diff options
| author | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 04:46:53 -0700 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 04:46:53 -0700 |
| commit | 76f165dc1b4626f3527e95af21e0149c28bced62 (patch) | |
| tree | ada60f3415b665fdcac37280db9eef93231b7937 /15495.txt | |
Diffstat (limited to '15495.txt')
| -rw-r--r-- | 15495.txt | 5593 |
1 files changed, 5593 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/15495.txt b/15495.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d7e3779 --- /dev/null +++ b/15495.txt @@ -0,0 +1,5593 @@ +The Project Gutenberg EBook of In a Green Shade, by Maurice Hewlett + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: In a Green Shade + A Country Commentary + +Author: Maurice Hewlett + +Release Date: March 29, 2005 [EBook #15495] + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ASCII + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK IN A GREEN SHADE *** + + + + +Produced by S.R.Ellison, Audrey Longhurst, and the Online Distributed +Proofreading Team. + + + + + + In a Green Shade. + + A Country Commentary. + + By Maurice Hewlett. + + + London + G. Bell and Sons + 1920 + + + + G. BELL AND SONS, LTD. + YORK HOUSE, PORTUGAL STREET, LONDON, W.C. 2. + + + + +NOTE + + +All of these Essays, with two exceptions, have been published +periodically. All, without exception, have been revised and corrected. +My thanks for hospitality afforded to them _en route_ are due to the +_Westminster Gazette_, _Daily News_, and _Daily Chronicle_; to the +_New Statesman_; to the _Cornhill Magazine_, _Fortnightly Review_, +_Anglo-French Review_, and _London Mercury_. + + BROADCHALKE, _22 Jan. 1920._ + + + + +CONTENTS + + + PAGE + NOTE v + ROUND ABOUT A PREFACE ix + CHANGE AND THE PEASANTRY 1 + A HERMITAGE IN SIGHT 6 + DORIAN MODES 11 + CHURCH AND THE MAN 16 + BESSY MOORE 20 + THE MAIDS 31 + POETRY AND THE MODE 35 + POLYOLBION 45 + THE WELTER 50 + CATNACHERY 54 + LANDNAMA 60 + "WORKS AND DAYS" 64 + THE ENGLISH HESIOD 72 + FLOWER OF THE FIELD 83 + UNDER THE HARVEST MOON 87 + _LA PETITE PERSONNE_ 91 + A FOOL OF QUALITY 99 + SHERIDAN AS MANIAC 105 + A FOOTNOTE TO COLERIDGE 119 + THE CRYSTAL VASE 132 + _NOCTES AMBROSIANAE_ 147 + SKELETONS AT A FEAST 151 + A COMMENTARY UPON BUTLER 156 + THE COMMEMORATION 164 + THE QUAKER EIRENICON 168 + + + + +IN A GREEN SHADE + +ROUND ABOUT A PREFACE + + +The title has become equivocal, since there are more green shades in +employment now than were dreamed of by Andrew Marvell. Science is a +great maker of homophones, without respect for the poets. There is, +for instance, the demilune of lined buckram borne by the weak-eyed on +their foreheads, the phylactery of the have-beens--I lay myself open +to be believed a cripple, or to look an old fool. A vivacious reviewer +in _Punch's_ "Booking Office," will have a vision of me as a babbling +elder peering at society from below a green pent. However--I must +risk it. It says exactly what I mean; and what I have written I have +written. + +The point is that, having worked hard for a good many years, I can now +consider my latter end under conditions favourable to leisurely and +extended thought, sometimes in a garden made, if rightly made, in my +own image, sometimes in a house which was built aforetime, in a day +when men wrought for posterity as well as for themselves. In such +seed-plots it is impossible that one's thoughts should not take colour +as they rise. Whithersoever I look I see as much permanency as is good +for any sojourner upon earth; I see embodied tradition, respect for +Nature's laws, attention to beauty, subservience to use; all this +within doors. Outside, the trees, the flowers are my calendar; +the birds chime the hours; periodically the church-bell calls the +travellers home. Between all these friendly monitors it is hard if +one cannot keep the mean. If the passing-bell tempts me to moralise +overmuch I may turn to the creatures, and learn to live for the +moment. I should be slow to confess how much worldly wisdom I have +won from what we choose to call the lower orders of creation, because +nobody willingly betrays the whereabouts of his buried treasure, or +the amount of it. Mr. Pepys, I remember, forgot both on a certain +occasion, and had a devil of a time until he recovered his hoard. But +my wealth was not made with hands, or not with my hands. + +My house is fortunately placed, too, in the village street, so that I +am in touch with my neighbours and their daily concerns, which I make +mine so far as they are pleased to allow it. I am aware of them all +day long by half a hundred signs; I know the trot of their horses, the +horns of their motor-cars--that shows that there are not too many of +them--the voices of their children, the death-shrieks of their pigs, +the barking of their dogs. Not a day passes but one or other is in, +to have some paper signed, to air a grievance, or to ask advice. The +vicar and the minister are my good friends, and, I am glad to say, +each other's. The farmers understand my ways (it is as much as I can +expect of them), and the labourers like them. All this keeps the +pores of the mind open; you cannot stagnate if you are useful to +other people. Nor--unless you are a fool--can you be strict with your +categories. The more you know of men and systems the more overlapping +you see. I could not now, for my life, pigeonhole my acquaintance +in this village of five hundred souls. "I have now been in Italy two +days," Goethe wrote, "and I think I know my Italians pretty well!" +When he had been there two years he knew better. + +If ever there is a time for sententiousness it is when one is elderly, +leisured and comfortable; that is the time to set down one's thoughts +as they come, not inviting anybody to read them, but promising to +those who do, that they will find a commentary upon life as it passes, +either because it may be useful or because it may have been earned. I +hope I have neither prejudice nor afterthought; I know that I have, +as we say now, neither axe to grind nor log to roll. Politics! None. +I want people to be happy; and whether Mr. George make them so, or the +Trade Unions, whether Christ or Sir Conan Doyle, it's all one to me. +I have my pet nostrums, of course. I believe in Poverty, Love, and +England, and am convinced that only through the first will the other +two thrive. I want men to be gentlemen and women to be modest. I want +men to have work and women to have children. Any check on production, +Trade-Union, war, or something else, will get no good words from me. +As for war, after our late experience, I confess that I could be a Mr. +Dick with it, but we are not apt in the country to dwell overmuch on +war now it is over. We honour our beloved dead; those of us who have +returned unbattered go now about our work with cooler, more critical +eyes, but mostly with lips closed against our three or four years' +experience. Khaki has disappeared; the war is over; let us forget +it. If there is a people to be pitied, swarming and groping on this +tormented earth, we say, it is the German people; but that seems an +insufficient reason for hating them _in saecula saeculorum_. A German +is a human being, and very likely Mr. Bottomley is one too, and not a +big-head in a pantomime; such also may be Mrs. Partington's nephew and +the editor of the _Morning Post_. There does not seem much difference +between them, and we must be charitable. + +The sojourner in the green shade will find himself, as I have found +myself, more interested in people (but not those people) than in +books. We have too many books, as I discovered when I left London for +good. I sold six tons, and again another six, when, after two years in +West Sussex, I came home. Now I have collected about me the things I +can't do without, the things of which I read at least portions every +year, as well as a few which it is good to have handy in case of +accidents. Book-collecting is a foppery, a pastime of youth, when +spending money is as necessary as taking exercise, and you are better +for an object in each case. But I find that I now read with motives +other than those of old. I am now more interested in the author than +in his book. That must mean that I am more interested in life than +in art. I am reading at this moment Professor Child's edition of the +Ballads, and though I am occasionally moved to tears by the beauty +and tragic insight of things like _The Wife of Usher's Well_; +_Clerk Saunders_, or _Lord Thomas and Fair Annie_, I am sure that +considerations altogether unliterary move me more--such, for instance, +as curiosity to know who composed, and for whom they composed, these +lovely tales. I don't suppose that we shall ever know the name, or +anything of the personality of any one poet of them. Those poets were +as anonymous as our church-builders, and if they were content to be so +we should be content to have it so. But one would be happy to know of +what kind they were, and perhaps even happier (certainly I should) to +realise their auditors. Did they write for men or women? That is one +of my consuming quests. The staves of the _Iliad_ were for men: that +seems certain. Those of the _Odyssey_ not so certainly. But take this +from _May Collin_, and consider it. + +You know the story, how "She fell in love with a false priest, and +rued it ever mair"? The priest followed her "butt and ben," and gave +her no peace. They took horses and money and rode out together "Until +they came to a rank river, Was raging like the sea." There the priest +declared his purpose: + + "Light off, light off now, May Collin, + It's here that you must dee; + Here I have drown'd seven kings' daughters, + The eighth now you must be." + +So her torture begins. He bids her cast off "her gown that's of the +green," because it is too good to rot in the sea-stream; next her +"coat that's of the black "; next her "stays that are well-laced"; +lastly her "sark that's of the holland"--all for the same reason. Then +the girl speaks: + + "Turn you about now, false Mess John, + To the green leaf of the tree; + It does not fit a mansworn man + A naked woman to see." + +The point is that he obeys her. She catches him round the body and +flings him into the tide. _Women were listening to that tale_. + +If I am to deal with life it must be in my own way, for there's no +escape from one's character. I may be a good poet or a bad one--that's +not for me to say; but I am a poet of sorts. Now a poet does not +observe like a novelist. He does not indeed necessarily observe at +all until he feels the need of observation. Then he observes, and +intensely. He does not analyse, he does not amass his facts; he +concentrates. He wrings out quintessences; and when he has distilled +his drops of pure spirit he brews his potion. Something of the kind +happens to me now, whether verse or prose be the Muse of my devotion. +A stray thought, a chance vision, moves me; presently the flame is +hissing hot. Everything then at any time observed and stored in the +memory which has relation to the fact is fused and in a swimming flux. +Anon, as the Children of Israel said to Moses, "There came forth +this calf." One cannot get any nearer, I believe; and while I do not +pretend that I have said all there is to say about anything here, I +shall maintain that I have said all that need be said about the things +which I touch upon. In an essay, as in a poem, the half is greater +than the whole, if it is the right half. If it is the wrong half, why, +then the shorter it is the better. + +As most of these commentaries were written during the year which is +mercifully over, it would not have been possible, even if it had been +sought, to avoid current topics. Why should a writer shrink from being +called a journalist? He need not cease to be writer. But if he wishes +to be true to his original calling, to make his hope and election +sure, he must always be careful to seek the universal in the +particular; and that is where your idealist has such a pull, for he +can see nothing else. And if he does that he need not be afraid that +the conventions of Time and Space will be a hindrance to his book's +path. He will be readable a century hence; he will be readable in the +Antipodes; and that is as near infinity as any of us, short of Chaucer +and Shakespeare, need trouble about. In the country one reads, not +skims, the daily paper; and if one's comments are leisurely, perhaps +they are all the better. At any rate one is not tempted to see the end +of the world in a strike, or a second Bonaparte in Signor d'Annunzio. +To me that poet seems rather a comic-opera brigand. I suspect him of +a green velvet jacket with a two-inch tail. But if you regard him +_sub specie eternitatis_, then I fear we must see in him all Italy +in epitome. That was how Italy went to war--but you must live in the +country to understand things like that, out of range of the tumult and +the shouting. + +No more of Signor d'Annunzio here or elsewhere in these pages; but of +ourselves and our needs somewhat. Nobody could have lived through last +year without considering anxiously whither we are tending and with +what pretence. As the occasion moved me I have said my say about those +matters, and here the reader will have as much of it as I am ready +just now to give him. This is perhaps some sort of an apology for +what may be found hereafter of a hortatory kind. I may be charged with +wanting to do people "good." Well, if trying to make them happy is +trying to do them good, then I confess the charge. There is no doubt +whatever that they are not happy now. They hate too many people, they +pant and toil after the wrong things; they serve false gods and forget +the true ones. That is what we think about it in the country; and I am +of the country's opinion. + +We need, it seems to me, many things--religion, love, work, +seriousness and so on; but what we need most of all, as I believe, is +to wash our hands. For five years they have been groping and wrenching +in the vitals of other people. They are foul and we are still drunk +with the reek. In God's name, let us wash and then we can begin to +build up the world again. We see the need of that out in the country, +but so far as I can judge by what I read or have seen of London, +there's no notion of it there. + +But there's not much about London in this book. + + + + +CHANGE AND THE PEASANTRY + + +A book which I shall never willingly be without, one of my minor +classics, is _Idlehurst_. Published in 1898, its author John Halsham, +it has a touch upon country things, the penetrating, pitiful and _tant +soit peu_ condescending touch upon them of one who is both scholar and +recluse, fastidious but discerning. He reads our earth, cloudscape, +landscape, season, foison, man and beast of the field, with the same +wistfulness which women who have known sorrow exhibit for children +who have not. Reading him again, however, last night, after the long +interval of fever and unrest which the war has enforced, I found +his pessimism troublesome. Sussex, so far as I know it, is not so +degenerate as he seems to have found it; and surely since the war +began he must have changed his mind. It is hard to remember 1898, or +1913 for that matter, but I happen to know that Sussex emptied itself +of its young manhood, and voluntarily, because I went to live there +for a while in 1915 and found the village of my choice bare of youth. +But that was West Sussex, and John Halsham lives nearer London, in the +forest region, as I judge, which is a part of the country overflowed +and become suburban. I don't doubt but complete cockneyfication will +be the ultimate fate of that country of deep loam and handsome women +before many years are over. Going down to my village from London, +I could not feel that I was in the country until I had passed +Pulborough; and further east the same would hold good to Lewes. + +But when Mr Halsham in his bitterness cries out that "the town has +overflowed the country," meaning the whole country, and that "we are +cockney from sea to sea," he is being tragic at the cost of truth. +Would he drag Wiltshire and all the pastoral West into his turmoil? +You may go about any of the villages here, watch the daily doings of +the inhabitants, and feel confident that, practically, there has been +no substantial change since the Norman Conquest. The "feeling" of the +scene is the same as it always was, the outlook of the people, +their habit of mind, is the same. The one apparent difference is in +religion, and that is not a difference of substance but of accident. +We have forgotten the Madonna and the Saints, who were taken away +from us by violence. We still go to church, but they are not there any +more. They were expelled with a fork: one Cromwell but completed +what another began. And now it is late in the day: they can never be +brought back. "Vestigia nulla" is true of religion as of every other +human affair. But it was not them we worshipped. Rather it was what +they stood for--which endures. + +All this leads me away from John Halsham and _Idlehurst_. A good +antidote to his extreme depression is to be found in another beautiful +book which, if not a classic, will become one. I mean _A Shepherd's +Life_, wherein Mr. Hudson reveals the very heart of pastoral Wilts. +I went right through it only the other day, journeying from Sarum to +Trowbridge on county business--Wishford, Wylye, Codford, Heytesbury, +and so on to Melksham and Westbury--names which to us are symphonies. +No change from the sempiternal round of country labour in those quiet +hollows, though it is true that you saw soldiers in buff unloading +railway trucks, and that the valley was lined with their wooden +hutments. Soldiers, indeed, we have known ever since the Norman +Conquest; but the country is bigger than they are, and they fall +into its ways even as their huts fade into the shadows cast by its +everlasting hills. Mr. Hudson, by the way, does not seem to have +encountered a witch. We had one in this village a few years ago, and +she may be here still, though I haven't come across her. She laid a +malison on my chauffeur's potatoes--I had one once--and (as he told +me) blighted the year's crop. He was digging in his garden when she, a +dark-browed old woman with a beard, leaned over the gate and asked him +for some kindling wood. He, a Swiss, who may not have understood her, +waved her away, saying that he was busy. "You will get no good out of +those taters," said she, and slippered away. That was five years ago. + +John Halsham is fond of describing himself as a Tory, and perhaps +really is one of those almost extinct mammalia. I had thought +Professor Saintsbury the only one left. He, I understand, thinks +that the Reform Act of 1832 was a great mistake, and dislikes Horace +Walpole's Letters because their writer was a Whig. Then there is Mrs. +Partington's nephew, who muses perhaps without method, but certainly +not without malice, in _Blackwood_ once a month. He is more Jingo than +Tory. He has to bite somebody. I was amused the other day to consider +his girding at Sir Alfred Mond, chiefly on the score that he had a +German grandfather. It did not seem to have occurred to the man that +the same terrific charge could be brought against a much more august +Personage, and with much the same futility. Surely it is more to the +purpose that he will have an English grandson, That is the worst of +musing when you neglect method and surrender to malice. + +Toryism, which is a parasitic growth of mind, needs a relic to which +it can cling, not a person. In the country the Church will not provide +it, nor any longer the brewing interest. The air has been let into +the one, and the water which they call mineral into the other. There +remain the throne and the squirearchy, and of these the throne is +much the stouter. For the throne is remote enough to be an object of +veneration, separable from its occupant; but when the great house and +the old acres are held, and not filled, by a new man, the villager, +who sees more than he is supposed to see, is by no means concerned to +uphold them. Most of the villages have been Radical; now they are all +going "Labour." The elections, if there are to be some soon, will +be very interesting, and I think surprising to Mr. George and his +assortment of friends. + +However--another strike or two like that recent abortion on the +railways will dish the Labour Party and Trade Unionism as well--at +least in the country. Down here we are new to the movement, but have +gone into it keenly, without losing our heads. Indeed, I think we are +finding more in our heads than we suspected. We keep to our code; and +when we find that other men don't, we begin to doubt of Unionism. One +of the very best of our men said in my hearing at the time that if the +railway strike were the kind of thing we were to expect, he, for one, +would have no more to do with the Labourers' Union. As I have said +once before, I think, responsibility (which the Union is giving us) +deepens our men and quickens them too. The time is at hand when they +will begin to feel their power. I have no fears. I have long known +them to be the salt of the earth. If the quotation would not be from +one of my own works, I would quote now. + +It is an old discussion, but all my travels have convinced me that a +bad peasantry is the exception. Such exceptions there are, though I +don't mean to give them. If Zola had not made himself ridiculous in +the act, so ridiculous as to show himself negligible, he would stand +as the greatest traducer of his adopted country that France has +ever harboured. But he was a specialist in his particular line of +disgustfulness, and saw in rural France what he took there with him. +They say that the Bulgarian peasant is a savage brute, "they" being +the Greeks, of course. I would not mind betting a crown that he is +nothing of the sort. + +In manners, to be sure, peasantries differ remarkably. Here in the +West, from Wilts to Cornwall, our rustics are sweet-mannered. They +are instinctively gentlemen, if gentlehood consist, as I believe, in +having regard for other people's feelings. But in the Danish parts +of England, to be plain, manners are to seek. That means from +Bedfordshire pretty well up to Carlisle. North-east of that again, in +Northumberland, you have delightful manners. + +The Northumbrian peasant, like the Scottish, greets you as an equal, +the Wiltshire man as a superior, yet neither loses dignity thereby. +The Lancashire man treats you as his inferior, and is not himself +advantaged, whether it be so or not. + + + + +A HERMITAGE IN SIGHT + + +I hope that I have secured for myself a haven, a yet more impenetrable +shade than this, against the time when, having seen four generations +of men, two behind and two beyond, I may consider in silence what is +likely to be the end of it all. It is true that I am getting old, but +I am not yet prepared for a lodge in the wilderness. My present house +has a wall on the village street. The post-office is a matter of +crossing the road; the church is at the bottom of a meadow. I like all +that, because I like all my neighbours and the sound of their voices. +At eleven o'clock in the morning I can hear the children let out from +school, "as shrill as swifts in upper air." That, too, I like. But the +time will come when silence is best, and, as I say, I believe that I +have found the very place. I have had my eye upon it for years, and +seldom a month passes but I am there. A small black dog and I once saw +Oreads there, or said we did, and in print at that. This very year +the farm to which it belongs came into the market, and was sold; the +purchaser will treat with me. I have described it once, nay twice, +and won't do it again. Enough to say that it is the butt end of a deep +green combe in the Downs, that it is sheltered from every wind, faces +the south, and is below an ancient road, now a grass track, and the +remains of what is called a British village on the ordnance maps, a +great ramparted square with half a dozen gateways and two mist-pools +within its ambit. All about it lie the neolithic dead, of whose race, +as Glaucus told Diomede, "I boast myself to be." + +We are all Iberians here, or so I love to believe, grounding +myself upon the learned Dr. Beddoes--a swarthy people, dark-haired, +grey-eyed, rather under than over the mean height. The aboriginal +strain has proved itself stronger than the Frisian, and the Danish +type does not appear at all. There are English names among us, of +course, such as Gurd, which is Gurth as pronounced by a Norman; but it +is understood that we are neolithic chiefly on the distaff side. The +theory that each successive wave of invasion demolished the existing +inhabitants is absurd. Not even the Germans do that; nor have the +Turks succeeded in obliterating the Armenian nation. No--in turn our +oncoming hordes, Celts, Romans, English, Danes, enslaved the men and +married, or at least mated with, the women. And so we are descended, +and (let me at this hour of victory be allowed to say) a marvellous +people we are. For tenacity, patience, and obedience to the law--not +of men, but of nature--I don't suppose there is another such people +in the world. Those characteristics, for which neither Celt nor Roman, +Teuton nor Dane, as we know them now, is remarkable, I set to the +score of the neolithic race, whose physical features are equally +enduring. + +When you get what seems like a clear case in either sex, you have a +very handsome person. + +The most beautiful woman I ever saw in my days was scrubbing a kitchen +floor on her knees, when I saw her first--not a hundred miles from +here. Pure Iberian, so far as one can judge--olive skin, black hair, +grey-green eyes. Otherwise--colouring apart--the Venus of Milo, no +less. I don't say that she was very intelligent. I wonder if the Venus +was. But she was obedient to the law of her being--that I do know; and +it is a matter of faith with me that Aphrodite can have been no less +so. + +Neither a quick-witted nor an imaginative race are we; but we have +the roots of poetry in us, and the roots of other arts, for we have +reverence for what is above and beyond us. Custom, too, we worship, +and decency and order. We fight unwillingly, and are very slow to +anger; but we never let go. Witness the last four dreadful years; +witness Europe from Mons to Gallipoli. The British private, soldier +or sailor, has been the backbone of the fight for freedom. But I am a +long way from my valley in the Downs. + +I shall first of all sink a well, for one must have water, even if one +is going to die. Then I shall make a mist-pool--that art is not lost +yet--because as well as water to drink I like water to look upon. +Lastly, I will build a hermitage of puddled chalk and straw, and +thatch it with reeds, if I can get them. It will consist of a single +room thirty feet long. It will have a gallery at each end, attained +by a ladder. In each gallery shall be a bed, and the appurtenance +thereof, one for use and one for a co-hermit or hermitess, if such +there be. I leave that open. There must be a stoop, of course. Nothing +enclosed. No flowers, by request. The sheep shall nibble to the very +threshold. I don't forget that there is a fox-earth in the spinney +attached. I saw a vixen and her cubs there one morning as clearly as +I see this paper. She barked at me once or twice, sitting high on her +haunches, but the children played on without a glance at me. They were +playing at catch-as-catch-can--with a full-grown hare. Sheer fun. No +after-thoughts. I watched them for twenty minutes. + +If I grow anything there at all I shall confine my part of the +business to planting, and let Nature do the rest. It may be +absolutely necessary to keep the sheep off for a year or two, and the +rabbits--but that is all. And what I do plant shall be deciduous, so +that I may have the yearly miracle to expect. It is a mighty eater of +time--and there won't be much of that left probably; yet a joy which +no man who has ever begotten anything, baby or poem, can deny himself. + +If anybody wants to see what Nature can do in the way of a season's +growth, I can tell him how to go to work. Let him plant on the bank +of a running water a root of _Gunnera manicata_. Let him then wait ten +years, observing these directions faithfully. Every fall, after the +first frost--that frost which blackens his dahlias--let him cover +the crown of his _Gunnera_ with one of its own leaves. Pile some +stable-stuff over that, and then heap upon all the leaf-sweepings of +that part of the garden. Growth starts in mid-April and proceeds by +feet a week. Mine, which is about ten years old now, is thirty-five +feet in circumference, nearly twelve feet high, has flowers +two-feet-six in length, and in a hot summer has grown leaves seven +feet across. You can go under one of them in a shower of rain and be +as dry as in church. And all that done in five months. The plant is +a rhubarb of sorts and comes from Chili. I should like to see it over +there on the marge of some monstrous great river. In another order, +the _Ipomoea_ (Morning Glory), which comes from East Africa, runs it +close. I had one seed in Sussex which completely overflowed a garden +wall, smothering everything upon it. A kind of Jack's beanstalk, and +every morning starred with turquoise blue trumpet mouths of ravishing +beauty, which were dead at noon. The poor thing was constrained to be +a hierodule, gave no seed. Nature is the prodigal's foster-mother. + +I have a plant whose seed is much more beautiful than its flower. +By the way, I have two, for the Spindle Tree is in seed, which has +a quite insignificant blossom. But the plant I mean is a wild peony, +which I dug up in a brake on the slopes of Helikon. It is a single +white whose flower lasts, perhaps, three days. It makes a large +seed-pod, which burst a short time ago, and revealed blue-black seeds +sheathed in coralline forms of the most absolute vermilion. You could +see them fifty yards away. It seems to have no purpose in life but +to pack the seeds--or perhaps, they are beacons for the birds. I took +pains to be beforehand with the birds, having no desire to see Greek +peonies in my neighbours' gardens. The seeds are safely bestowed, +though their fate has not been Jonah's. There's a spinney of +elder-trees in the combe of my hermitage, which, I am told, was +planted entirely by magpies. And I suppose it was wood-pigeons who +planted two ilex trees on the top of the Guinigi tower in Lucca; and +some bird or other, once more, which is answerable for a fine +fig-tree growing in the parapet of the bridge at Cordova, in no soil +whatsoever. It was loaded with fruit when I saw it. But fig-trees are +like poets; if you want them to sing you must torture their roots. The +parallel wobbles, but will be understood. + + + + +DORIAN MODES + + +Being known in these parts for a friendly soul, and trusted, moreover, +I have fallen into the position among the peasantry which the parson +used to hold, and does still when he takes the trouble to qualify for +it. If I can't always tell them what to do I may be able to put them +in the way of the man who can. One learns how to make a dictionary of +life as one gets on in it. Another use which they can have of me: I +can tell them how to put their requests or demands. They have no sense +whatever of a written language. + +I must not betray confidences, or I could relate some curious matters +on this head. I know, for instance, a farmer who is worth a couple of +hundred thousand at the least, and who can neither write nor read. +He has learned somehow a cross between a scratch and a blot which is +accepted as a signature to cheques--but no more than that. And there +is no harm in saying that I often need an interpreter. I had a +case the other night when a man I know brought in a friend for +consultation--a youth of the round-headed, flaxen, Teutonic type, +rather rare here, who came from a village still more remote from the +world than this one. Not one word of his fluent and frequent speeches +could I understand. It was largely a question of intonation I +believe--but there it was. + +He had the wild, inspired look of a savage. He again could neither +read nor write, though he must have been at school within the last +ten or twelve years; but, as I think I have said elsewhere, it is not +uncommon for boys to go through the school course and fail to pass +the standards. There are here two families in particular, admirable +workmen, who for two generations have left school without having +acquired either writing or reading. One wonders deeply what kind of +processes go on in the minds of these fine young men, steady workmen, +as they are, good husbands, kind fathers, useful citizens oftener +than not. What is their conception of God, of human destiny? How does +Religion get at them? Or does it? Shall we ever know? Not if Mr. Hardy +cannot tell us. No other poet of peasant origin has done so--neither +Clare, nor Blomfield, nor even Burns. Mr. Hardy has told us something, +and might have told us a good deal more if by the time he had learned +his craft, he had not learned to be chiefly interested in himself. +That is the way of poets. + +Then there's _The Shropshire Lad_, a fake perhaps, since its author +was not a peasant, but a divine little book. _The Shropshire Lad_ is +morbid, unless lads are so in Shropshire--in which case they, too, are +morbid; but it is a golden book of whose beauty and felicity I never +tire. Technically it is by far the most considerable thing since _In +Memoriam_: "Loveliest of trees, the Cherry," makes me cry for sheer +pleasure. But it is haunted by the fear of death and old age; it is +afraid of love; it is sometimes cynical--none of which things are true +of youth in Salop or Salonika. The young peasant is a fatalist to the +core; but fatalists are not afraid of death. Youth is ephemeral and so +is the young peasant. He is always happy when the sun is out. + +As for love, it is truly the hot-and-cold disease with him. He is +himself his "own fever and pain," like the rest of us; but I think +love is a physical passion, until marriage. After marriage it may grow +into something very beautiful indeed, and the more beautiful for being +incapable of bodily utterance. I have a pair often under my eye down +here who are, I know, all in all to each other; yet their conversation +is that of two old gossips. But at fortunate moments I may induce one +of them to tell of the other, and then you find out. My _Village Wife_ +was no imagination of mine. She lives and suffers not so many miles +from where I write. Indeed, you may say of our peasantry very much +what French people will tell you of their marriage custom, that love +at its best follows that ceremony. It is not bred by romance, but by +intimacy. The romantic attachment flames up, and satiety quenches it. +The other kind glows red-hot but rarely breaks into a flame. You may +have which you choose: you are lucky indeed if you get both. + +To return, however, to dialect, intonation, as I say, has much to do +with it. It is attractive, and in poetry can be very touching. I have +had the advantage of hearing Barnes's poems read by a lady who has the +accent perfectly. One does not know Barnes or Wessex who does not +hear him read. That is true of all poetry, no doubt--but Barnes is +uncommonly