diff options
| -rw-r--r-- | .gitattributes | 3 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 7836-8.txt | 3385 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 7836-8.zip | bin | 0 -> 74534 bytes | |||
| -rw-r--r-- | 7836-h.zip | bin | 0 -> 77791 bytes | |||
| -rw-r--r-- | 7836-h/7836-h.htm | 3639 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 7836.txt | 3385 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 7836.zip | bin | 0 -> 74490 bytes | |||
| -rw-r--r-- | LICENSE.txt | 11 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | README.md | 2 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/8jwhs10.zip | bin | 0 -> 75058 bytes |
10 files changed, 10425 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/.gitattributes b/.gitattributes new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6833f05 --- /dev/null +++ b/.gitattributes @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +* text=auto +*.txt text +*.md text diff --git a/7836-8.txt b/7836-8.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..bb608f8 --- /dev/null +++ b/7836-8.txt @@ -0,0 +1,3385 @@ +The Project Gutenberg EBook of Jewish History, by S. M. Dubnow + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: Jewish History + +Author: S. M. Dubnow + + +Release Date: April, 2005 [EBook #7836] +This file was first posted on May 21, 2003 +Last Updated: May 8, 2013 + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK JEWISH HISTORY *** + + + + +Produced by David King, Charles Franks, and the Online +Distributed Proofreading Team + + + + + + + +JEWISH HISTORY + +AN ESSAY IN THE PHILOSOPHY +OF HISTORY + +By S. M. Dubnow + + + + +PREFACE TO THE GERMAN TRANSLATION + + +The author of the present essay, S. M. Dubnow, occupies a well-nigh +dominating position in Russian-Jewish literature as an historian and +an acute critic. His investigations into the history of the +Polish-Russian Jews, especially his achievements in the history of +Chassidism, have been of fundamental importance in these departments. +What raises Mr. Dubnow far above the status of the professional +historian, and awakens the reader's lively interest in him, is not so +much the matter of his books, as the manner of presentation. It is +rare to meet with an historian in whom scientific objectivity and +thoroughness are so harmoniously combined with an ardent temperament +and plastic ability. Mr. Dubnow's scientific activity, first and last, +is a striking refutation of the widespread opinion that identifies +attractiveness of form in the work of a scholar with superficiality of +content. Even his strictly scientific investigations, besides offering +the scholar a wealth of new suggestions, form instructive and +entertaining reading matter for the educated layman. In his critical +essays, Mr. Dubnow shows himself to be possessed of keen psychologic +insight. By virtue of this quality of delicate perception, he aims to +assign to every historical fact its proper place in the line of +development, and so establish the bond between it and the general +history of mankind. This psychologic ability contributes vastly to the +interest aroused by Mr. Dubnow's historical works outside of the +limited circle of scholars. There is a passage in one of his books[1] +in which, in his incisive manner, he expresses his views on the limits +and tasks of historical writing. As the passage bears upon the methods +employed in the present essay, and, at the same time, is a +characteristic specimen of our author's style, I take the liberty of +quoting: + +"The popularization of history is by no means to be pursued to the +detriment of its severely scientific treatment. What is to be guarded +against is the notion that tedium is inseparable from the scientific +method. I have always been of the opinion that the dulness commonly +looked upon as the prerogative of scholarly inquiries, is not an +inherent attribute. In most cases it is conditioned, not by the nature +of the subject under investigation, but by the temper of the +investigator. Often, indeed, the tediousness of a learned disquisition +is intentional: it is considered one of the polite conventions of the +academic guild, and by many is identified with scientific thoroughness +and profound learning.... If, in general, deadening, hide-bound caste +methods, not seldom the cover for poverty of thought and lack of +cleverness, are reprehensible, they are doubly reprehensible in +history. The history of a people is not a mere mental discipline, like +botany or mathematics, but a living science, a _magistra vitae_, +leading straight to national self-knowledge, and acting to a certain +degree upon the national character. History is a science _by_ the +people, _for_ the people, and, therefore, its place is the open +forum, not the scholar's musty closet. We relate the events of the +past to the people, not merely to a handful of archaeologists and +numismaticians. We work for national self-knowledge, not for our own +intellectual diversion." + + [1] In the introduction to his _Historische Mitteilungen, + Vorarbeiten zu einer Geschichte der pol-nischrussischen + Juden_. + +These are the principles that have guided Mr. Dubnow in all his works, +and he has been true to them in the present essay, which exhibits in a +remarkably striking way the author's art of making "all things seem +fresh and new, important and attractive." New and important his essay +undoubtedly is. The author attempts, for the first time, a psychologic +characterization of Jewish history. He endeavors to demonstrate the +inner connection between events, and develop the ideas that underlie +them, or, to use his own expression, lay bare the soul of Jewish +history, which clothes itself with external events as with a bodily +envelope. Jewish history has never before been considered from this +philosophic point of view, certainly not in German literature. The +present work, therefore, cannot fail to prove stimulating. As for the +poet's other requirement, attractiveness, it is fully met by the work +here translated. The qualities of Mr. Dubnow's style, as described +above, are present to a marked degree. The enthusiasm flaming up in +every line, coupled with his plastic, figurative style, and his +scintillating conceits, which lend vivacity to his presentation, is +bound to charm the reader. Yet, in spite of the racy style, even the +layman will have no difficulty in discovering that it is not a clever +journalist, an artificer of well-turned phrases, who is speaking to +him, but a scholar by profession, whose foremost concern is with +historical truth, and whose every statement rests upon accurate, +scientific knowledge; not a bookworm with pale, academic blood +trickling through his veins, but a man who, with unsoured mien, with +fresh, buoyant delight, offers the world the results laboriously +reached in his study, after all evidences of toil and moil have been +carefully removed; who derives inspiration from the noble and the +sublime in whatever guise it may appear, and who knows how to +communicate his inspiration to others. + +The translator lays this book of an accomplished and spirited +historian before the German public. He does so in the hope that it +will shed new light upon Jewish history even for professional +scholars. He is confident that in many to whom our unexampled past of +four thousand years' duration is now _terra incognita_, it will +arouse enthusiastic interest, and even to those who, like the +translator himself, differ from the author in religious views, it will +furnish edifying and suggestive reading. J. F. + + + + +PREFACE TO THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION + + +The English translation of Mr. Dubnow's Essay is based upon the +authorized German translation, which was made from the original +Russian. It is published under the joint auspices of the Jewish +Publication Society of America and the Jewish Historical Society of +England. H. S. + + + + +TABLE OF CONTENTS + + +PREFACE TO THE GERMAN TRANSLATION + +INTRODUCTORY NOTE + +I + +THE RANGE OF JEWISH HISTORY + Historical and Unhistorical Peoples + Three Groups of Nations + The "Most Historical" People + Extent of Jewish History + +II + +THE CONTENT OF JEWISH HISTORY + Two Periods of Jewish History + The Period of Independence + The Election of the Jewish People + Priests and Prophets + The Babylonian Exile and the Scribes + The Dispersion + Jewish History and Universal History + Jewish History Characterized + +III + +THE SIGNIFICANCE OF JEWISH HISTORY + The National Aspect of Jewish History + The Historical Consciousness + The National Idea and National Feeling + The Universal Aspect of Jewish History + An Historical Experiment + A Moral Discipline + Humanitarian Significance of Jewish History + Schleiden and George Eliot + +IV + +THE HISTORICAL SYNTHESIS + Three Primary Periods + Four Composite Periods + +V + +THE PRIMARY OR BIBLICAL PERIOD + Cosmic Origin of the Jewish Religion + Tribal Organization + Egyptian Influence and Experiences + Moses + Mosaism a Religious and Moral as well as a Social and Political + System + National Deities + The Prophets and the two Kingdoms + Judaism a Universal Religion + +VI + +THE SECONDARY OR SPIRITUAL-POLITICAL PERIOD + Growth of National Feeling + Ezra and Nehemiah + The Scribes + Hellenism + The Maccabees + Sadducees, Pharisees, and Essenes + Alexandrian Jews + Christianity + +VII + +THE TERTIARY TALMUDIC OR NATIONAL-RELIGIOUS +PERIOD + The Isolation of Jewry and Judaism + The Mishna + The Talmud + Intellectual Activity in Palestine and Babylonia + The Agada and the Midrash + Unification of Judaism + +VIII + +THE GAONIC PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE ORIENTAL JEWS (500-980) + The Academies + Islam + Karaism + Beginning of Persecutions in Europe + Arabic Civilization in Europe + +IX + +THE RABBINIC-PHILOSOPHICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE SPANISH +JEWS (980-1492) + The Spanish Jews + The Arabic-Jewish Renaissance + The Crusades and the Jews + Degradation of the Jews in Christian Europe + The Provence + The Lateran Council + The Kabbala + Expulsion from Spain + +X + +THE RABBINIC-MYSTICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE GERMAN-POLISH +JEWS (1492-1789) + The Humanists and the Reformation + Palestine an Asylum for Jews + Messianic Belief and Hopes + Holland a Jewish Centre + Poland and the Jews + The Rabbinical Authorities of Poland + Isolation of the Polish Jews + Mysticism and the Practical Kabbala + Chassidism + Persecutions and Morbid Piety + +XI + +THE MODERN PERIOD OF ENLIGHTENMENT (THE NINETEENTH CENTURY) + The French Revolution + The Jewish Middle Ages + Spiritual and Civil Emancipation + The Successors of Mendelssohn + Zunz and the Science of Judaism + The Modern Movements outside of Germany + The Jew in Russia + His Regeneration + Anti-Semitism and Judophobia + +XII + +THE TEACHINGS OF JEWISH HISTORY + Jewry a Spiritual Community + Jewry Indestructible + The Creative Principle of Jewry + The Task of the Future + The Jew and the Nations + The Ultimate Ideal + + + + +INTRODUCTORY NOTE + + +What is Jewish History? In the first place, what does it offer as to +quantity and as to quality? What are its range and content, and what +distinguishes it in these two respects from the history of other +nations? Furthermore, what is the essential meaning, what the spirit, +of Jewish History? Or, to put the question in another way, to what +general results are we led by the aggregate of its facts, considered, +not as a whole, but genetically, as a succession of evolutionary +stages in the consciousness and education of the Jewish people? + +If we could find precise answers to these several questions, they +would constitute a characterization of Jewish History as accurate as +is attainable. To present such a characterization succinctly is the +purpose of the following essay. + + + + +JEWISH HISTORY + +AN ESSAY IN THE PHILOSOPHY OF HISTORY + + + + +I + +THE RANGE OF JEWISH HISTORY + + + Le peuple juif n'est pas seulement considérable par son + antiquité, mais il est encore singulier en sa durée, qui a + toujours continué depuis son origine jusqu'à maintenant ... + S'étendant depuis les premiers temps jusqu'aux derniers, + l'histoire des juifs enferme dans sa durée celle de toutes nos + histoires.--PASCAL, _Pensées_, II, 7. + +To make clear the range of Jewish history, it is necessary to set down +a few general, elementary definitions by way of introduction. + +It has long been recognized that a fundamental difference exists +between historical and unhistorical peoples, a difference growing out +of the fact of the natural inequality between the various elements +composing the human race. Unhistorical is the attribute applied to +peoples that have not yet broken away, or have not departed very far, +from the state of primitive savagery, as, for instance, the barbarous +races of Asia and Africa who were the prehistoric ancestors of the +Europeans, or the obscure, untutored tribes of the present, like the +Tartars and the Kirghiz. Unhistorical peoples, then, are ethnic groups +of all sorts that are bereft of a distinctive, spiritual +individuality, and have failed to display normal, independent capacity +for culture. The term historical, on the other hand, is applied to the +nations that have had a conscious, purposeful history of appreciable +duration; that have progressed, stage by stage, in their growth and in +the improvement of their mode and their views of life; that have +demonstrated mental productivity of some sort, and have elaborated +principles of civilization and social life more or less rational; +nations, in short, representing not only zoologic, but also spiritual +types.[2] + + [2] "The primitive peoples that change with their environment, + constantly adapting themselves to their habitat and to + external nature, have no history.... Only those nations and + states belong to history which display self-conscious action; + which evince an inner spiritual life by diversified + manifestations; and combine into an organic whole what they + receive from without, and what they themselves originate." + (Introduction to Weber's _Allgemeine Weltgeschichte_, i, + pp. 16-18.) + +Chronologically considered, these latter nations, of a higher type, +are usually divided into three groups: 1, the most ancient civilized +peoples of the Orient, such as the Chinese, the Hindoos, the +Egyptians, the Chaldeans; 2, the ancient or classic peoples of the +Occident, the Greeks and the Romans; and 3, the modern peoples, the +civilized nations of Europe and America of the present day. The most +ancient peoples of the Orient, standing "at the threshold of history," +were the first heralds of a religious consciousness and of moral +principles. In hoary antiquity, when most of the representatives of +the human kind were nothing more than a peculiar variety of the class +mammalia, the peoples called the most ancient brought forth recognized +forms of social life and a variety of theories of living of fairly +far-reaching effect. All these culture-bearers of the Orient soon +disappeared from the surface of history. Some (the Chaldeans, +Phoenicians, and Egyptians) were washed away by the flood of time, and +their remnants were absorbed by younger and more vigorous peoples. +Others (the Hindoos and Persians) relapsed into a semi-barbarous +state; and a third class (the Chinese) were arrested in their growth, +and remained fixed in immobility. The best that the antique Orient had +to bequeath in the way of spiritual possessions fell to the share of +the classic nations of the West, the Greeks and the Romans. They +greatly increased the heritage by their own spiritual achievements, +and so produced a much more complex and diversified civilization, +which has served as the substratum for the further development of the +better part of mankind. Even the classic nations had to step aside as +soon as their historical mission was fulfilled. They left the field +free for the younger nations, with greater capability of living, which +at that time had barely worked their way up to the beginnings of a +civilization. One after the other, during the first two centuries of +the Christian era, the members of this European family of nations +appeared in the arena of history. They form the kernel of the +civilized part of mankind at the present day. + +Now, if we examine this accepted classification with a view to finding +the place belonging to the Jewish people in the chronological series, +we meet with embarrassing difficulties, and finally arrive at the +conclusion that its history cannot be accommodated within the compass +of the classification. Into which of the three historical groups +mentioned could the Jewish people be put? Are we to call it one of the +most ancient, one of the ancient, or one of the modern nations? It is +evident that it may lay claim to the first description, as well as to +the second and the last. In company with the most ancient nations of +the Orient, the Jewish people stood at the "threshold of history." It +was the contemporary of the earliest civilized nations, the Egyptians +and the Chaldeans. In those remote days it created and spread a +religious world-idea underlying an exalted social and moral system +surpassing everything produced in this sphere by its Oriental +contemporaries. Again, with the classical Greeks and Romans, it forms +the celebrated historical triad universally recognized as the source +of all great systems of civilization. Finally, in fellowship with the +nations of to-day, it leads an historical life, striding onward in the +path of progress without stay or interruption. Deprived of political +independence, it nevertheless continues to fill a place in the world +of thought as a distinctly marked spiritual individuality, as one of +the most active and intelligent forces. How, then, are we to +denominate this omnipresent people, which, from the first moment of +its historical existence up to our days, a period of thirty-five +hundred years, has been developing continuously. In view of this +Methuselah among the nations, whose life is co-extensive with the +whole of history, how are we to dispose of the inevitable barriers +between "the most ancient" and "the ancient," between "the ancient" +and "the modern" nations--the fateful barriers which form the +milestones on the path of the historical peoples, and which the Jewish +people has more than once overstepped? + +A definition of the Jewish people must needs correspond to the +aggregate of the concepts expressed by the three group-names, most +ancient, ancient, and modern. The only description applicable to it is +"the historical nation of all times," a description bringing into +relief the contrast between it and all other nations of modern and +ancient times, whose historical existence either came to an end in +days long past, or began at a date comparatively recent. And granted +that there are "historical" and "unhistorical" peoples, then it is +beyond dispute that the Jewish people deserves to be called "the most +historical" (_historicissimus_). If the history of the world be +conceived as a circle, then Jewish history occupies the position of +the diameter, the line passing through its centre, and the history of +every other nation is represented by a chord marking off a smaller +segment of the circle. The history of the Jewish people is like an +axis crossing the history of mankind from one of its poles to the +other. As an unbroken thread it runs through the ancient civilization +of Egypt and Mesopotamia, down to the present-day culture of France +and Germany. Its divisions are measured by thousands of years. + +Jewish history, then, in its range, or, better, in its duration, +presents an unique phenomenon. It consists of the longest series of +events ever recorded in the annals of a single people. To sum up its +peculiarity briefly, it embraces a period of thirty-five hundred +years, and in all this vast extent it suffers no interruption. At +every point it is alive, full of sterling content. Presently we shall +see that in respect to content, too, it is distinguished by +exceptional characteristics. + + + + +II + +THE CONTENT OF JEWISH HISTORY + + +From the point of view of content, or qualitative structure, Jewish +history, it is well known, falls into two parts. The dividing point +between the two parts is the moment in which the Jewish state +collapsed irretrievably under the blows of the Roman Empire (70 C. +E.). The first half deals with the vicissitudes of a nation, which, +though frequently at the mercy of stronger nations, still maintained +possession of its territory and government, and was ruled by its own +laws. In the second half, we encounter the history of a people without +a government, more than that, without a land, a people stripped of all +the tangible accompaniments of nationality, and nevertheless +successful in preserving its spiritual unity, its originality, +complete and undiminished. + +At first glance, Jewish history during the period of independence +seems to be but slightly different from the history of other nations. +Though not without individual coloring, there are yet the same wars +and intestine disturbances, the same political revolutions and +dynastic quarrels, the same conflicts between the classes of the +people, the same warring between economical interests. This is only a +surface view of Jewish history. If we pierce to its depths, and +scrutinize the processes that take place in its penetralia, we +perceive that even in the early period there were latent within it +great powers of intellect, universal principles, which, visibly or +invisibly, determined the course of events. We have before us not a +simple political or racial entity, but, to an eminent degree, "a +spiritual people." The national development is based upon an +all-pervasive religious tradition, which lives in the soul of the +people as the Sinaitic Revelation, the Law of Moses. With this holy +tradition, embracing a luminous theory of life and an explicit code of +morality and social converse, was associated the idea of the election +of the Jewish people, of its peculiar spiritual mission. "And ye shall +be unto me a kingdom of priests and a holy nation" is the figurative +expression of this ideal calling. It conveys the thought that the +Israelitish people as a whole, without distinction of rank and +regardless of the social prominence of individuals, has been called to +guide the other nations toward sublime moral and religious principles, +and to officiate for them, the laity as it were, in the capacity of +priests. This exalted ideal would never have been reached, if the +development of the Jewish people had lain along hackneyed lines; if, +like the Egyptians and the Chaldeans, it had had an inflexible caste +of priests, who consider the guardianship of the spiritual treasures +of the nation the exclusive privilege of their estate, and strive to +keep the mass of the people in crass ignorance. For a time, something +approaching this condition prevailed among the Jews. The priests +descended from Aaron, with the Temple servants (the Levites), formed a +priestly class, and played the part of authoritative bearers of the +religious tradition. But early, in the very infancy of the nation, +there arose by the side of this official, aristocratic hierarchy, a +far mightier priesthood, a democratic fraternity, seeking to enlighten +the whole nation, and inculcating convictions that make for a +consciously held aim. The Prophets were the real and appointed +executors of the holy command enjoining the "conversion" of all Jews +into "a kingdom of priests and a holy nation." Their activity cannot +be paralleled in the whole range of the world's history. They were not +priests, but popular educators and popular teachers. They were +animated by the desire to instil into every soul a deeply religious +consciousness, to ennoble every heart by moral aspirations, to +indoctrinate every individual with an unequivocal theory of life, to +inspire every member of the nation with lofty ideals. Their work did +not fail to leave its traces. Slowly but deeply idealism entered into +the very pith and marrow of the national consciousness. This +consciousness gained in strength and amplitude century by century, +showing itself particularly in the latter part of the first period, +after the crisis known as "the Babylonian Exile." Thanks to the +exertions of the _Soferim_ (Scribes), directed toward the +broadest popularization of the Holy Writings, and constituting the +formal complement to the work of the Prophets, spiritual activity +became an integral part of Jewish national life. In the closing +centuries of its political existence, the Jewish people received its +permanent form. There was imposed upon it the unmistakable hallmark of +spirituality that has always identified it in the throng of the +nations. Out of the bosom of Judaism went forth the religion that in a +short time ran its triumphant course through the whole ancient world, +transforming races of barbarians into civilized beings. It was the +fulfilment of the Prophetical promise--that the nations would walk in +the light of Israel. + +At the very moment when the strength and fertility of the Jewish mind +reached the culminating point, occurred a political revolution--the +period of homeless wandering began. It seemed as though, before +scattering the Jewish people to all ends of the earth, the providence +of history desired to teach it a final lesson, to take with it on its +way. It seemed to say: "Now you may go forth. Your character has been +sufficiently tempered; you can bear the bitterest of hardships. You +are equipped with an inexhaustible store of energy, and you can live +for centuries, yea, for thousands of years, under conditions that +would prove the bane of other nations in less than a single century. +State, territory, army, the external attributes of national power, are +for you superfluous luxury. Go out into the world to prove that a +people can continue to live without these attributes, solely and alone +through strength of spirit welding its widely scattered particles into +one firm organism!"--And the Jewish people went forth and proved it. + +This "proof" adduced by Jewry at the cost of eighteen centuries of +privation and suffering, forms the characteristic feature of the +second half of Jewish history, the period of homelessness and +dispersion. Uprooted from its political soil, national life displayed +itself on intellectual fields exclusively. "To think and to suffer" +became the watchword of the Jewish people, not merely because forced +upon it by external circumstances beyond its control, but chiefly +because it was conditioned by the very disposition of the people, by +its national inclinations. The extraordinary mental energy that had +matured the Bible and the old writings in the first period, manifested +itself in the second period in the encyclopedic productions of the +Talmudists, in the religious philosophy of the middle ages, in +Rabbinism, in the Kabbala, in mysticism, and in science. The spiritual +discipline of the school came to mean for the Jew what military +discipline is for other nations. His remarkable longevity is due, I am +tempted to say, to the acrid spiritual brine in which he was cured. In +its second half, the originality of Jewish history consists indeed, in +the circumstance that it is the only history stripped of every active +political element. There are no diplomatic artifices, no wars, no +campaigns, no unwarranted encroachments backed by armed force upon the +rights of other nations, nothing of all that constitutes the chief +content--the monotonous and for the most part idea-less content--of +many other chapters in the history of the world. Jewish history +presents the chronicle of an ample spiritual life, a gallery of +pictures representing national scenes. Before our eyes passes a long +procession of facts from the fields of intellectual effort, of +morality, religion, and social converse. Finally, the thrilling drama +of Jewish martyrdom is unrolled to our astonished gaze. If the inner +life and the social and intellectual development of a people form the +kernel of history, and politics and occasional wars are but its +husk,[3] then certainly the history of the Jewish diaspora is all +kernel. In contrast with the history of other nations it describes, +not the accidental deeds of princes and generals, not external pomp +and physical prowess, but the life and development of a whole people. +It gives heartrending expression to the spiritual strivings of a +nation whose brow is resplendent with the thorny crown of martyrdom. +It breathes heroism of mind that conquers bodily pain. In a word, +Jewish history is history sublimated.[4] + + [3] "History, without these (inner, spiritual elements), is a + shell without a kernel; and such is almost all the history + which is extant in the world." (Macaulay, on Mitford's History + of Greece, Collected Works, i, 198, ed. A. and C. Armstrong + and Son.) + + [4] A Jewish historian makes the pregnant remark: "If ever the + time comes when the prophecies of the Jewish seers are + fulfilled, and nation no longer raises the sword against + nation; when the olive leaf instead of the laurel adorns the + brow of the great, and the achievements of noble minds are + familiar to the dwellers in cottages and palaces alike, then + the history of the world will have the same character as + Jewish history. On its pages will be inscribed, not the + warrior's prowess and his victories, nor diplomatic schemes + and triumphs, but the progress of culture and its practical + application in real life." + +In spite of the noteworthy features that raise Jewish history above +the level of the ordinary, and assign it a peculiar place, it is +nevertheless not isolated, not severed from the history of mankind. +Rather is it most intimately interwoven with world-affairs at every +point throughout its whole extent. As the diameter, Jewish history is +again and again intersected by the chords of the historical circle. +The fortunes of the pilgrim people scattered in all the countries of +the civilized world are organically connected with the fortunes of the +most representative nations and states, and with manifold tendencies +of human thought. The bond uniting them is twofold: in the times when +the powers of darkness and fanaticism held sway, the Jews were +amenable to the "physical" influence exerted by their neighbors in the +form of persecutions, infringements of the liberty of conscience, +inquisitions, violence of every sort; and during the prevalence of +enlightment and humanity, the Jews were acted upon by the intellectual +and cultural stimulus proceeding from the peoples with whom they +entered into close relations. Momentary aberrations and reactionary +incidents are not taken into account here. On its side, Jewry made its +personality felt among the nations by its independent, intellectual +activity, its theory of life, its literature, by the very fact, +indeed, of its ideal staunchness and tenacity, its peculiar historical +physiognomy. From this reciprocal relation issued a great cycle of +historical events and spiritual currents, making the past of the +Jewish people an organic constituent of the past of all that portion +of mankind which has contributed to the treasury of human thought. + +We see, then, that in reference to content Jewish history is unique in +both its halves. In the first "national" period, it is the history of +a people to which the epithet "peculiar" has been conceded, a people +which has developed under the influence of exceptional circumstances, +and finally attained to so high a degree of spiritual perfection and +fertility that the creation of a new religious theory of life, which +eventually gained universal supremacy, neither exhausted its resources +nor ended its activity. Not only did it continue to live upon its vast +store of spiritual energy, but day by day it increased the store. In +the second "lackland" half, it is the instructive history of a +scattered people, organically one, in spite of dispersion, by reason +of its unshaken ideal traditions; a people accepting misery and +hardship with stoic calm, combining the characteristics of the thinker +with those of the sufferer, and eking out existence under conditions +which no other nation has found adequate, or, indeed, can ever find +adequate. The account of the people as teacher of religion--this is +the content of the first half of Jewish history; the account of the +people as thinker, stoic, and sufferer--this is the content of the +second half of Jewish history. + +A summing up of all that has been said in this and the previous +chapter proves true the statement with which we began, that Jewish +history, in respect to its quantitative dimensions as well as its +qualitative structure, is to the last degree distinctive and presents +a phenomenon of undeniable uniqueness. + + + + +III + +THE SIGNIFICANCE OF JEWISH HISTORY + + +We turn now to the question of the significance to be attached to +Jewish history. In view of its peculiar qualities, what has it to +offer to the present generation and to future generations as a subject +of study and research? + +The significance of Jewish history is twofold. It is at once national +and universal. At present the fulcrum of Jewish national being lies in +the historical consciousness. In the days of antiquity, the Jews were +welded into a single united nation by the triple agencies of state, +race, and religion, the complete array of material and spiritual +forces directed to one point. Later, in the period of homelessness and +dispersion, it was chiefly religious consciousness that cemented Jewry +into a whole, and replaced the severed political bond as well as the +dulled racial instinct, which is bound to go on losing in keenness in +proportion to the degree of removal from primitive conditions and +native soil. In our days, when the liberal movements leavening the +whole of mankind, if they have not completely shattered the religious +consciousness, have at least, in an important section of Jewry, +effected a change in its form; when abrupt differences of opinion with +regard to questions of faith and cult are asserting their presence; +and traditional Judaism developed in historical sequence is proving +powerless to hold together the diverse factors of the national +organism,--in these days the keystone of national unity seems to be +the historical consciousness. Composed alike of physical, +intellectual, and moral elements, of habits and views, of emotions and +impressions nursed into being and perfection by the hereditary +instinct active for thousands of years, this historical consciousness +is a remarkably puzzling and complex psychic phenomenon. By our common +memory of a great, stirring past and heroic deeds on the battle-fields +of the spirit, by the exalted historical mission allotted to us, by +our thorn-strewn pilgrim's path, our martyrdom assumed for the sake of +our principles, by such moral ties, we Jews, whether consciously or +unconsciously, are bound fast to one another. As Renan well says: +"Common sorrow unites men more closely than common joy." A long chain +of historical traditions is cast about us all like a strong ring. Our +wonderful, unparalleled past attracts us with magnetic power. In the +course of centuries, as generation followed generation, similarity of +historical fortunes produced a mass of similar impressions which have +crystallized, and have thrown off the deposit that may be called "the +Jewish national soul." This is the soil in which, deep down, lies +imbedded, as an unconscious element, the Jewish national _feeling_, +and as a conscious element, the Jewish national _idea_. + +It follows that the Jewish national idea and the national feeling +connected with it have their origin primarily in the historical +consciousness, in a certain complex of ideas and psychic +predispositions. These ideas and predispositions, the deposit left by +the aggregate of historical impressions, are of necessity the common +property of the whole nation, and they can be developed and quickened +to a considerable degree by a renewal of the impressions through the +study of history. Upon the knowledge of history, then, depends the +strength of the national consciousness.[5] + + [5] A different aspect of the same thought is presented with + logical clearness in another publication by our author. "The + national _idea_, and the national _feeling_," says + Mr. Dubnow, "must be kept strictly apart. Unfortunately the + difference between them is usually obliterated. National + feeling is spontaneous. To a greater or less degree it is + inborn in all the members of the nation as a feeling of + kinship. It has its flood-tide and its ebbtide in + correspondence to external conditions, either forcing the + nation to defend its nationality, or relieving it of the + necessity for self-defense. As this feeling is not merely a + blind impulse, but a complicated psychic phenomenon, it can be + subjected to a psychologic analysis. From the given historical + facts or the ideas that have become the common treasure of a + nation, thinking men, living life consciously, can, in one way + or another, derive the origin, development, and vital force of + its national feeling. The results of such an analysis, + arranged in some sort of system, form the content of the + national idea. The task of the national idea it is to clarify + the national feeling, and give it logical sanction for the + benefit of those who cannot rest satisfied with an unconscious + feeling. + + "In what, to be specific, does the essence of our Jewish national + idea consist? Or, putting the question in another form, what + is the cement that unites us into a single compact organism? + Territory and government, the external ties usually binding a + nation together, we have long ago lost. Their place is filled + by abstract principles, by religion and race. Undeniably these + are factors of first importance, and yet we ask the question, + do they alone and exclusively maintain the national cohesion + of Jewry? No, we reply, for if we admitted this proposition, + we should by consequence have to accept the inference, that + the laxity of religious principle prevailing among + free-thinking Jews, and the obliteration of race peculiarities + in the 'civilized' strata of our people, bring in their train + a corresponding weakening, or, indeed, a complete breaking up, + of our national foundations--which in point of fact is not the + case. On the contrary, it is noticeable that the + latitudinarians, the _libres penseurs_, and the + indifferent on the subject of religion, stand in the forefront + of all our national movements. Seeing that to belong to it is + in most cases heroism, and in many martyrdom, what is it that + attracts these Jews so forcibly to their people? There must be + something common to us all, so comprehensive that in the face + of multifarious views and degrees of culture it acts as a + consolidating force. This 'something,' I am convinced, is the + community of historical fortunes of all the scattered parts of + the Jewish nation. We are welded together by our glorious + past. We are encircled by a mighty chain of similar historical + impressions suffered by our ancestors, century after century + pressing in upon the Jewish soul, and leaving behind a + substantial deposit. In short, the Jewish national idea is + based chiefly upon the historical consciousness." [Note of the + German trl.] + +But over and above its national significance, Jewish history, we +repeat, possesses universal significance. Let us, in the first place, +examine its value for science and philosophy. Inasmuch as it is +pre-eminently a chronicle of ideas and spiritual movements, Jewish +history affords the philosopher or psychologist material for +observation of the most important and useful kind. The study of other, +mostly dull chapters of universal history has led to the fixing of +psychologic or sociologic theses, to the working out of comprehensive +philosophic systems, to the determination of general laws. Surely it +follows without far-fetched proof, that in some respects the chapter +dealing with Jewish history must supply material of the most original +character for such theses and philosophies. If it is true, as the last +chapter set out to demonstrate, that Jewish history is distinguished +by sharply marked and peculiar features, and refuses to accommodate +itself to conventional forms, then its content must have an original +contribution to make to philosophy. It does not admit of a doubt that +the study of Jewish history would yield new propositions appertaining +to the philosophy of history and the psychology of nations, hitherto +overlooked by inquirers occupied with the other divisions of universal +history. Inductive logic lays down a rule for ascertaining the law of +a phenomenon produced by two or more contributory causes. By means of +what might be called a laboratory experiment, the several causes must +be disengaged from one another, and the effect of each observed by +itself. Thus it becomes possible to arrive with mathematical precision +at the share of each cause in the result achieved by several +co-operating causes. This method of difference, as it is called, is +available, however, only for a limited number of phenomena, only for +phenomena in the department of the natural sciences. It is in the +nature of the case that mental and spiritual phenomena, though they +may be observed, cannot be artificially reproduced. Now, in one +respect, Jewish history affords the advantages of an arranged +experiment. The historical life of ordinary nations, such nations as +are endowed with territory and are organized into a state, is a +complete intermingling of the political with the spiritual element. +Totally ignorant as we are of the development either would have +assumed, had it been dissevered from the other, the laws governing +each of the elements singly can be discovered only approximately. +Jewish history, in which the two elements have for many centuries been +completely disentangled from each other, presents a natural +experiment, with the advantage of artificial exclusions, rendering +possible the determination of the laws of spiritual phenomena with far +greater scientific exactitude than the laws of phenomena that result +from several similar causes. + +Besides this high value for the purposes of science, this fruitful +suggestiveness for philosophic thought, Jewish history, as compared +with the history of other nations, enjoys another distinction in its +capacity to exercise an ennobling influence upon the heart. Nothing so +exalts and refines human nature as the contemplation of moral +steadfastness, the history of the trials of a martyr who has fought +and suffered for his convictions. At bottom, the second half of Jewish +history is nothing but this. The effective educational worth of the +Biblical part of Jewish history is disputed by none. It is called +"sacred" history, and he who acquires a knowledge of it is thought to +advance the salvation of his soul. Only a very few, however, recognize +the profound, moral content of the second half of Jewish history, the +history of the diaspora. Yet, by reason of its exceptional qualities +and intensely tragic circumstances, it is beyond all others calculated +to yield edification to a notable degree. The Jewish people is +deserving of attention not only in the time when it displayed its +power and enjoyed its independence, but as well in the period of its +weakness and oppression, during which it was compelled to purchase +spiritual development by constant sacrifice of self. A thinker crowned +with thorns demands no less veneration than a thinker with the laurel +wreath upon his brow. The flame issuing from the funeral pile on which +martyrs die an heroic death for their ideas is, in its way, as +awe-inspiring as the flame from Sinai's height. With equal force, +though by different methods, both touch the heart, and arouse the +moral sentiment. Biblical Israel the celebrated--medieval Judah the +despised--it is one and the same people, judged variously in the +various phases of its historical life. If Israel bestowed upon mankind +a religious theory of life, Judah gave it a thrilling example of +tenacious vitality and power of resistance for the sake of conviction. +This uninterrupted life of the spirit, this untiring aspiration for +the higher and the better in the domain of religious thought, +philosophy, and science, this moral intrepidity in night and storm and +in despite of all the blows of fortune--is it not an imposing, +soul-stirring spectacle? The inexpressible tragedy of the Jewish +historical life is unfailing in its effect upon a susceptible +heart.[6] The wonderful exhibition of spirit triumphant, subduing the +pangs of the flesh, must move every heart, and exercise uplifting +influence upon the non-Jew no less than upon the Jew. + + [6] "If there are ranks in suffering, Israel takes precedence of + all the nations--if the duration of sorrows and the patience + with which they are borne ennoble, the Jews are among the + aristocracy of every land--if a literature is called rich in + the possession of a few classic tragedies, what shall we say + to a National Tragedy lasting for fifteen hundred years, in + which the poets and the actors were also the heroes?" (Zunz, + _Die synagogale Poesie_. Translation by George Eliot in + "Daniel Deronda.") + +For non-Jews a knowledge of Jewish history may, under certain +conditions, come to have another, an humanitarian significance. It is +inconceivable that the Jewish people should be held in execration by +those acquainted with the course of its history, with its tragic and +heroic past.[7] Indeed, so far as Jew-haters by profession are +concerned, it is running a risk to recommend the study of Jewish +history to them, without adding a word of caution. Its effect upon +them might be disastrous. They might find themselves cured of their +modern disease, and in the possession of ideas that would render +worthless their whole stock in trade. Verily, he must have fallen to +the zero-point of anti-Semitic callousness who is not thrilled through +and through by the lofty fortitude, the saint-like humility, the +trustful resignation to the will of God, the stoic firmness, laid bare +by the study of Jewish history. The tribute of respect cannot be +readily withheld from him to whom the words of the poet[8] are +applicable: + + "To die was not his hope; he fain + Would live to think and suffer pain." + + [7] As examples and a proof of the strong humanitarian influence + Jewish history exercises upon Christians, I would point to the + relation established between the Jews and two celebrities of + the nineteenth century, Schleiden and George Eliot. In his old + age, the great scientist and thinker accidentally, in the + course of his study of sources for the history of botany, + became acquainted with medieval Jewish history. It filled him + with ardent enthusiasm for the Jews, for their intellectual + strength, their patience under martyrdom. Dominated by this + feeling, he wrote the two admirable sketches: _Die Bedeutung + der Juden für Erhaltung und Wiederbelebung der Wissenschaften + im Mittelalter_ (1876) and _Die Romantik des Martyriums + bei den Juden im Mittelalter_ (1878). According to his own + confession, the impulse to write them was "the wish to take at + least the first step toward making partial amends for the + unspeakable wrong inflicted by Christians upon Jews." As for + George Eliot, it may not be generally known that it was her + reading of histories of the Jews that inspired her with the + profound veneration for the Jewish people to which she gave + glowing utterance in "Daniel Deronda." (She cites Zunz, was + personally acquainted with Emanuel Deutsch, and carried on a + correspondence with Professor Dr. David Kaufmann. See + _George Eliot's Life as related in her Letters and + Journals_. Arranged and edited by her husband, J. W. Cross, + Vol. iii, ed. Harper and Brothers.) Her enthusiasm prompted + her, in 1879, to indite her passionate apology for the Jews, + under the title, "The Modern Hep! Hep! Hep!" + + [8] Pushkin. + +When, in days to come, the curtain rises upon the touching tragedy of +Jewish history, revealing it to the astonished eye of a modern +generation, then, perhaps, hearts will be attuned to tenderness, and +on the ruins of national hostility will be enthroned mutual love, +growing out of mutual understanding and mutual esteem. And who can +tell--perhaps Jewish history will have a not inconsiderable share in +the spiritual change that is to annihilate national intolerance, the +modern substitute for the religious bigotry of the middle ages. In +this case, the future task of Jewish history will prove as sublime as +was the mission of the Jewish people in the past. The latter consisted +in the spread of the dogma of the unity of creation; the former will +contribute indirectly to the realization of the not yet accepted dogma +of the unity of the human race. + + + + +IV + +THE HISTORICAL SYNTHESIS + + +To define the scope of Jewish history, its content and its +significance, or its place among scientific pursuits, disposes only of +the formal part of the task we have set ourselves. The central problem +is to unfold the meaning of Jewish history, to discover the principle +toward which its diversified phenomena converge, to state the +universal laws and philosophic inferences deducible from the peculiar +course of its events. If we liken history to an organic being, then +the skeleton of facts is its body, and the soul is the spiritual bond +that unites the facts into a whole, that conveys the meaning, the +psychologic essence, of the facts. It becomes our duty, then, to +unbare the soul of Jewish history, or, in scientific parlance, to +construct, on the basis of the facts, the synthesis of the whole of +Jewish national life. To this end, we must pass in review, by periods +and epochs, one after another, the most important groups of historical +events, the most noteworthy currents in life and thought that tell of +the stages in the development of Jewry and of Judaism. Exhaustive +treatment of the philosophical synthesis of a history extending over +three thousand years is possible only in a voluminous work. In an +essay like the present it can merely be sketched in large outline, or +painted in miniature. We cannot expect to do more than state a series +of general principles substantiated by the most fundamental arguments. +Complete demonstration of each of the principles must be sought in the +annals that recount the events of Jewish history in detail. + +The historical synthesis reduces itself, then, to uncovering the +psychologic processes of national development. The object before us to +be studied is the national spirit undergoing continuous evolution +during thousands of years. Our task is to arrive at the laws +underlying this growth. We shall reach our goal by imitating the +procedure of the geologist, who divides the mass of the earth into its +several strata or formations. In Jewish history there may be +distinguished three chief stratifications answering to its first three +periods, the Biblical period, the period of the Second Temple, and the +Talmudic period. The later periods are nothing more than these same +formations combined in various ways, with now and then the addition of +new strata. Of the composite periods there are four, which arrange +themselves either according to hegemonies, the countries in which at +given times lay the centre of gravity of the scattered Jewish people, +or according to the intellectual currents there predominant. + +This, then, is our scheme: + + I. The chief formations: + a) The primary or Biblical period. + b) The secondary or spiritual-political period + (the period of the Second Temple, 538 + B. C. E. to 70 C.E.) + c) The tertiary or national-religious period + (the Talmudic period, 70-500). + + II. The composite formations: + a) The Gaonic period, or the hegemony of + the Oriental Jews (500-980). + b) The Rabbinic-philosophical period, or the + hegemony of the Spanish Jews (980-1492). + c) The Rabbinic-mystical period, or the hegemony + of the German-Polish Jews + (1492-1789). + d) The modern period of enlightenment (the + nineteenth century). + + + + +V + +THE PRIMARY OR BIBLICAL PERIOD + + +In the daybreak of history, the hoary days when seeming and reality +merge into each other, and the outlines of persons and things fade +into the surrounding mist, the picture of a nomad people, moving from +the deserts of Arabia in the direction of Mesopotamia and Western +Asia, detaches itself clear and distinct from the dim background. The +tiny tribe, a branch of the Semitic race, bears a peculiar stamp of +its own. A shepherd people, always living in close touch with nature, +it yet resists the potent influence of the natural phenomena, which, +as a rule, entrap primitive man, and make him the bond-slave of the +visible and material. Tent life has attuned these Semitic nomads to +contemplativeness. In the endless variety of the phenomena of nature, +they seek to discover a single guiding power. They entertain an +obscure presentiment of the existence of an invisible, universal soul +animating the visible, material universe. The intuition is personified +in the Patriarch Abraham, who, according to Biblical tradition, held +communion with God, when, on the open field, "he looked up toward +heaven, and counted the stars," or when, "at the setting of the sun, +he fell into benumbing sleep, and terror seized upon him by reason of +the impenetrable darkness." Here we have a clear expression of the +original, purely cosmical character of the Jewish religion. + +There was no lack of human influence acting from without. Chaldea, +which the peculiar Semitic shepherds crossed in their pilgrimage, +presented them with notions from its rich mythology and cosmogony. The +natives of Syria and Canaan, among whom in the course of time the +Abrahamites settled, imparted to them many of their religious views +and customs. Nevertheless, the kernel of their pure original theory +remained intact. The patriarchal mode of life, admirable in its +simplicity, continued to hold its own within the circle of the +firmly-knitted tribe. It was in Canaan, however, that the shepherd +people hailing from Arabia showed the first signs of approaching +disintegration. Various tribal groups, like Moab and Ammon, +consolidated themselves. They took permanent foothold in the land, and +submitted with more or less readiness to the influences exerted by the +indigenous peoples. The guardianship of the sublime traditions of the +tribe remained with one group alone, the "sons of Jacob" or the "sons +of Israel," so named from the third Patriarch Jacob. To this group of +the Israelites composed of smaller, closely united divisions, a +special mission was allotted; its development was destined to lie +along peculiar lines. The fortunes awaiting it were distinctive, and +for thousands of years have filled thinking and believing mankind with +wondering admiration. + +Great characters are formed under the influence of powerful +impressions, of violent convulsions, and especially under the +influence of suffering. The Israelites early passed through their +school of suffering in Egypt. The removal of the sons of Jacob from +the banks of the Jordan to those of the Nile was of decisive +importance for the progress of their history. When the patriarchal +Israelitish shepherds encountered the old, highly complex culture of +the Egyptians, crystallized into fixed forms even at that early date, +it was like the clash between two opposing electric currents. The pure +conception of God, of _Elohim_, as of the spirit informing and +supporting the universe, collided with the blurred system of heathen +deities and crass idolatry. The simple cult of the shepherds, +consisting of a few severely plain ceremonies, transmitted from +generation to generation, was confronted with the insidious, coarsely +sensual animal worship of the Egyptians. The patriarchal customs of +the Israelites were brought into marked contrast with the vices of a +corrupt civilization. Sound in body and soul, the son of nature +suddenly found himself in unsavory surroundings fashioned by culture, +in which he was as much despised as the inoffensive nomad is by +"civilized" man of settled habit. The scorn had a practical result in +the enslavement of the Israelites by the Pharaohs. Association with +the Egyptians acted as a force at once of attraction and of repulsion. +The manners and customs of the natives could not fail to leave an +impression upon the simple aliens, and invite imitation on their part. +On the other hand, the whole life of the Egyptians, their crude +notions of religion, and their immoral ways, were calculated to +inspire the more enlightened among the Israelites with disgust. The +hostility of the Egyptians toward the "intruders," and the horrible +persecutions in which it expressed itself, could not but bring out +more aggressively the old spiritual opposition between the two races. +The antagonism between them was the first influence to foster the germ +of Israel's national consciousness, the consciousness of his peculiar +character, his individuality. This early intimation of a national +consciousness was weak. It manifested itself only in the chosen few. +But it existed, and the time was appointed when, under more favorable +conditions, it would develop, and display the extent of its power. + +This consciousness it was that inspired the activity of Moses, +Israel's teacher and liberator. He was penetrated alike by national +and religious feeling, and his desire was to impart both national and +religious feeling to his brethren. The fact of national redemption he +connected with the fact of religious revelation. "I am the Lord thy +God who have brought thee forth out of the land of Egypt" was +proclaimed from Sinai. The God-idea was nationalized. Thenceforth +"Eternal" became the name peculiar to the God of Israel. He was, +indeed, the same _Elohim_, the Creator of the world and its +Guide, who had been dimly discerned by the spiritual vision of the +Patriarchs. At the same time He was the special God of the Israelitish +nation, the only nation that avouched Him with a full and undivided +heart, the nation chosen by God Himself to carry out, alone, His +sublime plans.[9] In his wanderings, Israel became acquainted with the +chaotic religious systems of other nations. Seeing to what they paid +the tribute of divine adoration, he could not but be dominated by the +consciousness that he alone from of old had been the exponent of the +religious idea in its purity. The resolution must have ripened within +him to continue for all time to advocate and cherish this idea. From +that moment Israel was possessed of a clear theory of life in religion +and morality, and of a definite aim pursued with conscious intent. + + [9] This is the true recondite meaning of the verses Exod. vi, + 2-3: "And God spake unto Moses, and said unto him, I am the + Eternal: and I appeared unto Abraham, unto Isaac, and unto + Jacob, as _El-Shaddai_ (God Almighty), but by my name + Eternal I was not known unto them." + +Its originators designed that this Israelitish conception of life +should serve not merely theoretically, as the basis of religious +doctrine, but also practically, as the starting point of legislation. +It was to be realized in the daily walks of the people, which at this +very time attained to political independence. Sublime religious +conceptions were not to be made the content of a visionary creed, the +subject of dreamy contemplation, but, in the form of perspicuous +guiding principles, were to control all spheres of individual and +social life. Men must beware of looking upon religion as an ideal to +be yearned for, it should be an ideal to be applied directly, day by +day, to practical contingencies. In "Mosaism," so-called, the +religious and the ethical are intimately interwoven with the social +and the political. The chief dogmas of creed are stated as principles +shaping practical life. For instance, the exalted idea of One God +applied to social life produces the principle of the equality of all +men before the One Supreme Power, a principle on which the whole of +Biblical legislation is built. The commands concerning love of +neighbor, the condemnation of slavery, the obligation to aid the poor, +humane treatment of the stranger, sympathy and compassion with every +living being--all these lofty injunctions ensue as inevitable +consequences from the principle of equality. Biblical legislation is +perhaps the only example of a political and social code based, not +upon abstract reasoning alone, but also upon the requirements of the +feelings, upon the finest impulses of the human soul. By the side of +formal right and legality, it emphasizes, and, in a series of +precepts, makes tangible, the principle of justice and humanity. The +Mosaic law is a "propaganda by deed." Everywhere it demands active, +more than passive, morality. Herein, in this elevated characteristic, +this vital attribute, consists the chief source of the power of +Mosaism. The same characteristic, to be sure, prevented it from at +once gaining ground in the national life. It established itself only +gradually, after many fluctuations and errors. In the course of the +centuries, and keeping pace with the growth of the national +consciousness, it was cultivated and perfected in detail. + +The conquest of Canaan wrought a radical transformation in the life of +the Israelitish people. The acquiring of national territory supplied +firm ground for the development and manifold application of the +principles of Mosaism. At first, however, advance was out of the +question. The mass of the people had not reached the degree of +spiritual maturity requisite for the espousal of principles +constituting an exalted theory of life. It could be understood and +represented only by a thoughtful minority, which consisted chiefly of +Aaronites and Levites, together forming a priestly estate, though not +a hierarchy animated by the isolating spirit of caste that flourished +among all the other peoples of the Orient. The populace discovered +only the ceremonial side of the religion; its kernel was hidden from +their sight. Defective spiritual culture made the people susceptible +to alien influences, to notions more closely akin to its +understanding. Residence in Canaan, among related Semitic tribes that +had long before separated from the Israelites, and adopted altogether +different views and customs, produced a far greater metamorphosis in +the character of the Israelites than the sojourn in Egypt. After the +first flush of victory, when the unity of the Israelitish people had +been weakened by the particularistic efforts of several of the tribes, +the spiritual bonds confining the nation began to relax. Political +decay always brings religious defection in its train. Whenever Israel +came under the dominion of the neighboring tribes, he also fell a +victim to their cult. This phenomenon is throughout characteristic of +the so-called era of the Judges. It is a natural phenomenon readily +explained on psychologic grounds. The Mosaic national conception of +the "Eternal" entered more and more deeply into the national +consciousness, and, accommodating itself to the limited mental +capacity of the majority, became narrower and narrower in compass--the +lot of all great ideas! The "Eternal" was no longer thought of as the +only One God of the whole universe, but as the tutelar deity of the +Israelitish tribe. The idea of national tutelar deities was at that +time deeply rooted in the consciousness of all the peoples of Western +Asia. Each nation, as it had a king of its own, had a tribal god of +its own. The Phoenicians had their Baal, the Moabites their Kemosh, the +Ammonites their Milkom. Belief in the god peculiar to a nation by no +means excluded belief in the existence of other national gods. A +people worshiped its own god, because it regarded him as its master +and protecting lord. In fact, according to the views then prevalent, a +conflict between two nations was the conflict between two national +deities. In the measure in which respect for the god of the defeated +party waned, waxed the number of worshipers of the god of the +victorious nation, and not merely among the conquerors, but also among +the adherents of other religions.[10] These crude, coarsely +materialistic conceptions of God gained entrance with the masses of +the Israelitish people. If Moab had his Kemosh, and Ammon his Milkom, +then Israel had his "Eternal," who, after the model of all other +national gods, protected and abandoned his "clients" at pleasure, in +the one case winning, in the other losing, the devotion of his +partisans. In times of distress, in which the Israelites groaned under +the yoke of the alien, the enslaved "forgot" their "conquered" +"Eternal." As they paid the tribute due the strange king, and yielded +themselves to his power, so they submitted to the strange god, and +paid him his due tribute of devotion. It followed that liberation from +the yoke of the stranger coincided with return to the God of Israel, +the "Eternal." At such times the national spirit leaped into flaming +life. This sums up the achievements of the hero-Judges. But the traces +of repeated backsliding were deep and long visible, for, together with +the religious ideas of the strange peoples, the Israelites accepted +their customs, as a rule corrupt and noxious customs, in sharp +contrast with the lofty principles of the Mosaic Law, designed to +control social life and the life of the individual. + + [10] "Ye have forsaken me," says God unto Israel, "and served + other gods; wherefore I will deliver you no more. Go and cry + unto the gods which ye have chosen: let them deliver you in + the time of your tribulations" (Judges X, 13-14). The same + idea is brought out still more forcibly in the arguments + adduced by Jephthah in his message to the king of Ammon (more + correctly, Moab), who had laid claim to Israelitish lands: + "Thou," says Jephthah, "mayest possess that which Kemosh thy + god giveth thee to possess, but what the Lord our God giveth + us to possess, that will we possess" (Judges xi, 24). Usually + these words are taken ironically; to me they seem to convey + literal truth rather than irony. + +The Prophet Samuel, coming after the unsettled period of the Judges, +had only partial success in purifying the views of the people and +elevating it out of degradation to a higher spiritual level. His work +was continued with more marked results in the brilliant reigns of +Saul, David, and Solomon. An end was put to the baleful disunion among +the tribes, and the bond of national tradition was strengthened. The +consolidated Israelitish kingdom triumphed over its former oppressors. +The gods of the strange peoples cringed in the dust before the +all-powerful "Eternal." But, with the division of the kingdom and the +political rupture between Judah and Israel, the period of +efflorescence soon came to an end. Again confusion reigned supreme, +and customs and convictions deteriorated under foreign influence. +Prophets like Elijah and Elisha, feverish though their activity was, +stood powerless before the rank immorality in the two states. The +northern kingdom of Israel, composed of the Ten Tribes, passed swiftly +downward on the road to destruction, sharing the fate of the +numberless Oriental states whose end was inevitable by reason of inner +decay. The inspired words of the early Israelitish Prophets, Amos, +Hosea, and Micah, their trumpet-toned reproofs, their thrilling +admonitions, died unheeded upon the air--society was too depraved to +understand their import. It was reserved for later generations to give +ear to their immortal utterances, eloquent witnesses to the lofty +heights to which the Jewish spirit was permitted to mount in times of +general decline. The northern kingdom sank into irretrievable ruin. +Then came the turn of Judah. He, too, had disregarded the law of +"sanctification" from Sinai, and had nearly arrived at the point of +stifling his better impulses in the morass of materialistic living. + +At this critical moment, on the line between to be and not to be, a +miracle came to pass. The spirit of the people, become flesh in its +noblest sons, rose aloft. From out of the midst of the political +disturbances, the frightful infamy, and the moral corruption, +resounded the impressive call of the great Prophets of Judah. Like a +flaming torch carried through dense darkness, they cast a glaring +light upon the vices of society, at the same time illuminating the +path that leads upward to the goal of the ethical ideal. At first the +negative, denouncing element predominated in the exhortations of the +Prophets: unsparingly they scourged the demoralization and the +iniquity, the social injustice and the political errors prevalent in +their time; they threatened divine punishment, that is, the natural +consequences of evil-doing, and appealed to the reason rather than the +feelings of the people. But gradually they elaborated positive ideals, +more soul-stirring than the ideals identified with the old religious +tradition. The Prophets were the first to touch the root of the evil. +It is clear that they realized that alien influences and the low grade +of intelligence possessed by the masses were not the sole causes of +the frequent backsliding of the people. The Jewish doctrine itself +bore within it the germ of error. The two chief pillars of the old +faith--the nationalizing of the God-idea, and the stress laid upon the +cult, the ceremonial side of religion, as compared with moral +requirements--were first and foremost to be held responsible for the +flagrant departures from the spirit of Judaism. This was the direction +in which reform was needed. Thereafter the sermons of the Prophets +betray everywhere the intense desire, on the one hand, to restore to +the God-idea its original universal character, and, on the other hand, +while strongly emphasizing the importance of morality in the religious +and the social sphere, to derogate from the value of the ceremonial +system. The "Eternal" is no longer the national God of Israel, +belonging to him exclusively; He becomes the God of the whole of +mankind, the same _Elohim_, Creator and Preserver of the world, +whom the Patriarchs had worshiped, and to whom, being His creatures, +all men owe worship. His precepts and His laws of morality are binding +upon all nations; they will bring salvation and blessing to all +without distinction.