diff options
| author | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 05:23:57 -0700 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Roger Frank <rfrank@pglaf.org> | 2025-10-15 05:23:57 -0700 |
| commit | d326aa1d92c8a57cf5fb8887ec443e5f03f33883 (patch) | |
| tree | 169e86d7cab2c0d7cf7a56837aaa7020bf170b0e | |
| -rw-r--r-- | .gitattributes | 3 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 4664-0.txt | 6458 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | 4664.txt | 6848 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | LICENSE.txt | 11 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | README.md | 2 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/4664.txt | 6848 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | old/4664.zip | bin | 0 -> 142754 bytes |
7 files changed, 20170 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/.gitattributes b/.gitattributes new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6833f05 --- /dev/null +++ b/.gitattributes @@ -0,0 +1,3 @@ +* text=auto +*.txt text +*.md text diff --git a/4664-0.txt b/4664-0.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..084ada5 --- /dev/null +++ b/4664-0.txt @@ -0,0 +1,6458 @@ +*** START OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK 4664 *** + +LIGHT, LIFE, AND LOVE + +Selections from the German Mystics of the Middle Ages + +by + +W. R. Inge + +LONDON +Second Edition + +1919 + + + + + + +CONTENTS + + + + + +INTRODUCTION +ECKHART +TAULER +MEDITATIONS ON THE SEVEN WORDS FROM THE CROSS +SUSO +RUYSBROEK +THEOLOGIA GERMANICA + + + + + + +INTRODUCTION + +Sect. 1. THE PRECURSORS OF THE GERMAN MYSTICS + + + + + +TO most English readers the "Imitation of Christ" is the +representative of mediaeval German mysticism. In reality, however, +this beautiful little treatise belongs to a period when that +movement had nearly spent itself. Thomas a Kempis, as Dr. Bigg has +said,[1] was only a semi-mystic. He tones down the most +characteristic doctrines of Eckhart, who is the great original +thinker of the German mystical school, and seems in some ways to +revert to an earlier type of devotional literature. The "Imitation" +may perhaps be described as an idealised picture of monastic piety, +drawn at a time when the life of the cloister no longer filled a +place of unchallenged usefulness in the social order of Europe. To +find German mysticism at its strongest we must go back a full +hundred years, and to understand its growth we must retrace our +steps as far as the great awakening of the thirteenth century--the +age of chivalry in religion--the age of St. Louis, of Francis and +Dominic, of Bonaventura and Thomas Aquinas. It was a vast revival, +bearing fruit in a new ardour of pity and charity, as well as in a +healthy freedom of thought. The Church, in recognising the new +charitable orders of Francis and Dominic, and the Christianised +Aristotelianism of the schoolmen, retained the loyalty and profited +by the zeal of the more sober reformers, but was unable to prevent +the diffusion of an independent critical spirit, in part provoked +and justified by real abuses. Discontent was aroused, not only by +the worldiness of the hierarchy, whose greed and luxurious living +were felt to be scandalous, but by the widespread economic distress +which prevailed over Western Europe at this period. The crusades +periodically swept off a large proportion of the able-bodied men, of +whom the majority never returned to their homes, and this helped to +swell the number of indigent women, who, having no male protectors, +were obliged to beg their bread. The better class of these female +mendicants soon formed themselves into uncloistered charitable +Orders, who were not forbidden to marry, and who devoted themselves +chiefly to the care of the sick. These Beguines and the +corresponding male associations of Beghards became very numerous in +Germany. Their religious views were of a definite type. Theirs was +an intensely inward religion, based on the longing of the soul for +immediate access to God. The more educated among them tended to +embrace a vague idealistic Pantheism. Mechthild of Magdeburg +(1212-1277), prophetess, poetess, Church reformer, quietist, was the +ablest of the Beguines. Her writings prove to us that the technical +terminology of German mysticism was in use before Eckhart,[2] and +also that the followers of what the "Theologia Germanica" calls the +False Light, who aspired to absorption in the Godhead, and despised +the imitation of the incarnate Christ, were already throwing +discredit on the movement. Mechthild's independence, and her +unsparing denunciations of corruption in high places, brought her +into conflict with the secular clergy. They tried to burn her +books--those religious love songs which had already endeared her to +German popular sentiment. It was then that she seemed to hear a +voice saying to her: + +Lieb' meine, betrŸbe dich nicht zu sehr, + +Die Wahrheit mag niemand verbrennen! + +The rulers of the Church, unhappily, were not content with burning +books. Their hostility towards the unrecognised Orders became more +and more pronounced: the Beghards and Beguines were harried and +persecuted till most of them were driven to join the Franciscans or +Dominicans, carrying with them into those Orders the ferment of +their speculative mysticism. The more stubborn "Brethren and Sisters +of the Free Spirit" were burned in batches at Cologne and elsewhere. +Their fate in those times did not excite much pity, for many of the +victims were idle vagabonds of dissolute character, and the general +public probably thought that the licensed begging friars were enough +of a nuisance without the addition of these free lances. + +The heretical mystical sects of the thirteenth century are very +interesting as illustrating the chief dangers of mysticism. Some of +these sectaries were Socialists or Communists of an extreme kind; +others were Rationalists, who taught that Jesus Christ was the son +of Joseph and a sinner like other men; others were Puritans, who +said that Church music was "nothing but a hellish noise" (nihil nisi +clamor inferni), and that the Pope was the magna meretrix of the +Apocalypse. The majority were Anti-Sacramentalists and Determinists; +and some were openly Antinomian, teaching that those who are led by +the Spirit can do no wrong. The followers of Amalric of Bena[3] +believed that the Holy Ghost had chosen their sect in which to +become incarnate; His presence among them was a continual guarantee +of sanctity and happiness. The "spiritual Franciscans" had dreams of +a more apocalyptic kind. They adopted the idea of an "eternal +Gospel," as expounded by Joachim of Floris, and believed that the +"third kingdom," that of the Spirit, was about to begin among +themselves. It was to abolish the secular Church and to inaugurate +the reign of true Christianity--i.e. "poverty" and asceticism. + +Such are some of the results of what our eighteenth-century +ancestors knew and dreaded as "Enthusiasm"--that ferment of the +spirit which in certain epochs spreads from soul to soul like an +epidemic, breaking all the fetters of authority, despising tradition +and rejecting discipline in its eagerness to get rid of formalism +and unreality; a lawless, turbulent, unmanageable spirit, in which, +notwithstanding, is a potentiality for good far higher than any to +which the lukewarm "religion of all sensible men" can ever attain. +For mysticism is the raw material of all religion; and it is easier +to discipline the enthusiast than to breathe enthusiasm into the +disciplinarian. + +Meanwhile, the Church looked with favour upon the orthodox mystical +school, of which Richard and Hugo of St. Victor, Bonaventura, and +Albertus Magnus were among the greatest names. These men were +working out in their own fashion the psychology of the contemplative +life, showing how we may ascend through "cogitation, meditation, and +speculation" to "contemplation," and how we may pass successively +through jubilus, ebrietas spiritus, spiritualis jucunditas, and +liquefactio, till we attain raptus or ecstasy. The writings of the +scholastic mystics are so overweighted with this pseudo-science, +with its wire-drawn distinctions and meaningless classifications, +that very few readers have now the patience to dig out their +numerous beauties. They are, however, still the classics of mystical +theology in the Roman Church, so far as that science has not +degenerated into mere miracle-mongering. + +Sect. 2. MEISTER ECKHART + +It was in 1260, when Mechthild of Magdeburg was at the height of her +activity, that Meister Eckhart, next to Plotinus the greatest +philosopher-mystic, was born at Hocheim in Thuringia. It seems that +his family was in a good position, but nothing is known of his early +years. He entered the Dominican Order as a youth, perhaps at +sixteen, the earliest age at which novices were admitted into that +Order. The course of instruction among the Dominicans was as +follows:--After two years, during which the novice laid the +foundations of a good general education, he devoted the next two +years to grammar, rhetoric, and dialectic, and then the same amount +of time to what was called the Quadrivium, which consisted of +"arithmetic, mathematics, astronomy, and music." Theology, the queen +of the sciences, occupied three years; and at the end of the course, +at the age of twenty-five, the brothers were ordained priests. We +find Eckhart, towards the end of the century, Prior of Erfurt and +Vicar of Thuringia, then Lector Biblicus at Paris, then Provincial +Prior of Saxony. In 1307 the master of the Order appointed him +Vicar-General for Bohemia, and in 1311 he returned to Paris. We find +him next preaching busily at Strassburg,[4] and after a few more +years, at Cologne, where the persecution of the Brethren of the Free +Spirit was just then at its height. At Strassburg there were no less +than seven convents of Dominican nuns, for since 1267 the Order had +resumed the supervision of female convents, which it had renounced a +short time after its foundation. Many of Eckhart's discourses were +addressed to these congregations of devout women, who indeed were to +a large extent the backbone of the mystical movement, and it is +impossible not to see that the devotional treatises of the school +are strongly coloured by feminine sentiment. A curious poem, written +by a Dominican nun of this period, celebrates the merits of three +preachers, the third of whom is a Master Eckhart, "who speaks to us +about Nothingness. He who understands him not, in him has never +shone the light divine." These nuns seem to have been fed with the +strong meat of Eckhart's mystical philosophy; in the more popular +sermons he tried to be intelligible to all. It was not very long +after he took up his residence at Cologne that he was himself +attacked for heresy. In 1327 he read before his own Order a +retractation of "any errors which might be found" (si quid errorum +repertum fuerit) in his writings, but withdrew nothing that he had +actually said, and protested that he believed himself to be +orthodox. He died a few months later, and it was not till 1329 that +a Papal bull was issued, enumerating seventeen heretical and eleven +objectionable doctrines in his writings. + +This bull is interesting as showing what were the points in +Eckhart's teaching which in the fourteenth century were considered +dangerous. They also indicate very accurately what are the real +errors into which speculative mysticism is liable to fall, and how +thinkers of this school may most plausibly be misrepresented by +those who differ from them. After expressing his sorrow that "a +certain Teuton named Ekardus, doctor, ut fertur, sacrae paginae, has +wished to know more than he should," and has sown tares and thistles +and other weeds in the field of the Church, the Pope specifies the +following erroneous statements as appearing in Eckhart's +writings[5]:--1. "God created the world as soon as God was. 2. In +every work, bad as well as good, the glory of God is equally +manifested. 3. A man who prays for any particular thing prays for an +evil and prays ill, for he prays for the negation of good and the +negation of God, and that God may be denied to him.[6] 4. God is +honoured in those who have renounced everything, even holiness and +the kingdom of heaven. 5. We are transformed totally into God, even +as in the Sacrament the bread is converted into the Body of Christ. +Unum, non simile. 6. Whatever God the Father gave to His +only-begotten Son in His human nature, He has given it all to me. 7. +Whatever the Holy Scripture says about Christ is verified in every +good and godlike man. 8. External action is not, properly speaking, +good nor divine; God, properly speaking, only works in us internal +actions. 9. God is one, in every way and according to every reason, +so that it is not possible to find any plurality in Him, either in +the intellect or outside it; for he who sees two, or sees any +distinction, does not see God; for God is one, outside number and +above number, for one cannot be put with anything else, but follows +it; therefore in God Himself no distinction can be or be understood. +10. All the creatures are absolutely nothing: I say not that they +are small or something, but that they are absolutely nothing." All +these statements are declared to have been found in his writings. It +is also "objected against the said Ekardus" that he taught the +following two articles in these words:--1. "There is something in +the soul, which is uncreated and uncreatable: if the whole soul were +such, it would be uncreated and uncreatable: and this is the +intelligence.[7] 2. God is not good or better or best: I speak ill +when I call God good; it is as if I called white black."[8] The bull +declares all the propositions above quoted to be heretical, with the +exception of the three which I have numbered 8-10, and these "have +an ill sound" and are "very rash," even if they might be so +supplemented and explained as to bear an orthodox sense. + +This condemnation led to a long neglect of Eckhart's writings. He +was almost forgotten till Franz Pfeiffer in 1857 collected and +edited his scattered treatises and endeavoured to distinguish those +which were genuine from those which were spurious. Since Pfeiffer's +edition fresh discoveries have been made, notably in 1880, when +Denifle found at Erfurt several important fragments in Latin, which +in his opinion show a closer dependence on the scholastic theology, +and particularly on St Thomas Aquinas, than Protestant scholars, +such as Preger, had been willing to allow. But the attempt to prove +Eckhart a mere scholastic is a failure; the audacities of his German +discourses cannot be explained as an accommodation to the tastes of +a peculiar audience. For good or evil Eckhart is an original and +independent thinker, whose theology is confined by no trammels of +authority. + +Sect. 3. ECKHART'S RELIGIOUS PHILOSOPHY + +The Godhead, according to Eckhart, is the universal and eternal +Unity comprehending and transcending all diversity. "The Divine +nature is Rest," he says in one of the German discourses; and in the +Latin fragments we find: "God rests in Himself, and makes all things +rest in Him." The three Persons of the Trinity, however, are not +mere modes or accidents,[9] but represent a real distinction within +the Godhead. God is unchangeable, and at the same time an +"everlasting process." The creatures are "absolutely nothing"; but +at the same time "God without them would not be God," for God is +love, and must objectify Himself; He is goodness, and must impart +Himself. As the picture in the mind of the painter, as the poem in +the mind of the poet, so was all creation in the mind of God from +all eternity, in uncreated simplicity. The ideal world was not +created in time; "the Father spake Himself and all the creatures in +His Son"; "they exist in the eternal Now"[10]--"a +becoming without a becoming, change without change." "The Word of +God the Father is the substance of all that exists, the life of all +that lives, the principle and cause of life." Of creation he says: +"We must not falsely imagine that God stood waiting for something to +happen, that He might create the world. For so soon as He was God, +so soon as He begat His coeternal and coequal Son, He created the +world." So Spinoza says: "God has always been before the creatures, +without even existing before them. He precedes them not by an +interval of time, but by a fixed eternity." This is not the same as +saying that the world of sense had no beginning; it is possible that +Eckhart did not mean to go further than the orthodox scholastic +mystic, Albertus Magnus, who says: "God created things from +eternity, but the things were not created from eternity." St +Augustine (Conf. xi. 30) bids objectors to "understand that there +can be no time without creatures, and cease to talk nonsense." +Eckhart also tries to distinguish between the "interior" and the +"exterior" action of God. God, he says, is in all things, not as +Nature, not as Person, but as Being. He is everywhere, undivided; +yet the creatures participate in Him according to their measure.[11] +The three Persons of the Trinity have impressed their image upon the +creatures, yet it is only their "nothingness" that keeps them +separate creatures. Most of this comes from the Neoplatonists, and +much of it through the pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite, a +Platonising Christian of the fifth century, whose writings were +believed in the Middle Ages to proceed from St Paul's Athenian +convert. It would, however, be easy to find parallels in St +Augustine's writings to most of the phases quoted in this paragraph. +The practical consequences will be considered presently. + +The creatures are a way from God; they are also a way to Him. "In +Christ," he says, "all the creatures are one man, and that man is +God." Grace, which is a real self-unfolding of God in the soul, can +make us "what God is by Nature"--one of Eckhart's audacious phrases, +which are not really so unorthodox as they sound. The following +prayer, which appears in one of his discourses, may perhaps be +defended as asking no more than our Lord prayed for (John xvii.) for +His disciples, but it lays him open to the charge, which the Pope's +bull did not fail to urge against him, that he made the servant +equal to his Lord. "Grant that I, by Thy grace, may be united to Thy +Nature, as Thy Son is eternally one in Thy Nature, and that grace +may become my nature." + +The ethical aim is to be rid of "creatureliness," and so to be +united to God. In Eckhart's system, as in that of Plotinus, +speculation is never divorced from ethics. On our side the process +is a negative one. All our knowledge must be reduced to +not-knowledge; our reason and will, as well as our lower faculties, +must transcend themselves, must die to live. We must detach +ourselves absolutely "even from God," he says. This state of +spiritual nudity he calls "poverty." Then, when our house is empty +of all else, God can dwell there: "He begets His Son in us." This +last phrase has always been a favourite with the mystics. St Paul +uses very similar language, and the Epistle to Diognetus, written in +the second century, speaks of Christ as, "being ever born anew in +the hearts of the saints." Very characteristic, too, is the doctrine +that complete detachment from the creatures is the way to union with +God. Jacob Bšhme has arrived independently at the same conclusion as +Eckhart. "The scholar said to his master: How may I come to the +supersensual life, that I may see God and hear Him speak? The master +said: When thou canst throw thyself but for a moment into that place +where no creature dwelleth, then thou hearest what God speaketh. The +scholar asked: Is that near or far off? The master replied: It is in +thee, and if thou canst for a while cease from all thy thinking and +willing, thou shalt hear unspeakable words of God. The scholar said: +How can I hear, when I stand still from thinking and willing? The +master answered: When thou standest still from the thinking and +willing of self, the eternal hearing, seeing, and speaking will be +revealed to thee, and so God heareth and seeth through thee." + +In St Thomas Aquinas it is "the will enlightened by reason" which +unites us to God. But there are two sorts of reason. The passive +reason is the faculty which rises through discursive thinking to +knowledge. The active reason is a much higher faculty, which exists +by participation in the divine mind, "as the air is light by +participation in the sunshine." When this active reason is regarded +as the standard of moral action, it is called by Aquinas +synteresis.[12] Eckhart was at first content with this teaching of +St Thomas, whom he always cites with great reverence; but the whole +tendency of his thinking was to leave the unprofitable +classification of faculties in which the Victorine School almost +revelled, and to concentrate his attention on the union of the soul +with God. And therefore in his more developed teaching,[13] the +"spark" which is the point of contact between the soul and its Maker +is something higher than the faculties, being "uncreated." He seems +to waver about identifying the "spark" with the "active reason," but +inclines on the whole to regard it as something even higher still. +"There is something in the soul," he says, "which is so akin to God +that it is one with Him and not merely united with Him." And again: +"There is a force in the soul; and not only a force, but something +more, a being; and not only a being, but something more; it is so +pure and high and noble in itself that no creature can come there, +and God alone can dwelt there. Yea, verily, and even God cannot come +there with a form; He can only come with His simple divine nature." +And in the startling passage often quoted against him, a passage +which illustrates admirably his affinity to one side of Hegelianism, +we read: "The eye with which I see God is the same eye with which He +sees me. Mine eye and God's eye are one eye and one sight and one +knowledge and one love." + +I do not defend these passages as orthodox; but before exclaiming +"rank Pantheism!" we ought to recollect that for Eckhart the being +of God is quite different from His personality. Eckhart never taught +that the Persons of the Holy Trinity become, after the mystical +Union, the "Form" of the human soul. It is the impersonal light of +the divine nature which transforms our nature; human personality is +neither lost nor converted into divine personality. Moreover, the +divine spark at the centre of the soul is not the soul nor the +personality. "The soul," he says in one place, using a figure which +recurs in the "Theologia Germanica," "has two faces. One is turned +towards this world and towards the body, the other towards God." The +complete dominion of the "spark" over the soul is an unrealised +ideal.[14] + +The truth which he values is that, as Mr Upton[15] has well +expressed it, "there is a certain self-revelation of the eternal and +infinite One to the finite soul, and therefore an indestructible +basis for religious ideas and beliefs as distinguished from what is +called scientific knowledge. . . . This immanent universal principle +does not pertain to, and is not the property of any individual mind, +but belongs to that uncreated and eternal nature of God which lies +deeper than all those differences which separate individual minds +from each other, and is indeed that incarnation of the Eternal, who +though He is present in every finite thing, is still not broken up +into individualities, but remains one and the same eternal +substance, one and the same unifying principle, immanently and +indivisibly present in every one of the countless plurality of +finite individuals." It might further be urged that neither God nor +man can be understood in independence of each other. A recent writer +on ethics,[16] not too well disposed towards Christianity, is, I +think, right in saying: "To the popular mind, which assumes God and +man to be two different realities, each given in independence of the +other, . . . the identification of man's love of God with God's love +of Himself has always been a paradox and a stumbling-block. But it +is not too much to say that until it has been seen to be no paradox, +but a simple and fundamental truth, the masterpieces of the world's +religious literature must remain a sealed book to us." + +Eckhart certainly believed himself to have escaped the pitfall of +Pantheism; but he often expressed himself in such an unguarded way +that the charge may be brought against him with some show of reason. + +Love, Eckhart teaches, is the principle of all virtues; it is God +Himself. Next to it in dignity comes humility. The beauty of the +soul, he says in the true Platonic vein, is to be well ordered, with +the higher faculties above the lower, each in its proper place. The +will should be supreme over the understanding, the understanding +over the senses. Whatever we will earnestly, that we have, and no +one can hinder us from attaining that detachment from the creatures +in which our blessedness consists. + +Evil, from the highest standpoint, is only a means for realising the +eternal aim of God in creation; all will ultimately be overruled for +good. Nevertheless, we can frustrate the good will of God towards +us, and it is this, and not the thought of any insult against +Himself, that makes God grieve for our sins. It would not be worth +while to give any more quotations on this subject, for Eckhart is +not more successful than other philosophers in propounding a +consistent and intelligible theory of the place of evil in the +universe. + +Eckhart is well aware of the two chief pitfalls into which the +mystic is liable to fall--dreamy inactivity and Antinomianism. The +sects of the Free Spirit seem to have afforded a good object-lesson +in both these errors, as some of the Gnostic sects did in the second +century. Eckhart's teaching here is sound and good. Freedom from +law, he says, belongs only to the "spark," not to the faculties of +the soul, and no man can live always on the highest plane. +Contemplation is, in a sense, a means to activity; works of charity +are its proper fruit. "If a man were in an ecstasy like that of St +Paul, when he was caught up into the third heaven, and knew of a +poor man who needed his help, he ought to leave his ecstasy and help +the needy." Suso[17] tells us how God punished him for disregarding +this duty. True contemplation considers Reality (or Being) in its +manifestations as well as in its origin. If this is remembered, +there need be no conflict between social morality and the inner +life. Eckhart recognises[18] that it is a harder and a nobler task +to preserve detachment in a crowd than in a cell; the little daily +sacrifices of family life are often a greater trial than +self-imposed mortifications. "We need not destroy any little good in +ourselves for the sake of a better, but we should strive to grasp +every truth in its highest meaning, for no one good contradicts +another." "Love God, and do as you like, say the Free Spirits. Yes; +but as long as you like anything contrary to God's will, you do not +love Him." + +There is much more of the same kind in Eckhart's sermons--as good +and sensible doctrine as one could find anywhere. But what was the +practical effect of his teaching as a whole? It is generally the +case that the really weak points of any religious movement are +exposed with a cruel logicality most exasperating to the leaders by +the second generation of its adherents. The dangerous side of the +Eckhartian mysticism is painfully exhibited in the life of his +spiritual daughter, "Schwester Katrei," the saint of the later +Beguines. Katrei is a rather shadowy person; but for our present +purpose it does not much matter whether the story of her life has +been embroidered or not. Her memory was revered for such sayings and +doings as these which follow. On one occasion she exclaimed: +"Congratulate me; I have become God!" and on another she declared +that "not even the desire of heaven should tempt a good man towards +activity." It was her ambition to forget who were her parents, to be +indifferent whether she received absolution and partook of the Holy +Communion or not; and she finally realised her ambition by falling +into a cataleptic state in which she was supposed to be dead, and +was carried out for burial. Her confessor, perceiving that she was +not really dead, awoke her: "Art thou satisfied?" "I am satisfied at +last," said Katrei: she was now "dead all through," as she wished to +be. + +Are we to conclude that the logical outcome of mysticism is this +strange reproduction, in Teutonic Europe, of Indian Yogism? Many who +have studied the subject have satisfied themselves that Schwester +Katrei is the truly consistent mystic. They have come to the +conclusion that the real attraction of mysticism is a pining for +deliverance from this fretful, anxious, exacting, individual life, +and a yearning for absorption into the great Abyss where all +distinctions are merged in the Infinite. According to this view, +mysticism in its purest form should be studied in the ancient +religious literature of India, which teaches us how all this world +of colour and diversity, of sharp outlines and conflicting forces, +may be lost and swallowed up in the "white radiance," or black +darkness (it does not really matter which we call it) of an empty +Infinite. + +The present writer is convinced that this is not the truth about +mysticism. Eckhart may have encouraged Schwester Katrei in her +attempt to substitute the living death of the blank trance for the +dying life of Christian charity; but none the less she caricatured +and stultified his teaching. And I think it is possible to lay our +finger on the place where she and so many others went wrong. The +aspiration of mysticism is to find the unity which underlies all +diversity, or, in religious language, to see God face to face. From +the Many to the One is always the path of the mystic. Plotinus, the +father of all mystical philosophy in Europe (unless, as he himself +would have wished, we give that honour to Plato), mapped out the +upward road as follows:--At the bottom of the hill is the sphere of +the "merely many"--of material objects viewed in disconnection, +dull, and spiritless. This is a world which has no real existence; +it may best be called "not-being" ("ein lauteres Nichts," as Eckhart +says), and as the indeterminate, it can only be apprehended by a +corresponding indeterminateness in the soul. The soul, however, +always adds some form and determination to the abstract formlessness +of the "merely many." Next, we rise to, or project for ourselves, +the world of "the one and the many." This is the sphere in which our +consciousness normally moves. We are conscious of an overruling +Mind, but the creatures still seem external to and partially +independent of it. Such is the temporal order as we know it. Above +this is the intelligible world, the eternal order, "the one-many," +das ewige Nu, the world in which God's will is done perfectly and +all reflects the divine mind. Highest of all is "the One," the, +Absolute, the Godhead, of whom nothing can be predicated, because He +is above all distinctions. This Neoplatonic Absolute is the Godhead +of whom Eckhart says: "God never looked upon deed," and of whom +Angelus Silesius sings: + + "Und sieh, er ist nicht Wille, + Er ist ein' ewige Stille." + +Plotinus taught that the One, being superessential, can only be +apprehended in ecstasy, when thought, which still distinguishes +itself from its object, is transcended, and knower and known become +one. As Tennyson's Ancient Sage says: + + "If thou would'st hear the Nameless, and descend + Into the Temple-cave of thine own self, + There, brooding by the central altar, thou + May'st haply learn the Nameless hath a voice, + By which thou wilt abide, if thou be wise; + For knowledge is the swallow on the lake, + That sees and stirs the surface-shadow there + But never yet hath dipt into the Abysm." + +In the same way Eckhart taught that no creature can apprehend the +Godhead, and, therefore, that the spark in the centre of the soul +(this doctrine, too, is found in Plotinus) must be verily divine. +The logic of the theory is inexorable. If only like can know like, +we cannot know God except by a faculty which is itself divine. The +real question is whether God, as an object of knowledge and worship +for finite beings, is the absolute Godhead, who transcends all +distinctions. The mediaeval mystics held that this "flight of the +alone to the alone," as Plotinus calls it, is possible to men, and +that in it consists our highest blessedness. They were attracted +towards this view by several influences. First, there was the +tradition of Dionysius, to whom (e.g.) the author of the "Theologia +Germanica" appeals as an authority for the possibility of "beholding +the hidden things of God by utter abandonment of thyself, and of +entering into union with Him who is above all existence, and all +knowledge." Secondly, there was what a modern writer has called "the +attraction of the Abyss," the longing which some persons feel very +strongly to merge their individuality in a larger and better whole, +to get rid not only of selfishness but of self for ever. "Leave +nothing of myself in me," is Crashaw's prayer in his wonderful poem +on St Teresa. Thirdly, we may mention the awe and respect long paid +to ecstatic trances, the pathological nature of which was not +understood. The blank trance was a real experience; and as it could +be induced by a long course of ascetical exercises and fervid +devotions, it was naturally regarded as the crowning reward of +sanctity on earth. Nor would it be at all safe to reject the +evidence, which is very copious,[19] that the "dreamy state" may +issue in permanent spiritual gain. The methodical cultivation of it, +which is at the bottom of most of the strange austerities of the +ascetics, was not only (though it was partly) practised in the hope +of enjoying those spiritual raptures which are described as being +far more intense than any pleasures of sense[20]: it was the hope of +stirring to its depths the subconscious mind and permeating the +whole with the hidden energy of the divine Spirit that led to the +desire for visions and trances. Lastly, I think we must give a place +to the intellectual attraction of an uncompromising monistic theory +of the universe. Spiritualistic monism, when it is consistent with +itself, will always lean to semi-pantheistic mysticism rather than +to such a compromise with pluralism as Lotze and his numerous +followers in this country imagine to be possible. + +But it is possible to go a long way with the mystics and yet to +maintain that under no conditions whatever can a finite being escape +from the limitations of his finitude and see God or the world or +himself "with the same eye with which God sees" all things. The old +Hebrew belief, that to see the face of God is death, expresses the +truth under a mythical form. That the human mind, while still "in +the body pent," may obtain glimpses of the eternal order, and enjoy +foretastes of the bliss of heaven, is a belief which I, at least, +see no reason to reject. It involves no rash presumption, and is not +contrary to what may be readily believed about the state of immortal +spirits passing through a mortal life. But the explanation of the +blank trance as a temporary transit into the Absolute must be set +down as a pure delusion. It involves a conception of the divine +"Rest" which in his best moments Eckhart himself repudiates. "The +Rest of the Godhead," he says, "is not in that He is the source of +being, but in that He is the consummation of all being." This +profound saying expresses the truth, which he seems often to forget, +that the world-process must have a real value in God's sight--that +it is not a mere polarisation of the white radiance of eternity +broken up by the imperfection of our vision. Whatever theories we +may hold about Absolute Being, or an Absolute that is above Being, +we must make room for the Will, and for Time, which is the "form" of +the will, and for the creatures who inhabit time and space, as +having for us the value of reality. Nor shall we, if we are to +escape scepticism, be willing to admit that these appearances have +no sure relation to ultimate reality. We must not try to uncreate +the world in order to find God. We were created out of nothing, but +we cannot return to nothing, to find our Creator there. The still, +small voice is best listened for amid the discordant harmony of life +and death. + +The search for God is no exception to the mysterious law of human +nature, that we cannot get anything worth having--neither holiness +nor happiness nor wisdom--by trying for it directly. It must be +given us through something else. The recluse who lives like +Parnell's "Hermit": + +"Prayer all his business, all his pleasure praise," + +is not only a poor sort of saint, but he will offer a poor sort of +prayers and praises. He will miss real holiness for the same reason +that makes the pleasure-seeker miss real happiness. We must lose +ourselves in some worthy interest in order to find again both a +better self and an object higher than that which we sought. This the +German mystics in a sense knew well. There is a noble sentence of +Suso to the effect that "he who realises the inward in the outward, +to him the inward becomes more inward than to him who only +recognises the inward in the inward." Moreover, the recognition that +"God manifests Himself and worketh more in one creature than +another" ("Theologia Germanica"), involves a denial of the +nihilistic view that all the creatures are "ein lauteres +Nichts."[21] It would be easy to find such passages in all the +fourteenth-century mystics, but it cannot be denied that on the +whole their religion is too self-centred. There are not many maxims +so fundamentally wrong-headed and un-Christian as Suso's advice to +"live as if you were the only person in the world."[22] The life of +the cloistered saint may be abundantly justified--for the spiritual +activity of some of them has been of far greater service to mankind +than the fussy benevolence of many "practical" busybodies--but the +idea of social service, whether in the school of Martha or of Mary, +ought surely never to be absent. The image of Christ as the Lover of +the individual soul rather than as the Bridegroom of the Church was +too dear to these lonely men and women. Unconsciously, they looked +to their personal devotions to compensate them for the human loves +which they had forsworn. The raptures of Divine Love, which they +regarded as signal favours bestowed upon them, were not very +wholesome in themselves, and diverted their thoughts from the needs +of their fellow-men. They also led to most painful reactions, in +which the poor contemplative believed himself abandoned by God and +became a pray to terrible depression and melancholy. These fits of +wretchedness came indeed to be recognised as God's punishment for +selfishness in devotion and for too great desire for the sweetness +of communing with God, and so arose the doctrine of "disinterested +love," which was more and more emphasised in the later mysticism, +especially by the French Quietists. + +I have spoken quite candidly of the defects of Eckhart's mystical +Christianity. As a religious philosophy it does not keep clear of +the fallacy that an ascent though the unreal can lead to reality. +"To suppose, as the mystic does, that the finite search has of +itself no Being at all, is illusory, is Maya, is itself nothing, +this is also to deprive the Absolute of even its poor value as a +contrasting goal. For a goal that is a goal of no real process has +as little value as it has content."[23] But, as Prof. Royce says, +mysticism furnishes us with the means of correcting itself. It +supplies an obvious reductio ad absurdum of the theory with which it +set out, that "Immediacy is the one test of reality," and is itself +forced to give the world of diversity a real value as manifesting in +different degrees the nature of God. Those who are acquainted with +the sacred books of the East will recognise that here is the +decisive departure from real Pantheism. And it may be fairly claimed +for the German mystics that though their speculative teaching +sometimes seems to echo too ominously the apathetic detachment of +the Indian sage, their lives and example, and their practical +exhortations, preached a truer and a larger philosophy. Eckhart, as +we have seen, was a busy preacher as well as a keen student, and +some of the younger members of his school were even more occupied in +pastoral work. If the tree is to be judged by its fruits, mysticism +can give a very good account of itself to the Marthas as well as the +Marys of this world. + +Sect. 4. THE GERMAN MYSTICS AS GUIDES TO HOLINESS + +THIS little volume is a contribution to a "Library of Devotion," and +in the body of the work the reader will be seldom troubled by any +abstruse philosophising. I have thought it necessary to give, in +this Introduction, a short account of Eckhart's system, but the +extracts which follow are taken mainly from his successors, in whom +the speculative tendency is weaker and less original, while the +religious element is stronger and more attractive. It is, after all, +as guides to holiness that these mystics are chiefly important to +us. This side of their life's work can never be out of date, for the +deeper currents of human nature change but little; the language of +the heart is readily understood everywhere and at all times. The +differences between Catholic and Protestant are hardly felt in the +keen air of these high summits. It was Luther himself who discovered +the "Theologia Germanica" and said of it that, "next to the Bible +and St Augustine, no book hath ever come into my hands whence I have +learnt or would wish to learn more of what God and Christ and man +and all things are. I thank God that I have heard and found my God +in the German tongue, as I have not yet found Him in Latin, Greek, +or Hebrew." The theology of these mystics takes us straight back to +the Johannine doctrine of Christ as the all-pervading Word of God, +by whom all things were made and in whom all things hold together. +He is not far from any one of us if we will but seek Him where He is +to be found--in the innermost sanctuary of our personal life. In +personal religion this means that no part of revelation is to be +regarded as past, isolated, or external. "We should mark and know of +a very truth," says the author of the "Theologia Germanica," "that +all manner of virtue and goodness, and even the eternal Good which +is God Himself, can never make a man virtuous, good, or happy, so +long as it is outside the soul." In the same spirit Jacob Bšhme, 250 +years later, says: "If the sacrifice of Christ is to avail for me, +it must be wrought in me." Or, as his English admirer, William Law, +puts it: "Christ given for us is neither more nor less than Christ +given into us. He is in no other sense our full, perfect, and +sufficient Atonement than as His nature and spirit are born and +formed in us." The whole process of redemption must in a sense be +reenacted in the inner life of every Christian. And as Christ +emptied Himself for our sakes, so must we empty ourselves of all +self-seeking. "When the creature claimeth for its own anything good, +such as life, knowledge, or power, and in short whatever we commonly +call good, as if it were that, or possessed that--it goeth astray." +Sin is nothing else but self-assertion, self-will. "Be assured," +says the "Theologia Germanica," "that he who helpeth a man to his +own will, helpeth him to the worst that he can." He, therefore, who +is "simply and wholly bereft of self" is delivered from sin, and God +alone reigns in his inmost soul. Concerning the highest part or +faculty of the soul, the author of this little treatise follows +Eckhart, but cautiously. "The True Light," he says, "is that eternal +Light which is God; or else it is a created light, but yet Divine, +which is called grace." In either case, "where God dwells in a godly +man, in such a man somewhat appertaineth to God which is His own, +and belongs to Him only and not to the creature." This doctrine of +divine immanence, for which there is ample warrant in the New +Testament, is the real kernel of German mysticism. It is a doctrine +which, when rightly used, may make this world a foretaste of heaven, +but alas! the "False Light" is always trying to counterfeit the +true. In the imitation of the suffering life of Christ lies the only +means of escaping the deceptions of the Evil One. "The False Light +dreameth itself to be God, and sinless"; but "none is without sin; +if any is without consciousness of sin, he must be either Christ or +the Evil Spirit." + +Very characteristic is the teaching of all these writers about +rewards and punishments. Without in any way impugning the Church +doctrine of future retribution, they yet agree with Benjamin +Whichcote, the Cambridge Platonist, that "heaven is first a temper, +then a place"; while of hell there is much to recall the noble +sentence of Juliana of Norwich, the fourteenth-century visionary, +"to me was showed no harder hell than sin." "Nothing burneth in hell +but self-will," is a saying in the "Theologia Germanica."[24] They +insist that the difference between heaven and hell is not that one +is a place of enjoyment, the other of torment; it is that in the one +we are with Christ, in the other without Him. "The Christlike life +is not chosen," to quote the "Theologia Germanica" once more, "in +order to serve any end, or to get anything by it, but for love of +its nobleness, and because God loveth and esteemeth it so highly. He +who doth not take it up for love, hath none of it at all; he may +dream indeed that he hath put it on, but he is deceived. Christ did +not lead such a life as this for the sake of reward, but out of +love, and love maketh such a life light, and taketh away all its +hardships, so that it becometh sweet and is gladly endured." The +truly religious man is always more concerned about what God will do +in him than what He will do to him; in his intense desire for the +purification of his motives he almost wishes that heaven and hell +were blotted out, that he might serve God for Himself alone. + +Sect. 5. WRITERS OF THE SCHOOL OF ECKHART--TAULER + +Such are the main characteristics of the religious teachings which +we find in the German mystics. Among the successors of Eckhart, from +whose writings the following extracts are taken, the most notable +names are those of Tauler, Suso, and Ruysbroek. From Tauler I have +taken very little, because a volume of selections from his sermons +has already appeared in this series.[25] Accordingly, it will only +be necessary to mention a very few facts about his life. + +John Tauler was born at Strassburg about 1300, and studied at the +Dominican convents of Strassburg and Cologne. At both places he +doubtless heard the sermons of Eckhart. In 1329 the great interdict +began at Strassburg, and was stoutly resisted by many of the clergy. +It is a disputed point whether Tauler himself obeyed the Papal +decree or not. His uneventful life, which was devoted to study, +preaching, and pastoral work, came to an end in 1361. Like Eckhart, +he had a favourite "spiritual daughter," Margaret Ebner, who won a +great reputation as a visionary. + +Sect. 6. SUSO + +Henry Suso was born in 1295 and died in 1365. His autobiography was +published not long before his death. He is the poet of the band. The +romance of saintship is depicted by him with a strange vividness +which alternately attracts and repels, or even disgusts, the modern +reader. The whole-hearted devotion of the "Servitor" to the "Divine +Wisdom," the tender beauty of the visions and conversations, and the +occasional na•veté of the narrative, which shows that the saint +remained very human throughout, make Suso's books delightful +reading; but the accounts of the horrible macerations to which he +subjected himself for many years shock our moral sense almost as +much as our sensibilities; we do not now believe that God takes +pleasure in sufferings inflicted in His honour. Moreover, the erotic +symbolism of the visions is occasionally unpleasant: we are no +longer in the company of such sane and healthy people as Eckhart and +Tauler. The half-sensuous pleasure of ecstasy was evidently a +temptation to Suso, and the violent alternations of rapture and +misery which he experienced suggest a neurotic and ill-balanced +temperament.[26] + +On this subject--the pathological side of mysticism--a few remarks +will not be out of place, for there has been much discussion of it +lately. A great deal of nonsense has been written on the connexion +between religion and neuroticism. To quote Professor James' vigorous +protest, "medical materialism finishes up St Paul by calling his +vision on the road to Damascus a discharging lesion of the occipital +cortex, he being an epileptic. It snuffs out St Teresa as an +hysteric, St Francis of Assisi as an hereditary degenerate. George +Fox's discontent with the shams of his age, and his pining for +spiritual veracity, it treats as a symptom of a disordered colon. +Carlyle's organ-tones of misery it accounts for by a gastro-duodenal +catarrh. All such mental over-tensions, it says, are, when you come +to the bottom of the matter, mere affairs of diathesis +(auto-intoxications most probably), due to the perverted action of +various glands which physiology will yet discover."[27] Now, even if +it were true that most religious geniuses, like most other geniuses, +have been "psychopaths" of one kind or another, this fact in no way +disposes of the value of their intuitions and experiences. Nearly +all the great benefactors of humanity have been persons of +one-sided, and therefore ill-balanced, characters. Even Maudsley +admits that "Nature may find an incomplete mind a more suitable +instrument for a particular purpose. It is the work that is done, +and the quality in the worker by which it is done, that is alone of +moment; and it may be no great matter from a cosmical standpoint, if +in other qualities of character he (the genius) was singularly +defective."[28] Except in the character of our Lord Himself, there +are visible imperfections in the record of every great saint; but +that is no reason for allowing such traces of human infirmity to +discredit what is pure and good in their work. More particularly, it +would be a great pity to let our minds dwell on the favourite +materialistic theory that saintliness, especially as cultivated and +venerated by Catholicism, has its basis in "perverted sexuality." +There is enough plausibility in the theory to make it mischievous. +The allegorical interpretation of the Book of Canticles was in truth +the source of, or at least the model for, a vast amount of +unwholesome and repulsive pietism. Not a word need be said for such +a paltry narrative of endearments and sickly compliments as the +"Revelations of the Nun Gertrude," in the thirteenth century. Nor +are we concerned to deny that the artificially induced ecstasy, +which is desired on account of the intense pleasure which is said to +accompany it, nearly always contains elements the recognition of +which would shock and distress the contemplatives themselves.[29] +There are, however, other elements, of a less insidious kind, which +make the ecstatic trance seem desirable. These are, according to +Professor Leuba, the calming of the restless intellect by the +concentration of the mind on one object; the longing for a support +and comfort more perfect than man can give; and, thirdly, the +consecration and strengthening of the will, which is often a +permanent effect of the trance. These are legitimate objects of +desire, and in many of the mystics they are much more prominent than +any tendencies which might be considered morbid. As regards the +larger question, about the alleged pathological character of all +distinctively religious exaltation, I believe that no greater +mistake could be made than to suppose that the religious life +flourishes best in unnatural circumstances. Religion, from a +biological standpoint, I take to be the expression of the racial +will to live; its function (from this point of view) is the +preservation and development of humanity on the highest possible +level. If this is true, a simple, healthy, natural life must be the +most favourable for religious excellence--and this I believe to be +the case. Poor Suso certainly did not lead a healthy or natural +life. But in his case, though the suppressed natural instincts +obviously overflow into the religious consciousness and in part +determine the forms which his devotion assumes, we can never forget +that we are in the company of a poet and a saint who will lift us, +if we can follow him, into a very high region of the spiritual life, +an altitude which he has himself climbed with bleeding feet. + +The simple confidence which at the end of the dialogue he expresses +in the value of his work is, I think, amply justified. "Whoever will +read these writings of mine in a right spirit, can hardly fail to be +stirred to the depths of his soul, either to fervent love, or to new +light, or to hunger and thirst for God, or to hatred and loathing +for his sins, or to that spiritual aspiration by which the soul is +renewed in grace." + +Sect. 7. RUYSBROEK + +[Note: the Ruysbroek selection has not been reproduced in this +electronic edition. An electronic text of a larger collection of +Ruysbroek's works may be available.] + +Sect. 8. THEOLOGIA GERMANICA + +The "Theologia Germanica," an isolated treatise of no great length +by an unknown author, was written towards the end of the fourteenth +century by one of the Gottesfreunde, a widespread association of +pious souls in Germany. He is said to have been "a priest and warden +of the house of the Teutonic Order at Frankfort." His book is both +the latest and one of the most important productions of the German +mystical school founded by Eckhart. The author is a deeply religious +philosopher, as much interested in speculative mysticism as Eckhart +himself, but as thoroughly penetrated with devout feeling as Thomas +ˆ Kempis. The treatise should be read by all, as one of the very +best devotional works in any language. My only reason for not +translating it in full here is that a good English translation +already exists,[30] so that it seemed unnecessary to offer a new one +to the public. I have therefore only translated a few characteristic +passages, which are very far from exhausting its beauties, and a few +of the more striking aphorisms, which indicate the main points in +the religious philosophy of the writer. + +Sect. 9. MODERN MYSTICISM + +The revival of interest in the old mystical writers is not +surprising when we consider the whole trend of modern thought. Among +recent philosophers--though Lotze, perhaps the greatest name among +them, is unsympathetic, in consequence of his over-rigid theory of +personality--the great psychologist Fechner, whose religious +philosophy is not so well known in this country as it deserves to +be, has with some justice been called a mystic. And our own greatest +living metaphysician, Mr F.H. Bradley, has expounded the dialectic +of speculative mysticism with unequalled power, though with a bias +against Christianity. Another significant fact is the great +popularity, all over Europe, of Maeterlinck's mystical works, "Le +Trésor des Humbles," "La Sagesse et la Destinée," and "Le +Temple Enseveli." + +The growing science of psychology has begun to turn its attention +seriously to the study of the religious faculty. Several able men +have set themselves to collect material which may form the basis of +an inductive science. Personal experiences, communicated by many +persons of both sexes and of various ages, occupations, and levels +of culture, have been brought together and tabulated. It is claimed +that important facts have already been established, particularly in +connexion with the phenomena of conversion, by this method. The +results have certainly been more than enough to justify confidence +in the soundness of the method, and hope that the new science may +have a great future before it. Towards mysticism, recent writers on +the psychology of religion have been less favourable than the pure +metaphysicians. While the latter have shown a tendency towards +Pantheism and Determinism, which makes them sympathise with the +general trend of speculative mysticism, psychology seems just at +present to lean towards a pluralistic metaphysic and a belief in +free-will or even in chance. This attitude is especially noticeable +in the now famous Gifford Lectures of Professor William James[31] +and in the recent volume of essays written at Oxford.[32] But even +if the rising tide of neo-Kantianism should cause the speculative +mystics to be regarded with disfavour, nothing can prevent the +religion of the twentieth century from being mystical in type. The +strongest wish of a vast number of earnest men and women to-day is +for a basis of religious belief which shall rest, not upon tradition +or external authority or historical evidence, but upon the +ascertainable facts of human experience. The craving for immediacy, +which we have seen to be characteristic of all mysticism, now takes +the form of a desire to establish the validity of the +God-consciousness as a normal part of the healthy inner life. We may +perhaps venture to predict that the Christian biologist of the +future will turn the Pauline Christology into his own dialect +somewhat after the following fashion:--"The function of religion in +the human race is closely analogous to, if not identical with, that +of instinct in the lower animals. Religion is the racial will to +live; not, however, to live anyhow and at all costs, but to live as +human beings, conforming as far as possible to the highest type of +humanity. Religion, therefore, acts as a higher instinct, inhibiting +all self-destroying and race-destroying impulses in the interest of +a larger self than the individual life." To turn this statement into +theological form it is only necessary to claim that the "perfect +man" which the religious instinct is trying to form is "the measure +of the stature of the fulness of Christ," that that perfect humanity +was once realised in the historical Christ, and that the higher +instinct within us--ourselves, yet not ourselves--which makes for +life and righteousness, and is the source of all the good that we +can think, say, or do, may (in virtue of that historical +incarnation) be justly called the indwelling Christ. This is all +that the Christian mystic needs. + +Sect. 10. SPECIMENS OF MODERN MYSTICISM + +I conclude this introductory essay with a few extracts from recent +American books on the psychology of religion. It is interesting to +find some of the strangest experiences of the cloister reproduced +under the very different conditions of modern American life. The +quotations will serve to show how far Tauler and the "Theologia +Germanica" are from being out of date. + +"The thing which impressed me most" (says a correspondent of +Professor William James)[33] "was learning the fact that we must be +in absolutely constant relation or mental touch with that essence of +life which permeates all and which we call God. This is almost +unrecognisable unless we live into it ourselves actually--that is, +by a constant turning to the very innermost, deepest consciousness +of our real selves or of God in us, for illumination from within, +just as we turn to the sun for light, warmth, and invigoration +without. When you do this consciously, realising that to turn inward +to the light within you is to live in the presence of God or of your +Divine self, you soon discover the unreality of the objects to which +you have hitherto been turning and which have engrossed you +without." + +The next quotation comes from a small book by one of the "New +Thought" or "Mind Cure" school in America. The enormous sale of the +volume testifies to the popularity of the teaching which it +contains.[34] + +"Intuition is an inner spiritual sense through which man is opened +to the direct revelation and knowledge of God, the secret of nature +and life, and through which he is brought into conscious unity and +fellowship with God, and made to realise his own deific nature and +supremacy of being as the son of God. Spiritual supremacy and +illumination thus realised through the development and perfection of +intuition under divine inspiration gives the perfect inner vision +and direct insight into the character, properties, and purpose of +all things to which the attention and interest are directed. It is, +we repeat, a spiritual sense opening inwardly, as the physical +senses open outwardly; and because it has the capacity to perceive, +grasp, and know the truth at first hand, independent of all external +sources of information, we call it intuition. All inspired teaching +and spiritual revelations are based upon the recognition of this +spiritual faculty of the soul and its power to receive and +appropriate them. Conscious unity of man in spirit and purpose with +the Father, born out of his supreme desire and trust, opens his soul +through this inner sense to immediate aspiration and enlightenment +from the divine omniscience, and the co-operative energy of the +divine omnipotence, under which he becomes a seer and a master. On +this higher plane of realised spiritual life in the flesh the mind +acts with unfettered freedom and unbiassed vision, grasping truth at +first hand, independent of all external sources of information. +Approaching all beings and things from the divine side, they are +seen in the light of the divine omniscience.[35] God's purpose in +them, and so the truth concerning them, as it rests in the mind of +God, are thus revealed by direct illumination from the divine mind, +to which the soul is opened inwardly through this spiritual sense we +call intuition." + +The practice of meditation "without images," as the mediaeval +mystics called it, is specially recommended. "Many will receive +great help, and many will be entirely healed by a practice somewhat +after the following nature:--With a mind at peace, and with a heart +going out in love to all, go into the quiet of your own interior +self, holding the thought, I am one with the Infinite Spirit of +Life, the life of my life. I now open my body, in which disease has +gotten a foothold, I open it fully to the inflowing tide of this +infinite life, and it now, even now, is pouring in and coursing +through my body, and the healing process is going on." "If you would +find the highest, the fullest, and the richest life that not only +this world but that any world can know, then do away with the sense +of the separateness of your life from the life of God. Hold to the +thought of your oneness. In the degree that you do this, you will +find yourself realising it more and more, and as this life of +realisation is lived, you will find that no good thing will be +withheld, for all things are included in this."[36] + +This modern mysticism is very much entangled with theories about the +cure of bodily disease by suggestion; and it is fair to warn those +who are unacquainted with the books of this sect that they will find +much fantastic superstition mixed with a stimulating faith in the +inner light as the voice of God. + +But whatever may be the course of this particular movement there can +be no doubt that the Americans, like ourselves, are only at the +beginning of a great revival of mystical religion. The movement will +probably follow the same course as the mediaeval movement in +Germany, with which this little book is concerned. It will have its +philosophical supportees, who will press their speculation to the +verge of Pantheism, perhaps reviving the Logos-cosmology of the +Christian Alexandrians under the form of the pan-psychism of Lotze +and Fechner. It will have its evangelists like Tauler, who will +carry to our crowded town populations the glad tidings that the +kingdom of God is not here or there, but within the hearts of all +who will seek for it within them. It will assuredly attract some to +a life of solitary contemplation; while others, intellectually +weaker or less serious, will follow the various theosophical and +theurgical delusions which, from the days of Iamblichus downward, +have dogged the heels of mysticism. For the "False Light" against +which the "Theologia Germanica" warns us is as dangerous as ever; we +may even live to see some new "Brethren of the Free Spirit" turning +their liberty into a cloak of licentiousness. If so, the world will +soon whistle back the disciplinarian with his traditions of the +elders; prophesying will once more be suppressed and discredited, +and a new crystallising process will begin. But before that time +comes some changes may possibly take place in the external +proportions of Christian orthodoxy. The appearance of a vigorous +body of faith, standing firmly on its own feet, may even have the +effect of relegating to the sphere of pious opinion some tenets +which have hitherto "seemed to be pillars." + +For these periodical returns to the "fresh springs" of religion +never leave the tradition exactly where it was before. The German +movement of the fourteenth century made the Reformation inevitable, +and our own age may be inaugurating a change no less momentous, +which will restore in the twentieth century some of the features of +Apostolic Christianity. + + + + + + +LIGHT, LIFE AND LOVE + +ECKHART + + + + + +GOD + +GOD is nameless, for no man can either say or understand aught about +Him. If I say, God is good, it is not true; nay more; I am good, God +is not good. I may even say, I am better than God; for whatever is +good, may become better, and whatever may become better, may become +best. Now God is not good, for He cannot become better. And if He +cannot become better, He cannot become best, for these three things, +good, better, and best, are far from God, since He is above all. If +I also say, God is wise, it is not true; I am wiser than He. If I +also say, God is a Being, it is not true; He is transcendent Being +and superessential Nothingness. Concerning this St Augustine says: +the best thing that man can say about God is to be able to be silent +about Him, from the wisdom of his inner judgement. Therefore be +silent and prate not about God, for whenever thou dost prate about +God, thou liest, and committest sin. If thou wilt be without sin, +prate not about God. Thou canst understand nought about God, for He +is above all understanding. A master saith: If I had a God whom I +could understand, I would never hold Him to be God. (318)[37] + +God is not only a Father of all good things, as being their First +Cause and Creator, but He is also their Mother, since He remains +with the creatures which have from Him their being and existence, +and maintains them continually in their being. If God did not abide +with and in the creatures, they must necessarily have fallen back, +so soon as they were created, into the nothingness out of which they +were created. (610) + +REST ONLY IN GOD + +IF I had everything that I could desire, and my finger ached, I +should not have everything, for I should have a pain in my finger, +and so long as that remained, I should not enjoy full comfort. Bread +is comfortable for men, when they are hungry; but when they are +thirsty, they find no more comfort in bread than in a stone. So it +is with clothes, they are welcome to men, when they are cold; but +when they are too hot, clothes give them no comfort. And so it is +with all the creatures. The comfort which they promise is only on +the surface, like froth, and it always carries with it a want. But +God's comfort is clear and has nothing wanting: it is full and +complete, and God is constrained to give it thee, for He cannot +cease till He have given thee Himself. (300) + +It is only in God that are collected and united all the perfections, +which in the creatures are sundered and divided. (324) + +Yet all the fulness of the creatures can as little express God, as a +drop of water can express the sea. (173) + +GOD IS ALWAYS READY + +NO one ought to think that it is difficult to come to Him, though it +sounds difficult and is really difficult at the beginning, and in +separating oneself from and dying to all things. But when a man has +once entered upon it, no life is lighter or happier or more +desirable; for God is very zealous to be at all times with man, and +teaches him that He will bring him to Himself if man will but +follow. Man never desires anything so earnestly as God desires to +bring a man to Himself, that he may know Him. God is always ready, +but we are very unready; God is near to us, but we are far from Him; +God is within, but we are without; God is at home, but we are +strangers. The prophet saith: God guideth the redeemed through a +narrow way into the broad road, so that they come into the wide and +broad place; that is to say, into true freedom of the spirit, when +one has become a spirit with God. May God help us to follow this +course, that He may bring us to Himself. Amen. (223) + +GRACE + +THE masters say: That is young, which is near its beginning. +Intelligence is the youngest faculty in man: the first thing to +break out from the soul is intelligence, the next is will, the other +faculties follow. Now he saith: Young man, I say unto thee, arise. +The soul in itself is a simple work; what God works in the simple +light of the soul is more beautiful and more delightful than all the +other works which He works in all creatures. But foolish people take +evil for good and good for evil. But to him who rightly understands, +the one work which God works in the soul is better and nobler and +higher than all the world. Through that light comes grace. Grace +never comes in the intelligence or in the will. If it could come in +the intelligence or in the will, the intelligence and the will would +have to transcend themselves. On this a master says: There is +something secret about it; and thereby he means the spark of the +soul, which alone can apprehend God. The true union between God and +the soul takes place in the little spark, which is called the spirit +of the soul. Grace unites not to any work. It is an indwelling and a +living together of the soul in God. (255) + +Every gift of God makes the soul ready to receive a new gift, +greater than itself. (15) + +Yea, since God has never given any gift, in order that man might +rest in the possession of the gift, but gives every gift that He has +given in heaven and on earth, in order that He might be able to give +one gift, which is Himself, so with this gift of grace, and with all +His gifts He will make us ready for the one gift, which is Himself. +(569) + +No man is so boorish or stupid or awkward, that he cannot, by God's +grace, unite his will wholly and entirely with God's will. And +nothing more is necessary than that he should say with earnest +longing: O Lord, show me Thy dearest will, and strengthen me to do +it. And God does it, as sure as He lives, and gives him grace in +ever richer fulness, till he comes to perfection, as He gave to the +woman at Jacob's well. Look you, the most ignorant and the lowest of +you all can obtain this from God, before he leaves this church, yea, +before I finish this sermon, as sure as God lives and I am a man. +(187) + +O almighty and merciful Creator and good Lord, be merciful to me for +my poor sins, and help me that I may overcome all temptations and +shameful lusts, and may be able to avoid utterly, in thought and +deed, what Thou forbiddest, and give me grace to do and to hold all +that Thou hast commanded. Help me to believe, to hope, and to love, +and in every way to live as Thou willest, as much as Thou willest, +and what Thou willest. (415) + +THE WILL + +THEN is the will perfect, when it has gone out of itself, and is +formed in the will of God. The more this is so, the more perfect and +true is the will, and in such a will thou canst do all things. (553) + +SURRENDER OF THE WILL + +YOU should know, that that which God gives to those men who seek to +do His will with all their might, is the best. Of this thou mayest +be as sure, as thou art sure that God lives, that the very best must +necessarily be, and that in no other way could anything better +happen. Even if something else seems better, it would not be so good +for thee, for God wills this and not another way, and this way must +be the best for thee. Whether it be sickness or poverty or hunger or +thirst, or whatever it be, that God hangs over thee or does not hang +over thee--whatever God gives or gives not, that is all what is best +for thee; whether it be devotion or inwardness, or the lack of these +which grieves thee--only set thyself right in this, that thou +desirest the glory of God in all things, and then whatever He does +to thee, that is the best. + +Now thou mayest perchance say: How can I tell whether it is the will +of God or not? If it were not the will of God, it would not happen. +Thou couldst have neither sickness nor anything else unless God +willed it. But know that it is God's will that thou shouldst have so +much pleasure and satisfaction therein, that thou shouldst feel no +pain as pain; thou shouldst take it from God as the very best thing, +for it must of necessity be the very best thing for thee. Therefore +I may even wish for it and desire it, and nothing would become me +better than so to do. + +If there were a man whom I were particularly anxious to please, and +if I knew for certain that he liked me better in a grey cloak than +in any other, there is no doubt that however good another cloak +might be, I should be fonder of the grey than of all the rest. And +if there were anyone whom I would gladly please, I should do nothing +else in word or deed than what I knew that he liked. + +Ah, now consider how your love shows itself! If you loved God, of a +surety nothing would give you greater pleasure than what pleases Him +best, and that whereby His will may be most fully done. And, however +great thy pain or hardship may be, if thou hast not as great +pleasure in it as in comfort or fulness, it is wrong. + +We say every day in prayer to our Father, Thy will be done. And yet +when His will is done, we grumble at it, and find no pleasure in His +will. If our prayers were sincere, we should certainly think His +will, and what He does, to be the best, and that the very best had +happened to us. (134) + +Those who accept all that the Lord send, as the very best, remain +always in perfect peace, for in them God's will has become their +will. This is incomparably better than for our will to become God's +will. For when thy will becomes God's will--if thou art sick, thou +wishest not to be well contrary to God's will, but thou wishest that +it were God's will that thou shouldest be well. And so in other +things. But when God's will becomes thy will--then thou art sick: in +God's name; thy friend dies: in God's name! (55) + +SUFFERING + +MEN who love God are so far from complaining of their sufferings, +that their complaint and their suffering is rather because the +suffering which God's will has assigned them is so small. All their +blessedness is to suffer by God's will, and not to have suffered +something, for this is the loss of suffering. This is why I said, +Blessed are they who are willing to suffer for righteousness, not, +Blessed are they who have suffered. (434) + +All that a man bears for God's sake, God makes light and sweet for +him. (45) + +If all was right with you, your sufferings would no longer be +suffering, but love and comfort. (442) + +If God could have given to men anything more noble than suffering, +He would have redeemed mankind with it: otherwise, you must say that +my Father was my enemy, if he knew of anything nobler than +suffering. (338) + +True suffering is a mother of all the virtues. (338) + +SIN + +DEADLY sin is a death of the soul. To die is to lose life. But God +is the life of the soul; since then deadly sin separates us from +God, it is a death of the soul. + +Deadly sin is also an unrest of the heart. Everything can rest only +in its proper place. But the natural place of the soul is God; as St +Augustine says, Lord, thou hast made us for Thyself, and our heart +is restless till it finds rest in Thee. But deadly sin separates us +from God; therefore it is an unrest of the heart. Deadly sin is also +a sickness of the faculties, when a man can never stand up alone for +the weight of his sins, nor ever resist falling into sin. Therefore +deadly sin is a sickness of the faculties. Deadly sin is also a +blindness of the sense, in that it suffers not a man to know the +shortness of the pleasures of lust, nor the length of the punishment +in hell, nor the eternity of joys in heaven. Deadly sin is also a +death of all graces; for as soon as a deadly sin takes place, a man +becomes bare of all graces. (217) + +Every creature must of necessity abide in God; if we fall out of the +hands of his mercy, we fall into the hands of His justice. We must +ever abide in Him. What madness then is it to wish not to be with +Him, without whom thou canst not be! (169) + +CONTENTMENT + +A GREAT teacher once told a story in his preaching about a man who +for eight years besought God to show him a man who would make known +to him the way of truth. While he was in this state of anxiety there +came a voice from God and spake to him: Go in front of the church, +and there shalt thou find a man who will make known to thee the way +of truth. He went, and found a poor man whose feet were chapped and +full of dirt, and all his clothes were hardly worth +twopence-halfpenny. He greeted this poor man and said to him, God +give thee a good morning. The poor man answered, I never had a bad +morning. The other said, God give thee happiness. How answerest thou +that? The poor man answered, I was never unhappy. The first then +said, God send thee blessedness. How answerest thou that? I was +never unblessed, was the answer. Lastly the questioner said, God +give thee health! Now enlighten me, for I cannot understand it. And +the poor man replied, When thou saidst to me, may God give thee a +good morning, I said I never had a bad morning. If I am hungry, I +praise God for it; if I am cold, I praise God for it; if I am +distressful and despised, I praise God for it; and that is why I +never had a bad morning. When thou askedst God to give me happiness, +I answered that I had never been unhappy; for what God gives or +ordains for me, whether it be His love or suffering, sour or sweet, +I take it all from God as being the best, and that is why I was +never unhappy. Thou saidst further, May God make thee blessed, and I +said, I was never unblessed, for I have given up my will so entirely +to God's will, that what God wills, that I also will, and that is +why I was never unblessed, because I willed alone God's will. Ah! +dear fellow, replied the man; but if God should will to throw thee +into hell, what wouldst thou say then? He replied, Throw me into +hell! Then I would resist Him. But even if He threw me into hell, I +should still have two arms wherewith to embrace Him. One arm is true +humility, which I should place under Him, and with the arm of love I +should embrace Him. And he concluded, I would rather be in hell and +possess God, than in the kingdom of heaven without Him. (623) + +DETACHMENT + +THE man who has submitted his will and purposes entirely to God, +carries God with him in all his works and in all circumstances. +Therein can no man hinder him, for he neither aims at nor enjoys +anything else, save God. God is united with Him in all his purposes +and designs. Even as no manifoldness can dissipate God, so nothing +can dissipate such a man, or destroy his unity. Man, therefore, +should take God with him in all things; God should be always present +to his mind and will and affections. The same disposition that thou +hast in church or in thy cell, thou shouldst keep and maintain in a +crowd, and amid the unrest and manifoldness of the world. + +Some people pride themselves on their detachment from mankind, and +are glad to be alone or in church; and therein lies their peace. But +he who is truly in the right state, is so in all circumstances, and +among all persons; he who is not in a good state, it is not right +with him in all places and among all persons. He who is as he should +be has God with him in truth, in all places and among all persons, +in the street as well as in the church; and then no man can hinder +him. (547) + +It is often much harder for a man to be alone in a crowd than in the +desert; and it is often harder to leave a small thing than a great, +and to practise a small work than one which people consider very +great. (565) + +PRAYER + +GOOD and earnest prayer is a golden ladder which reaches up to +heaven, and by which man ascends to God. + +The man who will pray aright should ask for nothing except what may +promote God's honour and glory, his own profit and the advantage of +his neighbours. When we ask for temporal things we should always +add, if it be God's will and if it be for my soul's health. But when +we pray for virtues, we need add no qualification, for these are +God's own working. (359) + +LOVE OF OUR NEIGHBOUR + +IT is a hard thing to practise this universal love, and to love our +neighbours as ourselves, as our Lord commanded us. But if you will +understand it rightly, there is a greater reward attached to this +command, than to any other. The commandment seems hard, but the +reward is precious indeed. (135) + +LOVE + +HE who has found this way of love, seeketh no other. He who turns on +this pivot is in such wise a prisoner that his foot and hand and +mouth and eyes and heart, and all his human faculties, belong to +God. And, therefore, thou canst overcome thy flesh in no better way, +so that it may not shame thee, than by love. This is why it is +written, Love is as strong as death, as hard as hell. Death +separates the soul from the body, but love separates all things from +the soul. She suffers nought to come near her, that is not God nor +God-like. Happy is he who is thus imprisoned; the more thou art a +prisoner, the more wilt thou be freed. That we may be so imprisoned, +and so freed, may He help us, Who Himself is Love. (30) + +THE UNION WITH GOD + +THE union of the soul with God is far more inward than that of the +soul and body. (566) + +Now I might ask, how stands it with the soul that is lost in God? +Does the soul find herself or not? To this will I answer as it +appears to me, that the soul finds herself in the point, where every +rational being understands itself with itself. Although it sinks and +sinks in the eternity of the Divine Essence, yet it can never reach +the ground. Therefore God has left a little point wherein the soul +turns back upon itself and finds itself, and knows itself to be a +creature. (387) + +God alone must work in thee without hindrance, that He may bring to +perfection His likeness in thee. So thou mayest understand with Him, +and love with Him. This is the essence of perfection. (471) + +THE LAST JUDGMENT + +PEOPLE say of the last day, that God shall give judgment. This is +true. But it is not true as people imagine. Every man pronounces his +own sentence; as he shows himself here in his essence, so will he +remain everlastingly. (471) + +PRECEPT AND PRACTICE + +BETTER one life-master than a thousand reading-masters (wêger wêre +ein lebemeister denne tûsent lesemeister). If I sought a master +in the scriptures, I should seek him in Paris and in the high +schools of high learning. But if I wished to ask questions about the +perfect life, that he could not tell me. Where then must I go? +Nowhere at all save to an utterly simple nature; he could answer my +question. (599) + +RELICS + +MY people, why seek ye after dead bones? Why seek ye not after +living holiness, which might give you everlasting life? The dead can +neither give nor take away. (599) + +SAYINGS OF ECKHART + +MASTER ECKHART saith: He who is always alone, he is worthy of God; +and he who is always at home, to him is God present; and be who +abides always in a present now, in him doth God beget His Son +without ceasing. (600) + +Master Eckhart saith: I will never pray to God to give Himself to +me: I will pray Him to make me purer. If I were purer, God must give +Himself to me, of His own nature, and sink into me. (601) + +Master Eckhart was asked, what were the greatest goods, that God had +done to him. He said, there are three. The first is, that the lusts +and desires of the flesh have been taken away from me. The second +is, that the Divine Light shines and gives me light in all my +doings. The third is, that I am daily renewed in virtue, grace and +holiness. (602) + + + + + + +TAULER + + + + + +OUR AIM + +THINK, and think earnestly, how great, how unutterable will be the +joy and blessedness, the glory and honour of those who shall see +clearly and without veil the gladsome and beauteous face of God, how +they will enjoy the best and highest good, which is God Himself. For +in Him is included all pleasure, might, joy, and all beauty, so that +the blessed in God will possess everything that is good and +desirable, with everlasting joy and security, without fear lest they +should ever be parted from Him. (138)[38] + +CONSEQUENCES OF THE FALL + +FROM the time when the first man gave a ready ear to the words of +the enemy, mankind have been deaf, so that none of us can hear or +understand the loving utterances of the eternal Word. Something has +happened to the ears of man, which has stopped up his ears, so that +he cannot hear the loving Word; and he has also been so blinded, +that he has become stupid, and does not know himself. If he wished +to speak of his own inner life, he could not do it; he knows not +where he is, nor what is his state. (91) + +How can it be that the noble reason, the inner eye, is so blinded +that it cannot see the true light? This great shame has come about, +because a thick coarse skin and a thick fur has been drawn over him, +even the love and the opinion of the creatures, whether it be the +man himself or something that belongs to him; hence man has become +blind and deaf, in whatever position he may be, worldly or +spiritual. Yes, that is his guilt, that many a thick skin is drawn +over him, as thick as an ox's forehead, and it has so covered up his +inner man, that neither God nor himself can get inside; it has grown +into him. (92) + +THE FALL + +THROUGH two things man fell in Paradise--through pride, and through +inordinate affection. Therefore we too must return by two things, +that nature may recover her power: we must first sink our nature and +bring it down under God and under all men in deep humility, against +whom it had exalted itself in pride. We must also manfully die to +all inordinate lusts. (1) + +LIFE A BATTLE + +NOTHING in the world is so necessary for man as to be constantly +assailed; for in fighting he learns to know himself. As grace is +necessary to a man, so also is fighting. Virtue begins in fighting, +and is developed in fighting. In every state to which a man is +called, inward and outward, he must of necessity be assailed. A high +Master said: As little as meat can remain without salt and yet not +become corrupt, so little can a man remain without fighting. (104) + +A man should in the first place act as when a town is besieged, and +it is certain that the besieging army is stronger than the town. +When the town is weakest, men take the very greatest care to guard +and defend the town; if they neglected to do so, they would lose the +town, and with it their lives and properties. So should every man +do: he should be most careful to find out in what things the evil +spirit most often besets him--that is, on what side the man is +weakest, and to what kind of errors and failings he is most prone, +and should manfully defend himself at those points. + +Next, turn thyself earnestly away from sin; for I tell you of a +truth, by whatever temptation a man is assailed, if he turns not +from it heartily, but stands in it vacillating, he has no +wholehearted desire to leave his sins by God's will, and without +doubt the evil spirit is close upon him, who may make him fall into +endless perdition. + +Know of a truth, that if thou wouldst truly overcome the evil +spirit, this can only be done by a complete manful turning away from +sin. Say then with all thy heart: Oh, everlasting God, help me and +give me Thy Divine grace to be my help, for it is my steadfast +desire never again to commit any deadly sin against Thy Divine will +and Thine honour. So with thy good will and intention thou entirely +overcomest the evil spirit, so that he must fly from thee ashamed. + +Understand, however, that it is a miserable and pitiable thing for a +reasonable man to let himself be overcome by the evil spirit, and in +consequence of his attacks to fall voluntarily into grievous and +deadly sin, whereby man loses the grace of God. A reasonable man, +who allows himself voluntarily to be overcome by the evil spirit, is +like a well-armed man who voluntarily lets a fly bite him to death. +For man has many great and strong weapons, wherewith he may well and +manfully withstand the evil spirit--the holy faith, the blessed +sacrament, the holy word of God, the model and example of all good +and holy men, the prayers of holy Church, and other great supports +against the power of the evil spirit, whose power is much less than +that of a fly against a great bear. If a man will manfully and +boldly withstand the evil spirit, the evil one can gain no advantage +against his free will. + +Turn, therefore, manfully and earnestly from your sins, and watch +diligently and earnestly; for I tell you of a truth, that when you +have come to the next world, if you have not withstood the evil +spirit, and if you are found there without repentance and sorrow, +you will be a mockery to all the devils and to yourself, and you +will be eternally punished and tormented. And it will then be a +greater woe to you, that you have followed the evil spirit, than all +the external pains that you must endure eternally for your sins. + +Thirdly, a man should diligently attend to his inner Ground, that +there shall be nothing in it save God alone, and His eternal glory. +For alas! there are many men, both lay and clerical, who live +falsely beneath a fair show, and imagine that they can deceive the +everlasting God. No, in truth, thou deceivest thyself, and losest +the day of grace, and the favour of God, and makest thyself guilty +towards God, in that He gives the evil spirits power over thee, so +that thou canst do no good work. Therefore, watch while it is day, +that the hour of darkness and God's disfavour may not overtake thee, +and take heed that in thy inner ground God may dwell, and nought +besides. (75) + +Even as each man in his baptism is placed under the charge of a +special angel, who is with him always and never leaves him, and +protects him waking and sleeping in all his ways and in all his +works, so every man has a special devil, who continually opposes him +and exercises him without ceasing. But if the man were wise and +diligent, the opposition of the devil and his exercises would be +much more profitable to him than the aid of the good angel; for if +there were no struggle, there could be no victory. (139) + +SIN + +WHEN a man has had the fair net of his soul torn by sin, he must +patch and mend it by a humble, repentant return to the grace and +mercy of God. He must act like one who wishes to make a crooked +stick straight: he bends the stick further back than it ought to go, +and by being thus bent back it becomes straight again. So must a man +do to his own nature. He must bend himself under all things which +belong to God, and break himself right off, inwardly and outwardly, +from all things which are not God. + +Every deadly sin causes the precious blood of Christ to be shed +afresh. Jesus Christ is spiritually crucified many times every day. +(75) + +FISHING FOR SOULS + +THE fisherman throws his hook, that he may catch the fish; but the +fish itself takes the hook. When the fish takes the hook, the +fisherman is sure of the fish, and draws it to him. Even so, God has +thrown His hook and His net into all the world, before our feet, +before our eyes, before our minds, and He would gladly draw us +securely to Himself by means of all His creatures. By pleasurable +things He draws us on; by painful things He drives us on. He who +will not be drawn, is in fault; for he has not taken God's hook, nor +will he be caught in God's net. If he came therein, beyond doubt he +would be caught by God and would be drawn by God. It is not God's +fault if we will not be drawn; we should grasp the hand held out to +us. If a man were in a deep pool, and one tried to help him and pull +him out, would he not gladly grasp his hand and allow himself to be +pulled out? (42) + +Where two things are so related to each other, that one may receive +something for the other, there must be something in common between +them. If they had nothing in common, there must be a middle term +between them, which has something in common both with the higher, +from which it may receive, and with the lower, to which it may +impart. Now God hath created all things, and especially mankind, +immediately for Himself. He created man for His pleasure. But by +sin, human nature was so far estranged from God, that it was +impossible for a man to attain to that, for which he was made. Now +Aristotle says that God and Nature are not unprofitable +workers--that is, what they work at, they carry to its end. Now God +created man that He might have pleasure in him. If then God's work +in creating mankind was not to be unprofitable, when they were so +far estranged from God by sin, that they could not receive that by +which they might return and attain the enjoyment of eternal +happiness, a Mediator was necessary between us and God, one who has +something in common with us and our natures, and also shares in the +nature of God. In order that on the one side, He might in Himself +destroy our sickness, which was a cause of all our sins, and also +destroy all our sins, to which our weakness has brought us; and on +the other side that He might include in Himself all the treasure of +grace and of God's honour, that He might be able to give us grace +richly, and forgiveness of our sins, and eternal glory hereafter, +this could only be, if the Son of God became man. (90) + +Yea, the highest God and Lord of all lords, the Son of God, in His +deep love felt pity for us poor, sinful men, condemned to the flames +of hell. Though He was in the form of God, He thought it not robbery +(as St Paul says) to be equal with God, and He annihilated Himself, +and took upon Him the form of a servant, and was made like any other +man, being found in fashion as a man. He humbled Himself, and became +obedient unto death, even the death of the cross. (117) + +THE EFFICACY OF DIVINE GRACE + +ALL works which men and all creatures can ever work even to the end +of the world, without the grace of God--all of them together, +however great they may be, are an absolute nothing, as compared with +the smallest work which God has worked in men by His grace. As much +as God is better than all His creatures, so much better are His +works than all the works, or wisdom, or designs, which all men could +devise. Even the smallest drop of grace is better than all earthly +riches that are beneath the sun. Yea, a drop of grace is more noble +than all angels and all souls, and all the natural things that God +has made. And yet grace is given more richly by God to the soul than +any earthly gift. It is given more richly than brooks of water, than +the breath of the air, than the brightness of the sun; for spiritual +things are far finer and nobler than earthly things. The whole +Trinity, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, give grace to the soul, and +flow immediately into it; even the highest angel, in spite of his +great nobility, cannot do this. Grace looses us from the snares of +many temptations; it relieves us from the heavy burden of worldly +cares, and carries the spirit up to heaven, the land of spirits. It +kills the worm of conscience, which makes sins alive. Grace is a +very powerful thing. The man, to whom cometh but a little drop of +the light of grace, to him all that is not God becomes as bitter as +gall upon the tongue. (86) + +Grace makes, contrary to nature, all sorrows sweet, and brings it +about that a man no longer feels any relish for things which +formerly gave him great pleasure and delight. On the other hand, +what formerly disgusted him, now delights him and is the desire of +his heart--for instance, weakness, sorrow, inwardness, humility, +self-abandonment, and detachment from all the creatures. All this is +in the highest degree dear to him, when this visitation of the Holy +Ghost, grace, has in truth come to him. Then the sick man, that is +to say the external man, with all his faculties is plunged +completely into the pool of water, even as the sick man who had been +for thirty-eight years by the pool at Jerusalem, and there washes +himself thoroughly in the exalted, noble, precious blood of Christ +Jesus. For grace in manifold ways bathes the soul in the wounds and +blood of the holy Lamb, Jesus Christ. (22) + +PRAYER + +THE essence of prayer is the ascent of the mind to God, as holy +teachers tell us. Therefore every good man, when he wishes to pray, +ought to collect his outer senses into himself, and look into his +mind, to see whether it be really turned to God. He who wishes that +his prayers may be truly heard, must keep himself turned away from +all temporal and external things, and all that is not Divine, +whether it be friend or joy (Freund oder Freude), and all vanities, +whether they be clothes or ornaments, and from everything of which +God is not the true beginning and ending, and from everything that +does not belong to Him. He must cut off his words and his conduct, +his manners and his demeanour, from all irregularity, inward or +outward. Dream not that that can be a true prayer, when a man only +babbles outwardly with his mouth, and reads many psalms, gabbling +them rapidly and hastily, while his mind wanders this way and that, +backwards and forwards. Much rather must the true prayer be, as St +Peter tells us, "one-minded"[39]—that is, the mind must cleave to +God alone, and a man must look with the face of his soul turned +directly towards God, with a gentle, willing dependence on Him. (80) + +If thy prayer has these conditions, thou mayst with true humility +fall at the feet of God, and pray for the gentle succour of God; +thou mayest knock at His fatherly heart, and ask for bread—that is, +for love. If a man had all the food in the world, and had not bread, +his food would be neither eatable, nor pleasant, nor useful. So it +is with all things, without the Love of God. Knock also at the door +through which we must go--namely, Christ Jesus. At this door, the +praying man must knock for three ends, if he wishes to be really +admitted. First he must knock devoutly, at the broken heart and the +open side, and enter in with all devotion, and in recognition of his +unfathomable poverty and nothingness, as poor Lazarus did at the +rich man's gate, and ask for crumbs of His grace. Then again, he +should knock at the door of the holy open wounds of His holy hands, +and pray for true Divine knowledge, that it may enlighten him and +exalt him. Finally, knock at the door of His holy feet, and pray for +true Divine love, which may unite thee with Him, and immerse and +cover thee in Him. (57) + + + + + + +MEDITATIONS ON THE SEVEN WORDS FROM THE CROSS + + + + + +[From a devotional treatise on the Passion of Christ, published in a +Latin translation, by Surius, in 1548, and wrongly ascribed by him +to Tauler. The author was an unknown German of the fourteenth +century.] + +THE FIRST WORD + +NOW, O my soul, and all ye who have been redeemed by the precious +blood of Christ, come, and let us go with inward compassion and +fervent devotion to the blessed palm-tree of the Cross, which is +laden with the fairest fruit. Let us pass like the bee from flower +to flower, for all are full of honey. Let us consider and ponder +with the greatest care the sacred words of Christ, which He spoke +upon the Cross; for everything that comes From this blessed Tree is +wholesome and good. In the Cross of our Lord and Saviour are centred +all our salvation, all our health, all our life, all our glory; and, +"if we suffer with Him," saith the Apostle, "we shall also reign +with Him." That we may not be found ungrateful for these inestimable +benefits, let us call upon heaven and earth, and all that in them +is, to join us in praising and blessing and giving thanks to God. +Let us invite them to come and look upon this wondrous sight, and +say: "Magnify the Lord with me, for He hath done marvellous things. +O praise and bless the Lord with me, for great is His mercy toward +us." Come up with me, I pray you, ye angelic spirits, to Mount +Calvary, and see your King Solomon on His throne, wearing the diadem +wherewith His mother has crowned Him. Let us weep in the presence of +the Lord who made us, the Lord our God. O all mankind, and all ye +who are members of Christ, behold your Redeemer as He hangs on high; +behold and weep. See if any sorrow is like unto His sorrow. +Acknowledge the heinousness of your sins, which needed such +satisfaction. Go to every part of His body; you will find only +wounds and blood. Cry to Him with lamentations and say, "O Jesus, +our redemption, our love, our desire, what mercy has overcome Thee, +that Thou shouldest bear our sins, and endure a cruel death, to +rescue us from everlasting death?" And Thou, O God, the almighty +Father of heaven, look down from Thy sanctuary upon Thine innocent +Son Joseph, sold and given over unjustly to the hands of bloody men, +to suffer a shameful death. See whether this be Thy Son's coat or +not. Of a truth an evil beast hath devoured Him. The blood of our +sins is sprinkled over His garments, and all the coverings of His +good name are defiled by it. See how Thy holy Child has been +condemned with the wicked, how Thy royal Son has been crowned with +thorns. Behold His innocent hands, which have known no sin, dripping +with blood; behold His sacred feet, which have never turned aside +from the path of justice, pierced through by a cruel nail; behold +His defenceless side smitten with a sharp spear; behold His fair +face, which the angels desire to look upon, marred and shorn of all +its beauty; behold His blessed heart, which no impure thought ever +stained, weighed down with inward sorrow. Behold, O loving Father, +Thy sweet Son, stretched out upon the harp of the Cross, and harping +blessings on Thee with all His members. Wherefore, O my God, I pray +Thee to forgive me, for the sake of Thy Son's Passion, all the sins +that I have committed in my members. O merciful Father, look on Thy +only-begotten Son, that Thou mayst have compassion on Thy servant. +Whenever that red blood of Thy Son speaks in Thy sight, do Thou wash +me from every stain of sin. Whenever Thou beholdest the wounds of +this Thy Son, open to me the bosom of Thy fatherly compassion. +Behold, O tender Father, how Thy obedient Son does not cry, "Bind my +hands and my feet, that I may not rebel against Thee," but how of +His own will He extends His hands and feet, and gladly allows them +to be pierced with nails. Look down, I pray Thee, not on the brazen +serpent hanging on a pole for the salvation of Israel, but on Thine +only Son hanging on the Cross for the salvation of all men. It is +not Moses who now stretches out his hand to heaven, that the thunder +and lightning and the other plagues may cease, but it is Thy beloved +Son, who lovingly stretches out His bleeding arms to Thee, that Thy +wrath may depart from the human race. Aaron and Hur are not now +holding up the hands of Moses that he may pray more unweariedly for +Israel; but hard and cruel nails have fastened the hands of Thy only +Son to the Cross, that He may wait with long-suffering for our +repentance, and receive us back into His grace, and that He may not +turn away in wrath from our prayers. This is that faithful David, +who now strings tight the harp-strings of His body, and makes sweet +melody before Thee, singing to Thee the sweetest song that has been +ever sung to Thee: "Father forgive them, for they know not what they +do." This is that High Priest, who by His own blood has entered into +the Holy of Holies, to offer Himself as a peace-offering for the +sins of the whole world. This is that innocent Lamb, who has washed +us in His own precious blood, who, Himself without spot of sin, has +taken away the sins of the world. Therefore from the storehouse of +His Passion I borrow the price of my debt, and I count out before +Thee all its merits, to pay what I owe Thee. For He has done all in +my nature, and for my sake. O merciful Father, if Thou weighest all +my sins on one side of the balance, and in the other scale the +Passion of Thy Son, the last will outweigh the first. For what sin +can be so great, that the innocent blood of Thy Son has not washed +it out? What pride, or disobedience, or lust, is so unchecked or so +rebellious, that such lowliness, obedience, and poverty cannot +abolish it? O merciful Father, accept the deeds of Thy beloved Son, +and forgive the errors of Thy wicked servant. For the innocent blood +of our brother Abel crieth to Thee from the Cross, not for +vengeance, but for grace and mercy, saying, "Father, forgive them, +for they know not what they do." + +THE SECOND WORD + +NOW the thieves who were crucified with Jesus reviled Him. But after +a while, the one who hung on the right side of Christ, when he saw +His great patience and long-suffering, wherewith He so lovingly +prayed to His Father for those who cast reproaches upon Him and +cruelly tortured Him, became entirely changed, and began to be moved +with very great sorrow and repentance for his sins. And he showed +this outwardly, when he rebuked his fellow-thief, who continued to +revile Christ, saying: "Dost not thou fear God, seeing thou art in +the same condemnation?" "Although" (he would say) "thou art so +obstinate as not to fear men, and thinkest nought of thy bodily +pain, yet surely thou must fear God, in the last moments of thy +life--God, who hath power to destroy both thy body and soul in hell. +And though we suffer the same punishment with Him, our deserts are +very different. We, indeed, suffer justly, for we receive the due +reward of our deeds, but this man hath done nothing amiss." He, who +but lately was a blasphemer, is now a confessor and preacher, he +distinguishes good from evil, blaming the sinner, and excusing the +innocent: the unbelieving thief has become the confessor of almighty +God. O good Jesus, this sudden change is wrought by Thy right hand, +at which he hung. Thy right hand touched him inwardly, and forthwith +he is changed into another man. O Lord, in this Thou hast declared +Thy patience, out of a stone Thou hast raised up a child unto +Abraham. Verily, the penitent thief received the light of faith +solely from that bright light on the candlestick of the Cross, which +shone there in the darkness and scattered the shades of night. But +what does this signify, save that our Lord Jesus, out of the +greatness of His goodness, looked upon him with the eyes of His +mercy, although He found no merit in him, except what it pleased Him +out of His goodness to bestow? For as God gives to His elect, out of +His goodness alone, what no one has a right to demand, so out of His +justice He gives to the wicked what they deserve. For this cause +David says: "He saved me because He desired me." And this is why the +thief, before the Lord touched his heart with the beams of His grace +and love, joined the other thief in reviling Christ, thus showing +first what his own character was, and afterwards what was wrought in +him by grace. At first he acted like the other, being, like him, a +child of wrath; but when the precious blood of Christ was shed as +the price of our redemption and paid to the Father for our debt, +then the thief asked God to give him an alms for his good, and at +once received it. For how can one alms diminish that inexhaustible +treasure? How could our tender Lord, whose property is always to +have mercy, have refused his request? Indeed He gave him more than +he asked. Yet how could the thief escape the glow of the fire which +was burning so near him? Truly this was the fire, which the Father +had sent down from heaven to earth, which had long smouldered, but +now, kindled anew, and fed by the wood of the Cross, and sprinkled +with the oil of mercy, and fanned, as it were, by the reproaches and +blasphemies of the Jews, sent up its flames to heaven, by which that +thief was quite kindled and set on fire, and his love became as +strong as death, so that he said: "I indeed suffer no grievous +penalty, for it is less than I deserve; but that this innocent One, +who has done no wrong, should be so tortured, contrary to justice +and righteousness, this, truly, adds grievous sorrow to my sorrow." +O splendid faith of this thief! He contemned all the punishment that +might be inflicted on him: he feared not the rage of the people, who +were barking like mad dogs against Jesus: he cared not for the chief +priests: he feared not the executioners with their weapons and +instruments of torture; but in the presence of them all, with a +fearless heart he confessed that Christ was the true Son of God, and +Lord of the whole world: and at the same time he confounded the Jews +by confessing that He had done nothing amiss, and therefore that +they had crucified Him unjustly. O wondrous faith! O mighty +constancy! O amazing love of this poor thief, love that cast out all +fear! He was indeed well drunken with that new wine which in the +wine-press of the Cross had been pressed out of that sweet cluster, +Jesus Christ, and therefore he confessed Christ without shame before +all the people. At the very beginning of the Passion, the apostles +and disciples had forsaken Christ and fled; even St Peter, +frightened by the voice of one maidservant, had denied Christ. But +this poor thief did not forsake Him even in death, but confessed Him +to be the Lord of heaven in the presence of all those armed men. Who +can do justice to the merits of this man? Who taught him so quickly +that faith of his, and his clear knowledge of all the virtues, save +the very Wisdom of the Father, Jesus Christ, who hung near him on +the Cross? Him whom the Jews could not or would not know, in spite +of the promises made to the patriarchs, the fulfilment of +prophecies, the teaching of the Scriptures, and the interpretation +of allegories, this poor thief learned to know by repentance. He +confessed Christ to be the Son of God, though he saw Him full of +misery, want, and torment, and dying from natural weakness. He +confessed Him at a time when the apostles, who had seen His mighty +works, denied Him. The nails were holding his hands and feet fixed +to the cross; he had nothing free about him, except his heart and +his tongue; yet he gave to God all that he could give to Him, and, +in the words of Scripture, "with his heart he believed unto +righteousness, and with his tongue he made confession of Christ unto +salvation." O infinite and unsearchable mercy of God! For what +manner of man was he when he was sent to the cross, and what when he +left it? (Not that it was his own cross, that wrought this change, +but the power of Christ crucified.) He came to the cross stained +with the blood of his fellow-man; he was taken down from it cleansed +by the blood of Christ. He came to the cross still savage and full +of rage, and while he was upon it he became so meek and pitiful that +he lamented for the sufferings of another more than for his own. One +member only was left to him, and at the eleventh hour he came to +work in God's vineyard, and yet so eagerly did he labour that he was +the first to finish his work and receive his reward. Indeed he +behaved like a just man; for he first accused himself and confessed +his sins, saying, "and we, indeed, justly, for we receive the due +reward of our deeds." Secondly, he excused Christ, and confessed +that He was the Just One when he said "but this Man hath done +nothing amiss." Thirdly, he showed brotherly love, for he said, +"dost not thou fear God?" Fourthly, with all his members, or at +least with all that he could offer, and with loving eyes and a +devout heart and a humble spirit, he turned himself to Christ and +prayed earnestly, "Lord, remember me when Thou comest into Thy +Kingdom." How great was the justice and humility and resignation +which he showed in this prayer, for he asked only for a little +remembrance of himself, acknowledging that he was not worthy to ask +for anything great. Nor did he pray for the safety of his body, for +he gladly desired to die for his sins. It was more pleasant for him +to die with Christ than to live any longer. Nor did he pray that our +Lord would deliver him from the pains of hell, or of purgatory, nor +did he ask for the kingdom of heaven; but he resigned himself +entirely to the will of God, and offered himself altogether to +Christ, to do what He would with him. In his humility he prayed for +nothing except for grace and mercy, for which David also prayed when +he said, "Deal with Thy servant according to Thy mercy." And +therefore, because he had prayed humbly and wisely, the Eternal +Wisdom, Who reads the hearts of all who pray, heard his prayer, and, +opening wide the rich storehouse of His grace, bestowed upon him +much more than he had dared to ask. O marvellous goodness of God! +How plainly dost Thou declare in this, that Thou desirest not the +death of a sinner, but rather that he should be converted and live. +Now Thou hast manifested and fulfilled what Thou didst promise +aforetime by Thy prophet: "When the wicked man shall mourn for his +sins, I will remember his iniquity no more." Thou didst not impose +upon him many years of severe penance, nor many sufferings in +purgatory for the expiation of his sins; but just as if Thou hadst +quite forgotten his crimes, and couldst see nothing in him but +virtue, Thou didst say: "This day shalt thou be with Me in +paradise." O immeasurable compassion of God! Our tender Lord forgot +all the countless crimes which that poor thief had done, and forgave +him when he repented, and gave so great and splendid a reward to the +good which there was in him, small indeed though it was. Our loving +God is very rich; He needs not our gifts; but He seeks for a heart +which turns to Him with lowliness and resignation, such a heart as +He found in this poor thief. For He says Himself: "turn to Me, and I +will turn to you." And so when this thief so courageously and +effectively turned to God, his prayer was at once not only accepted +but answered. For our Lord did not reject his prayer, or say to him: +"See how I hang here in torment, and I behold before My eyes My +mother in sore affliction, and I have not yet spoken one word to +her, so that to hear thee now would not be just." No, our Lord said +nothing of this kind to the thief. Rather, He heard his prayer at +once, and made answer in that sweet word, "Amen, I say unto thee, +this day shalt thou be with Me in paradise." O tender goodness, O +marvellous mercy of God! O great wisdom of the thief! He saw that +the treasures of Christ were wide open, and were being scattered +abroad. Who then should forbid him to take as much as would pay what +he owed to his Lord? And O the accursed hardness of the impenitent +thief, whom neither the rebuke of his associate, nor the patience of +Christ, nor the many signs of love and mercy that shone forth in +Christ, could melt or convert! He saw that alms were plentiful at +the rich man's gate, that more was given than was asked for, and yet +he was too proud and obstinate to ask. He saw that life and the +kingdom of heaven were being granted, and yet he would not bend his +heart to wish for them: therefore he shall not have them. He loved +better revilings and curses, and they shall come unto him, and that +for all eternity. These new first-fruits of the grape, which our +Lord gathered on the wood of the Cross from our barren soil, by much +sweat of His brow and much watering with His own precious blood, He +sent with great joy as a precious gift to His heavenly Father, by +His celestial messengers the holy angels. But if there is joy among +the angels of God over one sinner that repenteth, how must they +rejoice and exult at the salvation of this thief, of whom they had +almost despaired? We can picture to ourselves with what joy the +Father of heaven received these first-fruits of the harvest of His +Son's Passion. But Christ Himself, though He felt some joy at the +thief's conversion, was still more afflicted thereby, for by His +wisdom He foresaw that this thief would be the cause of perdition to +many, who would resolve to pass their whole lives in sin, hoping to +obtain pardon and grace at the moment of death. Truly a most foolish +hope, for nowhere in the Scriptures do we read that it has so +happened to any man. In truth, they who seek after God only when +they must, will not, it is to be feared, find Him near them in their +time of need. In the meantime, none can trust too much in God, and +no one has ever been forsaken by Him, who has turned to Him with his +whole heart, and leant upon Him with loving confidence. + +THE THIRD WORD + +THERE stood also by the Cross of Jesus His most holy and ever-virgin +mother Mary; not in order that His sufferings might thereby be +lessened, but that they might be greatly augmented. For if any +creature could have given consolation to the Lord while He hung on +the Cross, no one could have done it so fitly as His blessed mother. +But since it was God's will that Christ should die the most bitter +of deaths, and end His Passion without any comfort or relief, but +with true resignation, His mother's presence brought Him no +consolation, but rather added to His sufferings, for her sufferings +were thereby added to His, and this added yet more to His +affliction. Who then, O good Jesus can discover by meditation how +great was Thy inward grief, for Thou knowest the hearts of all, when +Thou sawest all the body of Thy holy mother tortured by inward +compassion, even as Thou wast tortured on the Cross, and her tender +heart and maternal breast pierced with the sword of sharp sorrow, +her face pale as death, telling the anguish of her soul, and almost +dead, yet unable to die. When Thou beheldest her hot tears, flowing +down abundantly like sweet rivers upon her gracious cheeks, and over +all her face, all witnesses to Thee that she shared in Thy sorrow +and love; when Thou heardest her sad laments, forced from her by the +weight of her affliction; when Thou sawest that same tender mother, +melted away with the heat of love, her strength quite failing her, +worn out and exhausted by the pains of Thy Passion, which wasted her +away; all this, truly, was a new affliction to Thee on the Cross; it +was itself a new Cross. For Thou alone, by the spear of, Thy pity, +didst explore the weight and grievousness of her woes, which to men +are beyond comprehension. All this, indeed, greatly increased the +pain of Thy Passion, because Thou wast crucified not only in Thy own +body, but in Thy mother's heart; for her Cross was Thy Cross, and +Thine was hers. O how bitter was Thy Passion, sweet Jesus! Great +indeed was Thy outward suffering, but far more grievous was Thy +inward suffering, which Thy heart experienced at Thy mother's +anguish. It was now, beyond doubt, that the sword of sorrow pierced +her through, for the queen of martyrs was terribly and mortally +wounded in that part which is impassible--that is, the soul; she +bore the death of the Cross in that part which could not die, +suffering all the more her grievous inward death, as outward death +departed further from her. Who, O most loving mother, can recount or +conceive in his mind the immeasurable sorrows of thy soul, or thine +inward woes? Him whom thou didst bring forth without pain, as a +blessed mother free from the curse of our first mother Eve, who +instead of the pains of labour wast filled with joy of spirit, and +who for thy refreshment didst listen to the sweet songs of the +angels as they praised thy Son, thou hast now seen slain before +thine eyes with the greatest cruelty and tyranny. How manifold was +that sorrow of thine, which thou wast permitted to escape at His +birth, when thou sawest thy blessed and only Son hanging in such +torment on the Cross, in the presence of a cruel and furious crowd, +who showered upon Him all the insults and contumely and shame that +they could think of; when thou sawest Him whom thou didst bear in +thy pure womb without feeling the burden, so barbarously stretched +on the Cross, and pierced with nails; when thou sawest His sacred +arms, with which He had so many times lovingly embraced thee, +stretched out so that He could not move them, and covered with red +blood, His adorable head pierced with sharp thorns, and His whole +body one streaming wound, while thou wast not able to staunch or +anoint any of those wounds. What must thy grief have been when thou +sawest Him whom thou hadst so often laid on thy virgin bosom that He +might rest, without anything on which to lean His sacred head; and +Him whom thou hadst nourished with the milk of thy holy breasts, now +vexed with vinegar and gall. O how thy maternal heart was oppressed +when thou beheldest with thy pure eyes that fair face so piteously +marred, so that there was no beauty in it, and nothing by which He +could be distinguished. How did the wave of affliction beat against +and overflow and overwhelm thy soul! Truly, if even a devout man +cannot without unspeakable sorrow and pity revolve in his mind the +Passion of thy Son, what must have been thy Cross, thy affliction, +who wast His mother and sawest it all with thine eyes? If to many +friends of God and to many who love Him, thy Son's Passion is as +grievous as if they suffered it themselves, if by inward pity they +are crucified with thy Son, how terribly, even unto death, must thou +have been crucified inwardly, when thou didst not only ponder and +search into the outward and inward pains of thy Son in thy devout +heart, but sawest them with thy bodily eyes? For never did any +mother love her child as thou lovedst thy Son. And if St Paul, who +loved so much, could say, out of his ardent love and deep pity for +thy Son, "I am crucified with Christ; and I bear in my body the +marks of the Lord Jesus," how much more wert thou crucified with +Him, and didst inwardly receive all His wounds, being made, in a +manner, an image and likeness of thy crucified Son? + +THE FOURTH WORD + +ABOUT the ninth hour our Lord Jesus cried with a loud voice, "My +God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" He cried with a loud voice, +that He might be easily heard by all, and also that by this wondrous +word He might shake off from our souls the sleep of sloth, and cause +them to wonder and marvel at the immeasurable goodness of God to us. +Therefore He saith, "My God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" For +the sake of vile sinners, for evil and thankless servants, for +sinful and disobedient deceivers, Thou hast forsaken Thy beloved Son +and most obedient Child. That Thy enemies, who are vessels of wrath, +might be changed into children of adoption, Thou hast slain Thine +own Son, and given Him over to death like one guilty. "O my God, +why, I pray Thee, hast Thou forsaken me?" For the very cause why men +ought to praise and give thanks to Thee, and love Thee with an +everlasting love; because Thou hast delivered Thy dear Son to death +for their redemption, and sacrificed Him willingly, for this reason +they will find ground for blasphemy and reproach against Thee, +saying, "He saith He is the Son of God. Let God deliver Him now if +He will have Him." Why, O my God, hast Thou willed to spend so +precious a treasure for such vile and counterfeit goods? Besides, +this word may be understood to have been spoken by Christ against +those who seek to diminish the glory of His Passion, by saying that +it was not really so bitter and terrible, owing to the great support +and comfort which He drew from His Godhead. Let those who speak and +think thus know that they renew His Passion and crucify Him afresh. +It was to prove the error of such men that our Lord cried with a +loud voice, and said, "My God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" +It is as if He had said these words to His own Divine nature, with +which He formed one Person--for the Godhead of the Father and of the +Son is all one--wondering, Himself, at His own love, which had so +cast Him down and worn Him out and humbled Him, and that He who +brings help to all mankind should have forsaken Himself, and offered +Himself to suffer every kind of pain, impelled thereto by conquering +love alone. Again, we should not be wrong, if we were to interpret +this word which Christ spoke out of the exceeding bitterness of His +sorrow in the following way--namely, that His spirit and inward man, +taking upon itself the severe judgment of God upon all sinners, and +at the same time discerning clearly and feeling and measuring in +Himself the intolerable weight of His Passion, on this account cried +out in a sorrowful voice to His Father, and complained tenderly to +Him because He had been cast into these dreadful torments; as if the +goodness of His Father had become so embittered against the sins of +men, that in the ardour of His justice He had quite forgotten the +inseparable union between His passible humanity and His impassible +Godhead, and therefore in the zealousness of His justice had quite +given up His passible nature to the cruelty and malice of fierce +men, that they might waste it away and destroy it. For this reason, +therefore, He said, "My God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" +This word has besides an inward meaning, according to which Christ, +in His sensitive parts, complained to His Father that He had been +forsaken by Him. For as many as contend for His honour, and endure +patiently the troubles of this world, our merciful God so moderates +and tempers their crosses and afflictions by the inpouring of His +divine consolation, that by His sensible grace He makes their +crosses hardly felt; but He left His own beloved Son quite without +any comfort, and so deprived Him of all consolation and light, that +He endured as much in His human nature as had been ordained by the +Eternal Wisdom, according to the strictness of justice, as much as +was needed to atone for so many sins. And indeed our salvation was +the more nobly and perfectly achieved, in that it was done and +finished without any light at all, in absolute resignation and +abandonment. For a chief cause of the Passion was to show clearly +how great was the injury and insult brought upon His most high +Godhead by the sins of the human race. Now as the knowledge of +Christ was greater and more acute than that of all other beings, in +heaven or in earth, so much the greater and heavier was His sorrow +and agony. Nay more--what is more wonderful than anything--whatever +afflictions have been endured by all the saints, as members of +Christ, existed much more abundantly in Christ their Head; and this +I wish to be understood according to the spirit and reasonably. For +all the saints have suffered no more than flowed in upon them +through Christ, joined to them as His members, who communicated to +them His own afflictions. For He took upon Himself the afflictions +of all the saints, out of His great love for His members, and +wondrous pity, and He suffered far greater internal anguish than any +of the saints, nay, more even than the blessed Virgin, His mother, +felt her own sharp sorrow and sickness of heart. For if an earthly +father loves his child so much, that in fatherly pity he takes upon +himself the sorrows of his child, and grieves for them as if he +suffered them himself, what must have been Christ's Cross and +compassion for the affliction of His members, and above all, of +those who suffered for His name's sake? Truly He bore witness to His +members, how much He suffered from their afflictions, and how great +was His inward pity for their sufferings, when He took all their +debt upon Himself, and abolished all the penalties which they had +merited, so that they might depart free. The same is most amply +proved by the words which He spoke to St Paul, when He said, "Saul, +Saul, why persecutest thou Me?" For the persecution which Saul had +stirred up against the disciples, the members of the Lord, was not +less grievous to Him than if He had suffered it Himself. Therefore +He says to His friends and members, "He who touches you, touches the +apple of Mine eye." For is there anything suffered by the members, +which the Head does not suffer with them, He whose nature is +goodness, and whose property is always to have mercy and to forgive? + +THE FIFTH WORD + +OUR most tender Lord was so worn out and parched by the extreme +bitterness of His pain and suffering, and by the great loss of +blood, that He cried, "I thirst." A little word, but full of +mysteries. + +In the first place it may be understood literally. For it is natural +for those who are at the point of death to feel thirst, and to +desire to drink. But how great was the drouth felt by Him who is the +fountain of living water, but who was now worn out and parched by +the heat of His ardent love, when he could truly say, "I am poured +out like water," and "My strength is dried up like a potsherd." For +not only did He shed all His own blood, and pour out moisture by +tears, but the very marrow of His bones, and all His heart's blood, +were consumed for our sakes by the heat and flame of love. Therefore +He said rightly, "I thirst." + +But, secondly, the word may be understood spiritually, as if Christ +said to all men, "I thirst for your salvation." Hence St Bernard +says: "Jesus cried, I thirst, not, I grieve. O Lord, what dost Thou +thirst for? For your faith, your joy. I thirst because of the +torments of your souls, far more than for My own bodily sufferings. +Have pity on yourselves, if not on Me." And again, "O good Jesus, +Thou wearest the crown of thorns; Thou art silent about Thy Cross +and wounds, yet Thou criest out, I thirst. For what, then, dost Thou +thirst? Truly, for the redemption of mankind only, and for the +felicity of the human race." This thirst of Christ was a hundred +times more keen and intense than His natural thirst. And, besides, +He had another sort of thirst--that is to say, a thirst to suffer +more, and to prove to us still more clearly His immeasurable love, +as if He said to man, "See how I am worn out and exhausted for thy +salvation. See how terrible are the pains and anguish which I +endure. The fierce cruelty of man has almost brought Me to nothing; +the sinners of earth have drunk out all My blood, and yet I thirst. +Not yet is My heart satisfied, nor My desire accomplished, nor the +fire of My love quenched. For if it were possible for Me, and +according to My Father's will, that I should be crucified again a +thousand times for your salvation and conversion, or that I should +hang here, in all this pain and anguish, till the day of judgment, I +would gladly do it, to prove to you the immeasurable love which I +bear you in My heart, and to soften your stony hearts and rouse you +to love Me in return. This is why I hang here so thirsty by the +fountain of your hearts, that I may watch the pious souls who come +hither to draw from the deep well of My Passion. Therefore, the +maiden to whom I shall say, 'Give Me to drink a little water out of +the pitcher of thy conscience'--the water of devotion, pity, tears, +and mutual love--and who shall let down to Me her pitcher, and shall +say, 'Drink, my Lord; and for Thy camels also--that is, Thy +servants, who carry Thee about daily on their bodies, and who by +night and day are held bound fast by Thy yoke, I will draw the water +of brotherly love'--that is the maiden whom the Lord hath prepared +for the Son of My Lord, even the bride of the Word of God, united to +My humanity. And she shall be counted worthy to enter, like a bride +with her bridegroom, into the chamber of eternal rest, when the +Bridegroom invites her, saying, 'Come, My blessed bride, inherit the +Kingdom of My Father. For I was thirsty, and thou gavest Me drink.'" + +Thirdly, we may apply this word to the Father, as if Christ said to +His Father: "Father, I have declared Thy name to mankind; I have +finished the work which Thou gavest Me to do; and in Thy service I +have spent My whole body as Thine instrument. Behold, I am all worn +out and exhausted; and yet I still thirst to do and suffer more for +Thine honour. This is why I hang here, extended to the furthest +breadth of love, for I long to be an everlasting sacrifice, a sweet +savour to Thee, and at the same time an eternal atonement and +salvation to mankind." Thus, too, might this strong Samson have +said: "O Lord, Thou hast put into the hand of Thy servant this very +great salvation and victory, and yet behold, I die of thirst." As if +He would say: "Father, I have accomplished Thy gracious will; I have +finished the work of man's salvation, as Thou didst demand; and yet +I still thirst; for the sins by which Thou art offended are +infinite. And so I desire that the love and merits of My Passion, by +which Thou wilt be appeased, may be infinite too. And as I now offer +myself as a peace-offering and a living sacrifice for the salvation +of all men, so through Me may all men appease Thee, by offering Me +to Thee as a peace-offering to Thine eternal glory, in memory of My +Passion, and to make good all their shortcomings." O how acceptable +to the Father must this desire of love have been! For what was this +thirst but a sweet and pleasant refreshment to the Father, and at +the same time the blessed renovation of mankind? Or what other +language does this burning throat speak to us, save that of Christ's +burning love, without measure and without limit, out of which He did +all His works? This truly is the most noble sacrifice of our +redemption, this is that peace-offering which will be offered even +to the last day, by all good men, to the Holy Ghost, to the highest +Father, in memory of the Son, to the eternal glory of the adorable +Trinity, and to the fruit of salvation for mankind. Here, certainly, +is the inexhaustible storehouse of our reconciliation, which never +fails, for it is greater than all the debts of the world. This is +that immeasurable love, which is higher than the heavens, for it has +repaired the ruin of the angels; deeper than hell, for it has freed +souls from hell; wider and broader than the earth, for it is without +end and incomprehensible by any created understanding. O how keen +and intense was this thirst of our Lord! For not only did He then +say once, "I thirst," but even now He says in our hearts +continually, "I thirst; woman, give me to drink." So great, so +mighty, is that thirst, that He asks drink not only from the +children of Israel, but from the Samaritans. To each one He +complaineth of His thirst. But for what dost Thou thirst, O good +Jesus? "My meat and drink," saith He, "is that men should do My +Father's will. Now this is the will of My Father, even your +sanctification and salvation, that you may sanctify your souls by +walking in My precepts, by doing works of repentance, by adorning +yourselves with all virtues, in order that, like a bride adorned for +her husband, you may be worthy to be present at My supper in My +Father's kingdom, and to sleep with Me as My elect bride, in the +chamber of My Father's heart." O how Christ longs to bring all men +thither! This is the meaning of His words: "Where I am there shall +also My servant be"; and again: "Father, I will that they may be one +even as We are one." O, how incomprehensible is this thirst of +Christ! What toil and labour He endured for thirty and three years, +for the sake of it! For this His very heart's blood was poured out. +See what our tender Lord says to His Father: "The zeal of Thine +house hath even eaten Me." Truly, He would have submitted to be +crucified a thousand times, rather than allow one soul to perish +through any fault of His. O how this inward thirst tormented Him, +when He thought that He had done all that He could, and even a +hundredfold more than He need have done, and yet that so few had +turned to Him, and been won by Him. His whole body was now worn out; +all His blood was shed; nothing remained for Him to do; and +therefore He was constrained to confess, "It is finished"; and yet +by all His labours, afflictions, and sufferings, He had brought no +richer harvest to the Father than this. Truly, this was the most +bitter of all His sorrows, that after so hard a battle His victory +had not been more glorious, and that He returned a conqueror to His +Father with so few spoils. Therefore, all those who do not refresh +Him by performing His will, and doing all that is pleasing and +honourable to Him, and withstanding all that reason tells them to be +displeasing to Him, will one day hear Him say, "I was thirsty, and +ye gave Me no drink. Depart, ye cursed, into everlasting fire." + +Fourthly, there is yet another inward meaning of this word--namely, +that Christ spoke it out of the love which inwardly draws Him +towards all men, thus making known to us His ardent love, and +opening His own heart, as a delightful couch, on which we may feed +pleasantly, and inviting us to it, saying, "I thirst for you." For +as the liquid which we drink is sent down pleasantly through the +throat into the body, and so passes into the substance and nature of +our body, so Christ out of the ardent thirst of His love, takes +spiritual pleasure in drinking in all men into Himself, swallowing +them, as it were, and incorporating them into Himself, and bringing +them into the secret chamber of His loving heart. Therefore He says: +"I, if I be lifted up from the earth, will draw all men unto +Me"--all men, that is, who allow themselves to be drawn by Me, and +submit to Me as obedient instruments, suffering Me to do with them +according to My gracious will. But those who resist Him quench not +His thirst, but give Him a bitter draught instead, even the deeds of +their own self-will. These, when our Lord tasteth them, He +straightway rejects. + +THE SIXTH WORD + +WHEN Christ had tasted the draught of vinegar and gall, He spoke the +sixth word: "It is finished." Thereby He signified that by His +Passion had been fulfilled all the prophecies, types, mysteries, +scriptures, sacrifices, and promises, which had been predicted and +written about Him. This is that true Son of God, for whom the Father +of heaven made ready a supper in the kingdom of His eternal +blessedness; and He sent His servant--that is the human nature of +Christ, coming in the form of a servant, to call them that were +bidden to the wedding. For Christ, when He took human nature upon +Him, was not only a servant but a servant of servants, and served +all of us for thirty and three years with great toil and suffering. +Indeed, He spent His whole life in bidding all men to His supper. It +was for this that He preached, and wrought miracles, and travelled +from place to place, and proclaimed that the kingdom of heaven was +at hand, and that all should be prepared for it. But they would not +come. And when the Father of the household heard this, He said to +His Servant: "Compel them to come in, that My house may be filled." +Then that Servant thought within Himself: "How shall I be able +without violence to compel these men to come, that rebellion may be +avoided and yet that their privilege and power of free will may +remain unimpaired? For if I compel them to come by iron chains, and +blows, and whips, I shall have asses and not men." Then He said to +Himself: "I perceive that man is so constituted as to be prone to +love. Therefore I will show him such love as shall pass all his +understanding, love than which no other love can be greater. If man +will observe this, he will be so caught in its toils, that he will +not be able to escape its heat and flame, and will be constrained to +turn to God, and love Him in return. For, turn where he will, he +will always be met by the immeasurable benefits, the infinite +goodness, and the wonderful love of God; and at the same time he +will feel more and more compelled to return love for love, till he +will be no more able to resist it, and will be gently constrained to +follow." When this was done, Jesus Christ, this faithful and wise +Servant, said to His Lord and Father, "It is finished. I have +finished the work which Thou gavest Me to do. What more could I have +done, and have not done it? I have no member left that is not weary +and worn with toil and pain. My veins are dry, My blood is shed; My +marrow is spent, My throat is hoarse with crying. Such love have I +shown to man, that his heart cannot be human, cannot even be stony, +or the heart of a brute beast, but must be quite devilish and +desperate, if it be not moved by the thought of these things." + +Moreover, this word of our Lord Jesus is a word of sorrow, not of +joy. He spoke it not as if He had now escaped from all His +suffering. No; when He said, "It is finished," He meant all that had +been ordained and decreed by the eternal Truth for Him to suffer. +Besides, all the sufferings which had been inflicted upon Him by +degrees and singly, He now endures together with immeasurable +anguish. Who can have such a heart of adamant as not to be moved by +such torment as this? How short were the words which our Lord Jesus +spoke on the Cross, yet how full of sacramental mysteries! Now were +fulfilled the words of Exodus: "And all things were finished which +belonged to the sacrifice of the Lord." + +Moreover by this word our Lord declared the glorious victory of the +Passion, and how the old enemy, the jealous serpent, was overcome +and thrown down; for this was the cause for which He suffered. For +this He had taken upon Himself the garment of human nature, that He +might vanquish and confound the enemy, by the same weapons wherewith +the enemy boasted that he had conquered man. This was the chief +purpose of His Passion, and now He confesses that it is finished. O +how wonderful are the mysteries, and the victories, included in this +little but deep word: "It is finished!" All that the eternal Wisdom +had decreed, all that strict justice had demanded for each man, all +that love had asked for, all the promises made to the fathers, all +the mysteries, types, ceremonies in Scripture, all that was meet and +necessary for our redemption, all that was needed to wipe out our +debts, all that must repair our negligences, all that was glorious +and loving for the exhibition of this splendid love, all that we +could desire, for our spiritual instruction--in a word, all that was +good and fitting for the celebration of the glorious triumph of our +redemption, all is included in that one word, "It is finished." +What, then, remains for Him, but to finish and perfect His life in +this glorious conflict; and, because nothing remains for Him to do, +to commend His precious soul into His Father's hands, seeing that He +has fought the good fight, and finished His course in all holiness? +It is meet, then, that He should obtain the crown of glory which His +heavenly Father will give Him on the day of His exaltation. + +Lastly, by this word Christ offered up all His toil, sorrow, and +affliction for all the elect, as the Apostle saith: "Who in the days +of His flesh offered up prayer and supplications with strong crying +and tears unto Him who was able to save Him from death, and was +heard in that He feared. For if the blood of bulls and of goats and +the ashes of a heifer, sprinkling the unclean, sanctifieth to the +purifying of the flesh, how much more shall the blood of Christ, who +through the eternal Spirit offered Himself without spot to God, +purge our conscience from dead works to serve the living God?" + +THE SEVENTH WORD + +OUR Lord Jesus cried again with a loud voice, and said, "Father, +into Thy hands I commend My Spirit." O all ye who love our Lord +Jesus Christ, come, I beseech you, and let us watch, with all +devotion and pity, His passing away. Let us see what must have been +His sorrow and agony and torment, when His glorious soul was now at +last forced to pass out of His worthy and most sacred body, in which +for thirty and three years it had rested so sweetly, peacefully, +joyfully, and holily, even as two lovers on one bed. How hard was it +for them to be rent asunder, between whom no disagreement had ever +arisen, no strife, or quarrel, or treachery. How unspeakably +grievous was that Cross, when His sacred body was compelled to part +with so faithful a friend, so gentle an occupant, so loving a +teacher and master; and how great was the sorrow with which His +glorious and pure soul was torn away from so faithful a servant, +which had ever served obediently, never sparing any trouble, never +shrinking from cold or heat or hunger or thirst; always enduring +labour and sorrow in gentleness and patience. O how great was this +affliction! For, as the philosopher says: "Of all terrible things +death is the most terrible, on account of the natural and mutual +affection, which is very great, between soul and body." How much +greater must have been the anguish and sorrow, when the most holy +soul and body of Christ were sundered, between which there had +always been such wonderful harmony and love. Therefore, with inward +pity and anxious sorrow, let us meditate on this sad parting; for +the death of Christ is our life. + +Let us meditate devoutly how His sacred body, the instrument of our +salvation, was steeped in anguish, when all His members, as if to +bid a last farewell, were bowing themselves down to die! Who can +look without remorse and sorrow and pity upon the most gracious face +of Christ, and behold how it is changed into the pallor and likeness +of death; how tears still flow from His dimmed eyes; how His sacred +head is bent; how all His members prove to us, by signs and motions, +the love which they can no longer show by deeds. Let us pity Him, I +pray you, for He is our own flesh and blood, and it is for our sins, +not His own, that He is shamefully slain. O ye who up till now have +passed by the Cross of Jesus with tepid or cold hearts, and whom all +these torments and tears, and His blood shed like water, have not +been able to soften; now at last let this loud voice, this terrible +cry, rend and pierce your hearts through and through. Let that voice +which shook the heaven and the earth and hell with fear, which rent +the rocks and laid open ancient graves, now soften your stony +hearts, and lay bare the old sepulchres of your conscience, full of +dead men's bones--that is to say, of wicked deeds, and call again +into life your departed spirits. For this is the voice which once +cried: "Adam, where art thou; and what hast thou done?" This is the +voice which brought Lazarus from Hades, saying, "Lazarus, come +forth: arise from the grave of sin, and let them free thee from thy +grave-clothes." Truly it was not so much the grievousness of His +sufferings, as the greatness of our sins, which made our Lord utter +this cry. He cried also, to show that He had the dominion over life +and death, over the living and the dead. For though he was quite +worn out, and destitute of strength, and though He had borne the +bitter pangs of death so long, beyond the power of man, yet He would +not allow Death to put forth its power against Him, until it pleased +Him. + +With a loud voice He cried, that earthly men, who care only for the +things of earth, might quake with fear and trembling, and to cause +them to meditate and see how naked and helpless the Lord of lords +departed from this life. With a terrible voice He cried, to stir up +all those who live in wantonness, and who have grown old in their +defilement, and send forth a foul savour, like dead dogs, so that at +last these miserable men may rise from their lusts and pleasures and +sensual delights, and see how the Son of God, who was never strained +with any spot of defilement, went forth to His Father; and with what +toil and pain and anguish He departed from the light of day, and +what He had to suffer before He reached his Father's Kingdom. He +also cried with a loud voice, that He might inflame the lukewarm and +slothful to devotion and love. + +Moreover He cried with a loud voice as a sign of the glorious +victory which He had gained, when after a single combat with His +strong and cruel enemy, and having descended into the arena--the +battlefield of this world--He had routed him on Mount Calvary and +stripped him bare of his spoils. This victory, this glorious +triumph, Christ proclaimed with a loud voice, and thus departing +from the battlefield triumphant and victorious, He departed to the +place of all delights, to the heart and breast of God, His Father, +commending to it, as to a safe refuge, both Himself and all His own, +with the words, "Father, into Thy hands I commend My Spirit." + +We may learn from these words that the eternal Word, our Lord Jesus +Christ, had been let down like a fishing-hook or great net, by the +Father of heaven, into the great sea of this world, that He might +catch not fish but men. Hear how He says: "My word, that goeth forth +out of My mouth shall not return unto Me void, but shall execute +that which I please, and shall prosper in the thing whereto I send +it." And this net is drawn by the Father out of the salt sea, to the +peaceful shore of His fatherly heart, full of the elect, of works of +charity, of repentance, patience, humility, obedience, spiritual +exercises, merits and virtues. For Christ drew unto Himself all the +afflictions and good deeds of the good; just as St Paul says, "I +live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me." Even so, Christ lives in +all the good, and all who have been willing and obedient instruments +in the hands of Christ. In all such Christ lives and suffers and +works. For whatever good there is in all men, is all God's work. +Therefore Christ, feeling His Father drawing Him, gathered together +in Himself in a wonderful manner all the elect with all their works, +and commended them to His Father, saying, "My Father, these are +Thine; these are the spoils which I have won by My conquest, by the +sword of the Cross; these are the vessels which I have purchased +with My precious blood; these are the fruits of My labours. Keep in +Thine own name those whom Thou hast given Me. I pray not that Thou +shouldest take them out of the world, but that Thou shouldest keep +them from the evil." Thus did Christ commend Himself and all His own +into His Father's hands. Come therefore, O faithful and devout soul, +and contemplate with great earnestness the coming in and the going +out of thy Lord Jesus; follow Him with love and longing, even to the +chamber and bed of joy, which He has prepared for thee in thy +Father's heart. Happy would he be, who could now be dissolved with +Christ, and die with the thief, and hear from the lips of the Lord +that comfortable word, "This day shalt thou be with Me in paradise." +And though this is not granted to us, yet whatever we can here gain +by labours and watchings and fastings and prayers, let us commend it +all with Christ to the Father; let us pour it back again into the +fountain, whence it flowed forth for us; and let nothing be left in +us of empty self-satisfaction, no seeking after human praise or +honour or reward. But whatever our God hath been willing to do in +us, let us return it back into His own hands and say, "We are +nothing of ourselves. It is He who made us, and not we ourselves. +All good was made by Him, and without Him was not anything made. +When therefore He taketh with Him what He made Himself, we are +absolutely nothing." + +Lastly, Christ commended His soul into His Father's hands, to show +us how the souls of good and holy men mount up after Him to the +bosom of the eternal Father, who must otherwise have gone down to +hell; for it is He who has opened to us the way of life, and His +sacred soul, by making the journey safe and free from danger, has +been our guide into the kingdom of heaven. + + + + + + +SUSO + + + + + +SUSO AND HIS SPIRITUAL DAUGHTER + +AFTER this, certain very high thoughts arose in the mind of the +servitor's spiritual daughter, concerning which she asked him +whether she might put questions to him. He replied, Yea verily: +since thou hast been led through the proper exercises, it is +permitted to thy spiritual intelligence to enquire about high +things. Ask then whatever thou wilt. She said: Tell me, father, what +is God, and how He is both One and Three? The servitor replied, +These be indeed high questions. As to the first, What is God, you +must know that all the Doctors who ever lived cannot explain it, for +He is above all sense and reason. Yet if a man is diligent, and does +not relax his efforts, he gains some knowledge of God, though very +far off. Yet in this knowledge of God consists our eternal life and +man's supreme happiness. In this way, in former times, certain +worthy philosophers searched for God, and especially that great +thinker Aristotle, who tried to discover the Author of Nature from +the order of nature and its course. He sought earnestly, and he was +convinced from the well-ordered course of nature that there must of +necessity be one Prince and Lord of the whole universe--He whom we +call God. About this God and Lord we know this much, that He is an +immortal Substance, eternal, without before or after, simple, bare, +unchangeable, an incorporeal and essential Spirit, whose substance +is life and energy, whose most penetrating intelligence knows all +things in and by itself, whose essence in itself is an abyss of +pleasures and joys, and who is to Himself, and to all who shall +enjoy Him in a future life, a supernatural, ineffable, and most +sweet happiness. The maiden, when she heard this, looked up, and +said: These things are sweet to tell and sweet to hear, for they +rouse the heart, and lift the spirit up far beyond itself. +Therefore, father, tell me more about these things. The servitor +said: The Divine Essence, about which we speak, is an intelligible +or intellectual Substance of such a kind, that it cannot be seen in +itself by mortal eyes; but it can be discerned in its effects, even +as we recognise a fine artist by his works. As the Apostle teaches +us, "The invisible things of God from the creation of the world are +clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made." For the +creatures are a kind of mirror, in which God shines. This knowledge +is called speculation, by which we contemplate the great Architect +of the world in His works. Come now, look upward and about thee, +through all the quarters of the universe, and see how wide and high +the beautiful heaven is, how swift its motion, and how marvellously +its Creator has adorned it with the seven planets, and with the +countless multitude of the twinkling stars. Consider what +fruitfulness, what riches, the sun bestows upon the earth, when in +summer it sheds abroad its rays unclouded! See how the leaves and +grass shoot up, and the flowers smile, and the woods and plains +resound with the sweet song of nightingales and other birds; how all +the little animals, after being imprisoned by grim winter, come +forth rejoicing, and pair; and how men and women, both old and +young, rejoice and are merry. O Almighty God, if Thou art so lovable +and so pleasant in Thy creatures, how happy and blessed, how full of +all joy and beauty, must Thou be in Thyself? But further, my +daughter, contemplate the elements themselves--Earth, Water, Air, +and Fire, with all the wonderful things which they contain in +infinite variety--men, beasts, birds, fishes, and sea-monsters. And +all of these give praise and honour to the unfathomable immensity +that is in Thee. Who is it, Lord, who preserves all these things, +who nourishes them? It is Thou who providest for all, each in his +own way, for great and small, rich and poor. Thou, O God, doest +this; Thou alone art God indeed! Behold, my daughter, thou hast now +found the God whom thou hast sought so long. Look up, then, with +shining eyes, with radiant face and exulting heart, behold Him and +embrace Him with the outstretched arms of thy soul and mind, and +give thanks to Him as the one and supreme Lord of all creatures. By +gazing on this mirror, there springs up speedily, in one of loving +and pious disposition, an inward jubilation of the heart; for by +this is meant a joy which no tongue can tell, though it pours with +might through heart and soul. Alas, I now feel within me, that I +must open for thee the closed mouth of my soul; and I am compelled, +for the glory of God, to tell thee certain secrets, which I never +yet told to any one. A certain Dominican, well known to me, at the +beginning of his course used to receive from God twice every day, +morning and evening, for ten years, an outpouring of grace like +this, which lasted about as long as it would take to say the "Vigils +of the Dead" twice over.