dull to read. As for words, we have enough of our own to +support a small lexicon, which I used to possess, but have just been +hunting, in vain. Perhaps after the pattern of the arrow, I shall find +it again in the shelf of a friend. I remember that we call the roots +of a tree the _mores_; that a dipper is a _spudgell_; that we say +"_dout_ the candle" when we mean extinguish it. We say "to-year" as +you say "to-morrow," and call the month of March "Lide." February used +to be "Soul-grove," but I have never heard it called so. The pole of +a scythe is the _snead_; the two handles are the _nibs_. They are +fastened by rings called _quinnets_. Isaac Taylor says that the few +remaining Celtic words we have in use (other than hill or river +names) are words for obscure parts of tools. We have some queer +intensives--"terriblish" or "tarblish" is one, and "ghastly," meaning +ugly, is another. "A terrible ghastly sight" we say, meaning that a +thing looks rather ugly. + +Our demonstrative pronoun is _thic_, or more properly _dhic_; "dhic +meaed" means "that meadow." _Suent_ means pleasant or proper--really +both. It always has a sense of right consequence, of one thing +following another as it ought. "Suently" would be "duly." But that +now is common to the West, and will be heard from Land's End to +Hengistbury Head, as well as in every one of Mr. Phillpotts' novels. + +Doubtless it is too late to protest--since I am upon words--against a +current barbarism which is at least ten years old, and against which +I have publicly cried out at least twenty times. For the twenty-first +time, then, let me object to "wage" for "wages." _Is_ the wages of sin +death, or _are_ they? Do you give a man an alms, or an alm? + +Shall we read-- + + Fear no more the heat o' the sun, + Nor the furious winter's _rage_, + +and so on? Go to. But I shall not so easily convert Trade Union +orators, Members of Parliament, Mr. Sidney Webb, or the _Times_. To +them a wages is a wage, and an alms an alm, a man's riches his rich, +and his breeches his--at least I suppose so. I wish that we could call +a man's speeches his speech, and find it was perfectly true. It is a +terrible thought, "a terrible ghastly thought" indeed, that we have +not so long ago chosen over seven hundred persons of both sexes, each +of whom will conceive it his right to make a speech in Parliament +every day. Think of it. It is fair to suppose that every one of them +will make one speech every year, many of them, no doubt, one every +week, some certainly every day. I am thankful that I wasn't a +candidate, for I might have been successful. Then I should have been +compelled to listen, and perhaps tempted to reply, to some or all of +those speeches. "In the end thereof despondency and madness." + + + + +CHURCH AND THE MAN + + +At our Peace Celebration the other day that happened which in my +recollection never happened before. The entire village was in the +parish church, sang _Te Deum_, prayed prelatical prayers, and shared +_Hymns Ancient and Modern_. The Congregational Minister, in a black +gown, read the Lesson, the Vicar, in surplice and stole, preached. All +that in a village where more than half the people are Nonconformists, +and done upon the mere motion of that particular section of us. + +No experience since the War has touched me more; and I believe it is +strongly symptomatic. Akin to it was the streaming of the people in +London to Buckingham Palace, just when war was declared, and again on +the day of the Armistice: both matters of pure instinct. For what do +these things show except that we are children who, when we are moved, +run to our mother to tell her all about it? What are we, when we are +stripped to the soul, but one great family? A man told me once that he +was present at a trial for murder where there were half a dozen in +the dock, men and women, principals and accessories. The verdict was +"Guilty," and the wretches stood up to receive the death-sentence. +As they did so, by one common instinct, they all joined hands, and +so remained until they were led away to the cells. A strangely moving +scene. + +It is by no means a necessity of the simple alone to seek a common +expression of their hope and calling. A similar stream is carrying the +learned which at present runs parallel with our homelier brook, but +will sooner or later mingle waters. Then there will be a flood wherein +many tired swimmers will doubtless perish, but which may lead to the +sea those who keep their heads. Signs of that are on all sides of +us. "_What is the Kingdom of Heaven_?" asks Mr. Clutton-Brock, and +succeeds at his best in telling us what it is not. As for anything +more positive, he concludes very reasonably that it is a state of +mind, and leaves us to infer that the ruck of humanity need the +guidance of inspiration to induce it. + +It is not at all difficult for him to show that the Church lacks +inspiration, or that there is something inherent in the essence of +a Church destructive of it. What should have been equally easy would +have been to point out that the Church's Founder as certainly had it. +Nobody ever guided men more unfalteringly than He, and we need not +doubt but that it was His instigation which turned the hearts of the +village people to find a common focus for their thanksgiving. Mr. +Clutton-Brock has felt the sting and owned to the need; he is in the +stream, but is not a bold swimmer. I hope he may reach the sea. + +Why it is--assuming the inspiration of Christ--that men have +nevertheless ceased to be guided by it, and have consequently lost +touch with the Kingdom of Heaven, is explained by a more hardy plunger +in the stream, the Hibbert Lecturer upon "_Christ, Saint Francis, +and To-day_." With great learning, skill and courage he has used +the documents of the Franciscan revival to illustrate what must have +happened to the Christian well-spring. He shows that even in the +lifetime of its founder the Franciscan fraternity crystallised under +the insensible but enormous pressure of the world, the flesh and +(doubtless) the devil. Saint Francis of Assisi, for instance, +taught literal poverty--abstinence from money, goods and books. His +Franciscans wouldn't have it. They asked for money and took it. Not +always directly, but always somehow. + +"By God we owen forty pound for rent!" said Chaucer's Franciscan when +pressed by the good wife to declare what ailed him; and he got his +forty pound. Saint Francis told them to build churches like barns; +they built them like cathedrals. He would have had men uninstructed +in all but love; and they became the greatest schoolmen in Europe. The +world, in fact, was too much with them. So also did Christ teach; and +as the Franciscans modified their master's precepts, so did Saint Paul +his. + +Twice, then, the world has been demonstrably wrong. Is it a +possibility that Christ and St. Francis can be proved to have been +right? To those who say, as Mr. Clutton-Brock does, that Christianity +has failed, I should like to retort, "Let Christianity be tried." +Poverty is of the essence of it, and luckily for us poverty is coming +upon us, nation and individuals, whether we deserve it or not. When we +are all really poor together--in heart as well as purse--we shall have +the chance of a common religion, but not till then. Now, then, comes +the question: Can the high in heart become poor in heart, or the +high-minded humble themselves? If it is hard for the man rich in goods +to enter the Kingdom of Heaven, is it not still harder for the man +stored with knowledge? How are Mr. Clutton-Brock and the Hibbert +Lecturer to become as little children? How will Mr. Wells manage it? +He, too, is in the stream, splashing about and apparently enjoying +himself. But you may call an invisible God an invisible king, if you +please, and yet be no nearer the heart of the matter. A change of +definitions will not do it. And what of Sir Oliver Lodge and Sir Conan +Doyle? Are their outpourings symptomatic? I don't myself think so. +They are concerned with a future life, whereas those who seek a common +religion will take no account of life at all, past, present or to +come, once they have found the Kingdom of Heaven. Those eloquent and +(I trust) sincere gospellers are agog to dispel that sense of loss +which besets us just now. It is not that we fear death so much, but +that we miss the dead--and no wonder. Hence these prophets crying Lo +here! and Lo there! That they have reassured many I know well, that +they have baffled others I know also, for they have baffled me. My +puzzle is that, with evidence of authenticity difficult to withstand, +the things they can find to report are so trivial. The test of a +revelation I take to be exactly the same as the test of a good poem. +It doesn't much matter whether the thing revealed is new or not. Is it +so revealed that we needs must believe it? Relevance is to the point, +compatibility is to the point. But when Sir Oliver Lodge's medium puts +whisky and cigars into the mouth of the dead, we don't laugh: it is +too serious for that. We change the conversation. + +Steadfastness in mutability, that is the common need, a Rock of Ages. + + Then 'gin I thinke on that which Nature sayd, + Of that same time when no more change shall be, + But stedfast rest of all things, firmely stayd + Upon the pillars of Eternity, + That is contrayr to Mutabilitie; + For all that moveth doth in change delight: + But thenceforth all shall rest eternally + With Him that is the God of Sabaoth hight: + O! that great Sabaoth God, grant me that Sabaoth's sight. + + + + +BESSY MOORE + + +"My best wishes and respects to Mrs. Moore; she is beautiful. I may +say so even to you, for I was never more struck with a countenance." +That is Byron, writing to Tom Moore in 1812, when he had been married +little more than a year--and Byron's opinion of woman's beauty +is worth having. In the eight volumes of Tom's memoirs, worthily +collected by his friend Lord John Russell, and in all the crowded +stage of it, I see no figure shining in so sweet and clear a morning +light as that of his little home-keeping wife, with her "wild, poetic +face," her fancy which rings always truer than Tom's own, and her +mother-love, which sorrow has to sound so deeply before she can leave +the scene. Her appearances are fitful; she keeps to the hearth when +the grandees hold the floor. You see nothing of her at Holland House, +which Tom may use as his inn, or at Bowood, if she can help herself, +which in the country is his house of call. She is the Jenny Wren of +this little cock-robin; she wears drab, too often mourning; but you +find that she counts for very much with Tom. He loves to know her at +his back, loves to remind himself of it. He is always happy to be home +again in her faithful arms. Through all the sparkle and flash, under +all the talk, through all the tinklings of pianos and guitars which +declare Tom's whereabouts, if you listen you can hear the quiet burden +of her heart-beats. I don't know what he would have done without her, +nor what we should have to say to his literary remains if she were +not in them to make them smell of lavender. Few men of letters, and no +wits, can have left more behind, with less in them. + +There is a great deal less of Bessy in the memoirs than, say, of Lady +Donegal, or of Rogers, or of Lord Lansdowne, but somehow or another +she makes herself felt; and though her appearances in them are of +Tom's contrivance, a personality is more surely expressed than in most +of his more elaborate portraits. One gets to know her as indeed the +"excellent and beautiful person" of Lord John's measured approval, not +so much by what she says or does as by her reactions on Tom himself. +A study of her has to be made out of a number of pencil-scratches--one +here, one there--put down by the diarist with unpremeditated art; for +it is certain that, though Moore intended his diaries to speak for him +after his death, what he had to say of his wife was the last thing +in them he would have relied upon to do it. I am sure that is so; +nevertheless, with the exception of Tom himself, who, of course, holds +the centre of the stage, she is more surely and sensibly there than +any of his thousand characters, from the Prince Regent to the poet +Bowles; more surely and fragrantly there. We are the better for her +presence; and so is her Tom's memory, infinitely the better. + +It was a secret marriage and, except in the minds of a few good +judges, an improvident. + + "I breakfast with Lady Donegal on Monday," he writes to his + mother in May, 1811, "and dine to meet her at Rogers' on + Tuesday; and there is to be a person at both parties whom you + little dream of." + +This person was Bessy, to whom he had been married some two months +on the day of writing, and of whom, when his family was notified, he +found that it had nothing good to say. He complains of disappointment, +of a "degree of coldness" in his father's comments; and neither is +perhaps very wonderful. For Miss Bessy not only had nothing a year, +but in the reckoning of the day, and in comparison with the young +friend of Lord Moira and Lady Donegal, she herself was nothing. +She was indeed a professional actress--Miss E. Dyke in the +play-bills--whom Tom had first met in 1808 when the Kilkenny Theatre +began a meteor-course. He had lent himself as an amateur to the +enterprise, was David in _The Rivals_, Spado (with song) in _A Castle +of Andalusia_. In 1809, for three weeks on end, he had been Peeping +Tom of Coventry to the Lady Godiva of Miss E. Dyke. The rest is easy +guessing, and so it is that Tom's parents were dismayed, and that +there was a "degree of coldness." Lady Godiva, indeed! + +But Bessy was not long in showing herself as good as gold, or +approving herself to some of Tom's best friends. Lady Donegal and her +sharp-tongued sister, Mary Godfrey, both took to her. "Give our +love, honest, downright love to Bessy," they write. Rogers called her +Psyche, had the pair to stay with him, stayed with them in his turn, +and gave Bessy handsome sums for the charities in which she abounded +all her life. Rogers knew simplicity when he saw it, and had no +vitriol on hand when she was in the way. I don't think Tom ever took +her to Ireland with him, or that, consequently, she ever met his +parents in the flesh; but no doubt that they accepted her, and +esteemed her. + +Bit by bit she reveals herself in Tom's random diaries. As in the +printing of a photograph the lights and darks come sparsely out, and +unawares the delicate outline, so by a word here, a phrase elsewhere, +we realise the presence of a sweet-natured, sound-minded girl, and +more than that, of a girl with character. After a spell of Brompton +lodgings Tom took her to Kegworth in Leicestershire, where he was to +have the neighbourhood and countenance of his patron of the moment, +Moira, the Regent's jackal, a solemn, empty-headed lord. Donington +Hall and Bessy appear together in a letter to Mary Godfrey. + + "... I took Bessy yesterday to Lord Moira's, and she was not + half so much struck with its grandeur as I expected. She said, + in coming out, 'I like Mr. Rogers's house ten times better.'" + +Tom feels it necessary to explain such remarkable taste. "She loves +everything by association, and she was very happy in Rogers's +house." I don't know whether Tom's simplicity or Bessy's is the more +remarkable in all this. Tom's, I think. + +"Lady Loudoun and Lord Moira called upon us on their way to town and +brought pine apples, etc." One sees them at it; and the very next +letter he writes is dated "Donington Park." Tom fairly lets himself go +over it. + + "... I think it would have pleased you to see _my wife_ in one + of Lord Moira's carriages, with his servant riding after her, + and Lady Loudoun's crimson travelling-cloak round her to keep + her comfortable. It is a glorious triumph of good conduct on + both sides, and makes my heart happier and prouder than all + the best worldly connections could possibly have done. The + dear girl and I sometimes look at each other with astonishment + in our splendid room here, and she says she is quite sure it + must be all a dream." + +Marble halls, in fact; but let us see how it acted upon Bessy. Shortly +after: "... I am just returned from a most delightful little tour with +Rogers, poor Bessy being too ill and too fatigued with the ceremonies +of the week to accompany us." That was to be the way of it for the +rest of their lives together. She would never go to the great houses +if she could by any means avoid it, but bore him no grudge for going +without her, and was always open-armed for his return. + +Mayfield Cottage, Ashbourne, was their next harbourage; and here is a +Wheatley picture of them on their way to a dinner-party. + + "We dined out to-day at the Ackroyds', neighbours of ours ... + we found, in the middle of our walk, that we were near half an + hour too early, so we set to practising country-dances in the + middle of a retired green lane till the time was expired." + +Then he takes her to the Ashbourne ball, and for once leaves himself +out of the letter. + + "... You cannot imagine what a sensation Bessy excited at the + Ball the other night. She was prettily dressed, and certainly + looked very beautiful.... She was very much frightened, but + she got through it very well. She wore a turban that night to + please me, and she looks better in it than anything else; for + it strikes everybody almost that sees her, how like the form + and expression of her face are to Catalani's, and a turban is + the thing for that kind of character." + +Catalani, in Caverford's portrait, has the rapt eye of the Cumaean +sibyl. One of Moore's fine friends, an admirer of Bessy's, speaks to +him of her "wild, poetic face," and the Duchess of Sussex thought her +like "Lady Heathcote in the days of her beauty." That is putting her +very high, for, according to Cosway, Lady Heathcote was a lovely young +woman indeed; but the "wild, poetic face" gets us as near as need be. + +In 1815 troubles began from which the poor girl was never to be free +again. She lost one of her three little girls, Olivia Byron, for whom +the poet had been sponsor. "... It was with difficulty I could get +her away from her little dead baby," Moore tells his mother, "and then +only under a promise that she should see it again last night...." In +1817, while Moore was in Paris, pursuing his pleasures, another child, +Barbara, had a fall, and he came home in August to find her "very ill +indeed." On September 10th she is still ill, but if she should get a +little better, "I mean to go for a day or two to Lord Lansdowne's +to look at a house.... He has been searching his neighbourhood for a +habitation for me, in a way very flattering indeed from such a man." +But he did not go. September 20th, "It's all over, my dearest Mother!" + +"Poor Bessy," we read, "neither eats nor sleeps enough hardly to +sustain life": nevertheless in the first week of October he is at +Bowood. "I arrived here the day before yesterday, and found Rogers, +Lord and Lady Kerry, etc." He saw Sloperton Cottage and stayed out +his week. Bessy then had to see the cottage, and went--but not from +Bowood. "Bessy, who went off the night before last to look at the +cottage near Lord Lansdowne's, is returned this morning, after +travelling both nights. Power went with her." In a month's time they +were in possession, and Tom vastly set up by the near neighbourhood of +his exalted friend. Not so, however, his Jenny Wren. + + "... We are getting on here as quietly and comfortably as + possible, and the only thing I regret is the want of some near + and plain neighbours for Bessy to make an intimacy with, and + enjoy a little tea-drinking now and then, as she used to do + in Derbyshire. She contrives, however, to employ herself + very well without them; and her favourite task of cutting out + things for the poor people is here even in greater requisition + than we bargained for, as there never was such wretchedness in + any place where we have been; and the better class of people + (with but one or two exceptions) seem to consider their + contributions to the poor-rates as abundantly sufficient, + without making any further exertion towards the relief of the + poor wretches. It is a pity Bessy has not more means, for she + takes the true method of charity--that of going herself into + the cottages, and seeing what they are most in want of. + + "Lady Lansdowne has been very kind indeed, and has a good deal + won me over (as you know, kindness _will_ do now and then). + After many exertions to get Bessy to go and dine there, I have + at last succeeded this week, in consequence of our being on + a visit to Bowles's, and her having the shelter of the poet's + old lady to protect her through the enterprise. She did not, + however, at all like it, and I shall not often put her to the + torture of it. In addition to her democratic pride--which I + cannot blame her for--which makes her prefer the company + of her equals to that of her superiors, she finds herself a + perfect stranger in the midst of people who are all intimate; + and this is a sort of dignified desolation which poor Bessy + is not at all ambitious of. Vanity gets over all these + difficulties; but pride is not so practicable." + +Vanity indeed did, though Tom had a pride of his own too. But he was +soothed and not offended by pomp, whereas she was bored as well as +irritated. It is obvious that her wits were valid enough. She could be +happy with Rogers or the Bowleses, who could allow for simplicity, and +delight in it--a talent denied to the good Lansdownes. As for Bowles, +Tom is shrewd enough to remark upon "the mixture of talent and +simplicity in him." + + "His parsonage-house at Brenthill is beautifully situated; + but he has a good deal frittered away its beauty in grottos, + hermitages and Shenstonian inscriptions. When company is + coming he cries, 'Here, John, run with the crucifix and missal + to the hermitage, and set the fountain going.' His sheep-bells + are tuned in thirds and fifths." + +Such was Bowles, Bessy's best friend in Wilts. + +Bowood to Tom was centre of his scheme of things; he was always there +on some pretext or other; or he would dine and sleep at Bowles's or at +Lacock Abbey, or spend days in Bath, or a week in London. It is true +that half his talent and more than half his fame were social: these +things were the bread as well as the butter of life to him. But here +is Bessy meantime: + + "... Came home and found my dearest Bessy very tired after her + walk from church. She has been receiving the Sacrament, + and never did a purer heart.... In the note she wrote me to + Bowles's the day before, she said, 'I am sorry I am not to see + you before I go to church.'" + +Tom had sensibility, not a doubt of it; but it seems to me that she +had something better. + +Here again, on the 16th October, "My dear Bessy planting some roots +Miss Hughes has brought her, looking for a place to put a root of pink +hepatica in, where (as she said) 'I might best see them in my walk.'" +Yes, he had sensibility; but she had imagination. A little Tom was +born a week after that. She took it badly, as she did most of her +labours, and was in bed a month. On the 18th November she went out for +the first time after the event--"the day delightful." She "went round +to all her flower-beds to examine their state, for she has every +little leaf in the garden by heart." Tom himself had been much moved +by the birth of his first boy. He was called up at 11.30, sent for +the midwife, was upset, walked about half the night, thanked God--"the +maid, by the way, very near catching me on my knees." She might have +caught Bessy on them every day, and no thought taken of so simple a +thing. But Tom had sensibility. + +But a man who, eight years after marriage, can make his wife an April +fool, and record it, is no bad husband, and it would be a trespass on +his good fame to suggest it. He loved her dearly and could never have +been unkind to her. Far from that, happy domestic pictures abound in +his diaries. Here is one of a time when she had joined him in London, +on her way to stay with her sister in Edinburgh. They went together to +Hornsey, to see Barbara's grave. "At eight o'clock she and I sauntered +up and down the Burlington Arcade, then went and bought some prawns +and supped most snugly together." He takes the state-rooms costing L7 +apiece, for "his own pretty girl." Meantime he is preparing to shelter +in France from civil process served upon him for the defalcations of +his deputy in Bermuda. + +I need not follow the scenes through as they come. The essence of +Bessy Moore is expressed in what I have written of the first flush of +her married life. There was much more to come. Moore outlived all his +children, and she, poor soul, outlived her rattling, melodious Tom, +having known more sorrow than falls, luckily, to the lot of most +mothers. The death of her last girl, Anastasia, is beautifully told by +Tom; but a worse stroke than even that was the wild career of little +Tom, the son, his illness, disgrace, and death in the French Foreign +Legion. That indeed went near to breaking Bessy's heart. "Why do +people sigh for children? They know not what sorrow will come with +them." That is her own, and only recorded, outcry. + +In _The Loves of the Angels_, an erotic and perfervid poem, which +fails, nevertheless, from want of concentration of the thought, +Zeraph, the third angel, is Tom himself, and the daughter of man, +Nama, with whom he consorts, is Bessy. + + Humility, that low, sweet root, + From which all heavenly virtues shoot, + Was in the hearts of both--but most + In Nama's heart, by whom alone + Those charms for which a heaven was lost + Seemed all unvalued and unknown... + +Certainly she had humility; but he gives her other Christian virtues-- + + So true she felt it that to _hope_, + To _trust_ is happier than to know. + +But we may doubt if Tom knew what Bessy knew and excused. Sensibility +will not dig very deep. + + + + +THE MAIDS + + +They tell me that a respectable and ancient profession, and one always +honoured by literature, is dying out; and if that is true, then two +more clauses of the tenth Commandment will lose their meaning. For +a long time to come we shall go on grudging our neighbour his +house--there's no doubt about that; but even as his ox and ass have +ceased to enter into practical ethics because our average neighbour +doesn't possess either, so we hear it is to be with his servant and +his maid. + +They have had their day. There are no domestic servants at the +registries; the cap and apron, than which no uniform ever more +enhanced a fair maid or extenuated a plain one, will be found only in +the war museum, as relics of ante-bellum practice; we shall sluice our +own doorsteps in the early morning hours, receive our own letters from +the postman, have our own conversations with the butcher's young man +at the area gate; and in time, perhaps, learn how it may be possible +to eat a dinner which we have ourselves cooked and served up. Better +for us, all that, it may well be; but will it be better for our girls? +I am sure it will not. + +Domestic service, I have said, is an employment which literature has +always approved. From Gay to Hazlitt, from Swift to Dickens, there +have been few writers of light touch upon life who have not had a kind +eye for the housemaid. There's a passage somewhere in Stevenson for +which I have spent an hour's vain hunting, which exactly hits the +centre. The confidential relationship, the trim appearance, not +without its suggestion of comic opera and the soubrette of the +_Comedie Francaise_, the combined air of cheerfulness and respect +which is demanded, mind you, on either side the bargain--all this is +acutely and vivaciously observed in half a page by a writer who never +missed a romantic opening in his days. The profession, indeed, has +never lacked romance in real life. Strangeness has persistently +followed beauty in and out of the kitchen. The number of old +gentlemen who have married their cooks is really considerable. +Younger gentlemen, whose god has been otherwhere, have married +their housemaids. A Lord Viscount Townshend, who died in 1763 or +thereabouts, did so in the nick of time, and left her fifty thousand +pounds. Tom Coutts the banker, founder of the great house in the +Strand, married his brother's nursemaid, and loved her faithfully for +fifty years. She gave him three daughters who all married titles; but +she was their ladyships' "dear Mamma" throughout; and Coutts himself +saw to it that where he dined she dined also. There's nothing in caste +in our country, given the essential solvent. + +A stranger story still is this one. Some fifteen years ago a barrister +in fair practice died, and made by will a handsome provision for his +"beloved wife." This wife, thereby first revealed to an interested +acquaintance, had acted as his parlourmaid for many years, standing +behind his chair at dinner, and bringing him his evening letters on a +tray; and she had been so engaged on the day of his death. Nobody of +his circle except, of course, her fellow-servants, knew that she stood +in any other relationship to her so-called master. I consider her +conduct admirable; nor do I think his necessarily blameworthy. Those +two, depend upon it, understood each other, and had worked out a +common line of least resistance. On the distaff side there is the +tale of the two maiden ladies so admirably served by their butler +that when, to their consternation, he gave warning, they held a +heart-to-heart talk together, as the result of which one of them +proposed in all the forms to the invaluable man, and was accepted. It +is deplorable that a pursuit which opens vistas so rose-coloured as +these should be allowed to lapse. + +A lady whom I knew well, and whose recent death I deplore, was cured +of a bad attack of neuritis by being cut off all domestic assistance, +except her cook's, and set to do her own housework. Therefore it is +probable that we should all be the better for the same treatment; +but, as I asked just now, will the girls be the better for it? The +disengaged philosopher can only answer that question in one way. That +feverish community-work which they have been doing through a four +years' orgy of patriotism will have taught them very much of life and +manners. It will have taught them, among other more desirable things, +how to spend money, and how to keep a good many young men greatly +entertained; but it will not, I fear, have taught them how to save +money, how to make one man happy and comfortable, or how to bring up +children in the fear of God. + +And if it has failed to teach those things it will have failed to fit +them for this world, to say the least. It will not only have failed +them, but it will have failed us with them. For the world needs at +this moment a thousand things before it can be made tolerable again; +and all of those can be summed up into one paramount need, which is +for men and women who will observe faithfully the laws of their being. +And what, pray, are the laws of their being? At the outside, three; in +reality, two: to work, to love and to have children. + +At this hour neither men nor women will work. The strain is taken off, +the bow relaxed. At the same time they must have money, that they may +spend it; for as always happens in moments of reaction, the +simplest way of expressing high spirits and a sense of ease is +wild expenditure. So wages must be high, and because wages are high +everything is dear. There are no houses, and there will be none; there +can be no marriages, and there will be none; there will be no milk for +children, so there will be no children. How long are such things to +go on? Just so long as we disregard the laws of our being. We began to +neglect them long before the war, and they must be learned again. We +must learn first what they are, and next, how to keep them. + +Now the education of men is another text; but for women there can be +little doubt but that the prime educationary in the laws of being is +domestic service. You can be ribald about it. That is easy. But where +else is a girl to learn how to keep house? And if she does not learn +how to be a mother, as indeed she may, poor dear, she gets to know +very much of what to do when she becomes one. + +So I hope to see a soberer generation of girls return to a profession +which they have always adorned, for the schooling of which their +husbands and children shall rise up and call them blessed. + + + + +POETRY AND THE MODE + + +A good friend of mine, poet and scholar, was recently approached by +the President, or other kind of head of a Working Men's Association, +for a paper. A party of them was to visit Oxford, where, after an +inspection, there should be a feast, and after the feast, it was +hoped, a paper from my friend--upon Addison. The occasion was not to +be denied: I don't doubt that he was equal to it. I wish that I had +heard him; I wish also that I had seen him; for he had determined on +a happy way of illustrating and pointing his discourse. He had the +notion of providing himself with a full-bottomed wig, a Ramillies; at +the right moment he was to clothe the head of the President with +it; and--Bless thee, Bottom, how art thou translated! In that woolly +panoply, if one could not allow for _Cato_ and the balanced antitheses +of the grand manner, or condone rhetoric infinitely remote from life +past, present or to come--well, one would never understand Addison, or +forgive him. This, for instance:-- + + CATO (_loq._): Thus am I doubly arm'd; my death and life, + My bane and antidote are both before me: + _This_ in a moment brings me to an end; + But _this_ informs me I shall never die. + The soul, secured in her existence, smiles + At the drawn dagger.... + +Ten pages more sententious and leisurely comment; then: + + Oh! (_dies_). + +There is much to be said for it, in a Ramillies wig. It is stately, it +is dignified, it is perhaps noble. If, as I say, it is not very much +like life, neither are you who enact it. But be sure that out of sight +or remembrance of the wig such a tragedy were not to be endured. + +That is very well. The wig serves its turn, inspiring what without it +would be intolerable. I am sure my friend had no trouble in accounting +for Addison in full dress and his learned sock. Nor need he have had +with Addison the urbane, Addison of the _Spectator_ condescending to +Sir Roger de Coverley and Will Honeycomb. There is in that, the very +best gentlemanly humour our literature possesses, nothing inconsistent +with the full-bottomed wig and an elbow-chair. But when the right +honourable gentleman set himself to compose _Rosamond: an Opera_, and +disported himself thus: + + PAGE: + Behold on yonder rising ground + The bower, that wanders + In meanders + Ever bending, + Never ending, + Glades on glades, + Shades in shades, + Running an eternal round. + + QUEEN: + In such an endless maze I rove, + Lost in the labyrinths of love, + My breast with hoarded vengeance burns, + While fear and rage + With hope engage, + And rule my wav'ring soul by turns-- + +then I do not see how the wig can have been useful. I feel that +Addison must have left it on the bedpost and tied up his bald pate +in a tricky bandana after the fashion