[11] The ideal of piety consists in the profession +of God and a life of rectitude. The time will come when all nations +will be penetrated by true knowledge of God and actuated by the +noblest motives; then will follow the universal brotherhood of man. +Until this consummation is reached, and so long as Israel is the only +nation formally professing the one true God, and accepting His blessed +law, Israel's sole task is to embody in himself the highest ideals, to +be an "ensign to the nations," to bear before them the banner of God's +law, destined in time to effect the transformation of the whole of +mankind. Israel is a missionary to the nations. As such he must stand +before them as a model of holiness and purity. Here is the origin of +the great idea of the spiritual "Messianism" of the Jewish people, or, +better, its "missionism," an eternal idea, far more comprehensive than +the old idea of national election, which it supplanted. + + [11] Two Biblical passages, the one from Deuteronomy, the other + from Deutero-Isaiah, afford a signal illustration of the + contrast between the religious nationalism of the Mosaic law + and the universalism of the Prophets. Moses says to Israel: + "Thou art an holy people unto the Lord thy God: the Lord thy + God hath chosen thee to be a special people unto himself, + above all people that are upon the face of the earth. The Lord + did not set his love upon you, nor choose you, because ye were + more in number than any people: for ye were the fewest of all + people. But because the Lord loved you...." (Deut. vii, 6-8). + And these are the words of the prophecy: "Listen, O isles, + unto me, and hearken, ye people, from far! The Lord hath + called me... and said unto me, Thou art my servant, O Israel, + in whom I will be glorified! But I had thought, I have labored + in vain, I have spent my strength for nought, and in vain; yet + surely my judgment is with the Lord, and my work with my God. + For now said the Lord unto me... It is too light a thing that + thou shouldest be my servant to raise up the tribes of Jacob, + and to restore the preserved of Israel: no, I will also give + thee for a light to the Gentiles, that my salvation may reach + unto the end of the earth" (Is. xlix, 1-6). + +These sublime teachings were inculcated at the moment in which Judah +was hastening to meet his fate. It had become impossible to check the +natural results of the earlier transgressions. The inevitable +happened; Babylon the mighty laid her ponderous hand upon tiny Judah. +But Judah could not be crushed. From the heavy chastisement the Jewish +nation emerged purified, re-born for a new life. + + + + +VI + +THE SECONDARY OR SPIRITUAL-POLITICAL PERIOD + + +The rank and file of a people are instructed by revolutions and +catastrophes better than by sermons. More quickly than Isaiah and +Jeremiah, Nebuchadnezzar brought the Jews to a recognition of their +tasks. The short span of the Babylonian Exile (586-538 B. C. E.) was a +period of introspection and searching self-examination for the people. +Spiritual forces hitherto latent came into play; a degree of +self-consciousness asserted itself. The people grasped its mission. At +last it comprehended that to imitate inferior races, instead of +teaching them and making itself a model for them to follow, was +treason to its vocation in life. When the hour of release from the +Babylonian yoke struck, the people suddenly saw under its feet "a new +earth," and to "a new heaven" above it raised eyes dim with tears of +repentance and emotion. It renewed its covenant with God. Like the +Exodus from Egypt, so the second national deliverance was connected +with a revelation. But the messages delivered by the last +Prophets--especially by "the great unknown," the author of the latter +part of the Book of Isaiah--were too exalted, too universal in +conception, for a people but lately emerged from a severe crisis to +set about their realization at once. They could only illumine its path +as a guiding-star, inspire it as the ultimate goal, the far-off +Messianic ideal. Meanwhile the necessity appeared for uniform +religious laws, dogmas, and customs, to bind the Jews together +externally as a nation. The moralizing religion of the Prophets was +calculated to bring about the regeneration of the individual, +regardless of national ties; but at that moment the chief point +involved was the nation. It had to be established and its organization +perfected. The universalism of the Prophets was inadequate for the +consolidating of a nation. To this end outward religious discipline +was requisite, an official cult and public ceremonies. Led by such +considerations, the Jewish captives, on their return to Jerusalem, +first of all devoted themselves to the erection of a Temple, to the +creating of a visible religious centre, which was to be the rallying +point for the whole nation. + +The days of the Prophets were over. Their religious universalism could +apply only to a distant future. In the present, the nation, before it +might pose as a teacher, had to learn and grow spiritually strong. +Aims of such compass require centuries for their realization. +Therefore, the spiritual-national unification of the people was pushed +into the foreground. The place of the Prophet was filled by the Priest +and the Scribe. Zerubbabel, Ezra, and Nehemiah were permeated by the +purpose to make religion and the cult subservient to the cause of +national union and isolation. The erection of the Temple, the solemn +service with the singing of Psalms and the public reading from the +"Book of the Law" (the Pentateuch, which underwent its final redaction +at that time), the removal of whatever might arouse the remembrance of +strange and heathen institutions--these were the levers of their +unifying activity. At first sight this activity might appear almost +too one-sided. But if we summon to mind a picture of the conditions +prevailing in those days, we are forced to the conclusion that, in the +interest of national restoration, a consistent course was imperative. +In point of fact, however, some of Ezra's innovations testify to the +broad-minded, reformatory character of this activity; as, for +instance, the public reading of the Pentateuch, introduced with a view +to making the people see the necessity of obtaining detailed knowledge +of the principles of its religion, and obeying the precepts of the +Law, not blindly, but with conscious assent. The object steadily aimed +at was the elevation of the whole body of the people to the plane of +spirituality, its transformation, in accordance with the Biblical +injunction, into a "kingdom of priests." + +This injunction of civilizing import became the starting point of the +activity of all of Ezra's successors, of the so-called school of the +_Soferim_, the Scribes, those versed in the art of writing. The +political calm that prevailed during the two centuries of the Persian +supremacy (538-332 B. C. E.), was calculated to an eminent degree to +promote spiritual development and the organization of the inner life +of the people. During this period, a large part of the writings after +the Pentateuch that have been received into the Bible were collected, +compiled, and reduced to writing. The immortal thoughts of the +Prophets clothed themselves in the visible garb of letters. On +parchment rolls and in books they were made accessible to distant +ages. The impressive traditions transmitted from earliest times, the +chronicles of the past of the people, the Psalms brought forth by the +religious enthusiasm of a long series of poets, all were gathered and +put into literary shape with the extreme of care. The spiritual +treasures of the nation were capitalized, and to this process of +capitalization solely and alone generations of men have owed the +possibility of resorting to them as a source of faith and knowledge. +Without the work of compilation achieved by the _Soferim_, of +which the uninstructed are apt to speak slightingly, mankind to-day +had no Bible, that central sun in world-literature. + +These two centuries may fitly be called the school-days of the Jewish +nation; the Scribes were the teachers of Jewry. In the way of original +work but little was produced. The people fed upon the store of +spiritual food, of which sufficient had been laid up for several +generations. It was then that the Jews first earned their title to the +name, "the People of the Book." They made subservient to themselves +the two mightiest instruments of thought, the art of writing and of +reading. Their progress was brilliant, and when their schooling had +come to an end, and they stepped out into the broader life, they were +at once able to apply their knowledge successfully to practical +contingencies. They were prepared for all the vicissitudes of life. +Their spiritual equipment was complete. + +Nothing could have been more opportune than this readiness to assume +the responsibilities of existence, for a time of peril and menace was +again approaching. From out of the West, a new agent of civilization, +Hellenism, advanced upon the East. Alexander the Great had put an end +to the huge Persian monarchy, and brought the whole of Western Asia +under his dominion (332 B. C. E.). His generals divided the conquered +lands among themselves. With all their might, the Ptolemies in Egypt +and the Seleucidae in Syria hellenized the countries subject to their +rule. In the old domain of the Pharaohs, as in Babylonia, in Phoenicia, +and in Syria, the Greek language was currently spoken, Greek +ceremonies were observed, the Greek mode of life was adopted. Athens +ceded her rights of primogeniture to New Athens, Alexandria, capital +of Egypt, and cosmopolitan centre of the civilized world. For a whole +century Judea played the sad part of the apple of discord between the +Egyptian and the Syrian dynasty (320-203 B. C. E.). By turns she owned +the sway of the Ptolemies and the Seleucidae, until finally, in 203, +she was declared a Syro-Macedonian province. Here, as in the other +parts of their realm, the rulers devoted themselves energetically to +the dissemination of Greek culture. Meeting with resistance, they had +resort to main force. At first, indeed, a large part of the people +permitted itself to be blinded by the "beauty of Japheth," and +promoted assimilation with the Greeks. But when the spread of +Hellenism began to threaten the spiritual individuality of Judaism, +the rest of the nation, endowed with greater capacity of resistance, +arose and sturdily repulsed the enemy. + +Hellenism was the first gravely dangerous opponent Judaism had to +encounter. It was not the ordinary meeting of two peoples, or of two +kinds of civilization. It was a clash between two theories of life +that stood abruptly opposed to each other, were, indeed, mutually +exclusive. It was a duel between "the Eternal" on the one side, and +Zeus on the other--between the Creator of the universe, the invisible +spiritual Being who had, in a miraculous way, revealed religious and +ethical ideals to mankind, and the deity who resided upon Olympus, who +personified the highest force of nature, consumed vast quantities of +nectar and ambrosia, and led a pretty wild life upon Olympus and +elsewhere. In the sphere of religion and morality, Hellene and Judean +could not come close to each other. The former deified nature herself, +the material universe; the latter deified the Creator of nature, the +spirit informing the material universe. The Hellene paid homage first +and foremost to external beauty and physical strength; the Judean to +inner beauty and spiritual heroism. The Hellenic theory identified the +moral with the beautiful and the agreeable, and made life consist of +an uninterrupted series of physical and mental pleasures. The Judean +theory is permeated by the strictly ethical notions of duty, of +purity, of "holiness"; it denounces licentiousness, and sets up as its +ideal the controlling of the passions and the infinite improvement of +the soul, not of the intellect alone, but of the feelings as well. +These differences between the two theories of life showed themselves +in the brusque opposition in character and customs that made the +Greeks and the Jews absolute antipodes in many spheres of life. It +cannot be denied that in matters of the intellect, especially in the +field of philosophy and science, not to mention art, it might have +been greatly to the advantage of the Jews to become disciples of the +Greeks. Nor is there any doubt that the brighter aspects of Hellenism +would make an admirable complement to Judaism. An harmonious blending +of the Prophets with Socrates and Plato would have produced a +many-sided, ideal _Weltanschauung_. The course of historical events +from the first made such blending, which would doubtless have +required great sacrifices on both sides, an impossible consummation. +In point of fact, the events were such as to widen the abyss between +the two systems. The meeting of Judaism and Hellenism unfortunately +occurred at the very moment when the classical Hellenes had been +supplanted by the hellenized Macedonians and Syrians, who had accepted +what were probably the worst elements of the antique system, while +appropriating but few of the intellectual excellencies of Greek +culture. There was another thwarting circumstance. In this epoch, the +Greeks were the political oppressors of the Jews, outraging Jewish +national feeling through their tyranny to the same degree as by their +immoral life they shocked Jewish ethical feeling and Jewish chastity. + +Outraged national and religious feeling found expression in the +insurrection of the Maccabees (168 B. C. E.). The hoary priest +Mattathias and his sons fought for the dearest and noblest treasures +of Judaism. Enthusiasm begets heroism. The Syrian-Greek yoke was +thrown off, and, after groaning under alien rule, the Persian, the +Egyptian, and the Syro-Macedonian, for four hundred years, Judea +became an independent state. In its foreign relations, the new state +was secured by the self-sacrificing courage of the first Maccabean +brothers, and from within it was supported by the deep-sunk pillars of +the spiritual life. The rise of the three famous parties, the +Sadducees, the Pharisees, and the Essenes, by no means testifies, as +many would have us believe, to national disintegration, but rather to +the intense spiritual activity of the people. The three tendencies +afforded opportunity for the self-consciousness of the nation to +express itself in all its variety and force. The unbending religious +dogmatism of the Sadducees, the comprehensive practical sense of the +Pharisees in religious and Rational concerns, the contemplative +mysticism of the Essenes, they are the most important offshoots from +the Jewish system as held at that time. In consequence of the external +conditions that brought about the destruction of the Maccabean +state[12] after a century's existence (165-63 B. C. E.), the Pharisee +tendency, which had proved itself the best in practice, won the upper +hand. When Judea was held fast in the clutches of the Roman eagle, all +hope of escape being cut off, the far-seeing leaders of the people +gained the firm conviction that the only trustworthy support of the +Jewish nation lay in its religion. They realized that the preservation +of national unity could be effected only by a consistent organization +of the religious law, which was to envelop and shape the whole +external life of the people. This explains the feverish activity of +the early creators of the Mishna, of Hillel, Shammai, and others, and +it interprets also the watchword of still older fame, "Make a fence +about the Law." If up to that moment religious usage in its +development had kept abreast of the requirements of social and +individual life, the requirements out of which it had grown forth, it +now became a national function, and its further evolution advanced +with tremendous strides. For the protection of the old "Mosaic Laws," +a twofold and a threefold fence of new legal ordinances was erected +about them, and the cult became more and more complicated. But the +externals of religion did not monopolize all the forces. The moral +element in the nation was promoted with equal vigor. Hillel, the head +of the Pharisee party, was not a legislator alone, he was also a model +of humane principles and rare moral attainments. + + [12] The external causes of the downfall of the Maccabean state, + dynastic quarrels, are well known. Much less light has been + thrown upon the inner, deeper-lying causes of the catastrophe. + These are possibly to be sought in the priestly-political + dualism of the Judean form of government. The ideal of a + nation educated by means of the Bible was a theocratic state, + and the first princes of the Maccabean house, acting at once + as regents and as high priests, in a measure reached this + ideal. But the attempts of other nations had demonstrated + conclusively enough that a dualistic form of government cannot + maintain itself permanently. Sooner or later one of the two + elements, the priestly or the secular, is bound to prevail + over the other and crush it. In the Judean realm, with its + profoundly religious trend, the priestly element obtained the + ascendency, and political ruin ensued. The priestly-political + retreated before the priestly-national form of government. + Though the religious element was powerless to preserve the + _state_ from destruction, we shall see that it has + brilliantly vindicated its ability to keep the _nation_ + intact. + +While Judaism, in its native country was striving to isolate itself, +and was seizing upon all sorts of expedients to insure this end, it +readily entered into relations, outside of Judea, with other systems +of thought, and accepted elements of the classical culture. Instead of +the violent opposition which the Palestinian Judaism of the +pre-Maccabean period, that is, the period of strife, had offered to +Hellenism, the tendency to make mutual concessions, and pave the way +for an understanding between the two theories of life, asserted itself +in Alexandria. In the capital city of the hellenized world the Jews +constituted one of the most important elements of culture. According +to Mommsen, the Jewish colony in Alexandria was not inferior, in point +of numbers, to the Jewish population of Jerusalem, the metropolis. +Influenced by Greek civilization, the Jews in turn exercised decisive +influence upon their heathen surroundings, and introduced a new +principle of development into the activity of the cultivated classes. +The Greek translation of the Biblical writings formed the connecting +link between Judaism and Hellenism. The "Septuaginta," the translation +of the Pentateuch, in use since the third century before the Christian +era, had acquainted the classical world with Jewish views and +principles. The productions of the Prophets and, in later centuries, +of the other Biblical authors, translated and spread broadcast, acted +irresistibly upon the spirit of the cultivated heathen, and granted +him a glimpse into a world of hitherto unknown notions. On this soil +sprang up the voluminous Judeo-Hellenic literature, of which but a +few, though characteristic, specimens have descended to us. The +intermingling of Greek philosophy with Jewish religious conceptions +resulted in a new religio-philosophic doctrine, with a mystic tinge, +of which Philo is the chief exponent. In Jerusalem, Judaism appeared +as a system of practical ceremonies and moral principles; in +Alexandria, it presented itself as a complex of abstract symbols and +poetical allegories. The Alexandrian form of Judaism might satisfy the +intellect, but it could not appeal to the feelings. It may have made +Judaism accessible to the cultivated minority, to the upper ten +thousand with philosophic training; for the masses of the heathen +people Judaism continued unintelligible. Yet it was pre-eminently the +masses that were strongly possessed by religious craving. Disappointed +in their old beliefs, they panted after a new belief, after spiritual +enlightenment. In the decaying classical world, which had so long +filled out life with materialistic and intellectual interests, the +moral and religious feelings, the desire for a living faith, for an +active inspiration, had awakened, and was growing with irresistible +force. + +Then, from deep out of the bosom of Judaism, there sprang a moral, +religious doctrine destined to allay the burning thirst for religion, +and bring about a reorganization of the heathen world. The originators +of Christianity stood wholly upon the ground of Judaism. In their +teachings were reflected as well the lofty moral principles of the +Pharisee leader as the contemplative aims of the Essenes. But the same +external circumstances that had put Judaism under the necessity of +choosing a sharply-defined practical, national policy, made it +impossible for Judaism to fraternize with the preachers of the new +doctrine. Judaism, in fact, was compelled to put aside entirely the +thought of universal missionary activity. Instead, it had to devote +its powers to the more pressing task of guarding the spiritual unity +of a nation whose political bonds were visibly dropping away. + +For just then the Jewish nation, gory with its own blood, was +struggling in the talons of the Roman eagle. Its sons fought +heroically, without thought of self. When, finally, physical strength +gave out, their spiritual energy rose to an intenser degree. The state +was annihilated, the nation remained alive. At the very moment when +the Temple was enwrapped in flames, and the Roman legions flooded +Jerusalem, the spiritual leaders of Jewry sat musing, busily casting +about for a means whereby, without a state, without a capital, without +a Temple, Jewish unity might be maintained. And they solved the +difficult problem. + + + + +VII + +THE TERTIARY TALMUDIC OR NATIONAL-RELIGIOUS PERIOD + + +The solution of the problem consisted chiefly in more strictly +following out the process of isolation. In a time in which the worship +of God preached by Judaism was rapidly spreading to all parts of the +classical world, and the fundamental principles of the Jewish religion +were steadily gaining appreciation and active adherence, this intense +desire for seclusion may at first glance seem curious. But the +phenomenon is perfectly simple. A foremost factor was national +feeling, enhanced to a tremendous degree at the time of the +destruction of Jerusalem. Lacking a political basis, it was +transferred to religious soil. Every tradition, every custom, however +insignificant, was cherished as a jewel. Though without a state and +without territory, the Jews desired to form a nation, if only a +spiritual nation, complete in itself. They considered themselves then +as before the sole guardians of the law of God. They did not believe +in a speedy fulfilment of the prophetical promise concerning "the end +of time" when all nations would be converted to God. A scrupulous +keeper of the Law, Judaism would not hear of the compromises that +heathendom, lately entered into the bosom of the faith, claimed as its +due consideration. It refused to sacrifice a single feature of its +simple dogmatism, of its essential ceremonies, such as circumcision +and Sabbath rest. Moreover, in the period following close upon the +fall of the Temple, a part of the people still nursed the hope of +political restoration, a hope repudiating in its totality the +proclamation of quite another Messianic doctrine. The delusion ended +tragically in Bar Kochba's hapless rebellion (135 C. E.), whose +disastrous issue cut off the last remnant of hope for the restoration +of an "earthly kingdom." Thereafter the ideal of a spiritual state was +replaced by the ideal of a spiritual nation, rallying about a peculiar +religious banner. Jewry grew more and more absorbed in itself. Its +seclusion from the rest of the world became progressively more +complete. Instinct dictated this course as an escape from the danger +of extinction, or, at least, of stagnation. It was conscious of +possessing enough vitality and energy to live for itself and work out +its own salvation. It had its spiritual interests, its peculiar +ideals, and a firm belief in the future. It constituted an ancient +order, whose patent of nobility had been conferred upon it in the days +of the hoary past by the Lord God Himself. Such as it was, it could +not consent to ally itself with _parvenus_, ennobled but to-day, +and yesterday still bowing down before "gods of silver and gods of +gold." This white-haired old man, with a stormy past full of +experiences and thought, would not mingle with the scatter-brained +crowd, would not descend to the level of neophytes dominated by +fleeting, youthful enthusiasm. Loyally this weather-bronzed, +inflexible guardian of the Law stuck to his post--the post entrusted +to him by God Himself--and, faithful to his duty, held fast to the +principle _j'y suis, j'y reste_. + +As a political nation threatened by its neighbors seeks support in its +army, and provides sufficient implements of war, so a spiritual nation +must have spiritual weapons of defense at its command. Such weapons +were forged in great numbers, and deposited in the vast arsenal called +the Talmud. The Talmud represents a complicated spiritual discipline, +enjoining unconditional obedience to a higher invisible power. Where +discipline is concerned, questions as to the necessity for one or +another regulation are out of place. Every regulation is necessary, if +only because it contributes to the desired end, namely, discipline. +Let no one ask, then, to what purpose the innumerable religious and +ritual regulations, sometimes reaching the extreme of pettiness, to +what purpose the comprehensive code in which every step in the life of +the faithful is foreseen. The Talmudic religious provisions, all taken +together, aim to put the regimen of the nation on a strictly uniform +basis, so that everywhere the Jew may be able to distinguish a brother +in faith by his peculiar mode of life. It is a uniform with insignia, +by which soldiers of the same regiment recognize one another. Despite +the vast extent of the Jewish diaspora, the Jews formed a +well-articulated spiritual army, an invisible "state of God" +(_civitas dei_). Hence these "knights of the spirit," the +citizens of this invisible state, had to wear a distinct uniform, and +be governed by a suitable code of army regulations. + +As a protection for Jewish national unity, which was exposed to the +greatest danger after the downfall of the state, there arose and +developed, without any external influence whatsoever, an extraordinary +dictatorship, unofficial and spiritual. The legislative activity of +all the dictators--such as, Rabbi Jochanan ben Zakkai, Rabbi Akiba, +the Hillelites, and the Shammaites--was formulated in the Mishna, the +"oral law," which was the substructure of the Talmud. Their activity +had a characteristic feature, which deserves somewhat particularized +description. The laws were not laid down arbitrarily and without +ceremony. In order to possess binding force, they required the +authoritative confirmation to be found in the Mosaic Books. From +these, whether by logical or by forced interpretation of the holy +text, its words, or, perchance, its letters, they had to be derived. +Each law, barring only the original "traditions," the _Halacha +le-Moshe mi-Sinai_, was promulgated over the supreme signature, as +it were, that is, with the authentication of a word from the Holy +Scriptures. Or it was inferred from another law so authenticated. The +elaboration of every law was thus connected with a very complicated +process of thought, requiring both inductive and deductive reasoning, +and uniting juridical interpretation with the refinements of +casuistry. This legislation was the beginning of Talmudic science, +which from that time on, for many centuries, growing with the ages, +claimed in chief part the intellectual activity of Jewry. The schools +and the academies worked out a system of laws at once religious and +practical in character, which constituted, in turn, the object of +further theoretic study in the same schools and academies. In the +course of time, however, the means became the end. Theoretic +investigation of the law, extending and developing to the furthest +limits, in itself, without reference to its practical value, afforded +satisfaction to the spiritual need. The results of theorizing often +attained the binding force of law in practical life, not because +circumstances ordered it, but simply because one or another academy, +by dint of logic or casuistry, had established it as law. The number +of such deductions from original and secondary laws increased in +geometric progression, and practical life all but failed to keep up +with the theory. The "close of the Mishna," that is, its reduction to +writing, had no daunting effect upon the zeal for research. If +anything, a new and strong impetus was imparted to it. As up to that +time the text of the Holy Scriptures had been made the basis of +interpretation, giving rise to the most diverse inferences, so the +rabbis now began to use the law book recently canonized as a new basis +of interpretation, and to carry its principles to their utmost +consequences. In this way originated first the "Palestinian Gemara." +Later, when the Patriarchate in Palestine was stripped of its glory by +persecutions, and, in consequence, the centre of activity had to be +transferred from the Talmud academies of Palestine to those of +Babylonia, supreme place and exclusive dominion were obtained by the +"Babylonian Gemara," put into permanent form about the year 500 C. E., +a gigantic work, the result of two hundred years of mental labor. + +This busy intellectual activity was as comprehensive as it was +thoroughgoing. Talmudic legislation, the Halacha, by no means confines +itself to religious practices, extensive as this field is. It embraces +the whole range of civil and social life. Apart from the dietary laws, +the regulations for the festivals and the divine service, and a mass +of enactments for the shaping of daily life, the Talmud elaborated a +comprehensive and fairly well-ordered system of civil and criminal +law, which not infrequently bears favorable comparison with the famous +_rationi scriptae_ of the Romans. While proceeding with extreme +rigor and scrupulousness in ritual matters, the Talmud is governed in +its social legislation by the noblest humanitarian principles. +Doubtless this difference of attitude can be explained by the fact +that religious norms are of very much greater importance for a nation +than judicial regulations, which concern themselves only with the +interests of the individual, and exercise but little influence upon +the development of the national spirit. + +The most sympathetic aspects of the Jewish spirit in that epoch are +revealed in the moral and poetic elements of the Talmud, in the Agada. +They are the receptacles into which the people poured all its +sentiments, its whole soul. They are a clear reflex of its inner +world, its feelings, hopes, ideals. The collective work of the nation +and the trend of history have left much plainer traces in the Agada +than in the dry, methodical Halacha. In the Agada the learned jurist +and formalist appears transformed into a sage or poet, conversing with +the people in a warm, cordial tone, about the phenomena of nature, +history, and life. The reader is often thrown into amazement by the +depth of thought and the loftiness of feeling manifested in the Agada. +Involuntarily one pays the tribute of reverence to its practical +wisdom, to its touching legends pervaded by the magic breath of poesy, +to the patriarchal purity of its views. But these pearls are not +strung upon one string, they are not arranged in a complete system. +They are imbedded here and there, in gay variety, in a vast mass of +heterogeneous opinions and sentiments naive at times and at times +eccentric. The reader becomes aware of the thoughts before they are +consolidated. They are still in a fluid, mobile state, still in +process of making. The same vivacious, versatile spirit is revealed in +the Midrashim literature, directly continuing the Agada up to the end +of the middle ages. These two species of Jewish literature, the Agada +and the Midrashim, have a far greater absolute value than the Halacha. +The latter is an official work, the former a national product. Like +every other special legislation, the Halacha is bound to definite +conditions and times, while the Agada concerns itself with the eternal +verities. The creations of the philosophers, poets, and moralists are +more permanent than the work of legislators. + +Beautiful as the Agada is, and with all its profundity, it lacks +breadth. It rests wholly on the national, not on a universal basis. It +would be vain to seek in it for the comprehensive universalism of the +Prophets. Every lofty ideal is claimed as exclusively Jewish. So far +from bridging over the chasm between Israel and the other nations, +knowledge and morality served to widen it. It could not be otherwise, +there was no influx of air from without. The national horizon grew +more and more contracted. The activities of the people gathered +intensity, but in the same measure they lost in breadth. It was the +only result to be expected from the course of history in those ages. +Let us try to conceive what the first five centuries of the Christian +era, the centuries during which the Talmud was built up, meant in the +life of mankind. Barbarism, darkness, and elemental outbreaks of man's +migratory instincts, illustrated by the "great migration of races," +are characteristic features of those centuries. It was a wretched +transition period between the fall of the world of antique culture and +the first germinating of a new Christian civilization. The Orient, the +centre and hearth of Judaism, was shrouded in impenetrable darkness. +In Palestine and in Babylonia, their two chief seats, the Jews were +surrounded by nations that still occupied the lowest rung of the +ladder of civilization, that had not yet risen above naive mysticism +in religion, or continued to be immersed in superstitions of the +grossest sort. + +In this abysmal night of the middle ages, the lamp of thought was fed +and guarded solely and alone by the Jews. It is not astonishing, then, +that oblivious of the other nations they should have dispensed light +only for themselves. Furthermore, the circumstance must be considered +that, in the period under discussion, the impulse to separate from +Judaism gained ground in the Christian world. After the Council of +Nicaea, after Constantine the Great had established Christianity as +the state-church, the official breach between the Old Testament and +the New Testament partisans became unavoidable. + +Thus the Jews, robbed of their political home, created a spiritual +home for themselves. Through the instrumentality of the numberless +religious rules which the Talmud had laid down, and which shaped the +life of the individual as well as that of the community, they were +welded into a firmly united whole. The Jewish spirit--national feeling +and individual mental effort alike--was absorbed in this pursuit of +unification. Head, heart, hands, all human functions of the Jew, were +brought under complete control and cast into fixed forms, by these +five centuries of labor. With painful exactitude, the Talmud +prescribed ordinances for all the vicissitudes of life, yet, at the +same time, offered sufficient food for brain and heart. It was at once +a religion and a science. The Jew was equipped with all the +necessaries. He could satisfy his wants from his own store. There was +no need for him to knock at strange doors, even though he had thereby +profited. The consequences of this attitude, positive as well as +negative consequences, asserted themselves in the further course of +Jewish history. + + + + +VIII + +THE GAONIC PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE ORIENTAL JEWS (500-980) + + +With the close of the Talmud, at the beginning of the sixth century, +the feverish intellectual activity abated. The Jewish centre of +gravity continued in Babylonia. In this country, in which the Jewish +race had heard its cradle song at the dawn of existence, and later on +_Judaea capta_ had sat and wept remembering Zion, Judaism, after +the destruction of the second Temple and hundreds of years of trials, +was favored with a secure asylum. In the rest of the diaspora, +persecution gave the Jews no respite, but in Babylonia, under Persian +rule, they lived for some centuries comparatively free from +molestation. Indeed, they enjoyed a measure of autonomy in internal +affairs, under a chief who was entitled Exilarch (_Resh-Galutha_). +The Law and the word of God went forth from Babylonia for the Jews of +all lands. The Babylonian Talmud became the anthoritative code for the +Jewish people, a holy book second only to the Bible. The intellectual +calm that supervened at the beginning of the sixth century and lasted +until the end of the eighth century, betrayed itself in the slackening of +independent creation, though not in the flagging of intellectual activity +in general. In the schools and academies of Pumbeditha, Nahardea, +and Sura, scientific work was carried on with the same zest as before, +only this work had for its primary object the sifting and exposition of +the material heaped up by the preceding generations. This was the +province of the Sabureans and the Geonim, whose relation to the Talmud +was the same as that of the Scribes (the _Soferim_) of the Second +Temple to the Bible (see above, ch. vi). In the later period, as in the +earlier, the aim was the capitalization of the accumulated spiritual +treasures, an undertaking that gives little occasion for movement and +life, but all the more for endurance and industry. + +This intellectual balance was destroyed by two events: the appearance +of Islam and the rise of Karaism. Islam, the second legitimate +offspring of Judaism, was appointed to give to religious thought in +the slumbering Orient the slight impulse it needed to start it on its +rapid career of sovereign power. Barely emancipated from swaddling +clothes, young Hotspur at once began to rage. He sought an outlet for +his unconquerable thirst for action, his lust for world-dominion. The +victorious religious wars of the followers of Allah ensued. This +foreign movement was not without significance for the fate of the +Jews. They were surrounded no longer by heathens but by Mohammedans, +who believed in the God of the Bible, and through the mouth of their +prophet conferred upon the Jews the honorable appellation of "the +People of the Book." In the eighth century the wars ceased, and the +impetuous energy of the rejuvenated Orient was diverted into quieter +channels. The Bagdad Khalifate arose, the peaceful era of the growth +of industry, the sciences, and the arts was inaugurated. Endowed with +quick discernment for every enlightening movement, the Jews yielded to +the vivifying magic of young Arabic culture. + +Partly under the influence of the Arabic tendency to split into +religio-philosophic sects, partly from inner causes, Karaism sprang up +in the second half of the eighth century. Its active career began with +a vehement protest against the Talmud as the regulator of life and +thought. It proclaimed the creators of this vast encyclopedia to be +usurpers of spiritual power, and urged a return to the Biblical laws +in their unadulterated simplicity. The weakness of its positive +principles hindered the spread of Karaism, keeping it forever within +the narrow limits of a sect and consigning it to stagnation. What gave +it vogue during the first century of its existence was its negative +strength, its violent opposition to the Talmud, which aroused +strenuous intellectual activity. For a long time it turned Judaism +away from its one-sided Talmudic tendency, and opened up new avenues +of work for it. True to their motto: "Search diligently in the Holy +Scriptures," the adherents of Karaism applied themselves to the +rational study of the Bible, which had come to be, among the +Talmudists, the object of casuistic interpretation and legendary +adornment. By the cultivation of grammar and lexicography as applied +to the Biblical thesaurus of words, they resuscitated the Hebrew +language, which, ousted by the Aramaic dialect, had already sunk into +oblivion. By the same means they laid the foundation of a school of +rejuvenated poetry. In general, thought on religious and philosophic +subjects was promoted to a higher degree by the lively discussions +between them and the Talmudists. + +By imperceptible steps Talmudic Judaism, influenced at once by the +enlightened Arabs and the protesting Karaites, departed from the "four +ells of the Halacha," and widened its horizon. Among the spiritual +leaders of the people arose men who occupied themselves not only with +the study of the Talmud but also with a rational exegesis of the +Bible, with philology, poetry, philosophy. The great Gaon Saadiah +(892-942) united within himself all strands of thought. Over and above +a large number of philological and other writings of scientific +purport, he created a momentous religio-philosophic system, with the +aim to clarify Judaism and refine religious conceptions. He was an +encyclopedic thinker, a representative of the highest Jewish culture +and of Arabic culture as well--he wrote his works in Arabic by +preference. In this way Jewish thought gained ground more and more in +the Orient. It was in the West, however, that it attained soon after +to the climax of its development. + +Gradually the centre of gravity of Jewry shifted from Asia Minor to +Western Europe. Beginning with the sixth century, the sparsely sown +Jewish population of Occidental Europe increased rapidly in numbers. +In Italy, Byzantium, France, and Visigothic Spain, important Jewish +communities were formed. The medieval intolerance of the Church, +though neither so widespread nor so violent as it later became, +suffered its first outbreak in that early century. The persecutions of +the Jews by the Visigothic kings of Spain and the Bishops Avitus of +Clermont and Agobard in France (sixth to the ninth century) were the +prelude to the more systematic and the more bloody cruelties of +subsequent days. The insignificant numbers of the European Jews and +the insecurity of their condition stood in the way of forming an +intellectual centre of their own. They were compelled to acknowledge +the spiritual supremacy of their Oriental brethren in faith. With the +beginning of the tenth century the situation underwent a change. +Arabic civilization, which had penetrated to Spain in previous +centuries, brought about a radical transformation in the character of +the country. The realm of the fanatic Visigoths, half barbarous and +wholly averse to the light of progress, changed into the prosperous +and civilized Khalifate of the Ommeyyades. Thither the best forces of +Oriental Jewry transferred themselves. With the growth of the Jewish +population in Arabic Spain and the strengthening of its communal +organization, the spiritual centre of the Jewish people gradually +established itself in Spain. The academies of Sura and Pumbeditha +yielded first place to the high schools of Cordova and Toledo. + +The Jewry of the East resigned the national hegemony to the Jewry of +the West. The Geonim withdrew in favor of the Rabbis. After centuries +of seclusion, the Jewish spirit once more asserted itself, and enjoyed +a period of efflorescence. The process of national growth became more +complex, more varied. + + + + +IX + +THE RABBINIC-PHILOSOPHICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE SPANISH JEWS +(980-1492) + + +The five centuries marked at their beginning by the rise of +Arabic-Jewish civilization in Spain and at their end by the banishment +of the Jews from Spain (980-1492), offer the Jewish historian an +abundance of culture manifestations and intellectual movements so +luxuriant that it is well-nigh impossible to gather them up in one +formula. The monotony formerly prevailing in Jewish national life, +both in its external and in its internal relations, was succeeded by +almost gaily checkered variety. Swept along by the movement towards +enlightenment that dominated their surroundings, the Jews of Arabic +Spain threw themselves into energetic work in all the spheres of life +and thought. While they had political ground more or less firm under +their feet, and for the most part enjoyed peace and liberty, the Jews +in the Christian lands of Europe stood upon volcanic soil, every +moment threatening to swallow them up. Exposed constantly to +persecutions, they lived more or less isolated, and devoted themselves +to one-sided though intense intellectual activity. Sombre shadows and +streaks of bright light alternate with each other in this period. In +its second half, the clouds massed themselves heavily upon the +darkening horizon. Even the "privileged" Spanish Jews suffered an +untoward change in their affairs at the beginning of the thirteenth +century: gradually they were withdrawn from under the sovereignty of +the Arabs, and made subject to the power of the Catholic monarchs. +They became thenceforward the equal partners of their brethren in +faith in the rest of Europe. All without distinction had a share in +the spiritual martyrdom which is the greenest bayleaf in the crown of +Jewish history. To think and to suffer became the watchword of the +whole nation. + +At first, as we have said, a considerable portion of the Jewish people +enjoyed the happy possibility of thinking. This was during the +classical epoch of the Arabic-Jewish Renaissance, which preceded the +Italian Renaissance by four centuries. There is a fundamental +difference between the two Renaissance periods: the earlier one was +signalized by a re-birth of the sciences and of philosophy, the later +one pre-eminently of the arts and of literature. The eleventh and +twelfth centuries marked the meridian of the intellectual development +of medieval Judaism. As once, in Alexandria, the union of Judaic with +Hellenic culture brought in its train a superabundance of new ideas of +a universal character, so again the amalgamation, on Spanish soil, of +Jewish culture with Arabic gave rise to rich intellectual results, +more lasting and fruitful than the Alexandrian, inasmuch as, in spite +of their universal character, they did not contravene the national +spirit. The Jewish people dropped its misanthropy and its leaning +toward isolation. The Jews entered all sorts of careers: by the side +of influential and cultivated statesmen, such as Chasdai ibn Shaprut +and Samuel Hanagid, at the courts of the Khalifs, stood a brilliant +group of grammarians, poets, and philosophers, like Jonah ibn Ganach, +Solomon Gabirol, and Moses ibn Ezra. The philosophic-critical +scepticism of Abraham ibn Ezra co-existed in peace and harmony with +the philosophic-poetic enthusiasm of Jehuda Halevi. The study of +medicine, mathematics, physics, and astronomy went hand in hand with +the study of the Talmud, which, though it may not have occupied the +first place with the Spanish Jews of this time, by no means +disappeared, as witness the compendium by Alphassi. Unusual breadth +and fulness of the spiritual life is the distinction of the epoch. +This variety of mental traits combined in a marvelous union to form +the great personality of Maimonides, the crown of a glorious period. +With one "Strong Hand," this intellectual giant brought order out of +the Talmudic chaos, which at his word was transformed into a +symmetrical, legal system; with the other, he "guided the Perplexed" +through the realm of faith and knowledge. For rationalistic clarity +and breadth of view no counterpart to the religio-philosophic doctrine +which he formulated can be found in the whole extent of medieval +literature. The main feature of the philosophy of Maimonides and of +the systems based upon it is rationalism, not a dry, scholastic, +abstract rationalism, but a living rationalism, embracing the whole +field of the most exalted psychic phenomena. It is not philosophy pure +and simple, but religious philosophy, an harmonization, more or less +felicitous, of the postulates of reason with the dogmas of faith. It +is reason mitigated by faith, and faith regulated by reason. In the +darkness of the middle ages, when the Romish Church impregnated +religion with the crudest superstitions, going so far as to forbid its +adherents to read the Bible, and when the greatest philosopher +representatives of the Church, like Albertus Magnus, would have +rejected offhand, as a childish fancy or, indeed, as an heretical +chimera, any attempt to rescue the lower classes of the people from +their wretched state of spiritual servitude--in a time like this, the +truly majestic spectacle is presented of a philosophy declaring war on +superstition, and setting out to purify the religious notions of the +people. + +Not a breath of this ample spiritual development of the Jews of Arabic +Spain reached the Jews living in the Christian countries of Europe. +Their circumstances were too grievous, and in sombreness their inner +life matched their outer estate. Their horizon was as contracted as +the streets of the Jewries in which they were penned. The crusades +(beginning in 1096) clearly showed the Jews of France and Germany what +sentiments their neighbors cherished towards them. They were the first +returns which Christianity paid the Jewish people for its old-time +teaching of religion. The descendants of the "chosen people," the +originators of the Bible, were condemned to torture of a sort to +exhaust their spiritual heritage. Judaism suffered the tragic fate of +King Lear. Was it conceivable that the horrors--the rivers of blood, +the groans of massacred communities, the serried ranks of martyrs, the +ever-haunting fear of the morrow--should fail to leave traces in the +character of Judaism? The Jewish people realized its imminent danger. +It convulsively held fast to its precious relics, clung to the pillars +of its religion, which it regarded as the only asylum. The Jewish +spirit again withdrew from the outer world. It gave itself up wholly +to the study of the Talmud. In northern France and in Germany, +Talmudic learning degenerated into the extreme of scholastic pedantry, +the lot of every branch of science that is lopped off from the main +trunk of knowledge, and vegetates in a heavy, dank atmosphere, lacking +light and air. Rashi (1064-1105), whose genial activity began before +the first crusade, opened up Jewish religious literature to the +popular mind, by his systematic commentaries on the Bible and the +Talmud. On the other hand, the Tossafists, the school of commentators +succeeding him, by their petty quibbling and hairsplitting casuistry +made the Talmudic books more intricate and less intelligible. Such +being the intellectual bias of the age, a sober, rationalistic +philosophy could not assert itself. In lieu of an Ibn Ezra or a +Maimonides, we have Jehuda Hachassid and Eliezer of Worms, with their +mystical books of devotion, _Sefer Chassidim, Rokeach_, etc., +filled with pietistic reflections on the other world, in which the +earth figures as a "vale of tears." Poetry likewise took on the dismal +hue of its environment. Instead of the varied lyrical notes of Gabirol +and Halevi, who sang the weal and woe, not only of the nation, but +also of the individual, and lost themselves in psychologic analysis, +there now fall upon our ear the melancholy, heartrending strains of +synagogue poetry, the harrowing outcries that forced themselves from +the oppressed bosoms of the hunted people, the prayerful lamentations +that so often shook the crumbling walls of the medieval synagogues at +the very moment when, full of worshipers, they were fired by the +inhuman crusaders. A mighty chord reverberates in this poetry: +_Morituri te salutant_. + +One small spot there was, in the whole of Europe, in which Jews could +still hope to endure existence and enjoy a measure of security. This +was Southern France, or the Provence. The population of Provence had +assimilated the culture of the neighboring country, Arabic Spain, and +become the mediator between it and the rest of Europe. This work of +mediation was undertaken primarily by the Jews. In the twelfth century +several universities existed in Provence, which were frequented in +great numbers by students from all countries. At these universities +the teachers of philosophy, medicine, and other branches of science +were for the most part Jews. The rationalistic philosophy of the +Spanish Jews was there proclaimed _ex cathedra_. The Tibbonides +translated all the more important works of the Jewish thinkers of +Spain from Arabic into Hebrew. The Kimchis devoted themselves to +grammatical studies and the investigation of the Bible. In +Montpellier, Narbonne, and Lunel, intellectual work was in full swing. +Rational ideas gradually leavened the masses of the Provençal +population. Conscience freed from intellectual trammels began to +revolt against the oppression exercised by the Roman clergy. Through +the Albigensian heresy, Innocent III, founder of the papal power, had +his attention directed to the Jews, whom he considered the dangerous +protagonists of rationalism. The "heresy" was stifled, Provence in all +her magnificence fell a prey to the Roman mania for destruction, and, +on the ruins of a noble civilization, the Dominican Inquisition raged +with all its horrors (1213). + +Thenceforward the Catholic Church devoted herself to a hostile watch +upon the Jews. Either she persecuted them directly through her +Inquisition, or indirectly through her omnipotent influence on kings +and peoples. In the hearts of the citizens of medieval Europe, the +flame of religious hatred was enkindled, and religious hatred served +as a cloak for the basest passions. Jewish history from that time on +became a history of uninterrupted suffering. The Lateran Council +declared the Jews to be outcasts, and designed a peculiar, +dishonorable badge for them, a round patch of yellow cloth, to be worn +on their upper garment (1215). In France the Jews became by turns the +victims of royal rapacity and the scapegoats of popular fanaticism. +Massacres, confiscations, banishments followed by dearly purchased +permission to return, by renewed restrictions, persecutions, and +oppressions--these were the measures that characterized the treatment +of the Jews in France until their final expulsion (1394). In Germany +the Jews were not so much hated as despised. They were _servi +camerae_, serfs of the state, and as such had to pay oppressive +taxes. Besides, they were limited to the meanest trades and to usury +and peddling. They were shut up in their narrow Jewries, huddled in +wretched cabins, which clustered about the dilapidated synagogue in a +shamefaced way. What strange homes! What gigantic misery, what +boundless suffering dumbly borne, was concealed in those crumbling, +curse-laden dwellings! And yet, how resplendent they were with +spiritual light, what exalted virtues, what lofty heroism they +harbored! In those gloomy, tumbledown Jew houses, intellectual +endeavor was at white heat. The torch of faith blazed clear in them, +and on the pure domestic hearth played a gentle flame. In the abject, +dishonored son of the Ghetto was hidden an intellectual giant. In his +nerveless body, bent double by suffering, and enveloped in the shabby +old cloak still further disfigured by the yellow wheel, dwelt the soul +of a thinker. The son of the Ghetto might have worn his badge with +pride, for in truth it was a medal of distinction awarded by the papal +Church to the Jews, for dauntlessness and courage. The awkward, puny +Jew in his way was stronger and braver than a German knight armed +cap-a-pie, for he was penetrated by the faith that "moves mountains." +And when the worst came to the worst, he demonstrated his courage. +When his peaceful home was stormed by the bestialized hordes of +Armleder, or the drunken bands of the Flagellants, or the furious +avengers of the "Black Death," he did not yield, did not purchase life +by disgraceful treason. With invincible courage he put his head under +the executioner's axe, and breathed forth his heroic spirit with the +enthusiastic cry: "Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God is One." + +At length the turn of the Spanish Jews arrived. For the unbroken peace +they had enjoyed, they had to atone by centuries of unexampled +suffering. By degrees, the Arabs were forced out of the Pyrenean +Peninsula, and the power they had to abdicate was assumed by the +Catholic kings of Castile and Aragon. In 1236 occurred the fall of +Cordova, the most important centre of Arabic Jewish culture. +Thereafter Arab power held sway only in the province of Granada. The +fortunes of the Spanish Jews underwent a calamitous change. The kings +and the upper ten thousand were, indeed, favorably disposed toward +them. At the courts of Castile and Aragon, the Jews were active as +ministers, physicians, astronomers. But the people, incited by the +propaganda of the clerics, nursed frightful hatred against the Jews, +not only as "infidels," but also as intellectual aristocrats. The rage +of the populace was the combustible material in the terrific +explosions that occurred periodically, in the bloody saturnalia of the +Pastouraux (1320), in the Black Death riots (1348), in the massacre of +Seville (1391). + +Dire blows of fortune were unable to weigh down the Spanish Jew, +accustomed to independence, as they did the German Jew. He carried his +head proudly on high, for he was conscious that in all respects he +stood above the rabble pursuing him, above its very leaders, the +clerics. In spite of untoward fate his mental development proceeded, +but inevitably it was modified by the trend of the times. By the side +of the philosophic tendency of the previous age, a mystical tendency +appeared in literature. The Kabbala, with its mist-shrouded symbolism, +so grateful to the feelings and the imagination, chimed in better than +rationalistic philosophy with the depressed humor under which the +greater part of the Jews were then laboring. Another force +antagonistic to rationalistic philosophy was the Rabbinism +transplanted from France and Germany. The controversy between +Rabbinism and philosophy, which dragged itself through three-quarters +of a century (1232-1305), ended in the formal triumph of Rabbinism. +However, philosophic activity merely languished, it did not cease +entirely; in fact, the three currents for some time ran along parallel +with one another. Next to the pillars of Rabbinism, Asheri, Rashba, +Isaac ben Sheshet, loomed up the philosophers, Gersonides (Ralbag), +Kreskas, and Albo, and a long line of Kabbalists, beginning with +Nachmanides and Moses de Leon, the compiler of the Zohar, and ending +with the anonymous authors of the mysterious "Kana and Pelia." + +The times grew less and less propitious. Catholicism steadily gained +ground in Spain. The scowling Dominican put forward his claim upon the +Jewish soul with vehement emphasis, and made every effort to drag it +into the bosom of the alone-saving Church. The conversion of the Jews +would have been a great triumph, indeed, for Catholicism militant. The +conversion methods of the Dominican monk were of a most insinuating +kind--he usually began with a public religious disputation. +Unfortunately, the Jews were experts in the art of debate, and too +often by their bold replies covered the self-sufficient dignitaries of +Rome with confusion. The Jews should have known, from bitter +experience, that such boldness would not be passed over silently. From +sumptuous debating hall to Dominican prison and scaffold was but a +short step. In 1391, one of these worthy soul-catchers, Bishop +Ferdinando Martinez, set the fanatical mob of Seville on the Jews, and +not without success. Terrorized by the threat of death, many accepted +Catholicism under duress. But they became Christians only in +appearance; in reality they remained true to the faith of their +fathers, and, in secret, running the risk of loss of life, they +fulfilled all the Jewish ordinances. This is the prologue to the +thrilling Marrano tragedy. + +Finally, the moment approached when gloomy Catholicism attained to +unchallenged supremacy in the Pyrenean Peninsula. On the ruins of the +enlightened culture of the Arabs, Ferdinand the Catholic and Isabella +of Castile reared the reactionary government of medieval Rome. The +Inquisition was introduced (1480). Torquemada presided as high priest +over the rites attending the human sacrifices. _Ad gloriam +ecclesiae_, the whole of Spain was illuminated. Everywhere the +funeral pyres of the Inquisition flared to the skies, the air was rent +by the despairing shrieks of martyrs enveloped in flames or racked by +tortures, the prisons overflowed with Marranos,--all instruments of +torture were vigorously plied. + +At last the hour of redemption struck: in 1492 all Jews were driven +from Spain, and a few years later from Portugal. Jewish-Arabic culture +after five centuries of ascendency suffered a sudden collapse. The +unhappy people again grasped its staff, and wandered forth into the +world without knowing whither. + + + + +X + +THE RABBINIC-MYSTICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE GERMAN-POLISH +JEWS (1492-1789) + + +The expulsion from Spain was a stunning blow. The hoary martyr people +which had defied so many storms in its long life was for a moment +dazed. The soil of Europe was quaking under its feet. At the time when +the medieval period had formally come to a close for Occidental +Christendom, and the modern period had opened, the middle ages +continued in unmitigated brutality for the Jews. If anything, the life +of the Jews had become more unendurable than before. What, indeed, had +the much-vaunted modern age to offer them? In the ranks of the +humanistic movement Reuchlin alone stood forth prominently as the +advocate of the Jews, and he was powerless before the prejudices of +the populace. The Reformation in Germany and elsewhere had illuminated +the minds of the people, but had not softened their hearts. Luther +himself, the creator of the Reformation, was not innocent of hating +the followers of an alien faith. The Jews especially did not enjoy too +great a measure of his sympathies. The wars growing out of the +Reformation, which in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries +devastated Europe in the name of religion, were not calculated to +favor the spread of tolerance and milder manners. The conflict raging +in the bosom of the Church and setting her own children by the ears, +was yet insufficient to divert her maternal care from her +"unbelieving" stepchildren. In Spain and Portugal, stakes continued to +burn two centuries longer for the benefit of the Marranos, the false +Christians. In Germany and Austria, the Jews were kept in the same +condition of servitude as before. Their economic circumstances were +appalling. They were forced to emigrate _en masse_ to Poland, +which offered the adherents of their faith a comparatively quiet life, +and by and by was invested with the Jewish hegemony. Some of the +smaller states and independent towns of Italy also afforded the Jews +an asylum, though one not always to be depended upon. A group of +hard-driven Spanish exiles, for instance, under the leadership of +Abarbanel had found peace in Italy. The rest had turned to Turkey and +her province Palestine, + +For a time, indeed, the Jewish spiritual centre was located in Turkey. +What Europe, old, Christian, and hardhearted, refused the Jews, was +granted them by Turkey, young, Mussulman, and liberal. On hearing of +the banishment of the Jews from Spain, Sultan Bajazet exclaimed: "How +can you call Ferdinand of Aragon a wise king, the same Ferdinand who +has made his land poor and enriched ours?" His amazement characterizes +the relation of Turkey to the Jews of the day. The one-time Marrano, +Joseph Nassi, rose to be a considerable dignitary at the court of +Sultan Selim (1566-1580). Occasionally he succeeded, by diplomatic +means, in wreaking vengeance upon European courts in retaliation for +the brutal tortures inflicted upon his people. With the generosity of +a Maecenas, he assembled Jewish scholars and poets, and surrounded +himself with a sunlit atmosphere of intellectuality and talent. All +other Jewish communities looked up to that of Constantinople. Now and +again its rabbis played the part of Patriarchs of the synagogue. To +this commanding position the rabbis of Palestine especially were +inclined to lay claim. They even attempted to restore the +Patriarchate, and the famous controversy between Jacob Berab and Levi +ben Chabib regarding the _Semicha_ is another evidence of the +same assertive tendency. Among the Spanish exiles settled in the Holy +Land a peculiar spiritual current set in. The storm-tossed wanderers, +but now returned to their native Jordan from the shores of the +blood-stained Tagus and Guadalquivir, were mightily moved at the sight +of their ancestral home. Ahasuerus, who on his thorn-strewn pilgrim's +path had drained the cup of woe to the dregs, suddenly caught sight of +the home of his childhood razed level with the ground. The precious, +never-to-be-forgotten ruins exhaled the home feeling, which took +possession of him with irresistible charm. Into his soul there flowed +sweet memories of a golden youth, past beyond recall. The impact of +these emotions enkindled passionate "longing for Zion" in the heart of +the forlorn, homeless martyr. He was seized by torturing thirst for +political resurrection. Such melancholy feelings and vehement +outbursts found expression in the practical Kabbala, originating with +Ari (Isaac Luria) and his famous Safed school. A mystical belief in +the coming of Messiah thenceforward became one of the essential +elements of the Jewish spirit. It vanquished the heart of the learned +Joseph Karo, who had brought Rabbinism to its climax by the +compilation of his celebrated ritual code, the Shulchan Aruch. With +equal force it dominated the being of Solomon Molcho, the enthusiastic +youth who, at one time a Marrano, on his public return to Judaism +proclaimed the speedy regeneration of Israel. He sealed his faith in +his prophecy with death at the stake (1532). The Marranos beyond the +Pyrenees and the unfortunate Jews of Italy, who, in the second half of +the sixteenth century had to bear the brunt of papal fanaticism, on +the increase since the Reformation, were kept in a state of constant +excitement by this Messianic doctrine, with its obscure stirrings of +hope. A mournful national feeling pervades the Jewish literature of +the time. Recollections of torments endured enflamed all hearts. A +series of chronicles were thus produced that record the centuries of +Jewish martyrdom--_Jocha-sin, Shebet Jehuda, Emek ha-Bacha_, etc. +The art of printing, even then developed to a considerable degree of +perfection, became for the dispersed Jews the strongest bond of +spiritual union. The papal _index librorum prohibitorum_ was +impotent in the face of the all-pervading propaganda for thought and +feeling carried on by the printing press. + +After Palestine and Turkey, Holland for a time became the spiritual +centre of the scattered Jews (in the seventeenth century). Holland was +warmly attached to the cause of liberty. When it succeeded in freeing +itself from the clutches of fanatical Spain and her rapacious king, +Philip II, it inaugurated the golden era of liberty of conscience, of +peaceful development in culture and industry, and granted an asylum to +the persecuted and abandoned of all countries. By the thousands the +harassed Ghetto sons, especially the Marranos from Spain and Portugal, +migrated to Holland. Amsterdam became a second Cordova. The +intellectual life was quickened. Freedom from restraint tended to +break down the national exclusivism of the Jew, and intercourse with +his liberal surroundings varied his mental pursuits. Rabbinism, the +Kabbala, philosophy, national poetry--they all had their prominent +representatives in Holland. These manifold tendencies were united in +the literary activity of Manasseh ben Israel, a scholar of extensive, +though not intensive, encyclopedic attainments. Free thought and +religious rationalism were embodied in Uriel Acosta. To a still higher +degree they were illustrated in the theory of life expounded by the +immortal author of the "Theologico-Political Tractate" (1640-1677). +This advanced state of culture in Holland did not fail to react upon +the neighboring countries. Under the impulse of enthusiasm for the +Bible Puritan England under Cromwell opened its portals to the Jews. +In Italy, in the dank atmosphere of rabbinical dialectics and morbid +mysticism, great figures loom up--Leon de Modena, the antagonist of +Rabbinism and of the Kabbala, and Joseph del Medigo, mathematician, +philosopher, and mystic, the disciple of Galileo. + +These purple patches were nothing more than the accidents of a +transition period. The people as a whole was on the decline. The +Jewish mind darted hither and thither, like a startled bird seeking +its nest. Holland or Turkey was an inadequate substitute for Spain, if +only for the reason that but a tiny fraction of the Jews had found +shelter in either. The Jewish national centre must perforce coincide +with the numerical centre of the dispersed people, in which, moreover, +conditions must grant Jews the possibility of living undisturbed in +closely compacted masses, and of perfecting a well-knit organization +of social and individual life. Outside of Spain these conditions were +fulfilled only by Poland, which gradually, beginning with the +sixteenth century, assumed the hegemony over the Jewry of the world. +This marks the displacement of the Sephardic (Spanish, in a broader +sense, Romanic) element, and the supremacy of the Ashkenazic +(German-Polish) element. + +Poland had been a resort for Jewish immigrants from Germany since the +outbreak of the Crusades, until, in the sixteenth century, it rose to +the position of a Jewish centre of the first magnitude. As the +merchant middle class, the Jews were protected and advanced by the +kings and the Szlachta. The consequent security of their position +induced so rapid a growth of the Jewish element that in a little while +the Jews of Poland outnumbered those of the old Jewish settlements in +Occidental Europe. The numerous privileges granted the Jews, by +Boleslaus of Kalish (1246), Kasimir the Great (1347-1370), Witowt +(1388), Kasimir IV (1447), and some of their successors, fortified +their position in the extended territory covered by Poland, Lithuania, +and the Ukraine. Their peculiar circumstances in Poland left an +impress upon their inner life. An intense mental activity was called +forth. This activity can be traced back to German beginnings, though +at the same time it is made up of many