%PDF-1.5
%����
5 0 obj <<
/Length 1673      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 518.175 Td [(The)-328(Project)-328(Gutenberg)-328(EBook)-328(of)-328(The)-328(Supernatural)-328(in)-328(the)-327(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-250(by)-250(Charles)-250(A.)-250(Row)]TJ 0 -29.913 Td [(This)-200(ebook)-199(is)-200(for)-200(the)-199(use)-200(of)-199(anyone)-200(anywhere)-200(in)-199(the)-200(United)-199(States)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-287(most)-286(other)-287(parts)-287(of)-286(the)-287(world)-287(at)-286(no)-287(cost)-287(and)-286(with)-287(almost)-286(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(restrictions)-260(whatsoever.)-279(You)-259(may)-260(copy)-260(it,)-262(give)-259(it)-260(away)-260(or)-259(re-use)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-201(under)-200(the)-201(terms)-201(of)-200(the)-201(Project)-201(Gutenberg)-200(License)-201(included)-200(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-251(eBook)-250(or)-251(online)-250(at)-251(htt)1(p://www.gutenberg.org/license.)-252(If)-250(you)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-224(not)-223(located)-224(in)-223(the)-224(United)-223(States,)-229(you'll)-223(have)-224(to)-223(check)-224(the)-223(laws)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(country)-250(where)-250(you)-250(are)-250(located)-250(before)-250(using)-250(this)-250(ebook.)]TJ 0 -29.913 Td [(Title:)-500(The)-500(Supernatural)-500(in)-500(the)-500(New)-500(Testament)]TJ 0 -27.098 Td [(Author:)-500(Charles)-500(A.)-500(Row)]TJ 0 -27.099 Td [(Release)-500(Date:)-500(August)-500(19,)-500(2014)-500([Ebook)-500(46630])]TJ 0 -27.098 Td [(Language:)-500(English)]TJ 0 -40.648 Td [(***START)-500(OF)-500(THE)-500(PROJECT)-500(GUTENBERG)-500(EBOOK)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(THE)-500(SUPERNATURAL)-500(IN)-500(THE)-500(NEW)-500(TESTAMENT***)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
14 0 obj <<
/Length 1423      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 123.995 516.375 Td [(The)-259(Supernatural)-259(in)-259(the)-260(New)]TJ 70.372 -24.647 Td [(Testament)]TJ/F16 15.7808 Tf -60.624 -20.515 Td [(Possible,)-261(Credible,)-260(and)-259(Historical)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf -11.606 -17.096 Td [(Or:)-260(An)-255(Examination)-255(of)-255(the)-255(Validity)-255(of)-255(Some)]TJ -22.767 -17.096 Td [(Recent)-252(Objections)-251(Against)-252(Christianity)-252(as)-252(a)-251(Divine)]TJ 105.997 -17.095 Td [(Revelation)]TJ 16.885 -17.096 Td [(By)-285(the)]TJ/F16 15.7808 Tf -70.979 -20.515 Td [(Rev.)-291(Charles)-264(A.)-264(Row,)-267(M.A.)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 24.95 -17.096 Td [(Prebendary)-271(of)-272(St.)-313(Paul's)]TJ -60.701 -17.096 Td [(Author)-253(of)]TJ/F20 13.1507 Tf 54.865 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 5.839 0 Td [(The)-253(Jesus)-253(of)-253(the)-253(Evangelists,)]TJ/F20 13.1507 Tf 152.469 0 Td [(\035)-253(\034)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 15.005 0 Td [(The)]TJ -234.024 -17.096 Td [(Nature)-255(and)-255(Extent)-255(of)-254(Divine)-255(Inspiration,)]TJ/F20 13.1507 Tf 212.886 0 Td [(\035)-255(\034)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 15.029 0 Td [(The)]TJ -222.678 -17.096 Td [(Moral)-256(Teaching)-257(of)-256(the)-257(New)-256(Testament,)]TJ/F20 13.1507 Tf 207.862 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 9.211 0 Td [(Etc.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -109.119 -13.549 Td [(London)]TJ -20.298 -13.549 Td [(Frederic)-279(Norgate)]TJ 26.358 -13.549 Td [(1875)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
18 0 obj <<
/Length 4587      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Contents)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -32.791 Td [(Dedication.)-862(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-1474(2)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -13.627 Td [(Chapter)-322(I.)-322(Introduction.)-466(The)-322(Position)-322(of)-322(the)-322(Controversy)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(Between)-163(the)-163(Opponents)-162(and)-163(the)-163(Defenders)-163(of)-162(Christianity.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-1050(5)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.627 Td [(Chapter)-250(II.)-250(Definitions)-250(of)-250(Terms.)-530(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-974(27)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -13.627 Td [(Chapter)-323(III.)-323(The)-323(Supernatural)-323(Elements)-323(Contained)-323(in)-323(the)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(New)-226(Testament:)-237(In)-226(What)-226(Do)-225(They)-226(Consist?)-242(And)-225(What)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(View)-250(Do)-250(Its)-250(Writers)-250(Take)-250(Respecting)-250(Them?)-993(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-974(47)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.627 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-310(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-974(63)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -13.627 Td [(Chapter)-720(V.)-719(The)-720(Antecedent)-719(Improbability)-720(of)-719(Mira-)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(cles.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.691 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(The)-250(Unknown)-250(and)-250(Unknowable)-250(God.)-520(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-974(87)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -45.873 -13.627 Td [(Chapter)-213(VI.)-214(The)-213(Objection)-214(That)-213(Miracles)-214(Are)-213(Contrary)-213(To)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(Reason)-250(Considered.)-601(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(112)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.627 Td [(Chapter)-165(VII.)-164(The)-165(Allegation)-164(That)-165(No)-164(Testimony)-165(Can)-164(Prove)]TJ 15.273 -13.55 Td [(The)-250(Truth)-250(Of)-250(A)-250(Supernatural)-250(Event.)-853(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(139)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.626 Td [(Chapter)-186(VIII.)-186(The)-185(Objection)-186(That)-186(The)-186(Defenders)-186(Of)-185(Chris-)]TJ 15.273 -13.55 Td [(tianity)-229(Assume)-229(Certain)-229(Facts)-229(The)-229(Truth)-229(Of)-229(Which)-229(Can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Only)-457(Be)-456(Known)-457(By)-457(Revelation,)-508(And)-457(Then)-456(Reason)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(From)-218(Those)-218(Facts)-219(To)-218(The)-218(Truth)-218(Of)-219(The)-218(Bible,)-224(Consid-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ered.)-629(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(160)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.627 Td [(Chapter)-239(IX.)-240(Demoniacal)-239(Miracles)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 147.492 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(General)-239(Considerations.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-50(177)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -158.401 -13.627 Td [(Chapter)-250(X.)-250(The)-250(Existence)-250(And)-250(Miracles)-250(Of)-250(Satan.)-421(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(197)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -13.627 Td [(Chapter)-551(XI.)-550(Possession:)-851(Is)-551(The)-551(Theory)-550(That)-551(It)-550(Was)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(Madness)-318(Subversive)-317(Of)-318(The)-318(Historical)-317(Value)-318(Of)-317(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-250(Or)-250(Inconsistent)-250(With)-250(The)-250(Veracity)-250(Of)-250(Christ?)-298(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(211)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.627 Td [(Chapter)-266(XII.)-267(Possession,)-270(If)-266(An)-267(Objective)-266(Reality,)-270(Neither)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(Incredible)-215(Nor)-214(Contrary)-215(To)-215(The)-214(Ascertained)-215(Truths)-214(Of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Mental)-250(Science.)-657(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(236)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.626 Td [(Chapter)-234(XIII.)-234(The)-235(Alleged)-234(Credulity)-234(Of)-234(The)-234(Followers)-234(Of)]TJ 15.273 -13.55 Td [(Jesus.)-989(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(253)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
21 0 obj <<
/Length 3883      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(iv)-8977(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Chapter)-292(XIV.)-291(The)-291(Love)-292(Of)-291(The)-292(Marvellous)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 193.276 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(Its)-291(Bearing)]TJ -188.912 -13.549 Td [(On)-250(The)-250(Value)-250(Of)-250(Testimony)-250(To)-250(Miracles.)-742(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(273)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.549 Td [(Chapter)-323(XV.)-323(Our)-323(Summary)-323(Rejection)-323(Of)-323(Current)-323(Super-)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(naturalism)-214(Considered)-215(In)-214(Its)-214(Bearing)-215(On)-214(The)-214(Evidence)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(For)-250(Miracles.)-962(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(287)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.549 Td [(Chapter)-220(XVI.)-220(General)-221(Objections)-220(To)-220(Miracles)-220(As)-220(Creden-)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(tials)-250(Of)-250(A)-250(Revelation.)-573(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(304)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.549 Td [(Chapter)-427(XVII.)-426(The)-426(Historical)-427(Evidence)-426(On)-427(Which)-426(The)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(Great)-267(Facts)-266(Of)-267(Christianity)-267(Rest)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 141.324 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(General)-267(Considera-)]TJ -152.233 -13.55 Td [(tions.)-405(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(323)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.549 Td [(Chapter)-201(XVIII.)-201(The)-201(Testimony)-200(Of)-201(The)-201(Church,)-211(And)-201(Of)-200(St.)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(Paul's)-211(Epistles,)-218(To)-211(The)-210(Facts)-211(Of)-211(Primitive)-210(Christianity.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Their)-250(Historical)-250(Value)-250(Considered.)-547(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(345)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.549 Td [(Chapter)-213(XIX.)-213(The)-214(Evidence)-213(Furnished)-213(By)-213(The)-213(Epistles)-213(To)]TJ 15.273 -13.55 Td [(The)-338(Facts)-338(Of)-339(Our)-338(Lord's)-338(Life,)-360(And)-339(To)-338(The)-338(Truth)-338(Of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-250(Resurrection.)-685(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(371)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.549 Td [(Chapter)-248(XX.)-248(The)-248(Resurrection)-248(Of)-248(Jesus)-248(Christ)-248(An)-247(Histor-)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(ical)-250(Fact.)-434(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(392)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.549 Td [(Chapter)-394(XXI.)-394(The)-394(Historical)-394(Value)-394(Of)-394(The)-394(Gospels)-393(As)]TJ 15.273 -13.55 Td [(Deduced)-250(From)-250(Previous)-250(Considerations.)-629(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(414)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.549 Td [(Chapter)-347(XXII.)-347(The)-348(Historical)-347(Character)-347(Of)-347(The)-347(Gospels)]TJ 15.273 -13.549 Td [(As)-250(Deduced)-250(From)-250(Their)-250(Internal)-250(Structure.)-326(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(431)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -15.273 -13.549 Td [(Footnotes)-805(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)-500(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 [-474(459)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
25 0 obj <<
/Length 530       
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
1 0 0 1 143.552 416.891 cm
q
.1403 0 0 .1403 0 0 cm
q
600 0 0 800 0 0 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
Q
1 0 0 1 -143.552 -416.891 cm
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 58.727 403.341 Td [([Transcriber's)-251(Note:)-253(The)-251(above)-251(cover)-252(image)-251(was)-251(produced)-251(by)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-396(submitter)-395(at)-396(Distributed)-395(Proofreaders,)-432(and)-395(is)-396(being)-395(placed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-250(the)-250(public)-250(domain.])]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 -29.64 Td [([iii])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
22 0 obj <<
/Type /XObject
/Subtype /Image
/Width 600
/Height 800
/BitsPerComponent 8
/Length 130060
/ColorSpace /DeviceRGB
/Filter /DCTDecode
>>
stream
����JFIF


HH��Created with GIMP��C




��C
		

�� X


��






��

��

��0h�#�1
0h�F$H�@L$��<�C��`��D�8�4��A0h�#�1`�a�	�LP,�0�L0a1�	����	�&4a1@�B0pÁ0��ƌ&(Fp&0�QQ9��q�Ȋ��hD�	�"*#��<p'<���PF�TNp���p�"�1A
Q9��q�Ȇ4#L	X#ē81�a�	�+x�`� Ќ8a0%`�L���&��I��B0���� ����g�~�}Y��ߟ:~|}��i��^Bp��)>�����O�C#|��
�y��Q�������g�l��~�~�|y��ψ?!?Q>���O�>������O�>��1�Ÿ�i��S珋,a�a�'�&�J|�嗟6{d�^}q���F|�Dg���Ǹ{g�G��z'�'�@��2}I�1��~z~�q瑓�
�}Y1�g����4��>T�q'�~�N8
4�,�=S���O<���>X�ȏ׏<��=�s�ϭ>xy!�R~^}
�b~p��s�a׎>�$�#�#�ҏ�>����?i���O�<�b�S���=��!>t�t�gp�F��8�0�>8����4���h
�`���s��8h#I�f�F8᠍'0p
�p��
0�EJ���Lp��
0�EJ���Lp��
0�EJ���Lp��
0�EJ���Lp��
0�E@%)�D�Pi9@D�F�%)�D�Pi9@D�F�%)�D�Pi9@D�F�%)�D�Pi9@D�F�%)�D�Pi9a	��a1X$���81�'
��`�V(���<`�LX��Bp�LV	0eb�a	��a1X$�@�8��
X���#�a�q�$`�BL4
b�4�D�CɆ�,YƀP���y0�	�L���0�E�pF�)0�
i�$��L,#4Y�h��
0`��0�f��JL���0�F�),@Cĕ��ҳ�R,X���+'	�g,�X�
VN(J�0YH�b$��P&��`��b�<IY8�KACD#)'*�pKACD#)'*�pKACD#)'*�pKACD#)'*�pKACD#=
�Tp���b"��J	,��QH���Z`��	A��Œ43�+q��A!�G�^`��4�p��Tp��0`�"G�b`��s�=���O�=���*?J<����<��=��O�Ϥ��@��8�Ϛ?q?��{��j4���z��8�H��A0h�#�1`�a�	�LP~\}I��H����=� ?`=��s�=���I��>8��O0������O�<����P��C�J��=��+>����X!8a��`�aED�	�"*#��<p'<�K��hD���Ȋ��hD�	�"*#��<p'<�`�B0����<I0C�hF0��G�&pb
ÆV�$�A�p�`J�$�!��4#L	X"
,�1c
4�h��M(8p�0Ōҁ�%4�����0J��҃�#X�M( 2SJ,�1c
4�,xGN8!�IA
����p�PApDŽp$�4�@��	8��
%,xGN8
4!��	��8 i�
�Mh����Mh&h�FHhCA0E�0p"@0�B	��,��s��8h#I�f�F8᠍'0p
�a ㆂ4���h
�`���s�	�P4�Y(���	�P4�Y(���	�P4�Y(���	�P4�Y(���	�P4R��I���N4h�R��I���N4h�R��I���N4h�R��I���N4h�R��I����<`�LX��Bp�LV	0eb�a	��a1X$���81�'
��`�V(���<`�LT���y0��8�

0p!&�g
@"F!��@,�@(H���<�hŜh�8��
���L,#4Y�h��
0`��0�f��JL���0�E�pF�)0�
i�$��L,#4h��b�<IY8�M+8�e"ňx��q@�Vq��E��%d�4���� !�J��iY�),@Cĕ��� �4@�2�r��'� �4@�2�r��'� �4@�2�r��'� �4@�2�r��'� �4@�3�	A!�G
0X��&<@%�(�cC4�p��Tp���a��PHaQŒ43I�	A!�G
0XC
$y�� 
�
��D�p!�i�D�0��։<rs�C��`��D�8�4��A0h�#�1`�a�	�LP,�0�L0a1�	���)!⟵��2i����&(Fp&0�ф�����
*'8x�N8yQ������8��EDb�4��H �D�2���Q������8��EDb�4�s��㇑hF0��G�&pb
ÆV�$�A�p�`J�$�!��4#L	X#ē81�a�	�+AAÅ��,`&�
)�F���P4@d��8Yb�i@�
��Pp�da�	�DJiA��,`&����I�8i( �8
c�8q�J X���pC����<#�'ᤠ����I�a��4
4Y�$
4!��	��8 i�
�Mh����Mh&h�FHhCA0E�q�AN`�4�0A�
i9����4��3@#p�F��8�0�q�AN`�4�#BaŠ�%8�χ>��!F(���O�%8��#�Ƅ(��.=
��|��c�$hGž��	�Eb�F&8HЅp�����p"L(4��"q�O����8��0��?Z?>�����K��-<��C�?���?g'?=s�<S�%}��g�'�G�������`D�F�%)�D�Pi9a	��a1X$���83�c�,���������P�|?[?,)=���������CO���r��q�Q��ǟz|i�У���J���>���S�ߏdQ��!8x�&+��#�a�q���	
�����|��<���>��O0q
��@��>p�����<����<�"<���8�

0p!&
1I��0XFh�N�%&`�aa��8#D��	��a��4��R`&�,ӂ4II��0XFh�e"ňx��q@�Vq��E��%d�4���� !�J��iY�),@Cĕ��ҳ�R,X���+'	h"Ah��e$�AN	h"Ah��e$�AN	h"Ah��e$�AN	h"Ah��e$�AN	h"Ah��g� �C
�`���L8x�J	*8Q�Ɔi0��
($0��F�Ç���£�,hf� �C
�`��$H�@L$��<�C��`��D�8�4��A0h�#�1
0h�F$H�A�8a��`�cF#8Lh�b�`�`�a�	�LP,�0�L0a1�	����	�&TNp���p�"�1A
Q9��q�Ȋ��hD�	�"*#��<p'<���PF�TNp���p�!�
ÆV�$�A�p�`J�$�!��4#L	X#ē81�a�	�+x�`� Ќ8a0%`�(8p�0Ōҁ�%4�����0J��҃�#X�M( 2SJ,�1c
4�h��M(8p�0ŌӀ��	8��
%,xG�g՟@	�gقi0���,<��J �����=���X}	Y����� ��p�PApDŽp$�0�B	��,у�
���O�
�`����??=��=�>Ty�1���(~2$�����?Z-?��O��f�Z~�	��8 i�
�Mq�
i9����4��8������y����'͗�8���-=��!<���@�JO`p
�a ㆂ4���i�F�(Å
*J0q1�F�(Å
*J0q1�F�(Å
*J0q1�F�(Å
*J0q1�F�(Å
��3�aA��
�$��3�aA��
�$��3�aA��
�$��3�aA��
�$��3�aA��'
��`�V(���<`�LX��Bp�LV	0eb�a	��a1X$���81�'
��`�$`�BL4
b�4�D�CɆ�,YƀP���y0��8�

0p!&�g
@"F!��@&)0�
i�$��L,#4Y�h��
0`��0�f��JL���0�E�pF�)0�
,�X�
VN(J�0YH�b$��P&��`��b�<IY8�M+8�e"ňx��q@�Vq��E��%d�-H!
<����#	�-H!
<����#	�-H!
<����#	�-H!
<����#	�-H!
<��PHaQŒ43I�	A!�G
0X��&<@%�(�cC4�p��Tp���a��PHaQŒ��D�p!�i�D�0`�"G�b`� �4H����4H#
$y�� 
�
��D�p!�0#8Lh�b�`�`�a�	�LP,�0�L0a1�	����	�&4a1@�B0pÁ0��Š��8�DTF(#@*'8x�N8yQ������8��EDb�4�s��㇑��
��8�D0A�p�`J�$�!��4#L	X#ē81�a�	�+x�`� Ќ8a0%`�L���&�F���P4@d��8Yb�i@�
��Pp�da�	�DJiA��,`&�
)�F���p�<#�'ᤠ����I�8i( �8
c�8q�J X���pC����<#�'	���L�f��4І�`&�4`�D�a��4
4Y�$
4!��	��8 i�
�Mq�
i9����4��3@#p�F��8�0�q�AN`�4�0A�
i9��ӄ�Q�
(T,�`�c��Q�
(T,�`�c��Q�
(T,�`�c��Q�
(T,�`�c��Q�
(
)Hg$ƒI�'4I)Hg$ƒI�'4I)Hg$ƒI�'4I)Hg$ƒI�'4I)Hg$ƒI�N0	��&�Q��!8x�&+�2�G0���0��`������b�I�+pcN0	��&*H���<�hŜh�8��
X���#�a�q�$`�BL4
b�4�D�CɆ�LR`&�,ӂ4II��0XFh�N��=�
0�d#4Y�h��
0`��0�f��JL���0�F�),@Cĕ��ҳ�R,X���+'	�g��4|��0{'�}q�8�M+8�e"ňx��q@�Vq��E��%d�-H!
<����#	�-H!
<����#�!(=3��ϲ}!I9PF�Z�B yI9PF�Z�B y���£�,hf� �C
�`���L8x�J	*8Q�Ɔi0��
($0��F�Ç���£�,!��<�C��`��D�8�4��A0h�#�1
0h�F$H�@L$��<�C`Fp&0����0��X!8a��`�cF#8Lh�b�`�`�a�	��<p'<���PF�TNp���p�"�1A
Q9��q�Ȋ��hD�	�"*#��<p'<�`�B0����<I0C�hF0��G�&pb
ÆV�$�A�p�`J�$�!��4#L	X"
,�1c
4�h��M(8p�0Ō҃���KIO�S�O@�H��4���2SJ,�1c
4�h��M(8p�0ŌӀ��	8��
%,xGN8#�S�>@qY��ߗ�}��Y�g�|��Z|����  X���pC����<#�'	���L�f��4І�`&�4�>J0�Ϧ*>l����&=S������'�a��4
4Y�$
4!��	��8᠍'0p
�a ㆂ4���h
�`���s��8h#I�f�F8᠍'0p
�p��
0�EJ���Lp��
0�EJ���Lp��
0�EJ���Lp��
0�EJ���Lp��
0�E@%)�D�Pi9@D�F�%)�D�Pi9@D�F�%)�D�Pi9@D�F�%)�D�Pi9@D�F�%)�D�Pi9a	��a1X$���81�'
��`�V(���<`�LX��Bp�LV	0eb�a	��a1X$�@�8��
X���#�a�q�$`�BL4
b�4�D�CɆ�,YƀP���y0�	�L���0�E�pF�)0�
i�$��L,#4Y�h��
0`��0�f��JL���0�F�),@Cĕ��ҳ�R,X���+'	�g,����<��>��I�iY�),@Cĕ��ҳ�R,X���+'	h"Ah��e$�AN	h"Ah��e$�AN	i�i
�=s��Iʂ0��D����Iʂ0��D����@@%�(�cC4�p��Tp���a��|X��<#�Ƌ�Ç���£�,hf� �C
�`��$H�@L$��<�C��`��D�8�4��A0h�#�1
0h�F$H�A�8a��`�cF#8Lh�b�`�`�a�	�LP,�0�L0a1�	����	�&TNp���p�"�1A
Q9��q�Ȋ��hD�	�"*#��<p'<���PF�TNp���p�!�
ÆV�$�A�p�`J�$�!��4#L	X#ē81�a�	�+x�`� Ќ8a0%`���/








!"12#3AB&6'7��


F,3���HG������
:"�*�33��Xg��֐�/1����tE�U"fgd7���ӭ!^c������D���o�1a�'�ZB8��7��P/	�T�����Tb�<ON��qy�o���^0�)tj
u1����U�qx'�R�TbM�e�F�S]��[��|��/F$��FQ�itj
u1����U�qx'�R�TbM�e�F�S]��[��|��/F$��FQ�itj
u1����U�qx'�R�u;�+2�"�T+�x��*B���*;+*�b�w,Ve�E��.W��_8T�{XTv.VU�=��X��(�
P\�a�p�
>��� �\��	�{�ܱY�Q��^��|�R}�aPAعYT�S�b�,�,5Ar����¤(��u'����[����|I�ќAiS���%�]I�de��t��+�j4gZT�c>	lFRq�l�����GĚ���;�ς[�ԜfF[(GAn~"���&�Fq�N�3���au'����[����|I�ќL����sz�
�l�Oa��q��WA�7m�{N�Z�>���5�#�w��{��7
�kڴ���l�w=.��w�!�y��߻iw�.����96��%nO�P�76ن�[���w
ED��N��T��-�a����z������7mN�������C����i�P~A�+W�����j���h�l��[
�h7M6������F����n��8UNe�i��H��y��:��;��G��?6����t�v��4���@�5��}�l�7~A�����6*m�ܸ����gk��[������7��Cr�;NǨ޹��O��Ț-~ٻ�m�`}��m��k9�I�m��jݫ���ͯ�VT��ǗQ��t{n۩��.��N�Kf��G�赻��{��J�������j�C��������E�?*V���Kx�6n!GY���
�Hn;Lڹ�|�_���'���?��v�-m���W��s�V�|�yV�EK[�k��?�6�6��P�(�8^��w�/�W���U������7^�/�m-����m�f��j��1�jS�������A��?ii��oLQ��o6�v������? ��}'ݷMF����h��㭧s��6�� ���J�/򦢫��w��e�.���n����ng�r��[���~��-Wj�7����n�O�������ۄ�<���~�j5)�C�h��*~D��~I�V�=��cUWI�P�e���v��t��/�.�]��&�l�� �8��y{A��cs�hN�p����u�cQ_��1_|��?�ɴ	���:U)鷝&�W�{<�S�F�ɶl�Oz�4��jx����I���|e�j�������?"}n�Ƶ~u�x�~Q�s
���;W����9
m�a�6�#�v>Cǩ�<cpNIC���k��Q�y�O�l���m�k㚝�MM��gi��֧��<�W�O�z��{(�n|Wp�ɹO��G�E}���U<sA��N7Kg��������ޣd�9����v�r�%�Q�r�MF���'
�5�����G���(�q~1_g�?�7=�uڨ���tܡ+�<7�^��켋�S�8��G�Q�������u\���N��s�;��;F������E�rͶ���k��"6z����2v�!ǶC� ,�E�(&�L�l����ˆ�\0u1�t��\oK�4F(&�L�l����ˆ�\0u1�t�X`�`.�ʆ�z{�!��hE�SS�KE�(&�L�l����ˆ�\0u1�t�X`�`.�ʆ�z{�!��h��
�צxƭ����BdV��������j�uhW��3�5l��>�"���e� ���LO#T�+�B�u�1�doy�P��D�,A�=�by��]Z�L�[#{Ϫ�ȭ"'Yb/i���6
�Я]zg�j��}T&Ei:���sM�
�t�OjT�xL�R94�HÏk!���sM�
�t�OjT�xL�R94�HÏk!���sM�
�t�OjT�xL�R94�HÏk!���sM�
�t�OjT�xL�R94�HÏk!���sM�
�t�OjT�xL�R94��r��_
�t"�=�*�JE���
�|���*\���@r���OD�����yB���$��J�(|���gB-S�*��^P�j����,-
��)|D(YЋT�J��y)�.�*}�K@D�r��_
�t"�=�*�JE�2�NZ�XI@�į鈊�:(��ʛ:A�2�NZ�XI@�į鈊�:(��ʛ:A�2�NZ�XI@�į鈊�:(��ʛ:A�2�NZ�XI@�į鈊�:(��ʛ:A�2�NZ�XI@�į鈊�:(�,�R��؅hǡ�'?B���������f�����+F=�9���/0��o�Le�4�}�!Z1�t	�Э��y�/s�c,Y�����
яC�N~�l=��1{��b�/m�V�zs�+a�^=� 
zm�zf��C�)ھP=fG7�{�
�<�쐱�n��7n�IN����29�#����0�d��^�w��u�Jv���Y����@|�)�{$,@�۸��ۨ�S�|�6z̎o��2�yL#�!b��Ǧn�D8����
��ds��cJ��&����,U�ĥ�*�%�М��E�(W_ě�f���VC�H�l�oBr�4�\!n01�z��YJY"��Y�	�$X҅p��I���l!�d1)d���f�'!��cJ��&����,U��W��e���&/����rA�J�B������t;t�k�[���e���'q�����=6�5��Zm.�Z��;�
�W*5;��B��)��������Cl��Wr��Zm�ju�44��z�:��y���$��T)���C����j�ki&�MU�[�
�-�7�Ԙ�+�ܴ۬�rA�[^�CuЩ��7��T�W��e���&/����rA�Hņx��i��߷�@�`'DXER&fvG3�����i��:<��kt{�6/��ۆ���=�ޓ�����o?�>�Ww�w��x�=�x�w������+�4z����O�6ݓ}޷=-=���Z=O456�C��F�����j�����w�+G{��qz{��k����1ݶ���MM�h�{�m���nU7��[���D��6M��p��O�r}7(�[�l���][m�������ƶ�o��^�ƹ �-����mt7W���7]�o���)����-T�����Tb�<ON��qy�o���^0�)tj
u1����U�qx'�R�TbM�e9>��˕6ǥ�[�޷]�hj�\c��:=~�B��U��?�v}v�ǵ�M�__g�x�mˎm{N���wF��+�i�4�n��-&�Y��x�ٶ�_
��4e*�V�I��7
"֮���C�����i6�v�h���mύ�N�w:[�T�;����h-�u�n���0���.��8�(�[_��J2�K[G�6
-j<�i�_A��t��_U�㜷Zu�{�q�6�u䟏�u��?K�5��˷���Γ�p}�U�޿����y6�Q��]�]Lav��o^	���C�N�̲�����+�
���k
���ʠ������ea���<W�!i�D�k
���ʠ������ea����FW�!G�����A1u;�+2�"�T+�x��*B���*;+*�b�w,Ve�E��.W��_8T�|.��22�B:s����53�-*w1��#�8̌�P����E#�MF��J��g�-���N3#-�#��?_���Q�8�ҧs�Kb0�����e�-��W�>$�h� ����|،.��22�B:s����53��XZ���c��F��OHH����1�BŦEak�繌n�mw�E=!"f�?��u�����1�=�a��􄉚�S�,ZdV�@.{����чtS�&hc�LgP�i�XZ���c��F��OHH��
���ؐ�H�U���H�
ӌ0*ׂk��&����V;�����AZq�Z�A�-x{#���6��bB�"uV"�="+N0��^<e�dx���UX�HZ�N��[ǤAi�k�����{��J��T��X�x� �8��y{A��cr`��(�`�
`_��}&S+) �ܽ� ��1�
�YjA0F��/�A>�)���a�^�fv�܅X,�
 �#@X� �I���H0�/b3;LnB�Z�L�,�O��ee${����7!V-B�&���"��
v�T6C��Q
��B.�:�ܺZ,0yA0jeCd==��\4"�)���˥���
v�T6C��Q
��B.�:�ܺZ,0yA0jeCd==��\4"�)���˥���
v�T6C��Q
��EuhW��3�5l��>�"���e� ���LO#T�+�B�u�1�doy�P��D�,A�=�by��]Z�L�[#{Ϫ�ȭ"'Yb/i���6
�Я]zg�j��}T&Ei:�A{Ox��F��WV�z��<cV����2+H��N�k�lT��{R�+�`6��ɠ|Hr@�{X��n�k�lT��{R�+�`6��ɠ|Hr@�{X��n�k�lT��{R�+�`6��ɠ|Hr@�{X��n�k�lT��{R�+�`6��ɠ|Hr@�{X��n�k�lT��{R�+�`6��ɠ|MK�>R��P����qV�R/(\5@T����R���"�,�E�z%\U����
P>�%��"T�C�/���:j��Wo%"��TO�Iah�.P�K� 9B΄Z��U�[�H��p�
S�XZ%K�>R��P����qV�R/)�%Jr�T��J��%LDT1�D��T��~i�%Jr�T��J��%LDT1�D��T��~i�%Jr�T��J��%LDT1�D��T��~i�%Jr�T��J��%LDT1�D��T��~i�%Jr�T��J��%LDT1�D�f�����+F=�9���/0��o�Le�4�}�!Z1�t	���y�/s�c,Y�����
яC�N~�l=��1{��b�/m�V�zs�+a�^a������h)x�lB�c����[r�쐱�n��7n�IN����29�#����0�d��^�w��u�Jv���Y����@|�)�{$,@�۸��ۨ�S�|�6z̎o��2�yL#�!b��Ǧn�D8����
��ds|G��#�a��6�=3v�!Ĕ�_(
��#��P���7̈́=Ab��%,�T�,ބ�?�,iB�B�$�`c6�����ESd�z��H��
���q���C�*�bR�M���NC�"Ɣ+�/�M�3aPX�!�K$U6K7�9�P���7̈́=Ab��b�6[,o��1|U��|c�
�W*���E*f+�Ce������[��9 ߥr�NNI��R�b�6[,o��1|U��|c�
�W*���E*f+�Ce������[��9 ߥr�NNI��R�b�6[,o��1|U��|c�
�F,3���HG������
:"�*�33��Xg��֐�/1����tE�U"fgd7����9�`�l�K�j�^c4��
n�o_��tE�U"fgd7���ӭ!^c������D���o�1a�'�ZB8��7��P/	��5����t*�8��)x�1&ފ2��K�P��.��B���>X—��m�(�4�5���[M�������U8�
�gM�iڸ�٩������վk���^���{�K�Q�6�Q��]�]Lav��o^	���U�oEG��Ѩ��k��V����,aK�=��X��(�
P\�a�p�
>��� �\��	�{�ܱY�Q��^��|�R}�aPAعYT�S��l:=�K��m�bz;V�v�f�/��^�t��hiiu{l�v퟉�|x���*;+*�b�w,Ve�E��.W��_8T�{XTv.VU�=��X��(�
P\�a�p�
>�]I�de��t��+�j4gZT�c>	lFRq�l�����GĚ���;�ς[�ԜfF[(GAn~"���&�Fq�N�3���au'����[����|I�ќAiS���%�]I�de��t��+�j4g"���
s��7G��;�����3C�c:��L����s��0��zBD�)��-2+\ =�ct{hÿ�)�	41��3�X�Ȭ-p�\�1�����觤$L���Ρb�"���
s��7G��;�����/x	Uc�!j�:�o��`U�2ׇ�<M�a*�v$-R'Ub-�� ���
����Z��G���l%U�ą�D�E�zDV�a�V�x�^��7�
���ؐ�H�U���H�
ӌ0*ׂk��&����V;�����AZq�Z�� �3���*�e�Q���q�L�VRA��{A��cr`��(�`�
`_��}&S+) �ܽ� ��1�
�YjA0F��/�A>�)���a�^�fv�܅X,�
 �#@X� �I���H0�/b3;LnB�Z�L�,�E�(&�L�l����ˆ�\0u1�t�X`�`.�ʆ�z{�!��hE�SS�KE�(&�L�l����ˆ�\0u1�t�X`�`.�ʆ�z{�!��hE�SS�KE�(&�L�l����ˆ��Я]zg�j��}T&Ei:�A{Ox��F����]�B����F��)j���[#{Ϫ���[��c������M&��������j�ui�����:��ղ7�ݷ����է�����e�oz
�IK�G���<�S`��
�צxͿ���޷z�{v��n��t
2;������������j�uhW��3�5l��>�"���d�f����H�p'�*R�&h)�ć$
aǵ�
��9m�4��c���Ы��z.A�rCǹ%}�p�E[��8�'�r-�AH��t��^����M��Ϥ��G��w#�?�P�[��<{]�9>����~�z�u���nU�o���z���仾�m�kiI�Ƒ弻�n���gh�����}�5|o�{���&޴z^h��~cP�u�Ui�=���쫧{Sf��^���*��M�X�r��*��p
���HÏk!���sM�
�t�OjT�xL�R94��r��_
�t"�=�*�JE���
�|���?'�m'
�7���m^��x�Gu�x��m;�%�W༧�m��.#����RJ��	���۞�h�m6�?���c�?!rn�~H�i���G�0���{�<+fJ����������[���E��SS������? ���[p�ߐ*����"������|G��jo����~�h�q�Ԇ��Z�7nN�Wwz�6�*�Z�9N	���yǸ�n?���J<s�6�9�6�K��8o�<s�iu�v��O�Iah�.P�K� 9B΄Z��U�[�H��@�)�]S�	(^x��1P�E�ySgH!��m�]�CGEKE�N=�]�p��.�Wiض�����6��j44��]�l�m鉸l[v�KG�v��]�A[v�6=&�ݶm����·y�4[���m{�`�n�[k�N�ƶ���6Źj4v�g�����o�iv��m��m�o�nΊ&�h7�/�6�q�٬�p=�W��������v�&��~�u�.���-==�m.���u*z�6�b���5N-��Ϧ�ѣK]���n�Gh��ݼ����� J�宩���
/<J����c��b�/m�V�zs�+a�^a������h)x�lB�c����[r�^����X�AK��b��@��
�{��b�7�&2Ś
^>���:��V�ܼ����1�,�R��؅hǡ�'?B����!b��Ǧn�D8����
��ds|G��#�a��6�=3v�!Ĕ�_(
��#��=̀�S�HX��q雷Q$�j�@l����d��G�B�/M��Lݺ�q%;W�g�����s >G��=� 
zm�zf��C�)ھP=fG?�4�\!n01�z��YJY"��Y�	�$X҅p��I���l!�d1)d���f�'!��cJ��&����,U�ĥ�*�%�М��E�(W_ě�f���VC�H�l�oBr�4�\!n01�z��Y�p(l�X�Rb��y���$��T)��7��T�W��e���&/����rA�J�B�����L�p(l�X�Rb��y���$��T)��7��T�W��e���&/����rA�J�B�����L�p(l�X�Rb��y���$�Xg��֐�/1����tE�U"fgd7���ӭ!^c������D���o�1a�'�ZB8��7��P/	�T�����Tb�<ON��qy�o���^0�,"�3;!��ņx��i��߷�@�`'DR���c��Ыx��O�0��ěz(�?�.�@.�0�_�
��/�c
^*�I���������c��Ыx��O�0��ěz(�?�.�@.�0�_�
��/�c
^*�I���������c��Ыx��O�0���w,Ve�E��.W��_8T�{XTv.VU�=��X��(�
P\�a�p�
>��� �\��	�{�ܱY�Q��^��|�R}�aPAعYT�S�b�,�,5Ar����¤(�� ��r��&!�r�fYDXj��{�HQ���N3#-�#��?_���Q�8�ҧs�Kb0�����e�-��W�>$�h� ����|،.��22�B:s����53�-*w1��#�8̌�P����E#�MF��J��g�-���N3#-�#��?_���Q�8�����1�=�a��􄉚�S�,ZdV�@.{����чtS�&hc�LgP�i�XZ���c��F��OHH����1�BŦEak�繌n�mw�E=!"f�?��u�����1�=�a���{��J��T��X�x� �8��x �=��ox	Uc�!j�:�o4۷&ݵ['���F�Lں{ց���_Eɴ[��\5[��CSS����.��V����
�^e���j��e-.��*SS@P�Ed��t�j
�COG�w�v���{�ش:��u5���A�):j)�Γz仦�a䉺m�-�M�u�}e#��r��O��W�i4���KYM�AZq�Z�A�-x{#���6��bB�"uV"�="+N0��^^�fv�܅X,�
 �#@X� �I���H0�/b3;LnB�Z�N?�n[��������K����N���;/#�F���&�j��{n�w�;��_j�e���ݳ�M���_��m.�G�'ߴU뾧��%���i�5�z�:k��v��FߡNc��C�^)�m�
�C������m�W�Z�.��lV���~�`��ug=z�G�U
E-W��ǺM>��r�:ۖ���T���q�L�VRA��{A��cr`��(�`�
`_��,0yA0jeCd==��\4"�)���˥���
v�T6Bhv�6�7=�wв��q����om�g�v�۟
ٷ���W���j���=�b�o�v�5����͍��m��uy���Z��d&��v��v��A�P۶�F�r��[֟C��=����6�A4�&�C���K�i�ɹ��O��[N�Wv��w ]��m�N�n�t�F�z�[f��nͥ����Q
��B.�:�ܺZ,0yA0jeCd==��\4WV�z��<cV����2+H��X��{���5M���+�^���F��U	�ZDN��^��&'��lա^���ղ7���L��"u� ����1<�S`��
�צxƭ����BdV��������j�uhW��3�5l��>�"���d�f����H�p'�*R�&h)�ć$
aǵ�
��f����H�p'�*R�&h)�ć$
aǵ�
��f����H�p'�*R�&h)�ć$
aǵ�
��f����H�p'�*R�&h)�ć$
aǵ�
��f����H�p'�*R�&h)��ԹC�/���:j��Wo%"��TO�Iah�.P�K� 9B΄Z��U�[�H��p�
S�XZ%K�>R��P����qV�R/(\5@T����R���"�,�E�z%\U����
P>�%��"T�C�/���:j��Wo%"�T�-uO�$�	y�W��ECOp	�M� ��T�-uO�$�	y�W��ECOp	�M� ��T�-uO�$�	y�W��ECOp	�M� ��T�-uO�$�	y�W��ECOp	�M� ��T�-uO�$�	y�W��ECKh)x�lB�c����[r�^����X�AK��b��@��
�{��b�7�&2Ś
^>���:��V�ܼ����1�,�R��؅hǡ�'?B���������f�����+F=�9���/��6�=3v�!Ĕ�_(
��#��=̀�S�HX��q雷Q$�j�@l����d��G�B�/M��Lݺ�q%;W�g�����s >G��=� 
zm�zf��C�)ھP=fG7�{�
�<�쐱�n��7n�IN����29�H��
���q���C�*�bR�M���NC�"Ɣ+�/�M�3aPX�!�K$U6K7�9�P���7̈́=Ab��%,�T�,ބ�?�,iB�B�$�`c6�����ESd�z��H��
���q���C�*�f+�Ce������[��9 ߥr�NNI��R�b�6[,o��1|U��|c�
�W*���E*f+�Ce������[��9 ߥr�NNI��R�b�6[,o��1|U��|c�
�W*���E*f+�Ce������[��9 ߤb�<ON��qy�o���^0�,"�3;!��ņx��i��߷�@�`'DXER&fvC}Q��=:���1�o��x�N����L�����zu�#��c~���aH���
�F,3���HG������
:"�F�S]��[��|��/F$��FQ�itj
u1����U�qx'�R�TbM�e�F�S]��[��|��/F$��FQ�itj
u1����U�qx'�R�TbM�e�F�S]��[��|��/�S�b�,�,5Ar����¤(�� ��r��&!�r�fYDXj��{�HQ���Ab�ePLC�N�̲�����+�
���k
���ʠ������ea���<W�!G�����A1u;�+2�"�T+�x��*B��Rq�l�����GĚ���;�ς[�ԜfF[(GAn~"���&�Fq�N�3���au'����[����|I�ќAiS���%�]I�de��t��+�j4gZT�c>	lFRq�l�����GĚ��Ȭ-p�\�1�����觤$L���Ρb�"���
s��7G��;�����3C�c:��L����s��0��zBD�)��-2+\ =�ct{hÿ�)�	41��3�X�Ȭ-p�\�1�����觤$K��UX�HZ�N��[ǤAi�k�����{��J��T��X�x� �8��x �=��ox	Uc�!j�:�o��`U�2ׇ�<M�a*�v$-R'Ub-�� ���
����Z��G���l%U�ą�D�E�zDV�a�V��� ��1�
�YjA0F��/�A>�)���a�^�fv�܅X,�
 �#@X� �I���H0�/b3;LnB�Z�L�,�O��ee${����7!V-B�&���'�e2��=�؂������Dh��a��	��S*!���
LLn]-<���2����o.p������a��	��S*!���
LLn]-<���2����o.p������a��	��S*!��ᢺ�+�^���F��U	�ZDN��^��&'��lա^���ղ7���L��"u� ����1<�S`��
�צxƭ����BdV��������j�uhW��3�5l��>�"���e� ���LO#T�+�B�u�1�doy�P��D�'K5�6*EӁ=�R��0AH��>$9 S=�Hh��K5�6*EӁ=�R��0AH��>$9 S=�Hh��K5�6*EӁ=�R��0AH��>$9 S=�Hh��K5�6*EӁ=�R��0AH��>$9 S=�Hh��K5�6*EӁ=�R��0AH��>&��)|D(YЋT�J��y)�.�*}�K@D�r��_
�t"�=�*�JE���
�|���*\���@r���OD�����yB���$��J�(|���gB-S�*��^P�j����,-
��)|D(YЋT�J��y)���9k�}a%K���"*�{�O*l�?4��9k�}a%K���"*�{�O*l�?4��9k�}a%K���"*�{�O*l�?4��9k�}a%K���"*�{�O*l�?4��9k�}a%K���"*�X�AK��b��@��
�{��b�7�&2Ś
^>���:��V�ܼ����1��5�R��؅i��h�w1�'?B���������f�����+F=�9���/0��o�Le�4�}�!Z1�t	�Э��x�HX��q雷Q$�j�@l����d��G�B�/M��Lݺ�q%;W�g�����s >G��r/oͷMVݵ�t��#��{�ᠫ���]�uڮ7Wt��Omm�}�t���`l����d��G�B�/M��Lݺ�q%;W�g�����s >G��=� 
zm�zf��C�)ھP=fG?�4�\!n01�z��YJY"��Y�	�$X҅p��I���l!�d1)d���f�'!�q�;��8v��=��ht�|cO��븆�[��p��n]/�����i���.�G��b�YJY"��Y�	�$X҅p��I���l!�d1)d���f�'!��cJ��&����,U��W��e���&/����rA�J�B�����L�p(l�X�Rb��y���$��T)��7��T�W��e���&/����rA�J�B�����L�p(l�X�Rb��y���$��T)��7��T�W��e���&/����rA�Hņx��i��߷�@�`'DXER&fvC}Q��=:���1�o��x�N����L�����zu�#��c~���aH���
�F,3���HG������
:"�*�33��Xg��֐�/1����tE.�@.�0�_�
��/�c
^*�I���������c��Ыx��O�0��ěz(�?�.�@.�0�_�
��/�c
^*�I���������c��Ыx��O�0��ěz(�?�.�@.�0�_�
��/�c
^!�r�fYDXj��{�HQ���Ab�ePLC�N�̲�����+�
���k
���ʠ������ea���<W�!G�����A1u;�+2�"�T+�x��*B���*;+*�b�w,Ve�E��.W��_8T�|.��22�B:s����53�-*w1��#�8̌�P����E#�MF��J��g�-���N3#-�#��?_���Q�8�ҧs�Kb0�����e�-��W�>$�h� ����|،.��22�B:s����53��XZ���c��F��OHH����1�BŦEak�繌n�mw�E=!"f�k"q�.�I^��M�,Z����k��_}��Ԧ�OGz�j��=zz�?�􄉚�nzm�c:��L����s��0��zBD�)��-2+\ =�ct{hÿ�)�	����V;�����AZq�Z�A�-x{#���6��bB�"uV"�="+N0��^	�O ��kw�c��z��{��o;�����s
[����j�p�9F�_��9'�5��7("��Ǎq���ghэW�\Tk���J{������U�w��/�z�^կ��������6��bB�"uV"�="+N0��^<e�dx���UX�HZ�N��[ǤAi�k�؂������Dh���2�YI��Agi��U��P�	�4�~�	��N�Cg�=���r�8~�q���}m�l�:=�r��І��:]�v==M�E�t-^�GK_��q]�`��=�_�l�SM�kv���˴V㏸���h������G�j��������{A��cr`��(�`�
`_��}&S+) �ܽ� ��1�
�YjA0F��/�A<���2����o.p������a��	��S*!���
LLn]-<���2����o.p������a��	��S*!���
LLn]-<���2����o.+�B�u�1�doy�P��D�,A�=�by��]Z�L�[#{Ϫ�ȭ"'Yb/i���6
�Я]zg�j��}T&Ei:�A{Ox��F��WV�z��<cV����2+H��X��{���5M���+�^���F��U	�ZDN�t�\�`¤]8ڕ)^
��M�C�0��Ć�{t�\�`¤]8ڕ)^
��M�C�0��Ć�{t�\�`¤]8ڕ)^
��M�C�0��Ć�{t�\�`¤]8ڕ)^
��M�C�0��Ć�{t�\�`¤]8ڕ)^
��M�j\���@r���OD�����yB���$��J�(|���gB-S�*��^P�j����,-
��)|D(YЋT�J��y)�.�*}�K@D�r��_
�t"�=�*�JE���
�|���*\���@r���OD�����yL�*S����P��+�b"���'��ΐC�L�*S����P��+�b"���'��ΐC�L�*S����P��+�b"���'��ΐC�L�*S����P��+�b"���'��ΐC�L�*S����P��+�b"���%�4�}�!Z1�t	�Э��y�/s�c,Y�����
яC�N~�l=��1{��b�/m�V�zs�+a�^a������h)x�lB�c����[r�^����X�AK��b��@��
�{��d��^�w��u�Jv���Y����@|�)�{$,@�۸��ۨ�S�|�6z̎o��2�yL#�!b��s�w���7]/��O�(�~���l���U�^�=fG7�{�
�<�쐱�n��7n�IN����29�#����0�d��^�w��u�Jv���Y���E�(W_ě�f���VC�H�l�oBr�4�\!n01�z��YJY"��Y�	�$XҜ�p�⧹�㢮���o��'�����ƾ�ƅ����ESd�z��H��
���q���C�*�bR�M���NC�"Ɣ+�/�M�3aPX�!��
����L_o8�~�ʅ99&�J���P�l��>���V��H7�\�S��o����
��7^
�o��Q���;����4�k�?f޵t驹 ߥr�NNI��R�b�6[,o��1|U��|c�
�W*���E*f+�Ce������[��9 ߤb�<ON��qy�o���^0�,"�3;!��ņx��i��߷�@�`'DXER&fvC}Q��=:���1�o��x�N����L�����zu�#��c~���aH���
�F,3���HG������
:"�F�S]��[��|��/F$��FQ�itj
u1����U�qx'�R�TbM�e�F�S]��[��|��/F$��FQ�itj
u1����U�qx'�R�TbM�e�F�S]��[��|��/�S�b�,�,5Ar����¤(�� ��r��&!�r�fYDXj��{�HQ���Ab�ePLC�N�̲�����+�
���k
���ʠ������ea���<W�!G�����A1u;�+2�"�T+�x��*B��Rq�l�����GĚ���;�ς[�ԜfF[(GAn~"���&�Fq�N�3���au'����[����|I�ќAiS���%�]I�de��t��+�j4gZT�c>	lFRq�l�����GĚ����
���


?
jg��
���


?
jg��P
	
!1AQ"aq����2 Rb���#B�$3r���%t��S��45C�Dcdsu������

?��6)�����*we�UZ���o�Mt/��YP��/DZ���M�k�}n�ʅ�z B�V��e[�lS]�uVT(�����E�*��b��_[���GvD^����
{�4t�醗aD^����
{�4t�醗aD^����
{�4t�醗aD^����
{�4t�醗aD^����
{�4t���ݓ*����ꨫ��	���ɕ
��t�uTU�����wdʆ�e�p��*����t�;�eCw��8]UtAb�A:{��2���n�'��|��S���'!8��s'��|��S���'!8��s'��|��S���'!8��s'��|��S���'!8��s'��|��S���'!P�P����j���ٙ"Dsa�(H��VKu��q�&���a�"6�3g�`�`")�����g�۠�8#�Ϛ�d��˗sE��H��K�2�@y���zm�K��d�FrrX~���m�H���h�M�f�������.I�oo<����*]��7���|a!ض�)����c0�1
�z���aq�n`�hrg�h���6]�Oއ����,�,�9��d3�5�
�<
�X���>�k6�i�_��|w�Nװ�;8�vvf�U�3x��m/���;>J9�cJ�b�(�
v?Y�ǐ&�����h3��Ax���&a�5V	�i�fǂ(��LMA�e?�K���L8�J�i
5����G�{[gA�K�����.�>�%Z��f�"�W��J�Gf�A6(y�1]H�P�8��]�,X|ٗ0�{$ܿ�W
�����S������)�Lq�DxE>Q�/���g�e�`��L
>�Ch��!� �>�5m����������q}�Ն�e��H��0G���kܾe�T6�Æ�~K�B����!�1���γ͂|����u�}��h����c�2���L���Ef�c�Gf&��"a���aE6d�*+Q
	q=�-�	�bY��O�M�<�	�e���÷��K�*+t���`�����3�����x��
�i�.5.;d��8�2�3�)fYr1F+�Q������"����t��2�1ح0Z!�<9���-�K�*e1��d�V�%�a�!��f�U��ĭ�����3bC�Ô-�(a�[ �C��&�
(�6�-s���'φM�8�a �
�|����X��N�L5�hX�[�̴�"�ȣ-�]��r�;e��3(���� �s
���L38���C2|�8zS�N�|H��f<� fI��V?���b�a�MI���ɕt��Cq�b�?������7��p�v���D�$����+6#��e�Rt� �6eP�(�b�5�	qL�i�s�Ň�fh_��6���PI�aid[e�@V)B�p�"�iQє�-��L�p�
?Rq�E�ĉ�/�E����a���&˙�.H��\:�ݧ��+O��_�[-&
�8�s��?���?%��p�\���㖹\$qy�y����/���
�����|Pp/����&Ak�<p=}q#>0I��#����Vj3Z����� ��vf�BV[m��l2���<"�.�F�����L�D��Bߢ�22����1
�.?���"\k�R�R��~�W�·����'V�Kz)��@$�9���6n��F��LQ�h�h�o�B�E3��
��1��.Z�H�-��n/�@�����)�N2���?��Qd��D�W$#(y��P����p����1�������A,5���z�
�W�A���r����	�Vi6_��ZdM���6�c�}H\NU���Vi�D�<���;���7}8�L�ij��Ŏc	��۸}�d�����pkv��6�yB<=�ah_L����PI�ah�+�GB��0[�$DF H�"��s/
�i�ս�Y&,pɒ-3ū�OU�[UB�������\K���_Z�gN"+DV�e���z��E����M�`�C
��,kN�W�2�W��kdx���,9,<�㓬r�Şwm*(Z(b�s\7�i��Hp���q^��48!���V37��2�".�L3D�t���G��gr͛�v���7�vqZf<Ƞ�0<!���p�D�!�6�j�K0��0���	�u��C�C�>�2�˯^��l|J�8&��ÈEˎ�WF���ܖ�<�M�#��
�x`~���?ԉ6_D��Y��D�$�V�,��gH�\&#��VN>d���Ō�r+;u\?��2X�Y�QC�'� ߈.h�̓.U�i0L$1@iO�W�L�ʙ,�:��	���Bv�Ah|2R��4M� �aÈ�YM�d�|�,&	�>��.���IӶ0G��%m�:i�ηm3�1?�ʏ�!f��(�8����:�j�*9��3
�I
��+E��ZdA4���Z�&YhacL�J�Z���+�Z�͎��GŸ-�]��44�3�yS�����
��&�\��,��1̓��	p�"�~L��J�c�̓*8g���13a�lwV�
�(`�7��R N]�_�4A�K�c��-_0�p{U���I2�B,qS�Dtd��ָ��>�d�̣F�œ��Y�2����6�����-���h�*�`��˴��1���<j�j�;�'���a�4j�w\;�����H2������~ �6����~a�w�L�6�u��a�e�2��t�Y�2Q��ℜ&�uV[���X�u��t�%6�j�\ɑ�3?�I
����ms%G2)�h2�x[#Q�q�L�b�o��K�$B����~jg�֋,gJ�J���pV[��p[����0���h�(��k��x��t�,fPR T�l�0,2&a���p�u��b�X��ʢ���.�>(��2���hz�=k�G*)v����,�f��A|u�l�F8�'�@P�̘d̀�:��	1Z�dp�ݼR��<�S,���s$vq���Y�ei��������$� S1ޭ�ɳ$�&0a��ND&'�;�BXֽ��=i�6Q�n��J�b�֟�+M��Z�A.�qM�����p�(�����D�$���M�;W
�"(���e�PC��k�Am�|E���o
�_/�U��.�� �S0F&�19m4x��١�6�t�P8N[w%a�v�\��%�ݞf�r
���ơ�(Yl���$�~|����6�3%C�wi0L%��
�?
�e��.\�'���pC@wS��{)�C�'p��ɶp�T�cm0G�|(��ٖ�3x��&t\��|Z>�_T���6�1W.��(xE�(Lf	��MCDb���>]�����V)�17
��h��͓g}^��[ �9L��7Z����:�5��ْ��<�	v@6TUz�El���2�0�j���\�,�`�+d��)�9��PuU�R�Ygu^��[ �9L��7Z����:�;���X<��5��eNa��U\z��e��s����:'�eC�49��j�*��]�u�&�_3#ZtO�ʇ�hrUrմUq�-��$MξfF��U�T��.��h���t[-�H��|̍i�>�*���]U�V�UǪ�[��7:��Ӣ}W.J�Xb�p�NJ٬p��U͑Y�S"Fary_U˒���"q�6k#�*UsdVkTȑ�\�W�r�E�,��x�M���
�\���2$f'��\�*Qa�=�'(Sf��;¥W6Ef�L����}W.J�Xb�p�NJ٬p��U͑Y�S!���;���F6^�OЧ�{���:]�6GuR�h���a���op�;�K�S���VM�{�1?B�W��Gx�w�t��Jɣ/u�'�S����h�.�N�#��Y4ce���
q^�2������-VEQֽ��z�Ӎoe�/�'���Z����{���[���^7�O�/H�YGZ�#�1�N5�� �o�$^�j�*���Gc�n�k{,Ax��<>H�"�dUk�uC�J��4Ɨ8���x5M��m�s�P�R���1����F�d�
SD*�l�@�\�T8T�xsLis��;�Y'�T�
��&�.�=�*��\�,N�jVI��4B��ɴ��uC�J��4Ɨ8���x5M��[ z�TY����VB��Un��_�d�\��5[��â�S7���\��l��Qf�sC�XtTa
f�U�k�~-��r�,�nhr+��!L�*�ms�Ųw�UE���Ea�Q�)��w*�����eK�t��b߭��UK�&�w*�����eK�t��b߭��UK�&�w*�����eK�t��b߭��UK�&�w*�����eK�t��b߭��UK�&�w*�����eK�t��bߪfe�]d���{�ӢnկtyO���e�E����bn�M��&��ɘ#�)u�'�5���=�g���϶j�l�;O����!��:�:,2�@c�,�ԛD��I���prZ���R,���0C���LBl���]A񺾉�������'C"]	x�A|6�v]�f��vw�V�f���3b�ͣa�f+�jm�tXdʄ�y�#5&|��ɛ�	l��:&�Z�_Wb?�����;;��'I��1e���ȂdN�ݤ����+G�M��tR&P�1��VL�|׺�:��<�Ӱ���#p�+v�t�]�gkg����;׹:<����&f\��L�|׺�:&�Z���b��_[���Gv^��U��5��@�i��-���L�Y'ps&�Ӣ�'�x�ʙ��,�6��}c�D�����\>&I���V��˖��V��ZE��"Wk	��H��+W��Vk_����b��Sb���u:Se�}����|F��x�_��\z�¬�R�R|����
9@�}!�j�,��$���ʄ��Я��l�����Ȓ�>@��
�g�v[ ��#�ϱEA����Z�Y�b����?�6x8����2e��P9.-m������.{<P�NZx+?�ȱ�xOc�M�b3O/���E�������	S������\6u���6�"pȓ`�?r�~-f������O�DpP����
 ��{o���_�[/��} �p�5������lQ`��CU辐I��ŗ�X�M�>P.>B��p	V{?���vyR�Jv rzb��5�H�G�K�X⋖=OuTɶ��V+6�����ؤCi����f�&�U�-d�Cd�M ��1K��"|��|�"d�P	��Z���|�5*g���ڥp��.�'�?⃊�U���-V���/({8�q�tW�[]�gk"g�a��v��{��+�I	�&�Y���V�.��Rc���,3s��6#�C��L8wո�I�>+�l8Ofͫg�G�8=�D��`ϟj$K��
UZ�o��g�2!?�^	��
�i��a�e�tن'���wo��Cm�g�g�c�Ζ~=�5N��Cj��p�$��,�&��7~Jl��٤E��J~b��y�d�����)(��1ˉ�%p����� B�V��e[�lS]�uVT(�ȋ�Q�v�/tƎ�p��0�ྏ	�O�����)x���i���l�%Y �J�Y�`�E/�E��sx��}�%��"j�p�m��8ԨDFoa�ˉރ��l�����]��|7����)������_�\C��2�8{)0֯V!|Gc��U���ˋ�v}���-��c��gL��SŞx~�{�Ҟ#h��&����%�Ec�,��_F�Ea6��R lQDe�0B�C+VO�ND�&�mi�8 �_��U���`�g�Z(�awS$�\�LxШxe��Z���?,�U�x��Ƌ���6e����g�y��g�J+-�p�Lq�a��1�屢^'�N�i�K�3�QG�����|C�p��2a�����뾾+��<�e�I����[D������?�����p�8�Wg�q�3�[mY�Bt�qY��Y��M*��qM�96�%&.��+�fGy_F�Ea6��2 �l1De�&qw��l�D8���M�#6�c�	u��YM���*U�M��"�"X@��V�2"�̕2��&�����!4qHl����pC�b�,�ٗ��a�Ίd�M�΀@^Xԑ�.�I�h��H�_!ܞ���eX'��\?���q�SfS-��:�f���r�A��"�,肰Y�fY�C����,��K69Q�&o�vs-mX꾑�3�L��RtP٢��id�P��u��pno��	�ڦO\���=W�n�����0Gb��6X���)vG�����>S%�a˳+O�Y#�J6qe�&w���b#J��L��̓)sa��$Z/�6��Dv�%:91L��a0��٨$O�9�
���p��#�5k�[��9e�*\6c*Wj%0�
ߪ��f��%���P��6�jw���ʴJ�L��<!�G�"L4�#
"�G�ݸ�1��� �=��P��NUE]X�N��vL�n�[���
Q�2g�몢��,^'Os�&T*dPA1�����^�t�uTU�����wdʆ�e�p��*����t�;�eCw��8O������	��NBq_�2�O������	��NBq_�2�O������	��NBq_�2�O������	��NBq_�2�O������	��NB���{-ng�Y�].�Ь�
���XtT5T�e����;�����!��_+����쵹��gut��B�d6���a�P�P���3��whVL��U|�:*�W���U�����
�e�D���_u�T.�VM���:����'e�D���_u�T.�VM���:����'e�D���_u�T.�VM���:����'e�D���_u�T.�VM���:����'e�D���_u�T.�VM���:��j��1�5W�����3�l�6wV�T�f�=�U~�,k^��;&͓gun��Ovj��1�5W�����3�l�6wV�T�f�=�U~�,k^��;&͓gun��Ovj��1�5W�����3�l�6w�U�y�ks�ʜ�u�:��s�����U�ȭ�[��T��A�WuK�e��Uz�El���2�0�j���\�,�`�+d��)�9��PuU�R�Ygu^��[ �9L��7Z����U�l�Y"nu�25�D���z��!uW-[EW���n�D���dkN��YP�MB�Z���=WE��d�����֝겡���\�m\z��e��s����:'�eC�49��j�*��]�u�&�_3#ZtO���R�Y�8�B�5��*��+5�dH�.O+�rT��{�N<P��c�w�J�l��j�3����\�(�Ş��)�X��R��"�Z�D���򾫗%J,1g�D��
l�8GxT��Ȭ֩�#0�<����R�Y�8�B�5��*��+5�d:]�6GuR�h���a���op�;�K�S���VM�{�1?B�W��Gx�w�t��Jɣ/u�'�S����h�.�N�#��Y4ce���
q^��M��)�dwU+&�l����N+��X��x|�zE�Ȫ:׹!�U�q���D��"�U�Tu�r8C�t�[�b�����E��"��^�p�=V�Ʒ�������-VEQֽ��z�Ӎoe�/�'���Z����{��p�T����
bv#R�O��]6M�].{�*U<9�4��X��Ԭ���h�WM�hK��
�Oi�.p'b5+$�j�!U�d��纡¥SÚcK��؍J�<��Ut�6�t��p�T����
bv#R�O��_�d�\��5[��â�S7���\��l��Qf�sC�XtTa
f�U�k�~-��r�,�nhr+��!L�*�ms�Ųw�UE���Ea�Q�)��V��u��@�ʨ�U��Ȭ:*0�3x��_4٢�]�p.��,[������D�.�_4٢�]�p.��,[������D�.�_4٢�]�p.��,[������D�.�_4٢�]�p.��,[������D�.�_4٢�]�p.��,[�L̹K��>��u�tMڵ�)򺾉��)u�'�5�N��V���>WW�32�.�d���i�7j׺<����&f\��L�|׺�:&�Z�G��]_D�˔�ɓ��Y�Dݫ][�lS]�uVT(�����E�*��b��_[���Gv^��U�,V�3�H�h��	K�C�#v��Sl�ɵX�R����+xwMu��Cb}���"#���.#���-�,�3���ު�*we�UZ���o�Mt/��YP��/DZ���M�k�}n�ʅ�{�#������N;�\�{�#������N;�\�w�L��t\RH�nXDŵRe[�p�ke�DPChvqK�l&F;�+����L�E��M-�����a��*'�O��A�>(��l��<�R(�(�u�_K��b�f�mָ�a��P���K���m�;|�G�|R>(Y��7����Z,����$c����"����a��Q��?~��^���a��Q��?~��^����wdʆ�e�p��*����t�;�eCw��8]UtAb�A:�E�Oo*�qk�ޢ�a��"a
����/�[�r�[�7�fi'��M)<Bm�풌1C4E%�Yf��h$��tq�>G�(�w��a�c�m�L"	r�~PP棎�c�L��b���NUE]X�N��vL�n�[�����,^'Os�&T7{-ӄ�]��٪p��d�'�.d�]��٪p��d�'�.d�]��٪p��d�'�.d�]��٪p��d�'�.d�]��٪p��d�*�W���U�����
ɐ�ꯕ�ECU@
�Z��곺�]ݡY2]U��j�
^�[��VwWK��+&Ck��V
U+�ks?����wv�d�muW�â���{-ng�Y�].���vX�O5�[UB�d�M}�����vX�O5�[UB�d�M}�����vX�O5�[UB�d�M}�����vX�O5�[UB�d�M}�����vX�O5�[UB�d�M}��f�=�U~�,k^��;&͓gun��Ovj��1�5W�����3�l�6wV�T�f�=�U~�,k^��;&͓gun��Ovj��1�5W�����3�l�6wV�T�f�=�U~�,k^��;&͓g}^��[ �9L��7Z����:�;���X<��5��eNa��UwT��Y�EW���V�
��S*s
֠꫺�β��*�V"�@
nr�S�n�U]�.u�wQU�y�ks�ʜ�u�:���]�u�&�_3#ZtO�ʇ�hrUrմS-��̛<
�613�E�q1�*`�B�l��d����[��7:��c�[%��99���	v~#,�4�L@�y�'�T߉���a�����)��]U�V�UǪ��e�l��e4��s�[-�H����8Y��;�)s�LK���Ӣ}T6�!7��Gf"�b�zw!.W��ˎR0���W-[EW���n�B�d��������)Q[��&RS�.�d��H��cb�dW��H��ş�$AC�'YP�MB�Z���=WE��d�����֝�rT��{�N<P��c�w�J�l��j�3����"��HU�M��e��fY�AD���kʄ̎d�T�ܩ��%����O���[aJ����œ�Y(e����V���R�[,�{9��c��e��P�h�9Q�qF{ߧ�\���\z��gv6xc���^!Ef�Y��
��q�p�ҥ�E���ځ����k,���̲��_��C�m�T��,'��0�Ւ9e���>�Z,F.C��j�˕2dsĢ'�Ca��6R�
e���!Ȣ6�P�4���o�q�h��;5�(,��e��
�`!S�7�.�o����6����%����b��ζ�OF�*(���L��Ň�<f(b9��ʕV>x$�噳�?�?�N���h����;i�<����r�F��Ų�k�J�*8c����;�b�l�LQ���a�����K��2�Z#���:h��F�"-�HOig��
;h�q�r�\ƀJ���G�"�-�R���Ņ�Վ}�%�'K�{ �>^��x�M���!�ḉ�5���P�V����.���}X�#��)�?ԉf����<.�a���`�Ŀ���O6W�c��"Fary_U˒���"q�6k#�*UsdVkT�t��:l��dэ����)�z��4w������?	"M�e�\B�.X�!
Ru\[��I���.d�cR���]��|R�l�P̲H�vb�+M�W�[-�K��L�c,Y�����G$+�ٌP���|��H�Lfi�E�z׸2�t��N�r�.,@���'�W�V�Ĉ����t�d&���E�|�'�]�U�?�b�&��/���c���['`�jjˆ���Ya����g�3gh���6��Vo�������?�\_�qi��C�ۥO/&�h��cvj��H�}km�q	00ڭ�p�l�̭��&��q���,�91j�q5�p��b�ًL,�_��O���q����lB�
�am��L:�R�q?��,1|!��Ŧz�~e.�mR��1�&1�!�K���p��5|6�*��%LvhD��iEn��[��!�?��b�@V�|� �Ȇ	�[
�1u�ك���{0u��`��Fc(,\F;LG����������`����}E�d�,�im9�a����l��pF�.�M��qk�m���=Y} ��/��Α5�� ��^*�2db\��qv�j�\F\�-���S%Ŋ���_b���m=����v�-�⭼"�%Bm���	$�o�+�ʣ��i��
�)"1��x��4w��x�M��T��1��Xb~�8�[�b�����E��"��^�p�=V�Ʒ̱Z���y��Dd_N�*M�e@ ���E�!����f��|��k�K�8�&{�54q͇8�ΪO�Qi�_1����SdG93`2㗕
��e��I����}VE-�X-0����t]���	q��o5'���	0`�a�*C]2�b�s�R{i�H�I1b#	�Ӹ.��&D�_Z�W������*��}J��o��ʆ<bF�w�QI��{	1E�È�\�X��Isc��0���c�"aLu17y�Qϟ���lGQCP��(Y� � ,
��<�{ICG/��B�e���%J