of Mr. Prior or Mr. Gay, one of +whom, if I remember rightly, did not disdain to sit for his picture in +that frolic guise. The wig, which adds age and ensures dignity, would +have been out of place there; nor is it possible that _The Beggar's +Opera_ owes anything to it. To explain the Addison of _Rosamond_ +or _The Drummer_, my friend would have had to shave the head of his +victim and clap a nightcap upon it. + +The device was ingenious and happy. You yoke one art to serve another. +It can be extended in either direction, working backwards from the +Ramillies, or forwards, as I propose to show. Skip for a moment +the Restoration and the perruque, skip the cropped polls of the +Roundheads; with this you are in full Charles I. + + Go, lovely Rose! + Tell her that wastes her time and me, + That now she knows, + When I resemble her to thee, + How sweet and fair she seems to be. + +What vision of what singer does that evoke? What other than that of +a young gallant in a lace collar, with lovelocks over his shoulders, +pointed Vandyke fingers, possibly a peaked chin-beard? There is +accomplishment enough, beauty enough, God knows; but there is +impertinence too; it is _de haut en bas_-- + + Tell her that wastes her time and me! + +Lovelocks and pointed fingers all over it. It is witty, but does not +bite. If you bite you are serious, if you bite you are in love; but +that is elegant make-believe. He will take himself off next minute, +and encountering a friend, hear himself rallied: + + Quit, quit, for shame I This will not move, + This cannot take her; + If of herself she will not love, + Nothing can her make: + The D----l take her! + +Laughter and a shrug are the end of it. With the Carolines it was not +music that was the food of love, but love that was a staple food +of music. A man who lets his hair down over his shoulders may be as +sentimental as you please, or as impudent. He cannot nourish both a +passion and a head of hair. He won't have time. + +There, then, again, is a clear congruity established between your +versifying and your clothes; they will both be in the mode, and the +mode the same. One feels about the Cavalier fashion that it was +not serious either one way or the other. It had not the Elizabethan +swagger; it had not the Restoration cynicism; it had not the Augustan +urbanity. Go back now to the Elizabethan, and avoiding Shakespeare as +a law unto himself, which is the right of genius--for the sonnets +have wit as well as passion (but a mordant wit), everything that real +love-poetry must have, and much that no poetry but Shakespeare's could +possibly survive--avoiding Shakespeare, I say, take two snatches in +order. Take first-- + + Thou art not fair, for all thy red and white, + For all those rosy ornaments in thee,-- + Thou art not sweet, though made of mere delight, + Nor fair nor sweet--unless thou pity me! + +That first; and then this: + + Shake hands for ever, cancel all our vows + And when we meet at any time again, + Be it not seen in either of our brows + That we one jot of former love retain-- + +and consider them for what they are: unapproachably beautiful, +passionate, serious, on the edge of cynicism, but never over it. There +you have the love of a young age of the world, when young men, hard +hit, could be sharp-tongued, bitter, and often (though not in those +two) too much in earnest not to be shameless. Agree with me, and see +the men who sang and the women they sang of in preposterous stuffed +and starched clothes which made them unapproachable except at the +finger-tips, and yet burning so for each other that by words alone and +the music in them they could rend all the buckram and whalebone and +make such armour vain! You may see in Elizabethan dress a return +to Art, as in Elizabethan poetry you see a return to Learning; but +neither was designed to prevent a return to Nature; rather indeed to +stimulate it. And so you come back to this: + + Take thou of me smooth pillows, sweetest bed, + A chamber deaf of noise and blind of light, + A rosy garland and a weary head ... + +which is the perfectly-clothed utterance of an Elizabethan longing to +be rid of his clothes. + +I don't propose to linger over the perruque. The Restoration was a +time of carnival when, if the men were overdressed, the ladies were +underdressed; and the perruque was a part of the masquerade. In such a +figurehead you could be as licentious as you chose--and you were; you +could only be serious in satire. The perruque accounts for Dryden and +his learned pomp, for Rochester and Sedley, and for Congreve, who told +Voltaire that he desired to be considered as a gentleman rather than +poet, and was with a shrug accepted on that valuation: it accounts for +Timotheus crying Revenge, and not meaning it, or anything else except +display; it accounts for Pepys thinking _King Lear_ ridiculous. Let me +go on rather to the day of the tie-wig, of Pope's Achilles and Diomede +in powder; of Gray awaking the purple year; of Kitty beautiful and +young, of Sir Plume and his clouded cane; of Mason and Horace Walpole. +When ladies were painted, and their lovers in powder, poetry would be +painted too. It would be either for the boudoir or the alcove. I don't +call to mind a single genuine love-song in all that century among +those who dressed _a la mode_. There were, however, some who did not +so dress. + +Gray was not one. Whether in the country churchyard, or by the grave +of Horace Walpole's favourite cat, he never lost hold of himself, +never let heart take whip and reins, never drowned the scholar in the +poet, never, in fact, showed himself in his shirtsleeves. But before +he was dead the hearts of men began to cry again. Forty years before +Gray died Cowper was born; fourteen years before he died, Blake was +born; twelve years before he died, Burns. It is strange to contrast +the _Elegy_ with _The Poplar Field:_ + + My fugitive years are all wasting away, + And I must ere long be as lowly as they, + With a turf on my breast and a stone at my head, + Ere another such grove shall arise in its stead. + +Put beside that melodious jingle the ordered diction and ordered +sentiment of one of the best-known and most elegant poems in our +tongue. They were written within fifteen years of each other. Within +the same space of time, or near about it, there came this spontaneous +utterance of simplicity, tragedy and hopeless sorrow: + + Young Jamie lo'ed me weel, and sought me for his bride; + But saving a croun he had naething else beside: + To make the croun a pund young Jamie gaed to sea; + And the croun and the pund they were baith for me. + +The authoress of that was born twenty-one years before Gray died. I +speak, perhaps, only for myself when I say that reading that, or the +like of that in Burns or in Blake, my heart becomes as water, and +I feel that I would lose, if necessary, all of Milton, all of +Shakespeare but a song or two, much of Dante and some of Homer, to +be secured in them for ever. My friend (of the Ramillies) and I +were disputing about a phrase I had applied to lyric poetry as the +infallible test of its merit. I asked for "the lyric cry," and he +scorned me. I could find a better phrase with time; but the quatrain +just quoted makes it unmistakable, as I think. Anyhow, it will be +conceded that there was some putting off of the tie-wig, the hoop and +the red-heeled shoe about 1770. + +In the time of Reform, say from 1795 to 1830, you could do much as +you pleased, and dress according to your fancy. You could smother your +neck in a stock, wear a high-waisted swallow-tail coat, kerseymere +continuations and silk stockings. So sat Southey for his portrait, and +so did Rogers continually. Or you could wear a curly _toupe_ with Tom +Moore and the Prince Regent, be as rough as a dalesman with Wordsworth +or as sleek as a dissenting minister with Coleridge, an open-throated +pirate with Byron, or a seraph with Shelley. If the rules lingered, +they were relaxed. I think there were none. Individuality was in the +air; schools were closing down. For the first time since the spacious +days men sang as they pleased, and some sang as they felt and were, +but with this difference added that you would no longer identify the +age with the utterance. There were many survivals: most of Coleridge, +all of Rogers, much of Byron, some of Wordsworth (_Laodamia_) is +eighteenth century; and then, for the first time, you could archaicize +or walk in Wardour Street--Macpherson had taught us that, and Bishop +Percy. But all of Shelley and Keats, the best of Coleridge and +Wordsworth belong to no age. + + The pale stars are gone! + For the sun, their swift shepherd, + To their folds them compelling, + In the depths of the dawn, + Hastes in meteor-eclipsing array and they flee + Beyond his blue dwelling, + As fawns flee the leopard. + But where are ye? + +That is like nothing on earth: music and diction are stark new. And +that was the way of it for a forty years of freedom. + +Then came a reaction. With Queen Victoria we all went to church again +in our Sunday clothes. You cannot date Keats, Shelley and Wordsworth +by the fashions; but you can date Tennyson assuredly. He belongs +to the top-hat and the crinoline; to _Friends in Council_ and "nice +feelings." True, there was nothing dressy about Tennyson himself. I +doubt if he ever wore a top-hat. But is not _The Gardener's Daughter_ +in ringlets? Did not Aunt Elizabeth and Sister Lilia wear crinolines? +And as for _Maud_-- + + Look, a horse at the door, + And little King Charley snarling: + Go back, my lord, across the moor, + You are not her darling. + +That settles it. "Little King Charley's" name would have been Gyp. +I yield to no man in my admiration of _In Memoriam_; but when one +compares it with _Adonais_ it is impossible not to allocate the one +and salute the other as for all time and place: + + When in the down I sink my head + Sleep, Death's twin-brother, times my breath; + Sleep, Death's twin-brother, knows not Death, + Nor can I dream of thee as dead. + +And then: + + He lives, he wakes--'tis Death is dead, not he; + Mourn not for Adonais. Thou young Dawn, + Turn all thy dew to splendour, for from thee + The spirit thou lamentest is not gone. + +No: _In Memoriam_ is a beautiful poem, and technically a much better +one than _Adonais_. But the spirit is different; narrower, more +circumscribed; in a word, it dates, like the top-hat and the +crinoline. + +In our day, clothes have lost touch with mankind, they cover the body +but do not express the soul. With the vogue of the short coat, short +skirt, slouch hat, and brown boots, style has gone out and ease come +in; and with ease, it would seem, easy, not to say free-and-easy, +manners. I speak not of the "nineties" when a young degenerate could +lightly say, + + I have been faithful to thee, Cynara, in my fashion, + +and be praised for it, but rather of the Georgians, of whom a golden +lad, who happily lived long enough to do better, wrote thus of a lady +of his love: + + And I shall find some girl, perhaps, + And a better one than you, + With eyes as wise, but kindlier, + And lips as soft, but true. + And I daresay she will do. + +If that is not slouch-hat and brown boots, I don't know what to call +it. For that golden lad I think _The Shropshire Lad_ must answer, who +perhaps brought corduroys into the drawing-room. And if that is to be +the way of it, we should do well to go back to Lovelace or Waller, and +make believe with a difference. I shall find myself watching the sunny +side of Bond Street for a revival--because while one does not ask for +passion, or even object to the tart flavours of satiety, I feel that +there is a standard somewhere, and a line to be drawn. Taste draws it. +I trouble myself very little with the morals of the matter, yet must +think manners very nearly half of the conduct of life. And the manners +which are expressed in clothes are those which are instilled in art. +They are symptomatic alike and correlated. There is nothing surprising +about it, or even curious. It would be so, and it is so. If Milton +had not on a prim white collar and a doctor's gown I misread _Paradise +Lost_ and _Lycidas_ too. + + + + +POLYOLBION + + +How precisely does the Englishman love England? I remember saying some +years ago that he was not patriotic in the ordinary sense, because +though he loved the land, he had very little feeling for the political +entity called England--whereas both will be loved by the true patriot. +On recent consideration of the matter I am beginning to ask whether he +does, after all, love the land itself, as the Irishman loves his, the +Scot his, the Switzer his, and the Greek his. I must say that I doubt +it. There is this, I think, to be noted of fervent patriots, that the +object of their devotion will have had a distressful story. That is +the case with the four nations just remarked upon. It has been the +case with France ever since France was the passion of the French. + +Every man loves his home, for reasons not necessarily connected with +the country which happens to hold it; every one of our soldiers of +late longed to get back, by no means necessarily because he wanted to +see England again. Did he really want to see it at all--I mean for its +own sake apart from what it held of his? I know that he would have cut +his tongue out sooner than have confessed it. That is his nature, and +I can't help liking him for it--because it is a part of himself, and I +like him better than any man in the world. But allowing for that queer +shyness, how are we to test his love of our country? Is there a sure +test? Well, I know of one, which to my mind is a certainty. Judged +by that I must own that Atkins does not stand as a lover should, or +would. + +My test is this. The lover of his countryside knows its physical +features by heart, and to him they have personality. You will have +observed the tendency of Londoners to guide you by the names of +public-houses; you will have noticed their blank ignorance of points +of the compass. To a great extent these defects characterise the Home +Counties, and one might try to excuse them in various ways. In the +North of England, and in Scotland throughout, you will be told to +"go east," or "keep west" (as the Wordsworths were asked, were they +"stepping westward?"), with a conviction that the direction will be +sufficient for you as it plainly is for your guide. Now nobody can +be said to know his countryside who does not know the airts; and +the plain truth is that the Southern Englishman does not know his +countryside at all. How, then, can he love it? But there's a stronger +point than that. + +Nothing is more surprising than the indifference of Southerners to +their rivers. Where, for instance, throughout its course do you ever +hear the Thames spoken of as "Thames"--as if it was a person, which no +doubt it is? In the North you talk of Lune and Leven, Esk and Eden: + + Tweed said to Till, + What gars ye run so still? + +Scotland shows the same respect. Do you remember when Bailie Nicol +Jarvie points out the Forth to Francis? "Yon's Forth," he said with +great solemnity. That was well observed by Scott. In Italy--notably in +Tuscany--a river is always spoken of without the definite article. It +may be the case in Devonshire too; but it is never done here in South +Wilts though we have five beautiful streams ministering to our county +town. Indeed Wiltshire people are nearly as bad as the Cockneys, who +always call their Thames "the river," which is as if a man might say +"the railway." + +Beautiful how Burns personified his rivers! More, he individualised +them. The same verb won't do. You have: + + Where Cart rins rowin' to the sea, + +but + + Where Doon rins wimplin' clear; + +And Dante says, or makes Francesca say, + + Siede la terra dove nata fui + Sulla marina dove Po discende + Per aver pace co' seguaci sui. + +_Per aver pace_: a lovely phrase. And that brings me to Michael +Drayton. + +That was a poet--author also of one lovely lyric--who treated our +rivers after the fashion of his day, which ran to length and tedious +excess. Shakespeare's _Venus and Adonis_ is by pages too long; but +that is nothing to Drayton's masterpiece. With the best dispositions +in the world I have never been able to get right through the +_Polyolbion_. His anthropomorphism is surprising, and a little of it +only, amusing. + +Here is an example, wherein he desires to express the fact that an +island called Portholme stands in the Ouse at Huntingdon. + + Held on with this discourse, she--[that is, Ouse]--not so far hath run, + But that she is arrived at goodly Huntingdon + Where she no sooner views her darling and delight, + Proud Portholme, but becomes so ravished with the sight, + That she her limber arms lascivious doth throw + About the islet's waist, who being embraced so, + Her flowing bosom shows to the enamour'd Brook; + +and so on. + +That will be enough to show that one really might have too much of the +kind of thing. In Drayton you very soon do; every page begins to +crawl with demonstrative monsters, and there is soon a good deal +more love-making than love. But you may read Drayton for all sorts of +reasons and find some much better than others. He describes Britain +league by league, and is said to have the accuracy of a roadbook. In +thirty books, then, of perhaps 500 lines apiece, he conducts you +from Land's End to Berwick-on-Tweed, naming every river and hill, +dramatising, as it were, every convolution, contact and contour; and +not forgetting history either. That means a mighty piece of work, of +such a scope and purport that we may well grudge him the doing of it +Charles Lamb, who loved a poet because he was bad, I believe, as a +mother will love a crippled child, is more generous to Drayton than I +can be. "That panegyrist of my native earth," he calls him, "who +has gone over her soil, in his _Polyolbion_, with the fidelity of a +herald, and the painful love of a son; who has not left a rivulet so +narrow that it may be stept over, without honourable mention; and has +animated hills and streams with life and passion beyond the dreams +of old mythology." No more delightful task could be the lifework of a +poet who loved his own land; but it could hardly be done again, nor, I +dare say, ever be done again so well. + +To describe, however, the windings and circumfluences of rivers, the +embraces of mountain and rain-cloud in language on the other side +of amorousness may easily be inconvenient or ridiculous, and not +impossibly both; but I shouldn't at all mind upholding in public +disputation, say, at the Poetry Bookshop, that there was no other way +than Drayton's of doing the thing at all. It was the mythopoetic way. +For purposes of poetry, Britain is an unwieldy subject, and if you are +to allow to a river no other characters than those of mud and ooze, +swiftness or slowness, why, you will relate of it little but its rise, +length and fall. Drayton's weakness is that he can conceive of no +other relation than a sex-relation, and in so describing the relations +of every river in England, he very naturally becomes tedious. Satiety +is the bane of the amorist, and of worse than he. Casanova had that +in front of him when he set out to be immoral, _on ne peut plus_, in +seven volumes octavo. There simply were not enough vices to go round. +He ended, therefore, by being a dull as well as a dirty dog. "Take +back your bonny Mrs. Behn," said Walter Scott's great-aunt to him +after a short inspection, "and if you will take my advice, put her +in the fire, for I found it impossible to get through the very first +novel." The nemesis of the pornographer: he can't avoid boring you to +tears. + + + + +THE WELTER + + +Soused still to the ears in the lees of war, I win a rueful reminder +from a stray volume of _Hours in a Library_. Was the world regenerated +between 1848 and 1855? Were English labourers all properly fed, housed +and taught? Had the sanctity of domestic life acquired a new charm in +the interval, and was the old quarrel between rich and poor definitely +settled? Charles Kingsley (of whom the moralist was writing) seems +really to have believed it, and attributed the exulting affirmative +to--the Crimean War! The Crimean War, after our five years of colossal +nightmare, looks to us like a bicker of gnats in a beam; yet perhaps +any war will do for a text, since any war will produce some moral +upheaval in the generations concerned. Let us suppose, then, that the +British were seriously turned to domestic politics in 1855; let us +admit that they are so turned to-day, and ask ourselves fairly whether +we are now in a better way of reasonable living than history shows +those poor devils to have been. + +If we are, it will not be the fault of the old agencies, in which +Kingsley always believed. Church and State are adrift; organised +Christianity has abdicated; the aristocracy no longer governs +even itself; Parliament has died of a surfeit of its own rules. +If fundamental reform is to come, it will be forced upon us by the +working class, and (at the pinch) opposed tooth and nail by the +privileged. But is it to come? Is the working class deploying for +action? In all the miscellaneous scrapping which we watch to-day is +there one strong man with a sense of direction? It doesn't look like +it. + +Men, having learned to get what they lust after by strife, do not +easily forget the lesson. Sporadic war, like a heath fire, breaks out +daily in some part of the world; and society is as easily kindled, +and as irrationally as nations. A Jew is put out of Hungary and an +Archduke takes his place. The working men of Britain, having chosen a +Parliament which they don't believe in, and didn't want, set to work, +not to get rid of it, but to make any future Parliament impossible. +The police do their best for the shoplifters; the engine-drivers, +to help the police, prevent them from going home to bed. Sir Edward +Carson, a staunch Unionist, makes union out of the question. The +bakers, to improve the prospects of their trade, teach people to make +their own bread. The colliers--well, the colliers do not yet seem to +have found out that unless they provide people with coal, people won't +provide them with many things they are in need of. + +This doesn't look much like solidarity, it must be owned; and yet I +make bold to say that the one abiding good we have got out of the war +is the discovery of the solidarity of man. Nationality (mother of war) +has been killed since we have learned from the Germans how much +alike we are at our worst, and best. Caste is mortally wounded. The +land-girl and her ladyship admit their sisterhood; the staff officer +and the batman understand each other in the light of common needs and +their satisfaction. There's the seed; water it with the dew of common +poverty and you may have one Britain instead of a round dozen, and a +League of Men to succeed a stillborn League of Nations. Courage, then; +_Eppur si muove!_ + +Poverty is certainly coming, for Europe is on the edge of bankruptcy. +With poverty will come freedom, and it can come in no other way. +Nobody is free while he is serf to his own necessities, and the +necessities of such a man as I am (to take the first instance that +comes to hand) have grown to such a pitch that I am as rogue and +peasant slave to them as ever Hamlet was to his. Gentleman born, +quotha! Caste and self-indulgence go hand in hand. I must be a great +man in the village, therefore live in the great house. Men must touch +their hat-brims to me, therefore my hat (not I) must be worth their +respect. A village girl must wait upon me, therefore (for my life) +I must not wait upon her. That is where I have been ever since I was +born, but now I am going to be poor and free. The time is at hand when +I must give up my roomy old house in its seven-acre garden and live in +the five-roomed cottage now occupied by my gardener. My hat must be +as it may, since I shan't buy a new one. If a maid comes to work in my +house she can only come in one capacity, which will equally involve +my working in hers. She in the kitchen, I in the coalhole or potato +patch, 'twill be all one. If she works it will be in our common +interest; and for that I too shall work. + +If I, still harping on myself, go that way to freedom, shredding off +what is tiresome, cumbrous and a hindrance, one is tempted to think we +shall all--so life is in a concatenation--lose what is really vicious +in our social coil; and if in our social then in our political coil. +For if the essence of a sound private life is that a man should be +himself, so a public life for its smooth working depends upon the same +sincerity. Read my parable of the particular into society at large. +If I am to live so, and gain, are not nations? Are we to hire a great +navy, a great army, to secure us in things which we have seen to be +tiresome, cumbrous and a hindrance? Are we to exact flag-dippings +from nations to our flag? Are we to make washpots of the Maltese, +Cypriotes, Hindoos, Egyptians, Hottentots, and who not? If we go +bankrupt we shall not be able to do it, and if we are not able to do +it we shall stand among people as Britons, not as a British Empire, +over against French, Germans, Maltese, Cypriotes, standing as their +needs involve, and for what worth their virtue can ensure. So men, +being men, nations of men will become families of men: + +_Magnus ab integro saeclorum nascitur ordo._ + +Two things therefore are clear: men are a family, and the family is to +be poor. Almost as clear to me is the coming of the day when we shall +slough the ragged skin of empire and become again a small, hardy, +fishing and pastoral people. The profiteers will leave us, like +rats and their parasites. We shall be able to feed ourselves by our +industry. We shall be contented, and as happy as men with inordinate +desires and subordinate capacities can ever hope to be. There is no +reason to suppose that we need cease to be a nursery of heroes, +that our old men will not see visions or our young men dream dreams. +Neither vision nor dream will be the worse for having its bottom in +truth. + + + + +CATNACHERY + + +Catnach was a dealer in ballads. His stock line was the murderer's +confession, and his standard price half a crown. I don't know that +there is a Catnach now, or a market for Catnachery, but people collect +the old ones. You find them in county anthologies, with one of which +"_The Kentish Garland_, Vol. II., edited by Julia H.L. de Voynes, +Hertford: Stephen Austin and Sons, 1882," I lately spent a pleasant +morning in a friend's house. I should have liked Volume I., though it +could not by any possibility have contained worse matter. That is my +only consolation for missing it, because there are bad things and bad +things, and if a thing of literature is bad enough, it may well be as +entertaining as the best. I have long felt that there was a future for +_Half-hours with the Worst Authors_. It might prove a goldmine to a +resolute editor, and I hope I am not betraying a friend when I say +that one of mine has laid the footings of such a collection as may +some day add lustre to his name.[A] If I don't mistake, I can put him +on to a thing or two now which he will be glad of. + +[Footnote A: He is here following Edward FitzGerald.] + +Every bad ballad has its archetype in a good one, and all ballads +of whatsoever quality, can be pigeonholed under subjects, whether +of content or of treatment. My first specimen from Kent could be +classified as the Ballad Encomiastic, or, at will, as the Ballad of +Plain Statement, in which latter case it would be considered as a +ballad proper and derive itself _passim_ from Professor Child's +book. In the former case you would have to go back to Homer for its +original. It calls itself "An Epitaphe"--which it could not be--"uppon +the death of the noble and famous Sir Thomas Scott of Scottshall, who +dyed the 30 Dec. 1594," and begins thus: + + Here lyes Sir Thomas Scott by name-- + O happie Kempe that bore him! + +Kempe is his mother. + + Sir Reynold with four knights of fame + Lyv'd lynealy before him. + +The poet chooses to treat of ladies by their surnames, for we go on: + + His wieves were Baker, Heyman, Beere, + His love to them unfayned; + He lived nyne and fiftie yeare. + And seventeen soules he gayned. + +Seventeen children, in fact--but + + His first wief bore them every one, + The world might not have myst her-- + +A very obscure line, at first blush rather hard on Baker, and flatly +contradicted by what follows: + + She was a very paragone, + The Lady Buckhurst's syster. + +Nothing could be more succinct. Now for Beere: + + His widow lives in sober sort, + No matron more discreeter; + She still reteines a good report, + And is a great housekeeper. + +Apart from his valiancy as a consort Sir Thomas seems to have done +little in the world but be rich in it. The best that can be said of +him by the epigraphist is contained in what follows: + + He made his porter shut his gate + To sycophants and briebors, + And ope it wide to great estates, + And also to his neighbours. + +That does not recommend Sir Thomas to me. I suspect himself of +sycophancy, if not of briebory, and it may well be that he shut out +others of his kidney in order that he might have free play with the +great estates. But that is not the poet's fault, who had to say what +he could. + +My next example should be styled the Ballad of Extravagant Grief, and +will be found at its highest in the Poetical Works of John Donne. I +can find nothing greater than his-- + + Death can find nothing after her, to kill + Except the world itself, so great as she, + +in "A funerall elegie upon the death of George Sonds Esquire who was +killed by his brother Mr. Freeman Sonds the 7 of August 1658." Freeman +Sonds, a younger son, hit his brother George on the head with a +cleaver as he lay in his bed, and thereafter dispatched him with a +three-sided dagger. He then went in to his father and confessed his +fault. "Then you had best kill me too," said the father; to whom the +son, "Sir, I have done enough." He was hanged at Maidstone, full +of penitence and edifying discourse. The elegy begins in Donne's +circumstantial manner: + + Reach me a handkerchief, another yet, + And yet another, for the last is wet. + +Nothing could be better; but he must needs outdo his usual outdoings, +call for a bottle to hold his tears, finally require that-- + + The Muses should be summoned in by force + And spend their all upon the wounded corse-- + +which presents a rather comic picture to the imaginative reader. + +The elegist, reserving blasphemy for his conclusion, now becomes +foolish: + + In thy expyring it was made appear + In bloody wounds the Trinity was here. + +_Where_ was the Trinity, you ask? In the wounds, naturally, which, +made with a three-edged dagger, showed red triangles. But there were +twelve wounds: therefore-- + + The gates thro' which thy fertil soul did mount + To blessed Aboad came to the full account + Of Twelve, or four times three; and three + Hath ever in it some great Mysterie. + +Obviously. Here is his peroration: + + Great God, what can, what shall, man's frailtie thinke + When thy great goodness at this act did winke? + But thou art just, perhaps thou thoughtest it fit; + And Lord, unto thy judgment I submit. + +Any comment must fail upon the sublimity of that great "perhaps." + +Elkanah Settle might have written that, as he did undoubtedly another, +"On the untimely death of Mrs. Annie Gray, who dyed of small pox": + + Scarce have I dry'd my cheeks but griefs invite + Again my eyes to weep, my hand to write, + Which still return with greater force, being more + In weight and number than they were before. + +A touch of Crabbe there--but enough of innocent death, which was not +in Catnach's line of business. He dealt in murder, from the convicted +murderer's standpoint. For us the _locus classicus_ is the Thavies Inn +Affair; but from the _Kentish Garland_ I gather "The Dying Soldier in +Maidstone Gaol," a later flower, written and published no longer ago +than 1857. + +The dying soldier was Dedea Redanies, so called, though probably his +name should be spelt as it is rhymed, Redany. He was a Servian (not a +Serbian) from Belgrade, engaged in the Second British-Swiss Legion, an +armament of which I never heard before. Quartered at Shorncliffe, and +goaded by jealousy, he stabbed his young woman, and her sister, on the +cliffs above Dover, gave himself up, was tried and duly hanged. I +hope that is a plain statement, but none which I could make could be +plainer than Dedea's rhapsodist's: + + Oh, list my friends to a foreign soldier + Whose name is Dedea Redanies-- + My friends and kindred had no idea + That I should die on a foreign tree. + I loved a maiden, a pretty maiden, + In the town of Dover did she reside-- + I sweetly kissed her and with her sister + I after killed and laid side by side. + +That is admirably said, but not at all advantaged by subsequent +re-statement in something like fifteen verses. The colossal egotism +of the notorious criminal, however, provides him with a conclusion +oleaginous enough for a scaremonger of our own day, with a confusion +of _summject_ and _ommject_ very much after his heart. "O God," he +whines-- + + O God receive me, from pain relieve me, + Since I on earth can no comfort find-- + To stand before thee, let me, in glory, + With poor Maria and sweet Caroline. + +I should like Sir Conan Doyle to treat of this modest proposal in a +present lecture. + + + + +LANDNAMA + + +I have been reading in _Landnama Book_ the records of the settlement +of Iceland and can now realise how lately in our history it is that +the world has become small. At the beginning of the last century +it was roughly of the size which it had been at the end of the last +millennium. It then took seven days to sail from Norway to Iceland, +and if it was foggy, or blew hard, you were likely not to hit it off +at all, but to fetch up at Cape Wharf in Greenland. It was some +such accident, in fact, which discovered Iceland to the Norwegians. +Gardhere was on a voyage to the Isle of Man "to get in the inheritance +of his wife's father," by methods no doubt as summary as efficacious. +But "as he was sailing through Pentland frith a gale broke his +moorings and he was driven west into the sea." He made land in +Iceland, and presently went home with a good report of it. He may +have been the actual first discoverer, but he had rival claimants, as +Columbus did after him. There was Naddodh the Viking, driven ashore +from the Faroes. He called the island Snowland because he saw little +else. Nevertheless, says his historian, "he praised the land much." +Such was the beginning of colonisation in Thule. It was accidental, +and took place in A.D. 871. + +But those who intended to settle there had to devise a better way of +reaching it than that of aiming at somewhere else and being caught in +a storm. What should you do when you had no compass? One way, perhaps +as good as any, was Floki Wilgerdsson's. "He made ready a great +sacrifice and hallowed three ravens who were to tell him the way." It +was a near thing though. The first raven flew back into the bows; the +second went up into the air, but then came aboard again. "The third +flew forth from the bows to the quarter where they found the land." +It was then very cold. They saw a frith full of sea-ice--enough for +Floki. He called the country Iceland, and the name has stuck. They +stayed out the spring and summer, then sailed back to Norway, of +divided minds concerning the adventure. "Floki spoke evil of the +country; but Herolf told the best and the worst of it; and Thorolf +said that butter dripped out of every blade of grass there." He was +a poet and his figure clove to him. "Therefore he was called Butter +Thorolf." + +The first real settlers were two sworn brethren, Ingolf and Leif. They +went because they had made their own country too hot to hold them, +having in fact slain men in heaps. This had been on a lady's account, +Helga daughter of Erne. They had gone a-warring with Earl Atle's three +sons, and been very friendly until they made a feast afterwards for +the young men. At that feast one of the Earl's sons "made a vow to get +Helga, Erne's daughter, to wife, and to own no other woman." The vow +was not liked by anybody; and it was not, perhaps, the most delicate +way of putting it. Leif in particular "turned red," having a mind +to her himself. These things led to battle, and the Earl's son was +killed. Then the sworn brethren thought they had best go to Iceland, +and they did; but Leif took Helga with him. They left their country +for their country's good, and for their own good, too. + +Having found your asylum, how did you choose the exact quarter +in which to settle? The popular way was that adopted by the sworn +brethren. "As soon as Ingolf saw land, he pitched his porch-pillars +overboard to get an omen, saying as he did so, that he would settle +where the pillars should come ashore." That was his plan. If it wasn't +porch-pillars it was the pillars of your high seat. Either might be +the nucleus of your house; both sets were sacred things, heirlooms, +symbols of your worth. You never left them behind when you flitted. +Another plan, and a good one, was to leave the site to Heaven. +Thorolf, son of Ernolf Whaledriver, did that. He was a great +sacrificer, and put his trust in Thor. He had Thor carven on his +porch-pillars, and cast them overboard off Broadfrith, saying as +he did so, "that Thor should go ashore where he wished Thorolf to +settle." He vowed also to hallow the whole intake to Thor and call it +after him. The porch-pillars went ashore upon a ness which is called +Thorsness to this day, as the site of the shrine Thorolf built is +still called Templestead. Thorolf was a very pious colonist. "He had +so great faith in the mountain that stood upon the ness that he +called it Holyfell;" and he gave out that no man should look upon it +unwashed. It should be sanctuary also for man and beast, a hill of +refuge. "It was the faith of Thorolf and all his kin that they should +all die into this hill." I hope that they did so, but _Landnama Book_ +doesn't say. + +There were few, if any, Christians among these fine people. King Olaf +and his masterful ways with the heathen were yet to come. And those +who took on the new religion took it lightly. They cast it, like an +outer garment, over shoulders still snug in the livery of Frey and +Thor. It was not allowed to interfere with their customs, which were +free, or their manners, which were hearty. Glum, son of Thorkel, son +of Kettle Black, "took Christendom when he was old. He was wont thus +to pray before the Cross, 'Good for ever to the old! Good for ever +to the young.'" That seems to have been all his prayer, which was +comprehensive enough. But there are older and more obstinate garments +than religions. Illugi the Red and Holm-Starri "exchanged lands and +wives with all their stock." But the plan miscarried, for Sigrid, who +was Illugi's wife, "hanged herself in the Temple because she would not +change husbands." The compliment was greater than Illugi deserved. + +With the world as large as it was in those spacious days there was +room for strange things to happen. Here is the experience of Grim, +son of Ingiald. "He used to row out to fish in the winter with his +thralls, and his son used to be with him. When the boy began to grow +cold they wrapt him in a sealskin bag and pulled it up to his neck. +Grim pulled up a merman. And when he came up Grim said, 'Do thou tell +us our life and how long we shall live, or else thou shalt never +see thy home again.' 