diff options
Diffstat (limited to '19856-8.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | 19856-8.txt | 10943 |
1 files changed, 10943 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/19856-8.txt b/19856-8.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..0969997 --- /dev/null +++ b/19856-8.txt @@ -0,0 +1,10943 @@ +The Project Gutenberg EBook of A Study of Pueblo Architecture: Tusayan and +Cibola, by Victor Mindeleff and Cosmos Mindeleff + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: A Study of Pueblo Architecture: Tusayan and Cibola + Eighth Annual Report of the Bureau of Ethnology to the + Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, 1886-1887, + Government Printing Office, Washington, 1891, pages 3-228 + +Author: Victor Mindeleff and Cosmos Mindeleff + +Illustrator: Henry Hobart Nichols + +Release Date: November 17, 2006 [EBook #19856] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK PUEBLO ARCHITECTURE *** + + + + +Produced by Louise Hope, Carlo Traverso, Håkon Hope and +the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at +http://www.pgdp.net (This file was produced from images +generously made available by the Bibliothèque nationale +de France (BnF/Gallica) at http://gallica.bnf.fr) + + + + + + [Transcriber's Note: + + This e-text is intended for browsers or text readers that cannot use + the "real" (Unicode, UTF-8) version of the text. A few letters have + been "unpacked" and shown within brackets: + [)E] [)i] [)o] letter with breve or "short" mark + [n] small raised n + Except footnote and illustration tags, all other brackets are from the + original, as are the parenthetical question marks. + + Variant spellings and typographical errors are listed at the end of + the text.] + + * * * * * + + A STUDY + + of + + PUEBLO ARCHITECTURE: + + Tusayan And Cibola. + + by + + Victor Mindeleff. + + * * * * * + + +CONTENTS. + + +Introduction 13 + +CHAPTER I.--Traditionary history of Tusayan 16 + Explanatory 16 + Summary of traditions 16 + List of traditionary gentes 38 + Supplementary legend 40 + +CHAPTER II.--Ruins and inhabited villages of Tusayan 42 + Physical features of the province 42 + Methods of survey 44 + Plans and description of ruins 45 + Walpi ruins 46 + Old Mashongnavi 47 + Shitaimuvi 48 + Awatubi 49 + Horn House 50 + Small ruin near Horn House 51 + Bat House 52 + Mishiptonga 52 + Moen-kopi 53 + Ruins on the Oraibi wash 54 + Kwaituki 56 + Tebugkihu, or Fire House 57 + Chukubi 59 + Payupki 59 + Plans and descriptions of inhabited villages 61 + Hano 61 + Sichumovi 62 + Walpi 63 + Mashongnavi 66 + Shupaulovi 71 + Shumopavi 73 + Oraibi 76 + Moen-kopi 77 + +CHAPTER III.--Ruins and inhabited villages of Cibola 80 + Physical features of the province 80 + Plans and descriptions of ruins 80 + Hawikuh 80 + Ketchipauan 81 + Chalowe 83 + Hampassawan 84 + K'iakima 85 + Matsaki 86 + Pinawa 86 + Halona 88 + Tâaaiyalana ruins 89 + Kin-tiel and Kinna-Zinde 91 + Plans and descriptions of inhabited villages 94 + Nutria 94 + Pescado 95 + Ojo Caliente 96 + Zuñi 97 + +CHAPTER IV.--Architecture of Tusayan and Cibola compared + by constructional details 100 + Introduction 100 + Housebuilding 100 + Rites and methods 100 + Localization of gentes 104 + Interior arrangement 108 + Kivas in Tusayan 111 + General use of kivas by pueblo builders 111 + Origin of the name 111 + Antiquity of the kiva 111 + Excavation of the kiva 112 + Access 113 + Masonry 114 + Orientation 115 + The ancient form of kiva 116 + Native explanations of position 117 + Methods of kiva building and rites 118 + Typical plans 118 + Work by women 129 + Consecration 129 + Various uses of kivas 130 + Kiva ownership 133 + Motives for building a kiva 134 + Significance of structural plan 135 + Typical measurements 136 + List of Tusayan Kivas 136 + Details of Tusayan and Cibola construction 137 + Walls 137 + Roofs and floors 148 + Wall copings and roof drains 151 + Ladders and steps 156 + Cooking pits and ovens 162 + Oven-shaped structures 167 + Fireplaces and chimneys 167 + Gateways and covered passages 180 + Doors 182 + Windows 194 + Roof openings 201 + Furniture 208 + Corrals and gardens; eagle cages 214 + "Kisi" construction 217 + Architectural nomenclature 220 + +Concluding remarks 223 + + + + +ILLUSTRATIONS. + + Page. + Plate I. Map of the provinces of Tusayan and Cibola 12 + II. Old Mashongnavi, plan 14 + III. General view of Awatubi 16 + IV. Awatubi (Talla-Hogan), plan 18 + V. Standing walls of Awatubi 20 + VI. Adobe fragment in Awatubi 22 + VII. Horn House ruin, plan 24 + VIII. Bat House 26 + IX. Mishiptonga (Jeditoh) 28 + X. A small ruin near Moen-kopi 30 + XI. Masonry on the outer wall of the Fire-House, + detail 32 + XII. Chukubi, plan 34 + XIII. Payupki, plan 36 + XIV. General view of Payupki 38 + XV. Standing walls of Payupki 40 + XVI. Plan of Hano 42 + XVII. View of Hano 44 + XVIII. Plan of Sichumovi 46 + XIX. View of Sichumovi 48 + XX. Plan of Walpi 50 + XXI. View of Walpi 52 + XXII. South passageway of Walpi 54 + XXIII. Houses built over irregular sites, Walpi 56 + XXIV. Dance rock and kiva, Walpi 58 + XXV. Foot trail to Walpi 60 + XXVI. Mashongnavi, plan 62 + XXVII. Mashongnavi with Shupaulovi in distance 64 + XXVIII. Back wall of a Mashongnavi house-row 66 + XXIX. West side of a principal row in Mashongnavi 68 + XXX. Plan of Shupaulovi 70 + XXXI. View of Shupaulovi 72 + XXXII. A covered passageway of Shupaulovi 74 + XXXIII. The chief kiva of Shupaulovi 76 + XXXIV. Plan of Shumopavi 78 + XXXV. View of Shumopavi 80 + XXXVI. Oraibi, plan In pocket. + XXXVII. Key to the Oraibi plan, also showing + localization of gentes 82 + XXXVIII. A court of Oraibi 84 + XXXIX. Masonry terraces of Oraibi 86 + XL. Oraibi house row, showing court side 88 + XLI. Back of Oraibi house row 90 + XLII. The site of Moen-kopi 92 + XLIII. Plan of Moen-kopi 94 + XLIV. Moen-kopi 96 + XLV. The Mormon mill at Moen-kopi 98 + XLVI. Hawikuh, plan 100 + XLVII. Hawikuh, view 102 + XLVIII. Adobe church at Hawikuh 104 + XLIX. Ketchipanan, plan 106 + L. Ketchipauan 108 + LI. Stone church at Ketchipauan 110 + LII. K'iakima, plan 112 + LIII. Site of K'iakima, at base of Tâaaiyalana 114 + LIV. Recent wall at K'iakima 116 + LV. Matsaki, plan 118 + LVI. Standing wall at Pinawa 120 + LVII. Halona excavations as seen from Zuñi 122 + LVIII. Fragments of Halona wall 124 + LIX. The mesa of Tâaaiyalana, from Zuñi 126 + LX. Tâaaiyalana, plan 128 + LXI. Standing walls of Tâaaiyalana ruins 130 + LXII. Remains of a reservoir on Tâaaiyalana 132 + LXIII. Kin-tiel, plan (also showing excavations) 134 + LXIV. North wall of Kin-tiel 136 + LXV. Standing walls of Kin-tiel 138 + LXVI. Kinna-Zinde 140 + LXVII. Nutria, plan 142 + LXVIII. Nutria, view 144 + LXIX. Pescado, plan 146 + LXX. Court view of Pescado, showing corrals 148 + LXXI. Pescado houses 150 + LXXII. Fragments of ancient masonry in Pescado 152 + LXXIII. Ojo Caliente, plan In pocket. + LXXIV. General view of Ojo Caliente 154 + LXXV. House at Ojo Caliente 156 + LXXVI. Zuñi, plan In pocket. + LXXVII. Outline plan of Zuñi, showing distribution + of oblique openings 158 + LXXVIII. General inside view of Zuñi, looking west 160 + LXXIX. Zuñi terraces 162 + LXXX. Old adobe church of Zuñi 164 + LXXXI. Eastern rows of Zuñi 166 + LXXXII. A Zuñi court 168 + LXXXIII. A Zuñi small house 170 + LXXXIV. A house-building at Oraibi 172 + LXXXV. A Tusayan interior 174 + LXXXVI. A Zuñi interior 176 + LXXXVII. A kiva hatchway of Tusayan 178 + LXXXVIII. North kivas of Shumopavi, from the northeast 180 + LXXXIX. Masonry in the north wing of Kin-tiel 182 + XC. Adobe garden walls near Zuñi. 184 + XCI. A group of stone corrals near Oraibi 186 + XCII. An inclosing wall of upright stones at + Ojo Caliente 188 + XCIII. Upright blocks of sandstone built into an + ancient pueblo wall 190 + XCIV. Ancient wall of upright rocks in southwestern + Colorado 192 + XCV. Ancient floor-beams at Kin-tiel 194 + XCVI. Adobe walls in Zuñi 196 + XCVII. Wall coping and oven at Zuñi 198 + XCVIII. Cross-pieces on Zuñi ladders 200 + XCIX. Outside steps at Pescado 202 + C. An excavated room at Kin-tiel 204 + CI. Masonry chimneys of Zuñi 206 + CII. Remains of a gateway in Awatubi 208 + CIII. Ancient gateway, Kin-tiel 210 + CIV. A covered passageway in Mashongnavi 212 + CV. Small square openings in Pueblo Bonito 214 + CVI. Sealed openings in a detached house of Nutria 216 + CVII. Partial filling-in of a large opening in + Oraibi, converting it into a doorway 218 + CVIII. Large openings reduced to small windows, Oraibi 220 + CIX. Stone corrals and kiva of Mashongnavi 222 + CX. Portion of a corral in Pescado 224 + CXI. Zuñi eagle-cage 226 + + + Page. +Fig. 1. View of the First Mesa 43 + 2. Ruins, Old Walpi mound 47 + 3. Ruin between Bat House and Horn House 51 + 4. Ruin near Moen-kopi, plan 53 + 5. Ruin 7 miles north of Oraibi 55 + 6. Ruin 14 miles north of Oraibi (Kwaituki) 56 + 7. Oval fire-house ruin, plan. (Tebugkihu) 58 + 8. Topography of the site of Walpi 64 + 9. Mashongnavi and Shupaulovi from Shumopavi 66 + 10. Diagram showing growth of Mashongnavi 67 + 11. Diagram showing growth of Mashongnavi 68 + 12. Diagram showing growth of Mashongnavi 69 + 13. Topography of the site of Shupaulovi 71 + 14. Court kiva of Shumopavi 75 + 15. Hampassawan, plan 84 + 16. Pinawa, plan 87 + 17. Nutria, plan; small diagram, old wall 94 + 18. Pescado, plan, old wall diagram 95 + 19. A Tusayan wood-rack 103 + 20. Interior ground plan of a Tusayan room 108 + 21. North kivas of Shumopavi from the southwest 114 + 22. Ground plan of the chief-kiva of Shupaulovi 122 + 23. Ceiling-plan of the chief-kiva of Shupaulovi 123 + 24. Interior view of a Tusayan kiva 124 + 25. Ground-plan of a Shupaulovi kiva 125 + 26. Ceiling-plan of a Shupaulovi kiva 125 + 27. Ground-plan of the chief-kiva of Mashongnavi 126 + 28. Interior view of a kiva hatchway in Tusayan 127 + 29. Mat used in closing the entrance of Tusayan kivas 128 + 30. Rectangular sipapuh in a Mashongnavi kiva 131 + 31. Loom-post in kiva floor at Tusayan 132 + 32. A Zuñi chimney showing pottery fragments embedded in + its adobe base 139 + 33. A Zuñi oven with pottery scales embedded in + its surface 139 + 34. Stone wedges of Zuñi masonry exposed in a + rain-washed wall 141 + 35. An unplastered house wall in Ojo Caliente 142 + 36. Wall decorations in Mashongnavi, executed in pink + on a white ground 146 + 37. Diagram of Zuñi roof construction 149 + 38. Showing abutment of smaller roof-beams over + round girders 151 + 39. Single stone roof-drains 153 + 40. Trough roof-drains of stone 153 + 41. Wooden roof-drains 154 + 42. Curved roof-drains of stone in Tusayan 154 + 43. Tusayan roof-drains; a discarded metate and a gourd 155 + 44. Zuñi roof-drain, with splash-stones on roof below 156 + 45. A modern notched ladder in Oraibi 157 + 46. Tusayan notched ladders from Mashongnavi 157 + 47. Aboriginal American forms of ladder 158 + 48. Stone steps at Oraibi with platform at corner 161 + 49. Stone steps, with platform at chimney, in Oraibi 161 + 50. Stone steps in Shumopavi 162 + 51. A series of cooking pits in Mashongnavi 163 + 52. Pi-gummi ovens of Mashongnavi 163 + 53. Cross sections of pi-gummi ovens of Mashongnavi 163 + 54. Diagrams showing foundation stones of a Zuñi oven 164 + 55. Dome-shaped oven on a plinth of masonry 165 + 56. Oven in Pescado exposing stones of masonry 166 + 57. Oven in Pescado exposing stones of masonry 166 + 58. Shrines in Mashongnavi 167 + 59. A poultry house in Sichumovi resembling an oven 167 + 60. Ground-plan of an excavated room in Kin-tiel 168 + 61. A corner chimney-hood with two supporting poles, + Tusayan 170 + 62. A curved chimney-hood of Mashongnavi 170 + 63. A Mashongnavi chimney-hood and walled-up fireplace 171 + 64. A chimney-hood of Shupaulovi 172 + 65. A semi-detached square chimney-hood of Zuñi 172 + 66. Unplastered Zuñi chimney-hoods, + illustrating construction 173 + 67. A fireplace and mantel in Sichumovi 174 + 68. A second-story fireplace in Mashongnavi 174 + 69. Piki stone and chimney-hood in Sichumovi 175 + 70. Piki stone and primitive andiron in Shumopavi 176 + 71. A terrace fireplace and chimney of Shumopavi 177 + 72. A terrace cooking-pit and chimney of Walpi 177 + 73. A ground cooking-pit of Shumopavi covered with + a chimney 178 + 74. Tusayan chimneys 179 + 75. A barred Zuñi door 183 + 76. Wooden pivot hinges of a Zuñi door 184 + 77. Paneled wooden doors in Hano 185 + 78. Framing of a Zuñi door panel 186 + 79. Rude transoms over Tusayan openings 188 + 80. A large Tusayan doorway, with small transom openings 189 + 81. A doorway and double transom in Walpi 189 + 82. An ancient doorway in a Canyon de Chelly cliff ruin 190 + 83. A symmetrical notched doorway in Mashongnavi 190 + 84. A Tusayan notched doorway 191 + 85. A large Tusayan doorway with one notched jamb 192 + 86. An ancient circular doorway, or "stone-close," + in Kin-tiel 193 + 87. Diagram illustrating symmetrical arrangement of + small openings in Pueblo Bonito 195 + 88. Incised decoration on a rude window-sash in Zuñi 196 + 89. Sloping selenite window at base of Zuñi wall + on upper terrace 197 + 90. A Zuñi window glazed with selenite 197 + 91. Small openings in the back wall of a Zuñi + house cluster 198 + 92. Sealed openings in Tusayan 199 + 93. A Zuñi doorway converted into a window 201 + 94. Zuñi roof-openings 202 + 95. A Zuñi roof-opening with raised coping 203 + 96. Zuñi roof-openings with one raised end 203 + 97. A Zuñi roof-hole with cover 204 + 98. Kiva trap-door in Zuñi 205 + 99. Halved and pinned trap-door frame of a Zuñi kiva 206 + 100. Typical sections of Zuñi oblique openings 208 + 101. Arrangement of mealing stones in a Tusayan house 209 + 102. A Tusayan grain bin 210 + 103. A Zuñi plume-box 210 + 104. A Zuñi plume-box 210 + 105. A Tusayan mealing trough 211 + 106. An ancient pueblo form of metate 211 + 107. Zuñi stools 213 + 108. A Zuñi chair 213 + 109. Construction of a Zuñi corral 215 + 110. Gardens of Zuñi 216 + 111. "Kishoni," or uncovered shade, of Tusayan 218 + 112. A Tusayan field shelter, from southwest 219 + 113. A Tusayan field shelter, from northeast 219 + 114. Diagram showing ideal section of terraces, + with Tusayan names 223 + + + + + [Illustration: Plate I. + General Map of the Pueblo Region of Arizona and New Mexico, + Showing Relative Position of the Provinces of Tusayan and Cibola. + by Victor Mindeleff.] + + + * * * * * + + + A STUDY OF PUEBLO ARCHITECTURE + IN TUSAYAN AND CIBOLA. + + By Victor Mindeleff. + + + * * * * * + + +INTRODUCTION. + + +The remains of pueblo architecture are found scattered over thousands +of square miles of the arid region of the southwestern plateaus. This +vast area includes the drainage of the Rio Pecos on the east and that +of the Colorado on the west, and extends from central Utah on the north +beyond the limits of the United States southward, in which direction its +boundaries are still undefined. + +The descendants of those who at various times built these stone +villages are few in number and inhabit about thirty pueblos distributed +irregularly over parts of the region formerly occupied. Of these the +greater number are scattered along the upper course of the Rio Grande +and its tributaries in New Mexico; a few of them, comprised within the +ancient provinces of Cibola and Tusayan, are located within the +drainage of the Little Colorado. From the time of the earliest Spanish +expeditions into the country to the present day, a period covering more +than three centuries, the former province has been often visited by +whites, but the remoteness of Tusayan and the arid and forbidding +character of its surroundings have caused its more complete isolation. +The architecture of this district exhibits a close adherence to +aboriginal practices, still bears the marked impress of its development +under the exacting conditions of an arid environment, and is but slowly +yielding to the influence of foreign ideas. + +The present study of the architecture of Tusayan and Cibola embraces all +of the inhabited pueblos of those provinces, and includes a number of +the ruins traditionally connected with them. It will be observed by +reference to the map that the area embraced in these provinces comprises +but a small portion of the vast region over which pueblo culture once +extended. + +This study is designed to be followed by a similar study of two typical +groups of ruins, viz, that of Canyon de Chelly, in northeastern Arizona, +and that of the Chaco Canyon, of New Mexico; but it has been necessary +for the writer to make occasional reference to these ruins in the +present paper, both in the discussion of general arrangement and +characteristic ground plans, embodied in Chapters II and III and in the +comparison by constructional details treated in Chapter IV, in order +to define clearly the relations of the various features of pueblo +architecture. They belong to the same pueblo system illustrated by the +villages of Tusayan and Cibola, and with the Canyon de Chelly group +there is even some trace of traditional connection, as is set forth by +Mr. Stephen in Chapter I. The more detailed studies of these ruins, to +be published later, together with the material embodied in the present +paper, will, it is thought, furnish a record of the principal +characteristics of an important type of primitive architecture, which, +under the influence of the arid environment of the southwestern +plateaus, has developed from the rude lodge into the many-storied +house of rectangular rooms. Indications of some of the steps of this +development are traceable even in the architecture of the present day. + +The pueblo of Zuñi was surveyed by the writer in the autumn of 1881 +with a view to procuring the necessary data for the construction of a +large-scale model of this pueblo. For this reason the work afforded a +record of external features only. + +The modern pueblos of Tusayan were similarly surveyed in the following +season (1882-'83), the plans being supplemented by photographs, from +which many of the illustrations accompanying this paper have been drawn. +The ruin of Awatubi was also included in the work of this season. + +In the autumn of 1885 many of the ruined pueblos of Tusayan were +surveyed and examined. It was during this season's work that the details +of the kiva construction, embodied in the last chapter of this paper, +were studied, together with interior details of the dwellings. It was in +the latter part of this season that the farming pueblos of Cibola were +surveyed and photographed. + +The Tusayan farming pueblo of Moen-kopi and a number of the ruins in the +province were surveyed and studied in the early part of the season of +1887-'88, the latter portion of which season was principally devoted to +an examination of the Chaco ruins in New Mexico. + +In the prosecution of the field work above outlined the author has been +greatly indebted to the efficient assistance and hearty cooperation of +Mr. Cosmos Mindeleff, by whom nearly all the pueblos illustrated, with +the exception of Zuñi, have been surveyed and platted. + +The plans obtained have involved much careful work with surveying +instruments, and have all been so platted as faithfully to record the +minute variations from geometric forms which are so characteristic of +the pueblo work, but which have usually been ignored in the hastily +prepared sketch plans that have at times appeared. In consequence of +the necessary omission of just such information in hastily drawn plans, +erroneous impressions have been given regarding the degree of skill to +which the pueblo peoples had attained in the planning and building of +their villages. In the general distribution of the houses, and in the +alignment and arrangement of their walls, as indicated in the plans +shown in Chapters II and III, an absence of high architectural +attainment is found, which is entirely in keeping with the lack of skill +apparent in many of the constructional devices shown in Chapter IV. + + [Illustration: Plate II. Old Mashongnavi, plan.] + +In preparing this paper for publication Mr. Cosmos Mindeleff has +rendered much assistance in the revision of manuscript, and in the +preparation of some of the final drawings of ground plans; on him has +also fallen the compilation and arrangement of Mr. A. M. Stephen's +traditionary material from Tusayan, embraced in the first chapter of the +paper. + +This latter material is of special interest in a study of the pueblos as +indicating some of the conditions under which this architectural type +was developed, and it appropriately introduces the more purely +architectural study by the author. + +Such traditions must be used as history with the utmost caution, +and only for events that are very recent. Time relations are often +hopelessly confused and the narratives are greatly incumbered with +mythologic details. But while so barren in definite information, these +traditions are of the greatest value, often through their merely +incidental allusions, in presenting to our minds a picture of the +conditions under which the repeated migrations of the pueblo builders +took place. + +The development of architecture among the Pueblo Indians was +comparatively rapid and is largely attributable to frequent changes, +migrations, and movements of the people as described in Mr. Stephen's +account. These changes were due to a variety of causes, such as disease, +death, the frequent warfare carried on between different tribes and +branches of the builders, and the hostility of outside tribes; but a +most potent factor was certainly the inhospitable character of their +environment. The disappearance of some venerated spring during an +unusually dry season would be taken as a sign of the disfavor of the +gods, and, in spite of the massive character of the buildings, would +lead to the migration of the people to a more favorable spot. The +traditions of the Zuñis, as well as those of the Tusayan, frequently +refer to such migrations. At times tribes split up and separate, and +again phratries or distant groups meet and band together. It is +remarkable that the substantial character of the architecture should +persist through such long series of compulsory removals, but while the +builders were held together by the necessity for defense against their +wilder neighbors or against each other, this strong defensive motive +would perpetuate the laborious type of construction. Such conditions +would contribute to the rapid development of the building art. + + + + +CHAPTER I. + +TRADITIONAL HISTORY OF TUSAYAN. + + +EXPLANATORY. + +In this chapter[1] is presented a summary of the traditions of the +Tusayan, a number of which were collected from old men, from Walpi on +the east to Moen-kopi on the west. A tradition varies much with the +tribe and the individual; an authoritative statement of the current +tradition on any point could be made only with a complete knowledge of +all traditions extant. Such knowledge is not possessed by any one man, +and the material included in this chapter is presented simply as a +summary of the traditions secured. + + [Footnote 1: This chapter is compiled by Cosmos Mindeleff from + material collected by A. M. Stephen.] + +The material was collected by Mr. A. M. Stephen, of Keam's Canyon, +Arizona, who has enjoyed unusual facilities for the work, having lived +for a number of years past in Tusayan and possessed the confidence +of the principal priests--a very necessary condition in work of +this character. Though far from complete, this summary is a more +comprehensive presentation of the traditionary history of these people +than has heretofore been published. + + +SUMMARY OF TRADITIONS. + +The creation myths of the Tusayan differ widely, but none of them +designate the region now occupied as the place of their genesis. These +people are socially divided into family groups called wi´ngwu, the +descendants of sisters, and groups of wi´ngwu tracing descent from the +same female ancestor, and having a common totem called my´umu. Each of +these totemic groups preserves a creation myth, carrying in its details +special reference to themselves; but all of them claim a common origin +in the interior of the earth, although the place of emergence to the +surface is set in widely separated localities. They all agree in +maintaining this to be the fourth plane on which mankind has existed. In +the beginning all men lived together in the lowest depths, in a region +of darkness and moisture; their bodies were misshaped and horrible, and +they suffered great misery, moaning and bewailing continually. Through +the intervention of Myúingwa (a vague conception known as the god of the +interior) and of Baholikonga (a crested serpent of enormous size, the +genius of water), the "old men" obtained a seed from which sprang a +magic growth of cane. It penetrated through a crevice in the roof +overhead and mankind climbed to a higher plane. A dim light appeared in +this stage and vegetation was produced. Another magic growth of cane +afforded the means of rising to a still higher plane on which the light +was brighter; vegetation was reproduced and the animal kingdom was +created. The final ascent to this present, or fourth plane, was effected +by similar magic growths and was led by mythic twins, according to some +of the myths, by climbing a great pine tree, in others by climbing the +cane, _Phragmites communis_, the alternate leaves of which afforded +steps as of a ladder, and in still others it is said to have been a +rush, through the interior of which the people passed up to the surface. +The twins sang as they pulled the people out, and when their song was +ended no more were allowed to come; and hence, many more were left below +than were permitted to come above; but the outlet through which mankind +came has never been closed, and Myu´ingwa sends through it the germs of +all living things. It is still symbolized by the peculiar construction +of the hatchway of the kiva and in the designs on the sand altars in +these underground chambers, by the unconnected circle painted on pottery +and by devices on basketry and other textile fabrics. + + [Illustration: Plate III. General view of Awatubi.] + +All the people that were permitted to come to the surface were collected +and the different families of men were arranged together. This was done +under the direction of twins, who are called Pekónghoya, the younger one +being distinguished by the term Balíngahoya, the Echo. They were +assisted by their grandmother, Kóhkyang wúhti, the Spider woman, and +these appear in varying guises in many of the myths and legends. They +instructed the people in divers modes of life to dwell on mountain or on +plain, to build lodges, or huts, or windbreaks. They distributed +appropriate gifts among them and assigned each a pathway, and so the +various families of mankind were dispersed over the earth's surface. + +The Hopituh,[2] after being taught to build stone houses, were also +divided, and the different divisions took separate paths. The legends +indicate a long period of extensive migrations in separate communities; +the groups came to Tusayan at different times and from different +directions, but the people of all the villages concur in designating the +Snake people as the first occupants of the region. The eldest member of +that nyumu tells a curious legend of their migration from which the +following is quoted: + + At the general dispersal my people lived in snake skins, each family + occupying a separate snake skin bag, and all were hung on the end of + a rainbow, which swung around until the end touched Navajo Mountain, + where the bags dropped from it; and wherever a bag dropped, there + was their house. After they arranged their bags they came out from + them as men and women, and they then, built a stone house which had + five sides. [The story here relates the adventures of a mythic Snake + Youth, who brought back a strange woman who gave birth to + rattlesnakes; these bit the people and compelled them to migrate.] A + brilliant star arose in the southeast, which would shine for a while + and then disappear. The old men said, "Beneath that star there must + be people," so they determined to travel toward it. They cut a staff + and set it in the ground and watched till the star reached its top, + then they started and traveled as long as the star shone; when it + disappeared they halted. But the star did not shine every night, for + sometimes many years elapsed before it appeared again. When this + occurred, our people built houses during their halt; they built both + round and square houses, and all the ruins between here and Navajo + Mountain mark the places where our people lived. They waited till + the star came to the top of the staff again, then they moved on, but + many people were left in those houses and they followed afterward at + various times. When our people reached Wipho (a spring a few miles + north from Walpi) the star disappeared and has never been seen + since. They built a house there and after a time Másauwu (the god of + the face of the earth) came and compelled them to move farther down + the valley, to a point about half way between the East and Middle + Mesa, and there they stayed many plantings. One time the old men + were assembled and Másauwu came among them, looking like a horrible + skeleton, and his bones rattling dreadfully. He menaced them with + awful gestures, and lifted off his fleshless head and thrust it into + their faces; but he could not frighten them. So he said, "I have + lost my wager; all that I have is yours; ask for anything you want + and I will give it to you." At that time our people's house was + beside the water course, and Másauwu said, "Why are you sitting here + in the mud? Go up yonder where it is dry." So they went across to + the low, sandy terrace on the west side of the mesa, near the point, + and built a house and lived there. Again the old men were assembled + and two demons came among them and the old men took the great Baho + and the nwelas and chased them away. When they were returning, and + were not far north from, their village, they met the Lenbaki + (Cane-Flute, a religious society still maintained) of the Horn + family. The old men would not allow them to come in until Másauwu + appeared and declared them to be good Hopituh. So they built houses + adjoining ours and that made a fine, large village. Then other + Hopituh came in from time to time, and our people would say, "Build + here, or build there," and portioned the land among the new comers. + + [Footnote 2: The term by which the Tusayan Indians proper designate + themselves. This term does not include the inhabitants of the + village of Tewa or Hano, who are called Hanomuh.] + +The site of the first Snake house in the valley, mentioned in the +foregoing legend, is now barely to be discerned, and the people refuse +to point out the exact spot. It is held as a place of votive offerings +during the ceremony of the Snake dance, and, as its name, Bátni, +implies, certain rain-fetiches are deposited there in small jars buried +in the ground. The site of the village next occupied can be quite easily +distinguished, and is now called Kwetcap tutwi, ash heap terrace, and +this was the village to which the name Walpi was first applied--a term +meaning the place at the notched mesa, in allusion to a broad gap in the +stratum of sandstone on the summit of the mesa, and by which it can be +distinguished from a great distance. The ground plan of this early Walpi +can still be partly traced, indicating the former existence of an +extensive village of clustering, little-roomed houses, with thick walls +constructed of small stones. + +The advent of the Lenbaki is still commemorated by a biennial ceremony, +and is celebrated on the year alternating with their other biennial +ceremony, the Snake dance. + +The Horn people, to which the Lenbaki belonged, have a legend of coming +from a mountain range in the east. + + Its peaks were always snow covered, and the trees were always green. + From the hillside the plains were seen, over which roamed the deer, + the antelope, and the bison, feeding on never-failing grasses. + Twining through these plains were streams of bright water, beautiful + to look upon. A place where none but those who were of our people + ever gained access. + + [Illustration: Plate IV. Awatubi (Talla-Hogan), plan.] + +This description suggests some region of the head-waters of the Rio +Grande. Like the Snake people, they tell of a protracted migration, not +of continuous travel, for they remained for many seasons in one place, +where they would plant and build permanent houses. One of these halting +places is described as a canyon with high, steep walls, in which was a +flowing stream; this, it is said, was the Tségi (the Navajo name for +Canyon de Chelly). Here they built a large house in a cavernous recess, +high up in the canyon wall. They tell of devoting two years[3] to ladder +making and cutting and pecking shallow holes up the steep rocky side by +which to mount to the cavern, and three years more were employed in +building the house. While this work was in progress part of the men were +planting gardens, and the women and children were gathering stones. But +no adequate reason is given for thus toiling to fit this impracticable +site for occupation; the footprints of Másauwu, which they were +following, led them there. + + [Footnote 3: The term yasuna, translated here as "year," is of + rather indefinite significance; it sometimes means thirteen moons + and in other instances much longer periods.] + +The legend goes on to tell that after they had lived there for a long +time a stranger happened to stray in their vicinity, who proved to be a +Hopituh, and said that he lived in the south. After some stay he left +and was accompanied by a party of the "Horn," who were to visit the land +occupied by their kindred Hopituh and return with an account of them; +but they never came back. After waiting a long time another band was +sent, who returned and said that the first emissaries had found wives +and had built houses on the brink of a beautiful canyon, not far from +the other Hopituh dwellings. After this many of the Horns grew +dissatisfied with their cavern home, dissensions arose, they left their +home, and finally they reached Tusayan. They lived at first in one of +the canyons east of the villages, in the vicinity of Keam's Canyon, and +some of the numerous ruins on its brink mark the sites of their early +houses. There seems to be no legend distinctly attaching any particular +ruin to the Horn people, although there is little doubt that the Snake +and the Horn were the two first peoples who came to the neighborhood of +the present villages. The Bear people were the next, but they arrived as +separate branches, and from opposite directions, although of the same +Hopituh stock. It has been impossible to obtain directly the legend of +the Bears from the west. The story of the Bears from the east tells of +encountering the Fire people, then living about 25 miles east from +Walpi; but these are now extinct, and nearly all that is known of them +is told in the Bear legend, the gist of which is as follows: + +The Bears originally lived among the mountains of the east, not far +distant from the Horns. Continual quarrels with neighboring villages +brought on actual fighting, and the Bears left that region and traveled +westward. As with all the other people, they halted, built houses, and +planted, remaining stationary for a long while; this occurred at +different places along their route. + +A portion of these people had wings, and they flew in advance to survey +the land, and when the main body were traversing an arid region they +found water for them. Another portion had claws with which they dug +edible roots, and they could also use them for scratching hand and foot +holes in the face of a steep cliff. Others had hoofs, and these carried +the heaviest burdens; and some had balls of magic spider web, which they +could use on occasion for ropes, and they could also spread the web and +use it as a mantle, rendering the wearer invisible when he apprehended +danger. + +They too came to the Tségi (Canyon de Chelly), where they found houses +but no people, and they also built houses there. While living there a +rupture occurred, a portion of them separating and going far to the +westward. These seceding bands are probably that branch of the Bears who +claim their origin in the west. Some time after this, but how long after +is not known, a plague visited the canyon, and the greater portion of +the people moved away, but leaving numbers who chose to remain. They +crossed the Chinli valley and halted for a short time at a place a short +distance northeast from Great Willow water ("Eighteen Mile Spring"). +They did not remain there long, however, but moved a few miles farther +west, to a place occupied by the Fire people who lived in a large oval +house. The ruin of this house still stands, the walls from 5 to 8 feet +high, and remarkable from the large-sized blocks of stone used in their +construction; it is still known to the Hopituh as Tebvwúki, the +Fire-house. Here some fighting occurred, and the Bears moved westward +again to the head of Antelope (Jeditoh) Canyon, about 4 miles from +Keam's Canyon and about 15 miles east from Walpi. They built there a +rambling cluster of small-roomed houses, of which the ground plan has +now become almost obliterated. This ruin is called by the Hopituh "the +ruin at the place of wild gourds." They seem to have occupied this +neighborhood for a considerable period, as mention is made of two or +three segregations, when groups of families moved a few miles away and +built similar house clusters on the brink of that canyon. + + [Illustration: Plate V. Standing walls of Awatubi.] + +The Fire-people, who, some say, were of the Horn people, must have +abandoned their dwelling at the Oval House or must have been driven out +at the time of their conflict with the Bears, and seem to have traveled +directly to the neighborhood of Walpi. The Snakes allotted them a place +to build in the valley on the east side of the mesa, and about two miles +north from the gap. A ridge of rocky knolls and sand dunes lies at the +foot of the mesa here, and close to the main cliff is a spring. There +are two prominent knolls about 400 yards apart and the summits of these +are covered with traces of house walls; also portions of walls can be +discerned on all the intervening hummocks. The place is known as +Sikyátki, the yellow-house, from the color of the sandstone of which the +houses were built. These and other fragmentary bits have walls not over +a foot thick, built of small stones dressed by rubbing, and all laid in +mud; the inside of the walls also show a smooth coating of mud plaster. +The dimensions of the rooms are very small, the largest measuring 9½ +feet long, by 4½ feet wide. It is improbable that any of these +structures were over two stories high, and many of them were built in +excavated places around the rocky summits of the knolls. In these +instances no rear wall was built; the partition walls, radiating at +irregular angles, abut against the rock itself. Still, the great numbers +of these houses, small as they were, must have been far more than the +Fire-people could have required, for the oval house which they abandoned +measures not more than a hundred feet by fifty. Probably other incoming +gentes, of whom no story has been preserved, had also the ill fate to +build there, for the Walpi people afterward slew all its inhabitants. + +There is little or no detail in the legends of the Bear people as to +their life in Antelope Canyon; they can now distinguish only one ruin +with certainty as having been occupied by their ancestors, while to all +the other ruins fanciful names have been applied. Nor is there any +special cause mentioned for abandoning their dwellings there; probably, +however, a sufficient reason was the cessation of springs in their +vicinity. Traces of former large springs are seen at all of them, but no +water flows from them at the present time. Whatever their motive, the +Bears left Antelope Canyon, and moved over to the village of Walpi, +on the terrace below the point of the mesa. They were received kindly +there, and were apparently placed on an equal footing with the Walpi, +for it seems the Snake, Horn, and Bear have always been on terms of +friendship. They built houses at that village, and lived there for some +considerable time; then they moved a short distance and built again +almost on the very point of the mesa. This change was not caused by any +disagreement with their neighbors; they simply chose that point as a +suitable place on which to build all their houses together. The site of +this Bear house is called Kisákobi, the obliterated house, and the name +is very appropriate, as there is merely the faintest trace here and +there to show where a building stood, the stones having been used in the +construction of the modern Walpi. These two villages were quite close +together, and the subsequent construction of a few additional groups of +rooms almost connected them, so that they were always considered and +spoken of as one. + +It was at this period, while Walpi was still on this lower site, that +the Spaniards came into the country. They met with little or no +opposition, and their entrance was marked by no great disturbances. +No special tradition preserves any of the circumstances of this event; +these first coming Spaniards being only spoken of as the "Kast´ilumuh +who wore iron garments, and came from the south," and this brief mention +may be accounted for by the fleeting nature of these early visits. + +The zeal of the Spanish priests carried them everywhere throughout their +newly acquired territory, and some time in the seventeenth century a +band of missionary monks found their way to Tusayan. They were +accompanied by a few troops to impress the people with a due regard for +Spanish authority, but to display the milder side of their mission, they +also brought herds of sheep and cattle for distribution. At first these +were herded at various springs within a wide radius around the villages, +and the names still attaching to these places memorize the introduction +of sheep and cattle to this region. The Navajo are first definitely +mentioned in tradition as occupants of this vicinity in connection with +these flocks and herds, in the distribution of which they gave much +undesirable assistance by driving off the larger portion to their own +haunts. + +The missionaries selected Awatubi, Walpi, and Shumopavi as the sites for +their mission buildings, and at once, it is said, began to introduce a +system of enforced labor. The memory of the mission period is held in +great detestation, and the onerous toil the priests imposed is still +adverted to as the principal grievance. Heavy pine timbers, many of +which are now pointed out in the kiva roofs, of from 15 to 20 feet in +length and a foot or more in diameter, were cut at the San Francisco +Mountain, and gangs of men were compelled to carry and drag them to the +building sites, where they were used as house beams. This necessitated +prodigious toil, for the distance by trail is a hundred miles, most of +the way over a rough and difficult country. The Spaniards are said to +have employed a few ox teams in this labor, but the heaviest share was +performed by the impressed Hopituh, who were driven in gangs by the +Spanish soldiers, and any who refused to work were confined in a prison +house and starved into submission. + +The "men with the long robes," as the missionaries were called, are said +to have lived among these people for a long time, but no trace of their +individuality survives in tradition. + +Possibly the Spanish missionaries may have striven to effect some social +improvement among these people, and by the adoption of some harsh +measures incurred the jealous anger of the chiefs. But the system of +labor they enforced was regarded, perhaps justly, as the introduction of +serfdom, such as then prevailed in the larger communities in the Rio +Grande valleys. Perhaps tradition belies them; but there are many +stories of their evil, sensual lives--assertions that they violated +women, and held many of the young girls at their mission houses, not as +pupils, but as concubines. + + [Illustration: Plate VI. Adobe fragment in Awatubi.] + +In any case, these hapless monks were engaged in a perilous mission in +seeking to supplant the primitive faith of the Tusayan, for among the +native priests they encountered prejudices even as violent as their own. +With too great zeal they prohibited the sacred dances, the votive +offerings to the nature-deities, and similar public observances, and +strove to suppress the secret rites and abolish the religious orders and +societies. But these were too closely incorporated with the system of +gentes and other family kinships to admit of their extinction. +Traditionally, it is said that, following the discontinuance of the +prescribed ceremonies, the favor of the gods was withdrawn, the clouds +brought no rain, and the fields yielded no corn. Such a coincidence in +this arid region is by no means improbable, and according to the +legends, a succession of dry seasons resulting in famine has been of not +infrequent occurrence. The superstitious fears of the people were thus +aroused, and they cherished a mortal hatred of the monks. + +In such mood were they in the summer of 1680, when the village Indians +rose in revolt, drove out the Spaniards, and compelled them to retreat +to Mexico. There are some dim traditions of that event still existing +among the Tusayan, and they tell of one of their own race coming from +the river region by the way of Zuñi to obtain their cooperation in the +proposed revolt. To this they consented. + +Only a few Spaniards being present at that time, the Tusayan found +courage to vent their enmity in massacre, and every one of the hated +invaders perished on the appointed day. The traditions of the massacre +center on the doom of the monks, for they were regarded as the +embodiment of all that was evil in Spanish rule, and their pursuit, +as they tried to escape among the sand dunes, and the mode of their +slaughter, is told with grim precision; they were all overtaken and +hacked to pieces with stone tomahawks. + +It is told that while the monks were still in authority some of the +Snake women urged a withdrawal from Walpi, and, to incite the men to +action, carried their mealing-stones and cooking vessels to the summit +of the mesa, where they desired the men to build new houses, less +accessible to the domineering priests. The men followed them, and two or +three small house groups were built near the southwest end of the +present village, one of them being still occupied by a Snake family, but +the others have been demolished or remodeled. A little farther north, +also on the west edge, the small house clusters there were next built by +the families of two women called Tji-vwó-wati and Si-kya-tcí-wati. +Shortly after the massacre the lower village was entirely abandoned, and +the building material carried above to the point which the Snakes had +chosen, and on which the modern Walpi was constructed. Several beams of +the old mission houses are now pointed out in the roofs of the kivas. + +There was a general apprehension that the Spaniards would send a force +to punish them, and the Shumopavi also reconstructed their village in a +stronger position, on a high mesa overlooking its former site. The other +villages were already in secure positions, and all the smaller +agricultural settlements were abandoned at this period, and excepting at +one or two places on the Moen-kopi, the Tusayan have ever since confined +themselves to the close vicinity of their main villages. + +The house masses do not appear to bear any relation to division by +phratries. It is surprising that even the social division of the +phratries is preserved. The Hopituh certainly marry within phratries, +and occasionally with the same gens. There is no doubt, however, that in +the earlier villages each gens, and where practicable, the whole of the +phratry, built their houses together. To a certain extent the house of +the priestess of a gens is still regarded as the home of the gens. She +has to be consulted concerning proposed marriages, and has much to say +in other social arrangements. + +While the village of the Walpi was still upon the west side of the mesa +point, some of them moved around and built houses beside a spring close +to the east side of the mesa. Soon after this a dispute over planting +ground arose between them and the Sikyátki, whose village was also on +that side of the mesa and but a short distance above them. From this +time forward bad blood lay between the Sikyátki and the Walpi, who took +up the quarrel of their suburb. It also happened about that time, so +tradition says, more of the Coyote people came from the north, and the +Pikyás nyu-mu, the young cornstalk, who were the latest of the Water +people, came in from the south. The Sikyátki, having acquired their +friendship, induced them to build on two mounds, on the summit of the +mesa overlooking their village. They had been greatly harrassed by the +young slingers and archers of Walpi, who would come across to the edge +of the high cliff and assail them with impunity, but the occupation of +these two mounds by friends afforded effectual protection to their +village. These knolls are about 40 yards apart, and about 40 feet above +the level of the mesa which is something over 400 feet above Sikyátki. +Their roughly leveled summits measure 20 by 10 feet and are covered with +traces of house walls; and it is evident that groups of small-roomed +houses were clustered also around the sloping sides. About a hundred +yards south from their dwellings the people of the mounds built for +their own protection a strong wall entirely across the mesa, which at +that point is contracted to about 200 feet in width, with deep vertical +cliffs on either side. The base of the wall is still quite distinct, and +is about 3 feet thick. + +But no reconciliation was ever effected between the Walpi and the +Sikyátki and their allies, and in spite of their defensive wall frequent +assaults were made upon the latter until they were forced to retreat. +The greater number of them retired to Oraibi and the remainder to +Sikyátki, and the feud was still maintained between them and the Walpi. + + [Illustration: Plate VII. Horn House ruin, plan.] + +Some of the incidents as well as the disastrous termination of this feud +are still narrated. A party of the Sikyátki went prowling through Walpi +one day while the men were afield, and among other outrages, one of them +shot an arrow through a window and killed a chief's daughter while she +was grinding corn. The chief's son resolved to avenge the death of his +sister, and some time after this went to Sikyátki, professedly to take +part in a religious dance, in which he joined until just before the +close of the ceremony. Having previously observed where the handsomest +girl was seated among the spectators on the house terraces, he ran up +the ladder as if to offer her a prayer emblem, but instead he drew out a +sharp flint knife from his girdle and cut her throat. He threw the body +down where all could see it, and ran along the adjoining terraces till +he cleared the village. A little way up the mesa was a large flat rock, +upon which he sprang and took off his dancer's mask so that all might +recognize him; then turning again to the mesa he sped swiftly up the +trail and escaped. + +And so foray and slaughter continued to alternate between them until the +planting season of some indefinite year came around. All the Sikyátki +men were to begin the season by planting the fields of their chief on a +certain day, which was announced from the housetop by the Second Chief +as he made his customary evening proclamations, and the Walpi, becoming +aware of this, planned a fatal onslaught. Every man and woman able to +draw a bow or wield a weapon were got in readiness and at night they +crossed the mesa and concealed themselves along its edge, overlooking +the doomed village. When the day came they waited until the men had gone +to the field and then rushed down upon the houses. The chief, who was +too old to go afield, was the first one killed, and then followed the +indiscriminate slaughter of women and children, and the destruction of +the houses. The wild tumult in the village alarmed the Sikyátki and they +came rushing back, but too late to defend their homes. Their struggles +were hopeless, for they had only their planting sticks to use as +weapons, which availed but little against the Walpi with their bows and +arrows, spears, slings, and war clubs. Nearly all of the Sikyátki men +were killed, but some of them escaped to Oraibi and some to Awatubi. A +number of the girls and younger women were spared, and distributed among +the different villages, where they became wives of their despoilers. + +It is said to have been shortly after the destruction of Sikyátki that +the first serious inroad of a hostile tribe occurred within this region, +and all the stories aver that these early hostiles were from the north, +the Ute being the first who are mentioned, and after them the Apache, +who made an occasional foray. + +While these families of Hopituh stock had been building their straggling +dwellings along the canyon brinks, and grouping in villages around the +base of the East Mesa, other migratory bands of Hopituh had begun to +arrive on the Middle Mesa. As already said, it is admitted that the +Snake were the first occupants of this region, but beyond that fact the +traditions are contradictory and confused. It is probable, however, that +not long after the arrival of the Horn, the Squash people came from the +south and built a village on the Middle Mesa, the ruin of which is +called Chukubi. It is on the edge of the cliff on the east side of the +neck of that mesa, and a short distance south of the direct trail +leading from Walpi to Oraibi. The Squash people say that they came from +Palát Kwabi, the Red Land in the far South, and this vague term +expresses nearly all their knowledge of that traditional land. They say +they lived for a long time in the valley of the Colorado Chiquito, +on the south side of that stream and not far from the point where the +railway crosses it. They still distinguish the ruin of their early +village there, which was built as usual on the brink of a canyon, and +call it Etípsíkya, after a shrub that grows there profusely. They +crossed the river opposite that place, but built no permanent houses +until they reached the vicinity of Chukubi, near which two smaller +clusters of ruins, on knolls, mark the sites of dwellings which they +claim to have been theirs. Three groups (nyumu) traveling together were +the next to follow them; these were the Bear, the Bear-skin-rope, and +the Blue Jay. They are said to have been very numerous, and to have come +from the vicinity of San Francisco Mountain. They did not move up to +Chukubi, but built a large village on the summit, at the south end of +the mesa, close to the site of the present Mashongnavi. Soon afterward +came the Burrowing Owl, and the Coyote, from the vicinity of Navajo +Mountains in the north, but they were not very numerous. They also built +upon the Mashongnavi summit. + +After this the Squash people found that the water from their springs was +decreasing, and began moving toward the end of the mesa, where the other +people were. But as there was then no suitable place left on the summit, +they built a village on the sandy terrace close below it, on the west +side; and as the springs at Chukubi ultimately ceased entirely, the rest +of the Squash people came to the terrace and were again united in one +village. Straggling bands of several other groups, both wingwu and +nyumu, are mentioned as coming from various directions. Some built on +the terrace and some found house room in Mashongnavi. This name is +derived as follows: On the south side of the terrace on which the Squash +village was built is a high column of sandstone which is vertically +split in two, and formerly there was a third pillar in line, which has +long since fallen. These three columns were called Tútuwalha, the +guardians, and both the Squash village and the one on the summit were so +named. On the north side of the terrace, close to the present village, +is another irregular massy pillar of sandstone called Mashóniniptu, +meaning "the other which remains erect," having reference to the one on +the south side, which had fallen. When the Squash withdrew to the summit +the village was then called Mashóniniptuovi, "at the place of the other +which remains erect;" now that term is never used, but always its +syncopated form, Mashongnavi. + + [Illustration: Plate VIII. Bat House.] + +The Squash village, on the south end of the Middle Mesa, was attacked by +a fierce band that came from the north, some say the Ute, others say the +Apache; but whoever the invaders were, they completely overpowered the +people, and carried off great stores of food and other plunder. The +village was then evacuated, the houses dismantled, and the material +removed to the high summit, where they reconstructed their dwellings +around the village which thenceforth bore its present name of +Mashongnavi. Some of the Squash people moved over to Oraibi, and +portions of the Katchina and Paroquet people came from there to +Mashongnavi about the same time, and a few of these two groups occupied +some vacant houses also in Shupaulovi; for this village even at that +early date had greatly diminished in population, having sustained a +disastrous loss of men in the canyon affrays east of Walpi. + +Shumopavi seems to have been built by portions of the same groups who +went to the adjacent Mashongnavi, but the traditions of the two villages +are conflicting. The old traditionists at Shumopavi hold that the first +to come there were the Paroquet, the Bear, the Bear-skin-rope, and the +Blue Jay. They came from the west--probably from San Francisco Mountain. +They claim that ruins on a mesa bluff about 10 miles south from the +present village are the remains of a village built by these groups +before reaching Shumopavi, and the Paroquets arrived first, it is said, +because they were perched on the heads of the Bears, and, when nearing +the water, they flew in ahead of the others. These groups built a +village on a broken terrace, on the east side of the cliff, and just +below the present village. There is a spring close by called after the +Shunóhu, a tall red grass, which grew abundantly there, and from which +the town took its name. This spring was formerly very large, but two +years ago a landslide completely buried it; lately, however, a small +outflow is again apparent. + +The ruins of the early village cover a hillocky area of about 800 by 250 +feet, but it is impossible to trace much of the ground plan with +accuracy. The corner of an old house still stands, some 6 or 8 feet +high, extending about 15 feet on one face and about 10 feet on the +other. The wall is over 3 feet in thickness, but of very clumsy masonry, +no care having been exercised in dressing the stones, which are of +varying sizes and laid in mud plaster. Interest attaches to this +fragment, as it is one of the few tangible evidences left of the Spanish +priests who engaged in the fatal mission to the Hopituh in the sixteenth +century. This bit of wall, which now forms part of a sheep-fold, is +pointed out as the remains of one of the mission buildings. + +Other groups followed--the Mole, the Spider, and the "Wíksrun." These +latter took their name from a curious ornament worn by the men. A piece +of the leg-bone of a bear, from which the marrow had been extracted and +a stopper fixed in one end, was attached to the fillet binding the hair, +and hung down in front of the forehead. This gens and the Mole are now +extinct. + +Shumopavi received no further accession of population, but lost to +some extent by a portion of the Bear people moving across to Walpi. +No important event seems to have occurred among them for a long period +after the destruction of Sikyátki, in which they bore some part, and +only cursory mention is made of the ingress of "enemies from the north;" +but their village, apparently, was not assailed. + +The Oraibi traditions tend to confirm those of Shumopavi, and tell that +the first houses there were built by Bears, who came from the latter +place. The following is from a curious legend of the early settlement: + +The Bear people had two chiefs, who were brothers; the elder was called +Vwen-ti-só-mo, and the younger Ma-tcí-to. They had a desperate quarrel +at Shumopavi, and their people divided into two factions, according as +they inclined to one or other of the contestants. After a long period of +contention Ma-tcí-to and his followers withdrew to the mesa where Oraibi +now stands, about 8 miles northwest from Shumopavi, and built houses a +little to the southwest of the limits of the present town. These houses +were afterwards destroyed by "enemies from the north," and the older +portion of the existing town, the southwest ends of the house rows, were +built with stones from the demolished houses. Fragments of these early +walls are still occasionally unearthed. + +After Ma-tcí-to and his people were established there, whenever any of +the Shumopavi people became dissatisfied with that place they built at +Oraibi, Ma-tcí-to placed a little stone monument about halfway between +these two villages to mark the boundary of the land. Vwenti-so´-mo +objected to this, but it was ultimately accepted with the proviso that +the village growing the fastest should have the privilege of moving it +toward the other village. The monument still stands, and is on the +direct Oraibi trail from Shumopavi, 3 miles from the latter. It is a +well dressed, rectangular block of sandstone, projecting two feet above +the ground, and measures 8½ by 7 inches. On the end is carved the rude +semblance of a human head, or mask, the eyes and mouth being merely +round shallow holes, with a black line painted around them. The stone is +pecked on the side, but the head and front are rubbed quite smooth, and +the block, tapering slightly to the base, suggests the ancient Roman +Termini. + +There are Eagle people living at Oraibi, Mashongnavi, and Walpi, and it +would seem as if they had journeyed for some time with the later Snake +people and others from the northwest. Vague traditions attach them to +several of the ruins north of the Moen-kopi, although most of these are +regarded as the remains of Snake dwellings. + +The legend of the Eagle people introduces them from the west, coming in +by way of the Moen-kopi water course. They found many people living in +Tusayan, at Oraibi, the Middle Mesa, and near the East Mesa, but the +Snake village was yet in the valley. Some of the Eagles remained at +Oraibi, but the main body moved to a large mound just east of +Mashongnavi, on the summit of which they built a village and called it +Shi-tái-mu. Numerous traces of small-roomed houses can be seen on this +mound and on some of the lower surroundings. The uneven summit is about +300 by 200 feet, and the village seems to have been built in the form of +an irregular ellipse, but the ground plan is very obscure. + + [Illustration: Plate IX. Mishiptonga (Jeditoh).] + +While the Eagles were living at Shi-tái-mu, they sent "Yellow Foot" to +the mountain in the east (at the headwaters of the Rio Grande) to obtain +a dog. After many perilous adventures in caverns guarded by bear, +mountain lion, and rattlesnake, he got two dogs and returned. They were +wanted to keep the coyotes out of the corn and the gardens. The dogs +grew numerous, and would go to Mashongnavi in search of food, and also +to some of the people of that village, which led to serious quarrels +between them and the Eagle people. Ultimately the Shi-tái-mu chief +proclaimed a feast, and told the people to prepare to leave the village +forever. On the feast day the women arranged the food basins on the +ground in a long line leading out of the village. The people passed +along this line, tasting a mouthful here or there, but without stopping, +and when they reached the last basin they were beyond the limits of the +village. Without turning around they continued on down into the valley +until they were halted by the Snake people. An arrangement was effected +with the latter, and the Eagles built their houses in the Snake village. +A few of the Eagle families who had become attached to Mashongnavi chose +to go to that village, where their descendants still reside, and are yet +held as close relatives by the Eagles of Walpi. The land around the East +Mesa was then portioned out, the Snakes, Horns, Bears, and Eagles each +receiving separate lands, and these old allotments are still +approximately maintained. + +According to the Eagle traditions the early occupants of Tusayan came in +the following succession: Snake, Horn, Bear, Middle Mesa, Oraibi, and +Eagle, and finally from the south came the Water families. This sequence +is also recognized in the general tenor of the legends of the other +groups. + +Shupaulovi, a small village quite close to Mashongnavi, would seem to +have been established just before the coming of the Water people. Nor +does there seem to have been any very long interval between the arrival +of the earliest occupants of the Middle Mesa and this latest colony. +These were the Sun people, and like the Squash folk, claim to have come +from Palátkwabi, the Red Land, in the south. On their northward +migration, when they came to the valley of the Colorado Chiquito, they +found the Water people there, with whom they lived for some time. This +combined village was built upon Homólobi, a round terraced mound near +Sunset Crossing, where fragmentary ruins covering a wide area can yet be +traced. + +Incoming people from the east had built the large village of Awatubi, +high rock, upon a steep mesa about nine miles southeast from Walpi. When +the Sun people came into Tusayan they halted at that village and a few +of them remained there permanently, but the others continued west to the +Middle Mesa. At that time also they say Chukubi, Shitaimu, Mashongnavi, +and the Squash village on the terrace were all occupied, and they built +on the terrace close to the Squash village also. The Sun people were +then very numerous and soon spread their dwellings over the summit where +the ruin now stands, and many indistinct lines of house walls around +this dilapidated village attest its former size. Like the neighboring +village, it takes its name from a rock near by, which is used as a place +for the deposit of votive offerings, but the etymology of the term can +not be traced. + +Some of the Bear people also took up their abode at Shupaulovi, and +later a nyumu of the Water family called Batni, moisture, built with +them; and the diminished families of the existing village are still +composed entirely of these three nyumu. + +The next arrivals seem to have been the Asanyumu, who in early days +lived in the region of the Chama, in New Mexico, at a village called +Kaékibi, near the place now known as Abiquiu. When they left that region +they moved slowly westward to a place called Túwii (Santo Domingo), +where some of them are said to still reside. The next halt was at +Kaiwáika (Laguna) where it is said some families still remain, and they +staid also a short time at A´ikoka (Acoma); but none of them remained at +that place. From the latter place they went to Sióki (Zuñi), where they +remained a long time and left a number of their people there, who are +now called Aiyáhokwi by the Zuñi. They finally reached Tusayan by way of +Awatubi. They had been preceded from the same part of New Mexico by the +Honan nyumu (the Badger people), whom they found living at the +last-named village. The Magpie, the Pute Kóhu (Boomerang-shaped hunting +stick), and the Field-mouse families of the Asa remained and built +beside the Badger, but the rest of its groups continued across to the +Walpi Mesa. They were not at first permitted to come up to Walpi, which +then occupied its present site, but were allotted a place to build at +Coyote Water, a small spring on the east side of the mesa, just under +the gap. They had not lived there very long, however, when for some +valuable services in defeating at one time a raid of the Ute (who used +to be called the Tcingawúptuh) and of the Navajo at another, they were +given for planting grounds all the space on the mesa summit from the gap +to where Sichumovi now stands, and the same width, extending across the +valley to the east. On the mesa summit they built the early portion of +the house mass on the north side of the village, now known as Hano. But +soon after this came a succession of dry seasons, which caused a great +scarcity of food almost amounting to a famine, and many moved away to +distant streams. The Asa people went to Túpkabi (Deep Canyon, the de +Chelly), about 70 miles northeast from Walpi, where the Navajo received +them kindly and supplied them with food. The Asa had preserved some +seeds of the peach, which they planted in the canyon nooks, and numerous +little orchards still flourish there. They also brought the Navajo new +varieties of food plants, and their relations grew very cordial. They +built houses along the base of the canyon walls, and dwelt there for two +or three generations, during which time many of the Asa women were given +to the Navajo, and the descendants of these now constitute a numerous +clan among the Navajo, known as the Kiáini, the High-house people. + + [Illustration: Plate X. A small ruin near Moen-kopi.] + +The Navajo and the Asa eventually quarreled and the latter returned to +Walpi, but this was after the arrival of the Hano, by whom they found +their old houses occupied. The Asa were taken into the village of Walpi, +being given a vacant strip on the east edge of the mesa, just where the +main trail comes up to the village. The Navajo, Ute, and Apache had +frequently gained entrance to the village by this trail, and to guard it +the Asa built a house group along the edge of the cliff at that point, +immediately overlooking the trail, where some of the people still live; +and the kiva there, now used by the Snake order, belongs to them. There +was a crevice in the rock, with a smooth bottom extending to the edge of +the cliff and deep enough for a ki´koli. A wall was built to close the +outer edge and it was at first intended to build a dwelling house there, +but it was afterward excavated to its present size and made into a kiva, +still called the wikwálhobi, the kiva of the Watchers of the High Place. +The Walpi site becoming crowded, some of the Bear and Lizard people +moved out and built houses on the site of the present Sichumovi; several +Asa families followed them, and after them came some of the Badger +people. The village grew to an extent considerably beyond its present +size, when it was abandoned on account of a malignant plague. After the +plague, and within the present generation, the village was rebuilt--the +old houses being torn down to make the new ones. + +After the Asa came the nest group to arrive was the Water family. Their +chief begins the story of their migration in this way: + + In the long ago the Snake, Horn, and Eagle people lived here (in + Tusayan), but their corn grew only a span high, and when they sang + for rain the cloud god sent only a thin mist. My people then lived + in the distant Pa-lát Kwá-bi in the South. There was a very bad old + man there, who, when he met any one, would spit in his face, blow + his nose upon him, and rub ordure upon him. He ravished the girls + and did all manner of evil. Baholikonga got angry at this and turned + the world upside down, and water spouted up through the kivas and + through the fireplaces in the houses. The earth was rent in great + chasms, and water covered everything except one narrow ridge of mud; + and across this the serpent deity told all the people to travel. + As they journeyed across, the feet of the bad slipped and they fell + into the dark water, but the good, after many days, reached dry + land. While the water was rising around the village the old people + got on the tops of the houses, for they thought they could not + struggle across with the younger people; but Baholikonga clothed + them with the skins of turkeys, and they spread their wings out and + floated in the air just above the surface of the water, and in this + way they got across. There were saved of our people Water, Corn, + Lizard, Horned Toad, Sand, two families of Rabbit, and Tobacco. The + turkey tail dragged in the water--hence the white on the turkey tail + now. Wearing these turkey-skins is the reason why old people have + dewlaps under the chin like a turkey; it is also the reason why old + people use turkey-feathers at the religious ceremonies. + +In the story of the wandering of the Water people, many vague references +are made to various villages in the South, which they constructed or +dwelt in, and to rocks where they carved their totems at temporary +halting places. They dwelt for a long time at Homólobi, where the Sun +people joined them; and probably not long after the latter left the +Water people followed on after them. The largest number of this family +seem to have made their dwellings first at Mashongnavi and Shupaulovi; +but like the Sun people they soon spread to all the villages. + +The narrative of part of this journey is thus given by the chief before +quoted: + + It occupied 4 years to cross the disrupted country. The kwakwanti (a + warrior order) went ahead of the people and carried seed of corn, + beans, melons, squashes, and cotton. They would plant corn in the + mud at early morning and by noon it was ripe and thus the people + were fed. When they reached solid ground they rested, and then they + built houses. The kwakwanti were always out exploring--sometimes + they were gone as long as four years. Again we would follow them on + long journeys, and halt and build houses and plant. While we were + traveling if a woman became heavy with child we would build her a + house and put plenty of food in it and leave her there, and from + these women sprang the Pima, Maricopa, and other Indians in the + South. + + Away in the South, before we crossed the mountains (south of the + Apache country) we built large houses and lived there a long while. + Near these houses is a large rock on which was painted the + rain-clouds of the Water phratry, also a man carrying corn in his + arms; and the other phratries also painted the Lizard and the Rabbit + upon it. While they were living there the kwakwanti made an + expedition far to the north and came in conflict with a hostile + people. They fought day after day, for days and days--they fought by + day only and when night came they separated, each party retiring to + its own ground to rest. One night the cranes came and each crane + took a kwakwanti on his back and brought them back to their people + in the South. + + Again all the people traveled north until they came to the Little + Colorado, near San Francisco Mountains, and there they built houses + up and down the river. They also made long ditches to carry the + water from the river to their gardens. After living there a long + while they began to be plagued with swarms of a kind of gnat called + the sand-fly, which bit the children, causing them to swell up and + die. The place becoming unendurable, they were forced again to + resume their travels. Before starting, one of the Rain-women, who + was big with child, was made comfortable in one of the houses on the + mountain. She told her people to leave her, because she knew this + was the place where she was to remain forever. She also told them, + that hereafter whenever they should return to the mountain to hunt + she would provide them with plenty of game. Under her house is a + spring and any sterile woman who drinks of its water will bear + children. The people then began a long journey to reach the summit + of the table land on the north. They camped for rest on one of the + terraces, where there was no water, and they were very tired and + thirsty. Here the women celebrated the rain-feast--they danced for + three days, and on the fourth day the clouds brought heavy rain and + refreshed the people. This event is still commemorated by a circle + of stones at that place. They reached a spring southeast from + Káibitho (Kumás Spring) and there they built a house and lived for + some time. Our people had plenty of rain and cultivated much corn + and some of the Walpi people came to visit us. They told ns that + their rain only came here and there in fine misty sprays, and a + basketful of corn was regarded as a large crop. So they asked us to + come to their land and live with them and finally we consented. When + we got there we found some Eagle people living near the Second Mesa; + our people divided, and part went with the Eagle and have ever since + remained there; but we camped near the First Mesa. It was planting + time and the Walpi celebrated their rain-feast but they brought only + a mere misty drizzle. Then we celebrated our rain-feast and planted. + Great rains and thunder and lightning immediately followed and on + the first day after planting our corn was half an arm's length high; + on the fourth day it was its full height, and in one moon it was + ripe. When we were going up to the village (Walpi was then north of + the gap, probably), we were met by a Bear man who said that our + thunder frightened the women and we must not go near the village. + Then the kwakwanti said, "Let us leave these people and seek a land + somewhere else," but our women said they were tired of travel and + insisted upon our remaining. Then "Fire-picker" came down from the + village and told us to come up there and stay, but after we had got + into the village the Walpi women screamed out against us--they + feared our thunder--and so the Walpi turned us away. Then our + people, except those who went to the Second Mesa, traveled to the + northeast as far as the Tsegi (Canyon de Chelly), but I can not tell + whether our people built the louses there. Then they came hack to + this region again and built houses and had much trouble with the + Walpi, but we have lived here ever since. + + [Illustration: Plate XI. Masonry on the outer wall of the Fire-House, + detail.] + +Groups of the Water people, as already stated, were distributed among +all the villages, although the bulk of them remained at the Middle Mesa; +but it seems that most of the remaining groups subsequently chose to +build their permanent houses at Oraibi. There is no special tradition of +this movement; it is only indicated by this circumstance, that in +addition to the Water families common to every village, there are still +in Oraibi several families of that people which have no representatives +in any of the other villages. At a quite early day Oraibi became a place +of importance, and they tell of being sufficiently populous to establish +many outlying settlements. They still identify these with ruins on the +detached mesas in the valley to the south and along the Moen-kopi +("place of flowing water") and other intermittent streams in the west. +These sites were occupied for the purpose of utilizing cultivable tracts +of land in their vicinity, and the remotest settlement, about 45 miles +west, was especially devoted to the cultivation of cotton, the place +being still called by the Navajo and other neighboring tribes, the +"cotton planting ground." It is also said that several of the larger +ruins along the course of the Moen-kopi were occupied by groups of the +Snake, the Coyote, and the Eagle who dwelt in that region for a long +period before they joined the people in Tusayan. The incursions of +foreign bands from the north may have hastened that movement, and the +Oraibi say they were compelled to withdraw all their outlying colonies. +An episode is related of an attack upon the main village when a number +of young girls were carried off, and 2 or 3 years afterward the same +marauders returned and treated with the Oraibi, who paid a ransom in +corn and received all their girls back again. After a quiet interval the +pillaging bands renewed their attacks and the settlements on the +Moen-kopi were vacated. They were again occupied after another peace was +established, and this condition of alternate occupancy and abandonment +seems to have existed until within quite recent time. + +While the Asa were still sojourning in Canyon de Chelly, and before the +arrival of the Hano, another bloody scene had been enacted in Tusayan. +Since the time of the Antelope Canyon feuds there had been enmity +between Awatubi and some of the other villages, especially Walpi, and +some of the Sikyatki refugees had transmitted their feudal wrongs to +their descendants who dwelt in Awatubi. They had long been perpetrating +all manner of offenses; they had intercepted hunting parties from the +other villages, seized their game, and sometimes killed the hunters; +they had fallen upon men in outlying corn fields, maltreating and +sometimes slaying them, and threatened still more serious outrage. +Awatubi was too strong for Walpi to attack single-handed, so the +assistance of the other villages was sought, and it was determined to +destroy Awatubi at the close of a feast soon to occur. This was the +annual "feast of the kwakwanti," which is still maintained and is held +during the month of November by each village, when the youths who have +been qualified by certain ordeals are admitted to the councils. The +ceremonies last several days, and on the concluding night special rites +are held in the kivas. At these ceremonies every man must be in the kiva +to which he belongs, and after the close of the rites they all sleep +there, no one being permitted to leave the kiva until after sunrise on +the following day. + +There was still some little intercourse between Awatubi and Walpi, and +it was easily ascertained when this feast was to be held. On the day of +its close, the Walpi sent word to their allies "to prepare the war arrow +and come," and in the evening the fighting bands from the other villages +assembled at Walpi, as the foray was to be led by the chief of that +village. By the time night had fallen something like 150 marauders had +met, all armed, of course; and of still more ominous import than their +weapons were the firebrands they carried--shredded cedar bark loosely +bound in rolls, resinous splinters of piñon, dry greasewood (a furze +very easily ignited), and pouches full of pulverized red peppers. + + [Illustration: Plate XII. Chukubi, plan.] + +Secure in the darkness from observation, the bands followed the Walpi +chief across the valley, every man with his weapons in hand and a bundle +of inflammables on his back. Beaching the Awatubi mesa they cautiously +crept up the steep, winding trail to the summit, and then stole round +the village to the passages leading to the different courts holding the +kivas, near which they hid themselves. They waited till just before the +gray daylight came, then the Walpi chief shouted his war cry and the +yelling bands rushed to the kivas. Selecting their positions, they were +at them in a moment, and quickly snatching up the ladders through the +hatchways, the only means of exit, the doomed occupants were left as +helpless as rats in a trap. Fire was at hand in the numerous little +cooking pits, containing the jars of food prepared for the celebrants, +the inflammable bundles were lit and tossed into the kivas, and the +piles of firewood on the terraced roofs were thrown down upon the blaze, +and soon each kiva became a furnace. The red pepper was then cast upon +the fire to add its choking tortures, while round the hatchways the +assailants stood showering their arrows into the mass of struggling +wretches. The fires were maintained until the roofs fell in and buried +and charred the bones of the victims. It is said that every male of +Awatubi who had passed infancy perished in the slaughter, not one +escaping. Such of the women and children as were spared were taken out, +and all the houses were destroyed, after which the captives were divided +among the different villages. + +The date of this last feudal atrocity can be made out with some degree +of exactness, because in 1692, Don Diego Vargas with a military force +visited Tusayan and mentions Awatubi as a populous village at which he +made some halt. The Hano (Tewa) claim that they have lived in Tusayan +for five or six generations, and that when they arrived there was no +Awatubi in existence; hence it must have been destroyed not long after +the close of the seventeenth century. + +Since the destruction of Awatubi only one other serious affray has +occurred between the villages; that was between Oraibi and Walpi. It +appears that after the Oraibi withdrew their colonies from the south and +west they took possession of all the unoccupied planting grounds to the +east of the village, and kept reaching eastward till they encroached +upon some land claimed by the Walpi. This gave rise to intermittent +warfare in the outlying fields, and whenever the contending villagers +met a broil ensued, until the strife culminated in an attack upon Walpi. +The Oraibi chose a day when the Walpi men were all in the field on the +east side of the mesa, but the Walpi say that their women and dogs held +the Oraibi at bay until the men came to the rescue. A severe battle was +fought at the foot of the mesa, in which the Oraibi were routed and +pursued across the Middle Mesa, where an Oraibi chief turned and +implored the Walpi to desist. A conciliation was effected there, and +harmonious relations have ever since existed between them. Until within +a few years ago the spot where they stayed pursuit was marked by a +stone, on which a shield and a dog were depicted, but it was a source of +irritation to the Oraibi and it was removed by some of the Walpi. + +In the early part of the eighteenth century the Ute from the north, and +the Apache from the south made most disastrous inroads upon the +villages, in which Walpi especially suffered. The Navajo, who then lived +upon their eastern border, also suffered severely from the same bands, +but the Navajo and the Tusayan were not on the best terms and never made +any alliance for a common defense against these invaders. + +Hano was peopled by a different linguistic stock from that of the other +villages--a stock which belongs to the Rio Grande group. According to +Polaka, the son of the principal chief, and himself an enterprising +trader who has made many journeys to distant localities--and to others, +the Hano once lived in seven villages on the Rio Grande, and the village +in which his forefathers lived was called Tceewáge. This, it is said, +is the same as the present Mexican village of Peña Blanca. + +The Hano claim that they came to Tusayan only after repeated +solicitation by the Walpi, at a time when the latter were much harassed +by the Ute and Apache. The story, as told by Kwálakwai, who lives in +Hano, but is not himself a Hano, begins as follows: + + Long ago the Hopi´tuh were few and were continually harassed by the + Yútamo (Ute), Yuíttcemo (Apache), and Dacábimo (Navajo). The chiefs + of the Tcuin nyumu (Snake people) and the Hánin nyumu (Bear people) + met together and made the ba´ho (sacred plume stick) and sent it + with a man from each of these people to the house of the Tewa, + called Tceewádigi, which was far off on the Múina (river) near + Alavia (Santa Fé). + +The messengers did not succeed in persuading the Tewa to come and the +embassy was sent three times more. On the fourth visit the Tewa +consented to come, as the Walpi had offered to divide their land and +their waters with them, and set out for Tusayan, led by their own chief, +the village being left in the care of his son. This first band is said +to have consisted of 146 women, and it was afterwards followed by +another and perhaps others. + +Before the Hano arrived there had been a cessation of hostile inroads, +and the Walpi received them churlishly and revoked their promises +regarding the division of land and waters with them. They were shown +where they could build houses for themselves on a yellow sand mound on +the east side of the mesa just below the gap. They built there, but they +were compelled to go for their food up to Walpi. They could get no +vessels to carry their food in, and when they held out their hands for +some the Walpi women mockingly poured out hot porridge and scalded the +fingers of the Hano. + +After a time the Ute came down the valley on the west side of the mesa, +doing great harm again, and drove off the Walpi flocks andiron Then the +Hano got ready for war; they tied buckskins around their loins, whitened +their legs with clay, and stained their body and arms with dark red +earth (ocher). They overtook the Ute near Wípho (about 3 miles north +from Hano), but the Ute had driven the flocks up the steep mesa side, +and when they saw the Tewa coming they killed all the sheep and piled +the carcasses up for a defense, behind which they lay down. They had a +few firearms also, while the Hano had only clubs and bows and arrows; +but after some fighting the Ute were driven out and the Tewa followed +after them. The first Ute was killed a short distance beyond, and a +stone heap still (?) marks the spot. Similar heaps marked the places +where other Ute were killed as they fled before the Hano, but not far +from the San Juan the last one was killed. + +Upon the return of the Hano from this successful expedition they were +received gratefully and allowed to come up on the mesa to live--the old +houses built by the Asa, in the present village of Hano, being assigned +to them. The land was then divided, an imaginary line between Hano and +Sichumovi, extending eastward entirely across the valley, marked the +southern boundary, and from this line as far north as the spot where the +last Utah was killed was assigned to the Hano as their possession. + + When the Hano first came the Walpi said to them, "let us spit in + your mouths, and you will learn our tongue," and to this the Hano + consented. When the Hano came up and built on the mesa they said to + the Walpi, "let us spit in your mouths and you will learn our + tongue," but the Walpi would not listen to this, saying it would + make them vomit. This is the reason why all the Hano can talk Hopí, + and none of the Hopítuh can talk Hano. + + [Illustration: Plate XIII. Payupki, plan.] + +The Asa and the Hano were close friends while they dwelt in New Mexico, +and when they came to this region both of them were called Hánomuh by +the other people of Tusayan. This term signifies the mode in which the +women of these people wear their hair, cut off in front on a line with +the mouth and carelessly parted or hanging over the face, the back hair +rolled up in a compact queue at the nape of the neck. This uncomely +fashion prevails with both matron, and maid, while among the other +Tusayan the matron parts her hair evenly down the head and wears it +hanging in a straight queue on either side, the maidens wearing theirs +in a curious discoid arrangement over each temple. + +Although the Asa and the Hano women have the same peculiar fashion of +wearing the hair, still there is no affinity of blood claimed between +them. The Asa speak the same language as the other Tusayan, but the Tewa +(Hano) have a quite distinct language which belongs to the Tañoan stock. +They claim that the occupants of the following pueblos, in the same +region of the Rio Grande, are of their people and speak the same tongue. + + Kótite Cochití (?). Kápung Santa Clara (?) + Númi Nambé. Pokwádi Pojoaque. + Ohke San Juan. Tetsógi Tesuque. + Posówe (Doubtless extinct.) Also half of Taos. + +Pleasant relations existed for some time, but the Walpi again grew +ill-tempered; they encroached upon the Hano planting grounds and stole +their property. These troubles increased, and the Hano moved away from +the mesa; they crossed the west valley and built temporary shelters. +They sent some men to explore the land on the westward to find a +suitable place for a new dwelling. These scouts went to the Moen-kopi, +and on returning, the favorable story they told of the land they had +seen determined the Tewa to go there. + +Meanwhile some knowledge of these troubles had reached Tceewádigi, and a +party of the Tewa came to Tusayan to take their friends back. This led +the Hopituh to make reparation, which restored the confidence of the +Hano, and they returned to the mesa, and the recently arrived party were +also induced to remain. Yet even now, when the Hano (Tewa) go to visit +their people on the river, the latter beseech them to come back, but the +old Tewa say, "we shall stay here till our breath leaves us, then surely +we shall go back to our first home to live forever." + +The Walpi for a long time frowned down all attempts on the part of the +Hano to fraternize; they prohibited intermarriages, and in general +tabued the Hano. Something of this spirit was maintained until quite +recent years, and for this reason the Hano still speak their own +language, and have preserved several distinctive customs, although now +the most friendly relations exist among all the villages. After the Hano +were quietly established in their present position the Asa returned, and +the Walpi allotted them a place to build in their own village. As before +mentioned, the house mass on the southeast side of Walpi, at the head of +the trail leading up to the village at that point, is still occupied by +Asa families, and their tenure of possession was on the condition that +they should always defend that point of access and guard the south end +of the village. Their kiva is named after this circumstance as that of +"the Watchers of the High Place." + +Some of the Bear and Lizard families being crowded for building space, +moved from Walpi and built the first houses on the site of the present +village of Sichumovi, which is named from the Sivwapsi, a shrub which +formerly grew there on some mounds (chumo). + +This was after the Asa had been in Walpi for some time; probably about +125 years ago. Some of the Asa, and the Badger, the latter descendants +of women saved from the Awatubi catastrophe, also moved to Sichumovi, +but a plague of smallpox caused the village to be abandoned shortly +afterward. This pestilence is said to have greatly reduced the number of +the Tusayan, and after it disappeared there were many vacant houses in +every village. Sichumovi was again occupied by a few Asa families, but +the first houses were torn down and new ones constructed from them. + + +LIST OF TRADITIONARY GENTES. + +In the following table the early phratries (nyu-mu) are arranged in the +order of their arrival, and the direction from which each came is given, +except in the case of the Bear people. There are very few +representatives of this phratry existing now, and very little tradition +extant concerning its early history. The table does not show the +condition of these, organizations in the present community but as they +appear in the traditional accounts of their coming to Tusayan, although +representatives of most of them can still be found in the various +villages. There are, moreover, in addition to these, many other gentes +and sub-gentes of more recent origin. The subdivision, or rather the +multiplication of gentes may be said to be a continuous process; as, for +example, in "corn" can be found families claiming to be of the root, +stem, leaf, ear, blossom, etc., all belonging to corn; but there may be +several families of each of these components constituting district +sub-gentes. At present there are really but four phratries recognized +among the Hopituh, the Snake, Horn, Eagle, and Rain, which is +indifferently designated as Water or Corn: + +1. Ho´-nan--Bear. + + Ho´-nan Bear. + Ko´-kyañ-a Spider. + Tco´-zir Jay. + He´k-pa Fir. + +2. Tcu´-a--Rattlesnake--from the west and north. + + Tcu´-a Rattlesnake. + Yu´ñ-ya Cactus--opuntia. + Pü´n-e Cactus, the species that grows in dome-like masses. + Ü´-se Cactus, candelabra, or branching stemmed species. + He´-wi Dove. + Pi-vwa´ni Marmot. + Pi´h-tca Skunk. + Ka-la´-ci-au-u Raccoon. + +3. A´-la--Horn--from the east. + + So´-wiñ-wa Deer. + Tc´ib-io Antelope. + Pa´ñ-wa Mountain sheep. + +4. Kwa´-hü--Eagle--from the west and south. + + Kwa´-hü Eagle. + Kwa´-yo Hawk. + Mas-si´ kwa´-yo Chicken hawk. + Tda´-wa Sun. + Ka-ha´-bi Willow. + Te´-bi Greasewood. + +5. Ka-tci´-na--Sacred, dancer--from the east. + + Ka-tci´-na Sacred dancer. + Gya´-zro Parroquet. + Uñ-wu´-si Raven. + Si-kya´-tci Yellow bird. + Si-he´-bi Cottonwood. + Sa-la´-bi Spruce. + +6. A´sa--a plant (unknown)--from the Chama. + + A´sa + Tca´-kwai-na Black earth Katcina. + Pu´tc-ko-hu Boomerang hunting stick. + Pi´-ca Field mouse. + Hoc´-bo-a Road runner, or chaparral cock. + Po-si´-o Magpie. + Kwi´ñobi Oak. + +7. Ho-na´-ni--Badger--from the east. + + Ho-na´-ni Badger. + Müñ-ya´u-wu Porcupine. + Wu-so´-ko Vulture. + Bu´-li Butterfly. + Bu-li´-so Evening primrose. + Na´-hü Medicine of all kinds; generic. + +8. Yo´-ki--Rain--from the south. + + Yo´-ki Rain. + O´-mau Cloud. + Ka´i-e Corn. + Mu´r-zi-bu-si Bean. + Ka-wa´i-ba-tuñ-a Watermelon. + Si-vwa´-pi Bigelovia graveolens. + + [Illustration: Plate XIV. General view of Payupki.] + +The foregoing is the Water or Rain phratry proper, but allied to them +are the two following phratries, who also came to this region with the +Water phratry. + + LIZARD. + + Ka´-kü-tci } + Ba-tci´p-kwa-si } Species of lizards. + Na´-nan-a-wi } + Mo´-mo-bi } + Pi´-sa White sand. + Tdu´-wa Red sand. + Ten´-kai Mud. + + RABBIT. + + So´-wi Jackass rabbit. + Tda´-bo Cottontail rabbit. + Pi´-ba Tobacco. + Tcoñ-o Pipe. + +Polaka gives the following data: + +Te´-wa gentes and phratries. + + _Tewa_ _Hopi´tuh_ _Navajo._ + Ko´[n]-lo \ Ka´-ai Nata´[n] Corn. + Cä / Pi´-ba Na´-to Tobacco. + Ke \ Ho´-nau Cac Bear. + Tce´-li / Ca´-la-bi Ts´-co Spruce. + Ke´gi \ Ki´-hu Ki-a´-ni House. + Tuñ / Tda´-wu Tjon-a-ai´ Sun. + O´-ku-wuñ \ O´-mau Kus Cloud. + Nuñ / Tcu´-kai Huc-klic Mud. + +The gentes bracketed are said to "belong together," but do not seem to +have distinctive names--as phratries. + + +SUPPLEMENTARY LEGEND. + +An interesting ruin which occurs on a mesa point a short distance north +of Mashongnavi is known to the Tusayan under the name of Payupki. There +are traditions and legends concerning it among the Tusayan, but the only +version that could be obtained is not regarded by the writer as being up +to the standard of those incorporated in the "Summary" and it is +therefore given separately, as it has some suggestive value. It was +obtained through Dr. Jeremiah Sullivan, then resident in Tusayan. + +The people of Payupki spoke the same language as those on the first mesa +(Walpi). Long ago they lived in the north, on the San Juan, but they +were compelled to abandon that region and came to a place about 20 miles +northwest from Oraibi. Being compelled to leave there, they went to +Canyon de Chelly, where a band of Indians from the southeast joined +them, with whom they formed an alliance. Together the two tribes moved +eastward toward the Jemez Mountains, whence they drifted into the valley +of the Rio Grande. There they became converts to the fire-worship then +prevailing, but retained their old customs and language. At the time of +the great insurrection (of 1680) they sheltered the native priests that +were driven from some of the Rio Grande villages, and this action +created such distrust and hatred among the people that the Payupki were +forced to leave their settlement. Their first stop was at Old Laguna (12 +miles east of the modern village) and they had with them then some 35 or +40 of the priests. After leaving Laguna they came to Bear Spring (Fort +Wingate) and had a fight there with the Apache, whom they defeated. They +remained at Bear Spring for several years, until the Zuñi compelled them +to move. They then attempted to reach the San Juan, but were deceived in +the trail, turned to the west and came to where Pueblo Colorado is now +(the present post-office of Ganado, between Fort Defiance and Keam's +Canyon). They remained there a long time, and through their success in +farming became so favorably known that they were urged to come farther +west. They refused, in consequence of which some Tusayan attacked them. +They were captured and brought to Walpi (then on the point) and +afterwards they were distributed among the villages. Previous to this +capture the priests had been guiding them by feathers, smoke, and signs +seen in the fire. When the priest's omens and oracles had proved false +the people were disposed to kill them, but the priests persuaded them to +let it depend on a test case--offering to kill themselves in the event +of failure. So they had a great feast at Awatubi. The priests had long, +hollow reeds inclosing various substances--feathers, flour, corn-pollen, +sacred water, native tobacco (piba), corn, beans, melon seeds, etc., and +they formed in a circle at sunrise on the plaza and had their +incantations and prayers. As the sun rose a priest stepped forth before +the people and blew through his reed, desirous of blowing that which was +therein away from him, to scatter it abroad. But the wind would not +blow and the contents of the reed fell to the ground. The priests were +divided into groups, according to what they carried. In the evening all +but two groups had blown. Then the elder of the twain turned his back +eastward, and the reed toward the setting sun, and he blew, and the wind +caught the feather and carried it to the west. This was accepted as a +sign and the next day the Tusayan freed the slaves, giving each a +blanket with corn in it. They went to the mesa where the ruin now stands +and built the houses there. They asked for planting grounds, and fields +were given them; but their crops did not thrive, and they stole corn +from the Mashongnavi. Then, fearful lest they should be surprised at +night, they built a wall as high as a man's head about the top of their +mesa, and they had big doorways, which they closed and fastened at +night. When they were compelled to plant corn for themselves they +planted it on the ledges of the mesa, but it grew only as high as a +man's knees; the leaves were very small and the grains grew only on one +side of it. After a time they became friendly with the Mashongnavi +again, and a boy from that village conceived a passion for a Payupki +girl. The latter tribe objected to a marriage but the Mashongnavi were +very desirous for it and some warriors of that village proposed if the +boy could persuade the girl to fly with him, to aid and protect him. On +an appointed day, about sundown, the girl came down from the mesa into +the valley, but she was discovered by some old women who were baking +pottery, who gave the alarm. Hearing the noise a party of the +Mashongnavi, who were lying in wait, came up, but they encountered a +party of the Payupki who had come out and a fight ensued. During the +fight the young man was killed; and this caused so much bitterness of +feeling that the Payupki were frightened, and remained quietly in their +pueblo for several days. One morning, however, an old woman came over to +Mashongnavi to borrow some tobacco, saying that they were going to have +a dance in her village in five days. The next day the Payupki quietly +departed. Seeing no smoke from the village the Mashongnavi at first +thought that the Payupki were preparing for their dance, but on the +third day a band of warriors was sent over to inquire and they found the +village abandoned. The estufas and the houses of the priests were pulled +down. + +The narrator adds that the Payupki returned to San Felipe whence they +came. + + [Illustration: Plate XV. Standing walls of Payupki.] + + + + +CHAPTER II. + +RUINS AND INHABITED VILLAGES OF TUSAYAN. + + +PHYSICAL FEATURES OF THE PROVINCE. + +That portion of the southwestern plateau country comprised in the +Province of Tusayan has usually been approached from the east, so that +the easternmost of the series of mesas upon which the villages are +situated is called the "First Mesa." The road for 30 or 40 miles before +reaching this point traverses the eastern portion of the great plateau +whose broken margin, farther west, furnishes the abrupt mesa-tongues +upon which the villages are built. The sandstone measures of this +plateau are distinguished from many others of the southwest by their +neutral colors. The vegetation consisting of a scattered growth of +stunted piñon and cedar, interspersed with occasional stretches of +dull-gray sage, imparts an effect of extreme monotony to the landscape. +The effect is in marked contrast to the warmth and play of color +frequently seen elsewhere in the plateau country. + +The plateaus of Tusayan are generally diversified by canyons and buttes, +whose precipitous sides break down into long ranges of rocky talus and +sandy foothills. The arid character of this district is especially +pronounced about the margin of the plateau. In the immediate vicinity of +the villages there are large areas that do not support a blade of grass, +where barren rocks outcrop through drifts of sand or lie piled in +confusion at the bases of the cliffs. The canyons that break through the +margins of these mesas often have a remarkable similarity of appearance, +and the consequent monotony is extremely embarrassing to the traveler, +the absence of running water and clearly defined drainage confusing his +sense of direction. + +The occasional springs which furnish scanty water supply to the +inhabitants of this region are found generally at great distances apart, +and there are usually but few natural indications of their location. +They often occur in obscure nooks in the canyons, reached by tortuous +trails winding through the talus and foothills, or as small seeps at the +foot of some mesa. The convergence of numerous Navajo trails, however, +furnishes some guide to these rare water sources. + + [Illustration: Plate XVI. Plan of Hano.] + +The series of promontories upon which the Tusayan villages are built are +exceptionally rich in these seeps and springs. About the base of the +"First Mesa" (Fig. 1), within a distance of 4 or 5 miles from the +villages located upon it, there are at least five places where water can +be obtained. One of these is a mere surface reservoir, but the others +appear to be permanent springs. The quantity of water, however, is so +small that it produces no impression on the arid and sterile effect of +the surroundings, except in its immediate vicinity. Here small patches +of green, standing out in strong relief against their sandy +back-grounds, mark the position of clusters of low, stunted peach trees +that have obtained a foothold on the steep sand dunes. + + [Illustration: Fig. 1. View of the First Mesa.] + +In the open plains surrounding the mesa rim (6,000 feet above the sea), +are seen broad stretches of dusty sage brush and prickly greasewood. +Where the plain rises toward the base of the mesa a scattered growth of +scrub cedar and piñon begins to appear. But little of this latter growth +is seen in the immediate vicinity of the villages; it is, however, the +characteristic vegetation of the mesas, while, in still higher +altitudes, toward the San Juan, open forests of timber are met with. +This latter country seems scarcely to have come within the ancient +builder's province; possibly on account of its coldness in winter and +for the reason that it is open to the incursions of warlike hunting +tribes. Sage brush and greasewood grow abundantly near the villages, and +these curious gnarled and twisted shrubs furnish the principal fuel of +the Tusayan. + +Occasionally grassy levels are seen that for a few weeks in early summer +are richly carpeted with multitudes of delicate wild flowers. The beauty +of these patches of gleaming color is enhanced by contrast with the +forbidding and rugged character of the surroundings; but in a very short +time these blossoms disappear from the arid and parched desert that they +have temporarily beautified. These beds of bloom are not seen in the +immediate vicinity of the present villages, but are unexpectedly met +with in portions of the neighboring mesas and canyons. + +After crossing the 6 or 7 miles of comparatively level country that +intervenes between the mouth of Keam's Canyon and the first of the +occupied mesas, the toilsome ascent begins; at first through slopes and +dunes and then over masses of broken talus, as the summit of the mesa is +gradually approached. Near the top the road is flanked on one side by a +very abrupt descent of broken slopes, and on the other by a precipitous +rocky wall that rises 30 or 40 feet above. The road reaches the brink of +the promontory by a sharp rise at a point close to the village of Hano. + + +METHODS OF SURVEY. + +Before entering upon a description of the villages and ruins, a few +words as to the preparation of the plans accompanying this paper will +not be amiss. The methods pursued in making the surveys of the inhabited +pueblos were essentially the same throughout. The outer wall of each +separate cluster was run with a compass and a tape measure, the lines +being closed and checked upon the corner from which the beginning was +made, so that the plan of each group stands alone, and no accumulation +of error is possible. The stretched tapeline afforded a basis for +estimating any deviations from a straight line which the wall presented, +and as each sight was plotted on the spot these deviations are all +recorded on the plan, and afford an indication of the degree of accuracy +with which the building was carried out. Upon the basis thus obtained, +the outlines of the second stories were drawn by the aid of measurements +from the numerous jogs and angles; the same process being repeated for +each of the succeeding stories. The plan at this stage recorded all the +stories in outline. The various houses and clusters were connected by +compass sights and by measurements. A tracing of the outline plan was +then made, on which the stories were distinguished by lines of different +colors, and upon this tracing were recorded all the vertical +measurements. These were generally taken at every corner, although in a +long wall it was customary to make additional measurements at +intervening points. + + [Illustration: Plate XVII. View of Hano.] + +Upon the original outline were then drawn all such details as coping +stones, chimneys, trapdoors, etc., the tapeline being used where +necessary to establish positions. The forms of the chimneys as well as +their position and size were also indicated on this drawing, which was +finally tinted to distinguish the different terraces. Upon this colored +sheet were located all openings. These were numbered, and at the same +time described in a notebook, in which were also recorded the necessary +vertical measurements, such as their height and elevation above the +ground. In the same notebook the openings were also fully described. The +ladders were located upon the same sheet, and were consecutively +lettered and described in the notebook. This description furnishes a +record of the ladder, its projection above the coping, if any, the +difference in the length of its poles, the character of the tiepiece, +etc. Altogether these notebooks furnish a mass of statistical data which +has been of great service in the elaboration of this report and in the +preparation of models. Finally, a level was carried over the whole +village, and the height of each corner and jog above an assumed base was +determined. A reduced tracing was then made of the plan as a basis for +sketching in such details of topography, etc., as it was thought +advisable to preserve. + +These plans were primarily intended to be used in the construction of +large scale models, and consequently recorded an amount of information +that could not be reproduced upon the published drawings without causing +great confusion. + +The methods followed in surveying the ruins underwent some changes from +time to time as the work progressed. In the earlier work the lines of +the walls, so far as they could be determined, were run with a compass +and tapeline and gone over with a level. Later it was found more +convenient to select a number of stations and connect them by +cross-sights and measurements. These points were then platted, and the +walls and lines of débris were carefully drawn in over the framework of +lines thus obtained, additional measurements being taken when necessary. +The heights of standing walls were measured from both sides, and +openings were located on the plan and described in a notebook, as was +done in the survey of the inhabited villages. The entire site was then +leveled, and from the data obtained contour lines were drawn with a +5-foot interval. Irregularities in the directions of walls were noted. +In the later plans of ruins a scale of symbols, seven in number, were +employed to indicate the amount and distribution of the débris. The +plans, as published, indicate the relative amounts of débris as seen +upon the ground. Probable lines of wall are shown on the plan by dotted +lines drawn through the dots which indicate débris. With this exception, +the plans show the ruins as they actually are. Standing walls, as a +rule, are drawn in solid black; their heights appear on the field +sheets, but could not be shown upon the published plans without +confusing the drawing. The contour lines represent an interval of 5 +feet; the few cases in which the secondary or negative contours are used +will not produce confusion, as their altitude is always given in +figures. + + +PLANS AND DESCRIPTIONS OF RUINS. + +The ruins described in this chapter comprise but a few of those found +within the province of Tusayan. These were surveyed and recorded on +account of their close traditional connection with the present villages, +and for the sake of the light that they might throw upon the relation of +the modern pueblos to the innumerable stone buildings of unknown date so +widely distributed over the southwestern plateau country. Such +traditional connection with the present peoples could probably be +established for many more of the ruins of this country by investigations +similar to those conducted by Mr. Stephen in the Tusayan group; but this +phase of the subject was not included in our work. In the search for +purely architectural evidence among these ruins it must be confessed +that the data have proved disappointingly meager. No trace of the +numerous constructive details that interest the student of pueblo +architecture in the modern villages can be seen in the low mounds of +broken down masonry that remain in most of the ancient villages of +Tusayan. But little masonry remains standing in even the best preserved +of these ruins, and villages known to have been occupied within two +centuries are not distinguishable from the remains to which distinct +tradition (save that they were in the same condition when the first +people of the narrators' gens came to this region) no longer clings. +Though but little architectural information is to be derived from these +ruins beyond such as is conveyed by the condition and character of the +masonry and the general distribution of the plan, the plans and relation +to the topography are recorded as forming, in connection with the +traditions, a more complete account than can perhaps be obtained later. + +In our study of architectural details, when a comparison is suggested +between the practice at Tusayan and that of the ancient builders, our +illustrations for the latter must often be drawn from other portions of +the builders' territory where better preserved remains furnish the +necessary data. + +WALPI RUINS. + +In the case of the pueblo of Walpi, a portion of whose people seem to +have been the first comers in this region, a number of changes of sites +have taken place, at least one of which has occurred within the historic +period. Of the various sites occupied one is pointed out north of the +gap on the first mesa. At the present time this site is only a low mound +of sand-covered débris with no standing fragment of wall visible. The +present condition of this early Walpi is illustrated in Fig. 2. In the +absence of foundation walls or other definite lines, the character of +the site is expressed by the contour lines that define its relief. +Another of the sites occupied by the Walpi is said to have been in the +open valley separating the first from the second mesa, but here no trace +of the remains of a stone village has been discovered. This traditional +location is referred to by Mr. Stephen in his account of Walpi. The last +site occupied previous to the present one on the mesa summit was on a +lower bench of the first mesa promontory at its southern extremity. Here +the houses are said to have been distributed over quite a large area, +and occasional fragments of masonry are still seen at widely separated +points; but the ground plan can not now be traced. This was the site of +a Spanish mission, and some of the Tusayan point out the position +formerly occupied by mission buildings, but no architectural evidence of +such structures is visible. It seems to be fairly certain, however, that +this was the site of Walpi at a date well within the historic period, +although now literally there is not one stone upon another. The +destruction in this instance has probably been more than usually +complete on account of the close proximity of the succeeding pueblo, +making the older remains a very convenient stone quarry for the +construction of the houses on the mesa summit. Of the three abandoned +sites of Walpi referred to, not one furnishes sufficient data for a +suggestion of a ground plan or of the area covered. + + [Illustration: Plate XVIII. Plan of Sichumovi.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 2. Ruins, Old Walpi mound.] + +OLD MASHONGNAVI. + +In the case of Mashongnavi we have somewhat more abundant material. It +will be desirable to quote a few lines of narrative from the account of +a Mashongnavi Indian of the name of Nuvayauma, as indicating the causes +that led to the occupation of the site illustrated. + + We turned and came to the north, meeting the Apache and "Beaver + Indians," with whom we had many battles, and being few we were + defeated, after which we came up to Mashongnavi [the ruin at the + "Giant's Chair"] and gave that rock its name [name not known], and + built our houses there. The Apache came upon us again, with the + Comanche, and then we came to [Old Mashóngnavi]. We lived there in + peace many years, having great success with crops, and our people + increased in numbers, and the Apache came in great numbers and set + fire to the houses and burned our corn, which you will find to-day + there burnt and charred. After they had destroyed our dwellings we + came upon the mesa, and have lived here since. + +The ruins referred to as having been the first occupied by the +Mashongnavi at a large isolated rock known as the "Giant's Chair," have +not been examined. The later village from which they were driven by the +attacks of the Apache to their present site has been surveyed. The plan +of the fallen walls and lines of débris by which the form of much of the +old pueblo can still be traced is given in Pl. II. The plan of the best +preserved portion of the pueblo towards the north end of the sheet +clearly indicates a general adherence to the inclosed court arrangement +with about the same degree of irregularity that characterizes the modern +village. Besides the clearly traceable portions of the ruin that bear +such resemblance to the present village in arrangement, several small +groups and clusters appear to have been scattered along the slope of the +foothills, but in their present state of destruction it is not clear +whether these clusters were directly connected with the principal group, +or formed part of another village. Occasional traces of foundation walls +strongly suggest such connection, although from the character of the +site this intervening space could hardly have been closely built over. +With the exception of the main cluster above described the houses occupy +very broken and irregular sites. As indicated on the plan, the slope is +broken by huge irregular masses of sandstone protruding from the soil, +while much of the surface is covered by scattered fragments that have +fallen from neighboring pinnacles and ledges. The contours indicate the +general character of the slopes over which these irregular features are +disposed. The fragment of ledge shown on the north end of the plate, +against which a part of the main cluster has been built, is a portion of +a broad massive ledge of sandstone that supports the low buttes upon +which the present villages of Mashongnavi and Shupaúlovi are built, and +continues as a broad, level shelf of solid rock for several miles along +the mesa promontory. Its continuation on the side opposite that shown in +the plate may be seen in the general view of Shupaulovi (Pl. XXXI). + +SHITAIMUVI. + +The vestiges of another ruined village, known as Shitaimuvi, are found +in the vicinity of Mashongnavi, occupying and covering the crown of a +rounded foothill on the southeast side of the mesa. No plan of this ruin +could be obtained on account of the complete destruction of the walls. +No line of foundation stones even could be found, although the whole +area is more or less covered with the scattered stones of former +masonry. An exceptional quantity of pottery fragments is also strewn +over the surface. These bear a close resemblance to the fine class of +ware characteristic of "Talla Hogan" or "Awatubi," and would suggest +that this pueblo was contemporaneous with the latter. Some reference to +this ruin win be found in the traditionary material in Chapter I. + + [Illustration: Plate XIX. View of Sichumovi.] + +AWATUBI. + +The ruin of Awatubi is known to the Navajo as Talla Hogan, a term +interpreted as meaning "singing house" and thought to refer to the +chapel and mission that at one time nourished here, as described by Mr. +Stephen in Chapter I. Tradition ascribes great importance to this +village. At the time of the Spanish conquest it was one of the most +prosperous of the seven "cities" of Tusayan, and was selected as the +site of a mission, a distinction shared by Walpi, which was then on a +lower spur of the first mesa, and by Shumopavi, which also was built on +a lower site than the present village of that name. Traditions referring +to this pueblo have been collected from several sources and, while +varying somewhat in less important details, they all concur in bringing +the destruction of the village well within the period of Spanish +occupation. + +On the historical site, too, we know that Cruzate on the occasion of the +attempted reconquest of the country visited this village in 1692, and +the ruin must therefore be less than two centuries old, yet the +completeness of destruction is such that over most of its area no +standing wall is seen, and the outlines of the houses and groups are +indicated mainly by low ridges and masses of broken-down masonry, partly +covered by the drifting sands. The group of rooms that forms the south +east side of the pueblo is an exception to the general rule. Here +fragmentary walls of rough masonry stand to a height, in some cases, of +8 feet above the débris. The character of the stonework, as may be seen +from Pl. V, is but little better than that of the modern villages. This +better preserved portion of the village seems to have formed part of a +cluster of mission buildings. At the points designated A on the ground +plan may be seen the remnants of walls that have been built of straw +adobe in the typical Spanish manner. These rest upon foundations of +stone masonry. See Pl. VI. The adobe fragments are probably part of the +church or associated buildings. At two other points on the ground plan, +both on the northeast side, low fragments of wall are still standing, as +may be seen from the plate. At one of these points the remains indicate +that the village was provided with a gateway near the middle of the +northeast side. + +The general plan of this pueblo is quite different from that of the +present villages, and approaches the older types in symmetry and +compactness. There is a notable absence of the arrangement of rooms into +long parallel rows. This typical Tusayan feature is only slightly +approximated in some subordinate rows within the court. The plan +suggests that the original pueblo was built about three sides of a +rectangular court, the fourth or southeast side--later occupied by the +mission buildings--being left open, or protected only by a low wall. +Outside the rectangle of the main pueblo, on the northeast side, are two +fragments of rude masonry, built by Navajo sheep herders. Near the west +corner of the pueblo are the vestiges of two rooms, outside the pueblo +proper, which seem to belong to the original construction. + +Awatubi is said to have had excavated rectangular kivas, situated in the +open court, similar to those used in the modern village. The people of +Walpi had partly cleared out one of these chambers and used it as a +depository for ceremonial plume-sticks, etc., but the Navajo came and +carried off their sacred deposits, tempted probably by their market +value as ethnologic specimens. No trace of these kivas was visible at +the time the ruins were surveyed. + +The Awatubi are said to have had sheep at the time the village was +destroyed. Some of the Tusayan point out the remains of a large sheep +corral near the spring, which they say was used at that time, but it is +quite as likely to have been constructed for that purpose at a much +later date. + +HORN HOUSE. + +The Horn House is so called because tradition connects this village with +some of the people of the Horn phratry of the Hopituh or Tusayan. The +ruin is situated on a projecting point of the mesa that forms the +western flank of Jeditoh Valley, not far from where the Holbrook road to +Keam's Canyon ascends the brink of the mesa. The village is almost +completely demolished, no fragment of standing wall remaining in place. +Its general plan and distribution are quite clearly indicated by the +usual low ridges of fallen masonry partly covered by drifted sand. There +is but little loose stone scattered about, the sand having filled in all +the smaller irregularities. + +It will be seen from the plan, Pl. VII, that the village has been built +close to the edge of the mesa, following to some extent the +irregularities of its outline. The mesa ruin at this point, however, is +not very high, the more abrupt portion having a height of 20 or 30 feet. +Near the north end of the village the ground slopes very sharply toward +the east and is rather thickly covered with the small stones of fallen +masonry, though but faint vestiges of rooms remain. In plan the ruin is +quite elongated, following the direction of the mesa. The houses were +quite irregularly disposed, particularly in the northern portion of the +ruin. But here the indications are too vague to determine whether the +houses were originally built about one long court or about two or more +smaller ones. The south end of the pueblo, however, still shows a well +defined court bounded on all sides by clearly traceable rooms. At the +extreme south end of the ruin the houses have very irregular outlines, +a result of their adaptation to the topography, as may be seen in the +illustration. + + [Illustration: Plate XX. Plan of Walpi.] + +The plan shows the position of a small group of cottonwood trees, just +below the edge of the mesa and nearly opposite the center of the +village. These trees indicate the proximity of water, and mark the +probable site of the spring that furnished this village with at least +part of its water supply. + +There are many fragments of pottery on this spot, but they are not so +abundant as at Awatubi. + +Two partly excavated rooms were seen at this ruin, the work of some +earlier visitors who hoped to discover ethnologic or other treasure. + +These afforded no special information, as the character of the masonry +exposed differed in no respect from that seen at other of the Tusayan +ruins. No traces of adobe construction or suggestions of foreign +influence were seen at this ruin. + +SMALL RUIN BETWEEN HORN HOUSE AND BAT HOUSE. + +On a prolongation of the mesa occupied by the Horn House, midway between +it and another ruined pueblo known as the Bat House, occur the remains +of a small and compact cluster of houses (Fig. 3). It is situated on the +very mesa edge, here about 40 feet high, at the head of a small canyon +which opens into the Jeditoh Valley, a quarter of a mile below. + + [Illustration: Fig. 3. Ruin between Bat House and Horn House.] + +The site affords an extended outlook to the south over a large part of +Jeditoh Valley. The topography about this point, which receives the +drainage of a considerable area of the mesa top, would fit it especially +for the establishment of a reservoir. This fact probably had much to do +with its selection as a dwelling site. The masonry is in about the same +state of preservation as that of the Horn House, and some of the stones +of the fallen walls seem to have been washed down from the mesa edge to +the talus below. + +BAT HOUSE. + +The Bat House is a ruin of nearly the same size as the Horn House, +although in its distribution it does not follow the mesa edge so closely +as the latter, and is not so elongated in its general form. The northern +portion is quite irregular, and the rooms seem to have been somewhat +crowded. The southern half, with only an occasional room traceable, +as indicated on the plan, Pl. VIII, still shows that the rooms were +distributed about a large open court. + +The Bat House is situated on the northwest side of the Jeditoh Valley, +on part of the same mesa occupied by the two ruins described above. It +occupies the summit of a projecting spur, overlooking the main valley +for an extent of more than 5 miles. The ruin lies on the extreme edge of +the cliff, here about 200 feet high, and lying beneath it on the east +and south are large areas of arable land. Altogether it forms an +excellent defensive site, combined with a fair degree of convenience to +fields and water from the Tusayan point of view. + +This ruin, near its northeastern extremity, contains a feature that is +quite foreign to the architecture of Tusayan, viz, a defensive wall. +It is the only instance of the use by the Hopituh of an inclosing wall, +though it is met with again at Payupki (Pl. XIII), which, however, was +built by people from the Rio Grande country. + +MISHIPTONGA. + +Mishiptonga is the Tusayan name for the southernmost, and by far the +largest, of the Jeditoh series of ruins (Pl. IX). It occurs quite close +to the Jeditoh spring which gives its name to the valley along whose +northern and western border are distributed the ruins above described, +beginning with the Horn house. + + [Illustration: Plate XXI. View of Walpi.] + +This village is rather more irregular in its arrangement than any other +of the series. There are indications of a number of courts inclosed by +large and small clusters of rooms, very irregularly disposed, but with a +general trend towards the northeast, being roughly parallel with the +mesa edge. In plan this village approaches somewhat that of the +inhabited Tusayan villages. At the extreme southern extremity of the +mesa promontory is a small secondary bench, 20 feet lower than the site +of the main village. This bench has also been occupied by a number of +houses. On the east side the pueblo was built to the very edge of the +bluff, where small fragments of masonry are still standing. The whole +village seems so irregular and crowded in its arrangement that it +suggests a long period of occupancy and growth, much more than do the +other villages of this (Jeditoh) group. + +The pueblo may have been abandoned or destroyed prior to the advent of +the Spaniards in this country, as claimed by the Indians, for no +traditional mention of it is made in connection with the later feuds and +wars that figure so prominently in the Tusayan oral history of the last +three centuries. The pueblo was undoubtedly built by some of the ancient +gentes of the Tusayan stock, as its plan, the character of the site +chosen, and, where traceable, the quality of workmanship link it with +the other villages of the Jeditoh group. + + [Illustration: Fig. 4. Ruin near Moen-kopi, plan.] + +MOEN-KOPI RUINS. + +A very small group of rooms, even smaller than the neighboring farming +pueblo of Moen-kopi, is situated on the western edge of the mesa summit +about a quarter of a mile north of the modern village of Moen-kopi. As +the plan shows (Fig. 4), the rooms were distributed in three rows around +a small court. This ruin also follows the general northeastern trend +which has been noticed both in the ruined and in the occupied pueblos of +Tusayan. The rows here were only one room deep and not more than a +single story high at any point, as indicated by the very small amount of +débris. As the plate shows, nearly the entire plan is clearly defined by +fragments of standing walls. The walls are built of thin tablets of the +dark-colored sandstone which caps the mesa. Where the walls have fallen +the débris is comparatively free from earth, indicating that adobe has +been sparingly used. The walls, in places standing to a height of 2 or 3 +feet, as may be seen in the illustration, Pl. X, show unusual precision +of workmanship and finish, resembling in this respect some of the +ancient pueblos farther north. This is to some extent due to the +exceptional suitability of the tabular stones of the mesa summit. The +almost entire absence of pottery fragments and other objects of art +which are such a constant accompaniment of the ruins throughout this +region strongly suggest that it was occupied for a very short time. In +Chapter III it will be shown that a similar order of occupation took +place at Ojo Caliente, one of the Zuñi farming villages. This ruin is +probably of quite recent origin, as is the present village of Moen-kopi, +although it may possibly have belonged to an earlier colony of which +we have no distinct trace. This fertile and well watered valley, a +veritable garden spot in the Tusayan deserts, must have been one of the +first points occupied. Some small cliff-dwellings, single rooms in +niches of a neighboring canyon wall, attest the earlier use of the +valley for agricultural purposes, although it is doubtful whether these +rude shelters date back of the Spanish invasion of the province. + +A close scrutiny of the many favorable sites in this vicinity would +probably reveal the sand-encumbered remains of some more important +settlement than any of those now known. + +RUINS ON THE ORAIBI WASH. + +The wagon road from Keam's Canyon to Tuba City crosses the Oraibi wash +at a point about 7 miles above the village of Oraibi. As it enters a +branch canyon on the west side of the wash it is flanked on each side by +rocky mesas and broken ledges. On the left or west side a bold +promontory, extending southward, is quite a conspicuous feature of the +landscape. The entire flat mesa summit, and much of the slope of a rocky +butte that rises from it, are covered with the remains of a small +pueblo, as shown on the plan, Fig. 5. All of this knoll except its +eastern side is lightly covered with scattered débris. On the west and +north sides there are many large masses of broken rock distributed over +the slope. There is no standing wall visible from below, but on closer +approach several interesting specimens of masonry are seen. On the north +side, near the west end, there is a fragment of curved wall which +follows the margin of the rock on which it is built. It is about 8 or 10 +feet long and 3 feet high on the outer side. The curve is carefully +executed and the workmanship of the masonry good. Farther east, and +still on the north side, there is a fragment of masonry exhibiting a +reversed curve. This piece of wall spans the space between two adjoining +rocks, and the top of the wall is more than 10 feet above the rock on +which it stands. The shape of this wall and its relation to the +surroundings are indicated on the plan, Fig. 5. On the south side of the +ruin on the mesa surface, and near an outcropping rock, are the remains +of what appears to have been a circular room, perhaps 8 or 10 feet in +diameter, though it is too much broken down to determine this +accurately. Only a small portion of the south wall can be definitely +traced. On the south slope of the mesa are indications of walls, too +vaguely defined to admit of the determination of their direction. +Similar vestiges of masonry are found on the north and west, but not +extending to as great a distance from the knoll as those on the south. + + [Illustration: Plate XXII. South passageway of Walpi.