[40] At these times he was so entirely +absorbed in God, the eternal Wisdom, that he would not speak of it. +Sometimes he would converse with God as with a friend, not with the +mouth, but mentally; at other times he would utter piteous sighs to +Him; at other times he would weep copiously, or smile silently. He +often seemed to himself to be flying in the air, and swimming +between time and eternity in the depth of the Divine wonders, which +no man can fathom. And his heart became so full from this, that he +would sometimes lay his hand upon it as it beat heavily, saying, +"Alas, my heart, what labours will befall thee to-day?" One day it +seemed to him that the heart of his heavenly Father was, in a +spiritual and indescribable manner, pressed tenderly, and with +nothing between, against his heart; and that the Father's +heart--that is, the eternal Wisdom, spoke inwardly to his heart +without forms.[41] Then he began to exclaim joyously in spiritual +jubilation: Behold, now, Thou whom I most fervently love, thus do I +lay bare my heart to Thee, and in simplicity and nakedness of all +created things I embrace Thy formless Godhead! O God, most excellent +of all friends! Earthly friends must needs endure to be distinct and +separate from those whom they love; but Thou, O fathomless sweetness +of all true love, meltest into the heart of Thy beloved, and pourest +Thyself fully into the essence of his soul, that nothing of Thee +remains outside, but Thou art joined and united most lovingly with +Thy beloved. + +To this the maiden replied: Truly it is a great grace, when anyone +is thus caught up into God. But I should like to be informed, +whether this is the most perfect kind of union or not? The servitor +answered: No, it is not the most perfect, but a preliminary, gently +drawing a man on, that he may arrive at an essential way of being +carried up into God. The maiden asked him what he meant by essential +and non-essential. He answered: I call that man essential or +habitual (so to speak), who by the good and persevering practice of +all the virtues, has arrived at the point of finding the practice of +them in their highest perfection pleasant to him, even as the +brightness of the sun remains constant in the sun. But I call him +non-essential, in whom the brightness of the virtues shines in an +unstable and imperfect way like the brightness of the moon. That +full delight of grace which I described is so sweet to the spirit of +the non-essential man, that he would be glad always to have it. When +he has it, he rejoices; when he is deprived of it, he grieves +inordinately; and when it smiles upon him, he is reluctant to pass +to doing other things, even things that are pleasing to God; as I +will show you by an example. The servitor of the Divine Wisdom was +once walking in the chapter-house, and his heart was full of +heavenly jubilation, when the porter called him out to see a woman +who wished to confess to him. He was unwilling to interrupt his +inward delight, and received the porter harshly, bidding him tell +the woman that she must find some one else to confess to, for he did +not wish to hear her confession just then. She, however, being +oppressed with the burden of her sins, said that she felt specially +drawn to seek comfort from him, and that she would confess to no one +else. And when he still refused to go out, she began to weep most +sadly, and going into a corner, lamented greatly. Meanwhile, God +quickly withdrew from the servitor the delights of grace, and his +heart became as hard as flint. And when he desired to know the cause +of this, God answered him inwardly: Even as thou hast driven away +uncomforted that poor woman, so have I withdrawn from thee my Divine +comfort. The servitor groaned deeply and beat his breast, and +hurried to the door, and as he did not find the woman there, was +much distressed. The porter, however, looked about for her +everywhere, and when he found her, still weeping, bade her return to +the door. When she came, the servitor received her gently, and +comforted her sorrowing heart. Then he went back from her to the +chapter-house, and immediately God was with him, with His Divine +consolations, as before. + +Then said the maiden: It must be easy for him to bear sufferings, to +whom God gives such jubilation and internal joys. And yet, said the +servitor, all had to be paid for afterward with great suffering. +However, at last, when all this had passed away, and God's appointed +time had come, the same grace of jubilation was restored to him, and +remained with him almost continuously both at home and abroad, in +company and alone. Often in the bath or at table the same grace was +with him; but it was now internal, and did show itself outside. + +Then the maiden said: My father, I have now learned what God is; but +I am also eager to know where He is. Thou shalt hear, said the +servitor. The opinion of the theologians is that God is in no +particular place, but that He is everywhere, and all in all. The +same doctors say that we come to know a thing through its name. Now +one doctor says that Being is the first name of God. Turn your eyes, +therefore, to Being in its pure and naked simplicity, and take no +notice of this or that substance which can be torn asunder into +parts and separated; but consider Being in itself, unmixed with any +Not-Being. Whatever is nothing, is the negation of what is; and what +is, is the negation of what is not. A thing which has yet to be, or +which once was, is not now in actual being. Moreover, we cannot know +mixed being or not-being unless we take into account that which is +all-being. This Being is not the being of this or that creature; for +all particular being is mixed with something extraneous, whereby it +can receive something new into itself. Therefore the nameless Divine +Being must be in itself a Being that is all-being, and that sustains +all particular things by its presence. + +It shows the strange blindness of man's reason, that it cannot +examine into that which it contemplates before everything, and +without which it cannot perceive anything. Just as, when the eye is +bent on noticing various colours, it does not observe the light +which enables it to see all these objects, and even if it looks at +the light it does not observe it; so it is with the eye of the soul. +When it looks at this or that particular substance, it takes no heed +of the being, which is everywhere one, absolute and simple, and by +the virtue and goodness of which it can apprehend all other things. +Hence the wise Aristotle says, that the eye of our intelligence, +owing to its weakness, is affected towards that being which is +itself the most manifest of all things, as the eye of a bat or owl +is towards the bright rays of the sun. For particular substances +distract and dazzle the mind, so that it cannot behold the Divine +darkness, which is the clearest light. + +Come now, open the eyes of thy mind, and gaze if thou canst, on +Being in its naked and simple purity. You will perceive that it +comes from no one, and has no before nor after, and that it cannot +change, because it is simple Being. You will also observe that it is +the most actual, the most present, and the most perfect of beings, +with no defect or mutation, because it is absolutely one in its bare +simplicity. This is so evident to an instructed intellect, that it +cannot think otherwise. Since it is simple Being, it must be the +first of beings, and without beginning or end, and because it is the +first and everlasting and simple, it must be the most present. If +you can understand this, you will have been guided far into the +incomprehensible light of God's hidden truth. This pure and simple +Being is altogether in all things, and altogether outside all +things. Hence a certain doctor says: God is a circle, whose centre +is everywhere, and His circumference nowhere. + +When this had been said, the maiden answered: Blessed be God, I have +been shown, as far as may be, both what God is, and where He is. But +I should like also to be told how, if God is so absolutely simple, +He can also be threefold. + +The servitor answered: The more simple any being is in itself, the +more manifold is it in its energy and operation. That which has +nothing gives nothing, and that which has much can give much. I have +already spoken of the inflowing and overflowing fount of good which +God is in Himself. This infinite and superessential goodness +constrains Him not to keep it all within Himself, but to communicate +it freely both within and without Himself. But the highest and most +perfect outpouring of the good must be within itself, and this can +be nought else but a present, interior, personal and natural +outpouring, necessary, yet without compulsion, infinite and perfect. +Other communications, in temporal matters, draw their origin from +this eternal communication of the Divine Goodness. Some theologians +say that in the outflow of the creatures from their first origin +there is a return in a circle of the end to the beginning; for as +the emanation of the Persons from the Godhead is an image of the +origin of the creatures, so also it is a type of the flowing back of +the creatures into God. There is, however, a difference between the +outpouring of the creatures and that of God. The creature is only a +particular and partial substance, and its giving and communication +is also partial and limited. When a human father begets a son, he +gives him part, but not the whole, of his own substance, for he +himself is only a partial good. But the outpouring of God is of a +more interior and higher kind than the creature's outpouring, +inasmuch as He Himself is a higher good. If the outpouring of God is +to be worthy of His pre-eminent being, it must be according to +personal relations. + +Now, then, if you can look upon the pure goodness of the highest +Good (which goodness is, by its nature, the active principle of the +spontaneous love with which the highest Good loves itself) you will +behold the most excellent and superessential outpouring of the Word +from the Father, by which generation all things exist and are +produced; and you will see also in the highest good, and the highest +outpouring, the most holy Trinity, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, +existing in the Godhead. And if the highest outpouring proceeds from +the highest essential good, it follows that there must be in this +Trinity the highest and most intimate consubstantiality or community +of being, and complete equality and identity of essence, which the +Persons enjoy in sweetest communion, and also that the Substance and +power of the three almighty Persons is undivided and unpartitioned. + +Here the maiden exclaimed: Marvellous! I swim in the Godhead like an +eagle in the air. The servitor, resuming his exposition, continued: +It is impossible to express in words how the Trinity can subsist in +the unity of one essence. Nevertheless, to say what may be said on +the subject, Augustine says that in the Godhead the Father is the +Fountain-head of the Son and the Holy Ghost. Dionysius says, that in +the Father there is an outflowing of the Godhead, which naturally +communicates itself to the Word or Son. He also freely and lovingly +pours Himself out into the Son; and the Son in turn pours Himself +out freely and lovingly into the Father; and this love of the Father +for the Son, and of the Son for the Father, is the Holy Ghost. This +is truly said, but it is made clearer by that glorious Doctor of the +Church, St Thomas, who says as follows: In the outpouring of the +Word from the Father's heart, God the Father must contemplate +Himself with His own mind, bending back, as it were, upon His Divine +essence; for if the reason of the Father had not the Divine essence +for its object, the Word so conceived would be a creature instead of +God; which is false. But in the way described He is "God of God." +Again, this looking back upon the Divine essence, which takes place +in the mind of God, must, in a manner, produce a natural likeness; +else the Word would not be the Son of God. So here we have the unity +of essence in the diversity of Persons; and a clear proof of this +distinction may be found in the word of that soaring eagle St John: +"The Word was in the beginning with God." + +Thus the Father is the Fountain-head of the Son, and the Son is the +outflowing of the Father; and the Father and Son pour forth the +Spirit; and the Unity, which is the essence of the Fountain-head, is +also the substance of the three Persons. But as to how the Three are +One, this cannot be expressed in words, on account of the simplicity +of that Abyss. Into this intellectual Where, the spirits of men made +perfect soar and plunge themselves, now flying over infinite +heights, now swimming in unfathomed depths, marvelling at the high +and wonderful mysteries of the Godhead. Nevertheless, the spirit +remains a spirit, and retains its nature, while it enjoys the vision +of the Divine Persons, and abstracted from all occupation with +things below contemplates with fixed gaze those stupendous +mysteries. For what can be more marvellous than that simple Unity, +into which the Trinity of the Persons merges itself, and in which +all multiplicity ceases? For the outflowing of the Persons is always +tending back into the Unity of the same essence, and all creatures, +according to their ideal existence in God, are from eternity in this +Unity, and have their life, knowledge, and essence in the eternal +God; as it is said in the Gospel: "That which was made, was Life in +Him."[42] This bare Unity is a dark silence and tranquil inactivity, +which none can understand unless he is illuminated by the Unity +itself, unmixed with any evil. Out of this shines forth hidden +truth, free from all falsehood; and this truth is born from the +unveiling of the veiled Divine purity; for after the revelation of +these things, the spirit is at last unclothed of the dusky light +which up till now has followed it, and in which it has hitherto seen +things in an earthly way. Indeed, the spirit finds itself now +changed and something very different from what it supposed itself to +be according to its earlier light: even as St Paul says, "I, yet not +I." Thus it is unclothed and simplified in the simplicity of the +Divine essence, which shines upon all things in simple stillness. In +this modeless mode of contemplation, the permanent distinction of +the Persons, viewed as separate, is lost. For, as some teach, it is +not the Person of the Father, taken by Himself, which produces +bliss, nor the Person of the Son, taken by Himself, nor the Person +of the Holy Ghost, taken by Himself; but the three Persons, dwelling +together in the unity of the essence, confer bliss. And this is the +natural essence of the Persons, which by grace gives the substance +or essence to all their creatures, and it contains in itself the +ideas of all things in their simple essence. Now since this ideal +light subsists as Being, so all things subsist in it according to +their essential being, not according to their accidental forms; and +since it shines upon all things, its property is to subsist as +light. Hence all things shine forth in this essence in interior +stillness, without altering its simplicity. + +Then the maiden said: I could wish greatly, sir, that you could give +me this mysterious teaching, as you understand it, under a figure, +that I might understand it better. I should also be glad if you +could sum up what you have been saying at length, so that it may +stick more firmly in my weak mind. The servitor replied: Who can +express in forms what has no form? Who can explain that which has no +mode of being, and is above sense and reason? Any similitude must be +infinitely more unlike than like the reality. Nevertheless, that I +may drive out forms from your mind by forms, I will try to give you +a picture of these ideas which surpass all forms, and to sum up a +long discourse in a few words. A certain wise theologian says that +God, in regard to His Godhead, is like a vast circle, of which the +centre is everywhere, and the circumference nowhere. Now consider +the image which follows. If anyone throws a great stone into the +middle of a pool, a ring is formed in the water, and this ring makes +a second ring, and the second a third; and the number and size of +the rings depend on the force of the throw. They may even require a +larger space than the limit of the pool. Suppose now that the first +ring represents the omnipotent virtue of the Divine nature, which is +infinite in God the Father. This produces another ring like itself, +which is the Son. And the two produce the third, which is the Holy +Ghost. The spiritual superessential begetting of the Divine Word is +the cause of the creation of all spirits and all things. This +supreme Spirit has so ennobled man, as to shed upon him a ray from +His own eternal Godhead. This is the image of God in the mind, which +is itself eternal. But many men turn away from this dignity of their +nature, befouling the bright image of God in themselves, and turning +to the bodily pleasures of this world. They pursue them greedily and +devote themselves to them, till death unexpectedly stops them. But +he who is wise, turns himself and elevates himself, with the help of +the Divine spark in his soul, to that which is stable and eternal, +whence he had his own origin: he says farewell to all the fleeting +creatures, and clings to the eternal truth alone. + +Attend also to what I say about the order in which the spirit ought +to return to God. First of all, we should disentangle ourselves +absolutely from the pleasures of the world, manfully turning our +backs upon all vices; we should turn to God by continual prayers, by +seclusion, and holy exercise, that the flesh may thus be subdued to +the spirit. Next, we must offer ourselves willingly to endure all +the troubles which may come upon us, from God, or from the +creatures. Thirdly, we must impress upon ourselves the Passion of +Christ crucified; we must fix upon our minds His sweet teaching, His +most gentle conversation, His most pure life, which He gave us for +our example, and so we must penetrate deeper and advance further in +our imitation of Him. Fourthly, we must divest ourselves of external +occupations, and establish ourselves in a tranquil stillness of soul +by an energetic resignation, as if we were dead to self, and thought +only of the honour of Christ and His heavenly Father. Lastly, we +should be humble towards all men, whether friends or foes. . . . But +all these images, with their interpretations, are as unlike the +formless truth as a black Ethiopian is to the bright sun. + +Soon after this holy maiden died, and passed away happy from earth, +even as her whole life had been conspicuous only for her virtues. +After her death she appeared to her spiritual father in a vision. +She was clothed in raiment whiter than snow; she shone with dazzling +brightness, and was full of heavenly joy. She came near to him, and +showed him in what an excellent fashion she had passed away into the +simple Godhead. He saw and heard her with exceeding delight, and the +vision filled his soul with heavenly consolations. When he returned +to himself, he sighed most deeply, and thus pondered: O Almighty +God, how blessed is he, who strives after Thee alone! He may well be +content to bear affliction, whose sufferings Thou wilt thus reward! +May the Almighty God grant that we likewise may be brought to the +same joys as this blessed maiden! + +A MEDITATION ON THE PASSION OF CHRIST + +THEN said the Eternal Wisdom to the servitor, Attend and listen +dutifully, while I tell thee what sufferings I lovingly endured for +thy sake. + +After I had finished My last Supper with My disciples, when I had +offered Myself to My enemies on the mount, and had resigned Myself +to bear a terrible death, and knew that it was approaching very +near, so great was the oppression of My tender heart and all My +body, that I sweated blood; then I was wickedly arrested, bound, and +carried away. On the same night they treated Me with insult and +contumely, beating Me, spitting upon Me, and covering My head. +Before Caiaphas was I unjustly accused and condemned to death. What +misery it was to see My mother seized with unspeakable sorrow of +heart, from the time when she beheld Me threatened with such great +dangers, till the time when I was hung upon the cross. They brought +Me before Pilate with every kind of ignominy, they accused Me +falsely, they adjudged Me worthy of death. Before Herod I, the +Eternal Wisdom, was mocked in a bright robe. My fair body was +miserably torn and rent by cruel scourgings. They surrounded My +sacred head with a crown of thorns; My gracious face was covered +with blood and spittings. When they had thus condemned Me to death, +they led Me out with My cross to bear the last shameful punishment. +Their terrible and savage cries could be heard afar off: "Crucify, +crucify, the wicked man." + +Servitor. Alas, Lord, if so bitter were the beginnings of Thy +passion, what will be the end thereof? In truth, if I saw a brute +beast so treated in my presence I could hardly bear it. What grief +then should I feel in heart and soul at Thy Passion? And yet there +is one thing at which I marvel greatly. For I long, O my most dear +God, to know only Thy Godhead; and Thou tellest me of Thy humanity. +I long to taste Thy sweetness, and Thou showest me Thy bitterness. +What meaneth this, O my Lord God? + +Wisdom. No man can come to the height of My Godhead, nor attain to +that unknown sweetness, unless he be first led through the +bitterness of My humanity. My humanity is the road by which men must +travel. My Passion is the gate, through which they must enter. Away +then with thy cowardice of heart, and come to Me prepared for a hard +campaign. For it is not right for the servant to live softly and +delicately, while his Lord is fighting bravely. Come, I will now put +on thee My own armour. And so thou must thyself also experience the +whole of My Passion, so far as thy strength permits. Take, +therefore, the heart of a man; for be sure that thou wilt have to +endure many deaths, before thou canst put thy nature under the yoke. +I will sprinkle thy garden of spices with red flowers. Many are the +afflictions which will come upon thee; till thou hast finished thy +sad journey of bearing the cross, and hast renounced thine own will +and disengaged thyself so completely from all creatures, in all +things, which might hinder thine eternal salvation, as to be like +one about to die, and no longer mixed up with the affairs of this +life. + +Servitor. Hard and grievous to bear are the things which Thou +sayest, Lord. I tremble all over. How can I bear all these things? +Suffer me, O Lord, to ask Thee something. Couldst Thou not devise +any other way of saving my soul, and of testifying Thy love towards +me, so as to spare Thyself such hard sufferings, and so that I need +not suffer so bitterly with Thee? + +Wisdom. The unfathomable Abyss of My secret counsels no man ought to +seek to penetrate, for no one can comprehend it. And yet that which +thou hast suggested, and many other things, might have been +possible, which nevertheless never happen. Be assured, however, that +as created things now are, no more fitting method could be found. +The Author of Nature doth not think so much what He is able to do in +the world, as what is most fitting for every creature; and this is +the principle of His operations. And by what other means could the +secrets of God have been made known to man, than by the assumption +of humanity by Christ? By what other means could he who had deprived +himself of joy by the inordinate pursuit of pleasure, be brought +back more fittingly to the joys of eternity? And who would be +willing to tread the path, avoided by all, of a hard and despised +life, if God had not trodden it Himself? If thou wert condemned to +death, how could any one show his love and fidelity to thee more +convincingly, or provoke thee to love him in return more powerfully, +than by taking thy sentence upon himself? If, then, there is any one +who is not roused and moved to love Me from his heart by My immense +love, My infinite pity, My exalted divinity, My pure humanity, My +brotherly fidelity, My sweet friendship, is there anything that +could soften that stony heart? + +Servitor. The light begins to dawn upon me, and I seem to myself to +see clearly that it is as Thou sayest, and that whoever is not +altogether blind must admit that this is the best and most fitting +of all ways. And yet the imitation of Thee is grievous to a slothful +and corruptible body. + +Wisdom. Shrink not because thou must follow the footsteps of My +Passion. For he who loves God, and is inwardly united to Him, finds +the cross itself light and easy to bear, and has nought to complain +of. No one receives from Me more marvellous sweetness, than he who +shares My bitterest labours. He only complains of the bitterness of +the rind, who has not tasted the sweetness of the kernel. He who +relies on Me as his protector and helper may be considered to have +accomplished a large part of his task. + +Servitor. Lord, by these consoling words I am so much encouraged, +that I seem to myself to be able to do and suffer all things through +Thee. I pray Thee, then, that Thou wilt unfold the treasure of Thy +Passion to me more fully. + +Wisdom. When I was hung aloft and fastened to the wood of the cross +(which I bore for My great love to thee and all mankind), all the +wonted appearance of My body was piteously changed. My bright eyes +lost their light; My sacred ears were filled with mocking and +blasphemy; My sweet mouth was hurt by the bitter drink. Nowhere was +there any rest or refreshment for Me. My sacred head hung down in +pain; My fair neck was cruelly bruised; My shining face was +disfigured by festering wounds; My fresh colour was turned to +pallor. In a word, the beauty of My whole body was so marred, that I +appeared like a leper--I, the Divine Wisdom, who am fairer than the +sun. + +Servitor. O brightest mirror of grace, which the Angels desire to +look into, in which they delight to fix their gaze, would that I +might behold Thy beloved countenance in the throes of death just +long enough to water it with the tears of my heart, and to satisfy +my mind with lamentations over it. + +Wisdom. No one more truly testifies his grief over My Passion, than +he who in very deed passes through it with Me. Far more pleasing to +Me is a heart disentangled from the love of all transitory things, +and earnestly intent on gaining the highest perfection according to +the example which I have set before him in My life, than one which +continually weeps over My Passion, shedding as many tears as all the +raindrops that ever fell. For this was what I most desired and +looked for in My endurance of that cruel death--namely, that mankind +might imitate Me; and yet pious tears are very dear to Me. + +Servitor. Since then, O most gracious God, the imitation of Thy most +gentle life and most loving Passion is so pleasing to Thee, I will +henceforth labour more diligently to follow Thy Passion than to weep +over it. But since both are pleasing to Thee, teach me, I pray Thee, +how I ought to conform myself to Thy Passion. + +Wisdom. Forbid thyself the pleasure of curious and lax seeing and +hearing; let love make sweet to thee those things which formerly +thou shrankest from; eschew bodily pleasures; rest in Me alone; bear +sweetly and moderately the ills that come from others; desire to +despise thyself; break thy appetites; crush out all thy pleasures +and desires. These are the first elements in the school of Wisdom, +which are read in the volume of the book of My crucified body. But +consider whether anyone, do what he may, can make himself for My +sake such as I made Myself for his. + +Servitor. Come then, my soul, collect thyself from all external +things, into the tranquil silence of the inner man. Woe is me! My +heavenly Father had adopted my soul to be His bride; but I fled far +from Him. Alas, I have lost my Father, I have lost my Lover. Alas, +alas, and woe is me! What have I done, what have I lost? Shame on +me, I have lost myself, and all the society of my heavenly country. +All that could delight and cheer me has utterly forsaken me; I am +left naked. My false lovers were only deceivers. They have stripped +me of all the good things which my one true Lover gave me; they have +despoiled me of all honour, joy, and consolation. O ye red roses and +white lilies, behold me a vile weed, and see also how soon those +flowers wither and die, which this world plucks. And yet, O most +gracious God, none of my sufferings are of any account, compared +with this, that I have grieved the eyes of my heavenly Father. This +is indeed hell, and a cross more intolerable than all other pain. O +heart of mine, harder than flint or adamant, why dost thou not break +for grief? Once I was called the bride of the eternal King, now I +deserve not to be called the meanest of his handmaids. Never again +shall I dare to raise mine eyes, for shame. O that I could hide +myself in some vast forest, with none to see or hear me, till I had +wept to my heart's desire. O Sin, Sin, whither hast thou brought me? +O deceitful World, woe to those who serve thee! Now I have thy +reward, I receive thy wages--namely, that I am a burden to myself +and the whole world, and always shall be. + +Wisdom. Thou must by no means despair; it was for thy sins and those +of others that I came into this world, that I might restore thee to +Thy heavenly Father, and bring thee back to greater glory and honour +than thou ever hadst before. + +Servitor. Ah, what is this, which whispers such flattering things to +a soul that is dead, abhorred, rejected? + +Wisdom. Dost thou not know Me? Why art thou so despondent? Art thou +beside thyself with excessive grief, My dearest son? Knowest thou +not that I am Wisdom, most gentle and tender, in whom is the Abyss +of infinite mercy, never yet explored perfectly even by all the +saints, but none the less open to thee and all other sorrowing +hearts. I am he who for thy sake willed to be poor and an exile, +that I might recall thee to thy former honour. I am He who bore a +bitter death, that I might restore thee to life. I am thy Brother; I +am thy Bridegroom. I have put away all the wrong that thou ever +didst against Me, even as if it had never been, only henceforth, +thou must turn wholly to Me, and never again forsake Me. Wash away +thy stains in My blood. Lift up thy head, open thine eyes, and take +heart. In token of reconciliation, take this ring and put it on thy +finger as My bride, put on this robe, and these shoes on thy feet, +and receive this sweet and loving name, that thou mayst both be and +be called for ever My bride. Thou has cost Me much labour and pain; +for that cause, the Abyss of My mercy toward thee is unfathomable. + +Servitor. O kindest Father, O sweetest Brother, O only joy of my +heart, wilt Thou be so favourable to my unworthy soul? What is this +grace? What is the Abyss of Thy clemency and mercy? From the bottom +of my heart I thank Thee, O heavenly Father, and beseech Thee by Thy +beloved Son, whom Thou hast willed to suffer a cruel death for love, +to forget my impieties. . . . + +Now, O Lord, I remember that most loving word, wherewith in the book +of Ecclesiasticus[43] Thou drawest us to Thyself. "Come to me, all +ye who desire me, and be filled with my fruits. I am the mother of +beautiful affection. My breath is sweeter than honey, and my +inheritance above honey and the honeycomb." "Wine and music rejoice +the heart, and above both is the love of Wisdom."[44] Of a surety, O +Lord, Thou showest Thyself so lovable and desirable, that it is no +wonder that the hearts of all long for Thee, and are tormented by +the desire of Thee. Thy words breathe love, and flow so sweetly, +that in many hearts the love of temporal things has wholly dried up. +Therefore, I greatly long to hear Thee speak of Thy lovableness. +Come, O Lord, my only comfort, speak to the heart of Thy servant. +For I sleep sweetly beneath Thy shadow, and my heart is awake. + +Wisdom. Hear, My son, and see; incline thine ear, forgetting thyself +and all other things. Lo, I in Myself am that ineffable Good, which +is and ever was; which has never been expressed nor ever will be. +For although I give Myself to be felt by men in their inmost hearts, +yet no tongue can ever declare or explain in words what I am. For +verily all the beauty, grace, and adornment which can be conceived +by thee or by others, exists in me far more excellently, more +pleasantly, more copiously, than any one could say in words. I am +the most loving Word of the Father, begotten from the pure substance +of the Father, and wondrously pleasing am I to His loving eyes in +the sweet and burning love of the Holy Spirit. I am the throne of +happiness, the crown of souls: most bright are Mine eyes, most +delicate My mouth, My cheeks are red and white, and all My +appearance is full of grace and loveliness. All the heavenly host +gaze upon Me with wonder and admiration; their eyes are ever fixed +upon Me, their hearts rest in Me, their minds turn to Me and turn +again. O thrice and four times happy is he, to whom it shall be +given to celebrate this play of love amid heavenly joys at My side, +holding My tender hands in happiest security, for ever and ever to +all eternity. Only the word that proceeds out of My sweet mouth +surpasses the melodies of all the angels, the sweet harmony of all +harps, and musical instruments of every kind.... + +Servitor. There are three things, O Lord, at which I marvel greatly. +The first is, that although Thou art in Thyself so exceedingly +loving, yet towards sin Thou art a most severe judge and avenger. +Alas, Thy face in wrath is too terrible; the words which Thou +speakest in anger pierce the heart and soul like fire. O holy and +adorable God, save me from Thy wrathful countenance, and defer not +till the future life my punishment. + +Wisdom. I am the unchangeable Good, remaining always the same. The +reason why I do not appear always the same, is on account of those +who do not behold Me in the same way. By nature I am friendly; yet +none the less I punish vice severely, so that I deserve to be +feared. From My friends I require a pure and filial fear, and a +friendly love, that fear may ever restrain them from sin, and that +love may join them to Me in unbroken loyalty. + +Servitor. What Thou sayest pleases me, O Lord, and it is as I would +have it. But there is another thing at which I greatly marvel--how +it is that when the soul is faint from desire of the sweetness of +Thy presence, Thou art wholly mute, and dost not utter a single word +that can be heard. And who, O Lord, would not be grieved, when Thou +showest Thyself so strange, so silent, to the soul that loves Thee +above all things? + +Wisdom. And yet all the creatures speak of Me. + +Servitor. But that is by no means enough for the soul that loves. + +Wisdom. Also every word that is uttered about Me is a message of My +love; all the voices of holy Scripture that are written about Me are +letters of love, sweet as honey. They are to be received as if I had +written them Myself. Ought not this to satisfy thee? + +Servitor. Nay but, O most holy God, dearest Friend of all to me, +Thou knowest well that a heart which is on fire with love is not +satisfied with anything that is not the Beloved himself, in whom is +its only comfort. Even though all the tongues of all the angelic +spirits were to speak to me, none the less would my unquenchable +love continue to yearn and strive for the one thing which it +desires. The soul that loves Thee would choose Thee rather than the +kingdom of heaven. Pardon me, O Lord: it would become Thee to show +more kindness to those who love Thee so ardently, who sigh and look +up to Thee and say: Return, return! Who anxiously debate with +themselves: alas, thinkest thou that thou hast offended Him? That He +has deserted thee? Thinkest thou that He will ever restore thee His +most sweet presence, that thou wilt ever again embrace Him with the +arms of Thy heart, and press Him to thy breast, that all thy grief +and trouble may vanish? All this, O Lord, Thou hearest and knowest, +and yet Thou art silent. + +Wisdom. Certainly I know all this, and I watch it with great +pleasure. But I would have thee also answer a few questions, since +thy wonder, though veiled, is so great. What is it which gives the +greatest joy to the highest of all created spirits? + + Servitor. Ah, Lord, this question is beyond my range. I prithee, +answer it Thyself. + +Wisdom. I will do as thou desirest. The highest angelic spirit finds +nothing more desirable or more delightful than to satisfy My will in +all things; so much so, that if he knew that it would redound to My +praise for him to root out nettles and tares, he would diligently +fulfil this task in preference to all others. + +Servitor. Of a truth, Lord, this answer of Thine touches me sharply. +I perceive that it is Thy will that I should be resigned in the +matter of receiving and feeling tokens of Thy love, and that I +should seek Thy glory alone, in dryness and hardness as well as in +sweetness. + +Wisdom. No resignation is more perfect or more excellent, than to be +resigned in dereliction. + + Servitor. And yet, O Lord, the pain is very grievous. + +Wisdom. Wherein is virtue proved, if not in adversity? But be +assured, that I often come, and try whether the door into My house +is open, but find Myself repulsed. Many times I am received like a +stranger, harshly treated, and then driven out of doors. Nay, I not +only come to the soul that loves me, but tarry with her like a +friend; but that is done so secretly, that none know it save those +who live quite detached and separated from men, and observe My ways, +and care only to please and satisfy My grace. For according to My +Divinity I am purest Spirit, and I am received spiritually in pure +spirits. + +Servitor. So far as I understand, Lord God, Thou art a very secret +Lover. How glad would I be if Thou wouldest give me some signs, by +which I might know Thee to be truly present. + +Wisdom. By no other way canst thou know the certainty of My presence +better, than when I hide Myself from thee, and withdraw what is Mine +from thy soul. Then at last thou knowest by experience what I am, +and what thou art. Of a surety I am everlasting Good, without whom +no one can have anything good. When therefore I impart that immense +Good, which is Myself, generously and lovingly, and scatter it +abroad, all things to which I communicate Myself are clothed with a +certain goodness, by which My presence can be as easily inferred, as +that of the Sun, the actual ball of which cannot be seen, by its +rays. If therefore thou ever feelest My presence, enter into +thyself, and learn how to separate the roses from the thorns, the +flowers from the weeds. + +Servitor. Lord, I do search, and I find within myself a great +diversity. When I am deserted by Thee, my soul is like a sick man, +whose taste is spoiled. Nothing pleases me, but all things disgust +me. My body is torpid, my mind oppressed; within is dryness, without +is sadness. All that I see or hear, however good in reality, is +distasteful and hateful to me. I am easily led into sins; I am weak +to resist my enemies; I am cold or lukewarm towards all good. +Whoever comes to me, finds my house empty. For the House-Father is +away, who knows how to counsel for the best, and to inspire the +whole household. On the other hand, when the day-star arises in my +inmost heart, all the pain quickly vanishes, all the darkness is +dispelled, and a great brightness arises and shines forth. My heart +laughs, my mind is exalted, my soul becomes cheerful, all things +around me are blithe and merry; whatever is around me and within me +is turned to Thy praise. That which before seemed hard, difficult, +irksome, impossible, becomes suddenly easy and pleasant. To give +myself to fasting, watching, and prayer, to suffer or abstain or +avoid, in a word all the hardnesses of life seem when compared with +Thy presence to have no irksomeness at all. My soul is bathed in +radiance, truth, and sweetness, so that all its labours are +forgotten. My heart delights itself in abundant sweet meditations, +my tongue learns to speak of high things, my body is brisk and ready +for any undertaking; whoever comes to ask my advice, takes back with +him high counsels such as he desired to hear. In short, I seem to +myself to have transcended the limits of time and space, and to be +standing on the threshold of eternal bliss. But who, O Lord, can +secure for me, that I may be long in this state? Alas, in a moment +it is withdrawn from me; and for a long space again I am left as +naked and destitute as if I had never experienced anything of the +kind; till at last, after many and deep sighings of heart, it is +restored to me. Is this Thou, O Lord, or rather I myself? Or what is +it? + +Wisdom. Of thyself thou hast nothing except faults and defects. +Therefore that about which thou askest is I Myself, and this is the +play of love. + +Servitor. What is the play of love? + +Wisdom. So long as the loved one is present with the lover, the +lover knoweth not how dear the loved one is to him; it is only +separation which can teach him that. + +Servitor. It is a very grievous game. But tell me, Lord, are there +any who in this life no longer experience these vicissitudes of Thy +presence? + +Wisdom. You will find very few indeed. For never to be deprived of +My presence belongs not to temporal but to eternal life. + +APHORISMS AND MAXIMS + +ACT according to the truth in simplicity; and, whatever happens, do +not help thyself; for he who helps himself too much will not be +helped by the Truth. + +God wishes not to deprive us of pleasure; but He wishes to give us +pleasure in its totality--that is, all pleasure. + +Wilt thou be of use to all creatures? Then turn thyself away from +all creatures. + +If a man cannot comprehend a thing, let him remain quiet, and it +will comprehend him. + +Say to the creatures, I will not be to thee what thou art to me. + +The power of abstaining from things gives us more power than the +possession of them would. + +Some men one meets who have been inwardly drawn by God, but have not +followed Him. The inner man and the outer man in these cases are +widely at variance, and in this way many fail. + +He who has attained to the purgation of his senses in God performs +all the operations of the senses all the better. + +He who finds the inward in the outward goes deeper than he who only +finds the inward in the inward. + +He is on the right road who contemplates under the forms of things +their eternal essence. + +It is well with a man who has died to self and begun to live in +Christ. + + + + + + +RUYSBROEK + +THE ADORNMENT OF THE SPIRITUAL NUPTIALS + +BOOK I + + + + + +PREFACE + +"SEE the Bridegroom cometh: go forth to meet Him." St Matthew the +evangelist wrote these words, and Christ said them to His disciples +and to all men, in the Parable of the Ten Virgins. The Bridegroom is +our Lord Jesus Christ, and human nature is the bride, whom God has +made in His own image and likeness. He placed her at first in the +most exalted, the most beautiful, the richest and most fertile place +on earth--in paradise. He subjected to her all the creatures; He +adorned her with graces; and He laid a prohibition upon her, in +order that by obedience she might deserve to be established in an +eternal union with her Bridegroom, and never more fall into any +affliction, trouble, or guilt. Then came a deceiver--the infernal, +envious foe, under the guise of a cunning serpent. He deceived the +woman, and the two together deceived the man, who possessed the +essence of human nature. So the enemy despoiled human nature, the +bride of God, by his deceitful counsels, and she was driven into a +strange country; poor and miserable, a prisoner and oppressed, +persecuted by her enemies, as if she could never more return to her +country and the grace of reconciliation. But when God saw that the +time was come, and took pity on the sufferings of His beloved, He +sent His only Son to earth, in a rich abode and a glorious +temple--that is to say, in the body of the Virgin Mary. There he +married His bride, our nature, and united it to His Person, by means +of the pure blood of the noble Virgin. The priest who joined the +Bride and Bridegroom was the Holy Spirit; the angel Gabriel +announced the marriage, and the blessed Virgin gave her consent. So +Christ, our faithful Bridegroom, united our nature to His, and +visited us in a strange land, and taught us the manners of heaven +and perfect fidelity. And He laboured and fought like a champion +against our enemy, and He broke the prison and gained the victory, +and His death slew our death, and His blood delivered us, and He set +us free in baptism under the life-giving waters, and enriched us by +His sacraments and gifts, that we might go forth, as He said, +adorned with all virtues, and might meet Him in the abode of His +glory, to enjoy Him throughout all eternity. + +Now the Master of truth, Christ, saith: "See, the Bridegroom +cometh, go forth to meet Him." In these words Jesus, our Lover, +teaches us four things. In the first word He gives a command, for He +says, "See." Those who remain blind, and those who resist this +command are condemned without exception. In the next word He shows +us what we shall see--that is to say, the coming of the Bridegroom, +when He says, "The Bridegroom cometh." In the third place, He +teaches us and commands us what we ought to do, when He says, "Go +forth." In the fourth place, when He says, "to meet Him," He shows +us the reward of all our works and of all our life, for that must be +a loving "going forth," by which we meet our Bridegroom. + +We shall explain and analyse these words in three ways, first, +according to the ordinary mode of the beginner's life--that is to +say, the active life, which is necessary to all who would be saved. +In the second place, we shall analyse these words by applying them +to the inner life, exalted and loving, to which many men arrive by +the virtues and by the grace of God. Thirdly, we shall explain them +by applying them to the superessential and contemplative life, to +which few attain and which few can taste, because of the supreme +sublimity of this life. + +ON THE ACTIVE LIFE + +CHRIST, the Wisdom of the Father, hath said from the time of Adam +and still saith (inwardly, according to His Divinity), to all men, +"See"; and this vision is necessary. Now let us observe attentively +that for him who wishes to see materially or spiritually, three +things are necessary. First, in order that a man may be able to see +materially, he must have the external light of heaven, or another +natural light, in order that the medium--that is to say, the air +across which one sees, may be illuminated. In the second place, he +must have the will, that the things which he will see may be +reflected in his eyes. Thirdly, he must have the instruments, his +eyes, healthy and without flaw, that the material objects may be +exactly reflected in them. If a man lacks any one of these three +things, his material vision disappears. We shall speak no more of +this vision, but of another, spiritual and supernatural, wherein all +our blessedness resides. + +Three things are necessary for spiritual and supernatural vision. +First, the light of the divine grace, then the free conversion of +the will towards God, and lastly, a conscience pure from all mortal +sin. Now observe: God being a God common to all, and His boundless +love being common to all, He grants a double grace; both antecedent +grace, and the grace by which one merits eternal life. All men, +heathens and Jews, good and bad, have in common antecedent grace. In +consequence of the common love of God towards all men, He has caused +to be preached and published His name and the deliverance of human +nature, even to the ends of the earth. He who wishes to be converted +can be converted. For God wishes to save all men and to lose none. +At the day of judgment none will be able to complain that enough was +not done for him, if he had wished to be converted. So God is a +common Light and Splendour which illumine heaven and earth, and men +according to their merits and their needs. But though God is common, +and though the sun shines on all trees, some trees remain without +fruit, and others bear wild fruit useless to mankind. This is why we +prune these trees and graft fertile branches upon them, that they +may bear good fruit, sweet to taste and useful for men. The fertile +branch which comes from the living paradise of the eternal kingdom, +is the light of divine grace. No work can have savour, or be useful +to man, unless it comes from this branch. This branch of divine +grace, which makes man acceptable and by which we merit eternal +life, is offered to all. But it is not grafted on all, for they will +not purge away the wild branches of their trees--that is to say, +unbelief or a perverse will, or disobedience to the commandments of +God. But in order that this branch of divine grace may be planted in +our soul, three things are necessary; the antecedent grace of God, +the conversion of our free will, and the purification of the +conscience. Antecedent grace touches all men; but all men do not +attain to free conversion and purification of the conscience, and +this is why the grace of God, by which they might merit eternal +life, fails to touch them. The antecedent grace of God touches man +from within or from without. From without, by sickness or loss of +outward goods, of relations and friends, or by public shame; or +perhaps a man is moved by preaching, or by the examples of saints +and just men, by their words or works, till he comes to the +knowledge of himself. This is how God touches us from without. +Sometimes also a man is touched from within, by recalling the pains +and sufferings of our Lord, and the good which God has done to him +and to all men, or by the consideration of his sins, of the +shortness of life, of the eternal pains of hell and the eternal joys +of heaven, or because God has spared him in his sins and has waited +for his conversion; or he observes the marvellous works of God in +heaven, on earth, and in all creation. These are the works of +antecedent divine grace, which touch man from within or from +without, and in divers manners. And man has still a natural +inclination towards God, proceeding from the spark of his soul or +synteresis, [Footnote: See Introduction] and from the highest +reason, which always desires the good and hates the evil. Now, in +these three manners God touches every man according to his needs, so +that the man is struck, warned, frightened, and stops to consider +himself. All this is still antecedent grace and not merited; it thus +prepares us to receive the other grace, by which we merit eternal +life; when the mind is thus empty of bad wishes and bad deeds, +warned, struck, in fear of what it ought to do, and considers God, +and considers itself with its evil deeds. Thence come a natural +sorrow for sin and a natural good will. This is the highest work of +antecedent grace. + +When man does what he can, and can go no further because of his +weakness, it is the infinite goodness of God which must finish this +work. Then comes a higher splendour of the grace of God, like a ray +of the sun, and it is poured upon the soul, though it is as yet +neither merited nor desired. In this light God gives Himself, by +free will and by bounty, and no one can merit it before he has it. +And it is in the soul an internal and mysterious operation of God, +above time, and it moves the soul and all its faculties. Here then +ends antecedent grace; and here begins the other--that is to say, +supernatural light. + +This light is the first necessary condition, and from it is born a +second spiritual condition--that is to say, a free conversion of the +will in a moment of time, and then love is born in the union of God +and the soul. These two conditions are connected, so that one cannot +be accomplished without the other. There, where God and the soul are +united in the unity of love, God grants His light above time, and +the sou! freely turns to God by the force of grace, in a moment of +time, and charity is born in the soul, from God and the soul, for +charity is a bond of love between God and the loving soul. From +these two things, the grace of God, and the free conversion of the +will illuminated by grace, is born charity--that is to say, divine +love. And from divine love proceeds the third point, the +purification of the conscience. And this is accomplished in the +consideration of sin and of the flaws in the soul, and because man +loves God, there enters into him a contempt for self and for all his +works. This is the order of conversion. From it are born a true +repentance and a perfect sorrow for the evil that we have done, and +an ardent desire to sin no more and to serve God henceforward in +humble obedience; from it are born a sincere confession, without +reserves, without duplicity and without pretences, the desire to +satisfy God and to undertake the practice of all the virtues and all +good works. These three things, as you have just heard, are +necessary for divine vision. If you possess them, Christ says to +you, "See," and you become really seeing. This is the first of the +four chief ways in which Christ, our Lord, says "See." + +ON THE FIRST COMING OF CHRIST, IN THE FLESH + +NEXT, He shows us what we shall see when He says, "The Bridegroom +cometh." Christ, our Bridegroom, says this word in Latin: Venit. +The word expresses two tenses, the past and the present, and yet +here it indicates the future. And this is why we must consider three +comings of our Bridegroom Jesus Christ. At His first coming He was +made man for love of man. The second coming is daily and frequent in +every loving soul, with new graces and new gifts, as man is able to +receive them. In the third coming, He will come manifestly on the +dreadful day of judgment or at the hour of each man's death. In all +these comings we must observe three things, the cause, the interior +mode, and the external work. + +The cause of the creation of angels and men is the infinite goodness +and nobleness of God; He wished that the wealth and blessedness, +which are Himself, should be revealed to reasonable creatures, for +them to enjoy in time, and in eternity above time. The reason why +God became man, is His inconceivable love, and the distress of all +men, lost since the fall in original sin, and unable to raise +themselves again. But the reason why Christ, according to His +divinity and His humanity, accomplished His works on earth, is +fourfold--namely, His divine love, which is without measure; the +created love, which is called charity, and which He had in His soul +by the union of the Eternal Word and the perfect gift of His Father; +the great distress of human nature; and the glory of His Father. +These are the reasons for the coming of Christ, our Bridegroom, and +for all His works, exterior and interior. + +Now we must observe in Jesus Christ, if we wish to follow Him in His +virtues according to our powers, the mode or condition which He had +within, and the works which He wrought without, for they are virtues +and the acts of virtues. + +The mode which He had according to His divinity is inaccessible and +incomprehensible to us, for it is after this mode that He is +continually born of the Father, and that the Father in Him and by +Him knows and creates and orders, and rules everything in heaven and +on earth; for He is the Wisdom of the Father, and from them flows +spiritually a Spirit--that is to say, a love, which is the bond +between them and the bond of all the saints and just persons on +earth and in heaven. We will speak no more of this mode but of the +created mode which He had by these divine gifts and according to His +humanity. These modes are singularly multiform; for Christ had as +many modes as He had interior virtues, for each virtue has its +special mode. These virtues and these modes were, in the mind of +Christ, above the intelligence and above the comprehension of all +creatures. But let us take three--namely, humility, charity, and +interior or exterior suffering in patience. These are the three +principal roots and origins of all virtues and all perfection. + +ON THE TWOFOLD HUMILITY OF CHRIST + +NOW understand: there are two kinds of humility in Jesus Christ, +according to His divinity. First, He willed to become man; and this +nature, which was accursed even to the depth of hell, He accepted +according to His personality and was willing to unite Himself to it. +So that every man, good or bad, may say, Jesus Christ, the Son of +God, is my brother. Secondly, He chose for mother a poor virgin, and +not a king's daughter, so that this poor virgin became the mother of +God, who is the only Lord of heaven and earth and all creatures. In +consequence, of all the works of humility which Christ ever +accomplished, one may say that God accomplished them. Now let us +take the humility which was in Jesus Christ according to His +humanity and by grace and divine gifts; according to His humility +His soul inclined with all its power in respect and veneration +before the power of the Father. For an inclined heart is a humble +heart. This is why He did all His works to the praise and glory of +the Father, and sought in nothing His own glory according to His +humanity. He was humble, and submitted to the old law, and to the +commandments, and often to the customs. He was circumcised, and +carried to the Temple, and redeemed according to usages, and He paid +taxes to Caesar like other Jews. And He submitted Himself humbly to +His mother and to Joseph, and served them with a sincere deference +according to their needs. He chose for friends--for apostles--the poor +and the despised, in order to convert the world. In his intercourse +with them and all others He was humble and modest. This is why He +was at the disposal of all men, in whatever distress they were, +within or without; He was, as it were, the servant of the whole +world. This is what we find first in Jesus Christ, our Bridegroom. + +ON THE LOVE OF CHRIST, ADORNED WITH ALL VIRTUES + +NEXT comes charity, the beginning and source of all virtues. This +charity maintained the supreme forces of His soul in tranquillity, +and in the enjoyment of the same blessedness which He enjoys at +present. And this same charity kept Him continually exalted towards +His Father, with veneration, love, praise, respect, with internal +prayers for the need of all men, and with the offering of all His +works to the glory of God the Father. And this same charity made +Christ still overflow with love and kindness towards all the +material or spiritual needs of mankind. This is why He has given, by +His life, the model after which all men should fashion their lives. +He has given spiritual nourishment to all well-disposed men by real +internal teachings, as well as by outward miracles. We cannot +comprehend His charity to its full extent, for it flowed from the +unfathomable fountains of the Holy Spirit, above all the creatures +who have ever received charity, for He was God and man in one +Person. This is the second point of charity. + +ON THE PATIENCE OF CHRIST, EVEN UNTO DEATH + +THE third point is to suffer in patience. We will examine this +seriously, for it is this which adorned Christ, our Bridegroom, +during all His life. He suffered when He was newly born, from +poverty and cold. He was circumcised and shed his blood. He was +obliged to fly into a foreign country. He served Joseph and His +mother, He suffered from hunger and thirst, from shame and contempt +and from the wicked words and deeds of the Jews. He fasted, He +watched, and was tempted by the enemy. He was subject to all men, He +went from district to district, from town to town, to preach the +gospel painfully and zealously. Finally, He was taken by the Jews, +who were His enemies and whom He loved. He was betrayed, mocked, +insulted, scourged, struck, and condemned on false testimony. He +carried His cross with great pain to the mount of Calvary. He was +stripped naked as at His birth, and never was seen a body so +beautiful, nor a mother so unhappy. He endured shame, pain, and cold +before all the world, for He was naked, and it was cold, and He was +exhausted by His wounds. He was nailed with large nails to the wood +of the cross, and was so strained that His veins were burst. He was +lifted up and shaken upon the cross, so as to make His wounds bleed, +His head was crowned with thorns, and His ears heard the fierce Jews +crying out, "Crucify Him! crucify Him!" and many other shameful +words. His eyes saw the obstinacy and wickedness of the Jews, and +the distress of His mother, and His eyes were extinguished under the +bitterness of pain and death. His mouth and palate were hurt by the +vinegar and gall, and all the sensitive parts of His body wounded by +the scourge. + +Behold then Christ, our Bridegroom, wounded to death, abandoned by +God and the creatures, dying on the cross, hanging from a post, with +no one to care much for Him except Mary, His unhappy mother, who +nevertheless could not aid Him. And Christ suffered moreover +spiritually, in His soul, from the hardness of the Jews' hearts and +those who made Him die, for in spite of the prodigies and miracles +which they saw, they remained in their wickedness; and He suffered +by reason of their corruption and the vengeance which God was about +to inflict upon them, in body and soul, for His death. He suffered +moreover for the grief and misery of His mother and disciples, who +were in great sadness. And He suffered because His death would be +wasted for many men, and for the ingratitude of many, and for the +blasphemies of those who would curse Him who died for love of us. +And His nature and interior reason suffered because God withdrew +from them the inflow of His gifts and consolations, and abandoned +them to themselves in such distress. Therefore Christ complained and +said, My God, my God, why hast Thou forsaken me? + +Behold then the interior virtues of Christ; humility, charity, and +suffering in patience. These three virtues Jesus, our Bridegroom, +practised throughout His life, and He died in them, and He paid our +debt by satisfying justice, and opened His side in His bounty. And +thence flow rivers of delight, and sacraments of blessedness. And He +was exalted to His power, and sat at the right hand of the Father, +and reigns eternally. This is the first coming of our Bridegroom, +and it is completely past. + +ON THE SECOND COMING OF CHRIST, HOW HE EVERY DAY FLOWS INTO OUR +HEARTS WITH NEW GRACE + +THE second coming of Christ, our Bridegroom, takes place every day +in just men. We do not wish to speak here of the first conversion of +man, nor of the first grace which was given him when he was +converted from sin to virtue. But we wish to speak of a daily +increase of new gifts and new virtues, and of a more actual coming +of Christ, our Bridegroom, into our soul. Now we must observe the +cause, the mode, and the work, of this coming. The cause is fourfold; +the mercy of God, our misery, the divine generosity, and our +desire. These four causes make the virtues grow and increase. + +Now understand. When the sun sends forth its bright rays into a deep +valley between two high mountains, and while it is at the zenith, so +that it can illuminate the depths of the valley, a triple phenomenon +occurs; for the valley is lighted from the mountains, and it becomes +warmer and more fertile than the plain. In the same way, when a just +man sinks in his misery, and recognises that he has nothing, and is +nothing, that he can neither halt nor go forward by his own +strength; and when he perceives also that he fails often in virtues +and good works, he thus confesses his poverty and distress, and +forms the valley of humility. And because he is humble and in need, +and because he confesses his need, he makes his plaint to the +kindness and mercy of God. He is conscious of the sublimity of God, +and of his own abasement. + +Thus he becomes a deep valley. And Christ is the sun of justice and +mercy, which burns at the meridian of the firmament--that is to say, +at the right hand of the Father, and shines even to the bottom of +humble hearts; for Christ is always moved by distress, when man +humbly offers to Him complaints and prayers. Then the two mountains +rise--that is to say, a double desire, in the first place a desire to +serve and love God by his merits, in the second place to obtain +excellent virtues. These two desires are higher than heaven, for +they touch God without any intermediary, and desire His immense +generosity. Then that generosity cannot be kept back, it must flow, +for the soul is at this moment susceptible of receiving countless +boons. + +These are the causes of the second coming of Christ, with new +virtues. Then the valley--that is to say, the humble heart, receives +three things. It is enlightened the more, and illuminated by grace, +and warmed by charity, and becomes more fertile in virtues and good +works. Thus you have the cause, the mode, and the work, of this +coming. + +HOW WE MAY MAKE DAILY PROGRESS BY THE SACRAMENTS OF THE CHURCH + +THERE is yet another coming of Christ, our Bridegroom, which takes +place every day, in the growth of grace and in new gifts--that is to +say, when a man receives some sacrament with a humble and +well-prepared heart. He receives then new gifts and more ample +graces, by reason of his humility, and by the internal and secret +work of Christ in the sacrament. That which is contrary to the +sacrament is in baptism the want of faith, in confession the want of +contrition; it is to go to the sacrament of the altar in a state of +mortal sin, or of bad will; and it is the same with the other +sacraments. + +ON THE THIRD COMING OF CHRIST, TO JUDGMENT + +THE third coming, which is still future, will take place at the last +judgment or at the hour of death. Christ, our Bridegroom and our +Judge at this judgment, will recompense and avenge according to +justice, for He will award to each according to his deserts. He +gives to every just man, for every good work done in the spirit of +the Lord, a reward without measure, which no creature can merit-- +namely, Himself. But as He co-operates in the creature, the creature +deserves, through His merit, to have a reward. And by a necessary +justice He gives eternal pains to those who have rejected an eternal +good for a perishable. + +ON THE THIRD SPIRITUAL GOING FORTH, TO ALL THE VIRTUES + +NOW understand and observe. Christ says at the beginning of our +text, "See"--that is to say, see by charity and pureness of +conscience, as you have been told. Now, He has shown us what we +shall see--namely, His three comings. + +He orders us what we must do next, and says, "Go forth" if you have +fulfilled the first necessary condition--that is to say, if you see +in grace and in charity, and if you have well observed your model, +Christ, in His "going forth"; there leaps up in you, from your love +and loving observation of your Bridegroom, an ardour of justice-- +that is to say, a desire to follow Him in virtue. Then Christ says +in you, "Go forth." This going forth must have three modes. We must +go forth towards God, towards ourselves, and towards our neighbour +by charity and justice; for charity always pushes upward, towards +the kingdom of God, which is God Himself; for He is the source from +which it flowed without any intermediary, and He remains always +immanent in it. The justice which is born of charity wishes to +perfect the manners and the virtues which are suitable to the +kingdom of God--that is to say, to the soul. These two things, +charity and justice, establish a solid foundation in the kingdom of +the soul where God may dwell, and this foundation is humility. These +three virtues support all the weight and all the edifice of all the +virtues and all sublimity; for charity maintains man in presence of +the unfathomable good things of God from whence it flows, so that it +perseveres in God, and increases in all the virtues and in true +humility; and justice maintains man in presence of the eternal truth +of God, so that truth may be discovered by him, and that he may be +illuminated, and may accomplish all the virtues without error. But +humility maintains man always before the supreme power of God, so +that he remains always abased and little, and abandons himself to +God, and holds no longer by himself. This is the way in which a man +must bear himself before God, that he may grow alway in new virtues. + +HOW HUMILITY IS THE FOUNDATION OF ALL THE VIRTUES + +NOW understand; for having made humility the base of everything, we +must speak first of it. Humility is the desire of abasement or of +depth--that is to say, an inclination or internal desire for +abasement of heart and conscience before the sublimity of God. The +justice of God exacts this submission, and, thanks to charity, the +loving heart cannot abandon it. When the loving and humble man +considers that God has served him so humbly, so lovingly, and so +faithfully, and then that God is so high, so powerful, and so noble, +and that man is so poor, little, and base, there is born from all +this, in the humble heart, an immense respect and reverence towards +God; for to reverence God in all works, within and without, is the +first and most delightful work of humility, the sweetest work of +charity, and the most suitable work of justice. For the humble and +loving heart cannot pay honours to God and His noble humanity, nor +abase himself so deeply as to satisfy his desire. That is why it +seems to the humble man that he always does too little in honour of +God and in his humble service. And he is humble, and venerates Holy +Church and the sacraments, and he is temperate in meat and drink, in +his words, and in all relations of life. He is content with poor +raiment, with menial employment, and his face is naturally humble, +without pretence. And he is hunible in his practices, within and +without, before God and before men, that none may be offended by +reason of him. Thus he tames and removes far from him all pride, +which is the cause and origin of all sins. Humility breaks the +snares of sin, the world, and the Devil. And man is ordered within +himself, and established in the very place of virtue. Heaven is open +to him, and God is inclined to hear his prayer, and he is loaded +with graces. And Christ, the solid stone, is his support, and he who +builds his virtues upon humility cannot go wrong. + +ON OBEDIENCE + +FROM this humility is born obedience, for only the humble man can be +inwardly obedient. Obedience is a submission and pliant disposition, +and a good will ready for all that is good. Obedience subjects a man +to orders, to prohibitions, and to the will of God, and it subjects +the soul and sensual force to the highest reason, in such a way that +the man lives suitably and reasonably. And it makes men submissive +and obedient to Holy Church and to the sacraments, and to all the +good practices of holy Christianity. It prepares man, and makes him +ready for the service of all, in works, in bodily and spiritual +care, according to the needs of each, and prudence. Also, it drives +far away disobedience, which is the daughter of pride, and which we +ought to flee from more than from poison. Obedience in will and work +adorns, extends, and manifests the humility of man. It gives peace +to cloisters, and if it exists in the prelate, as it ought to exist, +it attracts those who are under his orders. It maintains peace and +equality among equals. And he who observes it is beloved by those +who are above him, and the gifts of God, which are eternal, elevate +and enrich him. + +ON THE ABDICATION OF OUR OWN WILL + +FROM this obedience is born the abdication of our own will. By this +abdication the substance and occasion of pride are repulsed, and the +greatest humility is accomplished. And God rules the man as He +wills; and the will of the man is so well united to that of God that +he can neither wish nor desire anything otherwise. He has put off +the old man, and has put on the new man, renewed and perfect +according to the divine will. It is of such an one that Christ said, +"Blessed are the poor in spirit," that is, those who have renounced +their will--"for theirs is the kingdom of heaven." + +ON PATIENCE + +FROM the abandonment of the will is born patience; for no one can +be perfectly patient in everything, except he who has submitted his +will to the will of God, and to all men in things useful and +convenient. Patience is a tranquil endurance of all that can happen +to a man, whether sent by God or by men. Nothing can trouble the +patient man, neither the loss of earthly goods, nor the loss of +friends or relations, nor sickness, nor disgrace, nor life, nor +death, nor purgatory, nor the devil, nor hell. For he has abandoned +himself to the will of God in true love. And, provided that mortal +sin does not touch him, all that God orders for him in time or +eternity seems light. This patience adorns a man, and arms him +against anger and sudden rage, and against impatience of suffering, +which often deceives a man within and without, and exposes him to +manifold temptations. + +ON GENTLENESS + +FROM this patience are born gentleness and kindness, for no one can +be gentle under adversity if not the patient man. Gentleness creates +in man peace and repose from everything; for the gentle man endures +insulting words and gestures, and bad faces and bad deeds, and all +manner of injustice towards his friends and himself, and he is +content with all, for gentleness is suffering in repose. Thanks to +gentleness, the force of anger remains immovable in its +tranquillity, the force of desire lifts itself up towards the +virtues, and the reason rejoices, and the conscience dwells in +peace, for the other mortal sins, such as anger and rage, are +removed far from her. For the Spirit of God reposes in a gentle and +humble heart, as Christ saith, "Blessed are the meek, for they shall +inherit the earth"--that is to say, their own nature and the things +of earth in meekness, and, after this life, the things of eternity. + +ON KINDNESS + +FROM the same source as gentleness comes kindness, for the gentle +spirit alone can possess kindness. This kindness causes a man to +oppose a loving face and friendly words, and all the works of pity, +to those who are angry with him, and he hopes that they will return +to themselves and amend. Thanks to mercy and kindness, charity +remains lively and fruitful in a man; for the heart full of kindness +is like a lamp full of precious oil; and the oil of kindness +lightens the wandering sinner by its good example, and soothes and +heals by consoling words and deeds those whose heart is wounded, +saddened, or irritated. And it inflames and illumines those who are +in charity, and no jealousy or envy can touch it. + +ON COMPASSION + +FROM kindness is born compassion, by which we sympathise with every +one, for no one can suffer with all men, except he who has kindness. +Compassion is an inward movement of the heart, aroused by pity for +the bodily or spiritual distress of all men. This compassion makes a +man partaker in Christ's sufferings, when he considers the reason of +these sufferings, the resignation and love of Christ, His wounds, +His tortures, His shame, His nobleness, His misery, the shame which +He endured, the crown, the nails, and the death in patience. These +unheard of and manifold pains of Christ, our Redeemer and +Bridegroom, move to pity anyone who is capable of feeling pity. +Compassion makes a man observe and note his faults, his want of +power to do any good thing, and weakness in all that pertains to the +glory of God; his lukewarmness and slowness, the multitude of his +faults, the waste of his time, and his positive shortcomings in +virtue and good conduct. All this makes a man truly sorry for +himself. Then his compassion for himself makes him consider his +errors and wanderings, the small care which he has of God and of his +eternal salvation, his ingratitude for all the good that God has +done him, and for all that He has suffered for man. And he considers +also that he is a stranger to the virtues, that he neither knows +them nor practises them, while he is clever and crafty in all that +is bad and unjust; he sees how attentive he is to the loss or gain +of worldly goods, how inattentive and indifferent towards God, the +things of eternity, and his own salvation. This consideration makes +the just man feel a great compassion towards the salvation of all +men. The man will also observe with pity the bodily needs of his +neighbour and the manifold pains of nature, when he sees the hunger +which men suffer, the thirst, cold, nakedness, poverty, contempt, +and oppression; the sadness which they feel at the loss of +relations, friends, goods, honour, and repose; and the innumerable +afflictions to which flesh is heir. All this rouses the just man to +compassion, and he suffers with all men; but his greatest suffering +arises when he sees the impatience of others under their own +sufferings, by which they lose their reward and often deserve hell. +This is the work of compassion and pity. + +This work of compassion and love for all men overcomes and removes +the third mortal sin--namely, hatred and envy; for compassion is a +wound of the heart, which makes us love all men, and can only work +healing in so far as some suffering lives in men; for God has +ordained that mourning and pain must precede all the other virtues. +This is why Christ said, "Blessed are they that mourn, for they +shall be comforted"--that is to say, when they shall reap in joy what +they now sow in compassion and sorrow. + +ON GENEROSITY + +FROM this compassion is born generosity, for no one can be +supernaturally generous, with faith in all men, and with love, +except the merciful man; though one many give to a particular +individual without charity, and without supernatural generosity. + +Generosity is the copious outflow of a heart moved with charity and +pity. When a man considers with compassion the sufferings and pains +of Christ, from this compassion is born generosity, which excites us +to praise and thank Christ for His pains and for His love, at the +same time that it causes to be born in us respect and veneration, +and a joyous and humble submission of heart and soul, in time and in +eternity. When a man observes and pities himself, and considers the +good that God has done to him and his own weakness, he cannot help +flowing out into the liberality of God, taking refuge in His pity +and fidelity, and abandoning himself to God, with a free and perfect +wish to serve Him for ever. The generous man, who observes the +errors, the wanderings, and the injustice of men, desires and +implores the outflow of the divine gifts and the exercise of their +generosity on all men, that they may return to themselves and be +converted to the truth. The generous man considers also with +compassion the material needs of all men; he helps them, gives, +lends, consoles to the best of his power. By means of this +generosity, men practise the seven works of mercy, the rich by their +services and the bestowal of their goods, the poor by good will and +the desire to do good if they can, and thus the virtue of generosity +is perfected. Generosity in the depth of the heart multiplies all +the virtues, and illuminates the forces of the soul. For the +generous, man is always of joyful spirit, he is without anxiety; he +is full of sympathy, and is ready to do kindnesses to all men in the +works of virtue. He who is generous, and loves not the things of +earth, however poor he may be, is like unto God, for all that he +has, and all the thoughts of his heart flow out of him in largess. +And so he is delivered from the fourth of the deadly sins, avarice. +Jesus Christ saith to these: "Blessed are the merciful, for they +shall obtain mercy"; in the day when they shall hear this word +spoken unto them: "Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the +kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world." + +ON ZEAL AND DILIGENCE + +FROM this generosity are born supernatural zeal and diligence in all +the virtues. None can exhibit this zeal, save the generous and +diligent man. This is an internal and eager impulse towards all the +virtues, and towards the imitation of Christ and the saints. In this +zeal, a man desires to expend in the honour of God the united powers +of his heart and senses, his soul and body, all that he is, and all +that he may receive. This zeal makes a man watchful in reason and +discrimination, and makes him practise the virtues in justice. +Thanks to this supernatural zeal, all the forces of his soul are +open to God, and prepared for all the virtues. His conscience is +refreshed, and divine grace is increased, virtue is practised with +joy, and his external works are adorned. He who has received this +lively zeal from God is removed far from the fifth deadly +sin--lukewarmness and gloominess towards the virtues necessary for +salvation. [Footnote: The best account in English of the deadly sin +of acedia, too much neglected in modern religious teaching, is to be +found in Bishop Paget's Spirit of Discipline.] And sometimes this +lively zeal disperses heaviness and sluggishness of the bodily +temperament. It is on this subject that Jesus Christ says: "Blessed +are they who hunger and thirst after righteousness, for they shall +be filled." This will be, when the glory of God shall be manifested, +and shall fill every man in proportion to his love and justice. + +ON TEMPERANCE AND SOBRIETY + +FROM zeal are born temperance and sobriety within and without; for +none can maintain true moderation in sobriety, if he is not +thoroughly diligent and zealous to preserve his body and soul in +justice. Sobriety separates the higher faculties from the animal +faculties, and preserves a man from excesses. Sobriety wishes not to +taste nor know those things which are not permitted. + +The incomprehensible and sublime nature of God surpasses all the +creatures in heaven and earth, for whatever the creature conceives +is creature. But God is above every creature, and within and without +every creature, and all created comprehension is too strait to +comprehend Him. In order that the creature may conceive and +comprehend God, it must be drawn up into God from above; it is only +by God that it can comprehend God. Those then who wish to know what +God is, and to study Him, let them know that it is forbidden. They +would become mad. All created light must fail here. What God is, +passes the comprehension of every creature. But Holy Scripture, +nature, and all the creatures show us that He is. We shall believe +the articles of faith without trying to penetrate them, for that is +impossible while we are here: this is sobriety. The difficult and +subtle teachings of the inspired writings we shall only explain in +accordance with the life of Christ and His saints. Man will study +nature and the Scriptures, and every creature; and will seek to +learn from them only what may be to his own advantage. This is +sobriety of spirit. + +A man will maintain sobriety of the senses, and he will subdue by +reason his animal faculties, that the animal pleasure in food and +drink may not delight him too much, but that he may eat and drink as +a sick man takes a potion, because it is his duty to preserve his +strength for the service of God. This is sobriety of body. A man +will preserve moderation in words and actions, in silence and +speech, in eating and drinking, in what he does and abstains from +doing, as Holy Church enjoins and the saints give the example. + +By moderation and sobriety of spirit within, a man maintains +constancy and perseverance in the faith, that purity of intelligence +and calmness of reason which are necessary to understand the truth, +readiness to bend to the will of God with regard to every virtue, +peace of heart and serenity of conscience. Thanks to this virtue, he +possesses assured peace in God and in himself. + +By moderation and sobriety in the use of the bodily faculties, he +often preserves health and contentment of the bodily nature, his +honour in external relations, and his good name. And thus he is at +peace with himself and with his neighbour. For he attracts and +rejoices all men of good will, by his moderation and sobriety. And +he escapes the sixth deadly sin, which is want of temperance, and +gluttony. It is of this that Christ said: "Blessed are the +peacemakers, for they shall be called the children of God." For +being like unto the Son, who has made peace in all creatures who +desire it, and who make peace in their turn, by moderation and +sobriety, the Son will divide among them the heritage of His Father, +and they will possess this heritage with Him throughout eternity. + +ON PURITY + +FROM this sobriety are born purity of soul and body, for none can be +absolutely pure in body and soul, save he who follows after sobriety +in body and soul. Purity of spirit consists in this--that a man +cleaves to no creature with any passionate desire, but attaches +himself to God only; for one may use all the creatures while +rejoicing in God only. Purity of spirit makes a man attach himself +to God above intelligence and above the senses, and above all the +gifts which God may bestow upon the soul; for all that the creature +receives in its intelligence or in its senses purity desires to +transcend, and to repose in God only. We should approach the +sacrament of the altar not for the sake of the delights, the +pleasure, the peace, or the sweetness which we find there, but for +the glory of God only, and that we may grow in all the virtues. This +is purity of spirit. + +Purity of heart signifies that a man turns towards God without +hesitation in every bodily temptation and every disturbance of +nature, in the freedom of his will abandoning himself to Him with a +new confidence and a firm resolve to abide always with God. For to +consent to sin, or to the animal desires of the bodily nature, is a +separation from God. + +Purity of body means that a man abstains from impure actions of +every kind, when his conscience assures him that they are impure and +contrary to the commandments, to the glory, and to the will of God. + +Thanks to these three kinds of purity, the seventh deadly sin, that +of wantonness, is conquered and driven away. Wantonness is a +voluptuous inclination of the spirit, leading away from God towards +a created thing; it is the impure act of the flesh outside what +Holy Church permits, and the carnal occupation of the heart in some +taste or desire for a creature. I do not here refer to those sudden +stirrings of love or desire which none can escape. + +You now know that purity of spirit preserves men in the likeness of +God, without care for the creatures, inclined towards God and united +to Him. The chastity of the body is compared to the whiteness of the +lily and to the purity of the angels. In its resistance to +temptation, it is compared to the redness of the rose, and to the +nobility of the martyrs. If it is preserved for love of God and in +His honour, it is then perfect, and it is compared to the +heliotrope, for it is one of the highest adornments of nature. + +Purity of heart renews and increases the grace of God. In purity of +heart all the virtues are inspired, practised, and preserved. It +keeps and preserves the outer senses, it subdues and binds the +animal desires within, and it is the ornament of all the inner life. +It is the exclusion of the heart from things of earth and from all +lies, and its inclusion among the things of heaven and all truth. +And this is why Christ has said: "Blessed are the pure in heart, for +they shall see God." This is the vision in which consists our +eternal joy, and all our reward, and our entrance into bliss. This +is why a man will be sober and moderate in everything, and will keep +himself from every occasion which might tarnish the purity of his +soul and body. + +ON THE THREE ENEMIES WHO ARE TO BE CONQUERED BY JUSTICE + +IF we wish to possess this virtue and to repulse these enemies, we +must have justice, and we must practise it, and preserve it even +until our death, in purity of heart, for we have three powerful +enemies who try to attack us at all times, in all states, and in +many different ways. If we make our peace with any one of them and +follow him, we are vanquished, for they are in league with each +other in all wickedness and injustice. These three enemies are the +devil, the world, and our own flesh, which is the nearest to us, and +is often the worst and most mischievous of our foes. For our animal +desires are the weapons with which our enemies fight against us. +Idleness, and indifference to virtue and the glory of God are the +cause and occasion of war and combat. But the weakness of our +natures, our negligence and ignorance of truth are the sword by +which our enemies wound us and sometimes conquer us. + +And this is why we must be divided in ourselves. The lower part of +ourselves, which is animal and contrary to the virtues, we ought to +hate and persecute and cause it to suffer by means of penitence and +austerities, so that it may be always crushed down and submissive to +reason, and that justice, with purity of heart, may always keep the +upper hand in all virtuous actions. And all the pains, sorrows, and +persecutions which God makes us suffer at the hands of those who are +enemies to virtue, we shall endure with joy, in honour of God and +for the glory of virtue, and in the hope of obtaining and possessing +justice in purity of heart; for Christ said: "Blessed are those who +are persecuted for righteousness' sake, for theirs is the kingdom of +heaven." For righteousness preserved in virtue and in virtuous +actions is a coin of the same weight and value as the kingdom of +heaven, and it is by it that we may purchase and obtain eternal +life. By these virtues a man goes forth towards God and towards +himself, in good conduct, virtue, and justice. + +ON THE KINGDOM OF THE SOUL + +HE who wishes to obtain and preserve these virtues, will adorn, +occupy, and order his soul like a kingdom. Free will is the king of +the soul. It is free by nature, and more free still by grace. It +will be crowned with a crown or diadem named Charity. We shall +receive this crown and this kingdom from the Emperor, who is the +Lord, the sovereign and king of kings, and we shall possess, rule, +and preserve this kingdom in His name. This king, free will, will +dwell in the highest town in the kingdom--that is to say, in the +concupiscent faculty of the soul. He will be adorned and clad with a +robe in two parts. The right side of his robe will be a virtue +called strength, that he may be strong and powerful to overcome all +obstacles and sojourn in the heaven, in the palace of the supreme +Emperor, and to bend with love and ardent self-surrender his crowned +head before the supreme monarch. This is the proper work of charity. +By it we receive the crown, by it we adorn the crown, and by it we +keep and possess the kingdom throughout eternity. The left side of +the robe will be a cardinal virtue, called moral courage. Thanks to +it, free will, the king, will subdue all immorality, will accomplish +all virtue, and will have the power to keep his kingdom even until +death. The king will choose councillors in his country, the wisest +in the land. They will be two divine virtues, knowledge and +discretion, illuminated by divine grace. They will dwell near the +king, in a palace called the reasonable force of the soul. They will +be crowned and adorned with a moral virtue called temperance, that +the king may always act and refrain from acting according to their +advice. By knowledge we shall purge our conscience from all its +faults and adorn it with all virtues; and, thanks to discretion, we +shall give and take, do and not do, speak and be silent, fast and +eat, listen and answer, and act in all ways according to knowledge +and discretion clad in their moral virtue, which is called +temperance or moderation. + +This king, free will, will also establish in his kingdom a judge, +who will be justice, which is a divine virtue when it is born from +love. And it is one of the highest moral virtues. This judge will +dwell in the conscience, in the middle of the kingdom in the +irascible faculty. And he will be adorned with a moral virtue called +prudence. For justice without prudence cannot be perfect. This +judge, justice, will traverse the kingdom with royal powers, +accompanied by wise counsel and his own prudence. He will promote +and dismiss, he will judge and condemn, will condemn to death and +acquit, will mutilate, blind, and restore to sight, will exalt and +abase and organise, will punish and chastise according to justice, +and will destroy all vices. The people of the kingdom--that is to +say, all the faculties of the soul, will be supported by humility +and the fear of God, submitting to Him in all the virtues, each +after its own manner. He who has thus occupied, preserved, and +ordered the kingdom of his soul, has gone forth, by love and the +virtues, towards God, towards himself, and towards his neighbour. +This is the third of the four principal points which Christ speaks +of when He says, Go forth. + +ON THE THREEFOLD MEETING OF THE SOUL + +WHEN a man has, by the grace of God, eyes to see, and a pure +conscience, and when he has considered the three comings of Christ, +our Bridegroom, and lastly when he has gone forth by the virtues, +then takes place the meeting with our Bridegroom, and this is the +fourth and last point. In this meeting consist all our blessedness, +and the beginning and the end of all the virtues, and without this +meeting no virtue can be practised. + +He who wishes to meet Christ as his well-beloved Bridegroom, and to +possess in Him and with Him eternal life, must meet Christ, now in +time, in three points or in three manners. First, he must love God +in everything wherein we shall merit eternal life. Secondly, he must +attach himself to nothing which he might love as much as or more +than God. Thirdly, he must repose in God with all his might, above +all creatures and above all the gifts of God, and above all acts of +virtue and above all the sensible graces which God might spread +abroad in his soul and body. + +Now understand: he who has God for his end must have Him present to +himself, by some divine reason. That is to say, he must have in view +Him who is the Lord of heaven, and of earth, and of every creature, +Him who died for him, and who can and will give him eternal +salvation. In whatever mode and under whatever name he represents +God, as Lord of every creature, it is well. If he takes some divine +Person, and in Him sees the essence and power of the divine nature, +it is well. If he regards God as saviour, redeemer, creator, +governor, as blessedness, power, wisdom, truth, goodness, it is +well. Though the names which we ascribe to God are numerous, the +sublime nature of God is simple and unnameable by the creatures. But +we give Him all these names by reason of His nobleness and +incomprehensible sublimity, and because we cannot name or proclaim +Him completely. See now under what mode and by what knowledge God +will be present to our intention. For to have God for our aim is to +see spiritually. To this quest belong also affection and love, for +to know God and be without love aids and advances us not a whit, and +has no savour. This is why a man, in all his actions, must bend +lovingly towards God, whom he seeks and loves above everything. +This, then, is the meeting with God by means of intention and love. + +In order that the sinner may turn from his sins in a meritorious +penitence, he must meet God by contrition, free conversion, and a +sincere intention to serve God for ever, and to sin no more. Then, +at this meeting, he receives from the mercy of God the assured hope +of eternal salvation and the pardon of his sins, and he receives the +foundation of all the virtues, faith, hope, and charity, and the +good will to practise all the virtues. If this man advances in the +light of faith, and observes all the works of Christ, all His +sufferings and all His promises, and all that He has done for us and +will do to the day of judgment and through eternity; if he examines +all this for his soul's health, he must needs meet with Christ; and +Christ must needs be present to his soul, so grateful and full of +thankfulness. So his faith is fortified, and he is impelled more +inwardly and powerfully towards all the virtues. If he still +progresses in the works of virtue, he must again meet with Christ, +by the annihilation of self. Let him not seek his own things; let +him set before him no extraneous ends; let him be discreet in his +actions; let him set God always before him, and the praise and glory +of God; and let him so continue till his death; then his reason +will be enlightened and his charity increased, and he will become +more pious and apt for all the virtues. We shall set God before us +in every good work; in bad works we cannot set Him before us. We +shall not have two intentions--that is to say, we shall not seek God +at the same time as something else, but all our intention must be +subordinated to God and not contrary to Him, but of one and the same +kind, so that it may help us and give us an impulse which may lead +us more easily to God. Then and then only is a man in the right +road. Moreover, we shall rest rather upon Him who is our aim and our +goal and the object of our love, than upon the messengers whom He +sends us--that is to say, His gifts. The soul will rest constantly +upon God, above all the adornments and presents which His messengers +may bring. The messengers sent by the soul are intention, love, and +desire. They carry to God all our good works and virtues. Above all +these, the soul will rest on God, its Beloved, above all +multiplicity. This is the manner in which we shall meet Christ all +through our life, in all our actions and virtues, by right +intention, that we may meet Him at the hour of our death in the +light of glory. + +This mode, as you have learnt, is called the active life. It is +necessary to all men; or at least they must not live in a manner +contrary to any virtue, though they may not attain the degree of +perfection in all the virtues which I have described. For to live +contrary to the virtues is to live in sin, as Christ has said: "He +that is not with me is against me." He who is not humble is proud, +and he who is proud belongs not to God. We must always possess a +virtue and be in a state of grace, or possess what is contrary to +that virtue and be in a state of sin. May every man examine and +prove himself, and order his life as I have here described. + +ON THE DESIRE TO KNOW GOD AS HE IS, IN THE NATURE OF HIS GODHEAD + +THE man who thus lives, in this perfection, as I have here described +it, and who devotes all his life and actions to the honour and glory +of God, and who seeks and loves God above all things, is often +seized by the desire to see and know Christ, this Bridegroom who was +made man for love of him, who laboured in love even till death, who +drove away from him sin and the enemy, who gave him His grace, who +gave him Himself, who left him His sacraments and promised him His +kingdom. When a man considers all this, he is exceedingly desirous +to see Christ his Bridegroom, and to know what He is in Himself +While He only knows Him in His works he is not satisfied. So he will +do like Zacchasus, the publican, who desired to see Jesus Christ. He +will go in front of the crowd--that is to say, the multitude of the +creatures, for they make us so little and short, that we cannot +perceive God. And he will climb the tree of faith, which grows from +above downwards, for its roots are in the Godhead. This tree has +twelve branches, which are the twelve articles of faith. The lower +branches speak of the humanity of Christ, and of the things which +concern the salvation of our body and soul. The higher part of the +tree speaks of the Godhead, of the Trinity of the Divine Persons and +the Unity of the Divine Nature. A man will strive to reach the unity +at the top of the tree, for it is there that Jesus must pass with +all His gifts. Here Jesus comes, and sees the man, and tells Him in +the light of faith that He is, according to His Godhead, +immeasurable and incomprehensible, inaccessible and abysmal, and +that He surpasses all created light and all finite comprehension. +This is the highest knowledge acquired in the active life, to +recognise thus, in the light of faith, that God is inconceivable and +unknowable. In this light Christ saith to the desire of a man: "Come +down quickly, for I must lodge at thy house to-day." This rapid +descent to which God invites him is nothing else but a descent, by +desire and love, into the abyss of the Godhead, to which no +intelligence can attain in crested light. But where intelligence +remains outside, love and desire enter. The soul thus bending +towards God, by the intention of love, above all that the intellect +can comprehend, rests and abides in God, and God abides in her. Then +mounting by desire, above the multitude of the creatures, above the +work of the senses, above the light of nature, she meets Christ in +the light of faith, and is enlightened, and recognises that God is +unknowable and inconceivable. Finally, bending by her desires +towards this inconceivable God, she meets Christ and is loaded with +His gifts; by living and resting upon Him, above all His gifts, +above herself and above all the creatures, she dwells in God and God +in her. + +This is how you will meet Christ at the summit of the active life, +if you have as your foundations justice, charity, and humility; and +if you have built a house above--that is to say, the virtues here +described, and if you have met Christ by faith--that is to say, by +faith and the intention of love, you dwell in God and God dwells in +you, and you possess the active life. + +This is the first explanation of the word of Jesus Christ our +Bridegroom, when He said, "See, the Bridegroom cometh; go forth to +meet Him." + +BOOK II + +THE SUBJECTS OF THE SECOND BOOK + +THE prudent virgin--that is to say, the pure soul, who has +renounced the things of earth, and lives henceforth for God in +virtue, has taken in the vessel of her heart the oil of charity and +of divine works by means of the lamp of an unstained conscience. But +when Christ, her Bridegroom, withdraws His consolations and the +fresh outpouring of His gifts, the soul becomes heavy and torpid. + +At midnight--that is to say, when it is least expected, a spiritual +cry resounds in the soul: "See, the Bridegroom cometh, go forth to +meet Him." We shall now speak of this seeing, and of the inward +coming of Christ, and of the spiritual going forth of the man to +meet Jesus, and we shall explain these four conditions of an inward +life, exalted and full of desire, to which all men attain not, but +many reach it by means of the virtues and their inward courage. + +In these words, Christ teaches us four things. In the first, He +requires that our intelligence shall be enlightened with a +supernatural light. This is what we observe in the word, "See." In +the next words He shows us what we ought to see--that is to say, the +inward coming of our Bridegroom of eternal truth. This is His +meaning when He says: "The Bridegroom cometh." In the third place, +in the words "go forth," He bids us go forth in inward actions +according to righteousness. In the fourth place, He shows us the end +and motive of all our works, the meeting with our Bridegroom Jesus +Christ in the joyous unity of His adorable Godhead. + +HOW WE MAY GAIN SUPERNATURAL VISION BY INTERNAL EXERCISES + +NOW let us speak of the first word. Christ saith, "See." Three +things are required by him who would see supernaturally in interior +exercises. The first is the light of the divine grace, but in a far +more sublime manner than can be felt in the external, active life. +The second is a stripping off of extraneous images and a denudation +of the heart, so that a man may be free from images, and attachments +to every creature. The third is a free conversion of the will, by +means of a concentration of all the bodily and spiritual faculties, +and complete deliverance from all inordinate affections. Thus this +will flows together into the unity of the Godhead and of our own +mind, so that the reasonable creature may be able to obtain and +possess supernaturally the sublime unity of God. It is for this that +God made the heaven and earth and mankind, it is for this that He +was made man, and taught us by word and example by what way we +should come to this unity. And then in the ardour of His love He +endured to die, and He ascended to heaven, and opened to us this +unity in which we may possess felicity and eternal blessedness. + +ON THE THREEFOLD NATURAL UNITY OF MAN + +NOW consider attentively: there are three kinds of natural unity in +all men, and, moreover, of supernatural unity among the just. The +first and supreme unity of man is in God; for all creatures are +immanent in this unity, and if they were to be separated from God, +they would be annihilated, and would become nothing. This unity is +essential in us according to nature, whether we are good or bad. And +without our co-operation it makes us neither holy nor blessed. This +unity we possess in ourselves, and nevertheless above us, as a +beginning and support of our life and essence. + +Another unity exists in us naturally--that of the supreme forces, in +so far as they actively take their natural origin in the unity of +the spirit or of the thoughts. This is the same unity as that which +is immanent in God, but it is taken here actively and there +essentially. Nevertheless the spirit is entirely in each unity +according to the integrity of its substance. We possess this unity +in ourselves, above the sensitive part of us; and thence are born +memory, intelligence, and will, and all the power of spiritual +works. In this unity the soul is called spirit. + +The third unity which is in us naturally is the foundation of bodily +forces in the unity of the heart, the source and origin of bodily +life. The soul possesses this unity in the lively centre of the +heart, and from it flow all the material works and the five senses, +and the soul draws from thence its name of soul (anima); for it is +the source of life, and animates the body--that is to say, it makes +it living and preserves it in life. These three unities are in man +naturally, as a life and a kingdom. In the inferior unity we are +sensible and animal, in the intermediate unity we are rational and +spiritual; and in the superior unity we are preserved according to +our essence. And this exists in all men, naturally. + +Now these three unities are adorned and cultivated naturally, like a +kingdom and an eternal abode, by the virtues, in charity and in the +active life. And they are adorned still better and more gloriously +cultivated by the internal exercises of a spiritual life. But most +gloriously and blessedly of all by a supernatural contemplative +life. + +The inferior unity, which is corporeal, is adorned and cultivated +supernaturally by external practices, by perfect conduct, by the +example of Christ and the saints, by carrying the cross with Christ, +by submitting our nature to the command of Holy Church and the +teachings of the saints, according to the forces of nature and +prudence. + +The other unity which resides in the spirit and which is absolutely +spiritual, is adorned and cultivated supernaturally by the three +Divine gifts, Faith, Hope, and Charity, and by the influx of grace +and Divine gifts, and by good will directed to all the virtues, and +the desire to follow the example of Christ and of holy Christendom. + +The third and supreme unity is above our intelligence and yet +essentially in us. We cultivate it supernaturally when in all our +works of virtue we have in view only the glory of God, without any +other desire but to repose in Him, above thought, above ourselves, +and above everything. And this is the unity from which we flowed out +when we were created, and where we abide according to our essence, +and towards which we endeavour to return by love. These are the +virtues which adorn this triple unity in the active life. + +Now we proceed to say how this triple unity is adorned more +sublimely and cultivated more nobly by interior exercises joined to +the active life. When a man, by love and right intention, elevates +himself in all his works and in all his life towards the honour and +glory of God, and seeks rest in God above all things, he will wait +in humility and patience and abandonment of self and in the hope of +new riches and new gifts, and he will not be troubled or anxious +whether it pleases God to grant His gifts or to refuse them. So men +prepare themselves for receiving an internal life of desires; even +as a vessel is fitted and prepared, into which a precious liquid is +to be poured. There is no vessel more noble than the loving soul, +and no drink more necessary than the grace of God. Man will thus +offer to God all his works and all his life, in a simple and right +intention, and in a zest above his intention, above himself, and +above everything, in the sublime unity in which God and the loving +spirit are united without intermediary. + +ON THE FIRST MODE OR DEGREE OF THE FIRST SPIRITUAL COMING OF CHRIST + +THE first coming of Christ to those who are engaged in the exercises +of desire is an internal and sensible current from the Holy Spirit, +which impels and attracts us to all the virtues. We shall compare +this coming to the splendour and power of the sun, which, so soon as +it is risen, enlightens and warms the whole world in the twinkling +of an eye. In the same way Christ, the eternal sun, burns and +shines, dwelling at the highest point of the spirit, and enlightens +and fires the lower part of man--that is to say, his physical heart +and sense-faculties, and this is accomplished in less time than the +twinkling of an eye, for the work of God is prompt; but the man in +whom it takes place ought to be internally seeing by means of his +spiritual eyes. + +The sun burns in the East, in the middle of the world, on the +mountains; there it hastens in the summer, and creates good fruits +and strong wines, filling the earth with joy. The same sun shines in +the West, at the end of the world; the country there is colder and +the force of the heat less; nevertheless, it there produces a great +number of good fruits, but not much wine. The men who dwell in the +West part of themselves, abide in their external senses, and by +their good intentions, their virtues, and their outer practices, by +the grace of God produce abundant harvests of virtues of divers +kinds, but they but rarely taste the wine of inward joy and +spiritual consolation. + +The man who wishes to experience the rays of the eternal sun, which +is Christ Himself, will be seeing; and will dwell on the mountains +of the East, by concentrating all his faculties, and lifting up his +heart to God, free, and indifferent to joy and pain and all the +creatures. There shines Christ, the sun of righteousness, on the +free and exalted heart, and this is what I mean by the mountains. +Christ, the glorious sun and divine effulgence, shines through and +fires by his internal coming, and by the power of His Spirit, the +free heart and all the powers of the soul. This is the first work of +the internal coming in the exercises of desire. Just as fire +inflames things which are thrown into it, so Christ inflames the +hearts offered to Him in freedom and exultation at His internal +coming, and He says in this coming: "Go forth by the exercises +appropriate to this life." + +ON UNITY OF HEART + +FROM this heat is born unity of heart, for we cannot obtain true +unity, unless the Spirit of God lights His flame in our heart. For +this fire makes one and like unto itself all that it can overtop and +transform. Unity gives a man the feeling of being concentrated with +all his faculties on one point. It gives internal peace and repose +of heart. Unity of heart is a bond which draws and binds together +the body and the soul, and all exterior and interior forces, in the +unity of love. + +HOW THE VIRTUES PROCEED FROM UNITY + +FROM this unity of heart is born inwardness or the internal life, +for none can have inwardness unless he is one and united in himself; +fervour or inwardness is the introversion of a man into his own +heart, to comprehend and experience the internal operation or speech +of God. Inwardness is a sensible flame of love, which the Spirit of +God lights and kindles in a man, and a man knows not whence it +comes, nor what has happened to him. + +ON SENSIBLE LOVE + +FROM inwardness is born a sensible love which penetrates the heart +of man and the highest faculties of the soul. This love and delight +none can experience who has not inwardness. Sensible love is the +desire and appetite for God as for an eternal good in which all is +contained. Sensible love renounces all the creatures, not as needs +but as pleasures. Interior love feels itself touched from above by +the eternal love which it must practise eternally Interior love +willingly renounces and despises everything, in order to obtain that +which it loves. + +ON DEVOTION + +FROM this sensible love is born devotion to God and His glory. For +none can have a hungry devotion in his heart, unless he possesses +the sensible love of God. Devotion excites and stimulates a man +internally and externally to the service of God. It makes the body +and soul abound in glory and merit in the eyes of God and men. God +exacts devotion in all that we do. It purges the body and soul from +all that might hold us back; it shows us the true path to +blessedness. + +ON GRATITUDE + +FROM fervent devotion is born gratitude, for none can thank or +praise God perfectly if he is not fervent and pious. We should thank +God for everything here below, that we may be able to thank Him +eternally above. Those who praise not God here, will be mute +eternally. To praise God is the most joyous and delicious employment +of the loving heart. There is no limit to the praises of God, for +therein is our salvation, and we shall praise Him eternally. + +Now hear a comparison, by which you may understand the exercise of +gratitude. When the summer approaches and the sun mounts, it +attracts the moisture of the earth along the stems and branches of +the trees, whence come green leaves, flowers, and fruit. Even so +when Christ, the eternal sun, rises in our hearts, He sends His +light and heat upon our desires, and draws the heart away from all +the manifold things of earth, creating unity and inwardness, and +makes the heart grow and become green by interior love, and makes +loving devotion flourish, and makes us bear the fruits of gratitude +and love, and preserves these fruits eternally in the humble pain of +our inability to praise and serve Him enough. + +Here ends the first of the four chief kinds ot interior exercises, +which adorn the lower part of a man. + +HOW TO INCREASE INWARDNESS BY HUMILITY + +BUT in thus comparing to the splendour and power of the sun the +modes in which Jesus Christ comes, we shall find in the sun another +virtue or influence which makes the fruit more early ripe and more +abundant. + +When the sun rises to a very great height, and enters the sign of +the Twins--that is to say, into a double thing, but of the same +nature, in the middle of the month of May, the sun has a double +power over the flowers, herbs, and all that grows upon the earth. If +at that time the planets which rule nature are well ordered +according to the season of the year, the sun shines brightly on the +earth, and attracts the moisture in the atmosphere. Hence are born +dew and rain, and the fruits of the ground increase and multiply. + +Even so when Christ, that bright sun, rises in our heart above all +other things, and when the requirements of material nature, which +are contrary to the spirit, are well regulated according to reason, +when we possess the virtues as I have said above, and when, lastly, +we offer and restore to God, by the ardour of charity, and with +gratitude and love, the delight and peace which we find in the +virtues, from all these are born, at times, a gentle rain of new +internal consolations, and a celestial dew of divine sweetness. This +dew and rain make all the virtues increase and multiply day by day, +if we put no hindrance in their way. This is a new and special +operation, and a new coming of Christ into the loving heart. + +ON PURE SATISFACTION OF THE HEART + +FROM this sweetness is born satisfaction of heart, and of all the +bodily faculties, so that a man imagines that he is inwardly +embraced in the divine bands of love. This pleasure and consolation +is greater and more delicious to body and soul than all the +pleasures granted on earth, even if a man could enjoy them to the +full. In this pleasure God sinks into the heart by means of His +gifts with such a profusion of delights, consolations, and joys, +that the heart overflows internally. + +ON THE OBSTACLES WHICH WE ENCOUNTER IN THIS STATE + +THIS coming, or kind of coming, is granted to beginners, when they +turn from the world, when their conversion is complete, and they +abandon all the consolations of earth to live for God only; +nevertheless they are still weak, and need milk and not strong meat, +such as great temptations and the hiding of God's face. At this +season frost and fog often injure them, for they are in the middle +of the May of the interior life. The frost is to wish to be +something, or to imagine that we are something, or to be somewhat +attached to ourselves, or to believe that we have deserved +consolations and are worthy of them. The fog is the wish to rest +upon internal consolations and pains. This obscures the atmosphere +of reason, and the ilowers, which were about to unfold and bloom and +bear fruits, shut up again. This is why we lose the knowledge of +truth, and nevertheless we sometimes keep certain false sweetnesses +granted by the enemy, which at the last lead men astray. + +HOW ONE OUGHT TO BEHAVE IN THIS CASE + +I WISH to give you here a brief comparison, that you may not go +astray, and that you may be able to behave wisely in this case. +Observe the wise bee, and imitate her. She dwells in unity, in the +midst of the assembly of her kind, and she goes forth, not during a +storm, but when the weather is calm and bright, and the sun shines; +and she flies towards every flower where she may find sweetness. She +rests not on any flower, neither for its beauty nor for its +sweetness, but draws out from the cups of the flowers their +sweetness and clearness--that is to say, the honey and wax, and she +brings them back to the unity which is formed of the assembly of all +the bees, that the honey and wax may be put to good use. + +The expanded heart on which Christ, the eternal sun, shines, grows +and blooms under His rays, and from it flow all the interior forces +in joy and sweetness. + +Now the wise man will act like the bee, and will try to settle, with +affection, intelligence, and prudence, on all the gifts and all the +sweetness that he has experienced, and on all the good that God has +done to him. He will not rest on any flower of the gifts, but laden +with gratitude and praise he will fly back towards the unity where +he wishes to dwell, and to rest with God eternally. + +ON THE THIRD MODE OF THE SPIRITUAL COMING OF CHRIST + +WHEN the sun in heaven reaches its highest point, in the sign of the +Crab--that is to say, when it can go no higher, but must begin to go +backwards, then the greatest heat of the year begins. The sun +attracts the moisture, the earth dries, and the fruits ripen. In the +same way, when Christ, the divine sun, arises above the highest +summit of our heart--that is to say, above all His gifts, +consolations and sweetnesses, and if we do not rest in any of these, +however sweet, but return always with humble praises to the source +from which these gifts flow, Christ stops and remains lifted up +above the summit of our heart, and desires to attract all our powers +to Himself. + +This invitation is an irradiation of Christ, the eternal sun, and +causes in the heart a joy and pleasure so great that the heart +cannot close again after such an expansion, without pain. A man is +wounded internally and feels the smart of love. To be wounded by +love is the sweetest sensation and the most grievous pain that can +be experienced. To be wounded by love is a sure sign that we shall +be cured. This spiritual wound does us good and harm at the same +time. + +ON THE FOURTH KIND OF THE SPIRITUAL COMING OF CHRIST + +NOW I wish to speak of the fourth kind of coming of Jesus Christ, +which exalts and perfects the man in his interior exercises, +according to the lower part of his being. But having compared all +the interior comings to the shining of the sun, we will continue to +speak, while following the course of the seasons, of the other +effects and works of the sun. + +When the sun begins to descend the sky, it enters the sign of the +Virgin, so called because this period of the year becomes barren +like a virgin. The glorious virgin Mary, mother of Christ, full of +joys and rich in all the virtues, ascended to heaven at this season. +The heat begins then to diminish, and men gather, for use during the +whole year, the ripe fruits which can be used long after, such as +corn and the grape. And they sow part of the corn, that it may be +multiplied for the use of men. At this season all the solar work of +the year is finished. In the same way, when Christ, the glorious +sun, has risen to the zenith in the heart of men, and begins to +descend, so as to hide the splendour of His divine beams and to +leave a man alone, the heat and impatience of love diminish. Now +this occultation of Christ and the withdrawal of His light and heat +are the first work and the new coming of this mode. Now Christ says +spiritually in a man: "Go forth in the manner that I now show thee"; +and the man goes forth, and finds himself poor, miserable, and +desolate. Here all the storm, all the passion and eagerness of love +grow cold; summer becomes autumn, and all his wealth is changed into +great poverty. And the man begins to complain by reason of his +misery; what is become of his ardent love, his inwardness, his +gratitude, the interior consolations, the heartfelt joys? Where has +it all gone? How comes it that all is dead within him? He is like +a scholar who has lost his knowledge and his work; and nature is +often troubled by such losses. Sometimes these unhappy ones are +deprived of the good things of earth, of their friends and +relations, and are deserted by all the creatures; their holiness is +mistrusted and despised, men put a bad construction upon all the +works of their life, and they are rejected and disdained by all +those who surround them; and sometimes they are afflicted with +diverse diseases; and some of them fall into bodily temptations, or +into spiritual temptations, the most dangerous of all. From this +misery are born the fear of falling, and a sort of half-doubt, and +this is the extreme point where we can stop without despair. Let +such men seek out the good, complain to them, show them their +distress, and ask their help, and implore the aid of Holy +Church, and of all just men. + +WHAT A MAN OUGHT TO DO WHEN HE IS ABANDONED + +A MAN will here observe humbly that he has nothing but his distress, +and he will say in his resignation and self-abnegation the words of +holy Job: "The Lord gave, and the Lord hath taken away; He hath done +what seemed good to Him; blessed be the name of the Lord." And he +will leave himself in everything, and will say and think in his +heart: "Lord, I am as willing to be poor, lacking all that Thou hast +taken from me, as I should be to be rich, if such were Thy will, and +if it were for Thine honour. It is not my will according to nature +which must be accomplished, but Thy will, and my will according to +my spirit, O Lord; for I belong to Thee, and I should love as well +to be Thine in hell as in heaven, if that could serve Thy glory; and +therefore, O Lord, accomplish in me the excellence of Thy will." +From all these pains and acts of resignation, a man will derive an +inward joy, and he will offer himself into the hands of God, and +will rejoice to be able to suffer in His honour. And if he so +perseveres, he will taste inward pleasures such as he has never had +before; for nothing so rejoices the lover of God as to feel that he +is His beloved. And if he is truly exalted as far as this mode, in +the path of virtue, it is not necessary for him to have passed +through all the states which we have described above; for he feels +within himself in action, in humble obedience, in patience, and in +resignation, the source of all the virtues. It is thus that this +mode is eternally sure. + +At this season the sun in the sky enters the sign of the Scales, for +the day and night are equal, and the sun balances the light and the +darkness. In the same way Jesus Christ is in the sign of the Scales +for the resigned man; and whether He grants sweetness or +bitterness, darkness or light, whatever He chooses to send him, the +man keeps his balance, all things are equal to him except sin, which +has been driven away once for all. When every consolation has been +thus withdrawn from these resigned men, when they believe that they +have lost all their virtues and that they are abandoned by God and +all the creatures, if they then know how to reap the divers fruits, +their corn and wine are ready and ripe. That is to say, that all +that the bodily virtues can suffer will be offered by them to God +with joy, without resistance to His supreme will. All the exterior +and interior virtues, which they formerly practised with joy in the +light of love, they will now practise courageously and laboriously, +and will offer them to God, and never will they have so much merit +in His eyes. Never will they have been more noble or more beautiful. +All the consolations which God formerly granted, they will allow to +be stripped from them with joy, since it is for the glory of God. It +is thus that the virtues become perfect, and that sadness is +transformed into an eternal vintage. These men--their life and their +patience--improve and teach all who know and live near them, and +thus it is that the wheat of their virtues is sown and multiplied +for the good of all just men. + +This is the fourth kind of coming which, according to the bodily +faculties and the lower part of his being, adorns and perfects a man +in interior exercises. + +HOW THESE FOUR MODES ARE FOUND IN JESUS CHRIST + +WE must needs walk in the light if we wish not to lose our way, and +we must observe Jesus Christ, who has taught us these four modes, +and has preceded us in them. Christ, the bright sun, rises in the +heaven of the sublime Trinity and in the dawn of His glorious mother +the virgin Mary, who was and is the dawn of all the graces. Now +observe. Christ had and still has the first mode, for He was unique +and united. In Him were and are collected and united all the virtues +which have ever been practised, and which ever will be, and besides +this, all the creatures who will cultivate these virtues. He was +thus in an unique sense the Son of the Father, and united to human +nature. And He was equally full of inwardness, for it was He who +brought upon earth the fire which has consumed all the saints and +all good men. And He had a sensible and faithful love for His +Father, and for all who will have joy in Him eternally, and His +pitiful and loving heart sighed and glowed with love for all men, +before His Father. All His life and all His actions, within and +without, and all His words, were praises of His Father. This is the +first mode. + +Christ, the sun of love, blazed and shone yet more brightly and +warmly, for in Him was and is the fullness of all gifts. This is why +the heart of Christ, and His character, and His habits and His +service, overflowed with pity, sweetness, humility, and generosity. +So gracious was He and so loving, that His manners and His +personality attracted all whose nature was good. He was the pure +lily in the midst of the flowers of the field, from which the good +were to draw the honey of eternal sweetness and eternal +consolations. According to His humanity He thanked His eternal +Father for all the gifts which were ever granted to humanity, and +praised Him, for His Father is the Father of all gifts, and He +rested on Him, according to the highest faculties of His soul, above +all gifts, in the sublime unity of God from which all the gifts flow; +thus He had the second mode. + +Christ, the glorious sun, blazed and shone yet higher, and more +brightly and warmly; for during all His days on earth, all His +bodily faculties were invited and pressed to the sublime glory and +bliss which He now experiences in His senses and body. And He was +inclined thereto Himself, according to His desires; and nevertheless +He willed to remain