I��9��ŎYL'��<R)&+t�pA3���jV��Y��~�\1��Lq
�n�V�e�Og:�Y�EOs�3�p�}���L#�PI�2�CH`�0
w�g�gC�d�F�i��O�F+d��L�i�⍂D�r�ɰv�G�Azz)Vya�ʄA����$v2"��0�&�=�l�����#�'�E�����x"���M"w�z�/��e��eŊBdCW��桗(a�!���n�$�k�w��<��'*F|�;9�qVi��n�k{,Ax��<>H�"�dUk�uC�J��4Ɨ8���x5M��m�s�P�R���1����F�d�
SD*�l�@�\�T8T�xsLis��;�Y'�T�
��&�.�=�*��\�,N�jVI��4B��ɴ��uC�J��4Ɨ8���x5M��[ z�TY����VB��Un��_�d�\��5[��â�S7���\��l��Qf�sC�XtTa
f�U�k�~-��r�,�nhr+��!L�*�ms�Ųw�UE���Ea�Q�)��w*�����eK�t��b߭��UK�&�w*�����eK�t��b߭��UK�&�w*�����eK�t��b߭��UK�&�w*�����eK�t��b߭��UK�&�w*�����eK�t��bߪfe�]d���{�ӢnկtyO���L̹K��>��u�tMڵ�)򺾉��)u�'�5�N��V���>WW�32�.�d���i�7j׺<����&f\��L�|׺�:&�Z���b��_[���Gv^��U�,V���B��U�
;��@���Q`ʷ�ئ��ꬨQݗ�-Uj�U���5о�UeB��!j�TX2��6)�����*wdE�(�߻p�cGA8@�ipFE�(�߻p�cGA8@�ipFE�(�߻p�cGA8@�ipFE�(�߻p�cGA8@�ipFE�(�߻p�cGA8A:{��2���n�.��� �x �=��P��NUE]X�N��vL�n�[�����,^'Os�&T7{-Ӆ�QWD/��ݓ*����}.����8L2r����2}.����8L2r����2}.����8L2r����2}.����8L2r����2}.����8L2r
U+�ks?����wv�d�muW�â���{-ng�Y�].�Ь�
���XtT5T�e����;�����!��_+����쵹��gut��B�d6���a�P�P���3��whn;,Z'�LO�����tڲl&����w�;,Z'�LO�����u��_�,���P'v�3���Sm6�a�G"lV{Gi,��_��˴ʎ�b�`�r����ݗh1�.f�p�f�|Gn���6[L�@�2�BM��g����"t�rd
���>k�.A�������-3eȕ��F!Y$�a�â��A��g~�%M�Y���Êl �(�ϝ�#9�dž�˙n������=�hΙ22�f�+w�c��C0�B�j�ʳB�lb�+�e|/�9�0�>3 K���R��c����بfK��6��a�ɕ�qeU'⬼6e�(����F#�jkB�.>l��?m��� D�ݑ�UA2Tp̂1��.:���H�%𿇲��Y�����)��\0XfH���8�a�uQ-�M�
�����a�������!�N�u]�m�`�;,|�rv�1PZm�Y�����ڭ���lb��<�-��K��mY6_D����읖-��'�}��P�mY6_D��Y��D�$�_�hK�׿4�ɳd��[�=Sݚ��LrMU����9�{�\|ظ�ղ>��	�,����q�eĬ��s�ɓfh�3!rW��٠�k�Nh��E�DşU�'��2"��K������d�':\�qA0M�"�pA�Į/�K�Gm"o�ʐ-�H�V��
�mv��G��b#�|1>]<�Z'٧E�,f(%Bc��w�S�VK4�vX����>0Ůk�Y���1d�92������Ek�a�%�.^PE�
�V�!g�\
E�dq��~#7:�!ȌqD.v�~�m�,��FTɬ1�oj��Fi=��A�l�y�<����ˈ��b	���_&w�a?9n��xu�L��.+,1ϳ��T3�R�d�V�,҅�12��!�?���n!0ˎ!���Z1�K�H�s���p����	���
��"t38f,3e�����Ք)QI�d�C"
��ö����Ə����e43Ҹ��U�W���N���3�E�y.*t�f�t��̕��C��`�)}��������L�T}�e��D�#ڻz��D�'J8�\�"��-��d���'ʑ��x�1@��Ĭ_
+��l�A��,R�1���3�l�6wV�T�f�=�U~�,k^��;&͓g}^��[ �9L��7Z����:�;���X<��5�y�+����>g1/̩�;d���1�A��/�rf�Wjxd�����䬢�d�8l��.L9C!�a�FlHl�G�D��Wok�A2q�8I��,��
�v)���H�i��@�Y-��Y[8�v/�r�U��
�K��#�(gج�ț��$��������,OV}�侦6o�~�����f�]��`&	X��:�q/�dAf��d��������~��A<��NDC�#"�f��,�8s=�K�X��@�F"Z��z�-�!�-�[#���K��1F�ĕ/㬐�2�X�'�)6�20ΕgHb�i(e
S��+����O��K�s(I�Y�K�:x�4�%�3l�#. bq�1}麂!e�����
�[$2&�+��O����\�[$��D����_^�V�$��7 ��aa��g��8u�)�eNa��UwT��Y�EW���V�
��S*s
֠���t[-�H��|̍i�>�*���]U�V�UǪ�[��7:��Ӣ}VT=SC��������U�l�Y"nu�25�D���z��!uW-[EW���n�D���dkN��YP�MB�Z���=WE��d�����֝�rT��{�N<P��c�w�J�l��j�3����\�(�Ş��)�X��R��"�Z�D���򾫗%J,1g�D��
l�8GxT��Ȭ֩�#0�<����R�Y�8�B�5��*��+5�dH�.O+�rT��{�N<P��c�w�J�l��j��x�M��T��1��Xb~�8�[�&�����;���F6^�OЧ�{���:]�6GuR�h���a���op�;�K�S���VM�{�1?B�W��Gx�w�t��Jɣ/u�'�S���� �o�$^�j�*���Gc�n�k{,Ax��<>H�"�dUk܎Ǫ�8��X��x|�zE�Ȫ:׹!�U�q���D��"�U�Tu�r8C�t�[�b�����E��"��^�*U<9�4��X��Ԭ���h�WM�hK��
�Oi�.p'b5+$�j�!U�d��纡¥SÚcK��؍J�<��Ut�6�t��p�T����
bv#R�O��]6M�].{�*U<9�4��X��Ԭ���h�W��;�*��V�"�����v�:�[ z�TY����VB��Un��_�d�\��5[��â�S7���\��l��Qf�sC�XtTa
f�U�k�~-��r�,�nhr+��!L�+�W�6h��{*\�>�n?���_�6K�W�6h��{*\�>�n?���_�6K�W�6h��{*\�>�n?���_�6K�W�6h��{*\�>�n?���_�6K�W�6h��{*\�>�S3.R�&O�k�f�v�{��|���fe�]d���{�ӢnկtyO���L̹K��>��u�tMڵ�)򺾉��)u�'�5�N��V���>WW�32�.�d���i�7j�V���B��U�
;��@���Q`ʷ�ئ��ꬨQݗ�-Uj�U���5о�UeB��!j�TX2��6)�����*we�UZ���o�Mt/��YP��"/qD~�ۀ��:	�t�K�0�/qD~�ۀ��:	�t�K�0�/qD~�ۀ��:	�t�K�0�/qD~�ۀ��:	�t�K�0�/qD~�ۀ��:	�	���ɕ
��t�uTU�����wdʆ�e�p��*����t�;�eCw��8]UtAb�A:{��2���n�.��� �x �=��P��N�v�f��c����W����v�f��c����W����v�f��c����W����v�f��c����W����v�f��c����j�
^�[��VwWK��+&Ck��V
U+�ks?����wv�d�muW�â���{-ng�Y�].�Ь�
���XtT5T�e����;�����!��_+����쵹��gut��Cq�b�?�b|��mU�Փa5�N�k����b�?�b|��mU�Փa5�N�k����b�?�b|��mU�Փa5�N�k����b�?�b|��mU�Փa5�N�k����b�?�b|��mU�Փa5�N�e���LrMU����9�{�L�6M�ջC�=٪�D�$�_�hK�׿4�ɳd��[�=Sݚ��LrMU����9�{�L�6M�ջC�=٪�D�$�_�hK�׿4�ɳd��[�=Sݚ��LrMU����9�{�L�6M��Uz�El���2�0�j���\�,�`�+d��)�9��PuU�R�Ygu^��[ �9L��7Z����:�;���X<��5��eNa��UwT��Y�EW���V�
��S*s
֠���t[-�H��|̍i�>�*���]U�V�UǪ�[��7:��Ӣ}VT=SC��������U�l�Y"nu�25�D���z��!uW-[EW���n�D���dkN��YP�MB�Z���=WE��d�����֝�rT��{�N<P��c�w�J�l��j�3����\�(�Ş��)�X��R��"�Z�D���򾫗%J,1g�D��
l�8GxT��Ȭ֩�#0�<����R�Y�8�B�5��*��+5�dH�.O+�rT��{�N<P��c�w�J�l��j��x�M��T��1��Xb~�8�[�&�����;���F6^�OЧ�{���:]�6GuR�h���a���op�;�K�S���VM�{�1?B�W��Gx�w�t��Jɣ/u�'�S���� �o�$^�j�*���Gc�n�k{,Ax��<>H�"�dUk܎Ǫ�8��X��x|�zE�Ȫ:׹!�U�q���D��"�U�Tu�r8C�t�[�b�����E��"��^�*U<9�4��X��Ԭ���h�WM�hK��
�Oi�.p'b5+$�j�!U�d���V[$ɘ-6�]�y��5U*��.!`���g��)�2p'b5+$�j�!U�d��纡¥SÚcK��؍J�<��Ut�6�t��p�T����
bv#R�O��_�d�\��5[��â�S7���\��l��Qf�sC�XtTa
f�U�k�}��W�aY���vmv�,�y���p���{_�l��f�"�?���ٗ�{h�6��m����NZ���pk�M�K��a�͎��%�]}3���]�@�C�r�	�=��/�[fA����4��5������{ɍ�#/�;�f��1c� ŻDG��S7���\��l��Qf�sC�XtTa
f�U�k�~-��r�,�nhr+��!L�+�W�6h��{*\�>�n?���_�6K�W�6h��{*\�>�n?���_�6J�6;U��6ˋ��e��.fz�+U��l�q)S�����ma�3R�q�-v�ҿ�����>�Ŭ�̚e�	�fM$�`h��+��ța�%I�ȏ�,ٮ!0̝.�΂tn��|ܻ�"3>�k�&,R�։إ�t`���f3:�����yF����g�dre8eMI>鏂ſ[��<��M��U�M�-��ʗ鏂ſ[��<��M��U�M�-��ʗ鏂ſT�˔�ɓ��Y�Dݫ^��+�虙r�Y2}�^�4蛵k�S�u}3.R�&O�k�f�v�{��|���fe�]d���{�ӢnկtyO���L̹K��>��u�tMڵտ��5о�UeB��!j�TX2��6)�����*we�UZ���o�Mt/��YP��/DZ���M�k�}n�ʅ�z B�V��e[�lS]�uVT(�ȋ�Q�v�/tƎ�p��0���(��Q�v�/tƎ�p��0���(��Q�v�/tƎ�p��0���(��Q�v�/tƎ�p��0���(��Q�v�/tƎ�p�t�;�eCw��8]UtAb�A:{��2���n�.��� �x �=��P��NUE]X�N��vL�n�[�����,^'Os�&T7{-ӄ�]��٪p��d�'�.d�]��٪p��d�'�.d�]��٪p��d�'�.d�]��٪p��d�'�.d�]��٪p��d�*�W���U�����
ɐ�ꯕ�ECU@
�Z��곺�]ݡY2�f��0͓��fP���I�H����5�9*���E�X>'��'r�Ň��P���|=���׷���/����ǂL�LqE�B3G�K��P�f��t�E&�&,rg@#�-��WK��+&Vo���Z'C"_)/�S+��V
U+�ks?����wv�d�muW�â���{-ng�Y�].���vX�O5�[UB�d�M}�����vX�O5�[UB�d�M}���=�Wտ���_�b�O��K���[e��#��<։̿�:j��P�x�2,�̉P�y\��#��p�h�k��-6���̗�N�T��q.�
�v��G�4s%���a�:ꅶ\Ϥq[��=���!��ec��]��˝�`�O�(�0�u`r9SeCh�h�e�Fn	�	�1����X���;l�|�3���<}�d��B��O�;�p��ݣ����}�v[I�}ag���C�Xw�<B��,v�s)k�r�!��z�ĭv��J�s3�&������C���Z!�pchF(� ������"�ƻy2���2�@M^=���%k�Zgʝ6�����0���CԮ���8Ţ@�g̝e��c�i�a���2-�ISx���"z���y�b�?�b|��mU�Փa5�N�k����b�?�b|��mU�Փa5�N�e���LrMU����9�{�L�6M�ջC�=٪�D�$�_�hK�׿4�ɳd��Ul좙�Z#�ǏH�ͺQq!.(�m��@O(�2��.�l�֙��Ga����B��Q�M�Ť�&p���x#l�u�}�9��h�hܾ�"$�8��A��Y�&~JU��� ��'�����}b{H��7™e��ʼnA2M��.L��l6?����8�0ʴK�Tx3b�����M�\K�c�cEYxt�3�D���d,�Gj�-�Y�ol��(F�_��u�X�� I%��<:��������k8w&
�V��Zd̘���`��V~c�v#�%���!��wn�YdδZ�γ?gn3��/�#i��m�y�;d�ч�f�=�U~�,k^��;&͓gun��Ovj��1�5W�����3�l�6w�U�y�ks�ʜ�u�:��s�����U�ȭ�[��T��A�WuK�e��Uz�El���2�0�j���\�,�`�+d��)�9��PuU�R�Ygu^��[ �9L��7Z����U�l�Y"nu�25�D���z��!uW-[EW���n�D���dkN��YP�MB�Z���=WE��d�����֝겡���\�m\z��e��s����:'�eC�49��j�*��]�u�&�_3#ZtO���R�Y�8�B�5��*��+5�dH�.O+�rT��{�N<P��c�w�J�l��j�3����\�(�Ş��)�X��R��"�Z�D���򾫗%J,1g�D��
l�8GxT��Ȭ֩�#0�<����R�Y�8�B�5��*��+5�d:]�6GuR�h���a���op�;�K�S���VM�{�1?B�W��Gx�w�t��Jɣ/u�'�S����h�.�N�#��Y4ce���
q^��M��)�dwU+&�l����N+��X��x|�zE�Ȫ:׹!�U�q���D��"�U�Tu�r8C�t�[�b�����E��"��^�p�=V�Ʒ�������-VEQֽ��z�Ӎoe�/�'���Z����{��p�T����
bv#R�O��]6M�].{�*U<9�4��X��Ԭ���h�WM�hK��
�Oi�.p'b5+$�j�!U�d��纡¥SÚcK��؍J�<��Ut�6�t��p�T����
bv#R�O��_�d�\��5[��â�S7���\��l��Qf�sC�XtTa
f�U�k�~-��r�<8˵G:d�r1�/����*Oo�M�:,2�H���r�A
��*�f���d�'�:C���fp�)f��g
�Y��C��
��>9=�X䉍&�q�G��(G���B���S7���\��l��Qf�sC�XtTa
f�U�k�~-��r�,�nhr+��!L�+�W�6h��{*\�>�n?���_�6K�W�6h��{*\�>�n?���_�6K�W�6k�������."Db�o�6>���'����em�[������L0b�0�+T[�O
����?��w���ᶙa$�0�*b��\>�i/>d$ELؐ�,��,[������D�.�_4٢�]�p.��,[������D�.�_4٢�]�p.��,[�L̹K��>��u�tMڵ�)򺾉��)u�'�5�N��V���>WW�32�.�e2�k�v։�<}�c ���جp�b�I��8j�9�f�F?�2O��N�+�D}�ӈ�Qx�k��`�h�<D?{�%ʀK��!�0
j׺<����&f\��L�|׺�:&�Z�G��]_D�˔�ɓ��Y�Dݫ][�lS]�uVT(�����E�*��b��_[���Gv^��U�,V���B��U�
;��@���Q`ʷ�ئ��ꬨQݗ�-Uj�U���5о�UeB�숽���n�Lh�'�
.ˆ����n�Lh�'�
.ˆ����n�Lh�'�
.ˆ����n�Lh�'�
.ˆ����n�Lh�''Os�&T7{-Ӆ�QWD/��ݓ*����ꨫ��	���ɕ
��t�uTU�����wdʆ�e�p��*����t�;�eCw��8O������	��NBq_�2�O������	��NBq_�2�O������	��NBq_�2�O������	��NBq_�2�O������	��NB��%






!1AQaq�����������


?!�+{�r_�7�o�~a`.ۇ4�%A^r�W0
JJN)�C�/��<����ԯ�m:?�P뻖�����S��`�![�Ò����~��
v�81��*
󗺹�PrRRqMb���a����P�i��J��]ܵ�<\�Ҝœ�)
������[�ߘX����4�PW���������k���c'�`�u+���N��T:��i�����,��HV�p��ob߾���]�i�J����`���SX��_�;y?sC�_�,�t��!�w-sO/��1d�=JB���%�#{�����pcM"T�/us�䤤��=�������*J���gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����* ;M���j�<���پƦ�gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����* ;M���j�<���پƦ�gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����* ;M���j�<���پƦ�gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����* ;M���j�<���پƦ�gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����*p�)���sV��K�W���轧"����a?����\2�H�
�M��"����0�,�uPk̠
����(7PS=~�/���w���{NE9C�(�SIp�e�����E��3�anY���י@����Pn��z��Z_A.9^������r��Q���&��p��"!�*6���f;H�ܳ��A�2�7�/�3���AL,������\r���'E�9�ܣ	�LM%���DC�T
l?1��v���g+�"�^eo_�g
A���Y��5i}��{��N��r)��F���K��/Ĉ���~`?�jY��t�(�쮗�)�=]�r�\�aRv5wA�}Q���![
�>Ȩ%\��6�g�V�c�@�Գ�#F��Qy�]/�S^z���x�t���j�����)i5LB��N}�PJ<8�=W�*m��*�L2�$����g<F�Ӭ��_Ԧ��w9��r�	I���	=��DR�j��l7���"��xqpz��T�=��UZ�e�I
�#R�x��YE�et��My��s��������{�ꈥ��1
�o%9�EA(����_��{?���0���F���7N�����R�����+�˦%'cWp$���KI�b��Js웭�J�oQo���S��͝���œ���N�2�+����.N���\Z�
�*[Jv�����
�0��Ƕ:|]��9�Ae%)Ɉ�$��D|���-�,
��
D�AGC�aĀ���&�e4�[#��3��F{�E
�ں���
�W�[���xp�n�¡ໟb�2���+ЋW�@�7����f���o���@�Q��g��"��卸y{��`�[�N���3*j�(��l�+�%f:�H0����m�����P����d���pі��3f%!�7��}��b<�p/�O�s�pAX�($f��|,XBŜ�+�wêP� T
=��
񓩔����$���Z���ڣ�qQ�6}�b��ńѺ�)@g�[-f2���������:+��YZ%)��
W1�Ȑ(�n1V��	=�'�(�,��g��r���T�����)��n�_�̾�I�K�j�����vƬ�&&�V�J6�CLţi@�t�DO�n����+����-��JUk����f#�Q�ʩ�&y8�X��4�����D�����E�,Y�s.B����b��8�2"z�Y;��&i8�Mҍ2uѕ�S�c��e�!ٙg��]a�4�Y0
~/R���@̧�
�������h�=2�]�1��{��MZ:�_tu�9�G��X0�sY���@�G�㩘��)�/u){�$0�=�;�����x
����r���"k}�1
�������]D>FJ(��\��cYk���;��
}nU^b��r�Q�Uѿ�v�xJU�p$�N��
Ek���c�U��/���F��>ae�KdV�p�S�����v��ӭE�ۧ@-��av7�#a4/�W�Y�Cș��ǔx�l$��˭�
��ѯ�%���9
�<N����~�;�:�O�������
H��xQt��4qu�
�c��e=�8�T�0S�^1bw�7a�&)�tͥP�:|���U�xI�=����j��Γ>;'��0��=$t_�K��*����Vu&�}�w���������и;nƫ�x�wa�"P��sp;0�.�Z�葨9y�t<�����
��L���ͺ��}(�F}R�•�9��O��u������a�=�5&V��/
��A�����Q�c0�A����p���%��:����H�扜��`"h^@�k�
�?6:�s�v�?�c6�<4r�G~�bl'0x�8�Z��@W����
B):1d���]. Kc�*��=6u$9�beZZ��s/�-l��t���k[�A؋��$���ƹ��0�Em�K��K*"�a^n��*��r!�
�|�r�B��Fn`���oͺ>V��?������T��f�_�J��ۚ0
֖ օ�Z�3�T�l������bΥ��V��ftS�W�C���#
�i�c� o$������#D�yr-���pE�w�8E=�/��t���
̾Ǔ��R�Gh����z������b��Ͳ�
&\@��+	�
�U�p���>a��kE�}��[39��Cs,��W��̸Ext1n�t+���������n;)w��@
�X�r�c��M�is/d�W��RW�p�[���� ^?lQh�,�A�$�:���\�Q�P��2�y
�^5�ih��l���p�eKwV���H:us�b����X*����!`�
R�<���s-]1a�[���9��,	���I����`h�u���=��.�!���P�`�VN_����~\5J���>��̵tŇ9nS�,�,�� �$�v�'�N�rI��sq�K�N���Ի�<��R�r���,��T������e��,9�r�a`�Ag7q� \�)>�u#�L
���^�v����ܡ�0X*����!`�
R�<���s-]1a�[���9��,	���I����`h�u���=��.�!���T���}q��j�!��}�#�j�rܧXX%PY��A`H�
O��Y����{��aY���Ns��y+��\cU�B�r�|B�]nh�mW(a��������D���4���^p3^>�E�����7����
��?�g����5�5]D*��,��-E��F�r��.o��)
@=���Nϛe�5��Y����{��aY���Ns��y+��\cU�B�r�|B�]nh�mW(a��������D���4���^p3^>�E�����7����
��?�g����5�5]D*��,��-E��F�r��.o��)
@=���Nϛe�5��Y����{��aY���Ns��y+��\cU�B�r�|B�]nh�mW(a���E�7]g�ٔt���@x��ލܦx���!ʝ'�!��G�,6*���l
��|r�ѫ�#O�f������b
�Y��e%0t�
�%+7�w)�(x��r�I��z;���
��Dt�y���\�4j�H��Y���`��f$X�u�|��GIL1g�J����g�9�B��}���r�b�Q8f�n:7�W/��R4��`(�8~ٟ� �u�?fQ�SLA�R�z7r�⇎��*t�x���ܰث�G@�����U��F�T�>��
<f�g�E�7]g�ٔt���@x��ލܦx���!ʝ'�!��G�,6*���l
��W�+�opZ��)4��bd�������;��C��ACP�_Ȯ�|]ND��#ㇸj�ò"w5��2�	]�{�ׇiH���͇�%+�����79�F��
�
z�EwC��r&��q=��Vn���Ϙ)��J����;JD
<fl?X�)_��d��A���6P�PP�8k��+�S�5ģ������p숝�n|�L�BWv����R i�3a���J�G�%'�
�wQ�������^��]������%G�p(՛�dD�ks�
ez����ґO��&JW�?Y)?�ns���8�5�������.������������&�ɤ]M���~���7r�?�����Ic��8����e5��	��T‡��4����?}�cX��#���4�멿�X���f�nYg�����,r��C�\즳}A3Yª�P��Ə��x����kß��zb���&�=u7�k��Ì�
�,����c�%�Rt��v+���o�&k8US
:���bw�x|��a�`xs��L\Wd�����c?�q���e��W�����N�@Y�s�����g
�aC�S?�N������1�~��鋂j�@�����g��3p7,��J��a���9IӉ����!�w��f4b�#��
��U,ؿ1\��Ua�sFhz��cE8o��D2/�1&����
��j��4p=O
�:�A7��Wz��cF(�8�0�R͋��}5P��4f���F4S���dC"��hM_�
����G���s�����!�w��f4b�#��
��U,ؿ1\��Ua�sFhz��cE8o��D2/�1&����
��j��4p=O
�:�A7��Wz��cF(�8�0�R͋��}5P��4f���F4S���dC"��hM_�
����G���s�����!�w��f4b�#��
��U,ؿ1\��Ua�sFhz��cE8o��D��5h@4�?Q,Y3L�,�X=��E�G��j�µ�/���P��@wy��IP<�F*�'��D��~����PX�������G�%�&i�e������H�0�W�V������<s(�?}SI*�a��Y��TH����t�z�v�7Tա���D�d�2���`�>/�����
��z��Bǎe
���i%@�,9�0�J�6�����QAb��fꚴ y��,��U�,�����#�µ^aZ��_w(X�̠;���M$�e�#f�Q"F޿Q�U�(,Q�L�SV�O#�œ4ʲ������Z�{�V��+\r����9�w�����	u����|��1�hb�:��}LeY�S��W`�t�d�j�O��`@���Q�UE��A�0��N8Q�-Ћ�?s��1.�^_z���f2�U�P{/���<�{�*����-Ui�����8�ʨ���5��_)�
2źz��c�%����Q�[��Y��� �e�1�g�Os�\���
����?��c=GU�����8�FX�B/X��~s�ĺ�y}�>K}��41VA쾦2���x��0S�`2T�U���0 slg��*��� �{
|�(��E����~��[�/�G�o�f�*���=���U�U=�pF
wLJ�����fm��`eTZ#��sV�1
���Ym���ڜm
&ݕ���2�c�!��p�]��cNw�3�W��
�G��ψ�7����3/׋����B���j���!�>�-���S���L��j�U���-O�.�ɉ@����FZ&
^m5�ç�8r.��1�;����s�L��B[R=ϜF����aR�������]�5t��F�7��Wr�L���82b\�xhmQ���ՊV�Ξb���P�_u�5z�����i���pj�5@9H�	a���Ү�q�o7}�/�5��haȓ
�
׻/s�:�@��&"S����}�+�8�M�*++~ v7�ufLGZCW��Ȼ��Ɯ�az��MPR<�|F����aR�����Xz��6��Ae���Wjq�4�vTVV�J�Ꮄ��QÑw�ٍ9�\�B���%�#{�����pcM"T�/us�䤤��=�������*J��fӣ��
��k�x��9�b'��O2�}l���x�mE,�1�!�����*�on/��c���yi�S7动<��>���]"�Pe\��$���+��^�xf�#+����i���0T:��@��}ʟ�����҇")�lDy�50��%�����(�L��ht9
�\�X9�8�C�K�
�0��`fʮ�G�/�]=�Iv�ѹs7�Wb��)8��@��n�� ��ġpB��R���0;�Y�[ǘ&�8����%sn#/��3����*hjy��E�;\A�9�A.m?�
v.HM��їh7��1��1:ٵ�ٔ���W���\���SE5��<ۈ5+/j���<
�mo�Z�pS����g�Î+�cN�jwr�4�r�JsLԤ+{�r_�7�o�~a`.ۇ4�%A^r�W0
JJN)�C�/��<����ԯ�h�v3^��3j����r�
�qufו
Yvt�@Nɉ��.o��c��hV��̡��������.��L֠^ᛀ�kw�*����]�.��")	7�Jl�?��*8�����	�W�ku�X��U��u�T�A%���b���QB59��P;&1eږ�ĬS�g�[��>�Xc��s+�:��M��_�p0�r^�no[�U�j'�yD*��q1<{j�O%��:�5Ծ7��W�0����
�C豬@lTq����rS��5Q�brm†���b֚F+�Q!5
�ךrJ�<���V9.�m�Z����
�v����0��uR���p�+�Y�̌pV�G
j]4B`�C�����h�����HYY�l!� ��`66���%�rń-gH�׬�f�^a��Ѳ�����༭�Y�??pP$�34u���Ͱ��j�<���پƦ�gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����*p�)���sV��K�W���轧"����a?����\2�H�
�M��"����0�,�uPk̠
����(7PS=~�/���w���{NE9C�(�SIp�e����
���"����0�,�uPk̠
����(7PS=~�/���w���{NE9C�(�QZP���?�e�����E��3�anY���י@����Pn��z��Z_A.9^������r��Q���&��p��"!�*6���f;H�ܳ��A�2�7�/�3���AL,������\r���'E�9�ܣ	�LM%���DC�T
l?0�5,�Ѻu�^vWK��מ��9^.]0�);�� ǿ���ZMS���S�dT�.U�
�G��
�S�� ?�jY��t�(�쮗�)�=]�r�\�aRv5wA�}Q���![
�>Ȩ%\��6�g�V�c�@�Գ�#F��Qy�]/�S^z���x�t���j�����)i5LB��N}�PJ<8�=W�*m��*�L2�$����g<F�Ӭ��_Ԧ��w9��r�	I���	=��DR�j��l7���"��xqpz��T�=��UZ�e�I
�#R�x��YE�et��My��s��������{�ꈥ��1
�o%9�M��%u7������)��&J:����˖S�<� X;tImp�_�TXBŜ�2)�|���PX� �:�r��V}N$�u�	]M�!��5:
r1	���s
�;���?��[\/W���g5̊t�?�T=�+�N�\�uU�S���oWSz�{|
N���Bd����y��e;c����D�����E�,Y�s"�7����b
��(]Ug��A�7[���ޢ�S��#�(�70c�.YN����`��%���}Qas\ȧM���EAc؂�d�5�UY�8�{M��%u7������)��&J:����˖S�<� X;tImp�_�TXBŜ�2�+���V.�À�"'�/",��d_�BeL�ٸ�FP-uOtHV��;��]���|�S�<3.B����b��8�2"z��"�K�E�d&T�����لau�T�D�k��^Z���L��u=��2�+���V.�À�"'�/",��d_�BeL�ٸ�FP-uOtHV��;��]���|�S�<3.B����b��8�2"z��"�K�E�d&T�����لau�T�D�k��^Z���L��u=��2�+���V.�À�"'�/",��d_�BeL�ٸ�FP-uOtH���:Iw������9i3M�R����Zg�%D��TAZvj5 ���;5�+��G,�}��7]T�b*�L%�G��A��á����`�,c��4��+	�
�U�p��TM=UD�f�R�\óX����r���j3u�N8"���Y�{����:Iw������9i3M�R����Zg�%D��TAZvj5 ���;5�+��G,�}��7]T�b*�L%�G��A��á����`�,c��4��+	�
�U�p��TM=UD�f�R�\óX����r���j3u�N8"���Y�{����:Iw������9i3M�R����Zg�%D��TAZvj5 ���;5�+��@y`�VN_����~\5J���>��̵tŇ9nS�,�,�� �$�v�'�N�rI��sq�K�N���Ի�<��R�r���,��T������e��,9�r�a`�Ag7q� \�)>�u#�L
���^�v����ܡ�0X*����!`�
R�<���s-]1a�[���9��,	���I����`h�u���=��.�!���T���}q��j�!��}�#�j�rܧXX%PY��A`H�
O��H�@�㮗����g�w(y�
�d���X��T�����WLXs��:��*��n�@�'hR}$"�OH�ƛ��C
τ�s�ܳ�^�����`{�`���sF�j�C
`7���� �_}Q�gͲ���B,���i���0��@o�9��<��Q�1��!V�f>!j.�4j6��0�
s|N�AHh�
����v|�/8�T"�OH�ƛ��C
τ�s�ܳ�^�����`{�`���sF�j�C
`7���� �_}Q�gͲ���B,���i���0��@o�9��<��Q�1��!V�f>!j.�4j6��0�
s|N�AHh�
����v|�/8�T"�OH�ƛ��C
τ�s�ܳ�^�����`{�`���sF�j�C
`?�,A��>~̣����3ĥf�n�3��!T�>�Gr?�a�W���3`7૗ƍ\�}K0x�?l��n�ϟ�(�)�� ��)Y��L�C�?�C�:O�C�܏�XlU�#����F�*��W*F�R�3�3�"������:J`� <JVoF�S<P����N���w#��z��
�6�qѾ
�|h�ʑ�Գ
G������H����2���:b���ѻ��<s��9S���=����^�:p̀<�to��_5r�i�,�Q�0p��?�,A��>~̣����3ĥf�n�3��!T�>�Gr?�a�W���3`72�	]�{�ׇiH���͇�%+�����79�F��
�
z�EwC��r&��q=��Vn���Ϙ)��J����;JD
<fl?X�)_��d��A���6P�PP�8k��+�S�5ģ������p숝�n|�L�BWv����R i�3a���J�G�%'�
�wQ�������^��]������%G�p(՛�dD�ks�
ez����ґO��&JW�?Y)?�ns���8�5�������Mq(�>8{�@&��;"'s[�0S+Еݷ�-xv��x��~�2R����I��s��l������pׯ�Wt>.�x�p���f��?H���5vM z�o��3�����Y�%}����K�����W;)��PL�p��<u1����.������������&�ɤ]M���~���7r�?�����Ic��8����e5��	��T‡��4����?}�cX��#���4�멿�X���f�nYg�����,r��C�\즳}A3Yª�P��Ə��x����kß��zb���&�=u7�k��Ì�
�,����c�%�Rt��v+���o�&k8US
:���bw�x|��a�`xs��L\Wd�����c?�q���e��W�����N�M ���A
��d�1�a_���f����>��@��3C��#)��d�!�~I�4&���
��U�٣��xm9���A��ڻ�O�1F����_��l_��C骄0๣4=}�1��7��K"䘓Bj����m�_��8��ӝM ���A
��d�1�a_���f����>��@��3C��#)��d�!�~I�4&���
��U�٣��xm9���A��ڻ�O�1F����_��l_��C骄0๣4=}�1��7��K"䘓Bj����m�_��8��ӝM ���A
��d�1�a_���f����>��@��3C��#)��d�&n��B
����bɚeYg���|_�-R=�+U��9|��r������T�J��Xr1Va<�$m��5^������5h@4�?Q,Y3L�,�X=��E�G��j�µ�/���P��@wy��IP<�F*�'��D��~����PX�������G�%�&i�e������H�0�W�V������<s(�?}SI*�a��Y��TH����t�z�v�7Tա���D�d�2���`�>/�����
��z��Bǎe
���i%@�,9�0�J�6�����QAb��fꚴ y��,��U�,�����#�µ^aZ��_w(X�̠;���M$�K�חޣ�ٌ�C`A���c*�*�犸#;�%KUZ~�36�z�02�-.2
a���qŒ�n�^������u����|��1�hb�:��}LeY�S��W`�t�d�j�O��`@���Q�UE��A�0��N8Q�-Ћ�?s��1.�^_z���f2�U�P{/���<�{�*����-Ui�����8�ʨ���5��_)�
2źz��c�%����Q�[��Y��� �e�1�g�Os�\���
����?��c=GU�����8�FX�B/X��~s�ĺ�y}�>K}��41VA쾦2���x��0S�`2T�U���0 slg��*�������y�mO�.��m�Į��hi6쨬���)��i
^��"￳s�����PR<�|F����aR�����Xz��6��Ae���Wjq�4�vTVV�J�Ꮄ��QÑw�ٍ9�\�
^�)_>#x�n���0�HGe��=^bS����}�+�8�M�*++~%
e��ZCW��Ȼ��Ɯ�g�sT�����o7}�T�#��sV�1
���Ym���ڜm
&ݕ���2�c�!��p�]��cNw�3�W��
�G��ψ�7����*R�{��W������,��|J�N6��nʊ�߉B�|1֐��8r.��1�;�HV�p��ob߾���]�i�J����`���SX��_�;y?sC�_�,�t��!�w-sO/��1d�=JB���%�#{�����pcM"T�/us�䤤��=�������*J��fӣ��
��k�x��9�&
�R��9/���@B�1���
j�qi81��*
󗺹i�n=ۍ�E�A�U�ϸz�c����0T:��BͧG�*wr�4�r�JsLԤ+{�r_�7�o�~a`.ۇ4�%A^r�W0
JJN)�C�/��<����ԯ�m:?�P뻖�����S��`�![�Ò����~��
v�81��*
󗺹�PrRRqMb���a����SD������T�L����{����0޼�j˳�J�vLNX�as|���{B�Ve
��Cl�cSD������T�L����{����0޼�j˳�J�vLNX�as|���{B�Ve
��Cl�cSD������'pr,Q�s<��D�.�1��X��K\>�Ζv�K�M�i�֥p䷕��<�:D����a�^2��Ɋ�Έ���* ;M���j�<���پƦ�gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����* ;M���j�<���پƦ�gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����*p�)���sV��K�W���轧"����a?����\2�H�
�M��"����0�,�uPk̠
����(7PS=~�/���w���{NE9C�(�SIp�e�����E��3�anY���י@����Pn��z���ap�]�p��g;1^�S�D���ACJ]�,�S�?p�-�����2
ܷwc¸���D�3����lf&j� Sa���<�c��-�9]A�(x���8

���_��K�%�+���t^ӑNP��0����\.~$D?�@���`y�i[�r��(5�P���p�)���sV��K�W���轧"����a?����\2�H�
�M���F���7N�����R�����+�˦%'cWp$���KI�b��Js슂Q����!Sh�!Uja�9$��K9�4n�e�����5竹�W��L JNƮ�H1��"��T�+a�����Ë��|B����B���,rH��s�h�:�/;+��Jk�Ws��.�@���]��c��TE-&��V�y)ϲ*	G����M����U��X��5,�Ѻu�^vWK��מ��9^.]0�);�� ǿ���ZMS���S�dT�.U�
�G��
�S�� ?�jY��t�(�쮗�)�=]�r�\�aRv5wA�}Q���![
�>ɺ�������9��GQ����r�vǟ�n�-����X���E:o���*��'Q�P��ϩă�n��+��D=��ANF!2Q�n`<�v\������ۢKk������,湑N������DZx��k�.���q ����J�oQo���S��L�u�1ݗ,�ly�@�v���z������9�dS����"���A^2u�����H=��x���C��jt�b%F��we�)��,�$��^��,!b�k��~�Ȩ,{W��F�B�>�i��������9��GQ����r�vǟ�n�-����X���\�wy���!�pdD��E�����L����7������
�}�~��������{��e�Ww���]r�
�&DOP^DY�~ȿ�ʙ|��p;0�.�Z�萭w�w��P���N��xf\�wy���!�pdD��E�����L����7������
�}�~��������{��e�Ww���]r�
�&DOP^DY�~ȿ�ʙ|��p;0�.�Z�萭w�w��P���N��xf\�wy���!�pdD��E�����L����7����������C�	.����ZX�-&i��V���L�Ĩ�z��+N�F�:��f�e}��嗯��f몜pEU)��h�Q�9y�t<�����
��r�f��a8
Yj���J��������jAӫ�vkW���Yz��@n����UR�K6�u����C�	.����ZX�-&i��V���L�Ĩ�z��+N�F�:��f�e}��嗯��f몜pEU)��h�Q�9y�t<�����
��r�f��a8
Yj���J��������jAӫ�vkW���Yz��@n����UR�K6�u����C�	.����ZX�-&i��V���L�Ĩ�z��+N�F�:��f�e}��,J�����ˆ�R?���9�����-�u��U����pNФ�IԎI04n:�{���z�r���y`�VN_����~\5J���>��̵tŇ9nS�,�,�� �$�v�'�N�rI��sq�K�N���Ի�<��R�r���,��T������e��,9�r�a`�Ag7q� \�)>�u#�L
���^�v����ܡ�0X*����!`�
R�<���s-]1a�[���9��,	���I����`h�u���=��.�!���T���}q��j�!��}�#�j�rܧXX%PY��A`H�
O��Y����{��aY���Ns��y+��\cU�B�r�|B�]nh�mW(a��������D���4���^p3^>��W��wgt���(��@o�9��<��Q�1��!V�f>!j.�	�+/�3�"t��:��ֱe��]D�� �_}Q�gͲ���B,���ق�0��@o�9��<��Q�1��!V�"D3�B�†B�����Q�\����jD)b0WK��vZ@��%Bd�"xO�v|�/8�T"�OH�ƛ��C
τ�s�ܳ�^��	RK�9Q*������a���`�-E��ø������9�U���|N�AHh�
����v|�/8�T"�OH�ƛ��C
τ�s�ܳ�^�����`{�`���sF�j�C
`?�,A��>~̣����3ĥf�n�3��!T�>�Gr?�a�W���3`7૗ƍ\�}K0x�?l�o�:���&��'c2�����q�ȣb�=�������گ:L�<hSٽ��}��\V��܏�XlU��0��b����u��y�(�U��W�b�f����
*[����zː(��b��K�o�/���*�d�R��H��Z/���&��f��L/(�����lk�]�w�uQ0�0�}��h��=�m+��T�>��F�����)��_�8f�no�y����MGD��]�W�>:@�(]sR���R6�g�[Gc(VڽJ�j�L,�������\v9� <JVoF�)sd!��t;,'�@�6z�Ű��h��"���૗ƍ\�}K0x�?l��n�ϟ�(�)�� ��)Y��L�C�?�C�:O�C�܏�XlU�#����L�BWv����R i�3a���J�G�%'�
�wQ�������^��]������%G�p(՛�dD�ks�]Ʌ�'�%B���Z�6w����q��$r��ʏ8)������G�R�TU��qM�K�xu6���se�zY�h����ĵ��[�S�(VK�cT�{X;�W�U:ĮV�ޠ�po������A�lo������?fQ=BQt���x�[�p<a�}��;���T�)��5��#��m��Y-|���Wt>.�L�e����5�U)O#��X,���}�B�w�@]�U#� �5T�B�����ڟ@��l?X��
��(�Z��&��Je"Ux�c:u%7��]p�	=��6�Ŏ��m����������p숝�n|�L�BWv����R i�3a���J�G�%'�
�wQ�������^��]�������?}�cX��#���4�멿�X���f�nYg�����,r��C�\즳}A3Yª�P��Ə��Zf��;̪�r�3��4�h��I��R_��.��-�e�$��^��w��7
�<�k�[R�y�Y�%}����YÃ:p���&�.�,n��Q26����g�R;�_���|iH���j�F�*�(�H�e���x�r�O��,��~�l��k��� �Z�ū�^�6U��"8]�����A��2Ճ�em�h�ھ�~``I��&a衪?�s,r���P*�Cmi��k7Ը��W^]]�
S#^�~���d
3?!�m4�}�gi�g�de*�
��0y��n��A5vM�(�����/�~�Y�?�˘��bl���\�BM��9��
A��H,ͻ��{e=�+V��5�N�k7�5�*��Lh�1;Nj�<>~�0ư<9��G�.	��i�S�����8��ܲ��+���?�X�'N&�G�
�@ ��޲}�ъ0�/��T�b��rMT q��������2Yȿ$ĚW���m������<6��ix ��m]�'ٍ����p/�K6/�W!��Bp\њ���N�C%���LI�5}��l6گ��S�iΦ�G�
�@ ��޲}�ъ0�/��T�b��rMT q��������2Yȿ$ĚW���m������<6��ix ��m]�'ٍ����p/�K6/�W!��Bp\њ���N�C%���LI�5}��l6گ��S�iΦ�G�
�@ ��޲}�ъ0�/��T�b��rMT q��������2Y7Tա���D�d�2���`�>/�����
��z��Bǎe
���i%@�,9�0�J�6�����QAb��fꚴ y��,��U�,�����#�µ^aZ��_w(X�̠;���M$�e�#f�Q"F޿Q�U�(,Q�L�SV�O#�œ4ʲ������Z�{�V��+\r����9�w�����̰�b��y*$H���:j�E�;I��jЀi�~�X�f�VY��z��T�s
�y�k�_=}ܡc�2�����4��y��U�O%D�z�GMW���Gi3uMZ
<��KL�*�?�C��Qj��aZ�0�q�篻�,x�P�~���T%����Q�[��Y��� �e�1�g�Os�\���
����?��c=GU�����8�FX�B/X��~s�ĺ�y}�>K}��41VA쾦2���x��0S�`2T�U���0 slg��*��� �{
|�(��E����~��[�/�G�o�f�*���=���U�U=�pF
wLJ�����fm��`eTZ\d�`/��b��c�1����u����-�c,��Xu���ʳʧ���N��R�V�����ͱ�����K��Xa��p�,[��~�?9�b]n���%��e����_SVyT�<U�)�0*Z����9�3�q��Qh����Xz��6��Ae���Wjq�4�vTVV�J�Ꮄ��QÑw�ٍ9�\�
^�)_>#x�n���0�HGe��=^bS����}�+�8�M�*++~%
e��ZCW��Ȼ��Ɯ�g�sT�����o7}�T�#��sV�1
���Ym���ڜm
&ݕ���2�c�!��p�]��cNw�3�W��
�G��ψ�7����*R�{��W������,��|J�N6��nʊ�߉B�|1֐��8r.��1�;������#�
���o���p�)��Շ��Cj}�t[o�%v�CI�eEeoġL��Hj�9}��ӝ�̤+{�r_�7�o�~a`.ۇ4�%A^r�W0
JJN)�C�/��<����ԯ�m:?�P뻖�����S��`�![�Ò����~��
v�81��*
󗺹�PrRRqMb���a����P�i��J��]ܵ�<\�Ҝœ�)
������[�ߘX����4�PW���������k���c'�`�u+���N��T:��i�����,��HV�p��ob߾���]�i�J����`���SX��_�;y?sC�_�,�t��!�w-sO/��1d�=JB���%�#{�����pcM"T�/us�䤤��=�������*J���gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����* ;M���j�<���پƦ�gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����* ;M���j�<���پƦ�gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����* ;M���j�<���پƦ�gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����* ;M���j�<���پƦ�gc5�/6���]w)��W�a�yP՗gH�
�옜�����*p�)���sV��K�W���轧"����a?����\2�H�
�M��"����0�,�uPk̠
����(7PS=~�/���w���{NE9C�(�SIp�e�����E��3�anY���י@����Pn��z��Z_A.9^������r��Q���&��p��"!�*6���f;H�ܳ��A�2�7�/�3���AL,������\r���'E�9�ܣ	�LM%���DC�T
l?1��v���g+�"�^eo_�g
A���Y��5i}��{��N��r)��F���K��/Ĉ���~`?�jY��t�(�쮗�)�=]�r�\�aRv5wA�}Q���![
�>Ȩ%\��6�g�V�c�@�Գ�#F��Qy�]/�S^z���x�t���j�����)i5LB��N}�PJ<8�=W�*m��*�L2�$����g<F�Ӭ��_Ԧ��w9��r�	I���	=��DR�j��l7���"��xqpz��T�=��UZ�e�I
�#R�x��YE�et��My��s��������{�ꈥ��1
�o%9�EA(����_��{?���0���F���7N�����R�����+�˦%'cWp$���KI�b��Js웭�J�oQo���S��L�u�1ݗ,�ly�@�v���z������9�dS����"���A^2u�����H=��x���C��jt�b%F��we�)��,�$��^��,!b�k��~�Ȩ,{W��F�B�>�i��������9��GQ����r�vǟ�n�-����X���E:o���*��'Q�P��ϩă�n��+��D=��ANF!2Q�n`<�v\������ۢKk������,湑N������DZx��k�.���q ����J�oQo���S��L�u�1ݗ,�ly�@�v���z������9�e�Ww���]r�
�&DOP^DY�~ȿ�ʙ|��p;0�.�Z�萭w�w��P���N��xf\�wy���!�pdD��E�����OaX3�M�J��c ��՘b
��-��O�'-��z�pm:�{G8O2��z�g��k�ي�f
�
��?ش��{�n�omy�m ]䷅]F�Z��n%�4e������&����5�V~�eq6Ӵi<A��/�k�.V���������U��j�;��ib�E1�[�Q�7P���*#V�:�B�	`4I���$�^��.	�f���)o*�b�\[�iEk���8\��A���z�����D�2�
�������eL�ٸ�FP-uOtHV��;��]���|�S�<3.B����b��8�2"z��"�K�E�d&T�����لau�T�D�A��á����`�,c��4��+	�
�U�p��TM=UD�f�R�\óX����r���j3u�N8"���Y�{����:Iw������9i3M�R����Zg�#н��K�
�-]G�5_�{�n�<��/�pC��0�?����t�����Ƅb03U�d�`c#n��j\��˙�/�[����c���݃XZ�X^vs[Y����q/�L���f"�yi��Vk�r��O�P�dJ��K��P��9]w�o[ӆ�n�â���n�o���	��㨞�a�Pd���:V��zW���6'uɹf�e-M1=��N�6P�-�����"�J�\k+��>�MX�2�(i����1k�bZ��<+�Q4�UV���H:us�b�����/_}���U8���S	f��Pr�0�x 
%����+K��6=J�p��i�#��OUQi٨ԃ�W0��,���
傩Y9~��
�p�*C����G2���N��J�������.	��I:��&���]/q;C��R�P�,J�����ˆ�R?���9�����-�u����݋WFM
M�e�2���r>�ū`:?�J��=�������@��ů����Y����W ��|D��d�ؙ� (za?ػv{ĺ|��1-p�����F�=�w��贊f�,��E�U�@8���=Ju��
��uh׉E19�i�����d�R�@ae��)ӗ'{�����+&X5�v.�NM���N����v���w.����:4W�I��Ք��/�x�x�AwH?�@(%�����3�hYK�,:��^@ծ<��h��?�%PY��A`H�
O��H�@�㮗����g�w(y�
�d���X��T�����WLXs��:��*��n�@�'hR}$"�OH�ƛ��C
τ�s�ܳ�^�����`{�`���sF�j�C
`7���� �_}Q�gͲ���B,���i���0��@o�9��<��Q�1��!V�f>!j.�4j6��0�
s|N�AHh�
����v|�/8�T"�OH�ƛ��C
τ�s�ܳ�^�����`{�`���sF�j�C
`7���� �_}Q�gͲ���B,���i���0��@o�9��<��Q�1��!V�f>!j.�4j6��0�
s|N�AHh�
����v|�/8�T"�OH�ƛ��C
τ�s�ܳ�^�����`{�`���sF�j�C
`?�,A��>~̣����3ĥf�n�3��!T�>�Gr?�a�W���3`7૗ƍ\�}K0x�?l��n�ϟ�(�)�� ��)Y��L�C�?�C�:O�C�܏�XlU�#����F�*��W*F�R�3�3�"������:J`� <JVoF�S<P����N���w#��z��
�6�qѾ
�|h�ʑ�Գ
G������H����2���:b���ѻ��<s��9S���=����^�:p̀<�to��_5r�i�,�Q�0p��?�,A��>~̣����3ĥf�n�3��!T�>�Gr?�a�W���3`72�	]�{�ׇiH���͇�%+�����79�F��
�
z�EwC��r&��q=��Vn���Ϙ)��J����;JD
<fl?X�)_��d��A���6P�PP�8k��+�S�5ģ������p숝�n|�L�BWv����R i�3a���J�G�%'�
�wQ�������^��]������%G�p(՛�dD�ks�
ez����ґO��&JW�?Y)?�ns���8�5�������Mq(�>8{�@&��;"'s[�0S+Еݷ�-xv��x��~�2R����I��s��l������pׯ�Wt>.�x�p���f��?H���5vM z�o��3�����Y�%}����K�����W;)��PL�p��<u1����.������������&�ɤ]M���~���7r�?�����Ic��8����e5��	��T‡��4����?}�cX��#���4�멿�X���f�nYg�����,r��C�\즳}A3Yª�P��Ə��x����kß��zb���&�=u7�k��Ì�
�,����c�%�Rt��v+���o�&k8US
:���bw�x|��a�`xs��L\Wd�����c?�q���e��W�����N�M ���A
��d�1�a_���f����>��@��3C��#)��d�!�~I�4&���
��U�٣��xm9���A��ڻ�O�1F����_��l_��C骄0๣4=}�1��7��K"䘓Bj����m�_��8��ӝM ���A
��d�1�a_���f����>��@��3C��#)��d�!�~I�4&���
��U�٣��xm9���A��ڻ�O�1F����_��l_��C骄0๣4=}�1��7��K"䘓Bj����m�_��8��ӝM ���A
��d�1�a_���f����>��@��3C��#)��d�&n��B
����bɚeYg���|_�-R=�+U��9|��r������T�J��Xr1Va<�$m��5^������5h@4�?Q,Y3L�,�X=��E�G��j�µ�/���P��@wy��IP<�F*�'��D��~����PX�������G�%�&i�e������H�0�W�V������<s(�?}SI*�a��Y��TH����t�z�v�7Tա���D�d�2���`�>/�����
��z��Bǎe
���i%@�,9�0�J�6�����QAb��fꚴ y��,��U�,�����#�µ^aZ��_w(X�̠;���M$�K�חޣ�ٌ�C`A���c*�*�犸#;�%KUZ~�36�z�02�-.2
a���qŒ�n�^������u����|��1�hb�:��}LeY�S��W`�t�d�j�O��`@���Q�UE��A�0��N8Q�-Ћ�?s��1.�^_z���f2�U�P{/���<�{�*����-Ui�����8�ʨ���5��_)�
2źz��c�%����Q�[��Y��� �e�1�g�Os�\���
����?��c=GU�����8�FX�B/X��~s�ĺ�y}�>K}��41VA쾦2���x��0S�`2T�U���0 slg��*�������y�mO�.��m�Į��hi6쨬���)��i
^��"￳s�����PR<�|F����aR�����Xz��6��Ae���Wjq�4�vTVV�J�Ꮄ��QÑw�ٍ9�\�
^�)_>#x�n���0�HGe��=^bS����}�+�8�M�*++~%
e��ZCW��Ȼ��Ɯ�g�sT�����o7}�T�#��sV�1
���Ym���ڜm
&ݕ���2�c�!��p�]��cNw�3�W��
�G��ψ�7����*R�{��W������,��|J�N6��nʊ�߉B�|1֐��8r.��1�;�HV�p��ob߾���]�i�J����`���SX��_�;y?sC�_�,�t��!�w-sO/��1d�=JB���%�#{�����pcM"T�/us�䤤��=�������*J��fӣ��
��k�x��9�&
�R��9/�ط�0�mÃi��9{��%%'�!����O��P�W�6��u��\����)�Y0R�������ſ}����n�H�y��\�(9))8��@��v0�~�
�R��Y���%@C��Z�._�Nbɀz��owK�F�-���,�p�ƚD�+�^��
A�II�5�z�c����0T:��M��k�^&mS2��S�9�".���z�.Α(��19cq���T@v�a�
�Xy�6u
�}�M��k�^&mS2��S�9�".���z�.Α(��19cq���T@v�a�
�Xy�6u
�}�M��k�^&mS2��S�9�".���z�.Α(��19cq���T@v�a�
�Xy�6u
�}�M��k�^&mS2��S�9�".���z�.Α(��19cq���T@v�a�
�Xy�6u
�}�M��k�^&mS2��S�9�".���z�.Α(��19cq���T�(7PS=~�/���w���{NE9C�(�SIp�e�����E��3�anY���י@����Pn��z��Z_A.9^������r��Q���&��p��"!�*6���f;H�ܳ��A�2�7�/�3���AL,������\r���'E�9�ܣ	�LM%���DC�T
l?1��v���g+�"�^eo_�g
A���Y��5i}��{��N��r)��F���K��/Ĉ���~b,!��#r�WPE���0����u0���j��	q��x���S�?r�'�14��_��P)����Գ�#F��Qy�]/�S^z���x�t���j�����)i5LB��N}�PJ<8�=W�*m��*�L2�$����g<F�Ӭ��_Ԧ��w9��r�	I���	=��DR�j��l7���"��xqpz��T�=��UZ�e�I
�#R�x��YE�et��My��s��������{�ꈥ��1
�o%9�EA(����_��{?���0���F���7N�����R�����+�˦%'cWp$���KI�b��Js슂Q����!Sh�!Uja�9$��K9�4n�e�����5竹�W��L JNƮ�H1��"��T�+a����7[���ޢ�S��#�(�70c�.YN����`��%���}Qas\ȧM���EAc؂�d�5�UY�8�{M��%u7������)��&J:����˖S�<� X;tImp�_�TXBŜ�2)�|���PX� �:�r��V}N$�u�	]M�!��5:
r1	���s
�;���?��[\/W���g5̊t�?�T=�+�N�\�uU�S���oWSz�{|
N���Bd����y��e;c����D�����E�,Y�s"�7����b
��(]Ug��A�7[���ޢ�S��#�(�70c�.YN����`��%���}Qas\ː���1X��3�L����������	�2��f�va]@��=�!Z��ז�v7�1�Op�̹
�����C0�>ȉ�ȋ=/����S/��nf��]S�����yjc}3)��ː���1X��3�L����������	�2��f�va]@��=�!Z��ז�v7�1�Op�̹
�����C0�>ȉ�ȋ=/����S/��nf��]S�����yjc}3)��ː���1X��3�L����������	�2��f�va]@��=�#Pr�0�x 
%����+K��6=J�p��i�#��OUQi٨ԃ�W0��,������ڀ�uS�
���0�m�5/3��]����"���ZL�cԬ'+-V��?�Q4�UV���H:us�b�����/_}���U8���S	f��Pr�0�x 
%����+K��6=J�p��i�#��OUQi٨ԃ�W0��,������ڀ�uS�
���0�m�5/3��]����"���ZL�cԬ'+-V��?�Q4�UV���H:us�b�����/_}���U8���S	f��Pr�0�x 
%����+K��6=J�p��i�#��OUQi٨ԃ�W0��,���
傩Y9~��
�p�*C����G2���N��J�������.	��I:��&���]/q;C��R�P�,J�����ˆ�R?���9�����-�u��U����pNФ�IԎI04n:�{���z�r���y`�VN_����~\5J���>��̵tŇ9nS�,�,�� �$�v�'�N�rI��sq�K�N���Ի�<��R�r���,��T������e��,9�r�a`�Ag7q� \�)>�u#�L
���^�v����ܡ�0X*����!`�
R�<���s-]1a�[���9��,	���I���9=#soq+>��r�%{��k�j��U��Y��Z������5�\��R(�z=}�F��6��k�����71���³�
����,�W�=F�ƫ��X������ѨڮP�X��;!!�����Ti��l��f�}P�9=#soq+>��r�%{��k�j��U��Y��Z������5�\��R(�z=}�F��6��k�����71���³�
����,�W�=F�ƫ��X������ѨڮP�X��;!!�����Ti��l��f�}P�9=#soq+>��r�%{��k�j��U��Y��Z������5�\�H����2���:b���ѻ��<s��9S���=����^�:p̀<�to��_5r�i�,�Q�0p��?�,A��>~̣����3ĥf�n�3��!T�>�Gr?�a�W���3`7૗ƍ\�}K0x�?l��n�ϟ�(�)�� ��)Y��L�C�?�C�:O�C�܏�XlU�#����F�*��W*F�R�3�3�"������:J`� <JVoF�S<P����N���w#��z��
�6�qѾ
�|h�ʑ�Գ
G������H����2���:b���ѻ��<s��9S���=����^�:p̀<���%wm�^�"�36�L���~�R ��u(p?�(j5�����Ț�Q�|p��MY�vDN�>`�W�+�opZ��)4��bd�������;��C��ACP�_Ȯ�|]ND��#ㇸj�ò"w5��2�	]�{�ׇiH���͇�%+�����79�F��
�
z�EwC��r&��q=��Vn���Ϙ)��J����;JD
<fl?X�)_��d��A���6P�PP�8k��+�S�5ģ������p숝�n|�L�BWv����R i�3a���J�G�%'�
�wQ�������^��]�������?}�cX��#���4�멿�X���f�nYg�����,r��C�\즳}A3Yª�P��Ə��x����kß��zb���&�=u7�k��Ì�
�,����c�%�Rt��v+���o�&k8US
:���bw�x|��a�`xs��L\Wd�����c?�q���e��W�����N�@Y�s�����g
�aC�S?�N������1�~��鋂j�@�����g��3p7,��J��a���9Iӈ!خvSY�����UL(x�cG��<\
���ن5�����=1pM]�H�������a�n�	_�1���):q4�<o�
6����ƌQ�q~`8꥛�+��j��8.h�_x�h�
�!�ȆE�&$К��`6mW�f����SH#�� Cj�Y>�h�G��~�Y�~b���8Â�����Ɗp��,�d_�bM	���a���h�z�Nu9�tE���A
��d�1�a_����0+v����C骄0๣4=}�1��7��K"䘓Bj����m�_��8��ӝM ���A
��d�1�a_���f����>��@��3C��#)��d�!�~I�4&���
��U�٣��xm9���A��ڻ�O�1F����_��l_��C骄0๣4=}�1��7��K"fꚴ y��,��U�,�����#�µ^aZ��_w(X�̠;���M$�e�#f�Q"F޿Q�U�(,Q�L�SV�O#�œ4ʲ������Z�{�V��+\r����9�w�����̰�b��y*$H���:j�E�;I�a��L�/
'����{C��)Q
���ZA���u8V�ُխ���T�����{��ȯ`)j�#�g��}�P�~���T2Ñ��	䨑#o_���(�&n��B
����bɚeYg���|_�-R=�+U��9|��r������T�J��Xr1Va<�$m��5^������5h@4�?Q,Y3L�,�X=��E�G��j�µ�/���P��@wy��IP�[�/�G�o�f�*���=���U�U=�pF
wLJ�����fm��`eTZ\d�`/��b��c�1����u����-�c,��Xu���ʳʧ���N��R�V�����ͱ�����K��Xa��p�,[��~�?9�eanPhSU��l�^�����F��h�י�0��� R0��%7]z���`�)M�.��KI��<˄�쮭�sk/�-V�/j�6�z�02�-.2
a���qŒ�n�^������u����|��1�hb�:��}LeY�S��W`�t�d�j�O��`@���Q�UE��A�0��N8Q�-Ћ�?s��1.�^_z���f2�U�P{/���<�{�*����-Ui�����8�ʨ�Ge��=^bS����}�+�8�M�*++~%
e��ZCW��Ȼ��Ɯ�g�sT�����o7}�T�#��sV�1
���Ym���ڜm
&ݕ���2�c�!��p�]��cNw�3�W��
�G��ψ�7����*R�{��W������,��|J�N6��nʊ�߉B�|1֐��8r.��1�;������#�
���o���p�)��Շ��Cj}�t[o�%v�CI�eEeoġL��Hj�9}��ӝ�����j�r�����7����c
��v^�j���!�>�-���S���۲����P�_u�5z�����i���R��9/�ط�0�mÃi��9{��%%'�!����O��P�W�6��u��\����)�Y0R�������ſ}����n�H�y��\�(9))8��@��v0�~�
�R��Y���%@C��Z�._�Nbɀz��owK�F�-���,�p�ƚD�+�^��
A�II�5�z�c����0T:��BͧG�*wr�4�r�JsLԤ+{�r_�7�o�~a`.ۇ4�%A^r�W0
JJN)�C�/��<����ԯ�m:?�P뻖�����S��`�![�Ò����~��
v�81��*
󗺹�PrRRqMb���a����SD������T�L����{����0޼�j˳�J�vLNX�as|���{B�Ve
��Cl�cSD������T�L����{����0޼�j˳�J�vLNX�as|���{B�Ve
��Cl�cSD������T�L����{����0޼�j˳�J�vLNX�as|���{B�Ve
��Cl�cSD������T�L����{����0޼�j˳�J�vLNX�as|���{B�Ve
��Cl�cSD������T�L����{����0޼�j˳�J�vLNX�as|�8

