diff options
| author | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 04:53:00 -0700 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 04:53:00 -0700 |
| commit | 49d8948f8a211e4d503461fec07fdb2614cc1d64 (patch) | |
| tree | 5cfadc8136d51188bbec0a0a52c4e0fbc76a7b27 /18300-8.txt | |
Diffstat (limited to '18300-8.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | 18300-8.txt | 10015 |
1 files changed, 10015 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/18300-8.txt b/18300-8.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c389033 --- /dev/null +++ b/18300-8.txt @@ -0,0 +1,10015 @@ +The Project Gutenberg eBook, History of English Humour, Vol. 1 (of 2), by +Alfred Guy Kingan L'Estrange + + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + + + + +Title: History of English Humour, Vol. 1 (of 2) + With an Introduction upon Ancient Humour + + +Author: Alfred Guy Kingan L'Estrange + + + +Release Date: May 2, 2006 [eBook #18300] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 + + +***START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK HISTORY OF ENGLISH HUMOUR, VOL. 1 +(OF 2)*** + + +E-text prepared by Barbara Tozier, Janet Blenkinship, Bill Tozier, and the +Project Gutenberg Online Distributed Proofreading Team +(http://www.pgdp.net/) + + + +HISTORY OF ENGLISH HUMOUR + +With an Introduction upon Ancient Humour. + +by + +THE REV. A. G. L'ESTRANGE, + +Author of +"The Life of the Rev. William Harness," +"From the Thames to the Tamar," +Etc. + +In Two Volumes. + +Vol. I. + + + + + + + +London: +Hurst and Blackett, Publishers, +13, Great Marlborough Street. +1878. +All rights reserved. + + + + +CONTENTS OF THE FIRST VOLUME. + + + PRELIMINARY OBSERVATIONS. + + Subjective Character of the Ludicrous--The Subject little + Studied--Obstacles to the Investigation--Evanescence--Mental + Character of the Ludicrous--Distinction between + Humour and the Ludicrous 1 + + + INTRODUCTION. + + PART I. + + ORIGIN OF HUMOUR. + + Pleasure in Humour--What is Laughter?--Sympathy--First + Phases--Gradual Development--Emotional Phase--Laughter + of Pleasure--Hostile Laughter--Is there any sense of the Ludicrous + in the Lower Animals?--Samson--David--Solomon--Proverbs--Fables 13 + + PART II. + + GREEK HUMOUR. + + Birth of Humour--Personalities--Story of Hippocleides--Origin + of Comedy--Archilochus--Hipponax--Democritus, + the Laughing Philosopher--Aristophanes--Humour + of the Senses--Indelicacy--Enfeeblement of the Drama--Humorous + Games--Parasites, their Position and Jests--Philoxenus--Diogenes--Court + of Humour--Riddles--Silli 52 + + + PART III. + + ROMAN HUMOUR. + + Roman Comedy--Plautus--Acerbity--Terence--Satire--Lucilius--Horace + --Humour of the Cæsar Family--Cicero--Augustus--Persius--Petronius + --Juvenal--Martial--Epigrammatist--Lucian--Apuleius--Julian + the Apostate--The Misopogon--Symposius' Enigmas--Macrobius--Hierocles + and Philagrius 99 + + + ENGLISH HUMOUR. + + CHAPTER I. + + MIDDLE AGES. + + Relapse of Civilization in the Middle Ages--Stagnation of + Mind--Scarcity of Books--Character of reviving Literature--Religious + Writings--Fantastic Legends--Influence + of the Crusades--Romances--Sir Bevis of Hamptoun--Prominence + of the Lower Animals--Allegories 161 + + CHAPTER II. + + Anglo-Saxon Humour--Rhyme--Satires against the Church--The + Brunellus--Walter Mapes--Goliardi--Piers the + Ploughman--Letters of Obscure Men--Erasmus--The + Praise of Folly--Skelton--The Ship of Fools--Doctour + Doubble Ale--The Sak full of Nuez--Church Ornamentation--Representations + of the Devil 179 + + CHAPTER III. + + Origin of Modern Comedy--Ecclesiastical Buffoonery--Jougleurs + and Minstrels--Court Fools--Monks' Stories--The + "Tournament of Tottenham"--Chaucer--Heywood--Roister + Doister--Gammer Gurton 211 + + CHAPTER IV. + + Robert Greene--Friar Bacon's Demons--The "Looking + Glasse"--Nash and Harvey 231 + + CHAPTER V. + + Donne--Hall--Fuller 243 + + CHAPTER VI. + + Shakespeare--Ben Jonson--Beaumont and Fletcher--The + Wise Men of Gotham 250 + + CHAPTER VII. + + Jesters--Court of Queen Elizabeth--James I.--The + "Counterblasts to Tobacco"--Puritans--Charles II. + --Rochester--Buckingham--Dryden--Butler 271 + + CHAPTER VIII. + + Comic Drama of the Restoration--Etheridge--Wycherley 303 + + CHAPTER IX. + + Tom Brown--His Prose Works--Poetry--Sir Richard + Blackmore--D'Urfey--Female Humorists--Carey 312 + + CHAPTER X. + + Vanbrugh--Colley Cibber--Farquhar 340 + + CHAPTER XI. + + Congreve--Lord Dorset 355 + + + + +HISTORY OF ENGLISH HUMOUR. + + + + +PRELIMINARY OBSERVATIONS. + +Subjective Character of the Ludicrous--The Subject little + Studied--Obstacles to the Investigation--Evanescence--Mental Character + of the Ludicrous--Distinction between Humour and the Ludicrous. + + +The ludicrous is in its character so elusive and protean, and the field +over which it extends is so vast, that few have ever undertaken the task +of examining it systematically. Many philosophers and literary men have +made passing observations upon it, but most writers are content to set +it down as one of those things which cannot be understood, and care not +to study and grapple with a subject which promises small results in +return for considerable toil. Moreover, the inquiry does not seem +sufficiently important to warrant the expenditure of much time upon it, +and there has always been a great tendency among learned men to +underrate the emotional feelings of our nature. Thus it comes to pass +that a much larger amount of our labour has been expended upon inquiring +into physical and intellectual constitution than upon the inner workings +of our passions and sentiments, for our knowledge of which, though +affecting our daily conduct, we are mostly indebted to the +representations of poets and novelists. Beattie well observes that +nothing is below the attention of a philosopher which the Author of +Nature has been pleased to establish. Investigations of this kind would +not be unrewarded, nor devoid of a certain amount of interest; and I +think that in the present subject we can, by perseverance, penetrate a +little distance into an almost untrodden and apparently barren region, +and if we cannot reach the source from whence the bright waters spring, +can at least obtain some more accurate information about the surrounding +country. + +Notwithstanding all the obstructions and discouragements in the way of +this investigation a few great men have given it a certain amount of +attention. Aristotle informs us in his "Rhetoric" that he has dealt +fully with the subject in his Poetics, and although the treatise is +unfortunately lost, some annotations remain which show that it was of a +comprehensive character. Cicero and Quintilian in their instructions in +Oratory, made the study of humour a necessary part of the course, and +in modern days many ingenious definitions and descriptions of it are +found among the pages of general literature. Most philosophers have +touched the subject timidly and partially, unwilling to devote much time +to it, and have rather stated what they thought ought to be in +accordance with some pet theories of their own, than drawn deductions +from careful analysis. They generally only looked at one phase of the +ludicrous, at one kind of humour, and had not a sufficient number of +examples before them--probably from the difficulty of recalling slight +turns of thought in widely scattered subjects. Add to this, that many of +them--constantly immersed in study--would have had some little +difficulty in deciding what did and did not deserve the name of humour. +Most of their definitions are far too wide, and often in supporting a +theory they make remarks which tend to refute it. The imperfect +treatment, which the subject had received, led Dugald Stewart to observe +that it was far from being exhausted. + +The two principal publications which have appeared on humour, are +Flögel's "Geschichte der Komischen Litteratur" (1786), and Léon Dumont's +"Les Causes du Rire." The former is voluminous, but scarcely touches on +philosophy, without which such a work can have but little coherence. +The latter shows considerable psychological knowledge, but is written to +support a somewhat narrow and incomplete view. Mr. Wright's excellent +book on "The Grotesque in Literature and Art," is, as the name suggests, +principally concerned with broad humour, and does not so much trace its +source as the effects it has produced upon mankind. Mr. Cowden Clark's +contributions on the subject to the "Gentleman's Magazine," are mostly +interesting from their biographical notices. + +To analyse and classify all the vagaries of the human imagination which +may be comprehended under the denomination of humour, is no easy task, +and as it is multiform we may stray into devious paths in pursuing it. +But vast and various as the subject seems to be, there cannot be much +doubt that there are some laws which govern it, and that it can be +brought approximately under certain heads. It seems to be as generally +admitted that there are different kinds of humour as that some +observations possess none at all. Moreover, when remarks of a certain +kind are made, especially such as show confusion or exaggeration, we +often seem to detect some conditions of humour, and by a little change +are able to make something, which has more or less the character of a +jest. + +There is in this investigation a very formidable "Dweller on the +Threshold." We contend with great disadvantages in any attempts to +examine our mental constitution. When we turn the mind in upon itself, +and make it our object, the very act of earnest reflection obscures the +idea, or destroys the emotion we desire to contemplate. This is +especially the case in the present instance. The ludicrous, when we +attempt to grasp it, shows off its gay and motley garb, and appears in +grave attire. It is only by abstracting our mind from the inquiry, and +throwing it into lighter considerations, that we can at all retain the +illusion. A clever sally appears brilliant when it breaks suddenly upon +the mental vision, but when it is brought forward for close examination +it loses half its lustre, and seems to melt into unsubstantial air. +Humour may be compared to a delicate scent, which we only perceive at +the first moment, or to evanescent beauty-- + + "For every touch that wooed its stay + Has brushed its brightest hues away." + +This last simile is especially in point here, and the quotations in this +book will scarcely be found humorous, so long as they are regarded as +mere illustrations of the nature of humour. + +We need not--taking these matters into consideration--feel much +surprised that some people say the ludicrous cannot be defined; as for +instance, Buckingham, + + "True wit is everlasting like the sun, + Describing all men, but described by none;" + +and Addison:--"It is much easier to decide what is not humorous than +what is, and very difficult to define it otherwise than Cowley has done, +by negatives"--the only meaning of which is that the subject is +surrounded with rather more than the usual difficulties attending moral +and psychological researches. Similar obstacles would be encountered in +answering the question, "What is poetry?" or "What is love?" We can only +say that even here there must be some surroundings by which we can +increase our knowledge. + +Humour is the offspring of man--it comes forth like Minerva fully armed +from the brain. Our sense of the ludicrous is produced by our peculiar +mental constitution, and not by external objects, in which there is +nothing either absurd or serious. As when the action of our mind is +imperceptible--for instance, in hearing and seeing with our "bodily" +senses--we think what we notice is something in the external world, +although it is only so far dependent upon it that it could not exist +without some kind of outer influence, so the result of our not +recognising the amusing action of the mind in the ludicrous is that we +regard it as a quality resident in the persons and things we +contemplate.[1] But it does not belong to these things, and is totally +different from them in kind. Thus, the rose is formed of certain +combinations of earth, air, and water; yet none of these dull elements +possess the fragrance or beauty of the flower. These properties come +from some attractive and constructive power. Not only are there no types +or patterns in things of our emotions, but there are none even of our +sensations; heat and cold, red or blue, are such only for our +constitution. This truth is beautifully set forth by Addison in a +passage in which, as Dugald Stewart justly remarks, "We are at a loss +whether most to admire the author's depth and refinement of thought, or +the singular felicity of fancy displayed in its illustration." "Things," +he observes, "would make but a poor appearance to the eye, if we saw +them only in their proper figures and motions. And what reason can we +assign for their exciting in us many of those ideas which are different +from anything that exists in the objects themselves (for such are light +and colours) were it not to add supernumerary ornaments to the universe, +and make it more agreeable to the imagination? We are everywhere +entertained with pleasing shows and apparitions. We discover imaginary +glories in the heavens and on the earth, and see some of this visionary +beauty poured out over the whole creation. But what a rough, unsightly +sketch of Nature should we be entertained with, did all her colouring +disappear, and the several distinctions of light and shade vanish! In +short, our souls are delightfully lost and bewildered in a pleasing +delusion, and we walk about like the enchanted hero of a romance, who +sees beautiful castles, woods, and meadows, and at the same time hears +the warbling of birds and the purling of streams; but upon the finishing +of some secret spell, the fantastic scene breaks up, and the +disconsolate knight finds himself on a barren heath, or in a solitary +desert." + +I have introduced these considerations, because it is very difficult for +us to realize that what we behold is merely phenomenal, that + + "Things are not what they seem;" + +but that we are looking into the mirror of Nature at our own likeness. +When we speak of a ludicrous occurrence, we cannot avoid thinking that +the external events themselves contain something of that character. +Thus, the ludicrous has come in our ideas and language to be separated +from the sense in which alone it exists, and it is desirable that we +should clearly understand that the distinction is only logical and not +real. + +When the cause of our laughter--be it mind, matter, or imaginary +circumstance--is merely regarded as something incongruous and amusing, +we name it the ludicrous, and a man is called ludicrous as faulty or +contemptible. But when the cause of it is viewed as something more than +this, as coming from some conscious power or tendency within us--a +valuable gift and an element in our mental constitution--we call it +humour, a term applied only to human beings and their productions; and a +man is called humorous as worthy of commendation. Both are in truth +feelings--we might say one feeling--and although we can conceive humour +to exist apart from the ludicrous, and to be a power within us creating +it, there is a difficulty in following out the distinction. The +difference between them is in our regard. + +As soon as in course of time it became plainly evident that gay +creations might emanate from man, and not only from the outer world, the +fact was marked by the formation of a distinctive name, and by degrees +several names--among which the most comprehensive in English is Humour. +This kind of gift became gradually known as more or less possessed by +all, and when the operations of the mind came to be recognised, we were +more enlightened on the subject, and acknowledged it to be a mental and +creative power. Such admissions would not be made by men in general +without some very strong evidence, and therefore a humorous man was not +merely one who had an internal sense of the ludicrous, but one who +employed it for the delectation of others. Hence, also, though there is +no consciousness of being amusing in the man who is ludicrous, there is +in one that is humorous. A wit must always be pleasant intentionally. A +man who in sober seriousness recounts something which makes us laugh is +not humorous, although his want of discrimination may not be sufficient +to make him ludicrous. Children are not regarded as humorous, for, +although they enjoy such simple humour as toys afford, they very seldom +notice what is merely ludicrous, and do not reproduce it in any way; and +the same may be said of many grown persons, who require to be fed as it +were, and although they can enjoy what is embellished by others, have no +original observation. Thus, although Herbert Mayo is substantially +correct in saying that "humour is the sentiment of the ludicrous," he +might have added that there is a difference between the two in our +knowledge of them. In the former, the creative mind is more marked, and, +a man though he laughs much, if he be dull in words is only considered +to have mirth, _i.e._, joyousness or a sense of the ludicrous, not +humour. The gift can only be brought prominently forward in speech or +writing, and thus humour comes to be often regarded as a kind of +ingredient or seasoning in a speech or book, if not actually synonymous +with certain sentences or expressions. Still we always confine the name +to human productions, as, for instance, gestures, sayings, writings, +pictures, and plays. + +The recognition of the mental character of humour did not necessarily +imply any knowledge as to the authority, instability, or constancy of +the feeling--that could only be acquired by philosophical investigation. +Nor have we yet so far ascertained its character as to be able to form +humorous fancies upon any fixed principle. We are guided by some sense +of the ludicrous which we cannot analyse; or we introduce into new and +similar cases relationships in things which we have observed to be +amusing. Some forms are so general that they will produce a vast number +of jests, and we thus seem to have some insight into the influences that +awaken humour, but we see only approximately and superficially, and can +merely produce good results occasionally--rather by an accident than +with any certainty. + + + + +INTRODUCTION. + +PART I. + +ORIGIN OF HUMOUR. + +Pleasure in Humour--What is Laughter?--Sympathy--First Phases--Gradual + Development--Emotional Phase--Laughter of Pleasure--Hostile + Laughter--Is there any sense of the Ludicrous in the Lower + Animals?--Samson--David--Solomon--Proverbs--Fables. + + +Few of the blessings we enjoy are of greater value than the gift of +humour. The pleasure attendant upon it attracts us together, forms an +incentive, and gives a charm to social intercourse, and, unlike the +concentrating power of love, scatters bright rays in every direction. +That humour is generally associated with enjoyment might be concluded +from the fact that the genial and good-natured are generally the most +mirthful, and we all have so much personal experience of the +gratification it affords, that it seems superfluous to adduce any proofs +upon the subject. "Glad" is from the Greek word for laughter, and the +word "jocund" comes from a Latin term signifying "pleasant." But we can +trace the results of this connection in our daily observation. How comes +it to pass that many a man who is the life and soul of social +gatherings, and keeps his friends in delighted applause, sits, when +alone in his study, grave and sedate, and seldom, if ever, smiles in +reading or meditation? Is it not because humour is a source of pleasure? +We are not joyously disposed when alone, whereas in society we are ready +to give and receive whatever is bright and cheering. + +The first question which now presents itself is what is laughter? and +our answer must be that it is a change of countenance accompanied by a +spasmodic intermittent sound--a modification of the voice--but that we +cannot trace its physical origin farther than to attribute it to some +effect produced upon the sympathetic nerve, or rather the system of +nerves termed respiratory. These communicate with every organ affected +in mirth, but the ultimate connection between mind and body is hidden +from our view. + +In all laughter there is more or less pleasure, except in that of +hysteria, when by a sudden shock the course of Nature is reversed, and +excessive grief will produce the signs of joy, as extravagant delight +will sometimes exhibit those of sorrow. We should also exclude the +laughter caused by inhalation of gas, and that of maniacs, which arising +from some strange and unaccountable feeling is abnormal and imperfect, +and known by a hollow sound peculiar to itself. None of these kinds of +laughter are primary, they are but imperfect reflections of our usual +modes of expression, and, excepting such cases, we may agree that M. +Paffe is correct in observing that "Joy is an indispensable condition of +laughter." Dr. Darwin refers to the laughter of idiots to prove that it +may be occasioned by pleasure alone. Strangely enough, he quotes as an +instance in point the fact of an idiot boy having laughed at receiving a +black eye. + +Proceeding onwards, we next come to inquire why the sense of humour is +expressed by voice and countenance, and does not merely afford a silent +and secret delight? The answer may be given, that one object, at least, +is to increase social communication and multiply pleasure. The +well-being of the animal world largely depends upon the power of each +member of it to communicate with others of the same species. They all do +so by sound and gesture, probably to a larger extent than we generally +imagine. A celebrated physician lately observed to me that "all animals +have some language." How far mere signs deserve so high a name may be +questioned. But man has great powers of intercourse, and it is much +owing to his superior faculties in this respect that he holds his place +so high above the rest of creation. Orators, who make it their study to +be impressive, give full importance to every kind of expression, and say +that a man should be able to make his meaning understood, even when his +voice is inaudible. It has been lately discovered that the mere movement +of the lips alone, without sound, is sufficient to convey +information.[2] Facial expression has been given us as a means of +assisting communication, and smiles and laughter have become the +distinctive manifestations of humour. Thus the electric spark passes +from one to another, and the flashing eye and wreathed lip lights up the +world. Profit also accrues--fear of being laughed at leads us to avoid +numerous small errors, and by laughing at others we are enabled to +detect shortcomings in ourselves. + +Sympathetic laughter does not arise from any contemplation of ludicrous +circumstances, but is only a sort of reflection of the feelings of +others. There seems to be little intelligence in it, but something +almost physical, just as yawning is infectious, or as on seeing a person +wounded in a limb we instinctively shrink ourselves in the same part of +the body. Even a picture of a man laughing will have some effect upon +us, and so have those songs in which exuberant mirth is imitated. Thus +we often laugh without feeling just cause, as we often feel cause +without laughing. All exhibitions of emotion are infectious. We feel sad +at seeing a man in grief, although the source of his sorrow is unknown +to us; and we are inclined to be joyous when surrounded by the votaries +of mirth. Not unfrequently we find a number of persons laughing, when +the greater part of them have no idea what is the cause of the +merriment. Sometimes we cannot entirely resist the impulse, even when we +ourselves are the object of it, so much are we inclined to enter into +the feelings and views of those who surround us. In this, as well as in +many other cases, the sight and proximity of others exercise over us a +great influence, and sometimes almost a fascination. + +To this sympathy we are largely indebted for the diffusion of high +spirits. It is pleasant to laugh and see others laughing, and thus the +one leads to the other. "Laugh and be fat," is a proverb, and it has +been well observed that "we like those who make us laugh," because they +give us pleasure. We may add that we like to see others joyous, because +we feel that we are surrounded by kindly natures. A gallant writer tells +us that he hopes to be rewarded for his labours in the field of +literature by "the sweetest of all sounds in nature--the laughter of +fair women." Macready, speaking of this influence, says: + +"The words of Milman would have applied well to Mrs. Jordan, 'Oh, the +words laughed on her lips!' Mrs. Nesbitt, the charming actress of a late +day, had a fascinating power in the sweetly-ringing notes of her hearty +mirth; but Mrs. Jordan's laugh was so rich, so apparently irrepressible, +so deliciously self-enjoying, as to be at all times irresistible." + +The agreeable influence of smiles is so well known that many are tempted +to counterfeit them, and assume an expression in which the eye and lip +are in unhappy conflict.[3] On the other hand, painful thoughts are +inimical to mirth. No sally of humour will brighten the countenance of a +man who has lately suffered a severe loss, and even mental reflection +will extinguish every sparkle. But the bed of sickness can often be +better cheered by some gay efflorescence, some happy turn of thought, +than by expressions of condolence. Galen says that Æsculapius wrote +comic songs to promote circulation in his patients; and Hippocrates +tells us that "a physician should have a certain ready humour, for +austerity is repulsive both to well and ill." The late Sir Charles Clark +recognised this so far that one of his patients told me that his visits +were like a bottle of Champagne; and Sir John Byles observes, +"Cheerfulness eminently conduces to health both of body and mind; it is +one of the great physicians of nature. + + "Il y a trois médecins qui ne se trompent pas, + La gaité, le doux exercice, et le modeste repas. + +Every hour redeemed from despondency and melancholy, and bathed in the +sunshine of cheerfulness, is an hour of true life gained." + +Our views with regard to the first appearance of laughter depend on +whether we consider that man was gradually developed from the primeval +oyster, or that he came into the world much in the same condition as +that in which we find him now. If we adopt the former opinion, we must +consider that no outward expressions of feeling originally existed; if +the latter, that they were from the first almost as perfect as they are +at present. But I think that we shall be on tolerably safe ground, and +have the support of probability and history, if we say that, in his +earliest condition, the mental endowments of man were of the very +humblest description, but that he had always a tendency to progress and +improve. This view obtains some little corroboration from the fact that +the sounds animals utter in the early stages of their lives are not +fully developed, and that the children of the poor are graver and more +silent than those of the educated classes. But a certain predisposition +to laughter there always was, for what animal has ever produced any but +its own characteristic sound? Has not everyone its own natural mode of +expression? Does not the dog show its pleasure by wagging its tail, and +the cat by purring? We never find one animal adopting the vocal sounds +of another--a bird never mews, and a cat never sings. Some men have been +called cynics from their whelpish ill-temper, but none of them have ever +adopted a real canine snarl, though it might express their feelings +better than human language. Laughter, so far as we can judge, could not +have been obtained by any mere mental exercise, nor would it have come +from imitation, for it is only found in man, the yelping of a hyena +being as different from it as the barking of a dog, or the cackling of +a goose. We may, however, suppose that the first sounds uttered by man +were demonstrative of pain or pleasure, marking a great primary +distinction, which we make in common with all animals. But our next +expression showed superior sensibility and organism: it denoted a very +peculiar perception of the intermingling of pain and pleasure, a +combination of opposite feelings not possessed by other animals, or not +distinct enough in them to have a specific utterance. There might seem +to be something almost physical in the sensation, as it can be excited +by tickling, or the inhalation of gas. Similar results may be produced +by other bodily causes. Homer speaks of the chiefs laughing after a +sumptuous banquet, and of a man "laughing sweetly" when drunk. Bacon's +term _titillatio_, would seem very appropriate in such cases. There was +an idea, in olden times, that laughter emanated from a particular part +of the body. Tasso, in "Jerusalem Delivered," describing the death of +Ardonio, who was slain by a lance, says that it + + "Pierced him through the vein + Where laughter has her fountain and her seat, + So that (a dreadful bane) + He laughed for pain, and laughed himself to death." + +This idea probably arose from observing the spasmodic power of +laughter, which was greater formerly than now, and to the same origin we +may attribute the stories of the fatal consequences it has, at times, +produced; of Zeuxis, the painter, having expired in a fit brought on by +contemplating a caricature he had made of an old woman, and of +Franciscus Cosalinus, a learned logician, having thus broken a +blood-vessel, which led to his dying of consumption. Wolfius relates +"that a country bumpkin, called Brunsellius, by chance seeing a woman +asleep at a sermon fall off her seat, was so taken that he laughed for +three days, which weakened him so that he continued for a long time +afterwards in an infirm state." + +We must suppose that laughter has always existed in man, at least as +long as he has been physically constituted as he is now, for it might +always have been produced by tickling the papillæ of the nerves, which +are said to be more exposed in man than in other animals. When we have +stated the possibility of this pleasurable sensation being awakened +under such circumstances, we have, in fact, asserted that it was in +course of time thus called into existence. But the enjoyment might have +been limited to this low phase, for the mind might have been so vacant, +so deficient in emotion and intelligence that the moral and intellectual +conditions necessary for a higher kind of laughter might have been +wanting. This seems to be the case among some savages at the present +day, such as the New Zealanders and North American Indians. The earliest +laughter did not arise from what we call the ludicrous, but from +something apparently physical--such as touch--though it does not follow +that it would never otherwise have existed at all, for, as the mind more +fully developed itself, facial expressions would flow from superior and +more numerous causes. Nor can we consider that what is properly called +mirth was shown in this primitive physical laughter, which was such as +may be supposed to have existed when darkness was on the face of the +intellectual world. How great, and of what continuance, was this +primeval stagnation must be for ever unknown to us, but it was not +destined to prevail. Light gradually dawned upon the mental wastes, and +they became productive of beauty and order. As greater sensibility +developed itself, emotion began to be expressed; first, probably at an +adult period of life, by the sounds belonging to the corresponding +feelings in the bodily constitution. Tears and cries betoken mental as +well as physical anguish, and laughter denoted a mixed pleasurable +feeling either in mind or body. There is a remarkable instance of this +transference from the senses to the emotional feelings in the case of +what is called sardonic laughter, in which a similar contortion of +countenance to that caused by the pungency of a Sardinian herb is +considered to denote a certain moral acerbity. Here there is an analogy +established between the senses and emotions in their outward +manifestation, just as there is in language in the double meaning of +such terms as bitter and sweet. + +When we consider the fact that matter is that which gives, and mind that +which receives impressions, or that our perceptions do not teach the +nature of external things, but that of our own constitution, we shall +admit that there is not such a fundamental difference between feelings +derived from the sense of touch, and those coming through our other +senses. But we must observe that there is a great practical difference +between them, inasmuch as the one sense remains in its original +primitive state, and is not cultivated as are the others. Physical +laughter requires no previous experience, no exercise of judgment, and +therefore has no connection with the intellectual powers of the mind. +The lowest boor may laugh on being tickled, but a man must have +intelligence to be amused by wit. The senses which are the least +discriminating are the least productive of humour, little is derived +from that of smell or of taste, though we may talk sometimes of an +educated palate and an acquired taste. The finer organs of sight and +hearing are the chief mediums of humour, but the sense of touch might by +education be rendered exquisitely sensitive, and Dickens mentions the +case of a girl he met in Switzerland who was blind, deaf, and dumb, but +who was constantly laughing. Among infants, also, where very slight +complication is required, the sense of humour can be excited by touch. +Thus nurses will sing, "Brow brinky, eye winkey, nose noppy, cheek +cherry, mouth merry," and greatly increase the little one's appreciation +by, at the same time, touching the features named. Contact with other +bodies occasions a sensation, and might, by degrees, awaken an emotion; +and we might thus have such a sense of the ludicrous as that obtained +through eye and ear, which is sometimes almost intuitive, and but +slightly derived from reflection or experience. Of this kind is that +aroused by the rapid changes of form and colour of the kaleidoscope, and +those pantomimic representations which amuse the young and uneducated, +and others who live mostly in the senses. + +We have now arrived at the emotional phase of laughter, that in which +emotion far exceeds intellectual action. At this stage, we have a kind +of laughter which we may call that of pleasure, inasmuch as it is the +first that deserves a distinct name. This laughter of pleasure required +very little complication of thought, contained no unamiable feeling, and +expressed the mildest sense of the ludicrous. At the same time, it did +not flow from any mere constitutional joyousness, but only arose upon +certain occasions, in consequence of some remarkable and unusual +occurrence--such as the reception of glad tidings, or the sudden +acquisition of some good fortune. This ancient laughter, now no longer +existing, is alluded to in early writings. + +Thus we read in Gen. xxi. 6, that Sarah, on the birth of Isaac, said +"God hath made me to laugh, so that all that hear will laugh with me," +and in Ps. cxxvi., "When the Lord turned again the captivity of Zion, we +were like them that dream. Then was our mouth filled with laughter, and +our tongue with singing." And in Proverbs we find, "There is a time to +weep, and a time to laugh," contrasting the expression of sorrow with +that of pleasure. Passing into Greek literature, we find laughter +constantly termed "sweet." In Iliad xxi, "Saturn smiled sweetly at +seeing his daughter;" in xxiii. "The chiefs arose to throw the shield, +and the Greeks laughed, _i.e._, with joy." In Odyssey, xx. 390, they +prepare the banquet with laughter. Od. xxii., 542, Penelope laughs at +Telemachus sneezing, when she is talking of Ulysses' return; she takes +it for a good omen. And in the Homeric Hymns, which, although inferior +in date to the old Bard, are still among the earliest specimens of +literature, we find, in that to Mercury, that the god laughs on +beholding a tortoise, "thinking that he will make a beautiful lyre out +of its shell;" and a little further on, Apollo laughs at hearing the +sound of the lyre. In the hymn to Aphrodite, the laughter-loving Venus +laughed sweetly when she thought of men and mortals being intermarried. +The fact that this and the preceding kinds of laughter were not +necessarily regarded as intellectual, is evident from the ancient poets +attributing them to vegetable and inorganic life. Considerable licence +in personification must no doubt be conceded to those who went so far as +to deify the elements, and to imagine a sort of soul in the universe, +and no doubt language as well as feeling was not at the time strictly +limited. But it must be remarked that, while they rarely attribute +laughter to the lower animals, they also never ascribe any other sign of +emotion, nor even that in its higher kinds, to insensate matter. In all +these passages it is of a physical, or merely pleasurable description. +In Iliad xiv. 362, speaking of the Grecian host, Homer says that "the +gleam of their armour was reflected to heaven, and all the earth around +laughed at the brazen refulgence." + +In Hesiod's Theogony, v. 40, we read that when the Muses are singing +"the palace of loud-thundering Jove laughs (with delight) at their lily +voice;" and in the Hymn to Ceres we find Proserpine beholding a +Narcissus, from the root of which a hundred heads sprang forth "and the +whole heavens were scented with its fragrance, and the whole earth +laughed and the briny wave of the sea." Theognis writes that Delos, when +Apollo was born, "was filled with the ambrosial odour, and the huge +earth laughed." The poets seemed scarcely to have advanced beyond such a +bold similitude, and we may conclude that while they saw in laughter +something above the powers of the brute creation, they did not consider +that it necessarily expressed the smallest exercise of intellect. + +This laughter of pleasure, which cheered the early centuries of the +world, now no longer exists except perhaps in childhood. It belongs to +simpler if not happier natures than our own. If a man were now to say +that his friends laughed on hearing of some good fortune having come to +him, we should suppose that they disbelieved it, or thought there was +something ridiculous in the occurrence. In these less emotional ages, in +which the manifestations of joy and sorrow are more subdued, it is mute, +and has subsided into a smile. It is difficult to say when the change +took place, but our finding smiles mentioned in Homer, though not in +Scripture, might suggest their Greek origin, if they were at first +merely a modification of the early laughter of pleasure, betokening +little more than kindly or joyous emotions. Although not always now +genial, the smile continues to be used for the symbol of pleasure, even +in reference to inanimate Nature, as where Milton writes "Old Ocean +smiled." The smile may have preceded laughter, as the bud comes before +the blossom, but it may, on the other hand, have been a reduction of +something more demonstrative. + +We have still a kind of laughter approaching very nearly to that of +pleasure, which contains little reflection, but cannot be regarded as +simply physical. This description seems to be that alluded to in the +Book of Ecclesiastes, "I said of laughter, it is mad, and of mirth, what +good doeth it?" Of the same nature is that to which some excitable and +joyous persons are constitutionally inclined. Their perpetual merriment +seems to us childish and silly. Thus Steele observes to an hilarious +friend, "Sir, you never laughed in your life," and farther on he +remarks, "Some men laugh from mere benevolence." + +The pleasure accompanying the perception of the ludicrous has been by +some attributed to the exercise of certain muscles in the face, and by +others to the acquisition of new ideas. But we may safely discard both +theories, for the former derives the enjoyment from physical instead of +mental sources, and the latter gives us credit for too great a delight +in knowledge, even were it thus generally obtained. The enjoyment seems +partly to arise from stimulation and activity of mind, excitement being +generally agreeable, whereas inaction is monotonous and wearisome. But +it seems also partly to be derived from sources which are, or appear to +be, collateral. Thus, in the early laughter of pleasure, some solid +advantage or gratification, present or future, was always in view, and +from men being delighted at their own success, which must often have +been obtained at the expense of others, it was an easy transition to +rejoice at the failure of rivals. In those primitive times, when people +felt themselves insecure, and one tribe was constantly at war with +another, there was nothing that gave them so much joy as the misfortunes +of their enemies. They exhibited their exultation by indulging in +extravagant transports, in shouting, in singing and dancing, and when +there appeared some strangeness or peculiarity, something sudden or +unaccountable in such disasters, laughter broke forth of that rude and +hostile character which we may occasionally still hear among the +uneducated classes. It accorded with the age in which it prevailed--a +period when men were highly emotional and passionate, while their +intellectual powers were feeble and inactive. + +The two early phases of the ludicrous--those of pleasure and of +hostility--containing small complexity, and a large proportion of +emotion, are to a certain extent felt by the lower animals. Dr. Darwin +has observed an approximation to the laughter of pleasure in monkeys, +but he does not connect it with intelligence, and would not, I believe, +claim for them any sense of the ludicrous. I have, however, seen a dog, +on suddenly meeting a friend, not only wag his tail, but curl up the +corners of his lips, and show his teeth, as if delighted and amused. We +may also have observed a very roguish expression sometimes in the face +of a small dog when he is barking at a large one, just as a cat +evidently finds some fun in tormenting and playing with a captured +mouse. I have even heard of a monkey who, for his amusement, put a live +cat into a pot of boiling water on the fire. These animals are those +most nearly allied to man, but the perception of the ludicrous is not +strong enough in them to occasion laughter. The opinion of Vives that +animals do not laugh because the muscles of their countenances do not +allow them, can scarcely be regarded as philosophical. Milton tells us +that, + + "Smiles from reason flow, To brutes denied;" + +a statement which may be taken as generally correct, although we admit +that there may be some approximation to smiling among the lower animals, +and that it does not always necessarily proceed from reason. + +The pleasure found in hostile laughter soon led to practical jokes. +Although now discountenanced, they were anciently very common, and +formed the first link between humour and the ludicrous. They were not +imitative, and did not show any actual power to invent what was +humorous, but a desire to amuse by doing something which might cause +some ludicrous action or scene, just as people unable to speak would +point to things they wish to designate. These early jokes had severer +objects coupled with amusement, and were what we should call no joke at +all. The first character in the records of antiquity that seems to have +had anything quaint or droll about it is that of Samson. Standing out +amid the confusion of legendary times, he gives us good specimens of the +fierce and wild kind of merriment relished in ancient days; and was fond +of making very sanguinary "sport for the Philistines." He was an +exaggeration of a not very uncommon type of man, in which brute strength +is joined to loose morals and whimsical fancy. People were more inclined +to laugh at sufferings formerly, because they were not keenly sensitive +to pain, and also had less feeling and consideration for others. That +Samson found some malicious kind of pleasure and diversion in his +reprisals on his enemies, and made their misfortunes minister to his +amusement, is evident from the strange character of his exploits. "He +caught three hundred foxes, and took fire-brands, and turned tail to +tail, and put a fire-brand in the midst between two tails, and when he +had set the brands on fire, he let them go into the standing corn of the +Philistines, and burnt up both the shocks and also the standing corn of +the Philistines, with the vineyards and olives." On another occasion he +allowed himself to be bound with cords, and thus apparently delivered +powerless into the hands of his enemies; he then broke his bonds "like +flax that was burnt with fire," and taking the _jaw-bone of an ass_, +which he found, slew a thousand men with it. His account of this +massacre shows that he regarded it in a humorous light: "With the +jaw-bone of an ass heaps upon heaps, with the jaw of an ass I have slain +a thousand men." We might also refer to his carrying away the gates of +Gaza to the top of a hill that is before Hebron, and to his duping +Delilah about the seven green withes. + +In the above instances it will be observed that destruction or +disappointment of enemies was the primary, and amusement the secondary +object. It must be admitted that all such jokes are of a very poor and +severe description. They have not the undesigned coincidence of the +ludicrous nor the fanciful invention of true humour. Samson was +evidently regarded as a droll fellow in his day, but beyond his jokes +the only venture of his on record is a riddle, which showed very little +ingenuity, and can not be regarded as humorous now, even if it were so +then. + +It would, perhaps, be going too far to assert that no laughter of a +better kind existed before the age at which we are now arrived; some +minds are always in advance of their time, as others are behind it, but +they are few. The only place in which there is any approach in early +times to what may be called critical laughter is recorded where Abraham +and Sarah were informed of the approaching birth of Isaac. Perhaps this +laughter was mostly that of pleasure. Sarah denied that she laughed, and +Abraham was not rebuked when guilty of the same levity.[4] + +With the exception of the above-mentioned riddle, and rough pranks of +Samson, we have no trace of humour until after the commencement of the +Monarchy. The reigns of David and Solomon seemed to have formed the +brightest period in the literary history of the Jews. The sweet Psalmist +of Israel was partly the pioneer to deeper thought, partly the +representative of the age in which he lived. It is the charm of his +poetry that it is very rich and recondite--a mine of gold, which the +farther it is worked, the more precious its yield becomes. But it +everywhere bears the stamp of passion and religious ardour, and does not +bespeak the critical incisiveness of a highly civilised age. +Argumentative acumen would have been as much below the poetic mind of +David in one respect as it was above it in another, and while his +rapturous language of admiration and faith seems above the range of +human genius; his bitter denunciations of his enemies remind us of his +date, and the circumstances by which he was surrounded. Such immaturity +would be sufficient to account for the non-existence of humour. It may +be urged that David had no tendency in that direction. His thoughts were +turned towards the sublime, and his religious character, his royal +estate, and the vicissitudes of his early life, all inclined him to +serious reflection. But we do not find that David was invariably grave +and solemn. He indulged in laughter at the misfortunes of his +adversaries, as we may conclude from a passage in Psalm lii, 6. "God +shall likewise destroy thee for ever; he shall take thee away and pluck +thee out of thy dwelling-place, and root thee out of the land of the +living. Selah. The righteous also shall see and fear, and shall laugh at +him." + +He also considered that, in turn, his enemies would deride him, if he +were unsuccessful. Psalm xxii, 7--"All they that see me laugh me to +scorn; they shoot out the lip and shake the head, saying, 'He trusted in +the Lord.'" + +He evidently thought there was nothing wrong in such laughter, for he +even considers it compatible with Divine attributes,[5] Psalm ii, 4, +"He that sitteth in Heaven shall laugh; the Lord shall have them in +derision;" and Psalm xxxvii, 13, "The Lord shall laugh at him, for he +seeth that his day is coming." + +Nothing can make it more certain than such expressions that the prophets +interpreted the intimations they received from above by clothing them +with their own mundane similitudes. + +On the other hand, although David laughed at his enemies, he never seems +to have done so at anything else. He frequently mentions fools, but +always with detestation. To him the term did not convey any idea of +frivolity or eccentricity, but of crime and wickedness. All these +considerations tend to convince us that we can see in the writings of +David a fairly good reflection of the mirth common in his day. Add to +this that there is no trace in any contemporary work of an attempt +beyond the emotional phases of the ludicrous, and we do not at this time +read of any performance of Jewish plays, or of any kind of amusing +representations. + +A more advanced, but less faithful age is represented by another man. +The soldier-king passed away to make room for one educated under milder +influences. He inherited not the piety or warlike virtues of his father, +but turned the same greatness of mind into a more luxurious and learned +channel. In his writings we find little that approaches the sublime, but +much that implies analytical depth and complexity of thought. His tone +bespeaks a settled and civilized period favourable to art and +philosophy, in which subtlety was appreciated, while the old feelings of +acerbity had become greatly softened. + +In the intellectual and moral state at this date, there were many +conditions favourable to the development of humour. But we do not find +it yet actually existing, although we must suppose that a mind capable +of forming proverbs could not have been entirely insensible to it. We +may define a proverb to be a moral statement, instructive in object, and +epigrammatically expressed. It is always somewhat controversial, and +when it approaches a truism scarcely deserves the name. + +A great many of Solomon's proverbs may be regarded in two lights, and I +think a comparison between some of them will show that he was aware of +the fact, and if so he could scarcely have avoided feeling some sense +of the ludicrous, and even of having a slight idea of humour in its +higher phases. I shall allude in illustration of this to a proverb often +quoted ironically at the present day. "In the multitude of counsellors +there is wisdom," and which we have combated and answered by a common +domestic adage. + +Again Solomon is rather hard upon the failings of the ladies, "The +contentions of a wife," he says, "are a continual dropping." "It is +better to dwell in the corner of a housetop than with a brawling woman +in a wide house." "It is better to dwell in the wilderness than with a +contentious and angry woman." The meaning of all these sayings must be +that women are of a very irritable and vexatious character. But did +Solomon really believe in the strong terms he used towards them. We +should say not to judge by his life, for he had "seven hundred wives, +and three hundred concubines;" and although he says that, "as a jewel of +gold in a swine's snout, so is a fair woman that is without +discretion"--a very strong comparison--we may be sure that he had a +great many of these despicable creatures domiciled in his own palace. + +Solomon's strictures with regard to money may also be regarded as of +somewhat uncertain value:--"How much better is it to get wisdom than +gold," sounds very well, although Solomon must have known that many men +would prefer the latter, and history seems to say that he was not averse +from it himself. "He that is despised and hath a servant is better than +he that honoureth himself, and lacketh bread," shows at least some +appreciation of the usefulness of wealth. Ecclesiastes makes a more +decided statement. "Money answereth all things." I should imagine +Solomon was as much alive to the two sides of the question, as was the +Greek who on being asked scoffingly "why philosophers followed rich men, +but rich men never followed philosophers," replied, "Because +philosophers know what they want, but rich men do not." + +In one place Solomon shows his consciousness that his proverbs may be +viewed as true or false. He gives two opposite propositions--"Answer not +a fool according to his folly, lest thou also be like unto him," and, +"Answer a fool according to his folly, lest he be wise in his own +conceit." Shortly afterwards, he observes, as if the idea of perverting +and turning proverbs was in his mind, "The legs of a lame man are not +equal, so is a parable in the mouth of fools." + +There was another form besides that of Proverbs, in which during +earlier ages moral and political teachings were expressed. One of the +first comparisons man learned to draw was that between himself and the +lower animals; and the separation between reason and instinct would not +appear to be at first so clearly defined as it is at present. Before the +growth of cities, and the increased intercourse and accumulated +experience resulting from their formation, the mental development of man +was so small as not to offer any very strong contrast to the sagacity of +other animals. The greatest men of ancient times were merely nomad +chiefs living on the wild pasture plains, often tending their own +flocks, and, no doubt, like the Arabs of the present day, making +companions of their camels and horses. By the rivers and in the jungles, +they often encountered beasts of prey, became familiar with their +habits, and formed a higher opinion of their intelligence than we +generally hold. At that time, when strength was more esteemed than +intellectual gifts, there was sometimes a tendency to consider them as +rather above than below the human race. The lion, the eagle, and the +stag possessed qualities to which it was man's highest ambition to +aspire, and, in some cases, he even went so far as to worship them. In +the ancient civilisation of Egypt we find the most numerous traces of +this culture and feeling--gods, kings, rulers, and disembodied spirits +being represented entirely or partially under the forms of what we call +the lower animals. The strange allegorical figures found at Nineveh may +also be considered illustrations in point. There was evidently no +caricature intended in these representations, and it is worthy of notice +that such as are grotesque are not earlier than Roman times. + +It is unnecessary to recapitulate the beautiful comparisons of this +character which are profusely scattered through Holy Writ, but we should +especially notice the blessing given by Jacob to his sons on his +death-bed; in which we seem almost to discover the first origin of +heraldry. Another remarkable comparison is that of Nathan, aptly made, +and likely to sink with weight into the heart of the Shepherd-King. The +same respect for animals survived in the time of the earliest Greek +writers. + +Homer in his solemn epic has numerous instances of it:--Hector in +"Iliad" xi, 297, is setting the Trojans on "like dogs at a wild boar or +lion." In xi, 557, Ajax retreating slowly from the Trojans is compared +to an ass who has gone to feed in a field, and whom the boys find great +difficulty in driving out, "though they belabour him well with cudgels." +Agamemnon is compared to a bull, Sarpedon and Patroclus in deadly +combat to two vultures, and Diomed and Ulysses pursue Dolon as two fleet +hounds chase a hare. All these were evidently intended to be most +poetical, if not elevating similes; their dignity would have been lost +could they possibly have been regarded as humorous. + +Simonides of Amorgos in the seventh century B.C., is remarkable +for this kind of illustration. After some lamentations about human life, +he observes that nothing is better than a good wife, or worse than a bad +one, and he proceeds to compare women to various animals. He is also +evidently very serious over the subject, and regards it as no joke at +all. Perhaps there was also something to be said on the other side, for +he remarks that a gadding wife cannot be cured, even if you "knock out +her teeth with a stone." He likens them to pigs and polecats, horses +and apes; and only praises the descendant of the bee. In a passage +undoubtedly of early date, and attributed to Xenophanes, the founder of +the Eleatic school of philosophy, (540-500) the writer enumerates the +various ways, in which other animals are superior to man. "If by the +will of God there were an equality and community in life, so that the +herald of the Olympian games should not only call men to the contest, +but also bid all animals to come, no man would carry off a prize; for +in the long race the horse would be the best; the hare would win the +short race; the deer would be best in the double race. No man's +fleetness would count for anything, and no one since Hercules would seem +to have been stronger than the elephant or lion; the bull would carry +off the crown in striking, and the ass in kicking, and history would +record that an ass conquered men in wrestling and boxing." + +But the light in which the lower animals were regarded, produced other +fanciful combinations. Not only were men given the attributes of +animals, but animals were endowed with the gifts peculiar to man. All +things were then possible. Standing as he seemed in the centre of a +plain of indefinite or interminable extent, how could any man limit the +productions or vagaries of Nature, even if he possessed far more than +the narrow experience of those days? Moreover, the boundary lines were +vague between the natural and supernatural, and the latter was supposed +to be constantly interposing in the ordinary affairs of life. Among +other beliefs then prevalent, was one in the existence of a kind of half +nature, such as that in Centaurs, dragons, and griffins. In the Assyrian +cuneiform inscriptions lately deciphered, we read, of one Heabani, a +semi-bovine hermit, supposed to have lived 2,200 B.C. Thus the +accounts in Scripture of the serpent accosting Eve, and of Balaam +arguing with his ass, would not have seemed so remarkable then as they +do to us. In an Egyptian novel--the oldest extant, cir. 1,400 +B.C.