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 5. Ruin 7 miles north of Oraibi.] + +In that portion of the ruin which lies on top of the knoll, the walls so +far as traced conform to the shape of the site. The ground plan of the +buildings that once occupied the slopes can not be traced, and it is +impossible to determine whether its walls were carried through +continuously. + +The masonry exhibited in the few surviving fragments of wall is of +unusually good quality, resembling somewhat that of the Fire House, Fig. +7, and other ruins of that class. The stones are of medium size, not +dressed, and are rather rougher and less flat than is usual, but the +wall has a good finish. The stone, however, is of poor quality. Most of +the débris about the ruin consists of small stone fragments and sand, +comparatively few stones of the size used in the walls being seen. The +material evidently came from the immediate vicinity of the ruin. + +Pottery fragments were quite abundant about this ruin, most of the ware +represented being of exceptional quality and belonging to the older +types; red ware with black lines and black and white ware were +especially abundant. + +There is quite an extensive view from the ruin, the top of the butte +commanding an outlook down the valley past Oraibi, and about 5 miles +north. There is also an extended outlook up the valley followed by the +wagon road above referred to, and over two branch valleys, one on the +east and another of much less extent on the west. The site was well +adapted for defense, which must have been one of the principal motives +for its selection. + + [Illustration: Fig. 6. Ruin 14 miles north of Oraibi (Kwaituki).] + +KWAITUKI. + +The ruin known to the Tusayan as Kwaituki (Fig. 6) is also on the west +side of the Oraibi wash, 14 miles above Oraibi, and about 7 miles above +the ruin last described. Its general resemblance to the latter is very +striking. The builders have apparently been actuated by the same motives +in their choice of a site, and their manner of utilizing it corresponds +very closely. The crowning feature of the rocky knoll in this case is a +picturesque group of rectangular masses of sandstone, somewhat +irregularly distributed. The bare summit of a large block-like mass +still retains the vestiges of rooms, and probably most of the groups +were at one time covered with buildings, forming a prominent +citadel-like group in the midst of the village. To the north of this +rocky butte a large area seems to have been at one time inclosed by +buildings, forming a court of unusual dimensions. Along the outer margin +of the pueblo occasional fragments of walls define former rooms, but the +amount and character of the débris indicate that the inner area was +almost completely inclosed with buildings. The remains of masonry extend +on the south a little beyond the base of the central group of rocks, but +here the vestiges of stonework are rather faint and scattered. + + [Illustration: Plate XXIII. Houses built over irregular sites, Walpi.] + +In the nearly level tops of some of the rocks forming the central pile +are many smoothly worn depressions or cavities, which have evidently +been used for the grinding and shaping of stone implements. + +A remarkable feature occurring within this village is a cave or +underground fissure in the rocks, which evidently had been used by the +inhabitants. The mouth or entrance to this cavern, partly obstructed and +concealed at the time of our visit, occurs at the point A on the plan. +On clearing away the rubbish at the mouth and entering it was found so +obstructed with broken rock and fine dust that but little progress could +be made in its exploration; but the main crevice in the rock could be +seen by artificial light to extend some 10 feet back from the mouth, +where it became very shallow. It could be seen that the original cavern +had been improved by the pueblo-builders, as some of the timbers that +had been placed inside were still in position, and a low wall of masonry +on the south side remained intact. Some Navajos stated that they had +discovered this small cave a couple of years before and had taken from +it a large unbroken water jar of ancient pottery and some other +specimens. The place was probably used by the ancient occupants simply +for storage. + +Fragments of pottery of excellent quality were very abundant about this +ruin and at the foot of the central rocks the ground was thickly strewn +with fragments, often of large size. + +The defensive character of this site parallels that of the ruin 7 miles +farther south in quite a remarkable manner, and the villages were +apparently built and occupied at the same time. + +TEBUGKIHU, OR FIRE HOUSE. + +About 15 miles northeast of Keam's Canyon, and about 25 miles from +Walpi, is a small ruin called by the Tusayan "Tebugkihu," built by +people of the Fire gens (now extinct). As the plan (Fig. 7) clearly +shows, this pueblo is very different from the typical Tusayan villages +that have been previously described. The apparent unity of the plan, and +the skillful workmanship somewhat resembling the pueblos of the Chaco +are in marked contrast to the irregularity and careless construction of +most of the Tusayan ruins. Its distance from the center of the province, +too, suggests outside relationship; but still the Tusayan traditions +undoubtedly connect the place with some of the ancestral gentes, as seen +in Chapter I. + +The small and compact cluster of rooms is in a remarkable state of +preservation, especially the outside wall. This wall was carefully and +massively constructed, and stands to the height of several feet around +the entire circumference of the ruin, except along the brink of the +cliff, as the plan shows. + +This outer wall contains by far the largest stones yet found +incorporated in pueblo masonry. A fragment of this masonry is +illustrated in Pl. XI. The largest stone shown measures about 5 feet in +length, and the one adjoining on the right measures about 4 feet. These +dimensions are quite remarkable in pueblo masonry, which is +distinguished by the use of very small stones. + +The well defined outer wall of this cluster to the unaided eye appears +to be elliptical, but it will be seen from the plan that the ellipse is +somewhat pointed on the side farthest from the cliff. As in other cases +of ancient pueblos with curved outlines, the outer wall seems to have +been built first, and the inner rooms, while kept as rectangular as +possible, were adjusted to this curve. This arrangement often led to a +cumulating divergence from radial lines in some of the partitions, which +irregularity was taken up in one room, as in this instance, in the space +near the gate. The outer wall is uniform in construction so far as +preserved. Many irregularities appear, however, in the construction of +the inner or partition walls, and some of the rooms show awkward +attempts at adjustment to the curve of the outer wall. + + [Illustration: Fig. 7. Oval (Fire House) ruin, plan (Tebugkihu).] + +The ruin is situated on the very brink of a small canyon, which probably +contained a spring at the foot of the cliff close under the ruin site, +as the vegetation there has an unusual appearance of freshness, +suggesting the close proximity of water to the surface. A steep trail +evidently connected the village with the bottom of the canyon. Some of +the rocks of the mesa rim were marked by numerous cup-like cavities +similar to those seen at Kwaituki, and used in the polishing and forming +of stone implements. The type of pueblo here illustrated belonged to a +people who relied largely on the architecture for defense, differing in +this respect from the spirit of Tusayan architecture generally, where +the inaccessible character of the site was the chief dependence. + +CHUKUBI. + +The ruin called Chukubi by the Tusayan (Pl. XII) is situated on the +Middle Mesa, about 3 miles northeast of Mashongnavi. It occupies a +promontory above the same broad sandstone ledge that forms such a +conspicuous feature in the vicinity of Mashongnavi and Shupaulovi, and +which supports the buttes upon which these villages are built. + + [Illustration: Plate XXIV. Dance rock and kiva, Walpi.] + +Little masonry now remains on this site, but here and there a fragment +aids in defining the general plan of the pueblo. In general form the +village was a large rectangle with a line of buildings across its +center, dividing it into two unequal courts, and a projecting wing on +the west side. As may be seen from the illustration, one end of the ruin +forms a clearly defined rectangular court, composed of buildings mostly +two rooms deep. Here, as in other ruins of Tusayan, the arrangement +about inclosed courts is in contrast with the parallelism of rows, so +noticeable a feature in the occupied villages. At the east end of the +ruin are several curious excavations. The soft sandstone has been +hollowed out to a depth of about 10 inches, in prolongation of the +outlines of adjoining rooms. Such excavation to obtain level floors is +quite unusual among the pueblo builders; it was practiced to a very +small extent, and only where it could be done with little trouble. Any +serious inequality of surface was usually incorporated in the +construction, as will be noticed at Walpi (Pl. XXIII). Vestiges of +masonry indicating detached rooms were seen in each of the courts of the +main rectangle. + +On the slope of the hill, just above the broad ledge previously +described, there is a fine spring, but no trace of a trail connecting it +with the pueblo could be found. + +This village was advantageously placed for defense, but not to the same +degree as Payupki, illustrated in Pl. XIII. + +PAYUPKI. + +The ruin called Payupki (Pl. XIII) occupies the summit of a bold +promontory south of the trail, from Walpi to Oraibi, and about 6 miles +northwest from Mashongnavi. The outer extremity of this promontory is +separated from the mesa by a deep notch. The summit is reached from the +mesa by way of the neck, as the outer point itself is very abrupt, much +of the sandstone ledge being vertical. A bench, 12 or 15 feet below the +summit and in places quite broad, encircles the promontory. This bench +also breaks off very abruptly. + +As may be seen from the plan, the village is quite symmetrically laid +out and well arranged for defense. It is placed at the mesa end of the +promontory cap, and for greater security the second ledge has also been +fortified. All along the outer margin of this ledge are the remains of a +stone wall, in some places still standing to a height of 1 or 2 feet. +This wall appears to have extended originally all along the ledge around +three sides of the village. The steepness of the cliff on the remaining +side rendered a wall superfluous. On the plain below this promontory, +and immediately under the overhanging cliff, are two corrals, and also +the remains of a structure that resembles a kiva, but which appears to +be of recent construction. + +In the village proper (Pl. XIV) are two distinctly traceable kivas. One +of these, situated in the court, is detached and appears to have been +partly underground. The other, located in the southeast end of the +village, has also, like the first, apparently been sunk slightly below +the surface. There is a jog in the standing wall of this kiva which +corresponds to that usually found in the typical Tusayan kivas (see +Figs. 22 and 25). On the promontory and east of the village is a single +room of more than average length, with a well formed door in the center +of one side. This room has every appearance of being contemporary with +the rest of the village, but its occurrence in this entirely isolated +position is very unusual. Still farther east there is a mass of debris +that may have belonged to a cluster of six or eight rooms, or it may +possibly be the remains of temporary stone shelters for outlooks over +crops, built at a later date than the pueblo. As may be seen from the +illustration (Pl. XV), the walls are roughly built of large slabs of +sandstone of various sizes. The work is rather better than that of +modern Tusayan, but much inferior to that seen in the skillfully laid +masonry of the ruins farther north. In many of these walls an occasional +sandstone slab of great length is introduced. This peculiarity is +probably due to the character of the local material, which is more +varied than usual. All of the stone here used is taken from ledges in +the immediate vicinity. It is usually light in color and of loose +texture, crumbling readily, and subject to rapid decay, particularly +when used in walls that are roughly constructed. + +Much of the pottery scattered about this ruin has a very modern +appearance, some of it having the characteristic surface finish and +color of the Rio Grande ware. A small amount of ancient pottery also +occurs here, some of the fragments of black and white ware displaying +intricate fret patterns. The quantity of these potsherds is quite small, +and they occur mainly in the refuse heaps on the mesa edge. + +This ruin combines a clearly defined defensive plan with utilization of +one of the most inaccessible sites in the vicinity, producing altogether +a combination that would seem to have been impregnable by any of the +ordinary methods of Indian warfare. + + [Illustration: Plate XXV. Foot trail to Walpi.] + + +PLANS AND DESCRIPTIONS OF THE INHABITED VILLAGES. + +HANO. + +The village of Hano, or Tewa, is intrusive and does not properly belong +to the Tusayan stock, as appears from their own traditions. It is +somewhat loosely planned (Pl. XVI) and extends nearly across the mesa +tongue, which is here quite narrow, and in general there is no +appreciable difference between the arrangement here followed and that of +the other villages. One portion of the village, however, designated as +House No. 5 on the plan, differs somewhat from the typical arrangement +in long irregular rows, and approaches the pyramidal form found among +the more eastern pueblos, notably at Taos and in portions of Zuñi. As +has been seen, tradition tells us that this site was taken up by the +Tewa at a late date and subsequent to the Spanish conquest; but some +houses, formerly belonging to the Asa people, formed a nucleus about +which the Tewa village of Hano was constructed. The pyramidal house +occupied by the old governor, is said to have been built over such +remains of earlier houses. + +The largest building in the village appears to have been added to from +time to time as necessity for additional space arose, resulting in much +the same arrangement as that characterizing most of the Tusayan houses, +viz, a long, irregular row, not more than three stories high at any +point. The small range marked No. 4 on the plan contains a section three +stories high, as does the long row and also the pyramidal cluster above +referred to. (Pl. XVII.) + +The kivas are two in number, one situated within the village and the +other occupying a position in the margin of the mesa. These ceremonial +chambers, so far as observed, appear to be much like those in the other +villages, both in external and internal arrangement. + +Within the last few years the horse trail that afforded access to Hano +and Sichumovi has been converted into a wagon road, and during the +progress of this work, under the supervision of an American, +considerable blasting was done. Among other changes the marginal kiva, +which was nearly in line with the proposed improvements, was removed. +This was done despite the protest of the older men, and their +predictions of dire calamity sure to follow such sacrilege. A new site +was selected close by and the newly acquired knowledge of the use of +powder was utilized in blasting out the excavation for this subterranean +chamber. It is altogether probable that the sites of all former kivas +were largely determined by accident, these rooms being built at points +where natural fissures or open spaces in the broken mesa edge furnished +a suitable depression or cavity. The builders were not capable of +working the stone to any great extent, and their operations were +probably limited to trimming out such natural excavations and in part +lining them with masonry. + +There is a very noticeable scarcity of roof-holes, aside from those of +the first terrace. As a rule the first terrace has no external openings +on the ground and is entered from its roof through large trap-doors, as +shown on the plans. The lower rooms within this first terrace are not +inhabited, but are used as storerooms. + +At several points ruined walls are seen, remains of abandoned rooms that +have fallen into decay. Occasionally a rough, buttress-like projection +from a wall is the only vestige of a room or a cluster of rooms, all +traces on the ground having been obliterated. + +The mesa summit, that forms the site of this village, is nearly level, +with very little earth on its surface. A thin accumulation of soil and +rubbish lightly covers the inner court, but outside, along the face of +the long row, the bare rock is exposed continuously. Where the rooms +have been abandoned and the walls have fallen, the stones have all been +utilized in later constructions, leaving no vestige of the former wall +on the rocky site, as the stones of the masonry have always been set +upon the surface of the rock, with no excavation or preparation of +footings of any kind. + +SICHUMOVI. + +According to traditional accounts this village was founded at a more +recent date than Walpi. It has, however, undergone many changes since +its first establishment. + +The principal building is a long irregular row, similar to that of Hano +(Pl. XVIII). A portion of an L-shaped cluster west of this row, and a +small row near it parallel to the main building, form a rude +approximation to the inclosed court arrangement. The terracing here, +however, is not always on the court side, whereas in ancient examples +such arrangement was an essential defensive feature, as the court +furnished the only approach to upper terraces. In all of these villages +there is a noticeable tendency to face the rows eastward instead of +toward the court. The motive of such uniformity of direction in the +houses must have been strong, to counteract the tendency to adhere to +the ancient arrangement. The two kivas of the village are built side by +side, in contact, probably on account of the presence at this point of a +favorable fissure or depression in the mesa surface. + +On the south side of the village are the remains of two small clusters +of rooms that apparently have been abandoned a long time. A portion of a +room still bounded by standing walls has been utilized as a corral for +burros (PL. XIX). + + [Illustration: Plate XXVI. Mashongnavi, plan.] + +At this village are three small detached houses, each composed of but a +single room, a feature not at all in keeping with the spirit of pueblo +construction. In this instance it is probably due to the selection of +the village as the residence of whites connected with the agency or +school. Of these single-room houses, one, near the south end of the long +row, was being built by an American, who was living in another such +house near the middle of this row. The third house, although fairly well +preserved at the time of the survey, was abandoned and falling into +ruin. Adjoining the middle one of these three buildings on the south +side are the outlines of two small compartments, which were evidently +built as corrals for burros and are still used for that purpose. + +This village, though limited to two stories in height, has, like the +others of the first mesa, a number of roof holes or trapdoors in the +upper story, an approach to the Zuñi practice. This feature among the +Tusayan villages is probably due to intercourse with the more eastern +pueblos, for it seems to occur chiefly among those having such +communication most frequently. Its presence is probably the result +simply of borrowing a convenient feature from those who invented it to +meet a necessity. The conditions under which the houses were built have +hardly been such as to stimulate the Tusayan to the invention of such a +device. The uniform height of the second-story roofs seen in this +village, constituting an almost unbroken level, is a rather exceptional +feature in pueblo architecture. Only one depression occurs in the whole +length of the main row. + +WALPI. + +Of all the pueblos, occupied or in ruins, within the provinces of +Tusayan and Cibola, Walpi exhibits the widest departure from the typical +pueblo arrangement (Pl. XX). + +The carelessness characteristic of Tusayan architecture seems to have +reached its culmination here. The confused arrangement of the rooms, +mainly due to the irregularities of the site, contrasts with the work at +some of the other villages, and bears no comparison with much of the +ancient work. The rooms seem to have been clustered together with very +little regard to symmetry, and right angles are very unusual. (See Fig. +8.) + +The general plan of the village of to-day confirms the traditional +accounts of its foundation. According to these its growth was gradual, +beginning with a few small clusters, which were added to from time to +time as the inhabitants of the lower site upon the spur of the mesa, +where the mission was established, moved up and joined the pioneers on +the summit. It is probable that some small rooms or clusters were built +on this conspicuous promontory soon after the first occupation of this +region, on account of its exceptionally favorable position as an outlook +over the fields (Pl. XXI). + +Though the peculiar conformation of the site on which the village has +been built has produced an unusual irregularity of arrangement, yet even +here an imperfect example of the typical inclosed court may be found, +at one point containing the principal kiva or ceremonial chamber of the +village. It is probable that the accidental occurrence of a suitable +break or depression in the mesa top determined the position of this kiva +at an early date and that the first buildings clustered about this +point. + + [Illustration: Fig. 8. Topography of the site of Walpi.] + +A unique feature in this kiva is its connection with a second +subterranean chamber, reached from the kiva through an ordinary doorway. +The depression used for the kiva site must have been either larger than +was needed or of such form that it could not be thrown into one +rectangular chamber. It was impossible to ascertain the form of this +second room, as the writer was not permitted to approach the connecting +doorway, which was closed with a slab of cottonwood. This chamber, used +as a receptacle for religious paraphernalia, was said to connect with an +upper room within the cluster of dwellings close by, but this could not +be verified at the time of our visit. The plan indicates that such an +adjoining chamber, if of average size, could easily extend partly under +the dwellings on either the west or south side of the court. The rocky +mesa summit is quite irregular in this vicinity, with rather an abrupt +ascent to the passageway on the south as shown in Pl. XXII. Southeast +from the kiva there is a large mass of rocks projecting above the +general level, which has been incorporated into a cluster of dwelling +rooms. Its character and relation to the architecture may be seen in Pl. +XXIII. So irregular a site was not likely to be built upon until most of +the available level surface had been taken up, for even in masonry of +much higher development than can be found in Tusayan the builders, +unable to overcome such obstacles as a large mass of protruding rock, +have accommodated their buildings to such irregularities. This is very +noticeable in the center cluster of Mummy Cave (in Canyon del Muerto, +Arizona), where a large mass of sandstone, fallen from the roof of the +rocky niche in which the houses were built, has been incorporated into +the house cluster. Between this and another kiva to the north the mesa +top is nearly level. The latter kiva is also subterranean and was built +in an accidental break in sandstone. On the very margin of this fissure +stands a curious isolated rock that has survived the general erosion of +the mesa. It is near this rock that the celebrated Snake-dance takes +place, although the kiva from which the dancers emerge to perform the +open air ceremony is not adjacent to this monument (Pl. XXIV). + + [Illustration: Plate XXVII. Mashongnavi with Shupaulovi in distance.] + +A short distance farther toward the north occur a group of three more +kivas. These are on the very brink of the mesa, and have been built in +recesses in the crowning ledge of sandstone of such size that they could +conveniently be walled up on the outside, the outer surface of rude +walls being continuous with the precipitous rock face of the mesa. + +The positions of all these ceremonial chambers seem to correspond with +exceptionally rough and broken portions of the mesa top, showing that +their location in relation to the dwelling clusters was due largely to +accident and does not possess the significance that position does in +many ancient pueblos built on level and unencumbered sites, where the +adjustment was not controlled by the character of the surface. + +The Walpi promontory is so abrupt and difficult of access that there is +no trail by which horses can be brought to the village without passing +through Hano and Sichumovi, traversing the whole length of the mesa +tongue, and crossing a rough break or depression in the mesa summit +close to the village. Several foot trails give access to the village, +partly over the nearly perpendicular faces of rock. All of these have +required to be artificially improved in order to render them +practicable. Plate XXV, from a photograph, illustrates one of these +trails, which, a portion of the way, leads up between a huge detached +slab of sandstone and the face of the mesa. It will be seen that the +trail at this point consists to a large extent of stone steps that have +been built in. At the top of the flight of steps where the trail to the +mesa summit turns to the right the solid sandstone has been pecked out +so as to furnish a series of footholes, or steps, with no projection or +hold of any kind alongside. There are several trails on the west side of +the mesa leading down both from Walpi and Sichúmovi to a spring below, +which are quite as abrupt as the example illustrated. All the water used +in these villages, except such as is caught during showers in the +basin-like water pockets of the mesa top, is laboriously brought up +these trails in large earthenware canteens slung over the backs of the +women. + +Supplies of every kind, provisions, harvested crops, fuel, etc., are +brought up these steep trails, and often from a distance of several +miles, yet these conservative people tenaciously cling to the +inconvenient situation selected by their fathers long after the +necessity for so doing has passed away. At present no argument of +convenience or comfort seems sufficient to induce them to abandon their +homes on the rocky heights and build near the water supply and the +fields on which they depend for subsistence. + +One of the trails referred to in the description of Hano has been +converted into a wagon road, as has been already described. The Indians +preferred to expend the enormous amount of labor necessary to convert +this bridle path into a wagon road in order slightly to overcome the +inconvenience of transporting every necessary to the mesa upon their own +backs or by the assistance of burros. This concession to modern ideas is +at best but a poor substitute for the convenience of homes built in the +lower valleys. + + [Illustration: Fig. 9. Mashongnavi and Shupaulovi from Shumopavi.] + +MASHONGNAVI. + +Mashongnavi, situated on the summit of a rocky knoll, is a compact +though irregular village, and the manner in which it conforms to the +general outline of the available ground is shown on the plan. +Convenience of access to the fields on the east and to the other +villages probably prompted the first occupation of the east end of this +rocky butte (Pl. XXVI). + + [Illustration: Plate XXVIII. Back wall of a Mashongnavi house-row.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 10. Diagram showing growth of Mashongnavi.] + +In Mashongnavi of to-day the eastern portion of the village forms a more +decided court than do the other portions. The completeness in itself of +this eastern end of the pueblo, in connection with the form of the +adjoining rows, strongly suggests that this was the first portion of the +pueblo built, although examination of the masonry and construction +furnish but imperfect data as to the relative age of different portions +of the village. One uniform gray tint, with only slight local variations +in character and finish of masonry, imparts a monotonous effect of +antiquity to the whole mass of dwellings. Here and there, at rare +intervals, is seen a wall that has been newly plastered; but, +ordinarily, masonry of 10 years' age looks nearly as old as that built +200 years earlier. Another feature that suggests the greater antiquity +of the eastern court of the pueblo is the presence and manner of +occurrence here of the kiva. The old builders may have been influenced +to some extent in their choice of site by the presence of a favorable +depression for the construction of a kiva, though this particular +example of the ceremonial room is only partly subterranean. The other +kivas are almost or quite below the ground level. Although a favorable +depression might readily occur on the summit of the knoll, a deep +cavity, suitable for the construction of the subterranean kiva, would +not be likely to occur at such a distance from the margin of the +sandstone ledge. The builders evidently preferred to adopt such half-way +measures with their first kiva in order to secure its inclosure within +the court, thus conforming to the typical pueblo arrangement. The +numerous exceptions to this arrangement seen in Tusayan are due to local +causes. The general view of Mashongnavi given in Pl. XXVII shows that +the site of this pueblo, as well as that of its neighbor, Shupaulovi, +was not particularly defensible, and that this fact would have weight in +securing adherence in the first portion of the pueblo built to the +defensive inclosed court containing the ceremonial chamber. The plan +strongly indicates that the other courts of the pueblo were added as the +village grew, each added row facing toward the back of an older row, +producing a series of courts, which, to the present time, show more +terracing on their western sides. The eastern side of each court is +formed, apparently, by a few additions of low rooms to what was +originally an unbroken exterior wall, and which is still clearly +traceable through these added rooms. Such an exterior wall is +illustrated in Pl. XVIII. This process continued until the last cluster +nearly filled the available site and a wing was thrown out corresponding +to a tongue or spur of the knoll upon which it was built. Naturally the +westernmost or newer portions show more clearly the evidence of +additions and changes, but such evidence is not wholly wanting in the +older portions. The large row that bounds the original eastern court on +the west side may be seen on the plan to be of unusual width, having the +largest number of rooms that form a terrace with western aspect; yet the +nearly straight line once defining the original back wall of the court +inclosing cluster on this side has not been obscured to any great extent +by the later additions (Pl. XXVIII). This village furnishes the most +striking example in the whole group of the manner in which a pueblo was +gradually enlarged as increasing population demanded more space. Such +additions were often carried out on a definite plan, although the +results in Tusayan fall far short of the symmetry that characterizes +many ruined pueblos in New Mexico and Arizona. + + [Illustration: Fig. 11. Diagram showing growth of Mashongnavi.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 12. Diagram showing growth of Mashongnavi.] + + [Illustration: Plate XXIX. West side of a principal row in + Mashongnavi.] + +A few of these ancient examples, especially some of the smaller ruins of +the Chaco group, are so symmetrical in their arrangement that they seem +to be the result of a single effort to carry out a clearly fixed plan. +By far the largest number of pueblos, however, built among the southwest +tablelands, if occupied for any length of time, must have been subject +to irregular enlargement. In some ancient examples, such additions to +the first plan undoubtedly took place without marring the general +symmetry. This was the case at Pueblo Bonito, on the Chaco, where the +symmetrical and even curve of the exterior defensive wall, which was at +least four stories high, remained unbroken, while the large inclosed +court was encroached upon by wings added to the inner terraces. These +additions comfortably provided for a very large increase of population +after the first building of the pueblo, without changing its exterior +appearance. + +In order to make clearer this order of growth in Mashongnavi, a series +of skeleton diagrams is added in Figs. 10, 11, and 12, giving the +outlines of the pueblo at various supposed periods in the course of its +enlargement. The larger plan of the village (Pl. XXVI) serves as a key +to these terrace outlines. + +The first diagram illustrates the supposed original cluster of the east +court (Fig. 10), the lines of which can be traced on the larger plan, +and it includes the long, nearly straight line that marks the western +edge of the third story. This diagram shows also, in dotted lines, the +general plan that may have guided the first additions to the west. The +second diagram (Fig. 11) renders all the above material in full tint, +again indicating further additions by dotted lines, and so on. (Fig. +12.) The portions of a terrace, which face westward in the newer courts +of the pueblo, illustrated in Pl. XXIX, were probably built after the +western row, completing the inclosure, and were far enough advanced to +indicate definitely an inclosed court, upon which the dwelling rooms +faced. + + [Illustration: Plate XXX. Plan of Shupaulovi.] + +SHUPAULOVI. + +This village, by far the smallest pueblo of the Tusayan group, +illustrates a simple and direct use of the principle of the inclosed +court. The plan (Pl. XXX) shows that the outer walls are scarcely broken +by terraces, and nearly all the dwelling apartments open inwards upon +the inclosure, in this respect closely following the previously +described ancient type, although widely differing from it in the +irregular disposition of the rooms. (Pl. XXXI) A comparison with the +first of the series of diagrams illustrating the growth of Mashóngnavi, +will show how similar the villages may have been at one stage, and how +suitable a nucleus for a large pueblo this village would prove did space +and character of the site permit. Most of the available summit of the +rocky knoll has already been covered, as will be seen from the +topographic sketch of the site (Fig. 13). The plan shows also that some +efforts at extension of the pueblo have been made, but the houses +outside of the main cluster have been abandoned, and are rapidly going +to ruin. Several small rooms occur on the outer faces of the rows, but +it can be readily seen that they do not form a part of the original plan +but were added to an already complete structure. + + [Illustration: Fig. 13. Topography of the site of Shupaulovi.] + +In the inclosed court of this pueblo occurs a small box-like stone +inclosure, covered with a large slab, which is used as a sort of shrine +or depository for the sacred plume sticks and other ceremonial +offerings. This feature is found at some of the other villages, notably +at Mashongnavi, in the central court, and at Hano, where it is located +at some distance outside of the village, near the main trail to the +mesa. + +The plan of this small village shows three covered passageways similar +to those noted in Walpi on the first mesa, though their presence here +can not be ascribed to the same motives that impelled the Walpi to build +in this way; for the densely crowded site occupied by the latter +compelled them to resort to this expedient. One of these is illustrated +in Pl. XXXII. Its presence may be due in this instance to a +determination to adhere to the protected court while seeking to secure +convenient means of access to the inclosed area. It is remarkable that +this, the smallest of the group, should contain this feature. + +This village has but two kivas, one of which is on the rocky summit near +the houses and the other on the lower ground near the foot of the trail +that leads to the village. The upper kiva is nearly subterranean, the +roof being but a little above the ground on the side toward the village, +but as the rocky site slopes away a portion of side wall is exposed. +This was roughly built, with no attempt to impart finish to its outer +face, either by careful laying of the masonry or by plastering. Pl. +XXXIII illustrates this kiva in connection with the southeastern portion +of the village. The plan shows how the prolongation of the side rows of +the village forms a suggestion of a second court. Its development into +any such feature as the secondary or additional courts of Mashóngnavi +was prohibited by the restricted site. + +As in other villages of this group, the desire to adhere to the +subterranean form of ceremonial chamber outweighed the inducement to +place it within the village, or, in the case of the second kiva, even of +placing it on the same level as the houses, which are 30 feet above it +with an abrupt trail between them. It is curious and instructive to see +a room, the use of which is so intimately connected with the inner life +of the village, placed in such a comparatively remote and inaccessible +position through an intensely conservative adherence to ancient practice +requiring this chamber to be depressed. + + [Illustration: Plate XXXI. View of Shupaulovi.] + +The general view of the village given in Pl. XXXI strikingly illustrates +the blending of the rectangular forms of the architecture with the +angular and sharply defined fractures of the surrounding rock. This +close correspondence in form between the architecture and its immediate +surroundings is greatly heightened by the similarity in color. Mr. +Stephen has called attention to a similar effect on the western side of +Walpi and its adjacent mesa edge, which he thought indicates a distinct +effort at concealment on the part of the builders, by blending the +architecture with the surroundings. This similarity of effect is often +accidental, and due to the fact that the materials of the houses and of +the mesas on which they are built are identical. Even in the case of +Walpi, cited by Mr. Stephen, where the buildings come to the very mesa +edge, and in their vertical lines appear to carry out the effect of the +vertical fissures in the upper benches of sandstone, there was no +intentional concealment. It is more likely that, through the necessity +of building close to the limits of the crowded sites, a certain degree +of correspondence was unintentionally produced between the jogs and +angles of the houses and those of the mesa edge. + +Such correspondence with the surroundings, which forms a striking +feature of many primitive types of construction where intention of +concealment had no part, is doubtless mainly due to the use of the most +available material, although the expression of a type of construction +that has prevailed for ages in one locality would perhaps be somewhat +influenced by constantly recurring forms in its environment. In the +system of building under consideration, such influence would, however, +be a very minute fraction in the sum of factors producing the type and +could never account for such examples of special and detailed +correspondence as the cases cited, nor could it have any weight in +developing a rectangular type of architecture. + +In the development of primitive arts the advances are slow and +laborious, and are produced by adding small increments to current +knowledge. So vague and undefined an influence as that exerted by the +larger forms of surrounding nature are seldom recognized and +acknowledged by the artisan; on the contrary, experiments, resulting in +improvement, are largely prompted by practical requirements. +Particularly is this the case in the art of house-building. + +SHUMOPAVI. + +This village, although not so isolated as Oraibi, has no near neighbors +and is little visited by whites or Indians. The inhabitants are rarely +seen at the trading post to which the others resort, and they seem to be +pretty well off and independent as compared with their neighbors of the +other villages (Pl. XXXIV). The houses and courts are in keeping with +the general character of the people and exhibit a degree of neatness and +thrift that contrasts sharply with the tumble-down appearance of some of +the other villages, especially those of the Middle Mesa and Oraibi. +There is a general air of newness about the place, though it is +questionable whether the architecture is more recent than that of the +other villages of Tusayan. This effect is partly due to the custom of +frequently renewing the coating of mud plaster. In most of the villages +little care is taken to repair the houses until the owner feels that to +postpone such action longer would endanger its stability. Many of the +illustrations in this chapter indicate the proportion of rough masonry +usually exposed in the walls. At Shumopavi (Pl. XXXV), however, most of +the walls are smoothly plastered. In this respect they resemble Zuñi and +the eastern pueblos, where but little naked masonry can be seen. Another +feature that adds to the effect of neatness and finish in this village +is the frequent use of a whitewash of gypsum on the outer face of the +walls. This wash is used partly as an ornament and partly as protection +against the rain. The material, called by the Mexicans "yeso," is very +commonly used in the interior of their houses throughout this region, +both by Mexicans and Indians. More rarely it is used among the pueblos +as an external wash. Here, however, its external use forms quite a +distinctive feature of the village. The same custom in several of the +cliff houses of Canyon de Chelly attests the comparative antiquity of +the practice, though not necessarily its pre-Columbian origin. + +Shumopavi, compared with the other villages, shows less evidence of +having been built on the open court idea, as the partial inclosures +assume such elongated forms in the direction of the long, straight rows +of the rooms; yet examination shows that the idea was present to a +slight extent. + +At the southeast corner of the pueblo there is a very marked approach to +the open court, though it is quite evident that the easternmost row has +its back to the court, and that the few rooms that face the other way +are later additions. In fact, the plan of the village and the +distribution of the terraces seem to indicate that the first +construction consisted only of a single row facing nearly east, and was +not an inclosed court, and that a further addition to the pueblo assumed +nearly the same form, with its face or terraced side toward the back of +the first row only partly adapting itself by the addition of a few small +rooms later, to the court arrangement, the same operation being +continued, but in a form not so clearly defined, still farther toward +the west. + +The second court is not defined on the west by such a distinct row as +the others, and the smaller clusters that to some extent break the long, +straight arrangement bring about an approximation to a court, though +here again the terraces only partly face it, the eastern side being +bounded by the long exterior wall of the middle row, two and three +stories high, and almost unbroken throughout its entire length of 400 +feet. The broken character of the small western row, in conjunction with +the clusters near it, imparts a distinct effect to the plan of this +portion, differentiating it in character from the masses of houses +formed by the other two rows. The latter are connected at their southern +end by a short cross row which converts this portion of the village +practically into a single large house. Two covered passageways, however, +which are designated on the plan, give access to the southeast portion +of the court. This portion is partly separated from the north half of +the inclosure by encroaching groups of rooms. This partial division of +the original narrow and long court appears to be of later date. + + [Illustration: Plate XXXII. A covered passageway of Shupaulovi.] + +The kivas are four in number, of which but one is within the village. +The latter occupies a partly inclosed position in the southwest portion, +and probably owes its place to some local facility for building a kiva +on this spot in the nature of a depression in the mesa summit; but even +with such aid the ceremonial chamber was built only partly under ground, +as may be seen in Fig. 14. The remaining three kivas are more distinctly +subterranean, and in order to obtain a suitable site one of these was +located at a distance of more than 200 feet from the village, toward the +mesa edge on the east. The other two are built very close together, +apparently in contact, just beyond the northern extremity of the +village. One of these is about 3 feet above the surface at one corner, +but nearly on a level with the ground at its western side where it +adjoins its neighbor. These two kivas are illustrated in Pl. LXXXVIII +and Fig. 21. + + [Illustration: Fig. 14. Court kiva of Shumopavi.] + +Here again we find that the ceremonial chamber that forms so important a +feature among these people, occupies no fixed relation to the dwellings, +and its location is largely a matter of accident, a site that would +admit of the partial excavation or sinking of the chamber below the +surface being the main requisite. The northwest court contains another +of the small inclosed shrines already described as occurring at +Shupaulovi and elsewhere. + +The stonework of this village also possesses a somewhat distinctive +character. Exposed masonry, though comparatively rare in this +well-plastered pueblo, shows that stones of suitable fracture were +selected and that they were more carefully laid than in the other +villages. In places the masonry bears a close resemblance to some of the +ancient work, where the spaces between the longer tablets of stone were +carefully chinked with small bits of stone, bringing the whole wall to a +uniform face, and is much in advance of the ordinary slovenly methods of +construction followed in Tusayan. + +Shumopavi is the successor of an older village of that name, one of the +cities of the ancient Tusayan visited by a detachment of Coronado's +expedition in 1540. The ruins of that village still exist, and they +formerly contained vestiges of the old church and mission buildings +established by the monks. The squared beams from, these buildings were +considered valuable enough to be incorporated in the construction of +ceremonial kivas in some of the Tusayan villages. This old site was not +visited by the party. + +ORAIBI. + +This is one of the largest modern pueblos, and contains nearly half the +population of Tusayan; yet its great size has not materially affected +the arrangement of the dwellings. The general plan (see Pl. XXXVI), +simply shows an unusually large collection of typical Tusayan +house-rows, with the general tendency to face eastward displayed in the +other villages of the group. There is a remarkable uniformity in the +direction of the rows, but there are no indications of the order in +which the successive additions to the village were made, such as were +found at Mashóngnavi. + +The clusters of rooms do not surpass the average dimensions of those in +the smaller villages. In five of the clusters in Oraibi a height of four +stories is reached by a few rooms; a height seen also in Walpi. + +At several points in Oraibi, notably on the west side of cluster No. 7, +may be seen what appears to be low terraces faced with rough masonry. +The same thing is also seen at Walpi, on the west side of the +northernmost cluster. This effect is produced by the gradual filling in +of abandoned and broken-down marginal houses, with fallen masonry and +drifted sand. The appearance is that of intentional construction, as may +be seen in Pl. XXXIX. + + [Illustration: Plate XXXIII. The chief kiva of Shupaulovi.] + +The rarity of covered passageways in this village is noteworthy, and +emphasizes the marked difference in the character of the Tusayan and +Zuñi ground plans. The close crowding of rooms in the latter has made a +feature of the covered way, which in the scattered plan of Oraibi is +rarely called for. When found it does not seem an outgrowth of the same +conditions that led to its adoption in Zuñi. A glance at the plans will +show how different has been the effect of the immediate environment in +the two cases. In Zuñi, built on a very slight knoll in the open plain, +the absence of a defensive site has produced unusual development of the +defensive features of the architecture, and the result is a remarkably +dense clustering of the dwellings. At Tusayan, on the other hand, the +largest village of the group does not differ in character from the +smallest. Occupation of a defensive site has there, in a measure taken +the place of a special defensive arrangement, or close clustering of +rooms. Oraibi is laid out quite as openly as any other of the group, and +as additions to its size have from time to time been made the builders +have, in the absence of the defensive motive for crowding the rows or +groups into large clusters, simply followed the usual arrangement. The +crowding that brought about the use of the covered way was due in Walpi +to restricted site, as nearly all the available summit of its rocky +promontory has been covered with buildings. In Zuñi, on the other hand, +it was the necessity for defense that led to the close clustering of the +dwellings and the consequent employment of the covered way. + +A further contrast between the general plans of Oraibi and Zuñi is +afforded in the different manner in which the roof openings have been +employed in the two cases. The plan of Zuñi, Pl. LXXVI, shows great +numbers of small openings, nearly all of which are intended exclusively +for the admission of light, a few only being provided with ladders. In +Oraibi, on the other hand, there are only seventeen roof openings above +the first terrace, and of these not more than half are intended for the +admission of light. The device is correspondingly rare in other villages +of the group, particularly in those west of the first mesa. In +Mashóngnavi the restricted use of the roof openings is particularly +noticeable; they all are of the same type as those used for access to +first terrace rooms. There is but one roof opening in a second story. An +examination of the plan, Pl. XXX, will show that in Shupaúlovi but two +such openings occur above the first terrace, and in the large village of +Shumopavi, Pl. XXXIV, only about eight. None of the smaller villages can +be fairly compared with Zuñi in the employment of this feature, but in +Oraibi we should expect to find its use much more general, were it not +for the fact that the defensive site has taken the place of the close +clustering of rooms seen in the exposed village of Zuñi, and, in +consequence, the devices for the admission of light still adhere to the +more primitive arrangement (Pls. XL and XLI). + +The highest type of pueblo construction, embodied in the large communal +fortress houses of the valleys, could have developed only as the +builders learned to rely for protection more upon their architecture and +less upon the sites occupied. So long as the sites furnished a large +proportion of the defensive efficiency of a village, the invention of +the builders was not stimulated to substitute artificial for natural +advantages. Change of location and consequent development must +frequently have taken place owing to the extreme inconvenience of +defensive sites to the sources of subsistence. + +The builders of large valley pueblos must frequently have been forced to +resort hastily to defensive sites on finding that the valley towns were +unfitted to withstand attack. This seems to have been the case with the +Tusayan; but that the Zuñi have adhered to their valley pueblo through +great difficulties is clearly attested by the internal evidence of the +architecture itself, even were other testimony altogether wanting. + +MOEN-KOPI. + +About 50 miles west from Oraibi is a small settlement used by a few +families from Oraibi during the farming season, known as Moen-kopi. (Pl. +XLIII). The present village is comparatively recent, but, as is the case +with many others, it has been built over the remains of an older +settlement. It is said to have been founded within the memory of some of +the Mormon pioneers at the neighboring town of Tuba City, named after an +old Oraibi chief, recently deceased. + +The site would probably have attracted a much larger number of settlers, +had it not been so remote from the main pueblos of the province, as in +many respects it far surpasses any of the present village sites. A large +area of fertile soil can be conveniently irrigated from copious springs +in the side of a small branch of the Moen-kopi wash. The village +occupies a low, rounded knoll at the junction of this branch with the +main wash, which on the opposite or southern side is quite precipitous. +The gradual encroachments of the Mormons for the last twenty years have +had some effect in keeping the Tusayan from more fully utilizing the +advantages of this site (Pl. XLII). + +Moen-kopi is built in two irregular rows of one-story houses. There are +also two detached single rooms in the village--one of them built for a +kiva, though apparently not in use at the time of our survey, and the +other a small room with its principal door facing an adjoining row. The +arrangement is about the same that prevails in the other villages, the +rows having distinct back walls of rude masonry. + +Rough stone work predominates also in the fronts of the houses, though +it is occasionally brought to a fair degree of finish. Some adobe work +is incorporated in the masonry, and at one point a new and still +unroofed room was seen built of adobe bricks on a stone foundation about +a foot high. There is but little adobe masonry, however, in Tusayan. Its +use in this case is probably due to Mormon influence. + + [Illustration: Plate XXXIV. Plan of Shumopavi.] + +Moen-kopi was the headquarters of a large business enterprise of the +Mormons a number of years ago. They attempted to concentrate the product +of the Navajo wool trade at this point and to establish here a +completely appointed woolen mill. Water was brought from a series of +reservoirs built in a small valley several miles away, and was conducted +to a point on the Moen-kopi knoll, near the end of the south row of +houses, where the ditch terminated in a solidly constructed box of +masonry. From this in turn the water was delivered through a large pipe +to a turbine wheel, which furnished the motive power for the works. The +ditch and masonry are shown on the ground plan of the village (Pl. +XLIII). This mill was a large stone building, and no expense was spared +in fitting it up with the most complete machinery. At the time of our +visit the whole establishment had been abandoned for some years and was +rapidly going to decay. The frames had been torn from the windows, and +both the floor of the building and the ground in its vicinity were +strewn with fragments of expensive machinery, broken cog-wheels, shafts, +etc. This building is shown in Pl. XLV, and may serve as an illustration +of the contrast between Tusayan masonry and modern stonemason's work +carried out with the same material. The comparison, however, is not +entirely fair, as applied to the pueblo builders in general, as the +Tusayan mason is unusually careless in his work. Many old examples are +seen in which the finish of the walls compares very favorably with the +American mason's work, though the result is attained in a wholly +different manner, viz, by close and careful chinking with numberless +small tablets of stone. This process brings the wall to a remarkably +smooth and even surface, the joints almost disappearing in the +mosaic-like effect of the wall mass. The masonry of Moen-kopi is more +than ordinarily rough, as the small village was probably built hastily +and used for temporary occupation as a farming center. In the winter the +place is usually abandoned, the few families occupying it during the +farming months returning to Oraibi for the season of festivities and +ceremonials. + + + + +CHAPTER III. + +RUINS AND INHABITED VILLAGES OF CIBOLA. + + +PHYSICAL FEATURES OF THE PROVINCE. + +Though the surroundings of the Cibolan pueblos and ruins exhibit the +ordinary characteristics of plateau scenery, they have not the +monotonous and forbidding aspect that characterizes the mesas and +valleys of Tusayan. The dusty sage brush and the stunted cedar and +piñon, as in Tusayan, form a conspicuous feature of the landscape, but +the cliffs are often diversified in color, being in cases composed of +alternating bands of light gray and dark red sandstone, which impart a +considerable variety of tints to the landscape. The contrast is +heightened by the proximity of the Zuñi Mountains, an extensive +timber-bearing range that approaches within 12 miles of Zuñi, narrowing +down the extent of the surrounding arid region. + +Cibola has also been more generously treated by nature in the matter of +water supply, as the province contains a perennial stream which has its +sources near the village of Nutria, and, flowing past the pueblo of +Zuñi, disappears a few miles below. During the rainy season the river +empties into the Colorado Chiquito. The Cibolan pueblos are built on the +foothills of mesas or in open valley sites, surrounded by broad fields, +while the Tusayan villages are perched upon mesa promontories that +overlook the valley lands used for cultivation. + + +PLANS AND DESCRIPTIONS OF RUINS. + +HAWIKUH. + +The village of Hawikuh, situated about 15 miles to the south of Zuñi, +consisted of irregular groups of densely clustered cells, occupying the +point of a spur projecting from a low rounded hill. The houses are in +such a ruined condition that few separate rooms can be traced, and these +are much obscured by débris. This débris covers the entire area +extending down the east slope of the hill to the site of the church. The +large amount of débris and the comparative thinness of such walls as are +found suggest that the dwellings had been densely clustered, and carried +to the height of several stories. Much of the space between the village +on the hill and the site of the Spanish church on the plain at its foot +is covered with masonry débris, part of which has slid down from above +(Pl. XLVI). + + [Illustration: Plate XXXV. View of Shumopavi.] + +The arrangement suggests a large principal court of irregular form. The +surrounding clusters are very irregularly disposed, the directions of +the prevailing lines of walls greatly varying in different groups. There +is a suggestion also of several smaller courts, as well as of alleyways +leading to the principal one. + +The church, built on the plain below at a distance of about 200 feet +from the main village, seems to have been surrounded by several groups +of rooms and inclosures of various sizes, differing somewhat in +character from those within the village. These groups are scattered and +open, and the small amount of debris leads to the conclusion that this +portion of the village was not more than a single story in height. (Pl. +XLVII.) + +The destruction of the village has been so complete that no vestige of +constructional details remains, with the exception of a row of posts in +a building near the church. The governor of Zuñi stated that these posts +were part of a projecting porch similar to those seen in connection with +modern houses. (See Pls. LXXI, LXXV.) Suggestions of this feature are +met with at other points on the plain, but they all occur within the +newer portion of the village around the church. Some of the larger +inclosures in this portion of the village were very lightly constructed, +and cover large areas. They were probably used as corrals. Inclosures +for this purpose occur at other pueblos traditionally ascribed to the +same age. + +The church in this village was constructed of adobe bricks, without the +introduction of any stonework. The bricks appear to have been molded +with an unusual degree of care. The massive angles of the northwest, or +altar end of the structure, have survived the stonework of the adjoining +village and stand to-day 13 feet high. (Pl. XLVIII.) + +KETCHIPAUAN. + +The small village of Ketchipauan appears to have been arranged about two +courts of unequal dimensions. It is difficult to determine, however, how +much of the larger court, containing the stone church, is of later +construction. (Pl. XLIX.) + +All the northwest portion of the village is now one large inclosure or +corral, whose walls have apparently been built of the fallen masonry +from the surrounding houses, leaving the central space clear. This wall +on the northeast side of the large inclosure apparently follows the jogs +and angles of the original houses. This may have been the outer line of +rooms, as traces of buildings occur for some distance within it. On the +opposite side the wall is nearly continuous, the jogs being of slight +projection. Here some traces of dwellings occur outside of the wall in +places to a depth of three rooms. The same thing occurs also at the +north corner. The continuation of these lines suggests a rectangular +court of considerable size, bounded symmetrically by groups of +compartments averaging three rooms deep. (Pl. L.) + +Several much smaller inclosures made in the same way occur in the +village, but they apparently do not conform to the original courts. + +At the present time dwelling rooms are traceable over a portion of the +area south and west of the church. As shown on the plan, upright posts +occasionally occur. These appear to have been incorporated into the +original walls, but the latter are so ruined that this can not be stated +positively, as such posts have sometimes been incorporated in modern +corral walls. In places they suggest the balcony-like feature seen in +modern houses, as in Hawikuh, but in the east portion of the pueblo they +are irregularly scattered about the rooms. A considerable area on the +west side of the ruin is covered with loosely scattered stones, +affording no suggestions of a ground plan. They do not seem sufficient +in amount to be the remains of dwelling rooms. + +The Spanish church in this pueblo was built of stone, but the walls were +much more massive than those of the dwellings. The building is well +preserved, most of the walls standing 8 or 10 feet high, and in places +14 feet. This church was apparently built by Indian labor, as the walls +everywhere show the chinking with small stones characteristic of the +native work. In this village also, the massive Spanish construction has +survived the dwelling houses. + +The ground plan of the church shows that the openings were splayed in +the thickness of the walls, at an angle of about 45°. In the doorway, in +the east end of the building, the greater width of the opening is on the +inside, a rather unusual arrangement; in the window, on the north side, +this arrangement is reversed, the splay being outward. On the south side +are indications of a similar opening, but at the present time the wall +is so broken out that no well defined jamb can be traced, and it is +impossible to determine whether the splayed opening was used or not. The +stones of the masonry are laid with extreme care at the angles and in +the faces of these splays, producing a highly finished effect. + +The position of the beam-holes on the inner face of the wall suggests +that the floor of the church had been raised somewhat above the ground, +and that there may have been a cellar-like space under it. No beams are +now found, however, and no remains of wood are seen in the "altar" end +of the church. At the present time there are low partitions dividing the +inclosed area into six rooms or cells. The Indians state that these were +built at a late date to convert the church into a defense against the +hostile Apache from the south. These partitions apparently formed no +part of the original design, yet it is difficult to see how they could +have served as a defense, unless they were intended to be roofed over +and thus converted into completely inclosed rooms. A stone of somewhat +larger size than usual has been built into the south wall of the church. +Upon its surface some native artist has engraved a rudely drawn mask. + + [Illustration: Plate XXXVII. Key to the Oraibi plan, also showing + localization of gentes.] [numbering gap] + +About 150 yards southeast from the church, and on the edge of the low +mesa upon which the ruin stands, has been constructed a reservoir of +large size which furnished the pueblo with a reserve water supply. The +ordinary supply was probably derived from the valley below, where water +is found at no great distance from the pueblo. Springs may also have +formerly existed near the village, but this reservoir, located where the +drainage of a large area discharges, must have materially increased the +water supply. The basin or depression is about 110 feet in diameter and +its present depth in the center is about 4 feet; but it has undoubtedly +been filled in by sediment since its abandonment. More than half of its +circumference was originally walled in, but at the present time the old +masonry is indicated only by an interrupted row of large foundation +stones and fallen masonry. Some large stones, apparently undisturbed +portions of the mesa edge, have been incorporated into the inclosing +masonry. The Indians stated that originally the bottom of this basin was +lined with stones, but these statements could not be verified. Without +excavation on the upper side, the basin faded imperceptibly into the +rising ground of the surrounding drainage. Other examples of these basin +reservoirs are met with in this region. + +CHALOWE. + +About 15° north of west from Hawikuh, and distant 1½ miles from it, +begins the series of ruins called Chalowe. They are located on two low +elevations or foothills extending in a southwestern direction from the +group of hills, upon whose eastern extremity Hawikuh is built. The +southernmost of the series covers a roughly circular area about 40 feet +in diameter. Another cluster, measuring about 30 feet by 20, lies +immediately north of it, with an intervening depression of a foot or so. +About 475 feet northwest occurs a group of three rooms situated on a +slight rise, A little east of north and a half a mile distant from the +latter is a small hill, upon which is located a cluster of about the +same form and dimensions as the one first described. Several more +vaguely defined clusters are traceable near this last one, but they are +all of small dimensions. + +This widely scattered series of dwelling clusters, according to the +traditional accounts, belonged to one tribe, which was known by the +general name of Chalowe. It is said to have been inhabited at the time +of the first arrival of the Spaniards. The general character and +arrangement however, are so different from the prevailing type in this +region that it seems hardly probable that it belonged to the same people +and the same age as the other ruins. + +No standing walls are found in any portion of the group, and the small +amount of scattered masonry suggests that the rooms were only one story +high. Yet the débris of masonry may have been largely covered up by +drifting sand. Now it is hardly possible to trace the rooms, and over +most of the area only scattered stones mark the positions of the groups +of dwellings. + +HAMPASSAWAN. + +Of the village of Hampassawan, which is said traditionally to have been +one of the seven cities of Cibola visited by Coronado, nothing now +remains but two detached rooms, both showing vestiges of an upper story. +With this exception, the destruction of the village is complete and only +a low rise in the plain marks its site. Owing to its exposed position, +the fallen walls have been completely covered with drifting sand and +earth, no vestige of the buildings showing through the dense growth of +sagebrush that now covers it. + + [Illustration: Fig. 15. Hampassawan, plan.] + + [Illustration: Plate XXXVIII. A court of Oraibi.] + +The two surviving rooms referred to appear to have been used from time +to time, as outlooks over corn fields close by, and as a defense against +the Navajo. Their final abandonment, and that of the cultivation of the +adjoining fields, is said to have been due to the killing of a Zuñi +there, by the Navajo, within very recent times. These rooms have been +several times repaired, the one on the west particularly. In the latter +an additional wall has been built upon the northern side, as shown on +the plan, Fig. 15. The old roof seems to have survived until recently, +for, although at the present time the room is covered with a roof of +rudely split cedar beams, the remains of the old, carefully built roof +lie scattered about in the corners of the room, under the dirt and +débris. The openings are very small and seem to have been modified since +the original construction, but it is difficult to distinguish between +the older original structure and the more recent additions. + +K'IAKIMA. + +On the south side of the isolated mesa of Tâaaiyalana and occupying a +high rounded spur of foothills, is the ruined village of K'iakima (Pl. +LII). A long gulch on the west side of the spur contains, for 300 or 400 +yards, a small stream which is fed from springs near the ruined village. + +The entire surface of the hill is covered with scattered débris of +fallen walls, which must at one time have formed a village of +considerable size. Over most of this area the walls can not be traced; +the few rooms which can be distinctly outlined, occurring in a group on +the highest part of the hill. Standing walls are here seen, but they are +apparently recent, one room showing traces of a chimney (Pl. LIV). Some +of the more distinct inclosures, built from fallen masonry of the old +village, seem to have been intended for corrals. This is the case also +with the remains found on the cliffs to the north of the village, whose +position is shown on the plan (Pl. LIII). Here nearly all the scattered +stones of the original one-story buildings, have been utilized for these +large inclosures. It is quite possible that these smaller structures on +the ledge of the mesa were built and occupied at a much later date than +the principal village. Pl. LIII illustrates a portion of the base of +Tâaaiyalana where these inclosures appear. + +A striking feature of this ruin is the occurrence in the northeast +corner of the village of large upright slabs of stone. The largest of +these is about 3 feet wide and stands 5½ feet out of the ground. One of +the slabs is of such symmetrical form that it suggests skillful +artificial treatment, but the stone was used just as it came from a seam +in the cliff above. From the same seam many slabs of nearly equal size +and symmetrical form have fallen out and now lie scattered about on the +talus below. Some are remarkable for their perfectly rectangular form, +while all are distinguished by a notable uniformity in thickness. Close +by, and apparently forming part of the same group, are a number of +stones imbedded in the ground with their upper edges exposed and placed +at right angles to the faces of the vertical monuments. The taller slabs +are said by the Indians to have been erected as a defense against the +attacks of the Apache upon this pueblo, but only a portion of the group +could, from their position, have been of any use for this purpose. The +stones probably mark graves. Although thorough excavation of the hard +soil could not be undertaken, digging to the depth of 18 inches revealed +the same character of pottery fragments, ashes, etc., found in many of +the pueblo graves. Mr. E. W. Nelson found identical remains in graves in +the Rio San Francisco region which he excavated in collecting pottery. +Comparatively little is known, however, of the burial practices of this +region, so it would be difficult to decide whether this was an ordinary +method of burial or not. + +This pueblo has been identified by Mr. Cushing, through Zuñi tradition, +as the scene of the death of Estevanico, the negro who accompanied the +first Spanish expedition to Cibola. + +MATSAKI. + +Matsaki is situated on a foothill at the base of Tâaaiyalana, near its +northwestern extremity. This pueblo is in about the same state of +preservation as K'iakima, no complete rooms being traceable over most of +the area. Traces of walls, where seen, are not uniform in direction, +suggesting irregular grouping of the village. At two points on the plan +rooms partially bounded by standing walls are found. These appear to owe +their preservation to their occupation as outlooks over fields in the +vicinity long after the destruction of the pueblo. One of the two rooms +shows only a few feet of rather rude masonry. The walls of the other +room, in one corner, stand the height of a full story above the +surrounding débris, a low room under it having been partially filled up +with fallen masonry and earth. The well preserved inner corner of the +exposed room shows lumps of clay adhering here and there to the walls, +the remnants of an interior corner chimney. No trace of the supports for +a chimney hood, such as occur in the modern fireplaces, could be found. +The form outlined against the wall by these slight remains indicates a +rather rudely constructed feature which was added at a late date to the +room and formed no part of its original construction. It was probably +built while the room was used as a farming outlook. As shown on the +ground plan (Pl. LV), a small cluster of houses once stood at some +little distance to the southwest of the main pueblo and was connected +with the latter by a series of rooms. The intervening space may have +been a court. At the northern edge of the village a primitive shrine has +been erected in recent times and is still in use. It is rudely +constructed by simply piling up stones to a height of 2½ or 3 feet, in a +rudely rectangular arrangement, with an opening on the east. This +shrine, facing east, contains an upright slab of thin sandstone on which +a rude sun-symbol has been engraved. The governor of Zuñi, in explaining +the purpose of this shrine, compared its use to that of our own +astronomical observatories, which he had seen. + + [Illustration: Plate XXXIX. Masonry terraces of Oraibi.] + +PINAWA. + +The ruins of the small pueblo of Pinawa occupy a slight rise on the +south side of the Zuñi River, a short distance west of Zuñi. The road +from Zuñi to Ojo Caliente traverses the ruin. Over most of the area +rooms can not be traced. One complete room, however, has been preserved +and appears to be still occupied during the cultivation of the +neighboring "milpas." It is roofed over and in good condition, though +the general character of the masonry resembles the older work. On the +plan (Fig. 16) it will be seen that the stones of the original masonry +have been collected and built into a number of large inclosures, which +have in turn been partly destroyed. The positions of the entrances to +these inclosures can be traced by the absence of stones on the surface. +The general outline of the corral-like inclosures appears to have +followed comparatively well preserved portions of the original wall, +as was the case at Ketchipauan. (Pl. LVI.) + + [Illustration: Fig. 16. Pinawa, plan.] + +On the southwest side of the pueblo, portions of the outer wall are +distinctly traceable, some of the stones being still in position. This +portion of the outline is distinguished by a curious series of curves, +resembling portions of Nutria and Pescado, but intersecting in an +unusual manner. + +The Ojo Caliente road passes between the main ruin and the standing room +above described. The remnants of the fallen masonry are so few and so +promiscuously scattered over this area that the continuity of remains +can not be fully traced. + +HALONA. + +An ancient pueblo called Halona is said to have belonged to the Cibolan +group, and to have been inhabited at the time of the conquest. It +occupied a portion of the site upon which the present pueblo of Zuñi +stands. A part of this pueblo was built on the opposite side of the +river, where the remains of walls were encountered at a slight depth +below the surface of the ground in excavating for the foundations of Mr. +Cushing's house. At that time only scattered remains of masonry were met +with, and they furnished but little indication of details of plan or +arrangement. Later--during the summer of 1888--Mr. Cushing made +extensive additions to his house on the south side of the river, and in +excavating for the foundations laid bare a number of small rooms. +Excavation was continued until December of that year, when a large part +of the ancient village had been exposed. Pl. LVII, from a photograph, +illustrates a portion of these remains as seen from the southwest corner +of Zuñi. The view was taken in the morning during a light fall of snow +which, lightly covering the tops of the walls left standing in the +excavations, sharply defined their outlines against the shadows of the +rooms. + +It seems impossible to restore the entire outline of the portion of +Halona that has served as a nucleus for modern Zuñi from such data as +can be procured. At several points of the present village, however, +vestiges of the old pueblo can be identified. Doubtless if access could +be obtained to all the innermost rooms of the pueblo some of them would +show traces of ancient methods of construction sufficient, at least, to +admit of a restoration of the general form of the ancient pueblo. At the +time the village was surveyed such examination was not practicable. The +portion of the old pueblo serving as a nucleus for later construction +would probably be found under houses Nos. 1 and 4, forming practically +one mass of rooms. Strangers and outsiders are not admitted to these +innermost rooms. Outcrops in the small cluster No. 2 indicate by their +position a continuous wall of the old pueblo, probably the external one. +Portions of the ancient outer wall are probably incorporated into the +west side of cluster No. 1. On the north side of cluster No. 2 (see Pl. +LXXVI) may be seen a buttress-like projection whose construction of +small tabular stones strongly contrasts with the character of the +surrounding walls, and indicates that it is a fragment of the ancient +pueblo. This projecting buttress answers no purpose whatever in its +present position. + + [Illustration: Plate XL. Oraibi house row, showing court side.] + +The above suggestions are confirmed by another feature in the same +house-cluster. On continuing the line of this buttress through the +governor's house we find a projecting fragment of second story wall, the +character and finish of which is clearly shown in Pl. LVIII. Its general +similarity to ancient masonry and contrast with the present careless +methods of construction are very noticeable. The height of this fragment +above the ground suggests that the original pueblo was in a very good +state of preservation when it was first utilized as a nucleus for later +additions. That portion under house No. 1 is probably equally well +preserved. The frequent renovation of rooms by the application of a mud +coating renders the task of determining the ancient portions of the +cluster by the character of the masonry a very difficult one. Ceilings +would probably longest retain the original appearance of the ancient +rooms as they are not subjected to such renovation. + +Mr. Cushing thought that the outer western wall of the ancient pueblo +was curved in outline. It is more probable, however, that it regulated +the lines of the present outer rooms, and is reflected in them, as the +usual practice of these builders was to put one partition directly over +another in adding to the height of a building. This would suggest a +nearly rectangular form, perhaps with jogs and offsets, for the old +builders could not incorporate a curved outer wall into a mass of +rectangular cells, such as that seen in the present