���_��K�%�+���t^ӑNP��0����\.~$D?�@���`y�i[�r��(5�P���p�)���sV��K�W���轧"����a?����\2�H�
�M��"����0�,�uPk̠
����(7PS=~�/���w���{NE9C�(�SIp�e�����E��3�anY���י@����Pn��z��Z_A.9^������r��Q���&��p��"!�*6���f;H�ܳ��A�2�7�/�3���AL,������\r���'E�9�ܣ	�LM%���DC�T
l?0�5,�Ѻu�^vWK��מ��9^.]0�);�� ǿ���ZMS���S�dT�.U�
�G��
�S�� ?�jY��t�(�쮗�)�=]�r�\�aRv5wA�}Q���![
�>Ȩ%\��6�g�V�c�@�Գ�#F��Qy�]/�S^z���x�t���j�����)i5LB��N}�PJ<8�=W�*m��*�L2�$����g<F�Ӭ��_Ԧ��w9��r�	I���	=��DR�j��l7���"��xqpz��T�=��UZ�e�I
�#R�x��YE�et��My��s��������{�ꈥ��1
�o%9�M��%u7������)��&J:����˖S�<� X;tImp�_�TXBŜ�2)�|���PX� �:�r��V}N$�u�	]M�!��5:
r1	���s
�;���?��[\/W���g5̊t�?�ɂ&�B�l�L�J�90������H=��bE��ҹ��ޢ�S��C�{a��&J:�)�����Ǥ>��[sĥx90��ۢKk������,湑N������a�Qʝ�
��(]Ug��A�7[���ޢ�S��#�(�70c�.YN����`��%���}Qas\ȧM���EAc؂�d�5�UY�8�{M��%u7������)��&J:����˖S�<� X;tImp�_�TXBŜ�2�+���V.�À�"'�/",��d_�BeL�ٸ�FP-uOtHV��;��]���|�S�<3.B����b��8�2"z��"�K�E�d&T�����لau�T�D�k��>���t��s6֭R]v�*�A]M[v��H�G"��b9�ͱ�FP�U�n�c=�Q�
��5�K���.F�]	�V:�ʜ�}OyQ*���m$fNZ��=<��N6���I����%��c�����D�7:M!e�%*4��
�gfQ!"����
Y���TF��<%�	`�����~��r���+\�a�|	���z_�/�!2�_?���#����$+]����.��f>S���!]��b�u�f��=Ayg��"��*e������0��k�{�F���a��@K��?�V�1�I�lz���e��8G�*&���
ӳQ�N�a٬Y_�9e����UJa,�=�j^f$����Eic���ǩXNVZ�3��i� �;5�t���ŕ��#�^��P�a�8T�x.��0�&֝Y�6�	z���3
u<*W���F�����j	�+0��k��ޠ��7.k)�+w櫈���o}��4i}�s���
Px�Q��ԂLP�A���M(������/h�.�T't��K�@
��l����NJ5_�崙�Rh%���*(68�ͣ�F���a��@K��?�V�1�I�lz���e��8G�*&���
ӳQ�N�a٬Y_�9e����UJa,�=�j^f$����Eic���ǩXNVZ�3��i� �;5�t���ŕ�� <�U+'/�\B�?.�Hx���Z�bÜ�)�	TswX�;B��'R9$��9���'h{��]�C
傩Y9~��
�p�*C����G2���N��J�������.	��I:��&���]/q;C��R�P�,J�����ˆ�R?���9�����-�u��U����pNФ�IԎI04n:�{���z�r���y`�VN_����~\5J���>��̵tŇ9nS�,�,�� �$�v�'�N�rI��sq�K�N���Ի�<��R�r���,��T������e��,9�r�a`�Ag7q� \�)>�g'�ncM��!�g�}9��Y�|z�q�WQ
�=�0
�Qu��Q�\�����vB
CEG���ӳ��y��x��rzF�4���V| 7Ӝ��J�Ǩ��u�ܳ�[�5U�k��'d �4Q�z��;>m��׏�g'�ncM��!�g�}9��Y�|z�q�WQ
�=�0
�Qu��Q�\�����vB
CEG���ӳ��y��x��rzF�4���V| 7Ӝ��J�Ǩ��u�ܳ�[�5U�k��'d �4Q�z��;>m��׏�g'�ncM��!�g�}9��Y�|z�q�WQ
�=�0
�Qu��Q�\����� �u�?fQ�SLA�R�z7r�⇎��*t�x���ܰث�G@�����U��F�T�>��
<f�g�E�7]g�ٔt���@x��ލܦx���!ʝ'�!��G�,6*���l
��|r�ѫ�#O�f������b
�Y��e%0t�
�%+7�w)�(x��r�I��z;���
��Dt�y���\�4j�H��Y���`��f$X�u�|��GIL1g�J����g�9�B��}���r�b�Q8f�n:7�W/��R4��`(�8~ٟ� �u�?fQ�SLA�R�z7r�⇎��*t�x���ܰث�G@����^�����kô�@��f��������JO���e�
C��"���u9\J8���P	�7ȉ������%wm�^�"�36�L���~�R ��u(p?�(j5�����Ț�Q�|p��MY�vDN�>`�W�+�opZ��)4��bd�������;��C��ACP�_Ȯ�|]ND��#ㇸj�ò"w5��2�	]�{�ׇiH���͇�%+�����79�F��
�
z�EwC��r&��q=��Vn���Ϙ)��J����;JD
<fl?X�)_��d��A���6P�PP�8k��+�S�x����k��zb���&�=u7�k���
�,����c�%�Rt��v+���o�&k8US
:���bw�x|��a�`xs��L\Wd�����c?�q���e��W�����N�@Y�s�����g
�aC�S?�N������1�~��鋂j�@�����g��3p7,��J��a���9Iӈ!خvSY�����UL(x�cG��<\
���ن5�����=1pM]�H�������a�n�	_�1���):q
d;��k7�5�*��Lh�1;Nj�<>~�0ư<9��G�.	��i�S�����8��ܲ��+���?�X�'N&�G�
�@ ��޲}�ъ0�/��T�b��rMT q��������2Yȿ$ĚW���m������<6��ix ��m]�'ٍ����p/�K6/�W!��Bp\њ���N�C%���LI�5}��l6گ��S�iΦ�G�
�@ ��޲}�ъ0�/��T�b��rMT q��������2Yȿ$ĚW���m������<6��ix ��m]�'ٍ����p/�K6/�W!��Bp\њ���N�C%���LI�5}��l6گ��S�iΦ�G�
�@ ��޲}�ъ0�/��T�b��rMT q��������2Y7Tա���D�d�2���`�>/�����
��z��Bǎe
���i%@�,9�0�J�6�����QAb��fꚴ y��,��U�,�����#�µ^aZ��_w(X�̠;���M$�e�#f�Q"F޿Q�U�(,Q�L�SV�O#�œ4Ť�FR��x�z��������r(Lݓ���-�l^r�m��&�E�G�%��u��P�~���T2Ñ��	䨑#o_���(�&n��B
����bɚeYg���|_�-R=�+U��9|��r������T�J��Xr1Va<�$m��5^������5h@4�?Q,Y3L�,�X=��E�G��j�µ�/���P��@wy��IP�[�/�G�o�f�*���=���U�U=�pF
wLJ�����fm��`eTZ\d�`/��b��c�1����u����-�c,��Xu���ʳʧ���N��R�V�����ͱ�����K��Xa��p�,[��~�?9�b]n���%��e�j�F�[UC�
V�K7);8�cկ����g
��6i�14K	�����8�ʨ���5��_)�
2źz��c�%����Q�[��Y��� �e�1�g�Os�\���
����?��c=GU�����8�FX�B/X��~s�ĺ�y}�>K}��41VA쾦2���x��0S�`2T�U���0 slg��*�������y�mO�.��m�Į��hi6쨬���)��i
^��"￳s�����PR<�|F����aR�����Xz��6��Ae���Wjq�4�vTVV�J�Ꮄ��QÑw�ٍ9�\�
^�)_>#x�n���0�HGe��=^bS�a�6
4?�a�9��j�˘Y�,i�jZ�����&��y�GB�
@�0�@9}��ӝ�����j�r�����7����c
��v^�j���!�>�-���S���۲����P�_u�5z�����i���pj�5@9H�z����w��1�JB;/w5a��ڟp]���]����m�QY[�(S/�:��GE�f4�}s)
������[�ߘX����4�PW���������k���c'�`�u+���N��T:��i�����,��HV�p��ob߾���]�i�J����`���SX��_�;y?sC�_�,�t��!�w-sO/��1d�=JB���%�#{�����pcM"T�/us�䤤��=�������*J��fӣ��
��k�x��9�&
�R��9/�ط�0�mÃi��9{��%%'�!����O��P�W�6��u��\����)�Y0R�������ſ}����n�H�y��\�(9))8��@��v0�~�
�R���Y��z�ͪb&W]�p=�E���o^T5e��%q;&',n0��J�
��l=�Z�2��o���Y��z�ͪb&W]�p=�E���o^T5e��%q;&',n0��J�
��l=�Z�2��o���Y��z�ͪb&W]�p=�E���o^T5e��%q;&',n0��J�
��l=�Z�2��o���Y��z�ͪb&W]�p=�E���o^T5e��%q;&',n0��J�
��l=�Z�2��o���Y��z�ͪb&W]�p=�E���o^T5e��%q;&',n0��J��
ag��ե�����:/iȧ(~�O�bi.�" Sa���<�c��-�9]A�(x���8

���_��K�%�+���t^ӑNP��0����\.~$D?�@���`y�i[�r��(5�P���p�)���sV��K�W���轧"����a?����\2�H�
�M��"����0�,�uPk̠
����(7PS=~�/���w���{NE9C�(�SIp�e�����E��3�anY���י@����Pn��z��Z_A.9^������r��Q���&��p��"!�*6���s�h�:�/;+��Jk�Ws��.�@���]��c��TE-&��V�y)ϲ*	G����M����U��X��5,�Ѻu�^vWK��מ��9^.]0�);�� ǿ���ZMS���S�dT�.U�
�G��
�S�� ?�jY��t�(�쮗�)�=]�r�\�aRv5wA�}Q���![
�>Ȩ%\��6�g�V�c�@�Գ�#F��Qy�]/�S^z���x�t���j�����)i5LB��N}�PJ<8�=W�*m��*�L2�$����g<F�Ӭ��_Ԧ��w9��r�	I���	=��DR�j��l7���'��
�$�$�$�$�$
 �
 �
 �
 �
�@��@��@��@��@�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�	�I�$I �I�I$H �I �I�$	�@$@A �A
$�H�@ �	$$�I �
$ �
�$@ 	�A ��A �	�A �	�A �	�A �$�	�$�	�$�	�$�	�$�I @�I @�I @�I @�I @ 
$�H 
$�H 
$�H 
$�H 
$� 
$ 
$ 
$ 
$ �����I�
 �I�
 �I�
 �I�
 �I�
	
	
	
	
 �A �H�@ �H �$ A�A@�	$�$
 �I	�I 
 �@ �
�@��@�A��@��@�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�	� �I� �I� �I� �I�$A �AA �AA �AA �AA �	�	$	�	$	�	$	�	$	�	�A �	�A �	�A �	�A �	�A �$�	�$�	�$�	�$�	�$�I @�I @�I @�I @�I @ 
$�H 
$�H 
$�H 
$�H 
$� 
$ 
$ 
$ 
$ �����I�
 �I�
 �I�
 �I�
 �I�
	
	
	
	
 �H �H �H �H �$�$�@ �$�$
 �
 �
 �
 �
�@��@��H��@��@�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�	� �I� �I� �I� �I�$A �AA �AA �AA �AA �	�	$	�	$	�	$	�	$	�	�A �	�A �	�A �	�A �	�A �$�	�$�I�$
�$�	�$�I @�$I$�H@$�
 �A�I @ 
$�H�@$IH �H��H 
$� 
$�H �I	HI$ �����I�
 �I�
 �I�
 �I�
 �I�
	
	
	
	
 �H �H �H �H �$�$�$�$�$
 �
 �
 �
 �
�@��@��@��@��@�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�	� �I� �I� �I� �I�$A �AAI�I
	 �AA �	�	$	�	 �I$�	
 	$	�	�A �	�@I@�
A �	�A �$�	�$�	�$�	�$�	�$�I @�I @�I @�I @�I @ 
$�H 
$�H 
$�H 
$�H 
$� 
$ 
$ 
$ 
$ �����I�
 �I�
 �I�
 �I�
 �I�
	
	
	
	
 �H �H �H �H �$�$�$�$�$
 �
 �
 �
 �
�@��@��@��@��@�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�	� �I� �I� �I� �I�$A �AA �AA �AA �AA �	�	$	�	$	�	$	�	$	�	�A �	�A �	�A �	�A �	�A �$�	�$�	�$�	�$�	�$�I @�I @�I @�I @�I @ 
$�H 
$�H 
$�H 
$�H 
$� 
$ 
$ 
$ 
$ �����I�
 �I�
 I�
 �I�
 �I�
	
	I �	
	
 �H �H �H �H �$�$�$�$�$
 �
 �
 �
 �
�@��@��@��@��@�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�	� �I� �I�H I� �I�$A �AA �H$H IA �AA �	�	$	�	 �@$�@�	�	$	�	�A �	�A �	�A �	�A �	�A �$�	�$�	�$�	�$�	�$�I @�I @�I @�I @�I @ 
$�H 
$�H 
$�H 
$�H 
$� 
$ 
$ 
$ 
$ �����I�
 �I�
 �	$�
 �I�
 �I�
	
	
�	
	
 �H �H �
�H �H �$�$�$�$�$
 �
 �
 �
 �
�@��@��@��@��@�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$�$�	$���
���


?jg��
���


?jg��%



!1AQaq�𑡱������


?
P zz���A8�Q�<#,@�\A�.$r>
��=Q��p@1

���v �{���t���T59k�W���R	�M�؇	"%_������%�����p+��*OW�h'�='�e�k�;�ĎG�^���>5R��n!��?��!��p�0�X�ꆧ-p
����A0	���$@��8�#��R���@3[.|
p@����
�QG����a�q|����+���Gƪ_�-��4T�$1؂�a���KXB}P��
^^?1H&
7[b$���\Dvs
C[8@��fke���.�==_`A��P
(��� U� �9{����K�� �����D�;P=�Pú	`KO����+���)�&�lC�����k���aHkg�@L�l������4�
E��2��
����G#�{C��~@��P�H��b

��jwA,	a	�CS��yx�����
��C�mK��8���`0�O�3��b)�=��8P[1l���	k-��`ET��t8+���0��>p��Q+`�����,
��0�)l�8vԼ]S����8�!����c���˯~�����=G�UN�]A3��
�
ʎS�
�E�	�|�:�����
��C�mK��8���`0�O�3��b)�=��8P[1l���	k-��`ET��t8+���0��>p��Q+`�����,
��0�)l�8vԼ]S����8�!����c���˯~�����=G�UN�]A3��
�
ʎS�
�E�	�|�:�����
��C�mK��8���`0�O�3��b)�=��8P[1l���	k-��`ET��t��X����:���cE��B�Y>c
y�"b�t`�+C�_)sW��BH]�����A���r�L�=y���`uX�=p*��:���
�732�H+>�0a��������Qf���O��^{���] 
��W�
\����l/�fPmh���<^oqvXF5�\
��N����@cM��L���
ϥ�h룫�x61�_ل+ 5��0מ�!�*F�=���5{=D$���Z;*4�כ�]�Q��c�¯�S�0(:P�s1S �-t���c:����
�u�a
�
d��5簈y��т�e|@��^�Q	!v����e֎�ʍ3����e��acX��0����
�4��T�0] ��X����:���cE��B�Y>c
y�"b�t`�+C�_)sW��BH]�����A���r�L�=y������_�f,[X�G�e?��� 
��֥PQ]�
4{MK�<?8�G���ЋX�n�76�Ol]��+�
g��u�P
�b2�0?�0�����
��O��"�H�f�5�TWsM�R�� Qù�����4"�.[��͸��~5
��C@@��.}
�bX����
��/���bŵ�|@yS�!�� ��jU��G�Ը@��p�a��~y
����ssn$��ߍB�;����6xK�_@u�#(��C�s�~1��m`
A��B/$�n�Z�AEw0��5.���;�xߞCB-b�\�ۉ=�w�P��t0t
����@%��,|�����_�f,[X�G�e?��� 
��֥PQ]�
4{MK�<?8�G���ЋX�n�7&M�"<B�	�!��F(b�z/�;X Eq�6�p(�X��ܤ��Q$���KR��Y�'L�U�p����N��
e� MB4ۖ�b?]����<�X�C��
E
b�&�T�HP�dn�z�Ż���00*��0�#�k�2%��рe��D74���

�D����B�@ÁM���� ,]�my�I��D��ʣ/
��@("0��lA�A
L����
$�`�I3�V�w$��Ŕň���
9
H��F%�U�������"�*�61�>�y2��Ӟ\��BbC�
�fv2��x��E#jR�
FBO��P��U�{ə1
@	�V�;3�+#Q�$���(���`
U���s����8�O�IP1�R��1H˯��R�1�
 b0�Xx�\�Y!�	Y�� �;� B��P96"�W6a@TS��x�P��Z� R�
O�nIrDH
���<z�`��d�K���+P2 R�. 5�|�6!X
��K���.I愻6,����p���!u���%�c�i�E4&L��dX(@�j�@�!   
#��j�`� `F�_
H���̤�Q(QX�������b�Wj)�\U����6
OL@���Kj�0(��rk��P �a���(��<�-l���#l�o��`��pH�x���j W��0�Xx�\�Y#�?������[�Pf
B~���D2��W����a~�lPFM�j3
po̑rA���3b<"A	�@42���@�CvЈ9�P�	���i1.��Y �X ��@#��DM�#�<�0o ��=B�W�L�����Q��!ʼn�SD2���
E�%�R���,G&N��4�!�������Qo)YPt_���R%ư��,�!�@R	2����$P�0�H(@��}��� H!�a�Q%��M!@�O�>|ř�a��

 �Lc ��J�PV&	��%�@���b��!��[=������(���ӣ��x�P���i[�,�LW�!�����F7
3T��^�����,B���KIdD�<�I!���TFX;G�Hl;H@��E
���ܹ�0��а7>�R���
"�# 
@T��S�P!�"``�GTr
���a
�IZ(P^L#cu#5��30�
���
n���21�
�y��Vmy›
$J��0��#dV��$�AH@�PX��dH�
�
Q �fg�#��Li�#��
��[i�!�A�8�m�>!�!`�
* �h�r�ؿPQK�1(�$����F�G�H�� s��k#�wO��R�������dB�	��B�،�
z�"������do�w��t��A�pF�Ca���c�a`c�^M\�+�� ��+�e�,�`H@%4�܁�,A�K�{ѡ
��A��K2VśY[��
@"�D@�ãԫ���X�j���Z�oV��	@XD�E$k�%�^N9x�}�I5P��&�dv!�)a�IA�E�D����
%�`k��	

�%��(&��´d�	/D��i%^�c
�F��l�$�NK"����a������IJD1D ю���VJȖ$�U瞌C|J�@0� %��H�A��lsn
ϭ�26�'E	0�f
!�a��*J��*�lY���?$
�H
1�w`��XX+Pj�\l1ύ��xB"�
n���`i"/(��B�,-@���Ss]Aa��A��	��v����
��������VF0?�e @!@Áx��h���
B:1��INJ5�D
2 kc����3f"* b�	�'o	V,M�J�Y,C
E�@�LcҢ%�����]9�b��$Q ^U�Ԑ��ߓ9!��P&���R�W�A1j�J�����i��Z΄H���F��
�m2�
[$#�,��B�Q;�5h` P���@lV@�@#`�lq�$4"��"�$`l"tPxkY6��‚��
��$
��Vuj@Ѣ4L��p��������^`Q$�@-t�'���a�P�ˊ��d�E�*�DpE*
I���
'�����ߵ�n`YZ��8ޜ?�`!r�.@���l֌=B�Ԫ�o�@7Z;�Yg#��0�&?�x���.aC�\��H�� �:~�J�J�(E�G_f=��*`lu>b�0��c�| )Bl��?�`!r�.@���l֌=B�Ԫ�o�@7Z;�Yg#��0�&?�x���.aC�\��H�� �:~�J�J�(E�G_f=��*`lu>b�0���#�m������(b��	l�h�� ��J�&�Dq��U�r>��Rc�w�����:u������@s��ī���„X$u�cߨ���P��)#��̲8ޜ?�`!r�.@���l֌=B�Ԫ�o�@7Z;�Yg#��0�&?�x���.aC�\��H�� �:~�J�J�(E�G_f=��*`lu>b�0���#�m������(b��	l�h�� ��J�&�Dq��U�r>��Rc�w�����:u�����/+�_C�Ĉ�
�>��a�&GO����^����f�Β��_ک���h�v�*gP��aH����X��@9#��;���,	t�(�Xm�.��h�9�/+�_C�Ĉ�
�>��a�&GO����^����f�Β��_ک���h�v�*gP��aH����X��@9#��;���,	t�(�Xm�.��h�9�/+�_C�Ĉ�
�>��a�&GO����^����f�Β��_ک���h�v�*gP��aH����X��@9#��;���,	t�(�Xm�.��h�9�/+�_C�Ĉ�
�>��a�&GO����^����f�Β��_ک���h�v�*gP��aH����X��@9#��;���,	t�(�Xm�.��h�9�/+�_C�Ĉ�
�>��a�&GO����^����f�Β��_ک���h�v�*gP��aH����X��
	�,?�|�k$��{!c� ����>��U p!"�'��z��ui��#�*�}�(�����g�d�w��~�bV+d�I�v���3U�qƸ0q����y.0�3����Ζ��b>a��`g=��Ő�@�CF�I]�
*�8�]��=`Ӻ�����~>ЀKut��3��|���?
�1+�`$�;@CP���8�\8Ё�Ix��l����BgK��10��03��X��
G ~��O��ƀ�HH����x��i�Z`H�
�h@
%��~g�Y>]�c������0b��!�L�vq�h@�x$�^K�6��q��3������md��d,qd��?Pѧ�Wc@J�$WD��<BX4�?�$u_�� �]?3��,�.�1��@��J�l�	1@���&j�8�4 C�^/%��|���Й����G�6�L�8�
Q��h��+��%R+�~a�!�wV��:�����n����O�z��� }�%b�Aˑ[?p��`�l���[��?R|�<��]�����S�i'�x �܇5�������ÕP��ըo��FE��V��p�4Y�wa�9�?��,���t-o�\������g�"�v���������f����B�I<c�f�9��@�ଯ�gn�����C��0,g����#�1�"�ۻ�����Qe�0e�k~�r�V�� -�.�> �ð/O��.0%�k4��#���I��7!�n����e~C;p�T<5uj�~�рc8��q9�
v��g�v粋,�([���"�~�
l�v����z~ ��py�,�Y��y����O�@Y�ku��58++�ۇ*�᫫P��������$+���h����>s�=�YgL@�Z߬���f�ψ8E����'˃�	e��'�����>�xǂ:��s[�>8���Y_���9U
]Z��_�4`X�m�F���dn��9���kE_���;i�^�E�U������a����c*[\�Q��
_��pP{T��ʬB��H�=sB�4}3d�z=P ��.�@7���(�%~�:r�����-�w�#�QW����y׫QB(U{q&�?��C�t��m��ʖ�)�s�—�)�\�"!r�����*\СE
L�=C�T7���
�:y�J'�_�Μ�iz<FF��c���ưTU�}}���u��P�^�AɿO�9P�/hG��2���u�����|��H�\�� n,䊃�4(QCG�6APǣ�
���8�p��R��W��)^�������1�_`���z�"�W�ro���T9�K���}��mr�G?�)|r�%�A�R"*��9"���
P��͐C�1��@�0�!�#��Ԣ|��<��F���dn��9���kE_���;i�^�E�U������a����c*[\�Q��
_��pP{T��ʬB��H�N���T����ސ��.���
V��q�� ��a˞*�h�E׊�4y(���G��Ll�
n��kC�� �����r]=�Z)c��
��Ƈ1e�&bw��B��gw􅰕P�w�G�x�
���$���\�V��ER.�V�� �E�=n`�d u���Z�!,|�u�� ����K@8] 
M49��/�3�/*/k;���-���˼<;��U�}m� ��'Xr犷�*�uⷍA
(�5��p�![��Z��1
c䃬���OlV�X�
���jh���D�~I���yP�{Y�ǽ!l%T&]���>��0�o�@?!:×<U�6�T���h�(QG���[��,��}�2և��@$g��8�{b�Rǐ�HSE�b$��L��ʅK���=�a*�2����hA�~H2
�	�������]x��G�AB�<
dz��f�@�����=F�}f(q�K� �DŽ�eGν�l,���*�ɫ:Ԡ uv�.X=<{��@�ϣ"����==��P�k����BM/b���(D�rt=_�AZq3� ��D��/��=�|8�����׼M���0@Y95gZ�
�ۀ���q@h��d_�<:{G��S�
s������I��^���Ѡ��NB·���+N&z��(�E���ǵ/��g��:����:�'&��R��!��p�`���#h
[>���G�Oh���}CA�vc�|?��	4���?�:4�?��Y��=i��P��h��8���l��s2��^�6G@�d�՝jP:�n,�=�m
�Kgё~������O�h5��v���!&��{�F�"�9:�砭8��BԢ`M�b�Ծ
�xN`FT|��&��� �����J�Wm���Ǹ��4	l�2/�=��ߩ�
�َ���{�6����'P���]`,4�q/.ħ�D��ͬs��-9tW���PF��_�`���<�!!'�†�#C#�K-B��A���������&Gt�~���@�=���xm��7U�N���ں�Xh7�8�^04]�O��U!�X�߸Zr,诟�Р��ȿ|��Z
�y�BBO�
�F<�F7�Z.��?��#���;��L�����,	"�{Gz/~��n���C+�u���o�qļ`h����C6�Ͽp� �Y�_?��A��~��������+
 �y<�n
,�]�1G���v��ә��
XE<���^���W�:�Wj�
a��L�x��v%?�%T�mc�~�
hAȳ��B�7/"��h7��		<V6A�y�Yh�/�b<�_����2;�3���$�y����l<1���u����A�����J�J���>��Ѓ�gE|��n^E��
�oC�2x�(l�1�0�1���1t ^!��1D���G+�a�v��(Q���c]��KM��c�(b��>8�*1�������=�
��4���o�6�pD�?ň���3�hL����oѕ
����|rM�BN��XG�v.w ��29^�����@�G��Zn�}�`$e�~.}�+��9��'D˝�����	Z��$vW�۷�c8"�~��Ѝd?�B8ôEC� �
�_��T*�k�������yJ��m���w1��dB��YJ�9
�@ a�$8s�aeP�)@IL,�cG�!��F:������u1'��_����6��&����_���4#Y��cR�ǦZ�O�W*G��|��yfј���F����)%��!��/���p�pZ;QZ
(�y`����%��ޱ�1py�G��r�~Za�tLLI��W�a�}
�	�3� 8��,B2�~j�b��c1�V�ɚ���&�P�=����$0c�#��(b6��#���W�:�
�h�EhP���ƻ#����zǘP���|qTc�	;�S{>��i_Cn��m�����@����
�QG����a�q|����+���Gƪ_�-��4T�$1؂�a���KXB}P��
^^?1H&
7[b$���\Dvs
C[8@��R��g�U��<�a8���
3Ll ����I0�$D��L�D��1�A$�9D�*q���@D�hQ:
����KQ�<�
x��w�0Y�Y��|KZ��2����I`V��\��~a�@�Et���R"8Ƃv�
"�I�p1
� S �B,=08!$�8�΢R�p!
�f�f�j��,UFK�c�Q�ۊ�A
9`��&A��N�B$O�y�����Y3l�����"C�(ᨘ4�
�0�N
0 ��0=�I1��I-՗$@�t
�ƀ[�0��D�/� `.@�)
l�^��<��͛j&�w�	����
{3��61�@ّ�[|����FDT�6j%4rE0��,� A�#`�b^)�WY@�

D�!n 
�((�8B���&��4���@�����K.IZ��L�
�f��H�	W�p5�Gg0�5��	z� &f�\
��
����	���I�`�Z��q#��W��ꏍT� [�
�h��$Hc���5;��������\��~a`،Ɇ�Kd�ö���x��0`�Ԉ�u������?�-��]{��5���?�"�w
�:	��pnTr�8TZ(��C��K������6�� ��~�h��
��M��2��;"ȂOTK�'"�����(v�H�ئ����#�
��2����̔�2
f��0��3�+�4�'3t���{E�x�	J�:eA;� ��bM��5ۨ<
Bd�E@2j�(�"q�>4��� �-�	�Ϸ���TjH0��a��y%	���	���S}B��
���*r���H��yU�13�.pa9&X\�jĭ�#'�qC
WU�K^�Al.|¢(l���O��nQ�˥�d�@��g!(p�7�`aG��Q+`��JX�C1`��72E�d-EA��n���́�q�B(��I�qHD��\	�hT
pMH"�BP9�J��D
��Ȝ��S�
�a�I),,Q��Jg�mvQ�$�0��c���m惀@�[�ٗ���!0�X �Tr�8TZ(��Mc�
����̘o��J;j^.�Ǐ�
�
}H��[�L	��б���ًe׿pHCYl��*�p����g��4u��׼�/�����k�a��
Z���K����B�����
���g����.���Ʊ�aW�)՘(i����`�AY���
tuu��:��0�d�|���D<�B��V��� R�g����c�}�2�kG`�_�c"A�@]�Q��c�¯�S�0(:P�s1S �-t���c:����
�u�a
�
d��5簈y��т�e|A<k�L��%�B�����
���g����.���Ʊ�aW�)՘(i����`�AY���
tuu��:��0�d�|���D<�B��V��� R�g����c�}�2�kG`�F��z�{����0��z�U�
ufJnf*d��V},`�G]]{������!Y
��1���1P�0@�쯈����!$.��_|̠���9Q�x���Na/�3-��#�2��E�
��kR�(���=����@��s���hE�\�k��q'�.�j�������\:��ı@��Ә_��ŋk�����By$@3uԪ
+��&�i�p���(�������k-����I틿�`wC��� l����1,FP
c������c1b��> <�)��^I�F�*���`	��j\ 
���
8w0���<��Z��v���{b�ơX��`�<%ï�:�K�X��!�9����X���� ��!�@7Q�J����h���x~q��<?��!��rݮnmĞػ�Vt::�	p����e>`Na/�3-��#�2��E�
��kR�(���=����@��s���hE�\�k��&�!D��I�_�
1J�����"��F��*5���
Y���+������D�@�O�a��\�������޻�\!�~�H��͘P�`+�xT<�ʺw�A��~���"h�y$�/х
�^�����\u��`��K�����s���]���pH�x���j W��0�Xx�\�Yf�B���]�.��G�Xj��(j0�<*Le]
�� �ɿDG�B
4D<�~�…R�E��`�k�:�Ѱ���F%��eVG���Ů���$h<A��5+��A�<W�y��t!c|���|_��,5sf5
�&2�����bdߢ#�!��"I?�aB�)W��C�p��Wah��EF��2�+#��~b�ewt\4 �蚈��
 �+��<�Y�

���{�u��>/����
�r
��W@n��12o���@M$���0�C��~!�8Z�+���l
~��Q�q��@��z�1k���.	w�MD
����k��k$r#�����:��p��(A����H�]��sG���?��� pW��hkt>�����ʉw�p!�G��g� ��`���P��*�
����#��LS��p�!����M��G":�o�����(����e�Y�4x��S��bx~���C�k�ܨ�~��q����&y��
��
x2�0�/oB?��=���w���	��܄r#�����:��p��(A����H�]��sG���?��� pW��hkt>�����ʉw�p!�G��g� ��`���P��*�
����#��LS��p�!����M��G":�o�����(����e�Y�4x��S��bx~���C�k�ܨ�~��q����&y��
��
x2�0�/oB?��=���w���	��܄r#�����:��p��(A����H�]��sG���?��� pW��hkt>�����ʉw�p!�G��g� ��`���P�|;���X�דW$
�a�
�A&�����A���D���^�nk��<
�+:@@�{���;��P)����$� �g�\QQ�ȁ���4���0��zx��������Ǿ��� W@�	0<W��h��H��Z$�@��Ss]N1�@��Y���FN���oځN�0,�A'a�<�⊎��&D
l��ŕ��c��6�&8F=������bI��&�E%bG D"� �jע���q�D�J·P(��2t��~�
u��ej	;<Y�TtD
2 kc��&,�� 3�!��wy1�0�1�&�H����L�5Z)(�9!��P&���S�x'�Vt:��D�Q��v?���S��+PI�A��0���� 	�[�i1e~a
���
�ûɎ���}y5r@�6��`x����ID���H?��5�溜c��?R���
'�����ߵ�n`YZ��8ޜ?�`!r�.@���l֌=B�Ԫ�o�@7Z;�Yg#��0�&?�x���.aC�\��H�� �:~�J�J�(E�G_f=��*`lu>b�0���#�m������(b��	l�h�� ��J�&�Dq��U�r>��Rc�w�����:u������@s��ī���„X$u�cߨ���P��)#��̲8ޜ?�`!r�.@���l֌=B�Ԫ�o�@7Z;�Yg#��0�&?�x���.aC�\��H�� �:~�J�J�(E�G_f=��*`lu>b�0���#�m������(b��	l�h�� ��J�&�Dq��U�r>��Rc�w�����:u������@s��ī���„X$u�cߨ���P��)#��̲8ޜ?�`!r�.@���l֌=B�Ԫ�o�@7Z;�Yg#��0�&?�x���.aC�\��H��b�5�:\H�����&dt��OI������?n&l��)@U���0����go��u����i���5��D�9���!N�b���O�B��05���ዾƇ�Øb�5�:\H�����&dt��OI������?n&l��)@U���0����go��u����i���5��D�9���!N�b���O�B��05���ዾƇ�Øb�5�:\H�����&dt��OI������?n&l��)@U���0����go��u����i���5��D�9���!N�b���O�B��05���ዾƇ�Øb�5�:\H�����&dt��OI������?n&l��)@U���0����go��u����i���5��D�9���!N�b���O�B��05���ዾƇ�Øb�5�:\H�����&dt��OI������?n&l��)@U���0����go��u����i���5���Й����G�6�L�8�
Q��h��+��%R+�~a�!�wV��:�����n����O�z��� }�%b�L��Ghj5]�k�!�	/��
�s>_�phL�a���#�Y&s�Y�(��4i������	�?0���
;�O�	AW��
D�WO��?�'˽Lc�>��[&LP#�5	��Î5�������q����/�84&t��|C�
��9셎,�@r�4�J�h	T����蟘g�A��է��������[���q�œ�ަ1�q�X��
&(���Wa���Ƅw�K���`\ϗ�:X~>!����I���B�@ 
9�
}%v4�@�BEtO�3� ��N���GPU��BQ-���8�����S��ĬVɀ��

Bf���p`�B;�%��\a�.g���
	�,?�|�k$��{!c� ����>��U p!"�'��z��ui��#�*�}�(�����g�d�w��~�bV+d���f�ψ8E����'˃�	e��'�����>�xǂ:��s[�>8���Y_���9U
]Z��_�4`X�m�!\Gc@E��v����:`�B��`�ȭ��@[0]�|A�-�`^��)>\`K.�i?�G��)�4��<
�nC��q��
N
���v�ʨxj��7��
�"�p+n	
�8s,���Ϝ��eY�P:��.El��ق���l;��AI���Yv�I��?�!O���1���r�돎 jpVW�3�UC�WV����

3�[pHWØ�gm݆|�`�{(�Θ2�е�X9r+g��m�p�a���
O��˵�O���a
|
$�u���\|qS���!��r���
��@h���
ۂB��ƀ�;n�3�;��E�t������ˑ[?p��`�l���[��?R|�<��]�����S�i'�x �܇5�������ÕP��ըo��FE��Vܤiz<FF��c���ưTU�}}���u��P�^�AɿO�9P�/hG��2���u�����|��H�\�� n,䊃�4(QCG�6APǣ�
���8�p��R��W��)^�������1�_`���z�"�W�ro���T9�K���}��mr�G?�)|r�%�A�R"*��9"���
P��͐C�1��@�0�!�#��Ԣ|��<��F���dn��9���kE_���;i�^�E�U������a����c*[\�Q��
_��pP{T��ʬB��H�=sB�4}3d�z=P ��.�@7���(�%~�:r�����-�w�#�QW����y׫QB(U{q&�?��C�t��m��ʖ�)�s�—�)�\�"!r�����*\СE
L�=C�T7���
�:y�J'�_�Μ�iz<FF��c���ưTU�}}���u��P�^�AɿO�9P�/hG��2���u�����|��H�\�� n,���ʅK���=�a*�2����hA�~H2
�	�������]x��G�AB�<
dz��f�@�����=BX� �=<A�%����<�p>�@�,hs&_�f'|^T*^�wq�H[	U	�xxw���@�8��A��N���n
�U"��o<�
Q�k#��&6B�_n���b��Y��9.�ح�������cC��2��1;��R����zB�J�L��#ü|Z�a�ߒ�~Bu�.x�pm��^+x��P��Y�
0Y���pe�C�>H:�Oq�t��h�� �����I�䙉��
����{��UBe�
��*�>�6��d��9s�[�mH��[Ə ��x���	�͐�-�ۃ-hz���A�zx��K��+E,y�}t�54X��"L�$�N���T����ސ��.���
V��q�� ��a˞*�h�E׊�4y(���G��Ll�
n��kC��`M�b�Ծ
�xN`FT|��&��� �����J�Wm���Ǹ��4	l�2/�=��ߩ�
�َ���{�$��/`�����@��!gC����=BZ�L	���P�ڗ�A��	�ʏ�{��YU��Vu�@@���\�zx���-�FE�#ç�z{�>���;1�>�x��^���P���,�z�����g�AR��4_Y�{R�6q�9�Q�x�#�`�
�rjε(]��O�6��%��ȿDxt��O~��4�f;����Kؽ����@
����W��V�L�!jQ0&��1C�j_
�<'0#*>u�adt
VNMY֥
C���
r����F��}���������\��`�=�i{�pth
B S�����z
Ӊ��-J&�}f(q�K� �DŽ�eGν�l,���*�ɫ:Ԡ uv�.X=<{��@�ϣ"����==��P�k����Cl<1���u����A�����J�J���>��Ѓ�gE|��n^E��
�oC�2x�(l�1�0�1���1t ^!��y�?��,�dwNg�P)`I��;�{���xcu_��]����}3�%�Eؔ�ȕR��}���"Ί��
ܼ����އ�d$$�XP�c�a�cp	e�b�@�C��0�=~S�X����ޠR��(�w���
���꿉�02�WX
�gK���)��*�3k��BE���:�y�0+A�0�HIⰡ�ǐ�����@�Ёx��a�z���`�?���9��@��$P#�h�E��`
���`ev��
��8��
bS�"UHf�9����:+��t(#r�/�0`V�za����aCd�!����%������ �����N�`#�s?z�KH�G��ދ߼6����'P���]`,4�q/.ħ�D��ͬs��-9tW���PF��_�`���<�!!'�†�#C#�K-B��C�M�\dr�
�Gj+B�%�,5��ݠ��<†.3��PpI�_�:������J�v�lg@p/��X�����c1�V�ɚ���&�P�=����$0c�#��(b6��#���W�:�
�h�EhP���ƻ#����zǘP���|qTc�	;�S{>��i_Cn��m�����#B5���f5*Й3S��$ߣ*G��|��~Du<�F�6�qq���X@8-��
�z<�X�dp�v��X�
�<ώ#ʌuA�'a �bOg¿s
+�m��M��
���bhF��
�ƥZ&js�d��eB���o����Ȏ�����&؎.29^�����@�G��Zn�}�aC���yQ��8$�/�LI��W�a�}
�	�3� 8��,@��C��1�ԫBd�Nwl�~��U����1���1D���G+�a�v��(Q���c]��KM��c�(b��>8�*1�������=�
��4���o�6�pD�?ň�@��}��q@(��xFX0�V���\H�|�hz��U/���b*�	�A@0�
C�%�,!>�jr��/�����DJ�Ӂ�";9�!�� K�

35��W�T��� �N(zO�*�wˉ����T|j���CE@a"C�(�a��%�'�
NZ�����`u�!�H�	W�p5�Gg0�5��	z� &f�\
��
����	���I�q�P" �PÀ�m�Q#��W��ꏍT� [�玉��.
}�Ad�{���t���T59k�W���R	�M�؇	"%_������%�����p+��*OW�h'�='�e�k�;�ĎG�^���>5R��n!��?��!��p�0�X�ꆧ-p
����A0	���$@��8�#��R���@3[.|
p@����
�QG����a�q|����+���Gƪ_�-��4T�$1؂�a���KXB}P��
^^?0��Fd�|��P��R�uN<`0S�D�:؄
`OGh~����[.���B�`��U;�t�
�87*9O�*-J�&����~�fL7�[%�/T���
��>�@���@��v��X��AlŲ�߸$!��Q��S�WA�L�Ãp�r���a¢�D��k8�0��Fd�|��͊�nA��і��Չ	$��n7*	4!A�EFr�2?�(	KK
�h�K�~�e"Phn�J

vA�`hp�;���+�"�w
�:	��pnTr�8TZ(��Mc�
����̘o��J;j^.�Ǐ�
�
}H��[�L	��б���ًe׿pHCYl��*�p�����]���G)�ÅE��[�>p~a`،Ɇ�Kd�ö���x��0`�Ԉ�u������?�-��]{��5���?�"�w
�:V},`�G]]{������!Y
��1���1P�0@�쯈����!$.��_|̠���9Q�x����:�,k�}Y�AҀƛ���
k��K0��GW^�lc���V@k'�a�=�C�T.�h{+�.j�z�I�?��3(6�vTi��7��,�Ǯ
�_p�V`Pt�1��b�A�Z�g��4u��׼T������W9af�XM�Px��ѿ�딎�G��]�8T� �T3�{MI"
1%�O
�
�Y��!2L� Q t%F��z�{����0��z�U�
ufJnf*d��V},`�G]]{������!Y
��1���1P�0@�쯈����!$.��_|̠���9Q�x����:�,k�}Y�AҀƛ���
k��K0��GW^�lc���V@k'�a�=�C�T.�h{+�.j�z�I�?��3(6�vTi��7�Ә_��ŋk�����By$@3uԪ
+��&�i�p���(�������k-����I틿�`wC��� l����1,FP
c������c1b��> <�)��^I�F�*���`	��j\ 
���
8w0���<��Z��v���{b�ơX��`�<%ï�:�K�X��!�9����X���� ��!�@7Q�J����h���x~q��<?��!��rݮnmĞػ�Vt::�	p����e>`Na/�3-��#�2��E�
��kR�(���=����@��s���hE�\�k��q'�.�j�������\:��ı@��Ә_��ŋk�����By$@3uԪ
+��&�i�p���(�������k-����ɿDG�B
4D<�~�…R�E��`�k�:�Ѱ���F%��eVG���Ů���$h<A��5+��A�<W�y��t!c|���|_��,5sf5
�&2�����bdߢ#�!��"I?�aB�)W��C�p��Wah��EF��2�+#��~b�ewt\4 �蚈��
 �+��<�Y�

���{�u��>/����
�r
��W@n��12o���@M$���0�C��~!�8Z�+���l
~��Q�q��@��z�1k���.	w�MD
����k��k,���X�=�����
\م
F��CɌ��7��7��B &���O��P��U��-`��XZ6�QQ�ĸ�̠
��=_���]���;�&�z}@C5�����5�n�@d,o���b���zE��l†�
\�¡��U���L��Dx�!DC�'�~�(P�*�_�v�@��-_���b\o�Pd{���Z�F���Q�>�!���pz����� u�N��B�"�0
x��~fR!�}f�㯩O�/�a�������dcsr�]�\kQ�F��x��H?�7`>)�ʼ¤d���������0HC��&wrȎ��[��{�-�(3��?G�e"w�a�:�����f��^�������F77*%ߥ���do�w��t��A�pF�B���*FK�Џ��1O{p|��>~:�a7w!��� u�N��B�"�0
x��~fR!�}f�㯩O�/�a�������dcsr�]�\kQ�F��x��H?�7`>)�ʼ¤d���������0HC��&wrȎ��[��{�-�(3��?G�e"w�a�:�����f��^�������F77*%ߥ���do�w��t��A�pF�B���*FK�Џ��1O{p|��>~:�a7w!��� u�N��B�"�0
x��~fR!�}f�㯩O�/�a�������dcsr�]�\kQ�F��x��H?�7`>6�&8F=������bI��&�E%bG D"� �jע���q�D�J·P(��2t��~�
u��ej	;<Y�TtD
2 kc��&,�� 3�!��wy1�0�1�&�H����L�5Z)(�9!��P&���S�x'�Vt:��D�Q��v?���S��+PI�A��0���� 	�[�i1e~a
���
�ûɎ���}y5r@�6��`x����ID���H?��5�溜c��?R���
'�����ߵ�n`YZ�N�y��L���#I�+�ǧ�l>�Lp�,{�ɫ�q��� ��|MV�J Ď@�E�A��	�E75������� Q=�d������s��vx��.(��d@���LY_�@f=<Ca���c�a`c�^M\�+�� ��+�j�RQ$rB-�Mz)���� OԬ�u
��'@���@�[�V�,���û�\���$-�5�P�:5*���
�V���VY���@1I���.:�K�P��(vR>��
����
`��ُ~���C����/C�2��[zp�;������1B�
�Z0�#�R�I�Q�Ehx�e��������������r�e#���>���*�
(p�	}���(����8��H��?s,���û�\���$-�5�P�:5*���
�V���VY���@1I���.:�K�P��(vR>��
����
`��ُ~���C����/C�2��[zp�;������1B�
�Z0�#�R�I�Q�Ehx�e��������������r�e#���>���*�
(p�	}���(����8��H��?s,���û�\���$-�5�P�:5*���
�V���VY���@1I���.:�K�P��(vR>���
}�#l8 ��	�ę>���paz� otOۉ�':JPj�Log�9�����x
�@.���#�k���c��b4D�S���,%����L
a�G��bﱡ���
�S\H���cVL&A��=^	DYI�80�b7�'��͓�%(
���R&
�7������T,��h�L6�8�1HE"�	�^���k+�!N�b���O�B��05���ዾƇ�Øb�5�:\+���ъ
���L>$�������!{�~�L�9�R���U"`�u�
E����X����u����i���5�����@5�B��k`
��cu"qT��Xm�.��h�9�/+�_C�Ĉ�
�>��a�&GO����^����>��. 	M�x�fl�4��@����f�5��A�4{;x�ls�*��p�˾U��D�9���!N�b���O�B��05���ዾƇ�Øb�5�:\H�����&dt��OI������?n&l��)@U���0����go��u����i���5���Й����G�6�L�8�
Q��h��+��%R+�~a�!�wV��:�����n����O�z��� }�%b�L��Ghj5]�k�!�	/��
�s>_�h����j����@b)D�
̔��G QcQp箤`!
�����A�X����0�J8�P&b�~u@
%��~g�Y>]��ap�@U�a�(�AD4Gb��1PO�U��rm��X�C�KU�NJ��������5t^�#.�Ma
f鸕��� ��bC�s�/uv��`
hPO,��ГA,B0�
���0rX'7ȁ�ŝ�	AW��>Q��@�2@����4c������}��0���F���:m��/T��E�V�.`b��P���]$��DE��vL�e������`X�Y��.#P6y<`4�J�h	T����蟙���P: I� uݰ���|�@�9�l�3��|���Ұ�[�1Z��9S�J`$�;@CP���8�\8Ё�Ix��l����BgK��10��03��X��
G ~��O��ƀ�HH����x��i�Z`H�
�h@
%��~g�Y>]�c������.El��ق���l;��AI���Yv�I��?�!O���1���r�돎 jpVW�3�UC�WV����

3�[pHWØ�gm݆|�`�{(�Θ2�е�X��sܸ-�"�0X��s%CPY;t1$�T��� �,�B���.�t�KJ��(
�Q�i�Ȗ�Hr��h�2!ʨxj��)�O��� x;�u(3�`��F�tFų��*P�P#2F�fax�@��$4H\���{�i
�i
�0�X��h��"4�uQdk=Ԅp�DQL��$vbI.�X(e�d��8�P�_C�|H�������oE�6��p`�M
�
3�[q�@M)����*#���/:r�e�h�A*&0g2bN@F42FX:pyd"$���eb�k$&7F�	7�@`D$0�
�20Ek���AA%�k4��#���B:�M��<;����� ��ĚNlpdJc�z��Q(��Edk�� �m�\�8�&
��qfl&h��#@E��v����:`�B��`�ȭ��@[0]�|A�-�`^��)>\`K.�i?�G��)�4��<
�nC��q��
N
���v�ʨxj��7��
�"�p+nR4�##w����cX**�>���O:�j(E
�n �ߧ���s��
���R��:��R��>K��ڤD.Ub7rEA�(��� ��c���apB
�GO?�D�+�yӊ�zozQ�
#D�����RD�Ĉ=+�%y;v�$�`ǀY�&Y�j�T�M��d��jM�-QŠ'&ʩH��@	�\��e$�d� /�S�.uh�bvHp`��84@jckn@�"lnÚ'���8Y"
X��JDHd
$`��Lj0$A������	^(JF���jݶ���@����lUDf:�$���D
`u
�t���I$�I$�jb��l�Tbt�J�a	D=�l%d	$�$�ɘ���$6��.�h���tqg$�O�*%^d�z=Q���L�
�(�d\2%�`�|����ڀ:p�<	$��Vl��fdM�8%�3h��@o�c6%u"
�QB(U{pI
멩�H�2 �},	�2A4)g\҄r\��� �L�"Y"�q&��e��@ �tK&�(H��N��l��z�=�o�
� �t���O��G�9H��x��ߖ�;��`�����m<�ը�*����~��r��:^�6���eKk��9�aK��.
j��U�@�Y����
����{��UBe�
��*�>�6��d��9s�[�mH��[Ə ��x���	�͐�-�ۃ-hz���A�zx��K��+E,y�}t�54X��"L�$�N���T����ސ��.���
V��q�� ��a˞*�h�E׊�4y(���G��Ll�
n��kC�� �����r]=�Z)c��
��Ƈ1e�&bw��B��gw􅰕P�w�G�x�
���$���\�V��ER.�V�� �E�=n`�d u���Z�!,|�u�� ����K@8] 
M49��/�3�/*/k;���-���˼<;��U�}m� ��'Xr犷�*�uⷍA
(�5��p�![��Z��1
c䃬���OlV�X�
���jh���D�~I���yP�{Y�ǽ!l%T&]���>��0�o�@?!:×<U�6�T���h�(QG���[��,��}�2և����/��=�|8�����׼M���0@Y95gZ�
�ۀ���q@h��d_�<:{G��S�
s������I��^���Ѡ��NB·���+N&z��(�E���ǵ/��g��:����:�'&��R��!��p�`���#h
[>���G�Oh���}CA�vc�|?��	4���?�:4�?��Y��=i��P��h��8���l��s2��^�6G@�d�՝jP:�n,�=�m
�Kgё~������O�h5��v���!&��{�F�"�9:�砭8��BԢ`M�b�Ծ
�xN`FT|��&��� �����J�Wm���Ǹ��4	l�2/�=��ߩ�
�َ���{�$��/`�����@��!gC����=BZ�L	���P�ڗ�A��	�ʏ�{��YU��Vu�@@���\�zx���-�FE�#ç�z{�>���;1�>�x��xcu_��]����}3�%�Eؔ�ȕR��}���"Ί��
ܼ����އ�d$$�XP�c�a�cp	e�b�@�C��0�=~S�X����ޠR��(�w���
���꿉�02�WX
�gK���)��*�3k��BE���:�y�0+A�0�HIⰡ�ǐ�����@�Ёx��a�z���`�?���9��@��$P#�h�E��`
���`ev��
��8��
bS�"UHf�9����:+��t(#r�/�0`V�za����aCd�!����%������ �����N�`#�s?z�KH�G��ދ߼6����'P���]`,4�q/.ħ�D��ͬs��-9tW���PF��_�`���<�!!'�†�#C#�K-B��A���������&Gt�~���@�=���xm��7U�N���ں�Xh7�8�^04]�O��U!�X�߸Zr,诟�Р��ȿ|��Z
�y�BBO�
�F<�F7�Z.��?��#h�b8���z� ��V�J=X,k�8	i�A��y�\g��F:������u1'��_����6��&����_���4#Y��cR�	�59ݲM�2�T{_7ώH`��GS�P�mlG�@u���ڊР	G���vG
-7h>��0������<��Tv��$�|+�0Ҿ�ݿ����� F�k!�`�jU�2f�;�I�FT*�k�������yJ��m���#����pZ;QZ
(�y`����%��ޱ�1py�G�ꃂN��A�Ğυ~�W�۷�c8"�~��Ѝd?��J�&L��v�7�ʅQ�|�>9!��O)C�M�\dr�
�Gj+B�%�,5��ݠ��<†.3��PpI�_�:������J�v�lg@p/��X�����c1�V�ɚ���&�P�=����$0c�#��(b6��#���W�:�
�h�EhP���ƻ#����zǘP���|qTc�	;�S{>��i_Cn��m�����@����
�QG����a�q|����+���Gƪ_�-��4T�$1؂�a���KXB}P��
^^?1H&
7[b$���\Dvs
C[8@��fke���.�==_`A��P
(��� U� �9{����K�� �����D�;P=�Pú	`KO����+���)�&�lC�����k���aHkg�@L�l������4�
E��2��
����G#�{C��~@��P�H��b

��jwA,	a	�CS��yx�� ��m�p� U��
q��)
l�^�	������@��}��q@(��xFX0�V���\H�|�hz��U/���b*�	�A@0�
C�%�,!>�jr��/�����DJ�Ӂ�";9�!�� K�

35��W�T��� �N(zO�*�wˉ����T|j���CE@a"C�(�a��%�'�
NZ����~�fL7�[%�/T���
��>�@���@��v��X��AlŲ�߸$!��Q��S�WA�L�Ãp�r���a¢�D��k8�0��Fd�|��P��R�uN<`0S�D�:؄
`OGh~����[.���B�`��U;�t�
�87*9O�*-J�&����~�fL7�[%�/T���
��>�@���@��v��X��AlŲ�߸$!��Q��S�WA�L�Ãp�r���a¢�D��k8�0��Fd�|��P��R�uN<`0S�D�:؄
`OGh~����[.���B�`��U;�t�
�87*9O�*-J�&����~�fL7�[%�/T���
��>�@���@��v��X��AlŲ�߸$!��Q��S�WA�B��c:����
�u�a
�
d��5簈y��т�e|@��^�Q	!v����e֎�ʍ3����e��acX��0����
�4��T�0] ��X����:���cE��B�Y>c
y�"b�t`�+C�_)sW��BH]�����A���r�L�=y���`uX�=p*��:���
�732�H+>�0a��������Qf���O��^{���] 
��W�
\����l/�fPmh���<^oqvXF5�\
��N����@cM��L���
ϥ�h룫�x61�_ل+ 5��0מ�!�*F�=���5{=D$���Z;*4�כ�]�Q��c�¯�S�0(:P�s1S �-t���c:����
�u�a
�
d��5簈y��т�e|@��^�Q	!v����e֎�ʍ3����C�s�~1��m`
A��B/$�n�Z�AEw0��5.���;�xߞCB-b�\�ۉ=�w�P��t0t
����@%��,|�����_�f,[X�G�e?��� 
��֥PQ]�
4{MK�<?8�G���ЋX�n�76�Ol]��+�
g��u�P
�b2�0?�0�����
��O��"�H�f�5�TWsM�R�� Qù�����4"�.[��͸��~5
��C@@��.}
�bX����
��/���bŵ�|@yS�!�� ��jU��G�Ը@��p�a��~y
����ssn$��ߍB�;����6xK�_@u�#(��C�s�~1��m`
A��B/$�n�Z�AEw0��5.���;�xߞCB-b�\��7��B &���O��P��U��-`��XZ6�QQ�ĸ�̠
��=_���]���;�&�z}@C5�����5�n�@d,o���b���zE��l†�
\�¡��U���L��Dx�!DC�'�~�(P�*�_�v�@��-_���b\o�Pd{���Z�F���Q�>�!���pz��7@ 27�z�p���="�W6aCQ��A�P�c*�
��&M�"<B�	�!��F(b�z/�;X Eq���/�Tj1.7�(�=�W�-vWwE�#A�����^�P�
a�=s�e���wX�C���a��0���W �y1�t���&�!D��I�_�
1J�����"��F��*5���
Y���+������D�@�O�a��\�������޻�\!�~�H��͘P�`+�xT<�ʺw�A��~���"h�y$�/х
�^�����\u��`��K�����s���]���pH�x���j W��0�Xx�\�Y#�?������[�Pf
B~���D2�Ú<u�)����1��?{C[��5��nnTK�K�
j8��T�<�����…<W�T������b����;�	|�u��n�B9��@�|�O|��E` �G��̤C.��9��_R��_��8+���5�SX�����\�Lt�A�
�Z�"�""ŨH�g:B@�)��
V裦f ��s���N/�Y?�{�`D'�a�E0��u�H�H6� ���ðV�9��n6źp}�w��DaQ�f�
�:�yܑj�
HG+�i�Pd��/L<T4�aA(�L��`�	�� 
�*s�¿A��-Jh��J��
��IAZB0\�@QK�jL�Q+HT � �� �`����X(,"�‘:�P��$iC4�e2HUs��X[�
XH%<�I��-�雮zV��,�"D��4('(G`���@�O�z	e�E+3r�]�\kQ�F��x��H?�7`>)�ʼ¤d���������0HC��&wrȎ��[��{�-�(3��?G�e"w�a�:�����f��^�������F77*%ߥ���do�w��t��A�pF�Ca���c�a`c�^M\�+�� ��+�j�RQ$rB-�Mz)���� OԬ�u
��'@���@�[�V����ŞaqEGD@"�?��b���1���w�#��j�\l1?�$��_U���1#�"h�5k�M�uN��Hb���c�`�R$�B6�*�q��4C��7� 5�!��1z��VXEC���lh�7H+=�h 
���>!�
M$��#K�(����\�$c��*
$���h�	Rf�\�l��
 �0b�Q�ZV���E�
Y!��hA�
7�S6�!b�`�$0�,Q�tl�	�`��H�DB�P` \�h0`HQ�� ��p!�?���4� ��M	���	��b���_�
 
�%�(r5���3�tQ�K����`Ѐ��L
JN�J,��\phA$�1D΁j�`d,4ޔz� D@�@������ Q=�d������s��vx��.(��d@���LY_�@f=<Ca���c�a`c�^M\�+�� ��+�j�RQ$rB-�Mz)���� OԬ�u
��'@���@�[�V�,���û�\���$-�5�P�:5*���
�V���VY���@1I���.:�K�P��(vR>��
����
`��ُ~���C����/C�2��[zp�;������1B�
�Z0�#�R�I�Q�Ehx�))~;T4�~@7#LC8�$@�/��&	����fTX �~ëY 0*�%�m�Đlhp�\��T2;! A*�h2J48�Dab+���	���Hn@�@l
 �P��Q;�Ä�d����]�a34!(�S�����n"�<w��� "ףԶ�
:J�e)��!�m���p�
����ZyP(2�c�p4���kD���R��������P��̀�zg@@a9Я������UЀ��
�DF��dPb��;k�{%�$��lY�JhRg�~$� @�&*TؤLtS"�U�r>��Rc�w�����:u������@s��ī���„X$u�cߨ���P��)#��̲8ޜ?�`!r�.@���l֌=B�Ԫ�o�@7Z;�Yg#��0�&?�x���.aC�\��H��b�5�:\H�����&dt��OI������?n&l��)@U���0����go��u����i���5��D�9���!N�b���O�B��05���ዾƇ�Øb�5�:\H�����&dt��OI������?n&l��)@U���0����go��u����i���5��D�9���!N�b���O�B��05���ዾƇ�Øb�5�:\H�����&dt��OI������?n&l��)@U���0����go��u����i���5��D�9���!N�b���O�B��05���ዾƇ�Øb�5�:\H�����&dt��OI������?n&l��)@U���0����go��u����i���5��D�9���!N�b���O�B��05���ዾƇ�Øb�5�:\H�����&dt��OI������?n&l��)@U���0����go��u����i���5���Й����G�6�L�8�
Q��h��+��%R+�~a�!�wV��:�����n����O�z��� }�%b�L��Ghj5]�k�!�	/��
�s>_�phL�a���#�Y&s�Y�(��4i������	�?0���
;�O�	AW��
D�WO��?�'˽Lc�>��[&LP#�5	��Î5�������q����/�84&t��|C�
��9셎,�@r�4�J�h	T����蟘g�A��է��������[���q�œ�ަ1�q�X��
&(���Wa���Ƅw�K���`\ϗ�:X~>!����I���B�@ 
9�
}%v4�@�BEtO�3� ��N���GPU��BQ-���8�����S��ĬVɀ��

Bf���p`�B;�%��\a�.g���
	�,?�|�k$��{!c� ����>��U p!"�'��z��ui��#�*�}�(�����g�d�w��~�bV+d���f�ψ8E����'˃�	e��'�����>�xǂ:��s[�>8���Y_���9U
]Z��_�4`X�m�!\Gc@E��v����:`�B��`�ȭ��@[0]�|A�-�`^��)>\`K.�i?�G��)�4��<
�nC��q��
N
���v�ʨxj��7��
�"�p+n	
�8s,���Ϝ��eY�P:��.El��ق���l;��AI���Yv�I��?�!O���1���r�돎 jpVW�3�UC�WV����

3�[pHWØ�gm݆|�`�{(�Θ2�е�X9r+g��m�p�a���
O��˵�O���a
|
$�u���\|qS���!��r���
��@h���
ۂB��ƀ�;n�3�;��E�t������ˑ[?p��`�l���[��?R|�<��]�����S�i'�x �܇5�������ÕP��ըo��FE��Vܤiz<FF��c���ưTU�}}���u��P�^�AɿO�9P�/hG��2���u�����|��H�\�� n,䊃�4(QCG�6APǣ�
���8�p��R��W��)^�������1�_`���z�"�W�ro���T9�K���}��mr�G?�)|r�%�A�R"*��9"���
P��͐C�1��@�0�!�#��Ԣ|��<��F���dn��9���kE_���;i�^�E�U������a����c*[\�Q��
_��pP{T��ʬB��H�=sB�4}3d�z=P ��.�@7���(�%~�:r�����-�w�#�QW����y׫QB(U{q&�?��C�t��m��ʖ�)�s�—�)�\�"!r�����*\СE
L�=C�T7���
�:y�J'�_�Μ�iz<FF��c���ưTU�}}���u��P�^�AɿO�9P�/hG��2���u�����|��H�\�� n,���ʅK���=�a*�2����hA�~H2
�	�������]x��G�AB�<
dz��f�@�����=BX� �=<A�%����<�p>�@�,hs&_�f'|^T*^�wq�H[	U	�xxw���@�8��A��N���n
�U"��o<�
Q�k#��&6B�_n���b��Y��9.�ح�������cC��2��1;��R����zB�J�L��#ü|Z�a�ߒ�~Bu�.x�pm��^+x��P��Y�
0Y���pe�C�>H:�Oq�t��h�� �����I�䙉��
����{��UBe�
��*�>�6��d��9s�[�mH��[Ə ��x���	�͐�-�ۃ-hz���A�zx��K��+E,y�}t�54X��"L�$�N���T����ސ��.���
V��q�� ��a˞*�h�E׊�4y(���G��Ll�
n��kC��`M�b�Ծ
�xN`FT|��&��� �����J�Wm���Ǹ��4	l�2/�=��ߩ�
�َ���{�$��/`�����@��!gC����=BZ�L	���P�ڗ�A��	�ʏ�{��YU��Vu�@@���\�zx���-�FE�#ç�z{�>���;1�>�x��^���P���,�z�����g�AR��4_Y�{R�6q�9�Q�x�#�`�
�rjε(]��O�6��%��ȿDxt��O~��4�f;����Kؽ����@
����W��V�L�!jQ0&��1C�j_
�<'0#*>u�adt
VNMY֥
C���
r����F��}���������\��`�=�i{�pth
B S�����z
Ӊ��-J&�}f(q�K� �DŽ�eGν�l,���*�ɫ:Ԡ uv�.X=<{��@�ϣ"����==��P�k����Cl<1���u����A�����J�J���>��Ѓ�gE|��n^E��
�oC�2x�(l�1�0�1���1t ^!��y�?��,�dwNg�P)`I��;�{���xcu_��]����}3�%�Eؔ�ȕR��}���"Ί��
ܼ����އ�d$$�XP�c�a�cp	e�b�@�C��0�=~S�X����ޠR��(�w���
���꿉�02�WX
�gK���)��*�3k��BE���:�y�0+A�0�HIⰡ�ǐ�����@�Ёx��a�z���`�?���9��@��$P#�h�E��`
���`ev��
��8��
bS�"UHf�9����:+��t(#r�/�0`V�za����aCd�!����%������ �����N�`#�s?z�KH�G��ދ߼6����'P���]`,4�q/.ħ�D��ͬs��-9tW���PF��_�`���<�!!'�†�#C#�K-B��C�M�\dr�
�Gj+B�%�,5��ݠ��<†.3��PpI�_�:������J�v�lg@p/��X�����c1�V�ɚ���&�P�=����$0c�#��(b6��#���W�:�
�h�EhP���ƻ#����zǘP���|qTc�	;�S{>��i_Cn��m�����#B5���f5*Й3S��$ߣ*G��|��~Du<�F�6�qq���X@8-��
�z<�X�dp�v��X�
�<ώ#ʌuA�'a �bOg¿s
+�m��M��
���bhF��
�ƥZ&js�d��eB���o����Ȏ�����&؎.29^�����@�G��Zn�}�aC���yQ��8$�/�LI��W�a�}
�	�3� 8��,@��C��1�ԫBd�Nwl�~��U����1���1D���G+�a�v��(Q���c]��KM��c�(b��>8�*1�������=�
��4���o�6�pD�?ň�@��}��q@(��xFX0�V���\H�|�hz��U/���b*�	�A@0�
C�%�,!>�jr��/�����DJ�Ӂ�";9�!�� K�

35��W�T��� �N(zO�*�wˉ����T|j���CE@a"C�(�a��%�'�
NZ�����`u�!�H�	W�p5�Gg0�5��	z� &f�\
��
����	���I�`�Z��q#��W��ꏍT� [�
�h��$Hc���5;��������\��~b�Ln��8I
*�N������p�/P��ˁ_\
P zz���A8�Q�<#,@�\A�.$r>
��=Q��p@1

���v �{���t���T59k�W���R	�M�؇	"%_������%�����p+��*OW�h'�='�e�k�;�ĎG�^���>5R��n!��?��!��p�0�X�ꆧ-p
�����?b3&�-��ڗ��q���a��R g
�� Sz;C�,p���b�u���[������+��&pWa��`9Q�|0�Qh�V�5��_�X�#2a�R�(p��x��?�)�"plB0'��?B��f-�^��!
e�z����º�gv�����%lX��u���?b3&�-��ڗ��q���a��R g
�� Sz;C�,p���b�u���[������+��&pWa��`9Q�|0�Qh�V�5��_�X�#2a�R�(p��x��?�)�"plB0'��?B��f-�^��!
e�z����º�gv�����%lX��u���?b3&�-��ڗ��q���a��R g
�� Sz;C�,p���b�u���[������+��!Y���
tuu��:��0�d�|���D<�B��V��� R�g����c�}�2�kG`�F��z�{����0��z�U�
ufJnf*d��V},`�G]]{������!Y
��1���1P�0@�쯈����!$.��_|̠���9Q�x����:�,k�}Y�AҀƛ���
k��K0��GW^�lc���V@k'�a�=�C�T.�h{+�.j�z�I�?��3(6�vTi��7��,�Ǯ
�_p�V`Pt�1��b�A�Z�g��4u��׼�/�����k�a��
Z���K����B�����
���g����.���Ʊ�aW�)՘(i����`�AY���
tuu��:��0�d�|���D<�B��V��� R�g����c�}�2�kG`�F��z�{�!�9����X���� ��!�@7Q�J����h���x~q��<?��!��rݮnmĞػ�Vt::�	p����e>`Na/�3-��#�2��E�
��kR�(���=����@��s���hE�\�k��q'�.�j�������\:��ı@��Ә_��ŋk�����By$@3uԪ
+��&�i�p���(�������k-����I틿�`wC��� l����1,FP
c������c1b��> <�)��^I�F�*���`	��j\ 
���
8w0���<��Z��v���{b�ơX��`�<%ï�:�K�X��!�9����X���� ��!�@7Q�J����h���x~q��<?��!��rݮnL��Dx�!DC�'�~�(P�*�_�v�@��-_���b\o�Pd{���Z�F���Q�>�!���pz��7@ 27�z�p���="�W6aCQ��A�P�c*�
��&M�"<B�	�!��F(b�z/�;X Eq���/�Tj1.7�(�=�W�-vWwE�#A�����^�P�
a�=s�e���wX�C���a��0���W �y1�t���&�!D��I�_�
1J�����"��F��*5���
Y���+������D�@�O�a��\�������޻�\!�~�H��͘P�`+�xT<�ʺw�A��~���"h�y$�/х
�^�����\u��`��K�����s���]���pH�x���j W��0�Xx�\�Yf�B���]�.��G�Xj��(j0�<*Le]
�� �ɿDG�B
4D<�~�…R�E��`�k�:�Ѱ���F%��eVG���Ů���$h<A��5+��A�<W�y��Ȏ��[��{�-�(3��?G�e"w�a�:�����f��^�������F77*%ߥ���do�w��t��A�pF�B���*FK�Џ��1O{p|��>~:�a7w!��� u�N��B�"�0
x��~fR!�}f�㯩O�/�a�������dcsr�]�\kQ�F��x��H?�7`>)�ʼ¤d���������0HC��&wrȎ��[��{�-�(3��?G�e"w�a�:�����f��^�������F77*%ߥ���do�w��t��A�pF�B���*FK�Џ��1O{p|��>~:�a7w!��� u�N��B�"�0
x��~fR!�}f�㯩O�/�a�������dcsr�]�\kQ�F��x��H?�7`>)�ʼ¤d���������0HC��&wrȎ��[��{�-�(3��?G�e"w�a�:�����f��^�������F77*%ߥ���do�w��t��A�pF�Ca���c�a`c�^M\�+�� ��+�j�RQ$rB-�Mz)���� OԬ�u
��'@���@�[�V����ŞaqEGD@"�?��b���1���w�#��j�\l1?�$��_U���1#�"h�5k�M�u8ǁ"~�gC�Ou:c��j:������,��*:"�5��F�W��O�|;���X�דW$
�a�
�A&�����A���D���^�nk��<
�+:@@�{���;��P)����$� �g�\QQ�ȁ���4���0��zx��������Ǿ��� W@�	0<W��h��H��Z$�@��Ss]N1�@��Y���FN���oځN�0,�A'a�<�⊎��&D
l��ŕ��c��6�&8F=������bI��&�E%bG D"� �jע���q�D�J·P(��2t��~�
u��ej2��[zp�;������1B�
�Z0�#�R�I�Q�Ehx�e��������������r�e#���>���*�
(p�	}���(����8��H��?s,���û�\���$-�5�P�:5*���
�V���VY���@1I���.:�K�P��(vR>��
����
`��ُ~���C����/C�2��[zp�;������1B�
�Z0�#�R�I�Q�Ehx�e��������������r�e#���>���*�
(p�	}���(����8��H��?s,���û�\���$-�5�P�:5*���
�V���VY���@1I���.:�K�P��(vR>��
����
`��ُ~���C����/C�2��[zp�;������1B�
�Z0�#�R�I�Q�Ehx�e��������������r�e#�������q"6Àr��|I���)='�B�D����s��1W��D�0F�{C�=��
�����R9�����>�H�#DN��;���]>

*��Dˆ.��a������q"6Àr��|I���)='�B�D����s��1W��D�0F�{C�=��
�����R9�����>�H�#DN��;���]>

*��Dˆ.��a������q"6Àr��|I���)='�B�D����s��1W��D�0F�{C�=��
�����R9�����>�H�#DN��;���]>

*��Dˆ.��a������q"6Àr��|I���)='�B�D����s��1W��D�0F�{C�=��
�����R9�����>�H�#DN��;���]>

*��Dˆ.��a������q"6Àr��|I���)='�B�D����s��1W��D�0F�{C�=��
�����R9�����>�BgK��10��03��X��
G ~��O��ƀ�HH����x��i�Z`H�
�h@
%��~g�Y>]�c������0b��!�L�vq�h@�x$�^K�6��q��3������md��d,qd��?Pѧ�Wc@J�$WD��<BX4�?�$u_�� �]?3��,�.�1��@��J�l�	1@���&j�8�4 C�^/%��|���Й����G�6�L�8�
Q��h��+��%R+�~a�!�wV��:�����n����O�z��� }�%b�L��Ghj5]�k�!�	/��
�s>_�phL�a���#�Y&s�Y�(��4i������	�?0���
;�O�	AW��
D�WO��?�'˽Lc�>��[&LP#�5	��Î5�������q����/�84&t��|C�
��9셎,�@r�4�J�h	T����蟘g�A��է��������[���q�œ�ަ1�q�X��r�V�� -�.�> �ð/O��.0%�k4��#���I��7!�n����e~C;p�T<5uj�~�рc8��q9�
v��g�v粋,�([���"�~�
l�v����z~ ��py�,�Y��y����O�@Y�ku��58++�ۇ*�᫫P��������$+���h����>s�=�YgL@�Z߬���f�ψ8E����'˃�	e��'�����>�xǂ:��s[�>8���Y_���9U
]Z��_�4`X�m�!\Gc@E��v����:`�B��`�ȭ��@[0]�|A�-�`^��)>\`K.�i?�G��)�4��<
�nC��q��
N
���v�ʨxj��7��
�"�p+n	
�8s,���Ϝ��eY�P:��.El��ق���l;��AI���Yv�I��?�!O���1���r�돎 jpVW�3�UC�WV����

3�[r�����-�w�#�QW����y׫QB(U{q&�?��C�t��m��ʖ�)�s�—�)�\�"!r�����*\СE
L�=C�T7���
�:y�J'�_�Μ�iz<FF��c���ưTU�}}���u��P�^�AɿO�9P�/hG��2���u�����|��H�\�� n,䊃�4(QCG�6APǣ�
���8�p��R��W��)^�������1�_`���z�"�W�ro���T9�K���}��mr�G?�)|r�%�A�R"*��9"���
P��͐C�1��@�0�!�#��Ԣ|��<��F���dn��9���kE_���;i�^�E�U������a����c*[\�Q��
_��pP{T��ʬB��H�=sB�4}3d�z=P ��.�@7���(�%~�:r�����-�w�#�QW����y׫QB(U{q&�?��C�t��m��ʖ�)�s�—�)�\�"!r�����3�/*/k;���-���˼<;��U�}m� ��'Xr犷�*�uⷍA
(�5��p�![��Z��1
c䃬���OlV�X�
���jh���D�~I���yP�{Y�ǽ!l%T&]���>��0�o�@?!:×<U�6�T���h�(QG���[��,��}�2և��@$g��8�{b�Rǐ�HSE�b$��B�u�+�Pn��*^�wq�H[	U	�xxw���@�8��JM{��4P1s�9s�[�mH��[Ə ��x���	�͐�-�ۃ-hz���A�zx��K��+E,y�}t�54X��"L�$�N���T����ސ��.���
V��q�� ��a˞*�h�E׊�4y(���G��Ll�
n��kC�� �����r]=�Z)c��
��Ƈ1e�&bw��B��gw􅰕P�w�G�x�
��Í�$���\�V��ER.�V�� �E�=n`�d u���Z�#h��8���l��s2��^�6G@�d�՝jP:�n,�=�m
�Kgё~������O�h5��v���!&��{�F�"�9:�砭8��BԢ`M�b�Ծ
�xN`FT|��&��� �����J�Wm���Ǹ��4	l�2/�=��ߩ�
�َ���{�$��/`�����@��!gC����=BZ�U �6�ڃb2�
�ł }�@h$��% �p���E�Hz[M@ �X(#��Ҋ�i�"ȕ'�����F�Ȃ2�B����q'5�I;$�}CA�vc�|?��	4���?�:4�?��Y��=i��P��h��8���l��s2��^�6G@�d�՝jP:�n,�=�m
�Kgё~������O�h5��v���!&��{�F�"�9:�砭8��BԢ`M�b�Ծ
�xN`FT|��&��� �����J�Wm���Ǹ��4	l�2/�=��ߩ�
�َ���{�6����'P���]`,4�q/.ħ�D��ͬs��-9tW���PF��_�`���<�!!'�†�#C#�K-B��A���������&Gt�~���@�=���xm��7U�N���ں�Xh7�8�^04]�O��U!�X�߸Zr,诟�Р��ȿ|��Z
�y�BBO�
�F<�F7�Z.��?��#���;��L�����,	"�{Gz/~�����g�
`��Qы!�Cj4-}�#

��@0Ѡ�d D�&`Q�@j�9 �6�(�p�`1���	p@�*��qG&4��6T>o5Q1�
&a�cp	e�b�@�C��0�=~S�X����ޠR��(�w���
���꿉�02�WX
�gK���)��*�3k��BE���:�y�0+A�0�HIⰡ�ǐ�����@�Ёx��a�z���`�?���9��@��$P#�h�E��`
���`ev��
��8��
bS�"UHf�9����:+��t(#r�/�0`V�za����aCd�!����%������!��&؎.29^�����@�G��Zn�}�aC���yQ��8$�/�LI��W�a�}
�	�3� 8��,@��C��1�ԫBd�Nwl�~��U����1���1D���G+�a�v��(Q���c]��KM��c�(b��>8�*1�������=�
��4���o�6�pD�?ň���3�hL����oѕ
����|rC?":�R�#h�b8���z� ��V�J=X,k�8	i�A��y�\g��F:������u1'��_����6��&����_���4#Y��cR�	�59ݲM�2�T{_7ώH`��GS�P�mlG�@u���ڊР	G���vG
-7h>��0������<��Tv��$�|+�0Ҿ�ݿ����� F�k!�`�jU�2f�;�I�FT*�k�������yJ��m���#����pZ;QZ
(�y`����%��ޱ�1py�G�ꃂN��A�Ğυ~�W�۷�c8"�~��
P zz���A8�Q�<#,@�\A�.$r>
��=Q��p@1

���v �{���t���T59k�W���R	�M�؇	"%_������%�����p+��*OW�h'�='�e�k�;�ĎG�^���>5R��n!��?��!��p�0�X�ꆧ-p
����A0	���$@��8�#��R���@3[.|
p@����
�QG����a�q|����+���Gƪ_�-��4T�$1؂�a���KXB}P��
^^?1H&
7[b$���\Dvs
C[8@��fke���.�==_`A��P
(��� U� �9{����K�� �����D�;P=�Pú	`KO����+���)�&�lC�����k���aHkg�@L�l������4�
E��2��
����G#�{C��~@��P�H��b

��jwA,	a	�CS��yx�����
��C�mK��8���`0�O�3��b)�=��8P[1l���	k-��`ET��t8+���0��>p��Q+`�����,
��0�)l�8vԼ]S����8�!����c���˯~�����=G�UN�]A3��
�
ʎS�
�E�	�|�:�����
��C�mK��8���`0�O�3��b)�=��8P[1l���	k-��`ET��t8+���0��>p��Q+`�����,
��0�)l�8vԼ]S����8�!����c���˯~�����=G�UN�]A3��
�
ʎS�
�E�	�|�:�����
��C�mK��8���`0�O�3��b)�=��8P[1l���	k-��`ET��t��X����:���cE��B�Y>c
y�"b�t`�+C�_)sW��BH]�����A���r�L�=y���`uX�=p*��:���
�732�H+>�0a��������Qf���O��^{���] 
��W�
\����l/�fPmh���<^oqvXF5�\
��N����@cM��L���
ϥ�h룫�x61�_ل+ 5��0מ�!�*F�=���5{=D$���Z;*4�כ�]�Q��c�¯�S�0(:P�s1S �-t���c:����
�u�a
�
d��5簈y��т�e|@��^�Q	!v����e֎�ʍ3����e��acX��0����
�4��T�0] ��X����:���cE��B�Y>c
y�"b�t`�+C�_)sW��BH]�����A���r�L�=y������_�f,[X�G�e?��� 
��֥PQ]�
4{MK�<?8�G���ЋX�n�76�Ol]��+�
g��u�P
�b2�0?�0�����
��O��"�H�f�5�TWsM�R�� Qù�����4"�.[��͸��~5
��C@@��.}
�bX����
��/���bŵ�|@yS�!�� ��jU��G�Ը@��p�a��~y
����ssn$��ߍB�;����6xK�_@u�#(��C�s�~1��m`
A��B/$�n�Z�AEw0��5.���;�xߞCB-b�\�ۉ=�w�P��t0t
����@%��,|�����_�f,[X�G�e?��� 
��֥PQ]�
4{MK�<?8�G���ЋX�n�7&M�"<B�	�!��F(b�z/�;X Eq���/�Tj1.7�(�=�W�-vWwE�#A�����^�P�
a�=s�e���wX�C���a��0���W �y1�t���&�!D��I�_�
1J�����"��F��*5���
Y���+������D�@�O�a��\�������޻�L�6�"TL��-
���j0�<*Le]
�� ����ӝy
�!DC�'�~�(P�*�_��8?Ճr�-_��k`l�@���@�|��2d"t7l�eX����;�&�z}@C5�����5�n�@d,o���`s���dE��l†�
\�¡��U���L��Dx�!DC�'�~�(P�*�_�v�@��-_���b\o�Pd{���Z�F���Q�>�!���pz��7@ 27�z�p���="�W6aCQ��A�P�c*�
��&M�"<B�	�!��F(b�z/�;X Eq���/�Tj1.7�(�=�W�-vWwE�#A�����^�P�
a�=s�d�Dt�:�'S�!nA�<Q�?3)˾�h��ԧ��0�
���
n���21��Q.�.5��#}S�L���0
�e^aR2^ބ~��{ۃ��$!���	���GO���u=���P����2���0�}Ja~3@�����}Mc#�����CZ�27�;��:A� ��#
�OU����跗���
� d�����
L(�	�Q�flgV��h�����|
¤��5x�6
�2�n��P�H���(ɫ�	
����9W��hQ�
���Ɂ9�����Ah����{&wV
`A��s��x1GP�a;�Xv�	E��!BP;L��q�h�	T	
��"�v���"��&wrȎ��[��{�-�(3��?G�e"w�a�:�����f��^�������F77*%ߥ���do�w��t��A�pF�B���*FK�Џ��1O{p|��>~:�a7w!��� u�N��B�"�0
x��~fR!�}f�㯩O�/�a�������dcsr�]�\kQ�F��x��H?�7`>6�&8F=������bI��&�E%bG D"� �jע���q�D�J·P(��2t��~�
u��ej	;<Y�TtD
2 kc��&,�� 3�!��wy1�0�1�&�H����L�5Z)(�9!��P&���S�x'�Vt:��D�Q��v?���S��+PI�A��0
����
�4R�XB)0J!4)�	ۗIĄUL�w��4S�����L
hl�a򇴈	�#!�0���ȑrdEjZ�p V���
�#%�@$�0q
U݃�)njP�QaA�%�
���(����l]�2AkJ@�$+�H��I$0a7�����cIʝ�p �F��D�`a�m��nܑ,��zx��������Ǿ��� W@�	0<W��h��H��Z$�@��Ss]N1�@��Y���FN���oځN�0,�A'a�<�⊎��&D
l��ŕ��c��6�&8F=������bI��&�E%bG D"� �jע���q�D�J·P(��2t��~�
u��ej2��[zp�;������1B�
�Z0�#�R�I�Q�Ehx�e��������������r�e#���>���*�
(p�	}���(����8��H��?s,���û�\���$-�5�P�:5*���
�V���VY���@1I���.:�K�P��(vR>��
����
`��ُ~���C����/C�2��[zp�;������1B�
�Z0�#�R�I�Q�Ehx�e��������������r�e#���>���*�
(p�	}���(����8��H��?s,���û�\���$-�5�P�:5*���
�V���VY���@1I���.:�K�P��(vR>��
����
`��ُ~���C����/C�2��[zp�;������1B�
�Z0�#�R�I�Q�Ehx�e��������������r�e#�������q"6Àr��|I���)='�B�D����s��1W��D�0F�{C�=��
�����R9�����>�H�#DN��;���]>

*��Dˆ.��a������q"6Àr��|I���)='�B�D����s��1W��D�0F�{C�=��
�����R9�����>�H�#DN��;���]>

*��Dˆ.��a������q"6Àr��|I���)='�B�D����s��1W��D�0F�{C�=��
�����R9�����>�H�#DN��;���]>

*��Dˆ.��a������q"6Àr��|I���)='�B�D����s��1W��D�0F�{C�=��
�����R9�����>�H�#DN��;���]>

*��Dˆ.��a������q"6Àr��|I���)='�B�D����s��1W��D�0F�{C�=��
�����R9�����>�BgK��10��03��X��
G ~��O��ƀ�HH����x��i�Z`H�
�h@
%��~g�Y>]�c������0b��!�L�vq�h@�x$�^K�6��q��3������md��d,qd��?Pѧ�Wc@J�$WD��<BX4�?�$u_�� �]?3��,�.�1��@��J�l�	1@���&j�8�4 C�^/%��|���Й����G�6�L�8�
Q��h��+��%R+�~a�!�wV��:�����n����O�z��� }�%b�L��Ghj5]�k�!�	/��
�s>_�phL�a���#�Y&s�Y�(��4i������	�?0���
;�O�	AW��
D�WO��?�'˽Lc�>��[&LP#�5	��Î5�������q����/�84&t��|C�
��9셎,�@r�4�J�h	T����蟘g�A��է��������[���q�œ�ަ1�q�X��r�V�� -�.�> �ð/O��.0%�k4��#���I��7!�n����e~C;p�T<5uj�~�рc8��q9�
v��g�v粋,�([���"�~�
l�v����z~ ��py�,�Y��y����O�@Y�ku��58++�ۇ*�᫫P��������$+���h����>s�=�YgL@�Z߬���f�ψ8E����'˃�	e��'�����>�xǂ:��s[�>8���Y_���9U
]Z��_�4`X�m�!\Gc@E��v����:`�B��`�ȭ��@[0]�|A�-�`^��)>\`K.�i?�G��)�4��<
�nC��q��
N
���v�ʨxj��7��
�"�p+n	
�8s,���Ϝ��eY�P:��.El��ق���l;��AI���Yv�I��?�!O���1���r�돎 jpVW�3�UC�WV����

3�[r�����-�w�#�QW����y׫QB(U{q&�?��C�t��m��ʖ�)�s�—�)�\�"!r�����*\СE
L�=C�T7���
�:y�J'�_�Μ�iz<FF��c���ưTU�}}���u��P�^�AɿO�9P�/hG��2���u�����|��H�\�� n,䊃�4(QCG�6APǣ�
���8�p��R��W��)^�������1�_`���z�"�W�ro���T9�K���}��mr�G?�)|r�%�A�R"*��9"���
P��͐C�1��@�0�!�#��Ԣ|��<��F���dn��9���kE_���;i�^�E�U������a����c*[\�Q��
_��pP{T��ʬB��H�=sB�4}3d�z=P ��.�@7���(�%~�:r�����-�w�#�QW����y׫QB(U{q&�?��C�t��m��ʖ�)�s�—�)�\�"!r�����3�/*/k;���-���˼<;��U�}m� ��'Xr犷�*�uⷍA
(�5��p�![��Z��1
c䃬���OlV�X�
���jh���D�~I���yP�{Y�ǽ!l%T&]���>��0�o�@?!:×<U�6�T���h�(QG���[��,��}�2և��@$g��8�{b�Rǐ�HSE�b$��L��ʅK���=�a*�2����hA�~H2
�	�������]x��G�AB�<
dz��f�@�����=BX� �=<A�%����<�p>�@�,hs&_�f'|^T*^�wq�H[	U	�xxw���@�8��A��N���n
�U"��o<�
Q�k#��&6B�_n���b��Y��9.�ح�������cC��2��1;��R����zB�J�L��#ü|Z�a�ߒ�~Bu�.x�pm��^+x��P��Y�
0Y���pe�C�4_Y�{R�6q�9�Q�x�#�`�
�rjε(]��O�6��%��ȿDxt��O~��4�f;����Kؽ����@
����W��V�L�!jQ0&��1C�j_
�<'0#*>u�adt
VNMY֥
C���
r����F��}���������\��`�=�i{�pth
B S�����z
Ӊ��-J&�}f(q�K� �DŽ�eGν�;L"M�H�=
2�#P
��$�6Dv�F�8��A S"�A�d&� $�{+9��T��"s��r�D��
�َ���{�$��/`�����@��!gC����=BZ�L	���P�ڗ�A��	�ʏ�{��YU��Vu�@@���\�zx���-�FE�#ç�z{�>���;1�>�x��^���P���,�z�����g�AR��4_Y�{R�6q�9�Q�x�#�`�
�rjε(]��O�6��%��ȿDxt��O~��4�f;����n���C+�u���o�qļ`h����C6�Ͽp� �Y�_?��A��~��������+
 �y<�n
,�]�1G���v��ә��
XE<���^���W�:�Wj�
a��L�x��v%?�%T�mc�~�
hAȳ��B�7/"��h7��		<V6A�y�Yh�/�b<�_����2;�3���$�y����l<1���u����A���h�r)��I%��jHu����_�)��.�` 
 ��4\��r�683, 6ϵ�<$���cp	e�b�@�C��0�=~S�X����ޠR��(�w���
���꿉�02�WX
�gK���)��*�3k��BE���:�y�0+A�0�HIⰡ�ǐ�����@�Ёx��a�z���`�?���9��@��$P#�h�E��`
���`ev��
��8��
bS�"UHf�9����:+��t(#r�/�0`V�za����aCd�!����%������!��&؎.29^�����@�G��Zn�}�aC���yQ��8$�/�LI��W�a�}
�	�3� 8��,@��C��1�ԫBd�Nwl�~��U����1���1D���G+�a�v��(Q���c]��KM��c�(b��>8�*1�������=�
��4���o�6�pD�?ň���3�hL����oѕ
����|rC?":�R�#h�b8���z� ��"��ò3�4��,H�tZ�g"�1�H�ahPPh�f�@0 ��8a$��W�۷�c8"�~��Ѝd?��J�&L��v�7�ʅQ�|�>9!��O)C�M�\dr�
�Gj+B�%�,5��ݠ��<†.3��PpI�_�:������J�v�lg@p/��X�����c1�V�ɚ���&�P�=����$0c�#��(b6��#���W�:�
�h�EhP���ƻ#����zǘP���|qTc�	;�S{>��i_Cn��m�����@����
�QG����a�q|����+���Gƪ_�-��4T�$1؂�a���KXB}P��
^^?1H&
7[b$���\Dvs
C[8@��fke���.�==_`A��P
(��� U� �9{����K�� �����D�;P=�Pú	`KO����+���)�&�lC�����k���aHkg�@L�l������4�
E��2��
����G#�{C��~@��P�H��b

��jwA,	a	�CS��yx�� ��m�p� U��
q��)
l�^�	������@��}��q@(��xFX0�V���\H�|�hz��U/���b*�	�A@0�
C�%�,!>�jr��/�����DJ�Ӂ�";9�!�� K�

35��W�T��� �N(zO�*�wˉ����T|j���CE@a"C�(�a��%�'�
NZ����~�fL7�[%�/T���
��>�@���@��v��X��AlŲ�߸$!��Q��S�WA�L�Ãp�r���a¢�D��k8�0��Fd�|��P��R�uN<`0S�D�:؄
`OGh~����[.���B�`��U;�t�
�87*9O�*-J�&����~�fL7�[%�/T���
��>�@���@��v��X��AlŲ�߸$!��Q��S�WA�L�Ãp�r���a¢�D��k8�0��Fd�|��P��R�uN<`0S�D�:؄
`OGh~����[.���B�`��U;�t�
�87*9O�*-J�&����~�fL7�[%�/T���
��>�@���@��v��X��AlŲ�߸$!��Q��S�WA�B��c:����
�u�a
�
d��5簈y��т�e|@��^�Q	!v����e֎�ʍ3����e��acX��0����
�4��T�0] ��X����:���cE��B�Y>c
y�"b�t`�+C�_)sW��BH]�����A���r�L�=y���`uX�=p*��:���
�732�H+>�0a��������Qf���O��^{���] 
��W�
\����l/�fPmh���<^oqvXF5�\
��N����@cM��L���
ϥ�h룫�x61�_ل+ 5��0מ�!�*F�=���5{=D$���Z;*4�כ�]�Q��c�¯�S�0(:P�s1S �-t���c:����
�u�a
�
d��5簈y��т�e|@��^�Q	!v����e֎�ʍ3����C�s�~1��m`
A��B/$�n�Z�AEw0��5.���;�xߞCB-b�\�ۉ=�w�P��t0t
����@%��,|�����_�f,[X�G�e?��� 
��֥PQ]�
4{MK�<?8�G���ЋX�n�76�Ol]��+�
g��u�P
�b2�0?�0�����
��O��"�H�f�5�TWsM�R�� Qù�����4"�.[��͸��~5
��C@@��.}
�bX����
��/���bŵ�|@yS�!�� ��jU��G�Ը@��p�a��~y
����ssn$��ߍB�;����6xK�_@u�#(��C�s�~1��m`
A��B/$�n�Z�AEw0��5.���;�xߞCB-b�\���
endstream
endobj
33 0 obj <<
/Length 3912      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 93.543 479.321 Td [(Dedication.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -33.407 Td [(To)-250(The)-250(Committee)-250(Of)-250(The)-250(Christian)-250(Evidence)-250(Society.)]TJ 11.956 -13.747 Td [(My)-250(Lords)-250(and)-250(Gentlemen,)]TJ 0 -13.746 Td [(Having)-372(undertaken)-373(to)-372(compose)-373(this)-372(work)-373(at)-372(your)-372(request,)-403(I)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(beg)-354(permission)-354(to)-354(dedicate)-354(it)-354(to)-354(you.)-562(In)-354(doing)-354(so)-354(I)-354(feel)-353(that)-354(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-350(a)-349(duty)-349(which)-350(I)-349(owe)-350(both)-349(to)-350(you)-349(and)-350(to)-349(myself)-350(that)-349(I)-349(should)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(state)-334(the)-334(position)-334(which)-334(we)-334(respectively)-334(occupy)-334(with)-334(regard)-334(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it.)-706(Your)-401(responsibility)-402(is)-402(confined)-402(to)-402(having)-402(requested)-402(me)-401(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(compose)-340(a)-341(work)-340(in)-340(refutation)-340(of)-341(certain)-340(principles)-340(now)-340(widely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disseminated,)-201(which)-189(impugn)-188(the)-189(supernatural)-189(elements)-188(contained)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-288(the)-288(New)-289(Testament.)-364(For)-288(the)-288(contents)-289(of)-288(the)-288(work)-288(and)-288(for)-288(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mode)-206(of)-207(treat)1(ment)-207(I)-206(alone)-206(am)-206(responsible.)-236(When)-206(I)-206(considered)-206(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(position)-297(of)-296(the)-296(present)-297(controversy,)-308(I)-297(felt)-296(that)-296(it)-297(was)-296(impossible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-451(treat)-452(the)-451(subject)-451(satisfactorily)-451(except)-452(on)-451(the)-451(principle)-451(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-303(responsibility)-303(for)-303(the)-303(mode)-303(of)-303(conducting)-303(the)-303(argument)-303(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-393(answering)-392(the)-393(objections)-392(should)-393(rest)-393(with)-392(the)-393(writer)-392(alone.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(In)-378(dealing)-378(with)-377(a)-378(subject)-378(so)-378(complicated,)-409(involving)-378(as)-378(it)-377(does)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(questions)-289(of)-290(philosophy)-289(and)-290(science)-289(as)-290(well)-289(as)-290(the)-289(principles)-289(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-248(criticism,)-248(I)-248(can)-248(scarcely)-248(venture)-248(to)-248(hope)-248(that)-248(every)-248(po-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sition)-223(which)-223(I)-222(have)-223(taken)-223(will)-223(prove)-223(acceptable)-222(to)-446(all)-223(the)-222(various)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([iv])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(shades)-200(of)-200(theological)-201(thought.)-233(I)-200(have)-201(endeavoured)-200(to)-200(take)-200(such)-200(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(seemed)-240(to)-239(me)-240(to)-240(be)-239(logically)-240(defensible)-240(without)-239(any)-240(reference)-239(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(particular)-281(schools)-281(of)-281(theological)-281(opinion.)-343(As)-281(the)-281(entire)-281(question)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-286(essentially)-285(historical,)-295(I)-286(have)-285(done)-286(my)-285(utmost)-286(to)-286(exclude)-285(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-348(all)-347(discussions)-348(that)-348(are)-347(strictly)-348(theological.)-543(Modern)-347(unbelief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(however)-189(puts)-190(in)-189(two)-190(objections)-189(which)-190(if)-189(valid)-190(render)-189(all)-189(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-201(in)-200(proof)-201(of)-200(the)-201(occurrence)-201(of)-200(miracles)-201(nugatory,)-210(namely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-294(they)-295(are)-294(both)-295(impossible)-294(and)-295(incredible.)-383(In)-295(meeting)-294(these)-294(I)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-339(been)-338(compelled)-339(to)-339(appeal)-338(to)-339(what)-338(appear)-339(to)-339(me)-338(to)-339(be)-338(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(principles)-382(of)-383(a)-382(sound)-383(philosophy.)-647(In)-383(all)-382(other)-383(respects)-382(I)-382(have)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
37 0 obj <<
/Length 4113      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Dedication.)-20586(3)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(viewed)-340(the)-341(question)-340(before)-340(me)-340(as)-341(exclusively)-340(one)-340(of)-340(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(If)-428(the)-429(Resurrection)-428(of)-429(our)-428(Lord)-429(is)-428(an)-429(actual)-428(occurrence,)-473(it)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(follows)-269(that)-270(Christianity)-269(must)-270(be)-269(a)-270(divine)-269(revelation.)-308(If)-270(it)-269(is)-269(not,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-259(amount)-259(of)-259(other)-259(evidence)-259(will)-259(avail)-259(to)-259(prove)-259(it)-259(to)-259(be)-259(so.)-277(As)-258(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-275(been)-275(strongly)-275(affirmed)-275(that)-276(for)-275(this)-275(great)-275(fact,)-281(which)-275(consti-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tutes)-294(the)-295(central)-294(position)-294(of)-295(Christianity,)-305(the)-294(historical)-294(evidence)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-305(worthless,)-318(I)-305(have)-305(devoted)-304(the)-305(latter)-305(portion)-304(of)-305(this)-305(volume)-304(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-280(consideration)-281(of)-280(this)-280(question,)-288(with)-280(a)-281(view)-280(of)-280(putting)-280(before)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-328(reader)-328(the)-329(value)-328(of)-328(the)-328(New)-328(Testament)-328(when)-328(contemplated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-368(simple)-369(history.)-604(Using)-369(the)-368(Epistles)-368(as)-369(the)-368(foundation)-368(of)-368(my)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(argument,)-226(I)-220(have)-220(endeavoured)-220(to)-220(prove)-220(that)-220(the)-220(greatest)-220(of)-220(all)-219(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miracles)-356(recorded)-356(in)-356(the)-357(Gospels)-356(rests)-356(on)-356(an)-356(attestation)-356(that)-356(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unsurpassed)-257(by)-258(any)-257(event)-258(recorded)-257(in)-258(history.)-272(For)-258(this)-257(purpose)-257(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-214(used)-213(the)-214(Epistles)-214(as)-214(simple)-213(historical)-214(documents,)-221(and)-214(I)-213(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(claimed)-384(for)-383(them)-384(precisely)-383(the)-384(same)-384(value)-383(which)-384(is)-383(conceded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-359(other)-359(writings)-360(of)-359(a)-359(similar)-359(description.)-578(The)-359(feeling)-718(among)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([v])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(Christians)-297(that)-297(these)-297(writings)-296(contain)-297(the)-297(great)-297(principles)-297(of)-296(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-323(faith)-323(has)-323(occasioned)-322(it)-323(to)-323(be)-323(overlooked)-323(that)-323(they)-322(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(also)-259(contemporary)-259(historical)-259(documents)-259(of)-259(the)-259(highest)-259(order.)-276(As)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-262(I)-262(have)-262(used)-263(them)-262(in)-262(proof)-262(of)-262(the)-262(great)-262(facts)-262(of)-262(Christianity,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(above)-220(all)-220(in)-220(proof)-220(of)-220(the)-220(greatest)-220(of)-220(them,)-226(the)-220(Resurrection)-220(of)-220(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Lord.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(With)-184(these)-185(observations)-184(I)-185(now)-184(present)-184(you)-185(the)-184(following)-185(work,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(with)-369(the)-369(hope)-369(that)-370(it)-369(may)-369(prove)-369(the)-369(means)-369(of)-369(removing)-369(many)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-348(the)-348(difficulties)-349(with)-348(which)-348(recent)-348(controversial)-348(writers)-348(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(endeavoured)-326(to)-327(obscure)-326(the)-327(subject.)-479(Trusting)-326(that)-327(it)-326(maybe)-326(ac-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cepted)-253(by)-253(the)-253(great)-253(Head)-253(of)-253(the)-253(Church,)-254(the)-253(reality)-253(of)-252(whose)-253(life)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-237(teaching)-236(as)-237(they)-237(are)-237(recorded)-236(in)-237(the)-237(Gospels)-236(it)-237(is)-237(designed)-236(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(establish,)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(I)-250(remain,)-250(my)-250(Lords)-250(and)-250(Gentlemen,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Your's)-250(faithfully,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(C.)-250(A.)-250(Row.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(London,)-250(January,)-250(1875.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
42 0 obj <<
/Length 195       
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(4)-9255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -36.123 Td [([001])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
50 0 obj <<
/Length 3349      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-250(I.)-250(Introduction.)-251(The)-250(Position)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(of)-262(the)-261(Controversy)-262(Between)-261(the)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Opponents)-260(and)-261(the)-260(Defenders)-261(of)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Christianity.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -39.701 Td [(Although)-346(every)-346(portion)-347(of)-346(the)-346(Bible)-346(is)-346(vehemently)-346(assailed)-346(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-300(various)-300(forms)-300(of)-300(modern)-300(Scepticism,)-312(it)-300(is)-300(clear)-300(that)-300(the)-299(real)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(turning)-316(point)-315(of)-316(the)-315(controversy)-315(between)-316(those)-315(who)-316(affirm)-315(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God)-306(has)-307(made)-306(a)-306(supernatural)-306(revelation)-307(of)-306(himself)-306(to)-306(mankind,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-428(those)-429(who)-428(deny)-428(it,)-473(centres)-428(in)-428(those)-429(portions)-428(of)-428(the)-428(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-359(which)-360(affirm)-359(the)-359(presence)-359(of)-359(the)-360(supernatural.)-577(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question)-309(may)-310(be)-309(still)-309(further)-309(narrowed)-310(into)-309(the)-309(inquiry)-309(whether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-359(person)-359(and)-360(actions)-359(of)-359(Jesus)-359(Christ,)-387(as)-359(they)-359(are)-359(depicted)-359(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-337(Gospels,)-360(are)-337(historical)-338(facts,)-359(or)-337(fictitious)-338(inventions.)-512(If)-337(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(opponents)-356(of)-357(Revelation)-356(can)-357(prove)-356(that)-356(they)-357(are)-356(the)-356(latter,)-383(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entire)-447(controversy)-447(will)-448(end)-447(in)-447(their)-447(favour.)-842(It)-447(would)-447(in)-447(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(case)-395(be)-395(utterly)-395(useless)-395(to)-395(attempt)-395(to)-395(defend)-395(any)-395(other)-395(portion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-312(the)-312(Bible;)-343(and)-312(the)-312(controversy)-312(respecting)-312(the)-312(Old)-312(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(becomes)-217(a)-217(mere)-218(waste)-217(of)-217(labour.)-239(If,)-224(on)-217(the)-217(other)-218(hand,)-223(Christians)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-267(prove)-266(that)-267(the)-266(narratives)-267(of)-267(the)-266(four)-267(Gospels,)-271(or)-266(even)-267(of)-266(any)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(one)-222(of)-222(them,)-227(are)-222(a)-222(true)-222(representation)-222(of)-222(historical)-222(facts,)-228(then)-222(it)-221(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-251(that)-250(God)-251(has)-251(made)-251(a)-250(revelation)-251(of)-251(himself,)-250(notwithstand-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ing)-256(the)-256(objections)-256(which)-256(may)-256(be)-256(urged)-256(against)-256(certain)-512(positions)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([002])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(which)-402(have)-403(been)-402(taken)-402(by)-403(Ecclesiastical)-402(Christianity,)-440(and)-402(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difficulties)-362(by)-362(which)-361(certain)-362(questions)-362(connected)-362(with)-362(the)-361(Old)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Testament)-250(are)-250(surrounded.)]TJ 11.956 -15.005 Td [(It)-300(follows,)-312(therefore,)-312(that)-300(the)-300(historical)-299(truth)-300(of)-300(the)-300(facts)-299(nar-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(rated)-273(in)-273(the)-272(Gospels)-273(constitutes)-273(the)-272(central)-273(position)-273(of)-273(the)-272(entire)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
54 0 obj <<
/Length 4477      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(6)-9255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(controversy.)-717(It)-405(is)-406(not)-405(my)-406(purpose)-405(on)-406(the)-405(present)-406(occasion)-405(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discuss)-396(the)-395(general)-396(question,)-431(whether)-396(the)-395(delineation)-396(of)-395(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ)-362(which)-361(the)-362(Gospels)-361(contain)-362(is)-361(one)-362(of)-361(an)-362(ideal)-361(or)-362(an)-361(his-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(torical)-296(person.)-389(That)-296(question)-296(I)-297(have)-296(already)-296(considered)-296(in)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 258.823 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)]TJ -263.667 -13.55 Td [(Jesus)-359(of)-359(the)-359(Evangelists.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 110.221 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.758 0 Td [(But)-359(as)-359(the)-359(various)-358(forms)-359(of)-359(modern)]TJ -118.979 -13.549 Td [(unbelief)-451(are)-452(making)-451(the)-451(most)-451(strenuous)-452(efforts)-451(to)-451(prove)-451(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-307(supernatural)-306(elements)-307(of)-306(the)-307(New)-306(Testament)-307(are)-306(hopelessly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incredible,)-491(and)-443(that)-442(the)-443(attestation)-442(on)-443(which)-443(the)-442(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrences)-330(mentioned)-329(in)-330(it)-330(rests,)-349(is)-330(simply)-330(worthless,)-349(it)-330(is)-329(my)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(intention)-377(to)-377(devote)-377(the)-377(present)-377(volume)-377(to)-377(the)-377(consideration)-377(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-227(special)-228(subject,)-232(and)-227(to)-228(examine)-227(the)-228(question)-227(of)-228(miracles,)-231(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-250(historical)-250(credibility.)]TJ 11.956 -14.095 Td [(Modern)-257(scepticism)-257(makes)-258(with)-257(respect)-257(to)-257(supernatural)-257(occur-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(rences)-378(\050under)-377(which)-378(more)-378(general)-377(term)-378(I)-377(include)-378(the)-377(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-519(the)-519(New)-518(Testament\051,)-586(the)-519(three)-519(following)-519(assertions,)-585(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(endeavours)-250(to)-250(substantiate)-250(them)-250(by)-250(every)-250(available)-250(argument:)]TJ 11.956 -14.095 Td [(1st.)-250(That)-250(all)-250(supernatural)-250(occurrences)-250(are)-250(impossible.)]TJ 0 -14.095 Td [(2nd.)-405(That,)-315(if)-302(not)-301(impossible,)-315(they)-302(are)-301(incredible;)-328(that)-302(is,)-314(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(they)-250(are)-250(contrary)-250(to)-250(reason.)]TJ 11.956 -14.095 Td [(3rd.)-346(That)-282(those)-283(which)-282(are)-282(narrated)-282(in)-282(the)-282(New)-282(Testament)-282(are)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(devoid)-194(of)-194(any)-194(adequate)-194(historical)-194(attestation,)-205(and)-194(owe)-194(their)-193(origin)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(the)-250(inventive)-250(powers)-250(of)-250(the)-250(mythic)-250(and)-250(legendary)-250(spirit.)]TJ 11.956 -14.095 Td [(It)-238(is)-237(my)-238(purpose,)-240(in)-237(the)-238(course)-237(of)-238(the)-237(present)-238(work,)-240(to)-237(traverse)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(each)-250(of)-250(these)-250(three)-250(positions,)-250(and)-250(to)-250(show:)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([003])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -14.095 Td [(1st.)-230(That)-188(miracles)-189(and)-189(supernatural)-189(occurrences)-189(are)-189(not)-188(impos-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(sible;)-346(and)-314(that)-314(the)-314(arguments)-314(by)-314(which)-314(this)-314(has)-314(been)-313(attempted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(be)-250(established)-250(are)-250(wholly)-250(inconclusive.)]TJ 11.956 -14.095 Td [(2nd.)-382(That)-294(they)-294(are)-294(neither)-294(incredible,)-305(nor)-294(contrary)-294(to)-294(reason;)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(but)-250(are)-250(entirely)-250(consistent)-250(with)-250(its)-250(dictates.)]TJ 11.956 -14.095 Td [(3rd,)-231(That)-227(the)-226(greatest)-227(of)-226(all)-227(the)-226(miracles)-227(which)-226(are)-227(recorded)-226(in)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-193(New)-193(Testament,)-204(and)-193(which,)-205(if)-193(an)-193(actual)-193(hist)1(orical)-193(occurrence,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-394(sufficient)-394(to)-393(carry)-394(with)-394(it)-394(all)-393(the)-394(others,)-430(the)-394(resurrection)-393(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-250(Christ,)-250(rests)-250(on)-250(the)-250(highest)-250(form)-250(of)-250(historical)-250(testimony.)]TJ 11.956 -14.095 Td [(Such)-250(is)-250(my)-250(position.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
58 0 obj <<
/Length 5006      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 321.947 548.934 Td [(7)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -263.22 -30.759 Td [(A)-439(recent)-438(writer,)-486(who)-439(has)-439(ably)-438(advocated)-439(the)-439(principles)-438(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(modern)-222(scepticism,)-228(the)-222(author)-223(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 144.586 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)-222(Religion,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 98.479 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.268 0 Td [(has)-222(in)]TJ -255.177 -13.549 Td [(the)-238(opening)-238(passage)-239(of)-238(his)-238(work)-238(clearly)-239(placed)-238(before)-238(us)-238(the)-238(real)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(point)-250(at)-250(issue.)-250(He)-250(states)-250(the)-250(case)-250(as)-250(follows:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -14.59 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(On)-435(the)-436(very)-435(threshold)-435(of)-436(inquiry)-435(into)-435(the)-436(origin)-435(and)-436(true)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(character)-390(of)-390(Christianity)-390(we)-389(are)-390(brought)-390(face)-390(to)-390(face)-390(with)-389(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural.)-657(It)-386(is)-385(impossible,)-420(without)-386(totally)-385(setting)-386(aside)-385(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(peculiar)-328(and)-328(indispensable)-329(claim)-328(to)-328(be)-328(a)-328(direct)-328(external)-328(revela-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-223(from)-223(God)-222(of)-223(truths)-223(which)-222(otherwise)-223(human)-223(reason)-223(could)-222(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-275(discovered,)-281(to)-275(treat)-274(Ecclesiastical)-275(Christianity)-275(as)-275(a)-275(form)-274(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(religion)-224(developed)-223(by)-224(the)-223(wisdom)-224(of)-223(man.)-241(Not)-224(only)-223(in)-224(form)-223(does)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-389(profess)-388(to)-389(be)-388(the)-389(result)-388(of)-389(divine)-388(communication,)-423(but)-389(in)-388(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(very)-302(essence,)-315(in)-302(its)-302(principal)-302(dogmas)-302(it)-302(is)-302(either)-302(superhuman)-302(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(untenable.)-304(There)-268(is)-268(no)-269(question)-268(here)-268(of)-268(mere)-268(accessories,)-272(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-248(comparatively)-247(unimportant,)-248(and)-248(do)-247(not)-247(necessarily)-248(affect)-247(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(essential)-379(matter,)-411(but)-379(we)-379(have)-379(to)-379(do)-379(with)-379(a)-379(scheme)-379(of)-378(religion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(claiming)-189(to)-190(be)-189(miraculous)-190(in)-189(all)-190(points,)-201(in)-190(form,)-201(in)-190(essence,)-201(and)-189(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence.)-327(This)-276(religion)-276(cannot)-275(be)-276(accepted)-276(without)-276(an)-275(emphatic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belief)-341(in)-340(supernatural)-341(interposition,)-363(and)-340(it)-341(is)-340(absurd)-341(to)-340(imagine)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-332(its)-664(dogmas)-332(can)-332(be)-331(held,)-353(whilst)-332(the)-332(miraculous)-332(is)-331(rejected.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([004])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(Those)-431(who)-430(profess)-431(to)-430(hold)-431(the)-431(religion,)-475(whilst)-431(they)-430(discredit)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-300(supernatural)-299(element,)-312(and)-300(they)-299(are)-300(many)-300(at)-299(the)-300(present)-299(day,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-292(widely)-293(receded)-292(from)-292(Ecclesiastical)-292(Christianity.)-377(It)-292(is)-292(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(important)-237(that)-237(the)-236(inseparable)-237(connection)-237(of)-237(the)-237(miraculous)-236(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-283(origin,)-291(doctrines,)-290(and)-283(the)-283(evidence)-282(of)-283(Christianity)-283(should)-282(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(clearly)-383(understood,)-416(in)-383(order)-382(that)-383(inquiry)-383(may)-383(pursue)-383(a)-382(logical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(consistent)-250(course.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.044 0 Td [(\035\024)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 15.753 0 Td [(Supernatural)-250(Religion,)-250(page)-250(1.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 134.847 3.959 Td [(1)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -234.688 -18.548 Td [(I)-269(fully)-270(accept)-269(all)-270(the)-269(chief)-270(positions)-269(laid)-270(down)-269(in)-270(this)-269(passage)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(as)-390(an)-389(adequate)-390(statement)-389(of)-390(the)-389(points)-390(at)-389(issue)-390(between)-389(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-445(affirm)-445(and)-445(those)-444(who)-445(deny)-445(that)-445(Christianity)-445(is)-445(a)-444(divine)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(revelation.)-377(A)-293(few)-292(minor)-293(points)-292(require)-293(a)-292(slight)-292(modification,)-303(as)]TJ
0 g 0 G
ET
q
1 0 0 1 46.771 98.681 cm
[]0 d 0 J 0.398 w 0 0 m 112.25 0 l S
Q
BT
/F16 5.9776 Tf 52.998 91.869 Td [(1)]TJ/F16 8.9664 Tf 5.729 -3.809 Td [(My)-329(quotations)-328(throughout)-329(this)-329(work)-328(are)-329(taken)-329(from)-328(the)-329(first)-329(edition.)-486(The)]TJ -11.956 -10.959 Td [(passage)-308(here)-308(quoted)-309(is)-308(somewhat)-308(altered)-308(in)-308(the)-308(third)-309(edition,)-322(but)-309(not)-308(so)-308(as)-308(to)]TJ 0 -10.959 Td [(affect)-250(the)-250(general)-250(meaning.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
63 0 obj <<
/Length 4831      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(8)-9255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(incurring)-223(the)-223(danger)-223(of)-223(confusing)-223(ideas)-223(that)-223(ought)-223(to)-223(be)-222(carefully)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinguished.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-373(writer)-373(before)-373(me)-374(also)-373(raises)-373(no)-373(minor)-373(issue.)-619(Although)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-365(work)-364(is)-365(entitled)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 91.66 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)-364(Religion,)-394(or)-364(an)-365(inquiry)-364(into)]TJ -96.504 -13.549 Td [(the)-266(reality)-265(of)-266(divine)-265(revelation,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 135.502 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.74 0 Td [(its)-266(object,)-269(which)-265(is)-266(consistently)]TJ -143.242 -13.55 Td [(carried)-371(out)-370(throughout)-371(it,)-401(is)-371(to)-370(impugn)-371(the)-371(historical)-370(character)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-359(the)-359(Gospels,)-386(and)-359(to)-359(prove)-359(that)-359(the)-359(supernatural)-359(occurrences)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-310(are)-311(recorded)-310(in)-311(them)-310(are)-311(fictitious.)-431(The)-310(title)-311(of)-310(the)-310(work)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(might)-295(have)-295(justified)-295(the)-294(writer)-295(in)-295(assailing)-295(other)-295(portions)-295(of)-294(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Bible;)-477(but)-402(he)-401(clearly)-401(sees)-402(that)-401(to)-401(adopt)-402(this)-401(course)-402(is)-401(only)-401(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(attack)-320(the)-319(outworks)-320(of)-320(Christianity,)-337(and)-319(to)-320(leave)-320(the)-319(key)-320(of)-319(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entire)-202(position)-202(unassailed.)-235(In)-202(doing)-202(so)-202(he)-203(has)-202(pursued)-202(a)-202(far)-202(nobler)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(course)-314(than)-314(that)-313(which)-314(has)-314(been)-314(adopted)-313(by)-314(many)-314(of)-314(the)-313(oppo-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nents)-224(of)-223(the)-224(Christian)-224(faith.)-241(He)-224(has)-224(directed)-223(his)-224(attack)-224(against)-223(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(very)-242(centre)-242(of)-242(the)-242(Christian)-242(position,)-244(the)-242(historical)-483(credibility)-242(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([005])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.55 Td [(the)-232(supernatural)-232(actions)-232(attributed)-232(to)-232(Jesus)-232(Christ)-232(in)-232(the)-231(Gospels,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-339(well)-340(aware)-339(that)-339(a)-340(successful)-339(assault)-339(on)-340(this)-339(position)-339(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(involve)-309(the)-308(capture)-309(of)-308(all)-308(the)-309(outworks)-308(by)-309(which)-308(it)-309(is)-308(supposed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-325(be)-326(protected;)-363(while)-325(it)-325(by)-326(no)-325(means)-325(follows)-326(that)-325(a)-325(successful)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assault)-379(on)-380(any)-379(of)-380(the)-379(latter)-379(involves)-380(the)-379(capture)-380(of)-379(the)-379(citadel)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(itself.)-450(This)-317(writer)-316(does)-317(not)-316(take)-317(up)-317(a)-316(bye)-317(question,)-333(but)-317(he)-316(goes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(direct)-387(to)-386(the)-387(foundation)-387(on)-386(which)-387(Christianity)-387(rests.)-660(In)-386(doing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so,)-288(it)-281(must)-280(be)-281(acknowledged)-280(that)-281(he)-280(has)-280(taken)-281(a)-280(straightforward)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(course,)-399(and)-369(one)-369(which)-369(must)-369(bring)-369(the)-369(question)-369(of)-369(the)-368(truth)-369(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(falsehood)-250(of)-250(Christianity)-250(to)-250(a)-250(direct)-250(issue.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-254(fully)-255(agree)-254(with)-255(the)-254(chief)-254(position)-255(taken)-254(in)-255(the)-254(quotation)-254(be-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(fore)-181(us,)-195(that)-182(Christianity)-181(involves)-181(the)-182(presence)-181(of)-181(the)-181(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-297(the)-297(superhuman,)-308(what)-297(in)-297(fact)-296(is)-297(generally)-297(designated)-297(as)-296(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miraculous,)-239(or)-237(it)-237(is)-237(nothing.)-245(To)-237(remove)-237(these)-236(elements)-237(out)-237(of)-236(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pages)-312(of)-313(the)-312(New)-312(Testament,)-328(is)-312(not)-312(to)-313(retain)-312(the)-312(same)-312(religion,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-343(to)-344(manufacture)-343(another)-343(quite)-343(different)-344(and)-343(distinct)-343(from)-343(it.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(In)-237(the)-236(first)-237(place,)-239(we)-237(have)-237(the)-236(great)-237(central)-237(figure)-236(in)-237(the)-236(Gospels,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-315(divine)-314(person)-315(of)-315(Jesus)-314(Christ)-315(our)-315(Lord,)-330(and)-315(the)-315(entire)-314(body)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-253(his)-252(actions)-253(and)-253(his)-253(teaching.)-258(He,)-253(although)-253(depicted)-253(as)-252(human,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
67 0 obj <<
/Length 4578      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 321.947 548.934 Td [(9)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -275.176 -30.759 Td [(is)-225(at)-225(the)-225(same)-226(time)-225(depicted)-225(as)-225(superhuman)-225(and)-225(supernatural,)-230(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(merely)-319(in)-318(his)-319(miraculous)-318(works,)-336(but)-318(in)-319(his)-318(entire)-319(character.)-455(To)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remove)-273(the)-272(divine)-273(lineaments)-273(of)-272(Jesus)-273(Christ)-273(out)-272(of)-273(the)-272(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-269(simply)-269(to)-270(destroy)-269(them.)-307(Besides)-270(this,)-274(we)-269(have)-269(a)-269(large)-269(number)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-331(miraculous)-331(actions)-331(attributed)-332(to)-331(him.)-493(These)-331(are)-331(inextricably)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interwoven)-241(with)-242(the)-241(entire)-241(narrative,)-243(which,)-243(when)-242(they)-241(are)-241(taken)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(away,)-409(loses)-378(all)-378(cohesion.)-632(Lives)-378(of)-377(Jesus)-378(which)-377(have)-378(been)-377(set)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forth,)-342(deprived)-324(of)-324(their)-324(supernatural)-324(and)-324(superhuman)-323(elements,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-369(in)-370(fact)-369(nothing)-369(better)-370(than)-369(a)-369(new)-370(Gospel)-369(composed)-369(out)-369(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-364(subjective)-365(consciousness)-364(of)-365(the)-729(writers.)-593(Various)-364(attempts)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([006])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(have)-285(been)-285(made)-285(to)-285(pare)-285(down)-285(the)-285(supernatural)-285(and)-284(superhuman)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(elements)-210(in)-210(the)-210(Gospels)-210(to)-211(the)-210(smallest)-210(possible)-210(dimensions.)-236(Still)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-256(obstinately)-255(persist)-256(in)-255(remaining.)-266(If)-256(everything)-255(else)-256(is)-255(struck)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(out)-359(of)-360(the)-359(Gospels,)-387(except)-359(their)-359(moral)-360(teaching,)-386(we)-360(are)-359(left)-359(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-234(presence)-234(of)-234(teaching)-235(which)-234(is)-234(raised)-234(at)-234(an)-234(immense)-234(elevation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(above)-295(the)-295(thoughts)-295(and)-295(conceptions)-295(of)-295(the)-295(age)-295(that)-295(produced)-295(it;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-315(of)-315(a)-315(teacher,)-331(who)-314(while)-315(distinguished)-315(by)-315(the)-315(marks)-315(of)-314(pre-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eminent)-256(holiness)-257(and)-256(greatness)-256(of)-257(mind,)-258(is)-256(also)-256(distinguished)-256(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-270(degree)-270(of)-269(self-assertion)-270(in)-270(his)-270(utterances)-269(of)-270(moral)-270(truth,)-274(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-283(without)-284(parallel,)-292(even)-283(among)-284(the)-283(most)-284(presumptuous)-283(of)-283(men.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Deal)-315(with)-314(the)-315(Gospels)-315(as)-314(we)-315(will,)-331(while)-314(we)-315(allow)-315(any)-314(portions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-238(them)-237(to)-238(remain)-237(as)-238(historical,)-240(we)-237(are)-238(still)-237(in)-238(the)-237(presence)-238(of)-237(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(superhuman.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(As)-209(the)-209(narrative)-209(now)-209(stands)-209(it)-209(is)-208(at)-209(least)-209(harmonious.)-237(The)-209(l)1(ofty)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(pretensions)-328(of)-328(the)-328(teacher)-328(bear)-328(the)-328(most)-328(intimate)-328(correlation)-327(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-294(supernatural)-294(and)-295(superhuman)-294(facts)-294(that)-294(are)-294(reported)-294(of)-294(him.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-226(one)-225(are)-226(the)-226(complement)-225(of)-226(the)-226(other.)-241(If)-226(the)-226(facts)-225(are)-226(true,)-230(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(lofty)-245(self-assertion)-246(of)-245(the)-246(teacher)-245(is)-246(justified;)-247(if)-245(they)-246(are)-245(not)-245(true,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-223(pretensions)-222(conflict)-223(with)-223(the)-223(entire)-222(conception)-223(of)-223(his)-222(holiness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-323(elevation)-323(of)-324(mind.)-469(The)-323(use)-324(which)-323(a)-323(wide)-323(spread)-323(school)-323(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modern)-251(criticism)-250(so)-251(freely)-251(makes)-251(of)-250(the)-251(critical)-251(dissecting)-250(knife,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-226(the)-226(purpose)-226(of)-226(amputating)-226(the)-226(supernatural)-226(from)-226(the)-226(Gospels,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(can)-334(only)-334(be)-334(attended)-334(by)-334(the)-334(fatal)-334(termination)-334(of)-334(destroying)-333(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entire)-218(Gospels)-218(as)-217(of)-218(the)-218(smallest)-218(historical)-218(value.)-239(It)-218(is)-217(marvellous)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
72 0 obj <<
/Length 4572      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(10)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(that)-295(persons)-295(who)-295(retain)-295(any)-295(respect)-295(for)-295(Christianity)-295(as)-295(a)-295(system)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-263(religious)-262(and)-263(moral)-262(teaching,)-266(should)-263(have)-262(attempted)-263(to)-262(throw)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discredit)-218(on)-218(this)-218(element)-218(in)-218(the)-218(Gospels)-218(with)-218(a)-218(view)-218(of)-218(saving)-217(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remainder.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Nor)-312(is)-312(the)-312(case)-312(different)-312(with)-312(the)-312(other)-312(portions)-312(of)-624(the)-312(New)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([007])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(Testament.)-561(Christianity,)-379(as)-354(enunciated)-353(by)-354(its)-353(writers,)-380(does)-353(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(profess)-351(merely)-351(to)-350(teach)-351(a)-351(new)-350(and)-351(improved)-351(system)-351(of)-350(moral-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ity.)-509(If)-336(this)-336(was)-336(its)-337(only)-336(pretension,)-358(it)-336(would)-336(certainly)-336(have)-336(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(little)-387(claim)-387(to)-387(be)-387(viewed)-388(as)-387(a)-387(divine)-387(revelation.)-661(In)-387(morals)-387(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(teaching)-341(is)-341(both)-341(unsystematic)-341(and)-342(fragmentary;)-386(though)-341(it)-341(is)-341(an)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(unquestionable)-323(fact,)-341(that)-323(a)-322(great)-323(system)-323(of)-323(moral)-323(teaching)-322(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-370(deduced)-370(from)-370(the)-370(principles)-370(it)-370(unfolds.)-610(But)-370(if)-370(one)-370(thing)-369(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(plainer)-428(than)-429(another)-428(on)-429(the)-428(face)-429(of)-428(the)-429(New)-428(Testament,)-473(it)-428(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-278(the)-278(great)-279(purpose)-278(sought)-278(to)-278(be)-279(effected)-278(by)-278(Christianity)-278(is)-278(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impart)-257(a)-258(new)-257(moral)-258(and)-257(spiritual)-258(power)-257(to)-258(mankind.)-272(It)-257(professes)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-233(be,)-236(not)-232(a)-233(body)-232(of)-233(moral)-232(rules,)-236(but)-233(a)-232(mighty)-233(moral)-232(force,)-236(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-304(concentrated)-304(in)-304(the)-304(person)-304(of)-304(its)-304(Founder.)-412(The)-304(acceptance)-303(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-355(had)-354(generated)-354(a)-355(new)-354(power)-355(or)-354(energy,)-381(a)-354(moral)-355(and)-354(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(life,)-268(which)-264(raised)-265(those)-264(who)-265(had)-264(embraced)-264(it)-265(above)-264(their)-264(former)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(selves;)-401(and)-350(which)-350(it)-351(professes)-350(to)-350(be)-351(able)-350(to)-350(impart)-351(to)-350(all)-350(time.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(This)-308(supernatural)-307(element,)-322(concentrated)-308(as)-307(I)-308(have)-308(said)-307(that)-308(it)-307(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-263(the)-262(person)-263(of)-262(its)-263(founder,)-266(runs)-262(through)-263(the)-262(entire)-263(epistles,)-265(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(constitutes)-294(their)-293(most)-294(distinguishing)-294(feature.)-381(If)-294(the)-293(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(elements)-389(in)-390(the)-389(person)-390(of)-389(Jesus)-390(Christ)-389(be)-390(removed)-389(from)-389(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(teaching)-229(nothing)-229(remains)-230(but)-229(a)-229(number)-229(of)-229(moral)-229(precepts)-229(robbed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-324(all)-324(their)-323(vitality.)-472(In)-323(one)-324(word,)-342(the)-324(whole)-324(system)-324(of)-323(teaching)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(simply)-250(collapses.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(In)-288(a)-289(similar)-288(manner,)-298(if)-289(we)-288(eliminate)-289(every)-288(thing)-288(supernatural)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(out)-253(of)-253(the)-252(New)-253(Testament,)-254(with)-253(a)-252(view)-253(of)-253(arriving)-253(at)-253(a)-252(residuum)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-362(truth,)-389(we)-362(are)-361(brought)-362(into)-361(immediate)-362(contact)-361(with)-362(the)-361(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unique)-404(fact)-403(in)-404(the)-404(history)-403(of)-404(man,)-442(the)-404(creation)-403(of)-404(the)-403(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-329(Jesus)-329(Christ,)-348(the)-329(greatest)-328(institution)-329(which)-329(has)-329(ever)-328(affected)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-351(destinies)-351(of)-351(our)-351(race,)-377(and)-351(which)-351(has)-351(for)-351(eighteen)-351(centuries)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exerted)-292(a)-293(most)-292(commanding)-293(influence)-292(on)-293(human)-292(happiness)-292(and)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
76 0 obj <<
/Length 4819      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(11)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(civilization.)-1310(This)-385(is)-385(professedly)-385(based)-385(on)-385(a)-385(miraculous)-385(fact,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([008])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(the)-367(Resurrection)-366(of)-367(Jesus)-367(Christ.)-600(If,)-395(therefore,)-396(we)-367(remove)-366(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-221(elements)-220(out)-221(of)-221(Christianity,)-226(this)-221(institution,)-226(mighty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-348(good)-348(in)-349(its)-348(influence)-348(on)-348(the)-348(progress)-348(of)-348(our)-349(race,)-372(has)-348(been)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(based)-309(on)-308(an)-309(unreality)-309(and)-308(a)-309(delusion.)-426(Here)-308(again)-309(we)-308(encounter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(something)-254(which)-254(has)-254(very)-254(much)-254(the)-254(appearance)-254(of)-254(the)-254(supernat-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ural.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(On)-351(these)-351(accounts,)-376(therefore,)-375(I)-351(cordially)-351(accept)-351(the)-350(position)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(which)-301(is)-300(laid)-301(down)-300(by)-301(the)-300(author)-301(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 161.971 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)-301(Religion)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.606 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.122 0 Td [(as)]TJ -271.543 -13.549 Td [(a)-419(correct)-419(statement)-418(of)-419(the)-419(case,)-461(that)-419(Christianity)-419(involves)-418(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presence)-359(of)-360(the)-359(Supernatural,)-387(or)-359(it)-359(is)-360(nothing.)-578(We)-359(must)-359(either)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(defend)-260(the)-261(chief)-260(supernatural)-260(elements)-260(of)-261(the)-260(New)-260(Testament)-260(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(abandon)-250(it)-250(as)-250(worthless.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(But)-255(there)-254(is)-255(an)-255(expression)-254(which)-255(occurs)-254(in)-255(this)-255(quotation,)-256(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(which)-241(is)-240(frequently)-241(made)-240(use)-241(of)-240(in)-240(subsequent)-241(parts)-240(of)-241(the)-240(work,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-188(requires)-188(consideration,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 129.588 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Ecclesiastical)-188(Christianity.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 115.678 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.892 0 Td [(What)]TJ -257.001 -13.549 Td [(is)-316(intended)-317(by)-316(it?)-448(The)-317(meaning)-316(is)-316(nowhere)-316(defined,)-333(and)-316(unless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-280(come)-280(to)-280(a)-280(clear)-280(understanding)-280(with)-281(respect)-280(to)-280(it,)-287(we)-280(shall)-280(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-370(danger)-370(of)-370(complicating)-370(the)-370(entire)-370(question.)-610(The)-370(expression)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-305(ambiguous.)-414(If)-305(by)-305(it)-305(is)-305(meant)-305(any)-304(other)-305(form)-305(of)-305(thought,)-318(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-243(which)-244(is)-243(contained)-243(in)-243(the)-243(pages)-244(of)-243(the)-243(New)-243(Testament;)-246(if,)-244(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact,)-219(by)-211(it)-211(is)-211(intended)-211(a)-211(systematic)-211(arrangement)-211(of)-211(doctrinal)-210(truth,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-219(has)-220(been)-219(elaborated)-220(at)-219(a)-219(subsequent)-220(period,)-225(I)-219(emphatically)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assert)-294(that)-293(those)-294(who)-294(are)-293(called)-294(upon)-294(to)-293(defend)-294(the)-294(divine)-293(char-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(acter)-259(of)-259(the)-259(Christian)-259(Revelation)-258(have)-259(nothing)-259(to)-259(do)-259(with)-259(it.)-276(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-371(thing)-371(which)-371(those)-370(who)-371(maintain)-371(that)-371(the)-371(New)-370(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contains)-369(a)-369(divine)-369(revelation)-370(can)-369(be)-369(called)-369(on)-369(to)-369(defend,)-399(is)-369(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(express)-214(statements)-215(of)-214(the)-215(book)-214(itself,)-222(and)-214(not)-214(a)-215(system)-214(of)-214(thought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-238(subsequent)-239(writers)-238(may)-239(have)-238(attempted)-238(to)-239(deduce)-238(from)-238(it.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([009])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -15.186 Td [(This)-205(point)-205(is)-206(so)-205(important,)-214(that)-205(I)-206(must)-205(make)-205(the)-205(position)-206(which)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(I)-349(intend)-348(taking)-349(with)-348(respect)-349(to)-349(it)-348(clear.)-546(It)-349(involves)-349(the)-348(distinc-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-331(between)-331(revelation)-331(and)-332(theology.)-493(The)-331(religious)-331(and)-331(moral)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(teaching)-329(which)-329(is)-329(contained)-328(in)-329(the)-329(New)-329(Testament)-329(is)-329(in)-329(a)-328(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unsystematic)-240(form.)-246(Not)-240(one)-240(of)-239(its)-240(writings)-240(is)-239(a)-240(formal)-240(treatise)-239(on)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
81 0 obj <<
/Length 4354      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(12)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(theology,)-245(nor)-245(does)-244(one)-244(of)-244(them)-245(contain)-244(a)-244(systematised)-244(statement)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-359(what)-358(constitutes)-359(Christianity.)-576(Its)-359(teaching)-358(of)-359(religious)-358(truth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-413(incidental,)-453(and)-413(is)-413(called)-413(forth)-413(by)-413(the)-413(special)-412(circumstances)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-348(the)-347(writer.)-543(The)-348(plain)-348(fact)-347(is)-348(that)-348(four)-347(of)-348(the)-348(writings)-347(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(comprise)-321(the)-322(New)-321(Testament)-321(are)-322(religions)-321(memoirs.)-464(One)-321(is)-321(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-292(account)-293(of)-292(the)-292(foundation)-293(of)-292(the)-292(Church.)-377(Twenty-one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-265(letters,)-269(written)-266(to)-265(different)-265(Churches)-266(and)-265(individuals,)-269(and)-265(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(called)-407(forth)-408(by)-407(special)-408(emergencies.)-722(These)-407(all)-408(partake)-407(of)-407(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-296(character.)-389(The)-296(only)-296(one)-296(which)-296(does)-296(not)-296(participate)-296(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-242(character)-242(is)-241(the)-242(Apocalypse,)-243(which,)-244(being)-242(a)-241(vision,)-244(is)-241(utterly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unlike)-266(a)-265(formal)-266(or)-265(systematic)-266(treatise)-266(on)-265(Christianity.)-297(The)-265(result)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-394(the)-395(form)-394(in)-395(which)-394(the)-394(New)-395(Testament)-394(is)-395(composed)-394(is)-394(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-401(definite)-401(teaching)-400(is)-401(always)-401(incidental,)-438(called)-401(forth)-401(to)-400(meet)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(special)-320(circumstances)-321(and)-320(occasions)-320(in)-321(the)-320(history)-320(of)-320(Churches)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-258(individuals,)-260(and)-258(never)-258(formal.)-274(It)-258(is)-258(also)-258(universally)-257(couched)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-268(popular,)-272(as)-268(distinct)-268(from)-268(scientific)-267(or)-268(technical)-268(language.)-303(Not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-410(of)-409(its)-410(writers)-409(makes)-410(an)-410(attempt)-409(to)-410(formulate)-409(a)-410(system)-409(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-250(theology.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-230(person)-231(of)-230(Jesus)-230(Christ)-230(constitutes)-231(Christianity)-230(in)-230(its)-230(truest)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(and)-251(highest)-250(sense.)-252(Three)-251(of)-250(the)-251(Gospels)-250(embody)-251(the)-250(traditionary)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(teaching)-336(of)-336(the)-336(Church)-336(on)-335(this)-336(subject.)-508(The)-336(fourth)-336(is)-336(the)-335(work)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-420(an)-419(independent)-420(writer.)-759(The)-420(epistles)-420(may)-419(be)-420(received)-420(as)-419(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(set)-290(of)-289(incidental)-290(commentaries)-289(on)-290(the)-289(person)-290(and)-289(work)-290(of)-289(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ,)-416(called)-383(forth)-383(by)-382(the)-383(special)-383(occasions)-383(which)-383(gave)-382(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(birth,)-299(and)-288(embodying)-289(the)-289(author's)-289(general)-288(views)-289(as)-289(to)-289(his)-577(work)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([010])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(and)-378(teaching)-377(as)-378(adapted)-377(to)-377(a)-378(number)-377(of)-378(special)-377(circumstances)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-250(occasions.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Between)-236(the)-235(contents)-236(of)-235(the)-236(New)-235(Testament)-236(and)-235(what)-236(is)-235(com-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(monly)-231(understood)-231(by)-231(Ecclesiastical)-231(Christianity)-231(the)-231(difference)-230(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(extremely)-337(wide.)-511(The)-337(New)-337(Testament)-337(contains)-337(a)-337(divine)-336(revela-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion.)-526(Ecclesiastical)-342(Christianity)-342(is)-342(a)-342(body)-342(of)-342(religious)-342(teaching)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-384(which)-384(Christianity)-384(has)-383(been)-384(attempted)-384(to)-384(be)-384(presented)-384(in)-383(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(systematised)-336(form,)-356(or,)-357(in)-336(other)-335(words,)-357(it)-336(is)-335(a)-335(theology)-336(more)-335(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(less)-250(complete.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
85 0 obj <<
/Length 4614      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(13)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -257.765 -30.759 Td [(It)-408(is)-408(necessary)-408(that)-408(we)-408(should)-408(have)-408(a)-408(clear)-408(appreciation)-407(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-387(difference.)-661(Theology)-387(is)-387(an)-387(attempt)-387(of)-387(the)-387(human)-386(intellect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-467(present)-467(to)-467(us)-467(the)-467(truths)-467(communicated)-467(in)-467(Revelation)-467(in)-467(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(systematised)-349(form.)-546(It)-349(is)-348(in)-349(fact)-349(the)-349(result)-348(of)-349(the)-349(human)-348(reason)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(investigating)-337(the)-337(facts)-337(and)-337(statements)-337(of)-337(Revelation.)-510(Theology)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-384(is)-385(a)-384(simple)-384(creation)-384(of)-384(human)-385(reason)-384(erected)-384(on)-384(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(facts)-316(of)-316(divine)-316(revelation.)-447(As)-316(such)-316(it)-316(is)-316(subject)-316(to)-316(all)-316(the)-315(errors)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-331(imperfections)-330(to)-331(which)-331(our)-330(rational)-331(powers)-331(are)-330(obnoxious.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-323(can)-323(claim)-322(no)-323(infallibility)-323(more)-322(than)-323(any)-323(other)-323(rational)-322(action)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-289(the)-290(human)-289(mind.)-368(Theology)-289(is)-290(a)-289(science,)-299(and)-289(is)-290(subject)-289(to)-289(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(imperfections)-295(to)-294(which)-295(all)-294(other)-295(sciences)-294(are)-295(liable.)-383(It)-295(stands)-294(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-323(facts)-322(of)-323(Christianity)-323(in)-322(the)-323(same)-323(relation)-322(as)-323(philosophy)-322(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical)-392(science)-391(stand)-392(to)-391(the)-392(works)-391(of)-392(nature.)-675(In)-391(the)-392(one)-391(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(human)-382(intellect)-381(investigates)-382(the)-382(divine)-381(revelation)-382(contained)-381(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-278(works)-277(of)-278(nature,)-284(and)-278(endeavours)-278(to)-277(systematise)-278(its)-277(truths:)-305(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-334(other)-334(it)-334(does)-333(the)-334(same)-334(with)-334(respect)-334(to)-334(the)-334(divine)-333(revelation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-328(in)-328(accordance)-328(with)-328(the)-328(assertions)-328(of)-328(the)-328(New)-328(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-250(been)-250(made)-250(in)-250(the)-250(person)-250(of)-250(Jesus)-250(Christ.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(What)-259(I)-260(am)-259(desirous)-259(of)-260(drawing)-259(attention)-259(to)-260(is)-259(that)-259(theology)-259(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(not)-270(revelation.)-310(Systems)-270(of)-270(theology)-270(may)-270(be)-270(accurate)-270(deductions)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-207(reason)-206(from)-207(Revelation;)-221(or)-413(they)-206(may)-207(be)-206(inaccurate)-207(and)-206(imper-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([011])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(fect)-248(ones.)-249(It)-248(is)-248(very)-248(possible)-248(that)-248(a)-248(system)-248(of)-248(theology)-248(which)-248(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-359(evolved)-359(by)-358(human)-359(reason,)-386(although)-359(it)-359(may)-359(have)-358(attained)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-319(wide)-318(acceptance,)-336(may)-319(be)-319(as)-319(inadequate)-318(an)-319(explanation)-319(of)-318(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(facts)-248(of)-248(revelation,)-248(as)-248(the)-247(Ptolemaic)-248(system)-248(of)-248(astronomy)-248(was)-247(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-276(facts)-276(of)-276(the)-276(material)-276(universe.)-328(Objections)-276(which)-276(were)-276(raised)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(against)-390(the)-389(latter)-390(were)-390(no)-390(real)-389(objections)-390(against)-390(the)-389(structure)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-373(the)-373(universe)-374(itself.)-619(In)-373(the)-374(same)-373(way)-373(objections)-373(which)-373(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-286(raised)-286(against)-286(a)-286(particular)-286(system)-286(of)-286(theology,)-295(may)-286(leave)-285(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-250(facts)-250(of)-250(revelation)-250(entirely)-250(untouched.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(If)-316(we)-316(look)-315(into)-316(the)-316(history)-316(of)-316(Christianity,)-332(we)-316(shall)-316(find)-316(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(as)-303(soon)-304(as)-303(the)-304(Church)-303(began)-303(to)-304(consolidate)-303(itself)-304(into)-303(a)-303(distinct)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(community,)-211(the)-201(reason)-201(of)-201(man)-202(began)-201(to)-201(exert)-201(itself)-201(on)-201(the)-201(facts)-201(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(revelation,)-315(and)-302(to)-302(attempt)-302(to)-302(reduce)-302(its)-302(teaching)-302(to)-302(a)-302(systematic)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
89 0 obj <<
/Length 4710      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(14)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(form.)-827(From)-442(this)-443(source)-442(have)-442(sprung)-443(all)-442(the)-442(various)-442(systems)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-328(theology)-329(which)-328(have)-328(from)-328(time)-328(to)-329(time)-328(predominated)-328(in)-328(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church.)-357(It)-285(has)-286(been)-286(a)-285(plant)-286(of)-286(gradual)-285(growth,)-295(and)-285(as)-286(such)-285(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bear)-367(a)-368(fair)-367(comparison)-367(with)-367(the)-367(slow)-368(growth)-367(of)-367(philosophy)-367(or)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(physical)-298(science.)-393(Such)-298(an)-297(action)-298(of)-298(reason)-298(on)-297(the)-298(facts)-298(of)-297(reve-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lation)-237(was)-238(inevitable)-237(and)-237(entirely)-238(legitimate.)-245(What)-238(I)-237(am)-237(desirous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-237(guarding)-236(against)-237(is)-237(the)-237(idea)-236(that)-237(when)-237(reason)-236(is)-237(exerted)-237(on)-236(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(facts)-235(of)-235(revelation,)-239(it)-235(is)-235(more)-235(infallible)-236(than)-235(when)-235(exerted)-235(on)-235(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-250(subjects)-250(which)-250(come)-250(under)-250(its)-250(cognisance.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-341(am)-341(not)-341(ignorant)-341(that)-341(there)-341(is)-341(another)-341(theory)-341(respecting)-341(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(nature)-236(of)-236(theology.)-245(A)-236(large)-235(branch)-236(of)-236(the)-236(Christian)-236(Church)-235(holds)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-328(a)-329(body)-328(of)-329(dogmatic)-328(statements)-329(has)-328(been)-329(handed)-328(down)-328(tra-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ditionally)-315(from)-314(the)-315(Apostles)-315(and)-314(other)-315(inspired)-315(teachers,)-330(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-284(been)-284(embodied)-284(in)-284(the)-284(system)-284(of)-284(theology)-284(which)-284(is)-283(accepted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-248(this)-248(Church,)-248(and)-248(that)-248(this)-248(was)-248(intended)-248(to)-496(be)-248(an)-248(authoritative)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([012])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(statement)-310(of)-311(the)-310(facts)-310(of)-310(the)-311(Christian)-310(revelation.)-431(It)-310(is)-310(also)-310(part)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-343(the)-343(same)-343(theory)-344(that)-343(the)-343(Church)-343(as)-343(a)-343(collective)-343(body)-343(has)-343(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-297(ages)-296(possessed)-297(an)-297(inspiration,)-308(which)-297(enables)-296(it)-297(to)-297(affirm)-296(au-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thoritatively)-256(and)-257(dogmatically,)-258(what)-256(is)-256(and)-257(what)-256(is)-256(not)-256(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(doctrine,)-312(and)-299(that)-299(which)-299(it)-299(thus)-300(authoritatively)-299(affirms)-299(to)-299(be)-299(so,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(must)-218(be)-218(accepted)-217(as)-218(a)-218(portion)-218(of)-217(the)-218(Christian)-218(revelation)-218(as)-217(much)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-250(the)-250(contents)-250(of)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)-250(itself.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-375(fully)-375(admit)-376(that)-375(those)-375(who)-376(assume)-375(a)-375(position)-376(of)-375(this)-375(kind)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(are)-324(bound)-324(to)-323(act)-324(consistently,)-342(and)-324(to)-324(defend)-324(every)-324(statement)-323(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-276(dogmatic)-276(creeds)-275(as)-276(an)-276(integral)-276(portion)-275(of)-276(Christianity.)-327(Nor)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-355(it)-355(less)-356(certain,)-381(if)-355(this)-356(principle)-355(is)-355(true,)-382(that)-355(if)-355(any)-355(portion)-355(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-254(dogmatic)-254(creeds)-254(can)-254(be)-254(successfully)-254(assailed)-254(as)-254(contrary)-254(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(reason,)-314(as)-302(for)-301(instance)-302(the)-301(formulated)-302(doctrine)-301(of)-301(transubstanti-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ation,)-287(it)-280(would)-280(imperil)-279(the)-280(position)-280(of)-280(Christianity)-279(itself.)-339(Those,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(however,)-416(who)-383(have)-383(taken)-382(such)-383(positions,)-416(must)-383(be)-383(left)-383(to)-382(take)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-290(consequences)-289(of)-290(them.)-369(It)-290(is)-290(not)-289(my)-290(intention)-290(in)-289(undertaking)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-284(defend)-284(the)-284(historical)-284(truth)-284(of)-284(the)-284(supernatural)-284(elements)-284(in)-283(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(New)-293(Testament,)-303(to)-293(burden)-293(myself)-292(with)-293(an)-293(armour)-293(which)-292(seems)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-317(fitted)-317(to)-317(crash)-318(beneath)-317(its)-317(weight)-317(the)-317(person)-317(who)-317(attempts)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
93 0 obj <<
/Length 4883      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(15)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(to)-250(use)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-410(has)-410(been)-410(necessary)-409(to)-410(be)-410(explicit)-410(on)-410(this)-410(point,)-450(in)-409(order)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-281(the)-281(argument)-281(may)-282(be)-281(kept)-281(free)-281(from)-281(all)-281(adventitious)-281(issues.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-274(introduction)-274(into)-275(it)-274(of)-274(the)-274(expression,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 186.145 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Ecclesiastical)-274(Chris-)]TJ -190.988 -13.549 Td [(tianity,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30.611 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.644 0 Td [(brings)-257(with)-256(it)-257(no)-257(inconsiderable)-257(danger)-256(of)-257(diverting)-257(our)]TJ -38.255 -13.55 Td [(attention)-443(from)-442(what)-443(is)-442(the)-443(real)-442(point)-443(of)-442(controversy.)-828(I)-442(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-325(repeat)-325(it.)-474(Ecclesiastical)-325(Christianity)-325(is)-325(a)-324(development)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-399(by)-399(reason)-399(from)-398(the)-399(facts)-399(of)-399(the)-399(New)-399(Testament,)-436(and)-398(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-334(thing)-334(which)-333(is)-334(entirely)-334(distinct)-334(from)-333(the)-334(contents)-334(of)-334(the)-333(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament.)-233(With)-200(its)-200(affirmations)-200(therefore)-200(I)-200(have)-200(nothing)-200(to)-200(do)-200(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-473(present)-237(discussion.)-246(It)-236(will)-237(not)-237(be)-236(my)-237(duty)-236(to)-237(examine)-237(into)-236(its)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([013])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(positions,)-266(with)-263(a)-263(view)-262(of)-263(ascertaining)-263(whether)-263(they)-263(are)-262(develop-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ments)-211(of)-210(Christian)-211(teaching)-210(which)-211(can)-211(be)-210(logically)-211(deduced)-210(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-277(pages;)-291(still)-277(less)-277(to)-277(accept)-276(and)-277(to)-277(defend)-277(them)-277(as)-277(authoritative)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(statements)-326(of)-327(its)-326(meaning.)-479(In)-326(defending)-327(the)-326(New)-326(Testament)-326(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(containing)-199(a)-199(divine)-199(revelation,)-209(I)-199(have)-199(only)-199(to)-199(do)-199(with)-199(the)-199(contents)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-389(assertions)-388(of)-388(the)-389(book)-388(itself,)-424(and)-388(with)-389(nothing)-388(outside)-388(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pages.)-236(What)-210(others)-209(may)-209(have)-210(propounded)-209(respecting)-209(its)-209(meaning)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-321(form)-322(no)-321(legitimate)-321(portion)-322(of)-321(the)-321(present)-322(controversy.)-463(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(real)-208(point)-208(at)-208(issue)-208(is)-208(one)-208(which)-208(is)-208(simple)-208(and)-208(distinct.)-236(It)-208(is,)-216(are)-208(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supernatural)-209(incidents)-209(recorded)-209(in)-209(it)-209(historical)-209(events)-209(or)-209(fictitious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inventions?)-440(As)-313(that)-313(is)-313(the)-313(question)-314(before)-313(us,)-329(I)-313(must)-313(decline)-313(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(allow)-367(any)-368(other)-367(issue)-368(to)-367(be)-367(substituted)-368(in)-367(the)-368(place)-367(of)-367(it.)-602(Our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inquiry)-250(is)-250(one)-250(which)-250(is)-250(strictly)-250(historical.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Another)-447(statement)-448(made)-447(by)-447(the)-448(author)-447(before)-447(me)-447(requires)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(qualification.)-403(He)-301(says)-301(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 119.986 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Christianity)-301(is)-301(a)-301(scheme)-301(of)-301(religion)]TJ -124.83 -13.549 Td [(which)-270(claims)-269(to)-270(be)-270(miraculous)-269(in)-270(all)-270(points,)-274(in)-270(form,)-275(in)-269(essence,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-278(in)-279(evidence.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 71.809 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.879 0 Td [(This)-278(statement)-279(I)-278(must)-278(controvert.)-335(Christianity)]TJ -79.688 -13.549 Td [(does)-336(not)-336(profess)-336(to)-336(be)-336(divine)-336(on)-336(all)-337(points.)-508(On)-336(the)-336(contrary,)-357(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contains)-248(a)-247(divine)-248(and)-247(a)-248(human)-248(element)-247(so)-248(intimately)-247(united,)-248(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-299(is)-298(impossible)-299(to)-298(separate)-299(the)-298(one)-298(from)-299(the)-298(other.)-396(It)-298(is)-299(also)-298(far)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-359(clear)-360(to)-359(me)-360(how)-359(it)-360(can)-359(be)-359(miraculous)-360(in)-359(form)-360(when)-359(it)-359(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(contained)-191(in)-192(a)-191(body)-192(of)-191(historical)-191(writings.)-231(I)-191(shall)-192(have)-191(occasion)-191(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(show)-219(hereafter,)-225(that)-219(although)-218(miracles)-219(form)-219(an)-219(important)-218(portion)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
98 0 obj <<
/Length 4639      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(16)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(attestation)-250(on)-250(which)-250(it)-250(rests,)-250(they)-250(are)-250(not)-250(the)-250(only)-250(one.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(With)-305(these)-304(qualifications)-305(I)-305(fully)-305(accept)-304(the)-305(position)-305(taken)-304(by)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(this)-314(writer)-314(as)-313(a)-314(correct)-314(statement)-314(of)-313(the)-314(points)-314(at)-314(issue)-313(between)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-253(who)-253(affirm,)-254(and)-253(those)-254(who)-253(deny)-253(the)-253(claims)-253(of)-253(Christianity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-257(be)-258(a)-257(divine)-258(revelation,)-259(and)-515(accept)-258(his)-257(challenge)-258(to)-257(defend)-257(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([014])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-253(elements)-254(in)-253(the)-253(New)-254(Testament,)-254(or)-253(to)-254(abandon)-253(it)-253(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(worthless.)-243(To)-229(maintain)-229(that)-229(any)-230(of)-229(its)-229(dogmas)-229(can)-229(be)-229(accepted)-229(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(true)-223(while)-223(its)-223(miraculous)-222(elements)-223(are)-223(abandoned)-223(seems)-223(to)-223(me)-222(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(involve)-250(a)-250(question)-250(which)-250(is)-250(hopelessly)-250(illogical.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Modern)-297(unbelief)-298(rejects)-297(every)-297(supernatural)-298(occurrence)-297(as)-297(ut-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(terly)-281(incredible.)-344(Before)-281(proceeding)-281(to)-282(examine)-281(into)-281(the)-281(grounds)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-359(this,)-387(it)-359(will)-359(be)-359(necessary)-359(to)-359(lay)-359(down)-359(definitely)-359(the)-359(bearing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-254(the)-253(present)-254(argument)-253(on)-254(the)-254(principles)-253(of)-254(atheism,)-254(pantheism,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(theism.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(As)-489(far)-489(as)-488(the)-489(impossibility)-489(of)-489(supernatural)-489(occurrences)-488(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(concerned,)-453(pantheism)-412(and)-411(atheism)-412(occupy)-412(precisely)-412(the)-412(same)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(grounds.)-546(If)-349(either)-349(of)-349(them)-349(propounds)-348(a)-349(true)-349(theory)-349(of)-349(the)-348(uni-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(verse,)-444(any)-405(supernatural)-406(occurrence,)-444(which)-405(necessarily)-405(implies)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-425(supernatural)-425(agent)-425(to)-425(bring)-425(it)-425(about,)-469(is)-425(impossible,)-468(and)-425(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entire)-205(controversy)-205(as)-205(to)-204(whether)-205(miracles)-205(have)-205(ever)-205(been)-204(actually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performed)-348(is)-348(a)-349(foregone)-348(conclusion.)-544(Modern)-349(atheism,)-372(while)-348(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(does)-200(not)-200(venture)-200(in)-200(categorical)-200(terms)-200(to)-200(affirm)-200(that)-200(no)-200(God)-200(exists,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(definitely)-349(asserts)-349(that)-348(there)-349(is)-349(no)-349(evidence)-349(that)-348(there)-349(is)-349(one.)-546(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(follows)-398(that)-398(if)-398(there)-398(is)-398(no)-398(evidence)-398(that)-398(there)-398(is)-398(a)-398(God,)-434(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-305(be)-306(no)-305(evidence)-305(that)-306(a)-305(miracle)-305(ever)-306(has)-305(been)-305(performed,)-319(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-394(very)-393(idea)-394(of)-394(a)-394(miracle)-393(implies)-394(the)-394(idea)-394(of)-393(a)-394(God)-394(to)-393(work)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(one.)-408(If)-302(therefore)-303(atheism)-302(is)-303(true,)-316(all)-302(controversy)-303(about)-302(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-327(useless.)-481(They)-327(are)-327(simply)-327(impossible,)-346(and)-327(to)-327(inquire)-326(whether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-332(impossible)-331(event)-332(has)-331(happened)-332(is)-331(absurd.)-495(To)-331(such)-332(a)-331(person)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-301(historical)-302(enquiry,)-314(as)-302(far)-301(as)-301(a)-302(miracle)-301(is)-302(concerned,)-314(must)-301(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-289(foregone)-289(conclusion.)-367(It)-289(might)-289(have)-289(a)-289(little)-289(interest)-289(as)-289(a)-288(matter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-382(curiosity;)-448(but)-383(even)-382(if)-382(the)-382(most)-382(unequivocal)-382(evidence)-382(could)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-296(adduced)-295(that)-296(an)-295(occurrence)-296(such)-295(as)-296(we)-295(call)-296(supernatural)-295(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taken)-303(place,)-315(the)-303(utmost)-302(that)-303(it)-302(could)-303(prove)-302(would)-303(be)-302(that)-303(some)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([015])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
103 0 obj <<
/Length 4649      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(17)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(most)-297(extraordinary)-298(and)-297(abnormal)-297(fact)-297(had)-298(taken)-297(place)-297(in)-297(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-306(which)-306(we)-306(did)-306(not)-306(know)-306(the)-306(cause.)-418(But)-306(to)-306(prove)-306(a)-306(miracle)-305(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-228(person)-229(who)-228(consistently)-229(denies)-228(that)-229(he)-228(has)-229(any)-228(evidence)-228(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-361(being)-362(exists)-361(which)-362(is)-361(not)-362(a)-361(portion)-362(of)-361(and)-362(included)-361(in)-361(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(material)-250(universe,)-250(or)-250(developed)-250(out)-250(of)-250(it,)-250(is)-250(impossible.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Nor)-227(does)-227(the)-228(case)-227(differ)-227(in)-227(any)-228(material)-227(sense)-227(with)-227(pantheism.)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(When)-423(we)-424(have)-423(got)-423(rid)-423(of)-424(its)-423(hazy)-423(mysticism,)-467(and)-423(applied)-423(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-379(clear)-379(principles)-379(of)-378(logic,)-411(its)-379(affirmation)-379(is)-379(that)-379(God)-379(and)-378(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Universe)-220(are)-220(one,)-226(and)-220(that)-220(all)-220(past)-220(and)-220(present)-220(forms)-220(of)-219(existence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-286(been)-286(the)-287(result)-286(of)-286(the)-286(Universe,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 165.245 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 17.242 0 Td [(God,)-295(everlastingly)-286(de-)]TJ -182.487 -13.549 Td [(veloping)-303(himself)-303(in)-303(conformity)-303(with)-303(immutable)-303(law.)-409(All)-302(things)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-262(either)-262(have)-262(existed)-261(or)-262(exist)-262(are)-262(as)-262(many)-262(manifestations)-261(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God,)-223(who)-216(is)-216(in)-215(fact)-216(an)-216(infinite)-216(impersonal)-216(Proteus,)-223(ever)-215(changing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-239(his)-240(outward)-239(form.)-247(From)-239(him,)-241(or)-240(to)-239(speak)-240(more)-239(correctly,)-241(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-187(\050for)-187(he)-187(is)-187(no)-187(person\051,)-200(all)-187(things)-187(have)-187(issued)-187(as)-186(mere)-187(phenomenal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(babbles)-194(of)-194(the)-194(passing)-193(moment,)-205(and)-194(by)-194(it)-194(will)-194(be)-194(again)-193(swallowed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(up)-336(in)-336(never-ending)-336(succession.)-509(Such)-336(a)-336(God)-336(must)-336(be)-336(devoid)-336(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(everything)-464(which)-465(we)-464(understand)-464(by)-465(personality,)-517(intelligence,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wisdom,)-353(volition)-332(or)-332(a)-332(moral)-332(nature.)-496(It)-332(is)-332(evident)-332(therefore)-332(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-262(a)-261(person)-262(who)-261(logically)-262(and)-261(consistently)-262(holds)-261(these)-262(views)-261(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrence)-235(of)-236(a)-235(miracle)-236(is)-235(no)-236(less)-235(an)-235(impossibility)-236(than)-235(it)-236(is)-235(to)-235(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(atheist,)-295(for)-286(the)-286(conception)-286(of)-286(a)-286(miracle)-286(involves)-286(the)-286(presence)-286(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(personality,)-361(intelligence,)-361(and)-339(power)-338(at)-339(the)-339(disposal)-339(of)-338(volition.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(All)-367(that)-367(the)-367(strongest)-368(evidence)-367(could)-367(prove)-367(to)-367(those)-367(who)-367(hold)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-291(principles,)-302(is)-291(that)-292(some)-291(abnormal)-291(event)-292(had)-291(taken)-291(place)-291(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(the)-250(cause)-250(was)-250(unknown.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-432(is)-432(evident,)-478(therefore,)-477(that)-432(the)-432(only)-432(course)-432(which)-432(can)-432(be)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(pursued)-297(with)-296(a)-297(professed)-296(atheist)-297(or)-297(pantheist,)-308(is)-296(to)-297(grapple)-296(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(him)-325(on)-324(the)-325(evidences)-325(of)-324(theism,)-343(and)-325(to)-325(endeavour)-324(to)-325(prove)-324(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(existence)-359(of)-359(a)-359(God)-359(possessed)-717(of)-359(personality,)-386(intelligence,)-386(vo-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([016])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(lition,)-363(and)-341(adequate)-341(power,)-363(before)-340(we)-341(attempt)-341(to)-340(deal)-341(with)-340(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidences)-313(of)-313(miracles.)-439(Until)-313(we)-313(have)-313(convinced)-313(him)-313(of)-313(this)-313(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-250(reasonings)-250(must)-250(be)-250(in)-250(vain.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(There)-356(are)-355(four)-356(modes)-356(of)-355(reasoning)-356(by)-356(which)-355(the)-356(being)-356(of)-355(a)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
107 0 obj <<
/Length 4680      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(18)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(God)-228(may)-227(be)-228(established.)-242(I)-227(will)-228(simply)-227(enumerate)-228(them.)-242(First,)-232(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(argument)-206(which)-206(is)-206(founded)-205(on)-206(the)-206(principle)-206(of)-206(causation;)-220(second,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-279(which)-279(rests)-278(on)-279(the)-279(order)-278(of)-279(the)-279(universe;)-293(third,)-286(that)-279(from)-278(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(innumerable)-298(adaptations;)-323(fourth,)-310(that)-298(which)-299(is)-298(derived)-298(from)-298(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(moral)-200(nature)-201(and)-200(personality)-200(of)-201(man.)-233(If)-200(the)-201(argument)-200(from)-200(causa-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-269(fails)-269(to)-269(prove)-269(to)-269(those)-269(with)-269(whom)-269(we)-269(are)-269(reasoning)-269(that)-268(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(finite)-228(causes)-228(in)-228(the)-228(universe)-228(must)-228(have)-228(a)-228(first)-228(cause)-228(from)-228(whence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-222(have)-222(originated;)-231(if)-222(that)-222(from)-222(the)-222(orderly)-222(arrangements)-222(in)-222(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(universe)-203(fails)-202(to)-203(prove)-202(that)-202(there)-203(must)-202(be)-203(an)-202(intelligent)-203(being)-202(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(produced)-368(them;)-427(if)-369(its)-368(innumerable)-368(adaptations)-368(fail)-368(to)-368(establish)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-251(presence)-250(of)-251(a)-250(presiding)-251(mind;)-251(and)-250(if)-251(the)-251(moral)-250(nature)-251(of)-250(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fails)-260(to)-259(prove)-260(that)-260(must)-260(be)-259(a)-260(moral)-260(being)-259(from)-260(whom)-260(that)-259(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(emanated,)-250(and)-251(of)-250(whom)-250(it)-250(is)-251(the)-250(image,)-250(it)-251(follows)-250(that)-250(the)-250(minds)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-245(be)-245(so)-245(differently)-245(constituted)-245(as)-245(to)-245(offer)-245(no)-245(common)-244(ground)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(or)-355(basis)-354(of)-355(reasoning)-354(on)-355(this)-354(question.)-564(The)-354(whole)-355(involves)-354(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(essential)-420(difference)-419(of)-420(principle,)-462(which)-420(no)-420(argumentation)-419(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(really)-336(reach.)-508(To)-335(attempt)-336(to)-336(prove)-336(to)-336(a)-336(mind)-336(of)-336(this)-335(description)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(occurrence)-250(of)-250(a)-250(miracle,)-250(is)-250(simply)-250(a)-250(waste)-250(of)-250(labour.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(A)-427(work,)-471(therefore,)-471(on)-427(the)-426(subject)-427(of)-427(miracles)-427(can)-427(only)-426(be)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(addressed)-371(to)-371(theists,)-401(because)-371(the)-371(very)-371(conception)-371(of)-371(a)-371(miracle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(involves)-213(the)-213(existence)-213(of)-213(a)-213(personal)-213(God.)-238(To)-213(take)-213(this)-213(for)-213(granted)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-313(reasoning)-314(with)-313(a)-314(pantheist)-313(or)-313(atheist)-314(is)-313(simply)-314(to)-313(assume)-313(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(point)-441(at)-441(issue.)-824(It)-441(is)-441(perfectly)-441(true,)-489(that)-441(a)-441(legitimate)-441(body)-441(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reasoning)-416(may)-416(be)-416(constructed,)-457(if)-416(the)-416(pantheist)-416(or)-416(the)-831(atheist)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([017])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(agrees)-227(to)-228(assume)-227(that)-228(a)-227(God)-227(exists)-228(for)-227(the)-227(purpose)-228(of)-227(supplying)-227(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(basis)-285(for)-286(the)-285(argument.)-356(We)-285(may)-285(then)-286(reason)-285(with)-285(him)-285(precisely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-287(the)-288(same)-287(way)-287(as)-288(we)-287(would)-287(with)-287(a)-288(theist.)-362(But)-287(the)-287(contest)-287(will)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-241(with)-242(one)-241(who)-241(has)-241(clad)-242(himself)-241(in)-241(armour)-242(which)-241(no)-241(weapon)-241(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-237(disposal)-238(can)-237(penetrate.)-246(After)-238(the)-237(strongest)-238(amount)-237(of)-237(histori-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cal)-299(evidence)-299(has)-299(been)-300(adduced,)-311(and)-299(after)-299(all)-299(alleged)-299(difficulties)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-305(been)-305(answered,)-318(he)-305(simply)-305(falls)-305(back)-305(on)-305(his)-305(atheism)-305(or)-304(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pantheism,)-212(which)-202(assumes)-202(that)-202(all)-202(supernatural)-201(occurrences)-202(must)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-335(impossible,)-356(and)-335(therefore)-335(that)-335(alleged)-335(instances)-335(of)-335(them)-334(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(delusions.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