'It is of little worth to you to know this,' he +answered,' though it is to the boy in the sealskin bag, for thou shalt +be dead ere the spring come, but thy son shall take up his abode and +take land in settlement where thy mare Skalm shall lie down under the +pack.' They got no more words out of him. But later in the winter Grim +died, and he is buried there." So much for Grim. His widow took her +son forth to Broadfrith, and all that summer Skalm never lay down. +Next year they were on Borgfrith, "and Skalm went on till they came +off the heath south to Borgfrith, where two red sand-dunes were, and +there she lay down under the pack below the outermost sand-well." +There the son of Grim set up his rest. There will nevermore be room in +the world for things like that, but it is pleasant to know of them, + + + + +"WORKS AND DAYS" + + +Some time or another, Apollo my helper, I would choose to write a new +_Works and Days_ wherein the land-lore of our own Boeotia should be +recorded and enshrined for a season. There should be less practice +than Tusser gives you, less art than the _Georgics_, but rather more +of each than Hesiod finds occasion for. Though it is long since I read +the _Georgics_, I seem to remember that the poem was overloaded +with spicy merchandise. You might die of it in aromatic pain. As for +Tusser, certainly he is the complete Elizabethan farmer; sooner than +leave anything out he will say it twice; sooner than say it twice, he +will say it three times. Nevertheless he was a good farmer; as poet, +his itch to be quaint and anxiety to find a rhyme combine to make him +difficult. He writes like Old Moore: + + Strong yoke for a hog, with a twitcher and rings, + With tar in a tarpot, for dangerous things; + A sheep-mark, a tar-kettle, little or mitch, + Two pottles of tar to a pottle of pitch. + +"Mitch" is a desperate rhyme, but nothing to Tusser. He gives you a +league or more of that; all the same, I don't doubt he was a better +farmer than Virgil. More of him anon. + +Hesiod also was a better farmer than Virgil, and a poet into the +bargain, though the Mantuan had him there. He prefers terseness to +eloquence, is on the dry side, and avoids ornament as if he was a +Quaker. Such adjectives as he allows himself are Homer's, well-worn +and familiar. The sea is _atrugetos_, Zeus _hypsibremetes_, the earth +_polyboteire_, the hawk _tanysipteros_, and so on. They have no more +effect upon you than the egg-and-dart mouldings on your cornices. His +own tropes are more curious than beautiful, but I cannot deny +their charm. The spring, with him, is always _gray_--[Greek: polion +ear]--which is exact for the moment when the breaking leaf-buds are no +more than a mist over the woodlands. You shall begin your harvesting-- + + When the House-carrier shuns the Pleiades, + And climbs the stalks to get a little ease. + +The House-carrier is the snail, of course; and he shuns the heat of +the ground, not the Pleiades. Here again is a maxim deeply involved in +language: + + When 'tis a god's high feast let not your knife + Cut off the withered from the quick with life, + Upon the five-brancht stock-- + +or, in other words, never cut your finger-nails on a holy day. + +Hesiod, by birth an AEolian, was by settlement a Boeotian. He lived and +farmed his own land on the slopes of Helikon, under the governance of +the lords of Thespiae, whoever they were. I have been to Thespiae, and +certify that there are no lords there now. I saw little but fleas and +dogs of incredible savagery, where once were the precinct and shrine +of Eros with a famous statue of the god by Praxiteles. It is not far +from the Valley of the Muses, where or whereabouts those fair ladies +met with Hesiod, and, as we are told in the Theogony, plucked him a +rod of olive, a thing of wonder, + + And breath'd in me a voice divine and clear + To sing the things that shall be, are, and were. + +Also they told him to sing of the blessed gods, + + But ever of themselves both first and last, + +and he obeyed them. When he won a tripod at Chalkis, in a singing +contest, he dedicated it to his patronesses, + + There where they first instilled clear song in me. + +So he was a grateful poet, which is very unusual. + +In _Works and Days_ he sang of what he knew best, the country round, +and sang it as a poet should who was also a shrewd farmer and thrifty +husbandman. It is full of the love of earth and of the ways of them +who lie closest in her bosom; but it is full of the wisdom, too, +which such men win from their mother, and are not at all unwilling to +impart. There is a good deal of Polonius in Hesiod, who addresses his +_Works and Days_ to his brother Perses, a bad lot. Perses in fact had +diddled him out of his patrimony, or part of it, by bribing the +judges at Thespiae; and the poet, who doesn't mince matters, loses +no opportunity of telling him what he thinks of him. Indeed, one of +Hesiod's reasons for instructing him in good farming was that thereby +he might perhaps prevent him from spunging on his relations. So +the injured bard got a sad, exalted pleasure out of his griefs, and +something back, too, in his quiet way. + +After a glance at the golden and other past ages he gets to work with +a charming passage: + + Whenas the Pleiads, Atlas' daughters, rise + Begin your harvest; when they hide their eyes, + Then plow. For forty nights and forty days + They are shrouded; then, as the year rounds, they raise + Their shining heads what time unto the stone + You lay your sickle's edge-- + +and that is your time for harvesting. But you must work hard; for the +law of the plains, of the seaboard, and of the upland dales is the +same: + + You who Demeter's gifts will win good cheap + Strip you to plow and sow, and strip to reap-- + +and if you in particular, Perses, will do that, perhaps you won't need +to go begging at other men's houses as you have begged at Hesiod's. +But he gives you warning that you will get no more out of him--than +advice. + +The Pleiades, however, don't set till November, and before that there +is October to be considered, the season of the rains. Get you into +the woods in October and cut for your needs. And what might these +be? Well, a mortar to pound your grain in, and a pestle to pound it +withal; an axle for your wain, a beetle to break the clods. Then, for +your plows, look out for a plow-tree of holm-oak: that is the best +wood for them. Make two plows in case of accident, one all of a piece +([Greek: autogyon]), one jointed and dowelled. The pole should be +of laurel or elm; the share must be oak. The [Greek: gues] is the +plow-tree, and it is not always easy to find one ready-made--but get +one if you can. + + Two oxen then, each one a nine year bull, + Whose strength is not yet spent, the best to pull, + Which will not fight i' the furrow, break the plow + And leave your work undone. To drive them now + Get a smart man of forty, fed to rights + With a four-quartered loaf of eight full bites: + That's one to work, and drive the furrow plim, + Too old to gape at mates, or mates at him. + +That precise loaf, with just that much bitage, is the staple in +Boeotia to-day; but the [Greek: aizeos] of forty will not so readily +be found. Elsewhere in his poem Hesiod recommends something more in +accord with modern practice: + + Your house, your ox, your woman you must have; + For she must drive the plow--not wife but slave. + +The terms are synonymous in Greece to-day. + +Plowing time is when you hear the crane in the clouds overhead. Be +beforehand with your cattle. + + When year by year high in the clouds the crane + Calls in the plow-time and the month of rain, + Take care to feed your oxen in the byre; + For easy 'tis to beg, but hard to hire. + +That is in Tusser's vein, and no doubt comes naturally to rustic +aphorists. A man may plow in the spring, too; and if Zeus should +happen to send rain on the third day, after the cuckoo's first call, +"As much as hides an ox-hoof, and no more," he may do as well as the +autumn-tiller. In any case don't forget your prayers when you begin +plowing: + + You who in hand first the plow-handles feel, + Or on the ox's flank lay the first weal, + Pray Chthonian Zeus and chaste Demeter bless + The grain you sow with heart and heaviness. + +Now for your vines. First, for the pruning, note this: + + When, from the solstice sixty days being fled, + Arcturus leaves the holy Ocean's bed + And, shining, burns the twilight; when that shrill + Child of Pandion opens first her bill-- + Before she twitters, prune your vines! 'Tis best. + +No reasons at all: simply "[Greek: os gar ameinon]." That is like +Homer. The stars continue their signals. Vintage time is when Orion +and Sirius are come to mid-heaven, and rosy-fingered Dawn sees +Arcturus. Then-- + + Cut your grape clusters off and bring to hive; + Show ten days to the sun, ten nights; for five + Cover them up; the sixth day draw all off-- + +That is the way of it, Perses, and much profit to you in my learning, +you scamp. + +Scattered up and down these frosty but kindly old pages are scraps of +wisdom on all kinds of subjects--for life is Hesiod's theme as well +as agriculture. He will tell you under what star to go to sea, if +sail you must; but better not seafare at all. However, if you will go, +choose fifty days after the summer solstice. That is the right time, +the only pretty swim-time. If you must venture out in the spring, let +it be when you see leaves on the fig-tree top as large as the print of +a crow's foot--but even so the thing is desperate. + + For me, I praise it not, nor like at all-- + 'Tis a snatcht thing--mischief is bound to fall. + +Then there's marriage, certainly the greatest venture of all. Don't +think of it until you are rising thirty, anyhow. And as for _her_: + + Let her be four years woman, and no more; + In her fifth year take her, and shut the door + Till she is yours, enured to your good laws. + Take her from near at hand and give no cause + That neighbours find your wedding stuff for mirth: + Than a good wife no better thing on earth; + Than a bad one, what worse? Pot of desire, + That roasts her husband up without a fire! + +That would make her sixteen or thereabouts. Poor child! But neither +Homer, nor Hesiod, nor any Greek I ever read had any mercy on women. +Hesiod in more than one page lets you know what he thinks about them. +It comes hardly from one who in the _Eoioe_(if those apostrophes are +his) was to hymn the great women of history and myth; but there, I +think, spoke the courtier Hesiod, and not the husbandman. + +Lastly come a mort of things which you must not do. Here are some--for +some must be omitted from the decorous page: + + Let not your twelve-year-old presume to sit + On things not to be moved. That's bad. His wit + Will never harden; nor let a twelve-month child. + Let no man wash in water that's defiled + By women washing in it. Bitter price + You pay for that in time. Burnt sacrifice + Mock not, lest Heaven be angry ... So do you + That men talk not against you. Talk's a brew + Mischievous, heady, easy raised, whose sting + Is ill to bear, and not by physicking + Voided. Talk never dies once set a-working-- + Indeed, in talk a kind of god is lurking. + +I regret to record the manner of death of the mainly pleasant old +country poet, still more the supposed cause of it--but it may not +be true. The Oracle at Delphi, which it seems he consulted after his +triumph at Chalkis, warned him that he would come by his end in the +grove of Nemean Zeus. He took pains, therefore, to avoid Nemea in his +travels, and chose to stay for a while at OEnoe in Lokris, "where," +says Mr. Evelyn-White, his editor in the _Loeb Library_, "he was +entertained by Amphiphanes and Ganyktor, sons of Phegeus." But you +never knew when the Oracle would have you, or where. OEnoe was also +sacred to Nemean Zeus, "and the poet, suspected by his hosts of having +seduced their sister, was murdered there. His body, cast into the sea, +was brought to shore by dolphins, and buried at OEnoe; at a later +date his bones were removed to Orchomenos." An unhappy ending for +the instructor of Perses! But it may not be true. To be sure, these +poets--I can only say that to me it sounds improbable, and so, I take +it, it sounded to Alkaeus of Messene, who wrote this epigram upon his +dust: + + When, in the Lokrian grove dead Hesiod lay, + The Nymphs with water washt the stains away. + From their own well they fetcht it, and heapt high + The Mound. Then certain goatherds, being by, + Poured milk and yellow honey on the grave, + Minding the Muses' honey which he gave + Living, that old man stored with poesy. + +That, surely, bespeaks a happier end to Hesiod. It is an epitaph that +any poet might desire. + + + + +THE ENGLISH HESIOD + + +Now for Tusser, whom I feel that I belittled in the last Essay in +order to make a point for the Boeotian. + +"Five Hundreth Points of Good Husbandry United to as Many of Good +Huswifery" was the sixth edition in twenty years of a book which that +fact alone proves to have been a power in its day. It was indeed more +lasting than that, for it had twenty editions between 1557, when +it began with a modest "Hundreth Pointes," and 1692, when the +black-letter quartos ended. Thomas Tusser, the author of it, was +a gentleman-farmer and had the education of one. He began as a +singing-boy at Wallingford, went next to St. Paul's, then to Eton, +where Nicholas Udall gave him once fifty-three strokes, "for fault but +small or none at all"; presently to Cambridge, where Trinity Hall had +him at nurse. All that done, he settled as a farmer under the Lord +Paget in Suffolk; and there it was that in 1557 he published his +notable book. Taking the months _seriatim_, beginning, as he should, +in September, he runs through the whole round of work with an +exhaustiveness and accuracy which could hardly be bettered to-day. +Given a holding of the sort he had, a man might do much worse than +obey old Tusser from point to point. + +He wrote in verse, a verse which is not often much better than those +rustic runes which still survive, wherein weather-lore and suchlike +sometimes prompt and sometimes are prompted by a rhyme. The best of +these semi-proverbial maxims are recalled by the best of Tusser. Take +this of the autumn winds as an example: + + The West, as a father, all goodness doth bring, + The East, a forbearer, no manner of thing; + The South, as unkind, draweth sickness too near, + The North, as a friend, maketh all again clear. + +But he can be more pointed than that and no less just--as when he is +telling the maids how to wash linen: + + "Go wash well," saith Summer, "with sun I shall dry." + "Go wring well," saith Winter, "with wind so shall I." + +He is never dull if he is never eloquent; he is always wise if he is +seldom witty. Among the Elizabethan poets there will have been many of +a lowlier quality, many who could not have reached the piety and sweet +humour of "My friend if cause doth wrest thee," which, with its happy +close of "And sit down, Robin, and rest thee," is the best known of +all his rhymes. As a verbal acrobat I don't suppose any of them +could approach him. His greatest feat in that kind was his "Brief +Conclusion" in twelve lines, every word in every line of which began +with T. Thus: + + The thrifty that teacheth the thriving to thrive, + Teach timely to traverse the thing that thou 'trive, + +and so on. If _Peter Piper_ dates so early, Tusser beats it +handsomely. + +For the rest, he writes doggerel, and has no other pretensions that I +can see. All the Elizabethans did, Shakespeare among the best of +them. And I don't know that Shakespeare's doggerel is much better +than Tusser's doggerel. It is something that, swimming in such a brave +company, he should keep his head above water; and something more that +in one other point Tusser can vie with the foremost. His knack of +christening his personages with _ad hoc_ names recalls Shakespeare's, +which, with its Dick the Carter and Marian's nose, was of the same +kind and degree. Here is an example, where he wishes to instil the +value of hedge-mending. If you let your fences down, he says: + + At noon, if it bloweth, at night if it shine, + Out trudgeth Hew Makeshift with hook and with line; + While Gillet his blowse is a milking thy cow, + Sir Hew is a rigging thy gate, or thy plow. + +Autolycus sang like that. Now take an allusive couplet addressed to +the house-mistress, that she by all means see the lights out: + + Fear candle in hay-loft, in barn, and in shed, + Fear Flea-smock and Mend-breech for burning their bed. + +Right Shakespearian direction: few words and to the mark. But Tusser +is seldom up to that level, and never on it long. + +We may as well be clear about the kind of farmer Tusser was before we +go any further. A farmer, indeed, he happens to have been; but he was +also a husbandman. A farmer in his day was a man who paid a yearly +rent for something, by no means necessarily land. To farm a thing was +to pay a rent for it. You could farm the tithe, or the King's taxes; +you could farm a landlord's rent-roll, a corporation's market-dues, +the profits of a bridge or of a highway. The first farmers of land +were the men who took over all the estates of a monastery, paying the +holy men a sufficiency, and making what they could over and above. +In Elizabeth's time the great landlords had taken a leaf out of the +monks' book, and the farmer of land was becoming more common. There +were yet, however, many husbandmen who were not farmers at all: yeomen +of soccage tenure, and tenants by copy of court-roll. That class was +probably the most numerous of all, and Tusser, though he objected to +its common fields, or "champion land," as he calls it, had plenty to +tell them. He must, I think, himself have been a copyholder in +his day, so feelingly does he deal with the detriments of a +champion-holding. The need, for example, of watching the beasts +straying at will over the open fields! + + Where champion wanteth a swineherd for hog + There many complaineth of naughty man's dog. + Where each his own keeper appoints without care, + There corn is destroyed ere men be aware + +And again more bitterly: + + Some pester the commons with jades and with geese, + With hog without ring, and with sheep without fleece. + Some lose a day's labour with seeking their own, + Some meet with a booty they would not have known. + Great troubles and losses the champion sees, + And even in brawling, as wasps among bees: + As charity that way appeareth but small; + So less be their winnings, or nothing at all. + +The probabilities are that he was quite right; but so long as copyhold +endured so long lasted the open fields. + +Tusser's holding, and that of every husbandman in England in his time, +was self-sufficient. Not only did you eat your own mutton, make your +own souse, your own beer, cheese, butter, wine, cordials, and physic; +you built your own house, made your own roads, fenced your own lands, +contrived your own plows, wains, wagons, wheelbarrows, and all manner +of tools. But much more than that. You grew your own hemp, had your +own ropewalk, twisted your own twine; you grew your flax and wove your +linen; you tanned and dressed your own leather, cut and spun your own +wool, made, no doubt, your own clothes. Indeed, you stood four-square +to fate in Tusser's time; and in that particular, as well as in +another which I must speak of next, you were much nearer to Hesiod's +farmer than to ours. This precept of his upon the uses of your +woodland recalls Hesiod directly: + + Save elm, ash and crabtree for cart and for plow; + Save step for a stile of the crotch of the bough; + Save hazel for forks, save sallow for rake; + Save hulver and thorn, whereof flail to make. + +Hulver is holly. In the same section (April) he has a verse about +stone-picking which will show his encyclopaedic grip of his matter: + + Where stones be too many, annoying thy land, + Make servant come home with a stone in his hand: + By daily so doing, have plenty ye shall, + Both handsome for paving and good for a wall. + +He bought little or nothing, trafficked very much by barter, and had +scarcely any need for money. His men and maids lived in the house, and +if they were paid anything, he does not say so. I suppose they were +paid something, those of them who were not apprentices, bound for a +seven years' term. They stood to his wife and himself as children, had +their keep, learned their business, married each other by and by, +and probably set up for themselves with a pig and a cock and hen on +a pightle of land of the master's. It was a family relationship well +into the eighteenth century. Horace Walpole used to call his servants +his family. With the privilege of parenthood went the power of the +rod. There's no doubt about that: maid and man had it if it was +earned. In his dairy instruction Tusser gives us a list of "ten +topping guests unsent for," whose presence in the cheese will cause +Cicely to rue it. There are: + + Gehazi, Lot's wife, and Argus his eyes, + Tom Piper, poor Cobler, and Lazarus's thighs: + Rough Esau, with Maudlin, and gentles that scrawl, + With Bishop that burneth--ye thus know them all. + +Gehazi the leper is in cheese when it is white and dry; Lot's wife +when it is too salt; Argus's eyes are obvious: + + Tom Piper hath hoven and puffed up cheeks; + +poor Cobler is there when it is leathery; Esau betrays himself by +hairs, Maudlin by weeping; and as for the "Bishop that burneth" the +explanation is complicated. It seems that Cicely would run after the +bishop for his blessing, and leave the milk on the fire to burn.[A] +For all these ill-timed guests you are to baste Cicely, or "tug her +a crash," or "make her seek creeks"; you "call her a slut," or "dress +her down." But you encourage her at the end with this quatrain: + + "If thou, so oft beaten, + Amendest by this, + I will no more threaten, + I promise thee, Cis." + +[Footnote A: A correspondent from Yorkshire gives me a better +explanation. In that county burnt milk is still said to be "bishoped." +The bishop's power of the keys is thought to be hinted.] + +Fizgig, too, which is his lively name for the kitchen knave, gets the +holly-wand across his quarters when he deserves it; but Tusser seems +to feel that discipline may be overdone. It may be waste of good stick +and good pains, for: + + As rod little mendeth where manners be spilt, + So naught will be naught, say and do what thou wilt; + +and he is careful to remind you in concluding his chapter of Huswifely +Admonitions that you had always better smile than scold: + + Much brawling with servant, what man can abide? + Pay home when thou fightest, but love not to chide. + +The whole matter of servants is amusing or rueful study nowadays, +accordingly as one looks at servants. Their treatment under Tusser's +handling brings the husbandman poet very near to Hesiod, in whose time +servitude was not called by any other name. Tusser's huswife, warned +by the matin cock, called up her maids and men at four in the summer, +at five in the winter. She packed them off to bed at ten or nine at +night, according to the season, and, it would appear, to bed in the +dark. She made her own candles, and feared also a fire, which will +account for that. There was no early tea for Mistress Tusser's maids, +let me tell you: + + Some slovens from sleeping no sooner get up + But hand is in aumbry and nose is in cup. + +Nothing of the kind with Mrs. Tusser. On the other hand, hard work all +round: "Sluts' corner" to be ridded; sweeping, dusting, mop-twirling, + + Let some to peel hemp, or else rushes to twine, + To spin or to card, to seething of brine; + +and as for the men: + + Let some about cattle, some pastures to view, + Some malt to be grinding against ye do brew. + +And so to breakfast. The morning star was the signal for it; and a +hasty meal was expected of you: + + Call servants to breakfast, by day-star appear, + A snatch, and to work--fellows tarry not here. + +You had porridge and a scrap of meat, and if you laid hands on +something sweeter, look out for Mrs. Tusser: + + "What tack in a pudding?" saith greedy gut-wringer: + Give such ye wot what, ere a pudding he finger. + +And, summarily, of breakfast there is this to be understood, that it +is a thing of grace, not of custom: + + No breakfast of custom provide for to save, + But only for such as deserveth to have. + +Very near Hesiod indeed! + +For your dinner at noon you were more hospitably served. First of all, +it was ready for you: + + By noon see your dinner be ready and neat: + Let meat tarry servant not servant his meat. + +And you were to have enough--plain fare, but enough. + + Give servants no dainties, but give them enow; + Too many chaps wagging do beggar the plow; + +but even here you would get according to your deserts. If you were +lazy at your threshing, you would be given a "flap and a trap," +whatever those may be. And you were expected to eat the trencher bare: + + Some gnaweth and leaveth, some crusts and some crumbs: + Eat such their own leavings, or gnaw their own thumbs. + +In the hot weather you had time for sleep allowed you: + + From May to mid-August an hour or two + Let Patch sleep a snatch, howsoever ye do. + Though sleeping one hour refresheth his song + Yet trust not Hob Grouthead for sleeping too long. + +Then came afternoon work, and at last supper. Here the mistress might +unbend somewhat; for, as Tusser puts it: + + Whatever God sendeth, be merry withal. + +She had still, however, an eye for the servants: + + No servant at table use sauc'ly to talk, + Lest tongue set at large out of measure do walk; + No lurching, no snatching, no striving at all, + Lest one go without, and another have all. + +And then a final word: + + Declare after supper--take heed thereunto-- + What work in the morning each servant shall do. + +And then--bed! + +There were feast days, of course: Christmas to Epiphany was one long +feast; then Plow Monday, Shrovetide, Sheep-shearing, Wake-Day, Harvest +Home, Seed-Cake--these as the times came round. But there was a weekly +regale too, which was known as Twice-a-Week-Roast. On Sundays and +Thursdays a hot joint was the custom at supper. Tusser is clear about +the value and sanction at once: + + Thus doing and keeping such custom and guise, + They call thee good huswife--they love thee likewise. + +Those days are past and done, with much to regret and much to be +thankful for. You trained good servants that way--but did you make +good men and women? Some think so, and I among them; but such training +is two-edged, and while I feel sure that the girls and lads were +the better for the discipline, I cannot believe that the masters and +mistresses were. They nursed arrogance; out of them came the tyrants +and gang-drivers of the eighteenth century, Act of Settlement, the +Enclosure Acts, Speenhamland, rick-burning, machine-breaking, and the +Bloody Assize of 1831. Well, now the reckoning has come, and Hodge +will have Farmer Blackacre at his discretion. + +One or two variations from modern practice may be noted. The +Elizabethan husbandman grew, I have said, his own flax and hemp; he +grew his vines too, and Tusser bids him prune them in February. I, who +grow mine, call that full early. He does not tell us when he gathered +his grapes or (what I very much want to know) how he made his +wine--whether with pure fermented grape-juice, which is the French +way, or by adding water and sugar to the must, which is our present +English fashion. Again, he used sheep's milk both for draught and for +butter-making. I wish we had sheep's milk butter. No one who has had +it in Greece would be without it at home if he could help it. You +weaned the lambs at Philip and Jacob, he says, if you wanted any milk +from the ewe. Lastly, he grew saffron, which he pared between the two +St. Mary's days. To pare is to strip the soil with a breast-plow. +The two St. Mary's days were July 22 and August 15, which would be a +pretty good time to plant saffron. + +We also, in my country, date our operations by holy days, long after +the holy men have ceased to be commemorated. Who knows St. Gregory's +Day? It is March 12. Marrowfat peas go into the drill: + + Sow runcivals timely, and all that is grey; + But sow not the white till St. Gregory's Day. + +I will undertake that half a dozen old hands round about my house +follow out this rule in its entirety. + + + + +FLOWER OF THE FIELD + + +A county inquiry took me, one day last summer, deeply into the Plain, +up and over a rutty track which my driver will have cause to remember. +An uncommonly large hawk soaring over his prey, and so near the ground +that I could see the light through his ragged plumes, a hare limping +through the bents, further off a crawling flock bustling after +shepherd and dog, were all the living things I saw. The ground was +iron, the colour of what had once been herbage a glaring brown. Of the +flowers none but the hardiest had outlived the visitation of the sun. +I saw rest-harrow which has a root like whipcord, and the flat thistle +which thrives in dust. The harebells floated no more, the discs of the +scabious were shrivelled husks; ladies' bedstraw was straw indeed, but +not for ladies' uses. Three miles away from anywhere we came upon a +clump of dusty sycamores whose leaves were spotted and beginning to +fall; beyond them was a squat row of flint and brick bungalows, the +goal of our quest. There were three tenements, of which two were +empty. In the third lives the shepherd who had called me up to +consider his circumstances. + +There was thunder about, though not visibly; a day both airless and +pitiless; one of those days when you feel that the unseen powers are +conspiring against your peace. A naked sun from a naked sky stared +down upon a naked earth. It seemed to me that the hawk had been a +figure of more than himself and his purpose; I saw him as Homer's +people saw their eagles. Just as he hung aloft so hung the sun, intent +upon the life of our cowering ball. Not elsewhere in England have I +seen so shadeless a place, or one so unfitted for human intercourse, +so lacking in the comfort, which human sensibilities need. We live in +nature as hunted things, beasts of chase. Every eye is upon us in fear +or dislike; but in our turn, cursed as well as blessed by imagination, +we people the wild with dreadful shapes of menace. The heat, the cold, +the wind and the rain work as much against us as for us. We endow them +with minds like our own, but magnified by our dismay to be the minds +of gods maleficent. Without shelter of our own provision we are +comfortless, and without comfort our souls perish, then our bodies. +Salisbury Plain, swooning in the heat, is a paradise for insects. In +those desolate dwellings both flies and (I am sure) fleas abounded, +dreadfully healthy and alive. I only guess at the fleas, but the flies +I can answer for. They swarmed on the baking walls and wove webs in +the air above us. The rooms were black with them, and their humming +filled them up with noise. + +Here lived the shepherd, too heavily taxed as he thought for his +hermitage; here lived his family of half a dozen swarthy and beautiful +children; and here we discussed the state of affairs, since the +shepherd was abroad, with his daughter, a flower of the field. She +came out of this stivy tenement at the sound of our boiling radiator, +and stood framed in the doorway, shading her eyes against the sun, a +tall and graceful, very pretty girl, dressed in cool white which might +have been fresh from its cardboard box, as she herself might have +stepped from her typewriter and Government office at Whitehall. +Gentle-voiced, quiet and self-possessed, she showed us the conditions +of her lot. One living-room, two bedrooms, and a washhouse in a shed: +three miles over the grass to shop, church, post-office, and doctor; +half a mile to call up a neighbour in case of need. A rain-water tank, +less than a quarter full of last winter's rain, must keep clean her +house and her, and for drinking she was served by a galvanised tank in +full sun, which she was lucky to get filled once a week. + +I tasted of it. The water was warm, flat, and not too clean. "Where +does this come from?" "It is fetched in a barrel from over the hill." +"Who brings it?" "The farmer--but he makes a fuss whenever we ask for +it." "He must water the stock, surely?" "Oh yes, and the sheep, too, +but--" A pregnant aposiopesis. I wondered if that tank could not be +put in the shade; but it seemed that it could not. The water had to be +drawn from the barrel, the barrel was on wheels; time was short, life +was tough; and so--you see! We did justice to the shepherd. + +It is shocking that a man should live so, held of less account than +the sheep which he rears; but it is admirable that this man should +live as he does. The house, to call it so, was as clean as a dairy; +the children were neat, washed and brushed; the girl was one for +Herrick to have sung of. I wish that I could have seen the shepherd, +though it may well be that his wife, if she is alive, would reveal +more. Something told me that he was a widower, and that this fair +young woman mothered his brood for him. What she had of the nest-lore +can only have come from a shrewd mistress of it. I did not see a book +in the place, nor a newspaper. + +Life out there, on such terms, is more solitary than in +Northumberland, where the farms are isolated and self-sufficient, +but all the hinds' dwellings are clustered, and society may be had. +I don't believe you can set up for a successful hermit without a +long education; and although a shepherd himself may be one by a stern +schooling in solitude, you should not expect it of his daughter. Here +was a girl made for social amenity, who would want to be danced +with, flirted with, courted with flowers, sweets and other delicate +observance. She deserved admiration both to receive and impart. It is +useless to talk about nature; the love of that is both sophisticated +and acquired. Nothing to her the great blue spaces of the Plain, the +brooded mystery of Stonehenge, the companionship of her long-dead +ancestry, dust in their barrows. No solace for her, after the burden +of the day, in the large solemnity of evening out there, which to +some of us would call a message almost vocal. To me, for instance, a +summer's dusk, a moonrise on the Plain, are poems without words. Heard +melodies are sweet, but those unheard--! + +For whom, then, had she adorned herself in white raiment, for whom +dressed her dark hair? Not for us, that's certain. She had had no +notice of our coming. That she should do such things for their own +sake, _elegantia quadam prope divinum_, was original virtue in her. +Solomon in all his glory had been no goodlier sight; and if she toiled +or spun to achieve it, her state, I should say, is by so much the +more gracious. And what the devil does she do with herself in the long +winter nights, when you light the lamp at four and see nothing of the +sun till eight the next morning--and she arrayed like a lily of the +field? There's mending, but you have the afternoon for that; a letter +to a brother in Canada; let us hope there's one to a sweetheart not so +far away. And then--what? To-morrow, and to-morrow, and to-morrow. + + + + +UNDER THE HARVEST MOON + + +She is at her full, and even as I write rising red and heavy in the +south-west. All night long she will look down upon at least one corner +of the earth satiate with the good things of life. I don't remember +such a September as this has been for many years past. Misty, +gossamered mornings, a day all blue and pale gold, bees in the +ivy bloom, sprawling overblown flowers, red apples, purpling +vine-clusters, clear evenings: then this smouldering moon to go to +bed by! It is all like a great Veronese wall-picture, or the Masque +in _The Tempest_--"Rich scarf to my proud earth!"