in this exile, till the time which the Father +had foreseen and fixed from all eternity. Thus He had the third +mode. When the time came at which Christ was to reap and carry away +to the eternal kingdom the fruits of all the virtues which ever have +been and ever will be practised, the eternal sun began to descend; +for Christ humbled Himself, and gave up His bodily life into the +hands of His enemies. And he was misunderstood and deserted by His +friends in so great a distress; and all consolation, within and +without, was withdrawn from His nature; and it was overwhelmed with +misery, pain, and contempt, and paid all the debt which our sins +justly incurred. All this He suffered in humble patience, and He +accomplished the greatest works of love in this resignation, whereby +He received and purchased our eternal inheritance. It is thus that +the lower part of His noble humanity was adorned, for it was in it +that He suffered this pain for our sins. It is on this account that +He is called the Saviour of the world, and that He is glorified and +raised up and seated on the right hand of His Father, and that He +reigns in power. And every creature, on the earth, above the earth, +and under the earth, bends the knee for ever before His glorious +name. + +HOW A MAN SHOULD LIVE IF HE DESIRES TO BE ENLIGHTENED + +THE man who, in true obedience to the commandments of God, lives in +the moral virtues, and moreover exercises himself in the interior +virtues, after the direction and impulse of the Holy Spirit, acting +and speaking according to righteousness, and who seeks not his own +interests in time or in eternity, and who supports with true +patience obscurity and affliction and every kind of misery, and who +thanks God for everything, and offers himself in humble resignation, +has received the first coming of Jesus Christ according to interior +exercises. When this man is purified and pacified, and turns back +upon himself according to his lower nature, he may be internally +enlightened, if he asks it, and if God judges that the right time +has come. It may also happen that he is enlightened from the +beginning of his conversion, so that he may offer himself entirely +to the will of God and give up all possession of himself, which is +the supreme end. But if he is to follow any further the road which I +have shown, in the exterior and at the same time in the interior +life, it will be much easier for him than for the man who has been +raised straight from the bottom, for the former will have more light +than the latter. + +ON ANOTHER COMING OF CHRIST + +NOW we are about to speak of another mode of the coming of Christ, +in interior exercises, which adorn, enlighten, and enrich a man, +according to the three supreme faculties of his soul. We shall +compare this coming to a life-giving fountain from which flow three +rivers. + +This fountain is the fullness of divine grace in the unity of our +spirit. There resides grace essentially in its permanence, like a +full fountain, and it flows out actively by its rivers into each of +the faculties of the soul, according to their needs. These rivers +are a special influx, or operation of God in the highest faculties, +in which God operates in various manners by the intermediary of His +grace. + +HOW THE FIRST RIVER FLOWS INTO THE MEMORY + +THE first river of grace, which God causes to flow in this coming, +is a pure simplicity which shines without distinction in the spirit. +This river takes its source in the fountain, in the unity of the +spirit, and flows directly downwards, and penetrates all the +faculties of the soul, both higher and lower, and lifts them up out +of all multiplicity and all over-occupation, and makes a simplicity +in a man, and gives and shows him an internal bond in the unity of +his spirit. A man is thus lifted up according to his memory, and +delivered from strange and irrelevant thoughts, and from +inconstancy. Now Christ in this light demands a going forth, +according to the mode of this light and this coming. Then the man +goes forth, and observes himself that by virtue of the simple light +that is spread abroad in him he is united, established, penetrated +and fixed in the unity of his spirit or of his thoughts. Here the +man is exalted and established in a new essence; he turns his +thoughts inwards, and rests his memory on the naked truth, above all +sensuous images and above all multiplicity. There the man possesses +essentially and supernaturally the unity of his spirit, for his own +dwelling, and as an heritage of his own for ever. He always has an +inclination towards that same unity, and this unity will have an +eternal and loving inclination towards the more sublime unity where +the Father and the Son are united with all the saints in the bands +of the Holy Spirit. + +HOW THE SECOND RIVER ENLIGHTENS THE INTELLIGENCE + +THROUGH internal love, and loving inclination towards union with +God, is born the second river from the fullness of grace, in unity +of spirit, and this is a spiritual brightness which flows and sheds +light through the intelligence, but with distinctions in the diverse +modes. For this light shows and gives to the spirit, in the truth, +the discretion in all the virtues. But this light is not placed +altogether in our power, for though we have it always in our soul, +God makes it speak or keep silence, and He can manifest or hide it, +give or withdraw it, at all times and under all conditions, for this +light is His. Such men do not absolutely need revelations, nor to be +drawn up above sense, for their life and abode and habits and +essence are in the spirit above sense and sensibility. And God shows +them what He wills and what is necessary for them. Nevertheless God, +if He wished, could withdraw their exterior sense, and show them, +from within, unknown symbols and future things, in diverse manners. + +Now Christ desires that this man should go forth, and go into the +light, according to the mode of this light. This enlightened man +will therefore go forth and observe his state and his life within +and without, in order to know if he is perfectly like Christ +according to His humanity and also according to His divinity. And +this man will lift up his eyes, enlightened by enlightened reason, +in intelligible truth, and will observe and consider, as a creature +can, the sublime nature of God, and the unlimited attributes which +are in God. + +It is then necessary to consider and examine the sublime nature of +God; how it contains simplicity and purity, inaccessible height and +abysmal depth, incomprehensible extension and eternal duration; dark +silence and wild waste; repose of all the saints in unity and joy in +itself and in all the saints in eternity. This enlightened man will +also examine the attributes of the Father in the Godhead, how He is +all-powerful, the creator, mover, preserver, beginning and end, +cause and existence of all creatures; this is what the bright river +of grace shows to the enlightened reason. It shows also the +attributes of the eternal Word, abysmal wisdom and truth, model of +every creature and of all life, eternal norm of things, unveiled +contemplation and intuition into everything, brightness and +illumination of all saints, according to their merits, in heaven and +on earth. But this bright river shows also to the enlightened reason +the attributes of the Holy Spirit; inconceivable charity and +generosity, pity and mercy, infinite watchfulness and faithfulness, +immense and inconceivable riches flowing with delights through all +heavenly spirits, ardent flame consuming all in unity, effluent +fountain, preparation of all the saints for their eternal +blessedness, and their introduction thereto; enveloping and +penetrating the Father, the Son, and all the saints in joyous unity. + +ON THE STATE OF AMAZEMENT AT THE DIVINE EFFLUENCE + +THE incomprehensible wealth and sublimity, and the universal +generosity which flow from the divine nature, bring a man into a +state of amazement; and above all he admires the communication of +God and His effluence above everything, for he sees the +inconceivable essence, which is the common joy of God and all the +saints. And he sees that the three divine Persons are a common +effluence in works, in graces, and in glory, in nature and above +nature, in all conditions and in all times, in the saints and in +men, in heaven and on earth, in all reasonable and irrational +creatures, according to each one's merits, needs, and powers of +receiving. God is common to all, with all His gifts, the angels are +common, the soul is common in all its faculties, in all life, in all +the members, and all in each, for one cannot divide it, except by +reason. For the higher and lower faculties, the spirit and the soul, +are distinct according to reason, but one in nature. Thus God is +entirely and specially present to each one, and nevertheless common +to all the creatures, for by Him are all things, and on Him depend +the heaven, the earth, and the whole of nature. When a man thus +observes the astonishing wealth and sublimity of the divine nature, +and all the manifold gifts which He grants and offers to His +creatures, he is lifted up internally by wonder at such manifold +riches and sublimity; and from thence arises a singular inward joy +of spirit, and a vast confidence in God; and this internal joy +surrounds and penetrates all the faculties of the soul in inwardness +of spirit. + +HOW THE THIRD RIVER CONFIRMS THE WILL + +FROM this joy and fullness of graces, and divine faithfulness, there +is born and flows out the third river in this same unity of spirit. +This river, like a flame, lights up the spirit and absorbs all +things in unity. And it causes to overflow and flood with rich gifts +and singular nobility, all the faculties of the soul, and it creates +in the will a love without labour, spiritual and subtle. Now Christ +says internally in the spirit by means of this flaming river: "Go +forth by exercises according to the mode of these gifts and this +coming." Thanks to the first river--that is to say, to a simple +light, the memory is lifted up above the accidents of sense, and is +established in the unity of spirit. Thanks to the second river-- +that is to say, to the brightness spread abroad within, the +intelligence and reason are enlightened, so as to recognise the +diverse modes of the virtues and of exercises, and the mysteries of +the Scriptures. Thanks to the third river--that is to say, to an +inspired ardour, the sublime will is kindled into a more tranquil +love, and adorned with greater riches. In this way a man becomes +spiritually enlightened, for the grace of God abides, like a +fountain in the unity of the spirit; and these rivers create in the +faculties of the soul an effluence of all the virtues. And the +fountain of grace always requires a reflux towards its source. + +HOW CHRIST IS GIVEN TO ALL MEN IN THE SACRAMENT OF THE ALTAR + +THERE is a special benefit which Christ left in the Holy Church, to +all good people, in this supper of the great Paschal feast, when He +was about to pass from His sufferings to His Father after having +eaten the Paschal lamb with His disciples, and when the ancient law +was accomplished. At the end of the supper, He wished to give them a +special meal, as He had long desired to do. And this is why He +wished to finish the ancient law and to inaugurate the new law. He +took bread in His sacred hands, and consecrated His holy body, and +then His holy blood, and gave them to all His disciples, and left +them to all the just, for their eternal good. + +This gift and this special food rejoice and adorn all the great +festivals and all the banquets in heaven and on earth. In this gift +Christ gives Himself to us in three manners; He gives us His flesh +and blood and His bodily life, glorified and full of joys and +griefs. And He gives us His spirit with its highest faculties, and +full of glory, of gifts, of truths and justifications. And He gives +us His personality with the divine light which lifts up His spirit +and all enlightened spirits, even to the sublime and joyous unity. + +Now Christ wishes us to remember Him, whenever we consecrate, offer, +and receive His body. Now observe how we should remember Him. We +shall observe and consider how Christ bends towards us in loving +affection, in great desire, in loving joy, and by flowing into our +bodily nature. For He gives us that which He received from our +humanity--that is to say, His flesh and blood and bodily nature. We +shall contemplate this precious body pierced and wounded with love, +by reason of His faithfulness to us. It is by it that we are adorned +and nourished in the lower part of our human nature. He gives us +also, in this sublime gift of the sacrament, His spirit full of +glory, and the richest gifts of the virtues, and ineffable marvels +of charity and nobleness. + +It is by this that we are nourished, adorned, and illuminated in the +unity of our spirit and in our higher faculties, thanks to the +indwelling of Christ with all His riches. He gives us also in the +sacrament of the altar His sublime personality in incomprehensible +light. And thanks to this, we are united to the Father, and so we +reach our inheritance of divinity in eternal bliss. If a man +meditate rightly on this, he will meet Christ in the same manner in +which Christ comes to him. He will raise himself up to receive +Christ, with all his faculties and in eager joy. It is not possible +for our joy to be too great, for our nature receives His nature--that +is to say the glorified humanity of Christ, full of joyfulness and +full of merits. This is why I would that man, at the reception of +this sacrament, should melt away with desire, joy, and pleasure, for +he is receiving the fairest, the most gracious, the most lovable of +the children of men, and is united to Him. In this union and in this +joy great benefits often come to men, and many mysterious and +marvellous secrets of divine treasures are manifested and disclosed. +When a man meditates, at this reception, on the martyrdom and +sufferings of the precious body of Christ, whom he is receiving, he +enters sometimes into so loving a devotion and so great a +compassion, that he desires to be nailed with Christ to the cross, +and to shed his heart's blood for the honour of Christ. And he +presses himself to the wounds and open heart of Christ His Saviour. +In these exercises revelations and great benefits have often come to +men. + +ON THE UNITY OF THE DIVINE NATURE IN THE TRINITY OF PERSONS + +THE sublime and superessential unity of the Divine nature, in which +the Father and the Son possess their nature in the unity of the Holy +Spirit, above the conception and comprehension of all our faculties, +in the bare essence of our spirit, surpasses in this sublime calm +all the creatures of created light. This sublime unity of the Divine +nature is living and fruitful, for, from this same unity, the +eternal Word is born from the Father without interruption. And by +this birth the Father knows the Son, and all things in the Son. And +the Son knows the Father, and all things in the Father, for their +nature is simple. From this reciprocal vision of the Father and the +Son in an eternal clearness, flow forth an eternal satisfaction and +unfathomable love, which is the Holy Spirit. And by the Holy Spirit +and the eternal Wisdom God inclines towards every creature +severally, and loads every one of them with gifts and kindles it +with love, according to its nobility and according to the state +wherein it is constituted and elected though its virtues and the +eternal foresight of God. And it is by this that all just spirits, +in heaven and on earth, are united in virtue and justice. + +HOW GOD MOVES AND POSSESSES THE SOUL, NATURALLY AND SUPERNATURALLY + +NOW be attentive: I am about to give you an example on this +subject. God has made the upper heaven a pure and simple clearness +encircling and enveloping all the heavens; and all the material +world which God has created for it is the exterior abode and kingdom +of God and His saints, full of glory and eternal joys. Now the +heaven being an unmixed clearness, there is there neither time, nor +state, nor temptation, nor change, for it is unchangeably fixed +above all things. The sphere which approaches most nearly to it is +called the primum mobile. All movement, by the power of God, +emanates from the supreme heaven. This is the movement which carries +with it the motions of the firmament and all the planets. It is by +this same initial movement that all the creatures live and grow, +according to their order. Now understand that the essence of the +soul is like a spiritual kingdom of God, full of Divine clearness, +surpassing all our faculties, unless these faculties are not +transformed in a simple fashion, of which I do not wish to speak +now. See; in this essence of the soul in which God reigns, the +unity of our spirit is like the primum mobile; for in this unity +the spirit is moved from above, by the power of God, naturally and +supernaturally; for by ourselves we have nothing either in or above +nature. And this motion of God, when it is supernatural, is the +first and chief cause of all our virtue. And by this motion of God +the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit are granted to certain +enlightened men, like the seven planets which illuminate all the +lives of men. This is how God possesses the essential unity of our +spirit, as His Kingdom. + +ON THE ESSENTIAL MEETING WITH GOD, WITHOUT INTERMEDIARY + +NOW attend carefully. The unity of our spirit has two modes, one +essential and the other active. You should know that the spirit, +according to its essential existence, receives the coming of Christ +in its bare nature, without intermediary and without interruption. +For this essence and life which we are in God, in our eternal image, +and which we have in ourselves, according to essential existence, +are without intermediary and inseparable. This is why the spirit +receives, in its highest and most intimate part, in its bare nature, +the impression of its eternal image, and the divine brightness +without interruption, and it is an eternal dwelling of God, which He +occupies by a perpetual inhabitation, and which He visits always +with a new coming, and a new effulgence from His eternal birth. For +where He comes He is, and where He is He comes. And where He has +never been, He will never come, for there is in Him neither accident +nor change, and everything, where He is, is in Him, for He never +goes out of Himself. And this is why the spirit possesses God +essentially in its bare nature, and God the spirit, for the spirit +lives in God, and God in the spirit. And it is capable, in its +highest part, of receiving the brightness of God, and all that God +may grant it, without intermediary. And by the brightness of its +eternal image, which shines essentially and personally in it, the +spirit is plunged, as regards the highest part of its vitality, in +the divine essence; and there enters into possession of its eternal +bliss, and flowing out again by the eternal birth of the Son is +placed in its created essence by the free will of the Holy Trinity, +And here it is like the image of the sublime Trinity and Unity for +which it is created. And in its created nature, it takes the +impression of its eternal image without interruption, like an +immaculate mirror in which every impression abides, and which renews +the likeness in itself without interruption. This essential unity of +our spirit in God, exists not in itself, but abides in God and flows +out from God, and is immanent in God and returns to God, as to its +eternal cause. It never separates itself from God, for this unity is +a fact of bare nature, and if nature separated itself from God it +would fall into nothingness. And this unity is above time and +conditions, and works always without interruption according to the +mode of God. This is the nobleness which we have naturally according +to the essential unity of our spirit, where it is united naturally +to God. + +This makes us neither saints nor blessed, for all men have it in +them, the bad as well as the good; but it is the first cause of all +holiness and bliss; and this is the meeting and unity of God in our +spirit, in our base nature. + +HOW MAN IS LIKE GOD BY GRACE, AND UNLIKE HIM BY MORTAL SIN + +NOW examine this thought with care, for if you understand well what +I wish to say to you, and what I have already said, you will +understand all the divine truth which a creature can apprehend at +present, and even things far more sublime. In the second mode, our +spirit keeps itself actively in this same unity, and subsists by +itself as in its personal created essence. This is the foundation +and origin of the supreme faculties, and this is the beginning and +end of all the works of a created nature, accomplished according to +the mode of the creatures, both in nature and above nature. + +Nevertheless this unity does not operate as unity; but all the +faculties of the soul have their power entirely in their +foundation--that is to say, in the unity of the spirit, where it +resides in its personal essence. In this unity the spirit must +always be like unto God, by grace and virtue, or unlike Him by +mortal sin; for man is made in the likeness of God, which he must +understand in the sense of grace; for grace is a deiform light which +shines through us and makes us like unto God; and without this light +we cannot be united supernaturally to God, even though we can never +lose the image of God, nor our natural unity in Him. If we lose this +likeness--that is to say, grace, we are damned. And this is why, so +soon as God finds in us something which is capable of receiving His +grace, He wishes to enliven us by His goodness, and to make us like +unto Himself by His gifts. And this happens whenever we turn towards +Him with full purpose; for at the same moment Christ comes to us and +in us, with and without intermediary--that is to say, by the virtues +and above all the virtues. And He impresses His image and likeness +upon us--that is to say, Himself and all His gifts, and He relieves +us from sin and makes us like unto Himself. + +By the same operation in which God relieves us from sin, and makes +us like Him and free in charity, the spirit is plunged in joyous +love. And here take place a meeting and a union, which are without +intermediaries and supernatural, and wherein resides our supreme +blessedness. Although all that He gives by love and pure goodness is +natural to God, yet to us it is accidental and supernatural, +according to our mode, since formerly we were strangers and unlike, +and only subsequently have become like God and obtained union with +Him. + +ON THE SUPREME DEGREE OF THE INTERIOR LIFE + +NOW understand. This incomprehensible light transforms and +penetrates the joyous inclination of our spirit. In this light, the +spirit is plunged in joyous repose; for this repose is without mode +and without bottom, and we can only know it by itself--that is to +say, by repose. For if we could know it and conceive it, it would +fall into mode and measure, and so would not be able to satisfy us, +and repose would become an eternal restlessness. And this is why the +simple, loving, complete inclination of our spirit forms in us a +joyous love, and joyous love is without bottom. And the abyss of God +calls to abyss; so it is with all those whose spirits are united to +God in joyous love. This calling is an irruption from His essential +brightness; and this essential brightness in the embrace of His +bottomless love, causes us to lose ourselves and escape from +ourselves, in the lonely darkness of God. And thus united, without +intermediary, to the spirit of God, we can meet God by God, and +possess unchangeably, with Him and in Him, our eternal blessedness. + +ON THE FIRST MODE OF THIS HIGHEST MEETING + +THE most interior life is practised in three ways. Sometimes the +interior man operates, above all activity and all virtue, by simple +introspection in joyous love. And here he meets God without +intermediary. And from the unity of God a simple light shines in +him, and this light shows him darkness, nakedness, and nothingness. +He is enveloped in darkness, and falls into the absence of mode as +one who loses his way. He loses, in nakedness, the power of +observing and distinguishing all things, and he is transformed and +penetrated by a simple brightness. He loses, in nothingness, all his +works, for he is overcome in the work of the unlimited love of God; +and in the joyous inclination of his spirit he triumphs in God and +becomes one spirit with Him. This is the first mode, which is +inactive; for it empties a man of all things, and lifts him up above +works and virtues. + +ON THE SECOND MODE + +THERE are moments when the interior man turns desirously and +actively towards God, to pay Him homage, and to offer up and +annihilate, in the love of God, his being and all that he can give. +And here he meets God, through an intermediary. This intermediary is +the gift of wisdom, which is the foundation and source of all the +virtues, and excites the just to virtues in proportion to their love; +and sometimes it touches and inflames the interior man with love +so violently, that all the gifts of God, and all that God can give +without giving Himself, seem to him too little and do not satisfy +him, but only increase his impatience. For he has at the bottom of +his being an interior perception or sensation, wherein all the +virtues begin and end, and wherein he offers to God all the virtues, +and wherein love lives. And thus the hunger and thirst of love +become so great, that he is reduced to nothingness, and then touched +anew, as it were for the first time, by the irradiation of God. Thus +in living he dies and in dying he lives again. This is the second +mode, and it is more useful and more glorious than the first; for +none can enter into the repose that is above action unless he has +first actively loved love. And this is why none will be inactive, +who is master of himself and who is able to practise love. + +ON THE THIRD MODE + +FROM these two kinds is born the third, which is an interior life +according to righteousness. Now understand. God comes to us without +interruption, with and. without intermediary, He requires of us +action and joy, in such a way that action may not hinder joy, nor +joy action, but that each may help the other. This is why the +interior man possesses his life in these two modes, repose and work. +And in each of them he is entire and undivided; for he is entirely +in God, in his joyous repose, and he is entirely in himself, in his +active love; and God warns him that He requires him to renew +continually his repose and his work. The righteousness of the spirit +wishes to pay, every hour, what God requires of us, and this is why, +at every irradiation of God, the spirit turns inwards, actively and +joyously, and so is renewed in all the virtues, and plunged more +deeply in joyous love. For God at every gift gives Himself with all +His gifts, and the spirit whenever it turns inwards, gives itself +with all its works. The spirit is united to God, and transferred +without interruption into repose. The man is hungry, for he sees the +nourishment of angels and the food of heaven. He works actively in +love, for he sees his repose. He is a pilgrim, and he sees his +country. He fights, in love, for victory, for he sees his crown. +Consolation, peace, joy, beauty, and riches, and all that can +rejoice the heart, are shown to the reason illuminated by God, in +spiritual similitudes and without measure. And by this vision, at +the touch of God, love remains active. For this just man has built +up, in the spirit, a true life, which will last eternally, but after +this life it will be transformed into a more sublime state. Thus the +man is just, and he goes towards God by interior love in eternal +work, and he goes in God by joyous inclination, in eternal repose. +And he abides in God, and yet he goes out towards all the creatures, +in common love, in the virtues, and in the works of justice. This is +the supreme summit of the inner life. + +Note.--Here follow in Ruysbroek's treatise four chapters of warnings +against the errors of Quietism, such as were exemplified in his time +by many of the Brethren of the Free Spirit and similar sects. + +BOOK III + +THE THREE CONDITIONS BY WHICH WE MAY ATTAIN TO THE CONTEMPLATIVE +LIFE + +THE interior lover of God, who possesses God in joyous repose, and +possesses himself in the unity of active love, and possesses all his +life in the virtues, enters into the contemplative life, thanks to +these three points and to the secret manifestation of God; yes, it +is the internal and devout lover, whom God will choose freely and +lift him up even to a superessential contemplation in divine light +and according to the mode of God. This contemplation places us in a +purity and brightness above all intelligence, for it is a singular +ornament and a celestial crown, and at last the eternal recompense +of all the virtues and of all life. And none can arrive there by +knowledge or subtlety, nor by any exercise; but he whom God wills to +unite to His own Spirit and to illuminate by Himself, can +contemplate God, and none other can. To such an one the heavenly +Father says, in the secret and submerged part of the spirit: "See, +the Bridegroom cometh, go forth to meet Him." + +I wish to analyse and explain these words, in their relation to +superessential contemplation, which is the basis of all holiness and +of the perfect life. Very few men attain to this divine +contemplation, by reason of our incapacity, and the mystery of the +light in which contemplation takes place. And this is why no one, by +his own knowledge or by any subtle examination, will understand +these ideas. For all words, and all that can be learned and +understood according to the mode of the creatures, are strangers to +the truth which I speak of, and far below it. But he who is united +to God, and illuminated in this truth, can comprehend the truth by +itself. For to conceive and understand God above all similitudes, as +He is in Himself, is to be God in God, without intermediary and +without any difference which might prove an obstacle. This is why I +desire that every man who does not understand this, nor experience +it in the joyous unity of his spirit, may not be wounded by my +words, for what I say is true. And this is why he who wishes to +understand this, must be dead to himself and alive to God, and he +will turn his face to the eternal light, at the bottom of his +spirit, where the hidden truth is manifested without intermediary. +For the heavenly Father wishes that we should be seeing; for He is +the Father of Light, and this is why He says eternally, without +interruption and without intermediary, one abysmal word and no +other. In this word He proffers Himself and all things. The word is: +"See." And it is the going forth and the birth of the Son of the +eternal light, in whom we see and recognise all our blessedness. + +HOW A MAN OUGHT TO EXERCISE HIMSELF, IN ORDER TO RECEIVE THE ETERNAL +LIGHT AND TO CONTEMPLATE GOD + +IN order that the spirit may contemplate God by God, without +intermediary, in this Divine light, three things are necessary. +First, the man must be well governed externally in all the virtues, +and without obstacles within, and as free from all external works as +if he did them not; for if he is troubled within by any act of +virtue, he has images, and so long as they remain in him he cannot +contemplate. In the second place, he must adhere internally to God, +by the combination of intention and of love, like a burning fire, +which can never more be extinguished. At the moment when he feels +himself in this state, he can contemplate. In the third place, he +should be lost in an absence of mode, and in a darkness, in which +all contemplatives wander joyously, and can never find themselves +again according to the mode of the creatures. In the abyss of this +darkness, where the loving spirit is dead to itself, begin the +manifestation of God and of eternal life. For in this darkness is +born and shines an incomprehensible light, which is the Son of God, +in whom we see eternal life. And in this light we become seeing; and +this Divine light is given in the simple vision of the spirit, in +which the spirit receives the clearness which is God Himself, +without intermediary, and becomes without interruption this +clearness which it receives. See; this dark clearness, in which we +contemplate all that we desire, while the spirit is passive,--this +clearness is so great than the loving contemplative, in the depth +where he reposes, sees and experiences nothing save an +incomprehensible light, and according to the simple nudity which +envelopes all things, he sees and apprehends the same light by which +he sees, and nothing else. This is the first condition of becoming +seeing in the Divine light. Happy are the eyes which thus see, for +they have eternal life. + +HOW THE ETERNAL BIRTH OF GOD IS RENEWED WITHOUT INTERRUPTION IN +NOBLENESS OF SPIRIT + +WHEN we have thus become seeing, we can contemplate in joy the +eternal coming of the Bridegroom, and this is the second point on +which I wish to speak. What is then this coming of the Bridegroom +which is eternal? It is a new birth and a new illumination without +interruption; for the foundation out of which the clearness shines, +and which is the clearness itself, is living and fruitful; and this +is why the manifestation of the eternal light is renewed without +interruption, in the most secret part of the spirit. See; every +creaturely work, and every exercise of virtue must here submit +themselves, for God works alone in the highest part of the spirit. +There is nought here but an eternal contemplation and fixity of +light, by light, and in light. And the coming of the Bridegroom is +so swift that He comes always, and is immanent with His unfathomable +riches, and comes back ever anew, in person, with such new +splendours that He seems never to have come before. For His coming +consists in an eternal Now, transcending time, and He is always +received with new desire and new joy. The delights and joy which +this Bridegroom brings at His coming are without bottom and without +limits, for they are Himself. This is why the eyes of the spirit, by +which the lover contemplates the Bridegroom, are open so wide that +they will never more be shut. For the contemplation and fixity of +the spirit remain eternal in the hidden manifestation of God. And +the contemplation of the spirit is so widely opened, while waiting +for the coming of the Bridegroom, that the spirit itself acquires +the amplitude of that which it comprehends. And in this way, God is +seen and comprehended by God, in which all our salvation and +blessedness consists. This is the second manner in which we receive, +without interruption in our spirit, the eternal coming of our +Bridegroom. + +ON THE ETERNAL GOING FORTH WHICH WE POSSESS IN THE BIRTH OF THE SON + +NOW the Spirit of God saith, in the secret depths of our spirit: +"Go forth," in an eternal contemplation and joy, according to the +mode of God. All the wealth which is in God naturally, we possess in +Him by love; and God possesses it in us, by His boundless Love, +which is the Holy Spirit. For in this love all is tasted that can be +desired. And this is why, thanks to this love, we are dead to +ourselves, and have gone forth in loving liquefaction or immersion, +in the absence of mode and in darkness. There the spirit, enveloped +by the Holy Trinity, is eternally immanent in the superessential +unity, in repose and in joy. And in this same unity, according to +the mode of generation, the Father is in the Son, and the Son in the +Father, and every creature in them both. And this is above the +distinction of Persons, for here we understand by reason the +fatherhood and sonship in the lively fruitfulness of nature. + +Here is born and begins an eternal going forth, and an eternal work +without beginning, for there is here a beginning without beginning. +For by means of the eternal birth of the Son, the Word of the +Father, all creatures have gone forth eternally, before they were +created in time, and God has considered and recognised them +distinctly in Himself, in lively reason, and in distinction from +Himself: but not in another mode, for all that is in God is God. +This eternal going forth and this eternal life, which we have and +are eternally in God, without ourselves, is the cause of our created +essence in time. And our created essence is immanent in the eternal +essence, and this eternal life, which we have and are in the eternal +wisdom of God, is like unto God; for they have an eternal immanence, +without distinction, in the divine essence. And they have an eternal +effluence by the birth of the Son, in a difference with distinction, +according to the eternal reason. And thanks to these two things, a +man is in this way like unto God, that he recognises himself and +reflects on himself without interruption, in this resemblance, +according to essence and according to the Persons. For though here +there is still distinction and difference, according to reason, this +resemblance is nevertheless one with the very image of the Holy +Trinity, which is the wisdom of God, and wherein God contemplates +Himself and all things in an eternal Now, without before or after. +In simple vision He regards Himself as He regards all things. And +this is the image and likeness of God, and our image and likeness, +for in it God and all things are reflected. In this divine image, +all the creatures, without themselves, have an eternal life, as in +their eternal model, and the Holy Trinity has made us in this +eternal image and likeness. And this is why God wishes that we +should go out from ourselves, in this eternal light, and that we +should pursue this image, which is our true life, supernaturally, +and possess it with Him actively and joyously, in eternal +blessedness. + +For we know well that the bosom of the Father is our foundation and +origin, wherein we begin our life and our being. And from our true +foundation--that is to say, from the Father and from all that lives +in Him, beams forth an eternal radiance, which is the birth of the +Son. In this radiance, the Father manifests Himself, and all that +lives in Himself, to Himself; for all that He is, and all that He +has, He gives to the Son, except the prerogative of fatherhood, +which resides in Himself. And this is why all that lives in the +Father hidden in the Unity, lives also in the Son, and flows forth +in His manifestation; but the simple foundation of our eternal image +remains always without mode in the darkness. But the boundless +radiance which shines out thence manifests and reflects in the mode +the mystery of God. And all men who are raised above their +creatureliness into a contemplative life, are united to this divine +splendour. And they are this splendour itself, and they see, +experience, and find, thanks to this divine radiance, that they are +this same simple foundation, according to their uncreated essence, +from which shines forth, in the divine mode, this immeasurable +radiance, which, according to simplicity of essence, remains +eternally within, and without mode. This is why interior men and +contemplatives will go forth, according to the mode of +contemplation, above distinction and above their created essence, by +means of an eternal intuition. Thanks to this inborn light, they are +transformed, and are united to this same light by which they see and +which they see. In this manner contemplatives pursue the eternal +image, after which they are made, and contemplate God and all things +without distinction, by a pure vision in divine brightness. This is +the most sublime and the most useful contemplation which we can +attain in this life; for in this contemplation a man remains the +best and freest master of himself, and at each loving introversion, +above all that we can comprehend, he can advance in the sublimities +of life, for he remains free and master of himself, in unity and in +the virtues. And this contemplation in the divine light maintains +him above all inwardness, above all virtue, above all merit, for it +is the crown and recompense towards which we are striving, and which +we already have and possess in this mode, for the contemplative life +is a celestial life. But if we shall be drawn up out of this exile +and this misery, we shall be, according to our created nature, more +susceptible of this radiance, and then the glory of God would shine +through us better and more sublimely. This is the mode above all +modes, according to which we go forth in a divine contemplation and +in an eternal stability, and according to which we are transformed +and reformed in the divine radiance. This going forth of the +contemplative is also loving; for by joyous love he surpasses his +created essence, and finds and tastes the riches and delights which +are God, and which He causes to flow without interruption into the +most secret part of the spirit, into the place where he is like the +sublimity of God. + +ON THE DIVINE MEETING, WHICH TAKES PLACE IN THE MOST SECRET PART OF +OUR SPIRIT + +WHEN the interior man and contemplative has thus pursued his eternal +image, and possessed in this purity the bosom of the Father by the +Son, he is illuminated by the divine truth, and receives anew at +each instant the eternal birth; and he goes forth according to the +mode of light, in a divine contemplation. And here arises the fourth +and last point--that is to say, the loving meeting, in which before +all else resides our eternal blessedness. + +You know that our heavenly Father, like a living foundation, is +actively inclined towards His Son, as towards His own eternal +wisdom. And this same wisdom, and all that lives therein, is +actively inclined in the Father--that is to say, in the foundation +whence it proceeds. And in this meeting arises the Third Person, +between the Father and the Son, and this is the Holy Spirit, their +mutual love, which is united to them both in the same nature. And He +envelopes and penetrates, actively and joyously, the Father and the +Son and all that lives in them with such riches and such joy, that +all the creatures must be silent thereupon eternally, for the +incomprehensible marvel of this love surpasses eternally the +intelligence of all the creatures. But where we comprehend and taste +this amazement, without being amazed, there the spirit is above +itself, and one with the Spirit of God, and it tastes and sees, +without measure, like God, the riches which He is Himself in the +unity of the living foundation, where He possesses Himself according +to the unity of His uncreated essence. + +Now this delightful meeting is without interruption actively renewed +in us, according to the mode of God, for the Father gives Himself in +the Son, and the Son in the Father, in an eternal gratification and +a loving embrace, and this is renewed at every hour in the ties of +love; for even as the Father without interruption contemplates anew +all things in the birth of His Son, so all things are beloved anew, +by the Father and the Son, through the influence of the Holy Spirit. +And this is the eternal meeting of the Father and the Son, in which +we are lovingly wrapped by the Holy Spirit in eternal love. + +Now this active meeting and this loving embrace are, in their +foundation, joyous and without mode, for God's infinite absence of +mode is so obscure and so destitute of mode, that it envelopes in +itself every divine mode and every work, and the individuality of +the Persons, in the rich envelopment of essential unity, and forms a +divine rejoicing in the abyss of the unnameable. And here there is a +joyous and outflowing immersion in the essential nakedness, where +all the divine names and all the modes, and all divine reason, +reflected in the mirror of the divine truth, fall into simple +ineffability, in the absence of mode and of reason. For in this +boundless abyss of simplicity, all things are enveloped in joyous +blessedness, and the abyss remains itself uncomprehended save by the +essential unity. Before this essential unity, the Persons must give +way, and all that lives in God. For here is nought but an eternal +rest, in a joyous envelopment of loving immersion, and this is the +essence, without mode, which all interior spirits have chosen above +all other things. It is the dark silence in which all lovers are +lost. But if we could prepare ourselves thus for the virtues, we +should unclothe ourselves, so to speak, from life, and should float +on the wide expanses of this divine sea, and created things would no +longer have power to touch us. + +May we be able to possess, rejoicing, the essential unity, and +clearly to contemplate the Unity in Trinity; and may the divine +love, which rejects no suppliant, grant us this. Amen. + + + + + + +THEOLOGIA GERMANICA + + + + + +SIN AND SELFISHNESS + +SIN is nothing else but the turning away of the creature from the +unchangeable Good to the changeable; from the perfect to the +imperfect, and most often to itself. And when the creature claims +for its own anything good, such as substance, life, knowledge, or +power, as if it were that, or possessed it, or as if that proceeded +from itself, it goeth astray. What else did the devil do, and what +was his error and fall, except that he claimed for himself to be +something, and that something was his and was due to him? This claim +of his--this "I, me, and mine," were his error and his fall. And so +it is to this day. For what else did Adam do? It is said that Adam +was lost, or fell, because he ate the apple. I say, it was because +he claimed something for his own, because of his "I, me, and mine." +If he had eaten seven apples, and yet never claimed anything for his +own, he would not have fallen: but as soon as he called something +his own, he fell, and he would have fallen, though he had never +touched an apple. I have fallen a hundred times more often and more +grievously than Adam; and for his fall all mankind could not make +amends. How then shall my fall be amended? It must be healed even as +Adam's fall was healed. And how, and by whom, was that healing +wrought? Man could not do it without God, and God could not do it +without man. Therefore God took upon Himself human nature; He was +made man, and man was made God. Thus was the healing effected. So +also must my fall be healed. I cannot do the work without God, and +He may not or will not do it without me. If it is to be done, God +must be made man in me also; God must take into Himself all that is +in me, both within and without, so that there may be nothing in me +which strives against God or hinders His work. Now if God took to +Himself all men who are or ever lived in the world, and was made man +in them, and they were deified in Him, and this work were not +accomplished in me, my fall and my error would never be healed +unless this were accomplished in me also. And in this bringing back +and healing I can and shall do nothing of myself; I shall simply +commit myself to God, so that He alone may do and work all things in +me, and that I may suffer Him, and all His work, and His divine +will. And because I will not do this, but consider myself to be mine +own, and "I, me, and mine," and the like, God is impeded, and cannot +do His work in me alone and without let or hindrance; this is why my +fall and error remain unhealed. All comes of my claiming something +for my own. ii., iii. + +THE TWO EYES + +We should remember the saying that the soul of Christ had two eyes, +a right eye and a left eye. In the beginning, when the soul of +Christ was created, she fixed her right eye upon eternity and the +Godhead, and remained in the full beholding and fruition of the +Divine essence and eternal perfection; and thus remained unmoved by +all the accidents and labours, the suffering, anguish, and pain, +that befell the outer man. But with the left eye she looked upon the +creation, and beheld all things that are therein, and observed how +the creatures differ from each other, how they are better or worse, +nobler or baser; and after this manner was the outer man of Christ +ordered. Thus the inner man of Christ, according to the right eye of +His soul, stood in the full exercise of His Divine nature, in +perfect blessedness, joy, and eternal peace. But the outer man and +the left eye of the soul of Christ stood with Him in perfect +suffering, in all His tribulations, afflictions and labours; in such +a way that the inner or right eye remained unmoved, unimpeded and +untouched by all the labour, suffering, woe, and misery that +happened to the outer man. It has been said that when Jesus was +bound to the pillar and scourged, and when He hung on the cross, +according to the outer man, the inner man, a soul according to the +right eye, stood in as full possession of Divine joy and blessedness +as it did after the ascension, or as it does now. Even so His outer +man, or soul according to the left eye, was never impeded, +disturbed, or troubled by the inward eye in its contemplation of the +outward things which pertained to it. The created soul of man has +also two eyes. The one is the power of looking into eternity, the +other the power of looking into time and the creatures, of +perceiving how they differ from each other, of giving sustenance and +other things necessary to the body, and ordering and ruling it for +the best. But these two eyes of the soul cannot both perform their +office at once; if the soul would look with the right eye into +eternity, the left eye must be shut, and must cease to work: it must +be as if it were dead. For if the left eye is discharging its office +towards outward things--if it is holding conversation with time and +the creatures--then the right eye must be impeded in its working, +which is contemplation. Therefore, he who would have one must let +the other go; for no man can serve two masters. vii. + +A FORETASTE OF ETERNAL LIFE + +Some have asked whether it is possible for the soul, while it is +still in the body, to reach so great a height as to gaze into +eternity, and receive a foretaste of eternal life and blessedness. +This is commonly denied; and in a sense the denial is true. For +indeed it cannot come about, so long as the soul is occupied with +the body, and the things which minister to the body and belong to +it, and to time and created things, and is disturbed and troubled +and distracted by them. For the soul that would mount to such a +state, must be quite pure, entirely stripped and bare of all images; +it must be wholly separate from all creatures, and above all from +itself. Many think that this is impossible in this present life. But +St Dionysius claims that it is possible, as we find from his words +in his letter to Timothy, where he says: "In order to behold the +hidden things of God, thou shalt forsake sense and the things of the +flesh, and all that can be perceived by the senses, and all that +reason can bring forth by her own power, and all things created and +uncreated which reason can know and comprehend, and thou shalt stand +upon an utter abandonment of thyself, as if thou knewest none of +those things which I have mentioned, and thou shalt enter into union +with Him who is, and who is above all existence and knowledge." If +he did not think this to be possible in this present time, why did +he teach it and urge it upon us in this present time? But you ought +to know that a master has said, about this passage of St Dionysius, +that it is possible, and may come to a man so often that he may +become accustomed to it, and be able to gaze into eternity whenever +he will. And a single one of these glances is better, worthier, +higher, and more pleasing to God than all that the creature can do +as a creature. He who has attained to it asks for nothing more, for +he has found the kingdom of heaven and eternal life here on earth. +viii. + +DESCENT INTO HELL + +Even as the soul of Christ had to descend into hell, before it +ascended into heaven, so must the soul of man. And mark how this +comes to pass. When a man truly perceives and considers who and what +he is, and finds himself wholly base and wicked, and unworthy of all +the consolation and kindness that he ever received, either from God +or from the creatures, he falls into such a profound abasement and +contempt for himself, that he thinks himself unworthy to walk upon +the earth; he feels that he deserves that all creatures should rise +against him and avenge their Maker upon him with punishments and +torments; nay, even that were too good for him. And therefore he +will not and dare not desire any consolation or release, either from +God or any creature; he is willing to be unconsoled and unreleased, +and he does not lament for his condemnation and punishment, for they +are right and just, and in accordance with God's will. Nothing +grieves him but his own guilt and wickedness; for that is not right, +and is contrary to God's will: for this reason he is heavy and +troubled. This is the meaning of true repentance for sin. And the +man who in this life enters into this hell, enters afterwards into +the kingdom of heaven, and has a foretaste of it which exceeds all +the delights and happiness which he has ever had, or could have, +from the things of time. But while a man is in this hell, no one can +comfort him, neither God, nor the creatures. Of this condition it +has been written, "Let me die, let me perish! I live without hope; +from within and from without I am condemned, let no man pray for my +deliverance." Now God has not forsaken a man, while he is in this +hell, but He is laying His hand upon him, that he may desire nothing +but the eternal Good only, and may discover that this is so noble +and exceedingly good, that its blessedness cannot be searched out +nor expressed, comfort and joy, peace, rest, and satisfaction. When, +therefore, the man cares for and seeks and desires the eternal Good +and nought beside, and seeks not himself, nor his own things, but +the glory of God only, he is made to partake of every kind of joy, +blessedness, peace, rest, and comfort, and from that time forward is +in the kingdom of God. + +This hell and this heaven are two good safe ways for a man in this +present life, and he is happy who truly finds them. For this hell +shall pass away, but this heaven shall abide for evermore. Let a man +also observe, that when he is in this hell, nothing can console him; +and he cannot believe that he shall ever be delivered or comforted. +But when he is in heaven, nothing can disturb him: he believes that +no one will ever be able to offend or trouble him again, though it +is indeed possible that he may again be troubled and left +unconsoled. + +This heaven and hell come upon a man in such a way, that he knows +not whence they come; and he can do nothing himself towards making +them either come or depart. He can neither give them to himself, nor +take them away from himself, neither bring them nor drive them away; +even as it is written, "The wind bloweth where it listeth, and thou +hearest the sound thereof, but canst not tell whence it cometh or +whither it goeth." And when a man is in either of these two states, +all is well with him, and he is as safe in hell as in heaven. And +while a man is in the world, it is possible for him to pass many +times from the one state into the other--even within a day and +night, and without any motion of his own. But when a man is in +neither of these two states, he holds intercourse with the +creatures, and is carried this way and that, and knows not what +manner of man he is. A man should therefore never forget either of +these states, but carry the memory of them in his heart. xi. + +THE THREE STAGES + +Be well assured that none can be illuminated, unless he be first +cleansed, purified, or stripped. Also none can be united to God +unless he be first illuminated. There are therefore three +stages--first, the purification; secondly, the illumination; and +thirdly, the union. The purification belongs to those who are +beginning or repenting. It is effected in three ways; by repentance +and sorrow for sin, by full confession, and by hearty amendment. The +illumination belongs to those who are growing, and it also is +effected in three ways; by the renunciation of sin, by the practice +of virtue and good works, and by willing endurance of all trials and +temptations. The union belongs to those who are perfect, and this +also is effected in three ways; by pureness and singleness of heart, +by love, and by the contemplation of God, the Creator of all things. +xiv. + +THE LIFE OF CHRIST + +We ought truly to know and believe that no life is so noble, or +good, or pleasing to God, as the life of Christ. And yet it is to +nature and selfishness the most bitter of all lives. For to nature, +and selfishness, and the Me, a life of careless freedom is the +sweetest and pleasantest, but it is not the best; indeed, in some +men it may be the worst. But the life of Christ, though it be the +bitterest of all, should be preferred above all. And hereby ye shall +know this. There is an inward sight which is able to perceive the +one true good, how that it is neither this nor that, but that it is +that of which St Paul says: "When that which is perfect is come, +then that which is in part shall be done away." By this he signifies +that what is whole and perfect excels all the parts, and that all +which is imperfect, and in part, is as nothing compared to what is +perfect. In like manner, all knowledge of the parts is swallowed up +when the whole is known. And where the good is known, it cannot fail +to be desired and loved so greatly, that all other love, with which +a man has loved himself, and other things, vanishes away. Moreover, +that inward sight perceives what is best and noblest in all things, +and loves it in the one true good, and for the sake of the true good +alone. Where this inward sight exists, a man perceives truly that +the life of Christ is the best and noblest life, and that it is +therefore to be chosen above all others; and therefore he willingly +accepts and endures it, without hesitation or complaining, whether +it is pleasing or displeasing to nature and other men, and whether +he himself likes or dislikes it, and finds it sweet or bitter. +Therefore, whenever this perfect and true good is known, the life of +Christ must be followed, until the decease of the body. If any man +vainly deems otherwise, he is deceived, and if any man says +otherwise, he tells a lie; and in whatever man the life of Christ is +not, he will never know the true good or the eternal truth. + +But let no one imagine that we can attain to this true light and +perfect knowledge, and to the life of Christ, by much questioning, +or by listening to others, or by reading and study, or by ability +and deep learning. For so long as a man is occupied with anything +which is this or that, whether it be himself or any other creature; +or does anything, or forms plans, or opinions, or objects, he comes +not to the life of Christ. Christ Himself declared as much, for He +said: "If any man will come after Me, let him deny himself, and take +up his cross, and follow Me." "And if any man hate not his father +and mother, and wife and children, and brethren and sisters, yea and +his own life also, he cannot be my disciple." He means this: "He who +does not give up and abandon everything can never know My eternal +truth, nor attain to My life." And even if this had not been +declared to us, the truth itself proclaims it, for so verily it is. +But as long as a man holds fast to the rudiments and fragments of +this world, and above all to himself, and is conversant with them, +and sets great store by them, he is deceived and blinded, and +perceives what is good only in so far as is convenient and agreeable +to himself and profitable to his own objects. + +Since then the life of Christ is in all ways most bitter to nature +and the self and the Me--for in the true life of Christ nature and +the self and the Me must be abandoned and lost and suffered to die +completely--therefore in all of us nature has a horror of it, and +deems it evil and unjust and foolish; and she strives after such a +life as shall be most agreeable and pleasant to ourselves; and says, +and believes too in her blindness, that such a life is the best of +all. Now nothing is so agreeable and pleasant to nature as a free +and careless manner of life. To this therefore she clings, and takes +enjoyment in herself and her powers, and thinks only of her own +peace and comfort. And this is especially likely to happen, when a +man has high natural gifts of reason, for reason mounts up in its +own light and by its own power, till at last it comes to think +itself the true eternal light, and gives itself out to be such; and +it is thus deceived in itself, and deceives others at the same time, +people who know no better and are prone to be so deceived. +xviii.-xx. + +UNION WITH GOD + +In what does union with God consist? It means that we should be +indeed purely, simply, and wholly at one with the one eternal Will +of God, or altogether without will, so that the created will should +flow out into the eternal Will and be swallowed up and lost in it, +so that the eternal Will alone should do and leave undone in us. Now +observe what may be of use to us in attaining this object. Religious +exercises cannot do this, nor words, nor works, nor any creature or +work done by a creature. We must therefore give up and renounce all +things, suffering them to be what they are, and enter into union +with God. Yet the outward things must be; and sleeping and waking, +walking and standing still, speaking and being silent, must go on as +long as we live. + +But when this union truly comes to pass and is established, the +inner man henceforth stands immoveable in this union; as for the +outer man, God allows him to be moved hither and thither, from this +to that, among things which are necessary and right. So the outer +man says sincerely, "I have no wish to be or not to be, to live or +die, to know or be ignorant, to do or leave undone; I am ready for +all that is to be or ought to be, and obedient to whatever I have to +do or suffer." Thus the outer man has no purpose except to do what +in him lies to further the eternal Will. As for the inner man, it is +truly perceived that he shall stand immoveable, though the outer +man must needs be moved. And if the inner man has any explanation of +the actions of the outer man, he says only that such things as are +ordained by the eternal Will must be and ought to be. It is thus +when God Himself dwells in a man; as we plainly see in the case of +Christ. Moreover, where there is this union, which is the outflow of +the Divine light and dwells in its beams, there is no spiritual +pride nor boldness of spirit, but unbounded humility and a lowly +broken heart; there is also an honest and blameless walk, justice, +peace, contentment, and every virtue. Where these are not, there is +no true union. For even as neither this thing nor that can bring +about or further this union, so nothing can spoil or hinder it, +except the man himself with his self-will, which does him this great +injury. Be well assured of this. xxvii., xxviii. + +THE FALSE LIGHT + +Now I must tell you what the False Light is, and what belongs to it. +All that is contrary to the true light belongs to the false. It +belongs of necessity to the true light that it never seeks to +deceive, nor consents that anyone should be injured or deceived; and +it cannot be deceived itself. But the false light both deceives +others, and is deceived itself. Even as God deceives no man, and +wills not that any should be deceived, so it is with His true light. +The true light is God or Divine, but the false light is nature or +natural. It belongeth to God, that He is neither this nor that, and +that He requires nothing in the man whom He has made to be partaker +in the Divine nature, except goodness as goodness and for the sake +of goodness. This is the token of the true light. But it belongs to +the creature, and to nature, to be something, this or that, and to +intend and seek something, this or that, and not simply what is good +without asking Why. And as God and the true light are without all +self-will, selfishness, and self-Seeking, so the "I, Me, and Mine" +belong to the false light, which in everything seeks itself and its +own ends, and not goodness for the sake of goodness. This is the +character of the natural or carnal man in each of us. Now observe +how it first comes to be deceived. It does not desire or choose +goodness for its own sake, but desires and chooses itself and its +own ends rather than the highest good; and this is an error and the +first deception. Secondly, it fancies itself to be God, when it is +nothing but nature. And because it feigns itself to be God, it takes +to itself what belongs to God; and not that which belongs to God +when He is made man, or when He dwells in a Godlike man; but that +which belongs to God as He is in eternity without the creature. God, +they say, and say truly, needs nothing, is free, exempt from toil, +apart by Himself, above all things: He is unchangeable, immoveable, +and whatever He does is well done. "so will I be," says the false +light. "The more like one is to God, the better one is; I therefore +will be like God and will be God, and will sit and stand at His +right hand." This is what Lucifer the Evil Spirit also said. Now God +in eternity is without contradiction, suffering, and grief, and +nothing can injure or grieve Him. But with God as He is made man it +is otherwise. The false light thinks itself to be above all works, +words, customs, laws, and order, and above the life which Christ led +in the body which He possessed in His human nature. It also claims +to be unmoved by any works of the creatures; it cares not whether +they be good or bad, for God or against Him; it keeps itself aloof +from all things, and deems it fitting that all creatures should +serve it. Further, it says that it has risen beyond the life of +Christ according to the flesh, and that outward things can no longer +touch or pain it, even as it was with Christ after the Resurrection. +Many other strange and false notions it cherishes. Moreover, this +false light says that it has risen above conscience and the sense of +sin, and that whatever it does is right. One of the so-called "Free +Spirits" even said that if he had killed ten men, he would have as +little sense of guilt as if he had killed a dog. This false light, +in so far as it fancies itself to be God, is Lucifer, the Evil +Spirit; but in so far as it makes of no account the life of Christ, +it is Antichrist. It says, indeed, that Christ was without sense of +sin, and that therefore we should be so. We may reply that Satan +also is without sense of sin, and is none the better for that. What +is a sense of sin? It is when we perceive that man has turned away +from God in his will, and that this is man's fault, not God's, for +God is guiltless of sin. Now, who knows himself to be free from sin, +save Christ only? Scarce will any other affirm this. So he who is +without sense of sin is either Christ or the Evil Spirit. But where +the true light is, there is a true and just life such as God loves. +And if a man's life is not perfect, as was that of Christ, still it +is modelled and built on His, and His life is loved, together with +modesty, order, and the other virtues, and all self-will, the "I, +Me, and Mine," is lost; nothing is devised or sought for except +goodness for its own sake. But where the false light is, men no +longer regard the life of Christ and the virtues, but they seek and +purpose what is convenient and pleasant to nature. From this arises +a false liberty, whereby men become regardless of everything. For +the true light is the seed of God, and bringeth forth the fruits of +God; but the false light is the seed of the Devil, and where it is +sown, the fruits of the Devil, nay the very Devil himself, spring +up. xl. + +LIGHT AND LOVE + +It may be asked, What is it like to be a partaker of the Divine +nature, or a Godlike man? The answer is, that he who is steeped in, +or illuminated by, the eternal and Divine Light, and kindled or +consumed by the eternal and Divine Love, is a Godlike man and a +partaker of the Divine nature. But this light or knowledge is of no +avail without love. You may understand this if you remember that a +man who knows very well the difference between virtue and +wickedness, but does not love virtue, is not virtuous, in that he +obeys vice. But he who loves virtue follows after it, and his love +makes him an enemy to wickedness, so that he will not perform any +wicked act and hates wickedness in others; and he loves virtue so +that he would not leave any virtue unperformed even if he had the +choice, not for the sake of reward, but from love of virtue. To such +a man virtue brings its own reward, and he is content with it, and +would part with it for no riches. Such a man is already virtuous, or +in the way to become so. And the truly virtuous man would not cease +to be so to gain the whole world. He would rather die miserably. The +case of justice is the same. Many men know well what is just and +unjust, but yet neither are nor ever will be just men. For they love +not justice, and therefore practise wickedness and injustice. If a +man loved justice, he would do no unjust deed; he would feel so +great abhorrence and anger against injustice whenever he saw it that +he would be willing to do and suffer anything in order to put an end +to injustice, and that men might be made just. He would rather die +than commit an injustice, and all for love of justice. To him, +justice brings her own reward, she rewards him with herself, and so +the just man would rather die a thousand deaths than live as an +unjust man. The same may be said of truth. A man may know very well +what is truth or a lie, but if he loves not the truth, he is not a +true man. If, however, he loves it, it is with truth as with +justice. And of justice Isaiah speaks in the fifth chapter: "Woe +unto them that call evil good, and good evil, that put darkness for +light, and light for darkness; that put bitter for sweet, and sweet +for bitter." Thus we may understand that knowledge and light avail +nothing without love. We see the truth of this in the case of the +Evil One. He perceives and knows good and evil, right and wrong: but +since he has no love for the good that he sees, he becomes not good. +It is true indeed that Love must be led and instructed by knowledge, +but if knowledge is not followed by Love, it will be of no avail. So +also with God and Divine things. Although a man know much about God +and Divine things, and even dream that he sees and understands what +God Himself is, yet if he have not Love, he will never become like +God or a partaker of the Divine nature. But if Love be added to his +knowledge, he cannot help cleaving to God, and forsaking all that is +not God or from God, and hating it and fighting with it, and finding +it a cross and burden. And this Love so unites a man to God, that he +can never again be separated from Him. xli. + +PARADISE + +What is Paradise? All things that are. For all things are good and +pleasant, and may therefore fitly be called Paradise. It is also +said, that Paradise is an outer court of heaven. In the same way, +this world is truly an outer court of the eternal, or of eternity; +and this is specially true of any temporal things or creatures which +manifest the Eternal or remind us of eternity; for the creatures are +a guide and path to God and eternity. Thus the world is an outer +court of eternity, and therefore it may well be called a Paradise, +for so indeed it is. And in this Paradise all things are lawful +except one tree and its fruit. That is to say, of all things that +exist, nothing is forbidden or contrary to God, except one thing +only. That one thing is self-will, or to will otherwise than as the +eternal Will would have it. Remember this. For God says to Adam +(that is, to every man) "Whatever thou art, or doest, or leavest +undone, or whatever happens, is lawful if it be done for the sake of +and according to My will, and not according to thy will. But all +that is done from thy will is contrary to the eternal Will." Not +that everything which is so done is in itself contrary to the +eternal Will, but in so far as it is done from a different will, or +otherwise than from the Eternal and Divine Will. l. + +WILL AND SELF-WILL + +Some may ask: "If this tree, Self-Will, is so contrary to God and to +the eternal will, why did God create it, and place it in Paradise?" +We may answer: a man who is truly humble and enlightened does not +ask God to reveal His secrets to him, or enquire why God does this +or that, or prevents or allows this or that; he only desires to know +how he may please God, and become as nothing in himself, having no +will of his own, and that the eternal will may live in him, and +possess him wholly, unhampered by any other will, and how what is +due may be paid to the Eternal Will, by him and through him. But +there is another answer to this question. For we may say: the most +noble and gracious gift that is bestowed on any creature is the +Reason and the Will. These two are so intimately connected that the +one cannot be anywhere without the other. If it were not for these +two gifts, there would be no reasonable creatures, but only brutes +and brutality; and this would be a great loss, for God would then +never receive His due, or behold Himself and His attributes +exhibited in action; a thing which ought to be, and is, necessary to +perfection. Now Perception and Reason are conferred together with +will, in order that they may teach the will and also themselves, +that neither perception nor will is of itself, or to itself, nor +ought to seek or obey itself. Nor must they turn themselves to their +own profit, nor use themselves for their own ends; for they belong +to Him from whom they proceed, and they shall submit to Him, and +flow back to Him, and become nothing in themselves--that is, in +their selfhood. + +But now you must consider more in detail something concerning the +will. There is an Eternal Will, which is a first principle and +substance in God, apart from all works and all externalisation; and +the same will is in man, or the creature, willing and bringing to +pass certain things. For it pertains to the will, to will something. +For what else does it exist? It would be a vain thing if it had no +work to do, and this it cannot have without the creature. And so +there must needs be creatures, and God will have them, in order that +by their means the will may be exercised, and may work, though in +God it must be without work. Therefore the will in the creature, +which we call the created will, is as truly God's as the eternal +will, and is not from the creature. + +And since God cannot exercise His will, in working and effecting +changes, without the creature, He is pleased to do so in and with +the creature. Therefore the will is not given to be exercised by the +creature, but by God alone, who has the right to carry into effect +His own will by the will which is in man, but yet is God's will. And +in any man or creature, in whom it should be thus, purely and +simply, the will of that man or creature would be exercised not by +the man but by God, and thus it would not be self-will, and the man +would only will as God wills; for God Himself, and not man, would be +moving the will. Thus the will would be united with the Eternal +Will, and would flow into it; although the man would retain his +sense of liking and disliking, pleasure and pain. But nothing is +complained of, except what is contrary to God. And there is no +rejoicing except in God alone, and in that which belongs to Him. And +as with the will, so is it with all the other faculties of man; they +are all of God and not of man. And when the will is wholly given up +to God, the other faculties will certainly be given up too; and God +will have what is due to Him. + +No one may call that which is free his own, and he who makes it his +own, doeth injustice. Now in all the sphere of freedom nothing is so +free as the will; and he who makes it his own, and allows it not to +remain in its excellent freedom, and free nobleness, and free +exercise, does it a great injustice. This is what is done by the +devil, and Adam, and all their followers. But he who leaves the will +in its noble freedom does right; and this is what Christ, and all +who follow Him, do. And he who deprives the will of its noble +freedom, and makes it his own, must necessarily be oppressed with +cares and discontent, and disquietude, and every kind of misery, and +this will be his lot throughout time and eternity. But he who leaves +the will in its freedom has contentment and peace and rest and +blessedness, through time and eternity. Where there is a man whose +will is not enslaved, he is free indeed, and in bondage to no man. +He is one of those to whom Christ said: "The truth shall make you +free"; and He adds immediately afterwards: "If the Son shall make +you free, ye shall be free indeed." + +Moreover, observe that whenever the will chooses unhindered whatever +it will, it always and in all cases chooses what is noblest and +best, and hates whatever is not noble and good, and regards it as an +offence. And the more free and unhampered the will is, the more it +is grieved by evil, by injustice, by iniquity, and all manner of +sin. We see this in Christ, whose will was the purest and freest and +the least brought into bondage of any man's who ever lived. So was +the human nature of Christ the most free and pure of all creatures; +and yet He felt the deepest distress, pain, and wrath at sin that +any creature ever felt. But when men claim freedom for themselves, +in such a way as to feel no sorrow or anger at sin, and all that is +contrary to God, and say that we must take no notice of anything, +and care for nothing, but be, in this life, what Christ was after +the resurrection, and so forth, this is not the true and Divine +freedom that springs from the true and Divine light, but a natural, +unrighteous, false, deceiving freedom, which springs from the +natural, false, deceitful light. + +If there were no self-will, there would be no proprietorship. There +is no proprietorship in heaven; and this is why contentment, peace, +and blessedness are there. If anyone in heaven were so bold as to +call anything his own, he would immediately be cast out into hell, +and become an evil spirit. But in hell everyone will have self-will, +and therefore in hell is every kind of wretchedness and misery. And +so it is also on earth. But if anyone in hell could rid himself of +his self-will and call nothing his own, he would pass out of hell +into heaven. And if a man, while here on earth, could be entirely +rid of self-will and proprietorship, and stand up free and at +liberty in the true light of God, and continue therein, he would be +sure to inherit the kingdom of heaven. For he who has anything, or +who desires to have anything of his own, is a slave; and he who has +nothing of his own, nor desires to have anything, is free and at +liberty, and is in bondage to no man. li. + +UNION THROUGH CHRIST + +Observe now how the Father draws men to Christ. When something of +the perfect good is revealed and made manifest within the human +soul, as it were in a sudden flash, the soul conceives a desire to +draw near to the perfect goodness, and to unite herself with the +Father. And the more strongly she longs and desires, the more is +revealed to her; and the more is revealed to her, the more she is +drawn to the Father, and the more is her desire kindled. So the soul +is drawn and kindled into an union with the eternal goodness. And +this is the drawing of the Father; and so the soul is taught by Him +who draws her to Himself, that she cannot become united with Him +unless she can come to Him by means of the life of Christ. liii. + +[1]In his Introduction to the "Imitation of Christ," in this series. + +[2]e.g. she distinguishes, as Eckhart does, between God and the +Godhead. + +[3]The "three propositions" of Amalric are--1. "Deus est omnia." 2. +Every Christian, as a con-dition of salvation, must believe that he +is a member of Christ. 3. To those who are in charity no sin is +imputed. + +[4]Preger is probably wrong in identifying him with a "brother +Eckhart," Prior of Frankfort, who about 1320 was delated to the head +of the Order as suspectus de malis familiaritatibus, words which can +only mean "keeping bad company" in a moral sense, not "con-sorting +with heretics," as Preger suggests. Eckhart's character, so far as +we know, was never assailed, even by his enemies, and it is +therefore probable that "brother Eckhart" was a different person. + +[5]I have abridged the bull considerably, but have included all the +main accusations. + +[6]See pages 13, 16. + +[7]See pages 14, 15. + +[8]See page 1. + +[9]This is an obscure point in Eckhart's philosophy, too technical +to be discussed here; but Eckhart's doctrine of God is certainly +more orthodox and less pantheistic than those of 'Dionysius' and +Scotus Erigena. + +[10]Cf. St Augustine, In Joann. Ev. Tract. xxxix. 10: praeteritum et +futurum invenio in omni motu rerum: in veritate quae manet +praeteritum et futurum non invenio, sed solum praesens. + +[11]This doctrine is fully explained by St. Augustine, Epist. 237, +who follows Plotinus, Enn. vi. 4-6. + +[12]This queer word occurs for the first time, I think, in Jerome's +notes to the first chapter of Ezekiel. He writes the word in Greek, +and explains it as that part of the soul which always opposes vices. +The word is common in Bonaventura and other scholastic mystics, and +is often misspelt synderesis. + +[13]It must, however, be said that Preger is too ready to assume +that the logical development of Eckhart's system away from Thomist +scholasticism can be traced as a gradual process in his writings, +the order of which is very uncertain. We are not justified in saying +in a positive manner that Eckhart's philosophy passed through three +phases, in the first of which the primacy is held by the will, in +the second by the created reason, and in the third by the uncreated +reason. + +[14]See pages 14, 15. + +[15]C.B. Upton: "Hibbert Lectures," p. 17. + +[16]A.E. Taylor: "The Problem of Conduct," PP. 464-5. + +[17]See pages 71-2. + +[18]See pages 12-13. + +[19]See, for example, Prof. W. James' "Varieties of Religions +Experience," P. 400. + +[20]Jacob Bšhme's experience is typical: "Suddenly did my spirit +break through into the innermost birth or geniture of the Deity, and +there was I embraced with love, as a bridegroom embraces his dearly +beloved bride. But the greatness of the triumphing that was in the +spirit I cannot express in speech or writing; nor can it be compared +to anything but the resurrection of the dead to life. In this light +my spirit suddenly saw through all; even in herbs and grass it knew +God, who and what He is," etc. Dr Johnson was, no doubt, right in +thinking that "Jacob" would have been wiser, and "more like St +Paul," if he had not attempted to utter the unutterable things which +he saw. + +[21]The extracts from the "Theologia Germanica" will show that this +treatise represents a later and less paradoxical form of mystical +thought than Eckhart's. + +[22]The maxim, however, is much older than Suso. + +[23]Royce: "The World and the Individual" vol. i. p. 193. + +[24]So in the "Lignum Vitae" of Laurentius Justinianus we read: "Let +self-will cease, and there will be no more hell." + +[25] "The Inner Way," being thirty-six sermons by John Tauler. +Translated by A.W. Hutton, M.A. + +[26]On the psychology of ecstatic mysticism see Leuba, in the Revue +Philosophique, July and November 1902. + +[27] "Varieties of Religious Experience," p. 13. + +[28]Maudsley: "Natural Causes and Supernatural Seemings," p. 256. + +[29]See Leuba: "Tendances religieuses chez les mystiques +chrétiens" in Revue Philosophique, Nov. 1902. + +[30] "Theologia Germanica," translated by Susanna Winkworth. +Macmillan & Co., 1893. + +[31] "Varieties of Religious Experience," 1902. + +[32] "Personal Idealism," 1902. + +[33] "Varieties of Religious Experience," p. 103. + +[34] "In Tune with the Infinite," by R.W. Trine (Bell & Sons, 1902). +Fifty-ninth thousand. The extract appears to be a quotation from +another writer, but no reference is given. + +[35]Compare Eckhart's saying that the eye with which I see God is +the same as the eye with which He sees me. + +[36] "In Tune with the Infinite," pp. 58, 119. + +[37]The numbers refer to pages in Pfeiffer's edition. + +[38]The numbers refer to the Sermons in Hamberger's edition of 1864. + +[39]The reference is to 1 Peter iii. 8. + +[40]The time would, I suppose, be about half-an-hour. Many other +ecstatics have named this as the normal duration of trance. + +[41]Or, "spoke the eternal Wisdom (= the Word of God) in his heart." + +[42]John i. 3, 4. This punctuation, whereby the words "that which +was made" are referred to the clause which follows, and not to that +which precedes, is adopted by most of the Greek fathers, and is +still maintained by some good commentators--e.g. Bishop Westcott. + +[43]Ecclus. xxiv. 19. + +[44]Ecclus. xl. 20. + + +*** END OF THE PROJECT GUTENBERG EBOOK 4664 *** diff --git a/4664.txt b/4664.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d529f3d --- /dev/null +++ b/4664.txt @@ -0,0 +1,6848 @@ +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Light, Life, and Love +by W. R. Inge + +Copyright laws are changing all over the world. Be sure to check the +copyright laws for your country before downloading or redistributing +this or any other Project Gutenberg file. + +Please do not remove this header information. + +This header should be the first thing seen when anyone starts to +view the eBook. Do not change or edit it without written permission. +The words are carefully chosen to provide users with the information +needed to understand what they may and may not do with the eBook. +To encourage this, we have moved most of the information to the end, +rather than having it all here at the beginning. + + +**Welcome To The World of Free Plain Vanilla Electronic Texts** + +**eBooks Readable By Both Humans and By Computers, Since 1971** + +*****These eBooks Were Prepared By Thousands of Volunteers!***** + +Information on contacting Project Gutenberg to get eBooks, and +further information, is included below. We need your donations. + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a 501(c)(3) +organization with EIN [Employee Identification Number] 64-6221541 +Find out about how to make a donation at the bottom of this file. + + +Title: Light, Life, and Love + +Author: W. R. Inge + +Release Date: November, 2003 [Etext #4664] +[Yes, we are more than one year ahead of schedule] +[This file was first posted on February 25, 2002] + +Edition: 10 + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: Latin1 + +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Light, Life, and Love +by W. R. Inge +******This file should be named 4664.txt or 4664.zip****** + +Corrected EDITIONS of our etexts get a new NUMBER, lllov11.txt +VERSIONS based on separate sources get new LETTER, lllov10a.txt + +Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the US +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we usually do not +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +The "legal small print" and other information about this book +may now be found at the end of this file. Please read this +important information, as it gives you specific rights and +tells you about restrictions in how the file may be used. + +*** +This etext was produced by Charles Aldarondo. + +LIGHT, LIFE, AND LOVE + +Selections from the German Mystics of the Middle Ages + +by + +W. R. Inge + +LONDON +Second Edition + +1919 + + + + + + +CONTENTS + + + + + +INTRODUCTION +ECKHART +TAULER +MEDITATIONS ON THE SEVEN WORDS FROM THE CROSS +SUSO +RUYSBROEK +THEOLOGIA GERMANICA + + + + + + +INTRODUCTION + +Sect. 1. THE PRECURSORS OF THE GERMAN MYSTICS + + + + + +TO most English readers the "Imitation of Christ" is the +representative of mediaeval German mysticism. In reality, however, +this beautiful little treatise belongs to a period when that +movement had nearly spent itself. Thomas a Kempis, as Dr. Bigg has +said,[1] was only a semi-mystic. He tones down the most +characteristic doctrines of Eckhart, who is the great original +thinker of the German mystical school, and seems in some ways to +revert to an earlier type of devotional literature. The "Imitation" +may perhaps be described as an idealised picture of monastic piety, +drawn at a time when the life of the cloister no longer filled a +place of unchallenged usefulness in the social order of Europe. To +find German mysticism at its strongest we must go back a full +hundred years, and to understand its growth we must retrace our +steps as far as the great awakening of the thirteenth century--the +age of chivalry in religion--the age of St. Louis, of Francis and +Dominic, of Bonaventura and Thomas Aquinas. It was a vast revival, +bearing fruit in a new ardour of pity and charity, as well as in a +healthy freedom of thought. The Church, in recognising the new +charitable orders of Francis and Dominic, and the Christianised +Aristotelianism of the schoolmen, retained the loyalty and profited +by the zeal of the more sober reformers, but was unable to prevent +the diffusion of an independent critical spirit, in part provoked +and justified by real abuses. Discontent was aroused, not only by +the worldiness of the hierarchy, whose greed and luxurious living +were felt to be scandalous, but by the widespread economic distress +which prevailed over Western Europe at this period. The crusades +periodically swept off a large proportion of the able-bodied men, of +whom the majority never returned to their homes, and this helped to +swell the number of indigent women, who, having no male protectors, +were obliged to beg their bread. The better class of these female +mendicants soon formed themselves into uncloistered charitable +Orders, who were not forbidden to marry, and who devoted themselves +chiefly to the care of the sick. These Beguines and the +corresponding male associations of Beghards became very numerous in +Germany. Their religious views were of a definite type. Theirs was +an intensely inward religion, based on the longing of the soul for +immediate access to God. The more educated among them tended to +embrace a vague idealistic Pantheism. Mechthild of Magdeburg +(1212-1277), prophetess, poetess, Church reformer, quietist, was the +ablest of the Beguines. Her writings prove to us that the technical +terminology of German mysticism was in use before Eckhart,[2] and +also that the followers of what the "Theologia Germanica" calls the +False Light, who aspired to absorption in the Godhead, and despised +the imitation of the incarnate Christ, were already throwing +discredit on the movement. Mechthild's independence, and her +unsparing denunciations of corruption in high places, brought her +into conflict with the secular clergy. They tried to burn her +books--those religious love songs which had already endeared her to +German popular sentiment. It was then that she seemed to hear a +voice saying to her: + +Lieb' meine, betrbe dich nicht zu sehr, + +Die Wahrheit mag niemand verbrennen! + +The rulers of the Church, unhappily, were not content with burning +books. Their hostility towards the unrecognised Orders became more +and more pronounced: the Beghards and Beguines were harried and +persecuted till most of them were driven to join the Franciscans or +Dominicans, carrying with them into those Orders the ferment of +their speculative mysticism. The more stubborn "Brethren and Sisters +of the Free Spirit" were burned in batches at Cologne and elsewhere. +Their fate in those times did not excite much pity, for many of the +victims were idle vagabonds of dissolute character, and the general +public probably thought that the licensed begging friars were enough +of a nuisance without the addition of these free lances. + +The heretical mystical sects of the thirteenth century are very +interesting as illustrating the chief dangers of mysticism. Some of +these sectaries were Socialists or Communists of an extreme kind; +others were Rationalists, who taught that Jesus Christ was the son +of Joseph and a sinner like other men; others were Puritans, who +said that Church music was "nothing but a hellish noise" (nihil nisi +clamor inferni), and that the Pope was the magna meretrix of the +Apocalypse. The majority were Anti-Sacramentalists and Determinists; +and some were openly Antinomian, teaching that those who are led by +the Spirit can do no wrong. The followers of Amalric of Bena[3] +believed that the Holy Ghost had chosen their sect in which to +become incarnate; His presence among them was a continual guarantee +of sanctity and happiness. The "spiritual Franciscans" had dreams of +a more apocalyptic kind. They adopted the idea of an "eternal +Gospel," as expounded by Joachim of Floris, and believed that the +"third kingdom," that of the Spirit, was about to begin among +themselves. It was to abolish the secular Church and to inaugurate +the reign of true Christianity--i.e. "poverty" and asceticism. + +Such are some of the results of what our eighteenth-century +ancestors knew and dreaded as "Enthusiasm"--that ferment of the +spirit which in certain epochs spreads from soul to soul like an +epidemic, breaking all the fetters of authority, despising tradition +and rejecting discipline in its eagerness to get rid of formalism +and unreality; a lawless, turbulent, unmanageable spirit, in which, +notwithstanding, is a potentiality for good far higher than any to +which the lukewarm "religion of all sensible men" can ever attain. +For mysticism is the raw material of all religion; and it is easier +to discipline the enthusiast than to breathe enthusiasm into the +disciplinarian. + +Meanwhile, the Church looked with favour upon the orthodox mystical +school, of which Richard and Hugo of St. Victor, Bonaventura, and +Albertus Magnus were among the greatest names. These men were +working out in their own fashion the psychology of the contemplative +life, showing how we may ascend through "cogitation, meditation, and +speculation" to "contemplation," and how we may pass successively +through jubilus, ebrietas spiritus, spiritualis jucunditas, and +liquefactio, till we attain raptus or ecstasy. The writings of the +scholastic mystics are so overweighted with this pseudo-science, +with its wire-drawn distinctions and meaningless classifications, +that very few readers have now the patience to dig out their +numerous beauties. They are, however, still the classics of mystical +theology in the Roman Church, so far as that science has not +degenerated into mere miracle-mongering. + +Sect. 2. MEISTER ECKHART + +It was in 1260, when Mechthild of Magdeburg was at the height of her +activity, that Meister Eckhart, next to Plotinus the greatest +philosopher-mystic, was born at Hocheim in Thuringia. It seems that +his family was in a good position, but nothing is known of his early +years. He entered the Dominican Order as a youth, perhaps at +sixteen, the earliest age at which novices were admitted into that +Order. The course of instruction among the Dominicans was as +follows:--After two years, during which the novice laid the +foundations of a good general education, he devoted the next two +years to grammar, rhetoric, and dialectic, and then the same amount +of time to what was called the Quadrivium, which consisted of +"arithmetic, mathematics, astronomy, and music." Theology, the queen +of the sciences, occupied three years; and at the end of the course, +at the age of twenty-five, the brothers were ordained priests. We +find Eckhart, towards the end of the century, Prior of Erfurt and +Vicar of Thuringia, then Lector Biblicus at Paris, then Provincial +Prior of Saxony. In 1307 the master of the Order appointed him +Vicar-General for Bohemia, and in 1311 he returned to Paris. We find +him next preaching busily at Strassburg,[4] and after a few more +years, at Cologne, where the persecution of the Brethren of the Free +Spirit was just then at its height. At Strassburg there were no less +than seven convents of Dominican nuns, for since 1267 the Order had +resumed the supervision of female convents, which it had renounced a +short time after its foundation. Many of Eckhart's discourses were +addressed to these congregations of devout women, who indeed were to +a large extent the backbone of the mystical movement, and it is +impossible not to see that the devotional treatises of the school +are strongly coloured by feminine sentiment. A curious poem, written +by a Dominican nun of this period, celebrates the merits of three +preachers, the third of whom is a Master Eckhart, "who speaks to us +about Nothingness. He who understands him not, in him has never +shone the light divine." These nuns seem to have been fed with the +strong meat of Eckhart's mystical philosophy; in the more popular +sermons he tried to be intelligible to all. It was not very long +after he took up his residence at Cologne that he was himself +attacked for heresy. In 1327 he read before his own Order a +retractation of "any errors which might be found" (si quid errorum +repertum fuerit) in his writings, but withdrew nothing that he had +actually said, and protested that he believed himself to be +orthodox. He died a few months later, and it was not till 1329 that +a Papal bull was issued, enumerating seventeen heretical and eleven +objectionable doctrines in his writings. + +This bull is interesting as showing what were the points in +Eckhart's teaching which in the fourteenth century were considered +dangerous. They also indicate very accurately what are the real +errors into which speculative mysticism is liable to fall, and how +thinkers of this school may most plausibly be misrepresented by +those who differ from them. After expressing his sorrow that "a +certain Teuton named Ekardus, doctor, ut fertur, sacrae paginae, has +wished to know more than he should," and has sown tares and thistles +and other weeds in the field of the Church, the Pope specifies the +following erroneous statements as appearing in Eckhart's +writings[5]:--1. "God created the world as soon as God was. 2. In +every work, bad as well as good, the glory of God is equally +manifested. 3. A man who prays for any particular thing prays for an +evil and prays ill, for he prays for the negation of good and the +negation of God, and that God may be denied to him.[6] 4. God is +honoured in those who have renounced everything, even holiness and +the kingdom of heaven. 5. We are transformed totally into God, even +as in the Sacrament the bread is converted into the Body of Christ. +Unum, non simile. 6. Whatever God the Father gave to His +only-begotten Son in His human nature, He has given it all to me. 7. +Whatever the Holy Scripture says about Christ is verified in every +good and godlike man. 8. External action is not, properly speaking, +good nor divine; God, properly speaking, only works in us internal +actions. 9. God is one, in every way and according to every reason, +so that it is not possible to find any plurality in Him, either in +the intellect or outside it; for he who sees two, or sees any +distinction, does not see God; for God is one, outside number and +above number, for one cannot be put with anything else, but follows +it; therefore in God Himself no distinction can be or be understood. +10. All the creatures are absolutely nothing: I say not that they +are small or something, but that they are absolutely nothing." All +these statements are declared to have been found in his writings. It +is also "objected against the said Ekardus" that he taught the +following two articles in these words:--1. "There is something in +the soul, which is uncreated and uncreatable: if the whole soul were +such, it would be uncreated and uncreatable: and this is the +intelligence.[7] 2. God is not good or better or best: I speak ill +when I call God good; it is as if I called white black."[8] The bull +declares all the propositions above quoted to be heretical, with the +exception of the three which I have numbered 8-10, and these "have +an ill sound" and are "very rash," even if they might be so +supplemented and explained as to bear an orthodox sense. + +This condemnation led to a long neglect of Eckhart's writings. He +was almost forgotten till Franz Pfeiffer in 1857 collected and +edited his scattered treatises and endeavoured to distinguish those +which were genuine from those which were spurious. Since Pfeiffer's +edition fresh discoveries have been made, notably in 1880, when +Denifle found at Erfurt several important fragments in Latin, which +in his opinion show a closer dependence on the scholastic theology, +and particularly on St Thomas Aquinas, than Protestant scholars, +such as Preger, had been willing to allow. But the attempt to prove +Eckhart a mere scholastic is a failure; the audacities of his German +discourses cannot be explained as an accommodation to the tastes of +a peculiar audience. For good or evil Eckhart is an original and +independent thinker, whose theology is confined by no trammels of +authority. + +Sect. 3. ECKHART'S RELIGIOUS PHILOSOPHY + +The Godhead, according to Eckhart, is the universal and eternal +Unity comprehending and transcending all diversity. "The Divine +nature is Rest," he says in one of the German discourses; and in the +Latin fragments we find: "God rests in Himself, and makes all things +rest in Him." The three Persons of the Trinity, however, are not +mere modes or accidents,[9] but represent a real distinction within +the Godhead. God is unchangeable, and at the same time an +"everlasting process." The creatures are "absolutely nothing"; but +at the same time "God without them would not be God," for God is +love, and must objectify Himself; He is goodness, and must impart +Himself. As the picture in the mind of the painter, as the poem in +the mind of the poet, so was all creation in the mind of God from +all eternity, in uncreated simplicity. The ideal world was not +created in time; "the Father spake Himself and all the creatures in +His Son"; "they exist in the eternal Now"[10]--"a +becoming without a becoming, change without change." "The Word of +God the Father is the substance of all that exists, the life of all +that lives, the principle and cause of life." Of creation he says: +"We must not falsely imagine that God stood waiting for something to +happen, that He might create the world. For so soon as He was God, +so soon as He begat His coeternal and coequal Son, He created the +world." So Spinoza says: "God has always been before the creatures, +without even existing before them. He precedes them not by an +interval of time, but by a fixed eternity." This is not the same as +saying that the world of sense had no beginning; it is possible that +Eckhart did not mean to go further than the orthodox scholastic +mystic, Albertus Magnus, who says: "God created things from +eternity, but the things were not created from eternity." St +Augustine (Conf. xi. 30) bids objectors to "understand that there +can be no time without creatures, and cease to talk nonsense." +Eckhart also tries to distinguish between the "interior" and the +"exterior" action of God. God, he says, is in all things, not as +Nature, not as Person, but as Being. He is everywhere, undivided; +yet the creatures participate in Him according to their measure.[11] +The three Persons of the Trinity have impressed their image upon the +creatures, yet it is only their "nothingness" that keeps them +separate creatures. Most of this comes from the Neoplatonists, and +much of it through the pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite, a +Platonising Christian of the fifth century, whose writings were +believed in the Middle Ages to proceed from St Paul's Athenian +convert. It would, however, be easy to find parallels in St +Augustine's writings to most of the phases quoted in this paragraph. +The practical consequences will be considered presently. + +The creatures are a way from God; they are also a way to Him. "In +Christ," he says, "all the creatures are one man, and that man is +God." Grace, which is a real self-unfolding of God in the soul, can +make us "what God is by Nature"--one of Eckhart's audacious phrases, +which are not really so unorthodox as they sound. The following +prayer, which appears in one of his discourses, may perhaps be +defended as asking no more than our Lord prayed for (John xvii.) for +His disciples, but it lays him open to the charge, which the Pope's +bull did not fail to urge against him, that he made the servant +equal to his Lord. "Grant that I, by Thy grace, may be united to Thy +Nature, as Thy Son is eternally one in Thy Nature, and that grace +may become my nature." + +The ethical aim is to be rid of "creatureliness," and so to be +united to God. In Eckhart's system, as in that of Plotinus, +speculation is never divorced from ethics. On our side the process +is a negative one. All our knowledge must be reduced to +not-knowledge; our reason and will, as well as our lower faculties, +must transcend themselves, must die to live. We must detach +ourselves absolutely "even from God," he says. This state of +spiritual nudity he calls "poverty." Then, when our house is empty +of all else, God can dwell there: "He begets His Son in us." This +last phrase has always been a favourite with the mystics. St Paul +uses very similar language, and the Epistle to Diognetus, written in +the second century, speaks of Christ as, "being ever born anew in +the hearts of the saints." Very characteristic, too, is the doctrine +that complete detachment from the creatures is the way to union with +God. Jacob Bhme has arrived independently at the same conclusion as +Eckhart. "The scholar said to his master: How may I come to the +supersensual life, that I may see God and hear Him speak? The master +said: When thou canst throw thyself but for a moment into that place +where no creature dwelleth, then thou hearest what God speaketh. The +scholar asked: Is that near or far off? The master replied: It is in +thee, and if thou canst for a while cease from all thy thinking and +willing, thou shalt hear unspeakable words of God. The scholar said: +How can I hear, when I stand still from thinking and willing? The +master answered: When thou standest still from the thinking and +willing of self, the eternal hearing, seeing, and speaking will be +revealed to thee, and so God heareth and seeth through thee." + +In St Thomas Aquinas it is "the will enlightened by reason" which +unites us to God. But there are two sorts of reason. The passive +reason is the faculty which rises through discursive thinking to +knowledge. The active reason is a much higher faculty, which exists +by participation in the divine mind, "as the air is light by +participation in the sunshine." When this active reason is regarded +as the standard of moral action, it is called by Aquinas +synteresis.[12] Eckhart was at first content with this teaching of +St Thomas, whom he always cites with great reverence; but the whole +tendency of his thinking was to leave the unprofitable +classification of faculties in which the Victorine School almost +revelled, and to concentrate his attention on the union of the soul +with God. And therefore in his more developed teaching,[13] the +"spark" which is the point of contact between the soul and its Maker +is something higher than the faculties, being "uncreated." He seems +to waver about identifying the "spark" with the "active reason," but +inclines on the whole to regard it as something even higher still. +"There is something in the soul," he says, "which is so akin to God +that it is one with Him and not merely united with Him." And again: +"There is a force in the soul; and not only a force, but something +more, a being; and not only a being, but something more; it is so +pure and high and noble in itself that no creature can come there, +and God alone can dwelt there. Yea, verily, and even God cannot come +there with a form; He can only come with His simple divine nature." +And in the startling passage often quoted against him, a passage +which illustrates admirably his affinity to one side of Hegelianism, +we read: "The eye with which I see God is the same eye with which He +sees me. Mine eye and God's eye are one eye and one sight and one +knowledge and one love." + +I do not defend these passages as orthodox; but before exclaiming +"rank Pantheism!" we ought to recollect that for Eckhart the being +of God is quite different from His personality. Eckhart never taught +that the Persons of the Holy Trinity become, after the mystical +Union, the "Form" of the human soul. It is the impersonal light of +the divine nature which transforms our nature; human personality is +neither lost nor converted into divine personality. Moreover, the +divine spark at the centre of the soul is not the soul nor the +personality. "The soul," he says in one place, using a figure which +recurs in the "Theologia Germanica," "has two faces. One is turned +towards this world and towards the body, the other towards God." The +complete dominion of the "spark" over the soul is an unrealised +ideal.[14] + +The truth which he values is that, as Mr Upton[15] has well +expressed it, "there is a certain self-revelation of the eternal and +infinite One to the finite soul, and therefore an indestructible +basis for religious ideas and beliefs as distinguished from what is +called scientific knowledge. . . . This immanent universal principle +does not pertain to, and is not the property of any individual mind, +but belongs to that uncreated and eternal nature of God which lies +deeper than all those differences which separate individual minds +from each other, and is indeed that incarnation of the Eternal, who +though He is present in every finite thing, is still not broken up +into individualities, but remains one and the same eternal +substance, one and the same unifying principle, immanently and +indivisibly present in every one of the countless plurality of +finite individuals." It might further be urged that neither God nor +man can be understood in independence of each other. A recent writer +on ethics,[16] not too well disposed towards Christianity, is, I +think, right in saying: "To the popular mind, which assumes God and +man to be two different realities, each given in independence of the +other, . . . the identification of man's love of God with God's love +of Himself has always been a paradox and a stumbling-block. But it +is not too much to say that until it has been seen to be no paradox, +but a simple and fundamental truth, the masterpieces of the world's +religious literature must remain a sealed book to us." + +Eckhart certainly believed himself to have escaped the pitfall of +Pantheism; but he often expressed himself in such an unguarded way +that the charge may be brought against him with some show of reason. + +Love, Eckhart teaches, is the principle of all virtues; it is God +Himself. Next to it in dignity comes humility. The beauty of the +soul, he says in the true Platonic vein, is to be well ordered, with +the higher faculties above the lower, each in its proper place. The +will should be supreme over the understanding, the understanding +over the senses. Whatever we will earnestly, that we have, and no +one can hinder us from attaining that detachment from the creatures +in which our blessedness consists. + +Evil, from the highest standpoint, is only a means for realising the +eternal aim of God in creation; all will ultimately be overruled for +good. Nevertheless, we can frustrate the good will of God towards +us, and it is this, and not the thought of any insult against +Himself, that makes God grieve for our sins. It would not be worth +while to give any more quotations on this subject, for Eckhart is +not more successful than other philosophers in propounding a +consistent and intelligible theory of the place of evil in the +universe. + +Eckhart is well aware of the two chief pitfalls into which the +mystic is liable to fall--dreamy inactivity and Antinomianism. The +sects of the Free Spirit seem to have afforded a good object-lesson +in both these errors, as some of the Gnostic sects did in the second +century. Eckhart's teaching here is sound and good. Freedom from +law, he says, belongs only to the "spark," not to the faculties of +the soul, and no man can live always on the highest plane. +Contemplation is, in a sense, a means to activity; works of charity +are its proper fruit. "If a man were in an ecstasy like that of St +Paul, when he was caught up into the third heaven, and knew of a +poor man who needed his help, he ought to leave his ecstasy and help +the needy." Suso[17] tells us how God punished him for disregarding +this duty. True contemplation considers Reality (or Being) in its +manifestations as well as in its origin. If this is remembered, +there need be no conflict between social morality and the inner +life. Eckhart recognises[18] that it is a harder and a nobler task +to preserve detachment in a crowd than in a cell; the little daily +sacrifices of family life are often a greater trial than +self-imposed mortifications. "We need not destroy any little good in +ourselves for the sake of a better, but we should strive to grasp +every truth in its highest meaning, for no one good contradicts +another." "Love God, and do as you like, say the Free Spirits. Yes; +but as long as you like anything contrary to God's will, you do not +love Him." + +There is much more of the same kind in Eckhart's sermons--as good +and sensible doctrine as one could find anywhere. But what was the +practical effect of his teaching as a whole? It is generally the +case that the really weak points of any religious movement are +exposed with a cruel logicality most exasperating to the leaders by +the second generation of its adherents. The dangerous side of the +Eckhartian mysticism is painfully exhibited in the life of his +spiritual daughter, "Schwester Katrei," the saint of the later +Beguines. Katrei is a rather shadowy person; but for our present +purpose it does not much matter whether the story of her life has +been embroidered or not. Her memory was revered for such sayings and +doings as these which follow. On one occasion she exclaimed: +"Congratulate me; I have become God!" and on another she declared +that "not even the desire of heaven should tempt a good man towards +activity." It was her ambition to forget who were her parents, to be +indifferent whether she received absolution and partook of the Holy +Communion or not; and she finally realised her ambition by falling +into a cataleptic state in which she was supposed to be dead, and +was carried out for burial. Her confessor, perceiving that she was +not really dead, awoke her: "Art thou satisfied?" "I am satisfied at +last," said Katrei: she was now "dead all through," as she wished to +be. + +Are we to conclude that the logical outcome of mysticism is this +strange reproduction, in Teutonic Europe, of Indian Yogism? Many who +have studied the subject have satisfied themselves that Schwester +Katrei is the truly consistent mystic. They have come to the +conclusion that the real attraction of mysticism is a pining for +deliverance from this fretful, anxious, exacting, individual life, +and a yearning for absorption into the great Abyss where all +distinctions are merged in the Infinite. According to this view, +mysticism in its purest form should be studied in the ancient +religious literature of India, which teaches us how all this world +of colour and diversity, of sharp outlines and conflicting forces, +may be lost and swallowed up in the "white radiance," or black +darkness (it does not really matter which we call it) of an empty +Infinite. + +The present writer is convinced that this is not the truth about +mysticism. Eckhart may have encouraged Schwester Katrei in her +attempt to substitute the living death of the blank trance for the +dying life of Christian charity; but none the less she caricatured +and stultified his teaching. And I think it is possible to lay our +finger on the place where she and so many others went wrong. The +aspiration of mysticism is to find the unity which underlies all +diversity, or, in religious language, to see God face to face. From +the Many to the One is always the path of the mystic. Plotinus, the +father of all mystical philosophy in Europe (unless, as he himself +would have wished, we give that honour to Plato), mapped out the +upward road as follows:--At the bottom of the hill is the sphere of +the "merely many"--of material objects viewed in disconnection, +dull, and spiritless. This is a world which has no real existence; +it may best be called "not-being" ("ein lauteres Nichts," as Eckhart +says), and as the indeterminate, it can only be apprehended by a +corresponding indeterminateness in the soul. The soul, however, +always adds some form and determination to the abstract formlessness +of the "merely many." Next, we rise to, or project for ourselves, +the world of "the one and the many." This is the sphere in which our +consciousness normally moves. We are conscious of an overruling +Mind, but the creatures still seem external to and partially +independent of it. Such is the temporal order as we know it. Above +this is the intelligible world, the eternal order, "the one-many," +das ewige Nu, the world in which God's will is done perfectly and +all reflects the divine mind. Highest of all is "the One," the, +Absolute, the Godhead, of whom nothing can be predicated, because He +is above all distinctions. This Neoplatonic Absolute is the Godhead +of whom Eckhart says: "God never looked upon deed," and of whom +Angelus Silesius sings: + + "Und sieh, er ist nicht Wille, + Er ist ein' ewige Stille." + +Plotinus taught that the One, being superessential, can only be +apprehended in ecstasy, when thought, which still distinguishes +itself from its object, is transcended, and knower and known become +one. As Tennyson's Ancient Sage says: + + "If thou would'st hear the Nameless, and descend + Into the Temple-cave of thine own self, + There, brooding by the central altar, thou + May'st haply learn the Nameless hath a voice, + By which thou wilt abide, if thou be wise; + For knowledge is the swallow on the lake, + That sees and stirs the surface-shadow there + But never yet hath dipt into the Abysm." + +In the same way Eckhart taught that no creature can apprehend the +Godhead, and, therefore, that the spark in the centre of the soul +(this doctrine, too, is found in Plotinus) must be verily divine. +The logic of the theory is inexorable. If only like can know like, +we cannot know God except by a faculty which is itself divine. The +real question is whether God, as an object of knowledge and worship +for finite beings, is the absolute Godhead, who transcends all +distinctions. The mediaeval mystics held that this "flight of the +alone to the alone," as Plotinus calls it, is possible to men, and +that in it consists our highest blessedness. They were attracted +towards this view by several influences. First, there was the +tradition of Dionysius, to whom (e.g.) the author of the "Theologia +Germanica" appeals as an authority for the possibility of "beholding +the hidden things of God by utter abandonment of thyself, and of +entering into union with Him who is above all existence, and all +knowledge." Secondly, there was what a modern writer has called "the +attraction of the Abyss," the longing which some persons feel very +strongly to merge their individuality in a larger and better whole, +to get rid not only of selfishness but of self for ever. "Leave +nothing of myself in me," is Crashaw's prayer in his wonderful poem +on St Teresa. Thirdly, we may mention the awe and respect long paid +to ecstatic trances, the pathological nature of which was not +understood. The blank trance was a real experience; and as it could +be induced by a long course of ascetical exercises and fervid +devotions, it was naturally regarded as the crowning reward of +sanctity on earth. Nor would it be at all safe to reject the +evidence, which is very copious,[19] that the "dreamy state" may +issue in permanent spiritual gain. The methodical cultivation of it, +which is at the bottom of most of the strange austerities of the +ascetics, was not only (though it was partly) practised in the hope +of enjoying those spiritual raptures which are described as being +far more intense than any pleasures of sense[20]: it was the hope of +stirring to its depths the subconscious mind and permeating the +whole with the hidden energy of the divine Spirit that led to the +desire for visions and trances. Lastly, I think we must give a place +to the intellectual attraction of an uncompromising monistic theory +of the universe. Spiritualistic monism, when it is consistent with +itself, will always lean to semi-pantheistic mysticism rather than +to such a compromise with pluralism as Lotze and his numerous +followers in this country imagine to be possible. + +But it is possible to go a long way with the mystics and yet to +maintain that under no conditions whatever can a finite being escape +from the limitations of his finitude and see God or the world or +himself "with the same eye with which God sees" all things. The old +Hebrew belief, that to see the face of God is death, expresses the +truth under a mythical form. That the human mind, while still "in +the body pent," may obtain glimpses of the eternal order, and enjoy +foretastes of the bliss of heaven, is a belief which I, at least, +see no reason to reject. It involves no rash presumption, and is not +contrary to what may be readily believed about the state of immortal +spirits passing through a mortal life. But the explanation of the +blank trance as a temporary transit into the Absolute must be set +down as a pure delusion. It involves a conception of the divine +"Rest" which in his best moments Eckhart himself repudiates. "The +Rest of the Godhead," he says, "is not in that He is the source of +being, but in that He is the consummation of all being." This +profound saying expresses the truth, which he seems often to forget, +that the world-process must have a real value in God's sight--that +it is not a mere polarisation of the white radiance of eternity +broken up by the imperfection of our vision. Whatever theories we +may hold about Absolute Being, or an Absolute that is above Being, +we must make room for the Will, and for Time, which is the "form" of +the will, and for the creatures who inhabit time and space, as +having for us the value of reality. Nor shall we, if we are to +escape scepticism, be willing to admit that these appearances have +no sure relation to ultimate reality. We must not try to uncreate +the world in order to find God. We were created out of nothing, but +we cannot return to nothing, to find our Creator there. The still, +small voice is best listened for amid the discordant harmony of life +and death. + +The search for God is no exception to the mysterious law of human +nature, that we cannot get anything worth having--neither holiness +nor happiness nor wisdom--by trying for it directly. It must be +given us through something else. The recluse who lives like +Parnell's "Hermit": + +"Prayer all his business, all his pleasure praise," + +is not only a poor sort of saint, but he will offer a poor sort of +prayers and praises. He will miss real holiness for the same reason +that makes the pleasure-seeker miss real happiness. We must lose +ourselves in some worthy interest in order to find again both a +better self and an object higher than that which we sought. This the +German mystics in a sense knew well. There is a noble sentence of +Suso to the effect that "he who realises the inward in the outward, +to him the inward becomes more inward than to him who only +recognises the inward in the inward." Moreover, the recognition that +"God manifests Himself and worketh more in one creature than +another" ("Theologia Germanica"), involves a denial of the +nihilistic view that all the creatures are "ein lauteres +Nichts."[21] It would be easy to find such passages in all the +fourteenth-century mystics, but it cannot be denied that on the +whole their religion is too self-centred. There are not many maxims +so fundamentally wrong-headed and un-Christian as Suso's advice to +"live as if you were the only person in the world."[22] The life of +the cloistered saint may be abundantly justified--for the spiritual +activity of some of them has been of far greater service to mankind +than the fussy benevolence of many "practical" busybodies--but the +idea of social service, whether in the school of Martha or of Mary, +ought surely never to be absent. The image of Christ as the Lover of +the individual soul rather than as the Bridegroom of the Church was +too dear to these lonely men and women. Unconsciously, they looked +to their personal devotions to compensate them for the human loves +which they had forsworn. The raptures of Divine Love, which they +regarded as signal favours bestowed upon them, were not very +wholesome in themselves, and diverted their thoughts from the needs +of their fellow-men. They also led to most painful reactions, in +which the poor contemplative believed himself abandoned by God and +became a pray to terrible depression and melancholy. These fits of +wretchedness came indeed to be recognised as God's punishment for +selfishness in devotion and for too great desire for the sweetness +of communing with God, and so arose the doctrine of "disinterested +love," which was more and more emphasised in the later mysticism, +especially by the French Quietists. + +I have spoken quite candidly of the defects of Eckhart's mystical +Christianity. As a religious philosophy it does not keep clear of +the fallacy that an ascent though the unreal can lead to reality. +"To suppose, as the mystic does, that the finite search has of +itself no Being at all, is illusory, is Maya, is itself nothing, +this is also to deprive the Absolute of even its poor value as a +contrasting goal. For a goal that is a goal of no real process has +as little value as it has content."[23] But, as Prof. Royce says, +mysticism furnishes us with the means of correcting itself. It +supplies an obvious reductio ad absurdum of the theory with which it +set out, that "Immediacy is the one test of reality," and is itself +forced to give the world of diversity a real value as manifesting in +different degrees the nature of God. Those who are acquainted with +the sacred books of the East will recognise that here is the +decisive departure from real Pantheism. And it may be fairly claimed +for the German mystics that though their speculative teaching +sometimes seems to echo too ominously the apathetic detachment of +the Indian sage, their lives and example, and their practical +exhortations, preached a truer and a larger philosophy. Eckhart, as +we have seen, was a busy preacher as well as a keen student, and +some of the younger members of his school were even more occupied in +pastoral work. If the tree is to be judged by its fruits, mysticism +can give a very good account of itself to the Marthas as well as the +Marys of this world. + +Sect. 4. THE GERMAN MYSTICS AS GUIDES TO HOLINESS + +THIS little volume is a contribution to a "Library of Devotion," and +in the body of the work the reader will be seldom troubled by any +abstruse philosophising. I have thought it necessary to give, in +this Introduction, a short account of Eckhart's system, but the +extracts which follow are taken mainly from his successors, in whom +the speculative tendency is weaker and less original, while the +religious element is stronger and more attractive. It is, after all, +as guides to holiness that these mystics are chiefly important to +us. This side of their life's work can never be out of date, for the +deeper currents of human nature change but little; the language of +the heart is readily understood everywhere and at all times. The +differences between Catholic and Protestant are hardly felt in the +keen air of these high summits. It was Luther himself who discovered +the "Theologia Germanica" and said of it that, "next to the Bible +and St Augustine, no book hath ever come into my hands whence I have +learnt or would wish to learn more of what God and Christ and man +and all things are. I thank God that I have heard and found my God +in the German tongue, as I have not yet found Him in Latin, Greek, +or Hebrew." The theology of these mystics takes us straight back to +the Johannine doctrine of Christ as the all-pervading Word of God, +by whom all things were made and in whom all things hold together. +He is not far from any one of us if we will but seek Him where He is +to be found--in the innermost sanctuary of our personal life. In +personal religion this means that no part of revelation is to be +regarded as past, isolated, or external. "We should mark and know of +a very truth," says the author of the "Theologia Germanica," "that +all manner of virtue and goodness, and even the eternal Good which +is God Himself, can never make a man virtuous, good, or happy, so +long as it is outside the soul." In the same spirit Jacob Bhme, 250 +years later, says: "If the sacrifice of Christ is to avail for me, +it must be wrought in me." Or, as his English admirer, William Law, +puts it: "Christ given for us is neither more nor less than Christ +given into us. He is in no other sense our full, perfect, and +sufficient Atonement than as His nature and spirit are born and +formed in us." The whole process of redemption must in a sense be +reenacted in the inner life of every Christian. And as Christ +emptied Himself for our sakes, so must we empty ourselves of all +self-seeking. "When the creature claimeth for its own anything good, +such as life, knowledge, or power, and in short whatever we commonly +call good, as if it were that, or possessed that--it goeth astray." +Sin is nothing else but self-assertion, self-will. "Be assured," +says the "Theologia Germanica," "that he who helpeth a man to his +own will, helpeth him to the worst that he can." He, therefore, who +is "simply and wholly bereft of self" is delivered from sin, and God +alone reigns in his inmost soul. Concerning the highest part or +faculty of the soul, the author of this little treatise follows +Eckhart, but cautiously. "The True Light," he says, "is that eternal +Light which is God; or else it is a created light, but yet Divine, +which is called grace." In either case, "where God dwells in a godly +man, in such a man somewhat appertaineth to God which is His own, +and belongs to Him only and not to the creature." This doctrine of +divine immanence, for which there is ample warrant in the New +Testament, is the real kernel of German mysticism. It is a doctrine +which, when rightly used, may make this world a foretaste of heaven, +but alas! the "False Light" is always trying to counterfeit the +true. In the imitation of the suffering life of Christ lies the only +means of escaping the deceptions of the Evil One. "The False Light +dreameth itself to be God, and sinless"; but "none is without sin; +if any is without consciousness of sin, he must be either Christ or +the Evil Spirit." + +Very characteristic is the teaching of all these writers about +rewards and punishments. Without in any way impugning the Church +doctrine of future retribution, they yet agree with Benjamin +Whichcote, the Cambridge Platonist, that "heaven is first a temper, +then a place"; while of hell there is much to recall the noble +sentence of Juliana of Norwich, the fourteenth-century visionary, +"to me was showed no harder hell than sin." "Nothing burneth in hell +but self-will," is a saying in the "Theologia Germanica."[24] They +insist that the difference between heaven and hell is not that one +is a place of enjoyment, the other of torment; it is that in the one +we are with Christ, in the other without Him. "The Christlike life +is not chosen," to quote the "Theologia Germanica" once more, "in +order to serve any end, or to get anything by it, but for love of +its nobleness, and because God loveth and esteemeth it so highly. He +who doth not take it up for love, hath none of it at all; he may +dream indeed that he hath put it on, but he is deceived. Christ did +not lead such a life as this for the sake of reward, but out of +love, and love maketh such a life light, and taketh away all its +hardships, so that it becometh sweet and is gladly endured." The +truly religious man is always more concerned about what God will do +in him than what He will do to him; in his intense desire for the +purification of his motives he almost wishes that heaven and hell +were blotted out, that he might serve God for Himself alone. + +Sect. 5. WRITERS OF THE SCHOOL OF ECKHART--TAULER + +Such are the main characteristics of the religious teachings which +we find in the German mystics. Among the successors of Eckhart, from +whose writings the following extracts are taken, the most notable +names are those of Tauler, Suso, and Ruysbroek. From Tauler I have +taken very little, because a volume of selections from his sermons +has already appeared in this series.[25] Accordingly, it will only +be necessary to mention a very few facts about his life. + +John Tauler was born at Strassburg about 1300, and studied at the +Dominican convents of Strassburg and Cologne. At both places he +doubtless heard the sermons of Eckhart. In 1329 the great interdict +began at Strassburg, and was stoutly resisted by many of the clergy. +It is a disputed point whether Tauler himself obeyed the Papal +decree or not. His uneventful life, which was devoted to study, +preaching, and pastoral work, came to an end in 1361. Like Eckhart, +he had a favourite "spiritual daughter," Margaret Ebner, who won a +great reputation as a visionary. + +Sect. 6. SUSO + +Henry Suso was born in 1295 and died in 1365. His autobiography was +published not long before his death. He is the poet of the band. The +romance of saintship is depicted by him with a strange vividness +which alternately attracts and repels, or even disgusts, the modern +reader. The whole-hearted devotion of the "Servitor" to the "Divine +Wisdom," the tender beauty of the visions and conversations, and the +occasional navet of the narrative, which shows that the saint +remained very human throughout, make Suso's books delightful +reading; but the accounts of the horrible macerations to which he +subjected himself for many years shock our moral sense almost as +much as our sensibilities; we do not now believe that God takes +pleasure in sufferings inflicted in His honour. Moreover, the erotic +symbolism of the visions is occasionally unpleasant: we are no +longer in the company of such sane and healthy people as Eckhart and +Tauler. The half-sensuous pleasure of ecstasy was evidently a +temptation to Suso, and the violent alternations of rapture and +misery which he experienced suggest a neurotic and ill-balanced +temperament.[26] + +On this subject--the pathological side of mysticism--a few remarks +will not be out of place, for there has been much discussion of it +lately. A great deal of nonsense has been written on the connexion +between religion and neuroticism. To quote Professor James' vigorous +protest, "medical materialism finishes up St Paul by calling his +vision on the road to Damascus a discharging lesion of the occipital +cortex, he being an epileptic. It snuffs out St Teresa as an +hysteric, St Francis of Assisi as an hereditary degenerate. George +Fox's discontent with the shams of his age, and his pining for +spiritual veracity, it treats as a symptom of a disordered colon. +Carlyle's organ-tones of misery it accounts for by a gastro-duodenal +catarrh. All such mental over-tensions, it says, are, when you come +to the bottom of the matter, mere affairs of diathesis +(auto-intoxications most probably), due to the perverted action of +various glands which physiology will yet discover."[27] Now, even if +it were true that most religious geniuses, like most other geniuses, +have been "psychopaths" of one kind or another, this fact in no way +disposes of the value of their intuitions and experiences. Nearly +all the great benefactors of humanity have been persons of +one-sided, and therefore ill-balanced, characters. Even Maudsley +admits that "Nature may find an incomplete mind a more suitable +instrument for a particular purpose. It is the work that is done, +and the quality in the worker by which it is done, that is alone of +moment; and it may be no great matter from a cosmical standpoint, if +in other qualities of character he (the genius) was singularly +defective."[28] Except in the character of our Lord Himself, there +are visible imperfections in the record of every great saint; but +that is no reason for allowing such traces of human infirmity to +discredit what is pure and good in their work. More particularly, it +would be a great pity to let our minds dwell on the favourite +materialistic theory that saintliness, especially as cultivated and +venerated by Catholicism, has its basis in "perverted sexuality." +There is enough plausibility in the theory to make it mischievous. +The allegorical interpretation of the Book of Canticles was in truth +the source of, or at least the model for, a vast amount of +unwholesome and repulsive pietism. Not a word need be said for such +a paltry narrative of endearments and sickly compliments as the +"Revelations of the Nun Gertrude," in the thirteenth century. Nor +are we concerned to deny that the artificially induced ecstasy, +which is desired on account of the intense pleasure which is said to +accompany it, nearly always contains elements the recognition of +which would shock and distress the contemplatives themselves.[29] +There are, however, other elements, of a less insidious kind, which +make the ecstatic trance seem desirable. These are, according to +Professor Leuba, the calming of the restless intellect by the +concentration of the mind on one object; the longing for a support +and comfort more perfect than man can give; and, thirdly, the +consecration and strengthening of the will, which is often a +permanent effect of the trance. These are legitimate objects of +desire, and in many of the mystics they are much more prominent than +any tendencies which might be considered morbid. As regards the +larger question, about the alleged pathological character of all +distinctively religious exaltation, I believe that no greater +mistake could be made than to suppose that the religious life +flourishes best in unnatural circumstances. Religion, from a +biological standpoint, I take to be the expression of the racial +will to live; its function (from this point of view) is the +preservation and development of humanity on the highest possible +level. If this is true, a simple, healthy, natural life must be the +most favourable for religious excellence--and this I believe to be +the case. Poor Suso certainly did not lead a healthy or natural +life. But in his case, though the suppressed natural instincts +obviously overflow into the religious consciousness and in part +determine the forms which his devotion assumes, we can never forget +that we are in the company of a poet and a saint who will lift us, +if we can follow him, into a very high region of the spiritual life, +an altitude which he has himself climbed with bleeding feet. + +The simple confidence which at the end of the dialogue he expresses +in the value of his work is, I think, amply justified. "Whoever will +read these writings of mine in a right spirit, can hardly fail to be +stirred to the depths of his soul, either to fervent love, or to new +light, or to hunger and thirst for God, or to hatred and loathing +for his sins, or to that spiritual aspiration by which the soul is +renewed in grace." + +Sect. 7. RUYSBROEK + +[Note: the Ruysbroek selection has not been reproduced in this +electronic edition. An electronic text of a larger collection of +Ruysbroek's works may be available.] + +Sect. 8. THEOLOGIA GERMANICA + +The "Theologia Germanica," an isolated treatise of no great length +by an unknown author, was written towards the end of the fourteenth +century by one of the Gottesfreunde, a widespread association of +pious souls in Germany. He is said to have been "a priest and warden +of the house of the Teutonic Order at Frankfort." His book is both +the latest and one of the most important productions of the German +mystical school founded by Eckhart. The author is a deeply religious +philosopher, as much interested in speculative mysticism as Eckhart +himself, but as thoroughly penetrated with devout feeling as Thomas + Kempis. The treatise should be read by all, as one of the very +best devotional works in any language. My only reason for not +translating it in full here is that a good English translation +already exists,[30] so that it seemed unnecessary to offer a new one +to the public. I have therefore only translated a few characteristic +passages, which are very far from exhausting its beauties, and a few +of the more striking aphorisms, which indicate the main points in +the religious philosophy of the writer. + +Sect. 9. MODERN MYSTICISM + +The revival of interest in the old mystical writers is not +surprising when we consider the whole trend of modern thought. Among +recent philosophers--though Lotze, perhaps the greatest name among +them, is unsympathetic, in consequence of his over-rigid theory of +personality--the great psychologist Fechner, whose religious +philosophy is not so well known in this country as it deserves to +be, has with some justice been called a mystic. And our own greatest +living metaphysician, Mr F.H. Bradley, has expounded the dialectic +of speculative mysticism with unequalled power, though with a bias +against Christianity. Another significant fact is the great +popularity, all over Europe, of Maeterlinck's mystical works, "Le +Trsor des Humbles," "La Sagesse et la Destine," and "Le +Temple Enseveli." + +The growing science of psychology has begun to turn its attention +seriously to the study of the religious faculty. Several able men +have set themselves to collect material which may form the basis of +an inductive science. Personal experiences, communicated by many +persons of both sexes and of various ages, occupations, and levels +of culture, have been brought together and tabulated. It is claimed +that important facts have already been established, particularly in +connexion with the phenomena of conversion, by this method. The +results have certainly been more than enough to justify confidence +in the soundness of the method, and hope that the new science may +have a great future before it. Towards mysticism, recent writers on +the psychology of religion have been less favourable than the pure +metaphysicians. While the latter have shown a tendency towards +Pantheism and Determinism, which makes them sympathise with the +general trend of speculative mysticism, psychology seems just at +present to lean towards a pluralistic metaphysic and a belief in +free-will or even in chance. This attitude is especially noticeable +in the now famous Gifford Lectures of Professor William James[31] +and in the recent volume of essays written at Oxford.