diff options
Diffstat (limited to 'old')
| -rw-r--r-- | old/7saht10.txt | 1539 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/7saht10.zip | bin | 0 -> 32914 bytes |
2 files changed, 1539 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/old/7saht10.txt b/old/7saht10.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..1cc1f3c --- /dev/null +++ b/old/7saht10.txt @@ -0,0 +1,1539 @@ +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Hasisadra's Adventure, by Huxley +#10 in our series by Thomas Henry Huxley +This is Essay #7 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" + +Copyright laws are changing all over the world, be sure to check +the copyright laws for your country before posting these files!! + +Please take a look at the important information in this header. +We encourage you to keep this file on your own disk, keeping an +electronic path open for the next readers. Do not remove this. + +*It must legally be the first thing seen when opening the book.* +In fact, our legal advisors said we can't even change margins. + +**Welcome To The World of Free Plain Vanilla Electronic Texts** + +**Etexts Readable By Both Humans and By Computers, Since 1971** + +*These Etexts Prepared By Hundreds of Volunteers and Donations* + +Information on contacting Project Gutenberg to get Etexts, and +further information is included below. We need your donations. + + +Title: Hasisadra's Adventure +Title: This is Essay #7 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" + +Author: Thomas Henry Huxley + +May, 2001 [Etext #2633] + + +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Hasisadra's Adventure, by Huxley +*****This file should be named 7saht10.txt or 7saht10.zip****** + +Corrected EDITIONS of our etexts get a new NUMBER, 7saht11.txt +VERSIONS based on separate sources get new LETTER, 7saht10a.txt + +Processed by D.R. Thompson <drthom@ihug.co.nz> + +Project Gutenberg Etexts are usually created from multiple editions, +all of which are in the Public Domain in the United States, unless a +copyright notice is included. Therefore, we usually do NOT keep any +of these books in compliance with any particular paper edition. + + +We are now trying to release all our books one month in advance +of the official release dates, leaving time for better editing. + +Please note: neither this list nor its contents are final till +midnight of the last day of the month of any such announcement. +The official release date of all Project Gutenberg Etexts is at +Midnight, Central Time, of the last day of the stated month. A +preliminary version may often be posted for suggestion, comment +and editing by those who wish to do so. To be sure you have an +up to date first edition [xxxxx10x.xxx] please check file sizes +in the first week of the next month. Since our ftp program has +a bug in it that scrambles the date [tried to fix and failed] a +look at the file size will have to do, but we will try to see a +new copy has at least one byte more or less. + + +Information about Project Gutenberg (one page) + +We produce about two million dollars for each hour we work. The +time it takes us, a rather conservative estimate, is fifty hours +to get any etext selected, entered, proofread, edited, copyright +searched and analyzed, the copyright letters written, etc. This +projected audience is one hundred million readers. If our value +per text is nominally estimated at one dollar then we produce $2 +million dollars per hour this year as we release thirty-six text +files per month, or 432 more Etexts in 1999 for a total of 2000+ +If these reach just 10% of the computerized population, then the +total should reach over 200 billion Etexts given away this year. + +The Goal of Project Gutenberg is to Give Away One Trillion Etext +Files by December 31, 2001. [10,000 x 100,000,000 = 1 Trillion] +This is ten thousand titles each to one hundred million readers, +which is only ~5% of the present number of computer users. + +At our revised rates of production, we will reach only one-third +of that goal by the end of 2001, or about 3,333 Etexts unless we +manage to get some real funding; currently our funding is mostly +from Michael Hart's salary at Carnegie-Mellon University, and an +assortment of sporadic gifts; this salary is only good for a few +more years, so we are looking for something to replace it, as we +don't want Project Gutenberg to be so dependent on one person. + +We need your donations more than ever! + + +All donations should be made to "Project Gutenberg/CMU": and are +tax deductible to the extent allowable by law. (CMU = Carnegie- +Mellon University). + +For these and other matters, please mail to: + +Project Gutenberg +P. O. Box 2782 +Champaign, IL 61825 + +When all other email fails. . .try our Executive Director: +Michael S. Hart <hart@pobox.com> +hart@pobox.com forwards to hart@prairienet.org and archive.org +if your mail bounces from archive.org, I will still see it, if +it bounces from prairienet.org, better resend later on. . . . + +We would prefer to send you this information by email. + +****** + +To access Project Gutenberg etexts, use any Web browser +to view http://promo.net/pg. This site lists Etexts by +author and by title, and includes information about how +to get involved with Project Gutenberg. You could also +download our past Newsletters, or subscribe here. This +is one of our major sites, please email hart@pobox.com, +for a more complete list of our various sites. + +To go directly to the etext collections, use FTP or any +Web browser to visit a Project Gutenberg mirror (mirror +sites are available on 7 continents; mirrors are listed +at http://promo.net/pg). + +Mac users, do NOT point and click, typing works better. + +Example FTP session: + +ftp metalab.unc.edu +login: anonymous +password: your@login +cd pub/docs/books/gutenberg +cd etext90 through etext99 or etext00 through etext01, etc. +dir [to see files] +get or mget [to get files. . .set bin for zip files] +GET GUTINDEX.?? [to get a year's listing of books, e.g., GUTINDEX.99] +GET GUTINDEX.ALL [to get a listing of ALL books] + +*** + +**Information prepared by the Project Gutenberg legal advisor** + +(Three Pages) + + +***START**THE SMALL PRINT!**FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN ETEXTS**START*** +Why is this "Small Print!" statement here? You know: lawyers. +They tell us you might sue us if there is something wrong with +your copy of this etext, even if you got it for free from +someone other than us, and even if what's wrong is not our +fault. So, among other things, this "Small Print!" statement +disclaims most of our liability to you. It also tells you how +you can distribute copies of this etext if you want to. + +*BEFORE!* YOU USE OR READ THIS ETEXT +By using or reading any part of this PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm +etext, you indicate that you understand, agree to and accept +this "Small Print!" statement. If you do not, you can receive +a refund of the money (if any) you paid for this etext by +sending a request within 30 days of receiving it to the person +you got it from. If you received this etext on a physical +medium (such as a disk), you must return it with your request. + +ABOUT PROJECT GUTENBERG-TM ETEXTS +This PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm etext, like most PROJECT GUTENBERG- +tm etexts, is a "public domain" work distributed by Professor +Michael S. Hart through the Project Gutenberg Association at +Carnegie-Mellon University (the "Project"). Among other +things, this means that no one owns a United States copyright +on or for this work, so the Project (and you!) can copy and +distribute it in the United States without permission and +without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, set forth +below, apply if you wish to copy and distribute this etext +under the Project's "PROJECT GUTENBERG" trademark. + +To create these etexts, the Project expends considerable +efforts to identify, transcribe and proofread public domain +works. Despite these efforts, the Project's etexts and any +medium they may be on may contain "Defects". Among other +things, Defects may take the form of incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other +intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged +disk or other etext medium, a computer virus, or computer +codes that damage or cannot be read by your equipment. + +LIMITED WARRANTY; DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES +But for the "Right of Replacement or Refund" described below, +[1] the Project (and any other party you may receive this +etext from as a PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm etext) disclaims all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including +legal fees, and [2] YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE OR +UNDER STRICT LIABILITY, OR FOR BREACH OF WARRANTY OR CONTRACT, +INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE +OR INCIDENTAL DAMAGES, EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE +POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES. + +If you discover a Defect in this etext within 90 days of +receiving it, you can receive a refund of the money (if any) +you paid for it by sending an explanatory note within that +time to the person you received it from. If you received it +on a physical medium, you must return it with your note, and +such person may choose to alternatively give you a replacement +copy. If you received it electronically, such person may +choose to alternatively give you a second opportunity to +receive it electronically. + +THIS ETEXT IS OTHERWISE PROVIDED TO YOU "AS-IS". NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, ARE MADE TO YOU AS +TO THE ETEXT OR ANY MEDIUM IT MAY BE ON, INCLUDING BUT NOT +LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A +PARTICULAR PURPOSE. + +Some states do not allow disclaimers of implied warranties or +the exclusion or limitation of consequential damages, so the +above disclaimers and exclusions may not apply to you, and you +may have other legal rights. + +INDEMNITY +You will indemnify and hold the Project, its directors, +officers, members and agents harmless from all liability, cost +and expense, including legal fees, that arise directly or +indirectly from any of the following that you do or cause: +[1] distribution of this etext, [2] alteration, modification, +or addition to the etext, or [3] any