original elements. For a space +Rabbinism monopolized the intellectual endeavors of the Polish Jews. +The rabbi of Cracow, Moses Isserles, and the rabbi of Ostrog, Solomon +Luria (d. 1572), disputed first place with the foremost rabbinical +authorities of other countries. Their decisions and circular letters +regarding religious and legal questions were accorded binding force. +Associates and successors of theirs founded Talmud academies +throughout the country, and large numbers of students attended them. +Commentators upon the Talmud and expounders of classical works in +Jewish theological literature appeared in shoals. Jewish printing +establishments in Cracow and Lublin were assiduous in turning out a +mass of writings, which spread the fame of the Polish rabbis to the +remotest communities. The large autonomy enjoyed by the Polish and +Lithuanian Jews conferred executive power upon rabbinical legislation. +The _Kahal_, or Jewish communal government, to a certain degree +invested with judicial and administrative competence, could not do +without the guiding hand of the rabbis as interpreters of the law. The +guild of rabbis, on their side, chose a "college of judges," with +fairly extensive jurisdiction, from among their own members. The +organization of the Rabbinical Conferences, or the "Synods of the Four +Countries," formed the keystone of this intricate social-spiritual +hierarchy. The comprehensive inner autonomy and the system of Talmud +academies (_Yeshiboth_) that covered the whole of Poland remind +one of the brilliant days of the Exilarchate and the Babylonia of the +Geonim. One element was lacking, there was no versatile, commanding +thinker like Saadia Gaon. Secular knowledge and philosophy were under +the ban in Poland. Rabbinism absorbed the whole output of intellectual +energy. As little as the Poles resembled the Arabs of the "golden +age," did the Polish Jews resemble their brethren in faith in the +Orient at Saadia's time or in the Spain of Gabirol and Maimonides. +Isolation and clannishness were inevitable in view of the character of +the Christian environment and the almost insuperable barriers raised +between the classes of Polish society. But it was this exclusiveness +that gave peculiar stability and completeness to the life of the Jew +as an individual and as a member of Jewish society, and it was the +same exclusiveness that afforded opportunity for the development of a +sharply defined culture, for its fixation to the point of resisting +violent shocks and beyond the danger point of extinction through +foreign invasion. + +The fateful year 1648 formed a turning point in the history of the +Polish Jews, as in the history of the countries belonging to the +Polish crown. The Cossack butcheries and wars of extermination of +1648-1658 were the same for the Polish Jews that the Crusades, the +Black Death, and all the other occasions for carnage had been for the +Jews of Western Europe. It seemed as though history desired to avoid +the reproach of partiality, and hastened to mete out even-handed +justice by apportioning the same measure of woe to the Jews of Poland +as to the Jews of Western Europe. But the Polish Jews were prepared to +accept the questionable gift from the hands of history. They had +mounted that eminence of spiritual stability on which suffering loses +the power to weaken its victim, but, on the contrary, endues him with +strength. More than ever they shrank into their shell. They shut +themselves up more completely in their inner world, and became morally +dulled against the persecutions, the bitter humiliations, the deep +scorn, which their surroundings visited upon them. The Polish Jew +gradually accustomed himself to his pitiable condition. He hardly knew +that life might be other than it was. That the Polish lord to whom he +was a means of entertainment might treat him with a trace of respect, +or that his neighbors, the middle class merchant, the German guild +member, and the Little Russian peasant, might cherish kindly feelings +toward him, he could not conceive as a possibility. Seeing himself +surrounded by enemies, he took precautions to fortify his camp, not so +much to protect himself against hostile assaults from without--they +were inevitable--as to paralyze the disastrous consequences of such +assaults in his inner world. To compass this end he brought into play +all the means suggested by his exceptional position before the law and +by his own peculiar social constitution. The _Kahal_, the +autonomous rabbinical administration of communal affairs, more and +more assumed the character of an inner dictatorship. Jewish society +was persistently kept under the discipline of rigid principles. In +many affairs the synagogue attained the position of a court of final +appeal. The people were united, or rather packed, into a solid mass by +purely mechanical processes--by pressure from without, and by drawing +tight a noose from within. Besides this social factor tending to +consolidate the Jewish people into a separate union, an intellectual +lever was applied to produce the same result. Rabbinism employed the +mystical as its adjutant. The one exercised control over all minds, +the other over all hearts. The growth of mysticism was fostered both +by the unfortunate conditions under which the Polish Jews endured +existence and by the Messianic movements which made their appearance +among the Jews of other countries. + +In the second half of the seventeenth century, mysticism reached its +zenith in Turkey, the country in which, had stood the cradle of the +"practical Kabbala." The teachings of Ari, Vital, and the school +established by them spread like wildfire. Messianic extravagances +intoxicated the baited and persecuted people. In Smyrna appeared the +false Messiah, Sabbatai Zebi. As by magic he attracted to himself a +tremendous company of adherents in the East and in the West. For a +quarter of a century (1650-1676), he kept the Jewish communities +everywhere in a state of quivering suspense. + +The harassed people tossed to and fro like a fever patient, and raved +about political re-birth. Its delirious visions still further heated +its agitated blood. It came to its senses but slowly. Not even the +apostasy and death of Sabbatai Zebi sufficed to sober all his +followers. Under the guise of a symbolic faith in a Messiah, many of +them, publicly or secretly, continued the propaganda for his +doctrines. + +This propaganda prepared the fertile soil from which, in the +eighteenth century, shot up Messianic systems, tending to split +Judaism into sects. Nowhere did the mystical teachings evoke so ready +a response as in Poland, the very centre of Judaism. At first an ally +of the rabbinical school, mysticism grown passionate and +uncontrollable now and again acted as the violent opponent of +Rabbinism. Secret devotion to the Sabbatian doctrines, which had made +their home in Poland, sometimes led to such extremes in dogma and +ethics that the rabbis could not contain themselves. Chayyim Malach, +Judah Chassid, and other Galician mystics, in the second decade of the +eighteenth century brought down upon themselves a rabbinical decree of +excommunication. The mystical tendency was the precursor of the +heretical half-Christian sect of Frankists, who ventured so far as to +lift a hand against the fundamentals of Judaism: they rejected the +Talmud in favor of the Zohar (1756-1773). At the same time a much more +profound movement, instinct with greater vitality, made its appearance +among the Polish-Jewish masses, a movement rooted in their social and +spiritual organization. The wretched, debased condition of the average +Jew, conjoined with the traditions of the Kabbala and the excrescences +of Rabbinism, created a foothold for Chassidic teaching. Chassidism +replaced Talmudic ratiocination by exalted religious sentiment. By the +force of enthusiasm for faith, it drew its adherents together into a +firmly welded unit in contrast with Rabbinism, which sought the same +goal by the aid of the formal law. Scenting danger, the rabbinical +hierarchy declared war upon the Kabbala. Emden opposed Eibeschütz, the +Polish Sabbatians and Frankists were fought to the death, the Wilna +Gaon organized a campaign against the Chassidim. Too late! Rabbinism +was too old, too arid, to tone down the impulsive outbreaks of passion +among the people. In their religious exaltation the masses were +looking for an elixir. They were languishing, not for light to +illumine the reason, but for warmth to set the heart aglow. They +desired to lose themselves in ecstatic self-renunciation. Chassidism +and its necessary dependence upon the Zaddik offered the masses the +means of this forgetfulness of self through faith. They were the +medium through which the people saw the world in a rosy light, and the +consequences following upon their prevalence were seen in a marked +intensification of Jewish exclusiveness. + +The same aloofness characterizes the Jews of the rest of the +eighteenth century diaspora. Wherever, as in Germany, Austria, and +Italy, Jews were settled in considerable numbers, they were separated +from their surroundings by forbidding Ghetto walls. On the whole, no +difference is noticeable between conditions affecting Jews in one +country and those in another. Everywhere they were merely tolerated, +everywhere oppressed and humiliated. The bloody persecutions of the +middle ages were replaced by the burden of the exceptional laws, which +in practice degraded the Jews socially to an inferior race, to +citizens of a subordinate degree. The consequences were uniformly the +same in all countries: spiritual isolation and a morbid religious +mood. During the first half of the "century of reason," Jewry +presented the appearance of an exhausted wanderer, heavily dragging +himself on his way, his consciousness clouded, his trend of thought +obviously anti-rationalistic. At the very moment in which Europe was +beginning to realize its medieval errors and repent of them, and the +era of universal ideals of humanity was dawning, Judaism raised +barricades between itself and the world at large. Elijah Gaon and +Israel Besht were the contemporaries of Voltaire and Rousseau. +Apparently there was no possibility of establishing communication +between these two diametrically opposed worlds. But history is a +magician. Not far from the Poland enveloped in medieval darkness, the +morning light of a new life was breaking upon slumbering Jewry in +German lands. New voices made themselves heard, reverberating like an +echo to the appeal issued by the "great century" in behalf of a +spiritual and social regeneration of mankind. + + + + +XI + +THE MODERN PERIOD OF ENLIGHTENMENT (THE NINETEENTH CENTURY) + + +Two phenomena signalized the beginning of the latest period in Jewish +history: the lofty activity of Mendelssohn and the occurrence of the +great French Revolution. The man stands for the spiritual emancipation +of the Jews, the movement for their political emancipation. At bottom, +these two phenomena were by no means the ultimate causes of the social +and spiritual regeneration of the Jewish people. They were only the +products of the more general causes that had effected a similar +regeneration in all the peoples of Western Europe. The new currents, +the abandonment of effete intellectual and social forms, the +substitution of juster and more energetic principles, the protest +against superstition and despotism--all these traits had a common +origin, the resuscitation of reason and free thought, which dominated +all minds without asking whether they belonged to Jew or to Christian. +It might seem that the rejuvenation of the Jews had been consummated +more rapidly than the rejuvenation of the other peoples. The latter +had had two centuries, the period elapsing since the middle ages, that +is, the period between the Reformation and the great Revolution, in +which to prepare for a more rational and a more humane conduct of +life. As for the Jews, their middle ages began much later, and ended +later, almost on the eve of 1789, so that the revolution in their +minds and their mode of life had to accomplish itself hastily, under +the urgence of swiftly crowding events, by the omission of +intermediate stages. But it must be taken into consideration that long +before, in the Judeo-Hellenic and in the Arabic-Spanish period, the +Jews had passed through their "century of reason." In spite of the +intervening ages of suffering and gloom, the faculty of assimilating +new principles had survived. For the descendants of Philo and +Maimonides the rationalistic movement of the eighteenth century was in +part a repetition of a well-known historical process. They had had the +benefit of a similar course of studies before, and, therefore, had no +need to cram on the eve of the final examination. + +In point of fact, the transformation in the life of the Jews did take +place with extraordinary swiftness. It was hastened in France by the +principles of the Revolution and the proclamation of the civil +equality of Jews with the other citizens. In Germany, however, it +advanced upon purely spiritual lines. Mendelssohn and Lessing, the +heralds of spiritual reform, who exposed old prejudices, carried on +their labors at a time in which the Jews still stood beyond the pale +of the law, a condition which it did not occur to Frederick II, "the +philosopher upon the throne," to improve. A whole generation was +destined to pass before the civil emancipation of the German Jews was +accomplished. Meantime their spiritual emancipation proceeded apace, +without help from the ruling powers. A time so early as the end of the +eighteenth century found the German Jews in a position to keep step +with their Christian fellow-citizens in cultural progress. Enlightened +Jews formed close connections with enlightened Christians, and joined +them in the universal concerns of mankind as confederates espousing +the same fundamental principles. If they renounced some of their +religious and national traditions, it was by no means out of +complaisance for their neighbors. They were guided solely and alone by +those universal principles that forced non-Jews as well as Jews to +reject many traditions as incompatible with reason and conscience. +Non-Jews and Jews alike yielded themselves up to the fresh inspiration +of the time, and permitted themselves to be carried along by the +universal transforming movement. Mendelssohn himself, circumspect and +wise, did not move off from religious national ground. But the +generation after him abandoned his position for that of universal +humanity, or, better, German nationality. His successors intoxicated +themselves with deep draughts of the marvelous poetry created by the +magic of Goethe and Schiller. They permitted themselves to be rushed +along by the liberty doctrines of 1789, they plunged head over heels +into the vortex of romanticism, and took an active part in the +conspicuous movements of Europe, political, social, and literary, as +witness Bôrne, Heine, and their fellow-combatants. + +The excitement soon evaporated. When the noise of the liberty +love-feasts had subsided, when the cruel reaction (after 1814) had +settled heavily upon the Europe of the nineteenth century, and God's +earth had again become the arena of those agents of darkness whom +dreamers had thought buried forever beneath the ruins of the old +order, then the German Jews, or such of them as thought, came to their +senses. The more intelligent Jewish circles realized that, in devotion +to the German national movement, they had completely neglected their +own people. Yet their people, too, had needs, practical or spiritual, +had its peculiar national sphere of activity, circumscribed, indeed, +by the larger sphere of mankind's activities as by a concentric +circle, but by no means merged into it. To atone for their sin, +thinking Jews retraced their steps. They took in hand the transforming +of Jewish inner life, the simplification of the extremely complicated +Jewish ritual, the remodeling of pedagogic methods, and, above all, +the cultivation of the extended fields of Jewish science, whose head +and front is Jewish historical research in all its vastness and +detail. Heine's friend, Zunz, laid the cornerstone of Jewish science +in the second decade of the nineteenth century. His work was taken up +by a goodly company of zealous and able builders occupied for half a +century with the task of rearing the proud edifice of a scientific +historical literature, in which national self-consciousness was +sheltered and fostered. At the very height of this reforming and +literary activity, German Jewry was overwhelmed by the civil +emancipation of 1848. Again a stirring movement drew them into +sympathy with a great general cause, but this time without drawing +them away from Jewish national interests. Cultural and civil +assimilation was accomplished as an inner compelling necessity, as a +natural outcome of living. But spiritual assimilation, in the sense of +a merging of Judaism in foreign elements, was earnestly repudiated by +the noblest representatives of Judaism. It was their ideal that +universal activity and national activity should be pursued to the +prejudice of neither, certainly not to the exclusion of one or the +other, but in perfect harmony with each other. In point of fact, it +may be asserted that, in spite of a frequent tendency to go to the one +or the other extreme, the two currents, the universal and the +national, co-exist within German Jewry, and there is no fear of their +uniting, they run parallel with each other. The Jewish genius is +versatile. Without hurt to itself it can be active in all sorts of +careers: in politics and in civil life, in parliament and on the +lecture platform, in all branches of science and departments of +literature, in every one of the chambers of mankind's intellectual +laboratory. At the same time it has its domestic hearth, its national +sanctuary; it has its sphere of original work and its self-consciousness, +its national interests and spiritual ideals rooted in the past of the Jew. +By the side of a Lassalle, a Lasker, and a Marx towers a Riesser, a +Geiger, a Graetz. The leveling process unavoidably connected with +widespread culture, so far from causing spiritual desolation in +German Judaism, has, on the contrary, furnished redundant proof +that even under present conditions, so unfavorable to what is +individual and original, the Jewish people has preserved its vitality +to the full. + +An analogous movement stirred the other countries of Western +Europe--France, Italy, and England. The political emancipation of the +Jews was accomplished earlier in them than in Germany. The +reconstruction of the inner life, too, proceeded more quietly and +regularly, without leaps and bounds, and religious reform established +itself by degrees. Yet even here, where the Jewish contingent was +insignificant, the spiritual physiognomy of the Jews maintained its +typical character. In these countries, as in Germany, the Jew +assimilated European culture with all its advantages and its +drawbacks. He was active on diplomatic fields, he devoted himself to +economic investigations, he produced intellectual creations of all +kinds--first and last he felt himself to be a citizen of his country. +None the less he was a loyal son of the Jewish people considered as a +spiritual people with an appointed task. Crémieux, Beaconsfield, +Luzzatti are counterbalanced by Salvador, Frank, Munk, Reggio, and +Montefiore. All the good qualities and the shortcomings distinctive of +the civilization of modern times adhere to the Jew. But at its worst +modern civilization has not succeeded in extinguishing the national +spirit in Jewry. The national spirit continues to live in the people, +and it is this spirit that quickens the people. The genius of Jewish +history, as in centuries gone by, holds watch over the sons of the +"eternal people" scattered to all ends of the earth. West-European +Jewry may say of itself, without presumption: _Cogito ergo sum_. + +Russian Jewry, the Jewry that had been Polish, and that is counted by +the millions, might, if necessary, prove its existence by even more +tangible marks than Occidental Jewry. To begin with, the centre of +gravity of the Jewish nation lies in Russia, whose Jews not only +outnumber those of the rest of Europe, but continue to live in a +compact mass. Besides, they have preserved the original Jewish culture +and their traditional physiognomy to a higher degree than the Jews of +other countries. The development of the Russian Jews took a course +very different from that of the Jews of the West. This difference was +conditioned by the tremendous contrast between Russian culture and +West-European culture, and by the change which the external +circumstances of Jews outside of Russia underwent during the modern +period. The admission of the Polish provinces into the Russian Empire +at the end of the eighteenth century found the numerous Jewish +population in an almost medieval condition, the same condition in +which the non-Jewish population of Russian Poland was at that time. +The Polish regime, as we saw above, had isolated the Jews alike in +civil and spiritual relations. The new order did not break down the +barriers. The masses of Jews cooped up in the "Pale of Settlement" +were strong only by reason of their inner unity, their firmly +established patriarchal organization. The bulwark of Rabbinism and the +citadel of Chassidism protected them against alien influences. They +guarded their isolation jealously. True to the law of inertia, they +would not allow the privilege of isolation to be wrested from them. +They did not care to step beyond the ramparts. Why, indeed, should the +Jews have quitted their fortress, if outside of their walls they could +expect nothing but scorn and blows? The unfortunates encaged in the +sinister Pale of Settlement could have been lured out of their +exclusive position only by complete civil emancipation combined with a +higher degree of culture than had been attained by Russian society, an +impossible set of circumstances in the first half of the nineteenth +century. The legislative measures of the time, in so far as they +relate to the Jews, breathe the spirit of police surveillance rather +than of enlightenment and humanity. To civilizing and intellectual +influences from without the way was equally barred. Yet all this +watchfulness was of no avail. Nothing could prevent the liberty +principles espoused by the Jews of Western Europe from being smuggled +into the Pale, to leaven the sad, serried masses. A sluggish process +of fermentation set in, and culminated in the literary activity of +Isaac Beer Levinsohn and of the Wilna reformers of the second and +fourth decades of the nineteenth century. They were the harbingers of +approaching spring. + +When spring finally came (after 1855), and the sun sent down his +genial rays upon the wretched Jewry of Russia, life and activity began +to appear at once, especially in the upper strata. As in Germany, so +in Russia spiritual emancipation preceded political emancipation. +Still shorn almost entirely of the elementary rights of citizens, the +Russian Jews nevertheless followed their ideal promptings, and +participated enthusiastically in the movement for enlightenment which +at that time held the noblest of the Russians enthralled. In a +considerable portion of the Russian Jewish community a process of +culture regeneration began, an eager throwing off of outworn forms of +life and thought, a swift adoption of humane principles. Jewish young +men crowded into the secular schools, in which they came in close +contact with their Christian contemporaries. Influenced by their new +companions, they gave themselves up to Russian national movements, +often at the cost of renunciation of self. Some of them, indeed, in +one-sided aspiration strove to become, not Russians, but men. The +influence exercised by literature was more moderate than that of the +schools. Rabbinic and Chassidistic literature, on the point of dying +out as it was, abandoned the field to the literature of enlightenment +in the Hebrew language, a literature of somewhat primitive character. +It consisted chiefly of naive novels and of didactic writings of +publicists, and lacked the solid scientific and historical element +that forms the crown of Western Jewish literature. It is indisputable, +however, that it exerted an educational influence. Besides, it +possesses the merit of having resuscitated one of the most valuable of +Jewish national possessions, the Hebrew language in its purity, which +in Russia alone has become a pliant instrument of literary expression. +A still greater field was reserved for the Jewish-Russian literature +that arose in the "sixties." It was called into being in order to +present a vivid and true picture of the social and spiritual interests +of the Jews. Proceeding from discussions of current political topics, +this literature gradually widened its limits so as to include Jewish +history, Jewish science, and the portrayal of Jewish life, and more +and more approached the character of a normal European literature. All +this was in the making, and the most important work had not yet begun. +The lower strata of the people had not been touched by the fresh air. +In time, if all had gone well, they, too, would have had their day. +And if the minority of the Jewish people in the West in a short span +of time brought forth so many notable workers in so many departments +of life and thought, how much superior would be the culture +achievements of the Eastern majority! How vigorously the mighty mental +forces latent in Russian Jewry would develop when their advance was no +longer obstructed by all sorts of obstacles, and they could be applied +to every sphere of political, social, and intellectual life! + +Nothing of all this came to pass; exactly the opposite happened. Not +only were the barriers in the way of a prosperous, free development of +Jewry not removed, but fresh hindrances without number were +multiplied. Some spectre of the middle ages, some power of darkness, +put brakes upon the wheel of history. It first appeared in the West, +under the name anti-Semitism, among the dregs of European society. But +in its earliest abode it was and is still met with an abrupt rebuff on +the part of the most intelligent circles, those whom even the present +age of decadence has not succeeded in robbing of belief in lofty moral +ideals. Anti-Semitism in the West is in _anima vili_. Its cult is +confined to a certain party, which enjoys a rather scandalous +reputation. But there are countries in which this power of darkness, +in the coarser form of Judophobia[13], has cast its baleful spell upon +the most influential members of society and upon the press. There it +has ripened noxious fruit. Mocking at the exalted ideals and the +ethical traditions of religious and thinking mankind, Judophobia +shamelessly professes the dogma of misanthropy. Its propaganda is +bringing about the moral ruin of an immature society, not yet +confirmed in ethical or truly religious principles. Upon its victims, +the Jews, it has the same effect as the misfortunes of the middle +ages, which were meted out to our hoary people with overflowing +measure, and against which it learnt to assume an armor of steel. The +recent severe trials are having the same result as the persecutions of +former days: they do not weaken, on the contrary, they invigorate the +Jewish spirit, they spur on to thought, they stimulate the pulse of +the people. + + "The hammer shivers glass, + But iron by its blows is forged."[14] + + [13] As anti-Semitism is called in Russia. + [14] Pushkin. + +The historical process Jewry has undergone repeatedly, it must undergo +once again. But now, too, in this blasting time of confusion and +dispersion, of daily torture and the horrors of international +conflict, "the keeper of Israel slumbereth not and sleepeth not." The +Jewish spirit is on the alert. It is ever purging and tempering itself +in the furnace of suffering. The people which justly bears the name of +the veteran of history withdraws and falls into a revery. It is not a +narrow-minded fanatic's flight from the world, but the concentrated +thought of a mourner. Jewry is absorbed in contemplation of its great, +unparalleled past. More than ever it is now in need of the teachings +of its past, of the moral support and the prudent counsels of its +history, its four thousand years of life crowded with checkered +experiences. + + + + +XII + +THE TEACHINGS OF JEWISH HISTORY + + +Let us return now to the starting point of our discussion, and +endeavor to establish the thoughts and lessons to be deduced from the +course of Jewish history. + +Above all, Jewish history possesses the student with the conviction +that Jewry at all times, even in the period of political independence, +was pre-eminently a spiritual nation, and a spiritual nation it +continues to be in our own days, too. Furthermore, it inspires him +with the belief that Jewry, being a spiritual entity, cannot suffer +annihilation: the body, the mold, may be destroyed, the spirit is +immortal. Bereft of country and dispersed as it is, the Jewish nation +lives, and will go on living, because a creative principle permeates +it, a principle that is the root of its being and an indigenous +product of its history. This principle consists first in a sum of +definite religious, moral, or philosophic ideals, whose exponent at +all times was the Jewish people, either in its totality, or in the +person of its most prominent representatives. Next, this principle +consists in a sum of historical memories, recollections of what in the +course of many centuries the Jewish people experienced, thought, and +felt, in the depths of its being. Finally, it consists in the +consciousness that true Judaism, which has accomplished great things +for humanity in the past, has not yet played out its part, and, +therefore, may not perish. In short, the Jewish people lives because +it contains a living soul which refuses to separate from its +integument, and cannot be forced out of it by heavy trials and +misfortunes, such as would unfailingly inflict mortal injury upon less +sturdy organisms. + +This self-consciousness is the source from which the suffering Jewish +soul draws comfort. History speaks to it constantly through the mouth +of the great apostle who went forth from the midst of Israel eighteen +hundred years ago: "Call to remembrance the former days, in which, +after ye were enlightened, ye endured a great conflict of sufferings; +partly, being made a gazing-stock both by reproaches and afflictions; +and partly, becoming partakers with them that were so used.... Cast +not away therefore your boldness, which hath great recompense of +reward" (Epistle to the Hebrews, x, 32-34, 35). + +Jewish history, moreover, arouses in the Jew the desire to work +unceasingly at the task of perfecting himself. To direct his attention +to his glorious past, to the resplendent intellectual feats of his +ancestors, to their masterly skill in thinking and suffering, does not +lull him to sleep, does not awaken a dullard's complacency or hollow +self-conceit. On the contrary, it makes exacting demands upon him. +Jewish history admonishes the Jews: "_Noblesse oblige_. The +privilege of belonging to a people to whom the honorable title of the +'veteran of history' has been conceded, puts serious responsibilities +on your shoulders. You must demonstrate that you are worthy of your +heroic past. The descendants of teachers of religion and martyrs of +the faith dare not be insignificant, not to say wicked. If the long +centuries of wandering and misery have inoculated you with faults, +extirpate them in the name of the exalted moral ideals whose bearers +you were commissioned to be. If, in the course of time, elements out +of harmony with your essential being have fastened upon your mind, +cast them out, purify yourselves. In all places and at all times, in +joy and and in sorrow, you must aim to live for the higher, the +spiritual interests. But never may you deem yourselves perfect. If you +become faithless to these sacred principles, you sever the bonds that +unite you with the most vital elements of your past, with the first +cause of your national existence." + +The final lesson to be learned is that in the sunny days of mankind's +history, in which reason, justice, and philanthropic instinct had the +upper hand, the Jews steadfastly made common cause with the other +nations. Hand in hand with them, they trod the path leading to +perfection. But in the dark days, during the reign of rude force, +prejudice, and passion, of which they were the first victims, the Jews +retired from the world, withdrew into their shell, to await better +days. Union with mankind at large, on the basis of the spiritual and +the intellectual, the goal set up by the Jewish Prophets in their +sublime vision of the future (Isaiah, ch. ii, and Micah, ch. iv), is +the ultimate ideal of Judaism's noblest votaries. Will their radiant +hope ever attain to realization? If ever it should be realized,--and +it is incumbent upon us to believe that it will,--not a slight part of +the merits involved will be due to Jewish history. We have adverted to +the lofty moral and humanitarian significance of Jewish history in its +role as conciliator. With regard to one-half of Jewish history, this +conciliatory power is even now a well-established fact. The first part +of Jewish history, the Biblical part, is a source from which, for many +centuries, millions of human beings belonging to the most diverse +denominations have derived instruction, solace, and inspiration. It is +read with devotion by Christians in both hemispheres, in their houses +and their temples. Its heroes have long ago become types, incarnations +of great ideas. The events it relates serve as living ethical +formulas. But a time will come--perhaps it is not very far off--when +the second half of Jewish history, the record of the two thousand +years of the Jewish people's life after the Biblical period, will be +accorded the same treatment. This latter part of Jewish history is not +yet known, and many, in the thrall of prejudice, do not wish to know +it. But ere long it will be known and appreciated. For the thinking +portion of mankind it will be a source of uplifting moral and +philosophical teaching. The thousand years' martyrdom of the Jewish +people, its unbroken pilgrimage, its tragic fate, its teachers of +religion, its martyrs, philosophers, champions, this whole epic will +in days to come sink deep into the memory of men. It will speak to the +heart and the conscience of men, not merely to their curious mind. It +will secure respect for the silvery hair of the Jewish people, a +people of thinkers and sufferers. It will dispense consolation to the +afflicted, and by its examples of spiritual steadfastness and +self-denial encourage martyrs in their devotion. It is our firm +conviction that the time is approaching in which the second half of +Jewish history will be to the noblest part of _thinking_ humanity +what its first half has long been to _believing_ humanity, a +source of sublime moral truths. In this sense, Jewish history in its +entirety is the pledge of the spiritual union between the Jews and the +rest of the nations. + + + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of Jewish History, by S. M. Dubnow + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK JEWISH HISTORY *** + +***** This file should be named 7836-8.txt or 7836-8.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + http://www.gutenberg.org/7/8/3/7836/ + +Produced by David King, Charles Franks, and the Online +Distributed Proofreading Team + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License available with this file or online at + www.gutenberg.org/license. + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS', WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at 809 +North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887. Email +contact links and up to date contact information can be found at the +Foundation's web site and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit www.gutenberg.org/donate + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. +To donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For forty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. + diff --git a/7836-8.zip b/7836-8.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..3b7f423 --- /dev/null +++ b/7836-8.zip diff --git a/7836-h.zip b/7836-h.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..cb52cae --- /dev/null +++ b/7836-h.zip diff --git a/7836-h/7836-h.htm b/7836-h/7836-h.htm new file mode 100644 index 0000000..12c2444 --- /dev/null +++ b/7836-h/7836-h.htm @@ -0,0 +1,3639 @@ +<?xml version="1.0" encoding="iso-8859-1"?> + +<!DOCTYPE html + PUBLIC "-//W3C//DTD XHTML 1.0 Strict//EN" + "http://www.w3.org/TR/xhtml1/DTD/xhtml1-strict.dtd" > + +<html xmlns="http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml" lang="en"> + <head> + <title> + Jewish History, by S. M. Dubnow + </title> + <style type="text/css" xml:space="preserve"> + + body { margin:5%; background:#faebd0; text-align:justify} + P { text-indent: 1em; margin-top: .25em; margin-bottom: .25em; } + H1,H2,H3,H4,H5,H6 { text-align: center; margin-left: 15%; margin-right: 15%; } + hr { width: 50%; text-align: center;} + .foot { margin-left: 20%; margin-right: 20%; text-align: justify; text-indent: -3em; font-size: 90%; } + blockquote {font-size: 97%; font-style: italic; margin-left: 10%; margin-right: 10%;} + .mynote {background-color: #DDE; color: #000; padding: .5em; margin-left: 10%; margin-right: 10%; font-family: sans-serif; font-size: 95%;} + .toc { margin-left: 10%; margin-bottom: .75em;} + .toc2 { margin-left: 20%;} + div.fig { display:block; margin:0 auto; text-align:center; } + div.middle { margin-left: 20%; margin-right: 20%; text-align: justify; } + .figleft {float: left; margin-left: 0%; margin-right: 1%;} + .figright {float: right; margin-right: 0%; margin-left: 1%;} + .pagenum {display:inline; font-size: 70%; font-style:normal; + margin: 0; padding: 0; position: absolute; right: 1%; + text-align: right;} + pre { font-style: italic; font-size: 90%; margin-left: 10%;} + +</style> + </head> + <body> + + +<pre> + +The Project Gutenberg EBook of Jewish History, by S. M. Dubnow + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: Jewish History + +Author: S. M. Dubnow + + +Release Date: April, 2005 [EBook #7836] +This file was first posted on May 21, 2003 +Last Updated: May 8, 2013 + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ISO-8859-1 + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK JEWISH HISTORY *** + + + + +Text file produced by David King, Charles Franks, and the Online +Distributed Proofreading Team + +HTML file produced by David Widger + + + + +</pre> + + <div style="height: 8em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /><br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h1> + JEWISH HISTORY + </h1> + <h3> + AN ESSAY IN THE PHILOSOPHY<br /> OF HISTORY + </h3> + <p> + <br /> + </p> + <h2> + By S. M. Dubnow + </h2> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_PREF"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + PREFACE TO THE GERMAN TRANSLATION + </h2> + <p> + The author of the present essay, S. M. Dubnow, occupies a well-nigh + dominating position in Russian-Jewish literature as an historian and an + acute critic. His investigations into the history of the Polish-Russian + Jews, especially his achievements in the history of Chassidism, have been + of fundamental importance in these departments. What raises Mr. Dubnow far + above the status of the professional historian, and awakens the reader's + lively interest in him, is not so much the matter of his books, as the + manner of presentation. It is rare to meet with an historian in whom + scientific objectivity and thoroughness are so harmoniously combined with + an ardent temperament and plastic ability. Mr. Dubnow's scientific + activity, first and last, is a striking refutation of the widespread + opinion that identifies attractiveness of form in the work of a scholar + with superficiality of content. Even his strictly scientific + investigations, besides offering the scholar a wealth of new suggestions, + form instructive and entertaining reading matter for the educated layman. + In his critical essays, Mr. Dubnow shows himself to be possessed of keen + psychologic insight. By virtue of this quality of delicate perception, he + aims to assign to every historical fact its proper place in the line of + development, and so establish the bond between it and the general history + of mankind. This psychologic ability contributes vastly to the interest + aroused by Mr. Dubnow's historical works outside of the limited circle of + scholars. There is a passage in one of his books<a href="#linknote-1" + name="linknoteref-1" id="noteref-1"><small>1</small></a> in which, in his + incisive manner, he expresses his views on the limits and tasks of + historical writing. As the passage bears upon the methods employed in the + present essay, and, at the same time, is a characteristic specimen of our + author's style, I take the liberty of quoting: + </p> + <p> + "The popularization of history is by no means to be pursued to the + detriment of its severely scientific treatment. What is to be guarded + against is the notion that tedium is inseparable from the scientific + method. I have always been of the opinion that the dulness commonly looked + upon as the prerogative of scholarly inquiries, is not an inherent + attribute. In most cases it is conditioned, not by the nature of the + subject under investigation, but by the temper of the investigator. Often, + indeed, the tediousness of a learned disquisition is intentional: it is + considered one of the polite conventions of the academic guild, and by + many is identified with scientific thoroughness and profound learning.... + If, in general, deadening, hide-bound caste methods, not seldom the cover + for poverty of thought and lack of cleverness, are reprehensible, they are + doubly reprehensible in history. The history of a people is not a mere + mental discipline, like botany or mathematics, but a living science, a <i>magistra + vitae</i>, leading straight to national self-knowledge, and acting to a + certain degree upon the national character. History is a science <i>by</i> + the people, <i>for</i> the people, and, therefore, its place is the open + forum, not the scholar's musty closet. We relate the events of the past to + the people, not merely to a handful of archaeologists and numismaticians. + We work for national self-knowledge, not for our own intellectual + diversion." + </p> + <p> + These are the principles that have guided Mr. Dubnow in all his works, and + he has been true to them in the present essay, which exhibits in a + remarkably striking way the author's art of making "all things seem fresh + and new, important and attractive." New and important his essay + undoubtedly is. The author attempts, for the first time, a psychologic + characterization of Jewish history. He endeavors to demonstrate the inner + connection between events, and develop the ideas that underlie them, or, + to use his own expression, lay bare the soul of Jewish history, which + clothes itself with external events as with a bodily envelope. Jewish + history has never before been considered from this philosophic point of + view, certainly not in German literature. The present work, therefore, + cannot fail to prove stimulating. As for the poet's other requirement, + attractiveness, it is fully met by the work here translated. The qualities + of Mr. Dubnow's style, as described above, are present to a marked degree. + The enthusiasm flaming up in every line, coupled with his plastic, + figurative style, and his scintillating conceits, which lend vivacity to + his presentation, is bound to charm the reader. Yet, in spite of the racy + style, even the layman will have no difficulty in discovering that it is + not a clever journalist, an artificer of well-turned phrases, who is + speaking to him, but a scholar by profession, whose foremost concern is + with historical truth, and whose every statement rests upon accurate, + scientific knowledge; not a bookworm with pale, academic blood trickling + through his veins, but a man who, with unsoured mien, with fresh, buoyant + delight, offers the world the results laboriously reached in his study, + after all evidences of toil and moil have been carefully removed; who + derives inspiration from the noble and the sublime in whatever guise it + may appear, and who knows how to communicate his inspiration to others. + </p> + <p> + The translator lays this book of an accomplished and spirited historian + before the German public. He does so in the hope that it will shed new + light upon Jewish history even for professional scholars. He is confident + that in many to whom our unexampled past of four thousand years' duration + is now <i>terra incognita</i>, it will arouse enthusiastic interest, and + even to those who, like the translator himself, differ from the author in + religious views, it will furnish edifying and suggestive reading. J. F. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_PREF2"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + PREFACE TO THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION + </h2> + <p> + The English translation of Mr. Dubnow's Essay is based upon the authorized + German translation, which was made from the original Russian. It is + published under the joint auspices of the Jewish Publication Society of + America and the Jewish Historical Society of England. H. S. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <p> + <b>CONTENTS</b> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_PREF"> PREFACE TO THE GERMAN TRANSLATION </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_PREF2"> PREFACE TO THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_TOC"> DETAILED TABLE OF CONTENTS </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0003"> INTRODUCTORY NOTE </a> + </p> + <p> + <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0004"> <b>JEWISH HISTORY</b> </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0005"> I. THE RANGE OF JEWISH HISTORY </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0006"> II. THE CONTENT OF JEWISH HISTORY </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0007"> III. THE SIGNIFICANCE OF JEWISH HISTORY </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0008"> IV. THE HISTORICAL SYNTHESIS </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0009"> V. THE PRIMARY OR BIBLICAL PERIOD </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0010"> VI. THE SECONDARY OR SPIRITUAL-POLITICAL PERIOD </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0011"> VII. THE TERTIARY TALMUDIC OR NATIONAL-RELIGIOUS + PERIOD </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0012"> VIII. THE GAONIC PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE + ORIENTAL JEWS (500-980) </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0013"> IX. THE RABBINIC-PHILOSOPHICAL PERIOD, OR THE + HEGEMONY OF THE SPANISH JEWS </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0014"> X. THE RABBINIC-MYSTICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF + THE GERMAN-POLISH </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0015"> XI. THE MODERN PERIOD OF ENLIGHTENMENT (THE + NINETEENTH CENTURY) </a> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0016"> XII. THE TEACHINGS OF JEWISH HISTORY </a> + </p> + <p> + <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_FOOT"> FOOTNOTES: </a> + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_TOC"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + DETAILED TABLE OF CONTENTS + </h2> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_PREF"> PREFACE TO THE GERMAN TRANSLATION </a> + </p> + <p> + PREFACE TO THE GERMAN TRANSLATION <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0003"> INTRODUCTORY NOTE </a> + </p> + <p> + INTRODUCTORY NOTE <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0005"> I. THE RANGE OF JEWISH HISTORY </a> + </p> + <p> + I. THE RANGE OF JEWISH HISTORY <br /> Historical and Unhistorical Peoples + <br /> Three Groups of Nations <br /> The "Most Historical" People <br /> + Extent of Jewish History <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0006"> II. THE CONTENT OF JEWISH HISTORY </a> + </p> + <p> + II. THE CONTENT OF JEWISH HISTORY <br /> Two Periods of Jewish History + <br /> The Period of Independence <br /> The Election of the Jewish People + <br /> Priests and Prophets <br /> The Babylonian Exile and the Scribes + <br /> The Dispersion <br /> Jewish History and Universal History <br /> + Jewish History Characterized <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0007"> III. THE SIGNIFICANCE OF JEWISH HISTORY </a> + </p> + <p> + III. THE SIGNIFICANCE OF JEWISH HISTORY <br /> The National Aspect of + Jewish History <br /> The Historical Consciousness <br /> The National Idea + and National Feeling <br /> The Universal Aspect of Jewish History <br /> An + Historical Experiment <br /> A Moral Discipline <br /> Humanitarian + Significance of Jewish History <br /> Schleiden and George Eliot <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0008"> IV. THE HISTORICAL SYNTHESIS </a> + </p> + <p> + IV. THE HISTORICAL SYNTHESIS <br /> Three Primary Periods <br /> Four + Composite Periods <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0009"> V. THE PRIMARY OR BIBLICAL PERIOD </a> + </p> + <p> + V. THE PRIMARY OR BIBLICAL PERIOD <br /> Cosmic Origin of the Jewish + Religion <br /> Tribal Organization <br /> Egyptian Influence and + Experiences <br /> Moses <br /> Mosaism a Religious and Moral as well as a + Social and Political <br /> System <br /> National Deities <br /> The + Prophets and the two Kingdoms <br /> Judaism a Universal Religion <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0010"> VI. THE SECONDARY OR SPIRITUAL-POLITICAL PERIOD </a> + </p> + <p> + VI. THE SECONDARY OR SPIRITUAL-POLITICAL PERIOD <br /> Growth of National + Feeling <br /> Ezra and Nehemiah <br /> The Scribes <br /> Hellenism <br /> + The Maccabees <br /> Sadducees, Pharisees, and Essenes <br /> Alexandrian + Jews <br /> Christianity <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0011"> VII. THE TERTIARY TALMUDIC OR NATIONAL-RELIGIOUS + PERIOD </a> + </p> + <p> + VII. THE TERTIARY TALMUDIC OR NATIONAL-RELIGIOUS PERIOD <br /> The + Isolation of Jewry and Judaism <br /> The Mishna <br /> The Talmud <br /> + Intellectual Activity in Palestine and Babylonia <br /> The Agada and the + Midrash <br /> Unification of Judaism <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0012"> VIII. THE GAONIC PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE + ORIENTAL JEWS (500-980) </a> + </p> + <p> + VIII. THE GAONIC PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE ORIENTAL JEWS (500-980) + <br /> The Academies <br /> Islam <br /> Karaism <br /> Beginning of + Persecutions in Europe <br /> Arabic Civilization in Europe <br /> IX. THE + RABBINIC-PHILOSOPHICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE SPANISH JEWS + (980-1492) <br /> The Spanish Jews <br /> The Arabic-Jewish Renaissance + <br /> The Crusades and the Jews <br /> Degradation of the Jews in Christian + Europe <br /> The Provence <br /> The Lateran Council <br /> The Kabbala + <br /> Expulsion from Spain <br /> X. THE RABBINIC-MYSTICAL PERIOD, OR THE + HEGEMONY OF THE GERMAN-POLISH JEWS (1492-1789) <br /> The Humanists and the + Reformation <br /> Palestine an Asylum for Jews <br /> Messianic Belief and + Hopes <br /> Holland a Jewish Centre <br /> Poland and the Jews <br /> The + Rabbinical Authorities of Poland <br /> Isolation of the Polish Jews <br /> + Mysticism and the Practical Kabbala <br /> Chassidism <br /> Persecutions + and Morbid Piety <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0015"> XI. THE MODERN PERIOD OF ENLIGHTENMENT (THE + NINETEENTH CENTURY) </a> + </p> + <p> + XI. THE MODERN PERIOD OF ENLIGHTENMENT (THE NINETEENTH CENTURY) <br /> The + French Revolution <br /> The Jewish Middle Ages <br /> Spiritual and Civil + Emancipation <br /> The Successors of Mendelssohn <br /> Zunz and the + Science of Judaism <br /> The Modern Movements outside of Germany <br /> The + Jew in Russia <br /> His Regeneration <br /> Anti-Semitism and Judophobia + <br /> + </p> + <p class="toc"> + <a href="#link2H_4_0016"> XII. THE TEACHINGS OF JEWISH HISTORY </a> + </p> + <p> + XII. THE TEACHINGS OF JEWISH HISTORY <br /> Jewry a Spiritual Community + <br /> Jewry Indestructible <br /> The Creative Principle of Jewry <br /> The + Task of the Future <br /> The Jew and the Nations <br /> The Ultimate Ideal + <br /> <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0003"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + INTRODUCTORY NOTE + </h2> + <p> + What is Jewish History? In the first place, what does it offer as to + quantity and as to quality? What are its range and content, and what + distinguishes it in these two respects from the history of other nations? + Furthermore, what is the essential meaning, what the spirit, of Jewish + History? Or, to put the question in another way, to what general results + are we led by the aggregate of its facts, considered, not as a whole, but + genetically, as a succession of evolutionary stages in the consciousness + and education of the Jewish people? + </p> + <p> + If we could find precise answers to these several questions, they would + constitute a characterization of Jewish History as accurate as is + attainable. To present such a characterization succinctly is the purpose + of the following essay. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0004"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h1> + JEWISH HISTORY + </h1> + <h3> + AN ESSAY IN THE PHILOSOPHY OF HISTORY + </h3> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0005"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + I. THE RANGE OF JEWISH HISTORY + </h2> +<pre xml:space="preserve"> + Le peuple juif n'est pas seulement considérable par son + antiquité, mais il est encore singulier en sa durée, qui a + toujours continué depuis son origine jusqu'à maintenant ... + S'étendant depuis les premiers temps jusqu'aux derniers, + l'histoire des juifs enferme dans sa durée celle de toutes nos + histoires.—PASCAL, <i>Pensées</i>, II, 7. +</pre> + <p> + To make clear the range of Jewish history, it is necessary to set down a + few general, elementary definitions by way of introduction. + </p> + <p> + It has long been recognized that a fundamental difference exists between + historical and unhistorical peoples, a difference growing out of the fact + of the natural inequality between the various elements composing the human + race. Unhistorical is the attribute applied to peoples that have not yet + broken away, or have not departed very far, from the state of primitive + savagery, as, for instance, the barbarous races of Asia and Africa who + were the prehistoric ancestors of the Europeans, or the obscure, untutored + tribes of the present, like the Tartars and the Kirghiz. Unhistorical + peoples, then, are ethnic groups of all sorts that are bereft of a + distinctive, spiritual individuality, and have failed to display normal, + independent capacity for culture. The term historical, on the other hand, + is applied to the nations that have had a conscious, purposeful history of + appreciable duration; that have progressed, stage by stage, in their + growth and in the improvement of their mode and their views of life; that + have demonstrated mental productivity of some sort, and have elaborated + principles of civilization and social life more or less rational; nations, + in short, representing not only zoologic, but also spiritual types.<a + href="#linknote-2" name="linknoteref-2" id="noteref-2"><small>2</small></a> + </p> + <p> + Chronologically considered, these latter nations, of a higher type, are + usually divided into three groups: 1, the most ancient civilized peoples + of the Orient, such as the Chinese, the Hindoos, the Egyptians, the + Chaldeans; 2, the ancient or classic peoples of the Occident, the Greeks + and the Romans; and 3, the modern peoples, the civilized nations of Europe + and America of the present day. The most ancient peoples of the Orient, + standing "at the threshold of history," were the first heralds of a + religious consciousness and of moral principles. In hoary antiquity, when + most of the representatives of the human kind were nothing more than a + peculiar variety of the class mammalia, the peoples called the most + ancient brought forth recognized forms of social life and a variety of + theories of living of fairly far-reaching effect. All these + culture-bearers of the Orient soon disappeared from the surface of + history. Some (the Chaldeans, Phoenicians, and Egyptians) were washed away + by the flood of time, and their remnants were absorbed by younger and more + vigorous peoples. Others (the Hindoos and Persians) relapsed into a + semi-barbarous state; and a third class (the Chinese) were arrested in + their growth, and remained fixed in immobility. The best that the antique + Orient had to bequeath in the way of spiritual possessions fell to the + share of the classic nations of the West, the Greeks and the Romans. They + greatly increased the heritage by their own spiritual achievements, and so + produced a much more complex and diversified civilization, which has + served as the substratum for the further development of the better part of + mankind. Even the classic nations had to step aside as soon as their + historical mission was fulfilled. They left the field free for the younger + nations, with greater capability of living, which at that time had barely + worked their way up to the beginnings of a civilization. One after the + other, during the first two centuries of the Christian era, the members of + this European family of nations appeared in the arena of history. They + form the kernel of the civilized part of mankind at the present day. + </p> + <p> + Now, if we examine this accepted classification with a view to finding the + place belonging to the Jewish people in the chronological series, we meet + with embarrassing difficulties, and finally arrive at the conclusion that + its history cannot be accommodated within the compass of the + classification. Into which of the three historical groups mentioned could + the Jewish people be put? Are we to call it one of the most ancient, one + of the ancient, or one of the modern nations? It is evident that it may + lay claim to the first description, as well as to the second and the last. + In company with the most ancient nations of the Orient, the Jewish people + stood at the "threshold of history." It was the contemporary of the + earliest civilized nations, the Egyptians and the Chaldeans. In those + remote days it created and spread a religious world-idea underlying an + exalted social and moral system surpassing everything produced in this + sphere by its Oriental contemporaries. Again, with the classical Greeks + and Romans, it forms the celebrated historical triad universally + recognized as the source of all great systems of civilization. Finally, in + fellowship with the nations of to-day, it leads an historical life, + striding onward in the path of progress without stay or interruption. + Deprived of political independence, it nevertheless continues to fill a + place in the world of thought as a distinctly marked spiritual + individuality, as one of the most active and intelligent forces. How, + then, are we to denominate this omnipresent people, which, from the first + moment of its historical existence up to our days, a period of thirty-five + hundred years, has been developing continuously. In view of this + Methuselah among the nations, whose life is co-extensive with the whole of + history, how are we to dispose of the inevitable barriers between "the + most ancient" and "the ancient," between "the ancient" and "the modern" + nations—the fateful barriers which form the milestones on the path + of the historical peoples, and which the Jewish people has more than once + overstepped? + </p> + <p> + A definition of the Jewish people must needs correspond to the aggregate + of the concepts expressed by the three group-names, most ancient, ancient, + and modern. The only description applicable to it is "the historical + nation of all times," a description bringing into relief the contrast + between it and all other nations of modern and ancient times, whose + historical existence either came to an end in days long past, or began at + a date comparatively recent. And granted that there are "historical" and + "unhistorical" peoples, then it is beyond dispute that the Jewish people + deserves to be called "the most historical" (<i>historicissimus</i>). If + the history of the world be conceived as a circle, then Jewish history + occupies the position of the diameter, the line passing through its + centre, and the history of every other nation is represented by a chord + marking off a smaller segment of the circle. The history of the Jewish + people is like an axis crossing the history of mankind from one of its + poles to the other. As an unbroken thread it runs through the ancient + civilization of Egypt and Mesopotamia, down to the present-day culture of + France and Germany. Its divisions are measured by thousands of years. + </p> + <p> + Jewish history, then, in its range, or, better, in its duration, presents + an unique phenomenon. It consists of the longest series of events ever + recorded in the annals of a single people. To sum up its peculiarity + briefly, it embraces a period of thirty-five hundred years, and in all + this vast extent it suffers no interruption. At every point it is alive, + full of sterling content. Presently we shall see that in respect to + content, too, it is distinguished by exceptional characteristics. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0006"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + II. THE CONTENT OF JEWISH HISTORY + </h2> + <p> + From the point of view of content, or qualitative structure, Jewish + history, it is well known, falls into two parts. The dividing point + between the two parts is the moment in which the Jewish state collapsed + irretrievably under the blows of the Roman Empire (70 C. E.). The first + half deals with the vicissitudes of a nation, which, though frequently at + the mercy of stronger nations, still maintained possession of its + territory and government, and was ruled by its own laws. In the second + half, we encounter the history of a people without a government, more than + that, without a land, a people stripped of all the tangible accompaniments + of nationality, and nevertheless successful in preserving its spiritual + unity, its originality, complete and undiminished. + </p> + <p> + At first glance, Jewish history during the period of independence seems to + be but slightly different from the history of other nations. Though not + without individual coloring, there are yet the same wars and intestine + disturbances, the same political revolutions and dynastic quarrels, the + same conflicts between the classes of the people, the same warring between + economical interests. This is only a surface view of Jewish history. If we + pierce to its depths, and scrutinize the processes that take place in its + penetralia, we perceive that even in the early period there were latent + within it great powers of intellect, universal principles, which, visibly + or invisibly, determined the course of events. We have before us not a + simple political or racial entity, but, to an eminent degree, "a spiritual + people." The national development is based upon an all-pervasive religious + tradition, which lives in the soul of the people as the Sinaitic + Revelation, the Law of Moses. With this holy tradition, embracing a + luminous theory of life and an explicit code of morality and social + converse, was associated the idea of the election of the Jewish people, of + its peculiar spiritual mission. "And ye shall be unto me a kingdom of + priests and a holy nation" is the figurative expression of this ideal + calling. It conveys the thought that the Israelitish people as a whole, + without distinction of rank and regardless of the social prominence of + individuals, has been called to guide the other nations toward sublime + moral and religious principles, and to officiate for them, the laity as it + were, in the capacity of priests. This exalted ideal would never have been + reached, if the development of the Jewish people had lain along hackneyed + lines; if, like the Egyptians and the Chaldeans, it had had an inflexible + caste of priests, who consider the guardianship of the spiritual treasures + of the nation the exclusive privilege of their estate, and strive to keep + the mass of the people in crass ignorance. For a time, something + approaching this condition prevailed among the Jews. The priests descended + from Aaron, with the Temple servants (the Levites), formed a priestly + class, and played the part of authoritative bearers of the religious + tradition. But early, in the very infancy of the nation, there arose by + the side of this official, aristocratic hierarchy, a far mightier + priesthood, a democratic fraternity, seeking to enlighten the whole + nation, and inculcating convictions that make for a consciously held aim. + The Prophets were the real and appointed executors of the holy command + enjoining the "conversion" of all Jews into "a kingdom of priests and a + holy nation." Their activity cannot be paralleled in the whole range of + the world's history. They were not priests, but popular educators and + popular teachers. They were animated by the desire to instil into every + soul a deeply religious consciousness, to ennoble every heart by moral + aspirations, to indoctrinate every individual with an unequivocal theory + of life, to inspire every member of the nation with lofty ideals. Their + work did not fail to leave its traces. Slowly but deeply idealism entered + into the very pith and marrow of the national consciousness. This + consciousness gained in strength and amplitude century by century, showing + itself particularly in the latter part of the first period, after the + crisis known as "the Babylonian Exile." Thanks to the exertions of the <i>Soferim</i> + (Scribes), directed toward the broadest popularization of the Holy + Writings, and constituting the formal complement to the work of the + Prophets, spiritual activity became an integral part of Jewish national + life. In the closing centuries of its political existence, the Jewish + people received its permanent form. There was imposed upon it the + unmistakable hallmark of spirituality that has always identified it in the + throng of the nations. Out of the bosom of Judaism went forth the religion + that in a short time ran its triumphant course through the whole ancient + world, transforming races of barbarians into civilized beings. It was the + fulfilment of the Prophetical promise—that the nations would walk in + the light of Israel. + </p> + <p> + At the very moment when the strength and fertility of the Jewish mind + reached the culminating point, occurred a political revolution—the + period of homeless wandering began. It seemed as though, before scattering + the Jewish people to all ends of the earth, the providence of history + desired to teach it a final lesson, to take with it on its way. It seemed + to say: "Now you may go forth. Your character has been sufficiently + tempered; you can bear the bitterest of hardships. You are equipped with + an inexhaustible store of energy, and you can live for centuries, yea, for + thousands of years, under conditions that would prove the bane of other + nations in less than a single century. State, territory, army, the + external attributes of national power, are for you superfluous luxury. Go + out into the world to prove that a people can continue to live without + these attributes, solely and alone through strength of spirit welding its + widely scattered particles into one firm organism!"—And the Jewish + people went forth and proved it. + </p> + <p> + This "proof" adduced by Jewry at the cost of eighteen centuries of + privation and suffering, forms the characteristic feature of the second + half of Jewish history, the period of homelessness and dispersion. + Uprooted from its political soil, national life displayed itself on + intellectual fields exclusively. "To think and to suffer" became the + watchword of the Jewish people, not merely because forced upon it by + external circumstances beyond its control, but chiefly because it was + conditioned by the very disposition of the people, by its national + inclinations. The extraordinary mental energy that had matured the Bible + and the old writings in the first period, manifested itself in the second + period in the encyclopedic productions of the Talmudists, in the religious + philosophy of the middle ages, in Rabbinism, in the Kabbala, in mysticism, + and in science. The spiritual discipline of the school came to mean for + the Jew what military discipline is for other nations. His remarkable + longevity is due, I am tempted to say, to the acrid spiritual brine in + which he was cured. In its second half, the originality of Jewish history + consists indeed, in the circumstance that it is the only history stripped + of every active political element. There are no diplomatic artifices, no + wars, no campaigns, no unwarranted encroachments backed by armed force + upon the rights of other nations, nothing of all that constitutes the + chief content—the monotonous and for the most part idea-less content—of + many other chapters in the history of the world. Jewish history presents + the chronicle of an ample spiritual life, a gallery of pictures + representing national scenes. Before our eyes passes a long procession of + facts from the fields of intellectual effort, of morality, religion, and + social converse. Finally, the thrilling drama of Jewish martyrdom is + unrolled to our astonished gaze. If the inner life and the social and + intellectual development of a people form the kernel of history, and + politics and occasional wars are but its husk,<a href="#linknote-3" + name="linknoteref-3" id="noteref-3"><small>3</small></a> then certainly the + history of the Jewish diaspora is all kernel. In contrast with the history + of other nations it describes, not the accidental deeds of princes and + generals, not external pomp and physical prowess, but the life and + development of a whole people. It gives heartrending expression to the + spiritual strivings of a nation whose brow is resplendent with the thorny + crown of martyrdom. It breathes heroism of mind that conquers bodily pain. + In a word, Jewish history is history sublimated.