[32] But even +if the rising tide of neo-Kantianism should cause the speculative +mystics to be regarded with disfavour, nothing can prevent the +religion of the twentieth century from being mystical in type. The +strongest wish of a vast number of earnest men and women to-day is +for a basis of religious belief which shall rest, not upon tradition +or external authority or historical evidence, but upon the +ascertainable facts of human experience. The craving for immediacy, +which we have seen to be characteristic of all mysticism, now takes +the form of a desire to establish the validity of the +God-consciousness as a normal part of the healthy inner life. We may +perhaps venture to predict that the Christian biologist of the +future will turn the Pauline Christology into his own dialect +somewhat after the following fashion:--"The function of religion in +the human race is closely analogous to, if not identical with, that +of instinct in the lower animals. Religion is the racial will to +live; not, however, to live anyhow and at all costs, but to live as +human beings, conforming as far as possible to the highest type of +humanity. Religion, therefore, acts as a higher instinct, inhibiting +all self-destroying and race-destroying impulses in the interest of +a larger self than the individual life." To turn this statement into +theological form it is only necessary to claim that the "perfect +man" which the religious instinct is trying to form is "the measure +of the stature of the fulness of Christ," that that perfect humanity +was once realised in the historical Christ, and that the higher +instinct within us--ourselves, yet not ourselves--which makes for +life and righteousness, and is the source of all the good that we +can think, say, or do, may (in virtue of that historical +incarnation) be justly called the indwelling Christ. This is all +that the Christian mystic needs. + +Sect. 10. SPECIMENS OF MODERN MYSTICISM + +I conclude this introductory essay with a few extracts from recent +American books on the psychology of religion. It is interesting to +find some of the strangest experiences of the cloister reproduced +under the very different conditions of modern American life. The +quotations will serve to show how far Tauler and the "Theologia +Germanica" are from being out of date. + +"The thing which impressed me most" (says a correspondent of +Professor William James)[33] "was learning the fact that we must be +in absolutely constant relation or mental touch with that essence of +life which permeates all and which we call God. This is almost +unrecognisable unless we live into it ourselves actually--that is, +by a constant turning to the very innermost, deepest consciousness +of our real selves or of God in us, for illumination from within, +just as we turn to the sun for light, warmth, and invigoration +without. When you do this consciously, realising that to turn inward +to the light within you is to live in the presence of God or of your +Divine self, you soon discover the unreality of the objects to which +you have hitherto been turning and which have engrossed you +without." + +The next quotation comes from a small book by one of the "New +Thought" or "Mind Cure" school in America. The enormous sale of the +volume testifies to the popularity of the teaching which it +contains.[34] + +"Intuition is an inner spiritual sense through which man is opened +to the direct revelation and knowledge of God, the secret of nature +and life, and through which he is brought into conscious unity and +fellowship with God, and made to realise his own deific nature and +supremacy of being as the son of God. Spiritual supremacy and +illumination thus realised through the development and perfection of +intuition under divine inspiration gives the perfect inner vision +and direct insight into the character, properties, and purpose of +all things to which the attention and interest are directed. It is, +we repeat, a spiritual sense opening inwardly, as the physical +senses open outwardly; and because it has the capacity to perceive, +grasp, and know the truth at first hand, independent of all external +sources of information, we call it intuition. All inspired teaching +and spiritual revelations are based upon the recognition of this +spiritual faculty of the soul and its power to receive and +appropriate them. Conscious unity of man in spirit and purpose with +the Father, born out of his supreme desire and trust, opens his soul +through this inner sense to immediate aspiration and enlightenment +from the divine omniscience, and the co-operative energy of the +divine omnipotence, under which he becomes a seer and a master. On +this higher plane of realised spiritual life in the flesh the mind +acts with unfettered freedom and unbiassed vision, grasping truth at +first hand, independent of all external sources of information. +Approaching all beings and things from the divine side, they are +seen in the light of the divine omniscience.[35] God's purpose in +them, and so the truth concerning them, as it rests in the mind of +God, are thus revealed by direct illumination from the divine mind, +to which the soul is opened inwardly through this spiritual sense we +call intuition." + +The practice of meditation "without images," as the mediaeval +mystics called it, is specially recommended. "Many will receive +great help, and many will be entirely healed by a practice somewhat +after the following nature:--With a mind at peace, and with a heart +going out in love to all, go into the quiet of your own interior +self, holding the thought, I am one with the Infinite Spirit of +Life, the life of my life. I now open my body, in which disease has +gotten a foothold, I open it fully to the inflowing tide of this +infinite life, and it now, even now, is pouring in and coursing +through my body, and the healing process is going on." "If you would +find the highest, the fullest, and the richest life that not only +this world but that any world can know, then do away with the sense +of the separateness of your life from the life of God. Hold to the +thought of your oneness. In the degree that you do this, you will +find yourself realising it more and more, and as this life of +realisation is lived, you will find that no good thing will be +withheld, for all things are included in this."[36] + +This modern mysticism is very much entangled with theories about the +cure of bodily disease by suggestion; and it is fair to warn those +who are unacquainted with the books of this sect that they will find +much fantastic superstition mixed with a stimulating faith in the +inner light as the voice of God. + +But whatever may be the course of this particular movement there can +be no doubt that the Americans, like ourselves, are only at the +beginning of a great revival of mystical religion. The movement will +probably follow the same course as the mediaeval movement in +Germany, with which this little book is concerned. It will have its +philosophical supportees, who will press their speculation to the +verge of Pantheism, perhaps reviving the Logos-cosmology of the +Christian Alexandrians under the form of the pan-psychism of Lotze +and Fechner. It will have its evangelists like Tauler, who will +carry to our crowded town populations the glad tidings that the +kingdom of God is not here or there, but within the hearts of all +who will seek for it within them. It will assuredly attract some to +a life of solitary contemplation; while others, intellectually +weaker or less serious, will follow the various theosophical and +theurgical delusions which, from the days of Iamblichus downward, +have dogged the heels of mysticism. For the "False Light" against +which the "Theologia Germanica" warns us is as dangerous as ever; we +may even live to see some new "Brethren of the Free Spirit" turning +their liberty into a cloak of licentiousness. If so, the world will +soon whistle back the disciplinarian with his traditions of the +elders; prophesying will once more be suppressed and discredited, +and a new crystallising process will begin. But before that time +comes some changes may possibly take place in the external +proportions of Christian orthodoxy. The appearance of a vigorous +body of faith, standing firmly on its own feet, may even have the +effect of relegating to the sphere of pious opinion some tenets +which have hitherto "seemed to be pillars." + +For these periodical returns to the "fresh springs" of religion +never leave the tradition exactly where it was before. The German +movement of the fourteenth century made the Reformation inevitable, +and our own age may be inaugurating a change no less momentous, +which will restore in the twentieth century some of the features of +Apostolic Christianity. + + + + + + +LIGHT, LIFE AND LOVE + +ECKHART + + + + + +GOD + +GOD is nameless, for no man can either say or understand aught about +Him. If I say, God is good, it is not true; nay more; I am good, God +is not good. I may even say, I am better than God; for whatever is +good, may become better, and whatever may become better, may become +best. Now God is not good, for He cannot become better. And if He +cannot become better, He cannot become best, for these three things, +good, better, and best, are far from God, since He is above all. If +I also say, God is wise, it is not true; I am wiser than He. If I +also say, God is a Being, it is not true; He is transcendent Being +and superessential Nothingness. Concerning this St Augustine says: +the best thing that man can say about God is to be able to be silent +about Him, from the wisdom of his inner judgement. Therefore be +silent and prate not about God, for whenever thou dost prate about +God, thou liest, and committest sin. If thou wilt be without sin, +prate not about God. Thou canst understand nought about God, for He +is above all understanding. A master saith: If I had a God whom I +could understand, I would never hold Him to be God. (318)[37] + +God is not only a Father of all good things, as being their First +Cause and Creator, but He is also their Mother, since He remains +with the creatures which have from Him their being and existence, +and maintains them continually in their being. If God did not abide +with and in the creatures, they must necessarily have fallen back, +so soon as they were created, into the nothingness out of which they +were created. (610) + +REST ONLY IN GOD + +IF I had everything that I could desire, and my finger ached, I +should not have everything, for I should have a pain in my finger, +and so long as that remained, I should not enjoy full comfort. Bread +is comfortable for men, when they are hungry; but when they are +thirsty, they find no more comfort in bread than in a stone. So it +is with clothes, they are welcome to men, when they are cold; but +when they are too hot, clothes give them no comfort. And so it is +with all the creatures. The comfort which they promise is only on +the surface, like froth, and it always carries with it a want. But +God's comfort is clear and has nothing wanting: it is full and +complete, and God is constrained to give it thee, for He cannot +cease till He have given thee Himself. (300) + +It is only in God that are collected and united all the perfections, +which in the creatures are sundered and divided. (324) + +Yet all the fulness of the creatures can as little express God, as a +drop of water can express the sea. (173) + +GOD IS ALWAYS READY + +NO one ought to think that it is difficult to come to Him, though it +sounds difficult and is really difficult at the beginning, and in +separating oneself from and dying to all things. But when a man has +once entered upon it, no life is lighter or happier or more +desirable; for God is very zealous to be at all times with man, and +teaches him that He will bring him to Himself if man will but +follow. Man never desires anything so earnestly as God desires to +bring a man to Himself, that he may know Him. God is always ready, +but we are very unready; God is near to us, but we are far from Him; +God is within, but we are without; God is at home, but we are +strangers. The prophet saith: God guideth the redeemed through a +narrow way into the broad road, so that they come into the wide and +broad place; that is to say, into true freedom of the spirit, when +one has become a spirit with God. May God help us to follow this +course, that He may bring us to Himself. Amen. (223) + +GRACE + +THE masters say: That is young, which is near its beginning. +Intelligence is the youngest faculty in man: the first thing to +break out from the soul is intelligence, the next is will, the other +faculties follow. Now he saith: Young man, I say unto thee, arise. +The soul in itself is a simple work; what God works in the simple +light of the soul is more beautiful and more delightful than all the +other works which He works in all creatures. But foolish people take +evil for good and good for evil. But to him who rightly understands, +the one work which God works in the soul is better and nobler and +higher than all the world. Through that light comes grace. Grace +never comes in the intelligence or in the will. If it could come in +the intelligence or in the will, the intelligence and the will would +have to transcend themselves. On this a master says: There is +something secret about it; and thereby he means the spark of the +soul, which alone can apprehend God. The true union between God and +the soul takes place in the little spark, which is called the spirit +of the soul. Grace unites not to any work. It is an indwelling and a +living together of the soul in God. (255) + +Every gift of God makes the soul ready to receive a new gift, +greater than itself. (15) + +Yea, since God has never given any gift, in order that man might +rest in the possession of the gift, but gives every gift that He has +given in heaven and on earth, in order that He might be able to give +one gift, which is Himself, so with this gift of grace, and with all +His gifts He will make us ready for the one gift, which is Himself. +(569) + +No man is so boorish or stupid or awkward, that he cannot, by God's +grace, unite his will wholly and entirely with God's will. And +nothing more is necessary than that he should say with earnest +longing: O Lord, show me Thy dearest will, and strengthen me to do +it. And God does it, as sure as He lives, and gives him grace in +ever richer fulness, till he comes to perfection, as He gave to the +woman at Jacob's well. Look you, the most ignorant and the lowest of +you all can obtain this from God, before he leaves this church, yea, +before I finish this sermon, as sure as God lives and I am a man. +(187) + +O almighty and merciful Creator and good Lord, be merciful to me for +my poor sins, and help me that I may overcome all temptations and +shameful lusts, and may be able to avoid utterly, in thought and +deed, what Thou forbiddest, and give me grace to do and to hold all +that Thou hast commanded. Help me to believe, to hope, and to love, +and in every way to live as Thou willest, as much as Thou willest, +and what Thou willest. (415) + +THE WILL + +THEN is the will perfect, when it has gone out of itself, and is +formed in the will of God. The more this is so, the more perfect and +true is the will, and in such a will thou canst do all things. (553) + +SURRENDER OF THE WILL + +YOU should know, that that which God gives to those men who seek to +do His will with all their might, is the best. Of this thou mayest +be as sure, as thou art sure that God lives, that the very best must +necessarily be, and that in no other way could anything better +happen. Even if something else seems better, it would not be so good +for thee, for God wills this and not another way, and this way must +be the best for thee. Whether it be sickness or poverty or hunger or +thirst, or whatever it be, that God hangs over thee or does not hang +over thee--whatever God gives or gives not, that is all what is best +for thee; whether it be devotion or inwardness, or the lack of these +which grieves thee--only set thyself right in this, that thou +desirest the glory of God in all things, and then whatever He does +to thee, that is the best. + +Now thou mayest perchance say: How can I tell whether it is the will +of God or not? If it were not the will of God, it would not happen. +Thou couldst have neither sickness nor anything else unless God +willed it. But know that it is God's will that thou shouldst have so +much pleasure and satisfaction therein, that thou shouldst feel no +pain as pain; thou shouldst take it from God as the very best thing, +for it must of necessity be the very best thing for thee. Therefore +I may even wish for it and desire it, and nothing would become me +better than so to do. + +If there were a man whom I were particularly anxious to please, and +if I knew for certain that he liked me better in a grey cloak than +in any other, there is no doubt that however good another cloak +might be, I should be fonder of the grey than of all the rest. And +if there were anyone whom I would gladly please, I should do nothing +else in word or deed than what I knew that he liked. + +Ah, now consider how your love shows itself! If you loved God, of a +surety nothing would give you greater pleasure than what pleases Him +best, and that whereby His will may be most fully done. And, however +great thy pain or hardship may be, if thou hast not as great +pleasure in it as in comfort or fulness, it is wrong. + +We say every day in prayer to our Father, Thy will be done. And yet +when His will is done, we grumble at it, and find no pleasure in His +will. If our prayers were sincere, we should certainly think His +will, and what He does, to be the best, and that the very best had +happened to us. (134) + +Those who accept all that the Lord send, as the very best, remain +always in perfect peace, for in them God's will has become their +will. This is incomparably better than for our will to become God's +will. For when thy will becomes God's will--if thou art sick, thou +wishest not to be well contrary to God's will, but thou wishest that +it were God's will that thou shouldest be well. And so in other +things. But when God's will becomes thy will--then thou art sick: in +God's name; thy friend dies: in God's name! (55) + +SUFFERING + +MEN who love God are so far from complaining of their sufferings, +that their complaint and their suffering is rather because the +suffering which God's will has assigned them is so small. All their +blessedness is to suffer by God's will, and not to have suffered +something, for this is the loss of suffering. This is why I said, +Blessed are they who are willing to suffer for righteousness, not, +Blessed are they who have suffered. (434) + +All that a man bears for God's sake, God makes light and sweet for +him. (45) + +If all was right with you, your sufferings would no longer be +suffering, but love and comfort. (442) + +If God could have given to men anything more noble than suffering, +He would have redeemed mankind with it: otherwise, you must say that +my Father was my enemy, if he knew of anything nobler than +suffering. (338) + +True suffering is a mother of all the virtues. (338) + +SIN + +DEADLY sin is a death of the soul. To die is to lose life. But God +is the life of the soul; since then deadly sin separates us from +God, it is a death of the soul. + +Deadly sin is also an unrest of the heart. Everything can rest only +in its proper place. But the natural place of the soul is God; as St +Augustine says, Lord, thou hast made us for Thyself, and our heart +is restless till it finds rest in Thee. But deadly sin separates us +from God; therefore it is an unrest of the heart. Deadly sin is also +a sickness of the faculties, when a man can never stand up alone for +the weight of his sins, nor ever resist falling into sin. Therefore +deadly sin is a sickness of the faculties. Deadly sin is also a +blindness of the sense, in that it suffers not a man to know the +shortness of the pleasures of lust, nor the length of the punishment +in hell, nor the eternity of joys in heaven. Deadly sin is also a +death of all graces; for as soon as a deadly sin takes place, a man +becomes bare of all graces. (217) + +Every creature must of necessity abide in God; if we fall out of the +hands of his mercy, we fall into the hands of His justice. We must +ever abide in Him. What madness then is it to wish not to be with +Him, without whom thou canst not be! (169) + +CONTENTMENT + +A GREAT teacher once told a story in his preaching about a man who +for eight years besought God to show him a man who would make known +to him the way of truth. While he was in this state of anxiety there +came a voice from God and spake to him: Go in front of the church, +and there shalt thou find a man who will make known to thee the way +of truth. He went, and found a poor man whose feet were chapped and +full of dirt, and all his clothes were hardly worth +twopence-halfpenny. He greeted this poor man and said to him, God +give thee a good morning. The poor man answered, I never had a bad +morning. The other said, God give thee happiness. How answerest thou +that? The poor man answered, I was never unhappy. The first then +said, God send thee blessedness. How answerest thou that? I was +never unblessed, was the answer. Lastly the questioner said, God +give thee health! Now enlighten me, for I cannot understand it. And +the poor man replied, When thou saidst to me, may God give thee a +good morning, I said I never had a bad morning. If I am hungry, I +praise God for it; if I am cold, I praise God for it; if I am +distressful and despised, I praise God for it; and that is why I +never had a bad morning. When thou askedst God to give me happiness, +I answered that I had never been unhappy; for what God gives or +ordains for me, whether it be His love or suffering, sour or sweet, +I take it all from God as being the best, and that is why I was +never unhappy. Thou saidst further, May God make thee blessed, and I +said, I was never unblessed, for I have given up my will so entirely +to God's will, that what God wills, that I also will, and that is +why I was never unblessed, because I willed alone God's will. Ah! +dear fellow, replied the man; but if God should will to throw thee +into hell, what wouldst thou say then? He replied, Throw me into +hell! Then I would resist Him. But even if He threw me into hell, I +should still have two arms wherewith to embrace Him. One arm is true +humility, which I should place under Him, and with the arm of love I +should embrace Him. And he concluded, I would rather be in hell and +possess God, than in the kingdom of heaven without Him. (623) + +DETACHMENT + +THE man who has submitted his will and purposes entirely to God, +carries God with him in all his works and in all circumstances. +Therein can no man hinder him, for he neither aims at nor enjoys +anything else, save God. God is united with Him in all his purposes +and designs. Even as no manifoldness can dissipate God, so nothing +can dissipate such a man, or destroy his unity. Man, therefore, +should take God with him in all things; God should be always present +to his mind and will and affections. The same disposition that thou +hast in church or in thy cell, thou shouldst keep and maintain in a +crowd, and amid the unrest and manifoldness of the world. + +Some people pride themselves on their detachment from mankind, and +are glad to be alone or in church; and therein lies their peace. But +he who is truly in the right state, is so in all circumstances, and +among all persons; he who is not in a good state, it is not right +with him in all places and among all persons. He who is as he should +be has God with him in truth, in all places and among all persons, +in the street as well as in the church; and then no man can hinder +him. (547) + +It is often much harder for a man to be alone in a crowd than in the +desert; and it is often harder to leave a small thing than a great, +and to practise a small work than one which people consider very +great. (565) + +PRAYER + +GOOD and earnest prayer is a golden ladder which reaches up to +heaven, and by which man ascends to God. + +The man who will pray aright should ask for nothing except what may +promote God's honour and glory, his own profit and the advantage of +his neighbours. When we ask for temporal things we should always +add, if it be God's will and if it be for my soul's health. But when +we pray for virtues, we need add no qualification, for these are +God's own working. (359) + +LOVE OF OUR NEIGHBOUR + +IT is a hard thing to practise this universal love, and to love our +neighbours as ourselves, as our Lord commanded us. But if you will +understand it rightly, there is a greater reward attached to this +command, than to any other. The commandment seems hard, but the +reward is precious indeed. (135) + +LOVE + +HE who has found this way of love, seeketh no other. He who turns on +this pivot is in such wise a prisoner that his foot and hand and +mouth and eyes and heart, and all his human faculties, belong to +God. And, therefore, thou canst overcome thy flesh in no better way, +so that it may not shame thee, than by love. This is why it is +written, Love is as strong as death, as hard as hell. Death +separates the soul from the body, but love separates all things from +the soul. She suffers nought to come near her, that is not God nor +God-like. Happy is he who is thus imprisoned; the more thou art a +prisoner, the more wilt thou be freed. That we may be so imprisoned, +and so freed, may He help us, Who Himself is Love. (30) + +THE UNION WITH GOD + +THE union of the soul with God is far more inward than that of the +soul and body. (566) + +Now I might ask, how stands it with the soul that is lost in God? +Does the soul find herself or not? To this will I answer as it +appears to me, that the soul finds herself in the point, where every +rational being understands itself with itself. Although it sinks and +sinks in the eternity of the Divine Essence, yet it can never reach +the ground. Therefore God has left a little point wherein the soul +turns back upon itself and finds itself, and knows itself to be a +creature. (387) + +God alone must work in thee without hindrance, that He may bring to +perfection His likeness in thee. So thou mayest understand with Him, +and love with Him. This is the essence of perfection. (471) + +THE LAST JUDGMENT + +PEOPLE say of the last day, that God shall give judgment. This is +true. But it is not true as people imagine. Every man pronounces his +own sentence; as he shows himself here in his essence, so will he +remain everlastingly. (471) + +PRECEPT AND PRACTICE + +BETTER one life-master than a thousand reading-masters (wger wre +ein lebemeister denne tsent lesemeister). If I sought a master +in the scriptures, I should seek him in Paris and in the high +schools of high learning. But if I wished to ask questions about the +perfect life, that he could not tell me. Where then must I go? +Nowhere at all save to an utterly simple nature; he could answer my +question. (599) + +RELICS + +MY people, why seek ye after dead bones? Why seek ye not after +living holiness, which might give you everlasting life? The dead can +neither give nor take away. (599) + +SAYINGS OF ECKHART + +MASTER ECKHART saith: He who is always alone, he is worthy of God; +and he who is always at home, to him is God present; and be who +abides always in a present now, in him doth God beget His Son +without ceasing. (600) + +Master Eckhart saith: I will never pray to God to give Himself to +me: I will pray Him to make me purer. If I were purer, God must give +Himself to me, of His own nature, and sink into me. (601) + +Master Eckhart was asked, what were the greatest goods, that God had +done to him. He said, there are three. The first is, that the lusts +and desires of the flesh have been taken away from me. The second +is, that the Divine Light shines and gives me light in all my +doings. The third is, that I am daily renewed in virtue, grace and +holiness. (602) + + + + + + +TAULER + + + + + +OUR AIM + +THINK, and think earnestly, how great, how unutterable will be the +joy and blessedness, the glory and honour of those who shall see +clearly and without veil the gladsome and beauteous face of God, how +they will enjoy the best and highest good, which is God Himself. For +in Him is included all pleasure, might, joy, and all beauty, so that +the blessed in God will possess everything that is good and +desirable, with everlasting joy and security, without fear lest they +should ever be parted from Him. (138)[38] + +CONSEQUENCES OF THE FALL + +FROM the time when the first man gave a ready ear to the words of +the enemy, mankind have been deaf, so that none of us can hear or +understand the loving utterances of the eternal Word. Something has +happened to the ears of man, which has stopped up his ears, so that +he cannot hear the loving Word; and he has also been so blinded, +that he has become stupid, and does not know himself. If he wished +to speak of his own inner life, he could not do it; he knows not +where he is, nor what is his state. (91) + +How can it be that the noble reason, the inner eye, is so blinded +that it cannot see the true light? This great shame has come about, +because a thick coarse skin and a thick fur has been drawn over him, +even the love and the opinion of the creatures, whether it be the +man himself or something that belongs to him; hence man has become +blind and deaf, in whatever position he may be, worldly or +spiritual. Yes, that is his guilt, that many a thick skin is drawn +over him, as thick as an ox's forehead, and it has so covered up his +inner man, that neither God nor himself can get inside; it has grown +into him. (92) + +THE FALL + +THROUGH two things man fell in Paradise--through pride, and through +inordinate affection. Therefore we too must return by two things, +that nature may recover her power: we must first sink our nature and +bring it down under God and under all men in deep humility, against +whom it had exalted itself in pride. We must also manfully die to +all inordinate lusts. (1) + +LIFE A BATTLE + +NOTHING in the world is so necessary for man as to be constantly +assailed; for in fighting he learns to know himself. As grace is +necessary to a man, so also is fighting. Virtue begins in fighting, +and is developed in fighting. In every state to which a man is +called, inward and outward, he must of necessity be assailed. A high +Master said: As little as meat can remain without salt and yet not +become corrupt, so little can a man remain without fighting. (104) + +A man should in the first place act as when a town is besieged, and +it is certain that the besieging army is stronger than the town. +When the town is weakest, men take the very greatest care to guard +and defend the town; if they neglected to do so, they would lose the +town, and with it their lives and properties. So should every man +do: he should be most careful to find out in what things the evil +spirit most often besets him--that is, on what side the man is +weakest, and to what kind of errors and failings he is most prone, +and should manfully defend himself at those points. + +Next, turn thyself earnestly away from sin; for I tell you of a +truth, by whatever temptation a man is assailed, if he turns not +from it heartily, but stands in it vacillating, he has no +wholehearted desire to leave his sins by God's will, and without +doubt the evil spirit is close upon him, who may make him fall into +endless perdition. + +Know of a truth, that if thou wouldst truly overcome the evil +spirit, this can only be done by a complete manful turning away from +sin. Say then with all thy heart: Oh, everlasting God, help me and +give me Thy Divine grace to be my help, for it is my steadfast +desire never again to commit any deadly sin against Thy Divine will +and Thine honour. So with thy good will and intention thou entirely +overcomest the evil spirit, so that he must fly from thee ashamed. + +Understand, however, that it is a miserable and pitiable thing for a +reasonable man to let himself be overcome by the evil spirit, and in +consequence of his attacks to fall voluntarily into grievous and +deadly sin, whereby man loses the grace of God. A reasonable man, +who allows himself voluntarily to be overcome by the evil spirit, is +like a well-armed man who voluntarily lets a fly bite him to death. +For man has many great and strong weapons, wherewith he may well and +manfully withstand the evil spirit--the holy faith, the blessed +sacrament, the holy word of God, the model and example of all good +and holy men, the prayers of holy Church, and other great supports +against the power of the evil spirit, whose power is much less than +that of a fly against a great bear. If a man will manfully and +boldly withstand the evil spirit, the evil one can gain no advantage +against his free will. + +Turn, therefore, manfully and earnestly from your sins, and watch +diligently and earnestly; for I tell you of a truth, that when you +have come to the next world, if you have not withstood the evil +spirit, and if you are found there without repentance and sorrow, +you will be a mockery to all the devils and to yourself, and you +will be eternally punished and tormented. And it will then be a +greater woe to you, that you have followed the evil spirit, than all +the external pains that you must endure eternally for your sins. + +Thirdly, a man should diligently attend to his inner Ground, that +there shall be nothing in it save God alone, and His eternal glory. +For alas! there are many men, both lay and clerical, who live +falsely beneath a fair show, and imagine that they can deceive the +everlasting God. No, in truth, thou deceivest thyself, and losest +the day of grace, and the favour of God, and makest thyself guilty +towards God, in that He gives the evil spirits power over thee, so +that thou canst do no good work. Therefore, watch while it is day, +that the hour of darkness and God's disfavour may not overtake thee, +and take heed that in thy inner ground God may dwell, and nought +besides. (75) + +Even as each man in his baptism is placed under the charge of a +special angel, who is with him always and never leaves him, and +protects him waking and sleeping in all his ways and in all his +works, so every man has a special devil, who continually opposes him +and exercises him without ceasing. But if the man were wise and +diligent, the opposition of the devil and his exercises would be +much more profitable to him than the aid of the good angel; for if +there were no struggle, there could be no victory. (139) + +SIN + +WHEN a man has had the fair net of his soul torn by sin, he must +patch and mend it by a humble, repentant return to the grace and +mercy of God. He must act like one who wishes to make a crooked +stick straight: he bends the stick further back than it ought to go, +and by being thus bent back it becomes straight again. So must a man +do to his own nature. He must bend himself under all things which +belong to God, and break himself right off, inwardly and outwardly, +from all things which are not God. + +Every deadly sin causes the precious blood of Christ to be shed +afresh. Jesus Christ is spiritually crucified many times every day. +(75) + +FISHING FOR SOULS + +THE fisherman throws his hook, that he may catch the fish; but the +fish itself takes the hook. When the fish takes the hook, the +fisherman is sure of the fish, and draws it to him. Even so, God has +thrown His hook and His net into all the world, before our feet, +before our eyes, before our minds, and He would gladly draw us +securely to Himself by means of all His creatures. By pleasurable +things He draws us on; by painful things He drives us on. He who +will not be drawn, is in fault; for he has not taken God's hook, nor +will he be caught in God's net. If he came therein, beyond doubt he +would be caught by God and would be drawn by God. It is not God's +fault if we will not be drawn; we should grasp the hand held out to +us. If a man were in a deep pool, and one tried to help him and pull +him out, would he not gladly grasp his hand and allow himself to be +pulled out? (42) + +Where two things are so related to each other, that one may receive +something for the other, there must be something in common between +them. If they had nothing in common, there must be a middle term +between them, which has something in common both with the higher, +from which it may receive, and with the lower, to which it may +impart. Now God hath created all things, and especially mankind, +immediately for Himself. He created man for His pleasure. But by +sin, human nature was so far estranged from God, that it was +impossible for a man to attain to that, for which he was made. Now +Aristotle says that God and Nature are not unprofitable +workers--that is, what they work at, they carry to its end. Now God +created man that He might have pleasure in him. If then God's work +in creating mankind was not to be unprofitable, when they were so +far estranged from God by sin, that they could not receive that by +which they might return and attain the enjoyment of eternal +happiness, a Mediator was necessary between us and God, one who has +something in common with us and our natures, and also shares in the +nature of God. In order that on the one side, He might in Himself +destroy our sickness, which was a cause of all our sins, and also +destroy all our sins, to which our weakness has brought us; and on +the other side that He might include in Himself all the treasure of +grace and of God's honour, that He might be able to give us grace +richly, and forgiveness of our sins, and eternal glory hereafter, +this could only be, if the Son of God became man. (90) + +Yea, the highest God and Lord of all lords, the Son of God, in His +deep love felt pity for us poor, sinful men, condemned to the flames +of hell. Though He was in the form of God, He thought it not robbery +(as St Paul says) to be equal with God, and He annihilated Himself, +and took upon Him the form of a servant, and was made like any other +man, being found in fashion as a man. He humbled Himself, and became +obedient unto death, even the death of the cross. (117) + +THE EFFICACY OF DIVINE GRACE + +ALL works which men and all creatures can ever work even to the end +of the world, without the grace of God--all of them together, +however great they may be, are an absolute nothing, as compared with +the smallest work which God has worked in men by His grace. As much +as God is better than all His creatures, so much better are His +works than all the works, or wisdom, or designs, which all men could +devise. Even the smallest drop of grace is better than all earthly +riches that are beneath the sun. Yea, a drop of grace is more noble +than all angels and all souls, and all the natural things that God +has made. And yet grace is given more richly by God to the soul than +any earthly gift. It is given more richly than brooks of water, than +the breath of the air, than the brightness of the sun; for spiritual +things are far finer and nobler than earthly things. The whole +Trinity, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, give grace to the soul, and +flow immediately into it; even the highest angel, in spite of his +great nobility, cannot do this. Grace looses us from the snares of +many temptations; it relieves us from the heavy burden of worldly +cares, and carries the spirit up to heaven, the land of spirits. It +kills the worm of conscience, which makes sins alive. Grace is a +very powerful thing. The man, to whom cometh but a little drop of +the light of grace, to him all that is not God becomes as bitter as +gall upon the tongue. (86) + +Grace makes, contrary to nature, all sorrows sweet, and brings it +about that a man no longer feels any relish for things which +formerly gave him great pleasure and delight. On the other hand, +what formerly disgusted him, now delights him and is the desire of +his heart--for instance, weakness, sorrow, inwardness, humility, +self-abandonment, and detachment from all the creatures. All this is +in the highest degree dear to him, when this visitation of the Holy +Ghost, grace, has in truth come to him. Then the sick man, that is +to say the external man, with all his faculties is plunged +completely into the pool of water, even as the sick man who had been +for thirty-eight years by the pool at Jerusalem, and there washes +himself thoroughly in the exalted, noble, precious blood of Christ +Jesus. For grace in manifold ways bathes the soul in the wounds and +blood of the holy Lamb, Jesus Christ. (22) + +PRAYER + +THE essence of prayer is the ascent of the mind to God, as holy +teachers tell us. Therefore every good man, when he wishes to pray, +ought to collect his outer senses into himself, and look into his +mind, to see whether it be really turned to God. He who wishes that +his prayers may be truly heard, must keep himself turned away from +all temporal and external things, and all that is not Divine, +whether it be friend or joy (Freund oder Freude), and all vanities, +whether they be clothes or ornaments, and from everything of which +God is not the true beginning and ending, and from everything that +does not belong to Him. He must cut off his words and his conduct, +his manners and his demeanour, from all irregularity, inward or +outward. Dream not that that can be a true prayer, when a man only +babbles outwardly with his mouth, and reads many psalms, gabbling +them rapidly and hastily, while his mind wanders this way and that, +backwards and forwards. Much rather must the true prayer be, as St +Peter tells us, "one-minded"[39]that is, the mind must cleave to +God alone, and a man must look with the face of his soul turned +directly towards God, with a gentle, willing dependence on Him. (80) + +If thy prayer has these conditions, thou mayst with true humility +fall at the feet of God, and pray for the gentle succour of God; +thou mayest knock at His fatherly heart, and ask for breadthat is, +for love. If a man had all the food in the world, and had not bread, +his food would be neither eatable, nor pleasant, nor useful. So it +is with all things, without the Love of God. Knock also at the door +through which we must go--namely, Christ Jesus. At this door, the +praying man must knock for three ends, if he wishes to be really +admitted. First he must knock devoutly, at the broken heart and the +open side, and enter in with all devotion, and in recognition of his +unfathomable poverty and nothingness, as poor Lazarus did at the +rich man's gate, and ask for crumbs of His grace. Then again, he +should knock at the door of the holy open wounds of His holy hands, +and pray for true Divine knowledge, that it may enlighten him and +exalt him. Finally, knock at the door of His holy feet, and pray for +true Divine love, which may unite thee with Him, and immerse and +cover thee in Him. (57) + + + + + + +MEDITATIONS ON THE SEVEN WORDS FROM THE CROSS + + + + + +[From a devotional treatise on the Passion of Christ, published in a +Latin translation, by Surius, in 1548, and wrongly ascribed by him +to Tauler. The author was an unknown German of the fourteenth +century.] + +THE FIRST WORD + +NOW, O my soul, and all ye who have been redeemed by the precious +blood of Christ, come, and let us go with inward compassion and +fervent devotion to the blessed palm-tree of the Cross, which is +laden with the fairest fruit. Let us pass like the bee from flower +to flower, for all are full of honey. Let us consider and ponder +with the greatest care the sacred words of Christ, which He spoke +upon the Cross; for everything that comes From this blessed Tree is +wholesome and good. In the Cross of our Lord and Saviour are centred +all our salvation, all our health, all our life, all our glory; and, +"if we suffer with Him," saith the Apostle, "we shall also reign +with Him." That we may not be found ungrateful for these inestimable +benefits, let us call upon heaven and earth, and all that in them +is, to join us in praising and blessing and giving thanks to God. +Let us invite them to come and look upon this wondrous sight, and +say: "Magnify the Lord with me, for He hath done marvellous things. +O praise and bless the Lord with me, for great is His mercy toward +us." Come up with me, I pray you, ye angelic spirits, to Mount +Calvary, and see your King Solomon on His throne, wearing the diadem +wherewith His mother has crowned Him. Let us weep in the presence of +the Lord who made us, the Lord our God. O all mankind, and all ye +who are members of Christ, behold your Redeemer as He hangs on high; +behold and weep. See if any sorrow is like unto His sorrow. +Acknowledge the heinousness of your sins, which needed such +satisfaction. Go to every part of His body; you will find only +wounds and blood. Cry to Him with lamentations and say, "O Jesus, +our redemption, our love, our desire, what mercy has overcome Thee, +that Thou shouldest bear our sins, and endure a cruel death, to +rescue us from everlasting death?" And Thou, O God, the almighty +Father of heaven, look down from Thy sanctuary upon Thine innocent +Son Joseph, sold and given over unjustly to the hands of bloody men, +to suffer a shameful death. See whether this be Thy Son's coat or +not. Of a truth an evil beast hath devoured Him. The blood of our +sins is sprinkled over His garments, and all the coverings of His +good name are defiled by it. See how Thy holy Child has been +condemned with the wicked, how Thy royal Son has been crowned with +thorns. Behold His innocent hands, which have known no sin, dripping +with blood; behold His sacred feet, which have never turned aside +from the path of justice, pierced through by a cruel nail; behold +His defenceless side smitten with a sharp spear; behold His fair +face, which the angels desire to look upon, marred and shorn of all +its beauty; behold His blessed heart, which no impure thought ever +stained, weighed down with inward sorrow. Behold, O loving Father, +Thy sweet Son, stretched out upon the harp of the Cross, and harping +blessings on Thee with all His members. Wherefore, O my God, I pray +Thee to forgive me, for the sake of Thy Son's Passion, all the sins +that I have committed in my members. O merciful Father, look on Thy +only-begotten Son, that Thou mayst have compassion on Thy servant. +Whenever that red blood of Thy Son speaks in Thy sight, do Thou wash +me from every stain of sin. Whenever Thou beholdest the wounds of +this Thy Son, open to me the bosom of Thy fatherly compassion. +Behold, O tender Father, how Thy obedient Son does not cry, "Bind my +hands and my feet, that I may not rebel against Thee," but how of +His own will He extends His hands and feet, and gladly allows them +to be pierced with nails. Look down, I pray Thee, not on the brazen +serpent hanging on a pole for the salvation of Israel, but on Thine +only Son hanging on the Cross for the salvation of all men. It is +not Moses who now stretches out his hand to heaven, that the thunder +and lightning and the other plagues may cease, but it is Thy beloved +Son, who lovingly stretches out His bleeding arms to Thee, that Thy +wrath may depart from the human race. Aaron and Hur are not now +holding up the hands of Moses that he may pray more unweariedly for +Israel; but hard and cruel nails have fastened the hands of Thy only +Son to the Cross, that He may wait with long-suffering for our +repentance, and receive us back into His grace, and that He may not +turn away in wrath from our prayers. This is that faithful David, +who now strings tight the harp-strings of His body, and makes sweet +melody before Thee, singing to Thee the sweetest song that has been +ever sung to Thee: "Father forgive them, for they know not what they +do." This is that High Priest, who by His own blood has entered into +the Holy of Holies, to offer Himself as a peace-offering for the +sins of the whole world. This is that innocent Lamb, who has washed +us in His own precious blood, who, Himself without spot of sin, has +taken away the sins of the world. Therefore from the storehouse of +His Passion I borrow the price of my debt, and I count out before +Thee all its merits, to pay what I owe Thee. For He has done all in +my nature, and for my sake. O merciful Father, if Thou weighest all +my sins on one side of the balance, and in the other scale the +Passion of Thy Son, the last will outweigh the first. For what sin +can be so great, that the innocent blood of Thy Son has not washed +it out? What pride, or disobedience, or lust, is so unchecked or so +rebellious, that such lowliness, obedience, and poverty cannot +abolish it? O merciful Father, accept the deeds of Thy beloved Son, +and forgive the errors of Thy wicked servant. For the innocent blood +of our brother Abel crieth to Thee from the Cross, not for +vengeance, but for grace and mercy, saying, "Father, forgive them, +for they know not what they do." + +THE SECOND WORD + +NOW the thieves who were crucified with Jesus reviled Him. But after +a while, the one who hung on the right side of Christ, when he saw +His great patience and long-suffering, wherewith He so lovingly +prayed to His Father for those who cast reproaches upon Him and +cruelly tortured Him, became entirely changed, and began to be moved +with very great sorrow and repentance for his sins. And he showed +this outwardly, when he rebuked his fellow-thief, who continued to +revile Christ, saying: "Dost not thou fear God, seeing thou art in +the same condemnation?" "Although" (he would say) "thou art so +obstinate as not to fear men, and thinkest nought of thy bodily +pain, yet surely thou must fear God, in the last moments of thy +life--God, who hath power to destroy both thy body and soul in hell. +And though we suffer the same punishment with Him, our deserts are +very different. We, indeed, suffer justly, for we receive the due +reward of our deeds, but this man hath done nothing amiss." He, who +but lately was a blasphemer, is now a confessor and preacher, he +distinguishes good from evil, blaming the sinner, and excusing the +innocent: the unbelieving thief has become the confessor of almighty +God. O good Jesus, this sudden change is wrought by Thy right hand, +at which he hung. Thy right hand touched him inwardly, and forthwith +he is changed into another man. O Lord, in this Thou hast declared +Thy patience, out of a stone Thou hast raised up a child unto +Abraham. Verily, the penitent thief received the light of faith +solely from that bright light on the candlestick of the Cross, which +shone there in the darkness and scattered the shades of night. But +what does this signify, save that our Lord Jesus, out of the +greatness of His goodness, looked upon him with the eyes of His +mercy, although He found no merit in him, except what it pleased Him +out of His goodness to bestow? For as God gives to His elect, out of +His goodness alone, what no one has a right to demand, so out of His +justice He gives to the wicked what they deserve. For this cause +David says: "He saved me because He desired me." And this is why the +thief, before the Lord touched his heart with the beams of His grace +and love, joined the other thief in reviling Christ, thus showing +first what his own character was, and afterwards what was wrought in +him by grace. At first he acted like the other, being, like him, a +child of wrath; but when the precious blood of Christ was shed as +the price of our redemption and paid to the Father for our debt, +then the thief asked God to give him an alms for his good, and at +once received it. For how can one alms diminish that inexhaustible +treasure? How could our tender Lord, whose property is always to +have mercy, have refused his request? Indeed He gave him more than +he asked. Yet how could the thief escape the glow of the fire which +was burning so near him? Truly this was the fire, which the Father +had sent down from heaven to earth, which had long smouldered, but +now, kindled anew, and fed by the wood of the Cross, and sprinkled +with the oil of mercy, and fanned, as it were, by the reproaches and +blasphemies of the Jews, sent up its flames to heaven, by which that +thief was quite kindled and set on fire, and his love became as +strong as death, so that he said: "I indeed suffer no grievous +penalty, for it is less than I deserve; but that this innocent One, +who has done no wrong, should be so tortured, contrary to justice +and righteousness, this, truly, adds grievous sorrow to my sorrow." +O splendid faith of this thief! He contemned all the punishment that +might be inflicted on him: he feared not the rage of the people, who +were barking like mad dogs against Jesus: he cared not for the chief +priests: he feared not the executioners with their weapons and +instruments of torture; but in the presence of them all, with a +fearless heart he confessed that Christ was the true Son of God, and +Lord of the whole world: and at the same time he confounded the Jews +by confessing that He had done nothing amiss, and therefore that +they had crucified Him unjustly. O wondrous faith! O mighty +constancy! O amazing love of this poor thief, love that cast out all +fear! He was indeed well drunken with that new wine which in the +wine-press of the Cross had been pressed out of that sweet cluster, +Jesus Christ, and therefore he confessed Christ without shame before +all the people. At the very beginning of the Passion, the apostles +and disciples had forsaken Christ and fled; even St Peter, +frightened by the voice of one maidservant, had denied Christ. But +this poor thief did not forsake Him even in death, but confessed Him +to be the Lord of heaven in the presence of all those armed men. Who +can do justice to the merits of this man? Who taught him so quickly +that faith of his, and his clear knowledge of all the virtues, save +the very Wisdom of the Father, Jesus Christ, who hung near him on +the Cross? Him whom the Jews could not or would not know, in spite +of the promises made to the patriarchs, the fulfilment of +prophecies, the teaching of the Scriptures, and the interpretation +of allegories, this poor thief learned to know by repentance. He +confessed Christ to be the Son of God, though he saw Him full of +misery, want, and torment, and dying from natural weakness. He +confessed Him at a time when the apostles, who had seen His mighty +works, denied Him. The nails were holding his hands and feet fixed +to the cross; he had nothing free about him, except his heart and +his tongue; yet he gave to God all that he could give to Him, and, +in the words of Scripture, "with his heart he believed unto +righteousness, and with his tongue he made confession of Christ unto +salvation." O infinite and unsearchable mercy of God! For what +manner of man was he when he was sent to the cross, and what when he +left it? (Not that it was his own cross, that wrought this change, +but the power of Christ crucified.) He came to the cross stained +with the blood of his fellow-man; he was taken down from it cleansed +by the blood of Christ. He came to the cross still savage and full +of rage, and while he was upon it he became so meek and pitiful that +he lamented for the sufferings of another more than for his own. One +member only was left to him, and at the eleventh hour he came to +work in God's vineyard, and yet so eagerly did he labour that he was +the first to finish his work and receive his reward. Indeed he +behaved like a just man; for he first accused himself and confessed +his sins, saying, "and we, indeed, justly, for we receive the due +reward of our deeds." Secondly, he excused Christ, and confessed +that He was the Just One when he said "but this Man hath done +nothing amiss." Thirdly, he showed brotherly love, for he said, +"dost not thou fear God?" Fourthly, with all his members, or at +least with all that he could offer, and with loving eyes and a +devout heart and a humble spirit, he turned himself to Christ and +prayed earnestly, "Lord, remember me when Thou comest into Thy +Kingdom." How great was the justice and humility and resignation +which he showed in this prayer, for he asked only for a little +remembrance of himself, acknowledging that he was not worthy to ask +for anything great. Nor did he pray for the safety of his body, for +he gladly desired to die for his sins. It was more pleasant for him +to die with Christ than to live any longer. Nor did he pray that our +Lord would deliver him from the pains of hell, or of purgatory, nor +did he ask for the kingdom of heaven; but he resigned himself +entirely to the will of God, and offered himself altogether to +Christ, to do what He would with him. In his humility he prayed for +nothing except for grace and mercy, for which David also prayed when +he said, "Deal with Thy servant according to Thy mercy." And +therefore, because he had prayed humbly and wisely, the Eternal +Wisdom, Who reads the hearts of all who pray, heard his prayer, and, +opening wide the rich storehouse of His grace, bestowed upon him +much more than he had dared to ask. O marvellous goodness of God! +How plainly dost Thou declare in this, that Thou desirest not the +death of a sinner, but rather that he should be converted and live. +Now Thou hast manifested and fulfilled what Thou didst promise +aforetime by Thy prophet: "When the wicked man shall mourn for his +sins, I will remember his iniquity no more." Thou didst not impose +upon him many years of severe penance, nor many sufferings in +purgatory for the expiation of his sins; but just as if Thou hadst +quite forgotten his crimes, and couldst see nothing in him but +virtue, Thou didst say: "This day shalt thou be with Me in +paradise." O immeasurable compassion of God! Our tender Lord forgot +all the countless crimes which that poor thief had done, and forgave +him when he repented, and gave so great and splendid a reward to the +good which there was in him, small indeed though it was. Our loving +God is very rich; He needs not our gifts; but He seeks for a heart +which turns to Him with lowliness and resignation, such a heart as +He found in this poor thief. For He says Himself: "turn to Me, and I +will turn to you." And so when this thief so courageously and +effectively turned to God, his prayer was at once not only accepted +but answered. For our Lord did not reject his prayer, or say to him: +"See how I hang here in torment, and I behold before My eyes My +mother in sore affliction, and I have not yet spoken one word to +her, so that to hear thee now would not be just." No, our Lord said +nothing of this kind to the thief. Rather, He heard his prayer at +once, and made answer in that sweet word, "Amen, I say unto thee, +this day shalt thou be with Me in paradise." O tender goodness, O +marvellous mercy of God! O great wisdom of the thief! He saw that +the treasures of Christ were wide open, and were being scattered +abroad. Who then should forbid him to take as much as would pay what +he owed to his Lord? And O the accursed hardness of the impenitent +thief, whom neither the rebuke of his associate, nor the patience of +Christ, nor the many signs of love and mercy that shone forth in +Christ, could melt or convert! He saw that alms were plentiful at +the rich man's gate, that more was given than was asked for, and yet +he was too proud and obstinate to ask. He saw that life and the +kingdom of heaven were being granted, and yet he would not bend his +heart to wish for them: therefore he shall not have them. He loved +better revilings and curses, and they shall come unto him, and that +for all eternity. These new first-fruits of the grape, which our +Lord gathered on the wood of the Cross from our barren soil, by much +sweat of His brow and much watering with His own precious blood, He +sent with great joy as a precious gift to His heavenly Father, by +His celestial messengers the holy angels. But if there is joy among +the angels of God over one sinner that repenteth, how must they +rejoice and exult at the salvation of this thief, of whom they had +almost despaired? We can picture to ourselves with what joy the +Father of heaven received these first-fruits of the harvest of His +Son's Passion. But Christ Himself, though He felt some joy at the +thief's conversion, was still more afflicted thereby, for by His +wisdom He foresaw that this thief would be the cause of perdition to +many, who would resolve to pass their whole lives in sin, hoping to +obtain pardon and grace at the moment of death. Truly a most foolish +hope, for nowhere in the Scriptures do we read that it has so +happened to any man. In truth, they who seek after God only when +they must, will not, it is to be feared, find Him near them in their +time of need. In the meantime, none can trust too much in God, and +no one has ever been forsaken by Him, who has turned to Him with his +whole heart, and leant upon Him with loving confidence. + +THE THIRD WORD + +THERE stood also by the Cross of Jesus His most holy and ever-virgin +mother Mary; not in order that His sufferings might thereby be +lessened, but that they might be greatly augmented. For if any +creature could have given consolation to the Lord while He hung on +the Cross, no one could have done it so fitly as His blessed mother. +But since it was God's will that Christ should die the most bitter +of deaths, and end His Passion without any comfort or relief, but +with true resignation, His mother's presence brought Him no +consolation, but rather added to His sufferings, for her sufferings +were thereby added to His, and this added yet more to His +affliction. Who then, O good Jesus can discover by meditation how +great was Thy inward grief, for Thou knowest the hearts of all, when +Thou sawest all the body of Thy holy mother tortured by inward +compassion, even as Thou wast tortured on the Cross, and her tender +heart and maternal breast pierced with the sword of sharp sorrow, +her face pale as death, telling the anguish of her soul, and almost +dead, yet unable to die. When Thou beheldest her hot tears, flowing +down abundantly like sweet rivers upon her gracious cheeks, and over +all her face, all witnesses to Thee that she shared in Thy sorrow +and love; when Thou heardest her sad laments, forced from her by the +weight of her affliction; when Thou sawest that same tender mother, +melted away with the heat of love, her strength quite failing her, +worn out and exhausted by the pains of Thy Passion, which wasted her +away; all this, truly, was a new affliction to Thee on the Cross; it +was itself a new Cross. For Thou alone, by the spear of, Thy pity, +didst explore the weight and grievousness of her woes, which to men +are beyond comprehension. All this, indeed, greatly increased the +pain of Thy Passion, because Thou wast crucified not only in Thy own +body, but in Thy mother's heart; for her Cross was Thy Cross, and +Thine was hers. O how bitter was Thy Passion, sweet Jesus! Great +indeed was Thy outward suffering, but far more grievous was Thy +inward suffering, which Thy heart experienced at Thy mother's +anguish. It was now, beyond doubt, that the sword of sorrow pierced +her through, for the queen of martyrs was terribly and mortally +wounded in that part which is impassible--that is, the soul; she +bore the death of the Cross in that part which could not die, +suffering all the more her grievous inward death, as outward death +departed further from her. Who, O most loving mother, can recount or +conceive in his mind the immeasurable sorrows of thy soul, or thine +inward woes? Him whom thou didst bring forth without pain, as a +blessed mother free from the curse of our first mother Eve, who +instead of the pains of labour wast filled with joy of spirit, and +who for thy refreshment didst listen to the sweet songs of the +angels as they praised thy Son, thou hast now seen slain before +thine eyes with the greatest cruelty and tyranny. How manifold was +that sorrow of thine, which thou wast permitted to escape at His +birth, when thou sawest thy blessed and only Son hanging in such +torment on the Cross, in the presence of a cruel and furious crowd, +who showered upon Him all the insults and contumely and shame that +they could think of; when thou sawest Him whom thou didst bear in +thy pure womb without feeling the burden, so barbarously stretched +on the Cross, and pierced with nails; when thou sawest His sacred +arms, with which He had so many times lovingly embraced thee, +stretched out so that He could not move them, and covered with red +blood, His adorable head pierced with sharp thorns, and His whole +body one streaming wound, while thou wast not able to staunch or +anoint any of those wounds. What must thy grief have been when thou +sawest Him whom thou hadst so often laid on thy virgin bosom that He +might rest, without anything on which to lean His sacred head; and +Him whom thou hadst nourished with the milk of thy holy breasts, now +vexed with vinegar and gall. O how thy maternal heart was oppressed +when thou beheldest with thy pure eyes that fair face so piteously +marred, so that there was no beauty in it, and nothing by which He +could be distinguished. How did the wave of affliction beat against +and overflow and overwhelm thy soul! Truly, if even a devout man +cannot without unspeakable sorrow and pity revolve in his mind the +Passion of thy Son, what must have been thy Cross, thy affliction, +who wast His mother and sawest it all with thine eyes? If to many +friends of God and to many who love Him, thy Son's Passion is as +grievous as if they suffered it themselves, if by inward pity they +are crucified with thy Son, how terribly, even unto death, must thou +have been crucified inwardly, when thou didst not only ponder and +search into the outward and inward pains of thy Son in thy devout +heart, but sawest them with thy bodily eyes? For never did any +mother love her child as thou lovedst thy Son. And if St Paul, who +loved so much, could say, out of his ardent love and deep pity for +thy Son, "I am crucified with Christ; and I bear in my body the +marks of the Lord Jesus," how much more wert thou crucified with +Him, and didst inwardly receive all His wounds, being made, in a +manner, an image and likeness of thy crucified Son? + +THE FOURTH WORD + +ABOUT the ninth hour our Lord Jesus cried with a loud voice, "My +God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" He cried with a loud voice, +that He might be easily heard by all, and also that by this wondrous +word He might shake off from our souls the sleep of sloth, and cause +them to wonder and marvel at the immeasurable goodness of God to us. +Therefore He saith, "My God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" For +the sake of vile sinners, for evil and thankless servants, for +sinful and disobedient deceivers, Thou hast forsaken Thy beloved Son +and most obedient Child. That Thy enemies, who are vessels of wrath, +might be changed into children of adoption, Thou hast slain Thine +own Son, and given Him over to death like one guilty. "O my God, +why, I pray Thee, hast Thou forsaken me?" For the very cause why men +ought to praise and give thanks to Thee, and love Thee with an +everlasting love; because Thou hast delivered Thy dear Son to death +for their redemption, and sacrificed Him willingly, for this reason +they will find ground for blasphemy and reproach against Thee, +saying, "He saith He is the Son of God. Let God deliver Him now if +He will have Him." Why, O my God, hast Thou willed to spend so +precious a treasure for such vile and counterfeit goods? Besides, +this word may be understood to have been spoken by Christ against +those who seek to diminish the glory of His Passion, by saying that +it was not really so bitter and terrible, owing to the great support +and comfort which He drew from His Godhead. Let those who speak and +think thus know that they renew His Passion and crucify Him afresh. +It was to prove the error of such men that our Lord cried with a +loud voice, and said, "My God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" +It is as if He had said these words to His own Divine nature, with +which He formed one Person--for the Godhead of the Father and of the +Son is all one--wondering, Himself, at His own love, which had so +cast Him down and worn Him out and humbled Him, and that He who +brings help to all mankind should have forsaken Himself, and offered +Himself to suffer every kind of pain, impelled thereto by conquering +love alone. Again, we should not be wrong, if we were to interpret +this word which Christ spoke out of the exceeding bitterness of His +sorrow in the following way--namely, that His spirit and inward man, +taking upon itself the severe judgment of God upon all sinners, and +at the same time discerning clearly and feeling and measuring in +Himself the intolerable weight of His Passion, on this account cried +out in a sorrowful voice to His Father, and complained tenderly to +Him because He had been cast into these dreadful torments; as if the +goodness of His Father had become so embittered against the sins of +men, that in the ardour of His justice He had quite forgotten the +inseparable union between His passible humanity and His impassible +Godhead, and therefore in the zealousness of His justice had quite +given up His passible nature to the cruelty and malice of fierce +men, that they might waste it away and destroy it. For this reason, +therefore, He said, "My God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" +This word has besides an inward meaning, according to which Christ, +in His sensitive parts, complained to His Father that He had been +forsaken by Him. For as many as contend for His honour, and endure +patiently the troubles of this world, our merciful God so moderates +and tempers their crosses and afflictions by the inpouring of His +divine consolation, that by His sensible grace He makes their +crosses hardly felt; but He left His own beloved Son quite without +any comfort, and so deprived Him of all consolation and light, that +He endured as much in His human nature as had been ordained by the +Eternal Wisdom, according to the strictness of justice, as much as +was needed to atone for so many sins. And indeed our salvation was +the more nobly and perfectly achieved, in that it was done and +finished without any light at all, in absolute resignation and +abandonment. For a chief cause of the Passion was to show clearly +how great was the injury and insult brought upon His most high +Godhead by the sins of the human race. Now as the knowledge of +Christ was greater and more acute than that of all other beings, in +heaven or in earth, so much the greater and heavier was His sorrow +and agony. Nay more--what is more wonderful than anything--whatever +afflictions have been endured by all the saints, as members of +Christ, existed much more abundantly in Christ their Head; and this +I wish to be understood according to the spirit and reasonably. For +all the saints have suffered no more than flowed in upon them +through Christ, joined to them as His members, who communicated to +them His own afflictions. For He took upon Himself the afflictions +of all the saints, out of His great love for His members, and +wondrous pity, and He suffered far greater internal anguish than any +of the saints, nay, more even than the blessed Virgin, His mother, +felt her own sharp sorrow and sickness of heart. For if an earthly +father loves his child so much, that in fatherly pity he takes upon +himself the sorrows of his child, and grieves for them as if he +suffered them himself, what must have been Christ's Cross and +compassion for the affliction of His members, and above all, of +those who suffered for His name's sake? Truly He bore witness to His +members, how much He suffered from their afflictions, and how great +was His inward pity for their sufferings, when He took all their +debt upon Himself, and abolished all the penalties which they had +merited, so that they might depart free. The same is most amply +proved by the words which He spoke to St Paul, when He said, "Saul, +Saul, why persecutest thou Me?" For the persecution which Saul had +stirred up against the disciples, the members of the Lord, was not +less grievous to Him than if He had suffered it Himself. Therefore +He says to His friends and members, "He who touches you, touches the +apple of Mine eye." For is there anything suffered by the members, +which the Head does not suffer with them, He whose nature is +goodness, and whose property is always to have mercy and to forgive? + +THE FIFTH WORD + +OUR most tender Lord was so worn out and parched by the extreme +bitterness of His pain and suffering, and by the great loss of +blood, that He cried, "I thirst." A little word, but full of +mysteries. + +In the first place it may be understood literally. For it is natural +for those who are at the point of death to feel thirst, and to +desire to drink. But how great was the drouth felt by Him who is the +fountain of living water, but who was now worn out and parched by +the heat of His ardent love, when he could truly say, "I am poured +out like water," and "My strength is dried up like a potsherd." For +not only did He shed all His own blood, and pour out moisture by +tears, but the very marrow of His bones, and all His heart's blood, +were consumed for our sakes by the heat and flame of love. Therefore +He said rightly, "I thirst." + +But, secondly, the word may be understood spiritually, as if Christ +said to all men, "I thirst for your salvation." Hence St Bernard +says: "Jesus cried, I thirst, not, I grieve. O Lord, what dost Thou +thirst for? For your faith, your joy. I thirst because of the +torments of your souls, far more than for My own bodily sufferings. +Have pity on yourselves, if not on Me." And again, "O good Jesus, +Thou wearest the crown of thorns; Thou art silent about Thy Cross +and wounds, yet Thou criest out, I thirst. For what, then, dost Thou +thirst? Truly, for the redemption of mankind only, and for the +felicity of the human race." This thirst of Christ was a hundred +times more keen and intense than His natural thirst. And, besides, +He had another sort of thirst--that is to say, a thirst to suffer +more, and to prove to us still more clearly His immeasurable love, +as if He said to man, "See how I am worn out and exhausted for thy +salvation. See how terrible are the pains and anguish which I +endure. The fierce cruelty of man has almost brought Me to nothing; +the sinners of earth have drunk out all My blood, and yet I thirst. +Not yet is My heart satisfied, nor My desire accomplished, nor the +fire of My love quenched. For if it were possible for Me, and +according to My Father's will, that I should be crucified again a +thousand times for your salvation and conversion, or that I should +hang here, in all this pain and anguish, till the day of judgment, I +would gladly do it, to prove to you the immeasurable love which I +bear you in My heart, and to soften your stony hearts and rouse you +to love Me in return. This is why I hang here so thirsty by the +fountain of your hearts, that I may watch the pious souls who come +hither to draw from the deep well of My Passion. Therefore, the +maiden to whom I shall say, 'Give Me to drink a little water out of +the pitcher of thy conscience'--the water of devotion, pity, tears, +and mutual love--and who shall let down to Me her pitcher, and shall +say, 'Drink, my Lord; and for Thy camels also--that is, Thy +servants, who carry Thee about daily on their bodies, and who by +night and day are held bound fast by Thy yoke, I will draw the water +of brotherly love'--that is the maiden whom the Lord hath prepared +for the Son of My Lord, even the bride of the Word of God, united to +My humanity. And she shall be counted worthy to enter, like a bride +with her bridegroom, into the chamber of eternal rest, when the +Bridegroom invites her, saying, 'Come, My blessed bride, inherit the +Kingdom of My Father. For I was thirsty, and thou gavest Me drink.'" + +Thirdly, we may apply this word to the Father, as if Christ said to +His Father: "Father, I have declared Thy name to mankind; I have +finished the work which Thou gavest Me to do; and in Thy service I +have spent My whole body as Thine instrument. Behold, I am all worn +out and exhausted; and yet I still thirst to do and suffer more for +Thine honour. This is why I hang here, extended to the furthest +breadth of love, for I long to be an everlasting sacrifice, a sweet +savour to Thee, and at the same time an eternal atonement and +salvation to mankind." Thus, too, might this strong Samson have +said: "O Lord, Thou hast put into the hand of Thy servant this very +great salvation and victory, and yet behold, I die of thirst." As if +He would say: "Father, I have accomplished Thy gracious will; I have +finished the work of man's salvation, as Thou didst demand; and yet +I still thirst; for the sins by which Thou art offended are +infinite. And so I desire that the love and merits of My Passion, by +which Thou wilt be appeased, may be infinite too. And as I now offer +myself as a peace-offering and a living sacrifice for the salvation +of all men, so through Me may all men appease Thee, by offering Me +to Thee as a peace-offering to Thine eternal glory, in memory of My +Passion, and to make good all their shortcomings." O how acceptable +to the Father must this desire of love have been! For what was this +thirst but a sweet and pleasant refreshment to the Father, and at +the same time the blessed renovation of mankind? Or what other +language does this burning throat speak to us, save that of Christ's +burning love, without measure and without limit, out of which He did +all His works? This truly is the most noble sacrifice of our +redemption, this is that peace-offering which will be offered even +to the last day, by all good men, to the Holy Ghost, to the highest +Father, in memory of the Son, to the eternal glory of the adorable +Trinity, and to the fruit of salvation for mankind. Here, certainly, +is the inexhaustible storehouse of our reconciliation, which never +fails, for it is greater than all the debts of the world. This is +that immeasurable love, which is higher than the heavens, for it has +repaired the ruin of the angels; deeper than hell, for it has freed +souls from hell; wider and broader than the earth, for it is without +end and incomprehensible by any created understanding. O how keen +and intense was this thirst of our Lord! For not only did He then +say once, "I thirst," but even now He says in our hearts +continually, "I thirst; woman, give me to drink." So great, so +mighty, is that thirst, that He asks drink not only from the +children of Israel, but from the Samaritans. To each one He +complaineth of His thirst. But for what dost Thou thirst, O good +Jesus? "My meat and drink," saith He, "is that men should do My +Father's will. Now this is the will of My Father, even your +sanctification and salvation, that you may sanctify your souls by +walking in My precepts, by doing works of repentance, by adorning +yourselves with all virtues, in order that, like a bride adorned for +her husband, you may be worthy to be present at My supper in My +Father's kingdom, and to sleep with Me as My elect bride, in the +chamber of My Father's heart." O how Christ longs to bring all men +thither! This is the meaning of His words: "Where I am there shall +also My servant be"; and again: "Father, I will that they may be one +even as We are one." O, how incomprehensible is this thirst of +Christ! What toil and labour He endured for thirty and three years, +for the sake of it! For this His very heart's blood was poured out. +See what our tender Lord says to His Father: "The zeal of Thine +house hath even eaten Me." Truly, He would have submitted to be +crucified a thousand times, rather than allow one soul to perish +through any fault of His. O how this inward thirst tormented Him, +when He thought that He had done all that He could, and even a +hundredfold more than He need have done, and yet that so few had +turned to Him, and been won by Him. His whole body was now worn out; +all His blood was shed; nothing remained for Him to do; and +therefore He was constrained to confess, "It is finished"; and yet +by all His labours, afflictions, and sufferings, He had brought no +richer harvest to the Father than this. Truly, this was the most +bitter of all His sorrows, that after so hard a battle His victory +had not been more glorious, and that He returned a conqueror to His +Father with so few spoils. Therefore, all those who do not refresh +Him by performing His will, and doing all that is pleasing and +honourable to Him, and withstanding all that reason tells them to be +displeasing to Him, will one day hear Him say, "I was thirsty, and +ye gave Me no drink. Depart, ye cursed, into everlasting fire." + +Fourthly, there is yet another inward meaning of this word--namely, +that Christ spoke it out of the love which inwardly draws Him +towards all men, thus making known to us His ardent love, and +opening His own heart, as a delightful couch, on which we may feed +pleasantly, and inviting us to it, saying, "I thirst for you." For +as the liquid which we drink is sent down pleasantly through the +throat into the body, and so passes into the substance and nature of +our body, so Christ out of the ardent thirst of His love, takes +spiritual pleasure in drinking in all men into Himself, swallowing +them, as it were, and incorporating them into Himself, and bringing +them into the secret chamber of His loving heart. Therefore He says: +"I, if I be lifted up from the earth, will draw all men unto +Me"--all men, that is, who allow themselves to be drawn by Me, and +submit to Me as obedient instruments, suffering Me to do with them +according to My gracious will. But those who resist Him quench not +His thirst, but give Him a bitter draught instead, even the deeds of +their own self-will. These, when our Lord tasteth them, He +straightway rejects. + +THE SIXTH WORD + +WHEN Christ had tasted the draught of vinegar and gall, He spoke the +sixth word: "It is finished." Thereby He signified that by His +Passion had been fulfilled all the prophecies, types, mysteries, +scriptures, sacrifices, and promises, which had been predicted and +written about Him. This is that true Son of God, for whom the Father +of heaven made ready a supper in the kingdom of His eternal +blessedness; and He sent His servant--that is the human nature of +Christ, coming in the form of a servant, to call them that were +bidden to the wedding. For Christ, when He took human nature upon +Him, was not only a servant but a servant of servants, and served +all of us for thirty and three years with great toil and suffering. +Indeed, He spent His whole life in bidding all men to His supper. It +was for this that He preached, and wrought miracles, and travelled +from place to place, and proclaimed that the kingdom of heaven was +at hand, and that all should be prepared for it. But they would not +come. And when the Father of the household heard this, He said to +His Servant: "Compel them to come in, that My house may be filled." +Then that Servant thought within Himself: "How shall I be able +without violence to compel these men to come, that rebellion may be +avoided and yet that their privilege and power of free will may +remain unimpaired? For if I compel them to come by iron chains, and +blows, and whips, I shall have asses and not men." Then He said to +Himself: "I perceive that man is so constituted as to be prone to +love. Therefore I will show him such love as shall pass all his +understanding, love than which no other love can be greater. If man +will observe this, he will be so caught in its toils, that he will +not be able to escape its heat and flame, and will be constrained to +turn to God, and love Him in return. For, turn where he will, he +will always be met by the immeasurable benefits, the infinite +goodness, and the wonderful love of God; and at the same time he +will feel more and more compelled to return love for love, till he +will be no more able to resist it, and will be gently constrained to +follow." When this was done, Jesus Christ, this faithful and wise +Servant, said to His Lord and Father, "It is finished. I have +finished the work which Thou gavest Me to do. What more could I have +done, and have not done it? I have no member left that is not weary +and worn with toil and pain. My veins are dry, My blood is shed; My +marrow is spent, My throat is hoarse with crying. Such love have I +shown to man, that his heart cannot be human, cannot even be stony, +or the heart of a brute beast, but must be quite devilish and +desperate, if it be not moved by the thought of these things." + +Moreover, this word of our Lord Jesus is a word of sorrow, not of +joy. He spoke it not as if He had now escaped from all His +suffering. No; when He said, "It is finished," He meant all that had +been ordained and decreed by the eternal Truth for Him to suffer. +Besides, all the sufferings which had been inflicted upon Him by +degrees and singly, He now endures together with immeasurable +anguish. Who can have such a heart of adamant as not to be moved by +such torment as this? How short were the words which our Lord Jesus +spoke on the Cross, yet how full of sacramental mysteries! Now were +fulfilled the words of Exodus: "And all things were finished which +belonged to the sacrifice of the Lord." + +Moreover by this word our Lord declared the glorious victory of the +Passion, and how the old enemy, the jealous serpent, was overcome +and thrown down; for this was the cause for which He suffered. For +this He had taken upon Himself the garment of human nature, that He +might vanquish and confound the enemy, by the same weapons wherewith +the enemy boasted that he had conquered man. This was the chief +purpose of His Passion, and now He confesses that it is finished. O +how wonderful are the mysteries, and the victories, included in this +little but deep word: "It is finished!" All that the eternal Wisdom +had decreed, all that strict justice had demanded for each man, all +that love had asked for, all the promises made to the fathers, all +the mysteries, types, ceremonies in Scripture, all that was meet and +necessary for our redemption, all that was needed to wipe out our +debts, all that must repair our negligences, all that was glorious +and loving for the exhibition of this splendid love, all that we +could desire, for our spiritual instruction--in a word, all that was +good and fitting for the celebration of the glorious triumph of our +redemption, all is included in that one word, "It is finished." +What, then, remains for Him, but to finish and perfect His life in +this glorious conflict; and, because nothing remains for Him to do, +to commend His precious soul into His Father's hands, seeing that He +has fought the good fight, and finished His course in all holiness? +It is meet, then, that He should obtain the crown of glory which His +heavenly Father will give Him on the day of His exaltation. + +Lastly, by this word Christ offered up all His toil, sorrow, and +affliction for all the elect, as the Apostle saith: "Who in the days +of His flesh offered up prayer and supplications with strong crying +and tears unto Him who was able to save Him from death, and was +heard in that He feared. For if the blood of bulls and of goats and +the ashes of a heifer, sprinkling the unclean, sanctifieth to the +purifying of the flesh, how much more shall the blood of Christ, who +through the eternal Spirit offered Himself without spot to God, +purge our conscience from dead works to serve the living God?" + +THE SEVENTH WORD + +OUR Lord Jesus cried again with a loud voice, and said, "Father, +into Thy hands I commend My Spirit." O all ye who love our Lord +Jesus Christ, come, I beseech you, and let us watch, with all +devotion and pity, His passing away. Let us see what must have been +His sorrow and agony and torment, when His glorious soul was now at +last forced to pass out of His worthy and most sacred body, in which +for thirty and three years it had rested so sweetly, peacefully, +joyfully, and holily, even as two lovers on one bed. How hard was it +for them to be rent asunder, between whom no disagreement had ever +arisen, no strife, or quarrel, or treachery. How unspeakably +grievous was that Cross, when His sacred body was compelled to part +with so faithful a friend, so gentle an occupant, so loving a +teacher and master; and how great was the sorrow with which His +glorious and pure soul was torn away from so faithful a servant, +which had ever served obediently, never sparing any trouble, never +shrinking from cold or heat or hunger or thirst; always enduring +labour and sorrow in gentleness and patience. O how great was this +affliction! For, as the philosopher says: "Of all terrible things +death is the most terrible, on account of the natural and mutual +affection, which is very great, between soul and body." How much +greater must have been the anguish and sorrow, when the most holy +soul and body of Christ were sundered, between which there had +always been such wonderful harmony and love. Therefore, with inward +pity and anxious sorrow, let us meditate on this sad parting; for +the death of Christ is our life. + +Let us meditate devoutly how His sacred body, the instrument of our +salvation, was steeped in anguish, when all His members, as if to +bid a last farewell, were bowing themselves down to die! Who can +look without remorse and sorrow and pity upon the most gracious face +of Christ, and behold how it is changed into the pallor and likeness +of death; how tears still flow from His dimmed eyes; how His sacred +head is bent; how all His members prove to us, by signs and motions, +the love which they can no longer show by deeds. Let us pity Him, I +pray you, for He is our own flesh and blood, and it is for our sins, +not His own, that He is shamefully slain. O ye who up till now have +passed by the Cross of Jesus with tepid or cold hearts, and whom all +these torments and tears, and His blood shed like water, have not +been able to soften; now at last let this loud voice, this terrible +cry, rend and pierce your hearts through and through. Let that voice +which shook the heaven and the earth and hell with fear, which rent +the rocks and laid open ancient graves, now soften your stony +hearts, and lay bare the old sepulchres of your conscience, full of +dead men's bones--that is to say, of wicked deeds, and call again +into life your departed spirits. For this is the voice which once +cried: "Adam, where art thou; and what hast thou done?" This is the +voice which brought Lazarus from Hades, saying, "Lazarus, come +forth: arise from the grave of sin, and let them free thee from thy +grave-clothes." Truly it was not so much the grievousness of His +sufferings, as the greatness of our sins, which made our Lord utter +this cry. He cried also, to show that He had the dominion over life +and death, over the living and the dead. For though he was quite +worn out, and destitute of strength, and though He had borne the +bitter pangs of death so long, beyond the power of man, yet He would +not allow Death to put forth its power against Him, until it pleased +Him. + +With a loud voice He cried, that earthly men, who care only for the +things of earth, might quake with fear and trembling, and to cause +them to meditate and see how naked and helpless the Lord of lords +departed from this life. With a terrible voice He cried, to stir up +all those who live in wantonness, and who have grown old in their +defilement, and send forth a foul savour, like dead dogs, so that at +last these miserable men may rise from their lusts and pleasures and +sensual delights, and see how the Son of God, who was never strained +with any spot of defilement, went forth to His Father; and with what +toil and pain and anguish He departed from the light of day, and +what He had to suffer before He reached his Father's Kingdom. He +also cried with a loud voice, that He might inflame the lukewarm and +slothful to devotion and love. + +Moreover He cried with a loud voice as a sign of the glorious +victory which He had gained, when after a single combat with His +strong and cruel enemy, and having descended into the arena--the +battlefield of this world--He had routed him on Mount Calvary and +stripped him bare of his spoils. This victory, this glorious +triumph, Christ proclaimed with a loud voice, and thus departing +from the battlefield triumphant and victorious, He departed to the +place of all delights, to the heart and breast of God, His Father, +commending to it, as to a safe refuge, both Himself and all His own, +with the words, "Father, into Thy hands I commend My Spirit." + +We may learn from these words that the eternal Word, our Lord Jesus +Christ, had been let down like a fishing-hook or great net, by the +Father of heaven, into the great sea of this world, that He might +catch not fish but men. Hear how He says: "My word, that goeth forth +out of My mouth shall not return unto Me void, but shall execute +that which I please, and shall prosper in the thing whereto I send +it." And this net is drawn by the Father out of the salt sea, to the +peaceful shore of His fatherly heart, full of the elect, of works of +charity, of repentance, patience, humility, obedience, spiritual +exercises, merits and virtues. For Christ drew unto Himself all the +afflictions and good deeds of the good; just as St Paul says, "I +live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me." Even so, Christ lives in +all the good, and all who have been willing and obedient instruments +in the hands of Christ. In all such Christ lives and suffers and +works. For whatever good there is in all men, is all God's work. +Therefore Christ, feeling His Father drawing Him, gathered together +in Himself in a wonderful manner all the elect with all their works, +and commended them to His Father, saying, "My Father, these are +Thine; these are the spoils which I have won by My conquest, by the +sword of the Cross; these are the vessels which I have purchased +with My precious blood; these are the fruits of My labours. Keep in +Thine own name those whom Thou hast given Me. I pray not that Thou +shouldest take them out of the world, but that Thou shouldest keep +them from the evil." Thus did Christ commend Himself and all His own +into His Father's hands. Come therefore, O faithful and devout soul, +and contemplate with great earnestness the coming in and the going +out of thy Lord Jesus; follow Him with love and longing, even to the +chamber and bed of joy, which He has prepared for thee in thy +Father's heart. Happy would he be, who could now be dissolved with +Christ, and die with the thief, and hear from the lips of the Lord +that comfortable word, "This day shalt thou be with Me in paradise." +And though this is not granted to us, yet whatever we can here gain +by labours and watchings and fastings and prayers, let us commend it +all with Christ to the Father; let us pour it back again into the +fountain, whence it flowed forth for us; and let nothing be left in +us of empty self-satisfaction, no seeking after human praise or +honour or reward. But whatever our God hath been willing to do in +us, let us return it back into His own hands and say, "We are +nothing of ourselves. It is He who made us, and not we ourselves. +All good was made by Him, and without Him was not anything made. +When therefore He taketh with Him what He made Himself, we are +absolutely nothing." + +Lastly, Christ commended His soul into His Father's hands, to show +us how the souls of good and holy men mount up after Him to the +bosom of the eternal Father, who must otherwise have gone down to +hell; for it is He who has opened to us the way of life, and His +sacred soul, by making the journey safe and free from danger, has +been our guide into the kingdom of heaven. + + + + + + +SUSO + + + + + +SUSO AND HIS SPIRITUAL DAUGHTER + +AFTER this, certain very high thoughts arose in the mind of the +servitor's spiritual daughter, concerning which she asked him +whether she might put questions to him. He replied, Yea verily: +since thou hast been led through the proper exercises, it is +permitted to thy spiritual intelligence to enquire about high +things. Ask then whatever thou wilt. She said: Tell me, father, what +is God, and how He is both One and Three? The servitor replied, +These be indeed high questions. As to the first, What is God, you +must know that all the Doctors who ever lived cannot explain it, for +He is above all sense and reason. Yet if a man is diligent, and does +not relax his efforts, he gains some knowledge of God, though very +far off. Yet in this knowledge of God consists our eternal life and +man's supreme happiness. In this way, in former times, certain +worthy philosophers searched for God, and especially that great +thinker Aristotle, who tried to discover the Author of Nature from +the order of nature and its course. He sought earnestly, and he was +convinced from the well-ordered course of nature that there must of +necessity be one Prince and Lord of the whole universe--He whom we +call God. About this God and Lord we know this much, that He is an +immortal Substance, eternal, without before or after, simple, bare, +unchangeable, an incorporeal and essential Spirit, whose substance +is life and energy, whose most penetrating intelligence knows all +things in and by itself, whose essence in itself is an abyss of +pleasures and joys, and who is to Himself, and to all who shall +enjoy Him in a future life, a supernatural, ineffable, and most +sweet happiness. The maiden, when she heard this, looked up, and +said: These things are sweet to tell and sweet to hear, for they +rouse the heart, and lift the spirit up far beyond itself. +Therefore, father, tell me more about these things. The servitor +said: The Divine Essence, about which we speak, is an intelligible +or intellectual Substance of such a kind, that it cannot be seen in +itself by mortal eyes; but it can be discerned in its effects, even +as we recognise a fine artist by his works. As the Apostle teaches +us, "The invisible things of God from the creation of the world are +clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made." For the +creatures are a kind of mirror, in which God shines. This knowledge +is called speculation, by which we contemplate the great Architect +of the world in His works. Come now, look upward and about thee, +through all the quarters of the universe, and see how wide and high +the beautiful heaven is, how swift its motion, and how marvellously +its Creator has adorned it with the seven planets, and with the +countless multitude of the twinkling stars. Consider what +fruitfulness, what riches, the sun bestows upon the earth, when in +summer it sheds abroad its rays unclouded! See how the leaves and +grass shoot up, and the flowers smile, and the woods and plains +resound with the sweet song of nightingales and other birds; how all +the little animals, after being imprisoned by grim winter, come +forth rejoicing, and pair; and how men and women, both old and +young, rejoice and are merry. O Almighty God, if Thou art so lovable +and so pleasant in Thy creatures, how happy and blessed, how full of +all joy and beauty, must Thou be in Thyself? But further, my +daughter, contemplate the elements themselves--Earth, Water, Air, +and Fire, with all the wonderful things which they contain in +infinite variety--men, beasts, birds, fishes, and sea-monsters. And +all of these give praise and honour to the unfathomable immensity +that is in Thee. Who is it, Lord, who preserves all these things, +who nourishes them? It is Thou who providest for all, each in his +own way, for great and small, rich and poor. Thou, O God, doest +this; Thou alone art God indeed! Behold, my daughter, thou hast now +found the God whom thou hast sought so long. Look up, then, with +shining eyes, with radiant face and exulting heart, behold Him and +embrace Him with the outstretched arms of thy soul and mind, and +give thanks to Him as the one and supreme Lord of all creatures. By +gazing on this mirror, there springs up speedily, in one of loving +and pious disposition, an inward jubilation of the heart; for by +this is meant a joy which no tongue can tell, though it pours with +might through heart and soul. Alas, I now feel within me, that I +must open for thee the closed mouth of my soul; and I am compelled, +for the glory of God, to tell thee certain secrets, which I never +yet told to any one. A certain Dominican, well known to me, at the +beginning of his course used to receive from God twice every day, +morning and evening, for ten years, an outpouring of grace like +this, which lasted about as long as it would take to say the "Vigils +of the Dead" twice over.[40] At these times he was so entirely +absorbed in God, the eternal Wisdom, that he would not speak of it. +Sometimes he would converse with God as with a friend, not with the +mouth, but mentally; at other times he would utter piteous sighs to +Him; at other times he would weep copiously, or smile silently. He +often seemed to himself to be flying in the air, and swimming +between time and eternity in the depth of the Divine wonders, which +no man can fathom. And his heart became so full from this, that he +would sometimes lay his hand upon it as it beat heavily, saying, +"Alas, my heart, what labours will befall thee to-day?" One day it +seemed to him that the heart of his heavenly Father was, in a +spiritual and indescribable manner, pressed tenderly, and with +nothing between, against his heart; and that the Father's +heart--that is, the eternal Wisdom, spoke inwardly to his heart +without forms.[41] Then he began to exclaim joyously in spiritual +jubilation: Behold, now, Thou whom I most fervently love, thus do I +lay bare my heart to Thee, and in simplicity and nakedness of all +created things I embrace Thy formless Godhead! O God, most excellent +of all friends! Earthly friends must needs endure to be distinct and +separate from those whom they love; but Thou, O fathomless sweetness +of all true love, meltest into the heart of Thy beloved, and pourest +Thyself fully into the essence of his soul, that nothing of Thee +remains outside, but Thou art joined and united most lovingly with +Thy beloved. + +To this the maiden replied: Truly it is a great grace, when anyone +is thus caught up into God. But I should like to be informed, +whether this is the most perfect kind of union or not? The servitor +answered: No, it is not the most perfect, but a preliminary, gently +drawing a man on, that he may arrive at an essential way of being +carried up into God. The maiden asked him what he meant by essential +and non-essential. He answered: I call that man essential or +habitual (so to speak), who by the good and persevering practice of +all the virtues, has arrived at the point of finding the practice of +them in their highest perfection pleasant to him, even as the +brightness of the sun remains constant in the sun. But I call him +non-essential, in whom the brightness of the virtues shines in an +unstable and imperfect way like the brightness of the moon. That +full delight of grace which I described is so sweet to the spirit of +the non-essential man, that he would be glad always to have it. When +he has it, he rejoices; when he is deprived of it, he grieves +inordinately; and when it smiles upon him, he is reluctant to pass +to doing other things, even things that are pleasing to God; as I +will show you by an example. The servitor of the Divine Wisdom was +once walking in the chapter-house, and his heart was full of +heavenly jubilation, when the porter called him out to see a woman +who wished to confess to him. He was unwilling to interrupt his +inward delight, and received the porter harshly, bidding him tell +the woman that she must find some one else to confess to, for he did +not wish to hear her confession just then. She, however, being +oppressed with the burden of her sins, said that she felt specially +drawn to seek comfort from him, and that she would confess to no one +else. And when he still refused to go out, she began to weep most +sadly, and going into a corner, lamented greatly. Meanwhile, God +quickly withdrew from the servitor the delights of grace, and his +heart became as hard as flint. And when he desired to know the cause +of this, God answered him inwardly: Even as thou hast driven away +uncomforted that poor woman, so have I withdrawn from thee my Divine +comfort. The servitor groaned deeply and beat his breast, and +hurried to the door, and as he did not find the woman there, was +much distressed. The porter, however, looked about for her +everywhere, and when he found her, still weeping, bade her return to +the door. When she came, the servitor received her gently, and +comforted her sorrowing heart. Then he went back from her to the +chapter-house, and immediately God was with him, with His Divine +consolations, as before. + +Then said the maiden: It must be easy for him to bear sufferings, to +whom God gives such jubilation and internal joys. And yet, said the +servitor, all had to be paid for afterward with great suffering. +However, at last, when all this had passed away, and God's appointed +time had come, the same grace of jubilation was restored to him, and +remained with him almost continuously both at home and abroad, in +company and alone. Often in the bath or at table the same grace was +with him; but it was now internal, and did show itself outside. + +Then the maiden said: My father, I have now learned what God is; but +I am also eager to know where He is. Thou shalt hear, said the +servitor. The opinion of the theologians is that God is in no +particular place, but that He is everywhere, and all in all. The +same doctors say that we come to know a thing through its name. Now +one doctor says that Being is the first name of God. Turn your eyes, +therefore, to Being in its pure and naked simplicity, and take no +notice of this or that substance which can be torn asunder into +parts and separated; but consider Being in itself, unmixed with any +Not-Being. Whatever is nothing, is the negation of what is; and what +is, is the negation of what is not. A thing which has yet to be, or +which once was, is not now in actual being. Moreover, we cannot know +mixed being or not-being unless we take into account that which is +all-being. This Being is not the being of this or that creature; for +all particular being is mixed with something extraneous, whereby it +can receive something new into itself. Therefore the nameless Divine +Being must be in itself a Being that is all-being, and that sustains +all particular things by its presence. + +It shows the strange blindness of man's reason, that it cannot +examine into that which it contemplates before everything, and +without which it cannot perceive anything. Just as, when the eye is +bent on noticing various colours, it does not observe the light +which enables it to see all these objects, and even if it looks at +the light it does not observe it; so it is with the eye of the soul. +When it looks at this or that particular substance, it takes no heed +of the being, which is everywhere one, absolute and simple, and by +the virtue and goodness of which it can apprehend all other things. +Hence the wise Aristotle says, that the eye of our intelligence, +owing to its weakness, is affected towards that being which is +itself the most manifest of all things, as the eye of a bat or owl +is towards the bright rays of the sun. For particular substances +distract and dazzle the mind, so that it cannot behold the Divine +darkness, which is the clearest light. + +Come now, open the eyes of thy mind, and gaze if thou canst, on +Being in its naked and simple purity. You will perceive that it +comes from no one, and has no before nor after, and that it cannot +change, because it is simple Being. You will also observe that it is +the most actual, the most present, and the most perfect of beings, +with no defect or mutation, because it is absolutely one in its bare +simplicity. This is so evident to an instructed intellect, that it +cannot think otherwise. Since it is simple Being, it must be the +first of beings, and without beginning or end, and because it is the +first and everlasting and simple, it must be the most present. If +you can understand this, you will have been guided far into the +incomprehensible light of God's hidden truth. This pure and simple +Being is altogether in all things, and altogether outside all +things. Hence a certain doctor says: God is a circle, whose centre +is everywhere, and His circumference nowhere. + +When this had been said, the maiden answered: Blessed be God, I have +been shown, as far as may be, both what God is, and where He is. But +I should like also to be told how, if God is so absolutely simple, +He can also be threefold. + +The servitor answered: The more simple any being is in itself, the +more manifold is it in its energy and operation. That which has +nothing gives nothing, and that which has much can give much. I have +already spoken of the inflowing and overflowing fount of good which +God is in Himself. This infinite and superessential goodness +constrains Him not to keep it all within Himself, but to communicate +it freely both within and without Himself. But the highest and most +perfect outpouring of the good must be within itself, and this can +be nought else but a present, interior, personal and natural +outpouring, necessary, yet without compulsion, infinite and perfect. +Other communications, in temporal matters, draw their origin from +this eternal communication of the Divine Goodness. Some theologians +say that in the outflow of the creatures from their first origin +there is a return in a circle of the end to the beginning; for as +the emanation of the Persons from the Godhead is an image of the +origin of the creatures, so also it is a type of the flowing back of +the creatures into God. There is, however, a difference between the +outpouring of the creatures and that of God. The creature is only a +particular and partial substance, and its giving and communication +is also partial and limited. When a human father begets a son, he +gives him part, but not the whole, of his own substance, for he +himself is only a partial good. But the outpouring of God is of a +more interior and higher kind than the creature's outpouring, +inasmuch as He Himself is a higher good. If the outpouring of God is +to be worthy of His pre-eminent being, it must be according to +personal relations. + +Now, then, if you can look upon the pure goodness of the highest +Good (which goodness is, by its nature, the active principle of the +spontaneous love with which the highest Good loves itself) you will +behold the most excellent and superessential outpouring of the Word +from the Father, by which generation all things exist and are +produced; and you will see also in the highest good, and the highest +outpouring, the most holy Trinity, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, +existing in the Godhead. And if the highest outpouring proceeds from +the highest essential good, it follows that there must be in this +Trinity the highest and most intimate consubstantiality or community +of being, and complete equality and identity of essence, which the +Persons enjoy in sweetest communion, and also that the Substance and +power of the three almighty Persons is undivided and unpartitioned. + +Here the maiden exclaimed: Marvellous! I swim in the Godhead like an +eagle in the air. The servitor, resuming his exposition, continued: +It is impossible to express in words how the Trinity can subsist in +the unity of one essence. Nevertheless, to say what may be said on +the subject, Augustine says that in the Godhead the Father is the +Fountain-head of the Son and the Holy Ghost. Dionysius says, that in +the Father there is an outflowing of the Godhead, which naturally +communicates itself to the Word or Son. He also freely and lovingly +pours Himself out into the Son; and the Son in turn pours Himself +out freely and lovingly into the Father; and this love of the Father +for the Son, and of the Son for the Father, is the Holy Ghost. This +is truly said, but it is made clearer by that glorious Doctor of the +Church, St Thomas, who says as follows: In the outpouring of the +Word from the Father's heart, God the Father must contemplate +Himself with His own mind, bending back, as it were, upon His Divine +essence; for if the reason of the Father had not the Divine essence +for its object, the Word so conceived would be a creature instead of +God; which is false. But in the way described He is "God of God." +Again, this looking back upon the Divine essence, which takes place +in the mind of God, must, in a manner, produce a natural likeness; +else the Word would not be the Son of God. So here we have the unity +of essence in the diversity of Persons; and a clear proof of this +distinction may be found in the word of that soaring eagle St John: +"The Word was in the beginning with God." + +Thus the Father is the Fountain-head of the Son, and the Son is the +outflowing of the Father; and the Father and Son pour forth the +Spirit; and the Unity, which is the essence of the Fountain-head, is +also the substance of the three Persons. But as to how the Three are +One, this cannot be expressed in words, on account of the simplicity +of that Abyss. Into this intellectual Where, the spirits of men made +perfect soar and plunge themselves, now flying over infinite +heights, now swimming in unfathomed depths, marvelling at the high +and wonderful mysteries of the Godhead. Nevertheless, the spirit +remains a spirit, and retains its nature, while it enjoys the vision +of the Divine Persons, and abstracted from all occupation with +things below contemplates with fixed gaze those stupendous +mysteries. For what can be more marvellous than that simple Unity, +into which the Trinity of the Persons merges itself, and in which +all multiplicity ceases? For the outflowing of the Persons is always +tending back into the Unity of the same essence, and all creatures, +according to their ideal existence in God, are from eternity in this +Unity, and have their life, knowledge, and essence in the eternal +God; as it is said in the Gospel: "That which was made, was Life in +Him."[42] This bare Unity is a dark silence and tranquil inactivity, +which none can understand unless he is illuminated by the Unity +itself, unmixed with any evil. Out of this shines forth hidden +truth, free from all falsehood; and this truth is born from the +unveiling of the veiled Divine purity; for after the revelation of +these things, the spirit is at last unclothed of the dusky light +which up till now has followed it, and in which it has hitherto seen +things in an earthly way. Indeed, the spirit finds itself now +changed and something very different from what it supposed itself to +be according to its earlier light: even as St Paul says, "I, yet not +I." Thus it is unclothed and simplified in the simplicity of the +Divine essence, which shines upon all things in simple stillness. In +this modeless mode of contemplation, the permanent distinction of +the Persons, viewed as separate, is lost. For, as some teach, it is +not the Person of the Father, taken by Himself, which produces +bliss, nor the Person of the Son, taken by Himself, nor the Person +of the Holy Ghost, taken by Himself; but the three Persons, dwelling +together in the unity of the essence, confer bliss. And this is the +natural essence of the Persons, which by grace gives the substance +or essence to all their creatures, and it contains in itself the +ideas of all things in their simple essence. Now since this ideal +light subsists as Being, so all things subsist in it according to +their essential being, not according to their accidental forms; and +since it shines upon all things, its property is to subsist as +light. Hence all things shine forth in this essence in interior +stillness, without altering its simplicity. + +Then the maiden said: I could wish greatly, sir, that you could give +me this mysterious teaching, as you understand it, under a figure, +that I might understand it better. I should also be glad if you +could sum up what you have been saying at length, so that it may +stick more firmly in my weak mind. The servitor replied: Who can +express in forms what has no form? Who can explain that which has no +mode of being, and is above sense and reason? Any similitude must be +infinitely more unlike than like the reality. Nevertheless, that I +may drive out forms from your mind by forms, I will try to give you +a picture of these ideas which surpass all forms, and to sum up a +long discourse in a few words. A certain wise theologian says that +God, in regard to His Godhead, is like a vast circle, of which the +centre is everywhere, and the circumference nowhere. Now consider +the image which follows. If anyone throws a great stone into the +middle of a pool, a ring is formed in the water, and this ring makes +a second ring, and the second a third; and the number and size of +the rings depend on the force of the throw. They may even require a +larger space than the limit of the pool. Suppose now that the first +ring represents the omnipotent virtue of the Divine nature, which is +infinite in God the Father. This produces another ring like itself, +which is the Son. And the two produce the third, which is the Holy +Ghost. The spiritual superessential begetting of the Divine Word is +the cause of the creation of all spirits and all things. This +supreme Spirit has so ennobled man, as to shed upon him a ray from +His own eternal Godhead. This is the image of God in the mind, which +is itself eternal. But many men turn away from this dignity of their +nature, befouling the bright image of God in themselves, and turning +to the bodily pleasures of this world. They pursue them greedily and +devote themselves to them, till death unexpectedly stops them. But +he who is wise, turns himself and elevates himself, with the help of +the Divine spark in his soul, to that which is stable and eternal, +whence he had his own origin: he says farewell to all the fleeting +creatures, and clings to the eternal truth alone. + +Attend also to what I say about the order in which the spirit ought +to return to God. First of all, we should disentangle ourselves +absolutely from the pleasures of the world, manfully turning our +backs upon all vices; we should turn to God by continual prayers, by +seclusion, and holy exercise, that the flesh may thus be subdued to +the spirit. Next, we must offer ourselves willingly to endure all +the troubles which may come upon us, from God, or from the +creatures. Thirdly, we must impress upon ourselves the Passion of +Christ crucified; we must fix upon our minds His sweet teaching, His +most gentle conversation, His most pure life, which He gave us for +our example, and so we must penetrate deeper and advance further in +our imitation of Him. Fourthly, we must divest ourselves of external +occupations, and establish ourselves in a tranquil stillness of soul +by an energetic resignation, as if we were dead to self, and thought +only of the honour of Christ and His heavenly Father. Lastly, we +should be humble towards all men, whether friends or foes. . . . But +all these images, with their interpretations, are as unlike the +formless truth as a black Ethiopian is to the bright sun. + +Soon after this holy maiden died, and passed away happy from earth, +even as her whole life had been conspicuous only for her virtues. +After her death she appeared to her spiritual father in a vision. +She was clothed in raiment whiter than snow; she shone with dazzling +brightness, and was full of heavenly joy. She came near to him, and +showed him in what an excellent fashion she had passed away into the +simple Godhead. He saw and heard her with exceeding delight, and the +vision filled his soul with heavenly consolations. When he returned +to himself, he sighed most deeply, and thus pondered: O Almighty +God, how blessed is he, who strives after Thee alone! He may well be +content to bear affliction, whose sufferings Thou wilt thus reward! +May the Almighty God grant that we likewise may be brought to the +same joys as this blessed maiden! + +A MEDITATION ON THE PASSION OF CHRIST + +THEN said the Eternal Wisdom to the servitor, Attend and listen +dutifully, while I tell thee what sufferings I lovingly endured for +thy sake. + +After I had finished My last Supper with My disciples, when I had +offered Myself to My enemies on the mount, and had resigned Myself +to bear a terrible death, and knew that it was approaching very +near, so great was the oppression of My tender heart and all My +body, that I sweated blood; then I was wickedly arrested, bound, and +carried away. On the same night they treated Me with insult and +contumely, beating Me, spitting upon Me, and covering My head. +Before Caiaphas was I unjustly accused and condemned to death. What +misery it was to see My mother seized with unspeakable sorrow of +heart, from the time when she beheld Me threatened with such great +dangers, till the time when I was hung upon the cross. They brought +Me before Pilate with every kind of ignominy, they accused Me +falsely, they adjudged Me worthy of death. Before Herod I, the +Eternal Wisdom, was mocked in a bright robe. My fair body was +miserably torn and rent by cruel scourgings. They surrounded My +sacred head with a crown of thorns; My gracious face was covered +with blood and spittings. When they had thus condemned Me to death, +they led Me out with My cross to bear the last shameful punishment. +Their terrible and savage cries could be heard afar off: "Crucify, +crucify, the wicked man." + +Servitor. Alas, Lord, if so bitter were the beginnings of Thy +passion, what will be the end thereof? In truth, if I saw a brute +beast so treated in my presence I could hardly bear it. What grief +then should I feel in heart and soul at Thy Passion? And yet there +is one thing at which I marvel greatly. For I long, O my most dear +God, to know only Thy Godhead; and Thou tellest me of Thy humanity. +I long to taste Thy sweetness, and Thou showest me Thy bitterness. +What meaneth this, O my Lord God? + +Wisdom. No man can come to the height of My Godhead, nor attain to +that unknown sweetness, unless he be first led through the +bitterness of My humanity. My humanity is the road by which men must +travel. My Passion is the gate, through which they must enter. Away +then with thy cowardice of heart, and come to Me prepared for a hard +campaign. For it is not right for the servant to live softly and +delicately, while his Lord is fighting bravely. Come, I will now put +on thee My own armour. And so thou must thyself also experience the +whole of My Passion, so far as thy strength permits. Take, +therefore, the heart of a man; for be sure that thou wilt have to +endure many deaths, before thou canst put thy nature under the yoke. +I will sprinkle thy garden of spices with red flowers. Many are the +afflictions which will come upon thee; till thou hast finished thy +sad journey of bearing the cross, and hast renounced thine own will +and disengaged thyself so completely from all creatures, in all +things, which might hinder thine eternal salvation, as to be like +one about to die, and no longer mixed up with the affairs of this +life. + +Servitor. Hard and grievous to bear are the things which Thou +sayest, Lord. I tremble all over. How can I bear all these things? +Suffer me, O Lord, to ask Thee something. Couldst Thou not devise +any other way of saving my soul, and of testifying Thy love towards +me, so as to spare Thyself such hard sufferings, and so that I need +not suffer so bitterly with Thee? + +Wisdom. The unfathomable Abyss of My secret counsels no man ought to +seek to penetrate, for no one can comprehend it. And yet that which +thou hast suggested, and many other things, might have been +possible, which nevertheless never happen. Be assured, however, that +as created things now are, no more fitting method could be found. +The Author of Nature doth not think so much what He is able to do in +the world, as what is most fitting for every creature; and this is +the principle of His operations. And by what other means could the +secrets of God have been made known to man, than by the assumption +of humanity by Christ? By what other means could he who had deprived +himself of joy by the inordinate pursuit of pleasure, be brought +back more fittingly to the joys of eternity? And who would be +willing to tread the path, avoided by all, of a hard and despised +life, if God had not trodden it Himself? If thou wert condemned to +death, how could any one show his love and fidelity to thee more +convincingly, or provoke thee to love him in return more powerfully, +than by taking thy sentence upon himself? If, then, there is any one +who is not roused and moved to love Me from his heart by My immense +love, My infinite pity, My exalted divinity, My pure humanity, My +brotherly fidelity, My sweet friendship, is there anything that +could soften that stony heart? + +Servitor. The light begins to dawn upon me, and I seem to myself to +see clearly that it is as Thou sayest, and that whoever is not +altogether blind must admit that this is the best and most fitting +of all ways. And yet the imitation of Thee is grievous to a slothful +and corruptible body. + +Wisdom. Shrink not because thou must follow the footsteps of My +Passion. For he who loves God, and is inwardly united to Him, finds +the cross itself light and easy to bear, and has nought to complain +of. No one receives from Me more marvellous sweetness, than he who +shares My bitterest labours. He only complains of the bitterness of +the rind, who has not tasted the sweetness of the kernel. He who +relies on Me as his protector and helper may be considered to have +accomplished a large part of his task. + +Servitor. Lord, by these consoling words I am so much encouraged, +that I seem to myself to be able to do and suffer all things through +Thee. I pray Thee, then, that Thou wilt unfold the treasure of Thy +Passion to me more fully. + +Wisdom. When I was hung aloft and fastened to the wood of the cross +(which I bore for My great love to thee and all mankind), all the +wonted appearance of My body was piteously changed. My bright eyes +lost their light; My sacred ears were filled with mocking and +blasphemy; My sweet mouth was hurt by the bitter drink. Nowhere was +there any rest or refreshment for Me. My sacred head hung down in +pain; My fair neck was cruelly bruised; My shining face was +disfigured by festering wounds; My fresh colour was turned to +pallor. In a word, the beauty of My whole body was so marred, that I +appeared like a leper--I, the Divine Wisdom, who am fairer than the +sun. + +Servitor. O brightest mirror of grace, which the Angels desire to +look into, in which they delight to fix their gaze, would that I +might behold Thy beloved countenance in the throes of death just +long enough to water it with the tears of my heart, and to satisfy +my mind with lamentations over it. + +Wisdom. No one more truly testifies his grief over My Passion, than +he who in very deed passes through it with Me. Far more pleasing to +Me is a heart disentangled from the love of all transitory things, +and earnestly intent on gaining the highest perfection according to +the example which I have set before him in My life, than one which +continually weeps over My Passion, shedding as many tears as all the +raindrops that ever fell. For this was what I most desired and +looked for in My endurance of that cruel death--namely, that mankind +might imitate Me; and yet pious tears are very dear to Me. + +Servitor. Since then, O most gracious God, the imitation of Thy most +gentle life and most loving Passion is so pleasing to Thee, I will +henceforth labour more diligently to follow Thy Passion than to weep +over it. But since both are pleasing to Thee, teach me, I pray Thee, +how I ought to conform myself to Thy Passion. + +Wisdom. Forbid thyself the pleasure of curious and lax seeing and +hearing; let love make sweet to thee those things which formerly +thou shrankest from; eschew bodily pleasures; rest in Me alone; bear +sweetly and moderately the ills that come from others; desire to +despise thyself; break thy appetites; crush out all thy pleasures +and desires. These are the first elements in the school of Wisdom, +which are read in the volume of the book of My crucified body. But +consider whether anyone, do what he may, can make himself for My +sake such as I made Myself for his. + +Servitor. Come then, my soul, collect thyself from all external +things, into the tranquil silence of the inner man. Woe is me! My +heavenly Father had adopted my soul to be His bride; but I fled far +from Him. Alas, I have lost my Father, I have lost my Lover. Alas, +alas, and woe is me! What have I done, what have I lost? Shame on +me, I have lost myself, and all the society of my heavenly country. +All that could delight and cheer me has utterly forsaken me; I am +left naked. My false lovers were only deceivers. They have stripped +me of all the good things which my one true Lover gave me; they have +despoiled me of all honour, joy, and consolation. O ye red roses and +white lilies, behold me a vile weed, and see also how soon those +flowers wither and die, which this world plucks. And yet, O most +gracious God, none of my sufferings are of any account, compared +with this, that I have grieved the eyes of my heavenly Father. This +is indeed hell, and a cross more intolerable than all other pain. O +heart of mine, harder than flint or adamant, why dost thou not break +for grief? Once I was called the bride of the eternal King, now I +deserve not to be called the meanest of his handmaids. Never again +shall I dare to raise mine eyes, for shame. O that I could hide +myself in some vast forest, with none to see or hear me, till I had +wept to my heart's desire. O Sin, Sin, whither hast thou brought me? +O deceitful World, woe to those who serve thee! Now I have thy +reward, I receive thy wages--namely, that I am a burden to myself +and the whole world, and always shall be. + +Wisdom. Thou must by no means despair; it was for thy sins and those +of others that I came into this world, that I might restore thee to +Thy heavenly Father, and bring thee back to greater glory and honour +than thou ever hadst before. + +Servitor. Ah, what is this, which whispers such flattering things to +a soul that is dead, abhorred, rejected? + +Wisdom. Dost thou not know Me? Why art thou so despondent? Art thou +beside thyself with excessive grief, My dearest son? Knowest thou +not that I am Wisdom, most gentle and tender, in whom is the Abyss +of infinite mercy, never yet explored perfectly even by all the +saints, but none the less open to thee and all other sorrowing +hearts. I am he who for thy sake willed to be poor and an exile, +that I might recall thee to thy former honour. I am He who bore a +bitter death, that I might restore thee to life. I am thy Brother; I +am thy Bridegroom. I have put away all the wrong that thou ever +didst against Me, even as if it had never been, only henceforth, +thou must turn wholly to Me, and never again forsake Me. Wash away +thy stains in My blood. Lift up thy head, open thine eyes, and take +heart. In token of reconciliation, take this ring and put it on thy +finger as My bride, put on this robe, and these shoes on thy feet, +and receive this sweet and loving name, that thou mayst both be and +be called for ever My bride. Thou has cost Me much labour and pain; +for that cause, the Abyss of My mercy toward thee is unfathomable. + +Servitor. O kindest Father, O sweetest Brother, O only joy of my +heart, wilt Thou be so favourable to my unworthy soul? What is this +grace? What is the Abyss of Thy clemency and mercy? From the bottom +of my heart I thank Thee, O heavenly Father, and beseech Thee by Thy +beloved Son, whom Thou hast willed to suffer a cruel death for love, +to forget my impieties. . . . + +Now, O Lord, I remember that most loving word, wherewith in the book +of Ecclesiasticus[43] Thou drawest us to Thyself. "Come to me, all +ye who desire me, and be filled with my fruits. I am the mother of +beautiful affection. My breath is sweeter than honey, and my +inheritance above honey and the honeycomb." "Wine and music rejoice +the heart, and above both is the love of Wisdom."