--a cow tells Bata that his elder brother is standing +before him with his dagger ready to kill him. He understood, we are +told, the language of animals, and was afterwards transformed into a +bull. Greek tradition as recorded by Plato, Xenophon, Babrius, and +others, speaks of an early golden age in which men and animals held +colloquies together "as in our fables;" whence we should conclude this +much--that there was a time when poets very commonly introduced them as +holding conversations, and when philosophers illustrated their doctrines +from the animal world. + +The fable, we are told, was "an invention of ancient Assyrian men in the +days of Ninus and Belus," and in confirmation of its Eastern origin, we +may observe that the apologues of Lokman are of Indian derivation. He is +supposed, by Arabian writers, to have been either a nephew of Abraham or +Job, or a counsellor of David or Solomon. + +The first specimen we have of an ordinary fable, _i.e._, of one in which +the interlocutors are lower animals, is found in Hesiod, who is placed +about a century after Homer. It runs thus:-- + +"Now I will tell the kings a fable, which they will understand of +themselves. Thus spake the hawk to the nightingale, whom he was carrying +in his talons high in air, 'Foolish creature! why dost thou cry out? One +much stronger than thou hath seized thee, though thou art a songster. I +can tear thee to pieces, or let thee go at my pleasure.'" + +But fables do not come fully under our view until they are connected +with the name of Æsop, who is said to have introduced them into Greece. +In general his fables pretend to nothing more than an illustration of +proverbial wisdom, but in some cases they proceed a step farther, and +show the losses and disappointments which result from a neglect of +prudent considerations. It cannot be denied that there is something +fanciful and amusing in these fables, still there is not much in them to +excite laughter--they are not sufficiently direct or pungent for that. +The losses or disappointments mentioned, or implied, give a certain +exercise to the feelings of opposition in the human breast, and if they +are supposed to be such as could not easily have been foreseen, we +should regard the narratives as humorous. But this is scarcely the +case; the mishaps arise simply and directly from the situations, and +are related with a view to the inculcation of truth, rather than the +exhibition of error. Hence the basis is different from that in genuine +humour, and the complication is small. Still the object evidently was to +allure men into the paths of wisdom through the pleasure grounds of +imagination. + +Addison has justly observed that fables were the first kind of humour. +As the days of Athenian civilization advanced, their light chaff was +thought more of than their solid matter. Two hundred years of progress +in man caused the animals to be truly considered "lower," natural +distinctions were better appreciated, and there seemed to be something +absurd in the idea of their thinking or talking. Hence Æsop's fables are +spoken of by Aristophanes as something laughable, and the fabulist came +to be regarded as a humorist. This feeling gained ground so much +afterwards that Lucian makes Æsop act the part of a buffoon in "The +Isles of the Blessed." Such views no doubt influenced the traditions +with regard to the condition and characteristics of their composer. +There was the more field for this, inasmuch as even the fables were only +handed down orally. Some biographer, formerly supposed to have been +Planudes the monk, seems to have fertilized with his own inventive +genius many tales which had themselves no better foundation than the +conjectures derived from the tone and nature of the fables. Æsop was +represented as droll, as a sort of wit, and by a development of the +connection in the mind between humour and the ludicrous, they gave him +an infirm body, hesitating speech, and servile condition. Improving the +story, they said his figure frightened the servants of the merchant who +bought him. At the same time many clever tricks and speeches were +attributed to him. What we really glean from such stories is, that +animal fables soon came to be regarded as humorous. It is probable that +some fabulist of the name of Æsop at one time existed, but we know +nothing with certainty about his life, and many of the fables attributed +to him were perhaps of older date. + +The advance in the direction of humour, which was manifested in Æsop's +fictions, was also found in the opulent Ionian Sybaris. This city, +situated on the lovely Bay of Tarentum, was now at the height of its +fame, the acknowledged centre of Greek luxury and civilization. A +reflection of oriental splendour seems to have been cast upon it, and we +read of all kinds of extravagant and curious arrangements for the +indulgence of ease and indolence. Amid all this luxury and leisure, +fancy was not unemployed. We find that, like the former leaders of +fashion in this country, they kept a goodly train of monkeys,[6] and +anticipated our circus performances by teaching their horses to dance on +their hind legs, an advance above practical joking and below pictorial +caricature. Moreover, intellectual entertainment was required at their +sumptuous feasts, and genius was tasked to find something light and +racy, maxims of deep significance interwoven with gay and fanciful +creations. There was not sufficient subtlety about these inventions to +entitle them to the name of humour in our modern sense of the word; much +complication was not then required, nor much laughter expected. The +"fables" of Sybaris seem to have been of a similarly philosophical cast +to those of Æsop. The following specimen is given in the Vespæ, 1427. + +"A man of Sybaris fell from a chariot, and, as it happened, had his head +broken--for he was not well acquainted with driving--and a friend who +stood by, said, 'Let every man practise the craft, which he +understands.'" + +We observe that these fables are not carried on through the assistance +of our four-footed friends. At Sybaris, conversation between men and the +lower animals had begun to appear not only absurd, but to be improved +upon and made with the evident intention of being humorous. Hence, +inanimate things were sometimes made to speak, and in succeeding +fictions birds and beasts were given such special characteristics and +requirements of men as could least have belonged to them. As an example +of this, we may refer to the Batrachomyomachia--a production called +Homeric but proved by the very length of its name to belong to a later +date. It is ascribed by Plutarch to Pigres, the brother of the +Halicarnassian Queen, Artemisia, contemporary with the Persian War. This +poem, which is a parody on Homer, reminds us, in its microscopic +representation of human affairs, of the travels of Gulliver in Lilliput. +A frog offers to give a mouse a ride across the water on his back. +Unfortunately, a water-snake lifts up its head when they are in the +middle passage, and the frog diving to avoid the danger, the mouse is +drowned. From this trifling cause there arises a mighty war between the +frogs and the mice. The contest is carried on in true Homeric style; the +mice-warriors are armed with bean-pods for greaves, lamp-bosses for +shields, nutshells for helmets, and long needles for spears. The frogs +have leaves of willow on their legs, cabbage leaves for shields, +cockle-shells for helmets, and bulrushes for spears. Their names are +suggestive, as in a modern pantomime. Among the mice we have +Crumb-stealer, Cheese-scooper, and Lick-dish; among the frogs, +Puff-cheeks, Loud-croaker, Muddyman, Lovemarsh, &c. + + + + +PART II. + +GREEK HUMOUR. + +Birth of Humour--Personalities--Story of Hippocleides--Origin of + Comedy--Archilochus--Hipponax--Democritus, the Laughing + Philosopher--Aristophanes--Humour of the + Senses--Indelicacy--Enfeeblement of the Drama--Humorous + Games--Parasites, their Position and + Jests--Philoxenus--Diogenes--Court of Humour--Riddles--Silli. + + +There is every reason to suppose that a very considerable period elapsed +before any progress was made in advance of the ludicrous, but at length +by those who appreciated it strongly, and saw it in things in which it +did not appear to others, humorous devices were invented from a growing +desire to multiply the occasions for enjoyment. Observation and our +power of imitation provided the means, and men of humour employed +themselves in reproducing some ludicrous situations; and thus, instead +of things derided being as previously wholly separate from those who +derided them, a man could laugh, and yet be the cause of laughter to +others. This discovery was soon improved upon, and by aid of imagination +and memory, as opportunities offered, certain connections and +appearances were represented under a great variety of forms. As the mind +enlarged, the exciting causes of laughter were not mainly physical or +emotional, but assumed a higher and more rational character. + +At the period at which we have now arrived, we find humour dawning +through various channels. We have traced approximations towards it in +proverbs and fables, and, in a coarse form, in practical jokes; and as +from historical evidences we are ready to admit that civilization had an +Eastern origin, so we shall feel little difficulty in assigning Greece +as the birthplace of humour. A greater activity of mind now begins to +prevail, reflection has gradually given distinctness to emotion, and the +ludicrous is not only recognised as a source of pleasure, but +intentionally represented in literature. + +Before the time of Æsop, though not perhaps of his fables, Homer related +a few laughable occurrences of so simple a character as to require +little ingenuity. In this respect he is not much better than a man who +recounts some absurd incident he has witnessed without adding sufficient +to it to show that he has a humorous imagination. His mirth, except +when merely that of pleasure, is of the old hostile character. In Iliad, +xi, 378, Paris, having hit Diomed, from behind a pillar with an arrow in +the foot, springs forth from his concealment and laughs at him, saying +he wished he had killed him. In Iliad, xxi, 407, where the gods descend +into the battle, Minerva laughs at Mars when she has struck him with a +huge stone so that he fell, his hair was draggled in the dust, and his +armour clanged around him. In the Odyssey, Ulysses speaks of his heart +laughing within him after he had put out Polyphemus' eye with a burning +stick without being discovered. And in Book xviii, Ulysses strikes Irus +under the ear and breaks his head, so that blood pours from his mouth, +and he falls gnashing and struggling on the ground, at which, we are +told, the suitors "die with laughter." + +From this hostile phase the transition was easy to ridiculing personal +defects, and so Homer tells us that when the gods at their banquet saw +Vulcan, who was acting as butler, "stumping about on his lame leg," they +fell into "unextinguishable laughter." + +Thersites is described as "squint-eyed, lame-legged, with bent shoulders +pinched over his chest, a pointed head, and very little hair on it." +Homer may merely have intended to represent the reviler of kings as +odious and despicable, but there seems to be some humour intended. +Ridicule of personal defects must always be of an inferior kind, being a +matter of sight, and of small complexity. As the first advance of the +ludicrous was from the hostile to the personal, so the beginning of +humour seems to have been the representation of personal defects.[7] + +In accordance with this, we find that the only mention of laughter made +by Simonides of Amorgos is where he says that some women may be compared +to apes, and then gives a very rude description of their persons. This +subservience to the eye can also be observed in the appreciation of +monkeys and dancing horses, already mentioned, the latter forming a +humorous exhibition, as the animals were trained with a view to amuse. +We have marks of the same optical tendencies in the appreciation of +antics and contortions of the body, either as representing personal +deformity, or as a kind of puzzling and disorderly action. A little +contemporary story related by Herodotus shows that these pantomimic +performances were now becoming fashionable in Athens. Cleisthenes, +tyrant of Sicyon, was even at this date so much in favour of competitive +examinations, that he determined to give his daughter to the most +proficient and accomplished man. On the appointed day the suitors came +to the examination from every quarter, for the fair Agariste was heiress +to great possessions. Among them was one Hippocleides, an Athenian, who +proved himself far superior to all the rest in music and dissertation. +Afterwards, when the trial was over, desiring to indulge his feelings of +triumph and show his skill, he called for a piper, and then for a table, +upon which he danced, finishing up by standing on his head and kicking +his legs about. Cleisthenes, who was apparently one of the "old school," +and did not appreciate the manners and customs of young Athens, was much +offended by this undignified performance of his would-be son-in-law, and +when he at last saw him standing on his head, could no longer contain +himself, but cried out, "Son of Tisander, thou hast danced away thy +marriage." To which the other replied with characteristic unconcern: +"It's all the same to Hippocleides,"--an expression which became +proverbial. In this story we see the new conception of humour, though +of a rude kind, coming into collision with the old philosophic contests +of ingenuity, which it was destined to survive if not to supersede. + +We have another curious instance about this date of an earnest-minded +man being above the humour of the day, (which, no doubt, consisted +principally of gesticulation), and he was probably voted an unsociable, +old-fashioned fellow. Anacharsis, the great Scythian philosopher, when +jesters were introduced into his company maintained his gravity, but +when afterwards a monkey was brought in, he burst into a fit of +laughter, and said, "Now this is laughable by Nature; the other by Art." +That amusement should be thus excited by natural objects denotes a very +eccentric or primitive perception of the ludicrous, seldom now found +among mature persons, but it is such as Diodorus, quoting no doubt from +earlier histories, attributed to Osiris--"to whom," he says, "when in +Ethiopia, they brought Satyrs, (who have hair on their backs,) for he +was fond of what was laughable." + +But a further development of humour was in progress. As people were at +that time easily induced to regard sufferings as ludicrous, the idea +suggested itself of creating mirth by administering punishment, or by +indulging in threats and gross aspersions. A very slight amount of +invention or complexity was here necessary. The origin of the comic +drama furnishes an illustration of this. It commenced in the harvest +homes of Greece and Sicily--in the festivals of the grape-gatherers at +the completion of the vintage. They paraded the villages, crowned with +vine-leaves, carrying poles and branches, and smeared with the juice of +grapes. Their aim was to provoke general merriment by dancing, singing, +and grotesque attitudes, and by giving rein to their coarse and +pugnacious propensities. Spectators and passers by were assailed with +invectives, pelted with missiles, and treated to all that hostile humour +which is associated with practical joking. So vile was their language +and conduct that "comedy" came to signify abuse and vilification. As the +taste for music and rhythm became general in that sunny clime, even +these rioters adopted a kind of verse, by which rustic genius could give +additional point to scurrility. Thus arose the Iambic measure used at +the festivals of Ceres and Bacchus, and afterwards fabled to have been +invented by Iambe, the daughter of the King of Eleusis. Hence, also, +came the jesting used in celebrating the rites of Ceres in Sicily, and +the custom for people to post themselves on the bridge leading to +Eleusis in Attica, and to banter and abuse those going to the festivals. +The story of Iambe only marks the rural origin of the metre, and its +connection with Ceres, the Goddess of Harvest. Eleusis was her chosen +abode, and next in her favour was Paros; and here we accordingly find +the first improvement made upon these uncouth and virulent effusions. +About the commencement of the 7th century, Archilochus, a native of this +place, harnessed his ribaldries better, and put them into a "light horse +gallop." He raised the Iambic style and metre so as to obtain the +unenviable notoriety of having been the first to dip his pen in viper's +gall. Good cause had he for his complaints, for a young lady's father, +one Lycambes, refused to give him his daughter's hand. There was +apparently some difficulty about the marriage gifts--the poet having +nothing to give but himself. Rejected, he took to writing defamatory +verses on Lycambes and his daughters, and composed them with so much +skill and point that the whole family hanged themselves. Allusions, +which led to such a catastrophe, could not now be regarded as +pleasantries; but at that time he obtained a high reputation, and +perhaps the suicide of the wretched Lycambes was considered the best +joke of all.[8] The fragments which remain to us of Archilochus' +productions seem melancholy enough, and the only place where he speaks +of laughter is where he calls Charilaus "a thing to be laughed at,"--an +expression which would seem to point to some personal deformity--we are +told, however, by later writers, that he was a glutton. In another +remaining passage Archilochus says that "he is not fond of a tall +general walking with his legs apart, with his hair carefully arranged, +and his chin well shaven;" where we still detect the same kind of +caricature, and in default of any adequate specimen of his "gall," we +may perhaps be excused for borrowing an illustration from Alcæus, who +lived slightly later; and who, speaking of his political opponent +Pittacus, calls him a "bloated paunch-belly," and a "filthy +splay-footed, crack-footed, night fellow." + +Archilochus lived in the fable age, and the most perfect of the small +fragments remaining of his works are of that allegorical description. +But he may be regarded as a representative of the dull and bitter humour +of his time--a large proportion of which, as in his writings, and those +of Simonides and Hesiod, was ungallantly directed against the "girls of +the period."[9] + +But Archilochus' humour, though rude and simple, opened a new mine of +wealth, and if it was not at first very rich, it was enough to indicate +the golden treasure beneath. Sonorous narratives about heroes and +demi-gods were to be gradually supplanted by the bright contrasts of +real life. Archilochus' ingenuity had introduced light metres suited for +flippant and pointed allusions. The conceit was generally approved, and +though the new form could not exactly be called humorous, it occurred to +Hipponax, in the next century, that he could make it so by a slight +alteration. Perhaps this "Father of Parody" intended to mimic +Archilochus; at any rate, by means of a change in termination, he +manufactured "limping" Iambics. We must suppose that he produced +something better than this, but look in vain into his lines for any +instances of real pungency. He was a sort of Greek Samson, his best +jokes seem to have been connected with great strength, and to judge from +what remains of his works, we should conclude that he was more justly +famous for "tossing an oil cruise" than for producing anything which we +should call humour. But, were we asked whether in that age his sayings +would have been amusing, we may reply in the affirmative; they certainly +had severity, for his figure having been caricatured by the sculptors of +Chios, Bupalus and Anthermus, he repaid them so well in their own coin, +that they also duly hanged themselves. It must be admitted that the fact +of the same kind of death having been chosen by them, and by the objects +of Archilochus' derision, does not increase greatly the credibility of +the stories. + +We now come to consider what we may call a serious source of humour. +Already we have noticed the tendency in ancient times to exercises of +ingenuity in answering hard questions. These led to deeper thought, to +the aphoristic wisdom of the seven wise men, and the speculations of +those who were in due time to raise laughter at the follies of mankind. + +This introduces the era of the philosophers--a remarkable class of men, +who grew up in the mercurial atmosphere of Greece. One of the most +distinguished of them was Democritus, born 460 B.C. He came of +noble descent, and belonged to so wealthy a family of Abdera that his +father was able to entertain Xerxes on his return to Asia. The King left +some Chaldean Magi to instruct his son, who, early in life, evinced a +great desire for the acquisition of knowledge, and after studying under +Leucippus, travelled to Egypt, Persia, and Babylon. He almost seemed a +compound of two different characters, uniting the intellectual energy of +the sage with the social feelings of a man of the world. Living in ease +and opulence, he was not inclined to be censorious or morose; having +mingled much in society, he was not very emotional or sympathetic; not +tempted to think life a melancholy scene of suffering, but callous +enough to find amusement in the ills he could not prevent. He regarded +man, generally, as a curious study, as remarkable for not exercising the +intellect with which he was endowed--not so much from censurable causes +as from some obliquity in mental vision. Not that he regarded him as +unaccountable--a fool in the ordinary acceptation of the word, is always +a responsible being, and not synonymous with an idiot. + +The humour of this laughing sage, grounded upon deep philosophy, was so +little understood in his day that none were able to join in his +merriment, nor did he expect that they should be; if he was humorous to +himself, he was not so, and did not aim at being so, to others. On the +contrary, he was thought to be mad, and Hippocrates was directed to +inquire into his disorder, but the learned physician returned answer +that not he, but his opponents were deranged. Whether this story be a +fabrication or not, we may regard it as a testimony that wise men saw +much truth in his philosophy. Montaigne, in his Essay on Democritus and +Heraclitus, gives his preference to the former, "Because," he observes, +"men are more to be laughed at than hated," showing that he regarded him +as imputing folly to men rather than vice. + +Even Socrates, whom we are accustomed to regard as the most earnest of +philosophers was by no means a melancholy man. Fully aware of the +influence exercised by humour, he often put his teachings into an +indirect form, and he seems to have first thus generally attracted +attention. He introduced what is called irony[10]--the using expressions +which literally mean exactly the opposite to what is intended. A man may +be either praised or blamed in this way, but Socrates' intention was +always sarcastic. He put questions to men, as if merely desiring some +information they could easily give him, while he knew that his inquiries +could not be answered, without overthrowing the theories of those he +addressed. Thus, he gave instruction whilst he seemed to solicit it. In +various other ways he enlivened and recommended his doctrines by +humorous illustration. It is said that he even went to the theatre to +see himself caricatured, laughed as heartily as any, and stood up to +show the audience how correctly his ill-favoured countenance had been +reproduced. This story may be questioned, and it has been observed that +he was not insensible to ridicule, for he said shortly before his death +that no one would deride him any longer. We are told that he spent some +of his last days in versifying the fables of Æsop. + +We now return from theoretical to practical life, from the philosophers +to the public. Nothing exhibits more forcibly the variable character of +humour than that, while philosophers in their "thinking shops" were +laughing at the follies of the world, the populace in the theatre were +shaking their sides at the absurdities of sages. Ordinary men did not +appreciate abstract views, nor understand abstruse philosophic humour, +indeed it died out almost as soon as it appeared, and was only +contemporary with a certain epoch in the mental history of Greece. Every +popular man is to a great extent a reflection of the age in which he +lives, "a boat borne up by a billow;" and what, in this respect is true +generally, is especially so with regard to the humorist, who seeks a +present reward, and must be in unison with the characters of those he +has to amuse. He depends much on hitting the current fancies of men by +small and subtle allusions, and he must have a natural perception of +fitness, of the direction in which he must go, and the limits he must +not transgress. The literature of an epoch exhibits the taste of the +readers, as well as that of the authors. + +We shall thus be prepared to find that the mind of Aristophanes, +although his views were aristocratic, harmonized in tone with that of +the people, and that his humour bears the stamp of the ancient era in +which he lived. The illustrations from the animal world in which he +constantly indulges remind us of the conceits of old times, when +marvellous stories were as much admired as the monstrous figures upon +the Persian tapestry. Would any man at the present day produce comedies +with such names as "The Wasps," "The Frogs," and "The Birds."[11] But we +here meet with our feathered and four-footed companions at every corner. +The building of the bird's city is a good illustration of this. Thirty +thousand cranes brought stones for the foundations from Libya, and ten +thousand storks made bricks, the ducks with aprons on carried the +bricks, and the swallows flew with trowels behind them like little boys, +and with mortar in their beaks. + +We also notice in Aristophanes a simple and rude form of the ludicrous, +scarcely to be called humour, much in favour with his immediate +predecessors. I refer to throwing fruits and sweatmeats among the +audience. Trygæus (Vintner), celebrating a joyous country festival in +honour of the return of peace and plenty, takes occasion to throw barley +among the spectators. In another place Dicæpolis, also upon pacific +deeds intent, establishes a public treat, and calls out, "Let some one +bring in figs for the little pigs. How they squeak! will they eat them? +(throws some) Bless me! how they do munch them! from what place do they +come? I should say from Eaton." + +In this scrambling fun there would be good and bad fortune, and much +laughter would be occasioned, but mostly of an emotional character. Some +of the jokes of Hegemon, who first introduced dramatic parody, were of a +similar description, but more unpleasant. On one occasion he came into +the theatre with his robe full of stones, and began to throw them into +the orchestra, saying, "These are stones, and let those who will throw +them." Aristophanes makes great use of that humour which is dependent +upon awakening hostile and combative feelings. Personal violence and +threats are with him common stage devices. We have here as much "fist +sauce," and shaking of sticks, and as many pommellings, boxings of ears, +and threats of assault and battery as in any modern harlequinade. + +Next in order, we come to consider some of the many instances in +Aristophanes of what may be called optical humour--that in which the +point principally depends upon the eye. Thus he makes Hercules say he +cannot restrain his laughter on seeing Bacchus wearing a lion's skin +over a saffron robe. A Megarian reduced to extremities, determines to +sell his little daughters as pigs, and disguises them accordingly.[12] +In the Thesmophoriazusæ, there is a shaving scene, in which the man +performed upon has his face cut, and runs away, "looking ridiculous with +only one side of his face shaven." In another play where the ladies have +stolen the gentlemen's clothes, the latter come on the stage in the +most ludicrous attire, wearing saffron-coloured robes, kerchiefs, and +Persian slippers. In another, the chorus is composed of men representing +wasps, with waists pinched in, bodies striped with black and yellow, and +long stings behind. The piece ends with three boys disguised as crabs, +dancing a furious breakdown, while the chorus encourages them with, +"Come now, let us all make room for them, that they may twirl themselves +about. Come, oh famous offsprings of your briny father!--skip along the +sandy shore of the barren sea, ye brothers of shrimps. Twirl, whirl +round your foot swiftly, and fling up your heels in the air like +Phrynicus, until the spectators shout aloud! Spin like a top, pass along +in circle, punch yourself in the stomach, and fling your leg to the sky, +for the King himself, who rules the sea, approaches, delighted with his +children!" + +The greater the optical element in humour, the lower and more simple it +becomes, the complexity being more that of the senses than of intellect. +It may be said there is always some appeal to both, but not in any equal +proportions, and there is manifestly a great difference between the +humour of a plough-boy grinning through a horse-collar, and of a sage +observing that "when the poor man makes the rich a present, he is +unkind to him." Caricature drawings produce little effect upon educated +people, unless assisted by a description on which the humour largely +depends. We can see in a picture that a man has a grotesque figure, or +is made to represent some other animal; by gesticulation we can +understand when a person is angry or pleased, or hungry or thirsty; but +what we gain merely through the senses is not so very far superior to +that which is obtained by savages or even the lower animals, except +where there has been special education. + +Next to optical humour may be placed acoustic--that of sound--another +inferior kind. The ear gives less information than the eye. In music +there is not so much conveyed to the mind as in painting, and although +it may be lively, it cannot in itself be humorous. We cannot judge of +the range of hearing by the vast store of information brought by words +written or spoken, because these are conventional signs, and have no +optical or acoustic connection with the thing signified. We can +understand this when we listen to a foreign language. + +Hipponax seems to have been the first man who introduced acoustic humour +by the abrupt variation in his metre. Exclamations and strange sounds +were found very effective on the stage, and were now frequently +introduced, especially emanating from slaves to amuse the audience. +Aristophanes commences the knights with a howling duet between two +slaves who have been flogged, + +"Oh, oh--Oh, oh--Oh, oh--Oh, oh--" + +In another play, there is a constant chorus of frogs croaking from the +infernal marshes. + +"Brekekekex, coax, coax, brekekekex, coax, coax." + +In "The Birds," the songsters of the woods are frequently heard trilling +their lays. As they were only befeathered men, this must have been a +somewhat comic performance. The king of birds, transformed from Tereus, +King of Thrace, twitters in the following style. + +"Epopopopopopopopopopoi! io! io! come, come, come, come, come. Tio, tio, +tio, tio, tio, tio, tio! trioto, trioto, totobrix! Torotorotorotorolix! +Ciccabau, ciccabau! Torotorotorotorotililix." + +Rapidity of utterance was also aimed at in some parts of the choruses, +and sometimes very long words had to be pronounced without pause--such +as green-grocery-market-woman, and garlic-bread-selling-hostesses. At +the end of the Ecclesiazusæ, there is a word of twenty-seven +syllables--a receipt for a mixture--as multifarious in its contents as a +Yorkshire pie. + +We may conclude that there was a humour in tone as well as of rhythm in +fashion before the time of Aristophanes, and we read that there was a +certain ventriloquist named Eurycles; but Aristophanes must be content +to bear the reproach of having been the first to introduce punning. He +probably had accomplices among his contemporaries, but they have been +lost in obscurity. Playing with words seems to have commenced very +early. The organs of speech are not able to produce any great number of +entirely different sounds, as is proved by the paucity of the vowels and +consonants we possess. To increase the vocabulary, syllables are grouped +together by rapid utterance, and distinctions of time were made. +Similarities in the length and flow of words began soon to be noticed, +and hence arose the idea of parallelism, that is of poetry--a similarity +of measure. A likeness in the tone of words, in the vowel and consonant +sounds, was afterwards observed, and became the foundation of punning. +The difference between rhythm and puns is partly that of degree--and the +latter were originally regarded as poetical. Simonides of Ceos called +Jupiter Aristarchus, _i.e._, the best of rulers; and Æschylus spoke of +Helen as a "hell,"[13] but neither of them intended to be facetious. +Aristotle ranked such conceits among the ornaments of style; and we do +not until much later times find them regarded as ludicrous. + +With Aristophanes they are humorous, and his ingenuity in representing +things as the same because their names were so, would not have been +unworthy of a modern burlesque writer. They, perhaps, were more +appreciated at that time from their appearing less common and less +easily made. But there is a worse direction than any above mentioned, in +which Aristophanes truckled to the low taste of his day. The modern +reader is shocked and astounded at the immense amount of indelicacy +contained in his works. It ranges from the mild impropriety of saying +that a girl dances as nimbly as a flea in a sheepskin, or of naming +those other industrious little creatures he euphemistically calls +"Corinthians," to a grand exhibition of the blessings of Peace under the +form of a young lady, the liberal display of whose charms would have +petrified a modern Chamberlain. In one place, Trygæus is riding to +heaven on a dung-beetle, and of course a large fund of amusement is +obtained from the literal and metaphorical manipulation of its food. +Socrates' disciples are discovered in a kneeling posture, with their +heads on the ground. "What are they doing?" inquires the visitor. "They +are in search of things below the earth." "And why are their backs up in +the air?" "With them they are studying astronomy." + +These passages will give some faint idea, though not an adequate one, of +the coarseness of Aristophanes' humour. The primitive character of it is +marked by the fact that the greater portion has no reference to the +sexes. + +It is a crumb of comfort to know that women were not generally present +at performances of comedies, and Aristotle says that young men should +not be allowed to attend them until they are old enough to sit at table +and get drunk. Moreover, to be humorous the comedian must necessarily +have exceeded the bounds of ordinary usage. Aristophanes occasionally +deplores the degeneracy of his times,--the youth of the period making +"rude jests," but his own writings are the principal evidence of this +depravity. His allusions are not excusable on the ground of ignorance; +they are intentionally impure. There was once an age of innocence--still +reflected in childhood, and among some unprogressive races--in which a +sort of natural darkness hung over the thoughts and actions of men,--but +it was in reality an age of ignorance. When light broke forth delicacy +sprang up, and when by degrees one thing after another had been +forbidden and veiled from sight by the common consent of society, there +was a large borderland formed outside immorality upon which the +trespasser could enter and sport; and much could be said which was +objectionable without giving serious offence. Before the days of +Aristophanes and the comic performances for which he wrote, very little +genius or enterprise was directed into the paths of humour, but now +every part of them was explored. Indelicacy would here afford great +assistance, from the attraction it possesses for many people and the +ease with which it is understood. Something perhaps is due to the fact +that Greece had now reached the highest point of her prosperity, and +that a certain amount of lawlessness prevailed as her brilliancy began +to tremble and fade. From whatever cause it arose, Aristophanes stands +before us as one of the first to introduce this base ornamentation. The +most remarkable circumstance connected with it is that he assigns a +large part of his coarse language to women. His object was to amuse a +not very refined audience, and one that relished something +preposterous. + +Thus Aristophanes lowered his style to the level of his audience, but in +his brighter moments, forgetting his failings and exigencies, he disowns +expedients unworthy of the comic art. He says he has not like +"Phrynicus, Lycis, and Amisias" introduced slaves groaning beneath their +burdens, or yelping from their stripes; he comes away, "a year older +from hearing such stage tricks." "It is not becoming," he observes in +another place for a dramatic poet to throw figs and sweetmeats to the +spectators to force a laugh, and "we have not two slaves throwing nuts +from a basket." In _his_ plays "the old man does not belabour the person +next him with a stick." He claims that he has made his rivals give up +scoffing at rags and lice, and that he does not indulge in what I have +termed optical humour. He has not, like some of his contemporaries, +"jeered at the bald head," and not danced the Cordax. He seems in the +following passage even to despise animal illustrations-- + + _Bdelycleon._ Tell me no fables, but domestic stories about men. + + _Philocleon._ Then I know that very domestic story, "Once on a time + there was a mouse and a weazel." + + _Bdel._ "Oh, thou lubberly and ignorant fellow," as Theogenes said + when he was abusing the scavenger. Are you going to tell a story of + mice and weazels among men? + +Like most humorists he blames in one place what he adopts in another. + +Plato had so high an opinion of Aristophanes that, in reply to Dionysius +of Syracuse, he sent him a copy of his plays as affording the best +picture of the commonwealth of Athens. This philosopher is also said to +have introduced mimes--a sort of minor comedy--from Sicily, and to have +esteemed their composer Sophron so highly that he kept a copy of his +works under his pillow. Plato appreciated humour, was fond of writing +little amatory couplets, and among the epigrams attributed to him is the +following dedication of a mirror by a fading beauty, thus rendered by +Prior:-- + + "Venus, take this votive glass, + Since I am not what I was! + What I shall hereafter be, + Venus, let me never see!" + +Plato objected to violent laughter as indicative of an impulsive and +ill-regulated temper, observing "that it is not suitable for men of +worth, much less for the gods," the first part of which remark shows +that he was not emotional, and the second that a great improvement in +critical taste had taken place since the early centuries of Homer and +David. + +As youth is romantic, and old age humorous, so in history sentiment +precedes criticism and poetry attained a high degree of excellence, +while humour was in its infancy. Comedy is said to have been produced +first in Sicily by Susarion in 564 B.C., but we have only two +or three lines by which to judge of his work, and they are on the old +favourite topic. "A wife is an evil, but you can't live in a house +without one." As it is said his wife left him, it must be considered +doubtful whether this was not meant seriously. He was succeeded by +Epicharmus, whose humour seems to have been of a very poor description. +His subjects were mostly mythological, and he was fond of representing +the gluttony of Hercules, and Bacchus making Vulcan drunk. In the more +intellectual direction his taste was entirely philosophical, so much so +that Plato adopted many of his views. We may safely assert that no comic +performance worthy of the name took place until towards the end of the +fifth century,[14] though in the meantime the tragic drama had reached +its highest point of excellence. One _Satyric_ play, so called because +the chorus was formed of Satyrs, was put on the stage with three +tragedies by those competing for the dramatic prize. It seems to have +been mythological and grotesque rather than comic, but in the Cyclops +of Euripides, the only specimen extant, we have feasting and wine +drinking, the chorus tells Polyphemus he may swallow any milk he pleases +so that he does not swallow them--which the Cyclops says he would not do +because they might be dancing in his stomach--and Silenus recommends the +Cyclops to eat Ulysses' tongue, as it will make him a clever talker. + +After the time of Aristophanes, the literary, and, we may say, the +social humour of Greece altered. It grew less political as liberty +became more restricted, and men's minds were gradually diverted by +business and foreign trade from that philosophical and artistic +industry, which had made Athens the centre of the world. The brighter +part of the country's genius descended to effeminate pursuits, and +employed itself in the development of amorous fancies. In the comedies +which came into favour, the dramatis personæ represented a strange +society of opulent old men, spendthrift sons, intriguing slaves, and +courtezans. If we did not know what temptation there is to make literary +capital out of the tender passion, we might suppose that the youth of +that day were entirely occupied in clandestine amours, and in buying and +selling women as if they were dogs and parrots. No wonder that "to live +like the Greeks" became a by-word and reproach. Beyond this, the authors +throw the whole force of their genius into the construction of the plot, +upon the strength and intricacy of which their success depends; and the +management of the various threads of the story so as to meet together in +the conclusion, shows a great improvement in art since the days of +Aristophanes. Advancing time seems also to have brought a greater +refinement in language. The indelicacy we now meet with is almost +entirely of an amatory character, and not quite of so low a description +as that previously in use. But in quantity it was greater. Philemon, who +is said to have died from a fit of laughter caused by seeing an ass eat +figs, wrote much that was objectionable; and Diphilus was probably +little better. Philemon found coarseness answer, and was more often +crowned, and a greater favourite than Menander, who is reported to have +said to him, "Do you not blush to conquer me?" but it may be doubted +whether even the latter was as free from indelicacy as is generally +supposed. Plautus and Terence both complain that they cannot find a +really chaste Greek play. + +The age of Greek fables, that is the period when they were in common use +in writing and conversation, was now drawing to a close. A few remain +in Callimachus, and Suidas quotes some of perhaps the same date. At this +time Demetrius Phalareus made a prose collection of what were called +Æsop's Fables--as we seek to perpetuate the memory of that which is +passing away. Babrius, also, who performed the same charitable office in +"halting iambics," like those of Hipponax, may be supposed to have +flourished about this period, although it has been contended that he was +a Roman and lived in the Augustan age. However this may be, fabular +illustrations began to drop out of fashion soon after this time, and by +degrees were so far disallowed, that the man, who would have related +such stories, would have been regarded as ludicrous rather than +humorous. Although Phædrus Romanized Æsop's Fables, and gave them a +poetical meaning, he never gained any fame or popularity by them. +Martial calls him "improbus," _i.e._, a rascal. + +In these and earlier days, besides the humour exhibited in comedies, a +considerable amount was displayed at public festivals and private +entertainments. In the Homeric hymn to Mercury, we read that the god +extemporized a song, "just as when young men at banquets slily twit each +other." When the cups flowed, and the conversation sparkled, men +indulged in repartee, or capped each other in verses. One man, for +instance, would quote or compose a line beginning and ending with a +certain letter, and another person was called upon for a similar one to +complete the couplet. Sometimes the line commenced with the first +syllable of a word, and ended with the last, and a corresponding conceit +was to be formed to answer it. The successful competitors at these games +were to be kissed and crowned with flowers; the unsuccessful to drink a +bowl of brine. These verbal devices were too simple and far-fetched to +be humorous, but were, to a certain extent, amusing, and no doubt the +forfeits and rewards occasioned some merriment. + +A coarser kind of humour originated in the market-place, where professed +wags of a low class were wont to congregate, and amuse themselves by +chaffing and insulting passers-by. Such men are mentioned centuries +afterwards by St. Paul as "lewd fellows of the baser sort,"--an +expression which would be more properly rendered "men of the +market-place." Such centres of trade do not seem to have been improving +to the manners, for we read of people "railing like bread-women," and of +the "rude jests" of the young men of the market.[15] Lysistratus was +one of these fellows in Aristophanes' days, and his condition seems to +have been as miserable as his humour, for his garment had "shed its +leaves,"[16] and he was shivering and starving "more than thirty days in +the month." + +By degrees, as wealth increased, there came a greater demand for +amusement. Jesters obtained patrons, and a distinct class of men grew +up, who, having more humour than means were glad to barter their +pleasantries for something more substantial. Wit has as little tendency +to enrich its possessor as genius--the mind being turned to gay and idle +rather than remunerative pursuits, and into a destructive rather than a +constructive channel. Talent does not imply industry, and where the +stock in trade consists of luxuries of small money value, men make but a +precarious livelihood. One of them says that he will give as a fortune +to his daughter "six hundred _bon mots_--all pure Attic," which seems to +suggest that they were to be puns. No doubt it was the demand that led +to the supply, for jesters were in request at convivial meetings, and +the jealousy of their equally poor, but less amusing neighbours, not +improbably led to some of the ill-natured reflections upon them. Society +was to blame for encouraging the parasite, who seems to have become an +institution in Greece. He is not mentioned by Aristophanes, but figures +constantly in the plays of later writers, where he is a smooth-tongued +witty varlet, whose aim is to make himself agreeable, and who is ready +to submit to any humiliation in order to live at other people's expense. +Thus Gelasimus--so called, as he avers, because his mother was a +droll--laments the changed times. He liked the old forms of expression, +"Come to dinner--make no excuse;" but now it is always, "I'd invite you, +only I'm engaged myself." In another place a parasite's stomach is +called a "bottomless pit," and they are said to "live on their juices" +while their patrons are away in the country. Their servility was, of +course, exaggerated in comedy to make humorous capital, but as they were +poor and of inferior social standing to those with whom they consorted, +they were sure occasionally to suffer indignities varying in proportion +to the bad taste and insolence of their patrons. Thus we read that they +not only sat on benches at the lower end of the table, but sometimes had +their faces daubed and their ears boxed. In the ambiguous position they +occupied, they were no doubt exposed to temptations, but we are not to +suppose that they were generally guilty of such short-sighted treachery +as that attributed to them by the dramatists. Still, they certainly were +in bad repute in their generation, and hence we are enabled to +understand Aristotle's observation that he who is deficient in humour is +a boor, but he who is in culpable excess is a _bomolochos_, or thorough +scoundrel. He would connect the idea of great jocosity with unprincipled +designs. + +Philoxenus, had a more independent spirit than most parasites, and the +history of his sojourn in Syracuse gives us an amusing insight into the +state of Court life in Sicily 400 years B.C. He was an Athenian +dithyrambic poet and musician; and as Dionysius affected literature, he +was welcomed at his palace, where he wrote a poem entitled "The +Banquet," containing an account of the luxurious style of living there +adopted. Philoxenus was probably the least esteemed guest at these +feasts, of which, but for him no record would survive. He was a man of +humour, and some instances of his quaintness remain. On one occasion, +when supping with the tyrant, a small mullet was placed before him, and +a large one before Dionysius. He thereupon took up his fish and placed +it to his ear. Dionysius asked him why he did so, to which he replied +that he was writing a poem, called "Galatæa," and wanted to hear some +news from the kingdom of Nereus. "The fish given to him," he added, +"knew nothing about it, because it had been caught so young; but no +doubt that set before Dionysius would know everything." The tyrant, we +are told, laughed and sent him his mullet. As might have been +anticipated, he soon greatly offended Dionysius, who actually sent him +to work in the stone-quarries; but the cause of his misfortune is +uncertain. Athenæus attributes it to his falling in love with a +favourite "flute-girl" of Dionysius, and says that in his "Galatæa," he +caricatured his rival as the Cyclops. According to another account, his +disgrace was owing to his having, when asked to revise one of Dionysius' +poetical compositions, crossed out the whole of it from beginning to +end. He was, however, restored to favour, and seated once more at the +royal table; but, unfortunately, the tyrant had again been perpetrating +poetry, and recited some of his verses, which were loudly applauded by +all the courtiers. Philoxenus was called upon to join in the +commendation, but instead of complying, he cried out to the guards, +"Take me back to the quarries." Dionysius, took the joke and pardoned +him. He afterwards left the Syracusan Court, and went to his native +place, Cythera; and it was characteristic of his bluntness and wit, +that, on being invited by the tyrant to return, he replied by only one +letter of the alphabet signifying "NO." + +And now a most grotesque figure stands before us--it is that of +Diogenes, who was a youth at the time of Aristophanes' successes, and +was, no doubt by many, classed with those rude idlers of the +market-place of whom we have already spoken. Some people have questioned +his claim to be regarded as a philosopher. He does not appear to have +been learned, or deeply read; but he was meditative and observant, and +that which in an anchorite, or hermit, would have been a mere sentiment, +and in an ordinary man a vague and occasional reflection, expanded in +his mind into a general and practical view of life. Observing that the +things we covet are not only difficult of attainment, but unsatisfactory +in possession, he thought to solve the problem of life by substituting +contempt for admiration. He was, probably, somewhat influenced by his +own condition in this vain attempt to draw sweetness from sour grapes. +He was poor, and we find that this despiser of the goods of this world, +who considered money to be the "metropolis of all evils"--in his youth +coined false money, and was banished to Sinope in consequence. Among his +recorded sayings, he expresses his surprise that the slaves attending +at banquets could keep their hands off their master's dainties. + +But we should be doing Diogenes an injustice, if we set him down as a +mere discontented misanthrope. In giving due weight to unworthy motives, +we have looked only at one side--and that the worst--of his character. +His mind was of an inquiring speculative cast, and in youth he aspired +to join the disciples of Zeno. So persistent indeed was he that the +stoic, unwilling to have such a questionable pupil, one day forgot his +serene philosophy, and set upon him with a cudgel. Such arguments did +not tend to soften Diogenes' disposition, and although he accused man of +folly rather than malignity, he went so far to say that a man should +have "reason or a rope." He probably thought it easier than Democritus +to follow wisdom, because he did not see quite so far. Still he showed +that he took an interest in social life, and had he been less of a +moralist, he would have had better claims to be regarded as a "wit" than +any other character in Grecian history. Many examples could be adduced +in which his principal object was evidently to be amusing:-- + +Entering a school in which he saw many statues of the Muses, but few +pupils, "You have many scholars among the gods," he said to the master. +On being asked at what time it was proper to dine, "If you are rich, +when you will; if poor, when you can," he replied, perhaps a little +sadly; and to "What wine do you like to drink?" he quickly responded +"Another man's." Meeting one, Anaximenes, a very fat man, he called out, +"Give us poor fellows some of your stomach; it will be a great relief to +you, and an advantage to us." + +That Diogenes recognised humour as a means of drawing attention and +impressing the memory, is shown by the story that on one occasion, when +he was speaking seriously and found no one attending, he began to +imitate the singing of birds, and when he had thus collected a crowd, +told them they were ready to hear folly but not wisdom. There was also, +probably, in adopting this form a desire to preclude the possibility of +his being contradicted. He was thus proof against criticism--if his +statements were said to be false--well, they were intended to be so; +while, if they raised a laugh, there was an admission that they +contained some seeds of truth. The following are examples of his +disguised wisdom:-- + +On being asked when a man should marry, "A young man not yet; an old man +not at all," he replied. "Why men gave money to beggars and not to +philosophers?" "Because they think they may themselves become blind and +lame, but never philosophers." When Perdiccas threatened that unless he +came to him he would kill him, "You would do no great thing," he +replied, "even a beetle or a spider could do that." + +We can scarcely suppose that all the sayings attributed to Diogenes are +genuine. There has always been a tendency to attribute to great men +observations made in accordance with their manner. + +Philosophers have generally been to a certain extent destructive, and +seldom spared the religion of their times. Diogenes, who was called +"Socrates gone mad," was no exception to this rule. Humour, which is +seasoned with profanity, is most telling when there is not too large an +amount either of faith or scepticism; very few could find any amusement +in the sneers of an utter infidel. Diogenes was almost as deficient in +ordinary religious belief as in most other kinds of veneration. +Sometimes he may have had the good effect of checking the abuse of +sacerdotal power, as when he observed to some who were admiring the +thank offerings at Samothracia, "There would have been many more, had +those made them, who had not been cured." He also said that the +Dionysian festival was a great sight for fools, and that when he heard +prophets and interpreters of dreams, he thought nothing was so silly as +man. His blaming men for making prayers, because they asked not that +which was good, but only what seemed desirable to them, may be taken in +a favourable sense. + +Before the end of Diogenes' life fanciful conceits became so much +appreciated in Greece, that a regular "Court of Humour" was held at +Heracleum, a village near Athens, and it is to be feared that many of +the racy sayings attributed to eminent men, originated in the sessions +of this jocund assembly. It was composed of sixty members, and their +sayings came forth with the stamp of "The Sixty" upon them. Their +reputation became so great, that Philip of Macedon gave them a talent to +write out their jokes, and send them to him. He was himself fond of +gaiety, invented some musical instruments, and kept professed jesters. + +Soon after this time, we read of amateur jesters or rather practical +jesters called _planoi_. Chrysippus, who was not only a philosopher, but +a man of humour--a union we are not surprised to find common at that +date--and who is said, perhaps with equal truth, to have died like +Philemon in a fit of laughter, on seeing an ass eat figs off a silver +plate--mentions a genius of this kind, one Pantaleon, who, when at the +point of death told each of his sons separately that he confided to him +alone the place where he had buried his gold. When he was dead, they all +betook themselves to the same spot, where they laboured for some time, +before discovering that they had all been deceived. + +From this period we are mostly indebted to epigrams for any knowledge of +Greek humour. They originated in inscriptions or offerings in temples; +afterwards came to be principally epitaphial or sarcastic; and grew into +a branch of literature. + +We can scarcely understand some of the fancies indulged in at the time, +which contain no salt at all--"Sports," Hephæstio calls them. Of these +devices may be mentioned the "Wings of Love" by Simmias, a Rhodian, who +lived before 300 B.C. The verses are graduated so as to form a +pair of wings. "The first altar," written by Dosiadas of Rhodes, is the +earliest instance of a Greek acrostic, or of any one which formed words. +An acrostic is a play upon spelling, as a pun is upon sound; and in both +cases the complication is too slight for real humour. They are rather to +be considered as ingenious works of fancy. The first specimens are those +in the Psalms--twelve of which have twenty-two verses beginning with the +twenty-two letters of the Hebrew alphabet. The 119th Psalm is a curious +specimen of this conceit; it is divided into twenty-two stanzas, and a +letter of the alphabet in regular order begins each of them. The initial +letters of "The First Altar" of Dosiadas of Rhodes, form four words, and +seem to be addressed to some "Olympian," who, the dedicator hopes "may +live to offer sacrifice for many years." The altar states that it is not +stained with the blood of victims, nor perfumed with frankincense, that +it is not made of gold and silver; but formed by the hand of the Graces +and the Muses. In the "Second Altar," also usually attributed to +Dosiadas of Rhodes, we find not only a fanciful outline formed by long +and short verses, but also a studious avoidance of proper names. Not one +is mentioned, although thirteen persons are designated. It is evident +that this "Altar" was a work of ingenuity, and intended to be +enigmatical. Probably the substitutions were also considered to be +somewhat playful and amusing, as in Antiphanes--a comic poet, said to +have died from an apple falling on his head--we read, + + _A._ Shall I speak of rosy sweat + From Bacchic spring? + + _B._ I'd rather you'd say wine. + + _A._ Or shall I speak of dusky dewy drops? + + _B._ No such long periphrasis--say plainly water. + + _A._ Or shall I praise the cassia breathing fragrance + That scents the air. + + _B._ No, call it myrrh. + +Another conceit in the form of a Sphinx or Pandean pipe has been +attributed to Theocritus--perhaps without good foundation. + +In the "Egg" there is not only the form of the lines, which gradually +expand and then taper downwards, but there is also a great amount of +similitude--the literary egg being compared to a real egg, and the poet +to the nightingale that laid it. There is also a remarkable involution +in form--the last line succeeding the first, and so on; and this +alternation of the verses is compared to the leaping of fawns. The Axe +or Hatchet is apparently a sort of double axe, being nearly in the form +of wings; and is supposed to be a dedicatory inscription written to +Minerva on the axe of Epeus, who made the wooden horse by which Troy was +taken. + +The ancient riddles seem to have been generally of a descriptive +character, and not to have turned upon quibbles of words, like those of +the present day. They more corresponded to our enigmas--being +emblematic--and in general were small tests of ingenuity, some being +very simple, others obscure from requiring special knowledge or from +being a mere vague description of things. Of the learned kind were +doubtless those hard questions with which the Queen of Sheba proved +Solomon, and those with which, on the authority of Dius and Menander, +Josephus states Solomon to have contended with Hiram. The riddle of +Samson also required special information; and the same characteristics +which marked the early riddles of Asia, where the conceit seems to have +originated, is also found in those of Greece. Who could have guessed the +following "Griphus" from Simonides of Ceos, without local knowledge, or +with it, could have failed, + + "I say that he who does not like to win + The grasshopper's prize, will give a mighty feast, + To the Panopeiadean Epeus." + +This means, we are told, that when Simonides was at Carthea he used to +train choruses, and there was an ass to fetch water for them. He called +the ass "Epeus," after the water-carrier of the Atridae; and if any +member of the chorus was not present to sing, _i.e._, to win the +grasshopper's prize, he was to give a choenix of barley to the ass. +Well might Clearchus say "the investigation of riddles is not +unconnected with philosophy, for the ancients used to display their +erudition in such things." + +Somewhat of the same character is found in the following from +Aristophanes. + + _People._ How is a trireme a "dog fox?" + + _Sausage Seller._ Because the trireme and the dog are swift. + + _People._ But why fox? + + _Sausage Seller._ The soldiers are little foxes, for they eat up + the grapes in the farms. + +The simplicity of some of the ancient riddles may be conjectured from +the fact that the same word "griphus" included such conceits as verses +beginning and ending with a certain letter or syllable. + +An instance of the emblematic character of early riddles is seen in that +proposed by the Sphinx to OEdipus. "What is that which goes on four +legs in the morning, on two in the middle of the day, and on three in +the evening?" And in the riddle of Cleobulus, one of the seven wise men: + +"There was a father, and he had twelve daughters; each of his daughters +had thirty children; some were white and others black, and though +immortal they all taste of death." + +Also in the following griphi, which are capable of receiving more than +one answer. + +The first two are respectively by Eubulus and Alexis--writers of the +"New Comedy"--who flourished in the first half of the 4th century, +B.C. + + "I know a thing, which while it's young is heavy, + But when it's old, though void of wings, can fly, + With lightest motion out of sight of earth. + + "It is not mortal or immortal either + But as it were compounded of the two, + So that it neither lives the life of man + Nor yet of god, but is incessantly + New born again, and then again + Of this its present life invisible, + Yet it is known and recognised by all." + +From Hermippus:-- + + "There are two sisters, one of whom brings forth, + The other and in turn becomes her daughter." + +Diphilus, in his Theseus, says, there were once three Samian damsels, +who on the day of the festival of Adonis delighted themselves with +riddles. One of them proposed, "What is the strongest of all things?" +Another answered, "Iron, because it is that with which men dig and cut." +The third said, "The blacksmith, for he bends and fashions the iron." +But the first replied, "Love, for it can subdue the blacksmith himself." + +The following is from Theadectes, a pupil of Isocrates, who lived about +300 B.C., and wrote fifty tragedies--none of which survive. + + "Nothing which earth or sea produces, + Nought among mortals hath so great increase. + In its first birth the largest it appears, + Small in its prime, and in old age again, + In form and size it far surpasses all."