the flower and its shadow on the stone, the cuckoo and +its echo. The poem of Resolution and Independence is a storehouse of +such records: for its fulness of imagery it may be compared to +Keats's Saint Agnes' Eve. To [45] read one of his longer pastoral +poems for the first time, is like a day spent in a new country: the +memory is crowded for a while with its precise and vivid incidents-- + +The pliant harebell swinging in the breeze +On some grey rock ;-- + +The single sheep and the one blasted tree +And the bleak music from that old stone wall;-- + +In the meadows and the lower ground +Was all the sweetness of a common dawn;-- + +And that green corn all day is rustling in thine ears. + +Clear and delicate at once, as he is in the outlining of visible +imagery, he is more clear and delicate still, and finely scrupulous, +in the noting of sounds; so that he conceives of noble sound as even +moulding the human countenance to nobler types, and as something +actually "profaned" by colour, by visible form, or image. + +He has a power likewise of realising, and conveying to the +consciousness of the reader, abstract and elementary impressions-- +silence, darkness, absolute motionlessness: or, again, the whole +complex sentiment of a particular place, the abstract expression of +desolation in the long white road, of peacefulness in a particular +folding of the hills. In the airy building of the brain, a special +day or hour even, comes to have for him a sort of personal identity, +a spirit or angel given to it, by which, for its exceptional [46] +insight, or the happy light upon it, it has a presence in one's +history, and acts there, as a separate power or accomplishment; and +he has celebrated in many of his poems the "efficacious spirit," +which, as he says, resides in these "particular spots" of time. + +It is to such a world, and to a world of congruous meditation +thereon, that we see him retiring in his but lately published poem of +The Recluse--taking leave, without much count of costs, of the world +of business, of action and ambition; as also of all that for the +majority of mankind counts as sensuous enjoyment.* + +And so it came about that this sense of a life in natural objects, +which in most poetry is but a rhetorical artifice, is with Wordsworth +the assertion of what for him is almost literal fact. To him every +natural object seemed to possess more or less of a moral or spiritual +life, to be [47] capable of a companionship with man, full of +expression, of inexplicable affinities and delicacies of intercourse. +An emanation, a particular spirit, belonged, not to the moving leaves +or water only, but to the distant peak of the hills arising suddenly, +by some change of perspective, above the nearer horizon, to the +passing space of light across the plain, to the lichened Druidic +stone even, for a certain weird fellowship in it with the moods of +men. It was like a "survival," in the peculiar intellectual +temperament of a man of letters at the end of the eighteenth century, +of that primitive condition, which some philosophers have traced in +the general history of human culture, wherein all outward objects +[48] alike, including even the works of men's hands, were believed to +be endowed with animation, and the world was "full of souls"--that +mood in which the old Greek gods were first begotten, and which had +many strange aftergrowths. + +In the early ages, this belief, delightful as its effects on poetry +often are, was but the result of a crude intelligence. But, in +Wordsworth, such power of seeing life, such perception of a soul, in +inanimate things, came of an exceptional susceptibility to the +impressions of eye and ear, and was, in its essence, a kind of +sensuousness. At least, it is only in a temperament exceptionally +susceptible on the sensuous side, that this sense of the +expressiveness of outward things comes to be so large a part of life. +That he awakened "a sort of thought in sense," is Shelley's just +estimate of this element in Wordsworth's poetry. + +And it was through nature, thus ennobled by a semblance of passion +and thought, that he approached the spectacle of human life. Human +life, indeed, is for him, at first, only an additional, accidental +grace on an expressive landscape. When he thought of man, it was of +man as in the presence and under the influence of these effective +natural objects, and linked to them by many associations. The close +connexion of man with natural objects, the habitual association of +his thoughts and feelings with a particular spot of earth, has +sometimes seemed to [49] degrade those who are subject to its +influence, as if it did but reinforce that physical connexion of our +nature with the actual lime and clay of the soil, which is always +drawing us nearer to our end. But for Wordsworth, these influences +tended to the dignity of human nature, because they tended to +tranquillise it. By raising nature to the level of human thought he +gives it power and expression: he subdues man to the level of nature, +and gives him thereby a certain breadth and coolness and solemnity. +The leech-gatherer on the moor, the woman "stepping westward," are +for him natural objects, almost in the same sense as the aged thorn, +or the lichened rock on the heath. In this sense the leader of the +"Lake School," in spite of an earnest preoccupation with man, his +thoughts, his destiny, is the poet of nature. And of nature, after +all, in its modesty. The English lake country has, of course, its +grandeurs. But the peculiar function of Wordsworth's genius, as +carrying in it a power to open out the soul of apparently little or +familiar things, would have found its true test had he become the +poet of Surrey, say! and the prophet of its life. The glories of +Italy and Switzerland, though he did write a little about them, had +too potent a material life of their own to serve greatly his poetic +purpose. + +Religious sentiment, consecrating the affections and natural regrets +of the human heart, above all, that pitiful awe and care for the [50] +perishing human clay, of which relic-worship is but the corruption, +has always had much to do with localities, with the thoughts which +attach themselves to actual scenes and places. Now what is true of +it everywhere, is truest of it in those secluded valleys where one +generation after another maintains the same abiding-place; and it was +on this side, that Wordsworth apprehended religion most strongly. +Consisting, as it did so much, in the recognition of local +sanctities, in the habit of connecting the stones and trees of a +particular spot of earth with the great events of life, till the low +walls, the green mounds, the half-obliterated epitaphs seemed full of +voices, and a sort of natural oracles, the very religion of these +people of the dales appeared but as another link between them and the +earth, and was literally a religion of nature. It tranquillised them +by bringing them under the placid rule of traditional and narrowly +localised observances. "Grave livers," they seemed to him, under +this aspect, with stately speech, and something of that natural +dignity of manners, which underlies the highest courtesy. + +And, seeing man thus as a part of nature, elevated and solemnised in +proportion as his daily life and occupations brought him into +companionship with permanent natural objects, his very religion +forming new links for him with the narrow limits of the valley, the +low vaults of his church, the rough stones of his [51] home, made +intense for him now with profound sentiment, Wordsworth was able to +appreciate passion in the lowly. He chooses to depict people from +humble life, because, being nearer to nature than others, they are on +the whole more impassioned, certainly more direct in their expression +of passion, than other men: it is for this direct expression of +passion, that he values their humble words. In much that he said in +exaltation of rural life, he was but pleading indirectly for that +sincerity, that perfect fidelity to one's own inward presentations, +to the precise features of the picture within, without which any +profound poetry is impossible. It was not for their tameness, but +for this passionate sincerity, that he chose incidents and situations +from common life, "related in a selection of language really used by +men." He constantly endeavours to bring his language near to the +real language of men: to the real language of men, however, not on +the dead level of their ordinary intercourse, but in select moments +of vivid sensation, when this language is winnowed and ennobled by +excitement. There are poets who have chosen rural life as their +subject, for the sake of its passionless repose, and times when +Wordsworth himself extols the mere calm and dispassionate survey of +things as the highest aim of poetical culture. But it was not for +such passionless calm that he preferred the scenes of pastoral life; +and the meditative poet, sheltering [52] himself, as it might seem, +from the agitations of the outward world, is in reality only clearing +the scene for the great exhibitions of emotion, and what he values +most is the almost elementary expression of elementary feelings. + +And so he has much for those who value highly the concentrated +presentment of passion, who appraise men and women by their +susceptibility to it, and art and poetry as they afford the spectacle +of it. Breaking from time to time into the pensive spectacle of +their daily toil, their occupations near to nature, come those great +elementary feelings, lifting and solemnising their language and +giving it a natural music. The great, distinguishing passion came to +Michael by the sheepfold, to Ruth by the wayside, adding these humble +children of the furrow to the true aristocracy of passionate souls. +In this respect, Wordsworth's work resembles most that of George +Sand, in those of her novels which depict country life. With a +penetrative pathos, which puts him in the same rank with the masters +of the sentiment of pity in literature, with Meinhold and Victor +Hugo, he collects all the traces of vivid excitement which were to be +found in that pastoral world--the girl who rung her father's knell; +the unborn infant feeling about its mother's heart; the instinctive +touches of children; the sorrows of the wild creatures, even--their +home-sickness, their strange yearnings; the tales of passionate +regret that hang [53] by a ruined farm-building, a heap of stones, a +deserted sheepfold; that gay, false, adventurous, outer world, which +breaks in from time to time to bewilder and deflower these quiet +homes; not "passionate sorrow" only, for the overthrow of the soul's +beauty, but the loss of, or carelessness for personal beauty even, in +those whom men have wronged--their pathetic wanness; the sailor "who, +in his heart, was half a shepherd on the stormy seas"; the wild woman +teaching her child to pray for her betrayer; incidents like the +making of the shepherd's staff, or that of the young boy laying the +first stone of the sheepfold;--all the pathetic episodes of their +humble existence, their longing, their wonder at fortune, their poor +pathetic pleasures, like the pleasures of children, won so hardly in +the struggle for bare existence; their yearning towards each other, +in their darkened houses, or at their early toil. A sort of biblical +depth and solemnity hangs over this strange, new, passionate, +pastoral world, of which he first raised the image, and the +reflection of which some of our best modern fiction has caught from +him. + +He pondered much over the philosophy of his poetry, and reading +deeply in the history of his own mind, seems at times to have passed +the borders of a world of strange speculations, inconsistent enough, +had he cared to note such inconsistencies, with those traditional +beliefs, which [54] were otherwise the object of his devout +acceptance. Thinking of the high value he set upon customariness, +upon all that is habitual, local, rooted in the ground, in matters of +religious sentiment, you might sometimes regard him as one tethered +down to a world, refined and peaceful indeed, but with no broad +outlook, a world protected, but somewhat narrowed, by the influence +of received ideas. But he is at times also something very different +from this, and something much bolder. A chance expression is +overheard and placed in a new connexion, the sudden memory of a thing +long past occurs to him, a distant object is relieved for a while by +a random gleam of light--accidents turning up for a moment what lies +below the surface of our immediate experience--and he passes from the +humble graves and lowly arches of "the little rock-like pile" of a +Westmoreland church, on bold trains of speculative thought, and +comes, from point to point, into strange contact with thoughts which +have visited, from time to time, far more venturesome, perhaps +errant, spirits. + +He had pondered deeply, for instance, on those strange reminiscences +and forebodings, which seem to make our lives stretch before and +behind us, beyond where we can see or touch anything, or trace the +lines of connexion. Following the soul, backwards and forwards, on +these endless ways, his sense of man's dim, potential powers became a +pledge to him, indeed, of a future life, [55] but carried him back +also to that mysterious notion of an earlier state of existence--the +fancy of the Platonists--the old heresy of Origen. It was in this +mood that he conceived those oft-reiterated regrets for a half-ideal +childhood, when the relics of Paradise still clung about the soul--a +childhood, as it seemed, full of the fruits of old age, lost for all, +in a degree, in the passing away of the youth of the world, lost for +each one, over again, in the passing away of actual youth. It is +this ideal childhood which he celebrates in his famous Ode on the +Recollections of Childhood, and some other poems which may be grouped +around it, such as the lines on Tintern Abbey, and something like +what he describes was actually truer of himself than he seems to have +understood; for his own most delightful poems were really the +instinctive productions of earlier life, and most surely for him, +"the first diviner influence of this world" passed away, more and +more completely, in his contact with experience. + +Sometimes as he dwelt upon those moments of profound, imaginative +power, in which the outward object appears to take colour and +expression, a new nature almost, from the prompting of the observant +mind, the actual world would, as it were, dissolve and detach itself, +flake by flake, and he himself seemed to be the creator, and when he +would the destroyer, of the world in which he lived--that old +isolating thought of many a brain-sick mystic of ancient and modern +times. + +[56] At other times, again, in those periods of intense +susceptibility, in which he appeared to himself as but the passive +recipient of external influences, he was attracted by the thought of +a spirit of life in outward things, a single, all-pervading mind in +them, of which man, and even the poet's imaginative energy, are but +moments--that old dream of the anima mundi, the mother of all things +and their grave, in which some had desired to lose themselves, and +others had become indifferent to the distinctions of good and evil. +It would come, sometimes, like the sign of the macrocosm to Faust in +his cell: the network of man and nature was seen to be pervaded by a +common, universal life: a new, bold thought lifted him above the +furrow, above the green turf of the Westmoreland churchyard, to a +world altogether different in its vagueness and vastness, and the +narrow glen was full of the brooding power of one universal spirit. + +And so he has something, also, for those who feel the fascination of +bold speculative ideas, who are really capable of rising upon them to +conditions of poetical thought. He uses them, indeed, always with a +very fine apprehension of the limits within which alone philosophical +imaginings have any place in true poetry; and using them only for +poetical purposes, is not too careful even to make them consistent +with each other. To him, theories which for other men [57] bring a +world of technical diction, brought perfect form and expression, as +in those two lofty books of The Prelude, which describe the decay and +the restoration of Imagination and Taste. Skirting the borders of +this world of bewildering heights and depths, he got but the first +exciting influence of it, that joyful enthusiasm which great +imaginative theories prompt, when the mind first comes to have an +understanding of them; and it is not under the influence of these +thoughts that his poetry becomes tedious or loses its blitheness. He +keeps them, too, always within certain ethical bounds, so that no +word of his could offend the simplest of those simple souls which are +always the largest portion of mankind. But it is, nevertheless, the +contact of these thoughts, the speculative boldness in them, which +constitutes, at least for some minds, the secret attraction of much +of his best poetry--the sudden passage from lowly thoughts and places +to the majestic forms of philosophical imagination, the play of these +forms over a world so different, enlarging so strangely the bounds of +its humble churchyards, and breaking such a wild light on the graves +of christened children. + +And these moods always brought with them faultless expression. In +regard to expression, as with feeling and thought, the duality of the +higher and lower moods was absolute. It belonged to the higher, the +imaginative mood, and was the pledge of its reality, to bring the +[58] appropriate language with it. In him, when the really poetical +motive worked at all, it united, with absolute justice, the word and +the idea; each, in the imaginative flame, becoming inseparably one +with the other, by that fusion of matter and form, which is the +characteristic of the highest poetical expression. His words are +themselves thought and feeling; not eloquent, or musical words +merely, but that sort of creative language which carries the reality +of what it depicts, directly, to the consciousness. + +The music of mere metre performs but a limited, yet a very peculiar +and subtly ascertained function, in Wordsworth's poetry. With him, +metre is but an additional grace, accessory to that deeper music of +words and sounds, that moving power, which they exercise in the +nobler prose no less than in formal poetry. It is a sedative to that +excitement, an excitement sometimes almost painful, under which the +language, alike of poetry and prose, attains a rhythmical power, +independent of metrical combination, and dependent rather on some +subtle adjustment of the elementary sounds of words themselves to the +image or feeling they convey. Yet some of his pieces, pieces +prompted by a sort of half-playful mysticism, like the Daffodils and +The Two April Mornings, are distinguished by a certain quaint gaiety +of metre, and rival by their perfect execution, in this respect, +similar pieces among our own Elizabethan, or contemporary French +poetry. + +[59] And those who take up these poems after an interval of months, +or years perhaps, may be surprised at finding how well old favourites +wear, how their strange, inventive turns of diction or thought still +send through them the old feeling of surprise. Those who lived about +Wordsworth were all great lovers of the older English literature, and +oftentimes there came out in him a noticeable likeness to our earlier +poets. He quotes unconsciously, but with new power of meaning, a +clause from one of Shakespeare's sonnets; and, as with some other +men's most famous work, the Ode on the Recollections of Childhood had +its anticipator.* He drew something too from the unconscious +mysticism of the old English language itself, drawing out the inward +significance of its racy idiom, and the not wholly unconscious poetry +of the language used by the simplest people under strong excitement-- +language, therefore, at its origin. + +The office of the poet is not that of the moralist, and the first aim +of Wordsworth's poetry is to give the reader a peculiar kind of +pleasure. But through his poetry, and through this pleasure in it, +he does actually convey to the reader an extraordinary wisdom in the +things of practice. One lesson, if men must have lessons, he conveys +more clearly than all, the supreme importance of contemplation in the +conduct of life. + +[60] Contemplation--impassioned contemplation--that, is with +Wordsworth the end-in-itself, the perfect end. We see the majority +of mankind going most often to definite ends, lower or higher ends, +as their own instincts may determine; but the end may never be +attained, and the means not be quite the right means, great ends and +little ones alike being, for the most part, distant, and the ways to +them, in this dim world, somewhat vague. Meantime, to higher or +lower ends, they move too often with something of a sad countenance, +with hurried and ignoble gait, becoming, unconsciously, something +like thorns, in their anxiety to bear grapes; it being possible for +people, in the pursuit of even great ends, to become themselves thin +and impoverished in spirit and temper, thus diminishing the sum of +perfection in the world, at its very sources. We understand this +when it is a question of mean, or of intensely selfish ends--of +Grandet, or Javert. We think it bad morality to say that the end +justifies the means, and we know how false to all higher conceptions +of the religious life is the type of one who is ready to do evil that +good may come. We contrast with such dark, mistaken eagerness, a +type like that of Saint Catherine of Siena, who made the means to her +ends so attractive, that she has won for herself an undying place in +the House Beautiful, not by her rectitude of soul only, but by its +"fairness"--by those quite different qualities [61] which commend +themselves to the poet and the artist. + +Yet, for most of us, the conception of means and ends covers the +whole of life, and is the exclusive type or figure under which we +represent our lives to ourselves. Such a figure, reducing all things +to machinery, though it has on its side the authority of that old +Greek moralist who has fixed for succeeding generations the outline +of the theory of right living, is too like a mere picture or +description of men's lives as we actually find them, to be the basis +of the higher ethics. It covers the meanness of men's daily lives, +and much of the dexterity with which they pursue what may seem to +them the good of themselves or of others; but not the intangible +perfection of those whose ideal is rather in being than in doing--not +those manners which are, in the deepest as in the simplest sense, +morals, and without which one cannot so much as offer a cup of water +to a poor man without offence--not the part of "antique Rachel," +sitting in the company of Beatrice; and even the moralist might well +endeavour rather to withdraw men from the too exclusive consideration +of means and ends, in life. + +Against this predominance of machinery in our existence, Wordsworth's +poetry, like all great art and poetry, is a continual protest. +Justify rather the end by the means, it seems to say: whatever may +become of the fruit, make sure of [62] the flowers and the leaves. +It was justly said, therefore, by one who had meditated very +profoundly on the true relation of means to ends in life, and on the +distinction between what is desirable in itself and what is desirable +only as machinery, that when the battle which he and his friends were +waging had been won, the world would need more than ever those +qualities which Wordsworth was keeping alive and nourishing.* + +That the end of life is not action but contemplation--being as +distinct from doing--a certain disposition of the mind: is, in some +shape or other, the principle of all the higher morality. In poetry, +in art, if you enter into their true spirit at all; you touch this +principle, in a measure: these, by their very sterility, are a type +of beholding for the mere joy of beholding. To treat life in the +spirit of art, is to make life a thing in which means and ends are +identified: to encourage such treatment, the true moral significance +of art and poetry. Wordsworth, and other poets who have been like +him in ancient or more recent times, are the masters, the experts, in +this art of impassioned contemplation. Their work is, not to teach +lessons, or enforce rules, or even to stimulate us to noble ends; but +to withdraw the thoughts for a little while from the mere machinery +of life, to fix [63] them, with appropriate emotions, on the +spectacle of those great facts in man's existence which no machinery +affects, "on the great and universal passions of men, the most +general and interesting of their occupations, and the entire world of +nature,"--on "the operations of the elements and the appearances of +the visible universe, on storm and sunshine, on the revolutions of +the seasons, on cold and heat, on loss of friends and kindred, on +injuries and resentments, on gratitude and hope, on fear and +sorrow." To witness this spectacle with appropriate emotions is the +aim of all culture; and of these emotions poetry like Wordsworth's is +a great nourisher and stimulant. He sees nature full of sentiment +and excitement; he sees men and women as parts of nature, passionate, +excited, in strange grouping and connexion with the grandeur and +beauty of the natural world:--images, in his own words, "of man +suffering, amid awful forms and powers." + +Such is the figure of the more powerful and original poet, hidden +away, in part, under those weaker elements in Wordsworth's poetry, +which for some minds determine their entire character; a poet +somewhat bolder and more passionate than might at first sight be +supposed, but not too bold for true poetical taste; an unimpassioned +writer, you might sometimes fancy, yet thinking the chief aim, in +life and art alike, to be a certain deep emotion; seeking most often +the great [64] elementary passions in lowly places; having at least +this condition of all impassioned work, that he aims always at an +absolute sincerity of feeling and diction, so that he is the true +forerunner of the deepest and most passionate poetry of our own day; +yet going back also, with something of a protest against the +conventional fervour of much of the poetry popular in his own time, +to those older English poets, whose unconscious likeness often comes +out in him. + +1874. + +NOTES + +43. *Since this essay was written, such selections have been made, +with excellent taste, by Matthew Arnold and Professor Knight. + +46-47. *In Wordsworth's prefatory advertisement to the first edition +of The Prelude, published in 1850, it is stated that that work was +intended to be introductory to The Recluse; and that The Recluse, if +completed, would have consisted of three parts. The second part is +The Excursion. The third part was only planned; but the first book +of the first part was left in manuscript by Wordsworth--though in +manuscript, it is said, in no great condition of forwardness for the +printers. This book, now for the first time printed in extenso (a +very noble passage from it found place in that prose advertisement to +The Excursion), is included in the latest edition of Wordsworth by +Mr. John Morley. It was well worth adding to the poet's great +bequest to English literature. A true student of his work, who has +formulated for himself what he supposes to be the leading +characteristics of Wordsworth's genius, will feel, we think, lively +interest in testing them by the various fine passages in what is +here presented for the first time. Let the following serve for +a sample:-- + +Thickets full of songsters, and the voice +Of lordly birds, an unexpected sound +Heard now and then from morn to latest eve, +Admonishing the man who walks below +Of solitude and silence in the sky:-- +These have we, and a thousand nooks of earth +Have also these, but nowhere else is found, +Nowhere (or is it fancy?) can be found +The one sensation that is here; 'tis here, +Here as it found its way into my heart +In childhood, here as it abides by day, +By night, here only; or in chosen minds +That take it with them hence, where'er they go. +--'Tis, but I cannot name it, 'tis the sense +Of majesty, and beauty, and repose, +A blended holiness of earth and sky, +Something that makes this individual spot, +This small abiding-place of many men, +A termination, and a last retreat, +A centre, come from wheresoe'er you will, +A whole without dependence or defect, +Made for itself, and happy in itself, +Perfect contentment, Unity entire. + +59. *Henry Vaughan, in The Retreat. + +62. *See an interesting paper, by Mr. John Morley, on "The Death of +Mr. Mill," Fortnightly Review, June 1873. + + + +COLERIDGE* + +[65] FORMS of intellectual and spiritual culture sometimes exercise +their subtlest and most artful charm when life is already passing +from them. Searching and irresistible as are the changes of the human +spirit on its way to perfection, there is yet so much elasticity of +temper that what must pass away sooner or later is not disengaged all +at once, even from the highest order of minds. Nature, which by one +law of development evolves ideas, hypotheses, modes of inward life, +and represses them in turn, has in this way provided that the earlier +growth should propel its fibres into the later, and so transmit the +whole of its forces in an unbroken continuity of life. Then comes the +spectacle of the reserve of the elder generation exquisitely refined +by the antagonism of the new. That current of new life chastens them +while they contend against it. Weaker minds fail to perceive the +change: the clearest minds abandon themselves to it. To [66] feel +the change everywhere, yet not abandon oneself to it, is a situation +of difficulty and contention. Communicating, in this way, to the +passing stage of culture, the charm of what is chastened, high- +strung, athletic, they yet detach the highest minds from the past, by +pressing home its difficulties and finally proving it impossible. +Such has been the charm of many leaders of lost causes in philosophy +and in religion. It is the special charm of Coleridge, in connexion +with those older methods of philosophic inquiry, over which the +empirical philosophy of our day has triumphed. + +Modern thought is distinguished from ancient by its cultivation of +the "relative" spirit in place of the "absolute." Ancient philosophy +sought to arrest every object in an eternal outline, to fix thought +in a necessary formula, and the varieties of life in a classification +by "kinds," or genera. To the modern spirit nothing is, or can be +rightly known, except relatively and under conditions. The +philosophical conception of the relative has been developed in modern +times through the influence of the sciences of observation. Those +sciences reveal types of life evanescing into each other by +inexpressible refinements of change. Things pass into their +opposites by accumulation of undefinable quantities. The growth of +those sciences consists in a continual analysis of facts of rough and +general observation into groups of facts more precise and minute. + +[67] The faculty for truth is recognised as a power of distinguishing +and fixing delicate and fugitive detail. The moral world is ever in +contact with the physical, and the relative spirit has invaded moral +philosophy from the ground of the inductive sciences. There it has +started a new analysis of the relations of body and mind, good and +evil, freedom and necessity. Hard and abstract moralities are +yielding to a more exact estimate of the subtlety and complexity of +our life. Always, as an organism increases in perfection, the +conditions of its life become more complex. Man is the most complex +of the products of nature. Character merges into temperament: the +nervous system refines itself into intellect. Man's physical +organism is played upon not only by the physical conditions about it, +but by remote laws of inheritance, the vibration of long-past acts +reaching him in the midst of the new order of things in which he +lives. When we have estimated these conditions he is still not yet +simple and isolated; for the mind of the race, the character of the +age, sway him this way or that through the medium of language and +current ideas. It seems as if the most opposite statements about him +were alike true: he is so receptive, all the influences of nature and +of society ceaselessly playing upon him, so that every hour in his +life is unique, changed altogether by a stray word, or glance, or +touch. It is the truth of these relations that experience [68] gives +us, not the truth of eternal outlines ascertained once for all, but a +world of fine gradations and subtly linked conditions, shifting +intricately as we ourselves change--and bids us, by a constant +clearing of the organs of observation and perfecting of analysis, to +make what we can of these. To the intellect, the critical spirit, +just these subtleties of effect are more precious than anything else. +What is lost in precision of form is gained in intricacy of +expression. It is no vague scholastic abstraction that will satisfy +the speculative instinct in our modern minds. Who would change the +colour or curve of a rose-leaf for that ousia akhrômatos, +askhêmatistos, anaphês+--that colourless, formless, intangible, +being--Plato put so high? For the true illustration of the +speculative temper is not the Hindoo mystic, lost to sense, +understanding, individuality, but one such as Goethe, to whom every +moment of life brought its contribution of experimental, individual +knowledge; by whom no touch of the world of form, colour, and passion +was disregarded. + +Now the literary life of Coleridge was a disinterested struggle +against the relative spirit. With a strong native bent towards the +tracking of all questions, critical or practical, to first +principles, he is ever restlessly scheming to "apprehend the +absolute," to affirm it effectively, to get it acknowledged. It was +an effort, surely, an effort of sickly thought, that saddened his +[69] mind, and limited the operation of his unique poetic gift. + +So what the reader of our own generation will least find in +Coleridge's prose writings is the excitement of the literary sense. +And yet, in those grey volumes, we have the larger part of the +production of one who made way ever by a charm, the charm of voice, +of aspect, of language, above all by the intellectual charm of new, +moving, luminous ideas. Perhaps the chief offence in Coleridge is an +excess of seriousness, a seriousness arising not from any moral +principle, but from a misconception of the perfect manner. There is +a certain shade of unconcern, the perfect manner of the eighteenth +century, which may be thought to mark complete culture in the +handling of abstract questions. The humanist, the possessor of that +complete culture, does not "weep" over the failure of "a theory of +the quantification of the predicate," nor "shriek" over the fall of a +philosophical formula. A kind of humour is, in truth, one of the +conditions of the just mental attitude, in the criticism of by-past +stages of thought. Humanity cannot afford to be too serious about +them, any more than a man of good sense can afford to be too serious +in looking back upon his own childhood. Plato, whom Coleridge claims +as the first of his spiritual ancestors, Plato, as we remember him, a +true humanist, holds his theories lightly, glances with a somewhat +blithe and naive inconsequence from [70] one view to another, not +anticipating the burden of importance "views" will one day have for +men. In reading him one feels how lately it was that Croesus thought +it a paradox to say that external prosperity was not necessarily +happiness. But on Coleridge lies the whole weight of the sad +reflection that has since come into the world, with which for us the +air is full, which the "children in the market-place" repeat to each +other. His very language is forced and broken lest some saving +formula should be lost--distinctities, enucleation, pentad of +operative Christianity; he has a whole armoury of these terms, and +expects to turn the tide of human thought by fixing the sense of such +expressions as "reason," "understanding," "idea." Again, he lacks +the jealousy of a true artist in excluding all associations that have +no colour, or charm, or gladness in them; and everywhere allows the +impress of a somewhat inferior theological literature. + +"I was driven from life in motion to life in thought and sensation:" +so Coleridge sums up his childhood, with its delicacy, its +sensitiveness, and passion. But at twenty-five he was exercising a +wonderful charm, and had already defined for himself his peculiar +line of intellectual activity. He had an odd, attractive gift of +conversation, or rather of monologue, as Madame de Staël observed of +him, full of bizarreries, with the rapid alternations of a dream, and +here or there an unexpected summons into a world [71] strange to the +hearer, abounding in images drawn from a sort of divided imperfect +life, the consciousness of the opium-eater, as of one to whom the +external world penetrated only in part, and, blent with all this, +passages of deep obscurity, precious, if at all, only for their +musical cadence, echoes in Coleridge of the eloquence of those older +English writers of whom he was so ardent a lover. And all through +this brilliant early manhood we may discern the power of the +"Asiatic" temperament, of that voluptuousness, which is connected +perhaps with his appreciation of the intimacy, the almost mystical +communion of touch, between nature and man. "I am much better," he +writes, "and my new and tender health is all over me like a +voluptuous feeling." And whatever fame, or charm, or life-inspiring +gift he has had as a speculative thinker, is the vibration of the +interest he excited then, the propulsion into years which clouded his +early promise of that first buoyant, irresistible, self-assertion. +So great is even the indirect power of a sincere effort towards the +ideal life, of even a temporary escape of the spirit from routine. + +In 1798 he visited Germany, then, the only half-known, "promised +land," of the metaphysical, the "absolute," philosophy. A beautiful +fragment of this period remains, describing a spring excursion to the +Brocken. His excitement still vibrates in it. Love, all joyful +states [72] of mind, are self-expressive: they loosen the tongue, +they fill the thoughts with sensuous images, they harmonise one with +the world of sight. We hear of the "rich graciousness and courtesy" +of Coleridge's manner, of the white and delicate skin, the abundant +black hair, the full, almost animal lips--that whole physiognomy of +the dreamer, already touched with narcotism. One says, of the +beginning of one of his Unitarian sermons: "His voice rose like a +stream of rich, distilled perfumes;" another, "He talks like an +angel, and does--nothing!" + +The Aids to Reflection, The Friend, The