[44] Of a surety, O +Lord, Thou showest Thyself so lovable and desirable, that it is no +wonder that the hearts of all long for Thee, and are tormented by +the desire of Thee. Thy words breathe love, and flow so sweetly, +that in many hearts the love of temporal things has wholly dried up. +Therefore, I greatly long to hear Thee speak of Thy lovableness. +Come, O Lord, my only comfort, speak to the heart of Thy servant. +For I sleep sweetly beneath Thy shadow, and my heart is awake. + +Wisdom. Hear, My son, and see; incline thine ear, forgetting thyself +and all other things. Lo, I in Myself am that ineffable Good, which +is and ever was; which has never been expressed nor ever will be. +For although I give Myself to be felt by men in their inmost hearts, +yet no tongue can ever declare or explain in words what I am. For +verily all the beauty, grace, and adornment which can be conceived +by thee or by others, exists in me far more excellently, more +pleasantly, more copiously, than any one could say in words. I am +the most loving Word of the Father, begotten from the pure substance +of the Father, and wondrously pleasing am I to His loving eyes in +the sweet and burning love of the Holy Spirit. I am the throne of +happiness, the crown of souls: most bright are Mine eyes, most +delicate My mouth, My cheeks are red and white, and all My +appearance is full of grace and loveliness. All the heavenly host +gaze upon Me with wonder and admiration; their eyes are ever fixed +upon Me, their hearts rest in Me, their minds turn to Me and turn +again. O thrice and four times happy is he, to whom it shall be +given to celebrate this play of love amid heavenly joys at My side, +holding My tender hands in happiest security, for ever and ever to +all eternity. Only the word that proceeds out of My sweet mouth +surpasses the melodies of all the angels, the sweet harmony of all +harps, and musical instruments of every kind.... + +Servitor. There are three things, O Lord, at which I marvel greatly. +The first is, that although Thou art in Thyself so exceedingly +loving, yet towards sin Thou art a most severe judge and avenger. +Alas, Thy face in wrath is too terrible; the words which Thou +speakest in anger pierce the heart and soul like fire. O holy and +adorable God, save me from Thy wrathful countenance, and defer not +till the future life my punishment. + +Wisdom. I am the unchangeable Good, remaining always the same. The +reason why I do not appear always the same, is on account of those +who do not behold Me in the same way. By nature I am friendly; yet +none the less I punish vice severely, so that I deserve to be +feared. From My friends I require a pure and filial fear, and a +friendly love, that fear may ever restrain them from sin, and that +love may join them to Me in unbroken loyalty. + +Servitor. What Thou sayest pleases me, O Lord, and it is as I would +have it. But there is another thing at which I greatly marvel--how +it is that when the soul is faint from desire of the sweetness of +Thy presence, Thou art wholly mute, and dost not utter a single word +that can be heard. And who, O Lord, would not be grieved, when Thou +showest Thyself so strange, so silent, to the soul that loves Thee +above all things? + +Wisdom. And yet all the creatures speak of Me. + +Servitor. But that is by no means enough for the soul that loves. + +Wisdom. Also every word that is uttered about Me is a message of My +love; all the voices of holy Scripture that are written about Me are +letters of love, sweet as honey. They are to be received as if I had +written them Myself. Ought not this to satisfy thee? + +Servitor. Nay but, O most holy God, dearest Friend of all to me, +Thou knowest well that a heart which is on fire with love is not +satisfied with anything that is not the Beloved himself, in whom is +its only comfort. Even though all the tongues of all the angelic +spirits were to speak to me, none the less would my unquenchable +love continue to yearn and strive for the one thing which it +desires. The soul that loves Thee would choose Thee rather than the +kingdom of heaven. Pardon me, O Lord: it would become Thee to show +more kindness to those who love Thee so ardently, who sigh and look +up to Thee and say: Return, return! Who anxiously debate with +themselves: alas, thinkest thou that thou hast offended Him? That He +has deserted thee? Thinkest thou that He will ever restore thee His +most sweet presence, that thou wilt ever again embrace Him with the +arms of Thy heart, and press Him to thy breast, that all thy grief +and trouble may vanish? All this, O Lord, Thou hearest and knowest, +and yet Thou art silent. + +Wisdom. Certainly I know all this, and I watch it with great +pleasure. But I would have thee also answer a few questions, since +thy wonder, though veiled, is so great. What is it which gives the +greatest joy to the highest of all created spirits? + +Servitor. Ah, Lord, this question is beyond my range. I prithee, +answer it Thyself. + +Wisdom. I will do as thou desirest. The highest angelic spirit finds +nothing more desirable or more delightful than to satisfy My will in +all things; so much so, that if he knew that it would redound to My +praise for him to root out nettles and tares, he would diligently +fulfil this task in preference to all others. + +Servitor. Of a truth, Lord, this answer of Thine touches me sharply. +I perceive that it is Thy will that I should be resigned in the +matter of receiving and feeling tokens of Thy love, and that I +should seek Thy glory alone, in dryness and hardness as well as in +sweetness. + +Wisdom. No resignation is more perfect or more excellent, than to be +resigned in dereliction. + +Servitor. And yet, O Lord, the pain is very grievous. + +Wisdom. Wherein is virtue proved, if not in adversity? But be +assured, that I often come, and try whether the door into My house +is open, but find Myself repulsed. Many times I am received like a +stranger, harshly treated, and then driven out of doors. Nay, I not +only come to the soul that loves me, but tarry with her like a +friend; but that is done so secretly, that none know it save those +who live quite detached and separated from men, and observe My ways, +and care only to please and satisfy My grace. For according to My +Divinity I am purest Spirit, and I am received spiritually in pure +spirits. + +Servitor. So far as I understand, Lord God, Thou art a very secret +Lover. How glad would I be if Thou wouldest give me some signs, by +which I might know Thee to be truly present. + +Wisdom. By no other way canst thou know the certainty of My presence +better, than when I hide Myself from thee, and withdraw what is Mine +from thy soul. Then at last thou knowest by experience what I am, +and what thou art. Of a surety I am everlasting Good, without whom +no one can have anything good. When therefore I impart that immense +Good, which is Myself, generously and lovingly, and scatter it +abroad, all things to which I communicate Myself are clothed with a +certain goodness, by which My presence can be as easily inferred, as +that of the Sun, the actual ball of which cannot be seen, by its +rays. If therefore thou ever feelest My presence, enter into +thyself, and learn how to separate the roses from the thorns, the +flowers from the weeds. + +Servitor. Lord, I do search, and I find within myself a great +diversity. When I am deserted by Thee, my soul is like a sick man, +whose taste is spoiled. Nothing pleases me, but all things disgust +me. My body is torpid, my mind oppressed; within is dryness, without +is sadness. All that I see or hear, however good in reality, is +distasteful and hateful to me. I am easily led into sins; I am weak +to resist my enemies; I am cold or lukewarm towards all good. +Whoever comes to me, finds my house empty. For the House-Father is +away, who knows how to counsel for the best, and to inspire the +whole household. On the other hand, when the day-star arises in my +inmost heart, all the pain quickly vanishes, all the darkness is +dispelled, and a great brightness arises and shines forth. My heart +laughs, my mind is exalted, my soul becomes cheerful, all things +around me are blithe and merry; whatever is around me and within me +is turned to Thy praise. That which before seemed hard, difficult, +irksome, impossible, becomes suddenly easy and pleasant. To give +myself to fasting, watching, and prayer, to suffer or abstain or +avoid, in a word all the hardnesses of life seem when compared with +Thy presence to have no irksomeness at all. My soul is bathed in +radiance, truth, and sweetness, so that all its labours are +forgotten. My heart delights itself in abundant sweet meditations, +my tongue learns to speak of high things, my body is brisk and ready +for any undertaking; whoever comes to ask my advice, takes back with +him high counsels such as he desired to hear. In short, I seem to +myself to have transcended the limits of time and space, and to be +standing on the threshold of eternal bliss. But who, O Lord, can +secure for me, that I may be long in this state? Alas, in a moment +it is withdrawn from me; and for a long space again I am left as +naked and destitute as if I had never experienced anything of the +kind; till at last, after many and deep sighings of heart, it is +restored to me. Is this Thou, O Lord, or rather I myself? Or what is +it? + +Wisdom. Of thyself thou hast nothing except faults and defects. +Therefore that about which thou askest is I Myself, and this is the +play of love. + +Servitor. What is the play of love? + +Wisdom. So long as the loved one is present with the lover, the +lover knoweth not how dear the loved one is to him; it is only +separation which can teach him that. + +Servitor. It is a very grievous game. But tell me, Lord, are there +any who in this life no longer experience these vicissitudes of Thy +presence? + +Wisdom. You will find very few indeed. For never to be deprived of +My presence belongs not to temporal but to eternal life. + +APHORISMS AND MAXIMS + +ACT according to the truth in simplicity; and, whatever happens, do +not help thyself; for he who helps himself too much will not be +helped by the Truth. + +God wishes not to deprive us of pleasure; but He wishes to give us +pleasure in its totality--that is, all pleasure. + +Wilt thou be of use to all creatures? Then turn thyself away from +all creatures. + +If a man cannot comprehend a thing, let him remain quiet, and it +will comprehend him. + +Say to the creatures, I will not be to thee what thou art to me. + +The power of abstaining from things gives us more power than the +possession of them would. + +Some men one meets who have been inwardly drawn by God, but have not +followed Him. The inner man and the outer man in these cases are +widely at variance, and in this way many fail. + +He who has attained to the purgation of his senses in God performs +all the operations of the senses all the better. + +He who finds the inward in the outward goes deeper than he who only +finds the inward in the inward. + +He is on the right road who contemplates under the forms of things +their eternal essence. + +It is well with a man who has died to self and begun to live in +Christ. + + + + + + +RUYSBROEK + +THE ADORNMENT OF THE SPIRITUAL NUPTIALS + +BOOK I + + + + + +PREFACE + +"SEE the Bridegroom cometh: go forth to meet Him." St Matthew the +evangelist wrote these words, and Christ said them to His disciples +and to all men, in the Parable of the Ten Virgins. The Bridegroom is +our Lord Jesus Christ, and human nature is the bride, whom God has +made in His own image and likeness. He placed her at first in the +most exalted, the most beautiful, the richest and most fertile place +on earth--in paradise. He subjected to her all the creatures; He +adorned her with graces; and He laid a prohibition upon her, in +order that by obedience she might deserve to be established in an +eternal union with her Bridegroom, and never more fall into any +affliction, trouble, or guilt. Then came a deceiver--the infernal, +envious foe, under the guise of a cunning serpent. He deceived the +woman, and the two together deceived the man, who possessed the +essence of human nature. So the enemy despoiled human nature, the +bride of God, by his deceitful counsels, and she was driven into a +strange country; poor and miserable, a prisoner and oppressed, +persecuted by her enemies, as if she could never more return to her +country and the grace of reconciliation. But when God saw that the +time was come, and took pity on the sufferings of His beloved, He +sent His only Son to earth, in a rich abode and a glorious +temple--that is to say, in the body of the Virgin Mary. There he +married His bride, our nature, and united it to His Person, by means +of the pure blood of the noble Virgin. The priest who joined the +Bride and Bridegroom was the Holy Spirit; the angel Gabriel +announced the marriage, and the blessed Virgin gave her consent. So +Christ, our faithful Bridegroom, united our nature to His, and +visited us in a strange land, and taught us the manners of heaven +and perfect fidelity. And He laboured and fought like a champion +against our enemy, and He broke the prison and gained the victory, +and His death slew our death, and His blood delivered us, and He set +us free in baptism under the life-giving waters, and enriched us by +His sacraments and gifts, that we might go forth, as He said, +adorned with all virtues, and might meet Him in the abode of His +glory, to enjoy Him throughout all eternity. + +Now the Master of truth, Christ, saith: "See, the Bridegroom +cometh, go forth to meet Him." In these words Jesus, our Lover, +teaches us four things. In the first word He gives a command, for He +says, "See." Those who remain blind, and those who resist this +command are condemned without exception. In the next word He shows +us what we shall see--that is to say, the coming of the Bridegroom, +when He says, "The Bridegroom cometh." In the third place, He +teaches us and commands us what we ought to do, when He says, "Go +forth." In the fourth place, when He says, "to meet Him," He shows +us the reward of all our works and of all our life, for that must be +a loving "going forth," by which we meet our Bridegroom. + +We shall explain and analyse these words in three ways, first, +according to the ordinary mode of the beginner's life--that is to +say, the active life, which is necessary to all who would be saved. +In the second place, we shall analyse these words by applying them +to the inner life, exalted and loving, to which many men arrive by +the virtues and by the grace of God. Thirdly, we shall explain them +by applying them to the superessential and contemplative life, to +which few attain and which few can taste, because of the supreme +sublimity of this life. + +ON THE ACTIVE LIFE + +CHRIST, the Wisdom of the Father, hath said from the time of Adam +and still saith (inwardly, according to His Divinity), to all men, +"See"; and this vision is necessary. Now let us observe attentively +that for him who wishes to see materially or spiritually, three +things are necessary. First, in order that a man may be able to see +materially, he must have the external light of heaven, or another +natural light, in order that the medium--that is to say, the air +across which one sees, may be illuminated. In the second place, he +must have the will, that the things which he will see may be +reflected in his eyes. Thirdly, he must have the instruments, his +eyes, healthy and without flaw, that the material objects may be +exactly reflected in them. If a man lacks any one of these three +things, his material vision disappears. We shall speak no more of +this vision, but of another, spiritual and supernatural, wherein all +our blessedness resides. + +Three things are necessary for spiritual and supernatural vision. +First, the light of the divine grace, then the free conversion of +the will towards God, and lastly, a conscience pure from all mortal +sin. Now observe: God being a God common to all, and His boundless +love being common to all, He grants a double grace; both antecedent +grace, and the grace by which one merits eternal life. All men, +heathens and Jews, good and bad, have in common antecedent grace. In +consequence of the common love of God towards all men, He has caused +to be preached and published His name and the deliverance of human +nature, even to the ends of the earth. He who wishes to be converted +can be converted. For God wishes to save all men and to lose none. +At the day of judgment none will be able to complain that enough was +not done for him, if he had wished to be converted. So God is a +common Light and Splendour which illumine heaven and earth, and men +according to their merits and their needs. But though God is common, +and though the sun shines on all trees, some trees remain without +fruit, and others bear wild fruit useless to mankind. This is why we +prune these trees and graft fertile branches upon them, that they +may bear good fruit, sweet to taste and useful for men. The fertile +branch which comes from the living paradise of the eternal kingdom, +is the light of divine grace. No work can have savour, or be useful +to man, unless it comes from this branch. This branch of divine +grace, which makes man acceptable and by which we merit eternal +life, is offered to all. But it is not grafted on all, for they will +not purge away the wild branches of their trees--that is to say, +unbelief or a perverse will, or disobedience to the commandments of +God. But in order that this branch of divine grace may be planted in +our soul, three things are necessary; the antecedent grace of God, +the conversion of our free will, and the purification of the +conscience. Antecedent grace touches all men; but all men do not +attain to free conversion and purification of the conscience, and +this is why the grace of God, by which they might merit eternal +life, fails to touch them. The antecedent grace of God touches man +from within or from without. From without, by sickness or loss of +outward goods, of relations and friends, or by public shame; or +perhaps a man is moved by preaching, or by the examples of saints +and just men, by their words or works, till he comes to the +knowledge of himself. This is how God touches us from without. +Sometimes also a man is touched from within, by recalling the pains +and sufferings of our Lord, and the good which God has done to him +and to all men, or by the consideration of his sins, of the +shortness of life, of the eternal pains of hell and the eternal joys +of heaven, or because God has spared him in his sins and has waited +for his conversion; or he observes the marvellous works of God in +heaven, on earth, and in all creation. These are the works of +antecedent divine grace, which touch man from within or from +without, and in divers manners. And man has still a natural +inclination towards God, proceeding from the spark of his soul or +synteresis, [Footnote: See Introduction] and from the highest +reason, which always desires the good and hates the evil. Now, in +these three manners God touches every man according to his needs, so +that the man is struck, warned, frightened, and stops to consider +himself. All this is still antecedent grace and not merited; it thus +prepares us to receive the other grace, by which we merit eternal +life; when the mind is thus empty of bad wishes and bad deeds, +warned, struck, in fear of what it ought to do, and considers God, +and considers itself with its evil deeds. Thence come a natural +sorrow for sin and a natural good will. This is the highest work of +antecedent grace. + +When man does what he can, and can go no further because of his +weakness, it is the infinite goodness of God which must finish this +work. Then comes a higher splendour of the grace of God, like a ray +of the sun, and it is poured upon the soul, though it is as yet +neither merited nor desired. In this light God gives Himself, by +free will and by bounty, and no one can merit it before he has it. +And it is in the soul an internal and mysterious operation of God, +above time, and it moves the soul and all its faculties. Here then +ends antecedent grace; and here begins the other--that is to say, +supernatural light. + +This light is the first necessary condition, and from it is born a +second spiritual condition--that is to say, a free conversion of the +will in a moment of time, and then love is born in the union of God +and the soul. These two conditions are connected, so that one cannot +be accomplished without the other. There, where God and the soul are +united in the unity of love, God grants His light above time, and +the sou! freely turns to God by the force of grace, in a moment of +time, and charity is born in the soul, from God and the soul, for +charity is a bond of love between God and the loving soul. From +these two things, the grace of God, and the free conversion of the +will illuminated by grace, is born charity--that is to say, divine +love. And from divine love proceeds the third point, the +purification of the conscience. And this is accomplished in the +consideration of sin and of the flaws in the soul, and because man +loves God, there enters into him a contempt for self and for all his +works. This is the order of conversion. From it are born a true +repentance and a perfect sorrow for the evil that we have done, and +an ardent desire to sin no more and to serve God henceforward in +humble obedience; from it are born a sincere confession, without +reserves, without duplicity and without pretences, the desire to +satisfy God and to undertake the practice of all the virtues and all +good works. These three things, as you have just heard, are +necessary for divine vision. If you possess them, Christ says to +you, "See," and you become really seeing. This is the first of the +four chief ways in which Christ, our Lord, says "See." + +ON THE FIRST COMING OF CHRIST, IN THE FLESH + +NEXT, He shows us what we shall see when He says, "The Bridegroom +cometh." Christ, our Bridegroom, says this word in Latin: Venit. +The word expresses two tenses, the past and the present, and yet +here it indicates the future. And this is why we must consider three +comings of our Bridegroom Jesus Christ. At His first coming He was +made man for love of man. The second coming is daily and frequent in +every loving soul, with new graces and new gifts, as man is able to +receive them. In the third coming, He will come manifestly on the +dreadful day of judgment or at the hour of each man's death. In all +these comings we must observe three things, the cause, the interior +mode, and the external work. + +The cause of the creation of angels and men is the infinite goodness +and nobleness of God; He wished that the wealth and blessedness, +which are Himself, should be revealed to reasonable creatures, for +them to enjoy in time, and in eternity above time. The reason why +God became man, is His inconceivable love, and the distress of all +men, lost since the fall in original sin, and unable to raise +themselves again. But the reason why Christ, according to His +divinity and His humanity, accomplished His works on earth, is +fourfold--namely, His divine love, which is without measure; the +created love, which is called charity, and which He had in His soul +by the union of the Eternal Word and the perfect gift of His Father; +the great distress of human nature; and the glory of His Father. +These are the reasons for the coming of Christ, our Bridegroom, and +for all His works, exterior and interior. + +Now we must observe in Jesus Christ, if we wish to follow Him in His +virtues according to our powers, the mode or condition which He had +within, and the works which He wrought without, for they are virtues +and the acts of virtues. + +The mode which He had according to His divinity is inaccessible and +incomprehensible to us, for it is after this mode that He is +continually born of the Father, and that the Father in Him and by +Him knows and creates and orders, and rules everything in heaven and +on earth; for He is the Wisdom of the Father, and from them flows +spiritually a Spirit--that is to say, a love, which is the bond +between them and the bond of all the saints and just persons on +earth and in heaven. We will speak no more of this mode but of the +created mode which He had by these divine gifts and according to His +humanity. These modes are singularly multiform; for Christ had as +many modes as He had interior virtues, for each virtue has its +special mode. These virtues and these modes were, in the mind of +Christ, above the intelligence and above the comprehension of all +creatures. But let us take three--namely, humility, charity, and +interior or exterior suffering in patience. These are the three +principal roots and origins of all virtues and all perfection. + +ON THE TWOFOLD HUMILITY OF CHRIST + +NOW understand: there are two kinds of humility in Jesus Christ, +according to His divinity. First, He willed to become man; and this +nature, which was accursed even to the depth of hell, He accepted +according to His personality and was willing to unite Himself to it. +So that every man, good or bad, may say, Jesus Christ, the Son of +God, is my brother. Secondly, He chose for mother a poor virgin, and +not a king's daughter, so that this poor virgin became the mother of +God, who is the only Lord of heaven and earth and all creatures. In +consequence, of all the works of humility which Christ ever +accomplished, one may say that God accomplished them. Now let us +take the humility which was in Jesus Christ according to His +humanity and by grace and divine gifts; according to His humility +His soul inclined with all its power in respect and veneration +before the power of the Father. For an inclined heart is a humble +heart. This is why He did all His works to the praise and glory of +the Father, and sought in nothing His own glory according to His +humanity. He was humble, and submitted to the old law, and to the +commandments, and often to the customs. He was circumcised, and +carried to the Temple, and redeemed according to usages, and He paid +taxes to Caesar like other Jews. And He submitted Himself humbly to +His mother and to Joseph, and served them with a sincere deference +according to their needs. He chose for friends--for apostles--the poor +and the despised, in order to convert the world. In his intercourse +with them and all others He was humble and modest. This is why He +was at the disposal of all men, in whatever distress they were, +within or without; He was, as it were, the servant of the whole +world. This is what we find first in Jesus Christ, our Bridegroom. + +ON THE LOVE OF CHRIST, ADORNED WITH ALL VIRTUES + +NEXT comes charity, the beginning and source of all virtues. This +charity maintained the supreme forces of His soul in tranquillity, +and in the enjoyment of the same blessedness which He enjoys at +present. And this same charity kept Him continually exalted towards +His Father, with veneration, love, praise, respect, with internal +prayers for the need of all men, and with the offering of all His +works to the glory of God the Father. And this same charity made +Christ still overflow with love and kindness towards all the +material or spiritual needs of mankind. This is why He has given, by +His life, the model after which all men should fashion their lives. +He has given spiritual nourishment to all well-disposed men by real +internal teachings, as well as by outward miracles. We cannot +comprehend His charity to its full extent, for it flowed from the +unfathomable fountains of the Holy Spirit, above all the creatures +who have ever received charity, for He was God and man in one +Person. This is the second point of charity. + +ON THE PATIENCE OF CHRIST, EVEN UNTO DEATH + +THE third point is to suffer in patience. We will examine this +seriously, for it is this which adorned Christ, our Bridegroom, +during all His life. He suffered when He was newly born, from +poverty and cold. He was circumcised and shed his blood. He was +obliged to fly into a foreign country. He served Joseph and His +mother, He suffered from hunger and thirst, from shame and contempt +and from the wicked words and deeds of the Jews. He fasted, He +watched, and was tempted by the enemy. He was subject to all men, He +went from district to district, from town to town, to preach the +gospel painfully and zealously. Finally, He was taken by the Jews, +who were His enemies and whom He loved. He was betrayed, mocked, +insulted, scourged, struck, and condemned on false testimony. He +carried His cross with great pain to the mount of Calvary. He was +stripped naked as at His birth, and never was seen a body so +beautiful, nor a mother so unhappy. He endured shame, pain, and cold +before all the world, for He was naked, and it was cold, and He was +exhausted by His wounds. He was nailed with large nails to the wood +of the cross, and was so strained that His veins were burst. He was +lifted up and shaken upon the cross, so as to make His wounds bleed, +His head was crowned with thorns, and His ears heard the fierce Jews +crying out, "Crucify Him! crucify Him!" and many other shameful +words. His eyes saw the obstinacy and wickedness of the Jews, and +the distress of His mother, and His eyes were extinguished under the +bitterness of pain and death. His mouth and palate were hurt by the +vinegar and gall, and all the sensitive parts of His body wounded by +the scourge. + +Behold then Christ, our Bridegroom, wounded to death, abandoned by +God and the creatures, dying on the cross, hanging from a post, with +no one to care much for Him except Mary, His unhappy mother, who +nevertheless could not aid Him. And Christ suffered moreover +spiritually, in His soul, from the hardness of the Jews' hearts and +those who made Him die, for in spite of the prodigies and miracles +which they saw, they remained in their wickedness; and He suffered +by reason of their corruption and the vengeance which God was about +to inflict upon them, in body and soul, for His death. He suffered +moreover for the grief and misery of His mother and disciples, who +were in great sadness. And He suffered because His death would be +wasted for many men, and for the ingratitude of many, and for the +blasphemies of those who would curse Him who died for love of us. +And His nature and interior reason suffered because God withdrew +from them the inflow of His gifts and consolations, and abandoned +them to themselves in such distress. Therefore Christ complained and +said, My God, my God, why hast Thou forsaken me? + +Behold then the interior virtues of Christ; humility, charity, and +suffering in patience. These three virtues Jesus, our Bridegroom, +practised throughout His life, and He died in them, and He paid our +debt by satisfying justice, and opened His side in His bounty. And +thence flow rivers of delight, and sacraments of blessedness. And He +was exalted to His power, and sat at the right hand of the Father, +and reigns eternally. This is the first coming of our Bridegroom, +and it is completely past. + +ON THE SECOND COMING OF CHRIST, HOW HE EVERY DAY FLOWS INTO OUR +HEARTS WITH NEW GRACE + +THE second coming of Christ, our Bridegroom, takes place every day +in just men. We do not wish to speak here of the first conversion of +man, nor of the first grace which was given him when he was +converted from sin to virtue. But we wish to speak of a daily +increase of new gifts and new virtues, and of a more actual coming +of Christ, our Bridegroom, into our soul. Now we must observe the +cause, the mode, and the work, of this coming. The cause is fourfold; +the mercy of God, our misery, the divine generosity, and our +desire. These four causes make the virtues grow and increase. + +Now understand. When the sun sends forth its bright rays into a deep +valley between two high mountains, and while it is at the zenith, so +that it can illuminate the depths of the valley, a triple phenomenon +occurs; for the valley is lighted from the mountains, and it becomes +warmer and more fertile than the plain. In the same way, when a just +man sinks in his misery, and recognises that he has nothing, and is +nothing, that he can neither halt nor go forward by his own +strength; and when he perceives also that he fails often in virtues +and good works, he thus confesses his poverty and distress, and +forms the valley of humility. And because he is humble and in need, +and because he confesses his need, he makes his plaint to the +kindness and mercy of God. He is conscious of the sublimity of God, +and of his own abasement. + +Thus he becomes a deep valley. And Christ is the sun of justice and +mercy, which burns at the meridian of the firmament--that is to say, +at the right hand of the Father, and shines even to the bottom of +humble hearts; for Christ is always moved by distress, when man +humbly offers to Him complaints and prayers. Then the two mountains +rise--that is to say, a double desire, in the first place a desire to +serve and love God by his merits, in the second place to obtain +excellent virtues. These two desires are higher than heaven, for +they touch God without any intermediary, and desire His immense +generosity. Then that generosity cannot be kept back, it must flow, +for the soul is at this moment susceptible of receiving countless +boons. + +These are the causes of the second coming of Christ, with new +virtues. Then the valley--that is to say, the humble heart, receives +three things. It is enlightened the more, and illuminated by grace, +and warmed by charity, and becomes more fertile in virtues and good +works. Thus you have the cause, the mode, and the work, of this +coming. + +HOW WE MAY MAKE DAILY PROGRESS BY THE SACRAMENTS OF THE CHURCH + +THERE is yet another coming of Christ, our Bridegroom, which takes +place every day, in the growth of grace and in new gifts--that is to +say, when a man receives some sacrament with a humble and +well-prepared heart. He receives then new gifts and more ample +graces, by reason of his humility, and by the internal and secret +work of Christ in the sacrament. That which is contrary to the +sacrament is in baptism the want of faith, in confession the want of +contrition; it is to go to the sacrament of the altar in a state of +mortal sin, or of bad will; and it is the same with the other +sacraments. + +ON THE THIRD COMING OF CHRIST, TO JUDGMENT + +THE third coming, which is still future, will take place at the last +judgment or at the hour of death. Christ, our Bridegroom and our +Judge at this judgment, will recompense and avenge according to +justice, for He will award to each according to his deserts. He +gives to every just man, for every good work done in the spirit of +the Lord, a reward without measure, which no creature can merit-- +namely, Himself. But as He co-operates in the creature, the creature +deserves, through His merit, to have a reward. And by a necessary +justice He gives eternal pains to those who have rejected an eternal +good for a perishable. + +ON THE THIRD SPIRITUAL GOING FORTH, TO ALL THE VIRTUES + +NOW understand and observe. Christ says at the beginning of our +text, "See"--that is to say, see by charity and pureness of +conscience, as you have been told. Now, He has shown us what we +shall see--namely, His three comings. + +He orders us what we must do next, and says, "Go forth" if you have +fulfilled the first necessary condition--that is to say, if you see +in grace and in charity, and if you have well observed your model, +Christ, in His "going forth"; there leaps up in you, from your love +and loving observation of your Bridegroom, an ardour of justice-- +that is to say, a desire to follow Him in virtue. Then Christ says +in you, "Go forth." This going forth must have three modes. We must +go forth towards God, towards ourselves, and towards our neighbour +by charity and justice; for charity always pushes upward, towards +the kingdom of God, which is God Himself; for He is the source from +which it flowed without any intermediary, and He remains always +immanent in it. The justice which is born of charity wishes to +perfect the manners and the virtues which are suitable to the +kingdom of God--that is to say, to the soul. These two things, +charity and justice, establish a solid foundation in the kingdom of +the soul where God may dwell, and this foundation is humility. These +three virtues support all the weight and all the edifice of all the +virtues and all sublimity; for charity maintains man in presence of +the unfathomable good things of God from whence it flows, so that it +perseveres in God, and increases in all the virtues and in true +humility; and justice maintains man in presence of the eternal truth +of God, so that truth may be discovered by him, and that he may be +illuminated, and may accomplish all the virtues without error. But +humility maintains man always before the supreme power of God, so +that he remains always abased and little, and abandons himself to +God, and holds no longer by himself. This is the way in which a man +must bear himself before God, that he may grow alway in new virtues. + +HOW HUMILITY IS THE FOUNDATION OF ALL THE VIRTUES + +NOW understand; for having made humility the base of everything, we +must speak first of it. Humility is the desire of abasement or of +depth--that is to say, an inclination or internal desire for +abasement of heart and conscience before the sublimity of God. The +justice of God exacts this submission, and, thanks to charity, the +loving heart cannot abandon it. When the loving and humble man +considers that God has served him so humbly, so lovingly, and so +faithfully, and then that God is so high, so powerful, and so noble, +and that man is so poor, little, and base, there is born from all +this, in the humble heart, an immense respect and reverence towards +God; for to reverence God in all works, within and without, is the +first and most delightful work of humility, the sweetest work of +charity, and the most suitable work of justice. For the humble and +loving heart cannot pay honours to God and His noble humanity, nor +abase himself so deeply as to satisfy his desire. That is why it +seems to the humble man that he always does too little in honour of +God and in his humble service. And he is humble, and venerates Holy +Church and the sacraments, and he is temperate in meat and drink, in +his words, and in all relations of life. He is content with poor +raiment, with menial employment, and his face is naturally humble, +without pretence. And he is hunible in his practices, within and +without, before God and before men, that none may be offended by +reason of him. Thus he tames and removes far from him all pride, +which is the cause and origin of all sins. Humility breaks the +snares of sin, the world, and the Devil. And man is ordered within +himself, and established in the very place of virtue. Heaven is open +to him, and God is inclined to hear his prayer, and he is loaded +with graces. And Christ, the solid stone, is his support, and he who +builds his virtues upon humility cannot go wrong. + +ON OBEDIENCE + +FROM this humility is born obedience, for only the humble man can be +inwardly obedient. Obedience is a submission and pliant disposition, +and a good will ready for all that is good. Obedience subjects a man +to orders, to prohibitions, and to the will of God, and it subjects +the soul and sensual force to the highest reason, in such a way that +the man lives suitably and reasonably. And it makes men submissive +and obedient to Holy Church and to the sacraments, and to all the +good practices of holy Christianity. It prepares man, and makes him +ready for the service of all, in works, in bodily and spiritual +care, according to the needs of each, and prudence. Also, it drives +far away disobedience, which is the daughter of pride, and which we +ought to flee from more than from poison. Obedience in will and work +adorns, extends, and manifests the humility of man. It gives peace +to cloisters, and if it exists in the prelate, as it ought to exist, +it attracts those who are under his orders. It maintains peace and +equality among equals. And he who observes it is beloved by those +who are above him, and the gifts of God, which are eternal, elevate +and enrich him. + +ON THE ABDICATION OF OUR OWN WILL + +FROM this obedience is born the abdication of our own will. By this +abdication the substance and occasion of pride are repulsed, and the +greatest humility is accomplished. And God rules the man as He +wills; and the will of the man is so well united to that of God that +he can neither wish nor desire anything otherwise. He has put off +the old man, and has put on the new man, renewed and perfect +according to the divine will. It is of such an one that Christ said, +"Blessed are the poor in spirit," that is, those who have renounced +their will--"for theirs is the kingdom of heaven." + +ON PATIENCE + +FROM the abandonment of the will is born patience; for no one can +be perfectly patient in everything, except he who has submitted his +will to the will of God, and to all men in things useful and +convenient. Patience is a tranquil endurance of all that can happen +to a man, whether sent by God or by men. Nothing can trouble the +patient man, neither the loss of earthly goods, nor the loss of +friends or relations, nor sickness, nor disgrace, nor life, nor +death, nor purgatory, nor the devil, nor hell. For he has abandoned +himself to the will of God in true love. And, provided that mortal +sin does not touch him, all that God orders for him in time or +eternity seems light. This patience adorns a man, and arms him +against anger and sudden rage, and against impatience of suffering, +which often deceives a man within and without, and exposes him to +manifold temptations. + +ON GENTLENESS + +FROM this patience are born gentleness and kindness, for no one can +be gentle under adversity if not the patient man. Gentleness creates +in man peace and repose from everything; for the gentle man endures +insulting words and gestures, and bad faces and bad deeds, and all +manner of injustice towards his friends and himself, and he is +content with all, for gentleness is suffering in repose. Thanks to +gentleness, the force of anger remains immovable in its +tranquillity, the force of desire lifts itself up towards the +virtues, and the reason rejoices, and the conscience dwells in +peace, for the other mortal sins, such as anger and rage, are +removed far from her. For the Spirit of God reposes in a gentle and +humble heart, as Christ saith, "Blessed are the meek, for they shall +inherit the earth"--that is to say, their own nature and the things +of earth in meekness, and, after this life, the things of eternity. + +ON KINDNESS + +FROM the same source as gentleness comes kindness, for the gentle +spirit alone can possess kindness. This kindness causes a man to +oppose a loving face and friendly words, and all the works of pity, +to those who are angry with him, and he hopes that they will return +to themselves and amend. Thanks to mercy and kindness, charity +remains lively and fruitful in a man; for the heart full of kindness +is like a lamp full of precious oil; and the oil of kindness +lightens the wandering sinner by its good example, and soothes and +heals by consoling words and deeds those whose heart is wounded, +saddened, or irritated. And it inflames and illumines those who are +in charity, and no jealousy or envy can touch it. + +ON COMPASSION + +FROM kindness is born compassion, by which we sympathise with every +one, for no one can suffer with all men, except he who has kindness. +Compassion is an inward movement of the heart, aroused by pity for +the bodily or spiritual distress of all men. This compassion makes a +man partaker in Christ's sufferings, when he considers the reason of +these sufferings, the resignation and love of Christ, His wounds, +His tortures, His shame, His nobleness, His misery, the shame which +He endured, the crown, the nails, and the death in patience. These +unheard of and manifold pains of Christ, our Redeemer and +Bridegroom, move to pity anyone who is capable of feeling pity. +Compassion makes a man observe and note his faults, his want of +power to do any good thing, and weakness in all that pertains to the +glory of God; his lukewarmness and slowness, the multitude of his +faults, the waste of his time, and his positive shortcomings in +virtue and good conduct. All this makes a man truly sorry for +himself. Then his compassion for himself makes him consider his +errors and wanderings, the small care which he has of God and of his +eternal salvation, his ingratitude for all the good that God has +done him, and for all that He has suffered for man. And he considers +also that he is a stranger to the virtues, that he neither knows +them nor practises them, while he is clever and crafty in all that +is bad and unjust; he sees how attentive he is to the loss or gain +of worldly goods, how inattentive and indifferent towards God, the +things of eternity, and his own salvation. This consideration makes +the just man feel a great compassion towards the salvation of all +men. The man will also observe with pity the bodily needs of his +neighbour and the manifold pains of nature, when he sees the hunger +which men suffer, the thirst, cold, nakedness, poverty, contempt, +and oppression; the sadness which they feel at the loss of +relations, friends, goods, honour, and repose; and the innumerable +afflictions to which flesh is heir. All this rouses the just man to +compassion, and he suffers with all men; but his greatest suffering +arises when he sees the impatience of others under their own +sufferings, by which they lose their reward and often deserve hell. +This is the work of compassion and pity. + +This work of compassion and love for all men overcomes and removes +the third mortal sin--namely, hatred and envy; for compassion is a +wound of the heart, which makes us love all men, and can only work +healing in so far as some suffering lives in men; for God has +ordained that mourning and pain must precede all the other virtues. +This is why Christ said, "Blessed are they that mourn, for they +shall be comforted"--that is to say, when they shall reap in joy what +they now sow in compassion and sorrow. + +ON GENEROSITY + +FROM this compassion is born generosity, for no one can be +supernaturally generous, with faith in all men, and with love, +except the merciful man; though one many give to a particular +individual without charity, and without supernatural generosity. + +Generosity is the copious outflow of a heart moved with charity and +pity. When a man considers with compassion the sufferings and pains +of Christ, from this compassion is born generosity, which excites us +to praise and thank Christ for His pains and for His love, at the +same time that it causes to be born in us respect and veneration, +and a joyous and humble submission of heart and soul, in time and in +eternity. When a man observes and pities himself, and considers the +good that God has done to him and his own weakness, he cannot help +flowing out into the liberality of God, taking refuge in His pity +and fidelity, and abandoning himself to God, with a free and perfect +wish to serve Him for ever. The generous man, who observes the +errors, the wanderings, and the injustice of men, desires and +implores the outflow of the divine gifts and the exercise of their +generosity on all men, that they may return to themselves and be +converted to the truth. The generous man considers also with +compassion the material needs of all men; he helps them, gives, +lends, consoles to the best of his power. By means of this +generosity, men practise the seven works of mercy, the rich by their +services and the bestowal of their goods, the poor by good will and +the desire to do good if they can, and thus the virtue of generosity +is perfected. Generosity in the depth of the heart multiplies all +the virtues, and illuminates the forces of the soul. For the +generous, man is always of joyful spirit, he is without anxiety; he +is full of sympathy, and is ready to do kindnesses to all men in the +works of virtue. He who is generous, and loves not the things of +earth, however poor he may be, is like unto God, for all that he +has, and all the thoughts of his heart flow out of him in largess. +And so he is delivered from the fourth of the deadly sins, avarice. +Jesus Christ saith to these: "Blessed are the merciful, for they +shall obtain mercy"; in the day when they shall hear this word +spoken unto them: "Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the +kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world." + +ON ZEAL AND DILIGENCE + +FROM this generosity are born supernatural zeal and diligence in all +the virtues. None can exhibit this zeal, save the generous and +diligent man. This is an internal and eager impulse towards all the +virtues, and towards the imitation of Christ and the saints. In this +zeal, a man desires to expend in the honour of God the united powers +of his heart and senses, his soul and body, all that he is, and all +that he may receive. This zeal makes a man watchful in reason and +discrimination, and makes him practise the virtues in justice. +Thanks to this supernatural zeal, all the forces of his soul are +open to God, and prepared for all the virtues. His conscience is +refreshed, and divine grace is increased, virtue is practised with +joy, and his external works are adorned. He who has received this +lively zeal from God is removed far from the fifth deadly +sin--lukewarmness and gloominess towards the virtues necessary for +salvation. [Footnote: The best account in English of the deadly sin +of acedia, too much neglected in modern religious teaching, is to be +found in Bishop Paget's Spirit of Discipline.] And sometimes this +lively zeal disperses heaviness and sluggishness of the bodily +temperament. It is on this subject that Jesus Christ says: "Blessed +are they who hunger and thirst after righteousness, for they shall +be filled." This will be, when the glory of God shall be manifested, +and shall fill every man in proportion to his love and justice. + +ON TEMPERANCE AND SOBRIETY + +FROM zeal are born temperance and sobriety within and without; for +none can maintain true moderation in sobriety, if he is not +thoroughly diligent and zealous to preserve his body and soul in +justice. Sobriety separates the higher faculties from the animal +faculties, and preserves a man from excesses. Sobriety wishes not to +taste nor know those things which are not permitted. + +The incomprehensible and sublime nature of God surpasses all the +creatures in heaven and earth, for whatever the creature conceives +is creature. But God is above every creature, and within and without +every creature, and all created comprehension is too strait to +comprehend Him. In order that the creature may conceive and +comprehend God, it must be drawn up into God from above; it is only +by God that it can comprehend God. Those then who wish to know what +God is, and to study Him, let them know that it is forbidden. They +would become mad. All created light must fail here. What God is, +passes the comprehension of every creature. But Holy Scripture, +nature, and all the creatures show us that He is. We shall believe +the articles of faith without trying to penetrate them, for that is +impossible while we are here: this is sobriety. The difficult and +subtle teachings of the inspired writings we shall only explain in +accordance with the life of Christ and His saints. Man will study +nature and the Scriptures, and every creature; and will seek to +learn from them only what may be to his own advantage. This is +sobriety of spirit. + +A man will maintain sobriety of the senses, and he will subdue by +reason his animal faculties, that the animal pleasure in food and +drink may not delight him too much, but that he may eat and drink as +a sick man takes a potion, because it is his duty to preserve his +strength for the service of God. This is sobriety of body. A man +will preserve moderation in words and actions, in silence and +speech, in eating and drinking, in what he does and abstains from +doing, as Holy Church enjoins and the saints give the example. + +By moderation and sobriety of spirit within, a man maintains +constancy and perseverance in the faith, that purity of intelligence +and calmness of reason which are necessary to understand the truth, +readiness to bend to the will of God with regard to every virtue, +peace of heart and serenity of conscience. Thanks to this virtue, he +possesses assured peace in God and in himself. + +By moderation and sobriety in the use of the bodily faculties, he +often preserves health and contentment of the bodily nature, his +honour in external relations, and his good name. And thus he is at +peace with himself and with his neighbour. For he attracts and +rejoices all men of good will, by his moderation and sobriety. And +he escapes the sixth deadly sin, which is want of temperance, and +gluttony. It is of this that Christ said: "Blessed are the +peacemakers, for they shall be called the children of God." For +being like unto the Son, who has made peace in all creatures who +desire it, and who make peace in their turn, by moderation and +sobriety, the Son will divide among them the heritage of His Father, +and they will possess this heritage with Him throughout eternity. + +ON PURITY + +FROM this sobriety are born purity of soul and body, for none can be +absolutely pure in body and soul, save he who follows after sobriety +in body and soul. Purity of spirit consists in this--that a man +cleaves to no creature with any passionate desire, but attaches +himself to God only; for one may use all the creatures while +rejoicing in God only. Purity of spirit makes a man attach himself +to God above intelligence and above the senses, and above all the +gifts which God may bestow upon the soul; for all that the creature +receives in its intelligence or in its senses purity desires to +transcend, and to repose in God only. We should approach the +sacrament of the altar not for the sake of the delights, the +pleasure, the peace, or the sweetness which we find there, but for +the glory of God only, and that we may grow in all the virtues. This +is purity of spirit. + +Purity of heart signifies that a man turns towards God without +hesitation in every bodily temptation and every disturbance of +nature, in the freedom of his will abandoning himself to Him with a +new confidence and a firm resolve to abide always with God. For to +consent to sin, or to the animal desires of the bodily nature, is a +separation from God. + +Purity of body means that a man abstains from impure actions of +every kind, when his conscience assures him that they are impure and +contrary to the commandments, to the glory, and to the will of God. + +Thanks to these three kinds of purity, the seventh deadly sin, that +of wantonness, is conquered and driven away. Wantonness is a +voluptuous inclination of the spirit, leading away from God towards +a created thing; it is the impure act of the flesh outside what +Holy Church permits, and the carnal occupation of the heart in some +taste or desire for a creature. I do not here refer to those sudden +stirrings of love or desire which none can escape. + +You now know that purity of spirit preserves men in the likeness of +God, without care for the creatures, inclined towards God and united +to Him. The chastity of the body is compared to the whiteness of the +lily and to the purity of the angels. In its resistance to +temptation, it is compared to the redness of the rose, and to the +nobility of the martyrs. If it is preserved for love of God and in +His honour, it is then perfect, and it is compared to the +heliotrope, for it is one of the highest adornments of nature. + +Purity of heart renews and increases the grace of God. In purity of +heart all the virtues are inspired, practised, and preserved. It +keeps and preserves the outer senses, it subdues and binds the +animal desires within, and it is the ornament of all the inner life. +It is the exclusion of the heart from things of earth and from all +lies, and its inclusion among the things of heaven and all truth. +And this is why Christ has said: "Blessed are the pure in heart, for +they shall see God." This is the vision in which consists our +eternal joy, and all our reward, and our entrance into bliss. This +is why a man will be sober and moderate in everything, and will keep +himself from every occasion which might tarnish the purity of his +soul and body. + +ON THE THREE ENEMIES WHO ARE TO BE CONQUERED BY JUSTICE + +IF we wish to possess this virtue and to repulse these enemies, we +must have justice, and we must practise it, and preserve it even +until our death, in purity of heart, for we have three powerful +enemies who try to attack us at all times, in all states, and in +many different ways. If we make our peace with any one of them and +follow him, we are vanquished, for they are in league with each +other in all wickedness and injustice. These three enemies are the +devil, the world, and our own flesh, which is the nearest to us, and +is often the worst and most mischievous of our foes. For our animal +desires are the weapons with which our enemies fight against us. +Idleness, and indifference to virtue and the glory of God are the +cause and occasion of war and combat. But the weakness of our +natures, our negligence and ignorance of truth are the sword by +which our enemies wound us and sometimes conquer us. + +And this is why we must be divided in ourselves. The lower part of +ourselves, which is animal and contrary to the virtues, we ought to +hate and persecute and cause it to suffer by means of penitence and +austerities, so that it may be always crushed down and submissive to +reason, and that justice, with purity of heart, may always keep the +upper hand in all virtuous actions. And all the pains, sorrows, and +persecutions which God makes us suffer at the hands of those who are +enemies to virtue, we shall endure with joy, in honour of God and +for the glory of virtue, and in the hope of obtaining and possessing +justice in purity of heart; for Christ said: "Blessed are those who +are persecuted for righteousness' sake, for theirs is the kingdom of +heaven." For righteousness preserved in virtue and in virtuous +actions is a coin of the same weight and value as the kingdom of +heaven, and it is by it that we may purchase and obtain eternal +life. By these virtues a man goes forth towards God and towards +himself, in good conduct, virtue, and justice. + +ON THE KINGDOM OF THE SOUL + +HE who wishes to obtain and preserve these virtues, will adorn, +occupy, and order his soul like a kingdom. Free will is the king of +the soul. It is free by nature, and more free still by grace. It +will be crowned with a crown or diadem named Charity. We shall +receive this crown and this kingdom from the Emperor, who is the +Lord, the sovereign and king of kings, and we shall possess, rule, +and preserve this kingdom in His name. This king, free will, will +dwell in the highest town in the kingdom--that is to say, in the +concupiscent faculty of the soul. He will be adorned and clad with a +robe in two parts. The right side of his robe will be a virtue +called strength, that he may be strong and powerful to overcome all +obstacles and sojourn in the heaven, in the palace of the supreme +Emperor, and to bend with love and ardent self-surrender his crowned +head before the supreme monarch. This is the proper work of charity. +By it we receive the crown, by it we adorn the crown, and by it we +keep and possess the kingdom throughout eternity. The left side of +the robe will be a cardinal virtue, called moral courage. Thanks to +it, free will, the king, will subdue all immorality, will accomplish +all virtue, and will have the power to keep his kingdom even until +death. The king will choose councillors in his country, the wisest +in the land. They will be two divine virtues, knowledge and +discretion, illuminated by divine grace. They will dwell near the +king, in a palace called the reasonable force of the soul. They will +be crowned and adorned with a moral virtue called temperance, that +the king may always act and refrain from acting according to their +advice. By knowledge we shall purge our conscience from all its +faults and adorn it with all virtues; and, thanks to discretion, we +shall give and take, do and not do, speak and be silent, fast and +eat, listen and answer, and act in all ways according to knowledge +and discretion clad in their moral virtue, which is called +temperance or moderation. + +This king, free will, will also establish in his kingdom a judge, +who will be justice, which is a divine virtue when it is born from +love. And it is one of the highest moral virtues. This judge will +dwell in the conscience, in the middle of the kingdom in the +irascible faculty. And he will be adorned with a moral virtue called +prudence. For justice without prudence cannot be perfect. This +judge, justice, will traverse the kingdom with royal powers, +accompanied by wise counsel and his own prudence. He will promote +and dismiss, he will judge and condemn, will condemn to death and +acquit, will mutilate, blind, and restore to sight, will exalt and +abase and organise, will punish and chastise according to justice, +and will destroy all vices. The people of the kingdom--that is to +say, all the faculties of the soul, will be supported by humility +and the fear of God, submitting to Him in all the virtues, each +after its own manner. He who has thus occupied, preserved, and +ordered the kingdom of his soul, has gone forth, by love and the +virtues, towards God, towards himself, and towards his neighbour. +This is the third of the four principal points which Christ speaks +of when He says, Go forth. + +ON THE THREEFOLD MEETING OF THE SOUL + +WHEN a man has, by the grace of God, eyes to see, and a pure +conscience, and when he has considered the three comings of Christ, +our Bridegroom, and lastly when he has gone forth by the virtues, +then takes place the meeting with our Bridegroom, and this is the +fourth and last point. In this meeting consist all our blessedness, +and the beginning and the end of all the virtues, and without this +meeting no virtue can be practised. + +He who wishes to meet Christ as his well-beloved Bridegroom, and to +possess in Him and with Him eternal life, must meet Christ, now in +time, in three points or in three manners. First, he must love God +in everything wherein we shall merit eternal life. Secondly, he must +attach himself to nothing which he might love as much as or more +than God. Thirdly, he must repose in God with all his might, above +all creatures and above all the gifts of God, and above all acts of +virtue and above all the sensible graces which God might spread +abroad in his soul and body. + +Now understand: he who has God for his end must have Him present to +himself, by some divine reason. That is to say, he must have in view +Him who is the Lord of heaven, and of earth, and of every creature, +Him who died for him, and who can and will give him eternal +salvation. In whatever mode and under whatever name he represents +God, as Lord of every creature, it is well. If he takes some divine +Person, and in Him sees the essence and power of the divine nature, +it is well. If he regards God as saviour, redeemer, creator, +governor, as blessedness, power, wisdom, truth, goodness, it is +well. Though the names which we ascribe to God are numerous, the +sublime nature of God is simple and unnameable by the creatures. But +we give Him all these names by reason of His nobleness and +incomprehensible sublimity, and because we cannot name or proclaim +Him completely. See now under what mode and by what knowledge God +will be present to our intention. For to have God for our aim is to +see spiritually. To this quest belong also affection and love, for +to know God and be without love aids and advances us not a whit, and +has no savour. This is why a man, in all his actions, must bend +lovingly towards God, whom he seeks and loves above everything. +This, then, is the meeting with God by means of intention and love. + +In order that the sinner may turn from his sins in a meritorious +penitence, he must meet God by contrition, free conversion, and a +sincere intention to serve God for ever, and to sin no more. Then, +at this meeting, he receives from the mercy of God the assured hope +of eternal salvation and the pardon of his sins, and he receives the +foundation of all the virtues, faith, hope, and charity, and the +good will to practise all the virtues. If this man advances in the +light of faith, and observes all the works of Christ, all His +sufferings and all His promises, and all that He has done for us and +will do to the day of judgment and through eternity; if he examines +all this for his soul's health, he must needs meet with Christ; and +Christ must needs be present to his soul, so grateful and full of +thankfulness. So his faith is fortified, and he is impelled more +inwardly and powerfully towards all the virtues. If he still +progresses in the works of virtue, he must again meet with Christ, +by the annihilation of self. Let him not seek his own things; let +him set before him no extraneous ends; let him be discreet in his +actions; let him set God always before him, and the praise and glory +of God; and let him so continue till his death; then his reason +will be enlightened and his charity increased, and he will become +more pious and apt for all the virtues. We shall set God before us +in every good work; in bad works we cannot set Him before us. We +shall not have two intentions--that is to say, we shall not seek God +at the same time as something else, but all our intention must be +subordinated to God and not contrary to Him, but of one and the same +kind, so that it may help us and give us an impulse which may lead +us more easily to God. Then and then only is a man in the right +road. Moreover, we shall rest rather upon Him who is our aim and our +goal and the object of our love, than upon the messengers whom He +sends us--that is to say, His gifts. The soul will rest constantly +upon God, above all the adornments and presents which His messengers +may bring. The messengers sent by the soul are intention, love, and +desire. They carry to God all our good works and virtues. Above all +these, the soul will rest on God, its Beloved, above all +multiplicity. This is the manner in which we shall meet Christ all +through our life, in all our actions and virtues, by right +intention, that we may meet Him at the hour of our death in the +light of glory. + +This mode, as you have learnt, is called the active life. It is +necessary to all men; or at least they must not live in a manner +contrary to any virtue, though they may not attain the degree of +perfection in all the virtues which I have described. For to live +contrary to the virtues is to live in sin, as Christ has said: "He +that is not with me is against me." He who is not humble is proud, +and he who is proud belongs not to God. We must always possess a +virtue and be in a state of grace, or possess what is contrary to +that virtue and be in a state of sin. May every man examine and +prove himself, and order his life as I have here described. + +ON THE DESIRE TO KNOW GOD AS HE IS, IN THE NATURE OF HIS GODHEAD + +THE man who thus lives, in this perfection, as I have here described +it, and who devotes all his life and actions to the honour and glory +of God, and who seeks and loves God above all things, is often +seized by the desire to see and know Christ, this Bridegroom who was +made man for love of him, who laboured in love even till death, who +drove away from him sin and the enemy, who gave him His grace, who +gave him Himself, who left him His sacraments and promised him His +kingdom. When a man considers all this, he is exceedingly desirous +to see Christ his Bridegroom, and to know what He is in Himself +While He only knows Him in His works he is not satisfied. So he will +do like Zacchasus, the publican, who desired to see Jesus Christ. He +will go in front of the crowd--that is to say, the multitude of the +creatures, for they make us so little and short, that we cannot +perceive God. And he will climb the tree of faith, which grows from +above downwards, for its roots are in the Godhead. This tree has +twelve branches, which are the twelve articles of faith. The lower +branches speak of the humanity of Christ, and of the things which +concern the salvation of our body and soul. The higher part of the +tree speaks of the Godhead, of the Trinity of the Divine Persons and +the Unity of the Divine Nature. A man will strive to reach the unity +at the top of the tree, for it is there that Jesus must pass with +all His gifts. Here Jesus comes, and sees the man, and tells Him in +the light of faith that He is, according to His Godhead, +immeasurable and incomprehensible, inaccessible and abysmal, and +that He surpasses all created light and all finite comprehension. +This is the highest knowledge acquired in the active life, to +recognise thus, in the light of faith, that God is inconceivable and +unknowable. In this light Christ saith to the desire of a man: "Come +down quickly, for I must lodge at thy house to-day." This rapid +descent to which God invites him is nothing else but a descent, by +desire and love, into the abyss of the Godhead, to which no +intelligence can attain in crested light. But where intelligence +remains outside, love and desire enter. The soul thus bending +towards God, by the intention of love, above all that the intellect +can comprehend, rests and abides in God, and God abides in her. Then +mounting by desire, above the multitude of the creatures, above the +work of the senses, above the light of nature, she meets Christ in +the light of faith, and is enlightened, and recognises that God is +unknowable and inconceivable. Finally, bending by her desires +towards this inconceivable God, she meets Christ and is loaded with +His gifts; by living and resting upon Him, above all His gifts, +above herself and above all the creatures, she dwells in God and God +in her. + +This is how you will meet Christ at the summit of the active life, +if you have as your foundations justice, charity, and humility; and +if you have built a house above--that is to say, the virtues here +described, and if you have met Christ by faith--that is to say, by +faith and the intention of love, you dwell in God and God dwells in +you, and you possess the active life. + +This is the first explanation of the word of Jesus Christ our +Bridegroom, when He said, "See, the Bridegroom cometh; go forth to +meet Him." + +BOOK II + +THE SUBJECTS OF THE SECOND BOOK + +THE prudent virgin--that is to say, the pure soul, who has +renounced the things of earth, and lives henceforth for God in +virtue, has taken in the vessel of her heart the oil of charity and +of divine works by means of the lamp of an unstained conscience. But +when Christ, her Bridegroom, withdraws His consolations and the +fresh outpouring of His gifts, the soul becomes heavy and torpid. + +At midnight--that is to say, when it is least expected, a spiritual +cry resounds in the soul: "See, the Bridegroom cometh, go forth to +meet Him." We shall now speak of this seeing, and of the inward +coming of Christ, and of the spiritual going forth of the man to +meet Jesus, and we shall explain these four conditions of an inward +life, exalted and full of desire, to which all men attain not, but +many reach it by means of the virtues and their inward courage. + +In these words, Christ teaches us four things. In the first, He +requires that our intelligence shall be enlightened with a +supernatural light. This is what we observe in the word, "See." In +the next words He shows us what we ought to see--that is to say, the +inward coming of our Bridegroom of eternal truth. This is His +meaning when He says: "The Bridegroom cometh." In the third place, +in the words "go forth," He bids us go forth in inward actions +according to righteousness. In the fourth place, He shows us the end +and motive of all our works, the meeting with our Bridegroom Jesus +Christ in the joyous unity of His adorable Godhead. + +HOW WE MAY GAIN SUPERNATURAL VISION BY INTERNAL EXERCISES + +NOW let us speak of the first word. Christ saith, "See." Three +things are required by him who would see supernaturally in interior +exercises. The first is the light of the divine grace, but in a far +more sublime manner than can be felt in the external, active life. +The second is a stripping off of extraneous images and a denudation +of the heart, so that a man may be free from images, and attachments +to every creature. The third is a free conversion of the will, by +means of a concentration of all the bodily and spiritual faculties, +and complete deliverance from all inordinate affections. Thus this +will flows together into the unity of the Godhead and of our own +mind, so that the reasonable creature may be able to obtain and +possess supernaturally the sublime unity of God. It is for this that +God made the heaven and earth and mankind, it is for this that He +was made man, and taught us by word and example by what way we +should come to this unity. And then in the ardour of His love He +endured to die, and He ascended to heaven, and opened to us this +unity in which we may possess felicity and eternal blessedness. + +ON THE THREEFOLD NATURAL UNITY OF MAN + +NOW consider attentively: there are three kinds of natural unity in +all men, and, moreover, of supernatural unity among the just. The +first and supreme unity of man is in God; for all creatures are +immanent in this unity, and if they were to be separated from God, +they would be annihilated, and would become nothing. This unity is +essential in us according to nature, whether we are good or bad. And +without our co-operation it makes us neither holy nor blessed. This +unity we possess in ourselves, and nevertheless above us, as a +beginning and support of our life and essence. + +Another unity exists in us naturally--that of the supreme forces, in +so far as they actively take their natural origin in the unity of +the spirit or of the thoughts. This is the same unity as that which +is immanent in God, but it is taken here actively and there +essentially. Nevertheless the spirit is entirely in each unity +according to the integrity of its substance. We possess this unity +in ourselves, above the sensitive part of us; and thence are born +memory, intelligence, and will, and all the power of spiritual +works. In this unity the soul is called spirit. + +The third unity which is in us naturally is the foundation of bodily +forces in the unity of the heart, the source and origin of bodily +life. The soul possesses this unity in the lively centre of the +heart, and from it flow all the material works and the five senses, +and the soul draws from thence its name of soul (anima); for it is +the source of life, and animates the body--that is to say, it makes +it living and preserves it in life. These three unities are in man +naturally, as a life and a kingdom. In the inferior unity we are +sensible and animal, in the intermediate unity we are rational and +spiritual; and in the superior unity we are preserved according to +our essence. And this exists in all men, naturally. + +Now these three unities are adorned and cultivated naturally, like a +kingdom and an eternal abode, by the virtues, in charity and in the +active life. And they are adorned still better and more gloriously +cultivated by the internal exercises of a spiritual life. But most +gloriously and blessedly of all by a supernatural contemplative +life. + +The inferior unity, which is corporeal, is adorned and cultivated +supernaturally by external practices, by perfect conduct, by the +example of Christ and the saints, by carrying the cross with Christ, +by submitting our nature to the command of Holy Church and the +teachings of the saints, according to the forces of nature and +prudence. + +The other unity which resides in the spirit and which is absolutely +spiritual, is adorned and cultivated supernaturally by the three +Divine gifts, Faith, Hope, and Charity, and by the influx of grace +and Divine gifts, and by good will directed to all the virtues, and +the desire to follow the example of Christ and of holy Christendom. + +The third and supreme unity is above our intelligence and yet +essentially in us. We cultivate it supernaturally when in all our +works of virtue we have in view only the glory of God, without any +other desire but to repose in Him, above thought, above ourselves, +and above everything. And this is the unity from which we flowed out +when we were created, and where we abide according to our essence, +and towards which we endeavour to return by love. These are the +virtues which adorn this triple unity in the active life. + +Now we proceed to say how this triple unity is adorned more +sublimely and cultivated more nobly by interior exercises joined to +the active life. When a man, by love and right intention, elevates +himself in all his works and in all his life towards the honour and +glory of God, and seeks rest in God above all things, he will wait +in humility and patience and abandonment of self and in the hope of +new riches and new gifts, and he will not be troubled or anxious +whether it pleases God to grant His gifts or to refuse them. So men +prepare themselves for receiving an internal life of desires; even +as a vessel is fitted and prepared, into which a precious liquid is +to be poured. There is no vessel more noble than the loving soul, +and no drink more necessary than the grace of God. Man will thus +offer to God all his works and all his life, in a simple and right +intention, and in a zest above his intention, above himself, and +above everything, in the sublime unity in which God and the loving +spirit are united without intermediary. + +ON THE FIRST MODE OR DEGREE OF THE FIRST SPIRITUAL COMING OF CHRIST + +THE first coming of Christ to those who are engaged in the exercises +of desire is an internal and sensible current from the Holy Spirit, +which impels and attracts us to all the virtues. We shall compare +this coming to the splendour and power of the sun, which, so soon as +it is risen, enlightens and warms the whole world in the twinkling +of an eye. In the same way Christ, the eternal sun, burns and +shines, dwelling at the highest point of the spirit, and enlightens +and fires the lower part of man--that is to say, his physical heart +and sense-faculties, and this is accomplished in less time than the +twinkling of an eye, for the work of God is prompt; but the man in +whom it takes place ought to be internally seeing by means of his +spiritual eyes. + +The sun burns in the East, in the middle of the world, on the +mountains; there it hastens in the summer, and creates good fruits +and strong wines, filling the earth with joy. The same sun shines in +the West, at the end of the world; the country there is colder and +the force of the heat less; nevertheless, it there produces a great +number of good fruits, but not much wine. The men who dwell in the +West part of themselves, abide in their external senses, and by +their good intentions, their virtues, and their outer practices, by +the grace of God produce abundant harvests of virtues of divers +kinds, but they but rarely taste the wine of inward joy and +spiritual consolation. + +The man who wishes to experience the rays of the eternal sun, which +is Christ Himself, will be seeing; and will dwell on the mountains +of the East, by concentrating all his faculties, and lifting up his +heart to God, free, and indifferent to joy and pain and all the +creatures. There shines Christ, the sun of righteousness, on the +free and exalted heart, and this is what I mean by the mountains. +Christ, the glorious sun and divine effulgence, shines through and +fires by his internal coming, and by the power of His Spirit, the +free heart and all the powers of the soul. This is the first work of +the internal coming in the exercises of desire. Just as fire +inflames things which are thrown into it, so Christ inflames the +hearts offered to Him in freedom and exultation at His internal +coming, and He says in this coming: "Go forth by the exercises +appropriate to this life." + +ON UNITY OF HEART + +FROM this heat is born unity of heart, for we cannot obtain true +unity, unless the Spirit of God lights His flame in our heart. For +this fire makes one and like unto itself all that it can overtop and +transform. Unity gives a man the feeling of being concentrated with +all his faculties on one point. It gives internal peace and repose +of heart. Unity of heart is a bond which draws and binds together +the body and the soul, and all exterior and interior forces, in the +unity of love. + +HOW THE VIRTUES PROCEED FROM UNITY + +FROM this unity of heart is born inwardness or the internal life, +for none can have inwardness unless he is one and united in himself; +fervour or inwardness is the introversion of a man into his own +heart, to comprehend and experience the internal operation or speech +of God. Inwardness is a sensible flame of love, which the Spirit of +God lights and kindles in a man, and a man knows not whence it +comes, nor what has happened to him. + +ON SENSIBLE LOVE + +FROM inwardness is born a sensible love which penetrates the heart +of man and the highest faculties of the soul. This love and delight +none can experience who has not inwardness. Sensible love is the +desire and appetite for God as for an eternal good in which all is +contained. Sensible love renounces all the creatures, not as needs +but as pleasures. Interior love feels itself touched from above by +the eternal love which it must practise eternally Interior love +willingly renounces and despises everything, in order to obtain that +which it loves. + +ON DEVOTION + +FROM this sensible love is born devotion to God and His glory. For +none can have a hungry devotion in his heart, unless he possesses +the sensible love of God. Devotion excites and stimulates a man +internally and externally to the service of God. It makes the body +and soul abound in glory and merit in the eyes of God and men. God +exacts devotion in all that we do. It purges the body and soul from +all that might hold us back; it shows us the true path to +blessedness. + +ON GRATITUDE + +FROM fervent devotion is born gratitude, for none can thank or +praise God perfectly if he is not fervent and pious. We should thank +God for everything here below, that we may be able to thank Him +eternally above. Those who praise not God here, will be mute +eternally. To praise God is the most joyous and delicious employment +of the loving heart. There is no limit to the praises of God, for +therein is our salvation, and we shall praise Him eternally. + +Now hear a comparison, by which you may understand the exercise of +gratitude. When the summer approaches and the sun mounts, it +attracts the moisture of the earth along the stems and branches of +the trees, whence come green leaves, flowers, and fruit. Even so +when Christ, the eternal sun, rises in our hearts, He sends His +light and heat upon our desires, and draws the heart away from all +the manifold things of earth, creating unity and inwardness, and +makes the heart grow and become green by interior love, and makes +loving devotion flourish, and makes us bear the fruits of gratitude +and love, and preserves these fruits eternally in the humble pain of +our inability to praise and serve Him enough. + +Here ends the first of the four chief kinds ot interior exercises, +which adorn the lower part of a man. + +HOW TO INCREASE INWARDNESS BY HUMILITY + +BUT in thus comparing to the splendour and power of the sun the +modes in which Jesus Christ comes, we shall find in the sun another +virtue or influence which makes the fruit more early ripe and more +abundant. + +When the sun rises to a very great height, and enters the sign of +the Twins--that is to say, into a double thing, but of the same +nature, in the middle of the month of May, the sun has a double +power over the flowers, herbs, and all that grows upon the earth. If +at that time the planets which rule nature are well ordered +according to the season of the year, the sun shines brightly on the +earth, and attracts the moisture in the atmosphere. Hence are born +dew and rain, and the fruits of the ground increase and multiply. + +Even so when Christ, that bright sun, rises in our heart above all +other things, and when the requirements of material nature, which +are contrary to the spirit, are well regulated according to reason, +when we possess the virtues as I have said above, and when, lastly, +we offer and restore to God, by the ardour of charity, and with +gratitude and love, the delight and peace which we find in the +virtues, from all these are born, at times, a gentle rain of new +internal consolations, and a celestial dew of divine sweetness. This +dew and rain make all the virtues increase and multiply day by day, +if we put no hindrance in their way. This is a new and special +operation, and a new coming of Christ into the loving heart. + +ON PURE SATISFACTION OF THE HEART + +FROM this sweetness is born satisfaction of heart, and of all the +bodily faculties, so that a man imagines that he is inwardly +embraced in the divine bands of love. This pleasure and consolation +is greater and more delicious to body and soul than all the +pleasures granted on earth, even if a man could enjoy them to the +full. In this pleasure God sinks into the heart by means of His +gifts with such a profusion of delights, consolations, and joys, +that the heart overflows internally. + +ON THE OBSTACLES WHICH WE ENCOUNTER IN THIS STATE + +THIS coming, or kind of coming, is granted to beginners, when they +turn from the world, when their conversion is complete, and they +abandon all the consolations of earth to live for God only; +nevertheless they are still weak, and need milk and not strong meat, +such as great temptations and the hiding of God's face. At this +season frost and fog often injure them, for they are in the middle +of the May of the interior life. The frost is to wish to be +something, or to imagine that we are something, or to be somewhat +attached to ourselves, or to believe that we have deserved +consolations and are worthy of them. The fog is the wish to rest +upon internal consolations and pains. This obscures the atmosphere +of reason, and the ilowers, which were about to unfold and bloom and +bear fruits, shut up again. This is why we lose the knowledge of +truth, and nevertheless we sometimes keep certain false sweetnesses +granted by the enemy, which at the last lead men astray. + +HOW ONE OUGHT TO BEHAVE IN THIS CASE + +I WISH to give you here a brief comparison, that you may not go +astray, and that you may be able to behave wisely in this case. +Observe the wise bee, and imitate her. She dwells in unity, in the +midst of the assembly of her kind, and she goes forth, not during a +storm, but when the weather is calm and bright, and the sun shines; +and she flies towards every flower where she may find sweetness. She +rests not on any flower, neither for its beauty nor for its +sweetness, but draws out from the cups of the flowers their +sweetness and clearness--that is to say, the honey and wax, and she +brings them back to the unity which is formed of the assembly of all +the bees, that the honey and wax may be put to good use. + +The expanded heart on which Christ, the eternal sun, shines, grows +and blooms under His rays, and from it flow all the interior forces +in joy and sweetness. + +Now the wise man will act like the bee, and will try to settle, with +affection, intelligence, and prudence, on all the gifts and all the +sweetness that he has experienced, and on all the good that God has +done to him. He will not rest on any flower of the gifts, but laden +with gratitude and praise he will fly back towards the unity where +he wishes to dwell, and to rest with God eternally. + +ON THE THIRD MODE OF THE SPIRITUAL COMING OF CHRIST + +WHEN the sun in heaven reaches its highest point, in the sign of the +Crab--that is to say, when it can go no higher, but must begin to go +backwards, then the greatest heat of the year begins. The sun +attracts the moisture, the earth dries, and the fruits ripen. In the +same way, when Christ, the divine sun, arises above the highest +summit of our heart--that is to say, above all His gifts, +consolations and sweetnesses, and if we do not rest in any of these, +however sweet, but return always with humble praises to the source +from which these gifts flow, Christ stops and remains lifted up +above the summit of our heart, and desires to attract all our powers +to Himself. + +This invitation is an irradiation of Christ, the eternal sun, and +causes in the heart a joy and pleasure so great that the heart +cannot close again after such an expansion, without pain. A man is +wounded internally and feels the smart of love. To be wounded by +love is the sweetest sensation and the most grievous pain that can +be experienced. To be wounded by love is a sure sign that we shall +be cured. This spiritual wound does us good and harm at the same +time. + +ON THE FOURTH KIND OF THE SPIRITUAL COMING OF CHRIST + +NOW I wish to speak of the fourth kind of coming of Jesus Christ, +which exalts and perfects the man in his interior exercises, +according to the lower part of his being. But having compared all +the interior comings to the shining of the sun, we will continue to +speak, while following the course of the seasons, of the other +effects and works of the sun. + +When the sun begins to descend the sky, it enters the sign of the +Virgin, so called because this period of the year becomes barren +like a virgin. The glorious virgin Mary, mother of Christ, full of +joys and rich in all the virtues, ascended to heaven at this season. +The heat begins then to diminish, and men gather, for use during the +whole year, the ripe fruits which can be used long after, such as +corn and the grape. And they sow part of the corn, that it may be +multiplied for the use of men. At this season all the solar work of +the year is finished. In the same way, when Christ, the glorious +sun, has risen to the zenith in the heart of men, and begins to +descend, so as to hide the splendour of His divine beams and to +leave a man alone, the heat and impatience of love diminish. Now +this occultation of Christ and the withdrawal of His light and heat +are the first work and the new coming of this mode. Now Christ says +spiritually in a man: "Go forth in the manner that I now show thee"; +and the man goes forth, and finds himself poor, miserable, and +desolate. Here all the storm, all the passion and eagerness of love +grow cold; summer becomes autumn, and all his wealth is changed into +great poverty. And the man begins to complain by reason of his +misery; what is become of his ardent love, his inwardness, his +gratitude, the interior consolations, the heartfelt joys? Where has +it all gone? How comes it that all is dead within him? He is like +a scholar who has lost his knowledge and his work; and nature is +often troubled by such losses. Sometimes these unhappy ones are +deprived of the good things of earth, of their friends and +relations, and are deserted by all the creatures; their holiness is +mistrusted and despised, men put a bad construction upon all the +works of their life, and they are rejected and disdained by all +those who surround them; and sometimes they are afflicted with +diverse diseases; and some of them fall into bodily temptations, or +into spiritual temptations, the most dangerous of all. From this +misery are born the fear of falling, and a sort of half-doubt, and +this is the extreme point where we can stop without despair. Let +such men seek out the good, complain to them, show them their +distress, and ask their help, and implore the aid of Holy +Church, and of all just men. + +WHAT A MAN OUGHT TO DO WHEN HE IS ABANDONED + +A MAN will here observe humbly that he has nothing but his distress, +and he will say in his resignation and self-abnegation the words of +holy Job: "The Lord gave, and the Lord hath taken away; He hath done +what seemed good to Him; blessed be the name of the Lord." And he +will leave himself in everything, and will say and think in his +heart: "Lord, I am as willing to be poor, lacking all that Thou hast +taken from me, as I should be to be rich, if such were Thy will, and +if it were for Thine honour. It is not my will according to nature +which must be accomplished, but Thy will, and my will according to +my spirit, O Lord; for I belong to Thee, and I should love as well +to be Thine in hell as in heaven, if that could serve Thy glory; and +therefore, O Lord, accomplish in me the excellence of Thy will." +From all these pains and acts of resignation, a man will derive an +inward joy, and he will offer himself into the hands of God, and +will rejoice to be able to suffer in His honour. And if he so +perseveres, he will taste inward pleasures such as he has never had +before; for nothing so rejoices the lover of God as to feel that he +is His beloved. And if he is truly exalted as far as this mode, in +the path of virtue, it is not necessary for him to have passed +through all the states which we have described above; for he feels +within himself in action, in humble obedience, in patience, and in +resignation, the source of all the virtues. It is thus that this +mode is eternally sure. + +At this season the sun in the sky enters the sign of the Scales, for +the day and night are equal, and the sun balances the light and the +darkness. In the same way Jesus Christ is in the sign of the Scales +for the resigned man; and whether He grants sweetness or +bitterness, darkness or light, whatever He chooses to send him, the +man keeps his balance, all things are equal to him except sin, which +has been driven away once for all. When every consolation has been +thus withdrawn from these resigned men, when they believe that they +have lost all their virtues and that they are abandoned by God and +all the creatures, if they then know how to reap the divers fruits, +their corn and wine are ready and ripe. That is to say, that all +that the bodily virtues can suffer will be offered by them to God +with joy, without resistance to His supreme will. All the exterior +and interior virtues, which they formerly practised with joy in the +light of love, they will now practise courageously and laboriously, +and will offer them to God, and never will they have so much merit +in His eyes. Never will they have been more noble or more beautiful. +All the consolations which God formerly granted, they will allow to +be stripped from them with joy, since it is for the glory of God. It +is thus that the virtues become perfect, and that sadness is +transformed into an eternal vintage. These men--their life and their +patience--improve and teach all who know and live near them, and +thus it is that the wheat of their virtues is sown and multiplied +for the good of all just men. + +This is the fourth kind of coming which, according to the bodily +faculties and the lower part of his being, adorns and perfects a man +in interior exercises. + +HOW THESE FOUR MODES ARE FOUND IN JESUS CHRIST + +WE must needs walk in the light if we wish not to lose our way, and +we must observe Jesus Christ, who has taught us these four modes, +and has preceded us in them. Christ, the bright sun, rises in the +heaven of the sublime Trinity and in the dawn of His glorious mother +the virgin Mary, who was and is the dawn of all the graces. Now +observe. Christ had and still has the first mode, for He was unique +and united. In Him were and are collected and united all the virtues +which have ever been practised, and which ever will be, and besides +this, all the creatures who will cultivate these virtues. He was +thus in an unique sense the Son of the Father, and united to human +nature. And He was equally full of inwardness, for it was He who +brought upon earth the fire which has consumed all the saints and +all good men. And He had a sensible and faithful love for His +Father, and for all who will have joy in Him eternally, and His +pitiful and loving heart sighed and glowed with love for all men, +before His Father. All His life and all His actions, within and +without, and all His words, were praises of His Father. This is the +first mode. + +Christ, the sun of love, blazed and shone yet more brightly and +warmly, for in Him was and is the fullness of all gifts. This is why +the heart of Christ, and His character, and His habits and His +service, overflowed with pity, sweetness, humility, and generosity. +So gracious was He and so loving, that His manners and His +personality attracted all whose nature was good. He was the pure +lily in the midst of the flowers of the field, from which the good +were to draw the honey of eternal sweetness and eternal +consolations. According to His humanity He thanked His eternal +Father for all the gifts which were ever granted to humanity, and +praised Him, for His Father is the Father of all gifts, and He +rested on Him, according to the highest faculties of His soul, above +all gifts, in the sublime unity of God from which all the gifts flow; +thus He had the second mode. + +Christ, the glorious sun, blazed and shone yet higher, and more +brightly and warmly; for during all His days on earth, all His +bodily faculties were invited and pressed to the sublime glory and +bliss which He now experiences in His senses and body. And He was +inclined thereto Himself, according to His desires; and nevertheless +He willed to remain in this exile, till the time which the Father +had foreseen and fixed from all eternity. Thus He had the third +mode. When the time came at which Christ was to reap and carry away +to the eternal kingdom the fruits of all the virtues which ever have +been and ever will be practised, the eternal sun began to descend; +for Christ humbled Himself, and gave up His bodily life into the +hands of His enemies. And he was misunderstood and deserted by His +friends in so great a distress; and all consolation, within and +without, was withdrawn from His nature; and it was overwhelmed with +misery, pain, and contempt, and paid all the debt which our sins +justly incurred. All this He suffered in humble patience, and He +accomplished the greatest works of love in this resignation, whereby +He received and purchased our eternal inheritance. It is thus that +the lower part of His noble humanity was adorned, for it was in it +that He suffered this pain for our sins. It is on this account that +He is called the Saviour of the world, and that He is glorified and +raised up and seated on the right hand of His Father, and that He +reigns in power. And every creature, on the earth, above the earth, +and under the earth, bends the knee for ever before His glorious +name. + +HOW A MAN SHOULD LIVE IF HE DESIRES TO BE ENLIGHTENED + +THE man who, in true obedience to the commandments of God, lives in +the moral virtues, and moreover exercises himself in the interior +virtues, after the direction and impulse of the Holy Spirit, acting +and speaking according to righteousness, and who seeks not his own +interests in time or in eternity, and who supports with true +patience obscurity and affliction and every kind of misery, and who +thanks God for everything, and offers himself in humble resignation, +has received the first coming of Jesus Christ according to interior +exercises. When this man is purified and pacified, and turns back +upon himself according to his lower nature, he may be internally +enlightened, if he asks it, and if God judges that the right time +has come. It may also happen that he is enlightened from the +beginning of his conversion, so that he may offer himself entirely +to the will of God and give up all possession of himself, which is +the supreme end. But if he is to follow any further the road which I +have shown, in the exterior and at the same time in the interior +life, it will be much easier for him than for the man who has been +raised straight from the bottom, for the former will have more light +than the latter. + +ON ANOTHER COMING OF CHRIST + +NOW we are about to speak of another mode of the coming of Christ, +in interior exercises, which adorn, enlighten, and enrich a man, +according to the three supreme faculties of his soul. We shall +compare this coming to a life-giving fountain from which flow three +rivers. + +This fountain is the fullness of divine grace in the unity of our +spirit. There resides grace essentially in its permanence, like a +full fountain, and it flows out actively by its rivers into each of +the faculties of the soul, according to their needs. These rivers +are a special influx, or operation of God in the highest faculties, +in which God operates in various manners by the intermediary of His +grace. + +HOW THE FIRST RIVER FLOWS INTO THE MEMORY + +THE first river of grace, which God causes to flow in this coming, +is a pure simplicity which shines without distinction in the spirit. +This river takes its source in the fountain, in the unity of the +spirit, and flows directly downwards, and penetrates all the +faculties of the soul, both higher and lower, and lifts them up out +of all multiplicity and all over-occupation, and makes a simplicity +in a man, and gives and shows him an internal bond in the unity of +his spirit. A man is thus lifted up according to his memory, and +delivered from strange and irrelevant thoughts, and from +inconstancy. Now Christ in this light demands a going forth, +according to the mode of this light and this coming. Then the man +goes forth, and observes himself that by virtue of the simple light +that is spread abroad in him he is united, established, penetrated +and fixed in the unity of his spirit or of his thoughts. Here the +man is exalted and established in a new essence; he turns his +thoughts inwards, and rests his memory on the naked truth, above all +sensuous images and above all multiplicity. There the man possesses +essentially and supernaturally the unity of his spirit, for his own +dwelling, and as an heritage of his own for ever. He always has an +inclination towards that same unity, and this unity will have an +eternal and loving inclination towards the more sublime unity where +the Father and the Son are united with all the saints in the bands +of the Holy Spirit. + +HOW THE SECOND RIVER ENLIGHTENS THE INTELLIGENCE + +THROUGH internal love, and loving inclination towards union with +God, is born the second river from the fullness of grace, in unity +of spirit, and this is a spiritual brightness which flows and sheds +light through the intelligence, but with distinctions in the diverse +modes. For this light shows and gives to the spirit, in the truth, +the discretion in all the virtues. But this light is not placed +altogether in our power, for though we have it always in our soul, +God makes it speak or keep silence, and He can manifest or hide it, +give or withdraw it, at all times and under all conditions, for this +light is His. Such men do not absolutely need revelations, nor to be +drawn up above sense, for their life and abode and habits and +essence are in the spirit above sense and sensibility. And God shows +them what He wills and what is necessary for them. Nevertheless God, +if He wished, could withdraw their exterior sense, and show them, +from within, unknown symbols and future things, in diverse manners. + +Now Christ desires that this man should go forth, and go into the +light, according to the mode of this light. This enlightened man +will therefore go forth and observe his state and his life within +and without, in order to know if he is perfectly like Christ +according to His humanity and also according to His divinity. And +this man will lift up his eyes, enlightened by enlightened reason, +in intelligible truth, and will observe and consider, as a creature +can, the sublime nature of God, and the unlimited attributes which +are in God. + +It is then necessary to consider and examine the sublime nature of +God; how it contains simplicity and purity, inaccessible height and +abysmal depth, incomprehensible extension and eternal duration; dark +silence and wild waste; repose of all the saints in unity and joy in +itself and in all the saints in eternity. This enlightened man will +also examine the attributes of the Father in the Godhead, how He is +all-powerful, the creator, mover, preserver, beginning and end, +cause and existence of all creatures; this is what the bright river +of grace shows to the enlightened reason. It shows also the +attributes of the eternal Word, abysmal wisdom and truth, model of +every creature and of all life, eternal norm of things, unveiled +contemplation and intuition into everything, brightness and +illumination of all saints, according to their merits, in heaven and +on earth. But this bright river shows also to the enlightened reason +the attributes of the Holy Spirit; inconceivable charity and +generosity, pity and mercy, infinite watchfulness and faithfulness, +immense and inconceivable riches flowing with delights through all +heavenly spirits, ardent flame consuming all in unity, effluent +fountain, preparation of all the saints for their eternal +blessedness, and their introduction thereto; enveloping and +penetrating the Father, the Son, and all the saints in joyous unity. + +ON THE STATE OF AMAZEMENT AT THE DIVINE EFFLUENCE + +THE incomprehensible wealth and sublimity, and the universal +generosity which flow from the divine nature, bring a man into a +state of amazement; and above all he admires the communication of +God and His effluence above everything, for he sees the +inconceivable essence, which is the common joy of God and all the +saints. And he sees that the three divine Persons are a common +effluence in works, in graces, and in glory, in nature and above +nature, in all conditions and in all times, in the saints and in +men, in heaven and on earth, in all reasonable and irrational +creatures, according to each one's merits, needs, and powers of +receiving. God is common to all, with all His gifts, the angels are +common, the soul is common in all its faculties, in all life, in all +the members, and all in each, for one cannot divide it, except by +reason. For the higher and lower faculties, the spirit and the soul, +are distinct according to reason, but one in nature. Thus God is +entirely and specially present to each one, and nevertheless common +to all the creatures, for by Him are all things, and on Him depend +the heaven, the earth, and the whole of nature. When a man thus +observes the astonishing wealth and sublimity of the divine nature, +and all the manifold gifts which He grants and offers to His +creatures, he is lifted up internally by wonder at such manifold +riches and sublimity; and from thence arises a singular inward joy +of spirit, and a vast confidence in God; and this internal joy +surrounds and penetrates all the faculties of the soul in inwardness +of spirit. + +HOW THE THIRD RIVER CONFIRMS THE WILL + +FROM this joy and fullness of graces, and divine faithfulness, there +is born and flows out the third river in this same unity of spirit. +This river, like a flame, lights up the spirit and absorbs all +things in unity. And it causes to overflow and flood with rich gifts +and singular nobility, all the faculties of the soul, and it creates +in the will a love without labour, spiritual and subtle. Now Christ +says internally in the spirit by means of this flaming river: "Go +forth by exercises according to the mode of these gifts and this +coming." Thanks to the first river--that is to say, to a simple +light, the memory is lifted up above the accidents of sense, and is +established in the unity of spirit. Thanks to the second river-- +that is to say, to the brightness spread abroad within, the +intelligence and reason are enlightened, so as to recognise the +diverse modes of the virtues and of exercises, and the mysteries of +the Scriptures. Thanks to the third river--that is to say, to an +inspired ardour, the sublime will is kindled into a more tranquil +love, and adorned with greater riches. In this way a man becomes +spiritually enlightened, for the grace of God abides, like a +fountain in the unity of the spirit; and these rivers create in the +faculties of the soul an effluence of all the virtues. And the +fountain of grace always requires a reflux towards its source. + +HOW CHRIST IS GIVEN TO ALL MEN IN THE SACRAMENT OF THE ALTAR + +THERE is a special benefit which Christ left in the Holy Church, to +all good people, in this supper of the great Paschal feast, when He +was about to pass from His sufferings to His Father after having +eaten the Paschal lamb with His disciples, and when the ancient law +was accomplished. At the end of the supper, He wished to give them a +special meal, as He had long desired to do. And this is why He +wished to finish the ancient law and to inaugurate the new law. He +took bread in His sacred hands, and consecrated His holy body, and +then His holy blood, and gave them to all His disciples, and left +them to all the just, for their eternal good. + +This gift and this special food rejoice and adorn all the great +festivals and all the banquets in heaven and on earth. In this gift +Christ gives Himself to us in three manners; He gives us His flesh +and blood and His bodily life, glorified and full of joys and +griefs. And He gives us His spirit with its highest faculties, and +full of glory, of gifts, of truths and justifications. And He gives +us His personality with the divine light which lifts up His spirit +and all enlightened spirits, even to the sublime and joyous unity. + +Now Christ wishes us to remember Him, whenever we consecrate, offer, +and receive His body. Now observe how we should remember Him. We +shall observe and consider how Christ bends towards us in loving +affection, in great desire, in loving joy, and by flowing into our +bodily nature. For He gives us that which He received from our +humanity--that is to say, His flesh and blood and bodily nature. We +shall contemplate this precious body pierced and wounded with love, +by reason of His faithfulness to us. It is by it that we are adorned +and nourished in the lower part of our human nature. He gives us +also, in this sublime gift of the sacrament, His spirit full of +glory, and the richest gifts of the virtues, and ineffable marvels +of charity and nobleness. + +It is by this that we are nourished, adorned, and illuminated in the +unity of our spirit and in our higher faculties, thanks to the +indwelling of Christ with all His riches. He gives us also in the +sacrament of the altar His sublime personality in incomprehensible +light. And thanks to this, we are united to the Father, and so we +reach our inheritance of divinity in eternal bliss. If a man +meditate rightly on this, he will meet Christ in the same manner in +which Christ comes to him. He will raise himself up to receive +Christ, with all his faculties and in eager joy. It is not possible +for our joy to be too great, for our nature receives His nature--that +is to say the glorified humanity of Christ, full of joyfulness and +full of merits. This is why I would that man, at the reception of +this sacrament, should melt away with desire, joy, and pleasure, for +he is receiving the fairest, the most gracious, the most lovable of +the children of men, and is united to Him. In this union and in this +joy great benefits often come to men, and many mysterious and +marvellous secrets of divine treasures are manifested and disclosed. +When a man meditates, at this reception, on the martyrdom and +sufferings of the precious body of Christ, whom he is receiving, he +enters sometimes into so loving a devotion and so great a +compassion, that he desires to be nailed with Christ to the cross, +and to shed his heart's blood for the honour of Christ. And he +presses himself to the wounds and open heart of Christ His Saviour. +In these exercises revelations and great benefits have often come to +men. + +ON THE UNITY OF THE DIVINE NATURE IN THE TRINITY OF PERSONS + +THE sublime and superessential unity of the Divine nature, in which +the Father and the Son possess their nature in the unity of the Holy +Spirit, above the conception and comprehension of all our faculties, +in the bare essence of our spirit, surpasses in this sublime calm +all the creatures of created light. This sublime unity of the Divine +nature is living and fruitful, for, from this same unity, the +eternal Word is born from the Father without interruption. And by +this birth the Father knows the Son, and all things in the Son. And +the Son knows the Father, and all things in the Father, for their +nature is simple. From this reciprocal vision of the Father and the +Son in an eternal clearness, flow forth an eternal satisfaction and +unfathomable love, which is the Holy Spirit. And by the Holy Spirit +and the eternal Wisdom God inclines towards every creature +severally, and loads every one of them with gifts and kindles it +with love, according to its nobility and according to the state +wherein it is constituted and elected though its virtues and the +eternal foresight of God. And it is by this that all just spirits, +in heaven and on earth, are united in virtue and justice. + +HOW GOD MOVES AND POSSESSES THE SOUL, NATURALLY AND SUPERNATURALLY + +NOW be attentive: I am about to give you an example on this +subject. God has made the upper heaven a pure and simple clearness +encircling and enveloping all the heavens; and all the material +world which God has created for it is the exterior abode and kingdom +of God and His saints, full of glory and eternal joys. Now the +heaven being an unmixed clearness, there is there neither time, nor +state, nor temptation, nor change, for it is unchangeably fixed +above all things. The sphere which approaches most nearly to it is +called the primum mobile. All movement, by the power of God, +emanates from the supreme heaven. This is the movement which carries +with it the motions of the firmament and all the planets. It is by +this same initial movement that all the creatures live and grow, +according to their order. Now understand that the essence of the +soul is like a spiritual kingdom of God, full of Divine clearness, +surpassing all our faculties, unless these faculties are not +transformed in a simple fashion, of which I do not wish to speak +now. See; in this essence of the soul in which God reigns, the +unity of our spirit is like the primum mobile; for in this unity +the spirit is moved from above, by the power of God, naturally and +supernaturally; for by ourselves we have nothing either in or above +nature. And this motion of God, when it is supernatural, is the +first and chief cause of all our virtue. And by this motion of God +the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit are granted to certain +enlightened men, like the seven planets which illuminate all the +lives of men. This is how God possesses the essential unity of our +spirit, as His Kingdom. + +ON THE ESSENTIAL MEETING WITH GOD, WITHOUT INTERMEDIARY + +NOW attend carefully. The unity of our spirit has two modes, one +essential and the other active. You should know that the spirit, +according to its essential existence, receives the coming of Christ +in its bare nature, without intermediary and without interruption. +For this essence and life which we are in God, in our eternal image, +and which we have in ourselves, according to essential existence, +are without intermediary and inseparable. This is why the spirit +receives, in its highest and most intimate part, in its bare nature, +the impression of its eternal image, and the divine brightness +without interruption, and it is an eternal dwelling of God, which He +occupies by a perpetual inhabitation, and which He visits always +with a new coming, and a new effulgence from His eternal birth. For +where He comes He is, and where He is He comes. And where He has +never been, He will never come, for there is in Him neither accident +nor change, and everything, where He is, is in Him, for He never +goes out of Himself. And this is why the spirit possesses God +essentially in its bare nature, and God the spirit, for the spirit +lives in God, and God in the spirit. And it is capable, in its +highest part, of receiving the brightness of God, and all that God +may grant it, without intermediary. And by the brightness of its +eternal image, which shines essentially and personally in it, the +spirit is plunged, as regards the highest part of its vitality, in +the divine essence; and there enters into possession of its eternal +bliss, and flowing out again by the eternal birth of the Son is +placed in its created essence by the free will of the Holy Trinity, +And here it is like the image of the sublime Trinity and Unity for +which it is created. And in its created nature, it takes the +impression of its eternal image without interruption, like an +immaculate mirror in which every impression abides, and which renews +the likeness in itself without interruption. This essential unity of +our spirit in God, exists not in itself, but abides in God and flows +out from God, and is immanent in God and returns to God, as to its +eternal cause. It never separates itself from God, for this unity is +a fact of bare nature, and if nature separated itself from God it +would fall into nothingness. And this unity is above time and +conditions, and works always without interruption according to the +mode of God. This is the nobleness which we have naturally according +to the essential unity of our spirit, where it is united naturally +to God. + +This makes us neither saints nor blessed, for all men have it in +them, the bad as well as the good; but it is the first cause of all +holiness and bliss; and this is the meeting and unity of God in our +spirit, in our base nature. + +HOW MAN IS LIKE GOD BY GRACE, AND UNLIKE HIM BY MORTAL SIN + +NOW examine this thought with care, for if you understand well what +I wish to say to you, and what I have already said, you will +understand all the divine truth which a creature can apprehend at +present, and even things far more sublime. In the second mode, our +spirit keeps itself actively in this same unity, and subsists by +itself as in its personal created essence. This is the foundation +and origin of the supreme faculties, and this is the beginning and +end of all the works of a created nature, accomplished according to +the mode of the creatures, both in nature and above nature. + +Nevertheless this unity does not operate as unity; but all the +faculties of the soul have their power entirely in their +foundation--that is to say, in the unity of the spirit, where it +resides in its personal essence. In this unity the spirit must +always be like unto God, by grace and virtue, or unlike Him by +mortal sin; for man is made in the likeness of God, which he must +understand in the sense of grace; for grace is a deiform light which +shines through us and makes us like unto God; and without this light +we cannot be united supernaturally to God, even though we can never +lose the image of God, nor our natural unity in Him. If we lose this +likeness--that is to say, grace, we are damned. And this is why, so +soon as God finds in us something which is capable of receiving His +grace, He wishes to enliven us by His goodness, and to make us like +unto Himself by His gifts. And this happens whenever we turn towards +Him with full purpose; for at the same moment Christ comes to us and +in us, with and without intermediary--that is to say, by the virtues +and above all the virtues. And He impresses His image and likeness +upon us--that is to say, Himself and all His gifts, and He relieves +us from sin and makes us like unto Himself. + +By the same operation in which God relieves us from sin, and makes +us like Him and free in charity, the spirit is plunged in joyous +love. And here take place a meeting and a union, which are without +intermediaries and supernatural, and wherein resides our supreme +blessedness. Although all that He gives by love and pure goodness is +natural to God, yet to us it is accidental and supernatural, +according to our mode, since formerly we were strangers and unlike, +and only subsequently have become like God and obtained union with +Him. + +ON THE SUPREME DEGREE OF THE INTERIOR LIFE + +NOW understand. This incomprehensible light transforms and +penetrates the joyous inclination of our spirit. In this light, the +spirit is plunged in joyous repose; for this repose is without mode +and without bottom, and we can only know it by itself--that is to +say, by repose. For if we could know it and conceive it, it would +fall into mode and measure, and so would not be able to satisfy us, +and repose would become an eternal restlessness. And this is why the +simple, loving, complete inclination of our spirit forms in us a +joyous love, and joyous love is without bottom. And the abyss of God +calls to abyss; so it is with all those whose spirits are united to +God in joyous love. This calling is an irruption from His essential +brightness; and this essential brightness in the embrace of His +bottomless love, causes us to lose ourselves and escape from +ourselves, in the lonely darkness of God. And thus united, without +intermediary, to the spirit of God, we can meet God by God, and +possess unchangeably, with Him and in Him, our eternal blessedness. + +ON THE FIRST MODE OF THIS HIGHEST MEETING + +THE most interior life is practised in three ways. Sometimes the +interior man operates, above all activity and all virtue, by simple +introspection in joyous love. And here he meets God without +intermediary. And from the unity of God a simple light shines in +him, and this light shows him darkness, nakedness, and nothingness. +He is enveloped in darkness, and falls into the absence of mode as +one who loses his way. He loses, in nakedness, the power of +observing and distinguishing all things, and he is transformed and +penetrated by a simple brightness. He loses, in nothingness, all his +works, for he is overcome in the work of the unlimited love of God; +and in the joyous inclination of his spirit he triumphs in God and +becomes one spirit with Him. This is the first mode, which is +inactive; for it empties a man of all things, and lifts him up above +works and virtues. + +ON THE SECOND MODE + +THERE are moments when the interior man turns desirously and +actively towards God, to pay Him homage, and to offer up and +annihilate, in the love of God, his being and all that he can give. +And here he meets God, through an intermediary. This intermediary is +the gift of wisdom, which is the foundation and source of all the +virtues, and excites the just to virtues in proportion to their love; +and sometimes it touches and inflames the interior man with love +so violently, that all the gifts of God, and all that God can give +without giving Himself, seem to him too little and do not satisfy +him, but only increase his impatience. For he has at the bottom of +his being an interior perception or sensation, wherein all the +virtues begin and end, and wherein he offers to God all the virtues, +and wherein love lives. And thus the hunger and thirst of love +become so great, that he is reduced to nothingness, and then touched +anew, as it were for the first time, by the irradiation of God. Thus +in living he dies and in dying he lives again. This is the second +mode, and it is more useful and more glorious than the first; for +none can enter into the repose that is above action unless he has +first actively loved love. And this is why none will be inactive, +who is master of himself and who is able to practise love. + +ON THE THIRD MODE + +FROM these two kinds is born the third, which is an interior life +according to righteousness. Now understand. God comes to us without +interruption, with and. without intermediary, He requires of us +action and joy, in such a way that action may not hinder joy, nor +joy action, but that each may help the other. This is why the +interior man possesses his life in these two modes, repose and work. +And in each of them he is entire and undivided; for he is entirely +in God, in his joyous repose, and he is entirely in himself, in his +active love; and God warns him that He requires him to renew +continually his repose and his work. The righteousness of the spirit +wishes to pay, every hour, what God requires of us, and this is why, +at every irradiation of God, the spirit turns inwards, actively and +joyously, and so is renewed in all the virtues, and plunged more +deeply in joyous love. For God at every gift gives Himself with all +His gifts, and the spirit whenever it turns inwards, gives itself +with all its works. The spirit is united to God, and transferred +without interruption into repose. The man is hungry, for he sees the +nourishment of angels and the food of heaven. He works actively in +love, for he sees his repose. He is a pilgrim, and he sees his +country. He fights, in love, for victory, for he sees his crown. +Consolation, peace, joy, beauty, and riches, and all that can +rejoice the heart, are shown to the reason illuminated by God, in +spiritual similitudes and without measure. And by this vision, at +the touch of God, love remains active. For this just man has built +up, in the spirit, a true life, which will last eternally, but after +this life it will be transformed into a more sublime state. Thus the +man is just, and he goes towards God by interior love in eternal +work, and he goes in God by joyous inclination, in eternal repose. +And he abides in God, and yet he goes out towards all the creatures, +in common love, in the virtues, and in the works of justice. This is +the supreme summit of the inner life. + +Note.--Here follow in Ruysbroek's treatise four chapters of warnings +against the errors of Quietism, such as were exemplified in his time +by many of the Brethren of the Free Spirit and similar sects. + +BOOK III + +THE THREE CONDITIONS BY WHICH WE MAY ATTAIN TO THE CONTEMPLATIVE +LIFE + +THE interior lover of God, who possesses God in joyous repose, and +possesses himself in the unity of active love, and possesses all his +life in the virtues, enters into the contemplative life, thanks to +these three points and to the secret manifestation of God; yes, it +is the internal and devout lover, whom God will choose freely and +lift him up even to a superessential contemplation in divine light +and according to the mode of God. This contemplation places us in a +purity and brightness above all intelligence, for it is a singular +ornament and a celestial crown, and at last the eternal recompense +of all the virtues and of all life. And none can arrive there by +knowledge or subtlety, nor by any exercise; but he whom God wills to +unite to His own Spirit and to illuminate by Himself, can +contemplate God, and none other can. To such an one the heavenly +Father says, in the secret and submerged part of the spirit: "See, +the Bridegroom cometh, go forth to meet Him." + +I wish to analyse and explain these words, in their relation to +superessential contemplation, which is the basis of all holiness and +of the perfect life. Very few men attain to this divine +contemplation, by reason of our incapacity, and the mystery of the +light in which contemplation takes place. And this is why no one, by +his own knowledge or by any subtle examination, will understand +these ideas. For all words, and all that can be learned and +understood according to the mode of the creatures, are strangers to +the truth which I speak of, and far below it. But he who is united +to God, and illuminated in this truth, can comprehend the truth by +itself. For to conceive and understand God above all similitudes, as +He is in Himself, is to be God in God, without intermediary and +without any difference which might prove an obstacle. This is why I +desire that every man who does not understand this, nor experience +it in the joyous unity of his spirit, may not be wounded by my +words, for what I say is true. And this is why he who wishes to +understand this, must be dead to himself and alive to God, and he +will turn his face to the eternal light, at the bottom of his +spirit, where the hidden truth is manifested without intermediary. +For the heavenly Father wishes that we should be seeing; for He is +the Father of Light, and this is why He says eternally, without +interruption and without intermediary, one abysmal word and no +other. In this word He proffers Himself and all things. The word is: +"See." And it is the going forth and the birth of the Son of the +eternal light, in whom we see and recognise all our blessedness. + +HOW A MAN OUGHT TO EXERCISE HIMSELF, IN ORDER TO RECEIVE THE ETERNAL +LIGHT AND TO CONTEMPLATE GOD + +IN order that the spirit may contemplate God by God, without +intermediary, in this Divine light, three things are necessary. +First, the man must be well governed externally in all the virtues, +and without obstacles within, and as free from all external works as +if he did them not; for if he is troubled within by any act of +virtue, he has images, and so long as they remain in him he cannot +contemplate. In the second place, he must adhere internally to God, +by the combination of intention and of love, like a burning fire, +which can never more be extinguished. At the moment when he feels +himself in this state, he can contemplate. In the third place, he +should be lost in an absence of mode, and in a darkness, in which +all contemplatives wander joyously, and can never find themselves +again according to the mode of the creatures. In the abyss of this +darkness, where the loving spirit is dead to itself, begin the +manifestation of God and of eternal life. For in this darkness is +born and shines an incomprehensible light, which is the Son of God, +in whom we see eternal life. And in this light we become seeing; and +this Divine light is given in the simple vision of the spirit, in +which the spirit receives the clearness which is God Himself, +without intermediary, and becomes without interruption this +clearness which it receives. See; this dark clearness, in which we +contemplate all that we desire, while the spirit is passive,--this +clearness is so great than the loving contemplative, in the depth +where he reposes, sees and experiences nothing save an +incomprehensible light, and according to the simple nudity which +envelopes all things, he sees and apprehends the same light by which +he sees, and nothing else. This is the first condition of becoming +seeing in the Divine light. Happy are the eyes which thus see, for +they have eternal life. + +HOW THE ETERNAL BIRTH OF GOD IS RENEWED WITHOUT INTERRUPTION IN +NOBLENESS OF SPIRIT + +WHEN we have thus become seeing, we can contemplate in joy the +eternal coming of the Bridegroom, and this is the second point on +which I wish to speak. What is then this coming of the Bridegroom +which is eternal? It is a new birth and a new illumination without +interruption; for the foundation out of which the clearness shines, +and which is the clearness itself, is living and fruitful; and this +is why the manifestation of the eternal light is renewed without +interruption, in the most secret part of the spirit. See; every +creaturely work, and every exercise of virtue must here submit +themselves, for God works alone in the highest part of the spirit. +There is nought here but an eternal contemplation and fixity of +light, by light, and in light. And the coming of the Bridegroom is +so swift that He comes always, and is immanent with His unfathomable +riches, and comes back ever anew, in person, with such new +splendours that He seems never to have come before. For His coming +consists in an eternal Now, transcending time, and He is always +received with new desire and new joy. The delights and joy which +this Bridegroom brings at His coming are without bottom and without +limits, for they are Himself. This is why the eyes of the spirit, by +which the lover contemplates the Bridegroom, are open so wide that +they will never more be shut. For the contemplation and fixity of +the spirit remain eternal in the hidden manifestation of God. And +the contemplation of the spirit is so widely opened, while waiting +for the coming of the Bridegroom, that the spirit itself acquires +the amplitude of that which it comprehends. And in this way, God is +seen and comprehended by God, in which all our salvation and +blessedness consists. This is the second manner in which we receive, +without interruption in our spirit, the eternal coming of our +Bridegroom. + +ON THE ETERNAL GOING FORTH WHICH WE POSSESS IN THE BIRTH OF THE SON + +NOW the Spirit of God saith, in the secret depths of our spirit: +"Go forth," in an eternal contemplation and joy, according to the +mode of God. All the wealth which is in God naturally, we possess in +Him by love; and God possesses it in us, by His boundless Love, +which is the Holy Spirit. For in this love all is tasted that can be +desired. And this is why, thanks to this love, we are dead to +ourselves, and have gone forth in loving liquefaction or immersion, +in the absence of mode and in darkness. There the spirit, enveloped +by the Holy Trinity, is eternally immanent in the superessential +unity, in repose and in joy. And in this same unity, according to +the mode of generation, the Father is in the Son, and the Son in the +Father, and every creature in them both. And this is above the +distinction of Persons, for here we understand by reason the +fatherhood and sonship in the lively fruitfulness of nature. + +Here is born and begins an eternal going forth, and an eternal work +without beginning, for there is here a beginning without beginning. +For by means of the eternal birth of the Son, the Word of the +Father, all creatures have gone forth eternally, before they were +created in time, and God has considered and recognised them +distinctly in Himself, in lively reason, and in distinction from +Himself: but not in another mode, for all that is in God is God. +This eternal going forth and this eternal life, which we have and +are eternally in God, without ourselves, is the cause of our created +essence in time. And our created essence is immanent in the eternal +essence, and this eternal life, which we have and are in the eternal +wisdom of God, is like unto God; for they have an eternal immanence, +without distinction, in the divine essence. And they have an eternal +effluence by the birth of the Son, in a difference with distinction, +according to the eternal reason. And thanks to these two things, a +man is in this way like unto God, that he recognises himself and +reflects on himself without interruption, in this resemblance, +according to essence and according to the Persons. For though here +there is still distinction and difference, according to reason, this +resemblance is nevertheless one with the very image of the Holy +Trinity, which is the wisdom of God, and wherein God contemplates +Himself and all things in an eternal Now, without before or after. +In simple vision He regards Himself as He regards all things. And +this is the image and likeness of God, and our image and likeness, +for in it God and all things are reflected. In this divine image, +all the creatures, without themselves, have an eternal life, as in +their eternal model, and the Holy Trinity has made us in this +eternal image and likeness. And this is why God wishes that we +should go out from ourselves, in this eternal light, and that we +should pursue this image, which is our true life, supernaturally, +and possess it with Him actively and joyously, in eternal +blessedness. + +For we know well that the bosom of the Father is our foundation and +origin, wherein we begin our life and our being. And from our true +foundation--that is to say, from the Father and from all that lives +in Him, beams forth an eternal radiance, which is the birth of the +Son. In this radiance, the Father manifests Himself, and all that +lives in Himself, to Himself; for all that He is, and all that He +has, He gives to the Son, except the prerogative of fatherhood, +which resides in Himself. And this is why all that lives in the +Father hidden in the Unity, lives also in the Son, and flows forth +in His manifestation; but the simple foundation of our eternal image +remains always without mode in the darkness. But the boundless +radiance which shines out thence manifests and reflects in the mode +the mystery of God. And all men who are raised above their +creatureliness into a contemplative life, are united to this divine +splendour. And they are this splendour itself, and they see, +experience, and find, thanks to this divine radiance, that they are +this same simple foundation, according to their uncreated essence, +from which shines forth, in the divine mode, this immeasurable +radiance, which, according to simplicity of essence, remains +eternally within, and without mode. This is why interior men and +contemplatives will go forth, according to the mode of +contemplation, above distinction and above their created essence, by +means of an eternal intuition. Thanks to this inborn light, they are +transformed, and are united to this same light by which they see and +which they see. In this manner contemplatives pursue the eternal +image, after which they are made, and contemplate God and all things +without distinction, by a pure vision in divine brightness. This is +the most sublime and the most useful contemplation which we can +attain in this life; for in this contemplation a man remains the +best and freest master of himself, and at each loving introversion, +above all that we can comprehend, he can advance in the sublimities +of life, for he remains free and master of himself, in unity and in +the virtues. And this contemplation in the divine light maintains +him above all inwardness, above all virtue, above all merit, for it +is the crown and recompense towards which we are striving, and which +we already have and possess in this mode, for the contemplative life +is a celestial life. But if we shall be drawn up out of this exile +and this misery, we shall be, according to our created nature, more +susceptible of this radiance, and then the glory of God would shine +through us better and more sublimely. This is the mode above all +modes, according to which we go forth in a divine contemplation and +in an eternal stability, and according to which we are transformed +and reformed in the divine radiance. This going forth of the +contemplative is also loving; for by joyous love he surpasses his +created essence, and finds and tastes the riches and delights which +are God, and which He causes to flow without interruption into the +most secret part of the spirit, into the place where he is like the +sublimity of God. + +ON THE DIVINE MEETING, WHICH TAKES PLACE IN THE MOST SECRET PART OF +OUR SPIRIT + +WHEN the interior man and contemplative has thus pursued his eternal +image, and possessed in this purity the bosom of the Father by the +Son, he is illuminated by the divine truth, and receives anew at +each instant the eternal birth; and he goes forth according to the +mode of light, in a divine contemplation. And here arises the fourth +and last point--that is to say, the loving meeting, in which before +all else resides our eternal blessedness. + +You know that our heavenly Father, like a living foundation, is +actively inclined towards His Son, as towards His own eternal +wisdom. And this same wisdom, and all that lives therein, is +actively inclined in the Father--that is to say, in the foundation +whence it proceeds. And in this meeting arises the Third Person, +between the Father and the Son, and this is the Holy Spirit, their +mutual love, which is united to them both in the same nature. And He +envelopes and penetrates, actively and joyously, the Father and the +Son and all that lives in them with such riches and such joy, that +all the creatures must be silent thereupon eternally, for the +incomprehensible marvel of this love surpasses eternally the +intelligence of all the creatures. But where we comprehend and taste +this amazement, without being amazed, there the spirit is above +itself, and one with the Spirit of God, and it tastes and sees, +without measure, like God, the riches which He is Himself in the +unity of the living foundation, where He possesses Himself according +to the unity of His uncreated essence. + +Now this delightful meeting is without interruption actively renewed +in us, according to the mode of God, for the Father gives Himself in +the Son, and the Son in the Father, in an eternal gratification and +a loving embrace, and this is renewed at every hour in the ties of +love; for even as the Father without interruption contemplates anew +all things in the birth of His Son, so all things are beloved anew, +by the Father and the Son, through the influence of the Holy Spirit. +And this is the eternal meeting of the Father and the Son, in which +we are lovingly wrapped by the Holy Spirit in eternal love. + +Now this active meeting and this loving embrace are, in their +foundation, joyous and without mode, for God's infinite absence of +mode is so obscure and so destitute of mode, that it envelopes in +itself every divine mode and every work, and the individuality of +the Persons, in the rich envelopment of essential unity, and forms a +divine rejoicing in the abyss of the unnameable. And here there is a +joyous and outflowing immersion in the essential nakedness, where +all the divine names and all the modes, and all divine reason, +reflected in the mirror of the divine truth, fall into simple +ineffability, in the absence of mode and of reason. For in this +boundless abyss of simplicity, all things are enveloped in joyous +blessedness, and the abyss remains itself uncomprehended save by the +essential unity. Before this essential unity, the Persons must give +way, and all that lives in God. For here is nought but an eternal +rest, in a joyous envelopment of loving immersion, and this is the +essence, without mode, which all interior spirits have chosen above +all other things. It is the dark silence in which all lovers are +lost. But if we could prepare ourselves thus for the virtues, we +should unclothe ourselves, so to speak, from life, and should float +on the wide expanses of this divine sea, and created things would no +longer have power to touch us. + +May we be able to possess, rejoicing, the essential unity, and +clearly to contemplate the Unity in Trinity; and may the divine +love, which rejects no suppliant, grant us this. Amen. + + + + + + +THEOLOGIA GERMANICA + + + + + +SIN AND SELFISHNESS + +SIN is nothing else but the turning away of the creature from the +unchangeable Good to the changeable; from the perfect to the +imperfect, and most often to itself. And when the creature claims +for its own anything good, such as substance, life, knowledge, or +power, as if it were that, or possessed it, or as if that proceeded +from itself, it goeth astray. What else did the devil do, and what +was his error and fall, except that he claimed for himself to be +something, and that something was his and was due to him? This claim +of his--this "I, me, and mine," were his error and his fall. And so +it is to this day. For what else did Adam do? It is said that Adam +was lost, or fell, because he ate the apple. I say, it was because +he claimed something for his own, because of his "I, me, and mine." +If he had eaten seven apples, and yet never claimed anything for his +own, he would not have fallen: but as soon as he called something +his own, he fell, and he would have fallen, though he had never +touched an apple. I have fallen a hundred times more often and more +grievously than Adam; and for his fall all mankind could not make +amends. How then shall my fall be amended? It must be healed even as +Adam's fall was healed. And how, and by whom, was that healing +wrought? Man could not do it without God, and God could not do it +without man. Therefore God took upon Himself human nature; He was +made man, and man was made God. Thus was the healing effected. So +also must my fall be healed. I cannot do the work without God, and +He may not or will not do it without me. If it is to be done, God +must be made man in me also; God must take into Himself all that is +in me, both within and without, so that there may be nothing in me +which strives against God or hinders His work. Now if God took to +Himself all men who are or ever lived in the world, and was made man +in them, and they were deified in Him, and this work were not +accomplished in me, my fall and my error would never be healed +unless this were accomplished in me also. And in this bringing back +and healing I can and shall do nothing of myself; I shall simply +commit myself to God, so that He alone may do and work all things in +me, and that I may suffer Him, and all His work, and His divine +will. And because I will not do this, but consider myself to be mine +own, and "I, me, and mine," and the like, God is impeded, and cannot +do His work in me alone and without let or hindrance; this is why my +fall and error remain unhealed. All comes of my claiming something +for my own. ii., iii. + +THE TWO EYES + +We should remember the saying that the soul of Christ had two eyes, +a right eye and a left eye. In the beginning, when the soul of +Christ was created, she fixed her right eye upon eternity and the +Godhead, and remained in the full beholding and fruition of the +Divine essence and eternal perfection; and thus remained unmoved by +all the accidents and labours, the suffering, anguish, and pain, +that befell the outer man. But with the left eye she looked upon the +creation, and beheld all things that are therein, and observed how +the creatures differ from each other, how they are better or worse, +nobler or baser; and after this manner was the outer man of Christ +ordered. Thus the inner man of Christ, according to the right eye of +His soul, stood in the full exercise of His Divine nature, in +perfect blessedness, joy, and eternal peace. But the outer man and +the left eye of the soul of Christ stood with Him in perfect +suffering, in all His tribulations, afflictions and labours; in such +a way that the inner or right eye remained unmoved, unimpeded and +untouched by all the labour, suffering, woe, and misery that +happened to the outer man. It has been said that when Jesus was +bound to the pillar and scourged, and when He hung on the cross, +according to the outer man, the inner man, a soul according to the +right eye, stood in as full possession of Divine joy and blessedness +as it did after the ascension, or as it does now. Even so His outer +man, or soul according to the left eye, was never impeded, +disturbed, or troubled by the inward eye in its contemplation of the +outward things which pertained to it. The created soul of man has +also two eyes. The one is the power of looking into eternity, the +other the power of looking into time and the creatures, of +perceiving how they differ from each other, of giving sustenance and +other things necessary to the body, and ordering and ruling it for +the best. But these two eyes of the soul cannot both perform their +office at once; if the soul would look with the right eye into +eternity, the left eye must be shut, and must cease to work: it must +be as if it were dead. For if the left eye is discharging its office +towards outward things--if it is holding conversation with time and +the creatures--then the right eye must be impeded in its working, +which is contemplation. Therefore, he who would have one must let +the other go; for no man can serve two masters. vii. + +A FORETASTE OF ETERNAL LIFE + +Some have asked whether it is possible for the soul, while it is +still in the body, to reach so great a height as to gaze into +eternity, and receive a foretaste of eternal life and blessedness. +This is commonly denied; and in a sense the denial is true. For +indeed it cannot come about, so long as the soul is occupied with +the body, and the things which minister to the body and belong to +it, and to time and created things, and is disturbed and troubled +and distracted by them. For the soul that would mount to such a +state, must be quite pure, entirely stripped and bare of all images; +it must be wholly separate from all creatures, and above all from +itself. Many think that this is impossible in this present life. But +St Dionysius claims that it is possible, as we find from his words +in his letter to Timothy, where he says: "In order to behold the +hidden things of God, thou shalt forsake sense and the things of the +flesh, and all that can be perceived by the senses, and all that +reason can bring forth by her own power, and all things created and +uncreated which reason can know and comprehend, and thou shalt stand +upon an utter abandonment of thyself, as if thou knewest none of +those things which I have mentioned, and thou shalt enter into union +with Him who is, and who is above all existence and knowledge." If +he did not think this to be possible in this present time, why did +he teach it and urge it upon us in this present time? But you ought +to know that a master has said, about this passage of St Dionysius, +that it is possible, and may come to a man so often that he may +become accustomed to it, and be able to gaze into eternity whenever +he will. And a single one of these glances is better, worthier, +higher, and more pleasing to God than all that the creature can do +as a creature. He who has attained to it asks for nothing more, for +he has found the kingdom of heaven and eternal life here on earth. +viii. + +DESCENT INTO HELL + +Even as the soul of Christ had to descend into hell, before it +ascended into heaven, so must the soul of man. And mark how this +comes to pass. When a man truly perceives and considers who and what +he is, and finds himself wholly base and wicked, and unworthy of all +the consolation and kindness that he ever received, either from God +or from the creatures, he falls into such a profound abasement and +contempt for himself, that he thinks himself unworthy to walk upon +the earth; he feels that he deserves that all creatures should rise +against him and avenge their Maker upon him with punishments and +torments; nay, even that were too good for him. And therefore he +will not and dare not desire any consolation or release, either from +God or any creature; he is willing to be unconsoled and unreleased, +and he does not lament for his condemnation and punishment, for they +are right and just, and in accordance with God's will. Nothing +grieves him but his own guilt and wickedness; for that is not right, +and is contrary to God's will: for this reason he is heavy and +troubled. This is the meaning of true repentance for sin. And the +man who in this life enters into this hell, enters afterwards into +the kingdom of heaven, and has a foretaste of it which exceeds all +the delights and happiness which he has ever had, or could have, +from the things of time. But while a man is in this hell, no one can +comfort him, neither God, nor the creatures. Of this condition it +has been written, "Let me die, let me perish! I live without hope; +from within and from without I am condemned, let no man pray for my +deliverance." Now God has not forsaken a man, while he is in this +hell, but He is laying His hand upon him, that he may desire nothing +but the eternal Good only, and may discover that this is so noble +and exceedingly good, that its blessedness cannot be searched out +nor expressed, comfort and joy, peace, rest, and satisfaction. When, +therefore, the man cares for and seeks and desires the eternal Good +and nought beside, and seeks not himself, nor his own things, but +the glory of God only, he is made to partake of every kind of joy, +blessedness, peace, rest, and comfort, and from that time forward is +in the kingdom of God. + +This hell and this heaven are two good safe ways for a man in this +present life, and he is happy who truly finds them. For this hell +shall pass away, but this heaven shall abide for evermore. Let a man +also observe, that when he is in this hell, nothing can console him; +and he cannot believe that he shall ever be delivered or comforted. +But when he is in heaven, nothing can disturb him: he believes that +no one will ever be able to offend or trouble him again, though it +is indeed possible that he may again be troubled and left +unconsoled. + +This heaven and hell come upon a man in such a way, that he knows +not whence they come; and he can do nothing himself towards making +them either come or depart. He can neither give them to himself, nor +take them away from himself, neither bring them nor drive them away; +even as it is written, "The wind bloweth where it listeth, and thou +hearest the sound thereof, but canst not tell whence it cometh or +whither it goeth." And when a man is in either of these two states, +all is well with him, and he is as safe in hell as in heaven. And +while a man is in the world, it is possible for him to pass many +times from the one state into the other--even within a day and +night, and without any motion of his own. But when a man is in +neither of these two states, he holds intercourse with the +creatures, and is carried this way and that, and knows not what +manner of man he is. A man should therefore never forget either of +these states, but carry the memory of them in his heart. xi. + +THE THREE STAGES + +Be well assured that none can be illuminated, unless he be first +cleansed, purified, or stripped. Also none can be united to God +unless he be first illuminated. There are therefore three +stages--first, the purification; secondly, the illumination; and +thirdly, the union. The purification belongs to those who are +beginning or repenting. It is effected in three ways; by repentance +and sorrow for sin, by full confession, and by hearty amendment. The +illumination belongs to those who are growing, and it also is +effected in three ways; by the renunciation of sin, by the practice +of virtue and good works, and by willing endurance of all trials and +temptations. The union belongs to those who are perfect, and this +also is effected in three ways; by pureness and singleness of heart, +by love, and by the contemplation of God, the Creator of all things. +xiv. + +THE LIFE OF CHRIST + +We ought truly to know and believe that no life is so noble, or +good, or pleasing to God, as the life of Christ. And yet it is to +nature and selfishness the most bitter of all lives. For to nature, +and selfishness, and the Me, a life of careless freedom is the +sweetest and pleasantest, but it is not the best; indeed, in some +men it may be the worst. But the life of Christ, though it be the +bitterest of all, should be preferred above all. And hereby ye shall +know this. There is an inward sight which is able to perceive the +one true good, how that it is neither this nor that, but that it is +that of which St Paul says: "When that which is perfect is come, +then that which is in part shall be done away." By this he signifies +that what is whole and perfect excels all the parts, and that all +which is imperfect, and in part, is as nothing compared to what is +perfect. In like manner, all knowledge of the parts is swallowed up +when the whole is known. And where the good is known, it cannot fail +to be desired and loved so greatly, that all other love, with which +a man has loved himself, and other things, vanishes away. Moreover, +that inward sight perceives what is best and noblest in all things, +and loves it in the one true good, and for the sake of the true good +alone. Where this inward sight exists, a man perceives truly that +the life of Christ is the best and noblest life, and that it is +therefore to be chosen above all others; and therefore he willingly +accepts and endures it, without hesitation or complaining, whether +it is pleasing or displeasing to nature and other men, and whether +he himself likes or dislikes it, and finds it sweet or bitter. +Therefore, whenever this perfect and true good is known, the life of +Christ must be followed, until the decease of the body. If any man +vainly deems otherwise, he is deceived, and if any man says +otherwise, he tells a lie; and in whatever man the life of Christ is +not, he will never know the true good or the eternal truth. + +But let no one imagine that we can attain to this true light and +perfect knowledge, and to the life of Christ, by much questioning, +or by listening to others, or by reading and study, or by ability +and deep learning. For so long as a man is occupied with anything +which is this or that, whether it be himself or any other creature; +or does anything, or forms plans, or opinions, or objects, he comes +not to the life of Christ. Christ Himself declared as much, for He +said: "If any man will come after Me, let him deny himself, and take +up his cross, and follow Me." "And if any man hate not his father +and mother, and wife and children, and brethren and sisters, yea and +his own life also, he cannot be my disciple." He means this: "He who +does not give up and abandon everything can never know My eternal +truth, nor attain to My life." And even if this had not been +declared to us, the truth itself proclaims it, for so verily it is. +But as long as a man holds fast to the rudiments and fragments of +this world, and above all to himself, and is conversant with them, +and sets great store by them, he is deceived and blinded, and +perceives what is good only in so far as is convenient and agreeable +to himself and profitable to his own objects. + +Since then the life of Christ is in all ways most bitter to nature +and the self and the Me--for in the true life of Christ nature and +the self and the Me must be abandoned and lost and suffered to die +completely--therefore in all of us nature has a horror of it, and +deems it evil and unjust and foolish; and she strives after such a +life as shall be most agreeable and pleasant to ourselves; and says, +and believes too in her blindness, that such a life is the best of +all. Now nothing is so agreeable and pleasant to nature as a free +and careless manner of life. To this therefore she clings, and takes +enjoyment in herself and her powers, and thinks only of her own +peace and comfort. And this is especially likely to happen, when a +man has high natural gifts of reason, for reason mounts up in its +own light and by its own power, till at last it comes to think +itself the true eternal light, and gives itself out to be such; and +it is thus deceived in itself, and deceives others at the same time, +people who know no better and are prone to be so deceived. +xviii.