111 0 obj <<
/Length 4523      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(19)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -257.765 -30.759 Td [(This)-225(is)-226(not)-226(unfrequently)-225(the)-226(case)-225(in)-226(the)-225(present)-226(controversy.)-241(A)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(considerable)-334(number)-335(of)-334(objections)-334(which)-335(are)-334(urged)-334(against)-334(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-318(elements)-318(of)-318(Christianity,)-335(derive)-318(whatever)-317(cogency)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-415(possess)-414(from)-415(the)-414(assumption)-415(that)-414(there)-414(is)-415(a)-414(God)-415(who)-414(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-286(moral)-286(Governor)-286(of)-287(the)-286(universe.)-358(These)-286(are)-286(not)-286(unfrequently)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(urged)-178(by)-179(persons)-178(who)-178(deny)-178(the)-179(possibil)1(ity)-179(of)-178(miracles)-178(on)-178(atheistic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-212(pantheistic)-212(grounds.)-237(It)-212(is)-212(perfectly)-212(fair)-212(to)-212(reason)-212(against)-212(Chris-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tianity)-281(on)-282(these)-281(grounds;)-297(it)-282(is)-281(equally)-281(so)-282(for)-281(a)-282(person)-281(who)-281(holds)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-347(opinions,)-370(to)-347(attempt)-347(to)-346(prove)-347(that)-346(the)-347(historical)-346(evidence)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(adduced)-245(in)-246(proof)-245(of)-245(the)-246(miracles)-245(recorded)-245(in)-246(the)-245(New)-245(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-378(worthless)-379(as)-378(an)-378(additional)-379(reason)-378(why)-378(men)-379(should)-378(cease)-378(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believe)-223(in)-223(them.)-241(But)-224(it)-223(is)-223(not)-223(conducive)-223(to)-224(the)-223(interests)-223(of)-223(truth)-223(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(urge)-278(objections)-279(which)-278(have)-279(no)-278(reality)-278(except)-279(on)-278(the)-278(supposition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-239(a)-239(God)-238(exists)-239(who)-239(is)-239(the)-238(moral)-239(Governor)-239(of)-239(the)-238(universe,)-241(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(then)-290(to)-289(fall)-290(back)-290(on)-289(reasonings)-290(whose)-290(whole)-289(force)-290(is)-289(dependent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-429(the)-428(data)-429(furnished)-429(by)-429(pantheism)-428(or)-429(atheism.)-786(I)-429(shall)-428(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occasion)-309(to)-310(notice)-309(a)-310(remarkable)-309(instance)-309(of)-310(this)-309(involved)-309(mode)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(reasoning)-250(hereafter.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([018])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -16.004 Td [(I)-476(shall)-477(now)-477(proceed)-477(briefly)-476(to)-477(state)-477(the)-476(mode)-477(in)-477(which)-476(I)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(propose)-327(to)-328(treat)-327(the)-328(present)-327(subject.)-482(The)-328(point)-327(which)-328(I)-327(have)-327(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(defend)-201(is)-201(not)-200(any)-201(conceivable)-201(body)-200(of)-201(miracles)-201(or)-201(their)-200(evidential)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(value,)-256(but)-254(specially)-255(the)-254(supernatural)-255(occurrences)-254(recorded)-255(in)-254(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(New)-266(Testament.)-298(I)-266(must)-266(therefore)-266(endeavour)-266(to)-266(ascertain)-266(what)-265(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-232(extent)-233(of)-232(the)-232(supernaturalism)-232(asserted)-233(in)-232(the)-232(New)-232(Testament,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-223(what)-223(is)-223(the)-222(degree)-223(of)-223(evidential)-223(value)-223(which)-223(its)-223(writers)-222(claim)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-229(has)-228(been)-229(asserted)-229(by)-229(many)-228(writers)-229(that)-229(the)-228(sole)-229(and)-229(only)-228(ev-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(idence)-266(of)-266(a)-265(revelation)-266(must)-266(be)-266(a)-265(miraculous)-266(testimony.)-297(Whether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-284(be)-285(so)-284(or)-285(not,)-292(this)-285(is)-284(not)-285(the)-284(place)-284(to)-285(enquire.)-353(But)-284(in)-284(relation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-263(the)-263(present)-263(controversy)-264(the)-263(plain)-263(and)-263(obvious)-263(course)-263(is)-263(to)-263(ask)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-301(writers)-301(of)-300(the)-301(New)-301(Testament)-300(what)-301(is)-301(the)-301(precise)-300(evidential)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(value)-276(of)-275(the)-276(supernatural)-276(occurrences)-275(which)-276(they)-276(have)-275(narrated.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(This)-319(is)-319(far)-319(preferable)-318(to)-319(falling)-319(back)-319(on)-319(any)-319(assertions)-319(of)-318(mod-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ern)-342(writers,)-366(however)-342(eminent,)-366(on)-342(this)-343(subject.)-527(They)-342(may)-342(have)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
115 0 obj <<
/Length 4520      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(20)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(over-estimated,)-403(or)-372(under-estimated)-372(their)-372(evidential)-372(value.)-616(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writers)-297(of)-296(the)-297(New)-297(Testament)-296(must)-297(be)-297(held)-296(responsible,)-309(not)-296(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-278(assertions)-277(of)-278(others,)-285(but)-278(only)-277(for)-278(their)-278(own.)-333(I)-278(must)-277(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(carefully)-400(consider)-399(what)-400(it)-399(is)-400(that)-400(they)-399(affirm)-400(to)-399(be)-400(proved)-399(by)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miracles.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(One)-370(primary)-371(objection)-370(against)-371(the)-370(possibility)-371(of)-370(miracles)-370(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(founded)-287(on)-287(that)-287(peculiar)-287(form)-287(of)-287(theoreti)1(c)-287(belief,)-297(which)-286(affirms)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-435(both)-434(philosophy,)-481(science,)-481(and)-434(religion)-435(alike)-434(point)-435(to)-434(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-298(of)-299(a)-298(Cause)-298(of)-298(the)-299(Universe,)-310(which)-298(is)-299(the)-298(source)-298(of)-298(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-313(forces)-313(which)-313(exist,)-329(and)-313(of)-313(which)-313(the)-313(various)-313(phenomena)-313(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-257(universe)-257(are)-256(manifestations,)-259(and)-256(designates)-257(this)-257(cause)-257(by)-256(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(name)-309(of)-310(God.)-428(But)-309(while)-310(it)-309(concedes)-309(his)-310(existence,)-324(it)-309(proclaims)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(him)-264(to)-265(be)-264(Unknown)-264(and)-264(Unknowable.)-293(If)-265(this)-264(position)-264(is)-264(correct,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-292(inference)-291(seems)-292(inevitable,)-301(that)-292(any)-291(thing)-292(like)-291(a)-292(real)-291(revela-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-283(of)-284(him)-283(is)-283(impossible.)-700(It)-284(will)-283(be)-283(necessary)-284(therefore)-283(for)-283(me)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([019])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(examine)-250(into)-250(the)-250(validity)-250(of)-250(this)-250(position.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(A)-224(vast)-225(variety)-224(of)-225(arguments)-224(have)-225(been)-224(adduced)-225(both)-224(on)-224(philo-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(sophic)-320(grounds)-320(and)-320(from)-320(the)-320(principles)-320(established)-320(by)-320(physical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(science,)-390(for)-362(the)-362(purpose)-362(of)-362(proving)-362(that)-362(the)-362(occurrence)-362(of)-362(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-239(event)-239(is)-240(cont)1(rary)-240(to)-239(our)-239(reason.)-246(If)-240(this)-239(be)-239(true,)-241(it)-239(is)-239(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fatal)-168(objection)-168(against)-167(the)-168(entire)-168(mass)-168(of)-168(supernatural)-167(occurrences)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-392(are)-392(recorded)-392(in)-392(the)-392(New)-392(Testament.)-676(The)-392(most)-392(important)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(points)-250(of)-250(these)-250(reasonings)-250(will)-250(require)-250(a)-250(careful)-250(consideration.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(A)-274(very)-274(important)-274(objection)-274(has)-274(been)-274(urged)-274(against)-274(the)-273(Chris-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tian)-194(mode)-194(of)-194(conducting)-194(the)-195(argument)-194(from)-194(miracles.)-231(It)-194(is)-194(alleged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-318(it)-318(involves)-318(reasoning)-319(in)-318(a)-318(vicious)-318(circle,)-335(and)-318(that)-318(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apologists)-198(endeavour)-198(to)-199(prove)-198(the)-198(truth)-198(of)-198(doctrines)-198(which)-198(utterly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(transcend)-240(reason)-241(by)-240(miraculous)-241(evidence,)-242(and)-241(then)-240(endeavour)-240(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prove)-245(the)-245(truth)-246(of)-245(the)-245(miracles)-245(by)-245(the)-246(doctrines.)-248(If)-245(this)-245(allegation)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-336(true,)-357(it)-336(is)-336(no)-336(doubt)-336(a)-336(fatal)-335(objection)-336(to)-336(the)-336(argument.)-508(I)-335(shall)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(endeavour)-218(to)-217(show)-218(that)-218(it)-217(is)-218(founded)-218(on)-217(a)-218(misapprehension)-218(of)-217(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entire)-250(subject.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(An)-251(attempt)-251(has)-251(been)-250(made)-251(to)-251(re-affirm)-251(the)-251(validity)-251(of)-250(Hume's)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(argument)-445(that)-445(no)-445(amount)-446(of)-445(evidence)-445(can)-445(avail)-445(to)-445(prove)-445(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
119 0 obj <<
/Length 4518      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(21)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(reality)-268(of)-269(a)-268(miracle)-269(unless)-268(the)-268(falsehood)-269(of)-268(the)-269(evidence)-268(is)-268(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miraculous)-448(than)-447(the)-448(alleged)-447(miracle.)-843(It)-448(will)-447(be)-448(necessary)-447(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consider)-439(the)-439(validity)-439(of)-438(the)-439(positions)-439(which)-439(have)-439(been)-438(lately)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assumed)-250(respecting)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(A)-286(very)-287(formidable)-286(objection)-287(has)-286(been)-286(urged)-287(against)-286(the)-286(truth)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-300(the)-300(supernatural)-300(occurrences)-300(recorded)-300(in)-300(the)-300(New)-299(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-214(the)-215(ground)-214(that)-214(the)-214(followers)-215(of)-214(Jesus)-214(were)-214(a)-215(prey)-214(to)-214(a)-214(number)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-356(the)-355(most)-356(grotesque)-355(beliefs)-356(respecting)-356(the)-355(action)-356(of)-355(demons,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-319(that)-318(their)-319(superstition)-318(and)-319(credulity)-318(on)-318(this)-319(point)-318(was)-319(of)-318(so)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(extreme)-301(a)-301(character)-301(as)-301(to)-301(deprive)-301(their)-301(historical)-301(testimony,)-627(on)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([020])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(the)-179(subject)-180(of)-179(the)-179(supernatural)-180(of)-179(all)-180(value.)-226(As)-179(this)-180(objection)-179(is)-179(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(only)-204(one)-205(which)-204(is)-204(widely)-205(extended,)-213(but)-204(has)-205(been)-204(urged)-204(with)-204(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(force)-387(by)-386(the)-387(author)-387(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 104.696 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)-387(Religion,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 100.272 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.061 0 Td [(I)-386(shall)-387(devote)]TJ -218.872 -13.549 Td [(four)-288(chapters)-289(of)-288(this)-289(work)-288(to)-288(the)-289(examination)-288(of)-289(the)-288(question)-288(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession)-284(and)-284(demoniacal)-284(action)-285(as)-284(far)-284(as)-284(it)-284(affects)-284(the)-284(present)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(controversy.)]TJ 11.955 -15.186 Td [(The)-305(entire)-305(school)-305(of)-305(modern)-305(unbelief)-305(found)-305(a)-305(very)-305(consider-)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(able)-362(portion)-362(of)-362(their)-362(arguments)-362(against)-362(the)-362(historical)-362(character)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-334(the)-335(Gospels,)-356(on)-334(the)-335(alleged)-334(credulity)-335(and)-334(superstition)-335(of)-334(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(followers)-356(of)-355(our)-356(Lord.)-567(This)-355(is)-356(alleged)-355(to)-356(have)-356(been)-355(of)-356(a)-355(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(profound)-359(character,)-386(and)-359(it)-359(forms)-359(the)-359(weapon)-359(which)-359(is)-359(perhaps)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-447(most)-447(constant)-447(use)-447(with)-448(the)-447(assailants)-447(of)-447(Christianity.)-841(All)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difficulties)-376(which)-375(beset)-376(their)-376(arguments)-375(are)-376(met)-376(by)-375(attributing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-411(most)-412(unbounded)-411(credulity,)-451(superstition)-412(and)-411(enthusiasm)-411(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-409(followers)-408(of)-409(Jesus.)-726(It)-408(has)-409(also)-409(been)-408(urged)-409(that)-409(the)-408(belief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-323(supernatural)-323(occurrences)-323(has)-323(been)-324(so)-323(general,)-341(that)-323(it)-323(renders)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-447(attestation)-448(of)-447(miracles)-448(to)-448(a)-447(revelation)-448(invalid.)-842(I)-447(purpose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(examining)-391(into)-392(the)-391(validity)-391(of)-392(this)-391(objection.)-674(As)-392(this)-391(may)-391(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(said)-296(to)-296(be)-296(the)-296(key)-296(of)-296(the)-296(position)-296(occupied)-295(by)-296(modern)-296(unbelief,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(I)-285(must)-285(examine)-285(into)-285(the)-285(reality)-285(of)-285(the)-285(affirmation,)-294(and)-285(also)-285(how)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(far)-223(the)-223(love)-223(of)-222(the)-223(marvellous)-223(in)-223(mankind)-223(affects)-223(the)-223(credit)-222(of)-223(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testimony)-291(to)-290(miracles.)-372(This)-290(I)-291(propose)-291(discussing)-290(in)-291(two)-290(distinct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(chapters.)]TJ 11.955 -15.186 Td [(It)-324(is)-324(an)-325(unquestionable)-324(fact)-324(that)-324(in)-325(these)-324(days)-324(we)-325(summari)1(ly)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
124 0 obj <<
/Length 4654      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(22)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(reject)-322(whole)-322(masses)-322(of)-322(alleged)-322(supernatural)-322(occurrences,)-340(as)-321(ut-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(terly)-200(incredible,)-210(without)-200(inquiry)-199(into)-200(the)-200(testimony)-200(on)-200(which)-199(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rest.)-533(It)-345(will)-344(be)-345(necessary)-344(to)-344(inquire)-345(into)-344(the)-345(grounds)-344(on)-344(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-298(do)-298(this,)-311(and)-298(how)-298(far)-298(it)-298(affects)-299(the)-298(credibility)-298(of)-298(the)-298(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(recorded)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(The)-219(historical)-219(value)-219(of)-218(the)-219(testimony)-219(which)-219(has)-438(been)-218(adduced)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([021])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(for)-261(the)-260(truth)-261(of)-260(the)-261(miracles)-261(recorded)-260(in)-261(the)-261(New)-260(Testament,)-263(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-276(assailed)-276(by)-276(every)-276(weapon)-276(which)-276(criticism)-276(can)-276(supply.)-328(It)-276(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirmed)-306(in)-307(the)-306(strongest)-306(manner)-306(that)-306(they)-307(are)-306(utterly)-306(devoid)-306(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-320(reliable)-321(historical)-320(evidence.)-460(The)-321(Gospels)-320(are)-320(pronounced)-320(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consist)-248(of)-248(a)-248(bundle)-248(of)-248(myths)-249(and)-248(legends,)-248(with)-248(only)-248(a)-248(few)-248(grains)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-332(historic)-331(truth)-332(hidden)-332(beneath)-331(them.)-495(They)-332(are)-331(affirmed)-332(to)-331(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(late)-291(compositions,)-302(and)-291(that)-291(we)-291(are)-292(utterly)-291(devoid)-291(of)-291(all)-291(contem-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(poraneous)-253(attestation)-254(for)-253(the)-254(facts)-253(recorded)-254(in)-253(them,)-255(and)-253(that)-253(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(true)-208(account)-207(of)-208(the)-207(origin)-208(of)-208(Christianity)-207(is)-208(buried)-207(beneath)-208(a)-207(mass)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-248(fiction.)-250(If)-248(this)-249(be)-248(true,)-249(there)-248(cannot)-249(be)-248(a)-248(doubt)-249(that)-248(it)-249(is)-248(a)-248(most)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(serious)-283(allegation,)-291(which)-283(affects)-283(the)-283(entire)-283(Christian)-283(position.)-349(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-303(further)-303(urged)-303(that)-303(while)-303(the)-303(defenders)-303(of)-303(Christianity)-303(publish)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(works)-289(in)-290(which)-289(they)-290(attempt)-289(to)-290(prove)-289(that)-290(miracles)-289(are)-289(possible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-208(credible,)-217(they)-208(carefully)-208(avoid)-208(grappling)-209(with)-208(the)-208(real)-208(point)-208(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-297(whole)-297(question)-297(by)-297(showing)-297(that)-297(any)-297(historical)-297(evidence)-296(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-264(produced)-265(for)-264(a)-265(single)-264(miracle)-264(recorded)-265(in)-264(the)-264(Gospels,)-268(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(will)-369(stand)-368(the)-369(test)-369(of)-369(such)-368(historical)-369(criticism,)-398(and)-369(it)-369(is)-368(loudly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proclaimed)-218(that)-217(no)-218(real)-218(evidence)-217(can)-218(be)-218(made)-217(forthcoming.)-239(Such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-250(charge)-250(as)-250(this,)-250(it)-250(is)-250(impossible)-250(to)-250(pass)-250(over)-250(in)-250(silence.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-235(propose,)-238(therefore,)-238(to)-235(examine)-235(into)-235(the)-235(general)-235(truth)-235(of)-235(these)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(allegations,)-281(and)-275(to)-275(consider)-274(the)-275(nature)-275(of)-275(the)-275(historical)-274(evidence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-261(unbelief,)-265(after)-261(it)-262(has)-261(exhausted)-262(all)-261(its)-262(powers)-261(of)-261(criticism,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(still)-250(leaves)-250(us)-250(unquestionably)-250(in)-250(possession)-250(of.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(This)-403(consists)-404(of)-403(the)-404(epistles)-403(of)-404(the)-403(New)-404(Testament)-403(viewed)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(as)-372(historical)-372(documents.)-615(Their)-372(value)-372(as)-372(such)-372(has)-372(been)-371(greatly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(overlooked)-359(by)-358(both)-359(sides)-359(to)-359(the)-358(controversy,)-386(especially)-359(by)-358(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Christian)-437(side.)-812(Christians)-437(have)-437(been)-438(in)-437(the)-437(habit)-437(of)-437(viewing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-395(as)-395(inspired)-395(compositions,)-432(and)-395(have)-395(studied)-395(them)-395(almost)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
128 0 obj <<
/Length 4715      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(23)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(exclusively)-952(on)-476(account)-476(of)-476(the)-476(doctrinal)-476(and)-476(moral)-476(teaching)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([022])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(which)-384(they)-384(contain,)-418(and)-384(each)-384(sect)-383(has)-384(viewed)-384(them)-384(as)-384(a)-384(kind)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-273(armoury)-273(from)-273(which)-272(to)-273(draw)-273(weapons)-273(for)-273(the)-273(establishing)-272(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(own)-331(particular)-331(opinions.)-494(In)-331(doing)-332(this)-331(they)-331(have)-331(forgotten)-331(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-259(are)-259(also)-259(historical)-258(documents)-259(of)-259(the)-259(highest)-259(order,)-261(the)-258(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(majority)-248(of)-247(which)-248(even)-247(the)-248(opponents)-247(of)-247(Christianity)-248(concede)-247(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-295(been)-295(composed)-295(prior)-296(to)-295(the)-295(conclusion)-295(of)-295(the)-295(first)-295(century)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(Christian)-250(era,)-250(and)-250(many)-250(of)-250(them)-250(at)-250(a)-250(much)-250(earlier)-250(period.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Of)-252(these)-253(writings)-252(four)-253(are)-252(universally)-252(admitted)-253(to)-252(be)-252(genuine,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(and)-265(to)-266(have)-265(been)-265(composed)-266(prior)-265(to)-266(the)-265(year)-265(60)-266(of)-265(our)-265(era.)-296(Four)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more)-270(are)-270(genuine)-269(beyond)-270(all)-270(reasonable)-270(doubt,)-274(and)-270(of)-270(two)-269(more)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-327(evidence)-327(in)-327(favour)-327(of)-327(their)-327(authenticity)-327(is)-327(very)-327(strong.)-480(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Apocalypse,)-298(which)-289(is)-288(also)-289(admitted)-288(to)-288(be)-289(genuine,)-298(although)-288(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(strictly)-275(an)-275(historical)-275(document,)-281(can)-275(be)-275(rendered)-275(valuable)-275(for)-274(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purposes)-309(of)-309(history.)-426(Of)-309(the)-309(remaining)-309(writings)-309(the)-308(genuineness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-279(disputed;)-292(but)-279(whether)-279(genuine)-278(or)-279(not,)-285(it)-279(is)-278(impossible)-279(to)-278(deny)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-347(antiquity,)-371(and)-347(that)-346(they)-347(are)-347(faithful)-347(representations)-347(of)-346(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ideas)-229(of)-228(those)-229(who)-228(wrote)-229(them.)-243(In)-228(fact)-229(the)-229(names)-228(of)-229(their)-228(authors)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-292(of)-291(no)-292(great)-291(importance)-292(in)-291(the)-292(present)-291(controversy,)-302(when)-291(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writings)-303(themselves)-302(bear)-303(so)-303(decisively)-302(the)-303(marks)-303(of)-302(originality.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Thus)-417(the)-418(epistle)-417(of)-417(James,)-459(by)-418(whomsoever)-417(written,)-459(bears)-417(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(most)-275(unquestionable)-276(marks)-275(of)-276(the)-275(most)-275(primitive)-276(antiquity.)-326(It)-275(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-314(fact)-315(a)-314(document)-315(of)-314(the)-315(earliest)-314(form)-315(of)-314(Christianity,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 242.051 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(in)-314(one)]TJ -252.96 -13.549 Td [(word,)-299(the)-289(Jewish)-288(form,)-299(before)-289(the)-289(Church)-289(was)-289(finally)-288(separated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-250(the)-250(synagogue.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Such)-272(are)-272(our)-272(historical)-273(materials.)-316(Little)-272(justice)-272(has)-272(been)-272(done)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-230(their)-229(value)-229(in)-230(the)-229(writings)-230(of)-229(Christian)-230(apologists.)-243(As)-229(included)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-384(the)-385(Canon)-384(of)-384(the)-384(New)-384(Testament,)-418(it)-385(has)-384(been)-384(for)-384(the)-384(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(part)-332(the)-331(practice)-332(to)-332(view)-663(them)-332(as)-332(standing)-331(in)-332(need)-332(of)-331(defence,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([023])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.55 Td [(rather)-306(than)-306(as)-307(being)-306(the)-306(mainstay)-306(of)-307(the)-306(argument)-306(for)-306(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity,)-250(and)-250(constituting)-250(its)-250(central)-250(position.)]TJ 11.955 -15.185 Td [(It)-275(will)-275(be)-274(admitted)-275(that)-275(it)-275(will)-275(be)-274(impossible)-275(for)-275(me)-275(to)-275(do)-274(full)]TJ -11.955 -13.55 Td [(justice)-273(to)-272(such)-273(a)-272(subject)-273(in)-272(a)-273(work)-272(like)-273(the)-273(present.)-317(To)-273(bring)-272(out)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-402(the)-401(treasures)-402(of)-401(evidence)-402(respecting)-402(primitive)-401(Christianity,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
133 0 obj <<
/Length 4565      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(24)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(and)-254(the)-253(foundation)-254(of)-253(the)-254(Christian)-254(Church)-253(which)-254(these)-253(writings)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contain,)-457(the)-416(whole)-416(subject)-416(would)-416(require)-416(to)-416(be)-416(unfolded)-416(in)-415(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinct)-296(and)-296(separate)-296(treatise)-296(exclusively)-296(devoted)-296(to)-296(the)-295(subject.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Still,)-326(however,)-326(this)-311(work)-310(would)-311(be)-311(very)-311(incomplete)-310(if)-311(I)-311(did)-310(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(accept)-240(the)-240(challenge)-241(so)-240(boldly)-240(thrown)-240(down)-241(to)-240(us,)-242(and)-240(show)-240(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity)-232(rests)-232(on)-232(an)-232(historical)-232(attestation)-232(of)-232(the)-232(highest)-231(order.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(To)-373(this)-372(I)-373(propose)-373(devoting)-372(the)-373(six)-372(concluding)-373(chapters)-373(of)-372(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(work.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-322(intend,)-340(therefore,)-340(in)-322(the)-322(first)-322(place)-322(to)-322(examine)-322(the)-322(value)-322(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-335(historical)-334(documents)-335(of)-335(the)-335(New)-334(Testament,)-356(and)-335(show)-334(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(several)-268(of)-269(the)-268(epistles)-268(take)-269(rank)-268(as)-268(the)-269(highest)-268(form)-268(of)-268(historical)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(documents,)-201(and)-189(present)-188(us)-189(with)-189(what)-188(is)-189(to)-189(all)-188(intents)-189(and)-188(purposes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-371(large)-371(mass)-372(of)-371(contemporaneous)-371(evidence)-371(as)-371(to)-371(the)-371(primitive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beliefs,)-328(and)-312(the)-312(original)-312(foundation)-312(of)-313(the)-312(Christian)-312(Church.)-436(In)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(doing)-274(so)-274(I)-274(propose)-274(to)-274(treat)-274(them)-274(in)-274(the)-274(same)-274(manner)-274(as)-274(all)-273(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(similar)-250(historical)-250(documents)-250(are)-250(treated.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-391(shall)-391(then)-391(show)-392(that)-391(these)-391(documents)-391(afford)-391(a)-391(substantial)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(testimony)-401(to)-400(all)-401(the)-401(great)-400(facts)-401(of)-401(Christianity,)-438(and)-400(especially)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-367(the)-367(existence)-367(of)-367(miraculous)-368(powers)-367(in)-367(the)-367(Church,)-396(and)-367(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-295(various)-296(Churches)-295(were)-295(from)-295(the)-295(very)-296(earliest)-295(period)-295(in)-295(pos-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(session)-304(of)-303(an)-304(oral)-304(account)-303(of)-304(the)-304(actions)-303(and)-304(teachings)-304(of)-303(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ)-426(substantially)-427(the)-426(same)-426(as)-426(that)-427(which)-426(is)-426(now)-426(embodied)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-399(the)-398(Gospels;)-473(and)-398(that)-399(this)-398(oral)-399(Gospel)-398(was)-399(habitually)-398(used)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-364(the)-364(purposes)-363(of)-364(instruction.)-591(Further,)-392(that)-364(this)-728(oral)-363(Gospel)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([024])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(was)-445(a)-445(substantial)-445(embodiment)-445(of)-445(the)-445(beliefs)-445(of)-445(the)-444(primitive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(followers)-344(of)-345(Jesus,)-368(and)-344(that)-344(the)-345(Church)-344(as)-344(a)-345(community)-344(was)-344(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(body)-265(especially)-265(adapted)-265(for)-265(handing)-265(down)-265(correctly)-265(the)-264(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-225(the)-225(primitive)-225(beliefs)-225(respecting)-225(its)-225(origin,)-230(and)-225(that)-225(the)-225(peculiar)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(position)-250(in)-250(which)-250(it)-250(was)-250(placed)-250(compelled)-250(it)-250(to)-250(do)-250(so.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-297(shall)-296(further)-297(show)-297(on)-296(the)-297(evidence)-297(furnished)-296(by)-297(those)-296(epis-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tles,)-371(the)-347(genuineness)-347(of)-347(which)-347(unbelievers)-347(do)-347(not)-347(dispute,)-371(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-265(the)-264(earliest)-265(commencement)-264(of)-265(Christianity)-264(the)-265(whole)-264(body)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-282(believers,)-291(without)-282(distinction)-282(of)-282(sect)-282(or)-283(party,)-290(believed)-282(in)-282(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(resurrection)-312(of)-312(Jesus)-311(Christ)-312(as)-312(a)-312(fact,)-327(and)-311(viewed)-312(it)-312(not)-312(only)-311(as)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
137 0 obj <<
/Length 4620      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(25)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(the)-242(groundwork)-242(on)-242(which)-242(Christianity)-242(rested,)-244(but)-242(as)-242(the)-241(one)-242(sole)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-240(only)-240(reason)-240(for)-240(the)-239(existence)-240(of)-240(the)-240(Christian)-240(Church.)-247(I)-239(shall)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-329(able)-329(also)-329(to)-329(prove)-329(on)-329(the)-329(same)-329(evidence)-329(that)-329(a)-329(considerable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(number)-323(of)-323(the)-323(followers)-323(of)-323(Jesus)-323(were)-323(persuaded)-323(that)-323(they)-323(had)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(seen)-264(him)-265(alive)-264(after)-265(his)-264(crucifixion,)-268(and)-264(that)-265(his)-264(appearance)-264(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-332(actual)-331(resurrection)-332(from)-331(the)-332(dead.)-495(The)-331(same)-332(writings)-331(prove)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-306(demonstration)-306(that)-306(this)-306(was)-306(the)-306(universal)-306(belief)-306(of)-306(the)-306(whole)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-244(community,)-245(and)-244(that)-244(the)-244(Church)-244(was)-244(established)-244(on)-244(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(basis.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(These)-234(things)-233(being)-234(established)-234(as)-234(the)-233(basis)-234(for)-234(my)-234(reasonings,)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(I)-264(shall)-265(proceed)-264(to)-264(prove)-264(that)-265(it)-264(is)-264(impossible)-265(that)-264(these)-264(beliefs)-264(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-362(Church)-361(could)-362(have)-362(owed)-361(their)-362(origin)-362(to)-361(any)-362(possible)-361(form)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-446(delusion;)-545(but)-446(that)-446(the)-446(resurrection)-447(of)-446(Jesus)-446(Christ)-446(was)-446(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-203(fact,)-212(and)-202(that)-203(no)-202(other)-202(supposition)-203(can)-202(give)-203(an)-202(adequate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(account)-250(of)-250(the)-250(phenomenon.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Having)-297(proved)-296(that)-297(the)-297(greatest)-297(of)-296(all)-297(the)-297(miracles)-297(which)-296(are)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(recorded)-371(in)-371(the)-370(Gospels)-371(is)-371(an)-371(historical)-370(fact,)-401(I)-371(have)-371(got)-371(rid)-370(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 16.429 0 Td [(\340)-284(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 37.111 0 Td [(difficulty)-284(with)-284(which)-284(the)-284(acceptance)-284(of)-284(the)-284(Gospels)]TJ -53.54 -13.549 Td [(as)-284(genuine)-283(historical)-284(accounts)-283(is)-284(attended;)-300(but)-284(further,)-292(if)-283(it)-284(is)-283(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-266(fact)-267(that)-266(Jesus)-266(Christ)-266(really)-267(rose)-266(from)-266(the)-267(dead,)-270(it)-266(is)-266(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-544(highest)-272(degree)-272(probable)-272(that)-272(other)-272(supernatural)-272(occurrences)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([025])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(would)-352(be)-352(connected)-351(with)-352(his)-352(person.)-555(I)-352(shall)-352(therefore)-351(proceed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-280(restore)-280(the)-280(Gospels)-280(to)-280(their)-280(place)-279(as)-280(history,)-288(and)-280(to)-280(show)-279(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-208(on)-208(the)-208(principles)-208(of)-208(the)-208(opponents)-208(of)-208(Christianity,)-216(they)-208(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(every)-385(claim)-384(to)-385(be)-385(accepted)-384(as)-385(true)-385(accounts)-384(of)-385(the)-385(action)-384(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(teaching)-384(of)-384(Jesus)-384(Christ)-383(as)-384(it)-384(was)-384(transmitted)-384(by)-384(the)-383(different)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Churches,)-301(partly)-291(in)-290(an)-291(oral,)-301(and)-290(partly)-291(in)-291(a)-290(written)-291(form.)-372(I)-290(shall)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(also)-200(show)-199(that)-200(even)-200(if)-200(they)-199(were)-200(composed)-200(at)-199(the)-200(late)-200(dates)-199(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-264(assigned)-264(to)-264(them)-264(by)-264(opponents,)-268(they)-264(were)-264(yet)-264(written)-264(within)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-323(period)-322(which)-323(is)-322(strictly)-323(historical,)-341(while)-322(tradition)-323(was)-322(fresh)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-401(reminiscences)-401(vivid,)-438(and)-401(long)-400(before)-401(it)-401(was)-401(possible)-400(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-343(great)-343(mass)-344(of)-343(facts)-343(which)-343(must)-343(have)-344(formed)-343(the)-343(basis)-343(of)-343(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(existence)-362(of)-362(the)-362(Christian)-362(Church)-362(could)-362(have)-362(been)-362(superseded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-301(a)-301(number)-302(of)-301(mythic)-301(and)-301(legendary)-302(creations.)-403(Having)-301(placed)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
141 0 obj <<
/Length 1234      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(26)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(these)-240(facts)-241(on)-240(a)-241(firm)-240(foundation,)-242(I)-241(shall)-240(proceed)-241(to)-240(consider)-240(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accounts)-291(of)-291(the)-291(Resurrection)-291(of)-292(Jesus)-291(Christ,)-301(and)-291(to)-291(estimate)-291(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(The)-345(proof)-345(that)-345(the)-346(greatest)-345(miracle)-345(recorded)-345(in)-345(the)-345(Gospels,)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(the)-389(Resurrection)-389(of)-388(Jesus)-389(Christ,)-424(is)-388(an)-389(event)-389(which)-389(has)-388(really)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurred,)-288(places)-281(the)-280(remainder)-281(of)-280(them)-281(in)-280(point)-280(of)-281(credibility)-280(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-263(same)-262(position)-262(as)-263(the)-262(facts)-263(of)-262(ordinary)-263(history;)-269(and)-262(they)-262(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-291(accepted)-291(and)-291(regarded)-291(in)-291(conformity)-291(with)-291(the)-291(usual)-290(methods)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(testing)-250(evidence.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -29.651 Td [([026])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
9 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 816
/Length 8895      
>>
stream
4 0 1 138 8 302 2 464 6 674 3 726 13 789 12 900 17 976 16 1087
20 1163 19 1274 24 1350 26 1461 23 1515 27 1614 30 1652 32 1677 28 1788 34 1842
31 1897 36 1961 38 2072 35 2127 41 2191 43 2302 40 2356 44 2420 47 2458 49 2585
45 2696 51 2750 48 2805 53 2869 55 2980 52 3034 57 3110 59 3221 56 3273 62 3361
64 3472 61 3527 66 3603 68 3714 65 3769 71 3833 73 3944 70 3999 75 4063 77 4174
78 4229 74 4283 80 4359 82 4470 79 4524 84 4588 86 4699 83 4754 88 4818 90 4929
87 4984 92 5048 94 5159 91 5213 97 5289 99 5400 100 5455 96 5510 102 5574 104 5688
101 5745 106 5822 108 5936 105 5993 110 6058 112 6172 109 6228 114 6293 116 6407 113 6464
118 6529 120 6644 117 6700 123 6777 125 6892 122 6949 127 7014 129 7129 130 7186 126 7243
132 7320 134 7435 131 7492 136 7557 138 7672 135 7727 140 7804 142 7919 139 7975 143 8040
% 4 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 5 0 R
/Resources 3 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 10 0 R
/Annots [ 1 0 R 8 0 R 2 0 R ]
>>
% 1 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [268.245 431.687 327.401 441.407]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense) >>
>>
% 8 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [46.771 418.138 93.751 427.858]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense) >>
>>
% 2 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [148.918 418.138 295.569 427.858]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.gutenberg.org/license) >> 
>>
% 6 0 obj
<<
/D [4 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 3 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 13 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 14 0 R
/Resources 12 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 10 0 R
>>
% 12 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 17 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 18 0 R
/Resources 16 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 10 0 R
>>
% 16 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 20 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 21 0 R
/Resources 19 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 10 0 R
>>
% 19 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 24 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 25 0 R
/Resources 23 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 10 0 R
>>
% 26 0 obj
<<
/D [24 0 R /XYZ 46.771 346.603 null]
>>
% 23 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/XObject << /Im1 22 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text /ImageC ]
>>
% 27 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index1) >>
% 30 0 obj
(Dedication.)
% 32 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 33 0 R
/Resources 31 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 10 0 R
>>
% 28 0 obj
<<
/D [32 0 R /XYZ 93.543 529.134 null]
>>
% 34 0 obj
<<
/D [32 0 R /XYZ 310.526 201.634 null]
>>
% 31 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 36 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 37 0 R
/Resources 35 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 39 0 R
>>
% 38 0 obj
<<
/D [36 0 R /XYZ 293.788 300.161 null]
>>
% 35 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 41 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 42 0 R
/Resources 40 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 39 0 R
>>
% 43 0 obj
<<
/D [41 0 R /XYZ 93.543 518.175 null]
>>
% 40 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 44 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index2) >>
% 47 0 obj
(Chapter I. Introduction. The Position of the Controversy Between the Opponents and the Defenders of Christianity.)
% 49 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 50 0 R
/Resources 48 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 39 0 R
>>
% 45 0 obj
<<
/D [49 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 51 0 obj
<<
/D [49 0 R /XYZ 285.204 135.344 null]
>>
% 48 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 53 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 54 0 R
/Resources 52 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 39 0 R
>>
% 55 0 obj
<<
/D [53 0 R /XYZ 93.543 201.449 null]
>>
% 52 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 57 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 58 0 R
/Resources 56 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 39 0 R
>>
% 59 0 obj
<<
/D [57 0 R /XYZ 80.686 259.7 null]
>>
% 56 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 62 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 63 0 R
/Resources 61 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 39 0 R
>>
% 64 0 obj
<<
/D [62 0 R /XYZ 314.959 326.032 null]
>>
% 61 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 66 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 67 0 R
/Resources 65 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 69 0 R
>>
% 68 0 obj
<<
/D [66 0 R /XYZ 208.446 396.232 null]
>>
% 65 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 71 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 72 0 R
/Resources 70 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 69 0 R
>>
% 73 0 obj
<<
/D [71 0 R /XYZ 333.438 461.524 null]
>>
% 70 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 75 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 76 0 R
/Resources 74 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 69 0 R
>>
% 77 0 obj
<<
/D [75 0 R /XYZ 105.736 518.175 null]
>>
% 78 0 obj
<<
/D [75 0 R /XYZ 46.771 133.146 null]
>>
% 74 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 80 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 81 0 R
/Resources 79 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 69 0 R
>>
% 82 0 obj
<<
/D [80 0 R /XYZ 348.604 190.54 null]
>>
% 79 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 84 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 85 0 R
/Resources 83 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 69 0 R
>>
% 86 0 obj
<<
/D [84 0 R /XYZ 176.351 244.736 null]
>>
% 83 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 88 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 89 0 R
/Resources 87 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 69 0 R
>>
% 90 0 obj
<<
/D [88 0 R /XYZ 290.315 326.032 null]
>>
% 87 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 92 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 93 0 R
/Resources 91 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 95 0 R
>>
% 94 0 obj
<<
/D [92 0 R /XYZ 62.684 380.228 null]
>>
% 91 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 97 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 98 0 R
/Resources 96 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 95 0 R
>>
% 99 0 obj
<<
/D [97 0 R /XYZ 223.423 462.342 null]
>>
% 100 0 obj
<<
/D [97 0 R /XYZ 374.173 66.142 null]
>>
% 96 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 102 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 103 0 R
/Resources 101 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 95 0 R
>>
% 104 0 obj
<<
/D [102 0 R /XYZ 182.682 121.975 null]
>>
% 101 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 106 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 107 0 R
/Resources 105 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 95 0 R
>>
% 108 0 obj
<<
/D [106 0 R /XYZ 341.153 201.634 null]
>>
% 105 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 110 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 111 0 R
/Resources 109 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 95 0 R
>>
% 112 0 obj
<<
/D [110 0 R /XYZ 46.771 285.461 null]
>>
% 109 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 114 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 115 0 R
/Resources 113 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 95 0 R
>>
% 116 0 obj
<<
/D [114 0 R /XYZ 210.045 327.259 null]
>>
% 113 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 118 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 119 0 R
/Resources 117 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 121 0 R
>>
% 120 0 obj
<<
/D [118 0 R /XYZ 313.07 394.596 null]
>>
% 117 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 123 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 124 0 R
/Resources 122 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 121 0 R
>>
% 125 0 obj
<<
/D [123 0 R /XYZ 312.453 448.793 null]
>>
% 122 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 127 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 128 0 R
/Resources 126 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 121 0 R
>>
% 129 0 obj
<<
/D [127 0 R /XYZ 101.656 518.175 null]
>>
% 130 0 obj
<<
/D [127 0 R /XYZ 159.381 135.525 null]
>>
% 126 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 132 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 133 0 R
/Resources 131 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 121 0 R
>>
% 134 0 obj
<<
/D [132 0 R /XYZ 318.368 203.271 null]
>>
% 131 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 136 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 137 0 R
/Resources 135 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 121 0 R
>>
% 138 0 obj
<<
/D [136 0 R /XYZ 63.07 242.282 null]
>>
% 135 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 140 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 141 0 R
/Resources 139 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 121 0 R
>>
% 142 0 obj
<<
/D [140 0 R /XYZ 93.543 380.131 null]
>>
% 139 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 143 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index3) >>
endstream
endobj
150 0 obj <<
/Length 5444      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-250(II.)-250(Definitions)-250(of)-250(Terms.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -33.407 Td [(Nothing)-500(has)-501(more)-500(contributed)-501(to)-500(import)-501(an)-500(almost)-500(hopeless)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(confusion)-313(of)-313(thought)-314(into)-313(the)-313(entire)-313(controversy)-313(about)-313(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-371(the)-370(ambiguous)-371(senses)-371(in)-371(which)-370(the)-371(most)-371(important)-370(terms)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(connected)-281(with)-280(it)-281(have)-281(been)-280(employed,)-289(both)-280(by)-281(theologians)-280(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(men)-307(of)-308(science,)-321(by)-308(the)-307(defenders)-307(of)-308(revelation)-307(as)-307(well)-308(as)-307(by)-307(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opponents.)-318(Of)-272(these)-273(terms)-273(the)-272(words)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 164.069 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(nature,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 29.989 0 Td [(\035)-273(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.66 0 Td [(natural)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30.295 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 5.762 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(law,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.48 0 Td [(\035)]TJ -275.786 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(force,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 25.135 0 Td [(\035)-358(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.593 0 Td [(supernatural,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 56.651 0 Td [(\035)-358(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.594 0 Td [(superhuman,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 56.051 0 Td [(\035)-358(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.593 0 Td [(miracle,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 35.444 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.75 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.659 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(mirac-)]TJ -252.157 -13.55 Td [(ulous,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 26.367 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.989 0 Td [(are)-380(the)-380(most)-380(conspicuous.)-640(It)-380(is)-380(quite)-380(clear)-380(that)-380(unless)]TJ -35.356 -13.549 Td [(we)-298(use)-298(these)-299(terms)-298(in)-298(a)-298(definite)-298(and)-299(uniform)-298(sense,)-310(we)-298(shall)-298(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fighting)-379(the)-378(air.)-636(The)-379(neglect)-378(to)-379(do)-379(so)-378(has)-379(thrown)-379(the)-378(greatest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(obscurity)-316(over)-317(the)-316(entire)-316(subject.)-449(This)-316(vague)-317(and)-316(uncertain)-316(use)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-367(them)-367(is)-367(not)-367(confined)-367(to)-366(writers)-367(on)-367(theological)-367(subjects,)-396(but)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-332(diffused)-331(over)-332(a)-331(large)-332(number)-332(of)-331(scientific)-332(works.)-495(My)-331(object)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-320(the)-319(present)-320(chapter)-320(will)-320(be,)-337(not)-319(to)-320(lay)-320(down)-320(strictly)-319(accurate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(definitions)-223(of)-222(all)-223(the)-222(terms)-223(used)-223(in)-222(the)-223(controversy)-223(\050for)-222(this)-223(in)-222(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(present)-288(state)-288(of)-289(thought)-288(on)-288(the)-288(subject)-289(is)-288(hardly)-288(possible\051)-288(but)-288(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(endeavour)-268(to)-268(assign)-268(a)-268(definite)-269(meaning)-268(to)-268(those)-268(which)-268(it)-268(will)-268(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(necessary)-229(for)-230(me)-229(to)-229(employ,)-234(and)-229(to)-230(draw)-229(attention)-229(to)-230(some)-229(of)-229(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fallacies)-250(which)-250(a)-250(vague)-250(use)-250(of)-250(language)-250(has)-250(introduced.)]TJ 11.955 -13.746 Td [(First:)-382(No)-316(terms)-316(are)-316(more)-316(frequently)-316(used)-316(in)-316(this)-316(controversy)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(than)-237(the)-237(words)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 66.535 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.262 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.429 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.339 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(natural.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.021 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.016 0 Td [(They)-237(are)-237(constantly)-237(used)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 118.733 0 Td [([027])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(as)-267(if)-266(their)-267(meaning)-267(was)-266(definite)-267(and)-267(invariable.)-300(Nothing)-267(is)-266(more)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(common)-437(than)-436(to)-437(use)-437(the)-437(expression)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 168.572 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(laws)-437(of)-437(nature,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 68.602 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.608 0 Td [(and)-437(to)]TJ -251.625 -13.549 Td [(speak)-417(of)-417(miracles)-418(as)-417(involving)-417(contradictions,)-459(violations,)-459(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(suspensions)-251(of)-250(the)-251(laws)-251(and)-250(order)-251(of)-251(nature,)-250(as)-251(though)-251(there)-250(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-340(danger)-339(of)-340(our)-339(falling)-340(into)-339(fallacies)-340(of)-339(reasoning)-340(by)-339(classing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wholly)-250(different)-250(orders)-250(of)-250(phenomena)-250(under)-250(a)-250(common)-250(name.)]TJ 11.955 -13.747 Td [(What)-305(do)-306(we)-305(mean)-305(by)-305(the)-306(terms)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 142.679 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.262 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.174 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.083 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(natural)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30.295 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(?)-416(It)-305(is)]TJ -253.978 -13.549 Td [(evident)-297(that)-297(no)-297(satisfactory)-297(result)-297(can)-297(come)-297(from)-297(reasonings)-297(on)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
155 0 obj <<
/Length 5067      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(28)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(this)-329(subject,)-349(unless)-329(the)-329(parties)-329(to)-329(the)-329(discussion)-329(agree)-329(to)-329(attach)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-443(those)-442(words)-443(a)-443(steady)-442(and)-443(consistent)-442(meaning.)-828(Are)-443(we)-442(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-262(under)-262(the)-262(expression)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 112.608 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.261 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.7 0 Td [(to)-262(include)-262(both)-262(matter)-261(and)-262(its)]TJ -152.413 -13.549 Td [(phenomena,)-331(and)-315(mind)-314(and)-315(its)-315(phenomena?)-444(Is)-315(nature)-315(to)-314(include)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(all)-320(things)-320(which)-320(exist,)-337(including)-320(their)-320(causes;)-355(laws,)-338(and)-319(forces;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-292(is)-292(it)-293(to)-292(be)-292(restricted)-292(to)-292(matter,)-303(its)-292(laws)-292(and)-292(forces?)-377(Or)-292(is)-292(it)-292(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(include)-294(all)-293(things)-294(that)-294(exist,)-304(except)-294(God?)-381(I)-293(need)-294(hardly)-293(observe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-334(the)-334(laying)-334(down)-333(some)-334(clear)-334(and)-334(definite)-334(principles)-334(on)-333(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subject)-250(is)-250(vital)-250(to)-250(the)-250(present)-250(controversy.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Again:)-519(What)-385(do)-384(we)-385(mean)-384(by)-385(the)-384(laws)-385(of)-384(nature?)-654(How)-384(do)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(we)-348(distinguish)-348(between)-348(the)-348(laws)-347(and)-348(the)-348(forces)-348(of)-348(nature?)-543(Do)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-285(laws)-284(of)-284(nature,)-294(in)-284(the)-285(sense)-284(in)-285(which)-284(that)-284(expression)-285(is)-284(used)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-319(science,)-337(possess)-319(any)-319(efficient)-319(power)-319(whatever;)-354(or)-319(ought)-319(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(efficiency)-449(to)-449(be)-448(predicated)-449(only)-449(of)-449(the)-448(forces)-449(of)-449(nature,)-498(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(never)-280(of)-280(its)-279(laws?)-340(Or)-280(when)-279(we)-280(speak)-280(of)-280(the)-280(forces)-279(of)-280(nature,)-287(do)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-248(recognise)-247(any)-248(distinction)-247(between)-248(material)-247(and)-248(moral)-247(forces,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-365(do)-365(we)-365(confound)-365(phenomena)-365(so)-365(utterly)-365(differing)-365(in)-364(outward)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(character,)-319(and)-305(on)-305(whose)-305(difference)-305(some)-305(of)-305(the)-304(most)-305(important)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(points)-329(of)-329(the)-328(controversy)-329(about)-329(miracles)-329(rest,)-348(under)-329(a)-328(common)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(name?)-637(What)-379(again)-379(do)-379(we)-379(mean)-379(by)-379(the)-379(order)-379(of)-379(nature?)-637(Is)-379(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-428(material)-429(order;)-517(or)-428(does)-429(it)-428(include)-428(the)-428(order)-429(of)-428(the)-856(moral)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([028])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(universe?)-683(Until)-394(we)-394(can)-394(agree)-394(to)-395(attach)-394(a)-394(definite)-394(meaning)-394(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(these)-308(expressions,)-323(to)-308(argue)-308(t)1(hat)-308(miracles)-308(are)-308(contrary)-308(to)-308(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-261(involve)-260(a)-261(suspension)-261(of)-260(its)-261(laws,)-263(or)-261(a)-260(violation)-261(of)-261(its)-260(order,)-263(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-245(to)-246(affirm)-245(the)-246(contrary)-245(position,)-247(is)-245(fighting)-246(the)-245(air.)-249(Yet)-245(this)-245(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-250(almost)-250(say)-250(is)-250(the)-250(present)-250(aspect)-250(of)-250(the)-250(controversy.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Again:)-555(What)-403(do)-403(we)-402(intend,)-441(when)-403(we)-402(use)-403(the)-403(different)-402(ex-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(pressions,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 47.309 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(miracles,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 39.687 0 Td [(\035)-342(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.415 0 Td [(supernatural,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 56.651 0 Td [(\035)-342(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.414 0 Td [(superhuman,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 56.051 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.572 0 Td [(or)-342(events)]TJ -239.943 -13.549 Td [(occurring)-325(out)-326(of)-325(the)-326(order)-325(of)-326(nature?)-476(It)-325(is)-326(evident)-325(that)-325(whether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-196(point)-196(to)-196(any)-197(real)-196(distinctions)-196(or)-196(not,)-207(it)-196(is)-196(necessary)-196(to)-196(employ)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(them)-250(with)-250(consistency.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(The)-317(mere)-318(enumeration)-317(of)-317(these)-317(questions)-318(makes)-317(it)-317(clear)-317(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(by)-307(a)-307(vague)-308(and)-307(indefinite)-307(use)-307(of)-307(terms,)-322(or)-307(by)-307(attaching)-307(to)-307(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(meanings)-220(which)-220(they)-219(cannot)-220(accurately)-220(be)-219(made)-220(to)-220(bear,)-226(we)-219(may)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
159 0 obj <<
/Length 5649      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(II.)-250(Definitions)-250(of)-250(Terms.)-11504(29)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(unconsciously)-250(assume)-250(the)-250(entire)-250(question)-250(at)-250(issue.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(First:)-310(With)-280(respect)-280(to)-280(the)-280(terms)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 140.469 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.261 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.899 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.808 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(natural.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.021 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.899 0 Td [(What)]TJ -257.001 -13.55 Td [(do)-415(we)-414(include)-415(under)-414(them?)-744(Bishop)-415(Butler)-414(considers)-415(that)-414(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(latter)-392(term)-392(is)-392(satisfied)-393(by)-392(attaching)-392(to)-392(it)-392(the)-392(meaning)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 245.187 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(usual.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 25.757 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.787 -13.549 Td [(Nature)-192(then)-191(would)-192(mean)-191(the)-192(ordinary)-191(course)-191(of)-192(things.)-230(But)-192(such)-191(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(meaning)-254(would)-253(by)-254(no)-254(means)-254(satisfy)-253(the)-254(requirements)-254(of)-253(modern)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(science,)-250(philosophy,)-250(or)-250(theology.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(One)-386(obvious)-386(sense)-385(to)-386(attach)-386(to)-386(the)-385(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 188.794 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.262 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.052 0 Td [(is)-386(to)-386(use)]TJ -241.908 -13.549 Td [(it)-356(to)-356(denote)-356(the)-357(entire)-356(mass)-356(of)-356(phenomena)-356(as)-356(contemplated)-356(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical)-315(science.)-446(In)-315(this)-315(point)-315(of)-316(view)-315(it)-315(would)-315(include)-315(matter,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(its)-369(forces,)-399(and)-369(its)-369(laws,)-399(and)-369(embrace)-369(the)-369(entire)-369(range)-369(of)-369(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena)-359(and)-359(forces)-359(where)-359(action)-360(is)-359(necessary;)-413(and)-359(into)-359(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conception)-470(of)-470(which)-470(neither)-471(volition)-470(nor)-470(freedom)-470(enters.)-910(If)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.262 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.41 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.318 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(natural)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30.295 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.409 0 Td [(had)-235(been)-235(used)-236(only)-235(in)-235(this)-235(sense,)-239(it)-235(would)]TJ -100.382 -13.549 Td [(have)-276(saved)-276(us)-276(from)-276(a)-276(great)-276(mass)-276(of)-276(inconclusive)-276(reasoning.)-328(But)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-240(is)-239(far)-240(from)-239(being)-240(the)-239(case.)-493(Not)-240(only)-239(are)-240(they)-239(used)-240(to)-239(include)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([029])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(matter,)-429(its)-394(laws)-393(and)-394(forces,)-429(but)-394(also)-393(the)-394(whole)-393(phenomena)-393(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mind.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(To)-423(this)-423(use)-423(of)-423(the)-423(terms)-423(the)-423(Duke)-423(of)-423(Argyll)-423(has)-423(given)-423(no)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(inconsiderable)-320(countenance)-320(in)-320(his)-320(admirable)-320(work,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 229.27 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)-320(Reign)]TJ -234.114 -13.549 Td [(of)-255(Law,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.977 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.62 0 Td [(especially)-255(in)-254(the)-255(sixth)-254(chapter.)-264(He)-254(uses)-255(the)-254(term)-255(law)-254(as)]TJ -41.597 -13.549 Td [(alike)-345(applicable)-346(to)-345(the)-345(operations)-346(of)-345(mind)-346(and)-345(matter,)-369(and)-345(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-273(course)-273(implies)-273(that)-272(the)-273(whole)-273(of)-273(our)-273(mental)-273(phenomena)-272(form)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-300(portion)-299(of)-300(nature)-299(and)-300(its)-299(order.)-399(He)-299(is)-300(led)-299(to)-300(this,)-312(among)-299(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(considerations,)-261(by)-259(the)-259(use)-259(which)-259(we)-259(make)-259(of)-259(the)-259(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 240.648 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(natural)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30.295 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.787 -13.549 Td [(as)-332(applied)-331(to)-332(the)-331(results)-332(of)-331(all)-332(kinds)-332(of)-331(mental)-332(operations.)-494(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question)-225(may)-225(fairly)-225(be)-224(asked,)-230(Are)-225(not)-225(the)-225(works)-225(wrought)-225(by)-224(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-208(nat)1(ure,)-216(or)-208(is)-207(not)-208(the)-207(building)-208(of)-207(its)-208(nest)-207(by)-208(a)-207(bird,)-216(or)-208(of)-207(its)-207(comb)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-300(the)-299(bee,)-312(a)-300(natural)-300(operation?)-399(If)-299(so,)-313(man,)-312(bird,)-312(and)-299(bee,)-312(must)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(form)-250(a)-250(portion)-250(of)-250(nature,)-250(and)-250(their)-250(various)-250(actions,)-250(of)-250(its)-250(order.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(In)-291(a)-291(popular)-291(point)-291(of)-291(view)-291(such)-291(expressions)-291(involve)-291(no)-290(diffi-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(culty,)-248(and)-248(as)-248(a)-247(mere)-248(verbal)-248(distinction)-247(the)-248(whole)-248(question)-247(would)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(not)-276(be)-276(worth)-276(the)-276(labour)-276(of)-276(discussion.)-328(But)-276(in)-276(a)-276(question)-276(like)-276(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-183(now)-184(under)-183(consideration,)-197(which)-183(requires)-184(the)-183(utmost)-183(accuracy)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
163 0 obj <<
/Length 4991      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(30)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(both)-199(of)-198(thought)-199(and)-199(reasoning,)-209(the)-199(case)-198(is)-199(far)-199(different.)-233(The)-198(class-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ing)-278(together)-279(of)-278(phenomena)-279(which)-278(differ)-279(so)-278(entirely)-279(as)-278(mind)-278(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(matter,)-350(under)-330(a)-330(common)-331(term,)-350(leads)-330(to)-330(the)-330(inference)-330(that)-330(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-353(no)-353(essential)-353(difference)-352(between)-353(them,)-379(which)-353(involves)-353(at)-352(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(outset)-242(a)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 36.174 0 Td [(petitio)-242(princi)1(pii)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 70.734 0 Td [(of)-241(the)-242(entire)-241(question)-242(under)-241(definition.)-248(I)]TJ -106.908 -13.549 Td [(shall)-299(have)-298(occasion)-299(repeatedly)-298(to)-298(point)-299(out)-298(in)-299(the)-298(course)-299(of)-298(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(work)-217(the)-217(number)-217(of)-217(fallacious)-217(reasonings)-217(which)-217(have)-217(been)-216(intro-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(duced)-309(into)-309(the)-309(question)-309(about)-309(the)-309(possibility)-309(and)-309(the)-308(credibility)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-266(miracles)-266(by)-266(thus)-266(including)-266(under)-266(a)-266(common)-266(term)-266(phenomena)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(utterly)-292(different)-293(in)-292(character.)-377(It)-292(would)-293(be)-292(far)-292(better)-293(to)-292(get)-292(rid)-292(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(words)-259(so)-259(vague)-259(as)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 82.793 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.262 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.667 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.576 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(natural)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30.294 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.668 0 Td [(in)-259(this)-259(discussion,)-261(and)]TJ -180.198 -13.549 Td [(substitute)-344(for)-343(them)-344(terms)-343(of)-344(which)-343(it)-344(is)-344(impossible)-343(to)-344(mistake)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -76.504 0 Td [([030])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(the)-356(meaning,)-383(than)-356(to)-356(employ)-356(them)-356(in)-356(senses)-356(which)-356(are)-356(simply)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ambiguous)-250(and)-250(misleading.)-250(But)-250(of)-250(this)-250(more)-250(hereafter.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(What)-293(then)-293(are)-293(we)-294(to)-293(do)-293(with)-293(man?)-380(Is)-293(he)-293(a)-293(part)-293(of)-293(nature)-293(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(its)-381(order?)-645(I)-381(reply)-382(that)-381(man)-382(is)-381(within)-382(material)-381(nature)-382(as)-381(far)-381(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(regards)-300(his)-299(bodily)-300(organization;)-324(but)-299(that)-300(he)-299(is)-300(outside,)-312(or)-299(above)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it,)-315(and)-301(belongs)-302(to)-302(a)-302(different)-301(order,)-315(as)-302(far)-301(as)-302(his)-302(rational)-301(action,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-427(volition,)-472(and)-427(his)-428(moral)-427(powers)-427(are)-428(concerned.)-782(All)-427(that)-427(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(am)-334(contending)-334(for)-334(is)-334(that)-334(a)-334(clear)-334(distinction)-334(must)-334(be)-333(preserved)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(between)-387(the)-387(necessary)-387(action)-387(of)-387(the)-387(forces)-387(of)-387(material)-386(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-364(the)-364(voluntary)-364(action)-364(of)-364(man;)-421(and)-364(that)-364(terms)-364(must)-364(be)-363(used)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-332(accurately)-332(denote)-332(this)-332(distinction.)-495(Matter,)-353(its)-332(forces)-331(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(laws,)-402(involve)-372(the)-371(conception)-372(of)-372(necessary)-371(action.)-615(They)-372(act)-371(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-372(particular)-372(manner)-372(because)-372(they)-372(cannot)-372(help)-372(so)-372(acting.)-615(With)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-203(purely)-202(intellectual)-203(I)-202(am)-202(not)-203(concerned,)-212(but)-202(all)-203(moral)-202(action)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-317(voluntary.)-449(Man)-316(as)-317(an)-316(agent)-317(can)-316(act)-317(or)-316(forbear)-317(acting;)-349(matter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cannot.)-466(This)-321(distinction)-322(is)-322(of)-322(the)-322(highest)-322(importance,)-340(and)-321(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-454(be)-454(lost)-454(sight)-454(of)-455(behind)-454(a)-454(confused)-454(use)-454(of)-454(such)-454(terms)-454(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural,)-243(law,)-242(force,)-243(or)-241(order)-241(of)-241(nature,)-243(applied)-241(indeterminately)-240(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-257(necessary)-257(action)-257(of)-256(material)-257(agents,)-259(and)-257(the)-257(voluntary)-256(action)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-250(moral)-250(ones.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-280(will)-280(doubtless)-280(be)-279(objected)-280(by)-280(a)-280(certain)-280(order)-280(of)-279(philosophy)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-223(all)-223(mental)-222(and)-223(moral)-223(force)-222(is)-223(only)-223(some)-223(special)-222(modification)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
167 0 obj <<
/Length 4877      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(II.)-250(Definitions)-250(of)-250(Terms.)-11504(31)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(of)-353(material)-353(force,)-378(and)-353(consequently)-352(that)-353(there)-353(is)-353(no)-352(distinction)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(between)-463(material)-463(and)-463(moral)-464(action,)-516(or)-463(between)-463(material)-463(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-313(force,)-330(and)-313(that)-314(the)-313(words)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 143.385 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.261 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.264 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.172 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(natural)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30.295 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.263 0 Td [(are)-313(cor-)]TJ -246.327 -13.549 Td [(rectly)-371(applied)-370(to)-371(both)-370(alike,)-401(as)-371(being)-370(simple)-371(manifestations)-370(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-389(same)-390(original)-389(force.)-668(To)-389(this)-389(it)-389(will)-390(be)-389(sufficient)-389(to)-389(reply,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first:)-366(that)-308(this)-308(is)-307(an)-308(assertion)-308(only,)-645(and)-308(never)-308(has)-308(been)-308(nor)-307(can)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([031])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(be)-368(proved.)-603(Secondly:)-486(that)-368(it)-368(contradicts)-368(the)-368(highest)-368(of)-368(al)1(l)-368(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certitudes,)-302(the)-291(direct)-292(testimony)-291(of)-292(consciousness,)-302(which)-291(affirms)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-325(we)-325(live)-324(under)-325(a)-325(law)-325(of)-325(freedom,)-343(wholly)-325(different)-325(from)-324(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(necessary)-379(laws)-380(of)-379(material)-380(nature.)-638(Thirdly:)-509(that)-379(it)-379(contradicts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-219(universal)-219(experience)-220(of)-219(mankind,)-225(as)-220(embodied)-219(in)-219(the)-219(primary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(laws)-294(of)-295(human)-294(language)-294(and)-295(human)-294(thought.)-383(To)-295(assume)-294(this)-294(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-384(commencement)-384(of)-384(the)-384(argument)-384(is)-384(to)-384(take)-384(for)-384(granted)-384(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(point)-250(which)-250(requires)-250(to)-250(be)-250(proved.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(It)-296(would)-297(be)-296(quite)-297(out)-296(of)-297(place)-296(in)-297(a)-296(treatise)-297(like)-296(the)-297(present)-296(to)]TJ -11.955 -13.55 Td [(attempt)-324(to)-323(discuss)-324(the)-324(question)-324(of)-324(the)-323(origin)-324(of)-324(the)-324(free)-323(agency)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-324(the)-324(moral)-324(nature)-324(of)-323(man.)-472(It)-324(is)-324(sufficient)-324(for)-324(the)-323(purpose)-324(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(observe)-400(that,)-439(however)-400(voluntary)-401(agency)-400(may)-401(have)-400(originated,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-460(is)-460(a)-459(simple)-460(fact)-460(that)-460(it)-460(exists)-460(in)-460(the)-459(universe,)-513(and)-460(that)-459(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena)-302(belong)-302(to)-302(an)-302(order)-302(of)-302(its)-302(own.)-406(It)-302(is)-302(no)-302(mere)-302(theory,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(but)-298(a)-298(fact,)-310(that)-298(man)-298(not)-298(only)-298(is)-298(capable)-298(of)-298(modifying)-298(the)-298(action)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-325(the)-324(forces)-325(of)-325(the)-324(material)-325(universe,)-344(but)-324(that)-325(he)-325(has)-324(modified)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them,)-210(and)-200(has)-201(produced)-200(results)-200(utterly)-201(different)-200(from)-200(those)-200(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-308(have)-309(followed)-308(from)-308(their)-308(simple)-309(action.)-425(To)-308(use)-308(terms)-308(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-263(controversy)-262(which)-263(overlook)-262(this)-263(plain)-262(and)-263(obvious)-263(fact,)-265(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lead)-250(to)-250(no)-250(satisfactory)-250(result.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(Are)-337(then)-337(the)-337(actions)-337(of)-337(man,)-359(the)-337(bird,)-359(and)-337(the)-337(bee,)-359(properly)]TJ -11.955 -13.55 Td [(designated)-264(as)-265(natural?)-294(In)-264(a)-265(popular)-264(use)-265(of)-264(language)-265(the)-264(question)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-227(be)-227(one)-228(purely)-227(verbal;)-235(but)-227(when)-227(we)-228(are)-227(dealing)-227(with)-227(subjects)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(requiring)-305(accurate)-305(thought,)-318(it)-305(is)-305(in)-305(the)-305(highest)-305(degree)-304(necessary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-210(use)-211(language)-210(which)-211(does)-210(not)-211(confound)-210(the)-211(distinct)-210(phenomena)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-276(mind)-275(and)-276(matter)-276(under)-275(a)-276(common)-276(designation.)-327(Both)-275(together)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(compose)-341(the)-340(universe;)-386(but)-341(each)-341(belongs)-341(to)-340(a)-341(different)-341(order)-340(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena.)-677(The)-393(whole)-392(difficulty)-393(proceeds)-392(from)-392(the)-393(fact)-392(that)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
171 0 obj <<
/Length 5150      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(32)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(both)-183(material)-183(forces)-183(which)-183(act)-183(in)-183(conformity)-183(with)-183(necessary)-182(laws,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-271(moral)-271(ones)-541(which)-271(act)-271(in)-270(conformity)-271(with)-271(those)-271(of)-270(freedom,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([032])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(are)-250(united)-250(in)-250(the)-250(person)-250(of)-250(man.)]TJ 11.956 -16.626 Td [(Another)-286(order)-287(of)-286(thought)-287(uses)-286(the)-286(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 175.175 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.262 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.968 0 Td [(as)-286(including)]TJ -227.204 -13.549 Td [(everything)-362(that)-361(exists,)-390(even)-361(God;)-418(or)-361(in)-362(other)-361(words,)-390(it)-361(affirms)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-203(every)-202(thing)-203(which)-202(has)-202(existed)-203(and)-202(exists)-203(is)-202(a)-203(manifestation)-202(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Him.)-302(As)-268(this)-267(theory)-268(involves)-267(the)-267(denial)-268(of)-267(the)-268(personality)-267(of)-267(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Divine)-341(Being,)-363(it)-341(stands)-340(excluded)-341(from)-341(the)-340(question)-341(under)-340(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sideration,)-366(namely,)-366(the)-342(credibility)-343(of)-342(miracles,)-366(which)-343(is)-342(utterly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(irrelevant,)-383(except)-357(on)-356(the)-357(assumption)-356(of)-357(the)-356(existence)-356(of)-357(a)-356(per-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sonal)-297(God.)-391(It)-297(ought)-297(to)-298(be)-297(observed,)-308(however,)-309(that)-297(while)-297(theism)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirms)-374(that)-374(God)-374(and)-374(the)-374(universe,)-405(whether)-374(material)-374(or)-373(moral,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-295(distinct,)-306(it)-295(fully)-295(recognises)-294(the)-295(fact)-295(that)-295(God)-295(is)-295(immanent)-294(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(both)-325(the)-325(worlds)-326(of)-325(mind)-325(and)-325(matter,)-344(while)-326(at)-325(the)-325(same)-325(time)-325(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(transcends)-261(them)-262(both.)-283(This)-262(is)-261(an)-261(important)-261(consideration,)-264(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-250(too)-250(often)-250(overlooked)-250(by)-250(both)-250(parties)-250(to)-250(the)-250(discussion.)]TJ 11.956 -16.626 Td [(Secondly:)-404(a)-327(still)-328(greater)-327(confusion)-327(has)-327(been)-327(introduced)-327(by)-327(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(vague)-387(and)-387(indefinite)-387(use)-386(of)-387(the)-387(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 170.115 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(law,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.48 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.064 0 Td [(and)-387(by)-387(confusing)]TJ -202.503 -13.549 Td [(a)-397(number)-396(of)-397(utterly)-397(diverse)-396(phenomena)-397(under)-397(the)-396(designation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-357(the)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30.202 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(laws)-357(of)-357(nature.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 66.857 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.735 0 Td [(It)-357(is)-357(absolutely)-356(necessary)-357(to)-357(trace)-357(this)]TJ -110.638 -13.55 Td [(fallacy)-316(to)-316(its)-315(source.)-448(The)-316(Duke)-316(of)-315(Argyll)-316(tells)-316(us)-316(in)-316(his)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 249.725 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Reign)]TJ -254.568 -13.549 Td [(of)-265(Law)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 31.36 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.73 0 Td [(that)-265(there)-264(are)-265(five)-264(different)-265(senses)-265(at)-264(least)-265(in)-265(which)-264(this)]TJ -39.09 -13.549 Td [(word)-308(is)-309(habitually)-308(used)-308(even)-309(in)-308(scientific)-309(writings.)-425(They)-308(are)-308(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(follows:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 35.76 0 Td [(\024)]TJ -23.805 -16.626 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(First,)-259(we)-257(have)-256(law)-257(as)-257(applied)-257(simply)-257(to)-257(an)-257(observed)-257(order)-257(of)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(facts.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 23.324 0 Td [(\035)]TJ -11.369 -16.626 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Secondly,)-249(to)-250(that)-249(order)-249(as)-250(involving)-249(the)-250(action)-249(of)-249(some)-250(force)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(or)-250(forces)-250(of)-250(which)-250(nothing)-250(more)-250(can)-250(be)-250(known.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 206.924 0 Td [(\035)]TJ -194.969 -16.626 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Thirdly,)-198(as)-184(applied)-185(to)-185(individual)-185(forces,)-197(the)-185(measure)-185(of)-185(whose)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(operation)-250(has)-250(been)-250(more)-250(or)-250(less)-250(defined)-250(or)-250(ascertained.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 239.629 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -312.385 0 Td [([033])]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -16.625 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Fourthly,)-358(as)-337(applied)-336(to)-337(those)-337(combinations)-336(of)-337(forces)-337(which)]TJ -16.799 -13.55 Td [(have)-301(reference)-301(to)-301(the)-301(fulfilment)-301(of)-301(purposes)-301(or)-301(the)-300(discharge)-301(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(functions.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 43.331 0 Td [(\035)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