Biographia Literaria: those +books came from one whose vocation was in the world of the +imagination, the theory and practice of poetry. And yet, perhaps, of +all books that have been influential in modern times, they are +furthest from artistic form--bundles of notes; the original matter +inseparably mixed up with that borrowed from others; the whole, just +that mere preparation for an artistic effect which the finished +literary artist would be careful one day to destroy. Here, again, we +have a trait profoundly characteristic of Coleridge. He sometimes +attempts to reduce a phase of thought, subtle and exquisite, to +conditions too rough for it. He uses a purely speculative gift for +direct moral edification. Scientific truth is a thing fugitive, +relative, full of fine gradations: he tries to fix it in absolute +formulas. The Aids to Reflection, The Friend, are [73] efforts to +propagate the volatile spirit of conversation into the less ethereal +fabric of a written book; and it is only here or there that the +poorer matter becomes vibrant, is really lifted by the spirit. + +De Quincey said of him that "he wanted better bread than can be made +with wheat:" Lamb, that from childhood he had "hungered for +eternity." Yet the faintness, the continuous dissolution, whatever +its cause, which soon supplanted the buoyancy of his first wonderful +years, had its own consumptive refinements, and even brought, as to +the "Beautiful Soul" in Wilhelm Meister, a faint religious ecstasy-- +that "singing in the sails" which is not of the breeze. Here again +is one of his occasional notes:-- + +"In looking at objects of nature while I am thinking, as at yonder +moon, dim-glimmering through the window-pane, I seem rather to be +seeking, as it were asking, a symbolical language for something +within me, that already and for ever exists, than observing anything +new. Even when the latter is the case, yet still I have always an +obscure feeling, as if that new phenomenon were the dim awaking of a +forgotten or hidden truth of my inner nature. While I was preparing +the pen to make this remark, I lost the train of thought which had +led me to it." + +What a distemper of the eye of the mind! What an almost bodily +distemper there is in that! + +Coleridge's intellectual sorrows were many; [74] but he had one +singular intellectual happiness. With an inborn taste for +transcendental philosophy, he lived just at the time when that +philosophy took an immense spring in Germany, and connected itself +with an impressive literary movement. He had the good luck to light +upon it in its freshness, and introduce it to his countrymen. What +an opportunity for one reared on the colourless analytic English +philosophies of the last century, but who feels an irresistible +attraction towards bold metaphysical synthesis! How rare are such +occasions of intellectual contentment! This transcendental +philosophy, chiefly as systematised by the mystic Schelling, +Coleridge applied with an eager, unwearied subtlety, to the questions +of theology, and poetic or artistic criticism. It is in his theory +of poetry, of art, that he comes nearest to principles of permanent +truth and importance: that is the least fugitive part of his prose +work. What, then, is the essence of his philosophy of art--of +imaginative production? + +Generally, it may be described as an attempt to reclaim the world of +art as a world of fixed laws, to show that the creative activity of +genius and the simplest act of thought are but higher and lower +products of the laws of a universal logic. Criticism, feeling its +own inadequacy in dealing with the greater works of art, is sometimes +tempted to make too much of those dark and capricious suggestions of +genius, which even [75] the intellect possessed by them is unable to +explain or recall. It has seemed due to the half-sacred character of +those works to ignore all analogy between the productive process by +which they had their birth, and the simpler processes of mind. +Coleridge, on the other hand, assumes that the highest phases of +thought must be more, not less, than the lower, subject to law. + +With this interest, in the Biographia Literaria, he refines +Schelling's "Philosophy of Nature" into a theory of art. "There can +be no plagiarism in philosophy," says Heine:--Es giebt kein Plagiat +in der Philosophie, in reference to the charge brought against +Schelling of unacknowledged borrowing from Bruno; and certainly that +which is common to Coleridge and Schelling and Bruno alike is of far +earlier origin than any of them. Schellingism, the "Philosophy of +Nature," is indeed a constant tradition in the history of thought: it +embodies a permanent type of the speculative temper. That mode of +conceiving nature as a mirror or reflex of the intelligence of man +may be traced up to the first beginnings of Greek speculation. There +are two ways of envisaging those aspects of nature which seem to bear +the impress of reason or intelligence. There is the deist's way, +which regards them merely as marks of design, which separates the +informing mind from its result in nature, as the mechanist from the +machine; and there is the pantheistic way, which identifies the two, +which [76] regards nature itself as the living energy of an +intelligence of the same kind as though vaster in scope than the +human. Partly through the influence of mythology, the Greek mind +became early possessed with the conception of nature as living, +thinking, almost speaking to the mind of man. This unfixed poetical +prepossession, reduced to an abstract form, petrified into an idea, +is the force which gives unity of aim to Greek philosophy. Little by +little, it works out the substance of the Hegelian formula: "Whatever +is, is according to reason: whatever is according to reason, that +is." Experience, which has gradually saddened the earth's colours +for us, stiffened its motions, withdrawn from it some blithe and +debonair presence, has quite changed the character of the science of +nature, as we understand it. The "positive" method, in truth, makes +very little account of marks of intelligence in nature: in its wider +view of phenomena, it sees that those instances are a minority, and +may rank as happy coincidences: it absorbs them in the larger +conception of universal mechanical law. But the suspicion of a mind +latent in nature, struggling for release, and intercourse with the +intellect of man through true ideas, has never ceased to haunt a +certain class of minds. Started again and again in successive +periods by enthusiasts on the antique pattern, in each case the +thought may have seemed paler and more fantastic amid the growing +[77] consistency and sharpness of outline of other and more positive +forms of knowledge. Still, wherever the speculative instinct has +been united with a certain poetic inwardness of temperament, as in +Bruno, in Schelling, there that old Greek conception, like some seed +floating in the air, has taken root and sprung up anew. Coleridge, +thrust inward upon himself, driven from "life in thought and +sensation" to life in thought only, feels already, in his dark London +school, a thread of the Greek mind on this matter vibrating strongly +in him. At fifteen he is discoursing on Plotinus, as in later years +he reflects from Schelling that flitting intellectual tradition. He +supposes a subtle, sympathetic co-ordination between the ideas of the +human reason and the laws of the natural world. Science, the real +knowledge of that natural world, is to be attained, not by +observation, experiment, analysis, patient generalisation, but by the +evolution or recovery of those ideas directly from within, by a sort +of Platonic "recollection"; every group of observed facts remaining +an enigma until the appropriate idea is struck upon them from the +mind of a Newton, or a Cuvier, the genius in whom sympathy with the +universal reason becomes entire. In the next place, he conceives +that this reason or intelligence in nature becomes reflective, or +self-conscious. He fancies he can trace, through all the simpler +forms of life, fragments of an eloquent prophecy about the [78] human +mind. The whole of nature he regards as a development of higher +forms out of the lower, through shade after shade of systematic +change. The dim stir of chemical atoms towards the axis of crystal +form, the trance-like life of plants, the animal troubled by strange +irritabilities, are stages which anticipate consciousness. All +through the ever-increasing movement of life that was shaping itself; +every successive phase of life, in its unsatisfied susceptibilities, +seeming to be drawn out of its own limits by the more pronounced +current of life on its confines, the "shadow of approaching humanity" +gradually deepening, the latent intelligence winning a way to the +surface. And at this point the law of development does not lose +itself in caprice: rather it becomes more constraining and incisive. +From the lowest to the very highest acts of the conscious +intelligence, there is another series of refining shades. Gradually +the mind concentrates itself, frees itself from the limitations of +the particular, the individual, attains a strange power of modifying +and centralising what it receives from without, according to the +pattern of an inward ideal. At last, in imaginative genius, ideas +become effective: the intelligence of nature, all its discursive +elements now connected and justified, is clearly reflected; the +interpretation of its latent purposes being embodied in the great +central products of creative art. The secret of creative [79] genius +would be an exquisitely purged sympathy with nature, with the +reasonable soul antecedent there. Those associative conceptions of +the imagination, those eternally fixed types of action and passion, +would come, not so much from the conscious invention of the artist, +as from his self-surrender to the suggestions of an abstract reason +or ideality in things: they would be evolved by the stir of nature +itself, realising the highest reach of its dormant reason: they would +have a kind of prevenient necessity to rise at some time to the +surface of the human mind. + +It is natural that Shakespeare should be the favourite illustration +of such criticism, whether in England or Germany. The first +suggestion in Shakespeare is that of capricious detail, of a +waywardness that plays with the parts careless of the impression of +the whole; what supervenes is the constraining unity of effect, the +ineffaceable impression, of Hamlet or Macbeth. His hand moving +freely is curved round as if by some law of gravitation from within: +an energetic unity or identity makes itself visible amid an abounding +variety. This unity or identity Coleridge exaggerates into something +like the identity of a natural organism, and the associative act +which effected it into something closely akin to the primitive power +of nature itself. "In the Shakespearian drama," he says, "there is a +vitality which grows and evolves itself from within." + +[80] Again-- + +He, too, worked in the spirit of nature, by evolving the germ +from within, by the imaginative power, according to the idea. +For as the power of seeing is to light, so is an idea in mind +to a law in nature. They are correlatives which suppose +each other. + +Again-- + +The organic form is innate: it shapes, as it develops, itself from +within, and the fulness of its development is one and the same with +the perfection of its outward form. Such as the life is, such is the +form. Nature, the prime, genial artist, inexhaustible in diverse +powers, is equally inexhaustible in forms: each exterior is the +physiognomy of the being within, and even such is the appropriate +excellence of Shakespeare, himself a nature humanised, a genial +understanding, directing self-consciously a power and an implicit +wisdom deeper even than our consciousness.+ + +In this late age we are become so familiarised with the greater works +of art as to be little sensitive of the act of creation in them: they +do not impress us as a new presence in the world. Only sometimes, in +productions which realise immediately a profound influence and +enforce a change in taste, we are actual witnesses of the moulding of +an unforeseen type by some new principle of association; and to that +phenomenon Coleridge wisely recalls our attention. What makes his +view a one-sided one is, that in it the artist has become almost a +mechanical agent: instead of the most luminous and self-possessed +phase of consciousness, the associative act in art or poetry is made +to look like some blindly organic process of assimilation. The work +of art is likened to a living organism. That expresses [81] truly +the sense of a self-delighting, independent life which the finished +work of art gives us: it hardly figures the process by which such +work was produced. Here there is no blind ferment of lifeless +elements towards the realisation of a type. By exquisite analysis +the artist attains clearness of idea; then, through many stages of +refining, clearness of expression. He moves slowly over his work, +calculating the tenderest tone, and restraining the subtlest curve, +never letting hand or fancy move at large, gradually enforcing +flaccid spaces to the higher degree of expressiveness. The +philosophic critic, at least, will value, even in works of +imagination, seemingly the most intuitive, the power of the +understanding in them, their logical process of construction, the +spectacle of a supreme intellectual dexterity which they afford. + +Coleridge's prose writings on philosophy, politics, religion, and +criticism, were, in truth, but one element in a whole lifetime of +endeavours to present the then recent metaphysics of Germany to +English readers, as a legitimate expansion of the older, classical +and native masters of what has been variously called the a priori, or +absolute, or spiritual, or Platonic, view of things. His criticism, +his challenge for recognition in the concrete, visible, finite work +of art, of the dim, unseen, comparatively infinite, soul or power of +the artist, may well be [82] remembered as part of the long pleading +of German culture for the things "behind the veil." To introduce +that spiritual philosophy, as represented by the more transcendental +parts of Kant, and by Schelling, into all subjects, as a system of +reason in them, one and ever identical with itself, however various +the matter through which it was diffused, became with him the motive +of an unflagging enthusiasm, which seems to have been the one thread +of continuity in a life otherwise singularly wanting in unity of +purpose, and in which he was certainly far from uniformly at his +best. Fragmentary and obscure, but often eloquent, and always at +once earnest and ingenious, those writings, supplementing his +remarkable gift of conversation, were directly and indirectly +influential, even on some the furthest removed from Coleridge's own +masters; on John Stuart Mill, for instance, and some of the earlier +writers of the "high-church" school. Like his verse, they display +him also in two other characters--as a student of words, and as a +psychologist, that is, as a more minute observer or student than +other men of the phenomena of mind. To note the recondite +associations of words, old or new; to expound the logic, the +reasonable soul, of their various uses; to recover the interest of +older writers who had had a phraseology of their own--this was a vein +of inquiry allied to his undoubted gift of tracking out and analysing +curious modes of thought. A [83] quaint fragment of verse on Human +Life might serve to illustrate his study of the earlier English +philosophical poetry. The latter gift, that power of the "subtle- +souled psychologist," as Shelley calls him, seems to have been +connected with some tendency to disease in the physical temperament, +something of a morbid want of balance in those parts where the +physical and intellectual elements mix most closely together, with a +kind of languid visionariness, deep-seated in the very constitution +of the "narcotist," who had quite a gift for "plucking the poisons of +self-harm," and which the actual habit of taking opium, accidentally +acquired, did but reinforce. This morbid languor of nature, +connected both with his fitfulness of purpose and his rich delicate +dreaminess, qualifies Coleridge's poetic composition even more than +his prose; his verse, with the exception of his avowedly political +poems, being, unlike that of the "Lake School," to which in some +respects he belongs, singularly unaffected by any moral, or +professional, or personal effort or ambition,--"written," as he says, +"after the more violent emotions of sorrow, to give him pleasure, +when perhaps nothing else could;" but coming thus, indeed, very close +to his own most intimately personal characteristics, and having a +certain languidly soothing grace or cadence, for its most fixed +quality, from first to last. After some Platonic soliloquy on a +flower opening on a fine day in February, he goes on-- [84] + +Dim similitudes +Weaving in mortal strains, I've stolen one hour +From anxious self, life's cruel taskmaster! +And the warm wooings of this sunny day +Tremble along my frame and harmonise +The attempered organ, that even saddest thoughts +Mix with some sweet sensations, like harsh tunes +Played deftly on a sweet-toned instrument. + +The expression of two opposed, yet allied, elements of sensibility in +these lines, is very true to Coleridge:--the grievous agitation, the +grievous listlessness, almost never entirely relieved, together with +a certain physical voluptuousness. He has spoken several times of +the scent of the bean-field in the air:--the tropical touches in a +chilly climate; his is a nature that will make the most of these, +which finds a sort of caress in such things. Kubla Khan, the +fragment of a poem actually composed in some certainly not quite +healthy sleep, is perhaps chiefly of interest as showing, by the mode +of its composition, how physical, how much of a diseased or +valetudinarian temperament, in its moments of relief, Coleridge's +happiest gift really was; and side by side with Kubla Khan should be +read, as Coleridge placed it, the Pains of Sleep, to illustrate that +retarding physical burden in his temperament, that "unimpassioned +grief," the source of which lay so near the source of those +pleasures. Connected also with this, and again in contrast with +Wordsworth, is the limited quantity of his poetical performance, as +he himself [85] regrets so eloquently in the lines addressed to +Wordsworth after his recitation of The Prelude. It is like some +exotic plant, just managing to blossom a little in the somewhat un- +english air of Coleridge's own south-western birthplace, but never +quite well there. + +In 1798 he joined Wordsworth in the composition of a volume of poems- +-the Lyrical Ballads. What Wordsworth then wrote already vibrates +with that blithe impulse which carried him to final happiness and +self-possession. In Coleridge we feel already that faintness and +obscure dejection which clung like some contagious damp to all his +work. Wordsworth was to be distinguished by a joyful and penetrative +conviction of the existence of certain latent affinities between +nature and the human mind, which reciprocally gild the mind and +nature with a kind of "heavenly alchemy." + +My voice proclaims +How exquisitely the individual mind +(And the progressive powers, perhaps, no less +Of the whole species) to the external world +Is fitted; and how exquisitely, too, +The external world is fitted to the mind; +And the creation, by no lower name +Can it be called, which they with blended might +Accomplish. + +In Wordsworth this took the form of an unbroken dreaming over the +aspects and transitions of nature--a reflective, though altogether +unformulated, analysis of them. + +[86] There are in Coleridge's poems expressions of this conviction as +deep as Wordsworth's. But Coleridge could never have abandoned +himself to the dream, the vision, as Wordsworth did, because the +first condition of such abandonment must be an unvexed quietness of +heart. No one can read the Lines composed above Tintern without +feeling how potent the physical element was among the conditions of +Wordsworth's genius--"felt in the blood and felt along the heart." + +My whole life I have lived in quiet thought! + +The stimulus which most artists require of nature he can renounce. +He leaves the ready-made glory of the Swiss mountains that he may +reflect glory on a mouldering leaf. He loves best to watch the +floating thistledown, because of its hint at an unseen life in the +air. Coleridge's temperament, aei en sphodra orexei,+ with its +faintness, its grieved dejection, could never have been like that. + +My genial spirits fail; +And what can these avail +To lift the smothering weight from off my breast? +It were a vain endeavour, +Though I should gaze for ever +On that green light that lingers in the west +I may not hope from outward forms to win +The passion and the life whose fountains are within. + +Wordsworth's flawless temperament, his fine mountain atmosphere of +mind, that calm, sabbatic, mystic, wellbeing which De Quincey, [87] a +little cynically, connected with worldly (that is to say, pecuniary) +good fortune, kept his conviction of a latent intelligence in nature +within the limits of sentiment or instinct, and confined it to those +delicate and subdued shades of expression which alone perfect art +allows. In Coleridge's sadder, more purely intellectual, cast of +genius, what with Wordsworth was sentiment or instinct became a +philosophical idea, or philosophical formula, developed, as much as +possible, after the abstract and metaphysical fashion of the +transcendental schools of Germany. + +The period of Coleridge's residence at Nether Stowey, 1797-1798, was +for him the annus mirabilis. Nearly all the chief works by which his +poetic fame will live were then composed or planned. What shapes +itself for criticism as the main phenomenon of Coleridge's poetic +life, is not, as with most true poets, the gradual development of a +poetic gift, determined, enriched, retarded, by the actual +circumstances of the poet's life, but the sudden blossoming, through +one short season, of such a gift already perfect in its kind, which +thereafter deteriorates as suddenly, with something like premature +old age. Connecting this phenomenon with the leading motive of his +prose writings, we might note it as the deterioration of a productive +or creative power into one merely metaphysical or discursive. In his +unambitious conception of his function as a poet, and in the very +limited quantity of his [88] poetical performance, as I have said, he +was a contrast to his friend Wordsworth. That friendship with +Wordsworth, the chief "developing" circumstance of his poetic life, +comprehended a very close intellectual sympathy; and in such +association chiefly, lies whatever truth there may be in the popular +classification of Coleridge as a member of what is called the "Lake +School." Coleridge's philosophical speculations do really turn on +the ideas which underlay Wordsworth's poetical practice. His prose +works are one long explanation of all that is involved in that famous +distinction between the Fancy and the Imagination. Of what is +understood by both writers as the imaginative quality in the use +of poetic figures, we may take some words of Shakespeare as an +example.-- + +My cousin Suffolk, +My soul shall thine keep company to heaven +Tarry, sweet soul, for mine, then fly abreast. + +The complete infusion here of the figure into the thought, so vividly +realised, that, though birds are not actually mentioned, yet the +sense of their flight, conveyed to us by the single word "abreast," +comes to be more than half of the thought itself:--this, as the +expression of exalted feeling, is an instance of what Coleridge meant +by Imagination. And this sort of identification of the poet's +thought, of himself, with the image or figure which serves him, is +the secret, sometimes, [89] of a singularly entire realisation of +that image, such as makes these lines of Coleridge, for instance, +"imaginative"-- + +Amid the howl of more than wintry storms, +The halcyon hears the voice of vernal hours +Already on the wing. + +There are many such figures both in Coleridge's verse and prose. He +has, too, his passages of that sort of impassioned contemplation on +the permanent and elementary conditions of nature and humanity, which +Wordsworth held to be the essence of a poet; as it would be his +proper function to awaken such contemplation in other men--those +"moments," as Coleridge says, addressing him-- + +Moments awful, +Now in thy inner life, and now abroad, +When power streamed from thee, and thy soul received +The light reflected, as a light bestowed. + +The entire poem from which these lines are taken, "composed on the +night after Wordsworth's recitation of a poem on the growth of an +individual mind," is, in its high-pitched strain of meditation, and +in the combined justice and elevation of its philosophical +expression-- + +high and passionate thoughts +To their own music chanted; + +wholly sympathetic with The Prelude which it celebrates, and of +which the subject is, in effect, the generation of the spirit of +the "Lake poetry." [90] The Lines to Joseph Cottle have the same +philosophically imaginative character; the Ode to Dejection being +Coleridge's most sustained effort of this kind. + +It is in a highly sensitive apprehension of the aspects of external +nature that Coleridge identifies himself most closely with one of the +main tendencies of the "Lake School"; a tendency instinctive, and no +mere matter of theory, in him as in Wordsworth. That record of the + +green light +Which lingers in the west, + +and again, of + +the western sky, +And its peculiar tint of yellow green, + +which Byron found ludicrously untrue, but which surely needs no +defence, is a characteristic example of a singular watchfulness for +the minute fact and expression of natural scenery pervading all he +wrote--a closeness to the exact physiognomy of nature, having +something to do with that idealistic philosophy which sees in the +external world no mere concurrence of mechanical agencies, but an +animated body, informed and made expressive, like the body of man, by +an indwelling intelligence. It was a tendency, doubtless, in the +air, for Shelley too is affected by it, and Turner, with the school +of landscape which followed him. "I had found," Coleridge tells us, + +[91] + +That outward forms, the loftiest, still receive +Their finer influence from the world within; +Fair ciphers of vague import, where the eye +Traces no spot, in which the heart may read +History and prophecy:... + +and this induces in him no indifference to actual colour and form and +process, but such minute realism as this-- + +The thin grey cloud is spread on high, +It covers but not hides the sky. +The moon is behind and at the full; +And yet she looks both small and dull; + +or this, which has a touch of "romantic" weirdness-- + +Nought was green upon the oak +But moss and rarest misletoe + +or this-- + +There is not wind enough to twirl +The one red leaf, the last of its clan, +That dances as often as dance it can, +Hanging so light, and hanging so high, +On the topmost twig that looks up at the sky + +or this, with a weirdness, again, like that of some wild French +etcher-- + +Lo! the new-moon winter-bright! +And overspread with phantom light +(With swimming phantom light o'erspread, +But rimmed and circled with a silver thread) +I see the old moon in her lap, foretelling +The coming on of rain and squally blast. + +He has a like imaginative apprehension of the silent and unseen +processes of nature, its "ministries" [92] of dew and frost, for +instance; as when he writes, in April-- + +A balmy night! and though the stars be dim, +Yet let us think upon the vernal showers +That gladden the green earth, and we shall find +A pleasure in the dimness of the stars. + +Of such imaginative treatment of landscape there is no better +instance than the description of The Dell, in Fears in Solitude-- + +A green and silent spot amid the hills, +A small and silent dell! O'er stiller place +No singing skylark ever poised himself-- +But the dell, +Bathed by the mist is fresh and delicate +As vernal cornfield, or the unripe flax +When, through its half-transparent stalks, at eve, +The level sunshine glimmers with green light:-- + +The gust that roared and died away +To the distant tree-- + +heard and only heard +In this low dell, bowed not the delicate grass. + +This curious insistence of the mind on one particular spot, till it +seems to attain actual expression and a sort of soul in it--a mood so +characteristic of the "Lake School"--occurs in an earnest political +poem, "written in April 1798, during the alarm of an invasion"; and +that silent dell is the background against which the tumultuous fears +of the poet are in strong relief, while the quiet sense of the place, +maintained all through them, gives a true poetic unity to the piece. +Good political poetry--[93] political poetry that shall be +permanently moving--can, perhaps, only be written on motives which, +for those they concern, have ceased to be open questions, and are +really beyond argument; while Coleridge's political poems are for the +most part on open questions. For although it was a great part of his +intellectual ambition to subject political questions to the action of +the fundamental ideas of his philosophy, he was nevertheless an +ardent partisan, first on one side, then on the other, of the actual +politics proper to the end of the last and the beginning of the +present century, where there is still room for much difference of +opinion. Yet The Destiny of Nations, though formless as a whole, and +unfinished, presents many traces of his most elevated manner of +speculation, cast into that sort of imaginative philosophical +expression, in which, in effect, the language itself is inseparable +from, or essentially a part of, the thought. France, an Ode, begins +with a famous apostrophe to Liberty-- + +Ye Clouds! that far above me float and pause, +Whose pathless march no mortal may control! +Ye Ocean-waves! that wheresoe'er ye roll, +Yield homage only to eternal laws! +Ye Woods! that listen to the night-bird's singing, +Midway the smooth and perilous slope reclined, +Save when your own imperious branches swinging, +Have made a solemn music of the wind! +Where like a man beloved of God, +Through glooms which never woodman trod, +How oft, pursuing fancies holy, + +[94] + +My moonlight way o'er flowering weeds I wound, +Inspired, beyond the guess of folly, +By each rude shape and wild unconquerable sound! +O ye loud Waves! and O ye Forests high! +And O ye Clouds that far above me soar'd! + +Thou rising Sun! thou blue rejoicing Sky! +Yea, everything that is and will be free! +Bear witness for me, wheresoe'er ye be, +With what deep worship I have still adored +The spirit of divinest liberty. + +And the whole ode, though, after Coleridge's way, not quite equal to +that exordium, is an example of strong national sentiment, partly in +indignant reaction against his own earlier sympathy with the French +Republic, inspiring a composition which, in spite of some turgid +lines, really justifies itself as poetry, and has that true unity of +effect which the ode requires. Liberty, after all his hopes of young +France, is only to be found in nature:-- + +Thou speedest on thy subtle pinions, +The guide of homeless winds, and playmate of the waves! + +In his changes of political sentiment, Coleridge was associated with +the "Lake School"; and there is yet one other very different sort of +sentiment in which he is one with that school, yet all himself, his +sympathy, namely, with the animal world. That was a sentiment +connected at once with the love of outward nature in himself and in +the "Lake School," and its assertion of the natural affections in +their simplicity; with the homeliness and pity, consequent upon [95] +that assertion. The Lines to a Young Ass, tethered-- + +Where the close-eaten grass is scarcely seen, +While sweet around her waves the tempting green, + +which had seemed merely whimsical in their day, indicate a vein of +interest constant in Coleridge's poems, and at its height in his +greatest poems--in Christabel, where it has its effect, as it were +antipathetically, in the vivid realisation of the serpentine element +in Geraldine's nature; and in The Ancient Mariner, whose fate is +interwoven with that of the wonderful bird, at whose blessing of the +water-snakes the curse for the death of the albatross passes away, +and where the moral of the love of all creatures, as a sort of +religious duty, is definitely expressed. + +Christabel, though not printed till 1816, was written mainly in the +year 1797: The Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner was printed as a +contribution to the Lyrical Ballads in 1798; and these two poems +belong to the great year of Coleridge's poetic production, his +twenty-fifth year. In poetic quality, above all in that most poetic +of all qualities, a keen sense of, and delight in beauty, the +infection of which lays hold upon the reader, they are quite out of +proportion to all his other compositions. The form in both is that +of the ballad, with some of its terminology, and some also of its +quaint conceits. They connect themselves with that revival of ballad +literature, of which Percy's Relics, and, in another [96] way, +Macpherson's Ossian are monuments, and which afterwards so powerfully +affected Scott-- + +Young-eyed poesy +All deftly masked as hoar antiquity. + +The Ancient Mariner, as also, in its measure, Christabel, is a +"romantic" poem, impressing us by bold invention, and appealing to +that taste for the supernatural, that longing for le frisson, a +shudder, to which the "romantic" school in Germany, and its +derivations in England and France, directly ministered. In +Coleridge, personally, this taste had been encouraged by his odd and +out-of-the-way reading in the old-fashioned literature of the +marvellous--books like Purchas's Pilgrims, early voyages like +Hakluyt's, old naturalists and visionary moralists, like Thomas +Burnet, from whom he quotes the motto of "The Ancient Mariner, Facile +credo, plures esse naturas invisibiles quam visibiles in rerum +universitate, etc." Fancies of the strange things which may very +well happen, even in broad daylight, to men shut up alone in ships +far off on the sea, seem to have occurred to the human mind in all +ages with a peculiar readiness, and often have about them, from the +story of the stealing of Dionysus downwards, the fascination of a +certain dreamy grace, which distinguishes them from other kinds of +marvellous inventions. This sort of fascination The Ancient Mariner +brings to its highest degree: it is the delicacy, the dreamy [97] +grace, in his presentation of the marvellous, which makes Coleridge's +work so remarkable. The too palpable intruders from a spiritual +world in almost all ghost literature, in Scott and Shakespeare even, +have a kind of crudity or coarseness. Coleridge's power is in the +very fineness with which, as by some really ghostly finger, he brings +home to our inmost sense his inventions, daring as they are--the +skeleton ship, the polar spirit, the inspiriting of the dead corpses +of the ship's crew. The Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner has the +plausibility, the perfect adaptation to reason and the general aspect +of life, which belongs to the marvellous, when actually presented as +part of a credible experience in our dreams. Doubtless, the mere +experience of the opium-eater, the habit he must almost necessarily +fall into of noting the more elusive phenomena of dreams, had +something to do with that: in its essence, however, it is connected +with a more purely intellectual circumstance in the development of +Coleridge's poetic gift. Some one once asked William Blake, to whom +Coleridge has many resemblances, when either is at his best (that +whole episode of the re-inspiriting of the ship's crew in The Ancient +Mariner being comparable to Blake's well-known design of the "Morning +Stars singing together") whether he had ever seen a ghost, and was +surprised when the famous seer, who ought, one might think, to have +seen so many, answered frankly, "Only [98] once!" His "spirits," at +once more delicate, and so much more real, than any ghost--the +burden, as they were the privilege, of his temperament--like it, were +an integral element in his everyday life. And the difference of mood +expressed in that question and its answer, is indicative of a change +of temper in regard to the supernatural which has passed over the +whole modern mind, and of which the true measure is the influence of +the writings of Swedenborg. What that change is we may see if we +compare the vision by which Swedenborg was "called," as he thought, +to his work, with the ghost which called Hamlet, or the spells of +Marlowe's Faust with those of Goethe's. The modern mind, so minutely +self-scrutinising, if it is to be affected at all by a sense of the +supernatural, needs to be more finely touched than was possible in +the older, romantic presentment of it. The spectral object, so +crude, so impossible, has become plausible, as + +The blot upon the brain, +That will show itself without; + +and is understood to be but a condition of one's own mind, for which, +according to the scepticism, latent at least, in so much of our +modern philosophy, the so-called real things themselves are but +spectra after all. + +It is this finer, more delicately marvellous supernaturalism, fruit +of his more delicate [99] psychology, that Coleridge infuses into +romantic adventure, itself also then a new or revived thing in +English literature; and with a fineness of weird effect in The +Ancient Mariner, unknown in those older, more simple, romantic +legends and ballads. It is a flower of medieval or later German +romance, growing up in the peculiarly compounded atmosphere of modern +psychological speculation, and putting forth in it wholly new +qualities. The quaint prose commentary, which runs side by side with +the verse of The Ancient Mariner, illustrates this--a composition of +quite a different shade of beauty and merit from that of the verse +which it accompanies, connecting this, the chief poem of Coleridge, +with his philosophy, and emphasising therein that psychological +interest of which I have spoken, its curious soul-lore. + +Completeness, the perfectly rounded wholeness and unity of the +impression it leaves on the mind of a reader who fairly gives himself +to it--that, too, is one of the characteristics of a really excellent +work, in the poetic as in every other kind of art; and by this +completeness, The Ancient Mariner certainly gains upon Christabel--a +completeness, entire as that of Wordsworth's Leech-gatherer, or +Keats's Saint Agnes' Eve, each typical in its way of such wholeness +or entirety of effect on a careful reader. It is Coleridge's one +great complete work, the one really finished thing, in a life of many +beginnings. Christabel remained a fragment. In The Ancient Mariner +[100] this unity is secured in part by the skill with which the +incidents of the marriage-feast are made to break in dreamily from +time to time upon the main story. And then, how pleasantly, how +reassuringly, the whole nightmare story itself is made to end, among +the clear fresh sounds and lights of the bay, where it began, with + +The moon-light steeped in silentness, +The steady weather-cock. + +So different from The Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner in regard to this +completeness of effect, Christabel illustrates the same complexion of +motives, a like intellectual situation. Here, too, the work is of a +kind peculiar to one who touches the characteristic motives of the +old romantic ballad, with a spirit made subtle and fine by modern +reflection; as we feel, I think, in such passages as-- + +But though my slumber had gone by, +This dream it would not pass away-- +It seems to live upon mine eye; + +and-- + +For she, belike, hath drunken deep +Of all the blessedness of sleep; + +and again-- + +With such perplexity of mind +As dreams too lively leave behind. + +And that gift of handling the finer passages of human feeling, at +once with power and delicacy, which was another result of his finer +psychology, [101] of his exquisitely refined habit of self- +reflection, is illustrated by a passage on Friendship in the Second +Part-- + +Alas! they had been friends in youth; +But whispering tongues can poison truth; +And constancy lives in realms above; +And life is thorny; and youth is vain; +And to be wroth with one we love, +Doth work like madness in the brain. +And thus it chanced, as I divine, +With Roland and Sir Leoline. +Each spake words of high disdain +And insult to his heart's best brother +They parted--ne'er to meet again! +But never either found another +To free the hollow heart from paining-- +They stood aloof the scars remaining, +Like cliffs which had been rent asunder; +A dreary sea now flows between; +But neither heat, nor frost, nor thunder, +Shall wholly do away, I ween, +The marks of that which once hath been. + +I suppose these lines leave almost every reader with a quickened +sense of the beauty and compass of human feeling; and it is the sense +of such richness and beauty which, in spite of his "dejection," in +spite of that burden of his morbid lassitude, accompanies Coleridge +himself through life. A warm poetic joy in everything beautiful, +whether it be a moral sentiment, like the friendship of Roland and +Leoline, or only the flakes of falling light from the water-snakes-- +this joy, visiting him, now and again, after sickly dreams, in sleep +or waking, as a relief not to be forgotten, [102] and with such a +power of felicitous expression that the infection of it passes +irresistibly to the reader--such is the predominant element in the +matter of his poetry, as cadence is the predominant quality of its +form. "We bless thee for our creation!" he might have said, in his +later period of definite religious assent, "because the world is so +beautiful: the world of ideas--living spirits, detached from the +divine nature itself, to inform and lift the heavy mass of material +things; the world of man, above all in his melodious and intelligible +speech; the world of living creatures and natural scenery; the world +of dreams." What he really did say, by way of A Tombless Epitaph, is +true enough of himself-- + +Sickness, 'tis true, +Whole years of weary days, besieged him close, +Even to the gates and inlets of his life! +But it is true, no less, that strenuous, firm, +And with a natural gladness, he maintained +The citadel unconquered, and in joy +Was strong to follow the delightful Muse. +For not a hidden path, that to the shades +Of the beloved Parnassian forest leads, +Lurked undiscovered by him; not a rill +There issues from the fount of Hippocrene, +But he had traced it upward to its source, +Through open glade, dark glen, and secret dell, +Knew the gay wild flowers on its banks, and culled +Its med'cinable herbs. Yea, oft alone, +Piercing the long-neglected holy cave, +The haunt obscure of old Philosophy, +He bade with lifted torch its starry walls +Sparkle, as erst they sparkled to the flame + +[103] + +Of odorous lamps tended by saint and sage. +O framed for calmer times and nobler hearts! +O studious Poet, eloquent for truth! +Philosopher! contemning wealth and death, +Yet docile, childlike, full of Life and Love. + +The student of empirical science asks, Are absolute principles +attainable? What are the limits of knowledge? The answer he +receives from science itself is not ambiguous. What the moralist +asks is, Shall we gain or lose by surrendering human life to the +relative spirit? Experience answers that the dominant tendency of +life is to turn ascertained truth into a dead letter, to make us all +the phlegmatic servants of routine. The relative spirit, by its +constant dwelling on the more fugitive conditions or circumstances of +things, breaking through a thousand rough and brutal classifications, +and giving elasticity to inflexible principles, begets an +intellectual finesse of which the ethical result is a delicate and +tender justice in the criticism of human life. Who would gain more +than Coleridge by criticism in such a spirit? We know how his life +has appeared when judged by absolute standards. We see him trying to +apprehend the "absolute," to stereotype forms of faith and +philosophy, to attain, as he says, "fixed principles" in politics, +morals, and religion, to fix one mode of life as the essence of life, +refusing to see the parts as parts only; and all the time his own +pathetic history pleads for a more [104] elastic moral philosophy +than his, and cries out against every formula less living and +flexible than life itself. + +"From his childhood he hungered for eternity." There, after all, is +the incontestable claim of Coleridge. The perfect flower of any +elementary type of life must always be precious to humanity, and +Coleridge is a true flower of the ennuyé, of the type of René. More +than Childe Harold, more than Werther, more than René himself, +Coleridge, by what he did, what he was, and what he failed to do, +represents that inexhaustible discontent, languor, and homesickness, +that endless regret, the chords of which ring all through our modern +literature. It is to the romantic element in literature that those +qualities belong. One day, perhaps, we may come to forget the +distant horizon, with full knowledge of the situation, to be content +with "what is here and now"; and herein is the essence of classical +feeling. But by us of the present moment, certainly--by us for whom +the Greek spirit, with its engaging naturalness, simple, chastened, +debonair, tryphês, habrotêtos, khlidês, kharitôn, himerou, pothou +patêr+, is itself the Sangrail of an endless pilgrimage, Coleridge, +with his passion for the absolute, for something fixed where all is +moving, his faintness, his broken memory, his intellectual disquiet, +may still be ranked among the interpreters of one of the constituent +elements of our life. + +1865, 1880. + +NOTES + +65. *The latter part of this paper, like that on Dante Gabriel +Rossetti, was contributed to Mr. T. H. Ward's English Poets. + +68. +Transliteration: ousia akhrômatos, askhêmatistos, anaphês. +Translation: "the colorless, utterly formless, intangible essence." +Phaedrus 247C. + +80. +The two passages are not indented in the original; they are in +smaller typeface that makes for difficult reading. + +86. +Transliteration: aei en sphodra orexei. Translation: "always +greatly yearning." + +104. +Transliteration: tryphês, habrotêtos, khlidês, kharitôn, +himerou, pothou patêr. Translation: "Of daintiness, delicacy, +luxury, graces, father of desire." + + + +CHARLES LAMB + +[105] THOSE English critics who at the beginning of the present +century introduced from Germany, together with some other subtleties +of thought transplanted hither not without advantage, the distinction +between the Fancy and the Imagination, made much also of the cognate +distinction between Wit and Humour, between that unreal and +transitory mirth, which is as the crackling of thorns under the pot, +and the laughter which blends with tears and even with the +sublimities of the imagination, and which, in its most exquisite +motives, is one with pity--the laughter of the comedies of +Shakespeare, hardly less expressive than his moods of seriousness or +solemnity, of that deeply stirred soul of sympathy in him, as flowing +from which both tears and laughter are alike genuine and contagious. + +This distinction between wit and humour, Coleridge and other kindred +critics applied, with much effect, in their studies of some of our +older English writers. And as the distinction between imagination +and fancy, made popular by Wordsworth, [106] found its best +justification in certain essential differences of stuff in +Wordsworth's own writings, so this other critical distinction, +between wit and humour, finds a sort of visible interpretation and +instance in the character and writings of Charles Lamb;--one who +lived more consistently than most writers among subtle literary +theories, and whose remains are still full of curious interest for +the student of literature as a fine art. + +The author of the English Humourists of the Eighteenth Century, +coming to the humourists of the nineteenth, would have found, as is +true preeminently of Thackeray himself, the springs of pity in them +deepened by the deeper subjectivity, the intenser and closer living +with itself, which is characteristic of the temper of the later +generation; and therewith, the mirth also, from the amalgam of which +with pity humour proceeds, has become, in Charles Dickens, for +example, freer and more boisterous. + +To this more high-pitched feeling, since predominant in our +literature, the writings of Charles Lamb, whose life occupies the +last quarter of the eighteenth century and the first quarter of the +nineteenth, are a transition; and such union of grave, of terrible +even, with gay, we may note in the circumstances of his life, as +reflected thence into his work. We catch the aroma of a singular, +homely sweetness about his first years, spent on Thames' side, amid +the red [107] bricks and terraced gardens, with their rich historical +memories of old-fashioned legal London. Just above the poorer class, +deprived, as he says, of the "sweet food of academic institution," he +is fortunate enough to be reared in the classical languages at an +ancient school, where he becomes the companion of Coleridge, as at a +later period he was his enthusiastic disciple. So far, the years go +by with less than the usual share of boyish difficulties; protected, +one fancies, seeing what he was afterwards, by some attraction of +temper in the quaint child, small and delicate, with a certain Jewish +expression in his clear, brown complexion, eyes not precisely of the +same colour, and a slow walk adding to the staidness of his figure; +and whose infirmity of speech, increased by agitation, is partly +engaging. + +And the cheerfulness of all this, of the mere aspect of Lamb's quiet +subsequent life also, might make the more superficial reader think of +him as in himself something slight, and of his mirth as cheaply +bought. Yet we know that beneath this blithe surface there was +something of the fateful domestic horror, of the beautiful heroism +and devotedness too, of old Greek tragedy. His sister Mary, ten +years his senior, in a sudden paroxysm of madness, caused the death +of her mother, and was brought to trial for what an overstrained +justice might have construed as the greatest of crimes. She was +[108] released on the brother's pledging himself to watch over her; +and to this sister, from the age of twenty-one, Charles Lamb +sacrificed himself, "seeking thenceforth," says his earliest +biographer, "no connexion which could interfere with her supremacy in +his affections, or impair his ability to sustain and comfort her." +The "feverish, romantic tie of love," he cast away in exchange for +the "charities of home." Only, from time to time, the madness +returned, affecting him too, once; and we see the brother and sister +voluntarily yielding to restraint. In estimating the humour of Elia, +we must no more forget the strong undercurrent of this great +misfortune and pity, than one could forget it in his actual story. +So he becomes the best critic, almost the discoverer, of Webster, a +dramatist of genius so sombre, so heavily coloured, so macabre. +Rosamund Grey, written in his twenty-third year, a story with +something bitter and exaggerated, an almost insane fixedness of gloom +perceptible in it, strikes clearly this note in his work. + +For himself, and from his own point of view, the exercise of his +gift, of his literary art, came to gild or sweeten a life of +monotonous labour, and seemed, as far as regarded others, no very +important thing; availing to give them a little pleasure, and inform +them a little, chiefly in a retrospective manner, but in no way +concerned with the turning of the tides of the great world. And yet +this very modesty, this unambitious [109] way of conceiving his work, +has impressed upon it a certain exceptional enduringness. For of the +remarkable English writers contemporary with Lamb, many were greatly +preoccupied with ideas of practice--religious, moral, political-- +ideas which have since, in some sense or other, entered permanently +into the general consciousness; and, these having no longer any +stimulus for a generation provided with a different stock of ideas, +the writings of those who spent so much of themselves in their +propagation have lost, with posterity, something of what they gained +by them in immediate influence. Coleridge, Wordsworth, Shelley even- +-sharing so largely in the unrest of their own age, and made +personally more interesting thereby, yet, of their actual work, +surrender more to the mere course of time than some of those who may +have seemed to exercise themselves hardly at all in great matters, to +have been little serious, or a little indifferent, regarding them. + +Of this number of the disinterested servants of literature, smaller +in England than in France, Charles Lamb is one. In the making of +prose he realises the principle of art for its own sake, as +completely as Keats in the making of verse. And, working ever close +to the concrete, to the details, great or small, of actual things, +books, persons, and with no part of them blurred to his vision by the +intervention of mere abstract theories, he has reached an enduring +moral effect [l10] also, in a sort of boundless sympathy. +Unoccupied, as he might seem, with great matters, he is in immediate +contact with what is real, especially in its caressing littleness, +that littleness in which there is much of the whole woeful heart of +things, and meets it more than half-way with a perfect understanding +of it. What sudden, unexpected touches of pathos in him!--bearing +witness how the sorrow of humanity, the Weltschmerz, the constant +aching of its wounds, is ever present with him: but what a gift also +for the enjoyment of life in its subtleties, of enjoyment actually +refined by the need of some thoughtful economies and making the most +of things! Little arts of happiness he is ready to teach to others. +The quaint remarks of children which another would scarcely have +heard, he preserves--little flies in the priceless amber of his Attic +wit--and has his "Praise of chimney-sweepers" (as William Blake has +written, with so much natural pathos, the Chimney-sweeper's Song) +valuing carefully their white teeth, and fine enjoyment of white +sheets in stolen sleep at Arundel Castle, as he tells the story, +anticipating something of the mood of our deep humourists of the last +generation. His simple mother-pity for those who suffer by accident, +or unkindness of nature, blindness for instance, or fateful disease +of mind like his sister's, has something primitive in its largeness; +and on behalf of ill-used animals he is early in composing a Pity's +Gift. + +[111] And if, in deeper or more superficial sense, the dead do care +at all for their name and fame, then how must the souls of +Shakespeare and Webster have been stirred, after so long converse +with things that stopped their ears, whether above or below the soil, +at his exquisite appreciations of them; the souls of Titian and of +Hogarth too; for, what has not been observed so generally as the +excellence of his literary criticism, Charles Lamb is a fine critic +of painting also. It was as loyal, self-forgetful work for others, +for Shakespeare's self first, for instance, and then for +Shakespeare's readers, that that too was done: he has the true +scholar's way of forgetting himself in his subject. For though +"defrauded," as we saw, in his young years, "of the sweet food of +academic institution," he is yet essentially a scholar, and all his +work mainly retrospective, as I said; his own sorrows, affections, +perceptions, being alone real to him of the present. "I cannot make +these present times," he says once, "present to me." + +Above all, he becomes not merely an expositor, permanently valuable, +but for Englishmen almost the discoverer of the old English drama. +"The book is such as I am glad there should be," he modestly says of +the Specimens of English Dramatic Poets who lived about the time of +Shakespeare; to which, however, he adds in a series of notes the very +quintessence of criticism, the choicest savour and perfume of +Elizabethan poetry being [112] sorted, and stored here, with a sort +of delicate intellectual epicureanism, which has had the effect of +winning for these, then almost forgotten, poets, one generation after +another of enthusiastic students. Could he but have known how fresh +a source of culture he was evoking there for other generations, +through all those years in which, a little wistfully, he would harp +on the limitation of his time by business, and sigh for a better +fortune in regard to literary opportunities! + +To feel strongly the charm of an old poet or moralist, the literary +charm of Burton, for instance, or Quarles, or The Duchess of +Newcastle; and then to interpret that charm, to convey it to others-- +he seeming to himself but to hand on to others, in mere humble +ministration, that of which for them he is really the creator--this +is the way of his criticism; cast off in a stray letter often, or +passing note, or lightest essay or conversation. It is in such a +letter, for instance, that we come upon a singularly penetrative +estimate of the genius and writings of Defoe. + +Tracking, with an attention always alert, the whole process of their +production to its starting-point in the deep places of the mind, he +seems to realise the but half-conscious intuitions of Hogarth or +Shakespeare, and develops the great ruling unities which have swayed +their actual work; or "puts up," and takes, the one morsel of good +stuff in an old, forgotten writer. Even [113] in what he says +casually there comes an aroma of old English; noticeable echoes, in +chance turn and phrase, of the great masters of style, the old +masters. Godwin, seeing in quotation a passage from John Woodvil, +takes it for a choice fragment of an old dramatist, and goes to Lamb +to assist him in finding the author. His power of delicate imitation +in prose and verse reaches the length of a fine mimicry even, as in +those last essays of Elia on Popular Fallacies, with their gentle +reproduction or caricature of Sir Thomas Browne, showing, the more +completely, his mastery, by disinterested study, of those elements of +the man which were the real source of style in that great, solemn +master of old English, who, ready to say what he has to say with +fearless homeliness, yet continually overawes one with touches of a +strange utterance from worlds afar. For it is with the delicacies of +fine literature especially, its gradations of expression, its fine +judgment, its pure sense of words, of vocabulary--things, alas! dying +out in the English literature of the present, together with the +appreciation of them in our literature of the past--that his literary +mission is chiefly concerned. And yet, delicate, refining, daintily +epicurean, as he may seem, when he writes of giants, such as Hogarth +or Shakespeare, though often but in a stray note, you catch the sense +of veneration with which those great names in past literature and art +brooded over his intelligence, his undiminished [114] impressibility +by the great effects in them. Reading, commenting on Shakespeare, he +is like a man who walks alone under a grand stormy sky, and among +unwonted tricks of light, when powerful spirits might seem to be +abroad upon the air; and the grim humour of Hogarth, as he analyses +it, rises into a kind of spectral grotesque; while he too knows the +secret of fine, significant touches like theirs. + +There are traits, customs, characteristics of houses and dress, +surviving morsels of old life, such as Hogarth has transferred so +vividly into The Rake's Progress, or Marriage à la Mode, concerning +which we well understand how, common, uninteresting, or even +worthless in themselves, they have come to please us at last as +things picturesque, being set in relief against the modes of our +different age. Customs, stiff to us, stiff dresses, stiff furniture- +-types of cast-off fashions, left by accident, and which no one ever +meant to preserve--we contemplate with more than good-nature, as +having in them the veritable accent of a time, not altogether to be +replaced by its more solemn and self-conscious deposits; like those +tricks of individuality which we find quite tolerable in persons, +because they convey to us the secret of lifelike expression, and with +regard to which we are all to some extent humourists. But it is part +of the privilege of the genuine humourist to anticipate this pensive +mood with regard to the ways and things [115] of his own day; to look +upon the tricks in manner of the life about him with that same +refined, purged sort of vision, which will come naturally to those of +a later generation, in observing whatever may have survived by chance +of its mere external habit. Seeing things always by the light of an +understanding more entire than is possible for ordinary minds, of the +whole mechanism of humanity, and seeing also the manner, the outward +mode or fashion, always in strict connexion with the spiritual +condition which determined it, a humourist such as Charles Lamb +anticipates the enchantment of distance; and the characteristics of +places, ranks, habits of life, are transfigured for him, even now and +in advance of time, by poetic light; justifying what some might +condemn as mere sentimentality, in the effort to hand on unbroken the +tradition of such fashion or accent. "The praise of beggars," "the +cries of London," the traits of actors just grown "old," the spots in +"town" where the country, its fresh green and fresh water, still +lingered on, one after another, amidst the bustle; the quaint, +dimmed, just played-out farces, he had relished so much, coming +partly through them to understand the earlier English theatre as a +thing once really alive; those fountains and sun-dials of old +gardens, of which he entertains such dainty discourse:--he feels the +poetry of these things, as the poetry of things old indeed, but +surviving [116] as an actual part of the life of the present; and as +something quite different from the poetry of things flatly gone from +us and antique, which come back to us, if at all, as entire +strangers, like Scott's old Scotch-border personages, their oaths and +armour. Such gift of appreciation depends, as I said, on the +habitual apprehension of men's life as a whole--its organic +wholeness, as extending even to the least things in it--of its +outward manner in connexion with its inward temper; and it involves a +fine perception of the congruities, the musical accordance between +humanity and its environment of custom, society, personal +intercourse; as if all this, with its meetings, partings, ceremonies, +gesture, tones of speech, were some delicate instrument on which an +expert performer is playing. + +These are some of the characteristics of Elia, one essentially an +essayist, and of the true family of Montaigne, "never judging," as he +says, "system-wise of things, but fastening on particulars;" saying +all things as it were on chance occasion only, and by way of pastime, +yet succeeding thus, "glimpse-wise," in catching and recording more +frequently than others "the gayest, happiest attitude of things;" a +casual writer for dreamy readers, yet always giving the reader so +much more than he seemed to propose. There is something of the +follower of George Fox about him, and the Quaker's belief in the +inward light coming to one passive, [117] to the mere wayfarer, who +will be sure at all events to lose no light which falls by the way-- +glimpses, suggestions, delightful half-apprehensions, profound +thoughts of old philosophers, hints of the innermost reason in +things, the full knowledge of which is held in reserve; all the +varied stuff, that is, of which genuine essays are made. + +And with him, as with Montaigne, the desire of self-portraiture is, +below all more superficial tendencies, the real motive in writing at +all--a desire closely connected with that intimacy, that modern +subjectivity, which may be called the Montaignesque element in +literature. What he designs is to give you himself, to acquaint you +with his likeness; but must do this, if at all, indirectly, being +indeed always more or less reserved, for himself and his friends; +friendship counting for so much in his life, that he is jealous of +anything that might jar or disturb it, even to the length of a sort +of insincerity, to which he assigns its quaint "praise"; this lover +of stage plays significantly welcoming a little touch of the +artificiality of play to sweeten the intercourse of actual life. + +And, in effect, a very delicate and expressive portrait of him does +put itself together for the duly meditative reader. In indirect +touches of his own work, scraps of faded old letters, what others +remembered of his talk, the man's likeness emerges; what he laughed +and wept at, [118] his sudden elevations, and longings after absent +friends, his fine casuistries of affection and devices to jog +sometimes, as he says, the lazy happiness of perfect love, his solemn +moments of higher discourse with the young, as they came across him +on occasion, and went along a little way with him, the sudden, +surprised apprehension of beauties in old literature, revealing anew +the deep soul of poetry in things, and withal the pure spirit of fun, +having its way again; laughter, that most short-lived of all things +(some of Shakespeare's even being grown hollow) wearing well with +him. Much of all this comes out through his letters, which may be +regarded as a department of his essays. He is an old-fashioned +letter-writer, the essence of the old fashion of letter-writing +lying, as with true essay-writing, in the dexterous availing oneself +of accident and circumstance, in the prosecution of deeper lines of +observation; although, just as with the record of his conversation, +one loses something, in losing the actual tones of the stammerer, +still graceful in his halting, as he halted also in composition, +composing slowly and by fits, "like a Flemish painter," as he tells +us, so "it is to be regretted," says the editor of his letters, "that +in the printed letters the reader will lose the curious varieties of +writing with which the originals abound, and which are scrupulously +adapted to the subject." + +Also, he was a true "collector," delighting [119] in the personal +finding of a thing, in the colour an old book or print gets for him +by the little accidents which attest previous ownership. Wither's +Emblems, "that old book and quaint," long-desired, when he finds it +at last, he values none the less because a child had coloured the +plates with his paints. A lover of household warmth everywhere, of +that tempered atmosphere which our various habitations get by men's +living within them, he "sticks to his favourite books as he did to +his friends," and loved the "town," with a jealous eye for all its +characteristics, "old houses" coming to have souls for him. The +yearning for mere warmth against him in another, makes him content, +all through life, with pure brotherliness, "the most kindly and +natural species of love," as he says, in place of the passion of +love. Brother and sister, sitting thus side by side, have, of +course, their anticipations how one of them must sit at last in the +faint sun alone, and set us speculating, as we read, as to precisely +what amount of melancholy really accompanied for him the approach of +old age, so steadily foreseen; make us note also, with pleasure, his +successive wakings up to cheerful realities, out of a too curious +musing over what is gone and what remains, of life. In his subtle +capacity for enjoying the more refined points of earth, of human +relationship, he could throw the gleam of poetry or humour on what +seemed common or threadbare; has a care for the [120] sighs, and the +weary, humdrum preoccupations of very weak people, down to their +little pathetic "gentilities," even; while, in the purely human +temper, he can write of death, almost like Shakespeare. + +And that care, through all his enthusiasm of discovery, for what is +accustomed, in literature, connected thus with his close clinging to +home and the earth, was congruous also with that love for the +accustomed in religion, which we may notice in him. He is one of the +last votaries of that old-world sentiment, based on the feelings of +hope and awe, which may be described as the religion of men of +letters (as Sir Thomas Browne has his Religion of the Physician) +religion as understood by the soberer men of letters in the last +century, Addison, Gray, and Johnson; by Jane Austen and Thackeray, +later. A high way of feeling developed largely by constant +intercourse with the great things of literature, and extended in its +turn to those matters greater still, this religion lives, in the main +retrospectively, in a system of received sentiments and beliefs; +received, like those great things of literature and art, in the first +instance, on the authority of a long tradition, in the course of +which they have linked themselves in a thousand complex ways to the +conditions of human life, and no more questioned now than the feeling +one keeps by one of the greatness--say! of Shakespeare. For Charles +Lamb, such form of religion becomes [121] the solemn background on +which the nearer and more exciting objects of his immediate +experience relieve themselves, borrowing from it an expression of +calm; its necessary atmosphere being indeed a profound quiet, that +quiet which has in it a kind of sacramental efficacy, working, we +might say, on the principle of the opus operatum, almost without any +co-operation of one's own, towards the assertion of the higher self. +And, in truth, to men of Lamb's delicately attuned temperament mere +physical stillness has its full value; such natures seeming to long +for it sometimes, as for no merely negative thing, with a sort of +mystical sensuality. + +The writings of Charles Lamb are an excellent illustration of the +value of reserve in literature. Below his quiet, his quaintness, his +humour, and what may seem the slightness, the occasional or +accidental character of his work, there lies, as I said at starting, +as in his life, a genuinely tragic element. The gloom, reflected at +its darkest in those hard shadows of Rosamund Grey, is always there, +though not always realised either for himself or his readers, and +restrained always in utterance. It gives to those lighter matters on +the surface of life and literature among which he for the most part +moved, a wonderful force of expression, as if at any moment these +slight words and fancies might pierce very far into the deeper soul +of things. In his writing, as in his [122] life, that quiet is not +the low-flying of one from the first drowsy by choice, and needing +the prick of some strong passion or worldly ambition, to stimulate +him into all the energy of which he is capable; but rather the +reaction of nature, after an escape from fate, dark and insane as in +old Greek tragedy, following upon which the sense of mere relief +becomes a kind of passion, as with one who, having narrowly escaped +earthquake or shipwreck, finds a thing for grateful tears in just +sitting quiet at home, under the wall, till the end of days. + +He felt the genius of places; and I sometimes think he resembles the +places he knew and liked best, and where his lot fell--London, sixty- +five years ago, with Covent Garden and the old theatres, and the +Temple gardens still unspoiled, Thames gliding down, and beyond to +north and south the fields at Enfield or Hampton, to which, "with +their living trees," the thoughts wander "from the hard wood of the +desk"--fields fresher, and coming nearer to town then, but in one of +which the present writer remembers, on a brooding early summer's day, +to have heard the cuckoo for the first time. Here, the surface of +things is certainly humdrum, the streets dingy, the green places, +where the child goes a-maying, tame enough. But nowhere are things +more apt to respond to the brighter weather, nowhere is there so much +difference between rain and sunshine, nowhere do the [123] clouds +roll together more grandly; those quaint suburban pastorals gathering +a certain quality of grandeur from the background of the great city, +with its weighty atmosphere, and portent of storm in the rapid light +on dome and bleached stone steeples. + +1878. + + + +SIR THOMAS BROWNE + +[124] ENGLISH prose literature towards the end of the seventeenth +century, in the hands of Dryden and Locke, was becoming, as that of +France had become at an earlier date, a matter of design and skilled +practice, highly conscious of itself as an art, and, above all, +correct. Up to that time it had been, on the whole, singularly +informal and unprofessional, and by no means the literature of the +"man of letters," as we understand him. Certain great instances +there had been of literary structure or architecture--The +Ecclesiastical Polity, The Leviathan--but for the most part that +earlier prose literature is eminently occasional, closely determined +by the eager practical aims of contemporary politics and theology, or +else due to a man's own native instinct to speak because he cannot +help speaking. Hardly aware of the habit, he likes talking to +himself; and when he writes (still in undress) he does but take the +"friendly reader" into his confidence. The type of this literature, +obviously, is not Locke or Gibbon, but, above all others, Sir Thomas +[125] Browne; as Jean Paul is a good instance of it in German +literature, always in its developments so much later than the +English; and as the best instance of it in French literature, in the +century preceding Browne, is Montaigne, from whom indeed, in a great +measure, all those tentative writers, or essayists, derive. + +It was a result, perhaps, of the individualism and liberty of +personal development, which, even for a Roman Catholic, were effects +of the Reformation, that there was so much in Montaigne of the +"subjective," as people say, of the singularities of personal +character. Browne, too, bookish as he really is claims to give his +readers a matter, "not picked from the leaves of any author, but bred +amongst the weeds and tares" of his own brain. The faults of such +literature are what we all recognise in it: unevenness, alike in +thought and style; lack of design; and caprice--the lack of +authority; after the full play of which, there is so much to refresh +one in the reasonable transparency of Hooker, representing thus early +the tradition of a classical clearness in English literature, +anticipated by Latimer and More, and to be fulfilled afterwards in +Butler and Hume. But then, in recompense for that looseness and +whim, in Sir Thomas Browne for instance, we have in those "quaint" +writers, as they themselves understood the term (coint, adorned, but +adorned with all the curious ornaments of their own predilection, +provincial [126] or archaic, certainly unfamiliar, and selected +without reference to the taste or usages of other people) the charm +of an absolute sincerity, with all the ingenuous and racy effect of +what is circumstantial and peculiar in their growth. + +The whole creation is a mystery and particularly that of man. +At the blast of His mouth were the rest of the creatures made, +and at His bare word they started out of nothing. But in the +frame of man He played the sensible operator, and seemed not +so much to create as to make him. When He had separated the +materials of other creatures, there consequently resulted a +form and soul: but having raised the walls of man, He was +driven to a second and harder creation--of a substance like +Himself, an incorruptible and immortal soul. + +There, we have the manner of Sir Thomas Browne, in exact expression +of his mind!