<a href="#linknote-4" + name="linknoteref-4" id="noteref-4"><small>4</small></a> + </p> + <p> + In spite of the noteworthy features that raise Jewish history above the + level of the ordinary, and assign it a peculiar place, it is nevertheless + not isolated, not severed from the history of mankind. Rather is it most + intimately interwoven with world-affairs at every point throughout its + whole extent. As the diameter, Jewish history is again and again + intersected by the chords of the historical circle. The fortunes of the + pilgrim people scattered in all the countries of the civilized world are + organically connected with the fortunes of the most representative nations + and states, and with manifold tendencies of human thought. The bond + uniting them is twofold: in the times when the powers of darkness and + fanaticism held sway, the Jews were amenable to the "physical" influence + exerted by their neighbors in the form of persecutions, infringements of + the liberty of conscience, inquisitions, violence of every sort; and + during the prevalence of enlightment and humanity, the Jews were acted + upon by the intellectual and cultural stimulus proceeding from the peoples + with whom they entered into close relations. Momentary aberrations and + reactionary incidents are not taken into account here. On its side, Jewry + made its personality felt among the nations by its independent, + intellectual activity, its theory of life, its literature, by the very + fact, indeed, of its ideal staunchness and tenacity, its peculiar + historical physiognomy. From this reciprocal relation issued a great cycle + of historical events and spiritual currents, making the past of the Jewish + people an organic constituent of the past of all that portion of mankind + which has contributed to the treasury of human thought. + </p> + <p> + We see, then, that in reference to content Jewish history is unique in + both its halves. In the first "national" period, it is the history of a + people to which the epithet "peculiar" has been conceded, a people which + has developed under the influence of exceptional circumstances, and + finally attained to so high a degree of spiritual perfection and fertility + that the creation of a new religious theory of life, which eventually + gained universal supremacy, neither exhausted its resources nor ended its + activity. Not only did it continue to live upon its vast store of + spiritual energy, but day by day it increased the store. In the second + "lackland" half, it is the instructive history of a scattered people, + organically one, in spite of dispersion, by reason of its unshaken ideal + traditions; a people accepting misery and hardship with stoic calm, + combining the characteristics of the thinker with those of the sufferer, + and eking out existence under conditions which no other nation has found + adequate, or, indeed, can ever find adequate. The account of the people as + teacher of religion—this is the content of the first half of Jewish + history; the account of the people as thinker, stoic, and sufferer—this + is the content of the second half of Jewish history. + </p> + <p> + A summing up of all that has been said in this and the previous chapter + proves true the statement with which we began, that Jewish history, in + respect to its quantitative dimensions as well as its qualitative + structure, is to the last degree distinctive and presents a phenomenon of + undeniable uniqueness. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0007"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + III. THE SIGNIFICANCE OF JEWISH HISTORY + </h2> + <p> + We turn now to the question of the significance to be attached to Jewish + history. In view of its peculiar qualities, what has it to offer to the + present generation and to future generations as a subject of study and + research? + </p> + <p> + The significance of Jewish history is twofold. It is at once national and + universal. At present the fulcrum of Jewish national being lies in the + historical consciousness. In the days of antiquity, the Jews were welded + into a single united nation by the triple agencies of state, race, and + religion, the complete array of material and spiritual forces directed to + one point. Later, in the period of homelessness and dispersion, it was + chiefly religious consciousness that cemented Jewry into a whole, and + replaced the severed political bond as well as the dulled racial instinct, + which is bound to go on losing in keenness in proportion to the degree of + removal from primitive conditions and native soil. In our days, when the + liberal movements leavening the whole of mankind, if they have not + completely shattered the religious consciousness, have at least, in an + important section of Jewry, effected a change in its form; when abrupt + differences of opinion with regard to questions of faith and cult are + asserting their presence; and traditional Judaism developed in historical + sequence is proving powerless to hold together the diverse factors of the + national organism,—in these days the keystone of national unity + seems to be the historical consciousness. Composed alike of physical, + intellectual, and moral elements, of habits and views, of emotions and + impressions nursed into being and perfection by the hereditary instinct + active for thousands of years, this historical consciousness is a + remarkably puzzling and complex psychic phenomenon. By our common memory + of a great, stirring past and heroic deeds on the battle-fields of the + spirit, by the exalted historical mission allotted to us, by our + thorn-strewn pilgrim's path, our martyrdom assumed for the sake of our + principles, by such moral ties, we Jews, whether consciously or + unconsciously, are bound fast to one another. As Renan well says: "Common + sorrow unites men more closely than common joy." A long chain of + historical traditions is cast about us all like a strong ring. Our + wonderful, unparalleled past attracts us with magnetic power. In the + course of centuries, as generation followed generation, similarity of + historical fortunes produced a mass of similar impressions which have + crystallized, and have thrown off the deposit that may be called "the + Jewish national soul." This is the soil in which, deep down, lies + imbedded, as an unconscious element, the Jewish national <i>feeling</i>, + and as a conscious element, the Jewish national <i>idea</i>. + </p> + <p> + It follows that the Jewish national idea and the national feeling + connected with it have their origin primarily in the historical + consciousness, in a certain complex of ideas and psychic predispositions. + These ideas and predispositions, the deposit left by the aggregate of + historical impressions, are of necessity the common property of the whole + nation, and they can be developed and quickened to a considerable degree + by a renewal of the impressions through the study of history. Upon the + knowledge of history, then, depends the strength of the national + consciousness.<a href="#linknote-5" name="linknoteref-5" id="noteref-5"><small>5</small></a> + </p> + <p> + But over and above its national significance, Jewish history, we repeat, + possesses universal significance. Let us, in the first place, examine its + value for science and philosophy. Inasmuch as it is pre-eminently a + chronicle of ideas and spiritual movements, Jewish history affords the + philosopher or psychologist material for observation of the most important + and useful kind. The study of other, mostly dull chapters of universal + history has led to the fixing of psychologic or sociologic theses, to the + working out of comprehensive philosophic systems, to the determination of + general laws. Surely it follows without far-fetched proof, that in some + respects the chapter dealing with Jewish history must supply material of + the most original character for such theses and philosophies. If it is + true, as the last chapter set out to demonstrate, that Jewish history is + distinguished by sharply marked and peculiar features, and refuses to + accommodate itself to conventional forms, then its content must have an + original contribution to make to philosophy. It does not admit of a doubt + that the study of Jewish history would yield new propositions appertaining + to the philosophy of history and the psychology of nations, hitherto + overlooked by inquirers occupied with the other divisions of universal + history. Inductive logic lays down a rule for ascertaining the law of a + phenomenon produced by two or more contributory causes. By means of what + might be called a laboratory experiment, the several causes must be + disengaged from one another, and the effect of each observed by itself. + Thus it becomes possible to arrive with mathematical precision at the + share of each cause in the result achieved by several co-operating causes. + This method of difference, as it is called, is available, however, only + for a limited number of phenomena, only for phenomena in the department of + the natural sciences. It is in the nature of the case that mental and + spiritual phenomena, though they may be observed, cannot be artificially + reproduced. Now, in one respect, Jewish history affords the advantages of + an arranged experiment. The historical life of ordinary nations, such + nations as are endowed with territory and are organized into a state, is a + complete intermingling of the political with the spiritual element. + Totally ignorant as we are of the development either would have assumed, + had it been dissevered from the other, the laws governing each of the + elements singly can be discovered only approximately. Jewish history, in + which the two elements have for many centuries been completely + disentangled from each other, presents a natural experiment, with the + advantage of artificial exclusions, rendering possible the determination + of the laws of spiritual phenomena with far greater scientific exactitude + than the laws of phenomena that result from several similar causes. + </p> + <p> + Besides this high value for the purposes of science, this fruitful + suggestiveness for philosophic thought, Jewish history, as compared with + the history of other nations, enjoys another distinction in its capacity + to exercise an ennobling influence upon the heart. Nothing so exalts and + refines human nature as the contemplation of moral steadfastness, the + history of the trials of a martyr who has fought and suffered for his + convictions. At bottom, the second half of Jewish history is nothing but + this. The effective educational worth of the Biblical part of Jewish + history is disputed by none. It is called "sacred" history, and he who + acquires a knowledge of it is thought to advance the salvation of his + soul. Only a very few, however, recognize the profound, moral content of + the second half of Jewish history, the history of the diaspora. Yet, by + reason of its exceptional qualities and intensely tragic circumstances, it + is beyond all others calculated to yield edification to a notable degree. + The Jewish people is deserving of attention not only in the time when it + displayed its power and enjoyed its independence, but as well in the + period of its weakness and oppression, during which it was compelled to + purchase spiritual development by constant sacrifice of self. A thinker + crowned with thorns demands no less veneration than a thinker with the + laurel wreath upon his brow. The flame issuing from the funeral pile on + which martyrs die an heroic death for their ideas is, in its way, as + awe-inspiring as the flame from Sinai's height. With equal force, though + by different methods, both touch the heart, and arouse the moral + sentiment. Biblical Israel the celebrated—medieval Judah the + despised—it is one and the same people, judged variously in the + various phases of its historical life. If Israel bestowed upon mankind a + religious theory of life, Judah gave it a thrilling example of tenacious + vitality and power of resistance for the sake of conviction. This + uninterrupted life of the spirit, this untiring aspiration for the higher + and the better in the domain of religious thought, philosophy, and + science, this moral intrepidity in night and storm and in despite of all + the blows of fortune—is it not an imposing, soul-stirring spectacle? + The inexpressible tragedy of the Jewish historical life is unfailing in + its effect upon a susceptible heart.<a href="#linknote-6" name="linknoteref-6" + id="noteref-6"><small>6</small></a> The wonderful exhibition of spirit + triumphant, subduing the pangs of the flesh, must move every heart, and + exercise uplifting influence upon the non-Jew no less than upon the Jew. + </p> + <p> + For non-Jews a knowledge of Jewish history may, under certain conditions, + come to have another, an humanitarian significance. It is inconceivable + that the Jewish people should be held in execration by those acquainted + with the course of its history, with its tragic and heroic past.<a + href="#linknote-7" name="linknoteref-7" id="noteref-7"><small>7</small></a> + Indeed, so far as Jew-haters by profession are concerned, it is running a + risk to recommend the study of Jewish history to them, without adding a + word of caution. Its effect upon them might be disastrous. They might find + themselves cured of their modern disease, and in the possession of ideas + that would render worthless their whole stock in trade. Verily, he must + have fallen to the zero-point of anti-Semitic callousness who is not + thrilled through and through by the lofty fortitude, the saint-like + humility, the trustful resignation to the will of God, the stoic firmness, + laid bare by the study of Jewish history. The tribute of respect cannot be + readily withheld from him to whom the words of the poet<a href="#linknote-8" + name="linknoteref-8" id="noteref-8"><small>8</small></a> are applicable: + </p> +<pre xml:space="preserve"> + "To die was not his hope; he fain + Would live to think and suffer pain." +</pre> + <p> + When, in days to come, the curtain rises upon the touching tragedy of + Jewish history, revealing it to the astonished eye of a modern generation, + then, perhaps, hearts will be attuned to tenderness, and on the ruins of + national hostility will be enthroned mutual love, growing out of mutual + understanding and mutual esteem. And who can tell—perhaps Jewish + history will have a not inconsiderable share in the spiritual change that + is to annihilate national intolerance, the modern substitute for the + religious bigotry of the middle ages. In this case, the future task of + Jewish history will prove as sublime as was the mission of the Jewish + people in the past. The latter consisted in the spread of the dogma of the + unity of creation; the former will contribute indirectly to the + realization of the not yet accepted dogma of the unity of the human race. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0008"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + IV. THE HISTORICAL SYNTHESIS + </h2> + <p> + To define the scope of Jewish history, its content and its significance, + or its place among scientific pursuits, disposes only of the formal part + of the task we have set ourselves. The central problem is to unfold the + meaning of Jewish history, to discover the principle toward which its + diversified phenomena converge, to state the universal laws and + philosophic inferences deducible from the peculiar course of its events. + If we liken history to an organic being, then the skeleton of facts is its + body, and the soul is the spiritual bond that unites the facts into a + whole, that conveys the meaning, the psychologic essence, of the facts. It + becomes our duty, then, to unbare the soul of Jewish history, or, in + scientific parlance, to construct, on the basis of the facts, the + synthesis of the whole of Jewish national life. To this end, we must pass + in review, by periods and epochs, one after another, the most important + groups of historical events, the most noteworthy currents in life and + thought that tell of the stages in the development of Jewry and of + Judaism. Exhaustive treatment of the philosophical synthesis of a history + extending over three thousand years is possible only in a voluminous work. + In an essay like the present it can merely be sketched in large outline, + or painted in miniature. We cannot expect to do more than state a series + of general principles substantiated by the most fundamental arguments. + Complete demonstration of each of the principles must be sought in the + annals that recount the events of Jewish history in detail. + </p> + <p> + The historical synthesis reduces itself, then, to uncovering the + psychologic processes of national development. The object before us to be + studied is the national spirit undergoing continuous evolution during + thousands of years. Our task is to arrive at the laws underlying this + growth. We shall reach our goal by imitating the procedure of the + geologist, who divides the mass of the earth into its several strata or + formations. In Jewish history there may be distinguished three chief + stratifications answering to its first three periods, the Biblical period, + the period of the Second Temple, and the Talmudic period. The later + periods are nothing more than these same formations combined in various + ways, with now and then the addition of new strata. Of the composite + periods there are four, which arrange themselves either according to + hegemonies, the countries in which at given times lay the centre of + gravity of the scattered Jewish people, or according to the intellectual + currents there predominant. + </p> + <p> + This, then, is our scheme: + </p> +<pre xml:space="preserve"> + I. The chief formations: + a) The primary or Biblical period. + b) The secondary or spiritual-political period + (the period of the Second Temple, 538 + B. C. E. to 70 C.E.) + c) The tertiary or national-religious period + (the Talmudic period, 70-500). + + II. The composite formations: + a) The Gaonic period, or the hegemony of + the Oriental Jews (500-980). + b) The Rabbinic-philosophical period, or the + hegemony of the Spanish Jews (980-1492). + c) The Rabbinic-mystical period, or the hegemony + of the German-Polish Jews + (1492-1789). + d) The modern period of enlightenment (the + nineteenth century). +</pre> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0009"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + V. THE PRIMARY OR BIBLICAL PERIOD + </h2> + <p> + In the daybreak of history, the hoary days when seeming and reality merge + into each other, and the outlines of persons and things fade into the + surrounding mist, the picture of a nomad people, moving from the deserts + of Arabia in the direction of Mesopotamia and Western Asia, detaches + itself clear and distinct from the dim background. The tiny tribe, a + branch of the Semitic race, bears a peculiar stamp of its own. A shepherd + people, always living in close touch with nature, it yet resists the + potent influence of the natural phenomena, which, as a rule, entrap + primitive man, and make him the bond-slave of the visible and material. + Tent life has attuned these Semitic nomads to contemplativeness. In the + endless variety of the phenomena of nature, they seek to discover a single + guiding power. They entertain an obscure presentiment of the existence of + an invisible, universal soul animating the visible, material universe. The + intuition is personified in the Patriarch Abraham, who, according to + Biblical tradition, held communion with God, when, on the open field, "he + looked up toward heaven, and counted the stars," or when, "at the setting + of the sun, he fell into benumbing sleep, and terror seized upon him by + reason of the impenetrable darkness." Here we have a clear expression of + the original, purely cosmical character of the Jewish religion. + </p> + <p> + There was no lack of human influence acting from without. Chaldea, which + the peculiar Semitic shepherds crossed in their pilgrimage, presented them + with notions from its rich mythology and cosmogony. The natives of Syria + and Canaan, among whom in the course of time the Abrahamites settled, + imparted to them many of their religious views and customs. Nevertheless, + the kernel of their pure original theory remained intact. The patriarchal + mode of life, admirable in its simplicity, continued to hold its own + within the circle of the firmly-knitted tribe. It was in Canaan, however, + that the shepherd people hailing from Arabia showed the first signs of + approaching disintegration. Various tribal groups, like Moab and Ammon, + consolidated themselves. They took permanent foothold in the land, and + submitted with more or less readiness to the influences exerted by the + indigenous peoples. The guardianship of the sublime traditions of the + tribe remained with one group alone, the "sons of Jacob" or the "sons of + Israel," so named from the third Patriarch Jacob. To this group of the + Israelites composed of smaller, closely united divisions, a special + mission was allotted; its development was destined to lie along peculiar + lines. The fortunes awaiting it were distinctive, and for thousands of + years have filled thinking and believing mankind with wondering + admiration. + </p> + <p> + Great characters are formed under the influence of powerful impressions, + of violent convulsions, and especially under the influence of suffering. + The Israelites early passed through their school of suffering in Egypt. + The removal of the sons of Jacob from the banks of the Jordan to those of + the Nile was of decisive importance for the progress of their history. + When the patriarchal Israelitish shepherds encountered the old, highly + complex culture of the Egyptians, crystallized into fixed forms even at + that early date, it was like the clash between two opposing electric + currents. The pure conception of God, of <i>Elohim</i>, as of the spirit + informing and supporting the universe, collided with the blurred system of + heathen deities and crass idolatry. The simple cult of the shepherds, + consisting of a few severely plain ceremonies, transmitted from generation + to generation, was confronted with the insidious, coarsely sensual animal + worship of the Egyptians. The patriarchal customs of the Israelites were + brought into marked contrast with the vices of a corrupt civilization. + Sound in body and soul, the son of nature suddenly found himself in + unsavory surroundings fashioned by culture, in which he was as much + despised as the inoffensive nomad is by "civilized" man of settled habit. + The scorn had a practical result in the enslavement of the Israelites by + the Pharaohs. Association with the Egyptians acted as a force at once of + attraction and of repulsion. The manners and customs of the natives could + not fail to leave an impression upon the simple aliens, and invite + imitation on their part. On the other hand, the whole life of the + Egyptians, their crude notions of religion, and their immoral ways, were + calculated to inspire the more enlightened among the Israelites with + disgust. The hostility of the Egyptians toward the "intruders," and the + horrible persecutions in which it expressed itself, could not but bring + out more aggressively the old spiritual opposition between the two races. + The antagonism between them was the first influence to foster the germ of + Israel's national consciousness, the consciousness of his peculiar + character, his individuality. This early intimation of a national + consciousness was weak. It manifested itself only in the chosen few. But + it existed, and the time was appointed when, under more favorable + conditions, it would develop, and display the extent of its power. + </p> + <p> + This consciousness it was that inspired the activity of Moses, Israel's + teacher and liberator. He was penetrated alike by national and religious + feeling, and his desire was to impart both national and religious feeling + to his brethren. The fact of national redemption he connected with the + fact of religious revelation. "I am the Lord thy God who have brought thee + forth out of the land of Egypt" was proclaimed from Sinai. The God-idea + was nationalized. Thenceforth "Eternal" became the name peculiar to the + God of Israel. He was, indeed, the same <i>Elohim</i>, the Creator of the + world and its Guide, who had been dimly discerned by the spiritual vision + of the Patriarchs. At the same time He was the special God of the + Israelitish nation, the only nation that avouched Him with a full and + undivided heart, the nation chosen by God Himself to carry out, alone, His + sublime plans.<a href="#linknote-9" name="linknoteref-9" id="noteref-9"><small>9</small></a> + In his wanderings, Israel became acquainted with the chaotic religious + systems of other nations. Seeing to what they paid the tribute of divine + adoration, he could not but be dominated by the consciousness that he + alone from of old had been the exponent of the religious idea in its + purity. The resolution must have ripened within him to continue for all + time to advocate and cherish this idea. From that moment Israel was + possessed of a clear theory of life in religion and morality, and of a + definite aim pursued with conscious intent. + </p> + <p> + Its originators designed that this Israelitish conception of life should + serve not merely theoretically, as the basis of religious doctrine, but + also practically, as the starting point of legislation. It was to be + realized in the daily walks of the people, which at this very time + attained to political independence. Sublime religious conceptions were not + to be made the content of a visionary creed, the subject of dreamy + contemplation, but, in the form of perspicuous guiding principles, were to + control all spheres of individual and social life. Men must beware of + looking upon religion as an ideal to be yearned for, it should be an ideal + to be applied directly, day by day, to practical contingencies. In + "Mosaism," so-called, the religious and the ethical are intimately + interwoven with the social and the political. The chief dogmas of creed + are stated as principles shaping practical life. For instance, the exalted + idea of One God applied to social life produces the principle of the + equality of all men before the One Supreme Power, a principle on which the + whole of Biblical legislation is built. The commands concerning love of + neighbor, the condemnation of slavery, the obligation to aid the poor, + humane treatment of the stranger, sympathy and compassion with every + living being—all these lofty injunctions ensue as inevitable + consequences from the principle of equality. Biblical legislation is + perhaps the only example of a political and social code based, not upon + abstract reasoning alone, but also upon the requirements of the feelings, + upon the finest impulses of the human soul. By the side of formal right + and legality, it emphasizes, and, in a series of precepts, makes tangible, + the principle of justice and humanity. The Mosaic law is a "propaganda by + deed." Everywhere it demands active, more than passive, morality. Herein, + in this elevated characteristic, this vital attribute, consists the chief + source of the power of Mosaism. The same characteristic, to be sure, + prevented it from at once gaining ground in the national life. It + established itself only gradually, after many fluctuations and errors. In + the course of the centuries, and keeping pace with the growth of the + national consciousness, it was cultivated and perfected in detail. + </p> + <p> + The conquest of Canaan wrought a radical transformation in the life of the + Israelitish people. The acquiring of national territory supplied firm + ground for the development and manifold application of the principles of + Mosaism. At first, however, advance was out of the question. The mass of + the people had not reached the degree of spiritual maturity requisite for + the espousal of principles constituting an exalted theory of life. It + could be understood and represented only by a thoughtful minority, which + consisted chiefly of Aaronites and Levites, together forming a priestly + estate, though not a hierarchy animated by the isolating spirit of caste + that flourished among all the other peoples of the Orient. The populace + discovered only the ceremonial side of the religion; its kernel was hidden + from their sight. Defective spiritual culture made the people susceptible + to alien influences, to notions more closely akin to its understanding. + Residence in Canaan, among related Semitic tribes that had long before + separated from the Israelites, and adopted altogether different views and + customs, produced a far greater metamorphosis in the character of the + Israelites than the sojourn in Egypt. After the first flush of victory, + when the unity of the Israelitish people had been weakened by the + particularistic efforts of several of the tribes, the spiritual bonds + confining the nation began to relax. Political decay always brings + religious defection in its train. Whenever Israel came under the dominion + of the neighboring tribes, he also fell a victim to their cult. This + phenomenon is throughout characteristic of the so-called era of the + Judges. It is a natural phenomenon readily explained on psychologic + grounds. The Mosaic national conception of the "Eternal" entered more and + more deeply into the national consciousness, and, accommodating itself to + the limited mental capacity of the majority, became narrower and narrower + in compass—the lot of all great ideas! The "Eternal" was no longer + thought of as the only One God of the whole universe, but as the tutelar + deity of the Israelitish tribe. The idea of national tutelar deities was + at that time deeply rooted in the consciousness of all the peoples of + Western Asia. Each nation, as it had a king of its own, had a tribal god + of its own. The Phoenicians had their Baal, the Moabites their Kemosh, the + Ammonites their Milkom. Belief in the god peculiar to a nation by no means + excluded belief in the existence of other national gods. A people + worshiped its own god, because it regarded him as its master and + protecting lord. In fact, according to the views then prevalent, a + conflict between two nations was the conflict between two national + deities. In the measure in which respect for the god of the defeated party + waned, waxed the number of worshipers of the god of the victorious nation, + and not merely among the conquerors, but also among the adherents of other + religions.<a href="#linknote-10" name="linknoteref-10" id="noteref-10"><small>10</small></a> + These crude, coarsely materialistic conceptions of God gained entrance + with the masses of the Israelitish people. If Moab had his Kemosh, and + Ammon his Milkom, then Israel had his "Eternal," who, after the model of + all other national gods, protected and abandoned his "clients" at + pleasure, in the one case winning, in the other losing, the devotion of + his partisans. In times of distress, in which the Israelites groaned under + the yoke of the alien, the enslaved "forgot" their "conquered" "Eternal." + As they paid the tribute due the strange king, and yielded themselves to + his power, so they submitted to the strange god, and paid him his due + tribute of devotion. It followed that liberation from the yoke of the + stranger coincided with return to the God of Israel, the "Eternal." At + such times the national spirit leaped into flaming life. This sums up the + achievements of the hero-Judges. But the traces of repeated backsliding + were deep and long visible, for, together with the religious ideas of the + strange peoples, the Israelites accepted their customs, as a rule corrupt + and noxious customs, in sharp contrast with the lofty principles of the + Mosaic Law, designed to control social life and the life of the + individual. + </p> + <p> + The Prophet Samuel, coming after the unsettled period of the Judges, had + only partial success in purifying the views of the people and elevating it + out of degradation to a higher spiritual level. His work was continued + with more marked results in the brilliant reigns of Saul, David, and + Solomon. An end was put to the baleful disunion among the tribes, and the + bond of national tradition was strengthened. The consolidated Israelitish + kingdom triumphed over its former oppressors. The gods of the strange + peoples cringed in the dust before the all-powerful "Eternal." But, with + the division of the kingdom and the political rupture between Judah and + Israel, the period of efflorescence soon came to an end. Again confusion + reigned supreme, and customs and convictions deteriorated under foreign + influence. Prophets like Elijah and Elisha, feverish though their activity + was, stood powerless before the rank immorality in the two states. The + northern kingdom of Israel, composed of the Ten Tribes, passed swiftly + downward on the road to destruction, sharing the fate of the numberless + Oriental states whose end was inevitable by reason of inner decay. The + inspired words of the early Israelitish Prophets, Amos, Hosea, and Micah, + their trumpet-toned reproofs, their thrilling admonitions, died unheeded + upon the air—society was too depraved to understand their import. It + was reserved for later generations to give ear to their immortal + utterances, eloquent witnesses to the lofty heights to which the Jewish + spirit was permitted to mount in times of general decline. The northern + kingdom sank into irretrievable ruin. Then came the turn of Judah. He, + too, had disregarded the law of "sanctification" from Sinai, and had + nearly arrived at the point of stifling his better impulses in the morass + of materialistic living. + </p> + <p> + At this critical moment, on the line between to be and not to be, a + miracle came to pass. The spirit of the people, become flesh in its + noblest sons, rose aloft. From out of the midst of the political + disturbances, the frightful infamy, and the moral corruption, resounded + the impressive call of the great Prophets of Judah. Like a flaming torch + carried through dense darkness, they cast a glaring light upon the vices + of society, at the same time illuminating the path that leads upward to + the goal of the ethical ideal. At first the negative, denouncing element + predominated in the exhortations of the Prophets: unsparingly they + scourged the demoralization and the iniquity, the social injustice and the + political errors prevalent in their time; they threatened divine + punishment, that is, the natural consequences of evil-doing, and appealed + to the reason rather than the feelings of the people. But gradually they + elaborated positive ideals, more soul-stirring than the ideals identified + with the old religious tradition. The Prophets were the first to touch the + root of the evil. It is clear that they realized that alien influences and + the low grade of intelligence possessed by the masses were not the sole + causes of the frequent backsliding of the people. The Jewish doctrine + itself bore within it the germ of error. The two chief pillars of the old + faith—the nationalizing of the God-idea, and the stress laid upon + the cult, the ceremonial side of religion, as compared with moral + requirements—were first and foremost to be held responsible for the + flagrant departures from the spirit of Judaism. This was the direction in + which reform was needed. Thereafter the sermons of the Prophets betray + everywhere the intense desire, on the one hand, to restore to the God-idea + its original universal character, and, on the other hand, while strongly + emphasizing the importance of morality in the religious and the social + sphere, to derogate from the value of the ceremonial system. The "Eternal" + is no longer the national God of Israel, belonging to him exclusively; He + becomes the God of the whole of mankind, the same <i>Elohim</i>, Creator + and Preserver of the world, whom the Patriarchs had worshiped, and to + whom, being His creatures, all men owe worship. His precepts and His laws + of morality are binding upon all nations; they will bring salvation and + blessing to all without distinction.<a href="#linknote-11" name="linknoteref-11" + id="noteref-11"><small>11</small></a> The ideal of piety consists in the + profession of God and a life of rectitude. The time will come when all + nations will be penetrated by true knowledge of God and actuated by the + noblest motives; then will follow the universal brotherhood of man. Until + this consummation is reached, and so long as Israel is the only nation + formally professing the one true God, and accepting His blessed law, + Israel's sole task is to embody in himself the highest ideals, to be an + "ensign to the nations," to bear before them the banner of God's law, + destined in time to effect the transformation of the whole of mankind. + Israel is a missionary to the nations. As such he must stand before them + as a model of holiness and purity. Here is the origin of the great idea of + the spiritual "Messianism" of the Jewish people, or, better, its + "missionism," an eternal idea, far more comprehensive than the old idea of + national election, which it supplanted. + </p> + <p> + These sublime teachings were inculcated at the moment in which Judah was + hastening to meet his fate. It had become impossible to check the natural + results of the earlier transgressions. The inevitable happened; Babylon + the mighty laid her ponderous hand upon tiny Judah. But Judah could not be + crushed. From the heavy chastisement the Jewish nation emerged purified, + re-born for a new life. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0010"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + VI. THE SECONDARY OR SPIRITUAL-POLITICAL PERIOD + </h2> + <p> + The rank and file of a people are instructed by revolutions and + catastrophes better than by sermons. More quickly than Isaiah and + Jeremiah, Nebuchadnezzar brought the Jews to a recognition of their tasks. + The short span of the Babylonian Exile (586-538 B. C. E.) was a period of + introspection and searching self-examination for the people. Spiritual + forces hitherto latent came into play; a degree of self-consciousness + asserted itself. The people grasped its mission. At last it comprehended + that to imitate inferior races, instead of teaching them and making itself + a model for them to follow, was treason to its vocation in life. When the + hour of release from the Babylonian yoke struck, the people suddenly saw + under its feet "a new earth," and to "a new heaven" above it raised eyes + dim with tears of repentance and emotion. It renewed its covenant with + God. Like the Exodus from Egypt, so the second national deliverance was + connected with a revelation. But the messages delivered by the last + Prophets—especially by "the great unknown," the author of the latter + part of the Book of Isaiah—were too exalted, too universal in + conception, for a people but lately emerged from a severe crisis to set + about their realization at once. They could only illumine its path as a + guiding-star, inspire it as the ultimate goal, the far-off Messianic + ideal. Meanwhile the necessity appeared for uniform religious laws, + dogmas, and customs, to bind the Jews together externally as a nation. The + moralizing religion of the Prophets was calculated to bring about the + regeneration of the individual, regardless of national ties; but at that + moment the chief point involved was the nation. It had to be established + and its organization perfected. The universalism of the Prophets was + inadequate for the consolidating of a nation. To this end outward + religious discipline was requisite, an official cult and public + ceremonies. Led by such considerations, the Jewish captives, on their + return to Jerusalem, first of all devoted themselves to the erection of a + Temple, to the creating of a visible religious centre, which was to be the + rallying point for the whole nation. + </p> + <p> + The days of the Prophets were over. Their religious universalism could + apply only to a distant future. In the present, the nation, before it + might pose as a teacher, had to learn and grow spiritually strong. Aims of + such compass require centuries for their realization. Therefore, the + spiritual-national unification of the people was pushed into the + foreground. The place of the Prophet was filled by the Priest and the + Scribe. Zerubbabel, Ezra, and Nehemiah were permeated by the purpose to + make religion and the cult subservient to the cause of national union and + isolation. The erection of the Temple, the solemn service with the singing + of Psalms and the public reading from the "Book of the Law" (the + Pentateuch, which underwent its final redaction at that time), the removal + of whatever might arouse the remembrance of strange and heathen + institutions—these were the levers of their unifying activity. At + first sight this activity might appear almost too one-sided. But if we + summon to mind a picture of the conditions prevailing in those days, we + are forced to the conclusion that, in the interest of national + restoration, a consistent course was imperative. In point of fact, + however, some of Ezra's innovations testify to the broad-minded, + reformatory character of this activity; as, for instance, the public + reading of the Pentateuch, introduced with a view to making the people see + the necessity of obtaining detailed knowledge of the principles of its + religion, and obeying the precepts of the Law, not blindly, but with + conscious assent. The object steadily aimed at was the elevation of the + whole body of the people to the plane of spirituality, its transformation, + in accordance with the Biblical injunction, into a "kingdom of priests." + </p> + <p> + This injunction of civilizing import became the starting point of the + activity of all of Ezra's successors, of the so-called school of the <i>Soferim</i>, + the Scribes, those versed in the art of writing. The political calm that + prevailed during the two centuries of the Persian supremacy (538-332 B. C. + E.), was calculated to an eminent degree to promote spiritual development + and the organization of the inner life of the people. During this period, + a large part of the writings after the Pentateuch that have been received + into the Bible were collected, compiled, and reduced to writing. The + immortal thoughts of the Prophets clothed themselves in the visible garb + of letters. On parchment rolls and in books they were made accessible to + distant ages. The impressive traditions transmitted from earliest times, + the chronicles of the past of the people, the Psalms brought forth by the + religious enthusiasm of a long series of poets, all were gathered and put + into literary shape with the extreme of care. The spiritual treasures of + the nation were capitalized, and to this process of capitalization solely + and alone generations of men have owed the possibility of resorting to + them as a source of faith and knowledge. Without the work of compilation + achieved by the <i>Soferim</i>, of which the uninstructed are apt to speak + slightingly, mankind to-day had no Bible, that central sun in + world-literature. + </p> + <p> + These two centuries may fitly be called the school-days of the Jewish + nation; the Scribes were the teachers of Jewry. In the way of original + work but little was produced. The people fed upon the store of spiritual + food, of which sufficient had been laid up for several generations. It was + then that the Jews first earned their title to the name, "the People of + the Book." They made subservient to themselves the two mightiest + instruments of thought, the art of writing and of reading. Their progress + was brilliant, and when their schooling had come to an end, and they + stepped out into the broader life, they were at once able to apply their + knowledge successfully to practical contingencies. They were prepared for + all the vicissitudes of life. Their spiritual equipment was complete. + </p> + <p> + Nothing could have been more opportune than this readiness to assume the + responsibilities of existence, for a time of peril and menace was again + approaching. From out of the West, a new agent of civilization, Hellenism, + advanced upon the East. Alexander the Great had put an end to the huge + Persian monarchy, and brought the whole of Western Asia under his dominion + (332 B. C. E.). His generals divided the conquered lands among themselves. + With all their might, the Ptolemies in Egypt and the Seleucidae in Syria + hellenized the countries subject to their rule. In the old domain of the + Pharaohs, as in Babylonia, in Phoenicia, and in Syria, the Greek language + was currently spoken, Greek ceremonies were observed, the Greek mode of + life was adopted. Athens ceded her rights of primogeniture to New Athens, + Alexandria, capital of Egypt, and cosmopolitan centre of the civilized + world. For a whole century Judea played the sad part of the apple of + discord between the Egyptian and the Syrian dynasty (320-203 B. C. E.). By + turns she owned the sway of the Ptolemies and the Seleucidae, until + finally, in 203, she was declared a Syro-Macedonian province. Here, as in + the other parts of their realm, the rulers devoted themselves + energetically to the dissemination of Greek culture. Meeting with + resistance, they had resort to main force. At first, indeed, a large part + of the people permitted itself to be blinded by the "beauty of Japheth," + and promoted assimilation with the Greeks. But when the spread of + Hellenism began to threaten the spiritual individuality of Judaism, the + rest of the nation, endowed with greater capacity of resistance, arose and + sturdily repulsed the enemy. + </p> + <p> + Hellenism was the first gravely dangerous opponent Judaism had to + encounter. It was not the ordinary meeting of two peoples, or of two kinds + of civilization. It was a clash between two theories of life that stood + abruptly opposed to each other, were, indeed, mutually exclusive. It was a + duel between "the Eternal" on the one side, and Zeus on the other—between + the Creator of the universe, the invisible spiritual Being who had, in a + miraculous way, revealed religious and ethical ideals to mankind, and the + deity who resided upon Olympus, who personified the highest force of + nature, consumed vast quantities of nectar and ambrosia, and led a pretty + wild life upon Olympus and elsewhere. In the sphere of religion and + morality, Hellene and Judean could not come close to each other. The + former deified nature herself, the material universe; the latter deified + the Creator of nature, the spirit informing the material universe. The + Hellene paid homage first and foremost to external beauty and physical + strength; the Judean to inner beauty and spiritual heroism. The Hellenic + theory identified the moral with the beautiful and the agreeable, and made + life consist of an uninterrupted series of physical and mental pleasures. + The Judean theory is permeated by the strictly ethical notions of duty, of + purity, of "holiness"; it denounces licentiousness, and sets up as its + ideal the controlling of the passions and the infinite improvement of the + soul, not of the intellect alone, but of the feelings as well. These + differences between the two theories of life showed themselves in the + brusque opposition in character and customs that made the Greeks and the + Jews absolute antipodes in many spheres of life. It cannot be denied that + in matters of the intellect, especially in the field of philosophy and + science, not to mention art, it might have been greatly to the advantage + of the Jews to become disciples of the Greeks. Nor is there any doubt that + the brighter aspects of Hellenism would make an admirable complement to + Judaism. An harmonious blending of the Prophets with Socrates and Plato + would have produced a many-sided, ideal <i>Weltanschauung</i>. The course + of historical events from the first made such blending, which would + doubtless have required great sacrifices on both sides, an impossible + consummation. In point of fact, the events were such as to widen the abyss + between the two systems. The meeting of Judaism and Hellenism + unfortunately occurred at the very moment when the classical Hellenes had + been supplanted by the hellenized Macedonians and Syrians, who had + accepted what were probably the worst elements of the antique system, + while appropriating but few of the intellectual excellencies of Greek + culture. There was another thwarting circumstance. In this epoch, the + Greeks were the political oppressors of the Jews, outraging Jewish + national feeling through their tyranny to the same degree as by their + immoral life they shocked Jewish ethical feeling and Jewish chastity. + </p> + <p> + Outraged national and religious feeling found expression in the + insurrection of the Maccabees (168 B. C. E.). The hoary priest Mattathias + and his sons fought for the dearest and noblest treasures of Judaism. + Enthusiasm begets heroism. The Syrian-Greek yoke was thrown off, and, + after groaning under alien rule, the Persian, the Egyptian, and the + Syro-Macedonian, for four hundred years, Judea became an independent + state. In its foreign relations, the new state was secured by the + self-sacrificing courage of the first Maccabean brothers, and from within + it was supported by the deep-sunk pillars of the spiritual life. The rise + of the three famous parties, the Sadducees, the Pharisees, and the + Essenes, by no means testifies, as many would have us believe, to national + disintegration, but rather to the intense spiritual activity of the + people. The three tendencies afforded opportunity for the + self-consciousness of the nation to express itself in all its variety and + force. The unbending religious dogmatism of the Sadducees, the + comprehensive practical sense of the Pharisees in religious and Rational + concerns, the contemplative mysticism of the Essenes, they are the most + important offshoots from the Jewish system as held at that time. In + consequence of the external conditions that brought about the destruction + of the Maccabean state<a href="#linknote-12" name="linknoteref-12" id="noteref-12"><small>12</small></a> + after a century's existence (165-63 B. C. E.), the Pharisee tendency, + which had proved itself the best in practice, won the upper hand. When + Judea was held fast in the clutches of the Roman eagle, all hope of escape + being cut off, the far-seeing leaders of the people gained the firm + conviction that the only trustworthy support of the Jewish nation lay in + its religion. They realized that the preservation of national unity could + be effected only by a consistent organization of the religious law, which + was to envelop and shape the whole external life of the people. This + explains the feverish activity of the early creators of the Mishna, of + Hillel, Shammai, and others, and it interprets also the watchword of still + older fame, "Make a fence about the Law." If up to that moment religious + usage in its development had kept abreast of the requirements of social + and individual life, the requirements out of which it had grown forth, it + now became a national function, and its further evolution advanced with + tremendous strides. For the protection of the old "Mosaic Laws," a twofold + and a threefold fence of new legal ordinances was erected about them, and + the cult became more and more complicated. But the externals of religion + did not monopolize all the forces. The moral element in the nation was + promoted with equal vigor. Hillel, the head of the Pharisee party, was not + a legislator alone, he was also a model of humane principles and rare + moral attainments. + </p> + <p> + While Judaism, in its native country was striving to isolate itself, and + was seizing upon all sorts of expedients to insure this end, it readily + entered into relations, outside of Judea, with other systems of thought, + and accepted elements of the classical culture. Instead of the violent + opposition which the Palestinian Judaism of the pre-Maccabean period, that + is, the period of strife, had offered to Hellenism, the tendency to make + mutual concessions, and pave the way for an understanding between the two + theories of life, asserted itself in Alexandria. In the capital city of + the hellenized world the Jews constituted one of the most important + elements of culture. According to Mommsen, the Jewish colony in Alexandria + was not inferior, in point of numbers, to the Jewish population of + Jerusalem, the metropolis. Influenced by Greek civilization, the Jews in + turn exercised decisive influence upon their heathen surroundings, and + introduced a new principle of development into the activity of the + cultivated classes. The Greek translation of the Biblical writings formed + the connecting link between Judaism and Hellenism. The "Septuaginta," the + translation of the Pentateuch, in use since the third century before the + Christian era, had acquainted the classical world with Jewish views and + principles. The productions of the Prophets and, in later centuries, of + the other Biblical authors, translated and spread broadcast, acted + irresistibly upon the spirit of the cultivated heathen, and granted him a + glimpse into a world of hitherto unknown notions. On this soil sprang up + the voluminous Judeo-Hellenic literature, of which but a few, though + characteristic, specimens have descended to us. The intermingling of Greek + philosophy with Jewish religious conceptions resulted in a new + religio-philosophic doctrine, with a mystic tinge, of which Philo is the + chief exponent. In Jerusalem, Judaism appeared as a system of practical + ceremonies and moral principles; in Alexandria, it presented itself as a + complex of abstract symbols and poetical allegories. The Alexandrian form + of Judaism might satisfy the intellect, but it could not appeal to the + feelings. It may have made Judaism accessible to the cultivated minority, + to the upper ten thousand with philosophic training; for the masses of the + heathen people Judaism continued unintelligible. Yet it was pre-eminently + the masses that were strongly possessed by religious craving. Disappointed + in their old beliefs, they panted after a new belief, after spiritual + enlightenment. In the decaying classical world, which had so long filled + out life with materialistic and intellectual interests, the moral and + religious feelings, the desire for a living faith, for an active + inspiration, had awakened, and was growing with irresistible force. + </p> + <p> + Then, from deep out of the bosom of Judaism, there sprang a moral, + religious doctrine destined to allay the burning thirst for religion, and + bring about a reorganization of the heathen world. The originators of + Christianity stood wholly upon the ground of Judaism. In their teachings + were reflected as well the lofty moral principles of the Pharisee leader + as the contemplative aims of the Essenes. But the same external + circumstances that had put Judaism under the necessity of choosing a + sharply-defined practical, national policy, made it impossible for Judaism + to fraternize with the preachers of the new doctrine. Judaism, in fact, + was compelled to put aside entirely the thought of universal missionary + activity. Instead, it had to devote its powers to the more pressing task + of guarding the spiritual unity of a nation whose political bonds were + visibly dropping away. + </p> + <p> + For just then the Jewish nation, gory with its own blood, was struggling + in the talons of the Roman eagle. Its sons fought heroically, without + thought of self. When, finally, physical strength gave out, their + spiritual energy rose to an intenser degree. The state was annihilated, + the nation remained alive. At the very moment when the Temple was + enwrapped in flames, and the Roman legions flooded Jerusalem, the + spiritual leaders of Jewry sat musing, busily casting about for a means + whereby, without a state, without a capital, without a Temple, Jewish + unity might be maintained. And they solved the difficult problem. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0011"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + VII. THE TERTIARY TALMUDIC OR NATIONAL-RELIGIOUS PERIOD + </h2> + <p> + The solution of the problem consisted chiefly in more strictly following + out the process of isolation. In a time in which the worship of God + preached by Judaism was rapidly spreading to all parts of the classical + world, and the fundamental principles of the Jewish religion were steadily + gaining appreciation and active adherence, this intense desire for + seclusion may at first glance seem curious. But the phenomenon is + perfectly simple. A foremost factor was national feeling, enhanced to a + tremendous degree at the time of the destruction of Jerusalem. Lacking a + political basis, it was transferred to religious soil. Every tradition, + every custom, however insignificant, was cherished as a jewel. Though + without a state and without territory, the Jews desired to form a nation, + if only a spiritual nation, complete in itself. They considered themselves + then as before the sole guardians of the law of God. They did not believe + in a speedy fulfilment of the prophetical promise concerning "the end of + time" when all nations would be converted to God. A scrupulous keeper of + the Law, Judaism would not hear of the compromises that heathendom, lately + entered into the bosom of the faith, claimed as its due consideration. It + refused to sacrifice a single feature of its simple dogmatism, of its + essential ceremonies, such as circumcision and Sabbath rest. Moreover, in + the period following close upon the fall of the Temple, a part of the + people still nursed the hope of political restoration, a hope repudiating + in its totality the proclamation of quite another Messianic doctrine. The + delusion ended tragically in Bar Kochba's hapless rebellion (135 C. E.), + whose disastrous issue cut off the last remnant of hope for the + restoration of an "earthly kingdom." Thereafter the ideal of a spiritual + state was replaced by the ideal of a spiritual nation, rallying about a + peculiar religious banner. Jewry grew more and more absorbed in itself. + Its seclusion from the rest of the world became progressively more + complete. Instinct dictated this course as an escape from the danger of + extinction, or, at least, of stagnation. It was conscious of possessing + enough vitality and energy to live for itself and work out its own + salvation. It had its spiritual interests, its peculiar ideals, and a firm + belief in the future. It constituted an ancient order, whose patent of + nobility had been conferred upon it in the days of the hoary past by the + Lord God Himself. Such as it was, it could not consent to ally itself with + <i>parvenus</i>, ennobled but to-day, and yesterday still bowing down + before "gods of silver and gods of gold." This white-haired old man, with + a stormy past full of experiences and thought, would not mingle with the + scatter-brained crowd, would not descend to the level of neophytes + dominated by fleeting, youthful enthusiasm. Loyally this weather-bronzed, + inflexible guardian of the Law stuck to his post—the post entrusted + to him by God Himself—and, faithful to his duty, held fast to the + principle <i>j'y suis, j'y reste</i>. + </p> + <p> + As a political nation threatened by its neighbors seeks support in its + army, and provides sufficient implements of war, so a spiritual nation + must have spiritual weapons of defense at its command. Such weapons were + forged in great numbers, and deposited in the vast arsenal called the + Talmud. The Talmud represents a complicated spiritual discipline, + enjoining unconditional obedience to a higher invisible power. Where + discipline is concerned, questions as to the necessity for one or another + regulation are out of place. Every regulation is necessary, if only + because it contributes to the desired end, namely, discipline. Let no one + ask, then, to what purpose the innumerable religious and ritual + regulations, sometimes reaching the extreme of pettiness, to what purpose + the comprehensive code in which every step in the life of the faithful is + foreseen. The Talmudic religious provisions, all taken together, aim to + put the regimen of the nation on a strictly uniform basis, so that + everywhere the Jew may be able to distinguish a brother in faith by his + peculiar mode of life. It is a uniform with insignia, by which soldiers of + the same regiment recognize one another. Despite the vast extent of the + Jewish diaspora, the Jews formed a well-articulated spiritual army, an + invisible "state of God" (<i>civitas dei</i>). Hence these "knights of the + spirit," the citizens of this invisible state, had to wear a distinct + uniform, and be governed by a suitable code of army regulations. + </p> + <p> + As a protection for Jewish national unity, which was exposed to the + greatest danger after the downfall of the state, there arose and + developed, without any external influence whatsoever, an extraordinary + dictatorship, unofficial and spiritual. The legislative activity of all + the dictators—such as, Rabbi Jochanan ben Zakkai, Rabbi Akiba, the + Hillelites, and the Shammaites—was formulated in the Mishna, the + "oral law," which was the substructure of the Talmud. Their activity had a + characteristic feature, which deserves somewhat particularized + description. The laws were not laid down arbitrarily and without ceremony. + In order to possess binding force, they required the authoritative + confirmation to be found in the Mosaic Books. From these, whether by + logical or by forced interpretation of the holy text, its words, or, + perchance, its letters, they had to be derived. Each law, barring only the + original "traditions," the <i>Halacha le-Moshe mi-Sinai</i>, was + promulgated over the supreme signature, as it were, that is, with the + authentication of a word from the Holy Scriptures. Or it was inferred from + another law so authenticated. The elaboration of every law was thus + connected with a very complicated process of thought, requiring both + inductive and deductive reasoning, and uniting juridical interpretation + with the refinements of casuistry. This legislation was the beginning of + Talmudic science, which from that time on, for many centuries, growing + with the ages, claimed in chief part the intellectual activity of Jewry. + The schools and the academies worked out a system of laws at once + religious and practical in character, which constituted, in turn, the + object of further theoretic study in the same schools and academies. In + the course of time, however, the means became the end. Theoretic + investigation of the law, extending and developing to the furthest limits, + in itself, without reference to its practical value, afforded satisfaction + to the spiritual need. The results of theorizing often attained the + binding force of law in practical life, not because circumstances ordered + it, but simply because one or another academy, by dint of logic or + casuistry, had established it as law. The number of such deductions from + original and secondary laws increased in geometric progression, and + practical life all but failed to keep up with the theory. The "close of + the Mishna," that is, its reduction to writing, had no daunting effect + upon the zeal for research. If anything, a new and strong impetus was + imparted to it. As up to that time the text of the Holy Scriptures had + been made the basis of interpretation, giving rise to the most diverse + inferences, so the rabbis now began to use the law book recently canonized + as a new basis of interpretation, and to carry its principles to their + utmost consequences. In this way originated first the "Palestinian + Gemara." Later, when the Patriarchate in Palestine was stripped of its + glory by persecutions, and, in consequence, the centre of activity had to + be transferred from the Talmud academies of Palestine to those of + Babylonia, supreme place and exclusive dominion were obtained by the + "Babylonian Gemara," put into permanent form about the year 500 C. E., a + gigantic work, the result of two hundred years of mental labor. + </p> + <p> + This busy intellectual activity was as comprehensive as it was + thoroughgoing. Talmudic legislation, the Halacha, by no means confines + itself to religious practices, extensive as this field is. It embraces the + whole range of civil and social life. Apart from the dietary laws, the + regulations for the festivals and the divine service, and a mass of + enactments for the shaping of daily life, the Talmud elaborated a + comprehensive and fairly well-ordered system of civil and criminal law, + which not infrequently bears favorable comparison with the famous <i>rationi + scriptae</i> of the Romans. While proceeding with extreme rigor and + scrupulousness in ritual matters, the Talmud is governed in its social + legislation by the noblest humanitarian principles. Doubtless this + difference of attitude can be explained by the fact that religious norms + are of very much greater importance for a nation than judicial + regulations, which concern themselves only with the interests of the + individual, and exercise but little influence upon the development of the + national spirit. + </p> + <p> + The most sympathetic aspects of the Jewish spirit in that epoch are + revealed in the moral and poetic elements of the Talmud, in the Agada. + They are the receptacles into which the people poured all its sentiments, + its whole soul. They are a clear reflex of its inner world, its feelings, + hopes, ideals. The collective work of the nation and the trend of history + have left much plainer traces in the Agada than in the dry, methodical + Halacha. In the Agada the learned jurist and formalist appears transformed + into a sage or poet, conversing with the people in a warm, cordial tone, + about the phenomena of nature, history, and life. The reader is often + thrown into amazement by the depth of thought and the loftiness of feeling + manifested in the Agada. Involuntarily one pays the tribute of reverence + to its practical wisdom, to its touching legends pervaded by the magic + breath of poesy, to the patriarchal purity of its views. But these pearls + are not strung upon one string, they are not arranged in a complete + system. They are imbedded here and there, in gay variety, in a vast mass + of heterogeneous opinions and sentiments naive at times and at times + eccentric. The reader becomes aware of the thoughts before they are + consolidated. They are still in a fluid, mobile state, still in process of + making. The same vivacious, versatile spirit is revealed in the Midrashim + literature, directly continuing the Agada up to the end of the middle + ages. These two species of Jewish literature, the Agada and the Midrashim, + have a far greater absolute value than the Halacha. The latter is an + official work, the former a national product. Like every other special + legislation, the Halacha is bound to definite conditions and times, while + the Agada concerns itself with the eternal verities. The creations of the + philosophers, poets, and moralists are more permanent than the work of + legislators. + </p> + <p> + Beautiful as the Agada is, and with all its profundity, it lacks breadth. + It rests wholly on the national, not on a universal basis. It would be + vain to seek in it for the comprehensive universalism of the Prophets. + Every lofty ideal is claimed as exclusively Jewish. So far from bridging + over the chasm between Israel and the other nations, knowledge and + morality served to widen it. It could not be otherwise, there was no + influx of air from without. The national horizon grew more and more + contracted. The activities of the people gathered intensity, but in the + same measure they lost in breadth. It was the only result to be expected + from the course of history in those ages. Let us try to conceive what the + first five centuries of the Christian era, the centuries during which the + Talmud was built up, meant in the life of mankind. Barbarism, darkness, + and elemental outbreaks of man's migratory instincts, illustrated by the + "great migration of races," are characteristic features of those + centuries. It was a wretched transition period between the fall of the + world of antique culture and the first germinating of a new Christian + civilization. The Orient, the centre and hearth of Judaism, was shrouded + in impenetrable darkness. In Palestine and in Babylonia, their two chief + seats, the Jews were surrounded by nations that still occupied the lowest + rung of the ladder of civilization, that had not yet risen above naive + mysticism in religion, or continued to be immersed in superstitions of the + grossest sort. + </p> + <p> + In this abysmal night of the middle ages, the lamp of thought was fed and + guarded solely and alone by the Jews. It is not astonishing, then, that + oblivious of the other nations they should have dispensed light only for + themselves. Furthermore, the circumstance must be considered that, in the + period under discussion, the impulse to separate from Judaism gained + ground in the Christian world. After the Council of Nicaea, after + Constantine the Great had established Christianity as the state-church, + the official breach between the Old Testament and the New Testament + partisans became unavoidable. + </p> + <p> + Thus the Jews, robbed of their political home, created a spiritual home + for themselves. Through the instrumentality of the numberless religious + rules which the Talmud had laid down, and which shaped the life of the + individual as well as that of the community, they were welded into a + firmly united whole. The Jewish spirit—national feeling and + individual mental effort alike—was absorbed in this pursuit of + unification. Head, heart, hands, all human functions of the Jew, were + brought under complete control and cast into fixed forms, by these five + centuries of labor. With painful exactitude, the Talmud prescribed + ordinances for all the vicissitudes of life, yet, at the same time, + offered sufficient food for brain and heart. It was at once a religion and + a science. The Jew was equipped with all the necessaries. He could satisfy + his wants from his own store. There was no need for him to knock at + strange doors, even though he had thereby profited. The consequences of + this attitude, positive as well as negative consequences, asserted + themselves in the further course of Jewish history. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0012"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + VIII. THE GAONIC PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE ORIENTAL JEWS (500-980) + </h2> + <p> + With the close of the Talmud, at the beginning of the sixth century, the + feverish intellectual activity abated. The Jewish centre of gravity + continued in Babylonia. In this country, in which the Jewish race had + heard its cradle song at the dawn of existence, and later on <i>Judaea + capta</i> had sat and wept remembering Zion, Judaism, after the + destruction of the second Temple and hundreds of years of trials, was + favored with a secure asylum. In the rest of the diaspora, persecution + gave the Jews no respite, but in Babylonia, under Persian rule, they lived + for some centuries comparatively free from molestation. Indeed, they + enjoyed a measure of autonomy in internal affairs, under a chief who was + entitled Exilarch (<i>Resh-Galutha</i>). The Law and the word of God went + forth from Babylonia for the Jews of all lands. The Babylonian Talmud + became the anthoritative code for the Jewish people, a holy book second + only to the Bible. The intellectual calm that supervened at the beginning + of the sixth century and lasted until the end of the eighth century, + betrayed itself in the slackening of independent creation, though not in + the flagging of intellectual activity in general. In the schools and + academies of Pumbeditha, Nahardea, and Sura, scientific work was carried + on with the same zest as before, only this work had for its primary object + the sifting and exposition of the material heaped up by the preceding + generations. This was the province of the Sabureans and the Geonim, whose + relation to the Talmud was the same as that of the Scribes (the <i>Soferim</i>) + of the Second Temple to the Bible (see above, ch. vi). In the later + period, as in the earlier, the aim was the capitalization of the + accumulated spiritual treasures, an undertaking that gives little occasion + for movement and life, but all the more for endurance and industry. + </p> + <p> + This intellectual balance was destroyed by two events: the appearance of + Islam and the rise of Karaism. Islam, the second legitimate offspring of + Judaism, was appointed to give to religious thought in the slumbering + Orient the slight impulse it needed to start it on its rapid career of + sovereign power. Barely emancipated from swaddling clothes, young Hotspur + at once began to rage. He sought an outlet for his unconquerable thirst + for action, his lust for world-dominion. The victorious religious wars of + the followers of Allah ensued. This foreign movement was not without + significance for the fate of the Jews. They were surrounded no longer by + heathens but by Mohammedans, who believed in the God of the Bible, and + through the mouth of their prophet conferred upon the Jews the honorable + appellation of "the People of the Book." In the eighth century the wars + ceased, and the impetuous energy of the rejuvenated Orient was diverted + into quieter channels. The Bagdad Khalifate arose, the peaceful era of the + growth of industry, the sciences, and the arts was inaugurated. Endowed + with quick discernment for every enlightening movement, the Jews yielded + to the vivifying magic of young Arabic culture. + </p> + <p> + Partly under the influence of the Arabic tendency to split into + religio-philosophic sects, partly from inner causes, Karaism sprang up in + the second half of the eighth century. Its active career began with a + vehement protest against the Talmud as the regulator of life and thought. + It proclaimed the creators of this vast encyclopedia to be usurpers of + spiritual power, and urged a return to the Biblical laws in their + unadulterated simplicity. The weakness of its positive principles hindered + the spread of Karaism, keeping it forever within the narrow limits of a + sect and consigning it to stagnation. What gave it vogue during the first + century of its existence was its negative strength, its violent opposition + to the Talmud, which aroused strenuous intellectual activity. For a long + time it turned Judaism away from its one-sided Talmudic tendency, and + opened up new avenues of work for it. True to their motto: "Search + diligently in the Holy Scriptures," the adherents of Karaism applied + themselves to the rational study of the Bible, which had come to be, among + the Talmudists, the object of casuistic interpretation and legendary + adornment. By the cultivation of grammar and lexicography as applied to + the Biblical thesaurus of words, they resuscitated the Hebrew language, + which, ousted by the Aramaic dialect, had already sunk into oblivion. By + the same means they laid the foundation of a school of rejuvenated poetry. + In general, thought on religious and philosophic subjects was promoted to + a higher degree by the lively discussions between them and the Talmudists. + </p> + <p> + By imperceptible steps Talmudic Judaism, influenced at once by the + enlightened Arabs and the protesting Karaites, departed from the "four + ells of the Halacha," and widened its horizon. Among the spiritual leaders + of the people arose men who occupied themselves not only with the study of + the Talmud but also with a rational exegesis of the Bible, with philology, + poetry, philosophy. The great Gaon Saadiah (892-942) united within himself + all strands of thought. Over and above a large number of philological and + other writings of scientific purport, he created a momentous + religio-philosophic system, with the aim to clarify Judaism and refine + religious conceptions. He was an encyclopedic thinker, a representative of + the highest Jewish culture and of Arabic culture as well—he wrote + his works in Arabic by preference. In this way Jewish thought gained + ground more and more in the Orient. It was in the West, however, that it + attained soon after to the climax of its development. + </p> + <p> + Gradually the centre of gravity of Jewry shifted from Asia Minor to + Western Europe. Beginning with the sixth century, the sparsely sown Jewish + population of Occidental Europe increased rapidly in numbers. In Italy, + Byzantium, France, and Visigothic Spain, important Jewish communities were + formed. The medieval intolerance of the Church, though neither so + widespread nor so violent as it later became, suffered its first outbreak + in that early century. The persecutions of the Jews by the Visigothic + kings of Spain and the Bishops Avitus of Clermont and Agobard in France + (sixth to the ninth century) were the prelude to the more systematic and + the more bloody cruelties of subsequent days. The insignificant numbers of + the European Jews and the insecurity of their condition stood in the way + of forming an intellectual centre of their own. They were compelled to + acknowledge the spiritual supremacy of their Oriental brethren in faith. + With the beginning of the tenth century the situation underwent a change. + Arabic civilization, which had penetrated to Spain in previous centuries, + brought about a radical transformation in the character of the country. + The realm of the fanatic Visigoths, half barbarous and wholly averse to + the light of progress, changed into the prosperous and civilized Khalifate + of the Ommeyyades. Thither the best forces of Oriental Jewry transferred + themselves. With the growth of the Jewish population in Arabic Spain and + the strengthening of its communal organization, the spiritual centre of + the Jewish people gradually established itself in Spain. The academies of + Sura and Pumbeditha yielded first place to the high schools of Cordova and + Toledo. + </p> + <p> + The Jewry of the East resigned the national hegemony to the Jewry of the + West. The Geonim withdrew in favor of the Rabbis. After centuries of + seclusion, the Jewish spirit once more asserted itself, and enjoyed a + period of efflorescence. The process of national growth became more + complex, more varied. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0013"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + IX. THE RABBINIC-PHILOSOPHICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE SPANISH JEWS + </h2> + <p> + (980-1492) + </p> + <p> + The five centuries marked at their beginning by the rise of Arabic-Jewish + civilization in Spain and at their end by the banishment of the Jews from + Spain (980-1492), offer the Jewish historian an abundance of culture + manifestations and intellectual movements so luxuriant that it is + well-nigh impossible to gather them up in one formula. The monotony + formerly prevailing in Jewish national life, both in its external and in + its internal relations, was succeeded by almost gaily checkered variety. + Swept along by the movement towards enlightenment that dominated their + surroundings, the Jews of Arabic Spain threw themselves into energetic + work in all the spheres of life and thought. While they had political + ground more or less firm under their feet, and for the most part enjoyed + peace and liberty, the Jews in the Christian lands of Europe stood upon + volcanic soil, every moment threatening to swallow them up. Exposed + constantly to persecutions, they lived more or less isolated, and devoted + themselves to one-sided though intense intellectual activity. Sombre + shadows and streaks of bright light alternate with each other in this + period. In its second half, the clouds massed themselves heavily upon the + darkening horizon. Even the "privileged" Spanish Jews suffered an untoward + change in their affairs at the beginning of the thirteenth century: + gradually they were withdrawn from under the sovereignty of the Arabs, and + made subject to the power of the Catholic monarchs. They became + thenceforward the equal partners of their brethren in faith in the rest of + Europe. All without distinction had a share in the spiritual martyrdom + which is the greenest bayleaf in the crown of Jewish history. To think and + to suffer became the watchword of the whole nation. + </p> + <p> + At first, as we have said, a considerable portion of the Jewish people + enjoyed the happy possibility of thinking. This was during the classical + epoch of the Arabic-Jewish Renaissance, which preceded the Italian + Renaissance by four centuries. There is a fundamental difference between + the two Renaissance periods: the earlier one was signalized by a re-birth + of the sciences and of philosophy, the later one pre-eminently of the arts + and of literature. The eleventh and twelfth centuries marked the meridian + of the intellectual development of medieval Judaism. As once, in + Alexandria, the union of Judaic with Hellenic culture brought in its train + a superabundance of new ideas of a universal character, so again the + amalgamation, on Spanish soil, of Jewish culture with Arabic gave rise to + rich intellectual results, more lasting and fruitful than the Alexandrian, + inasmuch as, in spite of their universal character, they did not + contravene the national spirit. The Jewish people dropped its misanthropy + and its leaning toward isolation. The Jews entered all sorts of careers: + by the side of influential and cultivated statesmen, such as Chasdai ibn + Shaprut and Samuel Hanagid, at the courts of the Khalifs, stood a + brilliant group of grammarians, poets, and philosophers, like Jonah ibn + Ganach, Solomon Gabirol, and Moses ibn Ezra. The philosophic-critical + scepticism of Abraham ibn Ezra co-existed in peace and harmony with the + philosophic-poetic enthusiasm of Jehuda Halevi. The study of medicine, + mathematics, physics, and astronomy went hand in hand with the study of + the Talmud, which, though it may not have occupied the first place with + the Spanish Jews of this time, by no means disappeared, as witness the + compendium by Alphassi. Unusual breadth and fulness of the spiritual life + is the distinction of the epoch. This variety of mental traits combined in + a marvelous union to form the great personality of Maimonides, the crown + of a glorious period. With one "Strong Hand," this intellectual giant + brought order out of the Talmudic chaos, which at his word was transformed + into a symmetrical, legal system; with the other, he "guided the + Perplexed" through the realm of faith and knowledge. For rationalistic + clarity and breadth of view no counterpart to the religio-philosophic + doctrine which he formulated can be found in the whole extent of medieval + literature. The main feature of the philosophy of Maimonides and of the + systems based upon it is rationalism, not a dry, scholastic, abstract + rationalism, but a living rationalism, embracing the whole field of the + most exalted psychic phenomena. It is not philosophy pure and simple, but + religious philosophy, an harmonization, more or less felicitous, of the + postulates of reason with the dogmas of faith. It is reason mitigated by + faith, and faith regulated by reason. In the darkness of the middle ages, + when the Romish Church impregnated religion with the crudest + superstitions, going so far as to forbid its adherents to read the Bible, + and when the greatest philosopher representatives of the Church, like + Albertus Magnus, would have rejected offhand, as a childish fancy or, + indeed, as an heretical chimera, any attempt to rescue the lower classes + of the people from their wretched state of spiritual servitude—in a + time like this, the truly majestic spectacle is presented of a philosophy + declaring war on superstition, and setting out to purify the religious + notions of the people. + </p> + <p> + Not a breath of this ample spiritual development of the Jews of Arabic + Spain reached the Jews living in the Christian countries of Europe. Their + circumstances were too grievous, and in sombreness their inner life + matched their outer estate. Their horizon was as contracted as the streets + of the Jewries in which they were penned. The crusades (beginning in 1096) + clearly showed the Jews of France and Germany what sentiments their + neighbors cherished towards them. They were the first returns which + Christianity paid the Jewish people for its old-time teaching of religion. + The descendants of the "chosen people," the originators of the Bible, were + condemned to torture of a sort to exhaust their spiritual heritage. + Judaism suffered the tragic fate of King Lear. Was it conceivable that the + horrors—the rivers of blood, the groans of massacred communities, + the serried ranks of martyrs, the ever-haunting fear of the morrow—should + fail to leave traces in the character of Judaism? The Jewish people + realized its imminent danger. It convulsively held fast to its precious + relics, clung to the pillars of its religion, which it regarded as the + only asylum. The Jewish spirit again withdrew from the outer world. It + gave itself up wholly to the study of the Talmud. In northern France and + in Germany, Talmudic learning degenerated into the extreme of scholastic + pedantry, the lot of every branch of science that is lopped off from the + main trunk of knowledge, and vegetates in a heavy, dank atmosphere, + lacking light and air. Rashi (1064-1105), whose genial activity began + before the first crusade, opened up Jewish religious literature to the + popular mind, by his systematic commentaries on the Bible and the Talmud. + On the other hand, the Tossafists, the school of commentators succeeding + him, by their petty quibbling and hairsplitting casuistry made the + Talmudic books more intricate and less intelligible. Such being the + intellectual bias of the age, a sober, rationalistic philosophy could not + assert itself. In lieu of an Ibn Ezra or a Maimonides, we have Jehuda + Hachassid and Eliezer of Worms, with their mystical books of devotion, <i>Sefer + Chassidim, Rokeach</i>, etc., filled with pietistic reflections on the + other world, in which the earth figures as a "vale of tears." Poetry + likewise took on the dismal hue of its environment. Instead of the varied + lyrical notes of Gabirol and Halevi, who sang the weal and woe, not only + of the nation, but also of the individual, and lost themselves in + psychologic analysis, there now fall upon our ear the melancholy, + heartrending strains of synagogue poetry, the harrowing outcries that + forced themselves from the oppressed bosoms of the hunted people, the + prayerful lamentations that so often shook the crumbling walls of the + medieval synagogues at the very moment when, full of worshipers, they were + fired by the inhuman crusaders. A mighty chord reverberates in this + poetry: <i>Morituri te salutant</i>. + </p> + <p> + One small spot there was, in the whole of Europe, in which Jews could + still hope to endure existence and enjoy a measure of security. This was + Southern France, or the Provence. The population of Provence had + assimilated the culture of the neighboring country, Arabic Spain, and + become the mediator between it and the rest of Europe. This work of + mediation was undertaken primarily by the Jews. In the twelfth century + several universities existed in Provence, which were frequented in great + numbers by students from all countries. At these universities the teachers + of philosophy, medicine, and other branches of science were for the most + part Jews. The rationalistic philosophy of the Spanish Jews was there + proclaimed <i>ex cathedra</i>. The Tibbonides translated all the more + important works of the Jewish thinkers of Spain from Arabic into Hebrew. + The Kimchis devoted themselves to grammatical studies and the + investigation of the Bible. In Montpellier, Narbonne, and Lunel, + intellectual work was in full swing. Rational ideas gradually leavened the + masses of the Provençal population. Conscience freed from intellectual + trammels began to revolt against the oppression exercised by the Roman + clergy. Through the Albigensian heresy, Innocent III, founder of the papal + power, had his attention directed to the Jews, whom he considered the + dangerous protagonists of rationalism. The "heresy" was stifled, Provence + in all her magnificence fell a prey to the Roman mania for destruction, + and, on the ruins of a noble civilization, the Dominican Inquisition raged + with all its horrors (1213). + </p> + <p> + Thenceforward the Catholic Church devoted herself to a hostile watch upon + the Jews. Either she persecuted them directly through her Inquisition, or + indirectly through her omnipotent influence on kings and peoples. In the + hearts of the citizens of medieval Europe, the flame of religious hatred + was enkindled, and religious hatred served as a cloak for the basest + passions. Jewish history from that time on became a history of + uninterrupted suffering. The Lateran Council declared the Jews to be + outcasts, and designed a peculiar, dishonorable badge for them, a round + patch of yellow cloth, to be worn on their upper garment (1215). In France + the Jews became by turns the victims of royal rapacity and the scapegoats + of popular fanaticism. Massacres, confiscations, banishments followed by + dearly purchased permission to return, by renewed restrictions, + persecutions, and oppressions—these were the measures that + characterized the treatment of the Jews in France until their final + expulsion (1394). In Germany the Jews were not so much hated as despised. + They were <i>servi camerae</i>, serfs of the state, and as such had to pay + oppressive taxes. Besides, they were limited to the meanest trades and to + usury and peddling. They were shut up in their narrow Jewries, huddled in + wretched cabins, which clustered about the dilapidated synagogue in a + shamefaced way. What strange homes! What gigantic misery, what boundless + suffering dumbly borne, was concealed in those crumbling, curse-laden + dwellings! And yet, how resplendent they were with spiritual light, what + exalted virtues, what lofty heroism they harbored! In those gloomy, + tumbledown Jew houses, intellectual endeavor was at white heat. The torch + of faith blazed clear in them, and on the pure domestic hearth played a + gentle flame. In the abject, dishonored son of the Ghetto was hidden an + intellectual giant. In his nerveless body, bent double by suffering, and + enveloped in the shabby old cloak still further disfigured by the yellow + wheel, dwelt the soul of a thinker. The son of the Ghetto might have worn + his badge with pride, for in truth it was a medal of distinction awarded + by the papal Church to the Jews, for dauntlessness and courage. The + awkward, puny Jew in his way was stronger and braver than a German knight + armed cap-a-pie, for he was penetrated by the faith that "moves + mountains." And when the worst came to the worst, he demonstrated his + courage. When his peaceful home was stormed by the bestialized hordes of + Armleder, or the drunken bands of the Flagellants, or the furious avengers + of the "Black Death," he did not yield, did not purchase life by + disgraceful treason. With invincible courage he put his head under the + executioner's axe, and breathed forth his heroic spirit with the + enthusiastic cry: "Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God is One." + </p> + <p> + At length the turn of the Spanish Jews arrived. For the unbroken peace + they had enjoyed, they had to atone by centuries of unexampled suffering. + By degrees, the Arabs were forced out of the Pyrenean Peninsula, and the + power they had to abdicate was assumed by the Catholic kings of Castile + and Aragon. In 1236 occurred the fall of Cordova, the most important + centre of Arabic Jewish culture. Thereafter Arab power held sway only in + the province of Granada. The fortunes of the Spanish Jews underwent a + calamitous change. The kings and the upper ten thousand were, indeed, + favorably disposed toward them. At the courts of Castile and Aragon, the + Jews were active as ministers, physicians, astronomers. But the people, + incited by the propaganda of the clerics, nursed frightful hatred against + the Jews, not only as "infidels," but also as intellectual aristocrats. + The rage of the populace was the combustible material in the terrific + explosions that occurred periodically, in the bloody saturnalia of the + Pastouraux (1320), in the Black Death riots (1348), in the massacre of + Seville (1391). + </p> + <p> + Dire blows of fortune were unable to weigh down the Spanish Jew, + accustomed to independence, as they did the German Jew. He carried his + head proudly on high, for he was conscious that in all respects he stood + above the rabble pursuing him, above its very leaders, the clerics. In + spite of untoward fate his mental development proceeded, but inevitably it + was modified by the trend of the times. By the side of the philosophic + tendency of the previous age, a mystical tendency appeared in literature. + The Kabbala, with its mist-shrouded symbolism, so grateful to the feelings + and the imagination, chimed in better than rationalistic philosophy with + the depressed humor under which the greater part of the Jews were then + laboring. Another force antagonistic to rationalistic philosophy was the + Rabbinism transplanted from France and Germany. The controversy between + Rabbinism and philosophy, which dragged itself through three-quarters of a + century (1232-1305), ended in the formal triumph of Rabbinism. However, + philosophic activity merely languished, it did not cease entirely; in + fact, the three currents for some time ran along parallel with one + another. Next to the pillars of Rabbinism, Asheri, Rashba, Isaac ben + Sheshet, loomed up the philosophers, Gersonides (Ralbag), Kreskas, and + Albo, and a long line of Kabbalists, beginning with Nachmanides and Moses + de Leon, the compiler of the Zohar, and ending with the anonymous authors + of the mysterious "Kana and Pelia." + </p> + <p> + The times grew less and less propitious. Catholicism steadily gained + ground in Spain. The scowling Dominican put forward his claim upon the + Jewish soul with vehement emphasis, and made every effort to drag it into + the bosom of the alone-saving Church. The conversion of the Jews would + have been a great triumph, indeed, for Catholicism militant. The + conversion methods of the Dominican monk were of a most insinuating kind—he + usually began with a public religious disputation. Unfortunately, the Jews + were experts in the art of debate, and too often by their bold replies + covered the self-sufficient dignitaries of Rome with confusion. The Jews + should have known, from bitter experience, that such boldness would not be + passed over silently. From sumptuous debating hall to Dominican prison and + scaffold was but a short step. In 1391, one of these worthy soul-catchers, + Bishop Ferdinando Martinez, set the fanatical mob of Seville on the Jews, + and not without success. Terrorized by the threat of death, many accepted + Catholicism under duress. But they became Christians only in appearance; + in reality they remained true to the faith of their fathers, and, in + secret, running the risk of loss of life, they fulfilled all the Jewish + ordinances. This is the prologue to the thrilling Marrano tragedy. + </p> + <p> + Finally, the moment approached when gloomy Catholicism attained to + unchallenged supremacy in the Pyrenean Peninsula. On the ruins of the + enlightened culture of the Arabs, Ferdinand the Catholic and Isabella of + Castile reared the reactionary government of medieval Rome. The + Inquisition was introduced (1480). Torquemada presided as high priest over + the rites attending the human sacrifices. <i>Ad gloriam ecclesiae</i>, the + whole of Spain was illuminated. Everywhere the funeral pyres of the + Inquisition flared to the skies, the air was rent by the despairing + shrieks of martyrs enveloped in flames or racked by tortures, the prisons + overflowed with Marranos,—all instruments of torture were vigorously + plied. + </p> + <p> + At last the hour of redemption struck: in 1492 all Jews were driven from + Spain, and a few years later from Portugal. Jewish-Arabic culture after + five centuries of ascendency suffered a sudden collapse. The unhappy + people again grasped its staff, and wandered forth into the world without + knowing whither. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0014"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + X. THE RABBINIC-MYSTICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE GERMAN-POLISH + </h2> + <p> + JEWS (1492-1789) + </p> + <p> + The expulsion from Spain was a stunning blow. The hoary martyr people + which had defied so many storms in its long life was for a moment dazed. + The soil of Europe was quaking under its feet. At the time when the + medieval period had formally come to a close for Occidental Christendom, + and the modern period had opened, the middle ages continued in unmitigated + brutality for the Jews. If anything, the life of the Jews had become more + unendurable than before. What, indeed, had the much-vaunted modern age to + offer them? In the ranks of the humanistic movement Reuchlin alone stood + forth prominently as the advocate of the Jews, and he was powerless before + the prejudices of the populace. The Reformation in Germany and elsewhere + had illuminated the minds of the people, but had not softened their + hearts. Luther himself, the creator of the Reformation, was not innocent + of hating the followers of an alien faith. The Jews especially did not + enjoy too great a measure of his sympathies. The wars growing out of the + Reformation, which in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries devastated + Europe in the name of religion, were not calculated to favor the spread of + tolerance and milder manners. The conflict raging in the bosom of the + Church and setting her own children by the ears, was yet insufficient to + divert her maternal care from her "unbelieving" stepchildren. In Spain and + Portugal, stakes continued to burn two centuries longer for the benefit of + the Marranos, the false Christians. In Germany and Austria, the Jews were + kept in the same condition of servitude as before. Their economic + circumstances were appalling. They were forced to emigrate <i>en masse</i> + to Poland, which offered the adherents of their faith a comparatively + quiet life, and by and by was invested with the Jewish hegemony. Some of + the smaller states and independent towns of Italy also afforded the Jews + an asylum, though one not always to be depended upon. A group of + hard-driven Spanish exiles, for instance, under the leadership of + Abarbanel had found peace in Italy. The rest had turned to Turkey and her + province Palestine, + </p> + <p> + For a time, indeed, the Jewish spiritual centre was located in Turkey. + What Europe, old, Christian, and hardhearted, refused the Jews, was + granted them by Turkey, young, Mussulman, and liberal. On hearing of the + banishment of the Jews from Spain, Sultan Bajazet exclaimed: "How can you + call Ferdinand of Aragon a wise king, the same Ferdinand who has made his + land poor and enriched ours?" His amazement characterizes the relation of + Turkey to the Jews of the day. The one-time Marrano, Joseph Nassi, rose to + be a considerable dignitary at the court of Sultan Selim (1566-1580). + Occasionally he succeeded, by diplomatic means, in wreaking vengeance upon + European courts in retaliation for the brutal tortures inflicted upon his + people. With the generosity of a Maecenas, he assembled Jewish scholars + and poets, and surrounded himself with a sunlit atmosphere of + intellectuality and talent. All other Jewish communities looked up to that + of Constantinople. Now and again its rabbis played the part of Patriarchs + of the synagogue. To this commanding position the rabbis of Palestine + especially were inclined to lay claim. They even attempted to restore the + Patriarchate, and the famous controversy between Jacob Berab and Levi ben + Chabib regarding the <i>Semicha</i> is another evidence of the same + assertive tendency. Among the Spanish exiles settled in the Holy Land a + peculiar spiritual current set in. The storm-tossed wanderers, but now + returned to their native Jordan from the shores of the blood-stained Tagus + and Guadalquivir, were mightily moved at the sight of their ancestral + home. Ahasuerus, who on his thorn-strewn pilgrim's path had drained the + cup of woe to the dregs, suddenly caught sight of the home of his + childhood razed level with the ground. The precious, never-to-be-forgotten + ruins exhaled the home feeling, which took possession of him with + irresistible charm. Into his soul there flowed sweet memories of a golden + youth, past beyond recall. The impact of these emotions enkindled + passionate "longing for Zion" in the heart of the forlorn, homeless + martyr. He was seized by torturing thirst for political resurrection. Such + melancholy feelings and vehement outbursts found expression in the + practical Kabbala, originating with Ari (Isaac Luria) and his famous Safed + school. A mystical belief in the coming of Messiah thenceforward became + one of the essential elements of the Jewish spirit. It vanquished the + heart of the learned Joseph Karo, who had brought Rabbinism to its climax + by the compilation of his celebrated ritual code, the Shulchan Aruch. With + equal force it dominated the being of Solomon Molcho, the enthusiastic + youth who, at one time a Marrano, on his public return to Judaism + proclaimed the speedy regeneration of Israel. He sealed his faith in his + prophecy with death at the stake (1532). The Marranos beyond the Pyrenees + and the unfortunate Jews of Italy, who, in the second half of the + sixteenth century had to bear the brunt of papal fanaticism, on the + increase since the Reformation, were kept in a state of constant + excitement by this Messianic doctrine, with its obscure stirrings of hope. + A mournful national feeling pervades the Jewish literature of the time. + Recollections of torments endured enflamed all hearts. A series of + chronicles were thus produced that record the centuries of Jewish + martyrdom—<i>Jocha-sin, Shebet Jehuda, Emek ha-Bacha</i>, etc. The + art of printing, even then developed to a considerable degree of + perfection, became for the dispersed Jews the strongest bond of spiritual + union. The papal <i>index librorum prohibitorum</i> was impotent in the + face of the all-pervading propaganda for thought and feeling carried on by + the printing press. + </p> + <p> + After Palestine and Turkey, Holland for a time became the spiritual centre + of the scattered Jews (in the seventeenth century). Holland was warmly + attached to the cause of liberty. When it succeeded in freeing itself from + the clutches of fanatical Spain and her rapacious king, Philip II, it + inaugurated the golden era of liberty of conscience, of peaceful + development in culture and industry, and granted an asylum to the + persecuted and abandoned of all countries. By the thousands the harassed + Ghetto sons, especially the Marranos from Spain and Portugal, migrated to + Holland. Amsterdam became a second Cordova. The intellectual life was + quickened. Freedom from restraint tended to break down the national + exclusivism of the Jew, and intercourse with his liberal surroundings + varied his mental pursuits. Rabbinism, the Kabbala, philosophy, national + poetry—they all had their prominent representatives in Holland. + These manifold tendencies were united in the literary activity of Manasseh + ben Israel, a scholar of extensive, though not intensive, encyclopedic + attainments. Free thought and religious rationalism were embodied in Uriel + Acosta. To a still higher degree they were illustrated in the theory of + life expounded by the immortal author of the "Theologico-Political + Tractate" (1640-1677). This advanced state of culture in Holland did not + fail to react upon the neighboring countries. Under the impulse of + enthusiasm for the Bible Puritan England under Cromwell opened its portals + to the Jews. In Italy, in the dank atmosphere of rabbinical dialectics and + morbid mysticism, great figures loom up—Leon de Modena, the + antagonist of Rabbinism and of the Kabbala, and Joseph del Medigo, + mathematician, philosopher, and mystic, the disciple of Galileo. + </p> + <p> + These purple patches were nothing more than the accidents of a transition + period. The people as a whole was on the decline. The Jewish mind darted + hither and thither, like a startled bird seeking its nest. Holland or + Turkey was an inadequate substitute for Spain, if only for the reason that + but a tiny fraction of the Jews had found shelter in either. The Jewish + national centre must perforce coincide with the numerical centre of the + dispersed people, in which, moreover, conditions must grant Jews the + possibility of living undisturbed in closely compacted masses, and of + perfecting a well-knit organization of social and individual life. Outside + of Spain these conditions were fulfilled only by Poland, which gradually, + beginning with the sixteenth century, assumed the hegemony over the Jewry + of the world. This marks the displacement of the Sephardic (Spanish, in a + broader sense, Romanic) element, and the supremacy of the Ashkenazic + (German-Polish) element. + </p> + <p> + Poland had been a resort for Jewish immigrants from Germany since the + outbreak of the Crusades, until, in the sixteenth century, it rose to the + position of a Jewish centre of the first magnitude. As the merchant middle + class, the Jews were protected and advanced by the kings and the Szlachta. + The consequent security of their position induced so rapid a growth of the + Jewish element that in a little while the Jews of Poland outnumbered those + of the old Jewish settlements in Occidental Europe. The numerous + privileges granted the Jews, by Boleslaus of Kalish (1246), Kasimir the + Great (1347-1370), Witowt (1388), Kasimir IV (1447), and some of their + successors, fortified their position in the extended territory covered by + Poland, Lithuania, and the Ukraine. Their peculiar circumstances in Poland + left an impress upon their inner life. An intense mental activity was + called forth. This activity can be traced back to German beginnings, + though at the same time it is made up of many original elements. For a + space Rabbinism monopolized the intellectual endeavors of the Polish Jews. + The rabbi of Cracow, Moses Isserles, and the rabbi of Ostrog, Solomon + Luria (d. 1572), disputed first place with the foremost rabbinical + authorities of other countries. Their decisions and circular letters + regarding religious and legal questions were accorded binding force. + Associates and successors of theirs founded Talmud academies throughout + the country, and large numbers of students attended them. Commentators + upon the Talmud and expounders of classical works in Jewish theological + literature appeared in shoals. Jewish printing establishments in Cracow + and Lublin were assiduous in turning out a mass of writings, which spread + the fame of the Polish rabbis to the remotest communities. The large + autonomy enjoyed by the Polish and Lithuanian Jews conferred executive + power upon rabbinical legislation. The <i>Kahal</i>, or Jewish communal + government, to a certain degree invested with judicial and administrative + competence, could not do without the guiding hand of the rabbis as + interpreters of the law. The guild of rabbis, on their side, chose a + "college of judges," with fairly extensive jurisdiction, from among their + own members. The organization of the Rabbinical Conferences, or the + "Synods of the Four Countries," formed the keystone of this intricate + social-spiritual hierarchy. The comprehensive inner autonomy and the + system of Talmud academies (<i>Yeshiboth</i>) that covered the whole of + Poland remind one of the brilliant days of the Exilarchate and the + Babylonia of the Geonim. One element was lacking, there was no versatile, + commanding thinker like Saadia Gaon. Secular knowledge and philosophy were + under the ban in Poland. Rabbinism absorbed the whole output of + intellectual energy. As little as the Poles resembled the Arabs of the + "golden age," did the Polish Jews resemble their brethren in faith in the + Orient at Saadia's time or in the Spain of Gabirol and Maimonides. + Isolation and clannishness were inevitable in view of the character of the + Christian environment and the almost insuperable barriers raised between + the classes of Polish society. But it was this exclusiveness that gave + peculiar stability and completeness to the life of the Jew as an + individual and as a member of Jewish society, and it was the same + exclusiveness that afforded opportunity for the development of a sharply + defined culture, for its fixation to the point of resisting violent shocks + and beyond the danger point of extinction through foreign invasion. + </p> + <p> + The fateful year 1648 formed a turning point in the history of the Polish + Jews, as in the history of the countries belonging to the Polish crown. + The Cossack butcheries and wars of extermination of 1648-1658 were the + same for the Polish Jews that the Crusades, the Black Death, and all the + other occasions for carnage had been for the Jews of Western Europe. It + seemed as though history desired to avoid the reproach of partiality, and + hastened to mete out even-handed justice by apportioning the same measure + of woe to the Jews of Poland as to the Jews of Western Europe. But the + Polish Jews were prepared to accept the questionable gift from the hands + of history. They had mounted that eminence of spiritual stability on which + suffering loses the power to weaken its victim, but, on the contrary, + endues him with strength. More than ever they shrank into their shell. + They shut themselves up more completely in their inner world, and became + morally dulled against the persecutions, the bitter humiliations, the deep + scorn, which their surroundings visited upon them. The Polish Jew + gradually accustomed himself to his pitiable condition. He hardly knew + that life might be other than it was. That the Polish lord to whom he was + a means of entertainment might treat him with a trace of respect, or that + his neighbors, the middle class merchant, the German guild member, and the + Little Russian peasant, might cherish kindly feelings toward him, he could + not conceive as a possibility. Seeing himself surrounded by enemies, he + took precautions to fortify his camp, not so much to protect himself + against hostile assaults from without—they were inevitable—as + to paralyze the disastrous consequences of such assaults in his inner + world. To compass this end he brought into play all the means suggested by + his exceptional position before the law and by his own peculiar social + constitution. The <i>Kahal</i>, the autonomous rabbinical administration + of communal affairs, more and more assumed the character of an inner + dictatorship. Jewish society was persistently kept under the discipline of + rigid principles. In many affairs the synagogue attained the position of a + court of final appeal. The people were united, or rather packed, into a + solid mass by purely mechanical processes—by pressure from without, + and by drawing tight a noose from within. Besides this social factor + tending to consolidate the Jewish people into a separate union, an + intellectual lever was applied to produce the same result. Rabbinism + employed the mystical as its adjutant. The one exercised control over all + minds, the other over all hearts. The growth of mysticism was fostered + both by the unfortunate conditions under which the Polish Jews endured + existence and by the Messianic movements which made their appearance among + the Jews of other countries. + </p> + <p> + In the second half of the seventeenth century, mysticism reached its + zenith in Turkey, the country in which, had stood the cradle of the + "practical Kabbala." The teachings of Ari, Vital, and the school + established by them spread like wildfire. Messianic extravagances + intoxicated the baited and persecuted people. In Smyrna appeared the false + Messiah, Sabbatai Zebi. As by magic he attracted to himself a tremendous + company of adherents in the East and in the West. For a quarter of a + century (1650-1676), he kept the Jewish communities everywhere in a state + of quivering suspense. + </p> + <p> + The harassed people tossed to and fro like a fever patient, and raved + about political re-birth. Its delirious visions still further heated its + agitated blood. It came to its senses but slowly. Not even the apostasy + and death of Sabbatai Zebi sufficed to sober all his followers. Under the + guise of a symbolic faith in a Messiah, many of them, publicly or + secretly, continued the propaganda for his doctrines. + </p> + <p> + This propaganda prepared the fertile soil from which, in the eighteenth + century, shot up Messianic systems, tending to split Judaism into sects. + Nowhere did the mystical teachings evoke so ready a response as in Poland, + the very centre of Judaism. At first an ally of the rabbinical school, + mysticism grown passionate and uncontrollable now and again acted as the + violent opponent of Rabbinism. Secret devotion to the Sabbatian doctrines, + which had made their home in Poland, sometimes led to such extremes in + dogma and ethics that the rabbis could not contain themselves. Chayyim + Malach, Judah Chassid, and other Galician mystics, in the second decade of + the eighteenth century brought down upon themselves a rabbinical decree of + excommunication. The mystical tendency was the precursor of the heretical + half-Christian sect of Frankists, who ventured so far as to lift a hand + against the fundamentals of Judaism: they rejected the Talmud in favor of + the Zohar (1756-1773). At the same time a much more profound movement, + instinct with greater vitality, made its appearance among the + Polish-Jewish masses, a movement rooted in their social and spiritual + organization. The wretched, debased condition of the average Jew, + conjoined with the traditions of the Kabbala and the excrescences of + Rabbinism, created a foothold for Chassidic teaching. Chassidism replaced + Talmudic ratiocination by exalted religious sentiment. By the force of + enthusiasm for faith, it drew its adherents together into a firmly welded + unit in contrast with Rabbinism, which sought the same goal by the aid of + the formal law. Scenting danger, the rabbinical hierarchy declared war + upon the Kabbala. Emden opposed Eibeschütz, the Polish Sabbatians and + Frankists were fought to the death, the Wilna Gaon organized a campaign + against the Chassidim. Too late! Rabbinism was too old, too arid, to tone + down the impulsive outbreaks of passion among the people. In their + religious exaltation the masses were looking for an elixir. They were + languishing, not for light to illumine the reason, but for warmth to set + the heart aglow. They desired to lose themselves in ecstatic + self-renunciation. Chassidism and its necessary dependence upon the Zaddik + offered the masses the means of this forgetfulness of self through faith. + They were the medium through which the people saw the world in a rosy + light, and the consequences following upon their prevalence were seen in a + marked intensification of Jewish exclusiveness. + </p> + <p> + The same aloofness characterizes the Jews of the rest of the eighteenth + century diaspora. Wherever, as in Germany, Austria, and Italy, Jews were + settled in considerable numbers, they were separated from their + surroundings by forbidding Ghetto walls. On the whole, no difference is + noticeable between conditions affecting Jews in one country and those in + another. Everywhere they were merely tolerated, everywhere oppressed and + humiliated. The bloody persecutions of the middle ages were replaced by + the burden of the exceptional laws, which in practice degraded the Jews + socially to an inferior race, to citizens of a subordinate degree. The + consequences were uniformly the same in all countries: spiritual isolation + and a morbid religious mood. During the first half of the "century of + reason," Jewry presented the appearance of an exhausted wanderer, heavily + dragging himself on his way, his consciousness clouded, his trend of + thought obviously anti-rationalistic. At the very moment in which Europe + was beginning to realize its medieval errors and repent of them, and the + era of universal ideals of humanity was dawning, Judaism raised barricades + between itself and the world at large. Elijah Gaon and Israel Besht were + the contemporaries of Voltaire and Rousseau. Apparently there was no + possibility of establishing communication between these two diametrically + opposed worlds. But history is a magician. Not far from the Poland + enveloped in medieval darkness, the morning light of a new life was + breaking upon slumbering Jewry in German lands. New voices made themselves + heard, reverberating like an echo to the appeal issued by the "great + century" in behalf of a spiritual and social regeneration of mankind. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0015"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + XI. THE MODERN PERIOD OF ENLIGHTENMENT (THE NINETEENTH CENTURY) + </h2> + <p> + Two phenomena signalized the beginning of the latest period in Jewish + history: the lofty activity of Mendelssohn and the occurrence of the great + French Revolution. The man stands for the spiritual emancipation of the + Jews, the movement for their political emancipation. At bottom, these two + phenomena were by no means the ultimate causes of the social and spiritual + regeneration of the Jewish people. They were only the products of the more + general causes that had effected a similar regeneration in all the peoples + of Western Europe. The new currents, the abandonment of effete + intellectual and social forms, the substitution of juster and more + energetic principles, the protest against superstition and despotism—all + these traits had a common origin, the resuscitation of reason and free + thought, which dominated all minds without asking whether they belonged to + Jew or to Christian. It might seem that the rejuvenation of the Jews had + been consummated more rapidly than the rejuvenation of the other peoples. + The latter had had two centuries, the period elapsing since the middle + ages, that is, the period between the Reformation and the great + Revolution, in which to prepare for a more rational and a more humane + conduct of life. As for the Jews, their middle ages began much later, and + ended later, almost on the eve of 1789, so that the revolution in their + minds and their mode of life had to accomplish itself hastily, under the + urgence of swiftly crowding events, by the omission of intermediate + stages. But it must be taken into consideration that long before, in the + Judeo-Hellenic and in the Arabic-Spanish period, the Jews had passed + through their "century of reason." In spite of the intervening ages of + suffering and gloom, the faculty of assimilating new principles had + survived. For the descendants of Philo and Maimonides the rationalistic + movement of the eighteenth century was in part a repetition of a + well-known historical process. They had had the benefit of a similar + course of studies before, and, therefore, had no need to cram on the eve + of the final examination. + </p> + <p> + In point of fact, the transformation in the life of the Jews did take + place with extraordinary swiftness. It was hastened in France by the + principles of the Revolution and the proclamation of the civil equality of + Jews with the other citizens. In Germany, however, it advanced upon purely + spiritual lines. Mendelssohn and Lessing, the heralds of spiritual reform, + who exposed old prejudices, carried on their labors at a time in which the + Jews still stood beyond the pale of the law, a condition which it did not + occur to Frederick II, "the philosopher upon the throne," to improve. A + whole generation was destined to pass before the civil emancipation of the + German Jews was accomplished. Meantime their spiritual emancipation + proceeded apace, without help from the ruling powers. A time so early as + the end of the eighteenth century found the German Jews in a position to + keep step with their Christian fellow-citizens in cultural progress. + Enlightened Jews formed close connections with enlightened Christians, and + joined them in the universal concerns of mankind as confederates espousing + the same fundamental principles. If they renounced some of their religious + and national traditions, it was by no means out of complaisance for their + neighbors. They were guided solely and alone by those universal principles + that forced non-Jews as well as Jews to reject many traditions as + incompatible with reason and conscience. Non-Jews and Jews alike yielded + themselves up to the fresh inspiration of the time, and permitted + themselves to be carried along by the universal transforming movement. + Mendelssohn himself, circumspect and wise, did not move off from religious + national ground. But the generation after him abandoned his position for + that of universal humanity, or, better, German nationality. His successors + intoxicated themselves with deep draughts of the marvelous poetry created + by the magic of Goethe and Schiller. They permitted themselves to be + rushed along by the liberty doctrines of 1789, they plunged head over + heels into the vortex of romanticism, and took an active part in the + conspicuous movements of Europe, political, social, and literary, as + witness Bôrne, Heine, and their fellow-combatants. + </p> + <p> + The excitement soon evaporated. When the noise of the liberty love-feasts + had subsided, when the cruel reaction (after 1814) had settled heavily + upon the Europe of the nineteenth century, and God's earth had again + become the arena of those agents of darkness whom dreamers had thought + buried forever beneath the ruins of the old order, then the German Jews, + or such of them as thought, came to their senses. The more intelligent + Jewish circles realized that, in devotion to the German national movement, + they had completely neglected their own people. Yet their people, too, had + needs, practical or spiritual, had its peculiar national sphere of + activity, circumscribed, indeed, by the larger sphere of mankind's + activities as by a concentric circle, but by no means merged into it. To + atone for their sin, thinking Jews retraced their steps. They took in hand + the transforming of Jewish inner life, the simplification of the extremely + complicated Jewish ritual, the remodeling of pedagogic methods, and, above + all, the cultivation of the extended fields of Jewish science, whose head + and front is Jewish historical research in all its vastness and detail. + Heine's friend, Zunz, laid the cornerstone of Jewish science in the second + decade of the nineteenth century. His work was taken up by a goodly + company of zealous and able builders occupied for half a century with the + task of rearing the proud edifice of a scientific historical literature, + in which national self-consciousness was sheltered and fostered. At the + very height of this reforming and literary activity, German Jewry was + overwhelmed by the civil emancipation of 1848. Again a stirring movement + drew them into sympathy with a great general cause, but this time without + drawing them away from Jewish national interests. Cultural and civil + assimilation was accomplished as an inner compelling necessity, as a + natural outcome of living. But spiritual assimilation, in the sense of a + merging of Judaism in foreign elements, was earnestly repudiated by the + noblest representatives of Judaism. It was their ideal that universal + activity and national activity should be pursued to the prejudice of + neither, certainly not to the exclusion of one or the other, but in + perfect harmony with each other. In point of fact, it may be asserted + that, in spite of a frequent tendency to go to the one or the other + extreme, the two currents, the universal and the national, co-exist within + German Jewry, and there is no fear of their uniting, they run parallel + with each other. The Jewish genius is versatile. Without hurt to itself it + can be active in all sorts of careers: in politics and in civil life, in + parliament and on the lecture platform, in all branches of science and + departments of literature, in every one of the chambers of mankind's + intellectual laboratory. At the same time it has its domestic hearth, its + national sanctuary; it has its sphere of original work and its + self-consciousness, its national interests and spiritual ideals rooted in + the past of the Jew. By the side of a Lassalle, a Lasker, and a Marx + towers a Riesser, a Geiger, a Graetz. The leveling process unavoidably + connected with widespread culture, so far from causing spiritual + desolation in German Judaism, has, on the contrary, furnished redundant + proof that even under present conditions, so unfavorable to what is + individual and original, the Jewish people has preserved its vitality to + the full. + </p> + <p> + An analogous movement stirred the other countries of Western Europe—France, + Italy, and England. The political emancipation of the Jews was + accomplished earlier in them than in Germany. The reconstruction of the + inner life, too, proceeded more quietly and regularly, without leaps and + bounds, and religious reform established itself by degrees. Yet even here, + where the Jewish contingent was insignificant, the spiritual physiognomy + of the Jews maintained its typical character. In these countries, as in + Germany, the Jew assimilated European culture with all its advantages and + its drawbacks. He was active on diplomatic fields, he devoted himself to + economic investigations, he produced intellectual creations of all kinds—first + and last he felt himself to be a citizen of his country. None the less he + was a loyal son of the Jewish people considered as a spiritual people with + an appointed task. Crémieux, Beaconsfield, Luzzatti are counterbalanced by + Salvador, Frank, Munk, Reggio, and Montefiore. All the good qualities and + the shortcomings distinctive of the civilization of modern times adhere to + the Jew. But at its worst modern civilization has not succeeded in + extinguishing the national spirit in Jewry. The national spirit continues + to live in the people, and it is this spirit that quickens the people. The + genius of Jewish history, as in centuries gone by, holds watch over the + sons of the "eternal people" scattered to all ends of the earth. + West-European Jewry may say of itself, without presumption: <i>Cogito ergo + sum</i>. + </p> + <p> + Russian Jewry, the Jewry that had been Polish, and that is counted by the + millions, might, if necessary, prove its existence by even more tangible + marks than Occidental Jewry. To begin with, the centre of gravity of the + Jewish nation lies in Russia, whose Jews not only outnumber those of the + rest of Europe, but continue to live in a compact mass. Besides, they have + preserved the original Jewish culture and their traditional physiognomy to + a higher degree than the Jews of other countries. The development of the + Russian Jews took a course very different from that of the Jews of the + West. This difference was conditioned by the tremendous contrast between + Russian culture and West-European culture, and by the change which the + external circumstances of Jews outside of Russia underwent during the + modern period. The admission of the Polish provinces into the Russian + Empire at the end of the eighteenth century found the numerous Jewish + population in an almost medieval condition, the same condition in which + the non-Jewish population of Russian Poland was at that time. The Polish + regime, as we saw above, had isolated the Jews alike in civil and + spiritual relations. The new order did not break down the barriers. The + masses of Jews cooped up in the "Pale of Settlement" were strong only by + reason of their inner unity, their firmly established patriarchal + organization. The bulwark of Rabbinism and the citadel of Chassidism + protected them against alien influences. They guarded their isolation + jealously. True to the law of inertia, they would not allow the privilege + of isolation to be wrested from them. They did not care to step beyond the + ramparts. Why, indeed, should the Jews have quitted their fortress, if + outside of their walls they could expect nothing but scorn and blows? The + unfortunates encaged in the sinister Pale of Settlement could have been + lured out of their exclusive position only by complete civil emancipation + combined with a higher degree of culture than had been attained by Russian + society, an impossible set of circumstances in the first half of the + nineteenth century. The legislative measures of the time, in so far as + they relate to the Jews, breathe the spirit of police surveillance rather + than of enlightenment and humanity. To civilizing and intellectual + influences from without the way was equally barred. Yet all this + watchfulness was of no avail. Nothing could prevent the liberty principles + espoused by the Jews of Western Europe from being smuggled into the Pale, + to leaven the sad, serried masses. A sluggish process of fermentation set + in, and culminated in the literary activity of Isaac Beer Levinsohn and of + the Wilna reformers of the second and fourth decades of the nineteenth + century. They were the harbingers of approaching spring. + </p> + <p> + When spring finally came (after 1855), and the sun sent down his genial + rays upon the wretched Jewry of Russia, life and activity began to appear + at once, especially in the upper strata. As in Germany, so in Russia + spiritual emancipation preceded political emancipation. Still shorn almost + entirely of the elementary rights of citizens, the Russian Jews + nevertheless followed their ideal promptings, and participated + enthusiastically in the movement for enlightenment which at that time held + the noblest of the Russians enthralled. In a considerable portion of the + Russian Jewish community a process of culture regeneration began, an eager + throwing off of outworn forms of life and thought, a swift adoption of + humane principles. Jewish young men crowded into the secular schools, in + which they came in close contact with their Christian contemporaries. + Influenced by their new companions, they gave themselves up to Russian + national movements, often at the cost of renunciation of self. Some of + them, indeed, in one-sided aspiration strove to become, not Russians, but + men. The influence exercised by literature was more moderate than that of + the schools. Rabbinic and Chassidistic literature, on the point of dying + out as it was, abandoned the field to the literature of enlightenment in + the Hebrew language, a literature of somewhat primitive character. It + consisted chiefly of naive novels and of didactic writings of publicists, + and lacked the solid scientific and historical element that forms the + crown of Western Jewish literature. It is indisputable, however, that it + exerted an educational influence. Besides, it possesses the merit of + having resuscitated one of the most valuable of Jewish national + possessions, the Hebrew language in its purity, which in Russia alone has + become a pliant instrument of literary expression. A still greater field + was reserved for the Jewish-Russian literature that arose in the + "sixties." It was called into being in order to present a vivid and true + picture of the social and spiritual interests of the Jews. Proceeding from + discussions of current political topics, this literature gradually widened + its limits so as to include Jewish history, Jewish science, and the + portrayal of Jewish life, and more and more approached the character of a + normal European literature. All this was in the making, and the most + important work had not yet begun. The lower strata of the people had not + been touched by the fresh air. In time, if all had gone well, they, too, + would have had their day. And if the minority of the Jewish people in the + West in a short span of time brought forth so many notable workers in so + many departments of life and thought, how much superior would be the + culture achievements of the Eastern majority! How vigorously the mighty + mental forces latent in Russian Jewry would develop when their advance was + no longer obstructed by all sorts of obstacles, and they could be applied + to every sphere of political, social, and intellectual life! + </p> + <p> + Nothing of all this came to pass; exactly the opposite happened. Not only + were the barriers in the way of a prosperous, free development of Jewry + not removed, but fresh hindrances without number were multiplied. Some + spectre of the middle ages, some power of darkness, put brakes upon the + wheel of history. It first appeared in the West, under the name + anti-Semitism, among the dregs of European society. But in its earliest + abode it was and is still met with an abrupt rebuff on the part of the + most intelligent circles, those whom even the present age of decadence has + not succeeded in robbing of belief in lofty moral ideals. Anti-Semitism in + the West is in <i>anima vili</i>. Its cult is confined to a certain party, + which enjoys a rather scandalous reputation. But there are countries in + which this power of darkness, in the coarser form of Judophobia<a + href="#linknote-13" name="linknoteref-13" id="noteref-13"><small>13</small></a>, + has cast its baleful spell upon the most influential members of society + and upon the press. There it has ripened noxious fruit. Mocking at the + exalted ideals and the ethical traditions of religious and thinking + mankind, Judophobia shamelessly professes the dogma of misanthropy. Its + propaganda is bringing about the moral ruin of an immature society, not + yet confirmed in ethical or truly religious principles. Upon its victims, + the Jews, it has the same effect as the misfortunes of the middle ages, + which were meted out to our hoary people with overflowing measure, and + against which it learnt to assume an armor of steel. The recent severe + trials are having the same result as the persecutions of former days: they + do not weaken, on the contrary, they invigorate the Jewish spirit, they + spur on to thought, they stimulate the pulse of the people. + </p> +<pre xml:space="preserve"> + "The hammer shivers glass, + But iron by its blows is forged."<a href="#linknote-14" name="linknoteref-14" + id="noteref-14">14</a> +</pre> + <p> + The historical process Jewry has undergone repeatedly, it must undergo + once again. But now, too, in this blasting time of confusion and + dispersion, of daily torture and the horrors of international conflict, + "the keeper of Israel slumbereth not and sleepeth not." The Jewish spirit + is on the alert. It is ever purging and tempering itself in the furnace of + suffering. The people which justly bears the name of the veteran of + history withdraws and falls into a revery. It is not a narrow-minded + fanatic's flight from the world, but the concentrated thought of a + mourner. Jewry is absorbed in contemplation of its great, unparalleled + past. More than ever it is now in need of the teachings of its past, of + the moral support and the prudent counsels of its history, its four + thousand years of life crowded with checkered experiences. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_4_0016"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + XII. THE TEACHINGS OF JEWISH HISTORY + </h2> + <p> + Let us return now to the starting point of our discussion, and endeavor to + establish the thoughts and lessons to be deduced from the course of Jewish + history. + </p> + <p> + Above all, Jewish history possesses the student with the conviction that + Jewry at all times, even in the period of political independence, was + pre-eminently a spiritual nation, and a spiritual nation it continues to + be in our own days, too. Furthermore, it inspires him with the belief that + Jewry, being a spiritual entity, cannot suffer annihilation: the body, the + mold, may be destroyed, the spirit is immortal. Bereft of country and + dispersed as it is, the Jewish nation lives, and will go on living, + because a creative principle permeates it, a principle that is the root of + its being and an indigenous product of its history. This principle + consists first in a sum of definite religious, moral, or philosophic + ideals, whose exponent at all times was the Jewish people, either in its + totality, or in the person of its most prominent representatives. Next, + this principle consists in a sum of historical memories, recollections of + what in the course of many centuries the Jewish people experienced, + thought, and felt, in the depths of its being. Finally, it consists in the + consciousness that true Judaism, which has accomplished great things for + humanity in the past, has not yet played out its part, and, therefore, may + not perish. In short, the Jewish people lives because it contains a living + soul which refuses to separate from its integument, and cannot be forced + out of it by heavy trials and misfortunes, such as would unfailingly + inflict mortal injury upon less sturdy organisms. + </p> + <p> + This self-consciousness is the source from which the suffering Jewish soul + draws comfort. History speaks to it constantly through the mouth of the + great apostle who went forth from the midst of Israel eighteen hundred + years ago: "Call to remembrance the former days, in which, after ye were + enlightened, ye endured a great conflict of sufferings; partly, being made + a gazing-stock both by reproaches and afflictions; and partly, becoming + partakers with them that were so used.... Cast not away therefore your + boldness, which hath great recompense of reward" (Epistle to the Hebrews, + x, 32-34, 35). + </p> + <p> + Jewish history, moreover, arouses in the Jew the desire to work + unceasingly at the task of perfecting himself. To direct his attention to + his glorious past, to the resplendent intellectual feats of his ancestors, + to their masterly skill in thinking and suffering, does not lull him to + sleep, does not awaken a dullard's complacency or hollow self-conceit. On + the contrary, it makes exacting demands upon him. Jewish history + admonishes the Jews: "<i>Noblesse oblige</i>. The privilege of belonging + to a people to whom the honorable title of the 'veteran of history' has + been conceded, puts serious responsibilities on your shoulders. You must + demonstrate that you are worthy of your heroic past. The descendants of + teachers of religion and martyrs of the faith dare not be insignificant, + not to say wicked. If the long centuries of wandering and misery have + inoculated you with faults, extirpate them in the name of the exalted + moral ideals whose bearers you were commissioned to be. If, in the course + of time, elements out of harmony with your essential being have fastened + upon your mind, cast them out, purify yourselves. In all places and at all + times, in joy and and in sorrow, you must aim to live for the higher, the + spiritual interests. But never may you deem yourselves perfect. If you + become faithless to these sacred principles, you sever the bonds that + unite you with the most vital elements of your past, with the first cause + of your national existence." + </p> + <p> + The final lesson to be learned is that in the sunny days of mankind's + history, in which reason, justice, and philanthropic instinct had the + upper hand, the Jews steadfastly made common cause with the other nations. + Hand in hand with them, they trod the path leading to perfection. But in + the dark days, during the reign of rude force, prejudice, and passion, of + which they were the first victims, the Jews retired from the world, + withdrew into their shell, to await better days. Union with mankind at + large, on the basis of the spiritual and the intellectual, the goal set up + by the Jewish Prophets in their sublime vision of the future (Isaiah, ch. + ii, and Micah, ch. iv), is the ultimate ideal of Judaism's noblest + votaries. Will their radiant hope ever attain to realization? If ever it + should be realized,—and it is incumbent upon us to believe that it + will,—not a slight part of the merits involved will be due to Jewish + history. We have adverted to the lofty moral and humanitarian significance + of Jewish history in its role as conciliator. With regard to one-half of + Jewish history, this conciliatory power is even now a well-established + fact. The first part of Jewish history, the Biblical part, is a source + from which, for many centuries, millions of human beings belonging to the + most diverse denominations have derived instruction, solace, and + inspiration. It is read with devotion by Christians in both hemispheres, + in their houses and their temples. Its heroes have long ago become types, + incarnations of great ideas. The events it relates serve as living ethical + formulas. But a time will come—perhaps it is not very far off—when + the second half of Jewish history, the record of the two thousand years of + the Jewish people's life after the Biblical period, will be accorded the + same treatment. This latter part of Jewish history is not yet known, and + many, in the thrall of prejudice, do not wish to know it. But ere long it + will be known and appreciated. For the thinking portion of mankind it will + be a source of uplifting moral and philosophical teaching. The thousand + years' martyrdom of the Jewish people, its unbroken pilgrimage, its tragic + fate, its teachers of religion, its martyrs, philosophers, champions, this + whole epic will in days to come sink deep into the memory of men. It will + speak to the heart and the conscience of men, not merely to their curious + mind. It will secure respect for the silvery hair of the Jewish people, a + people of thinkers and sufferers. It will dispense consolation to the + afflicted, and by its examples of spiritual steadfastness and self-denial + encourage martyrs in their devotion. It is our firm conviction that the + time is approaching in which the second half of Jewish history will be to + the noblest part of <i>thinking</i> humanity what its first half has long + been to <i>believing</i> humanity, a source of sublime moral truths. In + this sense, Jewish history in its entirety is the pledge of the spiritual + union between the Jews and the rest of the nations. + </p> + <p> + <br /><br /> + </p> + <hr /> + <p> + <a name="link2H_FOOT"> </a> + </p> + <div style="height: 4em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + <h2> + FOOTNOTES: + </h2> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-1" id="note-1"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 1 (<a href="#linknoteref-1">return</a>)<br /> [ In the introduction to his <i>Historische + Mitteilungen, Vorarbeiten zu einer Geschichte der pol-nischrussischen + Juden</i>.] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-2" id="note-2"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 2 (<a href="#linknoteref-2">return</a>)<br /> [ "The primitive peoples that + change with their environment, constantly adapting themselves to their + habitat and to external nature, have no history.... Only those nations and + states belong to history which display self-conscious action; which evince + an inner spiritual life by diversified manifestations; and combine into an + organic whole what they receive from without, and what they themselves + originate." (Introduction to Weber's <i>Allgemeine Weltgeschichte</i>, i, + pp. 16-18.)] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-3" id="note-3"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 3 (<a href="#linknoteref-3">return</a>)<br /> [ "History, without these (inner, + spiritual elements), is a shell without a kernel; and such is almost all + the history which is extant in the world." (Macaulay, on Mitford's History + of Greece, Collected Works, i, 198, ed. A. and C. Armstrong and Son.)] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-4" id="note-4"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 4 (<a href="#linknoteref-4">return</a>)<br /> [ A Jewish historian makes the + pregnant remark: "If ever the time comes when the prophecies of the Jewish + seers are fulfilled, and nation no longer raises the sword against nation; + when the olive leaf instead of the laurel adorns the brow of the great, + and the achievements of noble minds are familiar to the dwellers in + cottages and palaces alike, then the history of the world will have the + same character as Jewish history. On its pages will be inscribed, not the + warrior's prowess and his victories, nor diplomatic schemes and triumphs, + but the progress of culture and its practical application in real life."] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-5" id="note-5"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 5 (<a href="#linknoteref-5">return</a>)<br /> [ A different aspect of the same + thought is presented with logical clearness in another publication by our + author. "The national <i>idea</i>, and the national <i>feeling</i>," says + Mr. Dubnow, "must be kept strictly apart. Unfortunately the difference + between them is usually obliterated. National feeling is spontaneous. To a + greater or less degree it is inborn in all the members of the nation as a + feeling of kinship. It has its flood-tide and its ebbtide in + correspondence to external conditions, either forcing the nation to defend + its nationality, or relieving it of the necessity for self-defense. As + this feeling is not merely a blind impulse, but a complicated psychic + phenomenon, it can be subjected to a psychologic analysis. From the given + historical facts or the ideas that have become the common treasure of a + nation, thinking men, living life consciously, can, in one way or another, + derive the origin, development, and vital force of its national feeling. + The results of such an analysis, arranged in some sort of system, form the + content of the national idea. The task of the national idea it is to + clarify the national feeling, and give it logical sanction for the benefit + of those who cannot rest satisfied with an unconscious feeling. + </p> + <p class="foot"> + "In what, to be specific, does the essence of our Jewish national idea + consist? Or, putting the question in another form, what is the cement that + unites us into a single compact organism? Territory and government, the + external ties usually binding a nation together, we have long ago lost. + Their place is filled by abstract principles, by religion and race. + Undeniably these are factors of first importance, and yet we ask the + question, do they alone and exclusively maintain the national cohesion of + Jewry? No, we reply, for if we admitted this proposition, we should by + consequence have to accept the inference, that the laxity of religious + principle prevailing among free-thinking Jews, and the obliteration of + race peculiarities in the 'civilized' strata of our people, bring in their + train a corresponding weakening, or, indeed, a complete breaking up, of + our national foundations—which in point of fact is not the case. On + the contrary, it is noticeable that the latitudinarians, the <i>libres + penseurs</i>, and the indifferent on the subject of religion, stand in the + forefront of all our national movements. Seeing that to belong to it is in + most cases heroism, and in many martyrdom, what is it that attracts these + Jews so forcibly to their people? There must be something common to us + all, so comprehensive that in the face of multifarious views and degrees + of culture it acts as a consolidating force. This 'something,' I am + convinced, is the community of historical fortunes of all the scattered + parts of the Jewish nation. We are welded together by our glorious past. + We are encircled by a mighty chain of similar historical impressions + suffered by our ancestors, century after century pressing in upon the + Jewish soul, and leaving behind a substantial deposit. In short, the + Jewish national idea is based chiefly upon the historical consciousness." + (Footnote Note of the German trl.)] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-6" id="note-6"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 6 (<a href="#linknoteref-6">return</a>)<br /> [ "If there are ranks in + suffering, Israel takes precedence of all the nations—if the + duration of sorrows and the patience with which they are borne ennoble, + the Jews are among the aristocracy of every land—if a literature is + called rich in the possession of a few classic tragedies, what shall we + say to a National Tragedy lasting for fifteen hundred years, in which the + poets and the actors were also the heroes?" (Zunz, <i>Die synagogale + Poesie</i>. Translation by George Eliot in "Daniel Deronda.")] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-7" id="note-7"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 7 (<a href="#linknoteref-7">return</a>)<br /> [ As examples and a proof of the + strong humanitarian influence Jewish history exercises upon Christians, I + would point to the relation established between the Jews and two + celebrities of the nineteenth century, Schleiden and George Eliot. In his + old age, the great scientist and thinker accidentally, in the course of + his study of sources for the history of botany, became acquainted with + medieval Jewish history. It filled him with ardent enthusiasm for the + Jews, for their intellectual strength, their patience under martyrdom. + Dominated by this feeling, he wrote the two admirable sketches: <i>Die + Bedeutung der Juden für Erhaltung und Wiederbelebung der Wissenschaften im + Mittelalter</i> (1876) and <i>Die Romantik des Martyriums bei den Juden im + Mittelalter</i> (1878). According to his own confession, the impulse to + write them was "the wish to take at least the first step toward making + partial amends for the unspeakable wrong inflicted by Christians upon + Jews." As for George Eliot, it may not be generally known that it was her + reading of histories of the Jews that inspired her with the profound + veneration for the Jewish people to which she gave glowing utterance in + "Daniel Deronda." (She cites Zunz, was personally acquainted with Emanuel + Deutsch, and carried on a correspondence with Professor Dr. David + Kaufmann. See <i>George Eliot's Life as related in her Letters and + Journals</i>. Arranged and edited by her husband, J. W. Cross, Vol. iii, + ed. Harper and Brothers.) Her enthusiasm prompted her, in 1879, to indite + her passionate apology for the Jews, under the title, "The Modern Hep! + Hep! Hep!"] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-8" id="note-8"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 8 (<a href="#linknoteref-8">return</a>)<br /> [ Pushkin.] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-9" id="note-9"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 9 (<a href="#linknoteref-9">return</a>)<br /> [ This is the true recondite + meaning of the verses Exod. vi, 2-3: "And God spake unto Moses, and said + unto him, I am the Eternal: and I appeared unto Abraham, unto Isaac, and + unto Jacob, as <i>El-Shaddai</i> (God Almighty), but by my name Eternal I + was not known unto them."] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-10" id="note-10"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 10 (<a href="#linknoteref-10">return</a>)<br /> [ "Ye have forsaken me," says + God unto Israel, "and served other gods; wherefore I will deliver you no + more. Go and cry unto the gods which ye have chosen: let them deliver you + in the time of your tribulations" (Judges X, 13-14). The same idea is + brought out still more forcibly in the arguments adduced by Jephthah in + his message to the king of Ammon (more correctly, Moab), who had laid + claim to Israelitish lands: "Thou," says Jephthah, "mayest possess that + which Kemosh thy god giveth thee to possess, but what the Lord our God + giveth us to possess, that will we possess" (Judges xi, 24). Usually these + words are taken ironically; to me they seem to convey literal truth rather + than irony.] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-11" id="note-11"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 11 (<a href="#linknoteref-11">return</a>)<br /> [ Two Biblical passages, the + one from Deuteronomy, the other from Deutero-Isaiah, afford a signal + illustration of the contrast between the religious nationalism of the + Mosaic law and the universalism of the Prophets. Moses says to Israel: + "Thou art an holy people unto the Lord thy God: the Lord thy God hath + chosen thee to be a special people unto himself, above all people that are + upon the face of the earth. The Lord did not set his love upon you, nor + choose you, because ye were more in number than any people: for ye were + the fewest of all people. But because the Lord loved you...." (Deut. vii, + 6-8). And these are the words of the prophecy: "Listen, O isles, unto me, + and hearken, ye people, from far! The Lord hath called me... and said unto + me, Thou art my servant, O Israel, in whom I will be glorified! But I had + thought, I have labored in vain, I have spent my strength for nought, and + in vain; yet surely my judgment is with the Lord, and my work with my God. + For now said the Lord unto me... It is too light a thing that thou + shouldest be my servant to raise up the tribes of Jacob, and to restore + the preserved of Israel: no, I will also give thee for a light to the + Gentiles, that my salvation may reach unto the end of the earth" (Is. + xlix, 1-6).] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-12" id="note-12"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 12 (<a href="#linknoteref-12">return</a>)<br /> [ The external causes of the + downfall of the Maccabean state, dynastic quarrels, are well known. Much + less light has been thrown upon the inner, deeper-lying causes of the + catastrophe. These are possibly to be sought in the priestly-political + dualism of the Judean form of government. The ideal of a nation educated + by means of the Bible was a theocratic state, and the first princes of the + Maccabean house, acting at once as regents and as high priests, in a + measure reached this ideal. But the attempts of other nations had + demonstrated conclusively enough that a dualistic form of government + cannot maintain itself permanently. Sooner or later one of the two + elements, the priestly or the secular, is bound to prevail over the other + and crush it. In the Judean realm, with its profoundly religious trend, + the priestly element obtained the ascendency, and political ruin ensued. + The priestly- political retreated before the priestly-national form of + government. Though the religious element was powerless to preserve the <i>state</i> + from destruction, we shall see that it has brilliantly vindicated its + ability to keep the <i>nation</i> intact.] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-13" id="note-13"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 13 (<a href="#linknoteref-13">return</a>)<br /> [ As anti-Semitism is called in + Russia.] + </p> + <p> + <br /> <a name="linknote-14" id="note-14"> </a> + </p> + <p class="foot"> + 14 (<a href="#linknoteref-14">return</a>)<br /> [ Pushkin.] + </p> + <div style="height: 6em;"> + <br /><br /><br /><br /><br /><br /> + </div> + + + + + + + +<pre> + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of Jewish History, by S. M. Dubnow + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK JEWISH HISTORY *** + +***** This file should be named 7836-h.htm or 7836-h.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + http://www.gutenberg.org/7/8/3/7836/ + + +Text file produced by David King, Charles Franks, and the Online +Distributed Proofreading Team + +HTML file produced by David Widger + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License available with this file or online at + www.gutenberg.org/license. + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS', WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at 809 +North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887. Email +contact links and up to date contact information can be found at the +Foundation's web site and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit www.gutenberg.org/donate + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. +To donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For forty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. + + + +</pre> + + </body> +</html> diff --git a/7836.txt b/7836.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c8e078f --- /dev/null +++ b/7836.txt @@ -0,0 +1,3385 @@ +The Project Gutenberg EBook of Jewish History, by S. M. Dubnow + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + + +Title: Jewish History + +Author: S. M. Dubnow + + +Release Date: April, 2005 [EBook #7836] +This file was first posted on May 21, 2003 +Last Updated: May 8, 2013 + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: ASCII + +*** START OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK JEWISH HISTORY *** + + + + +Produced by David King, Charles Franks, and the Online +Distributed Proofreading Team + + + + + + + +JEWISH HISTORY + +AN ESSAY IN THE PHILOSOPHY +OF HISTORY + +By S. M. Dubnow + + + + +PREFACE TO THE GERMAN TRANSLATION + + +The author of the present essay, S. M. Dubnow, occupies a well-nigh +dominating position in Russian-Jewish literature as an historian and +an acute critic. His investigations into the history of the +Polish-Russian Jews, especially his achievements in the history of +Chassidism, have been of fundamental importance in these departments. +What raises Mr. Dubnow far above the status of the professional +historian, and awakens the reader's lively interest in him, is not so +much the matter of his books, as the manner of presentation. It is +rare to meet with an historian in whom scientific objectivity and +thoroughness are so harmoniously combined with an ardent temperament +and plastic ability. Mr. Dubnow's scientific activity, first and last, +is a striking refutation of the widespread opinion that identifies +attractiveness of form in the work of a scholar with superficiality of +content. Even his strictly scientific investigations, besides offering +the scholar a wealth of new suggestions, form instructive and +entertaining reading matter for the educated layman. In his critical +essays, Mr. Dubnow shows himself to be possessed of keen psychologic +insight. By virtue of this quality of delicate perception, he aims to +assign to every historical fact its proper place in the line of +development, and so establish the bond between it and the general +history of mankind. This psychologic ability contributes vastly to the +interest aroused by Mr. Dubnow's historical works outside of the +limited circle of scholars. There is a passage in one of his books[1] +in which, in his incisive manner, he expresses his views on the limits +and tasks of historical writing. As the passage bears upon the methods +employed in the present essay, and, at the same time, is a +characteristic specimen of our author's style, I take the liberty of +quoting: + +"The popularization of history is by no means to be pursued to the +detriment of its severely scientific treatment. What is to be guarded +against is the notion that tedium is inseparable from the scientific +method. I have always been of the opinion that the dulness commonly +looked upon as the prerogative of scholarly inquiries, is not an +inherent attribute. In most cases it is conditioned, not by the nature +of the subject under investigation, but by the temper of the +investigator. Often, indeed, the tediousness of a learned disquisition +is intentional: it is considered one of the polite conventions of the +academic guild, and by many is identified with scientific thoroughness +and profound learning.... If, in general, deadening, hide-bound caste +methods, not seldom the cover for poverty of thought and lack of +cleverness, are reprehensible, they are doubly reprehensible in +history. The history of a people is not a mere mental discipline, like +botany or mathematics, but a living science, a _magistra vitae_, +leading straight to national self-knowledge, and acting to a certain +degree upon the national character. History is a science _by_ the +people, _for_ the people, and, therefore, its place is the open +forum, not the scholar's musty closet. We relate the events of the +past to the people, not merely to a handful of archaeologists and +numismaticians. We work for national self-knowledge, not for our own +intellectual diversion." + + [1] In the introduction to his _Historische Mitteilungen, + Vorarbeiten zu einer Geschichte der pol-nischrussischen + Juden_. + +These are the principles that have guided Mr. Dubnow in all his works, +and he has been true to them in the present essay, which exhibits in a +remarkably striking way the author's art of making "all things seem +fresh and new, important and attractive." New and important his essay +undoubtedly is. The author attempts, for the first time, a psychologic +characterization of Jewish history. He endeavors to demonstrate the +inner connection between events, and develop the ideas that underlie +them, or, to use his own expression, lay bare the soul of Jewish +history, which clothes itself with external events as with a bodily +envelope. Jewish history has never before been considered from this +philosophic point of view, certainly not in German literature. The +present work, therefore, cannot fail to prove stimulating. As for the +poet's other requirement, attractiveness, it is fully met by the work +here translated. The qualities of Mr. Dubnow's style, as described +above, are present to a marked degree. The enthusiasm flaming up in +every line, coupled with his plastic, figurative style, and his +scintillating conceits, which lend vivacity to his presentation, is +bound to charm the reader. Yet, in spite of the racy style, even the +layman will have no difficulty in discovering that it is not a clever +journalist, an artificer of well-turned phrases, who is speaking to +him, but a scholar by profession, whose foremost concern is with +historical truth, and whose every statement rests upon accurate, +scientific knowledge; not a bookworm with pale, academic blood +trickling through his veins, but a man who, with unsoured mien, with +fresh, buoyant delight, offers the world the results laboriously +reached in his study, after all evidences of toil and moil have been +carefully removed; who derives inspiration from the noble and the +sublime in whatever guise it may appear, and who knows how to +communicate his inspiration to others. + +The translator lays this book of an accomplished and spirited +historian before the German public. He does so in the hope that it +will shed new light upon Jewish history even for professional +scholars. He is confident that in many to whom our unexampled past of +four thousand years' duration is now _terra incognita_, it will +arouse enthusiastic interest, and even to those who, like the +translator himself, differ from the author in religious views, it will +furnish edifying and suggestive reading. J. F. + + + + +PREFACE TO THE ENGLISH TRANSLATION + + +The English translation of Mr. Dubnow's Essay is based upon the +authorized German translation, which was made from the original +Russian. It is published under the joint auspices of the Jewish +Publication Society of America and the Jewish Historical Society of +England. H. S. + + + + +TABLE OF CONTENTS + + +PREFACE TO THE GERMAN TRANSLATION + +INTRODUCTORY NOTE + +I + +THE RANGE OF JEWISH HISTORY + Historical and Unhistorical Peoples + Three Groups of Nations + The "Most Historical" People + Extent of Jewish History + +II + +THE CONTENT OF JEWISH HISTORY + Two Periods of Jewish History + The Period of Independence + The Election of the Jewish People + Priests and Prophets + The Babylonian Exile and the Scribes + The Dispersion + Jewish History and Universal History + Jewish History Characterized + +III + +THE SIGNIFICANCE OF JEWISH HISTORY + The National Aspect of Jewish History + The Historical Consciousness + The National Idea and National Feeling + The Universal Aspect of Jewish History + An Historical Experiment + A Moral Discipline + Humanitarian Significance of Jewish History + Schleiden and George Eliot + +IV + +THE HISTORICAL SYNTHESIS + Three Primary Periods + Four Composite Periods + +V + +THE PRIMARY OR BIBLICAL PERIOD + Cosmic Origin of the Jewish Religion + Tribal Organization + Egyptian Influence and Experiences + Moses + Mosaism a Religious and Moral as well as a Social and Political + System + National Deities + The Prophets and the two Kingdoms + Judaism a Universal Religion + +VI + +THE SECONDARY OR SPIRITUAL-POLITICAL PERIOD + Growth of National Feeling + Ezra and Nehemiah + The Scribes + Hellenism + The Maccabees + Sadducees, Pharisees, and Essenes + Alexandrian Jews + Christianity + +VII + +THE TERTIARY TALMUDIC OR NATIONAL-RELIGIOUS +PERIOD + The Isolation of Jewry and Judaism + The Mishna + The Talmud + Intellectual Activity in Palestine and Babylonia + The Agada and the Midrash + Unification of Judaism + +VIII + +THE GAONIC PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE ORIENTAL JEWS (500-980) + The Academies + Islam + Karaism + Beginning of Persecutions in Europe + Arabic Civilization in Europe + +IX + +THE RABBINIC-PHILOSOPHICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE SPANISH +JEWS (980-1492) + The Spanish Jews + The Arabic-Jewish Renaissance + The Crusades and the Jews + Degradation of the Jews in Christian Europe + The Provence + The Lateran Council + The Kabbala + Expulsion from Spain + +X + +THE RABBINIC-MYSTICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE GERMAN-POLISH +JEWS (1492-1789) + The Humanists and the Reformation + Palestine an Asylum for Jews + Messianic Belief and Hopes + Holland a Jewish Centre + Poland and the Jews + The Rabbinical Authorities of Poland + Isolation of the Polish Jews + Mysticism and the Practical Kabbala + Chassidism + Persecutions and Morbid Piety + +XI + +THE MODERN PERIOD OF ENLIGHTENMENT (THE NINETEENTH CENTURY) + The French Revolution + The Jewish Middle Ages + Spiritual and Civil Emancipation + The Successors of Mendelssohn + Zunz and the Science of Judaism + The Modern Movements outside of Germany + The Jew in Russia + His Regeneration + Anti-Semitism and Judophobia + +XII + +THE TEACHINGS OF JEWISH HISTORY + Jewry a Spiritual Community + Jewry Indestructible + The Creative Principle of Jewry + The Task of the Future + The Jew and the Nations + The Ultimate Ideal + + + + +INTRODUCTORY NOTE + + +What is Jewish History? In the first place, what does it offer as to +quantity and as to quality? What are its range and content, and what +distinguishes it in these two respects from the history of other +nations? Furthermore, what is the essential meaning, what the spirit, +of Jewish History? Or, to put the question in another way, to what +general results are we led by the aggregate of its facts, considered, +not as a whole, but genetically, as a succession of evolutionary +stages in the consciousness and education of the Jewish people? + +If we could find precise answers to these several questions, they +would constitute a characterization of Jewish History as accurate as +is attainable. To present such a characterization succinctly is the +purpose of the following essay. + + + + +JEWISH HISTORY + +AN ESSAY IN THE PHILOSOPHY OF HISTORY + + + + +I + +THE RANGE OF JEWISH HISTORY + + + Le peuple juif n'est pas seulement considerable par son + antiquite, mais il est encore singulier en sa duree, qui a + toujours continue depuis son origine jusqu'a maintenant ... + S'etendant depuis les premiers temps jusqu'aux derniers, + l'histoire des juifs enferme dans sa duree celle de toutes nos + histoires.--PASCAL, _Pensees_, II, 7. + +To make clear the range of Jewish history, it is necessary to set down +a few general, elementary definitions by way of introduction. + +It has long been recognized that a fundamental difference exists +between historical and unhistorical peoples, a difference growing out +of the fact of the natural inequality between the various elements +composing the human race. Unhistorical is the attribute applied to +peoples that have not yet broken away, or have not departed very far, +from the state of primitive savagery, as, for instance, the barbarous +races of Asia and Africa who were the prehistoric ancestors of the +Europeans, or the obscure, untutored tribes of the present, like the +Tartars and the Kirghiz. Unhistorical peoples, then, are ethnic groups +of all sorts that are bereft of a distinctive, spiritual +individuality, and have failed to display normal, independent capacity +for culture. The term historical, on the other hand, is applied to the +nations that have had a conscious, purposeful history of appreciable +duration; that have progressed, stage by stage, in their growth and in +the improvement of their mode and their views of life; that have +demonstrated mental productivity of some sort, and have elaborated +principles of civilization and social life more or less rational; +nations, in short, representing not only zoologic, but also spiritual +types.[2] + + [2] "The primitive peoples that change with their environment, + constantly adapting themselves to their habitat and to + external nature, have no history.... Only those nations and + states belong to history which display self-conscious action; + which evince an inner spiritual life by diversified + manifestations; and combine into an organic whole what they + receive from without, and what they themselves originate." + (Introduction to Weber's _Allgemeine Weltgeschichte_, i, + pp. 16-18.) + +Chronologically considered, these latter nations, of a higher type, +are usually divided into three groups: 1, the most ancient civilized +peoples of the Orient, such as the Chinese, the Hindoos, the +Egyptians, the Chaldeans; 2, the ancient or classic peoples of the +Occident, the Greeks and the Romans; and 3, the modern peoples, the +civilized nations of Europe and America of the present day. The most +ancient peoples of the Orient, standing "at the threshold of history," +were the first heralds of a religious consciousness and of moral +principles. In hoary antiquity, when most of the representatives of +the human kind were nothing more than a peculiar variety of the class +mammalia, the peoples called the most ancient brought forth recognized +forms of social life and a variety of theories of living of fairly +far-reaching effect. All these culture-bearers of the Orient soon +disappeared from the surface of history. Some (the Chaldeans, +Phoenicians, and Egyptians) were washed away by the flood of time, and +their remnants were absorbed by younger and more vigorous peoples. +Others (the Hindoos and Persians) relapsed into a semi-barbarous +state; and a third class (the Chinese) were arrested in their growth, +and remained fixed in immobility. The best that the antique Orient had +to bequeath in the way of spiritual possessions fell to the share of +the classic nations of the West, the Greeks and the Romans. They +greatly increased the heritage by their own spiritual achievements, +and so produced a much more complex and diversified civilization, +which has served as the substratum for the further development of the +better part of mankind. Even the classic nations had to step aside as +soon as their historical mission was fulfilled. They left the field +free for the younger nations, with greater capability of living, which +at that time had barely worked their way up to the beginnings of a +civilization. One after the other, during the first two centuries of +the Christian era, the members of this European family of nations +appeared in the arena of history. They form the kernel of the +civilized part of mankind at the present day. + +Now, if we examine this accepted classification with a view to finding +the place belonging to the Jewish people in the chronological series, +we meet with embarrassing difficulties, and finally arrive at the +conclusion that its history cannot be accommodated within the compass +of the classification. Into which of the three historical groups +mentioned could the Jewish people be put? Are we to call it one of the +most ancient, one of the ancient, or one of the modern nations? It is +evident that it may lay claim to the first description, as well as to +the second and the last. In company with the most ancient nations of +the Orient, the Jewish people stood at the "threshold of history." It +was the contemporary of the earliest civilized nations, the Egyptians +and the Chaldeans. In those remote days it created and spread a +religious world-idea underlying an exalted social and moral system +surpassing everything produced in this sphere by its Oriental +contemporaries. Again, with the classical Greeks and Romans, it forms +the celebrated historical triad universally recognized as the source +of all great systems of civilization. Finally, in fellowship with the +nations of to-day, it leads an historical life, striding onward in the +path of progress without stay or interruption. Deprived of political +independence, it nevertheless continues to fill a place in the world +of thought as a distinctly marked spiritual individuality, as one of +the most active and intelligent forces. How, then, are we to +denominate this omnipresent people, which, from the first moment of +its historical existence up to our days, a period of thirty-five +hundred years, has been developing continuously. In view of this +Methuselah among the nations, whose life is co-extensive with the +whole of history, how are we to dispose of the inevitable barriers +between "the most ancient" and "the ancient," between "the ancient" +and "the modern" nations--the fateful barriers which form the +milestones on the path of the historical peoples, and which the Jewish +people has more than once overstepped? + +A definition of the Jewish people must needs correspond to the +aggregate of the concepts expressed by the three group-names, most +ancient, ancient, and modern. The only description applicable to it is +"the historical nation of all times," a description bringing into +relief the contrast between it and all other nations of modern and +ancient times, whose historical existence either came to an end in +days long past, or began at a date comparatively recent. And granted +that there are "historical" and "unhistorical" peoples, then it is +beyond dispute that the Jewish people deserves to be called "the most +historical" (_historicissimus_). If the history of the world be +conceived as a circle, then Jewish history occupies the position of +the diameter, the line passing through its centre, and the history of +every other nation is represented by a chord marking off a smaller +segment of the circle. The history of the Jewish people is like an +axis crossing the history of mankind from one of its poles to the +other. As an unbroken thread it runs through the ancient civilization +of Egypt and Mesopotamia, down to the present-day culture of France +and Germany. Its divisions are measured by thousands of years. + +Jewish history, then, in its range, or, better, in its duration, +presents an unique phenomenon. It consists of the longest series of +events ever recorded in the annals of a single people. To sum up its +peculiarity briefly, it embraces a period of thirty-five hundred +years, and in all this vast extent it suffers no interruption. At +every point it is alive, full of sterling content. Presently we shall +see that in respect to content, too, it is distinguished by +exceptional characteristics. + + + + +II + +THE CONTENT OF JEWISH HISTORY + + +From the point of view of content, or qualitative structure, Jewish +history, it is well known, falls into two parts. The dividing point +between the two parts is the moment in which the Jewish state +collapsed irretrievably under the blows of the Roman Empire (70 C. +E.). The first half deals with the vicissitudes of a nation, which, +though frequently at the mercy of stronger nations, still maintained +possession of its territory and government, and was ruled by its own +laws. In the second half, we encounter the history of a people without +a government, more than that, without a land, a people stripped of all +the tangible accompaniments of nationality, and nevertheless +successful in preserving its spiritual unity, its originality, +complete and undiminished. + +At first glance, Jewish history during the period of independence +seems to be but slightly different from the history of other nations. +Though not without individual coloring, there are yet the same wars +and intestine disturbances, the same political revolutions and +dynastic quarrels, the same conflicts between the classes of the +people, the same warring between economical interests. This is only a +surface view of Jewish history. If we pierce to its depths, and +scrutinize the processes that take place in its penetralia, we +perceive that even in the early period there were latent within it +great powers of intellect, universal principles, which, visibly or +invisibly, determined the course of events. We have before us not a +simple political or racial entity, but, to an eminent degree, "a +spiritual people." The national development is based upon an +all-pervasive religious tradition, which lives in the soul of the +people as the Sinaitic Revelation, the Law of Moses. With this holy +tradition, embracing a luminous theory of life and an explicit code of +morality and social converse, was associated the idea of the election +of the Jewish people, of its peculiar spiritual mission. "And ye shall +be unto me a kingdom of priests and a holy nation" is the figurative +expression of this ideal calling. It conveys the thought that the +Israelitish people as a whole, without distinction of rank and +regardless of the social prominence of individuals, has been called to +guide the other nations toward sublime moral and religious principles, +and to officiate for them, the laity as it were, in the capacity of +priests. This exalted ideal would never have been reached, if the +development of the Jewish people had lain along hackneyed lines; if, +like the Egyptians and the Chaldeans, it had had an inflexible caste +of priests, who consider the guardianship of the spiritual treasures +of the nation the exclusive privilege of their estate, and strive to +keep the mass of the people in crass ignorance. For a time, something +approaching this condition prevailed among the Jews. The priests +descended from Aaron, with the Temple servants (the Levites), formed a +priestly class, and played the part of authoritative bearers of the +religious tradition. But early, in the very infancy of the nation, +there arose by the side of this official, aristocratic hierarchy, a +far mightier priesthood, a democratic fraternity, seeking to enlighten +the whole nation, and inculcating convictions that make for a +consciously held aim. The Prophets were the real and appointed +executors of the holy command enjoining the "conversion" of all Jews +into "a kingdom of priests and a holy nation." Their activity cannot +be paralleled in the whole range of the world's history. They were not +priests, but popular educators and popular teachers. They were +animated by the desire to instil into every soul a deeply religious +consciousness, to ennoble every heart by moral aspirations, to +indoctrinate every individual with an unequivocal theory of life, to +inspire every member of the nation with lofty ideals. Their work did +not fail to leave its traces. Slowly but deeply idealism entered into +the very pith and marrow of the national consciousness. This +consciousness gained in strength and amplitude century by century, +showing itself particularly in the latter part of the first period, +after the crisis known as "the Babylonian Exile." Thanks to the +exertions of the _Soferim_ (Scribes), directed toward the +broadest popularization of the Holy Writings, and constituting the +formal complement to the work of the Prophets, spiritual activity +became an integral part of Jewish national life. In the closing +centuries of its political existence, the Jewish people received its +permanent form. There was imposed upon it the unmistakable hallmark of +spirituality that has always identified it in the throng of the +nations. Out of the bosom of Judaism went forth the religion that in a +short time ran its triumphant course through the whole ancient world, +transforming races of barbarians into civilized beings. It was the +fulfilment of the Prophetical promise--that the nations would walk in +the light of Israel. + +At the very moment when the strength and fertility of the Jewish mind +reached the culminating point, occurred a political revolution--the +period of homeless wandering began. It seemed as though, before +scattering the Jewish people to all ends of the earth, the providence +of history desired to teach it a final lesson, to take with it on its +way. It seemed to say: "Now you may go forth. Your character has been +sufficiently tempered; you can bear the bitterest of hardships. You +are equipped with an inexhaustible store of energy, and you can live +for centuries, yea, for thousands of years, under conditions that +would prove the bane of other nations in less than a single century. +State, territory, army, the external attributes of national power, are +for you superfluous luxury. Go out into the world to prove that a +people can continue to live without these attributes, solely and alone +through strength of spirit welding its widely scattered particles into +one firm organism!"--And the Jewish people went forth and proved it. + +This "proof" adduced by Jewry at the cost of eighteen centuries of +privation and suffering, forms the characteristic feature of the +second half of Jewish history, the period of homelessness and +dispersion. Uprooted from its political soil, national life displayed +itself on intellectual fields exclusively. "To think and to suffer" +became the watchword of the Jewish people, not merely because forced +upon it by external circumstances beyond its control, but chiefly +because it was conditioned by the very disposition of the people, by +its national inclinations. The extraordinary mental energy that had +matured the Bible and the old writings in the first period, manifested +itself in the second period in the encyclopedic productions of the +Talmudists, in the religious philosophy of the middle ages, in +Rabbinism, in the Kabbala, in mysticism, and in science. The spiritual +discipline of the school came to mean for the Jew what military +discipline is for other nations. His remarkable longevity is due, I am +tempted to say, to the acrid spiritual brine in which he was cured. In +its second half, the originality of Jewish history consists indeed, in +the circumstance that it is the only history stripped of every active +political element. There are no diplomatic artifices, no wars, no +campaigns, no unwarranted encroachments backed by armed force upon the +rights of other nations, nothing of all that constitutes the chief +content--the monotonous and for the most part idea-less content--of +many other chapters in the history of the world. Jewish history +presents the chronicle of an ample spiritual life, a gallery of +pictures representing national scenes. Before our eyes passes a long +procession of facts from the fields of intellectual effort, of +morality, religion, and social converse. Finally, the thrilling drama +of Jewish martyrdom is unrolled to our astonished gaze. If the inner +life and the social and intellectual development of a people form the +kernel of history, and politics and occasional wars are but its +husk,[3] then certainly the history of the Jewish diaspora is all +kernel. In contrast with the history of other nations it describes, +not the accidental deeds of princes and generals, not external pomp +and physical prowess, but the life and development of a whole people. +It gives heartrending expression to the spiritual strivings of a +nation whose brow is resplendent with the thorny crown of martyrdom. +It breathes heroism of mind that conquers bodily pain. In a word, +Jewish history is history sublimated.[4] + + [3] "History, without these (inner, spiritual elements), is a + shell without a kernel; and such is almost all the history + which is extant in the world." (Macaulay, on Mitford's History + of Greece, Collected Works, i, 198, ed. A. and C. Armstrong + and Son.) + + [4] A Jewish historian makes the pregnant remark: "If ever the + time comes when the prophecies of the Jewish seers are + fulfilled, and nation no longer raises the sword against + nation; when the olive leaf instead of the laurel adorns the + brow of the great, and the achievements of noble minds are + familiar to the dwellers in cottages and palaces alike, then + the history of the world will have the same character as + Jewish history. On its pages will be inscribed, not the + warrior's prowess and his victories, nor diplomatic schemes + and triumphs, but the progress of culture and its practical + application in real life." + +In spite of the noteworthy features that raise Jewish history above +the level of the ordinary, and assign it a peculiar place, it is +nevertheless not isolated, not severed from the history of mankind. +Rather is it most intimately interwoven with world-affairs at every +point throughout its whole extent. As the diameter, Jewish history is +again and again intersected by the chords of the historical circle. +The fortunes of the pilgrim people scattered in all the countries of +the civilized world are organically connected with the fortunes of the +most representative nations and states, and with manifold tendencies +of human thought. The bond uniting them is twofold: in the times when +the powers of darkness and fanaticism held sway, the Jews were +amenable to the "physical" influence exerted by their neighbors in the +form of persecutions, infringements of the liberty of conscience, +inquisitions, violence of every sort; and during the prevalence of +enlightment and humanity, the Jews were acted upon by the intellectual +and cultural stimulus proceeding from the peoples with whom they +entered into close relations. Momentary aberrations and reactionary +incidents are not taken into account here. On its side, Jewry made its +personality felt among the nations by its independent, intellectual +activity, its theory of life, its literature, by the very fact, +indeed, of its ideal staunchness and tenacity, its peculiar historical +physiognomy. From this reciprocal relation issued a great cycle of +historical events and spiritual currents, making the past of the +Jewish people an organic constituent of the past of all that portion +of mankind which has contributed to the treasury of human thought. + +We see, then, that in reference to content Jewish history is unique in +both its halves. In the first "national" period, it is the history of +a people to which the epithet "peculiar" has been conceded, a people +which has developed under the influence of exceptional circumstances, +and finally attained to so high a degree of spiritual perfection and +fertility that the creation of a new religious theory of life, which +eventually gained universal supremacy, neither exhausted its resources +nor ended its activity. Not only did it continue to live upon its vast +store of spiritual energy, but day by day it increased the store. In +the second "lackland" half, it is the instructive history of a +scattered people, organically one, in spite of dispersion, by reason +of its unshaken ideal traditions; a people accepting misery and +hardship with stoic calm, combining the characteristics of the thinker +with those of the sufferer, and eking out existence under conditions +which no other nation has found adequate, or, indeed, can ever find +adequate. The account of the people as teacher of religion--this is +the content of the first half of Jewish history; the account of the +people as thinker, stoic, and sufferer--this is the content of the +second half of Jewish history. + +A summing up of all that has been said in this and the previous +chapter proves true the statement with which we began, that Jewish +history, in respect to its quantitative dimensions as well as its +qualitative structure, is to the last degree distinctive and presents +a phenomenon of undeniable uniqueness. + + + + +III + +THE SIGNIFICANCE OF JEWISH HISTORY + + +We turn now to the question of the significance to be attached to +Jewish history. In view of its peculiar qualities, what has it to +offer to the present generation and to future generations as a subject +of study and research? + +The significance of Jewish history is twofold. It is at once national +and universal. At present the fulcrum of Jewish national being lies in +the historical consciousness. In the days of antiquity, the Jews were +welded into a single united nation by the triple agencies of state, +race, and religion, the complete array of material and spiritual +forces directed to one point. Later, in the period of homelessness and +dispersion, it was chiefly religious consciousness that cemented Jewry +into a whole, and replaced the severed political bond as well as the +dulled racial instinct, which is bound to go on losing in keenness in +proportion to the degree of removal from primitive conditions and +native soil. In our days, when the liberal movements leavening the +whole of mankind, if they have not completely shattered the religious +consciousness, have at least, in an important section of Jewry, +effected a change in its form; when abrupt differences of opinion with +regard to questions of faith and cult are asserting their presence; +and traditional Judaism developed in historical sequence is proving +powerless to hold together the diverse factors of the national +organism,--in these days the keystone of national unity seems to be +the historical consciousness. Composed alike of physical, +intellectual, and moral elements, of habits and views, of emotions and +impressions nursed into being and perfection by the hereditary +instinct active for thousands of years, this historical consciousness +is a remarkably puzzling and complex psychic phenomenon. By our common +memory of a great, stirring past and heroic deeds on the battle-fields +of the spirit, by the exalted historical mission allotted to us, by +our thorn-strewn pilgrim's path, our martyrdom assumed for the sake of +our principles, by such moral ties, we Jews, whether consciously or +unconsciously, are bound fast to one another. As Renan well says: +"Common sorrow unites men more closely than common joy." A long chain +of historical traditions is cast about us all like a strong ring. Our +wonderful, unparalleled past attracts us with magnetic power. In the +course of centuries, as generation followed generation, similarity of +historical fortunes produced a mass of similar impressions which have +crystallized, and have thrown off the deposit that may be called "the +Jewish national soul." This is the soil in which, deep down, lies +imbedded, as an unconscious element, the Jewish national _feeling_, +and as a conscious element, the Jewish national _idea_. + +It follows that the Jewish national idea and the national feeling +connected with it have their origin primarily in the historical +consciousness, in a certain complex of ideas and psychic +predispositions. These ideas and predispositions, the deposit left by +the aggregate of historical impressions, are of necessity the common +property of the whole nation, and they can be developed and quickened +to a considerable degree by a renewal of the impressions through the +study of history. Upon the knowledge of history, then, depends the +strength of the national consciousness.[5] + + [5] A different aspect of the same thought is presented with + logical clearness in another publication by our author. "The + national _idea_, and the national _feeling_," says + Mr. Dubnow, "must be kept strictly apart. Unfortunately the + difference between them is usually obliterated. National + feeling is spontaneous. To a greater or less degree it is + inborn in all the members of the nation as a feeling of + kinship. It has its flood-tide and its ebbtide in + correspondence to external conditions, either forcing the + nation to defend its nationality, or relieving it of the + necessity for self-defense. As this feeling is not merely a + blind impulse, but a complicated psychic phenomenon, it can be + subjected to a psychologic analysis. From the given historical + facts or the ideas that have become the common treasure of a + nation, thinking men, living life consciously, can, in one way + or another, derive the origin, development, and vital force of + its national feeling. The results of such an analysis, + arranged in some sort of system, form the content of the + national idea. The task of the national idea it is to clarify + the national feeling, and give it logical sanction for the + benefit of those who cannot rest satisfied with an unconscious + feeling. + + "In what, to be specific, does the essence of our Jewish national + idea consist? Or, putting the question in another form, what + is the cement that unites us into a single compact organism? + Territory and government, the external ties usually binding a + nation together, we have long ago lost. Their place is filled + by abstract principles, by religion and race. Undeniably these + are factors of first importance, and yet we ask the question, + do they alone and exclusively maintain the national cohesion + of Jewry? No, we reply, for if we admitted this proposition, + we should by consequence have to accept the inference, that + the laxity of religious principle prevailing among + free-thinking Jews, and the obliteration of race peculiarities + in the 'civilized' strata of our people, bring in their train + a corresponding weakening, or, indeed, a complete breaking up, + of our national foundations--which in point of fact is not the + case. On the contrary, it is noticeable that the + latitudinarians, the _libres penseurs_, and the + indifferent on the subject of religion, stand in the forefront + of all our national movements. Seeing that to belong to it is + in most cases heroism, and in many martyrdom, what is it that + attracts these Jews so forcibly to their people? There must be + something common to us all, so comprehensive that in the face + of multifarious views and degrees of culture it acts as a + consolidating force. This 'something,' I am convinced, is the + community of historical fortunes of all the scattered parts of + the Jewish nation. We are welded together by our glorious + past. We are encircled by a mighty chain of similar historical + impressions suffered by our ancestors, century after century + pressing in upon the Jewish soul, and leaving behind a + substantial deposit. In short, the Jewish national idea is + based chiefly upon the historical consciousness." [Note of the + German trl.] + +But over and above its national significance, Jewish history, we +repeat, possesses universal significance. Let us, in the first place, +examine its value for science and philosophy. Inasmuch as it is +pre-eminently a chronicle of ideas and spiritual movements, Jewish +history affords the philosopher or psychologist material for +observation of the most important and useful kind. The study of other, +mostly dull chapters of universal history has led to the fixing of +psychologic or sociologic theses, to the working out of comprehensive +philosophic systems, to the determination of general laws. Surely it +follows without far-fetched proof, that in some respects the chapter +dealing with Jewish history must supply material of the most original +character for such theses and philosophies. If it is true, as the last +chapter set out to demonstrate, that Jewish history is distinguished +by sharply marked and peculiar features, and refuses to accommodate +itself to conventional forms, then its content must have an original +contribution to make to philosophy. It does not admit of a doubt that +the study of Jewish history would yield new propositions appertaining +to the philosophy of history and the psychology of nations, hitherto +overlooked by inquirers occupied with the other divisions of universal +history. Inductive logic lays down a rule for ascertaining the law of +a phenomenon produced by two or more contributory causes. By means of +what might be called a laboratory experiment, the several causes must +be disengaged from one another, and the effect of each observed by +itself. Thus it becomes possible to arrive with mathematical precision +at the share of each cause in the result achieved by several +co-operating causes. This method of difference, as it is called, is +available, however, only for a limited number of phenomena, only for +phenomena in the department of the natural sciences. It is in the +nature of the case that mental and spiritual phenomena, though they +may be observed, cannot be artificially reproduced. Now, in one +respect, Jewish history affords the advantages of an arranged +experiment. The historical life of ordinary nations, such nations as +are endowed with territory and are organized into a state, is a +complete intermingling of the political with the spiritual element. +Totally ignorant as we are of the development either would have +assumed, had it been dissevered from the other, the laws governing +each of the elements singly can be discovered only approximately. +Jewish history, in which the two elements have for many centuries been +completely disentangled from each other, presents a natural +experiment, with the advantage of artificial exclusions, rendering +possible the determination of the laws of spiritual phenomena with far +greater scientific exactitude than the laws of phenomena that result +from several similar causes. + +Besides this high value for the purposes of science, this fruitful +suggestiveness for philosophic thought, Jewish history, as compared +with the history of other nations, enjoys another distinction in its +capacity to exercise an ennobling influence upon the heart. Nothing so +exalts and refines human nature as the contemplation of moral +steadfastness, the history of the trials of a martyr who has fought +and suffered for his convictions. At bottom, the second half of Jewish +history is nothing but this. The effective educational worth of the +Biblical part of Jewish history is disputed by none. It is called +"sacred" history, and he who acquires a knowledge of it is thought to +advance the salvation of his soul. Only a very few, however, recognize +the profound, moral content of the second half of Jewish history, the +history of the diaspora. Yet, by reason of its exceptional qualities +and intensely tragic circumstances, it is beyond all others calculated +to yield edification to a notable degree. The Jewish people is +deserving of attention not only in the time when it displayed its +power and enjoyed its independence, but as well in the period of its +weakness and oppression, during which it was compelled to purchase +spiritual development by constant sacrifice of self. A thinker crowned +with thorns demands no less veneration than a thinker with the laurel +wreath upon his brow. The flame issuing from the funeral pile on which +martyrs die an heroic death for their ideas is, in its way, as +awe-inspiring as the flame from Sinai's height. With equal force, +though by different methods, both touch the heart, and arouse the +moral sentiment. Biblical Israel the celebrated--medieval Judah the +despised--it is one and the same people, judged variously in the +various phases of its historical life. If Israel bestowed upon mankind +a religious theory of life, Judah gave it a thrilling example of +tenacious vitality and power of resistance for the sake of conviction. +This uninterrupted life of the spirit, this untiring aspiration for +the higher and the better in the domain of religious thought, +philosophy, and science, this moral intrepidity in night and storm and +in despite of all the blows of fortune--is it not an imposing, +soul-stirring spectacle? The inexpressible tragedy of the Jewish +historical life is unfailing in its effect upon a susceptible +heart.[6] The wonderful exhibition of spirit triumphant, subduing the +pangs of the flesh, must move every heart, and exercise uplifting +influence upon the non-Jew no less than upon the Jew. + + [6] "If there are ranks in suffering, Israel takes precedence of + all the nations--if the duration of sorrows and the patience + with which they are borne ennoble, the Jews are among the + aristocracy of every land--if a literature is called rich in + the possession of a few classic tragedies, what shall we say + to a National Tragedy lasting for fifteen hundred years, in + which the poets and the actors were also the heroes?" (Zunz, + _Die synagogale Poesie_. Translation by George Eliot in + "Daniel Deronda.") + +For non-Jews a knowledge of Jewish history may, under certain +conditions, come to have another, an humanitarian significance. It is +inconceivable that the Jewish people should be held in execration by +those acquainted with the course of its history, with its tragic and +heroic past.[7] Indeed, so far as Jew-haters by profession are +concerned, it is running a risk to recommend the study of Jewish +history to them, without adding a word of caution. Its effect upon +them might be disastrous. They might find themselves cured of their +modern disease, and in the possession of ideas that would render +worthless their whole stock in trade. Verily, he must have fallen to +the zero-point of anti-Semitic callousness who is not thrilled through +and through by the lofty fortitude, the saint-like humility, the +trustful resignation to the will of God, the stoic firmness, laid bare +by the study of Jewish history. The tribute of respect cannot be +readily withheld from him to whom the words of the poet[8] are +applicable: + + "To die was not his hope; he fain + Would live to think and suffer pain." + + [7] As examples and a proof of the strong humanitarian influence + Jewish history exercises upon Christians, I would point to the + relation established between the Jews and two celebrities of + the nineteenth century, Schleiden and George Eliot. In his old + age, the great scientist and thinker accidentally, in the + course of his study of sources for the history of botany, + became acquainted with medieval Jewish history. It filled him + with ardent enthusiasm for the Jews, for their intellectual + strength, their patience under martyrdom. Dominated by this + feeling, he wrote the two admirable sketches: _Die Bedeutung + der Juden fuer Erhaltung und Wiederbelebung der Wissenschaften + im Mittelalter_ (1876) and _Die Romantik des Martyriums + bei den Juden im Mittelalter_ (1878). According to his own + confession, the impulse to write them was "the wish to take at + least the first step toward making partial amends for the + unspeakable wrong inflicted by Christians upon Jews." As for + George Eliot, it may not be generally known that it was her + reading of histories of the Jews that inspired her with the + profound veneration for the Jewish people to which she gave + glowing utterance in "Daniel Deronda." (She cites Zunz, was + personally acquainted with Emanuel Deutsch, and carried on a + correspondence with Professor Dr. David Kaufmann. See + _George Eliot's Life as related in her Letters and + Journals_. Arranged and edited by her husband, J. W. Cross, + Vol. iii, ed. Harper and Brothers.) Her enthusiasm prompted + her, in 1879, to indite her passionate apology for the Jews, + under the title, "The Modern Hep! Hep! Hep!" + + [8] Pushkin. + +When, in days to come, the curtain rises upon the touching tragedy of +Jewish history, revealing it to the astonished eye of a modern +generation, then, perhaps, hearts will be attuned to tenderness, and +on the ruins of national hostility will be enthroned mutual love, +growing out of mutual understanding and mutual esteem. And who can +tell--perhaps Jewish history will have a not inconsiderable share in +the spiritual change that is to annihilate national intolerance, the +modern substitute for the religious bigotry of the middle ages. In +this case, the future task of Jewish history will prove as sublime as +was the mission of the Jewish people in the past. The latter consisted +in the spread of the dogma of the unity of creation; the former will +contribute indirectly to the realization of the not yet accepted dogma +of the unity of the human race. + + + + +IV + +THE HISTORICAL SYNTHESIS + + +To define the scope of Jewish history, its content and its +significance, or its place among scientific pursuits, disposes only of +the formal part of the task we have set ourselves. The central problem +is to unfold the meaning of Jewish history, to discover the principle +toward which its diversified phenomena converge, to state the +universal laws and philosophic inferences deducible from the peculiar +course of its events. If we liken history to an organic being, then +the skeleton of facts is its body, and the soul is the spiritual bond +that unites the facts into a whole, that conveys the meaning, the +psychologic essence, of the facts. It becomes our duty, then, to +unbare the soul of Jewish history, or, in scientific parlance, to +construct, on the basis of the facts, the synthesis of the whole of +Jewish national life. To this end, we must pass in review, by periods +and epochs, one after another, the most important groups of historical +events, the most noteworthy currents in life and thought that tell of +the stages in the development of Jewry and of Judaism. Exhaustive +treatment of the philosophical synthesis of a history extending over +three thousand years is possible only in a voluminous work. In an +essay like the present it can merely be sketched in large outline, or +painted in miniature. We cannot expect to do more than state a series +of general principles substantiated by the most fundamental arguments. +Complete demonstration of each of the principles must be sought in the +annals that recount the events of Jewish history in detail. + +The historical synthesis reduces itself, then, to uncovering the +psychologic processes of national development. The object before us to +be studied is the national spirit undergoing continuous evolution +during thousands of years. Our task is to arrive at the laws +underlying this growth. We shall reach our goal by imitating the +procedure of the geologist, who divides the mass of the earth into its +several strata or formations. In Jewish history there may be +distinguished three chief stratifications answering to its first three +periods, the Biblical period, the period of the Second Temple, and the +Talmudic period. The later periods are nothing more than these same +formations combined in various ways, with now and then the addition of +new strata. Of the composite periods there are four, which arrange +themselves either according to hegemonies, the countries in which at +given times lay the centre of gravity of the scattered Jewish people, +or according to the intellectual currents there predominant. + +This, then, is our scheme: + + I. The chief formations: + a) The primary or Biblical period. + b) The secondary or spiritual-political period + (the period of the Second Temple, 538 + B. C. E. to 70 C.E.) + c) The tertiary or national-religious period + (the Talmudic period, 70-500). + + II. The composite formations: + a) The Gaonic period, or the hegemony of + the Oriental Jews (500-980). + b) The Rabbinic-philosophical period, or the + hegemony of the Spanish Jews (980-1492). + c) The Rabbinic-mystical period, or the hegemony + of the German-Polish Jews + (1492-1789). + d) The modern period of enlightenment (the + nineteenth century). + + + + +V + +THE PRIMARY OR BIBLICAL PERIOD + + +In the daybreak of history, the hoary days when seeming and reality +merge into each other, and the outlines of persons and things fade +into the surrounding mist, the picture of a nomad people, moving from +the deserts of Arabia in the direction of Mesopotamia and Western +Asia, detaches itself clear and distinct from the dim background. The +tiny tribe, a branch of the Semitic race, bears a peculiar stamp of +its own. A shepherd people, always living in close touch with nature, +it yet resists the potent influence of the natural phenomena, which, +as a rule, entrap primitive man, and make him the bond-slave of the +visible and material. Tent life has attuned these Semitic nomads to +contemplativeness. In the endless variety of the phenomena of nature, +they seek to discover a single guiding power. They entertain an +obscure presentiment of the existence of an invisible, universal soul +animating the visible, material universe. The intuition is personified +in the Patriarch Abraham, who, according to Biblical tradition, held +communion with God, when, on the open field, "he looked up toward +heaven, and counted the stars," or when, "at the setting of the sun, +he fell into benumbing sleep, and terror seized upon him by reason of +the impenetrable darkness." Here we have a clear expression of the +original, purely cosmical character of the Jewish religion. + +There was no lack of human influence acting from without. Chaldea, +which the peculiar Semitic shepherds crossed in their pilgrimage, +presented them with notions from its rich mythology and cosmogony. The +natives of Syria and Canaan, among whom in the course of time the +Abrahamites settled, imparted to them many of their religious views +and customs. Nevertheless, the kernel of their pure original theory +remained intact. The patriarchal mode of life, admirable in its +simplicity, continued to hold its own within the circle of the +firmly-knitted tribe. It was in Canaan, however, that the shepherd +people hailing from Arabia showed the first signs of approaching +disintegration. Various tribal groups, like Moab and Ammon, +consolidated themselves. They took permanent foothold in the land, and +submitted with more or less readiness to the influences exerted by the +indigenous peoples. The guardianship of the sublime traditions of the +tribe remained with one group alone, the "sons of Jacob" or the "sons +of Israel," so named from the third Patriarch Jacob. To this group of +the Israelites composed of smaller, closely united divisions, a +special mission was allotted; its development was destined to lie +along peculiar lines. The fortunes awaiting it were distinctive, and +for thousands of years have filled thinking and believing mankind with +wondering admiration. + +Great characters are formed under the influence of powerful +impressions, of violent convulsions, and especially under the +influence of suffering. The Israelites early passed through their +school of suffering in Egypt. The removal of the sons of Jacob from +the banks of the Jordan to those of the Nile was of decisive +importance for the progress of their history. When the patriarchal +Israelitish shepherds encountered the old, highly complex culture of +the Egyptians, crystallized into fixed forms even at that early date, +it was like the clash between two opposing electric currents. The pure +conception of God, of _Elohim_, as of the spirit informing and +supporting the universe, collided with the blurred system of heathen +deities and crass idolatry. The simple cult of the shepherds, +consisting of a few severely plain ceremonies, transmitted from +generation to generation, was confronted with the insidious, coarsely +sensual animal worship of the Egyptians. The patriarchal customs of +the Israelites were brought into marked contrast with the vices of a +corrupt civilization. Sound in body and soul, the son of nature +suddenly found himself in unsavory surroundings fashioned by culture, +in which he was as much despised as the inoffensive nomad is by +"civilized" man of settled habit. The scorn had a practical result in +the enslavement of the Israelites by the Pharaohs. Association with +the Egyptians acted as a force at once of attraction and of repulsion. +The manners and customs of the natives could not fail to leave an +impression upon the simple aliens, and invite imitation on their part. +On the other hand, the whole life of the Egyptians, their crude +notions of religion, and their immoral ways, were calculated to +inspire the more enlightened among the Israelites with disgust. The +hostility of the Egyptians toward the "intruders," and the horrible +persecutions in which it expressed itself, could not but bring out +more aggressively the old spiritual opposition between the two races. +The antagonism between them was the first influence to foster the germ +of Israel's national consciousness, the consciousness of his peculiar +character, his individuality. This early intimation of a national +consciousness was weak. It manifested itself only in the chosen few. +But it existed, and the time was appointed when, under more favorable +conditions, it would develop, and display the extent of its power. + +This consciousness it was that inspired the activity of Moses, +Israel's teacher and liberator. He was penetrated alike by national +and religious feeling, and his desire was to impart both national and +religious feeling to his brethren. The fact of national redemption he +connected with the fact of religious revelation. "I am the Lord thy +God who have brought thee forth out of the land of Egypt" was +proclaimed from Sinai. The God-idea was nationalized. Thenceforth +"Eternal" became the name peculiar to the God of Israel. He was, +indeed, the same _Elohim_, the Creator of the world and its +Guide, who had been dimly discerned by the spiritual vision of the +Patriarchs. At the same time He was the special God of the Israelitish +nation, the only nation that avouched Him with a full and undivided +heart, the nation chosen by God Himself to carry out, alone, His +sublime plans.