diff options
Diffstat (limited to '17350-8.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | 17350-8.txt | 4422 |
1 files changed, 4422 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/17350-8.txt b/17350-8.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..b7b56db --- /dev/null +++ b/17350-8.txt @@ -0,0 +1,4422 @@ +The Project Gutenberg EBook of The Practice and Theory of Bolshevism +by Bertrand Russell + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: The Practice and Theory of Bolshevism + +Author: Bertrand Russell + +Release Date: December 19, 2005 [EBook #17350] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK BOLSHEVISM *** + + + + +Produced by Thierry Alberto, Jeannie Howse and the Online +Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net + + + + + + + + +---------------------------------------------------------+ + | | + | Transcriber's Note: | + | A number of obvious typographical errors have been | + | corrected in this text. For a complete list, please | + | see the bottom of this document. | + | Corrections listed in the existing Errata at the | + | end of this book have been applied to the text. | + | | + +---------------------------------------------------------+ + + + + +The Practice and Theory +of Bolshevism + + + +Bertrand Russell + + + + + +LONDON: GEORGE ALLEN & UNWIN LTD. +RUSKIN HOUSE, 40 MUSEUM STREET, W.C. 1 + + + + +_First published November 1920_ +_Reprinted February 1921_ + + + +(_All rights reserved_) + + + + +PREFACE + + +The Russian Revolution is one of the great heroic events of the +world's history. It is natural to compare it to the French Revolution, +but it is in fact something of even more importance. It does more to +change daily life and the structure of society: it also does more to +change men's beliefs. The difference is exemplified by the difference +between Marx and Rousseau: the latter sentimental and soft, appealing +to emotion, obliterating sharp outlines; the former systematic like +Hegel, full of hard intellectual content, appealing to historic +necessity and the technical development of industry, suggesting a view +of human beings as puppets in the grip of omnipotent material forces. +Bolshevism combines the characteristics of the French Revolution with +those of the rise of Islam; and the result is something radically new, +which can only be understood by a patient and passionate effort of +imagination. + +Before entering upon any detail, I wish to state, as clearly and +unambiguously as I can, my own attitude towards this new thing. + +By far the most important aspect of the Russian Revolution is as an +attempt to realize Communism. I believe that Communism is necessary to +the world, and I believe that the heroism of Russia has fired men's +hopes in a way which was essential to the realization of Communism in +the future. Regarded as a splendid attempt, without which ultimate +success would have been very improbable, Bolshevism deserves the +gratitude and admiration of all the progressive part of mankind. + +But the method by which Moscow aims at establishing Communism is a +pioneer method, rough and dangerous, too heroic to count the cost of +the opposition it arouses. I do not believe that by this method a +stable or desirable form of Communism can be established. Three issues +seem to me possible from the present situation. The first is the +ultimate defeat of Bolshevism by the forces of capitalism. The second +is the victory of the Bolshevists accompanied by a complete loss of +their ideals and a régime of Napoleonic imperialism. The third is a +prolonged world-war, in which civilization will go under, and all its +manifestations (including Communism) will be forgotten. + +It is because I do not believe that the methods of the Third +International can lead to the desired goal that I have thought it +worth while to point out what seem to me undesirable features in the +present state of Russia. I think there are lessons to be learnt which +must be learnt if the world is ever to achieve what is desired by +those in the West who have sympathy with the original aims of the +Bolsheviks. I do not think these lessons can be learnt except by +facing frankly and fully whatever elements of failure there are in +Russia. I think these elements of failure are less attributable to +faults of detail than to an impatient philosophy, which aims at +creating a new world without sufficient preparation in the opinions +and feelings of ordinary men and women. + +But although I do not believe that Communism can be realized +immediately by the spread of Bolshevism, I do believe that, if +Bolshevism falls, it will have contributed a legend and a heroic +attempt without which ultimate success might never have come. A +fundamental economic reconstruction, bringing with it very +far-reaching changes in ways of thinking and feeling, in philosophy +and art and private relations, seems absolutely necessary if +industrialism is to become the servant of man instead of his master. +In all this, I am at one with the Bolsheviks; politically, I criticize +them only when their methods seem to involve a departure from their +own ideals. + +There is, however, another aspect of Bolshevism from which I differ +more fundamentally. Bolshevism is not merely a political doctrine; it +is also a religion, with elaborate dogmas and inspired scriptures. +When Lenin wishes to prove some proposition, he does so, if possible, +by quoting texts from Marx and Engels. A full-fledged Communist is not +merely a man who believes that land and capital should be held in +common, and their produce distributed as nearly equally as possible. +He is a man who entertains a number of elaborate and dogmatic +beliefs--such as philosophic materialism, for example--which may be +true, but are not, to a scientific temper, capable of being known to +be true with any certainty. This habit, of militant certainty about +objectively doubtful matters, is one from which, since the +Renaissance, the world has been gradually emerging, into that temper +of constructive and fruitful scepticism which constitutes the +scientific outlook. I believe the scientific outlook to be +immeasurably important to the human race. If a more just economic +system were only attainable by closing men's minds against free +inquiry, and plunging them back into the intellectual prison of the +middle ages, I should consider the price too high. It cannot be denied +that, over any short period of time, dogmatic belief is a help in +fighting. If all Communists become religious fanatics, while +supporters of capitalism retain a sceptical temper, it may be assumed +that the Communists will win, while in the contrary case the +capitalists would win. It seems evident, from the attitude of the +capitalist world to Soviet Russia, of the Entente to the Central +Empires, and of England to Ireland and India, that there is no depth +of cruelty, perfidy or brutality from which the present holders of +power will shrink when they feel themselves threatened. If, in order +to oust them, nothing short of religious fanaticism will serve, it is +they who are the prime sources of the resultant evil. And it is +permissible to hope that, when they have been dispossessed, fanaticism +will fade, as other fanaticisms have faded in the past. + +The present holders of power are evil men, and the present manner of +life is doomed. To make the transition with a minimum of bloodshed, +with a maximum of preservation of whatever has value in our existing +civilization, is a difficult problem. It is this problem which has +chiefly occupied my mind in writing the following pages. I wish I +could think that its solution would be facilitated by some slight +degree of moderation and humane feeling on the part of those who enjoy +unjust privileges in the world as it is. + +The present work is the outcome of a visit to Russia, supplemented by +much reading and discussion both before and after. I have thought it +best to record what I saw separately from theoretical considerations, +and I have endeavoured to state my impressions without any bias for or +against the Bolsheviks. I received at their hands the greatest +kindness and courtesy, and I owe them a debt of gratitude for the +perfect freedom which they allowed me in my investigations. I am +conscious that I was too short a time in Russia to be able to form +really reliable judgments; however, I share this drawback with most +other westerners who have written on Russia since the October +Revolution. I feel that Bolshevism is a matter of such importance that +it is necessary, for almost every political question, to define one's +attitude in regard to it; and I have hopes that I may help others to +define their attitude, even if only by way of opposition to what I +have written. + +I have received invaluable assistance from my secretary, Miss D.W. +Black, who was in Russia shortly after I had left. The chapter on Art +and Education is written by her throughout. Neither is responsible for +the other's opinions. + + BERTRAND RUSSELL + + _September, 1920._ + + + + +CONTENTS + + + PAGE +PREFACE 5 + + +PART I +THE PRESENT CONDITION OF RUSSIA + + I. WHAT IS HOPED FROM BOLSHEVISM 15 + + II. GENERAL CHARACTERISTICS 24 + + III. LENIN, TROTSKY AND GORKY 36 + + IV. ART AND EDUCATION 45 + + V. COMMUNISM AND THE SOVIET CONSTITUTION 72 + + VI. THE FAILURE OF RUSSIAN INDUSTRY 81 + + VII. DAILY LIFE IN MOSCOW 92 + +VIII. TOWN AND COUNTRY 99 + + IX. INTERNATIONAL POLICY 106 + + +PART II +BOLSHEVIK THEORY + + I. THE MATERIALISTIC THEORY OF HISTORY 119 + + II. DECIDING FORCES IN POLITICS 128 + + III. BOLSHEVIK CRITICISM OF DEMOCRACY 134 + + IV. REVOLUTION AND DICTATORSHIP 146 + + V. MECHANISM AND THE INDIVIDUAL 157 + + VI. WHY RUSSIAN COMMUNISM HAS FAILED 165 + + VII. CONDITIONS FOR THE SUCCESS OF COMMUNISM 178 + + + + +PART I + +THE PRESENT CONDITION OF RUSSIA + + + + +I + +WHAT IS HOPED FROM BOLSHEVISM + + +To understand Bolshevism it is not sufficient to know facts; it is +necessary also to enter with sympathy or imagination into a new +spirit. The chief thing that the Bolsheviks have done is to create a +hope, or at any rate to make strong and widespread a hope which was +formerly confined to a few. This aspect of the movement is as easy to +grasp at a distance as it is in Russia--perhaps even easier, because +in Russia present circumstances tend to obscure the view of the +distant future. But the actual situation in Russia can only be +understood superficially if we forget the hope which is the motive +power of the whole. One might as well describe the Thebaid without +mentioning that the hermits expected eternal bliss as the reward of +their sacrifices here on earth. + +I cannot share the hopes of the Bolsheviks any more than those of the +Egyptian anchorites; I regard both as tragic delusions, destined to +bring upon the world centuries of darkness and futile violence. The +principles of the Sermon on the Mount are admirable, but their effect +upon average human nature was very different from what was intended. +Those who followed Christ did not learn to love their enemies or to +turn the other cheek. They learned instead to use the Inquisition and +the stake, to subject the human intellect to the yoke of an ignorant +and intolerant priesthood, to degrade art and extinguish science for a +thousand years. These were the inevitable results, not of the +teaching, but of fanatical belief in the teaching. The hopes which +inspire Communism are, in the main, as admirable as those instilled by +the Sermon on the Mount, but they are held as fanatically, and are +likely to do as much harm. Cruelty lurks in our instincts, and +fanaticism is a camouflage for cruelty. Fanatics are seldom genuinely +humane, and those who sincerely dread cruelty will be slow to adopt a +fanatical creed. I do not know whether Bolshevism can be prevented +from acquiring universal power. But even if it cannot, I am persuaded +that those who stand out against it, not from love of ancient +injustice, but in the name of the free spirit of Man, will be the +bearers of the seeds of progress, from which, when the world's +gestation is accomplished, new life will be born. + +The war has left throughout Europe a mood of disillusionment and +despair which calls aloud for a new religion, as the only force +capable of giving men the energy to live vigorously. Bolshevism has +supplied the new religion. It promises glorious things: an end of the +injustice of rich and poor, an end of economic slavery, an end of war. +It promises an end of the disunion of classes which poisons political +life and threatens our industrial system with destruction. It promises +an end to commercialism, that subtle falsehood that leads men to +appraise everything by its money value, and to determine money value +often merely by the caprices of idle plutocrats. It promises a world +where all men and women shall be kept sane by work, and where all work +shall be of value to the community, not only to a few wealthy +vampires. It is to sweep away listlessness and pessimism and weariness +and all the complicated miseries of those whose circumstances allow +idleness and whose energies are not sufficient to force activity. In +place of palaces and hovels, futile vice and useless misery, there is +to be wholesome work, enough but not too much, all of it useful, +performed by men and women who have no time for pessimism and no +occasion for despair. + +The existing capitalist system is doomed. Its injustice is so glaring +that only ignorance and tradition could lead wage-earners to tolerate +it. As ignorance diminishes, tradition becomes weakened, and the war +destroyed the hold upon men's minds of everything merely traditional. +It may be that, through the influence of America, the capitalist +system will linger for another fifty years; but it will grow +continually weaker, and can never recover the position of easy +dominance which it held in the nineteenth century. To attempt to +bolster it up is a useless diversion of energies which might be +expended upon building something new. Whether the new thing will be +Bolshevism or something else, I do not know; whether it will be better +or worse than capitalism, I do not know. But that a radically new +order of society will emerge, I feel no doubt. And I also feel no +doubt that the new order will be either some form of Socialism or a +reversion to barbarism and petty war such as occurred during the +barbarian invasion. If Bolshevism remains the only vigorous and +effective competitor of capitalism, I believe that no form of +Socialism will be realized, but only chaos and destruction. This +belief, for which I shall give reasons later, is one of the grounds +upon which I oppose Bolshevism. But to oppose it from the point of +view of a supporter of capitalism would be, to my mind, utterly +futile and against the movement of history in the present age. + +The effect of Bolshevism as a revolutionary hope is greater outside +Russia than within the Soviet Republic. Grim realities have done much +to kill hope among those who are subject to the dictatorship of +Moscow. Yet even within Russia, the Communist party, in whose hands +all political power is concentrated, still lives by hope, though the +pressure of events has made the hope severe and stern and somewhat +remote. It is this hope that leads to concentration upon the rising +generation. Russian Communists often avow that there is little hope +for those who are already adult, and that happiness can only come to +the children who have grown up under the new régime and been moulded +from the first to the group-mentality that Communism requires. It is +only after the lapse of a generation that they hope to create a Russia +that shall realize their vision. + +In the Western World, the hope inspired by Bolshevism is more +immediate, less shot through with tragedy. Western Socialists who have +visited Russia have seen fit to suppress the harsher features of the +present régime, and have disseminated a belief among their followers +that the millennium would be quickly realized there if there were no +war and no blockade. Even those Socialists who are not Bolsheviks for +their own country have mostly done very little to help men in +appraising the merits or demerits of Bolshevik methods. By this lack +of courage they have exposed Western Socialism to the danger of +becoming Bolshevik through ignorance of the price that has to be paid +and of the uncertainty as to whether the desired goal will be reached +in the end. I believe that the West is capable of adopting less +painful and more certain methods of reaching Socialism than those that +have seemed necessary in Russia. And I believe that while some forms +of Socialism are immeasurably better than capitalism, others are even +worse. Among those that are worse I reckon the form which is being +achieved in Russia, not only in itself, but as a more insuperable +barrier to further progress. + +In judging of Bolshevism from what is to be seen in Russia at present, +it is necessary to disentangle various factors which contribute to a +single result. To begin with, Russia is one of the nations that were +defeated in the war; this has produced a set of circumstances +resembling those found in Germany and Austria. The food problem, for +example, appears to be essentially similar in all three countries. In +order to arrive at what is specifically Bolshevik, we must first +eliminate what is merely characteristic of a country which has +suffered military disaster. Next we come to factors which are Russian, +which Russian Communists share with other Russians, but not with other +Communists. There is, for example, a great deal of disorder and chaos +and waste, which shocks Westerners (especially Germans) even when they +are in close political sympathy with the Bolsheviks. My own belief is +that, although, with the exception of a few very able men, the Russian +Government is less efficient in organization than the Germans or the +Americans would be in similar circumstances, yet it represents what is +most efficient in Russia, and does more to prevent chaos than any +possible alternative government would do. Again, the intolerance and +lack of liberty which has been inherited from the Tsarist régime is +probably to be regarded as Russian rather than Communist. If a +Communist Party were to acquire power in England, it would probably be +met by a less irresponsible opposition, and would be able to show +itself far more tolerant than any government can hope to be in Russia +if it is to escape assassination. This, however, is a matter of +degree. A great part of the despotism which characterizes the +Bolsheviks belongs to the essence of their social philosophy, and +would have to be reproduced, even if in a milder form, wherever that +philosophy became dominant. + +It is customary among the apologists of Bolshevism in the West to +excuse its harshness on the ground that it has been produced by the +necessity of fighting the Entente and its mercenaries. Undoubtedly it +is true that this necessity has produced many of the worst elements in +the present state of affairs. Undoubtedly, also, the Entente has +incurred a heavy load of guilt by its peevish and futile opposition. +But the expectation of such opposition was always part of Bolshevik +theory. A general hostility to the first Communist State was both +foreseen and provoked by the doctrine of the class war. Those who +adopt the Bolshevik standpoint must reckon with the embittered +hostility of capitalist States; it is not worth while to adopt +Bolshevik methods unless they can lead to good in spite of this +hostility. To say that capitalists are wicked and we have no +responsibility for their acts is unscientific; it is, in particular, +contrary to the Marxian doctrine of economic determinism. The evils +produced in Russia by the enmity of the Entente are therefore to be +reckoned as essential in the Bolshevik method of transition to +Communism, not as specially Russian. I am not sure that we cannot even +go a step further. The exhaustion and misery caused by unsuccessful +war were necessary to the success of the Bolsheviks; a prosperous +population will not embark by such methods upon a fundamental economic +reconstruction. One can imagine England becoming Bolshevik after an +unsuccessful war involving the loss of India--no improbable +contingency in the next few years. But at present the average +wage-earner in England will not risk what he has for the doubtful gain +of a revolution. A condition of widespread misery may, therefore, be +taken as indispensable to the inauguration of Communism, unless, +indeed, it were possible to establish Communism more or less +peacefully, by methods which would not, even temporarily, destroy the +economic life of the country. If the hopes which inspired Communism at +the start, and which still inspire its Western advocates, are ever to +be realized, the problem of minimizing violence in the transition must +be faced. Unfortunately, violence is in itself delightful to most +really vigorous revolutionaries, and they feel no interest in the +problem of avoiding it as far as possible. Hatred of enemies is easier +and more intense than love of friends. But from men who are more +anxious to injure opponents than to benefit the world at large no +great good is to be expected. + + + + +II + +GENERAL CHARACTERISTICS + + +I entered Soviet Russia on May 11th and recrossed the frontier on June +16th. The Russian authorities only admitted me on the express +condition that I should travel with the British Labour Delegation, a +condition with which I was naturally very willing to comply, and which +that Delegation kindly allowed me to fulfil. We were conveyed from the +frontier to Petrograd, as well as on subsequent journeys, in a special +_train de luxe_; covered with mottoes about the Social Revolution and +the Proletariat of all countries; we were received everywhere by +regiments of soldiers, with the Internationale being played on the +regimental band while civilians stood bare-headed and soldiers at the +salute; congratulatory orations were made by local leaders and +answered by prominent Communists who accompanied us; the entrances to +the carriages were guarded by magnificent Bashkir cavalry-men in +resplendent uniforms; in short, everything was done to make us feel +like the Prince of Wales. Innumerable functions were arranged for us: +banquets, public meetings, military reviews, etc. + +The assumption was that we had come to testify to the solidarity of +British Labour with Russian Communism, and on that assumption the +utmost possible use was made of us for Bolshevik propaganda. We, on +the other hand, desired to ascertain what we could of Russian +conditions and Russian methods of government, which was impossible in +the atmosphere of a royal progress. Hence arose an amicable contest, +degenerating at times into a game of hide and seek: while they assured +us how splendid the banquet or parade was going to be, we tried to +explain how much we should prefer a quiet walk in the streets. I, not +being a member of the Delegation, felt less obligation than my +companions did to attend at propaganda meetings where one knew the +speeches by heart beforehand. In this way, I was able, by the help of +neutral interpreters, mostly English or American, to have many +conversations with casual people whom I met in the streets or on +village greens, and to find out how the whole system appears to the +ordinary non-political man and woman. The first five days we spent in +Petrograd, the next eleven in Moscow. During this time we were living +in daily contact with important men in the Government, so that we +learned the official point of view without difficulty. I saw also what +I could of the intellectuals in both places. We were all allowed +complete freedom to see politicians of opposition parties, and we +naturally made full use of this freedom. We saw Mensheviks, Social +Revolutionaries of different groups, and Anarchists; we saw them +without the presence of any Bolsheviks, and they spoke freely after +they had overcome their initial fears. I had an hour's talk with +Lenin, virtually _tête-à-tête_; I met Trotsky, though only in company; +I spent a night in the country with Kamenev; and I saw a great deal of +other men who, though less known outside Russia, are of considerable +importance in the Government. + +At the end of our time in Moscow we all felt a desire to see something +of the country, and to get in touch with the peasants, since they form +about 85 per cent, of the population. The Government showed the +greatest kindness in meeting our wishes, and it was decided that we +should travel down the Volga from Nijni Novgorod to Saratov, stopping +at many places, large and small, and talking freely with the +inhabitants. I found this part of the time extraordinarily +instructive. I learned to know more than I should have thought +possible of the life and outlook of peasants, village schoolmasters, +small Jew traders, and all kinds of people. Unfortunately, my friend, +Clifford Allen, fell ill, and my time was much taken up with him. This +had, however, one good result, namely, that I was able to go on with +the boat to Astrakhan, as he was too ill to be moved off it. This not +only gave me further knowledge of the country, but made me acquainted +with Sverdlov, Acting Minister of Transport, who was travelling on the +boat to organize the movement of oil from Baku up the Volga, and who +was one of the ablest as well as kindest people whom I met in Russia. + +One of the first things that I discovered after passing the Red Flag +which marks the frontier of Soviet Russia, amid a desolate region of +marsh, pine wood, and barbed wire entanglements, was the profound +difference between the theories of actual Bolsheviks and the version +of those theories current among advanced Socialists in this country. +Friends of Russia here think of the dictatorship of the proletariat as +merely a new form of representative government, in which only working +men and women have votes, and the constituencies are partly +occupational, not geographical. They think that "proletariat" means +"proletariat," but "dictatorship" does not quite mean "dictatorship." +This is the opposite of the truth. When a Russian Communist speaks of +dictatorship, he means the word literally, but when he speaks of the +proletariat, he means the word in a Pickwickian sense. He means the +"class-conscious" part of the proletariat, _i.e._, the Communist +Party.