--minute and curious in its thinking; but with an effect, +on the sudden, of a real sublimity or depth. His style is certainly +an unequal one. It has the monumental aim which charmed, and perhaps +influenced, Johnson--a dignity that can be attained only in such +mental calm as follows long and learned pondering on the high +subjects Browne loves to deal with. It has its garrulity, its +various levels of painstaking, its mannerism, pleasant of its kind or +tolerable, together with much, to us intolerable, but of which he was +capable on a lazy summer afternoon down at Norwich. And all is so +oddly mixed, showing, in its entire ignorance of self, how much he, +and the sort of literature he represents, really stood in need of +technique, [127] of a formed taste in literature, of a literary +architecture. + +And yet perhaps we could hardly wish the result different, in him, +any more than in the books of Burton and Fuller, or some other +similar writers of that age--mental abodes, we might liken, after +their own manner, to the little old private houses of some historic +town grouped about its grand public structures, which, when they have +survived at all, posterity is loth to part with. For, in their +absolute sincerity, not only do these authors clearly exhibit +themselves ("the unique peculiarity of the writer's mind," being, as +Johnson says of Browne, "faithfully reflected in the form and matter +of his work") but, even more than mere professionally instructed +writers, they belong to, and reflect, the age they lived in. In +essentials, of course, even Browne is by no means so unique among his +contemporaries, and so singular, as he looks. And then, as the very +condition of their work, there is an entire absence of personal +restraint in dealing with the public, whose humours they come at last +in a great measure to reproduce. To speak more properly, they have +no sense of a "public" to deal with, at all--only a full confidence +in the "friendly reader," as they love to call him. Hence their +amazing pleasantry, their indulgence in their own conceits; but hence +also those unpremeditated wildflowers of speech we should [128] never +have the good luck to find in any more formal kind of literature. + +It is, in truth, to the literary purpose of the humourist, in the +old-fashioned sense of the term, that this method of writing +naturally allies itself--of the humourist to whom all the world is +but a spectacle in which nothing is really alien from himself, who +has hardly a sense of the distinction between great and little among +things that are at all, and whose half-pitying, half-amused sympathy +is called out especially by the seemingly small interests and traits +of character in the things or the people around him. Certainly, in +an age stirred by great causes, like the age of Browne in England, of +Montaigne in France, that is not a type to which one would wish to +reduce all men of letters. Still, in an age apt also to become +severe, or even cruel (its eager interest in those great causes +turning sour on occasion) the character of the humourist may well +find its proper influence, through that serene power, and the leisure +it has for conceiving second thoughts, on the tendencies, conscious +or unconscious, of the fierce wills around it. Something of such a +humourist was Browne--not callous to men and their fortunes; +certainly not without opinions of his own about them; and yet, +undisturbed by the civil war, by the fall, and then the restoration, +of the monarchy, through that long quiet life (ending at last on the +day [129] himself had predicted, as if at the moment he had willed) +in which "all existence," as he says, "had been but food for +contemplation." + +Johnson, in beginning his Life of Browne, remarks that Browne "seems +to have had the fortune, common among men of letters, of raising +little curiosity after their private life." Whether or not, with the +example of Johnson himself before us, we can think just that, it is +certain that Browne's works are of a kind to directly stimulate +curiosity about himself--about himself, as being manifestly so large +a part of those works; and as a matter of fact we know a great deal +about his life, uneventful as in truth it was. To himself, indeed, +his life at Norwich, as he gives us to understand, seemed wonderful +enough. "Of these wonders," says Johnson, "the view that can now be +taken of his life offers no appearance." But "we carry with us," as +Browne writes, "the wonders we seek without us," and we may note on +the other hand, a circumstance which his daughter, Mrs. Lyttleton, +tells us of his childhood: "His father used to open his breast when +he was asleep, and kiss it in prayers over him, as 'tis said of +Origen's father, that the Holy Ghost would take possession there." +It was perhaps because the son inherited an aptitude for a like +profound kindling of sentiment in the taking of his life, that, +uneventful as it was, [130] commonplace as it seemed to Johnson, to +Browne himself it was so full of wonders, and so stimulates the +curiosity of his more careful reader of to-day. "What influence," +says Johnson again, "learning has had on its possessors may be +doubtful." Well! the influence of his great learning, of his +constant research on Browne, was its imaginative influence--that it +completed his outfit as a poetic visionary, stirring all the strange +"conceit" of his nature to its depths. + +Browne himself dwells, in connexion with the first publication +(extorted by circumstance) of the Religio Medici, on the natural +"inactivity of his disposition"; and he does, as I have said, pass +very quietly through an exciting time. Born in the year of the +Gunpowder Plot, he was not, in truth, one of those clear and +clarifying souls which, in an age alike of practical and mental +confusion, can anticipate and lay down the bases of reconstruction, +like Bacon or Hooker. His mind has much of the perplexity which was +part of the atmosphere of the time. Not that he is without his own +definite opinions on events. For him, Cromwell is a usurper, the +death of Charles an abominable murder. In spite of what is but an +affectation, perhaps, of the sceptical mood, he is a Churchman too; +one of those who entered fully into the Anglican position, so full of +sympathy with those ceremonies and observances [131] which "misguided +zeal terms superstition," that there were some Roman Catholics who +thought that nothing but custom and education kept him from their +communion. At the Restoration he rejoices to see the return of the +comely Anglican order in old episcopal Norwich, with its ancient +churches; the antiquity, in particular, of the English Church being, +characteristically, one of the things he most valued in it, +vindicating it, when occasion came, against the "unjust scandal" of +those who made that Church a creation of Henry the Eighth. As to +Romanists--he makes no scruple to "enter their churches in defect of +ours." He cannot laugh at, but rather pities, "the fruitless +journeys of pilgrims--for there is something in it of devotion." He +could never "hear the Ave Mary! bell without an oraison." At a +solemn procession he has "wept abundantly." How English, in truth, +all this really is! It reminds one how some of the most popular of +English writers, in many a half-conscious expression, have witnessed +to a susceptibility in the English mind itself, in spite of the +Reformation, to what is affecting in religious ceremony. Only, in +religion as in politics, Browne had no turn for disputes; was +suspicious of them, indeed; knowing, as he says with true acumen, +that "a man may be in as just possession of truth as of a city, and +yet be forced to surrender," even in controversies not [132] +necessarily maladroit--an image in which we may trace a little +contemporary colouring. + +The Enquiries into Vulgar Errors appeared in the year 1646; a year +which found him very hard on "the vulgar." His suspicion, in the +abstract, of what Bacon calls Idola Fori, the Idols of the Market- +place, takes a special emphasis from the course of events about him: +"being erroneous in their single numbers, once huddled together, they +will be error itself." And yet, congruously with a dreamy sweetness +of character we may find expressed in his very features, he seems not +greatly concerned at the temporary suppression of the institutions he +values so much. He seems to possess some inward Platonic reality of +them--church or monarchy--to hold by in idea, quite beyond the reach +of Roundhead or unworthy Cavalier. In the power of what is inward +and inviolable in his religion, he can still take note: "In my +solitary and retired imagination (neque enim cum porticus aut me +lectulus accepit, desum mihi) I remember I am not alone, and +therefore forget not to contemplate Him and His attributes who is +ever with me." + +His father, a merchant of London, with some claims to ancient +descent, left him early in possession of ample means. Educated at +Winchester and Oxford, he visited Ireland, France, and Italy; and in +the year 1633, at the age of twenty-eight, became Doctor of Medicine +at Leyden. Three years later he established himself as a physician +[133] at Norwich for the remainder of his life, having married a +lady, described as beautiful and attractive, and affectionate also, +as we may judge from her letters and postscripts to those of her +husband, in an orthography of a homeliness amazing even for that age. +Dorothy Browne bore him ten children, six of whom he survived. + +Their house at Norwich, even then an old one it would seem, must have +grown, through long years of acquisition, into an odd cabinet of +antiquities--antiquities properly so called; his old Roman, or +Romanised British urns, from Walsingham or Brampton, for instance, +and those natural objects which he studied somewhat in the temper of +a curiosity-hunter or antiquary. In one of the old churchyards of +Norwich he makes the first discovery of adipocere, of which grim +substance "a portion still remains with him." For his multifarious +experiments he must have had his laboratory. The old window- +stanchions had become magnetic, proving, as he thinks, that iron +"acquires verticity" from long lying in one position. Once we find +him re-tiling the place. It was then, perhaps, that he made the +observation that bricks and tiles also acquire "magnetic alliciency"- +-one's whole house, one might fancy; as indeed, he holds the earth +itself to be a vast lodestone. + +The very faults of his literary work, its desultoriness, the time it +costs his readers, that [134] slow Latinity which Johnson imitated +from him, those lengthy leisurely terminations which busy posterity +will abbreviate, all breathe of the long quiet of the place. Yet he +is by no means indolent. Besides wide book-learning, experimental +research at home, and indefatigable observation in the open air, he +prosecutes the ordinary duties of a physician; contrasting himself +indeed with other students, "whose quiet and unmolested doors afford +no such distractions." To most persons of mind sensitive as his, his +chosen studies would have seemed full of melancholy, turning always, +as they did, upon death and decay. It is well, perhaps, that life +should be something of a "meditation upon death": but to many, +certainly, Browne's would have seemed too like a lifelong following +of one's own funeral. A museum is seldom a cheerful place--oftenest +induces the feeling that nothing could ever have been young; and to +Browne the whole world is a museum; all the grace and beauty it has +being of a somewhat mortified kind. Only, for him (poetic dream, or +philosophic apprehension, it was this which never failed to evoke his +wonderful genius for exquisitely impassioned speech) over all those +ugly anatomical preparations, as though over miraculous saintly +relics, there was the perpetual flicker of a surviving spiritual +ardency, one day to reassert itself--stranger far than any fancied +odylic gravelights! + +[135] When Browne settled at Norwich, being then about thirty-six +years old, he had already completed the Religio Medici; a desultory +collection of observations designed for himself only and a few +friends, at all events with no purpose of immediate publication. It +had been lying by him for seven years, circulating privately in his +own extraordinarily perplexed manuscript, or in manuscript copies, +when, in 1642, an incorrect printed version from one of those copies, +"much corrupted by transcription at various hands," appeared +anonymously. Browne, decided royalist as he was in spite of seeming +indifference, connects this circumstance with the unscrupulous use of +the press for political purposes, and especially against the king, at +that time. Just here a romantic figure comes on the scene. Son of +the unfortunate young Everard Digby who perished on the scaffold for +some half-hearted participation in the Gunpowder Plot, Kenelm Digby, +brought up in the reformed religion, had returned in manhood to the +religion of his father. In his intellectual composition he had, in +common with Browne, a scientific interest, oddly tinged with both +poetry and scepticism: he had also a strong sympathy with religious +reaction, and a more than sentimental love for a seemingly vanishing +age of faith, which he, for one, would not think of as vanishing. A +copy of that surreptitious edition of the Religio Medici found him a +prisoner on suspicion of a too active [136] royalism, and with much +time on his hands. + +The Roman Catholic, although, secure in his definite orthodoxy, he +finds himself indifferent on many points (on the reality of +witchcraft, for instance) concerning which Browne's more timid, +personally grounded faith might indulge no scepticism, forced +himself, nevertheless, to detect a vein of rationalism in a book +which on the whole much attracted him, and hastily put forth his +"animadversions" upon it. Browne, with all his distaste for +controversy, thus found himself committed to a dispute, and his reply +came with the correct edition of the Religio Medici published at last +with his name. There have been many efforts to formulate the +"religion of the layman," which might be rightly understood, perhaps, +as something more than what is called "natural," yet less than +ecclesiastical, or "professional" religion. Though its habitual mode +of conceiving experience is on a different plane, yet it would +recognise the legitimacy of the traditional religious interpretation +of that experience, generally and by implication; only, with a marked +reserve as to religious particulars, both of thought and language, +out of a real reverence or awe, as proper only for a special place. +Such is the lay religion, as we may find it in Addison, in Gray, in +Thackeray; and there is something of a concession--a concession, on +second thoughts--about it. Browne's Religio Medici is designed as +the expression of a mind [137] more difficult of belief than that of +the mere "layman," as above described; it is meant for the religion +of the man of science. Actually, it is something less to the point, +in any balancing of the religious against the worldly view of things, +than the religion of the layman, as just now defined. For Browne, in +spite of his profession of boisterous doubt, has no real +difficulties, and his religion, certainly, nothing of the character +of a concession. He holds that there has never existed an atheist. +Not that he is credulous; but that his religion is only the +correlative of himself, his peculiar character and education, a +religion of manifold association. For him, the wonders of religion, +its supernatural events or agencies, are almost natural facts or +processes. "Even in this material fabric, the spirits walk as freely +exempt from the affection of time, place and motion, as beyond the +extremest circumference." Had not Divine interference designed to +raise the dead, nature herself is in act to do it--to lead out the +"incinerated soul" from the retreats of her dark laboratory. +Certainly Browne has not, like Pascal, made the "great resolution," +by the apprehension that it is just in the contrast of the moral +world to the world with which science deals that religion finds its +proper basis. It is from the homelessness of the world which science +analyses so victoriously, its dark unspirituality, wherein the soul +he is conscious of seems such a [138] stranger, that Pascal "turns +again to his rest," in the conception of a world of wholly reasonable +and moral agencies. For Browne, on the contrary, the light is full, +design everywhere obvious, its conclusion easy to draw, all small and +great things marked clearly with the signature of the "Word." The +adhesion, the difficult adhesion, of men such as Pascal, is an +immense contribution to religious controversy; the concession, again, +of a man like Addison, of great significance there. But in the +adhesion of Browne, in spite of his crusade against "vulgar errors," +there is no real significance. The Religio Medici is a contribution, +not to faith, but to piety; a refinement and correction, such as +piety often stands in need of; a help, not so much to religious +belief in a world of doubt, as to the maintenance of the religious +mood amid the interests of a secular calling. + +From about this time Browne's letters afford a pretty clear view of +his life as it passed in the house at Norwich. Many of these letters +represent him in correspondence with the singular men who shared his +own half poetic, half scientific turn of mind, with that +impressibility towards what one might call the thaumaturgic elements +in nature which has often made men dupes, and which is certainly an +element in the somewhat atrabiliar mental complexion of that age in +England. He corresponds seriously with William Lily, the astrologer; +is acquainted [139] with Dr. Dee, who had some connexion with +Norwich, and has "often heard him affirm, sometimes with oaths, that +he had seen transmutation of pewter dishes and flagons into silver +(at least) which the goldsmiths at Prague bought of him." Browne is +certainly an honest investigator; but it is still with a faint hope +of something like that upon fitting occasion, and on the alert always +for surprises in nature (as if nature had a rhetoric, at times, to +deliver to us, like those sudden and surprising flowers of his own +poetic style) that he listens to her everyday talk so attentively. +Of strange animals, strange cures, and the like, his correspondence +is full. The very errors he combats are, of course, the curiosities +of error--those fascinating, irresistible, popular, errors, which +various kinds of people have insisted on gliding into because they +like them. Even his heresies were old ones--the very fossils of +capricious opinion. + +It is as an industrious local naturalist that Browne comes before us +first, full of the fantastic minute life in the fens and "Broads" +around Norwich, its various sea and marsh birds. He is something of +a vivisectionist also, and we may not be surprised at it, perhaps, in +an age which, for the propagation of truth, was ready to cut off +men's ears. He finds one day "a Scarabaus capricornus odoratus," +which he takes "to be mentioned by Monfetus, folio 150. He saith, +'Nucem moschatam et cinnamomum vere spirat'--[140] but to me it smelt +like roses, santalum, and ambergris." "Musca tuliparum moschata," +again, "is a small bee-like fly of an excellent fragrant odour, which +I have often found at the bottom of the flowers of tulips." Is this +within the experience of modern entomologists? + +The Garden of Cyrus, though it ends indeed with a passage of +wonderful felicity, certainly emphasises (to say the least) the +defects of Browne's literary good qualities. His chimeric fancy +carries him here into a kind of frivolousness, as if he felt almost +too safe with his public, and were himself not quite serious, or +dealing fairly with it; and in a writer such as Browne levity must of +necessity be a little ponderous. Still, like one of those stiff +gardens, half-way between the medieval garden and the true "English" +garden of Temple or Walpole, actually to be seen in the background of +some of the conventional portraits of that day, the fantasies of this +indescribable exposition of the mysteries of the quincunx form part +of the complete portrait of Browne himself; and it is in connexion +with it that, once or twice, the quaintly delightful pen of Evelyn +comes into the correspondence--in connexion with the "hortulane +pleasure." "Norwich," he writes to Browne, "is a place, I +understand, much addicted to the flowery part." Professing himself a +believer in the operation "of the air and genius of gardens upon +human spirits, towards virtue and sanctity," he is all for [141] +natural gardens as against "those which appear like gardens of paste- +board and march-pane, and smell more of paint than of flowers and +verdure." Browne is in communication also with Ashmole and Dugdale, +the famous antiquaries; to the latter of whom, who had written a work +on the history of the embanking of fens, he communicates the +discovery of certain coins, on a piece of ground "in the nature of an +island in the fens." + +Far more interesting certainly than those curious scientific letters +is Browne's "domestic correspondence." Dobson, Charles the First's +"English Tintoret," would seem to have painted a life-sized picture +of Sir Thomas Browne and his family, after the manner of those big, +urbane, family groups, then coming into fashion with the Dutch +Masters. Of such a portrait nothing is now known. But in these old- +fashioned, affectionate letters, transmitted often, in those +troublous times, with so much difficulty, we have what is almost as +graphic--a numerous group, in which, although so many of Browne's +children died young, he was happy; with Dorothy Browne, occasionally +adding her charming, ill-spelt postscripts to her husband's letters; +the religious daughter who goes to daily prayers after the +Restoration, which brought Browne the honour of knighthood; and, +above all, two Toms, son and grandson of Sir Thomas, the latter being +the son of Dr. Edward Browne, [142] now become distinguished as a +physician in London (he attended John, Earl of Rochester, in his last +illness at Woodstock) and his childish existence as he lives away +from his proper home in London, in the old house at Norwich, two +hundred years ago, we see like a thing of to-day. + +At first the two brothers, Edward and Thomas (the elder) are together +in everything. Then Edward goes abroad for his studies, and Thomas, +quite early, into the navy, where he certainly develops into a +wonderfully gallant figure; passing away, however, from the +correspondence, it is uncertain how, before he was of full age. From +the first he is understood to be a lad of parts. "If you practise to +write, you will have a good pen and style:" and a delightful, boyish +journal of his remains, describing a tour the two brothers made in +September 1662 among the Derbyshire hills. "I received your two last +letters," he writes to his father from aboard the Marie Rose, "and +give you many thanks for the discourse you sent me out of Vossius: De +motu marium et ventorum. It seemed very hard to me at first; but I +have now beaten it, and I wish I had the book." His father is +pleased to think that he is "like to proceed not only a good +navigator, but a good scholar": and he finds the much exacting, old +classical prescription for the character of the brave man fulfilled +in him. On 16th July 1666 the young man writes--still from the Marie +Rose-- + +[143] If it were possible to get an opportunity to send as often +as I am desirous to write, you should hear more often from me, +being now so near the grand action, from which I would by no means +be absent. I extremely long for that thundering day: wherein I +hope you shall hear we have behaved ourselves like men, and to +the honour of our country. I thank you for your directions for +my ears against the noise of the guns, but I have found that I +could endure it; nor is it so intolerable as most conceive; +especially when men are earnest, and intent upon their business, +unto whom muskets sound but like pop-guns. It is impossible +to express unto another how a smart sea-fight elevates the spirits +of a man, and makes him despise all dangers. In and after all +sea-fights, I have been very thirsty. + +He died, as I said, early in life. We only hear of him later in +connexion with a trait of character observed in Tom the grandson, +whose winning ways, and tricks of bodily and mental growth, are duly +recorded in these letters: the reader will, I hope, pardon the +following extracts from them:-- + +Little Tom is lively.... Frank is fayne sometimes to play him +asleep with a fiddle. When we send away our letters he scribbles +a paper and will have it sent to his sister, and saith she doth +not know how many fine things there are in Norwich.... He +delights his grandfather when he comes home. + +Tom gives you many thanks for his clothes (from London). He +has appeared very fine this King's day with them. + +Tom presents his duty. A gentleman at our election asked Tom +who hee was for? and he answered, "For all four." The gentleman +replied that he answered like a physician's son. + +Tom would have his grandmother, his aunt Betty, and Frank, +valentines: but hee conditioned with them that they should give +him nothing of any kind that hee had ever had or seen before. + +[144] "Tom is just now gone to see two bears which are to be +shown." "Tom, his duty. He is begging books and reading of +them." "The players are at the Red Lion hard by; and Tom goes +sometimes to see a play." + +And then one day he stirs old memories-- + +The fairings were welcome to Tom. He finds about the house +divers things that were your brother's (the late Edward's), +and Betty sometimes tells him stories about him, so that he +was importunate with her to write his life in a quarter of +a sheet of paper, and read it unto him, and will have still +more added. + +Just as I am writing (learnedly about a comet, 7th January +1680-81) Tom comes and tells me the blazing star is in the +yard, and calls me to see it. It was but dim, and the sky +not clear.... I am very sensible of this sharp weather.+ + +He seems to have come to no good end, riding forth one stormy night. +Requiescat in pace! + +Of this long, leisurely existence the chief events were Browne's rare +literary publications; some of his writings indeed having been left +unprinted till after his death; while in the circumstances of the +issue of every one of them there is something accidental, as if the +world might have missed it altogether. Even the Discourse of Vulgar +Errors, the longest and most elaborate of his works, is entirely +discursive and occasional, coming to an end with no natural +conclusion, but only because the writer chose to leave off just +there; and few probably have been the readers of the book as a +consecutive whole. At times indeed we seem to have in it observations +only, or notes, preliminary to some more orderly composition. Dip +into it: read, for [145] instance, the chapter "Of the Ring-finger," +or the chapters "Of the Long Life of the Deer," and on the "Pictures +of Mermaids, Unicorns, and some Others," and the part will certainly +seem more than the whole. Try to read it through, and you will soon +feel cloyed;--miss very likely, its real worth to the fancy, the +literary fancy (which finds its pleasure in inventive word and +phrase) and become dull to the really vivid beauties of a book so +lengthy, but with no real evolution. Though there are words, +phrases, constructions innumerable, which remind one how much the +work initiated in France by Madame de Rambouillet--work, done for +England, we may think perhaps imperfectly, in the next century by +Johnson and others--was really needed; yet the capacities of Browne's +manner of writing, coming as it did so directly from the man, are +felt even in his treatment of matters of science. As with Buffon, +his full, ardent, sympathetic vocabulary, the poetry of his language, +a poetry inherent in its elementary particles--the word, the epithet- +-helps to keep his eye, and the eye of the reader, on the object +before it, and conduces directly to the purpose of the naturalist, +the observer. But, only one half observation, its other half +consisting of very out-of-the-way book-lore, this work displays +Browne still in the character of the antiquary, as that age +understood him. He is a kind of Elias Ashmole, but dealing with +natural objects; which are for him, in the first [146] place, and +apart from the remote religious hints and intimations they carry with +them, curiosities. He seems to have no true sense of natural law, as +Bacon understood it; nor even of that immanent reason in the natural +world, which the Platonic tradition supposes. "Things are really +true," he says, "as they correspond unto God's conception; and have +so much verity as they hold of conformity unto that intellect, in +whose idea they had their first determinations." But, actually, what +he is busy in the record of, are matters more or less of the nature +of caprices; as if things, after all, were significant of their +higher verity only at random, and in a sort of surprises, like music +in old instruments suddenly touched into sound by a wandering finger, +among the lumber of people's houses. Nature, "the art of God," as he +says, varying a little a phrase used also by Hobbes, in a work +printed later--Nature, he seems to protest, is only a little less +magical, its processes only a little less in the way of alchemy, than +you had supposed. We feel that, as with that disturbed age in +England generally (and it is here that he, with it, is so +interesting, curious, old-world, and unlike ourselves) his supposed +experience might at any moment be broken in upon by a hundred forms +of a natural magic, only not quite so marvellous as that older sort +of magic, or alchemy, he is at so much pains to expose; and the large +promises of which, its large words too, he still regretfully enjoys. + +[147] And yet the Discourse of Vulgar Errors, seeming, as it often +does, to be a serious refutation of fairy tales--arguing, for +instance, against the literal truth of the poetic statement that "The +pigeon hath no gall," and such questions as "Whether men weigh +heavier dead than alive?" being characteristic questions--is +designed, with much ambition, under its pedantic Greek title +Pseudodoxia Epidemica, as a criticism, a cathartic, an instrument for +the clarifying of the intellect. He begins from "that first error in +Paradise," wondering much at "man's deceivability in his +perfection,"--"at such gross deceit." He enters in this connexion, +with a kind of poetry of scholasticism which may interest the student +of Paradise Lost, into what we may call the intellectual and moral +by-play of the situation of the first man and woman in Paradise, with +strange queries about it. Did Adam, for instance, already know of +the fall of the Angels? Did he really believe in death, till Abel +died? It is from Julius Scaliger that he takes his motto, to the +effect that the true knowledge of things must be had from things +themselves, not from books; and he seems as seriously concerned as +Bacon to dissipate the crude impressions of a false "common sense," +of false science, and a fictitious authority. Inverting, oddly, +Plato's theory that all learning is but reminiscence, he reflects +with a sigh how much of oblivion must needs be involved in the +getting of any true knowledge. "Men that [148] adore times past, +consider not that those times were once present (that is, as our own +are) and ourselves unto those to come, as they unto us at present." +That, surely, coming from one both by temperament and habit so great +an antiquary, has the touch of something like an influence in the +atmosphere of the time. That there was any actual connexion between +Browne's work and Bacon's is but a surmise. Yet we almost seem to +hear Bacon when Browne discourses on the "use of doubts, and the +advantages which might be derived from drawing up a calendar of +doubts, falsehoods, and popular errors;" and, as from Bacon, one gets +the impression that men really have been very much the prisoners of +their own crude or pedantic terms, notions, associations; that they +have been very indolent in testing very simple matters--with a +wonderful kind of "supinity," as he calls it. In Browne's chapter on +the "Sources of Error," again, we may trace much resemblance to +Bacon's striking doctrine of the Idola, the "shams" men fall down and +worship. Taking source respectively, from the "common infirmity of +human nature," from the "erroneous disposition of the people," from +"confident adherence to authority," the errors which Browne chooses +to deal with may be registered as identical with Bacon's Idola +Tribus, Fori, Theatri; the idols of our common human nature; of the +vulgar, when they get together; and of the learned, when they get +together. + +[149] But of the fourth species of error noted by Bacon, the Idola +Specus, the Idols of the Cave, that whole tribe of illusions, which +are "bred amongst the weeds and tares of one's own brain," Browne +tells us nothing by way of criticism; was himself, rather, a lively +example of their operation. Throw those illusions, those "idols," +into concrete or personal form, suppose them introduced among the +other forces of an active intellect, and you have Sir Thomas Browne +himself. The sceptical inquirer who rises from his cathartic, his +purging of error, a believer in the supernatural character of pagan +oracles, and a cruel judge of supposed witches, must still need as +much as ever that elementary conception of the right method and the +just limitations of knowledge, by power of which he should not just +strain out a single error here or there, but make a final precipitate +of fallacy. + +And yet if the temperament had been deducted from Browne's work--that +inherent and strongly marked way of deciding things, which has guided +with so surprising effect the musings of the Letter to a Friend, and +the Urn-Burial--we should probably have remembered him little. Pity! +some may think, for himself at least, that he had not lived earlier, +and still believed in the mandrake, for instance; its fondness for +places of execution, and its human cries "on eradication, with hazard +of life to them that pull it up." "In philosophy," he observes, +meaning to contrast [150] his free-thinking in that department with +his orthodoxy in religion--in philosophy, "where truth seems double- +faced, there is no man more paradoxical than myself:" which is true, +we may think, in a further sense than he meant, and that it was the +"paradoxical" that he actually preferred. Happy, at all events, he +still remained--undisturbed and happy--in a hundred native +prepossessions, some certainly valueless, some of them perhaps +invaluable. And while one feels that no real logic of fallacies has +been achieved by him, one feels still more how little the +construction of that branch of logical inquiry really helps men's +minds; fallacy, like truth itself, being a matter so dependent on +innate gift of apprehension, so extra-logical and personal; the +original perception counting for almost everything, the mere +inference for so little! Yes! "A man may be in as just possession +of truth as of a city, and yet be forced to surrender," even in +controversies not necessarily maladroit. + +The really stirring poetry of science is not in guesses, or facile +divinations about it, but in its larger ascertained truths--the order +of infinite space, the slow method and vast results of infinite time. +For Browne, however, the sense of poetry which so overmasters his +scientific procedure, depends chiefly on its vaguer possibilities; +the empirical philosophy, even after Bacon, being still dominated by +a temper, resultant from the general unsettlement of men's [151] +minds at the Reformation, which may be summed up in the famous +question of Montaigne--Que sçais-je? The cold-blooded method of +observation and experiment was creeping but slowly over the domain of +science; and such unreclaimed portions of it as the phenomena of +magnetism had an immense fascination for men like Browne and Digby. +Here, in those parts of natural philosophy "but yet in discovery," +"the America and untravelled parts of truth," lay for them the true +prospect of science, like the new world itself to a geographical +discoverer such as Raleigh. And welcome as one of the minute hints +of that country far ahead of them, the strange bird, or floating +fragment of unfamiliar vegetation, which met those early navigators, +there was a certain fantastic experiment, in which, as was alleged, +Paracelsus had been lucky. For Browne and others it became the +crucial type of the kind of agency in nature which, as they +conceived, it was the proper function of science to reveal in larger +operation. "The subject of my last letter," says Dr. Henry Power, +then a student, writing to Browne in 1648, the last year of Charles +the First, "being so high and noble a piece of chemistry, invites me +once more to request an experimental eviction of it from yourself; +and I hope you will not chide my importunity in this petition, or be +angry at my so frequent knockings at your door to obtain a grant of +so great and admirable a [152] mystery." What the enthusiastic young +student expected from Browne, so high and noble a piece of chemistry, +was the "re-individualling of an incinerated plant"--a violet, +turning to freshness, and smelling sweet again, out of its ashes, +under some genially fitted conditions of the chemic art. + +Palingenesis, resurrection, effected by orderly prescription--the +"re-individualling" of an "incinerated organism"--is a subject which +affords us a natural transition to the little book of the +Hydriotaphia, or Treatise of Urn-Burial--about fifty or sixty pages-- +which, together with a very singular letter not printed till after +Browne's death, is perhaps, after all, the best justification of +Browne's literary reputation, as it were his own curiously figured +urn, and treasure-place of immortal memory. + +In its first presentation to the public this letter was connected +with Browne's Christian Morals; but its proper and sympathetic +collocation would be rather with the Urn-Burial, of which it is a +kind of prelude, or strikes the keynote. He is writing in a very +complex situation--to a friend, upon occasion of the death of a +common friend. The deceased apparently had been little known to +Browne himself till his recent visits, while the intimate friend to +whom he is writing had been absent at the time; and the leading +motive of Browne's letter is the deep impression he has received +during those visits, of a sort of [153] physical beauty in the coming +of death, with which he still surprises and moves his reader. There +had been, in this case, a tardiness and reluctancy in the +circumstances of dissolution, which had permitted him, in the +character of a physician, as it were to assist at the spiritualising +of the bodily frame by natural process; a wonderful new type of a +kind of mortified grace being evolved by the way. The spiritual body +had anticipated the formal moment of death; the alert soul, in that +tardy decay, changing its vesture gradually, and as if piece by +piece. The infinite future had invaded this life perceptibly to the +senses, like the ocean felt far inland up a tidal river. Nowhere, +perhaps, is the attitude of questioning awe on the threshold of +another life displayed with the expressiveness of this unique morsel +of literature; though there is something of the same kind, in another +than the literary medium, in the delicate monumental sculpture of the +early Tuscan School, as also in many of the designs of William Blake, +often, though unconsciously, much in sympathy with those +unsophisticated Italian workmen. With him, as with them, and with +the writer of the Letter to a Friend upon the occasion of the death +of his intimate Friend,--so strangely! the visible function of death +is but to refine, to detach from aught that is vulgar. And this +elfin letter, really an impromptu epistle to a friend, affords the +best possible light on the general temper of the man [154] who could +be moved by the accidental discovery of those old urns at Walsingham- +-funeral relics of "Romans, or Britons Romanised which had learned +Roman customs"--to the composition of that wonderful book the +Hydriotaphia. He had drawn up a short account of the circumstance at +the moment; but it was after ten years' brooding that he put forth +the finished treatise, dedicated to an eminent collector of ancient +coins and other rarities, with congratulations that he "can daily +command the view of so many imperial faces," and (by way of +frontispiece) with one of the urns, "drawn with a coal taken out of +it and found among the burnt bones." The discovery had resuscitated +for him a whole world of latent observation, from life, from out-of- +the-way reading, from the natural world, and fused into a +composition, which with all its quaintness we may well pronounce +classical, all the heterogeneous elements of that singular mind. The +desire to "record these risen ashes and not to let them be buried +twice among us," had set free, in his manner of conceiving things, +something not wholly analysable, something that may be properly +called genius, which shapes his use of common words to stronger and +deeper senses, in a way unusual in prose writing. Let the reader, +for instance, trace his peculiarly sensitive use of the epithets thin +and dark, both here and in the Letter to a Friend. + +Upon what a grand note he can begin and end [155] chapter or +paragraph! "When the funeral pyre was out, and the last valediction +over:" "And a large part of the earth is still in the urn unto us." +Dealing with a very vague range of feelings, it is his skill to +associate them to very definite objects. Like the Soul, in Blake's +design, "exploring the recesses of the tomb," he carries a light, the +light of the poetic faith which he cannot put off him, into those +dark places, "the abode of worms and pismires," peering round with a +boundless curiosity and no fear; noting the various casuistical +considerations of men's last form of self-love; all those whims of +humanity as a "student of perpetuity," the mortuary customs of all +nations, which, from their very closeness to our human nature, arouse +in most minds only a strong feeling of distaste. There is something +congruous with the impassive piety of the man in his waiting on +accident from without to take start for the work, which, of all his +work, is most truly touched by the "divine spark." Delightsome as +its eloquence is actually found to be, that eloquence is attained out +of a certain difficulty and halting crabbedness of expression; the +wretched punctuation of the piece being not the only cause of its +impressing the reader with the notion that he is but dealing with a +collection of notes for a more finished composition, and of a +different kind; perhaps a purely erudite treatise on its subject, +with detachment of all personal colour now adhering [156] to it. Out +of an atmosphere of all-pervading oddity and quaintness--the +quaintness of mind which reflects that this disclosing of the urns of +the ancients hath "left unto our view some parts which they never +beheld themselves"--arises a work really ample and grand, nay! +classical, as I said, by virtue of the effectiveness with which it +fixes a type in literature; as, indeed, at its best, romantic +literature (and Browne is genuinely romantic) in every period attains +classical quality, giving true measure of the very limited value of +those well-worn critical distinctions. And though the Urn-Burial +certainly has much of the character of a poem, yet one is never +allowed to forget that it was designed, candidly, as a scientific +treatise on one department of ancient "culture" (as much so as +Guichard's curious old French book on Divers Manners of Burial) and +was the fruit of much labour, in the way especially of industrious +selection from remote and difficult writers; there being then few or +no handbooks, or anything like our modern shortcuts to varied +knowledge. Quite unaffectedly, a curious learning saturates, with a +kind of grey and aged colour most apt and congruous with the subject- +matter, all the thoughts that arise in him. His great store of +reading, so freely displayed, he uses almost as poetically as Milton; +like him, profiting often by the mere sonorous effect of some heroic +or ancient name, which he can adapt to that same sort of learned +sweetness of [157] cadence with which so many of his single sentences +are made to fall upon the ear. + +Pope Gregory, that great religious poet, requested by certain eminent +persons to send them some of those relics he sought for so devoutly +in all the lurking-places of old Rome, took up, it is said, a portion +of common earth, and delivered it to the messengers; and, on their +expressing surprise at such a gift, pressed the earth together in his +hand, whereupon the sacred blood of the Martyrs was beheld flowing +out between his fingers. The veneration of relics became a part of +Christian (as some may think it a part of natural) religion. All +over Rome we may count how much devotion in fine art is owing to it; +and, through all ugliness or superstition, its intention still speaks +clearly to serious minds. The poor dead bones, ghastly and +forbidding:--we know what Shakespeare would have felt about them.