pueblo. On the other +hand, the outer wall of the original pueblo may have been outside of +rooms now occupied, for the village had been abandoned for some time +before the colony returned to the site. + +TÂAAIYALANA. + +On the abandonment of the pueblos known as the Seven Cities of Cibola, +supposed to have occurred at the time of the general uprising of the +pueblos in 1680, the inhabitants of all the Cibolan villages sought +refuge on the summit of Tâaaiyalana, an isolated mesa, 3 miles southeast +from Zuñi, and there built a number of pueblo clusters. + +This mesa, otherwise known as "Thunder Mountain," rises to the height of +1,000 feet above the plain, and is almost inaccessible. There are two +foot trails leading to the summit, each of which in places traverses +abrupt slopes of sandstone where holes have been pecked into the rock to +furnish foot and hand holds. From the northeast side the summit of the +mesa can be reached by a rough and tortuous burro trail. All the rest of +the mesa rim is too precipitous to be scaled. Its appearance as seen +from Zuñi is shown in Pl. LIX. + +On the southern portion of this impregnable site and grouped about a +point where nearly the whole drainage of the mesa top collects, are +found the village remains. The Zuñis stated that the houses were +distributed in six groups or clusters, each taking the place of one of +the abandoned towns. Mr. Frank H. Cushing [4] was also under the +impression that these houses had been built as six distinct clusters of +one village, and he has found that at the time of the Pueblo rebellion, +but six of the Cibolan villages were occupied. An examination of the +plan, however, will at once show that no such definite scheme of +arrangement governed the builders. There are but three, or at most four +groups that could be defined as distinct clusters, and even in the case +of these the disposition is so irregular and their boundaries so ill +defined, through the great number of outlying small groups scattered +about, that they can hardly be considered distinct. There are really +thirty-eight separate buildings (Pl. LX) ranging in size from one of two +rooms, near the southern extremity to one of one hundred and three +rooms, situated at the southwestern corner of the whole group and close +to the western edge of the mesa where the foot trails reach the summit. +There is also great diversity in the arrangement of rooms. In some cases +the clusters are quite compact, and in others the rooms are distributed +in narrow rows. In the large cluster at the northwestern extremity the +houses are arranged around a court; with this exception the clusters of +rooms are scattered about in an irregular manner, regardless of any +defensive arrangement of the buildings. The builders evidently placed +the greatest reliance on their impregnable site, and freely adopted such +arrangement as convenience dictated. + + [Footnote 4: See Millstone for April, 1884, Indianapolis, Indiana.] + +The masonry of these villages was roughly constructed, the walls being +often less than a foot thick. Very little adobe mortar seems to have +been used; some of the thickest and best preserved walls have apparently +been laid nearly dry (Pl. LXI). The few openings still preserved also +show evidence of hasty and careless construction. Over most of the area +the debris of the fallen walls is very clearly marked, and is but little +encumbered with earth or drifted sand. This imparts an odd effect of +newness to these ruins, as though the walls had recently fallen. The +small amount of debris suggests that the majority of these buildings +never were more than one story high, though in four of the broadest +clusters (see plan, Pl. LX) a height of two, and possibly three, stories +may have been attained. All the ruins are thickly covered by a very +luxurious growth of braided cactus, but little of which is found +elsewhere in the neighborhood. The extreme southeastern cluster, +consisting of four large rooms, differs greatly in character from the +rest of the ruins. Here the rooms or inclosures are defined only by a +few stones on the surface of the ground and partly embedded in the soil. +There is no trace of the debris of fallen walls. These outlined +inclosures appear never to have been walled to any considerable height. +Within one of the rooms is a slab of stone, about which a few ceremonial +plume sticks have been set on end within recent times. + + [Illustration: Plate XLI. Back of Oraibi house row.] + +The motive that led to the occupation of this mesa was defense; the +cause that led to the selection of the particular site was facility for +procuring a water supply. The trail on the west side passes a spring +half way down the mesa. There was another spring close to the foot trail +on the south side; this, however, was lower, being almost at the foot of +the talus. + +In addition to these water sources, the builders collected and stored +the drainage of the mesa summit near the southern gap or recess. At this +point are still seen the remains of two reservoirs or dams built of +heavy masonry. Only a few stones are now in place, but these indicate +unusually massive construction. Another reservoir occurs farther along +the mesa rim to the southeast, beyond the limits of the plan as given. +As may be seen from the plan (Pl. LX) the two reservoirs at the gap are +quite close together. These receptacles have been much filled up with +sediment. Pl. LXII gives a view of the principal or westernmost +reservoir as seen from the northeast. On the left are the large stones +once incorporated in the masonry of the dam. This masonry appears to +have originally extended around three-fourths of the circumference of +the reservoir. As at Ketchipauan, previously described, the upper +portion of the basins merged insensibly into the general drainage and +had no definite limit. + +The Zuñi claim to have here practiced a curious method of water storage. +They say that whenever there was snow on the ground the villagers would +turn out in force and roll up huge snowballs, which were finally +collected into these basins, the gradually melting snow furnishing a +considerable quantity of water. The desert environment has taught these +people to avail themselves of every expedient that could increase their +supply of water. + +It is proper to state that in the illustrated plan of the Tâaaiyalana +ruins the mesa margin was sketched in without the aid of instrumental +sights, and hence is not so accurately recorded as the plans and +relative positions of the houses. It was all that could be done at the +time, and will sufficiently illustrate the general relation of the +buildings to the surrounding topography. + +KIN-TIEL. + +All the ruins above described bear close traditional and historic +relationship to Zuñi. This is not the case with the splendidly preserved +ancient pueblo of Kin-tiel, but the absence of such close historic +connection is compensated for by its architectural interest. Differing +radically in its general plan from the ruins already examined, it still +suggests that some resemblance to the more ancient portions of Nutria +and Pescado, as will be seen by comparing the ground plans (Pls. LXVII +and LXIX). Its state of preservation is such that it throws light on +details which have not survived the general destruction in the other +pueblos. These features will be referred to in the discussion and +comparison of these architectural groups by constructional details in +Chapter IV. + +This pueblo, located nearly midway between Cibola and Tusayan, is given +on some of the maps as Pueblo Grande. It is situated on a small arm of +the Pueblo Colorado wash, 22 or 23 miles north of Navajo Springs, and +about the same distance south from Pueblo Colorado (Ganado post-office). +Geographically the ruins might belong to either Tusayan or Cibola, but +Mr. Cushing has collected traditional references among the Zuñi as to +the occupation of this pueblo by related peoples at a time not far +removed from the first Spanish visit to this region. + +The plan (Pl. LXIII) shows a marked contrast to the irregularity seen in +the ruins previously described. The pueblo was clearly defined by a +continuous and unbroken outer wall, which probably extended to the full +height of the highest stories (Pl. LXIV). This symmetrical form is all +the more remarkable in a pueblo of such large dimensions, as, with the +exception of Pueblo Bonito of the Chaco group, it is the largest ancient +pueblo examined by this Bureau. This village seems to belong to the same +type as the Chaco examples, representing the highest development +attained in building a large defensive pueblo practically as a single +house. All the terraces faced upon one or more inclosed courts, through +which access was gained to the rooms. The openings in this outer wall, +especially near the ground, were few in number and very small in size, +as shown in Pl. CIV. The pueblo was built in two wings of nearly equal +size on the opposite slopes of a large sandy wash, traversing its center +from east to west. This wash doubtless at one time furnished peculiar +facilities for storage of water within or near the village, and this +must have been one of the inducements for the selection of the site. +At the time of our survey, however, not a drop of water was to be found +about the ruin, nor could vestiges of any construction for gathering or +storing water be traced. Such vestiges would not be likely to remain, as +they must have been washed away by the violent summer torrents or buried +under the accumulating sands. Two seasons subsequent to our work at this +point it was learned that an American, digging in some rooms on the +arroyo margin, discovered the remains of a well or reservoir, which he +cleared of sand and debris and found to be in good condition, furnishing +so steady a water supply that the discoverer settled on the spot. This +was not seen by the writer. There is a small spring, perhaps a mile from +the pueblo in a northeasterly direction, but this source would have been +wholly insufficient for the needs of so large a village. It may have +furnished a much more abundant supply, however, when it was in constant +use, for at the time of our visit it seemed to be choked up. About a +mile and a half west quite a lagoon forms from the collected drainage of +several broad valleys, and contains water for a long time after the +cessation of the rains. About 6 miles to the north, in a depression of a +broad valley, an extensive lake is situated, and its supply seems to be +constant throughout the year, except, perhaps, during an unusually dry +season. These various bodies of water were undoubtedly utilized in the +horticulture of the occupants of Kin-tiel; in fact, near the borders of +the larger lake referred to is a small house of two rooms; much similar +in workmanship to the main pueblo, evidently designed as an outlook over +fields. This building is illustrated in Pl. LXVI. + + [Illustration: Plate XLII. The site of Moen-kopi.] + +The arrangement of the inner houses differs in the two halves of the +ruin. It will be seen that in the north half the general arrangement is +roughly parallel with the outer walls, with the exception of a small +group near the east end of the arroyo. In the south half, on the other +hand, the inner rows are nearly at right angles to the outer room +clusters. An examination of the contours of the site will reveal the +cause of this difference in the different configuration of the slopes in +the two cases. In the south half the rows of rooms have been built on +two long projecting ridges, and the diverging small cluster in the north +half owes its direction to a similar cause. The line of outer wall being +once fixed as a defensive bulwark, there seems to have been but little +restriction in the adjustment of the inner buildings to conform to the +irregularities of the site. (Pl. LXIII.) + +Only three clearly defined means of access to the interior of the pueblo +could be found in the outer walls, and of these only two were suitable +for general use. One was at a reentering angle of the outer wall, just +south of the east end of the arroyo, where the north wall, continued +across the arroyo, overlaps the outer wall of the south half, and the +other one was near the rounded northeastern corner of the pueblo. The +third opening was a doorway of ordinary size in the thick north wall. It +seems probable that other gateways once existed, especially in the south +half. From its larger size and more compact arrangement this south half +would seem to have greatly needed such facilities, but the preserved +walls show no trace of them. + +The ground plan furnishes indications, mostly in the north half, of +several large rooms of circular form, but broken down remains of square +rooms are so much like those of round ones in appearance, owing to the +greater amount of débris that collects at the corners, that it could not +be definitely determined that the ceremonial rooms here were of the +circular form so common in the ancient pueblos. While only circular +kivas have been found associated with ancient pueblos of this type, the +kivas of all the Cibola ruins above described are said by the Zuñis to +have been rectangular. The question can be decided for this pueblo only +by excavation on a larger scale than the party was prepared to +undertake. Slight excavation at a point where a round room was indicated +on the surface, revealed portions of straight walls only. + +The large size of the refuse heap on the south side of the village +indicates that the site had been occupied for many generations. +Notwithstanding this long period of occupation, no important structure +of the village seems to have extended beyond the plan. On the north +side, outside the main wall, are seen several rectangles faintly +outlined by stones, but these do not appear to have been rooms. They +resemble similar inclosures seen in connection with ruined pueblos +farther south, which proved on excavation to contain graves. + +The positions of the few excavations made are indicated on the plan (Pl. +LXIII). Our facilities for such work were most meager, and whatever +results were secured were reached at no great distance from the surface. +One of these excavations, illustrated in Pl. C, will be described at +greater length in Chapter IV. + + +PLANS AND DESCRIPTIONS OF INHABITED VILLAGES. + +NUTRIA. + +Nutria is the smallest of the three farming pueblos of Zuñi, and is +located about 23 miles by trail northeast from Zuñi at the head of +Nutria valley. The water supply at this point is abundant, and furnishes +a running stream largely utilized in irrigating fields in the vicinity. +Most of the village is compactly arranged, as may be seen from the plan +(Pl. LXVII and Fig. 17), but a few small clusters, of late construction, +containing two or three rooms each, are situated toward the east at +quite a distance from the principal group. It is now occupied solely as +a farming pueblo during the planting and harvesting season. + +The outline of this small pueblo differs greatly from those of most of +the Cibolan villages. The village (Pl. LXVIII), particularly in its +northernmost cluster, somewhat approximates the form of the ancient +pueblo of Kin-tiel (Pl. LXIII), and has apparently been built on the +remains of an older village of somewhat corresponding form, as indicated +by its curved outer wall. Fragments of carefully constructed masonry of +the ancient type, contrasting noticeably with the surrounding modern +construction, afford additional evidence of this. The ancient village +must have been provided originally with ceremonial rooms or kivas, but +no traces of such rooms are now to be found. + + [Illustration: Fig. 17. Nutria, plan; small diagram, old wall.] + + [Illustration: Plate XLIII. Plan of Moen-kopi.] + +At the close of the harvest, when the season of feasts and ceremonials +begins, lasting through most of the winter, the occupants of these +farming villages close up their houses and move back to the main pueblo +leaving them untenanted until the succeeding spring. + +The great number of abandoned and ruined rooms is very noticeable in the +farming pueblos illustrated in this and two of the succeeding plans +(Pls. LXIX and LXXIII). The families that farm in their vicinity seem to +occupy scarcely more than half of the available rooms. + +PESCADO. + +This village, also a Zuñi farming pueblo, is situated in a large valley +about 12 miles northeast from Zuñi. Although it is much larger than +Nutria it is wholly comprised within the compact group illustrated. The +tendency to build small detached houses noticed at Nutria and at Ojo +Caliente has not manifested itself here. The prevalence of abandoned and +roofless houses is also noticeable. + + [Illustration: Fig. 18. Pescado, plan, old wall diagram.] + +The outlines of the original court inclosing pueblo (Pl. LXX) are very +clearly marked, as the farming Zuñis in their use of this site have +scarcely gone outside of the original limits of the ancient pueblo. The +plan, Pl. LXIX and Fig. 18, shows a small irregular row built in the +large inclosed court; this row, with the inclosures and corrals that +surround it, probably formed no part of the original plan. The full +curved outline is broken only at the west end of the village by small +additions to the outer wall, and the north and east walls also closely +follow the boundary of the original pueblo. In fact, at two points along +the north wall fragments of carefully executed masonry, probably forming +part of the external wall of the ancient pueblo, are still preserved +(Pl. LXXII). This outer wall was probably once continuous to the full +height of the pueblo, but the partial restorations of the buildings by +the Zuñi farmers resemble more closely the modern arrangement. Small +rooms have been added to the outside of the cluster and in some cases +the terraces are reached by external stone steps, in contrast with the +defensive arrangement prevailing generally in pueblos of this form. +A number of dome-shaped ovens have been built outside the walls. + +The principle of pueblo plan embodied in Kin-tiel, before referred to, +is traceable in this village with particular clearness, distinguishing +it from most of the Cibolan pueblos. No traces of kivas were met with in +this village. + +OJO CALIENTE. + +The farming village of Ojo Caliente is located near the dry wash of the +Zuñi River, and is about 15 miles distant from Zuñi, in a southerly +direction. It is about midway between Hawikuh and Ketchipauan, two of +the seven cities of Cibola above described. Though situated in fertile +and well watered country and close to the remains of the ancient +villages, it bears indications of having been built in comparatively +recent times. There are no such evidences of connection with an older +village as were found at Nutria and Pescado. The irregular and small +clusters that form this village are widely scattered over a rather rough +and broken site, as shown on the plan (Pl. LXXIII). Here again a large +portion of the village is untenanted. The large cluster toward the +eastern extremity of the group, and the adjoining houses situated on the +low, level ground, compose the present inhabited village. The houses +occupying the elevated rocky sites to the west (Pl. LXXIV) are in an +advanced stage of decay, and have been for a long time abandoned. + +This southern portion of the Cibola district seems to have been much +exposed to the inroads of the Apache. One of the effects of this has +already been noticed in the defensive arrangement in the Ketchipauan +church. On account of such danger, the Zuñi were likely to have built +the first house-clusters here on the highest points of the rocky +promontory, notwithstanding the comparative inconvenience of such sites. +Later, as the farmers gained confidence or as times became safer, they +built houses down on the flat now occupied; but this apparently was not +done all at once. The distribution of the houses over sites of varying +degrees of inaccessibility, suggests a succession of approaches to the +occupation of the open and unprotected valley. + +Some of the masonry of this village is carelessly constructed, and, as +in the other farming pueblos, there is much less adobe plastering and +smoothing of outer walls than in the home pueblo. + + [Illustration: Plate XLIV. Moen-kopi.] + + [Illustration: Plate (unnumbered key).] + +At the time of the survey the occupation of this village throughout +the year was proposed by several families, who wished to resort to +the parent village only at stated ceremonials and important festivals. +The comparative security of recent times is thus tending to the +disintegration of the huge central pueblo. This result must be +inevitable, as the dying out of the defensive motive brings about a +realization of the great inconvenience of the present centralized +system. + +ZUÑI. + +The pueblo of Zuñi is built upon a small knoll on the north bank of +the Zuñi River, about three miles west of the conspicuous mesa of +Tâaaiyalana. It is the successor of all the original "Seven Cities of +Cibola" of the Spaniards, and is the largest of the modern pueblos. +As before stated, the remains of Halona, one of the "seven cities," as +identified by Mr. Cushing, have served as a nucleus for the construction +of the modern pueblo, and have been incorporated into the most densely +clustered portions, represented on the plan (Pl. LXXVI) by numbers 1 +and 4. + +Some of the Cibolan villages were valley pueblos, built at a distance +from the rocky mesas and canyons that must have served as quarries for +the stone used in building. The Halona site was of this type, the +nearest supply of stone being 3 miles distant. At this point (Halona) +the Zuñi River is perennial, and furnishes a plentiful supply of water +at all seasons of the year. It disappears, however, a few miles west in +a broad, sandy wash, to appear again 20 miles below the village, +probably through the accession of small streams from springs farther +down. The so-called river furnishes the sole water supply at Zuñi, with +the exception of a single well or reservoir on the north side of the +village. + +Zuñi has been built at a point having no special advantages for defense; +convenience to large areas of tillable soil has apparently led to the +selection of the site. This has subjected it in part to the same +influences that had at an earlier date produced the carefully walled +fortress pueblos of the valleys, where the defensive efficiency was due +to well planned and constructed buildings. The result is that Zuñi, +while not comparable in symmetry to many of the ancient examples, +displays a remarkably compact arrangement of dwellings in the portions +of the pueblos first occupied, designated on the plan (Pl. LXXVI) as +houses 1 and 4. Owing to this restriction of lateral expansion this +portion of the pueblo has been carried to a great height. + +Pl. LXXVIII gives a general view of these higher terraces of the village +from the southeast. A height of five distinct terraces from the ground +is attained on the south side of this cluster. The same point, however, +owing to the irregularity of the site, is only three terraces above the +ground on the north side. The summit of the knoll upon which the older +portion of Zuñi has been built is so uneven, and the houses themselves +vary so much in dimensions, that the greatest disparity prevails in the +height of terraces. A three-terrace portion of a cluster may have but +two terraces immediately alongside, and throughout the more closely +built portions of the village the exposed height of terraces varies from +1 foot to 8 or 10 feet. Pl. LXXIX illustrates this feature. + +The growth of the village has apparently been far beyond the original +expectation of the builders, and the crowded additions seem to have been +joined to the clusters wherever the demand for more space was most +urgent, without following any definite plan in their arrangement. In +such of the ancient pueblo ruins as afford evidence of having passed +through a similar experience, the crowding of additional cells seems to +have been made to conform to some extent to a predetermined plan. At +Kin-tiel we have seen how such additions to the number of habitable +rooms could readily be made within the open court without affecting the +symmetry and defensive efficiency of the pueblo; but here the nucleus of +the large clusters was small and compact, so that enlargement has taken +place only by the addition of rooms on the outside, both on the ground +and on upper terraces. + +The highest point of Zuñi, now showing five terraces, is said to have +had a height of seven terraces as late as the middle of the present +century, but at the time of the survey of the village no traces were +seen of such additional stories. The top of the present fifth terrace, +however, is more than 50 feet long, and affords sufficient space for the +addition of a sixth and seventh story. + +The court or plaza in which the church (Pl. LXXX) stands is so much +larger than such inclosures usually are when incorporated in a pueblo +plan that it seems unlikely to have formed part of the original village. +It probably resulted from locating the church prior to the construction +of the eastern rows of the village. Certain features in the houses +themselves indicate the later date of these rows. + + [Illustration: Plate XLV. The Mormon mill at Moen-kopi.] + +The arrangement of dwellings about a court (Pl. LXXXII), characteristic +of the ancient pueblos, is likely to have prevailed in the small pueblo +of Halona, about which clustered the many irregular houses that +constitute modern Zuñi. Occasional traces of such an arrangement are +still met with in portions of Zuñi, although nearly all of the ancient +pueblo has been covered with rooms of later date. In the arrangement of +Zuñi houses a noticeable difference in the manner of clustering is found +in different parts of the pueblo. That portion designated as house No. 1 +on the plan, built over the remains of the original small pueblo, is +unquestionably the oldest portion of the village. The clustering seems +to have gone on around this center to an extraordinary and exceptional +extent before any houses were built in other portions. House No. 4 is a +portion of the same structure, for although a street or passageway +intervenes it is covered with two or three terraces, indicating that +such connection was established at an early date. The rows on the lower +ground to the east (Pl. LXXXI), where the rooms are not so densely +clustered, were built after the removal of the defensive motive that +influenced the construction of the central pile. These portions, +arranged approximately in rows, show a marked resemblance to pueblos of +known recent date. That they were built subsequently to the main +clusters is also indicated by the abundant use of oblique openings and +roof holes, where there is very little necessity for such contrivances. +This feature was originally devised to meet the exceptional conditions +of lighting imposed by dense crowding of the living rooms. It will be +referred to again in examining the details of openings, and its wide +departure from the arrangement found to prevail generally in pueblo +constructions will there be noted. The habit of making such provisions +for lighting inner rooms became fixed and was applied generally to many +clusters much smaller in size than those of other pueblos where this +feature was not developed and where the necessity for it was not felt. +These less crowded rooms of more recent construction form the eastern +portion of the pueblo, and also include the governor's house on the +south side. + +The old ceremonial rooms or kivas, and the rooms for the meeting of the +various orders or secret societies were, during the Spanish occupancy, +crowded into the innermost recesses of this ancient portion of Zuñi +under house No. 1. But the kivas, in all likelihood, occupied a more +marginal position before such foreign influence was brought to bear on +them, as do some of the kivas at the present time, and as is the general +practice in other modern pueblos. + + + + +CHAPTER IV. + +ARCHITECTURE OF TUSAYAN AND CIBOLA COMPARED BY CONSTRUCTIONAL DETAILS. + + +INTRODUCTION. + +In the two preceding chapters the more general features of form and +distribution in the ruined and inhabited pueblos of Tusayan and Cibola +have been described. In order to gain a full and definite idea of the +architectural acquirements of the pueblo builders it will be necessary +to examine closely the constructional details of their present houses, +endeavoring, when practicable, to compare these details with the rather +meager vestiges of similar features that have survived the destruction +of the older villages, noting the extent to which these have departed +from early types, and, where practicable, tracing the causes of such +deviation. For convenience of comparison the various details of +housebuilding for the two groups will be treated together. + +The writer is indebted to Mr. A. M. Stephen, the collector of the +traditionary data already given, for information concerning the rites +connected with house building at Tusayan incorporated in the following +pages, and also for the carefully collected and valuable nomenclature of +architectural details appended hereto. Material of this class pertaining +to the Cibola group of pueblos unfortunately could not be procured. + + +HOUSE BUILDING. + +RITES AND METHODS. + +The ceremonials connected with house building in Tusayan are quite +meager, but the various steps in the ritual, described in their proper +connection in the following paragraphs, are well defined and definitely +assigned to those who participate in the construction of the buildings. + + [Illustration: Plate XLVI. Hawikuh, plan.] + +So far as could be ascertained there is no prearranged plan for an +entire house of several stories, or for the arrangement of contiguous +houses. Most of the ruins examined emphasize this absence of a clearly +defined general plan governing the location of rooms added to the +original cluster. Two notable exceptions to this want of definite plan +occur among the ruins described. In Tusayan the Fire House (Fig. 7) is +evidently the result of a clearly defined purpose to give a definite +form to the entire cluster, just as, on a very much larger scale, does +the ruin of Kin-tiel, belonging to the Cibola group (Pl. LXIII). In both +these cases the fixing of the outer wall on a definite line seems to +have been regarded as of more importance than the specific locations of +individual rooms or dwellings within this outline. Throughout that part +of Tusayan which has been examined, however, the single room seems now +to be regarded as the pueblo unit, and is spoken of as a complete house. +It is the construction of such a house unit that is here to be +described. + +A suitable site having been selected, the builder considers what the +dimensions of the house should be, and these he measures by paces, +placing a stone or other mark at each corner. He then goes to the woods +and cuts a sufficient number of timbers for the roof of a length +corresponding to the width of his house. Stones are also gathered and +roughly dressed, and in all these operations he is assisted by his +friends, usually of his own gens. These assistants receive no +compensation except their food, but that of itself entails considerable +expense on the builder, and causes him to build his house with as few +helpers as possible. + +The material having been accumulated, the builder goes to the village +chief, who prepares for him four small eagle feathers. The chief ties a +short cotton string to the stem of each, sprinkles them with votive +meal, and breathes upon them his prayers for the welfare of the proposed +house and its occupants. These feathers are called Nakwa kwoci, a term +meaning a breathed prayer, and the prayers are addressed to Másauwu, the +Sun, and to other deities concerned in house-life. These feathers are +placed at the four corners of the house and a large stone is laid over +each of them. The builder then decides where the door is to be located, +and marks the place by setting some food on each side of it; he then +passes around the site from right to left, sprinkling piki crumbs and +other particles of food, mixed with native tobacco, along the lines to +be occupied by the walls. As he sprinkles this offering he sings to the +Sun his Kitdauwi, house song: "Si-ai, a-hai, si-ai, a-hai." The meaning +of these words the people have now forgotten. + +Mr. Stephen has been informed by the Indians that the man is a mason and +the woman the plasterer, the house belonging to the woman when finished; +but according to my own observation this is not the universal practice +in modern Tusayan. In the case of the house in Oraibi, illustrated in +Pl. XL from a photograph, much, if not all, of the masonry was laid, as +well as finished and plastered, by the woman of the house and her female +relatives. There was but one man present at this house-building, whose +grudgingly performed duty consisted of lifting the larger roof beams and +lintels into place and of giving occasional assistance in the heavier +work. The ground about this house was strewn with quantities of broken +stone for masonry, which seemed to be all prepared and brought to the +spot before building began; but often the various divisions of the work +are carried on by both men and women simultaneously. While the men were +dressing the stones, the women brought earth and water and mixed a mud +plaster. Then the walls were laid in irregular courses, using the mortar +very sparingly. + +The house is always built in the form of a parallelogram, the walls +being from 7 to 8 feet high, and of irregular thickness, sometimes +varying from 15 to 22 inches in different parts of the same wall. + +Pine, piñon, juniper, cottonwood, willow, and indeed all the available +trees of the region are used in house construction. The main beams for +the roof are usually of pine or cottonwood, from which the bark has been +stripped. The roof is always made nearly level, and the ends of the +beams are placed across the side walls at intervals of about 2 feet. +Above these are laid smaller poles parallel with the side walls, and not +more than a foot apart. Across these again are laid reeds or small +willows, as close together as they can be placed, and above this series +is crossed a layer of grass or small twigs and weeds. Over this +framework a layer of mud is spread, which, after drying, is covered with +earth and firmly trodden down. The making of the roof is the work of the +women. When it is finished the women proceed to spread a thick coating +of mud for a floor. After this follows the application of plaster to the +walls. Formerly a custom prevailed of leaving a small space on the wall +unplastered, a belief then existing that a certain Katchina came and +finished it, and although the space remained bare it was considered to +be covered with an invisible plaster. + +The house being thus far completed, the builder prepares four feathers +similar to those prepared by the chief, and ties them to a short piece +of willow, the end of which is inserted over one of the central roof +beams. These feathers are renewed every year at the feast of Soyalyina, +celebrated in December, when the sun begins to return north ward. The +builder also makes an offering to Másauwu (called "feeding the house") +by placing fragments of food among the rafters, beseeching him not to +hasten the departure of any of the family to the under world. + +A hole is left in one corner of the roof, and under this the woman +builds a fireplace and chimney. The former is usually but a small cavity +about a foot square in the corner of the floor. Over this a chimney hood +is constructed, its lower rim being about 3 feet above the floor. + +As a rule the house has no eaves, the roof being finished with a stone +coping laid flush with the wall and standing a few inches higher than +the roof to preserve the earth covering from being blown or washed away. +Roof-drains of various materials are also commonly inserted in the +copings, as will be described later. + +All the natives, as far as could be ascertained, regard this +single-roomed house as being complete in itself, but they also consider +it the nucleus of the larger structure. When more space is desired, as +when the daughters of the house marry and require room for themselves, +another house is built in front of and adjoining the first one, and a +second story is often added to the original house. The same ceremony is +observed in building the ground story in front, but there is no ceremony +for the second and additional stories. + + [Illustration: Plate XLVII. Hawikuh, view.] + +Anawita (war-chief of Sichumovi) describes the house in Walpi in which +he was born as having had five rooms on the ground floor, and as being +four stories high, but it was terraced both in front and rear, his +sisters and their families occupying the rear portion. The fourth story +consisted of a single room and had terraces on two opposite sides. This +old house is now very dilapidated, and the greater portion of the walls +have been carried away. There is no prescribed position for +communicating doorways, but the outer doors are usually placed in the +lee walls to avoid the prevailing southwest winds. + + [Illustration: Fig. 19. A Tusayan wood rack.] + +Formerly on the approach of cold weather, and to some extent the custom +still exists, people withdrew from the upper stories to the kikoli +rooms, where they huddled together to keep warm. Economy in the +consumption of fuel also prompted this expedient; but these ground-floor +rooms forming the first terrace, as a rule having no external doorways, +and entered from without by means of a roof hatchway provided with a +ladder, are ordinarily used only for purposes of storage. Even their +roofs are largely utilized for the temporary storage of many household +articles, and in the autumn, after the harvests have been gathered, the +terraces and copings are often covered with drying peaches, and the +peculiar long strips into which pumpkins and squashes have been cut to +facilitate their desiccation for winter use. Among other things the +household supply of wood is sometimes piled up at one end of this +terrace, but more commonly the natives have so many other uses for this +space that the sticks of fuel are piled up on a rude projecting skeleton +of poles, supported on one side by two upright forked sticks set into +the ground, and on the other resting upon the stone coping of the wall, +as illustrated in Fig. 19. At other times poles are laid across a +re-entering angle of a house and used as a wood rack, without any +support from the ground. At the autumn season not only is the available +space of the first terrace fully utilized, but every projecting beam or +stick is covered with strings of drying meat or squashes, and many long +poles are extended between convenient points to do temporary duty as +additional drying racks. There was in all cases at least one fireplace +on the inside in the upper stories, but the cooking was done on the +terraces, usually at the end of the first or kikoli roof. This is still +a general custom, and the end of the first terrace is usually walled up +and roofed, and is called tupubi. Tuma is the name of the flat +baking-stone used in the houses, but the flat stone used for baking at +the kisi in the field is called tupubi. + +Kikoli is the name of the ground story of the house, which has no +opening in the outer wall. + +The term for the terraced roofs is ihpobi, and is applied to all of +them; but the tupatca ihpobi, or third terrace, is the place of general +resort, and is regarded as a common loitering place, no one claiming +distinct ownership. This is suggestive of an early communal dwelling, +but nothing definite can now be ascertained on this point. In this +connection it may also be noted that the eldest sister's house is +regarded as their home by her younger brothers and her nieces and +nephews. + +Aside from the tupubi, there are numerous small rooms especially +constructed for baking the thin, paper-like bread called piki. These are +usually not more than from 5 to 7 feet high, with interior dimensions +not larger than 7 feet by 10, and they are called tumcokobi, the place +of the flat stone, tuma being the name of the stone itself, and tcok +describing its flat position. Many of the ground-floor rooms in the +dwelling houses are also devoted to this use. + +The terms above are those more commonly used in referring to the houses +and their leading features. A more exhaustive vocabulary of +architectural terms, comprising those especially applied to the various +constructional features of the kivas or ceremonial rooms, and to the +"kisis," or temporary brush shelters for field use, will be found near +the end of this paper. + +The only trace of a traditional village plan, or arrangement of +contiguous houses, is found in a meager mention in some of the +traditions, that rows of houses were built to inclose the kiva, and to +form an appropriate place for the public dances and processions of +masked dancers. No definite ground plan, however, is ascribed to these +traditional court-inclosing houses, although at one period in the +evolution of this defensive type of architecture they must have partaken +somewhat of the symmetrical grouping found on the Rio Chaco and +elsewhere. + +LOCALIZATION OF GENTES. + +In the older and more symmetrical examples there was doubtless some +effort to distribute the various gentes, or at least the phratries, +in definite quarters of the village, as stated traditionally. At the +present day, however, there is but little trace of such localization. In +the case of Oraibi, the largest of the Tusayan villages, Mr. Stephen has +with great care and patience ascertained the distribution of the various +gentes in the village, as recorded on the accompanying skeleton plan +(Pl. XXXVII). An examination of the diagram in connection with the +appended list of the families occupying Oraibi will at once show that, +however clearly defined may have been the quarters of various gentes in +the traditional village, the greatest confusion prevails at the present +time. The families numerically most important, such as the Reed, Coyote, +Lizard, and Badger, are represented in all of the larger house clusters. + + [Illustration: Plate XLVIII. Adobe church at Hawikuh.] + +_Families occupying Oraibi._ + +[See house plan--house numbers in blue.] + + 1. Kokop................winwuh...................Burrowing owl. + 2. Pikyas...............nyumuh...................Young corn plant. + 3. Bakab................winwuh...................Reed (_Phragmites +communis_). + 4. Tuwa.................winwuh...................Sand. + 5. Tdap.................nyumuh...................Jack rabbit. + 6. Honan................winwuh...................Badger. + 7. Isn..................winwuh...................Coyote. + 8. See 3.........................................Reed. + 9. Kukuto...............winwuh...................Lizard. +10. Honan................nyumuh...................Bear. +11. Honau.........................................Bear. +12. See 3.........................................Reed. +13. See 7.........................................Coyote. +14. Tcuin.........................................Rattlesnake. +15. Awat..........................................Bow. +16. Kokuan........................................Spider. +17. See 9.........................................Lizard. +18. See 3.........................................Reed. +19. See 1.........................................Burrowing owl. +20. See 1.........................................Burrowing owl. +21. See 5.........................................Rabbit. +22. See 9.........................................Lizard. +23. See 9.........................................Lizard. +23½. See 9........................................Lizard. +24. See 2.........................................Young corn. +25. Gyazro...............nyumuh...................Paroquet. +26. See 2.........................................Young corn. +27. Kwah.................nyumuh...................Eagle. +28. See 7.........................................Coyote. +29. See 27........................................Eagle. +30. See 9.........................................Lizard. +31. See 9.........................................Lizard. +32. See 7.........................................Coyote. +33. See 7.........................................Coyote. +34. See 2.........................................Young corn. +35. See 6.........................................Badger. +36. See 16........................................Spider. +37. Batun................winwuh...................Squash. +38. See 15........................................Bow. +39. See 15........................................Bow. +40. See 1.........................................Burrowing owl. +41. See 1.........................................Burrowing owl. +42. See 6.........................................Badger. +43. Tdawuh...............winwuh...................Sun. +44. See 1.........................................Burrowing owl. +45. See 25........................................Paroquet. +46. See 1.........................................Burrowing owl. +47. See 1.........................................Burrowing-owl. +48. See 3.........................................Reed. +49. See 3.........................................Reed. +50. See 3.........................................Reed. +51. See 3.........................................Reed. +52. See 27........................................Eagle. +53. See 25........................................Paroquet. +54. See 1.........................................Burrowing owl. +55. See 5.........................................Rabbit. +56. See 9.........................................Lizard. +57. Pobol................winwuh...................Moth. +58. See 6.........................................Badger. +59. See 5.........................................Rabbit. +60. See 5.........................................Rabbit. +61. See 7.........................................Coyote. +62. See 7.........................................Coyote. +63. Atoko................winwuh...................Crane. +64. See 3.........................................Reed. +65. See 9.........................................Lizard. +66. Keli.................nyumuh...................Hawk. +67. See 7.........................................Coyote. +68. See 43........................................Sun. +69. Kwan.................nyumuh...................Mescal cake. +70. See 27........................................Eagle. +71. See 27........................................Eagle. +72. See 2.........................................Corn. +73. See 6.........................................Badger. +74. See 7.........................................Coyote. +75. See 7.........................................Coyote. +76. See 27........................................Eagle. +77. See 3.........................................Reed. +78. See 3.........................................Reed. +79. See 3.........................................Reed. +80. See 9.........................................Lizard. +81. See 43........................................Sun. +82. See 25........................................Paroquet. +83. See 9.........................................Lizard. +84. See 9.........................................Lizard. +85. See 43........................................Sun. +86. See 3.........................................Reed. +87. See 3.........................................Reed. +88. See 7.........................................Coyote. +89. See 3.........................................Reed. +90. Vacant. +91. See 2.........................................Corn. +92. See 25........................................Paroquet. +93. See 25........................................Paroquet. +94. See 10........................................Bear. +95. See 19........................................Bear. +96. See 4.........................................Sand. +97. See 4.........................................Sand. +98. See 4.........................................Sand. +99. See 3.........................................Reed. +100. See 2........................................Corn. +101. See 2........................................Corn. +102. See 7........................................Coyote. +103. See 7........................................Coyote. +104. See 3........................................Reed. +105. See 3........................................Reed. +106. See 3........................................Reed. +107. See 5........................................Rabbit. +108. See 7........................................Coyote. +109. See 5........................................Rabbit. +110. See 5........................................Rabbit. +111. See 3........................................Reed. +112. See 5........................................Rabbit. +113. Vacant. +114. Vacant. +115. See 3........................................Reed. +116. See 6........................................Badger. +117. See 43.......................................Sun. +118. See 7........................................Coyote. +119. See 43.......................................Sun. +120. See 5........................................Rabbit. +121. See 43.......................................Sun. +122. See 3........................................Reed. +123. See 4........................................Sand. +124. See 4........................................Sand. +125. See 3........................................Reed. +126. See 3........................................Reed. +127. See 43.......................................Sun. +128. See 2........................................Corn. +129. See 9........................................Lizard. +130. See 4........................................Sand. +131. See 4........................................Sand. +132. See 7........................................Coyote. +133. See 9........................................Lizard. +134. See 25.......................................Paroquet. +135. See 25.......................................Paroquet. +136. See 6........................................Badger. +137. See 6........................................Badger. +138. Vacant. +139. See 10.......................................Bear. +140. See 3........................................Reed. +141. See 25.......................................Paroquet. +142. See 25.......................................Paroquet. +143. See 43.......................................Sun. +144. See 5........................................Rabbit. +145. See 15.......................................Bow. +146. Vacant. +147. See 6........................................Badger. +148. Katcin..............nyumuh...................Katcina. +149. See 7........................................Coyote. +150. See 6........................................Badger. +151. See 6........................................Badger. +152. See 6........................................Badger. +153. See 6........................................Badger. + +Counting No. 23½, this makes 154 houses; 149 occupied, 5 vacant. + + [Illustration: Plate XLIX. Ketchipanan, plan.] + +Reed families..... 25 Paroquet families... 10 Eagle families.... 6 +Coyote families... 17 Owl families........ 9 Bear families..... 5 +Lizard families... 14 Corn families....... 9 Bow families...... 4 +Badger families... 13 Sun families........ 9 Spider families... 2 +Rabbit families... 11 Sand families....... 8 + +Snake, Squash, Moth, Crane, Hawk, Mescal cake, Katcina, one each. + +No tradition of gentile localization was discovered in Cibola. +Notwithstanding the decided difference in the general arrangements of +rooms in the eastern and western portions of the village, the +architectural evidence does not indicate the construction of the various +portions of the present Zuñi by distinct groups of people. + +INTERIOR ARRANGEMENT. + +On account of the purpose for which much of the architectural data here +given were originally obtained, viz, for the construction of large scale +models of the pueblos, the material is much more abundant for the +treatment of exterior than of interior details. Still, when the walls +and roof, with all their attendant features, have been fully recorded, +little remains to be described about a pueblo house; for such of its +interior details as do not connect with the external features are of the +simplest character. At the time of the survey of these pueblos no +exhaustive study of the interior of the houses was practicable, but the +illustrations present typical dwelling rooms from both Tusayan and Zuñi. +As a rule the rooms are smaller in Tusayan than at Zuñi. + + [Illustration: Fig. 20. Interior ground plan of a Tusayan room.] + + [Illustration: Plate L. Ketchipauan.] + +The illustration, Fig. 20, shows the ground plan of a second-story room +of Mashongnavi. This room measures 13 by 12½ feet, and is considerably +below the average size of the rooms in these villages. A projecting +buttress or pier in the middle of the east wall divides that end of the +room into two portions. One side is provided with facilities for storage +in the construction of a bench or ledge, used as a shelf, 3 feet high +from the floor; and a small inclosed triangular bin, built directly on +the floor, by fixing a thin slab of stone into the masonry. The whole +construction has been treated with the usual coating of mud, which has +afterwards been whitewashed, with the exception of a 10-inch band that +encircles the whole room at the floor line, occupying the position of +a baseboard. The other side of the dividing pier forms a recess, that +is wholly given up to a series of metates or mealing stones; an +indispensable feature of every pueblo household. It is quite common to +find a series of metates, as in the present instance, filling the entire +available width of a recess or bay, and leaving only so much of its +depth behind the stones as will afford floor space for the kneeling +women who grind the corn. In larger open apartments undivided by +buttress or pier, the metates are usually built in or near one corner. +They are always so arranged that those who operate them face the middle +of the room. The floor is simply a smoothly plastered dressing of clay +of the same character as the usual external roof covering. It is, in +fact, simply the roof of the room below smoothed and finished with +special care. Such apartments, even in upper stories, are sometimes +carefully paved over the entire surface with large flat slabs of stone. +It is often difficult to procure rectangular slabs of sufficient size +for this purpose, but the irregularities of outline of the large flat +stones are very skillfully interfitted, furnishing, when finished, +a smoothly paved floor easily swept and kept clean. + +On the right of the doorway as one enters this house are the fireplace +and chimney, built in the corner of the room. In this case the chimney +hood is of semicircular form, as indicated on the plan. The entire +chimney is illustrated in Fig. 62, which represents the typical curved +form of hood. In the corner of the left as one enters are two ollas, or +water jars, which are always kept filled. On the floor near the water +jars is indicated a jug or canteen, a form of vessel used for bringing +in water from the springs and wells at the foot of the mesa. At Zuñi +water seems to be all brought directly in the ollas, or water jars, in +which it is kept, this canteen form not being in use for the purpose. + +The entrance doorway to this house, as indicated on the plan, is set +back or stepped on one side, a type of opening which is quite common in +Tusayan. This form is illustrated in Fig. 84. + +This room has three windows, all of very small size, but it has no +interior communication with any other room. In this respect it is +exceptional. Ordinarily rooms communicate with others of the cluster. + +Pl. LXXXV shows another typical Tusayan interior in perspective. It +illustrates essentially the same arrangement as does the preceding +example. The room is much larger than the one above described, and it is +divided midway of its length by a similar buttress. This buttress +supports a heavy girder, thus admitting of the use of two tiers of floor +beams to span the whole length of the room. The fireplace and chimney +are similar to those described, as is also the single compartment for +mealing stones. In this case, however, this portion of the room is quite +large, and the row of mealing stones is built at right angles to its +back wall and not parallel with it. + +The right-hand portion of the room is provided with a long, straight +pole suspended from the roof beams. This is a common feature in both +Tusayan and Zuñi. The pole is used for the suspension of the household +stock of blankets and other garments. The windows of this house are +small, and two of them, in the right-hand division of the room, have +been roughly sealed up with masonry. + +Pl. LXXXVI illustrates a typical Zuñi interior. In this instance the +example happens to be rather larger than the average room. It will be +noticed that this apartment has many features in common with that at +Tusayan last described. The pole upon which blankets are suspended is +here incorporated into the original construction of the house, its two +ends being deeply embedded in the masonry of the wall. The entire floor +is paved with slabs of much more regular form than any used at Tusayan. +The Zuñi have access to building stone which is of a much better grade +than is available in Tusayan. + + [Illustration: Plate LI. Stone church at Ketchipauan.] + +This room is furnished with long, raised benches of masonry along the +sides, a feature much more common at Zuñi than at Tusayan. Usually such +benches extend along the whole length of a wall, but here the projection +is interrupted on one side by the fireplace and chimney, and on the left +it terminates abruptly near the beginning of a tier of mealing stones, +in order to afford floor space for the women who grind. The metates are +arranged in the usual manner, three in a row, but there is an additional +detached section placed at right angles to the main series. The sill of +the doorway by which this room communicates with an adjoining one is +raised about 18 inches above the floor, and is provided with a rudely +mortised door in a single panel. Alongside is a small hole through which +the occupant can prop the door on the inside of the communicating room. +The subsequent sealing of the small hand-hole with mud effectually +closes the house against intrusion. The unusual height of this door sill +from the floor has necessitated the construction of a small step, which +is built of masonry and covered with a single slab of stone. All the +doors of Zuñi are more or less raised above the ground or floor, though +seldom to the extent shown in the present example. This room has no +external door and can be directly entered only by means of the hatchway +and ladder shown in the drawing. At one time this room was probably +bounded by outer walls and was provided with both door and windows, +though now no evidence of the door remains, and the windows have become +niches in the wall utilized for the reception of the small odds and ends +of a Zuñi household. The chimney of this house will be noticed as +differing materially, both in form and in its position in the room, from +the Tusayan examples. This form is, however, the most common type of +chimney used in Zuñi at the present time, although many examples of the +curved type also occur. It is built about midway of the long wall of the +room. The Tusayan chimneys seldom occupy such a position, but are nearly +always built in corners. The use of a pier or buttress-projection for +the support of a roof girder that is characteristic of Tusayan is not +practiced at Zuñi to any extent. Deer horns have been built into the +wall of the room to answer the purpose of pegs, upon which various +household articles are suspended. + +The various features, whose positions in the pueblo dwelling house have +been briefly described above, will each be made the subject of more +exhaustive study in tracing the various modifications of form through +which they have passed. The above outline will furnish a general idea of +the place that these details occupy in the house itself. + + +KIVAS IN TUSAYAN. + +_General use of kivas._--Wherever the remains of pueblo architecture +occur among the plateaus of the southwest there appears in every +important village throughout all changes of form, due to variations of +environment and other causes, the evidence of chambers of exceptional +character. The chambers are distinguishable from the typical dwelling +rooms by their size and position, and, generally, in ancient examples, +by their circular form. This feature of pueblo architecture has survived +to the present time, and is prominent in all modern pueblos that have +come under the writer's notice, including the villages of Acoma and +Jemez, belonging to the Rio Grande group, as well as in the pueblos +under discussion. In all the pueblos that have been examined, both +ancient and modern, with the exception of those of Tusayan, these +special rooms, used for ceremonial purposes, occupy marginal or +semidetached positions in the house clusters. The latter are wholly +detached from the houses, as may be seen from the ground plans. + +_Origin of the name._--Such ceremonial rooms are known usually by the +Spanish term "estufa," meaning literally a stove, and here used in the +sense of "sweat house," but the term is misleading, as it more properly +describes the small sweat houses that are used ceremonially by +lodge-building Indians, such as the Navajo. At the suggestion of Major +Powell the Tusayan word for this everpresent feature of pueblo +architecture has been adopted, as being much more appropriate. The word +"kiva," then, will be understood to designate the ceremonial chamber of +the pueblo building peoples, ancient and modern. + +_Antiquity of the kiva._--The widespread occurrence of this feature and +its evident antiquity distinguish it as being especially worthy of +exhaustive study, especially as embodied in its construction maybe found +survivals of early methods of arrangement that have long ago become +extinct in the constantly improving art of housebuilding, but which are +preserved through the well known tendency of the survival of ancient +practice in matters pertaining to the religious observances of a +primitive people. Unfortunately, in the past the Zuñi have been exposed +to the repressive policy of the Spanish authorities, and this has +probably seriously affected the purity of the kiva type. At one time, +when the ceremonial observances of the Zuñi took place in secret for +fear of incurring the wrath of the Spanish priests, the original kivas +must have been wholly abandoned, and though at the present time some of +the kivas of Zuñi occupy marginal positions in the cell clusters, just +as in many ancient examples, it is doubtful whether these rooms +faithfully represent the original type of kiva. There seems to be but +little structural evidence to distinguish the present kivas from +ordinary large Zuñi rooms beyond the special character of the fireplace +and of the entrance trap door, features which will be fully described +later. At Tusayan, on the other hand, we find a distinct and +characteristic structural plan of the kiva, as well as many special +constructive devices. Although the position of the ceremonial room is +here exceptional in its entire separation from the dwelling, this is due +to clearly traceable influences in the immediate orograpic environment, +and the wholly subterranean arrangement of most of the kivas in this +group is also due to the same local causes. + + [Illustration: Plate LII. K'iakima, plan.] + +_Excavation of the kiva._--The tendency to depress or partly excavate +the ceremonial chamber existed in Zuñi, as in all the ancient pueblo +buildings which have been examined; but the solid rock of the mesa tops +in Tusayan did not admit of the necessary excavation, and the +persistence of this requirement, which, as I shall elsewhere show, has +an important connection with the early types of pueblo building, +compelled the occupants of these rocky sites to locate their kivas at +points where depressions already existed. Such facilities were most +abundant near the margins of the mesas, where in many places large +blocks of sandstone have fallen out from the edge of the surface +stratum, leaving nearly rectangular spaces at the summit of the cliff +wall. The construction of their villages on these rocky promontories +forced the Tusayan builders to sacrifice, to a large extent, the +traditional and customary arrangement of the kivas within the +house-inclosed courts of the pueblo, in order to obtain properly +depressed sites. This accidental effect of the immediate environment +resulted in giving unusual prominence to the sinking of the ceremonial +room below the ground surface, but a certain amount of excavation is +found as a constant accompaniment of this feature throughout the pueblo +region in both ancient and modern villages. Even at Zuñi, where the +kivas appear to retain but few of the specialized features that +distinguish them at Tusayan, the floors are found to be below the +general level of the ground. But at Tusayan the development of this +single requirement has been carried to such an extent that many of the +kivas are wholly subterranean. This is particularly the case with those +that occupy marginal sites on the mesas, such as have been referred to +above. In such instances the broken-out recesses in the upper rocks have +been walled up on the outside, roughly lined with masonry within, and +roofed over in the usual manner. In many cases the depth of these rock +niches is such that the kiva roof when finished does not project above +the general level of the mesa summit, and its earth covering is +indistinguishable from the adjoining surface, except for the presence of +the box-like projection of masonry that surrounds the entrance trap door +and its ladder (see Pl. LXXXVII). Frequently in such cases the surface +of the ground shows no evidence of the outlines or dimensions of the +underlying room. Examples of such subterranean kivas may be seen in the +foreground of the general view of a court in Oraibi (Pl. XXXVIII), and +in the view of the dance rock at Walpi (Pl. XXIV). But such wholly +subterranean arrangement of the ceremonial chamber is by no means +universal even at Tusayan. Even when the kiva was placed within the +village courts or close to the houses, in conformity to the traditional +plan and ancient practice as evidenced in the ruins, naturally depressed +sites were still sought; but such sites as the mesa margin affords were +rarely available at any distance from the rocky rim. The result is that +most of the court kivas are only partly depressed. This is particularly +noticeable in a court kiva in Shumopavi, an illustration of which is +given in Fig. 14. + +The mungkiva or principal kiva of Shupaulovi, illustrated in Pl. XXXIII, +is scarcely a foot above the ground level on the side towards the +houses, but its rough walls are exposed to a height of several feet down +on the declivity of the knoll. The view of the stone corrals of +Mashongnavi, shown in Pl. CIX, also illustrates a kiva of the type +described. This chamber is constructed on a sharp slope of the declivity +where a natural depression favored the builders. On the upper side the +roof is even with the ground, but on its outer or southern side the +masonry is exposed to nearly the whole depth of the chamber. At the +north end of Shumopavi, just outside the houses, are two kivas, one of +which is of the semi-subterranean type. The other shows scarcely any +masonry above the ground outside of the box-like entrance way. Pl. +LXXXVIII illustrates these two kivas as seen from the northeast, and +shows their relation to the adjacent houses. The following (Fig. 21) +illustrates the same group from the opposite point of view. + +_Access._--The last described semi-subterranean kiva and the similar one +in the court of the village, show a short flight of stone steps on their +eastern side. Entrance to the ceremonial chamber is prevented when +necessary by the removal of the ladder from the outside, or in some +instances by the withdrawal of the rungs, which are loosely inserted +into holes in the side pieces. There is no means of preventing access to +the exposed trap doors, which are nearly on a level with the ground. As +a matter of convenience and to facilitate the entrance into the kiva of +costumed and masked dancers, often encumbered with clumsy paraphernalia, +steps are permanently built into the outside wall of the kiva in direct +contradiction to the ancient principles of construction; that is, in +having no permanent or fixed means of access from the ground to the +first roof. These are the only cases in which stone steps spring +directly from the ground, although they are a very important feature in +Tusayan house architecture above the first story, as may be seen in any +of the general views of the villages. The justification of such an +arrangement in connection with the indefensible kiva roof lies obviously +in the different conditions here found as compared with the dwellings. + + [Illustration: Fig. 21. North kivas of Shumopavi, seen from the + southwest.] + +The subterranean kiva of the Shumopavi group, above illustrated, is +exceptional as occurring at some distance from the mesa rim. Probably +all such exceptions to the rule are located in natural fissures or +crevices of the sandstone, or where there was some unusual facility for +the excavation of the site to the required depth. The most noteworthy +example of such inner kiva being located with reference to favorable +rock fissures has been already described in discussing the ground plan +of Walpi and its southern court-inclosed kiva (p. 65). + +_Masonry._--The exterior masonry of these chambers seems in all cases to +be of ruder construction than that of the dwelling houses. This is +particularly noticeable in the kivas of Walpi on the mesa edge, but is +apparent even in some of the Zuñi examples. One of the kivas of house +No. 1 in Zuñi, near the churchyard, has small openings in its wall that +are rudely framed with stone slabs set in a stone wall of exceptional +roughness. Apparently there has never been any attempt to smooth or +reduce this wall to a finished surface with the usual coating of adobe +mud. + + [Illustration: Plate LIII. Site of K'iakima, at base of Tâaaiyalana.] + +In Tusayan also some of the kiva walls look as though they had been +built of the first material that came to hand, piled up nearly dry, and +with no attempt at the chinking of joints, that imparts some degree of +finish to the dwelling-house masonry. The inside of these kivas, +however, is usually plastered smoothly, but the interior plastering is +applied on a base of masonry even in the case of the kivas that are +wholly subterranean. It seems to be the Tusayan practice to line all +sides of the kivas with stone masonry, regardless of the completeness +and fitness of the natural cavity. It is impossible, therefore, to +ascertain from the interior of a kiva how much of the work of excavation +is artificial and how much has been done by nature. The lining of +masonry probably holds the plastering of adobe mud much better than the +naked surface of the rock, but the Tusayan builders would hardly resort +to so laborious a device to gain this small advantage. The explanation +of this apparent waste of labor lies in the fact that kivas had been +built of masonry from time immemorial, and that the changed conditions +of the present Tusayan environment have not exerted their influence for +a sufficient length of time to overcome the traditional practice. As +will be seen later, the building of a kiva is accompanied by certain +rites and ceremonies based on the use of masonry walls, additional +testimony of the comparatively recent date of the present subterranean +types. + +_Orientation._--In questioning the Tusayan on this subject Mr. Stephen +was told that no attention to the cardinal points was observed in the +plan, although the walls are spoken of according to the direction to +which