--and summons from +me more adjectives than I have needed this twelvemonth. It is indeed +adjectival weather; for Nature is still adding, not discarding stores. +The last act of the "maturing sun" is to ingerminate the flowers and +fruit which will bless or tantalise us next year. + +Now is the time when maids get up at six and hunt for mushrooms in +the dew; now the good wives of the village make wine of all sorts of +unlikely fruits, blackberries, elderberries, peaches, pears, and, of +all things in the world, parsnips. I have lately been given of this +wine to taste. It is a cordial rather than a wine and on the good +rather than the bad side. The addition of spices is admitted; +nevertheless out of a particularly mawkish vegetable is made a +palatable drink. "Out of the strong come forth sweetness." After it I +shall be prepared to find a potable in the banana, which is favoured +by many people, of whom I am not one. But I don't find it nastier than +the parsnip, and it is evident that fermentation can work miracles. + +In such a year as this I, too, shall have a vintage. For the first +time in my life I shall tread my own winepress, vat my own must, +and (I hope) need no sugar for it. I don't know why it is, but I can +conceive no more romantic rural adventure than that of growing and +drinking your own wine. But there are yet many things to happen. The +grapes must get ripe and the wasps be kept off; and then there are +problems connected with vinification which I have not yet solved. The +Marquis of Bute could tell me all about it, and I wish he would. +He has made wine at Castle Coch these many years, and of the most +excellent. Unfortunately I have not his acquaintance, so I invite +advice, and shall be grateful for it. The chief of my perplexities are +concerned with the beginning of fermentation and the end of it. For +the first, should I use yeast? My neighbours here say, yes; the French +tell me that I don't need it, the grapes having enough of their own. +Pass that and consider the second point. Having started your ferment, +how do you stop it?[A] Fermentation in Italy goes on in the barrel, +after the liquor has left the vat. That gives you a peculiar prickly +wine which the Italians call "Frizzante" and profess to like. Our word +for it is "beastly." + +[Footnote A: Since that was written I have learned the answer. It +stops itself--why, I don't know, unless by the grace of God.] + +My village gossips tell me that fermentation will stop of itself when +I draw the wine off the lye; but the French practice certainly seems +to be to burn sulphur matches in the vat and so kill the vinegar germs +there latent. And then _platrage_? You sprinkle the must with plaster +of Paris before fermentation begins. Is that done in England? It is +not done in this part of England at least. Nor do I know why it +is done in France. Probably before I have solved my problems by +stomach-ache and other experiences of a biliary kind, prohibition +will be in the air over here, wafted upon some newspaper breeze from +America. There will be no difficulty in starting a fermentation out of +that sweeping doctrine, that's for certain. I don't say that we need +take prohibition seriously; but we think about it, naturally, and talk +about it out here. + +If it were put to the local vote in this village, it would be lost. +We have many total abstainers, yet one of them, I know, and several of +them, I believe, would vote against it. Says the one I am sure of: +"If I abstain from strong drink, as I do, it is my own doing; and if I +were tempted to a fall and withstood it, that is to my credit. But if +the law cuts me off it, and I am a criminal if I drink, it cuts me off +a good part of my credit too--and I am against that." My friend has +there put his finger upon a sharp little dilemma. If alcohol is a bad +thing, then prohibition is a good thing. But if temperance is a good +thing, then prohibition is a bad thing. You cannot be temperate in the +use of alcohol if you have none. Nor is sobriety a virtue in you if +you lock up the wine-cellar and throw the keys down the well. Very +well; then will you do without alcohol or without temperance? There is +the choice; and I have made mine. + +Besides, we are all for liberty down here, individualists to a man. +Give us a loophole to avoid compulsion and we use it. One of the +most frequently exercised of my magisterial functions is to certify +conscientious objections to the Vaccination Act. I do it against the +grain. A doctor told me the other day that he believed smallpox had +reached the end of its tether, and was on the ebb. I am sure I hope +so, lest there should be one day a bad outbreak among these liberty +men. I must have signed away the chances of hundreds of children, who, +by the way, are not of an age to consent. I never fail to point out +the risk; but the Court awards it and the law allows it; so I sign. + +There is much to be said for Anarchy in the abstract, nothing at all +in the concrete. Mr. Smillie, however, appears to favour it, raw, +rough and ready. In that he is precocious, and, like the rathe +primrose, will "forsaken die." He will rend the Labour party in twain +from the top to the bottom, and will see the agricultural vote drop +off his industrials just as it had begun to adhere to them. I know the +peasantry. They will never strike for political ends, for though they +are not quick to see the consequences of hypothetical actions, they +do see that if you make Parliamentary government impossible you make a +Labour majority not worth having. + +And another thing: Mr. Smillie and his friends may want a revolution, +but Hodge and his most certainly do not. They want to earn their +livelihood, pay their way, and dig their plots of ground. No more +warfare for them. I dare say I shall be sorry for Mr. Smillie when +the time comes; but I may have to be still more sorry for my country +first. I can't help hoping, however, when it comes to the point that +his feet will be a little colder than his head seems to be just now. + + + + +_LA PETITE PERSONNE_ + + +No letter-writer's stage can at any time be called empty, because upon +it you necessarily have at all times two persons at least: the mover +of the figures and the audience, the puppeteer and the puppetee, the +letter-writer and the letter-reader. The play presented is, therefore, +a play within a play: like the _Mousetrap_ in _Hamlet_, like _Pyramus +and Thisbe_ in _A Midsummer Night's Dream_, like the romantic drama +of _Gayferos and Melisandra_ which Don Quixote witnessed with a select +company of acquaintance at an inn. The temperament of this presented +spectator, himself or herself a person of the scene, is always +reflected in the entertainment when the letter-writer is a sensitive +artist. So Horace Walpole's comedy varies according as it goes before +Sir Horace Mann in Florence or Lady Upper-Ossory at Ampthill; so, more +delicately, does Madame de Sevigne's. There are blacker strokes in +the dialogue when Bussy is to see the play; there is always idolatry +implied, and sometimes anxiety, if the spoilt child of Provence is the +audience. It is this _chere bonne_, this Madame de Grignan, nine times +out of ten, who is queen of the entertainment. You have to reckon with +her upon her throne of degrees, set up there like Hippolita, Duchess +of Athens, to be propitiated and, if possible, diverted. For her sake, +not for ours, her incomparable mother beckons from the wings character +after character, and gives each his cue, having set the scene with +her exquisite art. In a few cases her anxiety to please spoils the +effects. As we should say, she "laboured" the Cardinal de Retz. The +sour-faced beauty would have none of him. But that is a rare case, one +in which predilection betrayed her. Madame de Sevigne had a weakness +for the Cardinal. It is very seldom that the lightest hand in the +world fails her at a portrait. Her great successes are her thumb-nail +sketches: she will be remembered by Picard in the hayfield so long +as the world knows how to laugh. One of her best, because one of her +tenderest, is the _petite personne_. + +The name is Charles de Sevigne's, but his mother takes it up after +him, and makes better play with it. Charles writes from Les Rochers in +December, 1675--Madame being really ill for once in her life with "a +nice little rheumatism," and Charles her amanuensis--"in the room of +la Plessis," that striving lady, too, was ill, or thought she was--"we +have had lately a very pretty young party (_une petite personne fort +jolie_) whose good looks don't at all remind us of that divinity. At +her instigation we have started _Reversis_: now, instead of knaves, +we talk about jacks." He adds a stroke too good to be lost, though his +mother might have left it out. "To give you a notion of her age and +quality, she has just confided to us that the day after Easter Eve was +a Tuesday. She thought that over, then said, 'No--it was a Monday!' +Then, judging by the look of us that that wouldn't do either, +'Heavens, how stupid! Of course--it was a Friday!' That is the kind +of party we are. If you wouldn't mind sending us word what day of the +week you believe it to have been, you will save us a great deal of +discomfort." The stage is the brisker for the coming in of this pretty +_soubrette_. + +Madame de Sevigne, meantime, is in a discomfort of her own. It takes +her some ten days to absorb the _petite personne_, but then she fixes +her for ever. Nobody can wish to know more about a young party than +this: + + "_Christmas Day_ (1675).... I still have that nice child here. + She lives on the other side of the park; her mother is the + good-wife Marcile's daughter--but you won't remember her. The + mother lives at Rennes, but I shall keep her here. She plays + _trictrac, reversis;_ she is quite pretty, quite innocent, and + called Jeannette. She is no more trouble than Fidele." + +Quite pretty, quite innocent and called Jeannette! _Quid Plura?_ Need +I say who Fidele was? Fidele is a shrewd touch of Madame's, put in, +as I guess, to placate the hungry-eyed Goddess of Grignan; but it +does clinch the portrait. All that one needs to know of the nature, +parentage, and upbringing of a _petite personne_ is in these two +letters. + +Immediately upon her entry the comedy begins, with Mademoiselle du +Plessis in a leading part. "... La Plessis has a quartan fever. It is +pretty to see her jealous fury when she comes here and finds the +child with me. The fuss there is to have my stick or muff to hold! But +enough of these nothings...." + +It was of nothings that the vexed days of Mlle. du Plessis must exist. +An elderly virgin, evidently; stiff, gauche, full of _guinderie_, says +Madame, "_et de l'esprit fichu_." Everybody made game of her at Les +Rochers. As we shall see, the servants knew that very well. Charles is +always witty at her expense. Madame de Grignan once slapped her. + +Meanwhile, here's another vignette, a Chardin picture--you will find +nothing by Greuze of this _petite personne_. "... What do you think +of the handy little lady we were telling you of, who couldn't make out +what the day after Easter Eve was? She is a dear little rosebud of a +thing who delights us." + +"'In six years to come she'll be twenty years old!' I wish you could +see her in the mornings, eating a hunk of bread-and-butter as long as +from here to Easter, or, after dinner, crunching up two green apples +with brown bread...." + +But now the clowns come tumbling in, to turn over the poor du Plessis. +"... Mlle. du Plessis will die of the _petite personne_. Being more +than half dead of jealousy already, she is always at my people to find +out how I treat her. Not one of them but has a pin ready. One says +that I love her as much as I do you; another that I have her to sleep +with me--which would assuredly be a notable sign of affection! They +swear that I am taking her to Paris, that I kiss her, am mad about +her; that the Abbe is giving her 10,000 _livres_; that if she had but +20,000 _ecus_ I should marry her to my son. That is the sort of thing; +and they carry it so far that we can't help laughing at it. The poor +lady is ill with it all." + +To the same letter Charles adds his scene in the farce: "La Plessis +said to Rahuel (he was the concierge) yesterday that she had been +gratified at dinner to find that Madame had turned the child out of +her seat and put herself in the place of honour. And Rahuel, in his +Breton way: 'Nay, Miss, there's no wonder. 'Tis an honour to your +years, naturally. Besides, the little girl is one of the house, as +you might say. Madame looks on her almost as she might be Madame de +Grignan's little sister.'" + +La Plessis, in fact, agonised, and the way was made for the great +scene--so good a scene that I think it must have been bagged for +the theatre. Labiche must surely have lifted it. It is Charles de +Sevigne's masterpiece. + + "The young party here, when she saw how my mother's pains + increased towards night, thought that the best thing she could + do for her was to cry--which she did. She is that sort, and + always the focus of jealousy for la Plessis, who tries to + recommend herself to my mother by hating her like the devil. + This is what happened yesterday. My mother was dozing quietly + in bed; the child, the Abbe and I were by the fire. In came La + Plessis. We warned her to come quietly, and she did, and was + half across the room when my mother coughed, and then asked + for her handkerchief to get rid of some phlegm. The child and + I jumped up to get it, but La Plessis was too quick for us, + rushed to the bed, and instead of putting the thing to my + mother's lips, caught hold of her nose with it, and pinched + it so hard that the poor dear cried out with the pain. She + couldn't help being sniffy with the old fuss who had hurt + her so--nor laughing at her afterwards. If you had seen this + little comedy you would have laughed too." + +I should like to know who wouldn't have laughed to tears, after it was +over. The scene is priceless. + +But all the same, it is not Madame de Sevigne's _genre_. She is +mistress of the chuckle, not of the _fou rire_; and La Plessis is not +one of her best characters. The _petite personne_, however, is; and I +must give a very pretty scene, quite in her own manner, where she is +half laughing at the child and half in love with her too. + + "The _petite personne_ is still here, and always delightful. + She has a sharp little wit of her own, too, as new as a young + chick's. We enjoy telling her things, for she knows nothing + at all, and it makes a kind of game to enlighten her on + all sides--with a word or two about the Universe, or about + Empires, or countries, or kings, or religions, or wars, or + Fate, or the map. There's a pretty jumble of facts to put + tidily away in a little head which has never seen a town, nor + even a river, and has never really supposed that the world + went any farther than the end of the park! But she is + delicious. I was telling her to-day about the taking of + Wismar; and she understands quite well that we are sorry about + it because the King of Sweden is our ally. See how wildly we + amuse ourselves." + +The last sentence is for the _chere bonne's_ benefit, who was very +capable herself of being jealous of the _petite personne_. I fancy +the touch about Fidele was put in with the same object. She had to be +infinitely careful with the _chere bonne's_ black dogs. + +In another month the _petite personne_ is so far advanced that she +can be secretary to her patroness, whose poor hand is too swollen to +write. Elaborate perambulations introduce her to the _chere bonne_. +"My son has gone to Vitre on some business or other. That is why I +give his functions of secretary over to the little lady of whom I +have often told you, and who begs you to be pleased to allow her, with +great respect, to kiss your hands." That, I should think, was courtesy +enough even for the pouting great lady of Provence. In a later letter +she kisses Madame de Grignan's _left_ hand; so it is written--by +herself, but to dictation. Thus the proper distances were kept by one +as humane as Madame de Sevigne when she was dealing with her daughter +on the other side of idolatry. + +But she herself and the child are on better terms than such discipline +would imply. In February: "... My letters are so full of myself that +it bores me to have them read over. You have too much taste not to be +bored too. So I shall stop: even the child is laughing at me now." And +then in March: "... My son has left us--we are quite alone, the child +and I--reading, writing, and saying our prayers." A jolly little +picture of still and gentle life. No Greuze there. + +The idyll ends in tears, but not just yet. Two days before she leaves +Brittany, having "neither rhyme nor reason in my hands," she makes use +of the _petite personne_ for the last time: "the most obliging child +in the world. I don't know what I should have done without her. She +reads me what I like--quite well; she writes as you see; she is fond +of me; she is willing; she can talk about Madame de Grignan. In fact, +you may love her on my assurance." And then the poor little dear puts +in her little word for herself to propitiate this formidable Countess +in Provence: + +"That would make me very happy, Madame, and I am sure that you must +envy my joy to be with your mother. She has been pleased to make me +write all that praise of myself, though I was rather ashamed to do it. +But I am very unhappy that she is going away." + +Madame resumes the pen: "... The child, desired to converse with you +..."--which one may or may not believe. If, as I feel sure, she was +bidden to the task, I don't see how she could possibly have brought it +off better than in those demure phrases. But is she not a dear little +creature? + +Then came the dreadful day, the 24th of March, and Madame's coach and +six horses carry her to Laval on her way to Paris. She stays there +for the night and writes, of course, to her _chere bonne_: "... They +carried off the _petite personne_ early this morning to save me the +outcries of her grief. They were the sobs of a child, so natural that +they moved me. I dare say she is dancing about now, but for two days +she has been in floods, not having been able to learn restraint from +me!" Madame, as we know, had abundantly the gift of tears, and was +assuredly none the worse for it. + +In Paris, Corbinelli was secretary for a time; but she regretted the +_petite personne_. "... I don't like a secretary who is cleverer than +I am.... The child suited me much better." + +And there the happy little figurine, having danced her hour at Les +Rochers, leaves the stage. Other _petites personnes_ there are--one +the sister of _La Murinette Beaute_, who got on so well with M. de +Rohan, and was a lady of Madame de Chaulnes', and presently married +a respectable gentleman, a M. de le Bedoyere of Rennes. But these are +too high levels for the granddaughter of the good-wife Marcile. That +_petite personne_, moreover, was a rather sophisticated young lady. +One would never have seen her, in the mornings, munching a hunk of +bread-and-butter "as long as from here to Easter." No; Jeannette has +fulfilled her part, providing a whiff of marjoram and cottage flowers +for the castle chambers. She has read, written and said her prayers. +She has the firm outline, the rosy cheeks, the simplicity of a Watteau +peasant-girl--nothing of the Greuze languish, with its hint of a +_cruche cassee_. She is as fresh as a March wind. Let us believe that +she found a true man to relish her prettiness and sharp little wits. + + + + +A FOOL OF QUALITY + + +Tom Coryat, the "single-soled, single-souled and single-shirted +observer of Odcombe," having finally bored his neighbours in the +country past bearing, was volleyed off upon a tempest of their yawns +to London. Exactly when that was I can't find out, but I suppose it to +have been in the region of 1605. + +In London he set up for a wit, was enrolled in "The Right Worshipful +Fraternity of Sireniacal Gentlemen," who met at "The Sign of the +Mere-maide in Bread Streete"; had John Donne and Ben Jonson among his +convives, and may well have seen Shakespeare and heard him talk, if +he did talk. How he appeared himself we can only guess, but I conceive +his position in the society to have been that of Polonius in the +convocation of politic worms, as one, namely, where he was eaten +rather than eating. That, if it was so, may have determined him to +make a name for himself by what was his strongest part, namely, his +feet. + +In 1608 he, the "Odcombian leg-stretcher," did indeed travel "for five +months, mostly on foot, from his native place of Odcombe in Somerset, +through France, Savoy, Italy, Rhetia, Helvetia, some parts of High +Germany, and the Netherlands, making in the whole 1975 miles." He +started on the 14th May and was in London again on the 3rd October, +and if indeed he did travel mostly on foot, I call it a very +creditable performance. The result was a book more talked of than +read. "Coryat's Crudities, hastily gobbled up in five months' travels +... newly digested in the hungry aire of Odcombe in his county of +Somerset, and now dispersed to the nourishment of the travelling +members of this Kingdom." So runs the text of a Palladian title-page, +surrounded by emblems of adventure which support a _vera effigies_ of +Tom himself. He shows there as a beady-eyed bonhomme of thirty-five +or so, with a Jacobean beard, and his hair brushed back and worn long, +like that of our present-day young men. + +The book published, the Sireniacal Gentlemen took off their coats and +took up their battledores. Their gibes and quirks are all printed in +my edition, and are better reading than the book itself. Coryat was a +cockscomb and scorned a straight sentence. A rule of his was: "Never +use one adjective if three will do." So far as I know he was the first +Englishman who travelled for the fun or the glory of the thing, unless +Fynes Moryson anticipated him in those also, as he certainly did in +travelling and writing about it. But I think it more probable that +Moryson went abroad to improve his mind. I don't think Coryat had any +notion of that. Foppery may have moved him, vanity perhaps; in any +case there can be no comparison between them. Moryson is thorough, +Coryat is not. Moryson is often dull, Coryat seldom. Moryson was +a student, Coryat a cockscomb. Moryson was a plain man, Coryat a +euphuist of the first water. I haven't the least doubt but that +Shakespeare met him at the Mermaid--he called himself a friend of +Ben Jonson's--and took the best of him. You will find him in _Love's +Labour's Lost_ as well as in _All's Well_. For a foretaste of his +quality take a small portion of his first sentence, the whole of which +fills a page: "I was imbarked at Dover, about tenne of the clocke in +the morning, the fourteenth of May 1608, and arrived at Calais ... +about five of the clocke in the afternoone, after I had varnished the +exterior parts of the ship with the excrementall ebullitions of my +tumultuous stomach...." There is more about it, but that will do. +Shakespeare can never have missed such a man as that. + +Coryat's abiding sensation throughout his travels was astonishment, +not at the things which he saw, but rather that he from Odcombe in +Somerset should be seeing them. He can never get over it. Here am I, +Odcombian Tom, face to face with Amiens Cathedral, with the tombs of +the kings at Saint Denis, at Fountaine Beleau cheek by jowl with Henri +IV., crossing in a litter the "stupendious" Mont Cenis, pacing the +Duomo of Milan, disputing with a Turk in Lyons, with a Jew in Padua, +to the detriment of their religions, "swimming" in a gondola on the +Grand Canal: here I am, and now what about it? There is always an +imported flavour of Odcombe about it. He brings it with him and +sprinkles it like scent. He is careful at every stage of his journey +to give you the mileage from his own door; his measure of a city's +quality is its worth to him as a gift were Odcombe the alternative. +Few cities indeed survive the test. Mantua stood a fair chance. "That +most sweet Paradise, that _domicilium Venerum et Charitum_," did +so ravish his senses and tickle his spirits, he says, that he would +desire to live there and spend the remainder of his days "in some +divine meditations among the sacred Muses," but for two things, "their +grosse idolatry and superstitious ceremonies, which I detest, and the +love of Odcombe in Somersetshire, which is so deare unto me that I +preferre the very smoak thereof before the fire of all other places +under the sunne." So much for Mantua; but Venice, before whose +"incomparable and most decantated majestie" his pen faints--Venice +beats Odcombe, or something very much like it. He decides that should +"foure of the richest mannors of Somersetshire" have been offered +him if he would have undertaken not to see Venice, he would have gone +without the manors. Odcombe, you see, is not put in question here. He +was afraid to risk it. + +When he came home he hung up his pair of shoes in the chancel of +Odcombe Church, and they may be there to this day for all I know. + +The Sireniacal Gentlemen made great sport of him. + + If any aske in verse what soar I at? + My Muse replies The praise of Coryat---- + +so John Gyfford begins, + + A work that will eternise thee till God come + And for thy sake the famous parish Odcombe---- + +so George Sydenham ends. Ben Jonson is not represented at the revels, +and Inigo Jones lets his high spirits run away with him beyond the +bounds of modern printing. Donne is not at his best: + + Lo, here's a man worthy indeed to travell + Fat Libian plaines, strangest China's gravell; + For Europe well hath seen him stirre his stumpes, + Turning his double shoes to simple pumpes. + +--the wit of which escapes me. Better is the conceit of + + What had he done, had he e'er hugged th' ocean + With swimming Drake or famous Magelan, + And kiss'd that unturn'd cheeke of our old mother, + Since so our Europe's world he can discover? + +The "unturn'd cheeke of our old mother!" The New World should be +pleased with that. + +In 1615 he made a much further flight, and was to be heard of at "the +Court of the most Mighty Monarch, the Great Mogul," whence he wrote +to, among other people, the High Seneschal of the "Right Worshipful +Fraternity of Sireniacal Gentlemen that meet the first Friday of +every month at the Signe of the Mere-maide in Bread-Streete." In this +particular letter he greets by name Mr. John Donne, "the author of two +most elegant Latine Bookes," Master Benjamin Jonson, the poet, at his +chamber in the Blacke Friars, Mr. Samuel Purkas, and Mr. Inigo +Jones, and signs himself "the Hierosolymitan--Syrian--Mesopotamian +--Armenian--Median--Parthian--Persian--Indian--Leggestretcher +of Odcomb in Somerset." The news he gives of "the most famigerated +Region of all the East, the ample and large India," is various and +occasionally incredible, but none the worse perhaps for that. You +must allow the leg-stretcher to be something also of a leg-puller. The +Great Mogul had elephant-fights twice a week, we learn. He might well +do so if we could believe that he maintained three thousand of them +"at an unmeasurable charge." Proceeding, nevertheless, to measure it, +Coryat finds it works out at L10,000 a day, which is pretty good even +for the Mogul. He also had a thousand wives, "whereof the chiefest +(which is his Queene) is called Normal." I like her name. Coryat +rode on an elephant, "determining one day (by God's leave) to have my +picture expressed in my next book, sitting upon an elephant." But the +voyage to the East was one too many for "the ingenious perambulator," +and he died of a flux at Surat in December, 1617. Certain English +merchants offered him refreshments. "Sack, sack, is there any such +thing as sack? I pray you give me some sack." They did; the dysentery +was upon him at the time. Even as Sir John might have done did he, and +was buried "under a little monument." _Sic exit Coryatus_, says his +biographer. + +No sooner was he dead than his fellow Sireniacks fell upon his +reputation and tore it to shreds. + + He was the imp, whilst he on earth surviv'd, + From whom this West-World's pastimes were deriv'd; + He was in city, country, field and court + The well of dry-trimm'd jests, the pump of sport. + +So writes the Water Poet. Another wag trounces his Crudities: + + Tom Coriat, I have seen thy Crudities, + And methinks very strangely brewed it is, + With piece and patch together glued it is; + And now (like thee) ill-favour'd hued it is. + In many a line I see that lewd it is, + And therefore fit to be subdued it is-- + +and much more to the same effect. + +Coryat's "natalitial place," as it happens, is very near to mine, and +I find something to love in a man who can never forget it. He was +a cockscomb, he was an ass; but he preferred the West of England +to Italy. He called James I., our king, the "refulgent carbuncle of +Christendom," and Prince Charles "the most glittering chrysolite of +our English diademe" Both are hard sayings. + + + + +SHERIDAN AS MANIAC + + +All allowances made for the near alliance of great wits--"the lunatic, +the lover, and the poet"--there comes a point where the vagaries of +temperament overlap and are confounded, and where the historian, at +least, must take a line. None of Sheridan's biographers, and he has +had, as I think, more than his share, refer to an eclipse of his +rational self which he undoubtedly suffered; probably because it +was not made public until the other day. Yet there have always been +indications of the truth, as when, on his death-bed, he told Lady +Bessborough that his eyes would be looking at her through the +coffin-lid. Being the woman she was, she probably believed him, or +thought that she did. It is from her published letters that we may now +understand what reason she had for believing him. + +These letters are contained in the correspondence of Lord Granville +Leveson-Gower, who was our Ambassador in Paris on and off between 1824 +and 1841, a correspondence published in 1916, in two hefty volumes. +The period covered is from 1781 to 1821, and the documents are mainly +the letters to him of Lady Bessborough, which reveal a relation +between the pair so curious that, to me, it is extraordinary that +nobody should have called attention to them before. I can only account +for that by considering that the letters, which are very long, and +the volumes, which