-- +"Beat not the bones of the buried: when he breathed, he was a man!" +And it is with something of a similar feeling that Browne is full, on +the common and general ground of humanity; an awe-stricken sympathy +with those, whose bones "lie at the mercies of the living," strong +enough to unite all his various chords of feeling into a single +strain of impressive and genuine poetry. His real interest is in +what may be called the curiosities of our common humanity. As +another might be moved at the sight of Alexander's bones, or Saint +Edmund's, or Saint Cecilia's, [158] so he is full of a fine poetical +excitement at such lowly relics as the earth hides almost everywhere +beneath our feet. But it is hardly fair to take our leave amid these +grievous images of so happy a writer as Sir Thomas Browne; so great a +lover of the open air, under which much of his life was passed. His +work, late one night, draws to a natural close:--"To keep our eyes +open longer," he bethinks himself suddenly, "were but to act our +Antipodes. The huntsmen are up in America! " + +What a fund of open-air cheerfulness, there! in turning to sleep. +Still, even when we are dealing with a writer in whom mere style +counts for so much as with Browne, it is impossible to ignore his +matter; and it is with religion he is really occupied from first to +last, hardly less than Richard Hooker. And his religion, too, after +all, was a religion of cheerfulness: he has no great consciousness of +evil in things, and is no fighter. His religion, if one may say so, +was all profit to him; among other ways, in securing an absolute +staidness and placidity of temper, for the intellectual work which +was the proper business of his life. His contributions to +"evidence," in the Religio Medici, for instance, hardly tell, because +he writes out of view of a really philosophical criticism. What does +tell in him, in this direction, is the witness he brings to men's +instinct of survival--the "intimations of immortality," as Wordsworth +terms them, which [159] were natural with him in surprising force. +As was said of Jean Paul, his special subject was the immortality of +the soul; with an assurance as personal, as fresh and original, as it +was, on the one hand, in those old half-civilised people who had +deposited the urns; on the other hand, in the cynical French poet of +the nineteenth century, who did not think, but knew, that his soul +was imperishable. He lived in an age in which that philosophy made a +great stride which ends with Hume; and his lesson, if we may be +pardoned for taking away a "lesson" from so ethical a writer, is the +force of men's temperaments in the management of opinion, their own +or that of others;--that it is not merely different degrees of bare +intellectual power which cause men to approach in different degrees +to this or that intellectual programme. Could he have foreseen the +mature result of that mechanical analysis which Bacon had applied to +nature, and Hobbes to the mind of man, there is no reason to think +that he would have surrendered his own chosen hypothesis concerning +them. He represents, in an age, the intellectual powers of which +tend strongly to agnosticism, that class of minds to which the +supernatural view of things is still credible. The non-mechanical +theory of nature has had its grave adherents since: to the non- +mechanical theory of man--that he is in contact with a moral order on +a different plane from the [160] mechanical order--thousands, of the +most various types and degrees of intellectual power, always adhere; +a fact worth the consideration of all ingenuous thinkers, if (as is +certainly the case with colour, music, number, for instance) there +may be whole regions of fact, the recognition of which belongs to one +and not to another, which people may possess in various degrees; for +the knowledge of which, therefore, one person is dependent upon +another; and in relation to which the appropriate means of cognition +must lie among the elements of what we call individual temperament, +so that what looks like a pre-judgment may be really a legitimate +apprehension. "Men are what they are," and are not wholly at the +mercy of formal conclusions from their formally limited premises. +Browne passes his whole life in observation and inquiry: he is a +genuine investigator, with every opportunity: the mind of the age all +around him seems passively yielding to an almost foregone +intellectual result, to a philosophy of disillusion. But he thinks +all that a prejudice; and not from any want of intellectual power +certainly, but from some inward consideration, some afterthought, +from the antecedent gravitation of his own general character--or, +will you say? from that unprecipitated infusion of fallacy in him--he +fails to draw, unlike almost all the rest of the world, the +conclusion ready to hand. + +1886. + +NOTES + +144. +In the original, this quotation, like several above it, is not +indented; it is in smaller type. Return. + + + +"LOVE'S LABOURS LOST" + +[161] Love's Labours Lost is one of the earliest of Shakespeare's +dramas, and has many of the peculiarities of his poems, which are +also the work of his earlier life. The opening speech of the king on +the immortality of fame--on the triumph of fame over death--and the +nobler parts of Biron, display something of the monumental style of +Shakespeare's Sonnets, and are not without their concerts of thought +and expression. This connexion of Love's Labours Lost with +Shakespeare's poems is further enforced by the actual insertion in it +of three sonnets and a faultless song; which, in accordance with his +practice in other plays, are inwoven into the argument of the piece +and, like the golden ornaments of a fair woman, give it a peculiar +air of distinction. There is merriment in it also, with choice +illustrations of both wit and humour; a laughter, often exquisite, +ringing, if faintly, yet as genuine laughter still, though sometimes +sinking into mere burlesque, which has not lasted quite so well. And +Shakespeare [162] brings a serious effect out of the trifling of his +characters. A dainty love-making is interchanged with the more +cumbrous play: below the many artifices of Biron's amorous speeches +we may trace sometimes the "unutterable longing;" and the lines in +which Katherine describes the blighting through love of her younger +sister are one of the most touching things in older literature.* +Again, how many echoes seem awakened by those strange words, actually +said in jest! "The sweet war-man (Hector of Troy) is dead and +rotten; sweet chucks, beat not the bones of the buried: when he +breathed, he was a man!"--words which may remind us of Shakespeare's +own epitaph. In the last scene, an ingenious turn is given to the +action, so that the piece does not conclude after the manner of other +comedies.-- + +Our wooing doth not end like an old play; +Jack hath not Jill: + +and Shakespeare strikes a passionate note across it at last, in the +entrance of the messenger, who announces to the princess that the +king her father is suddenly dead. + +The merely dramatic interest of the piece is slight enough; only just +sufficient, indeed, to form the vehicle of its wit and poetry. The +scene--a park of the King of Navarre--is unaltered throughout; and +the unity of the [163] play is not so much the unity of a drama as +that of a series of pictorial groups, in which the same figures +reappear, in different combinations but on the same background. It +is as if Shakespeare had intended to bind together, by some inventive +conceit, the devices of an ancient tapestry, and give voices to its +figures. On one side, a fair palace; on the other, the tents of the +Princess of France, who has come on an embassy from her father to the +King of Navarre; in the midst, a wide space of smooth grass. + +The same personages are combined over and over again into a series of +gallant scenes--the princess, the three masked ladies, the quaint, +pedantic king; one of those amiable kings men have never loved +enough, whose serious occupation with the things of the mind seems, +by contrast with the more usual forms of kingship, like frivolity or +play. Some of the figures are grotesque merely, and all the male +ones at least, a little fantastic. Certain objects reappearing from +scene to scene--love-letters crammed with verses to the margin, and +lovers' toys--hint obscurely at some story of intrigue. Between +these groups, on a smaller scale, come the slighter and more homely +episodes, with Sir Nathaniel the curate, the country-maid Jaquenetta, +Moth or Mote the elfin-page, with Hiems and Ver, who recite "the +dialogue that the two learned men have compiled in praise of the owl +and the cuckoo." The ladies are [164] lodged in tents, because the +king, like the princess of the modern poet's fancy, has taken a vow + +to make his court a little Academe, + +and for three years' space no woman may come within a mile of it; and +the play shows how this artificial attempt was broken through. For +the king and his three fellow-scholars are of course soon forsworn, +and turn to writing sonnets, each to his chosen lady. These fellow- +scholars of the king--"quaint votaries of science" at first, +afterwards "affection's men-at-arms"--three youthful knights, +gallant, amorous, chivalrous, but also a little affected, sporting +always a curious foppery of language, are, throughout, the leading +figures in the foreground; one of them, in particular, being more +carefully depicted than the others, and in himself very noticeable--a +portrait with somewhat puzzling manner and expression, which at once +catches the eye irresistibly and keeps it fixed. + +Play is often that about which people are most serious; and the +humourist may observe how, under all love of playthings, there is +almost always hidden an appreciation of something really engaging and +delightful. This is true always of the toys of children: it is often +true of the playthings of grown-up people, their vanities, their +fopperies even, their lighter loves; the cynic would add their +pursuit of fame. Certainly, this is true without exception [165] of +the playthings of a past age, which to those who succeed it are +always full of a pensive interest--old manners, old dresses, old +houses. For what is called fashion in these matters occupies, in each +age, much of the care of many of the most discerning people, +furnishing them with a kind of mirror of their real inward +refinements, and their capacity for selection. Such modes or +fashions are, at their best, an example of the artistic predominance +of form over matter; of the manner of the doing of it over the thing +done; and have a beauty of their own. It is so with that old +euphuism of the Elizabethan age--that pride of dainty language and +curious expression, which it is very easy to ridicule, which often +made itself ridiculous, but which had below it a real sense of +fitness and nicety; and which, as we see in this very play, and still +more clearly in the Sonnets, had some fascination for the young +Shakespeare himself. It is this foppery of delicate language, this +fashionable plaything of his time, with which Shakespeare is occupied +in Love's Labours Lost. He shows us the manner in all its stages; +passing from the grotesque and vulgar pedantry of Holofernes, through +the extravagant but polished caricature of Armado, to become the +peculiar characteristic of a real though still quaint poetry in Biron +himself, who is still chargeable even at his best with just a little +affectation. As Shakespeare laughs broadly at it in Holofernes or +Armado, so he [166] is the analyst of its curious charm in Biron; and +this analysis involves a delicate raillery by Shakespeare himself at +his own chosen manner. + +This "foppery" of Shakespeare's day had, then, its really delightful +side, a quality in no sense "affected," by which it satisfies a real +instinct in our minds--the fancy so many of us have for an exquisite +and curious skill in the use of words. Biron is the perfect flower +of this manner: + +A man of fire-new words, fashion's own knight: + +--as he describes Armado, in terms which are really applicable to +himself. In him this manner blends with a true gallantry of nature, +and an affectionate complaisance and grace. He has at times some of +its extravagance or caricature also, but the shades of expression by +which he passes from this to the "golden cadence" of Shakespeare's +own most characteristic verse, are so fine, that it is sometimes +difficult to trace them. What is a vulgarity in Holofernes, and a +caricature in Armado, refines itself with him into the expression of +a nature truly and inwardly bent upon a form of delicate perfection, +and is accompanied by a real insight into the laws which determine +what is exquisite in language, and their root in the nature of +things. He can appreciate quite the opposite style-- + +In russet yeas, and honest kersey noes; + +he knows the first law of pathos, that + +Honest plain words best suit the ear of grief. + +[167] He delights in his own rapidity of intuition; and, in harmony +with the half-sensuous philosophy of the Sonnets, exalts, a little +scornfully, in many memorable expressions, the judgment of the +senses, above all slower, more toilsome means of knowledge, scorning +some who fail to see things only because they are so clear: + +So here you find where light in darkness lies, +Your light grows dark by losing of your eyes:-- + +as with some German commentators on Shakespeare. Appealing always to +actual sensation from men's affected theories, he might seem to +despise learning; as, indeed, he has taken up his deep studies partly +in sport, and demands always the profit of learning in renewed +enjoyment. Yet he surprises us from time to time by intuitions which +could come only from a deep experience and power of observation; and +men listen to him, old and young, in spite of themselves. He is +quickly impressible to the slightest clouding of the spirits in +social intercourse, and has his moments of extreme seriousness: his +trial-task may well be, as Rosaline puts it-- + +To enforce the pained impotent to smile. + +But still, through all, he is true to his chosen manner: that gloss +of dainty language is a second nature with him: even at his best he +is not without a certain artifice: the trick of playing on words +never deserts him; and [168] Shakespeare, in whose own genius there +is an element of this very quality, shows us in this graceful, and, +as it seems, studied, portrait, his enjoyment of it. + +As happens with every true dramatist, Shakespeare is for the most +part hidden behind the persons of his creation. Yet there are +certain of his characters in which we feel that there is something of +self-portraiture. And it is not so much in his grander, more subtle +and ingenious creations that we feel this--in Hamlet and King Lear-- +as in those slighter and more spontaneously developed figures, who, +while far from playing principal parts, are yet distinguished by a +peculiar happiness and delicate ease in the drawing of them; figures +which possess, above all, that winning attractiveness which there is +no man but would willingly exercise, and which resemble those works +of art which, though not meant to be very great or imposing, are yet +wrought of the choicest material. Mercutio, in Romeo and Juliet, +belongs to this group of Shakespeare's characters--versatile, +mercurial people, such as make good actors, and in whom the + +nimble spirits of the arteries, + +the finer but still merely animal elements of great wit, predominate. +A careful delineation of minor, yet expressive traits seems to mark +them out as the characters of his predilection; [169] and it is hard +not to identify him with these more than with others. Biron, in +Love's Labours Lost, is perhaps the most striking member of this +group. In this character, which is never quite in touch, never quite +on a perfect level of understanding, with the other persons of the +play, we see, perhaps, a reflex of Shakespeare himself, when he has +just become able to stand aside from and estimate the first period of +his poetry. + +1878. + +NOTES + +162. *Act V. Scene II. Return. + + + +"MEASURE FOR MEASURE" + +[170] IN Measure for Measure, as in some other of his plays, +Shakespeare has remodelled an earlier and somewhat rough composition +to "finer issues," suffering much to remain as it had come from the +less skilful hand, and not raising the whole of his work to an equal +degree of intensity. Hence perhaps some of that depth and +weightiness which make this play so impressive, as with the true seal +of experience, like a fragment of life itself, rough and disjointed +indeed, but forced to yield in places its profounder meaning. In +Measure for Measure, in contrast with the flawless execution of Romeo +and Juliet, Shakespeare has spent his art in just enough modification +of the scheme of the older play to make it exponent of this purpose, +adapting its terrible essential incidents, so that Coleridge found it +the only painful work among Shakespeare's dramas, and leaving for the +reader of to-day more than the usual number of difficult expressions; +but infusing a lavish colour and a profound significance into it, so +that under his [171] touch certain select portions of it rise far +above the level of all but his own best poetry, and working out of it +a morality so characteristic that the play might well pass for the +central expression of his moral judgments. It remains a comedy, as +indeed is congruous with the bland, half-humorous equity which +informs the whole composition, sinking from the heights of sorrow and +terror into the rough scheme of the earlier piece; yet it is hardly +less full of what is really tragic in man's existence than if Claudio +had indeed "stooped to death." Even the humorous concluding scenes +have traits of special grace, retaining in less emphatic passages a +stray lire or word of power, as it seems, so that we watch to the end +for the traces where the nobler hand has glanced along, leaving its +vestiges, as if accidentally or wastefully, in the rising of the +style. + +The interest of Measure for Measure, therefore, is partly that of an +old story told over again. We measure with curiosity that variety of +resources which has enabled Shakespeare to refashion the original +material with a higher motive; adding to the intricacy of the piece, +yet so modifying its structure as to give the whole almost the unity +of a single scene; lending, by the light of a philosophy which dwells +much on what is complex and subtle in our nature, a true human +propriety to its strange and unexpected turns of feeling and +character, to incidents so [172] difficult as the fall of Angelo, and +the subsequent reconciliation of Isabella, so that she pleads +successfully for his life. It was from Whetstone, a contemporary +English writer, that Shakespeare derived the outline of Cinthio's +"rare history" of Promos and Cassandra, one of that numerous class of +Italian stories, like Boccaccio's Tancred of Salerno, in which the +mere energy of southern passion has everything its own way, and +which, though they may repel many a northern reader by a certain +crudity in their colouring, seem to have been full of fascination for +the Elizabethan age. This story, as it appears in Whetstone's +endless comedy, is almost as rough as the roughest episode of actual +criminal life. But the play seems never to have been acted, and some +time after its publication Whetstone himself turned the thing into a +tale, included in his Heptameron of Civil Discourses, where it still +figures as a genuine piece, with touches of undesigned poetry, a +quaint field-flower here and there of diction or sentiment, the whole +strung up to an effective brevity, and with the fragrance of that +admirable age of literature all about it. Here, then, there is +something of the original Italian colour: in this narrative +Shakespeare may well have caught the first glimpse of a composition +with nobler proportions; and some artless sketch from his own hand, +perhaps, putting together his first impressions, insinuated itself +between Whetstone's work and the play as we actually read it. Out +[173] of these insignificant sources Shakespeare's play rises, full +of solemn expression, and with a profoundly designed beauty, the new +body of a higher, though sometimes remote and difficult poetry, +escaping from the imperfect relics of the old story, yet not wholly +transformed, and even as it stands but the preparation only, we might +think, of a still more imposing design. For once we have in it a +real example of that sort of writing which is sometimes described as +suggestive, and which by the help of certain subtly calculated hints +only, brings into distinct shape the reader's own half-developed +imaginings. Often the quality is attributed to writing merely vague +and unrealised, but in Measure for Measure, quite certainly, +Shakespeare has directed the attention of sympathetic readers along +certain channels of meditation beyond the immediate scope of his +work. + +Measure for Measure, therefore, by the quality of these higher +designs, woven by his strange magic on a texture of poorer quality, +is hardly less indicative than Hamlet even, of Shakespeare's reason, +of his power of moral interpretation. It deals, not like Hamlet with +the problems which beset one of exceptional temperament, but with +mere human nature. It brings before us a group of persons, +attractive, full of desire, vessels of the genial, seed-bearing +powers of nature, a gaudy existence flowering out over the old court +and city of Vienna, a spectacle of the fulness and [174] pride of +life which to some may seem to touch the verge of wantonness. Behind +this group of people, behind their various action, Shakespeare +inspires in us the sense of a strong tyranny of nature and +circumstance. Then what shall there be on this side of it--on our +side, the spectators' side, of this painted screen, with its puppets +who are really glad or sorry all the time? what philosophy of life, +what sort of equity? + +Stimulated to read more carefully by Shakespeare's own profounder +touches, the reader will note the vivid reality, the subtle +interchange of light and shade, the strongly contrasted characters of +this group of persons, passing across the stage so quickly. The +slightest of them is at least not ill-natured: the meanest of them +can put forth a plea for existence--Truly, sir, I am a poor fellow +that would live!--they are never sure of themselves, even in the +strong tower of a cold unimpressible nature: they are capable of many +friendships and of a true dignity in danger, giving each other a +sympathetic, if transitory, regret--one sorry that another "should be +foolishly lost at a game of tick-tack." Words which seem to exhaust +man's deepest sentiment concerning death and life are put on the lips +of a gilded, witless youth; and the saintly Isabella feels fire creep +along her, kindling her tongue to eloquence at the suggestion of +shame. In places the shadow deepens: death intrudes itself on the +scene, as among other [175] things "a great disguiser," blanching the +features of youth and spoiling its goodly hair, touching the fine +Claudio even with its disgraceful associations. As in Orcagna's +fresco at Pisa, it comes capriciously, giving many and long reprieves +to Barnardine, who has been waiting for it nine years in prison, +taking another thence by fever, another by mistake of judgment, +embracing others in the midst of their music and song. The little +mirror of existence, which reflects to each for a moment the stage on +which he plays, is broken at last by a capricious accident; while all +alike, in their yearning for untasted enjoyment, are really +discounting their days, grasping so hastily and accepting so +inexactly the precious pieces. The Duke's quaint but excellent +moralising at the beginning of the third act does but express, like +the chorus of a Greek play, the spirit of the passing incidents. To +him in Shakespeare's play, to a few here and there in the actual +world, this strange practical paradox of our life, so unwise in its +eager haste, reveals itself in all its clearness. + +The Duke disguised as a friar, with his curious moralising on life +and death, and Isabella in her first mood of renunciation, a thing +"ensky'd and sainted," come with the quiet of the cloister as a +relief to this lust and pride of life: like some grey monastic +picture hung on the wall of a gaudy room, their presence cools the +heated air of the piece. For a moment we [176] are within the placid +conventual walls, whither they fancy at first that the Duke has come +as a man crossed in love, with Friar Thomas and Friar Peter, calling +each other by their homely, English names, or at the nunnery among +the novices, with their little limited privileges, where + +If you speak you must not show your face, +Or if you show your face you must not speak. + +Not less precious for this relief in the general structure of the +piece, than for its own peculiar graces is the episode of Mariana, a +creature wholly of Shakespeare's invention, told, by way of +interlude, in subdued prose. The moated grange, with its dejected +mistress, its long, listless, discontented days, where we hear only +the voice of a boy broken off suddenly in the midst of one of the +loveliest songs of Shakespeare, or of Shakespeare's school,* is the +pleasantest of many glimpses we get here of pleasant places--the +field without the town, Angelo's garden-house, the consecrated +fountain. Indirectly it has suggested two of the most perfect +compositions among the poetry of our own generation. Again it is a +picture within a picture, but with fainter lines and a greyer +atmosphere: we have here the same passions, the same wrongs, the same +continuance of affection, the same crying out upon death, as in the +nearer and larger piece, though softened, and reduced to the mood of +a more dreamy scene. + +[177] Of Angelo we may feel at first sight inclined to say only +guarda e passa! or to ask whether he is indeed psychologically +possible. In the old story, he figures as an embodiment of pure and +unmodified evil, like "Hyliogabalus of Rome or Denis of Sicyll." But +the embodiment of pure evil is no proper subject of art, and +Shakespeare, in the spirit of a philosophy which dwells much on the +complications of outward circumstance with men's inclinations, turns +into a subtle study in casuistry this incident of the austere judge +fallen suddenly into utmost corruption by a momentary contact with +supreme purity. But the main interest in Measure for Measure is not, +as in Promos and Cassandra, in the relation of Isabella and Angelo, +but rather in the relation of Claudio and Isabella. + +Greek tragedy in some of its noblest products has taken for its theme +the love of a sister, a sentiment unimpassioned indeed, purifying by +the very spectacle of its passionlessness, but capable of a fierce +and almost animal strength if informed for a moment by pity and +regret. At first Isabella comes upon the scene as a tranquillising +influence in it. But Shakespeare, in the development of the action, +brings quite different and unexpected qualities out of her. It is +his characteristic poetry to expose this cold, chastened personality, +respected even by the worldly Lucio as "something ensky'd and +sainted, and almost an immortal spirit," to two [178] sharp, shameful +trials, and wring out of her a fiery, revealing eloquence. Thrown +into the terrible dilemma of the piece, called upon to sacrifice that +cloistral whiteness to sisterly affection, become in a moment the +ground of strong, contending passions, she develops a new character +and shows herself suddenly of kindred with those strangely conceived +women, like Webster's Vittoria, who unite to a seductive sweetness +something of a dangerous and tigerlike changefulness of feeling. The +swift, vindictive anger leaps, like a white flame, into this white +spirit, and, stripped in a moment of all convention, she stands +before us clear, detached, columnar, among the tender frailties of +the piece. Cassandra, the original of Isabella in Whetstone's tale, +with the purpose of the Roman Lucretia in her mind, yields gracefully +enough to the conditions of her brother's safety; and to the lighter +reader of Shakespeare there may seem something harshly conceived, or +psychologically impossible even, in the suddenness of the change +wrought in her, as Claudio welcomes for a moment the chance of life +through her compliance with Angelo's will, and he may have a sense +here of flagging skill, as in words less finely handled than in the +preceding scene. The play, though still not without traces of nobler +handiwork, sinks down, as we know, at last into almost homely comedy, +and it might be supposed that just here the grander manner [179] +deserted it. But the skill with which Isabella plays upon Claudio's +well-recognised sense of honour, and endeavours by means of that to +insure him beforehand from the acceptance of life on baser terms, +indicates no coming laxity of hand just in this place. It was rather +that there rose in Shakespeare's conception, as there may for the +reader, as there certainly would in any good acting of the part, +something of that terror, the seeking for which is one of the notes +of romanticism in Shakespeare and his circle. The stream of ardent +natural affection, poured as sudden hatred upon the youth condemned +to die, adds an additional note of expression to the horror of the +prison where so much of the scene takes place. It is not here only +that Shakespeare has conceived of such extreme anger and pity as +putting a sort of genius into simple women, so that their "lips drop +eloquence," and their intuitions interpret that which is often too +hard or fine for manlier reason; and it is Isabella with her grand +imaginative diction, and that poetry laid upon the "prone and +speechless dialect" there is in mere youth itself, who gives +utterance to the equity, the finer judgments of the piece on men and +things. + +From behind this group with its subtle lights and shades, its poetry, +its impressive contrasts, Shakespeare, as I said, conveys to us a +strong sense of the tyranny of nature and [180] circumstance over +human action. The most powerful expressions of this side of +experience might be found here. The bloodless, impassible +temperament does but wait for its opportunity, for the almost +accidental coherence of time with place, and place with wishing, to +annul its long and patient discipline, and become in a moment the +very opposite of that which under ordinary conditions it seemed to +be, even to itself. The mere resolute self-assertion of the blood +brings to others special temptations, temptations which, as defects +or over-growths, lie in the very qualities which make them otherwise +imposing or attractive; the very advantage of men's gifts of +intellect or sentiment being dependent on a balance in their use so +delicate that men hardly maintain it always. Something also must be +conceded to influences merely physical, to the complexion of the +heavens, the skyey influences, shifting as the stars shift; as +something also to the mere caprice of men exercised over each other +in the dispensations of social or political order, to the chance +which makes the life or death of Claudio dependent on Angelo's will. + +The many veins of thought which render the poetry of this play so +weighty and impressive unite in the image of Claudio, a flowerlike +young man, whom, prompted by a few hints from Shakespeare, the +imagination easily clothes with all the bravery of youth, as he +crosses the stage before us on his way to death, coming so [181] +hastily to the end of his pilgrimage. Set in the horrible blackness +of the prison, with its various forms of unsightly death, this flower +seems the braver. Fallen by "prompture of the blood," the victim of +a suddenly revived law against the common fault of youth like his, he +finds his life forfeited as if by the chance of a lottery. With that +instinctive clinging to life, which breaks through the subtlest +casuistries of monk or sage apologising for an early death, he +welcomes for a moment the chance of life through his sister's shame, +though he revolts hardly less from the notion of perpetual +imprisonment so repulsive to the buoyant energy of youth. +Familiarised, by the words alike of friends and the indifferent, to +the thought of death, he becomes gentle and subdued indeed, yet more +perhaps through pride than real resignation, and would go down to +darkness at last hard and unblinded. Called upon suddenly to +encounter his fate, looking with keen and resolute profile straight +before him, he gives utterance to some of the central truths of human +feeling, the sincere, concentrated expression of the recoiling flesh. +Thoughts as profound and poetical as Hamlet's arise in him; and but +for the accidental arrest of sentence he would descend into the dust, +a mere gilded, idle flower of youth indeed, but with what are perhaps +the most eloquent of all Shakespeare's words upon his lips. + +As Shakespeare in Measure for Measure has [182] refashioned, after a +nobler pattern, materials already at hand, so that the relics of +other men's poetry are incorporated into his perfect work, so traces +of the old "morality," that early form of dramatic composition which +had for its function the inculcating of some moral theme, survive in +it also, and give it a peculiar ethical interest. This ethical +interest, though it can escape no attentive reader, yet, in +accordance with that artistic law which demands the predominance of +form everywhere over the mere matter or subject handled, is not to be +wholly separated from the special circumstances, necessities, +embarrassments, of these particular dramatic persons. The old +"moralities" exemplified most often some rough-and-ready lesson. +Here the very intricacy and subtlety of the moral world itself, the +difficulty of seizing the true relations of so complex a material, +the difficulty of just judgment, of judgment that shall not be +unjust, are the lessons conveyed. Even in Whetstone's old story this +peculiar vein of moralising comes to the surface: even there, we +notice the tendency to dwell on mixed motives, the contending issues +of action, the presence of virtues and vices alike in unexpected +places, on "the hard choice of two evils," on the "imprisoning" of +men's "real intents." Measure for Measure is full of expressions +drawn from a profound experience of these casuistries, and that +ethical interest becomes predominant in it: it is no longer Promos +and [183] Cassandra, but Measure for Measure, its new name expressly +suggesting the subject of poetical justice. The action of the play, +like the action of life itself for the keener observer, develops in +us the conception of this poetical justice, and the yearning to +realise it, the true justice of which Angelo knows nothing, because +it lies for the most part beyond the limits of any acknowledged law. +The idea of justice involves the idea of rights. But at bottom +rights are equivalent to that which really is, to facts; and the +recognition of his rights therefore, the justice he requires of our +hands, or our thoughts, is the recognition of that which the person, +in his inmost nature, really is; and as sympathy alone can discover +that which really is in matters of feeling and thought, true justice +is in its essence a finer knowledge through love. + +'Tis very pregnant: +The jewel that we find we stoop and take it, +Because we see it; but what we do not see +We tread upon, and never think of it. + +It is for this finer justice, a justice based on a more delicate +appreciation of the true conditions of men and things, a true respect +of persons in our estimate of actions, that the people in Measure for +Measure cry out as they pass before us; and as the poetry of this +play is full of the peculiarities of Shakespeare's poetry, so in its +ethics it is an epitome of Shakespeare's moral judgments. They are +the moral judgments of [184] an observer, of one who sits as a +spectator, and knows how the threads in the design before him hold +together under the surface: they are the judgments of the humourist +also, who follows with a half-amused but always pitiful sympathy, the +various ways of human disposition, and sees less distance than +ordinary men between what are called respectively great and little +things. It is not always that poetry can be the exponent of +morality; but it is this aspect of morals which it represents most +naturally, for this true justice is dependent on just those finer +appreciations which poetry cultivates in us the power of making, +those peculiar valuations of action and its effect which poetry +actually requires. + +1874. + +NOTES + +176. *Fletcher, in the Bloody Brother, gives the rest of it. +Return. + + + +SHAKESPEARE'S ENGLISH KINGS + +[185] + +A brittle glory shineth in this face: +As brittle as the glory is the face. + +THE English plays of Shakespeare needed but the completion of one +unimportant interval to possess the unity of a popular chronicle from +Richard the Second to Henry the Eighth, and possess, as they actually +stand, the unity of a common motive in the handling of the various +events and persons which they bring before us. Certain of his +historic dramas, not English, display Shakespeare's mastery in the +development of the heroic nature amid heroic circumstances; and had +he chosen, from English history, to deal with Coeur-de-Lion or Edward +the First, the innate quality of his subject would doubtless have +called into play something of that profound and sombre power which in +Julius Caesar and Macbeth has sounded the depths of mighty character. +True, on the whole, to fact, it is another side of kingship which he +has made prominent in his English histories. The irony [186] of +kingship--average human nature, flung with a wonderfully pathetic +effect into the vortex of great events; tragedy of everyday quality +heightened in degree only by the conspicuous scene which does but +make those who play their parts there conspicuously unfortunate; the +utterance of common humanity straight from the heart, but refined +like other common things for kingly uses by Shakespeare's unfailing +eloquence: such, unconsciously for the most part, though palpably +enough to the careful reader, is the conception under which +Shakespeare has arranged the lights and shadows of the story of the +English kings, emphasising merely the light and shadow inherent in +it, and keeping very close to the original authorities, not simply in +the general outline of these dramatic histories but sometimes in +their very expression. Certainly the history itself, as he found it +in Hall, Holinshed, and Stowe, those somewhat picturesque old +chroniclers who had themselves an eye for the dramatic "effects" of +human life, has much of this sentiment already about it. What he did +not find there was the natural prerogative--such justification, in +kingly, that is to say, in exceptional, qualities, of the exceptional +position, as makes it practicable in the result. It is no Henriade +he writes, and no history of the English people, but the sad fortunes +of some English kings as conspicuous examples of the ordinary human +condition. As in a children's [187] story, all princes are in +extremes. Delightful in the sunshine above the wall into which +chance lifts the flower for a season, they can but plead somewhat +more touchingly than others their everyday weakness in the storm. +Such is the motive that gives unity to these unequal and intermittent +contributions toward a slowly evolved dramatic chronicle, which it +would have taken many days to rehearse; a not distant story from real +life still well remembered in its general course, to which people +might listen now and again, as long as they cared, finding human +nature at least wherever their attention struck ground in it. + +He begins with John, and allows indeed to the first of these English +kings a kind of greatness, making the development of the play centre +in the counteraction of his natural gifts--that something of heroic +force about him--by a madness which takes the shape of reckless +impiety, forced especially on men's attention by the terrible +circumstances of his end, in the delineation of which Shakespeare +triumphs, setting, with true poetic tact, this incident of the king's +death, in all the horror of a violent one, amid a scene delicately +suggestive of what is perennially peaceful and genial in the outward +world. Like the sensual humours of Falstaff in another play, the +presence of the bastard Faulconbridge, with his physical energy and +his unmistakable family likeness--"those limbs [188] which Sir Robert +never holp to make"* contributes to an almost coarse assertion of the +force of nature, of the somewhat ironic preponderance of nature and +circumstance over men's artificial arrangements, to, the recognition +of a certain potent natural aristocracy, which is far from being +always identical with that more formal, heraldic one. And what is a +coarse fact in the case of Faulconbridge becomes a motive of pathetic +appeal in the wan and babyish Arthur. The magic with which nature +models tiny and delicate children to the likeness of their rough +fathers is nowhere more justly expressed than in the words of King +Philip.-- + +Look here upon thy brother Geoffrey's face +These eyes, these brows were moulded out of his: +This little abstract doth contain that large +Which died in Geoffrey; and the hand of time +Shall draw this brief into as huge a volume. + +It was perhaps something of a boyish memory of the shocking end of +his father that had distorted the piety of Henry the Third into +superstitious terror. A frightened soul, himself touched with the +contrary sort of religious madness, doting on all that was alien from +his father's huge ferocity, on the genialities, the soft gilding, of +life, on the genuine interests of art and poetry, to be credited more +than any other person with the deep religious expression of [189] +Westminster Abbey, Henry the Third, picturesque though useless, but +certainly touching, might have furnished Shakespeare, had he filled +up this interval in his series, with precisely the kind of effect he +tends towards in his English plays. But he found it completer still +in the person and story of Richard the Second, a figure--"that sweet +lovely rose"--which haunts Shakespeare's mind, as it seems long to +have haunted the minds of the English people, as the most touching of +all examples of the irony of kingship. + +Henry the Fourth--to look for a moment beyond our immediate subject, +in pursuit of Shakespeare's thought--is presented, of course, in +general outline, as an impersonation of "surviving force:" he has a +certain amount of kingcraft also, a real fitness for great +opportunity. But still true to his leading motive, Shakespeare, in +King Henry the Fourth, has left the high-water mark of his poetry in +the soliloquy which represents royalty longing vainly for the +toiler's sleep; while the popularity, the showy heroism, of Henry the +Fifth, is used to give emphatic point to the old earthy commonplace +about "wild oats." The wealth of homely humour in these plays, the +fun coming straight home to all the world, of Fluellen especially in +his unconscious interview with the king, the boisterous earthiness of +Falstaff and his companions, contribute to the same effect. The +keynote of [190] Shakespeare's treatment is indeed expressed by Henry +the Fifth himself, the greatest of Shakespeare's kings.--"Though I +speak it to you," he says incognito, under cover of night, to a +common soldier on the field, "I think the king is but a man, as I am: +the violet smells to him as it doth to me: all his senses have but +human conditions; and though his affections be higher mounted than +ours yet when they stoop they stoop with like wing." And, in truth, +the really kingly speeches which Shakespeare assigns to him, as to +other kings weak enough in all but speech, are but a kind of flowers, +worn for, and effective only as personal embellishment. They combine +to one result with the merely outward and ceremonial ornaments of +royalty, its pageantries, flaunting so naively, so credulously, in +Shakespeare, as in that old medieval time. And then, the force of +Hotspur is but transient youth, the common heat of youth, in him. +The character of Henry the Sixth again, roi fainéant, with La +Pucelle* for his counterfoil, lay in the direct course of +Shakespeare's design: he has done much to fix the sentiment of the +"holy Henry." Richard the Third, touched, like John, with an effect +of real heroism, is spoiled like him by something of criminal +madness, and reaches his highest level of tragic expression [191] +when circumstances reduce him to terms of mere human nature.-- + +A horse! A horse! My kingdom for a horse! + +The Princes in the Tower recall to mind the lot of young Arthur:-- + +I'll go with thee, +And find the inheritance of this poor child, +His little kingdom of a forced grave. + +And when Shakespeare comes to Henry the Eighth, it is not the +superficial though very English splendour of the king himself, but +the really potent and ascendant nature of the butcher's son on the +one hand, and Katharine's subdued reproduction of the sad fortunes of +Richard the Second on the other, that define his central interest.* + +With a prescience of the Wars of the Roses, of which his errors were +the original cause, it is Richard who best exposes Shakespeare's own +constant sentiment concerning war, and especially that sort of +civil war which was then recent in English memories. The soul of +Shakespeare, certainly, was not wanting in a sense of the magnanimity +of warriors. The grandiose aspects of war, its magnificent +apparelling, he records [192] monumentally enough--the "dressing of +the lists," the lion's heart, its unfaltering haste thither in all +the freshness of youth and morning.-- + +Not sick although I have to do with death-- +The sun doth gild our armour: Up, my Lords!-- +I saw young Harry with his beaver on, +His cuisses on his thighs, gallantly arm'd, +Rise from the ground like feather'd Mercury. + +Only, with Shakespeare, the afterthought is immediate:-- + +They come like sacrifices in their trim. + +--Will it never be to-day? I will trot to-morrow a mile, and my +way shall be paved with English faces. + +This sentiment Richard reiterates very plaintively, in association +with the delicate sweetness of the English fields, still sweet and +fresh, like London and her other fair towns in that England of +Chaucer, for whose soil the exiled Bolingbroke is made to long so +dangerously, while Richard on his return from Ireland salutes it-- + +That pale, that white-fac'd shore,-- +As a long-parted mother with her child.-- +So, weeping, smiling, greet I thee, my earth! +And do thee favour with my royal hands.-- + +Then (of Bolingbroke) + +Ere the crown he looks for live in peace, +Ten thousand bloody crowns of mothers' sons +Shall ill become the flower of England's face; +Change the complexion of her maid-pale peace +To scarlet indignation, and bedew +My pastures' grass with faithful English blood.-- + +[193] + +Why have they dared to march?-- + +asks York, + +So many miles upon her peaceful bosom, +Frighting her pale-fac'd visages with war?-- + +waking, according to Richard, + +Our peace, which in our country's cradle, +Draws the sweet infant breath of gentle sleep:-- + +bedrenching "with crimson tempest" + +The fresh green lap of fair king Richard's land:-- + +frighting "fair peace" from "our quiet confines," laying + +The summer's dust with showers of blood, +Rained from the wounds of slaughter'd Englishmen: + +bruising + +Her flowerets with the armed hoofs +Of hostile paces. + +Perhaps it is not too fanciful to note in this play a peculiar recoil +from the mere instruments of warfare, the contact of the "rude ribs," +the "flint bosom," of Barkloughly Castle or Pomfret or + +Julius Caesar's ill-erected tower: + +the + +Boisterous untun'd drums +With harsh-resounding trumpets' dreadful bray +And grating shock of wrathful iron arms. + +It is as if the lax, soft beauty of the king took effect, at least by +contrast, on everything beside. One gracious prerogative, certainly, +Shakespeare's [194] English kings possess: they are a very eloquent +company, and Richard is the most sweet-tongued of them all. In no +other play perhaps is there such a flush of those gay, fresh, +variegated flowers of speech--colour and figure, not lightly attached +to, but fused into, the very phrase itself--which Shakespeare cannot +help dispensing to his characters, as in this "play of the Deposing +of King Richard the Second," an exquisite poet if he is nothing else, +from first to last, in light and gloom alike, able to see all things +poetically, to give a poetic turn to his conduct of them, and +refreshing with his golden language the tritest aspects of that +ironic contrast between the pretensions of a king and the actual +necessities of his destiny. What a garden of words! With him, blank +verse, infinitely graceful, deliberate, musical in inflexion, becomes +indeed a true "verse royal," that rhyming lapse, which to the +Shakespearian ear, at least in youth, came as the last touch of +refinement on it, being here doubly appropriate. His eloquence +blends with that fatal beauty, of which he was so frankly aware, so +amiable to his friends, to his wife, of the effects of which on the +people his enemies were so much afraid, on which Shakespeare himself +dwells so attentively as the "royal blood" comes and goes in the face +with his rapid changes of temper. As happens with sensitive natures, +it attunes him to a congruous suavity of manners, by which anger +itself became flattering: [195] it blends with his merely youthful +hopefulness and high spirits, his sympathetic love for gay people, +things, apparel--"his cote of gold and stone, valued at thirty +thousand marks," the novel Italian fashions he preferred, as also +with those real amiabilities that made people forget the darker +touches of his character, but never tire of the pathetic rehearsal of +his fall, the meekness of which would have seemed merely abject in a +less graceful performer. + +Yet it is only fair to say that in the painstaking "revival" of King +Richard the Second, by the late Charles Kean, those who were very +young thirty years ago were afforded much more than Shakespeare's +play could ever have been before--the very person of the king based +on the stately old portrait in Westminster Abbey, "the earliest +extant contemporary likeness of any English sovereign," the grace, +the winning pathos, the sympathetic voice of the player, the tasteful +archaeology confronting vulgar modern London with a scenic +reproduction, for once really agreeable, of the London of Chaucer. +In the hands of Kean the play became like an exquisite performance on +the violin. + +The long agony of one so gaily painted by nature's self, from his +"tragic abdication" till the hour in which he + +Sluiced out his innocent soul thro' streams of blood, + +was for playwrights a subject ready to hand, and [196] became early +the theme of a popular drama, of which some have fancied surviving +favourite fragments in the rhymed parts of Shakespeare's work. + +The king Richard of Yngland +Was in his flowris then regnand: +But his flowris efter sone +Fadyt, and ware all undone:-- + +says the old chronicle. Strangely enough, Shakespeare supposes him +an over-confident believer in that divine right of kings, of which +people in Shakespeare's time were coming to hear so much; a general +right, sealed to him (so Richard is made to think) as an ineradicable +personal gift by the touch--stream rather, over head and breast and +shoulders--of the "holy oil" of his consecration at Westminster; not, +however, through some oversight, the genuine balm used at the +coronation of his successor, given, according to legend, by the +Blessed Virgin to Saint Thomas of Canterbury. Richard himself found +that, it was said, among other forgotten treasures, at the crisis of +his changing fortunes, and vainly sought reconsecration therewith-- +understood, wistfully, that it was reserved for his happier rival. +And yet his coronation, by the pageantry, the amplitude, the learned +care, of its order, so lengthy that the king, then only eleven years +of age, and fasting, as a communicant at the ceremony, was carried +away in a faint, fixed the type under which it has ever [197] since +continued. And nowhere is there so emphatic a reiteration as in +Richard the Second of the sentiment which those singular rites were +calculated to produce. + +Not all the water in the rough rude sea +Can wash the balm from an anointed king,-- + +as supplementing another, almost supernatural, right.--"Edward's +seven sons," of whom Richard's father was one, + +Were as seven phials of his sacred blood. + +But this, too, in the hands of Shakespeare, becomes for him, like any +other of those fantastic, ineffectual, easily discredited, personal +graces, as capricious in its operation on men's wills as merely +physical beauty, kindling himself to eloquence indeed, but only +giving double pathos to insults which "barbarism itself" might have +pitied--the dust in his face, as he returns, through the streets of +London, a prisoner in the train of his victorious enemy. + +How soon my sorrow hath destroyed my face! + +he cries, in that most poetic invention of the mirror scene, which +does but reinforce again that physical charm which all confessed. +The sense of "divine right" in kings is found to act not so much as a +secret of power over others, as of infatuation to themselves. And of +all those personal gifts the one which alone never altogether fails +him is just that royal utterance, his [198] appreciation of the +poetry of his own hapless lot, an eloquent self-pity, infecting +others in spite of themselves, till they too become irresistibly +eloquent about him. + +In the Roman Pontifical, of which the order of Coronation is really +a part, there is no form for the inverse process, no rite of +"degradation," such as that by which an offending priest or bishop +may be deprived, if not of the essential quality of "orders," yet, +one by one, of its outward dignities. It is as if Shakespeare had +had in mind some such inverted rite, like those old ecclesiastical or +military ones, by which human hardness, or human justice, adds the +last touch of unkindness to the execution of its sentences, in the +scene where Richard "deposes" himself, as in some long, agonising +ceremony, reflectively drawn out, with an extraordinary refinement of +intelligence and variety of piteous appeal, but also with a felicity +of poetic invention, which puts these pages into a very select class, +with the finest "vermeil and ivory" work of Chatterton or Keats. + +Fetch hither Richard that in common view +He may surrender!-- + +And Richard more than concurs: he throws himself into the part, +realises a type, falls gracefully as on the world's stage.--Why is he +sent for? + +To do that office of thine own good will +Which tired majesty did make thee offer.-- + +Now mark me! how I will undo myself. + +[199] "Hath Bolingbroke deposed thine intellect?" the Queen asks him, +on his way to the Tower:-- + +Hath Bolingbroke +Deposed thine intellect? hath he been in thy heart? + +And in truth, but for that adventitious poetic gold, it would be only +"plume-plucked Richard."-- + +I find myself a traitor with the rest, +For I have given here my soul's consent +To undeck the pompous body of a king. + +He is duly reminded, indeed, how + +That which in mean men we entitle patience +Is pale cold cowardice in noble breasts. + +Yet at least within the poetic bounds of Shakespeare's play, through +Shakespeare's bountiful gifts, his desire seems fulfilled.-- + +O! that I were as great +As is my grief. + +And his grief becomes nothing less than a central expression of all +that in the revolutions of Fortune's wheel goes down in the world. + +No! Shakespeare's kings are not, nor are meant to be, great men: +rather, little or quite ordinary humanity, thrust upon greatness, +with those pathetic results, the natural self-pity of the weak +heightened in them into irresistible appeal to others as the net +result of their royal prerogative. One after another, they seem to +lie composed in Shakespeare's embalming pages, with just that touch +of nature about them, [200] making the whole world akin, which has +infused into their tombs at Westminster a rare poetic grace. It is +that irony of kingship, the sense that it is in its happiness child's +play, in its sorrows, after all, but children's grief, which gives +its finer accent to all the changeful feeling of these wonderful +speeches:--the great meekness of the graceful, wild creature, tamed +at last.-- + +Give Richard leave to live till Richard die! + +his somewhat abject fear of death, turning to acquiescence at moments +of extreme weariness:-- + +My large kingdom for a little grave! +A little little grave, an obscure grave!-- + +his religious appeal in the last reserve, with its bold reference to +the judgment of Pilate, as he thinks once more of his "anointing." + +And as happens with children he attains contentment finally in the +merely passive recognition of superior strength, in the naturalness +of the result of the great battle as a matter of course, and +experiences something of the royal prerogative of poetry to obscure, +or at least to attune and soften men's griefs. As in some sweet +anthem of Handel, the sufferer, who put finger to the organ under the +utmost pressure of mental conflict, extracts a kind of peace at last +from the mere skill with which he sets his distress to music.-- + +Beshrew thee, Cousin, that didst lead me forth +Of that sweet way I was in to despair! + +[201] "With Cain go wander through the shades of night!" cries the +new king to the gaoler Exton, dissimulating his share in the murder +he is thought to have suggested; and in truth there is something of +the murdered Abel about Shakespeare's Richard. The fact seems to be +that he died of "waste and a broken heart:" it was by way of proof +that his end had been a natural one that, stifling a real fear of the +face, the face of Richard, on men's minds, with the added pleading +now of all dead faces, Henry exposed the corpse to general view; and +Shakespeare, in bringing it on the stage, in the last scene of his +play, does but follow out the motive with which he has emphasised +Richard's physical beauty all through it--that "most beauteous inn," +as the Queen says quaintly, meeting him on the way to death-- +residence, then soon to be deserted, of that wayward, frenzied, but +withal so affectionate soul. Though the body did not go to +Westminster immediately, his tomb, + +That small model of the barren earth +Which serves as paste and cover to our bones,* + +the effigy clasping the hand of his youthful consort, was already +prepared there, with "rich [202] gilding and ornaments," monument of +poetic regret, for Queen Anne of Bohemia, not of course the "Queen" +of Shakespeare, who however seems to have transferred to this second +wife something of Richard's wildly proclaimed affection for the +first. In this way, through the connecting link of that sacred spot, +our thoughts once more associate Richard's two fallacious +prerogatives, his personal beauty and his "anointing." + +According to Johnson, Richard the Second is one of those plays which +Shakespeare has "apparently revised;" and how doubly delightful +Shakespeare is where he seems to have revised! "Would that he had +blotted a thousand"--a thousand hasty phrases, we may venture once +more to say with his earlier critic, now that the tiresome German +superstition has passed away which challenged us to a dogmatic faith +in the plenary verbal inspiration of every one of Shakespeare's +clowns. Like some melodiously contending anthem of Handle's, I said, +of Richard's meek "undoing" of himself in the mirror-scene; and, in +fact, the play of Richard the Second does, like a musical +composition, possess a certain concentration of all its parts, a +simple continuity, an evenness in execution, which are rare in the +great dramatist. With Romeo and Juliet, that perfect symphony +(symphony of three independent poetic forms set in a grander one* +which it is the merit of German [203] criticism to have detected) it +belongs to a small group of plays, where, by happy birth and +consistent evolution, dramatic form approaches to something like the +unity of a lyrical ballad, a lyric, a song, a single strain of music. +Which sort of poetry we are to account the highest, is perhaps a +barren question. Yet if, in art generally, unity of impression is a +note of what is perfect, then lyric poetry, which in spite of complex +structure often preserves the unity of a single passionate +ejaculation, would rank higher than dramatic poetry, where, +especially to the reader, as distinguished from the spectator +assisting at a theatrical performance, there must always be a sense +of the effort necessary to keep the various parts from flying +asunder, a sense of imperfect continuity, such as the older criticism +vainly sought to obviate by the rule of the dramatic "unities." It +follows that a play attains artistic perfection just in proportion as +it approaches that unity of lyrical effect, as if a song or ballad +were still lying at the root of it, all the various expression of the +conflict of character and circumstance falling at last into the +compass of a single melody, or musical theme. As, historically, the +earliest classic drama arose out of the chorus, from which this or +that person, this or that episode, detached itself, so, into the +unity of a choric song the perfect drama ever tends to return, its +intellectual scope deepened, complicated, enlarged, but still with an +unmistakable [204] singleness, or identity, in its impression on the +mind. Just there, in that vivid single impression left on the mind +when all is over, not in any mechanical limitation of time and place, +is the secret of the "unities"--the true imaginative unity--of the +drama. + +1889. + +NOTES + +188. *Elinor. Do you not read some tokens of my son (Coeur-de-Lion) +/ In the large composition of this man? + +190. *Perhaps the one person of genius in these English plays. + +The spirit of deep prophecy she hath, +Exceeding the nine Sibyls of old Rome: +What's past and what's to come she can descry. + +191. *Proposing in this paper to trace the leading sentiment in +Shakespeare's English Plays as a sort of popular dramatic chronicle, +I have left untouched the question how much (or, in the case of Henry +the Sixth and Henry the Eighth, how little) of them may be really +his: how far inferior hands have contributed to a result, true on the +whole to the greater, that is to say, the Shakespearian elements in +them. + +201. *Perhaps a double entendre:--of any ordinary grave, as +comprising, in effect, the whole small earth now left to its occupant +or, of such a tomb as Richard's in particular, with its actual model, +or effigy, of the clay of him. Both senses are so characteristic +that it would be a pity to lose either. + +202. *The Sonnet: the Aubade: the Epithalamium. + + + +DANTE GABRIEL ROSSETTI + +[205] IT was characteristic of a poet who had ever something about +him of mystic isolation, and will still appeal perhaps, though with a +name it may seem now established in English literature, to a special +and limited audience, that some of his poems had won a kind of +exquisite fame before they were in the full sense published. The +Blessed Damozel, although actually printed twice before the year +1870, was eagerly circulated in manuscript; and the volume which it +now opens came at last to satisfy a long-standing curiosity as to the +poet, whose pictures also had become an object of the same peculiar +kind of interest. For those poems were the work of a painter, +understood to belong to, and to be indeed the leader, of a new school +then rising into note; and the reader of to-day may observe already, +in The Blessed Damozel, written at the age of eighteen, a +prefigurement of the chief characteristics of that school, as he will +recognise in it also, in proportion as he really knows Rossetti, many +of the characteristics which are most markedly personal and his own. +Common [206] to that school and to him, and in both alike of primary +significance, was the quality of sincerity, already felt as one of +the charms of that earliest poem--a perfect sincerity, taking effect +in the deliberate use of the most direct and unconventional +expression, for the conveyance of a poetic sense which recognised no +conventional standard of what poetry was called upon to be. At a +time when poetic originality in England might seem to have had its +utmost play, here was certainly one new poet more, with a structure +and music of verse, a vocabulary, an accent, unmistakably novel, yet +felt to be no mere tricks of manner adopted with a view to forcing +attention--an accent which might rather count as the very seal of +reality on one man's own proper speech; as that speech itself was the +wholly natural expression of certain wonderful things he really felt +and saw. Here was one, who had a matter to present to his readers, +to himself at least, in the first instance, so valuable, so real and +definite, that his primary aim, as regards form or expression in his +verse, would be but its exact equivalence to those data within. That +he had this gift of transparency in language--the control of a style +which did but obediently shift and shape itself to the mental motion, +as a well-trained hand can follow on the tracing-paper the outline of +an original drawing below it, was proved afterwards by a volume of +typically perfect translations from the delightful but difficult +[207] "early Italian poets:" such transparency being indeed the +secret of all genuine style, of all such style as can truly belong to +one man and not to another. His own meaning was always personal and +even recondite, in a certain sense learned and casuistical, sometimes +complex or obscure; but the term was always, one could see, +deliberately chosen from many competitors, as the just transcript of +that peculiar phase of soul which he alone knew, precisely as he knew +it. + +One of the peculiarities of The Blessed Damozel was a definiteness of +sensible imagery, which seemed almost grotesque to some, and was +strange, above all, in a theme so profoundly visionary. The gold bar +of heaven from which she leaned, her hair yellow like ripe corn, are +but examples of a general treatment, as naively detailed as the +pictures of those early painters contemporary with Dante, who has +shown a similar care for minute and definite imagery in his verse; +there, too, in the very midst of profoundly mystic vision. Such +definition of outline is indeed one among many points in which +Rossetti resembles the great Italian poet, of whom, led to him at +first by family circumstances, he was ever a lover--a "servant and +singer," faithful as Dante, "of Florence and of Beatrice"--with some +close inward conformities of genius also, independent of any mere +circumstances of education. It was said by a critic of the last +century, not wisely though agreeably to the practice of his time, +[208] that poetry rejoices in abstractions. For Rossetti, as for +Dante, without question on his part, the first condition of the +poetic way of seeing and presenting things is particularisation. +"Tell me now," he writes, for Villon's + +Dictes-moy où, n'en quel pays, +Est Flora, la belle Romaine-- + +Tell me now, in what hidden way is +Lady Flora the lovely Roman: + +--"way," in which one might actually chance to meet her; the +unmistakably poetic effect of the couplet in English being dependent +on the definiteness of that single word (though actually lighted on +in the search after a difficult double rhyme) for which every one +else would have written, like Villon himself, a more general one, +just equivalent to place or region. + +And this delight in concrete definition is allied with another of his +conformities to Dante, the really imaginative vividness, namely, of +his personifications--his hold upon them, or rather their hold upon +him, with the force of a Frankenstein, when once they have taken life +from him. Not Death only and Sleep, for instance, and the winged +spirit of Love, but certain particular aspects of them, a whole +"populace" of special hours and places, "the hour" even "which might +have been, yet might not be," are living creatures, with hands and +eyes and articulate voices. + +[209] + +Stands it not by the door-- +Love's Hour--till she and I shall meet; +With bodiless form and unapparent feet +That cast no shadow yet before, +Though round its head the dawn begins to pour +The breath that makes day sweet?-- + +Nay, why +Name the dead hours? I mind them well: +Their ghosts in many darkened doorways dwell +With desolate eyes to know them by. + +Poetry as a mania--one of Plato's two higher forms of "divine" mania- +-has, in all its species, a mere insanity incidental to it, the +"defect of its quality," into which it may lapse in its moment of +weakness; and the insanity which follows a vivid poetic +anthropomorphism like that of Rossetti may be noted here and there in +his work, in a forced and almost grotesque materialising of +abstractions, as Dante also became at times a mere subject of the +scholastic realism of the Middle Age. + +In Love's Nocturn and The Stream's Secret, congruously perhaps with a +certain feverishness of soul in the moods they present, there is at +times a near approach (may it be said?) to such insanity of realism-- + +Pity and love shall burn +In her pressed cheek and cherishing hands; +And from the living spirit of love that stands +Between her lips to soothe and yearn, +Each separate breath shall clasp me round in turn +And loose my spirit's bands. + +[210] But even if we concede this; even if we allow, in the very plan +of those two compositions, something of the literary conceit--what +exquisite, what novel flowers of poetry, we must admit them to be, as +they stand! In the one, what a delight in all the natural beauty of +water, all its details for the eye of a painter; in the other, how +subtle and fine the imaginative hold upon all the secret ways of +sleep and dreams! In both of them, with much the same attitude and +tone, Love--sick and doubtful Love--would fain inquire of what lies +below the surface of sleep, and below the water; stream or dream +being forced to speak by Love's powerful "control"; and the poet +would have it foretell the fortune, issue, and event of his wasting +passion. Such artifices, indeed, were not unknown in the old +Provençal poetry of which Dante had learned something. Only, in +Rossetti at least, they are redeemed by a serious purpose, by that +sincerity of his, which allies itself readily to a serious beauty, a +sort of grandeur of literary workmanship, to a great style. One +seems to hear there a really new kind of poetic utterance, with +effects which have nothing else like them; as there is nothing else, +for instance, like the narrative of Jacob's Dream in Genesis, or +Blake's design of the Singing of the Morning Stars, or Addison's +Nineteenth Psalm. + +With him indeed, as in some revival of the old mythopoeic age, common +things--dawn, [211] noon, night--are full of human or personal +expression, full of sentiment. The lovely little sceneries scattered +up and down his poems, glimpses of a landscape, not indeed of broad +open-air effects, but rather that of a painter concentrated upon the +picturesque effect of one or two selected objects at a time--the +"hollow brimmed with mist," or the "ruined weir," as he sees it from +one of the windows, or reflected in one of the mirrors of his "house +of life" (the vignettes for instance seen by Rose Mary in the magic +beryl) attest, by their very freshness and simplicity, to a pictorial +or descriptive power in dealing with the inanimate world, which is +certainly also one half of the charm, in that other, more remote and +mystic, use of it. For with Rossetti this sense of lifeless nature, +after all, is translated to a higher service, in which it does but +incorporate itself with some phase of strong emotion. Every one +understands how this may happen at critical moments of life; what a +weirdly expressive soul may have crept, even in full noonday, into +"the white-flower'd elder-thicket," when Godiva saw it "gleam through +the Gothic archways in the wall," at the end of her terrible ride. +To Rossetti it is so always, because to him life is a crisis at every +moment. A sustained impressibility towards the mysterious conditions +of man's everyday life, towards the very mystery itself in it, gives +a singular gravity to all his work: those matters never became trite +[212] to him. But throughout, it is the ideal intensity of love--of +love based upon a perfect yet peculiar type of physical or material +beauty--which is enthroned in the midst of those mysterious powers; +Youth and Death, Destiny and Fortune, Fame, Poetic Fame, Memory, +Oblivion, and the like. Rossetti is one of those who, in the words +of Mérimée, se passionnent pour la passion, one of Love's lovers. + +And yet, again as with Dante, to speak of his ideal type of beauty as +material, is partly misleading. Spirit and matter, indeed, have been +for the most part opposed, with a false contrast or antagonism by +schoolmen, whose artificial creation those abstractions really are. +In our actual concrete experience, the two trains of phenomena which +the words matter and spirit do but roughly distinguish, play +inextricably into each other. Practically, the church of the Middle +Age by its aesthetic worship, its sacramentalism, its real faith in +the resurrection of the flesh, had set itself against that Manichean +opposition of spirit and matter, and its results in men's way of +taking life; and in this, Dante is the central representative of its +spirit. To him, in the vehement and impassioned heat of his +conceptions, the material and the spiritual are fused and blent: if +the spiritual attains the definite visibility of a crystal, what is +material loses its earthiness and impurity. And here again, by force +of instinct, Rossetti [213] is one with him. His chosen type of +beauty is one, + +Whose speech Truth knows not from her thought, +Nor Love her body from her soul. + +Like Dante, he knows no region of spirit which shall not be sensuous +also, or material. The shadowy world, which he realises so +powerfully, has still the ways and houses, the land and water, the +light and darkness, the fire and flowers, that had so much to do in +the moulding of those bodily powers and aspects which counted for so +large a part of the soul, here. + +For Rossetti, then, the great affections of persons to each other, +swayed and determined, in the case of his highly pictorial genius, +mainly by that so-called material loveliness, formed the great +undeniable reality in things, the solid resisting substance, in a +world where all beside might be but shadow. The fortunes of those +affections--of the great love so determined; its casuistries, its +languor sometimes; above all, its sorrows; its fortunate or +unfortunate collisions with those other great matters; how it looks, +as the long day of life goes round, in the light and shadow of them: +all this, conceived with an abundant imagination, and a deep, a +philosophic, reflectiveness, is the matter of his verse, and +especially of what he designed as his chief poetic work, "a work to +be called The House of Life," towards which the majority of his +sonnets and songs were contributions. + +[214] The dwelling-place in which one finds oneself by chance or +destiny, yet can partly fashion for oneself; never properly one's own +at all, if it be changed too lightly; in which every object has its +associations--the dim mirrors, the portraits, the lamps, the books, +the hair-tresses of the dead and visionary magic crystals in the +secret drawers, the names and words scratched on the windows, windows +open upon prospects the saddest or the sweetest; the house one must +quit, yet taking perhaps, how much of its quietly active light and +colour along with us!