[17] + +To make a riddle, that is a real test of ingenuity for all, and which +but one answer satisfies, shows an advanced stage of the art. The +ancient riddles were almost invariably symbolical, and either too vague +or too learned. They seem to us not to have sufficient point to be +humorous, but no doubt they were thought so in their day. + +It may not be out of place here to advert to those light compositions +called Silli, about which we have no clear information, even with regard +to the meaning of the name. From the fragments of them extant, we find +that they were written in verse, and contained a considerable amount of +poetical sentiment; indeed, all that has come down to us of Xenophanes, +the first sillographer, is of this character. We are told that he used +parody, but his pleasantry, probably, consisted much of after-dinner +jests and stories, for we find that although he praises wisdom, and +despises the fashionable athletic games, he rejoiced in sumptuous +banquets, and said that the water should first be poured into the cup, +then the wine. But the most celebrated sillographer was Timon the +Phliasian--intimate with Antigonus and Ptolemy Philadelphus--who wrote +three books of Silli, two in dialogues, and one in continuous narrative. +He was a philosopher, and the principal object of his work was to bring +other sects into ridicule and discredit. A few reflections of general +application are scattered through it, but they are in general quite +subsidiary and suggested by the subject matter. + + + + +PART III. + +ROMAN HUMOUR. + +Roman Comedy--Plautus--Acerbity--Terence--Satire--Lucilius--Horace--Humour + of the Cæsar Family--Cicero--Augustus--Persius--Petronius--Juvenal + --Martial--Epigrammatist--Lucian--Apuleius--Julian the Apostate--The + Misopogon--Symposius' Enigmas--Macrobius--Hierocles and Philagrius. + + +The light of genius which shone in Greece was to some extent reflected +upon Rome, where there was never an equal brilliancy. As for humour, +such as was indigenous in the country, it was only represented by a few +Saturnian snatches, some Fescennine banterings at weddings and +harvest-homes, and rude pantomimic performances also originating in +Etruria. Intellectual pleasantry was unknown, except as an exotic, and +flourished almost exclusively among those who were imbued with the +literature of Greece. + +About the date at which we arrived at the end of the last chapter--the +middle of the third century, B.C.--the first regular play was +introduced at Rome by Livius Andronicus. He was a Greek slave, having +been taken prisoner at the capture of Tarentum. Scarcely anything +remains by which to judge of his writings, but we know that he copied +from Greek originals. His plays were, no doubt, mostly appreciated by +the better educated classes of the audience. He had a rival in +Noevius, a Campanian by birth, who also copied from the Greek, but +retained something of the Fescennine licence, or rather, we should say, +had much of the hostile humour common to the earlier periods of Greece +and Rome. So violent were his attacks upon the leading men of the day, +that he was imprisoned, and finally died in exile at Utica. This early +connection of comedy with abuse and buffoonery was probably one cause of +professional actors being held in contempt in Rome. We read that they +were frequently slaves, who were whipped if they came late. At the same +time native scurrility was allowed. Freeborn Romans might act for +amusement in the Atellane plays, which were considered to be Italian, +and were accompanied by broad "Exodia" or pantomimic interludes +containing regular characters such as Maccus the clown, Buccones the +chatterers, Pappus the pantaloon, and Simus, the ape. But these +productions came from Campania, and it is probable that the better +parts of them were Greek in spirit, though not in form. + +Some fifty years later brings us to Plautus--the most remarkable of the +Roman comic writers. Little is known of his origin, except that he was +born in Umbria. There is a story that at one time he was in so humble a +position that he was employed in grinding corn for a baker; but, if so, +he must have possessed extraordinary ability and perseverance to acquire +such a thorough knowledge of Greek and Latin. The fact of his adopting +the stage as a profession, and acting in his own dramas, proves that he +was not encumbered with rank or wealth. His plays were numbered among +the classics, and were produced upon the stage till the time of +Diocletian, five hundred years after his death; he generally copied from +the Greek, often naming the author to whom he was indebted. + +Plautus is interesting, not only as giving us an insight into the Greek +mode of life before his time, and preserving many of the works of +Philemon, Diphilus, and others, but as being the only Latin writer of +his date whose productions have survived. He wrote one hundred and +thirty plays, of which thirty are extant, and show an orthography very +different from that of the Augustan age. His style was forcible, and +like that of all the Latin comic writers, highly complex. He sometimes +coins words, (such as Trifurcifur, gugga,[18] parenticida,) and he is +constantly giving new metaphorical senses to those already in use--as +when he speaks of a man being a "hell of elms," _i.e._, severely flogged +with elm-rods--calls cooks "briars," because they take fast hold of +everything they touch, and threatens a slave with "memorials of oxen," +_i.e._, a thrashing that will make him remember the thong. + +We may possibly trace the Greek original in a few references to +conversations of animals--although no plays are now called after +them--and the names, places, and money he introduces are generally +Greek. Still, we cannot regard him as a mere servile imitator--much of +his own genius is doubtless preserved in the plays. In some, we can +clearly recognise his hand, as where he alludes to Roman customs, or +indulges in puns. For instance, where a man speaks of the blessing of +having children, (liberi,) another observes he would rather be _free_ +(liber). In "The Churl," we read that it is better to fight with minæ +than with menaces, and a lover says that Phronesium has expelled her own +name (wisdom) from his breast. + +An old man says he has begun to go to school again, and learn his +letters. "I know three already," he continues, "What three?" is asked, +"A M O." + +While we are glad to mark an advancement in less pleasures being derived +from personal threats and conflicts on the stage, we are pained to find +such an entire want of sympathy with the sufferings of those in a +servile condition. The severity with which slaves were treated in +previous times was not mitigated under the Roman rule, and at the +present day it is difficult to realise the moral state of those who +could derive amusement from hearing men threatened with bull-hidings, +and flogged on the stage. Such terms as "whip-knave" became stale from +repetition, and so many jokes were made even about crucifixion, that we +might suppose it to be a very trifling punishment. Chrysalus, a slave, +facetiously observes, that when his master discovers he has spent his +gold, he will make him "cruscisalus" _i.e._ "cross jumper." In "The +Haunted House," Tranio, who, certainly seems to have been a great scamp, +soliloquises as follows on hearing of his master's return:-- + +"Is there any one, who would like to gain a little money, who could +endure this day to take my place in being tortured? Who are those +fellows hardened to a flogging, who wear out iron chains, or those who +for three didrachmas[19] would get beneath besieging towers, where they +might have their bodies pierced with fifteen spears? I'll give a talent +to that man who shall be the first to run to the cross for me, but on +condition that his feet and arms are doubly fastened there. When that is +done, then ask the money of me." + +Acoustic humour appears not only in puns, but under the form of long +names of which Plautus was especially fond, Periplecomenus, +Polymacharoplagides, and Thesaurochrysonicocræ are specimens of his +inventive genius in this direction. + +In the "Three Coins," Charmides asks the sharper's name. + + _Sh._ You demand an arduous task. + + _Charmides._ How so? + + _Sh._ Because if you were to begin before daylight at the first + part of my name 'twould be dead of night before you could reach the + end of it. I have another somewhat less, about the size of a wine + cask. + +In the "Persian," Toxilus gives his name as follows, + + "Vaniloquidorus Virginisvendonides + Nugipolyloquides Argentiexterebronides + Tedigniloquides Nummorumexpalponides + Quodsemelarripides + Nunquamposteareddides." + +There are a few other cases in which there is a playing upon sound, as +where Demipho remarks that if he had such a good-looking girl as +Pasicompsa for a servant, all the people would be "staring, gazing, +nodding, winking, hissing, twitching, crying, annoying, and serenading." + +The failings of the fair seems always to have been a favourite subject +for men's attack, but reflections of this kind have decreased in number +and acerbity since the days of Aristophanes. We find, however, some in +Plautus, such as the following:-- + +"Love is a fawning flatterer. For he that is in love, soon as ever he +has been smitten with the kisses of the object he loves, forthwith his +substance vanishes out of doors, and melts away. 'Give me this, my +honey, if you love me.' And then Gudgeon says, 'Oh apple of my eye, both +that and still more, if you wish.' He who plunges into love perishes +more dreadfully than if he leapt from a rock. Away with you, Love, if +you please." + +He is fully alive to the power of this destructive passion. In one place +Philolaches half mad with love and jealousy sees his mistress looking +into a mirror. "Ah, wretched me," he exclaims passionately, "she gave +the mirror a kiss. I wish I had a stone to break the head of that +mirror."[20] + +The love of money has always been a stock subject with humorists. This +common weakness of human nature can be played upon even by those who can +produce no other wit, and many worse jokes have been made on it than the +following,-- + +Calidorus asks his servant, Pseudolus, to lend him a drachma. + + _P._ What for? + + _C._ To buy a rope to hang myself. + + _P._ Who then will pay me back? Do you wish to hang yourself to + cheat me out of my drachma? + +The "Concealed Treasure" turns on an old man having found a pot of gold. +He conceals it, and his nervousness lest some one should discover it is +brought out with excellent humour. He drives the cooks out of the place +with his stick. He has a battle-royal with a dunghill cock, who, he +imagines is trying to scratch for it, then thinks Strobilus has stolen +it, and calls on him to show one hand, and the other, and then the +third. + +We are the more inclined to lament the utter destruction of ancient +African literature on finding that the most refined Roman dramas were +placed upon the stage by a Carthaginian, when Plautus, whose enterprize +and perseverance had given the great impetus to Latin comedy, was +approaching the end of his long life. Terence was born the last, and as +some think the greatest master in this branch of Art. He was at one time +a slave, but his literary talent was so remarkable that his master set +him free, and he became the friend of distinguished men, especially of +Scipio the younger. It must seem strange that this brilliancy should +have flashed up for a moment, and then been for ever quenched, but it +was derived from Greece and not in its nature enduring. The genius of +Menander fed the flame of Terence, as that of Diphilus and others gave +power to Plautus, and it may well be supposed that men of their talent +appropriated all that was most excellent, and left their successors to +draw from inferior sources. It may, moreover, be doubted, whether the +regular drama was ever popular among the lower classes in Rome, who +preferred the more exciting scenes of the circus. Such plays as were +intended for them were coarser and more sensational. + +Terence has not the rough power and drollery of Plautus; his whole +attraction lies in the subtlety of his amorous intrigues. Steele, +speaking of one of the plays, "The Self-Tormentor," observes, "It is +from the beginning to the end a perfect picture of human life, but I did +not observe in the whole one passage that could possibly raise a laugh." +It was for this reason, no doubt, that Cæsar spoke of him as only "half +a Menander," and as deficient in comic force. Ingenious complexity is so +exclusively his aim, that we have neither the coarseness nor the sparkle +of earlier writers. He was the first to introduce Comedies, which were +not comic, and whatever humour he introduces is that of situation. + +We now come to consider a kind of humour of which the Romans claim to +have been the originators, and which they certainly developed into a +branch of literature. Satire first signified a basket of first fruits +offered to Ceres; then a hotchpot or olla podrida, then a medley; and so +the name was given to poems written without any definite design. We +might therefore conclude that they possessed no uniform character, but +merely contained a mixture of miscellaneous matter. But we find in them +no allusions to politics or war, and but few to the literature and +philosophy of the day--their variety being due to their social +complexion. One feeling and character pervades them all--they were +called forth by a scornful indignation at the degeneracy of the age as +represented by the rich and powerful, or even by certain leading +individuals. The appearance of such a kind of literature denoted greater +activity in society, an increase of profligacy among some, and of moral +sensibility among others. Satire was a social scourge. It was not a +philosophical investigation into the nature and origin of vice, but a +denunciation of it as inimical to the interests of society. It was +practical not theoretical--and sought to bring vice into contempt, by +making it both odious and ridiculous. In the latter attempt, the +satirists may have had more success than we credit them with, for in our +day such virulent attacks would be distasteful, immorality being +regarded as essentially a matter for grave and serious condemnation. +Satire differs from abuse, not only in being declamatory, but in being +deserved. The amusement in it mostly depends upon the deformity of the +sensual, the failures of the wicked, and the exposure of guilt in a kind +of moral pillory. It did not aim at mere accidental losses or +imperfections, and made no fanciful accusations merely to amuse, but it +was often lightened by metaphor, by coined words, and especially by +exaggeration. + +The satire of Rome, though in a certain sense new, seems to have been +somewhat derived from Greece. Ennius, who commenced it, a man younger +than Plautus and older than Terence, was himself half a Greek. He wrote +epic poems and comedies, and also introduced this comic literature for +private reading. Lucilius, who was the first eminent Roman satirist, is +said to have imitated the old Greek comedies. His attacks are very +severe and personal, reminding us a little of Archilochus, though +apparently not written to gratify any private spleen. The tendency to +personalities marked a time when the range of society and the tone of +thought were equally narrow. Moral depravity was considered to be +centred in a few individuals, and in the broken fragments of Lucilius' +rage, which have descended to us, we find a man stigmatised as an +"ulcer," "gangrene," a "poison," "jibber," "shuffler," "a hard-mouthed +obstinate brute." Sometimes he ridicules the bodily infirmities of the +depraved; but Lucilius' attacks seem less ill-natured and more justly +humorous from being always directed against the vicious and demoralised. +Occasionally he indulges in such uncomplimentary expressions as "There +is no flummery-maker equal to you," while some are hailed with "Long +life to you, glutton, gormandizer, and belly-god." He might truly say in +his metaphorical language, "I seize his beak and smash his lips, +Zopyrus' fashion, and knock out all his front teeth." + +The satire of Horace was exceptionally mild; with him its social +character was much more marked than its acerbity. In many places he +shows Greek reflections, for he had received a liberal education, duly +completed at Athens. But his philosophy did not consist of dreamy +theories and arbitrary rules--it was directed to practical ends, to the +harmonizing of the feelings, and the elevation of society. As a man of +the world, he was not carried away by fancies, nor given to exaggerated +views; and as a companion of the great, he was not inclined to inveigh +bitterly against the degeneracy of the times. On the contrary, so kindly +were his feelings, that he tells us that we should overlook the vices of +our friends. His teaching, both in spirit and range, was broader than +that of his predecessors; his shafts were directed against classes +rather than individuals, and wherever he is more pointed, his object is +not to gratify personal spite, but to make his warning more forcible by +illustration. Moreover, his names are generally unreal. In this way he +attacks Nasidienus on the excessive luxury of the table, and his advice +was applicable not only to the rich and great, but to more ordinary men. +Thus, he shows the bad tendencies of avarice and love-intrigues, and the +meanness of sycophantism and legacy-hunting. Many of the faults he +condemns are rather errors in taste than serious moral delinquencies. +Sometimes he criticises merely trivial matters, such as a costume or a +scent. "Rufillus smells all perfumes, Gorgonius like a goat," and the +most humorous of his pieces is that in which he ridicules the ignorance +and impudence of a manoeuvring chatterer. But in this line he is not +very successful, and his contests of rival jesters are as much beneath +the notice of any good writer of the present day, as his account is of +Porcius, the jack-pudding "swallowing cakes whole." + +Horace says that men are more impervious to slashing reproach than to +fine ridicule, and he was unusually adroit in hitting foibles without +inflicting pain. He was not a man who held strong opinions on subjects. +This is especially evident where he speaks of his own fickleness; and +while he reiterates his dislike of Rome, with its noise and bustle, he +makes his slave say that this is but affectation, and when an invitation +comes from Mecænas, "Mulvius and the 'scurræ' are turned out," from +which we learn that parasites had their parasites, and that Horace in +the country played the patron to the rustic wits. + +Although the Romans generally have no claim to be called a humorous +people, many of them became celebrated for their talent in repartee. +Scipio Africanus Æmilianus above mentioned, was remarkable in this way, +as was Crassus, Granius, Vargula, and others. There was a good old joke +that Nasica having called at the house of the poet Ennius, and the +maid-servant having told him that Ennius was not at home, he perceived +she had said so by her master's order; and when, a few days afterwards, +Ennius called at Nasica's house, and inquired for him, Nasica cried out +that he was "not at home." "What!" says Ennius, "do I not know your +voice?" "You are an impudent fellow," replied Nasica, "I believed your +servant when she said you were not at home, and you will not believe +me." + +A vein of humour seems to have run through the Cæsar family. Caius +Julius Cæsar Strabo Vopiscus was so noted for the gift that Cicero in +his work on Oratory makes him deliver his observations on the subject. +Julius Cæsar himself was as remarkable for pleasantry as for clemency. +His "Veni, vidi, vici," in which his enemies saw so much arrogance, was +no doubt intended and understood by his friends to be humorous. In his +youth he was accused of effeminate habits, and when on his obtaining the +entire command of Gaul, he said that he would now make his enemies his +suppliants, and a senator replied sarcastically, "That will not be an +easy task for a woman." He rejoined with gaiety, "Semiramis reigned in +Assyria, and the Amazons possessed a great part of Asia." We have +already seen him lamenting over the loss of comic force in Terence as +compared with Menander, and in the triumphal games given in his honour +in the year 45, he commanded Decimus Laberius, though a man of sixty, to +appear on the stage in the contest of wit. This knight was a composer of +mimes--a light kind of comedy, somewhat to be compared to the +"entertainments" given by humorists at the present day. Julius Cæsar +obliged him to perform in person--an act of degradation--but afterwards +gave him 500,000 sesterces, and restored him to his rank. This act of +Cæsar's has been regarded as having a political significance, but it may +merely have shown his love of humour. He may have wished to bring out +the talent of the new mime, Publius, a young Syrian, who had acquired +great celebrity both for beauty and wit. It is said that when his master +first took Publius to see his patron, the latter observed one of his +slaves, who was dropsical, lying in the sunshine, and asking him angrily +what he was doing there, Publius answered for him "Warming water." On +the same visit, in jesting after supper, the question was asked, "What +is a disagreeable repose?" When many had attempted answers, Publius +replied, "That of gouty feet." + +Some of the sayings of Publius, have been preserved. + +"He receives a benefit who gives to a worthy person." + +"He to whom more than is just is allowed, wishes for more than he gets." + +"A man who talks well on the road is as good as a carriage." + +"He unjustly accuses Neptune who is ship-wrecked twice." + +"By overlooking an old injury you invite a new one." + +These sayings are of a worldly-wise and proverbial character, and, +therefore, as has been already observed, although not actually humorous, +are easily capable of being so regarded. + +Cæsar awarded the prize to Publius instead of Laberius, because, as it +is supposed, of some reflections the latter made upon him. But it may +have been that Cæsar was right, and Publius' wit was the most salient. + +Scarcely any specimens remain of Laberius' talent. Aulus Gellius says +that he coined many strange words, and he seems to have made +considerable use of alliteration. + +We may suppose that the humour of Cicero was somewhat hereditary, for he +records a saying of his grandfather that "the men of our time are like +Syrian slaves; the more Greek they know, the greater knaves they are!" +It is fortunate the grandson inherited the old man's wit without his +plebeian prejudices, and became as celebrated for his culture as for his +readiness. In his work entitled "The Orator," he commends humour as a +means of gaining influence, and a vehicle for moral instruction. +"Orators," he says, "joke with an object, not to appear jesters, but to +obtain some advantage." But we may feel sure he did not keep this dry +and profitable end always in view, for he wrote a jest-book, and was +nick-named by his enemies "Scurra Consularis,"[21] the consular buffoon. + +A man can scarcely have a talent for humour without being conscious of +its fascination, and being sometimes led away by it--as Cicero says, "it +pleases the listeners"--but he need not therefore descend to buffoonery. +We should not be inclined to accuse a man of that, who tells us that "a +regard to proper times, moderation and forbearance in jesting, and a +limitation in the number of jokes, will distinguish the orator from the +buffoon;" who says that "indelicacy is a disgrace, not only to the +forum, but to any company of well-bred people," and that neither great +vice nor great misery is a subject for ridicule. From all this we may +gather that Cicero was full of graceful and clever jocosity, but did not +indulge in what was vapid and objectionable. Both by precept and +practice he approved good verbal humour. The better class of puns was +used in the literature of the time, as we find by St. Paul and others, +not in levity, but merely as embellishments.[22] + +Cicero replied to Vibius Curius, who was telling a falsehood about his +age: "Then when we declaimed at the schools together, you were not +born;" and to Fabia, Dolabella's wife, who said she was thirty, "No +doubt, for I have heard you say so twenty years." When he saw Lentulus, +his cousin--a little man girt with a big sword: "Who," he asked, "has +fastened my cousin to that sword?" and on being shown a colossal bust of +his brother, who was also small, he exclaimed, "The half of my brother +is greater than the whole." One day Cicero had supped with Damasippus, +and his host had said--putting some inferior wine before him--"Drink +this Falernian, it is forty years old!" "It bears its age well," replied +Cicero. + +We have a most interesting collection of good sayings in "The Orator," +which although not spoken by Cicero himself, were those which he had +from time to time noticed, and probably jotted down. Here is one of +Cæsar's (Strabo). A Sicilian, when a friend made lamentation to him that +his wife had hanged herself upon a fig tree: "I beseech you," he said, +"give me some shoots of that tree that I may plant them." Some one asked +Crassus whether he should be troublesome if he came to him before it was +light. Crassus said, "You will not." The other rejoined, "You will order +yourself to be awakened then." To which Crassus replied, "Surely, I said +that you would not be troublesome." + +To return to the Cæsars. The humorous vein which we have traced in the +family descended to Augustus--the great nephew of Julius. Some of his +sayings, which have survived, show him to have been as pleasant in his +wit as he was proverbially happy in his fortunes. + +When the inhabitants of Tarraco made him a fulsome speech, telling him +that they had raised an altar to him as their presiding deity, and that, +marvellous to relate, a splendid palm tree had grown up on it: "That +shows," replied the Emperor, "how often you kindle a fire there." To +Galba, a hunchback orator, who was pleading before him, and frequently +saying, "Set me right, if I am wrong," he replied, "I can easily correct +you, but I cannot set you right." + +The following will give a slight idea of the variety of his humour. + +When he heard that, among the children under two years old whom Herod +had ordered to be slain, his own son had been killed, he said, "It is +better to be Herod's pig than his son." Being entertained on one +occasion with a very poor dinner, and without any ceremony, as he was +passing out he whispered in the ear of his host, "I did not know that I +was such a friend of yours." A Roman knight having died enormously in +debt, Augustus ordered them to buy him his bed-pillow at the auction, +observing: "The pillow of a man who could sleep when he owed so much +must be truly soporific." A man who had been removed from a cavalry +command and asked for an allowance, "not from any mercenary motive, but +that I may seem to have resigned upon obtaining the grant from you," he +dismissed with the words: "Tell everybody you have received it. I will +not deny it." + +Augustus kept a jester, Gabba, and patronised mimes, and among other +diversions with which he amused himself and his friends, was that of +giving presents by lottery; each drew a ticket upon which something was +named, but on applying for the article a totally different thing was +received, answering to a second meaning of the name. This occasioned +great merriment, a man who thought he was to get a grand present was +given a little sponge, or rake, or a pair of pincers; another who seemed +to have no claim whatever, obtained something very valuable. The humour +was not great, but a little refreshing distraction was thus obtained +from the cares of state. There is no loss in light literature so much to +be deplored as that of the correspondence between Augustus and Mecænas. +The latter prided himself upon his skill in poetry and humour, and we +may be sure that he sent some of his choicest productions to Augustus, +who in turn exerted himself to send something worthy of the eye of so +celebrated a critic. It is not impossible that the Emperor showed +himself equal, if not superior to the friend of Horace. + +Those who succeeded to the imperial purple proved very different from +their illustrious predecessor, and in Persius the severity of Roman +satire re-appears. We could scarcely expect a man who lived under Nero, +and after the reigns of Tiberius, Caligula, and Claudius to write with +the mild placidity of the Augustan poet. Moreover, the satires of +Persius were written at an early age--twenty-eight, and youth always +feels acutely, and expresses strongly. Some of his attacks are evidently +aimed at Nero, but his principal object is to denounce the vices of the +times. Hence, indolence and prurient literature are stigmatised. He +ridicules the extremes of extravagance, and of that parsimony by which +it is usually accompanied. "Am I on a festive day to have a nettle +dressed for me, and a smoked pig's cheek with a hole in its ear, in +order that that grandson of yours may be surfeited with goose liver, and +indulge in patrician amours. Am I to be a living anatomy that his pope's +stomach may shake with fat."[23] Alluding to the absurdity of the +prayers generally offered up, he uses language worthy of a Christian. +"You ask for vigour, but rich dishes and fat sausages prevent the gods +from granting your behest. You ask what your fleshly mind suggests. What +avails gold in sacrifice? Offer justice to God and man--generous honour, +and a soul free from pollution." + +In Persius we miss the light geniality of Horace and the pure language +of the Augustan age, but we mark the complexity and finesse of a later +date, a form of thought bespeaking a comprehensive grasp, and suitable +to subtle minds. But as regards his humour it depends much on +exaggeration, and is proportionably weak, and beyond this we have little +but the coining of some words,[24] the using others in unaccustomed +senses, and a large seasoning of severity. He evidently aimed rather at +being corrective than amusing, and his covert attacks upon Nero were, no +doubt, well understood. Humour of a poor kind was evidently fashionable +at the day--the Emperor himself wrote Satires and was so fond of comic +performances that he first encouraged and rewarded a celebrated +pantomimic actor named Paris, and then put him to death for being his +rival in the mimetic art. Even Seneca could not resist the example of +his contemporaries, and we find the sedate philosopher attacking his +enemy with severe ridicule. Claudius had him sent into exile for eight +years to the picturesque but lonely Island of Corsica; and Seneca who +liked something more social and luxurious, held him up in a satire +bordering upon lampoon. The fanciful production was called the +Apolokokyntosis of Claudius; that is his apotheosis, except that, +instead of the Emperor being deified, he is supposed to be +"gourdified," changed not into a god, but into a pumpkin. Seneca, after +deriding Claudius' bodily defects, accuses him of committing many +atrocities, and finally sends him down from heaven to the nether world, +where a new punishment is invented for him--he is to be always trying to +throw dice out of an empty box. + +One of the most remarkable characters in the reign of Nero was Titus +Petronius Arbiter. He was a great favourite with the Emperor, and held +some official appointment--the duties of which he is said to have +discharged with ability. In his writings he is supposed to condemn +immorality, but he enlarges so much upon what he disapproves that we +doubt whether he does not promote the vice he pretends to condemn.[25] +His "Satyricon" is not intended to be a satire, but an imitation of one +of those old Greek comedies which treated of the doings of Satyrs and +grotesque country deities. It is the first comic prose work, for in +early times verse was thought as necessary to humour as to poetry. The +whole work is enveloped in a voluptuous atmosphere; it is written in a +gay roystering style, but although the indelicacy is great the humour +is small. Occasionally it is interesting, as giving an insight into +private life in the days of Nero. Here we find Trimalchio, a rich man, +providing for the amusement of his guests, as well as for their +sumptuous entertainment. One dish was a wild boar, which was placed on +the table with a cap of liberty on its head. Petronius asked the meaning +of this. "Why," said he, "your servant could explain that, it is no +riddle. This boar escaped from yesterday's dinner where it was dismissed +by the guests, and he now returns to table as a freedman." Afterwards a +much larger hog was brought in. "What!" cried Trimalchio, looking +closely at it, "is not his inside taken out? No! it is not; call the +cook, call the cook." The cook being brought in, excused himself saying +that he forgot. "Forgot!" cried Trimalchio, "why, he talks as if it were +only a pinch of pepper omitted. Strip him." In a moment the cook was +stripped to be flogged. All interceded for him, but Petronius felt +somewhat indignant at such an oversight, and said he must be a careless +rascal to forget to disembowel a hog. Trimalchio with a pleasant look +said, "Come, you with the short memory, see if you can bowel him before +us." The cook slashed with his knife, and out tumbled a load of puddings +and sausages. All the servants raised a shout, and the cook was +presented with a cup of wine, and a silver crown. + +Petronius shared the fate of Seneca. He was suspected of conspiring +against the Emperor, and his life being demanded, he preferred to suffer +by his own hand rather than by that of the executioner. He caused his +veins to be opened, but strangely whimsical to the last, and wishing to +die slowly, he had them closed at intervals. In his dying state he was +daily carried about the streets of Cumæ, and received his friends, made +love verses and humorous epigrams, and endeavoured to withdraw his +thoughts from the sad reality by indulging in all kinds of amusing +caprices. At length he expired--another distinguished victim of Nero's +cruelty. + +Juvenal, who wrote under Domitian, a little later than Persius, equalled +him in severity--due either to his natural disposition or to the +spectacle presented by the ever increasing demoralization of Rome. Like +Persius, he makes use of much metaphor and involution in his +works--showing the literary taste and intellectual acumen of a settled +state of society, but an early age is impressed upon his pages in the +indelicacy with which he is frequently chargeable. His depiction of +guilt was appreciated at that day, but under the Christian dispensation +vice is thought too sinful, and in a highly civilised state too +injurious to be laughable. The views then held were different, and +Tacitus considered it a mark of great superiority in the Germans that +they did not laugh at crimes. Juvenal tells us that the Romans jeered at +poverty. There was much in the character of this satirist to raise him +in the estimation of right-minded men. His tastes were simple, he loved +the country and its homely fare, and although devoid of ambition, was +highly cultivated. No doubt he was rather austere than genial: his aim +was to instruct and warn rather than amuse; and where he approaches +humour it is merely from complexity of style, in coining words and +barbarisms, or in comparisons mostly dependent upon exaggeration. The +following is one of his best specimens, though over-weighted with +severity. It gives an idea of the state of Rome at the time. A drunken +magnate and his retinue stop a citizen in the street, and insolently +demand-- + +"With whose vinegar and beans are you blown out? What cobbler has been +eating leeks and sheepshead with you? Answer, or be kicked." "This," +says Juvenal "is a poor man's liberty. When pummelled, he begs that he +may be allowed to escape with a few of his teeth remaining." + +Juvenal longs for the sword of Lucilius, and the lamp of Horace, that +he may attack the vices of Rome, but he himself is more severe than +either. Forgers, gamblers and profligates are assailed, and names are +frequently given, though we often cannot now decide whether they +belonged to real persons. Laughing at those who desire length of years +without remembering the concomitant infirmities of age, he says: + +"All kinds of disease dance around the aged in a troop, of which if you +were to ask the names I could sooner tell you how many lovers Hippia +had, how many patients Themison killed in one autumn, or how many allies +Basilus and Hirrus defrauded." He condemns the increased desire for +luxury. "Do not," he warns, "long for a mullet, when you have only a +gudgeon in your purse." The rule of the day was to purchase sensual +indulgence at any cost, "Greediness is so great that they will not even +invite a parasite." Excessive selfishness leads to every kind of +dishonesty. "A man of probity is as rare as a mule's foal, or as a +shower of stones from a cloud." "What day is so sacred that it fails to +produce thieving, perfidy, fraud, gain sought through every crime, and +money acquired by bowl and dagger. The good are so scarce that their +number is barely as great as that of the gates of Thebes, or the mouths +of the fertilizing Nile." + +He attacks every kind of social abuse, and does not even spare the +ladies--some are too fast, some are learned and pedantic, some cruel to +their slaves--even scourging them with cowhides. "What fault," he +asks, "has the girl committed, if your own nose has displeased you?" As +to religion, that has disappeared altogether. "What a laugh your +simplicity would raise in public, if you were to require of anyone that +he should not perjure himself, but believe that there was some deity in +the temple, or at the ensanguined altar! That the souls of the departed +are anything, and the realms below, and the punt-pole and frogs of the +Stygian pool, and that so many thousands pass over in one boat, not even +the boys believe, except those who are too young to pay for their bath." + +The language used in the last passage is no doubt an example of the +profane manner in which some men spoke at that day, but in general, we +must remember that these pictures are humorous and overdrawn. Still, +some of the offences spoken of with horror by Juvenal were treated +almost as lightly by contemporary poets as they had been by +Aristophanes. + +There is a slightly foreign complexion about the productions of Martial, +which reminds us that he was a Spaniard. Even at this time there seems +to have been a sparkle and richness in the thoughts that budded in that +sunny clime. Martial was a contemporary of Juvenal, and addressed two or +three of his epigrams to him. His works consisted of fourteen books, +containing altogether more than fifteen hundred of these short poems. + +The appearance of such works may be taken as indicative of the condition +of Rome at the time. The calls of business had become more urgent from +the increase of the population and development of commerce, while the +unsatisfactory state of the Government and of foreign affairs kept men's +minds in agitation and suspense. Martial himself observes that those +were no times for poems of any length, and that some of his friends +would not even read his longer pieces, though they never exceeded thirty +lines. The period demanded something light and short--a book which could +be taken up and laid down without any interruption of the narrative. But +the swifter current of affairs had also produced a keener or more active +turn of mind, so that it was necessary not only to be short, but also +pithy. It was not necessary to be humorous, but it was essential to be +concise and interesting, and thus Martial gave to the epigram that +character for point which it has since maintained. + +Nothing could be more attractive than allusions to contemporary men, +passing scenes, or novelties of the day, and when we read his works we +seem to be transported by magic into the streets and houses of ancient +Rome. On one page we have the sanguinary scenes of the circus; in +another we see the ladies waving their purple fans, and hear them +toasted in as many glasses as they have letters to their names. + +From this kind of gaiety Martial graduates into another--that of +pleasantry. In an epitaph on his barber, he bids the earth lie light +upon him, adding, "It could not be lighter than his artistic hand." From +his censure of bad wit, it is evident that he drew great distinctions +between broad and subtle humour. "Every man," he says, "has not a +_nose_," _i.e._, a keen perception--cannot smell a fault. He is very +seldom guilty of a pun, and says in one place that he has not adopted +verbal tricks, imitating echoes, or making lines which can be read +backwards or forwards.[26] Nor has he any intention to indulge in bitter +reflections; he says,-- + +"My page injures not those it hates, and no reputation obtained at the +expense of another is pleasing to me. Some versifiers wish publications +which are but darts dipped in the blood of Lycambus to be mine, and +vomit forth the poison of vipers under my name. My sport is harmless." + +But he well saw that some little severity was necessary for humour, for +he chides a dull poet: + +"Although the epigrams which you write are always sweetness itself, and +more spotless than a white-leaded skin, and although there is in them +neither an atom of salt, nor a drop of bitter gall, yet you expect, +foolish man, that they will be read. Why, not even food is pleasant if +wholly destitute of acid seasoning, nor is a face pleasing which shows +no dimples. Give children your honey, apples, and luscious figs--the +Chian fig, which has sharpness, pleases my taste." + +Following this view we find him often sarcastic, but not personal, the +names being fictitious, or if not, those of well known public men. In a +few instances he is a little ill-natured, and writes, "Laugh, if thou +art wise, girl, laugh, said Ovid, but he did not say this to all girls, +not, for instance, to Maximina, who has only three teeth, and those the +colour of pitch and boxwood. Avoid the pantomimes of Philistion and gay +feasts. It befits you to sit beside an afflicted mother, and a wife +lamenting her husband. Weep, if thou art wise, girl, weep." + +Martial often uses the figure called by the Greek grammarians "contrary +to expectation." The point of the whole epigram lies in the last word or +line, which changes the drift of the whole. + + "His funeral pile was strewn with reed, + His tearful wife brought fragrant myrrh, + The bier, the grave, the ointment were prepared, + He named me as his heir, and he--got well." + + "Sorry is Athenagoras not to send the gifts, + Which in mid-winter he is wont to send; + Whether he be sorry I shall shortly see, + But sorry he has certainly made me." + + "You feast so often without me, Lupercus, + I've found a way by which to pay you out, + I am incensed, and if you should invite me, + What would I do, you ask me? Why--I'd come." + +The growing appreciation of this kind of writing had already led +Meleager, a cynic philosopher of Gadara, to form the first collection of +Greek epigrams, which he prettily termed the anthology or bouquet. +Martial has been commended at the expense of the Greeks, but he borrowed +considerably from them in form and matter. His epigrams were more +uniformly suggestive and concentrated than those of any previous writer, +and he largely contributed to raise such compositions from being merely +inscriptive into a branch of literature. He opened a new field, and the +larger portion of these productions in Greek were written about this +time. They are not generally humorous, with the exception of a few from +Philo and Leonidas of Alexandria who lived about 60 B.C., from +Ammianus in 120 B.C., and from Lucilius, a great composer of +this kind, of whose history nothing is known but that he lived in the +reign of Nero. The following are from the last-mentioned. + +"Some say, Nicylla, that thou dyest thy hair, which thou boughtest most +black at the market." + +"All the astrologers prophesied that my uncle would be long-lived except +Hermocleides, who said he would not be so. This, however, was not until +we were lamenting his death." + +The following are free translations from the same writer. + + "Poor Cleon out of envy died, + His brother thief to see + Nailed near him to be crucified + Upon a higher tree." + +On a bad painter. + + "You paint Deucalion and Phaeton, + And ask what price for each you should require; + I'll tell you what they're worth before you've done, + One deserves water, and the other fire." + +The works of Lucian are generally regarded as forming a part of Roman +literature, although they were written in Greek by a native of Samosata +in Syria. In them we have an intermingling of the warm imagination of +the East with the cold sceptical philosophy of the West. Lucian was +originally brought up to be a stone-cutter, but he had an insatiable +desire for learning, and in his "Dream" he tells us how he seemed to be +carried aloft on the wings of Pegasus. He became a pleader at the bar, +but soon found that "deceit, lies, impudence, and chicanery" were +inseparable from that profession. In disgust he betook himself to +philosophy, but could not restrain his indignation when he found so many +base men throwing the blame of their conduct on Plato, Chrysippus, +Pythagoras, and other great men. "A fellow who tells you that the wise +man alone is rich, comes the next moment and asks you for money--just as +if a person in regal array should go about begging." He says they pay no +more attention to the doctrines they teach than if their words were +tennis balls to play with in schools. "There is," he continues, "a story +told of a certain king of Egypt, who took a fancy to have apes taught to +dance. The apes, as they are apt to mimic human actions, came on in +their lessons and improved very fast, and were soon fit to appear on the +public stage, and display their skill, dressed in purple robes, with +masks on their faces. The spectators were much pleased with them for a +considerable time, when a wag who was present, having brought with him a +quantity of nuts, threw a handful amongst them. The dance was +immediately forgotten, and the performers from pyrrhic dancers, relapsed +into apes, who went chattering and snapping at one another, and fighting +for nuts; so that in a few moments the masks were crumpled, the clothes +torn to rags, and the ape dance, which had been so much extolled, +terminated amidst peals of laughter. Such is the history of mock +philosophers." + +The above story may serve to exhibit Lucian's views, and his love of +humorous illustration. He indulges in many fancies, such as the +complaint of the letter S against T, which had in Attic been substituted +for it. + +Another kind of pleasantry which he brings forward is interesting, +inasmuch as after having been in fashion among the grammarians, and +reviving among the monks in the middle ages it has now fallen entirely +out of use. It may be regarded as being a kind of continuation of the +philosophical "hard questions" of ancient times, originated with the +Sophists, and was entirely confined to logical subtleties affording +diversion, but not awakening any emotion sufficient to cause laughter. +Lucian makes a parasite ask his host after dinner to solve such riddles +as "The Sorites and the Reaper," and the "Horned Syllogism." The latter +proposition was, "What you have not lost that you still have. You have +not lost horns, therefore you have horns." In "The Sale of the +Philosophers," in which Jupiter puts them all up to auction to see what +will be bid for them, Chrysippus gives some similar examples. "A stone +is a substance, is it not?" "Certainly." "A living being is also a +substance." "Yes." "And you are a living being--therefore you are a +stone." Chrysippus then offers to turn him back into a man. "Is every +substance a living being?" "No." "Is a stone a living being?" "No." "But +you are a substance?" "Yes." "And a living being; then, although you are +a substance you are not a stone, because you are a living being." + +Lucian's crusade against vice is of so general a kind as to remind us +more of some of the old philosophers than of the Roman satirists. At the +same time he says he has only spoken against impostors, and is only the +enemy of false pretence, quackery, lies, and puffing. But we may suppose +that he would not be sparing of his lash in any direction, for in the +"Resuscitated Philosophers," he observes, "Philosophy says that +ridicule can never make anything worse than it is in itself, and +whatever is beautiful and good comes out with more lustre from it, and, +like gold, is rendered splendid by the strokes of the hammer." + +Following this view, he makes pretty sport of the parasites, whom he +represents as forming a large and educated class. Patroclus he counts as +Achilles' parasite, and includes several philosophers, who, he says, +sponged upon Dionysius of Syracuse, "but Plato failed in the art." He +commends them in merry irony, and describes the parasite as stout and +robust--bold, with an eye full of fire and spirit. Who could venture a +bet against a parasite, whether in jesting or feasting? Who could +contribute more to the diversion of the company? A parasite is obliged +to be strict in his conduct. He has an annual salary, but is always +beaten down in it. He does not receive the same food as the chief +people, and in travelling he is put with the servants. Jokes are made at +his expense by the company, and when he receives a present of his +patron's old clothes, he has to fee the servants for them. Of +philosophers, some are poisoned, some are burned alive. None ever tell +of a parasite who came to such an end--he dies gently and sweetly, +amidst loaded dishes and flowing bowls, and should one of them come to +a violent death, it is merely from indigestion. The parasite does honour +to the rich man--not the rich man to the parasite. + +Lucian's "True History" deserves especial notice as having been the +first extravagant story written under the form of a circumstantial +narration of travels. It was the precursor of "The Voyage to the Moon," +Baron Münchausen, and various Utopias. We must therefore allow it the +merit of originality, and it evinces talent, for mere exaggeration would +not be entertaining. The intention was to ridicule the marvellous +travellers' stories then current. Much of this history is merely florid, +and we may compare it to a waving line, in which the fable is constantly +undulating between humour and poetry. + +Lucian says he is going to write about what never can be. He sets sail +on a voyage of discovery for the Western Ocean, and reaches a beautiful +island. There they find a river of wine, navigable in many places. He +could not trace the source of it, but near the place where it seemed to +rise, were several vines full of grapes, and at the root of every one +wine flowed out. They found fish in the stream, and after eating some, +felt intoxicated; when they cut them up, they found grape-stones in +them. Passing the river, they found a most wonderful species of vine; +the lower parts, which touched the ground, were green and thick, the +upper formed the most beautiful women, from the top of whose fingers +branches sprang forth full of grapes; and on their heads, instead of +hair, they had leaves and tendrils. Two of his companions, going up to +embrace them, became so entangled that they could not again disengage +themselves. After this, they left the island, and were caught in such a +violent storm that the vessel was lifted out of the water, so high that +it could not come down again. Then they came to another island, round +and shining. Here they found Hippogypi, men riding upon vultures--birds +so large that each of their feathers was like the mast of a ship. The +voyagers join the Hippogypi in a battle against the inhabitants of the +sun, and have various allies--some mounted on fleas about the size of +twelve elephants, and spiders, each as big as one of the Cyclades +islands. The travellers were taken prisoners, and conveyed to the Sun, +but he returned to the Moon, of which he gives a description. The +inhabitants there make use of their stomachs--which are empty and lined +with hair--as bags or pockets to put away things. They take their eyes +in and out, and borrow them. "Whoever does not believe me, had better +go and see." Returning from the air to the earth and sea, they saw +several enormous whales, one of whom swam up to them with its mouth wide +open. Coming near he swallowed them up--ship and all. It was dark +inside, until he opened his mouth again. There was a large extent of +land inside, and hills and woods, in which birds were building nests. + +From this last fancy, we might conclude that Lucian had read the Book of +Jonah, and a description he afterwards gives of the Isles of the +Blessed, seems to be written in imitation of the Revelation. + +The age in which Lucian lived was marked by theological contests between +Pagans, Jews, and Christians, and such times have generally caused an +increase of scepticism and profanity. Lucian was a follower of +Democritus, and his Confabulations consist of a succession of squibs and +satires on the mythological legends of the gods and goddesses. He laughs +at curing diseases by charms and incantations. People pretended to fly, +walk on water and through fire--they are called Babylonians and +Hyperboreans. A Syrian from Palestine professes to drive devils out of +people (perhaps alluding to the exorcists of the early church.) He makes +Eucrates speak of one Pancrates, who would take a broom or the pestle of +a wooden mortar, and upon saying a couple of magical words, it appeared +to become a man, drew water, and ordered food. When Pancrates had no +further need of him, he spoke a couple of words, and the man was a +pestle again. Eucrates tried this himself, but having made the pestle a +man, and told him to bring water, he forgot how to change him back +again. So he kept on bringing water. Eucrates then split the pestle in +two, and both halves still continued to bring water. + +Demonax, the friend of Lucian, was as remarkable for his wit and +repartee as for his kindly nature. A man who over-rated his austerity, +expressed one day his surprise at seeing him eat sweet-cakes. "Do you +think," he replied, "that the bees make their honey only for fools?" He +seems to have had as little respect as Lucian for the idolatry of his +day, for on one of his companions saying to him "Let us go to the Temple +of Æsculapius to pray for my son," he answered, "Is the god then so deaf +that he cannot hear us where we are?" + +He lived and died a bachelor, and we are told that on being blamed by +Epictetus, with whom he studied, for not marrying and having a family as +a philosopher should, he replied "Very well, give me one of your +daughters." Epictetus was an old bachelor. + +He counselled a bad orator to practise and exercise himself in the art +of speaking, and on his replying, "I am always doing so--to myself," he +added, "It is therefore not surprising you speak as you do--having a +fool for your audience." + +When the sophist Sidonius, delivering a long panegyric on himself, said +that he was acquainted with all the tenets of the philosophers: "If +Aristotle calls me to the Lyceum, I obey; if Plato to the Academy, I +come; Zeno to the Stoa, I take up my abode there; if Pythagoras calls, I +am silent:" Demonax jumped up in the middle of the Assembly and cried +out, "Pythagoras calls you." + +His humour was purely genial and jocose, as when, on the point of +setting sail in winter, he replied to a friend who asked him whether he +was not afraid he should be ship-wrecked and go to feed the fishes, +"Should I not be ungrateful were I unwilling to be devoured by fishes, +when I have feasted on so many myself?" + +But there is one speech of his which must ever make his memory dear to +all good men. When the Athenians wished to emulate the Corinthians by +exhibiting a gladiatorial combat, he said, "Do not vote this, Athenians, +before ye have taken down the Altar of Mercy." + +Demonax lived to a ripe old age, and we are told that he was so much +beloved in Athens that, as he passed the bread-shops, the bakers would +run out to beg his acceptance of a loaf, and thought it a good omen if +he complied; and that the little children called him father, and would +bring him presents of fruit. + +Apuleius wrote in Latin in the second century. He was a native of +Carthage--not the celebrated Carthage of Terence, but that of Cyprian--a +new city. He travelled like many of the learned men of his time to +Athens and Alexandria, and thus, most probably, became acquainted with +his contemporary Lucian. At any rate, his "Golden Ass" seems taken from +the work by that author. Bishop Warburton has seen in his production a +subtle attack upon Christianity, but we may take it as intended to +ridicule magical arts, and those who believed in them. He was likely to +feel keenly on this subject, for having married a rich widow, +Pudentilla, her relatives accused him of having obtained her by +witchcraft, and even dragged him into a court of justice. + +Lucian ridiculed the religion of his day, Apuleius its superstitions. +Apuleius speaks of his "book of jests," but it is lost--the few lines he +gives out of it are a somewhat matter-of-fact recommendation of +tooth-powder. His enemies thought that tooth-powder was something +magical and unholy--at any rate, they made his mention of it a charge +against him. In reply, he says that perhaps a man who only opens his +mouth to revile ought not to have tooth-powder. + +In the "Golden Ass," Apuleius gravely supposes that transformations take +place between men and the lower animals. He makes Aristomenes tell a +story in which a witch appears, "able to drag down the firmament, to +support the world on her shoulders, crumble mountains, raise the dead, +dethrone gods, extinguish the stars, and illuminate hell." She changed +one of her lovers, of whom she was jealous, into a beaver, and +persecuted him with hunters. She punished the wife of another of them, +who was about to increase her family, by condemning her to remain in +that condition. "It is now eight years since she has been growing larger +and larger, and seems as though about to produce an elephant." + +Lucius goes to Thessaly, celebrated for its witches, and a good story is +told how returning late from supper he finds three men battering against +his door. Taking them for robbers he draws his dagger, and stabs them, +and the ground is covered with blood. Next day he is tried for murder, +and about to be crucified, when the corpses are brought into court, and +are found to be three wine-skins. He is told that this was a trick +played on him upon the day when they usually celebrated the festival of +the god of laughter, but it seems to have been really owing to an +incantation. He sees Pamphile, his hostess, change herself into an owl, +thinks he also will transform himself into a bird, and anoints himself +with some of the witch's preparations. By mistake, taking the wrong +ointment, he transforms himself into a donkey. He then goes to look for +his horse, who, thinking he is coming to eat his food, kicks him out, +and soon afterwards he is well thrashed by his servant boy. He is told +that eating fresh roses will restore him to his former self, but for +various reasons he cannot get any. Being hungry he goes into a kitchen +garden, and makes a good meal of the vegetables, for which transgression +he is nearly killed by the gardener. To prevent this he kicks the man +over, whereupon a general outcry was raised, and great dogs rush upon +him. After this persecution he is in danger of dying of +starvation--"spiders began to spin their webs on his lips," but becoming +instrumental in saving a young girl, he receives better treatment. He is +then bought by vagrants, who go about playing cymbals, and carrying an +image of the Syrian goddess. He is accompanied by a troop of fanatical +priests, who dance and scourge themselves. While the priests are being +royally entertained by one of their votaries, a dog runs off with a +haunch of venison, and the cook, not knowing what to do, conceives the +project of killing the ass, and dressing one of his haunches instead. To +avoid this the donkey breaks loose, and gallops into the supper room. +After the band of priests is dispersed, owing to their thieving +propensities, the donkey is sold to a baker, and by him to a gardener, +and nearly dies of cold and exposure. Then he becomes the property of +the servants of a very rich man, and is found eating up the remains of +their supper. This greatly amuses them all, and their lord orders him to +be brought to his table. A buffoon, or parasite, who sat among the +guests, exclaims "Give him a cup of wine," and he was taught various +tricks. His fame increases so that his master only admits people to see +him on payment. Finally being taken to the circus, and afraid that some +of the wild beasts might eat him by mistake, he slips away and gallops +to Cenchroea, where he prays to the goddess Iris, and is by her +restored to his human form. The descriptions in this work are often very +beautiful, and the humour in describing the misfortunes of the ass is +excellent. + +In contrast to the humour of Lucian and Apuleius, we may place that of +the Emperor Julian, an ascetic and devotee, who was nephew of +Constantine the Great, and brought up a Christian. Julian's early life +was spent in terror, for Constantius, Constantine's son, imprisoned him +at Milan, after having put his elder brother to death. Perhaps this +treatment at the hands of a Christian may have prejudiced him against +the new religion, or his mild disposition may have been scandalized at +the fierceness of theological controversies, or at the lives of many of +the converts. His early education and experiences of life were more +inclined to imbue him with principles of toleration than to make him a +zealous Christian, and, finally, when he arrived at the age of twenty, +he determined to return back into Paganism. This retrograde movement, +not altogether out of keeping with his quaint character and love of +antiquity, has stamped him with the opprobrious title of the "Apostate," +but in moral excellence he was superior to the age in which he lived. +Many of his writings show a sense of humour, such as that he wrote in +Lutetia (Paris) on "Barley wine" the drink of the Gauls. + + "Who and whence art thou, Dionyse? for, by true Bacchus + I know thee not, but Jove's great son alone, + He smells of nectar, thou of goats, truly the Celts + For want of grapes made thee of ears of corn; + Wherefore thou shouldst be Cereal called, not Bacchus, + Pyrogenes and Bromos, not Bromion."