[9] In his wanderings, Israel became acquainted with the +chaotic religious systems of other nations. Seeing to what they paid +the tribute of divine adoration, he could not but be dominated by the +consciousness that he alone from of old had been the exponent of the +religious idea in its purity. The resolution must have ripened within +him to continue for all time to advocate and cherish this idea. From +that moment Israel was possessed of a clear theory of life in religion +and morality, and of a definite aim pursued with conscious intent. + + [9] This is the true recondite meaning of the verses Exod. vi, + 2-3: "And God spake unto Moses, and said unto him, I am the + Eternal: and I appeared unto Abraham, unto Isaac, and unto + Jacob, as _El-Shaddai_ (God Almighty), but by my name + Eternal I was not known unto them." + +Its originators designed that this Israelitish conception of life +should serve not merely theoretically, as the basis of religious +doctrine, but also practically, as the starting point of legislation. +It was to be realized in the daily walks of the people, which at this +very time attained to political independence. Sublime religious +conceptions were not to be made the content of a visionary creed, the +subject of dreamy contemplation, but, in the form of perspicuous +guiding principles, were to control all spheres of individual and +social life. Men must beware of looking upon religion as an ideal to +be yearned for, it should be an ideal to be applied directly, day by +day, to practical contingencies. In "Mosaism," so-called, the +religious and the ethical are intimately interwoven with the social +and the political. The chief dogmas of creed are stated as principles +shaping practical life. For instance, the exalted idea of One God +applied to social life produces the principle of the equality of all +men before the One Supreme Power, a principle on which the whole of +Biblical legislation is built. The commands concerning love of +neighbor, the condemnation of slavery, the obligation to aid the poor, +humane treatment of the stranger, sympathy and compassion with every +living being--all these lofty injunctions ensue as inevitable +consequences from the principle of equality. Biblical legislation is +perhaps the only example of a political and social code based, not +upon abstract reasoning alone, but also upon the requirements of the +feelings, upon the finest impulses of the human soul. By the side of +formal right and legality, it emphasizes, and, in a series of +precepts, makes tangible, the principle of justice and humanity. The +Mosaic law is a "propaganda by deed." Everywhere it demands active, +more than passive, morality. Herein, in this elevated characteristic, +this vital attribute, consists the chief source of the power of +Mosaism. The same characteristic, to be sure, prevented it from at +once gaining ground in the national life. It established itself only +gradually, after many fluctuations and errors. In the course of the +centuries, and keeping pace with the growth of the national +consciousness, it was cultivated and perfected in detail. + +The conquest of Canaan wrought a radical transformation in the life of +the Israelitish people. The acquiring of national territory supplied +firm ground for the development and manifold application of the +principles of Mosaism. At first, however, advance was out of the +question. The mass of the people had not reached the degree of +spiritual maturity requisite for the espousal of principles +constituting an exalted theory of life. It could be understood and +represented only by a thoughtful minority, which consisted chiefly of +Aaronites and Levites, together forming a priestly estate, though not +a hierarchy animated by the isolating spirit of caste that flourished +among all the other peoples of the Orient. The populace discovered +only the ceremonial side of the religion; its kernel was hidden from +their sight. Defective spiritual culture made the people susceptible +to alien influences, to notions more closely akin to its +understanding. Residence in Canaan, among related Semitic tribes that +had long before separated from the Israelites, and adopted altogether +different views and customs, produced a far greater metamorphosis in +the character of the Israelites than the sojourn in Egypt. After the +first flush of victory, when the unity of the Israelitish people had +been weakened by the particularistic efforts of several of the tribes, +the spiritual bonds confining the nation began to relax. Political +decay always brings religious defection in its train. Whenever Israel +came under the dominion of the neighboring tribes, he also fell a +victim to their cult. This phenomenon is throughout characteristic of +the so-called era of the Judges. It is a natural phenomenon readily +explained on psychologic grounds. The Mosaic national conception of +the "Eternal" entered more and more deeply into the national +consciousness, and, accommodating itself to the limited mental +capacity of the majority, became narrower and narrower in compass--the +lot of all great ideas! The "Eternal" was no longer thought of as the +only One God of the whole universe, but as the tutelar deity of the +Israelitish tribe. The idea of national tutelar deities was at that +time deeply rooted in the consciousness of all the peoples of Western +Asia. Each nation, as it had a king of its own, had a tribal god of +its own. The Phoenicians had their Baal, the Moabites their Kemosh, the +Ammonites their Milkom. Belief in the god peculiar to a nation by no +means excluded belief in the existence of other national gods. A +people worshiped its own god, because it regarded him as its master +and protecting lord. In fact, according to the views then prevalent, a +conflict between two nations was the conflict between two national +deities. In the measure in which respect for the god of the defeated +party waned, waxed the number of worshipers of the god of the +victorious nation, and not merely among the conquerors, but also among +the adherents of other religions.[10] These crude, coarsely +materialistic conceptions of God gained entrance with the masses of +the Israelitish people. If Moab had his Kemosh, and Ammon his Milkom, +then Israel had his "Eternal," who, after the model of all other +national gods, protected and abandoned his "clients" at pleasure, in +the one case winning, in the other losing, the devotion of his +partisans. In times of distress, in which the Israelites groaned under +the yoke of the alien, the enslaved "forgot" their "conquered" +"Eternal." As they paid the tribute due the strange king, and yielded +themselves to his power, so they submitted to the strange god, and +paid him his due tribute of devotion. It followed that liberation from +the yoke of the stranger coincided with return to the God of Israel, +the "Eternal." At such times the national spirit leaped into flaming +life. This sums up the achievements of the hero-Judges. But the traces +of repeated backsliding were deep and long visible, for, together with +the religious ideas of the strange peoples, the Israelites accepted +their customs, as a rule corrupt and noxious customs, in sharp +contrast with the lofty principles of the Mosaic Law, designed to +control social life and the life of the individual. + + [10] "Ye have forsaken me," says God unto Israel, "and served + other gods; wherefore I will deliver you no more. Go and cry + unto the gods which ye have chosen: let them deliver you in + the time of your tribulations" (Judges X, 13-14). The same + idea is brought out still more forcibly in the arguments + adduced by Jephthah in his message to the king of Ammon (more + correctly, Moab), who had laid claim to Israelitish lands: + "Thou," says Jephthah, "mayest possess that which Kemosh thy + god giveth thee to possess, but what the Lord our God giveth + us to possess, that will we possess" (Judges xi, 24). Usually + these words are taken ironically; to me they seem to convey + literal truth rather than irony. + +The Prophet Samuel, coming after the unsettled period of the Judges, +had only partial success in purifying the views of the people and +elevating it out of degradation to a higher spiritual level. His work +was continued with more marked results in the brilliant reigns of +Saul, David, and Solomon. An end was put to the baleful disunion among +the tribes, and the bond of national tradition was strengthened. The +consolidated Israelitish kingdom triumphed over its former oppressors. +The gods of the strange peoples cringed in the dust before the +all-powerful "Eternal." But, with the division of the kingdom and the +political rupture between Judah and Israel, the period of +efflorescence soon came to an end. Again confusion reigned supreme, +and customs and convictions deteriorated under foreign influence. +Prophets like Elijah and Elisha, feverish though their activity was, +stood powerless before the rank immorality in the two states. The +northern kingdom of Israel, composed of the Ten Tribes, passed swiftly +downward on the road to destruction, sharing the fate of the +numberless Oriental states whose end was inevitable by reason of inner +decay. The inspired words of the early Israelitish Prophets, Amos, +Hosea, and Micah, their trumpet-toned reproofs, their thrilling +admonitions, died unheeded upon the air--society was too depraved to +understand their import. It was reserved for later generations to give +ear to their immortal utterances, eloquent witnesses to the lofty +heights to which the Jewish spirit was permitted to mount in times of +general decline. The northern kingdom sank into irretrievable ruin. +Then came the turn of Judah. He, too, had disregarded the law of +"sanctification" from Sinai, and had nearly arrived at the point of +stifling his better impulses in the morass of materialistic living. + +At this critical moment, on the line between to be and not to be, a +miracle came to pass. The spirit of the people, become flesh in its +noblest sons, rose aloft. From out of the midst of the political +disturbances, the frightful infamy, and the moral corruption, +resounded the impressive call of the great Prophets of Judah. Like a +flaming torch carried through dense darkness, they cast a glaring +light upon the vices of society, at the same time illuminating the +path that leads upward to the goal of the ethical ideal. At first the +negative, denouncing element predominated in the exhortations of the +Prophets: unsparingly they scourged the demoralization and the +iniquity, the social injustice and the political errors prevalent in +their time; they threatened divine punishment, that is, the natural +consequences of evil-doing, and appealed to the reason rather than the +feelings of the people. But gradually they elaborated positive ideals, +more soul-stirring than the ideals identified with the old religious +tradition. The Prophets were the first to touch the root of the evil. +It is clear that they realized that alien influences and the low grade +of intelligence possessed by the masses were not the sole causes of +the frequent backsliding of the people. The Jewish doctrine itself +bore within it the germ of error. The two chief pillars of the old +faith--the nationalizing of the God-idea, and the stress laid upon the +cult, the ceremonial side of religion, as compared with moral +requirements--were first and foremost to be held responsible for the +flagrant departures from the spirit of Judaism. This was the direction +in which reform was needed. Thereafter the sermons of the Prophets +betray everywhere the intense desire, on the one hand, to restore to +the God-idea its original universal character, and, on the other hand, +while strongly emphasizing the importance of morality in the religious +and the social sphere, to derogate from the value of the ceremonial +system. The "Eternal" is no longer the national God of Israel, +belonging to him exclusively; He becomes the God of the whole of +mankind, the same _Elohim_, Creator and Preserver of the world, +whom the Patriarchs had worshiped, and to whom, being His creatures, +all men owe worship. His precepts and His laws of morality are binding +upon all nations; they will bring salvation and blessing to all +without distinction.[11] The ideal of piety consists in the profession +of God and a life of rectitude. The time will come when all nations +will be penetrated by true knowledge of God and actuated by the +noblest motives; then will follow the universal brotherhood of man. +Until this consummation is reached, and so long as Israel is the only +nation formally professing the one true God, and accepting His blessed +law, Israel's sole task is to embody in himself the highest ideals, to +be an "ensign to the nations," to bear before them the banner of God's +law, destined in time to effect the transformation of the whole of +mankind. Israel is a missionary to the nations. As such he must stand +before them as a model of holiness and purity. Here is the origin of +the great idea of the spiritual "Messianism" of the Jewish people, or, +better, its "missionism," an eternal idea, far more comprehensive than +the old idea of national election, which it supplanted. + + [11] Two Biblical passages, the one from Deuteronomy, the other + from Deutero-Isaiah, afford a signal illustration of the + contrast between the religious nationalism of the Mosaic law + and the universalism of the Prophets. Moses says to Israel: + "Thou art an holy people unto the Lord thy God: the Lord thy + God hath chosen thee to be a special people unto himself, + above all people that are upon the face of the earth. The Lord + did not set his love upon you, nor choose you, because ye were + more in number than any people: for ye were the fewest of all + people. But because the Lord loved you...." (Deut. vii, 6-8). + And these are the words of the prophecy: "Listen, O isles, + unto me, and hearken, ye people, from far! The Lord hath + called me... and said unto me, Thou art my servant, O Israel, + in whom I will be glorified! But I had thought, I have labored + in vain, I have spent my strength for nought, and in vain; yet + surely my judgment is with the Lord, and my work with my God. + For now said the Lord unto me... It is too light a thing that + thou shouldest be my servant to raise up the tribes of Jacob, + and to restore the preserved of Israel: no, I will also give + thee for a light to the Gentiles, that my salvation may reach + unto the end of the earth" (Is. xlix, 1-6). + +These sublime teachings were inculcated at the moment in which Judah +was hastening to meet his fate. It had become impossible to check the +natural results of the earlier transgressions. The inevitable +happened; Babylon the mighty laid her ponderous hand upon tiny Judah. +But Judah could not be crushed. From the heavy chastisement the Jewish +nation emerged purified, re-born for a new life. + + + + +VI + +THE SECONDARY OR SPIRITUAL-POLITICAL PERIOD + + +The rank and file of a people are instructed by revolutions and +catastrophes better than by sermons. More quickly than Isaiah and +Jeremiah, Nebuchadnezzar brought the Jews to a recognition of their +tasks. The short span of the Babylonian Exile (586-538 B. C. E.) was a +period of introspection and searching self-examination for the people. +Spiritual forces hitherto latent came into play; a degree of +self-consciousness asserted itself. The people grasped its mission. At +last it comprehended that to imitate inferior races, instead of +teaching them and making itself a model for them to follow, was +treason to its vocation in life. When the hour of release from the +Babylonian yoke struck, the people suddenly saw under its feet "a new +earth," and to "a new heaven" above it raised eyes dim with tears of +repentance and emotion. It renewed its covenant with God. Like the +Exodus from Egypt, so the second national deliverance was connected +with a revelation. But the messages delivered by the last +Prophets--especially by "the great unknown," the author of the latter +part of the Book of Isaiah--were too exalted, too universal in +conception, for a people but lately emerged from a severe crisis to +set about their realization at once. They could only illumine its path +as a guiding-star, inspire it as the ultimate goal, the far-off +Messianic ideal. Meanwhile the necessity appeared for uniform +religious laws, dogmas, and customs, to bind the Jews together +externally as a nation. The moralizing religion of the Prophets was +calculated to bring about the regeneration of the individual, +regardless of national ties; but at that moment the chief point +involved was the nation. It had to be established and its organization +perfected. The universalism of the Prophets was inadequate for the +consolidating of a nation. To this end outward religious discipline +was requisite, an official cult and public ceremonies. Led by such +considerations, the Jewish captives, on their return to Jerusalem, +first of all devoted themselves to the erection of a Temple, to the +creating of a visible religious centre, which was to be the rallying +point for the whole nation. + +The days of the Prophets were over. Their religious universalism could +apply only to a distant future. In the present, the nation, before it +might pose as a teacher, had to learn and grow spiritually strong. +Aims of such compass require centuries for their realization. +Therefore, the spiritual-national unification of the people was pushed +into the foreground. The place of the Prophet was filled by the Priest +and the Scribe. Zerubbabel, Ezra, and Nehemiah were permeated by the +purpose to make religion and the cult subservient to the cause of +national union and isolation. The erection of the Temple, the solemn +service with the singing of Psalms and the public reading from the +"Book of the Law" (the Pentateuch, which underwent its final redaction +at that time), the removal of whatever might arouse the remembrance of +strange and heathen institutions--these were the levers of their +unifying activity. At first sight this activity might appear almost +too one-sided. But if we summon to mind a picture of the conditions +prevailing in those days, we are forced to the conclusion that, in the +interest of national restoration, a consistent course was imperative. +In point of fact, however, some of Ezra's innovations testify to the +broad-minded, reformatory character of this activity; as, for +instance, the public reading of the Pentateuch, introduced with a view +to making the people see the necessity of obtaining detailed knowledge +of the principles of its religion, and obeying the precepts of the +Law, not blindly, but with conscious assent. The object steadily aimed +at was the elevation of the whole body of the people to the plane of +spirituality, its transformation, in accordance with the Biblical +injunction, into a "kingdom of priests." + +This injunction of civilizing import became the starting point of the +activity of all of Ezra's successors, of the so-called school of the +_Soferim_, the Scribes, those versed in the art of writing. The +political calm that prevailed during the two centuries of the Persian +supremacy (538-332 B. C. E.), was calculated to an eminent degree to +promote spiritual development and the organization of the inner life +of the people. During this period, a large part of the writings after +the Pentateuch that have been received into the Bible were collected, +compiled, and reduced to writing. The immortal thoughts of the +Prophets clothed themselves in the visible garb of letters. On +parchment rolls and in books they were made accessible to distant +ages. The impressive traditions transmitted from earliest times, the +chronicles of the past of the people, the Psalms brought forth by the +religious enthusiasm of a long series of poets, all were gathered and +put into literary shape with the extreme of care. The spiritual +treasures of the nation were capitalized, and to this process of +capitalization solely and alone generations of men have owed the +possibility of resorting to them as a source of faith and knowledge. +Without the work of compilation achieved by the _Soferim_, of +which the uninstructed are apt to speak slightingly, mankind to-day +had no Bible, that central sun in world-literature. + +These two centuries may fitly be called the school-days of the Jewish +nation; the Scribes were the teachers of Jewry. In the way of original +work but little was produced. The people fed upon the store of +spiritual food, of which sufficient had been laid up for several +generations. It was then that the Jews first earned their title to the +name, "the People of the Book." They made subservient to themselves +the two mightiest instruments of thought, the art of writing and of +reading. Their progress was brilliant, and when their schooling had +come to an end, and they stepped out into the broader life, they were +at once able to apply their knowledge successfully to practical +contingencies. They were prepared for all the vicissitudes of life. +Their spiritual equipment was complete. + +Nothing could have been more opportune than this readiness to assume +the responsibilities of existence, for a time of peril and menace was +again approaching. From out of the West, a new agent of civilization, +Hellenism, advanced upon the East. Alexander the Great had put an end +to the huge Persian monarchy, and brought the whole of Western Asia +under his dominion (332 B. C. E.). His generals divided the conquered +lands among themselves. With all their might, the Ptolemies in Egypt +and the Seleucidae in Syria hellenized the countries subject to their +rule. In the old domain of the Pharaohs, as in Babylonia, in Phoenicia, +and in Syria, the Greek language was currently spoken, Greek +ceremonies were observed, the Greek mode of life was adopted. Athens +ceded her rights of primogeniture to New Athens, Alexandria, capital +of Egypt, and cosmopolitan centre of the civilized world. For a whole +century Judea played the sad part of the apple of discord between the +Egyptian and the Syrian dynasty (320-203 B. C. E.). By turns she owned +the sway of the Ptolemies and the Seleucidae, until finally, in 203, +she was declared a Syro-Macedonian province. Here, as in the other +parts of their realm, the rulers devoted themselves energetically to +the dissemination of Greek culture. Meeting with resistance, they had +resort to main force. At first, indeed, a large part of the people +permitted itself to be blinded by the "beauty of Japheth," and +promoted assimilation with the Greeks. But when the spread of +Hellenism began to threaten the spiritual individuality of Judaism, +the rest of the nation, endowed with greater capacity of resistance, +arose and sturdily repulsed the enemy. + +Hellenism was the first gravely dangerous opponent Judaism had to +encounter. It was not the ordinary meeting of two peoples, or of two +kinds of civilization. It was a clash between two theories of life +that stood abruptly opposed to each other, were, indeed, mutually +exclusive. It was a duel between "the Eternal" on the one side, and +Zeus on the other--between the Creator of the universe, the invisible +spiritual Being who had, in a miraculous way, revealed religious and +ethical ideals to mankind, and the deity who resided upon Olympus, who +personified the highest force of nature, consumed vast quantities of +nectar and ambrosia, and led a pretty wild life upon Olympus and +elsewhere. In the sphere of religion and morality, Hellene and Judean +could not come close to each other. The former deified nature herself, +the material universe; the latter deified the Creator of nature, the +spirit informing the material universe. The Hellene paid homage first +and foremost to external beauty and physical strength; the Judean to +inner beauty and spiritual heroism. The Hellenic theory identified the +moral with the beautiful and the agreeable, and made life consist of +an uninterrupted series of physical and mental pleasures. The Judean +theory is permeated by the strictly ethical notions of duty, of +purity, of "holiness"; it denounces licentiousness, and sets up as its +ideal the controlling of the passions and the infinite improvement of +the soul, not of the intellect alone, but of the feelings as well. +These differences between the two theories of life showed themselves +in the brusque opposition in character and customs that made the +Greeks and the Jews absolute antipodes in many spheres of life. It +cannot be denied that in matters of the intellect, especially in the +field of philosophy and science, not to mention art, it might have +been greatly to the advantage of the Jews to become disciples of the +Greeks. Nor is there any doubt that the brighter aspects of Hellenism +would make an admirable complement to Judaism. An harmonious blending +of the Prophets with Socrates and Plato would have produced a +many-sided, ideal _Weltanschauung_. The course of historical events +from the first made such blending, which would doubtless have +required great sacrifices on both sides, an impossible consummation. +In point of fact, the events were such as to widen the abyss between +the two systems. The meeting of Judaism and Hellenism unfortunately +occurred at the very moment when the classical Hellenes had been +supplanted by the hellenized Macedonians and Syrians, who had accepted +what were probably the worst elements of the antique system, while +appropriating but few of the intellectual excellencies of Greek +culture. There was another thwarting circumstance. In this epoch, the +Greeks were the political oppressors of the Jews, outraging Jewish +national feeling through their tyranny to the same degree as by their +immoral life they shocked Jewish ethical feeling and Jewish chastity. + +Outraged national and religious feeling found expression in the +insurrection of the Maccabees (168 B. C. E.). The hoary priest +Mattathias and his sons fought for the dearest and noblest treasures +of Judaism. Enthusiasm begets heroism. The Syrian-Greek yoke was +thrown off, and, after groaning under alien rule, the Persian, the +Egyptian, and the Syro-Macedonian, for four hundred years, Judea +became an independent state. In its foreign relations, the new state +was secured by the self-sacrificing courage of the first Maccabean +brothers, and from within it was supported by the deep-sunk pillars of +the spiritual life. The rise of the three famous parties, the +Sadducees, the Pharisees, and the Essenes, by no means testifies, as +many would have us believe, to national disintegration, but rather to +the intense spiritual activity of the people. The three tendencies +afforded opportunity for the self-consciousness of the nation to +express itself in all its variety and force. The unbending religious +dogmatism of the Sadducees, the comprehensive practical sense of the +Pharisees in religious and Rational concerns, the contemplative +mysticism of the Essenes, they are the most important offshoots from +the Jewish system as held at that time. In consequence of the external +conditions that brought about the destruction of the Maccabean +state[12] after a century's existence (165-63 B. C. E.), the Pharisee +tendency, which had proved itself the best in practice, won the upper +hand. When Judea was held fast in the clutches of the Roman eagle, all +hope of escape being cut off, the far-seeing leaders of the people +gained the firm conviction that the only trustworthy support of the +Jewish nation lay in its religion. They realized that the preservation +of national unity could be effected only by a consistent organization +of the religious law, which was to envelop and shape the whole +external life of the people. This explains the feverish activity of +the early creators of the Mishna, of Hillel, Shammai, and others, and +it interprets also the watchword of still older fame, "Make a fence +about the Law." If up to that moment religious usage in its +development had kept abreast of the requirements of social and +individual life, the requirements out of which it had grown forth, it +now became a national function, and its further evolution advanced +with tremendous strides. For the protection of the old "Mosaic Laws," +a twofold and a threefold fence of new legal ordinances was erected +about them, and the cult became more and more complicated. But the +externals of religion did not monopolize all the forces. The moral +element in the nation was promoted with equal vigor. Hillel, the head +of the Pharisee party, was not a legislator alone, he was also a model +of humane principles and rare moral attainments. + + [12] The external causes of the downfall of the Maccabean state, + dynastic quarrels, are well known. Much less light has been + thrown upon the inner, deeper-lying causes of the catastrophe. + These are possibly to be sought in the priestly-political + dualism of the Judean form of government. The ideal of a + nation educated by means of the Bible was a theocratic state, + and the first princes of the Maccabean house, acting at once + as regents and as high priests, in a measure reached this + ideal. But the attempts of other nations had demonstrated + conclusively enough that a dualistic form of government cannot + maintain itself permanently. Sooner or later one of the two + elements, the priestly or the secular, is bound to prevail + over the other and crush it. In the Judean realm, with its + profoundly religious trend, the priestly element obtained the + ascendency, and political ruin ensued. The priestly-political + retreated before the priestly-national form of government. + Though the religious element was powerless to preserve the + _state_ from destruction, we shall see that it has + brilliantly vindicated its ability to keep the _nation_ + intact. + +While Judaism, in its native country was striving to isolate itself, +and was seizing upon all sorts of expedients to insure this end, it +readily entered into relations, outside of Judea, with other systems +of thought, and accepted elements of the classical culture. Instead of +the violent opposition which the Palestinian Judaism of the +pre-Maccabean period, that is, the period of strife, had offered to +Hellenism, the tendency to make mutual concessions, and pave the way +for an understanding between the two theories of life, asserted itself +in Alexandria. In the capital city of the hellenized world the Jews +constituted one of the most important elements of culture. According +to Mommsen, the Jewish colony in Alexandria was not inferior, in point +of numbers, to the Jewish population of Jerusalem, the metropolis. +Influenced by Greek civilization, the Jews in turn exercised decisive +influence upon their heathen surroundings, and introduced a new +principle of development into the activity of the cultivated classes. +The Greek translation of the Biblical writings formed the connecting +link between Judaism and Hellenism. The "Septuaginta," the translation +of the Pentateuch, in use since the third century before the Christian +era, had acquainted the classical world with Jewish views and +principles. The productions of the Prophets and, in later centuries, +of the other Biblical authors, translated and spread broadcast, acted +irresistibly upon the spirit of the cultivated heathen, and granted +him a glimpse into a world of hitherto unknown notions. On this soil +sprang up the voluminous Judeo-Hellenic literature, of which but a +few, though characteristic, specimens have descended to us. The +intermingling of Greek philosophy with Jewish religious conceptions +resulted in a new religio-philosophic doctrine, with a mystic tinge, +of which Philo is the chief exponent. In Jerusalem, Judaism appeared +as a system of practical ceremonies and moral principles; in +Alexandria, it presented itself as a complex of abstract symbols and +poetical allegories. The Alexandrian form of Judaism might satisfy the +intellect, but it could not appeal to the feelings. It may have made +Judaism accessible to the cultivated minority, to the upper ten +thousand with philosophic training; for the masses of the heathen +people Judaism continued unintelligible. Yet it was pre-eminently the +masses that were strongly possessed by religious craving. Disappointed +in their old beliefs, they panted after a new belief, after spiritual +enlightenment. In the decaying classical world, which had so long +filled out life with materialistic and intellectual interests, the +moral and religious feelings, the desire for a living faith, for an +active inspiration, had awakened, and was growing with irresistible +force. + +Then, from deep out of the bosom of Judaism, there sprang a moral, +religious doctrine destined to allay the burning thirst for religion, +and bring about a reorganization of the heathen world. The originators +of Christianity stood wholly upon the ground of Judaism. In their +teachings were reflected as well the lofty moral principles of the +Pharisee leader as the contemplative aims of the Essenes. But the same +external circumstances that had put Judaism under the necessity of +choosing a sharply-defined practical, national policy, made it +impossible for Judaism to fraternize with the preachers of the new +doctrine. Judaism, in fact, was compelled to put aside entirely the +thought of universal missionary activity. Instead, it had to devote +its powers to the more pressing task of guarding the spiritual unity +of a nation whose political bonds were visibly dropping away. + +For just then the Jewish nation, gory with its own blood, was +struggling in the talons of the Roman eagle. Its sons fought +heroically, without thought of self. When, finally, physical strength +gave out, their spiritual energy rose to an intenser degree. The state +was annihilated, the nation remained alive. At the very moment when +the Temple was enwrapped in flames, and the Roman legions flooded +Jerusalem, the spiritual leaders of Jewry sat musing, busily casting +about for a means whereby, without a state, without a capital, without +a Temple, Jewish unity might be maintained. And they solved the +difficult problem. + + + + +VII + +THE TERTIARY TALMUDIC OR NATIONAL-RELIGIOUS PERIOD + + +The solution of the problem consisted chiefly in more strictly +following out the process of isolation. In a time in which the worship +of God preached by Judaism was rapidly spreading to all parts of the +classical world, and the fundamental principles of the Jewish religion +were steadily gaining appreciation and active adherence, this intense +desire for seclusion may at first glance seem curious. But the +phenomenon is perfectly simple. A foremost factor was national +feeling, enhanced to a tremendous degree at the time of the +destruction of Jerusalem. Lacking a political basis, it was +transferred to religious soil. Every tradition, every custom, however +insignificant, was cherished as a jewel. Though without a state and +without territory, the Jews desired to form a nation, if only a +spiritual nation, complete in itself. They considered themselves then +as before the sole guardians of the law of God. They did not believe +in a speedy fulfilment of the prophetical promise concerning "the end +of time" when all nations would be converted to God. A scrupulous +keeper of the Law, Judaism would not hear of the compromises that +heathendom, lately entered into the bosom of the faith, claimed as its +due consideration. It refused to sacrifice a single feature of its +simple dogmatism, of its essential ceremonies, such as circumcision +and Sabbath rest. Moreover, in the period following close upon the +fall of the Temple, a part of the people still nursed the hope of +political restoration, a hope repudiating in its totality the +proclamation of quite another Messianic doctrine. The delusion ended +tragically in Bar Kochba's hapless rebellion (135 C. E.), whose +disastrous issue cut off the last remnant of hope for the restoration +of an "earthly kingdom." Thereafter the ideal of a spiritual state was +replaced by the ideal of a spiritual nation, rallying about a peculiar +religious banner. Jewry grew more and more absorbed in itself. Its +seclusion from the rest of the world became progressively more +complete. Instinct dictated this course as an escape from the danger +of extinction, or, at least, of stagnation. It was conscious of +possessing enough vitality and energy to live for itself and work out +its own salvation. It had its spiritual interests, its peculiar +ideals, and a firm belief in the future. It constituted an ancient +order, whose patent of nobility had been conferred upon it in the days +of the hoary past by the Lord God Himself. Such as it was, it could +not consent to ally itself with _parvenus_, ennobled but to-day, +and yesterday still bowing down before "gods of silver and gods of +gold." This white-haired old man, with a stormy past full of +experiences and thought, would not mingle with the scatter-brained +crowd, would not descend to the level of neophytes dominated by +fleeting, youthful enthusiasm. Loyally this weather-bronzed, +inflexible guardian of the Law stuck to his post--the post entrusted +to him by God Himself--and, faithful to his duty, held fast to the +principle _j'y suis, j'y reste_. + +As a political nation threatened by its neighbors seeks support in its +army, and provides sufficient implements of war, so a spiritual nation +must have spiritual weapons of defense at its command. Such weapons +were forged in great numbers, and deposited in the vast arsenal called +the Talmud. The Talmud represents a complicated spiritual discipline, +enjoining unconditional obedience to a higher invisible power. Where +discipline is concerned, questions as to the necessity for one or +another regulation are out of place. Every regulation is necessary, if +only because it contributes to the desired end, namely, discipline. +Let no one ask, then, to what purpose the innumerable religious and +ritual regulations, sometimes reaching the extreme of pettiness, to +what purpose the comprehensive code in which every step in the life of +the faithful is foreseen. The Talmudic religious provisions, all taken +together, aim to put the regimen of the nation on a strictly uniform +basis, so that everywhere the Jew may be able to distinguish a brother +in faith by his peculiar mode of life. It is a uniform with insignia, +by which soldiers of the same regiment recognize one another. Despite +the vast extent of the Jewish diaspora, the Jews formed a +well-articulated spiritual army, an invisible "state of God" +(_civitas dei_). Hence these "knights of the spirit," the +citizens of this invisible state, had to wear a distinct uniform, and +be governed by a suitable code of army regulations. + +As a protection for Jewish national unity, which was exposed to the +greatest danger after the downfall of the state, there arose and +developed, without any external influence whatsoever, an extraordinary +dictatorship, unofficial and spiritual. The legislative activity of +all the dictators--such as, Rabbi Jochanan ben Zakkai, Rabbi Akiba, +the Hillelites, and the Shammaites--was formulated in the Mishna, the +"oral law," which was the substructure of the Talmud. Their activity +had a characteristic feature, which deserves somewhat particularized +description. The laws were not laid down arbitrarily and without +ceremony. In order to possess binding force, they required the +authoritative confirmation to be found in the Mosaic Books. From +these, whether by logical or by forced interpretation of the holy +text, its words, or, perchance, its letters, they had to be derived. +Each law, barring only the original "traditions," the _Halacha +le-Moshe mi-Sinai_, was promulgated over the supreme signature, as +it were, that is, with the authentication of a word from the Holy +Scriptures. Or it was inferred from another law so authenticated. The +elaboration of every law was thus connected with a very complicated +process of thought, requiring both inductive and deductive reasoning, +and uniting juridical interpretation with the refinements of +casuistry. This legislation was the beginning of Talmudic science, +which from that time on, for many centuries, growing with the ages, +claimed in chief part the intellectual activity of Jewry. The schools +and the academies worked out a system of laws at once religious and +practical in character, which constituted, in turn, the object of +further theoretic study in the same schools and academies. In the +course of time, however, the means became the end. Theoretic +investigation of the law, extending and developing to the furthest +limits, in itself, without reference to its practical value, afforded +satisfaction to the spiritual need. The results of theorizing often +attained the binding force of law in practical life, not because +circumstances ordered it, but simply because one or another academy, +by dint of logic or casuistry, had established it as law. The number +of such deductions from original and secondary laws increased in +geometric progression, and practical life all but failed to keep up +with the theory. The "close of the Mishna," that is, its reduction to +writing, had no daunting effect upon the zeal for research. If +anything, a new and strong impetus was imparted to it. As up to that +time the text of the Holy Scriptures had been made the basis of +interpretation, giving rise to the most diverse inferences, so the +rabbis now began to use the law book recently canonized as a new basis +of interpretation, and to carry its principles to their utmost +consequences. In this way originated first the "Palestinian Gemara." +Later, when the Patriarchate in Palestine was stripped of its glory by +persecutions, and, in consequence, the centre of activity had to be +transferred from the Talmud academies of Palestine to those of +Babylonia, supreme place and exclusive dominion were obtained by the +"Babylonian Gemara," put into permanent form about the year 500 C. E., +a gigantic work, the result of two hundred years of mental labor. + +This busy intellectual activity was as comprehensive as it was +thoroughgoing. Talmudic legislation, the Halacha, by no means confines +itself to religious practices, extensive as this field is. It embraces +the whole range of civil and social life. Apart from the dietary laws, +the regulations for the festivals and the divine service, and a mass +of enactments for the shaping of daily life, the Talmud elaborated a +comprehensive and fairly well-ordered system of civil and criminal +law, which not infrequently bears favorable comparison with the famous +_rationi scriptae_ of the Romans. While proceeding with extreme +rigor and scrupulousness in ritual matters, the Talmud is governed in +its social legislation by the noblest humanitarian principles. +Doubtless this difference of attitude can be explained by the fact +that religious norms are of very much greater importance for a nation +than judicial regulations, which concern themselves only with the +interests of the individual, and exercise but little influence upon +the development of the national spirit. + +The most sympathetic aspects of the Jewish spirit in that epoch are +revealed in the moral and poetic elements of the Talmud, in the Agada. +They are the receptacles into which the people poured all its +sentiments, its whole soul. They are a clear reflex of its inner +world, its feelings, hopes, ideals. The collective work of the nation +and the trend of history have left much plainer traces in the Agada +than in the dry, methodical Halacha. In the Agada the learned jurist +and formalist appears transformed into a sage or poet, conversing with +the people in a warm, cordial tone, about the phenomena of nature, +history, and life. The reader is often thrown into amazement by the +depth of thought and the loftiness of feeling manifested in the Agada. +Involuntarily one pays the tribute of reverence to its practical +wisdom, to its touching legends pervaded by the magic breath of poesy, +to the patriarchal purity of its views. But these pearls are not +strung upon one string, they are not arranged in a complete system. +They are imbedded here and there, in gay variety, in a vast mass of +heterogeneous opinions and sentiments naive at times and at times +eccentric. The reader becomes aware of the thoughts before they are +consolidated. They are still in a fluid, mobile state, still in +process of making. The same vivacious, versatile spirit is revealed in +the Midrashim literature, directly continuing the Agada up to the end +of the middle ages. These two species of Jewish literature, the Agada +and the Midrashim, have a far greater absolute value than the Halacha. +The latter is an official work, the former a national product. Like +every other special legislation, the Halacha is bound to definite +conditions and times, while the Agada concerns itself with the eternal +verities. The creations of the philosophers, poets, and moralists are +more permanent than the work of legislators. + +Beautiful as the Agada is, and with all its profundity, it lacks +breadth. It rests wholly on the national, not on a universal basis. It +would be vain to seek in it for the comprehensive universalism of the +Prophets. Every lofty ideal is claimed as exclusively Jewish. So far +from bridging over the chasm between Israel and the other nations, +knowledge and morality served to widen it. It could not be otherwise, +there was no influx of air from without. The national horizon grew +more and more contracted. The activities of the people gathered +intensity, but in the same measure they lost in breadth. It was the +only result to be expected from the course of history in those ages. +Let us try to conceive what the first five centuries of the Christian +era, the centuries during which the Talmud was built up, meant in the +life of mankind. Barbarism, darkness, and elemental outbreaks of man's +migratory instincts, illustrated by the "great migration of races," +are characteristic features of those centuries. It was a wretched +transition period between the fall of the world of antique culture and +the first germinating of a new Christian civilization. The Orient, the +centre and hearth of Judaism, was shrouded in impenetrable darkness. +In Palestine and in Babylonia, their two chief seats, the Jews were +surrounded by nations that still occupied the lowest rung of the +ladder of civilization, that had not yet risen above naive mysticism +in religion, or continued to be immersed in superstitions of the +grossest sort. + +In this abysmal night of the middle ages, the lamp of thought was fed +and guarded solely and alone by the Jews. It is not astonishing, then, +that oblivious of the other nations they should have dispensed light +only for themselves. Furthermore, the circumstance must be considered +that, in the period under discussion, the impulse to separate from +Judaism gained ground in the Christian world. After the Council of +Nicaea, after Constantine the Great had established Christianity as +the state-church, the official breach between the Old Testament and +the New Testament partisans became unavoidable. + +Thus the Jews, robbed of their political home, created a spiritual +home for themselves. Through the instrumentality of the numberless +religious rules which the Talmud had laid down, and which shaped the +life of the individual as well as that of the community, they were +welded into a firmly united whole. The Jewish spirit--national feeling +and individual mental effort alike--was absorbed in this pursuit of +unification. Head, heart, hands, all human functions of the Jew, were +brought under complete control and cast into fixed forms, by these +five centuries of labor. With painful exactitude, the Talmud +prescribed ordinances for all the vicissitudes of life, yet, at the +same time, offered sufficient food for brain and heart. It was at once +a religion and a science. The Jew was equipped with all the +necessaries. He could satisfy his wants from his own store. There was +no need for him to knock at strange doors, even though he had thereby +profited. The consequences of this attitude, positive as well as +negative consequences, asserted themselves in the further course of +Jewish history. + + + + +VIII + +THE GAONIC PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE ORIENTAL JEWS (500-980) + + +With the close of the Talmud, at the beginning of the sixth century, +the feverish intellectual activity abated. The Jewish centre of +gravity continued in Babylonia. In this country, in which the Jewish +race had heard its cradle song at the dawn of existence, and later on +_Judaea capta_ had sat and wept remembering Zion, Judaism, after +the destruction of the second Temple and hundreds of years of trials, +was favored with a secure asylum. In the rest of the diaspora, +persecution gave the Jews no respite, but in Babylonia, under Persian +rule, they lived for some centuries comparatively free from +molestation. Indeed, they enjoyed a measure of autonomy in internal +affairs, under a chief who was entitled Exilarch (_Resh-Galutha_). +The Law and the word of God went forth from Babylonia for the Jews of +all lands. The Babylonian Talmud became the anthoritative code for the +Jewish people, a holy book second only to the Bible. The intellectual +calm that supervened at the beginning of the sixth century and lasted +until the end of the eighth century, betrayed itself in the slackening of +independent creation, though not in the flagging of intellectual activity +in general. In the schools and academies of Pumbeditha, Nahardea, +and Sura, scientific work was carried on with the same zest as before, +only this work had for its primary object the sifting and exposition of +the material heaped up by the preceding generations. This was the +province of the Sabureans and the Geonim, whose relation to the Talmud +was the same as that of the Scribes (the _Soferim_) of the Second +Temple to the Bible (see above, ch. vi). In the later period, as in the +earlier, the aim was the capitalization of the accumulated spiritual +treasures, an undertaking that gives little occasion for movement and +life, but all the more for endurance and industry. + +This intellectual balance was destroyed by two events: the appearance +of Islam and the rise of Karaism. Islam, the second legitimate +offspring of Judaism, was appointed to give to religious thought in +the slumbering Orient the slight impulse it needed to start it on its +rapid career of sovereign power. Barely emancipated from swaddling +clothes, young Hotspur at once began to rage. He sought an outlet for +his unconquerable thirst for action, his lust for world-dominion. The +victorious religious wars of the followers of Allah ensued. This +foreign movement was not without significance for the fate of the +Jews. They were surrounded no longer by heathens but by Mohammedans, +who believed in the God of the Bible, and through the mouth of their +prophet conferred upon the Jews the honorable appellation of "the +People of the Book." In the eighth century the wars ceased, and the +impetuous energy of the rejuvenated Orient was diverted into quieter +channels. The Bagdad Khalifate arose, the peaceful era of the growth +of industry, the sciences, and the arts was inaugurated. Endowed with +quick discernment for every enlightening movement, the Jews yielded to +the vivifying magic of young Arabic culture. + +Partly under the influence of the Arabic tendency to split into +religio-philosophic sects, partly from inner causes, Karaism sprang up +in the second half of the eighth century. Its active career began with +a vehement protest against the Talmud as the regulator of life and +thought. It proclaimed the creators of this vast encyclopedia to be +usurpers of spiritual power, and urged a return to the Biblical laws +in their unadulterated simplicity. The weakness of its positive +principles hindered the spread of Karaism, keeping it forever within +the narrow limits of a sect and consigning it to stagnation. What gave +it vogue during the first century of its existence was its negative +strength, its violent opposition to the Talmud, which aroused +strenuous intellectual activity. For a long time it turned Judaism +away from its one-sided Talmudic tendency, and opened up new avenues +of work for it. True to their motto: "Search diligently in the Holy +Scriptures," the adherents of Karaism applied themselves to the +rational study of the Bible, which had come to be, among the +Talmudists, the object of casuistic interpretation and legendary +adornment. By the cultivation of grammar and lexicography as applied +to the Biblical thesaurus of words, they resuscitated the Hebrew +language, which, ousted by the Aramaic dialect, had already sunk into +oblivion. By the same means they laid the foundation of a school of +rejuvenated poetry. In general, thought on religious and philosophic +subjects was promoted to a higher degree by the lively discussions +between them and the Talmudists. + +By imperceptible steps Talmudic Judaism, influenced at once by the +enlightened Arabs and the protesting Karaites, departed from the "four +ells of the Halacha," and widened its horizon. Among the spiritual +leaders of the people arose men who occupied themselves not only with +the study of the Talmud but also with a rational exegesis of the +Bible, with philology, poetry, philosophy. The great Gaon Saadiah +(892-942) united within himself all strands of thought. Over and above +a large number of philological and other writings of scientific +purport, he created a momentous religio-philosophic system, with the +aim to clarify Judaism and refine religious conceptions. He was an +encyclopedic thinker, a representative of the highest Jewish culture +and of Arabic culture as well--he wrote his works in Arabic by +preference. In this way Jewish thought gained ground more and more in +the Orient. It was in the West, however, that it attained soon after +to the climax of its development. + +Gradually the centre of gravity of Jewry shifted from Asia Minor to +Western Europe. Beginning with the sixth century, the sparsely sown +Jewish population of Occidental Europe increased rapidly in numbers. +In Italy, Byzantium, France, and Visigothic Spain, important Jewish +communities were formed. The medieval intolerance of the Church, +though neither so widespread nor so violent as it later became, +suffered its first outbreak in that early century. The persecutions of +the Jews by the Visigothic kings of Spain and the Bishops Avitus of +Clermont and Agobard in France (sixth to the ninth century) were the +prelude to the more systematic and the more bloody cruelties of +subsequent days. The insignificant numbers of the European Jews and +the insecurity of their condition stood in the way of forming an +intellectual centre of their own. They were compelled to acknowledge +the spiritual supremacy of their Oriental brethren in faith. With the +beginning of the tenth century the situation underwent a change. +Arabic civilization, which had penetrated to Spain in previous +centuries, brought about a radical transformation in the character of +the country. The realm of the fanatic Visigoths, half barbarous and +wholly averse to the light of progress, changed into the prosperous +and civilized Khalifate of the Ommeyyades. Thither the best forces of +Oriental Jewry transferred themselves. With the growth of the Jewish +population in Arabic Spain and the strengthening of its communal +organization, the spiritual centre of the Jewish people gradually +established itself in Spain. The academies of Sura and Pumbeditha +yielded first place to the high schools of Cordova and Toledo. + +The Jewry of the East resigned the national hegemony to the Jewry of +the West. The Geonim withdrew in favor of the Rabbis. After centuries +of seclusion, the Jewish spirit once more asserted itself, and enjoyed +a period of efflorescence. The process of national growth became more +complex, more varied. + + + + +IX + +THE RABBINIC-PHILOSOPHICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE SPANISH JEWS +(980-1492) + + +The five centuries marked at their beginning by the rise of +Arabic-Jewish civilization in Spain and at their end by the banishment +of the Jews from Spain (980-1492), offer the Jewish historian an +abundance of culture manifestations and intellectual movements so +luxuriant that it is well-nigh impossible to gather them up in one +formula. The monotony formerly prevailing in Jewish national life, +both in its external and in its internal relations, was succeeded by +almost gaily checkered variety. Swept along by the movement towards +enlightenment that dominated their surroundings, the Jews of Arabic +Spain threw themselves into energetic work in all the spheres of life +and thought. While they had political ground more or less firm under +their feet, and for the most part enjoyed peace and liberty, the Jews +in the Christian lands of Europe stood upon volcanic soil, every +moment threatening to swallow them up. Exposed constantly to +persecutions, they lived more or less isolated, and devoted themselves +to one-sided though intense intellectual activity. Sombre shadows and +streaks of bright light alternate with each other in this period. In +its second half, the clouds massed themselves heavily upon the +darkening horizon. Even the "privileged" Spanish Jews suffered an +untoward change in their affairs at the beginning of the thirteenth +century: gradually they were withdrawn from under the sovereignty of +the Arabs, and made subject to the power of the Catholic monarchs. +They became thenceforward the equal partners of their brethren in +faith in the rest of Europe. All without distinction had a share in +the spiritual martyrdom which is the greenest bayleaf in the crown of +Jewish history. To think and to suffer became the watchword of the +whole nation. + +At first, as we have said, a considerable portion of the Jewish people +enjoyed the happy possibility of thinking. This was during the +classical epoch of the Arabic-Jewish Renaissance, which preceded the +Italian Renaissance by four centuries. There is a fundamental +difference between the two Renaissance periods: the earlier one was +signalized by a re-birth of the sciences and of philosophy, the later +one pre-eminently of the arts and of literature. The eleventh and +twelfth centuries marked the meridian of the intellectual development +of medieval Judaism. As once, in Alexandria, the union of Judaic with +Hellenic culture brought in its train a superabundance of new ideas of +a universal character, so again the amalgamation, on Spanish soil, of +Jewish culture with Arabic gave rise to rich intellectual results, +more lasting and fruitful than the Alexandrian, inasmuch as, in spite +of their universal character, they did not contravene the national +spirit. The Jewish people dropped its misanthropy and its leaning +toward isolation. The Jews entered all sorts of careers: by the side +of influential and cultivated statesmen, such as Chasdai ibn Shaprut +and Samuel Hanagid, at the courts of the Khalifs, stood a brilliant +group of grammarians, poets, and philosophers, like Jonah ibn Ganach, +Solomon Gabirol, and Moses ibn Ezra. The philosophic-critical +scepticism of Abraham ibn Ezra co-existed in peace and harmony with +the philosophic-poetic enthusiasm of Jehuda Halevi. The study of +medicine, mathematics, physics, and astronomy went hand in hand with +the study of the Talmud, which, though it may not have occupied the +first place with the Spanish Jews of this time, by no means +disappeared, as witness the compendium by Alphassi. Unusual breadth +and fulness of the spiritual life is the distinction of the epoch. +This variety of mental traits combined in a marvelous union to form +the great personality of Maimonides, the crown of a glorious period. +With one "Strong Hand," this intellectual giant brought order out of +the Talmudic chaos, which at his word was transformed into a +symmetrical, legal system; with the other, he "guided the Perplexed" +through the realm of faith and knowledge. For rationalistic clarity +and breadth of view no counterpart to the religio-philosophic doctrine +which he formulated can be found in the whole extent of medieval +literature. The main feature of the philosophy of Maimonides and of +the systems based upon it is rationalism, not a dry, scholastic, +abstract rationalism, but a living rationalism, embracing the whole +field of the most exalted psychic phenomena. It is not philosophy pure +and simple, but religious philosophy, an harmonization, more or less +felicitous, of the postulates of reason with the dogmas of faith. It +is reason mitigated by faith, and faith regulated by reason. In the +darkness of the middle ages, when the Romish Church impregnated +religion with the crudest superstitions, going so far as to forbid its +adherents to read the Bible, and when the greatest philosopher +representatives of the Church, like Albertus Magnus, would have +rejected offhand, as a childish fancy or, indeed, as an heretical +chimera, any attempt to rescue the lower classes of the people from +their wretched state of spiritual servitude--in a time like this, the +truly majestic spectacle is presented of a philosophy declaring war on +superstition, and setting out to purify the religious notions of the +people. + +Not a breath of this ample spiritual development of the Jews of Arabic +Spain reached the Jews living in the Christian countries of Europe. +Their circumstances were too grievous, and in sombreness their inner +life matched their outer estate. Their horizon was as contracted as +the streets of the Jewries in which they were penned. The crusades +(beginning in 1096) clearly showed the Jews of France and Germany what +sentiments their neighbors cherished towards them. They were the first +returns which Christianity paid the Jewish people for its old-time +teaching of religion. The descendants of the "chosen people," the +originators of the Bible, were condemned to torture of a sort to +exhaust their spiritual heritage. Judaism suffered the tragic fate of +King Lear. Was it conceivable that the horrors--the rivers of blood, +the groans of massacred communities, the serried ranks of martyrs, the +ever-haunting fear of the morrow--should fail to leave traces in the +character of Judaism? The Jewish people realized its imminent danger. +It convulsively held fast to its precious relics, clung to the pillars +of its religion, which it regarded as the only asylum. The Jewish +spirit again withdrew from the outer world. It gave itself up wholly +to the study of the Talmud. In northern France and in Germany, +Talmudic learning degenerated into the extreme of scholastic pedantry, +the lot of every branch of science that is lopped off from the main +trunk of knowledge, and vegetates in a heavy, dank atmosphere, lacking +light and air. Rashi (1064-1105), whose genial activity began before +the first crusade, opened up Jewish religious literature to the +popular mind, by his systematic commentaries on the Bible and the +Talmud. On the other hand, the Tossafists, the school of commentators +succeeding him, by their petty quibbling and hairsplitting casuistry +made the Talmudic books more intricate and less intelligible. Such +being the intellectual bias of the age, a sober, rationalistic +philosophy could not assert itself. In lieu of an Ibn Ezra or a +Maimonides, we have Jehuda Hachassid and Eliezer of Worms, with their +mystical books of devotion, _Sefer Chassidim, Rokeach_, etc., +filled with pietistic reflections on the other world, in which the +earth figures as a "vale of tears." Poetry likewise took on the dismal +hue of its environment. Instead of the varied lyrical notes of Gabirol +and Halevi, who sang the weal and woe, not only of the nation, but +also of the individual, and lost themselves in psychologic analysis, +there now fall upon our ear the melancholy, heartrending strains of +synagogue poetry, the harrowing outcries that forced themselves from +the oppressed bosoms of the hunted people, the prayerful lamentations +that so often shook the crumbling walls of the medieval synagogues at +the very moment when, full of worshipers, they were fired by the +inhuman crusaders. A mighty chord reverberates in this poetry: +_Morituri te salutant_. + +One small spot there was, in the whole of Europe, in which Jews could +still hope to endure existence and enjoy a measure of security. This +was Southern France, or the Provence. The population of Provence had +assimilated the culture of the neighboring country, Arabic Spain, and +become the mediator between it and the rest of Europe. This work of +mediation was undertaken primarily by the Jews. In the twelfth century +several universities existed in Provence, which were frequented in +great numbers by students from all countries. At these universities +the teachers of philosophy, medicine, and other branches of science +were for the most part Jews. The rationalistic philosophy of the +Spanish Jews was there proclaimed _ex cathedra_. The Tibbonides +translated all the more important works of the Jewish thinkers of +Spain from Arabic into Hebrew. The Kimchis devoted themselves to +grammatical studies and the investigation of the Bible. In +Montpellier, Narbonne, and Lunel, intellectual work was in full swing. +Rational ideas gradually leavened the masses of the Provencal +population. Conscience freed from intellectual trammels began to +revolt against the oppression exercised by the Roman clergy. Through +the Albigensian heresy, Innocent III, founder of the papal power, had +his attention directed to the Jews, whom he considered the dangerous +protagonists of rationalism. The "heresy" was stifled, Provence in all +her magnificence fell a prey to the Roman mania for destruction, and, +on the ruins of a noble civilization, the Dominican Inquisition raged +with all its horrors (1213). + +Thenceforward the Catholic Church devoted herself to a hostile watch +upon the Jews. Either she persecuted them directly through her +Inquisition, or indirectly through her omnipotent influence on kings +and peoples. In the hearts of the citizens of medieval Europe, the +flame of religious hatred was enkindled, and religious hatred served +as a cloak for the basest passions. Jewish history from that time on +became a history of uninterrupted suffering. The Lateran Council +declared the Jews to be outcasts, and designed a peculiar, +dishonorable badge for them, a round patch of yellow cloth, to be worn +on their upper garment (1215). In France the Jews became by turns the +victims of royal rapacity and the scapegoats of popular fanaticism. +Massacres, confiscations, banishments followed by dearly purchased +permission to return, by renewed restrictions, persecutions, and +oppressions--these were the measures that characterized the treatment +of the Jews in France until their final expulsion (1394). In Germany +the Jews were not so much hated as despised. They were _servi +camerae_, serfs of the state, and as such had to pay oppressive +taxes. Besides, they were limited to the meanest trades and to usury +and peddling. They were shut up in their narrow Jewries, huddled in +wretched cabins, which clustered about the dilapidated synagogue in a +shamefaced way. What strange homes! What gigantic misery, what +boundless suffering dumbly borne, was concealed in those crumbling, +curse-laden dwellings! And yet, how resplendent they were with +spiritual light, what exalted virtues, what lofty heroism they +harbored! In those gloomy, tumbledown Jew houses, intellectual +endeavor was at white heat. The torch of faith blazed clear in them, +and on the pure domestic hearth played a gentle flame. In the abject, +dishonored son of the Ghetto was hidden an intellectual giant. In his +nerveless body, bent double by suffering, and enveloped in the shabby +old cloak still further disfigured by the yellow wheel, dwelt the soul +of a thinker. The son of the Ghetto might have worn his badge with +pride, for in truth it was a medal of distinction awarded by the papal +Church to the Jews, for dauntlessness and courage. The awkward, puny +Jew in his way was stronger and braver than a German knight armed +cap-a-pie, for he was penetrated by the faith that "moves mountains." +And when the worst came to the worst, he demonstrated his courage. +When his peaceful home was stormed by the bestialized