[1] He includes people by no means proletarian (such as Lenin +and Tchicherin) who have the right opinions, and he excludes such +wage-earners as have not the right opinions, whom he classifies as +lackeys of the _bourgeoisie_. The Communist who sincerely believes the +party creed is convinced that private property is the root of all +evil; he is so certain of this that he shrinks from no measures, +however harsh, which seem necessary for constructing and preserving +the Communist State. He spares himself as little as he spares others. +He works sixteen hours a day, and foregoes his Saturday half-holiday. +He volunteers for any difficult or dangerous work which needs to be +done, such as clearing away piles of infected corpses left by Kolchak +or Denikin. In spite of his position of power and his control of +supplies, he lives an austere life. He is not pursuing personal ends, +but aiming at the creation of a new social order. The same motives, +however, which make him austere make him also ruthless. Marx has +taught that Communism is fatally predestined to come about; this fits +in with the Oriental traits in the Russian character, and produces a +state of mind not unlike that of the early successors of Mahomet. +Opposition is crushed without mercy, and without shrinking from the +methods of the Tsarist police, many of whom are still employed at +their old work. Since all evils are due to private property, the evils +of the Bolshevik régime while it has to fight private property will +automatically cease as soon as it has succeeded. + +These views are the familiar consequences of fanatical belief. To an +English mind they reinforce the conviction upon which English life has +been based ever since 1688, that kindliness and tolerance are worth +all the creeds in the world--a view which, it is true, we do not apply +to other nations or to subject races. + +In a very novel society it is natural to seek for historical +parallels. The baser side of the present Russian Government is most +nearly paralleled by the Directoire in France, but on its better side +it is closely analogous to the rule of Cromwell. The sincere +Communists (and all the older members of the party have proved their +sincerity by years of persecution) are not unlike the Puritan +soldiers in their stern politico-moral purpose. Cromwell's dealings +with Parliament are not unlike Lenin's with the Constituent Assembly. +Both, starting from a combination of democracy and religious faith, +were driven to sacrifice democracy to religion enforced by military +dictatorship. Both tried to compel their countries to live at a higher +level of morality and effort than the population found tolerable. Life +in modern Russia, as in Puritan England, is in many ways contrary to +instinct. And if the Bolsheviks ultimately fall, it will be for the +reason for which the Puritans fell: because there comes a point at +which men feel that amusement and ease are worth more than all other +goods put together. + +Far closer than any actual historical parallel is the parallel of +Plato's Republic. The Communist Party corresponds to the guardians; +the soldiers have about the same status in both; there is in Russia an +attempt to deal with family life more or less as Plato suggested. I +suppose it may be assumed that every teacher of Plato throughout the +world abhors Bolshevism, and that every Bolshevik regards Plato as an +antiquated _bourgeois_. Nevertheless, the parallel is extraordinarily +exact between Plato's Republic and the régime which the better +Bolsheviks are endeavouring to create. + +Bolshevism is internally aristocratic and externally militant. The +Communists in many ways resemble the British public-school type: they +have all the good and bad traits of an aristocracy which is young and +vital. They are courageous, energetic, capable of command, always +ready to serve the State; on the other hand, they are dictatorial, +lacking in ordinary consideration for the plebs. They are practically +the sole possessors of power, and they enjoy innumerable advantages in +consequence. Most of them, though far from luxurious, have better food +than other people. Only people of some political importance can obtain +motor-cars or telephones. Permits for railway journeys, for making +purchases at the Soviet stores (where prices are about one-fiftieth of +what they are in the market), for going to the theatre, and so on, +are, of course, easier to obtain for the friends of those in power +than for ordinary mortals. In a thousand ways, the Communists have a +life which is happier than that of the rest of the community. Above +all, they are less exposed to the unwelcome attentions of the police +and the extraordinary commission. + +The Communist theory of international affairs is exceedingly simple. +The revolution foretold by Marx, which is to abolish capitalism +throughout the world, happened to begin in Russia, though Marxian +theory would seem to demand that it should begin in America. In +countries where the revolution has not yet broken out, the sole duty +of a Communist is to hasten its advent. Agreements with capitalist +States can only be make-shifts, and can never amount on either side to +a sincere peace. No real good can come to any country without a bloody +revolution: English Labour men may fancy that a peaceful evolution is +possible, but they will find their mistake. Lenin told me that he +hopes to see a Labour Government in England, and would wish his +supporters to work for it, but solely in order that the futility of +Parliamentarism may be conclusively demonstrated to the British +working man. Nothing will do any real good except the arming of the +proletariat and the disarming of the _bourgeoisie_. Those who preach +anything else are social traitors or deluded fools. + +For my part, after weighing this theory carefully, and after admitting +the whole of its indictment of _bourgeois_ capitalism, I find myself +definitely and strongly opposed to it. The Third International is an +organization which exists to promote the class-war and to hasten the +advent of revolution everywhere. My objection is not that capitalism +is less bad than the Bolsheviks believe, but that Socialism is less +good, not in its best form, but in the only form which is likely to be +brought about by war. The evils of war, especially of civil war, are +certain and very great; the gains to be achieved by victory are +problematical. In the course of a desperate struggle, the heritage of +civilization is likely to be lost, while hatred, suspicion, and +cruelty become normal in the relations of human beings. In order to +succeed in war, a concentration of power is necessary, and from +concentration of power the very same evils flow as from the capitalist +concentration of wealth. For these reasons chiefly, I cannot support +any movement which aims at world revolution. The damage to +civilization done by revolution in one country may be repaired by the +influence of another in which there has been no revolution; but in a +universal cataclysm civilization might go under for a thousand years. +But while I cannot advocate world revolution, I cannot escape from the +conclusion that the Governments of the leading capitalist countries +are doing everything to bring it about. Abuse of our power against +Germany, Russia, and India (to say nothing of any other countries) may +well bring about our downfall, and produce those very evils which the +enemies of Bolshevism most dread. + +The true Communist is thoroughly international. Lenin, for example, so +far as I could judge, is not more concerned with the interests of +Russia than with those of other countries; Russia is, at the moment, +the protagonist of the social revolution, and, as such, valuable to +the world, but Lenin would sacrifice Russia rather than the +revolution, if the alternative should ever arise. This is the orthodox +attitude, and is no doubt genuine in many of the leaders. But +nationalism is natural and instinctive; through pride in the +revolution, it grows again even in the breasts of Communists. Through +the Polish war, the Bolsheviks have acquired the support of national +feeling, and their position in the country has been immensely +strengthened. + +The only time I saw Trotsky was at the Opera in Moscow. The British +Labour Delegation were occupying what had been the Tsar's box. After +speaking with us in the ante-chamber, he stepped to the front of the +box and stood with folded arms while the house cheered itself hoarse. +Then he spoke a few sentences, short and sharp, with military +precision, winding up by calling for "three cheers for our brave +fellows at the front," to which the audience responded as a London +audience would have responded in the autumn of 1914. Trotsky and the +Red Army undoubtedly now have behind them a great body of nationalist +sentiment. The reconquest of Asiatic Russia has even revived what is +essentially an imperialist way of feeling, though this would be +indignantly repudiated by many of those in whom I seemed to detect it. +Experience of power is inevitably altering Communist theories, and men +who control a vast governmental machine can hardly have quite the same +outlook on life as they had when they were hunted fugitives. If the +Bolsheviks remain in power, it is much to be feared that their +Communism will fade, and that they will increasingly resemble any +other Asiatic Government--for example, our own Government in India. + +FOOTNOTES: + +[1] See the article "On the rôle of the Communist Party in the +Proletarian Revolution," in _Theses presented to the Second Congress +of the Communist International, Petrograd-Moscow, 18 July, 1920_--a +valuable work which I possess only in French. + + + + +III + +LENIN, TROTSKY AND GORKY + + +Soon after my arrival in Moscow I had an hour's conversation with +Lenin in English, which he speaks fairly well. An interpreter was +present, but his services were scarcely required. Lenin's room is very +bare; it contains a big desk, some maps on the walls, two book-cases, +and one comfortable chair for visitors in addition to two or three +hard chairs. It is obvious that he has no love of luxury or even +comfort. He is very friendly, and apparently simple, entirely without +a trace of _hauteur_. If one met him without knowing who he was, one +would not guess that he is possessed of great power or even that he is +in any way eminent. I have never met a personage so destitute of +self-importance. He looks at his visitors very closely, and screws up +one eye, which seems to increase alarmingly the penetrating power of +the other. He laughs a great deal; at first his laugh seems merely +friendly and jolly, but gradually I came to feel it rather grim. He +is dictatorial, calm, incapable of fear, extraordinarily devoid of +self-seeking, an embodied theory. The materialist conception of +history, one feels, is his life-blood. He resembles a professor in his +desire to have the theory understood and in his fury with those who +misunderstand or disagree, as also in his love of expounding, I got +the impression that he despises a great many people and is an +intellectual aristocrat. + +The first question I asked him was as to how far he recognized the +peculiarity of English economic and political conditions? I was +anxious to know whether advocacy of violent revolution is an +indispensable condition of joining the Third International, although I +did not put this question directly because others were asking it +officially. His answer was unsatisfactory to me. He admitted that +there is little chance of revolution in England now, and that the +working man is not yet disgusted with Parliamentary government. But he +hopes that this result may be brought about by a Labour Ministry. He +thinks that, if Mr. Henderson, for instance, were to become Prime +Minister, nothing of importance would be done; organized Labour would +then, so he hopes and believes, turn to revolution. On this ground, he +wishes his supporters in this country to do everything in their power +to secure a Labour majority in Parliament; he does not advocate +abstention from Parliamentary contests, but participation with a view +to making Parliament obviously contemptible. The reasons which make +attempts at violent revolution seem to most of us both improbable and +undesirable in this country carry no weight with him, and seem to him +mere _bourgeois_ prejudices. When I suggested that whatever is +possible in England can be achieved without bloodshed, he waved aside +the suggestion as fantastic. I got little impression of knowledge or +psychological imagination as regards Great Britain. Indeed the whole +tendency of Marxianism is against psychological imagination, since it +attributes everything in politics to purely material causes. + +I asked him next whether he thought it possible to establish Communism +firmly and fully in a country containing such a large majority of +peasants. He admitted that it was difficult, and laughed over the +exchange the peasant is compelled to make, of food for paper; the +worthlessness of Russian paper struck him as comic. But he said--what +is no doubt true--that things will right themselves when there are +goods to offer to the peasant. For this he looks partly to +electrification in industry, which, he says, is a technical necessity +in Russia, but will take ten years to complete.[2] He spoke with +enthusiasm, as they all do, of the great scheme for generating +electrical power by means of peat. Of course he looks to the raising +of the blockade as the only radical cure; but he was not very hopeful +of this being achieved thoroughly or permanently except through +revolutions in other countries. Peace between Bolshevik Russia and +capitalist countries, he said, must always be insecure; the Entente +might be led by weariness and mutual dissensions to conclude peace, +but he felt convinced that the peace would be of brief duration. I +found in him, as in almost all leading Communists, much less eagerness +than existed in our delegation for peace and the raising of the +blockade. He believes that nothing of real value can be achieved +except through world revolution and the abolition of capitalism; I +felt that he regarded the resumption of trade with capitalist +countries as a mere palliative of doubtful value. + +He described the division between rich and poor peasants, and the +Government propaganda among the latter against the former, leading to +acts of violence which he seemed to find amusing. He spoke as though +the dictatorship over the peasant would have to continue a long time, +because of the peasant's desire for free trade. He said he knew from +statistics (what I can well believe) that the peasants have had more +to eat these last two years than they ever had before, "and yet they +are against us," he added a little wistfully. I asked him what to +reply to critics who say that in the country he has merely created +peasant proprietorship, not Communism; he replied that that is not +quite the truth, but he did not say what the truth is.[3] + +The last question I asked him was whether resumption of trade with +capitalist countries, if it took place, would not create centres of +capitalist influence, and make the preservation of Communism more +difficult? It had seemed to me that the more ardent Communists might +well dread commercial intercourse with the outer world, as leading to +an infiltration of heresy, and making the rigidity of the present +system almost impossible. I wished to know whether he had such a +feeling. He admitted that trade would create difficulties, but said +they would be less than those of the war. He said that two years ago +neither he nor his colleagues thought they could survive against the +hostility of the world. He attributes their survival to the jealousies +and divergent interests of the different capitalist nations; also to +the power of Bolshevik propaganda. He said the Germans had laughed +when the Bolsheviks proposed to combat guns with leaflets, but that +the event had proved the leaflets quite as powerful. I do not think he +recognizes that the Labour and Socialist parties have had any part in +the matter. He does not seem to know that the attitude of British +Labour has done a great deal to make a first-class war against Russia +impossible, since it has confined the Government to what could be done +in a hole-and-corner way, and denied without a too blatant mendacity. + +He thoroughly enjoys the attacks of Lord Northcliffe, to whom he +wishes to send a medal for Bolshevik propaganda. Accusations of +spoliation, he remarked, may shock the _bourgeois_, but have an +opposite effect upon the proletarian. + +I think if I had met him without knowing who he was, I should not have +guessed that he was a great man; he struck me as too opinionated and +narrowly orthodox. His strength comes, I imagine, from his honesty, +courage, and unwavering faith--religious faith in the Marxian gospel, +which takes the place of the Christian martyr's hopes of Paradise, +except that it is less egotistical. He has as little love of liberty +as the Christians who suffered under Diocletian, and retaliated when +they acquired power. Perhaps love of liberty is incompatible with +whole-hearted belief in a panacea for all human ills. If so, I cannot +but rejoice in the sceptical temper of the Western world. I went to +Russia a Communist; but contact with those who have no doubts has +intensified a thousandfold my own doubts, not as to Communism in +itself, but as to the wisdom of holding a creed so firmly that for its +sake men are willing to inflict widespread misery. + +Trotsky, whom the Communists do not by any means regard as Lenin's +equal, made more impression upon me from the point of view of +intelligence and personality, though not of character. I saw too +little of him, however, to have more than a very superficial +impression. He has bright eyes, military bearing, lightning +intelligence and magnetic personality. He is very good-looking, with +admirable wavy hair; one feels he would be irresistible to women. I +felt in him a vein of gay good humour, so long as he was not crossed +in any way. I thought, perhaps wrongly, that his vanity was even +greater than his love of power--the sort of vanity that one associates +with an artist or actor. The comparison with Napoleon was forced upon +one. But I had no means of estimating the strength of his Communist +conviction, which may be very sincere and profound. + +An extraordinary contrast to both these men was Gorky, with whom I had +a brief interview in Petrograd. He was in bed, apparently very ill and +obviously heart-broken. He begged me, in anything I might say about +Russia, always to emphasize what Russia has suffered. He supports the +Government--as I should do, if I were a Russian--not because he thinks +it faultless, but because the possible alternatives are worse. One +felt in him a love of the Russian people which makes their present +martyrdom almost unbearable, and prevents the fanatical faith by which +the pure Marxians are upheld. I felt him the most lovable, and to me +the most sympathetic, of all the Russians I saw. I wished for more +knowledge of his outlook, but he spoke with difficulty and was +constantly interrupted by terrible fits of coughing, so that I could +not stay. All the intellectuals whom I met--a class who have suffered +terribly--expressed their gratitude to him for what he has done on +their behalf. The materialistic conception of history is all very +well, but some care for the higher things of civilization is a relief. +The Bolsheviks are sometimes said to have done great things for art, +but I could not discover that they had done more than preserve +something of what existed before. When I questioned one of them on the +subject, he grew impatient, and said: "We haven't time for a new art, +any more than for a new religion." Unavoidably, although the +Government favours art as much as it can, the atmosphere is one in +which art cannot flourish, because art is anarchic and resistant to +organization. Gorky has done all that one man could to preserve the +intellectual and artistic life of Russia. I feared that he was dying, +and that, perhaps, it was dying too. But he recovered, and I hope it +will recover also. + +FOOTNOTES: + +[2] Electrification is desired not merely for reorganizing industry, +but in order to industrialize agriculture. In _Theses presented to the +Second Congress of the Communist International_ (an instructive little +book, which I shall quote as _Theses_), it is said in an article on +the Agrarian question that Socialism will not be secure till industry +is reorganized on a new basis with "general application of electric +energy in all branches of agriculture and rural economy," which "alone +can give to the towns the possibility of offering to backward rural +districts a technical and social aid capable of determining an +extraordinary increase of productivity of agricultural and rural +labour, and of engaging the small cultivators, in their own interest, +to pass progressively to a collectivist mechanical cultivation" (p. 36 +of French edition). + +[3] In _Theses_ (p. 34) it is said: "It would be an irreparable error +... not to admit the gratuitous grant of part of the expropriated +lands to poor and even well-to-do peasants." + + + + +IV + +ART AND EDUCATION + + +It has often been said that, whatever the inadequacy of Bolshevik +organization in other fields, in art and in education at least they +have made great progress. + +To take first of all art: it is true that they began by recognizing, +as perhaps no other revolutionary government would, the importance and +spontaneity of the artistic impulse, and therefore while they +controlled or destroyed the counter-revolutionary in all other social +activities, they allowed the artist, whatever his political creed, +complete freedom to continue his work. Moreover, as regards clothing +and rations they treated him especially well. This, and the care +devoted to the upkeep of churches, public monuments, and museums, are +well-known facts, to which there has already been ample testimony. + +The preservation of the old artistic community practically intact was +the more remarkable in view of the pronounced sympathy of most of them +with the old régime. The theory, however, was that art and politics +belonged to two separate realms; but great honour would of course be +the portion of those artists who would be inspired by the revolution. + +Three years' experience, however, have proved the falsity of this +doctrine and led to a divorce between art and popular feeling which a +sensitive observer cannot fail to remark. It is glaringly apparent in +the hitherto most vital of all Russian arts, the theatre. The artists +have continued to perform the old classics in tragedy or comedy, and +the old-style operette. The theatre programmes have remained the same +for the last two years, and, but for the higher standard of artistic +performance, might belong to the theatres of Paris or London. As one +sits in the theatre, one is so acutely conscious of the discrepancy +between the daily life of the audience and that depicted in the play +that the latter seems utterly dead and meaningless. To some of the +more fiery Communists it appears that a mistake has been made. They +complain that _bourgeois_ art is being preserved long after its time, +they accuse the artists of showing contempt for their public, of being +as untouched by the revolutionary mood as an elderly _bourgeoise_ +bewailing the loss of her personal comfort; they would like to see +only the revolutionary mood embodied in art, and to achieve this +would make a clean sweep, enforcing the writing and performance of +nothing but revolutionary plays and the painting of revolutionary +pictures. Nor can it be argued that they are wrong as to the facts: it +is plain that the preservation of the old artistic tradition has +served very little purpose; but on the other hand it is equally plain +that an artist cannot be drilled like a military recruit. There is, +fortunately, no sign that these tactics will be directly adopted, but +in an indirect fashion they are already being applied. An artist is +not to blame if his temperament leads him to draw cartoons of leading +Bolsheviks, or satirize the various comical aspects--and they are +many--of the Soviet régime. To force such a man, however, to turn his +talent only against Denikin, Yudenitch and Kolchak, or the leaders of +the Entente, is momentarily good for Communism, but it is discouraging +to the artist, and may prove in the long run bad for art, and possibly +for Communism also. It is plain from the religious nature of Communism +in Russia, that such controlling of the impulse to artistic creation +is inevitable, and that propaganda art alone can flourish in such an +atmosphere. For example, no poetry or literature that is not orthodox +will reach the printing press. It is so easy to make the excuse of +lack of paper and the urgent need for manifestoes. Thus there may +well come to be a repetition of the attitude of the mediæval Church to +the sagas and legends of the people, except that, in this case, it is +the folk tales which will be preserved, and the more sensitive and +civilized products banned. The only poet who seems to be much spoken +of at present in Russia is one who writes rough popular songs. There +are revolutionary odes, but one may hazard a guess that they resemble +our patriotic war poetry. + +I said that this state of affairs may in the long run be bad for art, +but the contrary may equally well prove to be the truth. It is of +course discouraging and paralysing to the old-style artist, and it is +death to the old individual art which depended on subtlety and oddity +of temperament, and arose very largely from the complicated psychology +of the idle. There it stands, this old art, the purest monument to the +nullity of the art-for-art's-sake doctrine, like a rich exotic plant +of exquisite beauty, still apparently in its glory, till one perceives +that the roots are cut, and that leaf by leaf it is gradually fading +away. + +But, unlike the Puritans in this respect, the Bolsheviks have not +sought to dig up the roots, and there are signs that the paralysis is +merely temporary. Moreover, individual art is not the only form, and +in particular the plastic arts have shown that they can live by mass +action, and flourish under an intolerant faith. Communist artists of +the future may erect public buildings surpassing in beauty the +mediæval churches, they may paint frescoes, organize pageants, make +Homeric songs about their heroes. Communist art will begin, and is +beginning now, in the propaganda pictures, and stories such as those +designed for peasants and children. There is, for instance, a kind of +Rake's Progress or "How she became a Communist," in which the Entente +leaders make a sorry and grotesque appearance. Lenin and Trotsky +already figure in woodcuts as Moses and Aaron, deliverers of their +people, while the mother and child who illustrate the statistics of +the maternity exhibition have the grace and beauty of mediæval +madonnas. Russia is only now emerging from the middle ages, and the +Church tradition in painting is passing with incredible smoothness +into the service of Communist doctrine. These pictures have, too, an +oriental flavour: there are brown Madonnas in the Russian churches, +and such an one illustrates the statistics of infant mortality in +India, while the Russian mother, broad-footed, in gay petticoat and +kerchief, sits in a starry meadow suckling her baby from a very ample +white breast. I think that this movement towards the Church tradition +may be unconscious and instinctive, and would perhaps be deplored by +many Communists, for whom grandiose bad Rodin statuary and the crudity +of cubism better express what they mean by revolution. But this +revolution is Russian and not French, and its art, if all goes well, +should inevitably bear the popular Russian stamp. It is would-be +primitive and popular art that is vulgar. Such at least is the +reflection engendered by an inspection of Russian peasant work as +compared with the spirit of _Children's Tales_. + +The Russian peasant's artistic impulse is no legend. Besides the +carving and embroidery which speak eloquently to peasant skill, one +observes many instances in daily life. He will climb down, when his +slowly-moving train stops by the wayside, to gather branches and +flowers with which he will decorate the railway carriage both inside +and out, he will work willingly at any task which has beauty for its +object, and was all too prone under the old régime to waste his time +and his employer's material in fashioning small metal or wooden +objects with his hands. + +If the _bourgeois_ tradition then will not serve, there is a popular +tradition which is still live and passionate and which may perhaps +persist. Unhappily it has a formidable enemy in the organization and +development of industry, which is far more dangerous to art than +Communist doctrine. Indeed, industry in its early stages seems +everywhere doomed to be the enemy of beauty and instinctive life. One +might hope that this would not prove to be so in Russia, the first +Socialist State, as yet unindustrial, able to draw on the industrial +experience of the whole world, were it not that one discovers with a +certain misgiving in the Bolshevik leaders the rasping arid +temperament of those to whom the industrial machine is an end in +itself, and, in addition, reflects that these industrially minded men +have as yet no practical experience, nor do there exist men of +goodwill to help them. It does not seem reasonable to hope that Russia +can pass through the period of industrialization without a good deal +of mismanagement, involving waste resulting in too long hours, child +labour and other evils with which the West is all too familiar. What +the Bolsheviks would not therefore willingly do to art, the Juggernaut +which they are bent on setting in motion may accomplish for them. + +The next generation in Russia will have to consist of practical +hard-working men, the old-style artists will die off and successors +will not readily arise. A State which is struggling with economic +difficulties is bound to be slow to admit an artistic vocation, since +this involves exemption from practical work. Moreover the majority of +minds always turn instinctively to the real need of the moment. A man +therefore who is adapted by talent and temperament to becoming an +opera singer, will under the pressure of Communist enthusiasm and +Government encouragement turn his attention to economics. (I am here +quoting an actual instance.) The whole Russian people at this stage in +their development strike one as being forced by the logic of their +situation to make a similar choice. + +It may be all to the good that there should be fewer professional +artists, since some of the finest work has been done by men and groups +of men to whom artistic expression was only a pastime. They were not +hampered by the solemnity and reverence for art which too often +destroy the spontaneity of the professional. Indeed a revival of this +attitude to art is one of the good results which may be hoped for from +a Communist revolution in a more advanced industrial community. There +the problem of education will be to stimulate the creative impulses +towards art and science so that men may know how to employ their +leisure hours. Work in the factory can never be made to provide an +adequate outlet. The only hope, if men are to remain human beings +under industrialism, is to reduce hours to the minimum. But this is +only possible when production and organization are highly efficient, +which will not be the case for a long time in Russia. Hence not only +does it appear that the number of artists will grow less, but that the +number of people undamaged in their artistic impulses and on that +account able to create or appreciate as amateurs is likely to be +deplorably small. It is in this damaging effect of industry on human +instinct that the immediate danger to art in Russia lies. + +The effect of industry on the crafts is quite obvious. A craftsman who +is accustomed to work with his hands, following the tradition +developed by his ancestors, is useless when brought face to face with +a machine. And the man who can handle the machine will only be +concerned with quantity and utility in the first instance. Only +gradually do the claims of beauty come to be recognized. Compare the +modern motor car with the first of its species, or even, since the +same law seems to operate in nature, the prehistoric animal with its +modern descendant. The same relation exists between them as between +man and the ape, or the horse and the hipparion. The movement of life +seems to be towards ever greater delicacy and complexity, and man +carries it forward in the articles that he makes and the society that +he develops. Industry is a new tool, difficult to handle, but it will +produce just as beautiful objects as did the mediæval builder and +craftsman, though not until it has been in being for a long time and +belongs to tradition. + +One may expect, therefore, that while the crafts in Russia will lose +in artistic value, the drama, sculpture and painting and all those +arts which have nothing to do with the machine and depend entirely +upon mental and spiritual inspiration will receive an impetus from the +Communist faith. Whether the flowering period will be long or short +depends partly on the political situation, but chiefly on the rapidity +of industrial development. It may be that the machine will ultimately +conquer the Communist faith and grind out the human impulses, and +Russia become during this transition period as inartistic and soulless +as was America until quite recent years. One would like to hope that +mechanical progress will be swift and social idealism sufficiently +strong to retain control. But the practical difficulties are almost +insuperable. + +Such signs of the progress of art as it is possible to notice at this +early stage would seem to bear out the above argument. For instance, +an attempt is being made to foster the continuation of peasant +embroidery, carving, &c., in the towns. It is done by people who have +evidently lost the tradition already. They are taught to copy the +models which are placed in the Peasant Museum, but there is no +comparison between the live little wooden lady who smiles beneath the +glass case, and the soulless staring-eyed creature who is offered for +sale, nor between the quite ordinary carved fowl one may buy and the +amusing life-like figure one may merely gaze at. + +But when one comes to art directly inspired by Communism it is a +different story. Apart from the propaganda pictures already referred +to, there are propaganda plays performed by the Red Army in its spare +moments, and there are the mass pageant plays performed on State +occasions. I had the good fortune to witness one of each kind. + +The play was called _Zarevo_ (The Dawn), and was performed on a +Saturday night on a small stage in a small hall in an entirely amateur +fashion. It represented Russian life just before the revolution. It +was intense and tragic and passionately acted. Dramatic talent is not +rare in Russia. Almost the only comic relief was provided by the +Tsarist police, who made one appearance towards the end, got up like +comic military characters in a musical comedy--just as, in mediæval +miracle plays, the comic character was Satan. The play's intention was +to show a typical Russian working-class family. There were the old +father, constantly drunk on vodka, alternately maudlin and scolding; +the old mother; two sons, the one a Communist and the other an +Anarchist; the wife of the Communist, who did dressmaking; her +sister, a prostitute; and a young girl of _bourgeois_ family, also a +Communist, involved in a plot with the Communist son, who was of +course the hero of the play. + +The first act revealed the stern and heroic Communist maintaining his +views despite the reproaches of father and mother and the nagging of +his wife. It showed also the Anarchist brother (as might be expected +from the Bolshevik hostility to Anarchism) as an unruly, lazy, +ne'er-do-well, with a passionate love for Sonia, the young +_bourgeoise_, which was likely to become dangerous if not returned. +She, on the other hand, obviously preferred the Communist. It was +clear that he returned her love, but it was not quite clear that he +would wish the relation to be anything more than platonic comradeship +in the service of their common ideal. An unsuccessful strike, bringing +want and danger from the police, together with increasing jealousy on +the part of the Anarchist, led up to the tragic dénouement. I was not +quite definite as to how this was brought about. All violent action +was performed off the stage, and this made the plot at times difficult +to follow. But it seemed that the Anarchist in a jealous rage forged a +letter from his brother to bring Sonia to a rendezvous, and there +murdered her, at the same time betraying his brother to the police. +When the latter came to effect his arrest, and accuse him also, as the +most likely person, of the murder, the Anarchist was seized with +remorse and confessed. Both were therefore led away together. Once the +plot is sketched, the play calls for no comment. It had not great +merit, though it is unwise to hazard a judgment on a play whose +dialogue was not fully interpreted, but it was certainly real, and the +link between audience and performers was established as it never +seemed to be in the professional theatre. After the performance, the +floor was cleared for dancing, and the audience were in a mood of +thorough enjoyment. + +The pageant of the "World Commune," which was performed at the opening +of the Third International Congress in Petrograd, was a still more +important and significant phenomenon. I do not suppose that anything +of the kind has been staged since the days of the mediæval mystery +plays. It was, in fact, a mystery play designed by the High Priests of +the Communist faith to instruct the people. It was played on the steps +of an immense white building that was once the Stock Exchange, a +building with a classical colonnade on three sides of it, with a vast +flight of steps in front, that did not extend the whole width of the +building but left at each side a platform that was level with the +floor of the colonnade. In front of this building a wide road ran +from a bridge over one arm of the river to a bridge over the other, so +that the stretches of water and sky on either side seemed to the eye +of imagination like the painted wings of a gigantic stage. Two +battered red columns of fantastic design, that were once light towers +to guide ships, stood on either side midway between the extremities of +the building and the water, but on the opposite side of the road. +These two towers were beflagged and illuminated and carried the +limelight, and between and behind them was gathered a densely packed +audience of forty or fifty thousand people. The play began at sundown, +while the sky was still red away to the right and the palaces on the +far bank to the left still aglow with the setting sun, and it +continued under the magic of the darkening sky. At first the beauty +and grandeur of the setting drew the attention away from the +performers, but gradually one became aware that on the platform before +the columns kings and queens and courtiers in sumptuous conventional +robes, and attended by soldiers, were conversing in dumb show with one +another. A few climbed the steps of a small wooden platform that was +set up in the middle, and one indicated by a lifted hand that here +should be built a monument to the power of capitalism over the earth. +All gave signs of delight. Sentimental music was heard, and the gay +company fell to waltzing away the hours. Meanwhile, from below on the +road level, there streamed out of the darkness on either side of the +building and up the half-lit steps, their fetters ringing in harmony +with the music, the enslaved and toiling masses coming in response to +command to build the monument for their masters. It is impossible to +describe the exquisite beauty of the slow movement of those dark +figures aslant the broad flight of steps; individual expressions were +of course indistinguishable, and yet the movement and attitude of the +groups conveyed pathos and patient endurance as well as any individual +speech or gesture in the ordinary theatre. Some groups carried hammer +and anvil, and others staggered under enormous blocks of stone. Love +for the ballet has perhaps made the Russians understand the art of +moving groups of actors in unison. As I watched these processions +climbing the steps in apparently careless and spontaneous fashion, and +yet producing so graceful a result, I remembered the mad leap of the +archers down the stage in _Prince Igor_, which is also apparently +careless and spontaneous and full of wild and irregular beauty, yet +never varies a hair-breadth from one performance to the next. + +For a time the workers toiled in the shadow in their earthly world, +and dancing continued in the lighted paradise of the rulers above, +until presently, in sign that the monument was complete, a large +yellow disc was hoisted amid acclamation above the highest platform +between the columns. But at the same moment a banner was uplifted +amongst the people, and a small figure was seen gesticulating. Angry +fists were shaken and the banner and speaker disappeared, only to +reappear almost immediately in another part of the dense crowd. Again +hostility, until finally among the French workers away up on the +right, the first Communist manifesto found favour. Rallying around +their banner the _communards_ ran shouting down the steps, gathering +supporters as they came. Above, all is confusion, kings and queens +scuttling in unroyal fashion with flying velvet robes to safe citadels +right and left, while the army prepares to defend the main citadel of +capitalism with its golden disc of power. The _communards_ scale the +steps to the fortress which they finally capture, haul down the disc +and set their banner in its place. The merry music of the _Carmagnole_ +is heard, and the victors are seen expressing their delight by dancing +first on one foot and then on the other, like marionettes. Below, the +masses dance with them in a frenzy of joy. But a pompous procession of +Prussian legions is seen approaching, and, amid shrieks and wails of +despair, the people are driven back, and their leaders set in a row +and shot. Thereafter came one of the most moving scenes in the drama. +Several dark-clad women appeared carrying a black pall supported on +sticks, which they set in front of the bodies of the leaders so that +it stood out, an irregular pointed black shape against the white +columns behind. But for this melancholy monument the stage was now +empty. Thick clouds of black smoke arose from braziers on either side +and obscured the steps and the platform. Through the smoke came the +distant sound of Chopin's _Marche Funèbre_, and as the air became +clearer white figures could be dimly seen moving around the black pall +in a solemn dance of mourning. Behind them the columns shone ghostly +and unreal against the glimmering mauve rays of an uncertain and +watery dawn. + +The second part of the pageant opened in July 1914. Once again the +rulers were feasting and the workers at toil, but the scene was +enlivened by the presence of the leaders of the Second International, +a group of decrepit professorial old men, who waddled in in solemn +procession carrying tomes full of international learning. They sat in +a row between the rulers and the people, deep in study, spectacles on +nose. The call to war was the signal for a dramatic appeal from the +workers to these leaders, who refused to accept the Red Flag, but +weakly received patriotic flags from their respective governments. +Jaurès, elevated to be the symbol of protest, towered above the +people, crying in a loud voice, but fell back immediately as the +assassin's shot rang out. Then the people divided into their national +groups and the war began. It was at this point that "God Save the +King" was played as the English soldiers marched out, in a comic +manner which made one think of it as "_Gawd_ save the King." Other +national anthems were burlesqued in a similar fashion, but none quite +so successfully. A ridiculous effigy of the Tsar with a knout in his +hand now occupied the symbolic position and dominated the scene. The +incidents of the war which affected Russia were then played. +Spectacular cavalry charges on the road, marching soldiers, batteries +of artillery, a pathetic procession of cripples and nurses, and other +scenes too numerous to describe, made up that part of the pageant +devoted to the war. + +Then came the Russian Revolution in all its stages. Cars dashed by +full of armed men, red flags appeared everywhere, the people stormed +the citadel and hauled down the effigy of the Tsar. The Kerensky +Government assumed control and drove them forth to war again, but soon +they returned to the charge, destroyed the Provisional Government, and +hoisted all the emblems of the Russian Soviet Republic. The Entente +leaders, however, were seen preparing their troops for battle, and the +pageant went on to show the formation of the Red Army under its emblem +the Red Star. White figures with golden trumpets appeared foretelling +victory for the proletariat. The last scene, the World Commune, is +described in the words of the abstract, taken from a Russian +newspaper, as follows:-- + + Cannon shots announce the breaking of the blockade against + Soviet Russia, and the victory of the World Proletariat. The + Red Army returns from the front, and passes in triumphant + review before the leaders of the Revolution. At their feet lie + the crowns of kings and the gold of the bankers. Ships draped + with flags are seen carrying workers from the west. The + workers of the whole world, with the emblems of labour, gather + for the celebration of the World Commune. In the heavens + luminous inscriptions in different languages appear, greeting + the Congress: "Long live the Third International! Workers of + the world, unite! Triumph to the sounds of the hymn of the + World Commune, the 'International'." + +Even so glowing an account, however, hardly does it justice. It had +the pomp and majesty of the Day of Judgment itself. Rockets climbed +the skies and peppered them with a thousand stars, fireworks blazed on +all sides, garlanded and beflagged ships moved up and down the river, +chariots bearing the emblems of prosperity, grapes and corn, travelled +slowly along the road. The Eastern peoples came carrying gifts and +emblems. The actors, massed upon the steps, waved triumphant hands, +trumpets sounded, and the song of the International from ten thousand +throats rose like a mighty wave engulfing the whole. + +Though the end of this drama may have erred on the side of the +grandiose, this may perhaps be forgiven the organizers in view of the +occasion for which they prepared it. Nothing, however, could detract +from the beauty and dramatic power of the opening and of many of the +scenes. Moreover, the effects obtained by movement in the mass were +almost intoxicating. The first entrance of the masses gave a sense of +dumb and patient force that was moving in the extreme, and the +frenzied delight of the dancing crowd at the victory of the French +_communards_ stirred one to ecstasy. The pageant lasted for five hours +or more, and was as exhausting emotionally as the Passion Play is said +to be. I had the vision of a great period of Communist art, more +especially of such open-air spectacles, which should have the grandeur +and scope and eternal meaning of the plays of ancient Greece, the +mediæval mysteries, or the Shakespearean theatre. In building, +writing, acting, even in painting, work would be done, as it once was, +by groups, not by one hand or mind, and evolution would proceed slowly +until once again the individual emerged from the mass. + +In considering Education under the Bolshevik régime, the same two +factors which I have already dealt with in discussing art, namely +industrial development and the communist doctrine, must be taken into +account. Industrial development is in reality one of the tenets of +Communism, but as it is one which in Russia is likely to endanger the +doctrine as a whole I have thought it better to consider it as a +separate item. + +As in the matter of art, so in education, those who have given +unqualified praise seem to have taken the short and superficial view. +It is hardly necessary to launch into descriptions of the crèches, +country homes or palaces for children, where Montessori methods +prevail, where the pupils cultivate their little gardens, model in +plasticine, draw and sing and act, and dance their Eurythmic dances +barefoot on floors once sacred to the tread of the nobility. I saw a +reception and distributing house in Petrograd with which no fault +could be found from the point of view of scientific organization. The +children were bright-eyed and merry, and the rooms airy and clean. I +saw, too, a performance by school children in Moscow which included +some quite wonderful Eurythmic dancing, in particular an +interpretation of Grieg's _Tanz in der Halle des Bergkönigs_ by the +Dalcroze method, but with a colour and warmth which were Russian, and +in odd contrast to the mathematical precision associated with most +Dalcroze performances. + +But in spite of the obvious merit of such institutions as exist, +misgivings would arise. To begin with, it must be remembered that it +is necessary first to admit that children should be delivered up +almost entirely to the State. Nominally, the mother still comes to see +her child in these schools, but in actual fact, the drafting of +children to the country must intervene, and the whole temper of the +authorities seemed to be directed towards breaking the link between +mother and child. To some this will seem an advantage, and it is a +point which admits of lengthy discussion, but as it belongs rather to +the question of women and the family under Communism, I can do no more +than mention it here. + +Then, again, it must be remembered that the tactics of the Bolsheviks +towards such schools as existed under the old régime in provincial +towns and villages, have not been the same as their tactics towards +the theatres. The greater number of these schools are closed, in part, +it would seem, from lack of personnel, and in part from fear of +counter-revolutionary propaganda. The result is that, though those +schools which they have created are good and organized on modern +lines, on the whole there would seem to be less diffusion of child +education than before. In this, as in most other departments, the +Bolsheviks show themselves loath to attempt anything which cannot be +done on a large scale and impregnated with Communist doctrine. It goes +without saying that Communist doctrine is taught in schools, as +Christianity has been taught hitherto, moreover the Communist teachers +show bitter hostility to other teachers who do not accept the +doctrine. At the children's entertainment alluded to above, the dances +and poems performed had nearly all some close relation to Communism, +and a teacher addressed the children for something like an hour and a +half on the duties of Communists and the errors of Anarchism. + +This teaching of Communism, however necessary it may appear for the +building of the Communist state of the future, does seem to me to be +an evil in that it is done emotionally and fanatically, with an appeal +to hate and militant ardour rather than to constructive reason. It +binds the free intellect and destroys initiative. An industrial state +needs not only obedient and patient workers and artists, it needs also +men and women with initiative in scientific research. It is idle to +provide channels for scientific research later if it is to be choked +at the source. That source is an enquiring and free intellect +unhampered by iron dogma. Beneficial to artistic and emotional +development therefore, the teaching of Communism as a faith may well +be most pernicious to the scientific and intellectual side of +education, and will lead direct to the pragmatist view of knowledge +and scientific research which the Church and the capitalist already +find it so convenient to adopt. + +But to come to the chief and most practical question, the relation of +education to industry. Sooner or later education in Russia must become +subordinate to the needs of industrial development. That the +Bolsheviks already realize this is proved by the articles of +Lunacharsky which recently appeared in _Le Phare_ (Geneva). It was the +spectre of industry that haunted me throughout the consideration of +education as in the consideration of art, and what I have said above +of its dangers to the latter seems to me also to apply here. +Montessori schools belong, in my view, to that stage in industrial +development when education is directed as much towards leisure +occupations as towards preparation for professional life. Possibly the +fine flower of useless scientific enquiry belongs to this stage also. +Nobody in Russia is likely to have much leisure for a good many years +to come, if the Bolshevik programme of industrial development is +efficiently carried out. And there seemed to me to be something +pathetic and almost cruel in this varied and agreeable education of +the child, when one reflected on the long hours of grinding toil to +which he was soon to be subject in workshop or factory. For I repeat +that I do not believe industrial work in the early days of industry +can be made tolerable to the worker. Once again I experienced the +dread of seeing the ideals of the Russian revolutionaries go down +before the logic of necessity. They are beginning to pride themselves +on being hard, practical men, and it seems quite reasonable to fear +that they should come to regard this full and humane development of +the child as a mere luxury and ultimately neglect it. Worse still, the +few of these schools which already exist may perhaps become exclusive +to the Communists and their children, or that company of Samurai which +is to leaven and govern the mass of the people. If so, they will soon +come to resemble our public schools, in that they will prepare, in an +artificial play atmosphere, men who will pass straight to the position +of leaders, while the portion of the proletariat who serve under them +will be reading and writing, just so much technical training as is +necessary, and Communist doctrine. + +This is a nightmare hypothesis, but the difficulties of the practical +problem seem to warrant its entertainment. The number of people in +Russia who can even read and write is extremely small, the need to +get them employed industrially as rapidly as possible is very great, +hence the system of education which develops out of this situation +cannot be very ambitious or enlightened. Further it will have to +continue over a sufficiently long period of time to allow of the risk +of its becoming stable and traditional. In adult education already the +pupil comes for a short period, learns Communism, reading and +writing--there is hardly time to give him much more--and returns to +leaven the army or his native village. In achieving this the +Bolsheviks are already doing a very important and valuable work, but +they cannot hope for a long while to become the model of public +instruction which they have hitherto been represented to be. And the +conditions of their becoming so ultimately are adherence to their +ideals through a very long period of stress, and a lessening of +fanaticism in their Communist teaching, conditions which, unhappily, +seem to be mutually incompatible. + +The whole of the argument set out in this chapter may be summed up in +the statement of one fact which the mere idealist is prone to +overlook, namely that Russia is a country at a stage in economic +development not much more advanced than America in the pioneer days. +The old civilization was aristocratic and exotic; it could not survive +in the modern world. It is true that it produced great men, but its +foundations were rotten. The new civilization may, for the moment, be +less productive of individual works of genius, but it has a new +solidity and gives promise of a new unity. It may be that I have taken +too hopeful a view and that the future evolution of Russia will have +as little connection with the life and tradition of its present +population as modern America with the life of the Red Indian tribes. +The fact that there exists in Russia a population at a far higher +stage of culture, which will be industrially educated, not +exterminated, militates against this hypothesis, but the need for +education may make progress slower than it was in the United States. + +One would not have looked for the millennium of Communism, nor even +for valuable art and educational experiment in the America of early +railroading and farming days. Nor must one look for such things from +Russia yet. It may be that during the next hundred years there, +economic evolution will obscure Communist ideals, until finally, in a +country that has reached the stage of present-day America, the battle +will be fought out again to a victorious and stable issue. Unless, +indeed, the Marxian scripture prove to be not infallible, and faith +and heroic devotion show themselves capable of triumphing over +economic necessity. + + + + +V + +COMMUNISM AND THE SOVIET CONSTITUTION + + +Before I went to Russia I imagined that I was going to see an +interesting experiment in a new form of representative government. I +did see an interesting experiment, but not in representative +government. Every one who is interested in Bolshevism knows the series +of elections, from the village meeting to the All-Russian Soviet, by +which the people's commissaries are supposed to derive their power. We +were told that, by the recall, the occupational constituencies, and so +on, a new and far more perfect machinery had been devised for +ascertaining and registering the popular will. One of the things we +hoped to study was the question whether the Soviet system is really +superior to Parliamentarism in this respect. + +We were not able to make any such study, because the Soviet system is +moribund.