[27] + +Julian's principal work is on the Cæsars. He commences it by saying that +he is not addicted to jesting, but he will relate a sort of fable in +which all the gods and Cæsars are called to a great banquet. +Accordingly, he introduces various characters. Julius Cæsar seems in his +pride to wish to dispute the throne even with Jupiter. Augustus he +compares to a chameleon, sometimes one colour, sometimes another; one +moment a visage full of sorrow, another smiling. + +Tiberius has a fierce countenance, and shows the marks of intemperance +and debauchery. "Take care he does not pull your ear," says Bacchus, +"for thus he treated a grammarian." "He had better," returned Silenus, +"bemoan himself in his solitary island, and tear the face of some +miserable fisherman."[28] + +Constantine, not finding among the gods any type of his character, +betook himself to the goddess of pleasure. She, receiving him softly and +embracing him, trimmed him up and adorned him, dressed him in a shining +and many-coloured woman's gown, and led him away to demoralization. +With her he found one of his sons, who loudly proclaimed to all, +"Whosoever is a seducer, a murderer, or shameless, let him advance +boldly, for by washing him with water I will immediately make him pure; +and if he should be again guilty of such things, I will grant him to be +pure on striking his breast, or beating his head."[29] At the end of +this "fable," the Emperors are called upon to speak in their defence. +Constantine being asked what object he had in view, replied "to amass +great riches and spend them on myself and friends." Silenus burst into a +fit of laughter, and retorted "You now wish to pass for a banker, but +how can you forget your living like a cook, or a hair-dresser?" alluding +to his luxurious feastings, and his wearing gold-flowered stuffs, and a +diadem of jewels. + +Gibbon calls this work on the Cæsars one of the most agreeable and +instructive productions of ancient wit. + +Julian prided himself on his primitive and severe life, and made himself +ridiculous by wearing a long unfashionable beard--either in imitation of +the Gauls, or of the ancient philosophers. It is probable that he +persisted in this habit to discountenance the effeminacy of the times. +He says that soon after he entered Constantinople, he had occasion to +send for a barber. An officer, magnificently dressed, presented himself. +"It is a barber," said the prince, "that I want, and not a minister of +finance." He questioned the man about his profits, and was informed that +besides a large salary and some valuable perquisites, he enjoyed a daily +allowance of twenty servants and as many horses! Not only was Julian +strongly opposed to luxury, but he was, as far as his light went, a +religious man, and was strict in observing the feasts and festivals of +the heathen deities. All his antiquated peculiarities are brought +strongly before us on the occasion of his visit to Antioch. Strabo tells +us that this was one of the largest cities in the world--little inferior +in extent to Alexandria and Seleucia. It was noted for its gaieties, and +seems now to have been the centre of fashion. The new religion had been, +at least nominally, adopted, and also the new costumes, as well as every +kind of luxury and dissipation. Chrysostom bears witness to the same +effect. The town was full of dancers, pipers, and players, camels +"adorned like brides" stalked through the porticos, and fish and poultry +had come to be considered as necessaries of life. There were here many +people of leisure and cultivation, fond of light and fanciful pursuits, +and among others of forming verbal conceits. Hence, we find that the +disciples were first called _Christians_ at Antioch, no doubt, +derisively,[30] and in Julian's time they had a cant saying that they +had suffered nothing from the X or the K (Christ or Constantius). A +celebrated school of rhetoric was established here, and no doubt some of +the effusions penned at this time, abounded with rich and epigrammatic +humour. + +It must have been a rare sight for these polished and satirical +Christians of Antioch to behold Julian celebrating the festivals of the +pagan gods. To view the procession of Venus--a long line of all the +dissolute women in the town, singing loose songs--followed by the lean, +uncouth Roman Emperor, with his shaggy beard, and terminated by a +military train. No wonder they hooted him, and wrote lampoons upon him. +But Julian thought he was performing a solemn duty; he by no means +intended to countenance immorality. "Far from us," he says, "be all +licentious jests and scurrilous discourse--let no priest read +Archilochus or Hipponax." He gives an amusing account of his reception +at the celebrated grove of Daphnæ, near Antioch, which he visited at +the time of the annual festival. He expected to see a profusion of +wealth and splendour. He pictured to himself the solemn pomp, the +victims, the libations, the dancers, the incense, the children in white +robes. When he entered the temple, full of such elevated thoughts, he +found there neither incense, cake, nor victims. Much surprised, he could +only suppose that the people were waiting at the gate, by way of +respect, for a signal from the sovereign Pontiff. He therefore asked the +priest what offering the city was about to make on this great +anniversary; to which he replied, "The city has furnished nothing, but I +have brought the god a goose from my own house." + +Julian says the people of Antioch had transfixed him with sarcasms, as +with arrows. In accordance, however, with his peaceful disposition, he +only retaliated by writing the Misopogon or "Beard-hater." "No law," he +says, "forbids me to satirise myself." He begins with his face and says, + +"Although naturally good-looking, moroseness and bad manners have led me +to wear a long beard for no apparent reason but that nature has not made +it handsome. Therefore, I allow lice to run about in it like wild beasts +in a wood, nor have I the power of eating or drinking much, for I must +be cautious, lest I eat hairs along with bread. About being kissed, or +kissing, I do not much care; still a beard has this inconvenience among +others, that it does not allow us to join pure lips to those that are +pure, and, therefore, the sweeter. You say that ropes should be twisted +out of it, and I would willingly grant this, if only you were able to +draw out the bristles, so that your soft and delicate hands should not +suffer from their roughness." + +He says that he never goes to the theatre, and hates horse-races. As to +domestic matters, "I pass sleepless nights upon a bed of straw, and +insufficient food makes my manners severe and offensive to a luxurious +city. Do not think that I do this on your account--a great and senseless +mistake has led me from my childhood to wage war with my stomach." He is +not at all surprised that they should follow the dissolute habits of the +founder of their city, Antiochus, and that they think of nothing but +dressing, bathing, and love-making--charges which could not be brought +against himself. He esteems dancers and players "no more than the frogs +of the lakes," and tells a story, that when Cato came into the city of +Antioch, seeing all the young men under arms, and the magistrates in +their robes, he thought the parade was in his honour. He blamed his +friends for having told them he was coming, and advanced with some +hesitation, when the master of the ceremonies came up and asked, +"Stranger, how far off is Demetrius?" a man who had been a slave of +Pompey, but had become immensely rich. Cato made no reply, but +exclaimed, "O, miserable city!" and departed. + +The Misopogon is unique as a mock disparagement of self. Although +written in condemnation of the Antiochians, a vein of pleasantry runs +through it, which shows that Julian was not vindictive, and had a +considerable gift of humour. Had he lived to mature age, he would +probably have left some brilliant literary work. But shortly after his +visit to Antioch, he led an expedition into Persia, and with his usual +disregard of danger, entered the battle without his armour, and was +mortally wounded. + +We read that the Roman girls were very fond of amusing themselves in +their leisure hours by making "scirpi" or riddles. They do not seem to +have indulged much in puns, or to have attempted anything very +intricate, but rather to have aimed at testing knowledge and memory. We +have few specimens remaining of their art, but such as we have are of +that early kind, which demand some special information for their +solutions. Aulus Gellius has preserved one "old by Hercules," which +turns on the legend that when Tarquinius Superbus was installing Jupiter +at the Capitol, all the other gods were ready to leave except Terminus, +who being by his character immovable, and having no legs, refused to +depart.[31] Two other specimens are found in Virgil's bucolics:-- + + "Say in what lands grow flowers inscribed with names + Of kings--and Phyllis shall be yours alone," + +referring to the hyacinth, on whose petals the word Ajax was supposed to +be found. The responding couplet runs:-- + + "Say, and my great Apollo thou shalt be, + Where heaven's span extends but three ells wide;" + +the answer to which is not known. + +Probably some riddles of an earlier date may be incorporated in the book +of Symposius. Nothing is known of the life of this author, and it has +been suggested that the word should be Symposium or the "Banquet"--these +enigmas being supposed to be delivered after dinner. But most +authorities consider Symposius to have lived in the fourth century, +although an examination of his prosody might lead us to place him not +earlier than the fifth. Very few of the riddles are really ingenious; +among the best we may reckon:-- + + "Letters sustain me--yet I know them not, + I live on books, and yet I never read, + The Muses I've devoured and gained no knowledge." + +This is tolerably self-evident, but some require special information +as:-- + + "You can behold what you can scarce believe + There is but one eye, yet a thousand heads, + Who sells what he has, whence shall he get what he has not?" + +Few would ever guess that this referred to a one-eyed man selling +garlic. But the greater number of these conceits are merely emblematic +descriptions of well-known things, and are more vague than epigrammatic, +as, + + "I am the purple of the earth suffused with lovely tints and girt, + lest I be wronged with pointed spears. Happy indeed! had I but + length of life." + + "There's a new capture of some well-known game, that what you catch + not, you bear off with you." + + "Hoarsely amidst the waves I raise my voice + It sounds with praise with which it lauds itself, + And though I ever sing, no one applauds." + + "Spontaneous coming, I show various forms, + I feign vain fears, when there is no true conflict, + But no one can see me till he shuts his eyes." + + "By art four equal sisters run + As if in contest, though the labour's one, + And both are near, nor can each other touch."[32] + +We know little of Macrobius except that he was a Greek, and lived in the +fifth century. His principal work was his "Saturnalia," and he selected +for it this title and plan, because, as he tells us, men were in his day +so much occupied with business, that it was only in the annual festival +of misrule that they had any time for reflection or social intercourse. +The "Saturnalia," occupied the greater part of December, and Macrobius +represents a company of magnates and wits agreeing to meet daily to +discuss in the morning topics of importance, and to spend the evening in +light and jocund conversation. His work treats of astronomy, mythology, +poetry and rhetoric, but it is most interesting with regard to our +present subject, where he brings before us one of those scenes of +convivial merriment of which we have often heard. The party are to +relate humorous anecdotes in turn. Avienus says that they should be +intellectual not voluptuous, to which the president, Prætextatus, +replies, that they will not banish pleasure as an enemy, nor consider it +to be the greatest good. After these suggestions they commence:-- + +Prætextatus records a saying of Hannibal. Antiochus, to whom he had +fled, showed him in a plain a vast army he had collected to make war +with the Romans; the men were adorned with gold and silver, there were +chariots with scythes, elephants with towers, cavalry shining with +ornamental bits and housings. Then turning to Hannibal, he asked him if +he thought they would be enough for the Romans. The Carthaginian, +smiling at the weakness and cowardice of the gaudily accoutred host, +replied, "Certainly, I think they will be enough for them, however +greedy they may be." + +Furius Albinus says that after the flight at Mutina, on some lady asking +what Antony was doing, one of his friends replied, "What the dogs do in +Egypt--drink and run!" "It is well known," he adds, "that there the dogs +run while they drink, for fear of the crocodiles." + +Avenienus says that the sister of Faustus, the son of Sylla, had two +lovers--one of them, Fulvius, the son of a fuller; the other Pomponius, +nick-named Spot. "I wonder," he said, "that my sister should have a +spot, when she has a fuller." + +The remaining guests speak more at length, and their discourses occupy a +considerable portion of the book. + +The example set by Martial gradually led to a considerable development +of epigrammatic literature. A humorous epigram survives, written by +Trajan on a man with a large nose: + + "By placing your nose and gaping mouth opposite the sun + You will tell wayfarers the hour." + +Justinian in the sixth century is supposed to have assisted Paul the +Silentiary--a sort of master of the ceremonies--in his compositions; but +it may be hoped that the Emperor was not an accomplice in producing the +impurities with which they are disfigured. Here and there, however, a +few sweet flowers are found in his poisonous garland. We may hope that +he often received such a cool welcome as that he commemorates in his +"Drenched Lover." + +Hierocles and Philagrius are supposed to have lived in the fifth +century, but the jests and stories which bear their names seem to be +much later. They are based upon violations of the primary laws of nature +and mind, but have not the subtlety of the syllogistic quibbles, which +were the work of learned grammarians or the logicians of a better +period. Being little more than Bulls, they excite scarcely any emotion +and no laughter, although evincing a certain cleverness. The hero is +generally a "Scholastic," who is represented as a sort of fool. A friend +of Scholasticus going abroad asks him to buy him some books. +Scholasticus forgets all about it, and when he meets his friend on his +return, says, "By the way, I never received that letter you wrote about +the books." A man meeting Scholasticus says, "The slave you sold me +died." "Did he? By the gods," replied the other, "he never played me +that trick." Scholasticus meeting a friend exclaims, "Why, I heard you +were dead!" The other replies, "Well, I tell you that I'm alive." "Yes," +persists Scholasticus, "but the man who told me so was more veracious +than you!" A promising son apostrophizes his father, "Base varlet! don't +you see how you have wronged me? If you had never been born and stood in +the way I should have come into all my grandfather's money." + +The humour which has come to us from classic times, brings the life of +ancient Greece and Rome near to our own firesides. It is not that of a +primitive or decaying civilization, but of one advanced and matured, +resembling our own, in which density of population has brought a +clashing of interests, and enlarged knowledge has produced a variety of +thought upon a great multiplicity of home and foreign subjects. We can +thus bridge over two thousand years, and obtain, as it were, a grasp of +the Past, in which we find men so very like ourselves, not only in their +strong emotions, but in their little conceits and vanities, and their +opinions of each other. + + + + +ENGLISH HUMOUR. + + + + +CHAPTER I. + +MIDDLE AGES. + +Relapse of Civilization in the Middle Ages--Stagnation of Mind--Scarcity + of Books--Character of reviving Literature--Religious + Writings--Fantastic Legends--Influence of the Crusades--Romances--Sir + Bevis of Hamptoun--Prominence of the Lower Animals--Allegories. + + +Those ancient philosophers who believed in a mundane year and a +periodical repetition of the world's history, would have found a +remarkable corroboration of their theory in the retrogression of +learning during the middle ages, and its subsequent gradual revival. +This re-birth contained all the leading characteristics of the original +development of thought, although, amid the darkness, the torch handed +down from the past afforded occasionally some flickering light. The +great cause of the disappearance of literature and civilization was, of +course, the sword of the Goths, which made the rich countries of +Southern Europe, a wilderness and desolation. A lesser cause was the +intolerance of the ecclesiastics, who, in their detestation of Pagan +superstition and immorality endeavoured to destroy all classical +writings which touched upon mythological subjects, or contained unseemly +allusions. But, although we regret its action in this respect, and the +intellectual stagnation thus generally produced, we must admit that we +are indebted to the Church for the preservation of many valuable works. +There were many men of learning in the monasteries, and some of +sufficient enlightenment to be able to venerate the relics of Greek and +Latin literature. We find that in the East the works of Aristophanes +were so much admired by St. Chrysostom that he slept with them under his +pillow. Perhaps the Saint enjoyed the reflections of the comedian upon +the superstitions of his day, or he may have had a secret liking for the +drama, and in one place he observes how much the world resembles a +stage. There seems to have been a conflict in his breast, as no doubt +there was in many at the time, between love of the classics and +religious scruples; he tells us that he dreamed one night that he was +being whipped by the devil for reading Cicero. + +We may observe that the Eastern world was not at this time in such a +benighted state. Theodosius the younger founded in A.D. 425, +an academy and library at Constantinople, which, when it was destroyed +by the Turks contained 120,000 volumes. Nothing brings before us more +forcibly the state of ignorance in which the Western world was now sunk +than the scarcity of books. The price of them in the middle ages was so +great that a man who presented one to a monastery, thought he merited +eternal salvation. Documents were drawn up and duly signed when a book +passed from one person to another--and in the eighth century a library +of 150 volumes was regarded as something magnificent.[33] + +The state of ignorance among the Saxons may be imagined from the fact +that Alfred was twelve years old before he could get a master capable of +teaching him the alphabet, and even after the invention of paper in the +eleventh century books were very scarce. The cause of the scanty supply +of literature was not only the general destruction which had taken +place, but also that there was no demand for it. Archbishop Lanfranc, +with a view to improve education in England, directed in 1072 that a +book should be given to each of the monks, who were to be allowed a year +to read it, and what follows gives us some idea of the indolence of +these representatives of learning, for it was ordered that if the monk +has not then read it he is to prostrate himself, and ask pardon of the +abbot. The monks of Winchester were probably not much troubled in this +way, for some time afterwards the library of the bishop of that diocese +only consisted of seven books. What must then have been the ignorance of +the masses of the population! We should scarcely believe that such a +relapse could have taken place had we not seen the centres of +civilization in the world successively succumbing, and the greatest +cities becoming desolate, and did we not reflect that, but for such +vicissitudes, mankind must have attained a far greater degree of +excellence than has been reached at the present day. + +The first kind of composition attempted by the mind of man is that which +expresses religious feelings, and the idea that there exists a being +greater than himself. That dim searching after something beyond +experience could seldom confine itself to its legitimate direction, but +by dreams and hopes, and by the love of the marvellous--that early +source of idealism--strayed into a variety of fabulous and legendary +mazes. Hence arose all the strange and grotesque myths about heathen +gods and Christian saints which occupy the shadowy borders between +chaos and history. The stories which were current in this country in +early times spoke of miracles worked by the Virgin, represented St. +Christopher as a giant twenty-four feet high, and related how "Seynt +Pateryk" banished the "wormes" from Ireland; or sometimes would draw +from the rich mine of Rabbinical tradition such allegorical fictions as +that, when Noah planted the vine, Satan was present and sacrificed a +sheep, a lion, an ape, and a sow, representing the different stages of +inebriety.[34] + +But man's awakening thoughts turn not only to his Protector above, but +also to his enemies below, and thus the exploits of warlike heroes, who +generally combine the religious with the military character, easily +became tempting themes for the exercise of fancy. + +There is reason to believe that the earliest British legends recorded +the glories of King Arthur--the defender of Christianity against the +worshippers of Odin. The origin of these accounts have been traced by +some to Scandinavian, by some to Arabian sources, but we may suppose +them to have arisen among those ancient British people who inhabited +Wales and Cornwall,[35] and passed over in the fifth and sixth centuries +to Brittany (Armorica). It matters little for our present purpose whence +they came, they were full of extravagant and supernatural occurrences. +The names of two shadowy warriors, Sir Bevis and Sir Guy, seem to have +been handed down from Saxon times, probably by oral tradition; the +former is said to have performed prodigies of valour in the South, and +the latter in the North of England. The literature which has come down +to us from this date (with the exception of an ode of triumph) is purely +of a religious character, and adorned with a variety of miraculous +circumstances--a considerable part of it consists of the hymns of +Cædmon, an ignorant cowherd, who was inspired to sing by an angel +appearing to him in a vision. + +Bede's Ecclesiastical History is full of strange stories, and although +Acca, his contemporary, adorned his cathedral of Hexham in +Northumberland with what was then considered to be a magnificent +library, it was entirely composed of histories of the Apostles and +martyrs to whose relics he had dedicated the altars of his church.[36] +Meanwhile, the glorification of Charlemagne and his paladins, the great +champions of Christendom, exercised the invention of the minstrels of +France. But activity of mind increasing, additional subjects for +entertainment were demanded, and the old pagan kings and heroes appeared +in entirely new characters. The marvellous and magnificent career of +Alexander the Great seemed to invite a little additional ornamentation, +and the Roman Emperors were introduced in very fantastic habiliments. + +It would seem that traditional accounts of Roman times had been +preserved in some of the Western monasteries, as well as portions of the +old Homeric and mythological history in Latin translations[37]--Greek +had been fading out of Europe since the time of Theodosius. No doubt +there were still here and there a few genuine classical books, and we +hear of Aristotle being prized--the obscurity and subtlety of his works +having led to his being now regarded as a magician. + +The following will give some idea of the kind of stories then +appreciated. A beautiful princess, nourished with poison, was sent as a +present to Alexander. Aristotle discovered the danger, and a slave was +ordered to kiss her, who immediately fell down dead. + +The gigantic body of Pallas, the son of Evander, was found at Rome. It +exceeded in height the walls of the city, and had remained uncorrupted, +and accompanied with a burning lamp for two hundred and forty years. His +wound was fresh, and we may suppose caused instant death, for it was +four feet and a half long. + +Magical rings are often mentioned. There is some pretty sentiment in the +story of Vespasian and a wife whom he had married in a distant country. +She refuses to return home with him, and yet declares that she will kill +herself if he leaves her. The Emperor orders two rings to be made, one +bearing the image of Oblivion, the other that of Memory. The former he +gives to the Empress, the latter he wears himself. + +Virgil, who is represented as an enchanter, places a magical image in +the centre of Rome, which every day communicates to the Emperor Titus +all the secret offences committed in the city. + +From such fanciful sources, and with a discrimination such as they +display, Geoffrey of Monmouth drew up in the eleventh century a fabulous +history of England. His story of Gogmagog, the British giant, supposed +to have been destroyed by Brutus, the great grandson of Æneas, on his +landing in this country, is said to have been derived from that of two +Arabian giants Gog and Magog. The stones which compose Stonehenge, each +containing some medicinal virtue, are fabled to have been transported by +giants from the deserts of Africa to Ireland, and to have been carried +thence by Merlin's enchantment to form a monument over the British slain +by Hengist. The state of criticism existing at this time may be imagined +from the fact that even afterwards, in the reign of Edward I., the +descent of the Britons from the Trojans through Brutus was solemnly +alleged in a controversy of great importance concerning the subjection +of the crown of England to that of Scotland, showing an amount of +credulity which might almost have credited the legend that St. James, +mounted on horseback, led the Christian armies in Spain in their battles +against the Moors, or that there was in that country a golden image of +Mahomet as high as a bird could fly, in which the false prophet had +sealed up a legion of devils. + +But the imaginative powers were soon to be developed upon more +attractive themes. War and Religion were about to be blended in the +grand drama of the Crusades, prompted alike by zeal for the faith, by +hatred of the Moslem, and by thirst for military glory. The first nobles +of the West arrayed themselves in their armour, collected their +retainers, and set out for the lands of the rising sun. Here they came +into contact with an Eastern civilization, ornate and dazzling, superior +to their own, but still in a state of childhood, and revelling in the +fanciful creations which please the infantine mind.[38] Foremost among +the Christian knights went the Barons of Provence, accompanied by troops +of minstrels--troubadours to sing their praises; and we might well +suppose that some of the wonders of the dreaming East would now find +their way into Europe, interwoven with the doughty deeds of the +Christian heroes. This view is corroborated by the fact that almost all +our early romances recount some great exploits performed against the +Saracens; but the marvels they relate, from whatever source they come, +were in accordance with the times in which they were written, for as +alchemy preceded chemistry, so romance-writing was the commencement of +literature. Some of the Arabian stories had considerable grace and +beauty, and are even now attractive to the young. But whether our poets +borrowed from this prolific source or not, it is certain that about this +time they became more ambitious, and produced regular tales of +considerable length, in which the northern gallantry towards the fair +sex was combined with extravagances resembling those of Eastern +invention. + +Not until this time were the early heroic legends of this country +developed, and committed to writing, and as they appeared first in +French, some writers--among whom is Ritson--have concluded that they +were merely the offspring of our neighbours' fertile imagination. But +although the poets who recounted these stories wrote in French, they +were in attendance at the English Court, in which, even before the +Conquest, French was the language used, while Latin was that of the +learned, and Saxon that of the country-people. Henry the First, the +great patron of letters, sometimes held his Court at Caen, so that the +Norman poets who were competing for his favour, were doubtless familiar +with the legendary history of England. The first important works in the +French language seem to have come from Normandy, and it is not +improbable that some of them were written in England. They were called +romances, because they were composed in one of the languages of Southern +Europe, containing a large element of the Roman, which we find was still +used among the soldiery as late as the seventh century. It has been +supposed that all our early Anglo-Norman romances were translations from +the French, except the "Squyr of Lowe Degre," and of some the originals +are still extant. + +These productions, from whatever source they came, were the kind of +literature most acceptable at the time. There seemed then nothing harsh +or contemptibly puerile in stories we should now relegate to the +nursery, and no doubt people derived an amusement from them, for which +that of humour was afterwards gradually substituted. + +Examples of such stories are found in that of Robert, King of Sicily, +who for his pride was changed, like Nebuchadnezzar, into one of the +lower animals, and in that of Richard "Coeur de Lion," who rode a +horse possessed by the devil, and whose wife flew away like a bird. + +In the romance of Sir Bevis of Hamtoun, (Earl of Southampton,) he is +represented as a kind of infant Hercules, who, when fifteen, killed +sixty Saracen knights. He afterwards was imprisoned at Damascus in a den +with two dragons, but destroyed them. He was kept in a dungeon, however, +and + + "Rats and mice, and such small deer, + Was his meat that seven year." + +During this time he was cheered by an angel visiting him. An adversary +shortly appears in Ascapard: + + "This geaunt was mighty and strong, + And full thirty foot was long, + He was bristled like a sow; + A foot he had between each brow. + His lips were great, and hung aside, + His eyen were hollow, his mouth was wide, + Lothy he was to look on than, + And liker a devil than a man." + +He was overcome, and became page to Sir Bevis. Ascapard is very useful, +as he is able to take Bevis, Josyan, and even the horse Arundel under +his arm. An attempt at humour is introduced here, which is said to have +amused the people of Cologne. The bishop prepared to christen the giant, + + "For Ascapard was made a tun, + And when he should therein be done, + He lept out upon the brench (brink) + And said, 'Churl! wilt thou me drench? + The devil of hell mote fetche thee! + I am too much (big) christened to be!'" + +We will finish this sketch of the romancing tendencies of our early +literature by a description of a dragon from "Sir Degoré:" + + "There was a dragon great and grymme, + Full of fyre, and also venymme, + Wyth a wyde throte, and tuskes grete, + Uppon that knygte fast gan he bete, + And as a lyon then was hys feete, + Hys tayle was long, and full unmeete; + Between hys head and hys tayle + Was xxii fote withouten fayle; + His body was lyke a wyne tonne, + He shone ful bryght agaynst the sunne; + Hys eyen were bryght as any glasse, + Hys scales were hard as any brasse: + And thereto he was necked lyke a horse, + He bore hys hed up wyth grete force; + The breth of hys mouth that did not blow + As yt had been a fyre on lowe. + He was to loke on, as I you telle + As yt had been a fiende of helle." + +These romances were often called "Gestes," from the great "Gesta" or +exploits they recorded. + +The author of "Cursor Mundi," a book of religious legends, says, + + "Men lykyn jestis for to here + And romans rede in divers manere + Of Alexandre the conquerour, + Of Julius Cæsar the Emperour, &c." + +It may be doubted whether such tales as the above were ever regarded as +true, but it was not until thought became more active that the falsity +of them was fully appreciated, and "jests" gradually acquired their +present signification. The word romance has also come to be used not +only for a pleasant poetical narrative, but especially for something +utterly devoid of truth. "Story" is used in the same sense, but not +"novel," for in our present works of fiction there is seldom so much +improbability as to be offensive in our day, though it may be so to our +successors. + +In the above extracts it may have been observed that there is a +prominence and importance given to the lower animals which we should not +find in writings of the present day. As civilization fell back into +barbarism, fables re-appeared, and some indifferent literature of this +kind was produced in the fourth century by Aphthonius in Greek, and +afterwards by Flavius Avianus in Latin. In the Saxon ode on the victory +of Athelstan, a very particular account is given of the beasts of prey +present at the carnage. + +Theodosius, the blind Emperor, is said to have been restored to sight by +a serpent, whom he had benefited, coming in while he was asleep, and +placing a precious stone upon his eyes. In one of the early romances of +Marie, a baron is transformed into a bisclaveret,[39] or wolf, for three +days every week, much to his wife's discomfort; in another a falcon +changes into a knight, who is finally caught in a bird-trap; in another +a lady falls into a trance, and is supposed to be dead, until her rival, +seeing a weasel restore another one by placing a vermilion flower in its +mouth, she places it in the lady's mouth and thus awakens her. The same +element is largely present in the other romances. + +Alexander Neckam, who lived in the latter part of the twelfth century, +shows how fond our forefathers were of animals, and how they kept them +in their houses. The castles were often full of them, some roving about, +others necessarily in confinement. Monkeys were in high favour. Some of +them were taught to fight as in a tournament, which we are told caused +great laughter. In mediæval times there was a love of all kinds of +hybrid animals, and there was a certain amount of belief that all sorts +of monsters came from the East or North. Giraldus Cambrensis tells us +that there were in Ireland such mixtures as half ox and half man, half +dog and half monkey. + +All these stories remind us of the fabular period in old Greek history, +and bespeak a time, when both taste and knowledge were in their infancy; +but when, at the same time, the rays of the ideal were breaking upon the +mind, and "men appeared as trees walking." + +Allied to a love of fabling was that of allegory, which, as soon as +literary activity began to appear in the early church, produced an +abundant harvest. This tendency exhibited itself in the first progress +of thought in England. Philippe de Than, one of the most ancient +Anglo-Norman poets, wrote a work describing the character of each bird +and beast, upon which he grounded moral reflections. Robert Grosseteste, +Bishop of Lincoln, who died in 1253, was celebrated for a copious +dissertation on mystical divinity, and a poem is extant ascribed to him, +called the "Castle of Love" by Leland, in which the creation and +redemption are represented as an allegory--our Lord being supposed to +enter a magnificent castle, the body of the Virgin. The "Gesta +Romanorum" strongly exhibits the want of discrimination at this time, +for although the dramatis personæ are generally Roman Emperors, the +deepest Christian mysteries are supposed to be shadowed forth by their +actions. Some of the stories are evidently invented to enforce religious +teaching. We read of an angel accompanying a hermit on his wanderings, +the angel robs or murders all who receive him, but explains afterwards +that it is for their good. He gives a golden goblet to a rich man who +refuses to entertain them, to comfort him in this world, as he will go +to hell in the next. + +Vincent of Beauvais, a learned Dominican of France, who flourished in +the thirteenth century, observes that it was a practice of preachers to +rouse their congregation by relating a fable of Æsop. In the British +Museum there is a collection of two hundred and fifteen stories, +romantic, allegorical, and legendary, evidently compiled for the use of +monastic preachers. Mystic similitudes were at this time greatly +affected in all branches of learning. In the "Romaunt of the Rose," the +difficulties of a lover are represented under the form of a man seeking +a rose in an inaccessible garden. This flower, alchemists considered to +be emblematic of the Philosopher's Stone, while theologians referred it +to the white rose of Jericho--a state of grace into which the wicked +could not enter. + + + + +CHAPTER II. + +Anglo-Saxon Humour--Rhyme--Satires against the Church--The + Brunellus--Walter Mapes--Goliardi--Piers the Ploughman--Letters of + Obscure Men--Erasmus--The Praise of Folly--Skelton--The Ship of + Fools--Doctour Doubble Ale--The Sak full of Nuez--Church + Ornamentation--Representations of the Devil. + + +The rude character of the Anglo-Saxon humour may be gathered from our +having derived from it the word _fun_. This term which we often apply to +romping and boisterous games, refers principally to the sense of +feeling, and always implies some low kind of amusement connected with +the senses. We also discover among the Anglo-Saxons an unamiable +tendency to give nicknames to people from their personal peculiarities. +But if we look for anything better, we can find only a translation of +the Latin riddles of Symposius by Aldhelm, Bishop of Shirburn. This +prelate, who was a relation of Ina, King of the West Saxons, was in +attainments far superior to his age. He was celebrated as a harper, +poet, and theologian, and wrote several works, especially one in praise +of Virginity. His translations from Symposius were probably intended +for the post-prandial delectation of the monks. + +Aristophanes seems to have made the first approach to rhyming, for he +introduced some repetitions of the same word at the end of lines. He +probably thought the device had an absurd effect and used it as a kind +of humour. Aulus Gellius blames Isocrates, who lived about 400 +B.C., for introducing jingles into his orations, and as he also +refers to Lucilius' condemnation of them, he would probably have +objected to them in poetry. + +Classic Latin versification is supposed to have died out with +Fortunatus, Bishop of Poitiers in the sixth century, but an advance was +made towards playing with words by the introduction of rhymes in the +church hymns. Some trace of them is found in the verses of Hilary in the +fourth century, but we find them first regularly adopted in a Latin +panegyric written for Clotaire II. in France at the commencement of the +seventh. Some suppose that "Leonine verses" were invented shortly +afterwards by Pope Leo II. As in the days of Greece and Rome, the +development of poetry was accompanied by a considerable activity in the +fabrication of metres. This did not limit itself to a distich or +alternate rhyme called "tailed" or "interlaced," but included the +"horned," "crested," and "squared" verses--the last forming double +acrostics. Sometimes half a dozen lines were made to rhyme together. +This movement, pedantic as it was, showed an advance in finding +similarities in things dissimilar, a change in the appreciation of the +harmony. Previously rhymes were considered ludicrous, as they seem to us +now in prose, and even in the French drama. The old Welsh poetry +depended merely upon alliteration--as in the words ascribed to the +British Queen-- + + "Ruin seize thee, ruthless king." + +And among our old proverbs we have "Many men of many minds." "Fools +build houses, for wise men to live in." "First come, first served." The +motto of the Duke of Athole runs "Furth fortune and fill the fetters." + +The "Exeter Book," presented to his cathedral by Leofric, first Bishop +of Exeter in 1046 deserves notice, as indicative of the course of early +Anglo-Saxon literature. Here we have first religious meditations and +legends of Saints, then proverbial, or as they are called "gnomic" +verses, next allegorical descriptions by means of animals, and finally +riddles. The last are very long, and generally consist of emblematic +descriptions. + +It is a part of the great system of compensation under which we live, +that those who are most highly praised are most exposed to the attacks +of the envious, and that those who stand on an eminence above others +should have their bad as well as their good deeds recorded. And thus we +find that the earliest shafts of censure were directed against princes +and priests, and the first Norman satires of which we hear were some +songs called Sirventois, against Arnould, who was chaplain to Robert +Courthose in the time of William Rufus. He was apparently an excellent +man, established schools at Caen, and was afterwards promoted to be +patriarch of Jerusalem. The next attack of which we have any record was +that made by Luc de la Barr against Henry I. The nature of the +imputations it contained may be conjectured from the fact, that the king +ordered the writer's eyes to be put out. Another satire was directed +against Richard, "King of the Romans," who was taken prisoner at Lewes. +It was written to triumph over him, and taunt him with his defeat, and +the nearest approach to humour in it is where it speaks of his making a +castle of a windmill, which is supposed to refer to his having been +captured in such a building. The humour in the satires of this time was +almost entirely of a hostile or optical character. We have two metrical +ballads of the thirteenth century directed against the Scotch and +French, but containing little but animosity. There is also one +complaining of heavy taxation in the reign of Edward I., but generally +the church was attacked, as the clergy formed a prominent mark in every +parish in the country, and were safer game than the king or barons. +Thus, in the Harleian MSS., there is an ancient French poem pretending +to eulogise a new conventual order for both men and women, who are to +live together in great luxury and be bound to perpetual idleness. +Several monasteries in England are mentioned as affording instances of +such a mode of living. + +The earliest literary assault we have on the church in this country was +written probably in the thirteenth century--Warton says, soon after the +conquest--in a mixture of Saxon and Norman. A monastery, composed of +various kinds of gems and delicacies, represents the luxury of the +monks-- + + "Fur in see, bi west Spayngne + Is a lond ihote Cokaygne: + Ther nis lond under heuen-riche + Of wel of godness hit iliche. + + "Ther is a wel fair abbei, + Of white monkes and of grei, + Ther beth bowris and halles + Al of pasteiis beth the walles + Of fleis, of fisse, and rich met, + The likfullist that man mai et. + Fluren cakes beth the schingles[40] alle + Of cherche, cloister, boure, and halle. + The pinnes[41] beth fat podinges + Rich met to princez and kinges. + + "An other abbei is ther bi + For soth a gret fair nunnerie; + Vp a riuer of sweet milke, + Whar is gret plente of silk." + +He goes on to speak of the monks and nuns as dancing together in a very +indecorous manner. + +The clergy were often humorous themselves--Nigellus Wireker, a monk of +Canterbury, who is supposed to have lived in the time of Richard I., +wrote a very amusing attack on his brethren. It is in Latin elegiac +verse, and as being directed against ambition and discontent may be +compared with the first satire of Horace. But he wrote in a less +advanced state of civilisation to that in which the Roman poet lived, +and he carries on his discourse by means of conversations of animals. +The work is called the Brunellus--the name of an ass. + +The poem is directed against passion and avarice--and especially against +the monks, who, he says deserve to be called pastors, not _a pascendo_ +but _a poscendo_. But he takes so much interest in the animals he +introduces, that he seems to lose sight of his moral object. He delights +in the speeches of a cock and crow, but his main story is that the ass, +Brunellus, is dissatisfied, because, having long ears he thinks he ought +to have a long tail. He betakes himself to Galienus to consult him, who +endeavours to dissuade him from adopting any surgical or medical means, +and reminds him that if he has a short tail he has a very large head. He +inculcates contentment by a story of two cows, one of which, through +impatience when her tail has stuck in the mud, says it is not an +_honour_ but an _onus_, and so pulls it off, and becomes a laughing +stock to the world. The other cow waits patiently, and makes a long +speech containing references to Cato and the Trojan war. + +Prescription given by Galienus to the ass Brunellus to make his tail +grow: + + "Some marble's fat and seven fold furnace shade + The offspring of a male and female mule, + A little of the milk of goose and kite + A punchbowl's racing, and a wolf's alarms; + Of dogs and hares alliance take a drachm, + And kisses which the lark gives to her hawk." + +The ass begs Galienus to bestow upon him his blessing, which he does +with mock gravity-- + + "May Jove to thee a thousand omens give, + And to thy tail ten thousand omens more; + Mayst thou drink water, and on thistles feed, + Be thy bed marble, and thy covering dew. + May hail and snow and rain be ever near, + Ice and hoar frost thy constant comfort be!" + +The ass, whose extraordinary performances are narrated, is appointed the +"nuntius" of a bishop. + +The man who showed at this time the greatest judgment in humour and +insight into its nature, was John of Salisbury. His Polycraticus is +worthy of a religious character; but he speaks in it of "Court Trifles" +under which he places dice, music and dreams. Many of his observations +show a taste and knowledge in advance of his time. "Our age," he says, +"has fallen back to fables," and he speaks as though the jesters of the +day indulged in very questionable jokes and performances. He notices the +force of a jest made by a man who would himself fall under it, as when a +pauper laughs at poverty. Also he refers to the effect of accusing a man +of the faults to which his virtues may lead, as of telling a liberal man +he is a spendthrift. "So Diogenes told Antisthenes, his master, that he +had made him a doctor instead of a rich man--a dweller in a tub, instead +of in a mansion." Well-timed pleasantries, he says, are of use in +oratory, but convivial jesting is dangerous, remarks or personal defects +are objectionable, and as Lycurgus ordered, all jokes should be without +bitterness. + +But Walter Mapes seems to have been the first man of note, who +reconciled "divinity and wit." He was born on the borders of Wales about +the beginning of the twelvth century, and having studied at the +University of Paris became a favourite of Henry II., and was made a +Canon of St. Paul's, and Archdeacon of Oxford. It may be worth notice +that his name was really a monosyllable, "Map," a man's appellation +being not always without influence in determining his character and +conduct. From being a man of humour he obtained the credit of being a +man of pleasure, but as far as we can collect from the writings, which +are with certainty attributed to him, he was strongly imbued with +religious feelings. He delights to recount the miracles of saints. Peter +of Tarentaise exorcised, he tells us, a devil from one possessed, and +the man proved his cure by exclaiming, "Mother of God, have mercy upon +me!" whereupon John the bishop said of Peter. "This is the only +bishop--the rest of us are dogs unable to bark." Mapes also reflects the +credulity of the age in which he lived, by narrating extraordinary +stories of infidels walking about after death, and calling people by +name, who always died shortly afterwards. He gives us a collection of +Welsh "apparitions." + +We must suppose that even at that day there was something peculiarly +fanciful in the mind of the man who collected such tales. But, although +he commends his favourite saints as being jocund and pleasant men, we +are disappointed when we look for his own wit. It is either verbal or +sententious, and does not rise higher than, "Few things are impossible +to women." "May God omnipotent grant you not to be deceived by woman +omnipotent." "The dog does not gnaw a dry bone, nor the leech stick to +an empty vein." His "Mirror of the Church" is full of violent attacks +upon the monastic orders, especially the Cistercian, evidently written +in serious indignation, although he sometimes indulges in a play upon +words. In this he was unlike many writers, who attacked the monks merely +to amuse, for which there was a good opening, as the brethren, though in +some cases weak, were generally viewed with respect, and tales about +them were easily regarded as humorous. There is a story of Walter Mapes +having been called to see a Cistercian Abbot, when dangerously ill, and +the Archdeacon recommended him to quit his order, and give up avarice +and rapacity. The Abbot refused, and even administered to the Archdeacon +the rebuke, "Get thee behind me, Satan." Shortly afterwards Mapes was +taken ill, and the Abbot going to visit him, strongly recommended him to +renounce his light jesting habits, to give up his pluralities, and take +refuge in the bosom of the Cistercian order--at the same time producing +a gown and cowl, with which he proposed to invest him. Mapes, with +characteristic humour called his servants, and told them that, if ever +in a fit of sickness he expressed a desire of becoming a monk, they +were to consider it a sign that he had lost his senses, and keep him in +close confinement. + +The character which Mapes obtained for himself, caused a large amount of +poetry of a somewhat later date to be attributed to him. It is called +"Goliardic," as it gives the views of a class of wild ecclesiastical or +University men, who spent their time in composing lampoons, and were +called Goliards, from their supposed gluttony. In an epigram, one of +these men is represented coming to a bishop's palace, and stating that +he is "all ready to dine," somewhat in the way of the old Greek +parasites. The bishop tells him he does not want such disreputable +company, but that as he has come, he may have his food. We may suppose, +however, that he and his poorer brethren did not occupy any dignified +position at the repast, as one of them complains + + "Abbas ire sede sursum, + Et prioris juxta ipsum, + Ego semper stavi dorsum + Inter rascalilia." + +All these poems are in Latin rhyme. Two of them are especially +attributed to Mapes. One is "on not marrying;" Golias here sets forth a +very appalling catalogue of the miseries of matrimony. The husband is a +donkey who is spurned by his wife. Her tongue is a sword. He thanks +heaven he has escaped from the danger he was once in from the +fascinations of a beautiful lady. The other piece is the "Confessions of +Golias," which are very frank with regard to various unclerical +weaknesses. Some of the stanzas may be translated as follows, + + "I purpose in a tavern to die, + Place to my dying lips the flowing bowl, + May choirs of angels coming from on high + Sing, 'God be gracious to the toper's soul.'[42] + + "The race of poets shun both drink and food, + Avoid disputes, withdraw from public strife, + And to make verses that shall long hold good + O'ercome with labour, sacrifice their life. + + "Nature allots to each his proper course, + In hunger I could never use my ink, + The smallest boy then equals me in force, + I hate as death the want of food and drink." + +In one of these poems, Golias calls down every kind of misery, spiritual +and temporal, upon the man who has stolen his purse. He hopes he may die +of fever and madness, and be joined to Judas in hell. One of the most +amusing pieces is a consultation held among the priests, on account of +the Pope having ordered them to dismiss their women-servants. They +finally come to the conclusion that parish priests should be allowed two +wives, monks and canons three, and deans and bishops four or five. We +are not surprised to hear that such effusions as these called down the +displeasure of the heads of the Church, and in 1289, a statute was +published that no clerks should be "joculatores, goliardi seu bufones." + +About the middle of the fourteenth century, a French monk, Robert +Langlande, wrote the "Vision of Piers Plowman," an account of a dream he +is supposed to have had when among the Malvern Hills. It is possible +that the sight of the grand old abbey may have suggested his theme, for +he inveighs not only against the laity, but especially against the +ecclesiastics for their neglect of the poor. The poem is remarkable for +being without rhythm, but alliterative, such as was common in the +neighbouring district of Wales. It somewhat resembles one of the old +"Mysteries," introducing a variety of allegorical characters. Some of +the personifications are very strange. He says that, + + "Dowel and Dobet and Dobest the thirde coth he + Arn thre fair vertues and ben not fer to fynde." + + "Dobest is above bothe, and berith a bieschopis crois + And is hokid on that on ende to halie men fro helle + And a pike is in the poynt to putte adon the wyked." + +In another place, the effects of starvation are described "both the +man's eiyen wattred," and "he loked like a lanterne." + +In another work by the same hand, "Piers, the Ploughman's crede," the +author--a simple man--wishes to know how he is to follow Christ, and +betakes himself to the friars for information. But he finds that each +order thinks of little beyond railing against some other. The friars +preachers are thus described, + + "Than turned I ayen whan I hadde al ytoted + And fond in a freitoure a frere on a benche + A greet chorl and a grym, growen as a tonne, + With a face so fat, as a ful bleddere + Blowen bretful of breth, and as a bagge honged." + +All the humour of Piers the Ploughman seems to be more or less of this +personal kind. + +We must here notice the humorous though scurrilous attack made upon the +Roman clergy in the "Letters of Obscure Men," published in Germany at +the commencement of the sixteenth century. There was something novel in +the idea of a series of ironical letters, and from their appearance, the +steady progress of the Reformation may be dated. The greater part of +them seems to have been written by Ulrich von Hutten, and are addressed +to Ortuin Gratius, a professor of the University of Cologne, who had +attacked Reuchlin, a celebrated Hebraist. The original quarrel was only +about some translations of Rabbinical works, but it extended into a +contest between the Church party, represented by Gratius, and those +desirous of reformation. Doctrine is scarcely touched upon in these +letters, but accusations of immorality abound. There is great variety +in the plan upon which the irony and satire are conducted. For instance, +the writer says he has just heard from Gratius that he is sending +flowers and gifts to another man's wife. "Reuchlin has written a defence +of himself against Gratius, in which he calls him an ass. Reuchlin ought +to be burnt with his book. Some people say the monks are grossly +dishonest--it is a horrible lie. A preacher, after taking a little too +much wine, has actually said that the principals of the University are +given to drink and play. Some profane men say that the coat of our Lord +at Treves is not genuine, but only an old rag; he does not believe there +is now any hair of the Virgin in the world; and the preaching friars who +sell indulgences are only a set of buffoons who deceive old apple-women. +Another fool says that the preaching friars committed fearful +abominations at Berne, and one day put poison into the consecrated +elements. A great calamity has happened! A thief has stolen three +hundred florins, which the preachers had gained by the sale of +indulgences. The people who gave the money are in sad trouble to know +whether they still have absolution--they need not be alarmed, they have +as much as they had before they gave their money to the friars. Query. +Is it a sin to play at dice in order to buy indulgences? Gratius, in a +letter to another Father of the Church, expresses his astonishment at +hearing that he thinks so much about the ladies. Such thoughts come from +the devil; wherever they are suggested, he must make the sign of the +cross on his back, and put a pinch of blessed salt on his tongue. Women +make him ill by employing charms and sorceries against him; it is no +wonder, for he has grey hair and eyes, a red face, a large nose, and a +corporation. No man should ever make use of necromancy to obtain a +woman's love, for a student of theology once fell in love with a baker's +daughter at Leipzig, and threw an enchanted apple at her,[43] which +caused her to fall violently in love with him, and finally led to a +scandal in the church." + +No one enjoyed these epistles more thoroughly than Erasmus,[44] who, +perhaps, from being himself a monk, appreciated them the better. He is +said to have laughed so immoderately over some parts of them, that he +burst an abscess, which might have proved fatal to him. He was one of +those few celebrated men who combine both humour and learning, and he +seems to have imbibed somewhat of the spirit of Lucian, whose works he +translated, and who also lived in an age of religious controversy and +transition. There was such a love of amusement, and so little +earnestness in Erasmus, that he could laugh on both sides of the +question, with the Reformers and against them. When the monks told him +that Luther had married a nun, and that the offspring of such an unholy +alliance must needs be Antichrist, he merely replied: "Already are there +many Antichrists!" Writing to a zealous Catholic in London, he says +"that he grudges the heretics their due, because that, whereas winter is +approaching, it will raise the price of fagots." In another place he +attacks dignities: "No situation," he says, "could be more wretched than +that of the vicegerents of Christ, if they endeavoured to follow +Christ's life." There was scarcely anything sacred or profane which was +safe from the lash of his ridicule, and if, as some say, he sowed the +seeds of the Reformation, it was mostly because he could not resist the +temptation to laugh at the clergy. He wrote a very characteristic Work +entitled "The Praise of Folly," "Encomium Moriæ" (a play on the name of +Sir Thomas More), in which he maintains a sort of paradox, setting forth +the value and advantages of folly, _i.e._, of indulging the light +fancies and errors of imagination. With much humorous illustration he +enumerates a great many conceits, and includes among them jests, but his +main argument may be thus condensed.