they most closely approximate. An examination of the village plans +of the preceding chapters, however, will show a remarkable degree of +uniformity in the directions of kivas which can scarcely be due to +accident in rooms built on such widely differing sites. The intention +seems to have been to arrange these ceremonial chambers approximately on +the north and south line, though none of the examples approach the +meridian very closely. Most of them face southeast, though some, +particularly in Walpi, face west of south. In Walpi four of the five +kivas are planned on a southwest and northeast line, following the +general direction of the mesa edge, while the remaining one faces +southeast. The difference in this last case may have been brought about +by exigencies of the site on the mesa edge and the form of the cavity in +which the kiva was built. Again at Hano and Sichumovi (Pls. XVI and +XVIII) on the first mesa this uniformity of direction prevails, but, +as the plans show, the kivas in these two villages are few in number. +The two kivas of Shupaulovi will be seen (Pl. XXX) to have the same +direction, viz, facing southeast. In Shumopavi (Pl. XXXIV) there are +four kivas all facing southeast. In Mashongnavi, however (Pl. XXVI), the +same uniformity does not prevail. Three of the kivas face south of east, +and two others built in the edge of the rocky bench on the south side of +the village face west of south. In the large village of Oraibi there is +remarkable uniformity in the direction of the many kivas, there being a +variation of only a few degrees in direction in the whole number of +thirteen shown on the plan (Pl. XXXVI). But in the case of the large +kiva partly above ground designated as the Coyote kiva, the direction +from which it is entered is the reverse of that of the other kivas. +No explanation is offered that will account for this curious single +exception to the rule. The intention of the builders has evidently been +to make the altar and its attendant structural features conform to a +definite direction, fixed, perhaps, by certain requirements of the +ceremonial, but the irregularity of the general village plan in many +cases resulting from its adaptation to restricted sites, has given rise +to the variations that are seen. + +In Zuñi there was an evident purpose to preserve a certain uniformity of +direction in the kiva entrances. In house No. 1 (Pls. LXXVI and LXXVII) +there are two kivas, distinguishable on the plan by the large divided +trap door. The entrance of these both face southeast, and it can readily +be seen that this conformity has been provided intentionally, since the +rooms themselves do not correspond in arrangement. The roof opening is +in one case across the room and in the other it is placed +longitudinally. As has been pointed out above, the general plan of +arranging the kivas is not so readily distinguished in Zuñi as in +Tusayan. Uniformity, so far as it is traceable, is all the more striking +as occurring where there is so much more variation in the directions of +the walls of the houses. Still another confirmation is furnished by the +pueblo of Acoma, situated about 60 miles eastward from Zuñi. Here the +kivas are six in number and the directions of all the examples are found +to vary but a few degrees. These also face east of south. + +There are reasons for believing that the use of rectangular kivas is of +later origin in the pueblo system of building than the use of the +circular form of ceremonial chamber that is of such frequent occurrence +among the older ruins. Had strict orientation of the rectangular kiva +prevailed for long periods of time it would undoubtedly have exerted a +strong influence towards the orientation of the entire pueblo clusters +in which the kivas were incorporated; but in the earlier circular form, +the constructional ceremonial devices could occupy definite positions in +relation to the cardinal points at any part of the inner curve of the +wall without necessarily exerting any influence on the directions of +adjoining dwellings. + + [Illustration: Plate LIV. Recent wall at K'iakima.] + +_The ancient form of kiva._--In none of the ruins examined in the +province of Tusayan have distinct traces of ancient kivas been found, +nor do any of them afford evidence as to the character of the ceremonial +rooms. It is not likely, however, that the present custom of building +these chambers wholly under ground prevailed generally among the earlier +Tusayan villages, as some of the remains do not occupy sites that would +suggest such arrangement. The typical circular kiva characteristic of +most of the ancient pueblos has not been seen within the limits of +Tusayan, although it occurs constantly in the ruins of Canyon de Chelly +which are occasionally referred to in Tusayan tradition as having been +occupied by related peoples. Mr. Stephen, however, found vestiges of +such ancient forms among the debris of fallen walls occupying two small +knolls on the edge of the first mesa, at a point that overlooks the +broken-down ruin of Sikyatki. On the southeast shoulder of one of the +knolls is a fragment of a circular wall which was originally 12 feet in +diameter. It is built of flat stones, from 2 to 4 inches thick, 6 to 8 +inches wide, and a foot or more in length, nearly all of which have been +pecked and dressed. Mud mortar has been sparingly used, and the masonry +shows considerable care and skill in execution; the curve of the wall is +fairly true, and the interstices of the masonry are neatly filled in +with smaller fragments, in the manner of some of the best work of the +Canyon de Chelly ruins. + +The knoll farther south shows similar traces, and on the southeast slope +is the complete ground plan of a round structure 16½ feet in diameter. +At one point of the curved wall, which is about 22 inches thick, occurs +the characteristic recessed katchinkihu (described later in discussing +the interior of kivas) indicating the use of this chamber for ceremonial +purposes. + +Although these remains probably antedate any of the Tusayan ruins +discussed above (Chapter II), they suggest a connection and relationship +between the typical kiva of the older ruins and the radically different +form in use at the present time. + +_Native explanations of position._--Notwithstanding the present practice +in the location of kivas, illustrated in the plans, the ideal village +plan is still acknowledged to have had its house-clusters so distributed +as to form inclosed and protected courts, the kivas being located within +these courts or occupying marginal positions in the house-clusters on +the edge of the inclosed areas. But the native explanations of the +traditional plan are vague and contradictory. + +In the floor of the typical kiva is a sacred cavity called the sipapuh, +through which comes the beneficent influence of the deities or powers +invoked. According to the accounts of some of the old men the kiva was +constructed to inclose this sacred object, and houses were built on +every side to surround the kiva and form its outer wall. In earlier +times, too, so the priests relate, people were more devout, and the +houses were planned with their terraces fronting upon the court, so that +the women and children and all the people, could be close to the masked +dancers (katchinas) as they issued from the kiva. The spectators filled +the terraces, and sitting there they watched the katchinas dance in the +court, and the women sprinkled meal upon them, while they listened to +their songs. Other old men say the kiva was excavated in imitation of +the original house in the interior of the earth, where the human family +were created, and from which they climbed to the surface of the ground +by means of a ladder, and through just such an opening as the hatchway +of the kiva. Another explanation commonly offered is that they are made +underground because they are thus cooler in summer, and more easily +warmed in winter. + +All these factors may have had some influence in the design, but we have +already seen that excavation to the extent here practiced is wholly +exceptional in pueblo building and the unusual development of this +requirement of kiva construction has been due to purely local causes. +In the habitual practice of such an ancient and traditional device, the +Indians have lost all record of the real causes of the perpetuation of +this requirement. At Zuñi, too, a curious explanation is offered for the +partial depression of the kiva floor below the general surrounding +level. Here it is naively explained that the floor is excavated in order +to attain a liberal height for the ceiling within the kiva, this being a +room of great importance. Apparently it does not occur to the Zuñi +architect that the result could be achieved in a more direct and much +less laborious manner by making the walls a foot or so higher at the +time of building the kiva, after the manner in which the same problem is +solved when it is encountered in their ordinary dwelling house +construction. Such explanations, of course, originated long after the +practice became established. + +METHODS OF KIVA BUILDING AND RITES. + +The external appearance of the kivas of Tusayan has been described and +illustrated; it now remains to examine the general form and method of +construction of these subterranean rooms, and to notice the attendant +rites and ceremonies. + +_Typical plans._--All the Tusayan kivas are in the form of a +parallelogram, usually about 25 feet long and half as wide, the ceiling, +which is from 5½ to 8 feet high, being slightly higher in the middle +than at either end. There is no prescribed rule for kiva dimensions, and +seemingly the size of the chamber is determined according to the number +who are to use it, and who assume the labor of its construction. A list +of typical measurements obtained by Mr. Stephen is appended (p. 136). + + [Illustration: Plate LV. Matsaki, plan.] + +An excavation of the desired dimensions having been made, or an existing +one having been discovered, the person who is to be chief of the kiva +performs the same ceremony as that prescribed for the male head of a +family when the building of a dwelling house is undertaken. He takes a +handful of meal, mixed with piki crumbs, and a little of the crumbled +herb they use as tobacco, and these he sprinkles upon the ground, +beginning on the west side, passing southward, and so around, the +sprinkled line he describes marking the position to be occupied by the +walls. As he thus marks the compass of the kiva, he sings in a droning +tone "Si-ai, a-hai, a-hai, si-ai, a-hai"--no other words but these. The +meaning of these words seems to be unknown, but all the priests agree in +saying that the archaic chant is addressed to the sun, and it is called +Kitdauwi--the House Song. The chief then selects four good-sized stones +of hard texture for corner stones, and at each corner he lays a baho, +previously prepared, sprinkles it with the mixture with which he has +described the line of the walls, and then lays the corner stone upon it. +As he does this, he expresses his hope that the walls "will take good +root hold," and stand firm and secure. + +The men have already quarried or collected a sufficient quantity of +stone, and a wall is built in tolerably regular courses along each side +of the excavation. The stones used are roughly dressed by fracture; they +are irregular in shape, and of a size convenient for one man to handle. +They are laid with only a very little mud mortar, and carried up, if the +ground be level, to within 18 inches of the surface. If the kiva is +built on the edge of the cliff, as at Walpi, the outside wall connects +the sides of the gap, conforming to the line of the cliff. If the +surface is sloping, the level of the roof is obtained by building up one +side of the kiva above the ground to the requisite height as illustrated +in Fig. 21. One end of the "Goat" kiva at Walpi is 5 feet above ground, +the other end being level with the sloping surface. When the ledge on +the precipitous face of the mesa is uneven it is filled in with rough +masonry to obtain a level for the floor, and thus the outside wall of +some of the Walpi kivas is more than 12 feet high, although in the +interior the measurement from floor to ceiling is much less. + +Both cottonwood and pine are used for the roof timbers; they are roughly +dressed, and some of them show that an attempt has been made to hew them +with four sides, but none are square. In the roof of the "Goat" kiva, +at Walpi, are four well hewn pine timbers, measuring exactly 6 by 10 +inches, which are said to have been taken from the mission house built +near Walpi by the Spanish priests some three centuries ago. The ceiling +plan of the mungkiva of Shupaulovi (Fig. 23) shows that four of these +old Spanish squared beams have been utilized in its construction. One of +these is covered with a rude decoration of gouged grooves and bored +holes, forming a curious line-and-dot ornament. The other kiva of this +village contains a single undecorated square Spanish roof beam. This +beam contrasts very noticeably with the rude round poles of the native +work, one of which, in the case of the kiva last mentioned, is a forked +trunk of a small tree. Some of the Indians say that the timbers were +brought by them from the Shumopavi spring, where the early Spanish +priests had established a mission. According to these accounts, the home +mission was established at Walpi, with another chapel at Shumopavi, and +a third and important one at Awatubi. + +One man, Sikapiki by name, stated that the squared and carved beams were +brought from the San Francisco Mountains, more than a hundred miles +away, under the direction of the priests, and that they were carved and +finished prior to transportation. They were intended for the chapel and +cloister, but the latter building was never finished. The roof timbers +were finally distributed among the people of Shumopavi and Shupaulovi. +At Shumopavi one of the kivas, known, as the Nuvwatikyuobi +(The-high-place-of-snow--San Francisco Mountains) kiva, was built only +8 years ago. The main roof timbers are seven in number. Four of them are +hewn with flat sides, 8 by 12 inches to 9 by 13 inches; the other three +are round, the under sides slightly hewn, and they are 12 inches in +diameter. These timbers were brought from the San Francisco Mountains +while the Spaniards were here. The Shumopavi account states that the +people were compelled to drag most of the timbers with ropes, although +oxen were also used in some cases, and that the Spaniards used them to +roof their mission buildings. After the destruction of the mission these +timbers were used in the construction of a dwelling house, which, +falling into ruin, was abandoned and pulled down. Subsequently they were +utilized as described above. In the Teosobi, Jay, the main timbers were +taken out of it many years ago and used in another kiva. The timbers now +in the roof are quite small and are laid in pairs, but they are old and +much decayed. In the Gyarzobi, Paroquet, are six squared timbers from +the Spanish mission buildings, measuring 9 by 13 inches, 8 by 12 inches, +etc. These have the same curious grooved and dotted ornamentation that +occurs on the square beam of Shupaulovi, above described. At the other +end of the kiva are also two unusually perfect round timbers that may +have come from the mission ruin. All of these show marks of fire, and +are in places deeply charred. + +In continuation of the kiva building process, the tops of the walls are +brought to an approximate level. The main roof timbers are then laid +parallel with the end walls, at irregular distances, but less than 3 +feet apart, except near the middle, where a space of about 7 feet is +left between two beams, as there the hatchway is to be built. The ends +of the timbers rest upon the side walls, and as they are placed in +position a small feather, to which a bit of cotton string is tied +(nakwakwoci) is also placed under each. Stout poles, from which the bark +has been stripped, are laid at right angles upon the timbers, with +slight spaces between them. Near the center of the kiva two short +timbers are laid across the two main beams about 5 feet apart; this is +done to preserve a space of 5 by 7 feet for the hatchway, which is made +with walls of stone laid in mud plaster, resting upon the two central +beams and upon the two side pieces. This wall or combing is carried up +so as to be at least 18 inches above the level of the finished roof. +Across the poles, covering the rest of the roof, willows and straight +twigs of any kind are laid close together, and over these is placed a +layer of dry grass arranged in regular rows. Mud is then carefully +spread over the grass to a depth of about 3 inches, and after it has +nearly dried it is again gone over so as to fill up all the cracks. +A layer of dry earth is then spread over all and firmly trodden down, +to render the roof water-tight and bring its surface level with the +surrounding ground, following the same method and order of construction +that prevails in dwelling-house buildings. + + [Illustration: Plate LVI. Standing wall at Pinawa.] + +Short timbers are placed across the top of the hatchway wall, one end +of which is raised higher than the other, so as to form a slope, and +upon these timbers stone slabs are closely laid for a cover. (See Pl. +LXXXVII.) An open space, usually about 2 by 4½ feet, is preserved, and +this is the only outlet in the structure, serving at once as doorway, +window, and chimney. + +The roof being finished, a floor of stone flags is laid; but this is +never in a continuous level, for at one end it is raised as a platform +some 10 or 12 inches high, extending for about a third of the length of +the kiva and terminating in an abrupt step just before coming under the +hatchway, as illustrated in the ground plan of the mungkiva of +Shupaulovi (Fig. 22, and also in Figs. 25 and 27). On the edge of the +platform rests the foot of a long ladder, which leans against the higher +side of the hatchway, and its tapering ends project 10 or 12 feet in the +air. Upon this platform the women and other visitors sit when admitted +to witness any of the ceremonies observed in the kiva. The main floor in +a few of the kivas is composed of roughly hewn planks, but this is a +comparatively recent innovation, and is not generally deemed desirable, +as the movement of the dancers on the wooden floor shakes the fetiches +out of position. + +On the lower or main floor a shallow pit of varying dimensions, but +usually about a foot square, is made for a fireplace, and is located +immediately under the opening in the hatchway. The intention in raising +the hatchway above the level of the roof and in elevating the ceiling in +the middle is to prevent the fire from igniting them. The ordinary fuel +used in the kiva is greasewood, and there are always several bundles of +the shrub in its green state suspended on pegs driven in the wall of the +hatchway directly over the fire. This shrub, when green, smolders and +emits a dense, pungent smoke, but when perfectly dry, burns with a +bright, sparkling flame. + +Across the end of the kiva on the main floor a ledge of masonry is +built, usually about 2 feet high and 1 foot wide, which serves as a +shelf for the display of fetiches and other paraphernalia during stated +observances (see Fig. 22). A small, niche-like aperture is made in the +middle of this ledge, and is called the katchin kihu (katchina house). +During a festival certain masks are placed in it when not in use by the +dancers. Some of the kivas have low ledges built along one or both sides +for use as seats, and some have none, but all except two or three have +the ledge at the end containing the katchina house. + +In the main floor of the kiva there is a cavity about a foot deep and 8 +or 10 inches across, which is usually covered with a short, thick slab +of cottonwood, whose upper surface is level with the floor. Through the +middle of this short plank and immediately over the cavity a hole of 2 +or 2½ inches in diameter is bored. This hole is tapered, and is +accurately fitted with a movable wooden plug, the top of which is flush +with the surface of the plank. The plank and cavity usually occupy a +position in the main floor near the end of the kiva. This feature is the +sipapuh, the place of the gods, and the most sacred portion of the +ceremonial chamber. Around this spot the fetiches are set during a +festival; it typifies also the first world of the Tusayan genesis and +the opening through which the people first emerged. It is frequently so +spoken of at the present time. + +Other little apertures or niches are constructed in the side walls; they +usually open over the main floor of the kiva near the edge of the dais +that forms the second level, that upon which the foot of the ladder +rests. These are now dedicated to any special purpose, but are used as +receptacles for small tools and other ordinary articles. In early days, +however, these niches were used exclusively as receptacles for the +sacred pipes and tobacco and other smaller paraphernalia. + + [Illustration: Fig. 22. Ground plan of the chief kiva of Shupaulovi.] + + [Illustration: Plate LVII. Halona excavations as seen from Zuñi.] + +In order to make clearer the relative positions of the various features +of kiva construction that have been described several typical examples +are here illustrated. The three ground plans given are drawn to scale +and represent kivas of average dimensions. Mr. Stephen has made a series +of typical kiva measurements, which is appended to this section, and +comparison of these with the plans will show the relation of the +examples selected to the usual dimensions of these rooms. Fig. 22 is the +ground plan of the mungkiva, or chief kiva, of Shupaulovi. It will be +observed that the second level of the kiva floor, forming the dais +before referred to, is about 15 inches narrower on each side than the +main floor. The narrowing of this portion of the kiva floor is not +universal and does not seem to be regulated by any rule. Sometimes the +narrowing is carried out on one side only, as in the mungkiva of +Mashongnavi (Fig. 27), sometimes on both, as in the present example, and +in other cases it is absent. In the second kiva of Shupaulovi, +illustrated in Fig. 25, there is only one small jog that has been built +midway along the wall of the upper level and it bears no relation to the +point at which the change of floor level occurs. The ledge, or dais, is +free for the use of spectators, the Indians say, just as the women stand +on the house terraces to witness a dance, and do not step into the +court. The ledge in this case is about a foot above the main floor. +Benches of masonry are built along each side, though, as the plan shows, +they are not of the same length. The bench on the eastern side is about +4 feet shorter than the other, which is cut off by a continuation of the +high bench that contains the katchinkihu beyond the corner of the room. +These side benches are for the use of participants in the ceremonies. +When young men are initiated into the various societies during the +feasts in the fall of the year they occupy the floor of the sacred +division of the kiva, while the old members of the order occupy the +benches along the wall. The higher bench at the end of the room is used +as a shelf for paraphernalia. The hole, or recess, in this bench, whose +position is indicated by the dotted lines on the plan, is the sacred +orifice from which the katchina is said to come, and is called the +katchinkihu. In the floor of the kiva, near the katchinkihu, is the +sipapuh, the cottonwood plug set into a cottonwood slab over a cavity in +the floor. The plan shows how this plank, about 18 inches wide and 6½ +feet long, has been incorporated into the paving of the main floor. The +paving is composed of some quite large slabs of sandstone whose +irregular edges have been skillfully fitted to form a smooth and well +finished pavement. The position of the niches that form pipe receptacles +is shown on the plan opposite the fireplace in each side wall. The +position of the foot of the ladder is indicated, the side poles resting +upon the paved surface of the second level about 15 inches from the edge +of the step. Fig. 23 gives a ceiling plan of the same kiva, illustrating +the arrangement of such of the roof beams and sticks as are visible from +inside. The plan shows the position of the four Spanish beams before +referred to, the northernmost being the one that has the line and dot +decoration. The next two beams, laid in contact, are also square and of +Spanish make. The fourth Spanish beam is on the northern edge of the +hatchway dome and supports its wall. The adjoining beam is round and of +native workmanship. The position and dimensions of the large hatchway +projection are here indicated in plan, but the general appearance of +this curious feature of the Tusayan kiva can be better seen from the +interior view (Fig. 24). Various uses are attributed to this domelike +structure, aside from the explanation that it is built at a greater +height in order to lessen the danger of ignition of the roof beams. The +old men say that formerly they smoked and preserved meat in it. Others +say it was used for drying bundles of wood by suspension over the fire +preparatory to use in the fireplace. It is also said to constitute an +upper chamber to facilitate the egress of smoke, and doubtless it aids +in the performance of this good office. + + [Illustration: Fig. 23. Ceiling plan of the chief kiva of Shupaulovi.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 24. Interior view of a Tusayan kiva.] + + [Illustration: Plate LVIII. Fragments of Halona wall.] + +The mud plaster that has been applied directly to the stone work of the +interior of this kiva is very much blackened by smoke. From about half +of the wall space the plaster has fallen or scaled off, and the exposed +stonework is much blackened as though the kiva had long been used with +the wall in this uncovered condition. + +The fireplace is simply a shallow pit about 18 inches square that is +placed directly under the opening of the combined hatchway and smoke +hole. It is usually situated from 2 to 3 feet from the edge of the +second level of the kiva floor. The paving stones are usually finished +quite neatly and smoothly where their edges enframe the firepit. + + [Illustration: Fig. 25. Ground plan of a Shupaulovi kiva.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 26. Ceiling plan of a Shupaulovi kiva.] + +Figs. 25 and 26 illustrate the ground and ceiling plans of the second +kiva of the same village. In all essential principles of arrangement it +is identical with the preceding example, but minor modifications will be +noticed in several of the features. The bench at the katchina, or +"altar" end of the kiva, has not the height that was seen in the +mungkiva, but is on the same level as the benches of the sides. Here the +sipapuh is at much greater distance than usual from the katchina recess. +It is also quite exceptional in that the plug is let into an orifice in +one of the paving stones, as shown on the plan, instead of into a +cottonwood plank. Some of the paving stones forming the floor of this +kiva are quite regular in shape and of unusual dimensions, one of them +being nearly 5 feet long and 2 feet wide. The gray polish of long +continued use imparts to these stones an appearance of great hardness. +The ceiling plan of this kiva (Fig. 26) shows a single specimen of +Spanish beam at the extreme north end of the roof. It also shows a +forked "viga" or ceiling beam, which is quite unusual. + + [Illustration: Fig. 27. Ground plan of the chief kiva of Mashongnavi.] + + [Illustration: Plate LIX. The mesa of Tâaaiyalana, from Zuñi.] + +This kiva is better plastered than the mungkiva and shows in places +evidences of many successive coats. The general rule of applying the +interior plastering of the kiva on a base of masonry has been violated +in this example. The north end and part of the adjoining sides have been +brought to an even face by filling in the inequalities of the excavation +with reeds which are applied in a vertical position and are held in +place by long, slender, horizontal rods, forming a rude matting or +wattling. The rods are fastened to the rocky wall at favorable points by +means of small prongs of some hard wood, and the whole of the primitive +lathing is then thickly plastered with adobe mud. Mr. Stephen found the +Ponobi kiva of Oraibi treated in the same manner. The walls are lined +with a reed lathing over which mud is plastered. The reed used is the +Bakabi (_Phragmites communis_) whose stalks vary from a quarter of an +inch to three-quarters of an inch in diameter. In this instance the +reeds are also laid vertically, but they are applied to the ordinary +mud-laid kiva wall and not directly to the sides of the natural +excavation. The vertical laths are bound in place by horizontal reeds +laid upon them 1 or 2 feet apart. The horizontal reeds are held in place +by pegs of greasewood driven into the wall at intervals of 1 or 2 feet +and are tied to the pegs with split yucca. These specimens are very +interesting examples of aboriginal lathing and plastering applied to +stone work. + + [Illustration: Fig. 28. Interior view of a kiva hatchway in Tusayan.] + +The ground plan of the mungkiva of Mashongnavi is illustrated in Fig. +27. In this example the narrowing of the room at the second level of the +floor is on one side. The step by which the upper level is reached from +the main floor is 8 inches high at the east end, rising to 10 inches at +the west end. The south end of the kiva is provided with a small opening +like a loop-hole, furnishing an outlook to the south. The east side of +the main portion of the kiva is not provided with the usual bench. The +portion of the bench at the katchina end of the kiva is on a level with +the west bench and continuous for a couple of feet beyond the northeast +corner along the east wall. The small wall niches are on the west side +and nearer the north end than usual. The arrangement of the katchinkihu +is quite different from that described in the Shupaulovi kivas. The +orifice occurs in the north wall at a height of 3½ feet above the floor, +and 2 feet 3 inches above the top of the bench that extends across this +end of the room. The firepit is somewhat smaller than in the other +examples illustrated. Fig. 28 illustrates the appearance of the kiva +hatchway from within as seen from the north end of the kiva, but the +ladder has been omitted from the drawing to avoid confusion. The ladder +rests against the edge of the coping that caps the dwarf wall on the +near side of the hatchway, its top leaning toward the spectator. The +small smoke-blackened sticks that are used for the suspension of bundles +of greasewood and other fuel in the hatchway are clearly shown. At the +far end of the trapdoor, on the outside, is indicated the mat of reeds +or rushes that is used for closing the openings when necessary. It is +here shown rolled up at the foot of the slope of the hatchway top, its +customary position when not in use. When this mat is used for closing +the kiva opening it is usually held in place by several large stone +slabs laid over it. Fig. 29 illustrates a specimen of the Tusayan kiva +mat. + + [Illustration: Fig. 29. Mat used in closing the entrance of Tusayan + kiva.] + + [Illustration: Plate LX. Tâaaiyalana, plan.] + +The above kiva plans show that each of the illustrated examples is +provided with four long narrow planks, set in the kiva floor close to +the wall and provided with orifices for the attachment of looms. This +feature is a common accompaniment of kiva construction and pertains to +the use of the ceremonial room as a workshop by the male blanket weavers +of Tusayan. It will be more fully described in the discussion of the +various uses of the kiva. + +The essential structural features of the kivas above described are +remarkably similar, though the illustrations of types have been selected +at random. Minor modifications are seen in the positions of many of the +features, but a certain general relation between the various +constructional requirements of the ceremonial room is found to prevail +throughout all the villages. + +_Work by women._--After all the above described details have been +provided for, following the completion of the roofs and floors, the +women belonging to the people who are to occupy the kiva continue the +labor of its construction. They go over the interior surface of the +walls, breaking off projections and filling up the interstices with +small stones, and then they smoothly plaster the walls and the inside of +the hatchway with mud, and sometimes whitewash them with a gypsiferous +clay found in the neighborhood. Once every year, at the feast of Powuma +(the fructifying moon), the women give the kiva this same attention. + +_Consecration._--When all the work is finished the kiva chief prepares a +baho and "feeds the house," as it is termed; that is, he thrusts a +little meal, with piki crumbs, over one of the roof timbers, and in the +same place inserts the end of the baho. As he does this he expresses his +hope that the roof may never fall and that sickness and other evils may +never enter the kiva. + +It is difficult to elicit intelligent explanation of the theory of the +baho and the prayer ceremonies in either kiva or house construction. The +baho is a prayer token; the petitioner is not satisfied by merely +speaking or singing his prayer, he must have some tangible thing upon +which to transmit it. He regards his prayer as a mysterious, impalpable +portion of his own substance, and hence he seeks to embody it in some +object, which thus becomes consecrated. The baho, which is inserted in +the roof of the kiva, is a piece of willow twig about six inches long, +stripped of its bark and painted. From it hang four small feathers +suspended by short cotton strings tied at equal distances along the +twig. In order to obtain recognition from the powers especially +addressed, different colored feathers and distinct methods of attaching +them to bits of wood and string are resorted to. In the present case +these are addressed to the "chiefs" who control the paths taken by the +people after coming up from the interior of the earth. They are thus +designated: + + To the west: Siky´ak oma´uwu Yellow Cloud. + south: Sa´kwa oma´uwu Blue Cloud. + east: Pal´a oma´uwu Red Cloud. + north: Kwetsh oma´uwu White Cloud. + +Two separate feathers are also attached to the roof. These are addressed +to the zenith, héyap omáuwu--the invisible space of the above--and to +the nadir, Myuingwa--god of the interior of the earth and maker of the +germ of life. To the four first mentioned the bahos under the corner +stones are also addressed. These feathers are prepared by the kiva chief +in another kiva. He smokes devoutly over them, and as he exhales the +smoke upon them he formulates the prayers to the chiefs or powers, who +not only control the paths or lives of all the people, but also preside +over the six regions of space whence come all the necessaries of life. +The ancients also occupy his thoughts during these devotions; he desires +that all the pleasures they enjoyed while here may come to his people, +and he reciprocally wishes the ancients to partake of all the enjoyments +of the living. + +All the labor and ceremonies being completed the women prepare food for +a feast. Friends are invited, and the men dance all night in the kiva to +the accompaniment of their own songs and the beating of a primitive +drum, rejoicing over their new home. The kiva chief then proclaims the +name by which the kiva will be known. This is often merely a term of his +choosing, often without reference to its appropriateness. + +_Various uses of kivas._--Allusions occur in some of the traditions, +suggesting that in earlier times one class of kiva was devoted wholly to +the purposes of a ceremonial chamber, and was constantly occupied by a +priest. An altar and fetiches were permanently maintained, and +appropriate groups of these fetiches were displayed from month to month, +as the different priests of the sacred feasts succeeded each other, each +new moon bringing its prescribed feast. + +Many of the kivas were built by religious societies, which still hold +their stated observances in them, and in Oraibi several still bear the +names of the societies using them. A society always celebrates in a +particular kiva, but none of these kivas are now preserved exclusively +for religious purposes; they are all places of social resort for the +men, especially during the winter, when they occupy themselves with the +arts common among them. The same kiva thus serves as a temple during a +sacred feast, at other times as a council house for the discussion of +public affairs. It is also used as a workshop by the industrious and as +a lounging place by the idle. + + [Illustration: Plate LXI. Standing walls of Tâaaiyalana ruins.] + +There are still traces of two classes of kiva, marked by the distinction +that only certain ones contain the sipapuh, and in these the more +important ceremonies are held. It is said that no sipapuh has been made +recently. The prescribed operation is performed by the chief and the +assistant priests or fetich keepers of the society owning the kiva. Some +say the mystic lore pertaining to its preparation is lost and none can +now be made. It is also said that a stone sipapuh was formerly used +instead of the cottonwood plank now commonly seen. The use of stone for +this purpose, however, is nearly obsolete, though the second kiva of +Shupaulovi, illustrated in plan in Fig. 25, contains an example of this +ancient form. In one of the newest kivas of Mashongnavi the plank of the +sipapuh is pierced with a square hole, which is cut with a shoulder, the +shoulder supporting the plug with which the orifice is closed (see Fig. +30). This is a decided innovation on the traditional form, as the +orifice from which the people emerged, which is symbolized in the +sipapuh, is described as being of circular form in all the versions of +the Tusayan genesis myth. The presence of the sipapuh possibly at one +time distinguished such kivas as were considered strictly consecrated to +religious observances from those that were of more general use. At +Tusayan, at the present time, certain societies do not meet in the +ordinary kiva but in an apartment of a dwelling house, each society +having its own exclusive place of meeting. The house so used is called +the house of the "Sister of the eldest brother," meaning, probably, that +she is the descendant of the founder of the society. This woman's house +is also called the "house of grandmother," and in it is preserved the +tiponi and other fetiches of the society. The tiponi is a ceremonial +object about 18 inches long, consisting of feathers set upright around a +small disk of silicified wood, which serves as its base when set upon +the altar. This fetich is also called iso (grandmother), hence the name +given to the house where it is kept. In the house, where the order of +warriors (Kuleataka) meets, the eldest son of the woman who owns it is +the chief of the order. The apartment in which they meet is a low room +on the ground floor, and is entered only by a hatchway and ladder. There +is no sipapuh in this chamber, for the warriors appeal directly to +Cótukinungwa, the heart of the zenith, the sky god. Large figures of +animal fetiches are painted in different colors upon the walls. On the +west wall is the Mountain Lion; on the south, the Bear; on the east, the +Wild Cat, surmounted with a shield inclosing a star; on the north, the +White Wolf; and on the east side of this figure is painted a large disk, +representing the sun. The walls of the chambers of the other societies +are not decorated permanently. Here is, then, really another class of +kiva, although it is not so called by the people on the Walpi mesa. The +ordinary term for the ground story rooms is used, "kikoli," the house +without any opening in its walls. But on the second mesa, and at Oraibi, +although they sometimes use this term kikoli, they commonly apply the +term "kiva" to the ground story of the dwelling house used as well as to +the underground chambers. + + [Illustration: Fig. 30. Rectangular sipapuh in a Mashongnavi kiva.] + +It is probable that a class of kivas, not specially consecrated, has +existed from a very early period. The rooms in the dwelling houses have +always been small and dark, and in early times without chimneys. Within +such cramped limits it was inconvenient for the men to practice any of +the arts they knew, especially weaving, which could have been carried on +out of doors, as is done still occasionally, but subject to many +interruptions. It is possible that a class of kivas was designed for +such ordinary purposes, though now one type of room seems to answer all +these various uses. In most of the existing kivas there are planks, in +which stout loops are secured, fixed in the floor close to the wall, for +attaching the lower beam of a primitive vertical loom, and projecting +vigas or beams are inserted into the walls at the time of their +construction as a provision for the attachment of the upper loom poles. +The planks or logs to which is attached the lower part of the loom +appear in some cases to be quite carefully worked. They are often partly +buried in the ground and under the edges of adjacent paving stones in +such a manner as to be held in place very securely against the strain of +the tightly stretched warp while the blanket is being made. The holes +pierced in the upper surface of these logs are very neatly executed in +the manner illustrated in Fig. 31, which shows one of the orifices in +section, together with the adjoining paving stones. The outward +appearance of the device, as seen at short intervals along the length of +the log, is also shown. Strips of buckskin or bits of rope are passed +through these U-shaped cavities, and then over the lower pole of the +loom at the bottom of the extended series of warp threads. The latter +can thus be tightened preparatory to the operation of filling in with +the woof. The kiva looms seem to be used mainly for weaving the +dark-blue and black blankets of diagonal and diamond pattern, which form +a staple article of trade with the Zuni and the Rio Grande Pueblos. As +an additional convenience for the practice of weaving, one of the kivas +of Mashongnavi is provided with movable seats. These consist simply of +single stones of suitable size and form. Usually they are 8 or 10 inches +thick, a foot wide, and perhaps 15 or 18 inches long. Besides their use +as seats, these stones are used in connection with the edges of the +stone slabs that cap the permanent benches of the kiva to support +temporarily the upper and lower poles of the blanket loom while the warp +is gradually wound around them. The large stones that are incorporated +into the side of the benches of some of the Mashongnavi kivas have +occasionally round, cup-shaped cavities, of about an inch in diameter, +drilled into them. These holes receive one end of a warp stick, the +other end, being supported in a corresponding hole of the heavy, movable +stone seat. The other warp stick is supported in a similar manner, while +the thread is passed around both in a horizontal direction preparatory +to placing and stretching it in a vertical position for the final +working of the blanket. A number of these cup-shaped pits are formed +along the side of the stone bench, to provide for various lengths of +warp that may be required. On the opposite side of this same kiva a +number of similar holes or depressions are turned into the mud +plastering of the wall. All these devices are of common occurrence at +other of the Tusayan kivas, and indicate the antiquity of the practice +of using the kivas for such industrial purposes. There is a suggestion +of similar use of the ancient circular kivas in an example in Canyon de +Chelly. At a small cluster of rooms, built partly on a rocky ledge and +partly on adjoining loose earth and rocky debris, a land slide had +carried away half of a circular kiva, exposing a well-defined section of +its floor and the debris within the room. Here the writer found a number +of partly finished sandals of yucca fiber, with the long, unwoven fiber +carefully wrapped about the finished portion of the work, as though the +sandals had been temporarily laid aside until the maker could again work +on them. A number of coils of yucca fiber, similar to that used in the +sandals, and several balls of brown fiber, formed from the inner bark of +the cedar, were found on the floor of the room. The condition of the +ruin and the debris that filled the kiva clearly suggested that these +specimens were in use just where they were found at the time of the +abandonment or destruction of the houses. No traces were seen, however, +of any structural devices like those of Tusayan that would serve as aids +to the weavers, though the weaving of the particular articles comprised +in the collection from this spot would probably not require any cumbrous +apparatus. + + [Illustration: Fig. 31. Loom post in kiva at Tusayan.] + + [Illustration: Plate LXII. Remains of a reservoir on Tâaaiyalana.] + +_Kiva ownership._--The kiva is usually spoken of as being the home of +the organization which maintains it. Different kivas are not used in +common by all the inhabitants. Every man has a membership in some +particular one and he frequents that one only. The same person is often +a member of different societies, which takes him to different kivas, but +that is only on set occasions. There is also much informal visiting +among them, but a man presumes to make a loitering place only of the +kiva in which he holds membership. + +In each kiva there is a kiva mungwi (kiva chief), and he controls to a +great extent all matters pertaining to the kiva and its membership. This +office or trust is hereditary and passes from uncle to nephew through +the female line--that is, on the death of a kiva chief the eldest son of +his eldest sister succeeds him. + +A kiva may belong either to a society, a group of gentes, or an +individual. If belonging to a society or order, the kiva chief commonly +has inherited his office in the manner indicated from the "eldest +brother" of the society who assumed its construction. But the kiva chief +is not necessarily chief of the society; in fact, usually he is but an +ordinary member. A similar custom of inheritance prevails where the kiva +belongs to a group of gentes, only in that case the kiva chief is +usually chief of the gentile group. + +As for those held by individuals, a couple of examples will illustrate +the Tusayan practice. In Hano the chief kiva was originally built by a +group of "Sun" gentes, but about 45 years ago, during an epidemic of +smallpox, all the people who belonged to the kiva died except one man. +The room fell into ruin, its roof timbers were carried off, and it +became filled up with dust and rubbish. The title to it, however, rested +with the old survivor, as all the more direct heirs had died, and he, +when about to die, gave the kiva to Kotshve, a "Snake" man from Walpi, +who married a Tewa (Hano) woman and still lives in Hano. This man +repaired it and renamed it Tokónabi (said to be a Pah-Ute term, meaning +black mountain, but it is the only name the Tusayan have for Navajo +Mountain) because his people (the "Snake") came from that place. He in +turn gave it to his eldest son, who is therefore kiva mungwi, but the +son says his successor will be the eldest son of his eldest sister. The +membership is composed of men from all the Hano gentes, but not all of +any one gens. In fact, it is not now customary for all the members of a +gens to be members of the same kiva. + +Another somewhat similar instance occurs in Sichumovi. A kiva, abandoned +for a long time after the smallpox plague, was taken possession of by an +individual, who repaired it and renamed it Kevinyáp tshómo--Oak Mound. +He made his friends its members, but he called the kiva his own. He also +says that his eldest sister's son will succeed him as chief. + +In each village one of the kivas, usually the largest one, is called +(aside from its own special name) mungkiva--chief kiva. It is frequented +by the kimungwi--house or village chief--and the tshaakmungwi--chief +talker, councillor--and in it also the more elaborate ceremonies are +observed. + +No women frequent any of the kivas; in fact they never enter them except +to plaster the walls at customary periods, or during the occasion of +certain ceremonies. Yet one at least of the Oraibi kivas was built for +the observances of a society of women, the Mamzrántiki. This and another +female society--Lalénkobáki--exist in all the other villages, and on the +occasion of their festivals the women are given the exclusive use of one +of the kivas. + +_Motives for building a kiva._--Only two causes are mentioned for +building a new kiva. Quarrels giving rise to serious dissensions among +the occupants of a kiva are one cause. An instance of this occurred +quite recently at Hano. The conduct of the kiva chief gave rise to +dissensions, and the members opposed to him prepared to build a separate +room of their own. They chose a gap on the side of the mesa cliff, close +to Hano, collected stones for the walls, and brought the roof timbers +from the distant wooded mesas; but when all was ready to lay the +foundation their differences were adjusted and a complete reconciliation +was effected. + + [Illustration: Plate LXIII. Kin-tiel, plan (also showing + excavations).] + +The other cause assigned is the necessity for additional room when a +gens has outgrown its kiva. When a gens has increased in numbers +sufficiently to warrant its having a second kiva, the chief of the +gentile group, who in this case is also chief of the order, proposes to +his kin to build a separate kiva, and that being agreed to, he assumes +the direction of the construction and all the dedicatory and other +ceremonies connected with the undertaking. An instance of this kind +occurred within the last year or two at Oraibi, where the members of the +"Katchina" gentes, who are also members of the religious order of +Katchina, built a spacious kiva for themselves. + +The construction of a new kiva is said to be of rare occurrence. On the +other hand, it is common to hear the kiva chief lament the decadence of +its membership. In the "Oak Mound" kiva at Sichumovi there are now but +four members. The young men have married and moved to their wives' +houses in more thriving villages, and the older men have died. The chief +in this case also says that some 2 years ago the agent gave him a stove +and pipe, which he set up in the room to add to its comfort. He now has +grave fears that the stove is an evil innovation, and has exercised a +deleterious influence upon the fortune of his kiva and its members; but +the stove is still retained. + +_Significance of structural plan._--The designation of the curious +orifice of the sipapuh as "the place from which the people emerged" in +connection with the peculiar arrangement of the kiva interior with its +change of floor level, suggested to the author that these features might +be regarded as typifying the four worlds of the genesis myth that has +exercised such an influence on Tusayan customs; but no clear data on +this subject were obtained by the writer, nor has Mr. Stephen, who is +specially well equipped for such investigations, discovered that a +definite conception exists concerning the significance of the structural +plan of the kiva. Still, from many suggestive allusions made by the +various kiva chiefs and others, he also has been led to infer that it +typifies the four "houses," or stages, described in their creation +myths. The sipapuh, with its cavity beneath the floor, is certainly +regarded as indicating the place of beginning, the lowest house under +the earth, the abode of Myuingwa, the Creator; the main or lower floor +represents the second stage; and the elevated section of the floor is +made to denote the third stage, where animals were created. Mr. Stephen +observed, at the New Year festivals, that animal fetiches were set in +groups upon this platform. It is also to be noted that the ladder +leading to the surface is invariably made of pine, and always rests upon +the platform, never upon the lower floor, and in their traditional +genesis it is stated that the people climbed up from the third house +(stage) by a ladder of pine, and through such an opening as the kiva +hatchway; only most of the stories indicate that the opening was round. +The outer air is the fourth world, or that now occupied. + +There are occasional references in the Tusayan traditions to circular +kivas, but these are so confused with fantastic accounts of early mythic +structures that their literal rendition would serve no useful purpose in +the present discussion. + +_Typical measurements._--The following list is a record of a number +of measurements of Tusayan kivas collected by Mr. Stephen. The wide +difference between the end measurements of the same kiva are usually +due to the interior offsets that have been noticed on the plans, but +the differences in the lengths of the sides are due to irregularities +of the site. The latter differences are not so marked as the former. + + +-----------------+------------------+---------+---------------+ + | Width at ends. | Length of sides. |Height at| Height | + | | | center. | at ends. | + +-----------------+------------------+---------+---------------+ + | 13 6 -- -- | 24 0 -- -- | 8 6 | -- -- -- -- | + | 12 0 -- -- | 21 9 -- -- | 7 6 | 6 6 -- -- | + | 14 6 14 6 | 24 6 23 3 | 8 0 | 6 6 6 6 | + | 12 2 12 11 | 23 9 23 9 | 7 10 | 6 1 6 0 | + | 12 6 12 6 | 26 0 25 3 | 7 6 | 6 6 6 6 | + | 13 4 12 10 | 26 8 26 7 | 7 10 | 7 0 7 0 | + | 15 0 13 6 | 26 6 24 11 | 7 4 | 6 3 6 2 | + | 12 6 11 5 | 23 7 21 9 | 8 0 | 7 0 7 0 | + | 12 5 13 5 | 22 8 24 1 | 7 3 | 6 1 6 9 | + | 10 6 13 6 | 27 0 27 0 | 8 3 | 6 3 6 2 | + | 13 6 11 6 | 29 9 29 0 | 11 0 | 5 11 -- -- | + | 14 6 -- -- | 28 6 28 6 | 9 8 | 6 0 -- -- | + | 13 2 14 0 | 28 9 29 9 | 8 6 | 7 0 6 4 | + | 15 1 14 0 | 28 6 -- -- | 9 6 | 7 3 6 6 | + | 13 0 12 6 | 28 7 29 6 | -- -- | 7 4 6 3 | + +-----------------+------------------+---------+---------------+ + +_List of Tusayan kivas._--The following list gives the present names +of all the kivas in use at Tusayan. The mungkiva or chief kiva of the +village is in each case designated: + + HANO. + 1. Toko´nabi kiva Navajo Mountain. + 2. Hano sinte´ kiva Place of the Hano. + Toko´nabi kiva is the mungkiva. + + WALPI. + 1. Djiva´to kiva Goat. + 2. Al kiva A´la, Horn. + 3. Naca´b kiva Na´cabi, half-way or central. + 4. Picku´ibi kiva Opening oak bud.[5] + Wikwa´lobi kiva Place of the watchers. + 5. Mung kiva Mungwi chief. + No. 5 is the mungkiva. + + [Footnote 5: These two names are common to the kiva in which the + Snake order meets and in which the indoor ceremonies pertaining to + the Snake-dance are celebrated.] + + SICHUMOVI. + 1. Bave´ntcomo Water mound. + 2. Kwinzaptcomo Oak mound. + Bave´ntcomo is the mungkiva. + + MASHONGNAVI. + 1. Tcavwu´na kiva A small coiled-ware jar. + 2. Hona´n kiva Honani, Badger, a gens. + 3. Gy´arzohi kiva Gy´arzo, Paroquet, a gens. + 4. Kotcobi kiva High place. + 5. Al kiva A´la, Horn. + Teavwu´na kiva is the mungkiva. + + SHUPAULOVI. + 1. A´tkabi kiva Place below. + 2. Kokyangobi kiva Place of spider. + A´tkabi kiva is the mungkiva. + + SHUMOPAVI. + 1. Nuvwa´tikyuobi High place of snow, San Francisco + Mountain. + 2. Al kiva A´la, Horn. + 3. Gy´arzobi Gy´arzo, Paroquet, a gens. + 4. Tco´sobi Blue Jay, a gens. + Tco´sobi is the mungkiva. + + ORAIBI. + 1. Tdau kiva Tda´uollauwuh The singers. + 2. Ha´wiobi kiva Ha´wi, stair; High stair place. + obi, high place. + 3. Ish kiva Isa´uwuh Coyote, a gens. + 4. Kwang kiva Kwa´kwanti Religious order. + 5. Ma´zrau kiva Ma´mzrauti Female order. + 6. Na´cabi kiva Half way or Central place. + 7. Sa´kwalen kiva Sa´kwa le´na Blue Flute, a religious order. + 8. Po´ngobi kiva Pongo, a circle An order who decorate + themselves with circular + marks on the body. + 9. Hano´ kiva Ha´nomuh A fashion of cutting the hair. + 10. Motc kiva Mo´mtci The Warriors, an order. + 11. Kwita´koli kiva Kwita, ordure; Ordure heap. + ko´li, a heap. + 12. Katcin kiva Katcina A gens. + 13. Tcu kiva Tcua, a snake Religions order. + Tdau kiva is the mungkiva. + + [Illustration: Plate LXIV. North wall of Kin-tiel.] + + +DETAILS OF TUSAYAN AND CIBOLA CONSTRUCTION. + +WALLS. + +The complete operation of building a wall has never been observed at +Zuñi by the writer, but a close examination of numerous finished and +some broken-down walls indicates that the methods of construction +adopted are essentially the same as those employed in Tusayan, which, +have been repeatedly observed; with the possible difference, however, +that in the former adobe mud mortar is more liberally used. A singular +feature of pueblo masonry as observed at Tusayan is the very sparing use +of mud in the construction of the walls; in fact, in some instances when +walls are built during the dry season, the larger stones are laid up in +the walls without the use of mud at all, and are allowed to stand in +this condition until the rains come; then the mud mortar is mixed, the +interstices of the walls filled in with it and with chinking stones, and +the inside walls are plastered. But the usual practice is to complete +the house at once, finishing it inside and out with the requisite +mortar. In some instances the outside walls are coated, completely +covering the masonry, but this is not done in many of the houses, as may +be seen by reference to the preceding illustrations of the Tusayan +villages. At Zuñi, on the other hand, a liberal and frequently renewed +coating of mud is applied to the walls. Only one piece of masonry was +seen in the entire village that did not have traces of this coating of +mud, viz, that portion of the second story wall of house No. 2 described +as possibly belonging to the ancient nucleus pueblo of Halona and +illustrated in Pl. LVIII. Even the rough masonry of the kivas is partly +surfaced with this medium, though many jagged stones are still visible. +As a result of this practice it is now in many cases impossible to +determine from mere superficial inspection whether the underlying +masonry has been constructed of stone or of adobe; a difficulty that may +be realized from an examination of the views of Zuñi in Chapter III. +Where the fall of water, such as the discharge from a roof-drain, has +removed the outer coating of mud that covers stonework and adobe alike, +a large proportion of these exposures reveal stone masonry, so that it +is clearly apparent that Zuñi is essentially a stone village. The +extensive use of sun-dried bricks of adobe has grown up within quite +recent times. It is apparent, however, that the Zuñi builders preferred +to use stone; and even at the present time they frequently eke out with +stonework portions of a house when the supply of adobe has fallen short. +An early instance of such supplementary use of stone masonry still +survives in the church building, where the old Spanish adobe has been +repaired and filled in with the typical tabular aboriginal masonry, +consisting of small stones carefully laid, with very little intervening +mortar showing on the face. Such reversion to aboriginal methods +probably took place on every opportunity, though it is remarkable that +the Indians should have been allowed to employ their own methods in this +instance. Although this church building has for many generations +furnished a conspicuous example of typical adobe construction to the +Zuñi, he has never taken the lesson sufficiently to heart to closely +imitate the Spanish methods either in the preparation of the material or +in the manner of its use. The adobe bricks of the church are of large +and uniform size, and the mud from which they were made had a liberal +admixture of straw. This binding material does not appear in Zuñi in any +other example of adobe that has been examined, nor does it seem to have +been utilized in any of the native pueblo work either at this place or +at Tusayan. Where molded adobe bricks have been used by the Zuñi in +housebuilding they have been made from the raw material just as it was +taken from the fields. As a result these bricks have little of the +durability of the Spanish work. Pl. XCVI illustrates an adobe wall of +Zuñi, part of an unroofed house. The old adobe church at Hawikuh (Pl. +XLVIII), abandoned for two centuries, has withstood the wear of time and +weather better than any of the stonework of the surrounding houses. On +the right-hand side of the street that shows in the foreground of Pl. +LXXVIII is an illustration of the construction of a wall with adobe +bricks. This example is very recent, as it has not yet been roofed over. +The top of the wall, however, is temporarily protected by the usual +series of thin sandstone slabs used in the finishing of wall copings. +The very rapid disintegration of native-made adobe walls has brought +about the use in Zuñi of many protective devices, some of which will be +noticed in connection with the discussion of roof drains and wall +copings. Figs. 32 and 33 illustrate a curious employment of pottery +fragments on a mud-plastered wall and on the base of a chimney to +protect the adobe coating against rapid erosion by the rains. These +pieces, usually fragments from large vessels, are embedded in the adobe +with the convex side out, forming an armor of pottery scales well +adapted to resist disintegration, by the elements. + + [Illustration: Plate LXV. Standing walls of Kin-tiel.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 32. A Zuñi chimney, showing pottery fragments + embedded in its adobe base.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 33. A Zuñi oven with pottery scales embedded in + its surface.] + +The introduction of the use of adobe in Zuñi should probably be +attributed to foreign influence, but the position of the village in the +open plain at a distance of several miles from the nearest outcrop of +suitable building stone naturally led the builders to use stone more +sparingly when an available substitute was found close at hand. The thin +slabs of stone, which had to be brought from a great distance, came to +be used only for the more exposed portions of buildings, such as copings +on walls and borders around roof openings. Still, the pueblo builders +never attained to a full appreciation of the advantages and requirements +of this medium as compared with stone. The adobe walls are built only as +thick as is absolutely necessary, few of them being more than a foot in +thickness. The walls are thus, in proportion, to height and weight, +sustained, thinner than the crude brick construction of other peoples, +and require protection and constant repairs to insure durability. As to +thickness, they are evidently modeled directly after the walls of stone +masonry, which had already, in both Tusayan and Cibola, been pushed to +the limit of thinness. In fact, since the date of the survey of Zuñi, on +which the published plan is based, the walls of several rooms over the +court passageway in the house, illustrated in Pl. LXXXII, have entirely +fallen in, demonstrating the insufficiency of the thin walls to sustain +the weight of several stories. + +The climate of the pueblo region is not wholly suited to the employment +of adobe construction, as it is there practiced. For several months in +the year (the rainy season) scarcely a day passes without violent storms +which play havoc with the earth-covered houses, necessitating constant +vigilance and frequent repairs on the part of the occupants. + +Though the practice of mud-coating all walls has in Cibola undoubtedly +led to greater carelessness and a less rigid adherence to ancient +methods of construction, the stone masonry may still be seen to retain +some of the peculiarities that characterize ancient examples. Features +of this class are still more apparent at Tusayan, and notwithstanding +the rudeness of much of the modern stone masonry of this province, the +fact that the builders are familiar with the superior methods of the +ancient builders, is clearly shown in the masonry of the present +villages. + + [Illustration: Plate LXVI. Kinna-Zinde.] + +Perhaps the most noteworthy characteristic of pueblo masonry, and one +which is more or less present in both ancient and modern examples, is +the use of small chinking stones for bringing the masonry to an even +face after the larger stones forming the body of the wall have been laid +in place. This method of construction has, in the case of some of the +best built ancient pueblos, such as those on the Chaco in New Mexico, +resulted in the production of marvelously finished stone walls, in which +the mosaic-like bits are so closely laid as to show none but the finest +joints on the face of the wall with but little trace of mortar. The +chinking wedges necessarily varied greatly in dimensions to suit the +sizes of the interstices between the larger stones of the wall. The use +of stone in this manner no doubt suggested the banded walls that form so +striking a feature in some of the Chaco houses. This arrangement was +likely to be brought about by the occurrence in the cliffs of seams of +stone of two degrees of thickness, suggesting to the builders the use of +stones of similar thickness in continuous bands. The ornamental effect +of this device was originally an accidental result of adopting the most +convenient method of using the material at hand. Though the masonry of +the modern pueblos does not afford examples of distinct bands, the +introduction of the small chinking spalls often follows horizontal lines +of considerable length. Even in mud-plastered Zuñi, many outcrops of +these thin, tabular wedges protrude from the partly eroded mudcoating +of a wall and indicate the presence of this kind of stone masonry. +An example is illustrated in Fig. 34, a tower-like projection at the +northeast corner of house No. 2. + + [Illustration: Fig. 34. Stone wedges of Zuñi masonry exposed in + rain-washed wall.