--grown now to be a kind of raiment to one's +body, as the body, according to Swedenborg, is but the raiment of the +soul--under that image, the whole of Rossetti's work might count as a +House of Life, of which he is but the "Interpreter." And it is a +"haunted" house. A sense of power in love, defying distance, and +those barriers which are so much more than physical distance, of +unutterable desire penetrating into the world of sleep, however +"lead-bound," was one of those anticipative notes obscurely struck in +The Blessed Damozel, and, in his later work, makes him speak +sometimes almost like a believer in mesmerism. Dream-land, as we +said, with its "phantoms of the body," deftly coming and going on +love's service, is to him, in no mere fancy or figure of speech, a +real country, a veritable expansion of, or addition to, our waking +life; and he did well perhaps to wait carefully upon sleep, for the +lack [215] of it became mortal disease with him. One may even +recognise a sort of morbid and over-hasty making-ready for death +itself, which increases on him; thoughts concerning it, its +imageries, coming with a frequency and importunity, in excess, one +might think, of even the very saddest, quite wholesome wisdom. + +And indeed the publication of his second volume of Ballads and +Sonnets preceded his death by scarcely a twelvemonth. That volume +bears witness to the reverse of any failure of power, or falling-off +from his early standard of literary perfection, in every one of his +then accustomed forms of poetry--the song, the sonnet, and the +ballad. The newly printed sonnets, now completing The House of Life, +certainly advanced beyond those earlier ones, in clearness; his +dramatic power in the ballad, was here at its height; while one +monumental, gnomic piece, Soothsay, testifies, more clearly even than +the Nineveh of his first volume, to the reflective force, the dry +reason, always at work behind his imaginative creations, which at no +time dispensed with a genuine intellectual structure. For in matters +of pure reflection also, Rossetti maintained the painter's sensuous +clearness of conception; and this has something to do with the +capacity, largely illustrated by his ballads, of telling some red- +hearted story of impassioned action with effect. + +Have there, in very deed, been ages, in which [216] the external +conditions of poetry such as Rossetti's were of more spontaneous +growth than in our own? The archaic side of Rossetti's work, his +preferences in regard to earlier poetry, connect him with those who +have certainly thought so, who fancied they could have breathed more +largely in the age of Chaucer, or of Ronsard, in one of those ages, +in the words of Stendhal--ces siècles de passions où les âmes +pouvaient se livrer franchement à la plus haute exaltation, quand les +passions qui font la possibilité We may think, perhaps, that such old +time as that has never really existed except in the fancy of poets; +but it was to find it, that Rossetti turned so often from modern life +to the chronicle of the past. Old Scotch history, perhaps beyond any +other, is strong in the matter of heroic and vehement hatreds and +love, the tragic Mary herself being but the perfect blossom of them; +and it is from that history that Rossetti has taken the subjects of +the two longer ballads of his second volume: of the three admirable +ballads in it, The King's Tragedy (in which Rossetti has dexterously +interwoven some relics of James's own exquisite early verse) reaching +the highest level of dramatic success, and marking perfection, +perhaps, in this kind of poetry; which, in the earlier volume, gave +us, among other pieces, Troy Town, Sister Helen, and Eden Bower. + +Like those earlier pieces, the ballads of the [217] second volume +bring with them the question of the poetic value of the "refrain"-- + +Eden bower's in flower: +And O the bower and the hour! + +--and the like. Two of those ballads--Troy Town and Eden Bower, are +terrible in theme; and the refrain serves, perhaps, to relieve their +bold aim at the sentiment of terror. In Sister Helen again, the +refrain has a real, and sustained purpose (being here duly varied +also) and performs the part of a chorus, as the story proceeds. Yet +even in these cases, whatever its effect may be in actual recitation, +it may fairly be questioned, whether, to the mere reader their actual +effect is not that of a positive interruption and drawback, at least +in pieces so lengthy; and Rossetti himself, it would seem, came to +think so, for in the shortest of his later ballads, The White Ship-- +that old true history of the generosity with which a youth, worthless +in life, flung himself upon death--he was contented with a single +utterance of the refrain, "given out" like the keynote or tune of a +chant. + +In The King's Tragedy, Rossetti has worked upon motive, broadly human +(to adopt the phrase of popular criticism) such as one and all may +realise. Rossetti, indeed, with all his self-concentration upon his +own peculiar aim, by no means ignored those general interests which +are external to poetry as he conceived it; as he has [218] shown here +and there, in this poetic, as also in pictorial, work. It was but +that, in a life to be shorter even than the average, he found enough +to occupy him in the fulfilment of a task, plainly "given him to +do." Perhaps, if one had to name a single composition of his to +readers desiring to make acquaintance with him for the first time, +one would select: The King's Tragedy--that poem so moving, so +popularly dramatic, and lifelike. Notwithstanding this, his work, it +must be conceded, certainly through no narrowness or egotism, but in +the faithfulness of a true workman to a vocation so emphatic, was +mainly of the esoteric order. But poetry, at all times, exercises +two distinct functions: it may reveal, it may unveil to every eye, +the ideal aspects of common things, after Gray's way (though Gray +too, it is well to remember, seemed in his own day, seemed even to +Johnson, obscure) or it may actually add to the number of motives +poetic and uncommon in themselves, by the imaginative creation of +things that are ideal from their very birth. Rossetti did something, +something excellent, of the former kind; but his characteristic, his +really revealing work, lay in the adding to poetry of fresh poetic +material, of a new order of phenomena, in the creation of a new +ideal. + +1883. + + + +FEUILLET'S "LA MORTE" + +[219] IN his latest novel M. Octave Feuillet adds two charming people +to that chosen group of personages in which he loves to trace the +development of the more serious elements of character amid the +refinements and artifices of modern society, and which make such good +company. The proper function of fictitious literature in affording +us a refuge into a world slightly better--better conceived, or better +finished--than the real one, is effected in most instances less +through the imaginary events at which a novelist causes us to assist, +than by the imaginary persons to whom he introduces us. The +situations of M. Feuillet's novels are indeed of a real and intrinsic +importance:--tragic crises, inherent in the general conditions of +human nature itself, or which arise necessarily out of the special +conditions of modern society. Still, with him, in the actual result, +they become subordinate, as it is their tendency to do in real life, +to the characters they help to form. Often, his most attentive +reader will have forgotten the actual details of his plot; while +[220] the soul, tried, enlarged, shaped by it, remains as a well- +fixed type in the memory. He may return a second or third time to +Sibylle, or Le Journal d'une Femme, or Les Amours de Philippe, and +watch, surprised afresh, the clean, dainty, word-sparing literary +operation (word-sparing, yet with no loss of real grace or ease) +which, sometimes in a few pages, with the perfect logic of a problem +of Euclid, complicates and then unravels some moral embarrassment, +really worthy of a trained dramatic expert. But the characters +themselves, the agents in those difficult, revealing situations, such +a reader will recognise as old acquaintances after the first reading, +feeling for them as for some gifted and attractive persons he has +known in the actual world--Raoul de Chalys, Henri de Lerne, Madame de +Técle, Jeanne de la Roche-Ermel, Maurice de Frémeuse, many others; to +whom must now be added Bernard and Aliette de Vaudricourt. + +"How I love those people!" cries Mademoiselle de Courteheuse, of +Madame de Sévigné and some other of her literary favourites in the +days of the Grand Monarch. "What good company! What pleasure they +took in high things! How much more worthy they were than the people +who live now!"--What good company! That is precisely what the +admirer of M. Feuillet's books feels as one by one he places them on +his book-shelf, to be sought again. What is proposed here is not to +tell his last story, [221] but to give the English reader specimens +of his most recent effort at characterisation. + +It is with the journal of Bernard himself that the story opens, +September 187-. Bernard-Maurice Hugon de Montauret, Vicomte de +Vaudricourt, is on a visit to his uncle, the head of his family, at +La Savinière, a country-house somewhere between Normandy and +Brittany. This uncle, an artificial old Parisian in manner, but +honest in purpose, a good talker, and full of real affection for his +heir Bernard, is one of M. Feuillet's good minor characters--one of +the quietly humorous figures with which he relieves his more serious +company. Bernard, with whom the refinements of a man of fashion in +the Parisian world by no means disguise a powerful intelligence +cultivated by wide reading, has had thoughts during his tedious stay +at La Savinière of writing a history of the reign of Louis the +Fourteenth, the library of a neighbouring château being rich in +memoirs of that period. Finally, he prefers to write his own story, +a story so much more interesting to himself; to write it at a +peculiar crisis in his life, the moment when his uncle, unmarried, +but anxious to perpetuate his race, is bent on providing him with a +wife, and indeed has one in view. + +The accomplished Bernard, with many graces of person, by his own +confession, takes nothing seriously. As to that matter of religious +beliefs, "the breeze of the age, and of science, has blown [222] over +him, as it has blown over his contemporaries, and left empty space +there." Still, when he saw his childish religious faith departing +from him, as he thinks it must necessarily depart from all +intelligent male Parisians, he wept. Since that moment, however, a +gaiety, serene and imperturbable, has been the mainstay of his +happily constituted character. The girl to whom his uncle desires to +see him united--odd, quixotic, intelligent, with a sort of pathetic +and delicate grace, and herself very religious--belongs to an old- +fashioned, devout family,. resident at Varaville, near by. M. +Feuillet, with half a dozen fine touches of his admirable pencil +makes us see the place. And the enterprise has at least sufficient +interest to keep Bernard in the country, which the young Parisian +detests. "This piquant episode of my life," he writes, "seems to me +to be really deserving of study; to be worth etching off, day by day, +by an observer well informed on the subject." + +Recognising in himself, though as his one real fault, that he can +take nothing seriously in heaven or earth, Bernard de Vaudricourt, +like all M. Feuillet's favourite young men, so often erring or +corrupt, is a man of scrupulous "honour." He has already shown +disinterestedness in wishing his rich uncle to marry again. His +friends at Varaville think so well-mannered a young man more of a +Christian than he really is; and, at all events, he will never owe +his happiness to a falsehood. If he has great faults, [223] +hypocrisy at least is no part of them. In oblique paths he finds +himself ill at ease. Decidedly, as he thinks, he was born for +straight ways, for loyalty in all his enterprises; and he +congratulates himself upon the fact. + +In truth, Bernard has merits which he ignores, at least in this first +part of his journal: merits which are necessary to explain the +influence he is able to exercise from the first over such a character +as Mademoiselle de Courteheuse. His charm, in fact, is in the union +of that gay and apparently wanton nature with a genuine power of +appreciating devotion in others, which becomes devotion in himself. +With all the much-cherished elegance and worldly glitter of his +personality, he is capable of apprehending, of understanding and +being touched by the presence of great matters. In spite of that +happy lightness of heart, so jealously fenced about, he is to be +wholly caught at last, as he is worthy to be, by the serious, the +generous influence of things. In proportion to his immense worldly +strength is his capacity for the immense pity which breaks his heart. + +In a few life-like touches M. Feuillet brings out, as if it were +indeed a thing of ordinary existence, the simple yet delicate life of +a French country-house, the ideal life in an ideal France. Bernard +is paying a morning visit at the old turreted home of the +"prehistoric" Courteheuse family. Mademoiselle Aliette de +Courteheuse, a studious girl, though a bold and excellent rider [224] +--Mademoiselle de Courteheuse, "with her hair of that strange colour +of fine ashes"--has conducted her visitor to see the library: + +One day she took me to see the library, rich in works of the +seventeenth century and in memoirs relating to that time. I +remarked there also a curious collection of engravings of the +same period. "Your father," I observed, "had a strong +predilection for the age of Louis the Fourteenth." + +"My father lived in that age," she answered gravely. And as +I looked at her with surprise, and a little embarrassed, she +added, "He made me live there too, in his company." + +And then the eyes of this singular girl filled with tears. +She turned away, took a few steps to suppress her emotion, and +returning, pointed me to a chair. Then seating herself on the +step of the book-case, she said, "I must explain my father +to you." + +She was half a minute collecting her thoughts: then, speaking +with an expansion of manner not habitual with her, hesitating, +and blushing deeply, whenever she was about to utter a word that +might seem a shade too serious for lips so youthful:--"My +father," she proceeded, "died of the consequences of a wound he +had received at Patay. That may show you that he loved his +country, but he was no lover of his own age. He possessed in +the highest degree the love of order; and order was a thing +nowhere to be seen. He had a horror of disorder; and he saw it +everywhere. In those last years, especially, his reverence, +his beliefs, his tastes, all alike were ruffled to the point of +actual suffering, by whatever was done and said and written +around him. Deeply saddened by the conditions of the present +time, he habituated himself to find a refuge in the past, and +the seventeenth century more particularly offered him the kind +of society in which he would have wished to live--a society, +well-ordered, polished, lettered, believing. More and more he +loved to shut himself up in it. More and more also he loved to +make the moral discipline and the literary tastes of that +favourite age prevail in his own household. You may even have +remarked that he carried his predilection into minute matters of +arrangement and decoration. You can see from this window the +straight paths, the box in [225] patterns, the yew trees and +clipped alleys of our garden. You may notice that in our garden- +beds we have none but flowers of the period--lilies, rose-mallows, +immortelles, rose-pinks, in short what people call parsonage +flowers--des fleurs de curé. Our old silvan tapestries, +similarly, are of that age. You see too that all our furniture, +from presses and sideboards, down to our little tables and our +arm-chairs, is in the severest style of Louis the Fourteenth. +My father did not appreciate the dainty research of our modern +luxury. He maintained that our excessive care for the comforts +of life weakened mind as well as body. That," added the girl +with a laugh,--"that is why you find your chair so hard when +you come to see us." + +Then, with resumed gravity--"It was thus that my father +endeavoured, by the very aspect and arrangement of outward +things, to promote in himself the imaginary presence of the +epoch in which his thoughts delighted. As for myself--need I +tell you that I was the confidant of that father, so well- +beloved: a confidant touched by his sorrows, full of +indignation at his disappointments, charmed by his consolations. +Here, precisely--surrounded by those books which we read +together, and which he taught me to love--it is here that I +have passed the pleasantest hours of my youth. In common we +indulged our enthusiasm for those days of faith; of the quiet +life; its blissful hours of leisure well-secured; for the +French language in its beauty and purity; the delicate, the +noble urbanity, which was then the honour and the special mark +of our country, but has ceased to be so." + +She paused, with a little confusion, as I thought, at the warmth +of her last words. + +And then, just to break the silence, "You have explained," I +said, "an impression which I have experienced again and again +in my visits here, and which has sometimes reached the intensity +of an actual illusion, though a very agreeable one. The look +of your house, its style, its tone and keeping, carried me two +centuries back so completely that I should hardly have been +surprised to hear Monsieur le Prince, Madame de la Fayette, +or Madame de Sévigné herself, announced at your drawing- +room door." + +"Would it might be!" said Mademoiselle de Courteheuse. [226] +"Ah! Monsieur, how I love those people! What good company! +What pleasure they took in high things! How much more worthy +they were than the people who live now!" I tried to calm a +little this retrospective enthusiasm, so much to the prejudice +of my contemporaries and of myself. "Most truly, +Mademoiselle," I said, "the age which you regret had its +rare merits--merits which I appreciate as you do. But then, +need one say that that society, so regular, so choice in +appearance, had, like our own, below the surface, its troubles, +its disorders? I see here many of the memoirs of that time. +I can't tell exactly which of them you may or may not have read, +and so I feel a certain difficulty in speaking." + +She interrupted me: "Ah!" she said, with entire simplicity, "I +understand you. I have not read all you see here. But I have +read enough of it to know that my friends in that past age had, +like those who live now, their passions, their weaknesses, +their mistakes. But, as my father used to say to me, all that +did but pass over a ground of what was solid and serious, which +always discovered itself again anew. There were great faults +then; but there were also great repentances. There was a +certain higher region to which everything conducted--even what +as evil." She blushed deeply: then rising a little suddenly, +"A long speech!" she said: "Forgive me! I am not usually so +very talkative. It is because my father was in question; and +I should wish his memory to be as dear and as venerable to all +the rest of the world as it is to me." + +We pass over the many little dramatic intrigues and misunderstandings, +with the more or less adroit interferences of the uncle, which raise +and lower alternately Bernard's hopes. M. Feuillet has more than once +tried his hand with striking success in the portraiture of French +ecclesiastics. He has drawn none better than the Bishop of Saint-Méen, +uncle of Mademoiselle de Courteheuse, to whose interests he is devoted. +Bernard feels that to gain the influence of this prelate [227] would +be to gain his cause; and the opportunity for an interview comes. + +Monseigneur de Courteheuse would seem to be little over fifty +years of age: he is rather tall, and very thin: the eyes, black +and full of life, are encircled by a ring of deep brown. His +speech and gesture are animated, and, at times, as if carried +away. He adopts frequently a sort of furious manner which +on a sudden melts into the smile of an honest man. He has +beautiful silvery hair, flying in vagrant locks over his +forehead, and beautiful bishop's hands. As he becomes calm +he has an imposing way of gently resettling himself in his +sacerdotal dignity. To sum up: his is a physiognomy full of +passion, consumed with zeal, yet still frank and sincere. + +I was hardly seated, when with a motion of the hand he invited +me to speak. + +"Monseigneur!" I said, "I come to you (you understand me?) as +to my last resource. What I am now doing is almost an act of +despair; for it might seem at first sight that no member of +the family of Mademoiselle de Courteheuse must show himself +more pitiless than yourself towards the faults with which I +am reproached. I am an unbeliever: you are an apostle! And +yet, Monseigneur, it is often at the hands of saintly priests, +such as yourself, that the guilty find most indulgence. And +then, I am not indeed guilty: I have but wandered. I am refused +the hand of your niece because I do not share her faith--your +own faith. But, Monseigneur, unbelief is not a crime, it is +a misfortune. I know people often say, a man denies God when +by his own conduct he has brought himself into a condition in +which he may well desire that God does not exist. In this +way he is made guilty, or, in a sense, responsible for his +incredulity. For myself, Monseigneur, I have consulted my +conscience with an entire sincerity; and although my youth has +been amiss, I am certain that my atheism proceeds from no +sentiment of personal interest. On the contrary, I may tell you +with truth that the day on which I perceived my faith come to +nought, the day on which I lost hope in God, I shed the bitterest +tears of my life. In spite of appearances, I am not so light a +spirit as people think. I am not one of those for whom God, +when He disappears, [228] leaves no sense of a void place. +Believe me!--a man may love sport, his club, his worldly +habits, and yet have his hours of thought, of self- +recollection. Do you suppose that in those hours one does +not feel the frightful discomfort of an existence with no +moral basis, without principles, with no outlook beyond this +world? And yet, what can one do? You would tell me forthwith, +in the goodness, the compassion, which I read in your eyes; +Confide to me your objections to religion, and I will try to +solve them. Monseigneur, I should hardly know how to answer +you. My objections are 'Legion!' They are without number, +like the stars in the sky: they come to us on all sides, from +every quarter of the horizon, as if on the wings of the wind; +and they leave in us, as they pass, ruins only, and darkness. +Such has been my experience, and that of many others; and it +has been as involuntary as it is irreparable." + +"And I--Monsieur!" said the bishop, suddenly, casting on me +one of his august looks, "Do you suppose that I am but a +play-actor in my cathedral church?" + +"Monseigneur!" + +"Yes! Listening to you, one would suppose that we were come +to a period of the world in which one must needs be either an +atheist or a hypocrite! Personally, I claim to be neither +one nor the other." + +"Need I defend myself on that point, Monseigneur? Need I say +that I did not come here to give you offence?" + +"Doubtless! doubtless! Well, Monsieur, I admit; not without +great reserves, mind! for one is always more or less responsible +for the atmosphere in which he lives, the influences to which +he is subject, for the habitual turn he gives to his thoughts; +still, I admit that you are the victim of the incredulity of the +age, that you are altogether guiltless in your scepticism, your +atheism! since you have no fear of hard words. Is it therefore +any the less certain that the union of a fervent believer, such +as my niece, with a man like yourself would be a moral disorder +of which the consequences might be disastrous? Do you think it +could be my duty, as a relative of Mademoiselle de Courteheuse, +her spiritual father, as a prelate of the Church, to lend my +hands to such disorder, to preside over the shocking union of +two souls separated by the whole width of heaven?" + +[229] The bishop, in proposing that question, kept his eyes +fixed ardently on mine. + +"Monseigneur," I answered, after a moment's embarrassment, "you +know as well as, and better than I, the condition of the world, +and of our country, at this time. You know that unhappily I +am not an exception: that men of faith are rare in it. And +permit me to tell you my whole mind. If I must needs suffer +the inconsolable misfortune of renouncing the happiness I had +hoped for, are you quite sure that the man to whom one of these +days you will give your niece may not be something more than +a sceptic, or even an atheist?" + +"What, Monsieur?" + +"A hypocrite, Monseigneur! Mademoiselle de Courteheuse is +beautiful enough, rich enough, to excite the ambition of those +who may be less scrupulous than I. As for me, if you now know +that I am a sceptic, you know also that I am a man of honour: +and there is something in that!" + +"A man of honour!" the bishop muttered to himself, with a +little petulance and hesitation. "A man of honour! Yes, I +believe it!" Then, after an interval, "Come, Monsieur," he +said gently, "your case is not as desperate as you suppose. +My Aliette is one of those young enthusiasts through whom +Heaven sometimes works miracles." And Bernard refusing any +encouragement of that hope (the "very roots of faith are +dead" in him for ever) "since you think that," the bishop +answers, "it is honest to say so. But God has His ways!" + +Soon after, the journal comes to an end with that peculiar crisis in +Bernard's life which had suggested the writing of it. Aliette, with +the approval of her family, has given him her hand. Bernard accepts +it with the full purpose of doing all he can to make his wife as +happy as she is charming and beloved. The virginal first period of +their married life in their dainty house in Paris--the pure and +beautiful picture of the mother, the father, and at last the child, a +little [230] girl, Jeanne--is presented with M. Feuillet's usual +grace. Certain embarrassments succeed; the development of what was +ill-matched in their union; but still with mutual loyalty. A far- +reaching acquaintance with, and reflection upon, the world and its +ways, especially the Parisian world, has gone into the apparently +slight texture of these pages. The accomplished playwright may be +recognised in the skilful touches with which M. Feuillet, unrivalled, +as his regular readers know, in his power of breathing higher notes +into the frivolous prattle of fashionable French life, develops the +tragic germ in the elegant, youthful household. Amid the +distractions of a society, frivolous, perhaps vulgar, Aliette's mind +is still set on greater things; and, in spite of a thousand rude +discouragements, she maintains her generous hope for Bernard's +restoration to faith. One day, a little roughly, he bids her +relinquish that dream finally. She looks at him with the moist, +suppliant eyes of some weak animal at bay. Then his native goodness +returns. In a softened tone he owns himself wrong. + +"As to conversions;--no one must be despaired of. Do you +remember M. de Rancé? He lived in your favourite age;--M. de +Rancé. Well! before he became the reformer of La Trappe he +had been a worldling like me, and a great sceptic--what +people called a libertine. Still he became a saint! It is +true he had a terrible reason for it. Do you know what it +was converted him?" + +Aliette gave a sign that she did not know. + +"Well! he returned to Paris after a few days' absence. He +[231] ran straight to the lady he loved; Madame Montbazon, +I think: he went up a little staircase of which he had the +key, and the first thing he saw on the table in the middle +of the room was the head of his mistress, of which the +doctors were about to make a post-mortem examination." + +"If I were sure," said Aliette, "that my head could have +such power, I would love to die." + +She said it in a low voice, but with such an accent of loving +sincerity that her husband had a sensation of a sort of painful +disquiet. He smiled, however, and tapping her cheek softly, +"Folly!" he said. "A head, charming as yours, has no need to +be dead that it may work miracles!" + +Certainly M. Feuillet has some weighty charges to bring against the +Parisian society of our day. When Aliette revolts from a world of +gossip, which reduces all minds alike to the same level of vulgar +mediocrity, Bernard, on his side, can perceive there a deterioration +of moral tone which shocks his sense of honour. As a man of honour, +he can hardly trust his wife to the gaieties of a society which +welcomes all the world "to amuse itself in undress." + +It happened that at this perplexed period in the youthful +household, one and the same person became the recipient both +of the tearful confidences of Madame de Vaudricourt and those +of her husband. It was the Duchess of Castel-Moret [she is +another of M. Feuillet's admirable minor sketches] an old +friend of the Vaudricourt family, and the only woman with +whom Aliette since her arrival in Paris had formed a kind +of intimacy. The Duchess was far from sharing, on points +of morality, and above all of religion, the severe and +impassioned orthodoxy of her young friend. She had lived, +it is true, an irreproachable life, but less in consequence +of defined principles than by instinct and natural taste. +She admitted to herself that she was an honest woman as a +result of her birth, and had no further merit in the matter. +She was old, very careful of [232] herself, and a pleasant +aroma floated about her, below her silvery hair. People +loved her for her grace--the grace of another time than ours-- +for her wit, and her worldly wisdom, which she placed freely +at the disposal of the public. Now and then she made a match: +but her special gift lay rather in the way in which she came +to the rescue when a marriage turned out ill. And she had no +sinecure: the result was that she passed the best part of her +time in repairing family rents. That might "last its time," +she would say. "And then we know that what has been well +mended sometimes lasts better than what is new." + +A little later, Bernard, in the interest of Aliette, has chivalrously +determined to quit Paris. At Valmoutiers, a fine old place in the +neighbourhood of Fontainebleau, they established themselves for a +country life. Here Aliette tastes the happiest days since her +marriage. Bernard, of course, after a little time is greatly bored. +But so far they have never seriously doubted of their great love for +each other. It is here that M. Feuillet brings on the scene a kind +of character new in his books; perhaps hardly worthy of the other +company there; a sort of female Monsieur de Camors, but without his +grace and tenderness, and who actually commits a crime. How would +the morbid charms of M. de Camors have vanished, if, as his wife once +suspected of him, he had ever contemplated crime! And surely, the +showy insolent charms of Sabine de Tallevaut, beautiful, +intellectually gifted, supremely Amazonian, yet withal not drawn with +M. Feuillet's usual fineness, scarcely hold out for the reader, any +more than for [233] Bernard himself, in the long run, against the +vulgarising touch of her cold wickedness. Living in the +neighbourhood of Valmoutiers, in a somewhat melancholy abode (the +mystery of which in the eyes of Bernard adds to her poetic charm) +with her guardian, an old, rich, freethinking doctor, devoted to +research, she comes to Valmoutiers one night in his company on the +occasion of the alarming illness of the only child. They arrive +escorted by Bernard himself. The little Jeanne, wrapped in her +coverlet, was placed upon the table of her play-room, which was +illuminated as if for a party. The illness, the operation (skilfully +performed by the old doctor) which restores her to life, are +described with that seemingly simple pathos in which M. Feuillet's +consummate art hides itself. Sabine remains to watch the child's +recovery, and becomes an intimate. In vain Bernard struggles against +the first real passion of his life;--does everything but send its +object out of his sight. Aliette has divined their secret. In the +fatal illness which follows soon after, Bernard watches over her with +tender solicitude; hoping against hope that the disease may take a +favourable turn. + +"My child," he said to her one day, taking the hand which +she abandoned to him, "I have just been scolding old Victoire. +She is losing her head. In spite of the repeated assurances +of the doctors, she is alarmed at seeing you a little worse +than usual to-day, and has had the Curé sent for. Do you +wish to see him?" + +"Pray let me see him!" + +[234] She sighed heavily, and fixed upon her husband her large +blue eyes, full of anguish--an anguish so sharp and so singular +that he felt frozen to the marrow. + +He could not help saying with deep emotion, "Do you love me no +longer, Aliette?" + +"For ever!" murmured the poor child. + +He leaned over her with a long kiss upon the forehead. She saw +tears stealing from the eyes of her husband, and seemed as if +surprised. + +Soon afterwards Aliette is dead, to the profound sorrow of Bernard. +Less than two years later he has become the husband of Mademoiselle +Tallevaut. It was about two years after his marriage with Sabine +that Bernard resumed the journal with which we began. In the pages +which he now adds he seems at first unchanged. How then as to that +story of M. de Rancé, the reformer of La Trappe, finding the head of +his dead mistress; an incident which the reader of La Morte will +surely have taken as a "presentiment"? Aliette had so taken it. "A +head so charming as yours," Bernard had assured her tenderly, "does +not need to be dead that it may work miracles!"--How, in the few +pages that remain, will M. Feuillet justify that, and certain other +delicate touches of presentiment, and at the same time justify the +title of his book? + +The journal is recommenced in February. On the twentieth of April +Bernard writes, at Valmoutiers: + +Under pretext of certain urgently needed repairs I am come to +pass a week at Valmoutiers, and get a little pure air. By my +orders they have kept Aliette's room under lock and key since +[235] the day when she left it in her coffin. To-day I re- +entered it for the first time. There was a vague odour of her +favourite perfumes. My poor Aliette! why was I unable, as you +so ardently desired, to share your gentle creed, and associate +myself to the life of your dreams, the life of honesty and peace? +Compared with that which is mine to-day, it seems to me like +paradise. What a terrible scene it was, here in this room! What +a memory! I can still see the last look she fixed on me, a look +almost of terror! and how quickly she died! I have taken the room +for my own. But I shall not remain here long. I intend to go +for a few days to Varaville. I want to see my little girl: her +dear angel's face. + +VALMOUTIERS, April 22.