[4] No conceivable system of free election would give +majorities to the Communists, either in town or country. Various +methods are therefore adopted for giving the victory to Government +candidates. In the first place, the voting is by show of hands, so +that all who vote against the Government are marked men. In the second +place, no candidate who is not a Communist can have any printing done, +the printing works being all in the hands of the State. In the third +place, he cannot address any meetings, because the halls all belong to +the State. The whole of the press is, of course, official; no +independent daily is permitted. In spite of all these obstacles, the +Mensheviks have succeeded in winning about 40 seats out of 1,500 on +the Moscow Soviet, by being known in certain large factories where the +electoral campaign could be conducted by word of mouth. They won, in +fact, every seat that they contested. + +But although the Moscow Soviet is nominally sovereign in Moscow, it is +really only a body of electors who choose the executive committee of +forty, out of which, in turn, is chosen the Presidium, consisting of +nine men who have all the power. The Moscow Soviet, as a whole, meets +rarely; the Executive Committee is supposed to meet once a week, but +did not meet while we were in Moscow. The Presidium, on the contrary, +meets daily. Of course, it is easy for the Government to exercise +pressure over the election of the executive committee, and again over +the election of the Presidium. It must be remembered that effective +protest is impossible, owing to the absolutely complete suppression of +free speech and free Press. The result is that the Presidium of the +Moscow Soviet consists only of orthodox Communists. + +Kamenev, the President of the Moscow Soviet, informed us that the +recall is very frequently employed; he said that in Moscow there are, +on an average, thirty recalls a month. I asked him what were the +principal reasons for the recall, and he mentioned four: drinking, +going to the front (and being, therefore, incapable of performing the +duties), change of politics on the part of the electors, and failure +to make a report to the electors once a fortnight, which all members +of the Soviet are expected to do. It is evident that the recall +affords opportunities for governmental pressure, but I had no chance +of finding out whether it is used for this purpose. + +In country districts the method employed is somewhat different. It is +impossible to secure that the village Soviet shall consist of +Communists, because, as a rule, at any rate in the villages I saw, +there are no Communists. But when I asked in the villages how they +were represented on the Volost (the next larger area) or the Gubernia, +I was met always with the reply that they were not represented at all. +I could not verify this, and it is probably an overstatement, but all +concurred in the assertion that if they elected a non-Communist +representative he could not obtain a pass on the railway and, +therefore, could not attend the Volost or Gubernia Soviet. I saw a +meeting of the Gubernia Soviet of Saratov. The representation is so +arranged that the town workers have an enormous preponderance over the +surrounding peasants; but even allowing for this, the proportion of +peasants seemed astonishingly small for the centre of a very important +agricultural area. + +The All-Russian Soviet, which is constitutionally the supreme body, to +which the People's Commissaries are responsible, meets seldom, and has +become increasingly formal. Its sole function at present, so far as I +could discover, is to ratify, without discussion, previous decisions +of the Communist Party on matters (especially concerning foreign +policy) upon which the constitution requires its decision. + +All real power is in the hands of the Communist Party, who number +about 600,000 in a population of about 120 millions. I never came +across a Communist by chance: the people whom I met in the streets or +in the villages, when I could get into conversation with them, almost +invariably said they were of no party. The only other answer I ever +had was from some of the peasants, who openly stated that they were +Tsarists. It must be said that the peasants' reasons for disliking the +Bolsheviks are very inadequate. It is said--and all I saw confirmed +the assertion--that the peasants are better off than they ever were +before. I saw no one--man, woman, or child--who looked underfed in the +villages. The big landowners are dispossessed, and the peasants have +profited. But the towns and the army still need nourishing, and the +Government has nothing to give the peasants in return for food except +paper, which the peasants resent having to take. It is a singular fact +that Tsarist roubles are worth ten times as much as Soviet roubles, +and are much commoner in the country. Although they are illegal, +pocket-books full of them are openly displayed in the market places. I +do not think it should be inferred that the peasants expect a Tsarist +restoration: they are merely actuated by custom and dislike of +novelty. They have never heard of the blockade; consequently they +cannot understand why the Government is unable to give them the +clothes and agricultural implements that they need. Having got their +land, and being ignorant of affairs outside their own neighbourhood, +they wish their own village to be independent, and would resent the +demands of any Government whatever. + +Within the Communist Party there are, of course, as always in a +bureaucracy, different factions, though hitherto the external pressure +has prevented disunion. It seemed to me that the personnel of the +bureaucracy could be divided into three classes. There are first the +old revolutionists, tested by years of persecution. These men have +most of the highest posts. Prison and exile have made them tough and +fanatical and rather out of touch with their own country. They are +honest men, with a profound belief that Communism will regenerate the +world. They think themselves utterly free from sentiment, but, in +fact, they are sentimental about Communism and about the régime that +they are creating; they cannot face the fact that what they are +creating is not complete Communism, and that Communism is anathema to +the peasant, who wants his own land and nothing else. They are +pitiless in punishing corruption or drunkenness when they find either +among officials; but they have built up a system in which the +temptations to petty corruption are tremendous, and their own +materialistic theory should persuade them that under such a system +corruption must be rampant. + +The second class in the bureaucracy, among whom are to be found most +of the men occupying political posts just below the top, consists of +_arrivistes_, who are enthusiastic Bolsheviks because of the material +success of Bolshevism. With them must be reckoned the army of +policemen, spies, and secret agents, largely inherited from the +Tsarist times, who make their profit out of the fact that no one can +live except by breaking the law. This aspect of Bolshevism is +exemplified by the Extraordinary Commission, a body practically +independent of the Government, possessing its own regiments, who are +better fed than the Red Army. This body has the power of imprisoning +any man or woman without trial on such charges as speculation or +counter-revolutionary activity. It has shot thousands without proper +trial, and though now it has nominally lost the power of inflicting +the death penalty, it is by no means certain that it has altogether +lost it in fact. It has spies everywhere, and ordinary mortals live in +terror of it. + +The third class in the bureaucracy consists of men who are not ardent +Communists, who have rallied to the Government since it has proved +itself stable, and who work for it either out of patriotism or because +they enjoy the opportunity of developing their ideas freely without +the obstacle of traditional institutions. Among this class are to be +found men of the type of the successful business man, men with the +same sort of ability as is found in the American self-made Trust +magnate, but working for success and power, not for money. There is no +doubt that the Bolsheviks are successfully solving the problem of +enlisting this kind of ability in the public service, without +permitting it to amass wealth as it does in capitalist communities. +This is perhaps their greatest success so far, outside the domain of +war. It makes it possible to suppose that, if Russia is allowed to +have peace, an amazing industrial development may take place, making +Russia a rival of the United States. The Bolsheviks are industrialists +in all their aims; they love everything in modern industry except the +excessive rewards of the capitalists. And the harsh discipline to +which they are subjecting the workers is calculated, if anything can, +to give them the habits of industry and honesty which have hitherto +been lacking, and the lack of which alone prevents Russia from being +one of the foremost industrial countries. + +FOOTNOTES: + +[4] In _Theses_ (p. 6 of French edition) it is said: "The ancient +classic subdivision of the Labour movement into three forms (parties, +trade unions, and co-operatives) has served its time. The proletarian +revolution has raised up in Russia the essential form of proletarian +dictatorship, the _soviets_. But the work in the Soviets, as in the +industrial trade unions which have become revolutionary, must be +invariably and systematically directed by the party of the +proletariat, i.e. the Communist Party. As the organized advanced guard +of the working class, the Communist Party answers equally to the +economic, political and spiritual needs of the entire working class. +It must be the soul of the trade unions, the soviets, and all other +proletarian organizations. + +"The appearance of the Soviets, the principal historical form of the +dictatorship of the proletariat, in no way diminishes the directing +rôle of the party in the proletarian revolution. When the German +Communists of the 'Left' ... declare that 'the party itself must also +adapt itself more and more to the Soviet idea and proletarianize +itself,' we see there only an insinuating expression of the idea that +the Communist Party must dissolve itself into the Soviets, so that the +Soviets can replace it. + +"This idea is profoundly erroneous and reactionary. + +"The history of the Russian Revolution shows us, at a certain moment, +the Soviets going against the proletarian party and helping the agents +of the bourgeoisie.... + +"In order that the Soviets may fulfil their historic mission, the +existence of a Communist Party, strong enough not to 'adapt' itself to +the Soviets but to exercise on them a decisive influence, to force +them _not to adapt themselves_ to the bourgeoisie and official social +democracy, ... is on the contrary necessary." + + + + +VI + +THE FAILURE OF RUSSIAN INDUSTRY + + +At first sight it is surprising that Russian industry should have +collapsed as badly as it has done, and still more surprising that the +efforts of the Communists have not been more successful in reviving +it. As I believe that the continued efficiency of industry is the main +condition for success in the transition to a Communist State, I shall +endeavour to analyse the causes of the collapse, with a view to the +discovery of ways by which it can be avoided elsewhere. + +Of the fact of the collapse there can be no doubt. The Ninth Congress +of the Communist Party (March-April, 1920) speaks of "the incredible +catastrophes of public economy," and in connection with transport, +which is one of the vital elements of the problem, it acknowledges +"the terrible collapse of the transport and the railway system," and +urges the introduction of "measures which cannot be delayed and which +are to obviate the complete paralysis of the railway system and, +together with this, the ruin of the Soviet Republic." Almost all those +who have visited Russia would confirm this view of the gravity of the +situation. In the factories, in great works like those of Putilov and +Sornovo, very little except war work is being done; machinery stands +idle and plant is becoming unusable. One sees hardly any new +manufactured articles in Russia, beyond a certain very inadequate +quantity of clothes and boots--always excepting what is needed for the +army. And the difficulty of obtaining food is conclusive evidence of +the absence of goods such as are needed by the peasants. + +How has this state of affairs arisen? And why does it continue? + +A great deal of disorganization occurred before the first revolution +and under Kerensky. Russian industry was partly dependent on Poland; +the war was conducted by methods of reckless extravagance, especially +as regards rolling-stock; under Kerensky there was a tendency to +universal holiday, under the impression that freedom had removed the +necessity for work. But when all this is admitted to the full, it +remains true that the state of industry under the Bolsheviks is much +worse than even under Kerensky. + +The first and most obvious reason for this is that Russia was quite +unusually dependent upon foreign assistance. Not only did the +machinery in the factories and the locomotives on the railways come +from abroad, but the organizing and technical brains in industry were +mainly foreign. When the Entente became hostile to Russia, the +foreigners in Russian industry either left the country or assisted +counter-revolution. Even those who were in fact loyal naturally became +suspect, and could not well be employed in responsible posts, any more +than Germans could in England during the war. The native Russians who +had technical or business skill were little better; they almost all +practised sabotage in the first period of the Bolshevik régime. One +hears amusing stories of common sailors frantically struggling with +complicated accounts, because no competent accountant would work for +the Bolsheviks. + +But those days passed. When the Government was seen to be stable, a +great many of those who had formerly sabotaged it became willing to +accept posts under it, and are now in fact so employed, often at quite +exceptional salaries. Their importance is thoroughly realized. One +resolution at the above-mentioned Congress says (I quote verbally the +unedited document which was given to us in Moscow): + + Being of opinion that without a scientific organization of + industry, even the widest application of compulsory labour + service, as the great labour heroism of the working class, + will not only fail to secure the establishment of a powerful + socialist production, but will also fail to assist the country + to free itself from the clutches of poverty--the Congress + considers it imperative to register all able specialists of + the various departments of public economy and widely to + utilize them for the purpose of industrial organization. + + The Congress considers the elucidation for the wide masses of + the workers of the tremendous character of the economic + problems of the country to be one of the chief problems of + industrial and general political agitation and propaganda; and + of equal importance to this, technical education, and + administrative and scientific technical experience. The + Congress makes it obligatory on all the members of the party + mercilessly to fight that particular obnoxious form, the + ignorant conceit which deems the working class capable of + solving all problems without the assistance _in the most + responsible cases_ of specialists of the bourgeois school, the + management. Demagogic elements who speculate on this kind of + prejudice in the more backward section of our working classes, + can have no place in the ranks of the party of Scientific + Socialism. + +But Russia alone is unable to supply the amount of skill required, and +is very deficient in technical instructors, as well as in skilled +workmen. One was told, over and over again, that the first step in +improvement would be the obtaining of spare parts for locomotives. It +seems strange that these could not be manufactured in Russia. To some +extent they can be, and we were shown locomotives which had been +repaired on Communist Saturdays. But in the main the machinery for +making spare parts is lacking and the skill required for its +manufacture does not exist. Thus dependence on the outside world +persists, and the blockade continues to do its deadly work of +spreading hunger, demoralization and despair. + +The food question is intimately bound up with the question of +industry. There is a vicious circle, for not only does the absence of +manufactured goods cause a food shortage in the towns, but the food +shortage, in turn, diminishes the strength of the workers and makes +them less able to produce goods. I cannot but think that there has +been some mismanagement as regards the food question. For example, in +Petrograd many workers have allotments and often work in them for +eight hours after an eight hours' day in their regular employment. But +the food produced in the allotments is taken for general consumption, +not left to each individual producer. This is in accordance with +Communist theory, but of course greatly diminishes the incentive to +work, and increases the red tape and administrative machinery. + +Lack of fuel has been another very grave source of trouble. Before the +war coal came mostly from Poland and the Donetz Basin. Poland is lost +to Russia, and the Donetz Basin was in the hands of Denikin, who so +destroyed the mines before retreating that they are still not in +working order. The result is a practically complete absence of coal. +Oil, which is equally important in Russia, was also lacking until the +recent recovery of Baku. All that I saw on the Volga made me believe +that real efficiency has been shown in reorganizing the transport of +oil, and doubtless this will do something to revive industry. But the +oil used to be worked very largely by Englishmen, and English +machinery is much needed for refining it. In the meantime, Russia has +had to depend upon wood, which involves immense labour. Most of the +houses are not warmed in winter, so that people live in a temperature +below freezing-point. Another consequence of lack of fuel was the +bursting of water-pipes, so that people in Petrograd, for the most +part, have to go down to the Neva to fetch their water--a considerable +addition to the labour of an already overworked day. + +I find it difficult to believe that, if greater efficiency had existed +in the Government, the food and fuel difficulties could not have been +considerably alleviated. In spite of the needs of the army, there are +still many horses in Russia; I saw troops of thousands of horses on +the Volga, which apparently belonged to Kalmuk tribes. By the help of +carts and sledges, it ought to be possible, without more labour than +is warranted by the importance of the problem, to bring food and +timber into Moscow and Petrograd. It must be remembered that both +cities are surrounded by forests, and Moscow at least is surrounded by +good agricultural land. The Government has devoted all its best +energies hitherto to the two tasks of war and propaganda, while +industry and the food problem have been left to a lesser degree of +energy and intelligence. It is no doubt probable that, if peace is +secured, the economic problems will receive more attention than +hitherto. But the Russian character seems less adapted to steady work +of an unexciting nature than to heroic efforts on great occasions; it +has immense passive endurance, but not much active tenacity. Whether, +with the menace of foreign invasion removed, enough day-by-day +detailed energy would exist for the reorganization of industry, is a +doubtful question, as to which only time can decide. + +This leads to the conclusion--which I think is adopted by most of the +leading men in Russia--that it will be very difficult indeed to save +the revolution without outside economic assistance. Outside assistance +from capitalist countries is dangerous to the principles of Communism, +as well as precarious from the likelihood of fresh causes of quarrel. +But the need of help is urgent, and if the policy of promoting +revolution elsewhere were to succeed, it would probably render the +nations concerned temporarily incapable of supplying Russian needs. +It is, therefore, necessary for Russia to accept the risks and +uncertainties involved in attempting to make peace with the Entente +and to trade with America. By continuing war, Russia can do infinite +damage to us, especially in Asia, but cannot hope, for many years, to +achieve any degree of internal prosperity. The situation, therefore, +is one in which, even from the narrowest point of view, peace is to +the interest of both parties. + +It is difficult for an outsider with only superficial knowledge to +judge of the efforts which have been made to reorganize industry +without outside help. These efforts have chiefly taken the form of +industrial conscription. Workers in towns seek to escape to the +country, in order to have enough to eat; but this is illegal and +severely punished. The same Communist Report from which I have already +quoted speaks on this subject as follows: + + _Labour Desertion._--Owing to the fact that a considerable + part of the workers either in search of better food conditions + or often for the purposes of speculation, voluntarily leave + their places of employment or change from place to place, + which inevitably harms production and deteriorates the general + position of the working class, the Congress considers one of + the most urgent problems of Soviet Government and of the Trade + Union organization to be established as the firm, systematic + and insistent struggle with labour desertion, The way to fight + this is to publish a list of desertion fines, the creation of + a labour Detachment of Deserters under fine, and, finally, + internment in concentration camps. + +It is hoped to extend the system to the peasantry: + + The defeat of the White Armies and the problems of peaceful + construction in connection with the incredible catastrophes of + public economy demand an extraordinary effort of all the + powers of the proletariat and the drafting into the process of + public labour of the wide masses of the peasantry. + +On the vital subject of transport, in a passage of which I have +already quoted a fragment, the Communist Party declares: + + For the most immediate future transport remains the centre of + the attention and the efforts of the Soviet Government. The + improvement of transport is the indispensable basis upon which + even the most moderate success in all other spheres of + production and first of all in the provision question can be + gained. + + The chief difficulty with regard to the improvement of + transport is the weakness of the Transport Trade Union, which + is due in the first case to the heterogeneity of the personnel + of the railways, amongst whom there are still a number of + those who belong to the period of disorganization, and, + secondly, to the fact that the most class-conscious and best + elements of the railway proletariat were at the various fronts + of the civil war. + + Considering wide Trade Union assistance to the railway workers + to be one of the principal tasks of the Party, and as the only + condition under which transport can be raised to its height, + the Congress at the same time recognizes the inflexible + necessity of employing exclusive and extraordinary measures + (martial law, and so forth). Such necessity is the result of + the terrible collapse of the transport and the railroad system + and is to introduce measures which cannot be delayed and which + are to obviate the complete paralysis of the railway system + and, together with this, the ruin of the Soviet Republic. + +The general attitude to the militarization of labour is stated in the +Resolution with which this section of the Proceedings begins: + + The ninth Congress approves of the decision of the Central + Committee of the Russian Communist Party on the mobilization + of the industrial proletariat, compulsory labour service, + militarization of production and the application of military + detachments to economic needs. + + In connection with the above, the Congress decrees that the + Party organization should in every way assist the Trade Unions + and the Labour Sections in registering all skilled workers + with a view of employing them in the various branches of + production with the same consistency and strictness as was + done, and is being carried out at the present time, in + relation to the commanding staff for army needs. + + Every skilled worker is to return to his particular trade + Exceptions, i.e. the retention of the skilled worker in any + other branch of Soviet service, is allowed only with the + sanction of the corresponding central and local authorities. + +It is, of course, evident that in these measures the Bolsheviks have +been compelled to travel a long way from the ideals which originally +inspired the revolution. But the situation is so desperate that they +could not be blamed if their measures were successful. In a shipwreck +all hands must turn to, and it would be ridiculous to prate of +individual liberty. The most distressing feature of the situation is +that these stern laws seem to have produced so little effect. Perhaps +in the course of years Russia might become self-supporting without +help from the outside world, but the suffering meantime would be +terrible. The early hopes of the revolution would fade more and more. +Every failure of industry, every tyrannous regulation brought about by +the desperate situation, is used by the Entente as a justification of +its policy. If a man is deprived of food and drink, he will grow weak, +lose his reason, and finally die. This is not usually considered a +good reason for inflicting death by starvation. But where nations are +concerned, the weakness and struggles are regarded as morally +culpable, and are held to justify further punishment. So at least it +has been in the case of Russia. Nothing produced a doubt in our +governing minds as to the rightness of our policy except the strength +of the Red Army and the fear of revolution in Asia. Is it surprising +that professions of humanitarian feeling on the part of English people +are somewhat coldly received in Soviet Russia? + + + + +VII + +DAILY LIFE IN MOSCOW + + +Daily life in Moscow, so far as I could discover, has neither the +horrors depicted by the Northcliffe Press nor the delights imagined by +the more ardent of our younger Socialists. + +On the one hand, there is no disorder, very little crime, not much +insecurity for those who keep clear of politics. Everybody works hard; +the educated people have, by this time, mostly found their way into +Government offices or teaching or some other administrative profession +in which their education is useful. The theatres, the opera and the +ballet continue as before, and are quite admirable; some of the seats +are paid for, others are given free to members of trade unions. There +is, of course, no drunkenness, or at any rate so little that none of +us ever saw a sign of it. There is very little prostitution, +infinitely less than in any other capital. Women are safer from +molestation than anywhere else in the world. The whole impression is +one of virtuous, well-ordered activity. + +On the other hand, life is very hard for all except men in good posts. +It is hard, first of all, owing to the food shortage. This is familiar +to all who have interested themselves in Russia, and it is unnecessary +to dwell upon it. What is less realized is that most people work much +longer hours than in this country. The eight-hour day was introduced +with a flourish of trumpets; then, owing to the pressure of the war, +it was extended to ten hours in certain trades. But no provision +exists against extra work at other jobs, and very many people do extra +work, because the official rates do not afford a living wage. This is +not the fault of the Government, at any rate as regards the major +part; it is due chiefly to war and blockade. When the day's work is +over, a great deal of time has to be spent in fetching food and water +and other necessaries of life. The sight of the workers going to and +fro, shabbily clad, with the inevitable bundle in one hand and tin can +in the other, through streets almost entirely empty of traffic, +produces the effect of life in some vast village, rather than in an +important capital city. + +Holidays, such as are common throughout all but the very poorest class +in this country, are very difficult in Russia. A train journey +requires a permit, which is only granted on good reasons being shown; +with the present shortage of transport, this regulation is quite +unavoidable. Railway queues are a common feature in Moscow; it often +takes several days to get a permit. Then, when it has been obtained, +it may take several more days to get a seat in a train. The ordinary +trains are inconceivably crowded, far more so, though that seems +impossible, than London trains at the busiest hour. On the shorter +journeys, passengers are even known to ride on the roof and buffers, +or cling like flies to the sides of the waggons. People in Moscow +travel to the country whenever they can afford the time and get a +permit, because in the country there is enough to eat. They go to stay +with relations--most people in Moscow, in all classes, but especially +among manual workers, have relations in the country. One cannot, of +course, go to an hotel as one would in other countries. Hotels have +been taken over by the State, and the rooms in them (when they are +still used) are allocated by the police to people whose business is +recognized as important by the authorities. Casual travel is therefore +impossible even on a holiday. + +Journeys have vexations in addition to the slowness and overcrowding +of the trains. Police search the travellers for evidences of +"speculation," especially for food. The police play, altogether, a +much greater part in daily life than they do in other countries--much +greater than they did, for example, in Prussia twenty-five years ago, +when there was a vigorous campaign against Socialism. Everybody breaks +the law almost daily, and no one knows which among his acquaintances +is a spy of the Extraordinary Commission. Even in the prisons, among +prisoners, there are spies, who are allowed certain privileges but not +their liberty. + +Newspapers are not taken in, except by very few people, but they are +stuck up in public places, where passers-by occasionally glance at +them.