are very heavy, do not readily yield what store of +sweetness they possess, and that those in particular of Lord Granville +Gower have no store of sweetness to yield. They are the wooden letters +of a wooden young man. He may have been a beautiful young man, and +an estimable young man; but he was insensitive, dull, and a prig. +The best things he ever did in his days were to be belettered by Lady +Bessborough and married, finally, to her witty and sensible niece. + +Meantime, there is no need to disguise the fact, since we have it in +cold print, that the acquaintance of the couple, begun at Naples in +1794 as a flirtation, developed rapidly, on the lady's side, into a +love affair which was only ended by her death. In 1794, when it all +began, Lady Bessborough was thirty-two, had been married for fourteen +years, and had four children. Granville Gower was twenty, well born, +rich, exceedingly good-looking, and with no excuse for not knowing all +about it. In fact, he knew it perfectly, and was not afraid to allude +to himself as Antinous. We hear more than enough of his fine blue eyes +from Lady Bessborough--and perhaps he did too. She, in her turn, was +to hear, poor soul, more than her own heart could bear. All that need +be said about that is that, being the woman she was, it was to be +expected. And exactly what sort of woman she was she herself puts upon +record, in April, 1812, in the following words:-- + + "_Pour la rarete du fait et la bizarrerie des hommes_, I must + put down what I dare tell nobody--I should be so much ashamed + of it were it not so ridiculous. At this present April, 1812, + in my fifty-first year, I am courted, follow'd, flatter'd, and + made love to _en toutes les formes_, by four men--two of them + reckoned sensible, and one of the two whom I have known half + my life--Lord Holland, Ward, young M----n, and little M----y. + Sir J.C. wanted to marry me when I was fifteen; so from that + time to this--36 years, a + pretty long life--I have heard or spoke that language; and for + 17 years of it lov'd almost to Idolatry the only man from whom + I could have wish'd to hear it, the man who has probably lov'd + me least of all those who have profess'd to do so--tho' once I + thought otherwise." + +Arrant sentimentalist, born and trained flirt, as this confession +shows her to have been, it also shows that she lived to rue it. She +rued more than that, for she was the mother of Lady Caroline Lamb; and +if anything more need be said of her misfortunes, let it be added +that she was sister to Georgiana of Devonshire. Nevertheless, it is +impossible to read her letters with her wooden young lord without +seeing that she had a good heart, if a very weak head. She loved much; +and for those whom she loved--her sister, her children, Granville +Gower--she was ready to dare all things, and fail in most. Of her +husband there is nothing to tell, for she hardly names him, except to +say that he has the gout. Not much is known of him, and nothing but +good. Horace Walpole wrote of his marriage in 1780: "I know nothing to +the prejudice of the young lady; but I should not have selected for so +gentle and very amiable a man a sister of the empress of fashion, nor +a daughter of the Goddess of Wisdom." The goddess of wisdom was her +formidable and trenchant mother, Lady Spencer. + +But I don't intend to follow the vain stages of her sentimental +pilgrimage in pursuit of Lord Granville Gower's heart, vain because +apparently the young man had not such an organ at her disposal. It was +not, perhaps, for nothing that they exchanged reflections upon _Les +Liaisons Dangereuses_. A new Choderlos de Laclos would get a new +sentimental novel out of the Granville Gower correspondence; or it +may be taken as it stands for a recovered Richardson, quite as long +as _Sir Charles Grandison_ and much more amusing--for the poor lady is +often witty. The affair dragged on, with much scandal, much whispering +about it and about, until 1809, when the hero of it married Lady +Harriet Cavendish, his mistress's niece. J.W. Ward, one of her lovers, +according to her, sharply sums it up in a letter to Mrs. Dugald +Stewart: "Lord Granville Leveson is going to marry Lady Harriet +Cavendish. Lady Bessborough resigns, I presume, in favour of her +niece. I have not heard what are supposed to be the secret articles of +the treaty, but it must be a curious document." It was in 1812, as I +have said, that she wrote out the pathetic confession of what we must +suppose to have been the truth. + +But I intended to write about Sheridan. This correspondence reveals +him as the evil genius of Lady Bessborough's life; and perhaps, if all +the truth were known, she may have been the evil genius of his, or one +of them, anyhow. She had adventures with him behind her in 1794, when +she began adventures anew; for they became intimate at Devonshire +House, where, as the crony of Charles Fox, he was always at hand. The +Duchess herself was one of his familiars. His initials for her, in +letter-writing, were T.L., which a biographer pleasantly interprets as +"True Love." The sisters, Countess and Duchess, shared in all good and +evil things, and they seem to have shared Sheridan. His chosen initial +for Lady Bessborough's address was "F," her second name being Frances. +Mr. Sichel prints a letter from him to her, and guesses it to be +of 1788. Extracts will suffice for the judicious: "I must bid 'oo +good-night, for by the light passing to and fro near your room I +hope you are going to bed and to sleep happily with a hundred little +cherubs fanning their white wings over you in approbation of your +goodness. Yours is the sweet, untroubled sleep of purity." It is to be +feared that she could swallow this over-succulent stuff. A very little +more will do for us: "And yet, and yet--Beware! Milton will tell +you that even in Paradise serpents found their way to the ear of +slumbering innocence. Then, to be sure, poor Eve had no watchful +guardian to pace up and down beneath her windows.... And Adam, I +suppose--was at Brooks's ... I shall be gone before your hazel eyes +are open to-morrow...." + +Lady Duncannon, as she was then, lived in Cavendish Square. Sheridan's +leaguer of the house is thus betrayed. He never again left either her +or it alone for long, but beset them until his death. Bitterly enough +she was to rue that dalliance with the vainest sentimentalist ever +begotten in Ireland or fostered in England. His wife, as lovely as +a Muse and with the voice of a seraph, was to die; he was to adore, +pursue, and capture another; but he never let Lady Bessborough go, and +the antics of his mortified vanity were to lead her as far into the +mire as any woman could go without suffocation. Such experiences may +be common enough; it is rare to have them so nakedly portrayed as they +are in this lady's letters, and not easy to avoid the conclusion +that she made use of them to pique her wooden Antinous into some more +active kind of pose than that of allowing himself to be adored. + +Sheridan was forty-three and married to his second wife when Lady +Bessborough fell in with Antinous at Naples; but it was not until the +attachment of those two had become a notoriety that he began to make +scenes about it. In 1798, when Granville Gower was in Berlin, +Lady Bessborough writes to him that she had been at a concert at +Sheridan's. "It was as pleasant as anything of the sort can be to me, +as I sat by Fitzpatrick and Grey, who always amuse me. Sheridan +says, when he found I did not come to town, he imagined that you +had interdicted my coming till your return, and is always asking me +whether what I am doing is allowed." That was March 12th; between that +and the 17th she seems to have met Sheridan every day and nearly every +night. "I must tell you, by the by ... that I am in great request this +year.... I have had three _violent_ declarations of love--one from +an old man, another from a very young one, and the third between the +other two.... Pray come back. If you stay long in Prussia, Heaven +knows what may happen." + +In August of the same year she writes again. "Sheridan call'd in the +morning and found out that I was alone, and told me he would dine with +me. I thought, of course, he was in joke, but, _point du tout_, he +arriv'd at dinner, dined, and stayed the whole evening. He was very +pleasant, but--it was not you, and the seeing anybody only increas'd +my regrets, which I suppose were pretty visible, for every five +minutes he kept saying: 'How I am wasting all my efforts to entertain +you, while you are grieving that you cannot change me into _Lord +Leveson_. You would not be so grim if he was beaming on you.' At +length, as I thought he was preparing to pass the night as well as the +evening with me, and as he began to make some fine speeches I did not +quite approve of, I order'd my Chair, to get rid of him. This did +not succeed, for as I had no place to go to, he follow'd me about to +Anne's and Lady D----'s, where I knew I should not be let in, and home +again. But, luckily, I got in time enough to order every one to be +denied, and ran upstairs, while I heard him expostulating with the +porter...." It does not appear, from this narrative, that the hunted +fair was seriously annoyed at being hunted, and the implication of +Lord Granville in the unpleasant business is patent. Next year she has +asked her persecutor to help Antinous at his election, for his reply, +beginning "Dear Traitress," is given here. + +After that, peace or silence, until 1802, when Sheridan changed his +tactics. + + "The opera was beautiful.... The Prince paid us two visits, + but our chief company were Hare, Grey, and Sheridan, the + latter persecuting me in every pause of the music and + telling me he knew such things of you, could give me such + incontrovertible proofs of your falsehood, and not only + falsehood but treachery to me, that if I had one grain of + pride or spirit left I should fly you. And guess what I + answered, you who call me jealous. I told him I had such + entire reliance on your faith, such confidence in your truth, + that I should doubt my own eyes if they witness'd against your + word. He pitied me, and said: 'How are the mighty fallen,' and + then went on telling me things without end to drive me mad." + That was in March. In August she writes, actually under siege: + "Here I am quite alone in C. Square ... no carriage to watch + for, no rap at the door ... and alas! no chance of hearing + your step upon the stair.... Whilst I was regretting all this, + suddenly, the knock did come, to my utter astonishment. I ran + to the stair, and in a moment heard Sheridan's voice. I do + not know why, but I took a horror of seeing him, and hurried + Sally down to say I was out. I heard him answer: 'Tell her I + call'd twice this morning, and want particularly to see her, + for I know she is at home.' Sally protested I was out, and S. + answered: 'Then I shall walk up and down before the door till + she comes in,' and there he is walking sure enough. It is + partly all the nonsense he talk'd all this year, and the + hating to see any one when I cannot see you, that makes me + dislike letting him in so much." + +He solemnly did sentry-go for nearly an hour, she goes on to say. In +that hour he was in his fifty-first year, she in her fortieth. + +If she revealed these sorry doings to Antinous with the view of +fanning embers, she did not succeed in drawing more than a languid +protest from him. "As to Sheridan, in the morning I purposely staid +in my room till the time of our setting out, and only saw him as I was +getting into the carriage, so had nothing more to tell.... You say I +am not angry enough. I am provok'd, vex'd, and asham'd. To feel more +deeply I must care for the person who offends me...." I cannot myself +read either vexation or shame in her reports. Provocation I can and do +read--but it is not she who is provoked. + +In 1804, Antinous in Petersburg, there are new antics to record. "You +will think I live at the play; I am just return'd from Drury Lane.... +Sheridan persists in coming every night to us. He says one word to my +sister; then retires to the further corner of the box, where with +arms across, deep and audible sighs, and sometimes _tears_! he remains +without uttering and motionless, with his eyes fix'd on me in the most +marked and distressing manner, during the whole time we stay. To-night +he followed us in before the play begun, and remained as I tell you +thro' the play and farce. As we were going I dropped my shawl +and muff; he picked them up and with a look of ludicrous humility +presented them to Mr. Hill to give me." And this was the author of +_The School for Scandal_. + +Next year, being that of Trafalgar, and Sheridan's fifty-fourth, he +began a course of persecution which definitely marks an access of +dementia. The affair took an acute turn suddenly, and I don't intend +to say more about it than that it took the form of anonymous and +obscene letters, some of them addressed to Lady Bessborough's +daughter, Caroline, then a child, some to herself, some to the +children of the Duchess of Devonshire. The letters, which continued +throughout the year, were signed with the names of friends--a Mr. +Hill, J.W. Ward, and others. Some were sent out signed with her name. +The editor of the correspondence says that "Lady Bessborough was +subsequently convinced by evidence which appeared to her conclusive +that Sheridan was the writer." There can be no doubt of that whatever, +and as all the detail is in the published correspondence, little +more need be said. The wooden Antinous, in Petersburg, for his sole +comment, writes as follows: "I learn with sorrow that you are still +subjected to vexations from anonymous letters, etc. I suppose that +Sheridan is the author, though one would have imagined that, however +depraved his morals, and however malignant might be his mind, he would +have had _good taste_ enough not to have resorted to such a species of +vengeance." And that was all the fire to be blown into Antinous. "Good +taste" in the circumstances is comic. + +By the end of the season of the same year, however, Sheridan seems to +have found out what he had done, and Lady Bessborough also sufficient +self-respect to have helped him find it out. This is what happened on +July 12th, at a ball. "I sat between Prince Adolphus and Mr. Hill at +supper; Sheridan sat opposite, looking by turns so supplicating and +so fiercely at me that everybody round observ'd it and question'd me +about it. I could only say what was so, that he was very drunk. When +I got up, he seiz'd my arm as I pass'd him, begging me to shake hands +with him. I extricated myself from his grasp and pass'd on; he soon +after follow'd and began loudly reproaching me for my _cruelty_, and +asking why I would not shake hands. I was extremely distress'd, but at +last told him his own sagacity might explain to him why I never would, +and that his conduct to-night did not tend to alter my determination. +I then hurried out of the room, and by way of completely avoiding him, +cross'd a very formal circle of old ladies, and went and seated myself +between Lady Euston and Lady Beverly. He had the impudence to follow +me, and in face of the whole circle to enter into a loud explanation +of his conduct, begging my pardon for all the offences he had ever +committed against me, either on this night or in former times, and +assuring me that he had never ceased loving, _respecting_ and adoring +me, and that I was the only person he ever really loved...." "Think," +she says, "of the dismay of all the formal ladies." But the formal +ladies, no doubt, had every reason to know their Devonshire House set; +and if society in 1805 would allow Sheridan to be drunk and stay at a +ball, it would prefer him maudlin drunk to drunk and disorderly. One +is bound to add, too, that Lady Bessborough was a fool, though +that, to be sure, is no excuse for Sheridan proving himself both old +blackguard and old fool in one. + +Next year the Duchess died, and her sister's active persecution +appears to have ceased. But Sheridan by no means let her alone. On the +contrary, he had the assurance to send as intercessor no less a person +than the Prince Regent. "The Prince sent so repeatedly to me, and has +been throughout so kind and feeling that I thought it wrong to persist +in refusing to see him, so to-day he came soon after two and stayed +till six!... He gave me a very pretty emerald ring, which he begg'd me +to wear, _to bind still stronger the tie of Brotherhood which he has +always claim'd_. In the midst of all this he brought me a message from +Sheridan." This, which she describes as a "well-timed Petition for +Forgiveness," she had the prudence to wave aside. She said that she +had no wish to injure him, and only asked him to keep out of her way, +or, if they happened to meet, to cease to persecute her. And that was +very well, or would have been so, if she had had any character at +all, a quality which she unfortunately had not. In 1807, the following +year, she goes out to spend the evening with her daughter, Lady +Caroline, now married to William Lamb. "The entrance is, you know, +very dark; to my dismay, I saw a ruffian-like looking man following +me into the house. I hasten'd upstairs, but to my great dismay he also +ascended and enter'd the room immediately after me. It was so dark +I could not at first make out who he was. When I did, I was not the +better pleas'd with his establishing himself and passing the whole +evening with us; but much as I was displeased with him, I was still +more so with myself for being unable to resist laughing and appearing +entertained (he was so uncommonly clever), tho' I persevered in my +determination of not speaking to him. I do not like his having got +the entree there, and think him, even old as he is, a dangerous +acquaintance for Caroline. Of course you perceive it was Sheridan." +Considering that she suspected him of having written and sent grossly +indecent letters to that girl of hers, one would have said that he was +even more than a dangerous acquaintance. Light-mindedness here spills +over into something rather worse. However, there he was, established, +and it was no way to dispossess him to laugh at his jokes. + +I must now invite the reader to a farce, and, if he can forget that +Sheridan was a grandfather and fifty-six, a very good farce it is. It +is 1807, the 28th July. Lady Bessborough is staying with her daughter +for her first confinement, and receives a message from Mrs. Sheridan, +a rather wild young woman in her way, known to all Devonshire House as +Hecca. She goes at midnight, + + "... and was carried up to her bedroom, where we had not sat + long when a violent burst at the door announc'd the arrival + of Sheridan, not perfectly sober. The most ridiculous scene + ensued--that is, ridiculous it would have been if I had not + felt myself too indignant and disgusted to be entertain'd. He + began by asking my pardon, entreating my mercy and compassion, + saying that he was a wretch, and was even at that moment more + in love with _me_ than with any woman he had ever met with, on + which Hecca exclaimed: 'Not excepting me? Why, you always tell + me that I am the only woman you were ever in love with.' + 'So you are, to be sure, my dear Hecca; you know _that_, of + course--you _know_ that I love you better than anything + on earth.' '_Except_ her!' 'Pish, pish, child! Do not talk + nonsense.' Then he began again at me, upbraiding me for my + cruelty, both for quarrelling with him and setting Hecca + against him. The first, I said, I did in my own defence, the + other was false, Hecca every now and then coming in with: + 'Why, S----, I thought Lady B---- pursued you, and that you + reviled all her violence like a second Joseph? So you us'd + to tell me.' I cannot give you all the conversation, for it + lasted till near three in the morning.... Getting away was the + difficulty; he wanted to come down with me, and seiz'd my arm + with such violence once before Hecca, that I was obliged to + call her maid to help me, and at last only escaped by locking + him in." + +This sort of thing happened once more, in the same year, at Brocket. +On this occasion Sheridan pursued his victim into the nursery, and +threw himself on his knees. It gave Lady Bessborough an opportunity +which even she could not fail to perceive--and she used it. "I +interrupted the most animated professions by showing him the child and +asking him if his grandchildren were as pretty as mine. He jump'd up, +but with such fury in his looks that I was really frighten'd..." And +that may very well be the end: _solvuntur tabulae risu_. Lord Granville +Gower married in 1809, and the confidential correspondence died the +death; but Sheridan lingered until 1816, and actually carried on his +desperate pursuit within three days of the end. She visited him, and +described what took place to Lord Broughton. He assured her, she said, +that he should visit her after his death. She asked, "Why, having +persecuted her all her life, would he now carry it into death?' +'Because I am resolved you shall remember me.'"[A] The story of his +telling her that his eyes would see her through the coffin-lid is well +known, and may be apocryphal; but the melodrama is Sheridan all over. + +[Footnote A: Mr. Sichel, in his monumental book on Sheridan, doubts +the lady's memory, one of his grounds of doubt being that Sheridan +"would not have been likely to have thus behaved before his wife." But +Mr. Sichel did not then know what Sheridan was capable of doing before +his wife.] + +Curiosity rather than edification is served by the publication of such +frank revelations as Lady Bessborough's, but that is a matter for her +descendants, and was probably considered. What relates to Sheridan is +quite another thing. On his death Byron hailed him with eloquent if +extravagant praise; he was buried in Westminster Abbey; three long +biographies have been written round him, not one of which has failed +to do justice to his abilities, and not one pointed out the extent of +his moral aberration. Mr. Sichel, the latest of them, says that "he +had pursued his own path and spurned the little arts of those who +twitted him with roguery." But if the Granville Gower correspondence +is to be believed--and how can it not--he was either a very bad rogue +or a madman. Sheridan, after all's said, made a great figure in +his day, and must stand the racket of it, so to speak. Gossip about +Harriet may be left to the idle; but Sheridan belongs to History. + + + + +A FOOTNOTE TO COLERIDGE + + +Coleridge is one of our great men who require many footnotes, for +there are characteristics of his which need all the extenuation they +can get. How comes it, for instance, that he could write, and not only +write but publish, in the same decade, and sometimes in the same year, +poetry which is of our very best, and some which for frozen inanity it +would be hard to equal anywhere? How could a thinker of his power of +brain cover leagues of letter-paper with windy nonsense and mawkish +insincerity? And finally, of what quality was the talk of one whose +social life was entirely monologue? To the first of these questions +Wordsworth perhaps helps with an analogy, but not very far; for it is +certain that Wordsworth's opinion of the importance of his own +verses was inflexible, whereas Coleridge, having another medium of +expression, was by no means so insistent upon publishing. Upon the +second, it may be observed that when a philosopher is at the same time +a poet, and therefore his own rhapsodist, it is probable that he will +charm the understanding of many, but certain that he will bewitch +his own. The certainty is clinched when the rhapsodist is without the +humorous sense. It was the possession of that which enabled Charles +Lamb, who loved him, to see him "Archangel, a little damaged," and +even in one dreadful moment of his life to reprove him for a too +oleaginous sympathy. Lamb, in fact, was always able to view his friend +with clear eyes. In a letter to Manning, enclosing "all Coleridge's +letters" to himself, he says that in them Manning will find "a good +deal of amusement, to see genuine talent struggling against a pompous +display of it." No criticism could be sounder. But Coleridge never +wavered from the belief that he was in no phase of his being an +ordinary man. If his thoughts were not ordinary thoughts, his +imaginings not ordinary imaginings, then his stomach-aches were not +ordinary stomach-aches, but strokes of calamity so grievous as to +demand from him copious commentary and appeals for more sympathy than +is ordinarily given to ordinary men. And, strange to say, he received +it. There was that in the "noticeable man with large grey eyes" which +drew the love of his friends and the regard of acquaintance. His talk +had the quality of his Ancient Mariner's; one could not choose +but hear. The accounts which we have of that, however, are mainly +sympathetic; it is not so certain how it affected hearers who were not +predisposed. + +Lately a book has been published, or rather republished, which +illustrates Coleridge's relations with a world outside his own. _A +House of Letters_ (Jarrolds--N.D.), containing a selection of the +memoirs and correspondence of Miss Mary Matilda Betham, includes a +good many letters from Coleridge, and some few from Charles Lamb which +have not so far been recorded elsewhere. Miss Betham, who was born +in 1776, was a miniature painter by profession, and so far as can be +judged by reproductions a good one. She was a poetess, too, and the +compiler of a Biographical Dictionary of Celebrated Women. In 1797 she +published a volume of _Elegies_, which in 1802 was sent to Coleridge +by his friend Lady Boughton, and of which a short piece, "On a Cloud," +transported him. He addressed immediately a blank-verse exhortation +"To Matilda Betham, from a Stranger," dated it Keswick, September 9th, +1802, signed it "S.T.C.," and sent it off. + + Matilda! I have heard a sweet tune play'd + On a sweet instrument--thy Poesie, + +it began; and went on to hope-- + + That our own Britain, our dear mother Isle, + May boast one Maid, a poetess indeed, + Great as th' impassioned Lesbian, in sweet song, + And O! of holier mind, and happier fate. + +That was what he called twining her vernal wreath around the brows of +patriot Hope. He concluded with some cautionary lines whose epithets +are irresistibly comic: + + Be bold, meek Woman! but be wisely bold! + Fly, ostrich-like, firm land beneath thy feet. + +And for her ultimate reward-- + + What nobler meed, Matilda! canst thou win + Than tears of gladness in a Boughton's eyes, + And exultation even in strangers' hearts? + +It is a wonderful thing indeed that, having composed _The Ancient +Mariner_ (1797), _Love_ (1799), _Christabel_ (1797-1800), and _Kubla +Khan_ (1798), he should slip back into this eighteenth-century +flatulence--but Coleridge could do such things and not turn a hair. + +Nevertheless, to a young poetess, a bad poem is still a poem, and +means a reader. An acquaintance invited in such terms will thrive, and +that of Miss Betham and the Stranger ripened into a friendship. She +went to stay at Greta Hall, painted portraits of Mrs. Coleridge +and Sara, and of some of the Southeys too. Through them she became +acquainted with the Lambs, and if never one of their inner circle, +was a familiar correspondent, and had relations with George Dyer, the +Morgans, the Thelwalls, Montagues, Holcrofts and others. Altogether +Lady Boughton's bow at a venture brought down a goodly quarry for Miss +Betham, but many waters were to flow under the restless philosopher +before he could swim into her ken again. + +It was in 1808, in fact, when he was living in London (at the +_Courier_ office, 348, Strand), and in the midst of his second course +of lectures, that the intercourse was renewed--or rather it is there +that _A House of Letters_ enables us to pick it up. We find him then +writing in this kind of strain to Matilda:-- + + "What joy would it not be to you, or to me, Miss Betham, to + meet a Milton in a future state, and with that reverence + due to a superior, pour forth our deep thanks for the noble + feelings he had aroused in us, for the impossibility of many + mean and vulgar feelings and objects which his writings had + secured us!" + +The Americans call that sort of thing poppycock, which seems a useful +phrase. No doubt there was more of it, though it is precisely there, +without subscription or signature, that the Editor of _A House of +Letters_ thinks fit to conclude. He has much to learn of the duties of +editorship, among other things, as we shall have to note before long, +reasonable care in recording and printing his originals. Upon that +letter, at any rate, _post_ if not _propter_, Miss Betham proposed to +the philosopher that he should sit to her, and that, with some demur, +he promised to do. An appointment was made to that end, and punctually +broken. Then came this letter of excuse, which should have been +worth many a miniature, being indeed a full-length portrait done by a +master-hand:-- + + "Dear Miss Betham,--Not my will, but accident and necessity + made me a truant from my promise. I was to have left Merton, + in Surrey, at half-past eight on Tuesday morning with a Mr. + Hall, who would have driven me in his chaise to town by ten; + but having walked an unusual distance on the Monday, and + talked and exerted myself in spirits that have been long + unknown to me, on my return to my friend's house, being + thirsty, I drank at least a quart of lemonade; the consequence + was that all Tuesday morning, till indeed two o'clock in the + afternoon, I was in exceeding pain, and incapable of quitting + my room, or dismissing the hot flannels applied to my + body...." + +This was no ordinary philosopher; but the chapter is not yet full. + +He left Merton, he says, at five, walked stoutly on, was detained an +hour and a half on Clapham Common, "in an act of mere humanity," and +finally reached Vauxhall. + + "At Vauxhall I took a boat for Somerset House: two mere + children were my Charons; however, though against tide, we + sailed safely to the landing-place, when, as I was getting + out, one of the little ones (God Bless him!) moved the boat. + On turning halfway round to reprove him, he moved it again, + and I fell back on the landing-place. By my exertions I should + have saved myself but for a large stone which + I struck against just under my crown and unfortunately in the + very same place which had been contused at Melton (_sic_) when + I fell backward after learning suddenly and most abruptly of + Captain Wordsworth's fate in the _Abergavenny_, a most dear + friend of mine. Since that time any great agitation has + occasioned a feeling of, as it were, a _shuttle_ moving from + that part of the back of my head horizontally to my forehead, + with some pain but more confusion." + +The unction of that blessing called down upon his persecutor is +truly Coleridgian. "Melton" is the Editor's rendering of Malta, where +Coleridge was when he heard of John Wordsworth's drowning in 1805. He +had then kept his bed for a fortnight, or so he told Mrs. Coleridge. + +Apparently no meeting took place, as yet another letter, dated 7th +May, relates how instead of going to New Cavendish Street, where Miss +Betham lived, he went to Old Cavendish Street, where she did not. "I +knocked at every door in Old Cavendish Street, not unrecompensed for +the present pain by the remembrances of the different characters +of voice and countenance with which my question was answered in +all gradations, from gentle and hospitable kindness to downright +brutality." Further promises and assurances are given, and in July, as +we learn from a letter of Southey's, the good Matilda was still high +in hopes that her sitter would eventually sit. Her hopes could not +have come from Southey, who had none. "You would have found him the +most wonderful man living in conversation, but the most impracticable +one for a painter, and had you begun the picture it is ten thousand +to one that you must have finished it from memory." He was right. When +his lectures were over, in June, Coleridge went to Bury St. Edmunds, +and by the 9th September he was in Cumberland. "Coleridge has arrived +at last, about half as big as the house," Southey writes to his +brother on that day. There he cogitated and there began _The Friend_, +and there the separation from his wife was finally made. + +After the separation, very characteristically, he was less separated +from Mrs. Coleridge than he had been for many years. In 1810 he was +still in the Lakes, in the summer of which year his wife gives news of +him to the poetess. "Coleridge has been with me for some time past, +in good health, spirits and humour, but the _Friend_ for some +unaccountable reason, or for no reason at all, is utterly silent. +This, you will easily believe, is matter of perpetual grief to me, but +I am obliged to be silent on the subject, although ever uppermost in +my thoughts, but I am obliged to bear about a cheerful countenance, +knowing as I do by sad experience that to expostulate, or even to +hazard one anxious look, would soon drive him hence." Then comes a +sidelight on the Wordsworths. "Coleridge sends you his best thanks for +the elegant little book; I shall not, however, let it be carried +over to Grasmere, for _there_ it would soon be _soiled_, for the +Wordsworths are woeful destroyers of good books, as our poor library +will witness." + +But all this was too good to last, and as everybody knows, it did not. +In October Coleridge left the Lakes with the Montagues, and almost +immediately after that the rupture with the Wordsworths occurred, +which involved also the family at Keswick. Southey's letter to Miss +Betham giving her an account of the affair has been published by +Mr. Dykes Campbell, and is misplaced in _A House of Letters_. The +unfortunate philosopher set up his rest with the Morgans, friends of +the Lambs, at Hammersmith; and there he was in February, 1811, when +Miss Betham conceived her project of getting him as a lion at the +party of her friend Lady Jerningham. + +Lady Jerningham, blue mother of a bluer daughter (Lady Bedingfield) +and sister-in-law of the "Charming Man" of Walpole's and the Misses +Berry's acquaintance, was a friend of Miss Betham's of old standing. +Several letters of hers are in _A House of Letters_, but many more +of her daughter's. Whether it was her ladyship's or Miss Betham's +proposal there's no telling now; but Miss Betham, at any rate, did +not feel equal to the job, and called in Charles and Mary Lamb to help +her. Mary, in the first instance, sounded the philosopher, and with +success. I quote from Mr. Lucas's edition of the Lamb letters, as +the editor of Miss Betham's misreads and misprints his original. +"Coleridge," she writes, "has given me a very cheerful promise that he +will wait on Lady Jerningham any day you will be pleased to appoint. +He offered to write to you, but I found it was to be done _to-morrow_, +and as I am pretty well acquainted with his to-morrows, I thought good +to let you know his determination to-day. He is in town to-day, but +as he is often going to Hammersmith for a night or two, you had better +perhaps send the invitation through me, and I will manage it for +you as well as I can. You had better let him have four or five days' +previous notice, and you had better send the invitation as soon as +you can; for he seems tolerably well just now. I mention all these +betters, because I wish to do the best I can for you, perceiving, as I +do, it is a thing you have set your heart on." + +Charles was next brought in. Mr. Lucas gives his letter (I. 429) to +John Morgan, which says, "There--don't read any further, because the +letter is not intended for you, but for Coleridge, who might perhaps +not have opened it directed to him _suo nomine_. It is to invite C., +to Lady Jerningham's on Sunday." + +Finally, Coleridge went to the party, and apparently in company, +though it is not clear in whose company. This is what Lady Jerningham +thought about it:-- + + "My dear Miss Betham,--I have been pleased with your friends, + tho' (which is not singular) they sometimes fly higher than my + imagination can follow. I think the author ought to mix + more, I will not say with Fools, but with People of Common + Comprehension. His own intellect would be as bright, and + what emanated from it more clear. This is perhaps a very + impertinent Remark for me to venture at making, but your + indulgence invited sincerity." + +That letter, I think, whose capitals are particularly graphic, throws +the whole party up in a dry light. One can see the rhapsodist talking +interminably, involving himself ever deeplier in a web of his own +spinning; the great lady gazing in wonder. It is one of the very few +impartial witnesses we have to his conversational feats. Nearly all +the evidence is tainted either by predisposition in his favour or the +reverse. Hazlitt, a mainly hostile witness, says that he talked well +on every subject; Godwin on none. One suspects antithesis there. He +reports Holcroft as saying that "he thought Mr. C. a very clever man, +with a great command of language, but that he feared he did not always +affix very precise ideas to the words he used!" Then we have +Byron, who wrote for effect, and whose aim was scorn. "Coleridge is +lecturing. 