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 35. An unplastered house wall in Ojo Caliente.] + + [Illustration: Plate LXVII. Nutria, plan.] + +In the Tusayan house illustrated in Pl. LXXXIV, the construction of +which was observed at Oraibi, the interstices between the large stones +that formed the body of the wall, containing but small quantities of mud +mortar, were filled in or plugged with small fragments of stone, which, +after being partly embedded in the mud of the joint, were driven in with +unhafted stone hammers, producing a fairly even face of masonry, +afterward gone over with mud plastering of the consistency of modeling +clay, applied a handful at a time. Piled up on the ground near the new +house at convenient points for the builders may be seen examples of the +larger wall stones, indicating the marked tabular character of the +pueblo masons' material. The narrow edges of similar stones are visible +in the unplastered portions of the house wall, which also illustrates +the relative proportion of chinking stones. This latter, however, is a +variable feature. Pl. XV affords a clear illustration of the proportion +of these small stones in the old masonry of Payupki; while in Pl. XI, +illustrating a portion of the outer wall of the Fire House, the tablets +are fewer in number and thinner, their use predominating in the +horizontal joints, as in the best of the old examples, but not to the +same extent. Fig. 35 illustrates the inner face of an unplastered wall +of a small house at Ojo Caliente, in which the modern method of using +the chinking stones is shown. This example bears a strong resemblance to +the Payupki masonry illustrated in Pl. XV in the irregularity with which +the chinking stones are distributed in the joints of the wall. The same +room affords an illustration of a cellar-like feature having the +appearance of an intentional excavation to attain a depth for this room +corresponding to the adjoining floor level, but this effect is due +simply to a clever adaptation of the house wall to an existing ledge of +sandstone. The latter has had scarcely any artificial treatment beyond +the partial smoothing of the rock in a few places and the cutting out of +a small niche from the rocky wall. This niche occupies about the same +position in this room that it does in the ordinary pueblo house. It is +remarkable that the pueblo builders did not to a greater extent utilize +their skill in working stone in the preparation of some of the irregular +rocky sites that they have at times occupied for the more convenient +reception of their wall foundations; but in nearly all such cases the +buildings have been modified to suit the ground. An example of this +practice is illustrated in Pl. XXIII, from the west side of Walpi. In +some of the ancient examples the labor required to so prepare the sites +would not have exceeded that expended on the massive masonry composed of +numberless small stones. Many of the older works testify to the +remarkable patience and industry of the builders in amassing and +carefully adjusting vast quantities of building materials, and the +modern Indians of Tusayan and Cibola have inherited much of this ancient +spirit; yet this industry was rarely diverted to the excavation of room +or village sites, except in the case of the kivas, in which special +motives led to the practice. In some of the Chaco pueblos, as now seen, +the floors of outer marginal rooms seem to be depressed below the +general level of the surrounding soil; but it is now difficult to +determine whether such was the original arrangement, as much sand and +soil have drifted against the outer walls, raising the surface. In none +of the pueblos within the limits of the provinces under discussion has +there been found any evidence of the existence of underground cellars; +the rooms that answer such purpose are built on the level of the ground. +At Tusayan the ancient practice of using the ground-floor rooms for +storage still prevails. In these are kept the dried fruit, vegetables, +and meats that constitute the principal winter food of the Tusayan. +Throughout Tusayan the walls of the first terrace rooms are not finished +with as much care as those above that face the open courts. A quite +smoothly finished coat of adobe is often seen in the upper stories, but +is much more rarely applied to the rough masonry of the ground-floor +rooms. At Zuñi no such difference of treatment is to be seen, a result +of the recent departure from their original defensive use. At the +present day most of the rooms that are built on the ground have external +doors, often of large size, and are regarded by the Zuñi as preferable +to the upper terraces as homes. This indicates that the idea of +convenience has already largely overcome the traditional defensive +requirements of pueblo arrangement. The general finish and quality of +the masonry, too, does not vary noticeably in different portions of the +village. An occasional wall may be seen in which underlying stones may +be traced through the thin adobe covering, as in one of the walls of the +court illustrated in Pl. LXXXII, but most of the walls have a fairly +smooth finish. The occasional examples of rougher masonry do not seem to +be confined to any particular portion of the village. At Tusayan, on the +other hand, there is a noticeable difference in the extent to which the +finishing coat of adobe has been used in the masonry. The villages of +the first mesa, whose occupants have come in frequent contact with the +eastern pueblo Indians and with outsiders generally, show the effect in +the adoption of several devices still unknown to their western +neighbors, as is shown in the discussion of the distribution of roof +openings in these villages, pp. 201-208. The builders of the first mesa +seem also to have imitated their eastern brethren in the free use of the +adobe coating over their masonry, while at the villages of the middle +mesa, and particularly at Oraibi, the practice has been comparatively +rare, imparting an appearance of ruggedness and antiquity to the +architecture. + +The stonework of this village, perhaps approaches the ancient types more +closely than that of the others, some of the walls being noticeable for +the frequent use of long bond stones. The execution of the masonry at +the corners of some of the houses enforces this resemblance and +indicates a knowledge of the principles of good construction in the +proper alternation of the long stones. A comparison with the Kin-tiel +masonry (Pl. LXXXIX) will show this resemblance. As a rule in pueblo +masonry an upper house wall was supported along its whole length by a +wall of a lower story, but occasional exceptions occur in both ancient +and modern work, where the builders have dared to trust the weight of +upper walls to wooden beams or girders, supported along part of their +length by buttresses from the walls at their ends or by large, clumsy +pieces of masonry, as was seen in the house of Sichumovi. In an upper +story of Walpi also, partitions occur that are not built immediately +over the lower walls, but on large beams supported on masonry piers. +In the much higher terraces of Zuñi, the strength of many of the inner +ground walls must be seriously taxed to withstand the superincumbent +weight, as such walls are doubtless of only the average thickness and +strength of ground walls. The dense clustering of this village has +certainly in some instances thrown the weight of two, three, or even +four additional, stories upon walls in which no provision was made for +the unusual strain. The few supporting walls that were accessible to +inspection did not indicate any provision in their thickness for the +support of additional weight; in fact, the builders of the original +walls could have no knowledge of their future requirements in this +respect. In the pueblos of the Chaco upper partition walls were, in a +few instances, supported directly on double girders, two posts of 12 or +14 inches in diameter placed side by side, without reinforcement by +stone piers or buttresses, the room below being left wholly +unobstructed. This construction was practicable for the careful builders +of the Chaco, but an attempt by the Tusayan to achieve the same result +would probably end in disaster. It was quite common among the ancient +builders to divide the ground or storage floor into smaller rooms than +the floor above, still preserving the vertical alignment of the walls. + + [Illustration: Plate LXVIII. Nutria, view.] + +The finish of pueblo masonry rarely went far beyond the two leading +forms, to which attention has been called, the free use of adobe on the +one hand and the banded arrangement of ancient masonry on the other. +These types appear to present development along divergent lines. The +banded feature doubtless reached such a point of development in the +Chaco pueblos that its decorative value began to be appreciated, for it +is apparent that its elaboration has extended far beyond the +requirements of mere utility. This point would never have been reached +had the practice prevailed of covering the walls with a coating of mud. +The cruder examples of banded construction, however--those that still +kept well within constructional expediency--were doubtless covered with +a coating of plaster where they occurred inside of the rooms. At Tusayan +and Cibola, on the other hand, the tendency has been rather to elaborate +the plastic element of the masonry. The nearly universal use of adobe is +undoubtedly largely responsible for the more slovenly methods of +building now in vogue, as it effectually conceals careless construction. +It is not to be expected that walls would be carefully constructed of +banded stonework when they were to be subsequently covered with mud. The +elaboration of the use of adobe and its employment as a periodical +coating for the dwellings, probably developed gradually into the use of +a whitewash for the house walls, resulting finally in crude attempts at +wall decoration. + +Many of the interiors in Zuñi are washed with a coating of white, clayey +gypsum, used in the form of a solution made by dissolving in hot water +the lumps of the raw material, found in many localities. The mixture is +applied to the walls while hot, and is spread by means of a rude +glove-like sack, made of sheep or goat skin, with the hair side out. +With this primitive brush the Zuñi housewives succeed in laying on a +smooth and uniform coating over the plaster. An example of this class of +work was observed in a room of house No. 2. It is difficult to determine +to what extent this idea is aboriginal; as now employed it has doubtless +been affected by the methods of the neighboring Spanish population, +among whom the practice of white-coating the adobe houses inside and out +is quite common. Several traces of whitewashing have been found among +the cliff-dwellings of Canyon de Chelly, notably at the ruin known as +Casa Blanca, but as some of these ruins contained evidences of +post-Spanish occupation, the occurrence there of the whitewash does not +necessarily imply any great antiquity for the practice. + +External use of this material is much rarer, particularly in Zuñi, where +only a few walls of upper stories are whitened. Where it is not +protected from the rains by an overhanging coping or other feature, the +finish is not durable. Occasionally where a doorway or other opening has +been repaired the evidences of patchwork are obliterated by a +surrounding band of fresh plastering, varying in width from 4 inches to +a foot or more. Usually this band is laid on as a thick wash of adobe, +but in some instances a decorative effect is attained by using white. +It is curious to find that at Tusayan the decorative treatment of the +finishing wash has been carried farther than, at Zuñi. The use of a +darker band of color about the base of a whitewashed room has already +been noticed in the description of a Tusayan interior. On many of the +outer walls of upper stories the whitewash has been stopped within a +foot of the coping, the unwhitened portion of the walls at the top +having the effect of a frieze. In a second story house of Mashongnavi, +that had been carefully whitewashed, additional decorative effect was +produced by tinting a broad band about the base of the wall with an +application of bright pinkish clay, which was also carried around the +doorway as an enframing band, as in the case of the Zuñi door above +described. The angles on each side, at the junction of the broad base +band with the narrower doorway border, were filled in with a design of +alternating pink and white squares. This doorway is illustrated in Fig. +36. Farther north, on the same terrace, the jamb of a whitewashed +doorway was decorated with the design shown on the right hand side of +Fig. 36, executed also in pink clay. This design closely resembles a +pattern that is commonly embroidered upon the large white "kachina," or +ceremonial blankets. It is not known whether the device is here regarded +as having any special significance. The pink clay in which these designs +have been executed has in Sichumovi been used for the coating of an +entire house front. + + [Illustration: Fig. 36. Wall decorations in Mashongnavi executed in + pink on a white ground]. + +In addition to the above-mentioned uses of stone and earth in the +masonry of house walls, the pueblo builders have employed both these +materials in a more primitive manner in building the walls of corrals +and gardens, and for other purposes. The small terraced gardens of Zuñi, +located on the borders of the village on the southwest and southeast +sides, close to the river bank, are each surrounded by walls 2½ or 3 +feet high, of very light construction, the average thickness not +exceeding 6 or 8 inches. These rude walls are built of small, +irregularly rounded lumps of adobe, formed by hand, and coarsely +plastered with mud. When the crops are gathered in the fall the walls +are broken down in places to facilitate access to the inclosures, so +that they require repairing at each planting season. Aside from this +they are so frail as to require frequent repairs throughout the period +of their use. This method of building walls was adopted because it was +the readiest and least laborious means of inclosing the required space. +The character of these garden walls is illustrated in Pl. XC, and their +construction with rough lumps of crude adobe shows also the contrast +between the weak appearance of this work and the more substantial effect +of the masonry of the adjoining unfinished house. At the Cibolan farming +pueblos inclosing walls were usually made of stone, as were also those +of Tusayan. Pl. LXX indicates the manner in which the material has been +used in the corrals of Pescado, located within the village. The stone +walls are used in combination with stakes, such as are employed at the +main pueblo. + + [Illustration: Plate LXIX. Pescado, plan.] + +Small inclosed gardens, like those of Zuñi, occur at several points in +Tusayan. The thin walls are made of dry masonry, quite as rude in +character as those inclosing the Zuñi gardens. The smaller clusters are +usually located in the midst of large areas of broken stone that has +fallen from the mesa above. In the foreground of Pl. XXII may be seen a +number of examples of such work. Pl. XCI illustrates a group of corrals +at Oraibi whose walls are laid up without the use of mud mortar. + +Where exceptionally large blocks of stone are available they have been +utilized in an upright position, and occur at greater or less intervals +along the thin walls of dry masonry. An example of this use was seen in +a garden wall on the west side of Walpi, where the stones had been set +on end in the yielding surface of a sandy slope among the foothills. +A similar arrangement, occurring close to the houses at Ojo Caliente, +is illustrated in Pl. XCII. Large, upright slabs of stone have been used +by the pueblo builders in many ways, sometimes incorporated into the +architecture of the houses, and again in detached positions at some +distance from the villages. Pls. XCIII and XCIV, drawn from the +photographs of Mr. W. H. Jackson, afford illustrations of this usage in +the ancient ruins of Montezuma Canyon. In the first of these cases the +stones were utilized, apparently, in house masonry. Among the ruins in +the valley of the San Juan and its tributaries, as described by Messrs. +W. H. Holmes and W. H. Jackson, varied arrangements of upright slabs of +stone are of frequent occurrence. The rows of stones are sometimes +arranged in squares, sometimes in circles, and occasionally are +incorporated into the walls of ordinary masonry, as in the example +illustrated. Isolated slabs are also met with among the ruins. At +K'iakima, at a point near the margin of the ruin, occurs a series of +very large, upright slabs, which occupy the positions of headstones to a +number of small inclosures, thought to be mortuary, outlined upon the +ground. These have been already described in connection with the ground +plan of this village. + +The employment of upright slabs of stone to mark graves probably +prevailed to some extent in ancient practice, but other uses suggest +themselves. Occupying a conspicuous point in the village of Kin-tiel +(Pl. LXIII) is an upright slab of sandstone which seems to stand in its +original position undisturbed, though the walls of the adjoining rooms +are in ruins. A similar feature was seen at Peñasco Blanco, on the east +side of the village and a short distance without the inclosing wall. +Both these rude pillars are, in character and in position, very similar +to an upright stone of known use at Zuñi. A hundred and fifty feet from +this pueblo is a large upright block of sandstone, which is said to be +used as a datum point in the observations of the sun made by a priest of +Zuñi for the regulation of the time for planting and harvesting, for +determining the new year, and for fixing the dates of certain other +ceremonial observances. By the aid of such devices as the native priests +have at their command they are enabled to fix the date of the winter +solstice with a fair degree of accuracy. Such rude determination of time +was probably an aboriginal invention, and may have furnished the motive +in other cases for placing stone pillars in such unusual positions. The +explanation of the governor of Zuñi for a sun symbol seen on an upright +stone at Matsaki has been given in the description of that place. Single +slabs are also used, as seen in the easternmost room group of +Tâaaiyalana, and in the southwestern cluster on the same mesa, in the +building of shrines for the deposit of plume sticks and other ceremonial +objects. + +An unusual employment of small stones in an upright position occurs at +Zuñi. The inclosing wall of the church yard, still used as a burial +place, is provided at intervals along its top with upright pieces of +stone set into the joints of a regular coping course that caps the wall. +This feature may have some connection with the idea of vertical grave +stones, noted at K'iakima. It is difficult to surmise what practical +purpose could have been subserved by these small upright stones. + +Notwithstanding the use of large stones for special purposes the pueblo +builders rarely appreciated the advantages that might be obtained by the +proper use of such material. Pueblo masonry is essentially made up of +small, often minute, constructional units. This restriction doubtless +resulted in a higher degree of mural finish than would otherwise have +been attained, but it also imposes certain limitations upon their +architectural achievement. Some of these are noted in the discussion of +openings and of other details of construction. + +Pl. XLV, an illustration of a Mormon mill building at Moen-kopi, already +referred to in the description of that village, is introduced for the +purpose of comparing the methods adopted by the natives and by the +whites in the treatment of the same class of material. Perhaps the most +noteworthy contrast is seen in the sills and lintels of the openings. + +ROOFS AND FLOORS. + +In the pueblo system of building, roof and floor is one; for all the +floors, except such as are formed immediately on the surface of the +ground, are at the same time the roofs and ceilings of lower rooms. The +pueblo plan of to-day readily admits of additions at any time and almost +at any point of the basal construction. The addition of rooms above +converts a roof into the floor of the new room, so that there can be no +distinction in method of construction between floors and roofs, except +the floors are occasionally covered with a complete paving of thin stone +slabs, a device that in external roofs is confined to the copings that +cap the walls and enframe openings. + + [Illustration: Plate LXX. Court view of Pescado, showing corrals.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 37. Diagram of Zuñi roof construction.] + +The methods of roofing their houses practiced by the pueblo builders +varied but little, and followed the general order of construction that +has been outlined in describing Tusayan house building. The diagram, +shown in Fig. 37, an isometric projection illustrating roof +construction, is taken from a Zuñi example, the building of which was +observed by the writer. The roof is built by first a series of principal +beams or rafters. These are usually straight, round poles of 6 or 8 +inches in diameter, with all bark and projecting knots removed. Squared +beams are of very rare occurrence; the only ones seen were those of the +Tusayan kivas, of Spanish manufacture. In recently constructed houses +the principal beams are often of large size and are very neatly squared +off at the ends. Similar square ended beams of large size are met with +in the ancient work of the Chaco pueblos, but there the enormous labor +involved in producing the result with only the aid of stone implements +is in keeping with the highly finished character of the masonry and the +general massiveness of the construction. The same treatment was adopted +in Kin-tiel, as may be seen in Pl. XCV, which illustrates a beam resting +upon a ledge or offset of the inner walls. The recent introduction of +improved mechanical aids has exerted a strong influence on the character +of the construction in greatly facilitating execution. The use of the +American ax made it a much easier task to cut large timbers, and the +introduction of the "burro" and ox greatly facilitated their +transportation. In the case of the modern pueblos, such as Zuñi, the +dwelling rooms that were built by families so poor as not to have these +aids would to some extent indicate the fact by their more primitive +construction, and particularly by their small size, in this respect more +closely resembling the rooms of the ancient pueblos. As a result the +poorer classes would be more likely to perpetuate primitive devices, +through the necessity for practicing methods that to the wealthier +members of the tribe were becoming a matter of tradition only. In such a +sedentary tribe as the present Zuñi, these differences of wealth and +station are more marked than one would expect to find among a people +practicing a style of architecture so evidently influenced by the +communal principle, and the architecture of to-day shows the effect of +such distinctions. In the house of the governor of Zuñi a new room has +been recently built, in which the second series of the roof, that +applied over the principal beams, consisted of pine shakes or shingles, +and these supported the final earth covering without any intervening +material. In the typical arrangement, however, illustrated in the +figure, the first series, or principal beams, are covered by another +series of small poles, about an inch and a half or two inches in +diameter, at right angles to the first, and usually laid quite close +together. The ends of these small poles are partially embedded in the +masonry of the walls. In an example of the more careful and laborious +work of the ancient builders seen at Peñasco Blanco, on the Chaco, the +principal beams were covered with narrow boards, from 2 to 4 inches wide +and about 1 inch thick, over which was put the usual covering of earth. +The boards had the appearance of having been split out with wedges, the +edges and faces having the characteristic fibrous appearance of torn or +split wood. At Zuñi an instance occurs where split poles have been used +for the second series of a roof extending through the whole thickness of +the wall and projecting outside, as is commonly the case with the first +series. A similar arrangement was seen in a ruined tower in the vicinity +of Fort Wingate, New Mexico. In the typical roof construction +illustrated the second series is covered with small twigs or brush, +laid in close contact and at right angles to the underlying series, or +parallel with the main beams. Pl. XCVI, illustrating an unroofed adobe +house in Zuñi, shows several bundles of this material on an adjoining +roof. This series is in turn covered with a layer of grass and small +brush, again at right angles, which prepares the frame for the reception +of the final earth covering, this latter being the fifth application to +the roof. In the example illustrated the entire earth covering of the +roof was finished in a single application of the material. It has been +seen that at Tusayan a layer of moistened earth is applied, followed by +a thicker layer of the dry soil. + +In ancient construction, the method of arranging the material varied +somewhat. In some cases series 3 was very carefully constructed of +straight willow wands laid side by side in contact. This gave a very +neat appearance to the ceiling within the room. Examples were seen in +Canyon de Chelly, at Mummy Cave, and at Hungo Pavie and Pueblo Bonito on +the Chaco. + + [Illustration: Plate LXXI. Pescado houses.] + +Again examples occur where series 2 is composed of 2-inch poles in +contact and the joints are chinked on the upper side with small stones +to prevent the earth from sifting through. This arrangement was seen in +a small cluster on the canyon bottom on the de Chelly. + +The small size of available roofing rafters has at Tusayan brought about +a construction of clumsy piers of masonry in a few of the larger rooms, +which support the ends of two sets of main girders, and these in turn +carry series 1, or the main ceiling beams of the roof. The girders are +generally double, an arrangement that has been often employed in ancient +times, as many examples occur among the ruins. The purpose of such +arrangement may have been to admit of the abutment of the ends of series +1, when the members of the latter were laid in contact. In the absence +of squared beams, which seem never to have been used in the old work, +this abutment could only be securely accomplished by the use of double +girders, as suggested in the following diagram, Fig. 38. + + [Illustration: Fig. 38. Showing abutment of smaller roof beams over + round girders.] + +The final roof covering, composed of clay, is usually laid on very +carefully and firmly, and, when the surface is unbroken, answers fairly +well as a watershed. A slight slope or fall is given to the roof. This +roof subserves every purpose of a front yard to the rooms that open upon +it, and seems to be used exactly like the ground itself. Sheepskins are +stretched and pegged out upon it for tanning or drying, and the +characteristic Zuñi dome-shaped oven is frequently built upon it. In +Zuñi generally upper rooms are provided only with a mud floor, although +occasionally the method of paving with large thin slabs of stone is +adopted. These are often somewhat irregular in form, the object being to +have them as large as possible, so that considerable ingenuity is often +displayed in selecting the pieces and in joining the irregular edges. +This arrangement, similar to that of the kiva floors of Tusayan, is +occasionally met with in the kivas. + +In making excavations at Kin-tiel, the floor of the ground room in which +the circular door illustrated in Pl. C, was found was paved with large, +irregular fragments of stone, the thickness of which did not average +more than an inch. Its floor, whose paving was all in place, was strewn +with broken, irregular fragments similar in character, which must have +been used as the flooring of an upper chamber. + +WALL COPINGS AND ROOF DRAINS. + +In the construction of the typical pueblo house the walls are carried up +to the height of the roof surface, and are then capped with a continuous +protecting coping of thin flat stones, laid in close contact, their +outer edges flush with the face of the wall. This arrangement is still +the prevailing one at Tusayan, though there is an occasional example of +the projecting coping that practically forms a cornice. This latter is +the more usual form at Zuñi, though in the farming pueblos of Cibola it +does not occur with any greater frequency than at Tusayan. The flush +coping is in Tusayan made of the thinnest and most uniform specimens of +building stone available, but these are not nearly so well adapted to +the purpose as those found in the vicinity of Zuñi. + +Here the projecting stones are of singularly regular and symmetrical +form, and receive very little artificial treatment. Their extreme +thinness makes it easy to trim off the projecting corners and angles, +reducing them to such a form that they can be laid in close contact. +Thus laid they furnish an admirable protection against the destructive +action of the violent rains. The stones are usually trimmed to a width +corresponding to the thickness of the walls. Of course where a +projecting cornice is built, it can be made, to some extent, to conform +to the width of available coping stones. These can usually be procured, +however, of nearly uniform width. In the case of the overhanging +cornices the necessary projection is attained by continuing either the +main roof beams, or sometimes the smaller poles of the second series, +according to the position of the required cornice, for a foot or more +beyond the outer face of the wall. Over these poles the roofing is +continued as in ordinary roof construction with the exception that the +edge of the earth covering is built of masonry, an additional precaution +against its destruction by the rains. In many places the adobe +plastering originally applied to the faces of these cornices, as well as +to the walls, has been washed away, exposing the whole construction. In +some of these instances the face of the cornice furnishes a complete +section of the roof, in which all the series of its construction can be +readily identified. The protective agency of these coping stones is well +illustrated in Pl. XCVII, which shows the destructive effect of rain at +a point where an open joint has admitted enough water to bare the +masonry of the cornice face, eating through its coating of adobe, while +at the firmly closed joint toward the left there has been no erosive +action. The much larger proportion of projecting copings or cornices in +Zuñi, as compared with Tusayan, is undoubtedly attributable to the +universal smoothing of the walls with adobe, and to the more general use +of this perishable medium in this village, and the consequent necessity +for protecting the walls. The efficiency of this means of protecting the +wall against the wear of weather is seen in the preservation of external +whitewashing for several feet below such a cornice on the face of the +walls. At the pueblo of Acoma a similar extensive use of projecting +cornices is met with, particularly on the third story walls. Here again +it is due to the use of adobe, which has been more frequently employed +in the finish of the higher and newer portions of the village than in +the lower terraces. As a rule these overhanging copings occur +principally on the southern exposures of the buildings and on the +terraced sides of house rows. When walls rise to the height of several +stories directly from the ground, such as the back walls of house rows, +they are not usually provided with this feature but are capped with +flush copings. + + [Illustration: Plate LXXII. Fragments of ancient masonry in Pescado.] + +The rapid and destructive erosion of the earthen roof covering must have +early stimulated the pueblo architect to devise means for promptly +distributing where it would do the least harm, the water which came upon +his house. This necessity must have led to the early use of roof drains, +for in no other way could the ancient builders have provided for the +effectual removal of the water from, the roofs and at the same time have +preserved intact the masonry of the walls. Unfortunately we have no +examples of such features in the ruined pueblos, for in the destruction +or decay of the houses they are among the first details to be lost. The +roof drain in the modern architecture becomes a very prominent feature, +particularly at Zuñi. + + [Illustration: Fig. 39. Single stone roof drains.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 40. Trough roof drains of stone.] + +These drains are formed by piercing an opening through the thickness of +the coping wall, at a point where the drainage from the roof would +collect, the opening being made with a decided pitch and furnished with +a spout or device of some kind to insure the discharge of the water +beyond the face of the wall. These spouts assume a variety of forms. +Perhaps the most common is that of a single long, narrow slab of stone, +set at a suitable angle and of sufficient projection to throw the +discharge clear of the wall. Fig. 39 illustrates drains of this type, +No. 1 being a Tusayan example and No. 2 from Zuñi. It will be noted that +the surrounding masonry of the former, as well as the stone itself, are +much ruder than the Zuñi example. Another type of drain, not differing +greatly from the preceding, is illustrated in Fig. 40. This form is a +slight improvement on the single stone drain, as it is provided with +side pieces which convert the device into a trough-like spout, and more +effectually direct the discharge. No. 1 is a Tusayan spout and No. 2 a +Zuñi example. Wooden spouts are also commonly used for this purpose. +Fig. 41 illustrates an example from each province of this form of drain. +These are usually made from small tree trunks, not exceeding 3 or 4 +inches in diameter, and are gouged out from one side. No tubular +specimens of wooden spouts were seen. At Tusayan the builders have +utilized stone of a concretionary formation for roof drains. The workers +in stone could not wish for material more suitably fashioned for the +purpose than these specimens. Two of these curious stone channels are +illustrated in Fig. 42. Two more examples of Tusayan roof drains are +illustrated in Fig. 43. The first of the latter shows the use of a +discarded metate, or mealing stone, and the second of a gourd that has +been walled into the coping. + + [Illustration: Fig. 41. Wooden roof drains.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 42. Curved roof drains of stone in Tusayan.] + + [Illustration: Plate LXXIV. General view of Ojo Caliente.] + +It is said that tubes of clay were used at Awatubi in olden times for +roof drains, but there remains no positive evidence of this. Three forms +of this device are attributed to the people of that village. Some are +said to have been made of wood, others of stone, and some again of +sun-dried clay. The native explanation of the use in this connection of +sun-dried clay, instead of the more durable baked product, was that the +application of fire to any object that water passes through would be +likely to dry up the rains. It was stated in this connection that at the +present day the cobs of the corn used for planting are not burned until +rain has fallen on the crop. If the clay spout described really existed +among the people at Awatubi, it was likely to have been an innovation +introduced by the Spanish missionaries. Among the potsherds picked up at +this ruin was a small piece of coarsely made clay tube, which seemed to +be too large and too roughly modeled to have been the handle of a ladle, +which it roughly resembled, or to have belonged to any other known form +of domestic pottery. As a roof drain its use would not accord with the +restrictions referred to in the native account, as the piece had been +burnt. + + [Illustration: Fig. 43. Tusayan roof drains; a discarded metate and + a gourd.] + +In some cases in Zuñi where drains discharge from the roofs of upper +terraces directly upon those below, the lower roofs and also the +adjoining vertical walls are protected by thin tablets of stone, as +shown in Fig. 44. It will be seen that one of these is placed upon the +lower roof in such a position that the drainage falls directly upon it. +Where the adobe roof covering is left unprotected its destruction by the +rain is very rapid, as the showers of the rainy season in these regions, +though usually of short duration, are often extremely violent. The force +of the torrents is illustrated in the neighboring country. Here small +ruts in the surface of the ground are rapidly converted into large +arroyos. Frequently ordinary wagon tracks along a bit of valley slope +serve as an initial channel to the rapidly accumulating waters and are +eaten away in a few weeks so that the road becomes wholly impassable, +and must be abandoned for a new one alongside. + + [Illustration: Fig. 44. Zuñi roof drain, with splash stones on roof + below.] + +The shiftlessness of the native builders in the use of the more +convenient material brings its own penalty during this season in a +necessity for constant watchfulness and frequent repairs to keep the +houses habitable. One can often see in Zuñi where an inefficient drain +or a broken coping has given the water free access to the face of a +plastered wall, carrying away all its covering and exposing in a +vertical space the jagged stones of the underlying masonry. It is +noticeable that much more attention has been paid to protective devices +at Zuñi than at Tusayan. This is undoubtedly due to the prevalent use of +adobe in the former. This friable material must be protected at all +vulnerable points with slabs of stone in order quickly to divert the +water and preserve the roofs and walls from destruction. + +LADDERS AND STEPS. + +In the inclosed court of the old fortress pueblos the first terrace was +reached only by means of ladders, but the terraces or rooms above this +were reached both by ladders and steps. The removal of the lower tier of +ladders thus gave security against intrusion and attack. The builders of +Tusayan have preserved this primitive arrangement in much greater purity +than those of Cibola. + + [Illustration: Plate LXXV. House at Ojo Caliente.] + +In Zuñi numerous ladders are seen on every terrace, but the purpose of +these, on the highest terraces, is not to provide access to the rooms of +the upper story, which always have external doors opening on the +terraces, but to facilitate repairs of the roofs. At Tusayan, on the +other hand, ladders are of rare occurrence above the first terrace, +their place being supplied by flights of stone steps. The relative +scarcity of stone at Zuñi, suitable for building material, and its great +abundance at Tusayan, undoubtedly account for this difference of usage, +especially as the proximity of the timber supply of the Zuñi mountains +to the former facilitates the substitution of wood for steps of masonry. + + [Illustration: Fig. 45. A modern notched ladder in Oraibi.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 46. Tusayan notched ladders from Mashongnavi.] + +The earliest form of ladder among the pueblos was probably a notched +log, a form still occasionally used. Figures 45 and 46 illustrate +examples of this type of ladder from Tusayan. + +A notched ladder from Oraibi, made with a modern axe, is shown. This +specimen has a squareness of outline and an evenness of surface not +observed in the ancient examples. The ladder from Mashongnavi, +illustrated on the left of Fig. 46, closely resembles the Oraibi +specimen, though the workmanship is somewhat ruder. The example +illustrated on the right of the same figure is from Oraibi. This ladder +is very old, and its present rough and weatherbeaten surface affords but +little evidence of the character of the implement used in making it. + + [Illustration: Fig. 47. Aboriginal American forms of ladder.] + +The ladder having two poles connected by cross rungs is undoubtedly a +native invention, and was probably developed through a series of +improvements on the primitive notched type. It is described in detail in +the earliest Spanish accounts. Fig. 47 illustrates on the left the +notched ladder, and on the right a typical two-pole ladder in its most +primitive form. In this case the rungs are simply lashed to the +uprights. The center ladder of the diagram is a Mandan device +illustrated by Mr. Lewis H. Morgan.[6] As used by the Mandans this +ladder is placed with its forked end on the ground, the reverse of the +Pueblo practice. It will readily be seen, on comparing these examples, +that an elongation of the fork which occurs as a constant accompaniment +of the notched ladder might eventually suggest a construction similar to +that of the Mandan ladder reversed. The function of the fork on the +notched ladder in steadying it when placed against the wall would be +more effectually performed by enlarging this feature. + + [Footnote 6: Cont. to N.A. Ethn., vol. 4, Houses and House life, + pp. 129-131.] + + [Illustration: Plate LXXVII. Outline plan of Zuñi, showing + distribution of oblique openings.] + +At one stage in the development of the form of ladder in common use +to-day the rungs were laid in depressions or notches of the vertical +poles, resembling the larger notches of the single ladder, and then +lashed on with thongs of rawhide or with other materials. Later, when +the use of iron became known, holes were burned through the side poles. +This is the nearly universal practice to-day, though some of the more +skillful pueblo carpenters manage to chisel out rectangular holes. The +piercing of the side poles, particularly prevalent in Zuni, has brought +about a curious departure from the ancient practice of removing the +ladder in times of threatened danger. Long rungs are loosely slipped +into the holes in the side pieces, and the security formerly gained by +taking up the entire ladder is now obtained, partially at least, by the +removal of the rungs. The boring of the side pieces and the employment +of loose rungs seriously interferes with the stability of the structure, +as means must be provided to prevent the spreading apart of the side +pieces. The Zuni architect has met this difficulty by prolonging the +poles of the ladder and attaching a cross piece near their upper ends to +hold them together. As a rule this cross piece is provided with a hole +near each end into which the tapering extremities of the poles are +inserted. From their high position near the extremities of the ladders, +seen in silhouette against the sky, they form peculiarly striking +features of Zuni. They are frequently decorated with rude carvings of +terraced notches. Examples of this device may be seen in the views of +Zuni, and several typical specimens are illustrated in detail in Pl. +XCVIII. The use of cross pieces on ladders emerging from roof openings +is not so common as on external ones, as there is not the same necessity +for holding together the poles, the sides of the opening performing that +office. + +There are two places in Zuni, portions of the densest house cluster, +where the needs of unusual traffic have been met by the employment of +double ladders, made of three vertical poles, which accommodate two +tiers of rungs. The sticks forming the rungs are inserted in continuous +lengths through all three poles, and the cross pieces at the top are +also continuous, being formed of a single flat piece of wood perforated +by three holes for the reception of the tips of the poles. In additional +to the usual cross pieces pierced for the reception of the side poles +and rudely carved into ornamental forms, many temporary cross pieces are +added during the harvest season in the early autumn to support the +strips of meat and melons, strings of red peppers, and other articles +dried in the open air prior to storage for winter use. At this season +every device that will serve this purpose is employed. Occasionally +poles are seen extending across the reentering angles of a house or are +supported on the coping and rafters. The projecting roof beams also are +similarly utilized at this season. + +Zuni ladders are usually provided with about eight rungs, but a few have +as many as twelve. The women ascend these ladders carrying ollas of +water on their heads, children play upon them, and a few of the most +expert of the numerous dogs that infest the village can clumsily make +their way up and down them. As described in a previous section all +houses built during the year are consecrated at a certain season, and +among other details of the ceremonial, certain rites, intended to +prevent accidents to children, etc., are performed at the foot of the +ladders. + +In Tusayan, where stone is abundant, the ladder has not reached the +elaborate development seen in Zuñi. The perforated cross piece is rarely +seen, as there is little necessity for its adoption. The side poles are +held together by the top and bottom rungs, which pass entirely through +the side pieces and are securely fixed, while the ends of the others are +only partly embedded in the side pieces. In other cases (Pl. XXXII) the +poles are rigidly held in place by ropes or rawhide lashings. + +Short ladders whose side poles are but little prolonged beyond the top +rung are of common occurrence, particularly in Oraibi. Three such +ladders are shown in Pl. LXXXIV. A similar example may be seen in Pl. +CVII, in connection with a large opening closed with rough masonry. In +these cases the rungs are made to occupy slight notches or depressions +in the upright poles and are then firmly lashed with rawhide, forming a +fairly rigid structure. This type of ladder is probably a survival of +the earliest form of the pueblo ladder. + +In addition to the high cross piece whose function is to retain in place +the vertical poles, the kiva ladders are usually provided, both in Zuñi +and Tusayan, with a cross piece consisting of a round stick tied to the +uprights and placed at a uniform height above the kiva roof. This stick +affords a handhold for the marked dancers who are often encumbered with +ceremonial paraphernalia as they enter the kiva. In the case of the +Oraibi kiva occupying the foreground of Pl. XXXVIII, it may be seen that +this handhold cross piece is inserted into holes in the side poles, an +exception to the general practice. In Pl. LXXXVII, illustrating kivas, +the position of this feature will be seen. + +The exceptional mode of access to Tusayan kiva hatchways by means of +short nights of stone steps has already been noticed. In several +instances the top steps of these short flights cover the thickness of +the wall. The remains of a similar stairway were observed in Pueblo +Bonito, where it evidently reached directly from the ground to an +external doorway. Access by such means, however, is a departure from the +original defensive idea. + + [Illustration: Plate LXXVIII. General inside view of Zuñi, looking + west.] + +Modern practice in Zuñi has departed more widely from the primitive +system than at Tusayan. In the former pueblo short nights of stone steps +giving access to doors raised but a short distance above the ground are +very commonly seen. Even in the small farming pueblo of Pescado two +examples of this arrangement are met with. Pl. XCIX illustrates one of +these found on the north outside wall. In the general views of the +Tusayan villages the closer adherence to primitive methods is clearly +indicated, although the modern compare very unfavorably with the ancient +examples in precision of execution. Pl. XXXII illustrates two flights of +stone steps of Shupaulovi. In many cases the workmanship of these stone +steps does not surpass that seen in the Walpi trail, illustrated in Pl. +XXV. + + [Illustration: Fig. 48. Stone steps at Oraibi, with platform at + corner.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 49. Stone steps, with platform at chimney, + in Oraibi.] + +Perhaps in no one detail of pueblo construction are the careless and +shiftless modern methods so conspicuous as in the stone steps of the +upper terraces of Tusayan. Here are seen many awkward makeshifts by +means of which the builders have tried to compensate for their lack of +foresight in planning. The absence of a definite plan for a house +cluster of many rooms, already noted in the discussion of dwelling-house +construction, is rendered conspicuous by the manner in which the stone +stairways are used. Figs. 48 and 49 illustrate stone steps on upper +terraces in Oraibi. In both cases the steps have been added long after +the rooms against which they abut were built. In order to conform to the +fixed requirement of placing such means of access at the corners of the +upper rooms, the builders constructed a clumsy platform to afford +passage around the previously built chimney. Fig. 50 shows the result of +a similar lack of foresight. The upper portion of the flight, consisting +of three steps, has been abruptly turned at right angles to the main +flight, and is supported upon rude poles and beams. The restriction of +this feature to the corners of upper rooms where they were most likely +to conflict with chimneys is undoubtedly a survival of ancient practice, +and due to the necessary vertical alignment of walls and masonry in this +primitive construction. + + [Illustration: Fig. 50. Stone steps in Shumopavi.] + +COOKING PITS AND OVENS. + +Most of the cooking of the ancient Pueblos was probably done out of +doors, as among the ruins vestiges of cooking pits, almost identical in +character with those still found in Tusayan, are frequently seen. In +Cibola the large dome-shaped ovens, common to the Pueblos of the Rio +Grande and to their Mexican neighbors are in general use. In Tusayan a +few examples of this form of oven occur upon the roofs of the terraces, +while the cooking pit in a variety of forms is still extensively used. + + [Illustration: Plate LXXIX. Zuñi terraces.] + +The distribution of the dome-shaped ovens in Cibola and in Tusayan may +be seen on the ground plans in Chapters III and IV. The simplest form of +cooking pit, still commonly used in Tusayan, consists of a depression in +the ground, lined with a coating of mud. The pit is usually of small +size and is commonly placed at some little distance from the house; in a +few cases it is located in a sheltered corner of the building. Fig. 51 +illustrates a series of three such primitive ovens built against a house +wall, in a low bench or ledge of masonry raised 6 inches above the +ground; the holes measure about a foot across and are about 18 or 20 +inches deep. Many similar pits occur in the Tusayan villages; some of +them are walled in with upright stone slabs, whose rough edges project 6 +or 8 inches above the ground, the result closely resembling the ancient +form of in-door fireplace, such as that seen in a room of Kin-tiel. (Pl. +C.) + + [Illustration: Fig. 51. A series of cooking pits in Mashongnavi.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 52. Pi-gummi ovens of Mashongnavi.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 53. Cross sections of pi-gummi ovens of + Mashongnavi.] + +In its perfected form the cooking pit in Tusayan takes the place of the +more elaborate oven used in Zuñi. Figs. 52 and 53 show two specimens of +pits used for the preparation of pi-gummi, a kind of baked mush. + +These occur on the east side of Mashongnavi. They project 6 or 8 inches +above the ground, and have a depth of from 18 to 24 inches. The débris +scattered about the pits indicates the manner in which they are covered +with slabs of stone and sealed with mud when in use. In all the oven, +devices of the pueblos the interior is first thoroughly heated by a long +continued fire within, the structure. When the temperature is +sufficiently high the ashes and dirt are cleaned out, the articles to be +cooked inserted, and the orifices sealed. The food is often left in +these heated receptacles for 12 hours or more, and on removal it is +generally found to be very nicely cooked. Each of the pi-gummi ovens +illustrated above is provided with a tube-like orifice 3 or 4 inches in +diameter, descending obliquely from the ground level into the cavity. +Through this opening the fire is arranged and kept in order, and in this +respect it seems to be the counterpart of the smaller hole of the Zuñi +dome-shaped ovens. When the principal opening, by which the vessel +containing the pi-gummi or other articles is introduced, has been +covered with a slab of stone and sealed with mud, the effect is similar +to that of the dome-shaped oven when the ground-opening or doorway is +hermetically closed. + +No example of the dome-shaped oven of pre-Columbian origin has been +found among the pueblo ruins, although its prototype probably existed in +ancient times, possibly in the form of a kiln for baking a fine quality +of pottery formerly manufactured. However, the cooking pit alone, +developed to the point of the pi-gummi oven of Tusayan, may have been +the stem upon which the foreign idea was engrafted. Instances of the +complete adoption by these conservative people of a wholly foreign idea +or feature of construction are not likely to be found, as improvements +are almost universally confined to the mere modification of existing +devices. In the few instances in which more radical changes are +attempted the resulting forms bear evidence of the fact. + + [Illustration: Fig. 54. Diagram showing foundation stones of a Zuñi + oven.] + + [Illustration: Plate LXXX. Old adobe church of Zuñi.] + +In Cibola the construction of a dome-shaped oven is begun by laying out +roughly a circle of flat stones as a foundation. Upon these the upper +structure is rudely built of stones laid in the mud and approximately in +the courses, though often during construction one side will be carried +considerably higher than another. The walls curve inward to an +apparently unsafe degree, but the mud mortar is often allowed to partly +dry before carrying the overhanging portion so far as to endanger the +structure, and accidents rarely happen. The oven illustrated in Pl. +XCVII shows near its broken doorway the arrangement of foundation stones +referred to. Typical examples of the dome oven occur in the foreground +of the general view of Zuñi shown in Pl. LXXVIII. + +The dome ovens of Cibola are generally smoothly plastered, inside and +out, but a few examples are seen in which the stones of the masonry are +exposed. In. Pl. XCIX may be seen two ovens differing in size, one of +which shows the manner in which the opening is blocked up with stone to +keep out stray dogs during periods of disuse. Fig. 55 illustrates a +mud-plastered oven at Pescado, which is elevated about a foot above the +ground on a base or plinth of masonry. The opening of this oven is on +the side toward the houses. This form is quite exceptional in Cibola, +though of frequent occurrence among the Rio Grande pueblos. A very large +and carefully finished example was examined at Jemez. + + [Illustration: Fig. 55. Dome-shaped oven on a plinth of masonry.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 56. Oven in Pescado exposing stones of masonry.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 57. Oven in Pescado exposing stones of masonry.] + +Figs. 56 and 57 illustrate two specimens of rough masonry ovens seen at +Pescado. In one of these a decided horizontal arrangement of the stones +in the masonry prevails. The specimen at the right is small and rudely +constructed, showing but little care in the use of the building +material. The few specimens of dome ovens seen in Tusayan are +characterized by the same rudeness of construction noticed in their +house masonry. The rarity of this oven at Tusayan, where so many of the +constructions have retained a degree of primitiveness not seen +elsewhere, is perhaps an additional evidence of its foreign origin. + + [Illustration: Plate LXXXI. Eastern rows of Zuñi.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 58. Shrines in Mashongnavi.] + +OVEN-SHAPED STRUCTURES. + +In Tusayan, there are other structures, of rude dome-shape, likely to be +mistaken for some form of cooking device. Fig. 58 illustrates two +specimens of shrines that occur in courts of Mashongnavi. These are +receptacles for plume sticks (bahos) and other votive offerings used at +certain festivals, which, after being so used, are sealed up with stone +slabs and adobe. These shrines occur at several of the villages, as +noted in the discussion of the plans in Chapter III. In the foreground +of Pl. XXXVIII may be seen an Oraibi specimen somewhat resembling those +seen at Mashongnavi. + + [Illustration: Fig. 59. A poultry house in Sichumovi resembling an + oven.] + +Fig. 59 illustrates a very rude structure of stones in Sichumovi, +resembling in form a dome oven, which is used as a poultry house. +Several of these are seen in the Tusayan villages. + +FIREPLACES AND CHIMNEYS. + +The original fireplace of the ancient pueblo builders was probably the +simple cooking pit transferred to a position within the dwelling room, +and employed for the lighter cooking of the family as well as for +warming the dwelling. It was placed in the center of the floor in order +that the occupants of the house might conveniently gather around it. One +of the first improvements made in this shallow indoor cooking pit must +have consisted in surrounding it with a wall of sufficient height to +protect the fire against drafts, as seen in the outdoor pits of Tusayan. +In excavating a room in the ancient pueblo of Kin-tiel, a completely +preserved fireplace, about a foot deep, and walled in with thin slabs of +stone set on edge, was brought to light. The depression had been +hollowed out of the solid rock. + + [Illustration: Fig. 60. Ground plan of an excavated room in Kin-tiel.] + +This fireplace, together with the room in which it was found, is +illustrated in Pl. C and Fig. 60. It is of rectangular form, but other +examples have been found which are circular. Mr. W. H. Jackson describes +a fireplace in a cliff dwelling in "Echo Cave" that consisted of a +circular, basin-like depression 30 inches across and 10 inches deep. +Rooms furnishing evidence that fires were made in the corners against +the walls are found in many cliff dwellings; the smoke escaped overhead, +and the blackened walls afford no trace of a chimney or flue of any +kind. + +The pueblo chimney is undoubtedly a post-Spanish feature, and the best +forms in use at the present time are probably of very recent origin, +though they are still associated with fireplaces that have departed +little from the aboriginal form seen at Kin-tiel and elsewhere. It is +interesting to note, in this connection, that the ceremony consecrating +the house is performed in Tusayan before the chimney is added, +suggesting that the latter feature did not form a part of the aboriginal +dwelling. + + [Illustration: Plate LXXXII. A Zuñi court.] + +In Cibola a few distinct forms of chimney are used at the present time, +but in the more remote Tusayan the chimney seems to be still in the +experimental stage. Numbers of awkward constructions, varying from the +ordinary cooking pit to the more elaborate hooded structures, testify to +the chaotic condition of the chimney-building art in the latter +province. + +Before the invention of a chimney hood, and while the primitive +fireplace occupied a central position in the floor of the room, the +smoke probably escaped through the door and window openings. Later a +hole in the roof provided an exit, as in the kivas of to-day, where +ceremonial use has perpetuated an arrangement long since superseded in +dwelling-house construction. The comfort of a dwelling room provided +with this feature is sufficiently attested by the popularity of the +modern kivas as a resort for the men. The idea of a rude hood or flue to +facilitate the egress of the smoke would not be suggested until the +fireplace was transferred from the center of a room to a corner, and in +the first adoption of this device the builders would rely upon the +adjacent walls for the needed support of the constructional members. +Practically all of the chimneys of Tusayan are placed in corners at the +present time, though the Zuñi builders have developed sufficient skill +to construct a rigid hood and flue in the center of a side wall, as may +be seen in the view of a Zuñi interior, Pl. LXXXVI. + +Although the pueblo chimney owes its existence to foreign suggestion it +has evidently reached its present form through a series of timid +experiments, and the proper principles of its construction seem to have +been but feebly apprehended by the native builders, particularly in +Tusayan. The early form of hood, shown in Fig. 66, was made by placing a +short supporting pole across the corner of a room at a sufficient +distance from the floor and upon it arranging sticks to form the frame +work of a contracting hood or flue. The whole construction was finally +covered with a thick coating of mud. This primitive wooden construction +has probably been in use for a long time, although it was modified in +special cases so as to extend across the entire width of narrow rooms to +accommodate "piki" stones or other cumbersome cooking devices. It +embodies the principle of roof construction that must have been employed +in the primitive house from which the pueblo was developed, and +practically constitutes a miniature conical roof suspended over the +fireplace and depending upon the walls of the room for support. On +account of the careful and economical use of fuel by these people the +light and inflammable material of which the chimney is constructed does +not involve the danger of combustion that would be expected. The perfect +feasibility of such use of wood is well illustrated in some of the old +log-cabin chimneys in the Southern States, where, however, the +arrangement of the pieces is horizontal, not vertical. These latter +curiously exemplify also the use of a miniature section of house +construction to form a conduit for the smoke, placed at a sufficient +height to admit of access to the fire. + +A further improvement in the chimney was the construction of a corner +hood support by means of two short poles instead of a single piece, thus +forming a rectangular smoke hood of enlarged capacity. This latter is +the most common form in use at the present time in both provinces, but +its arrangement in Tusayan, where it represents the highest achievement +of the natives in chimney construction, is much more varied than in +Cibola. In the latter province the same form is occasionally executed in +stone. Fig. 61 illustrates a corner hood, in which the crossed ends of +the supporting poles are exposed to view. The outer end of the lower +pole is supported from the roof beams by a cord or rope, the latter +being embedded in the mud plastering with which the hood is finished. +The vertically ridged character of the surface reveals the underlying +construction, in which light sticks have been used as a base for the +plaster. The Tusayans say that large sunflower stalks are preferred for +this purpose on account of their lightness. Figs. 63 and 64 show another +Tusayan hood of the type described, and in Fig. 69 a large hood of the +same general form, suspended over a piki-stone, is noticeable for the +frank treatment of the suspending cords, which are clearly exposed to +view for nearly their entire length. + + [Illustration: Fig. 61. A corner chimney hood with two supporting + poles (Tusayan).] + +In a chimney in a Mashongnavi house, illustrated in Fig. 62, a simple, +sharply curved piece of wood has been used for the lower rim of this +hood, thus obtaining all the capacity of the two-poled form. The +vertical sticks in this example are barely discernible through the +plastering, which has been applied with more than the usual degree of +care. + + [Illustration: Fig. 62. A curved chimney hood of Mashongnavi.] + + [Illustration: Plate LXXXIII. A Zuñi small house.] + +A curious example illustrating a rudimentary form of two-poled hood is +shown in Fig. 63. A straight pole of unusual length is built into the +walls across the corner of a room, and its insertion into the wall is +much farther from the corner on one side than the other. From the longer +stretch of inclosed wall protrudes a short pole that joins the principal +one and serves as a support for one side of the chimney-hood. In this +case the builder appears to have been too timid to venture on the bolder +construction required in the perfected two-poled hood. This example +probably represents a stage in the development of the higher form. + + [Illustration: Fig. 63. A Mashongnavi chimney hood and walled up + fireplace.] + +In some instances the rectangular corner hood is not suspended from the +ceiling, but is supported from beneath by a stone slab or a piece of +wood. Such a chimney hood seen in a house of Shupaulovi measures nearly +4 by 5 feet. The short side is supported by two stone slabs built into +the wall and extending from the hood to the floor. Upon the upper stone +rests one end of the wooden lintel supporting the long side, while the +other end, near the corner of the room, is held in position by a light +crotch of wood. Fig. 64 illustrates this hood; the plan indicating the +relation of the stones and the forked stick to the corner of the room. +Fig. 71, illustrating a terrace fireplace and chimney of Shumopavi, +shows the employment of similar supports. + +Corner chimney hoods in Zuñi do not differ essentially from the more +symmetrical of the Tusayan specimens, but they are distinguished by +better finish, and by less exposure of the framework, having been, like +the ordinary masonry, subjected to an unusually free application of +adobe. + + [Illustration: Fig. 64. A chimney hood of Shupaulovi.] + +The builders of Tusayan appear to have been afraid to add the necessary +weight of mud mortar to produce this finished effect, the hoods usually +showing a vertically ridged or crenated surface, caused by the sticks of +the framework showing through the thin mud coat. Stone also is often +employed in their construction, and its use has developed a large, +square-headed type of chimney unknown at Tusayan. This is illustrated in +Fig. 65. This form of hood, projecting some distance beyond its flue, +affords space that may be used as a mantel-shelf, an advantage gained +only to a very small degree by the forms discussed above. This chimney, +as before stated, is built against one of the walls of a room, and near +the middle. + + [Illustration: Fig. 65. A semi-detached square chimney hood of Zuñi.] + + [Illustration: Plate LXXXIV. A house-building at Oraibi.] + +All the joints of these hoods, and even the material used, are generally +concealed from view by a carefully applied coating of plaster, +supplemented by a gypsum wash, and usually there is no visible evidence +of the manner in which they are built, but the construction is little +superior to that of the simple corner hoods. The method of framing the +various types of hoods is illustrated in Fig. 66. The example on the +left shows an unplastered wooden hood skeleton. The arrangement of the +parts in projecting rectangular stone hoods is illustrated in the +right-hand diagram of the figure. In constructing such a chimney a thin +buttress is first built against the wall of sufficient width and height +to support one side of the hood. The opposite side of the hood is +supported by a flat stone, firmly set on edge into the masonry of the +wall. The front of the hood is supported by a second flat stone which +rests at one end on a rude shoulder in the projecting slab, and at the +other end upon the front edge of the buttress. It would be quite +practicable for the pueblo builders to form a notch in the lower corner +of the supported stone to rest firmly upon a projection of the +supporting stone, but in the few cases in which the construction could +be observed no such treatment was seen, for they depended mainly on the +interlocking of the ragged ends of the stones. This structure serves to +support the body of the flue, usually with an intervening stone-covered +space forming a shelf. At the present period the flue is usually built +of thin sandstone slabs, rudely adjusted to afford mutual support. The +whole structure is bound together and smoothed over with mud plastering, +and is finally finished with the gypsum wash, applied also to the rest +of the room. Mr. A. F. Bandelier describes "a regular chimney, with +mantel and shelf, built of stone slabs," which he found "in the caves of +the Rito de los Frijoles, as well as in the cliff dwellings of the +regular detached family house type,"[7] which, from the description, +must have closely resembled the Zuñi chimney described above. Houses +containing such devices may be quite old, but if so they were certainly +reoccupied in post-Spanish times. Such dwellings are likely to have been +used as places of refuge in times of danger up to a comparatively recent +date. + + [Footnote 7: Fifth Ann. Rept. Arch. Inst. Am., p. 74.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 66. Unplastered Zuñi chimney hoods, illustrating + construction.] + +Among the many forms of chimneys and fireplaces seen in Tusayan a +curious approach to our own arrangement of fireplace and mantel was +noticed in a house in Sichumovi. In addition to the principal mantel +ledge, a light wooden shelf was arranged against the wall on one side of +the flue, one of its ends being supported by an upright piece of wood +with a cap, and the other resting on a peg driven into the wall. This +fireplace and mantel is illustrated in Fig. 67. + +Aside from the peculiar "guyave" or "piki" baking oven, there is but +little variation in the form of indoor fireplaces in Cibola, while in +Tusayan it appears to have been subjected to about the same mutations +already noted in the outdoor cooking pits. A serious problem was +encountered by the Tusayan builder when he was called upon to construct +cooking-pit fireplaces, a foot or more deep, in a loom of an upper +terrace. As it was impracticable to sink the pit into the floor, the +necessary depth was obtained by walling up the sides, as is shown in +Fig. 68, which illustrates a second-story fireplace in Mashongnavi. +Other examples may be seen in the outdoor chimneys shown in Figs. 72 and +73. + + [Illustration: Fig. 67. A fireplace and mantel in Sichumovi.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 68. A second-story fireplace in Mashongnavi.] + + [Illustration: Plate LXXXV. A Tusayan interior.] + +A modification of the interior fireplace designed for cooking the thin, +paper-like bread, known to the Spanish-speaking peoples of this region +as "guyave," and by the Tusayan as "piki," is common to both Cibola and +Tusayan, though in the former province the contrivance is more carefully +constructed than in the latter, and the surface of the baking stone +itself is more highly finished. In the guyave oven a tablet of carefully +prepared sandstone is supported in a horizontal position by two slabs +set on edge and firmly imbedded in the floor. A horizontal flue is thus +formed in which the fire is built. The upper stone, whose surface is to +receive the thin guyave batter, undergoes during its original +preparation a certain treatment with fire and piñon gum, and perhaps +other ingredients, which imparts to it a highly polished black finish. +This operation is usually performed away from the pueblo, near a point +where suitable stone is found, and is accompanied by a ceremonial, which +is intended to prevent the stone from breaking on exposure to the fire +when first used. During one stage of these rites the strictest silence +is enjoined, as, according to the native account, a single word spoken +at such a time would crack the tablet. + + [Illustration: Fig. 69. Piki stone and chimney hood in Sichumovi.] + +When the long guyave stone is in position upon the edges of the back and +front stones the fire must be so applied as to maintain the stone at a +uniform temperature. This is done by frequent feeding with small bits of +sage brush or other fuel. The necessity for such economy in the use of +fuel has to a certain extent affected the forms of all the heating and +cooking devices. Fig. 69 illustrates a Sichumovi piki stone, and Fig. 70 +shows the use of the oven in connection with a cooking fireplace, a +combination that is not uncommon. The latter example is from Shumopavi. +The illustration shows an interesting feature in the use of a primitive +andiron or boss to support the cooking pot in position above the fire. +This boss is modeled from the same clay as the fireplace floor and is +attached to it and forms a part of it. Mr. Stephen has collected free +specimens of these primitive props which had never been attached to the +floor. These were of the rudely conical form illustrated in the figure, +and were made of a coarsely mixed clay thoroughly baked to a stony +hardness. + + [Illustration: Fig. 70. Piki stone and primitive andiron in + Shumopavi.] + + [Illustration: Plate LXXXVI. A Zuñi interior.] + +Chimneys and fireplaces are often found in Tusayan in the small, +recessed, balcony-like rooms of the second terrace. When a deep +cooking-pit is required in such a position, it is obtained by building +up the sides, as in the indoor fireplaces of upper rooms. Such a +fireplace is illustrated in Fig. 71. A roofed recess which usually +occurs at one end of the first terrace, called "tupubi," takes its name +from the flat piki oven, the variety of fireplace generally built in +these alcoves. The transfer of the fireplace from the second-story room +to the corner of such a roofed-terrace alcove was easily accomplished, +and probably led to the occasional use of the cooking-pit, with +protecting chimney hood on the open and unsheltered roof. Fig. 72 +illustrates a deep cooking-pit on an upper terrace of Walpi. In this +instance the cooking pit is very massively built, and in the absence of +a sheltering "tupubi" corner is effectually protected on three sides by +mud-plastered stone work, the whole being capped with the usual +chimneypot. The contrivance is placed conveniently near the roof +hatchway of a dwelling room. + + [Illustration: Fig. 71. A terrace fireplace and chimney of Shumopavi.