-xx. + +UNION WITH GOD + +In what does union with God consist? It means that we should be +indeed purely, simply, and wholly at one with the one eternal Will +of God, or altogether without will, so that the created will should +flow out into the eternal Will and be swallowed up and lost in it, +so that the eternal Will alone should do and leave undone in us. Now +observe what may be of use to us in attaining this object. Religious +exercises cannot do this, nor words, nor works, nor any creature or +work done by a creature. We must therefore give up and renounce all +things, suffering them to be what they are, and enter into union +with God. Yet the outward things must be; and sleeping and waking, +walking and standing still, speaking and being silent, must go on as +long as we live. + +But when this union truly comes to pass and is established, the +inner man henceforth stands immoveable in this union; as for the +outer man, God allows him to be moved hither and thither, from this +to that, among things which are necessary and right. So the outer +man says sincerely, "I have no wish to be or not to be, to live or +die, to know or be ignorant, to do or leave undone; I am ready for +all that is to be or ought to be, and obedient to whatever I have to +do or suffer." Thus the outer man has no purpose except to do what +in him lies to further the eternal Will. As for the inner man, it is +truly perceived that he shall stand immoveable, though the outer +man must needs be moved. And if the inner man has any explanation of +the actions of the outer man, he says only that such things as are +ordained by the eternal Will must be and ought to be. It is thus +when God Himself dwells in a man; as we plainly see in the case of +Christ. Moreover, where there is this union, which is the outflow of +the Divine light and dwells in its beams, there is no spiritual +pride nor boldness of spirit, but unbounded humility and a lowly +broken heart; there is also an honest and blameless walk, justice, +peace, contentment, and every virtue. Where these are not, there is +no true union. For even as neither this thing nor that can bring +about or further this union, so nothing can spoil or hinder it, +except the man himself with his self-will, which does him this great +injury. Be well assured of this. xxvii., xxviii. + +THE FALSE LIGHT + +Now I must tell you what the False Light is, and what belongs to it. +All that is contrary to the true light belongs to the false. It +belongs of necessity to the true light that it never seeks to +deceive, nor consents that anyone should be injured or deceived; and +it cannot be deceived itself. But the false light both deceives +others, and is deceived itself. Even as God deceives no man, and +wills not that any should be deceived, so it is with His true light. +The true light is God or Divine, but the false light is nature or +natural. It belongeth to God, that He is neither this nor that, and +that He requires nothing in the man whom He has made to be partaker +in the Divine nature, except goodness as goodness and for the sake +of goodness. This is the token of the true light. But it belongs to +the creature, and to nature, to be something, this or that, and to +intend and seek something, this or that, and not simply what is good +without asking Why. And as God and the true light are without all +self-will, selfishness, and self-Seeking, so the "I, Me, and Mine" +belong to the false light, which in everything seeks itself and its +own ends, and not goodness for the sake of goodness. This is the +character of the natural or carnal man in each of us. Now observe +how it first comes to be deceived. It does not desire or choose +goodness for its own sake, but desires and chooses itself and its +own ends rather than the highest good; and this is an error and the +first deception. Secondly, it fancies itself to be God, when it is +nothing but nature. And because it feigns itself to be God, it takes +to itself what belongs to God; and not that which belongs to God +when He is made man, or when He dwells in a Godlike man; but that +which belongs to God as He is in eternity without the creature. God, +they say, and say truly, needs nothing, is free, exempt from toil, +apart by Himself, above all things: He is unchangeable, immoveable, +and whatever He does is well done. "so will I be," says the false +light. "The more like one is to God, the better one is; I therefore +will be like God and will be God, and will sit and stand at His +right hand." This is what Lucifer the Evil Spirit also said. Now God +in eternity is without contradiction, suffering, and grief, and +nothing can injure or grieve Him. But with God as He is made man it +is otherwise. The false light thinks itself to be above all works, +words, customs, laws, and order, and above the life which Christ led +in the body which He possessed in His human nature. It also claims +to be unmoved by any works of the creatures; it cares not whether +they be good or bad, for God or against Him; it keeps itself aloof +from all things, and deems it fitting that all creatures should +serve it. Further, it says that it has risen beyond the life of +Christ according to the flesh, and that outward things can no longer +touch or pain it, even as it was with Christ after the Resurrection. +Many other strange and false notions it cherishes. Moreover, this +false light says that it has risen above conscience and the sense of +sin, and that whatever it does is right. One of the so-called "Free +Spirits" even said that if he had killed ten men, he would have as +little sense of guilt as if he had killed a dog. This false light, +in so far as it fancies itself to be God, is Lucifer, the Evil +Spirit; but in so far as it makes of no account the life of Christ, +it is Antichrist. It says, indeed, that Christ was without sense of +sin, and that therefore we should be so. We may reply that Satan +also is without sense of sin, and is none the better for that. What +is a sense of sin? It is when we perceive that man has turned away +from God in his will, and that this is man's fault, not God's, for +God is guiltless of sin. Now, who knows himself to be free from sin, +save Christ only? Scarce will any other affirm this. So he who is +without sense of sin is either Christ or the Evil Spirit. But where +the true light is, there is a true and just life such as God loves. +And if a man's life is not perfect, as was that of Christ, still it +is modelled and built on His, and His life is loved, together with +modesty, order, and the other virtues, and all self-will, the "I, +Me, and Mine," is lost; nothing is devised or sought for except +goodness for its own sake. But where the false light is, men no +longer regard the life of Christ and the virtues, but they seek and +purpose what is convenient and pleasant to nature. From this arises +a false liberty, whereby men become regardless of everything. For +the true light is the seed of God, and bringeth forth the fruits of +God; but the false light is the seed of the Devil, and where it is +sown, the fruits of the Devil, nay the very Devil himself, spring +up. xl. + +LIGHT AND LOVE + +It may be asked, What is it like to be a partaker of the Divine +nature, or a Godlike man? The answer is, that he who is steeped in, +or illuminated by, the eternal and Divine Light, and kindled or +consumed by the eternal and Divine Love, is a Godlike man and a +partaker of the Divine nature. But this light or knowledge is of no +avail without love. You may understand this if you remember that a +man who knows very well the difference between virtue and +wickedness, but does not love virtue, is not virtuous, in that he +obeys vice. But he who loves virtue follows after it, and his love +makes him an enemy to wickedness, so that he will not perform any +wicked act and hates wickedness in others; and he loves virtue so +that he would not leave any virtue unperformed even if he had the +choice, not for the sake of reward, but from love of virtue. To such +a man virtue brings its own reward, and he is content with it, and +would part with it for no riches. Such a man is already virtuous, or +in the way to become so. And the truly virtuous man would not cease +to be so to gain the whole world. He would rather die miserably. The +case of justice is the same. Many men know well what is just and +unjust, but yet neither are nor ever will be just men. For they love +not justice, and therefore practise wickedness and injustice. If a +man loved justice, he would do no unjust deed; he would feel so +great abhorrence and anger against injustice whenever he saw it that +he would be willing to do and suffer anything in order to put an end +to injustice, and that men might be made just. He would rather die +than commit an injustice, and all for love of justice. To him, +justice brings her own reward, she rewards him with herself, and so +the just man would rather die a thousand deaths than live as an +unjust man. The same may be said of truth. A man may know very well +what is truth or a lie, but if he loves not the truth, he is not a +true man. If, however, he loves it, it is with truth as with +justice. And of justice Isaiah speaks in the fifth chapter: "Woe +unto them that call evil good, and good evil, that put darkness for +light, and light for darkness; that put bitter for sweet, and sweet +for bitter." Thus we may understand that knowledge and light avail +nothing without love. We see the truth of this in the case of the +Evil One. He perceives and knows good and evil, right and wrong: but +since he has no love for the good that he sees, he becomes not good. +It is true indeed that Love must be led and instructed by knowledge, +but if knowledge is not followed by Love, it will be of no avail. So +also with God and Divine things. Although a man know much about God +and Divine things, and even dream that he sees and understands what +God Himself is, yet if he have not Love, he will never become like +God or a partaker of the Divine nature. But if Love be added to his +knowledge, he cannot help cleaving to God, and forsaking all that is +not God or from God, and hating it and fighting with it, and finding +it a cross and burden. And this Love so unites a man to God, that he +can never again be separated from Him. xli. + +PARADISE + +What is Paradise? All things that are. For all things are good and +pleasant, and may therefore fitly be called Paradise. It is also +said, that Paradise is an outer court of heaven. In the same way, +this world is truly an outer court of the eternal, or of eternity; +and this is specially true of any temporal things or creatures which +manifest the Eternal or remind us of eternity; for the creatures are +a guide and path to God and eternity. Thus the world is an outer +court of eternity, and therefore it may well be called a Paradise, +for so indeed it is. And in this Paradise all things are lawful +except one tree and its fruit. That is to say, of all things that +exist, nothing is forbidden or contrary to God, except one thing +only. That one thing is self-will, or to will otherwise than as the +eternal Will would have it. Remember this. For God says to Adam +(that is, to every man) "Whatever thou art, or doest, or leavest +undone, or whatever happens, is lawful if it be done for the sake of +and according to My will, and not according to thy will. But all +that is done from thy will is contrary to the eternal Will." Not +that everything which is so done is in itself contrary to the +eternal Will, but in so far as it is done from a different will, or +otherwise than from the Eternal and Divine Will. l. + +WILL AND SELF-WILL + +Some may ask: "If this tree, Self-Will, is so contrary to God and to +the eternal will, why did God create it, and place it in Paradise?" +We may answer: a man who is truly humble and enlightened does not +ask God to reveal His secrets to him, or enquire why God does this +or that, or prevents or allows this or that; he only desires to know +how he may please God, and become as nothing in himself, having no +will of his own, and that the eternal will may live in him, and +possess him wholly, unhampered by any other will, and how what is +due may be paid to the Eternal Will, by him and through him. But +there is another answer to this question. For we may say: the most +noble and gracious gift that is bestowed on any creature is the +Reason and the Will. These two are so intimately connected that the +one cannot be anywhere without the other. If it were not for these +two gifts, there would be no reasonable creatures, but only brutes +and brutality; and this would be a great loss, for God would then +never receive His due, or behold Himself and His attributes +exhibited in action; a thing which ought to be, and is, necessary to +perfection. Now Perception and Reason are conferred together with +will, in order that they may teach the will and also themselves, +that neither perception nor will is of itself, or to itself, nor +ought to seek or obey itself. Nor must they turn themselves to their +own profit, nor use themselves for their own ends; for they belong +to Him from whom they proceed, and they shall submit to Him, and +flow back to Him, and become nothing in themselves--that is, in +their selfhood. + +But now you must consider more in detail something concerning the +will. There is an Eternal Will, which is a first principle and +substance in God, apart from all works and all externalisation; and +the same will is in man, or the creature, willing and bringing to +pass certain things. For it pertains to the will, to will something. +For what else does it exist? It would be a vain thing if it had no +work to do, and this it cannot have without the creature. And so +there must needs be creatures, and God will have them, in order that +by their means the will may be exercised, and may work, though in +God it must be without work. Therefore the will in the creature, +which we call the created will, is as truly God's as the eternal +will, and is not from the creature. + +And since God cannot exercise His will, in working and effecting +changes, without the creature, He is pleased to do so in and with +the creature. Therefore the will is not given to be exercised by the +creature, but by God alone, who has the right to carry into effect +His own will by the will which is in man, but yet is God's will. And +in any man or creature, in whom it should be thus, purely and +simply, the will of that man or creature would be exercised not by +the man but by God, and thus it would not be self-will, and the man +would only will as God wills; for God Himself, and not man, would be +moving the will. Thus the will would be united with the Eternal +Will, and would flow into it; although the man would retain his +sense of liking and disliking, pleasure and pain. But nothing is +complained of, except what is contrary to God. And there is no +rejoicing except in God alone, and in that which belongs to Him. And +as with the will, so is it with all the other faculties of man; they +are all of God and not of man. And when the will is wholly given up +to God, the other faculties will certainly be given up too; and God +will have what is due to Him. + +No one may call that which is free his own, and he who makes it his +own, doeth injustice. Now in all the sphere of freedom nothing is so +free as the will; and he who makes it his own, and allows it not to +remain in its excellent freedom, and free nobleness, and free +exercise, does it a great injustice. This is what is done by the +devil, and Adam, and all their followers. But he who leaves the will +in its noble freedom does right; and this is what Christ, and all +who follow Him, do. And he who deprives the will of its noble +freedom, and makes it his own, must necessarily be oppressed with +cares and discontent, and disquietude, and every kind of misery, and +this will be his lot throughout time and eternity. But he who leaves +the will in its freedom has contentment and peace and rest and +blessedness, through time and eternity. Where there is a man whose +will is not enslaved, he is free indeed, and in bondage to no man. +He is one of those to whom Christ said: "The truth shall make you +free"; and He adds immediately afterwards: "If the Son shall make +you free, ye shall be free indeed." + +Moreover, observe that whenever the will chooses unhindered whatever +it will, it always and in all cases chooses what is noblest and +best, and hates whatever is not noble and good, and regards it as an +offence. And the more free and unhampered the will is, the more it +is grieved by evil, by injustice, by iniquity, and all manner of +sin. We see this in Christ, whose will was the purest and freest and +the least brought into bondage of any man's who ever lived. So was +the human nature of Christ the most free and pure of all creatures; +and yet He felt the deepest distress, pain, and wrath at sin that +any creature ever felt. But when men claim freedom for themselves, +in such a way as to feel no sorrow or anger at sin, and all that is +contrary to God, and say that we must take no notice of anything, +and care for nothing, but be, in this life, what Christ was after +the resurrection, and so forth, this is not the true and Divine +freedom that springs from the true and Divine light, but a natural, +unrighteous, false, deceiving freedom, which springs from the +natural, false, deceitful light. + +If there were no self-will, there would be no proprietorship. There +is no proprietorship in heaven; and this is why contentment, peace, +and blessedness are there. If anyone in heaven were so bold as to +call anything his own, he would immediately be cast out into hell, +and become an evil spirit. But in hell everyone will have self-will, +and therefore in hell is every kind of wretchedness and misery. And +so it is also on earth. But if anyone in hell could rid himself of +his self-will and call nothing his own, he would pass out of hell +into heaven. And if a man, while here on earth, could be entirely +rid of self-will and proprietorship, and stand up free and at +liberty in the true light of God, and continue therein, he would be +sure to inherit the kingdom of heaven. For he who has anything, or +who desires to have anything of his own, is a slave; and he who has +nothing of his own, nor desires to have anything, is free and at +liberty, and is in bondage to no man. li. + +UNION THROUGH CHRIST + +Observe now how the Father draws men to Christ. When something of +the perfect good is revealed and made manifest within the human +soul, as it were in a sudden flash, the soul conceives a desire to +draw near to the perfect goodness, and to unite herself with the +Father. And the more strongly she longs and desires, the more is +revealed to her; and the more is revealed to her, the more she is +drawn to the Father, and the more is her desire kindled. So the soul +is drawn and kindled into an union with the eternal goodness. And +this is the drawing of the Father; and so the soul is taught by Him +who draws her to Himself, that she cannot become united with Him +unless she can come to Him by means of the life of Christ. liii. + +[1]In his Introduction to the "Imitation of Christ," in this series. + +[2]e.g. she distinguishes, as Eckhart does, between God and the +Godhead. + +[3]The "three propositions" of Amalric are--1. "Deus est omnia." 2. +Every Christian, as a con-dition of salvation, must believe that he +is a member of Christ. 3. To those who are in charity no sin is +imputed. + +[4]Preger is probably wrong in identifying him with a "brother +Eckhart," Prior of Frankfort, who about 1320 was delated to the head +of the Order as suspectus de malis familiaritatibus, words which can +only mean "keeping bad company" in a moral sense, not "con-sorting +with heretics," as Preger suggests. Eckhart's character, so far as +we know, was never assailed, even by his enemies, and it is +therefore probable that "brother Eckhart" was a different person. + +[5]I have abridged the bull considerably, but have included all the +main accusations. + +[6]See pages 13, 16. + +[7]See pages 14, 15. + +[8]See page 1. + +[9]This is an obscure point in Eckhart's philosophy, too technical +to be discussed here; but Eckhart's doctrine of God is certainly +more orthodox and less pantheistic than those of 'Dionysius' and +Scotus Erigena. + +[10]Cf. St Augustine, In Joann. Ev. Tract. xxxix. 10: praeteritum et +futurum invenio in omni motu rerum: in veritate quae manet +praeteritum et futurum non invenio, sed solum praesens. + +[11]This doctrine is fully explained by St. Augustine, Epist. 237, +who follows Plotinus, Enn. vi. 4-6. + +[12]This queer word occurs for the first time, I think, in Jerome's +notes to the first chapter of Ezekiel. He writes the word in Greek, +and explains it as that part of the soul which always opposes vices. +The word is common in Bonaventura and other scholastic mystics, and +is often misspelt synderesis. + +[13]It must, however, be said that Preger is too ready to assume +that the logical development of Eckhart's system away from Thomist +scholasticism can be traced as a gradual process in his writings, +the order of which is very uncertain. We are not justified in saying +in a positive manner that Eckhart's philosophy passed through three +phases, in the first of which the primacy is held by the will, in +the second by the created reason, and in the third by the uncreated +reason. + +[14]See pages 14, 15. + +[15]C.B. Upton: "Hibbert Lectures," p. 17. + +[16]A.E. Taylor: "The Problem of Conduct," PP. 464-5. + +[17]See pages 71-2. + +[18]See pages 12-13. + +[19]See, for example, Prof. W. James' "Varieties of Religions +Experience," P. 400. + +[20]Jacob Bhme's experience is typical: "Suddenly did my spirit +break through into the innermost birth or geniture of the Deity, and +there was I embraced with love, as a bridegroom embraces his dearly +beloved bride. But the greatness of the triumphing that was in the +spirit I cannot express in speech or writing; nor can it be compared +to anything but the resurrection of the dead to life. In this light +my spirit suddenly saw through all; even in herbs and grass it knew +God, who and what He is," etc. Dr Johnson was, no doubt, right in +thinking that "Jacob" would have been wiser, and "more like St +Paul," if he had not attempted to utter the unutterable things which +he saw. + +[21]The extracts from the "Theologia Germanica" will show that this +treatise represents a later and less paradoxical form of mystical +thought than Eckhart's. + +[22]The maxim, however, is much older than Suso. + +[23]Royce: "The World and the Individual" vol. i. p. 193. + +[24]So in the "Lignum Vitae" of Laurentius Justinianus we read: "Let +self-will cease, and there will be no more hell." + +[25] "The Inner Way," being thirty-six sermons by John Tauler. +Translated by A.W. Hutton, M.A. + +[26]On the psychology of ecstatic mysticism see Leuba, in the Revue +Philosophique, July and November 1902. + +[27] "Varieties of Religious Experience," p. 13. + +[28]Maudsley: "Natural Causes and Supernatural Seemings," p. 256. + +[29]See Leuba: "Tendances religieuses chez les mystiques +chrtiens" in Revue Philosophique, Nov. 1902. + +[30] "Theologia Germanica," translated by Susanna Winkworth. +Macmillan & Co., 1893. + +[31] "Varieties of Religious Experience," 1902. + +[32] "Personal Idealism," 1902. + +[33] "Varieties of Religious Experience," p. 103. + +[34] "In Tune with the Infinite," by R.W. Trine (Bell & Sons, 1902). +Fifty-ninth thousand. The extract appears to be a quotation from +another writer, but no reference is given. + +[35]Compare Eckhart's saying that the eye with which I see God is +the same as the eye with which He sees me. + +[36] "In Tune with the Infinite," pp. 58, 119. + +[37]The numbers refer to pages in Pfeiffer's edition. + +[38]The numbers refer to the Sermons in Hamberger's edition of 1864. + +[39]The reference is to 1 Peter iii. 8. + +[40]The time would, I suppose, be about half-an-hour. Many other +ecstatics have named this as the normal duration of trance. + +[41]Or, "spoke the eternal Wisdom (= the Word of God) in his heart." + +[42]John i. 3, 4. This punctuation, whereby the words "that which +was made" are referred to the clause which follows, and not to that +which precedes, is adopted by most of the Greek fathers, and is +still maintained by some good commentators--e.g. Bishop Westcott. + +[43]Ecclus. xxiv. 19. + +[44]Ecclus. xl. 20. + +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Light, Life, and Love +by W. R. Inge +******This file should be named lllov10.txt or lllov10.zip****** + +Corrected EDITIONS of our etexts get a new NUMBER, lllov11.txt +VERSIONS based on separate sources get new LETTER, lllov10a.txt + +This etext was produced by Charles Aldarondo. + +*** + +More information about this book is at the top of this file. + + +We are now trying to release all our eBooks one year in advance +of the official release dates, leaving time for better editing. +Please be encouraged to tell us about any error or corrections, +even years after the official publication date. + +Please note neither this listing nor its contents are final til +midnight of the last day of the month of any such announcement. +The official release date of all Project Gutenberg eBooks is at +Midnight, Central Time, of the last day of the stated month. A +preliminary version may often be posted for suggestion, comment +and editing by those who wish to do so. + +Most people start at our Web sites at: +https://gutenberg.org or +http://promo.net/pg + +These Web sites include award-winning information about Project +Gutenberg, including how to donate, how to help produce our new +eBooks, and how to subscribe to our email newsletter (free!). + + +Those of you who want to download any eBook before announcement +can get to them as follows, and just download by date. This is +also a good way to get them instantly upon announcement, as the +indexes our cataloguers produce obviously take a while after an +announcement goes out in the Project Gutenberg Newsletter. + +http://www.ibiblio.org/gutenberg/eBook03 or +ftp://ftp.ibiblio.org/pub/docs/books/gutenberg/eBook03 + +Or /eBook02, 01, 00, 99, 98, 97, 96, 95, 94, 93, 92, 92, 91 or 90 + +Just search by the first five letters of the filename you want, +as it appears in our Newsletters. + + +Information about Project Gutenberg (one page) + +We produce about two million dollars for each hour we work. The +time it takes us, a rather conservative estimate, is fifty hours +to get any eBook selected, entered, proofread, edited, copyright +searched and analyzed, the copyright letters written, etc. Our +projected audience is one hundred million readers. If the value +per text is nominally estimated at one dollar then we produce $2 +million dollars per hour in 2002 as we release over 100 new text +files per month: 1240 more eBooks in 2001 for a total of 4000+ +We are already on our way to trying for 2000 more eBooks in 2002 +If they reach just 1-2% of the world's population then the total +will reach over half a trillion eBooks given away by year's end. + +The Goal of Project Gutenberg is to Give Away 1 Trillion eBooks! +This is ten thousand titles each to one hundred million readers, +which is only about 4% of the present number of computer users. + +Here is the briefest record of our progress (* means estimated): + +eBooks Year Month + + 1 1971 July + 10 1991 January + 100 1994 January + 1000 1997 August + 1500 1998 October + 2000 1999 December + 2500 2000 December + 3000 2001 November + 4000 2001 October/November + 6000 2002 December* + 9000 2003 November* +10000 2004 January* + + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation has been created +to secure a future for Project Gutenberg into the next millennium. + +We need your donations more than ever! + +As of February, 2002, contributions are being solicited from people +and organizations in: Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Connecticut, +Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, +Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Massachusetts, +Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New +Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, +Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South +Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West +Virginia, Wisconsin, and Wyoming. + +We have filed in all 50 states now, but these are the only ones +that have responded. + +As the requirements for other states are met, additions to this list +will be made and fund raising will begin in the additional states. +Please feel free to ask to check the status of your state. + +In answer to various questions we have received on this: + +We are constantly working on finishing the paperwork to legally +request donations in all 50 states. If your state is not listed and +you would like to know if we have added it since the list you have, +just ask. + +While we cannot solicit donations from people in states where we are +not yet registered, we know of no prohibition against accepting +donations from donors in these states who approach us with an offer to +donate. + +International donations are accepted, but we don't know ANYTHING about +how to make them tax-deductible, or even if they CAN be made +deductible, and don't have the staff to handle it even if there are +ways. + +The most recent list of states, along with all methods for donations +(including credit card donations and international donations), may be +found online at https://www.gutenberg.org/donation.html + +Donations by check or money order may be sent to: + +Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +PMB 113 +1739 University Ave. +Oxford, MS 38655-4109 + +Contact us if you want to arrange for a wire transfer or payment +method other than by check or money order. + + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation has been approved by +the US Internal Revenue Service as a 501(c)(3) organization with EIN +[Employee Identification Number] 64-622154. Donations are +tax-deductible to the maximum extent permitted by law. As fund-raising +requirements for other states are met, additions to this list will be +made and fund-raising will begin in the additional states. + +We need your donations more than ever! + +You can get up to date donation information at: + +https://www.gutenberg.org/donation.html + + +*** + +If you can't reach Project Gutenberg, +you can always email directly to: + +Michael S. Hart <hart@pobox.com> + +Prof. Hart will answer or forward your message. + +We would prefer to send you information by email. + + +**The Legal Small Print** + + +(Three Pages) + +***START**THE SMALL PRINT!**FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN EBOOKS**START*** +Why is this "Small Print!" statement here? You know: lawyers. +They tell us you might sue us if there is something wrong with +your copy of this eBook, even if you got it for free from +someone other than us, and even if what's wrong is not our +fault. So, among other things, this "Small Print!" statement +disclaims most of our liability to you. It also tells you how +you may distribute copies of this eBook if you want to. + +*BEFORE!* YOU USE OR READ THIS EBOOK +By using or reading any part of this PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm +eBook, you indicate that you understand, agree to and accept +this "Small Print!" statement. If you do not, you can receive +a refund of the money (if any) you paid for this eBook by +sending a request within 30 days of receiving it to the person +you got it from. If you received this eBook on a physical +medium (such as a disk), you must return it with your request. + +ABOUT PROJECT GUTENBERG-TM EBOOKS +This PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm eBook, like most PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm eBooks, +is a "public domain" work distributed by Professor Michael S. Hart +through the Project Gutenberg Association (the "Project"). +Among other things, this means that no one owns a United States copyright +on or for this work, so the Project (and you!) can copy and +distribute it in the United States without permission and +without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, set forth +below, apply if you wish to copy and distribute this eBook +under the "PROJECT GUTENBERG" trademark. + +Please do not use the "PROJECT GUTENBERG" trademark to market +any commercial products without permission. + +To create these eBooks, the Project expends considerable +efforts to identify, transcribe and proofread public domain +works. Despite these efforts, the Project's eBooks and any +medium they may be on may contain "Defects". Among other +things, Defects may take the form of incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other +intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged +disk or other eBook medium, a computer virus, or computer +codes that damage or cannot be read by your equipment. + +LIMITED WARRANTY; DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES +But for the "Right of Replacement or Refund" described below, +[1] Michael Hart and the Foundation (and any other party you may +receive this eBook from as a PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm eBook) disclaims +all liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including +legal fees, and [2] YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE OR +UNDER STRICT LIABILITY, OR FOR BREACH OF WARRANTY OR CONTRACT, +INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE +OR INCIDENTAL DAMAGES, EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE +POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES. + +If you discover a Defect in this eBook within 90 days of +receiving it, you can receive a refund of the money (if any) +you paid for it by sending an explanatory note within that +time to the person you received it from. If you received it +on a physical medium, you must return it with your note, and +such person may choose to alternatively give you a replacement +copy. If you received it electronically, such person may +choose to alternatively give you a second opportunity to +receive it electronically. + +THIS EBOOK IS OTHERWISE PROVIDED TO YOU "AS-IS". NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, ARE MADE TO YOU AS +TO THE EBOOK OR ANY MEDIUM IT MAY BE ON, INCLUDING BUT NOT +LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A +PARTICULAR PURPOSE. + +Some states do not allow disclaimers of implied warranties or +the exclusion or limitation of consequential damages, so the +above disclaimers and exclusions may not apply to you, and you +may have other legal rights. + +INDEMNITY +You will indemnify and hold Michael Hart, the Foundation, +and its trustees and agents, and any volunteers associated +with the production and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm +texts harmless, from all liability, cost and expense, including +legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of the +following that you do or cause: [1] distribution of this eBook, +[2] alteration, modification, or addition to the eBook, +or [3] any Defect. + +DISTRIBUTION UNDER "PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm" +You may distribute copies of this eBook electronically, or by +disk, book or any other medium if you either delete this +"Small Print!" and all other references to Project Gutenberg, +or: + +[1] Only give exact copies of it. Among other things, this + requires that you do not remove, alter or modify the + eBook or this "small print!" statement. You may however, + if you wish, distribute this eBook in machine readable + binary, compressed, mark-up, or proprietary form, + including any form resulting from conversion by word + processing or hypertext software, but only so long as + *EITHER*: + + [*] The eBook, when displayed, is clearly readable, and + does *not* contain characters other than those + intended by the author of the work, although tilde + (~), asterisk (*) and underline (_) characters may + be used to convey punctuation intended by the + author, and additional characters may be used to + indicate hypertext links; OR + + [*] The eBook may be readily converted by the reader at + no expense into plain ASCII, EBCDIC or equivalent + form by the program that displays the eBook (as is + the case, for instance, with most word processors); + OR + + [*] You provide, or agree to also provide on request at + no additional cost, fee or expense, a copy of the + eBook in its original plain ASCII form (or in EBCDIC + or other equivalent proprietary form). + +[2] Honor the eBook refund and replacement provisions of this + "Small Print!" statement. + +[3] Pay a trademark license fee to the Foundation of 20% of the + gross profits you derive calculated using the method you + already use to calculate your applicable taxes. If you + don't derive profits, no royalty is due. Royalties are + payable to "Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation" + the 60 days following each date you prepare (or were + legally required to prepare) your annual (or equivalent + periodic) tax return. Please contact us beforehand to + let us know your plans and to work out the details. + +WHAT IF YOU *WANT* TO SEND MONEY EVEN IF YOU DON'T HAVE TO? +Project Gutenberg is dedicated to increasing the number of +public domain and licensed works that can be freely distributed +in machine readable form. + +The Project gratefully accepts contributions of money, time, +public domain materials, or royalty free copyright licenses. +Money should be paid to the: +"Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +If you are interested in contributing scanning equipment or +software or other items, please contact Michael Hart at: +hart@pobox.com + +[Portions of this header are copyright (C) 2001 by Michael S. Hart +and may be reprinted only when these eBooks are free of all fees.] +[Project Gutenberg is a TradeMark and may not be used in any sales +of Project Gutenberg eBooks or other materials be they hardware or +software or any other related product without express permission.] + +*END THE SMALL PRINT! FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN EBOOKS*Ver.02/11/02*END* + + + +End of The Project Gutenberg Etext of Light, Life, and Love +by W. R. Inge + diff --git a/LICENSE.txt b/LICENSE.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..6312041 --- /dev/null +++ b/LICENSE.txt @@ -0,0 +1,11 @@ +This eBook, including all associated images, markup, improvements, +metadata, and any other content or labor, has been confirmed to be +in the PUBLIC DOMAIN IN THE UNITED STATES. + +Procedures for determining public domain status are described in +the "Copyright How-To" at https://www.gutenberg.org. + +No investigation has been made concerning possible copyrights in +jurisdictions other than the United States. Anyone seeking to utilize +this eBook outside of the United States should confirm copyright +status under the laws that apply to them. diff --git a/README.md b/README.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7436d77 --- /dev/null +++ b/README.md @@ -0,0 +1,2 @@ +Project Gutenberg (https://www.gutenberg.org) public repository for +eBook #4664 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/4664) diff --git a/old/4664.txt b/old/4664.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..a290720 --- /dev/null +++ b/old/4664.txt @@ -0,0 +1,6848 @@ +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Light, Life, and Love +by W. R. Inge + +Copyright laws are changing all over the world. Be sure to check the +copyright laws for your country before downloading or redistributing +this or any other Project Gutenberg file. + +Please do not remove this header information. + +This header should be the first thing seen when anyone starts to +view the eBook. Do not change or edit it without written permission. +The words are carefully chosen to provide users with the information +needed to understand what they may and may not do with the eBook. +To encourage this, we have moved most of the information to the end, +rather than having it all here at the beginning. + + +**Welcome To The World of Free Plain Vanilla Electronic Texts** + +**eBooks Readable By Both Humans and By Computers, Since 1971** + +*****These eBooks Were Prepared By Thousands of Volunteers!***** + +Information on contacting Project Gutenberg to get eBooks, and +further information, is included below. We need your donations. + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation is a 501(c)(3) +organization with EIN [Employee Identification Number] 64-6221541 +Find out about how to make a donation at the bottom of this file. + + +Title: Light, Life, and Love + +Author: W. R. Inge + +Release Date: November, 2003 [Etext #4664] +[Yes, we are more than one year ahead of schedule] +[This file was first posted on February 25, 2002] + +Edition: 10 + +Language: English + +Character set encoding: Latin1 + +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Light, Life, and Love +by W. R. Inge +******This file should be named 4664.txt or 4664.zip****** + +Corrected EDITIONS of our etexts get a new NUMBER, lllov11.txt +VERSIONS based on separate sources get new LETTER, lllov10a.txt + +Project Gutenberg eBooks are often created from several printed +editions, all of which are confirmed as Public Domain in the US +unless a copyright notice is included. Thus, we usually do not +keep eBooks in compliance with any particular paper edition. + +The "legal small print" and other information about this book +may now be found at the end of this file. Please read this +important information, as it gives you specific rights and +tells you about restrictions in how the file may be used. + +*** +This etext was produced by Charles Aldarondo. + +LIGHT, LIFE, AND LOVE + +Selections from the German Mystics of the Middle Ages + +by + +W. R. Inge + +LONDON +Second Edition + +1919 + + + + + + +CONTENTS + + + + + +INTRODUCTION +ECKHART +TAULER +MEDITATIONS ON THE SEVEN WORDS FROM THE CROSS +SUSO +RUYSBROEK +THEOLOGIA GERMANICA + + + + + + +INTRODUCTION + +Sect. 1. THE PRECURSORS OF THE GERMAN MYSTICS + + + + + +TO most English readers the "Imitation of Christ" is the +representative of mediaeval German mysticism. In reality, however, +this beautiful little treatise belongs to a period when that +movement had nearly spent itself. Thomas a Kempis, as Dr. Bigg has +said,[1] was only a semi-mystic. He tones down the most +characteristic doctrines of Eckhart, who is the great original +thinker of the German mystical school, and seems in some ways to +revert to an earlier type of devotional literature. The "Imitation" +may perhaps be described as an idealised picture of monastic piety, +drawn at a time when the life of the cloister no longer filled a +place of unchallenged usefulness in the social order of Europe. To +find German mysticism at its strongest we must go back a full +hundred years, and to understand its growth we must retrace our +steps as far as the great awakening of the thirteenth century--the +age of chivalry in religion--the age of St. Louis, of Francis and +Dominic, of Bonaventura and Thomas Aquinas. It was a vast revival, +bearing fruit in a new ardour of pity and charity, as well as in a +healthy freedom of thought. The Church, in recognising the new +charitable orders of Francis and Dominic, and the Christianised +Aristotelianism of the schoolmen, retained the loyalty and profited +by the zeal of the more sober reformers, but was unable to prevent +the diffusion of an independent critical spirit, in part provoked +and justified by real abuses. Discontent was aroused, not only by +the worldiness of the hierarchy, whose greed and luxurious living +were felt to be scandalous, but by the widespread economic distress +which prevailed over Western Europe at this period. The crusades +periodically swept off a large proportion of the able-bodied men, of +whom the majority never returned to their homes, and this helped to +swell the number of indigent women, who, having no male protectors, +were obliged to beg their bread. The better class of these female +mendicants soon formed themselves into uncloistered charitable +Orders, who were not forbidden to marry, and who devoted themselves +chiefly to the care of the sick. These Beguines and the +corresponding male associations of Beghards became very numerous in +Germany. Their religious views were of a definite type. Theirs was +an intensely inward religion, based on the longing of the soul for +immediate access to God. The more educated among them tended to +embrace a vague idealistic Pantheism. Mechthild of Magdeburg +(1212-1277), prophetess, poetess, Church reformer, quietist, was the +ablest of the Beguines. Her writings prove to us that the technical +terminology of German mysticism was in use before Eckhart,[2] and +also that the followers of what the "Theologia Germanica" calls the +False Light, who aspired to absorption in the Godhead, and despised +the imitation of the incarnate Christ, were already throwing +discredit on the movement. Mechthild's independence, and her +unsparing denunciations of corruption in high places, brought her +into conflict with the secular clergy. They tried to burn her +books--those religious love songs which had already endeared her to +German popular sentiment. It was then that she seemed to hear a +voice saying to her: + +Lieb' meine, betrbe dich nicht zu sehr, + +Die Wahrheit mag niemand verbrennen! + +The rulers of the Church, unhappily, were not content with burning +books. Their hostility towards the unrecognised Orders became more +and more pronounced: the Beghards and Beguines were harried and +persecuted till most of them were driven to join the Franciscans or +Dominicans, carrying with them into those Orders the ferment of +their speculative mysticism. The more stubborn "Brethren and Sisters +of the Free Spirit" were burned in batches at Cologne and elsewhere. +Their fate in those times did not excite much pity, for many of the +victims were idle vagabonds of dissolute character, and the general +public probably thought that the licensed begging friars were enough +of a nuisance without the addition of these free lances. + +The heretical mystical sects of the thirteenth century are very +interesting as illustrating the chief dangers of mysticism. Some of +these sectaries were Socialists or Communists of an extreme kind; +others were Rationalists, who taught that Jesus Christ was the son +of Joseph and a sinner like other men; others were Puritans, who +said that Church music was "nothing but a hellish noise" (nihil nisi +clamor inferni), and that the Pope was the magna meretrix of the +Apocalypse. The majority were Anti-Sacramentalists and Determinists; +and some were openly Antinomian, teaching that those who are led by +the Spirit can do no wrong. The followers of Amalric of Bena[3] +believed that the Holy Ghost had chosen their sect in which to +become incarnate; His presence among them was a continual guarantee +of sanctity and happiness. The "spiritual Franciscans" had dreams of +a more apocalyptic kind. They adopted the idea of an "eternal +Gospel," as expounded by Joachim of Floris, and believed that the +"third kingdom," that of the Spirit, was about to begin among +themselves. It was to abolish the secular Church and to inaugurate +the reign of true Christianity--i.e. "poverty" and asceticism. + +Such are some of the results of what our eighteenth-century +ancestors knew and dreaded as "Enthusiasm"--that ferment of the +spirit which in certain epochs spreads from soul to soul like an +epidemic, breaking all the fetters of authority, despising tradition +and rejecting discipline in its eagerness to get rid of formalism +and unreality; a lawless, turbulent, unmanageable spirit, in which, +notwithstanding, is a potentiality for good far higher than any to +which the lukewarm "religion of all sensible men" can ever attain. +For mysticism is the raw material of all religion; and it is easier +to discipline the enthusiast than to breathe enthusiasm into the +disciplinarian. + +Meanwhile, the Church looked with favour upon the orthodox mystical +school, of which Richard and Hugo of St. Victor, Bonaventura, and +Albertus Magnus were among the greatest names. These men were +working out in their own fashion the psychology of the contemplative +life, showing how we may ascend through "cogitation, meditation, and +speculation" to "contemplation," and how we may pass successively +through jubilus, ebrietas spiritus, spiritualis jucunditas, and +liquefactio, till we attain raptus or ecstasy. The writings of the +scholastic mystics are so overweighted with this pseudo-science, +with its wire-drawn distinctions and meaningless classifications, +that very few readers have now the patience to dig out their +numerous beauties. They are, however, still the classics of mystical +theology in the Roman Church, so far as that science has not +degenerated into mere miracle-mongering. + +Sect. 2. MEISTER ECKHART + +It was in 1260, when Mechthild of Magdeburg was at the height of her +activity, that Meister Eckhart, next to Plotinus the greatest +philosopher-mystic, was born at Hocheim in Thuringia. It seems that +his family was in a good position, but nothing is known of his early +years. He entered the Dominican Order as a youth, perhaps at +sixteen, the earliest age at which novices were admitted into that +Order. The course of instruction among the Dominicans was as +follows:--After two years, during which the novice laid the +foundations of a good general education, he devoted the next two +years to grammar, rhetoric, and dialectic, and then the same amount +of time to what was called the Quadrivium, which consisted of +"arithmetic, mathematics, astronomy, and music." Theology, the queen +of the sciences, occupied three years; and at the end of the course, +at the age of twenty-five, the brothers were ordained priests. We +find Eckhart, towards the end of the century, Prior of Erfurt and +Vicar of Thuringia, then Lector Biblicus at Paris, then Provincial +Prior of Saxony. In 1307 the master of the Order appointed him +Vicar-General for Bohemia, and in 1311 he returned to Paris. We find +him next preaching busily at Strassburg,[4] and after a few more +years, at Cologne, where the persecution of the Brethren of the Free +Spirit was just then at its height. At Strassburg there were no less +than seven convents of Dominican nuns, for since 1267 the Order had +resumed the supervision of female convents, which it had renounced a +short time after its foundation. Many of Eckhart's discourses were +addressed to these congregations of devout women, who indeed were to +a large extent the backbone of the mystical movement, and it is +impossible not to see that the devotional treatises of the school +are strongly coloured by feminine sentiment. A curious poem, written +by a Dominican nun of this period, celebrates the merits of three +preachers, the third of whom is a Master Eckhart, "who speaks to us +about Nothingness. He who understands him not, in him has never +shone the light divine." These nuns seem to have been fed with the +strong meat of Eckhart's mystical philosophy; in the more popular +sermons he tried to be intelligible to all. It was not very long +after he took up his residence at Cologne that he was himself +attacked for heresy. In 1327 he read before his own Order a +retractation of "any errors which might be found" (si quid errorum +repertum fuerit) in his writings, but withdrew nothing that he had +actually said, and protested that he believed himself to be +orthodox. He died a few months later, and it was not till 1329 that +a Papal bull was issued, enumerating seventeen heretical and eleven +objectionable doctrines in his writings. + +This bull is interesting as showing what were the points in +Eckhart's teaching which in the fourteenth century were considered +dangerous. They also indicate very accurately what are the real +errors into which speculative mysticism is liable to fall, and how +thinkers of this school may most plausibly be misrepresented by +those who differ from them. After expressing his sorrow that "a +certain Teuton named Ekardus, doctor, ut fertur, sacrae paginae, has +wished to know more than he should," and has sown tares and thistles +and other weeds in the field of the Church, the Pope specifies the +following erroneous statements as appearing in Eckhart's +writings[5]:--1. "God created the world as soon as God was. 2. In +every work, bad as well as good, the glory of God is equally +manifested. 3. A man who prays for any particular thing prays for an +evil and prays ill, for he prays for the negation of good and the +negation of God, and that God may be denied to him.[6] 4. God is +honoured in those who have renounced everything, even holiness and +the kingdom of heaven. 5. We are transformed totally into God, even +as in the Sacrament the bread is converted into the Body of Christ. +Unum, non simile. 6. Whatever God the Father gave to His +only-begotten Son in His human nature, He has given it all to me. 7. +Whatever the Holy Scripture says about Christ is verified in every +good and godlike man. 8. External action is not, properly speaking, +good nor divine; God, properly speaking, only works in us internal +actions. 9. God is one, in every way and according to every reason, +so that it is not possible to find any plurality in Him, either in +the intellect or outside it; for he who sees two, or sees any +distinction, does not see God; for God is one, outside number and +above number, for one cannot be put with anything else, but follows +it; therefore in God Himself no distinction can be or be understood. +10. All the creatures are absolutely nothing: I say not that they +are small or something, but that they are absolutely nothing." All +these statements are declared to have been found in his writings. It +is also "objected against the said Ekardus" that he taught the +following two articles in these words:--1. "There is something in +the soul, which is uncreated and uncreatable: if the whole soul were +such, it would be uncreated and uncreatable: and this is the +intelligence.[7] 2. God is not good or better or best: I speak ill +when I call God good; it is as if I called white black."[8] The bull +declares all the propositions above quoted to be heretical, with the +exception of the three which I have numbered 8-10, and these "have +an ill sound" and are "very rash," even if they might be so +supplemented and explained as to bear an orthodox sense. + +This condemnation led to a long neglect of Eckhart's writings. He +was almost forgotten till Franz Pfeiffer in 1857 collected and +edited his scattered treatises and endeavoured to distinguish those +which were genuine from those which were spurious. Since Pfeiffer's +edition fresh discoveries have been made, notably in 1880, when +Denifle found at Erfurt several important fragments in Latin, which +in his opinion show a closer dependence on the scholastic theology, +and particularly on St Thomas Aquinas, than Protestant scholars, +such as Preger, had been willing to allow. But the attempt to prove +Eckhart a mere scholastic is a failure; the audacities of his German +discourses cannot be explained as an accommodation to the tastes of +a peculiar audience. For good or evil Eckhart is an original and +independent thinker, whose theology is confined by no trammels of +authority. + +Sect. 3. ECKHART'S RELIGIOUS PHILOSOPHY + +The Godhead, according to Eckhart, is the universal and eternal +Unity comprehending and transcending all diversity. "The Divine +nature is Rest," he says in one of the German discourses; and in the +Latin fragments we find: "God rests in Himself, and makes all things +rest in Him." The three Persons of the Trinity, however, are not +mere modes or accidents,[9] but represent a real distinction within +the Godhead. God is unchangeable, and at the same time an +"everlasting process." The creatures are "absolutely nothing"; but +at the same time "God without them would not be God," for God is +love, and must objectify Himself; He is goodness, and must impart +Himself. As the picture in the mind of the painter, as the poem in +the mind of the poet, so was all creation in the mind of God from +all eternity, in uncreated simplicity. The ideal world was not +created in time; "the Father spake Himself and all the creatures in +His Son"; "they exist in the eternal Now"[10]--"a +becoming without a becoming, change without change." "The Word of +God the Father is the substance of all that exists, the life of all +that lives, the principle and cause of life." Of creation he says: +"We must not falsely imagine that God stood waiting for something to +happen, that He might create the world. For so soon as He was God, +so soon as He begat His coeternal and coequal Son, He created the +world." So Spinoza says: "God has always been before the creatures, +without even existing before them. He precedes them not by an +interval of time, but by a fixed eternity." This is not the same as +saying that the world of sense had no beginning; it is possible that +Eckhart did not mean to go further than the orthodox scholastic +mystic, Albertus Magnus, who says: "God created things from +eternity, but the things were not created from eternity." St +Augustine (Conf. xi. 30) bids objectors to "understand that there +can be no time without creatures, and cease to talk nonsense." +Eckhart also tries to distinguish between the "interior" and the +"exterior" action of God. God, he says, is in all things, not as +Nature, not as Person, but as Being. He is everywhere, undivided; +yet the creatures participate in Him according to their measure.[11] +The three Persons of the Trinity have impressed their image upon the +creatures, yet it is only their "nothingness" that keeps them +separate creatures. Most of this comes from the Neoplatonists, and +much of it through the pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite, a +Platonising Christian of the fifth century, whose writings were +believed in the Middle Ages to proceed from St Paul's Athenian +convert. It would, however, be easy to find parallels in St +Augustine's writings to most of the phases quoted in this paragraph. +The practical consequences will be considered presently. + +The creatures are a way from God; they are also a way to Him. "In +Christ," he says, "all the creatures are one man, and that man is +God." Grace, which is a real self-unfolding of God in the soul, can +make us "what God is by Nature"--one of Eckhart's audacious phrases, +which are not really so unorthodox as they sound. The following +prayer, which appears in one of his discourses, may perhaps be +defended as asking no more than our Lord prayed for (John xvii.) for +His disciples, but it lays him open to the charge, which the Pope's +bull did not fail to urge against him, that he made the servant +equal to his Lord. "Grant that I, by Thy grace, may be united to Thy +Nature, as Thy Son is eternally one in Thy Nature, and that grace +may become my nature." + +The ethical aim is to be rid of "creatureliness," and so to be +united to God. In Eckhart's system, as in that of Plotinus, +speculation is never divorced from ethics. On our side the process +is a negative one. All our knowledge must be reduced to +not-knowledge; our reason and will, as well as our lower faculties, +must transcend themselves, must die to live. We must detach +ourselves absolutely "even from God," he says. This state of +spiritual nudity he calls "poverty." Then, when our house is empty +of all else, God can dwell there: "He begets His Son in us." This +last phrase has always been a favourite with the mystics. St Paul +uses very similar language, and the Epistle to Diognetus, written in +the second century, speaks of Christ as, "being ever born anew in +the hearts of the saints." Very characteristic, too, is the doctrine +that complete detachment from the creatures is the way to union with +God. Jacob Bhme has arrived independently at the same conclusion as +Eckhart. "The scholar said to his master: How may I come to the +supersensual life, that I may see God and hear Him speak? The master +said: When thou canst throw thyself but for a moment into that place +where no creature dwelleth, then thou hearest what God speaketh. The +scholar asked: Is that near or far off? The master replied: It is in +thee, and if thou canst for a while cease from all thy thinking and +willing, thou shalt hear unspeakable words of God. The scholar said: +How can I hear, when I stand still from thinking and willing? The +master answered: When thou standest still from the thinking and +willing of self, the eternal hearing, seeing, and speaking will be +revealed to thee, and so God heareth and seeth through thee." + +In St Thomas Aquinas it is "the will enlightened by reason" which +unites us to God. But there are two sorts of reason. The passive +reason is the faculty which rises through discursive thinking to +knowledge. The active reason is a much higher faculty, which exists +by participation in the divine mind, "as the air is light by +participation in the sunshine." When this active reason is regarded +as the standard of moral action, it is called by Aquinas +synteresis.[12] Eckhart was at first content with this teaching of +St Thomas, whom he always cites with great reverence; but the whole +tendency of his thinking was to leave the unprofitable +classification of faculties in which the Victorine School almost +revelled, and to concentrate his attention on the union of the soul +with God. And therefore in his more developed teaching,[13] the +"spark" which is the point of contact between the soul and its Maker +is something higher than the faculties, being "uncreated." He seems +to waver about identifying the "spark" with the "active reason," but +inclines on the whole to regard it as something even higher still. +"There is something in the soul," he says, "which is so akin to God +that it is one with Him and not merely united with Him." And again: +"There is a force in the soul; and not only a force, but something +more, a being; and not only a being, but something more; it is so +pure and high and noble in itself that no creature can come there, +and God alone can dwelt there. Yea, verily, and even God cannot come +there with a form; He can only come with His simple divine nature." +And in the startling passage often quoted against him, a passage +which illustrates admirably his affinity to one side of Hegelianism, +we read: "The eye with which I see God is the same eye with which He +sees me. Mine eye and God's eye are one eye and one sight and one +knowledge and one love." + +I do not defend these passages as orthodox; but before exclaiming +"rank Pantheism!" we ought to recollect that for Eckhart the being +of God is quite different from His personality. Eckhart never taught +that the Persons of the Holy Trinity become, after the mystical +Union, the "Form" of the human soul. It is the impersonal light of +the divine nature which transforms our nature; human personality is +neither lost nor converted into divine personality. Moreover, the +divine spark at the centre of the soul is not the soul nor the +personality. "The soul," he says in one place, using a figure which +recurs in the "Theologia Germanica," "has two faces. One is turned +towards this world and towards the body, the other towards God." The +complete dominion of the "spark" over the soul is an unrealised +ideal.[14] + +The truth which he values is that, as Mr Upton[15] has well +expressed it, "there is a certain self-revelation of the eternal and +infinite One to the finite soul, and therefore an indestructible +basis for religious ideas and beliefs as distinguished from what is +called scientific knowledge. . . . This immanent universal principle +does not pertain to, and is not the property of any individual mind, +but belongs to that uncreated and eternal nature of God which lies +deeper than all those differences which separate individual minds +from each other, and is indeed that incarnation of the Eternal, who +though He is present in every finite thing, is still not broken up +into individualities, but remains one and the same eternal +substance, one and the same unifying principle, immanently and +indivisibly present in every one of the countless plurality of +finite individuals." It might further be urged that neither God nor +man can be understood in independence of each other. A recent writer +on ethics,[16] not too well disposed towards Christianity, is, I +think, right in saying: "To the popular mind, which assumes God and +man to be two different realities, each given in independence of the +other, . . . the identification of man's love of God with God's love +of Himself has always been a paradox and a stumbling-block. But it +is not too much to say that until it has been seen to be no paradox, +but a simple and fundamental truth, the masterpieces of the world's +religious literature must remain a sealed book to us." + +Eckhart certainly believed himself to have escaped the pitfall of +Pantheism; but he often expressed himself in such an unguarded way +that the charge may be brought against him with some show of reason. + +Love, Eckhart teaches, is the principle of all virtues; it is God +Himself. Next to it in dignity comes humility. The beauty of the +soul, he says in the true Platonic vein, is to be well ordered, with +the higher faculties above the lower, each in its proper place. The +will should be supreme over the understanding, the understanding +over the senses. Whatever we will earnestly, that we have, and no +one can hinder us from attaining that detachment from the creatures +in which our blessedness consists. + +Evil, from the highest standpoint, is only a means for realising the +eternal aim of God in creation; all will ultimately be overruled for +good. Nevertheless, we can frustrate the good will of God towards +us, and it is this, and not the thought of any insult against +Himself, that makes God grieve for our sins. It would not be worth +while to give any more quotations on this subject, for Eckhart is +not more successful than other philosophers in propounding a +consistent and intelligible theory of the place of evil in the +universe. + +Eckhart is well aware of the two chief pitfalls into which the +mystic is liable to fall--dreamy inactivity and Antinomianism. The +sects of the Free Spirit seem to have afforded a good object-lesson +in both these errors, as some of the Gnostic sects did in the second +century. Eckhart's teaching here is sound and good. Freedom from +law, he says, belongs only to the "spark," not to the faculties of +the soul, and no man can live always on the highest plane. +Contemplation is, in a sense, a means to activity; works of charity +are its proper fruit. "If a man were in an ecstasy like that of St +Paul, when he was caught up into the third heaven, and knew of a +poor man who needed his help, he ought to leave his ecstasy and help +the needy." Suso[17] tells us how God punished him for disregarding +this duty. True contemplation considers Reality (or Being) in its +manifestations as well as in its origin. If this is remembered, +there need be no conflict between social morality and the inner +life. Eckhart recognises[18] that it is a harder and a nobler task +to preserve detachment in a crowd than in a cell; the little daily +sacrifices of family life are often a greater trial than +self-imposed mortifications. "We need not destroy any little good in +ourselves for the sake of a better, but we should strive to grasp +every truth in its highest meaning, for no one good contradicts +another." "Love God, and do as you like, say the Free Spirits. Yes; +but as long as you like anything contrary to God's will, you do not +love Him." + +There is much more of the same kind in Eckhart's sermons--as good +and sensible doctrine as one could find anywhere. But what was the +practical effect of his teaching as a whole? It is generally the +case that the really weak points of any religious movement are +exposed with a cruel logicality most exasperating to the leaders by +the second generation of its adherents. The dangerous side of the +Eckhartian mysticism is painfully exhibited in the life of his +spiritual daughter, "Schwester Katrei," the saint of the later +Beguines. Katrei is a rather shadowy person; but for our present +purpose it does not much matter whether the story of her life has +been embroidered or not. Her memory was revered for such sayings and +doings as these which follow. On one occasion she exclaimed: +"Congratulate me; I have become God!" and on another she declared +that "not even the desire of heaven should tempt a good man towards +activity." It was her ambition to forget who were her parents, to be +indifferent whether she received absolution and partook of the Holy +Communion or not; and she finally realised her ambition by falling +into a cataleptic state in which she was supposed to be dead, and +was carried out for burial. Her confessor, perceiving that she was +not really dead, awoke her: "Art thou satisfied?" "I am satisfied at +last," said Katrei: she was now "dead all through," as she wished to +be. + +Are we to conclude that the logical outcome of mysticism is this +strange reproduction, in Teutonic Europe, of Indian Yogism? Many who +have studied the subject have satisfied themselves that Schwester +Katrei is the truly consistent mystic. They have come to the +conclusion that the real attraction of mysticism is a pining for +deliverance from this fretful, anxious, exacting, individual life, +and a yearning for absorption into the great Abyss where all +distinctions are merged in the Infinite. According to this view, +mysticism in its purest form should be studied in the ancient +religious literature of India, which teaches us how all this world +of colour and diversity, of sharp outlines and conflicting forces, +may be lost and swallowed up in the "white radiance," or black +darkness (it does not really matter which we call it) of an empty +Infinite. + +The present writer is convinced that this is not the truth about +mysticism. Eckhart may have encouraged Schwester Katrei in her +attempt to substitute the living death of the blank trance for the +dying life of Christian charity; but none the less she caricatured +and stultified his teaching. And I think it is possible to lay our +finger on the place where she and so many others went wrong. The +aspiration of mysticism is to find the unity which underlies all +diversity, or, in religious language, to see God face to face. From +the Many to the One is always the path of the mystic. Plotinus, the +father of all mystical philosophy in Europe (unless, as he himself +would have wished, we give that honour to Plato), mapped out the +upward road as follows:--At the bottom of the hill is the sphere of +the "merely many"--of material objects viewed in disconnection, +dull, and spiritless. This is a world which has no real existence; +it may best be called "not-being" ("ein lauteres Nichts," as Eckhart +says), and as the indeterminate, it can only be apprehended by a +corresponding indeterminateness in the soul. The soul, however, +always adds some form and determination to the abstract formlessness +of the "merely many." Next, we rise to, or project for ourselves, +the world of "the one and the many." This is the sphere in which our +consciousness normally moves. We are conscious of an overruling +Mind, but the creatures still seem external to and partially +independent of it. Such is the temporal order as we know it. Above +this is the intelligible world, the eternal order, "the one-many," +das ewige Nu, the world in which God's will is done perfectly and +all reflects the divine mind. Highest of all is "the One," the, +Absolute, the Godhead, of whom nothing can be predicated, because He +is above all distinctions. This Neoplatonic Absolute is the Godhead +of whom Eckhart says: "God never looked upon deed," and of whom +Angelus Silesius sings: + + "Und sieh, er ist nicht Wille, + Er ist ein' ewige Stille." + +Plotinus taught that the One, being superessential, can only be +apprehended in ecstasy, when thought, which still distinguishes +itself from its object, is transcended, and knower and known become +one. As Tennyson's Ancient Sage says: + + "If thou would'st hear the Nameless, and descend + Into the Temple-cave of thine own self, + There, brooding by the central altar, thou + May'st haply learn the Nameless hath a voice, + By which thou wilt abide, if thou be wise; + For knowledge is the swallow on the lake, + That sees and stirs the surface-shadow there + But never yet hath dipt into the Abysm." + +In the same way Eckhart taught that no creature can apprehend the +Godhead, and, therefore, that the spark in the centre of the soul +(this doctrine, too, is found in Plotinus) must be verily divine. +The logic of the theory is inexorable. If only like can know like, +we cannot know God except by a faculty which is itself divine. The +real question is whether God, as an object of knowledge and worship +for finite beings, is the absolute Godhead, who transcends all +distinctions. The mediaeval mystics held that this "flight of the +alone to the alone," as Plotinus calls it, is possible to men, and +that in it consists our highest blessedness. They were attracted +towards this view by several influences. First, there was the +tradition of Dionysius, to whom (e.g.) the author of the "Theologia +Germanica" appeals as an authority for the possibility of "beholding +the hidden things of God by utter abandonment of thyself, and of +entering into union with Him who is above all existence, and all +knowledge." Secondly, there was what a modern writer has called "the +attraction of the Abyss," the longing which some persons feel very +strongly to merge their individuality in a larger and better whole, +to get rid not only of selfishness but of self for ever. "Leave +nothing of myself in me," is Crashaw's prayer in his wonderful poem +on St Teresa. Thirdly, we may mention the awe and respect long paid +to ecstatic trances, the pathological nature of which was not +understood. The blank trance was a real experience; and as it could +be induced by a long course of ascetical exercises and fervid +devotions, it was naturally regarded as the crowning reward of +sanctity on earth. Nor would it be at all safe to reject the +evidence, which is very copious,[19] that the "dreamy state" may +issue in permanent spiritual gain. The methodical cultivation of it, +which is at the bottom of most of the strange austerities of the +ascetics, was not only (though it was partly) practised in the hope +of enjoying those spiritual raptures which are described as being +far more intense than any pleasures of sense[20]: it was the hope of +stirring to its depths the subconscious mind and permeating the +whole with the hidden energy of the divine Spirit that led to the +desire for visions and trances. Lastly, I think we must give a place +to the intellectual attraction of an uncompromising monistic theory +of the universe. Spiritualistic monism, when it is consistent with +itself, will always lean to semi-pantheistic mysticism rather than +to such a compromise with pluralism as Lotze and his numerous +followers in this country imagine to be possible. + +But it is possible to go a long way with the mystics and yet to +maintain that under no conditions whatever can a finite being escape +from the limitations of his finitude and see God or the world or +himself "with the same eye with which God sees" all things. The old +Hebrew belief, that to see the face of God is death, expresses the +truth under a mythical form. That the human mind, while still "in +the body pent," may obtain glimpses of the eternal order, and enjoy +foretastes of the bliss of heaven, is a belief which I, at least, +see no reason to reject. It involves no rash presumption, and is not +contrary to what may be readily believed about the state of immortal +spirits passing through a mortal life. But the explanation of the +blank trance as a temporary transit into the Absolute must be set +down as a pure delusion. It involves a conception of the divine +"Rest" which in his best moments Eckhart himself repudiates. "The +Rest of the Godhead," he says, "is not in that He is the source of +being, but in that He is the consummation of all being." This +profound saying expresses the truth, which he seems often to forget, +that the world-process must have a real value in God's sight--that +it is not a mere polarisation of the white radiance of eternity +broken up by the imperfection of our vision. Whatever theories we +may hold about Absolute Being, or an Absolute that is above Being, +we must make room for the Will, and for Time, which is the "form" of +the will, and for the creatures who inhabit time and space, as +having for us the value of reality. Nor shall we, if we are to +escape scepticism, be willing to admit that these appearances have +no sure relation to ultimate reality. We must not try to uncreate +the world in order to find God. We were created out of nothing, but +we cannot return to nothing, to find our Creator there. The still, +small voice is best listened for amid the discordant harmony of life +and death. + +The search for God is no exception to the mysterious law of human +nature, that we cannot get anything worth having--neither holiness +nor happiness nor wisdom--by trying for it directly. It must be +given us through something else. The recluse who lives like +Parnell's "Hermit": + +"Prayer all his business, all his pleasure praise," + +is not only a poor sort of saint, but he will offer a poor sort of +prayers and praises. He will miss real holiness for the same reason +that makes the pleasure-seeker miss real happiness. We must lose +ourselves in some worthy interest in order to find again both a +better self and an object higher than that which we sought. This the +German mystics in a sense knew well. There is a noble sentence of +Suso to the effect that "he who realises the inward in the outward, +to him the inward becomes more inward than to him who only +recognises the inward in the inward." Moreover, the recognition that +"God manifests Himself and worketh more in one creature than +another" ("Theologia Germanica"), involves a denial of the +nihilistic view that all the creatures are "ein lauteres +Nichts."[21] It would be easy to find such passages in all the +fourteenth-century mystics, but it cannot be denied that on the +whole their religion is too self-centred. There are not many maxims +so fundamentally wrong-headed and un-Christian as Suso's advice to +"live as if you were the only person in the world."[22] The life of +the cloistered saint may be abundantly justified--for the spiritual +activity of some of them has been of far greater service to mankind +than the fussy benevolence of many "practical" busybodies--but the +idea of social service, whether in the school of Martha or of Mary, +ought surely never to be absent. The image of Christ as the Lover of +the individual soul rather than as the Bridegroom of the Church was +too dear to these lonely men and women. Unconsciously, they looked +to their personal devotions to compensate them for the human loves +which they had forsworn. The raptures of Divine Love, which they +regarded as signal favours bestowed upon them, were not very +wholesome in themselves, and diverted their thoughts from the needs +of their fellow-men. They also led to most painful reactions, in +which the poor contemplative believed himself abandoned by God and +became a pray to terrible depression and melancholy. These fits of +wretchedness came indeed to be recognised as God's punishment for +selfishness in devotion and for too great desire for the sweetness +of communing with God, and so arose the doctrine of "disinterested +love," which was more and more emphasised in the later mysticism, +especially by the French Quietists. + +I have spoken quite candidly of the defects of Eckhart's mystical +Christianity. As a religious philosophy it does not keep clear of +the fallacy that an ascent though the unreal can lead to reality. +"To suppose, as the mystic does, that the finite search has of +itself no Being at all, is illusory, is Maya, is itself nothing, +this is also to deprive the Absolute of even its poor value as a +contrasting goal. For a goal that is a goal of no real process has +as little value as it has content."[23] But, as Prof. Royce says, +mysticism furnishes us with the means of correcting itself. It +supplies an obvious reductio ad absurdum of the theory with which it +set out, that "Immediacy is the one test of reality," and is itself +forced to give the world of diversity a real value as manifesting in +different degrees the nature of God. Those who are acquainted with +the sacred books of the East will recognise that here is the +decisive departure from real Pantheism. And it may be fairly claimed +for the German mystics that though their speculative teaching +sometimes seems to echo too ominously the apathetic detachment of +the Indian sage, their lives and example, and their practical +exhortations, preached a truer and a larger philosophy. Eckhart, as +we have seen, was a busy preacher as well as a keen student, and +some of the younger members of his school were even more occupied in +pastoral work. If the tree is to be judged by its fruits, mysticism +can give a very good account of itself to the Marthas as well as the +Marys of this world. + +Sect. 4. THE GERMAN MYSTICS AS GUIDES TO HOLINESS + +THIS little volume is a contribution to a "Library of Devotion," and +in the body of the work the reader will be seldom troubled by any +abstruse philosophising. I have thought it necessary to give, in +this Introduction, a short account of Eckhart's system, but the +extracts which follow are taken mainly from his successors, in whom +the speculative tendency is weaker and less original, while the +religious element is stronger and more attractive. It is, after all, +as guides to holiness that these mystics are chiefly important to +us. This side of their life's work can never be out of date, for the +deeper currents of human nature change but little; the language of +the heart is readily understood everywhere and at all times. The +differences between Catholic and Protestant are hardly felt in the +keen air of these high summits. It was Luther himself who discovered +the "Theologia Germanica" and said of it that, "next to the Bible +and St Augustine, no book hath ever come into my hands whence I have +learnt or would wish to learn more of what God and Christ and man +and all things are. I thank God that I have heard and found my God +in the German tongue, as I have not yet found Him in Latin, Greek, +or Hebrew." The theology of these mystics takes us straight back to +the Johannine doctrine of Christ as the all-pervading Word of God, +by whom all things were made and in whom all things hold together. +He is not far from any one of us if we will but seek Him where He is +to be found--in the innermost sanctuary of our personal life. In +personal religion this means that no part of revelation is to be +regarded as past, isolated, or external. "We should mark and know of +a very truth," says the author of the "Theologia Germanica," "that +all manner of virtue and goodness, and even the eternal Good which +is God Himself, can never make a man virtuous, good, or happy, so +long as it is outside the soul." In the same spirit Jacob Bhme, 250 +years later, says: "If the sacrifice of Christ is to avail for me, +it must be wrought in me." Or, as his English admirer, William Law, +puts it: "Christ given for us is neither more nor less than Christ +given into us. He is in no other sense our full, perfect, and +sufficient Atonement than as His nature and spirit are born and +formed in us." The whole process of redemption must in a sense be +reenacted in the inner life of every Christian. And as Christ +emptied Himself for our sakes, so must we empty ourselves of all +self-seeking. "When the creature claimeth for its own anything good, +such as life, knowledge, or power, and in short whatever we commonly +call good, as if it were that, or possessed that--it goeth astray." +Sin is nothing else but self-assertion, self-will. "Be assured," +says the "Theologia Germanica," "that he who helpeth a man to his +own will, helpeth him to the worst that he can." He, therefore, who +is "simply and wholly bereft of self" is delivered from sin, and God +alone reigns in his inmost soul. Concerning the highest part or +faculty of the soul, the author of this little treatise follows +Eckhart, but cautiously. "The True Light," he says, "is that eternal +Light which is God; or else it is a created light, but yet Divine, +which is called grace." In either case, "where God dwells in a godly +man, in such a man somewhat appertaineth to God which is His own, +and belongs to Him only and not to the creature." This doctrine of +divine immanence, for which there is ample warrant in the New +Testament, is the real kernel of German mysticism. It is a doctrine +which, when rightly used, may make this world a foretaste of heaven, +but alas! the "False Light" is always trying to counterfeit the +true. In the imitation of the suffering life of Christ lies the only +means of escaping the deceptions of the Evil One. "The False Light +dreameth itself to be God, and sinless"; but "none is without sin; +if any is without consciousness of sin, he must be either Christ or +the Evil Spirit." + +Very characteristic is the teaching of all these writers about +rewards and punishments. Without in any way impugning the Church +doctrine of future retribution, they yet agree with Benjamin +Whichcote, the Cambridge Platonist, that "heaven is first a temper, +then a place"; while of hell there is much to recall the noble +sentence of Juliana of Norwich, the fourteenth-century visionary, +"to me was showed no harder hell than sin." "Nothing burneth in hell +but self-will," is a saying in the "Theologia Germanica."[24] They +insist that the difference between heaven and hell is not that one +is a place of enjoyment, the other of torment; it is that in the one +we are with Christ, in the other without Him. "The Christlike life +is not chosen," to quote the "Theologia Germanica" once more, "in +order to serve any end, or to get anything by it, but for love of +its nobleness, and because God loveth and esteemeth it so highly. He +who doth not take it up for love, hath none of it at all; he may +dream indeed that he hath put it on, but he is deceived. Christ did +not lead such a life as this for the sake of reward, but out of +love, and love maketh such a life light, and taketh away all its +hardships, so that it becometh sweet and is gladly endured." The +truly religious man is always more concerned about what God will do +in him than what He will do to him; in his intense desire for the +purification of his motives he almost wishes that heaven and hell +were blotted out, that he might serve God for Himself alone. + +Sect. 5. WRITERS OF THE SCHOOL OF ECKHART--TAULER + +Such are the main characteristics of the religious teachings which +we find in the German mystics. Among the successors of Eckhart, from +whose writings the following extracts are taken, the most notable +names are those of Tauler, Suso, and Ruysbroek. From Tauler I have +taken very little, because a volume of selections from his sermons +has already appeared in this series.[25] Accordingly, it will only +be necessary to mention a very few facts about his life. + +John Tauler was born at Strassburg about 1300, and studied at the +Dominican convents of Strassburg and Cologne. At both places he +doubtless heard the sermons of Eckhart. In 1329 the great interdict +began at Strassburg, and was stoutly resisted by many of the clergy. +It is a disputed point whether Tauler himself obeyed the Papal +decree or not. His uneventful life, which was devoted to study, +preaching, and pastoral work, came to an end in 1361. Like Eckhart, +he had a favourite "spiritual daughter," Margaret Ebner, who won a +great reputation as a visionary. + +Sect. 6. SUSO + +Henry Suso was born in 1295 and died in 1365. His autobiography was +published not long before his death. He is the poet of the band. The +romance of saintship is depicted by him with a strange vividness +which alternately attracts and repels, or even disgusts, the modern +reader. The whole-hearted devotion of the "Servitor" to the "Divine +Wisdom," the tender beauty of the visions and conversations, and the +occasional navet of the narrative, which shows that the saint +remained very human throughout, make Suso's books delightful +reading; but the accounts of the horrible macerations to which he +subjected himself for many years shock our moral sense almost as +much as our sensibilities; we do not now believe that God takes +pleasure in sufferings inflicted in His honour. Moreover, the erotic +symbolism of the visions is occasionally unpleasant: we are no +longer in the company of such sane and healthy people as Eckhart and +Tauler. The half-sensuous pleasure of ecstasy was evidently a +temptation to Suso, and the violent alternations of rapture and +misery which he experienced suggest a neurotic and ill-balanced +temperament.[26] + +On this subject--the pathological side of mysticism--a few remarks +will not be out of place, for there has been much discussion of it +lately. A great deal of nonsense has been written on the connexion +between religion and neuroticism. To quote Professor James' vigorous +protest, "medical materialism finishes up St Paul by calling his +vision on the road to Damascus a discharging lesion of the occipital +cortex, he being an epileptic. It snuffs out St Teresa as an +hysteric, St Francis of Assisi as an hereditary degenerate. George +Fox's discontent with the shams of his age, and his pining for +spiritual veracity, it treats as a symptom of a disordered colon. +Carlyle's organ-tones of misery it accounts for by a gastro-duodenal +catarrh. All such mental over-tensions, it says, are, when you come +to the bottom of the matter, mere affairs of diathesis +(auto-intoxications most probably), due to the perverted action of +various glands which physiology will yet discover."[27] Now, even if +it were true that most religious geniuses, like most other geniuses, +have been "psychopaths" of one kind or another, this fact in no way +disposes of the value of their intuitions and experiences. Nearly +all the great benefactors of humanity have been persons of +one-sided, and therefore ill-balanced, characters. Even Maudsley +admits that "Nature may find an incomplete mind a more suitable +instrument for a particular purpose. It is the work that is done, +and the quality in the worker by which it is done, that is alone of +moment; and it may be no great matter from a cosmical standpoint, if +in other qualities of character he (the genius) was singularly +defective."[28] Except in the character of our Lord Himself, there +are visible imperfections in the record of every great saint; but +that is no reason for allowing such traces of human infirmity to +discredit what is pure and good in their work. More particularly, it +would be a great pity to let our minds dwell on the favourite +materialistic theory that saintliness, especially as cultivated and +venerated by Catholicism, has its basis in "perverted sexuality." +There is enough plausibility in the theory to make it mischievous. +The allegorical interpretation of the Book of Canticles was in truth +the source of, or at least the model for, a vast amount of +unwholesome and repulsive pietism. Not a word need be said for such +a paltry narrative of endearments and sickly compliments as the +"Revelations of the Nun Gertrude," in the thirteenth century. Nor +are we concerned to deny that the artificially induced ecstasy, +which is desired on account of the intense pleasure which is said to +accompany it, nearly always contains elements the recognition of +which would shock and distress the contemplatives themselves.[29] +There are, however, other elements, of a less insidious kind, which +make the ecstatic trance seem desirable. These are, according to +Professor Leuba, the calming of the restless intellect by the +concentration of the mind on one object; the longing for a support +and comfort more perfect than man can give; and, thirdly, the +consecration and strengthening of the will, which is often a +permanent effect of the trance. These are legitimate objects of +desire, and in many of the mystics they are much more prominent than +any tendencies which might be considered morbid. As regards the +larger question, about the alleged pathological character of all +distinctively religious exaltation, I believe that no greater +mistake could be made than to suppose that the religious life +flourishes best in unnatural circumstances. Religion, from a +biological standpoint, I take to be the expression of the racial +will to live; its function (from this point of view) is the +preservation and development of humanity on the highest possible +level. If this is true, a simple, healthy, natural life must be the +most favourable for religious excellence--and this I believe to be +the case. Poor Suso certainly did not lead a healthy or natural +life. But in his case, though the suppressed natural instincts +obviously overflow into the religious consciousness and in part +determine the forms which his devotion assumes, we can never forget +that we are in the company of a poet and a saint who will lift us, +if we can follow him, into a very high region of the spiritual life, +an altitude which he has himself climbed with bleeding feet. + +The simple confidence which at the end of the dialogue he expresses +in the value of his work is, I think, amply justified. "Whoever will +read these writings of mine in a right spirit, can hardly fail to be +stirred to the depths of his soul, either to fervent love, or to new +light, or to hunger and thirst for God, or to hatred and loathing +for his sins, or to that spiritual aspiration by which the soul is +renewed in grace." + +Sect. 7. RUYSBROEK + +[Note: the Ruysbroek selection has not been reproduced in this +electronic edition. An electronic text of a larger collection of +Ruysbroek's works may be available.] + +Sect. 8. THEOLOGIA GERMANICA + +The "Theologia Germanica," an isolated treatise of no great length +by an unknown author, was written towards the end of the fourteenth +century by one of the Gottesfreunde, a widespread association of +pious souls in Germany. He is said to have been "a priest and warden +of the house of the Teutonic Order at Frankfort." His book is both +the latest and one of the most important productions of the German +mystical school founded by Eckhart. The author is a deeply religious +philosopher, as much interested in speculative mysticism as Eckhart +himself, but as thoroughly penetrated with devout feeling as Thomas + Kempis. The treatise should be read by all, as one of the very +best devotional works in any language. My only reason for not +translating it in full here is that a good English translation +already exists,[30] so that it seemed unnecessary to offer a new one +to the public. I have therefore only translated a few characteristic +passages, which are very far from exhausting its beauties, and a few +of the more striking aphorisms, which indicate the main points in +the religious philosophy of the writer. + +Sect. 9. MODERN MYSTICISM + +The revival of interest in the old mystical writers is not +surprising when we consider the whole trend of modern thought. Among +recent philosophers--though Lotze, perhaps the greatest name among +them, is unsympathetic, in consequence of his over-rigid theory of +personality--the great psychologist Fechner, whose religious +philosophy is not so well known in this country as it deserves to +be, has with some justice been called a mystic. And our own greatest +living metaphysician, Mr F.H. Bradley, has expounded the dialectic +of speculative mysticism with unequalled power, though with a bias +against Christianity. Another significant fact is the great +popularity, all over Europe, of Maeterlinck's mystical works, "Le +Trsor des Humbles," "La Sagesse et la Destine," and "Le +Temple Enseveli." + +The growing science of psychology has begun to turn its attention +seriously to the study of the religious faculty. Several able men +have set themselves to collect material which may form the basis of +an inductive science. Personal experiences, communicated by many +persons of both sexes and of various ages, occupations, and levels +of culture, have been brought together and tabulated. It is claimed +that important facts have already been established, particularly in +connexion with the phenomena of conversion, by this method. The +results have certainly been more than enough to justify confidence +in the soundness of the method, and hope that the new science may +have a great future before it. Towards mysticism, recent writers on +the psychology of religion have been less favourable than the pure +metaphysicians. While the latter have shown a tendency towards +Pantheism and Determinism, which makes them sympathise with the +general trend of speculative mysticism, psychology seems just at +present to lean towards a pluralistic metaphysic and a belief in +free-will or even in chance. This attitude is especially noticeable +in the now famous Gifford Lectures of Professor William James[31] +and in the recent volume of essays written at Oxford.[32] But even +if the rising tide of neo-Kantianism should cause the speculative +mystics to be regarded with disfavour, nothing can prevent the +religion of the twentieth century from being mystical in type. The +strongest wish of a vast number of earnest men and women to-day is +for a basis of religious belief which shall rest, not upon tradition +or external authority or historical evidence, but upon the +ascertainable facts of human experience. The craving for immediacy, +which we have seen to be characteristic of all mysticism, now takes +the form of a desire to establish the validity of the +God-consciousness as a normal part of the healthy inner life. We may +perhaps venture to predict that the Christian biologist of the +future will turn the Pauline Christology into his own dialect +somewhat after the following fashion:--"The function of religion in +the human race is closely analogous to, if not identical with, that +of instinct in the lower animals. Religion is the racial will to +live; not, however, to live anyhow and at all costs, but to live as +human beings, conforming as far as possible to the highest type of +humanity. Religion, therefore, acts as a higher instinct, inhibiting +all self-destroying and race-destroying impulses in the interest of +a larger self than the individual life." To turn this statement into +theological form it is only necessary to claim that the "perfect +man" which the religious instinct is trying to form is "the measure +of the stature of the fulness of Christ," that that perfect humanity +was once realised in the historical Christ, and that the higher +instinct within us--ourselves, yet not ourselves--which makes for +life and righteousness, and is the source of all the good that we +can think, say, or do, may (in virtue of that historical +incarnation) be justly called the indwelling Christ. This is all +that the Christian mystic needs. + +Sect. 10. SPECIMENS OF MODERN MYSTICISM + +I conclude this introductory essay with a few extracts from recent +American books on the psychology of religion. It is interesting to +find some of the strangest experiences of the cloister reproduced +under the very different conditions of modern American life. The +quotations will serve to show how far Tauler and the "Theologia +Germanica" are from being out of date. + +"The thing which impressed me most" (says a correspondent of +Professor William James)[33] "was learning the fact that we must be +in absolutely constant relation or mental touch with that essence of +life which permeates all and which we call God. This is almost +unrecognisable unless we live into it ourselves actually--that is, +by a constant turning to the very innermost, deepest consciousness +of our real selves or of God in us, for illumination from within, +just as we turn to the sun for light, warmth, and invigoration +without. When you do this consciously, realising that to turn inward +to the light within you is to live in the presence of God or of your +Divine self, you soon discover the unreality of the objects to which +you have hitherto been turning and which have engrossed you +without." + +The next quotation comes from a small book by one of the "New +Thought" or "Mind Cure" school in America. The enormous sale of the +volume testifies to the popularity of the teaching which it +contains.[34] + +"Intuition is an inner spiritual sense through which man is opened +to the direct revelation and knowledge of God, the secret of nature +and life, and through which he is brought into conscious unity and +fellowship with God, and made to realise his own deific nature and +supremacy of being as the son of God. Spiritual supremacy and +illumination thus realised through the development and perfection of +intuition under divine inspiration gives the perfect inner vision +and direct insight into the character, properties, and purpose of +all things to which the attention and interest are directed. It is, +we repeat, a spiritual sense opening inwardly, as the physical +senses open outwardly; and because it has the capacity to perceive, +grasp, and know the truth at first hand, independent of all external +sources of information, we call it intuition. All inspired teaching +and spiritual revelations are based upon the recognition of this +spiritual faculty of the soul and its power to receive and +appropriate them. Conscious unity of man in spirit and purpose with +the Father, born out of his supreme desire and trust, opens his soul +through this inner sense to immediate aspiration and enlightenment +from the divine omniscience, and the co-operative energy of the +divine omnipotence, under which he becomes a seer and a master. On +this higher plane of realised spiritual life in the flesh the mind +acts with unfettered freedom and unbiassed vision, grasping truth at +first hand, independent of all external sources of information. +Approaching all beings and things from the divine side, they are +seen in the light of the divine omniscience.[35] God's purpose in +them, and so the truth concerning them, as it rests in the mind of +God, are thus revealed by direct illumination from the divine mind, +to which the soul is opened inwardly through this spiritual sense we +call intuition." + +The practice of meditation "without images," as the mediaeval +mystics called it, is specially recommended. "Many will receive +great help, and many will be entirely healed by a practice somewhat +after the following nature:--With a mind at peace, and with a heart +going out in love to all, go into the quiet of your own interior +self, holding the thought, I am one with the Infinite Spirit of +Life, the life of my life. I now open my body, in which disease has +gotten a foothold, I open it fully to the inflowing tide of this +infinite life, and it now, even now, is pouring in and coursing +through my body, and the healing process is going on." "If you would +find the highest, the fullest, and the richest life that not only +this world but that any world can know, then do away with the sense +of the separateness of your life from the life of God. Hold to the +thought of your oneness. In the degree that you do this, you will +find yourself realising it more and more, and as this life of +realisation is lived, you will find that no good thing will be +withheld, for all things are included in this."[36] + +This modern mysticism is very much entangled with theories about the +cure of bodily disease by suggestion; and it is fair to warn those +who are unacquainted with the books of this sect that they will find +much fantastic superstition mixed with a stimulating faith in the +inner light as the voice of God. + +But whatever may be the course of this particular movement there can +be no doubt that the Americans, like ourselves, are only at the +beginning of a great revival of mystical religion. The movement will +probably follow the same course as the mediaeval movement in +Germany, with which this little book is concerned. It will have its +philosophical supportees, who will press their speculation to the +verge of Pantheism, perhaps reviving the Logos-cosmology of the +Christian Alexandrians under the form of the pan-psychism of Lotze +and Fechner. It will have its evangelists like Tauler, who will +carry to our crowded town populations the glad tidings that the +kingdom of God is not here or there, but within the hearts of all +who will seek for it within them. It will assuredly attract some to +a life of solitary contemplation; while others, intellectually +weaker or less serious, will follow the various theosophical and +theurgical delusions which, from the days of Iamblichus downward, +have dogged the heels of mysticism. For the "False Light" against +which the "Theologia Germanica" warns us is as dangerous as ever; we +may even live to see some new "Brethren of the Free Spirit" turning +their liberty into a cloak of licentiousness. If so, the world will +soon whistle back the disciplinarian with his traditions of the +elders; prophesying will once more be suppressed and discredited, +and a new crystallising process will begin. But before that time +comes some changes may possibly take place in the external +proportions of Christian orthodoxy. The appearance of a vigorous +body of faith, standing firmly on its own feet, may even have the +effect of relegating to the sphere of pious opinion some tenets +which have hitherto "seemed to be pillars." + +For these periodical returns to the "fresh springs" of religion +never leave the tradition exactly where it was before. The German +movement of the fourteenth century made the Reformation inevitable, +and our own age may be inaugurating a change no less momentous, +which will restore in the twentieth century some of the features of +Apostolic Christianity. + + + + + + +LIGHT, LIFE AND LOVE + +ECKHART + + + + + +GOD + +GOD is nameless, for no man can either say or understand aught about +Him. If I say, God is good, it is not true; nay more; I am good, God +is not good. I may even say, I am better than God; for whatever is +good, may become better, and whatever may become better, may become +best. Now God is not good, for He cannot become better. And if He +cannot become better, He cannot become best, for these three things, +good, better, and best, are far from God, since He is above all. If +I also say, God is wise, it is not true; I am wiser than He. If I +also say, God is a Being, it is not true; He is transcendent Being +and superessential Nothingness. Concerning this St Augustine says: +the best thing that man can say about God is to be able to be silent +about Him, from the wisdom of his inner judgement. Therefore be +silent and prate not about God, for whenever thou dost prate about +God, thou liest, and committest sin. If thou wilt be without sin, +prate not about God. Thou canst understand nought about God, for He +is above all understanding. A master saith: If I had a God whom I +could understand, I would never hold Him to be God. (318)[37] + +God is not only a Father of all good things, as being their First +Cause and Creator, but He is also their Mother, since He remains +with the creatures which have from Him their being and existence, +and maintains them continually in their being. If God did not abide +with and in the creatures, they must necessarily have fallen back, +so soon as they were created, into the nothingness out of which they +were created. (610) + +REST ONLY IN GOD + +IF I had everything that I could desire, and my finger ached, I +should not have everything, for I should have a pain in my finger, +and so long as that remained, I should not enjoy full comfort. Bread +is comfortable for men, when they are hungry; but when they are +thirsty, they find no more comfort in bread than in a stone. So it +is with clothes, they are welcome to men, when they are cold; but +when they are too hot, clothes give them no comfort. And so it is +with all the creatures. The comfort which they promise is only on +the surface, like froth, and it always carries with it a want. But +God's comfort is clear and has nothing wanting: it is full and +complete, and God is constrained to give it thee, for He cannot +cease till He have given thee Himself. (300) + +It is only in God that are collected and united all the perfections, +which in the creatures are sundered and divided. (324) + +Yet all the fulness of the creatures can as little express God, as a +drop of water can express the sea. (173) + +GOD IS ALWAYS READY + +NO one ought to think that it is difficult to come to Him, though it +sounds difficult and is really difficult at the beginning, and in +separating oneself from and dying to all things. But when a man has +once entered upon it, no life is lighter or happier or more +desirable; for God is very zealous to be at all times with man, and +teaches him that He will bring him to Himself if man will but +follow. Man never desires anything so earnestly as God desires to +bring a man to Himself, that he may know Him. God is always ready, +but we are very unready; God is near to us, but we are far from Him; +God is within, but we are without; God is at home, but we are +strangers. The prophet saith: God guideth the redeemed through a +narrow way into the broad road, so that they come into the wide and +broad place; that is to say, into true freedom of the spirit, when +one has become a spirit with God. May God help us to follow this +course, that He may bring us to Himself. Amen. (223) + +GRACE + +THE masters say: That is young, which is near its beginning. +Intelligence is the youngest faculty in man: the first thing to +break out from the soul is intelligence, the next is will, the other +faculties follow. Now he saith: Young man, I say unto thee, arise. +The soul in itself is a simple work; what God works in the simple +light of the soul is more beautiful and more delightful than all the +other works which He works in all creatures. But foolish people take +evil for good and good for evil. But to him who rightly understands, +the one work which God works in the soul is better and nobler and +higher than all the world. Through that light comes grace. Grace +never comes in the intelligence or in the will. If it could come in +the intelligence or in the will, the intelligence and the will would +have to transcend themselves. On this a master says: There is +something secret about it; and thereby he means the spark of the +soul, which alone can apprehend God. The true union between God and +the soul takes place in the little spark, which is called the spirit +of the soul. Grace unites not to any work. It is an indwelling and a +living together of the soul in God. (255) + +Every gift of God makes the soul ready to receive a new gift, +greater than itself. (15) + +Yea, since God has never given any gift, in order that man might +rest in the possession of the gift, but gives every gift that He has +given in heaven and on earth, in order that He might be able to give +one gift, which is Himself, so with this gift of grace, and with all +His gifts He will make us ready for the one gift, which is Himself. +(569) + +No man is so boorish or stupid or awkward, that he cannot, by God's +grace, unite his will wholly and entirely with God's will. And +nothing more is necessary than that he should say with earnest +longing: O Lord, show me Thy dearest will, and strengthen me to do +it. And God does it, as sure as He lives, and gives him grace in +ever richer fulness, till he comes to perfection, as He gave to the +woman at Jacob's well. Look you, the most ignorant and the lowest of +you all can obtain this from God, before he leaves this church, yea, +before I finish this sermon, as sure as God lives and I am a man. +(187) + +O almighty and merciful Creator and good Lord, be merciful to me for +my poor sins, and help me that I may overcome all temptations and +shameful lusts, and may be able to avoid utterly, in thought and +deed, what Thou forbiddest, and give me grace to do and to hold all +that Thou hast commanded. Help me to believe, to hope, and to love, +and in every way to live as Thou willest, as much as Thou willest, +and what Thou willest. (415) + +THE WILL + +THEN is the will perfect, when it has gone out of itself, and is +formed in the will of God. The more this is so, the more perfect and +true is the will, and in such a will thou canst do all things. (553) + +SURRENDER OF THE WILL + +YOU should know, that that which God gives to those men who seek to +do His will with all their might, is the best. Of this thou mayest +be as sure, as thou art sure that God lives, that the very best must +necessarily be, and that in no other way could anything better +happen. Even if something else seems better, it would not be so good +for thee, for God wills this and not another way, and this way must +be the best for thee. Whether it be sickness or poverty or hunger or +thirst, or whatever it be, that God hangs over thee or does not hang +over thee--whatever God gives or gives not, that is all what is best +for thee; whether it be devotion or inwardness, or the lack of these +which grieves thee--only set thyself right in this, that thou +desirest the glory of God in all things, and then whatever He does +to thee, that is the best. + +Now thou mayest perchance say: How can I tell whether it is the will +of God or not? If it were not the will of God, it would not happen. +Thou couldst have neither sickness nor anything else unless God +willed it. But know that it is God's will that thou shouldst have so +much pleasure and satisfaction therein, that thou shouldst feel no +pain as pain; thou shouldst take it from God as the very best thing, +for it must of necessity be the very best thing for thee. Therefore +I may even wish for it and desire it, and nothing would become me +better than so to do. + +If there were a man whom I were particularly anxious to please, and +if I knew for certain that he liked me better in a grey cloak than +in any other, there is no doubt that however good another cloak +might be, I should be fonder of the grey than of all the rest. And +if there were anyone whom I would gladly please, I should do nothing +else in word or deed than what I knew that he liked. + +Ah, now consider how your love shows itself! If you loved God, of a +surety nothing would give you greater pleasure than what pleases Him +best, and that whereby His will may be most fully done. And, however +great thy pain or hardship may be, if thou hast not as great +pleasure in it as in comfort or fulness, it is wrong. + +We say every day in prayer to our Father, Thy will be done. And yet +when His will is done, we grumble at it, and find no pleasure in His +will. If our prayers were sincere, we should certainly think His +will, and what He does, to be the best, and that the very best had +happened to us. (134) + +Those who accept all that the Lord send, as the very best, remain +always in perfect peace, for in them God's will has become their +will. This is incomparably better than for our will to become God's +will. For when thy will becomes God's will--if thou art sick, thou +wishest not to be well contrary to God's will, but thou wishest that +it were God's will that thou shouldest be well. And so in other +things. But when God's will becomes thy will--then thou art sick: in +God's name; thy friend dies: in God's name! (55) + +SUFFERING + +MEN who love God are so far from complaining of their sufferings, +that their complaint and their suffering is rather because the +suffering which God's will has assigned them is so small. All their +blessedness is to suffer by God's will, and not to have suffered +something, for this is the loss of suffering. This is why I said, +Blessed are they who are willing to suffer for righteousness, not, +Blessed are they who have suffered. (434) + +All that a man bears for God's sake, God makes light and sweet for +him. (45) + +If all was right with you, your sufferings would no longer be +suffering, but love and comfort. (442) + +If God could have given to men anything more noble than suffering, +He would have redeemed mankind with it: otherwise, you must say that +my Father was my enemy, if he knew of anything nobler than +suffering. (338) + +True suffering is a mother of all the virtues. (338) + +SIN + +DEADLY sin is a death of the soul. To die is to lose life. But God +is the life of the soul; since then deadly sin separates us from +God, it is a death of the soul. + +Deadly sin is also an unrest of the heart. Everything can rest only +in its proper place. But the natural place of the soul is God; as St +Augustine says, Lord, thou hast made us for Thyself, and our heart +is restless till it finds rest in Thee. But deadly sin separates us +from God; therefore it is an unrest of the heart. Deadly sin is also +a sickness of the faculties, when a man can never stand up alone for +the weight of his sins, nor ever resist falling into sin. Therefore +deadly sin is a sickness of the faculties. Deadly sin is also a +blindness of the sense, in that it suffers not a man to know the +shortness of the pleasures of lust, nor the length of the punishment +in hell, nor the eternity of joys in heaven. Deadly sin is also a +death of all graces; for as soon as a deadly sin takes place, a man +becomes bare of all graces. (217) + +Every creature must of necessity abide in God; if we fall out of the +hands of his mercy, we fall into the hands of His justice. We must +ever abide in Him. What madness then is it to wish not to be with +Him, without whom thou canst not be! (169) + +CONTENTMENT + +A GREAT teacher once told a story in his preaching about a man who +for eight years besought God to show him a man who would make known +to him the way of truth. While he was in this state of anxiety there +came a voice from God and spake to him: Go in front of the church, +and there shalt thou find a man who will make known to thee the way +of truth. He went, and found a poor man whose feet were chapped and +full of dirt, and all his clothes were hardly worth +twopence-halfpenny. He greeted this poor man and said to him, God +give thee a good morning. The poor man answered, I never had a bad +morning. The other said, God give thee happiness. How answerest thou +that? The poor man answered, I was never unhappy. The first then +said, God send thee blessedness. How answerest thou that? I was +never unblessed, was the answer. Lastly the questioner said, God +give thee health! Now enlighten me, for I cannot understand it. And +the poor man replied, When thou saidst to me, may God give thee a +good morning, I said I never had a bad morning. If I am hungry, I +praise God for it; if I am cold, I praise God for it; if I am +distressful and despised, I praise God for it; and that is why I +never had a bad morning. When thou askedst God to give me happiness, +I answered that I had never been unhappy; for what God gives or +ordains for me, whether it be His love or suffering, sour or sweet, +I take it all from God as being the best, and that is why I was +never unhappy. Thou saidst further, May God make thee blessed, and I +said, I was never unblessed, for I have given up my will so entirely +to God's will, that what God wills, that I also will, and that is +why I was never unblessed, because I willed alone God's will. Ah! +dear fellow, replied the man; but if God should will to throw thee +into hell, what wouldst thou say then? He replied, Throw me into +hell! Then I would resist Him. But even if He threw me into hell, I +should still have two arms wherewith to embrace Him. One arm is true +humility, which I should place under Him, and with the arm of love I +should embrace Him. And he concluded, I would rather be in hell and +possess God, than in the kingdom of heaven without Him. (623) + +DETACHMENT + +THE man who has submitted his will and purposes entirely to God, +carries God with him in all his works and in all circumstances. +Therein can no man hinder him, for he neither aims at nor enjoys +anything else, save God. God is united with Him in all his purposes +and designs. Even as no manifoldness can dissipate God, so nothing +can dissipate such a man, or destroy his unity. Man, therefore, +should take God with him in all things; God should be always present +to his mind and will and affections. The same disposition that thou +hast in church or in thy cell, thou shouldst keep and maintain in a +crowd, and amid the unrest and manifoldness of the world. + +Some people pride themselves on their detachment from mankind, and +are glad to be alone or in church; and therein lies their peace. But +he who is truly in the right state, is so in all circumstances, and +among all persons; he who is not in a good state, it is not right +with him in all places and among all persons. He who is as he should +be has God with him in truth, in all places and among all persons, +in the street as well as in the church; and then no man can hinder +him. (547) + +It is often much harder for a man to be alone in a crowd than in the +desert; and it is often harder to leave a small thing than a great, +and to practise a small work than one which people consider very +great. (565) + +PRAYER + +GOOD and earnest prayer is a golden ladder which reaches up to +heaven, and by which man ascends to God. + +The man who will pray aright should ask for nothing except what may +promote God's honour and glory, his own profit and the advantage of +his neighbours. When we ask for temporal things we should always +add, if it be God's will and if it be for my soul's health. But when +we pray for virtues, we need add no qualification, for these are +God's own working. (359) + +LOVE OF OUR NEIGHBOUR + +IT is a hard thing to practise this universal love, and to love our +neighbours as ourselves, as our Lord commanded us. But if you will +understand it rightly, there is a greater reward attached to this +command, than to any other. The commandment seems hard, but the +reward is precious indeed. (135) + +LOVE + +HE who has found this way of love, seeketh no other. He who turns on +this pivot is in such wise a prisoner that his foot and hand and +mouth and eyes and heart, and all his human faculties, belong to +God. And, therefore, thou canst overcome thy flesh in no better way, +so that it may not shame thee, than by love. This is why it is +written, Love is as strong as death, as hard as hell. Death +separates the soul from the body, but love separates all things from +the soul. She suffers nought to come near her, that is not God nor +God-like. Happy is he who is thus imprisoned; the more thou art a +prisoner, the more wilt thou be freed. That we may be so imprisoned, +and so freed, may He help us, Who Himself is Love. (30) + +THE UNION WITH GOD + +THE union of the soul with God is far more inward than that of the +soul and body. (566) + +Now I might ask, how stands it with the soul that is lost in God? +Does the soul find herself or not? To this will I answer as it +appears to me, that the soul finds herself in the point, where every +rational being understands itself with itself. Although it sinks and +sinks in the eternity of the Divine Essence, yet it can never reach +the ground. Therefore God has left a little point wherein the soul +turns back upon itself and finds itself, and knows itself to be a +creature. (387) + +God alone must work in thee without hindrance, that He may bring to +perfection His likeness in thee. So thou mayest understand with Him, +and love with Him. This is the essence of perfection. (471) + +THE LAST JUDGMENT + +PEOPLE say of the last day, that God shall give judgment. This is +true. But it is not true as people imagine. Every man pronounces his +own sentence; as he shows himself here in his essence, so will he +remain everlastingly. (471) + +PRECEPT AND PRACTICE + +BETTER one life-master than a thousand reading-masters (wger wre +ein lebemeister denne tsent lesemeister). If I sought a master +in the scriptures, I should seek him in Paris and in the high +schools of high learning. But if I wished to ask questions about the +perfect life, that he could not tell me. Where then must I go? +Nowhere at all save to an utterly simple nature; he could answer my +question. (599) + +RELICS + +MY people, why seek ye after dead bones? Why seek ye not after +living holiness, which might give you everlasting life? The dead can +neither give nor take away. (599) + +SAYINGS OF ECKHART + +MASTER ECKHART saith: He who is always alone, he is worthy of God; +and he who is always at home, to him is God present; and be who +abides always in a present now, in him doth God beget His Son +without ceasing. (600) + +Master Eckhart saith: I will never pray to God to give Himself to +me: I will pray Him to make me purer. If I were purer, God must give +Himself to me, of His own nature, and sink into me. (601) + +Master Eckhart was asked, what were the greatest goods, that God had +done to him. He said, there are three. The first is, that the lusts +and desires of the flesh have been taken away from me. The second +is, that the Divine Light shines and gives me light in all my +doings. The third is, that I am daily renewed in virtue, grace and +holiness. (602) + + + + + + +TAULER + + + + + +OUR AIM + +THINK, and think earnestly, how great, how unutterable will be the +joy and blessedness, the glory and honour of those who shall see +clearly and without veil the gladsome and beauteous face of God, how +they will enjoy the best and highest good, which is God Himself. For +in Him is included all pleasure, might, joy, and all beauty, so that +the blessed in God will possess everything that is good and +desirable, with everlasting joy and security, without fear lest they +should ever be parted from Him. (138)[38] + +CONSEQUENCES OF THE FALL + +FROM the time when the first man gave a ready ear to the words of +the enemy, mankind have been deaf, so that none of us can hear or +understand the loving utterances of the eternal Word. Something has +happened to the ears of man, which has stopped up his ears, so that +he cannot hear the loving Word; and he has also been so blinded, +that he has become stupid, and does not know himself. If he wished +to speak of his own inner life, he could not do it; he knows not +where he is, nor what is his state. (91) + +How can it be that the noble reason, the inner eye, is so blinded +that it cannot see the true light? This great shame has come about, +because a thick coarse skin and a thick fur has been drawn over him, +even the love and the opinion of the creatures, whether it be the +man himself or something that belongs to him; hence man has become +blind and deaf, in whatever position he may be, worldly or +spiritual. Yes, that is his guilt, that many a thick skin is drawn +over him, as thick as an ox's forehead, and it has so covered up his +inner man, that neither God nor himself can get inside; it has grown +into him. (92) + +THE FALL + +THROUGH two things man fell in Paradise--through pride, and through +inordinate affection. Therefore we too must return by two things, +that nature may recover her power: we must first sink our nature and +bring it down under God and under all men in deep humility, against +whom it had exalted itself in pride. We must also manfully die to +all inordinate lusts. (1) + +LIFE A BATTLE + +NOTHING in the world is so necessary for man as to be constantly +assailed; for in fighting he learns to know himself. As grace is +necessary to a man, so also is fighting. Virtue begins in fighting, +and is developed in fighting. In every state to which a man is +called, inward and outward, he must of necessity be assailed. A high +Master said: As little as meat can remain without salt and yet not +become corrupt, so little can a man remain without fighting. (104) + +A man should in the first place act as when a town is besieged, and +it is certain that the besieging army is stronger than the town. +When the town is weakest, men take the very greatest care to guard +and defend the town; if they neglected to do so, they would lose the +town, and with it their lives and properties. So should every man +do: he should be most careful to find out in what things the evil +spirit most often besets him--that is, on what side the man is +weakest, and to what kind of errors and failings he is most prone, +and should manfully defend himself at those points. + +Next, turn thyself earnestly away from sin; for I tell you of a +truth, by whatever temptation a man is assailed, if he turns not +from it heartily, but stands in it vacillating, he has no +wholehearted desire to leave his sins by God's will, and without +doubt the evil spirit is close upon him, who may make him fall into +endless perdition. + +Know of a truth, that if thou wouldst truly overcome the evil +spirit, this can only be done by a complete manful turning away from +sin. Say then with all thy heart: Oh, everlasting God, help me and +give me Thy Divine grace to be my help, for it is my steadfast +desire never again to commit any deadly sin against Thy Divine will +and Thine honour. So with thy good will and intention thou entirely +overcomest the evil spirit, so that he must fly from thee ashamed. + +Understand, however, that it is a miserable and pitiable thing for a +reasonable man to let himself be overcome by the evil spirit, and in +consequence of his attacks to fall voluntarily into grievous and +deadly sin, whereby man loses the grace of God. A reasonable man, +who allows himself voluntarily to be overcome by the evil spirit, is +like a well-armed man who voluntarily lets a fly bite him to death. +For man has many great and strong weapons, wherewith he may well and +manfully withstand the evil spirit--the holy faith, the blessed +sacrament, the holy word of God, the model and example of all good +and holy men, the prayers of holy Church, and other great supports +against the power of the evil spirit, whose power is much less than +that of a fly against a great bear. If a man will manfully and +boldly withstand the evil spirit, the evil one can gain no advantage +against his free will. + +Turn, therefore, manfully and earnestly from your sins, and watch +diligently and earnestly; for I tell you of a truth, that when you +have come to the next world, if you have not withstood the evil +spirit, and if you are found there without repentance and sorrow, +you will be a mockery to all the devils and to yourself, and you +will be eternally punished and tormented. And it will then be a +greater woe to you, that you have followed the evil spirit, than all +the external pains that you must endure eternally for your sins. + +Thirdly, a man should diligently attend to his inner Ground, that +there shall be nothing in it save God alone, and His eternal glory. +For alas! there are many men, both lay and clerical, who live +falsely beneath a fair show, and imagine that they can deceive the +everlasting God. No, in truth, thou deceivest thyself, and losest +the day of grace, and the favour of God, and makest thyself guilty +towards God, in that He gives the evil spirits power over thee, so +that thou canst do no good work. Therefore, watch while it is day, +that the hour of darkness and God's disfavour may not overtake thee, +and take heed that in thy inner ground God may dwell, and nought +besides. (75) + +Even as each man in his baptism is placed under the charge of a +special angel, who is with him always and never leaves him, and +protects him waking and sleeping in all his ways and in all his +works, so every man has a special devil, who continually opposes him +and exercises him without ceasing. But if the man were wise and +diligent, the opposition of the devil and his exercises would be +much more profitable to him than the aid of the good angel; for if +there were no struggle, there could be no victory. (139) + +SIN + +WHEN a man has had the fair net of his soul torn by sin, he must +patch and mend it by a humble, repentant return to the grace and +mercy of God. He must act like one who wishes to make a crooked +stick straight: he bends the stick further back than it ought to go, +and by being thus bent back it becomes straight again. So must a man +do to his own nature. He must bend himself under all things which +belong to God, and break himself right off, inwardly and outwardly, +from all things which are not God. + +Every deadly sin causes the precious blood of Christ to be shed +afresh. Jesus Christ is spiritually crucified many times every day. +(75) + +FISHING FOR SOULS + +THE fisherman throws his hook, that he may catch the fish; but the +fish itself takes the hook. When the fish takes the hook, the +fisherman is sure of the fish, and draws it to him. Even so, God has +thrown His hook and His net into all the world, before our feet, +before our eyes, before our minds, and He would gladly draw us +securely to Himself by means of all His creatures. By pleasurable +things He draws us on; by painful things He drives us on. He who +will not be drawn, is in fault; for he has not taken God's hook, nor +will he be caught in God's net. If he came therein, beyond doubt he +would be caught by God and would be drawn by God. It is not God's +fault if we will not be drawn; we should grasp the hand held out to +us. If a man were in a deep pool, and one tried to help him and pull +him out, would he not gladly grasp his hand and allow himself to be +pulled out? (42) + +Where two things are so related to each other, that one may receive +something for the other, there must be something in common between +them. If they had nothing in common, there must be a middle term +between them, which has something in common both with the higher, +from which it may receive, and with the lower, to which it may +impart. Now God hath created all things, and especially mankind, +immediately for Himself. He created man for His pleasure. But by +sin, human nature was so far estranged from God, that it was +impossible for a man to attain to that, for which he was made. Now +Aristotle says that God and Nature are not unprofitable +workers--that is, what they work at, they carry to its end. Now God +created man that He might have pleasure in him. If then God's work +in creating mankind was not to be unprofitable, when they were so +far estranged from God by sin, that they could not receive that by +which they might return and attain the enjoyment of eternal +happiness, a Mediator was necessary between us and God, one who has +something in common with us and our natures, and also shares in the +nature of God. In order that on the one side, He might in Himself +destroy our sickness, which was a cause of all our sins, and also +destroy all our sins, to which our weakness has brought us; and on +the other side that He might include in Himself all the treasure of +grace and of God's honour, that He might be able to give us grace +richly, and forgiveness of our sins, and eternal glory hereafter, +this could only be, if the Son of God became man. (90) + +Yea, the highest God and Lord of all lords, the Son of God, in His +deep love felt pity for us poor, sinful men, condemned to the flames +of hell. Though He was in the form of God, He thought it not robbery +(as St Paul says) to be equal with God, and He annihilated Himself, +and took upon Him the form of a servant, and was made like any other +man, being found in fashion as a man. He humbled Himself, and became +obedient unto death, even the death of the cross. (117) + +THE EFFICACY OF DIVINE GRACE + +ALL works which men and all creatures can ever work even to the end +of the world, without the grace of God--all of them together, +however great they may be, are an absolute nothing, as compared with +the smallest work which God has worked in men by His grace. As much +as God is better than all His creatures, so much better are His +works than all the works, or wisdom, or designs, which all men could +devise. Even the smallest drop of grace is better than all earthly +riches that are beneath the sun. Yea, a drop of grace is more noble +than all angels and all souls, and all the natural things that God +has made. And yet grace is given more richly by God to the soul than +any earthly gift. It is given more richly than brooks of water, than +the breath of the air, than the brightness of the sun; for spiritual +things are far finer and nobler than earthly things. The whole +Trinity, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, give grace to the soul, and +flow immediately into it; even the highest angel, in spite of his +great nobility, cannot do this. Grace looses us from the snares of +many temptations; it relieves us from the heavy burden of worldly +cares, and carries the spirit up to heaven, the land of spirits. It +kills the worm of conscience, which makes sins alive. Grace is a +very powerful thing. The man, to whom cometh but a little drop of +the light of grace, to him all that is not God becomes as bitter as +gall upon the tongue. (86) + +Grace makes, contrary to nature, all sorrows sweet, and brings it +about that a man no longer feels any relish for things which +formerly gave him great pleasure and delight. On the other hand, +what formerly disgusted him, now delights him and is the desire of +his heart--for instance, weakness, sorrow, inwardness, humility, +self-abandonment, and detachment from all the creatures. All this is +in the highest degree dear to him, when this visitation of the Holy +Ghost, grace, has in truth come to him. Then the sick man, that is +to say the external man, with all his faculties is plunged +completely into the pool of water, even as the sick man who had been +for thirty-eight years by the pool at Jerusalem, and there washes +himself thoroughly in the exalted, noble, precious blood of Christ +Jesus. For grace in manifold ways bathes the soul in the wounds and +blood of the holy Lamb, Jesus Christ. (22) + +PRAYER + +THE essence of prayer is the ascent of the mind to God, as holy +teachers tell us. Therefore every good man, when he wishes to pray, +ought to collect his outer senses into himself, and look into his +mind, to see whether it be really turned to God. He who wishes that +his prayers may be truly heard, must keep himself turned away from +all temporal and external things, and all that is not Divine, +whether it be friend or joy (Freund oder Freude), and all vanities, +whether they be clothes or ornaments, and from everything of which +God is not the true beginning and ending, and from everything that +does not belong to Him. He must cut off his words and his conduct, +his manners and his demeanour, from all irregularity, inward or +outward. Dream not that that can be a true prayer, when a man only +babbles outwardly with his mouth, and reads many psalms, gabbling +them rapidly and hastily, while his mind wanders this way and that, +backwards and forwards. Much rather must the true prayer be, as St +Peter tells us, "one-minded"[39]that is, the mind must cleave to +God alone, and a man must look with the face of his soul turned +directly towards God, with a gentle, willing dependence on Him. (80) + +If thy prayer has these conditions, thou mayst with true humility +fall at the feet of God, and pray for the gentle succour of God; +thou mayest knock at His fatherly heart, and ask for breadthat is, +for love. If a man had all the food in the world, and had not bread, +his food would be neither eatable, nor pleasant, nor useful. So it +is with all things, without the