'Many an old fool,' said Hannibal to some such lecturer, +'but such as this, never.'" Tom Moore, who met Coleridge at +Monkhouse's famous poets' dinner-party, goes no further than to allow +that "Coleridge told some tolerable things:" but what Tom wanted was +anecdote. Directly Coleridge began upon theory Moore was bored. He +shuts him down with a "This is absurd." Rogers was present at that +party, but we don't know what he thought about it. He admits that +Coleridge was a marvellous talker, however. "One morning when Hookham +Frere also breakfasted with me, Coleridge talked for three hours +without intermission about poetry, and so admirably that I wish every +word he uttered had been written down." But it was not always so +well. He says elsewhere that he and Wordsworth once called upon him. +Coleridge "talked uninterruptedly for about two hours, during which +Wordsworth listened with profound attention, every now and then +nodding his head. On quitting the lodging, I said to Wordsworth, +'Well, for my own part, I could not make head or tail of Coleridge's +oration; pray, did you understand it?' 'Not one syllable of it,' was +Wordsworth's reply." + +Keats' account is capital. He met the Sage between Highgate and +Hampstead, he says, and "walked with him, at his alderman-after-dinner +pace, for near two miles, I suppose. In those two miles he broached +a thousand things. Let me see if I can give you +a list--nightingales--poetry--on poetical +sensation--metaphysics--different genera and species of +dreams--nightmare--a dream accompanied with a sense of touch--single +and double touch--a dream related--first and second consciousness--the +difference explained between will and volition--so say +_metaphysicians_ from a _want of smoking the second +consciousness_--monsters--the Kraken--mermaids--Southey believes +in them--Southey's belief too much diluted--a ghost story--Good +morning--I heard his voice as he came towards me--I heard it as he +moved away--I had heard it all the interval--if it may be called so." + +Charles Lamb's is even better. On his way to the city he met +Coleridge, and "in spite of my assuring him that time was precious, he +drew me within the door of an unoccupied garden by the roadside, and +there, sheltered from observation by a hedge of evergreens, he took me +by the button of my coat, and closing his eyes, commenced an eloquent +discourse, waving his right hand gently, as the musical words flowed +in an unbroken stream from his lips. I listened entranced; but the +striking of a church-clock recalled me to a sense of duty." Charles +cut himself free with a pen-knife, he says, and went off to his +office. "Five hours afterwards, in passing the garden on my way home, +I heard Coleridge's voice, and on looking in, there he was, with +closed eyes--the button in his fingers--his right hand gracefully +waving." A good story, at least. This was no company for Lady +Jerningham, who demanded clarity, and probably had a good deal to do. + +Lastly, we have Coleridge's own confession to Miss Betham that +"Bacchus ever sleek and young," as at this time Lamb called him, +"pouring down," he went on to say, "goblet after goblet," must +have outdone his usual outdoings. Here is the best he can say for +himself:-- + + "True history will be my sufficient apology. After my return + from Lady J.'s on Monday night, or rather morning, I awoke + from my short sleep unusually indisposed, and was at last + forced to call up the good daughter of the house at an early + hour to get me hot water and procure me medicine. I could not + leave my bed till past six Monday evening, when I crawled + out in order to see Charles Lamb, and to afford him such + poor comfort as my society might perhaps do in the present + dejection of his spirits and loneliness." + +There is much more to the same effect; and surely it is not often that +a philosopher, or even a poet, will treat his post-prandial dumps (to +call them so) as a stroke of adverse fortune. Coleridge takes it as +an act of God. "This, my dear Miss Betham, waiving all connexion of +sentences, is the history of my breach of engagement, of its cause, +and of the occasion of that cause." There is much of Mr. Micawber +here. + +And here, so far as _A House of Letters_ can help us, Coleridge's +correspondence with Matilda Betham ends. It may well have been the end +indeed. From that date onwards the wreck of the thinker and poet slid +swiftly down the slope appointed, until he came up, after many bumps, +in the hospitable Highgate backwater where he was to end his days. +It was a wonderful London which within the same twenty years could +harbour three men, like Blake, Coleridge and Shelley, in whom the +incondite spirit which we call genius dwelt so near the surface +of conscious being, and had such freedom to range. With Blake and +Shelley, however, once over the threshold, it was untrammelled--and +with Blake at least entirely innocuous to society, except to one +drunken soldier who richly deserved what he got. But with Coleridge, +throughout his career, one sees it struggling like a fly glued in +treacle, pausing often to cleanse its wings. The fly, you adjudge, +walked into the treacle. But Coleridge always thought that it was the +treacle which had walked over him. + + + + +THE CRYSTAL VASE + + +I have often wished that I could write a novel in which, as mostly +in life, thank goodness, nothing happens. Jane Austen, it has been +objected, forestalled me there, and it is true that she very nearly +did--but not quite. It was a point for her art to make that the +novel should have form. Form involved plot, plot a logic of events; +events--well, that means that there were collisions. They may have +been mild shocks, but persons did knock their heads together, and +there were stars to be seen by somebody. In life, in a majority of +cases, there are no stars, yet life does not on that account cease to +be interesting; and even if stars should happen to be struck out, it +is not the collision, nor the stars either, which interest us most. +No, it is our state of soul, our mental process under the stress which +we care about, and as mental process is always going on, and the state +of the soul is never the same for two moments together, there is ample +material for a novel of extreme interest, which need never finish, +which might indeed be as perennial as a daily newspaper or the _Annual +Register_. Why is it, do you suppose, that anybody, if he can, will +read anybody else's letter? It is because every man-Jack of us lives +in a cage, cut off from every other man-Jack; because we are incapable +of knowing what is going on in the mind of our nearest and dearest, +and because we burn for the assurance we may get by evidence of +homogeneity procurable from any human source. Man is a creature of +social instinct condemned by his nature to be solitary. Creatures in +all outward respects similar to himself are awhirl about him. They +cannot help him, nor he them; he cannot even be sure, for all he may +assume it, that they share his hope and calling. + + Ensphered in flesh we live and die, + And see a myriad souls adrift, + Our likes, and send our voiceless cry + Shuddering across the void: "The truth! + Succour! The truth!" None can reply. + +That is the state of our case. We can cope with mere events, comedy, +tragedy, farce. The things that happen to us are not our life. They +are imposed upon life, they come and go. But life is a secret process. +We only see the accretions. + +The novel which I dreamed of writing has recently been done, or rather +begun, by Miss Dorothy Richardson. She betters the example of Jane +Austen by telling us much more about what seems to be infinitely less, +but is not so in reality. She dips into the well whereof Miss Austen +skims the surface. She has essayed to report the mental process of a +young woman's lifetime from moment to moment. In the course of four, +if not five, volumes nothing has happened yet but the death of a +mother and the marriage of a sister or so. She may write forty, and I +shall be ready for the forty-first. Mental process, the states of +the soul, emotional reaction--these as they are moved in us by other +people are Miss Richardson's subject-matter, and according as these +are handled is the interest we can devote to her novels. These +fleeting things are Miss Richardson's game, and they are the things +which interest us most in ourselves, and the things which we desire to +know most about in our neighbours. + +But, of course, it won't do. Miss Richardson does not, and cannot, +tell us all. A novel is a piece of art which does not so much report +life as transmute it. She takes up what she needs for her purpose, and +that may not be our purpose. And so it is with poetry--we don't go to +that for the facts, but for the essence of fact. The poet who told us +all about himself at some particular pass would write a bad poem, for +it is his affair to transfigure rather than transmute, to move us by +beauty at least as much as by truth. What we look for so wistfully +in each other is the raw material of poetry. We can make the finished +article for ourselves, given enough matter; and indeed the poetry +which is imagined in contemplation is apt to be much finer than that +which has passed through the claws of prosody and syntax. The fact, +to be short with it, is that literature has an eye upon the consumer. +Whether it is marketable or not, it is intended for the public. Now +no man will undress in public with design. It may be a pity, but so +it is. Undesignedly, I don't say. It would be possible, I think, +by analysis, to track the successive waves of mental process in _In +Memoriam_. Again, _The Angel in the House_ brought Patmore as near to +self-explication as a poet can go. Shakespeare's Sonnets offer a more +doubtful field of experiment. + +What then? Shall we go to the letter-writers--to Madame de Sevigne, to +Gray, to Walpole and Cowper, Byron and Lamb? A letter-writer implies +a letter-reader, and just that inadequacy of spoken communication +will smother up our written words. Madame de Sevigne must placate her +high-sniffing daughter, Gray must please himself; Walpole must at any +cost be lively, Cowper must be urbane to Lady Hesketh or deprecate +the judgment of the Reverend Mr. Newton. Byron was always before the +looking-glass as he wrote; and as for Charles Lamb, do not suppose +that he did anything but hide in his clouds of ink. Sir Sidney Colvin +thinks that Keats revealed himself in his letters, but I cannot agree +with him. Keats is one of the best letter-writers we have; he can be +merry, fanciful, witty, thoughtful, even profound. He has a sardonic +turn of language hardly to be equalled outside Shakespeare. "Were it +in my device, I would reject a Petrarchal coronation--on account of my +dying day, and because women have cancers?" Where will you match that +but from Hamlet? But Keats knew himself. "It is a wretched thing to +confess, but it is a very fact, that not one word I can utter can be +taken for granted as an opinion growing out of my identical Nature." +So I find him in his letters, swayed rather by his fancies than his +states of soul, until indeed that soul of his was wrung by agony of +mind and disease of body. Revelation, then, like gouts of blood, +did issue, but of that I do not now write. No man is sane at such a +crisis. + +_Parva componere magnis_, there is a letter contained in _The Early +Diary of Frances Burney_(ed. Mrs. A.R. Ellis, 1889), more completely +apocalyptic than anything else of the kind accessible to me. Its +writer was Maria Allen, daughter of Dr. Burney's second wife, +therefore half-sister to the charming Burney girls. She was a young +lady who could let herself go, in act as well as on paper, and withal, +as Fanny judged her, "flighty, ridiculous, uncommon, lively, comical, +entertaining, frank, and undisguised"--or because of it--she +did contrive to unfold her panting and abounding young self more +thoroughly than the many times more expert. You have her here in the +pangs of a love-affair, of how long standing I don't know, but now +evidently in a bad state of miss-fire. It was to end in elopement, +post-chaise, clandestine marriage, in right eighteenth-century. Here +it is in an earlier state, all mortification, pouting and hunching of +the shoulder. I reproduce it with Maria's punctuation, which shows it +to have proceeded, as no doubt she did herself, in gasps: + + "I was at the Assembly, forced to go entirely against my own + Inclination. But I always have sacrificed my own Inclinations + to the will of other people--could not resist the pressing + Importunity of--Bet Dickens--to go--tho' it proved Horribly + stupid. I drank tea at the--told old Turner--I was determined + not to dance--he would not believe me--a wager ensued--half + a crown provided I followed my own Inclinations--agreed--Mr. + Audley asked me. I refused--sat still--yet followed my own + Inclinations. But four couple began--Martin (c'etait Lui) + was there--yet stupid--n'importe--quite Indifferent--on both + sides--Who had I--to converse with the whole Evening--not + a female friend--none there--not an acquaintance--All + Dancing--who then--I've forgot--n'importe--I broke my + earring--how--heaven knows--foolishly enough--one can't always + keep on the Mask of Wisdom--well n'importe I danced a Minuet a + quatre the latter end of the Eve--with a stupid Wretch--need + I name him--They danced cotillions almost the whole Night--two + sets--yet I did not join them--Miss Jenny Hawkins danced--with + who--can't you guess--well--n'importe------" + +There is more, but my pen is out of breath. Nobody but Mr. Jingle ever +wrote like that; and in so far as Maria Allen may be said to have had +a soul, there in its little spasms is the soul of Maria Allen, with +all the _malentendus_ of the ballroom and all the surgings of a +love-affair at cross-purposes thrown in. + +As for Fanny Burney's early diary, its careful and admirable editor +claims that you have in it "the only published, perhaps the only +existing record of the life of an English girl, written of herself in +the eighteenth century." I believe that to be true. It is a record, +and a faithful and very charming record of the externals of such a +life. As such it is, to me, at least, a valuable thing. If it does +not unfold the amiable, brisk, and happy Fanny herself, there are two +simple reasons why it could not. First, she was writing her journal +for the entertainment of old Mr. Crisp of Chessington, the "Daddy +Crisp" of her best pages; secondly, it is not at all likely that she +knew of anything to unfold. Nor, for that matter, was Fanny herself of +the kind that can unfold to another person. Yet there is a charm all +over the book, which some may place here, some there, but which +all will confess. For me it is not so much that Fanny herself is a +charming girl, and a girl of shrewd observation, of a pointed pen, and +an admirable gift of mimicry. She has all that, and more--she has a +good heart. Her sister Susan is as good as she, and there are many of +Susan's letters. But the real charm of the book, I think, is in the +series of faithful pictures it contains of the everyday round of an +everyday family. Dutch pictures all--passers-by, a knock at the front +door, callers--Mr. Young, "in light blue embroidered with silver, +a bag and sword, and walking in the rain"; a jaunt to Greenwich, a +concert at home--the Agujari in one of her humours; a masquerade--a +very private one, at the house of Mr. Laluze.... Hetty had for three +months thought of nothing else ... she went as a Savoyard with a +hurdy-gurdy fastened round her waist. Nothing could look more simple, +innocent and pretty. "My dress was a close pink Persian vest +covered with a gauze in loose pleats...." What else? Oh, a visit to +Teignmouth--Maria Allen now Mrs. Ruston; another to Worcester; quiet +days at King's Lynn, where "I have just finished _Henry and Frances_ +... the greatest part of the last volume is wrote by Henry, and on +the gravest of grave subjects, and that which is most dreadful to our +thoughts, Eternal Misery...." Terrific novel: but need I go on? There +may be some to whom a description of the nothings of our life will be +as flat as the nothings themselves--but I am not of that party. The +things themselves interest me, and I confess the charm. It is the +charm of innocence and freshness, a morning dew upon the words. + +The Burneys, however, can do no more for us than shed that auroral +dew. They cannot reassure us of our normal humanity, since they needed +reassurance themselves. + +Where, then, shall we turn? So far as I am aware, to two only, except +for two others whom I leave out of account. Rousseau is one, for it is +long since I read him, but my recollection is that the _Confessions_ +is a kind of novel, pre-meditated, selective, done with great art. +Marie Bashkirtseff is another. I have not read her at all. Of the two +who remain I leave Pepys also out of account, because, though it may +be good for us to read Pepys, it is better to have read him and be +through with it. There, under the grace of God, go a many besides +Pepys, and among them every boy who has ever befouled a wall with a +stump of pencil. We are left then with one whom it is ill to name +in the same fill of the inkpot, "Wordsworth's exquisite sister," as +Keats, who saw her once, at once knew her to be. + +In Dorothy Wordsworth's journals, you may have the delight of daily +_intercourse--famigliarmente discorrendo_--with one of the purest +and noblest souls ever housed in flesh; to that you may add the +reassurance to be got from word and implication beyond doubt. She +tells us much, but implies more. We may see deeply into ourselves, but +she sees deeply into a deeper self than most of us can discern. It is +not only that, knowing her, we are grounded in the rudiments of honour +and lovely living; it is to learn that human life can be so lived, and +to conclude that of that at least is the Kingdom of Heaven. + +These journals are for fragments only of the years which they cover, +and as such exist for Jan.-May, 1798 (Alfoxden); May-Dec, 1800, +Oct.-Dec, 1801, Jan.-July, 1802: all these at Grasmere. They have been +printed by Professor Knight, and I have the assurance of Mr. Gordon +Wordsworth that what little has been omitted is unimportant. Nothing +is unimportant to me, and I wish the whole had been given us; but +what we have is enough whereby to trace the development of her +extraordinary mind and of her power of self-expression. The latter, +undoubtedly, grew out of emotion, which gradually culminated until the +day of William Wordsworth's marriage. There it broke, and with it, as +if by a determination of the will, there the revelation ceased. A new +life began with the coming of Mary Wordsworth to Dove Cottage, a life +of which Dorothy records the surface only. + +The Alfoxden fragment (20 Jan.-22 May, 1798), written when she +was twenty-seven, is chiefly notable for its power of interpreting +landscape. That was a power which Wordsworth himself possessed in +a high degree. There can be no doubt, I think, that they egged each +other on, but I myself should find it hard to say which was egger-on +and which the egged. This is the first sentence of it: + + "20 Jan.--The green paths down the hillsides are channels for + streams. The young wheat is streaked by silver lines of water + running between the ridges, the sheep are gathered together + on the slopes. After the wet dark days, the country seems more + populous. It peoples itself in the sunbeams." + +Here is one of a few days later: + + "23rd.--Bright sunshine; went out at 3 o'cl. The sea perfectly + calm blue, streaked with deeper colour by the clouds, and + tongues or points of sand; on our return of a gloomy red. The + sun gone down. The crescent moon, Jupiter and Venus. The sound + of the sea distinctly heard on the tops of the hills, which + we could never hear in summer. We attribute this partly to + the bareness of the trees, but chiefly to the absence of the + singing birds, the hum of insects, that noiseless noise which + lives in the summer air. The villages marked out by beautiful + beds of smoke. The turf fading into the mountain road." + +She handles words, phrases, like notes or chords of music, and never +gets her landscape by direct description. One more picture and I must +leave it: + + "26.-- ... Walked to the top of a high hill to see a + fortification. Again sat down to feed upon the prospect; a + magnificent scene, _curiously_ spread out for even minute + inspection though so extensive that the mind is afraid to + calculate its bounds...." + +Coleridge was with them most days, or they with him. Here is a curious +point to note. Dorothy records: + + "March 7th.--William and I drank tea at Coleridge's. Observed + nothing particularly interesting.... One only leaf upon the + top of a tree--the sole remaining leaf--danced round and round + like a rag blown by the wind." + +And Coleridge has in _Christabel_: + + The one red leaf, the last of its clan, + That dances as often as dance it can, + Hanging so light, and hanging so high, + On the topmost twig that looks up at the sky. + +William, Dorothy, and Coleridge went to Hamburg at the end of that +year, but in 1800 the brother and sister were in Grasmere; and the +journal which opens with May 14, at once betrays the great passion of +Dorothy's life: + + "William and John set off into Yorkshire after dinner at + half-past two o'clock, cold pork in their pockets. I left them + at the turning of the Low-Wood bay under the trees. My heart + was so full I could hardly speak to W., when I gave him a + farewell kiss. I sate a long time upon a stone at the margin + of the lake, and after a flood of tears my heart was easier. + The lake looked to me, I know not why, dull and melancholy, + and the weltering on the shore seemed a heavy sound.... I + resolved to write a journal of the time till W. and J. return, + and I set about keeping my resolve, because I will not quarrel + with myself, and because I shall give William pleasure by it + when he comes again...." + +"Because I will not quarrel with myself!" She is full of such +illuminations. Here is another: + + "Sunday, June 1st.--After tea went to Ambleside round the + lakes. A very fine warm evening. Upon the side of Loughrigg + _my heart dissolved in what I saw_." + +Now here is her account of a country funeral which she reads into, or +out of, the countryside: + + "Wednesday, 3rd Sept.-- ... a funeral at John Dawson's.... I + was affected to tears while we stood in the house, the coffin + lying before me. There were no near kindred, no children. + When we got out of the dark house the sun was shining, and + the prospect looked as divinely beautiful as I ever saw it. + It seemed more sacred than I had ever seen it, _and yet more + allied to human life_. I thought she was going to a quiet + spot, and I could not help weeping very much...." + +The italics are mine. William was pleased to call her weeping "nervous +blubbering." + +And then we come to 1802, the great last year of a twin life; the +last year of the five in which those two had lived as one soul and +one heart. They were at Dove Cottage, on something under L150 a year. +Poems were thronging thick about them; they were living intensely. +John was alive. Mary Hutchinson was at Sockburn. Coleridge was still +Coleridge, not the bemused and futile mystic he was to become. As for +Dorothy, she lives a thing enskied, floating from ecstasy to ecstasy. +It is the third of March, and William is to go to London. "Before we +had quite finished breakfast Calvert's man brought the horses for +Wm. We had a deal to do, pens to make, poems to be put in order for +writing, to settle for the press, pack up.... Since he left me at +half-past eleven (it is now two) I have been putting the drawers in +order, laid by his clothes, which he had thrown here and there and +everywhere, filed two months' newspapers, and got my dinner, two +boiled eggs and two apple tarts.... The robins are singing sweetly. +Now for my walk. I _will_ be busy. I _will_ look well, and be well +when he comes back to me. O the Darling! Here is one of his bitter +apples, I can hardly find it in my heart to throw it into the +fire.... I walked round the two lakes, crossed the stepping-stones at +Rydalefoot. Sate down where we always sit. I was full of thought of my +darling. Blessings on him." Where else in our literature will you find +mood so tender, so intimately, so delicately related? + +A week later, and William returned. With him, it seems, her +descriptive powers. "Monday morning--a soft rain and mist. We walked +to Rydale for letters, The Vale looked very beautiful in excessive +simplicity, yet at the same time, uncommon obscurity. The church stood +alone, mountains behind. The meadows looked calm and rich, bordering +on the still lake. Nothing else to be seen but lake and island." +Exquisite landscape. For its like we must go to Japan. Here is +another. An interior. It is the 23rd of March, "about ten o'clock, a +quiet night. The fire flickers, and the watch ticks. I hear nothing +save the breathing of my beloved as he now and then pushes his book +forward, and turns over a leaf...." No more, but the peace of it is +profound, the art incomparable. + +In April, between the 5th and 12th, William went into Yorkshire upon +an errand which she knew and dreaded. Her trouble makes the words +throb. + + "Monday, 12th.... The ground covered with snow. Walked to T. + Wilkinson's and sent for letters. The woman brought me one + from William and Mary. It was a sharp windy night. Thomas + Wilkinson came with me to Barton and questioned me like a + catechiser all the way. Every question was like the snapping + of a little thread about my heart. I was so full of thought of + my half-read letter and other things. I was glad when he left + me. Then I had time to look at the moon while I was thinking + of my own thoughts. The moon travelled through the clouds, + tinging them yellow as she passed along, with two stars near + her, one larger than the other.... At this time William, as + I found the next day, was riding by himself between Middleham + and Barnard Castle." + +I don't know where else to find the vague torment of thought, its way +of enhancing colour and form in nature, more intensely observed. Next +day: "When I returned _William_ was come. _The surprise shot through +me._" This woman was not so much poet as crystal vase. You can see the +thought cloud and take shape. + +The twin life was resumed for yet a little while. In the same month +came her descriptions of the daffodils in Gowbarrow Park, and of the +scene by Brothers Water, which prove to anybody in need of proof +that she was William's well-spring of poesy. Not that the journal is +necessarily involved. No need to suppose that he even read it. But +that she could make him see, and be moved by, what she had seen is +proved by this: "17th.-- ... I saw a robin chasing a scarlet butterfly +this morning"; and "Sunday, 18th.-- ... William wrote the poem on _The +Robin and the Butterfly_." No, beautiful beyond praise as the journals +are, it is certain that she was more beautiful than they. And what a +discerning, illuminative eye she had! "As I lay down on the grass, I +observed the glittering silver line on the ridge of the backs of the +sheep, owing to their situation respecting the sun, which made them +look beautiful, but with something of strangeness, like animals of +another kind, as if belonging to a more splendid world...." What a +woman to go a-gipsying through the world with! + +Then comes the end.... "Thursday, 8th July.-- In the afternoon, after +we had talked a little, William fell asleep. I read _The Winter's +Tale_; then I went to bed but did not sleep. The swallows stole in and +out of their nest, and sat there, _whiles_ quite still; _whiles_ they +sung low for two minutes or more at a time, just like a muffled robin. +William was looking at _The Pedlar_ when I got up. He arranged it, +and after tea I wrote it out--280 lines.... The moon was behind.... +We walked first to the top of the hill to see Rydale. It was dark and +dull, but our own vale was very solemn--the shape of Helm Crag was +quite distinct though black. We walked backwards and forwards on the +White Moss path; there was a sky like white brightness on the lake.... +O beautiful place! Dear Mary, William. The hour is come.... I must +prepare to go. The swallows, I must leave them, the wall, the garden, +the roses, all. Dear creatures, they sang last night after I was in +bed; seemed to be singing to one another, just before they settled to +rest for the night. Well, I must go. Farewell." + +Next day she set out with William to meet her secret dread, knowing +that life in Rydale could never be the same again. Wordsworth married +Mary Hutchinson on the 4th October, 1802. The secret is no secret now, +for Dorothy was a crystal vase. + + + + +_NOCTES AMBROSIANAE_ + +Weather has sent me indoors, chance to an old book. I have been +reading _Noctes Ambrosianae_ again. Bad buffoonery as much of it is and +full to the throttle of the warm-watery optimism induced by whisky, +yet as fighting literature it is incalculably better than its modern +substitute in _Blackwood_. The sniper who monthly tries to pinch out +his adversaries there--Mrs. Partington's nephew, in fact--wants the +one quality which will make that kind of thing intolerable--that is, +high spirits. The Black Hussars of Maga both had them, and drank +them, frequently neat. I judge that the Nephew has to be more careful. +Eupepsy is not revealed in his writing; but Christopher North and his +co-mates must have had the stomachs of ostriches. The guzzling and +swilling which were the staple of the _Noctes_ were remarked upon at +the time as incredible as well as disgusting; but it is to be presumed +that they wouldn't have been there if, to the majority at least, they +had not been a counsel of perfection. "I wasn't as drunk as I should +have liked to be, your Worship, but I was drunk." + +As well as that, most people thought it exceedingly funny. Dickens +and his readers thought it funny too. Christmas would not have been +Christmas unless somebody got beastly drunk. We have moved on since +then, and carried the Nephew with us, _multum gementem_. One can see +him kicking violently under the arm of the _Zeitgeist_ as he is borne +down the ringing grooves of change. Now, therefore, he is tart in his +musings, chastises rather with fleas than with scorpions. + +When the _Noctes_ can stand away from Politics and Literature--for the +two were always involved in those days, so that unless you approved a +man's party you couldn't allow that he wrote tolerable verse--they can +wile away a winter evening very pleasantly. Christopher North had an +eye for character, a sense of humour, and knew and loved the country. +He was country bred. He is at his best when he combines his loves, +as he does in the person of the Shepherd. Keep the Shepherd off (_a_) +girls, (_b_) nursing mothers, (_c_) the Sabbath, (_d_) eating, (_e_) +drinking, (_f_) his own poetry, and he is good reading. Knowing and +loving Ettrick Forest as I do, I need no better guide to it than +North's Shepherd. Having fished all its waters from Loch Skene +downwards, I should ask no better company, evenings, at Tibbie +Shields' or the Tushielaw Inn. Edward FitzGerald could have made a +good book out of the _Noctes_, cutting it down to one volume out of +four. As it is mainly, it will stand or fall by its high spirits. The +really funny character in it is Gurney, the shorthand writer, who is +kept in a cupboard, and at the end of the last uproarious chapter, +when the coast is cleared of the horseplaying protagonists, "comes out +like a mouse, and begins to nibble cheese." That is imagination. + +The real Ettrick Shepherd was better than the _Noctes_ can make him. +Lockhart gives a delightful account of his first visit to Walter Scott +in Castle Street--his first visit, mind you. He is shown into the +drawing-room and finds Mrs. Scott, disposed, _a la_ Madame Recamier, +on a sofa. His acuteness comes to the aid of his bewilderment, and he +is quick to extend himself in similar fashion upon the opposite sofa. +In the dining-room he was much more at his ease. Before the end of the +meal he had his host as "Wattie" and his hostess as "Charlotte." Next +day he wrote to Scott to ask what he might have said, and to offer +apologies if needful. + +A remark put into his mouth by North, that he could "ban" Burns for +having forestalled him with the line-- + + The summer to Nature, my Willie to me! + +set me wondering wherein consists the true lyrical magic. In that line +of Burns's, clearly, it lies in the harmony of lyric thought and lyric +lilt. In-- + + Come away, come away, Death, + +it is in the lilt alone. One thing only about it is sure, and that is +that the diction must be conversational. There will be tears in the +voice, but the voice must be that of the homely earth, never of the +stage, never of the pulpit If you agree with that, you will have to +cut out practically all the poets from Dryden to Cowper, Gray and +Collins among them; for Gray has a learned sock, and hardly allows +familiarity