[45] + +"Who knows not that man's childhood is by far the most delightful period +of his existence? And why? Because he is then most a fool. And next to +that his youth, in which folly still prevails; while in proportion as he +retires from her dominion, and becomes possessed through discipline and +experience of mature wisdom, his beauty loses its bloom, his strength +declines, his wit becomes less pungent, until at last weary old age +succeeds, which would be absolutely unbearable, unless folly, in pity +for such grievous miseries, gave relief by bringing on a second +childhood. Nature herself has kindly provided for an abundant supply of +folly in the human race, for since, according to the Stoic definition, +wisdom means only being guided by reason; whereas folly, on the other +hand, consists in submitting to the government of the passions; Jupiter +wishing to make life merry, gave men far more passion than reason, +banishing the latter into one little corner of his person, and leaving +all the rest of the body to the sway of the former. Man, however, being +designed for the arrangement of affairs, could not do without a small +quantity of reason, but in order to temper the evil thus occasioned, at +the suggestion of folly woman was introduced into the world--"a foolish, +silly creature, no doubt, but amusing, agreeable, and well adapted to +mitigate the gloom of man's temper." Woman owes all her advantages to +folly. The great end of her existence is to please man, and this she +could not do without folly. If any man doubts it, he has only to +consider how much nonsense he talks to a woman whenever he wishes to +enjoy the pleasures of female society." + +Erasmus wrote an ode in honour of Henry VII. and his children, and in it +he recommends him to keep with him Skelton, "the one light and ornament +of British literature." He says that no doubt the advice is unnecessary, +as he hears the King is most anxious to retain his services. He was +tutor to the young prince--afterwards Henry VIII. Skelton was born about +1460. Many of his humorous writings are lost, such as "The Balade of the +Mustarde Tarte." He became a "poet laureate," at that time a degree in +grammar, rhetoric and versification, on taking which, the graduate was +presented with a laurel crown. Having taken orders in 1498, he was +afterwards suspended for living with a lady whom he had secretly +married. This suspension was much owing to his having incurred the anger +of the Dominican Friars, whom he had attacked in his writings. We are +told that he was esteemed more fit for the stage than the pulpit. The +humour of Skelton consists principally of severe personal vituperation. +In "Colyn Cloute" he assailed the clergy generally, but he wrote +personal attacks on Garnesche (a courtier), and on Wolsey. The Cardinal +had been his patron at one time, and Skelton had dedicated poems to him, +among them "A Replycacion" against the followers of Wickliffe and +Luther--of which pious effusion the following lines will give a +specimen:-- + + "To the honour of our blessed lady + And her most blesed baby, + I purpose for to reply + Agaynst this horryble heresy + Of these young heretics that + Stynke unbrent. + + "I say, thou madde marche hare, + I wondre how ye dare + Open your ianglyng iawes, + To preche in any clawes + Lyke pratynge poppyng dawes. + + "I say, ye braynless beestes, + Why iangle you such iestes. + In your diuynite + Of Luther's affynite + To the people of lay fee + Raylying in your rages + To worshyppe none ymages + Nor do pylgrymages." + +The cause of his quarrel with Wolsey is not known, but he afterwards +wrote a severe personal attack upon him entitled, "Why come ye not to +Courte?" The tone of this effusion may be gathered from such expressions +as:-- + + "God save his noble grace + And grant him a place + Endlesse to dwell, + With the deuyll of hell, + For and he were there + We nede neuer feere, + Of the fendys blake; + For I vndertake + He wolde so brag and crake, + That he wolde then make + The deuyls to quake, + To shudder and to shake." + +Owing to such attacks, he was obliged to flee and take sanctuary at +Westminster, where he died. His most entertaining pieces are "Speke +Parrot," "Phyllyt Sparrowe," and "Elynour Rummynge." In the first a fair +lady laments the death of her bird, killed by "those vylanous false +cattes." She sings a "requiescat" for the soul of her dear bird, and +recounts all his pretty ways-- + + "Sometyme he wolde gaspe + When he sawe a waspe; + A fly or a gnat + He wolde flye at that; + And prytely he wold pant + When he saw an ant; + Lord, how he wolde pry + After the butterfly! + Lord, how he wolde hop + After the gressop, + And whan I said Phypp, Phypp, + Than he wolde lepe and skyp, + And take ane by the lyp. + Alas it will me slo + That Phillyp is gone we fro!" + +She gives a long list of birds, who are to attend at his funeral, from +which our nursery story of cock-robin may be taken. Skelton seems to +have been fond and observant of birds. In Speke Parrot, he thus +describes + + "With my beeke bent, my lyttyl wanton eye, + My fedders freshe as is the emrawde grene, + About my neck a cyrculet lyke the ryche rubye + My lyttyl leggys, my feet both fete and clene, + I am a mynyon to wayt uppon a quene; + My proper parrot my lyttyl prety foole, + With ladyes I lerne and go with them to scole." + +It will be observed that the humour in the above pieces is little +separated from poetry. In Elynour Rummynge however, we have something +undoubtedly jocose, and proportionally rustic and uncouth. + +Skelton adopted, as we have seen, a quick, short metre, somewhat +analogous to the "Swift Iambics," of the Greek humorists. Sometimes also +he alternated Latin with English in a conceit not very uncommon towards +the end of the fourteenth and in the fifteenth century as-- + + "Freeres, freeres, wo ye be! + Ministri malorum, + For many a mannes soul bringe ye, + Ad poenas infernorum." + +No work became more popular than the Ship of Fools by Sebastian Brandt. +It was published in Germany in 1494, and was speedily translated into +Latin and French. Alexander Barclay altered it so considerably in the +rendering as almost to make a new work, especially applicable to the +state of things existing in this country. Ersch and Grüber speak of +Brandt's fools as contemptible and loathsome, and say what he calls +follies might be better described as sins and vices. But here and there +we meet with touches of humour in the mishaps and absurd actions of +those he censures. The whole work is rather of a moral and religious +complexion, as the following heading of the poem will suggest-- + +"Of newe fassions and disgised garmentes. Of Avaryce and prodygalyte. Of +vnprofytable stody. Of lepynges and dauncis and Folys that pas theyr +tyme in suche vanyte. Of Pluralitees, of flatterers, and glosers. Of the +vyce of slouth. Of Usurers and okerers. Of the extorcion of knyghtis. Of +follisske, cokes, and buttelers." + +Literature increased greatly in the fifteenth century, and began to take +that general form it afterwards bore. One of the satires on the fashions +of the period, which in every age seem to have afforded materials for +mirth, begins as follows-- + + "Ye prowd gallonttes hertlesse + With your hyghe cappis witlesse, + And youre schort gownys thriftlesse, + Have brought this londe in gret hevynesse. + With youre longe peked schone. + Therfor your thrifte is almost don, + And with youre long here into your eyen + Have brought this londe to gret pyne." + +There is a good satire written on a priest about the time of the +Reformation, showing considerable humour both in matter, language and +versification. It is called "Doctor Doubble Ale." + +A little episode is given arising from the priest's ignorance-- + + "His learning is exceeding + Ye may know by his reading, + Yet coulde a cobbler's boy him tell + That he red a wrong gospell + Wherfore in dede he served him well, + He turned himselfe as round as a ball, + And with loud voyce began to call, + 'Is there no constable among you all + To take this knave that doth me troble?' + With that all was on a hubble shubble, + There was drawing and dragging, + There was lugging and lagging, + And snitching and snatching, + And ketching and catching, + And so the pore ladde, + To the counter they had, + Some wolde he should be hanged, + Or else he shulde be wranged; + Some sayd it were a good turne + Such an heretyke to burn." + +A great many of the humorous poems written against the church were +republished at the time of the Reformation to show that for centuries +the misdoings of the clergy had been a source of comment. In "the Sak +full of Nuez"--a rare book[46] referred to in 1575, containing a +collection of humorous pieces of a rough and rude character--we find +several hits at the expense of the church. + +"A friar used to visit the house of an old woman, who, when he was +coming, very prudently hid whatever she had to eat. One day coming with +some friends, he asked her if she had not some meat. And she said, +'Nay.' 'Well,' quoth the friar, 'have you not a whetstone?' 'Yea,' quoth +the woman, 'what will you do with it?' 'Marry,' quoth he, 'I would make +meat thereof.' Then she brought a whetstone. He asked her likewise if +she had not a frying-pan. 'Yea,' said she, 'but what the divil will ye +do therewith?' 'Marry,' said the fryer, 'you shall see by and by what I +will do with it;' and when he had the pan, he set it on the fire, and +put the whetstone therein. 'Cocks-body,' said the woman, 'you will burn +the pan.' 'No, no,' quoth the fryer, 'if you will give me some eggs, it +will not burn at all.' But she would have had the pan from him, when +that she saw the pan was in danger; but he would not let her, but still +urged her to fetch him some eggs, which she did. 'Tush,' said the fryer, +'here are not enow, go fetch ten or twelve.' So the good wife was +constrayned to fetch more, for feare that the pan should burn, and when +he had them he put them in the pan. 'Now,' quoth he, 'if you have no +butter, the pan will burn and the eggs too.' So the good-wife, being +very loth to have her pan burnt, and her eggs lost, she fetcht him a +dish of butter, the which he put into the pan and made good meat +thereof, and brought it to the table, saying, 'Much good may it do you, +my hostess, now may you say you have eaten of a buttered whetstone.'" + +Another story runs as follows:-- + +"There was a priest in the country, which had christened a child; and +when he had christened it, he and the clerk were bidden to the drinking +that should be there, and being there, the priest drank and made so +merry that he was quite foxed, and thought to go home before he laid him +down to sleep; but, having gone a little way, he grew so drousie that he +could go no further, but laid him down by a ditch-side, so that his feet +did hang in the water, and lying on his back, the moon shined in his +face; thus he lay till the rest of the company came from drinking, who, +as they came home, found the priest lying as aforesaid, and they thought +to get him away, but do what they could, he would not rise, but said, +'Do not meddle with me, for I lie very well, and will not stir hence +before morning, but I pray lay some more cloathes on my feet, and blow +out the candle.'" + +At first it occasions us no little surprise to find the clergy of the +early centuries so prone to attack and ridicule one another, but we must +remember that there was then no reading public, and that the few copies +of books in existence were mostly within the walls of the monasteries. +Thus, the object of these writers would be like that of St. Jerome in +his letters, not so much to disgrace the Church as to improve its +discipline. We can also, perhaps, understand how the conflicts between +the parish priests and monks led them sometimes to caricature each other +in the grotesque heads of corbels and gargoyles; nor does it surprise us +that Luther, indignant and rude, should portray the Pope to the public +under the form of a jackass. + +But how can we account for the strange and profane caricatures which are +so numerous in the stone and wood carvings of our cathedrals? In the +scriptural ornamentation of the thirteenth century in Strasburg +Cathedral, there was the representation of a funeral performed by +animals--a hare carried the taper, a wolf the cross, and a bear the holy +water--while in another place a stag was celebrating mass, and an ass +reading the gospel. We often find carvings in which foxes are habited as +ecclesiastics, sometimes accompanied by geese, who represent their +flock, and thus we can understand the significance of the design in +Sherborne Minster and Wellingborough, where two geese are hanging a fox. + +In St. Mary's, Beverley, are two foxes dressed as ecclesiastics, each +holding a pastoral staff, while a goose's head is peeping out of his +hood. At Boston Church we find a fox in a cope and episcopal vestments, +seated on a throne, and holding a pastoral staff, while on the right is +an ass holding a book for the bishop to read. The fact was that no means +were left untried by the Church to make converts and to obtain a hold on +the people. They wished to render religion as attractive as possible, +and perhaps to direct and control tendencies which they could not +destroy. It was then a favourite doctrine that the end justified the +means--the Roman Church instituted persecutions, adopted heathen rites, +and ordained fasts and festivals to impress the mind. It is recorded +that Theophylact of Constantinople introduced into the Church, in the +tenth century, the licentious "Feast of Fools," to wean the people from +the revels of their old religion, and have we not until late years +celebrated the Nativity of our Lord, not only by games and frolics, but +gluttony and drunkenness, and riotous proceedings, under pagan misletoe! +I believe that among the masses of the people the Roman saturnalia still +survive. We need not then be surprised that the early Christians tried +to recommend religion by unsuitable ornamentation. They adopted all +kinds of floral designs, they represented fables and romances. In the +old church of Budleigh, in Devonshire--which Sir Walter Raleigh +attended, and where his head is buried--all kinds of devices are +represented on the pews, from a pair of scissors to a man-of-war, +including a cook holding a sheep by the tail. It was only a step from +this to introduce humour, and as men's feelings had not then been +chastened or brought into order by reflection, they probably overlooked +the lowering tendencies of levity. Those who came to laugh, might remain +to pray, and so a strange crop of incongruities germinated upon the +sacred soil. Thus, in Beverley Minster, we have a monkey riding upon a +hare--a bedridden goat, with a monkey acting as doctor; and at +Winchester a boar is playing on the fiddle, while a young pig is +dancing.[47] Even scenes of drunkenness and immorality are not always +excluded. But the principal representations attributed human actions to +birds and beasts--people who could laugh at stories of this kind, could +also at depictions of them. It may be maintained that men were then +highly emotional, and demanded but little complexity or truth in humour, +so that they could see something amusing in a boar playing upon the +bagpipes, or in such a device as a monster composed of two birds, with +the head of a lion, or another with a human head on a lion's body! But +there must have been something more than this--some peculiar estimation +of animals to account for such numerous representations. They were +common in the secular ornamentation of the day, for instance, in a MS. +copy of Froissart of the fifteenth century, there is a drawing of a pig +walking upon stilts, playing the harp, and wearing one of the tall +head-dresses then in fashion. + +This love of the comic seems to have been fostered by the leisure and +the lively turn of some ecclesiastics. In the injunctions given to the +British Church in the year 680, no bishop is to allow tricks or +jocosities (ludos vel jocos) to be exhibited before him, and later we +read of two monks, near Oxford, receiving a man hospitably, thinking he +was a "jougleur," and could perform tricks, but kicking him out on +finding themselves mistaken. We find some of the monks amusing +themselves with "cloister humour," consisting principally of logical +paradoxes; while others indulged in verbal curiosities, such as those of +Tryphiodorus, the lipogrammatist, who wrote an Odyssey in twenty-four +books without once using the letter A. Some were more fond of pictorial +designs, and carved great figures on the chalk downs, such as the Giant +of Cerne Abbas, in Dorsetshire, and the Long Man of Wilmington, in +Sussex. + +As we found reason to believe that the earliest kind of laughter was +that of pleasure, so in this revival of civilization, we often see +humour regarded as having no influence beyond that of ministering to +amusement. The mind was scarcely equal to regarding things in more than +one light. A jest was often viewed as entirely unimportant, its levity +and depreciatory character being altogether overlooked. To this and to +the hostile element then very prominent, we may attribute the +caricatures of the devil, formerly so common. Before the tenth century, +the devil was thought too dreadful to be portrayed, but afterwards, as +the Church made a liberal exhibition of the torments of hell, the idea +occurred of deterring offenders by representing evil spirits in as +frightful a form as possible. Some think that such figures were +suggested by the Roman satyrs, but they may have come from Jewish or +Runic sources. There is a mediæval story of a monk having carved an +image of the devil so much more repulsive than he really was, that the +sable gentleman called upon him one night to expostulate. The monk, +however, was inexorable. But the story says further that, although the +holy man was proof against the entreaties of the devil, he was not so +well armed against the fascinations of the fair, and owing to his +suffering a defeat at the hands of the latter came afterwards to be shut +up in prison. The original of his portrait again called upon him, and +the monk agreed that, if he would obtain his release, he would represent +him as a handsome fellow. + +As times advanced, people began to fear the devil less, and to be amused +at these strange carvings. From regarding them as ludicrous, it was only +a step to make humorous caricatures--and there could be little harm in +ridiculing the Devil. Thus we frequently find imps and demons brought in +to perform the comic parts in the Church mysteries. It was a short +advance from the ludicrous to the humorous, and thus we find the devil a +merry fellow, playing all kinds of practical jokes on mankind. Such +representations would now appear rather ludicrous than humorous, and are +seldom seen, except to amuse children on Valentine's Day. + + + + +CHAPTER III. + +Origin of Modern Comedy--Ecclesiastical Buffoonery--Jougleurs and + Minstrels--Court Fools--Monks' Stories--The "Tournament of + Tottenham"--Chaucer--Heywood--Roister Doister--Gammer Gurton. + + +As the early drama of Greece arose from the celebration of religious +rites, so that of modern times originated in the church. This does not +seem so strange when we remember that religion is in connection with +abstract thought, and with an exercise of the representative powers of +the mind. And if we ask how comedy could have been thus introduced, the +reply must be that the ideal of former ages was very different from our +own. In the days when the mind was dull and inactive, striking +illustrations were very necessary to awaken interest in moral and +spiritual teaching. They changed in accordance with the progress of the +times and country--sometimes the medium was fables or other such +impossible fictions, sometimes it was similitudes from nature, as +parables, and sometimes dramatic performances. Whatever drama the Jews +had was of a religious character. It is supposed by some that the +words--"When your children shall say unto you, 'What mean ye by this +service,'" refers to some commemorative representation. However this may +be, we know that about the year 100 B.C., Ezekiel, an Alexandrian Jew, +wrote a play in Greek on the Exodus, which somewhat resembled a +"mystery." Luther thought that the books of Judith and Tobit were +originally in a dramatic form; and, even among the Jews, a comic element +was sometimes introduced--as in the ancient Ahasuerus' play at the feast +of Purim--with a view of attracting attention at a time when people had +little reflection, and were not very particular about the intermingling +of utterly incongruous feelings, whether religion and cruelty, or +religion and humour. + +We have traced the gradual decline of the drama in Rome, until it +consisted but of buffooneries and mimes; and so its revival in modern +times commenced with performances in dumb show, the low intellectual +character of the age being reflected in popular exhibitions. The mimi +were people who performed barefooted, clothed in skins of animals, +with shaven heads, and faces smeared with soot. The Italians gradually +came to relish nothing but a sort of pantomime, and it seems to have +occurred to the Roman Church, always enterprising and fond of +adaptation, that they might turn this taste of the people to some +account. Accordingly, we read of religious mummings in Spain as early as +the sixth century, and in 1264 the Brotherhood of the Gonfalone was +founded in Italy to represent the sufferings of Christ in dumb show and +processions.[48] In France the performance of holy plays, termed +Mysteries, dates from the conclusion of the fourteenth century, when a +company of pilgrims from the Holy Land, with their gowns hung with +scallop shells and images, assisted at the marriage of Charles VI. and +Isabella of Bavaria. They were incorporated as a Society in Paris to +give dramatic entertainments, and were known as the "Fraternity of the +Passion." Originally the intention was to represent scenes in Scripture +history, but gradually they introduced "Moralities"--fanciful pieces in +which God, the Devil, the Virtues, &c., were the dramatis personæ. In +one of these, for instance, the Devil invites the Follies to a banquet +on their arrival in hell. When they sit down the table seems hospitably +spread, but as soon as they begin to touch the food it all bursts into +flame, and the piece concludes with fireworks. We can see that a comic +element might easily be introduced into such performances. But Charles +VI., who seems to have been fond of all mimetic exhibitions, formed +another company named "L'Institution Joyeuse," composed of the sons of +the best families in Paris, who, under the name of the "Enfans sans +Souci," and presided over by the "Prince des Sots," made France laugh at +the follies of the day, personal and political. The above mentioned +religious fraternity joined these gay performers without apparently +seeing anything objectionable in such a connection, and under the name +of the "Clercs de la Bazoche," or clerks of the revels, acted with them +alternately. Even in the Mysteries, an occasional element of humour was +evidently introduced, although many things which would appear ludicrous +to us did not so affect the people of that day. A tinge of buffoonery +was thought desirable. Thus in the "Massacre of the Holy Innocents," a +good deal of scuffling takes place on the stage, especially where the +women attack with their distaffs a low fool, who has requested Herod to +knight him that he may join in the gallant adventure. In France there +was "The Feast of Asses," in which the priests were attired like the +Ancient Prophets, and accompanied by Virgil! Balaam, armed with a +tremendous pair of spurs, rode a wooden ass, in which a man was +enclosed. Robert Grosseteste, Bishop of Lincoln, forbade the celebration +in churches of the "Feast of Fools," in which the clergy danced and +gesticulated in masks. The "Mysteries" seem sometimes to have been of +extraordinary length, for there was a play called "The Creation," +performed at Clerkenwell which lasted eight days. + +Pageantry as well as humour--devices appealing to the senses--were +largely employed to enliven the exhibitions of early times. In the +Christmas games in the reign of Edward I., we find they made use of +eighty tunics of buckram of various colours, forty-two vizors, fourteen +faces of women, fourteen of men, and the same number of angels, as well +as imitations of dragons, peacocks, and swans. + +The taking of Constantinople in 1453 scattered the men of learning +throughout the West, and led to a revival of literature. The drama +recommenced with representations of the old plays of Plautus. They were +performed at the Universities, and on state occasions, as in 1528, when +Henry VIII. had a stage erected in his great hall at Greenwich. + +But the first development seems to have been in Spain, where the old +Romans had left their impress, and where the cruel games of the circus +still survive in the form of bull-fights. Lopez de Reuda, of Seville, +first brought comedy on the stage, but Cervantes tells us that then the +whole wardrobe of an actor consisted of four sheep-skins, trimmed with +gilt leather, four beards, four wigs, and four shepherds' crooks. +Nevertheless, after the classical period, Spain became the repertory for +the comedians of Europe. + +So far we have traced the origin of comedy as to public performance. We +now come to consider what tendencies of disposition opened the way for +it, and led to its becoming a branch of literature. The love of +amusement, which is so strong in man, induced the patronage, which in +early times was extended to the various kinds of professors of light +arts. + +In the days of Greece, as in those of Rome, there were ball-players, and +mountebanks, and we may remember an occasion on which Terence complained +that a rope-dancer had enticed away his audience. In Sparta there were +men who represented the tricks of thieves and impostors in dances, and +whose entertainments, though poor, were superior to that of mere +mountebanks. The mimes were a still greater improvement, in which a +certain amount of amusing narrative was illustrated by dances, songs, +contortions, and as the name implies by mimicry. We have seen Plato +introducing mimi from Greece, and Julius Cæsar interesting himself in +such performers. Our mediæval fool has been traced to the Roman mime, +who continued to please the country-people with coarse and debased +representations after Rome had fallen, and comedy had perished. Some +have even given a classic origin to our pantomime, considering harlequin +to be Mercury, the clown Momus, pantaloon Charon, and columbine Psyche. +The Roman Sannio and Manducus certainly somewhat corresponded to our +fool and clown, the latter especially in his gormandising propensities. +But it is scarcely necessary to travel so far back, for the desire for +amusement has in all countries produced an indigenous supply. + +Court-jesters are heard of as early as the reign of Philip of Macedon, +but they seem to have been at first little more than parasites of +inferior rank and education. In Roman times they were little more than +buffoons,[49] and not very different from the mediæval fools. They seem +to have received nicknames, and Petronius describes a very low buffoon +performing antics in a myrtle robe with a belt round his waist. + +As in ancient times we find Achilles singing to his lyre, so the English +musicians and story-tellers were originally amateurs of high rank. We +read of King Alfred charming the Danes with his minstrelsy. So also in +the Arthurian legends Sir Kaye is represented as amusing the company; +but at the time of Hoel Dha's Welsh laws, the bard was paid, for we read +that the king was to allow him a horse and a woollen garment, and the +queen to give him a linen robe; the prefect of the palace is privileged +to sit near him on festivals and to hand him his harp. Canute seems to +have treated his scalds with less ceremony, for he threatened to put one +of them to death because he recounted his exploits in too short a poem, +but the man escaped by producing thirty strophes on the subject next +day. The Saxon gleemen were generally of humble origin and not only +performed music, but exhibited tricks. So also among the Normans we find +the barons originally amusing one another with "gabs," _i.e._ boastful +and exaggerated accounts of their achievements. But soon a greater +amount of leisure and luxury led them to pay for amusement; professed +musicians and story-tellers were introduced, and were classed with the +_ministri_ or servants, whence came the name minstrel, which was soon +confined to them alone. We find Talliefer going before William the +Conqueror at the battle of Hastings chanting the brave deeds of +Charlemagne and making a display of skill in tossing and catching his +sword and spear. This union of tricks and music became so common that +the words minstrel and jougleur were soon synonymous, though there was +originally a distinction between them. The word jougleur, sometimes by +mistake written jongleur, is derived from the latin _joculator_. This +class of people were conjurers, as their name suggests, and often went +about the country with performing animals, especially bears and monkeys. +They gradually added songs to their accomplishments, which more +assimilated them to the minstrels, and they became connected with, and +were sometimes called "troubadours." In these minstrels or jougleurs, +though sometimes strolling independently, being often attached to great +households, we find an element of the domestic, or as he is called, +court fool, and we find another in their performances being of that +primitive character, which appeals chiefly to the perception of the +senses. For although the "jocular" part, originally subordinate, had +been increased, it took so rude a form that the ludicrous was not always +easily distinguished from the humorous. The Fool was a strange mixture +of both, varying from a mere idiot and butt to a man of genius, far +superior to his masters. He made shrewd remarks, and performed senseless +antics, the city fool, on Lord Mayor's day, was to jump clothes and all +into a large bowl of custard. To a certain extent he generally +corresponded with his name in having some mental weakness or +eccentricity, and it was a recommendation if he were dwarfish or +deformed. He wore a "motley" suit of discordant colours to make him +ridiculous, and correspond with the incongruity of his mind and +actions--a dress similar to the hundred patched _paniculus centunculus_ +of the Roman mimes. Sometimes he wore a petticoat or calf-skin to +resemble an idiot. Finally, he had his head shaved and wore a cowl to +make him like a monk, as his buffooneries would thus have a stranger +character, and the nobles had no great affection for the church.[50] The +domestic fool was common in the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries up to +the time of Louis XIV.; but it is said that there were such men at the +Court of Louis le Débonnaire. Giraldus Cambrenses writes that when he +was preaching for the Crusades in South Wales, one John Spang "who by +simulating fatuity, and having a quick tongue was wont to be a great +comfort to the court," said to Resus, the king: "You should be greatly +indebted to your relative the Archdeacon for sending a hundred of your +men to day to follow Christ, and if he had spoken Welsh I do not believe +that one of all your people would remain to you." This was towards the +end of the twelfth century, but it does not seem clear that John Spang +was a court jester. We may fairly consider that the institution of the +domestic fools, the employment of men, who professed jocularity as a +branch of art distinct from music and legerdemain increased mental +activity, and a growing desire for humour. But the men who made jesting +their profession were generally regarded with contempt, and an Act of +Parliament in the reign of Edward III. ordered strollers of this kind to +be whipped out of the town. An old satire written at the time of the +Reformation brings together actors, dustmen, jugglers, conjurers, and +sellers of indulgences. + +But we want something more than wits and drolleries, and even public +performances, to complete our idea of Comedy. We must have literary +composition and artistic construction. From songs of warlike +achievements such as were chanted by the old scalders to cheer their +chiefs over the bowl, there arose by degrees fanciful tales with which +the Saxons and their successors amused themselves after their dinner, +and round the blazing hearth. In the tenth century the clergy found +stories to amuse the post-prandial hour--extravagant, indelicate, or +profane--such were the times, but marking improved activity of thought. +Thus they enjoyed such a tale as that a "prophet" went to Heriger +(Archbishop of Mayence about 920) and told him he had been to the nether +world, a place, he said, surrounded by woods. The Archbishop replied +that, if that was the case, he would send his lean swine there to eat +acorns. The prophet added that afterwards he went to heaven, and saw +Christ and his saints sitting at table and eating; John the Baptist was +the butler, and served the wine, and St. Peter was the cook. The +Archbishop asked the stranger how he fared himself, and on his saying +that he sat in the corner and stole a piece of liver--Heriger instead of +praising his sanctity ordered him to be tied to a stake, and flogged for +theft. The "Supper," as old as the tenth century, is another humorous +description. A grave assembly of scriptural characters, from Adam and +Eve downwards, are invited, Cain sits on a plough, Abel on a milk-pail +&c.; two, Paul and Esau, are obliged to stand for want of room, and Job +complains of having nothing to sit on but a dunghill. Jonah is here the +butler. Samson brings honey to the dessert, and Adam apples-- + + "Tunc Adam poma ministrat, Samson favi dulcia. + David cytharum percussit, et Maria tympana, + Judith choreas ducebat et Jubal psalteria + Asael metra canebat, saltabat Herodias."[51] + +Thus stories, by degrees, began to be not only composed, but written, +and although not intended for acting, to be dignified with the old name +of "Comedies." Such poems were written by Robert Baston, who accompanied +Edward II. to Scotland. + +The Tournament of Tottenham is a merry story of this kind, written in +the reign of Henry VI. It is full of a rough kind of hostile humour, +and shows the sort of things which amused at that time. Here we have a +burlesque upon the deeds of chivalry. A mock tournament is held, the +prize is to be the Reve of Tottenham's daughter, a brood hen, a dun cow, +a grey mare, and a spotted sow. The combatants--clowns and +rustics--provide themselves with flails, and poles, and sheep skins + + "They armed tham in mattes; + They set on ther nollys (heads) + For to kape ther pollys, + Gode blake bollys (bowls) + For t' batryng of battes (cudgels)." + +The fierceness of the combat is described: + + "And fewe wordys spoken, + There were flayles al to-slatered, + Ther were scheldys al to-flatred, + Bollys and dysches al to-schatred, + And many hedys brokyn." + +We find some specimen of the kind of tales called Comedies, which +preceded acted Comedy, in the works of Chaucer, who died in 1400. +Scarcely any part of Chaucer's writings would raise a laugh at the +present day, though they might a blush.[52] But he was by no means a man +who revelled in indelicacy. We may suppose that he was moderate for the +time in which he lived, and when he makes an offensive allusion, he +usually adds some excuse for it. The antiquated language in which his +works are written prevents our now appreciating much of the humour they +contained; generally, there is more refinement and grace in his +writings. No doubt at the time he was thought witty, and his tendency in +this direction is shown by his praise of mirth in the "Romaunt of the +Rose." + + "Full faire was mirth, full long and high, + A fairer man I never sigh: + As round as apple was his face, + Full roddie and white in every place, + Fetis he was and well besey, + With meetly mouth and eyen gray, + His nose by measure wrought full right, + Crispe was his haire, and eke full bright, + His shoulderes of large trede + And smallish in the girdlestede: + He seemed like a purtreiture, + So noble was he of his stature, + So faire, so jolly, and so fetise + With limmes wrought at point devise, + Deliver smart, and of great might; + Ne saw thou never man so light + Of berd unneth had he nothing, + For it was in the firste spring, + Full young he was and merry of thought, + And in samette with birdes wrought + And with golde beaten full fetously + His bodie was clad full richely. + Wrought was his robe in straunge gise + And all slitttered for queintise + In many a place, low and hie, + And shode he was with great maistrie + With shoone decoped and with lace, + By drurie and by solace + His leefe a rosen chapelet + Had made, and on his head it set." + +He speaks in equally high terms of "Dame Gladnesse." + +We can appreciate Chaucer's address to his empty purse-- + + "To you my purse, and to none other wight + Complaine I, for ye be my lady dere, + I am sorry now that ye be light, + For certes ye now make me heauy chere + Me were as lefe laid vpon a bere, + For which vnto your mercy thus I crie + Be heauy againe or els mote I die. + + "Now vouchsafe this day or it be night + That I of you the blissful sowne may here, + Or see your colour like the sunne bright + That of yelowness had neuer pere; + Ye be my life, ye be my hertes stere + Queen of comfort, and good companie + Be heauy againe, or els mote I die. + + "Now purse that art to me my liues delight + And sauiour, as downe in this world here, + Out of this towne helpe me by your might + Sith that you woll not be my treasure, + For I am shave as nere as any frere, + But I pray vnto your curtesie + Be heauy againe, or els mote I die." + +Chaucer was very fond of allegory. This is especially visible not only +in the "Romaunt of the Rose," but in the "Court of Love," "Flower and +Leaf," the "House of Fame," and the "Cuckoo and Nightingale." In the +"Assembly of Fowls" we have a fable. Chaucer was attached to the service +of John of Gaunt, which may have led to his attacking the clergy, but in +his youth he was fined two shillings for beating a Franciscan friar in +Fleet Street. He favoured Wickliffe, and was for this reason eventually +obliged to flee the country; but he returned and obtained remunerative +appointments. It is said that on his death-bed he lamented the +encouragement which vice might receive from his writings, but their +indelicacy was not really great for the age in which he lived. + +Henry Heywood has been called the "Father of English Comedy," and he was +certainly one of the first that wrote original dramas, representing the +ordinary social life of this country. His pieces, which all appeared +before 1550, were short and simple, and seem to us very deficient in +delicacy and humour. But in his day he was considered a great wit, and +as a court-jester drew many a lusty laugh from old King Hal, and could +even soothe the rugged brow of the fanatical Mary. One of his best +sayings was addressed to her. When the Queen told Heywood that the +priests must forego their wives, he answered. "Then your Grace must +allow them _lemans_, for the clergy cannot live without sauce." He was +called the epigrammatist, but the greater part of his jests seem to have +little point. Some of them have been attributed to Sir Thomas More. + +One of the earliest English comedies written by Nicholas Udall, and +found entered in the books of the Stationers' Company in the year, +1566, is Royster Doister. + + "Which against the vayne glorious doth invey + Whose humour the roysting sort continually doth feede." + +The play turns on Ralph Royster Doister--a conceited fool--thinking +every woman must fall in love with him. Much of the humour is acoustic, +and depends on repetitions-- + + "Then twang with our sonnets, and twang with our dumps, + And hey hough for our heart, as heavie as lead lumps. + Then to our recorder with toodle doodle poope, + As the howlet out of an yvie bushe should hoope + Anon to our gitterne, thrumpledum, thrumpledrum thrum, + Thrumpledum, thrumpledum, thrumpledum, thrumpledum, thrum." + +Royster is duped into sending Custance a love-letter, telling her that +he seeks only her fortune, and that he will annoy her in every way after +marriage. On discovering the deception, he determines to take vengeance +on the scribbler who wrote the love-letter for him:-- + + "Yes, for although he had as many lives + As a thousande widowes and a thousande wives, + As a thousande lyons and a thousande rattes, + A thousande wolves and a thousande cattes, + A thousande bulles, and a thousande calves + And a thousande legions divided in halves, + He shall never 'scape death on my sworde's point + Though I shoulde be torne therefore joynt by joynt." + +Where he prepares to punish Custance and her friends for refusing him, +there is a play on the word "stomacke"--used for courage: + + _Ralph Royster._ Yea, they shall know, and thou knowest I have a + stomacke. + + _M.M._ A stomacke (quod you) you, as good as ere man had. + + _R. Royster._ I trowe they shall finde and feele that I am a lad. + + _M.M._ By this crosse I have seene you eate your meat as well. + + As any that ere I have seene of, or heard tell, + A stomacke quod you? he that will that denie, + I know was never at dynner in your companie. + + _R. Royster._ Nay, the stomacke of a man it is that I meane. + + _M.M._ Nay, the stomacke of a horse or a dogge I weene. + + _R. Royster._ Nay, a man's stomacke with a weapon mean I. + + _M.M._ Ten men can scarce match you with a spoon in a pie. + + +"Gammer Gurton's Needle" was acted in 1552. It bears marks of an early +time in its words being coarsely indelicate, but not amatory. The humour +is that of blows and insults and we may observe the great value then +attached to needles. It is "a right pithy, pleasant and merry comedy"--a +country story of an old dame who loses her needle when sewing a patch on +the seat of her servant Hodge's breeches. The cat's misdoings interrupt +her, and her needle is lost. The hunt for the needle is amusing, and +Gammer Gurton and Dame Chat, whom she suspects of having stolen it, +abuse and call each other witches. Hodge, the man with the patched +breeches encourages Gammer Gurton, who seems little to require it. + + "Smite, I say Gammer, + Bite, I say Gammer, + Where be your nails? Claw her by the jawes + Pull me out both her eyen. + + Hoise her, souse her, bounce her, trounce her, + Pull out her thrott." + +On some one giving Hodge a good slap, the needle runs into him, and is +thus happily found. + +At the opening of the second act of Gammer Gurton there is a drinking +song, which deserves notice as it was the first written in English,-- + + "I cannot eat but little meat + My stomack is not good: + But sure I think that I can drink + With him that wears a hood. + Though I go bare, take ye no care + I nothing am a colde; + I stuff my skin so full within + Of ioly good ale and olde. + Backe and side go bare, go bare, + Booth foot and hand go colde; + But belly, God send thee good ale inoughe, + Whether it be new or olde; + + "I love no rost, but a nut browne toste + And a crab laid in the fire; + A little bread shall do me stead + Moche bread I noght desire. + No frost, no snow, no wind I trowe + Can hurt me if I wolde. + I am so wrapt and throwly lapt + Of ioly good ale and olde. + Backe and side, &c. + + "And Tib my wife, that as her life + Loveth well good ale to seeke, + Full oft drinkes shee, till ye may see + The teares run downe her cheeke. + Then doth she trowle to me the bowle + Even as a mault-worm sholde, + And saith 'sweet heart I tooke my part + Of this ioly good ale and olde.' + Backe and side, &c. + + "Now let them drinke, till they nod and winke, + Even as good fellows should do; + They shall not misse to have the blisse + Good ale doth bring men to. + And al goode sowles that have scoured bowles, + Or have them lustely trolde, + God save the lives of them and their wives + Whether they be yong or olde. + Backe and side, &c." + + + + +CHAPTER IV. + +ROBERT GREENE. + +Robert Greene--Friar Bacon's Demons--The "Looking Glasse"--Nash and + Harvey. + + +One of the principal humorists at this time was Robert Greene, born at +Norwich about 1560. He was educated at Cambridge, and was generally +styled "Robert Greene, Maister of Artes." Early in life he became, as he +tells us, "an author of playes and a penner of love pamphlets." From the +titles of some of them, and from his motto, "_Omne tulit punctum qui +miscuit utile dulci_," it is evident that they were intended to be +humorous. Thus, his "Euphues" professes to contain "Mirth to purge +Melancholy;" his "Quips for an Vpstart Courtier" is "A Quaint Dispute +between Velvet-breeches and Cloth-breeches," and his "Notable Discovery +of Coosnage" has "a delightfull discourse of the coosnage of Colliers;" +his "Second and last part of conny-catching" has "new additions +containing many merry tales of all lawes worth the reading, because they +are worthy to be remembered. Discoursing strange cunning coosnage, which +if you reade without laughing, Ile give you my cap for a Noble." But in +all these works there is but little humour, and what we learn in reading +them is, that a very small amount of it was then thought considerable, +and that stories, which we should think slightly entertaining, appeared +in that simple age to be very ingenious and even comic. In the "Comicall +Historie of Alphonsus, King of Arragon," we do not find anything that +could have possibly been humorous, unless the speaking of a brazen head, +and the letting Venus down from Heaven and drawing her up again, could +have been so regarded. Greene is characteristic of his time in his love +of introducing magic and enchanters, and of characters from classic and +scripture history. In the "Looking-Glasse for London and England," in +which our metropolis is compared to Nineveh, we have angels and +magicians brought in. "A hand out of a cloud threateneth a burning +sword," and "Jonas is cast out of the whale's belly upon the stage." + +Greene is fond of introducing devils. In "The Honourable Historie of +Frier Bacon and Frier Bongay," Ralph says, "Why, Sirrah Ned we'll ride +to Oxford to Friar Bacon. O! he is a brave scholar, sirrah; they say he +is a brave necromancer, that he can make women of devils, and he can +juggle cats into coster-mongers." Further on in the same play a devil +and Miles, Bacon's servant, enter. + + _Miles._ A scholar, quoth you; marry, Sir, I would I had been a + bottle maker, when I was made a scholar, for I can get neither to + be a deacon, reader, nor schoolmaster. No, not the clerk of the + parish. Some call me dunce, another saith my head is full of Latin, + as an egg's full of oatmeal: thus I am tormented that the devil and + Friar Bacon haunt me. Good Lord, here's one of my master's devils! + I'll go speak to him. What Master Plutus, how cheer you? + + _D._ Dost know me? + + _M._ Know you, Sir? Why are not you one of my master's devils, that + were wont to come to my master, Doctor Bacon at Brazen-Nose? + + _D._ Yes, marry am I. + + _M._ Good Lord, Master Plutus, I have seen you a thousand times at + my master's; and yet I had never the manners to make you drink. + But, Sir, I am glad to see how comformable you are to the statutes. + I warrant you he's as yeomanly a man as you shall see; mark you, + masters, here's a plain honest man without welt or guard. But I + pray you Sir, do you come lately from hell? + + _D._ Ay, marry, how then? + + _M._ Faith, 'tis a place I have desired long to see: have you not + good tippling houses there? May not a man have a lusty fire there, + a good pot of ale, a pair of cards, a swinging piece of chalk, and + a brown toast that will clap a white waistcoat on a cup of good + drink. + + _D._ All this you may have there. + + _M._ You are for me, friend, and I am for you. But I pray you, may + I not have an office there? + + _D._ Yes, a thousand; what wouldst thou be? + + _M._ By my troth, Sir, in a place where I may profit myself. I know + hell is a hot place, and men are marvellous dry, and much drink is + spent there. I would be a tapster. + +In one play Greene introduces a court-fool, and he mixes with the +stupidity and knavery of his clowns, a sort of artificial philosophy +and argumentative ingenuity, which savours much of the old jesters. In +"James the Fourth" Slipper says:-- + + O mistress, mistress, may I turn a word upon you? + + _Countess._ Friend, what wilt thou? + + _Slipper._ O! what a happy gentlewoman be you truly; the world + reports this of you, mistress, that a man can no sooner come to + your house, but the butler comes with a black-jack, and says, + "Welcome, friend, here's a cup of the best for you," verily, + mistress, you are said to have the best ale in all Scotland. + + _Countess._ Sirrah, go fetch him drink [_an attendant brings + drink._] How likest thou this? + + _Slip._ Like it mistress! why this is quincy quarie, pepper de + watchet, single goby, of all that ever I tasted. I'll prove in this + ale, and toast the compass of the whole world. First, this is the + earth; it ties in the middle a fair brown toast, a goodly country + for hungry teeth to dwell upon; next this is the sea, a fair pool + for a dry tongue to fish in; now come I, and seeing the world is + naught, I divide it thus: and because the sea cannot stand without + the earth, as Aristotle saith, I put them both into their first + chaos, which is my belly, and so, mistress, you may see your ale is + become a miracle. + +Further on Slipper again shows his readiness in dialogue-- + + _Sir Bartram._ Ho, fellow! stay and let me speak with thee. + + _Slip._ Fellow! friend thou dost abuse me: I am a gentleman. + + _Sir B._ A gentleman! how so? + + _Slip._ Why, I rub horses, Sir. + + _Sir B._ And what of that? + + _Slip._ O simple-witted! mark my reason. They that do good service + in the commonweal are gentlemen, but such as rub horses do good + service in the commonweal, _ergo_, tarbox, master courtier, a + horse-keeper is a gentleman. + + _Sir B._ Here is over much wit in good earnest. But, sirrah, where + is thy master? + + _Slip._ Neither above ground nor under ground; drawing out red into + white, swallowing that down without chawing, which was never made + without treading. + + _Sir B._ Why, where is he then? + + _Slip._ Why in his cellar, drinking a cup of neat and brisk claret + in a bowl of silver. Oh, Sir, the wine runs trillill down his + throat, which cost the poor vintner many a stamp before it was + made. But I must hence, Sir, I have haste. + +Sir Bertram intimates that he wants his assistance, and will pay him. + + _Slip._ A good word, thou hast won me; this word is like a warm + caudle to a cold stomach. + + _Sir B._ Sirrah, wilt thou for money and reward + Convey me certain letters, out of hand, + From out thy master's pocket? + + _Slip._ Will I, Sir? Why were it to rob my father, hang my mother, + or any such like trifles, I am at your commandment, Sir. What will + you give me, Sir? + + _Sir B._ A hundred pounds. + + _Slip._ I am your man; give me earnest. I am dead at a pocket, Sir; + why I am a lifter, master, by occupation. + + _Sir B._ A lifter! what is that? + + Slip. Why, Sir, I can lift a pot as well as any man, and pick a + purse as soon as any thief in the country. + +These humorous characters remind us a little of the slaves and parasites +in Roman comedy, of whom, no doubt, Greene had read. His amusing fellows +are free livers, and fond of wine like himself. In the "Looking-Glasse" +above mentioned, Nineveh represents London, and a fast being proclaimed, +we find Adam, a smith's journeyman, trying to evade it. + + (_Enter Adam solus, with a bottle of beer in one slop (trouser) and + a great piece of beef in the other._) + + _Adam._ Well, goodman Jonas, I would you had never come from Jewry + to this country; you have made me look like a lean rib of roast + beef, or like the picture of Lent, painted upon a red-herring's + cob. Alas! masters, we are commanded by the proclamation to fast + and pray! By my troth, I could prettily so, so away with praying, + but for fasting, why 'tis so contrary to my nature, that I had + rather suffer a short hanging than a long fasting. Mark me, the + words be these: thou shalt take no manner of food for so many + days. I had as lief he should have said, thou shalt hang thyself + for so many days. And yet, in faith, I need not find fault with the + proclamation, for I have a buttery and a pantry and a kitchen about + me; for proof, _ecce signum_! This right slop is my pantry, behold + a manchet; this place is my kitchen, for lo! a piece of beef. O! + let me repeat that sweet word again!