Defect. + +DISTRIBUTION UNDER "PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm" +You may distribute copies of this etext electronically, or by +disk, book or any other medium if you either delete this +"Small Print!" and all other references to Project Gutenberg, +or: + +[1] Only give exact copies of it. Among other things, this + requires that you do not remove, alter or modify the + etext or this "small print!" statement. You may however, + if you wish, distribute this etext in machine readable + binary, compressed, mark-up, or proprietary form, + including any form resulting from conversion by word pro- + cessing or hypertext software, but only so long as + *EITHER*: + + [*] The etext, when displayed, is clearly readable, and + does *not* contain characters other than those + intended by the author of the work, although tilde + (~), asterisk (*) and underline (_) characters may + be used to convey punctuation intended by the + author, and additional characters may be used to + indicate hypertext links; OR + + [*] The etext may be readily converted by the reader at + no expense into plain ASCII, EBCDIC or equivalent + form by the program that displays the etext (as is + the case, for instance, with most word processors); + OR + + [*] You provide, or agree to also provide on request at + no additional cost, fee or expense, a copy of the + etext in its original plain ASCII form (or in EBCDIC + or other equivalent proprietary form). + +[2] Honor the etext refund and replacement provisions of this + "Small Print!" statement. + +[3] Pay a trademark license fee to the Project of 20% of the + net profits you derive calculated using the method you + already use to calculate your applicable taxes. If you + don't derive profits, no royalty is due. Royalties are + payable to "Project Gutenberg Association/Carnegie-Mellon + University" within the 60 days following each + date you prepare (or were legally required to prepare) + your annual (or equivalent periodic) tax return. + +WHAT IF YOU *WANT* TO SEND MONEY EVEN IF YOU DON'T HAVE TO? +The Project gratefully accepts contributions in money, time, +scanning machines, OCR software, public domain etexts, royalty +free copyright licenses, and every other sort of contribution +you can think of. Money should be paid to "Project Gutenberg +Association / Carnegie-Mellon University". + +We are planning on making some changes in our donation structure +in 2000, so you might want to email me, hart@pobox.com beforehand. + + + + +*END THE SMALL PRINT! FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN ETEXTS*Ver.04.29.93*END* + + + + + +Processed by D.R. Thompson <drthom@ihug.co.nz> + + + + + +Hasisadra's Adventure +by Thomas Henry Huxley +This is Essay #7 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" + + + + +Some thousands of years ago there was a city in Mesopotamia +called Surippak. One night a strange dream came to a dweller +therein, whose name, if rightly reported, was Hasisadra. +The dream foretold the speedy coming of a great flood; and it +warned Hasisadra to lose no time in building a ship, in which, +when notice was given, he, his family and friends, with their +domestic animals and a collection of wild creatures and seed of +plants of the land, might take refuge and be rescued from +destruction. Hasisadra awoke, and at once acted upon the +warning. A strong decked ship was built, and her sides were +paid, inside and out, with the mineral pitch, or bitumen, with +which the country abounded; the vessel's seaworthiness was +tested, the cargo was stowed away, and a trusty pilot or +steersman appointed. + +The promised signal arrived. Wife and friends embarked; +Hasisadra, following, prudently "shut the door," or, as we +should say, put on the hatches; and Nes-Hea, the pilot, was left +alone on deck to do his best for the ship. Thereupon a hurricane +began to rage; rain fell in torrents; the subterranean waters +burst forth; a deluge swept over the land, and the wind lashed +it into waves sky high; heaven and earth became mingled in +chaotic gloom. For six days and seven nights the gale raged, but +the good ship held out until, on the seventh day, the storm +lulled. Hasisadra ventured on deck; and, seeing nothing but a +waste of waters strewed with floating corpses and wreck, wept +over the destruction of his land and people. Far away, the +mountains of Nizir were visible; the ship was steered for them +and ran aground upon the higher land. Yet another seven days +passed by. On the seventh, Hasisadra sent forth a dove, which +found no resting place and returned; then he liberated a +swallow, which also came back; finally, a raven was let loose, +and that sagacious bird, when it found that the water had +abated, came near the ship, but refused to return to it. +Upon this, Hasisadra liberated the rest of the wild animals, +which immediately dispersed in all directions, while he, with +his family and friends, ascending a mountain hard by, offered +sacrifice upon its summit to the gods. + +The story thus given in summary abstract, told in an ancient +Semitic dialect, is inscribed in cuneiform characters upon a +tablet of burnt clay. Many thousands of such tablets, collected +by Assurbanipal, King of Assyria in the middle of the seventh +century B.C., were stored in the library of his palace at +Nineveh; and, though in a sadly broken and mutilated condition, +they have yielded a marvellous amount of information to the +patient and sagacious labour which modern scholars have bestowed +upon them. Among the multitude of documents of various kinds, +this narrative of Hasisadra's adventure has been found in a +tolerably complete state. But Assyriologists agree that it is +only a copy of a much more ancient work; and there are weighty +reasons for believing that the story of Hasisadra's flood was +well known in Mesopotamia before the year 2000 B.C. + +No doubt, then, we are in presence of a narrative which has all +the authority which antiquity can confer; and it is proper to +deal respectfully with it, even though it is quite as proper, +and indeed necessary, to act no less respectfully towards +ourselves; and, before professing to put implicit faith in it, +to inquire what claim it has to be regarded as a serious account +of an historical event. + +It is of no use to appeal to contemporary history, although the +annals of Babylonia, no less than those of Egypt, go much +further back than 2000 B.C. All that can be said is, that the +former are hardly consistent with the supposition that any +catastrophe, competent to destroy all the population, has +befallen the land since civilisation began, and that the latter +are notoriously silent about deluges. In such a case as this, +however, the silence of history does not leave the inquirer +wholly at fault. Natural science has something to say when the +phenomena of nature are in question. Natural science may be able +to show, from the nature of the country, either that such an +event as that described in the story is impossible, or at any +rate highly improbable; or, on the other hand, that it is +consonant with probability. In the former case, the narrative +must be suspected or rejected; in the latter, no such summary +verdict can be given: on the contrary, it must be admitted that +the story may be true. And then, if certain strangely prevalent +canons of criticism are accepted, and if the evidence that an +event might have happened is to be accepted as proof that it did +happen, Assyriologists will be at liberty to congratulate one +another on the "confirmation by modern science" of the authority +of their ancient books. + +It will be interesting, therefore, to inquire how far the +physical structure and the other conditions of the region in +which Surippak was situated are compatible with such a flood as +is described in the Assyrian record. + +The scene of Hasisadra's adventure is laid in the broad valley, +six or seven hundred miles long, and hardly anywhere less than a +hundred miles in width, which is traversed by the lower courses +of the rivers Euphrates and Tigris, and which is commonly known +as the "Euphrates valley." Rising, at the one end, into a hill +country, which gradually passes into the Alpine heights of +Armenia; and, at the other, dipping beneath the shallow waters +of the head of the Persian Gulf, which continues in the same +direction, from north-west to south-east, for some eight hundred +miles farther, the floor of the valley presents a gradual slope, +from eight hundred feet above the sea level to the depths of the +southern end of the Persian Gulf. The boundary between sea and +land, formed by the extremest mudflats of the delta of the two +rivers, is but vaguely defined; and, year by year, it advances +seaward. On the north-eastern side, the western frontier ranges +of Persia rise abruptly to great heights; on the south-western +side, a more gradual ascent leads to a table-land of less +elevation, which, very broad in the south, where it is occupied +by the deserts of Arabia and of Southern Syria, narrows, +northwards, into the highlands of Palestine, and is continued by +the ranges of the Lebanon, the Antilebanon, and the Taurus, into +the highlands of Armenia. + +The wide and gently inclined plain, thus inclosed between the +gulf and the highlands, on each side and at its upper extremity, +is distinguishable into two regions of very different character, +one of which lies north, and the other south of the parallel of +Hit, on the Euphrates. Except in the immediate vicinity of the +river, the northern division is stony and scantily covered with +vegetation, except in spring. Over the southern division, on the +contrary, spreads a deep alluvial soil, in which even a pebble +is rare; and which, though, under the existing misrule, mainly a +waste of marsh and wilderness, needs only intelligent attention +to become, as it was of old, the granary of western Asia. +Except in the extreme south, the rainfall is small and the air +dry. The heat in summer is intense, while bitterly cold northern +blasts sweep the plain in winter. Whirlwinds are not uncommon; +and, in the intervals of the periodical inundations, the fine, +dry, powdery soil is swept, even by moderate breezes, into +stifling clouds, or rather fogs, of dust. Low inequalities, +elevations here and depressions there, diversify the surface of +the alluvial region. The latter are occupied by enormous +marshes, while the