when he is elegising Horace Walpole's cat. But Shakespeare +proves it, Ben Jonson proves it, and all the good poets from +Wordsworth. Burns had the vernacular to help him, and for the most +part a model to steer by. All Lowland Scots, lads and lassies, wail, +and occasionally howl, in his songs. The first two lines of that one +envied by Hogg run: + + Here awa, there awa, wandering Willie, + Here awa, there awa, haud awa hame! + +and of these the second is traditional, altered only in one word. +Burns writes "haud awa hame" instead of repeating "here awa"--and +improves it. Shakespeare used the King's English, but never shirked a +racy idiom. Here is a good instance from the Sonnets, and from one of +the greatest of them, "Farewell, thou art too dear." + + Thus have I had thee as a dream doth flatter-- + In sleep a king; but waking _no such matter_. + +You might call that a slang phrase and be right. + +There are other cases, and many; some where he goes all lengths, and +one at least where he goes beyond them. But to leave Shakespeare, for +a perfect example of passion married to common speech, commend me to-- + + Since there's no help, come let us kiss and part, + Nay, I have done, you get no more of me; + But I am glad, yea, glad with all my heart + That thus so clearly I myself can free. + +Intense feeling, intense music, a lovely thing: a poem. + + + + +SKELETONS AT A FEAST + + +The other day the village was celebrating the birthday of its +Labourers' Union in a manner which used to be reserved for the coming +of age of the Squire's son, or for the Harvest Festival, in which the +farmer might give thanks for the harvest, and the peasant, perhaps, +for having been allowed to assist in winning it. I take a sort of +pride in recording a staidness in the observance which I believe to be +peculiar to the countryside in which I live. There was a service, +with a sermon, in church, all persuasions uniting; then a dinner with +speeches; then sports and dancing on the grass. Every stave of the +Pastoral was announced and punctuated by the village band. "God save +the King" closed all down at nine o'clock. + +It was sober merry-making after our manner, yet one could feel the +undercurrent of a triumph not difficult to understand. Not a man there +but knew, or had heard his father tell, of how things used to be. Ten +years ago those men were earning sixteen shillings a week for twelve +hours a day; fifteen years ago they were earning twelve shillings; +thirty years ago they were earning nine shillings; a hundred years +ago they were on the rates, herded about in conscript gangs under the +hectorings of an overseer. Now--and it has seemed to come all in a +moment--the humblest of them earn their 36_s._ 6_d._; the head men +their 40_s._; their hours are down to fifty for the week, with a +half-holiday on Saturday; delegates of their kind sit at a board in +Trowbridge face to face and of equal worth with delegates of their +employers. All matters affecting their status, housing, terms of +employment can be brought before the board; and beside that, and +behind it, like a buttress, there is a Union, whose name recalls that +other grim fortress to which alone in times bygone they had to look +when old age was upon them. This new Union has been in existence here +little more than a twelvemonth, but they know now that it has spread +all over England. + +They know more than that. They know that this plexus of organisations +is not only social, but political; they feel that the estate of the +realm which they stand for may soon become, and must before long +become, the predominant estate. They feel the rising tide already +lifting them off their feet. The elders are sobered by the flood; but +the young ones taste the salt water sprayed off the crest of the wave +and look at each other, laugh and cheer. If they rejoice they have +good reason, knowing what they know; and if I rejoice with them, I +think that I have good reason too. This time seven years ago I sang +at length of Hodge and his plow; and looking back and forth over his +blood-stained, sweat-stained and tear-stained history, I seemed to see +what was coming to him as the crown of his thousand years of toil. + + I look and see the end of it, + How fair the well-lov'd land appears; + I see September's misty heat + Laid like a swooning on the corn; + I see the reaping of the wheat, + I hear afar the hunter's horn, + I see the cattle at the ford, + The panting sheep beneath the thorn! + The burden of the years is scor'd, + The reckoning made, Hodge walks alone, + Content, contenting, his own lord, + Master of what his pain has won. + +And so indeed it is. The peasant now has his foot on the degrees of +the throne, and has only to step up, he and his mates of the mine, the +forge, the foundry and the railroad--to step up and lay hand to the +orb and sceptre. + + +If I had misgivings, and if those, when imparted to, were shared by an +old friend of mine who still gives me six hours a day of his strength +and skill when the weather and his rheumatics can hit it off together, +I may say at once that though they were renewed in me by the late +threat of the railwaymen arrogantly hurled at the only Government in +my recollection which has made arrogance in asking almost a necessary +stage in negotiation, they had been present for a long time--beyond +Mr. Smillie's wild proposals of direct action, beyond the Yorkshire +miners and the flooded coalfields; back to the day when electricians +refused to light the Albert Hall, and Merchant Seamen refused passage +to some politician or another because they didn't like his politics. +One and each of those direct and unsteady actions made me shiver for +the men with their feet on the throne's degrees. And now a Railway +Strike, which has injured every one and will throw back the railwaymen +and their Labour Party for many a year! If these things are done in +the green wood, I asked my friend, what will be done in the dry? + +He couldn't answer me but by asking in his turn questions which +were but a variation of my own. He said: "Our people don't seem to +understand anything but 'each man for himself.' The miners hold up +the country for higher wages, and the country has to pay them; the +railwaymen do the same, and the country must find double fares and +high freight. They hit their own class hardest of all, because dear +coal and high tariffs touch everybody. And they don't even help +themselves, because directly wages are raised, up goes the price of +everything. Now what I want you to tell me is how are they going to +stop all that when they are the Government? For it will have to stop." + +He is right: it will have to stop; but I don't see how the Labour +Party is going to stop it. So far as I can make out, the Labour Party, +as a responsible, political body, has no control whatsoever over the +trade unions; and the trade unions, as such, none over their members. +How, then, is one to look forward with comfort to the establishment +of a Labour Government? It will take a readier speech than even Mr. +Webb's, a more confident than even Mr. Smillie's to illuminate this +smoke-blurred scene whereon we make out every trade union preying upon +Mr. George's vitals (which are, unfortunately, for the moment our +own vitals), and with a success so disastrously easy as to make any +prospects of a return to sane, honest, dignified or just government +almost hopeless! Mr. George is destroying himself hand over fist, and +the sooner the better; but one does not want to see England go down +with him. I am all for anarchy myself when once it is thoroughly +grasped by everybody that anarchy means minding your own business. +But we are far from that as yet. Anarchy at present means minding, and +grudging, other people's business. Such anarchy is not government, but +plundering with both hands. + +My point, however, is that, if we are to have a Labour Government, +it must be a Government of a nation, and not a class-affair. When the +Duke said that the King's Government must be carried on, he meant the +Government of King George or King William. Our present Prime Minister +means the Government of Mr. George, which is a very different affair. +In its way of simple egotism it is precisely the meaning of the trade +unions, and can be shortlier put as "After me the deluge." And that +won't do. We want neither autocracy nor anarchy; and just now the one +involves the other. + + + + +A COMMENTARY UPON BUTLER + + +Mr. Festing Jones has written a large book about his friend, and +written it very well.[A] It is candid, and it is sincere; the work +of a lover at once of Butler and of truth; it neither extenuates the +faults nor magnifies the virtues of its subject so far as the author +could perceive them; and it makes it possible to understand why Butler +was so underrated in his lifetime, though not at once why he was so +overrated after his death. That remains a problem which cannot be +resolved by saying that his friends trumpeted him into it, or that +posthumous readers enjoyed seeing him belabour his betters, which his +contemporaries had not. It is true that _The Way of All Flesh_ did not +appear until he was dead, and also true that _The Way of All Flesh_ +is a witty and malicious novel, whose malice and wit Mr. Shaw had +prepared London to admire. Perhaps it is true, once more, that we are +more scornful of the old orthodoxy than our fathers were, and less +careful whose feelings are hurt. But I must confess that I should not +have expected any age to be so complacent about caricaturing one's +father and mother as our own was. However, for those who admire that +sort of thing--and there must be many--I doubt if they will find +it better done anywhere, with more gusto or more point. Dickens is +believed to have put his father into _David Copperfield_, not, I +think, his mother. But one can love Mr. Micawber, and Dickens would +not have so drawn him without love. We are led to Butler's favourite +distinction between _gnosis_ and _agape_. There's no doubt about the +_gnosis_ that went to the making of Theobald and Christina. But where +was _agape_? + +[Footnote A: _Samuel Butler, Author of "Erewhon"_ (1835-1902): _a +Memoir_. By Henry Festing Jones. Two Vols. Macmillan, 1919.] + +Butler was in many respects a fortunate man, and should have been +a happy one. He had a good education, good health, a sufficiency of +means. Even when his embarrassments were at their heaviest he could +always afford to do as he pleased. He could draw a little, play a +little, write more than a little; he loved travel, and covered all +Southern Europe in his time; he had good friends, a good mistress, a +faithful servant; he had a strong sense of humour, feared nobody, had +a hundred interests. Why, then, did he think himself a failure? Why +was the sense of it to cloud much of his writing, and much of Mr. +Jones's biography? + +He had his drawbacks--who has not? He did not get on with his father, +criticised his mother; his sisters scraped the edges of his nerves; a +man to whom he was extremely generous betrayed him. The like of these +things must happen to mortal men. Butler knew that as well as any one. +But his books were not read; the great men whom he attacked ignored +him. He thought himself to be something, they treated him as nothing, +and the public followed them. He knew all about it, and Mr. Jones +knows all about it. He had unseated the secure with _Erewhon_, +outraged the orthodox with _Fairhaven_, flouted the biologists, +himself being no biologist, plunged into Homeric criticism without +archaeology, swum against the current in Shakespearianism, enjoyed +himself immensely, playing _l'enfant terrible_, and treading on +every corn he could find--and then he was angry because the sufferers +pretended that they had no corns. How could he expect it both ways? +If he was serious, why did he write as if he was not? And if he had +tender feelings himself--as he obviously had--why should he expect +all the people he attacked with his pinpricks to have none? It was not +reasonable. + +The answer to these questions is to be found in some little weaknesses +of his which Mr. Jones's biography, all unconsciously, reveals. +Butler, it is clear, was morbidly vain. Many writers are so, but few +let their vanity take them so far. Learn from Mr. Jones. In 1879 he +and Butler met Edward Lear in an inn at Varese. He told them a little +tale about a tipsy man from Manchester--rather a good little tale. "I +do not remember that Edward Lear told us anything else particularly +amusing, but then neither did we tell him anything particularly +amusing. Butler was seldom at his best with a celebrated man. He +was not successful himself, and had a sub-aggressive feeling that +a celebrated man probably did not deserve his celebrity; if he did +deserve it, let him prove it." There is no getting away from that +symptom, which is as unreasonable as it is perverse. Celebrated men +are not usually so anxious to "prove" their celebrity as all that +comes to. It is bad enough to be "celebrated." It was hard lines on +old Lear to sulk with him because he would not show off. If he had +wanted to do that he would not have gone to Varese. But that is +mortified vanity. The same thing happened when he met Mr. Birrell at +dinner in 1900. Then it was the celebrity who took pains to save +his host and hostess from a frosty dinner party. The same thing is +recalled of meetings with Sir George Trevelyan and Lord Morley earlier +in the book. It is all pretty stupid; but when a man is ridden by a +vanity like that there can be no healthy pleasure to be got out of +writing for its own sake. You must have your public flat on its back +before your vanity will be soothed. + +Another failing of Butler's, shared, I am sorry to say, by Mr. Jones, +was a love of little jokes and an inability to see when and where they +could be worked off, or perhaps I ought to say when they were worked +out. A great many of them were pinpricks rather than jokes; he only +made them "to annoy." Well, they did, and they do, annoy--not because +they were jokes, but because they were feeble jokes. "If it is thought +desirable to have an article on the _Odyssey_, I have abundant, most +aggravating and impudent matter about Penelope and King Menelaus"--so +he wrote to Mr. H. Quilter, who naturally jumped at it. Here is +another gem which Mr. Jones seems to admire: "There will be no +comfortable and safe development of our social arrangements--I mean +we shall not get infanticide, and the permission of suicide, nor cheap +and easy divorce--till Jesus Christ's ghost has been laid." + +All that can be said for that is that it is vivacious, and that it has +helped Mr. Shaw, who has certainly bettered the instruction. There +are others which are a good deal more annoying than that. Jokes about +infanticide and Jesus Christ defeat themselves, and always will. They +are on a level with jokes about death or one's mother; they recoil +and smite the smiter on the nose. I confess that I find the joke +about Charles Lamb irritating. Butler said that he could not read +Lamb because Canon Ainger went to tea with his (Butler's) sisters. His +gibes at Dante are as bad--in fact they are worse, aggravated by the +fact that, having never read (he assures us) a word of him, he puts +him down as one of the seven humbugs of Christendom. He would not read +Dante because he had liked Virgil, nor Virgil because Tennyson liked +him. "We are not amused," as Queen Victoria said of another little +joke. + +The correspondence with Miss Savage, again, does not reveal a pleasant +personality. Indeed, the discomfort one gets from it is at times +painful. Mr. Jones says that she bored Butler, and I don't wonder at +it. The wonder would rather be that she did not set his teeth on +edge if it were not that he was nearly as bad as she was. It is not +a matter of facetiousness--I dare say he never tired of that; and +perhaps the thinness of the jokes--little misreadings of hymns, things +about the Mammon of Righteousness, and so on--in a kind of way added +to the fun of them. It is their subject matter which offends. They +commonly turn upon the health of the respective parents and the +chances of an attack carrying them off. _Queste cose_, as the hero +said of the suicide, _non si fanno_. But I suppose that if you could +put your mother's death-bed into a novel, you could do almost anything +in that kind. + +I am myself singularly moved, with Coventry Patmore, to love the +lovely who are not beloved--but not the unlovely. Those little jokes, +and many others, are by no means lovely, and if Butler repeated them +as often as Mr. Jones does, it is not surprising that he was avoided +by many who missed or dreaded the point. His lecture on the _Humour +of Homer_ made Mr. Garnett unhappy and Miss Jane Harrison cross, Mr. +Jones says. I don't doubt it. It is very cheap humour indeed, and no +more Homer's than mine is. It is entirely Butler's humour about +Homer, a very different thing. Its impudence did not mitigate +the aggravation, but made it more acute. If he had picked out a +fairy-tale, rather than two glorious poems--_Little Red Riding Hood_, +_The Three Bears_, _Rumpelstiltskin_, for example--he could have been +as facetious as he pleased. But that would not suit him. There would +have been no darts to fling. Butler was a _banderillero_. All right; +but then don't complain that the Miss Harrisons, Darwins, and others +shake off your darts and go about their business, which, oddly enough, +is not to gore and trample the _banderillero_; don't be huffed because +you are held for a _gamin_. Butler wanted it both ways. + +The conclusion is irresistible that Butler's controversial books were +not primarily written to discover truth, but because he was vain +and wished at once to be sensational and annoying. He resented the +greatness of the great, or the celebrity of the celebrated; his vanity +was wounded. He sought, then, for "most aggravating and impudent +matter" to wound them in turn who had vicariously wounded him. He +"learned" them to be toads, or celebrities, or tried to. But his love +of little jokes betrayed him. He, a sort of minnow, thought to trouble +the pool where the great fish were oaring at ease by flirting the +surface with his tail. It seemed to him that he was throwing up a fine +volume of water; but the great fish held their way unconscious in the +deep. Chiefly, therefore, he failed with all his cleverness. Brain he +had, logic he had; the heart was a-wanting and the intention faltered. +_Gnosis_ again and _agape_! + +Brain he had, logic he had; but brain must follow upon emotional +intention if it is to create; and logic must follow upon sound +premisses if it is to convince. Now if his prime intention was to +annoy, or, if you granted him his premisses, Butler would never miss +the mark. But is that intention worthy of more than it earned? I don't +think so. And can you grant him his premisses? I don't think that you +can. He argued _a priori_, apparently always. I am not a biologist, +nor was he, but if I know enough of scientific method to be sure that +biologists cannot argue that way, so undoubtedly did he. What should +Darwin, who had spent years in patient accumulation of fact, have +to say to him? In Homeric criticism--_a priori_ again. He had an +instinct--he owns it was no more--that the _Odyssey_ was written by a +woman. Then he studied the _Odyssey_ to prove that it was. Perhaps +a woman did write it, and perhaps it will one day be proved. The +_Odyssey_, as Butler used it, will never prove it. So also with the +Sicilian origin of the poem. He got his idea, and went to Trapani +to fit it in. It does not seem to have occurred to him that all the +things he found there are to be found also in the Ionian Islands and +might be found in half a hundred other places in a sea pullulating +with islands or a coast-line cut about like a jigsaw puzzle. But it +won't do, of course. No one knew that better than he. + +Mr. Jones says that "Butler's judgments were arrived at by thinking +the matter out for himself." I don't know what judgments he means: in +the context he is talking about "other writers." Among such he would +not, perhaps, include Dante, Virgil or Charles Lamb. If he includes +Homer and Shakespeare there would be a good deal to say. I don't +believe he had thought about the authorship of the _Odyssey_ at all +until he had assumed what he afterwards spent his time and pains in +supporting. As to Shakespeare's age when he wrote his Sonnets, I don't +myself find that the Sonnets support him. Those which he quotes in +particular show that W.H. was a youth, but not that the author was. +But there, again, he was arguing _a priori_. He desired to prove what +he set out to prove, and the scholars disregarded him. Mr. Bridges, in +a letter which Mr. Jones has the candour to quote, puts the matter as +neatly as may be. "I am very sorry indeed that you have been so clever +as to make up so good (or bad) a story: but I willingly recognise that +no one has brought the matter into so clear a light as you have done. +You are always perspicuous, and nothing but good can come of such +conscientious work as yours. Still, you must remember that you proved +Darwin to be an arch-impostor; and there was no fault in your logic. +It is not the logic that fails in this book." No. It was not the +logic. + + + + +THE COMMEMORATION + + +Eleven o'clock in the morning found the village at its field and +household affairs, with birds abroad and dogs at home assisting +in various ways. The plovers wove black and white webs over the +water-meadows, gulls were like drifting snow behind the plow. In a +cottage garden the dog, high on his haunches at the length of his +chain, cocked his ears towards the huswife in the wash-house, hoping +against hope for a miracle. Luxuriously full, the cat slept on the +window-ledge. Meantime a roadman was cleaning a gutter, a thatcher +pegged down his yelm; a milkmaid, driving up the street in a float, +stopped, threw the reins over the pony's quarters, and jumped down, +very trim in her overall and breeches. The church clock struck eleven. + +She turned, as if shot, and stood facing the church whose flag +streamed to the south. The roadman straightened himself and leaned +upon his mattock; the huswife shut the back door, and the dog crept +into his barrel. The schoolyard, accustomed at that hour to flood +suddenly with noise, remained empty. But the milkmaid's horse drew +to the hedge for a bite, the birds on the hillside settled about the +halted plow, and the cat slept on. + +We are what we are, all of us. Beasts and birds are not sentimental. +Things to them stand for things, not for thoughts about things. I have +seen young rabbits play cross-touch about the stiffened form of +an unfortunate brother. I have seen a barnyard cock flap and crow, +standing upon the dead body of one of his wives. Directly a creature +is dead it ceases to be a creature at all to those which once hailed +it fellow. It becomes part of the landscape in which it lies; and +with certain beasts which we are accustomed to call obscene it becomes +something to eat. But dogs which have lived long with us are not like +that. I knew two dogs which lived in a house together and shared the +same loose-box at night. One night one of them in fidgeting, bit upon +an artery and bled to death. Never again would the survivor enter that +sleeping place. Dogs have learned from us that things may stand for +thoughts. + +Anything that persuades the British people to spend two minutes a +year in thought is a good thing; for thinking is not congenial to us. +Feeling is; and feeling may perhaps be described as thinking about +thinking. We feel still, as we felt at the time, the wholesale, +hapless, heroic and entirely monstrous sacrifice of our young men; but +it is out of the question to suppose that we thought about them--or, +for that matter, that any nation in the world did; for if we had +thought as we felt the scythe would have stopt in mid-swathe and Death +been robbed of a crowning victory! But we did not think; and we +were not thinking just now when we stood still in the midst of our +interrupted affairs. The act sufficed us. It was a sacrament. An act, +that is, a thing, stood for a thought about a thing--namely heroic, +hapless death. Of such sacraments, maybe, is the kingdom of this +world, but not, I am persuaded, the Kingdom of Heaven; and assuredly +not of such, nor of any amount of it, will be a League of Nations +which is anything more than a name. + +The thought, or the feeling, of those two minutes here in the village, +or in the city eight miles away, where in full market the same +opportunity was taken, was concerned in all human probability, with +the hapless dead rather than with means to preserve the living from +hapless and unnecessary death; and yet, so curiously are we wrought +out of emotion, sensibility and habit, some good besides piety may +come out of a memorial Eleventh of November. Pitying, recording, +respecting the dead or perhaps the bereaved, it may presently become +a fixed idea with us that avoidable death is taboo. It may be borne +in upon us on the next occasion when stung pride, outraged feeling or +panic fear is sweeping like a plague over our land, that nothing +but sorrow and loss was gained by the Four Years War. That is just +possible, but no more than that, we being what we are. Yet, unless we +learn to think rather of life than of death, there is no other way. As +in religion, faith comes before works, and you must fall in love with +God if you are to believe in Him, so it is in politics. Emotional +conviction must precede action. And the conviction to be established +is that war is a crime and in some nations, a vice. + +In the Middle Ages a great and ever-present fear of death coincided +with an extraordinary neglect of life. Whole companies, whole classes +of men thought of little but death; yet they killed each other for a +look or a thought; in war whole cities were put to the sword and fire, +as the Black Prince put Limoges. _Timor mortis conturbat me!_ So men +shuddered and wailed, but took not the smallest trouble to keep +each other alive. The Black Death swept off at least a third of the +population of Europe; yet after it things went on exactly as before. +If nations had then possessed the technical skill which they have +to-day, it is quite on the cards that France in the Hundred Years or +Germany in the Thirty Years War, would have been emptied of its folk. +The will thereto was not wanting, that's certain. + +Well, we are a little better than that. Sanitation has at last become +a fixed idea. And there is another thing. We no longer consider a man +as magnified by his office, but rather that the office is magnified in +that a man is serving it. In the old days the splendour of an army on +the march was reflected upon the men composing it, and glorified +every one of them. Now it is the other way. We are apt to see the +army glorious because it is composed of men. Lord Kitchener's host, +perhaps, has taught us that. We are getting on, then, if we are +beginning to take manhood seriously. + +It is something at least, and so much to the good, that we have +imagined a new sacrament, and found it in the attitude, if not in the +act of thought. "Who rises from his prayer a better man, his prayer is +answered," said a wise man; and if that is true, the King may save +his people yet. But to enable him to do it we must pray for the living +rather than the dead, and pray for Good Will among them. For that is +what we want. + + + + +THE QUAKER EIRENICON + + +In our late scramble to spend our own, or secure some other body's, +money, a message of beauty, distinction and serene confidence in its +own truth, has been overlooked by this distracted world. There is +little wonder. As well might a blackbird flute on Margate Sands on a +Bank Holiday as this Quaker message, "To all men," breathe love and +goodwill among them just now. The effect has been much the same: to +those who heeded it matter for tears that such heavenly balm should be +within our hearing but out of our grasp; to the ravenous and the rabid +a mere foolishness. + +To my mind nothing so admirable has been put forward by any Church +calling itself Christian throughout five years' horror and delirium. +I must not expect the _Morning Boast_ or _Long Bow_ to agree with it, +but I am inclined to ask my fellow citizens if they have not yet had +enough of these evangelists of war and ill-will towards men. If they +have, here is an alternative for them to try. + +"We appeal to all men," say the Quakers to the world, "to recognise +the great spiritual force of love which is found in all, and which +makes us one common brotherhood." It is a hard saying, as things are +now; and yet, if it is true, that 'tis love that makes the world go +round, it is certain by this time that 'tis hate that makes it stop. +What stops trade? English hate Germans, Germans hate English; masters +grudge men, men masters. What holds up Ireland? Protestants hate +Catholics, Catholics Protestants; each hates England and England hates +both. The infernal brew of 1914 has poisoned the tissues of humanity; +proud flesh, sour blood, keep us all in a sick ferment. What will save +us? Who will show us any good? + +One thing only, say the Quakers. Listen. "Through the dark cloud of +selfishness and materialism shines the eternal light of Christ in man. +It can never perish.... The profound need of our time is to realise +the everlasting truth of the common Fatherhood of God--the Spirit of +Love--and the oneness of the human race." I wondered on Christmas Day, +when children were carolling "Peace on earth and mercy mild," for how +many hundred years men had been hearing that, how many of them had +said that they believed it, and how many had acted as if they did +believe it. I wondered if the editors of _Long Bow_ and the _Morning +Boast_ had heard them, and what effect the words would have upon +their next articles about the deportation of aliens, or the value of +machine-guns as strike-breakers. + +"We have used the words of Christ, but we have not acted upon them. +We have called ourselves by His name but we have not lived in His +spirit." Those words should form part of any General Confession to +be used in church, since the words used there now have lost their +meaning. They are entirely true; since Christ died we have never acted +upon His words, or attempted for six years at a time "to live in His +spirit." How does one do it? The Quakers go on to tell us. "The Divine +Seed is in all men. As men realise its presence, and follow the light +of Christ in their hearts, they enter upon the right way of life, and +receive power to overcome evil by good. Thus will be built the City of +God." + +While it is plain, then, how the City of God will be rebuilt on earth, +it ought to be equally so how it will not be built. Lately another +Message has been advertised in the Press, which does not promise any +help. It has been proposed[A] to publish certain private letters of +the German ex-Emperor which, we learn, incriminate him still more +deeply in the original sin of the war. Here no doubt is "a scoop," as +they call it, for somebody; but with "scoops," I suppose, the City of +God has little to do. + +[Footnote A: It was done too.] + +And apart from the supposition that the man is about to be tried for +his offences against society at large--in which case it is a +flouting of justice to publish evidence against him in a newspaper +beforehand--apart from all that, how in God's name is His city to be +rebuilt by raking in waste-heaps for more hate-stuff? The wretched man +is beaten, abdicated, exiled, sick, probably out of his mind, if +he ever had one. Is it an English habit to revile the fallen and +impotent? It has not been so hitherto, and the newspaper which +proposes to enrich itself by making most of us ashamed of our +nationality is doing us a bad service and, I hope, itself a worse. + +But while such things go on, far from the City of God being rebuilt, +the ruins of it will sink deeper into the morass, until we all go +down to the devil together. And if we are to be as the Evangelists +of Ill-Will desire us, the sooner that happens the better. As an +alternative to this disgusting but deserved consummation I call +attention to the Quaker Eirenicon. + +I love and respect the Quakers as Christians after the doctrine of +Christ. I have known many, and never a bad one among them, never one +that was not sound at heart and sweet in nature. As well as their +social quality there is to be considered their political. I don't +hesitate to say that their Corporation holds in its grasp the +salvation of the world through their Master and mine. I go further, +and don't hesitate to say that had the Quaker religion been this +country's, not only should we not have made war, but Germany would not +have provoked it. Had Europe at large been Quaker, war would have been +eliminated long ago from the catalogue of national crimes; for to a +Quaker war is what cannibalism is to all men, and love, apparently +to some men, an unthinkable offence against the sanctity of the +body. That body, they say, is a possible tabernacle for the Spirit of +Christ. If you believe that, all the rest follows. If you do not, you +will continue to read the _Morning Boast_. + + + +THE END + + PRINTED IN GREAT BRITAIN BY + WILLIAM CLOWES AND SONS, LIMITED + LONDON AND BECCLES + + + +Transcriber's Note. + +The following words were originally printed with an oe ligature, +regrettably not provided in the ASCII character set: + +Boeotia, Boeotian, Ipomoea, Eoioe, OEnoe, OEno. + + + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of In a Green Shade, by Maurice Hewlett + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK IN A GREEN SHADE *** + +***** This file should be named 15495.txt or 15495.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + https://www.gutenberg.org/1/5/4/9/15495/ + +Produced by S.R.Ellison, Audrey Longhurst, and the Online Distributed +Proofreading Team. + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License (available with this file or online at +https://gutenberg.org/license). + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH F3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS' WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTIBILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need, is critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation web page at https://www.pglaf.org. + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Its 501(c)(3) letter is posted at +https://pglaf.org/fundraising. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at +809 North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887, email +business@pglaf.org. Email contact links and up to date contact +information can be found at the Foundation's web site and official +page at https://pglaf.org + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit https://pglaf.org + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including including checks, online payments and credit card +donations. To donate, please visit: https://pglaf.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For thirty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + https://www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. |