176 0 obj <<
/Length 5599      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(II.)-250(Definitions)-250(of)-250(Terms.)-11504(33)]TJ
0 g 0 G
/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -30.759 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Fifthly,)-308(as)-296(applied)-296(to)-296(abstract)-296(conceptions)-296(of)-296(the)-297(mind)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 238.98 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(not)]TJ -266.688 -13.549 Td [(corresponding)-366(with)-366(any)-366(actual)-366(phenomena,)-395(but)-366(deduced)-366(there-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-419(as)-419(axioms)-418(of)-419(thought,)-461(necessary)-419(to)-419(an)-419(understanding)-418(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them.)-463(Law,)-339(in)-321(this)-321(sense,)-339(is)-321(a)-321(reduction)-321(of)-322(the)-321(phenomena,)-338(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(merely)-250(to)-250(an)-250(order)-250(of)-250(facts,)-250(but)-250(to)-250(an)-250(order)-250(of)-250(thought.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 235.407 0 Td [(\035)]TJ -223.451 -14.531 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(These)-492(leading)-493(significations)-492(of)-492(the)-493(word)-492(Law,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 216.13 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.214 0 Td [(says)-492(the)]TJ -243.143 -13.549 Td [(Duke,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30.08 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(all)-323(circle)-323(round)-323(the)-323(three)-323(great)-323(questions)-323(which)-323(science)]TJ -34.923 -13.549 Td [(asks)-250(of)-250(nature,)-250(the)-250(what,)-250(the)-250(how,)-250(and)-250(the)-250(why.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 205.113 0 Td [(\035)]TJ -193.157 -14.531 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(What)-250(are)-250(the)-250(facts)-250(in)-250(their)-250(established)-250(order?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 194.793 0 Td [(\035)]TJ -199.636 -14.531 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(How,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 26.718 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 16.193 0 Td [(from)-254(what)-254(physical)-254(causes)-255(does)-254(that)-254(order)-254(come)-254(to)]TJ -59.71 -13.55 Td [(be?)-453(What)-317(relation)-318(do)-318(they)-317(bear)-318(to)-317(purpose,)-335(to)-317(the)-318(fulfilment)-317(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intention,)-250(to)-250(the)-250(discharge)-250(of)-250(function?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 169.069 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -157.113 -14.531 Td [(Such)-455(are)-456(the)-455(multiform)-456(acceptations)-455(attached)-456(by)-455(scientific)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(men)-258(to)-257(the)-258(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 71.838 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(law,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.48 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.653 0 Td [(yet)-258(the)-257(Duke)-258(is)-257(not)-258(quite)-257(certain)-258(whether)]TJ -102.815 -13.549 Td [(they)-312(may)-312(not)-312(be)-312(even)-311(more)-312(numerous.)-436(It)-312(is)-312(evident)-312(that)-312(if)-311(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-309(all)-309(imported)-309(into)-308(the)-309(question)-309(of)-309(the)-309(credibility)-309(of)-308(miracles,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(our)-234(position)-234(must)-234(resemble)-233(that)-234(of)-234(persons)-234(who)-234(are)-234(compelled)-233(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fight)-272(in)-273(the)-272(dark;)-284(and)-272(that)-273(the)-272(question)-272(whether)-273(an)-272(occurrence)-272(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural)-222(or)-222(supernatural,)-227(whether)-222(it)-222(is)-222(contrary)-221(to,)-228(or)-222(a)-222(violation)-221(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-233(laws)-232(of)-233(nature,)-236(or)-232(above)-232(nature,)-236(and)-233(many)-232(others)-233(which)-232(enter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-206(this)-206(controversy)-205(must)-206(be)-206(without)-206(definite)-206(meaning.)-235(It)-206(is)-205(clear)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-378(unless)-377(we)-378(can)-377(restrict)-378(the)-377(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 166.373 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(law)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 15.753 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.962 0 Td [(to)-378(one,)-409(or)-378(at)-377(most,)]TJ -195.931 -13.549 Td [(two)-306(definite)-306(meanings,)-320(we)-306(shall)-306(get)-306(into)-306(hopeless)-306(confusion,)-320(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-414(speak)-413(more)-414(correctly,)-455(we)-413(shall)-414(open)-414(the)-413(gate)-414(wide)-414(for)-413(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(introduction)-250(of)-250(any)-250(number)-250(of)-250(fallacies.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(The)-224(primary)-225(conception)-224(implied)-224(by)-225(the)-224(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 194.077 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(law)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 15.753 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.738 0 Td [(is)-224(unques-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 54.656 0 Td [([034])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(tionably)-281(one)-281(which)-281(is)-281(strictly)-281(applicable)-281(to)-281(man)-281(and)-281(his)-280(actions,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-264(can)-264(only)-264(be)-264(applied)-264(metaphorically,)-268(and)-264(in)-264(some)-264(systems)-264(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thought)-264(after)-265(a)-264(considerable)-265(change)-264(of)-264(meaning,)-268(to)-265(the)-264(facts)-264(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena)-239(of)-238(the)-238(material)-239(universe.)-246(A)-239(law)-238(is)-239(a)-238(rule)-238(of)-239(action)-238(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(human)-267(conduct)-266(and)-267(nothing)-267(more.)-300(Such)-267(rules)-266(of)-267(conduct)-267(for)-266(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(most)-359(part)-358(pre-suppose)-359(that)-359(they)-359(are)-358(imposed)-359(by)-359(some)-358(external)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(authority,)-261(which)-259(has)-259(the)-259(right)-259(or)-259(the)-259(power)-259(to)-259(enforce)-258(obedience)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-412(them;)-494(or)-412(else)-412(that)-413(the)-412(person)-412(obeying)-413(them)-412(has)-412(an)-412(inward)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
181 0 obj <<
/Length 4728      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(34)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(feeling)-357(that)-357(it)-357(is)-357(right)-356(to)-357(do)-357(so,)-384(and)-357(knows)-357(that)-357(his)-356(conscience)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will)-329(reproach)-330(him)-329(for)-329(the)-330(omission.)-488(But)-329(law,)-349(strictly)-329(speaking,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-433(simply)-432(the)-433(rule)-433(of)-432(action)-433(itself,)-478(as)-433(for)-433(instance,)-478(an)-433(Act)-432(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Parliament;)-429(but)-369(as)-369(in)-369(practice)-369(all)-369(such)-369(rules)-369(are)-369(enforced)-369(by)-369(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sanction)-379(of)-379(some)-379(kind,)-411(our)-378(conception)-379(of)-379(a)-379(law)-379(is)-379(also)-378(united)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-271(that)-272(of)-271(a)-272(lawgiver,)-276(who)-272(has)-271(both)-272(the)-271(right)-271(and)-272(the)-271(power)-271(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enforce)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-434(follows)-435(therefore)-434(that)-435(such)-434(a)-435(conception)-434(is)-435(essentially)-434(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(moral)-322(one.)-466(It)-322(is)-322(also)-322(intimately)-322(united)-322(with)-322(the)-322(knowledge)-322(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-248(possess)-248(the)-248(power)-249(to)-248(act)-248(or)-248(forbear)-248(acting)-248(in)-248(conformity)-248(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-200(dictates,)-209(and,)-210(if)-199(we)-200(prefer)-199(it,)-210(of)-199(taking)-200(the)-199(consequences)-200(of)-199(dis-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(obedience.)-244(But)-231(when)-231(such)-231(a)-231(conception)-231(is)-231(transferred)-230(to)-231(material)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature)-250(it)-250(loses)-250(a)-250(considerable)-250(portion)-250(of)-250(its)-250(original)-250(significancy.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(In)-378(its)-379(application)-378(therefore)-378(to)-379(physical)-378(science,)-411(it)-378(may)-378(with)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(strict)-312(propriety)-312(be)-312(used)-311(to)-312(denote)-312(an)-312(invariable)-312(order)-312(of)-311(events:)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-260(if)-259(the)-260(human)-259(analogy)-260(could)-259(hold)-260(in)-259(physics)-260(it)-259(might)-260(be)-259(used)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-230(include)-230(the)-230(power)-230(which)-230(originated)-229(and)-230(enforced)-230(them.)-244(But)-229(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-289(consideration)-290(of)-289(will)-289(or)-290(purpose)-289(forms)-289(no)-290(portion)-289(of)-289(strictly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical)-245(science,)-246(and)-245(is)-245(expressly)-245(excluded)-245(from)-245(it,)-246(the)-245(term)-244(law)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-301(used)-301(by)-301(it)-302(ought)-301(to)-301(denote)-301(the)-301(invariable)-301(order)-301(of)-301(sequences,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-443(not)-442(to)-443(include)-886(the)-442(forces)-443(which)-443(generate)-442(them.)-828(Unless)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([035])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(this)-362(distinction)-361(is)-362(carefully)-362(observed,)-389(we)-362(shall)-361(be)-362(in)-362(danger)-361(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(introducing)-278(into)-279(our)-278(reasonings)-279(human)-278(analogies)-279(to)-278(which)-278(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-401(nothing)-400(corresponding)-401(in)-401(nature)-400(viewed)-401(as)-401(a)-400(mere)-401(body)-400(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(unintelligent)-250(forces.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(The)-406(use)-406(of)-406(the)-406(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.068 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(law)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 15.753 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.273 0 Td [(in)-406(physical)-406(science)-406(ought)-406(to)-406(be)]TJ -137.893 -13.549 Td [(confined)-522(to)-522(denote)-521(the)-522(invariable)-522(sequences)-522(of)-522(the)-521(material)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(phenomena.)-260(Physicists)-253(profess)-254(to)-253(know)-253(nothing)-254(of)-253(efficient)-253(cau-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sation;)-246(or)-245(of)-245(a)-244(lawgiver)-245(standing)-245(outside)-244(his)-245(laws)-245(and)-244(possessing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-231(to)-231(enforce)-231(them.)-243(The)-231(whole)-231(question)-231(of)-231(intelligent)-230(agency)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-270(purpose)-270(lies)-270(in)-270(a)-270(region)-270(outside)-270(their)-270(province.)-310(Law,)-275(as)-270(far)-270(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical)-320(science)-319(is)-320(acquainted)-320(with)-319(it,)-337(can)-320(consist)-320(only)-319(of)-320(a)-319(set)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-258(antecedents,)-260(followed)-258(by)-259(an)-258(invariable)-258(set)-258(of)-258(consequents.)-274(Of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-297(inherent)-298(efficacy)-297(in)-298(these)-297(antecedents)-297(to)-298(produce)-297(their)-297(con-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
185 0 obj <<
/Length 4667      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(II.)-250(Definitions)-250(of)-250(Terms.)-11504(35)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(sequents,)-266(it)-263(can)-263(affirm)-263(nothing.)-288(A)-263(very)-263(popular)-263(philosophy)-262(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(denies)-353(the)-354(power)-353(of)-353(the)-354(human)-353(mind)-353(to)-354(penetrate)-353(beyond)-353(this,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(affirms)-250(that)-250(its)-250(entire)-250(knowledge)-250(is)-250(limited)-250(to)-250(phenomena.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-353(physical)-353(science)-353(also)-354(deals)-353(with)-353(forces.)-559(These,)-379(and)-353(not)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(its)-282(laws,)-291(are)-282(its)-283(true)-282(principles)-282(of)-283(causation.)-347(Mere)-282(invariable)-282(se-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(quences)-262(can)-262(effect)-262(nothing;)-268(but)-262(forces,)-265(such)-262(as)-262(gravitation,)-264(heat,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(electricity,)-335(and)-319(the)-318(entire)-318(body)-318(of)-319(chemical)-318(forces,)-335(or)-318(whatever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(force)-428(they)-428(may)-428(ultimately)-428(be)-428(resolved)-428(into,)-472(can)-428(effect)-428(much.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(They)-259(are)-258(in)-259(fact)-258(the)-259(antecedents)-258(of)-258(which)-259(the)-258(invariable)-259(order)-258(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-276(are)-275(the)-276(consequents.)-327(Respecting)-276(the)-275(ultimate)-276(principle)-275(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(force,)-277(or)-271(what)-271(is)-271(its)-272(real)-271(nature,)-276(or)-272(how)-271(it)-271(is)-271(directed,)-277(or)-271(came)-271(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be,)-285(physical)-277(science)-278(is)-277(silent.)-333(All)-278(that)-278(it)-277(can)-278(do)-278(is)-277(to)-278(observe)-277(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-297(of)-297(their)-297(occurrence,)-308(measure)-297(their)-297(quantities,)-309(and)-296(tabulate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-256(results.)-269(By)-257(this)-256(means)-256(it)-257(rises)-256(to)-256(the)-257(conception)-256(of)-256(what)-256(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(called)-250(the)-250(laws)-250(of)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(If)-307(in)-308(the)-307(present)-308(controversy)-307(the)-308(word)-307(law)-308(had)-615(been)-307(used)-307(in)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 279.068 0 Td [([036])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(this)-247(sense)-247(only,)-248(it)-247(would)-247(have)-247(been)-247(wholly)-247(unexceptionable.)-249(But)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-294(becomes)-294(far)-294(otherwise)-293(when)-294(the)-294(idea)-294(of)-294(force)-294(or)-294(efficiency)-293(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(introduced)-247(into)-248(it.)-249(Nothing)-247(is)-248(more)-247(common)-247(in)-248(the)-247(reasonings)-247(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(those)-264(who)-264(attempt)-264(to)-264(prove)-264(that)-264(miracles)-264(are)-264(impossible,)-267(than)-264(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(import)-253(into)-253(the)-253(term)-254(law)-253(the)-253(idea)-253(of)-253(force,)-254(or)-253(efficient)-253(causation,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-314(at)-314(the)-313(very)-314(time)-314(when)-314(the)-313(presence)-314(of)-314(intelligent)-314(action)-313(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(denied.)-430(It)-310(is)-311(this)-310(which)-310(imparts)-310(to)-310(this)-310(class)-310(of)-310(reasonings)-310(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entire)-281(speciousness.)-344(The)-282(laws)-281(of)-281(material)-282(nature)-281(are)-281(continually)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(spoken)-274(of)-273(as)-274(though)-273(they)-274(were)-274(forces)-273(which)-274(are)-273(energetic)-274(in)-273(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(universe,)-257(and)-256(to)-255(the)-256(energy)-255(of)-256(which)-255(all)-256(things)-255(owe)-256(their)-255(present)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(form;)-437(or)-374(in)-375(other)-375(words,)-405(it)-375(is)-375(assumed)-374(that)-375(the)-374(laws)-375(of)-374(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-254(causes)-254(which)-254(have)-254(produced)-254(by)-254(their)-254(unintelligent)-254(action)-253(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(present)-250(order)-250(of)-250(the)-250(universe.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Nothing)-306(however)-307(can)-306(be)-307(clearer)-306(than)-307(that)-306(a)-307(law)-306(of)-307(nature,)-320(in)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-304(sense)-303(in)-304(which)-303(purely)-303(physical)-304(science)-303(can)-304(take)-303(cognizance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-301(one,)-313(can)-301(effectuate)-301(nothing.)-402(What)-301(can)-300(an)-301(invariable)-301(order)-300(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sequences)-204(effect?)-234(Before)-204(the)-204(idea)-204(of)-203(efficiency)-204(can)-204(be)-204(attached)-203(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(law,)-285(the)-277(conception)-278(of)-278(force)-278(must)-277(be)-278(introduced)-278(into)-277(it.)-333(Modern)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
189 0 obj <<
/Length 5026      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(36)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(controversy,)-195(however,)-195(is)-181(constantly)-181(in)-182(the)-181(habit)-181(of)-181(speaking)-181(of)-181(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(laws)-285(of)-285(nature)-285(as)-285(though)-285(they)-285(were)-285(efficient)-285(agents.)-355(We)-284(hear)-285(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(creation)-211(by)-211(law,)-219(evolution)-211(by)-212(law,)-219(of)-211(results)-211(brought)-211(about)-211(by)-211(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-323(of)-323(invariable)-322(laws,)-341(and)-323(a)-323(countless)-323(number)-323(of)-322(assertions)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-285(a)-285(similar)-286(description.)-355(To)-285(such)-286(expressions)-285(in)-285(a)-285(popular)-285(sense)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-197(no)-197(accuracy)-197(of)-197(expression)-197(is)-197(required,)-208(there)-197(is)-196(no)-197(objection;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-248(when)-247(they)-248(are)-248(introduced)-248(into)-247(the)-248(controversy)-248(respecting)-247(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(credibility)-283(of)-283(miracles,)-292(they)-283(create)-283(nothing)-283(but)-283(confusion.)-349(What)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-423(really)-424(meant)-423(is,)-466(that)-424(such)-423(results)-423(are)-424(brought)-423(about)-423(by)-423(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(action)-203(of)-202(forces)-203(which)-202(act)-202(in)-203(conformity)-202(with)-203(invariable)-202(laws,)-212(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-301(idea)-300(of)-301(intelligence)-601(and)-301(volition)-301(is)-300(carefully)-301(excluded)-300(from)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([037])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(the)-245(conception.)-248(It)-245(is)-245(clearly)-245(inaccurate)-245(to)-245(speak)-245(of)-245(laws)-244(reigning.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Laws)-253(do)-253(not)-252(reign)-253(even)-253(in)-253(political)-253(societies;)-254(but)-253(only)-253(the)-252(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-311(is)-310(able)-311(to)-310(enact)-311(and)-310(enforce)-310(them.)-432(In)-310(material)-311(nature)-310(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(only)-250(things)-250(which)-250(possess)-250(efficiency)-250(are)-250(its)-250(forces.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(There)-331(can)-331(be)-331(no)-331(objection)-331(to)-331(the)-331(use)-331(of)-331(the)-331(expression,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 250.5 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(the)]TJ -267.299 -13.55 Td [(laws)-251(of)-251(mind,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 59.712 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.579 0 Td [(when)-251(care)-251(is)-250(taken)-251(to)-251(use)-251(language)-250(which)-251(clearly)]TJ -67.291 -13.549 Td [(distinguishes)-310(between)-311(them)-310(and)-310(unintelligent)-311(and)-310(necessary)-310(se-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(quences)-285(of)-286(material)-285(nature.)-356(But)-285(when)-285(the)-286(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 208.351 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(law)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 15.753 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.956 0 Td [(is)-285(without)]TJ -236.904 -13.549 Td [(any)-334(qualification)-335(applied)-334(to)-335(both)-334(sets)-335(of)-334(phenomena)-334(alike,)-356(it)-334(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-362(either)-362(to)-361(lead)-362(to)-362(fallacious)-362(reasoning,)-389(or)-362(to)-362(involve)-361(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(assumption)-368(of)-369(the)-368(point)-369(at)-368(issue.)-606(Whatever)-368(may)-369(be)-368(the)-368(origin)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-393(the)-393(moral)-393(and)-393(spiritual)-393(in)-392(man,)-429(it)-393(is)-393(certain)-393(that)-393(as)-393(they)-392(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(present)-245(exist)-245(in)-245(him,)-247(they)-245(stand)-245(out)-245(in)-245(the)-245(strongest)-245(contrast)-245(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-305(forces)-305(which)-305(act)-305(upon)-304(material)-305(things,)-319(and)-305(with)-305(the)-305(laws)-304(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-281(action.)-344(Nothing)-281(can)-281(be)-281(more)-281(entirely)-281(different)-281(in)-281(character)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-356(the)-356(force)-356(of)-357(gravitation)-356(and)-356(the)-356(principles)-356(of)-356(volition)-356(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(self-consciousness,)-424(or)-389(than)-389(the)-389(unconscious)-389(forces)-389(of)-388(material)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature)-204(and)-204(those)-204(principles)-204(which)-204(constitute)-205(our)-204(rationality.)-234(If)-204(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-206(that)-205(the)-206(forces)-206(of)-206(mind)-205(act)-206(in)-206(conformity)-205(with)-206(law,)-215(it)-205(ought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-227(be)-228(clearly)-227(understood)-228(that)-227(they)-227(act)-228(in)-227(conformity)-227(with)-228(a)-227(law)-227(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-289(own,)-298(which)-288(affords)-289(free)-289(action)-288(to)-289(the)-288(principle)-289(of)-288(volition.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Otherwise)-371(there)-371(is)-372(the)-371(greatest)-371(danger)-371(that)-371(the)-371(expression)-371(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(involve)-434(the)-434(covert)-434(assumption)-433(of)-434(the)-434(truth)-434(of)-434(the)-434(doctrine)-433(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
193 0 obj <<
/Length 4862      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(II.)-250(Definitions)-250(of)-250(Terms.)-11504(37)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(philosophical)-370(necessity,)-401(or)-370(in)-371(other)-370(words,)-400(that)-371(all)-370(mental)-370(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(material)-251(forces)-251(are)-250(of)-251(the)-251(same)-251(character,)-251(that)-250(is)-251(to)-251(say,)-251(that)-250(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-286(both)-286(equally)-286(necessary.)-357(This)-286(involves)-286(the)-286(assumption)-286(of)-285(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(very)-220(point)-220(on)-219(which)-220(the)-220(entire)-220(controversy)-219(turns,)-226(for)-220(if)-220(moral)-219(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(material)-281(forces)-280(and)-281(laws)-280(are)-281(all)-281(alike,)-288(it)-280(destroys)-281(the)-280(conception)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(a)-250(God,)-250(and)-250(the)-250(significance)-250(of)-250(a)-250(miracle.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([038])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -16.004 Td [(This)-382(brings)-381(us)-382(to)-381(the)-382(conception)-381(of)-382(force,)-415(what)-381(is)-382(it?)-644(Var-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ious)-371(definitions)-371(of)-372(it)-371(have)-371(been)-371(given)-371(sufficiently)-371(accurate)-371(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(practical)-287(purposes.)-360(It)-287(should)-287(be)-287(observed)-287(however)-287(that)-286(physical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(science)-364(can)-364(know)-364(nothing)-364(of)-364(it)-364(except)-364(as)-364(a)-364(phenomenon.)-592(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(determination)-407(of)-406(its)-407(nature,)-446(and)-407(its)-406(ultimate)-407(cause)-407(lie)-406(entirely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beyond)-206(its)-207(limits.)-235(Many)-207(facts)-206(respecting)-207(it,)-215(have)-206(been)-206(ascertained)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-234(tabulated.)-244(Many)-234(of)-234(its)-234(manifestations,)-237(which)-234(bear)-234(a)-233(different)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomenal)-281(aspect,)-289(it)-281(has)-281(ascertained)-281(to)-281(be)-281(capable)-281(of)-280(transmu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tation)-300(into)-300(one)-299(another.)-400(But)-300(it)-300(must)-299(never)-300(be)-300(forgotten)-300(that)-300(it)-299(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(able)-290(to)-289(affirm)-290(nothing)-290(respecting)-289(the)-290(source)-290(in)-289(which)-290(the)-289(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-328(the)-329(universe)-328(originate.)-485(All)-328(that)-329(it)-328(can)-328(affirm)-329(is,)-348(that)-328(they)-328(do)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exist.)-484(The)-328(original)-328(conception)-328(of)-328(force)-328(is)-328(one,)-347(however,)-347(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-248(derive,)-249(not)-248(from)-248(the)-248(material)-248(universe,)-248(but)-248(from)-248(the)-248(action)-248(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-325(own)-325(minds.)-474(We)-325(are)-325(conscious)-324(that)-325(we)-325(are)-325(efficient)-324(agents,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-234(that)-235(definite)-234(results)-234(follow)-234(the)-235(action)-234(of)-234(our)-234(wills.)-245(This)-234(gives)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us)-209(the)-209(conception)-209(of)-209(force.)-236(We)-209(apply)-209(it)-209(in)-209(a)-209(metaphorical)-209(sense)-209(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-229(things)-228(which)-229(we)-228(observe)-229(in)-228(the)-229(material)-228(universe)-229(and)-228(call)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-203(forces,)-212(having)-203(abstracted)-203(from)-202(our)-203(primary)-203(idea)-203(of)-203(force)-202(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conception)-313(of)-313(volition.)-439(But)-313(all)-313(that)-313(we)-313(really)-313(know)-313(about)-312(force)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tends)-250(to)-250(prove)-250(that)-250(its)-250(origin)-250(is)-250(mental)-250(and)-250(not)-250(material.)]TJ 11.956 -16.003 Td [(It)-330(is)-330(of)-330(the)-329(utmost)-330(importance)-330(to)-330(preserve)-330(a)-330(clear)-330(di)1(stinction)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(between)-459(the)-459(unconscious)-460(forces)-459(of)-459(matter)-459(and)-459(the)-459(intelligent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ones)-330(of)-330(mind;)-369(otherwise)-330(we)-330(shall)-329(inevitably)-330(be)-330(misled)-330(by)-329(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(expressions)-348(as)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 67.581 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(the)-348(forces)-348(of)-348(nature.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 90.445 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.639 0 Td [(It)-348(is)-348(impossible)-348(to)-348(argue)]TJ -171.509 -13.549 Td [(the)-231(question)-230(unless)-231(the)-231(distinction)-230(is)-231(admitted)-231(as)-230(a)-231(fact,)-234(whatever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(theory)-315(may)-314(be)-315(held)-314(about)-315(their)-314(origin.)-443(It)-315(is)-314(absurd)-315(to)-314(confound)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(principles)-319(so)-319(distinct)-319(as)-319(heat)1(,)-337(or)-318(gravitation,)-337(or)-318(electricity,)-336(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-355(which)-355(produce)-355(the)-355(most)-355(disinterested)-355(moral)-355(actions,)-381(and)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
197 0 obj <<
/Length 5379      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(38)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(designate)-315(them)-314(by)-315(the)-629(common)-315(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 169.467 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(natural)-315(forces.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 63.105 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.276 0 Td [(In)-315(com-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -318.447 0 Td [([039])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(mon)-353(language)-352(we)-353(are)-353(in)-353(no)-352(danger)-353(of)-353(error)-352(when)-353(we)-353(speak)-352(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-405(force)-406(of)-405(conscience,)-444(or)-406(t)1(he)-406(force)-405(of)-405(a)-406(motive;)-483(but)-405(in)-405(dis-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cussions)-281(like)-281(the)-281(present,)-289(where)-281(such)-281(expressions)-281(really)-281(involve)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-275(assumption)-275(of)-275(t)1(he)-275(whole)-275(controversy,)-281(it)-275(is)-275(absurd)-275(to)-274(classify)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-305(phenomena,)-318(and)-305(the)-305(unintelligent)-305(forces)-305(of)-305(matter)-305(under)-304(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(common)-238(designation,)-240(unless)-238(it)-238(can)-238(be)-238(demonstrated)-238(that)-238(they)-238(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-250(manifestations)-250(of)-250(the)-250(same)-250(power.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(We)-280(come)-279(now)-280(to)-280(the)-279(much)-280(vexed)-280(question)-279(as)-280(to)-280(the)-279(meaning)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-262(be)-262(attached)-262(to)-262(the)-262(words)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 120.76 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(miracle)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 32.716 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.701 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.61 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(miraculous;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 51.513 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.701 0 Td [(and)-262(the)]TJ -248.689 -13.549 Td [(terms)-301(closely)-301(allied)-300(to)-301(them,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 128.965 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(supernatural)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 53.923 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.126 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.034 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(superhuman.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 56.05 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.55 Td [(Is)-279(there)-278(any)-279(valid)-279(distinction)-278(between)-279(miracles)-279(and)-278(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrences?)-289(Are,)-266(in)-263(fact,)-266(all)-263(miracles)-263(supernatural)-263(occurrences,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-390(all)-390(supernatural)-390(occurrences)-390(miracles?)-670(The)-390(determination)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-426(this)-427(question)-426(is)-426(closely)-426(connected)-427(with)-426(an)-426(important)-426(point)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-225(will)-226(be)-225(considered)-225(hereafter,)-230(viz.,)-231(whether)-225(a)-225(miracle)-225(could)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-329(any)-329(evidential)-329(value)-329(if)-329(it)-329(were)-329(brought)-329(about)-329(by)-329(a)-328(special)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(adaptation)-250(of)-250(the)-250(known)-250(or)-250(unknown)-250(forces)-250(of)-250(material)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Let)-229(it)-228(be)-229(observed)-228(that)-229(we)-228(are)-229(not)-228(discussing)-229(this)-228(question)-229(as)-228(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(purely)-289(abstract)-288(one,)-298(but)-289(in)-289(reference)-288(to)-289(the)-288(truth)-289(of)-288(Christianity.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(What)-302(miracles)-303(may)-302(be)-303(in)-302(themselves,)-315(I)-303(shall)-302(not)-303(inquire;)-328(but)-302(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(relation)-320(to)-320(the)-319(question)-320(before)-320(us,)-337(what)-320(we)-320(mean)-320(when)-320(we)-319(call)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-284(occurrence)-285(a)-284(miracle)-284(ought)-285(to)-284(be)-284(made)-285(sufficiently)-284(clear)-284(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinct.)-355(In)-285(this)-285(controversy)-285(it)-285(would)-285(greatly)-285(tend)-285(to)-285(precision)-285(if)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(we)-260(used)-261(the)-260(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 77.401 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(miracle)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 32.716 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.683 0 Td [(as)-260(distinguished)-261(from)-260(an)-260(occurrence)]TJ -122.644 -13.549 Td [(which)-207(is)-206(supernatural)-207(or)-206(superhuman,)-215(to)-207(denote)-206(only)-207(those)-206(super-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural)-203(occurrences)-202(which)-203(have)-202(an)-203(evidential)-202(value)-203(in)-202(connection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-400(the)-400(evidences)-399(of)-400(a)-400(divine)-400(revelation,)-437(since)-400(there)-400(may)-399(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-205(occurrences)-204(which)-205(would)-205(not)-205(be)-204(in)-205(any)-205(proper)-204(sense)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(evidential.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([040])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -15.185 Td [(But)-247(the)-247(further)-247(question)-247(arises,)-247(Is)-247(it)-247(necessary)-247(in)-247(order)-247(to)-247(con-)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(stitute)-268(an)-268(event)-269(a)-268(miracle)-268(that)-268(it)-269(should)-268(be)-268(one)-268(which)-268(transcends)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-429(known)-428(or)-429(the)-428(unknown)-429(forces)-428(of)-429(material)-428(nature)-429(to)-428(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(produced?)-275(It)-259(is)-258(clear)-258(that)-259(to)-258(constitute)-259(an)-258(event)-258(a)-259(miracle)-258(it)-258(must)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
202 0 obj <<
/Length 4686      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(II.)-250(Definitions)-250(of)-250(Terms.)-11504(39)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(involve)-228(supernatural)-229(or)-228(superhuman)-228(agency)-228(of)-228(some)-229(kind;)-235(that)-228(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-196(say,)-207(it)-196(must)-197(be)-196(either)-196(supernatural)-196(in)-197(the)-196(mode)-196(of)-196(its)-196(production)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-199(an)-198(objective)-199(fact,)-209(or)-198(superhuman)-199(in)-198(its)-199(productive)-199(elements,)-208(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-246(I)-245(mean,)-246(that)-246(it)-245(must)-246(be)-245(preceded)-246(by)-245(an)-246(announcement)-245(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-275(is)-276(going)-275(to)-275(occur,)-282(which)-275(must)-276(be)-275(beyond)-275(the)-276(sphere)-275(of)-275(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowledge.)-249(In)-248(order)-248(to)-247(render)-248(a)-248(supernatural)-248(event)-247(evidential,)-248(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-266(other)-266(words)-266(to)-266(constitute)-266(it)-266(a)-266(miracle,)-270(it)-266(must)-266(not)-266(only)-266(consist)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-208(an)-209(external)-208(objective)-208(fact,)-217(but)-208(its)-209(occurrence)-208(must)-208(be)-208(unknown)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beforehand,)-432(and)-396(take)-396(place)-395(at)-396(the)-396(bidding)-396(of)-395(the)-396(agent.)-687(Such)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(previous)-440(announcement,)-487(or)-440(prediction,)-488(is)-440(necessary)-440(to)-439(render)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-268(a)-267(supernatural)-268(occurrence)-268(in)-267(the)-268(strictest)-268(sense)-267(of)-268(the)-267(word)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-271(miracle.)-313(The)-271(prediction)-271(of)-271(some)-271(occurrence)-271(in)-271(physical)-271(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(previously)-369(unknown)-369(may)-369(therefore)-369(convert)-369(such)-369(an)-369(event)-368(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-353(evidential)-353(miracle,)-379(although)-353(the)-353(occurrence)-353(itself)-353(as)-353(a)-353(mere)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(objective)-306(fact)-307(may)-306(have)-306(been)-306(brought)-306(about)-307(by)-306(some)-306(known)-306(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unknown)-240(forces)-240(of)-240(material)-240(nature.)-247(To)-240(render)-240(it)-240(such)-240(it)-239(would)-240(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary)-217(that)-217(the)-218(knowledge)-217(of)-217(the)-217(occurrence)-217(should)-217(be)-217(clearly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beyond)-300(the)-300(bounds)-299(of)-300(existing)-300(knowledge.)-400(Thus,)-312(if)-300(any)-299(person,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-383(the)-383(science)-383(of)-383(astronomy)-383(was)-383(utterly)-382(unknown,)-417(had)-382(an-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nounced)-198(beforehand)-198(the)-198(day)-198(and)-198(the)-198(hour)-198(of)-198(the)-198(occurrence)-198(of)-197(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(next)-279(two)-279(transits)-279(of)-279(Venus,)-286(and)-279(the)-279(various)-279(places)-279(on)-279(the)-279(earth's)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(surface)-384(in)-384(which)-384(they)-384(would)-384(be)-383(visible,)-418(and)-384(if)-384(the)-384(events)-383(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taken)-251(place)-251(accordingly,)-251(this)-251(would)-251(have)-251(unquestionably)-250(proved)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-179(presence)-179(of)-179(superhuman)-179(knowledge.)-226(The)-179(only)-179(question)-179(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-228(such)-227(a)-228(case)-227(would)-228(require)-227(to)-228(be)-227(determined)-228(would)-227(be)-455(whether)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([041])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(such)-264(a)-264(knowledge)-265(must)-264(have)-264(been)-264(communicated)-264(by)-265(God,)-267(or)-264(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(some)-350(being)-350(inferior)-350(to)-351(God.)-550(As)-350(however)-350(none)-350(of)-350(the)-350(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recorded)-273(in)-272(the)-273(New)-273(Testament)-273(have)-272(the)-273(smallest)-273(appearance)-272(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-400(of)-400(this)-399(character,)-438(I)-399(need)-400(not)-400(further)-400(discuss)-400(a)-399(supposed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(case.)-257(My)-252(only)-252(reason)-252(for)-252(referring)-253(to)-252(it)-252(is,)-253(that)-252(if)-252(it)-252(is)-252(supposable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-235(any)-236(of)-235(the)-235(miracles)-236(recorded)-235(in)-235(the)-236(New)-235(Testament)-235(could,)-238(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(some)-244(future)-243(day,)-245(be)-243(shown)-244(to)-243(have)-244(been)-243(due)-244(to)-243(a)-244(combination)-243(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical)-301(forces,)-315(their)-301(occurring)-301(instantly)-301(at)-302(the)-301(direct)-301(command)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(agent)-250(would)-250(still)-250(give)-250(them)-250(an)-250(evidential)-250(value.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
207 0 obj <<
/Length 4748      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(40)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(But)-191(it)-192(is)-191(clear)-192(that)-191(the)-191(miracles)-192(recorded)-191(in)-192(the)-191(New)-191(Testament,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(if)-181(caused)-181(by)-182(material)-181(forces)-181(at)-181(all,)-195(could)-181(not)-182(have)-181(been)-181(due)-181(to)-181(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ordinary)-267(action.)-300(They)-267(must)-267(have)-267(been)-266(due)-267(either)-267(to)-267(an)-266(unknown)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(combination)-191(of)-191(known)-192(forces,)-202(or)-192(to)-191(the)-191(calling)-191(of)-191(unknown)-191(forces)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(into)-311(activity,)-326(or)-312(to)-311(the)-311(immediate)-311(agency)-311(of)-311(the)-311(divine)-311(mind.)-433(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-304(clear)-303(therefore)-304(that)-304(their)-304(occurrence)-303(as)-304(objective)-304(facts)-303(proves)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-289(presence)-288(of)-289(mind)-288(acting)-289(in)-289(some)-288(way)-289(on)-288(the)-289(material)-288(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-245(nature.)-249(To)-245(determine)-245(the)-245(mode)-245(in)-246(which)-245(this)-245(action)-245(mast)-245(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taken)-325(place)-324(has)-325(nothing)-324(to)-325(do)-324(with)-325(the)-324(question)-325(of)-324(miracles,)-343(or)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(reality)-250(of)-250(their)-250(occurrence.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(A)-277(miracle)-277(therefore)-276(may,)-284(for)-277(all)-276(practical)-277(purposes)-277(of)-277(this)-276(ar-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(gument,)-216(be)-207(defined)-207(as)-207(an)-207(occurrence)-207(which)-207(cannot)-207(be)-207(effectuated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-299(the)-298(ordinary)-299(action)-299(of)-298(the)-299(known)-299(material)-298(forces)-299(of)-299(the)-298(Uni-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(verse,)-269(and)-266(could)-265(only)-266(have)-265(been)-266(brought)-265(about)-266(by)-265(the)-266(agency)-265(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intelligent)-290(volition;)-310(and)-289(which)-290(is)-290(preceded)-290(by)-290(an)-289(announcement)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-294(the)-294(part)-294(of)-294(the)-295(agent)-294(that)-294(it)-294(is)-294(about)-294(to)-294(happen)-294(or)-294(takes)-294(place)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(directly)-312(on)-312(his)-311(bidding.)-436(The)-311(latter)-312(element,)-327(as)-312(I)-312(have)-311(observed,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-400(essential)-400(to)-401(constitute)-400(the)-400(occurrence)-400(an)-400(evidential)-400(miracle.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Otherwise)-223(in)-223(our)-223(ignorance)-223(of)-223(what)-223(unknown)-223(forces)-223(may)-223(exist)-222(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-280(universe,)-288(we)-280(could)-280(have)-280(no)-280(certainty)-560(that)-280(the)-280(event)-280(was)-280(not)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([042])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(a)-230(mere)-229(unusual)-230(occurrence)-229(effected)-229(by)-230(some)-229(already)-230(existing)-229(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unknown)-255(forces.)-264(To)-255(the)-255(highest)-255(form)-254(of)-255(the)-255(miracles)-255(in)-255(the)-254(New)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Testament,)-250(however,)-250(such)-250(an)-250(idea)-250(would)-250(be)-250(inapplicable.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(It)-469(may)-468(perhaps)-469(here)-469(be)-469(objected)-468(that)-469(in)-469(laying)-469(down)-468(this)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(definition)-286(of)-286(a)-286(miracle,)-294(I)-286(have)-286(not)-286(sufficiently)-286(identified)-286(its)-285(per-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(formance)-216(with)-216(the)-216(governing)-216(power)-216(of)-216(the)-217(universe,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 226.455 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.935 0 Td [(God;)-227(but)]TJ -242.39 -13.549 Td [(that)-231(if)-232(supernatural)-231(agents)-231(exist,)-235(inferior)-232(to)-231(God,)-235(it)-231(may)-232(be)-231(due)-231(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-233(operation;)-239(and)-233(consequently)-234(that)-233(it)-233(may)-234(not)-233(be)-233(evidential)-233(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-291(divine)-290(commission.)-372(This)-291(objection)-291(will)-290(be)-291(fully)-291(considered)-290(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-250(subsequent)-250(portion)-250(of)-250(this)-250(work.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(A)-280(supernatural)-281(event)-280(is)-281(one)-280(which)-280(exceeds)-281(and)-280(which)-280(cannot)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(be)-346(effected)-345(by)-346(any)-346(force)-345(existing)-346(in)-345(material)-346(nature.)-537(But)-345(there)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(must)-396(always)-396(be)-396(a)-395(difficulty)-396(in)-396(determining)-396(whether)-396(an)-395(occur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rence,)-369(viewed)-345(as)-345(a)-345(bare)-345(objective)-345(fact,)-368(belongs)-345(to)-345(that)-345(class)-345(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
211 0 obj <<
/Length 4692      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(II.)-250(Definitions)-250(of)-250(Terms.)-11504(41)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(events)-348(which)-348(is)-348(supernatural,)-373(or)-348(only)-347(to)-348(that)-348(which)-348(is)-348(unusual.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-237(will)-236(always)-237(be)-237(the)-237(case)-236(until)-237(our)-237(knowledge)-236(of)-237(the)-237(forces)-236(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-223(universe)-223(is)-223(so)-223(complete)-223(that)-223(we)-223(can)-223(ascertain)-223(for)-223(certain)-223(what)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-290(the)-290(limits)-290(of)-289(their)-290(possible)-290(action,)-300(and)-290(whether)-290(it)-290(is)-289(possible)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-305(bring)-305(into)-304(action)-305(any)-305(forces)-305(that)-305(may)-304(exist,)-319(but)-305(are)-304(unknown)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-307(us.)-421(In)-307(strict)-307(language)-307(therefore,)-321(it)-307(is)-307(impossible)-307(to)-307(be)-307(certain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whether)-292(an)-292(occurrence,)-303(as)-292(a)-292(bare)-292(objective)-293(fact,)-302(is)-292(supernatural,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(until)-334(we)-334(are)-334(acquainted)-335(with)-334(the)-334(possible)-334(action)-334(of)-334(every)-334(force)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-234(exists)-233(in)-234(the)-234(universe.)-244(This)-234(difficulty,)-237(however,)-237(is)-233(one)-234(that)-233(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(entirely)-212(theoretical,)-219(and)-212(has)-212(not)-211(the)-212(smallest)-212(practical)-211(importance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-197(respect)-197(to)-197(the)-197(miracles)-197(of)-197(the)-197(New)-197(Testament.)-232(Men)-197(have)-197(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(several)-211(thousand)-211(years')-211(experience)-211(of)-211(what)-211(can)-211(be)-211(effected)-211(by)-210(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ordinary)-202(forces)-202(of)-203(material)-202(nature.)-234(Occurrences)-202(which)-202(lie)-202(beyond)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-304(power)-303(to)-304(effectuate)-303(prove)-304(the)-304(presence)-303(of)-304(intelligence)-303(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(volition.)-689(The)-396(introduction)-396(of)-397(an)-396(unknown)-793(force)-396(can)-396(only)-396(be)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([043])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(accomplished)-383(by)-382(a)-383(being)-383(who,)-416(although)-382(he)-383(may)-383(be)-382(immanent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-341(nature,)-364(is)-342(yet)-341(capable)-341(of)-342(controlling)-341(its)-341(material)-342(forces.)-523(Oc-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(currences)-439(therefore)-439(which)-438(transcend)-439(the)-439(power)-439(of)-439(the)-438(known)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-329(existing)-329(in)-329(the)-328(universe)-329(to)-329(accomplish,)-349(whether)-329(they)-328(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(material)-308(or)-307(human,)-323(may)-307(for)-308(all)-308(practical)-307(purposes)-308(be)-308(viewed)-307(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural;)-263(that)-258(is)-259(to)-258(say,)-261(they)-258(denote)-259(the)-258(presence)-259(and)-258(agency)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-258(a)-259(being)-258(who)-259(is)-258(possessed)-259(of)-258(power,)-261(intelligence,)-260(and)-258(volition.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Whether)-330(that)-331(being)-330(be)-330(human,)-351(superhuman,)-350(or)-331(divine,)-350(must)-330(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(determined)-250(by)-250(an)-250(intelligent)-250(exercise)-250(of)-250(our)-250(reason.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-333(is)-332(useless)-333(to)-333(discuss)-333(this)-332(question)-333(further.)-498(We)-333(are)-332(dealing)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(with)-281(a)-281(very)-280(definite)-281(question,)-288(the)-281(miraculous)-281(events)-281(recorded)-280(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-350(Gospels.)-551(With)-350(respect)-351(to)-350(the)-350(great)-351(majority)-350(of)-350(them,)-375(there)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(can)-384(be)-383(no)-384(doubt)-383(as)-384(to)-384(their)-383(being)-384(supernatural)-383(occurrences,)-417(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-242(took)-242(place)-242(precisely)-243(as)-242(they)-242(are)-242(recorded.)-247(We)-242(know)-242(enough)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-370(the)-369(ordinary)-370(forces)-369(of)-370(material)-369(nature)-369(to)-370(be)-369(certain)-370(that)-369(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instantaneous)-400(cure)-399(of)-400(a)-399(blind)-400(or)-400(leprous)-399(man)-400(by)-399(a)-400(word)-399(does)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-293(lie)-293(within)-293(the)-293(sphere)-294(of)-293(their)-293(operation.)-379(Such)-293(an)-293(event)-293(must)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(denote)-328(the)-328(special)-328(interposition)-328(of)-328(an)-328(extremely)-328(high)-328(degree)-327(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intelligence)-286(and)-286(power.)-357(Common)-286(sense)-285(will)-286(affirm)-286(that)-286(it)-285(could)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
215 0 obj <<
/Length 4516      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(42)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(only)-267(be)-268(brought)-267(about)-267(by)-267(the)-267(intervention)-268(of)-267(the)-267(supreme)-267(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(universe,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 70.288 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 16.058 0 Td [(God.)]TJ -74.39 -16.004 Td [(In)-264(this)-263(sense)-264(every)-263(supernatural)-264(occurrence)-263(may)-264(be)-263(said)-264(to)-263(be)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(likewise)-382(evidential,)-416(when)-382(we)-383(have)-382(ascertained)-383(for)-382(certain)-382(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-409(is)-408(due)-409(to)-408(supernatural)-409(causes,)-448(and)-409(that)-409(it)-408(cannot)-409(have)-408(been)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(brought)-318(about)-319(by)-318(the)-318(action)-318(of)-318(unintelligent)-319(forces,)-335(or)-318(by)-318(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-272(are)-272(capable)-272(of)-272(being)-272(modified)-272(by)-272(the)-272(agency)-272(of)-272(man.)-315(But)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-362(that)-362(case)-361(it)-362(would)-362(only)-361(prove)-362(the)-362(presence)-362(and)-361(intervention)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-284(a)-284(being)-284(who)-284(is)-284(capable)-284(of)-284(controlling)-284(the)-284(unintelligent)-283(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-378(nature.)-635(The)-378(real)-378(difficulty,)-410(as)-379(I)-378(have)-378(observed,)-410(is)-378(to)-378(prove)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-373(supernatural)-373(nature)-373(of)-746(the)-373(occurrence.)-620(But)-373(although,)-403(if)-373(it)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([044])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(was)-311(certainly)-311(supernatural,)-326(it)-310(would)-311(prove)-311(the)-311(intervention)-311(of)-310(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-373(agent,)-403(it)-372(would)-373(say)-372(nothing)-373(as)-372(to)-372(the)-373(purpose)-372(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-278(such)-278(an)-277(intervention)-278(took)-278(place.)-333(It)-278(follows)-278(therefore,)-284(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-306(constitute)-307(a)-306(supernatural)-306(occurrence)-307(in)-306(the)-306(strict)-307(sense)-306(of)-306(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(term)-215(a)-216(miracle,)-222(it)-215(must)-215(take)-216(place)-215(after)-215(an)-216(announcement)-215(that)-215(it)-215(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(going)-280(to)-280(happen,)-288(and)-280(take)-280(pl)1(ace)-280(at)-280(the)-280(bidding)-280(of)-280(the)-280(agent)-280(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performs)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-498(is)-499(highly)-498(important,)-560(in)-498(considering)-499(the)-498(miracles)-498(of)-498(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Gospels,)-214(that)-204(the)-205(distinction)-204(between)-205(a)-204(merely)-205(supernatural)-204(event)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-350(an)-350(evidential)-350(miracle)-350(should)-350(be)-350(kept)-350(steadily)-350(in)-350(view.)-549(All)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(creative)-335(acts)-335(would)-334(be)-335(supernatural)-335(events,)-356(but)-335(they)-335(would)-334(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessarily)-380(be)-380(evidential)-380(miracles.)-640(The)-380(incarnation,)-412(and)-380(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrences)-320(mentioned)-321(in)-320(the)-320(New)-320(Testament,)-338(are)-320(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ones;)-536(but)-441(to)-440(mix)-441(them)-440(up)-441(with)-441(evidential)-440(miracles)-441(is)-440(simply)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-409(invite)-409(confusion)-409(of)-408(thought.)-727(Another)-409(class)-409(of)-408(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrences)-229(mentioned)-230(in)-229(the)-230(New)-229(Testament)-229(seem)-230(to)-229(have)-229(been)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(wrought,)-512(not)-460(for)-460(purposes)-460(directly)-460(evidential,)-512(but)-460(to)-459(awaken)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attention;)-457(and)-388(another)-388(class)-388(of)-388(supernatural)-388(endowments)-388(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(vouchsafed,)-376(to)-351(render)-351(it)-351(possible)-350(to)-351(lay)-351(deep)-351(in)-351(human)-350(society)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-234(foundations)-234(of)-234(the)-233(Church)-234(as)-234(a)-234(visible)-234(and)-234(permanent)-233(institu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion.)-335(Such)-279(occurrences)-278(are)-279(not)-278(directly)-279(but)-278(indirectly)-278(evidential,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-365(it)-365(will)-365(be)-364(necessary)-365(carefully)-365(to)-365(distinguish)-365(between)-364(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-315(occurrences)-314(brought)-315(about)-315(for)-314(directly)-315(evidential)-314(purposes.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
219 0 obj <<
/Length 4878      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(II.)-250(Definitions)-250(of)-250(Terms.)-11504(43)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(To)-364(keep)-364(this)-364(distinction)-364(clear,)-393(I)-363(shall)-364(designate)-364(the)-364(last)-364(by)-364(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 23.126 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(miracle.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 35.443 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.973 0 Td [(A)-287(miracle)-287(is)-287(supernatural)-286(in)-287(two)-287(ways:)-324(namely,)]TJ -71.386 -13.549 Td [(in)-459(the)-460(agency)-459(which)-460(produced)-459(the)-459(objective)-460(fact,)-512(and)-459(in)-459(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(announcement)-250(of)-250(its)-250(occurrence.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-311(common)-311(definition)-311(of)-311(a)-312(miracle,)-326(as)-311(a)-311(violation)-311(or)-311(a)-311(sus-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(pension)-307(of)-308(the)-307(laws)-308(of)-307(nature,)-322(is)-307(open)-307(to)-308(very)-307(grave)-307(objections.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-200(question,)-209(as)-200(I)-199(have)-200(observed,)-209(at)-399(once)-200(arises,)-209(what)-200(is)-199(included)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([045])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(under)-353(nature?)-557(It)-353(also)-352(assumes)-353(that)-352(we)-353(are)-352(acquainted)-353(with)-352(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mode)-205(in)-205(which)-205(miraculous)-204(agency)-205(must)-205(be)-205(exerted;)-220(which)-205(we)-204(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not.)-237(Other)-211(definitions)-211(which)-211(have)-211(been)-211(proposed)-211(take)-211(for)-210(granted)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(positions)-438(which)-438(those)-438(who)-438(undertake)-438(to)-438(prove)-438(the)-438(credibility)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-349(miracles)-349(ought)-349(never)-350(to)-349(concede.)-547(The)-349(plain)-349(fact)-349(is,)-374(that)-349(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-309(simply)-308(ignorant)-309(of)-308(the)-309(mode)-309(in)-308(which)-309(God)-308(acts)-309(on)-308(material)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature;)-352(and)-318(every)-317(definition)-318(must)-318(be)-318(faulty)-318(which)-318(assumes)-317(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-432(have)-433(that)-432(knowledge.)-797(To)-432(say)-433(that)-432(miracles)-432(must)-432(involve)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(even)-379(a)-378(suspension)-379(of)-378(the)-379(laws)-378(of)-379(nature)-378(introduces)-379(a)-378(needless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difficulty.)-572(No)-358(law)-357(or)-358(force)-357(of)-357(nature)-358(need)-357(be)-358(suspended)-357(in)-357(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-270(to)-269(render)-270(the)-269(occurrence)-270(of)-270(a)-269(supernatural)-270(event)-269(possible.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(All)-345(that)-345(is)-345(necessary)-345(is)-345(that)-345(forces)-345(should)-345(be)-345(introduced)-345(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-276(capable)-276(of)-277(overbalancing)-276(the)-276(action)-276(of)-276(opposing)-277(forces.)-328(It)-276(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(extremely)-273(inaccurate)-272(to)-273(affirm)-272(that)-272(the)-273(force)-272(of)-273(gravitation)-272(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-340(suspended)-339(in)-340(order)-339(to)-340(render)-339(possible)-340(either)-339(walking)-340(on)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(water,)-250(or)-250(an)-250(ascent)-250(into)-250(the)-250(sky.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-360(is)-360(equally)-360(unwise)-361(and)-360(unphilosophical)-360(to)-360(affirm)-360(that)-360(God)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-202(work)-201(a)-202(miracle)-201(by)-201(the)-202(use)-201(of)-202(intermediate)-201(agencies,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 253.839 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.882 0 Td [(by)]TJ -269.721 -13.549 Td [(the)-197(partial)-197(employment)-197(of)-197(the)-197(forces)-197(of)-196(the)-197(material)-197(universe.)-233(It)-196(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(true)-268(that)-269(in)-268(most)-268(of)-269(the)-268(miracles)-268(recorded)-269(in)-268(the)-268(New)-268(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(we)-251(cannot)-251(affirm)-250(the)-251(use)-251(of)-251(such)-250(media,)-251(although)-251(we)-251(observe)-250(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(economy)-360(in)-359(the)-360(use)-359(of)-360(divine)-360(power:)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 171.664 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 19.645 0 Td [(no)-360(power)-359(is)-360(exerted)]TJ -191.309 -13.549 Td [(beyond)-334(that)-334(which)-335(is)-334(necessary)-334(to)-334(produce)-334(the)-334(particular)-334(result)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-387(question.)-661(But)-387(in)-387(the)-387(Old)-387(Testament)-387(the)-387(use)-387(of)-387(such)-387(media)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-327(unquestionably)-327(affirmed.)-480(To)-327(lay)-327(down)-326(in)-327(our)-327(definition)-327(of)-326(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miracle)-348(a)-347(particular)-348(theory)-348(as)-348(to)-347(the)-348(mode)-348(in)-347(which)-348(it)-348(must)-347(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accomplished,)-202(involves)-189(the)-190(whole)-189(subject)-190(in)-189(needless)-189(difficulties.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
223 0 obj <<
/Length 4727      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(44)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(This)-268(question)-268(has)-268(been)-268(obscured)-268(by)-268(representing)-268(a)-268(miracle)-267(as)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(performed)-297(by)-297(the)-296(intervention)-297(of)-297(a)-297(higher)-593(law,)-309(superseding)-296(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([046])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(action)-341(of)-341(a)-341(lower)-341(one.)-523(This)-341(introduces)-341(the)-341(conception)-340(of)-341(force)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-260(the)-260(idea)-260(of)-260(law,)-262(and)-260(leads)-260(to)-260(confusion)-260(of)-260(thought.)-280(Laws,)-262(or)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-259(invariable)-259(sequences)-260(between)-259(phenomena,)-261(are)-259(neither)-259(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nor)-401(powers.)-704(The)-401(counteraction)-401(of)-401(one)-402(force)-401(by)-401(another)-401(is)-401(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(event)-276(of)-277(daily)-276(occurrence.)-329(All)-276(that)-276(is)-276(needful)-277(for)-276(the)-276(working)-276(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-237(miracle)-237(is)-236(the)-237(intervention)-237(of)-237(a)-237(force)-236(or)-237(mental)-237(energy)-237(which)-236(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(capable)-238(of)-239(acting)-238(on)-238(matter,)-241(and)-238(of)-239(overbalancing)-238(those)-238(ordinary)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(forces)-250(which)-250(would)-250(produce)-250(a)-250(contrary)-250(result.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-326(has)-326(also)-326(been)-326(urged)-326(that)-326(miracles)-326(may)-326(obey)-326(a)-326(law)-326(of)-325(mir-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(acles.)-585(The)-361(best)-362(illustrati)1(on)-362(of)-361(this)-362(idea)-361(is)-362(that)-361(which)-362(has)-361(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supplied)-297(from)-296(the)-297(supposed)-296(operations)-297(of)-296(Mr.)-390(Babbage's)-296(calcu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lating)-197(machine.)-233(He)-197(supposes)-198(that)-197(a)-197(machine)-198(might)-197(be)-197(constructed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-400(could)-399(go)-400(on)-399(grinding)-400(out)-399(a)-399(particular)-400(set)-399(of)-400(results)-399(for)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-440(long,)-487(yet)-439(definite)-440(period)-439(of)-440(time;)-534(then)-440(by)-439(the)-440(operation)-439(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-341(same)-341(machine,)-364(that)-341(a)-341(fresh)-341(order)-342(might)-341(be)-341(introduced;)-386(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(afterwards)-321(that)-320(it)-320(might)-321(revert)-320(to)-321(the)-320(original)-321(one;)-356(and)-320(that)-320(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(operation)-418(might)-417(be)-418(continued)-417(for)-417(ever.)-753(If)-417(therefore)-418(the)-417(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Author)-228(of)-228(nature)-228(had)-228(so)-228(planned)-228(the)-228(machine)-228(of)-228(the)-228(universe)-227(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(whenever)-322(a)-322(miracle)-322(was)-322(requisite)-322(in)-322(His)-322(scheme)-322(of)-321(Providence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-232(abnormal)-232(event)-232(occurred,)-235(like)-232(the)-232(new)-232(series)-232(introduced)-231(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-235(calculating)-235(mill,)-238(in)-235(that)-235(case)-235(miracles)-235(might)-235(be)-235(said)-235(to)-234(follow)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-315(definite)-315(law,)-331(which)-315(might)-314(be)-315(designated)-315(the)-315(law)-315(and)-315(order)-314(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miraculous)-250(intervention.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-326(is)-325(impossible)-326(to)-325(deny)-326(the)-326(ingenuity)-325(of)-326(this)-325(theory,)-345(but)-325(un-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(fortunately)-384(it)-385(is)-384(not)-384(only)-385(one)-384(which)-384(takes)-385(for)-384(granted)-384(that)-384(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(perfection)-353(of)-352(mechanical)-353(contrivance)-352(is)-353(the)-353(only)-352(thing)-353(that)-352(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Creator)-229(had)-230(in)-229(view)-229(in)-230(the)-229(production)-230(of)-229(the)-229(universe,)-234(but)-229(even)-229(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-270(were)-271(an)-270(unquestionable)-270(fact,)-276(it)-270(could)-270(afford)-271(us)-270(no)-270(help)-270(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(respect)-299(to)-298(all)-299(the)-298(most)-299(important)-299(miracles)-298(recorded)-299(in)-298(the)-597(New)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([047])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(Testament.)-303(How)-268(is)-267(it)-268(possible,)-272(I)-267(ask,)-272(to)-268(account)-268(for)-267(many)-268(of)-267(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Lord's)-318(miracles)-317(on)-318(such)-317(a)-318(supposit)1(ion?)-453(It)-317(is)-318(expressly)-317(affirmed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-291(this)-291(supernatural)-291(energy)-291(was)-291(frequently)-291(made)-291(to)-291(depend)-290(on)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
228 0 obj <<
/Length 4800      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(II.)-250(Definitions)-250(of)-250(Terms.)-11504(45)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(the)-218(faith)-219(of)-218(the)-218(person)-219(who)-218(invoked)-218(His)-218(help.)-240(Could)-218(any)-218(miracle-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(working)-190(mill)-191(be)-190(even)-190(conceived)-191(of,)-202(which)-190(could)-191(bring)-190(out,)-202(as)-190(part)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-305(the)-305(normal)-305(law)-305(of)-305(its)-305(operations,)-319(the)-305(cure)-305(of)-305(blind,)-319(deaf,)-318(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(leprous)-270(men)-270(by)-270(a)-269(word,)-275(or)-270(effectuate)-270(His)-270(own)-270(resurrection)-269(from)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-256(dead,)-257(or)-256(ascension)-255(into)-256(Heaven?)-267(Such)-256(occurrences)-256(could)-255(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-223(produced)-223(by)-223(the)-222(action)-223(of)-223(any)-223(machine)-223(which)-223(has)-223(the)-222(smallest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(analogy)-403(to)-403(a)-404(calculating)-403(mill.)-709(But)-404(further:)-556(such)-403(an)-403(operation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-329(be)-329(impotent)-330(to)-329(answer)-329(the)-329(purposes)-329(of)-329(a)-330(miracle,)-348(unless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-260(particular)-261(result)-260(was)-260(announced)-260(beforehand)-261(by)-260(one)-260(who)-260(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(completely)-293(ignorant)-292(that)-293(the)-292(machine)-293(was)-292(capable)-293(of)-292(producing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-300(extraordinary)-300(results.)-401(This)-300(ignorance)-300(would)-300(likewise)-300(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-320(be)-320(extended)-320(to)-320(those)-320(to)-320(whom)-320(the)-320(announcement)-320(was)-320(made.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-340(would)-341(also)-340(be)-340(necessary)-340(that)-341(the)-340(announcer)-340(should)-340(proclaim)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-339(on)-339(a)-339(particular)-339(day)-339(and)-339(hour)-339(the)-339(machine)-339(would)-339(grind)-338(out)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-276(particular)-275(result)-276(of)-276(the)-275(cure)-276(of)-276(a)-275(blind)-276(man,)-282(or)-276(a)-275(resurrection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-270(the)-269(dead.)-309(The)-269(ability)-270(to)-270(do)-269(this)-270(would)-269(be)-270(utterly)-269(abnormal,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-312(impossible)-312(ever)-311(to)-312(be)-312(ground)-311(out)-312(by)-312(the)-312(self-acting)-311(agency)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-281(any)-281(conceivable)-281(machine,)-289(however)-281(cleverly)-281(constructed.)-343(Mr.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Babbage's)-360(miracle-working)-360(mill,)-388(however)-360(ingenious)-360(a)-360(concep-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tion,)-221(must)-214(therefore)-214(be)-214(dismissed)-213(as)-214(incapable)-214(of)-214(affording)-214(us)-213(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(smallest)-250(help)-250(in)-250(the)-250(present)-250(argument.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-400(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 45.677 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(superhuman)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 53.323 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.203 0 Td [(remains)-400(to)-399(be)-400(considered.)-698(It)-400(need)]TJ -125.003 -13.549 Td [(not)-326(detain)-326(us)-326(long.)-478(Superhuman)-326(implies)-326(a)-326(result)-326(brought)-326(about)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-364(the)-364(intervention)-364(of)-364(a)-364(being)-364(superior)-364(to)-364(man.)-592(Whether)-363(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-329(agent)-329(be)-329(divine)-329(or)-329(otherwise)-329(can)-329(only)-329(be)-329(determined)-329(by)-328(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(exercise)-429(of)-429(our)-429(reason.)-787(It)-429(has)-429(been)-429(objected)-429(that)-429(the)-429(agency)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-567(produces)-283(an)-283(earthquake)-284(is)-283(a)-283(superhuman)-284(agency,)-291(that)-283(is,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([048])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(it)-248(exceeds)-248(the)-248(powers)-248(of)-248(man)-248(to)-248(produce)-248(it.)-249(Granted:)-249(but)-248(this)-248(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-364(bearing)-364(on)-364(the)-364(subject)-364(under)-364(discussion.)-592(When)-363(we)-364(use)-364(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 25.367 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(superhuman)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 53.324 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.793 0 Td [(we)-270(always)-271(mean)-270(by)-271(it,)-275(not)-270(the)-271(action)-270(of)-271(the)]TJ -91.328 -13.549 Td [(unintelligent)-293(forces)-292(of)-293(material)-293(nature,)-303(but)-293(of)-293(a)-293(being)-292(possessed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-250(intelligence)-250(and)-250(will.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(There)-308(is)-307(a)-308(large)-308(number)-308(of)-307(other)-308(subjects)-308(having)-308(an)-308(inti)1(mate)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(bearing)-414(on)-414(the)-415(correct)-414(definition)-414(of)-415(the)-414(terms)-414(habitually)-414(used)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
233 0 obj <<
/Length 577       
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(46)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(in)-426(this)-425(controversy,)-470(and)-426(which)-425(greatly)-426(modify)-426(their)-425(meaning.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(These)-223(however)-223(will)-223(best)-223(be)-223(considered)-223(when)-223(I)-223(enter)-223(on)-223(the)-223(direct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discussion)-250(of)-250(the)-250(possibility)-250(and)-250(the)-250(credibility)-250(of)-250(miracles.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -29.651 Td [([049])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
241 0 obj <<
/Length 3120      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-267(III.)-266(The)-267(Supernatural)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Elements)-262(Contained)-261(in)-262(the)-261(New)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Testament:)-284(In)-267(What)-267(Do)-268(They)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Consist?)-280(And)-260(What)-260(View)-260(Do)-260(Its)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Writers)-250(Take)-250(Respecting)-250(Them?)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -41.745 Td [(Before)-367(entering)-367(on)-367(the)-367(general)-368(question)-367(of)-367(miracles,)-396(it)-367(is)-367(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reasonable)-295(to)-296(inquire)-295(of)-295(the)-295(writers)-295(of)-296(the)-295(New)-295(Testament)-295(what)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-417(have)-417(to)-417(say)-417(on)-418(the)-417(subject.)-751(Their)-417(opinion)-417(of)-417(the)-417(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-349(character)-348(of)-349(the)-349(supernatural)-348(occurrences)-349(which)-349(they)-348(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reported)-299(is)-298(certainly)-299(of)-299(more)-298(value)-299(than)-299(that)-298(of)-299(all)-299(other)-298(writers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(put)-235(together.)-245(St.)-245(John)-235(and)-236(St.)-245(Paul)-235(must)-235(have)-235(been)-235(in)-235(the)-235(habit)-235(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(coming)-276(in)-275(contact)-276(with)-275(unbelievers.)-327(It)-276(would)-275(be)-276(most)-275(important)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-251(we)-250(could)-251(ascertain)-251(the)-250(mode)-251(adopted)-251(by)-250(them)-251(of)-250(commending)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity)-473(to)-473(their)-473(acceptance,)-529(and)-473(what)-473(use)-473(was)-472(made)-473(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-273(of)-273(the)-273(supernatural)-273(power)-273(with)-273(which)-273(they)-273(professed)-273(to)-272(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(endowed.)]TJ 11.956 -15.414 Td [(First:)-615(It)-432(is)-432(impossible)-433(to)-432(read)-432(the)-433(New)-432(Testament)-432(without)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(arriving)-211(at)-210(the)-211(conclusion)-211(that)-211(the)-210(superhuman)-211(character)-211(which)-210(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ascribed)-305(to)-305(Jesus)-304(Christ)-305(is)-305(perfectly)-305(unique,)-318(and)-305(differs)-304(entirely)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(from)-262(that)-262(which)-262(is)-263(ascribed)-262(to)-262(any)-262(other)-262(person.)-286(Others)-262(wrought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles;)-269(but)-263(they)-263(were)-263(men)-262(like)-263(ourselves.)-288(But)-263(in)-263(the)-263(person)-262(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-311(Christ)-311(the)-312(supernatural)-311(is)-311(represented)-311(as)-312(inherent.)-433(To)-311(say)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-186(he)-185(possessed)-186(the)-185(power)-186(of)-185(working)-186(miracles,)-198(is)-186(an)-185(inadequate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(statement)-357(of)-356(the)-357(fact.)-570(Although)-357(he)-356(embodies)-357(the)-357(perfection)-356(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(human)-280(nature)-281(with)-280(all)-281(its)-280(finite)-281(limitations,)-288(the)-280(supernatural)-280(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-272(divine)-272(take)-272(up)-272(their)-543(abode)-272(in)-272(his)-272(personality.)-316(Whenever)-271(our)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([050])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
245 0 obj <<
/Length 5819      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(48)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Lord)-188(is)-188(represented)-188(as)-188(working)-187(miracles,)-201(he)-188(is)-188(always)-187(represented)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-315(performing)-314(them)-315(by)-314(a)-315(power)-314(which)-315(was)-314(inherent)-315(in)-314(himself.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-306(is)-306(never)-306(once)-307(attributed)-306(to)-306(his)-306(followers.)-418(The)-306(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-379(which)-379(is)-379(ascribed)-378(to)-379(Jesus)-379(Christ)-379(must)-379(be)-379(viewed,)-411(as)-378(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(case)-293(distinct)-292(and)-293(separate,)-304(by)-292(itself.)-378(The)-293(miracles)-293(performed)-292(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(him)-259(are)-258(not)-259(only)-258(evidential,)-261(but)-258(also)-259(portions)-258(of)-259(his)-258(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manifestation.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(According)-309(to)-309(the)-309(author)-309(of)-309(the)-309(fourth)-309(Gospel,)-324(our)-309(Lord)-308(him-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(self)-243(rarely)-243(designated)-243(them)-244(by)-243(either)-243(of)-243(the)-243(three)-243(terms)-243(by)-243(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-483(are)-483(usually)-483(designated)-484(in)-483(the)-483(New)-483(Testament,)-541(viz.,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(signs,)-346(wonders,)-346(and)-327(mighty)-327(works)-327(\050)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 160.06 0 Td [(\303\267\274\265)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 21.501 0 Td [(\326)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.208 0 Td [(\261)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.727 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 6.503 0 Td [(\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 4.691 0 Td [(s)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\301\261\304\261)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 21.36 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 6.504 0 Td [(\264\305\275)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 16.287 0 Td [(q)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.727 0 Td [(\274\265\271\302)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 18.12 0 Td [(\051.)]TJ -274.27 -13.55 Td [(He)-252(almost)-253(uniformly)-252(called)-253(them)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 147.09 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Works)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 29.084 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.598 0 Td [(\050)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 3.632 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\301\263\261)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 16.124 0 Td [(\051.)-257(An)-253(important)]TJ -212.953 -13.549 Td [(distinction)-280(is)-281(here)-280(intended.)-342(Our)-280(Lord)-281(did)-280(not)-281(view)-280(his)-280(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-206(a)-206(separate)-205(class)-206(of)-206(actions)-206(by)-206(themselves,)-214(but)-206(as)-206(portions)-206(of)-205(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ordinary)-301(superhuman)-301(working,)-314(and)-302(as)-301(having)-301(a)-301(distinct)-301(relation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-295(his)-294(entire)-295(character.)-383(Four)-295(passages)-294(will)-295(be)-294(sufficient)-295(to)-294(show)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-249(clearly.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 53.621 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(The)-249(works)-250(that)-249(I)-250(do)-249(in)-249(my)-250(Father's)-249(name,)-250(they)-249(bear)]TJ -58.464 -13.549 Td [(witness)-329(of)-330(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 65.059 0 Td [(\035)-329(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.28 0 Td [(My)-329(Father)-330(worketh)-329(hitherto,)-349(and)-330(I)-329(work.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 181.745 0 Td [(\035)-329(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.281 0 Td [(If)]TJ -273.365 -13.549 Td [(ye)-278(believe)-278(not)-278(me,)-284(believe)-278(the)-278(works.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 164.291 0 Td [(\035)-278(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.719 0 Td [(Many)-278(good)-278(works)-278(have)]TJ -177.01 -13.549 Td [(I)-317(showed)-317(you)-317(from)-318(my)-317(Father;)-350(for)-318(which)-317(of)-317(those)-317(works)-317(do)-317(ye)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stone)-263(me?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 44.07 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.709 0 Td [(When)-263(contemplated)-262(by)-263(others)-263(only,)-266(they)-262(assume)-263(the)]TJ -51.779 -13.55 Td [(form)-314(of)-314(signs)-313(and)-314(wonders:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 126.279 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Except)-314(ye)-314(see)-313(signs)-314(and)-314(wonders,)]TJ -131.123 -13.549 Td [(ye)-311(will)-311(not)-311(believe.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 85.624 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.236 0 Td [(It)-311(is)-311(highly)-311(important)-311(that)-311(we)-311(should)-311(keep)]TJ -93.86 -13.549 Td [(steadily)-238(in)-238(view)-238(that)-237(the)-238(divine)-238(character)-238(attributed)-238(to)-238(Jesus)-238(is)-237(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-351(means)-351(restricted)-352(to)-351(the)-351(performance)-351(of)-351(miracles;)-402(but)-351(that)-351(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(extends)-257(throughout)-256(his)-257(entire)-256(working,)-258(and)-257(that)-256(the)-257(two)-256(together)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(constitute)-304(an)-303(harmonious)-304(whole.)-410(It)-304(pertains)-303(no)-304(less)-303(to)-304(its)-303(moral)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-364(spiritual)-364(aspects,)-393(than)-364(to)-364(the)-364(displays)-364(which)-364(he)-364(made)-364(of)-364(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-392(capable)-391(of)-392(controlling)-784(nature.)-675(Even)-391(in)-392(this)-392(portion)-391(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([051])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(his)-259(working,)-260(he)-259(draws)-258(special)-259(attention)-258(to)-259(its)-258(moral)-259(and)-258(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aspects.)-233(According)-198(to)-198(his)-199(view)-198(of)-198(his)-199(own)-198(mighty)-198(works,)-209(they)-198(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-232(exhibited)-232(a)-231(power)-232(of)-232(controlling)-232(nature,)-235(but)-232(were)-231(uniformly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(invested)-232(with)-231(a)-232(moral)-232(and)-231(spiritual)-232(environment.)-244(Throughout)-231(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-300(he)-300(is)-300(represented)-300(as)-300(exhibiting)-300(a)-300(greatness)-300(and)-300(dignity,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