--for lo! a piece of beef. This + is my buttery, for see, see, my friends, to my great joy a bottle + of beer. Thus, alas! I make shift to wear out this fasting; I drive + away the time. But there go searchers about to seek if any man + breaks the king's command. O, here they be; in with your victuals, + Adam. + + (_Enter two Searchers._) + + _1st Searcher._ How duly the men of Nineveh keep the proclamation! + how they are armed to repentance! We have searched through the + whole city, and have not as yet found one that breaks the fast. + + _2nd Sear._ The sign of the more grace; but stay, there sits one, + methinks at his prayers; let us see who it is. + + _1st Sear._ 'Tis Adam, the smith's man. How, now, Adam? + + _Adam._ Trouble me not; thou shalt take no manner of food, but fast + and pray. + + _1st Sear._ How devoutly he sits at his orisons! But stay, methinks + I feel a smell of some meat or bread about him. + + _2nd Sear._ So thinks me too. You, Sirrah, what victuals have you + about you? + + _Adam._ Victuals! O horrible blasphemy! Hinder me not of my prayer, + nor drive me not into a choler. Victuals? why heardest thou not the + sentence, thou shalt take no food, but fast and pray? + + _2nd Sear._ Troth, so it should be; but, methinks, I smell meat + about thee. + + _Adam._ About me, my friends? these words are actions in the case. + About me? no! no! hang those gluttons that cannot fast and pray. + + _1st Sear._ Well, for all your words we must search you. + + _Adam._ Search me? take heed what you do! my hose are my castles; + 'tis burglary if you break ope a slop; no officer must lift up an + iron hatch; take heed, my slops are iron. + + _2nd Sear._ O, villain! See how he hath gotten victuals--bread, + beef and beer, where the king commanded upon pain of death none + should eat for so many days, not the sucking infant. + + _Adam._ Alas! Sir, this is nothing but a _modicum non nocet ut + medicus daret_; why, Sir, a bit to comfort my stomach. + + _1st Sear._ Villain! thou shalt be hanged for it. + + _Adam._ These are your words, I shall be hanged for it; but first + answer me this question, how many days have we to fast still? + + _2nd Sear._ Five days. + + _Adam._ Five days! a long time; then I must be hanged. + + _1st Sear._ Ay, marry must thou. + + _Adam._ I am your man, I am for you, Sir, for I had rather be + hanged than abide so long a fast. What! five days! Come, I'll + untruss. Is your halter, and the gallows, the ladder, and all such + furniture in readiness. + + _1st Sear._ I warrant thee thou shalt want none of these. + + _Adam._ But hear you, must I be hanged? + + _1st Sear._ Ay, marry. + + _Adam._ And for eating of meat. Then, friends, know ye by these + presents, I will eat up all my meat, and drink up all my drink, for + it shall never be said, I was hanged with an empty stomach. + +It has been supposed that Greene was very indelicate in his language, as +well as reckless in his life. But we cannot find in his plays anything +very offensive, considering the date at which he wrote, and in the tract +called "Greene's Funeralls," we read:-- + + His gadding Muse, although it ran of love, + Yet did he sweetly morralize his song; + Ne ever gaue the looser cause to laugh + Ne men of judgement for to be offended. + +Greene died in "most woefull and rascall estate" at the house of a poor +shoemaker near Dowgate. He had previously written his "Groat's-worth of +Wit bought with a Million of Repentance;" in which he warns his former +companions and "gentlemen who spend their wits in making playes," to +take warning by his fate. He could get none of his friends to visit him +at the last but Mistress Appleby, and the mother of "his base sonne +Infortunatus Greene." He gave the following note for his wife--whom he +had not seen for six years--to the shoemaker: + +"Doll, I charge thee by the love of our youth, and by my soule's rest, +that thow wilte see this man paide; for if hee and his wife had not +succoured me, I had died in the streetes. + + "ROBERT GREENE." + + +Gabriel Harvey writes, "My next businesse was to inquire after the +famous author who was reported to lye dangerously sicke in a shop neere +Dowgate, not of plague, but of a surfett of pickle herringe and rennish +wine." + +Thomas Nash was one of Greene's jolly companions at this fatal banquet. +After Greene's death Harvey replied to some reflections made upon him by +Greene, and called him in accordance with the amenities of the times, "a +wilde head, ful of mad braine and a thousand crotchets; a scholler, a +discourser, a courtier, a ruffian, a gamester, a lover, a souldier, a +trauailer, a merchant, a broker, an artificer, a botcher, a pettifogger, +a player, a coosener, a rayler, a beggar, an omnium-gatherum, a +gay-nothing, a stoare-house of bald and baggage stuffe, unworth the +answering or reading, a triuall and triobular autor for knaves and +fooles," &c., &c. + +Nash, although he seems to have forsaken Greene in his last distress, +became the defender of his character after his death, and answered this +vituperation by still coarser abuse and invective, saying, "Had hee +lived, Gabriel, and thou shouldest vnartifically and odiously libel +against him as thou hast done, he would have made thee an example of +ignominy to all ages that are to come, and driven thee to eate thy owne +booke buttered, as I saw him make an Appariter once in a tavern eate his +Citation, waxe and all, very handsomely served 'twixt two dishes.'" + +From this he proceeds to caricature Gabriel's person. "That word +complexion is dropt forth in good time, for to describe to you his +complexion and composition entred I with this tale by the way. It is of +an adust swarth chollericke dye, like restie bacon, or a dried +scate-fish; so leane and so meagre, that you wold thinke (with the +Turks) he observed 4 Lents in a yere, or take him for a gentleman's man +in the courtier, who was so thin-cheeked, and gaunt, and starv'd, that +as he was blowing the fire with his mouth the smoke took him up like a +light strawe, and carried him to the top or funnell of the chimney, wher +he had flowne out God knowes whither if there had not been crosse barres +overthwart that stayde him; his skin riddled and crumpled like a piece +of burnt parchment; and more channels and creases he hath in his face +than there be fairie circles on Salsburie Plaine, and wrinckles and +frets of old age, than characters on Christ's sepulcher in Mount +Calvarie, on which euerie one that comes scrapes his name, and sets his +marke to shewe that hee hath been there; so that whosoever shall behold +him + + "Esse putet Boreæ triste furentis opus," + +will sweare on a book I have brought him lowe, and shrowdly broken him; +which more to confirme, look on his head, and you shall find a gray +haire for euery line I have writ against him; and you shall have all his +beard white too, by that time he hath read over this booke. For his +stature, he is such another pretie Jacke-a-Lent as boyes throw at in the +streete, and lookes in his blacke sute of veluet, like one of these +jet-droppes which divers weare at their eares instead of a iewell. A +smudge peice of a handsome fellow it hath been in his dayes, but now he +is olde and past his best, and fit for nothing but to be a nobleman's +porter, or a knight of Windsor." + +Nash was so full of invective and personal abuse that he scarcely +deserved the name of a satirist, and so great was the animosity with +which the quarrel between him and Gabriel Harvey was conducted, that the +Archbishop of Canterbury and Bishop of London issued an order in 1599 +that all such books "be taken wheresoever they be found, and that none +of the said books be ever printed hereafter." + +His humour was remarkable, as it largely consisted of coining long and +almost unintelligible words. This he laid great store by, and he speaks +wrathfully of one who translated his "Piers Penniless," into what he +calls "maccaronical language." In his "Lenten Stuffe or Praise of the +Red Herring," _i.e._, of Great Yarmouth, he calls those who despised +Homer in his life-time "dull-pated pennifathers," and says that "those +grey-beard huddle-duddles and crusty cum-twangs were strooke with +stinging remorse of their miserable euchonisme and sundgery." + +Peele was one of the gay play-writers to whom Greene addressed his +warning. They seem at this time to have united the professions of +dramatist and actor, and to have been infected with that dissipation +which has since been attributed with more or less justice to the stage. +Peele is as fond as Greene of surprises and miraculous interventions. In +the "Arraignment of Paris" a golden tree grows up, and in the "Old Wives +Tale," the most humorous of his works, the head of Huanebango rises from +a well. He is fond of dealing in phonetic words Latinisms and +barbarisms; in one place he makes Corebus say: + + "O _falsum Latinum_ + The fair maid is _minum_ + _Cum apurtinantibus gibletis_ and all." + +Peele was very popular in his day, and was often called upon to write +pieces for the Lord Mayor and for royal receptions. He sometimes used +Hexameter lines such as: + + "Dub, dub-a-dub bounce, quoth the guns with + a sulphurous huff shuff." + +Gabriel Harvey first introduced this metre into English, and he tried to +induce Spenser to adopt it. Nash calls it "that drunken staggering kind +of verse which is all vp hill and downe hill, like the way betwixt +Stamford and Beechfeild, and goes like a horse plunging through the mire +in the deep of winter, now soust vp to the saddle and straight aloft on +his tip-toes." + + + + +CHAPTER V. + +Donne--Hall--Fuller. + + +Already we have seen that some of our earliest humorists were +ecclesiastics, and it would be unfitting that we should here overlook +three eminent men, Donne, Hall, and Fuller. Pleasantry was with them +little more than a vehicle of instruction; the object was not to +entertain, but to enforce and illustrate their moral sentiments. Hence +their sober quaintness never raises a laugh, much less does it border +upon the profane or indelicate. + +Donne was born in 1573, in London, and was educated, as was not then +uncommon, first at Oxford, and then at Cambridge. His ability in church +controversy attracted the attention of James, and he was made chaplain +to the King. He became preacher at Lincoln's Inn, and afterwards was +made Dean of St. Paul's. He lived to be fifty-eight. + +His sermons are full of antitheses and epigrammatic diction. There is +an airy lightness in his letters and poems, but he scarcely ever +actually reaches humour. The following poem, an epistle to Sir Edmund +Herbert at Juliers, will give an idea of his style. + + "Man is a lump, where all beasts kneaded be, + Wisdom makes him an ark where all agree; + The fool in whom these beasts do live at jar, + Is sport to others, and a theatre. + Nor scapes he so, but is himself their prey, + All which was man in him is eat away, + And now his beasts on one another feed, + Yet couple in anger, and new monsters breed. + How happy's he, which hath due place assigned + To his beasts, and disaforested his mind! + Empaled himself to keep them out, not in, + Can sow, and dares trust corn where they've been; + Can use his horse, goat, wolf, and every beast, + And is not ass himself to all the rest." + +Bishop Hall was born in 1574, and commenced his extensive literary +labours by writing when twenty-three years of age, at Emmanuel College, +Cambridge, three books of satires called Virgidemiæ. These books he +calls "_Toothless_ Satyres, _poetical_, _academical_, _and moral_," and +he attacks bad writers, astrologers, drunkards, gallants, and others. +Alluding to the superabundance of indifferent poetry in his days, he +says:-- + + "Let them, that mean by bookish business + To earn their bread, or holpen to profess + Their hard-got skill, let them alone for me + Busy their brains with deeper bookery. + Great gains shall bide you sure, when ye have spent + A thousand lamps, and thousand reams have rent + Of needless papers; and a thousand nights + Have burned out with costly candle-lights." + +In the following year, he produced three books of "Byting Satyres." In +these he laughs at the effeminacy of the times--the strange dresses and +high heels. + + "When comely striplings wish it were their chance + For Cænis' distaff to exchange their lance, + And wear curled periwigs, and chalk their face + And still are poring on their pocket-glass; + Tired with pinned ruffs and fans and partlet strips + And busks and verdingales about their hips; + And tread on corked stilts, a prisoner's pace, + And make their napkin for a spitting place, + And gripe their waist within a narrow span, + Fond Cænis that wouldst wish to be a man!" + +The most severe is against the Pope:-- + + "To see an old shorn lozel perched high + Crossing beneath a golden canopy; + The whiles a thousand hairless crowns crouch low + To kiss the precious case of his proud toe; + And for the lordly fasces borne of old + To see two quiet crossed keys of gold; + But that he most would gaze and wonder at + To the horned mitre and the bloody hat, + The crooked staff, the cowl's strange form and store + Save that he saw the same in hell before; + To see the broken nuns, with new shorn heads + In a blind cloister toss their idle heads." + +Although Bishop Hall wrote learnedly and voluminously on theological +subjects, this light medley is now more esteemed than his graver works. +He claimed upon the strength of it to be the earliest English satirist, +and perhaps none of our writings of this kind had as yet been of equal +importance. The work was one of those condemned to the flames by +Whitgift and Bancroft. + +Fuller was born in Northamptonshire, in 1608. He became a distinguished +man at Cambridge, where he obtained a fellowship at Sidney Sussex +College. He was also an eminent preacher in London, and a prebendary of +Salisbury. In the Civil War, being a stanch Royalist, he was driven from +place to place, and held at one time the interesting post of "Infant +Lady's Chaplain" to the Princess Henrietta. In his "Worthies of +England," Fuller not only enumerates the eminent men for which each +country is distinguished, but gives an account of its products and +proverbs. "A Proverb is much matter decocted into few words. Six +essentials are wanting to it--that it be short, plain, common, +figurative, ancient, true." The most ordinary subject is enlivened by +his learned and humorous mind. Thus, in Bedfordshire, under the head of +"Larks," he tells us, "The most and best of these are caught and +well-dressed about Dunstable in this shire. A harmless bird while +living, not trespassing on grain, and wholesome when dead, then filling +the stomach with meat, as formerly the ear with music. In winter they +fly in flocks, probably the reason why _Alauda_ signifieth in Latin both +a lark and a legion of soldiers; except any will say a legion is so +called because helmeted on their heads and crested like a lark, +therefore also called in Latin _Galerita_. If men would imitate the +early rising of this bird, it would conduce much unto their +healthfulness." + +Fuller abounds with figures and illustrations in which learning and +humour are excellently intermingled. "They that marry where they do not +love, will love where they do not marry." "He knows little, who will +tell his wife all he knows." Speaking of children, he says that a man +complained that never father had so undutiful a child as he. "Yes," said +the son, "my grandfather had." Alluding to servants, and saying that the +Emperor Charles the Fifth being caught in a tempest had many horses +thrown overboard to save the lives of the slaves--which were not of so +great market-value--he asks, "Are there not many that in such a case had +rather save Jack the horse than Jockey the keeper?" Of widows' evil +speaking he observes, "Foolish is their project who, by raking up bad +savours against their former husbands, think thereby to perfume their +bed for a second marriage." Of celibacy he says, "If Christians be +forced to run races for their lives, the unmarried have the advantage of +being lighter by many ounces!" + +Speaking of the "Controversial Divine," he says, "What? make the Muses, +yea the Graces scolds? Such purulent spittle argues exulcerated lungs. +Why should there be so much railing about the body of Christ, when there +was none about the body of Moses in the act kept betwixt the devil and +Michael, the Archangel?" On schoolmasters he wrote, "That schoolmaster +deserves to be beaten himself, who beats Nature in a boy for a fault. +And I question whether all the whipping in the world can make their +parts, that are naturally sluggish, rise one minute before the hour +Nature hath appointed." + +The following are some good sayings that have been selected from his +works by an eminent humorist:-- + + _Virtue in a short person._ "His soul had but a short diocese to + visit, and therefore might the better attend the effectual + informing thereof." + + _Intellect in a very tall one._ "Oft times such, who are built four + storeys high, are observed to have little in their cock-loft." + + _Mr. Perkins, the Divine._ "He would pronounce the word Damn with + such an emphasis, as left a doleful echo in his auditor's ears a + good while after." + + _Memory._ "Philosophers place it in the rear of the head; and it + seems the mine of memory lies there, because men there naturally + dig for it, scratching it when they are at a loss." + +To this we may add something from his "Holy State,"--a pleasant and +profitable work, in which Fuller is happy in making his humour subserve +the best ends:--Of "The Good Wife," he says, "She never crosseth her +husband in the spring-tide of his anger, but stays till it be +ebbing-water. And then mildly she argues the matter, not so much to +condemn him as to acquit herself. Surely men, contrary to iron, are +worst to be wrought upon when they are hot, and are far more tractable +in cold blood. It is an observation of seamen, 'That if a single meteor +or fire-ball falls on their mast, it portends ill-luck; but if two come +together (which they count Castor and Pollux) they presage good +success.' But sure in a family it bodeth most bad when two fire balls +(husband's and wife's anger) both come together." In speaking of good +parents, he says, "A father that whipt his son for swearing, and swore +at him while he whipt him, did more harm by his example than good by his +correction." + + + + +CHAPTER VI. + +Shakespeare--Ben Jonson--Beaumont and Fletcher--The Wise Men of Gotham. + + +Greene, in his admonition to his brother sinners of the stage, tells +them that "there is an vpstart crow beautified with our feathers an +absolute Johannes factotum, in his own conceyt the onely Shake-scene in +a countrey," and in truth these olden writers are principally +interesting as having laid the foundations upon which Shakespeare built +some of his earliest plays. The genius of our great dramatist was +essentially poetic, and some of his plays, which we now call comedies, +were originally entitled "histories." How seldom do we hear any of his +humorous passages quoted, or find them reckoned among our household +words! From some of his observations we might think he was altogether +averse from jocosity. Henry V. says + + "How ill gray hairs become a fool--a jester!" + +In "Much ado about Nothing," Beatrice speaks as follows-- + + "Why, he is the Prince's jester; a very dull fool, only his gift is + in devising unprofitable slanders; none but libertines delight in + him, and the commendation is not in his wit, but in his villany, + for he both pleases men and angers them, and then they laugh at him + and beat him." + +But notwithstanding all this condemnation Beatrice is herself the +liveliest character in Shakespeare, and her lady's wit is some of the +best he shows-- + + _Beatrice._ For hear me, Hero; wooing, wedding, and repenting is as + a Scotch jig, a measure and a cinque-pace; the first suit is hot + and hasty, like a Scotch jig, and full as fantastical; the wedding + mannerly-modest, as a measure full of state and ancientry; and then + comes repentance, and with his bad legs, falls into the cinque-pace + faster and faster, till he sinks into his grave. + + _Leonato._ Cousin, you apprehend shrewdly. + + _Beat._ I have a good eye, uncle; I can see a church, by daylight. + +In the "Merchant of Venice" Lorenzo thus answers Launcelot-- + + "How every fool can play upon the word. I think the best grace of + wit will shortly turn into silence, and discourse grow commendable + in none but parrots." + +Again Lorenzo-- + + "Oh, dear discretion, how his words are suited, + The fool hath planted in his memory + An army of good words: And I do know + A many fools that stand in better place + Garnished like him, that for a tricksie word + Defie the matter." + +Comedians from Aristophanes downwards have been wont to complain in one +place of that which they adopt in another--their object not being to +adopt fixed principles so much as to show the varying shades of human +thought. Shakespeare required something light to bring his deep +reflections into bolder relief, and therefore frequently had recourse to +humour. We are not surprised that he had no very high estimate of it, +when we find him so much dependant upon "the alms-basket of words." +There is so much of this in his plays, that it is almost superfluous to +quote, but a few instances may be taken at random. Falstaff to Poins-- + + "You are straight enough in the shoulders; you care not who sees + your back--call you that backing your friends? A plague upon such + backing; give me a man who will face me." + +Falstaff to Prince Henry. Act I. Scene II. + + I prythee, sweet wag, when thou art king, as God save thy + grace--majesty, I should say, for grace thou wilt have none-- + + _P. Hen._ What! none? + + _Fal._ No, by my troth; not so much as will serve to be prologue to + an egg and butter. + +In Love's Labour Lost. Act I. Scene II. + + _Armado._ Comfort me, boy. What great men have been in love? + + _Inoth._ Hercules, master. + + _Arm._ Most sweet Hercules! More authority, dear boy, name more; + and, sweet my child, let them be men of good repute and carriage. + + _Inoth._ Samson, master; he was a man of good carriage, for he + raised the town gates on his back like a porter, and he was in + love. + +In the musicians scene, in Romeo and Juliet, Act IV. Scene V. we find-- + + _Musician._ Pray you put up your dagger, and put out your wit. + + _Peter._ Then have at you with my wit. I will dry beat you with my + iron wit, and put up my iron dagger. Answer me like: + + When griping grief the heart doth wound, + And doleful dumps the mind oppress, + Then music with her silver sound-- + + Why _silver_ sound? Why music with her silver sound? What say you, + Simon Catling? + + _First Mins._ Marry, Sir, because silver hath a sweet sound. + + _Peter._ Pretty. What say you, Hugh Rebeck? + + _Sec. Mins._ I say "silver sound," because musicians sound for + silver. + + _Peter._ Pretty, too! What say you, James Soundpost? + + _Third Mins._ Faith! I know not what to say. + + _Peter._ O! I cry for mercy; you are the singer; I will say for + you. It is music with her silver sound, because musicians have no + gold for sounding. + +We may here observe that the puns of Shakespeare are never of the +"atrocious" class; there is always something to back them up, and give +them a shadow of probability. The tournaments of humour which he is fond +of introducing, although good in effect upon the stage, are not +favourable for any keen wit. Such conflicts must be kept up by artifice, +cannot flow from natural suggestion, and degenerate into a mere +splintering of words. One cause of the absence of "salt" in his writings +is that he was not of a censorious or cynical spirit; another was that +his turn of mind was rather sentimental than gay. Shakespeare evidently +knew there might be humour among men of attainments, for he writes,-- + + "None are so surely caught, when they are catched, + As wit turned fool; folly is wisdom hatched, + Hath wisdom's warrant and the help of school + And wits' own grace to grace a learned fool." + +But with him, those who indulge in it are clowns, simpletons, and +profligates. Few of his grand characters are witty. Perhaps he was +conscious of the great difficulty there would be in finding suitable +sayings for them. Indelicacy and hostility would have to be alike +avoided, and thus when the sage Gonzalo is to be amusing, he sketches a +Utopian state of things, which he would introduce were he King of the +island on which they are cast. He would surpass the golden age. +Sebastian and Antonio laugh at him, and cry "God save the King," Alonzo +replies "Prythee, no more, thou dost talk nothing (_i.e._ nonsense) to +me." Gonzalo replies that he did so purposely "to minister occasion to +those gentlemen, who are of such sensible and nimble lungs that they +always use to laugh at nothing." They retort that they were not laughing +at his humour, but at himself. "Who," he replies, "in this merry fooling +am nothing to you" meaning, apparently, that he is acting the fool +intentionally and out of his real character. + +Hamlet, when his mind is distraught, "like sweet bells jangled," is +allowed to indulge in a little punning, and Biron is humorous, for which +he is reproached by Rosalind, who tells him that he is one + + "Whose influence is begot of that loose grace + Which shallow laughing hearers give to fools;" + +that only silly thoughtless people admire wit, and that + + "A jest's prosperity lies in the ear + Of him that hears it--never in the tongue + Of him that makes it." + +Here the variable character of humour is recognised, but it is not to be +supposed that Rosalind's arguments were intended to be strictly correct. +Very much must depend upon the form in which a jest is produced, and +without the tongue of the utterer, it cannot exist though the sympathy +of the listener is required for its appreciation. + +In Shakespeare's plays, and in most comedies we find humour in the +representation of ludicrous characters. Words, which would be dull +enough in ordinary cases, become highly amusing when coming from men of +peculiar views. Sometimes people are represented as perpetually riding +their hobby, or harping on one favourite subject. We have an instance of +this in Holophernes and his pedantry; and the conversation between the +two gravediggers in Hamlet, is largely indebted for its relish to the +contrast between the language of the men and their occupation. In the +same way, the ignorance and misrepresentations of rustics in play +acting, which Shakespeare had probably often observed in the +provinces--gives zest to the exaggerated caricature in "Midsummer +Night's Dream."-- + + _Bottom._ There are things in this comedy of Pyramus and Thisbe + that will never please. First, Pyramus must draw a sword to kill + himself, which ladies cannot abide. How answer you that? + + _Snout._ By'r lakin a parlous fear. + + _Starveling._ I believe we must leave the killing out, when all is + done. + + _Bottom._ Not a whit. I have a device to make all well. Write me a + prologue, and let the prologue seem to say, we will not do harm + with our swords, and that Pyramus is not killed indeed; and for the + more better assurance, tell them that I, Pyramus, am not Pyramus, + but Bottom the weaver; this will put them out of fear. + + * * * * * + + _Snout._ Will not the ladies be afeard of the lion? + + _Sta._ I fear it, I promise you. + + _Bottom._ Masters, you ought to consider with yourselves to bring + in--God shield us! a lion among ladies is a most dreadful thing; + for there is not a more fearful wildfowl than your lion living, and + we ought to look to it. + + _Snout._ Therefore another prologue must tell, he is not a lion. + + _Bottom._ Nay, you must name his name, and half his face must be + seen through the lion's neck; and he must himself speak through, + saying thus, or to the same effect--"Ladies," or "Fair ladies, I + would wish you," or "I would request you," or "I would entreat you + not to fear, nor to tremble: my life for yours. If you think I come + hither as a lion, it were pity of my life: no, I am no such thing. + I am a man as other men are," and there then let him name his name + and tell them plainly he is Snug the joiner. + +When the play comes on for performance and Snug the joiner roars "like +any sucking dove," the Duke Theseus remarks-- + + A very gentle beast, and of a good conscience. + + _Demetrius._ The very best as a beast, my lord, that e'er I saw. + + _Lysander._ This lion is a very fox for his valour. + + _Theseus._ True, and a goose for his discretion. + + _Demetrius._ Not so, my lord, for his valour cannot carry his + discretion, and the fox carries the goose. + + _Theseus._ His discretion, I am sure, cannot carry his valour, for + the goose carries not the fox. + +The enigmas and logical quibbles, which he occasionally intermingles +with his verbal conceits, remind us of the old philosophic paradoxes. +Sometimes a riddle is attempted; thus, he asks--"What was a month old at +Cain's birth, that's not five weeks old now?" Answer--"The Moon." + +Taken generally, there is such a remarkable uniformity in Shakespeare's +humour as must acquit him of all charge of plagiarism in this respect, +and may go some way towards proving the general originality of his +plays. Certainly, verbal conceits were then in high favour, and the +character of Shakespeare's humour is only one of many proofs that +pleasantry had not at this time reached its highest excellence. + +To Shakespeare's kindness and discretion Ben Jonson owed his first +introduction to dramatic fame. The young poet had presented "Every Man +in his Humour," to one of the leading players of the company to which +Shakespeare belonged, and the comedian upon reading it, determined to +refuse it. Jonson's fate was trembling in the balance; he was a +struggling man, and, had he been unsuccessful, might have eventually, +returned to his bricklayer's work, but he was destined to be raised up +for his own benefit and that of others. Shakespeare was present when his +play was about to be rejected, asked to be allowed to look over it, and, +at once recognising the poet's talent, recommended it to his companions. +From that moment Jonson's career was secured. But he was never destined +to acquire the lasting fame of Shakespeare. With him the stream of +Comedy was losing its deep and strong reflections, and beginning to flow +in a swifter and shallower current, meandering through labyrinths of +court and city life. Perhaps, also, his large amount of humorous +illustration, which must have been mostly ephemeral, tended to cut short +his fame. The best of it is interwoven with his several designs and +plots, as where, in "The Alchemist," a gentleman leaves his house in +town, and his housekeeper fills it with fortune-tellers vagabonds, who +carry on their trade there; and in "The Fox" a rich and childless man is +courted by his friends, from whom he obtains presents under the pretence +that he will leave them his property. In this last play a parasite is +introduced, and in general these plays abound with classical allusions, +sometimes very incongruously intermixed with modern concerns. An +indiscriminating admiration of ancient literature and art was as much +one of the features of the day, as was its crude humour--a cleverness +joined to folly and attributed to boobies and simpletons. Much of this +jocosity scarcely deserves the name of humour, and we may remark that in +Jonson's time it did not receive it. With him humour is thus defined-- + + "To be a quality of air or water, + And in itself holds these two properties, + Moisture and fluxure.... Now thus far + It may by metaphor apply itself + Unto the general disposition: + As when some one peculiar quality + Doth so possess a man, that it doth draw + All his affects, his spirits, and his power." + +The social peculiarities of the day are frequently alluded to by Jonson. +In "Every Man out of his own Humour," we have complete directions for +the conduct of a gentleman of the time. Smoking, then lately introduced, +is especially mentioned as one of the necessities of foppery. Cob, a +water-bearer says, "Ods me, I marle what pleasure or felicity they have +in taking this roguish tobacco. It's good for nothing but to choke a +man, and fill him full of smoke and embers: there were four died out of +one house last week with taking of it, and two more the bell went for +yesternight; one of them they say will never 'scape it: he cast up a +bushel of soot yesterday." + +In Cynthia's Revels a courtier is thus described-- + +"He walks most commonly with a clove or toothpick in his mouth: he is +the very mint of compliment, all his behaviours are pointed: his face is +another volume of essays, and his beard is Aristarchus. He speaks all +cream skimmed, and more affected than a dozen waiting women. The other +gallant is his zany, and doth most of these tricks after him, sweats to +imitate him in everything to a hair, except his beard, which is not yet +extant." + +But the stamp of the age is especially prominent in the constant +recurrence of verbal conceits. Jonson was fond of coining words, and of +using such as are long and little known. He evidently found this a +successful kind of humour, and may have partly imitated Plautus-- + +Lady Politick Would-be, to Volpone, supposed sick-- + + Seed pearl were good now, boiled with syrup of apples, + Tincture of gold, and coral, citron pills, + Your elicampane root, myrobalanes-- + + _Volpone (tired with her talk)_ Ah me! I have ta'en a grasshopper + by the wing. + +In "The Alchemist" Subtle says to Face, + + Sirrah my varlet, stand you forth and speak to him + Like a philosopher: answer in the language, + Name the vexations and the martyrizations + Of metals in the work. + + Face. Sir, putrefaction, + Solution, ablution, sublimation, + Cohabation, calcination, ceration and + Fixation. + +From "Every Man out of his Humour." + + _Macilente._ Pork! heart! what dost thou with such a greasy dish? I + think thou dost varnish thy face with the fat on't, it looks so + like a glue-pot. + + _Carlo._ True, my raw-boned rogue, and if thou wouldst farce thy + lean ribs with it too, they would not like rugged laths, rub out so + many doublets as they do; but thou knowest not a good dish thou. No + marvel though, that saucy stubborn generation, the Jews, were + forbidden it, for what would they have done, well pampered with fat + pork, that durst murmur at their Maker out of garlick and onions? + 'Slight! fed with it--the strummel-patched, goggle-eyed, + grumbledones would have gigantomachized.-- + +The following extracts will give a slight idea of Ben Jonson's varied +talent. At the conclusion of a play directed against plagiarists and +libellers, he sums up-- + + "Blush, folly, blush! here's none that fears + The wagging of an ass's ears, + Although a wolfish case he wears. + Detraction is but baseness varlet + And apes are apes, though clothed in scarlet." + +From "The Alchemist." + + + _Tribulation._ What makes the devil so devilish, I would ask you. + Sathan our common enemy, but his being + Perpetually about the fire, and boiling + Brimstone and arsenic?... + + _Fastidious._ How like you her wit. + + _Macilente._ Her ingenuity is excellent, Sir. + + _Fast._ You see the subject of her sweet fingers there (_the viol_) + oh, she tickles it so that--she makes it laugh most divinely--I'll + tell you a good jest just now, and yourself shall say it's a good + one. I have wished myself to be that instrument, I think a thousand + times, and not so few by heaven. + +The two following are from "Bartholomew Fair." + + _Littlewit._ I envy no man my delicates, Sir. + + _Winwife._ Alas, you have the garden where they grow still. A wife + here with a strawberry breath, cherry lips, apricot cheeks, and a + soft velvet head like a melicotton. + + _Lit._ Good i' faith! now dulness upon us, that I had not that + before him, that I should not light on't as well as he! Velvet + head!... + + _Knockem._ Sir, I will take your counsel, and cut my hair, and + leave vapours. I see that tobacco and bottle ale, and pig and whit, + and very Ursula herself is all vanity. + + _Busy._ Only pig was not comprehended in my admonition--the rest + were: for long hair, it is an ensign of pride, a banner: and the + world is full of those banners--very full of banners. And bottle + ale is a drink of Satan's, a diet-drink of Satan's devised to puff + us up, and make us swell in this latter age of vanity; as the smoke + of tobacco to keep us in mist and error: but the fleshly woman, + which you call Ursula, is above all to be avoided, having the marks + upon her of the three enemies of man--the world, as being in the + Fair, the Devil, as being in the fire;[53] and the flesh as being + herself. + +Ben Jonson has a strange, and I believe original conceit of introducing +persons to explain their plays, and make remarks on the characters. +Sometimes many interruptions of this kind occur in the course of a +drama, affording variety and amusement to the audience, or the reader. +In "Midsummer's Night's Dream" we have the insertion of a play within a +play. The following taken from Jonson's epigrams have fine complexity, +and show a certain tinge of humour. + + + THE HOUR GLASS. + + "Consider this small dust here in the glass, + By atoms moved: + Could you believe that this the body was + Of one that loved; + And in his mistress' flame, playing like a fly, + Was turned to cinders by her eye: + Yes; and in death as like unblest, + To have't exprest, + Ev'n ashes of lovers find no rest." + + + MY PICTURE.--LEFT IN SCOTLAND. + + I now think Love is rather deaf than blind, + For else it could not be + That she, + Whom I adore so much, should so slight me, + And cast my suit behind; + I'm sure my language to her was as sweet, + And every close did meet + In sentence of as subtle feet, + As hath the youngest, he, + That sits in shadow of Apollo's tree. + Oh! but my conscious fears + That fly my thoughts between + Tell me that she hath seen + My hundreds of gray hairs, + Told seven and forty years, + Read so much waste, as she cannot embrace + My mountain belly, and my rocky face, + And all these through her eyes have stopt her ears. + +Although fond of indulging in strong language, Jonson is scarcely ever +guilty of any really coarse allusion--he expresses his aversion from +anything of the kind, and this in the age in which he lived, argued +great refinement of feeling. + +In Fletcher we mark a progress in humour. Ben Jonson was so personal +that he made enemies, and was suspected of attacking Inigo Jones and +others, but Fletcher was general in his references, and merely ridiculed +the manners of the age. The classic element disappears, and quibbling +and playing with words--so fashionable in Shakespeare's time--is not +found in this author, whose humour has more point, and generally more +sarcasm, but of a refined character. + +The name of Fletcher is invariably connected with Beaumont. The two +young men lived together in the same house, and it is even said wore +each other's clothes. But Beaumont only lived to be twenty-nine, and has +left little in comparison with the voluminous works of Fletcher. They +were both born in a good position, and, mingling in the fashionable +society of their day, filled their pages with love intrigues, in colours +not then offensive. Fletcher never married, and those who look for +contrasts between fathers and children may learn that his father, who +was Bishop of London, was suspended by Elizabeth for taking a second +wife. Our author is said to have been himself a comedy, and his death, +if we can believe the story, was consistent with his gay life, for we +are told that, through waiting in London for a new suit of clothes, he +died of cholera, which was raging there at the time. + +Here is a specimen of his sketches--the character of a rich usurer-- + + _Sanchio._ Thou'art very brave. + + _Cacafogo._ I've reason; I have money. + + _San._ Is money reason? + + _Cac._ Yes, and rhyme too, captain. + If you've no money you're an ass. + + _San._ I thank you. + + _Cac._ You've manners! ever thank him that has money. + + _San._ Wilt thou lend me any? + + _Cac._ Not a farthing, captain; captains are casual things. + + _San._ Why, so are all men: + Thou shalt have my bond. + + _Cac._ Nor bonds, nor fetters, captain: + My money is my own; I make no doubt on't. + + _Juan._ What dost thou do with it? + + _Cac._ Put it to pious uses-- + Buy wine-- + + _Juan._ Are you for the wars, Sir? + + _Cac._ I am not poor enough to be a soldier, + Nor have I faith enough to ward a bullet; + This is no living for a trench, I take it. + + _Juan._ You have said wisely. + + _Cac._ Had you but money + + You'd swear it, colonel. I'd rather drill at home + A hundred thousand crowns, and with more honour, + Than exercise ten thousand fools with nothing; + A wise man safely feeds, fools cut their fingers. + +The prurient coarseness of Fletcher is due to the peculiar +licentiousness of the period. In his plays, although kissing is +sometimes provocative of jealousy, it is generally regarded, even by +persons of rank, as of less importance than it is now by boys and girls, +who play "Kiss in the ring." In "Rule a wife and have a wife" Margarita +says to the Duke + + "I may kiss a stranger, + For you must be so now." + +This lady is desirous of obtaining a very easy husband, who will let her +do whatever she likes. A friend says she has found one for her in Leon, +who is forthwith introduced. Margarita puts some questions to him to +ascertain his docility, and then says-- + + "Let me try your kisses-- + How the fool shakes!--I will not eat you, Sir. + Beshrew my heart, he kisses wondrous manly! + You must not look to be my master, Sir, + Nor talk i' th' house as though you wore the breeches, + No, nor command in anything. . . You must not be saucy, + No, nor at any time familiar with me; + Scarce know me when I call not." + +After trying and approving his kisses again, she tells him that he is +not to start or be offended if he sees her kissing anyone else. He is to +keep in the cellar, when not wanted. The proposed husband promises to be +most obedient and accommodating in everything, but as soon as he is +accepted and the ceremony performed, he appears in a totally different +character. He informs his wife, in whose magnificent house he goes to +live-- + + You've nothing to do here, Madam, + But as a servant to sweep clean the lodgings, + And at my farther will to do me service. + _Margarita_ (_to her servants._) Get me my coach! + _Leon._ Let me see who dare get it + Till I command; I'll make him draw your coach + And eat your couch, (which will be hard duty). + +On Cacafogo making some slighting remark, this gentle individual +exclaims-- + + "Peace! dirt and dunghill! + I will not lose mine anger on a rascal; + Provoke me more,--I will beat thy blown body + Till thou rebound'st again like a tennis-ball." + +In "Monsieur Thomas" we have the following jovial passage-- + + _Francisco._ What hast thou there? a julep? + + _Hylas._ He must not touch it; + 'Tis present death. + + _Thomas._ You are an ass, a twirepipe, + A Jeffery John Bo-peep! Thou minister? + Thou mend a left-handed pack-saddle? Out! puppy! + My Friend, Frank, but a very foolish fellow. + Dost thou see that bottle? view it well. + + _Fran._ I do, Tom. + + _Tho._ There be as many lives in it as a cat carries; + 'Tis everlasting liquor. + + _Fran._ What? + + _Tho._ Old sack, boy. + Old reverend sack; which for ought that I can read yet + Was the philosopher's stone the wise King Ptolomus + Did all his wonders by. + + _Fran._ I see no harm, Tom. + Drink with a moderation. + + _Tho._ Drink with sugar, + Which I have ready here, and here a glass, boy. + + * * * * * + + Hang up your juleps, and your Portugal possets, + Your barley broths and sorrel soups; they are mangy + And breed the scratches only: Give me sack! + +The devil now becomes a constant resource for humour. In "The Chances" +Antonio has lost his jewels. His servant suggests that the thieves have +"taken towards the ports." + + _Ant._ Get me a conjurer, + One that can raise a water-devil. I'll port 'em. + Play at duck and drake with my money? Take heed, fiddler, + I'll dance ye by this hand: your fiddlestick + I'll grease of a new fashion, for presuming + To meddle with my de-gambos! get me a conjurer, + Inquire me out a man that lets out devils. + +Beaumont and Fletcher were great conversationalists, their racy raillery +is said to have been as good as their plays. They were members of the +celebrated Mermaid Club in Fleet Street, a centre where the wits of the +day sharpened their humour in friendly conflict. In his epistle to Ben +Jonson, Beaumont writes-- + + "What things have we seen + Done at the 'Mermaid!' heard words that have been + So nimble and so full of subtle flame, + As if that every one from whom they came + Had meant to put his whole wit in a jest, + And had resolved to live a fool the rest + Of his dull life." + +Here it was that Shakespeare and Jonson often contended, the former like +"a light English man-of-war" the latter like "a high-built Spanish +galleon." + +To some portion of the seventeenth century, we must attribute those +curious stories called "The Merry tales of the Wise Men of Gotham" +although by some they have been attributed to Andrew Gotham, a physician +of Henry VIII. They are said to have been suggested by a circumstance +which occurred in the time of King John. He intended to pass through +Gotham, a village in Northamptonshire, but the inhabitants placed some +difficulties in his way. On his expressing his determination to carry +out his project, and sending officers to make inquiries about the +opposition offered, the inhabitants were seized with a panic and +pretended to have lost their senses. This was the tradition upon which, +in after-times, these tales were founded, and being unobjectionable they +are well adapted for the nursery, but being mere exercises of ingenuity +they afford but very slight pleasure to older minds. Although aimless, +there is something clever in them. The Wise Men determine to hedge round +a cuckoo to keep it in so that it should sing all the year. The bird +seeing the hedge flies away. "A vengeance on her," say the Wise Men, "we +made not the hedge high enough." There is the story of the young man, +whose mother told him to throw sheep's eyes at his sweetheart, and who, +literally, performed her bidding. One Good Friday the Men of Gotham +consulted what to do with their red herrings, and other salt fish, and +agreed to cart them into a pond that the number might increase next +year. At the beginning of the next summer they drag the pond, and only +find a great eel. "A mischief on him," they say, "he hath eaten up our +fish." Some propose to chop him in pieces, but the rest think it would +be best to drown him, so they throw him into another pond. Twelve men of +Gotham go to fish, and some stand on dry land, and some in the water. +And one says "We have ventured wonderfully in wading; I pray that none +of us come home drowned." So they begin to count, and as each omits +himself he can only count eleven, and so they go back to the water, and +make great lamentation. A courtier, who meets them, convinces them of +their mistake by laying his whip on each of them, who calls out in turn +"Here's one," until twelve are counted. The minister of Gotham preaches +that men should not drink in Lent. A man, who comes for absolution, and +confesses to having been drunk in Lent, replies that fish should swim. +"Yes," returns the priest, "but in water." "I cannot enjoin your +prayer," he adds, "for you cannot say your Paternoster. It is folly to +make you fast because you never get meat. Labour hard, and get a dinner +on Sunday, and I will come and dine with you." + + + + +CHAPTER VII. + +Jesters--Court of Queen Elizabeth--James I.--The "Counterblasts to + Tobacco"--Puritans--Charles + II.--Rochester--Buckingham--Dryden--Butler. + + +Professed fools seem to have been highly appreciated in the time of +Shakespeare. They do not correspond to our modern idea of a fool, +because there was intention in their actions, and yet we could not have +considered them to be really sensible men. Nor had they great talent, +their gifts being generally lower than those of our professed wits. + +Addison observes that, "when a man of wit makes us laugh, it is by +betraying some oddness or infirmity in his own character," and at the +present day, not only do those who indulge much in humour often say +things approaching nonsense, and make themselves in other ways +ridiculous, but their object, being entirely idle diversion and +pleasantry, appears foolish and puerile. Those who cultivate humour are +not generally to be complimented on their success, and a popular writer +has thus classified fools--"First, the ordinary fool; secondly the fool +who is one, and does not know it; thirdly, the fool who is not satisfied +with being one in reality, but undertakes in addition to play the fool." +Thus, to a certain extent we may always regard a professed wit as a +silly fellow, but still at the present day the acts or sayings of an +absolute idiot or lunatic, would be depressing and offensive, and could +afford little amusement in any way except accidentally.[54] They would +resemble the incongruities in dreams which although strange are not +generally laughable. And if we are not amused with a fool, neither are +we with a man who imitates him, although Cicero says that humour +consists in a man who is not a fool, speaking as though he were one. +Some mistake supposed to be made by an ordinary man is what amuses us, +and although humorous sayings originated in an imitation of ludicrous +things, and Quintilian's observation sometimes holds good that the same +things, which if they drop from us unintentionally are foolish, if we +imitate them are humorous; still humour is not confined to this; there +is generally no such imitation, and the witty sayings of the present day +are seldom representations of such things as anyone would utter in +earnest, whether he were a fool or not. + +We must not confuse folly and wit, though they may exist in the same +person and in close relationship. The latter requires intelligence and +intention. If a humorous man ever purposely enacts the dullard, the +impersonation is always modified--he is like Snug, the joiner, who does +not "fright the ladies." There is always some peculiar point in his +blunders; if he acted the fool to the life we should not laugh with him. +We always see something clever and admirable in him, and to be +successful in this way, a man should possess considerable mental gifts, +and be able to gauge the feelings of others. Still we can hardly assent +to the proposition that "it takes a wise man to make a fool." A man may +be witty without having any constructive power of mind. It is easier to +find fault than to be faultless, to see a blemish than to produce what +is perfect--a pilot may point out rocks, but not be able to steer a safe +course. + +At the time of which we are now speaking, the double character of the +court fool corresponded with that early and inferior humour which was +always on the verge of the ludicrous. The connection thus established, +long remained and led to witty observations being often spoken of as +"foolerie." Upon this conceit or confusion Shakespeare founded the +speech of Jaques in "As you like it." + + Act II. Scene IV. + + _Jaques._ A fool! a fool!--I met a fool i' the forest, + A motley fool:--a miserable fool!-- + As I do live by food, I met a fool: + Who laid him down, and basked him in the sun, + And railed on Lady Fortune in good terms. + In good set terms--and yet a motley fool. + "Good morrow, fool," quoth I. "No, Sir," quoth he, + "Call me not fool till heaven hath sent me fortune." + And then he drew a dial from his poke, + And looking on it with lack lustre eye, + Says very wisely, "It is ten o'clock;" + "Thus we may see," quoth he, "how the world wags; + 'Tis but an hour ago since it was nine, + And after one hour more t'will be eleven, + And so from hour to hour we ripe and ripe, + And then from hour to hour we rot and rot, + And thereby hangs a tale." + +There is nothing very laughable in the above reflections, but they +contain a deep satire, and afford a beautiful example of Shakespearian +complexity. From the mixture of wisdom and folly compounded in the +"fool" of the day--who was then, it must be remembered, the monitor of +the great--it is here implied that in his awkward way he sometimes +arrived at truth better than the sage. As supremely wise men are often +regarded as fools, so what seems folly may be the highest +wisdom--"motley's your only wear." + +The fool is generally represented in Shakespeare as saying things which +have a certain wit and shrewdness. + + _Clown._ God bless thee, lady. + + _Olivia._ Take the fool away. + + _Clo._ Do you not hear, fellows? Take away the lady. + + * * * * * + + Good Madonna, why mournest thou? + + _Oli._ Good fool, for my brother's death. + + _Clo._ I think his soul is in hell, Madonna. + + _Oli._ I know his soul is in heaven, fool. + + _Clo._ The more fool, Madonna, to mourn for your brother's soul + being in heaven. Take away the fool, gentlemen. + +In King Lear. + + _Fool._ Dost thou know the difference, my boy, between a bitter + fool and a sweet one? + + _Lear._ No, lad, teach me. + + _Fool._ That lord that counselled thee + + To give away thy land, + Come place him here by me-- + Do thou for him stand: + The sweet and bitter fool + Will presently appear, + The one in motley here, + The other found out there. + + _Lear._ Dost thou call me fool, boy? + + _Fool._ All thy other titles thou hast given away that thou wast + born with. + + _Kent._ This is not altogether a fool, my lord. + +The fact was that wit was now gradually improving, and was being wielded +by so called fools in such a way that it could not be confounded with +fatuity. The time was approaching when the humour manufactured by +professed jesters would not be appreciated. Something higher and keener, +such as Shakespeare has here shadowed forth would be required. This was +not reached in Ben Jonson's time, but fools and their artifices are by +him discarded for something more natural, for country bumpkins and +servants, ludicrous in their stupidity, knavery and drunkenness. As +civilization advanced, jugglers and clowns were relegated to country +fairs. + +Henry the Eighth, at the commencement of his reign was a great patron of +men of wit and learning, and probably the humour of More, as well as his +virtue, recommended him to the King. We read that at Cardinal Morton's +entertainments of his Christmas company, the future Chancellor, then a +boy, would often mount the stage and extemporize with so much wit and +talent as to surpass all the professional players. During his university +course, and shortly afterwards, he wrote many neat Latin epigrams of +which the two following rough translations will give some idea-- + + "A thief about to be accused, implored + Advice, and sent his counsel many a pound, + The counsel, when o'er mighty tomes he'd pored, + Replied, 'If you'd escape, you must abscond.' + + "Once in the loving cup, a guest saw flies, + Removed them, drank, and then put back a few. + And, being questioned, sagely thus replies, + 'I like them not--but cannot speak for you.'" + +He was to the last fond of pleasantry and kept a jester. + +The daughter of Henry the Eighth and Anne Boleyn[55] could scarcely have +been deficient in mirthfulness, and we find that the dangers through +which she passed in her youth were not able to extinguish Elizabeth's +love of humour. According to the custom of the day she exhibited this +not only in her sayings, but, as comedians were then often received in +great houses, she ordered in 1583 that twelve of them should be made +grooms of the chamber, be sworn the Queen's servants, and be arrayed in +her livery. The most remarkable of these was Tarlton. He came of humble +origin. Fuller says that, while tending his father's swine, a servant of +Robert, Earl of Leicester, passing by was so pleased with his _happy +unhappy_ answers that he took him to court. But Tarlton's humour was +often that of the common fool, and depended generally upon action, look, +and voice. His face was in this respect his fortune, for he had a flat +nose and squinting eyes. Nash mentions that on one occasion he "peept +out his head," probably with a grimace, at the audience, which caused a +burst of laughter, and led one of the justices, who did not understand +the fun, to beat the people on the bare pates, inasmuch as they, "being +farmers and hinds, had dared to laugh at the Queen's men." He was +celebrated for his jigs, _i.e._ extempore songs accompanied with tabor +and pipe, and sometimes with dancing. + +Fuller says he had great influence with Elizabeth, and could "undumpish" +her at pleasure. Her favourites were wont to go to him to prepare their +access to her, and "he told the Queen more of her faults than most of +her chaplains, and cured her melancholy better than all her physicians." + +Bohun says that, "at supper she would divert herself with her friends +and attendants, and if they made no answer she would put them upon mirth +and pleasant discourse with great civility. She would then also admit +Tarlton, a famous comedian and pleasant talker, and other men to divert +her with stories of the town, and the common jests or accidents, but so +that they kept within the bounds of modesty." Tarlton, on one occasion, +cast reflections upon Leicester; and said of Raleigh, "the knave +commands the Queen," at which she was so much offended that she forbade +any of her jesters to approach her table. + +The jests of Scogan, or rather those attributed to him, were very +popular in Elizabeth's time. This man was court-fool to Henry VII., and +is said to have been "of pleasant wit and bent to merrie devices." He +was fond of practical jokes, and often attacked the clergy. Elizabeth +seems to have had a natural gift of humour, and we read of many of her +witty sayings. On one occasion, upon an archbishop finding fault with +some of her actions, and quoting Scripture to prove she had acted more +as a politician than a Christian. "I see, my lord," she replied, "that +you have read the scriptures, but not the book of Kings." She was so +well acquainted with proverbs, that on being presented with a collection +of English aphorisms, and told by the author that it contained them +all, she answered, "Nay, where is 'Bate me an ace, quoth Bolton.'" + +Among the sayings, good for the period, which have been attributed to +her, we read that when the Archduke raised the siege of Grave, the Queen +who heard of it before her secretary, said to him, "Wot you that the +Archduke is risen from the Grave." When at Lord Burleigh's she promised +to make seven knights, and the gentlemen to be so honoured were placed +in a line as the Queen was going out. The least worthy of them, however, +were through interest with Lord Burleigh placed first, so that they +might have precedence of creation. But the Queen passed down the row and +took no notice of them; but when she had reached the screen, turned, and +observing, "I had almost forgotten my promise," proceeded to knight from +the lower end. On one of her Privy Council saying "Your Majesty was too +politic for my Lord Burleigh," she replied, "I have but followed the +scripture--'the first shall be last and the last first.'" + +The cares of sovereignty, and the opposition of her Roman Catholic +subjects led Elizabeth's humour to assume a somewhat severe complexion. +Her thoughts gradually became more earnest, and her jests cynical. +Moreover, as seen in Shakespeare, the age in which she lived was +reflective, and the budding activity of mind was directed towards great +interests. There was not that impression of the vanity of all things, +which grows up with the extension and maturity of society, and attracts +the mind to more fanciful and less grave considerations. A good contrast +between Elizabeth's position, and that of James I. may be seen in the +following occurrences. When Henry IV. had given the order of St. Michael +to Nicolas Clifford and Anthony Shirley, she commanded them to return +it. "I will not," she said, "have my sheep follow the pipe of a strange +shepherd;"[56] but when James I. was told that several noblemen of his +court and council, received pensions from Spain, the King replied that +he knew it well, and only wished the King of Spain would give them ten +times as much, as it would render him less able to make war upon him. + +James was a man of a very eccentric and grotesque fancy, combined with a +considerable amount of intelligence and learning. He was particularly +fond of religious controversy, and wrote what he considered to be an +important work on "Demonologie." From one passage we might suppose that +he thought it sinful to laugh, as he says that man can only laugh, +because he can only sin. But he kept two clowns for his amusement, and +also appreciated Ben Jonson, to whom he gave the direction of the Court +Masques. He occasionally made some caustic remarks, which have come down +to us, such as, "Who denys a thing he even now spake, is like him that +looks in my face and picks my pocket." "A travelling preacher and a +travelling woman never come to any good at all." + +Sir Henry Wooton told him how the Prince of Condé sued for the title of +Altesse from the Synod of Venice. The King replied, "The Prince had good +reason to sue for it, and that the Seigniory had done ill to deny it +him, considering that the world knew how well he deserved it; it being +his custom to raise himself upon every man's back, and to make himself +the higher by every man's tail he could get upon. And for that cause he +hoped to see him elevated by the just Justice of God to as high a +dignity as the gallows at last." + +James the First's writings were mostly of a religious character, and +some of them were sufficiently ludicrous. But in his "Counterblaste to +Tobacco," his indignation is often mixed with humour. He observes that +smoking came from the Indians, and continues-- + +"And now, good countreymen let vs (I pray you) consider what honour or +policy can move vs to imitate the barbarous and beastly maneres of the +wilde, Godlesse and slavish Indians, especially in so vile and stinking +a custome? Shall wee that disdaine to imitate the manners of our +neighbour France.... Shall wee, I say without blushing abase ourselves +so farre as to imitate these beastly Indians, slaves to the Spaniards, +refuse to the world, and as yet aliens from the Holy Covenant of God? +Why doe wee not as well imitate them in walking naked as they doe? in +preferring glasses, feathers, and such toyes to gold and precious +stones, as they doe? Yea, why do wee not deny God, and adore the divel +as they doe?" + +He proceeds to combat the theory, "That the braines of all men beeing +naturally cold and wet, all drie and hote things should be good for +them." "It is," he says, "as if a man, because the liver is hote, and as +it were an oven to the stomache, would therefore apply and weare close +upon his liver and stomache a cake of lead; he might within a short time +(I hope) bee susteined very cheape at an Ordinarie, besides the clearing +of his conscience from that dreadful sinne of gluttonie." + +Towards the end he gives some medical testimony-- + +"Surely smoke becomes a kitchin farre better than a dining chamber, and +yet it makes a kitchin also oftentimes in the inward parts of men, +soyling and infecting them with an vnctuous and oily kind of soote, as +hath been found in some great tobacco takers, that after their death, +were opened." + +Addison, speaking of James' love of jesting, observes:--"The age in +which the pun chiefly flourished was in the reign of King James the +First. That learned monarch was himself a tolerable punster, and made +very few bishops or privy-councillors that had not sometime or other +signalized themselves by a clinch or a conundrum. It was therefore in +this age that the pun appeared with pomp and dignity. It had been before +admitted into merry speeches and ludicrous compositions, but was now +delivered with great gravity from the pulpit, or pronounced in the most +solemn manner at the council-table." Verbal humour continued to be +admired for its ingenuity in the reign of Charles I. The childish taste +of the time in this respect is prominently exhibited in the "Fames +Roule," written by a Mrs. Mary Fage, in honour of the royal family and +principal peers of the realm. It consists of short poems, and each one +forms an acrostic, and commences with an anagram of the name. + +The following will give specimens of this ridiculous composition:-- + + "To the high and mighty. Princesse Mary, + Eldest Daughter of our Soveraigne Lord King Charles. + + MARY STVARTE. + + Anagramma. + + A MERRY STATV. + + "M irth may with Princes very well agree, + A Merry Statv then faire Madam be; + R ightly 'twill fit your age, your vertues grace; + Y eelding A Merry Statv in your face. + + "S mile then, high Lady, while of mirth write I, + T hat so my Muse may with alacrity, + U nto your Highness sing without all feare, + A nd a true Statv of your vertues reare: + R eaching whereto, that she may higher flee, + T hus humbly beg I on my bended knee, + E ver A Merry Statv be to me." + + GEORGE MANNERS. + + Anagramma. + + NOR AS GREEN GEM. + + "G reat honoured Peere, and _Rutland's_ Noble Earle, + E ven in vertue shining like a Pearle + O ver all _Europe_, adding to your birth, + R adiant bright beames of your true honoured worth: + G em great and precious, see you are remaining + E ver the rayes of vertue's beames retaining. + + "M aking all _Europe_ stand amazed quite, + A nd wonder much at _Rutland's_ glorious light, + N or _as_ a _green gem_ let your lustre be, + N o, _greenness_ here betokens _levity_, + E ver more as a precious gem remain you, + R ed or some orient colour still retaine you; + S o _nor as green gem_, will the world proclaime you." + +The jester still remained in office in Charles the First's reign and +Archee assumed the old prerogative of the motley in telling home truths +to his master. On one occasion he was ordered by the King to say grace, +as the chaplain was away, upon which the jester pronounced it, "All +glory be to God on high, and little Laud to the devil." At which all the +courtiers smiled, because it reflected upon the Archbishop of +Canterbury, who was a little man. The King said he would tell Laud, and +what would he do then? "Oh!" said Archee, "I will hide me where he will +never find me." "Where is that?" asked the King. "In his pulpit," +answered Archee, "for I am sure he never goes there." + +The rebellion against Charles the First and the success of the Puritans +led to a remarkable development of religious feeling. Men seemed for the +moment to think more of the next world than of the present, seasoned +their language with texts, and from Scripture adopted new names suitable +to a new life. Their usual tone of conversation is thus humorously +described by Harrison Ainsworth. + +Captain Stelfax pays Colonel Maunsel a domiciliary visit, and an old +Royalist retainer tells the redoubtable Roundhead that he looks more +like a roystering Cavalier than a Puritan, to which the latter replies-- + +"Go to, knave, and liken me not to a profane follower of Jehoram. Take +heed that thou answerest me truthfully. Thou art newly returned from +the battle-field whereat the young man Charles Stuart was utterly +routed, and where our general, like Pekah the son of Remaliah slew many +thousands of men in one day, because they had forsaken the Lord God of +their fathers. Didst thou bear arms in the service of Ahaz?" + +One Increase Micklegift soon afterwards fell into the captain's bad +graces-- + +"I begin to suspect it was by thy instrumentality that he hath escaped." + +"How could that be seeing I was with thee in the closet." Micklegift +rejoined. + +"It might easily be, since it was by thy devise that I was led into the +snare. Bitterly shalt thou rue it, if I find thee leagued with the +Amalekites." + +All this affords a good idea of the phraseology of these men, some of +whom indulged in such names as "Nehemiah, Lift-up-Hand" and +"Better-Late-than-Never," and it must be remembered, to their credit, +that there never was a more orderly army than that of Cromwell. In +accordance with the sentiments then entertained all theatrical +exhibitions were prohibited. Such austerity and self-denial could not be +of long continuance--it was kept up by an effort, and led to an +inevitable reaction, and so we find that the court of the "Merry +Monarch" became notorious in history for its dissipation. Humour +proportionally changed from what it had been under Charles I., and we +read that that the old Earl of Norwich, who had been esteemed the +greatest wit, was now quite out of fashion. + +Barbarous nations have little idea of delicacy of any kind; and +civilisation finds it hard entirely to change nature, so that +where-ever the ground is allowed to lie fallow, the old weeds appear in +their noisesome rankness. Hence from time to time we find indelicacy +springing up, and made to serve the purposes of those who know that the +evil plant is not radically extirpated. One of the most offensive men in +this respect was Peter Aretinus, an Italian adventurer, who became a +great favourite with the Emperor Charles V. He is said to have died from +falling back over his chair in a fit of laughter, on hearing some +indelicate joke. But modes of death have often been invented to accord +with the lives of those who suffered them, just as dithyrambic Anacreon +is said to have been choked by a grape stone. + +Louis XI. was also addicted to this jesting which is not convenient. We +read that he told Edward IV. in a jocose way that he was right glad to +see him at Paris, and that if he would come and divert himself with the +gay ladies there, he would assign for his confessor, the Cardinal of +Bourbon, who, he knew, would grant him easy absolution for peccadilloes +of love and gallantry. Edward was much pleased with this raillery, for +he knew the Cardinal was a gay man. Louis was afterwards in great alarm +upon Edward's acceptance of his invitation. + +The humour of Charles II. and his court consisted more of jollity than +wit. The king was always ready to laugh outright, even in church at the +sermon. He encouraged and led the way in an indelicate kind of jesting, +which he seems to have learned during his travels in France. On his +telling Lord Shaftesbury, "I believe Shaftesbury, that thou art the +wickedest dog in England," the statesman humbly replied, "May it please +your Majesty, of a subject, I believe I am." We should not expect too +much from the son of Henrietta Maria. It is related that one morning +when at Exeter, pressing her hand to her head she said to her physician, +"Mayerne, I am afraid I shall go mad some day." "Nay," he replied, "your +Majesty need not fear _going_ mad; you have been so some time." + +But Charles owed much to his gay and easy manner. Notwithstanding his +faults "he was so pleasant a man that no one could be sorrowful under +his government." He sometimes dined at the annual civic banquet, and one +of the company present on the occasion when Sir Robert Viner was Lord +Mayor, refers to it as follows. "Sir Robert was a very loyal man, and if +you will allow the expression, very fond of his sovereign, but what with +the joy he felt at heart for the honour done him by his prince and +through the warmth he was in with continual toasting healths of the +royal family, his lordship grew a little fond of His Majesty, and +entered into a familiarity not altogether so graceful in so public a +place. The king understood very well how to extricate himself in all +kinds of difficulties, and with a hint to the company to avoid ceremony, +stole off and made towards his coach which stood ready for him in +Guildhall yard. But the Mayor liked his company so well, and was grown +so intimate, that he pursued him hastily and catching him fast by the +hand, cried out with a vehement oath and accent, 'Sir, you shall stay +and take t'other bottle.' The airy monarch looked kindly at him over his +shoulder, and with a smile and graceful air (for I saw him at the time +and do now) repeated this line of the old song 'He that's drunk is as +great as a King,' and immediately turned back and complied with his +request." + +Tom Killegrew was the last of his cloth; forced and constant jesting +becoming less and less appreciated. As the jesters approached their end, +they had more of the moralist and politician in them than of the +mountebank. We may judge of Killegrew's wit, when we read that one day +on his appearance Charles said to his gay companions, "Now we shall hear +our faults." "No," replied the jester, "I don't care to trouble my head +with that which all the town talks of."