--What a change there has been in the world +since my childhood: since my youth even! what a surprising change +in so short a period, in the moral atmosphere we are breathing! +Then we were, as it were, impregnated with the thought of God--a +just God, but benevolent and fatherlike. We really lived under +His eyes, as under the eyes of a parent, with respect and fear, +but with confidence. We felt sustained by His invisible but +undoubted presence. We spoke to Him, and it seemed that He +answered. And now we feel ourselves alone--as it were abandoned +in the immensity of the universe. We live in a world, hard, +savage, full of hatred; whose one cruel law is the struggle for +existence, and in which we are no more than those natural elements, +let loose to war with each other in fierce selfishness, without +pity, with no appeal beyond, no hope of final justice. And above +us, in place of the good God of our happy youth, nothing, any +more! or worse than nothing--a deity, barbarous and ironical, +who cares nothing at all about us. + +The aged mother of Aliette, hitherto the guardian of his daughter, +is lately dead. Bernard proposes to take the child away with +him to Paris. The child's old nurse objects. On April the twenty- +seventh, Bernard writes: + +For a moment--for a few moments--in that room where I have been +shutting myself up with the shadow of my poor [236] dead one, a +horrible thought had come to me. I had driven it away as an +insane fancy. But now, yes! it is becoming a reality. Shall I +write this? Yes! I will write it. It is my duty to do so; for +from this moment the journal, begun in so much gaiety of heart, +is but my last will and testament. If I should disappear from +the world, the secret must not die with me. It must be bequeathed +to the natural protectors of my child. Her interests, if not her +life, are concerned therein. + +Here, then, is what passed: I had not arrived in time to render +my last duty to Madame de Courteheuse. The family was already +dispersed. I found here only Aliette's brother. To him I +communicated my plan concerning the child, and he could but +approve. My intention was to bring away with Jeanne her nurse +Victoire, who had brought her up, as she brought up her mother. +But she is old, and in feeble health, and I feared some +difficulties on her part; the more as her attitude towards myself +since the death of my first wife has been marked by an ill grace +approaching to hostility. I took her aside while Jeanne was +playing in the garden. + +"My good Victoire," I said, "while Madame de Courteheuse was +living, I considered it a duty to leave her granddaughter in +her keeping. Besides, no one was better fitted to watch over +her education. At present my duty is to watch over it myself. +I propose therefore to take Jeanne with me to Paris; and I hope +that you may be willing to accompany her, and remain in her +service." When she understood my intention, the old woman, in +whose hands I had noticed a faint trembling, became suddenly +very pale. She fixed her firm, grey eyes upon me: "Monsieur +le Comte will not do that!" + +"Pardon me, my good Victoire, that I shall do. I appreciate +your good qualities of fidelity and devotion. I shall be very +grateful if you will continue to take care of my daughter, as +you have done so excellently. But for the rest, I intend to +be the only master in my own house, and the only master of my +child." She laid a hand upon my arm: "I implore you, Monsieur, +don't do this!" Her fixed look did not leave my face, and +seemed to be questioning me to the very bottom of my soul. +"I have never believed it," she murmured, "No! I [237] never +could believe it. But if you take the child away I shall." + +"Believe what, wretched woman? believe what?" + +Her voice sank lower still. "Believe that you knew how her +mother came by her death; and that you mean the daughter to +die as she did." + +"Die as her mother did?" + +"Yes! by the same hand!" + +The sweat came on my forehead. I felt as it were a breathing of +death upon me. But still I thrust away from me that terrible +light on things. + +"Victoire!" I said, "take care! You are no fool: you are +something worse. Your hatred of the woman who has taken the +place of my first wife--your blind hatred--has suggested to +you odious, nay! criminal words." + +"Ah! Ah! Monsieur", she cried with wild energy. "After +what I have just told you, take your daughter to live with +that woman if you dare." + +I walked up and down the room awhile to collect my senses. +Then, returning to the old woman, "Yet how can I believe you?" +I asked. "If you had had the shadow of a proof of what you +give me to understand, how could you have kept silence so long? +How could you have allowed me to contract that hateful marriage?" + +She seemed more confident, and her voice grew gentler. "Monsieur, +it is because Madame, before she went to God, made me take oath +on the crucifix to keep that secret for ever." + +"Yet not with me, in fact,--not with me!" And I, in turn, +questioned her; my eyes upon hers. She hesitated: then +stammered out, "True! not with you! because she believed, poor +little soul! that..." + +"What did she believe? That I knew it? That I was an accomplice? +Tell me!" Her eyes fell, and she made no answer. "Is it +possible, my God, is it possible? But come, sit by me here, and +tell me all you know, all you saw. At what time was it you +noticed anything--the precise moment?" For in truth she had +been suffering for a long time past. + +Victoire tells the miserable story of Sabine's [238] crime--we must +pardon what we think a not quite worthy addition to the imaginary +world M. Feuillet has called up round about him, for the sake of +fully knowing Bernard and Aliette. The old nurse had surprised her +in the very act, and did not credit her explanation. "When I +surprised her," she goes on: + +"It may already have been too late--be sure it was not the first +time she had been guilty--my first thought was to give you +information. But I had not the courage. Then I told Madame. +I thought I saw plainly that I had nothing to tell she was not +already aware of. Nevertheless she chided me almost harshly. +'You know very well,' she said, 'that my husband is always there +when Mademoiselle prepares the medicines. So that he too would +be guilty. Rather than believe that, I would accept death at +his hands a hundred times over!' And I remember, Monsieur, how +at the very moment when she told me that, you came out from +the little boudoir, and brought her a glass of valerian. She +cast on me a terrible look and drank. A few minutes afterwards +she was so ill that she thought the end was come. She begged +me to give her her crucifix, and made me swear never to utter +a word concerning our suspicions. It was then I sent for the +priest. I have told you, Monsieur, what I know; what I have +seen with my own eyes. I swear that I have said nothing but +what is absolutely true." She paused. I could not answer her. +I seized her old wrinkled and trembling hands and pressed them +to my forehead, and wept like a child. + +May 10.--She died believing me guilty! The thought is terrible +to me. I know not what to do. A creature so frail, so +delicate, so sweet. "Yes!" she said to herself, "my husband +is a murderer; what he is giving me is poison, and he knows +it." She died with that thought in her mind--her last thought. +And she will never, never know that it was not so; that I am +innocent; that the thought is torment to me: that I am the most +unhappy of men. Ah! God, all-powerful! if you indeed exist, +you see what I suffer. Have pity on me! + +Ah! how I wish I could believe that all is not over between +[239] her and me; that she sees and hears me; that she knew +the truth. But I find it impossible! impossible! + +June.--That I was a criminal was her last thought, and she +will never be undeceived. + +All seems so completely ended when one dies. All returns to +its first elements. How credit that miracle of a personal +resurrection? and yet in truth all is mystery,--miracle, +around us, about us, within ourselves. The entire universe +is but a continuous miracle. Man's new birth from the womb +of death--is it a mystery less comprehensible than his birth +from the womb of his mother? + +Those lines are the last written by Bernard de Vaudricourt. +His health, for some time past disturbed by grief, was +powerless against the emotions of the last terrible trial +imposed on him. A malady, the exact nature of which was +not determined, in a few days assumed a mortal character. +Perceiving that his end was come, he caused Monseigneur +de Courteheuse to be summoned--he desired to die in the +religion of Aliette. Living, the poor child had been +defeated: she prevailed in her death. + +Two distinguished souls! deux êtres d'élite--M. Feuillet thinks-- +whose fine qualities properly brought them together. When +Mademoiselle de Courteheuse said of the heroes of her favourite age, +that their passions, their errors, did but pass over a ground of what +was solid and serious, and which always discovered itself afresh, she +was unconsciously describing Bernard. Singular young brother of +Monsieur de Camors--after all, certainly, more fortunate than he--he +belongs to the age, which, if it had great faults, had also great +repentances. In appearance, frivolous; with all the light charm of +the world, yet with that impressibility to great things, according to +the law which makes the best of M. Feuillet's [240] characters so +interesting; above all, with that capacity for pity which almost +everything around him tended to suppress; in real life, if he exists +there, and certainly in M. Feuillet's pages, it is a refreshment to +meet him. + +1886. + + + +POSTSCRIPT + +ainei de palaion men oinon, anthea d' hymnon neôterôn+ + +[241] THE words, classical and romantic, although, like many other +critical expressions, sometimes abused by those who have understood +them too vaguely or too absolutely, yet define two real tendencies +in the history of art and literature. Used in an exaggerated sense, +to express a greater opposition between those tendencies than really +exists, they have at times tended to divide people of taste into +opposite camps. But in that House Beautiful, which the creative +minds of all generations--the artists and those who have treated +life in the spirit of art--are always building together, for the +refreshment of the human spirit, these oppositions cease; and the +Interpreter of the House Beautiful, the true aesthetic critic, uses +these divisions, only so far as they enable him to enter into the +peculiarities of the objects with which he has to do. The term +classical, fixed, as it is, to a well-defined literature, and a well- +defined group in art, is clear, indeed; but then it has often been +used in a hard, and merely scholastic [242] sense, by the praisers of +what is old and accustomed, at the expense of what is new, by critics +who would never have discovered for themselves the charm of any work, +whether new or old, who value what is old, in art or literature, for +its accessories, and chiefly for the conventional authority that has +gathered about it--people who would never really have been made glad +by any Venus fresh-risen from the sea, and who praise the Venus of +old Greece and Rome, only because they fancy her grown now into +something staid and tame. + +And as the term, classical, has been used in a too absolute, and +therefore in a misleading sense, so the term, romantic, has been used +much too vaguely, in various accidental senses. The sense in which +Scott is called a romantic writer is chiefly this; that, in +opposition to the literary tradition of the last century, he loved +strange adventure, and sought it in the Middle Age. Much later, in a +Yorkshire village, the spirit of romanticism bore a more really +characteristic fruit in the work of a young girl, Emily Brontë, the +romance of Wuthering Heights; the figures of Hareton Earnshaw, of +Catherine Linton, and of Heathcliffe--tearing open Catherine's grave, +removing one side of her coffin, that he may really lie beside her in +death--figures so passionate, yet woven on a background of delicately +beautiful, moorland scenery, being typical examples of that spirit. +In Germany, again, [243] that spirit is shown less in Tieck, its +professional representative, than in Meinhold, the author of Sidonia +the Sorceress and the Amber-Witch. In Germany and France, within the +last hundred years, the term has been used to describe a particular +school of writers; and, consequently, when Heine criticises the +Romantic School in Germany--that movement which culminated in +Goethe's Goetz von Berlichingen; or when Théophile Gautier criticises +the romantic movement in France, where, indeed, it bore its most +characteristic fruits, and its play is hardly yet over where, by a +certain audacity, or bizarrerie of motive, united with faultless +literary execution, it still shows itself in imaginative literature, +they use the word, with an exact sense of special artistic qualities, +indeed; but use it, nevertheless, with a limited application to the +manifestation of those qualities at a particular period. But the +romantic spirit is, in reality, an ever-present, an enduring +principle, in the artistic temperament; and the qualities of thought +and style which that, and other similar uses of the word romantic +really indicate, are indeed but symptoms of a very continuous and +widely working influence. + +Though the words classical and romantic, then, have acquired an +almost technical meaning, in application to certain developments of +German and French taste, yet this is but one variation of an old +opposition, which may be traced from the [244] very beginning of the +formation of European art and literature. From the first formation +of anything like a standard of taste in these things, the restless +curiosity of their more eager lovers necessarily made itself felt, in +the craving for new motives, new subjects of interest, new +modifications of style. Hence, the opposition between the +classicists and the romanticists--between the adherents, in the +culture of beauty, of the principles of liberty, and authority, +respectively--of strength, and order or what the Greeks called +kosmiotês.+ + +Sainte-Beuve, in the third volume of the Causeries du Lundi, has +discussed the question, What is meant by a classic? It was a +question he was well fitted to answer, having himself lived through +many phases of taste, and having been in earlier life an enthusiastic +member of the romantic school: he was also a great master of that +sort of "philosophy of literature," which delights in tracing +traditions in it, and the way in which various phases of thought and +sentiment maintain themselves, through successive modifications, from +epoch to epoch. His aim, then, is to give the word classic a wider +and, as he says, a more generous sense than it commonly bears, to +make it expressly grandiose et flottant; and, in doing this, he +develops, in a masterly manner, those qualities of measure, purity, +temperance, of which it is the especial function of classical art +[245] and literature, whatever meaning, narrower or wider, we attach +to the term, to take care. + +The charm, therefore, of what is classical, in art or literature, is +that of the well-known tale, to which we can, nevertheless, listen +over and over again, because it is told so well. To the absolute +beauty of its artistic form, is added the accidental, tranquil, charm +of familiarity. There are times, indeed, at which these charms fail +to work on our spirits at all, because they fail to excite us. +"Romanticism," says Stendhal, "is the art of presenting to people the +literary works which, in the actual state of their habits and +beliefs, are capable of giving them the greatest possible pleasure; +classicism, on the contrary, of presenting them with that which gave +the greatest possible pleasure to their grandfathers." But then, +beneath all changes of habits and beliefs, our love of that mere +abstract proportion--of music--which what is classical in literature +possesses, still maintains itself in the best of us, and what pleased +our grandparents may at least tranquillise us. The "classic" comes +to us out of the cool and quiet of other times; as the measure of +what a long experience has shown will at least never displease us. +And in the classical literature of Greece and Rome, as in the +classics of the last century, the essentially classical element is +that quality of order in beauty, which they possess, indeed, [246] in +a pre-eminent degree, and which impresses some minds to the exclusion +of everything else in them. + +It is the addition of strangeness to beauty, that constitutes the +romantic character in art; and the desire of beauty being a fixed +element in every artistic organisation, it is the addition of +curiosity to this desire of beauty, that constitutes the romantic +temper. Curiosity and the desire of beauty, have each their place in +art, as in all true criticism. When one's curiosity is deficient, +when one is not eager enough for new impressions, and new pleasures, +one is liable to value mere academical proprieties too highly, to be +satisfied with worn-out or conventional types, with the insipid +ornament of Racine, or the prettiness of that later Greek sculpture, +which passed so long for true Hellenic work; to miss those places +where the handiwork of nature, or of the artist, has been most +cunning; to find the most stimulating products of art a mere +irritation. And when one's curiosity is in excess, when it +overbalances the desire of beauty, then one is liable to value in +works of art what is inartistic in them; to be satisfied with what is +exaggerated in art, with productions like some of those of the +romantic school in Germany; not to distinguish, jealously enough, +between what is admirably done, and what is done not quite so well, +in the writings, for instance, of Jean Paul. And if I had to give +[247] instances of these defects, then I should say, that Pope, in +common with the age of literature to which he belonged, had too +little curiosity, so that there is always a certain insipidity in the +effect of his work, exquisite as it is; and, coming down to our own +time, that Balzac had an excess of curiosity--curiosity not duly +tempered with the desire of beauty. + +But, however falsely those two tendencies may be opposed by critics, +or exaggerated by artists themselves, they are tendencies really at +work at all times in art, moulding it, with the balance sometimes a +little on one side, sometimes a little on the other, generating, +respectively, as the balance inclines on this side or that, two +principles, two traditions, in art, and in literature so far as it +partakes of the spirit of art. If there is a great overbalance of +curiosity, then, we have the grotesque in art: if the union of +strangeness and beauty, under very difficult and complex conditions, +be a successful one, if the union be entire, then the resultant +beauty is very exquisite, very attractive. With a passionate care +for beauty, the romantic spirit refuses to have it, unless the +condition of strangeness be first fulfilled. Its desire is for a +beauty born of unlikely elements, by a profound alchemy, by a +difficult initiation, by the charm which wrings it even out of +terrible things; and a trace of distortion, of the grotesque, may +perhaps linger, as an additional element of expression, about its +[248] ultimate grace. Its eager, excited spirit will have strength, +the grotesque, first of all--the trees shrieking as you tear off the +leaves; for Jean Valjean, the long years of convict life; for +Redgauntlet, the quicksands of Solway Moss; then, incorporate with +this strangeness, and intensified by restraint, as much sweetness, as +much beauty, as is compatible with that. Énergique, frais, et +dispos--these, according to Sainte-Beuve, are the characteristics of +a genuine classic--les ouvrages anciens ne sont pas classiques parce +qu'ils sont vieux, mais parce qu'ils sont énergiques, frais, et +dispos. Energy, freshness, intelligent and masterly disposition:-- +these are characteristics of Victor Hugo when his alchemy is +complete, in certain figures, like Marius and Cosette, in certain +scenes, like that in the opening of Les Travailleurs de la Mer, where +Déruchette writes the name of Gilliatt in the snow, on Christmas +morning; but always there is a certain note of strangeness +discernible there, as well. + +The essential elements, then, of the romantic spirit are curiosity +and the love of beauty; and it is only as an illustration of these +qualities, that it seeks the Middle Age, because, in the over-charged +atmosphere of the Middle Age, there are unworked sources of romantic +effect, of a strange beauty, to be won, by strong imagination, out of +things unlikely or remote. + +Few, probably, now read Madame de Staël's [249] De l'Allemagne, +though it has its interest, the interest which never quite fades out +of work really touched with the enthusiasm of the spiritual +adventurer, the pioneer in culture. It was published in 1810, to +introduce to French readers a new school of writers--the romantic +school, from beyond the Rhine; and it was followed, twenty-three +years later, by Heine's Romantische Schule, as at once a supplement +and a correction. Both these books, then, connect romanticism with +Germany, with the names especially of Goethe and Tieck; and, to many +English readers, the idea of romanticism is still inseparably +connected with Germany--that Germany which, in its quaint old towns, +under the spire of Strasburg or the towers of Heidelberg, was always +listening in rapt inaction to the melodious, fascinating voices of +the Middle Age, and which, now that it has got Strasburg back again, +has, I suppose, almost ceased to exist. But neither Germany, with +its Goethe and Tieck, nor England, with its Byron and Scott, is +nearly so representative of the romantic temper as France, with +Murger, and Gautier, and Victor Hugo. It is in French literature +that its most characteristic expression is to be found; and that, as +most closely derivative, historically, from such peculiar conditions, +as ever reinforce it to the utmost. + +For, although temperament has much to do with the generation of the +romantic spirit, and [250] although this spirit, with its curiosity, +its thirst for a curious beauty, may be always traceable in excellent +art (traceable even in Sophocles) yet still, in a limited sense, it +may be said to be a product of special epochs. Outbreaks of this +spirit, that is, come naturally with particular periods--times, when, +in men's approaches towards art and poetry, curiosity may be noticed +to take the lead, when men come to art and poetry, with a deep thirst +for intellectual excitement, after a long ennui, or in reaction +against the strain of outward, practical things: in the later Middle +Age, for instance; so that medieval poetry, centering in Dante, is +often opposed to Greek and Roman poetry, as romantic poetry to the +classical. What the romanticism of Dante is, may be estimated, if we +compare the lines in which Virgil describes the hazel-wood, from +whose broken twigs flows the blood of Polydorus, not without the +expression of a real shudder at the ghastly incident, with the whole +canto of the Inferno, into which Dante has expanded them, beautifying +and softening it, meanwhile, by a sentiment of profound pity. And it +is especially in that period of intellectual disturbance, immediately +preceding Dante, amid which the romance languages define themselves +at last, that this temper is manifested. Here, in the literature of +Provence, the very name of romanticism is stamped with its true +signification: here we have indeed a romantic world, grotesque [251] +even, in the strength of its passions, almost insane in its curious +expression of them, drawing all things into its sphere, making the +birds, nay! lifeless things, its voices and messengers, yet so +penetrated with the desire for beauty and sweetness, that it begets a +wholly new species of poetry, in which the Renaissance may be said to +begin. The last century was pre-eminently a classical age, an age in +which, for art and literature, the element of a comely order was in +the ascendant; which, passing away, left a hard battle to be fought +between the classical and the romantic schools. Yet, it is in the +heart of this century, of Goldsmith and Stothard, of Watteau and the +Siècle de Louis XIV.--in one of its central, if not most +characteristic figures, in Rousseau--that the modern or French +romanticism really originates. But, what in the eighteenth century +is but an exceptional phenomenon, breaking through its fair reserve +and discretion only at rare intervals, is the habitual guise of the +nineteenth, breaking through it perpetually, with a feverishness, an +incomprehensible straining and excitement, which all experience to +some degree, but yearning also, in the genuine children of the +romantic school, to be énergique, frais, et dispos--for those +qualities of energy, freshness, comely order; and often, in Murger, +in Gautier, in Victor Hugo, for instance, with singular felicity +attaining them. + +It is in the terrible tragedy of Rousseau, in [252] fact, that French +romanticism, with much else, begins: reading his Confessions we seem +actually to assist at the birth of this new, strong spirit in the +French mind. The wildness which has shocked so many, and the +fascination which has influenced almost every one, in the squalid, +yet eloquent figure, we see and hear so clearly in that book, +wandering under the apple-blossoms and among the vines of Neuchâtel +or Vevey actually give it the quality of a very successful romantic +invention. His strangeness or distortion, his profound subjectivity, +his passionateness--the cor laceratum--Rousseau makes all men in love +with these. Je ne suis fait comme aucun de ceux que j'ai sus. Mais +si je ne vaux pas mieux, au moins je suis autre. "I am not made like +any one else I have ever known: yet, if I am not better, at least I +am different." These words, from the first page of the Confessions, +anticipate all the Werthers, Renés, Obermanns, of the last hundred +years. For Rousseau did but anticipate a trouble in the spirit of +the whole world; and thirty years afterwards, what in him was a +peculiarity, became part of the general consciousness. A storm was +coming: Rousseau, with others, felt it in the air, and they helped to +bring it down: they introduced a disturbing element into French +literature, then so trim and formal, like our own literature of the +age of Queen Anne. + +In 1815 the storm had come and gone, but had left, in the spirit of +"young France," the [253] ennui of an immense disillusion. In the +last chapter of Edgar Quinet's Revolution Française, a work itself +full of irony, of disillusion, he distinguishes two books, +Senancour's Obermann and Chateaubriand's Génie du Christianisme, as +characteristic of the first decade of the present century. In those +two books we detect already the disease and the cure--in Obermann the +irony, refined into a plaintive philosophy of "indifference"--in +Chateaubriand's Génie du Christianisme, the refuge from a tarnished +actual present, a present of disillusion, into a world of strength +and beauty in the Middle Age, as at an earlier period--in René and +Atala--into the free play of them in savage life. It is to minds in +this spiritual situation, weary of the present, but yearning for the +spectacle of beauty and strength, that the works of French +romanticism appeal. They set a positive value on the intense, the +exceptional; and a certain distortion is sometimes noticeable in +them, as in conceptions like Victor Hugo's Quasimodo, or Gwynplaine, +something of a terrible grotesque, of the macabre, as the French +themselves call it; though always combined with perfect literary +execution, as in Gautier's La Morte Amoureuse, or the scene of the +"maimed" burial-rites of the player, dead of the frost, in his +Capitaine Fracasse--true "flowers of the yew." It becomes grim +humour in Victor Hugo's combat of Gilliatt with the devil-fish, or +the incident, with all its ghastly comedy drawn [254] out at length, +of the great gun detached from its fastenings on shipboard, in +Quatre-Vingt-Trieze (perhaps the most terrible of all the accidents +that can happen by sea) and in the entire episode, in that book, of +the Convention. Not less surely does it reach a genuine pathos; for +the habit of noting and distinguishing one's own most intimate +passages of sentiment makes one sympathetic, begetting, as it must, +the power of entering, by all sorts of finer ways, into the intimate +recesses of other minds; so that pity is another quality of +romanticism, both Victor Hugo and Gautier being great lovers of +animals, and charming writers about them, and Murger being unrivalled +in the pathos of his Scènes de la Vie de Jeunesse. Penetrating so +finely into all situations which appeal to pity, above all, into the +special or exceptional phases of such feeling, the romantic humour is +not afraid of the quaintness or singularity of its circumstances or +expression, pity, indeed, being of the essence of humour; so that +Victor Hugo does but turn his romanticism into practice, in his +hunger and thirst after practical Justice!--a justice which shall no +longer wrong children, or animals, for instance, by ignoring in a +stupid, mere breadth of view, minute facts about them. Yet the +romanticists are antinomian, too, sometimes, because the love of +energy and beauty, of distinction in passion, tended naturally to +become a little bizarre, plunging into the [255] Middle Age, into the +secrets of old Italian story. Are we in the Inferno?--we are tempted +to ask, wondering at something malign in so much beauty. For over +all a care for the refreshment of the human spirit by fine art +manifests itself, a predominant sense of literary charm, so that, in +their search for the secret of exquisite expression, the romantic +school went back to the forgotten world of early French poetry, and +literature itself became the most delicate of the arts--like +"goldsmith's work," says Sainte-Beuve, of Bertrand's Gaspard de la +Nuit--and that peculiarly French gift, the gift of exquisite speech, +argute loqui, attained in them a perfection which it had never seen +before. + +Stendhal, a writer whom I have already quoted, and of whom English +readers might well know much more than they do, stands between the +earlier and later growths of the romantic spirit. His novels are +rich in romantic quality; and his other writings--partly criticism, +partly personal reminiscences--are a very curious and interesting +illustration of the needs out of which romanticism arose. In his +book on Racine and Shakespeare, Stendhal argues that all good art was +romantic in its day; and this is perhaps true in Stendhal's sense. +That little treatise, full of "dry light" and fertile ideas, was +published in the year 1823, and its object is to defend an entire +independence and liberty in the choice and treatment of subject, both +in [256] art and literature, against those who upheld the exclusive +authority of precedent. In pleading the cause of romanticism, +therefore, it is the novelty, both of form and of motive, in writings +like the Hernani of Victor Hugo (which soon followed it, raising a +storm of criticism) that he is chiefly concerned to justify. To be +interesting and really stimulating, to keep us from yawning even, art +and literature must follow the subtle movements of that nimbly- +shifting Time-Spirit, or Zeit-Geist, understood by French not less +than by German criticism, which is always modifying men's taste, as +it modifies their manners and their pleasures. This, he contends, is +what all great workmen had always understood. Dante, Shakespeare, +Molière, had exercised an absolute independence in their choice of +subject and treatment. To turn always with that ever-changing +spirit, yet to retain the flavour of what was admirably done in past +generations, in the classics, as we say--is the problem of true +romanticism. "Dante," he observes, "was pre-eminently the romantic +poet. He adored Virgil, yet he wrote the Divine Comedy, with the +episode of Ugolino, which is as unlike the Aeneid as can possibly be. +And those who thus obey the fundamental principle of romanticism, one +by one become classical, and are joined to that ever-increasing +common league, formed by men of all countries, to approach nearer and +nearer to perfection." + +Romanticism, then, although it has its epochs, [257] is in its +essential characteristics rather a spirit which shows itself at all +times, in various degrees, in individual workmen and their work, and +the amount of which criticism has to estimate in them taken one by +one, than the peculiarity of a time or a school. Depending on the +varying proportion of curiosity and the desire of beauty, natural +tendencies of the artistic spirit at all times, it must always be +partly a matter of individual temperament. The eighteenth century in +England has been regarded as almost exclusively a classical period; +yet William Blake, a type of so much which breaks through what are +conventionally thought the influences of that century, is still a +noticeable phenomenon in it, and the reaction in favour of naturalism +in poetry begins in that century, early. There are, thus, the born +romanticists and the born classicists. There are the born +classicists who start with form, to whose minds the comeliness of the +old, immemorial, well-recognised types in art and literature, have +revealed themselves impressively; who will entertain no matter which +will not go easily and flexibly into them; whose work aspires only to +be a variation upon, or study from, the older masters. "'Tis art's +decline, my son!" they are always saying, to the progressive element +in their own generation; to those who care for that which in fifty +years' time every one will be caring for. On the other hand, there +are the born romanticists, who start with an original, [258] untried +matter, still in fusion; who conceive this vividly, and hold by it as +the essence of their work; who, by the very vividness and heat of +their conception, purge away, sooner or later, all that is not +organically appropriate to it, till the whole effect adjusts itself +in clear, orderly, proportionate form; which form, after a very +little time, becomes classical in its turn. + +The romantic or classical character of a picture, a poem, a literary +work, depends, then, on the balance of certain qualities in it; and +in this sense, a very real distinction may be drawn between good +classical and good romantic work. But all critical terms are +relative; and there is at least a valuable suggestion in that theory +of Stendhal's, that all good art was romantic in its day. In the +beauties of Homer and Pheidias, quiet as they now seem, there must +have been, for those who confronted them for the first time, +excitement and surprise, the sudden, unforeseen satisfaction of the +desire of beauty. Yet the Odyssey, with its marvellous adventure, is +more romantic than the Iliad, which nevertheless contains, among many +other romantic episodes, that of the immortal horses of Achilles, who +weep at the death of Patroclus. Aeschylus is more romantic than +Sophocles, whose Philoctetes, were it written now, might figure, for +the strangeness of its motive and the perfectness of its execution, +as typically romantic; while, of Euripides, it may be said, that his +method in [259] writing his plays is to sacrifice readily almost +everything else, so that he may attain the fulness of a single +romantic effect. These two tendencies, indeed, might be applied as a +measure or standard, all through Greek and Roman art and poetry, with +very illuminating results; and for an analyst of the romantic +principle in art, no exercise would be more profitable, than to walk +through the collection of classical antiquities at the Louvre, or the +British Museum, or to examine some representative collection of Greek +coins, and note how the element of curiosity, of the love of +strangeness, insinuates itself into classical design, and record the +effects of the romantic spirit there, the traces of struggle, of the +grotesque even, though over-balanced here by sweetness; as in the +sculpture of Chartres and Rheims, the real sweetness of mind in the +sculptor is often overbalanced by the grotesque, by the rudeness of +his strength. + +Classicism, then, means for Stendhal, for that younger enthusiastic +band of French writers whose unconscious method he formulated into +principles, the reign of what is pedantic, conventional, and narrowly +academical in art; for him, all good art is romantic. To Sainte- +Beuve, who understands the term in a more liberal sense, it is the +characteristic of certain epochs, of certain spirits in every epoch, +not given to the exercise of original imagination, but rather to the +working out of refinements of manner on some [260] authorised matter; +and who bring to their perfection, in this way, the elements of +sanity, of order and beauty in manner. In general criticism, again, +it means the spirit of Greece and Rome, of some phases in literature +and art that may seem of equal authority with Greece and Rome, the +age of Louis the Fourteenth, the age of Johnson; though this is at +best an uncritical use of the term, because in Greek and Roman work +there are typical examples of the romantic spirit. But explain the +terms as we may, in application to particular epochs, there are these +two elements always recognisable; united in perfect art--in +Sophocles, in Dante, in the highest work of Goethe, though not always +absolutely balanced there; and these two elements may be not +inappropriately termed the classical and romantic tendencies. + +Material for the artist, motives of inspiration, are not yet +exhausted: our curious, complex, aspiring age still abounds in +subjects for aesthetic manipulation by the literary as well as by +other forms of art. For the literary art, at all events, the problem +just now is, to induce order upon the contorted, proportionless +accumulation of our knowledge and experience, our science and +history, our hopes and disillusion, and, in effecting this, to do +consciously what has been done hitherto for the most part too +unconsciously, to write our English language as the Latins wrote +theirs, as the [261] French write, as scholars should write. +Appealing, as he may, to precedent in this matter, the scholar will +still remember that if "the style is the man" it is also the age: +that the nineteenth century too will be found to have had its style, +justified by necessity--a style very different, alike from the +baldness of an impossible "Queen Anne" revival, and an incorrect, +incondite exuberance, after the mode of Elizabeth: that we can only +return to either at the price of an impoverishment of form or matter, +or both, although, an intellectually rich age such as ours being +necessarily an eclectic one, we may well cultivate some of the +excellences of literary types so different as those: that in +literature as in other matters it is well to unite as many diverse +elements as may be: that the individual writer or artist, certainly, +is to be estimated by the number of graces he combines, and his power +of interpenetrating them in a given work. To discriminate schools, +of art, of literature, is, of course, part of the obvious business of +literary criticism: but, in the work of literary production, it is +easy to be overmuch occupied concerning them. For, in truth, the +legitimate contention is, not of one age or school of literary art +against another, but of all successive schools alike, against the +stupidity which is dead to the substance, and the vulgarity which is +dead to form. + + +NOTES + + +241. +Transliteration: ainei de palaion men oinon, anthea d' hymnon +neôterôn. Translation: "Praise wine for its age, but the song in first +bloom. Pindar, Odes, Book O, Poem 9, Line 47. + +244. +Transliteration: kosmiotês. Liddell and Scott definition: +"propriety, decorum, orderly behavior." + + +End of The Project Gutenberg Etext of Appreciations, With An Essay on Style +by Walter Horatio Pater + diff --git a/old/8awae10.zip b/old/8awae10.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..659703e --- /dev/null +++ b/old/8awae10.zip |