[5] There is very little to read; owing to paper shortage, books +are rare, and money to buy them is still rarer. One does not see +people reading, as one does here in the Underground for example. There +is practically no social life, partly because of the food shortage, +partly because, when anybody is arrested, the police are apt to arrest +everybody whom they find in his company, or who comes to visit him. +And once arrested, a man or woman, however innocent, may remain for +months in prison without trial. While we were in Moscow, forty social +revolutionaries and Anarchists were hunger-striking to enforce their +demand to be tried and to be allowed visits. I was told that on the +eighth day of the strike the Government consented to try them, and +that few could be proved guilty of any crime; but I had no means of +verifying this. + +Industrial conscription is, of course, rigidly enforced. Every man and +woman has to work, and slacking is severely punished, by prison or a +penal settlement. Strikes are illegal, though they sometimes occur. By +proclaiming itself the friend of the proletarian, the Government has +been enabled to establish an iron discipline, beyond the wildest +dreams of the most autocratic American magnate. And by the same +professions the Government has led Socialists from other countries to +abstain from reporting unpleasant features in what they have seen. + +The Tolstoyans, of whom I saw the leaders, are obliged by their creed +to resist every form of conscription, though some have found ways of +compromising. The law concerning conscientious objectors to military +service is practically the same as ours, and its working depends upon +the temper of the tribunal before which a man comes. Some +conscientious objectors have been shot; on the other hand, some have +obtained absolute exemption. + +Life in Moscow, as compared to life in London, is drab, monotonous, +and depressed. I am not, of course, comparing life there with that of +the rich here, but with that of the average working-class family. When +it is realized that the highest wages are about fifteen shillings a +month, this is not surprising. I do not think that life could, under +any system, be very cheerful in a country so exhausted by war as +Russia, so I am not saying this as a criticism of the Bolsheviks. But +I do think there might be less police interference, less vexatious +regulation, and more freedom for spontaneous impulses towards harmless +enjoyments. + +Religion is still very strong. I went into many churches, where I saw +obviously famished priests in gorgeous vestments, and a congregation +enormously devout. Generally more than half the congregation were men, +and among the men many were soldiers. This applies to the towns as +well as to the country. In Moscow I constantly saw people in the +streets crossing themselves. + +There is a theory that the Moscow working man feels himself free from +capitalist domination, and therefore bears hardships gladly. This is +no doubt true of the minority who are active Communists, but I do not +think it has any truth for the others. The average working man, to +judge by a rather hasty impression, feels himself the slave of the +Government, and has no sense whatever of having been liberated from a +tyranny. + +I recognize to the full the reasons for the bad state of affairs, in +the past history of Russia and the recent policy of the Entente. But I +have thought it better to record impressions frankly, trusting the +readers to remember that the Bolsheviks have only a very limited share +of responsibility for the evils from which Russia is suffering. + +FOOTNOTES: + +[5] The ninth Communist Congress (March-April, 1920) says on this +subject: "In view of the fact that the first condition of the success +of the Soviet Republic in all departments, including the economic, is +chiefly systematic printed agitation, the Congress draws the attention +of the Soviet Government to the deplorable state in which our paper +and printing industries find themselves. The ever decreasing number of +newspapers fail to reach not only the peasants but even the workers, +in addition to which our poor technical means render the papers hardly +readable. The Congress strongly appeals to the Supreme Council of +Public Economy, to the corresponding Trade Unions and other interested +institutions, to apply all efforts to raise the quantity, to introduce +general system and order in the printing business, and so secure for +the worker and peasant in Russia a supply of Socialist printed +matter." + + + + +VIII + +TOWN AND COUNTRY + + +The problem of inducing the peasants to feed the towns is one which +Russia shares with Central Europe, and from what one hears Russia has +been less unsuccessful than some other countries in dealing with this +problem. For the Soviet Government, the problem is mainly concentrated +in Moscow and Petrograd; the other towns are not very large, and are +mostly in the centre of rich agricultural districts. It is true that +in the North even the rural population normally depends upon food from +more southerly districts; but the northern population is small. It is +commonly said that the problem of feeding Moscow and Petrograd is a +transport problem, but I think this is only partially true. There is, +of course, a grave deficiency of rolling-stock, especially of +locomotives in good repair. But Moscow is surrounded by very good +land. In the course of a day's motoring in the neighbourhood, I saw +enough cows to supply milk to the whole child population of Moscow, +although what I had come to see was children's sanatoria, not farms. +All kinds of food can be bought in the market at high prices. I +travelled over a considerable extent of Russian railways, and saw a +fair number of goods trains. For all these reasons, I feel convinced +that the share of the transport problem in the food difficulties has +been exaggerated. Of course transport plays a larger part in the +shortage in Petrograd than in Moscow, because food comes mainly from +south of Moscow. In Petrograd, most of the people one sees in the +streets show obvious signs of under-feeding. In Moscow, the visible +signs are much less frequent, but there is no doubt that +under-feeding, though not actual starvation, is nearly universal. + +The Government supplies rations to every one who works in the towns at +a very low fixed price. The official theory is that the Government has +a monopoly of the food and that the rations are sufficient to sustain +life. The fact is that the rations are not sufficient, and that they +are only a portion of the food supply of Moscow. Moreover, people +complain, I do not know how truly, that the rations are delivered +irregularly; some say, about every other day. Under these +circumstances, almost everybody, rich or poor, buys food in the +market, where it costs about fifty times the fixed Government price. +A pound of butter costs about a month's wages. In order to be able to +afford extra food, people adopt various expedients. Some do additional +work, at extra rates, after their official day's work is over. For, +though there is supposed to be by law an eight-hours day, extended to +ten in certain vital industries, the wage paid for it is not a living +wage, and there is nothing to prevent a man from undertaking other +work in his spare time. But the usual resource is what is called +"speculation," i.e., buying and selling. Some person formerly rich +sells clothes or furniture or jewellery in return for food; the buyer +sells again at an enhanced price, and so on through perhaps twenty +hands, until a final purchaser is found in some well-to-do peasant or +_nouveau riche_ speculator. Again, most people have relations in the +country, whom they visit from time to time, bringing back with them +great bags of flour. It is illegal for private persons to bring food +into Moscow, and the trains are searched; but, by corruption or +cunning, experienced people can elude the search. The food market is +illegal, and is raided occasionally; but as a rule it is winked at. +Thus the attempt to suppress private commerce has resulted in an +amount of unprofessional buying and selling which far exceeds what +happens in capitalist countries. It takes up a great deal of time +that might be more profitably employed; and, being illegal, it places +practically the whole population of Moscow at the mercy of the police. +Moreover, it depends largely upon the stores of goods belonging to +those who were formerly rich, and when these are expended the whole +system must collapse, unless industry has meanwhile been +re-established on a sound basis. + +It is clear that the state of affairs is unsatisfactory, but, from the +Government's point of view, it is not easy to see what ought to be +done. The urban and industrial population is mainly concerned in +carrying on the work of government and supplying munitions to the +army. These are very necessary tasks, the cost of which ought to be +defrayed out of taxation. A moderate tax in kind on the peasants would +easily feed Moscow and Petrograd. But the peasants take no interest in +war or government. Russia is so vast that invasion of one part does +not touch another part; and the peasants are too ignorant to have any +national consciousness, such as one takes for granted in England or +France or Germany. The peasants will not willingly part with a portion +of their produce merely for purposes of national defence, but only for +the goods they need--clothes, agricultural implements, &c.--which the +Government, owing to the war and the blockade, is not in a position to +supply. + +When the food shortage was at its worst, the Government antagonized +the peasants by forced requisitions, carried out with great harshness +by the Red Army. This method has been modified, but the peasants still +part unwillingly with their food, as is natural in view of the +uselessness of paper and the enormously higher prices offered by +private buyers. + +The food problem is the main cause of popular opposition to the +Bolsheviks, yet I cannot see how any popular policy could have been +adopted. The Bolsheviks are disliked by the peasants because they take +so much food; they are disliked in the towns because they take so +little. What the peasants want is what is called free trade, i.e., +de-control of agricultural produce. If this policy were adopted, the +towns would be faced by utter starvation, not merely by hunger and +hardship. It is an entire misconception to suppose that the peasants +cherish any hostility to the Entente. The _Daily News_ of July 13th, +in an otherwise excellent leading article, speaks of "the growing +hatred of the Russian peasant, who is neither a Communist nor a +Bolshevik, for the Allies generally and this country in particular." +The typical Russian peasant has never heard of the Allies or of this +country; he does not know that there is a blockade; all he knows is +that he used to have six cows but the Government reduced him to one +for the sake of poorer peasants, and that it takes his corn (except +what is needed for his own family) at a very low price. The reasons +for these actions do not interest him, since his horizon is bounded by +his own village. To a remarkable extent, each village is an +independent unit. So long as the Government obtains the food and +soldiers that it requires, it does not interfere, and leaves untouched +the old village communism, which is extraordinarily unlike Bolshevism +and entirely dependent upon a very primitive stage of culture. + +The Government represents the interests of the urban and industrial +population, and is, as it were, encamped amid a peasant nation, with +whom its relations are rather diplomatic and military than +governmental in the ordinary sense. The economic situation, as in +Central Europe, is favourable to the country and unfavourable to the +towns. If Russia were governed democratically, according to the will +of the majority, the inhabitants of Moscow and Petrograd would die of +starvation. As it is, Moscow and Petrograd just manage to live, by +having the whole civil and military power of the State devoted to +their needs. Russia affords the curious spectacle of a vast and +powerful Empire, prosperous at the periphery, but faced with dire want +at the centre. Those who have least prosperity have most power; and +it is only through their excess of power that they are enabled to live +at all. The situation is due at bottom to two facts: that almost the +whole industrial energies of the population have had to be devoted to +war, and that the peasants do not appreciate the importance of the war +or the fact of the blockade. + +It is futile to blame the Bolsheviks for an unpleasant and difficult +situation which it has been impossible for them to avoid. Their +problem is only soluble in one of two ways: by the cessation of the +war and the blockade, which would enable them to supply the peasants +with the goods they need in exchange for food; or by the gradual +development of an independent Russian industry. This latter method +would be slow, and would involve terrible hardships, but some of the +ablest men in the Government believe it to be possible if peace cannot +be achieved. If we force this method upon Russia by the refusal of +peace and trade, we shall forfeit the only inducement we can hold out +for friendly relations; we shall render the Soviet State unassailable +and completely free to pursue the policy of promoting revolution +everywhere. But the industrial problem is a large subject, which has +been already discussed in Chapter VI. + + + + +IX + +INTERNATIONAL POLICY + + +In the course of these chapters, I have had occasion to mention +disagreeable features of the Bolshevik régime. But it must always be +remembered that these are chiefly due to the fact that the industrial +life of Russia has been paralysed except as ministering to the wants +of the Army, and that the Government has had to wage a bitter and +doubtful civil and external war, involving the constant menace of +domestic enemies. Harshness, espionage, and a curtailment of liberty +result unavoidably from these difficulties. I have no doubt whatever +that the sole cure for the evils from which Russia is suffering is +peace and trade. Peace and trade would put an end to the hostility of +the peasants, and would at once enable the Government to depend upon +popularity rather than force. The character of the Government would +alter rapidly under such conditions. Industrial conscription, which is +now rigidly enforced, would become unnecessary. Those who desire a +more liberal spirit would be able to make their voices heard without +the feeling that they were assisting reaction and the national +enemies. The food difficulties would cease, and with them the need for +an autocratic system in the towns. + +It must not be assumed, as is common with opponents of Bolshevism, +that any other Government could easily be established in Russia. I +think every one who has been in Russia recently is convinced that the +existing Government is stable. It may undergo internal developments, +and might easily, but for Lenin, become a Bonapartist military +autocracy. But this would be a change from within--not perhaps a very +great change--and would probably do little to alter the economic +system. From what I saw of the Russian character and of the opposition +parties, I became persuaded that Russia is not ready for any form of +democracy, and needs a strong Government. The Bolsheviks represent +themselves as the Allies of Western advanced Socialism, and from this +point of view they are open to grave criticism. For their +international programme there is, to my mind, nothing to be said. But +as a national Government, stripped of their camouflage, regarded as +the successors of Peter the Great, they are performing a necessary +though unamiable task. They are introducing, as far as they can, +American efficiency among a lazy and undisciplined population. They +are preparing to develop the natural resources of their country by the +methods of State Socialism, for which, in Russia, there is much to be +said. In the Army they are abolishing illiteracy, and if they had +peace they would do great things for education everywhere. + +But if we continue to refuse peace and trade, I do not think the +Bolsheviks will go under. Russia will endure great hardships, in the +years to come as before. But the Russians are inured to misery as no +Western nation is; they can live and work under conditions which we +should find intolerable. The Government will be driven more and more, +from mere self-preservation, into a policy of imperialism. The Entente +has been doing everything to expose Germany to a Russian invasion of +arms and leaflets, by allowing Poland to engage in war and compelling +Germany to disarm. All Asia lies open to Bolshevik ambitions. Almost +the whole of the former Russian Empire in Asia is quite firmly in +their grasp. Trains are running at a reasonable speed to Turkestan, +and I saw cotton from there being loaded on to Volga steamers. In +Persia and Turkey, revolts are taking place, with Bolshevik support. +It is only a question of a few years before India will be in touch +with the Red Army. If we continue to antagonize the Bolsheviks, I do +not see what force exists that can prevent them from acquiring the +whole of Asia within ten years. + +The Russian Government is not yet definitely imperialistic in spirit, +and would still prefer peace to conquest. The country is weary of war +and denuded of goods. But if the Western Powers insist upon war, +another spirit, which is already beginning to show itself, will become +dominant. Conquest will be the only alternative to submission. Asiatic +conquest will not be difficult. But for us, from the imperialist +standpoint, it will mean utter ruin. And for the Continent it will +mean revolutions, civil wars, economic cataclysms. The policy of +crushing Bolshevism by force was always foolish and criminal; it has +now become impossible and fraught with disaster. Our own Government, +it would seem, have begun to realize the dangers, but apparently they +do not realize them sufficiently to enforce their view against +opposition. + +In the Theses presented to the Second Congress of the Third +International (July 1920), there is a very interesting article by +Lenin called "First Sketch of the Theses on National and Colonial +Questions" (_Theses_, pp. 40-47). The following passages seemed to me +particularly illuminating:-- + + The present world-situation in politics places on the order of + the day the dictatorship of the proletariat; and all the + events of world politics are inevitably concentrated round one + centre of gravity: the struggle of the international + bourgeoisie against the Soviet Republic, which inevitably + groups round it, on the one hand the Sovietist movements of + the advanced working men of all countries, on the other hand + all the national movements of emancipation of colonies and + oppressed nations which have been convinced by a bitter + experience that there is no salvation for them except in the + victory of the Soviet Government over world-imperialism. + + We cannot therefore any longer confine ourselves to + recognizing and proclaiming the union of the workers of all + countries. It is henceforth necessary to pursue the + realization of the strictest union of all the national and + colonial movements of emancipation with Soviet Russia, by + giving to this union forms corresponding to the degree of + evolution of the proletarian movement among the proletariat of + each country, or of the democratic-bourgeois movement of + emancipation among the workers and peasants of backward + countries or backward nationalities. + + The federal principle appears to us as a transitory form + towards the complete unity of the workers of all countries. + +This is the formula for co-operation with Sinn Fein or with Egyptian +and Indian nationalism. It is further defined later. In regard to +backward countries, Lenin says, we must have in view:-- + + The necessity of the co-operation of all Communists in the + democratic-bourgeois movement of emancipation in those + countries. + +Again: + + "The Communist International must conclude temporary alliances + with the bourgeois democracy of backward countries, but must + never fuse with it." The class-conscious proletariat must + "show itself particularly circumspect towards the survivals of + national sentiment in countries long oppressed," and must + "consent to certain useful concessions." + +The Asiatic policy of the Russian Government was adopted as a move +against the British Empire, and as a method of inducing the British +Government to make peace. It plays a larger part in the schemes of the +leading Bolsheviks than is realized by the Labour Party in this +country. Its method is not, for the present, to preach Communism, +since the Persians and Hindoos are considered scarcely ripe for the +doctrines of Marx. It is nationalist movements that are supported by +money and agitators from Moscow. The method of quasi-independent +states under Bolshevik protection is well understood. It is obvious +that this policy affords opportunities for imperialism, under the +cover of propaganda, and there is no doubt that some among the +Bolsheviks are fascinated by its imperialist aspect. The importance +officially attached to the Eastern policy is illustrated by the fact +that it was the subject of the concluding portion of Lenin's speech to +the recent Congress of the Third International (July 1920). + +Bolshevism, like everything Russian, is partly Asiatic in character. +One may distinguish two distinct trends, developing into two distinct +policies. On the one side are the practical men, who wish to develop +Russia industrially, to secure the gains of the Revolution nationally, +to trade with the West, and gradually settle down into a more or less +ordinary State. These men have on their side the fact of the economic +exhaustion of Russia, the danger of ultimate revolt against Bolshevism +if life continues to be as painful as it is at present, and the +natural sentiment of humanity that wishes to relieve the sufferings of +the people; also the fact that, if revolutions elsewhere produce a +similar collapse of industry, they will make it impossible for Russia +to receive the outside help which is urgently needed. In the early +days, when the Government was weak, they had unchallenged control of +policy, but success has made their position less secure. + +On the other side there is a blend of two quite different aims: first, +the desire to promote revolution in the Western nations, which is in +line with Communist theory, and is also thought to be the only way of +obtaining a really secure peace; secondly, the desire for Asiatic +dominion, which is probably accompanied in the minds of some with +dreams of sapphires and rubies and golden thrones and all the glories +of their forefather Solomon. This desire produces an unwillingness to +abandon the Eastern policy, although it is realized that, until it is +abandoned, peace with capitalist England is impossible. I do not know +whether there are some to whom the thought occurs that if England were +to embark on revolution we should become willing to abandon India to +the Russians. But I am certain that the converse thought occurs, +namely that, if India could be taken from us, the blow to imperialist +feeling might lead us to revolution. In either case, the two policies, +of revolution in the West and conquest (disguised as liberation of +oppressed peoples) in the East, work in together, and dovetail into a +strongly coherent whole. + +Bolshevism as a social phenomenon is to be reckoned as a religion, not +as an ordinary political movement. The important and effective mental +attitudes to the world may be broadly divided into the religious and +the scientific. The scientific attitude is tentative and piecemeal, +believing what it finds evidence for, and no more. Since Galileo, the +scientific attitude has proved itself increasingly capable of +ascertaining important facts and laws, which are acknowledged by all +competent people regardless of temperament or self-interest or +political pressure. Almost all the progress in the world from the +earliest times is attributable to science and the scientific temper; +almost all the major ills are attributable to religion. + +By a religion I mean a set of beliefs held as dogmas, dominating the +conduct of life, going beyond or contrary to evidence, and inculcated +by methods which are emotional or authoritarian, not intellectual. By +this definition, Bolshevism is a religion: that its dogmas go beyond +or contrary to evidence, I shall try to prove in what follows. Those +who accept Bolshevism become impervious to scientific evidence, and +commit intellectual suicide. Even if all the doctrines of Bolshevism +were true, this would still be the case, since no unbiased examination +of them is tolerated. One who believes, as I do, that the free +intellect is the chief engine of human progress, cannot but be +fundamentally opposed to Bolshevism, as much as to the Church of Rome. + +Among religions, Bolshevism is to be reckoned with Mohammedanism +rather than with Christianity and Buddhism. Christianity and Buddhism +are primarily personal religions, with mystical doctrines and a love +of contemplation. Mohammedanism and Bolshevism are practical, social, +unspiritual, concerned to win the empire of this world. Their founders +would not have resisted the third of the temptations in the +wilderness. What Mohammedanism did for the Arabs, Bolshevism may do +for the Russians. As Ali went down before the politicians who only +rallied to the Prophet after his success, so the genuine Communists +may go down before those who are now rallying to the ranks of the +Bolsheviks. If so, Asiatic empire with all its pomps and splendours +may well be the next stage of development, and Communism may seem, in +historical retrospect, as small a part of Bolshevism as abstinence +from alcohol is of Mohammedanism. It is true that, as a world force, +whether for revolution or for empire, Bolshevism must sooner or later +be brought by success into a desperate conflict with America; and +America is more solid and strong, as yet, than anything that +Mohammed's followers had to face. But the doctrines of Communism are +almost certain, in the long run, to make progress among American +wage-earners, and the opposition of America is therefore not likely to +be eternal. Bolshevism may go under in Russia, but even if it does it +will spring up again elsewhere, since it is ideally suited to an +industrial population in distress. What is evil in it is mainly due to +the fact that it has its origin in distress; the problem is to +disentangle the good from the evil, and induce the adoption of the +good in countries not goaded into ferocity by despair. + +Russia is a backward country, not yet ready for the methods of equal +co-operation which the West is seeking to substitute for arbitrary +power in politics and industry. In Russia, the methods of the +Bolsheviks are probably more or less unavoidable; at any rate, I am +not prepared to criticize them in their broad lines. But they are not +the methods appropriate to more advanced countries, and our Socialists +will be unnecessarily retrograde if they allow the prestige of the +Bolsheviks to lead them into slavish imitation. It will be a far less +excusable error in our reactionaries if, by their unteachableness, +they compel the adoption of violent methods. We have a heritage of +civilization and mutual tolerance which is important to ourselves and +to the world. Life in Russia has always been fierce and cruel, to a +far greater degree than with us, and out of the war has come a danger +that this fierceness and cruelty may become universal. I have hopes +that in England this may be avoided through the moderation of both +sides. But it is essential to a happy issue that melodrama should no +longer determine our views of the Bolsheviks: they are neither angels +to be worshipped nor devils to be exterminated, but merely bold and +able men attempting with great skill an almost impossible task. + + + + +PART II + +BOLSHEVIK THEORY + + + + +I + +THE MATERIALISTIC THEORY OF HISTORY + + +The materialistic conception of history, as it is called, is due to +Marx, and underlies the whole Communist philosophy. I do not mean, of +course, that a man could not be a Communist without accepting it, but +that in fact it is accepted by the Communist Party, and that it +profoundly influences their views as to politics and tactics. The name +does not convey at all accurately what is meant by the theory. It +means that all the mass-phenomena of history are determined by +economic motives. This view has no essential connection with +materialism in the philosophic sense. Materialism in the philosophic +sense may be defined as the theory that all apparently mental +occurrences either are really physical, or at any rate have purely +physical causes. Materialism in this sense also was preached by Marx, +and is accepted by all orthodox Marxians. The arguments for and +against it are long and complicated, and need not concern us, since, +in fact, its truth or falsehood