former support the permanent dwellings of the +present scanty and miserable population. + +In antiquity, so long as the canalisation of the country was +properly carried out, the fertility of the alluvial plain +enabled great and prosperous nations to have their home in the +Euphrates valley. Its abundant clay furnished the materials for +the masses of sun-dried and burnt bricks, the remains of which, +in the shape of huge artificial mounds, still testify to both +the magnitude and the industry of the population, thousands of +years ago. Good cement is plentiful, while the bitumen, which +wells from the rocks at Hit and elsewhere, not only answers the +same purpose, but is used to this day, as it was in Hasisadra's +time, to pay the inside and the outside of boats. + +In the broad lower course of the Euphrates, the stream rarely +acquires a velocity of more than three miles an hour, while the +lower Tigris attains double that rate in times of flood. The +water of both great rivers is mainly derived from the northern +and eastern highlands in Armenia and in Kurdistan, and stands at +its lowest level in early autumn and in January. But when the +snows accumulated in the upper basins of the great rivers, +during the winter, melt under the hot sunshine of spring, they +rapidly rise,<1> and at length overflow their banks, covering +the alluvial plain with a vast inland sea, interrupted only by +the higher ridges and hummocks which form islands in a seemingly +boundless expanse of water. + +In the occurrence of these annual inundations lies one of +several resemblances between the valley of the Euphrates and +that of the Nile. But there are important differences. The time +of the annual flood is reversed, the Nile being highest in +autumn and winter, and lowest in spring and early summer. The +periodical overflows of the Nile, regulated by the great lake +basins in the south, are usually punctual in arrival, gradual in +growth, and beneficial in operation. No lakes are interposed +between the mountain torrents of the upper basis of the Tigris +and the Euphrates and their lower courses. Hence, heavy rain, or +an unusually rapid thaw in the uplands, gives rise to the sudden +irruption of a vast volume of water which not even the rapid +Tigris, still less its more sluggish companion, can carry off in +time to prevent violent and dangerous overflows. Without an +elaborate system of canalisation, providing an escape for such +sudden excesses of the supply of water, the annual floods of the +Euphrates, and especially of the Tigris, must always be attended +with risk, and often prove harmful. + +There are other peculiarities of the Euphrates valley which may +occasionally tend to exacerbate the evils attendant on the +inundations. It is very subject to seismic disturbances; and the +ordinary consequences of a sharp earthquake shock might be +seriously complicated by its effect on a broad sheet of water. +Moreover the Indian Ocean lies within the region of typhoons; +and if, at the height of an inundation, a hurricane from the +south-east swept up the Persian Gulf, driving its shallow waters +upon the delta and damming back the outflow, perhaps for +hundreds of miles up-stream, a diluvial catastrophe, fairly up +to the mark of Hasisadra's, might easily result.<2> + +Thus there seems to be no valid reason for rejecting Hasisadra's +story on physical grounds. I do not gather from the narrative +that the "mountains of Nizir" were supposed to be submerged, but +merely that they came into view above the distant horizon of the +waters, as the vessel drove in that direction. Certainly the +ship is not supposed to ground on any of their higher summits, +for Hasisadra has to ascend a peak in order to offer his +sacrifice. The country of Nizir lay on the north-eastern side of +the Euphrates valley, about the courses of the two rivers Zab, +which enter the Tigris where it traverses the plain of Assyria +some eight or nine hundred feet above the sea; and, so far as I +can judge from maps<3> and other sources of information, it is +possible, under the circumstances supposed, that such a ship as +Hasisadra's might drive before a southerly gale, over a +continuously flooded country, until it grounded on some of the +low hills between which both the lower and the upper Zab enter +upon the Assyrian plain. + +The tablet which contains the story under consideration is the +eleventh of a series of twelve. Each of these answers to a +month, and to the corresponding sign of the Zodiac. The Assyrian +year began with the spring equinox; consequently, the eleventh +month, called "the rainy," answers to our January-February, and +to the sign which corresponds with our Aquarius. The aquatic +adventure of Hasisadra, therefore, is not inappropriately +placed. It is curious, however, that the season thus indirectly +assigned to the flood is not that of the present highest level +of the rivers. It is too late for the winter rise and too early +for the spring floods. + +I think it must be admitted that, so far, the physical cross- +examination to which Hasisadra has been subjected does not break +down his story. On the contrary, he proves to have kept it in +all essential respects<4> within the bounds of probability or +possibility. However, we have not yet done with him. For the +conditions which obtained in the Euphrates valley, four or five +thousand years ago, may have differed to such an extent from +those which now exist that we should be able to convict him of +having made up his tale. But here again everything is in favour +of his credibility. Indeed, he may claim very powerful support, +for it does not lie in the mouths of those who accept the +authority of the Pentateuch to deny that the Euphrates valley +was what it is, even six thousand years back. According to the +book of Genesis, Phrat and Hiddekel--the Euphrates and the +Tigris--are coeval with Paradise. An edition of the Scriptures, +recently published under high authority, with an elaborate +apparatus of "Helps" for the use of students--and therefore, as +I am bound to suppose, purged of all statements that could by +any possibility mislead the young--assigns the year B.C. 4004 as +the date of Adam's too brief residence in that locality. + +But I am far from depending on this authority for the age of the +Mesopotamian plain. On the contrary, I venture to rely, with +much more confidence, on another kind of evidence, which tends +to show that the age of the great rivers must be carried back to +a date earlier than that at which our ingenuous youth is +instructed that the earth came into existence. For, the alluvial +deposit having been brought down by the rivers, they must needs +be older than the plain it forms, as navvies must needs antecede +the embankment painfully built up by the contents of their +wheel-barrows. For thousands of years, heat and cold, rain, +snow, and frost, the scrubbing of glaciers, and the scouring of +torrents laden with sand and gravel, have been wearing down the +rocks of the upper basins of the rivers, over an area of many +thousand square miles; and these materials, ground to fine +powder in the course of their long journey, have slowly +subsided, as the water which carried them spread out and lost +its velocity in the sea. It is because this process is still +going on that the shore of the delta constantly encroaches on +the head of the gulf<5> into which the two rivers are constantly +throwing the waste of Armenia and of Kurdistan. Hence, as might +be expected, fluviatile and marine shells are common in the +alluvial deposit; and Loftus found strata, containing subfossil +marine shells of species now living, in the Persian Gulf, at +Warka, two hundred miles in a straight line from the shore of +the delta.<6> It follows that, if a trustworthy estimate of the +average rate of growth of the alluvial can be formed, the lowest +limit (by no means the highest limit) of age of the rivers can +be determined. All such estimates are beset with sources of +error of very various kinds; and the best of them can only be +regarded as approximations to the truth. But I think it will be +quite safe to assume a maximum rate of growth of four miles in a +century for the lower half of the alluvial plain. + +Now, the cycle of narratives of which Hasisadra's adventure +forms a part contains allusions not only to Surippak, the exact +position of which is doubtful, but to other cities, such as +Erech. The vast ruins at the present village of Warka have been +carefully explored and determined to be all that remains of that +once great and flourishing city, "Erech the lofty." +Supposing that the two hundred miles of alluvial country, which +separates them from the head of the Persian Gulf at present, +have been deposited at the very high rate of four miles in a +century, it will follow that 4000 years ago, or about the year +2100 B.C., the city of Erech still lay forty miles inland. +Indeed, the city might have been built a thousand years earlier. +Moreover, there is plenty of independent archaeological and +other evidence that in the whole thousand years, 2000 to +3000 B.C, the alluvial plain was inhabited by a numerous people, +among whom industry, art, and literature had attained a very +considerable development. And it can be shown that the physical +conditions and the climate of the Euphrates valley, at that +time, must have been extremely similar to what they are now. + +Thus, once more, we reach the conclusion that, as a question of +physical probability, there is no ground for objecting to the +reality of Hasisadra's adventure. It would be unreasonable to +doubt that such a flood might have happened, and that such a +person might have escaped in the way described, any time during +the last 5000 years. And if the postulate of loose thinkers in +search of scientific "confirmations" of questionable narratives +--proof that an event may have happened is evidence that it did +happen--is to be accepted, surely Hasisadra's story is +"confirmed by modern scientific investigation" beyond all cavil. +However, it may be well to pause before adopting this +conclusion, because the original story, of which I have set +forth only the broad outlines, contains a great many statements +which rest upon just the same foundation as those cited, and yet +are hardly likely to meet with general acceptance. The account +of the circumstances which led up to the flood, of those under +which Hasisadra's adventure was made known to his descendant, of +certain remarkable incidents before and after the flood, are +inseparably bound up with the details already given. And I am +unable to discover any justification for arbitrarily picking out +some of these and dubbing them historical verities, while +rejecting the rest as legendary fictions. They stand or +fall together. + +Before proceeding to the consideration of these less +satisfactory details, it is needful to remark that Hasisadra's +adventure is a mere episode in a cycle of stories of which a +personage, whose name is provisionally read "Izdubar," is the +centre. The nature of Izdubar hovers vaguely between the heroic +and the divine; sometimes he seems a mere man, sometimes +approaches so closely to the divinities of fire and of the sun +as to be hardly distinguishable from them. As I have already +mentioned, the tablet which sets forth Hasisadra's perils is one +of twelve; and, since each of these represents a month and bears +a story appropriate to the corresponding sign of the Zodiac, +great weight must be attached to Sir Henry Rawlinson's +suggestion that the epos of Izdubar is a poetical embodiment of +solar mythology. + +In the earlier books of the epos, the hero, not content with +rejecting the proffered love of the Chaldaean Aphrodite, Istar, +freely expresses his very low estimate of her character; and it +is interesting to observe that, even in this early stage of +human experience, men had reached a conception of that law of +nature which expresses the inevitable consequences of an +imperfect appreciation of feminine charms. The injured goddess +makes Izdubar's life a burden to him, until at last, sick in +body and sorry in mind, he is driven to seek aid and comfort +from his forbears in the world of spirits. So this antitype of +Odysseus journeys to the shore of the waters of death, and there +takes ship with a Chaldaean Charon, who carries him within hail +of his ancestor Hasisadra. That venerable personage not only +gives Izdubar instructions how to regain his health, but tells +him, somewhat <i>a propos des bottes</i> (after the manner of +venerable personages), the long story of his perilous adventure; +and how it befell that he, his wife, and his steersman came to +dwell among the blessed gods, without passing through the +portals of death like ordinary mortals. + +According to the full story, the sins of mankind had become +grievous; and, at a council of the gods, it was resolved to +extirpate the whole race by a great flood. And, once more, let +us note the uniformity of human experience. It would appear +that, four thousand years ago, the obligations of confidential +intercourse about matters of state were sometimes violated-- +of course from the best of motives. Ea, one of the three chiefs +of the Chaldaean Pantheon, the god of justice and of practical +wisdom, was also the god of the sea; and, yielding to the +temptation to do a friend a good turn, irresistible to kindly +seafaring folks of all ranks, he warned Hasisadra of what was +coming. When Bel subsequently reproached him for this breach of +confidence, Ea defended himself by declaring that he did not +tell Hasisadra anything; he only sent him a dream. This was +undoubtedly sailing very near the wind; but the attribution of a +little benevolent obliquity of conduct to one of the highest of +the gods is a trifle compared with the truly Homeric +anthropomorphism which characterises other parts of the epos. + +The Chaldĉan deities are, in truth, extremely human; and, +occasionally, the narrator does not scruple to represent them in +a manner which is not only inconsistent with our idea of +reverence, but is sometimes distinctly humorous.<7> When the +storm is at its height, he exhibits them flying in a state of +panic to Anu, the god of heaven, and crouching before his portal +like frightened dogs. As the smoke of Hasisadra's sacrifice +arises, the gods, attracted by the sweet savour, are compared to +swarms of flies. I have already remarked that the lady Istar's +reputation is torn to shreds; while she and Ea scold Bel +handsomely for his ferocity and injustice in destroying the +innocent along with the guilty. One is reminded of Here hung up +with weighted heels; of misleading dreams sent by Zeus; of Ares +howling as he flies from the Trojan battlefield; and of the very +questionable dealings of Aphrodite with Helen and Paris. + +But to return to the story. Bel was, at first, excluded from the +sacrifice as the author of all the mischief; which really was +somewhat hard upon him, since the other gods agreed to his +proposal. But eventually a reconciliation takes place; the great +bow of Anu is displayed in the heavens; Bel agrees that he will +be satisfied with what war, pestilence, famine, and wild beasts +can do in the way of destroying men; and that, henceforward, he +will not have recourse to extraordinary measures. Finally, it is +Bel himself who, by way of making amends, transports Hasisadra, +his wife, and the faithful Nes-Hea to the abode of the gods. + +It is as indubitable as it is incomprehensible to most of us, +that, for thousands of years, a great people, quite as +intelligent as we are, and living in as high a state of +civilisation as that which had been attained in the greater part +of Europe a few centuries ago, entertained not the slightest +doubt that Anu, Bel, Ea, Istar, and the rest, were real +personages, possessed of boundless powers for good and evil. +The sincerity of the monarchs whose inscriptions gratefully +attribute their victories to Merodach, or to Assur, is as little +to be questioned as that of the authors of the hymns and +penitential psalms which give full expression to the heights and +depths of religious devotion. An "infidel" bold enough to deny +the existence, or to doubt the influence, of these deities +probably did not exist in all Mesopotamia; and even constructive +rebellion against their authority was apt to end in the +deprivation, not merely of the good name, but of the skin of the +offender. The adherents of modern theological systems dismiss +these objects of the love and fear of a hundred generations of +their equals, offhand, as "gods of the heathen," mere creations +of a wicked and idolatrous imagination; and, along with them, +they disown, as senseless, the crude theology, with its gross +anthropomorphism and its low ethical conception of the divinity, +which satisfied the pious souls of Chaldaea. + +I imagine, though I do not presume to be sure, that any +endeavour to save the intellectual and moral credit of Chaldaean +religion, by suggesting the application to it of that universal +solvent of absurdities, the allegorical method, would be +scouted; I will not even suggest that any ingenuity can be equal +to the discovery of the antitypes of the personifications +effected by the religious imagination of later ages, in the +triad Anu, Ea, and Bel, still less in Istar. Therefore, unless +some plausible reconciliatory scheme should be propounded by a +Neo-Chaldaean devotee (and, with Neo-Buddhists to the fore, this +supposition is not so wild as it looks), I suppose the moderns +will continue to smile, in a superior way, at the grievous +absurdity of the polytheistic idolatry of these ancient people. + +It is probably a congenital absence of some faculty which I +ought to possess which withholds me from adopting this summary +procedure. But I am not ashamed to share David Hume's want of +ability to discover that polytheism is, in itself, altogether +absurd. If we are bound, or permitted, to judge the government +of the world by human standards, it appears to me that +directorates are proved, by familiar experience, to conduct the +largest and the most complicated concerns quite as well as +solitary despots. I have never been able to see why the +hypothesis of a divine syndicate should be found guilty of +innate absurdity. Those Assyrians, in particular, who held Assur +to be the one supreme and creative deity, to whom all the other +supernal powers were subordinate, might fairly ask that the +essential difference between their system and that which obtains +among the great majority of their modern theological critics +should be demonstrated. In my apprehension, it is not the +quantity, but the quality, of the persons, among whom the +attributes of divinity are distributed, which is the serious +matter. If the divine might is associated with no higher ethical +attributes than those which obtain among ordinary men; if the +divine intelligence is supposed to be so imperfect that it +cannot foresee the consequences of its own contrivances; if the +supernal powers can become furiously angry with the creatures of +their omnipotence and, in their senseless wrath, destroy the +innocent along with the guilty; or if they can show themselves +to be as easily placated by presents and gross flattery as any +oriental or occidental despot; if, in short, they are only +stronger than mortal men and no better, as it must be admitted +Hasisadra's deities proved themselves to be--then, surely, it is +time for us to look somewhat closely into their credentials, and +to accept none but conclusive evidence of their existence. + +To the majority of my respected contemporaries this reasoning +will doubtless appear feeble, if not worse. However, to my mind, +such are the only arguments by which the Chaldaean theology can +be satisfactorily upset. So far from there being any ground for +the belief that Ea, Anu, and Bel are, or ever were, real +entities, it seems to me quite infinitely more probable that +they are products of the religious imagination, such as are to +be found everywhere and in all ages, so long as that imagination +riots uncontrolled by scientific criticism. + +It is on these grounds that I venture, at the risk of being +called an atheist by the ghosts of all the principals of all the +colleges of Babylonia, or by their living successors among the +Neo-Chaldaeans, if that sect should arise, to express my utter +disbelief in the gods of Hasisadra. Hence, it follows, that I +find Hasisadra's account of their share in his adventure +incredible; and, as the physical details of the flood are +inseparable from its theophanic accompaniments, and are +guaranteed by the same authority, I must let them go with the +rest. The consistency of such details with probability counts +for nothing. The inhabitants of Chaldaea