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 72. A terrace cooking-pit and chimney of Walpi.] + +The outdoor use of the above-described fireplaces on upper terraces has +apparently suggested the improvement of the ground cooking pit in a +similar manner. Several specimens were seen in which the cooking pit of +the ordinary depressed type, excavated near an inner corner of a house +wall, was provided with sheltering masonry and a chimney cap; but such +an arrangement is by no means of frequent occurrence. Fig. 73 +illustrates an example that was seen on the east side of Shumopavi. It +will be noticed that in the use of this arrangement on the ground--an +arrangement that evidently originated on the terraces--the builders have +reverted to the earlier form of excavated pit. In other respects the +example illustrated is not distinguishable from the terrace forms above +described. + + [Illustration: Fig. 73. A ground cooking-pit of Shumopavi covered with + a chimney.] + +In the discussion of the details of kiva arrangement in Tusayan (p. 121) +it was shown that the chimney is not used in any form in these +ceremonial chambers; but the simple roof-opening forming the hatchway +serves as a smoke vent, without the addition of either an internal hood +or an external shaft. In the Zuñi kivas the smoke also finds vent +through the opening that gives access to the chamber, but in the framing +of the roof, as is shown elsewhere, some distinction between door and +chimney is observed. The roof-hole is made double, one portion +accommodating the ingress ladder and the other intended to serve for the +egress of the smoke. + + [Illustration: Plate LXXXVII. A kiva hatchway of Tusayan.] + +The external chimney of the pueblos is a simple structure, and exhibits +but few variations from the type. The original form was undoubtedly a +mere hole in the roof; its use is perpetuated in the kivas. This +primitive form was gradually improved by raising its sides above the +roof, forming a rudimentary shaft. The earlier forms are likely to have +been rectangular, the round following and developing later short masonry +shafts which were finally given height by the addition of chimney pots. +In Zuñi the chimney has occasionally developed into a rather tall shaft, +projecting sometimes to a height of 4 or 5 feet above the roof. This is +particularly noticeable on the lower terraces of Zuñi, the chimneys of +the higher rooms being more frequently of the short types prevalent in +the farming pueblos of Cibola and in Tusayan. The tall chimneys found in +Zuñi proper, and consisting often of four or five chimney pots on a +substructure of masonry, are undoubtedly due to the same conditions that +have so much influenced other constructional details; that is, the +exceptional height of the clusters and crowding of the rooms. As a +result of this the chimney is a more conspicuous feature in Zuñi than +elsewhere, as will be shown by a comparison of the views of the villages +given in Chapters III and IV. + + [Illustration: Fig. 74. Tusayan chimneys.] + +In Tusayan many of the chimneys are quite low, a single pot surmounting +a masonry substructure not more than 6 inches high being quite common. +As a rule, however, the builders preferred to use a series of pots. Two +typical Tusayan chimneys are illustrated in Fig. 74. Most of the +substructures for chimneys in this province are rudely rectangular in +form, and clearly expose the rough stonework of the masonry, while in +Zuñi the use of adobe generally obliterates all traces of construction. +In both provinces chimneys are seen without the chimney pot. These +usually occur in clusters, simply because the builder of a room or group +of rooms preferred that form of chimney. Pl. CI illustrates a portion of +the upper terraces of Zuñi where a number of masonry chimneys are +grouped together. Those on the highest roof are principally of the +rectangular form, being probably a direct development from the square +roof hole. The latter is still sometimes seen with a rim rising several +inches above the roof surface and formed of slabs set on edge or of +ordinary masonry. These upper chimneys are often closed or covered with +thin slabs of sandstone laid over them in the same manner as the roof +holes that they resemble. The fireplaces to which some of them belong +appear to be used for heating the rooms rather than for cooking, as they +are often disused for long periods during the summer season. + +Pl. CI also illustrates chimneys in which pots have been used in +connection with masonry bases, and also a round masonry chimney. The +latter is immediately behind the single pot chimney seen in the +foreground. On the extreme left of the figure is shown a chimney into +which fire pots have been incorporated, the lower ones being almost +concealed from view by the coating of adobe. A similar effect may be +seen in the small chimney on the highest roof shown in Pl. LVIII. Pl. +LXXXII shows various methods of using the chimney pots. In one case the +chimney is capped with a reversed large-mouthed jar, the broken bottom +serving as an outlet for the smoke. The vessel usually employed for this +purpose is an ordinary black cooking pot, the bottom being burned out, +or otherwise rendered unfit for household use. Other vessels are +occasionally used. Pl. LXXXIII shows the use, as the crowning member of +the chimney, of an ordinary water jar, with dark decorations on a white +ground. A vessel very badly broken is often made to serve in chimney +building by skillful use of mud and mortar. To facilitate smoke exit the +upper pot is made to overlap the neck of the one below by breaking out +the bottom sufficiently. The joining is not often visible, as it is +usually coated with adobe. The lower pots of a series are in many cases +entirely embedded in the adobe. + +The pueblo builder has never been able to construct a detached chimney a +full story in height, either with or without the aid of chimney pots; +where it is necessary to build such shafts to obtain the proper draft he +is compelled to rely on the support of adjoining walls, and usually +seeks a corner. Pl. CI shows a chimney of this kind that has been built +of masonry to the full height of a story. A similar example is shown in +the foreground of Pl. LXXVIII. In Pl. XXII may be seen a chimney of the +full height of the adjoining story, but in this instance it is +constructed wholly of pots. Pl. LXXXV illustrates a similar case +indoors. + +The external chimney probably developed gradually from the simple roof +opening, as previously noted. The raised combing about trapdoors or roof +holes afforded the first suggestion in this direction. From this +developed the square chimney, and finally the tall round shaft, crowned +with a series of pots. The whole chimney, both internal and external, +excluding only the primitive fireplace, is probably of comparatively +recent origin, and based on the foreign (Spanish) suggestion. + +GATEWAYS AND COVERED PASSAGES. + +Gateways, arranged for defense, occur in many of the more +compactly-built ancient pueblos. Some of the passageways in the modern +villages of Tusayan and Cibola resemble these older examples, but most +of the narrow passages, giving access to the inner courts of the +inhabited villages, are not the result of the defensive idea, but are +formed by the crowding together of the dwellings. They occur, as a rule, +within the pueblo and not upon its periphery. Many of the terraces now +face outward and are reached from the outside of the pueblo, being in +marked contrast to the early arrangement, in which narrow passages to +inclose courts were exclusively used for access. In the ground plans of +several villages occupied within historic times, but now ruined, +vestiges of openings arranged on the original defensive plan may be +traced. About midway on the northeast side of Awatubi fragments of a +standing wall were seen, apparently the two sides of a passageway to the +inclosed court of the pueblo. The masonry is much broken down, however, +and no indication is afforded of the treatment adopted, nor do the +remains indicate whether this entrance was originally covered or not. +It is illustrated in Pl. CII. + + [Illustration: Plate LXXXVIII. North kivas of Shumopavi, from the + northeast.] + +Other examples of this feature may be seen in the ground plans of +Tebugkihu, Chukubi, and Payupki (Fig. 7, and Pls. XII and XIII). + +In the first of these the deep jambs of the opening are clearly defined, +but in the other two only low mounds of débris suggest the gateway. In +the ancient Cibolan pueblos, including those on the mesa of Tâaaiyalana, +no remains of external gateways have been found; the plans suggest that +the disposition of the various clusters approximated somewhat the +irregular arrangement of the present day. There are only occasional +traces, as of a continuous defensive outer wall, such as those seen at +Nutria and Pescado. In the pueblos of the Cibola group, ancient and +modern, access to the inner portion of the pueblo was usually afforded +at a number of points. In the pueblo of Kin-tiel, however, occurs an +excellent example of the defensive gateway. The jambs and corners of the +opening are finished with great neatness, as may be seen in the +illustration (Pl. CIII). This gateway or passage was roofed over, and +the rectangular depressions for the reception of cross-beams still +contain short stumps, protected from destruction by the masonry. The +masonry over the passageway in falling carried away part of the masonry +above the jamb corner, thus indicating continuity of bond. The ground +plan of this ruin (Pl. LXIII) indicates clearly the various points at +which access to the inner courts was obtained. On the east side a +noticeable feature is the overlapping of the boundary wall of the south +wing, forming an indirect entranceway. The remains do not indicate that +this passage, like the one just described, was roofed over. In some +cases the modern passageways, as they follow the jogs and angles of +adjoining rows of houses, display similar changes of direction. In +Shupaulovi, which preserves most distinctly in its plan the idea of the +inclosed court, the passageway at the south end of the village changes +its direction at a right angle before emerging into the court (Pl. XXX). +This arrangement was undoubtedly determined by the position of the +terraces long before the passageway was roofed over and built upon. Pl. +XXII shows the south passageway of Walpi; the entrances are made +narrower than the rest of the passage by building buttresses of masonry +at the sides. This was probably done to secure the necessary support for +the north and south walls of the upper story. One of the walls, as maybe +seen in the illustration, rests directly upon a cross beam, strengthened +in this manner. + +One of the smaller inclosed courts of Zuñi, illustrated in Pl. LXXXII, +is reached by means of two covered passages, bearing some general +resemblance to the ancient defensive entrances, but these houses, +reached from within the court, have also terraces without. The low +passage shown in the figure has gradually been surmounted by rooms, +reaching in some cases a height of three terraces above the openings; +but the accumulated weight finally proved too much for the beams and +sustaining walls--probably never intended by the builders to withstand +the severe test afterwards put upon them--and following an unusually +protracted period of wet weather, the entire section of rooms above fell +to the ground. This occurred since the surveying and photographing. It +is rather remarkable that the frail adobe walls withstood so long the +unusual strain, or even that they sustained the addition of a top story +at all. + +In the preceding examples the passageway was covered throughout its +length by rooms, but cases occur in both Tusayan and Cibola in which +only portions of the roof form the floor of superstructures. Pl. CIV +shows a passage roofed over beyond the two-story portion of the building +for a sufficient distance to form a small terrace, upon which a ladder +stands. Pl. XXIII illustrates a similar arrangement on the west side of +Walpi. The outer edges of these terraces are covered with coping stones +and treated in the same manner as outer walls of lower rooms. In Zuñi an +example of this form of passage roof occurs between two of the eastern +house rows, where the rooms have not been subjected to the close +crowding characteristic of the western clusters of the pueblo. + +DOORS. + +In Zuñi many rooms of the ground story, which in early times must have +been used largely for storage, have been converted into well-lighted, +habitable apartments by the addition of external doors. In Tusayan this +modification has not taken place to an equal extent, the distinctly +defensive character of the first terrace reached by removable ladders +being still preserved. In this province a doorway on the ground is +always provided in building a house, but originally this space was not +designed to be permanent; it was left merely for convenience of passing +in and out during the construction, and was built up before the walls +were completed. Of late years, however, such doorways are often +preserved, and additional small openings are constructed for windows. + + [Illustration: Plate LXXXIX. Masonry in the north wing of Kin-tiel.] + +In ancient times the larger doorways of the upper terraces were probably +never closed, except by means of blankets or rabbit-skin robes hung over +them in cold weather. Examples have been seen that seem to have been +constructed with this object in view, for a slight pole, of the same +kind as those used in the lintels, is built into the masonry of the +jambs a few inches below the lintel proper. Openings imperfectly closed +against the cold and wind were naturally placed in the lee walls to +avoid the prevailing southwest winds, and the ground plans of the +exposed mesa villages were undoubtedly influenced by this circumstance, +the tendency being to change them from the early inclosed court type and +to place the houses in longitudinal rows facing eastward. This is +noticeable in the plans given in Chapter II. + +Doorways closed with masonry are seen in many ruins. Possibly these are +an indication of the temporary absence of the owner, as in the harvest +season, or at the time of the destruction or abandonment of the village; +but they may have been closed for the purpose of economizing warmth and +fuel during the winter season. No provision was made for closing them +with movable doors. The practice of fastening up the doors during the +harvesting season prevails at the present time among the Zuñi, but the +result is attained without great difficulty by means of rude cross bars, +now that they have framed wooden doors. One of these is illustrated in +Fig. 75. These doors are usually opened by a latch-string, which, when +not hung outside, is reached by means of a small round hole through the +wall at the side of the door. Through this hole the owner of the house, +on leaving it, secures the door by props and braces on the inside of the +room, the hole being sealed up and plastered in the same manner that +other openings are treated. + + [Illustration: Fig. 75. A barred Zuñi door.] + +This curious arrangement affords another illustration of the survival of +ancient methods in modified forms. It is not employed, however, in +closing the doors of the first terrace; these are fastened by barring +from the inside, the exit being made by means of internal ladders to the +terrace above, the upper doors only being fastened in the manner +illustrated. In Pl. LXXIX may be seen good examples of the side hole. +Fig. 75 shows a barred door. The plastering or sealing of the small side +hole instead of the entire opening was brought about by the introduction +of the wooden door, which in its present paneled form is of foreign +introduction, but in this, as in so many other cases, some analogous +feature which facilitated the adoption of the idea probably already +existed. Tradition points to the early use of a small door, made of a +single slab of wood, that closed the small rectangular wall niches, in +which valuables, such as turquoise, shell, etc., were kept. This slab, +it is said, was reduced and smoothed by rubbing with a piece of +sandstone. A number of beams, rafters, and roofing planks, seen in the +Chaco pueblos, were probably squared and finished in this way. The +latter examples show a degree of familiarity with this treatment of wood +that would enable the builders to construct such doors with ease. As +yet, however, no examples of wooden doors have been seen in any of the +pre-Columbian ruins. + +The pueblo type of paneled door is much more frequently seen in Cibola +than in Tusayan, and in the latter province it does not assume the +variety of treatment seen in Zuñi, nor is the work so neatly executed. +The views of the modern pueblos, given in Chapters III and IV, will +indicate the extent to which this feature occurs in the two groups. In +the construction of a paneled door the vertical stile on one side is +prolonged at the top and bottom into a rounded pivot, which works into +cup-like sockets in the lintel and sill, as illustrated in Fig. 76. The +hinge is thus produced in the wood itself without the aid of any +external appliances. + + [Illustration: Fig. 76. Wooden pivot hinges of a Zuñi door.] + +It is difficult to trace the origin of this device among the pueblos. It +closely resembles the pivot hinges sometimes used in mediæval Europe in +connection with massive gates for closing masonry passages; in such +cases the prolonged pivots worked in cavities of stone sills and +lintels. The Indians claim to have employed it in very early times, but +no evidence on this point has been found. It is quite possible that the +idea was borrowed from some of the earlier Mormon settlers who came into +the country, as these people use a number of primitive devices which are +undoubtedly survivals of methods of construction once common in the +countries from which they came. Vestiges of the use of a pivotal hinge, +constructed on a much more massive scale than any of the pueblo +examples, were seen at an old fortress-like, stone storehouse of the +Mormons, built near the site of Moen-kopi by the first Mormon settlers. + + [Illustration: Plate XC. Adobe garden walls near Zuñi.] + +The paneled door now in use among the pueblos is rudely made, and +consists of a frame inclosing a single panel. This panel, when of large +size, is occasionally made of two or more pieces. These doors vary +greatly in size. A few reach the height of 5 feet, but the usual height +is from 3½ to 4 feet. As doors are commonly elevated a foot or more +above the ground or floor, the use of such openings does not entail the +full degree of discomfort that the small size suggests. Doors of larger +size, with sills raised but an inch or two above the floor or ground, +have recently been introduced in some of the ground stories in Zuñi; but +these are very recent, and the idea has been adopted only by the most +progressive people. + + [Illustration: Fig. 77. Paneled wooden doors in Hano.] + +Pl. XLI shows a small paneled door, not more than a foot square, used as +a blind to close a back window of a dwelling. The smallest examples of +paneled doors are those employed for closing the small, square openings +in the back walls of house rows, which still retain the defensive +arrangement so marked in many of the ancient pueblos. In some instances +doors occur in the second stories of unterraced walls, their sills being +5 or 6 feet above the ground. In such cases the doors are reached by +ladders whose upper ends rest upon the sills. Elevated openings of this +kind are closed in the usual manner with a rude, single-paneled door, +which is often whitened with a coating of clayey gypsum. + +Carefully worked paneled doors are much more common in Zuñi than in +Tusayan, and within the latter province the villages of the first mesa +make more extended use of this type of door, as they have come into more +intimate contact with their eastern brethren than other villages of the +group. Fig. 77 illustrates a portion of a Hano house in which two wooden +doors occur. These specimens indicate the rudeness of Tusayan +workmanship. It will be seen that the workman who framed the upper one +of these doors met with considerable difficulty in properly joining the +two boards of the panel and in connecting these with the frame. The +figure shows that at several points the door has been reenforced and +strengthened by buckskin and rawhide thongs. The same device has been +employed in the lower door, both in fastening together the two pieces of +the panel and in attaching the latter to the framing. These doors also +illustrate the customary manner of barring the door during the absence +of the occupant of the house. + +The doorway is usually framed at the time the house is built. The sill +is generally elevated above the ground outside and the floor inside, and +the door openings, with a few exceptions, are thus practically only +large windows. In this respect they follow the arrangement +characteristic of the ancient pueblos, in which all the larger openings +are window-like doorways. These are sometimes seen on the court margin +of house rows, and frequently occur between communicating rooms within +the cluster. They are usually raised about a foot and a half above the +floor, and in some cases are provided with one or two steps. In Zuñi, +doorways between communicating rooms, though now framed in wood, +preserve the same arrangement, as may be seen in Pl. LXXXVI. + + [Illustration: Fig. 78. Framing of a Zuñi door-panel.] + +The side pieces of a paneled pueblo door are mortised, an achievement +far beyond the aboriginal art of these people. Fig. 78 illustrates the +manner in which the framing is done. All the necessary grooving, and the +preparation of the projecting tenons is laboriously executed with the +most primitive tools, in many cases the whole frame, with all its +joints, being cut out with a small knife. + + [Illustration: Plate XCI. A group of stone corrals near Oraibi.] + +Doors are usually fastened by a simple wooden latch, the bar of which +turns upon a wooden pin. They are opened from without by lifting the +latch from its wooden catch, by means of a string passed through a small +hole in the door, and hanging outside. Some few doors are, however, +provided with a cumbersome wooden lock, operated by means of a square, +notched stick that serves as a key. These locks are usually fastened to +the inner side of the door by thongs of buckskin or rawhide, passed +through small holes bored or drilled through the edge of the lock, and +through the stile and panel of the door at corresponding points. The +entire mechanism consists of wood and strings joined together in the +rudest manner. Primitive as this device is, however, its conception is +far in advance of the aboriginal culture of the pueblos, and both it and +the string latch must have come from without. The lock was probably a +contrivance of the early Mormons, as it is evidently roughly modeled +after a metallic lock. + +Many doors having no permanent means of closure are still in use. These +are very common in Tusayan, and occur also in Cibola, particularly in +the farming pueblos. The open front of the "tupubi" or balcony-like +recess, seen so frequently at the ends of first-terrace roofs in +Tusayan, is often constructed with a transom-like arrangement in +connection with the girder supporting the edge of the roof, in the same +manner in which doorways proper are treated. Pl. XXXII illustrates a +balcony in which one bounding side is formed by a flight of stone steps, +producing a notched or terraced effect. The supporting girder in this +instance is embedded in the wall and coated over with adobe, obscuring +the construction. Fig. 79 shows a rude transom over the supporting beam +of a balcony roof in the principal house of Hano. The upper doorway +shown in this house has been partly walled in, reducing its size +somewhat. It is also provided with a small horizontal opening over the +main lintel, which, like the doorway, has been partly filled with +masonry. This upper transom often seems to have resulted from carrying +such openings to the full height of the story. The transom probably +originated from the spaces left between the ends of beams resting on the +main girder that spanned the principal opening (see Fig. 81). Somewhat +similar balconies are seen in Cibola, both in Zuñi and in the farming +villages, but they do not assume so much importance as in Tusayan. An +example is shown in Pl. CI, in which the construction of this feature is +clearly visible. + +In the remains of the ancient pueblos there is no evidence of the use of +the half-open terrace rooms described above. If such rooms existed, +especially if constructed in the open manner of the Tusayan examples, +they must have been among the first to succumb to destruction. The +comparative rarity of this feature in Zuñi does not necessarily indicate +that it is not of native origin, as owing to the exceptional manner of +clustering and to prolonged exposure to foreign influence, this pueblo +exhibits a wider departure from the ancient type than do any of the +Tusayan villages. It is likely that the ancient builders, trusting to +the double protection of the inclosed court and the defensive first +terrace, freely adopted this open and convenient arrangement in +connection with the upper roofs. + + [Illustration: Fig. 79. Rude transoms over Tusayan openings.] + + [Illustration: Plate XCII. An inclosing wall of upright stones at Ojo + Caliente.] + +The transom-like opening commonly accompanying the large opening is also +seen in many of the inclosed doorways of Tusayan, but in some of these +cases its origin can not be traced to the roof constructions, as the +openings do not approach the ceilings of the rooms. In early days such +doorways were closed by means of large slabs of stone set on edge, and +these were sometimes supplemented by a suspended blanket. In severe +winter weather many of the openings were closed with masonry. At the +present time many doorways not provided with paneled doors are closed in +such ways. When a doorway is thus treated its transom is left open for +the admission of light and air. The Indians state that in early times +this transom was provided for the exit of smoke when the main doorway +was closed, and even now such provision is not wholly superfluous. Fig. +80 illustrates a large doorway of Tusayan with a small transom. The +opening was being reduced in size by means of adobe masonry at the time +the drawing was made. Fig. 81 shows a double transom over a lintel +composed of two poles; a section of masonry separating the transom into +two distinct openings rests upon the lintel of the doorway and supports +a roof-beam; this is shown in the figure. Other examples of transoms may +be seen in connection with many of the illustrations of Tusayan +doorways. + + [Illustration: Fig. 80. A large Tusayan doorway with small transom + openings.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 81. A doorway and double transom in Walpi.] + +The transom bars over exterior doorways of houses probably bear some +relation to a feature seen in some of the best preserved ruins and still +surviving to some extent in Tusayan practice. This consists of a +straight pole, usually of the same dimensions as the poles of which the +lintel is made, extending across the opening from 2 to 6 inches below +the main lintel, and fixed into the masonry in a position to serve as a +curtain pole. Originally this pole undoubtedly served as a means of +suspension for the blanket or skin rug used in closing the opening, just +as such means are now used in the huts of the Navajo, as well as +occasionally in the houses of Tusayan. The space above this cross stick +answered the same purpose as the transoms of the present time. + +A most striking feature of doorways is the occasional departure from the +quadrangular form, seen in some ruined villages and also in some of the +modern houses of Tusayan. Fig. 82 illustrates a specimen of this type +found in a small cliff ruin, in Canyon de Chelly. Ancient examples of +this form of opening are distinguished by a symmetrical disposition of +the step in the jamb, while the modern doors are seldom so arranged. +A modern example from Mashongnavi is shown in Fig. 83. This opening also +illustrates the double or divided transom. The beam ends shown in the +figure project beyond the face of the wall and support an overhanging +coping or cornice. A door-like window, approximating the symmetrical +form described, is seen immediately over the passage-way shown in Pl. +XXII. This form is evidently the result of the partial closing of a +larger rectangular opening. + + [Illustration: Fig. 82. An ancient doorway in Canyon de Chelly cliff + ruin.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 83. A symmetrically notched doorway in + Mashongnavi.] + + [Illustration: Plate XCIII. Upright blocks of sandstone built into + an ancient pueblo wall.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 84. A Tusayan notched doorway.] + +Fig. 84 shows the usual type of terraced doorway in Tusayan, in which +one jamb is stepped at a considerably greater height than the other. +In Tusayan large openings occur in which only one jamb is stepped, +producing an effect somewhat of that of the large balcony openings with +flights of stone steps at one side, previously illustrated. An opening +of this form is shown in Fig. 85. Both of the stepped doorways, +illustrated above, are provided with transom openings extending from one +roof beam to another. In the absence of a movable door the openings were +made of the smallest size consistent with convenient use. The stepped +form was very likely suggested by the temporary partial blocking up of +an opening with loose, flat stones in such a manner as to least impair +its use. This is still quite commonly done, large openings being often +seen in which the lower portion on one or both sides is narrowed by +means of adobe bricks or stones loosely piled up. In this connection it +may be noted that the secondary lintel pole, previously described as +occurring in both ancient and modern doorways, serves the additional +purpose of a hand-hold when supplies are brought into the house on the +backs of the occupants. The stepping of the doorway, while diminishing +its exposed area, does not interfere with its use in bringing in large +bundles, etc. Series of steps, picked into the faces of the cliffs, and +affording access to cliff dwellings, frequently have a supplementary +series of narrow and deep cavities that furnish a secure hold for the +hands. The requirements of the precipitous environment of these people +have led to the carrying of loads of produce, fuel, etc., on the back by +means of a suspending band passed across the forehead; this left the +hands free to aid in the difficult task of climbing. These conditions +seem to have brought about the use, in some cases, of handholds in the +marginal frames of interior trapdoors as an aid in climbing the ladder. + + [Illustration: Fig. 85. A large Tusayan doorway with one notched + jamb.] + +One more characteristic type of the ancient pueblo doorway remains to be +described. During the autumn of 1883, when the ruined pueblo of Kin-tiel +was surveyed, a number of excavations were made in and about the pueblo. +A small room on the east side, near the brink of the arroyo that +traverses the ruin from east to west, was completely cleared out, +exposing its fireplace, the stone paving of its floor, and other details +of construction. Built into an inner partition of this room was found a +large slab of stone, pierced with a circular hole of sufficient size for +a man to squeeze through. This slab was set on edge and incorporated +into the masonry of the partition, and evidently served as a means of +communication with another room. The position of this doorway and its +relation to the room in which it occurs may be seen from the +illustration in Pl. C, which shows the stone in situ. The doorway or +"stone-close" is shown in Fig. 86 on a sufficient scale to indicate the +degree of technical skill in the architectural treatment of stone +possessed by the builders of this old pueblo. The writer visited Zuñi in +October of the same season, and on describing this find to Mr. Frank H. +Cushing, learned that the Zuñi Indians still preserved traditional +knowledge of this device. Mr. Cushing kindly furnished at the time the +following extract from the tale of "The Deer-Slayer and the Wizards," +a Zuñi folk-tale of the early occupancy of the valley of Zuñi. + + [Illustration: Plate XCIV. Ancient wall of upright rocks in + southwestern Colorado.] + +"'How will they enter?' said the young man to his wife. 'Through the +stone-close at the side,' she answered. In the days of the ancients, the +doorways were often made of a great slab of stone with a round hole cut +through the middle, and a round stone slab to close it, which was called +the stone-close, that the enemy might not enter in times of war." + + [Illustration: Fig. 86. An ancient circular doorway or "stone-close" + in Kin-tiel.] + +Mr. Cushing had found displaced fragments of such circular stone +doorways at ruins some distance northwest from Zuñi, but had been under +the impression that they were used as roof openings. All examples of +this device known to the writer as having been found in place occurred +in side walls of rooms. Mr. E. W. Nelson, while making collections of +pottery from ruins near Springerville, Arizona, found and sent to the +Smithsonian Institution, in the autumn of 1884, "a flat stone about 18 +inches square with a round hole cut in the middle of it. This stone was +taken from the wall of one of the old ruined stone houses near +Springerville, in an Indian ruin. The stone was set in the wall between +two inner rooms of the ruin, and evidently served as a means of +communication or perhaps a ventilator. I send it on mainly as an example +of their stone-working craft." The position of this feature in the +excavated room of Kin-tiel is indicated on the ground plan, Fig. 60, +which also shows the position of other details seen in the general view +of the room, Pl. C. + +A small fragment of a "stone-close" doorway was found incorporated into +the masonry of a flight of outside stone steps at Pescado, indicating +its use in some neighboring ruin, thus bringing it well within the +Cibola district. Another point at which similar remains have been +brought to light is the pueblo of Halona, just across the river from the +present Zuñi. Mr. F. Webb Hodge, recently connected with the Hemenway +Southwestern Archeological Exposition, under the direction of Mr. F. H. +Cushing, describes this form of opening as being of quite common +occurrence in the rooms of this long-buried pueblo. Here the doorways +are associated with the round slabs used for closing them. The latter +were held in place by props within the room. No slabs of this form were +seen at Kin-tiel, but quite possibly some of the large slabs of nearly +rectangular form, found within this ruin, may have served the same +purpose. It would seem more reasonable to use the rectangular slabs for +this purpose when the openings were conveniently near the floors. No +example of the stone-close has as yet been found in Tusayan. + +The annular doorway described above affords the only instance known to +the writer where access openings were closed with a rigid device of +aboriginal invention; and from the character of its material this device +was necessarily restricted to openings of small size. The larger +rectangular doorways, when not partly closed by masonry, probably were +covered only with blankets or skin rugs suspended from the lintel. +In the discussion of sealed windows modern examples resembling the +stone-close device will be noted, but these are usually employed in a +more permanent manner. + +The small size of the ordinary pueblo doorway was perhaps due as much to +the fact that there was no convenient means of closing it as it was to +defensive reasons. Many primitive habitations, even quite rude ones +built with no intention of defense, are characterized by small doors and +windows. The planning of dwellings and the distribution of openings in +such a manner as to protect and render comfortable the inhabited rooms +implies a greater advance in architectural skill than these builders had +achieved. + +The inconveniently small size of the doorways of the modern pueblos is +only a survival of ancient conditions. The use of full-sized doors, +admitting a man without stooping, is entirely practicable at the present +day, but the conservative builders persist in adhering to the early +type. The ancient position of the door, with its sill at a considerable +height from the ground, is also retained. From the absence of any +convenient means of rigidly closing the doors and windows, in early +times external openings were restricted to the smallest practicable +dimensions. The convenience of these openings was increased without +altering their dimensions by elevating them to a certain height above +the ground. In the ruin of Kin-tiel there is marked uniformity in the +height of the openings above the ground, and such openings were likely +to be quite uniform when used for similar purposes. The most common +elevation of the sills of doorways was such that a man could readily +step over at one stride. It will be seen that the same economy of space +has effected the use of windows in this system of architecture. + +WINDOWS. + +In the pueblo system of building, doors and windows are not always +clearly differentiated. Many of the openings, while used for access to +the dwellings, also answer all the purposes of windows, and, both in +their form and in their position in the walls, seem more fully to meet +the requirements of openings for the admission of light and air than for +access. We have seen in the illustrations in Chapters III and IV, +openings of considerable size so located in the face of the outer wall +as to unfit them for use as doorways, and others whose size is wholly +inadequate, but which are still provided with the typical though +diminutive single-paneled door. Many of these small openings, occurring +most frequently in the back walls of house rows, have the jambs, +lintels, etc., characteristic of the typical modern door. However, +as the drawings above referred to indicate, there are many openings +concerning the use of which there can be no doubt, as they can only +provide outlook, light, and air. + + [Illustration: Plate XCV. Ancient floor-beams at Kin-tiel.] + +In the most common form of window in present use in Tusayan and Cibola +the width usually exceeds the height. Although found often in what +appear to be the older portions of the present pueblos, this shape +probably does not date very far back. The windows of the ancient pueblos +were sometimes square, or nearly so, when of small size, but when larger +they were never distinguishable from doorways in either size or finish, +and the height exceeded the width. This restriction of the width of +openings was due to the exceptionally small size of the building stone +made use of. Although larger stones were available, the builders had not +sufficient constructive skill to successfully utilize them. The failure +to utilize this material indicates a degree of ignorance of mechanical +aids that at first thought seems scarcely in keeping with the +massiveness of form and the high degree of finish characterizing many of +the remains; but as already seen in the discussion of masonry, the +latter results were attained by the patient industry of many hands, +although laboring with but little of the spirit of cooperation. The +narrowness of the largest doors and windows in the ancient pueblos +suggests timidity on the part of the ancient builders. The apparently +bolder construction of the present day, shown in the prevailing use of +horizontal openings, is not due to greater constructive skill, but +rather to the markedly greater carelessness of modern construction. + + [Illustration: Fig. 87. Diagram illustrating symmetrical arrangement + of small openings in Pueblo Bonito.] + +The same contrast between modern and ancient practice is seen in the +disposition of openings in walls. In the modern pueblos there does not +seem to be any regularity or system in their introduction, while in some +of the older pueblos, such as Pueblo Bonito on the Chaco, and others of +the same group, the arrangement of the outer openings exhibits a certain +degree of symmetry. The accompanying diagram, Fig. 87, illustrates a +portion of the northern outer wall of Pueblo Bonito, in which the small +windows of successive rooms, besides being uniform in size, are grouped +in pairs. The degree of technical skill shown in the execution of the +masonry about these openings is in keeping with the precision with which +the openings themselves are placed. Pl. CV, gives a view of a portion of +the wall containing these openings. + +In marked contrast to the above examples is the slovenly practice of the +modern pueblos. There are rarely two openings of the same size, even in +a single room, nor are these usually placed at a uniform height from the +floor. The placing appears to be purely a matter of individual taste, +and no trace of system or uniformity is to be found. Windows occur +sometimes at considerable height, near or even at the ceiling in some +cases, while others are placed almost at the base of the wall; examples +may be found occupying all intermediate heights between these extremes. +Many of the illustrations show this characteristic irregularity, but +Pls. LXXIX and LXXXII of Zuñi perhaps represent it most clearly. + +The framing of these openings differs but little from that of the +ancient examples. The modern opening is distinguished principally by the +more careless method of combining the materials, and by the introduction +in many instances of a rude sash. A number of small poles or sticks, +usually of cedar, with the bark peeled off, are laid side by side in +contact, across the opening, to form a support for the stones and earth +of the superposed masonry. Frequently a particularly large tablet of +stone is placed immediately upon the sticks, but this stone is never +long enough or thick enough to answer the purpose of a lintel for larger +openings. The number of small sticks used is sufficient to reach from +the face to the back of the wall, and in the simplest openings the +surrounding masonry forms jambs and sill. American or Spanish influence +occasionally shows itself in the employment of sawed boards for lintels, +sills, and jambs. The wooden features of the windows exhibit a curiously +light and flimsy construction. + +A large percentage of the windows, in both Tusayan and Cibola, are +furnished with glass at the present time. Occasionally a primitive sash +of several lights is found, but frequently the glass is used singly; in +some instances it is set directly into the adobe without any intervening +sash or frame. In several cases in Zuñi the primitive sash or frame has +been rudely decorated with incised lines and notches. An example of this +is shown in Fig. 88. The frame or sash is usually built solidly into the +wall. Hinged sashes do not seem to have been adopted as yet. Often the +introduction of lights shows a curious and awkward compromise between +aboriginal methods and foreign ideas. + + [Illustration: Fig. 88. Incised decoration on a rude window sash in + Zuñi.] + + [Illustration: Plate XCVI. Adobe walls in Zuñi.] + +Characteristic of Zuñi windows, and also of those of the neighboring +pueblo of Acoma, is the use of semitranslucent slabs of selenite, about +1 inch in thickness and of irregular form. Pieces are occasionally met +with about 18 inches long and 8 or 10 inches wide, but usually they are +much smaller and very irregular in outline. For windows pieces are +selected that approximately fit against each other, and thin, flat +strips of wood are fixed in a vertical position in the openings to serve +as supports for the irregular fragments of selenite, which could not be +retained in place without some such provision. The use of window +openings at the bases of walls probably suggested this use of vertical +sticks as a support to slabs of selenite, as in this position they would +be particularly useful, the windows being generally arranged on a slope, +as shown in Fig. 89. Similar glazing is also employed in the related, +obliquely pierced openings of Zuñi, to be described later. + + [Illustration: Fig. 89. Sloping selenite window at base of Zuñi wall + on upper terrace.] + +Selenite, in all probability, was not used in pre-Spanish times. No +examples have as yet been met with among ruins in the region where this +material is found and now used. Throughout the south and east portion of +the ancient pueblo region, explored by Mr. A. F. Bandelier, where many +of the remains were in a very good state of preservation, no cases of +the use of this substance were seen. Fig. 90 illustrates a typical +selenite window. + + [Illustration: Fig. 90. A Zuñi window glazed with selenite.] + +In Zuñi some of the kivas are provided with small external windows +framed with slabs of stone. It is likely that the kivas would for a long +time perpetuate methods and practices that had been superseded in the +construction of dwellings. The use of stone jambs, however, would +necessarily be limited to openings of small size, as such use for large +openings was beyond the mechanical skill of the pueblo builders. + +Fig. 91 illustrates the manner of making small openings in external +exposed walls in Zuñi. Stone frames occur only occasionally in what seem +to be the older and least modified portions of the village. At Tusayan, +however, this method of framing windows is much more noticeable, as the +exceptional crowding that has exercised such an influence on Zuñi +construction has not occurred there. The Tusayan houses are arranged +more in rows, often with a suggestion of large inclosures resembling the +courts of the ancient pueblos. The inclosures have not been encroached +upon, the streets are wider, and altogether the earlier methods seem to +have been retained in greater purity than in Zuñi. The unbroken outer +wall, of two or three stories in height, like the same feature of the +old villages, is pierced at various heights with small openings that do +not seriously impair its efficiency for defense. Tusayan examples of +these loop-hole-like openings maybe seen in Pls. XXII, XXIII, and XXXIX. + + [Illustration: Fig. 91. Small openings in the back wall of a Zuñi + house-cluster.] + +In some of the ancient pueblos such openings were arranged on a +distinctly defensive plan, and were constructed with great care. +Openings of this type, not more than 4 inches square, pierced the second +story outer wall of the pueblo of Wejegi in the Chaco Canyon. In the +pueblo of Kin-tiel (Pl. LXIII) similar loop-hole-like openings were very +skillfully constructed in the outer wall at the rounded northeastern +corner of the pueblo. The openings pierced the wall at an oblique angle, +as shown on the plan. Two of these channel-like loopholes maybe seen in +Pl. LXV. This figure also shows the carefully executed jamb corners and +faces of three large openings of the second story, which, though greatly +undermined by the falling away of the lower masonry, are still held in +position by the bond of thin flat stones of which the wall is built. + + [Illustration: Plate XCVII. Wall coping and oven at Zuñi.] + +It is often the practice in the modern pueblos to seal up the windows of +a house with masonry, and sometimes the doors also during the temporary +absence of the occupant, which absence often takes place at the seasons +of planting and harvesting. At such times many Zuñi families occupy +outlying farming pueblos, such as Nutria and Pescado, and the Tusayans, +in a like manner, live in rude summer shelters close to their fields. +Such absence from the home pueblo often lasts for a month or more at a +time. The work of closing the opening is done sometimes in the roughest +manner, but examples are seen in which carefully laid masonry has been +used. The latter is sometimes plastered. Occasionally the sealing is +done with a thin slab of sandstone, somewhat larger than the opening, +held in place with mud plastering, or propped from the inside after the +manner of the "stone close" previously described. Fig. 92 illustrates +specimens of sealed openings in the village of Hano of the Tusayan +group. The upper window is closed with a single large slab and a few +small chinking stones at one side. The masonry used in closing the lower +opening is scarcely distinguishable from that of the adjoining walls. +Pl. CVI illustrates a similar treatment of an opening in a detached +house of Nutria, whose occupants had returned to the home pueblo of Zuñi +at the close of the harvesting season. The doorway in this case is only +partly closed, leaving a window-like aperture at its top, and the stones +used for the purpose are simply piled up without the use of adobe +mortar. + + [Illustration: Fig. 92. Sealed openings in Tusayan.] + +Windows and doors closed with masonry are often met with in the remains +of ancient pueblos, suggesting, perhaps, that some of the occupants were +absent at the time of the destruction of the village. When large +door-like openings in upper external walls were built up and plastered +over in this way, as in some ruins, the purpose was to economize heat +during the winter, as blankets or rugs made of skins would be +inadequate. + +Besides the closing and reopening of doors and windows just described, +the modern pueblo builders frequently make permanent changes in such +openings. Doors are often converted into windows, and windows are +reduced in size or enlarged, or new ones are broken through the walls, +apparently, with the greatest freedom, so that they do not, from their +finish or method of construction, furnish any clue to the antiquity of +the mud-covered wall in which they are found. Occasionally surface +weathering of the walls, particularly in Zuñi, exposes a bit of +horizontal pole embedded in the masonry, the lintel of a window long +since sealed up and obliterated by successive coats of mud finish. It is +probable that many openings are so covered up as to leave no trace of +their existence on the external wall. In Zuñi particularly, where the +original arrangement for entering and lighting many of the rooms must +have been wholly lost in the dense clustering of later times, such +changes are very numerous. It often happens that the addition of a new +room will shut off one or more old windows, and in such cases the latter +are often converted into interior niches which serve as open cupboards. +Such niches were sometimes of considerable size in the older pueblos. +Changes in the character of openings are quite common in all of the +pueblos. Usually the evidences of such changes are much clearer in the +rougher and more exposed work of Tusayan than in the adobe-finished +houses of Zuñi. Pl. CVII illustrates a large, balcony-like opening in +Oraibi that has been reduced to the size of an ordinary door by filling +in with rough masonry. A small window has been left immediately over the +lintel of the newer door. Pl. CVIII illustrates two large openings in +this village that have been treated in a somewhat similar manner, but +the filling has been carried farther. Both of these openings have been +used as doorways at one stage of their reduction, the one on the right +having been provided with a small transom; the combined opening was +arranged wholly within the large one and under its transom. In the +further conversion of this doorway into a small window, the secondary +transom was blocked up with stone slabs, set on edge, and a small +loophole window in the upper lefthand corner of the large opening was +also closed. The masonry filling of the large opening on the left in +this illustration shows no trace of a transom over the smaller doorway. +A small loophole in the corner of this large opening is still left open. +It will be noted that the original transoms of the large openings have +in all these cases been entirely filled up with masonry. + + [Illustration: Plate XCVIII. Cross-pieces on Zuñi ladders.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 93. A Zuñi doorway converted into a window.] + +The clearness with which all the steps of the gradual reduction of these +openings can be traced in the exposed stone work is in marked contrast +with the obscurity of such features in Zuñi. In the latter group, +however, examples are occasionally seen where a doorway has been partly +closed with masonry, leaving enough space at the top for a window. Often +in such cases the filled-in masonry is thinner than that of the +adjoining wall, and consequently the form of the original doorway is +easily traced. Fig. 93, from an adobe wall in Zuñi, gives an +illustration of this. The entrance doorway of the detached Zuñi house +illustrated in Pl. LXXXIII, has been similarly reduced in size, leaving +traces of the original form in a slight offset. In modern times, both in +Tusayan and Cibola, changes in the form and disposition of openings seem +to have been made with the greatest freedom, but in the ancient pueblos +altered doors or windows have rarely been found. The original placing of +these features was more carefully considered, and the buildings were +rarely subjected to unforeseen and irregular crowding. + +In both ancient and modern pueblo work, windows, used only as such, seem +to have been universally quadrilateral, offsets and steps being confined +exclusively to doorways. + +ROOF OPENINGS. + +The line of separation between roof openings and doors and windows is, +with few exceptions, sharply drawn. The origin of these roof-holes, +whose use at the present time is widespread, was undoubtedly in the +simple trap door which gave access to the rooms of the first terrace. +Pl. XXXVIII, illustrating a court of Oraibi, shows in the foreground a +kiva hatchway of the usual form seen in Tusayan. Here there is but +little difference between the entrance traps of the ceremonial chambers +and those that give access to the rooms of the first terrace; the former +are in most cases somewhat larger to admit of ingress of costumed +dancers, and the kiva traps are usually on a somewhat sharper slope, +conforming to the pitch of the small dome-roof of the kivas, while those +of the house terraces have the scarcely perceptible fall of the house +roofs in which they are placed. In Zuñi, however, where the development +and use of openings has been carried further, the kiva hatchways are +distinguished by a specialized form that will be described later. An +examination of the plans of the modern villages in Chapters II and III +will show the general distribution of roof openings. Those used as +hatchways are distinguishable by their greater dimensions, and in many +cases by the presence of the ladders that give access to the rooms +below. The smaller roof openings in their simplest form are constructed +in essentially the same manner as the trap doors, and the width is +usually regulated by the distance between two adjacent roof beams. The +second series of small roof poles is interrupted at the sides of the +opening, which sides are finished by means of carefully laid small +stones in the same manner as are projecting copings. This finish is +often carried several inches above the roof and crowned with narrow +stone slabs, one on each of the four sides, forming a sort of frame +which protects the mud plastered sides of the opening from the action of +the rains. Examples of this simple type may be seen in many of the +figures illustrating Chapters II and III, and in Pl. XCVII. Fig. 94 also +illustrates common types of roof openings seen in Zuñi. Two of the +examples in this figure are of openings that give access to lower rooms. +Occasional instances are seen in this pueblo in which an exaggerated +height is given to the coping, the result slightly approaching a square +chimney in effect. Fig. 95 illustrates an example of this form. + + [Illustration: Fig. 94. Zuñi roof-openings.] + + [Illustration: Plate XCIX. Outside steps at Pescado.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 95. A Zuñi roof opening, with raised coping.] + +In Zuñi, where many minor variations in the forms of roof openings +occur, certain of these variations appear to be related to roof +drainage. These have three sides crowned in the usual manner with coping +stones laid flat, but the fourth side is formed by setting a thin slab +on edge, as illustrated in Fig. 96. + + [Illustration: Fig. 96. Zuñi roof-openings, with one elevated end.] + +Fig. 94 also embodies two specimens of this form. + +The special object of this arrangement is in some cases difficult to +determine; the raised end in all the examples on any one roof always +takes the same direction, and in many cases its position relative to +drainage suggests that it is a provision against flooding by rain on the +slightly sloping roof; but this relation to drainage is by no means +constant. Roof holes on the west side of the village in such positions +as to be directly exposed to the violent sand storms that prevail here +during certain months of the year seem in some cases to have in view +protection against the flying sand. We do not meet with evidence of any +fixed system to guide the disposition of this feature. In many cases +these trap holes are provided with a thin slab of sandstone large enough +to cover the whole opening, and used in times of rain. During fair +weather these are laid on the roof, near the hole they are designed to +cover, or lie tilted against the higher edge of the trap, as shown in +Fig. 97. + + [Illustration: Fig. 97. A Zuñi roof hole with cover.] + +When the cover is placed on one of these holes, with a high slab at one +end, it has a steep pitch, to shed water, and at the same time light and +air are to some extent admitted, but it is very doubtful if this is the +result of direct intention on the part of the builder. The possible +development of this roof trap of unusual elevation into a rudimentary +chimney has already been mentioned in the discussion of chimneys. +A development in this direction would possibly be suggested by the +desirability of separating the access by ladder from the inconvenient +smoke hole. This must have been brought very forcibly to the attention +of the Indian when, at the time a fire was burning in the fireplace, +they were compelled to descend the ladder amidst the smoke and heat. + + [Illustration: Plate C. An excavated room at Kin-tiel.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 98. Kiva trapdoor in Zuñi.] + +The survival to the present time of such an inconvenient arrangement in +the kivas can be explained only on the ground of the intense +conservatism of these people in all that pertains to religion. In the +small roof holes methods of construction are seen which would not be so +practicable on the larger scale of the ladder holes after which they +have been modeled. In these latter the sides are built up of masonry or +adobe, but the framing around them is more like the usual coping over +walls. The stone that, set on edge in the small openings built for the +admission of light, forms a raised end never occurs in these. The ladder +for access rests against the coping. + +When occurring in connection with kivas, ladder holes have certain +peculiarities in which they differ from the ordinary form used in +dwellings. The opening in such cases is made of large size to admit +dancers in costume with full paraphernalia. These, the largest roof +openings to be found in Zuñi, are framed with pieces of wood. The +methods of holding the pieces in place vary somewhat in minor detail. It +is quite likely that recent examples, while still preserving the form +and general appearance of the earlier ones, would bear evidence that the +builders had used their knowledge of improved methods of joining and +finishing. + +As may readily be seen from the illustration, Fig. 98, this framing, +by the addition of a cross piece, divides the opening unequally. The +smaller aperture is situated immediately above the fireplace (which +conforms to the ancient type without chimney and located in the open +floor of the room) and is very evidently designed to furnish an outlet +to the smoke. In a chamber having no side doors or windows, or at most +very small square windows, and consequently no drafts, the column of +smoke and flame can often on still nights be seen rising vertically from +the roof. The other portion of the opening containing the ladder is used +for ingress and egress. This singular combination strongly suggests that +at no very remote period one opening was used to answer both purposes, +as it still does in the Tusayan kivas. It also suggests the direction in +which differentiation of functions began to take place, which in the +kiva was delayed and held back by the conservative religious feeling, +when in the civil architecture it may have been the initial point of a +development that culminated in the chimney, a development that was +assisted in its later steps by suggestions from foreign sources. In the +more primitively constructed examples the cross pieces seem to be simply +laid on without any cutting in. The central piece is held in place by a +peg set into each side piece, the weight and thrust of the ladder +helping to hold it. The primitive arrangement here seen has been +somewhat improved upon in some other cases, but it was not ascertained +whether these were of later date or not. + +In the best made frames for kiva entrances the timbers are "halved" in +the manner of our carpenters, the joint being additionally secured by a +pin as shown in Fig. 99. + +The use of a frame of wood in these trapdoors dates back to a +comparatively high antiquity, and is not at all a modern innovation, +as one would at first be inclined to believe. Their use in so highly +developed a form in the ceremonial chamber is an argument in favor of +antiquity. Only two examples were discovered by Mr. L. H. Morgan in a +ruined pueblo on the Animas. "One of these measured 16 by 17 inches and +the other was 16 inches square. Each was formed in the floor by pieces +of wood put together. The work was neatly done."[8] + + [Footnote 8: Contributions to N.A. Ethnology, vol. 4. House Life, + etc., p. 182.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 99. Halved and pinned trapdoor frame of a Zuñi + kiva.] + + [Illustration: Plate CI. Masonry chimneys of Zuñi.] + +Unfortunately, Mr. Morgan does not describe in detail the manner in +which the joining was effected, or whether the pieces were halved or cut +to fit. It seems hardly likely, considering the rude facilities +possessed by the ancients, that the enormous labor of reducing large +pieces of wood to such interfitting shapes would have been undertaken. +A certain neatness of finish would undoubtedly be attained by arranging +the principal roof beams and the small poles that cross them at right +angles, in the usual careful manner of the ancient builders. The kiva +roof opening, with the hole serving for access and smoke exit, is +paralleled in the excavated lodges of the San Francisco Mountains, where +a single opening served this double purpose. A slight recess or +excavation in the side of the entrance shaft evidently served for the +exit of smoke. + +At the village of Acoma the kiva trapdoors differ somewhat from the Zuñi +form. The survey of this village was somewhat hasty, and no opportunity +was afforded of ascertaining from the Indians the special purpose of the +mode of construction adopted. The roof hole is divided, as in Zuñi, but +the portion against which the ladder leans, instead of being made into a +smoke vent, is provided with a small roof. These roof holes to the +ceremonial chamber are entered directly from the open air, while in the +dwelling rooms it seems customary (much more customary than at Zuñi) to +enter the lower stories through trapdoors within upper rooms. In many +instances second-story rooms have no exterior rooms but are entered from +rooms above, contrary to the usual arrangement in both Tusayan and +Cibola. All six of the kivas in this village are provided with this +peculiarly constructed opening. + +In Zuñi close crowding of the cells has led to an exceptionally frequent +use of roof-lights and trapdoors. The ingenuity of the builders was +greatly taxed to admit sufficient light to the inner rooms. The roof +hole, which was originally used only to furnish the means of access and +light for the first terrace, as is still the case in Tusayan, is here +used in all stories indiscriminately, and principally for light and air. +In large clusters there are necessarily many dark rooms, which has led +to the employment of great numbers of roof holes, more or less directly +modeled after the ordinary trapdoor. Their occurrence is particularly +frequent in the larger clusters of the village, as in house No. 1. The +exceptional size of this pile, and of the adjoining house No. 4, with +the consequent large proportion of dark rooms, have taxed the ingenuity +of the Zuñi to the utmost, and as a result we see roof openings here +assuming a degree of importance not found elsewhere. + +In addition to roof openings of the type described, the dense clustering +of the Zuñi houses has led to the invention of a curious device for +lighting inner rooms not reached by ordinary external openings. This +consists of an opening, usually of oval or subrectangular form in +elevation, placed at the junction of the roof with a vertical wall. This +opening is carried down obliquely between the roofing beams, as shown in +the sections, Fig. 100, so that the light is admitted within the room +just at the junction of the ceiling and the inner face of the wall. With +the meager facilities and rude methods of the Zuñi, this peculiar +arrangement often involved weak construction, and the openings, placed +so low in the wall, were in danger of admitting water from the roof. The +difficulty of obtaining the desired light by this device was much +lessened where the outer roof was somewhat lower than the ceiling +within. + +These oblique openings occur not only in the larger clusters of houses +Nos. 1 and 4, but also in the more openly planned portions of the +village, though they do not occur either at Acoma or in the Tusayan +villages. They afford an interesting example of the transfer and +continuance in use of a constructional device developed in one place by +unusual conditions to a new field in which it was uncalled for, being +less efficient and more difficult of introduction than the devices in +ordinary use. + + [Illustration: Fig. 100. Typical sections of Zuñi oblique openings.] + +FURNITURE. + +The pueblo Indian has little household furniture, in the sense in which +the term is commonly employed; but his home contains certain features +which are more or less closely embodied in the house construction and +which answers the purpose. The suspended pole that serves as a clothes +rack for ordinary wearing apparel, extra blankets, robes, etc., has +already been described in treating of interiors. Religious costumes and +ceremonial paraphernalia are more carefully provided for, and are stored +away in some hidden corner of the dark storerooms. + + [Illustration: Plate CII. Remains of a gateway in Awatubi.] + +The small wall niches, which are formed by closing a window with a thin +filling-in wall, and which answer the purpose of cupboards or +receptacles for many of the smaller household articles, have also been +described and illustrated in connection with the Zuñi interior (Pl. +LXXXVI). + + [Illustration: Fig. 101. Arrangement of mealing stones in a Tusayan + house.] + +In many houses, both in Tusayan and in Cibola, shelves are constructed +for the more convenient storage of food, etc. These are often +constructed in a very primitive manner, particularly in the former +province. An unusually frail example may be seen in Fig. 67, in +connection with a fireplace. Fig. 101, showing a series of mealing +stones in a Tusayan house, also illustrates a rude shelf in the corner +of the room, supported at one end by an upright stone slab and at the +other by a projecting wooden peg. Shelves made of sawed boards are +occasionally seen, but as a rule such boards are considered too valuable +to be used in this manner. A more common arrangement, particularly in +Tusayan, is a combination of three or four slender poles placed side by +side, 2 or 3 inches apart, forming a rude shelf, upon which trays of +food are kept. + +Another device for the storage of food, occasionally seen in the pueblo +house, is a pocket or bin built into the corner of a room. Fig. 101, +illustrating the plan of a Tusayan house, indicates the position of one +of these cupboard-like inclosures. A sketch of this specimen is shown in +Fig. 102. This bin, used for the storage of beans, grain, and the like, +is formed by cutting off a corner of the room by setting two stone slabs +into the floor, and it is covered with the mud plastering which extends +over the neighboring walls. + +A curious modification of this device was seen in one of the inner rooms +in Zuñi, in the house of José Pié. A large earthen jar, apparently an +ordinary water vessel, was built into a projecting masonry bench near +the corner of the room in such a manner that its rim projected less than +half an inch above its surface. This jar was used for the same purpose +as the Tusayan corner bin. + + [Illustration: Fig. 102. A Tusayan grain bin.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 103. A Zuñi plume box.] + +Some of the Indians of the present time have chests or boxes in which +their ceremonial blankets and paraphernalia are kept. These of course +have been introduced since the days of American boards and boxes. In +Zuñi, however, the Indians still use a small wooden receptacle for the +precious ceremonial articles, such as feathers and beads. This is an +oblong box, provided with a countersunk lid, and usually carved from a +single piece of wood. Typical specimens are illustrated in Figs. 103 and +104. The workmanship displayed in these objects is not beyond the +aboriginal skill of the native workman, and their use is undoubtedly +ancient. + + [Illustration: Fig. 104. A Zuñi plume box.] + + [Illustration: Plate CIII. Ancient gateway, Kin-tiel.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 105. A Tusayan mealing trough.