hordes of +Armleder, or the drunken bands of the Flagellants, or the furious +avengers of the "Black Death," he did not yield, did not purchase life +by disgraceful treason. With invincible courage he put his head under +the executioner's axe, and breathed forth his heroic spirit with the +enthusiastic cry: "Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God is One." + +At length the turn of the Spanish Jews arrived. For the unbroken peace +they had enjoyed, they had to atone by centuries of unexampled +suffering. By degrees, the Arabs were forced out of the Pyrenean +Peninsula, and the power they had to abdicate was assumed by the +Catholic kings of Castile and Aragon. In 1236 occurred the fall of +Cordova, the most important centre of Arabic Jewish culture. +Thereafter Arab power held sway only in the province of Granada. The +fortunes of the Spanish Jews underwent a calamitous change. The kings +and the upper ten thousand were, indeed, favorably disposed toward +them. At the courts of Castile and Aragon, the Jews were active as +ministers, physicians, astronomers. But the people, incited by the +propaganda of the clerics, nursed frightful hatred against the Jews, +not only as "infidels," but also as intellectual aristocrats. The rage +of the populace was the combustible material in the terrific +explosions that occurred periodically, in the bloody saturnalia of the +Pastouraux (1320), in the Black Death riots (1348), in the massacre of +Seville (1391). + +Dire blows of fortune were unable to weigh down the Spanish Jew, +accustomed to independence, as they did the German Jew. He carried his +head proudly on high, for he was conscious that in all respects he +stood above the rabble pursuing him, above its very leaders, the +clerics. In spite of untoward fate his mental development proceeded, +but inevitably it was modified by the trend of the times. By the side +of the philosophic tendency of the previous age, a mystical tendency +appeared in literature. The Kabbala, with its mist-shrouded symbolism, +so grateful to the feelings and the imagination, chimed in better than +rationalistic philosophy with the depressed humor under which the +greater part of the Jews were then laboring. Another force +antagonistic to rationalistic philosophy was the Rabbinism +transplanted from France and Germany. The controversy between +Rabbinism and philosophy, which dragged itself through three-quarters +of a century (1232-1305), ended in the formal triumph of Rabbinism. +However, philosophic activity merely languished, it did not cease +entirely; in fact, the three currents for some time ran along parallel +with one another. Next to the pillars of Rabbinism, Asheri, Rashba, +Isaac ben Sheshet, loomed up the philosophers, Gersonides (Ralbag), +Kreskas, and Albo, and a long line of Kabbalists, beginning with +Nachmanides and Moses de Leon, the compiler of the Zohar, and ending +with the anonymous authors of the mysterious "Kana and Pelia." + +The times grew less and less propitious. Catholicism steadily gained +ground in Spain. The scowling Dominican put forward his claim upon the +Jewish soul with vehement emphasis, and made every effort to drag it +into the bosom of the alone-saving Church. The conversion of the Jews +would have been a great triumph, indeed, for Catholicism militant. The +conversion methods of the Dominican monk were of a most insinuating +kind--he usually began with a public religious disputation. +Unfortunately, the Jews were experts in the art of debate, and too +often by their bold replies covered the self-sufficient dignitaries of +Rome with confusion. The Jews should have known, from bitter +experience, that such boldness would not be passed over silently. From +sumptuous debating hall to Dominican prison and scaffold was but a +short step. In 1391, one of these worthy soul-catchers, Bishop +Ferdinando Martinez, set the fanatical mob of Seville on the Jews, and +not without success. Terrorized by the threat of death, many accepted +Catholicism under duress. But they became Christians only in +appearance; in reality they remained true to the faith of their +fathers, and, in secret, running the risk of loss of life, they +fulfilled all the Jewish ordinances. This is the prologue to the +thrilling Marrano tragedy. + +Finally, the moment approached when gloomy Catholicism attained to +unchallenged supremacy in the Pyrenean Peninsula. On the ruins of the +enlightened culture of the Arabs, Ferdinand the Catholic and Isabella +of Castile reared the reactionary government of medieval Rome. The +Inquisition was introduced (1480). Torquemada presided as high priest +over the rites attending the human sacrifices. _Ad gloriam +ecclesiae_, the whole of Spain was illuminated. Everywhere the +funeral pyres of the Inquisition flared to the skies, the air was rent +by the despairing shrieks of martyrs enveloped in flames or racked by +tortures, the prisons overflowed with Marranos,--all instruments of +torture were vigorously plied. + +At last the hour of redemption struck: in 1492 all Jews were driven +from Spain, and a few years later from Portugal. Jewish-Arabic culture +after five centuries of ascendency suffered a sudden collapse. The +unhappy people again grasped its staff, and wandered forth into the +world without knowing whither. + + + + +X + +THE RABBINIC-MYSTICAL PERIOD, OR THE HEGEMONY OF THE GERMAN-POLISH +JEWS (1492-1789) + + +The expulsion from Spain was a stunning blow. The hoary martyr people +which had defied so many storms in its long life was for a moment +dazed. The soil of Europe was quaking under its feet. At the time when +the medieval period had formally come to a close for Occidental +Christendom, and the modern period had opened, the middle ages +continued in unmitigated brutality for the Jews. If anything, the life +of the Jews had become more unendurable than before. What, indeed, had +the much-vaunted modern age to offer them? In the ranks of the +humanistic movement Reuchlin alone stood forth prominently as the +advocate of the Jews, and he was powerless before the prejudices of +the populace. The Reformation in Germany and elsewhere had illuminated +the minds of the people, but had not softened their hearts. Luther +himself, the creator of the Reformation, was not innocent of hating +the followers of an alien faith. The Jews especially did not enjoy too +great a measure of his sympathies. The wars growing out of the +Reformation, which in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries +devastated Europe in the name of religion, were not calculated to +favor the spread of tolerance and milder manners. The conflict raging +in the bosom of the Church and setting her own children by the ears, +was yet insufficient to divert her maternal care from her +"unbelieving" stepchildren. In Spain and Portugal, stakes continued to +burn two centuries longer for the benefit of the Marranos, the false +Christians. In Germany and Austria, the Jews were kept in the same +condition of servitude as before. Their economic circumstances were +appalling. They were forced to emigrate _en masse_ to Poland, +which offered the adherents of their faith a comparatively quiet life, +and by and by was invested with the Jewish hegemony. Some of the +smaller states and independent towns of Italy also afforded the Jews +an asylum, though one not always to be depended upon. A group of +hard-driven Spanish exiles, for instance, under the leadership of +Abarbanel had found peace in Italy. The rest had turned to Turkey and +her province Palestine, + +For a time, indeed, the Jewish spiritual centre was located in Turkey. +What Europe, old, Christian, and hardhearted, refused the Jews, was +granted them by Turkey, young, Mussulman, and liberal. On hearing of +the banishment of the Jews from Spain, Sultan Bajazet exclaimed: "How +can you call Ferdinand of Aragon a wise king, the same Ferdinand who +has made his land poor and enriched ours?" His amazement characterizes +the relation of Turkey to the Jews of the day. The one-time Marrano, +Joseph Nassi, rose to be a considerable dignitary at the court of +Sultan Selim (1566-1580). Occasionally he succeeded, by diplomatic +means, in wreaking vengeance upon European courts in retaliation for +the brutal tortures inflicted upon his people. With the generosity of +a Maecenas, he assembled Jewish scholars and poets, and surrounded +himself with a sunlit atmosphere of intellectuality and talent. All +other Jewish communities looked up to that of Constantinople. Now and +again its rabbis played the part of Patriarchs of the synagogue. To +this commanding position the rabbis of Palestine especially were +inclined to lay claim. They even attempted to restore the +Patriarchate, and the famous controversy between Jacob Berab and Levi +ben Chabib regarding the _Semicha_ is another evidence of the +same assertive tendency. Among the Spanish exiles settled in the Holy +Land a peculiar spiritual current set in. The storm-tossed wanderers, +but now returned to their native Jordan from the shores of the +blood-stained Tagus and Guadalquivir, were mightily moved at the sight +of their ancestral home. Ahasuerus, who on his thorn-strewn pilgrim's +path had drained the cup of woe to the dregs, suddenly caught sight of +the home of his childhood razed level with the ground. The precious, +never-to-be-forgotten ruins exhaled the home feeling, which took +possession of him with irresistible charm. Into his soul there flowed +sweet memories of a golden youth, past beyond recall. The impact of +these emotions enkindled passionate "longing for Zion" in the heart of +the forlorn, homeless martyr. He was seized by torturing thirst for +political resurrection. Such melancholy feelings and vehement +outbursts found expression in the practical Kabbala, originating with +Ari (Isaac Luria) and his famous Safed school. A mystical belief in +the coming of Messiah thenceforward became one of the essential +elements of the Jewish spirit. It vanquished the heart of the learned +Joseph Karo, who had brought Rabbinism to its climax by the +compilation of his celebrated ritual code, the Shulchan Aruch. With +equal force it dominated the being of Solomon Molcho, the enthusiastic +youth who, at one time a Marrano, on his public return to Judaism +proclaimed the speedy regeneration of Israel. He sealed his faith in +his prophecy with death at the stake (1532). The Marranos beyond the +Pyrenees and the unfortunate Jews of Italy, who, in the second half of +the sixteenth century had to bear the brunt of papal fanaticism, on +the increase since the Reformation, were kept in a state of constant +excitement by this Messianic doctrine, with its obscure stirrings of +hope. A mournful national feeling pervades the Jewish literature of +the time. Recollections of torments endured enflamed all hearts. A +series of chronicles were thus produced that record the centuries of +Jewish martyrdom--_Jocha-sin, Shebet Jehuda, Emek ha-Bacha_, etc. +The art of printing, even then developed to a considerable degree of +perfection, became for the dispersed Jews the strongest bond of +spiritual union. The papal _index librorum prohibitorum_ was +impotent in the face of the all-pervading propaganda for thought and +feeling carried on by the printing press. + +After Palestine and Turkey, Holland for a time became the spiritual +centre of the scattered Jews (in the seventeenth century). Holland was +warmly attached to the cause of liberty. When it succeeded in freeing +itself from the clutches of fanatical Spain and her rapacious king, +Philip II, it inaugurated the golden era of liberty of conscience, of +peaceful development in culture and industry, and granted an asylum to +the persecuted and abandoned of all countries. By the thousands the +harassed Ghetto sons, especially the Marranos from Spain and Portugal, +migrated to Holland. Amsterdam became a second Cordova. The +intellectual life was quickened. Freedom from restraint tended to +break down the national exclusivism of the Jew, and intercourse with +his liberal surroundings varied his mental pursuits. Rabbinism, the +Kabbala, philosophy, national poetry--they all had their prominent +representatives in Holland. These manifold tendencies were united in +the literary activity of Manasseh ben Israel, a scholar of extensive, +though not intensive, encyclopedic attainments. Free thought and +religious rationalism were embodied in Uriel Acosta. To a still higher +degree they were illustrated in the theory of life expounded by the +immortal author of the "Theologico-Political Tractate" (1640-1677). +This advanced state of culture in Holland did not fail to react upon +the neighboring countries. Under the impulse of enthusiasm for the +Bible Puritan England under Cromwell opened its portals to the Jews. +In Italy, in the dank atmosphere of rabbinical dialectics and morbid +mysticism, great figures loom up--Leon de Modena, the antagonist of +Rabbinism and of the Kabbala, and Joseph del Medigo, mathematician, +philosopher, and mystic, the disciple of Galileo. + +These purple patches were nothing more than the accidents of a +transition period. The people as a whole was on the decline. The +Jewish mind darted hither and thither, like a startled bird seeking +its nest. Holland or Turkey was an inadequate substitute for Spain, if +only for the reason that but a tiny fraction of the Jews had found +shelter in either. The Jewish national centre must perforce coincide +with the numerical centre of the dispersed people, in which, moreover, +conditions must grant Jews the possibility of living undisturbed in +closely compacted masses, and of perfecting a well-knit organization +of social and individual life. Outside of Spain these conditions were +fulfilled only by Poland, which gradually, beginning with the +sixteenth century, assumed the hegemony over the Jewry of the world. +This marks the displacement of the Sephardic (Spanish, in a broader +sense, Romanic) element, and the supremacy of the Ashkenazic +(German-Polish) element. + +Poland had been a resort for Jewish immigrants from Germany since the +outbreak of the Crusades, until, in the sixteenth century, it rose to +the position of a Jewish centre of the first magnitude. As the +merchant middle class, the Jews were protected and advanced by the +kings and the Szlachta. The consequent security of their position +induced so rapid a growth of the Jewish element that in a little while +the Jews of Poland outnumbered those of the old Jewish settlements in +Occidental Europe. The numerous privileges granted the Jews, by +Boleslaus of Kalish (1246), Kasimir the Great (1347-1370), Witowt +(1388), Kasimir IV (1447), and some of their successors, fortified +their position in the extended territory covered by Poland, Lithuania, +and the Ukraine. Their peculiar circumstances in Poland left an +impress upon their inner life. An intense mental activity was called +forth. This activity can be traced back to German beginnings, though +at the same time it is made up of many original elements. For a space +Rabbinism monopolized the intellectual endeavors of the Polish Jews. +The rabbi of Cracow, Moses Isserles, and the rabbi of Ostrog, Solomon +Luria (d. 1572), disputed first place with the foremost rabbinical +authorities of other countries. Their decisions and circular letters +regarding religious and legal questions were accorded binding force. +Associates and successors of theirs founded Talmud academies +throughout the country, and large numbers of students attended them. +Commentators upon the Talmud and expounders of classical works in +Jewish theological literature appeared in shoals. Jewish printing +establishments in Cracow and Lublin were assiduous in turning out a +mass of writings, which spread the fame of the Polish rabbis to the +remotest communities. The large autonomy enjoyed by the Polish and +Lithuanian Jews conferred executive power upon rabbinical legislation. +The _Kahal_, or Jewish communal government, to a certain degree +invested with judicial and administrative competence, could not do +without the guiding hand of the rabbis as interpreters of the law. The +guild of rabbis, on their side, chose a "college of judges," with +fairly extensive jurisdiction, from among their own members. The +organization of the Rabbinical Conferences, or the "Synods of the Four +Countries," formed the keystone of this intricate social-spiritual +hierarchy. The comprehensive inner autonomy and the system of Talmud +academies (_Yeshiboth_) that covered the whole of Poland remind +one of the brilliant days of the Exilarchate and the Babylonia of the +Geonim. One element was lacking, there was no versatile, commanding +thinker like Saadia Gaon. Secular knowledge and philosophy were under +the ban in Poland. Rabbinism absorbed the whole output of intellectual +energy. As little as the Poles resembled the Arabs of the "golden +age," did the Polish Jews resemble their brethren in faith in the +Orient at Saadia's time or in the Spain of Gabirol and Maimonides. +Isolation and clannishness were inevitable in view of the character of +the Christian environment and the almost insuperable barriers raised +between the classes of Polish society. But it was this exclusiveness +that gave peculiar stability and completeness to the life of the Jew +as an individual and as a member of Jewish society, and it was the +same exclusiveness that afforded opportunity for the development of a +sharply defined culture, for its fixation to the point of resisting +violent shocks and beyond the danger point of extinction through +foreign invasion. + +The fateful year 1648 formed a turning point in the history of the +Polish Jews, as in the history of the countries belonging to the +Polish crown. The Cossack butcheries and wars of extermination of +1648-1658 were the same for the Polish Jews that the Crusades, the +Black Death, and all the other occasions for carnage had been for the +Jews of Western Europe. It seemed as though history desired to avoid +the reproach of partiality, and hastened to mete out even-handed +justice by apportioning the same measure of woe to the Jews of Poland +as to the Jews of Western Europe. But the Polish Jews were prepared to +accept the questionable gift from the hands of history. They had +mounted that eminence of spiritual stability on which suffering loses +the power to weaken its victim, but, on the contrary, endues him with +strength. More than ever they shrank into their shell. They shut +themselves up more completely in their inner world, and became morally +dulled against the persecutions, the bitter humiliations, the deep +scorn, which their surroundings visited upon them. The Polish Jew +gradually accustomed himself to his pitiable condition. He hardly knew +that life might be other than it was. That the Polish lord to whom he +was a means of entertainment might treat him with a trace of respect, +or that his neighbors, the middle class merchant, the German guild +member, and the Little Russian peasant, might cherish kindly feelings +toward him, he could not conceive as a possibility. Seeing himself +surrounded by enemies, he took precautions to fortify his camp, not so +much to protect himself against hostile assaults from without--they +were inevitable--as to paralyze the disastrous consequences of such +assaults in his inner world. To compass this end he brought into play +all the means suggested by his exceptional position before the law and +by his own peculiar social constitution. The _Kahal_, the +autonomous rabbinical administration of communal affairs, more and +more assumed the character of an inner dictatorship. Jewish society +was persistently kept under the discipline of rigid principles. In +many affairs the synagogue attained the position of a court of final +appeal. The people were united, or rather packed, into a solid mass by +purely mechanical processes--by pressure from without, and by drawing +tight a noose from within. Besides this social factor tending to +consolidate the Jewish people into a separate union, an intellectual +lever was applied to produce the same result. Rabbinism employed the +mystical as its adjutant. The one exercised control over all minds, +the other over all hearts. The growth of mysticism was fostered both +by the unfortunate conditions under which the Polish Jews endured +existence and by the Messianic movements which made their appearance +among the Jews of other countries. + +In the second half of the seventeenth century, mysticism reached its +zenith in Turkey, the country in which, had stood the cradle of the +"practical Kabbala." The teachings of Ari, Vital, and the school +established by them spread like wildfire. Messianic extravagances +intoxicated the baited and persecuted people. In Smyrna appeared the +false Messiah, Sabbatai Zebi. As by magic he attracted to himself a +tremendous company of adherents in the East and in the West. For a +quarter of a century (1650-1676), he kept the Jewish communities +everywhere in a state of quivering suspense. + +The harassed people tossed to and fro like a fever patient, and raved +about political re-birth. Its delirious visions still further heated +its agitated blood. It came to its senses but slowly. Not even the +apostasy and death of Sabbatai Zebi sufficed to sober all his +followers. Under the guise of a symbolic faith in a Messiah, many of +them, publicly or secretly, continued the propaganda for his +doctrines. + +This propaganda prepared the fertile soil from which, in the +eighteenth century, shot up Messianic systems, tending to split +Judaism into sects. Nowhere did the mystical teachings evoke so ready +a response as in Poland, the very centre of Judaism. At first an ally +of the rabbinical school, mysticism grown passionate and +uncontrollable now and again acted as the violent opponent of +Rabbinism. Secret devotion to the Sabbatian doctrines, which had made +their home in Poland, sometimes led to such extremes in dogma and +ethics that the rabbis could not contain themselves. Chayyim Malach, +Judah Chassid, and other Galician mystics, in the second decade of the +eighteenth century brought down upon themselves a rabbinical decree of +excommunication. The mystical tendency was the precursor of the +heretical half-Christian sect of Frankists, who ventured so far as to +lift a hand against the fundamentals of Judaism: they rejected the +Talmud in favor of the Zohar (1756-1773). At the same time a much more +profound movement, instinct with greater vitality, made its appearance +among the Polish-Jewish masses, a movement rooted in their social and +spiritual organization. The wretched, debased condition of the average +Jew, conjoined with the traditions of the Kabbala and the excrescences +of Rabbinism, created a foothold for Chassidic teaching. Chassidism +replaced Talmudic ratiocination by exalted religious sentiment. By the +force of enthusiasm for faith, it drew its adherents together into a +firmly welded unit in contrast with Rabbinism, which sought the same +goal by the aid of the formal law. Scenting danger, the rabbinical +hierarchy declared war upon the Kabbala. Emden opposed Eibeschuetz, the +Polish Sabbatians and Frankists were fought to the death, the Wilna +Gaon organized a campaign against the Chassidim. Too late! Rabbinism +was too old, too arid, to tone down the impulsive outbreaks of passion +among the people. In their religious exaltation the masses were +looking for an elixir. They were languishing, not for light to +illumine the reason, but for warmth to set the heart aglow. They +desired to lose themselves in ecstatic self-renunciation. Chassidism +and its necessary dependence upon the Zaddik offered the masses the +means of this forgetfulness of self through faith. They were the +medium through which the people saw the world in a rosy light, and the +consequences following upon their prevalence were seen in a marked +intensification of Jewish exclusiveness. + +The same aloofness characterizes the Jews of the rest of the +eighteenth century diaspora. Wherever, as in Germany, Austria, and +Italy, Jews were settled in considerable numbers, they were separated +from their surroundings by forbidding Ghetto walls. On the whole, no +difference is noticeable between conditions affecting Jews in one +country and those in another. Everywhere they were merely tolerated, +everywhere oppressed and humiliated. The bloody persecutions of the +middle ages were replaced by the burden of the exceptional laws, which +in practice degraded the Jews socially to an inferior race, to +citizens of a subordinate degree. The consequences were uniformly the +same in all countries: spiritual isolation and a morbid religious +mood. During the first half of the "century of reason," Jewry +presented the appearance of an exhausted wanderer, heavily dragging +himself on his way, his consciousness clouded, his trend of thought +obviously anti-rationalistic. At the very moment in which Europe was +beginning to realize its medieval errors and repent of them, and the +era of universal ideals of humanity was dawning, Judaism raised +barricades between itself and the world at large. Elijah Gaon and +Israel Besht were the contemporaries of Voltaire and Rousseau. +Apparently there was no possibility of establishing communication +between these two diametrically opposed worlds. But history is a +magician. Not far from the Poland enveloped in medieval darkness, the +morning light of a new life was breaking upon slumbering Jewry in +German lands. New voices made themselves heard, reverberating like an +echo to the appeal issued by the "great century" in behalf of a +spiritual and social regeneration of mankind. + + + + +XI + +THE MODERN PERIOD OF ENLIGHTENMENT (THE NINETEENTH CENTURY) + + +Two phenomena signalized the beginning of the latest period in Jewish +history: the lofty activity of Mendelssohn and the occurrence of the +great French Revolution. The man stands for the spiritual emancipation +of the Jews, the movement for their political emancipation. At bottom, +these two phenomena were by no means the ultimate causes of the social +and spiritual regeneration of the Jewish people. They were only the +products of the more general causes that had effected a similar +regeneration in all the peoples of Western Europe. The new currents, +the abandonment of effete intellectual and social forms, the +substitution of juster and more energetic principles, the protest +against superstition and despotism--all these traits had a common +origin, the resuscitation of reason and free thought, which dominated +all minds without asking whether they belonged to Jew or to Christian. +It might seem that the rejuvenation of the Jews had been consummated +more rapidly than the rejuvenation of the other peoples. The latter +had had two centuries, the period elapsing since the middle ages, that +is, the period between the Reformation and the great Revolution, in +which to prepare for a more rational and a more humane conduct of +life. As for the Jews, their middle ages began much later, and ended +later, almost on the eve of 1789, so that the revolution in their +minds and their mode of life had to accomplish itself hastily, under +the urgence of swiftly crowding events, by the omission of +intermediate stages. But it must be taken into consideration that long +before, in the Judeo-Hellenic and in the Arabic-Spanish period, the +Jews had passed through their "century of reason." In spite of the +intervening ages of suffering and gloom, the faculty of assimilating +new principles had survived. For the descendants of Philo and +Maimonides the rationalistic movement of the eighteenth century was in +part a repetition of a well-known historical process. They had had the +benefit of a similar course of studies before, and, therefore, had no +need to cram on the eve of the final examination. + +In point of fact, the transformation in the life of the Jews did take +place with extraordinary swiftness. It was hastened in France by the +principles of the Revolution and the proclamation of the civil +equality of Jews with the other citizens. In Germany, however, it +advanced upon purely spiritual lines. Mendelssohn and Lessing, the +heralds of spiritual reform, who exposed old prejudices, carried on +their labors at a time in which the Jews still stood beyond the pale +of the law, a condition which it did not occur to Frederick II, "the +philosopher upon the throne," to improve. A whole generation was +destined to pass before the civil emancipation of the German Jews was +accomplished. Meantime their spiritual emancipation proceeded apace, +without help from the ruling powers. A time so early as the end of the +eighteenth century found the German Jews in a position to keep step +with their Christian fellow-citizens in cultural progress. Enlightened +Jews formed close connections with enlightened Christians, and joined +them in the universal concerns of mankind as confederates espousing +the same fundamental principles. If they renounced some of their +religious and national traditions, it was by no means out of +complaisance for their neighbors. They were guided solely and alone by +those universal principles that forced non-Jews as well as Jews to +reject many traditions as incompatible with reason and conscience. +Non-Jews and Jews alike yielded themselves up to the fresh inspiration +of the time, and permitted themselves to be carried along by the +universal transforming movement. Mendelssohn himself, circumspect and +wise, did not move off from religious national ground. But the +generation after him abandoned his position for that of universal +humanity, or, better, German nationality. His successors intoxicated +themselves with deep draughts of the marvelous poetry created by the +magic of Goethe and Schiller. They permitted themselves to be rushed +along by the liberty doctrines of 1789, they plunged head over heels +into the vortex of romanticism, and took an active part in the +conspicuous movements of Europe, political, social, and literary, as +witness Borne, Heine, and their fellow-combatants. + +The excitement soon evaporated. When the noise of the liberty +love-feasts had subsided, when the cruel reaction (after 1814) had +settled heavily upon the Europe of the nineteenth century, and God's +earth had again become the arena of those agents of darkness whom +dreamers had thought buried forever beneath the ruins of the old +order, then the German Jews, or such of them as thought, came to their +senses. The more intelligent Jewish circles realized that, in devotion +to the German national movement, they had completely neglected their +own people. Yet their people, too, had needs, practical or spiritual, +had its peculiar national sphere of activity, circumscribed, indeed, +by the larger sphere of mankind's activities as by a concentric +circle, but by no means merged into it. To atone for their sin, +thinking Jews retraced their steps. They took in hand the transforming +of Jewish inner life, the simplification of the extremely complicated +Jewish ritual, the remodeling of pedagogic methods, and, above all, +the cultivation of the extended fields of Jewish science, whose head +and front is Jewish historical research in all its vastness and +detail. Heine's friend, Zunz, laid the cornerstone of Jewish science +in the second decade of the nineteenth century. His work was taken up +by a goodly company of zealous and able builders occupied for half a +century with the task of rearing the proud edifice of a scientific +historical literature, in which national self-consciousness was +sheltered and fostered. At the very height of this reforming and +literary activity, German Jewry was overwhelmed by the civil +emancipation of 1848. Again a stirring movement drew them into +sympathy with a great general cause, but this time without drawing +them away from Jewish national interests. Cultural and civil +assimilation was accomplished as an inner compelling necessity, as a +natural outcome of living. But spiritual assimilation, in the sense of +a merging of Judaism in foreign elements, was earnestly repudiated by +the noblest representatives of Judaism. It was their ideal that +universal activity and national activity should be pursued to the +prejudice of neither, certainly not to the exclusion of one or the +other, but in perfect harmony with each other. In point of fact, it +may be asserted that, in spite of a frequent tendency to go to the one +or the other extreme, the two currents, the universal and the +national, co-exist within German Jewry, and there is no fear of their +uniting, they run parallel with each other. The Jewish genius is +versatile. Without hurt to itself it can be active in all sorts of +careers: in politics and in civil life, in parliament and on the +lecture platform, in all branches of science and departments of +literature, in every one of the chambers of mankind's intellectual +laboratory. At the same time it has its domestic hearth, its national +sanctuary; it has its sphere of original work and its self-consciousness, +its national interests and spiritual ideals rooted in the past of the Jew. +By the side of a Lassalle, a Lasker, and a Marx towers a Riesser, a +Geiger, a Graetz. The leveling process unavoidably connected with +widespread culture, so far from causing spiritual desolation in +German Judaism, has, on the contrary, furnished redundant proof +that even under present conditions, so unfavorable to what is +individual and original, the Jewish people has preserved its vitality +to the full. + +An analogous movement stirred the other countries of Western +Europe--France, Italy, and England. The political emancipation of the +Jews was accomplished earlier in them than in Germany. The +reconstruction of the inner life, too, proceeded more quietly and +regularly, without leaps and bounds, and religious reform established +itself by degrees. Yet even here, where the Jewish contingent was +insignificant, the spiritual physiognomy of the Jews maintained its +typical character. In these countries, as in Germany, the Jew +assimilated European culture with all its advantages and its +drawbacks. He was active on diplomatic fields, he devoted himself to +economic investigations, he produced intellectual creations of all +kinds--first and last he felt himself to be a citizen of his country. +None the less he was a loyal son of the Jewish people considered as a +spiritual people with an appointed task. Cremieux, Beaconsfield, +Luzzatti are counterbalanced by Salvador, Frank, Munk, Reggio, and +Montefiore. All the good qualities and the shortcomings distinctive of +the civilization of modern times adhere to the Jew. But at its worst +modern civilization has not succeeded in extinguishing the national +spirit in Jewry. The national spirit continues to live in the people, +and it is this spirit that quickens the people. The genius of Jewish +history, as in centuries gone by, holds watch over the sons of the +"eternal people" scattered to all ends of the earth. West-European +Jewry may say of itself, without presumption: _Cogito ergo sum_. + +Russian Jewry, the Jewry that had been Polish, and that is counted by +the millions, might, if necessary, prove its existence by even more +tangible marks than Occidental Jewry. To begin with, the centre of +gravity of the Jewish nation lies in Russia, whose Jews not only +outnumber those of the rest of Europe, but continue to live in a +compact mass. Besides, they have preserved the original Jewish culture +and their traditional physiognomy to a higher degree than the Jews of +other countries. The development of the Russian Jews took a course +very different from that of the Jews of the West. This difference was +conditioned by the tremendous contrast between Russian culture and +West-European culture, and by the change which the external +circumstances of Jews outside of Russia underwent during the modern +period. The admission of the Polish provinces into the Russian Empire +at the end of the eighteenth century found the numerous Jewish +population in an almost medieval condition, the same condition in +which the non-Jewish population of Russian Poland was at that time. +The Polish regime, as we saw above, had isolated the Jews alike in +civil and spiritual relations. The new order did not break down the +barriers. The masses of Jews cooped up in the "Pale of Settlement" +were strong only by reason of their inner unity, their firmly +established patriarchal organization. The bulwark of Rabbinism and the +citadel of Chassidism protected them against alien influences. They +guarded their isolation jealously. True to the law of inertia, they +would not allow the privilege of isolation to be wrested from them. +They did not care to step beyond the ramparts. Why, indeed, should the +Jews have quitted their fortress, if outside of their walls they could +expect nothing but scorn and blows? The unfortunates encaged in the +sinister Pale of Settlement could have been lured out of their +exclusive position only by complete civil emancipation combined with a +higher degree of culture than had been attained by Russian society, an +impossible set of circumstances in the first half of the nineteenth +century. The legislative measures of the time, in so far as they +relate to the Jews, breathe the spirit of police surveillance rather +than of enlightenment and humanity. To civilizing and intellectual +influences from without the way was equally barred. Yet all this +watchfulness was of no avail. Nothing could prevent the liberty +principles espoused by the Jews of Western Europe from being smuggled +into the Pale, to leaven the sad, serried masses. A sluggish process +of fermentation set in, and culminated in the literary activity of +Isaac Beer Levinsohn and of the Wilna reformers of the second and +fourth decades of the nineteenth century. They were the harbingers of +approaching spring. + +When spring finally came (after 1855), and the sun sent down his +genial rays upon the wretched Jewry of Russia, life and activity began +to appear at once, especially in the upper strata. As in Germany, so +in Russia spiritual emancipation preceded political emancipation. +Still shorn almost entirely of the elementary rights of citizens, the +Russian Jews nevertheless followed their ideal promptings, and +participated enthusiastically in the movement for enlightenment which +at that time held the noblest of the Russians enthralled. In a +considerable portion of the Russian Jewish community a process of +culture regeneration began, an eager throwing off of outworn forms of +life and thought, a swift adoption of humane principles. Jewish young +men crowded into the secular schools, in which they came in close +contact with their Christian contemporaries. Influenced by their new +companions, they gave themselves up to Russian national movements, +often at the cost of renunciation of self. Some of them, indeed, in +one-sided aspiration strove to become, not Russians, but men. The +influence exercised by literature was more moderate than that of the +schools. Rabbinic and Chassidistic literature, on the point of dying +out as it was, abandoned the field to the literature of enlightenment +in the Hebrew language, a literature of somewhat primitive character. +It consisted chiefly of naive novels and of didactic writings of +publicists, and lacked the solid scientific and historical element +that forms the crown of Western Jewish literature. It is indisputable, +however, that it exerted an educational influence. Besides, it +possesses the merit of having resuscitated one of the most valuable of +Jewish national possessions, the Hebrew language in its purity, which +in Russia alone has become a pliant instrument of literary expression. +A still greater field was reserved for the Jewish-Russian literature +that arose in the "sixties." It was called into being in order to +present a vivid and true picture of the social and spiritual interests +of the Jews. Proceeding from discussions of current political topics, +this literature gradually widened its limits so as to include Jewish +history, Jewish science, and the portrayal of Jewish life, and more +and more approached the character of a normal European literature. All +this was in the making, and the most important work had not yet begun. +The lower strata of the people had not been touched by the fresh air. +In time, if all had gone well, they, too, would have had their day. +And if the minority of the Jewish people in the West in a short span +of time brought forth so many notable workers in so many departments +of life and thought, how much superior would be the culture +achievements of the Eastern majority! How vigorously the mighty mental +forces latent in Russian Jewry would develop when their advance was no +longer obstructed by all sorts of obstacles, and they could be applied +to every sphere of political, social, and intellectual life! + +Nothing of all this came to pass; exactly the opposite happened. Not +only were the barriers in the way of a prosperous, free development of +Jewry not removed, but fresh hindrances without number were +multiplied. Some spectre of the middle ages, some power of darkness, +put brakes upon the wheel of history. It first appeared in the West, +under the name anti-Semitism, among the dregs of European society. But +in its earliest abode it was and is still met with an abrupt rebuff on +the part of the most intelligent circles, those whom even the present +age of decadence has not succeeded in robbing of belief in lofty moral +ideals. Anti-Semitism in the West is in _anima vili_. Its cult is +confined to a certain party, which enjoys a rather scandalous +reputation. But there are countries in which this power of darkness, +in the coarser form of Judophobia[13], has cast its baleful spell upon +the most influential members of society and upon the press. There it +has ripened noxious fruit. Mocking at the exalted ideals and the +ethical traditions of religious and thinking mankind, Judophobia +shamelessly professes the dogma of misanthropy. Its propaganda is +bringing about the moral ruin of an immature society, not yet +confirmed in ethical or truly religious principles. Upon its victims, +the Jews, it has the same effect as the misfortunes of the middle +ages, which were meted out to our hoary people with overflowing +measure, and against which it learnt to assume an armor of steel. The +recent severe trials are having the same result as the persecutions of +former days: they do not weaken, on the contrary, they invigorate the +Jewish spirit, they spur on to thought, they stimulate the pulse of +the people. + + "The hammer shivers glass, + But iron by its blows is forged."[14] + + [13] As anti-Semitism is called in Russia. + [14] Pushkin. + +The historical process Jewry has undergone repeatedly, it must undergo +once again. But now, too, in this blasting time of confusion and +dispersion, of daily torture and the horrors of international +conflict, "the keeper of Israel slumbereth not and sleepeth not." The +Jewish spirit is on the alert. It is ever purging and tempering itself +in the furnace of suffering. The people which justly bears the name of +the veteran of history withdraws and falls into a revery. It is not a +narrow-minded fanatic's flight from the world, but the concentrated +thought of a mourner. Jewry is absorbed in contemplation of its great, +unparalleled past. More than ever it is now in need of the teachings +of its past, of the moral support and the prudent counsels of its +history, its four thousand years of life crowded with checkered +experiences. + + + + +XII + +THE TEACHINGS OF JEWISH HISTORY + + +Let us return now to the starting point of our discussion, and +endeavor to establish the thoughts and lessons to be deduced from the +course of Jewish history. + +Above all, Jewish history possesses the student with the conviction +that Jewry at all times, even in the period of political independence, +was pre-eminently a spiritual nation, and a spiritual nation it +continues to be in our own days, too. Furthermore, it inspires him +with the belief that Jewry, being a spiritual entity, cannot suffer +annihilation: the body, the mold, may be destroyed, the spirit is +immortal. Bereft of country and dispersed as it is, the Jewish nation +lives, and will go on living, because a creative principle permeates +it, a principle that is the root of its being and an indigenous +product of its history. This principle consists first in a sum of +definite religious, moral, or philosophic ideals, whose exponent at +all times was the Jewish people, either in its totality, or in the +person of its most prominent representatives. Next, this principle +consists in a sum of historical memories, recollections of what in the +course of many centuries the Jewish people experienced, thought, and +felt, in the depths of its being. Finally, it consists in the +consciousness that true Judaism, which has accomplished great things +for humanity in the past, has not yet played out its part, and, +therefore, may not perish. In short, the Jewish people lives because +it contains a living soul which refuses to separate from its +integument, and cannot be forced out of it by heavy trials and +misfortunes, such as would unfailingly inflict mortal injury upon less +sturdy organisms. + +This self-consciousness is the source from which the suffering Jewish +soul draws comfort. History speaks to it constantly through the mouth +of the great apostle who went forth from the midst of Israel eighteen +hundred years ago: "Call to remembrance the former days, in which, +after ye were enlightened, ye endured a great conflict of sufferings; +partly, being made a gazing-stock both by reproaches and afflictions; +and partly, becoming partakers with them that were so used.... Cast +not away therefore your boldness, which hath great recompense of +reward" (Epistle to the Hebrews, x, 32-34, 35). + +Jewish history, moreover, arouses in the Jew the desire to work +unceasingly at the task of perfecting himself. To direct his attention +to his glorious past, to the resplendent intellectual feats of his +ancestors, to their masterly skill in thinking and suffering, does not +lull him to sleep, does not awaken a dullard's complacency or hollow +self-conceit. On the contrary, it makes exacting demands upon him. +Jewish history admonishes the Jews: "_Noblesse oblige_. The +privilege of belonging to a people to whom the honorable title of the +'veteran of history' has been conceded, puts serious responsibilities +on your shoulders. You must demonstrate that you are worthy of your +heroic past. The descendants of teachers of religion and martyrs of +the faith dare not be insignificant, not to say wicked. If the long +centuries of wandering and misery have inoculated you with faults, +extirpate them in the name of the exalted moral ideals whose bearers +you were commissioned to be. If, in the course of time, elements out +of harmony with your essential being have fastened upon your mind, +cast them out, purify yourselves. In all places and at all times, in +joy and and in sorrow, you must aim to live for the higher, the +spiritual interests. But never may you deem yourselves perfect. If you +become faithless to these sacred principles, you sever the bonds that +unite you with the most vital elements of your past, with the first +cause of your national existence." + +The final lesson to be learned is that in the sunny days of mankind's +history, in which reason, justice, and philanthropic instinct had the +upper hand, the Jews steadfastly made common cause with the other +nations. Hand in hand with them, they trod the path leading to +perfection. But in the dark days, during the reign of rude force, +prejudice, and passion, of which they were the first victims, the Jews +retired from the world, withdrew into their shell, to await better +days. Union with mankind at large, on the basis of the spiritual and +the intellectual, the goal set up by the Jewish Prophets in their +sublime vision of the future (Isaiah, ch. ii, and Micah, ch. iv), is +the ultimate ideal of Judaism's noblest votaries. Will their radiant +hope ever attain to realization? If ever it should be realized,--and +it is incumbent upon us to believe that it will,--not a slight part of +the merits involved will be due to Jewish history. We have adverted to +the lofty moral and humanitarian significance of Jewish history in its +role as conciliator. With regard to one-half of Jewish history, this +conciliatory power is even now a well-established fact. The first part +of Jewish history, the Biblical part, is a source from which, for many +centuries, millions of human beings belonging to the most diverse +denominations have derived instruction, solace, and inspiration. It is +read with devotion by Christians in both hemispheres, in their houses +and their temples. Its heroes have long ago become types, incarnations +of great ideas. The events it relates serve as living ethical +formulas. But a time will come--perhaps it is not very far off--when +the second half of Jewish history, the record of the two thousand +years of the Jewish people's life after the Biblical period, will be +accorded the same treatment. This latter part of Jewish history is not +yet known, and many, in the thrall of prejudice, do not wish to know +it. But ere long it will be known and appreciated. For the thinking +portion of mankind it will be a source of uplifting moral and +philosophical teaching. The thousand years' martyrdom of the Jewish +people, its unbroken pilgrimage, its tragic fate, its teachers of +religion, its martyrs, philosophers, champions, this whole epic will +in days to come sink deep into the memory of men. It will speak to the +heart and the conscience of men, not merely to their curious mind. It +will secure respect for the silvery hair of the Jewish people, a +people of thinkers and sufferers. It will dispense consolation to the +afflicted, and by its examples of spiritual steadfastness and +self-denial encourage martyrs in their devotion. It is our firm +conviction that the time is approaching in which the second half of +Jewish history will be to the noblest part of _thinking_ humanity +what its first half has long been to _believing_ humanity, a +source of sublime moral truths. In this sense, Jewish history in its +entirety is the pledge of the spiritual union between the Jews and the +rest of the nations. + + + + + + + +End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of Jewish History, by S. M. Dubnow + +*** END OF THIS PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK JEWISH HISTORY *** + +***** This file should be named 7836.txt or 7836.zip ***** +This and all associated files of various formats will be found in: + http://www.gutenberg.org/7/8/3/7836/ + +Produced by David King, Charles Franks, and the Online +Distributed Proofreading Team + + +Updated editions will replace the previous one--the old editions +will be renamed. + +Creating the works from public domain print editions means that no +one owns a United States copyright in these works, so the Foundation +(and you!) can copy and distribute it in the United States without +permission and without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, +set forth in the General Terms of Use part of this license, apply to +copying and distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works to +protect the PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm concept and trademark. Project +Gutenberg is a registered trademark, and may not be used if you +charge for the eBooks, unless you receive specific permission. If you +do not charge anything for copies of this eBook, complying with the +rules is very easy. You may use this eBook for nearly any purpose +such as creation of derivative works, reports, performances and +research. They may be modified and printed and given away--you may do +practically ANYTHING with public domain eBooks. Redistribution is +subject to the trademark license, especially commercial +redistribution. + + + +*** START: FULL LICENSE *** + +THE FULL PROJECT GUTENBERG LICENSE +PLEASE READ THIS BEFORE YOU DISTRIBUTE OR USE THIS WORK + +To protect the Project Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting the free +distribution of electronic works, by using or distributing this work +(or any other work associated in any way with the phrase "Project +Gutenberg"), you agree to comply with all the terms of the Full Project +Gutenberg-tm License available with this file or online at + www.gutenberg.org/license. + + +Section 1. General Terms of Use and Redistributing Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic works + +1.A. By reading or using any part of this Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work, you indicate that you have read, understand, agree to +and accept all the terms of this license and intellectual property +(trademark/copyright) agreement. If you do not agree to abide by all +the terms of this agreement, you must cease using and return or destroy +all copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in your possession. +If you paid a fee for obtaining a copy of or access to a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work and you do not agree to be bound by the +terms of this agreement, you may obtain a refund from the person or +entity to whom you paid the fee as set forth in paragraph 1.E.8. + +1.B. "Project Gutenberg" is a registered trademark. It may only be +used on or associated in any way with an electronic work by people who +agree to be bound by the terms of this agreement. There are a few +things that you can do with most Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works +even without complying with the full terms of this agreement. See +paragraph 1.C below. There are a lot of things you can do with Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works if you follow the terms of this agreement +and help preserve free future access to Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. See paragraph 1.E below. + +1.C. The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation ("the Foundation" +or PGLAF), owns a compilation copyright in the collection of Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic works. Nearly all the individual works in the +collection are in the public domain in the United States. If an +individual work is in the public domain in the United States and you are +located in the United States, we do not claim a right to prevent you from +copying, distributing, performing, displaying or creating derivative +works based on the work as long as all references to Project Gutenberg +are removed. Of course, we hope that you will support the Project +Gutenberg-tm mission of promoting free access to electronic works by +freely sharing Project Gutenberg-tm works in compliance with the terms of +this agreement for keeping the Project Gutenberg-tm name associated with +the work. You can easily comply with the terms of this agreement by +keeping this work in the same format with its attached full Project +Gutenberg-tm License when you share it without charge with others. + +1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also govern +what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most countries are in +a constant state of change. If you are outside the United States, check +the laws of your country in addition to the terms of this agreement +before downloading, copying, displaying, performing, distributing or +creating derivative works based on this work or any other Project +Gutenberg-tm work. The Foundation makes no representations concerning +the copyright status of any work in any country outside the United +States. + +1.E. Unless you have removed all references to Project Gutenberg: + +1.E.1. The following sentence, with active links to, or other immediate +access to, the full Project Gutenberg-tm License must appear prominently +whenever any copy of a Project Gutenberg-tm work (any work on which the +phrase "Project Gutenberg" appears, or with which the phrase "Project +Gutenberg" is associated) is accessed, displayed, performed, viewed, +copied or distributed: + +This eBook is for the use of anyone anywhere at no cost and with +almost no restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or +re-use it under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included +with this eBook or online at www.gutenberg.org + +1.E.2. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is derived +from the public domain (does not contain a notice indicating that it is +posted with permission of the copyright holder), the work can be copied +and distributed to anyone in the United States without paying any fees +or charges. If you are redistributing or providing access to a work +with the phrase "Project Gutenberg" associated with or appearing on the +work, you must comply either with the requirements of paragraphs 1.E.1 +through 1.E.7 or obtain permission for the use of the work and the +Project Gutenberg-tm trademark as set forth in paragraphs 1.E.8 or +1.E.9. + +1.E.3. If an individual Project Gutenberg-tm electronic work is posted +with the permission of the copyright holder, your use and distribution +must comply with both paragraphs 1.E.1 through 1.E.7 and any additional +terms imposed by the copyright holder. Additional terms will be linked +to the Project Gutenberg-tm License for all works posted with the +permission of the copyright holder found at the beginning of this work. + +1.E.4. Do not unlink or detach or remove the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License terms from this work, or any files containing a part of this +work or any other work associated with Project Gutenberg-tm. + +1.E.5. Do not copy, display, perform, distribute or redistribute this +electronic work, or any part of this electronic work, without +prominently displaying the sentence set forth in paragraph 1.E.1 with +active links or immediate access to the full terms of the Project +Gutenberg-tm License. + +1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary, +compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form, including any +word processing or hypertext form. However, if you provide access to or +distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg-tm work in a format other than +"Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other format used in the official version +posted on the official Project Gutenberg-tm web site (www.gutenberg.org), +you must, at no additional cost, fee or expense to the user, provide a +copy, a means of exporting a copy, or a means of obtaining a copy upon +request, of the work in its original "Plain Vanilla ASCII" or other +form. Any alternate format must include the full Project Gutenberg-tm +License as specified in paragraph 1.E.1. + +1.E.7. Do not charge a fee for access to, viewing, displaying, +performing, copying or distributing any Project Gutenberg-tm works +unless you comply with paragraph 1.E.8 or 1.E.9. + +1.E.8. You may charge a reasonable fee for copies of or providing +access to or distributing Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works provided +that + +- You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive from + the use of Project Gutenberg-tm works calculated using the method + you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The fee is + owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark, but he + has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to the + Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty payments + must be paid within 60 days following each date on which you + prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your periodic tax + returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked as such and + sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation at the + address specified in Section 4, "Information about donations to + the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +- You provide a full refund of any money paid by a user who notifies + you in writing (or by e-mail) within 30 days of receipt that s/he + does not agree to the terms of the full Project Gutenberg-tm + License. You must require such a user to return or + destroy all copies of the works possessed in a physical medium + and discontinue all use of and all access to other copies of + Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +- You provide, in accordance with paragraph 1.F.3, a full refund of any + money paid for a work or a replacement copy, if a defect in the + electronic work is discovered and reported to you within 90 days + of receipt of the work. + +- You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free + distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm works. + +1.E.9. If you wish to charge a fee or distribute a Project Gutenberg-tm +electronic work or group of works on different terms than are set +forth in this agreement, you must obtain permission in writing from +both the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation and Michael +Hart, the owner of the Project Gutenberg-tm trademark. Contact the +Foundation as set forth in Section 3 below. + +1.F. + +1.F.1. Project Gutenberg volunteers and employees expend considerable +effort to identify, do copyright research on, transcribe and proofread +public domain works in creating the Project Gutenberg-tm +collection. Despite these efforts, Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works, and the medium on which they may be stored, may contain +"Defects," such as, but not limited to, incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other intellectual +property infringement, a defective or damaged disk or other medium, a +computer virus, or computer codes that damage or cannot be read by +your equipment. + +1.F.2. LIMITED WARRANTY, DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES - Except for the "Right +of Replacement or Refund" described in paragraph 1.F.3, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation, the owner of the Project +Gutenberg-tm trademark, and any other party distributing a Project +Gutenberg-tm electronic work under this agreement, disclaim all +liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including legal +fees. YOU AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE, STRICT +LIABILITY, BREACH OF WARRANTY OR BREACH OF CONTRACT EXCEPT THOSE +PROVIDED IN PARAGRAPH 1.F.3. YOU AGREE THAT THE FOUNDATION, THE +TRADEMARK OWNER, AND ANY DISTRIBUTOR UNDER THIS AGREEMENT WILL NOT BE +LIABLE TO YOU FOR ACTUAL, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE OR +INCIDENTAL DAMAGES EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH +DAMAGE. + +1.F.3. LIMITED RIGHT OF REPLACEMENT OR REFUND - If you discover a +defect in this electronic work within 90 days of receiving it, you can +receive a refund of the money (if any) you paid for it by sending a +written explanation to the person you received the work from. If you +received the work on a physical medium, you must return the medium with +your written explanation. The person or entity that provided you with +the defective work may elect to provide a replacement copy in lieu of a +refund. If you received the work electronically, the person or entity +providing it to you may choose to give you a second opportunity to +receive the work electronically in lieu of a refund. If the second copy +is also defective, you may demand a refund in writing without further +opportunities to fix the problem. + +1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth +in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you 'AS-IS', WITH NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO +WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE. + +1.F.5. Some states do not allow disclaimers of certain implied +warranties or the exclusion or limitation of certain types of damages. +If any disclaimer or limitation set forth in this agreement violates the +law of the state applicable to this agreement, the agreement shall be +interpreted to make the maximum disclaimer or limitation permitted by +the applicable state law. The invalidity or unenforceability of any +provision of this agreement shall not void the remaining provisions. + +1.F.6. INDEMNITY - You agree to indemnify and hold the Foundation, the +trademark owner, any agent or employee of the Foundation, anyone +providing copies of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works in accordance +with this agreement, and any volunteers associated with the production, +promotion and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm electronic works, +harmless from all liability, costs and expenses, including legal fees, +that arise directly or indirectly from any of the following which you do +or cause to occur: (a) distribution of this or any Project Gutenberg-tm +work, (b) alteration, modification, or additions or deletions to any +Project Gutenberg-tm work, and (c) any Defect you cause. + + +Section 2. Information about the Mission of Project Gutenberg-tm + +Project Gutenberg-tm is synonymous with the free distribution of +electronic works in formats readable by the widest variety of computers +including obsolete, old, middle-aged and new computers. It exists +because of the efforts of hundreds of volunteers and donations from +people in all walks of life. + +Volunteers and financial support to provide volunteers with the +assistance they need are critical to reaching Project Gutenberg-tm's +goals and ensuring that the Project Gutenberg-tm collection will +remain freely available for generations to come. In 2001, the Project +Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation was created to provide a secure +and permanent future for Project Gutenberg-tm and future generations. +To learn more about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +and how your efforts and donations can help, see Sections 3 and 4 +and the Foundation information page at www.gutenberg.org + + +Section 3. Information about the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive +Foundation + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a non profit +501(c)(3) educational corporation organized under the laws of the +state of Mississippi and granted tax exempt status by the Internal +Revenue Service. The Foundation's EIN or federal tax identification +number is 64-6221541. Contributions to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation are tax deductible to the full extent +permitted by U.S. federal laws and your state's laws. + +The Foundation's principal office is located at 4557 Melan Dr. S. +Fairbanks, AK, 99712., but its volunteers and employees are scattered +throughout numerous locations. Its business office is located at 809 +North 1500 West, Salt Lake City, UT 84116, (801) 596-1887. Email +contact links and up to date contact information can be found at the +Foundation's web site and official page at www.gutenberg.org/contact + +For additional contact information: + Dr. Gregory B. Newby + Chief Executive and Director + gbnewby@pglaf.org + +Section 4. Information about Donations to the Project Gutenberg +Literary Archive Foundation + +Project Gutenberg-tm depends upon and cannot survive without wide +spread public support and donations to carry out its mission of +increasing the number of public domain and licensed works that can be +freely distributed in machine readable form accessible by the widest +array of equipment including outdated equipment. Many small donations +($1 to $5,000) are particularly important to maintaining tax exempt +status with the IRS. + +The Foundation is committed to complying with the laws regulating +charities and charitable donations in all 50 states of the United +States. Compliance requirements are not uniform and it takes a +considerable effort, much paperwork and many fees to meet and keep up +with these requirements. We do not solicit donations in locations +where we have not received written confirmation of compliance. To +SEND DONATIONS or determine the status of compliance for any +particular state visit www.gutenberg.org/donate + +While we cannot and do not solicit contributions from states where we +have not met the solicitation requirements, we know of no prohibition +against accepting unsolicited donations from donors in such states who +approach us with offers to donate. + +International donations are gratefully accepted, but we cannot make +any statements concerning tax treatment of donations received from +outside the United States. U.S. laws alone swamp our small staff. + +Please check the Project Gutenberg Web pages for current donation +methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of other +ways including checks, online payments and credit card donations. +To donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate + + +Section 5. General Information About Project Gutenberg-tm electronic +works. + +Professor Michael S. Hart was the originator of the Project Gutenberg-tm +concept of a library of electronic works that could be freely shared +with anyone. For forty years, he produced and distributed Project +Gutenberg-tm eBooks with only a loose network of volunteer support. + +Project Gutenberg-tm eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the U.S. +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we do not necessarily +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +Most people start at our Web site which has the main PG search facility: + + www.gutenberg.org + +This Web site includes information about Project Gutenberg-tm, +including how to make donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary +Archive Foundation, how to help produce our new eBooks, and how to +subscribe to our email newsletter to hear about new eBooks. + diff --git a/7836.zip b/7836.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..18b659a --- /dev/null +++ b/7836.zip diff --git a/LICENSE.txt b/LICENSE.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6312041 --- /dev/null +++ b/LICENSE.txt @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +This eBook, including all associated images, markup, improvements, +metadata, and any other content or labor, has been confirmed to be +in the PUBLIC DOMAIN IN THE UNITED STATES. + +Procedures for determining public domain status are described in +the "Copyright How-To" at https://www.gutenberg.org. + +No investigation has been made concerning possible copyrights in +jurisdictions other than the United States. Anyone seeking to utilize +this eBook outside of the United States should confirm copyright +status under the laws that apply to them. diff --git a/README.md b/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c9b7c86 --- /dev/null +++ b/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ +Project Gutenberg (https://www.gutenberg.org) public repository for +eBook #7836 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/7836) diff --git a/old/8jwhs10.zip b/old/8jwhs10.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..9a2eb21 --- /dev/null +++ b/old/8jwhs10.zip |