must always have been +familiar with inundations; probably no generation failed to +witness an inundation which rose unusually high, or was rendered +serious by coincident atmospheric or other disturbances. And the +memory of the general features of any exceptionally severe and +devastating flood, would be preserved by popular tradition for +long ages. What, then, could be more natural than that a +Chaldaean poet should seek for the incidents of a great +catastrophe among such phenomena? In what other way than by such +an appeal to their experience could he so surely awaken in his +audience the tragic pity and terror? What possible ground is +there for insisting that he must have had some individual good +in view, and that his history is historical, in the sense that +the account of the effects of a hurricane in the Bay of Bengal, +in the year 1875, is historical? + + +More than three centuries after the time of Assurbanipal, +Berosus of Babylon, born in the reign of Alexander the Great, +wrote an account of the history of his country in Greek. +The work of Berosus has vanished; but extracts from it--how far +faithful is uncertain--have been preserved by later writers. +Among these occurs the well-known story of the Deluge of +Xisuthros, which is evidently built upon the same foundation as +that of Hasisadra. The incidents of the divine warning, the +building of the ship, the sending out of birds, the ascension of +the hero, betray their common origin. But stories, like Madeira, +acquire a heightened flavour with time and travel; and the +version of Berosus is characterised by those circumstantial +improbabilities which habitually gather round the legend of a +legend. The later narrator knows the exact day of the month on +which the flood began. The dimensions of the ship are stated +with Munchausenian precision at five stadia by two--say, half by +one-fifth of an English mile. The ship runs aground among the +"Gordaean mountains" to the south of Lake Van, in Armenia, +beyond the limits of any imaginable real inundation of the +Euphrates valley; and, by way of climax, we have the assertion, +worthy of the sailor who said that he had brought up one of +Pharaoh's chariot wheels on the fluke of his anchor in the Red +Sea, that pilgrims visited the locality and made amulets of the +bitumen which they scraped off from the still extant remains of +the mighty ship of Xisuthros. + +Suppose that some later polyhistor, as devoid of critical +faculty as most of his tribe, had found the version of Berosus, +as well as another much nearer the original story; that, having +too much respect for his authorities to make up a <i>tertium +quid</i> of his own, out of the materials offered, he followed a +practice, common enough among ancient and, particularly, among +Semitic historians, of dividing, both into fragments and piecing +these together, without troubling himself very much about those +resulting repetitions and inconsistencies; the product of such a +primitive editorial operation would be a narrative analogous to +that which treats of the Noachian deluge in the book of Genesis. +For the Pentateuchal story is indubitably a patchwork, composed +of fragments of at least two, different and partly discrepant, +narratives, quilted together in such an inartistic fashion that +the seams remain conspicuous. And, in the matter of +circumstantial exaggeration, it in some respects excels even the +second-hand legend of Berosus. + +There is a certain practicality about the notion of taking +refuge from floods and storms in a ship provided with a +steersman; but, surely, no one who had ever seen more water than +he could wade through would dream of facing even a moderate +breeze, in a huge three-storied coffer, or box, three hundred +cubits long, fifty wide and thirty high, left to drift without +rudder or pilot.<8> Not content with giving the exact year of +Noah's age in which the flood began, the Pentateuchal story adds +the month and the day of the month. It is the Deity himself who +"shuts in" Noah. The modest week assigned to the full deluge in +Hasisadra's story becomes forty days, in one of the Pentateuchal +accounts, and a hundred and fifty in the other. The flood, +which, in the version of Berosus, has grown so high as to cast +the ship among the mountains of Armenia, is improved upon in the +Hebrew account until it covers "all the high hills that were +under the whole heaven"; and, when it begins to subside, the ark +is left stranded on the summit of the highest peak, commonly +identified with Ararat itself. + +While the details of Hasisadra's adventure are, at least, +compatible with the physical conditions of the Euphrates valley, +and, as we have seen, involve no catastrophe greater than such +as might be brought under those conditions, many of the very +precisely stated details of Noah's flood contradict some of the +best established results of scientific inquiry. + +If it is certain that the alluvium of the Mesopotamian plain has +been brought down by the Tigris and the Euphrates, then it is no +less certain that the physical structure of the whole valley has +persisted, without material modification, for many thousand +years before the date assigned to the flood. If the summits, +even of the moderately elevated ridges which immediately bound +the valley, still more those of the Kurdish and Armenian +mountains, were ever covered by water, for even forty days, that +water must have extended over the whole earth. If the earth was +thus covered, anywhere between 4000 and 5000 years ago, or, at +any other time, since the higher terrestrial animals came into +existence, they must have been destroyed from the whole face of +it, as the Pentateuchal account declares they were three several +times (Genesis vii. 21, 22, 23), in language which cannot be +made more emphatic, or more solemn, than it is; and the present +population must consist of the descendants of emigrants from the +ark. And, if that is the case, then, as has often been pointed +out, the sloths of the Brazilian forests, the kangaroos of +Australia, the great tortoises of the Galapagos islands, must +have respectively hobbled, hopped, and crawled over many +thousand miles of land and sea from "Ararat" to their present +habitations. Thus, the unquestionable facts of the geographical +distribution of recent land animals, alone, form an insuperable +obstacle to the acceptance of the assertion that the kinds of +animals composing the present terrestrial fauna have been, at +any time, universally destroyed in the way described in +the Pentateuch. + +It is upon this and other unimpeachable grounds that, as I +ventured to say some time ago, persons who are duly conversant +with even the elements of natural science decline to take the +Noachian deluge seriously; and that, as I also pointed out, +candid theologians, who, without special scientific knowledge, +have appreciated the weight of scientific arguments, have long +since given it up. But, as Goethe has remarked, there is nothing +more terrible than energetic ignorance;<9> and there are, even +yet, very energetic people, who are neither candid, nor clear- +headed, nor theologians, still less properly instructed in the +elements of natural science, who make prodigious efforts to +obscure the effect of these plain truths, and to conceal their +real surrender of the historical character of Noah's deluge +under cover of the smoke of a great discharge of +pseudoscientific artillery. They seem to imagine that the proofs +which abound in all parts of the world, of large oscillations of +the relative level of land and sea, combined with the +probability that, when the sea-level was rising, sudden +incursions of the sea like that which broke in over Holland and +formed the Zuyder Zee, may have often occurred, can be made to +look like evidence that something that, by courtesy, might be +called a general Deluge has really taken place. Their discursive +energy drags misunderstood truth into their service; and "the +glacial epoch" is as sure to crop up among them as King +Charles's head in a famous memorial--with about as much +appropriateness. The old story of the raised beach on Moel +Tryfaen is trotted out; though, even if the facts are as yet +rightly interpreted, there is not a shadow of evidence that the +change of sea-level in that locality was sudden, or that glacial +Welshmen would have known it was taking place.<10> Surely it is +difficult to perceive the relevancy of bringing in something +that happened in the glacial epoch (if it did happen) to account +for the tradition of a flood in the Euphrates valley between +2000 and 3000 B.C. But the date of the Noachian flood is solidly +fixed by the sole authority for it; no shuffling of the +chronological data will carry it so far back as 3000 B.C.; +and the Hebrew epos agrees with the Chaldaean in placing it +after the development of a somewhat advanced civilisation. +The only authority for the Noachian deluge assures us that, +before it visited the earth, Cain had built cities; Jubal had +invented harps and organs; while mankind had advanced so far +beyond the neolithic, nay even the bronze, stage that Tubal-cain +was a worker in iron. Therefore, if the Noachian legend is to be +taken for the history of an event which happened in the glacial +epoch, we must revise our notions of pleistocene civilisation. +On the other hand, if the Pentateuchal story only means +something quite different, that happened somewhere else, +thousands of years earlier, dressed up, what becomes of its +credit as history? I wonder what would be said to a modern +historian who asserted that Pekin was burnt down in 1886, and +then tried to justify the assertion by adducing evidence of the +Great Fire of London in 1666. Yet the attempt to save the credit +of the Noachian story by reference to something which is +supposed to have happened in the far north, in the glacial +epoch, is far more preposterous. + +Moreover, these dust-raising dialecticians ignore some of the +most important and well-known facts which bear upon the +question. Anything more than a parochial acquaintance with +physical geography and geology would suffice to remind its +possessor that the Holy Land itself offers a standing protest +against bringing such a deluge as that of Noah anywhere near it, +either in historical times or in the course of that pleistocene +period, of which the "great ice age" formed a