[57] Killegrew must have had fine +scope for his sarcasm. In these times the character of the monarch gave +the tone to society, and was reflected in the dramatists. Thus we find +the earnestness of Elizabeth in Shakespeare, the whimsicality of James +in Jonson, and the licentiousness of Charles II. in the poets of the +Restoration. The deterioration of men and of humour in the last reign is +marked by the fact that ridicule was mostly directed not against vice as +in Roman satire, but against undeserved misfortunes. Even virtue and +learning did not afford immunity; Bishop Warburton writes: "This weapon +(in the dissolute times of Charles II.) completed the ruin of the best +minister of that age. The historians tell us that Chancellor Hyde was +brought into his Majesty's contempt by this court argument. They +mimicked his walk and gesture with a fire-shovel and bellows for the +mace and purse." + +The indelicacy of which Charles and his companions was guilty, was not +of a primitive and ignorant kind, but always of an amatory character, +and at the expense of the fair sex; jests formerly so common as to +obtain the name of "japes." The writers of that day are objectionable +not merely for coarseness of this kind, but for the large amount of it, +as one artiste in complimentary attire might be tolerated where a crowd +of seminude performers could not. The poems of Sedley and Rochester are +as abundant in indelicacy as they are deficient in humour. The epigram +of Sedley to "Julius" gives a more correct idea of his character than of +his usual dullness. + + "Thou swearest thou'll drink no more; kind Heaven send Me such a + cook or coachman, but no friend." + +Rochester might have produced something good. His verses have more +traces of poetry and humour than we should expect from a man who out of +the thirty-four years of his life, was for five of them continually +drunk. He nearly always attunes his harp to the old subject, so as to +become hopelessly monotonous. Inconstancy has great charms for him, and +he consequently imputes it also to the ladies-- + + "Womankind more joy discovers + Making fools, than keeping lovers." + +Again: + + "Love like other little boys, + Cries for hearts as they for toys, + Which when gained, in childish play, + Wantonly are thrown away." + +He seems to have been oppressed by a disbelief in any kind of good in +the world. His philosophy, whenever he ventured upon any, was sceptical +and irreverent. His best attempt in this direction was a poem "Upon +Nothing," which commences: + + "Nothing! thou elder brother ev'n to shade, + That had'st a being 'ere the world was made, + And (well fixt) art alone of ending not afraid. + Ere Time and Place were, Time and Place were not, + When primitive Nothing, Something straight begot, + Then all proceeded from the great united--What?" + +Sometimes he amused himself writing libels on the king, and some of his +satires contain more or less truth, as-- + + "His father's foes he does reward, + Preserving those that cut off's head, + Old Cavaliers, the crown's best guard, + He lets them starve for want of bread. + Never was a King endued + With so much grace and gratitude." + +Buckingham does not appear to have agreed with Rochester about Charles, +for he writes, "He was an illustrious exception to all the common rules +of physiognomy, for with a most saturnine and harsh sort of countenance, +he was both of a merry and merciful disposition." Buckingham's humour +was of a very poor description, but he wrote a Comedy "The Rehearsal," +which was highly approved, mostly, however, because aimed at Dryden, and +the heroic drama. From one passage in it, we observe that he noticed the +difference between the effect of humour in the plot, and in the dialogue +of the play-- + + _Prettyman._ Well, Tom, I hope shortly we shall have another coin + for thee; for now the wars are coming on, I shall grow to be a man + of metal. + + _Bayes._ O, you did not do that half enough. + + _Johnson._ Methinks he does it admirably. + + _Bayes._ I, pretty well, but he does not hit me in't, he does not + top his part. + + _Thimble._ That's the way to be stamped yourself, Sir, I shall see + you come home like an angel for the king's evil, with a hole bored + through you. + + _Bayes._ There he has hit it up to the hilt. How do you like it + now, gentlemen? is not this pure wit? + + _Smith._ 'Tis snip snap, Sir, as you say, but methinks not pleasant + nor to the purpose, for the play does not go on. The plot stands + still. + + _Bayes._ Why, what the devil is the plot good for but to bring in + fine things. + +Dryden could scarcely be expected to remain silent under the blow here +aimed at his plays. An opportunity for revenge soon presented itself, +when he undertook to compose a political satire upon Monmouth and his +intrigues. Some say that this remarkable poem was written at the command +of Charles. It had a great success, five editions being sold within the +year--one cause of its popularity being its novel character. The idea of +introducing Scriptural impersonations into a poem was new or nearly so, +and very successful. Monmouth had already been called Absalom, and as +the King (David) was very fond of him, it was desirable to place his +shortcomings to the account of his advisers, represented by Achitophel. +The way in which Dryden handled his adversaries may be understood from +such passages as:-- + + "Levi, thou art a load: I'll lay thee down + And show rebellion bare, without a gown; + Poor slaves in metre, dull and addle-pated + Who rhime below e'en David's psalms translated." + +Doeg is another enemy:-- + + "'Twere pity treason at his door to lay + Who makes heaven's gate a lock to its own key. + Let him rail on, let his invective muse + Have four and twenty letters to abuse, + Which, if he jumbles to one line of sense + Indict him of a capital offence." + +This satire led to some replies, which Dryden crushed in his "Mac +Flecnoe," a poem named after an Irish priest--an inferior poet--who, but +for this notice, would never have been known to posterity. Shadwell was +the man really aimed at; Mac Flecnoe exclaims:-- + + "Shadwell alone, of all my sons, is he + Who stands confirmed in full stupidity, + The rest to some faint meaning make pretence + But Shadwell never deviates into sense."[58] + +After much in the same strain, he finishes with:-- + + "Thy genius calls thee not to purchase fame + In keen iambics, but mild anagram. + Leave writing plays, and choose for thy command + Some peaceful province in acrostic land, + There thou mayest wings display and altars raise, + And torture one poor world ten thousand ways." + +Dryden calls this kind of satire Varronian, as he weaves a sort of +imaginary story into which he introduces the object of his attack. He +was under the impression that this was the first piece of ridicule +written in heroics, and his claim seemed correct as far as England was +concerned, but Boileau and Tassoni had preceded him. Willmot says, +"Dryden is wanting in the graceful humour of Tassoni, and exquisite +power of Boileau. His wit has more weight than edge--it beat in armour, +but could not cut gause." The greater part of Dryden's satire could not +cut anything, nor be distinguished from elaborate vituperation. He +wrote an essay on Satire, in which he shows a much better knowledge of +history than of humour. His best passages are in the "Spanish Friars," +but they are weak and mainly directed against the profligacy of the +Church. The servant says of the friar, "There's a huge, fat religious +gentleman coming up, Sir. He says he's but a friar, but he's big enough +to be a Pope; his gills are as rosy as a turkey-cock's; his great belly +walks in state before him like an harbinger, and his gouty legs come +limping after it. Never was such a ton of devotion seen." + +Samuel Butler affords one of the many examples of highly gifted literary +men who have died in great poverty. His works, recommended by Lord +Dorset, were read largely, and even by the King himself; but there was +then no great demand for books, and authors had to look to patrons, and +eat the uncertain bread of dependence. We may suppose, however, that he +was an improvident man, for during his life he held several offices, and +was at one time steward of Ludlow Castle. + +Butler possessed a real gift of humour, and an astonishing fertility of +invention. To us there seems to be still too much indelicacy in his +writings, though less than heretofore, and there is a considerable +amount of bear-fighting, both in the literal and metaphorical sense. +This rough and cruel pastime was very common in that day. We read of +bear-baiting at Kenilworth to amuse Queen Elizabeth, and Alleyn, the +munificent founder of Dulwich College, was not only a dramatic author +and manager, but "Master of the bears and dogs," which seems to have +been a post of honour. To the present day, a ring for such sports is to +be seen outside the principal gate of Battle Abbey. + +We have already observed that the drama of Spain became the model for +that of modern Europe, and we are not therefore surprised to find that +the main design in Sir Hudibras is to produce an English Don Quixote. +All the accessories of the work point to this imitation; there is a long +account of his arms, his Squire, and horse. But beyond this, he aimed at +several well-known rogues of his day, especially those pretending to +necromancy and prophetic powers, who seem to have been numerous.[59] +This gave the poem an interest at that day which it cannot have now, and +it was increased by the amusing hits he makes at the Puritans, who had +lately convulsed the State, and whom he had been able to gauge when he +was employed by Sir Samuel Luke.[60] The lines are well known in which +he speaks of the time:-- + + "When pulpit, drum, ecclesiastic, + Was beat with fist, instead of a stick;" + +and the general outcry against dignitaries is thus represented:-- + + "The oyster women locked their fish up + And trudged away to cry 'No Bishop'; + Botchers left old clothes in the lurch, + And fell to turn and patch the church; + Some cry'd the Covenant, instead + Of pudding, pies, and gingerbread!" + +Sir Hudibras is a Presbyterian "true blue." + + "Such as do build their faith upon + The holy test of pike and gun; + Decide all controversies by + Infallible artillery: + And prove their doctrine orthodox + By apostolic blows and knocks. + + "Rather than fail, they will defy + That which they love most tenderly; + Quarrel with minced pies, and disparage. + Their best and dearest friend, plum porridge; + Fat pig and goose itself oppose, + And blaspheme custard through the nose." + +Sir Hudibras was learned in controversy:-- + + "For he a rope of sand could twist + As tough as learned Sorbonist + And weave fine cobwebs fit for skull + That's empty when the moon is full, + Such as take lodgings in a head + That's to be let unfurnished." + +He had been at the siege of "Bullen," by Henry VIII., and his breeches +were lined + + "With many a piece + Of ammunition, bread and cheese, + And fat black puddings, proper food + For warriors that delight in blood. + For as he said he always chose + To carry victual in his hose, + That often tempted rats and mice + The ammunition to surprise." + +Hudibras speaking of men fighting with an unworthy enemy, says:-- + + "So th' Emperor Caligula + That triumphed o'er the British sea, + Took crabs and oysters prisoners, + And lobsters 'stead of cuirassiers; + Engaged his legions in fierce bustles + With periwinkles, prawns, and mussels, + And led his troops with furious gallops + To charge whole regiments of scallops; + Not like their ancient way of war, + To wait on his triumphal car; + But, when he went to dine or sup, + More bravely ate his captives up." + +Butler begins one canto with + + "Ah me! what perils do environ + The man that meddles with cold iron." + +His political views are seen in the following: + + "For as a fly that goes to bed + Rests with its tail above its head, + So in this mongrel state of ours + The rabble are the supreme powers. + That horsed us on their backs to show us + A jadish trick at last, and throw us." + +Several minor poems have been attributed to Butler, but most of them +have been considered spurious. Some, however, are admitted--one of which +is a humorous skit against the Royal Society, who were supposed at that +day to be too minutely subtle. It is called "An Elephant in the Moon." +"Some learned astronomers think they have made a great discovery, but it +is really owing to a mouse and some gnats having got into their +telescope." + +The light, short metre in which Butler composed his comic narrative was +well suited to the subject, and corresponded to the "swift iambics" of +Archilochus. Dryden says that double rhymes are necessary companions of +burlesque writing. Addison, however, is of opinion that Hudibras "would +have made a much more agreeable figure in heroics," to which Cowden +Clarke replies, "Why, bless his head! the whole and sole intention of +the poem is _mock_ heroic, and the structure of the verse is burlesque," +and he also tells us that Butler's rhymes constitute one feature of his +wit. Certainly he had some strange terminations to his lines. Hudibras +speaking of hanging Sidrophel and Whackum says:-- + + "I'll make them serve for perpendiclars + As true as e'er were used by bricklayers." + +One of the bear-baiting mob annoys Rapho's steed, who + + "Began to kick, and fling, and wince, + As if he'd been beside his sense, + Striving to disengage from thistle + That gall'd him sorely under his tail." + +Again we have:-- + + "An ancient castle that commands + Th' adjacent parts, in all the fabric + You shall not see one stone, nor a brick." + +The astrologers made an instrument to examine the moon to + + "Tell what her diameter per inch is; + And prove that she's not made of green cheese." + +By the interchange which often takes place between the poetical and +ludicrous, this roughness of versification, then allowable, appears now +so childish, that Lamb and Cowden Clark mistook it for humour. But we +might extract from the writers of that day many ridiculous rhymes, +evidently intended to be serious. + +The humour of Butler was in his time more popular than the sentiment of +Milton, but he obtained no commensurate remuneration. Wycherley kindly +endeavoured to interest Buckingham on his behalf, and had almost +succeeded, when two handsome women passed by, and the Duke left him in +pursuit of them. John Wesley's father has written Butler's epitaph in +imperishable sarcasm:-- + + "See him when starved to death and turned to dust, + Presented with a monumental bust; + The poet's fate is here in emblem shown, + He asked for bread, and he received--a stone." + + + + +CHAPTER VIII. + +Comic Drama of the Restoration--Etherege--Wycherley. + + +The example set by Beaumont and Fletcher seems to have been much +followed by their immediate successors. Decker wrote conjointly with +Webster and Middleton, and it is sometimes difficult to distinguish his +work. His power of invective was well known; and in his humour there is +such straining after strong words and effective phrases, as to seem +quite unnatural. His "Gull's Hornbook" is written against coxcombs, and +he says their "vinegar railings shall not quench his Alpine +resolutions." + +Etherege and Wycherley ushered in the comic drama of the Restoration. +They were both courtiers, and the successful writers of this period took +their tone from that of "the quality." + +George, (afterwards Sir George) Etherege was born in 1636. He was known +as "Gentle George" or "Easy Etherege," and it is said that he was +himself a fop, and painted the character of Dorimant in Sir Fopling +Flutter from himself. In his principal plays there is very little +humour, though he gives some amusing sketches of the affectations of the +metropolis. + + _Mistress Loveit._ You are grown an early riser, I hear. + + _Belinda._ Do you not wonder, my dear, what made me abroad so soon? + + _Lov._ You do not use to do so. + + _Bel._ The country gentlewomen I told you of (Lord! they have the + oddest diversions) would never let me rest till I promised to go + with them to the markets this morning, to eat fruit and buy + nosegays. + + _Lov._ Are they so fond of a filthy nosegay? + + _Bel._ They complain of the stinks of the town, and are never well + but when they have their noses in one. + + _Lov._ There are essences and sweet waters. + + _Bel._ O, they cry out upon perfumes they are unwholesome, one of + 'em was falling into a fit with the smell of these Narolii. + + _Lov._ Methinks, in complaisance, you should have had a nosegay + too. + + _Bel._ Do you think, my dear, I could be so loathsome to trick + myself up with carnations and stock-gilly flowers? I begged their + pardon, and told them I never wore anything but Orange-flowers and + Tuberose. That which made me willing to go was a strange desire I + had to eat some fresh nectarines. + +Wycherley was the son of a Shropshire gentleman who being a Royalist, +and not willing to trust him to the Puritans, sent him to be educated in +France. He became a Roman Catholic, but afterwards recanted. + +Wycherley was remarkable for his beauty, and stalwart proportions, he +was called "manly" or "brawny" Wycherley; and the notorious Duchess of +Cleveland was so captivated by his appearance, that she made his +acquaintance when passing in her carriage by jocosely calling out at him +some abusive epithets. Afterwards, we are told that she often visited +Wycherley at the Temple, disguised as a country girl in a straw hat, +with pattens on her feet, and a basket on her arm. Later, he had the +misfortune to make the acquaintance of the Countess of Drogheda on the +Pantiles at Tunbridge Wells, and by secretly marrying her incurred the +King's displeasure. He was finally reduced to great distress, but James +II., recognising his talent, gave him a pension, and saved him from +destitution in his old age. + +Wycherley wrote his first play in 1667. In comparing him with +Shakespeare we find the same difference as existed between the old and +new comedy in Greece. Political characters have disappeared together +with hostility and combats on the stage, while amorous intrigue is +largely developed. There is at the same time considerable sprightliness +in the dialogue, and the tricks, deceptions and misadventures of lovers +fill the pages with much that is ingenious and amusing. In the +"Gentleman Dancing Master," a young spark pretends to a rich father that +he is only visiting his daughter to teach her to dance. A rival lover--a +Frenchified puppy--is made unconsciously to co-operate in his own +discomfiture, while the duped father jokes with the supposed "dancing +master," and asks him whether he is not engaged to one of his rich +pupils, laughing heartily at the picture he draws to himself of her +father's indignation. Again, in "A Country Wife," a jealous husband +obliges his spouse to write a disdainful letter to a gallant, but the +lady slyly substitutes one of quite a different character, which the +husband duly and pompously delivers to him. The humour of Wycherley is +almost entirely of this kind. Here are no verbal quips, no sallies of +professed fools, no stupidities of country boobies. These have passed +away from good comedy. Speaking of the change, he says that formerly +they were contented to make serving-men fools on the stage, "but now you +shall scarcely see a fool on the stage who is not a knight." The fact +was that a higher kind of humour was required, and accordingly we now, +for the first time, hear of "wits"--men of good birth and position, who +prided themselves on their talent. They were generally remarkable for +their manners and address, and affected a superiority in acuteness, but +not always in humour. Wycherley speaks of wits not exactly in the sense +of humorists, but rather as coxcombs, endued with a certain cunning: +"Your court wit is a fashionable, insinuating, flattering, cringing, +grimacing fellow, and has wit enough to solicit a suit of love; and if +he fail he has malice enough to ruin the woman with a dull lampoon; but +he rails still at the man that is absent, for all wits rail; and his wit +properly lies in combing perukes, matching ribbons, and being severe, as +they call it, upon other peoples' clothes." + + _Lydia._ Now, what is your coffee wit? + + _Dapperwit._ He is a lying, censorious, gossiping, quibbling + wretch, and sets people together by the ears over that sober + drink--coffee; he is a wit as he is a commentator upon the Gazette; + and he rails at the pirates of Algiers, the Grand Signior of + Constantinople, and the Christian Grand Signior. + + _Lydia._ What kind of wit is your pollwit? + + _Dap._ He is a fidgetting, busy, dogmatical, hot-headed fop, that + speaks always in sentences and proverbs, and he rails perpetually + against the present Government. His wit lies in projects and + monopolies, and penning speeches for Parliament men-- + +He goes on to speak of the scribble wit, and judge wit or critic, but in +general wits were regarded as rakes and not long afterwards we find it +debated whether a woman can be witty and virtuous. + +Wycherley did not aim much at facetiousness, nor introduce many humorous +episodes, but passages incidentally occur which show he had considerable +talent in that direction. The first from "Love in a Wood," is an +ironical conflict between one Gripe, a rich but parsimous Alderman, and +a Mrs. Joyner, a sly, designing old woman. + + _Gripe._ I am full of your praise, and it will run over. + + _Joyner._ Nay, sweet Sir, you are---- + + _Gripe._ Nay, sweet Mrs. Joyner, you are---- + + _Joy._ Nay, good your worship, you are---- + + (_Stops her mouth with his handkerchief_) + + _Gripe._ I say you are---- + + _Joy._ I must not be rude with your worship. + + _Gripe._ You are a nursing mother to the saints; through you they + gather together, through you they fructify and increase, and + through you the child cries out of the hand-basket. + + _Joy._ Through you virgins are married, or provided for as well; + through you the reprobate's wife is made a saint; and through you + the widow is not disconsolate, nor misses her husband. + + _Gripe._ Through you---- + + _Joy._ Indeed you will put me to the blush. + + _Gripe._ Blushes are badges of imperfection--Saints have no shame. + You are the flower of matrons, Mrs. Joyner. + + _Joy._ You are the pink of courteous Aldermen. + + _Gripe._ You are the muffler of secrecy. + + _Joy._ You are the head-band of Justice. + + _Gripe._ Thank you, sweet Mrs. Joyner; do you think so indeed? You + are--you are the bonfire of devotion. + + _Joy._ You are the bellows of zeal. + + _Gripe._ You are the cupboard of charity. + + _Joy._ You are the fob of liberality. + + _Gripe._ You are the rivet of sanctified love or wedlock. + + _Joy._ You are the pick-lock and dark-lantern of policy; and in a + word a conventicle of virtues. + + _Gripe._ Your servant, your servant, sweet Mrs. Joyner! You have + stopped my mouth. + + _Joy._ Your servant, your servant, sweet Alderman! I have nothing + to say. + +Indelicacy in words has by this time become very much reduced, although +here and there we find some cant expressions of the day which shock our +sensibilities. Much refinement in this respect could not be expected at +a period where a young lady of fortune could be represented as calling +her maid, and afterwards herself, a "damned jade," and a lady from the +country as saying she had not yet had "her bellyful of sights" in +London. + +"The Plain Dealer" is a naval captain in the time of the Dutch war. +Olivia says, + + "If he be returned, then shall I be pestered again with his + boisterous sea-love; have my alcove smell like a cabin, my chamber + perfumed with his tarpaulin Brandenburgh, and hear volleys of + brandy-sighs, enough to make a fog in one's room. Foh! I hate a + lover that smells like Thames Street." + +The Plain Dealer, _i.e._, the sea-captain Manly, meets with a lawyer, +and they converse in this way, + + _Manly._ Here's a lawyer I know threatening us with another + greeting. + + _Lawyer._ Sir! Sir! your very servant; I was afraid you had + forgotten me. + + _Man._ I was not afraid you had forgotten me. + + _Law._ No, Sir; we lawyers have pretty good memories. + + _Man._ You ought to have by your wits. + + _Law._ O, you are a merry gentleman, Sir; I remember you were merry + when I was last in your company. + + _Man._ I was never merry in your company, Mr. Lawyer, sure. + + _Law._ Why I am sure you joked upon me, and shammed me all night + long. + + _Man._ Shammed! prithee what barbarous law-term is that? + + _Law._ Shamming! why, don't you know that? 'tis all our way of wit, + Sir. + + _Man._ I am glad I don't know it, then. Shamming! what does he mean + by it, Freeman? + + _Free._ Shamming is telling an insipid dull lie with a dull face, + which the sly wag, the author, only laughs at himself; and making + himself believe 'tis a good jest, puts the sham only upon himself. + +Manly meets an Alderman. + + _Man._ Here's a city-rogue will stick as hard upon us as if I owed + him money. + + _Ald._ Captain, noble Sir, I am yours heartily, d'ye see; why + should you avoid your old friends? + + _Man._ And why should you follow me? I owe you nothing. + + _Ald._ Out of my hearty respects to you; for there is not a man in + England---- + + _Man._ Thou wouldst save from hanging at the expense of a shilling + only. + + _Ald._ Nay, nay, but Captain, you are like enough to tell me---- + + _Man._ Truth, which you wont care to hear; therefore you had better + go talk with somebody else. + + _Ald._ No, I know nobody can inform me better of some young wit or + spendthrift, who has a good dipped seat and estate in Middlesex, + Hertfordshire, Essex, or Kent; any of these would serve my turn; + now if you know of such an one, and would but help---- + + _Man._ You to finish his ruin. + + _Ald._ I' faith you should have a snip---- + + _Man._ Of your nose, you thirty in the hundred rascal; would you + make me your squire-setter? + + (_Takes him by the nose._) + +Two lovers, Lord Plausible and Novel, have the following dialogue about +their chances of success with a certain lady who is wooed by both. + + _Novel._ Prithee, prithee, be not impertinent, my lord; some of you + lords are such conceited, well assured impertinent rogues. + + _Plausible._ And you noble wits are so full of shamming and + drollery, one knows not where to have you seriously. + + _Nov._ Prithee, my lord, be not an ass. Dost thou think to get her + from me? I have had such encouragements-- + + _Plau._ I have not been thought unworthy of 'em. + + _Nov._ What? not like mine! Come to an éclaircissement, as I said. + + _Plau._ Why, seriously then; she told me Viscountess sounded + prettily. + + _Nov._ And me, that Novel was a name she would sooner change hers + for, than any title in England. + + _Plau._ She has commended the softness and respectfulness of my + behaviour. + + _Nov._ She has praised the briskness of my raillery in all things, + man. + + _Plau._ The sleepiness of my eyes she liked. + + _Nov._ Sleepiness! dulness, dulness. But the fierceness of mine she + adored. + + _Plau._ The brightness of my hair she liked. + + _Nov._ Brightness! no the greasiness, I warrant! But the blackness + and lustre of mine she admires. + + _Plau._ The gentleness of my smile. + + _Nov._ The subtilty of my leer. + + _Plau._ The clearness of my complexion. + + _Nov._ The redness of my lips. + + _Plau._ The whiteness of my teeth. + + _Nov._ My jaunty way of picking them. + + _Plau._ The sweetness of my breath. + + _Nov._ Ha! ha! nay there she abused you, 'tis plain; for you know + what Manly said: the sweetness of your pulvillio she might mean; + but for your breath! ha! ha! ha! Your breath is such, man, that + nothing but tobacco can perfume; and your complexion nothing could + mend but the small-pox. + + + + +CHAPTER IX. + +Tom Brown--His Prose Works--Poetry--Sir Richard + Blackmore--D'Urfey--Female Humorists--Carey. + + +Whether it was owing to the commotions of the Civil War in which "fears +and jealousies had soured the people's blood, and politics and polemics +had almost driven mirth and good humour out of the nation," or whether +it was from a dearth of eminent talent, humour seems to have made little +progress under the Restoration. The gaiety of the Merry Monarch and his +companions had nothing intellectual in it, and although "Tom" Brown[61] +tells us that "it was during the reign of Charles II. that learning in +general flourished, and the Muses, like other ladies, met with the +civilest sort of entertainment," his own works show that the best wits +of the day could not soar much above the attempts of Sedley and +Rochester. Had Brown not acquired in his day the character of a +humorist, we should think that he equally well deserved that of a man of +learning, for whereas he shows an acquaintance with the classics and +modern languages, his writings, which are of considerable length, +contain little Attic salt. He was born in 1663, the son of a substantial +Shropshire farmer, and was sent to Christ Church, Oxford, where he +became as remarkable for his quickness and proficiency, as for the +irregularity of his conduct. On one occasion, owing to his having been +guilty of some objectionable frolic, he was about to be expelled, when, +upon his writing a penitential letter, the Dean, who seems to have known +his talent, promised to forgive him on his translating extempore the +epigram of Martial. + + "Non amo te, Zabidi, nec possum dicere quare; + Hoc tantum possum dicere non amo te." + +The young delinquent replied in words now better known than the +original, + + "I do not love you, Dr. Fell, + But why I cannot tell, + But this I know full well, + I do not love you, Dr. Fell." + +At this period he occasionally indulged in such silly effusions as the +"Adverbial Declaration," which he first wrote in Latin, on "Mother +Warner's bellows at Oxford." + +Brown was finally obliged to leave the University, and went up to London +to seek his fortune. The unpromising and reckless spirit in which he +set out, is probably reflected in one of his pieces entitled "A Dialogue +between two Oxford scholars." + + _A._ Well, I see thou art resolved to leave us. I will not say, + "Go, and be hanged," but go and turn country parson. + + _B._ That's almost as bad, as the world goes now. But thanks to my + stars, I know a better trick than that. + + _A._ It may be thou art fallen out with mankind, and intendest to + turn quack; or as they call it in the country, doctor. + + _B._ No such matter; the _French_ can kill men fast enough, and for + women thou knowest my kindness. + + _A._ But some of them have lived too long; and there are others so + miserable, that even compassion will incline thee to help them out + of the world. I can assure thee 'tis a profitable calling; for + whether thou dost kill or cure, thy fees will be put in thy hand. + + _B._ Yes, when they are found. But, prithee, speak no more of it, + for I am resolved against it. + + _A._ What, then, art thou resolv'd for the law? Methinks thou + should'st have too much University learning and wit for that + profession-- + + _B._ And too much honesty. But I'll spare thee the pains of + guessing, and tell thee in short what my condition is, and what I + design. My portion is all spent--save fifty pounds; and with that I + am resolved for London or some other wealthy place, where + conventicles abound: and as a man of tender conscience and + infinitely dissatisfied with several things in the Church of + England, I will endeavour by some means or other to force myself + into an acquaintance with some of their leading men, and more + especially with some of the most zealous and wonderful women among + them; and this point once gained, I doubt not, but before my stock + is half spent, I shall receive a call to be pastor or holder-forth + in some congregation or other--why dost smile? + + _A._ At my friend's design. And I cannot but admire how it came + into thy head. Thy ability to manage such a design I know very + well; but how thou wilt dispense with the knavery of it, I am yet + to learn. + + _B._ That's a small matter. As the world goes one must practise a + little knavery, or resolve to leave the world. Dost thou know that + religious cheats are licensed by a law? and shall I live and die + without taking advantage of it? Believe me, friend, Nature has + fitted me pretty well to be one of these godly mountebanks, and a + little art, together with a few months' conversation with that sort + of people will supply all natural defects. Cannot I put on, when I + please, a grave and serious countenance, and with head depending on + one shoulder a little more than on the other, sigh for the + iniquities of the time and corruptions of the Church? Cannot I wipe + mine eyes with the fair pocket-cloth, as if I wept for all your + abominations? Cannot I grieve in spirit as if ready to burst with + grief and compassion. And cannot I likewise, when time serves, and + company is disposed to be kindly affected with it, smile and fleer + as takingly? And what hurt is there in this? Sure I may use my own + face as I please. + +We need scarcely say that Brown failed in his shrewd scheming; and he +was soon fain to take the humble position of a schoolmaster at Kingston +upon Thames, for which his acquirements qualified him. But his literary +ambition would not allow him to remain long at this drudgery, and we +soon find him wandering up again to town, where he was again +unfortunate. At this time, men of letters expected little from the sale +of books; but often obtained patrons who conferred valuable appointments +upon them. Brown's temper and position rendered him ineligible for this +sort of promotion. Not being a gentleman by birth, he had no good +introductions, nor would he have been very acceptable in the houses of +the great. His coarseness in writing--excessive even in that day--was +probably reflected in his manners and language, and he had so little +prudence that he ridiculed not only the clergy, but was always ready to +lose a friend rather than a joke. Mere literary talent will not procure +success in society. + +Brown wrote a variety of essays, generally rather admonitory than +humorous. His "Pocket-book of Common Places" resembles a collection of +Proverbs or good sayings. It commences, + +"To see the number of churches and conventicles open every Sunday, a +stranger would fancy London all religion. But to see the number of +taverns, ale-houses, &c., he would imagine Bacchus was the only God that +is worshipped there. If no _trades_ were permitted but those which were +useful and necessary, Lombard Street, Cheapside, and the Exchange might +go a-begging. For more are fed by our _vanities_ and _vices_ than by our +virtues, and the necessities of Nature." + +But his favourite and characteristic mode of writing was under the form +of letters. We have "Letters Serious and Comical," "Diverting Letters to +Gentlemen." One letter is to four ladies with whom the author was in +love at the same time. + +He probably took his idea of "Letters from the Dead to the Living," from +Lucian. He never spares Dissenters, and comically makes a Quaker relate +his warm reception in the lower world:-- + +"A parcel of black spiritual Janissaries saluted me as intimately as if +I had been resident in these parts during the term of an apprenticeship; +at last, up comes a swinging, lusty, overgrown, austere devil, armed +with an ugly weapon like a country dung-fork, looking as sharp about the +eyes as a Wood Street officer, and seemed to deport himself after such a +manner that discovered he had ascendancy over the rest of the immortal +negroes, and as I imagined, so 'twas quickly evident; for as soon as he +espied me leering between the diminutive slabbering-bib and the +extensive rims of my coney-wood umbrella, he chucks me under the chin +with his ugly toad-coloured paw, that stunk as bad of brimstone as a +card-match new-lighted, saying, 'How now, Honest Jones, I am glad to see +thee on this side the river Styx, prithee, hold up thy head, and don't +be ashamed, thou art not the first Quaker by many thousands that has +sworn allegiance to my government; besides, thou hast been one of my +best benefactors on earth, and now thou shalt see, like a grateful +devil, I'll reward thee accordingly.' 'I thank your excellence kindly,' +said I, 'pray, what is it your infernal protectorship will be pleased +to confer upon me?' To which his mighty ugliness replied, 'Friend +Naylor, I know thou hast been very industrious to make many people fools +in the upper world, which has highly conduced to my interest.' Then +turning to a pigmy aërial, who attended his commands as a running +footman, 'Haste, _Numps_,' says he, 'and fetch me the painted coat,' +which was no sooner brought, but by Lucifer's command I was shoved into +it, neck and shoulders, by half a dozen swarthy _valets de chambre_, and +in a minute's time found myself tricked up in a rainbow-coloured coat, +like a merry-Andrew. 'Now, friend,' says the ill-favoured prince of all +the hell-born scoundrels, 'for the many fools you have made above, I now +ordain you mine below;' so all the reward truly of my great services was +to be made Lucifer's jester, or fool in ordinary to the devil; a pretty +post, thought I, for a man of my principles, that from a Quaker in the +outer world I should be metamorphosed into a jack-adam in the lower +one." + +The occupation of people in the Nether world is described after +Rabelais, thus:--"Cardinal Mazarin keeps a nine-holes; Mary of Medicis +foots stockings; and Katharine of Sweden cries 'Two bunches a penny +card-matches--two bunches a penny!' Henry the Fourth of France carries +a raree-show, and Mahomet sells mussels. Seneca keeps a fencing-school, +and Julius Cæsar a two-penny ordinary." + +At the present day it is rather amusing to read, "A Comical View of +London and Westminster"--a weekly prophecy intended to ridicule the +increasing use of barometers and other scientific instruments for +predicting changes of weather. + +"Wednesday October 16th. Cloudy, foggy weather at Garraway's and +Jonathan's, and at most coffee-houses at about twelve. Crowds of people +gather at the Exchange by one; disperse by three. Afternoon, noisy and +bloody at her Majesty's bear-garden at _Hockly-in-the-Hole_. +Night--sober with broken chaplains and others that have neither credit +nor money. This week's transactions censured by the virtuosos at +_Child's_ from morning till night. + +"Thursday 17th. Coffee and water-gruel to be had at the Rainbow and +Nando's at four. Hot furmity at Bride-bridge at seven. Justice to be had +at _Doctor's Commons_, when people can get it. A lecture at Pinner's +hall at ten. Excellent pease-pottage and tripe in Baldwin's Gardens at +twelve. A constable and two watchmen killed, or near being so in +_Westminster_; whether by a lord or lord's footman, planets don't +determine. + +"Friday. Damsels whipped for their good nature at _Bridewell_ about ten. +Several people put in fear of their lives by their god-fathers at the +_Old Bailey_ at eleven. Great destruction of Herrings at one. Much +swearing at three among the horse-coursers at Smithfield; if the oaths +were registered as well as the horses, good Lord, what a volume 'twould +make! Several tails turned up at St. Paul's School, Merchant Taylors, +&c. for their repetitioning. Night very drunk, as the two former. + +"Saturday 19th. Twenty butchers' wives in Leadenhall and Newgate markets +overtaken with sherry and sugar by eight in the morning. Shop-keepers +walk out at nine to count the trees in Moorfields, and avoid duns. +People's houses cleansed in the afternoon, but their consciences we +don't know when. Evening pretty sober. + +"Sunday. Beggars take up their posts in Lincoln's Inn Fields and other +places by seven, that they may be able to praise God in capon and March +beer at night. Great jingling of bells all over the city from eight to +nine. Parish clerks liquor their throats plentifully at eight, and +chaunt out Hopkins most melodiously about ten. Sextons, men of great +authority most part of the day, whip dogs out of the church for being +obstreperous. Great thumping and dusting of the cushion at Salter's +Hall about eleven; one would almost think the man was in earnest he lays +so furiously about him. A most refreshing smell of garlic in +Spittlefield's and Soho at twelve. Country fellows staring at the two +wooden men at St. Dunstan's from one to two, to see how notably they +strike the quarters. The great point of Predestination settled in +Russell-court about three; and the people go home as wise as they came. +Afternoon sleepy in most churches. Store of handkerchiefs stolen at St. +Paul's. Night, not so sober as might be wished...." + +The following are some of the best specimens of Brown's poems--squibs on +the fashions and occurrences of the day-- + + "The _emblem of the nation_, so grave and precise, + On the _emblem of wisdom_ has laid an excise; + Pray tell me, grave sparks, and your answer don't smother, + Why one representative taxes another? + The _Commons_ on _salt_ a new impost have laid + To tax _wisdom_ too, they most humbly are pray'd; + For tell me ye patrons of woollen and crape, + Why the _type_ should be fined and the substance escape?" + +A song in ridicule of a famous musician, who was caught serenading his +mistress with his bass-viol on a very frosty night:-- + + Look down, fair garreteer bestow + One glance upon your swain, + Who stands below in frost and snow. + And shaking sings in pain. + + Thaw with your eyes the frozen street, + Or cool my hot desire, + I burn within, altho' my feet + Are numbed for want of fire. + _Chorus_. + + Thrum, thrum, thrum, thrum, + Come, come, come, come, + My dearest be not coy, + For if you are (zit, zan, zounds) I + Must without your favour die. + +The sentiment in the following is easily appreciated, but is there not +also some slight essence of humour? + + + ON FLOWERS IN A LADY'S BOSOM. + + Behold the promised land, where pleasures flow! + See how the milk-white hills do gently rise, + And beat the silken skies! + Behold the valley spread with flowers below! + The happy flowers, how they allure my sense! + The fairer soil gives them the nobler hue + Her breath perfumes them too: + Rooted i' th' heart they seem to spring from thence, + Tell, tell me why, thou fruitful virgin breast, + Why should so good a soil lie unpossest? + +Brown's humour partook of the coarseness of most of the writers of his +times, and scandalized the more religious and decent muse of Sir Richard +Blackmore, who endeavoured to correct this general failing in his +"Satire upon Wit." This called forth many sarcastic replies, and +critiques on Blackmore's works; such as Brown's "Epigram occasioned by +the news that Sir R----d B----e's paraphrase upon Job was in the +Press--" + + "When Job contending with the devil I saw + It did my wonder, not my pity draw; + For I concluded that without some trick, + A saint at any time could match old Nick. + Next came a fiercer fiend upon his back, + I mean his spouse, stunning him with her clack, + But still I could not pity him, as knowing + A crab tree cudgel soon would send her going. + But when the quack engaged with Job I spy'd, + The Lord have mercy on poor Job I cry'd. + What spouse and Satan did attempt in vain + The quack will compass with his murdering pen, + And on a dunghill leave poor Job again, + With impious doggrel he'll pollute his theme, + And make the saint against his will blaspheme." + +Upon the knighting of Sir R----d B----e. + + "Be not puffed up with knighthood, friend of mine, + A merry prince once knighted a Sir-loin, + And if to make comparisons were safe + An ox deserves it better then a calf. + Thy pride and state I value not a rush + Thou that art now Knight Phyz, wast once King Ush." + +Blackmore, who was successively physician to William III. and Queen +Anne, had been once a schoolmaster. + +Tom Brown died at the early age of forty. His life was full of +misfortunes, but we can scarcely say that he was unhappy, for nothing +could conquer his buoyant spirit. At one time he was actually in prison, +for what was deemed a libellous attack, but we are told that he obtained +his "enlargement" from it, upon his writing the following Pindaric +Petition to the Lords in Council. + + "Should you order Tho' Brown + To be whipped thro' the town + For scurvy lampoon, + Grave _Southern_ and _Crown_ + Their pens wou'd lay down; + Even D'Urfey himself, and such merry fellows + That put their whole trust in tunes and trangdillioes + May hang up their harps and themselves on the willows; + For if poets are punished for libelling trash + John Dryden, tho' sixty, may yet fear the lash. + No pension, no praise, + Much birch without bays, + These are not right ways + Our fancy to raise, + To the writing of plays + And prologues so witty + That jirk at the city, + And now and then hit + Some spark in the pit, + So hard and so pat + Till he hides with his hat + His monstrous cravat. + The pulpit alone + Can never preach down + The fops of the town + Then pardon Tho' Brown + And let him write on; + But if you had rather convert the poor sinner + His foul writing mouth may be stopped with a dinner. + Give him clothes to his back, some meat and some drink + Then clap him close prisoner without pen and ink + And your petitioner shall neither pray, write, or think." + +Unfortunately his pecuniary difficulties were not removed, but +accompanied him through life. What a strange mixture of gaiety, learning +and destitution is brought before us, when on a clamorons dun vowing she +would not leave him until she had her money, he exclaimed in an +extempore version of two lines of Martial-- + + "Sextus, thou nothing ow'st, nothing I say! + He something owes, that something has to pay." + +In an imitation of another epigram of Martial he gives an account of the +unpromising position of his affairs:-- + + "Without formal petition + Thus stands my condition, + I am closely blocked up in a garret, + Where I scribble and smoke, + And sadly invoke + The powerful assistance of claret. + Four children and a wife + 'Tis hard on my life, + Besides myself and a Muse + To be all clothed and fed, + Now the times are so dead, + By my scribbling of doggrel and news; + And what I shall do, + I'm a wretch if I know + So hard is the fate of a poet, + I must either turn rogue, + Or what's as bad--pedagogue, + And so drudge like a thing that has no wit." + +How much are we indebted to the pecuniary embarrassments of poets for +the interest we take in them. Who could read sentiment written by a man +faring sumptuously every day? Towards the end of his life, Brown became +acquainted with Lord Dorset, and we read of his once dining with that +nobleman and finding a note for fifty pounds under his plate. Tom Brown +seems to have regarded with great contempt his contemporary Tom +D'Urfey--best known as a composer of sonnets--words and music. He +addresses to him "upon his incomparable ballads, called by him Pindaric +Odes," the following acrimonious lines-- + + "Thou cur, half French half English breed, + Thou mongrel of Parnassus, + To think tall lines, run up to seed, + Should ever tamely pass us. + + "Thou write Pindaricks and be damned + Write epigrams for cutlers, + None with thy lyricks can be shammed + But chambermaids and butlers. + + "In t'other world expect dry blows; + No tears can wash thy stains out, + Horace will pluck thee by the nose + And Pindar beat thy brains out." + +Such unworthy attacks are not unfrequently made by ill-natured literary +men. Brown was no doubt jealous of his rival, but Addison's generous +heart formed a very different estimate of D'Urfey's talent. He says that +after having "made the world merry he hopes they will make him easy" in +his pecuniary affairs, for that although "Tom" had written more Odes +than Horace, and four times as many Comedies as Terence, he was reduced +to great difficulties by a set of men who had furnished him with the +accommodations of life, and would not, as we say, "be paid with a song." +"As my friend," he continues, "after the manner of all the old lyrics, +accompanies his works with his own voice, he has been the delight of the +most polite companies and conversations from the beginning of King +Charles II.'s reign to our present times. Many an honest gentleman has +got a reputation in his country by pretending to have been in company +with Tom D'Urfey." "I myself remember King Charles II. leaning on Tom +D'Urfey's shoulder more than once, and humming over a song with him. It +is certain that monarch was not a little supported by 'Joy to great +Cæsar,' which gave the Whigs such a blow as they were not able to +recover that whole reign. My friend afterwards attacked Popery with the +same success--he has made use of Italian tunes and Sonatas for promoting +the Protestant interest, and turned a considerable part of the Pope's +music against himself." + +Little need be added to this eloquent commendation, except that it was +written to obtain patronage for a benefit in behalf of an aged poet and +friend. D'Urfey wrote through the reigns of Charles II., James II., +William and Anne, into that of George I. His plays, which were thought +attractive at the time, contained much that was gross, and were +deficient in humour and power. Thus, they were soon forgotten, and +neither he nor his rival Brown were able to reach a point, which would +give them a permanent position in literature. + +The following description would have led us to expect something better +of him, at least in farcical talent[62]-- + + "Mr. D'Urfey generally writes state-plays, and is wonderfully + useful to the world in such representations. This method is the + same that was used by the old Athenians, to laugh out of + countenance or promote opinions among the people. My friend has + therefore against this play is acted for his own benefit, made two + dances which may be also of an universal benefit. In the first he + has represented absolute power in the person of a tall man with a + hat and feathers, who gives his first minister who stands just + before him a huge kick; the minister gives the kick to the next + before; and so to the end of the stage. In this moral and practical + jest you are made to understand that there is in an absolute + government no gratification, but giving the kick you receive from + one above you to one below you. This is performed to a grave and + melancholy air; but on a sudden the tune moves quicker, and the + whole company fall into a circle and take hands; and then, at a + certain sharp note, they move round and kick as kick can. This + latter performance he makes to be the representation of a free + state; where, if you all mind your steps, you may go round and + round very jollily, with a motion pleasant to yourselves and them + you dance with: nay, if you put yourselves out, at the worst you + only kick and are kicked by friends and equals." + +But D'Urfey's short songs and poems were his most successful +productions--sometimes he breathed martial strains in honour of +Marlborough's victories, sometimes formed adulatory addresses to members +of the Royal Family. His "Pills to purge Melancholy," at times +approached humour. The following is taken from the "Banquet of the +Gods," and refers to Hermes visiting the Infernal regions-- + + "Fierce Cerberus, who the gate did keep, + First with a sop he lays asleep, + Then forward goes to th' room of State, + Where on a lofty throne of jet, + The grizly King of Terrors sate, + Discoursing with his Proserpine + On things infernally divine. + To him the winged Ambassador + His message tells, then adds to her + How much her mother Ceres mourns + In Sicily, till she returns; + That now she hoped (the long half-year + Being ended) she would see her there, + And that instead of shrieks and howls, + The harmony of par-boiled souls, + She'd now divert with tunes more gay, + And go with her to see a play." + +D'Urfey often introduces fresh and pleasing glimpses of country life. He +is more happy in this direction than in his humour, which generally +drifted away into maudlin and indelicate love-making between +pseudo-Roman Corydons and Phyllises. The following effusion is very +characteristic of the times,-- + + "One _April_ morn, when from the sea + _Phoebus_ was just appearing! + Damon and Celia young and gay, + Long settled Love indearing; + Met in a grove to vent their spleen, + On parents unrelenting; + He bred of _Tory_ race had been, + She of the tribe _Dissenting_. + + "Celia, whose eyes outshone the God, + Newly the hills adorning, + Told him mamma wou'd be stark mad, + She missing prayers that morning; + Damon, his arm around her waist, + Swore tho' nought should 'em sunder, + Shou'd my rough dad know how I'm blest, + T'would make him roar like thunder. + + "Great ones whom proud ambition blinds, + By faction still support it, + Or where vile money taints the mind, + They for convenience court it; + But mighty Love, that scorns to show, + Party should raise his glory; + Swears he'll exalt a vassal true, + Let it be _Whig_ or _Tory_." + +The following is a song from "The Country Miss and her Furbelow." + + "Celladon, when spring came on, + Woo'd Sylvia in a grove, + Both gay and young, and still he sung + The sweet Delights of Love. + Wedded joys in girls and boys, + And pretty chat of this and that, + The honey kiss, and charming bliss + That crowns the marriage bed; + He snatched her hand, she blushed and fanned + And seemed as if afraid, + 'Forbear!' she crys, 'youre fawning lyes, + I've vowed to die a maid.' + + "Celladon at that began + To talk of apes in hell, + And what was worse, the odious curse + Of growing old and stale. + Loss of bloom, when wrinkles come, + And offers kind when none will mind, + The rosie joy, and sparkling eye + Grown faded and decayed, + At which, when known, she changed her tone, + And to the shepherd said, + 'Dear swain, give o'er, I'll think once more, + Before I'll die a maid.'" + +D'Urfey was a disciple of the "gentle art." Addison says "I must not +omit that my friend angles for a trout, the best of any man in England. +Mayflies come in late this season, or I myself should have had one of +his hooking." We can thus understand his enthusiastic commendation of +fishing-- + + "Of all the world's enjoyments, + That ever valu'd were, + There's none of our employments, + With fishing can compare; + Some preach, some write, + Some swear, some fight, + All golden lucre courting, + But fishing still bears off the bell + For profit or for sporting. + + "_Chorus._--Then who a jolly fisherman, a fisherman will be? + His throat must wet, + Just like his net, + To keep out cold at sea. + + "The country squire loves running + A pack of well-mouthed hounds, + Another fancies gunning + For wild ducks in his grounds; + This hunts, that fowls, + This hawks, Dick bowls, + No greater pleasure wishing, + But Tom that tells what sport excels, + Gives all the praise to fishing. + Then who, &c. + + "A good _Westphalia gammon_ + Is counted dainty fare; + But what is't to a salmon + Just taken from the Ware; + Wheat-ears and quailes, + Cocks, snipes and rayles, + Are prized while season's lasting, + But all must stoop to crawfish soup, + Or I've no skill in casting. + Then who, &c. + + "And tho' some envious wranglers, + To jeer us will make bold, + And laugh at patient anglers, + Who stand so long i' th' cold; + They wait on Miss, + We wait on this, + And think it easie labour; + And if you know, fish profits too, + Consult our _Holland_ neighbour. + Then who, &c." + +D'Urfey was a favourite with Queen Anne, and many of his poems were +written at Knole, Penshurst, and other seats of the nobility. + +Up to the time we have now reached, we have not had the opportunity of +enrolling the name of a lady among our humorists. Although in society +so many of the fair sparkle and overflow with quick and graceful +raillery, we find that when they come to impress their thoughts upon +paper they are invariably sentimental. Authors are often a contrast to +their writings, but no doubt the female mind is generally of a poetical +complexion. Thus, in the early part of the last century we meet with +only three lady humorists, Mrs. Manley, mostly noted for her scandalous +stories: Mrs. Behn, whose humour was crude, chiefly that of rough +harlequinade and gross immorality, and Mrs. Centlivre. Early +opportunities of study were afforded to the last in a remarkable way. +When flying from the anger of her stepmother, she met Anthony Hammond, +then at Cambridge, and went to live with him at the University, +disguised in boy's clothes. Remarkable for her beauty, she married, when +only fifteen, a nephew of Sir Stephen Fox, and upon his death at +sixteen, a Captain Carrol, who was killed