has little or no bearing on politics. + +In particular, philosophic materialism does not prove that economic +causes are fundamental in politics. The view of Buckle, for example, +according to which climate is one of the decisive factors, is equally +compatible with materialism. So is the Freudian view, which traces +everything to sex. There are innumerable ways of viewing history which +are materialistic in the philosophic sense without being economic or +falling within the Marxian formula. Thus the "materialistic conception +of history" may be false even if materialism in the philosophic sense +should be true. + +On the other hand, economic causes might be at the bottom of all +political events even if philosophic materialism were false. Economic +causes operate through men's desire for possessions, and would be +supreme if this desire were supreme, even if desire could not, from a +philosophic point of view, be explained in materialistic terms. + +There is, therefore, no logical connection either way between +philosophic materialism and what is called the "materialistic +conception of history." + +It is of some moment to realize such facts as this, because otherwise +political theories are both supported and opposed for quite +irrelevant reasons, and arguments of theoretical philosophy are +employed to determine questions which depend upon concrete facts of +human nature. This mixture damages both philosophy and politics, and +is therefore important to avoid. + +For another reason, also, the attempt to base a political theory upon +a philosophical doctrine is undesirable. The philosophical doctrine of +materialism, if true at all, is true everywhere and always; we cannot +expect exceptions to it, say, in Buddhism or in the Hussite movement. +And so it comes about that people whose politics are supposed to be a +consequence of their metaphysics grow absolute and sweeping, unable to +admit that a general theory of history is likely, at best, to be only +true on the whole and in the main. The dogmatic character of Marxian +Communism finds support in the supposed philosophic basis of the +doctrine; it has the fixed certainty of Catholic theology, not the +changing fluidity and sceptical practicality of modern science. + +Treated as a practical approximation, not as an exact metaphysical +law, the materialistic conception of history has a very large measure +of truth. Take, as an instance of its truth, the influence of +industrialism upon ideas. It is industrialism, rather than the +arguments of Darwinians and Biblical critics, that has led to the +decay of religious belief in the urban working class. At the same +time, industrialism has revived religious belief among the rich. In +the eighteenth century French aristocrats mostly became free-thinkers; +now their descendants are mostly Catholics, because it has become +necessary for all the forces of reaction to unite against the +revolutionary proletariat. Take, again, the emancipation of women. +Plato, Mary Wolstonecraft, and John Stuart Mill produced admirable +arguments, but influenced only a few impotent idealists. The war came, +leading to the employment of women in industry on a large scale, and +instantly the arguments in favour of votes for women were seen to be +irresistible. More than that, traditional sexual morality collapsed, +because its whole basis was the economic dependence of women upon +their fathers and husbands. Changes in such a matter as sexual +morality bring with them profound alterations in the thoughts and +feelings of ordinary men and women; they modify law, literature, art, +and all kinds of institutions that seem remote from economics. + +Such facts as these justify Marxians in speaking, as they do, of +"bourgeois ideology," meaning that kind of morality which has been +imposed upon the world by the possessors of capital. Contentment with +one's lot may be taken as typical of the virtues preached by the rich +to the poor. They honestly believe it is a virtue--at any rate they +did formerly. The more religious among the poor also believed it, +partly from the influence of authority, partly from an impulse to +submission, what MacDougall calls "negative self-feeling," which is +commoner than some people think. Similarly men preached the virtue of +female chastity, and women usually accepted their teaching; both +really believed the doctrine, but its persistence was only possible +through the economic power of men. This led erring women to punishment +here on earth, which made further punishment hereafter seem probable. +When the economic penalty ceased, the conviction of sinfulness +gradually decayed. In such changes we see the collapse of "bourgeois +ideology." + +But in spite of the fundamental importance of economic facts in +determining the politics and beliefs of an age or nation, I do not +think that non-economic factors can be neglected without risks of +errors which may be fatal in practice. + +The most obvious non-economic factor, and the one the neglect of which +has led Socialists most astray, is nationalism. Of course a nation, +once formed, has economic interests which largely determine its +politics; but it is not, as a rule, economic motives that decide what +group of human beings shall form a nation. Trieste, before the war, +considered itself Italian, although its whole prosperity as a port +depended upon its belonging to Austria. No economic motive can account +for the opposition between Ulster and the rest of Ireland. In Eastern +Europe, the Balkanization produced by self-determination has been +obviously disastrous from an economic point of view, and was demanded +for reasons which were in essence sentimental. Throughout the war +wage-earners, with only a few exceptions, allowed themselves to be +governed by nationalist feeling, and ignored the traditional Communist +exhortation: "Workers of the world, unite." According to Marxian +orthodoxy, they were misled by cunning capitalists, who made their +profit out of the slaughter. But to any one capable of observing +psychological facts, it is obvious that this is largely a myth. +Immense numbers of capitalists were ruined by the war; those who were +young were just as liable to be killed as the proletarians were. No +doubt commercial rivalry between England and Germany had a great deal +to do with causing the war; but rivalry is a different thing from +profit-seeking. Probably by combination English and German capitalists +could have made more than they did out of rivalry, but the rivalry +was instinctive, and its economic form was accidental. The capitalists +were in the grip of nationalist instinct as much as their proletarian +"dupes." In both classes some have gained by the war; but the +universal will to war was not produced by the hope of gain. It was +produced by a different set of instincts, and one which Marxian +psychology fails to recognize adequately. + +The Marxian assumes that a man's "herd," from the point of view of +herd-instinct, is his class, and that he will combine with those whose +economic class-interest is the same as his. This is only very +partially true in fact. Religion has been the most decisive factor in +determining a man's herd throughout long periods of the world's +history. Even now a Catholic working man will vote for a Catholic +capitalist rather than for an unbelieving Socialist. In America the +divisions in local elections are mainly on religious lines. This is no +doubt convenient for the capitalists, and tends to make them religious +men; but the capitalists alone could not produce the result. The +result is produced by the fact that many working men prefer the +advancement of their creed to the improvement of their livelihood. +However deplorable such a state of mind may be, it is not necessarily +due to capitalist lies. + +All politics are governed by human desires. The materialist theory of +history, in the last analysis, requires the assumption that every +politically conscious person is governed by one single desire--the +desire to increase his own share of commodities; and, further, that +his method of achieving this desire will usually be to seek to +increase the share of his class, not only his own individual share. +But this assumption is very far from the truth. Men desire power, they +desire satisfactions for their pride and their self-respect. They +desire victory over rivals so profoundly that they will invent a +rivalry for the unconscious purpose of making a victory possible. All +these motives cut across the pure economic motive in ways that are +practically important. + +There is need of a treatment of political motives by the methods of +psycho-analysis. In politics, as in private life, men invent myths to +rationalize their conduct. If a man thinks that the only reasonable +motive in politics is economic self-advancement, he will persuade +himself that the things he wishes to do will make him rich. When he +wants to fight the Germans, he tells himself that their competition is +ruining his trade. If, on the other hand, he is an "idealist," who +holds that his politics should aim at the advancement of the human +race, he will tell himself that the crimes of the Germans demand +their humiliation. The Marxian sees through this latter camouflage, +but not through the former. To desire one's own economic advancement +is comparatively reasonable; to Marx, who inherited eighteenth-century +rationalist psychology from the British orthodox economists, +self-enrichment seemed the natural aim of a man's political actions. +But modern psychology has dived much deeper into the ocean of insanity +upon which the little barque of human reason insecurely floats. The +intellectual optimism of a bygone age is no longer possible to the +modern student of human nature. Yet it lingers in Marxism, making +Marxians rigid and Procrustean in their treatment of the life of +instinct. Of this rigidity the materialistic conception of history is +a prominent instance. + +In the next chapter I shall attempt to outline a political psychology +which seems to me more nearly true than that of Marx. + + + + +II + +DECIDING FORCES IN POLITICS + + +The larger events in the political life of the world are determined by +the interaction of material conditions and human passions. The +operation of the passions on the material conditions is modified by +intelligence. The passions themselves may be modified by alien +intelligence guided by alien passions. So far, such modification has +been wholly unscientific, but it may in time become as precise as +engineering. + +The classification of the passions which is most convenient in +political theory is somewhat different from that which would be +adopted in psychology. + +We may begin with desires for the necessaries of life: food, drink, +sex, and (in cold climates) clothing and housing. When these are +threatened, there is no limit to the activity and violence that men +will display. + +Planted upon these primitive desires are a number of secondary +desires. Love of property, of which the fundamental political +importance is obvious, may be derived historically and psychologically +from the hoarding instinct. Love of the good opinion of others (which +we may call vanity) is a desire which man shares with many animals; it +is perhaps derivable from courtship, but has great survival value, +among gregarious animals, in regard to others besides possible mates. +Rivalry and love of power are perhaps developments of jealousy; they +are akin, but not identical. + +These four passions--acquisitiveness, vanity, rivalry, and love of +power--are, after the basic instincts, the prime movers of almost all +that happens in politics. Their operation is intensified and +regularized by herd instinct. But herd instinct, by its very nature, +cannot be a prime mover, since it merely causes the herd to act in +unison, without determining what the united action is to be. Among +men, as among other gregarious animals, the united action, in any +given circumstances, is determined partly by the common passions of +the herd, partly by imitation of leaders. The art of politics consists +in causing the latter to prevail over the former. + +Of the four passions we have enumerated, only one, namely +acquisitiveness, is concerned at all directly with men's relations to +their material conditions. The other three--vanity, rivalry, and love +of power--are concerned with social relations. I think this is the +source of what is erroneous in the Marxian interpretation of history, +which tacitly assumes that acquisitiveness is the source of all +political actions. It is clear that many men willingly forego wealth +for the sake of power and glory, and that nations habitually sacrifice +riches to rivalry with other nations. The desire for some form of +superiority is common to almost all energetic men. No social system +which attempts to thwart it can be stable, since the lazy majority +will never be a match for the energetic minority. + +What is called "virtue" is an offshoot of vanity: it is the habit of +acting in a manner which others praise. + +The operation of material conditions may be illustrated by the +statement (Myers's _Dawn of History_) that four of the greatest +movements of conquest have been due to drought in Arabia, causing the +nomads of that country to migrate into regions already inhabited. The +last of these four movements was the rise of Islam. In these four +cases, the primal need of food and drink was enough to set events in +motion; but as this need could only be satisfied by conquest, the four +secondary passions must have very soon come into play. In the +conquests of modern industrialism, the secondary passions have been +almost wholly dominant, since those who directed them had no need to +fear hunger or thirst. It is the potency of vanity and love of power +that gives hope for the industrial future of Soviet Russia, since it +enables the Communist State to enlist in its service men whose +abilities might give them vast wealth in a capitalistic society. + +Intelligence modifies profoundly the operation of material conditions. +When America was first discovered, men only desired gold and silver; +consequently the portions first settled were not those that are now +most profitable. The Bessemer process created the German iron and +steel industry; inventions requiring oil have created a demand for +that commodity which is one of the chief influences in international +politics. + +The intelligence which has this profound effect on politics is not +political, but scientific and technical: it is the kind of +intelligence which discovers how to make nature minister to human +passions. Tungsten had no value until it was found to be useful in the +manufacture of shells and electric light, but now people will, if +necessary, kill each other in order to acquire tungsten. Scientific +intelligence is the cause of this change. + +The progress or retrogression of the world depends, broadly speaking, +upon the balance between acquisitiveness and rivalry. The former makes +for progress, the latter for retrogression. When intelligence provides +improved methods of production, these may be employed to increase the +general share of goods, or to set apart more of the labour power of +the community for the business of killing its rivals. Until 1914, +acquisitiveness had prevailed, on the whole, since the fall of +Napoleon; the past six years have seen a prevalence of the instinct of +rivalry. Scientific intelligence makes it possible to indulge this +instinct more fully than is possible for primitive peoples, since it +sets free more men from the labour of producing necessaries. It is +possible that scientific intelligence may, in time, reach the point +when it will enable rivalry to exterminate the human race. This is the +most hopeful method of bringing about an end of war. + +For those who do not like this method, there is another: the study of +scientific psychology and physiology. The physiological causes of +emotions have begun to be known, through the studies of such men as +Cannon (_Bodily Changes in Pain, Hunger, Fear and Rage_). In time, it +may become possible, by physiological means, to alter the whole +emotional nature of a population. It will then depend upon the +passions of the rulers how this power is used. Success will come to +the State which discovers how to promote pugnacity to the extent +required for external war, but not to the extent which would lead to +domestic dissensions. There is no method by which it can be insured +that rulers shall desire the good of mankind, and therefore there is +no reason to suppose that the power to modify men's emotional nature +would cause progress. + +If men desired to diminish rivalry, there is an obvious method. Habits +of power intensify the passion of rivalry; therefore a State in which +power is concentrated will, other things being equal, be more +bellicose than one in which power is diffused. For those who dislike +wars, this is an additional argument against all forms of +dictatorship. But dislike of war is far less common than we used to +suppose; and those who like war can use the same argument to support +dictatorship. + + + + +III + +BOLSHEVIK CRITICISM OF DEMOCRACY + + +The Bolshevik argument against Parliamentary democracy as a method of +achieving Socialism is a powerful one. My answer to it lies rather in +pointing out what I believe to be fallacies in the Bolshevik method, +from which I conclude that no swift method exists of establishing any +desirable form of Socialism. But let us first see what the Bolshevik +argument is. + +In the first place, it assumes that those to whom it is addressed are +absolutely certain that Communism is desirable, so certain that they +are willing, if necessary, to force it upon an unwilling population at +the point of the bayonet. It then proceeds to argue that, while +capitalism retains its hold over propaganda and its means of +corruption, Parliamentary methods are very unlikely to give a majority +for Communism in the House of Commons, or to lead to effective action +by such a majority even if it existed. Communists point out how the +people are deceived, and how their chosen leaders have again and +again betrayed them. From this they argue that the destruction of +capitalism must be sudden and catastrophic; that it must be the work +of a minority; and that it cannot be effected constitutionally or +without violence. It is therefore, in their view, the duty of the +Communist party in a capitalist country to prepare for armed conflict, +and to take all possible measure for disarming the bourgeoisie and +arming that part of the proletariat which is willing to support the +Communists. + +There is an air of realism and disillusionment about this position, +which makes it attractive to those idealists who wish to think +themselves cynics. But I think there are various points in which it +fails to be as realistic as it pretends. + +In the first place, it makes much of the treachery of Labour leaders +in constitutional movements, but does not consider the possibility of +the treachery of Communist leaders in a revolution. To this the +Marxian would reply that in constitutional movements men are bought, +directly or indirectly, by the money of the capitalists, but that +revolutionary Communism would leave the capitalists no money with +which to attempt corruption. This has been achieved in Russia, and +could be achieved elsewhere. But selling oneself to the capitalists +is not the only possible form of treachery. It is also possible, +having acquired power, to use it for one's own ends instead of for the +people. This is what I believe to be likely to happen in Russia: the +establishment of a bureaucratic aristocracy, concentrating authority +in its own hands, and creating a régime just as oppressive and cruel +as that of capitalism. Marxians never sufficiently recognize that love +of power is quite as strong a motive, and quite as great a source of +injustice, as love of money; yet this must be obvious to any unbiased +student of politics. It is also obvious that the method of violent +revolution leading to a minority dictatorship is one peculiarly +calculated to create habits of despotism which would survive the +crisis by which they were generated. Communist politicians are likely +to become just like the politicians of other parties: a few will be +honest, but the great majority will merely cultivate the art of +telling a plausible tale with a view to tricking the people into +entrusting them with power. The only possible way by which politicians +as a class can be improved is the political and psychological +education of the people, so that they may learn to detect a humbug. In +England men have reached the point of suspecting a good speaker, but +if a man speaks badly they think he must be honest. Unfortunately, +virtue is not so widely diffused as this theory would imply. + +In the second place, it is assumed by the Communist argument that, +although capitalist propaganda can prevent the majority from becoming +Communists, yet capitalist laws and police forces cannot prevent the +Communists, while still a minority, from acquiring a supremacy of +military power. It is thought that secret propaganda can undermine the +army and navy, although it is admittedly impossible to get the +majority to vote at elections for the programme of the Bolsheviks. +This view is based upon Russian experience, where the army and navy +had suffered defeat and had been brutally ill used by incompetent +Tsarist authorities. The argument has no application to more efficient +and successful States. Among the Germans, even in defeat, it was the +civilian population that began the revolution. + +There is a further assumption in the Bolshevik argument which seems to +me quite unwarrantable. It is assumed that the capitalist governments +will have learned nothing from the experience of Russia. Before the +Russian Revolution, governments had not studied Bolshevik theory. And +defeat in war created a revolutionary mood throughout Central and +Eastern Europe. But now the holders of power are on their guard. There +seems no reason whatever to suppose that they will supinely permit a +preponderance of armed force to pass into the hands of those who wish +to overthrow them, while, according to the Bolshevik theory, they are +still sufficiently popular to be supported by a majority at the polls. +Is it not as clear as noonday that in a democratic country it is more +difficult for the proletariat to destroy the Government by arms than +to defeat it in a general election? Seeing the immense advantages of a +Government in dealing with rebels, it seems clear that rebellion could +have little hope of success unless a very large majority supported it. +Of course, if the army and navy were specially revolutionary, they +might effect an unpopular revolution; but this situation, though +something like it occurred in Russia, is hardly to be expected in the +Western nations. This whole Bolshevik theory of revolution by a +minority is one which might just conceivably have succeeded as a +secret plot, but becomes impossible as soon as it is openly avowed and +advocated. + +But perhaps it will be said that I am caricaturing the Bolshevik +doctrine of revolution. It is urged by advocates of this doctrine, +quite truly, that all political events are brought about by +minorities, since the majority are indifferent to politics. But there +is a difference between a minority in which the indifferent acquiesce, +and a minority so hated as to startle the indifferent into belated +action. To make the Bolshevik doctrine reasonable, it is necessary to +suppose that they believe the majority can be induced to acquiesce, at +least temporarily, in the revolution made by the class-conscious +minority. This, again, is based upon Russian experience: desire for +peace and land led to a widespread support of the Bolsheviks in +November 1917 on the part of people who have subsequently shown no +love for Communism. + +I think we come here to an essential part of Bolshevik philosophy. In +the moment of revolution, Communists are to have some popular cry by +which they win more support than mere Communism could win. Having thus +acquired the State machine, they are to use it for their own ends. But +this, again, is a method which can only be practised successfully so +long as it is not avowed. It is to some extent habitual in politics. +The Unionists in 1900 won a majority on the Boer War, and used it to +endow brewers and Church schools. The Liberals in 1906 won a majority +on Chinese labour, and used it to cement the secret alliance with +France and to make an alliance with Tsarist Russia. President Wilson, +in 1916, won his majority on neutrality, and used it to come into the +war. This method is part of the stock-in-trade of democracy. But its +success depends upon repudiating it until the moment comes to practise +it. Those who, like the Bolsheviks, have the honesty to proclaim in +advance their intention of using power for other ends than those for +which it was given them, are not likely to have a chance of carrying +out their designs. + +What seems to me to emerge from these considerations is this: That in +a democratic and politically educated country, armed revolution in +favour of Communism would have no chance of succeeding unless it were +supported by a larger majority than would be required for the election +of a Communist Government by constitutional methods. It is possible +that, if such a Government came into existence, and proceeded to carry +out its programme, it would be met by armed resistance on the part of +capital, including a large proportion of the officers in the army and +navy. But in subduing this resistance it would have the support of +that great body of opinion which believes in legality and upholds the +constitution. Moreover, having, by hypothesis, converted a majority of +the nation, a Communist Government could be sure of loyal help from +immense numbers of workers, and would not be forced, as the +Bolsheviks are in Russia, to suspect treachery everywhere. Under these +circumstances, I believe that the resistance of the capitalists could +be quelled without much difficulty, and would receive little support +from moderate people. Whereas, in a minority revolt of Communists +against a capitalist Government, all moderate opinion would be on the +side of capitalism. + +The contention that capitalist propaganda is what prevents the +adoption of Communism by wage-earners is only very partially true. +Capitalist propaganda has never been able to prevent the Irish from +voting against the English, though it has been applied to this object +with great vigour. It has proved itself powerless, over and over +again, in opposing nationalist movements which had almost no moneyed +support. It has been unable to cope with religious feeling. And those +industrial populations which would most obviously benefit by Socialism +have, in the main, adopted it, in spite of the opposition of +employers. The plain truth is that Socialism does not arouse the same +passionate interest in the average citizen as is roused by nationality +and used to be roused by religion. It is not unlikely that things may +change in this respect: we may be approaching a period of economic +civil wars comparable to that of the religious civil wars that +followed the Reformation. In such a period, nationalism is submerged +by party: British and German Socialists, or British and German +capitalists, will feel more kinship with each other than with +compatriots of the opposite political camp. But when that day comes, +there will be no difficulty, in highly industrial countries, in +securing Socialist majorities; if Socialism is not then carried +without bloodshed, it will be due to the unconstitutional action of +the rich, not to the need of revolutionary violence on the part of the +advocates of the proletariat. Whether such a state of opinion grows up +or not depends mainly upon the stubbornness or conciliatoriness of the +possessing classes, and, conversely, upon the moderation or violence +of those who desire fundamental economic change. The majority which +Bolsheviks regard as unattainable is chiefly prevented by the +ruthlessness of their own tactics. + +Apart from all arguments of detail, there are two broad objections to +violent revolution in a democratic community. The first is that, when +once the principle of respecting majorities as expressed at the +ballot-box is abandoned, there is no reason to suppose that victory +will be secured by the particular minority to which one happens to +belong. There are many minorities besides Communists: religious +minorities, teetotal minorities, militarist minorities, capitalist +minorities. Any one of these could adopt the method of obtaining power +advocated by the Bolsheviks, and any one would be just as likely to +succeed as they are. What restrains these minorities, more or less, at +present, is respect for the law and the constitution. Bolsheviks +tacitly assume that