part. + +Judaea and Galilee, Moab and Gilead, occupy part of that +extensive tableland at the summit of the western boundary of the +Euphrates valley, to which I have already referred. If that +valley had ever been filled with water to a height sufficient, +not indeed to cover a third of Ararat, in the north, or half of +some of the mountains of the Persian frontier in the east, but +to reach even four or five thousand feet, it must have stood +over the Palestinian hog's back, and have filled, up to the +brim, every depression on its surface. Therefore it could not +have failed to fill that remarkable trench in which the Dead +Sea, the Jordan, and the Sea of Galilee lie, and which is known +as the "Jordan-Arabah" valley. + +This long and deep hollow extends more than 200 miles, from near +the site of ancient Dan in the north, to the water-parting at +the head of the Wady Arabah in the south; and its deepest part, +at the bottom of the basin of the Dead Sea, lies 2500 feet below +the surface of the adjacent Mediterranean. The lowest portion of +the rim of the Jordan-Arabah valley is situated at the village +of El Fuleh, 257 feet above the Mediterranean. Everywhere else +the circumjacent heights rise to a very much greater altitude. +Hence, of the water which stood over the Syrian tableland, when +as much drained off as could run away, enough would remain to +form a "Mere" without an outlet, 2757 feet deep, over the +present site of the Dead Sea. From this time forth, the level of +the Palestinian mere could be lowered only by evaporation. It is +an extremely interesting fact, which has happily escaped capture +for the purposes of the energetic misunderstanding, that the +valley, at one time, was filled, certainly within 150 feet of +this height--probably higher. And it is almost equally certain, +that the time at which this great Jordan-Arabah mere reached its +highest level coincides with the glacial epoch. But then the +evidence which goes to prove this, also leads to the conclusion +that this state of things obtained at a period considerably +older than even 4000 B.C., when the world, according to the +"Helps" (or shall we say "Hindrances") provided for the simple +student of the Bible, was created; that it was not brought about +by any diluvial catastrophe, but was the result of a change in +the relative activities of certain natural operations which are +quietly going on now; and that, since the level of the mere +began to sink, many thousand years ago, no serious catastrophe +of any description has affected the valley. + +The evidence that the Jordan-Arabah valley really was once +filled with water, the surface of which reached within 160 feet +of the level of the pass of Jezrael, and possibly stood higher, +is this: Remains of alluvial strata, containing shells of the +freshwater mollusks which still inhabit the valley, worn down +into terraces by waves which long rippled at the same level, and +furrowed by the channels excavated by modern rainfalls, have +been found at the former height; and they are repeated, at +intervals, lower down, until the Ghor, or plain of the Jordan, +itself an alluvial deposit, is reached. These strata attain a +considerable thickness; and they indicate that the epoch at +which the freshwater mere of Palestine reached its highest level +is extremely remote; that its diminution has taken place very +slowly, and with periods of rest, during which the first formed +deposits were cut down into terraces. This conclusion is +strikingly borne out by other facts. A volcanic region stretches +from Galilee to Gilead and the Hauran, on each side of the +northern end of the valley. Some of the streams of basaltic lava +which have been thrown out from its craters and clefts in times +of which history has no record, have run athwart the course of +the Jordan itself, or of that of some of its tributary streams. +The lava streams, therefore, must be of later date than the +depressions they fill. And yet, where they have thus temporarily +dammed the Jordan and the Jermuk, these streams have had time to +cut through the hard basalts and lay bare the beds, over which, +before the lava streams invaded them, they flowed. + +In fact, the antiquity of the present Jordan-Arabah valley, as a +hollow in a tableland, out of reach of the sea, and troubled by +no diluvial or other disturbances, beyond the volcanic eruptions +of Gilead and of Galilee, is vast, even as estimated by a +geological standard. No marine deposits of later than miocene +age occur in or about it; and there is every reason to believe +that the Syro-Arabian plateau has been dry land, throughout the +pliocene and later epochs, down to the present time. +Raised beaches, containing recent shells, on the Levantine +shores of the Mediterranean and on those of the Red Sea, testify +to a geologically recent change of the sea level to the extent +of 250 or 300 feet, probably produced by the slow elevation of +the land; and, as I have already remarked, the alluvial plain of +the Euphrates and Tigris appears to have been affected in the +same way, though seemingly to a less extent. But of violent, or +catastrophic, change there is no trace. Even the volcanic +outbursts have flowed in even sheets over the old land surface; +and the long lines of the horizontal terraces which remain, +testify to the geological insignificance of such earthquakes as +have taken place. It is, indeed, possible that the original +formation of the valley may have been determined by the well- +known fault, along which the western rocks are relatively +depressed and the eastern elevated. But, whether that fault was +effected slowly or quickly, and whenever it came into existence, +the excavation of the valley to its present width, no less than +the sculpturing of its steep walls and of the innumerable deep +ravines which score them down to the very bottom, are +indubitably due to the operation of rain and streams, during an +enormous length of time, without interruption or disturbance of +any magnitude. The alluvial deposits which have been mentioned +are continued into the lateral ravines, and have more or less +filled them. But, since the waters have been lowered, these +deposits have been cut down to great depths, and are still being +excavated by the present temporary, or permanent, streams. +Hence, it follows, that all these ravines must have existed +before the time at which the valley was occupied by the great +mere. This fact acquires a peculiar importance when we proceed +to consider the grounds for the conclusion that the old +Palestinian mere attained its highest level in the cold period +of the pleistocene epoch. It is well known that glaciers +formerly came low down on the flanks of Lebanon and Antilebanon; +indeed, the old moraines are the haunts of the few survivors of +the famous cedars. This implies a perennial snowcap of great +extent on Hermon; therefore, a vastly greater supply of water to +the sources of the Jordan which rise on its flanks; and, in +addition, such a total change in the general climate, that the +innumerable Wadys, now traversed only by occasional storm +torrents, must have been occupied by perennial streams. All this +involves a lower annual temperature and a moist and rainy +atmosphere. If such a change of meteorological conditions could +be effected now, when the loss by evaporation from the surface +of the Dead Sea salt-pan balances all the gain from the Jordan +and other streams, the scale would be turned in the other +direction. The waters of the Dead Sea would become diluted; +its level would rise; it would cover, first the plain of the +Jordan, then the lake of Galilee, then the middle Jordan between +this lake and that of Huleh (the ancient Merom); and, finally, +it would encroach, northwards, along the course of the upper +Jordan, and, southwards, up the Wady Arabah, until it reached +some 260 feet above the level of the Mediterranean, when it +would attain a permanent level, by sending any superfluity +through the pass of Jezrael to swell the waters of the Kishon, +and flow thence into the Mediterranean. + +Reverse the process, in consequence of the excess of loss by +evaporation over gain by inflow, which must have set in as the +climate of Syria changed after the end of the pleistocene epoch, +and (without taking into consideration any other circumstances) +the present state of things must eventually be reached--a +concentrated saline solution in the deepest part of the valley-- +water, rather more charged with saline matter than ordinary +fresh water, in the lower Jordan and the lake of Galilee--fresh +waters, still largely derived from the snows of Hermon, in the +upper Jordan and in Lake Huleh. But, if the full state of the +Jordan valley marks the glacial epoch, then it follows that the +excavation of that valley by atmospheric agencies must have +occupied an immense antecedent time--a large part, perhaps the +whole, of the pliocene epoch; and we are thus forced to the +conclusion that, since the miocene epoch, the physical +conformation of the Holy Land has been substantially what it is +now. It has been more or less rained upon, searched by +earthquakes here and there, partially overflowed by lava +streams, slowly raised (relatively to the sea-level) a few +hundred feet. But there is not a shadow of ground for supposing +that, throughout all this time, terrestrial animals have ceased +to inhabit a large part of its surface; or that, in many parts, +they have been, in any respect, incommoded by the changes which +have taken place. + +The evidence of the general stability of the physical conditions +of Western Asia, which is furnished by Palestine and by the +Euphrates Valley, is only fortified if we extend our view +northwards to the Black Sea and the Caspian. The Caspian is a +sort of magnified replica of the Dead Sea. The bottom of the +deepest part of this vast inland mere is about 3000 feet below +the level of the Mediterranean, while its surface is lower by 85 +feet. At present, it is separated, on the west, by wide spaces +of dry land from the Black Sea, which has the same height as the +Mediterranean; and, on the east, from the Aral, 138 feet above +that level. The waters of the Black Sea, now in communication +with the Mediterranean by the Dardanelles and the Bosphorus, are +salt, but become brackish northwards, where the rivers of the +steppes pour in a great volume of fresh water. Those of the +shallower northern half of the Caspian are similarly affected by +the Volga and the Ural, while, in the shallow bays of the +southern division, they become extremely saline in consequence +of the intense evaporation. The Aral Sea, though supplied by the +Jaxartes and the Oxus, has brackish water. There is evidence +that, in the pliocene and pleistocene periods, to go no farther +back, the strait of the Dardanelles did not exist, and that the +vast area, from the valley of the Danube to that of the +Jaxartes, was covered by brackish or, in some parts, fresh water +to a height of at least 200 feet above the level of the +Mediterranean. At the present time, the water-parting which +separates the northern part of the basin of the Caspian from the +vast plains traversed by the Tobol and the Obi, in their course +to the Arctic Ocean, appears to be less than 200 feet above the +latter. It would seem, therefore, to be very probable that, +under the climatal conditions of part of the pleistocene period, +the valley of the Obi played the same part in relation to the +Ponto-Aralian sea, as that of the Kishon may have done to the +great mere of the Jordan valley; and that the outflow formed the +channel by which the well-known Arctic elements of the fauna of +the Caspian entered it. For the fossil remains imbedded in the +strata continuously deposited in the Aralo-Caspian area, since +the latter end of the miocene epoch, show no sign that, from +that time onward, it has ever been covered by sea water. +Therefore, the supposition of a free inflow of the Arctic Ocean, +which at one time was generally received, as well as that of +various hypothetical deluges from that quarter, must be +seriously questioned. + +The Caspian and the Aral stand in somewhat the same relation to +the vast basin of dry land in which they lie, as the Dead Sea +and the lake of Galilee to the Jordan valley. They are the +remains of a vast, mostly brackish, mere, which has dried up in +consequence of the excess of evaporation over supply, since the +cold and damp climate of the pleistocene epoch gave place to the +increasing dryness and great summer heats of Central Asia in +more modern times. The desiccation of the Aralo-Caspian basin, +which communicated with the Black Sea only by a comparatively +narrow and shallow strait along the present valley of Manytsch, +the bottom of which was less than 100 feet above the +Mediterranean, must have been vastly aided by the erosion of the +strait of the Dardanelles towards the end of the pleistocene +epoch, or perhaps later. For the result of thus opening a +passage for the waters of the Black Sea into the Mediterranean +must have been the gradual lowering of its level to that of the +latter sea. When this process had gone so far as to bring down +the Black Sea water to within less than a hundred feet of its +present level, the strait of Manytsch ceased to exist; and the +vast body of fresh water brought down by the Danube, the +Dnieper, the Don, and other South Russian rivers was cut off +from the Caspian, and eventually delivered into the +Mediterranean. Thus, there is as conclusive evidence as one can +well hope to obtain in these matters, that, north of the +Euphrates valley, the physical geography of an area as large as +all Central Europe has remained essentially unchanged, from the +miocene period down to our time; just as, to the west of the +Euphrates valley, Palestine has exhibited a similar persistence +of geographical type. To the south, the valley of the Nile tells +exactly the same story. The holes bored by miocene mollusks in +the cliffs east and west of Cairo bear witness that, in the +miocene epoch, it contained an arm of the sea, the bottom of +which has since been gradually filled up by the alluvium of the +Nile, and elevated to its present position. But the higher parts +of the Mokattam and of the desert about Ghizeh, have been dry +land from that time to this. Too little is known of the geology +of Persia, at present, to allow any positive conclusion to be +enunciated. But, taking the name to indicate the whole +continental mass of Iran, between the valleys of the Indus and +the Euphrates, the supposition that its physical geography has +remained unchanged for an immensely long period is hardly rash. +The country is, in fact, an enormous basin, surrounded on all +sides by a mountainous rim, and subdivided within by ridges into +plateaus and hollows, the bottom of the deepest of which, in the +province of Seistan, probably descends to the level of the +Indian Ocean. These depressions are occupied by salt marshes and +deserts, in which the waters of the streams which flow down the +sides of the basin are now dissipated by evaporation. I am +acquainted with no evidence that the present Iranian basin was +ever occupied by the sea; but the accumulations of gravel over a +great extent of its surface indicate long-continued water +action. It is, therefore, a fair presumption that large lakes +have covered much of its present deserts, and that they have +dried up by the operation of the same changed climatal +conditions as those which have reduced the Caspian and the Dead +Sea to their present dimensions.<11> + +Thus it would seem that the Euphrates valley, the centre of the +fabled Noachian deluge, is also the centre of a region covering +some millions of square miles of the present continents of +Europe, Asia, and Africa, in which all the facts, relevant to +the argument, at present known, converge to the conclusion that, +since the miocene epoch, the essential features of its physical +geography have remained unchanged; that it has neither been +depressed below the sea, nor swept by diluvial waters since that +time; and that the Chaldaean version of the legend of a flood in +the Euphrates valley is, of all those which are extant, the only +one which is even consistent with probability, since it depicts +a local inundation, not more severe than one which might be +brought about by a concurrence of favourable conditions at the +present day; and which might probably have been more easily +effected when the Persian Gulf extended farther north. +Hence, the recourse to the "glacial epoch" for some event which +might colourably represent a flood, distinctly asserted by the +only authority for it to have occurred in historical times, is +peculiarly unfortunate. Even a Welsh antiquary might hesitate +over the supposition that a tradition of the fate of Moel +Tryfaen, in the glacial epoch, had furnished the basis of fact +for a legend which arose among people whose own experience +abundantly supplied them with the needful precedents. +Moreover, if evidence of interchanges of land and sea are to be +accepted as "confirmations" of Noah's deluge, there are plenty +of sources for the tradition to be had much nearer than Wales. + +The depression now filled by the Red Sea, for example, appears +to be, geologically, of very recent origin. The later deposits +found on its shores, two or three hundred feet above the sea +level, contain no remains older than those of the present fauna; +while, as I have already mentioned, the valley of the adjacent +delta of the Nile was a gulf of the sea in miocene times. +But there is not a particle of evidence that the change of +relative level which admitted the waters of the Indian Ocean +between Arabia and Africa, took place any faster than that which +is now going on in Greenland and Scandinavia, and which has left +their inhabitants undisturbed. Even more remarkable changes were +effected, towards the end of, or since, the glacial epoch, over +the region now occupied by the Levantine Mediterranean and the +AEgean Sea. The eastern coast region of Asia Minor, the western +of Greece, and many of the intermediate islands, exhibit thick +masses of stratified deposits of later tertiary age and of +purely lacustrine characters; and it is remarkable that, on the +south side of the island of Crete, such masses present steep +cliffs facing the sea, so that the southern boundary of the lake +in which they were formed must have been situated where the sea +now flows. Indeed, there are valid reasons for the supposition +that the dry land once extended far to the west of the present +Levantine coast, and not improbably forced the Nile to seek an +outlet to the north-east of its present delta--a possibility of +no small importance in relation to certain puzzling facts in the +geographical distribution of animals in this region. At any +rate, continuous land joined Asia Minor with the Balkan +peninsula; and its surface bore deep fresh-water lakes, +apparently disconnected with the Ponto-Aralian sea. This state +of things lasted long enough to allow of the formation of the +thick lacustrine strata to which I have referred. I am not aware +that there is the smallest ground for the assumption that the +AEgean land was broken up in consequence of any of the +"catastrophes" which are so commonly invoked.<12> For anything +that appears to the contrary, the narrow, steep-sided, straits +between the islands of the AEgean archipelago may have been +originally brought about by ordinary atmospheric and stream +action; and may then have been filled from the Mediterranean, +during a slow submergence proceeding from the south northwards. +The strait of the Dardanelles is bounded by undisturbed +pleistocene strata forty feet thick, through which, to all +appearance, the present passage has been quietly cut. + +That Olympus and Ossa were torn asunder and the waters of the +Thessalian basin poured forth, is a very ancient notion, and an +often cited "confirmation" of Deucalion's flood. It has not yet +ceased to be in vogue, apparently because those who entertain it +are not aware that modern geological investigation has +conclusively proved that the gorge of the Penens is as typical +an example of a valley of erosion as any to be seen in Auvergne +or in Colorado.