Love of God. Knock also at the door +through which we must go--namely, Christ Jesus. At this door, the +praying man must knock for three ends, if he wishes to be really +admitted. First he must knock devoutly, at the broken heart and the +open side, and enter in with all devotion, and in recognition of his +unfathomable poverty and nothingness, as poor Lazarus did at the +rich man's gate, and ask for crumbs of His grace. Then again, he +should knock at the door of the holy open wounds of His holy hands, +and pray for true Divine knowledge, that it may enlighten him and +exalt him. Finally, knock at the door of His holy feet, and pray for +true Divine love, which may unite thee with Him, and immerse and +cover thee in Him. (57) + + + + + + +MEDITATIONS ON THE SEVEN WORDS FROM THE CROSS + + + + + +[From a devotional treatise on the Passion of Christ, published in a +Latin translation, by Surius, in 1548, and wrongly ascribed by him +to Tauler. The author was an unknown German of the fourteenth +century.] + +THE FIRST WORD + +NOW, O my soul, and all ye who have been redeemed by the precious +blood of Christ, come, and let us go with inward compassion and +fervent devotion to the blessed palm-tree of the Cross, which is +laden with the fairest fruit. Let us pass like the bee from flower +to flower, for all are full of honey. Let us consider and ponder +with the greatest care the sacred words of Christ, which He spoke +upon the Cross; for everything that comes From this blessed Tree is +wholesome and good. In the Cross of our Lord and Saviour are centred +all our salvation, all our health, all our life, all our glory; and, +"if we suffer with Him," saith the Apostle, "we shall also reign +with Him." That we may not be found ungrateful for these inestimable +benefits, let us call upon heaven and earth, and all that in them +is, to join us in praising and blessing and giving thanks to God. +Let us invite them to come and look upon this wondrous sight, and +say: "Magnify the Lord with me, for He hath done marvellous things. +O praise and bless the Lord with me, for great is His mercy toward +us." Come up with me, I pray you, ye angelic spirits, to Mount +Calvary, and see your King Solomon on His throne, wearing the diadem +wherewith His mother has crowned Him. Let us weep in the presence of +the Lord who made us, the Lord our God. O all mankind, and all ye +who are members of Christ, behold your Redeemer as He hangs on high; +behold and weep. See if any sorrow is like unto His sorrow. +Acknowledge the heinousness of your sins, which needed such +satisfaction. Go to every part of His body; you will find only +wounds and blood. Cry to Him with lamentations and say, "O Jesus, +our redemption, our love, our desire, what mercy has overcome Thee, +that Thou shouldest bear our sins, and endure a cruel death, to +rescue us from everlasting death?" And Thou, O God, the almighty +Father of heaven, look down from Thy sanctuary upon Thine innocent +Son Joseph, sold and given over unjustly to the hands of bloody men, +to suffer a shameful death. See whether this be Thy Son's coat or +not. Of a truth an evil beast hath devoured Him. The blood of our +sins is sprinkled over His garments, and all the coverings of His +good name are defiled by it. See how Thy holy Child has been +condemned with the wicked, how Thy royal Son has been crowned with +thorns. Behold His innocent hands, which have known no sin, dripping +with blood; behold His sacred feet, which have never turned aside +from the path of justice, pierced through by a cruel nail; behold +His defenceless side smitten with a sharp spear; behold His fair +face, which the angels desire to look upon, marred and shorn of all +its beauty; behold His blessed heart, which no impure thought ever +stained, weighed down with inward sorrow. Behold, O loving Father, +Thy sweet Son, stretched out upon the harp of the Cross, and harping +blessings on Thee with all His members. Wherefore, O my God, I pray +Thee to forgive me, for the sake of Thy Son's Passion, all the sins +that I have committed in my members. O merciful Father, look on Thy +only-begotten Son, that Thou mayst have compassion on Thy servant. +Whenever that red blood of Thy Son speaks in Thy sight, do Thou wash +me from every stain of sin. Whenever Thou beholdest the wounds of +this Thy Son, open to me the bosom of Thy fatherly compassion. +Behold, O tender Father, how Thy obedient Son does not cry, "Bind my +hands and my feet, that I may not rebel against Thee," but how of +His own will He extends His hands and feet, and gladly allows them +to be pierced with nails. Look down, I pray Thee, not on the brazen +serpent hanging on a pole for the salvation of Israel, but on Thine +only Son hanging on the Cross for the salvation of all men. It is +not Moses who now stretches out his hand to heaven, that the thunder +and lightning and the other plagues may cease, but it is Thy beloved +Son, who lovingly stretches out His bleeding arms to Thee, that Thy +wrath may depart from the human race. Aaron and Hur are not now +holding up the hands of Moses that he may pray more unweariedly for +Israel; but hard and cruel nails have fastened the hands of Thy only +Son to the Cross, that He may wait with long-suffering for our +repentance, and receive us back into His grace, and that He may not +turn away in wrath from our prayers. This is that faithful David, +who now strings tight the harp-strings of His body, and makes sweet +melody before Thee, singing to Thee the sweetest song that has been +ever sung to Thee: "Father forgive them, for they know not what they +do." This is that High Priest, who by His own blood has entered into +the Holy of Holies, to offer Himself as a peace-offering for the +sins of the whole world. This is that innocent Lamb, who has washed +us in His own precious blood, who, Himself without spot of sin, has +taken away the sins of the world. Therefore from the storehouse of +His Passion I borrow the price of my debt, and I count out before +Thee all its merits, to pay what I owe Thee. For He has done all in +my nature, and for my sake. O merciful Father, if Thou weighest all +my sins on one side of the balance, and in the other scale the +Passion of Thy Son, the last will outweigh the first. For what sin +can be so great, that the innocent blood of Thy Son has not washed +it out? What pride, or disobedience, or lust, is so unchecked or so +rebellious, that such lowliness, obedience, and poverty cannot +abolish it? O merciful Father, accept the deeds of Thy beloved Son, +and forgive the errors of Thy wicked servant. For the innocent blood +of our brother Abel crieth to Thee from the Cross, not for +vengeance, but for grace and mercy, saying, "Father, forgive them, +for they know not what they do." + +THE SECOND WORD + +NOW the thieves who were crucified with Jesus reviled Him. But after +a while, the one who hung on the right side of Christ, when he saw +His great patience and long-suffering, wherewith He so lovingly +prayed to His Father for those who cast reproaches upon Him and +cruelly tortured Him, became entirely changed, and began to be moved +with very great sorrow and repentance for his sins. And he showed +this outwardly, when he rebuked his fellow-thief, who continued to +revile Christ, saying: "Dost not thou fear God, seeing thou art in +the same condemnation?" "Although" (he would say) "thou art so +obstinate as not to fear men, and thinkest nought of thy bodily +pain, yet surely thou must fear God, in the last moments of thy +life--God, who hath power to destroy both thy body and soul in hell. +And though we suffer the same punishment with Him, our deserts are +very different. We, indeed, suffer justly, for we receive the due +reward of our deeds, but this man hath done nothing amiss." He, who +but lately was a blasphemer, is now a confessor and preacher, he +distinguishes good from evil, blaming the sinner, and excusing the +innocent: the unbelieving thief has become the confessor of almighty +God. O good Jesus, this sudden change is wrought by Thy right hand, +at which he hung. Thy right hand touched him inwardly, and forthwith +he is changed into another man. O Lord, in this Thou hast declared +Thy patience, out of a stone Thou hast raised up a child unto +Abraham. Verily, the penitent thief received the light of faith +solely from that bright light on the candlestick of the Cross, which +shone there in the darkness and scattered the shades of night. But +what does this signify, save that our Lord Jesus, out of the +greatness of His goodness, looked upon him with the eyes of His +mercy, although He found no merit in him, except what it pleased Him +out of His goodness to bestow? For as God gives to His elect, out of +His goodness alone, what no one has a right to demand, so out of His +justice He gives to the wicked what they deserve. For this cause +David says: "He saved me because He desired me." And this is why the +thief, before the Lord touched his heart with the beams of His grace +and love, joined the other thief in reviling Christ, thus showing +first what his own character was, and afterwards what was wrought in +him by grace. At first he acted like the other, being, like him, a +child of wrath; but when the precious blood of Christ was shed as +the price of our redemption and paid to the Father for our debt, +then the thief asked God to give him an alms for his good, and at +once received it. For how can one alms diminish that inexhaustible +treasure? How could our tender Lord, whose property is always to +have mercy, have refused his request? Indeed He gave him more than +he asked. Yet how could the thief escape the glow of the fire which +was burning so near him? Truly this was the fire, which the Father +had sent down from heaven to earth, which had long smouldered, but +now, kindled anew, and fed by the wood of the Cross, and sprinkled +with the oil of mercy, and fanned, as it were, by the reproaches and +blasphemies of the Jews, sent up its flames to heaven, by which that +thief was quite kindled and set on fire, and his love became as +strong as death, so that he said: "I indeed suffer no grievous +penalty, for it is less than I deserve; but that this innocent One, +who has done no wrong, should be so tortured, contrary to justice +and righteousness, this, truly, adds grievous sorrow to my sorrow." +O splendid faith of this thief! He contemned all the punishment that +might be inflicted on him: he feared not the rage of the people, who +were barking like mad dogs against Jesus: he cared not for the chief +priests: he feared not the executioners with their weapons and +instruments of torture; but in the presence of them all, with a +fearless heart he confessed that Christ was the true Son of God, and +Lord of the whole world: and at the same time he confounded the Jews +by confessing that He had done nothing amiss, and therefore that +they had crucified Him unjustly. O wondrous faith! O mighty +constancy! O amazing love of this poor thief, love that cast out all +fear! He was indeed well drunken with that new wine which in the +wine-press of the Cross had been pressed out of that sweet cluster, +Jesus Christ, and therefore he confessed Christ without shame before +all the people. At the very beginning of the Passion, the apostles +and disciples had forsaken Christ and fled; even St Peter, +frightened by the voice of one maidservant, had denied Christ. But +this poor thief did not forsake Him even in death, but confessed Him +to be the Lord of heaven in the presence of all those armed men. Who +can do justice to the merits of this man? Who taught him so quickly +that faith of his, and his clear knowledge of all the virtues, save +the very Wisdom of the Father, Jesus Christ, who hung near him on +the Cross? Him whom the Jews could not or would not know, in spite +of the promises made to the patriarchs, the fulfilment of +prophecies, the teaching of the Scriptures, and the interpretation +of allegories, this poor thief learned to know by repentance. He +confessed Christ to be the Son of God, though he saw Him full of +misery, want, and torment, and dying from natural weakness. He +confessed Him at a time when the apostles, who had seen His mighty +works, denied Him. The nails were holding his hands and feet fixed +to the cross; he had nothing free about him, except his heart and +his tongue; yet he gave to God all that he could give to Him, and, +in the words of Scripture, "with his heart he believed unto +righteousness, and with his tongue he made confession of Christ unto +salvation." O infinite and unsearchable mercy of God! For what +manner of man was he when he was sent to the cross, and what when he +left it? (Not that it was his own cross, that wrought this change, +but the power of Christ crucified.) He came to the cross stained +with the blood of his fellow-man; he was taken down from it cleansed +by the blood of Christ. He came to the cross still savage and full +of rage, and while he was upon it he became so meek and pitiful that +he lamented for the sufferings of another more than for his own. One +member only was left to him, and at the eleventh hour he came to +work in God's vineyard, and yet so eagerly did he labour that he was +the first to finish his work and receive his reward. Indeed he +behaved like a just man; for he first accused himself and confessed +his sins, saying, "and we, indeed, justly, for we receive the due +reward of our deeds." Secondly, he excused Christ, and confessed +that He was the Just One when he said "but this Man hath done +nothing amiss." Thirdly, he showed brotherly love, for he said, +"dost not thou fear God?" Fourthly, with all his members, or at +least with all that he could offer, and with loving eyes and a +devout heart and a humble spirit, he turned himself to Christ and +prayed earnestly, "Lord, remember me when Thou comest into Thy +Kingdom." How great was the justice and humility and resignation +which he showed in this prayer, for he asked only for a little +remembrance of himself, acknowledging that he was not worthy to ask +for anything great. Nor did he pray for the safety of his body, for +he gladly desired to die for his sins. It was more pleasant for him +to die with Christ than to live any longer. Nor did he pray that our +Lord would deliver him from the pains of hell, or of purgatory, nor +did he ask for the kingdom of heaven; but he resigned himself +entirely to the will of God, and offered himself altogether to +Christ, to do what He would with him. In his humility he prayed for +nothing except for grace and mercy, for which David also prayed when +he said, "Deal with Thy servant according to Thy mercy." And +therefore, because he had prayed humbly and wisely, the Eternal +Wisdom, Who reads the hearts of all who pray, heard his prayer, and, +opening wide the rich storehouse of His grace, bestowed upon him +much more than he had dared to ask. O marvellous goodness of God! +How plainly dost Thou declare in this, that Thou desirest not the +death of a sinner, but rather that he should be converted and live. +Now Thou hast manifested and fulfilled what Thou didst promise +aforetime by Thy prophet: "When the wicked man shall mourn for his +sins, I will remember his iniquity no more." Thou didst not impose +upon him many years of severe penance, nor many sufferings in +purgatory for the expiation of his sins; but just as if Thou hadst +quite forgotten his crimes, and couldst see nothing in him but +virtue, Thou didst say: "This day shalt thou be with Me in +paradise." O immeasurable compassion of God! Our tender Lord forgot +all the countless crimes which that poor thief had done, and forgave +him when he repented, and gave so great and splendid a reward to the +good which there was in him, small indeed though it was. Our loving +God is very rich; He needs not our gifts; but He seeks for a heart +which turns to Him with lowliness and resignation, such a heart as +He found in this poor thief. For He says Himself: "turn to Me, and I +will turn to you." And so when this thief so courageously and +effectively turned to God, his prayer was at once not only accepted +but answered. For our Lord did not reject his prayer, or say to him: +"See how I hang here in torment, and I behold before My eyes My +mother in sore affliction, and I have not yet spoken one word to +her, so that to hear thee now would not be just." No, our Lord said +nothing of this kind to the thief. Rather, He heard his prayer at +once, and made answer in that sweet word, "Amen, I say unto thee, +this day shalt thou be with Me in paradise." O tender goodness, O +marvellous mercy of God! O great wisdom of the thief! He saw that +the treasures of Christ were wide open, and were being scattered +abroad. Who then should forbid him to take as much as would pay what +he owed to his Lord? And O the accursed hardness of the impenitent +thief, whom neither the rebuke of his associate, nor the patience of +Christ, nor the many signs of love and mercy that shone forth in +Christ, could melt or convert! He saw that alms were plentiful at +the rich man's gate, that more was given than was asked for, and yet +he was too proud and obstinate to ask. He saw that life and the +kingdom of heaven were being granted, and yet he would not bend his +heart to wish for them: therefore he shall not have them. He loved +better revilings and curses, and they shall come unto him, and that +for all eternity. These new first-fruits of the grape, which our +Lord gathered on the wood of the Cross from our barren soil, by much +sweat of His brow and much watering with His own precious blood, He +sent with great joy as a precious gift to His heavenly Father, by +His celestial messengers the holy angels. But if there is joy among +the angels of God over one sinner that repenteth, how must they +rejoice and exult at the salvation of this thief, of whom they had +almost despaired? We can picture to ourselves with what joy the +Father of heaven received these first-fruits of the harvest of His +Son's Passion. But Christ Himself, though He felt some joy at the +thief's conversion, was still more afflicted thereby, for by His +wisdom He foresaw that this thief would be the cause of perdition to +many, who would resolve to pass their whole lives in sin, hoping to +obtain pardon and grace at the moment of death. Truly a most foolish +hope, for nowhere in the Scriptures do we read that it has so +happened to any man. In truth, they who seek after God only when +they must, will not, it is to be feared, find Him near them in their +time of need. In the meantime, none can trust too much in God, and +no one has ever been forsaken by Him, who has turned to Him with his +whole heart, and leant upon Him with loving confidence. + +THE THIRD WORD + +THERE stood also by the Cross of Jesus His most holy and ever-virgin +mother Mary; not in order that His sufferings might thereby be +lessened, but that they might be greatly augmented. For if any +creature could have given consolation to the Lord while He hung on +the Cross, no one could have done it so fitly as His blessed mother. +But since it was God's will that Christ should die the most bitter +of deaths, and end His Passion without any comfort or relief, but +with true resignation, His mother's presence brought Him no +consolation, but rather added to His sufferings, for her sufferings +were thereby added to His, and this added yet more to His +affliction. Who then, O good Jesus can discover by meditation how +great was Thy inward grief, for Thou knowest the hearts of all, when +Thou sawest all the body of Thy holy mother tortured by inward +compassion, even as Thou wast tortured on the Cross, and her tender +heart and maternal breast pierced with the sword of sharp sorrow, +her face pale as death, telling the anguish of her soul, and almost +dead, yet unable to die. When Thou beheldest her hot tears, flowing +down abundantly like sweet rivers upon her gracious cheeks, and over +all her face, all witnesses to Thee that she shared in Thy sorrow +and love; when Thou heardest her sad laments, forced from her by the +weight of her affliction; when Thou sawest that same tender mother, +melted away with the heat of love, her strength quite failing her, +worn out and exhausted by the pains of Thy Passion, which wasted her +away; all this, truly, was a new affliction to Thee on the Cross; it +was itself a new Cross. For Thou alone, by the spear of, Thy pity, +didst explore the weight and grievousness of her woes, which to men +are beyond comprehension. All this, indeed, greatly increased the +pain of Thy Passion, because Thou wast crucified not only in Thy own +body, but in Thy mother's heart; for her Cross was Thy Cross, and +Thine was hers. O how bitter was Thy Passion, sweet Jesus! Great +indeed was Thy outward suffering, but far more grievous was Thy +inward suffering, which Thy heart experienced at Thy mother's +anguish. It was now, beyond doubt, that the sword of sorrow pierced +her through, for the queen of martyrs was terribly and mortally +wounded in that part which is impassible--that is, the soul; she +bore the death of the Cross in that part which could not die, +suffering all the more her grievous inward death, as outward death +departed further from her. Who, O most loving mother, can recount or +conceive in his mind the immeasurable sorrows of thy soul, or thine +inward woes? Him whom thou didst bring forth without pain, as a +blessed mother free from the curse of our first mother Eve, who +instead of the pains of labour wast filled with joy of spirit, and +who for thy refreshment didst listen to the sweet songs of the +angels as they praised thy Son, thou hast now seen slain before +thine eyes with the greatest cruelty and tyranny. How manifold was +that sorrow of thine, which thou wast permitted to escape at His +birth, when thou sawest thy blessed and only Son hanging in such +torment on the Cross, in the presence of a cruel and furious crowd, +who showered upon Him all the insults and contumely and shame that +they could think of; when thou sawest Him whom thou didst bear in +thy pure womb without feeling the burden, so barbarously stretched +on the Cross, and pierced with nails; when thou sawest His sacred +arms, with which He had so many times lovingly embraced thee, +stretched out so that He could not move them, and covered with red +blood, His adorable head pierced with sharp thorns, and His whole +body one streaming wound, while thou wast not able to staunch or +anoint any of those wounds. What must thy grief have been when thou +sawest Him whom thou hadst so often laid on thy virgin bosom that He +might rest, without anything on which to lean His sacred head; and +Him whom thou hadst nourished with the milk of thy holy breasts, now +vexed with vinegar and gall. O how thy maternal heart was oppressed +when thou beheldest with thy pure eyes that fair face so piteously +marred, so that there was no beauty in it, and nothing by which He +could be distinguished. How did the wave of affliction beat against +and overflow and overwhelm thy soul! Truly, if even a devout man +cannot without unspeakable sorrow and pity revolve in his mind the +Passion of thy Son, what must have been thy Cross, thy affliction, +who wast His mother and sawest it all with thine eyes? If to many +friends of God and to many who love Him, thy Son's Passion is as +grievous as if they suffered it themselves, if by inward pity they +are crucified with thy Son, how terribly, even unto death, must thou +have been crucified inwardly, when thou didst not only ponder and +search into the outward and inward pains of thy Son in thy devout +heart, but sawest them with thy bodily eyes? For never did any +mother love her child as thou lovedst thy Son. And if St Paul, who +loved so much, could say, out of his ardent love and deep pity for +thy Son, "I am crucified with Christ; and I bear in my body the +marks of the Lord Jesus," how much more wert thou crucified with +Him, and didst inwardly receive all His wounds, being made, in a +manner, an image and likeness of thy crucified Son? + +THE FOURTH WORD + +ABOUT the ninth hour our Lord Jesus cried with a loud voice, "My +God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" He cried with a loud voice, +that He might be easily heard by all, and also that by this wondrous +word He might shake off from our souls the sleep of sloth, and cause +them to wonder and marvel at the immeasurable goodness of God to us. +Therefore He saith, "My God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" For +the sake of vile sinners, for evil and thankless servants, for +sinful and disobedient deceivers, Thou hast forsaken Thy beloved Son +and most obedient Child. That Thy enemies, who are vessels of wrath, +might be changed into children of adoption, Thou hast slain Thine +own Son, and given Him over to death like one guilty. "O my God, +why, I pray Thee, hast Thou forsaken me?" For the very cause why men +ought to praise and give thanks to Thee, and love Thee with an +everlasting love; because Thou hast delivered Thy dear Son to death +for their redemption, and sacrificed Him willingly, for this reason +they will find ground for blasphemy and reproach against Thee, +saying, "He saith He is the Son of God. Let God deliver Him now if +He will have Him." Why, O my God, hast Thou willed to spend so +precious a treasure for such vile and counterfeit goods? Besides, +this word may be understood to have been spoken by Christ against +those who seek to diminish the glory of His Passion, by saying that +it was not really so bitter and terrible, owing to the great support +and comfort which He drew from His Godhead. Let those who speak and +think thus know that they renew His Passion and crucify Him afresh. +It was to prove the error of such men that our Lord cried with a +loud voice, and said, "My God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" +It is as if He had said these words to His own Divine nature, with +which He formed one Person--for the Godhead of the Father and of the +Son is all one--wondering, Himself, at His own love, which had so +cast Him down and worn Him out and humbled Him, and that He who +brings help to all mankind should have forsaken Himself, and offered +Himself to suffer every kind of pain, impelled thereto by conquering +love alone. Again, we should not be wrong, if we were to interpret +this word which Christ spoke out of the exceeding bitterness of His +sorrow in the following way--namely, that His spirit and inward man, +taking upon itself the severe judgment of God upon all sinners, and +at the same time discerning clearly and feeling and measuring in +Himself the intolerable weight of His Passion, on this account cried +out in a sorrowful voice to His Father, and complained tenderly to +Him because He had been cast into these dreadful torments; as if the +goodness of His Father had become so embittered against the sins of +men, that in the ardour of His justice He had quite forgotten the +inseparable union between His passible humanity and His impassible +Godhead, and therefore in the zealousness of His justice had quite +given up His passible nature to the cruelty and malice of fierce +men, that they might waste it away and destroy it. For this reason, +therefore, He said, "My God, My God, why hast Thou forsaken Me?" +This word has besides an inward meaning, according to which Christ, +in His sensitive parts, complained to His Father that He had been +forsaken by Him. For as many as contend for His honour, and endure +patiently the troubles of this world, our merciful God so moderates +and tempers their crosses and afflictions by the inpouring of His +divine consolation, that by His sensible grace He makes their +crosses hardly felt; but He left His own beloved Son quite without +any comfort, and so deprived Him of all consolation and light, that +He endured as much in His human nature as had been ordained by the +Eternal Wisdom, according to the strictness of justice, as much as +was needed to atone for so many sins. And indeed our salvation was +the more nobly and perfectly achieved, in that it was done and +finished without any light at all, in absolute resignation and +abandonment. For a chief cause of the Passion was to show clearly +how great was the injury and insult brought upon His most high +Godhead by the sins of the human race. Now as the knowledge of +Christ was greater and more acute than that of all other beings, in +heaven or in earth, so much the greater and heavier was His sorrow +and agony. Nay more--what is more wonderful than anything--whatever +afflictions have been endured by all the saints, as members of +Christ, existed much more abundantly in Christ their Head; and this +I wish to be understood according to the spirit and reasonably. For +all the saints have suffered no more than flowed in upon them +through Christ, joined to them as His members, who communicated to +them His own afflictions. For He took upon Himself the afflictions +of all the saints, out of His great love for His members, and +wondrous pity, and He suffered far greater internal anguish than any +of the saints, nay, more even than the blessed Virgin, His mother, +felt her own sharp sorrow and sickness of heart. For if an earthly +father loves his child so much, that in fatherly pity he takes upon +himself the sorrows of his child, and grieves for them as if he +suffered them himself, what must have been Christ's Cross and +compassion for the affliction of His members, and above all, of +those who suffered for His name's sake? Truly He bore witness to His +members, how much He suffered from their afflictions, and how great +was His inward pity for their sufferings, when He took all their +debt upon Himself, and abolished all the penalties which they had +merited, so that they might depart free. The same is most amply +proved by the words which He spoke to St Paul, when He said, "Saul, +Saul, why persecutest thou Me?" For the persecution which Saul had +stirred up against the disciples, the members of the Lord, was not +less grievous to Him than if He had suffered it Himself. Therefore +He says to His friends and members, "He who touches you, touches the +apple of Mine eye." For is there anything suffered by the members, +which the Head does not suffer with them, He whose nature is +goodness, and whose property is always to have mercy and to forgive? + +THE FIFTH WORD + +OUR most tender Lord was so worn out and parched by the extreme +bitterness of His pain and suffering, and by the great loss of +blood, that He cried, "I thirst." A little word, but full of +mysteries. + +In the first place it may be understood literally. For it is natural +for those who are at the point of death to feel thirst, and to +desire to drink. But how great was the drouth felt by Him who is the +fountain of living water, but who was now worn out and parched by +the heat of His ardent love, when he could truly say, "I am poured +out like water," and "My strength is dried up like a potsherd." For +not only did He shed all His own blood, and pour out moisture by +tears, but the very marrow of His bones, and all His heart's blood, +were consumed for our sakes by the heat and flame of love. Therefore +He said rightly, "I thirst." + +But, secondly, the word may be understood spiritually, as if Christ +said to all men, "I thirst for your salvation." Hence St Bernard +says: "Jesus cried, I thirst, not, I grieve. O Lord, what dost Thou +thirst for? For your faith, your joy. I thirst because of the +torments of your souls, far more than for My own bodily sufferings. +Have pity on yourselves, if not on Me." And again, "O good Jesus, +Thou wearest the crown of thorns; Thou art silent about Thy Cross +and wounds, yet Thou criest out, I thirst. For what, then, dost Thou +thirst? Truly, for the redemption of mankind only, and for the +felicity of the human race." This thirst of Christ was a hundred +times more keen and intense than His natural thirst. And, besides, +He had another sort of thirst--that is to say, a thirst to suffer +more, and to prove to us still more clearly His immeasurable love, +as if He said to man, "See how I am worn out and exhausted for thy +salvation. See how terrible are the pains and anguish which I +endure. The fierce cruelty of man has almost brought Me to nothing; +the sinners of earth have drunk out all My blood, and yet I thirst. +Not yet is My heart satisfied, nor My desire accomplished, nor the +fire of My love quenched. For if it were possible for Me, and +according to My Father's will, that I should be crucified again a +thousand times for your salvation and conversion, or that I should +hang here, in all this pain and anguish, till the day of judgment, I +would gladly do it, to prove to you the immeasurable love which I +bear you in My heart, and to soften your stony hearts and rouse you +to love Me in return. This is why I hang here so thirsty by the +fountain of your hearts, that I may watch the pious souls who come +hither to draw from the deep well of My Passion. Therefore, the +maiden to whom I shall say, 'Give Me to drink a little water out of +the pitcher of thy conscience'--the water of devotion, pity, tears, +and mutual love--and who shall let down to Me her pitcher, and shall +say, 'Drink, my Lord; and for Thy camels also--that is, Thy +servants, who carry Thee about daily on their bodies, and who by +night and day are held bound fast by Thy yoke, I will draw the water +of brotherly love'--that is the maiden whom the Lord hath prepared +for the Son of My Lord, even the bride of the Word of God, united to +My humanity. And she shall be counted worthy to enter, like a bride +with her bridegroom, into the chamber of eternal rest, when the +Bridegroom invites her, saying, 'Come, My blessed bride, inherit the +Kingdom of My Father. For I was thirsty, and thou gavest Me drink.'" + +Thirdly, we may apply this word to the Father, as if Christ said to +His Father: "Father, I have declared Thy name to mankind; I have +finished the work which Thou gavest Me to do; and in Thy service I +have spent My whole body as Thine instrument. Behold, I am all worn +out and exhausted; and yet I still thirst to do and suffer more for +Thine honour. This is why I hang here, extended to the furthest +breadth of love, for I long to be an everlasting sacrifice, a sweet +savour to Thee, and at the same time an eternal atonement and +salvation to mankind." Thus, too, might this strong Samson have +said: "O Lord, Thou hast put into the hand of Thy servant this very +great salvation and victory, and yet behold, I die of thirst." As if +He would say: "Father, I have accomplished Thy gracious will; I have +finished the work of man's salvation, as Thou didst demand; and yet +I still thirst; for the sins by which Thou art offended are +infinite. And so I desire that the love and merits of My Passion, by +which Thou wilt be appeased, may be infinite too. And as I now offer +myself as a peace-offering and a living sacrifice for the salvation +of all men, so through Me may all men appease Thee, by offering Me +to Thee as a peace-offering to Thine eternal glory, in memory of My +Passion, and to make good all their shortcomings." O how acceptable +to the Father must this desire of love have been! For what was this +thirst but a sweet and pleasant refreshment to the Father, and at +the same time the blessed renovation of mankind? Or what other +language does this burning throat speak to us, save that of Christ's +burning love, without measure and without limit, out of which He did +all His works? This truly is the most noble sacrifice of our +redemption, this is that peace-offering which will be offered even +to the last day, by all good men, to the Holy Ghost, to the highest +Father, in memory of the Son, to the eternal glory of the adorable +Trinity, and to the fruit of salvation for mankind. Here, certainly, +is the inexhaustible storehouse of our reconciliation, which never +fails, for it is greater than all the debts of the world. This is +that immeasurable love, which is higher than the heavens, for it has +repaired the ruin of the angels; deeper than hell, for it has freed +souls from hell; wider and broader than the earth, for it is without +end and incomprehensible by any created understanding. O how keen +and intense was this thirst of our Lord! For not only did He then +say once, "I thirst," but even now He says in our hearts +continually, "I thirst; woman, give me to drink." So great, so +mighty, is that thirst, that He asks drink not only from the +children of Israel, but from the Samaritans. To each one He +complaineth of His thirst. But for what dost Thou thirst, O good +Jesus? "My meat and drink," saith He, "is that men should do My +Father's will. Now this is the will of My Father, even your +sanctification and salvation, that you may sanctify your souls by +walking in My precepts, by doing works of repentance, by adorning +yourselves with all virtues, in order that, like a bride adorned for +her husband, you may be worthy to be present at My supper in My +Father's kingdom, and to sleep with Me as My elect bride, in the +chamber of My Father's heart." O how Christ longs to bring all men +thither! This is the meaning of His words: "Where I am there shall +also My servant be"; and again: "Father, I will that they may be one +even as We are one." O, how incomprehensible is this thirst of +Christ! What toil and labour He endured for thirty and three years, +for the sake of it! For this His very heart's blood was poured out. +See what our tender Lord says to His Father: "The zeal of Thine +house hath even eaten Me." Truly, He would have submitted to be +crucified a thousand times, rather than allow one soul to perish +through any fault of His. O how this inward thirst tormented Him, +when He thought that He had done all that He could, and even a +hundredfold more than He need have done, and yet that so few had +turned to Him, and been won by Him. His whole body was now worn out; +all His blood was shed; nothing remained for Him to do; and +therefore He was constrained to confess, "It is finished"; and yet +by all His labours, afflictions, and sufferings, He had brought no +richer harvest to the Father than this. Truly, this was the most +bitter of all His sorrows, that after so hard a battle His victory +had not been more glorious, and that He returned a conqueror to His +Father with so few spoils. Therefore, all those who do not refresh +Him by performing His will, and doing all that is pleasing and +honourable to Him, and withstanding all that reason tells them to be +displeasing to Him, will one day hear Him say, "I was thirsty, and +ye gave Me no drink. Depart, ye cursed, into everlasting fire." + +Fourthly, there is yet another inward meaning of this word--namely, +that Christ spoke it out of the love which inwardly draws Him +towards all men, thus making known to us His ardent love, and +opening His own heart, as a delightful couch, on which we may feed +pleasantly, and inviting us to it, saying, "I thirst for you." For +as the liquid which we drink is sent down pleasantly through the +throat into the body, and so passes into the substance and nature of +our body, so Christ out of the ardent thirst of His love, takes +spiritual pleasure in drinking in all men into Himself, swallowing +them, as it were, and incorporating them into Himself, and bringing +them into the secret chamber of His loving heart. Therefore He says: +"I, if I be lifted up from the earth, will draw all men unto +Me"--all men, that is, who allow themselves to be drawn by Me, and +submit to Me as obedient instruments, suffering Me to do with them +according to My gracious will. But those who resist Him quench not +His thirst, but give Him a bitter draught instead, even the deeds of +their own self-will. These, when our Lord tasteth them, He +straightway rejects. + +THE SIXTH WORD + +WHEN Christ had tasted the draught of vinegar and gall, He spoke the +sixth word: "It is finished." Thereby He signified that by His +Passion had been fulfilled all the prophecies, types, mysteries, +scriptures, sacrifices, and promises, which had been predicted and +written about Him. This is that true Son of God, for whom the Father +of heaven made ready a supper in the kingdom of His eternal +blessedness; and He sent His servant--that is the human nature of +Christ, coming in the form of a servant, to call them that were +bidden to the wedding. For Christ, when He took human nature upon +Him, was not only a servant but a servant of servants, and served +all of us for thirty and three years with great toil and suffering. +Indeed, He spent His whole life in bidding all men to His supper. It +was for this that He preached, and wrought miracles, and travelled +from place to place, and proclaimed that the kingdom of heaven was +at hand, and that all should be prepared for it. But they would not +come. And when the Father of the household heard this, He said to +His Servant: "Compel them to come in, that My house may be filled." +Then that Servant thought within Himself: "How shall I be able +without violence to compel these men to come, that rebellion may be +avoided and yet that their privilege and power of free will may +remain unimpaired? For if I compel them to come by iron chains, and +blows, and whips, I shall have asses and not men." Then He said to +Himself: "I perceive that man is so constituted as to be prone to +love. Therefore I will show him such love as shall pass all his +understanding, love than which no other love can be greater. If man +will observe this, he will be so caught in its toils, that he will +not be able to escape its heat and flame, and will be constrained to +turn to God, and love Him in return. For, turn where he will, he +will always be met by the immeasurable benefits, the infinite +goodness, and the wonderful love of God; and at the same time he +will feel more and more compelled to return love for love, till he +will be no more able to resist it, and will be gently constrained to +follow." When this was done, Jesus Christ, this faithful and wise +Servant, said to His Lord and Father, "It is finished. I have +finished the work which Thou gavest Me to do. What more could I have +done, and have not done it? I have no member left that is not weary +and worn with toil and pain. My veins are dry, My blood is shed; My +marrow is spent, My throat is hoarse with crying. Such love have I +shown to man, that his heart cannot be human, cannot even be stony, +or the heart of a brute beast, but must be quite devilish and +desperate, if it be not moved by the thought of these things." + +Moreover, this word of our Lord Jesus is a word of sorrow, not of +joy. He spoke it not as if He had now escaped from all His +suffering. No; when He said, "It is finished," He meant all that had +been ordained and decreed by the eternal Truth for Him to suffer. +Besides, all the sufferings which had been inflicted upon Him by +degrees and singly, He now endures together with immeasurable +anguish. Who can have such a heart of adamant as not to be moved by +such torment as this? How short were the words which our Lord Jesus +spoke on the Cross, yet how full of sacramental mysteries! Now were +fulfilled the words of Exodus: "And all things were finished which +belonged to the sacrifice of the Lord." + +Moreover by this word our Lord declared the glorious victory of the +Passion, and how the old enemy, the jealous serpent, was overcome +and thrown down; for this was the cause for which He suffered. For +this He had taken upon Himself the garment of human nature, that He +might vanquish and confound the enemy, by the same weapons wherewith +the enemy boasted that he had conquered man. This was the chief +purpose of His Passion, and now He confesses that it is finished. O +how wonderful are the mysteries, and the victories, included in this +little but deep word: "It is finished!" All that the eternal Wisdom +had decreed, all that strict justice had demanded for each man, all +that love had asked for, all the promises made to the fathers, all +the mysteries, types, ceremonies in Scripture, all that was meet and +necessary for our redemption, all that was needed to wipe out our +debts, all that must repair our negligences, all that was glorious +and loving for the exhibition of this splendid love, all that we +could desire, for our spiritual instruction--in a word, all that was +good and fitting for the celebration of the glorious triumph of our +redemption, all is included in that one word, "It is finished." +What, then, remains for Him, but to finish and perfect His life in +this glorious conflict; and, because nothing remains for Him to do, +to commend His precious soul into His Father's hands, seeing that He +has fought the good fight, and finished His course in all holiness? +It is meet, then, that He should obtain the crown of glory which His +heavenly Father will give Him on the day of His exaltation. + +Lastly, by this word Christ offered up all His toil, sorrow, and +affliction for all the elect, as the Apostle saith: "Who in the days +of His flesh offered up prayer and supplications with strong crying +and tears unto Him who was able to save Him from death, and was +heard in that He feared. For if the blood of bulls and of goats and +the ashes of a heifer, sprinkling the unclean, sanctifieth to the +purifying of the flesh, how much more shall the blood of Christ, who +through the eternal Spirit offered Himself without spot to God, +purge our conscience from dead works to serve the living God?" + +THE SEVENTH WORD + +OUR Lord Jesus cried again with a loud voice, and said, "Father, +into Thy hands I commend My Spirit." O all ye who love our Lord +Jesus Christ, come, I beseech you, and let us watch, with all +devotion and pity, His passing away. Let us see what must have been +His sorrow and agony and torment, when His glorious soul was now at +last forced to pass out of His worthy and most sacred body, in which +for thirty and three years it had rested so sweetly, peacefully, +joyfully, and holily, even as two lovers on one bed. How hard was it +for them to be rent asunder, between whom no disagreement had ever +arisen, no strife, or quarrel, or treachery. How unspeakably +grievous was that Cross, when His sacred body was compelled to part +with so faithful a friend, so gentle an occupant, so loving a +teacher and master; and how great was the sorrow with which His +glorious and pure soul was torn away from so faithful a servant, +which had ever served obediently, never sparing any trouble, never +shrinking from cold or heat or hunger or thirst; always enduring +labour and sorrow in gentleness and patience. O how great was this +affliction! For, as the philosopher says: "Of all terrible things +death is the most terrible, on account of the natural and mutual +affection, which is very great, between soul and body." How much +greater must have been the anguish and sorrow, when the most holy +soul and body of Christ were sundered, between which there had +always been such wonderful harmony and love. Therefore, with inward +pity and anxious sorrow, let us meditate on this sad parting; for +the death of Christ is our life. + +Let us meditate devoutly how His sacred body, the instrument of our +salvation, was steeped in anguish, when all His members, as if to +bid a last farewell, were bowing themselves down to die! Who can +look without remorse and sorrow and pity upon the most gracious face +of Christ, and behold how it is changed into the pallor and likeness +of death; how tears still flow from His dimmed eyes; how His sacred +head is bent; how all His members prove to us, by signs and motions, +the love which they can no longer show by deeds. Let us pity Him, I +pray you, for He is our own flesh and blood, and it is for our sins, +not His own, that He is shamefully slain. O ye who up till now have +passed by the Cross of Jesus with tepid or cold hearts, and whom all +these torments and tears, and His blood shed like water, have not +been able to soften; now at last let this loud voice, this terrible +cry, rend and pierce your hearts through and through. Let that voice +which shook the heaven and the earth and hell with fear, which rent +the rocks and laid open ancient graves, now soften your stony +hearts, and lay bare the old sepulchres of your conscience, full of +dead men's bones--that is to say, of wicked deeds, and call again +into life your departed spirits. For this is the voice which once +cried: "Adam, where art thou; and what hast thou done?" This is the +voice which brought Lazarus from Hades, saying, "Lazarus, come +forth: arise from the grave of sin, and let them free thee from thy +grave-clothes." Truly it was not so much the grievousness of His +sufferings, as the greatness of our sins, which made our Lord utter +this cry. He cried also, to show that He had the dominion over life +and death, over the living and the dead. For though he was quite +worn out, and destitute of strength, and though He had borne the +bitter pangs of death so long, beyond the power of man, yet He would +not allow Death to put forth its power against Him, until it pleased +Him. + +With a loud voice He cried, that earthly men, who care only for the +things of earth, might quake with fear and trembling, and to cause +them to meditate and see how naked and helpless the Lord of lords +departed from this life. With a terrible voice He cried, to stir up +all those who live in wantonness, and who have grown old in their +defilement, and send forth a foul savour, like dead dogs, so that at +last these miserable men may rise from their lusts and pleasures and +sensual delights, and see how the Son of God, who was never strained +with any spot of defilement, went forth to His Father; and with what +toil and pain and anguish He departed from the light of day, and +what He had to suffer before He reached his Father's Kingdom. He +also cried with a loud voice, that He might inflame the lukewarm and +slothful to devotion and love. + +Moreover He cried with a loud voice as a sign of the glorious +victory which He had gained, when after a single combat with His +strong and cruel enemy, and having descended into the arena--the +battlefield of this world--He had routed him on Mount Calvary and +stripped him bare of his spoils. This victory, this glorious +triumph, Christ proclaimed with a loud voice, and thus departing +from the battlefield triumphant and victorious, He departed to the +place of all delights, to the heart and breast of God, His Father, +commending to it, as to a safe refuge, both Himself and all His own, +with the words, "Father, into Thy hands I commend My Spirit." + +We may learn from these words that the eternal Word, our Lord Jesus +Christ, had been let down like a fishing-hook or great net, by the +Father of heaven, into the great sea of this world, that He might +catch not fish but men. Hear how He says: "My word, that goeth forth +out of My mouth shall not return unto Me void, but shall execute +that which I please, and shall prosper in the thing whereto I send +it." And this net is drawn by the Father out of the salt sea, to the +peaceful shore of His fatherly heart, full of the elect, of works of +charity, of repentance, patience, humility, obedience, spiritual +exercises, merits and virtues. For Christ drew unto Himself all the +afflictions and good deeds of the good; just as St Paul says, "I +live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me." Even so, Christ lives in +all the good, and all who have been willing and obedient instruments +in the hands of Christ. In all such Christ lives and suffers and +works. For whatever good there is in all men, is all God's work. +Therefore Christ, feeling His Father drawing Him, gathered together +in Himself in a wonderful manner all the elect with all their works, +and commended them to His Father, saying, "My Father, these are +Thine; these are the spoils which I have won by My conquest, by the +sword of the Cross; these are the vessels which I have purchased +with My precious blood; these are the fruits of My labours. Keep in +Thine own name those whom Thou hast given Me. I pray not that Thou +shouldest take them out of the world, but that Thou shouldest keep +them from the evil." Thus did Christ commend Himself and all His own +into His Father's hands. Come therefore, O faithful and devout soul, +and contemplate with great earnestness the coming in and the going +out of thy Lord Jesus; follow Him with love and longing, even to the +chamber and bed of joy, which He has prepared for thee in thy +Father's heart. Happy would he be, who could now be dissolved with +Christ, and die with the thief, and hear from the lips of the Lord +that comfortable word, "This day shalt thou be with Me in paradise." +And though this is not granted to us, yet whatever we can here gain +by labours and watchings and fastings and prayers, let us commend it +all with Christ to the Father; let us pour it back again into the +fountain, whence it flowed forth for us; and let nothing be left in +us of empty self-satisfaction, no seeking after human praise or +honour or reward. But whatever our God hath been willing to do in +us, let us return it back into His own hands and say, "We are +nothing of ourselves. It is He who made us, and not we ourselves. +All good was made by Him, and without Him was not anything made. +When therefore He taketh with Him what He made Himself, we are +absolutely nothing." + +Lastly, Christ commended His soul into His Father's hands, to show +us how the souls of good and holy men mount up after Him to the +bosom of the eternal Father, who must otherwise have gone down to +hell; for it is He who has opened to us the way of life, and His +sacred soul, by making the journey safe and free from danger, has +been our guide into the kingdom of heaven. + + + + + + +SUSO + + + + + +SUSO AND HIS SPIRITUAL DAUGHTER + +AFTER this, certain very high thoughts arose in the mind of the +servitor's spiritual daughter, concerning which she asked him +whether she might put questions to him. He replied, Yea verily: +since thou hast been led through the proper exercises, it is +permitted to thy spiritual intelligence to enquire about high +things. Ask then whatever thou wilt. She said: Tell me, father, what +is God, and how He is both One and Three? The servitor replied, +These be indeed high questions. As to the first, What is God, you +must know that all the Doctors who ever lived cannot explain it, for +He is above all sense and reason. Yet if a man is diligent, and does +not relax his efforts, he gains some knowledge of God, though very +far off. Yet in this knowledge of God consists our eternal life and +man's supreme happiness. In this way, in former times, certain +worthy philosophers searched for God, and especially that great +thinker Aristotle, who tried to discover the Author of Nature from +the order of nature and its course. He sought earnestly, and he was +convinced from the well-ordered course of nature that there must of +necessity be one Prince and Lord of the whole universe--He whom we +call God. About this God and Lord we know this much, that He is an +immortal Substance, eternal, without before or after, simple, bare, +unchangeable, an incorporeal and essential Spirit, whose substance +is life and energy, whose most penetrating intelligence knows all +things in and by itself, whose essence in itself is an abyss of +pleasures and joys, and who is to Himself, and to all who shall +enjoy Him in a future life, a supernatural, ineffable, and most +sweet happiness. The maiden, when she heard this, looked up, and +said: These things are sweet to tell and sweet to hear, for they +rouse the heart, and lift the spirit up far beyond itself. +Therefore, father, tell me more about these things. The servitor +said: The Divine Essence, about which we speak, is an intelligible +or intellectual Substance of such a kind, that it cannot be seen in +itself by mortal eyes; but it can be discerned in its effects, even +as we recognise a fine artist by his works. As the Apostle teaches +us, "The invisible things of God from the creation of the world are +clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made." For the +creatures are a kind of mirror, in which God shines. This knowledge +is called speculation, by which we contemplate the great Architect +of the world in His works. Come now, look upward and about thee, +through all the quarters of the universe, and see how wide and high +the beautiful heaven is, how swift its motion, and how marvellously +its Creator has adorned it with the seven planets, and with the +countless multitude of the twinkling stars. Consider what +fruitfulness, what riches, the sun bestows upon the earth, when in +summer it sheds abroad its rays unclouded! See how the leaves and +grass shoot up, and the flowers smile, and the woods and plains +resound with the sweet song of nightingales and other birds; how all +the little animals, after being imprisoned by grim winter, come +forth rejoicing, and pair; and how men and women, both old and +young, rejoice and are merry. O Almighty God, if Thou art so lovable +and so pleasant in Thy creatures, how happy and blessed, how full of +all joy and beauty, must Thou be in Thyself? But further, my +daughter, contemplate the elements themselves--Earth, Water, Air, +and Fire, with all the wonderful things which they contain in +infinite variety--men, beasts, birds, fishes, and sea-monsters. And +all of these give praise and honour to the unfathomable immensity +that is in Thee. Who is it, Lord, who preserves all these things, +who nourishes them? It is Thou who providest for all, each in his +own way, for great and small, rich and poor. Thou, O God, doest +this; Thou alone art God indeed! Behold, my daughter, thou hast now +found the God whom thou hast sought so long. Look up, then, with +shining eyes, with radiant face and exulting heart, behold Him and +embrace Him with the outstretched arms of thy soul and mind, and +give thanks to Him as the one and supreme Lord of all creatures. By +gazing on this mirror, there springs up speedily, in one of loving +and pious disposition, an inward jubilation of the heart; for by +this is meant a joy which no tongue can tell, though it pours with +might through heart and soul. Alas, I now feel within me, that I +must open for thee the closed mouth of my soul; and I am compelled, +for the glory of God, to tell thee certain secrets, which I never +yet told to any one. A certain Dominican, well known to me, at the +beginning of his course used to receive from God twice every day, +morning and evening, for ten years, an outpouring of grace like +this, which lasted about as long as it would take to say the "Vigils +of the Dead" twice over.[40] At these times he was so entirely +absorbed in God, the eternal Wisdom, that he would not speak of it. +Sometimes he would converse with God as with a friend, not with the +mouth, but mentally; at other times he would utter piteous sighs to +Him; at other times he would weep copiously, or smile silently. He +often seemed to himself to be flying in the air, and swimming +between time and eternity in the depth of the Divine wonders, which +no man can fathom. And his heart became so full from this, that he +would sometimes lay his hand upon it as it beat heavily, saying, +"Alas, my heart, what labours will befall thee to-day?" One day it +seemed to him that the heart of his heavenly Father was, in a +spiritual and indescribable manner, pressed tenderly, and with +nothing between, against his heart; and that the Father's +heart--that is, the eternal Wisdom, spoke inwardly to his heart +without forms.[41] Then he began to exclaim joyously in spiritual +jubilation: Behold, now, Thou whom I most fervently love, thus do I +lay bare my heart to Thee, and in simplicity and nakedness of all +created things I embrace Thy formless Godhead! O God, most excellent +of all friends! Earthly friends must needs endure to be distinct and +separate from those whom they love; but Thou, O fathomless sweetness +of all true love, meltest into the heart of Thy beloved, and pourest +Thyself fully into the essence of his soul, that nothing of Thee +remains outside, but Thou art joined and united most lovingly with +Thy beloved. + +To this the maiden replied: Truly it is a great grace, when anyone +is thus caught up into God. But I should like to be informed, +whether this is the most perfect kind of union or not? The servitor +answered: No, it is not the most perfect, but a preliminary, gently +drawing a man on, that he may arrive at an essential way of being +carried up into God. The maiden asked him what he meant by essential +and non-essential. He answered: I call that man essential or +habitual (so to speak), who by the good and persevering practice of +all the virtues, has arrived at the point of finding the practice of +them in their highest perfection pleasant to him, even as the +brightness of the sun remains constant in the sun. But I call him +non-essential, in whom the brightness of the virtues shines in an +unstable and imperfect way like the brightness of the moon. That +full delight of grace which I described is so sweet to the spirit of +the non-essential man, that he would be glad always to have it. When +he has it, he rejoices; when he is deprived of it, he grieves +inordinately; and when it smiles upon him, he is reluctant to pass +to doing other things, even things that are pleasing to God; as I +will show you by an example. The servitor of the Divine Wisdom was +once walking in the chapter-house, and his heart was full of +heavenly jubilation, when the porter called him out to see a woman +who wished to confess to him. He was unwilling to interrupt his +inward delight, and received the porter harshly, bidding him tell +the woman that she must find some one else to confess to, for he did +not wish to hear her confession just then. She, however, being +oppressed with the burden of her sins, said that she felt specially +drawn to seek comfort from him, and that she would confess to no one +else. And when he still refused to go out, she began to weep most +sadly, and going into a corner, lamented greatly. Meanwhile, God +quickly withdrew from the servitor the delights of grace, and his +heart became as hard as flint. And when he desired to know the cause +of this, God answered him inwardly: Even as thou hast driven away +uncomforted that poor woman, so have I withdrawn from thee my Divine +comfort. The servitor groaned deeply and beat his breast, and +hurried to the door, and as he did not find the woman there, was +much distressed. The porter, however, looked about for her +everywhere, and when he found her, still weeping, bade her return to +the door. When she came, the servitor received her gently, and +comforted her sorrowing heart. Then he went back from her to the +chapter-house, and immediately God was with him, with His Divine +consolations, as before. + +Then said the maiden: It must be easy for him to bear sufferings, to +whom God gives such jubilation and internal joys. And yet, said the +servitor, all had to be paid for afterward with great suffering. +However, at last, when all this had passed away, and God's appointed +time had come, the same grace of jubilation was restored to him, and +remained with him almost continuously both at home and abroad, in +company and alone. Often in the bath or at table the same grace was +with him; but it was now internal, and did show itself outside. + +Then the maiden said: My father, I have now learned what God is; but +I am also eager to know where He is. Thou shalt hear, said the +servitor. The opinion of the theologians is that God is in no +particular place, but that He is everywhere, and all in all. The +same doctors say that we come to know a thing through its name. Now +one doctor says that Being is the first name of God. Turn your eyes, +therefore, to Being in its pure and naked simplicity, and take no +notice of this or that substance which can be torn asunder into +parts and separated; but consider Being in itself, unmixed with any +Not-Being. Whatever is nothing, is the negation of what is; and what +is, is the negation of what is not. A thing which has yet to be, or +which once was, is not now in actual being. Moreover, we cannot know +mixed being or not-being unless we take into account that which is +all-being. This Being is not the being of this or that creature; for +all particular being is mixed with something extraneous, whereby it +can receive something new into itself. Therefore the nameless Divine +Being must be in itself a Being that is all-being, and that sustains +all particular things by its presence. + +It shows the strange blindness of man's reason, that it cannot +examine into that which it contemplates before everything, and +without which it cannot perceive anything. Just as, when the eye is +bent on noticing various colours, it does not observe the light +which enables it to see all these objects, and even if it looks at +the light it does not observe it; so it is with the eye of the soul. +When it looks at this or that particular substance, it takes no heed +of the being, which is everywhere one, absolute and simple, and by +the virtue and goodness of which it can apprehend all other things. +Hence the wise Aristotle says, that the eye of our intelligence, +owing to its weakness, is affected towards that being which is +itself the most manifest of all things, as the eye of a bat or owl +is towards the bright rays of the sun. For particular substances +distract and dazzle the mind, so that it cannot behold the Divine +darkness, which is the clearest light. + +Come now, open the eyes of thy mind, and gaze if thou canst, on +Being in its naked and simple purity. You will perceive that it +comes from no one, and has no before nor after, and that it cannot +change, because it is simple Being. You will also observe that it is +the most actual, the most present, and the most perfect of beings, +with no defect or mutation, because it is absolutely one in its bare +simplicity. This is so evident to an instructed intellect, that it +cannot think otherwise. Since it is simple Being, it must be the +first of beings, and without beginning or end, and because it is the +first and everlasting and simple, it must be the most present. If +you can understand this, you will have been guided far into the +incomprehensible light of God's hidden truth. This pure and simple +Being is altogether in all things, and altogether outside all +things. Hence a certain doctor says: God is a circle, whose centre +is everywhere, and His circumference nowhere. + +When this had been said, the maiden answered: Blessed be God, I have +been shown, as far as may be, both what God is, and where He is. But +I should like also to be told how, if God is so absolutely simple, +He can also be threefold. + +The servitor answered: The more simple any being is in itself, the +more manifold is it in its energy and operation. That which has +nothing gives nothing, and that which has much can give much. I have +already spoken of the inflowing and overflowing fount of good which +God is in Himself. This infinite and superessential goodness +constrains Him not to keep it all within Himself, but to communicate +it freely both within and without Himself. But the highest and most +perfect outpouring of the good must be within itself, and this can +be nought else but a present, interior, personal and natural +outpouring, necessary, yet without compulsion, infinite and perfect. +Other communications, in temporal matters, draw their origin from +this eternal communication of the Divine Goodness. Some theologians +say that in the outflow of the creatures from their first origin +there is a return in a circle of the end to the beginning; for as +the emanation of the Persons from the Godhead is an image of the +origin of the creatures, so also it is a type of the flowing back of +the creatures into God. There is, however, a difference between the +outpouring of the creatures and that of God. The creature is only a +particular and partial substance, and its giving and communication +is also partial and limited. When a human father begets a son, he +gives him part, but not the whole, of his own substance, for he +himself is only a partial good. But the outpouring of God is of a +more interior and higher kind than the creature's outpouring, +inasmuch as He Himself is a higher good. If the outpouring of God is +to be worthy of His pre-eminent being, it must be according to +personal relations. + +Now, then, if you can look upon the pure goodness of the highest +Good (which goodness is, by its nature, the active principle of the +spontaneous love with which the highest Good loves itself) you will +behold the most excellent and superessential outpouring of the Word +from the Father, by which generation all things exist and are +produced; and you will see also in the highest good, and the highest +outpouring, the most holy Trinity, Father, Son, and Holy Ghost, +existing in the Godhead. And if the highest outpouring proceeds from +the highest essential good, it follows that there must be in this +Trinity the highest and most intimate consubstantiality or community +of being, and complete equality and identity of essence, which the +Persons enjoy in sweetest communion, and also that the Substance and +power of the three almighty Persons is undivided and unpartitioned. + +Here the maiden exclaimed: Marvellous! I swim in the Godhead like an +eagle in the air. The servitor, resuming his exposition, continued: +It is impossible to express in words how the Trinity can subsist in +the unity of one essence. Nevertheless, to say what may be said on +the subject, Augustine says that in the Godhead the Father is the +Fountain-head of the Son and the Holy Ghost. Dionysius says, that in +the Father there is an outflowing of the Godhead, which naturally +communicates itself to the Word or Son. He also freely and lovingly +pours Himself out into the Son; and the Son in turn pours Himself +out freely and lovingly into the Father; and this love of the Father +for the Son, and of the Son for the Father, is the Holy Ghost. This +is truly said, but it is made clearer by that glorious Doctor of the +Church, St Thomas, who says as follows: In the outpouring of the +Word from the Father's heart, God the Father must contemplate +Himself with His own mind, bending back, as it were, upon His Divine +essence; for if the reason of the Father had not the Divine essence +for its object, the Word so conceived would be a creature instead of +God; which is false. But in the way described He is "God of God." +Again, this looking back upon the Divine essence, which takes place +in the mind of God, must, in a manner, produce a natural likeness; +else the Word would not be the Son of God. So here we have the unity +of essence in the diversity of Persons; and a clear proof of this +distinction may be found in the word of that soaring eagle St John: +"The Word was in the beginning with God." + +Thus the Father is the Fountain-head of the Son, and the Son is the +outflowing of the Father; and the Father and Son pour forth the +Spirit; and the Unity, which is the essence of the Fountain-head, is +also the substance of the three Persons. But as to how the Three are +One, this cannot be expressed in words, on account of the simplicity +of that Abyss. Into this intellectual Where, the spirits of men made +perfect soar and plunge themselves, now flying over infinite +heights, now swimming in unfathomed depths, marvelling at the high +and wonderful mysteries of the Godhead. Nevertheless, the spirit +remains a spirit, and retains its nature, while it enjoys the vision +of the Divine Persons, and abstracted from all occupation with +things below contemplates with fixed gaze those stupendous +mysteries. For what can be more marvellous than that simple Unity, +into which the Trinity of the Persons merges itself, and in which +all multiplicity ceases? For the outflowing of the Persons is always +tending back into the Unity of the same essence, and all creatures, +according to their ideal existence in God, are from eternity in this +Unity, and have their life, knowledge, and essence in the eternal +God; as it is said in the Gospel: "That which was made, was Life in +Him."[42] This bare Unity is a dark silence and tranquil inactivity, +which none can understand unless he is illuminated by the Unity +itself, unmixed with any evil. Out of this shines forth hidden +truth, free from all falsehood; and this truth is born from the +unveiling of the veiled Divine purity; for after the revelation of +these things, the spirit is at last unclothed of the dusky light +which up till now has followed it, and in which it has hitherto seen +things in an earthly way. Indeed, the spirit finds itself now +changed and something very different from what it supposed itself to +be according to its earlier light: even as St Paul says, "I, yet not +I." Thus it is unclothed and simplified in the simplicity of the +Divine essence, which shines upon all things in simple stillness. In +this modeless mode of contemplation, the permanent distinction of +the Persons, viewed as separate, is lost. For, as some teach, it is +not the Person of the Father, taken by Himself, which produces +bliss, nor the Person of the Son, taken by Himself, nor the Person +of the Holy Ghost, taken by Himself; but the three Persons, dwelling +together in the unity of the essence, confer bliss. And this is the +natural essence of the Persons, which by grace gives the substance +or essence to all their creatures, and it contains in itself the +ideas of all things in their simple essence. Now since this ideal +light subsists as Being, so all things subsist in it according to +their essential being, not according to their accidental forms; and +since it shines upon all things, its property is to subsist as +light. Hence all things shine forth in this essence in interior +stillness, without altering its simplicity. + +Then the maiden said: I could wish greatly, sir, that you could give +me this mysterious teaching, as you understand it, under a figure, +that I might understand it better. I should also be glad if you +could sum up what you have been saying at length, so that it may +stick more firmly in my weak mind. The servitor replied: Who can +express in forms what has no form? Who can explain that which has no +mode of being, and is above sense and reason? Any similitude must be +infinitely more unlike than like the reality. Nevertheless, that I +may drive out forms from your mind by forms, I will try to give you +a picture of these ideas which surpass all forms, and to sum up a +long discourse in a few words. A certain wise theologian says that +God, in regard to His Godhead, is like a vast circle, of which the +centre is everywhere, and the circumference nowhere. Now consider +the image which follows. If anyone throws a great stone into the +middle of a pool, a ring is formed in the water, and this ring makes +a second ring, and the second a third; and the number and size of +the rings depend on the force of the throw. They may even require a +larger space than the limit of the pool. Suppose now that the first +ring represents the omnipotent virtue of the Divine nature, which is +infinite in God the Father. This produces another ring like itself, +which is the Son. And the two produce the third, which is the Holy +Ghost. The spiritual superessential begetting of the Divine Word is +the cause of the creation of all spirits and all things. This +supreme Spirit has so ennobled man, as to shed upon him a ray from +His own eternal Godhead. This is the image of God in the mind, which +is itself eternal. But many men turn away from this dignity of their +nature, befouling the bright image of God in themselves, and turning +to the bodily pleasures of this world. They pursue them greedily and +devote themselves to them, till death unexpectedly stops them. But +he who is wise, turns himself and elevates himself, with the help of +the Divine spark in his soul, to that which is stable and eternal, +whence he had his own origin: he says farewell to all the fleeting +creatures, and clings to the eternal truth alone. + +Attend also to what I say about the order in which the spirit ought +to return to God. First of all, we should disentangle ourselves +absolutely from the pleasures of the world, manfully turning our +backs upon all vices; we should turn to God by continual prayers, by +seclusion, and holy exercise, that the flesh may thus be subdued to +the spirit. Next, we must offer ourselves willingly to endure all +the troubles which may come upon us, from God, or from the +creatures. Thirdly, we must impress upon ourselves the Passion of +Christ crucified; we must fix upon our minds His sweet teaching, His +most gentle conversation, His most pure life, which He gave us for +our example, and so we must penetrate deeper and advance further in +our imitation of Him. Fourthly, we must divest ourselves of external +occupations, and establish ourselves in a tranquil stillness of soul +by an energetic resignation, as if we were dead to self, and thought +only of the honour of Christ and His heavenly Father. Lastly, we +should be humble towards all men, whether friends or foes. . . . But +all these images, with their interpretations, are as unlike the +formless truth as a black Ethiopian is to the bright sun. + +Soon after this holy maiden died, and passed away happy from earth, +even as her whole life had been conspicuous only for her virtues. +After her death she appeared to her spiritual father in a vision. +She was clothed in raiment whiter than snow; she shone with dazzling +brightness, and was full of heavenly joy. She came near to him, and +showed him in what an excellent fashion she had passed away into the +simple Godhead. He saw and heard her with exceeding delight, and the +vision filled his soul with heavenly consolations. When he returned +to himself, he sighed most deeply, and thus pondered: O Almighty +God, how blessed is he, who strives after Thee alone! He may well be +content to bear affliction, whose sufferings Thou wilt thus reward! +May the Almighty God grant that we likewise may be brought to the +same joys as this blessed maiden! + +A MEDITATION ON THE PASSION OF CHRIST + +THEN said the Eternal Wisdom to the servitor, Attend and listen +dutifully, while I tell thee what sufferings I lovingly endured for +thy sake. + +After I had finished My last Supper with My disciples, when I had +offered Myself to My enemies on the mount, and had resigned Myself +to bear a terrible death, and knew that it was approaching very +near, so great was the oppression of My tender heart and all My +body, that I sweated blood; then I was wickedly arrested, bound, and +carried away. On the same night they treated Me with insult and +contumely, beating Me, spitting upon Me, and covering My head. +Before Caiaphas was I unjustly accused and condemned to death. What +misery it was to see My mother seized with unspeakable sorrow of +heart, from the time when she beheld Me threatened with such great +dangers, till the time when I was hung upon the cross. They brought +Me before Pilate with every kind of ignominy, they accused Me +falsely, they adjudged Me worthy of death. Before Herod I, the +Eternal Wisdom, was mocked in a bright robe. My fair body was +miserably torn and rent by cruel scourgings. They surrounded My +sacred head with a crown of thorns; My gracious face was covered +with blood and spittings. When they had thus condemned Me to death, +they led Me out with My cross to bear the last shameful punishment. +Their terrible and savage cries could be heard afar off: "Crucify, +crucify, the wicked man." + +Servitor. Alas, Lord, if so bitter were the beginnings of Thy +passion, what will be the end thereof? In truth, if I saw a brute +beast so treated in my presence I could hardly bear it. What grief +then should I feel in heart and soul at Thy Passion? And yet there +is one thing at which I marvel greatly. For I long, O my most dear +God, to know only Thy Godhead; and Thou tellest me of Thy humanity. +I long to taste Thy sweetness, and Thou showest me Thy bitterness. +What meaneth this, O my Lord God? + +Wisdom. No man can come to the height of My Godhead, nor attain to +that unknown sweetness, unless he be first led through the +bitterness of My humanity. My humanity is the road by which men must +travel. My Passion is the gate, through which they must enter. Away +then with thy cowardice of heart, and come to Me prepared for a hard +campaign. For it is not right for the servant to live softly and +delicately, while his Lord is fighting bravely. Come, I will now put +on thee My own armour. And so thou must thyself also experience the +whole of My Passion, so far as thy strength permits. Take, +therefore, the heart of a man; for be sure that thou wilt have to +endure many deaths, before thou canst put thy nature under the yoke. +I will sprinkle thy garden of spices with red flowers. Many are the +afflictions which will come upon thee; till thou hast finished thy +sad journey of bearing the cross, and hast renounced thine own will +and disengaged thyself so completely from all creatures, in all +things, which might hinder thine eternal salvation, as to be like +one about to die, and no longer mixed up with the affairs of this +life. + +Servitor. Hard and grievous to bear are the things which Thou +sayest, Lord. I tremble all over. How can I bear all these things? +Suffer me, O Lord, to ask Thee something. Couldst Thou not devise +any other way of saving my soul, and of testifying Thy love towards +me, so as to spare Thyself such hard sufferings, and so that I need +not suffer so bitterly with Thee? + +Wisdom. The unfathomable Abyss of My secret counsels no man ought to +seek to penetrate, for no one can comprehend it. And yet that which +thou hast suggested, and many other things, might have been +possible, which nevertheless never happen. Be assured, however, that +as created things now are, no more fitting method could be found. +The Author of Nature doth not think so much what He is able to do in +the world, as what is most fitting for every creature; and this is +the principle of His operations. And by what other means could the +secrets of God have been made known to man, than by the assumption +of humanity by Christ? By what other means could he who had deprived +himself of joy by the inordinate pursuit of pleasure, be brought +back more fittingly to the joys of eternity? And who would be +willing to tread the path, avoided by all, of a hard and despised +life, if God had not trodden it Himself? If thou wert condemned to +death, how could any one show his love and fidelity to thee more +convincingly, or provoke thee to love him in return more powerfully, +than by taking thy sentence upon himself? If, then, there is any one +who is not roused and moved to love Me from his heart by My immense +love, My infinite pity, My exalted divinity, My pure humanity, My +brotherly fidelity, My sweet friendship, is there anything that +could soften that stony heart? + +Servitor. The light begins to dawn upon me, and I seem to myself to +see clearly that it is as Thou sayest, and that whoever is not +altogether blind must admit that this is the best and most fitting +of all ways. And yet the imitation of Thee is grievous to a slothful +and corruptible body. + +Wisdom. Shrink not because thou must follow the footsteps of My +Passion. For he who loves God, and is inwardly united to Him, finds +the cross itself light and easy to bear, and has nought to complain +of. No one receives from Me more marvellous sweetness, than he who +shares My bitterest labours. He only complains of the bitterness of +the rind, who has not tasted the sweetness of the kernel. He who +relies on Me as his protector and helper may be considered to have +accomplished a large part of his task. + +Servitor. Lord, by these consoling words I am so much encouraged, +that I seem to myself to be able to do and suffer all things through +Thee. I pray Thee, then, that Thou wilt unfold the treasure of Thy +Passion to me more fully. + +Wisdom. When I was hung aloft and fastened to the wood of the cross +(which I bore for My great love to thee and all mankind), all the +wonted appearance of My body was piteously changed. My bright eyes +lost their light; My sacred ears were filled with mocking and +blasphemy; My sweet mouth was hurt by the bitter drink. Nowhere was +there any rest or refreshment for Me. My sacred head hung down in +pain; My fair neck was cruelly bruised; My shining face was +disfigured by festering wounds; My fresh colour was turned to +pallor. In a word, the beauty of My whole body was so marred, that I +appeared like a leper--I, the Divine Wisdom, who am fairer than the +sun. + +Servitor. O brightest mirror of grace, which the Angels desire to +look into, in which they delight to fix their gaze, would that I +might behold Thy beloved countenance in the throes of death just +long enough to water it with the tears of my heart, and to satisfy +my mind with lamentations over it. + +Wisdom. No one more truly testifies his grief over My Passion, than +he who in very deed passes through it with Me. Far more pleasing to +Me is a heart disentangled from the love of all transitory things, +and earnestly intent on gaining the highest perfection according to +the example which I have set before him in My life, than one which +continually weeps over My Passion, shedding as many tears as all the +raindrops that ever fell. For this was what I most desired and +looked for in My endurance of that cruel death--namely, that mankind +might imitate Me; and yet pious tears are very dear to Me. + +Servitor. Since then, O most gracious God, the imitation of Thy most +gentle life and most loving Passion is so pleasing to Thee, I will +henceforth labour more diligently to follow Thy Passion than to weep +over it. But since both are pleasing to Thee, teach me, I pray Thee, +how I ought to conform myself to Thy Passion. + +Wisdom. Forbid thyself the pleasure of curious and lax seeing and +hearing; let love make sweet to thee those things which formerly +thou shrankest from; eschew bodily pleasures; rest in Me alone; bear +sweetly and moderately the ills that come from others; desire to +despise thyself; break thy appetites; crush out all thy pleasures +and desires. These are the first elements in the school of Wisdom, +which are read in the volume of the book of My crucified body. But +consider whether anyone, do what he may, can make himself for My +sake such as I made Myself for his. + +Servitor. Come then, my soul, collect thyself from all external +things, into the tranquil silence of the inner man. Woe is me! My +heavenly Father had adopted my soul to be His bride; but I fled far +from Him. Alas, I have lost my Father, I have lost my Lover. Alas, +alas, and woe is me! What have I done, what have I lost? Shame on +me, I have lost myself, and all the society of my heavenly country. +All that could delight and cheer me has utterly forsaken me; I am +left naked. My false lovers were only deceivers. They have stripped +me of all the good things which my one true Lover gave me; they have +despoiled me of all honour, joy, and consolation. O ye red roses and +white lilies, behold me a vile weed, and see also how soon those +flowers wither and die, which this world plucks. And yet, O most +gracious God, none of my sufferings are of any account, compared +with this, that I have grieved the eyes of my heavenly Father. This +is indeed hell, and a cross more intolerable than all other pain. O +heart of mine, harder than flint or adamant, why dost thou not break +for grief? Once I was called the bride of the eternal King, now I +deserve not to be called the meanest of his handmaids. Never again +shall I dare to raise mine eyes, for shame. O that I could hide +myself in some vast forest, with none to see or hear me, till I had +wept to my heart's desire. O Sin, Sin, whither hast thou brought me? +O deceitful World, woe to those who serve thee! Now I have thy +reward, I receive thy wages--namely, that I am a burden to myself +and the whole world, and always shall be. + +Wisdom. Thou must by no means despair; it was for thy sins and those +of others that I came into this world, that I might restore thee to +Thy heavenly Father, and bring thee back to greater glory and honour +than thou ever hadst before. + +Servitor. Ah, what is this, which whispers such flattering things to +a soul that is dead, abhorred, rejected? + +Wisdom. Dost thou not know Me? Why art thou so despondent? Art thou +beside thyself with excessive grief, My dearest son? Knowest thou +not that I am Wisdom, most gentle and tender, in whom is the Abyss +of infinite mercy, never yet explored perfectly even by all the +saints, but none the less open to thee and all other sorrowing +hearts. I am he who for thy sake willed to be poor and an exile, +that I might recall thee to thy former honour. I am He who bore a +bitter death, that I might restore thee to life. I am thy Brother; I +am thy Bridegroom. I have put away all the wrong that thou ever +didst against Me, even as if it had never been, only henceforth, +thou must turn wholly to Me, and never again forsake Me. Wash away +thy stains in My blood. Lift up thy head, open thine eyes, and take +heart. In token of reconciliation, take this ring and put it on thy +finger as My bride, put on this robe, and these shoes on thy feet, +and receive this sweet and loving name, that thou mayst both be and +be called for ever My bride. Thou has cost Me much labour and pain; +for that cause, the Abyss of My mercy toward thee is unfathomable. + +Servitor. O kindest Father, O sweetest Brother, O only joy of my +heart, wilt Thou be so favourable to my unworthy soul? What is this +grace? What is the Abyss of Thy clemency and mercy? From the bottom +of my heart I thank Thee, O heavenly Father, and beseech Thee by Thy +beloved Son, whom Thou hast willed to suffer a cruel death for love, +to forget my impieties. . . . + +Now, O Lord, I remember that most loving word, wherewith in the book +of Ecclesiasticus[43] Thou drawest us to Thyself. "Come to me, all +ye who desire me, and be filled with my fruits. I am the mother of +beautiful affection. My breath is sweeter than honey, and my +inheritance above honey and the honeycomb." "Wine and music rejoice +the heart, and above both is the love of Wisdom."[44] Of a surety, O +Lord, Thou showest Thyself so lovable and desirable, that it is no +wonder that the hearts of all long for Thee, and are tormented by +the desire of Thee. Thy words breathe love, and flow so sweetly, +that in many hearts the love of temporal things has wholly dried up. +Therefore, I greatly long to hear Thee speak of Thy lovableness. +Come, O Lord, my only comfort, speak to the heart of Thy servant. +For I sleep sweetly beneath Thy shadow, and my heart is awake. + +Wisdom. Hear, My son, and see; incline thine ear, forgetting thyself +and all other things. Lo, I in Myself am that ineffable Good, which +is and ever was; which has never been expressed nor ever will be. +For although I give Myself to be felt by men in their inmost hearts, +yet no tongue can ever declare or explain in words what I am. For +verily all the beauty, grace, and adornment which can be conceived +by thee or by others, exists in me far more excellently, more +pleasantly, more copiously, than any one could say in words. I am +the most loving Word of the Father, begotten from the pure substance +of the Father, and wondrously pleasing am I to His loving eyes in +the sweet and burning love of the Holy Spirit. I am the throne of +happiness, the crown of souls: most bright are Mine eyes, most +delicate My mouth, My cheeks are red and white, and all My +appearance is full of grace and loveliness. All the heavenly host +gaze upon Me with wonder and admiration; their eyes are ever fixed +upon Me, their hearts rest in Me, their minds turn to Me and turn +again. O thrice and four times happy is he, to whom it shall be +given to celebrate this play of love amid heavenly joys at My side, +holding My tender hands in happiest security, for ever and ever to +all eternity. Only the word that proceeds out of My sweet mouth +surpasses the melodies of all the angels, the sweet harmony of all +harps, and musical instruments of every kind.... + +Servitor. There are three things, O Lord, at which I marvel greatly. +The first is, that although Thou art in Thyself so exceedingly +loving, yet towards sin Thou art a most severe judge and avenger. +Alas, Thy face in wrath is too terrible; the words which Thou +speakest in anger pierce the heart and soul like fire. O holy and +adorable God, save me from Thy wrathful countenance, and defer not +till the future life my punishment. + +Wisdom. I am the unchangeable Good, remaining always the same. The +reason why I do not appear always the same, is on account of those +who do not behold Me in the same way. By nature I am friendly; yet +none the less I punish vice severely, so that I deserve to be +feared. From My friends I require a pure and filial fear, and a +friendly love, that fear may ever restrain them from sin, and that +love may join them to Me in unbroken loyalty. + +Servitor. What Thou sayest pleases me, O Lord, and it is as I would +have it. But there is another thing at which I greatly marvel--how +it is that when the soul is faint from desire of the sweetness of +Thy presence, Thou art wholly mute, and dost not utter a single word +that can be heard. And who, O Lord, would not be grieved, when Thou +showest Thyself so strange, so silent, to the soul that loves Thee +above all things? + +Wisdom. And yet all the creatures speak of Me. + +Servitor. But that is by no means enough for the soul that loves. + +Wisdom. Also every word that is uttered about Me is a message of My +love; all the voices of holy Scripture that are written about Me are +letters of love, sweet as honey. They are to be received as if I had +written them Myself. Ought not this to satisfy thee? + +Servitor. Nay but, O most holy God, dearest Friend of all to me, +Thou knowest well that a heart which is on fire with love is not +satisfied with anything that is not the Beloved himself, in whom is +its only comfort. Even though all the tongues of all the angelic +spirits were to speak to me, none the less would my unquenchable +love continue to yearn and strive for the one thing which it +desires. The soul that loves Thee would choose Thee rather than the +kingdom of heaven. Pardon me, O Lord: it would become Thee to show +more kindness to those who love Thee so ardently, who sigh and look +up to Thee and say: Return, return! Who anxiously debate with +themselves: alas, thinkest thou that thou hast offended Him? That He +has deserted thee? Thinkest thou that He will ever restore thee His +most sweet presence, that thou wilt ever again embrace Him with the +arms of Thy heart, and press Him to thy breast, that all thy grief +and trouble may vanish? All this, O Lord, Thou hearest and knowest, +and yet Thou art silent. + +Wisdom. Certainly I know all this, and I watch it with great +pleasure. But I would have thee also answer a few questions, since +thy wonder, though veiled, is so great. What is it which gives the +greatest joy to the highest of all created spirits? + +Servitor. Ah, Lord, this question is beyond my range. I prithee, +answer it Thyself. + +Wisdom. I will do as thou desirest. The highest angelic spirit finds +nothing more desirable or more delightful than to satisfy My will in +all things; so much so, that if he knew that it would redound to My +praise for him to root out nettles and tares, he would diligently +fulfil this task in preference to all others. + +Servitor. Of a truth, Lord, this answer of Thine touches me sharply. +I perceive that it is Thy will that I should be resigned in the +matter of receiving and feeling tokens of Thy love, and that I +should seek Thy glory alone, in dryness and hardness as well as in +sweetness. + +Wisdom. No resignation is more perfect or more excellent, than to be +resigned in dereliction. + +Servitor. And yet, O Lord, the pain is very grievous. + +Wisdom. Wherein is virtue proved, if not in adversity? But be +assured, that I often come, and try whether the door into My house +is open, but find Myself repulsed. Many times I am received like a +stranger, harshly treated, and then driven out of doors. Nay, I not +only come to the soul that loves me, but tarry with her like a +friend; but that is done so secretly, that none know it save those +who live quite detached and separated from men, and observe My ways, +and care only to please and satisfy My grace. For according to My +Divinity I am purest Spirit, and I am received spiritually in pure +spirits. + +Servitor. So far as I understand, Lord God, Thou art a very secret +Lover. How glad would I be if Thou wouldest give me some signs, by +which I might know Thee to be truly present. + +Wisdom. By no other way canst thou know the certainty of My presence +better, than when I hide Myself from thee, and withdraw what is Mine +from thy soul. Then at last thou knowest by experience what I am, +and what thou art. Of a surety I am everlasting Good, without whom +no one can have anything good. When therefore I impart that immense +Good, which is Myself, generously and lovingly, and scatter it +abroad, all things to which I communicate Myself are clothed with a +certain goodness, by which My presence can be as easily inferred, as +that of the Sun, the actual ball of which cannot be seen, by its +rays. If therefore thou ever feelest My presence, enter into +thyself, and learn how to separate the roses from the thorns, the +flowers from the weeds. + +Servitor. Lord, I do search, and I find within myself a great +diversity. When I am deserted by Thee, my soul is like a sick man, +whose taste is spoiled. Nothing pleases me, but all things disgust +me. My body is torpid, my mind oppressed; within is dryness, without +is sadness. All that I see or hear, however good in reality, is +distasteful and hateful to me. I am easily led into sins; I am weak +to resist my enemies; I am cold or lukewarm towards all good. +Whoever comes to me, finds my house empty. For the House-Father is +away, who knows how to counsel for the best, and to inspire the +whole household. On the other hand, when the day-star arises in my +inmost heart, all the pain quickly vanishes, all the darkness is +dispelled, and a great brightness arises and shines forth. My heart +laughs, my mind is exalted, my soul becomes cheerful, all things +around me are blithe and merry; whatever is around me and within me +is turned to Thy praise. That which before seemed hard, difficult, +irksome, impossible, becomes suddenly easy and pleasant. To give +myself to fasting, watching, and prayer, to suffer or abstain or +avoid, in a word all the hardnesses of life seem when compared with +Thy presence to have no irksomeness at all. My soul is bathed in +radiance, truth, and sweetness, so that all its labours are +forgotten. My heart delights itself in abundant sweet meditations, +my tongue learns to speak of high things, my body is brisk and ready +for any undertaking; whoever comes to ask my advice, takes back with +him high counsels such as he desired to hear. In short, I seem to +myself to have transcended the limits of time and space, and to be +standing on the threshold of eternal bliss. But who, O Lord, can +secure for me, that I may be long in this state? Alas, in a moment +it is withdrawn from me; and for a long space again I am left as +naked and destitute as if I had never experienced anything of the +kind; till at last, after many and deep sighings of heart, it is +restored to me. Is this Thou, O Lord, or rather I myself? Or what is +it? + +Wisdom. Of thyself thou hast nothing except faults and defects. +Therefore that about which thou askest is I Myself, and this is the +play of love. + +Servitor. What is the play of love? + +Wisdom. So long as the loved one is present with the lover, the +lover knoweth not how dear the loved one is to him; it is only +separation which can teach him that. + +Servitor. It is a very grievous game. But tell me, Lord, are there +any who in this life no longer experience these vicissitudes of Thy +presence? + +Wisdom. You will find very few indeed. For never to be deprived of +My presence belongs not to temporal but to eternal life. + +APHORISMS AND MAXIMS + +ACT according to the truth in simplicity; and, whatever happens, do +not help thyself; for he who helps himself too much will not be +helped by the Truth. + +God wishes not to deprive us of pleasure; but He wishes to give us +pleasure in its totality--that is, all pleasure. + +Wilt thou be of use to all creatures? Then turn thyself away from +all creatures. + +If a man cannot comprehend a thing, let him remain quiet, and it +will comprehend him. + +Say to the creatures, I will not be to thee what thou art to me. + +The power of abstaining from things gives us more power than the +possession of them would. + +Some men one meets who have been inwardly drawn by God, but have not +followed Him. The inner man and the outer man in these cases are +widely at variance, and in this way many fail. + +He who has attained to the purgation of his senses in God performs +all the operations of the senses all the better. + +He who finds the inward in the outward goes deeper than he who only +finds the inward in the inward. + +He is on the right road who contemplates under the forms of things +their eternal essence. + +It is well with a man who has died to self and begun to live in +Christ. + + + + + + +RUYSBROEK + +THE ADORNMENT OF THE SPIRITUAL NUPTIALS + +BOOK I + + + + + +PREFACE + +"SEE the Bridegroom cometh: go forth to meet Him." St Matthew the +evangelist wrote these words, and Christ said them to His disciples +and to all men, in the Parable of the Ten Virgins. The Bridegroom is +our Lord Jesus Christ, and human nature is the bride, whom God has +made in His own image and likeness. He placed her at first in the +most exalted, the most beautiful, the richest and most fertile place +on earth--in paradise. He subjected to her all the creatures; He +adorned her with graces; and He laid a prohibition upon her, in +order that by obedience she might deserve to be established in an +eternal union with her Bridegroom, and never more fall into any +affliction, trouble, or guilt. Then came a deceiver--the infernal, +envious foe, under the guise of a cunning serpent. He deceived the +woman, and the two together deceived the man, who possessed the +essence of human nature. So the enemy despoiled human nature, the +bride of God, by his deceitful counsels, and she was driven into a +strange country; poor and miserable, a prisoner and oppressed, +persecuted by her enemies, as if she could never more return to her +country and the grace of reconciliation. But when God saw that the +time was come, and took pity on the sufferings of His beloved, He +sent His only Son to earth, in a rich abode and a glorious +temple--that is to say, in the body of the Virgin Mary. There he +married His bride, our nature, and united it to His Person, by means +of the pure blood of the noble Virgin. The priest who joined the +Bride and Bridegroom was the Holy Spirit; the angel Gabriel +announced the marriage, and the blessed Virgin gave her consent. So +Christ, our faithful Bridegroom, united our nature to His, and +visited us in a strange land, and taught us the manners of heaven +and perfect fidelity. And He laboured and fought like a champion +against our enemy, and He broke the prison and gained the victory, +and His death slew our death, and His blood delivered us, and He set +us free in baptism under the life-giving waters, and enriched us by +His sacraments and gifts, that we might go forth, as He said, +adorned with all virtues, and might meet Him in the abode of His +glory, to enjoy Him throughout all eternity. + +Now the Master of truth, Christ, saith: "See, the Bridegroom +cometh, go forth to meet Him." In these words Jesus, our Lover, +teaches us four things. In the first word He gives a command, for He +says, "See." Those who remain blind, and those who resist this +command are condemned without exception. In the next word He shows +us what we shall see--that is to say, the coming of the Bridegroom, +when He says, "The Bridegroom cometh." In the third place, He +teaches us and commands us what we ought to do, when He says, "Go +forth." In the fourth place, when He says, "to meet Him," He shows +us the reward of all our works and of all our life, for that must be +a loving "going forth," by which we meet our Bridegroom. + +We shall explain and analyse these words in three ways, first, +according to the ordinary mode of the beginner's life--that is to +say, the active life, which is necessary to all who would be saved. +In the second place, we shall analyse these words by applying them +to the inner life, exalted and loving, to which many men arrive by +the virtues and by the grace of God. Thirdly, we shall explain them +by applying them to the superessential and contemplative life, to +which few attain and which few can taste, because of the supreme +sublimity of this life. + +ON THE ACTIVE LIFE + +CHRIST, the Wisdom of the Father, hath said from the time of Adam +and still saith (inwardly, according to His Divinity), to all men, +"See"; and this vision is necessary. Now let us observe attentively +that for him who wishes to see materially or spiritually, three +things are necessary. First, in order that a man may be able to see +materially, he must have the external light of heaven, or another +natural light, in order that the medium--that is to say, the air +across which one sees, may be illuminated. In the second place, he +must have the will, that the things which he will see may be +reflected in his eyes. Thirdly, he must have the instruments, his +eyes, healthy and without flaw, that the material objects may be +exactly reflected in them. If a man lacks any one of these three +things, his material vision disappears. We shall speak no more of +this vision, but of another, spiritual and supernatural, wherein all +our blessedness resides. + +Three things are necessary for spiritual and supernatural vision. +First, the light of the divine grace, then the free conversion of +the will towards God, and lastly, a conscience pure from all mortal +sin. Now observe: God being a God common to all, and His boundless +love being common to all, He grants a double grace; both antecedent +grace, and the grace by which one merits eternal life. All men, +heathens and Jews, good and bad, have in common antecedent grace. In +consequence of the common love of God towards all men, He has caused +to be preached and published His name and the deliverance of human +nature, even to the ends of the earth. He who wishes to be converted +can be converted. For God wishes to save all men and to lose none. +At the day of judgment none will be able to complain that enough was +not done for him, if he had wished to be converted. So God is a +common Light and Splendour which illumine heaven and earth, and men +according to their merits and their needs. But though God is common, +and though the sun shines on all trees, some trees remain without +fruit, and others bear wild fruit useless to mankind. This is why we +prune these trees and graft fertile branches upon them, that they +may bear good fruit, sweet to taste and useful for men. The fertile +branch which comes from the living paradise of the eternal kingdom, +is the light of divine grace. No work can have savour, or be useful +to man, unless it comes from this branch. This branch of divine +grace, which makes man acceptable and by which we merit eternal +life, is offered to all. But it is not grafted on all, for they will +not purge away the wild branches of their trees--that is to say, +unbelief or a perverse will, or disobedience to the commandments of +God. But in order that this branch of divine grace may be planted in +our soul, three things are necessary; the antecedent grace of God, +the conversion of our free will, and the purification of the +conscience. Antecedent grace touches all men; but all men do not +attain to free conversion and purification of the conscience, and +this is why the grace of God, by which they might merit eternal +life, fails to touch them. The antecedent grace of God touches man +from within or from without. From without, by sickness or loss of +outward goods, of relations and friends, or by public shame; or +perhaps a man is moved by preaching, or by the examples of saints +and just men, by their words or works, till he comes to the +knowledge of himself. This is how God touches us from without. +Sometimes also a man is touched from within, by recalling the pains +and sufferings of our Lord, and the good which God has done to him +and to all men, or by the consideration of his sins, of the +shortness of life, of the eternal pains of hell and the eternal joys +of heaven, or because God has spared him in his sins and has waited +for his conversion; or he observes the marvellous works of God in +heaven, on earth, and in all creation. These are the works of +antecedent divine grace, which touch man from within or from +without, and in divers manners. And man has still a natural +inclination towards God, proceeding from the spark of his soul or +synteresis, [Footnote: See Introduction] and from the highest +reason, which always desires the good and hates the evil. Now, in +these three manners God touches every man according to his needs, so +that the man is struck, warned, frightened, and stops to consider +himself. All this is still antecedent grace and not merited; it thus +prepares us to receive the other grace, by which we merit eternal +life; when the mind is thus empty of bad wishes and bad deeds, +warned, struck, in fear of what it ought to do, and considers God, +and considers itself with its evil deeds. Thence come a natural +sorrow for sin and a natural good will. This is the highest work of +antecedent grace. + +When man does what he can, and can go no further because of his +weakness, it is the infinite goodness of God which must finish this +work. Then comes a higher splendour of the grace of God, like a ray +of the sun, and it is poured upon the soul, though it is as yet +neither merited nor desired. In this light God gives Himself, by +free will and by bounty, and no one can merit it before he has it. +And it is in the soul an internal and mysterious operation of God, +above time, and it moves the soul and all its faculties. Here then +ends antecedent grace; and here begins the other--that is to say, +supernatural light. + +This light is the first necessary condition, and from it is born a +second spiritual condition--that is to say, a free conversion of the +will in a moment of time, and then love is born in the union of God +and the soul. These two conditions are connected, so that one cannot +be accomplished without the other. There, where God and the soul are +united in the unity of love, God grants His light above time, and +the sou! freely turns to God by the force of grace, in a moment of +time, and charity is born in the soul, from God and the soul, for +charity is a bond of love between God and the loving soul. From +these two things, the grace of God, and the free conversion of the +will illuminated by grace, is born charity--that is to say, divine +love. And from divine love proceeds the third point, the +purification of the conscience. And this is accomplished in the +consideration of sin and of the flaws in the soul, and because man +loves God, there enters into him a contempt for self and for all his +works. This is the order of conversion. From it are born a true +repentance and a perfect sorrow for the evil that we have done, and +an ardent desire to sin no more and to serve God henceforward in +humble obedience; from it are born a sincere confession, without +reserves, without duplicity and without pretences, the desire to +satisfy God and to undertake the practice of all the virtues and all +good works. These three things, as you have just heard, are +necessary for divine vision. If you possess them, Christ says to +you, "See," and you become really seeing. This is the first of the +four chief ways in which Christ, our Lord, says "See." + +ON THE FIRST COMING OF CHRIST, IN THE FLESH + +NEXT, He shows us what we shall see when He says, "The Bridegroom +cometh." Christ, our Bridegroom, says this word in Latin: Venit. +The word expresses two tenses, the past and the present, and yet +here it indicates the future. And this is why we must consider three +comings of our Bridegroom Jesus Christ. At His first coming He was +made man for love of man. The second coming is daily and frequent in +every loving soul, with new graces and new gifts, as man is able to +receive them. In the third coming, He will come manifestly on the +dreadful day of judgment or at the hour of each man's death. In all +these comings we must observe three things, the cause, the interior +mode, and the external work. + +The cause of the creation of angels and men is the infinite goodness +and nobleness of God; He wished that the wealth and blessedness, +which are Himself, should be revealed to reasonable creatures, for +them to enjoy in time, and in eternity above time. The reason why +God became man, is His inconceivable love, and the distress of all +men, lost since the fall in original sin, and unable to raise +themselves again. But the reason why Christ, according to His +divinity and His humanity, accomplished His works on earth, is +fourfold--namely, His divine love, which is without measure; the +created love, which is called charity, and which He had in His soul +by the union of the Eternal Word and the perfect gift of His Father; +the great distress of human nature; and the glory of His Father. +These are the reasons for the coming of Christ, our Bridegroom, and +for all His works, exterior and interior. + +Now we must observe in Jesus Christ, if we wish to follow Him in His +virtues according to our powers, the mode or condition which He had +within, and the works which He wrought without, for they are virtues +and the acts of virtues. + +The mode which He had according to His divinity is inaccessible and +incomprehensible to us, for it is after this mode that He is +continually born of the Father, and that the Father in Him and by +Him knows and creates and orders, and rules everything in heaven and +on earth; for He is the Wisdom of the Father, and from them flows +spiritually a Spirit--that is to say, a love, which is the bond +between them and the bond of all the saints and just persons on +earth and in heaven. We will speak no more of this mode but of the +created mode which He had by these divine gifts and according to His +humanity. These modes are singularly multiform; for Christ had as +many modes as He had interior virtues, for each virtue has its +special mode. These virtues and these modes were, in the mind of +Christ, above the intelligence and above the comprehension of all +creatures. But let us take three--namely, humility, charity, and +interior or exterior suffering in patience. These are the three +principal roots and origins of all virtues and all perfection. + +ON THE TWOFOLD HUMILITY OF CHRIST + +NOW understand: there are two kinds of humility in Jesus Christ, +according to His divinity. First, He willed to become man; and this +nature, which was accursed even to the depth of hell, He accepted +according to His personality and was willing to unite Himself to it. +So that every man, good or bad, may say, Jesus Christ, the Son of +God, is my brother. Secondly, He chose for mother a poor virgin, and +not a king's daughter, so that this poor virgin became the mother of +God, who is the only Lord of heaven and earth and all creatures. In +consequence, of all the works of humility which Christ ever +accomplished, one may say that God accomplished them. Now let us +take the humility which was in Jesus Christ according to His +humanity and by grace and divine gifts; according to His humility +His soul inclined with all its power in respect and veneration +before the power of the Father. For an inclined heart is a humble +heart. This is why He did all His works to the praise and glory of +the Father, and sought in nothing His own glory according to His +humanity. He was humble, and submitted to the old law, and to the +commandments, and often to the customs. He was circumcised, and +carried to the Temple, and redeemed according to usages, and He paid +taxes to Caesar like other Jews. And He submitted Himself humbly to +His mother and to Joseph, and served them with a sincere deference +according to their needs. He chose for friends--for apostles--the poor +and the despised, in order to convert the world. In his intercourse +with them and all others He was humble and modest. This is why He +was at the disposal of all men, in whatever distress they were, +within or without; He was, as it were, the servant of the whole +world. This is what we find first in Jesus Christ, our Bridegroom. + +ON THE LOVE OF CHRIST, ADORNED WITH ALL VIRTUES + +NEXT comes charity, the beginning and source of all virtues. This +charity maintained the supreme forces of His soul in tranquillity, +and in the enjoyment of the same blessedness which He enjoys at +present. And this same charity kept Him continually exalted towards +His Father, with veneration, love, praise, respect, with internal +prayers for the need of all men, and with the offering of all His +works to the glory of God the Father. And this same charity made +Christ still overflow with love and kindness towards all the +material or spiritual needs of mankind. This is why He has given, by +His life, the model after which all men should fashion their lives. +He has given spiritual nourishment to all well-disposed men by real +internal teachings, as well as by outward miracles. We cannot +comprehend His charity to its full extent, for it flowed from the +unfathomable fountains of the Holy Spirit, above all the creatures +who have ever received charity, for He was God and man in one +Person. This is the second point of charity. + +ON THE PATIENCE OF CHRIST, EVEN UNTO DEATH + +THE third point is to suffer in patience. We will examine this +seriously, for it is this which adorned Christ, our Bridegroom, +during all His life. He suffered when He was newly born, from +poverty and cold. He was circumcised and shed his blood. He was +obliged to fly into a foreign country. He served Joseph and His +mother, He suffered from hunger and thirst, from shame and contempt +and from the wicked words and deeds of the Jews. He fasted, He +watched, and was tempted by the enemy. He was subject to all men, He +went from district to district, from town to town, to preach the +gospel painfully and zealously. Finally, He was taken by the Jews, +who were His enemies and whom He loved. He was betrayed, mocked, +insulted, scourged, struck, and condemned on false testimony. He +carried His cross with great pain to the mount of Calvary. He was +stripped naked as at His birth, and never was seen a body so +beautiful, nor a mother so unhappy. He endured shame, pain, and cold +before all the world, for He was naked, and it was cold, and He was +exhausted by His wounds. He was nailed with large nails to the wood +of the cross, and was so strained that His veins were burst. He was +lifted up and shaken upon the cross, so as to make His wounds bleed, +His head was crowned with thorns, and His ears heard the fierce Jews +crying out, "Crucify Him! crucify Him!" and many other shameful +words. His eyes saw the obstinacy and wickedness of the Jews, and +the distress of His mother, and His eyes were extinguished under the +bitterness of pain and death. His mouth and palate were hurt by the +vinegar and gall, and all the sensitive parts of His body wounded by +the scourge. + +Behold then Christ, our Bridegroom, wounded to death, abandoned by +God and the creatures, dying on the cross, hanging from a post, with +no one to care much for Him except Mary, His unhappy mother, who +nevertheless could not aid Him. And Christ suffered moreover +spiritually, in His soul, from the hardness of the Jews' hearts and +those who made Him die, for in spite of the prodigies and miracles +which they saw, they remained in their wickedness; and He suffered +by reason of their corruption and the vengeance which God was about +to inflict upon them, in body and soul, for His death. He suffered +moreover for the grief and misery of His mother and disciples, who +were in great sadness. And He suffered because His death would be +wasted for many men, and for the ingratitude of many, and for the +blasphemies of those who would curse Him who died for love of us. +And His nature and interior reason suffered because God withdrew +from them the inflow of His gifts and consolations, and abandoned +them to themselves in such distress. Therefore Christ complained and +said, My God, my God, why hast Thou forsaken me? + +Behold then the interior virtues of Christ; humility, charity, and +suffering in patience. These three virtues Jesus, our Bridegroom, +practised throughout His life, and He died in them, and He paid our +debt by satisfying justice, and opened His side in His bounty. And +thence flow rivers of delight, and sacraments of blessedness. And He +was exalted to His power, and sat at the right hand of the Father, +and reigns eternally. This is the first coming of our Bridegroom, +and it is completely past. + +ON THE SECOND COMING OF CHRIST, HOW HE EVERY DAY FLOWS INTO OUR +HEARTS WITH NEW GRACE + +THE second coming of Christ, our Bridegroom, takes place every day +in just men. We do not wish to speak here of the first conversion of +man, nor of the first grace which was given him when he was +converted from sin to virtue. But we wish to speak of a daily +increase of new gifts and new virtues, and of a more actual coming +of Christ, our Bridegroom, into our soul. Now we must observe the +cause, the mode, and the work, of this coming. The cause is fourfold; +the mercy of God, our misery, the divine generosity, and our +desire. These four causes make the virtues grow and increase. + +Now understand. When the sun sends forth its bright rays into a deep +valley between two high mountains, and while it is at the zenith, so +that it can illuminate the depths of the valley, a triple phenomenon +occurs; for the valley is lighted from the mountains, and it becomes +warmer and more fertile than the plain. In the same way, when a just +man sinks in his misery, and recognises that he has nothing, and is +nothing, that he can neither halt nor go forward by his own +strength; and when he perceives also that he fails often in virtues +and good works, he thus confesses his poverty and distress, and +forms the valley of humility. And because he is humble and in need, +and because he confesses his need, he makes his plaint to the +kindness and mercy of God. He is conscious of the sublimity of God, +and of his own abasement. + +Thus he becomes a deep valley. And Christ is the sun of justice and +mercy, which burns at the meridian of the firmament--that is to say, +at the right hand of the Father, and shines even to the bottom of +humble hearts; for Christ is always moved by distress, when man +humbly offers to Him complaints and prayers. Then the two mountains +rise--that is to say, a double desire, in the first place a desire to +serve and love God by his merits, in the second place to obtain +excellent virtues. These two desires are higher than heaven, for +they touch God without any intermediary, and desire His immense +generosity. Then that generosity cannot be kept back, it must flow, +for the soul is at this moment susceptible of receiving countless +boons. + +These are the causes of the second coming of Christ, with new +virtues. Then the valley--that is to say, the humble heart, receives +three things. It is enlightened the more, and illuminated by grace, +and warmed by charity, and becomes more fertile in virtues and good +works. Thus you have the cause, the mode, and the work, of this +coming. + +HOW WE MAY MAKE DAILY PROGRESS BY THE SACRAMENTS OF THE CHURCH + +THERE is yet another coming of Christ, our Bridegroom, which takes +place every day, in the growth of grace and in new gifts--that is to +say, when a man receives some sacrament with a humble and +well-prepared heart. He receives then new gifts and more ample +graces, by reason of his humility, and by the internal and secret +work of Christ in the sacrament. That which is contrary to the +sacrament is in baptism the want of faith, in confession the want of +contrition; it is to go to the sacrament of the altar in a state of +mortal sin, or of bad will; and it is the same with the other +sacraments. + +ON THE THIRD COMING OF CHRIST, TO JUDGMENT + +THE third coming, which is still future, will take place at the last +judgment or at the hour of death. Christ, our Bridegroom and our +Judge at this judgment, will recompense and avenge according to +justice, for He will award to each according to his deserts. He +gives to every just man, for every good work done in the spirit of +the Lord, a reward without measure, which no creature can merit-- +namely, Himself. But as He co-operates in the creature, the creature +deserves, through His merit, to have a reward. And by a necessary +justice He gives eternal pains to those who have rejected an eternal +good for a perishable. + +ON THE THIRD SPIRITUAL GOING FORTH, TO ALL THE VIRTUES + +NOW understand and observe. Christ says at the beginning of our +text, "See"--that is to say, see by charity and pureness of +conscience, as you have been told. Now, He has shown us what we +shall see--namely, His three comings. + +He orders us what we must do next, and says, "Go forth" if you have +fulfilled the first necessary condition--that is to say, if you see +in grace and in charity, and if you have well observed your model, +Christ, in His "going forth"; there leaps up in you, from your love +and loving observation of your Bridegroom, an ardour of justice-- +that is to say, a desire to follow Him in virtue. Then Christ says +in you, "Go forth." This going forth must have three modes. We must +go forth towards God, towards ourselves, and towards our neighbour +by charity and justice; for charity always pushes upward, towards +the kingdom of God, which is God Himself; for He is the source from +which it flowed without any intermediary, and He remains always +immanent in it. The justice which is born of charity wishes to +perfect the manners and the virtues which are suitable to the +kingdom of God--that is to say, to the soul. These two things, +charity and justice, establish a solid foundation in the kingdom of +the soul where God may dwell, and this foundation is humility. These +three virtues support all the weight and all the edifice of all the +virtues and all sublimity; for charity maintains man in presence of +the unfathomable good things of God from whence it flows, so that it +perseveres in God, and increases in all the virtues and in true +humility; and justice maintains man in presence of the eternal truth +of God, so that truth may be discovered by him, and that he may be +illuminated, and may accomplish all the virtues without error. But +humility maintains man always before the supreme power of God, so +that he remains always abased and little, and abandons himself to +God, and holds no longer by himself. This is the way in which a man +must bear himself before God, that he may grow alway in new virtues. + +HOW HUMILITY IS THE FOUNDATION OF ALL THE VIRTUES + +NOW understand; for having made humility the base of everything, we +must speak first of it. Humility is the desire of abasement or of +depth--that is to say, an inclination or internal desire for +abasement of heart and conscience before the sublimity of God. The +justice of God exacts this submission, and, thanks to charity, the +loving heart cannot abandon it. When the loving and humble man +considers that God has served him so humbly, so lovingly, and so +faithfully, and then that God is so high, so powerful, and so noble, +and that man is so poor, little, and base, there is born from all +this, in the humble heart, an immense respect and reverence towards +God; for to reverence God in all works, within and without, is the +first and most delightful work of humility, the sweetest work of +charity, and the most suitable work of justice. For the humble and +loving heart cannot pay honours to God and His noble humanity, nor +abase himself so deeply as to satisfy his desire. That is why it +seems to the humble man that he always does too little in honour of +God and in his humble service. And he is humble, and venerates Holy +Church and the sacraments, and he is temperate in meat and drink, in +his words, and in all relations of life. He is content with poor +raiment, with menial employment, and his face is naturally humble, +without pretence. And he is hunible in his practices, within and +without, before God and before men, that none may be offended by +reason of him. Thus he tames and removes far from him all pride, +which is the cause and origin of all sins. Humility breaks the +snares of sin, the world, and the Devil. And man is ordered within +himself, and established in the very place of virtue. Heaven is open +to him, and God is inclined to hear his prayer, and he is loaded +with graces. And Christ, the solid stone, is his support, and he who +builds his virtues upon humility cannot go wrong. + +ON OBEDIENCE + +FROM this humility is born obedience, for only the humble man can be +inwardly obedient. Obedience is a submission and pliant disposition, +and a good will ready for all that is good. Obedience subjects a man +to orders, to prohibitions, and to the will of God, and it subjects +the soul and sensual force to the highest reason, in such a way that +the man lives suitably and reasonably. And it makes men submissive +and obedient to Holy Church and to the sacraments, and to all the +good practices of holy Christianity. It prepares man, and makes him +ready for the service of all, in works, in bodily and spiritual +care, according to the needs of each, and prudence. Also, it drives +far away disobedience, which is the daughter of pride, and which we +ought to flee from more than from poison. Obedience in will and work +adorns, extends, and manifests the humility of man. It gives peace +to cloisters, and if it exists in the prelate, as it ought to exist, +it attracts those who are under his orders. It maintains peace and +equality among equals. And he who observes it is beloved by those +who are above him, and the gifts of God, which are eternal, elevate +and enrich him. + +ON THE ABDICATION OF OUR OWN WILL + +FROM this obedience is born the abdication of our own will. By this +abdication the substance and occasion of pride are repulsed, and the +greatest humility is accomplished. And God rules the man as He +wills; and the will of the man is so well united to that of God that +he can neither wish nor desire anything otherwise. He has put off +the old man, and has put on the new man, renewed and perfect +according to the divine will. It is of such an one that Christ said, +"Blessed are the poor in spirit," that is, those who have renounced +their will--"for theirs is the kingdom of heaven." + +ON PATIENCE + +FROM the abandonment of the will is born patience; for no one can +be perfectly patient in everything, except he who has submitted his +will to the will of God, and to all men in things useful and +convenient. Patience is a tranquil endurance of all that can happen +to a man, whether sent by God or by men. Nothing can trouble the +patient man, neither the loss of earthly goods, nor the loss of +friends or relations, nor sickness, nor disgrace, nor life, nor +death, nor purgatory, nor the devil, nor hell. For he has abandoned +himself to the will of God in true love. And, provided that mortal +sin does not touch him, all that God orders for him in time or +eternity seems light. This patience adorns a man, and arms him +against anger and sudden rage, and against impatience of suffering, +which often deceives a man within and without, and exposes him to +manifold temptations. + +ON GENTLENESS + +FROM this patience are born gentleness and kindness, for no one can +be gentle under adversity if not the patient man. Gentleness creates +in man peace and repose from everything; for the gentle man endures +insulting words and gestures, and bad faces and bad deeds, and all +manner of injustice towards his friends and himself, and he is +content with all, for gentleness is suffering in repose. Thanks to +gentleness, the force of anger remains immovable in its +tranquillity, the force of desire lifts itself up towards the +virtues, and the reason rejoices, and the conscience dwells in +peace, for the other mortal sins, such as anger and rage, are +removed far from her. For the Spirit of God reposes in a gentle and +humble heart, as Christ saith, "Blessed are the meek, for they shall +inherit the earth"--that is to say, their own nature and the things +of earth in meekness, and, after this life, the things of eternity. + +ON KINDNESS + +FROM the same source as gentleness comes kindness, for the gentle +spirit alone can possess kindness. This kindness causes a man to +oppose a loving face and friendly words, and all the works of pity, +to those who are angry with him, and he hopes that they will return +to themselves and amend. Thanks to mercy and kindness, charity +remains lively and fruitful in a man; for the heart full of kindness +is like a lamp full of precious oil; and the oil of kindness +lightens the wandering sinner by its good example, and soothes and +heals by consoling words and deeds those whose heart is wounded, +saddened, or irritated. And it inflames and illumines those who are +in charity, and no jealousy or envy can touch it. + +ON COMPASSION + +FROM kindness is born compassion, by which we sympathise with every +one, for no one can suffer with all men, except he who has kindness. +Compassion is an inward movement of the heart, aroused by pity for +the bodily or spiritual distress of all men. This compassion makes a +man partaker in Christ's sufferings, when he considers the reason of +these sufferings, the resignation and love of Christ, His wounds, +His tortures, His shame, His nobleness, His misery, the shame which +He endured, the crown, the nails, and the death in patience. These +unheard of and manifold pains of Christ, our Redeemer and +Bridegroom, move to pity anyone who is capable of feeling pity. +Compassion makes a man observe and note his faults, his want of +power to do any good thing, and weakness in all that pertains to the +glory of God; his lukewarmness and slowness, the multitude of his +faults, the waste of his time, and his positive shortcomings in +virtue and good conduct. All this makes a man truly sorry for +himself. Then his compassion for himself makes him consider his +errors and wanderings, the small care which he has of God and of his +eternal salvation, his ingratitude for all the good that God has +done him, and for all that He has suffered for man. And he considers +also that he is a stranger to the virtues, that he neither knows +them nor practises them, while he is clever and crafty in all that +is bad and unjust; he sees how attentive he is to the loss or gain +of worldly goods, how inattentive and indifferent towards God, the +things of eternity, and his own salvation. This consideration makes +the just man feel a great compassion towards the salvation of all +men. The man will also observe with pity the bodily needs of his +neighbour and the manifold pains of nature, when he sees the hunger +which men suffer, the thirst, cold, nakedness, poverty, contempt, +and oppression; the sadness which they feel at the loss of +relations, friends, goods, honour, and repose; and the innumerable +afflictions to which flesh is heir. All this rouses the just man to +compassion, and he suffers with all men; but his greatest suffering +arises when he sees the impatience of others under their own +sufferings, by which they lose their reward and often deserve hell. +This is the work of compassion and pity. + +This work of compassion and love for all men overcomes and removes +the third mortal sin--namely, hatred and envy; for compassion is a +wound of the heart, which makes us love all men, and can only work +healing in so far as some suffering lives in men; for God has +ordained that mourning and pain must precede all the other virtues. +This is why Christ said, "Blessed are they that mourn, for they +shall be comforted"--that is to say, when they shall reap in joy what +they now sow in compassion and sorrow. + +ON GENEROSITY + +FROM this compassion is born generosity, for no one can be +supernaturally generous, with faith in all men, and with love, +except the merciful man; though one many give to a particular +individual without charity, and without supernatural generosity. + +Generosity is the copious outflow of a heart moved with charity and +pity. When a man considers with compassion the sufferings and pains +of Christ, from this compassion is born generosity, which excites us +to praise and thank Christ for His pains and for His love, at the +same time that it causes to be born in us respect and veneration, +and a joyous and humble submission of heart and soul, in time and in +eternity. When a man observes and pities himself, and considers the +good that God has done to him and his own weakness, he cannot help +flowing out into the liberality of God, taking refuge in His pity +and fidelity, and abandoning himself to God, with a free and perfect +wish to serve Him for ever. The generous man, who observes the +errors, the wanderings, and the injustice of men, desires and +implores the outflow of the divine gifts and the exercise of their +generosity on all men, that they may return to themselves and be +converted to the truth. The generous man considers also with +compassion the material needs of all men; he helps them, gives, +lends, consoles to the best of his power. By means of this +generosity, men practise the seven works of mercy, the rich by their +services and the bestowal of their goods, the poor by good will and +the desire to do good if they can, and thus the virtue of generosity +is perfected. Generosity in the depth of the heart multiplies all +the virtues, and illuminates the forces of the soul. For the +generous, man is always of joyful spirit, he is without anxiety; he +is full of sympathy, and is ready to do kindnesses to all men in the +works of virtue. He who is generous, and loves not the things of +earth, however poor he may be, is like unto God, for all that he +has, and all the thoughts of his heart flow out of him in largess. +And so he is delivered from the fourth of the deadly sins, avarice. +Jesus Christ saith to these: "Blessed are the merciful, for they +shall obtain mercy"; in the day when they shall hear this word +spoken unto them: "Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the +kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world." + +ON ZEAL AND DILIGENCE + +FROM this generosity are born supernatural zeal and diligence in all +the virtues. None can exhibit this zeal, save the generous and +diligent man. This is an internal and eager impulse towards all the +virtues, and towards the imitation of Christ and the saints. In this +zeal, a man desires to expend in the honour of God the united powers +of his heart and senses, his soul and body, all that he is, and all +that he may receive. This zeal makes a man watchful in reason and +discrimination, and makes him practise the virtues in justice. +Thanks to this supernatural zeal, all the forces of his soul are +open to God, and prepared for all the virtues. His conscience is +refreshed, and divine grace is increased, virtue is practised with +joy, and his external works are adorned. He who has received this +lively zeal from God is removed far from the fifth deadly +sin--lukewarmness and gloominess towards the virtues necessary for +salvation. [Footnote: The best account in English of the deadly sin +of acedia, too much neglected in modern religious teaching, is to be +found in Bishop Paget's Spirit of Discipline.] And sometimes this +lively zeal disperses heaviness and sluggishness of the bodily +temperament. It is on this subject that Jesus Christ says: "Blessed +are they who hunger and thirst after righteousness, for they shall +be filled." This will be, when the glory of God shall be manifested, +and shall fill every man in proportion to his love and justice. + +ON TEMPERANCE AND SOBRIETY + +FROM zeal are born temperance and sobriety within and without; for +none can maintain true moderation in sobriety, if he is not +thoroughly diligent and zealous to preserve his body and soul in +justice. Sobriety separates the higher faculties from the animal +faculties, and preserves a man from excesses. Sobriety wishes not to +taste nor know those things which are not permitted. + +The incomprehensible and sublime nature of God surpasses all the +creatures in heaven and earth, for whatever the creature conceives +is creature. But God is above every creature, and within and without +every creature, and all created comprehension is too strait to +comprehend Him. In order that the creature may conceive and +comprehend God, it must be drawn up into God from above; it is only +by God that it can comprehend God. Those then who wish to know what +God is, and to study Him, let them know that it is forbidden. They +would become mad. All created light must fail here. What God is, +passes the comprehension of every creature. But Holy Scripture, +nature, and all the creatures show us that He is. We shall believe +the articles of faith without trying to penetrate them, for that is +impossible while we are here: this is sobriety. The difficult and +subtle teachings of the inspired writings we shall only explain in +accordance with the life of Christ and His saints. Man will study +nature and the Scriptures, and every creature; and will seek to +learn from them only what may be to his own advantage. This is +sobriety of spirit. + +A man will maintain sobriety of the senses, and he will subdue by +reason his animal faculties, that the animal pleasure in food and +drink may not delight him too much, but that he may eat and drink as +a sick man takes a potion, because it is his duty to preserve his +strength for the service of God. This is sobriety of body. A man +will preserve moderation in words and actions, in silence and +speech, in eating and drinking, in what he does and abstains from +doing, as Holy Church enjoins and the saints give the example. + +By moderation and sobriety of spirit within, a man maintains +constancy and perseverance in the faith, that purity of intelligence +and calmness of reason which are necessary to understand the truth, +readiness to bend to the will of God with regard to every virtue, +peace of heart and serenity of conscience. Thanks to this virtue, he +possesses assured peace in God and in himself. + +By moderation and sobriety in the use of the bodily faculties, he +often preserves health and contentment of the bodily nature, his +honour in external relations, and his good name. And thus he is at +peace with himself and with his neighbour. For he attracts and +rejoices all men of good will, by his moderation and sobriety. And +he escapes the sixth deadly sin, which is want of temperance, and +gluttony. It is of this that Christ said: "Blessed are the +peacemakers, for they shall be called the children of God." For +being like unto the Son, who has made peace in all creatures who +desire it, and who make peace in their turn, by moderation and +sobriety, the Son will divide among them the heritage of His Father, +and they will possess this heritage with Him throughout