in a duel. It was then partly +owing to pecuniary embarrassments that she went on the stage and wrote +plays--the first of her dramas appearing in her twentieth year. So great +was the prejudice then against lady writers, that at her publisher's +suggestion her first production was anonymous. But those, who began by +deriding her pretensions, ended by acknowledging her merit; she became +a great favourite and constant writer for the stage, and an intimate +friend of Farquhar and Steele. There is an absence of indelicacy in her +plays, but not a little farcical humour, especially in the character of +"Marplot" in "The Busybody," and of rich "Mrs. Dowdy" with her vulgarity +and admirers in "The Platonic Lady." She often adopts the tone of the +day in ridiculing learned ladies. In one place she speaks as if even at +that time the founding of a college for ladies was in contemplation-- + + _Lady Reveller._ Why in such haste, Cousin Valeria? + + _Valeria._ Oh! dear Cousin, don't stop me; I shall lose the finest + insect for dissection, a huge flesh fly, which Mr. Lovely sent me + just now, and opening the box to try the experiment, away it flew. + + _Lady._ I am glad the poor fly escaped; will you never be weary of + these whimsies? + + _Val._ Whimsies! Natural Philosophy a whimsy! Oh! the unlearned + world! + + _Lady._ Ridiculous learning! + + _Mrs. Alpiew._ Ridiculous indeed for women. Philosophy suits our sex + as jack-boots would do. + + _Val._ Custom would bring them as much in fashion as furbelows, and + practice would make us as valiant as e'er a hero of them all; the + resolution is in the mind. Nothing can enslave that. + + _Lady._ My stars! This girl will be mad--that's certain. + + _Val._ Mad! So Nero banished philosophers from _Rome_, and the + first discoverer of the _Antipodes_ was condemned for a heretic. + + _Lady._ In my conscience, Alpiew, this pretty creature's spoiled. + Well, cousin, might I advise you should bestow your fortune in + founding a college for the study of philosophy, where none but + women should be admitted; and to immortalize your name, they + should be called _Valerians_;--ha! ha! ha! + + _Val._ What you make a jest of, I'd execute, were fortune in my + power. + +Her notices of married life are interesting, as she had great +experience, having taken for her third husband Mr. Centlivre, cook to +Queen Anne. In "The Wonder, a Woman keeps a Secret," we have the +following dialogue upon this important subject: + + _Col. Britton._ 'Egad, I think I must e'en marry, and sacrifice my + body for the good of my soul; wilt thou recommend me to a wife, + then--one that is willing to exchange her moydores for English + Liberty--ha friend? + + _Fred._ She must be very handsome, I suppose? + + _Col._ The handsomer the better, but be sure she has a nose. + + _Fred._ Ay! ay! and some gold. + + _Col._ Oh, very much gold. I shall never be able to swallow the + matrimonial pill, if it be not well gilded. + + _Fred._ Puh, beauty will make it slide down nimbly. + + _Col._ At first, perhaps it may, but the second or third dose will + choke me. I confess, Frederick, women are the prettiest playthings + in nature; but gold, substantial gold gives 'em the air, the mien, + the shape, the grace and beauty of a goddess. + + _Fred._ And has not gold the same divinity in their eyes, Colonel? + + _Col._ Too often--money is the very god of marriage, the poets + dress him in a saffron robe by which they figure out the golden + Deity, and his lighted torch blazons those mighty charms, which + encourage us to list under his banner. + +In "The Artifice" we have a matrimonial contention: + + _Lucy._ If you two are one flesh, how come you to have different + minds, pray, Sir? + + _Watchit._ Because the mind has nothing to do with the flesh. + + _Mrs. W._ That's your mistake, Sir; the body is governed by the + mind. So much philosophy I know. + + _Wat._ Yes, yes; I believe you understand natural philosophy very + well, wife; I doubt not the flesh has got the better of the spirit + in you. Look ye, madam! every man's wife is his vineyard; you are + mine, therefore I wall you in. Ods budikins, ne'er a coxcomb in the + kingdom shall plant as much as a primrose in my ground. + + _Mrs. W._ I am sure your management will produce nothing but + thorns. + + _Wat._ Nay, every wife is a thorn in her husband's side. Your whole + sex is a kind of sweet-briar, and he who meddles with it is sure to + prick his fingers. + + _Lucy._ That is when you handle us too roughly. + + _Mrs. W._ You are a kind of rue: neither good for smell nor taste. + + _Wat._ But very wholesome, wife. + + _Mrs. W._ Ay, so they say of all bitters, yet I would not be + obliged to feed on gentian and wormwood. + +Some subjects are peculiarly suitable for light female humour. In "The +Beau's Duel, or a Soldier for the Ladies," we have the following +soliloquy by Sir William Mode, a fop, as he stands in his night-gown +looking into his glass: + + This rising early is the most confounded thing on earth, nothing so + destructive to the complexion. Blister me, how I shall look in the + side box to-night, wretchedly upon my soul. [_looking in the glass + all the while._] Yet it adds something of a languishing air, not + altogether unbecoming, and by candle light may do mischief; but I + must stay at home to recover some colour, and that may be as well + laid on too; so 'tis resolved I will go. Oh 'tis unspeakable + pleasure to be in the side box, or bow'd to from the stage, and be + distinguished by the beaux of quality, to have a lord fly into + one's arms, and kiss one as amorously as a mistress. Then tell me + aloud, that he dined with his Grace and that he and the ladies were + so fond of me, they talked of nothing else. Then says I, "My lord, + his Grace does me too much honour." Then, my lord, "This play 'tis + not worth seeing; we havn't been seen at t'other house to-night; + and the ladies will be disappointed not to receive a bow from Sir + William." "He, he, he," says I, "my lord, I wait upon your + lordship." "Then," says my lord, "lead the way Sir William." "O, + pray my lord, I beg your lordship's pardon." "Nay, Sir William." + "Pray my lord," (_Enter La Riviere, Sir W's valet_). "Pray Sir + William." "Pray my lord." + + (_As he says this several times La Riviere enters behind him, but + as he designs to pass by him, is still prevented by his turning + from one side to t'other, as he acts himself for the lord._) + + _La Riv._ Hey! What the devil is he conjuring and talking with + invisible lords? He's in his airs, some pleasing imagination + hurries him out of his senses. But I must to my cue. Hem! hem! Sir, + dere be one two gentlemen below come to wait upon you dis morning, + sal I show dem up? + + _Sir. W._ No, my lord, by no means, I know better things-- + + _La Riv._ What then am I a lord? Egad I never knew my quality + before. (_Aside._) + + _Sir W._ Pshaw! this blockhead has rous'd me from the prettiest + entertainment in the world (_Aside_). Well, what would you, Sir? + + _La Riv._ I voo'd tell you, Sir, dere be one two gentlemen wait + upon you. + + _Sir W._ And let 'em wait till I have done. I had a thousand fine + things to say on that occasion, but this rude fellow has frightened + 'em all out of my head. (_Aside._) Well, since my better diversion + is over, show 'em up. + +In "The Wonder" we have an amusing scene between Lissardo, servant to +Felix, and Flora, maid to Violante. The former had been very sweet upon +the latter--telling her that his "chaps watered for a kiss," and that +"he would revenge himself on her lips;" but a change comes over him on +his being presented by Violante with a ring to be worn for his master's +sake. + + _Lissardo._ I shall, Madam, (_puts on the ring._) Methinks a + diamond ring is a vast addition to the little finger of a + gentleman. (_Admiring his hand._) + + _Flora._ That ring must be mine. Well, Lissardo, what haste you + make to pay off arrears now? Look how the fellow stands! + + _Liss._ Egad! methinks I have a very pretty hand--and very + white--and the shape! Faith! I never minded it so much before! In + my opinion it is a very fine shaped hand, and becomes a diamond + ring as well as the first grandee's in Portugal. + + _Flo._ The man's transported! Is this your love? This your + impatience? + + _Liss._ (_Takes snuff._) Now in my mind, I take snuff with a very + jaunty air. Well, I am persuaded I want nothing but a coach and a + title to make me a very fine gentleman. + + (_Struts about._) + + _Flo._ Sweet Mr. Lissardo, (_curtseying_,) if I may presume to + speak to you, without affronting your little finger-- + + _Liss._ Do so, Madam, I ask your pardon. Is it to me or to the ring + you direct your discourse, Madam? + + _Flo._ Madam! Good lack! how much a diamond ring improves one! + + _Liss._ Why, tho' I say it, I can carry myself as well as anybody. + But what wert thou going to say, child? + + _Flo._ Why, I was going to say, that I fancy you had best let me + keep that ring; it will be a very pretty wedding-ring. + + _Liss._ Would it not? Humph! Ah! But--but--but--I believe I shan't + marry yet a while. + + _Flo._ You shan't, you say; very well! I suppose you design that + ring for Inis? + + _Liss._ No, no, I never bribe an old acquaintance. Perhaps I might + let it sparkle in the eyes of a stranger a little, till we come to + a right understanding. But then, like all other mortal things, it + would return from whence it came. + + _Flo._ Insolent! Is that your manner of dealing? + + _Liss._ With all but thee--kiss me, you little rogue, you. + + (_Hugging her._) + + _Flo._ Little rogue! Prithee, fellow, don't be so familiar, + (_pushing him away_,) if I mayn't keep your ring, I can keep my + kisses. + + _Liss._ You can, you say! Spoke with the air of a chambermaid. + + _Flo._ Reply'd with the spirit of a serving-man. + +D'Urfey is said to have been the first, and Carey the last of those who +at this period united the professions of musician, dramatist and song +writer. The latter was the natural son of the Marquis of Halifax, who +presented the crown to William III. He wrote the popular song "Sally in +our Alley," and ridiculed Ambrose Philips in a poem called "Namby +Pamby." Overcome either by embarrassed circumstances, or the envy of +rivals, he died by his own hand in 1743. He has much that is clever +mingled with extravagant fancies. Most of his songs are amorous, though +never indelicate. Some are for drinking bouts. + + "Come all ye jolly Bucchanals + That love to tope good wine, + Let's offer up a hogshead + Unto our master's shrine, + Come, let us drink and never shrink, + For I'll tell you the reason why, + It's a great sin to leave a house till we've drunk the cellar dry. + In times of old I was a fool, + I drank the water clear, + But Bacchus took me from that rule, + He thought 'twas too severe; + He filled a bumper to the brim + And bade me take a sup, + But had it been a gallon pot, + By Jove I'd tossed it up. + And ever since that happy time, + Good wine has been my cheer, + Now nothing puts me in a swoon + But water or small beer. + Then let us tope about, my lads, + And never flinch nor fly, + But fill our skins brimfull of wine, + And drain the bottles dry." + +Many of his plays were burlesque operas, introducing songs. In one of +them the "Dragon of Wantley," we have-- + + "Zeno, Plato, Aristotle, + All were lovers of the bottle; + Poets, Painters, and Musicians, + Churchmen, Lawyers, and Physicians; + All admire a pretty lass, + All require a cheerful glass, + Every pleasure has its season, + Love and drinking are no treason." + +He was fond of jocose love-ditties, such as: + + "Pigs shall not be + So fond as we; + We will out-coo the turtle-dove, + Fondly toying, + Still enjoying, + Sporting sparrows we'll outlove." + +Among his successful farces is the well-known Chrononhotonthologos +written to ridicule some bombastic tragedies of the day. +Chrononhotonthologos is king of Queerummania, Bombardinian is his +general, while his courtiers are Aldiborontiphoscophornio and Rigdum +Funnidos. The following gives a good specimen of his ballad style. + + "O! London is a dainty place, + A great and gallant city, + For all the streets are paved with gold, + And all the folks are witty. + + "And there's your lords and ladies fine, + That ride in coach-and-six, + Who nothing drink but claret wine, + And talk of politicks. + + "And there's your beauxs with powdered clothes, + Bedaubed from head to shin; + Their pocket-holes adorned with gold, + But not one sous within." + + + + +CHAPTER X. + +Vanbrugh--Colley Cibber--Farquhar. + + +Vanbrugh--a man of Dutch extraction as his name suggests--was one of the +few whom literature led, though indirectly, to fortune. He became first +known as a playwriter, but also having studied architecture conceived +the idea of combining his two arts by the construction of a grand +theatre on the site of the present Haymarket Opera House. The enterprise +was doomed to be one of the many failures from which that ill-starred +spot has become remarkable, and Vanbrugh after vainly attempting to +support his undertaking by the exertion of all his dramatic power, +determined to quit literature altogether, and devoted himself to the +more remunerative profession. In this he was successful--he built +Blenheim, Castle Howard, and half-a-dozen of the stately halls of +England. We may suppose that he acquired wealth, for he built several +houses for himself, and in them seems to have exhibited his whimsical +fancy. One which he built near Whitehall was called by Swift "a thing +like a goose pie," and he called that which he built for himself, near +Greenwich, "the mince pie." + +There is a considerable amount of rough humour in Vanbrugh, and some +indelicacy, more like that of Aristophanes than of English writers. We +find one gentleman calling another "Old Satan," and fashionable ladies +indulging freely in oaths. A nobleman tells a lady, before her husband, +that he is desperately in love with her, "strike me speechless;" to +which she replies by giving him a box on the ear, and her husband by +drawing his sword. Everything bespeaks a low and primitive state of +society; but we must also remember that while something strong was +required, it was not then thought objectionable that the scenes of the +drama should be very different from those of real life. + +The following are from the "Relapse," the first play that made Vanbrugh +known, and which we might therefore expect to be one of his most +humorous comedies. Here we have a good caricature of the fops of the +day. In the first, Lord Foppington in his fashionable twang, gives us +his views, and sketches his mode of life. + + _Amanda._ Well I must own I think books the best entertainment in + the world. + + _Lord F._ I am so much of your ladyship's mind, madam, that I have + a private gallery where I walk sometimes, which is furnished with + nothing but books and looking glasses. Madam, I have gilded 'em so + prettily, before G--, it is the most entertaining thing in the + world to walk and look upon 'em. + + _Amanda._ Nay, I love a neat library too, but 'tis I think the + inside of a book should recommend it most to us. + + _Lord F._ That, I must confess, I am not altogether so fond of. For + to my mind the inside of a book is to entertain oneself with the + forced product of another man's brain. Now, I think a man of + quality and breeding may be much better diverted with the natural + sprouts of his own. But to say the truth, madam, let a man love + reading never so well, when once he comes to know this town, he + finds so many better ways of passing away the four-and-twenty hours + that 'twere ten thousand pities he should consume his time in that. + For example, madam, my life, my life, madam, is a perpetual stream + of pleasure that glides through such a variety of entertainments, I + believe the wisest of our ancestors never had the least conception + of any of 'em. I rise, madam, about ten o'clock. I don't rise + sooner because it is the worst thing in the world for the + complexion, not that I pretend to be a beau, but a man must + endeavour to look wholesome, lest he make so nauseous a figure in + the side box, the ladies should be compelled to turn their eyes + upon the play. So at ten o'clock I say I rise. Now, if I find it a + good day I resolve to take a turn in the park, and see the fine + women; so huddle on my clothes and get dressed by one. If it be + nasty weather I take a turn in the chocolate house, where as you + walk, madam, you have the prettiest prospect in the world; you have + looking glasses all round you. But I'm afraid I tire the company. + + _Berinthia._ Not at all; pray go on. + + _Lord F._ Why then, ladies, from thence I go to dinner at Lacket's, + where you are so nicely and delicately served that, stab my vitals! + they shall compose you a dish no bigger than a saucer, shall come + to fifty shillings. Between eating my dinner (and washing my mouth, + ladies) I spend my time till I go to the play, when till nine + o'clock I entertain myself with looking upon the company; and + usually dispose of one hour more in leading them out. So there's + twelve of the four-and-twenty pretty well over. The other twelve, + madam, are disposed of in two articles, in the first four I toast + myself drunk, and t'other eight I sleep myself sober again. Thus, + ladies, you see my life is an eternal round O of delight. + +Lord Foppington's interview with his Court artists is well described-- + + _Tom Fashion._ There's that fop now, has not by nature wherewithal + to move a cook-maid, and by that time these fellows have done with + him, egad he shall melt down a countess! But now for my reception; + I'll engage it shall be as cold a one as a courtier's to his + friend, who comes to put him in mind of his promise. + + _Lord F._ (_to his tailor._) Death and eternal tortures! Sir, I say + the packet's too high by a foot. + + _Tailor._ My lord, if it had been an inch lower it would not have + held your lordship's packet-handkerchief. + + _Lord F._ Rat my packet-handkerchief! have not I a page to carry + it? You may make him a packet up to his chin a purpose for it; but + I will not have mine come so near my face. + + _Tailor._ 'Tis not for me to dispute your lordship's fancy. + + _Lord F._ Look you, Sir, I shall never be reconciled to this + nauseous packet, therefore pray get me another suit with all manner + of expedition, for this is my eternal salvation. Mrs. Calico, are + not you of my mind? + + _Mrs. Cal._ O, directly, my lord! It can never be too low. + + _Lord F._ You are positively in the right on't, for the packet + becomes no part of the body but the knee. + + (_Exit tailor._) + + _Mrs. Cal._ I hope your lordship is pleased with your steenkirk. + + _Lord F._ In love with it, stap my vitals! bring your bill, you + shall be paid to-morrow. + + _Mrs. C._ I humbly thank your honour. (_Exit._) + + _Lord F._ Hark thee, shoemaker! these shoes an't ugly but they + don't fit me. + + _Shoemaker._ My lord, methinks they fit you very well. + + _Lord F._ They hurt me just below the instep. + + _Shoe._ (_feeling his foot_) My lord, they don't hurt you there. + + _Lord F._ I tell thee they pinch me execrably. + + _Shoe._ My lord, if they pinch you I'll be bound to be hanged, + that's all. + + _Lord F._ Why wilt thou undertake to persuade me that I cannot + feel? + + _Shoe._ Your lordship may please to feel what you think fit; but + the shoe does not hurt you. I think I understand my trade. + + _Lord F._ Now by all that's great and powerful thou art an + incomprehensible coxcomb! but thou makest good shoes and so I'll + bear with thee. + +Tom Fashion personates his brother, Lord Foppington, and goes down to +the country seat of Sir Tunbelly Clumpsey, in hope of marrying his rich +daughter. The old Squire at first turns out to meet him with guns and +pitchforks, but changes to the utmost servility on hearing that he is a +lord. It is now Tom's object to have the marriage ceremony performed +before he is discovered. + + _Fashion._ Your father, I suppose you know, has resolved to make me + happy in being your husband, and I hope I may depend upon your + consent to perform what he desires. + + _Miss Hoyden._ Sir, I never disobey my father in anything but + eating of green gooseberries. + + _Fash._ So good a daughter must needs be an admirable wife; I am + therefore impatient till you are mine, and hope you will so far + consider the violence of my love as not to defer my happiness so + long as your father designs it. + + _Miss H._ Pray, my lord, how long is that? + + _Fash._ Madam, a thousand years--a whole week. + + _Miss H._ A week! why I shall be an old woman by that time. + + _Fash._ And I an old man. + + _Miss H._ Why I thought it was to-morrow morning as soon as I was + up, I am sure nurse told me so. + + _Fash._ And it shall be to-morrow morning still, if you'll consent. + + _Miss H._ If I'll consent! Why I thought I was to obey you as my + husband. + + _Fash._ That's when we're married, till then I am to obey you. + + _Miss H._ Why then if we are to take it by turns it's the same + thing. I'll obey you now, and when we are married you shall obey + me. + + _Fash._ With all my heart; but I doubt we must get nurse on our + side, or we shall hardly prevail with the chaplain. + + _Miss H._ O Lord, I can tell you a way how to persuade her to + anything. + + _Fash._ How's that? + + _Miss H._ Why tell her she's a wholesome comely woman, and give her + half-a-crown. + + _Fash._ Nay, if that will do, she shall have half a score of them. + + _Miss H._ O gemini! for half that she'd marry you herself. I'll run + and call her. + + _Fash._ So matters go swimmingly. This is a rare girl i' faith. I + shall have a fine time on't with her in London, I'm much mistaken + if she don't prove a March hare all the year round. What a + scampering chase will she on't, when she finds the whole kennel of + beaux at her tail! hey to the park, and the play, and the church + and the devil; she'll show them sport, I'll warrant 'em. But no + matter, she brings me an estate that will afford me a separate + maintenance. + +The following from "The Provoked Husband," gives a good specimen of +social hypocrisy. + + _Servant._ Madam, here's my Lady Fanciful to wait upon your + ladyship. + + _Lady Brute._ Shield me, kind heaven! what an inundation of + impertinence is here coming upon us! + +At the end of this unwelcome visit, we have the following hit at the +ceremonious politeness then fashionable. + + _Lady B._ What going already, madam. + + _Lady Fan._ I must beg you excuse me this once, for really I have + eighteen visits to return this afternoon. So you see I am + importuned by the women as well as by the men. + + _Bel._ (_aside_). And she's quits with 'em both. + + _Lady F._ Nay, you shan't go one step out of the room. + + _Lady B._ Indeed, I'll wait upon you down. + + _Lady F._ No sweet, Lady Brute, you know I swoon at ceremony. + + _Lady B._ Pray give me leave. + + _Lady F._ You know I wont. + + _Lady B._ Indeed I must. + + _Lady F._ Indeed you shan't. + + _Lady B._ Indeed I will. + + _Lady F._ Indeed you shan't. + + _Lady B._ Indeed I will. + + _Lady F._ Indeed you shan't, indeed, indeed, indeed you shan't. + (_Exit running._) + +The aversions and disputes of husbands and wives furnish the subject of +some of his humour. Sir John Brute says:-- + + "Sure if women had been ready created, the devil instead of being + kicked down in hell had been married." + + _Lady Brute._ Are you afraid of being in love, Sir? + + _Heartfree._ I should if there were any danger of it. + + _Lady B._ Pray, why so? + + _Heart._ Because I always had an aversion to being used like a dog. + + _Belinda._ Why truly, men in love are seldom used much better. + + _Lady B._ But were you never in love, Sir? + + _Heart._ No, I thank heaven, madam. + + _Bel._ Pray, where got you your learning then? + + _Heart._ From other people's expense. + + _Bel._ That's being a spunger, Sir, which is scarce honest. If + you'd buy some experience with your own money, as 'twould be + fairlier got, so 'twould stick longer by you. + + * * * * * + + _Berinthia._ Ah, Amanda, it's a delicious thing to be a young + widow! + + _Aman._ You'll hardly make me think so. + + _Ber._ Phu! because you are in love with your husband; but that is + not every woman's case. + + _Aman._ I hope 'twas yours at least. + + _Ber._ Mine, say ye? Now I have a great mind to tell you a lie, but + I should do it so awkwardly you'd find me out. + + _Aman._ Then e'en speak the truth. + + _Ber._ Shall I? Then after all, I did love him, Amanda, as a man + does penance. + + _Aman._ Why did you not refuse to marry him, then? + + _Ber._ Because my mother would have whipped me. + + _Aman._ How did you live together? + + _Ber._ Like man and wife--asunder. He loved the country, I the + town. He hawks and hounds, I coaches and equipage. He eating and + drinking, I carding and playing. He the sound of a horn, I the + squeak of a fiddle. Whenever we met we gave one another the spleen. + + _Aman._ But tell me one thing truly and sincerely. + + _Ber._ What's that? + + _Aman._ Notwithstanding all these jars, did not his death at last + extremely trouble you? + + _Ber._ O, yes. Not that my present pangs were so very violent, but + the after pangs were intolerable. I was forced to wear a beastly + widow's band a twelvemonth for 't. + +In the "Journey to London," written at the end of Vanbrugh's life, and +not finished, there is a very amusing account of the manner in which a +country squire and family travelled up to London in the seventeenth +century. + + _James._ They have added two cart-horses to the four old mares, + because my lady will have it said she came to town in her + coach-and-six; and ha! ha! heavy George, the ploughman, rides + postilion! + + _Uncle Richard._ Very well; the journey begins as it should + do--James! + + _James._ Sir! + + _Uncle R._ Dost know whether they bring all the children with them? + + _James._ Only Squire Humphry and Miss Betty, Sir; the other six are + put to board at half-a-crown a week a head with Joan Growse, at + Smoke-dunghill Farm. + + _Uncle R._ The Lord have mercy upon all good folks! What work will + these people make! Dost know when they'll be here? + + _James._ John says, Sir, they'd have been here last night, but that + the old wheezy-belly horse tired, and the two fore-wheels came + crash down at once in Waggon-rut Lane. Sir, they were cruelly + loaden, as I understand. My lady herself, he says, laid on four + mail trunks, besides the great deal-box, which fat Tom sat upon + behind. + + _Uncle R._ So. + + _James._ Then within the coach there was Sir Francis, my lady, the + great fat lap-dog, Squire Humphry, Miss Betty, my lady's maid, Mrs. + Handy, and Doll Tripe, the cook--but she puked with sitting + backward, so they mounted her into the coach-box. + + _Uncle R._ Very well. + + _James._ Then, Sir, for fear of a famine before they should get to + the baiting-place, there was such baskets of plum-cake, Dutch + gingerbread, Cheshire cheese, Naples biscuits, maccaroons, neats' + tongues, and cold boiled beef; and in case of sickness, such + bottles of usquebaugh, black-cherry brandy, cinnamon water, sack, + tent, and strong beer, as made the old coach crack again. + + _Uncle R._ Well said! + + _James._ And for defence of this good cheer, and my lady's little + pearl necklace, there was the family basket-hilt sword, the great + Turkish cimiter, the old blunder-buss, a good bag of bullets, and a + great horn of gunpowder. + + _Uncle R._ Admirable! + +Vanbrugh's friend, Colley Cibber, was also of foreign origin. His father +was a native of Holstein, and coming over to England before the +Restoration, is known as having executed the two figures of lunatics, +for the gates of Bethlehem Hospital. Colley commenced life as an actor +and playwriter, and Vanbrugh was so pleased with his "Love's Last Shift, +or the Fool of Fashion," that he wrote an improved version of it in "The +Relapse." Thus Sir Novelty Fashion was developed into Lord Foppington, +and Vanbrugh, who patronized Cibber, employed him to act the character. +He was an exception to the rule that a good playwriter is not a good +performer. In Cibber, we especially mark the Spanish element, which then +tinged the drama, and although somewhat prosy and sententious, he is +fertile and entertaining in his love intrigues. Of real humour, he seems +to have no gift--some of his best attempts referring to such common +failures as sometimes occur at hotels. We have in "She wou'd, and she +wou'd not," + + _Host._ Did you call, gentlemen? + + _Trapparti._ Yes, and bawl too, Sir. Here the gentlemen are almost + famished, and nobody comes near 'em. What have you in the house now + that will be ready presently? + + _Host._ You may have what you please, Sir. + + _Hypolita._ Can you get us a partridge? + + _Host._ We have no partridges; but we'll get you what you please in + a moment. We have a very good neck of mutton, Sir, if you please, + it shall be clapt down in a moment. + + _Hyp._ Have you any pigeons or chickens? + + _Host._ Truly, Sir, we have no fowl in the house at present; if you + please, you may have anything else in a moment. + + _Hyp._ Then, prithee, get us some young rabbits. + + _Host._ Upon my word, Sir, rabbits are so scarce, they are not to + be had for money. + + _Trap._ Have you any fish? + + _Host._ Fish! Sir; I dressed yesterday the finest dish that ever + came upon a table; I am sorry we have none, Sir; but, if you + please, you may have anything else in a moment. + + _Trap._ Hast thou nothing but Anything else in the house? + + _Host._ Very good mutton, Sir. + + _Hyp._ Prithee, get us a breast, then. + + _Host._ Breast! Don't you love the neck, Sir? + + _Hyp._ Ha' ye nothing in the house but the neck? + + _Host._ Really, Sir, we don't use to be so unprovided, but at + present we have nothing else left. + + _Trap._ Faith, Sir, I don't know but a Nothing else may be very + good meat, when Anything else is not to be had. + +Sometimes there is a little smartness in the dialogue, and in the +"Careless Husband," Lord Foppington uses such strange expletives as "Sun +burn me," "Stop my breath," "Set my blood." But the greater part of any +amusement that there is, depends, as in the Roman Comedy, upon the +tricks of low-minded mercenary servants. + +Although neither of the two last-named writers was English by descent, +they were both so by adoption, and the same may be said of the next +author, Farquhar, who was born at Londonderry in 1678, but whose Irish +characters want the charm of the pure national comicality. He was the +son of a clergyman who sent him to the University, but his taste being +averse to the prescribed course of study, he left it, and became an +actor. Want of voice soon excluded him from the stage, and he entered +the army--a profession which we might conclude, from the experiences of +Wycherley and Vanbrugh, was somewhat favourable for the cultivation of +dramatic talent. The constant companionship of men of wild and fanciful +dispositions, the leisure for observing their talents and peculiarities, +and the perpetual demand for the exercise of light repartee, would all +tend to furnish effective materials for the stage. Farquhar soon +married, and his poverty, with an increasing family, led to his +producing a play nearly every year from 1703 to 1707. Finally he sold +out, and was in deep distress. Speaking of his condition with his +accustomed gaiety, he says:-- + + "I have very little estate, but what is under the circumference of + my hat, and should I by perchance come to lose my head, I should + not be worth a groat." + +He thus sketches his mental peculiarities:-- + + "As to my mind, which in most men wears as many changes as their + body, so in me 'tis generally drest like my person, in black. + Melancholy is its every-day apparel; and it has hitherto found few + holidays to make it change its clothes. In short, my constitution + is very splenetic and yet very amorous, both which I endeavour to + hide lest the former should offend others, and that the latter + might incommode myself; and my reason is so vigilant in restraining + these two failings, that I am taken for an easy-natured man with my + own sex, and an ill-natured clown by yours." + +Farquhar was very fond of jesting about his own misfortunes, and perhaps +the following from "Love in a Bottle," exhibits a scene in which he had +been himself an actor in real life. + + _Widow Bullfinch._ Mr. Lyric, what do you mean by all this? Here + you have lodged two years in my house, promised me eighteen-pence a + week for your lodging, and I have never received eighteen + farthings, not the value of _that_, Mr. Lyric, (_snaps her + fingers._) You always put me off with telling me of your play, your + play! Sir, you shall play no more with me: I'm in earnest. + + _Lyric._ There's more trouble in a play than you imagine, Madam. + + _Bull._ There's more trouble with a lodger than you think, Mr. + Lyric. + + _Lyric._ First there's the decorum of time. + + _Bull._ Which you never observe, for you keep the worst hours of + any lodger in town. + + _Lyric._ Then there's the exactness of characters. + + _Bull._ And you have the most scandalous one I ever heard.... + + _Lyric._ (_Aside_) Was ever poor rogue so ridden. If ever the Muses + had a horse, I am he. (_Aloud_) Faith! Madam, poor Pegasus is + jaded. + + _Bull._ Come, come, Sir; he shan't slip his neck out of collar for + all that. Money I will have, and money I must have. + +The above is taken from Farquhar's first play, and we generally find +richer humour in the first attempts of genius than in their later and +more elaborate productions. Widow Bullfinch says that "Champagne is a +fine liquor, which all your beaux drink to make em' witty." + + _Mockmode._ Witty! oh by the universe I must be witty! I'll drink + nothing else. I never was witty in all my life. I love jokes + dearly. Here, Club, bring us a bottle of what d'ye call it--the + witty liquor. + + _Bull._ But I thought that all you that were bred at the University + would be wits naturally? + + _Mock._ The quite contrary, Madam, there's no such thing there. We + dare not have wit there for fear of being counted rakes. Your solid + philosophy is all read there, which is clear another thing. But now + I will be a wit, by the universe.... Is that the witty liquor? Come + fill the glasses. Now that I have found my mistress, I must next + find my wits. + + _Club._ So you had need, master, for those that find a mistress are + generally out of their wits. (_Gives him a glass._) + + _Mock._ Come, fill for yourself. (_They jingle and drink._) But + where's the wit now, Club? Have you found it? + + _Club._ Egad! master, I think 'tis a very good jest. + + _Mock._ What? + + _Club._ What? why drinking--you'll find, master, that this same + gentleman in the straw doublet, this same will-i'-th'-wisp is a wit + at the bottom. (_Fills._) Here, here, master; how it puns and + quibbles in the glass! + + _Mock._ By the universe, now I have it!--the wit lies in the + jingling. All wit consists most in jingling; hear how the glasses + rhyme to one another. + +Again:-- + + _Mock._ Could I but dance well, push well,[63] play upon the flute, + and swear the most modish oaths, I would set up for quality with + e'er a young nobleman of 'em all. Pray what are the most + fashionable oaths in town? Zoons, I take it, is a very becoming + one. + + _Rigadoon._ (_a dancing-master._) Zoons is only used by the + disbanded officers and bullies, but zauns is the beaux + pronunciation. + + _Mock._ Zauns! + + _Rig._ Yes, Sir; we swear as we dance; smooth and with a + cadence--Zauns! 'Tis harmonious, and pleases the ladies, because it + is soft. Zauns, Madam, is the only compliment our great beaux pass + on a lady. + + _Mock._ But suppose a lady speaks to me; what must I say? + + _Rig._ Nothing, Sir; you must take snuff grin, and make her a + humble cringe--thus: (_Bows foppishly and takes snuff; Mockmode + imitates him awkwardly, and taking snuff, sneezes._) O Lord, Sir! + you must never sneeze; 'tis as unbecoming after orangery as grace + after meat. + + _Mock._ I thought people took it to clear the brain. + + _Rig._ The beaux have no brains at all, Sir; their skull is a + perfect snuff-box; and I heard a physician swear, who opened one of + 'em, that the three divisions of his head were filled with + orangery, bergamot, and plain Spanish. + + _Mock._ Zauns! I must sneeze, (_sneezes._) Bless me! + + _Rig._ Oh, fy! Mr. Mockmode! what a rustical expression that is! + 'Bless me!' You should upon all such occasions cry, Dem me! You + would be as nauseous to the ladies as one of the old patriarchs, if + you used that obsolete expression. + +Sir Harry Wildair gives a good sketch of a lady's waiting-woman of the +time. + + _Colonel Standard._ Here, here, Mrs. Parly; whither so fast? + + _Parly._ Oh Lord! my master! Sir, I was running to Mademoiselle + Furbelow, the French milliner, for a new burgundy for my lady's + head. + + _Col. S._ No, child; you're employed about an old-fashioned + garniture for your master's head, if I mistake not your errand. + + _Parly._ Oh, Sir! there's the prettiest fashion lately come over! + so airy, so French, and all that. The pinners are double ruffled + with twelve plaits of a side, and open all from the face; the hair + is frizzled all up round the head, and stands as stiff as a bodkin. + Then the favourites hang loose on the temples, with a languishing + lock in the middle. Then the caul is extremely wide, and over all + is a coronet raised very high, and all the lappets behind. + +This lady on being questioned, says that her wages are ten pounds a +year, but she makes two hundred a year of her mistress's old clothes. + +But Farquhar is best known as the author of the "Beaux Stratagem." +Though not so full of humour, as "Love in a Bottle," it had more action +and bolder sensational incidents. The play proved a great success, but +one which will always have sad associations. It came too late. Farquhar +died in destitution, while the plaudits resounded in his ears. + +The following are specimens from his last play:-- + +(Aimwell (a gentleman of broken fortune looking for a rich wife) goes to +church in the country to further his designs.) + + _Aimwell._ The appearance of a stranger in a country church draws + as many gazers as a blazing star; no sooner he comes into the + cathedral, but a train of whispers runs buzzing round the + congregation in a moment: _Who is he?_ _Whence comes he?_ _Do you + know him?_ Then I, Sir, tips me the verger with half-a-crown; he + pockets the simony, and inducts me into the best pew in the church; + I pull out my snuff-box, turn myself round, bow to the bishop, or + the dean, if he be the commanding officer, single out a beauty, + rivet both my eyes to hers, set my nose a bleeding by the strength + of imagination, and show the whole church my concern--by my + endeavouring to hide it; after the sermon the whole town gives me + to her for a lover, and by persuading the lady that I am a-dying + for her, the tables are turned, and she in good earnest falls in + love with me. + + _Archer._ There's nothing in this, Tom, without a precedent; but + instead of rivetting your eyes to a beauty, try to fix 'em upon a + fortune; that's our business at present. + + _Aim._ Psha! no woman can be a beauty without a fortune. Let me + alone, for I am a marksman. + +Talking afterwards of Dorinda, whom he observes in church, he says, + + _Aimwell._ Call me Oroondates, Cesario, Amadis, all that romance + can in a lover paint, and then I'll answer:--O, Archer! I read her + thousands in her looks, she looked like Ceres in her harvest; corn, + wine and oil, milk and honey, gardens, groves, and purling streams + played in her plenteous face. + + + + +CHAPTER XI. + +Congreve--Lord Dorset. + + +The birthplace of Congreve is uncertain, but he was born about 1671, and +was educated in Kilkenny and Dublin. He is an instance of that union of +Irish versatility with English reflection, which has produced the most +celebrated wits. We also mark in him a considerable improvement in +delicacy. "The Old Batchelor" was his first play, the success of which +was so great that Lord Halifax made him one of the commissioners for +licensing hackney-coaches; he afterwards gave him a place in the Pipe +Office and Custom House. + +Belmour begins very suitably by saying-- + + "Come come, leave business to idlers, and wisdom to fools; they + have need of 'em. Wit be my faculty, and pleasure my occupation; + and let Father Time shake his glass." + +Speaking of Belinda, he says-- + + "In my conscience I believe the baggage loves me, for she never + speaks well of me herself, nor suffers anybody else to rail at me." + +Heartwell, an old bachelor, says-- + + "Women's asses bear great burdens; are forced to undergo dressing, + dancing, singing, sighing, whining, rhyming, flattery, lying, + grinning, cringing, and the drudgery of loving to boot.... Every + man plays the fool once in his life, but to marry is to play the + fool all one's life long." + +In Belinda we have a specimen of one of the fast young ladies of the +period, who certainly seems to have used strong language. She cries, + + Oh, that most inhuman, barbarous, hackney-coach! I am jolted to a + jelly, am I not horridly touz'd? + +She chides Belmour, + + Prithee hold thy tongue! Lord! he has so pestered me with flowers + and stuff, I think I shan't endure the sight of a fire for a + twelvemonth. + + _Belmour._ Yet all can't melt that cruel frozen heart. + + _Bel._ O, gad! I hate your hideous fancy--you said that once + before--if you must talk impertinently, for Heaven's sake let it be + with variety; don't come always like the devil wrapped in flames. + I'll not hear a sentence more that begins with, "I burn," or an "I + beseech you, Madam." + +At last she exclaims, + + "O! my conscience! I could find in my heart to marry thee, purely + to be rid of thee." + +There is frequently a conflict of wit. Sharper tells Sir Joseph Willot +that he lost many pounds, when he was defending him in a scuffle the +night before. He hopes he will repay him. + + Money is but dirt, Sir Joseph; mere dirt, Sir Joseph. + + _Sir Joseph._ But I profess 'tis a dirt I have washed my hands of + at present. + +Lord Froth in "The Double Dealer" says, + + There is nothing more unbecoming in a man of gravity than to laugh, + to be pleased with what pleases the crowd. When I laugh, I always + laugh alone. + + _Brisk._ I suppose that's because you laugh at your own jests. + +Sir Paul Plyant in great wroth expresses himself as follows: + +The subjects of Congreve's Comedies would often be thought objectionable +at the present day. The humour is not in the plot, but in the general +dialogue. In "Love for Love," Ben Legend, a sailor, speaking of lawyers, +says-- + + Lawyer, I believe there's many a cranny and leak unstopt in your + conscience. If so be that one had a pump to your bosom, I believe + we should discern a foul hold. They say a witch will sail in a + sieve, but I believe the devil would not venture aboard your + conscience. + +The last play he wrote, which failed, was deficient in wit, but had +plenty of inebriety in it. After singing a drinking song, Sir Wilful +says in "The Way of the World." + + The sun's a good pimple, an honest soaker, he has a cellar at your + Antipodes. If I travel, Aunt, I touch at your Antipodes--your + Antipodes are a good rascally sort of topsy-turvy fellows. If I had + a bumper I'd stand on my head, and drink a health to them. + + * * * * * + + _Scandal._ Yes, mine (_pictures_) are not in black and white, and + yet there are some set out in their true colours, both men and + women. I can show you pride, folly, affectation, wantonness, + inconstancy, covetousness, dissimulation, malice and ignorance all + in one piece. Then I can show your lying, foppery, vanity, + cowardice, bragging, incontinence, and ugliness in another piece, + and yet one of them is a celebrated beauty, and t'other a professed + beau. I have paintings, too, some pleasant enough. + + _Mrs. Frail._ Come, let's hear 'em. + + _Scan._ Why, I have a beau in a bagnio cupping for a complexion, + and sweating for a shape. + + _Mrs. F._ So---- + + _Scan._ Then I have a lady burning brandy in a cellar with a + hackney coachman. + + _Mrs. F._ Oh! well, but that story is not true. + + _Scan._ I have some hieroglyphics, too; I have a lawyer with a + hundred hands, two heads, and but one face; a divine with two faces + and one head; and I have a soldier with his brains in his belly, + and his heart where his head should be. + +It has been said that Congreve retired on the appearance of Mrs. +Centlivre, but so high was the opinion entertained of his genius that he +was buried in Westminster Abbey, and his pall was supported by noblemen. +Pope was one of his greatest admirers, and dedicated his translation of +Homer to him. + +Dryden writes on Congreve. + + "In easy dialogue is Fletcher's praise, + He moved the mind, but had not power to raise, + Great Jonson did by strength of judgment please, + Yet doubling Fletcher's force, he wants his ease. + In differing talents both adorned their age, + One for the study, t'other for the stage, + But both to Congreve justly shall submit, + One matched in judgment, both over-matched in wit." + +Macaulay says "the wit of Congreve far outshines that of every comic +writer, except Sheridan, who has arisen within the last two centuries." + +Lord Dorset of whom we have above spoken deserves some passing notice. +He was high in the favour of Charles II., James, and William; and was +one of the most accomplished of the courtiers of that day, who, +notwithwstanding their dissipation, were more or less scholars, and +wrote poetry. What was better, he was a munificent supporter of real +literary genius, and patronized Dryden, and to judge by their +commendations was not neglectful of Congreve and Pope. + +Most of his poems are in the pastoral strain, but do not show any great +talent. Two or three of them have some humour-- + + "Dorinda's sparkling wit and eyes + United, cast too fierce a light, + Which blazes high, but quickly dies, + Pains not the heart, but hurts the sight; + + * * * * * + + "Love is a calmer, gentler joy, + Smooth are his looks, and soft his pace; + Her cupid is a blackguard boy + That runs his link right in your face." + +Lord Dorset was at the battle of Opdam when the Dutch Admiral's fleet +was destroyed in 1665. The night before the engagement he wrote the well +known epistle + + "To all you ladies now on land, + We men at sea indite, + And first would have you understand + How hard it is to write; + The Muses now and Neptune too, + We must implore to write to you. + With a fa la la la la. + + "For though the Muses should prove kind, + And fill our empty brain, + Yet if rough Neptune raise the wind, + To wave the azure main, + Our paper, pen and ink, and we, + Roll up and down our ships at sea. + With a fa, la, &c. + + "Should foggy Opdam chance to throw + Our sad and dismal story, + The Dutch would scorn so weak a foe, + And quit their fort at Goree; + For what resistance can they find + From men who've left their hearts behind? + With a fa, la, &c. + + "In justice you cannot refuse + To think of our distress, + When we for hope of honour lose + Our certain happiness; + All those designs are but to prove + Ourselves more worthy of your love. + With a fa, la, &c. + + "And now we've told you all our loves, + And likewise all our fears, + In hopes this declaration moves, + Some pity from your tears; + Let's hear of no inconstancy, + We have too much of that at sea. + With a fa la la la la." + +We can easily understand how the above lines were suggested, for in +those times the same officers served both in army and navy, and many of +the young sparks taken from the gaieties of London had not yet acquired +their sea legs. Wycherley is said to have been present at some of the +engagements with the Dutch. + + +END OF THE FIRST VOLUME. + + + * * * * * + + +FOOTNOTES: + +[1] Of course this will scarcely apply in those cases in which, by +abstraction, we overlook the creative action of the mind, and regard its +humorous productions as ludicrous. Nor does it hold good where from long +exercise of ingenuity a habit has been formed and amusing fancies spring +up, as it were naturally, and so involuntarily that, for the moment, we +see them only as ludicrous. This view changes almost instantaneously, +and beneath it we often find the best humour. It may be said that such +cases should be placed entirely under the head of humour, but can we +maintain that a man is unaware when he is humorous? The most telling +effects are produced by the ludicrous, and where the creative action of +the mind is scarcely discernible. Efforts to be humorous are seldom +crowned with success; we require something that appears to be real or +original, either as a close rendering of actual occurrences, or a +spontaneous efflorescence of genius. Among the latter class we may +reckon some of our most exquisite and permanent sayings. + +[2] A story is told of a Mr. Crispe, a merchant of London, who although +deaf, when Sir Alexander Cary made a speech before his execution, +followed the motion of his lips so as to be able to relate it to his +friends. + +[3] Mrs. Barbauld had such a perpetual smile that one of her friends +said it made her jaws ache to look at her. + +[4] St. Paul, who was brought up at the feet of Gamaliel, gives a +different account in Rom. iv. 19. See also Heb. xi. 11. + +[5] Soame Jenyns strangely imagined that a portion of the happiness of +Seraphim and of just men made perfect would be derived from an exquisite +perception of the ludicrous; while Addison mentions that a learned monk +laid it down as a doctrine that laughter was the effect of original sin, +and that Adam could not laugh before the fall. Some of the early +Christians felt so strongly the incompatibility of strong human emotions +with the divine nature that they expunged the words "Jesus wept." + +[6] Perhaps Solomon was amused by them, for in the catalogue of the +valuable things brought in his ships are apes and peacocks. + +[7] I cannot see in Homer any of that philosophic satire on the +condition of mortals, which some have found in those passages where men +are represented as being deceived and tricked by the gods. Anything so +deep would be beyond humour. He very probably conceived that the gods, +whom he represented as similar to men, were sometimes not above playing +severe practical jokes on them. The so-called irony of Sophocles in like +manner, is too philosophical and bitter for humour. + +[8] Tom Brown, the humorist, says, Lycambes complimented the Iambics of +Archilochus with the most convincing proof of their wit and goodness. + +[9] Archilochus could not have been called a satirist in the correct +sense of the word. His observations were mostly personal or +philosophical. He had evidently considerable power in illustrating the +moral by the physical world, and one of his sayings "Speak not evil of +the dead," has become proverbial. + +[10] Irony had previously been used in Asia. The only specimens of +humour in the Old Testament are of this character, as in Job, "No doubt +but ye are the people, and wisdom shall die with you;" where Elijah says +to the prophets of Baal, "Cry aloud, for he is a god," and the children +call after Elisha, "Go up, thou bald-head." + +[11] Magnes and others of the day used similar titles. We read that +there were once three Homeric hymns extant, named "The Monkeys," "The +seven-times-shorn Goat," and "The Song on the Thrushes." + +[12] After disposing of his daughters for a bunch of garlic and a little +salt, he exclaims, "Oh, Mercury, God of Traffic, grant that I may sell +my wife as profitably, and my mother too!" + +[13] So the pun may be represented. + +[14] Certainly not before 460 B.C. + +[15] Compare our "Billingsgate." + +[16] We sometimes speak of a seedy coat. + +[17] The answers to the above riddles are, thistledown, sleep, night and +day, shade. + +[18] "Gugga" seems to have corresponded with our "Nigger." + +[19] About three and nine pence. + +[20] Roman mirrors made of silver. + +[21] _Scurra_ originally meant a neighbour, then a gossip, then a +pleasant fellow, and finally a jocose, and in those rude times a +scurrilous man. + +[22] There is a story of Caligula having had an actor burnt alive for +making an offensive pun in an Atellane play. Sometimes nicknames were +thus made. Placidus was Acidus, Labienus, Rabienus; Claudius Tiberius +Nero was Caldius Biberius Mero. + +[23] I have been obliged to omit some of the pungent indelicacy of the +original. The Pope was the sacrificing priest. + +[24] We meet with such words as _verrucosus_, _sanna_, a grimace, and +_stloppus_, the sound made by striking the inflated cheeks. + +[25] "A satirist is always to be suspected, who to make vice odious +dwells upon all its acts and minutest circumstances with a sort of +relish and retrospective fondness."--_Lamb._ + +[26] Palindromes, such as "Tibi subito motibus ibit." We have some in +English, as where our forefather addresses his wife "Madam, I'm Adam." + +[27] Pyrogenes has a double meaning, "born of corn," and "born of fire," +alluding to Bacchus' mother having been burnt. Bromos is a kind of +cereal, Bromion a name for Bacchus. + +[28] A man of Capreæ, having caught an unusually large barbel, presented +it to Tiberius, who was so enraged at his being able to find him in his +retreat, that he ordered his face to be scrubbed with the fish. + +[29] Some of the pagans put off Christian baptism till the last moment +under this idea. + +[30] There seems to me to be several reasons for drawing this +conclusion. + +[31] "Semel minusne, an bis minus; non sat scio, An utrumque eorum, +ut quondam audivi dicier Jovi ipsi regi noluit concedere." + +[32] The answers to these enigmas are rose, fleas, sea-mew, visions, +wheels. + +[33] As late as the fourteenth century there were only four classical +works in the Royal Library at Paris. + +[34] Ritson characteristically observes, "There is this distinction +between the heathen deities and Christian saints, that the fables of the +former were indebted for their existence to the flowing inspiration of +the sublime poet, and the legends of the latter to the gloomy fanaticism +of a lazy monk or a stinking priest." + +[35] Sometimes anciently called "West Wales." + +[36] King Alfred advanced so far as to make a translation of a classical +history written by Orosius in 416; but the object of the work was to +show that Christianity was not the cause of the evils which had befallen +the Roman Empire. + +[37] Two of them are mentioned as superior to Homer. One pretended to be +derived from Dares, a Phrygian, who fought on the Trojan side, and +another from Dictys, a Cretan, who was with the Greeks. + +[38] The kind of stories prevalent in these countries may be conjectured +from the two related by John of Bromton, as believed by the natives. One +relates that the head of a child lies at the bottom of the Gulf of +Sataliah in Asia Minor, and that when the head is partly upright, such +storms prevail in the gulf that no vessel can live, but when it is lying +down there is a calm. The other asserts that once in every month a great +black dragon comes in the clouds, plunges his head into the stream, but +leaves his tail in the sky, and draws up the water, so that even ships +are carried into the air. The only way for sailors to escape this +monster, is to make a great noise by beating and shouting, so as to +frighten him. + +[39] Originally an Arcadian superstition. + +[40] Pinnacles. + +[41] Tiles. + +[42] The following is the original. + + "Meum est propositum in taberna mori, + Vinum sit appositum morientis ori, + Ut dicant cum venerint angelorum chori, + Deus sit propitius huic potatori." + +[43] An idea probably borrowed from the classical writers. + +[44] Or the "Amiable," a translation of his father's name. + +[45] Mr. Drummond in his Life of Erasmus. + +[46] Reprinted by Halliwell. + +[47] See "Art-Journal." + +[48] I remember to have seen such a procession at Como in the Holy Week. +The various accessories of the Passion were borne along on the top of +poles with appropriate mottoes, for example: Two ladders crossed, "He +bowed the heavens and came down." A stuffed cock, "The cock crew." A +barber's basin, "Pilate washed his hands," &c. The effect was almost +ludicrous. + +[49] Lucian makes the father of Cleanthis congratulate himself on having +obtained a buffoon for his son's wedding feast. This individual was an +ugly little fellow with close shaven head, except a few straggling hairs +made up to resemble a cock. He began by dancing and contorting his body +and spouting some Ægytian verses, then he launched all kinds of +fooleries at the company. Most laughed, but on his calling Alcidamas a +Maltese puppy, he was challenged to fight or have his brains dashed out. + +[50] But this may have been traditional, for the fools in classic times +were sometimes shaven. + +[51] Wright's "History of the Grotesque." + +[52] Such as the Wife of Bath's tale, and in "January and May," or the +"Marchante's Tale." + +[53] She was roasting a pig. + +[54] Most of the ridiculous answers said to have been made at +examinations are mere humorous inventions. We almost think there must be +a slight improvement made in the following, though they are upon the +authority of an examiner, + + What are the great Jewish Feasts? + Purim, Urim, and Thummin. + What bounded Samaria on the East? + The Jordan. + What on the West? + The other side of Jordan. + Derive an English word from the Latin _necto_? + Necktie. + +Nor can we doubt that a slight humorous colouring has been introduced +into the following from the "Memorials of Archibald Constable," recently +published by his son.--An old deaf relation said on her death-bed to her +attendant, "Ann, if I should be spared, I hope my nephew will get the +doctor to open my head, and see whether anything can be done for my +hearing." + +[55] One of Anne Boleyn's principal favourites was Sir Thomas Wyatt, who +was celebrated at that day as a man of humour, though at present we see +nothing in his poems but a few poetical conceits. The titles of them are +suggestive: "The Lover sending sighs to move his suit." "Of his Love who +pricked her finger with a needle." "The Lover praiseth the beauty of his +Lady's hand." He wrote the following upon the Queen's name:-- + + "What word is that, that changeth not, + Though it be turned and made in twain? + It is mine Anna, God it wot, + The only causer of my pain; + My love that meedeth with disdain; + Yet is it loved, what will you more? + It is my salve and eke my sore." + + +[56] Christina of Sweden made a similar remark when the Order of the +Garter was sent to Charles Gustavus. + +[57] Pace had said the same to Queen Elizabeth, and from such strokes +jesters were called 'honest,' as 'Honest Jo,' &c. + +[58] There is little humour in Shadwell's works; he succeeded Dryden as +Poet Laureate, which was perhaps the cause of the above lines. + +Rochester said, "If Shadwell had burnt all he wrote, and printed all he +spoke, he would have had more wit and humour than any poet." Probably +his wit would have been like Rochester's. Whether Shadwell were himself +a good poet or not, he made a hit at the poetasters of his day, in which +he showed some genius. + + _Poet._ O, very loftily! + The winged vallance of your eyes advance + Shake off your canopied and downie trance: + Phoebus already quaffs the morning dew, + Each does his daily lease of life renew. + Now you shall hear description, 'tis the very life of poetry. + He darts his beams on the lark's mossy house, + And from his quiet tenement doth rouse + The little charming and harmonious fowl + Which sings its lump of body to a soul. + Swiftly it clambers up in the steep air + With warbling notes, and makes each note a stair. + + +[59] Sir Roger L'Estrange gives the names of the people attacked. + +[60] One of Cromwell's principal officers. + +[61] Thus familiarly called, no doubt owing to the custom of giving pet +names to jesters. + +[62] Guardian, Vol. I. No. 2. + +[63] Fence. + + London: Printed by A. Schulze, 13, Poland Street. + + + +***END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK HISTORY OF ENGLISH HUMOUR, VOL. 1 +(OF 2)*** + + +******* This file should be named 18300-8.txt or 18300-8.zip ******* + + +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: +http://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/1/8/3/0/18300 + + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +http://www.gutenberg.org/license). + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS', WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need, is critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at http://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/pglaf. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at http://www.gutenberg.org/about/contact + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit http://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/donate + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. +To donate, please visit: +http://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart is the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + http://www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. + |