<13> + +Thus, in the immediate vicinity of the vast expanse of country +which can be proved to have been untouched by any catastrophe +before, during, and since the "glacial epoch," lie the great +areas of the AEgean and the Red Sea, in which, during or since +the glacial epoch, changes of the relative positions of land and +sea have taken place, in comparison with which the submergence +of Moel Tryfaen, with all Wales and Scotland to boot, does not +come to much. + +What, then, is the relevancy of talk about the "glacial epoch" +to the question of the historical veracity of the narrator of +the story of the Noachian deluge? So far as my knowledge goes, +there is not a particle of evidence that destructive inundations +were more common, over the general surface of the earth, in the +glacial epoch than they have been before or since. No doubt the +fringe of an ice-covered region must be always liable to them; +but, if we examine the records of such catastrophes in +historical times, those produced in the deltas of great rivers, +or in lowlands like Holland, by sudden floods, combined with +gales of wind or with unusual tides, far excel all others. + +With respect to such inundations as are the consequences of +earthquakes, and other slight movements of the crust of the +earth, I have never heard of anything to show that they were +more frequent and severer in the quaternary or tertiary epochs +than they are now. In the discussion of these, as of all other +geological problems, the appeal to needless catastrophes is born +of that impatience of the slow and painful search after +sufficient causes, in the ordinary course of nature, which is a +temptation to all, though only energetic ignorance nowadays +completely succumbs to it. + + +POSTSCRIPT. + +My best thanks are due to Mr. Gladstone for his courteous +withdrawal of one of the statements to which I have thought it +needful to take exception. The familiarity with controversy, to +which Mr. Gladstone alludes, will have accustomed him to the +misadventures which arise when, as sometimes will happen in the +heat of fence, the buttons come off the foils. I trust that any +scratch which he may have received will heal as quickly as my +own flesh wounds have done. + + +A contribution to the last number of this Review (<i>The +Nineteenth Century</i>) of a different order would be left +unnoticed, were it not that my silence would convert me into an +accessory to misrepresentations of a very grave character. +However, I shall restrict myself to the barest possible +statement of facts, leaving my readers to draw their +own conclusions. + +In an article entitled "A Great Lesson," published in this +Review for September, 1887: + +(1) The Duke of Argyll says the "overthrow of Darwin's +speculations" (p. 301) concerning the origin of coral reefs, +which he fancied had taken place, had been received by men of +science "with a grudging silence as far as public discussion is +concerned" (p. 301). + +The truth is that, as every one acquainted with the literature +of the subject was well aware, the views supposed to have +effected this overthrow had been fully and publicly discussed by +Dana in the United States; by Geikie, Green, and Prestwich in +this country; by Lapparent in France; and by Credner in Germany. + +(2) The Duke of Argyll says "that no serious reply has ever been +attempted" (p. 305). + +The truth is that the highest living authority on the subject, +Professor Dana, published a most weighty reply, two years before +the Duke of Argyll committed himself to this statement. + +(3) The Duke of Argyll uses the preceding products of defective +knowledge, multiplied by excessive imagination, to illustrate +the manner in which "certain accepted opinions" established "a +sort of Reign of Terror in their own behalf" (p. 307). + +The truth is that no plea, except that of total ignorance of the +literature of the subject, can excuse the errors cited, and that +the "Reign of Terror" is a purely subjective phenomenon. + +(4) The letter in "Nature" for the 17th of November, 1887, to +which I am referred, contains neither substantiation, nor +retractation, of statements 1 and 2. Nevertheless, it repeats +number 3. The Duke of Argyll says of his article that it "has +done what I intended it to do. It has called wide attention to +the influence of mere authority in establishing erroneous +theories and in retarding the progress of scientific truth." + +(5) The Duke of Argyll illustrates the influence of his +fictitious "Reign of Terror" by the statement that Mr. John +Murray "was strongly advised against the publication of his +views in derogation of Darwin's long-accepted theory of the +coral islands, and was actually induced to delay it for two +years" (p.307). And in "Nature" for the l7th November, 1887, the +Duke of Argyll states that he has seen a letter from Sir Wyville +Thomson in which he "urged and almost insisted that Mr. Murray +should withdraw the reading of his papers on the subject from +the Royal Society of Edinburgh. This was in February, 1877." +The next paragraph, however, contains the confession: +"No special reason was assigned." The Duke of Argyll proceeds to +give a speculative opinion that "Sir Wyville dreaded some injury +to the scientific reputation of the body of which he was the +chief." Truly, a very probable supposition; but as Sir Wyville +Thomson's tendencies were notoriously anti-Darwinian, it does +not appear to me to lend the slightest justification to the Duke +of Argyll's insinuation that the Darwinian "terror" influenced +him. However, the question was finally set at rest by a letter +which appeared in "Nature" (29th of December, 1887), in which +the writer says that: + +"talking with Sir Wyville about 'Murray's new theory,' I asked +what objection he had to its being brought before the public? +The answer simply was: he considered that the grounds of the +theory had not, as yet, been sufficiently investigated or +sufficiently corroborated, and that therefore any immature +dogmatic publication of it would do less than little service +either to science or to the author of the paper." + +Sir Wyville Thomson was an intimate friend of mine, and I am +glad to have been afforded one more opportunity of clearing his +character from the aspersions which have been so recklessly cast +upon his good sense and his scientific honour. + +(6) As to the "overthrow" of Darwin's theory, which, according +to the Duke of Argyll, was patent to every unprejudiced person +four years ago, I have recently become acquainted with a work, +in which a really competent authority,<14> thoroughly acquainted +with all the new lights which have been thrown upon the subject +during the last ten years, pronounces the judgment; +firstly, that some of the facts brought forward by Messrs. +Murray and Guppy against Darwin's theory are not facts; +secondly, that the others are reconcilable with Darwin's theory; +and, thirdly, that the theories of Messrs. Murray and Guppy "are +contradicted by a series of important facts" (p. 13). + +Perhaps I had better draw attention to the circumstance that +Dr. Langenbeck writes under shelter of the guns of the fortress +of Strasburg; and may therefore be presumed to be unaffected by +those dreams of a "Reign of Terror" which seem to disturb the +peace of some of us in these islands (April, 1891). + +[See, on the subject of this note, the essay entitled "An +Episcopal Trilogy" in the following volume.] + + +FOOTNOTES + +(1) In May 1849 the Tigris at Bagdad rose 22-1/2 feet--5 feet +above its usual rise--and nearly swept away the town. In 1831 a +similarly exceptional flood did immense damage, destroying 7000 +houses. See Loftus, <i>Chaldea and Susiana,</i> p. 7. + +(2) See the instructive chapter on Hasisadra's flood in Suess, +<i>Das Antlitz der Erde,</i> Abth. I. Only fifteen years ago a +cyclone in the Bay of Bengal gave rise to a flood which covered +3000 square miles of the delta of the Ganges, 3 to 45 feet deep, +destroying 100,000 people, innumerable cattle, houses, and +trees. It broke inland on the rising ground of Tipperah, and may +have swept a vessel from the sea that far, though I do not know +that it did. + +(3) See Cernik's maps in <i>Petermanns Mittheilungen,</i> +Erganzungashefte 44 and 45, 1875-76. + +(4) I have not cited the dimensions given to the ships in most +translations of the story, because there appears to be a doubt +about them. Haupt (<i>Keilinschriftliche Sindfluth-Bericht,</i> +p. 13) says that the figures are illegible. + +(5) It is probable that a slow movement of elevation of the land +at one time contributed to the result--perhaps does so still. + +(6) At a comparatively recent period, the littoral margin of the +Persian Gulf extended certainly 250 miles farther to the +northwest than the present embouchure of the Shatt-el Arab. +(Loftus, <i>Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society,</i> +1853, p. 251.) The actual extent of the marine deposit inland +cannot be defined, as it is covered by later +fluviatile deposits. + +(7) Tiele (<i>Babylonisch-Assyrische Geschicthe,</i> pp. 572-3) +has some very just remarks on this aspect of the epos. + +(8) In the second volume of the <i>History of the Euphrates,</i> +p. 637 Col. Chesney gives a very interesting account of the +simple and rapid manner in which the people about Tekrit and in +the marshes of Lemlum construct large barges, and make them +water-tight with bitumen. Doubtless the practice is extremely +ancient and as Colonel Chesney suggests, may possibly have +furnished the conception of Noah's ark. But it is one thing to +build a barge 44ft. long by 11ft. wide and 4ft. deep in the way +described; and another to get a vessel of ten times the +dimensions, so constructed, to hold together. + +(9) "Es ist nichts schrecklicher als eine thatige Unwissenheit," +<i>Maximen und Reflexionen,</i> iii. + +(10) The well-known difficulties connected with this case have +recently been carefully discussed by Mr. Bell in the +<i>Transactions</i> of the Geological Society of Glasgow. + +(11) An instructive parallel is exhibited by the "Great Basin" +of North America. See the remarkable memoir on <i>Lake +Bonneville</i> by Mr. G. K. Gilbert, of the United States +Geological Survey, just published. + +(12) It is true that earthquakes are common enough, but they +are incompetent to produce such changes as those which have +taken place. + +(13) See Teller, <i>Geologische Beschreibung des sud-ostlichen +Thessalien;</i> Denkschriften d. Akademie der Wissenschaften, +Wien, Bd. xl. p. 199. + +(14) Dr. Langenbeck, <i>Die Theorien uber die Entstehung der +Korallen-Inseln und Korallen-Riffe</i> (p. 13), 1890. + + + + + +End of The Project Gutenberg Etext of Hasisadra's Adventure, by Huxley +This is Essay #7 from "Science and Hebrew Tradition" + diff --git a/old/7saht10.zip b/old/7saht10.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..a540a74 --- /dev/null +++ b/old/7saht10.zip |