eternity. + +ON PURITY + +FROM this sobriety are born purity of soul and body, for none can be +absolutely pure in body and soul, save he who follows after sobriety +in body and soul. Purity of spirit consists in this--that a man +cleaves to no creature with any passionate desire, but attaches +himself to God only; for one may use all the creatures while +rejoicing in God only. Purity of spirit makes a man attach himself +to God above intelligence and above the senses, and above all the +gifts which God may bestow upon the soul; for all that the creature +receives in its intelligence or in its senses purity desires to +transcend, and to repose in God only. We should approach the +sacrament of the altar not for the sake of the delights, the +pleasure, the peace, or the sweetness which we find there, but for +the glory of God only, and that we may grow in all the virtues. This +is purity of spirit. + +Purity of heart signifies that a man turns towards God without +hesitation in every bodily temptation and every disturbance of +nature, in the freedom of his will abandoning himself to Him with a +new confidence and a firm resolve to abide always with God. For to +consent to sin, or to the animal desires of the bodily nature, is a +separation from God. + +Purity of body means that a man abstains from impure actions of +every kind, when his conscience assures him that they are impure and +contrary to the commandments, to the glory, and to the will of God. + +Thanks to these three kinds of purity, the seventh deadly sin, that +of wantonness, is conquered and driven away. Wantonness is a +voluptuous inclination of the spirit, leading away from God towards +a created thing; it is the impure act of the flesh outside what +Holy Church permits, and the carnal occupation of the heart in some +taste or desire for a creature. I do not here refer to those sudden +stirrings of love or desire which none can escape. + +You now know that purity of spirit preserves men in the likeness of +God, without care for the creatures, inclined towards God and united +to Him. The chastity of the body is compared to the whiteness of the +lily and to the purity of the angels. In its resistance to +temptation, it is compared to the redness of the rose, and to the +nobility of the martyrs. If it is preserved for love of God and in +His honour, it is then perfect, and it is compared to the +heliotrope, for it is one of the highest adornments of nature. + +Purity of heart renews and increases the grace of God. In purity of +heart all the virtues are inspired, practised, and preserved. It +keeps and preserves the outer senses, it subdues and binds the +animal desires within, and it is the ornament of all the inner life. +It is the exclusion of the heart from things of earth and from all +lies, and its inclusion among the things of heaven and all truth. +And this is why Christ has said: "Blessed are the pure in heart, for +they shall see God." This is the vision in which consists our +eternal joy, and all our reward, and our entrance into bliss. This +is why a man will be sober and moderate in everything, and will keep +himself from every occasion which might tarnish the purity of his +soul and body. + +ON THE THREE ENEMIES WHO ARE TO BE CONQUERED BY JUSTICE + +IF we wish to possess this virtue and to repulse these enemies, we +must have justice, and we must practise it, and preserve it even +until our death, in purity of heart, for we have three powerful +enemies who try to attack us at all times, in all states, and in +many different ways. If we make our peace with any one of them and +follow him, we are vanquished, for they are in league with each +other in all wickedness and injustice. These three enemies are the +devil, the world, and our own flesh, which is the nearest to us, and +is often the worst and most mischievous of our foes. For our animal +desires are the weapons with which our enemies fight against us. +Idleness, and indifference to virtue and the glory of God are the +cause and occasion of war and combat. But the weakness of our +natures, our negligence and ignorance of truth are the sword by +which our enemies wound us and sometimes conquer us. + +And this is why we must be divided in ourselves. The lower part of +ourselves, which is animal and contrary to the virtues, we ought to +hate and persecute and cause it to suffer by means of penitence and +austerities, so that it may be always crushed down and submissive to +reason, and that justice, with purity of heart, may always keep the +upper hand in all virtuous actions. And all the pains, sorrows, and +persecutions which God makes us suffer at the hands of those who are +enemies to virtue, we shall endure with joy, in honour of God and +for the glory of virtue, and in the hope of obtaining and possessing +justice in purity of heart; for Christ said: "Blessed are those who +are persecuted for righteousness' sake, for theirs is the kingdom of +heaven." For righteousness preserved in virtue and in virtuous +actions is a coin of the same weight and value as the kingdom of +heaven, and it is by it that we may purchase and obtain eternal +life. By these virtues a man goes forth towards God and towards +himself, in good conduct, virtue, and justice. + +ON THE KINGDOM OF THE SOUL + +HE who wishes to obtain and preserve these virtues, will adorn, +occupy, and order his soul like a kingdom. Free will is the king of +the soul. It is free by nature, and more free still by grace. It +will be crowned with a crown or diadem named Charity. We shall +receive this crown and this kingdom from the Emperor, who is the +Lord, the sovereign and king of kings, and we shall possess, rule, +and preserve this kingdom in His name. This king, free will, will +dwell in the highest town in the kingdom--that is to say, in the +concupiscent faculty of the soul. He will be adorned and clad with a +robe in two parts. The right side of his robe will be a virtue +called strength, that he may be strong and powerful to overcome all +obstacles and sojourn in the heaven, in the palace of the supreme +Emperor, and to bend with love and ardent self-surrender his crowned +head before the supreme monarch. This is the proper work of charity. +By it we receive the crown, by it we adorn the crown, and by it we +keep and possess the kingdom throughout eternity. The left side of +the robe will be a cardinal virtue, called moral courage. Thanks to +it, free will, the king, will subdue all immorality, will accomplish +all virtue, and will have the power to keep his kingdom even until +death. The king will choose councillors in his country, the wisest +in the land. They will be two divine virtues, knowledge and +discretion, illuminated by divine grace. They will dwell near the +king, in a palace called the reasonable force of the soul. They will +be crowned and adorned with a moral virtue called temperance, that +the king may always act and refrain from acting according to their +advice. By knowledge we shall purge our conscience from all its +faults and adorn it with all virtues; and, thanks to discretion, we +shall give and take, do and not do, speak and be silent, fast and +eat, listen and answer, and act in all ways according to knowledge +and discretion clad in their moral virtue, which is called +temperance or moderation. + +This king, free will, will also establish in his kingdom a judge, +who will be justice, which is a divine virtue when it is born from +love. And it is one of the highest moral virtues. This judge will +dwell in the conscience, in the middle of the kingdom in the +irascible faculty. And he will be adorned with a moral virtue called +prudence. For justice without prudence cannot be perfect. This +judge, justice, will traverse the kingdom with royal powers, +accompanied by wise counsel and his own prudence. He will promote +and dismiss, he will judge and condemn, will condemn to death and +acquit, will mutilate, blind, and restore to sight, will exalt and +abase and organise, will punish and chastise according to justice, +and will destroy all vices. The people of the kingdom--that is to +say, all the faculties of the soul, will be supported by humility +and the fear of God, submitting to Him in all the virtues, each +after its own manner. He who has thus occupied, preserved, and +ordered the kingdom of his soul, has gone forth, by love and the +virtues, towards God, towards himself, and towards his neighbour. +This is the third of the four principal points which Christ speaks +of when He says, Go forth. + +ON THE THREEFOLD MEETING OF THE SOUL + +WHEN a man has, by the grace of God, eyes to see, and a pure +conscience, and when he has considered the three comings of Christ, +our Bridegroom, and lastly when he has gone forth by the virtues, +then takes place the meeting with our Bridegroom, and this is the +fourth and last point. In this meeting consist all our blessedness, +and the beginning and the end of all the virtues, and without this +meeting no virtue can be practised. + +He who wishes to meet Christ as his well-beloved Bridegroom, and to +possess in Him and with Him eternal life, must meet Christ, now in +time, in three points or in three manners. First, he must love God +in everything wherein we shall merit eternal life. Secondly, he must +attach himself to nothing which he might love as much as or more +than God. Thirdly, he must repose in God with all his might, above +all creatures and above all the gifts of God, and above all acts of +virtue and above all the sensible graces which God might spread +abroad in his soul and body. + +Now understand: he who has God for his end must have Him present to +himself, by some divine reason. That is to say, he must have in view +Him who is the Lord of heaven, and of earth, and of every creature, +Him who died for him, and who can and will give him eternal +salvation. In whatever mode and under whatever name he represents +God, as Lord of every creature, it is well. If he takes some divine +Person, and in Him sees the essence and power of the divine nature, +it is well. If he regards God as saviour, redeemer, creator, +governor, as blessedness, power, wisdom, truth, goodness, it is +well. Though the names which we ascribe to God are numerous, the +sublime nature of God is simple and unnameable by the creatures. But +we give Him all these names by reason of His nobleness and +incomprehensible sublimity, and because we cannot name or proclaim +Him completely. See now under what mode and by what knowledge God +will be present to our intention. For to have God for our aim is to +see spiritually. To this quest belong also affection and love, for +to know God and be without love aids and advances us not a whit, and +has no savour. This is why a man, in all his actions, must bend +lovingly towards God, whom he seeks and loves above everything. +This, then, is the meeting with God by means of intention and love. + +In order that the sinner may turn from his sins in a meritorious +penitence, he must meet God by contrition, free conversion, and a +sincere intention to serve God for ever, and to sin no more. Then, +at this meeting, he receives from the mercy of God the assured hope +of eternal salvation and the pardon of his sins, and he receives the +foundation of all the virtues, faith, hope, and charity, and the +good will to practise all the virtues. If this man advances in the +light of faith, and observes all the works of Christ, all His +sufferings and all His promises, and all that He has done for us and +will do to the day of judgment and through eternity; if he examines +all this for his soul's health, he must needs meet with Christ; and +Christ must needs be present to his soul, so grateful and full of +thankfulness. So his faith is fortified, and he is impelled more +inwardly and powerfully towards all the virtues. If he still +progresses in the works of virtue, he must again meet with Christ, +by the annihilation of self. Let him not seek his own things; let +him set before him no extraneous ends; let him be discreet in his +actions; let him set God always before him, and the praise and glory +of God; and let him so continue till his death; then his reason +will be enlightened and his charity increased, and he will become +more pious and apt for all the virtues. We shall set God before us +in every good work; in bad works we cannot set Him before us. We +shall not have two intentions--that is to say, we shall not seek God +at the same time as something else, but all our intention must be +subordinated to God and not contrary to Him, but of one and the same +kind, so that it may help us and give us an impulse which may lead +us more easily to God. Then and then only is a man in the right +road. Moreover, we shall rest rather upon Him who is our aim and our +goal and the object of our love, than upon the messengers whom He +sends us--that is to say, His gifts. The soul will rest constantly +upon God, above all the adornments and presents which His messengers +may bring. The messengers sent by the soul are intention, love, and +desire. They carry to God all our good works and virtues. Above all +these, the soul will rest on God, its Beloved, above all +multiplicity. This is the manner in which we shall meet Christ all +through our life, in all our actions and virtues, by right +intention, that we may meet Him at the hour of our death in the +light of glory. + +This mode, as you have learnt, is called the active life. It is +necessary to all men; or at least they must not live in a manner +contrary to any virtue, though they may not attain the degree of +perfection in all the virtues which I have described. For to live +contrary to the virtues is to live in sin, as Christ has said: "He +that is not with me is against me." He who is not humble is proud, +and he who is proud belongs not to God. We must always possess a +virtue and be in a state of grace, or possess what is contrary to +that virtue and be in a state of sin. May every man examine and +prove himself, and order his life as I have here described. + +ON THE DESIRE TO KNOW GOD AS HE IS, IN THE NATURE OF HIS GODHEAD + +THE man who thus lives, in this perfection, as I have here described +it, and who devotes all his life and actions to the honour and glory +of God, and who seeks and loves God above all things, is often +seized by the desire to see and know Christ, this Bridegroom who was +made man for love of him, who laboured in love even till death, who +drove away from him sin and the enemy, who gave him His grace, who +gave him Himself, who left him His sacraments and promised him His +kingdom. When a man considers all this, he is exceedingly desirous +to see Christ his Bridegroom, and to know what He is in Himself +While He only knows Him in His works he is not satisfied. So he will +do like Zacchasus, the publican, who desired to see Jesus Christ. He +will go in front of the crowd--that is to say, the multitude of the +creatures, for they make us so little and short, that we cannot +perceive God. And he will climb the tree of faith, which grows from +above downwards, for its roots are in the Godhead. This tree has +twelve branches, which are the twelve articles of faith. The lower +branches speak of the humanity of Christ, and of the things which +concern the salvation of our body and soul. The higher part of the +tree speaks of the Godhead, of the Trinity of the Divine Persons and +the Unity of the Divine Nature. A man will strive to reach the unity +at the top of the tree, for it is there that Jesus must pass with +all His gifts. Here Jesus comes, and sees the man, and tells Him in +the light of faith that He is, according to His Godhead, +immeasurable and incomprehensible, inaccessible and abysmal, and +that He surpasses all created light and all finite comprehension. +This is the highest knowledge acquired in the active life, to +recognise thus, in the light of faith, that God is inconceivable and +unknowable. In this light Christ saith to the desire of a man: "Come +down quickly, for I must lodge at thy house to-day." This rapid +descent to which God invites him is nothing else but a descent, by +desire and love, into the abyss of the Godhead, to which no +intelligence can attain in crested light. But where intelligence +remains outside, love and desire enter. The soul thus bending +towards God, by the intention of love, above all that the intellect +can comprehend, rests and abides in God, and God abides in her. Then +mounting by desire, above the multitude of the creatures, above the +work of the senses, above the light of nature, she meets Christ in +the light of faith, and is enlightened, and recognises that God is +unknowable and inconceivable. Finally, bending by her desires +towards this inconceivable God, she meets Christ and is loaded with +His gifts; by living and resting upon Him, above all His gifts, +above herself and above all the creatures, she dwells in God and God +in her. + +This is how you will meet Christ at the summit of the active life, +if you have as your foundations justice, charity, and humility; and +if you have built a house above--that is to say, the virtues here +described, and if you have met Christ by faith--that is to say, by +faith and the intention of love, you dwell in God and God dwells in +you, and you possess the active life. + +This is the first explanation of the word of Jesus Christ our +Bridegroom, when He said, "See, the Bridegroom cometh; go forth to +meet Him." + +BOOK II + +THE SUBJECTS OF THE SECOND BOOK + +THE prudent virgin--that is to say, the pure soul, who has +renounced the things of earth, and lives henceforth for God in +virtue, has taken in the vessel of her heart the oil of charity and +of divine works by means of the lamp of an unstained conscience. But +when Christ, her Bridegroom, withdraws His consolations and the +fresh outpouring of His gifts, the soul becomes heavy and torpid. + +At midnight--that is to say, when it is least expected, a spiritual +cry resounds in the soul: "See, the Bridegroom cometh, go forth to +meet Him." We shall now speak of this seeing, and of the inward +coming of Christ, and of the spiritual going forth of the man to +meet Jesus, and we shall explain these four conditions of an inward +life, exalted and full of desire, to which all men attain not, but +many reach it by means of the virtues and their inward courage. + +In these words, Christ teaches us four things. In the first, He +requires that our intelligence shall be enlightened with a +supernatural light. This is what we observe in the word, "See." In +the next words He shows us what we ought to see--that is to say, the +inward coming of our Bridegroom of eternal truth. This is His +meaning when He says: "The Bridegroom cometh." In the third place, +in the words "go forth," He bids us go forth in inward actions +according to righteousness. In the fourth place, He shows us the end +and motive of all our works, the meeting with our Bridegroom Jesus +Christ in the joyous unity of His adorable Godhead. + +HOW WE MAY GAIN SUPERNATURAL VISION BY INTERNAL EXERCISES + +NOW let us speak of the first word. Christ saith, "See." Three +things are required by him who would see supernaturally in interior +exercises. The first is the light of the divine grace, but in a far +more sublime manner than can be felt in the external, active life. +The second is a stripping off of extraneous images and a denudation +of the heart, so that a man may be free from images, and attachments +to every creature. The third is a free conversion of the will, by +means of a concentration of all the bodily and spiritual faculties, +and complete deliverance from all inordinate affections. Thus this +will flows together into the unity of the Godhead and of our own +mind, so that the reasonable creature may be able to obtain and +possess supernaturally the sublime unity of God. It is for this that +God made the heaven and earth and mankind, it is for this that He +was made man, and taught us by word and example by what way we +should come to this unity. And then in the ardour of His love He +endured to die, and He ascended to heaven, and opened to us this +unity in which we may possess felicity and eternal blessedness. + +ON THE THREEFOLD NATURAL UNITY OF MAN + +NOW consider attentively: there are three kinds of natural unity in +all men, and, moreover, of supernatural unity among the just. The +first and supreme unity of man is in God; for all creatures are +immanent in this unity, and if they were to be separated from God, +they would be annihilated, and would become nothing. This unity is +essential in us according to nature, whether we are good or bad. And +without our co-operation it makes us neither holy nor blessed. This +unity we possess in ourselves, and nevertheless above us, as a +beginning and support of our life and essence. + +Another unity exists in us naturally--that of the supreme forces, in +so far as they actively take their natural origin in the unity of +the spirit or of the thoughts. This is the same unity as that which +is immanent in God, but it is taken here actively and there +essentially. Nevertheless the spirit is entirely in each unity +according to the integrity of its substance. We possess this unity +in ourselves, above the sensitive part of us; and thence are born +memory, intelligence, and will, and all the power of spiritual +works. In this unity the soul is called spirit. + +The third unity which is in us naturally is the foundation of bodily +forces in the unity of the heart, the source and origin of bodily +life. The soul possesses this unity in the lively centre of the +heart, and from it flow all the material works and the five senses, +and the soul draws from thence its name of soul (anima); for it is +the source of life, and animates the body--that is to say, it makes +it living and preserves it in life. These three unities are in man +naturally, as a life and a kingdom. In the inferior unity we are +sensible and animal, in the intermediate unity we are rational and +spiritual; and in the superior unity we are preserved according to +our essence. And this exists in all men, naturally. + +Now these three unities are adorned and cultivated naturally, like a +kingdom and an eternal abode, by the virtues, in charity and in the +active life. And they are adorned still better and more gloriously +cultivated by the internal exercises of a spiritual life. But most +gloriously and blessedly of all by a supernatural contemplative +life. + +The inferior unity, which is corporeal, is adorned and cultivated +supernaturally by external practices, by perfect conduct, by the +example of Christ and the saints, by carrying the cross with Christ, +by submitting our nature to the command of Holy Church and the +teachings of the saints, according to the forces of nature and +prudence. + +The other unity which resides in the spirit and which is absolutely +spiritual, is adorned and cultivated supernaturally by the three +Divine gifts, Faith, Hope, and Charity, and by the influx of grace +and Divine gifts, and by good will directed to all the virtues, and +the desire to follow the example of Christ and of holy Christendom. + +The third and supreme unity is above our intelligence and yet +essentially in us. We cultivate it supernaturally when in all our +works of virtue we have in view only the glory of God, without any +other desire but to repose in Him, above thought, above ourselves, +and above everything. And this is the unity from which we flowed out +when we were created, and where we abide according to our essence, +and towards which we endeavour to return by love. These are the +virtues which adorn this triple unity in the active life. + +Now we proceed to say how this triple unity is adorned more +sublimely and cultivated more nobly by interior exercises joined to +the active life. When a man, by love and right intention, elevates +himself in all his works and in all his life towards the honour and +glory of God, and seeks rest in God above all things, he will wait +in humility and patience and abandonment of self and in the hope of +new riches and new gifts, and he will not be troubled or anxious +whether it pleases God to grant His gifts or to refuse them. So men +prepare themselves for receiving an internal life of desires; even +as a vessel is fitted and prepared, into which a precious liquid is +to be poured. There is no vessel more noble than the loving soul, +and no drink more necessary than the grace of God. Man will thus +offer to God all his works and all his life, in a simple and right +intention, and in a zest above his intention, above himself, and +above everything, in the sublime unity in which God and the loving +spirit are united without intermediary. + +ON THE FIRST MODE OR DEGREE OF THE FIRST SPIRITUAL COMING OF CHRIST + +THE first coming of Christ to those who are engaged in the exercises +of desire is an internal and sensible current from the Holy Spirit, +which impels and attracts us to all the virtues. We shall compare +this coming to the splendour and power of the sun, which, so soon as +it is risen, enlightens and warms the whole world in the twinkling +of an eye. In the same way Christ, the eternal sun, burns and +shines, dwelling at the highest point of the spirit, and enlightens +and fires the lower part of man--that is to say, his physical heart +and sense-faculties, and this is accomplished in less time than the +twinkling of an eye, for the work of God is prompt; but the man in +whom it takes place ought to be internally seeing by means of his +spiritual eyes. + +The sun burns in the East, in the middle of the world, on the +mountains; there it hastens in the summer, and creates good fruits +and strong wines, filling the earth with joy. The same sun shines in +the West, at the end of the world; the country there is colder and +the force of the heat less; nevertheless, it there produces a great +number of good fruits, but not much wine. The men who dwell in the +West part of themselves, abide in their external senses, and by +their good intentions, their virtues, and their outer practices, by +the grace of God produce abundant harvests of virtues of divers +kinds, but they but rarely taste the wine of inward joy and +spiritual consolation. + +The man who wishes to experience the rays of the eternal sun, which +is Christ Himself, will be seeing; and will dwell on the mountains +of the East, by concentrating all his faculties, and lifting up his +heart to God, free, and indifferent to joy and pain and all the +creatures. There shines Christ, the sun of righteousness, on the +free and exalted heart, and this is what I mean by the mountains. +Christ, the glorious sun and divine effulgence, shines through and +fires by his internal coming, and by the power of His Spirit, the +free heart and all the powers of the soul. This is the first work of +the internal coming in the exercises of desire. Just as fire +inflames things which are thrown into it, so Christ inflames the +hearts offered to Him in freedom and exultation at His internal +coming, and He says in this coming: "Go forth by the exercises +appropriate to this life." + +ON UNITY OF HEART + +FROM this heat is born unity of heart, for we cannot obtain true +unity, unless the Spirit of God lights His flame in our heart. For +this fire makes one and like unto itself all that it can overtop and +transform. Unity gives a man the feeling of being concentrated with +all his faculties on one point. It gives internal peace and repose +of heart. Unity of heart is a bond which draws and binds together +the body and the soul, and all exterior and interior forces, in the +unity of love. + +HOW THE VIRTUES PROCEED FROM UNITY + +FROM this unity of heart is born inwardness or the internal life, +for none can have inwardness unless he is one and united in himself; +fervour or inwardness is the introversion of a man into his own +heart, to comprehend and experience the internal operation or speech +of God. Inwardness is a sensible flame of love, which the Spirit of +God lights and kindles in a man, and a man knows not whence it +comes, nor what has happened to him. + +ON SENSIBLE LOVE + +FROM inwardness is born a sensible love which penetrates the heart +of man and the highest faculties of the soul. This love and delight +none can experience who has not inwardness. Sensible love is the +desire and appetite for God as for an eternal good in which all is +contained. Sensible love renounces all the creatures, not as needs +but as pleasures. Interior love feels itself touched from above by +the eternal love which it must practise eternally Interior love +willingly renounces and despises everything, in order to obtain that +which it loves. + +ON DEVOTION + +FROM this sensible love is born devotion to God and His glory. For +none can have a hungry devotion in his heart, unless he possesses +the sensible love of God. Devotion excites and stimulates a man +internally and externally to the service of God. It makes the body +and soul abound in glory and merit in the eyes of God and men. God +exacts devotion in all that we do. It purges the body and soul from +all that might hold us back; it shows us the true path to +blessedness. + +ON GRATITUDE + +FROM fervent devotion is born gratitude, for none can thank or +praise God perfectly if he is not fervent and pious. We should thank +God for everything here below, that we may be able to thank Him +eternally above. Those who praise not God here, will be mute +eternally. To praise God is the most joyous and delicious employment +of the loving heart. There is no limit to the praises of God, for +therein is our salvation, and we shall praise Him eternally. + +Now hear a comparison, by which you may understand the exercise of +gratitude. When the summer approaches and the sun mounts, it +attracts the moisture of the earth along the stems and branches of +the trees, whence come green leaves, flowers, and fruit. Even so +when Christ, the eternal sun, rises in our hearts, He sends His +light and heat upon our desires, and draws the heart away from all +the manifold things of earth, creating unity and inwardness, and +makes the heart grow and become green by interior love, and makes +loving devotion flourish, and makes us bear the fruits of gratitude +and love, and preserves these fruits eternally in the humble pain of +our inability to praise and serve Him enough. + +Here ends the first of the four chief kinds ot interior exercises, +which adorn the lower part of a man. + +HOW TO INCREASE INWARDNESS BY HUMILITY + +BUT in thus comparing to the splendour and power of the sun the +modes in which Jesus Christ comes, we shall find in the sun another +virtue or influence which makes the fruit more early ripe and more +abundant. + +When the sun rises to a very great height, and enters the sign of +the Twins--that is to say, into a double thing, but of the same +nature, in the middle of the month of May, the sun has a double +power over the flowers, herbs, and all that grows upon the earth. If +at that time the planets which rule nature are well ordered +according to the season of the year, the sun shines brightly on the +earth, and attracts the moisture in the atmosphere. Hence are born +dew and rain, and the fruits of the ground increase and multiply. + +Even so when Christ, that bright sun, rises in our heart above all +other things, and when the requirements of material nature, which +are contrary to the spirit, are well regulated according to reason, +when we possess the virtues as I have said above, and when, lastly, +we offer and restore to God, by the ardour of charity, and with +gratitude and love, the delight and peace which we find in the +virtues, from all these are born, at times, a gentle rain of new +internal consolations, and a celestial dew of divine sweetness. This +dew and rain make all the virtues increase and multiply day by day, +if we put no hindrance in their way. This is a new and special +operation, and a new coming of Christ into the loving heart. + +ON PURE SATISFACTION OF THE HEART + +FROM this sweetness is born satisfaction of heart, and of all the +bodily faculties, so that a man imagines that he is inwardly +embraced in the divine bands of love. This pleasure and consolation +is greater and more delicious to body and soul than all the +pleasures granted on earth, even if a man could enjoy them to the +full. In this pleasure God sinks into the heart by means of His +gifts with such a profusion of delights, consolations, and joys, +that the heart overflows internally. + +ON THE OBSTACLES WHICH WE ENCOUNTER IN THIS STATE + +THIS coming, or kind of coming, is granted to beginners, when they +turn from the world, when their conversion is complete, and they +abandon all the consolations of earth to live for God only; +nevertheless they are still weak, and need milk and not strong meat, +such as great temptations and the hiding of God's face. At this +season frost and fog often injure them, for they are in the middle +of the May of the interior life. The frost is to wish to be +something, or to imagine that we are something, or to be somewhat +attached to ourselves, or to believe that we have deserved +consolations and are worthy of them. The fog is the wish to rest +upon internal consolations and pains. This obscures the atmosphere +of reason, and the ilowers, which were about to unfold and bloom and +bear fruits, shut up again. This is why we lose the knowledge of +truth, and nevertheless we sometimes keep certain false sweetnesses +granted by the enemy, which at the last lead men astray. + +HOW ONE OUGHT TO BEHAVE IN THIS CASE + +I WISH to give you here a brief comparison, that you may not go +astray, and that you may be able to behave wisely in this case. +Observe the wise bee, and imitate her. She dwells in unity, in the +midst of the assembly of her kind, and she goes forth, not during a +storm, but when the weather is calm and bright, and the sun shines; +and she flies towards every flower where she may find sweetness. She +rests not on any flower, neither for its beauty nor for its +sweetness, but draws out from the cups of the flowers their +sweetness and clearness--that is to say, the honey and wax, and she +brings them back to the unity which is formed of the assembly of all +the bees, that the honey and wax may be put to good use. + +The expanded heart on which Christ, the eternal sun, shines, grows +and blooms under His rays, and from it flow all the interior forces +in joy and sweetness. + +Now the wise man will act like the bee, and will try to settle, with +affection, intelligence, and prudence, on all the gifts and all the +sweetness that he has experienced, and on all the good that God has +done to him. He will not rest on any flower of the gifts, but laden +with gratitude and praise he will fly back towards the unity where +he wishes to dwell, and to rest with God eternally. + +ON THE THIRD MODE OF THE SPIRITUAL COMING OF CHRIST + +WHEN the sun in heaven reaches its highest point, in the sign of the +Crab--that is to say, when it can go no higher, but must begin to go +backwards, then the greatest heat of the year begins. The sun +attracts the moisture, the earth dries, and the fruits ripen. In the +same way, when Christ, the divine sun, arises above the highest +summit of our heart--that is to say, above all His gifts, +consolations and sweetnesses, and if we do not rest in any of these, +however sweet, but return always with humble praises to the source +from which these gifts flow, Christ stops and remains lifted up +above the summit of our heart, and desires to attract all our powers +to Himself. + +This invitation is an irradiation of Christ, the eternal sun, and +causes in the heart a joy and pleasure so great that the heart +cannot close again after such an expansion, without pain. A man is +wounded internally and feels the smart of love. To be wounded by +love is the sweetest sensation and the most grievous pain that can +be experienced. To be wounded by love is a sure sign that we shall +be cured. This spiritual wound does us good and harm at the same +time. + +ON THE FOURTH KIND OF THE SPIRITUAL COMING OF CHRIST + +NOW I wish to speak of the fourth kind of coming of Jesus Christ, +which exalts and perfects the man in his interior exercises, +according to the lower part of his being. But having compared all +the interior comings to the shining of the sun, we will continue to +speak, while following the course of the seasons, of the other +effects and works of the sun. + +When the sun begins to descend the sky, it enters the sign of the +Virgin, so called because this period of the year becomes barren +like a virgin. The glorious virgin Mary, mother of Christ, full of +joys and rich in all the virtues, ascended to heaven at this season. +The heat begins then to diminish, and men gather, for use during the +whole year, the ripe fruits which can be used long after, such as +corn and the grape. And they sow part of the corn, that it may be +multiplied for the use of men. At this season all the solar work of +the year is finished. In the same way, when Christ, the glorious +sun, has risen to the zenith in the heart of men, and begins to +descend, so as to hide the splendour of His divine beams and to +leave a man alone, the heat and impatience of love diminish. Now +this occultation of Christ and the withdrawal of His light and heat +are the first work and the new coming of this mode. Now Christ says +spiritually in a man: "Go forth in the manner that I now show thee"; +and the man goes forth, and finds himself poor, miserable, and +desolate. Here all the storm, all the passion and eagerness of love +grow cold; summer becomes autumn, and all his wealth is changed into +great poverty. And the man begins to complain by reason of his +misery; what is become of his ardent love, his inwardness, his +gratitude, the interior consolations, the heartfelt joys? Where has +it all gone? How comes it that all is dead within him? He is like +a scholar who has lost his knowledge and his work; and nature is +often troubled by such losses. Sometimes these unhappy ones are +deprived of the good things of earth, of their friends and +relations, and are deserted by all the creatures; their holiness is +mistrusted and despised, men put a bad construction upon all the +works of their life, and they are rejected and disdained by all +those who surround them; and sometimes they are afflicted with +diverse diseases; and some of them fall into bodily temptations, or +into spiritual temptations, the most dangerous of all. From this +misery are born the fear of falling, and a sort of half-doubt, and +this is the extreme point where we can stop without despair. Let +such men seek out the good, complain to them, show them their +distress, and ask their help, and implore the aid of Holy +Church, and of all just men. + +WHAT A MAN OUGHT TO DO WHEN HE IS ABANDONED + +A MAN will here observe humbly that he has nothing but his distress, +and he will say in his resignation and self-abnegation the words of +holy Job: "The Lord gave, and the Lord hath taken away; He hath done +what seemed good to Him; blessed be the name of the Lord." And he +will leave himself in everything, and will say and think in his +heart: "Lord, I am as willing to be poor, lacking all that Thou hast +taken from me, as I should be to be rich, if such were Thy will, and +if it were for Thine honour. It is not my will according to nature +which must be accomplished, but Thy will, and my will according to +my spirit, O Lord; for I belong to Thee, and I should love as well +to be Thine in hell as in heaven, if that could serve Thy glory; and +therefore, O Lord, accomplish in me the excellence of Thy will." +From all these pains and acts of resignation, a man will derive an +inward joy, and he will offer himself into the hands of God, and +will rejoice to be able to suffer in His honour. And if he so +perseveres, he will taste inward pleasures such as he has never had +before; for nothing so rejoices the lover of God as to feel that he +is His beloved. And if he is truly exalted as far as this mode, in +the path of virtue, it is not necessary for him to have passed +through all the states which we have described above; for he feels +within himself in action, in humble obedience, in patience, and in +resignation, the source of all the virtues. It is thus that this +mode is eternally sure. + +At this season the sun in the sky enters the sign of the Scales, for +the day and night are equal, and the sun balances the light and the +darkness. In the same way Jesus Christ is in the sign of the Scales +for the resigned man; and whether He grants sweetness or +bitterness, darkness or light, whatever He chooses to send him, the +man keeps his balance, all things are equal to him except sin, which +has been driven away once for all. When every consolation has been +thus withdrawn from these resigned men, when they believe that they +have lost all their virtues and that they are abandoned by God and +all the creatures, if they then know how to reap the divers fruits, +their corn and wine are ready and ripe. That is to say, that all +that the bodily virtues can suffer will be offered by them to God +with joy, without resistance to His supreme will. All the exterior +and interior virtues, which they formerly practised with joy in the +light of love, they will now practise courageously and laboriously, +and will offer them to God, and never will they have so much merit +in His eyes. Never will they have been more noble or more beautiful. +All the consolations which God formerly granted, they will allow to +be stripped from them with joy, since it is for the glory of God. It +is thus that the virtues become perfect, and that sadness is +transformed into an eternal vintage. These men--their life and their +patience--improve and teach all who know and live near them, and +thus it is that the wheat of their virtues is sown and multiplied +for the good of all just men. + +This is the fourth kind of coming which, according to the bodily +faculties and the lower part of his being, adorns and perfects a man +in interior exercises. + +HOW THESE FOUR MODES ARE FOUND IN JESUS CHRIST + +WE must needs walk in the light if we wish not to lose our way, and +we must observe Jesus Christ, who has taught us these four modes, +and has preceded us in them. Christ, the bright sun, rises in the +heaven of the sublime Trinity and in the dawn of His glorious mother +the virgin Mary, who was and is the dawn of all the graces. Now +observe. Christ had and still has the first mode, for He was unique +and united. In Him were and are collected and united all the virtues +which have ever been practised, and which ever will be, and besides +this, all the creatures who will cultivate these virtues. He was +thus in an unique sense the Son of the Father, and united to human +nature. And He was equally full of inwardness, for it was He who +brought upon earth the fire which has consumed all the saints and +all good men. And He had a sensible and faithful love for His +Father, and for all who will have joy in Him eternally, and His +pitiful and loving heart sighed and glowed with love for all men, +before His Father. All His life and all His actions, within and +without, and all His words, were praises of His Father. This is the +first mode. + +Christ, the sun of love, blazed and shone yet more brightly and +warmly, for in Him was and is the fullness of all gifts. This is why +the heart of Christ, and His character, and His habits and His +service, overflowed with pity, sweetness, humility, and generosity. +So gracious was He and so loving, that His manners and His +personality attracted all whose nature was good. He was the pure +lily in the midst of the flowers of the field, from which the good +were to draw the honey of eternal sweetness and eternal +consolations. According to His humanity He thanked His eternal +Father for all the gifts which were ever granted to humanity, and +praised Him, for His Father is the Father of all gifts, and He +rested on Him, according to the highest faculties of His soul, above +all gifts, in the sublime unity of God from which all the gifts flow; +thus He had the second mode. + +Christ, the glorious sun, blazed and shone yet higher, and more +brightly and warmly; for during all His days on earth, all His +bodily faculties were invited and pressed to the sublime glory and +bliss which He now experiences in His senses and body. And He was +inclined thereto Himself, according to His desires; and nevertheless +He willed to remain in this exile, till the time which the Father +had foreseen and fixed from all eternity. Thus He had the third +mode. When the time came at which Christ was to reap and carry away +to the eternal kingdom the fruits of all the virtues which ever have +been and ever will be practised, the eternal sun began to descend; +for Christ humbled Himself, and gave up His bodily life into the +hands of His enemies. And he was misunderstood and deserted by His +friends in so great a distress; and all consolation, within and +without, was withdrawn from His nature; and it was overwhelmed with +misery, pain, and contempt, and paid all the debt which our sins +justly incurred. All this He suffered in humble patience, and He +accomplished the greatest works of love in this resignation, whereby +He received and purchased our eternal inheritance. It is thus that +the lower part of His noble humanity was adorned, for it was in it +that He suffered this pain for our sins. It is on this account that +He is called the Saviour of the world, and that He is glorified and +raised up and seated on the right hand of His Father, and that He +reigns in power. And every creature, on the earth, above the earth, +and under the earth, bends the knee for ever before His glorious +name. + +HOW A MAN SHOULD LIVE IF HE DESIRES TO BE ENLIGHTENED + +THE man who, in true obedience to the commandments of God, lives in +the moral virtues, and moreover exercises himself in the interior +virtues, after the direction and impulse of the Holy Spirit, acting +and speaking according to righteousness, and who seeks not his own +interests in time or in eternity, and who supports with true +patience obscurity and affliction and every kind of misery, and who +thanks God for everything, and offers himself in humble resignation, +has received the first coming of Jesus Christ according to interior +exercises. When this man is purified and pacified, and turns back +upon himself according to his lower nature, he may be internally +enlightened, if he asks it, and if God judges that the right time +has come. It may also happen that he is enlightened from the +beginning of his conversion, so that he may offer himself entirely +to the will of God and give up all possession of himself, which is +the supreme end. But if he is to follow any further the road which I +have shown, in the exterior and at the same time in the interior +life, it will be much easier for him than for the man who has been +raised straight from the bottom, for the former will have more light +than the latter. + +ON ANOTHER COMING OF CHRIST + +NOW we are about to speak of another mode of the coming of Christ, +in interior exercises, which adorn, enlighten, and enrich a man, +according to the three supreme faculties of his soul. We shall +compare this coming to a life-giving fountain from which flow three +rivers. + +This fountain is the fullness of divine grace in the unity of our +spirit. There resides grace essentially in its permanence, like a +full fountain, and it flows out actively by its rivers into each of +the faculties of the soul, according to their needs. These rivers +are a special influx, or operation of God in the highest faculties, +in which God operates in various manners by the intermediary of His +grace. + +HOW THE FIRST RIVER FLOWS INTO THE MEMORY + +THE first river of grace, which God causes to flow in this coming, +is a pure simplicity which shines without distinction in the spirit. +This river takes its source in the fountain, in the unity of the +spirit, and flows directly downwards, and penetrates all the +faculties of the soul, both higher and lower, and lifts them up out +of all multiplicity and all over-occupation, and makes a simplicity +in a man, and gives and shows him an internal bond in the unity of +his spirit. A man is thus lifted up according to his memory, and +delivered from strange and irrelevant thoughts, and from +inconstancy. Now Christ in this light demands a going forth, +according to the mode of this light and this coming. Then the man +goes forth, and observes himself that by virtue of the simple light +that is spread abroad in him he is united, established, penetrated +and fixed in the unity of his spirit or of his thoughts. Here the +man is exalted and established in a new essence; he turns his +thoughts inwards, and rests his memory on the naked truth, above all +sensuous images and above all multiplicity. There the man possesses +essentially and supernaturally the unity of his spirit, for his own +dwelling, and as an heritage of his own for ever. He always has an +inclination towards that same unity, and this unity will have an +eternal and loving inclination towards the more sublime unity where +the Father and the Son are united with all the saints in the bands +of the Holy Spirit. + +HOW THE SECOND RIVER ENLIGHTENS THE INTELLIGENCE + +THROUGH internal love, and loving inclination towards union with +God, is born the second river from the fullness of grace, in unity +of spirit, and this is a spiritual brightness which flows and sheds +light through the intelligence, but with distinctions in the diverse +modes. For this light shows and gives to the spirit, in the truth, +the discretion in all the virtues. But this light is not placed +altogether in our power, for though we have it always in our soul, +God makes it speak or keep silence, and He can manifest or hide it, +give or withdraw it, at all times and under all conditions, for this +light is His. Such men do not absolutely need revelations, nor to be +drawn up above sense, for their life and abode and habits and +essence are in the spirit above sense and sensibility. And God shows +them what He wills and what is necessary for them. Nevertheless God, +if He wished, could withdraw their exterior sense, and show them, +from within, unknown symbols and future things, in diverse manners. + +Now Christ desires that this man should go forth, and go into the +light, according to the mode of this light. This enlightened man +will therefore go forth and observe his state and his life within +and without, in order to know if he is perfectly like Christ +according to His humanity and also according to His divinity. And +this man will lift up his eyes, enlightened by enlightened reason, +in intelligible truth, and will observe and consider, as a creature +can, the sublime nature of God, and the unlimited attributes which +are in God. + +It is then necessary to consider and examine the sublime nature of +God; how it contains simplicity and purity, inaccessible height and +abysmal depth, incomprehensible extension and eternal duration; dark +silence and wild waste; repose of all the saints in unity and joy in +itself and in all the saints in eternity. This enlightened man will +also examine the attributes of the Father in the Godhead, how He is +all-powerful, the creator, mover, preserver, beginning and end, +cause and existence of all creatures; this is what the bright river +of grace shows to the enlightened reason. It shows also the +attributes of the eternal Word, abysmal wisdom and truth, model of +every creature and of all life, eternal norm of things, unveiled +contemplation and intuition into everything, brightness and +illumination of all saints, according to their merits, in heaven and +on earth. But this bright river shows also to the enlightened reason +the attributes of the Holy Spirit; inconceivable charity and +generosity, pity and mercy, infinite watchfulness and faithfulness, +immense and inconceivable riches flowing with delights through all +heavenly spirits, ardent flame consuming all in unity, effluent +fountain, preparation of all the saints for their eternal +blessedness, and their introduction thereto; enveloping and +penetrating the Father, the Son, and all the saints in joyous unity. + +ON THE STATE OF AMAZEMENT AT THE DIVINE EFFLUENCE + +THE incomprehensible wealth and sublimity, and the universal +generosity which flow from the divine nature, bring a man into a +state of amazement; and above all he admires the communication of +God and His effluence above everything, for he sees the +inconceivable essence, which is the common joy of God and all the +saints. And he sees that the three divine Persons are a common +effluence in works, in graces, and in glory, in nature and above +nature, in all conditions and in all times, in the saints and in +men, in heaven and on earth, in all reasonable and irrational +creatures, according to each one's merits, needs, and powers of +receiving. God is common to all, with all His gifts, the angels are +common, the soul is common in all its faculties, in all life, in all +the members, and all in each, for one cannot divide it, except by +reason. For the higher and lower faculties, the spirit and the soul, +are distinct according to reason, but one in nature. Thus God is +entirely and specially present to each one, and nevertheless common +to all the creatures, for by Him are all things, and on Him depend +the heaven, the earth, and the whole of nature. When a man thus +observes the astonishing wealth and sublimity of the divine nature, +and all the manifold gifts which He grants and offers to His +creatures, he is lifted up internally by wonder at such manifold +riches and sublimity; and from thence arises a singular inward joy +of spirit, and a vast confidence in God; and this internal joy +surrounds and penetrates all the faculties of the soul in inwardness +of spirit. + +HOW THE THIRD RIVER CONFIRMS THE WILL + +FROM this joy and fullness of graces, and divine faithfulness, there +is born and flows out the third river in this same unity of spirit. +This river, like a flame, lights up the spirit and absorbs all +things in unity. And it causes to overflow and flood with rich gifts +and singular nobility, all the faculties of the soul, and it creates +in the will a love without labour, spiritual and subtle. Now Christ +says internally in the spirit by means of this flaming river: "Go +forth by exercises according to the mode of these gifts and this +coming." Thanks to the first river--that is to say, to a simple +light, the memory is lifted up above the accidents of sense, and is +established in the unity of spirit. Thanks to the second river-- +that is to say, to the brightness spread abroad within, the +intelligence and reason are enlightened, so as to recognise the +diverse modes of the virtues and of exercises, and the mysteries of +the Scriptures. Thanks to the third river--that is to say, to an +inspired ardour, the sublime will is kindled into a more tranquil +love, and adorned with greater riches. In this way a man becomes +spiritually enlightened, for the grace of God abides, like a +fountain in the unity of the spirit; and these rivers create in the +faculties of the soul an effluence of all the virtues. And the +fountain of grace always requires a reflux towards its source. + +HOW CHRIST IS GIVEN TO ALL MEN IN THE SACRAMENT OF THE ALTAR + +THERE is a special benefit which Christ left in the Holy Church, to +all good people, in this supper of the great Paschal feast, when He +was about to pass from His sufferings to His Father after having +eaten the Paschal lamb with His disciples, and when the ancient law +was accomplished. At the end of the supper, He wished to give them a +special meal, as He had long desired to do. And this is why He +wished to finish the ancient law and to inaugurate the new law. He +took bread in His sacred hands, and consecrated His holy body, and +then His holy blood, and gave them to all His disciples, and left +them to all the just, for their eternal good. + +This gift and this special food rejoice and adorn all the great +festivals and all the banquets in heaven and on earth. In this gift +Christ gives Himself to us in three manners; He gives us His flesh +and blood and His bodily life, glorified and full of joys and +griefs. And He gives us His spirit with its highest faculties, and +full of glory, of gifts, of truths and justifications. And He gives +us His personality with the divine light which lifts up His spirit +and all enlightened spirits, even to the sublime and joyous unity. + +Now Christ wishes us to remember Him, whenever we consecrate, offer, +and receive His body. Now observe how we should remember Him. We +shall observe and consider how Christ bends towards us in loving +affection, in great desire, in loving joy, and by flowing into our +bodily nature. For He gives us that which He received from our +humanity--that is to say, His flesh and blood and bodily nature. We +shall contemplate this precious body pierced and wounded with love, +by reason of His faithfulness to us. It is by it that we are adorned +and nourished in the lower part of our human nature. He gives us +also, in this sublime gift of the sacrament, His spirit full of +glory, and the richest gifts of the virtues, and ineffable marvels +of charity and nobleness. + +It is by this that we are nourished, adorned, and illuminated in the +unity of our spirit and in our higher faculties, thanks to the +indwelling of Christ with all His riches. He gives us also in the +sacrament of the altar His sublime personality in incomprehensible +light. And thanks to this, we are united to the Father, and so we +reach our inheritance of divinity in eternal bliss. If a man +meditate rightly on this, he will meet Christ in the same manner in +which Christ comes to him. He will raise himself up to receive +Christ, with all his faculties and in eager joy. It is not possible +for our joy to be too great, for our nature receives His nature--that +is to say the glorified humanity of Christ, full of joyfulness and +full of merits. This is why I would that man, at the reception of +this sacrament, should melt away with desire, joy, and pleasure, for +he is receiving the fairest, the most gracious, the most lovable of +the children of men, and is united to Him. In this union and in this +joy great benefits often come to men, and many mysterious and +marvellous secrets of divine treasures are manifested and disclosed. +When a man meditates, at this reception, on the martyrdom and +sufferings of the precious body of Christ, whom he is receiving, he +enters sometimes into so loving a devotion and so great a +compassion, that he desires to be nailed with Christ to the cross, +and to shed his heart's blood for the honour of Christ. And he +presses himself to the wounds and open heart of Christ His Saviour. +In these exercises revelations and great benefits have often come to +men. + +ON THE UNITY OF THE DIVINE NATURE IN THE TRINITY OF PERSONS + +THE sublime and superessential unity of the Divine nature, in which +the Father and the Son possess their nature in the unity of the Holy +Spirit, above the conception and comprehension of all our faculties, +in the bare essence of our spirit, surpasses in this sublime calm +all the creatures of created light. This sublime unity of the Divine +nature is living and fruitful, for, from this same unity, the +eternal Word is born from the Father without interruption. And by +this birth the Father knows the Son, and all things in the Son. And +the Son knows the Father, and all things in the Father, for their +nature is simple. From this reciprocal vision of the Father and the +Son in an eternal clearness, flow forth an eternal satisfaction and +unfathomable love, which is the Holy Spirit. And by the Holy Spirit +and the eternal Wisdom God inclines towards every creature +severally, and loads every one of them with gifts and kindles it +with love, according to its nobility and according to the state +wherein it is constituted and elected though its virtues and the +eternal foresight of God. And it is by this that all just spirits, +in heaven and on earth, are united in virtue and justice. + +HOW GOD MOVES AND POSSESSES THE SOUL, NATURALLY AND SUPERNATURALLY + +NOW be attentive: I am about to give you an example on this +subject. God has made the upper heaven a pure and simple clearness +encircling and enveloping all the heavens; and all the material +world which God has created for it is the exterior abode and kingdom +of God and His saints, full of glory and eternal joys. Now the +heaven being an unmixed clearness, there is there neither time, nor +state, nor temptation, nor change, for it is unchangeably fixed +above all things. The sphere which approaches most nearly to it is +called the primum mobile. All movement, by the power of God, +emanates from the supreme heaven. This is the movement which carries +with it the motions of the firmament and all the planets. It is by +this same initial movement that all the creatures live and grow, +according to their order. Now understand that the essence of the +soul is like a spiritual kingdom of God, full of Divine clearness, +surpassing all our faculties, unless these faculties are not +transformed in a simple fashion, of which I do not wish to speak +now. See; in this essence of the soul in which God reigns, the +unity of our spirit is like the primum mobile; for in this unity +the spirit is moved from above, by the power of God, naturally and +supernaturally; for by ourselves we have nothing either in or above +nature. And this motion of God, when it is supernatural, is the +first and chief cause of all our virtue. And by this motion of God +the seven gifts of the Holy Spirit are granted to certain +enlightened men, like the seven planets which illuminate all the +lives of men. This is how God possesses the essential unity of our +spirit, as His Kingdom. + +ON THE ESSENTIAL MEETING WITH GOD, WITHOUT INTERMEDIARY + +NOW attend carefully. The unity of our spirit has two modes, one +essential and the other active. You should know that the spirit, +according to its essential existence, receives the coming of Christ +in its bare nature, without intermediary and without interruption. +For this essence and life which we are in God, in our eternal image, +and which we have in ourselves, according to essential existence, +are without intermediary and inseparable. This is why the spirit +receives, in its highest and most intimate part, in its bare nature, +the impression of its eternal image, and the divine brightness +without interruption, and it is an eternal dwelling of God, which He +occupies by a perpetual inhabitation, and which He visits always +with a new coming, and a new effulgence from His eternal birth. For +where He comes He is, and where He is He comes. And where He has +never been, He will never come, for there is in Him neither accident +nor change, and everything, where He is, is in Him, for He never +goes out of Himself. And this is why the spirit possesses God +essentially in its bare nature, and God the spirit, for the spirit +lives in God, and God in the spirit. And it is capable, in its +highest part, of receiving the brightness of God, and all that God +may grant it, without intermediary. And by the brightness of its +eternal image, which shines essentially and personally in it, the +spirit is plunged, as regards the highest part of its vitality, in +the divine essence; and there enters into possession of its eternal +bliss, and flowing out again by the eternal birth of the Son is +placed in its created essence by the free will of the Holy Trinity, +And here it is like the image of the sublime Trinity and Unity for +which it is created. And in its created nature, it takes the +impression of its eternal image without interruption, like an +immaculate mirror in which every impression abides, and which renews +the likeness in itself without interruption. This essential unity of +our spirit in God, exists not in itself, but abides in God and flows +out from God, and is immanent in God and returns to God, as to its +eternal cause. It never separates itself from God, for this unity is +a fact of bare nature, and if nature separated itself from God it +would fall into nothingness. And this unity is above time and +conditions, and works always without interruption according to the +mode of God. This is the nobleness which we have naturally according +to the essential unity of our spirit, where it is united naturally +to God. + +This makes us neither saints nor blessed, for all men have it in +them, the bad as well as the good; but it is the first cause of all +holiness and bliss; and this is the meeting and unity of God in our +spirit, in our base nature. + +HOW MAN IS LIKE GOD BY GRACE, AND UNLIKE HIM BY MORTAL SIN + +NOW examine this thought with care, for if you understand well what +I wish to say to you, and what I have already said, you will +understand all the divine truth which a creature can apprehend at +present, and even things far more sublime. In the second mode, our +spirit keeps itself actively in this same unity, and subsists by +itself as in its personal created essence. This is the foundation +and origin of the supreme faculties, and this is the beginning and +end of all the works of a created nature, accomplished according to +the mode of the creatures, both in nature and above nature. + +Nevertheless this unity does not operate as unity; but all the +faculties of the soul have their power entirely in their +foundation--that is to say, in the unity of the spirit, where it +resides in its personal essence. In this unity the spirit must +always be like unto God, by grace and virtue, or unlike Him by +mortal sin; for man is made in the likeness of God, which he must +understand in the sense of grace; for grace is a deiform light which +shines through us and makes us like unto God; and without this light +we cannot be united supernaturally to God, even though we can never +lose the image of God, nor our natural unity in Him. If we lose this +likeness--that is to say, grace, we are damned. And this is why, so +soon as God finds in us something which is capable of receiving His +grace, He wishes to enliven us by His goodness, and to make us like +unto Himself by His gifts. And this happens whenever we turn towards +Him with full purpose; for at the same moment Christ comes to us and +in us, with and without intermediary--that is to say, by the virtues +and above all the virtues. And He impresses His image and likeness +upon us--that is to say, Himself and all His gifts, and He relieves +us from sin and makes us like unto Himself. + +By the same operation in which God relieves us from sin, and makes +us like Him and free in charity, the spirit is plunged in joyous +love. And here take place a meeting and a union, which are without +intermediaries and supernatural, and wherein resides our supreme +blessedness. Although all that He gives by love and pure goodness is +natural to God, yet to us it is accidental and supernatural, +according to our mode, since formerly we were strangers and unlike, +and only subsequently have become like God and obtained union with +Him. + +ON THE SUPREME DEGREE OF THE INTERIOR LIFE + +NOW understand. This incomprehensible light transforms and +penetrates the joyous inclination of our spirit. In this light, the +spirit is plunged in joyous repose; for this repose is without mode +and without bottom, and we can only know it by itself--that is to +say, by repose. For if we could know it and conceive it, it would +fall into mode and measure, and so would not be able to satisfy us, +and repose would become an eternal restlessness. And this is why the +simple, loving, complete inclination of our spirit forms in us a +joyous love, and joyous love is without bottom. And the abyss of God +calls to abyss; so it is with all those whose spirits are united to +God in joyous love. This calling is an irruption from His essential +brightness; and this essential brightness in the embrace of His +bottomless love, causes us to lose ourselves and escape from +ourselves, in the lonely darkness of God. And thus united, without +intermediary, to the spirit of God, we can meet God by God, and +possess unchangeably, with Him and in Him, our eternal blessedness. + +ON THE FIRST MODE OF THIS HIGHEST MEETING + +THE most interior life is practised in three ways. Sometimes the +interior man operates, above all activity and all virtue, by simple +introspection in joyous love. And here he meets God without +intermediary. And from the unity of God a simple light shines in +him, and this light shows him darkness, nakedness, and nothingness. +He is enveloped in darkness, and falls into the absence of mode as +one who loses his way. He loses, in nakedness, the power of +observing and distinguishing all things, and he is transformed and +penetrated by a simple brightness. He loses, in nothingness, all his +works, for he is overcome in the work of the unlimited love of God; +and in the joyous inclination of his spirit he triumphs in God and +becomes one spirit with Him. This is the first mode, which is +inactive; for it empties a man of all things, and lifts him up above +works and virtues. + +ON THE SECOND MODE + +THERE are moments when the interior man turns desirously and +actively towards God, to pay Him homage, and to offer up and +annihilate, in the love of God, his being and all that he can give. +And here he meets God, through an intermediary. This intermediary is +the gift of wisdom, which is the foundation and source of all the +virtues, and excites the just to virtues in proportion to their love; +and sometimes it touches and inflames the interior man with love +so violently, that all the gifts of God, and all that God can give +without giving Himself, seem to him too little and do not satisfy +him, but only increase his impatience. For he has at the bottom of +his being an interior perception or sensation, wherein all the +virtues begin and end, and wherein he offers to God all the virtues, +and wherein love lives. And thus the hunger and thirst of love +become so great, that he is reduced to nothingness, and then touched +anew, as it were for the first time, by the irradiation of God. Thus +in living he dies and in dying he lives again. This is the second +mode, and it is more useful and more glorious than the first; for +none can enter into the repose that is above action unless he has +first actively loved love. And this is why none will be inactive, +who is master of himself and who is able to practise love. + +ON THE THIRD MODE + +FROM these two kinds is born the third, which is an interior life +according to righteousness. Now understand. God comes to us without +interruption, with and. without intermediary, He requires of us +action and joy, in such a way that action may not hinder joy, nor +joy action, but that each may help the other. This is why the +interior man possesses his life in these two modes, repose and work. +And in each of them he is entire and undivided; for he is entirely +in God, in his joyous repose, and he is entirely in himself, in his +active love; and God warns him that He requires him to renew +continually his repose and his work. The righteousness of the spirit +wishes to pay, every hour, what God requires of us, and this is why, +at every irradiation of God, the spirit turns inwards, actively and +joyously, and so is renewed in all the virtues, and plunged more +deeply in joyous love. For God at every gift gives Himself with all +His gifts, and the spirit whenever it turns inwards, gives itself +with all its works. The spirit is united to God, and transferred +without interruption into repose. The man is hungry, for he sees the +nourishment of angels and the food of heaven. He works actively in +love, for he sees his repose. He is a pilgrim, and he sees his +country. He fights, in love, for victory, for he sees his crown. +Consolation, peace, joy, beauty, and riches, and all that can +rejoice the heart, are shown to the reason illuminated by God, in +spiritual similitudes and without measure. And by this vision, at +the touch of God, love remains active. For this just man has built +up, in the spirit, a true life, which will last eternally, but after +this life it will be transformed into a more sublime state. Thus the +man is just, and he goes towards God by interior love in eternal +work, and he goes in God by joyous inclination, in eternal repose. +And he abides in God, and yet he goes out towards all the creatures, +in common love, in the virtues, and in the works of justice. This is +the supreme summit of the inner life. + +Note.--Here follow in Ruysbroek's treatise four chapters of warnings +against the errors of Quietism, such as were exemplified in his time +by many of the Brethren of the Free Spirit and similar sects. + +BOOK III + +THE THREE CONDITIONS BY WHICH WE MAY ATTAIN TO THE CONTEMPLATIVE +LIFE + +THE interior lover of God, who possesses God in joyous repose, and +possesses himself in the unity of active love, and possesses all his +life in the virtues, enters into the contemplative life, thanks to +these three points and to the secret manifestation of God; yes, it +is the internal and devout lover, whom God will choose freely and +lift him up even to a superessential contemplation in divine light +and according to the mode of God. This contemplation places us in a +purity and brightness above all intelligence, for it is a singular +ornament and a celestial crown, and at last the eternal recompense +of all the virtues and of all life. And none can arrive there by +knowledge or subtlety, nor by any exercise; but he whom God wills to +unite to His own Spirit and to illuminate by Himself, can +contemplate God, and none other can. To such an one the heavenly +Father says, in the secret and submerged part of the spirit: "See, +the Bridegroom cometh, go forth to meet Him." + +I wish to analyse and explain these words, in their relation to +superessential contemplation, which is the basis of all holiness and +of the perfect life. Very few men attain to this divine +contemplation, by reason of our incapacity, and the mystery of the +light in which contemplation takes place. And this is why no one, by +his own knowledge or by any subtle examination, will understand +these ideas. For all words, and all that can be learned and +understood according to the mode of the creatures, are strangers to +the truth which I speak of, and far below it. But he who is united +to God, and illuminated in this truth, can comprehend the truth by +itself. For to conceive and understand God above all similitudes, as +He is in Himself, is to be God in God, without intermediary and +without any difference which might prove an obstacle. This is why I +desire that every man who does not understand this, nor experience +it in the joyous unity of his spirit, may not be wounded by my +words, for what I say is true. And this is why he who wishes to +understand this, must be dead to himself and alive to God, and he +will turn his face to the eternal light, at the bottom of his +spirit, where the hidden truth is manifested without intermediary. +For the heavenly Father wishes that we should be seeing; for He is +the Father of Light, and this is why He says eternally, without +interruption and without intermediary, one abysmal word and no +other. In this word He proffers Himself and all things. The word is: +"See." And it is the going forth and the birth of the Son of the +eternal light, in whom we see and recognise all our blessedness. + +HOW A MAN OUGHT TO EXERCISE HIMSELF, IN ORDER TO RECEIVE THE ETERNAL +LIGHT AND TO CONTEMPLATE GOD + +IN order that the spirit may contemplate God by God, without +intermediary, in this Divine light, three things are necessary. +First, the man must be well governed externally in all the virtues, +and without obstacles within, and as free from all external works as +if he did them not; for if he is troubled within by any act of +virtue, he has images, and so long as they remain in him he cannot +contemplate. In the second place, he must adhere internally to God, +by the combination of intention and of love, like a burning fire, +which can never more be extinguished. At the moment when he feels +himself in this state, he can contemplate. In the third place, he +should be lost in an absence of mode, and in a darkness, in which +all contemplatives wander joyously, and can never find themselves +again according to the mode of the creatures. In the abyss of this +darkness, where the loving spirit is dead to itself, begin the +manifestation of God and of eternal life. For in this darkness is +born and shines an incomprehensible light, which is the Son of God, +in whom we see eternal life. And in this light we become seeing; and +this Divine light is given in the simple vision of the spirit, in +which the spirit receives the clearness which is God Himself, +without intermediary, and becomes without interruption this +clearness which it receives. See; this dark clearness, in which we +contemplate all that we desire, while the spirit is passive,--this +clearness is so great than the loving contemplative, in the depth +where he reposes, sees and experiences nothing save an +incomprehensible light, and according to the simple nudity which +envelopes all things, he sees and apprehends the same light by which +he sees, and nothing else. This is the first condition of becoming +seeing in the Divine light. Happy are the eyes which thus see, for +they have eternal life. + +HOW THE ETERNAL BIRTH OF GOD IS RENEWED WITHOUT INTERRUPTION IN +NOBLENESS OF SPIRIT + +WHEN we have thus become seeing, we can contemplate in joy the +eternal coming of the Bridegroom, and this is the second point on +which I wish to speak. What is then this coming of the Bridegroom +which is eternal? It is a new birth and a new illumination without +interruption; for the foundation out of which the clearness shines, +and which is the clearness itself, is living and fruitful; and this +is why the manifestation of the eternal light is renewed without +interruption, in the most secret part of the spirit. See; every +creaturely work, and every exercise of virtue must here submit +themselves, for God works alone in the highest part of the spirit. +There is nought here but an eternal contemplation and fixity of +light, by light, and in light. And the coming of the Bridegroom is +so swift that He comes always, and is immanent with His unfathomable +riches, and comes back ever anew, in person, with such new +splendours that He seems never to have come before. For His coming +consists in an eternal Now, transcending time, and He is always +received with new desire and new joy. The delights and joy which +this Bridegroom brings at His coming are without bottom and without +limits, for they are Himself. This is why the eyes of the spirit, by +which the lover contemplates the Bridegroom, are open so wide that +they will never more be shut. For the contemplation and fixity of +the spirit remain eternal in the hidden manifestation of God. And +the contemplation of the spirit is so widely opened, while waiting +for the coming of the Bridegroom, that the spirit itself acquires +the amplitude of that which it comprehends. And in this way, God is +seen and comprehended by God, in which all our salvation and +blessedness consists. This is the second manner in which we receive, +without interruption in our spirit, the eternal coming of our +Bridegroom. + +ON THE ETERNAL GOING FORTH WHICH WE POSSESS IN THE BIRTH OF THE SON + +NOW the Spirit of God saith, in the secret depths of our spirit: +"Go forth," in an eternal contemplation and joy, according to the +mode of God. All the wealth which is in God naturally, we possess in +Him by love; and God possesses it in us, by His boundless Love, +which is the Holy Spirit. For in this love all is tasted that can be +desired. And this is why, thanks to this love, we are dead to +ourselves, and have gone forth in loving liquefaction or immersion, +in the absence of mode and in darkness. There the spirit, enveloped +by the Holy Trinity, is eternally immanent in the superessential +unity, in repose and in joy. And in this same unity, according to +the mode of generation, the Father is in the Son, and the Son in the +Father, and every creature in them both. And this is above the +distinction of Persons, for here we understand by reason the +fatherhood and sonship in the lively fruitfulness of nature. + +Here is born and begins an eternal going forth, and an eternal work +without beginning, for there is here a beginning without beginning. +For by means of the eternal birth of the Son, the Word of the +Father, all creatures have gone forth eternally, before they were +created in time, and God has considered and recognised them +distinctly in Himself, in lively reason, and in distinction from +Himself: but not in another mode, for all that is in God is God. +This eternal going forth and this eternal life, which we have and +are eternally in God, without ourselves, is the cause of our created +essence in time. And our created essence is immanent in the eternal +essence, and this eternal life, which we have and are in the eternal +wisdom of God, is like unto God; for they have an eternal immanence, +without distinction, in the divine essence. And they have an eternal +effluence by the birth of the Son, in a difference with distinction, +according to the eternal reason. And thanks to these two things, a +man is in this way like unto God, that he recognises himself and +reflects on himself without interruption, in this resemblance, +according to essence and according to the Persons. For though here +there is still distinction and difference, according to reason, this +resemblance is nevertheless one with the very image of the Holy +Trinity, which is the wisdom of God, and wherein God contemplates +Himself and all things in an eternal Now, without before or after. +In simple vision He regards Himself as He regards all things. And +this is the image and likeness of God, and our image and likeness, +for in it God and all things are reflected. In this divine image, +all the creatures, without themselves, have an eternal life, as in +their eternal model, and the Holy Trinity has made us in this +eternal image and likeness. And this is why God wishes that we +should go out from ourselves, in this eternal light, and that we +should pursue this image, which is our true life, supernaturally, +and possess it with Him actively and joyously, in eternal +blessedness. + +For we know well that the bosom of the Father is our foundation and +origin, wherein we begin our life and our being. And from our true +foundation--that is to say, from the Father and from all that lives +in Him, beams forth an eternal radiance, which is the birth of the +Son. In this radiance, the Father manifests Himself, and all that +lives in Himself, to Himself; for all that He is, and all that He +has, He gives to the Son, except the prerogative of fatherhood, +which resides in Himself. And this is why all that lives in the +Father hidden in the Unity, lives also in the Son, and flows forth +in His manifestation; but the simple foundation of our eternal image +remains always without mode in the darkness. But the boundless +radiance which shines out thence manifests and reflects in the mode +the mystery of God. And all men who are raised above their +creatureliness into a contemplative life, are united to this divine +splendour. And they are this splendour itself, and they see, +experience, and find, thanks to this divine radiance, that they are +this same simple foundation, according to their uncreated essence, +from which shines forth, in the divine mode, this immeasurable +radiance, which, according to simplicity of essence, remains +eternally within, and without mode. This is why interior men and +contemplatives will go forth, according to the mode of +contemplation, above distinction and above their created essence, by +means of an eternal intuition. Thanks to this inborn light, they are +transformed, and are united to this same light by which they see and +which they see. In this manner contemplatives pursue the eternal +image, after which they are made, and contemplate God and all things +without distinction, by a pure vision in divine brightness. This is +the most sublime and the most useful contemplation which we can +attain in this life; for in this contemplation a man remains the +best and freest master of himself, and at each loving introversion, +above all that we can comprehend, he can advance in the sublimities +of life, for he remains free and master of himself, in unity and in +the virtues. And this contemplation in the divine light maintains +him above all inwardness, above all virtue, above all merit, for it +is the crown and recompense towards which we are striving, and which +we already have and possess in this mode, for the contemplative life +is a celestial life. But if we shall be drawn up out of this exile +and this misery, we shall be, according to our created nature, more +susceptible of this radiance, and then the glory of God would shine +through us better and more sublimely. This is the mode above all +modes, according to which we go forth in a divine contemplation and +in an eternal stability, and according to which we are transformed +and reformed in the divine radiance. This going forth of the +contemplative is also loving; for by joyous love he surpasses his +created essence, and finds and tastes the riches and delights which +are God, and which He causes to flow without interruption into the +most secret part of the spirit, into the place where he is like the +sublimity of God. + +ON THE DIVINE MEETING, WHICH TAKES PLACE IN THE MOST SECRET PART OF +OUR SPIRIT + +WHEN the interior man and contemplative has thus pursued his eternal +image, and possessed in this purity the bosom of the Father by the +Son, he is illuminated by the divine truth, and receives anew at +each instant the eternal birth; and he goes forth according to the +mode of light, in a divine contemplation. And here arises the fourth +and last point--that is to say, the loving meeting, in which before +all else resides our eternal blessedness. + +You know that our heavenly Father, like a living foundation, is +actively inclined towards His Son, as towards His own eternal +wisdom. And this same wisdom, and all that lives therein, is +actively inclined in the Father--that is to say, in the foundation +whence it proceeds. And in this meeting arises the Third Person, +between the Father and the Son, and this is the Holy Spirit, their +mutual love, which is united to them both in the same nature. And He +envelopes and penetrates, actively and joyously, the Father and the +Son and all that lives in them with such riches and such joy, that +all the creatures must be silent thereupon eternally, for the +incomprehensible marvel of this love surpasses eternally the +intelligence of all the creatures. But where we comprehend and taste +this amazement, without being amazed, there the spirit is above +itself, and one with the Spirit of God, and it tastes and sees, +without measure, like God, the riches which He is Himself in the +unity of the living foundation, where He possesses Himself according +to the unity of His uncreated essence. + +Now this delightful meeting is without interruption actively renewed +in us, according to the mode of God, for the Father gives Himself in +the Son, and the Son in the Father, in an eternal gratification and +a loving embrace, and this is renewed at every hour in the ties of +love; for even as the Father without interruption contemplates anew +all things in the birth of His Son, so all things are beloved anew, +by the Father and the Son, through the influence of the Holy Spirit. +And this is the eternal meeting of the Father and the Son, in which +we are lovingly wrapped by the Holy Spirit in eternal love. + +Now this active meeting and this loving embrace are, in their +foundation, joyous and without mode, for God's infinite absence of +mode is so obscure and so destitute of mode, that it envelopes in +itself every divine mode and every work, and the individuality of +the Persons, in the rich envelopment of essential unity, and forms a +divine rejoicing in the abyss of the unnameable. And here there is a +joyous and outflowing immersion in the essential nakedness, where +all the divine names and all the modes, and all divine reason, +reflected in the mirror of the divine truth, fall into simple +ineffability, in the absence of mode and of reason. For in this +boundless abyss of simplicity, all things are enveloped in joyous +blessedness, and the abyss remains itself uncomprehended save by the +essential unity. Before this essential unity, the Persons must give +way, and all that lives in God. For here is nought but an eternal +rest, in a joyous envelopment of loving immersion, and this is the +essence, without mode, which all interior spirits have chosen above +all other things. It is the dark silence in which all lovers are +lost. But if we could prepare ourselves thus for the virtues, we +should unclothe ourselves, so to speak, from life, and should float +on the wide expanses of this divine sea, and created things would no +longer have power to touch us. + +May we be able to possess, rejoicing, the essential unity, and +clearly to contemplate the Unity in Trinity; and may the divine +love, which rejects no suppliant, grant us this. Amen. + + + + + + +THEOLOGIA GERMANICA + + + + + +SIN AND SELFISHNESS + +SIN is nothing else but the turning away of the creature from the +unchangeable Good to the changeable; from the perfect to the +imperfect, and most often to itself. And when the creature claims +for its own anything good, such as substance, life, knowledge, or +power, as if it were that, or possessed it, or as if that proceeded +from itself, it goeth astray. What else did the devil do, and what +was his error and fall, except that he claimed for himself to be +something, and that something was his and was due to him? This claim +of his--this "I, me, and mine," were his error and his fall. And so +it is to this day. For what else did Adam do? It is said that Adam +was lost, or fell, because he ate the apple. I say, it was because +he claimed something for his own, because of his "I, me, and mine." +If he had eaten seven apples, and yet never claimed anything for his +own, he would not have fallen: but as soon as he called something +his own, he fell, and he would have fallen, though he had never +touched an apple. I have fallen a hundred times more often and more +grievously than Adam; and for his fall all mankind could not make +amends. How then shall my fall be amended? It must be healed even as +Adam's fall was healed. And how, and by whom, was that healing +wrought? Man could not do it without God, and God could not do it +without man. Therefore God took upon Himself human nature; He was +made man, and man was made God. Thus was the healing effected. So +also must my fall be healed. I cannot do the work without God, and +He may not or will not do it without me. If it is to be done, God +must be made man in me also; God must take into Himself all that is +in me, both within and without, so that there may be nothing in me +which strives against God or hinders His work. Now if God took to +Himself all men who are or ever lived in the world, and was made man +in them, and they were deified in Him, and this work were not +accomplished in me, my fall and my error would never be healed +unless this were accomplished in me also. And in this bringing back +and healing I can and shall do nothing of myself; I shall simply +commit myself to God, so that He alone may do and work all things in +me, and that I may suffer Him, and all His work, and His divine +will. And because I will not do this, but consider myself to be mine +own, and "I, me, and mine," and the like, God is impeded, and cannot +do His work in me alone and without let or hindrance; this is why my +fall and error remain unhealed. All comes of my claiming something +for my own. ii., iii. + +THE TWO EYES + +We should remember the saying that the soul of Christ had two eyes, +a right eye and a left eye. In the beginning, when the soul of +Christ was created, she fixed her right eye upon eternity and the +Godhead, and remained in the full beholding and fruition of the +Divine essence and eternal perfection; and thus remained unmoved by +all the accidents and labours, the suffering, anguish, and pain, +that befell the outer man. But with the left eye she looked upon the +creation, and beheld all things that are therein, and observed how +the creatures differ from each other, how they are better or worse, +nobler or baser; and after this manner was the outer man of Christ +ordered. Thus the inner man of Christ, according to the right eye of +His soul, stood in the full exercise of His Divine nature, in +perfect blessedness, joy, and eternal peace. But the outer man and +the left eye of the soul of Christ stood with Him in perfect +suffering, in all His tribulations, afflictions and labours; in such +a way that the inner or right eye remained unmoved, unimpeded and +untouched by all the labour, suffering, woe, and misery that +happened to the outer man. It has been said that when Jesus was +bound to the pillar and scourged, and when He hung on the cross, +according to the outer man, the inner man, a soul according to the +right eye, stood in as full possession of Divine joy and blessedness +as it did after the ascension, or as it does now. Even so His outer +man, or soul according to the left eye, was never impeded, +disturbed, or troubled by the inward eye in its contemplation of the +outward things which pertained to it. The created soul of man has +also two eyes. The one is the power of looking into eternity, the +other the power of looking into time and the creatures, of +perceiving how they differ from each other, of giving sustenance and +other things necessary to the body, and ordering and ruling it for +the best. But these two eyes of the soul cannot both perform their +office at once; if the soul would look with the right eye into +eternity, the left eye must be shut, and must cease to work: it must +be as if it were dead. For if the left eye is discharging its office +towards outward things--if it is holding conversation with time and +the creatures--then the right eye must be impeded in its working, +which is contemplation. Therefore, he who would have one must let +the other go; for no man can serve two masters. vii. + +A FORETASTE OF ETERNAL LIFE + +Some have asked whether it is possible for the soul, while it is +still in the body, to reach so great a height as to gaze into +eternity, and receive a foretaste of eternal life and blessedness. +This is commonly denied; and in a sense the denial is true. For +indeed it cannot come about, so long as the soul is occupied with +the body, and the things which minister to the body and belong to +it, and to time and created things, and is disturbed and troubled +and distracted by them. For the soul that would mount to such a +state, must be quite pure, entirely stripped and bare of all images; +it must be wholly separate from all creatures, and above all from +itself. Many think that this is impossible in this present life. But +St Dionysius claims that it is possible, as we find from his words +in his letter to Timothy, where he says: "In order to behold the +hidden things of God, thou shalt forsake sense and the things of the +flesh, and all that can be perceived by the senses, and all that +reason can bring forth by her own power, and all things created and +uncreated which reason can know and comprehend, and thou shalt stand +upon an utter abandonment of thyself, as if thou knewest none of +those things which I have mentioned, and thou shalt enter into union +with Him who is, and who is above all existence and knowledge." If +he did not think this to be possible in this present time, why did +he teach it and urge it upon us in this present time? But you ought +to know that a master has said, about this passage of St Dionysius, +that it is possible, and may come to a man so often that he may +become accustomed to it, and be able to gaze into eternity whenever +he will. And a single one of these glances is better, worthier, +higher, and more pleasing to God than all that the creature can do +as a creature. He who has attained to it asks for nothing more, for +he has found the kingdom of heaven and eternal life here on earth. +viii. + +DESCENT INTO HELL + +Even as the soul of Christ had to descend into hell, before it +ascended into heaven, so must the soul of man. And mark how this +comes to pass. When a man truly perceives and considers who and what +he is, and finds himself wholly base and wicked, and unworthy of all +the consolation and kindness that he ever received, either from God +or from the creatures, he falls into such a profound abasement and +contempt for himself, that he thinks himself unworthy to walk upon +the earth; he feels that he deserves that all creatures should rise +against him and avenge their Maker upon him with punishments and +torments; nay, even that were too good for him. And therefore he +will not and dare not desire any consolation or release, either from +God or any creature; he is willing to be unconsoled and unreleased, +and he does not lament for his condemnation and punishment, for they +are right and just, and in accordance with God's will. Nothing +grieves him but his own guilt and wickedness; for that is not right, +and is contrary to God's will: for this reason he is heavy and +troubled. This is the meaning of true repentance for sin. And the +man who in this life enters into this hell, enters afterwards into +the kingdom of heaven, and has a foretaste of it which exceeds all +the delights and happiness which he has ever had, or could have, +from the things of time. But while a man is in this hell, no one can +comfort him, neither God, nor the creatures. Of this condition it +has been written, "Let me die, let me perish! I live without hope; +from within and from without I am condemned, let no man pray for my +deliverance." Now God has not forsaken a man, while he is in this +hell, but He is laying His hand upon him, that he may desire nothing +but the eternal Good only, and may discover that this is so noble +and exceedingly good, that its blessedness cannot be searched out +nor expressed, comfort and joy, peace, rest, and satisfaction. When, +therefore, the man cares for and seeks and desires the eternal Good +and nought beside, and seeks not himself, nor his own things, but +the glory of God only, he is made to partake of every kind of joy, +blessedness, peace, rest, and comfort, and from that time forward is +in the kingdom of God. + +This hell and this heaven are two good safe ways for a man in this +present life, and he is happy who truly finds them. For this hell +shall pass away, but this heaven shall abide for evermore. Let a man +also observe, that when he is in this hell, nothing can console him; +and he cannot believe that he shall ever be delivered or comforted. +But when he is in heaven, nothing can disturb him: he believes that +no one will ever be able to offend or trouble him again, though it +is indeed possible that he may again be troubled and left +unconsoled. + +This heaven and hell come upon a man in such a way, that he knows +not whence they come; and he can do nothing himself towards making +them either come or depart. He can neither give them to himself, nor +take them away from himself, neither bring them nor drive them away; +even as it is written, "The wind bloweth where it listeth, and thou +hearest the sound thereof, but canst not tell whence it cometh or +whither it goeth." And when a man is in either of these two states, +all is well with him, and he is as safe in hell as in heaven. And +while a man is in the world, it is possible for him to pass many +times from the one state into the other--even within a day and +night, and without any motion of his own. But when a man is in +neither of these two states, he holds intercourse with the +creatures, and is carried this way and that, and knows not what +manner of man he is. A man should therefore never forget either of +these states, but carry the memory of them in his heart. xi. + +THE THREE STAGES + +Be well assured that none can be illuminated, unless he be first +cleansed, purified, or stripped. Also none can be united to God +unless he be first illuminated. There are therefore three +stages--first, the purification; secondly, the illumination; and +thirdly, the union. The purification belongs to those who are +beginning or repenting. It is effected in three ways; by repentance +and sorrow for sin, by full confession, and by hearty amendment. The +illumination belongs to those who are growing, and it also is +effected in three ways; by the renunciation of sin, by the practice +of virtue and good works, and by willing endurance of all trials and +temptations. The union belongs to those who are perfect, and this +also is effected in three ways; by pureness and singleness of heart, +by love, and by the contemplation of God, the Creator of all things. +xiv. + +THE LIFE OF CHRIST + +We ought truly to know and believe that no life is so noble, or +good, or pleasing to God, as the life of Christ. And yet it is to +nature and selfishness the most bitter of all lives. For to nature, +and selfishness, and the Me, a life of careless freedom is the +sweetest and pleasantest, but it is not the best; indeed, in some +men it may be the worst. But the life of Christ, though it be the +bitterest of all, should be preferred above all. And hereby ye shall +know this. There is an inward sight which is able to perceive the +one true good, how that it is neither this nor that, but that it is +that of which St Paul says: "When that which is perfect is come, +then that which is in part shall be done away." By this he signifies +that what is whole and perfect excels all the parts, and that all +which is imperfect, and in part, is as nothing compared to what is +perfect. In like manner, all knowledge of the parts is swallowed up +when the whole is known. And where the good is known, it cannot fail +to be desired and loved so greatly, that all other love, with which +a man has loved himself, and other things, vanishes away. Moreover, +that inward sight perceives what is best and noblest in all things, +and loves it in the one true good, and for the sake of the true good +alone. Where this inward sight exists, a man perceives truly that +the life of Christ is the best and noblest life, and that it is +therefore to be chosen above all others; and therefore he willingly +accepts and endures it, without hesitation or complaining, whether +it is pleasing or displeasing to nature and other men, and whether +he himself likes or dislikes it, and finds it sweet or bitter. +Therefore, whenever this perfect and true good is known, the life of +Christ must be followed, until the decease of the body. If any man +vainly deems otherwise, he is deceived, and if any man says +otherwise, he tells a lie; and in whatever man the life of Christ is +not, he will never know the true good or the eternal truth. + +But let no one imagine that we can attain to this true light and +perfect knowledge, and to the life of Christ, by much questioning, +or by listening to others, or by reading and study, or by ability +and deep learning. For so long as a man is occupied with anything +which is this or that, whether it be himself or any other creature; +or does anything, or forms plans, or opinions, or objects, he comes +not to the life of Christ. Christ Himself declared as much, for He +said: "If any man will come after Me, let him deny himself, and take +up his cross, and follow Me." "And if any man hate not his father +and mother, and wife and children, and brethren and sisters, yea and +his own life also, he cannot be my disciple." He means this: "He who +does not give up and abandon everything can never know My eternal +truth, nor attain to My life." And even if this had not been +declared to us, the truth itself proclaims it, for so verily it is. +But as long as a man holds fast to the rudiments and fragments of +this world, and above all to himself, and is conversant with them, +and sets great store by them, he is deceived and blinded, and +perceives what is good only in so far as is convenient and agreeable +to himself and profitable to his own objects. + +Since then the life of Christ is in all ways most bitter to nature +and the self and the Me--for in the true life of Christ nature and +the self and the Me must be abandoned and lost and suffered to die +completely--therefore in all of us nature has a horror of it, and +deems it evil and unjust and foolish; and she strives after such a +life as shall be most agreeable and pleasant to ourselves; and says, +and believes too in her blindness, that such a life is the best of +all. Now nothing is so agreeable and pleasant to nature as a free +and careless manner of life. To this therefore she clings, and takes +enjoyment in herself and her powers, and thinks only of her own +peace and comfort. And this is especially likely to happen, when a +man has high natural gifts of reason, for reason mounts up in its +own light and by its own power, till at last it comes to think +itself the true eternal light, and gives itself out to be such; and +it is thus deceived in itself, and deceives others at the same time, +people who know no better and are prone to be so deceived. +xviii.-xx. + +UNION WITH GOD + +In what does union with God consist? It means that we should be +indeed purely, simply, and wholly at one with the one eternal Will +of God, or altogether without will, so that the created will should +flow out into the eternal Will and be swallowed up and lost in it, +so that the eternal Will alone should do and leave undone in us. Now +observe what may be of use to us in attaining this object. Religious +exercises cannot do this, nor words, nor works, nor any creature or +work done by a creature. We must therefore give up and renounce all +things, suffering them to be what they are, and enter into union +with God. Yet the outward things must be; and sleeping and waking, +walking and standing still, speaking and being silent, must go on as +long as we live. + +But when this union truly comes to pass and is established, the +inner man henceforth stands immoveable in this union; as for the +outer man, God allows him to be moved hither and thither, from this +to that, among things which are necessary and right. So the outer +man says sincerely, "I have no wish to be or not to be, to live or +die, to know or be ignorant, to do or leave undone; I am ready for +all that is to be or ought to be, and obedient to whatever I have to +do or suffer." Thus the outer man has no purpose except to do what +in him lies to further the eternal Will. As for the inner man, it is +truly perceived that he shall stand immoveable, though the outer +man must needs be moved. And if the inner man has any explanation of +the actions of the outer man, he says only that such things as are +ordained by the eternal Will must be and ought to be. It is thus +when God Himself dwells in a man; as we plainly see in the case of +Christ. Moreover, where there is this union, which is the outflow of +the Divine light and dwells in its beams, there is no spiritual +pride nor boldness of spirit, but unbounded humility and a lowly +broken heart; there is also an honest and blameless walk, justice, +peace, contentment, and every virtue. Where these are not, there is +no true union. For even as neither this thing nor that can bring +about or further this union, so nothing can spoil or hinder it, +except the man himself with his self-will, which does him this great +injury. Be well assured of this. xxvii., xxviii. + +THE FALSE LIGHT + +Now I must tell you what the False Light is, and what belongs to it. +All that is contrary to the true light belongs to the false. It +belongs of necessity to the true light that it never seeks to +deceive, nor consents that anyone should be injured or deceived; and +it cannot be deceived itself. But the false light both deceives +others, and is deceived itself. Even as God deceives no man, and +wills not that any should be deceived, so it is with His true light. +The true light is God or Divine, but the false light is nature or +natural. It belongeth to God, that He is neither this nor that, and +that He requires nothing in the man whom He has made to be partaker +in the Divine nature, except goodness as goodness and for the sake +of goodness. This is the token of the true light. But it belongs to +the creature, and to nature, to be something, this or that, and to +intend and seek something, this or that, and not simply what is good +without asking Why. And as God and the true light are without all +self-will, selfishness, and self-Seeking, so the "I, Me, and Mine" +belong to the false light, which in everything seeks itself and its +own ends, and not goodness for the sake of goodness. This is the +character of the natural or carnal man in each of us. Now observe +how it first comes to be deceived. It does not desire or choose +goodness for its own sake, but desires and chooses itself and its +own ends rather than the highest good; and this is an error and the +first deception. Secondly, it fancies itself to be God, when it is +nothing but nature. And because it feigns itself to be God, it takes +to itself what belongs to God; and not that which belongs to God +when He is made man, or when He dwells in a Godlike man; but that +which belongs to God as He is in eternity without the creature. God, +they say, and say truly, needs nothing, is free, exempt from toil, +apart by Himself, above all things: He is unchangeable, immoveable, +and whatever He does is well done. "so will I be," says the false +light. "The more like one is to God, the better one is; I therefore +will be like God and will be God, and will sit and stand at His +right hand." This is what Lucifer the Evil Spirit also said. Now God +in eternity is without contradiction, suffering, and grief, and +nothing can injure or grieve Him. But with God as He is made man it +is otherwise. The false light thinks itself to be above all works, +words, customs, laws, and order, and above the life which Christ led +in the body which He possessed in His human nature. It also claims +to be unmoved by any works of the creatures; it cares not whether +they be good or bad, for God or against Him; it keeps itself aloof +from all things, and deems it fitting that all creatures should +serve it. Further, it says that it has risen beyond the life of +Christ according to the flesh, and that outward things can no longer +touch or pain it, even as it was with Christ after the Resurrection. +Many other strange and false notions it cherishes. Moreover, this +false light says that it has risen above conscience and the sense of +sin, and that whatever it does is right. One of the so-called "Free +Spirits" even said that if he had killed ten men, he would have as +little sense of guilt as if he had killed a dog. This false light, +in so far as it fancies itself to be God, is Lucifer, the Evil +Spirit; but in so far as it makes of no account the life of Christ, +it is Antichrist. It says, indeed, that Christ was without sense of +sin, and that therefore we should be so. We may reply that Satan +also is without sense of sin, and is none the better for that. What +is a sense of sin? It is when we perceive that man has turned away +from God in his will, and that this is man's fault, not God's, for +God is guiltless of sin. Now, who knows himself to be free from sin, +save Christ only? Scarce will any other affirm this. So he who is +without sense of sin is either Christ or the Evil Spirit. But where +the true light is, there is a true and just life such as God loves. +And if a man's life is not perfect, as was that of Christ, still it +is modelled and built on His, and His life is loved, together with +modesty, order, and the other virtues, and all self-will, the "I, +Me, and Mine," is lost; nothing is devised or sought for except +goodness for its own sake. But where the false light is, men no +longer regard the life of Christ and the virtues, but they seek and +purpose what is convenient and pleasant to nature. From this arises +a false liberty, whereby men become regardless of everything. For +the true light is the seed of God, and bringeth forth the fruits of +God; but the false light is the seed of the Devil, and where it is +sown, the fruits of the Devil, nay the very Devil himself, spring +up. xl. + +LIGHT AND LOVE + +It may be asked, What is it like to be a partaker of the Divine +nature, or a Godlike man? The answer is, that he who is steeped in, +or illuminated by, the eternal and Divine Light, and kindled or +consumed by the eternal and Divine Love, is a Godlike man and a +partaker of the Divine nature. But this light or knowledge is of no +avail without love. You may understand this if you remember that a +man who knows very well the difference between virtue and +wickedness, but does not love virtue, is not virtuous, in that he +obeys vice. But he who loves virtue follows after it, and his love +makes him an enemy to wickedness, so that he will not perform any +wicked act and hates wickedness in others; and he loves virtue so +that he would not leave any virtue unperformed even if he had the +choice, not for the sake of reward, but from love of virtue. To such +a man virtue brings its own reward, and he is content with it, and +would part with it for no riches. Such a man is already virtuous, or +in the way to become so. And the truly virtuous man would not cease +to be so to gain the whole world. He would rather die miserably. The +case of justice is the same. Many men know well what is just and +unjust, but yet neither are nor ever will be just men. For they love +not justice, and therefore practise wickedness and injustice. If a +man loved justice, he would do no unjust deed; he would feel so +great abhorrence and anger against injustice whenever he saw it that +he would be willing to do and suffer anything in order to put an end +to injustice, and that men might be made just. He would rather die +than commit an injustice, and all for love of justice. To him, +justice brings her own reward, she rewards him with herself, and so +the just man would rather die a thousand deaths than live as an +unjust man. The same may be said of truth. A man may know very well +what is truth or a lie, but if he loves not the truth, he is not a +true man. If, however, he loves it, it is with truth as with +justice. And of justice Isaiah speaks in the fifth chapter: "Woe +unto them that call evil good, and good evil, that put darkness for +light, and light for darkness; that put bitter for sweet, and sweet +for bitter." Thus we may understand that knowledge and light avail +nothing without love. We see the truth of this in the case of the +Evil One. He perceives and knows good and evil, right and wrong: but +since he has no love for the good that he sees, he becomes not good. +It is true indeed that Love must be led and instructed by knowledge, +but if knowledge is not followed by Love, it will be of no avail. So +also with God and Divine things. Although a man know much about God +and Divine things, and even dream that he sees and understands what +God Himself is, yet if he have not Love, he will never become like +God or a partaker of the Divine nature. But if Love be added to his +knowledge, he cannot help cleaving to God, and forsaking all that is +not God or from God, and hating it and fighting with it, and finding +it a cross and burden. And this Love so unites a man to God, that he +can never again be separated from Him. xli. + +PARADISE + +What is Paradise? All things that are. For all things are good and +pleasant, and may therefore fitly be called Paradise. It is also +said, that Paradise is an outer court of heaven. In the same way, +this world is truly an outer court of the eternal, or of eternity; +and this is specially true of any temporal things or creatures which +manifest the Eternal or remind us of eternity; for the creatures are +a guide and path to God and eternity. Thus the world is an outer +court of eternity, and therefore it may well be called a Paradise, +for so indeed it is. And in this Paradise all things are lawful +except one tree and its fruit. That is to say, of all things that +exist, nothing is forbidden or contrary to God, except one thing +only. That one thing is self-will, or to will otherwise than as the +eternal Will would have it. Remember this. For God says to Adam +(that is, to every man) "Whatever thou art, or doest, or leavest +undone, or whatever happens, is lawful if it be done for the sake of +and according to My will, and not according to thy will. But all +that is done from thy will is contrary to the eternal Will." Not +that everything which is so done is in itself contrary to the +eternal Will, but in so far as it is done from a different will, or +otherwise than from the Eternal and Divine Will. l. + +WILL AND SELF-WILL + +Some may ask: "If this tree, Self-Will, is so contrary to God and to +the eternal will, why did God create it, and place it in Paradise?" +We may answer: a man who is truly humble and enlightened does not +ask God to reveal His secrets to him, or enquire why God does this +or that, or prevents or allows this or that; he only desires to know +how he may please God, and become as nothing in himself, having no +will of his own, and that the eternal will may live in him, and +possess him wholly, unhampered by any other will, and how what is +due may be paid to the Eternal Will, by him and through him. But +there is another answer to this question. For we may say: the most +noble and gracious gift that is bestowed on any creature is the +Reason and the Will. These two are so intimately connected that the +one cannot be anywhere without the other. If it were not for these +two gifts, there would be no reasonable creatures, but only brutes +and brutality; and this would be a great loss, for God would then +never receive His due, or behold Himself and His attributes +exhibited in action; a thing which ought to be, and is, necessary to +perfection. Now Perception and Reason are conferred together with +will, in order that they may teach the will and also themselves, +that neither perception nor will is of itself, or to itself, nor +ought to seek or obey itself. Nor must they turn themselves to their +own profit, nor use themselves for their own ends; for they belong +to Him from whom they proceed, and they shall submit to Him, and +flow back to Him, and become nothing in themselves--that is, in +their selfhood. + +But now you must consider more in detail something concerning the +will. There is an Eternal Will, which is a first principle and +substance in God, apart from all works and all externalisation; and +the same will is in man, or the creature, willing and bringing to +pass certain things. For it pertains to the will, to will something. +For what else does it exist? It would be a vain thing if it had no +work to do, and this it cannot have without the creature. And so +there must needs be creatures, and God will have them, in order that +by their means the will may be exercised, and may work, though in +God it must be without work. Therefore the will in the creature, +which we call the created will, is as truly God's as the eternal +will, and is not from the creature. + +And since God cannot exercise His will, in working and effecting +changes, without the creature, He is pleased to do so in and with +the creature. Therefore the will is not given to be exercised by the +creature, but by God alone, who has the right to carry into effect +His own will by the will which is in man, but yet is God's will. And +in any man or creature, in whom it should be thus, purely and +simply, the will of that man or creature would be exercised not by +the man but by God, and thus it would not be self-will, and the man +would only will as God wills; for God Himself, and not man, would be +moving the will. Thus the will would be united with the Eternal +Will, and would flow into it; although the man would retain his +sense of liking and disliking, pleasure and pain. But nothing is +complained of, except what is contrary to God. And there is no +rejoicing except in God alone, and in that which belongs to Him. And +as with the will, so is it with all the other faculties of man; they +are all of God and not of man. And when the will is wholly given up +to God, the other faculties will certainly be given up too; and God +will have what is due to Him. + +No one may call that which is free his own, and he who makes it his +own, doeth injustice. Now in all the sphere of freedom nothing is so +free as the will; and he who makes it his own, and allows it not to +remain in its excellent freedom, and free nobleness, and free +exercise, does it a great injustice. This is what is done by the +devil, and Adam, and all their followers. But he who leaves the will +in its noble freedom does right; and this is what Christ, and all +who follow Him, do. And he who deprives the will of its noble +freedom, and makes it his own, must necessarily be oppressed with +cares and discontent, and disquietude, and every kind of misery, and +this will be his lot throughout time and eternity. But he who leaves +the will in its freedom has contentment and peace and rest and +blessedness, through time and eternity. Where there is a man whose +will is not enslaved, he is free indeed, and in bondage to no man. +He is one of those to whom Christ said: "The truth shall make you +free"; and He adds immediately afterwards: "If the Son shall make +you free, ye shall be free indeed." + +Moreover, observe that whenever the will chooses unhindered whatever +it will, it always and in all cases chooses what is noblest and +best, and hates whatever is not noble and good, and regards it as an +offence. And the more free and unhampered the will is, the more it +is grieved by evil, by injustice, by iniquity, and all manner of +sin. We see this in Christ, whose will was the purest and freest and +the least brought into bondage of any man's who ever lived. So was +the human nature of Christ the most free and pure of all creatures; +and yet He felt the deepest distress, pain, and wrath at sin that +any creature ever felt. But when men claim freedom for themselves, +in such a way as to feel no sorrow or anger at sin, and all that is +contrary to God, and say that we must take no notice of anything, +and care for nothing, but be, in this life, what Christ was after +the resurrection, and so forth, this is not the true and Divine +freedom that springs from the true and Divine light, but a natural, +unrighteous, false, deceiving freedom, which springs from the +natural, false, deceitful light. + +If there were no self-will, there would be no proprietorship. There +is no proprietorship in heaven; and this is why contentment, peace, +and blessedness are there. If anyone in heaven were so bold as to +call anything his own, he would immediately be cast out into hell, +and become an evil spirit. But in hell everyone will have self-will, +and therefore in hell is every kind of wretchedness and misery. And +so it is also on earth. But if anyone in hell could rid himself of +his self-will and call nothing his own, he would pass out of hell +into heaven. And if a man, while here on earth, could be entirely +rid of self-will and proprietorship, and stand up free and at +liberty in the true light of God, and continue therein, he would be +sure to inherit the kingdom of heaven. For he who has anything, or +who desires to have anything of his own, is a slave; and he who has +nothing of his own, nor desires to have anything, is free and at +liberty, and is in bondage to no man. li. + +UNION THROUGH CHRIST + +Observe now how the Father draws men to Christ. When something of +the perfect good is revealed and made manifest within the human +soul, as it were in a sudden flash, the soul conceives a desire to +draw near to the perfect goodness, and to unite herself with the +Father. And the more strongly she longs and desires, the more is +revealed to her; and the more is revealed to her, the more she is +drawn to the Father, and the more is her desire kindled. So the soul +is drawn and kindled into an union with the eternal goodness. And +this is the drawing of the Father; and so the soul is taught by Him +who draws her to Himself, that she cannot become united with Him +unless she can come to Him by means of the life of Christ. liii. + +[1]In his Introduction to the "Imitation of Christ," in this series. + +[2]e.g. she distinguishes, as Eckhart does, between God and the +Godhead. + +[3]The "three propositions" of Amalric are--1. "Deus est omnia." 2. +Every Christian, as a con-dition of salvation, must believe that he +is a member of Christ. 3. To those who are in charity no sin is +imputed. + +[4]Preger is probably wrong in identifying him with a "brother +Eckhart," Prior of Frankfort, who about 1320 was delated to the head +of the Order as suspectus de malis familiaritatibus, words which can +only mean "keeping bad company" in a moral sense, not "con-sorting +with heretics," as Preger suggests. Eckhart's character, so far as +we know, was never assailed, even by his enemies, and it is +therefore probable that "brother Eckhart" was a different person. + +[5]I have abridged the bull considerably, but have included all the +main accusations. + +[6]See pages 13, 16. + +[7]See pages 14, 15. + +[8]See page 1. + +[9]This is an obscure point in Eckhart's philosophy, too technical +to be discussed here; but Eckhart's doctrine of God is certainly +more orthodox and less pantheistic than those of 'Dionysius' and +Scotus Erigena. + +[10]Cf. St Augustine, In Joann. Ev. Tract. xxxix. 10: praeteritum et +futurum invenio in omni motu rerum: in veritate quae manet +praeteritum et futurum non invenio, sed solum praesens. + +[11]This doctrine is fully explained by St. Augustine, Epist. 237, +who follows Plotinus, Enn. vi. 4-6. + +[12]This queer word occurs for the first time, I think, in Jerome's +notes to the first chapter of Ezekiel. He writes the word in Greek, +and explains it as that part of the soul which always opposes vices. +The word is common in Bonaventura and other scholastic mystics, and +is often misspelt synderesis. + +[13]It must, however, be said that Preger is too ready to assume +that the logical development of Eckhart's system away from Thomist +scholasticism can be traced as a gradual process in his writings, +the order of which is very uncertain. We are not justified in saying +in a positive manner that Eckhart's philosophy passed through three +phases, in the first of which the primacy is held by the will, in +the second by the created reason, and in the third by the uncreated +reason. + +[14]See pages 14, 15. + +[15]C.B. Upton: "Hibbert Lectures," p. 17. + +[16]A.E. Taylor: "The Problem of Conduct," PP. 464-5. + +[17]See pages 71-2. + +[18]See pages 12-13. + +[19]See, for example, Prof. W. James' "Varieties of Religions +Experience," P. 400. + +[20]Jacob Bhme's experience is typical: "Suddenly did my spirit +break through into the innermost birth or geniture of the Deity, and +there was I embraced with love, as a bridegroom embraces his dearly +beloved bride. But the greatness of the triumphing that was in the +spirit I cannot express in speech or writing; nor can it be compared +to anything but the resurrection of the dead to life. In this light +my spirit suddenly saw through all; even in herbs and grass it knew +God, who and what He is," etc. Dr Johnson was, no doubt, right in +thinking that "Jacob" would have been wiser, and "more like St +Paul," if he had not attempted to utter the unutterable things which +he saw. + +[21]The extracts from the "Theologia Germanica" will show that this +treatise represents a later and less paradoxical form of mystical +thought than Eckhart's. + +[22]The maxim, however, is much older than Suso. + +[23]Royce: "The World and the Individual" vol. i. p. 193. + +[24]So in the "Lignum Vitae" of Laurentius Justinianus we read: "Let +self-will cease, and there will be no more hell." + +[25] "The Inner Way," being thirty-six sermons by John Tauler. +Translated by A.W. Hutton, M.A. + +[26]On the psychology of ecstatic mysticism see Leuba, in the Revue +Philosophique, July and November 1902. + +[27] "Varieties of Religious Experience," p. 13. + +[28]Maudsley: "Natural Causes and Supernatural Seemings," p. 256. + +[29]See Leuba: "Tendances religieuses chez les mystiques +chrtiens" in Revue Philosophique, Nov. 1902. + +[30] "Theologia Germanica," translated by Susanna Winkworth. +Macmillan & Co., 1893. + +[31] "Varieties of Religious Experience," 1902. + +[32] "Personal Idealism," 1902. + +[33] "Varieties of Religious Experience," p. 103. + +[34] "In Tune with the Infinite," by R.W. Trine (Bell & Sons, 1902). +Fifty-ninth thousand. The extract appears to be a quotation from +another writer, but no reference is given. + +[35]Compare Eckhart's saying that the eye with which I see God is +the same as the eye with which He sees me. + +[36] "In Tune with the Infinite," pp. 58, 119. + +[37]The numbers refer to pages in Pfeiffer's edition. + +[38]The numbers refer to the Sermons in Hamberger's edition of 1864. + +[39]The reference is to 1 Peter iii. 8. + +[40]The time would, I suppose, be about half-an-hour. Many other +ecstatics have named this as the normal duration of trance. + +[41]Or, "spoke the eternal Wisdom (= the Word of God) in his heart." + +[42]John i. 3, 4. This punctuation, whereby the words "that which +was made" are referred to the clause which follows, and not to that +which precedes, is adopted by most of the Greek fathers, and is +still maintained by some good commentators--e.g. Bishop Westcott. + +[43]Ecclus. xxiv. 19. + +[44]Ecclus. xl. 20. + +The Project Gutenberg Etext of Light, Life, and Love +by W. R. Inge +******This file should be named lllov10.txt or lllov10.zip****** + +Corrected EDITIONS of our etexts get a new NUMBER, lllov11.txt +VERSIONS based on separate sources get new LETTER, lllov10a.txt + +This etext was produced by Charles Aldarondo. + +*** + +More information about this book is at the top of this file. + + +We are now trying to release all our eBooks one year in advance +of the official release dates, leaving time for better editing. +Please be encouraged to tell us about any error or corrections, +even years after the official publication date. + +Please note neither this listing nor its contents are final til +midnight of the last day of the month of any such announcement. +The official release date of all Project Gutenberg eBooks is at +Midnight, Central Time, of the last day of the stated month. A +preliminary version may often be posted for suggestion, comment +and editing by those who wish to do so. + +Most people start at our Web sites at: +https://gutenberg.org or +http://promo.net/pg + +These Web sites include award-winning information about Project +Gutenberg, including how to donate, how to help produce our new +eBooks, and how to subscribe to our email newsletter (free!). + + +Those of you who want to download any eBook before announcement +can get to them as follows, and just download by date. This is +also a good way to get them instantly upon announcement, as the +indexes our cataloguers produce obviously take a while after an +announcement goes out in the Project Gutenberg Newsletter. + +http://www.ibiblio.org/gutenberg/eBook03 or +ftp://ftp.ibiblio.org/pub/docs/books/gutenberg/eBook03 + +Or /eBook02, 01, 00, 99, 98, 97, 96, 95, 94, 93, 92, 92, 91 or 90 + +Just search by the first five letters of the filename you want, +as it appears in our Newsletters. + + +Information about Project Gutenberg (one page) + +We produce about two million dollars for each hour we work. The +time it takes us, a rather conservative estimate, is fifty hours +to get any eBook selected, entered, proofread, edited, copyright +searched and analyzed, the copyright letters written, etc. Our +projected audience is one hundred million readers. If the value +per text is nominally estimated at one dollar then we produce $2 +million dollars per hour in 2002 as we release over 100 new text +files per month: 1240 more eBooks in 2001 for a total of 4000+ +We are already on our way to trying for 2000 more eBooks in 2002 +If they reach just 1-2% of the world's population then the total +will reach over half a trillion eBooks given away by year's end. + +The Goal of Project Gutenberg is to Give Away 1 Trillion eBooks! +This is ten thousand titles each to one hundred million readers, +which is only about 4% of the present number of computer users. + +Here is the briefest record of our progress (* means estimated): + +eBooks Year Month + + 1 1971 July + 10 1991 January + 100 1994 January + 1000 1997 August + 1500 1998 October + 2000 1999 December + 2500 2000 December + 3000 2001 November + 4000 2001 October/November + 6000 2002 December* + 9000 2003 November* +10000 2004 January* + + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation has been created +to secure a future for Project Gutenberg into the next millennium. + +We need your donations more than ever! + +As of February, 2002, contributions are being solicited from people +and organizations in: Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Connecticut, +Delaware, District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Illinois, +Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Massachusetts, +Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New +Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, +Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South +Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West +Virginia, Wisconsin, and Wyoming. + +We have filed in all 50 states now, but these are the only ones +that have responded. + +As the requirements for other states are met, additions to this list +will be made and fund raising will begin in the additional states. +Please feel free to ask to check the status of your state. + +In answer to various questions we have received on this: + +We are constantly working on finishing the paperwork to legally +request donations in all 50 states. If your state is not listed and +you would like to know if we have added it since the list you have, +just ask. + +While we cannot solicit donations from people in states where we are +not yet registered, we know of no prohibition against accepting +donations from donors in these states who approach us with an offer to +donate. + +International donations are accepted, but we don't know ANYTHING about +how to make them tax-deductible, or even if they CAN be made +deductible, and don't have the staff to handle it even if there are +ways. + +The most recent list of states, along with all methods for donations +(including credit card donations and international donations), may be +found online at https://www.gutenberg.org/donation.html + +Donations by check or money order may be sent to: + +Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation +PMB 113 +1739 University Ave. +Oxford, MS 38655-4109 + +Contact us if you want to arrange for a wire transfer or payment +method other than by check or money order. + + +The Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation has been approved by +the US Internal Revenue Service as a 501(c)(3) organization with EIN +[Employee Identification Number] 64-622154. Donations are +tax-deductible to the maximum extent permitted by law. As fund-raising +requirements for other states are met, additions to this list will be +made and fund-raising will begin in the additional states. + +We need your donations more than ever! + +You can get up to date donation information at: + +https://www.gutenberg.org/donation.html + + +*** + +If you can't reach Project Gutenberg, +you can always email directly to: + +Michael S. Hart <hart@pobox.com> + +Prof. Hart will answer or forward your message. + +We would prefer to send you information by email. + + +**The Legal Small Print** + + +(Three Pages) + +***START**THE SMALL PRINT!**FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN EBOOKS**START*** +Why is this "Small Print!" statement here? You know: lawyers. +They tell us you might sue us if there is something wrong with +your copy of this eBook, even if you got it for free from +someone other than us, and even if what's wrong is not our +fault. So, among other things, this "Small Print!" statement +disclaims most of our liability to you. It also tells you how +you may distribute copies of this eBook if you want to. + +*BEFORE!* YOU USE OR READ THIS EBOOK +By using or reading any part of this PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm +eBook, you indicate that you understand, agree to and accept +this "Small Print!" statement. If you do not, you can receive +a refund of the money (if any) you paid for this eBook by +sending a request within 30 days of receiving it to the person +you got it from. If you received this eBook on a physical +medium (such as a disk), you must return it with your request. + +ABOUT PROJECT GUTENBERG-TM EBOOKS +This PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm eBook, like most PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm eBooks, +is a "public domain" work distributed by Professor Michael S. Hart +through the Project Gutenberg Association (the "Project"). +Among other things, this means that no one owns a United States copyright +on or for this work, so the Project (and you!) can copy and +distribute it in the United States without permission and +without paying copyright royalties. Special rules, set forth +below, apply if you wish to copy and distribute this eBook +under the "PROJECT GUTENBERG" trademark. + +Please do not use the "PROJECT GUTENBERG" trademark to market +any commercial products without permission. + +To create these eBooks, the Project expends considerable +efforts to identify, transcribe and proofread public domain +works. Despite these efforts, the Project's eBooks and any +medium they may be on may contain "Defects". Among other +things, Defects may take the form of incomplete, inaccurate or +corrupt data, transcription errors, a copyright or other +intellectual property infringement, a defective or damaged +disk or other eBook medium, a computer virus, or computer +codes that damage or cannot be read by your equipment. + +LIMITED WARRANTY; DISCLAIMER OF DAMAGES +But for the "Right of Replacement or Refund" described below, +[1] Michael Hart and the Foundation (and any other party you may +receive this eBook from as a PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm eBook) disclaims +all liability to you for damages, costs and expenses, including +legal fees, and [2] YOU HAVE NO REMEDIES FOR NEGLIGENCE OR +UNDER STRICT LIABILITY, OR FOR BREACH OF WARRANTY OR CONTRACT, +INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL, PUNITIVE +OR INCIDENTAL DAMAGES, EVEN IF YOU GIVE NOTICE OF THE +POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES. + +If you discover a Defect in this eBook within 90 days of +receiving it, you can receive a refund of the money (if any) +you paid for it by sending an explanatory note within that +time to the person you received it from. If you received it +on a physical medium, you must return it with your note, and +such person may choose to alternatively give you a replacement +copy. If you received it electronically, such person may +choose to alternatively give you a second opportunity to +receive it electronically. + +THIS EBOOK IS OTHERWISE PROVIDED TO YOU "AS-IS". NO OTHER +WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, ARE MADE TO YOU AS +TO THE EBOOK OR ANY MEDIUM IT MAY BE ON, INCLUDING BUT NOT +LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A +PARTICULAR PURPOSE. + +Some states do not allow disclaimers of implied warranties or +the exclusion or limitation of consequential damages, so the +above disclaimers and exclusions may not apply to you, and you +may have other legal rights. + +INDEMNITY +You will indemnify and hold Michael Hart, the Foundation, +and its trustees and agents, and any volunteers associated +with the production and distribution of Project Gutenberg-tm +texts harmless, from all liability, cost and expense, including +legal fees, that arise directly or indirectly from any of the +following that you do or cause: [1] distribution of this eBook, +[2] alteration, modification, or addition to the eBook, +or [3] any Defect. + +DISTRIBUTION UNDER "PROJECT GUTENBERG-tm" +You may distribute copies of this eBook electronically, or by +disk, book or any other medium if you either delete this +"Small Print!" and all other references to Project Gutenberg, +or: + +[1] Only give exact copies of it. Among other things, this + requires that you do not remove, alter or modify the + eBook or this "small print!" statement. You may however, + if you wish, distribute this eBook in machine readable + binary, compressed, mark-up, or proprietary form, + including any form resulting from conversion by word + processing or hypertext software, but only so long as + *EITHER*: + + [*] The eBook, when displayed, is clearly readable, and + does *not* contain characters other than those + intended by the author of the work, although tilde + (~), asterisk (*) and underline (_) characters may + be used to convey punctuation intended by the + author, and additional characters may be used to + indicate hypertext links; OR + + [*] The eBook may be readily converted by the reader at + no expense into plain ASCII, EBCDIC or equivalent + form by the program that displays the eBook (as is + the case, for instance, with most word processors); + OR + + [*] You provide, or agree to also provide on request at + no additional cost, fee or expense, a copy of the + eBook in its original plain ASCII form (or in EBCDIC + or other equivalent proprietary form). + +[2] Honor the eBook refund and replacement provisions of this + "Small Print!" statement. + +[3] Pay a trademark license fee to the Foundation of 20% of the + gross profits you derive calculated using the method you + already use to calculate your applicable taxes. If you + don't derive profits, no royalty is due. Royalties are + payable to "Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation" + the 60 days following each date you prepare (or were + legally required to prepare) your annual (or equivalent + periodic) tax return. Please contact us beforehand to + let us know your plans and to work out the details. + +WHAT IF YOU *WANT* TO SEND MONEY EVEN IF YOU DON'T HAVE TO? +Project Gutenberg is dedicated to increasing the number of +public domain and licensed works that can be freely distributed +in machine readable form. + +The Project gratefully accepts contributions of money, time, +public domain materials, or royalty free copyright licenses. +Money should be paid to the: +"Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation." + +If you are interested in contributing scanning equipment or +software or other items, please contact Michael Hart at: +hart@pobox.com + +[Portions of this header are copyright (C) 2001 by Michael S. Hart +and may be reprinted only when these eBooks are free of all fees.] +[Project Gutenberg is a TradeMark and may not be used in any sales +of Project Gutenberg eBooks or other materials be they hardware or +software or any other related product without express permission.] + +*END THE SMALL PRINT! FOR PUBLIC DOMAIN EBOOKS*Ver.02/11/02*END* + + + +End of The Project Gutenberg Etext of Light, Life, and Love +by W. R. Inge + diff --git a/old/4664.zip b/old/4664.zip Binary files differnew file mode 100644 index 0000000..456158d --- /dev/null +++ b/old/4664.zip |