every other party will preserve this respect while +they themselves, unhindered, prepare the revolution. But if their +philosophy of violence becomes popular, there is not the slightest +reason to suppose that they will be its beneficiaries. They believe +that Communism is for the good of the majority; they ought to believe +that they can persuade the majority on this question, and to have the +patience to set about the task of winning by propaganda. + +The second argument of principle against the method of minority +violence is that abandonment of law, when it becomes widespread, lets +loose the wild beast, and gives a free rein to the primitive lusts and +egoisms which civilization in some degree curbs. Every student of +mediæval thought must have been struck by the extraordinarily high +value placed upon law in that period. The reason was that, in +countries infested by robber barons, law was the first requisite of +progress. We, in the modern world, take it for granted that most +people will be law-abiding, and we hardly realize what centuries of +effort have gone to making such an assumption possible. We forget how +many of the good things that we unquestionably expect would disappear +out of life if murder, rape, and robbery with violence became common. +And we forget even more how very easily this might happen. The +universal class-war foreshadowed by the Third International, following +upon the loosening of restraints produced by the late war, and +combined with a deliberate inculcation of disrespect for law and +constitutional government, might, and I believe would, produce a state +of affairs in which it would be habitual to murder men for a crust of +bread, and in which women would only be safe while armed men protected +them. The civilized nations have accepted democratic government as a +method of settling internal disputes without violence. Democratic +government may have all the faults attributed to it, but it has the +one great merit that people are, on the whole, willing to accept it as +a substitute for civil war in political disputes. Whoever sets to work +to weaken this acceptance, whether in Ulster or in Moscow, is taking a +fearful responsibility. Civilization is not so stable that it cannot +be broken up; and a condition of lawless violence is not one out of +which any good thing is likely to emerge. For this reason, if for no +other, revolutionary violence in a democracy is infinitely dangerous. + + + + +IV + +REVOLUTION AND DICTATORSHIP + + +The Bolsheviks have a very definite programme for achieving +Communism--a programme which has been set forth by Lenin repeatedly, +and quite recently in the reply of the Third International to the +questionnaire submitted by the Independent Labour Party. + +Capitalists, we are assured, will stick at nothing in defence of their +privileges. It is the nature of man, in so far as he is politically +conscious, to fight for the interests of his class so long as classes +exist. When the conflict is not pushed to extremes, methods of +conciliation and political deception may be preferable to actual +physical warfare; but as soon as the proletariat make a really vital +attack upon the capitalists, they will be met by guns and bayonets. +This being certain and inevitable, it is as well to be prepared for +it, and to conduct propaganda accordingly. Those who pretend that +pacific methods can lead to the realization of Communism are false +friends to the wage-earners; intentionally or unintentionally, they +are covert allies of the bourgeoisie. + +There must, then, according to Bolshevik theory, be armed conflict +sooner or later, if the injustices of the present economic system are +ever to be remedied. Not only do they assume armed conflict: they have +a fairly definite conception of the way in which it is to be +conducted. This conception has been carried out in Russia, and is to +be carried out, before very long, in every civilized country. The +Communists, who represent the class-conscious wage-earners, wait for +some propitious moment when events have caused a mood of revolutionary +discontent with the existing Government. They then put themselves at +the head of the discontent, carry through a successful revolution, and +in so doing acquire the arms, the railways, the State treasure, and +all the other resources upon which the power of modern Governments is +built. They then confine political power to Communists, however small +a minority they may be of the whole nation. They set to work to +increase their number by propaganda and the control of education. And +meanwhile, they introduce Communism into every department of economic +life as quickly as possible. + +Ultimately, after a longer or shorter period, according to +circumstances, the nation will be converted to Communism, the relics +of capitalist institutions will have been obliterated, and it will be +possible to restore freedom. But the political conflicts to which we +are accustomed will not reappear. All the burning political questions +of our time, according to the Communists, are questions of class +conflict, and will disappear when the division of classes disappears. +Accordingly the State will no longer be required, since the State is +essentially an engine of power designed to give the victory to one +side in the class conflict. Ordinary States are designed to give the +victory to the capitalists; the proletarian State (Soviet Russia) is +designed to give the victory to the wage-earners. As soon as the +community contains only wage-earners, the State will cease to have any +functions. And so, through a period of dictatorship, we shall finally +arrive at a condition very similar to that aimed at by Anarchist +Communism. + +Three questions arise in regard to this method of reaching Utopia. +First, would the ultimate state foreshadowed by the Bolsheviks be +desirable in itself? Secondly, would the conflict involved in +achieving it by the Bolshevik method be so bitter and prolonged that +its evils would outweigh the ultimate good? Thirdly, is this method +likely to lead, in the end, to the state which the Bolsheviks desire, +or will it fail at some point and arrive at a quite different result? +If we are to be Bolsheviks, we must answer all these questions in a +sense favourable to their programme. + +As regards the first question, I have no hesitation in answering it in +a manner favourable to Communism. It is clear that the present +inequalities of wealth are unjust. In part, they may be defended as +affording an incentive to useful industry, but I do not think this +defence will carry us very far. However, I have argued this question +before in my book on _Roads to Freedom_, and I will not spend time +upon it now. On this matter, I concede the Bolshevik case. It is the +other two questions that I wish to discuss. + +Our second question was: Is the ultimate good aimed at by the +Bolsheviks sufficiently great to be worth the price that, according to +their own theory, will have to be paid for achieving it? + +If anything human were absolutely certain, we might answer this +question affirmatively with some confidence. The benefits of +Communism, if it were once achieved, might be expected to be lasting; +we might legitimately hope that further change would be towards +something still better, not towards a revival of ancient evils. But if +we admit, as we must do, that the outcome of the Communist revolution +is in some degree uncertain, it becomes necessary to count the cost; +for a great part of the cost is all but certain. + +Since the revolution of October, 1917, the Soviet Government has been +at war with almost all the world, and has had at the same time to face +civil war at home. This is not to be regarded as accidental, or as a +misfortune which could not be foreseen. According to Marxian theory, +what has happened was bound to happen. Indeed, Russia has been +wonderfully fortunate in not having to face an even more desperate +situation. First and foremost, the world was exhausted by the war, and +in no mood for military adventures. Next, the Tsarist régime was the +worst in Europe, and therefore rallied less support than would be +secured by any other capitalist Government. Again, Russia is vast and +agricultural, making it capable of resisting both invasion and +blockade better than Great Britain or France or Germany. The only +other country that could have resisted with equal success is the +United States, which is at present very far removed from a proletarian +revolution, and likely long to remain the chief bulwark of the +capitalist system. It is evident that Great Britain, attempting a +similar revolution, would be forced by starvation to yield within a +few months, provided America led a policy of blockade. The same is +true, though in a less degree, of continental countries. Therefore, +unless and until an international Communist revolution becomes +possible, we must expect that any other nation following Russia's +example will have to pay an even higher price than Russia has had to +pay. + +Now the price that Russia is having to pay is very great. The almost +universal poverty might be thought to be a small evil in comparison +with the ultimate gain, but it brings with it other evils of which the +magnitude would be acknowledged even by those who have never known +poverty and therefore make light of it. Hunger brings an absorption in +the question of food, which, to most people, makes life almost purely +animal. The general shortage makes people fierce, and reacts upon the +political atmosphere. The necessity of inculcating Communism produces +a hot-house condition, where every breath of fresh air must be +excluded: people are to be taught to think in a certain way, and all +free intelligence becomes taboo. The country comes to resemble an +immensely magnified Jesuit College. Every kind of liberty is banned as +being "_bourgeois_"; but it remains a fact that intelligence +languishes where thought is not free. + +All this, however, according to the leaders of the Third +International, is only a small beginning of the struggle, which must +become world-wide before it achieves victory. In their reply to the +Independent Labour Party they say: + + It is probable that upon the throwing off of the chains of the + capitalist Governments, the revolutionary proletariat of + Europe will meet the resistance of Anglo-Saxon capital in the + persons of British and American capitalists who will attempt + to blockade it. It is then possible that the revolutionary + proletariat of Europe will rise in union with the peoples of + the East and commence a revolutionary struggle, the scene of + which will be the entire world, to deal a final blow to + British and American capitalism (_The Times_, July 30, 1920). + +The war here prophesied, if it ever takes place, will be one compared +to which the late war will come to seem a mere affair of outposts. +Those who realize the destructiveness of the late war, the devastation +and impoverishment, the lowering of the level of civilization +throughout vast areas, the general increase of hatred and savagery, +the letting loose of bestial instincts which had been curbed during +peace--those who realize all this will hesitate to incur inconceivably +greater horrors, even if they believe firmly that Communism in itself +is much to be desired. An economic system cannot be considered apart +from the population which is to carry it out; and the population +resulting from such a world-war as Moscow calmly contemplates would +be savage, bloodthirsty and ruthless to an extent that must make any +system a mere engine of oppression and cruelty. + +This brings us to our third question: Is the system which Communists +regard as their goal likely to result from the adoption of their +methods? This is really the most vital question of the three. + +Advocacy of Communism by those who believe in Bolshevik methods rests +upon the assumption that there is no slavery except economic slavery, +and that when all goods are held in common there must be perfect +liberty. I fear this is a delusion. + +There must be administration, there must be officials who control +distribution. These men, in a Communist State, are the repositories of +power. So long as they control the army, they are able, as in Russia +at this moment, to wield despotic power even if they are a small +minority. The fact that there is Communism--to a certain extent--does +not mean that there is liberty. If the Communism were more complete, +it would not necessarily mean more freedom; there would still be +certain officials in control of the food supply, and these officials +could govern as they pleased so long as they retained the support of +the soldiers. This is not mere theory: it is the patent lesson of the +present condition of Russia. The Bolshevik theory is that a small +minority are to seize power, and are to hold it until Communism is +accepted practically universally, which, they admit, may take a long +time. But power is sweet, and few men surrender it voluntarily. It is +especially sweet to those who have the habit of it, and the habit +becomes most ingrained in those who have governed by bayonets, without +popular support. Is it not almost inevitable that men placed as the +Bolsheviks are placed in Russia, and as they maintain that the +Communists must place themselves wherever the social revolution +succeeds, will be loath to relinquish their monopoly of power, and +will find reasons for remaining until some new revolution ousts them? +Would it not be fatally easy for them, without altering economic +structure, to decree large salaries for high Government officials, and +so reintroduce the old inequalities of wealth? What motive would they +have for not doing so? What motive is possible except idealism, love +of mankind, non-economic motives of the sort that Bolsheviks decry? +The system created by violence and the forcible rule of a minority +must necessarily allow of tyranny and exploitation; and if human +nature is what Marxians assert it to be, why should the rulers +neglect such opportunities of selfish advantage? + +It is sheer nonsense to pretend that the rulers of a great empire such +as Soviet Russia, when they have become accustomed to power, retain +the proletarian psychology, and feel that their class-interest is the +same as that of the ordinary working man. This is not the case in fact +in Russia now, however the truth may be concealed by fine phrases. The +Government has a class-consciousness and a class-interest quite +distinct from those of the genuine proletarian, who is not to be +confounded with the paper proletarian of the Marxian schema. In a +capitalist state, the Government and the capitalists on the whole hang +together, and form one class; in Soviet Russia, the Government has +absorbed the capitalist mentality together with the governmental, and +the fusion has given increased strength to the upper class. But I see +no reason whatever to expect equality or freedom to result from such a +system, except reasons derived from a false psychology and a mistaken +analysis of the sources of political power. + +I am compelled to reject Bolshevism for two reasons: First, because +the price mankind must pay to achieve Communism by Bolshevik methods +is too terrible; and secondly because, even after paying the price, I +do not believe the result would be what the Bolsheviks profess to +desire. + +But if their methods are rejected, how are we ever to arrive at a +better economic system? This is not an easy question, and I shall +treat it in a separate chapter. + + + + +V + +MECHANISM AND THE INDIVIDUAL + + +Is it possible to effect a fundamental reform of the existing economic +system by any other method than that of Bolshevism? The difficulty of +answering this question is what chiefly attracts idealists to the +dictatorship of the proletariat. If, as I have argued, the method of +violent revolution and Communist rule is not likely to have the +results which idealists desire, we are reduced to despair unless we +can see hope in other methods. The Bolshevik arguments against all +other methods are powerful. I confess that, when the spectacle of +present-day Russia forced me to disbelieve in Bolshevik methods, I was +at first unable to see any way of curing the essential evils of +capitalism. My first impulse was to abandon political thinking as a +bad job, and to conclude that the strong and ruthless must always +exploit the weaker and kindlier sections of the population. But this +is not an attitude that can be long maintained by any vigorous and +temperamentally hopeful person. Of course, if it were the truth, one +would have to acquiesce. Some people believe that by living on sour +milk one can achieve immortality. Such optimists are answered by a +mere refutation; it is not necessary to go on and point out some other +way of escaping death. Similarly an argument that Bolshevism will not +lead to the millennium would remain valid even if it could be shown +that the millennium cannot be reached by any other road. But the truth +in social questions is not quite like truth in physiology or physics, +since it depends upon men's beliefs. Optimism tends to verify itself +by making people impatient of avoidable evils; while despair, on the +other hand, makes the world as bad as it believes it to be. It is +therefore imperative for those who do not believe in Bolshevism to put +some other hope in its place. + +I think there are two things that must be admitted: first, that many +of the worst evils of capitalism might survive under Communism; +secondly, that the cure for these evils cannot be sudden, since it +requires changes in the average mentality. + +What are the chief evils of the present system? I do not think that +mere inequality of wealth, in itself, is a very grave evil. If +everybody had enough, the fact that some have more than enough would +be unimportant. With a very moderate improvement in methods of +production, it would be easy to ensure that everybody should have +enough, even under capitalism, if wars and preparations for wars were +abolished. The problem of poverty is by no means insoluble within the +existing system, except when account is taken of psychological factors +and the uneven distribution of power. + +The graver evils of the capitalist system all arise from its uneven +distribution of power. The possessors of capital wield an influence +quite out of proportion to their numbers or their services to the +community. They control almost the whole of education and the press; +they decide what the average man shall know or not know; the cinema +has given them a new method of propaganda, by which they enlist the +support of those who are too frivolous even for illustrated papers. +Very little of the intelligence of the world is really free: most of +it is, directly or indirectly, in the pay of business enterprises or +wealthy philanthropists. To satisfy capitalist interests, men are +compelled to work much harder and more monotonously than they ought to +work, and their education is scamped. Wherever, as in barbarous or +semi-civilized countries, labour is too weak or too disorganized to +protect itself, appalling cruelties are practised for private profit. +Economic and political organizations become more and more vast, +leaving less and less room for individual development and initiative. +It is this sacrifice of the individual to the machine that is the +fundamental evil of the modern world. + +To cure this evil is not easy, because efficiency is promoted, at any +given moment, though not in the long run, by sacrificing the +individual to the smooth working of a vast organization, whether +military or industrial. In war and in commercial competition, it is +necessary to control individual impulses, to treat men as so many +"bayonets" or "sabres" or "hands," not as a society of separate people +with separate tastes and capacities. Some sacrifice of individual +impulses is, of course, essential to the existence of an ordered +community, and this degree of sacrifice is, as a rule, not regretable +even from the individual's point of view. But what is demanded in a +highly militarized or industrialized nation goes far beyond this very +moderate degree. A society which is to allow much freedom to the +individual must be strong enough to be not anxious about home defence, +moderate enough to refrain from difficult external conquests, and rich +enough to value leisure and a civilized existence more than an +increase of consumable commodities. + +But where the material conditions for such a state of affairs exist, +the psychological conditions are not likely to exist unless power is +very widely diffused throughout the community. Where power is +concentrated in a few, it will happen, unless those few are very +exceptional people, that they will value tangible achievements in the +way of increase in trade or empire more than the slow and less obvious +improvements that would result from better education combined with +more leisure. The joys of victory are especially great to the holders +of power, while the evils of a mechanical organization fall almost +exclusively upon the less influential. For these reasons, I do not +believe that any community in which power is much concentrated will +long refrain from conflicts of the kind involving a sacrifice of what +is most valuable in the individual. In Russia at this moment, the +sacrifice of the individual is largely inevitable, because of the +severity of the economic and military struggle. But I did not feel, in +the Bolsheviks, any consciousness of the magnitude of this misfortune, +or any realization of the importance of the individual as against the +State. Nor do I believe that men who do realize this are likely to +succeed, or to come to the top, in times when everything has to be +done against personal liberty. The Bolshevik theory requires that +every country, sooner or later, should go through what Russia is going +through now. And in every country in such a condition we may expect to +find the government falling into the hands of ruthless men, who have +not by nature any love for freedom, and who will see little importance +in hastening the transition from dictatorship to freedom. It is far +more likely that such men will be tempted to embark upon new +enterprises, requiring further concentration of forces, and postponing +indefinitely the liberation of the populations which they use as their +material. + +For these reasons, equalization of wealth without equalization of +power seems to me a rather small and unstable achievement. But +equalization of power is not a thing that can be achieved in a day. It +requires a considerable level of moral, intellectual, and technical +education. It requires a long period without extreme crises, in order +that habits of tolerance and good nature may become common. It +requires vigour on the part of those who are acquiring power, without +a too desperate resistance on the part of those whose share is +diminishing. This is only possible if those who are acquiring power +are not very fierce, and do not terrify their opponents by threats of +ruin and death. It cannot be done quickly, because quick methods +require that very mechanism and subordination of the individual which +we should struggle to prevent. + +But even equalization of power is not the whole of what is needed +politically. The right grouping of men for different purposes is also +essential. Self-government in industry, for example, is an +indispensable condition of a good society. Those acts of an individual +or a group which have no very great importance for outsiders ought to +be freely decided by that individual or group. This is recognized as +regards religion, but ought to be recognized over a much wider field. + +Bolshevik theory seems to me to err by concentrating its attention +upon one evil, namely inequality of wealth, which it believes to be at +the bottom of all others. I do not believe any one evil can be thus +isolated, but if I had to select one as the greatest of political +evils, I should select inequality of power. And I should deny that +this is likely to be cured by the class-war and the dictatorship of +the Communist party. Only peace and a long period of gradual +improvement can bring it about. + +Good relations between individuals, freedom from hatred and violence +and oppression, general diffusion of education, leisure rationally +employed, the progress of art and science--these seem to me among the +most important ends that a political theory ought to have in view. I +do not believe that they can be furthered, except very rarely, by +revolution and war; and I am convinced that at the present moment they +can only be promoted by a diminution in the spirit of ruthlessness +generated by the war. For these reasons, while admitting the necessity +and even utility of Bolshevism in Russia, I do not wish to see it +spread, or to encourage the adoption of its philosophy by advanced +parties in the Western nations. + + + + +VI + +WHY RUSSIAN COMMUNISM HAS FAILED + + +The civilized world seems almost certain, sooner or later, to follow +the example of Russia in attempting a Communist organization of +society. I believe that the attempt is essential to the progress and +happiness of mankind during the next few centuries, but I believe also +that the transition has appalling dangers. I believe that, if the +Bolshevik theory as to the method of transition is adopted by +Communists in Western nations, the result will be a prolonged chaos, +leading neither to Communism nor to any other civilized system, but to +a relapse into the barbarism of the Dark Ages. In the interests of +Communism, no less than in the interests of civilization, I think it +imperative that the Russian failure should be admitted and analysed. +For this reason, if for no other, I cannot enter into the conspiracy +of concealment which many Western Socialists who have visited Russia +consider necessary. + +I shall try first to recapitulate the facts which make me regard the +Russian experiment as a failure, and then to seek out the causes of +failure. + +The most elementary failure in Russia is in regard to food. In a +country which formerly produced a vast exportable surplus of cereals +and other agricultural produce, and in which the non-agricultural +population is only 15 per cent. of the total, it ought to be possible, +without great difficulty, to provide enough food for the towns. Yet +the Government has failed badly in this respect. The rations are +inadequate and irregular, so that it is impossible to preserve health +and vigour without the help of food purchased illicitly in the markets +at speculative prices. I have given reasons for thinking that the +breakdown of transport, though a contributory cause, is not the main +reason for the shortage. The main reason is the hostility of the +peasants, which, in turn, is due to the collapse of industry and to +the policy of forced requisitions. In regard to corn and flour, the +Government requisitions all that the peasant produces above a certain +minimum required for himself and his family. If, instead, it exacted a +fixed amount as rent, it would not destroy his incentive to +production, and would not provide nearly such a strong motive for +concealment. But this plan would have enabled the peasants to grow +rich, and would have involved a confessed abandonment of Communist +theory. It has therefore been thought better to employ forcible +methods, which led to disaster, as they were bound to do. + +The collapse of industry was the chief cause of the food difficulties, +and has in turn been aggravated by them. Owing to the fact that there +is abundant food in the country, industrial and urban workers are +perpetually attempting to abandon their employment for agriculture. +This is illegal, and is severely punished, by imprisonment or convict +labour. Nevertheless it continues, and in so vast a country as Russia +it is not possible to prevent it. Thus the ranks of industry become +still further depleted. + +Except as regards munitions of war, the collapse of industry in Russia +is extraordinarily complete. The resolutions passed by the Ninth +Congress of the Communist Party (April, 1920) speak of "the incredible +catastrophes of public economy." This language is not too strong, +though the recovery of the Baku oil has done something to produce a +revival along the Volga basin. + +The failure of the whole industrial side of the national economy, +including transport, is at the bottom of the other failures of the +Soviet Government. It is, to begin with, the main cause of the +unpopularity of the Communists both in town and country: in town, +because the people are hungry; in the country, because food is taken +with no return except paper. If industry had been prosperous, the +peasants could have had clothes and agricultural machinery, for which +they would have willingly parted with enough food for the needs of the +towns. The town population could then have subsisted in tolerable +comfort; disease