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 106. An ancient pueblo form of metate.] + +Perhaps the most important article of furniture in the home of the +pueblo Indian is the mealing trough, containing the household milling +apparatus. This trough usually contains a series of three metates of +varying degrees of coarseness firmly fixed in a slanting position most +convenient for the workers. It consists of thin slabs of sandstone set +into the floor on edge, similar slabs forming the separating partitions +between the compartments. This arrangement is shown in Fig. 105, +illustrating a Tusayan mealing trough. Those of Zuñi are of the same +form, as maybe seen in the illustration of a Zuñi interior, Fig. 105. +Occasionally in recently constructed specimens the thin inclosing walls +of the trough are made of planks. In the example illustrated one end of +the series is bounded by a board, all the other walls and divisions +being made of the usual stone slabs. The metates themselves are not +usually more than 3 inches in thickness. They are so adjusted in their +setting of stones and mortar as to slope away from the operator at the +proper angle. This arrangement of the mealing stones is characteristic +of the more densely clustered communal houses of late date. In the more +primitive house the mealing stone was usually a single large piece of +cellular basalt, or similar rock, in which a broad, sloping depression +was carved, and which could be transported from place to place. Fig. 106 +illustrates an example of this type from the vicinity of Globe, in +southern Arizona. The stationary mealing trough of the present day is +undoubtedly the successor of the earner moveable form, yet it was in use +among the pueblos at the time of the first Spanish expedition, as the +following extract from Castañeda's account[9] of Cibola will show. He +says a special room is designed to grind the grain: "This last is apart, +and contains a furnace and three stones made fast in masonry. Three +women sit down before these stones; the first crushes the grain, the +second brays it, and the third reduces it entirely to powder." It will +be seen how exactly this description fits both the arrangement and the +use of this mill at the present time. The perfection of mechanical +devices and the refinement of methods here exhibited would seem to be in +advance of the achievement of this people in other directions. + + [Footnote 9: Given by W. W. H. Davis in El Gringo, p. 119.] + +The grinding stones of the mealing apparatus are of correspondingly +varying degrees of roughness; those of basalt or lava are used for the +first crushing of the corn, and sandstone is used for the final grinding +on the last metate of the series. By means of these primitive appliances +the corn meal is as finely ground as our wheaten flour. The grinding +stones now used are always flat, as shown in Fig. 105, and differ from +those that were used with the early massive type of metate in being of +cylindrical form. + +One end of the series of milling troughs is usually built against the +wall near the corner of the room. In some cases, where the room is quite +narrow, the series extends across from wall to wall. Series comprising +four mealing stones, sometimes seen in Zuñi, are very generally arranged +in this manner. In all cases sufficient floor space is left behind the +mills to accommodate the women who kneel at their work. Pl. LXXXVI +illustrates an unusual arrangement, in which the fourth mealing stone is +set at right angles to the other stones of the series. + +Mortars are in general use in Zuñi and Tusayan households. As a rule +they are of considerable size, and made of the same material as the +rougher mealing stones. They are employed for crushing and grinding the +chile or red pepper that enters so largely into the food of the Zuñi, +and whose use has extended to the Mexicans of the same region. These +mortars have the ordinary circular depressions and are used with a round +pestle or crusher, often of somewhat long, cylindrical form for +convenience in handling. + +Parts of the apparatus for indoor blanket weaving seen in some of the +pueblo houses may be included under the heading of furniture. These +consist of devices for the attachment of the movable parts of the loom, +which need not be described in this connection. In some of the Tusayan +houses may be seen examples of posts sunk in the floor provided with +holes for the insertion of cords for attaching and tightening the warp, +similar to those built into the kiva floors, illustrated in Fig. 31. +No device of this kind was seen in Zuñi. A more primitive appliance for +such work is seen in both groups of pueblos in an occasional stump of a +beam or short pole projecting from the wall at varying heights. Ceiling +beams are also used for stretching the warp both in blanket and belt +weaving. + + [Illustration: Plate CIV. A covered passageway in Mashongnavi.] + +The furnishings of a pueblo house do not include tables and chairs. The +meals are eaten directly from the stone-paved floor, the participants +rarely having any other seat than the blanket that they wear, rolled up +or folded into convenient form. Small stools are sometimes seen, but the +need of such appliances does not seem to be keenly felt by these +Indians, who can, for hours, sit in a peculiar squatting position on +their haunches, without any apparent discomfort. Though moveable chairs +or stools are rare, nearly all of the dwellings are provided with the +low ledge or bench around the rooms, which in earlier times seems to +have been confined to the kivas. A slight advance on this fixed form of +seat was the stone block used in the Tusayan kivas, described on p. 132, +which at the same time served a useful purpose in the adjustment of the +warp threads for blanket weaving. + + [Illustration: Fig. 107. Zuñi stools.] + +The few wooden stools observed show very primitive workmanship, and are +usually made of a single piece of wood. Fig. 107 illustrates two forms +of wooden stool from Zuñi. The small three-legged stool on the left has +been cut from the trunk of a piñon tree in such a manner as to utilize +as legs the three branches into which the main stem separated. The other +stool illustrated is also cut from a single piece of tree trunk, which +has been reduced in weight by cutting out one side, leaving the two ends +for support. + + [Illustration: Fig. 108. A Zuñi chair.] + +A curiously worked chair of modern form seen in Zuñi is illustrated in +Fig. 108. It was difficult to determine the antiquity of this specimen, +as its rickety condition may have been due to the clumsy workmanship +quite as much as to the effects of age. Rude as is the workmanship, +however, it was far beyond the unaided skill of the native craftsman to +join and mortise the various pieces that go to make up this chair. Some +decorative effect has been sought here, the ornamentation, made up of +notches and sunken grooves, closely resembling that on the window sash +illustrated in Fig. 88, and somewhat similar in effect to the carving on +the Spanish beams seen in the Tusayan kivas. The whole construction +strongly suggests Spanish influence. + +Even the influence of Americans has as yet failed to bring about the use +of tables or bedsteads among the pueblo Indians. The floor answers all +the purposes of both these useful articles of furniture. The food dishes +are placed directly upon it at meal times, and at night the blankets, +rugs, and sheep skins that form the bed are spread directly upon it. +These latter, during the day, are suspended upon the clothes pole +previously described and illustrated. + +CORRALS AND GARDENS. + +The introduction of domestic sheep among the pueblos has added a new and +important element to their mode of living, but they seem never to have +reached a clear understanding as to how these animals should be cared +for. No forethought is exercised to separate the rams so that the lambs +will be born at a favorable season. The flocks consist of sheep and +goats which are allowed to run together at all tunes. Black sheep and +some with a grayish color of wool are often seen among them. No attempt +is made to eliminate these dark-fleeced members of the flock, since the +black and gray wool is utilized in its natural color in producing many +of the designs and patterns of the blankets woven by these people. The +flocks are usually driven up into the corrals or inclosures every +evening, and are taken out again in the morning, frequently at quite a +late hour. This, together with the time consumed in driving them to and +from pasture, gives them much less chance to thrive than those of the +nomadic Navajo. In Tusayan the corrals are usually of small size and +inclosed by thin walls of rude stone work. This may be seen in the +foreground of Pl. XXI. Pl. CIX illustrates several corrals just outside +the village of Mashongnavi similarly constructed, but of somewhat larger +size. Some of the corrals of Oraibi are of still larger size, +approaching in this respect the corrals of Cibola. The Oraibi pens are +rudely rectangular in form, with more or less rounded angles, and are +also built of rude masonry. + + [Illustration: Plate CV. Small square openings in Pueblo Bonito.] + +In the less important villages of Cibola stone is occasionally used for +inclosing the corrals, as in Tusayan, as may be seen in Pl. LXX, +illustrating an inclosure of this character in the court of the farming +pueblo of Pescado. Pl. CX illustrates in detail the manner in which +stone work is combined with the use of rude stakes in the construction +of this inclosure. On the rugged sites of the Tusayan villages corrals +are placed wherever favorable nooks happen to be found in the rocks, but +at Zuñi, built in the comparatively open plain, they form a nearly +continuous belt around the pueblo. Here they are made of stakes and +brush held in place by horizontal poles tied on with strips of rawhide. +The rudely contrived gateways are supported in natural forks at the top +and sides of posts. Often one or two small inclosures used for burros or +horses occur near these sheep corrals. The construction is identical +with those above described and is very rude. It is illustrated in Fig. +109, which shows the manner in which the stakes are arranged, and also +the method of attaching the horizontal tie-pieces. The construction of +these inclosures is frail, and the danger of pushing the stakes over by +pressure from within is guarded against by employing forked braces that +abut against horizontal pieces tied on 4 or 5 feet from the ground. +Reference to Pl. LXXIV will illustrate this construction. + + [Illustration: Fig. 109. Construction of a Zuñi corral.] + +Within the village of Zuñi inclosures resembling miniature corrals are +sometimes seen built against the houses; these are used as cages for +eagles. A number of these birds are kept in Zuñi for the sake of their +plumage, which is highly valued for ceremonial purposes. Pl. CXI +illustrates one of these coops, constructed partly with a thin adobe +wall and partly with stakes arranged like those of the corrals. + +In both of the pueblo groups under discussion, small gardens contiguous +to the villages are frequent. Those of Tusayan are walled in with stone. + +Within the pueblo of Zuñi a small group of garden patches is inclosed by +stake fences, but the majority of the gardens in the vicinity of the +principal villages are provided with low walls of mud masonry. The small +terraced gardens here are near the river bank on the southwest and +southeast sides of the village. The inclosed spaces, averaging in size +about 10 feet square, are used for the cultivation of red peppers, +beans, etc., which, during the dry season, are watered by hand. These +inclosures, situated close to the dwellings, suggest a probable +explanation for similar inclosures found in many of the ruins in the +southern and eastern portions of the ancient pueblo region. Mr. +Bandelier was informed by the Pimas[10] that these inclosures were +ancient gardens. He concluded that since acequias were frequent in the +immediate vicinity these gardens must have been used as reserves in case +of war, when the larger fields were not available, but the manner of +their occurrence in Zuñi suggests rather that they were intended for +cultivation of special crops, such as pepper, beans, cotton, and perhaps +also of a variety of tobacco--corn, melons, squashes, etc., being +cultivated elsewhere in larger tracts. There is a large group of gardens +on the bank of the stream at the southeastern corner of Zuñi, and here +there are slight indications of terracing. A second group on the steeper +slope at the southwestern corner is distinctly terraced. Small walled +gardens of the same type as these Zuñi examples occur in the vicinity of +some of the Tusayan villages on the middle mesa. They are located near +the springs or water pockets, apparently to facilitate watering by hand. +Some of them contain a few small peach trees in addition to the +vegetable crops ordinarily met with. The clusters here are, as a rule, +smaller than those of Zuñi, as there is much less space available in the +vicinity of the springs. At one point on the west side of the first +mesa, a few miles above Walpi, a copious spring serves to irrigate quite +an extensive series of small garden patches distributed over lower +slopes. + + [Footnote 10: Fifth Ann. Rept. Arch. Inst. Am., p. 92.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 110. Gardens of Zuñi.] + + [Illustration: Plate CVI. Sealed openings in a detached house of + Nutria.] + +At several points around Zuñi, usually at a greater distance than the +terrace gardens, are fields of much larger area inclosed in a similar +manner. Their inclosure was simply to secure them against the +depredations of stray burros, so numerous about the village. When the +crops are gathered in the autumn, several breaches are made in the low +wall and the burros are allowed to luxuriate on the remains. Pl. LIX +indicates the position of the large cluster of garden patches on the +southeastern side of Zuñi. Fig. 110, taken from photographs made in +1873, shows several of these small gardens with their growing crops and +a large field of corn beyond. The workmanship of the garden walls as +contrasted with that of the house masonry has been already described and +is illustrated in Pl. XC. + +"KISI" CONSTRUCTION. + +Lightly constructed shelters for the use of those in charge of fields +were probably a constant accompaniment of pueblo horticulture. Such +shelters were built of stone or of brush, according to which material +was most available. + +In very precipitous localities, as the Canyon de Chelly, these outlooks +naturally became the so-called cliff-dwellings or isolated shelters. +In Cibola single stone houses are in common use, not to the exclusion, +however, of the lighter structures of brush, while in Tusayan these +lighter forms, of which there are a number of well defined varieties, +are almost exclusively used. A detailed study of the methods of +construction employed in these rude shelters would be of great interest +as affording a comparison both with the building methods of the ruder +neighboring tribes and with those adopted in constructing some of the +details of the terraced house; the writer, however, did not have an +opportunity of making an examination of all the field shelters used in +these pueblos. Two of the simpler types are the "tuwahlki," or watch +house, and the "kishoni," or uncovered shade. The former is constructed +by first planting a short forked stick in the ground, which supports one +end of a pole, the other end resting on the ground. The interval between +this ridge pole and the ground is roughly filled in with slanting sticks +and brush, the inclosed space being not more than 3 feet in height, with +a maximum width of four or five feet. These shelters are for the +accommodation of the children who watch the melon patches until the +fruit is harvested. + + [Illustration: Fig. 111. Kishoni, or uncovered shade, of Tusayan.] + +The kishoni, or uncovered shade, illustrated in Fig. 111, is perhaps the +simplest form of shelter employed. Ten or a dozen cottonwood saplings +are set firmly into the ground, so as to form a slightly curved +inclosure with convex side toward the south. Cottonwood and willow +boughs in foliage, grease-wood, sage brush, and rabbit brush are laid +with stems upward in even rows against these saplings to a height of 6 +or 7 feet. This light material is held in place by bands of small +cottonwood branches laid in continuous horizontal lines around the +outside of the shelter and these are attached to the upright saplings +with cottonwood and willow twigs. + + [Illustration: Plate CVII. Partial filling-in of a large opening in + Oraibi, converting it into a doorway.] + +Figs. 112 and 113 illustrate a much more elaborate field shelter in +Tusayan. As may readily be seen from the figures this shelter covers a +considerable area; it will be seen too that the upright branches that +inclose two of its sides are of sufficient height to considerably shade +the level roof of poles and brush, converting it into a comfortable +retreat. + + [Illustration: Fig. 112. A Tusayan field shelter, from southwest.] + + [Illustration: Fig. 113. A Tusayan field shelter, from northeast.] + +ARCHITECTURAL NOMENCLATURE. + +The following nomenclature, collected by Mr. Stephen, comprises the +terms commonly used in designating the constructional details of Tusayan +houses and kivas: + + Kiko´li The ground floor rooms forming the first terrace. + Tupu´bi The roofed recess at the end of the first terrace. + Ah´pabi } A terrace roof. + Ih´pobi } + Tupat´ca ih´pobi The third terrace, used in common as a loitering + place. + Tumtco´kobi "The place of the flat stone;" small rooms in + which "piki," or paper-bread, is baked. "Tuma," + the piki stone, and "tcok" describing its flat + position. + Tupa´tca "Where you sit overhead;" the third story. + O´mi Ah´pabi The second story; a doorway always opens from it + upon the roof of the "kiko´li." + Kitcobi "The highest place;" the fourth story. + Tuhkwa A wall. + Puce An outer corner. + Apaphucua An inside corner. + Lestabi The main roof timbers. + Wina´kwapi Smaller cross poles. "Winahoya," a small pole, and + "Kwapi," in place. + Kaha´b kwapi The willow covering. + Süibi kwapi The brush covering. + Si´hü kwapi The grass covering. + Kiam´ balawi The mud plaster of roof covering, + "Balatle´lewini," to spread. + Tcukat´cvewata Dry earth covering the roof. "Tcuka," earth, + "katuto," to sit, and "at´cvewata," one laid + above another. + Kiami An entire roof. + Kwo´pku The fireplace. + Kwi´tcki "Smoke-house," an inside chimney-hood. + Sibvu´tütük´mula A series of bottomless jars piled above each + other, and luted together as a chimney-top. + Sibvu´ A bottomless earthen vessel serving as a chimney + pot. + Bok´ci Any small hole in a wall, or roof, smaller than + a doorway. + Hi´tci An opening, such as a doorway. This term is also + applied to a gap in a cliff. + Hi´tci Kalau´wata A door frame. + Tûñañ´îata A lintel; literally, "that holds the sides in + place." + Wuwûk´pi "The place step;" the door sill. + Niñuh´pi A handhold; the small pole in a doorway below the + lintel. + Pana´ptca ütc´pi bok´ci + A window; literally, "glass covered opening." + Ut´cpi A cover. + Ahpa´bütc´pi } A door. "Apab," inside; wina, a pole. + Wina´ütc´pi } + O´wa ütc´ppî "Stone cover," a stone slab. + Tüi´ka A projection in the wall of a room suggesting a + partition, such as shown in Pl. LXXXV. The same + term is applied to a projecting cliff in a mesa. + Kiam´i An entire roof. The main beams, cross poles, and + roof layers have the same names as in the kiva, + given later. + W[)i]na´kü´i Projecting poles; rafters extending beyond the + walls. + Bal´kakini "Spread out;" the floor. + O´tcokpü´h "Leveled with stones;" a raised level for the + foundation. + Ba´lkakini tü´wi "Floor ledge;" the floor of one room raised above + that of an adjoining one. + Hako´la "Lower place;" the floor of a lower room. Sand + dunes in a valley are called "Hakolpi." + Ko´ltci A shelf. + Owako´ltci A stone shelf. + Ta´pü kü´ita A support for a shelf. + Wina´koltci A hewn plank shelf. + Kokiüni A wooden peg in a wall. + Tületa A shelf hanging from the ceiling. + Tület´haipi The cords for suspending a shelf. + Tükûlci A niche in the wall. + Tükûli A stone mortar. + Ma´ta The complete mealing apparatus for grinding corn. + Owa´mata The trough or outer frame of stone slabs. + Mata´ki The metate or grinding slab. + Kakom´ta mata´ki The coarsest grinding slab. + Tala´kî mata´ki The next finer slab; from "talaki" to parch + crushed corn in a vessel at the fire. + Piñ´nyümta mata´ki The slab of finest texture; from "pin," fine. + Ma´ta ü´tci The upright partition stones separating the + metates. The rubbing stones have the same names + as the metates. + Hawi´wita A stone stairway. + Tütü´beñ hawi´wita A stairway pecked into a cliff face. + Sa´ka A ladder. + Wina´hawi´pi Steps of wood. + Ki´cka The covered way. + Hitcu´yî´wa "Opening to pass through;" a narrow passage +between + houses. + Ki´sombi "Place closed with houses;" courts and spaces + between house groups. + Bavwa´kwapi A gutter pipe inserted in the roof coping. + + [Illustration: Plate CVIII. Large openings reduced to small windows, + Oraibi.] + +In kiva nomenclature the various parts of the roof have the same names +as the corresponding features of the dwellings. These are described on +pp. 148-151. + + Le´stabi The main roof timbers. + Wina´kwapi The smaller cross poles. + Kaha´b kwapi The willow covering. + Süibi kwapi The brush covering. + Si´hü kwapi The grass covering. + Tcuka´tcve wata The dry earth layer of the roof. + Kiam´ba´lawi The layer of mud plaster on the roof. + Kiami An entire roof. + +The following terms are used to specially designate various features of +the kivas: + + Tüpat´caiata, Both of these terms are used to designate + lestabi } the kiva hatchway beams upon which the + Lesta´bkwapi, } hatchway walls rest. + Süna´cabi le´stabi The main beams in the roof, nearest to the + hatchway. + [)E]p´eoka le´stabi The main beams next to the central ones. + Püep´eoka le´stabi The main beams next in order, and all the beams + intervening between the "epeoka" and the end + beams are so designated. + Kala´beoka lestabi The beams at the ends of a kiva. + Mata´owa "Stone placed with hands." + Hüzrüowa "Hard stone." + Both of these latter terms are applied to + corner foundation stones. + Kwa´kü üt´cpi Moveable mat of reeds or sticks for covering + hatchway opening, Fig. 29. + "Kwaku," wild hay; "utepi," a stopper. + Tüpat´caiata The raised hatchway; "the sitting place," + Fig. 95. + Tüpat´caiata tü´kwa The walls of the hatchway. + Kipat´ctjua´ta The kiva doorway; the opening into the hatchway, + Fig. 28. + Apa´pho´ya Small niches in the wall. "Apap," from "apabi," + inside, and "hoya," small. + Si´papüh An archaic term. The etymology of this word is + not known. + Kw[)o]p´kota The fireplace. "Kwuhi," coals or embers; + "küaiti," head. + K[)o]i´tci Pegs for drying fuel, fixed under the hatchway. + "Ko-hu," wood; Fig. 28. + Kokü´ina Pegs in the walls. + Sa´ka A ladder. This term is applied to any ladder. + Figs. 45-47. + Sa´kaleta Ladder rungs; "Leta," from "lestabi;" see above. + Tüvwibi The platform elevation or upper level of the + floor. "Tu-vwi," a ledge; Fig. 24. + Tüvwi Stone ledges around the sides, for seats. The + same term is used to designate any ledge, + as that of a mesa, etc. + Katcin´ Kibü "Katcina," house. The niche in a ledge at the + end of the kiva. + Kwi´sa The planks set into the floor, to which the + lower beam of a blanket loom is fastened. + Kaintup´ha } Terms applied to the main floor; they both mean + Kiva´kani } "the large space." + Tapü´wü´tci Hewn planks a foot wide and 6 to 8 feet long, + set into the floor. + Wina´wü´tci A plank. + Owa´pühü´imiata "Stone spread out;" the flagged floor; also + designates the slabs covering the hatchway. + Yau´wiopi. Stones with holes pecked in the ends for holding + the loom beam while the warp is being + adjusted; also used as seats; see p. 132. + + [Illustration: Plate CIX. Stone corrals and kiva of Mashongnavi.] + +The accompanying diagram is an ideal section of a Tusayan four-story +house, and gives the native names for the various rooms and terraces. + + [Illustration: Fig. 114. Diagram showing ideal section of terraces, + with Tusayan names.] + + + + +CONCLUDING REMARKS. + + +The modern villages of Tusayan and Cibola differ more widely in +arrangement and in the relation they bear to the surrounding topography +than did their predecessors even of historic times. + +Many of the older pueblos of both groups appear to have belonged to the +valley types--villages of considerable size, located in open plains or +on the slopes of low-lying foothills. A comparison of the plans in +Chapters II and III will illustrate these differences. In Tusayan the +necessity of defense has driven the builders to inaccessible sites, so +that now all the occupied villages of the province are found on mesa +summits. The inhabitants of the valley pueblos of Cibola, although +compelled at one time to build their houses upon the almost inaccessible +summit of Tâaaiyalana mesa, occupied this site only temporarily, and +soon established a large valley pueblo, the size and large population of +which afforded that defensive efficiency which the Tusayan obtained only +by building on mesa promontories. This has resulted in some adherence on +the part of the Tusayan to the village plans of their ancestors, while +at Zuni the great house clusters, forming the largest pueblo occupied in +modern times, show a wide departure from the primitive types. In both +provinces the architecture is distinguished from that of other portions +of the pueblo region by greater irregularity of plan and by less +skillfully executed constructional details; each group, however, happens +to contain a notable exception to this general carelessness. + +In Cibola the pueblo of Kin-tiel, built with a continuous defensive +outer wall, occupies architecturally a somewhat anomalous position, +notwithstanding its traditional connection with the group, and the Fire +House occupies much the same relation in reference to Tusayan. The +latter, however, does not break in upon the unity of the group, since +the Tusayan, to a much greater extent than the Zuñi, are made up of +remnants of various bands of builders. In Cibola, however, some of the +Indians state that their ancestors, before reaching Zuñi, built a number +of pueblos, whose ruins are distinguished from those illustrated in the +present paper by the presence of circular kivas, this form of ceremonial +room being, apparently, wholly absent from the Cibolan pueblos here +discussed. + +The people of Cibola and of Tusayan belong to distinct linguistic +stocks, but their arts are very closely related, the differences being +no greater than would result from the slightly different conditions that +have operated within the last few generations. Zuñi, perhaps, came more +directly under early Spanish influence than Tusayan. + +Churches were established, as has been seen, in both provinces, but it +is doubtful whether their presence produced any lasting impression on +the people. In Tusayan the sway of the Spaniards was very brief. At some +of the pueblos the churches seem to have been built outside of the +village proper where ample space was available within the pueblo; but +such an encroachment on the original inclosed courts seems never to have +been attempted. Zuñi is an apparent exception; but all the house +clusters east of the church have probably been built later than the +church itself, the church court of the present village being a much +larger area than would be reserved for the usual pueblo court. These +early churches were, as a rule, built of adobe, even when occurring in +stone pueblos. The only exception noticed is at Ketchipauan, where it +was built of the characteristic Indian smoothly chinked masonry. The +Spaniards usually intruded their own construction, even to the +composition of the bricks, which are nearly always made of straw adobe. + +At Tusayan there is no evidence that a church or mission house ever +formed part of the villages on the mesa summits. Their plans are +complete in themselves, and probably represent closely the first pueblos +built on these sites. These summits have been extensively occupied only +in comparatively recent times, although one or more small clusters may +have been built here at an early date as outlooks over the fields in the +valleys below. + + [Illustration: Plate CX. Portion of a corral in Pescado.] + +It is to be noted that some of the ruins connected traditionally and +historically with Tusayan and Cibola differ in no particular from stone +pueblos widely scattered over the southwestern plateaus which have been +from time to time invested with a halo of romantic antiquity, and +regarded as remarkable achievements in civilization by a vanished but +once powerful race. These deserted stone houses, occurring in the midst +of desert solitudes, appealed strongly to the imaginations of early +explorers, and their stimulated fancy connected the remains with +"Aztecs" and other mysterious peoples. That this early implanted bias +has caused the invention of many ingenious theories concerning the +origin and disappearance of the builders of the ancient pueblos, is +amply attested in the conclusions reached by many of the writers on this +subject. + +In connection with the architectural examination of some of these +remains many traditions have been obtained from the present tribes, +clearly indicating that some of the village ruins, and even cliff +dwellings, have been built and occupied by ancestors of the present +Pueblo Indians, sometimes at a date well within the historic period. + +The migrations of the Tusayan clans, as described in the legends +collected by Mr. Stephen, were slow and tedious. While they pursued +their wanderings and awaited the favorable omens of the gods they halted +many times and planted. They speak traditionally of stopping at certain +places on their routes during a certain number of "plantings," always +building the characteristic stone pueblos and then again taking up the +march. + +When these Indians are questioned as to whence they came, their replies +are various and conflicting; but this is due to the fact that the +members of one clan came, after a long series of wanderings, from the +north, for instance, while those of other gentes may have come last from +the east. The tribe to-day seems to be made up of a collection or a +confederacy of many enfeebled remnants of independent phratries and +groups once more numerous and powerful. Some clans traditionally +referred to as having been important are now represented by few +survivors, and bid fair soon to become extinct. So the members of each +phratry have their own store of traditions, relating to the wanderings +of their own ancestors, which differ from those of other clans, and +refer to villages successively built and occupied by them. In the case +of others of the pueblos, the occupation of cliff dwellings and cave +lodges is known to have occurred within historic times. + +Both architectural and traditional evidence are in accord in +establishing a continuity of descent from the ancient Pueblos to those +of the present day. Many of the communities are now made up of the more +or less scattered but interrelated remnants of gentes which in former +times occupied villages, the remains of which are to-day looked upon as +the early homes of "Aztec colonies," etc. + +The adaptation, of this architecture to the peculiar environment +indicates that it has long been practiced under the same conditions that +now prevail. Nearly all of the ancient pueblos were built of the +sandstone found in natural quarries at the bases of hundreds of cliffs +throughout these table-lands. This stone readily breaks into small +pieces of regular form, suitable for use in the simple masonry of the +pueblos without receiving any artificial treatment. The walls themselves +give an exaggerated idea of finish, owing to the care and neatness with +which the component stones are placed. Some of the illustrations in the +last chapter, from photographs, show clearly that the material of the +walls was much ruder than the appearance of the finished masonry would +suggest, and that this finish depended on the careful selection and +arrangement of the fragments. This is even more noticeable in the Chaco +ruins, in which the walls were wrought to a high degrees of surface +finish. The core of the wall was laid up with the larger and more +irregular stones, and was afterwards brought to a smooth face by +carefully filling in and chinking the joints with smaller stones and +fragments, sometimes not more than a quarter of an inch thick; this +method is still roughly followed by both Tusayan and Cibolan builders. + +Although many details of construction and arrangement display remarkable +adaptation to the physical character of the country, yet the influence +of such environment would not alone suffice to produce this +architectural type. In order to develop the results found, another +element was necessary. This element was the necessity for defense. The +pueblo population was probably subjected to the more or less continuous +influence of this defensive motive throughout the period of their +occupation of this territory. A strong independent race of people, who +had to fear no invasion by stronger foes, would necessarily have been +influenced more by the physical environment and would have progressed +further in the art of building, but the motive for building rectangular +rooms--the initial point of departure in the development of pueblo +architecture--would not have been brought into action. The crowding of +many habitations upon a small cliff ledge or other restricted site, +resulting in the rectangular form of rooms, was most likely due to the +conditions imposed by this necessity for defense. + + [Illustration: Plate CXI. Zuñi eagle-cage.] + +The general outlines of the development of this architecture wherein the +ancient builders were stimulated to the best use of the exceptional +materials about them, both by the difficult conditions of their +semi-desert environment and by constant necessity for protection against +their neighbors, can be traced in its various stages of growth from the +primitive conical lodge to its culmination in the large communal village +of many-storied terraced buildings which we find to have been in use at +the time of the Spanish discovery, and which still survives in Zuñi, +perhaps its most striking modern example. Yet the various steps have +resulted from a simple and direct use of the material immediately at +hand, while methods gradually improved as frequent experiments taught +the builders more fully to utilize local facilities. In all cases the +material was derived from the nearest available source, and often +variations in the quality of the finished work are due to variations in +the quality of the stone near by. The results accomplished attest the +patient and persistent industry of the ancient builders, but the work +does not display great skill in construction or in preparation of +material. The same desert environment that furnished such an abundance +of material for the ancient builders, also, from its difficult and +inhospitable character and the constant variations in the water supply, +compelled the frequent employment of this material. This was an +important factor in bringing about the attained degree of advancement in +the building art. At the present day constant local changes occur in the +water sources of these arid table-lands, while the general character of +the climate remains unaltered. + +The distinguishing characteristics of Pueblo architecture may be +regarded as the product of a defensive motive and of an arid environment +that furnished an abundance of suitable building material, and at the +same time the climatic conditions that compelled its frequent +employment. + +The decline of the defensive motive within the last few years has +greatly affected the more recent architecture. Even after the long +practice of the system has rendered it somewhat fixed, comparative +security from attack has caused many of the Pueblo Indians to recognize +the inconvenience of dwellings grouped in large clusters on sites +difficult of access, while the sources of their subsistence are +necessarily sparsely scattered over large areas. This is noticeable in +the building of small, detached houses at a distance from the main +villages, the greater convenience to crops, flocks and water outweighing +the defensive motive. In Cibola particularly, a marked tendency in this +direction has shown itself within a score of years; Ojo Caliente, the +newest of the farming pueblos, is perhaps the most striking example +within the two provinces. The greater security of the pueblos as the +country comes more fully into the hands of Americans, has also resulted +in the more careless construction in modern examples as compared with +the ancient. + +There is no doubt that, as time shall go on, the system of building +many-storied clusters of rectangular rooms will gradually be abandoned +by these people. In the absence of the defensive motive a more +convenient system, employing scattered small houses, located near +springs and fields, will gradually take its place, thus returning to a +mode of building that probably prevailed in the evolution of the pueblo +prior to the clustering of many rooms into large defensive villages. Pl. +LXXXIII illustrates a building of the type described located on the +outskirts of Zuñi, across the river from the main pueblo. + +The cultural distinctions between the Pueblo Indians and neighboring +tribes gradually become less clearly defined as investigation +progresses. Mr. Cushing's study of the Zuñi social, political, and +religious systems has clearly established their essential identity in +grade of culture with those of other tribes. In many of the arts, too, +such as weaving, ceramics, etc., these people in no degree surpass many +tribes who build ruder dwellings. + +In architecture, though, they have progressed far beyond their +neighbors; many of the devices employed attest the essentially primitive +character of the art, and demonstrate that the apparent distinction in +grade of culture is mainly due to the exceptional condition of the +environment. + + + + +INDEX + + +Acoma, arrival of the Asanyumu at 30 + direction of kivas of 116 + kiva trap-doors at 207 +Adobe, use in Tusayan 54, 78 + use in Zuñi attributed to foreign influence 139 + necessity for protecting against rain 156 + used in Spanish churches 224 +Adobe balls used in garden walls 146 +Adobe bricks, in Hawikut church 81 + use modern in Zuñi 138 +Adobe mortar, in Tâaaiyalana structures 90 + Cibola and Tusayan use of, compared 137 +Adobe walls on stone foundation at Moenkopi 78 +Áikoka. See Acoma 30 +Aiyáhokwi, the descendants of the Asa at Zuñi 30 +Alleyway, Hawikuh 81 +Altar, conformity of, to direction of kiva 116 +Andiron, Shumopavi 176 +Annular doorway 192, 193 +Apache, inroads upon Tusayan by the 25, 26, 35 + exposure of southern Cibola to the 96 +Architectural nomenclature 220, 223 +Architecture, comparison of constructional details + of Tusayan and Cibola 100-223 + adaption to defense 226, 227 + adaption to environment 225, 226, 227, 228 +Art, textile and fictile, degree of Pueblo advancement in 227 +Arts of Cibola and Tusayan closely related 224 +Asa, migrations of the 30, 31 + language of the 37 + houses of, Hano 61 +Asanyumu. See Asa. +Awatubi, survey of 14 + Spanish mission established at 22 + when and by whom built 29 + settlement of the Asa at 30 + attacked by the Walpi 34 + description of ruins of 49, 50 + possession of sheep by the 50 + clay tubes used as roof drains at 155 + fragments of passage wall at 181 +Aztecs, ruined structures attributed to the 225 + +Badger people leave Walpi 31 +Baho, use of, in kiva consecratory ceremonies 119-120, 129, 130 +Balcony, notched and terraced 187 +Banded masonry 145 +Bandelier, A. F., description of chimney 173 + explorations of 197 + on ancient stone inclosures 216 +Bat house, description of ruin of 52 +Bátni, the first pueblo of the Snake people of Tusayan 18 +Bedsteads not used by Pueblos 214 +Beams, Tusayan kivas, taken from Spanish church at Shumopavi 76 + for supporting upper walls 144 + modern finish of 149 + construction of steps upon 162 + for supporting passageway wall 181 + Chaco pueblos, how squared 184 +Bear people, settlement in Tusayan of the 20, 26 + removal to Walpi of the 21, 27 + movements of 27, 30, 31, 38 +Bear-skin-rope people, settlement in Tusayan of the 26, 27 +Benches or ledges of masonry, Zuñi rooms 110 + Tusayan kivas 121, 123, 125 + Mashongnavi mungkiva 127 + around rooms of pueblo houses 213 +Bins for storage in Tusayan rooms 109, 209, 210 +Blankets formerly used to cover doorways 182, 188, 189, 194 +Blue Jay people, settlement in Tusayan of the 26, 27 +Bond stones used in pueblo walls 144, 198 +Boss, or andiron, Shumopavi 176 +Boundary line, Hano and Sichumovi 36 +Boundary mark, Shumopavi and Oraibi 28 +Boxes for plumes 210 +Bricks of adobe modern in Zuñi 138 +Brush, use of, in roof construction 150 +Brush shelters 217-219 +Burial custom of K'iakima natives 86 +Burial inclosures at K'iakima 147 +Burial place of Zuñi 148 +Burrowing Owl people, settlement in Tusayan of the 26 +Buttress, formerly of Halona, existing in Zuñi 88, 89 +Buttress projections, Zuñi 111 + Tusayan rooms 109, 110 + girders supported by 144 + chimney supported by 172, 173 + support of passageway roofs by 181 + +Cages for eagles at Zuñi 214 +Canyon de Chelly, proposed study of ruins of 14 + Tusayan, tradition concerning villages of 19 + early occupancy of, by the Bear people at Tusayan 20 + occupied by the Asa 30 + use of whitewash in cliff houses of 74, 145 + circular kivas of 117, 133 + finish of roofs of houses of 150, 151 + doorway described and figured 190 + cliff dwellings of 217 +Casa Blanca, traces of whitewashing at 145 +Castañeda's account of Cibolan milling 211, 212 +Cattle introduced into Tusayan 22 +Cave lodges occupied in historic times 225 +Cave used by inhabitants of Kwaituki 57 +Ceiling plan of Shupaulovi kiva 123, 125, 126 +Ceilings, retention of original appearance of rooms + through nonrenovation of 89 +Cellars not used in Tusayan and Cibola 143 +Ceremonial chamber. See Kiva. +Ceremonial paraphernalia of Tusayan taken by the Navajo 50 +Ceremonies connected with Tusayan house-building 100-104, 168 +Ceremonies accompanying kiva construction 115, 118 +Ceremonies performed at placing of Zuñi ladders 160 +Chaco ruins, character of 14, 70 + compared with Kin-tiel 92 + finish of masonry of 140, 226 + upper story partitions of, supported by beams 144 + finish of woodwork of 149, 184 + symmetry of arrangement of outer openings of 195 + loop-holes in walls of 198 +Chairs, lack of in Pueblo houses 212 +Chalowe, description of 83 +Charred roof timbers of Tusayan kiva 120 +Chimney. See Fireplace. +Chimney-hoods, how constructed 169-175 +Chimneys, traces of in K'iakima 85 + remains of, at Matsaki 86 + Tusayan 102 + Zuñi 111 + described and figured 167-180 +Chukubi pueblo, built by the Squash people 25 + description 58, 59 + fragments of passage wall at 181 +Church, Shumopavi, established by Spanish monks 75, 76 + Hawikuh 81, 138 + Ketchipauan, remains of 81, 82 + in court of Zuñi 98, 138, 148 + See Mission. +Churches established in Zuñi and Tusayan 224 +Cibola, ruins and inhabited villages of 80-99 + architecture of compared with that of Tusayan 100-223 + See Zuñi. +Circular doorway of Kin-tiel described 192 +Circular kivas, antiquity of 116 + traditional references to 135 + absent in Cibolan pueblos 224 +Circular room at Oraibi Wash 54-55 +Circular rooms at Kin-tiel 93 +Circular wall of kiva near Sikyatki 117 +Clay surface of pueblo roofs 151 +Clay tubes used as roof drains 155 +Cliff dwellings, Moen-kopi 54 + use of whitewash in 74 + absence of chimneys in 168 + developed from temporary shelters 217 + occupied in historic times 225 +Climatic conditions, effect of, upon pueblo architecture 140, 227 +Clustering of Tâaaiyalana ruins 89-90 +Cochití claimed to be a former Tewa pueblo 37 +Communal village, development of pueblo architecture + from conical lodge to 226 +Consecration of kivas 129 +Contours represented on plans, interval of 45 +Cooking, pueblo method of 164 +Cooking pits and ovens described 162-166, 176-177 +Cooking stones of Tusayan, flames of 104 +Copings of walls described 151-152 +Coping of hatchways 203 +Coping. See Roof-coping. +Cords, used for suspending chimney 170 +Corner stones of Tusayan kivas 119 +Corrals, Payupki 59 + Sichumovi 62-63 + Hawikuh 81 + Ketchipauan 81 + modern, at K'iakima 85 + how constructed 146 + described in detail 214-217 +Cotton cultivated by the Tusayan 33 +Courts, Mishiptonga 52 + Kwaituki 56 + Chukubi 59 + Sichumovi 62 + Walpi 63 + Mashongnavi 68 + Shupaulovi 71 + Shumopavi 74 + Hawikuh 81 + Ketchipauan 81 + Matsaki 86 + Tâaaiyalana 90 + Kin-tiel 92 + Pescado 95 + Zuñi 98 +Covered way, how developed 76 +Covered passages and gateways described 180-182 +Coyote people, settlement in Tusayan of the 26 +Coyote kiva, direction of the 116 +Crossbars used in fastening wooden doors 183 +Crosspieces of ladders 159 +Cruzate, visit to Awatubi of 49 +Culture of pueblo tribes, degree of 227 +Cushing, Frank H., identifies K'iakima + as scene of death of Estevanico 86 + excavations at Halona 88, 193 + opinion concerning western wall of Halona 89 + opinion concerning distribution of Tâaaiyalana ruins 89-90 + on the former occupancy of Kin-tiel 92 + Haloua identified as one of the Seven Cities of Cibola 97 + on Zuñi tradition concerning stone-close 192 + +Dais of kivas 121, 122, 123 +Dance ceremony in kiva consecration 130 +Dance rock, Tusayan, reference to snake dance of 65 +Débris, how indicated in plans of ruins 45 + an indication of original height of walls 90 +Decoration, house openings 145-146 + Kiva roof timbers 119, 120 + ladder crosspieces 159 + roof beams 123, 124 + wall of Mashongnavi house 146 + wooden chair 213 + Zuñi window sashes 196 +Deer horns used as pegs in Zuñi 111 +Defense, wall for, at Bat House 52 + a motive for selection of dwelling site 56 + architecture relied upon for 58 + method of, of Payupki 59, 60 + not a factor in selection of Mashongnavi site 67 + features of, at Ojo Calient 69 + wall for, at Pueblo Bonito 70 + features of, at Tusayan and Zuñi compared 76 + sites chosen for, inconvenient to sources of subsistence 77 + use of Kelchipauan church for, by natives 82 + the motive of occupation of Tâaaiyalana mesa 90 + provision for, at Kin-tie 92, 93 + provisions for, in Ketchipauan church 96 + motive for, dying out in Zuñi 96-97 + efficiency of, at Zuñi 97 + not a motive in selection of site of Zuñi 97 + gateways arranged for 180, 182 + loopholes for 198 + adaptation of architecture to 225 +Doors to ground floor rooms of Zuñi 143 +Doors of various lands described 183-194 +Doorway, Walpi kiva, closed with cottonwood slab 64 + Kin-tiel 93 + position of, in Tusayan 103 + stepped form in Tusayan 109 + how sealed against intrusion 110 + window and chimney in one 121 + annular 193 +Doorways, closed with masonry 183, 187, 188, 189 + why made small 197 +Drainage of roof, relations of certain roof openings to 203-204 +Drains of roofs described 153-156 +Drains. See roof drains. + +Eagle cages of Zuñi 214 +Eagle people, migration legend of the 28 +Earth used in pueblo roof construction 150 +Eaves, lack of, in Tusayan houses 102 +Echo Cave fireplace described 168 +Entrances, uniformity of direction of, in Zuñi kivas 116 +Environment, adaptation, of architecture to 225, 226, 227, 228 +Estevanico's death, at K'iakima 86 +Estufa. See Kiva. + +Families occupying Oraibi 105-108 +Farming outlook, Matsaki used as 86 + near Kin-tiel 93 +Farming pueblos, Cibola 14 + Moen-kopi 77 + Nutria 94, 95 + Pescado 95-96 + Ojo Caliente 96 + Zuñi 198 +Fastenings of doors 186 +Feathers, use of, in house-building ceremonies 101, 102 +Feather wand or baho used in kiva-building ceremonials + 119, 120, 129, 130 +Fences of corrals and gardens 215, 217 +Fetiches, where placed during kiva ceremonial 122 + Tusayan kivas 130, 131 +Fire gens, Tebugkihu constructed by the 57 +Fire-house or Tebugkihu, Tusayan 20, 57, 100, 142, 224 +Fire people of Tusayan, migration of the 20 +Fireplaces 102, 109, 121, 125, + 163, 167-180 +Floor, Mashongnavi house 109 + stone flags, Tusayan kiva 121 + sandstone slabs, Shupaulovi kiva 123 +Floors in pueblo buildings, various kinds described + 121, 135, 148-151 +Folk-tale of the Zuñi, describing stone-close 193 +Food sacrifices in Tusayan house building 101, 102 +Fortress houses the highest type of Pueblo construction 77 +Frames of trap-doors, method of making 206 +Framing of windows, method of 196-198 +Fuel, how stored in Tusayan 103 +Fuel used in kivas 121 +Fuel of kivas, where stored 124 +Furniture of the Pueblos described 208-214 + +Gardens and corrals of the Pueblos 214-217 +Gardens and garden walls 215-217 +Garden walls, how constructed 146 +Gateway at Awatubi 49 +Gateway jambs at Kin-tiel, finish of 181 +Gateways, probable existence in Kin-tiel of 93 +Gateways and covered passages described 180-182 +Gateways of corrals 214 +Genesis myth of the Tusayan 16 +Gentes of Tusayan, grouping of houses by 24 + land apportionment by 29 + list of traditionary 38 + localization of 104-108 +Girders supporting upper walls 144 + Tusayan houses supported by piers 151 +Glass used in modern Pueblo windows 193 +Glazing of Pueblo windows 196, 197 +Goat kiva of Walpi, height of 119 +Gourd used as roof drain 154, 155 +Grass, use of, in roof construction 150 +Graves, probable existence of, in Kin-tiel 93 +Gravestones at K'iakima 85, 86, 147 +Greasewood, the ordinary kiva fuel 121 +Grinding stones. See Metate; Milling. +Ground plan, Mashongnavi room 108 + Shupaulovi kiva 125 +Ground plans of Zuñi and Tusayan compared 76 + of mesa villages influenced by prevailing winds 182 +Guyave or piki oven 173, 175 +Gyarzobi or Paroquet kiva, roof timbers of 120 +Gypsum used as whitewash 73, 74, 172 + +Hairdressing among the Tusayan 37 +Halona, description of 88, 89 + remains of the nucleus of Zuñi 97, 98 + walls of the nucleus of modern Zuñi 138 + stone-close at, described 193 +"Halving" of timbers in kiva trap-frames 206 +Hampassawan, description of 83-85 +Hand-holds cut in faces of cliffs 191 +Hand-holds in frames of trap-doors 192 +Hano, Asa group occupy site of 30 + description of 61, 62 + direction of kivas of 115 + kiva, ownership of 134 + kivas, list of 136 + rude transom over roof beam in 187 + sealed openings in 199 +Hano people, length of time spent in Tusayan by the 35 + received by the Tusayan 36 + trouble between the Walpi and 37 +Hanomuh, the inhabitants of Hano 17 + definition of 36 +Hano traditions regarding settlement in Tusayan 35 +Harvest time, how determined in Zuñi 148 +Hatchways to pueblo houses 110, 120, 121, 124, 127 +Hawikuh, description of 80, 81 +Hawikuh church, durability of masonry of 138 +Hemenway Southwestern Archeological Expedition, + excavations at Halona 193 +High-house people, a Navajo clan 30 +Hinged sashes not in use in Zuñi 196 +Hinges of Pueblo doors 184 +Hodge, F. Webb, on stone-close of Halona 193 +Holmes, William H., on ruins of the San Juan 147 +Homólobi, the early home of the Sun and Water peoples 29 + legend of Water people concerning 31 +Hopituh, the native name of the Tusayan 17 +Hopituh marriage within phratries and gentes 24 +Horn House, description of ruin of 50, 51 +Horn people migration legend 18 + early settlement in Tusayan of the 19 +House-building rites of Tusayan 100-104 +House clusters in Zuñi, arrangement of 98 +Hungo Pavie, finish of roofs in 150 + +Interior arrangement of pueblos 108-111 +Interior of Zuñi house described 110 +Irrigation of gardens near Walpi 217 + +Jackson, W. H., on ruins of the San Juan 147 + photographs of pueblo ruins by 147 + describes fireplace of Echo Cave 168 +Jar of large size used for storage 210 +Jars used in chimney construction 180 +Jeditoh group of ruins 52, 53 +Jemez oven-opening described 165 + +Kaékibi, an ancient pueblo 30 +Kaiwáika. See Laguna 30 +Kápung. See Santa Clara 37 +Katchina kiva of Oraibi 135 +Katchina people depart from Oraibi + for eastern Tusayan villages 26, 27 +Katchinkihu, occurrence of, in ruined kiva near Sikyatki 117 + described 121, 123 + Shupaulovi kiva 126 + Mashonguavi mungkiva 127 +Kótite. See Cochití. +Ketchipauan church built of stone 224 +Ketchipauan, description of 81-83 +Kiáini. See High-house people 30 +K'iakima, description of 85, 86 + upright stone slabs at 147 +Kikoli rooms occupied in winter 103, 104, 131 +Kin-tiel, description of 91-94 + compared with Nutria 94 + compared with Pescado 96 + plan of, prearranged 100 + compared with Oraibi 114 + occurrence of upright stone slab at 147-148 + beams of ruins of 149 + upper room of, paved with stone 151 + fireplace in room of 163, 168 + defensive gateway at 181 +Kin-tiel, finish of gateway jambs at 181 + circular doorway at, described 192, 193 + openings at, of uniform height 194 + site of 224 +Kisákobi, description of pueblo of 21 +Kishoni, or uncovered shade 217-218 +"Kisi" construction 217-219 +Kitdauwi--the house song of Tusayan 118-119 +Kiva, study of construction of 14 + remains of, at Payupki 60 + Mashongnavi 66 + of Moen-kopi 78 + origin of the name 111 + ancient form of 116, 117 + native explanation of position of 118 + duties of mungwi, or chief of the 133 + ownership of 133-134 + motive for building 134-135 + significance of structural plan of 135 + measurements of 136 + hatchways of 201-202, 205-207 + openings of, at Acoma 207 + See Mungkiva. +Kivas, excavated, at Awatubi 50 + Hano 61 + Sichumovi 62 + Walpi 63, 64, 65 + Shupaulovi 72 + Shumopavi 74 + Kin-tiel and Cibola compared 93 + Zuñi, where located during Spanish occupancy 99 + in Tusayan 111-137 + typical plans of 118-129 + dimensions of 118, 136 + of, measurements of 118, 136 + annually repaired by women 129 + uses of 130 + nomenclature of 130, 223-223 + Tusayan, list of 136 + nonuse of chimneys in 178 + Zuñi, stone window-frames of 197 +Kwaituki, description of ruin of 56-57 +Kwálakwai, Hano tradition related by 35 +Kwetcap tutwi, the second pueblo of the + snake people of Tusayan 18 + +Ladders, arrangement in Tusayan kiva 121 + withdrawal of rungs to prevent use of 113 + significance of position of, in kivas 135 + described 156-162 + second-story terrace of Tusayan reached principally by 182 + openings for, in roofs 205 +Laguna, arrival of the Asanyumu at 30 +Lalénkobáki, a female society of Tusayan 134 +Land apportionment by gentes in Tusayan 29 +Language of the Asa and Hano of Tusayan 37 +Languages of Tusayan, tradition regarding difference in 36 +Las Animas ruins, trap-door frames in 206 +Latches of doors 186-187 +Latch strings used on Zuñi doors 183 +Lathing or wattling of kiva walls 126 +Ledges of masonry in kivas 121 +Ledges or benches around rooms 213 +Lenbaki, society of Tusayan 18 +Light, method of introducing, in inner rooms 207 +Lighting, method of, in crowded portions of Zuñi 99 +Lintels of old windows embedded in masonry 200 +Lizard people move from Walpi 31, 38 +Lock and key of wood, how made 187 +Loom appurtenances 212 +Loom posts of kivas 128-129, 132 +Loophole-like openings in pueblo buildings 127, 198 + +Mamzrántiki, an Oraibi society of women 134 +Mandan ladder described and figured 158 +Maricopa, myth of the Water people of Tusayan concerning the 32 +Marriage of the Hopituh within phratries and gentes 24 +Mashongnavi, origin of name of 26 + settlement of Paroquet and Katchina peoples in 27 + settlementof the Water people at 32 + description of ruins of 48 + age of masonry at 66 + description of 66-70 + ground plan of room of 108 + direction of kivas of 115 + description of dais of kiva at 122 + list of kivas at 136 + wall decoration at 146 + notched ladder of 157-158 + pi-gummi ovens at 163-164 + shrines of 167 + chimney hoods of 170-171 + second-story fireplace at 174 + doorway with transom at 190 + corrals of rude stonework at 214 + See Old Mashongnavi. +Masonry, ancient, at Nutria 94 + Ojo Caliente carelessly constructed 96 + exterior, of kivas 114 +Masonry of Pueblo Bonito, skill shown in 195 +Mat close for kiva hatchways 127, 128 +Matsaki, description of 86 + sun symbol at 148 +Meal, votive, used in pueblo house-building 101 +Mealing trough. See Milling. +Metate used as roof-drain 154, 155 +Metates, or grinding stones, + how arranged in pueblo houses 109, 110, 210, 211 +Migration, effect of, upon pueblo architecture 15 +Migration of the Tusayan 17 +Migration of Tusayan Water people 31, 32 +Migration of the Horn people 18, 19 +Migration of the Bear people of Tusayan 20 +Migration of the Asanynmu of Tusayan 30 +Milling troughs of Pueblo households 109, 210, 212 +Mindeleff, Cosmos, acknowledgments to 14, 15 + on traditional history of Tusayan 16-41 +Mindeleff, Victor, paper on pueblo architecture 3-228 +Mishiptonga, description of ruin of 52-53 +Mission buildings of Shumopavi 27, 75-76 +Mission house at Walpi, timbers of, used in Walpi kiva 119 +Missions of Tusayan 22, 49 +Moen-kopi surveyed and studied 14 + description of ruins of 53-54 + description of village of 77 +Mole people, settlement in Tusayan of the 27 +Montezuma Canyon ruins, use of large stone blocks in 147 +Monument marking boundary of Oraibi and Shumopavi 28 +Morgan, L. H., Mandan ladder described by 158 + on trap-door frames in Las Animas ruins 205 +Mormon and Pueblo building compared 148 +Mormons, effect of the, upon development of Moen-kopi 77 + establishment of woolen mill at Moen-kopi by the 78 + fort built by, at Moen-kopi 184 + lock and key contrivance of 187 +Mortar of adobe mud 137 +Mortars used in Pueblo households 212 +Mortised door in Zuñi house 110, 186 +Mummy cave, Arizona, ruin in 64 + finish of roofs in ruins of 150 +Mungkiva, Mashongnavi 127 + of Shupaulovi 113, 122 + Tusayan 134 + +Nambé, Tewa pueblo 37 +Navajo, Asa of Tusayan live among 30 + huts of, closed with blankets 189 + method of sheep-herding compared with Pueblo 214 +Nelson, E. W., graves unearthed by 86 + collection of stone-closes by 193 +Niches, use of, in kivas 121, 122 +Niches formed in old window openings 110, 200, 208-209 +Nomenclature of Tusayan structural details 220-223 +Númi. See Nambé. +Notched logs used as ladders 157-158 +Nutria, compared with Kin-tiel 91 + description of 91-95 +Nuvayauma, old Mashongnavi tradition related by 47-48 +Nuvwatikyuobi kiva 120 + +Oak mound kiva, Tusayan, decadence of membership of 135 +Ohke. See San Juan. +Ojo Caliente, a modern village 54, 96-97 + chinked walls of 142 +Old Mashongnavi, tradition concerning occupation of 47-48 +Openings, splayed, in Ketchipauan church 82 + walls of Tâaaiyalana structures 90 + Kin-tiel walls 92, 93 + oblique Zuñi 98, 207-208 + to kivas 113-114 + in wall of Zuñi kiva 114 + in lee walls 182 +Openings of Pueblo houses banded with whitewash 145-146 +Oraibi, retirement of Sikyátki inhabitants to 24 + departure of Ketchina and Paroquet peoples from 27 + settlement by the Bears of 27 + traditions regarding first settlement of 27 + settlement of the Water people at 33 + affray between the Walpi and 35 + description of 76-77 + families occupying 105-108 + direction of kivas of 115-116 + rare use of plastering on outer walls of 144 +Oraibi, notched ladders described and figured 157-158 + stone steps at, figured 161 + corral walls at, laid without mortar 147 + distribution of gentes of 104-105 + kiva for women 134 + list of kivas of 137 + kiva, hatchway of 201 + corrals at, large size of 214 +Oraibi-Shumopavi boundary stone 28 +Oraibi wash, ruins on the 54-56 +Orientation of kivas 115-116 +Ovens at Pescado 95 + upon roofs 151 + various kinds described 162-166 + in Zuñi 164-165 +Oven-shaped structures described and figured 167 +Oven-surface imbedded with pottery scales 139 + +Paintings on kiva walls 131 +Palát Kivabi, the pristine habitat of the Squash + and Sun people of Tusayan 25, 29 +Paneled doors in modern pueblos 184-186 +Parallelogramic form of Tusayan buildings 102-118 +Paroquet people, settlement in Shumopavi of the 37 +Partitions in Ketchipauan church 82 +Partitions of upper story supported by beams 144 +Passageways, Shupaulovi 72 + Shumopavi 74 + rarity of, at Oraibi 76 + description of 180-182 +Paving Shupaulovi kiva 126 +Paving stones of kiva floor, how finished 125 +Payupki, tradition concerning pueblo of 40 + migration legend 40 + description of 59-60 + finish of masonry of 143 + fragments of passage wall at 181 +Peaches planted by the Asa people 30 +Pegs, deer horns used as, in Zuñi 111 +Pegs for suspending kiva fuel 121 +Peña Blanca formerly inhabited by the Hano 35 +Peñasco Blanco, occurrence of upright stone slab at 148 + method of roof construction at 150 +Pescado compared with Kin-tiel 91 + description of 95-96 + corral walls at, how constructed 147 + outside steps at 160 + ovens at, described and figured 165-166 + fragment of stone close in steps of 193 + stone inclosure in court of 214 +Pestles or crushers used with Pueblo mortars 212 +Petroglyph, or sun-symbol at Matsaki 86 + Ketchipauan church 82 + legend of the Tusayan concerning 32 +Phratries, Tusayan 24, 38 +Pictograph on Oraibi-Shumopavi boundary monument 28 +Piers of masonry for supporting girders 151 +Piers. See Buttresses. +Pi-gummi ovens of Mashongnavi 163 +Piki or guyave oven 173-175 +Piki stone, process of making 175 +Pima, myth of the Water people of Tusayan concerning the 32 + opinion of the, as to ancient stone inclosures 216 +Pinawa, description of 86, 88 +Pine invariably used for kiva ladders 135 +Pink clay used in house decorations 146 +Pits for cooking 163 +Plan of villages, traditional mention of 104 +Plans and descriptions, Tusayan ruins 45-60 + inhabited villages 61-79 + Cibolan ruins 80 + Zuñi villages 94-99 +Plan of pueblo houses not usually prearranged 100-162 +Planting time, how determined in Zuñi 148 +Plaster, frequent renewal of, at Shumopavi 73 +Plastering, renovation of rooms by frequent 89 + on outer walls in Ojo Caliente 96 + custom formerly observed in 102 + on floor in Mashongnavi 109 + kiva walls 115 + Shupaulovi kiva, condition of 124-125 + Shupaulovi kiva 126 + on walls 140 + on masonry 144 + chimney hoods 169, 172 + side hole of door for fastening 183-184 +Platform in floor of Tusayan kiva 121 +Platform at head of steps 161-162 +Plaza. See Court. +Plume boxes 210 +Plume stick, baho, or feather wand, + used in Kiva consecratory ceremonials 119-120, 129, 130 +Plume-stick shrines at Mashongnavi 167 +Pojoaque, a Tewa pueblo 37 +Pokwádi. See Pojoaque 37 +Polaka, Hano tradition given by 35 +Poles for suspension of blankets, etc. 110, 189, 208, 214 +Ponobi kiva of Oraibi, wall lathing of 126 +Population, enlargement of pueblos necessitated by increase of 70 +Porch posts 81, 82 +Posówe, a former Tewa pueblo 37 +Posts of porch, remains of, at Hawikuh and Ketchipauan 81, 82 +Posts sunk in floor forming part of loom 212 +Pots used in chimney construction 179-180 +Pottery fragments, Horn House ruin 51 + Kwaituki 57 + ruin on Oraibi wash 55 + used in mud-plastered walls 139 +Pottery of Payupki, character of 60 +Poultry house of Sichumovi 167 +Prayer plume, or baho, used in + kiva consecratory ceremonials 119, 120, 129, 130 +Props used for fastening wooden doors 183 +Pueblo Bonito, additions to 70 + the largest yet examined 92 + finish of roof of 150 + stairway described 160 + symmetry of arrangement of outer openings of 195 + skill shown in masonry of 195 +Pueblo buildings, mode of additions to 70, 97, 98, 102, 148-149 +Pueblo construction in Tusayan and Cibola, details of 137-223 +Pueblo Grande. See Kin-tiel. +Pueblo openings, carelessness in placing 196 +Pueblo remains, area occupied by 13 +Pueblo revolt of 1680 89 +Pueblos of Tusayan and Cibola compared 80 +Pueblos, inhabited 61-79, 94-99 +Pyramidal form of pueblo house rows 61 + +Rabbit-skin robes used to cover doorways 182, 194 +Racks for suspending clothes 208, 214 +Rawhide thong used in pueblo construction + to fasten lock 186, 187, 214 +Rectangular kivas, antiquity of 116 +Rectangular rooms, how developed 226 +Rectangular type of architecture 72 +Reeds used for kiva lathing 126 +Repair of houses infrequent in Tusayan 73 +Reservoirs, pueblo 82-83, 91, 92, 97 +Reservoir site as affecting selection of dwelling site 51-52 +Revolt of the Pueblos in 1680 23 +Rites and methods of Tusayan kiva building 118-137 +Rites of house-building at Tusayan 100-104 +Rito de los Frijoles, chimney of, described 173 +Roof construction, pueblo buildings 120, 149 +Roof-coping of Tusayan houses 102 +Roof-drains, pueblo buildings 102, 153-156 +Roof-openings, pueblo buildings 61, 63, 77, 98, + 169, 178, 201-208 +Roofs, pueblo buildings 63, 102, 119, 148-151 +Roof timbers of kivas 119 +Rooms, arrangement of, into rows in Tusayan 49 + confused arrangement of, in Walpi 63 + Tâaaiyalana ruins, arrangement of 90 + circular, at Kin-tiel 93 + Tusayan, smaller than in Zuñi 108 + names of, in Tusayan 223 +Rows of houses forming Shumopavi 74 +Ruins, method of survey of 45 +Ruins, Tusayan 45-60 + between Horn House and Bat House 51 + Oraibi wash 54-56 + Cibola 80 + Tâaaiyalana 89 +Rungs of ladders, how attached 158, 159 + +Sacrifices of food in Tusayan house-building 101, 102 +Sandals of yucca found in Canyon de Chelly 133 +Sandstone used in pueblo construction, how quarried 225 +San Felipe, return of Payupki to 41 +San Juan, a Tewa pueblo 37 +Santa Clara doubtfully identified with Kápung 37 +Santo Domingo, settlement of the Asanyumu 30 +Sash of rude construction in window openings 196 +Sealing of doorways of pueblo buildings 110, 183-184, 198-201 +Seats of stone in Tusayan kivas 132 +Selenite used in pueblo windows 196, 197 +Semisubterranean kivas of Tusayan 113 +Seven cities of Cibola. See Cibola. +Sheep, introduced into Tusayan 22 + possessed by the Awatubi 50 + introduction of, among the Pueblos 214 +Shitáimu pueblo 28, 48, 49 +Shelters in pueblo fields 60, 198, 217-219 +Shelves, pueblo buildings 109, 173, 209 +Shrine, Matsaki 86 + court of Shupaulovi 71 + court of Shumopavi 75 + Tâaaiyalana 90 +Shrines, pueblo 72, 148, 167 +Shumopavi, Spanish mission established at 22 + by whom built 27 + removal of portion of Bear people from 27 + description of 73-76 + kivas of 113, 114, 137 + primitive andiron at 176 + piki stone at 176 + fireplace and chimney of 176, 177 + ground cooking-pit of 178 +Shumopavi-Oraibi boundary stone 28 +Shumopavi people, removal of, to mesa site 23 +Shupaulovi, settlement of Paroquet and Ketchina peoples in 27 + when established 29 + settlement of Bear people at 30 + settlement of the water people at 32 + description of 71-73 + mungkiva of, described 113 + direction of kivas of 115 + description of dais of kiva of 123 + ground and ceiling plans of kiva of 125 + list of kivas of 136 + description of chimney-hood at 171, 172 + passageway at, described 181 +Sichumovi, settled by peoples from Walpi 31 + derivation of term 38 + description of 62, 63 + direction of kivas of 115 + ownership of kiva of 134 + list of kivas of 136 + poultry-house of 167 + fireplace and mantel of 173 + piki stone at 175 +Sikyatki, ruin of 20, 21 + pueblo of 24 + ancient kiva near 117 +Sikyátki people dispute with the Walpi 24 + slaughtered by the Walpi 25 +Sills of doors 110, 186, 194 +Sióki. See Zuñi 30 +Sipapuh, Tusayan kivas 117, 121, 122, 123, + 126, 130, 131, 135 +Sites of pueblo buildings, why selected 63, 66, 90, 97, 112, 223 +Slabs of stone in pueblo architecture 147 +Slavery among the Tusayan 41 +Smallpox prevalent in Tusayan 38, 134 +Smoke escape through roof-opening and transoms 189, 204, 206, 207 +Snake dance, relation of dance-rock to 65 +Snake people, the first occupants of the Tusayan region 17 + construction of modern Walpi by the 23 +Snow, use of, as water supply by the Zuñi 91 +Spaniards, early visit of, to Tusayan 21, 22 +Spanish authority, effect of, + upon purity of Zuñi kiva type 112 +Spanish beams in Tusayan kivas 119, 123, 124, 125, 126 +Spanish churches at pueblos, Hawikuk 81, 82, 138 +Spanish influence in Zuñi and Tusayan 169, 180, 196, 213, 224 +Spanish missions established in Tusayan 22 +Spider people, settlement in Tusayan of the 27 +Splash-stones described and figured 155, 156 +Splayed openings in Ketchipauan church 82 +Squash people, settlement in Tusayan of the 25 +Stakes used in construction of stone walls 147 +Stephen, A. M., material on traditional history + of Tusayan collected by 16-41 + opinion on Walpi architectural features 72 + acknowledgments to 100 + on distribution of Oraibi gentes 104, 105 + on orientation of Tusayan kivas 115 + discovery of ancient kiva type near Sikyatki 117 + typical kiva measurements by 122 + on wattling or lathing of kiva walls 126 + on significance of structural plan of kiva 135 + collection of primitive andirons or bosses by 176 +Steps and ladders described 156-162 +Steps cut in faces of cliffs 191 +Steps or foot-holes of Walpi trail 65 +Steps to kivas 114 +Stone, size, character, and finish of, + in pueblo ruins 55, 58, 60, 138 + means of obtaining, in Zuñi 139 + effect of use of, in chimney hoods 172 + corrals 214 + flags used to floor Tusayan kiva 121 + inclosures in Southern Arizona 216 + roof drains, curious forms of 154 + shelters, possible remains of, at Payupki 60 + slabs formerly used to close doorways 188 +Stone-close anciently used 192, 193 +Stone wedges used in pueblo wall finish 140, 142 +Stonework, Shumopavi 75 + at Oraibi 144 + Mormon and Pueblos compared 148 +Stone steps, Pescado 95 + Tusayan 157 +Stools used by the Pueblos 212, 213 +Storage facilities of pueblo dwellings 57, 62, 103, 109, + 143, 144, 182, 209 +Straw adobe made by Spaniards 138, 224 +Structural features of kivas similar 129 +Subterranean character of kivas 63, 72, 112, 113 +Sullivan, Jeremiah, Payupki tradition obtained by 40 +Sunflower stalks used in chimney construction 170 +Sun people of Tusayan 29 +Supplies, how taken to Walpi mesa 65 +Survey of Tusayan and Cibola, methods of 44-45 + +Tâaaiyalana, relation of K'iakima to 85 + stone inclosures at base of 85 + description of ruins of 89-91 + flight of Zuñis to, during Pueblo revolt 89 + mesa of, temporarily occupied 223 +Tables not used in Pueblo houses 212, 214 +Talla Hogan. See Awatubi 49-50 +Taos formerly partly inhabited by the Tewa 37 +Tceewáge. See Peña Blanca. +Tcosobi or Jay kiva, roof timbers of 120 +Tebowúki, an early pueblo of the fire people of Tusayan 20 +Tebugkihu or fire-house, description of 57 + fragments of passage-wall at 181 +Terraced doorways 190-191 +Terraced gardens 217 +Terraced roofs of Tusayan, names of 104 +Terrace cooking-pits and fireplaces 174-177 +Terrace rooms, half open, not seen in ancient pueblos 187 +Terraces, Sichumovi form of 62 + Oraibi, formed by natural causes 76 + Zuñi 97, 98, 144 + ancient pueblos, how reached 156 + Tusayan names of 223 +Tusayan, order of settlement of, by various peoples 29 +Tesuque, a Tewa pueblo 37 +Tetsógi. See Tesuque. +Tewa conflict with the Ute 36 +Tewa, language of the 37 +Tewa. See Hano. +Timbers for roof, kind used in kiva-building 19 +Time for planting and harvesting, how determined in Zuñi 148 +Tiponi of Tusayan explained 131 +Topography, houses of Walpi constructed to conform to 64 + of Shupaulovi 71 +Tradition, historical value of 15 +Tradition, Tusayan 16-41 + Hano 35 + regarding Hano and Tusayan languages 36 + concerning Payupki pueblo 40 + concerning occupancy of Old Mashongnavi 47-48 + of foundation of Walpi 63 + concerning circular kivas 135 + Zuñi concerning stone-close 92-193 + concerning early occupancy of former pueblos + by existing tribes 225 +Traditionary gentes of Tusayan, list of 38 +Trails, Walpi 65, 66 + Tâaaiyalana 89 +Transoms over pueblo doorways 187-189 +Transportation to Walpi mesa, Indian method 66 +Trapdoors, Sichumovi 63 + kivas, no means of fastening 113 + frames furnished with hand-holds 192 +Tupubi defined 176 +Túpkabi. See Canyon de Chelly. +Tusayan, survey of 15 + traditional history of 16-41 + ruins and inhabited villages of 42-79 + house-building rites 100-104 + houses of, owned by women 101 + kivas in 111-137 + list of kivas of 136 +Tusayan and Cibola architecture + compared by constructional details 100-223 + details of 137-223 +Tusayan. See Hopituh. +Tuwahlki, or watch-house 217 +Tuwii. See Santo Domingo 30 +Twigs, use of, in roof construction 150 + +Ute, conflict with, by the Tewa of Hano 36 + inroads of, upon Tusayan 25, 26, 35 + +Vargas, Don Diego, visit to Tusayan of 35 +Vocabulary of Tusayan architectural terms 220-223 + +Walls, how indicated on plans of ruins 45 + defensive, at Bat House 52 + construction of, in Moen-kopi ruins 53 + curved, instances of 54 + showing precision of workmanship 54 + dimensions in Tâaaiyalana mesa 90 + original height of, indicated by débris 90 + thickness of, in modern Tusayan 102 + paintings on, in Tusayan kiva 131 + pueblo, mode of construction of 137-148 + copings of 139, 151, 152 +Walls, strength of 144 + weakness of, in Zuñi 182 + of gardens 215 +Walpi, settlement of Bear people at 21, 27 + Spanish mission established at 22 + construction of, by the Snake people 23 + dispute of, with the Sikyatki 24 + settlement of the Asa at 30, 31 + abandoned by Bear, Lizard, Asa, and Badger peoples 31 + description of 63-66 + court-surrounded kiva of 114 + kivas of 119, 136 + upper story partitions of, supported by beams 144 + use of large stone blocks in garden walls of 47 + cooking pit at 176, 177 + south passageway of, described 181 +Walpi people, attack of Awatubi by the 34 + affray between the Oraibi and 35 + trouble between the Hano and 37 + various pueblos formerly occupied by the 46, 47 +Warp-sticks, mode of supporting 133 +Water, method of carrying, at Walpi 65 +Water family, last to settle at Tusayan 29 + migration legend of 31 +Water jars used in chimney construction 180 +Water supply, Cibola 80 + Ketchipauan 82, 83 + Tâaaiyalana dwellings 90, 91 + Kin-tiel 92 + Zuñi 97 +Water vessels, forms of 109 +Wattling or lathing of kiva walls 126 +Weaving appliances 212 +Wejegi pueblo, loop-holes in 198 +Well or reservoir of Zuñi 97 +Whitewash on outer walls of Shumopavi 73-74 + on Mashongnavi room 109 + how made and applied in Zuñi 145 + on house walls 145 + used for coating doors 186 +Wíksrun people, settlement in Tusayan of the 27 +Willow wands used in roof construction 150 +Window, doorway and chimney in one 121 +Windows of various kinds described 194, 201 +Wings constructed in court of Pueblo Bonito 70 +Women, house owners at Tusayan 101 + work of, in Tusayan house-building 101, 102 + roof-building performed by 102 + work of, in kiva-building 129 + when admitted to kivas 134 + societies of, and kivas for, in Tusayan 134 +Wood, kinds of, used in Tusayan construction 102 +Wood rack of pueblos described 103 +Wood-working, how performed 184 +Wooden doors not found in pre-Columbian ruins 184 +Wooden features of pueblo windows 196 +Woolen mill established by Mormons at Moen-kopi 78 +Workshop, use of the kiva, as a 129, 133 + +Yeso used for interior whitewash 74 +Yucca, use of, in lathing 127 +Yucca fiber sandals from Canyon de Chelly 133 +Zuñi, survey of pueblo of 14 + arrival of the Asanyumu at 30 + portion of site of, formerly occupied by Halona 88 + tradition as to occupancy of Kin-tiel by the 92 + plans and descriptions of villages of 94-99 + description of pueblo of 97-99 + See Cibola. + + * * * * * + +Errors and Anomalies: + +Variant Forms, unchanged from original: + +nyumu + _sometimes hyphenated:_ + nyu-mu +Mashongnavi +Shupaulovi +Sichumovi + _sometimes written with accent:_ + Mashóngnavi + Shupaúlovi + Sichúmovi + +Irregularities in Table of Contents: + +CHAPTER I.--Traditionary history of Tusayan + _title in body text reads "Traditional..."_ +Small ruin near Horn House +Moen-kopi +Tâaaiyalana ruins +Kin-tiel and Kinna-Zinde + _titles in body text:_ + Small ruin between Horn House and Bat House + Moen-kopi ruins + Tâaaiyalana + Kin-tiel + +Many phrases are hyphenated in the List of Illustrations but not in the +captions themselves: + chief-kiva, ground-plan, loom-post, roof-beams... + +Whatever their motive, the Bears left Antelope Canyon + _text reads "Cañyon"_ +far off on the Múina (river) near Alavia (Santa Fé) + _text reads "Sante Fé"_ +The principal building is a long irregular row, similar to + _text reads "similiar"_ +All the Tusayan kivas are in the form of a parallelogram + _text reads "paralellogram"_ +the second level of the kiva floor, forming the dais before referred to +The ledge, or dais, is free for the use of spectators + _text reads "dias" both times, but is spelled "dais" on its first + occurrence (earlier in text)_ +these overhanging copings occur principally on the southern exposures + _text reads "pricipally"_ +particularly prevalent in Zuni + _text reads "particulary"_ +Chapters II and III + _text reads "Chapter"_ +usually carved from a single piece of wood + _text reads "single / single" at line break_ +somewhat similar in effect to the carving on the Spanish beams + _text reads "similiar"_ +the almost inaccessible summit of Tâaaiyalana mesa + _text reads "Tâaiyalana"_ + +[Index] +Stonework ... Oraibi + _text reads "Oraib"_ +Tâaaiyalana, relation of K'iakima to + _text reads "Tâaiyalana"_ + + +Punctuation: + +Long ago the Hopi´tuh were few + _paragraph (printed as block quote) begins with redundant + quotation mark_ + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of A Study of Pueblo Architecture: +Tusayan and Cibola, by Victor Mindeleff and Cosmos Mindeleff + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK PUEBLO ARCHITECTURE *** + +***** This file should be named 19856-8.txt or 19856-8.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + http://www.gutenberg.org/1/9/8/5/19856/ + +Produced by Louise Hope, Carlo Traverso, Håkon Hope and +the Online Distributed Proofreading Team at +http://www.pgdp.net (This file was produced from images +generously made available by the Bibliothèque nationale +de France (BnF/Gallica) at http://gallica.bnf.fr) + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +http://gutenberg.org/license). + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS' WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need, is critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at http://www.pglaf.org. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Its 501(c)(3) letter is posted at +http://pglaf.org/fundraising. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at http://pglaf.org + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit http://pglaf.org + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. +To donate, please visit: http://pglaf.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart is the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + http://www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. |