could have been coped with, and the general lowering +of vitality averted. It would not have been necessary, as it has been +in many cases, for men of scientific or artistic capacity to abandon +the pursuits in which they were skilled for unskilled manual labour. +The Communist Republic might have been agreeable to live in--at least +for those who had been very poor before. + +The unpopularity of the Bolsheviks, which is primarily due to the +collapse of industry, has in turn been accentuated by the measures +which it has driven the Government to adopt. In view of the fact that +it was impossible to give adequate food to the ordinary population of +Petrograd and Moscow, the Government decided that at any rate the men +employed on important public work should be sufficiently nourished to +preserve their efficiency. It is a gross libel to say that the +Communists, or even the leading People's Commissaries, live luxurious +lives according to our standards; but it is a fact that they are not +exposed, like their subjects, to acute hunger and the weakening of +energy that accompanies it. No tone can blame them for this, since the +work of government must be carried on; but it is one of the ways in +which class distinctions have reappeared where it was intended that +they should be banished. I talked to an obviously hungry working man +in Moscow, who pointed to the Kremlin and remarked: "In there they +have enough to eat." He was expressing a widespread feeling which is +fatal to the idealistic appeal that Communism attempts to make. + +Owing to unpopularity, the Bolsheviks have had to rely upon the army +and the Extraordinary Commission, and have been compelled to reduce +the Soviet system to an empty form. More and more the pretence of +representing the proletariat has grown threadbare. Amid official +demonstrations and processions and meetings the genuine proletarian +looks on, apathetic and disillusioned, unless he is possessed of +unusual energy and fire, in which case he looks to the ideas of +syndicalism or the I.W.W. to liberate him from a slavery far more +complete than that of capitalism. A sweated wage, long hours, +industrial conscription, prohibition of strikes, prison for slackers, +diminution of the already insufficient rations in factories where the +production falls below what the authorities expect, an army of spies +ready to report any tendency to political disaffection and to procure +imprisonment for its promoters--this is the reality of a system which +still professes to govern in the name of the proletariat. + +At the same time the internal and external peril has necessitated the +creation of a vast army recruited by conscription, except as regards a +Communist nucleus, from among a population utterly weary of war, who +put the Bolsheviks in power because they alone promised peace. +Militarism has produced its inevitable result in the way of a harsh +and dictatorial spirit: the men in power go through their day's work +with the consciousness that they command three million armed men, and +that civilian opposition to their will can be easily crushed. + +Out of all this has grown a system painfully like the old government +of the Tsar--a system which is Asiatic in its centralized bureaucracy, +its secret service, its atmosphere of governmental mystery and +submissive terror. In many ways it resembles our Government of India. +Like that Government, it stands for civilization, for education, +sanitation, and Western ideas of progress; it is composed in the main +of honest and hard-working men, who despise those whom they govern, +but believe themselves possessed of something valuable which they +must communicate to the population, however little it may be desired. +Like our Government in India, they live in terror of popular risings, +and are compelled to resort to cruel repressions in order to preserve +their power. Like it, they represent an alien philosophy of life, +which cannot be forced upon the people without a change of instinct, +habit, and tradition so profound as to dry up the vital springs of +action, producing listlessness and despair among the ignorant victims +of militant enlightenment. It may be that Russia needs sternness and +discipline more than anything else; it may be that a revival of Peter +the Great's methods is essential to progress. From this point of view, +much of what it is natural to criticize in the Bolsheviks becomes +defensible; but this point of view has little affinity to Communism. +Bolshevism may be defended, possibly, as a dire discipline through +which a backward nation is to be rapidly industrialized; but as an +experiment in Communism it has failed. + +There are two things that a defender of the Bolsheviks may say against +the argument that they have failed because the present state of Russia +is bad. It may be said that it is too soon to judge, and it may be +urged that whatever failure there has been is attributable to the +hostility of the outside world. + +As to the contention that it is too soon to judge, that is of course +undeniable in a sense. But in a sense it is always too soon to judge +of any historical movement, because its effects and developments go on +for ever. Bolshevism has, no doubt, great changes ahead of it. But the +last three years have afforded material for some judgments, though +more definitive judgments will be possible later. And, for reasons +which I have given in earlier chapters, I find it impossible to +believe that later developments will realize more fully the Communist +ideal. If trade is opened with the outer world, there will be an +almost irresistible tendency to resumption of private enterprise. If +trade is not re-opened, the plans of Asiatic conquest will mature, +leading to a revival of Yenghis Khan and Timur. In neither case is the +purity of the Communist faith likely to survive. + +As for the hostility of the Entente, it is of course true that +Bolshevism might have developed very differently if it had been +treated in a friendly spirit. But in view of its desire to promote +world-revolution, no one could expect--and the Bolsheviks certainly +did not expect--that capitalist Governments would be friendly. If +Germany had won the war, Germany would have shown a hostility more +effective than that of the Entente. However we may blame Western +Governments for their policy, we must realize that, according to the +deterministic economic theory of the Bolsheviks, no other policy was +to be expected from them. Other men might have been excused for not +foreseeing the attitude of Churchill, Clemenceau and Millerand; but +Marxians could not be excused, since this attitude was in exact accord +with their own formula. + +We have seen the symptoms of Bolshevik failure; I come now to the +question of its profounder causes. + +Everything that is worst in Russia we found traceable to the collapse +of industry. Why has industry collapsed so utterly? And would it +collapse equally if a Communist revolution were to occur in a Western +country? + +Russian industry was never highly developed, and depended always upon +outside aid for much of its plant. The hostility of the world, as +embodied in the blockade, left Russia powerless to replace the +machinery and locomotives worn out during the war. The need of +self-defence compelled the Bolsheviks to send their best workmen to +the front, because they were the most reliable Communists, and the +loss of them rendered their factories even more inefficient than they +were under Kerensky. In this respect, and in the laziness and +incapacity of the Russian workman, the Bolsheviks have had to face +special difficulties which would be less in other countries. On the +other hand, they have had special advantages in the fact that Russia +is self-supporting in the matter of food; no other country could have +endured the collapse of industry so long, and no other Great Power +except the United States could have survived years of blockade. + +The hostility of the world was in no way a surprise to those who made +the October revolution; it was in accordance with their general +theory, and its consequences should have been taken into account in +making the revolution. + +Other hostilities besides those of the outside world have been +incurred by the Bolsheviks with open eyes, notably the hostility of +the peasants and that of a great part of the industrial population. +They have attempted, in accordance with their usual contempt for +conciliatory methods, to substitute terror for reward as the incentive +to work. Some amiable Socialists have imagined that, when the private +capitalist had been eliminated, men would work from a sense of +obligation to the community. The Bolsheviks will have none of such +sentimentalism. In one of the resolutions of the ninth Communist +Congress they say: + + Every social system, whether based on slavery, feudalism, or + capitalism, had its ways and means of labour compulsion and + labour education in the interests of the exploiters. + + The Soviet system is faced with the task of developing its + own methods of labour compulsion to attain an increase of the + intensity and wholesomeness of labour; this method is to be + based on the socialization of public economy in the interests + of the whole nation. + + In addition to the propaganda by which the people are to be + influenced and the repressions which are to be applied to all + idlers, parasites and disorganizers who strive to undermine + public zeal--the principal method for the increase of + production will become the introduction of the system of + compulsory labour. + + In capitalist society rivalry assumed the character of + competition and led to the exploitation of man by man. In a + society where the means of production are nationalized, labour + rivalry is to increase the products of labour without + infringing its solidarity. + + Rivalry between factories, regions, guilds, workshops, and + individual workers should become the subject of careful + organization and of close study on the side of the Trade + Unions and the economic organs. + + The system of premiums which is to be introduced should become + one of the most powerful means of exciting rivalry. The system + of rationing of food supply is to get into line with it; so + long as Soviet Russia suffers from insufficiency of + provisions, it is only just that the industrious and + conscientious worker receives more than the careless worker. + +It must be remembered that even the "industrious and conscientious +worker" receives less food than is required to maintain efficiency. + +Over the whole development of Russia and of Bolshevism since the +October revolution there broods a tragic fatality. In spite of outward +success the inner failure has proceeded by inevitable stages--stages +which could, by sufficient acumen, have been foreseen from the first. +By provoking the hostility of the outside world the Bolsheviks were +forced to provoke the hostility of the peasants, and finally the +hostility or utter apathy of the urban and industrial population. +These various hostilities brought material disaster, and material +disaster brought spiritual collapse. The ultimate source of the whole +train of evils lies in the Bolshevik outlook on life: in its dogmatism +of hatred and its belief that human nature can be completely +transformed by force. To injure capitalists is not the ultimate goal +of Communism, though among men dominated by hatred it is the part that +gives zest to their activities. To face the hostility of the world may +show heroism, but it is a heroism for which the country, not its +rulers, has to pay the price. In the principles of Bolshevism there is +more desire to destroy ancient evils than to build up new goods; it is +for this reason that success in destruction has been so much greater +than in construction. The desire to destroy is inspired by hatred, +which is not a constructive principle. From this essential +characteristic of Bolshevik mentality has sprung the willingness to +subject Russia to its present martyrdom. It is only out of a quite +different mentality that a happier world can be created. + +And from this follows a further conclusion. The Bolshevik outlook is +the outcome of the cruelty of the Tsarist régime and the ferocity of +the years of the Great War, operating upon a ruined and starving +nation maddened into universal hatred. If a different mentality is +needed for the establishment of a successful Communism, then a quite +different conjuncture must see its inauguration; men must be persuaded +to the attempt by hope, not driven to it by despair. To bring this +about should be the aim of every Communist who desires the happiness +of mankind more than the punishment of capitalists and their +governmental satellites. + + + + +VII + +CONDITIONS FOR THE SUCCESS OF COMMUNISM + + +The fundamental ideas of Communism are by no means impracticable, and +would, if realized, add immeasurably to the well-being of mankind. The +difficulties which have to be faced are not in regard to the +fundamental ideas, but in regard to the transition from capitalism. It +must be assumed that those who profit by the existing system will +fight to preserve it, and their fight may be sufficiently severe to +destroy all that is best in Communism during the struggle, as well as +everything else that has value in modern civilization. The seriousness +of this problem of transition is illustrated by Russia, and cannot be +met by the methods of the Third International. The Soviet Government, +at the present moment, is anxious to obtain manufactured goods from +capitalist countries, but the Third International is meanwhile +endeavouring to promote revolutions which, if they occurred, would +paralyse the industries of the countries concerned, and leave them +incapable of supplying Russian needs. + +The supreme condition of success in a Communist revolution is that it +should not paralyse industry. If industry is paralysed, the evils +which exist in modern Russia, or others just as great, seem +practically unavoidable. There will be the problem of town and +country, there will be hunger, there will be fierceness and revolts +and military tyranny. All these things follow in a fatal sequence; and +the end of them is almost certain to be something quite different from +what genuine Communists desire. + +If industry is to survive throughout a Communist revolution, a number +of conditions must be fulfilled which are not, at present, fulfilled +anywhere. Consider, for the sake of definiteness, what would happen if +a Communist revolution were to occur in England to-morrow. Immediately +America would place an embargo on all trade with us. The cotton +industry would collapse, leaving about five million of the most +productive portion of the population idle. The food supply would +become inadequate, and would fail disastrously if, as is to be +expected, the Navy were hostile or disorganized by the sabotage of the +officers. The result would be that, unless there were a +counter-revolution, about half the population would die within the +first twelve months. On such a basis it would evidently be impossible +to erect a successful Communist State. + +What applies to England applies, in one form or another, to the +remaining countries of Europe. Italian and German Socialists are, many +of them, in a revolutionary frame of mind and could, if they chose, +raise formidable revolts. They are urged by Moscow to do so, but they +realize that, if they did, England and America would starve them. +France, for many reasons, dare not offend England and America beyond a +point. Thus, in every country except America, a successful Communist +revolution is impossible for economico-political reasons. America, +being self-contained and strong, would be capable, so far as material +conditions go, of achieving a successful revolution; but in America +the psychological conditions are as yet adverse. There is no other +civilized country where capitalism is so strong and revolutionary +Socialism so weak as in America. At the present moment, therefore, +though it is by no means impossible that Communist revolutions may +occur all over the Continent, it is nearly certain that they cannot be +successful in any real sense. They will have to begin by a war against +America, and possibly England, by a paralysis of industry, by +starvation, militarism and the whole attendant train of evils with +which Russia has made us familiar. + +That Communism, whenever and wherever it is adopted, will have to +begin by fighting the bourgeoisie, is highly probable. The important +question is not whether there is to be fighting, but how long and +severe it is to be. A short war, in which Communism won a rapid and +easy victory, would do little harm. It is long, bitter and doubtful +wars that must be avoided if anything of what makes Communism +desirable is to survive. + +Two practical consequences flow from this conclusion: first, that +nothing can succeed until America is either converted to Communism, or +at any rate willing to remain neutral; secondly, that it is a mistake +to attempt to inaugurate Communism in a country where the majority are +hostile, or rather, where the active opponents are as strong as the +active supporters, because in such a state of opinion a very severe +civil war is likely to result. It is necessary to have a great body of +opinion favourable to Communism, and a rather weak opposition, before +a really successful Communist state can be introduced either by +revolution or by more or less constitutional methods. + +It may be assumed that when Communism is first introduced, the higher +technical and business staff will side with the capitalists and +attempt sabotage unless they have no hopes of a counter-revolution. +For this reason it is very necessary that among wage-earners there +should be as wide a diffusion as possible of technical and business +education, so that they may be able immediately to take control of big +complex industries. In this respect Russia was very badly off, whereas +England and America would be much more fortunate. + +Self-government in industry is, I believe, the road by which England +can best approach Communism. I do not doubt that the railways and the +mines, after a little practice, could be run more efficiently by the +workers, from the point of view of production, than they are at +present by the capitalists. The Bolsheviks oppose self-government in +industry every where, because it has failed in Russia, and their +national self-esteem prevents them from admitting that this is due to +the backwardness of Russia. This is one of the respects in which they +are misled by the assumption that Russia must be in all ways a model +to the rest of the world. I would go so far as to say that the winning +of self-government in such industries as railways and mining is an +essential preliminary to complete Communism. In England, especially, +this is the case. The Unions can command whatever technical skill they +may require; they are politically powerful; the demand for +self-government is one for which there is widespread sympathy, and +could be much more with adequate propaganda; moreover (what is +important with the British temperament) self-government can be brought +about gradually, by stages in each trade, and by extension from one +trade to another. Capitalists value two things, their power and their +money; many individuals among them value only the money. It is wiser +to concentrate first on the power, as is done by seeking +self-government in industry without confiscation of capitalist +incomes. By this means the capitalists are gradually turned into +obvious drones, their active functions in industry become nil, and +they can be ultimately dispossessed without dislocation and without +the possibility of any successful struggle on their parts. + +Another advantage of proceeding by way of self-government is that it +tends to prevent the Communist régime, when it comes, from having that +truly terrible degree of centralization which now exists in Russia. +The Russians have been forced to centralize, partly by the problems of +the war, but more by the shortage of all kinds of skill. This has +compelled the few competent men to attempt each to do the work of ten +men, which has not proved satisfactory in spite of heroic efforts. The +idea of democracy has become discredited as the result first of +syndicalism, and then of Bolshevism. But there are two different +things that may be meant by democracy: we may mean the system of +Parliamentary government, or we may mean the participation of the +people in affairs. The discredit of the former is largely deserved, +and I have no desire to uphold Parliament as an ideal institution. But +it is a great misfortune if, from a confusion of ideas, men come to +think that, because Parliaments are imperfect, there is no reason why +there should be self-government. The grounds for advocating +self-government are very familiar: first, that no benevolent despot +can be trusted to know or pursue the interests of his subjects; +second, that the practice of self-government is the only effective +method of political education; third, that it tends to place the +preponderance of force on the side of the constitution, and thus to +promote order and stable government. Other reasons could be found, but +I think these are the chief. In Russia self-government has +disappeared, except within the Communist Party. If it is not to +disappear elsewhere during a Communist revolution, it is very +desirable that there should exist already important industries +competently administered by the workers themselves. + +The Bolshevik philosophy is promoted very largely by despair of more +gradual methods. But this despair is a mark of impatience, and is not +really warranted by the facts. It is by no means impossible, in the +near future, to secure self-government in British railways and mines +by constitutional means. This is not the sort of measure which would +bring into operation an American blockade or a civil war or any of the +other catastrophic dangers that are to be feared from a full-fledged +Communist revolution in the present international situation. +Self-government in industry is feasible, and would be a great step +towards Communism. It would both afford many of the advantages of +Communism and also make the transition far easier without a technical +break-down of production. + +There is another defect in the methods advocated by the Third +International. The sort of revolution which is recommended is never +practically feasible except in a time of national misfortune; in fact, +defeat in war seems to be an indispensable condition. Consequently, by +this method, Communism will only be inaugurated where the conditions +of life are difficult, where demoralization and disorganization make +success almost impossible, and where men are in a mood of fierce +despair very inimical to industrial construction. If Communism is to +have a fair chance, it must be inaugurated in a prosperous country. +But a prosperous country will not be readily moved by the arguments of +hatred and universal upheaval which are employed by the Third +International. It is necessary, in appealing to a prosperous country, +to lay stress on hope rather than despair, and to show how the +transition can be effected without a calamitous loss of prosperity. +All this requires less violence and subversiveness, more patience and +constructive propaganda, less appeal to the armed might of a +determined minority. + +The attitude of uncompromising heroism is attractive, and appeals +especially to the dramatic instinct. But the purpose of the serious +revolutionary is not personal heroism, nor martyrdom, but the creation +of a happier world. Those who have the happiness of the world at heart +will shrink from attitudes and the facile hysteria of "no parley with +the enemy." They will not embark upon enterprises, however arduous and +austere, which are likely to involve the martyrdom of their country +and the discrediting of their ideals. It is by slower and less showy +methods that the new world must be built: by industrial efforts after +self-government, by proletarian training in technique and business +administration, by careful study of the international situation, by a +prolonged and devoted propaganda of ideas rather than tactics, +especially among the wage-earners of the United States. It is not true +that no gradual approaches to Communism are possible: self-government +in industry is an important instance to the contrary. It is not true +that any isolated European country, or even the whole of the Continent +in unison, can, after the exhaustion produced by the war, introduce a +successful form of Communism at the present moment, owing to the +hostility and economic supremacy of America. To find fault with those +who urge these considerations, or to accuse them of faint-heartedness, +is mere sentimental self-indulgence, sacrificing the good we can do to +the satisfaction of our own emotions. + +Even under present conditions in Russia, it is possible still to feel +the inspiration of the essential spirit of Communism, the spirit of +creative hope, seeking to sweep away the incumbrances of injustice and +tyranny and rapacity which obstruct the growth of the human spirit, to +replace individual competition by collective action, the relation of +master and slave by free co-operation. This hope has helped the best +of the Communists to bear the harsh years through which Russia has +been passing, and has become an inspiration to the world. The hope is +not chimerical, but it can only be realized through a more patient +labour, a more objective study of facts, and above all a longer +propaganda, to make the necessity of the transition obvious to the +great majority of wage-earners. Russian Communism may fail and go +under, but Communism itself will not die. And if hope rather than +hatred inspires its advocates, it can be brought about without the +universal cataclysm preached by Moscow. The war and its sequel have +proved the destructiveness of capitalism; let us see to it that the +next epoch does not prove the still greater destructiveness of +Communism, but rather its power to heal the wounds which the old evil +system has inflicted upon the human spirit. + + + + + _Printed in Great Britain by_ + UNWIN BROTHERS, LIMITED, THE GRESHAM PRESS, WOKING AND LONDON + + + + +ERRATA + + +P. 20, l. 11. For "teaching" read "reaching" + +P. 23, between l. 18 and l. 19. Insert "violence in the transition +must be faced. Unfortunately," + +P. 43, l. 12. For "dying" read "very ill" + +P. 44, last sentence. Substitute "But he recovered, and I hope it will +recover also." (replacing: "I hope I was mistaken in both respects.") + +P. 60, l. 6 from below. For "waving triumphant hands and" read +"expressing their delight by" + +P. 61, l. 21. For "professional" read "professorial" + +P. 85, l. 2. For "This" read "Thus" + +P. 91, l. 8. For "losses" read "hopes" + +P. 104, l. 9. For "leave" read "leaves" + +P. 105, last line. Substitute "which has been already discussed in +Chapter VI" (replacing: "which is better reserved for a separate +chapter.") + +P. 120, l. 19 For "desires" read "desire" + +P. 132, l. 5 from below. For "Caunon" read "Cannon" + +P. 148, l. 5 from below. For "by" read "in" + +P. 155, l. 13. For "scheme" read "schema" + +P. 172, l. 15. For "Zenghis" read "Yenghis" + +P. 187, l. 15. Delete comma. + + + + +BY THE SAME AUTHOR + + +ROADS TO FREEDOM + +PRINCIPLES OF SOCIAL RECONSTRUCTION + +INTRODUCTION TO MATHEMATICAL PHILOSOPHY + +THE ANALYSIS OF MIND + + + * * * * * + +Typographical errors corrected in text: + +page 19: happinesss changed to happiness +page 163: genera to general + + + * * * * * + + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of The Practice and Theory of Bolshevism +by Bertrand Russell + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK BOLSHEVISM *** + +***** This file should be named 17350-8.txt or 17350-8.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + https://www.gutenberg.org/1/7/3/5/17350/ + +Produced by Thierry Alberto, Jeannie Howse and the Online +Distributed Proofreading Team at https://www.pgdp.net + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +https://gutenberg.org/license). + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS' WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need, is critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at https://www.pglaf.org. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Its 501(c)(3) letter is posted at +https://pglaf.org/fundraising. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at https://pglaf.org + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit https://pglaf.org + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including including checks, online payments and credit card +donations. To donate, please visit: https://pglaf.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + https://www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. |