251 0 obj <<
/Length 5669      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(49)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(a)-240(purity,)-241(holiness,)-242(humility)-239(and)-240(benevolence,)-241(so)-240(far)-239(transcending)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-453(of)-453(other)-452(men,)-504(as)-453(to)-453(constit)1(ute)-453(him)-453(what)-453(may)-453(be)-452(almost)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(designated)-251(a)-250(moral)-251(and)-250(spiritual)-251(miracle.)-252(Perfection)-250(in)-251(the)-250(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-299(spiritual)-298(world)-299(is)-299(as)-299(essentially)-298(superhuman,)-311(as)-299(power)-298(over)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nature)-342(is)-343(supernatural.)-527(In)-343(considering)-342(the)-343(miracles)-342(which)-342(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-359(attributed)-359(to)-359(Jesus)-358(Christ,)-386(it)-359(is)-359(important)-359(to)-359(bear)-359(in)-358(mind)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-262(manner)-262(in)-261(which)-262(they)-262(stand)-261(related)-262(to)-262(his)-262(entire)-261(superhuman)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character.)-450(Otherwise)-316(we)-317(shall)-316(fail)-316(to)-317(observe)-316(the)-317(double)-316(aspect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-273(they)-273(bear.)-318(They)-273(were)-273(manifestations)-273(of)-273(the)-273(divine,)-278(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(dwelt)-250(within)-250(him,)-250(and)-250(also)-250(they)-250(possessed)-250(an)-250(evidential)-250(value.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-447(shall)-447(occasionally)-447(use)-448(the)-447(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 155.913 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(superhuman)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 53.323 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.723 0 Td [(instead)-447(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf -235.759 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(divine,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.184 0 Td [(as)-398(applied)-398(to)-397(Jesus)-398(Christ,)-435(because)-398(for)-398(the)-398(purposes)]TJ -44.028 -13.549 Td [(of)-440(this)-440(argument)-440(it)-440(will)-440(be)-440(unnecessary)-440(for)-440(me)-440(to)-440(define)-439(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(precise)-210(degree)-209(of)-210(divine)-209(character)-210(which)-209(the)-210(evangelists)-209(intended)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-252(attribute)-253(to)-252(him.)-257(To)-252(ascertain)-253(this)-252(is)-252(the)-253(proper)-252(function)-252(of)-252(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(theologian,)-215(by)-207(comparing)-206(together)-207(the)-206(facts)-207(and)-206(statements)-207(of)-206(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(New)-194(Testament.)-232(It)-194(is)-194(sufficient)-194(for)-195(my)-194(present)-194(purpose)-194(to)-194(observe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-309(the)-310(perusal)-309(of)-309(the)-309(Gospels)-310(leaves)-309(the)-309(inevitable)-309(impression)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-399(the)-398(mind)-399(that)-398(it)-399(was)-398(the)-399(purpose)-398(of)-399(their)-398(writers)-399(to)-398(depict)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-365(divine)-365(character)-365(in)-365(union)-365(with)-365(a)-365(human)-365(one)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 206.972 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(a)-365(supernatural)]TJ -217.881 -13.55 Td [(power)-262(acting)-262(within)-262(the)-263(regions)-262(of)-262(the)-262(natural.)-286(This)-262(covers)-262(alike)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-356(aspects)-357(of)-356(character)-356(presented)-356(of)-356(him)-357(both)-356(in)-356(the)-356(Synoptic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(the)-250(Johannine)-250(Gospels.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Although)-199(our)-199(Lord)-198(speaks)-199(of)-199(his)-199(actions)-198(by)-199(the)-398(common)-198(name)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 279.068 0 Td [([052])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 12.733 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(works)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 26.661 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.489 0 Td [(\050)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 3.633 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\301\263\261)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 16.124 0 Td [(\051,)-355(when)-334(the)-334(sacred)-335(authors)-334(speak)-334(generally)-334(of)]TJ -77.066 -13.549 Td [(miracles,)-338(they)-320(apply)-321(to)-320(them,)-338(as)-320(I)-321(have)-320(observed,)-338(three)-320(distinct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(terms,)-490(signs,)-490(mighty)-441(works,)-490(and)-442(wonders)-442(\050)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 199.262 0 Td [(\303\267\274\265)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 21.502 0 Td [(\326)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\261)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.727 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 8.07 0 Td [(\264\305\275)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 16.288 0 Td [(q)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.727 0 Td [(\274\265\271\302)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 18.12 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf -277.903 -13.55 Td [(\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 4.691 0 Td [(s)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\301\261\304\261)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 21.36 0 Td [(\051.)-486(Each)-329(of)-329(these)-329(denotes)-328(different)-329(aspects)-329(in)-329(which)-328(they)]TJ -30.633 -13.549 Td [(contemplated)-319(miracles.)-456(The)-319(sign)-318(included)-319(the)-319(supernatural)-318(fact)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wrought)-406(on)-406(external)-406(nature)-407(with)-406(the)-406(whole)-406(of)-406(its)-406(moral)-406(envi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ronment.)-484(In)-328(this)-328(point)-328(of)-328(view,)-347(the)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 159.681 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(sign)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.185 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.422 0 Td [(was)-328(the)-328(direct)-328(proof)]TJ -191.132 -13.549 Td [(of)-323(a)-323(divine)-323(mission.)-469(It)-323(is)-323(worthy)-323(of)-323(observation)-323(that)-323(the)-322(author)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-383(the)-383(fourth)-382(Gospel)-383(has)-383(uniformly)-383(described)-383(the)-382(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(actions)-302(which)-301(he)-302(has)-302(ascribed)-301(to)-302(Jesus)-302(Christ)-301(by)-302(this)-302(term.)-404(The)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
255 0 obj <<
/Length 4877      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(50)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(expression)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 49.358 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(mighty)-247(works)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 60.278 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.544 0 Td [(is)-247(intended)-248(to)-247(bring)-248(under)-247(our)-248(notice)]TJ -122.024 -13.549 Td [(the)-259(power)-260(which)-259(was)-259(displayed)-259(in)-259(the)-260(performance)-259(of)-259(a)-259(miracle,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thereby)-348(directly)-348(connecting)-348(it)-348(with)-348(a)-348(superhuman)-348(agency.)-543(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 23.794 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(wonder)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 32.717 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.64 0 Td [(contemplates)-348(a)-348(supernatural)-348(event)-348(in)-348(its)-348(simple)]TJ -69.994 -13.55 Td [(aspect)-293(as)-293(an)-292(occurrence)-293(pre-eminently)-293(fitted)-293(to)-293(command)-292(atten-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-340(to)-341(the)-340(person)-340(who)-340(was)-341(capable)-340(of)-340(performing)-340(it.)-521(We)-340(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-347(conclude)-346(that)-347(the)-347(writers)-347(of)-346(the)-347(New)-347(Testament)-346(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sidered)-253(that)-253(these)-253(were)-253(the)-253(three)-253(special)-253(functions)-253(of)-253(miracles.)-259(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-356(quite)-356(possible)-356(that)-356(the)-356(same)-356(miracle)-356(might)-356(have)-356(fulfilled)-355(all)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(three)-200(at)-201(the)-200(same)-201(time:)-225(but)-200(as)-201(three)-200(such)-201(functions)-200(of)-200(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrences)-213(are)-213(distinctly)-213(stated,)-220(it)-213(is)-213(quite)-213(conceivable)-213(that)-213(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-294(occasions)-293(when)-294(they)-293(were)-294(limited)-294(to)-293(some)-294(one)-293(of)-294(these)-293(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(particular.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-224(is)-224(evident)-224(that)-225(our)-224(Lord)-224(attached)-224(the)-224(highest)-224(importance)-224(to)-224(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(miracle)-286(contemplated)-286(as)-286(a)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 117.903 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(sign,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 20.913 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 7.963 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 17.234 0 Td [(to)-286(the)-286(moral)-286(environment)]TJ -168.857 -13.55 Td [(with)-413(which)-413(it)-413(was)-413(connected.)-739(This,)-454(although)-413(more)-413(definitely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(brought)-263(out)-262(in)-263(St.)-288(John's)-262(Gospel,)-266(is)-263(also)-262(distinctly)-263(borne)-262(witness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-268(by)-267(the)-268(Synoptics.)-302(It)-268(forms)-268(the)-267(ground)-268(of)-267(the)-268(reiterated)-267(refusal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-283(our)-283(Lord)-283(to)-283(comply)-282(with)-283(the)-283(demand)-283(of)-283(the)-283(Pharisees)-283(that)-282(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-359(show)-360(some)-359(sign)-359(from)-360(heaven,)-773(as)-359(a)-360(proof)-359(of)-359(his)-359(divine)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([053])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.55 Td [(mission.)-478(His)-327(miracles)-326(combined)-326(in)-326(one)-326(the)-326(two)-326(conceptions)-326(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(signs)-412(and)-412(mighty)-412(works.)-737(None)-412(of)-412(them)-412(were)-412(mere)-412(prodigies)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(devoid)-250(of)-250(a)-250(moral)-250(aspect.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-508(is)-508(worthy)-508(of)-508(consideration)-508(whether)-508(our)-508(Lord's)-507(primary)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(purpose)-366(in)-366(performing)-367(supernatural)-366(actions)-366(was)-366(always)-366(direct-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ly)-397(evidential.)-691(I)-397(have)-397(already)-397(drawn)-397(attention)-397(to)-397(their)-397(twofold)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aspect,)-367(as)-343(divine)-343(manifestations,)-366(and)-344(as)-343(evidential)-343(miracles.)-529(A)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(considerable)-432(number)-431(of)-432(the)-431(miracles)-432(recorded)-431(in)-432(the)-431(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-439(represented)-440(as)-439(performed)-440(by)-439(him)-439(because)-440(he)-439(was)-439(moved)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-286(compassion.)-357(These)-286(evidently)-286(belong)-286(to)-286(the)-286(former)-286(class)-285(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-320(supernatural)-320(workings.)-459(But)-320(although)-320(this)-320(was)-320(their)-319(primary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(object)-243(it)-243(did)-243(not)-243(deprive)-243(them)-243(of)-243(an)-244(evidential)-243(value.)-247(But)-243(there)-243(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(also)-319(another)-318(remarkable)-319(class)-319(of)-318(supernatural)-319(actions)-318(attributed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-405(him,)-444(viz.,)-444(those)-405(in)-405(which)-405(he)-405(is)-405(recorded)-405(to)-405(have)-405(expressly)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
259 0 obj <<
/Length 4420      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(51)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(forbidden)-204(the)-204(persons)-204(whom)-204(he)-203(healed)-204(to)-204(publish)-204(the)-204(fact.)-235(As)-204(it)-203(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evident)-286(that)-285(these)-286(miracles)-285(could)-286(only)-285(have)-286(become)-285(extensively)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(known)-400(by)-399(the)-400(persons)-399(cured)-400(disobeying)-400(his)-399(orders,)-437(it)-400(is)-399(clear)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-322(they)-322(could)-322(not)-321(have)-322(been)-322(directly)-322(performed)-322(for)-321(evidential)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(purposes,)-205(but)-194(were)-194(the)-194(manifestations)-194(of)-194(the)-194(divine)-194(which)-193(resided)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(his)-250(person.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Such)-405(are)-406(the)-405(supernatural)-405(actions)-406(attributed)-405(to)-405(Jesus)-405(Christ)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-400(the)-400(New)-400(Testament,)-437(respecting)-400(which)-400(as)-400(a)-400(whole,)-437(whether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performed)-335(for)-335(purposes)-335(avowedly)-335(evidential)-335(or)-335(not,)-356(he)-335(himself)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirms,)-344(that)-326(they)-325(bore)-325(witness)-326(of)-325(him,)-344(that)-325(the)-326(Father)-325(had)-325(sent)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(him.)-926(Two)-476(other)-475(classes)-475(of)-476(miracles,)-531(affirmed)-476(to)-475(have)-475(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performed)-250(by)-250(his)-250(followers,)-250(require)-250(notice.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-366(whole)-366(of)-366(these)-365(are)-366(stated)-366(to)-366(have)-366(been)-366(performed)-366(by)-365(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(delegated)-204(power)-204(and)-205(commission.)-234(The)-205(great)-204(majority)-204(of)-204(them)-204(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(described)-248(as)-248(having)-248(been)-248(performed)-248(in)-248(the)-248(name)-248(of)-248(Jesus)-247(Christ.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(They)-379(are)-757(affirmed)-379(to)-379(have)-378(been)-379(performed)-379(for)-379(two)-378(purposes;)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([054])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(to)-429(prove)-430(the)-429(divine)-430(commission)-429(of)-429(those)-430(who)-429(wrought)-429(them,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-301(to)-301(attest)-300(the)-301(reality)-301(of)-301(their)-300(Master's)-301(resurrection,)-314(by)-300(giving)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exhibitions)-320(of)-320(his)-320(present)-321(power.)-460(These)-320(therefore)-320(are)-320(distinctly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirmed)-367(to)-367(have)-367(been)-367(evidential)-367(miracles.)-601(A)-367(few)-367(others)-367(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(providential)-293(interferences)-292(in)-293(favour)-292(of)-293(the)-292(infant)-293(Church.)-377(There)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-395(also)-396(another)-395(class)-395(of)-395(supernatural)-395(actions)-396(referred)-395(to)-395(in)-395(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Acts)-296(of)-295(the)-295(Apostles,)-307(such)-296(as)-295(the)-296(passing)-295(of)-296(St.)-386(Peter's)-295(shadow,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-311(the)-311(supposed)-310(supernatural)-311(effects)-311(resulting)-311(from)-311(it,)-326(and)-310(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conveyance)-291(from)-291(St.)-374(Paul's)-291(person)-291(of)-291(handkerchiefs)-291(and)-291(aprons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-226(the)-226(sick,)-231(and)-226(one)-226(or)-226(two)-226(other)-226(instances.)-242(These)-226(involve)-225(special)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manifestations)-210(of)-210(supernatural)-211(power,)-218(and)-210(belong)-210(to)-210(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(occurrences)-416(in)-417(their)-416(aspect)-416(of)-416(wonders,)-458(or)-416(very)-416(extraordinary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events,)-251(and)-251(as)-251(such)-251(were)-251(specially)-251(adapted)-251(for)-251(drawing)-250(attention)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-392(the)-391(message)-392(of)-392(the)-391(Apostles.)-675(But)-392(the)-391(New)-392(Testament)-391(also)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirms)-190(another)-190(and)-189(very)-190(peculiar)-190(form)-189(of)-190(the)-190(manifestation)-190(of)-189(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural,)-335(as)-318(then)-318(actually)-318(existing)-318(in)-318(the)-318(Apostolic)-317(Church.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(I)-314(need)-315(hardly)-314(say)-315(that)-315(I)-314(allude)-314(to)-315(the)-314(various)-315(gifts)-314(of)-315(the)-314(Spirit,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-348(which)-348(large)-348(numbers)-348(of)-348(its)-348(members)-348(believed)-347(themselves)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
264 0 obj <<
/Length 4645      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(52)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(to)-366(be)-366(endowed.)-597(I)-366(shall)-366(not)-366(consider)-366(them)-366(any)-366(further)-366(here,)-394(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-351(will)-351(be)-351(necessary)-351(for)-351(me)-351(to)-351(enter)-351(largely)-351(on)-351(the)-351(subject)-350(in)-351(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subsequent)-322(portion)-322(of)-323(this)-322(work.)-466(Their)-323(use)-322(and)-322(purpose)-322(was)-322(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lay)-224(deep)-223(the)-224(foundations)-223(of)-224(the)-223(Christian)-224(Church.)-241(All)-223(that)-224(will)-223(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(necessary)-297(in)-296(this)-297(place)-297(is)-297(to)-296(draw)-297(attention)-297(to)-296(them)-297(as)-297(a)-296(distinct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-342(of)-342(supernatural)-341(manifestations,)-365(to)-342(the)-342(existence)-342(of)-341(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(writers)-250(of)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)-250(are)-250(pledged.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(There)-336(is)-336(also)-337(one)-336(further)-336(form)-336(of)-336(supernatural)-336(manifestation)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(affirmed)-183(by)-183(them,)-197(namely,)-196(a)-183(great)-183(moral)-183(and)-183(spiritual)-183(transforma-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-212(effected)-212(in)-212(those)-212(who)-212(cordially)-212(embraced)-212(the)-212(Gospel.)-237(This)-212(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(most)-252(positively)-253(stated)-504(by)-252(St.)-257(Paul)-252(to)-252(have)-253(been)-252(a)-252(fact)-252(constantly)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([055])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(taking)-417(place)-417(under)-418(his)-417(own)-417(observation.)-752(It)-417(is)-417(only)-417(necessary)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(for)-412(me)-411(to)-412(notice)-411(its)-412(existence,)-451(as)-412(it)-411(is)-412(a)-411(form)-412(of)-411(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manifestation,)-311(the)-298(truth)-299(or)-299(falsehood)-298(of)-299(which)-298(forms)-299(no)-298(portion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(present)-250(controversy.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(Such)-390(then)-391(are)-390(the)-390(various)-391(forms)-390(of)-390(the)-391(supernatural,)-425(to)-390(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(existence)-223(of)-223(which)-223(the)-224(writers)-223(of)-223(the)-223(New)-223(Testament)-223(are)-223(pledged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-387(objective)-386(facts.)-660(To)-387(these)-386(only,)-421(and)-387(not)-386(to)-387(any)-386(conceivable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-352(possible)-351(ones,)-377(is)-352(the)-352(defender)-351(of)-352(Christianity)-352(committed.)-554(If)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-214(occurrence)-214(can)-214(be)-214(shown)-214(to)-214(have)-214(been)-214(impossible,)-221(either)-214(on)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(grounds)-315(of)-314(science)-315(or)-315(philosophy,)-330(or)-315(because)-315(human)-314(testimony)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-291(of)-291(so)-291(fallible)-291(a)-292(character)-291(that)-291(it)-291(cannot)-291(establish)-291(the)-291(truth)-291(of)-291(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-233(occurrence,)-236(it)-233(follows)-233(that)-233(the)-233(whole)-233(of)-233(Christianity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-220(have)-220(been)-220(an)-220(inventi)1(on)-220(of)-220(a)-220(purely)-220(human)-220(origin,)-226(that)-220(it)-219(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-275(no)-275(claim)-276(to)-275(the)-275(designation)-275(of)-275(a)-276(divine)-275(revelation,)-281(and)-275(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-220(is)-221(hardly)-220(possible)-221(to)-220(free)-221(its)-220(inventors)-221(from)-220(the)-221(charge)-220(of)-220(fraud.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(No)-240(mere)-239(paring)-240(down)-239(of)-240(its)-239(supernatural)-240(elements)-239(will)-240(enable)-239(us)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(escape)-250(from)-250(this)-250(conclusion.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(I)-402(must)-402(now)-403(proceed)-402(to)-402(consider)-402(whether)-403(the)-402(writers)-402(of)-402(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(New)-295(Testament)-295(rest)-295(the)-295(truth)-295(of)-295(Christianity)-295(on)-295(the)-295(evidence)-295(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-250(alone,)-250(and)-250(what)-250(position)-250(they)-250(occupy)-250(respecting)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(If)-280(we)-280(assume)-280(for)-279(the)-280(sake)-280(of)-280(argument)-280(that)-280(the)-280(fourth)-279(Gospel)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(is)-325(the)-325(work)-325(of)-326(the)-325(Apostle)-325(John,)-344(it)-325(is)-325(evident)-325(that)-325(neither)-325(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ)-301(nor)-301(the)-300(Apostle)-301(accepted)-301(the)-300(theory)-301(which)-301(has)-301(been)-300(pro-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
268 0 obj <<
/Length 5453      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(53)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(pounded)-305(by)-304(some)-305(divines,)-319(and)-304(readily)-305(accepted)-305(by)-304(unbelievers,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-272(the)-272(evidence)-273(of)-272(his)-272(divine)-272(mission)-272(was)-272(exclusively)-272(founded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-230(the)-231(testimony)-230(of)-230(miracles.)-243(To)-231(state)-230(the)-230(point)-230(distinctly:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 250.325 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(This)]TJ -261.234 -13.549 Td [(Gospel)-351(places)-352(the)-351(evidence)-351(afforded)-351(by)-352(our)-351(Lord's)-351(own)-351(divine)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(person,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 34.988 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 17.135 0 Td [(the)-283(moral)-566(evidence)-283(of)-283(his)-283(mission,)-291(in)-283(the)-283(first)-283(rank,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 238.901 0 Td [([056])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(his)-250(miraculous)-250(works)-250(in)-250(the)-250(second.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(As)-195(this)-196(is)-195(a)-195(point)-196(of)-195(considerable)-195(importance,)-207(and)-195(one)-195(to)-195(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(its)-248(proper)-248(weight)-248(has)-248(been)-248(seldom)-247(attached,)-249(I)-248(will)-248(enumerate)-247(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(chief)-250(statements)-250(made)-250(in)-250(this)-250(Gospel)-250(on)-250(this)-250(subject.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(First:)-395(The)-322(author)-323(of)-322(the)-323(Gospel)-322(directly)-323(affirms)-322(that)-323(Jesus)-322(is)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf -11.956 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(the)-287(light)-286(of)-287(men;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 73.621 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.97 0 Td [(and)-287(he)-286(himself)-287(distinctly)-286(affirms)-287(of)-286(himself,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf -86.435 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(He)-177(that)-177(seeth)-177(me)-177(seeth)-177(Him)-177(that)-177(sent)-177(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 172.094 0 Td [(\035)-177(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 11.618 0 Td [(I)-177(am)-177(come)-177(a)-177(light)-177(into)]TJ -188.556 -13.549 Td [(the)-329(world,)-349(that)-329(whosoever)-329(believeth)-329(on)-329(me)-329(should)-329(not)-329(abide)-329(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(darkness.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 40.899 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.311 0 Td [(\050John)-226(xii.)-242(45,)-231(46.\051)-242(Again,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 111.569 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(I)-226(am)-226(the)-227(light)-226(of)-226(the)-226(world;)]TJ -164.622 -13.55 Td [(he)-320(that)-319(followeth)-320(me)-319(shall)-320(not)-319(walk)-320(in)-319(darkness,)-337(but)-320(shall)-319(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-328(light)-329(of)-328(life.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 70.44 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.426 0 Td [(\050John)-328(viii.)-485(12.\051)-485(It)-329(is)-328(impossible)-328(to)-329(read)-328(these)]TJ -78.866 -13.549 Td [(and)-309(kindred)-310(passages)-309(without)-310(feeling)-309(that)-309(our)-310(Lord)-309(appealed)-309(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(something)-375(else)-376(besides)-375(his)-375(miraculous)-375(works,)-407(viewed)-375(as)-375(mere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(objective)-350(facts,)-375(as)-351(a)-350(proof)-350(of)-350(his)-350(divine)-351(mission.)-550(He)-350(evidently)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(places)-209(the)-209(highest)-208(proof)-209(of)-209(it)-209(in)-209(his)-208(great)-209(moral)-209(and)-209(spiritual)-208(man-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ifestation.)-393(He)-298(asserts)-297(the)-298(possession)-298(of)-297(an)-298(inherent)-297(illumination)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-369(his)-369(own)-369(divine)-369(Person)-369(in)-369(union)-369(with)-369(the)-369(great)-369(truths)-368(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-328(enunciated,)-347(and)-327(the)-328(entire)-328(course)-327(of)-328(his)-328(divine)-327(working.)-483(To)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-329(mind)-329(capable)-328(of)-329(appreciating)-329(a)-329(manifestation)-328(of)-329(holiness,)-348(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(person)-376(and)-375(divine)-376(working)-376(would)-375(be)-376(self-evidential.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 242.605 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(He)-376(that)]TJ -247.449 -13.549 Td [(seeth)-255(me,)-257(seeth)-255(Him)-255(that)-255(sent)-255(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 146.999 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.626 0 Td [(It)-255(is)-255(evident)-255(therefore)-255(that)-255(he)]TJ -154.625 -13.549 Td [(considered)-229(the)-228(moral)-229(aspect)-229(of)-228(even)-229(his)-229(supernatural)-228(works)-229(as)-228(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(important)-250(portion)-250(of)-250(the)-250(evidence)-250(that)-250(he)-250(came)-250(from)-250(God.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-302(fourth)-302(chapter)-303(of)-302(this)-302(Gospel)-302(contains)-303(an)-302(account)-302(of)-302(our)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Lord's)-293(visit)-294(to)-293(the)-293(Samaritans.)-380(He)-293(performed)-294(no)-293(miracle)-293(on)-293(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occasion.)-615(The)-372(Evangelist)-372(tells)-372(us)-371(that)-372(many)-372(of)-372(them)-371(accepted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(him)-288(as)-287(the)-288(Messiah;)-306(and)-288(expressly)-287(states)-288(that)-287(they)-288(affirmed)-287(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-365(was)-366(not)-365(on)-731(account)-366(of)-365(the)-366(report)-365(of)-366(the)-365(woman)-366(as)-365(to)-365(his)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([057])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-342(insight)-343(into)-342(her)-343(character;)-388(but)-343(because)-342(they)-342(them-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
273 0 obj <<
/Length 5306      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(54)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(selves)-239(had)-239(heard)-239(him,)-241(and)-239(on)-238(this)-239(account)-239(they)-239(had)-239(arrived)-239(at)-238(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(persuasion)-331(that)-332(was)-331(the)-331(Christ.)-494(There)-331(was)-331(something)-331(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-295(hi)1(s)-295(moral)-294(manifestation,)-306(even)-294(apart)-295(from)-294(his)-295(miracles,)-305(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(produced)-349(this)-350(persuasion.)-547(The)-350(Evangelist)-349(accepts)-349(this)-349(position)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-286(a)-286(correct)-285(one.)-358(He)-285(has)-286(even)-286(gone)-286(further,)-294(and)-286(has)-286(attributed)-285(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-280(the)-281(same)-280(chapter)-281(to)-280(our)-281(Lord)-280(himself.)-341(He)-281(makes)-280(him)-280(address)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-345(nobleman)-345(who)-345(came)-346(to)-345(solicit)-345(his)-345(interference)-345(in)-345(behalf)-345(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-296(sick)-296(son)-296(with)-296(these)-296(remarkable)-296(words:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 189.145 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Except)-296(ye)-296(see)-296(signs)]TJ -193.989 -13.549 Td [(and)-328(wonders,)-348(ye)-329(will)-328(not)-329(believe.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 149.015 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.426 0 Td [(\050John)-328(iv.)-486(48.\051)-485(These)-328(words)]TJ -157.441 -13.55 Td [(can)-335(only)-335(imply)-335(that,)-356(in)-335(the)-335(opinion)-335(of)-335(the)-334(speaker,)-357(there)-335(was)-334(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-231(and)-232(spiritual)-231(attestation)-231(of)-232(his)-231(divine)-231(mission,)-235(which)-231(stood)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(higher)-312(than)-312(objective)-312(miracles;)-343(and)-312(that)-312(those)-312(who)-312(witnessed)-311(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ought)-250(to)-250(have)-250(received)-250(it)-250(as)-250(such.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(In)-199(John)-199(vi.)-233(30,)-210(ff.,)-209(a)-199(remarkable)-199(dialogue)-199(is)-199(described)-199(as)-199(taking)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(place)-310(between)-311(our)-310(Lord)-311(and)-310(the)-311(Jews)-310(on)-310(this)-311(very)-310(subject.)-431(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Jews)-310(demand)-311(of)-310(him)-311(to)-310(work)-311(some)-310(distinct)-311(sign)-310(in)-311(proof)-310(of)-310(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine)-372(mission.)-616(Let)-373(it)-372(be)-372(observed)-372(that)-372(the)-372(demand)-372(of)-372(a)-372(sign,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(here)-241(stated)-240(to)-241(have)-241(been)-240(made,)-243(is)-241(of)-240(precisely)-241(the)-241(same)-240(character)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-367(similar)-367(statements)-367(which)-368(are)-367(made)-367(by)-367(the)-367(Synoptics)-367(on)-367(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same)-355(subject,)-382(and)-355(shows)-355(that)-355(a)-356(common)-355(conception,)-381(underlies)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(them)-214(all.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 40.389 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(What)-214(sign,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 46.879 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.18 0 Td [(say)-214(they,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 40.806 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(showest)-214(thou)-214(then,)-222(that)-214(we)-214(may)]TJ -144.941 -13.549 Td [(see)-269(and)-270(believe)-269(thee?)-308(what)-269(dost)-269(thou)-270(work?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 191.243 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.781 0 Td [(They)-269(then)-270(proceed)]TJ -199.024 -13.549 Td [(to)-364(define)-365(the)-364(particular)-365(sign)-364(which)-365(they)-364(wish)-365(to)-364(see)-364(exhibited,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-383(making)-382(an)-383(invidious)-382(comparison)-383(between)-382(his)-383(miracles)-382(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-387(of)-386(Moses,)-421(viewed)-387(as)-387(mere)-386(objective)-387(facts.)-660(In)-387(reply)-386(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Lord)-329(does)-329(not)-329(appeal)-329(directly)-329(to)-329(even)-329(the)-329(miracle)-329(of)-329(which)-328(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Evangelist)-358(had)-358(just)-359(described)-358(the)-358(performance;)-412(but)-358(throughout)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-330(remainder)-330(of)-329(the)-660(chapter,)-350(he)-329(proceeds)-330(to)-330(draw)-330(attention)-329(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([058])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(the)-253(moral)-253(and)-252(spiritual)-253(aspects)-253(of)-253(his)-253(working.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 204.828 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Moses)-253(gave)-253(you)]TJ -209.671 -13.549 Td [(not)-321(that)-320(bread)-321(from)-320(Heaven;)-356(but)-321(my)-320(Father)-321(giveth)-320(you)-321(the)-320(true)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bread)-364(from)-365(Heaven;)-421(for)-364(the)-365(bread)-364(of)-364(God)-365(is)-364(he)-364(which)-364(cometh)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(down)-250(from)-250(Heaven,)-250(and)-250(giveth)-250(life)-250(unto)-250(the)-250(world,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 221.782 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(&c.)]TJ -217.397 -16.004 Td [(In)-363(chapter)-362(vii.)-588(\05017,)-391(18\051)-363(our)-362(Lord)-363(affirms:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 193.183 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(If)-363(any)-362(man)-363(will)]TJ -209.983 -13.549 Td [(do)-455(his)-455(will,)-506(he)-455(shall)-454(know)-455(of)-455(the)-455(doctrine,)-506(whether)-455(it)-455(be)-454(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
277 0 obj <<
/Length 5383      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(55)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(God,)-301(or)-290(whether)-290(I)-291(speak)-290(of)-291(myself.)-371(He)-290(that)-291(speaketh)-290(of)-290(himself)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(seeketh)-210(his)-210(own)-210(glory;)-223(but)-210(he)-209(that)-210(seeketh)-210(his)-210(glory)-210(that)-210(sent)-209(him,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-381(same)-382(is)-381(true,)-414(and)-382(no)-381(unrighteousness)-381(is)-381(in)-382(him.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 232.939 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.004 0 Td [(Here)-381(the)]TJ -241.943 -13.549 Td [(affirmation)-233(is)-233(clear)-233(and)-232(distinct)-233(that)-233(there)-233(is)-233(a)-233(moral)-233(and)-232(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(element)-218(in)-218(our)-218(Lord's)-218(person)-218(and)-217(teaching,)-225(which)-218(jointly)-218(with)-217(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miraculous)-244(works)-244(bear)-245(witness)-244(to)-244(his)-244(divine)-244(character.)-248(The)-244(testi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mony)-252(given)-253(by)-252(the)-252(one)-253(is)-252(convergent)-252(with)-253(that)-252(of)-252(the)-253(other.)-256(This)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-326(following)-326(affirmation)-327(of)-326(our)-326(Lord)-326(most)-327(strongly)-326(asserts.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 272.154 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(I)]TJ -276.997 -13.549 Td [(am)-253(one)-253(who)-252(bear)-253(witness)-253(of)-253(myself,)-253(and)-253(the)-253(Father)-253(who)-253(sent)-252(me)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(hath)-250(borne)-251(witness)-250(of)-250(me,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 112.423 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.575 0 Td [(that)-250(is)-251(to)-250(say,)-251(His)-250(moral)-250(and)-251(spiritual)]TJ -119.998 -13.549 Td [(manifestation)-233(is)-234(in)-233(a)-234(certain)-233(sense)-233(evidential;)-239(and)-234(the)-233(Father)-233(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sent)-250(him)-250(bore)-250(a)-250(concurrent)-250(testimony)-250(of)-250(his)-250(supernatural)-250(work.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(On)-346(similar)-347(principles)-346(our)-347(Lord)-346(reasons)-347(with)-346(the)-347(Jews)-346(in)-346(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(eighth)-417(chapter)-417(of)-418(this)-417(Gospel.)-751(In)-418(reply)-417(to)-417(the)-417(charge)-417(that)-417(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performed)-374(miracles)-374(by)-374(the)-375(aid)-374(of)-374(the)-374(evil)-374(one)-374(he)-374(affirms,)-405(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(his)-228(own)-229(absolute)-228(sinlessness,)-233(constitutes)-228(a)-228(complete)-229(answer)-228(to)-228(it.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Which)-278(of)-278(you)-279(convinceth)-278(me)-278(of)-278(sin?)-335(and)-278(if)-279(I)-278(say)-278(the)-278(truth)-278(why)]TJ -4.844 -13.549 Td [(do)-278(ye)-279(not)-278(believe)-279(me?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.977 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.88 0 Td [(\050v.)-335(46.\051)-335(We)-279(have)-278(here)-278(a)-279(direct)-278(appeal)-279(to)]TJ -104.857 -13.549 Td [(men's)-279(moral)-280(and)-279(spiritual)-280(perception,)-286(as)-280(an)-279(independent)-279(witness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-259(the)-260(truth)-259(of)-259(his)-260(teaching;)-264(and)-259(the)-259(affirmation)-260(that)-259(a)-259(being)-259(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-315(not)-316(simply)-315(good)-316(and)-315(holy,)-332(but)-315(perfectly)-316(sinless,)-332(is)-315(worthy)-315(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(absolute)-405(credence.)-714(In)-405(other)-405(words,)-443(he)-405(does)-405(not)-405(rest)-405(the)-404(truth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-812(his)-406(teaching)-407(on)-406(miracles)-406(wrought)-406(to)-406(confirm)-406(his)-406(different)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([059])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(utterances,)-233(but)-229(on)-229(the)-228(inherent)-229(truthfulness)-229(of)-229(a)-229(sinless)-228(character.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-250(moral)-250(aspect)-250(of)-250(his)-250(works)-250(is)-250(the)-250(predominant)-250(one.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(In)-319(the)-319(fourteenth)-319(chapter)-319(of)-319(this)-319(Gospel)-319(we)-319(have)-319(the)-318(follow-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ing)-293(remarkable)-293(declaration,)-303(which)-293(puts)-292(the)-293(whole)-293(subject)-293(in)-292(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(clearest)-357(light.)-572(Philip)-357(says)-357(to)-358(him;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 155.711 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Show)-357(us)-357(the)-358(Father,)-384(and)-357(it)]TJ -160.554 -13.549 Td [(sufficeth)-372(us.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 54.649 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.896 0 Td [(Jesus)-371(said)-372(unto)-371(him,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.243 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Have)-372(I)-371(been)-371(so)-372(long)-371(time)]TJ -164.631 -13.549 Td [(with)-281(you,)-288(and)-281(yet)-281(hast)-281(thou)-281(not)-281(known)-281(me,)-288(Philip?)-343(He)-281(that)-280(hath)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(seen)-256(me)-257(hath)-256(seen)-256(the)-257(Father:)-262(Believest)-257(thou)-256(not)-256(that)-257(I)-256(am)-256(in)-256(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Father,)-253(and)-252(the)-252(Father)-252(in)-253(me?)-256(The)-253(words)-252(that)-252(I)-252(speak)-252(unto)-253(you,)-252(I)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(speak)-243(not)-243(of)-243(myself;)-246(but)-243(the)-243(Father)-243(that)-243(dwelleth)-244(in)-243(me,)-244(he)-243(doeth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-278(works.)-333(Believe)-278(me)-277(that)-278(I)-278(am)-277(in)-278(the)-278(Father,)-284(and)-278(the)-278(Father)-277(in)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
281 0 obj <<
/Length 4961      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(56)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(me,)-250(or)-250(else)-250(believe)-250(me)-250(for)-250(the)-250(very)-250(works')-250(sake.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 207.665 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050vs.)-250(8-11.\051)]TJ -203.28 -14.163 Td [(This)-327(passage)-328(contains)-327(several)-328(most)-327(important)-327(considerations)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(directly)-361(bearing)-362(on)-361(this)-362(subject.)-584(I)-362(will)-361(mention)-362(them)-361(in)-361(order.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(First)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 20.008 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -8.052 -14.163 Td [(Philip)-348(asks)-348(for)-348(his)-348(complete)-349(conviction,)-372(a)-348(visible)-348(miracle)-348(in)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-312(form)-312(of)-312(an)-312(appearance)-312(of)-312(God,)-328(such)-312(as)-312(was)-312(recorded)-312(in)-312(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Old)-250(Testament)-250(as)-250(having)-250(taken)-250(place)-250(at)-250(Sinai.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(Secondly.)-764(Our)-422(Lord)-421(affirms)-422(that)-421(the)-422(manifestations)-421(of)-421(his)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(character)-334(made)-334(in)-334(his)-335(person)-334(and)-334(work)-334(during)-334(his)-334(previous)-334(ac-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(quaintance)-208(with)-207(him)-208(were)-207(the)-207(truest)-208(manifestations)-207(of)-208(the)-207(person,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-250(and)-250(being)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Father.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(Thirdly.)-360(That)-286(the)-287(words)-286(which)-287(he)-286(spake)-287(and)-286(his)-287(entire)-286(work-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ing,)-379(possessed)-353(an)-353(evidential)-353(character)-353(as)-353(proving)-353(that)-352(he)-353(came)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-216(the)-215(Father:)-233(and)-216(that)-215(his)-216(moral)-216(and)-215(spiritual)-216(perfections)-215(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-234(as)-235(to)-234(entitle)-234(his)-234(affirmation)-235(to)-234(be)-234(received)-235(on)-234(his)-234(own)-234(word.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(Fourthly.)-567(That)-356(if)-356(Philip)-355(was)-356(unable)-356(to)-355(receive)-356(them)-356(on)-355(this)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(evidence,)-223(which)-216(occupied)-216(the)-216(highest)-216(place,)-223(then)-432(he)-216(was)-216(entitled)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([060])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(to)-285(be)-286(believed)-285(on)-285(the)-286(evidence)-285(of)-285(his)-286(supernatural)-285(works,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 255.11 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(If)-285(ye)]TJ -259.954 -13.549 Td [(believe)-250(not)-250(me,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 69.687 0 Td [(believe)-250(the)-250(works)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 75.742 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -136.2 -14.163 Td [(This)-229(entire)-228(passage)-229(makes)-228(it)-229(clear)-229(that)-228(in)-229(the)-229(mind)-228(of)-229(our)-228(Lord)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-223(moral)-223(evidence)-223(afforded)-222(by)-223(him)-223(constituted)-223(a)-223(most)-222(important)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(portion)-234(of)-234(the)-235(attestation)-234(of)-234(his)-234(divine)-234(mission.)-245(Nor)-234(was)-234(its)-234(value)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(confined)-192(to)-193(those)-192(who)-192(witnessed)-193(it)-192(during)-192(the)-193(time)-192(of)-192(his)-192(personal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ministry,)-275(but)-269(he)-270(viewed)-270(it)-269(as)-270(extending)-270(to)-269(all)-270(time.)-309(This)-270(is)-269(made)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(clear)-352(by)-353(his)-352(reply)-353(to)-352(Thomas)-353(in)-352(reference)-353(to)-352(his)-353(demand)-352(to)-352(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(allowed)-342(to)-342(handle)-342(his)-341(risen)-342(body.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 154.973 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Thomas,)-365(because)-342(thou)-342(hast)]TJ -159.817 -13.549 Td [(seen)-225(me,)-229(thou)-225(hast)-224(believed,)-230(Blessed)-224(are)-225(they)-224(who)-225(have)-224(not)-224(seen,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(yet)-250(have)-250(believed.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 97.549 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050xx.)-250(29.\051)]TJ -93.165 -14.163 Td [(With)-295(these)-294(statements)-295(before)-294(us,)-306(unless)-294(we)-295(reject)-294(the)-295(author-)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(ity)-394(of)-393(this)-394(Gospel,)-429(it)-393(is)-394(clear)-393(that)-394(those)-393(Christian)-394(writers)-393(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-310(asserted)-309(that)-309(the)-310(evidence)-309(of)-310(the)-309(Christian)-310(revelation)-309(rests)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(exclusively)-250(on)-250(miracles)-250(as)-250(objective)-250(facts)-250(are)-250(in)-250(error.)]TJ 11.955 -14.163 Td [(But)-209(the)-209(same)-209(Gospel)-209(refers)-208(us)-209(no)-209(less)-209(distinctly)-209(to)-209(the)-209(miracles)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(of)-204(our)-204(Lord)-205(as)-204(very)-204(important)-204(evidences)-204(of)-205(his)-204(divine)-204(mission,)-213(al-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
285 0 obj <<
/Length 5681      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(57)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(though)-232(they)-233(are)-232(subordinated)-232(to)-232(those)-233(we)-232(have)-232(been)-232(considering.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(One)-250(or)-250(two)-250(further)-250(references)-250(will)-250(be)-250(sufficient.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(We)-247(have)-246(several)-247(declarations)-247(on)-247(this)-246(subject)-247(in)-247(the)-247(fifth)-246(chap-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ter.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.244 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(My)-320(Father)-319(worketh)-320(hitherto,)-337(and)-320(I)-319(work.)-459(The)-320(Son)-320(can)-319(do)]TJ -24.088 -13.549 Td [(nothing)-269(of)-270(himself,)-274(but)-269(what)-270(he)-269(seeth)-269(the)-270(Father)-269(do;)-279(for)-269(whatso-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ever)-248(things)-248(he)-247(doeth,)-249(these)-247(also)-248(doeth)-248(the)-248(Son)-247(likewise.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 240.67 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.547 0 Td [(\050vs.)-249(17,)]TJ -248.217 -13.549 Td [(19.\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 22.549 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)-328(works)-328(which)-328(the)-328(Father)-328(hath)-328(given)-328(me)-328(to)-328(finish,)-347(the)]TJ -27.393 -13.55 Td [(same)-231(works)-232(that)-231(I)-231(do)-231(bear)-232(witness)-231(of)-231(me)-231(that)-232(the)-231(Father)-231(hath)-231(sent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 16.059 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050ver.)-250(36.\051)]TJ -11.674 -14.776 Td [(Here)-364(a)-363(plain)-364(parallel)-363(is)-364(drawn)-363(between)-364(the)-363(whole)-364(course)-363(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(our)-361(Lord's)-360(working)-361(and)-360(that)-361(of)-360(the)-361(Fat)1(her.)-582(In)-360(this)-361(working)-360(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidently)-316(intended)-316(to)-316(include)-317(his)-632(miracles.)-448(Taken)-316(in)-316(combina-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([061])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(tion)-228(with)-228(his)-228(entire)-228(character)-228(the)-228(speaker)-228(affirms)-228(that)-228(they)-228(form)-228(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conclusive)-296(proof)-296(that)-296(the)-296(Father)-296(had)-296(sent)-296(him.)-387(He)-296(subsequently)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(draws)-242(attention)-243(to)-242(the)-243(evidence)-242(afforded)-243(by)-242(his)-242(miracles)-243(as)-242(such,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.55 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(and)-306(the)-306(Father)-306(himself)-307(which)-306(hath)-306(sent)-306(me)-306(hath)-306(borne)-306(witness)]TJ -4.844 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.873 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050ver.)-250(37.\051)]TJ -23.488 -14.776 Td [(So)-272(again)-273(in)-273(the)-272(tenth)-273(chapter,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 131.518 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(The)-273(works)-272(that)-273(I)-272(do)-273(in)-272(my)-273(Fa-)]TJ -148.317 -13.55 Td [(ther's)-284(name,)-293(they)-284(bear)-285(witness)-284(of)-284(me,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 163.66 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.944 0 Td [(\050ver.)-353(25.\051)-353(A)-284(little)-284(further)]TJ -171.604 -13.549 Td [(on)-329(the)-330(moral)-329(aspect)-329(of)-329(his)-330(miracles,)-349(and)-329(their)-329(close)-329(connection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-398(his)-397(entire)-398(working)-398(is)-397(distinctly)-398(brought)-398(forward.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 250.336 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Many)]TJ -255.179 -13.549 Td [(good)-359(works)-360(have)-359(I)-359(showed)-359(you)-360(from)-359(my)-359(Father;)-414(for)-359(which)-359(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-254(works)-254(do)-254(ye)-253(stone)-254(me?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 125.948 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.613 0 Td [(\050vs)-254(37,)-255(38.\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 52.638 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(If)-254(I)-254(do)-253(not)-254(the)-254(works)]TJ -191.043 -13.55 Td [(of)-299(my)-299(Father,)-311(believe)-299(me)-299(not,)-311(but)-299(if)-299(I)-299(do,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 186.019 0 Td [(though)-299(ye)-299(believe)-299(not)]TJ -186.019 -13.549 Td [(me,)-375(believe)-350(the)-350(works)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 97.457 0 Td [(,)-375(that)-350(ye)-350(may)-349(know)-350(and)-350(believe,)-375(that)-350(the)]TJ -97.457 -13.549 Td [(Father)-276(is)-276(in)-275(me,)-283(and)-276(I)-275(in)-276(him.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 128.401 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.853 0 Td [(\050vs.)-327(37,)-283(38.\051)-327(No)-276(words)-276(can)-276(bring)]TJ -136.254 -13.549 Td [(out)-412(more)-411(strongly)-412(the)-412(weight)-411(which)-412(our)-412(Lord)-411(attached)-412(to)-411(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-250(aspect)-250(of)-250(his)-250(miracles)-250(as)-250(proofs)-250(of)-250(his)-250(divine)-250(mission.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(In)-240(the)-240(fifteenth)-240(chapter)-240(we)-240(have)-240(our)-240(Lord's)-240(own)-240(reflections)-239(on)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-264(evidences)-263(which)-264(he)-263(had)-263(afforded)-264(of)-263(his)-264(Messianic)-263(character,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(during)-349(his)-348(entire)-349(ministry.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 122.52 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(If)-349(I)-348(had)-349(not)-349(done)-348(among)-349(them)-349(the)]TJ -127.363 -13.549 Td [(works)-270(which)-270(none)-270(other)-270(man)-270(did,)-275(they)-270(had)-270(not)-270(had)-270(sin;)-280(but)-269(now)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-374(have)-375(both)-374(seen)-375(and)-374(hated)-374(both)-375(me)-374(and)-375(my)-374(Father.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 251.411 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.928 0 Td [(\050ver.)]TJ -260.339 -13.549 Td [(24.\051)-412(Here)-304(the)-303(miracles)-304(are)-304(classed)-304(with)-304(the)-304(other)-304(exhibitions)-303(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
147 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 884
/Length 9072      
>>
stream
146 0 149 48 144 163 151 219 148 276 154 353 156 468 153 524 158 601 160 716
157 773 162 850 164 965 161 1021 166 1110 168 1225 165 1282 170 1359 172 1474 173 1531
169 1587 175 1664 177 1779 174 1836 180 1925 182 2040 179 2097 184 2174 186 2289 183 2346
188 2411 190 2526 187 2583 192 2660 194 2775 191 2831 196 2908 198 3023 199 3080 195 3136
201 3213 203 3328 200 3385 206 3450 208 3565 205 3622 210 3699 212 3814 209 3871 214 3936
216 4051 213 4108 218 4185 220 4300 217 4356 222 4445 224 4560 225 4617 221 4673 227 4738
229 4853 226 4909 232 4986 234 5101 231 5157 235 5222 238 5261 240 5422 236 5537 242 5593
239 5649 244 5714 248 5829 243 5886 250 5989 252 6104 249 6161 254 6264 256 6379 253 6436
258 6525 260 6640 257 6696 263 6761 265 6876 262 6933 267 6998 269 7113 270 7170 266 7226
272 7315 274 7430 271 7487 276 7564 278 7679 275 7735 280 7812 282 7927 279 7984 284 8073
% 146 0 obj
(Chapter II. Definitions of Terms.)
% 149 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 150 0 R
/Resources 148 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 152 0 R
>>
% 144 0 obj
<<
/D [149 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 151 0 obj
<<
/D [149 0 R /XYZ 216.476 174.733 null]
>>
% 148 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 154 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 155 0 R
/Resources 153 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 152 0 R
>>
% 156 0 obj
<<
/D [154 0 R /XYZ 344.05 245.555 null]
>>
% 153 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 158 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 159 0 R
/Resources 157 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 152 0 R
>>
% 160 0 obj
<<
/D [158 0 R /XYZ 180.568 312.482 null]
>>
% 157 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 162 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 163 0 R
/Resources 161 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 152 0 R
>>
% 164 0 obj
<<
/D [162 0 R /XYZ 93.543 369.134 null]
>>
% 161 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 166 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 167 0 R
/Resources 165 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 152 0 R
>>
% 168 0 obj
<<
/D [166 0 R /XYZ 202.287 450.429 null]
>>
% 165 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 170 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 171 0 R
/Resources 169 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 152 0 R
>>
% 172 0 obj
<<
/D [170 0 R /XYZ 163.605 504.626 null]
>>
% 173 0 obj
<<
/D [170 0 R /XYZ 93.543 107.499 null]
>>
% 169 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 175 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 176 0 R
/Resources 174 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 178 0 R
>>
% 177 0 obj
<<
/D [175 0 R /XYZ 280.692 174.536 null]
>>
% 174 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 180 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 181 0 R
/Resources 179 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 178 0 R
>>
% 182 0 obj
<<
/D [180 0 R /XYZ 183.159 243.918 null]
>>
% 179 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 184 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 185 0 R
/Resources 183 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 178 0 R
>>
% 186 0 obj
<<
/D [184 0 R /XYZ 268.259 311.664 null]
>>
% 183 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 188 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 189 0 R
/Resources 187 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 178 0 R
>>
% 190 0 obj
<<
/D [188 0 R /XYZ 198.157 382.683 null]
>>
% 187 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 192 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 193 0 R
/Resources 191 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 178 0 R
>>
% 194 0 obj
<<
/D [192 0 R /XYZ 46.771 448.051 null]
>>
% 191 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 196 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 197 0 R
/Resources 195 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 178 0 R
>>
% 198 0 obj
<<
/D [196 0 R /XYZ 194.535 518.175 null]
>>
% 199 0 obj
<<
/D [196 0 R /XYZ 93.543 121.834 null]
>>
% 195 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 201 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 202 0 R
/Resources 200 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 204 0 R
>>
% 203 0 obj
<<
/D [201 0 R /XYZ 289.781 192.994 null]
>>
% 200 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 206 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 207 0 R
/Resources 205 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 204 0 R
>>
% 208 0 obj
<<
/D [206 0 R /XYZ 274.667 259.104 null]
>>
% 205 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 210 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 211 0 R
/Resources 209 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 204 0 R
>>
% 212 0 obj
<<
/D [210 0 R /XYZ 242.865 328.486 null]
>>
% 209 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 214 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 215 0 R
/Resources 213 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 204 0 R
>>
% 216 0 obj
<<
/D [214 0 R /XYZ 213.426 380.228 null]
>>
% 213 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 218 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 219 0 R
/Resources 217 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 204 0 R
>>
% 220 0 obj
<<
/D [218 0 R /XYZ 202.19 434.425 null]
>>
% 217 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 222 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 223 0 R
/Resources 221 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 204 0 R
>>
% 224 0 obj
<<
/D [222 0 R /XYZ 280.409 504.626 null]
>>
% 225 0 obj
<<
/D [222 0 R /XYZ 350.319 106.79 null]
>>
% 221 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 227 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 228 0 R
/Resources 226 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 230 0 R
>>
% 229 0 obj
<<
/D [227 0 R /XYZ 76.524 163.441 null]
>>
% 226 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 232 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 233 0 R
/Resources 231 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 230 0 R
>>
% 234 0 obj
<<
/D [232 0 R /XYZ 93.543 461.426 null]
>>
% 231 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 235 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index4) >>
% 238 0 obj
(Chapter III. The Supernatural Elements Contained in the New Testament: In What Do They Consist? And What View Do Its Writers Take Respecting Them?)
% 240 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 241 0 R
/Resources 239 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 230 0 R
>>
% 236 0 obj
<<
/D [240 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 242 0 obj
<<
/D [240 0 R /XYZ 151.285 66.142 null]
>>
% 239 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 244 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 245 0 R
/Resources 243 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 230 0 R
>>
% 248 0 obj
<<
/D [244 0 R /XYZ 228.181 133.888 null]
>>
% 243 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F37 246 0 R /F38 247 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 250 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 251 0 R
/Resources 249 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 230 0 R
>>
% 252 0 obj
<<
/D [250 0 R /XYZ 261.253 201.634 null]
>>
% 249 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F38 247 0 R /F37 246 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 254 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 255 0 R
/Resources 253 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 230 0 R
>>
% 256 0 obj
<<
/D [254 0 R /XYZ 263.706 258.286 null]
>>
% 253 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 258 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 259 0 R
/Resources 257 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 261 0 R
>>
% 260 0 obj
<<
/D [258 0 R /XYZ 90.773 310.028 null]
>>
% 257 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 263 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 264 0 R
/Resources 262 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 261 0 R
>>
% 265 0 obj
<<
/D [263 0 R /XYZ 191.504 381.456 null]
>>
% 262 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 267 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 268 0 R
/Resources 266 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 261 0 R
>>
% 269 0 obj
<<
/D [267 0 R /XYZ 143.849 463.978 null]
>>
% 270 0 obj
<<
/D [267 0 R /XYZ 120.297 79.691 null]
>>
% 266 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 272 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 273 0 R
/Resources 271 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 261 0 R
>>
% 274 0 obj
<<
/D [272 0 R /XYZ 187.908 149.892 null]
>>
% 271 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 276 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 277 0 R
/Resources 275 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 261 0 R
>>
% 278 0 obj
<<
/D [276 0 R /XYZ 60.289 217.638 null]
>>
% 275 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 280 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 281 0 R
/Resources 279 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 261 0 R
>>
% 282 0 obj
<<
/D [280 0 R /XYZ 307.112 298.319 null]
>>
% 279 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 284 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 285 0 R
/Resources 283 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 287 0 R
>>
endstream
endobj
291 0 obj <<
/Length 5813      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(58)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(our)-282(Lord's)-281(divine)-282(character;)-297(and)-281(attention)-282(is)-281(especially)-282(drawn)-281(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-334(moral)-334(aspect)-334(of)-334(his)-334(entire)-334(working)-334(as)-334(in)-334(the)-334(highest)-333(degree)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidential.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 49.259 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(They)-274(have)-274(seen)-273(and)-274(hated)-274(both)-274(me)-274(and)-273(my)-274(Father.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 221.684 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(It)-218(is)-218(worthy)-218(of)-218(remark)-218(that)-218(while)-218(our)-218(Lord)-218(uniformly)-218(spoke)-218(of)-218(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miracles)-264(as)-265(part)-264(of)-264(his)-264(general)-265(working,)-268(by)-264(which)-264(he)-264(manifested)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-419(divine)-420(character,)-461(the)-420(Evangelist)-419(himself)-419(almost)-419(invariably)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(calls)-382(them)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 50.154 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(signs.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 25.157 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.013 0 Td [(This)-382(is)-382(brought)-383(out)-382(when)-382(he)-382(gives)-382(us)-383(his)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -161.922 0 Td [([062])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(own)-346(reflections)-347(on)-346(the)-346(results)-347(of)-346(his)-346(public)-347(ministry.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 241.848 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Though)]TJ -246.692 -13.549 Td [(he)-332(had)-332(done)-332(so)-331(many)-332(signs)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 121.727 3.958 Td [(2)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.104 -3.958 Td [(before)-332(them)-332(yet)-332(they)-331(believed)-332(not)]TJ -129.831 -13.55 Td [(on)-314(him.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 34.036 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.269 0 Td [(\050xii.)-442(37.\051)-442(So)-314(again,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 89.691 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(many)-314(other)-314(signs)-314(truly)-314(did)-314(Jesus)]TJ -136.84 -13.549 Td [(in)-404(the)-403(presence)-404(of)-403(his)-404(disciples,)-442(which)-403(are)-404(not)-403(written)-404(in)-403(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(book:)-245(but)-241(these)-241(are)-241(written)-240(that)-241(ye)-241(might)-241(believe)-240(that)-241(Jesus)-241(is)-240(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ,)-257(the)-255(Son)-255(of)-256(God.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 101.463 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.63 0 Td [(\050xx.)-266(30,)-257(31.\051)-266(In)-255(both)-256(these)-255(passages)-255(our)]TJ -109.093 -13.549 Td [(Lord's)-319(miracles)-319(are)-319(evidently)-320(referred)-319(to.)-457(They)-319(are)-319(pronounced)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-448(be)-448(both)-447(evidential)-448(of)-448(his)-448(divine)-448(mission,)-497(and)-448(at)-448(the)-447(same)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(time)-271(to)-271(be)-270(manifestations)-271(of)-271(his)-271(character.)-312(The)-271(Evangelist)-270(while)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contemplating)-291(them)-290(as)-291(miracles)-291(never)-291(loses)-290(sight)-291(of)-291(their)-290(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aspect.)]TJ 11.956 -13.816 Td [(In)-241(the)-240(Synoptic)-241(Gospels)-241(one)-241(allusion)-240(is)-241(made)-241(to)-241(the)-240(evidential)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(purpose)-218(of)-218(a)-219(particular)-218(miracle)-218(which)-218(is)-219(worthy)-218(of)-218(notice.)-239(Gener-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ally)-248(speaking)-248(they)-248(are)-249(viewed)-248(by)-248(the)-248(authors)-248(of)-248(these)-248(Gospels)-248(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(simple)-289(manifestations)-290(of)-289(his)-290(divine)-289(character.)-369(On)-289(this)-289(occasion,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-291(his)-292(power)-291(to)-291(forgive)-292(sins)-291(was)-291(questioned,)-302(he)-291(directly)-291(per-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(formed)-256(a)-257(miracle)-256(to)-257(prove)-256(that)-256(he)-257(possessed)-256(it.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 206.185 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(But)-256(that)-257(ye)-256(may)]TJ -211.028 -13.549 Td [(know)-322(that)-322(the)-323(Son)-322(of)-322(Man)-322(hath)-322(power)-323(on)-322(earth)-322(to)-322(forgive)-322(sins,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-301(saith)-302(to)-301(the)-301(sick)-301(of)-302(the)-301(palsy,)-314(I)-301(say)-302(unto)-301(thee,)-314(arise,)-314(and)-301(take)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(up)-344(thy)-343(bed)-344(and)-343(go)-344(thy)-343(way)-344(into)-343(thine)-344(house.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 200.081 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.592 0 Td [(In)-343(this)-344(case)-344(it)-343(is)]TJ -208.673 -13.549 Td [(clear)-223(that)-223(the)-223(purpose)-223(of)-223(performing)-223(the)-223(miracle)-223(was)-223(not)-223(t)1(o)-223(prove)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-325(truth)-326(of)-325(any)-325(doctrinal)-326(statement)-325(which)-325(he)-326(had)-325(made;)-363(but)-325(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(establish)-250(the)-250(reality)-250(of)-250(his)-250(divine)-250(authority)-250(and)-250(commission.)]TJ 11.956 -13.815 Td [(While)-264(it)-265(is)-264(quite)-264(true)-265(that)-264(the)-264(authors)-265(of)-264(the)-264(Synoptic)-264(Gospels)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(have)-377(not)-377(enunciated)-377(the)-378(purpose)-377(of)-377(our)-377(Lord's)-377(miracles)-377(in)-377(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
ET
q
1 0 0 1 93.543 87.722 cm
[]0 d 0 J 0.398 w 0 0 m 112.25 0 l S
Q
BT
/F16 5.9776 Tf 99.77 80.91 Td [(2)]TJ/F16 8.9664 Tf 5.729 -3.809 Td [(The)-260(word)-259(which)-260(is)-260(here)-260(translated)-260(in)-259(the)-260(A.)-260(V.)]TJ/F20 8.9664 Tf 169.21 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 8.9664 Tf 3.981 0 Td [(miracles)]TJ/F20 8.9664 Tf 30.378 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 8.9664 Tf 6.31 0 Td [(is)-260(in)-260(the)-259(original)]TJ/F37 8.9664 Tf -221.835 -10.959 Td [(\303\267\274\265)]TJ/F38 8.9664 Tf 17.673 0 Td [(\326)]TJ/F37 8.9664 Tf 2.636 0 Td [(\261)]TJ/F16 8.9664 Tf 4.708 0 Td [(.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
295 0 obj <<
/Length 4686      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(59)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(formal)-394(manner)-393(in)-393(which)-394(it)-393(is)-394(done)-393(in)-394(St.)-680(John's)-394(Gospel,)-429(it)-393(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(clear)-339(that)-339(they)-339(must)-340(have)-339(taken)-339(the)-339(same)-339(view)-339(of)-339(their)-339(general)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character.)-571(In)-357(fact)-357(the)-714(evidential)-357(purpose)-357(of)-357(their)-357(performance)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([063])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(is)-288(less)-288(clearly)-288(stated)-288(in)-288(them)-288(than)-288(in)-288(the)-288(fourth)-288(Gospel.)-364(All)-288(four)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Gospels)-317(view)-317(his)-317(miracles)-318(only)-317(as)-317(a)-317(portion)-317(of)-317(his)-317(superhuman)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manifestation,)-364(and)-342(are)-342(ignorant)-341(of)-342(that)-341(broad)-342(distinction)-341(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-314(been)-313(laid)-314(down)-314(between)-313(them)-314(and)-314(the)-313(other)-314(portions)-314(of)-313(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine)-407(working.)-720(They)-407(are)-407(in)-406(fact)-407(included)-407(under)-407(it;)-485(and)-407(it)-406(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-329(concurrence)-329(of)-329(both)-329(together,)-349(and)-329(the)-329(moral)-329(aspect)-329(thereby)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(impressed)-250(on)-250(the)-250(whole,)-250(which)-250(proves)-250(him)-250(to)-250(be)-250(the)-250(Christ.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-345(has)-346(been)-345(important)-346(to)-345(ascertain)-346(what)-345(are)-346(the)-345(views)-346(of)-345(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(writers)-215(of)-214(the)-215(New)-215(Testament)-214(on)-215(this)-215(subject,)-221(because)-215(it)-215(has)-214(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(strongly)-223(asserted)-223(by)-222(authors)-223(on)-223(both)-222(sides)-223(of)-223(the)-223(controversy)-222(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-197(doctrines)-197(of)-196(Christianity)-197(are)-197(proved)-197(by)-196(miracles,)-208(and)-197(that)-196(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-336(rest)-337(for)-336(their)-337(attestation)-336(on)-336(no)-337(other)-336(evidence.)-509(The)-336(precise)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(value)-276(of)-276(this)-276(position)-276(I)-276(will)-276(consider)-276(in)-276(the)-276(following)-276(chapter.)-327(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must,)-392(however,)-393(be)-364(observed)-364(that)-364(this)-364(is)-364(not)-364(the)-364(view)-364(taken)-363(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-289(writers)-289(of)-289(the)-289(New)-289(Testament.)-367(There)-289(is)-289(not)-289(a)-289(single)-289(miracle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recorded)-289(in)-288(it)-289(which)-288(is)-289(alleged)-289(to)-288(have)-289(been)-288(performed)-289(with)-288(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(direct)-290(purpose)-289(of)-290(proving)-289(the)-290(truth)-289(of)-290(a)-289(single)-290(doctrine)-289(properly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(so)-256(called.)-267(Those)-256(wrought)-256(by)-255(our)-256(Lord)-256(are)-256(uniformly)-255(represented)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-330(having)-329(been)-330(performed)-329(in)-330(proof)-329(of)-330(his)-329(divine)-330(mission,)-349(or)-329(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-439(essential)-439(portion)-439(of)-438(the)-439(manifestation)-439(of)-439(the)-439(divine)-438(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dwelt)-423(within)-422(him.)-768(As)-423(such)-423(they)-423(were)-422(signs,)-466(precisely)-423(in)-422(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same)-218(manner)-217(as)-218(the)-217(performance)-218(of)-217(those)-218(actions)-217(which)-218(can)-217(only)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-357(performed)-358(by)-357(man)-357(are)-358(signs;)-411(that)-357(is,)-384(they)-357(are)-358(proofs)-357(of)-357(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presence)-299(of)-300(man.)-398(In)-299(the)-300(same)-299(manner)-299(the)-300(actions)-299(performed)-299(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-278(Lord)-279(are)-278(signs)-279(and)-278(proofs)-279(of)-278(the)-279(presence)-278(of)-279(the)-278(divine)-278(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-319(Christ.)-456(If)-319(our)-319(Lord)-319(was)-318(in)-319(truth)-319(what)-319(he)-319(asserted)-318(himself)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-268(be,)-271(supernatural)-268(manifestations)-267(would)-268(be)-267(the)-268(concomitants)-267(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-250(presence.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(In)-326(exact)-326(conformity)-326(with)-325(these)-326(facts)-326(as)-326(we)-326(find)-326(them)-652(in)-325(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 279.068 0 Td [([064])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(Gospels)-301(is)-300(the)-301(direct)-300(dogmatic)-301(statement)-300(made)-301(by)-300(the)-301(author)-300(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-257(Epistle)-258(to)-257(the)-258(Hebrews)-257(on)-258(this)-257(subject.)-273(After)-257(having)-257(asserted)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
300 0 obj <<
/Length 5618      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(60)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(in)-334(the)-334(first)-334(chapter)-333(that)-334(divine)-334(revelation)-334(is)-334(made)-334(in)-334(the)-333(person)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-280(Jesus)-280(Christ,)-288(and)-280(that)-279(God)-280(speaks)-280(to)-280(man)-280(under)-280(the)-280(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dispensation)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 59.007 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(in)-409(him,)-449(who)-409(is)-409(the)-409(brightness)-409(of)-409(his)-409(glory,)-448(and)]TJ -63.851 -13.549 Td [(the)-270(express)-270(image)-270(of)-271(his)-270(person,)-275(and)-270(upholding)-270(all)-270(things)-270(by)-270(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(word)-306(of)-306(his)-307(power,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 84.247 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.185 0 Td [(the)-306(author)-306(proceeds)-307(to)-306(compare)-306(it)-306(with)-307(the)]TJ -92.432 -13.549 Td [(former)-255(dispensation,)-257(and)-256(to)-255(give)-256(us)-255(his)-256(views)-255(of)-256(the)-255(evidence)-255(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-310(it)-311(rests.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 66.924 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(How,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 23.935 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.229 0 Td [(says)-310(he,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 38.746 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(shall)-310(we)-311(escape,)-325(if)-310(we)-311(neglect)]TJ -147.521 -13.549 Td [(so)-313(great)-312(salvation;)-344(which)-313(at)-313(the)-312(first)-313(began)-313(to)-312(be)-313(spoken)-313(by)-312(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Lord,)-321(and)-307(was)-307(confirmed)-307(unto)-307(us)-307(by)-307(them)-307(that)-307(heard)-307(him.)-421(God)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(also)-297(bearing)-296(them)-296(witness)-297(both)-296(by)-297(signs)-296(and)-297(wonders,)-308(and)-296(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divers)-215(miracles)-214(and)-214(gifts)-215(of)-214(the)-215(Holy)-214(Ghost,)-222(according)-214(to)-215(his)-214(own)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.702 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050ii.)-250(3,)-250(4.\051)]TJ -15.317 -15.186 Td [(These)-254(words)-254(distinctly)-254(inform)-254(us)-254(what)-254(were)-254(the)-254(writer's)-253(opin-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ions)-225(as)-225(to)-226(the)-225(nature)-225(of)-225(the)-226(evidences)-225(on)-225(which)-225(Christianity)-225(rests.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(First,)-389(it)-362(reposes)-361(on)-361(the)-362(testimony)-361(of)-362(Christ)-361(respecting)-361(himself.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Secondly,)-356(it)-334(is)-335(confirmed)-334(by)-335(a)-334(number)-335(of)-334(miracles)-335(wrought)-334(by)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(God.)-616(This)-372(view)-372(is)-372(strictly)-372(in)-372(accordance)-372(with)-372(our)-372(Lord's)-372(own)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirmation)-270(respecting)-270(it)-269(as)-270(recorded)-270(in)-270(the)-269(fourth)-270(Gospel,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 255.88 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(I)-270(am)]TJ -260.724 -13.549 Td [(one)-248(that)-248(bear)-249(witness)-248(of)-248(myself,)-248(and)-249(the)-248(Father)-248(that)-248(sent)-248(me)-248(hath)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(borne)-250(witness)-250(of)-250(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 90.895 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050viii.)-250(18.\051)]TJ -86.51 -15.186 Td [(With)-230(respect)-230(to)-230(numerous)-230(miracles)-230(recorded)-230(in)-230(the)-230(Acts)-230(of)-230(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Apostles,)-241(they)-238(are)-239(affirmed)-238(to)-239(have)-238(been)-239(performed)-238(for)-238(purposes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(directly)-177(evidential,)-192(not)-177(however)-177(to)-177(prove)-177(the)-177(truth)-176(of)-177(any)-177(doctrine,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-310(of)-310(our)-310(Lord's)-310(Messianic)-310(character.)-430(The)-310(affirmations)-310(on)-310(this)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(point)-270(are)-269(express.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 80.439 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(In)-270(the)-269(name)-270(of)-269(Jesus)-270(Christ)-269(of)-270(Nazareth,)-274(rise)]TJ -85.282 -13.549 Td [(up)-237(and)-237(walk.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 55.767 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.429 0 Td [(\050iii.)-246(6.\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 32.633 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(His)-237(name,)-240(through)-237(faith)-237(in)-237(his)-237(name,)-239(hath)]TJ -100.673 -13.549 Td [(made)-276(this)-277(man)-276(strong.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 97.226 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.876 0 Td [(\050iii.)-329(16.\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 39.914 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Therefore)-276(let)-277(all)-276(the)-277(house)-276(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -225.615 0 Td [([065])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(Israel)-197(know)-197(assuredly,)-207(that)-197(God)-197(hath)-196(made)-197(that)-197(same)-197(Jesus)-196(whom)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ye)-278(have)-278(crucified,)-285(both)-277(Lord)-278(and)-278(Christ.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 176.411 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.875 0 Td [(\050ii.)-334(36.\051)-333(Of)-278(the)-278(fact)-278(of)]TJ -184.286 -13.55 Td [(the)-331(resurrection,)-350(they)-331(affirm)-330(that)-331(they)-331(were)-330(witnesses;)-371(and)-330(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-320(miraculous)-321(powers)-320(imparted)-321(to)-320(them)-321(were)-320(the)-320(consequence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(that)-250(event,)-250(and)-250(a)-250(proof)-250(of)-250(its)-250(truth.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-316(nature)-315(of)-316(the)-316(other)-315(supernatural)-316(occurrences)-316(affirmed)-315(in)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-231(New)-231(Testament)-232(must)-231(be)-231(fully)-231(considered)-232(hereafter.)-243(There)-231(re-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
304 0 obj <<
/Length 4844      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(61)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(main)-207(however)-207(two)-206(further)-207(statements,)-215(made)-207(by)-207(the)-207(sacred)-206(writers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(respecting)-278(this)-278(subject,)-284(which)-278(require)-278(to)-278(be)-278(briefly)-278(noticed)-277(here.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(First,)-416(although)-384(the)-383(Gospels)-383(affirm)-383(that)-383(John)-383(the)-383(Baptist)-383(had)-383(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine)-291(commission)-290(to)-291(announce)-290(the)-290(immediate)-291(setting)-290(up)-291(of)-290(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(kingdom)-201(of)-200(the)-201(Messiah,)-210(and)-201(even)-201(to)-200(point)-201(him)-200(out,)-211(they)-200(express-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ly)-272(assert)-273(that)-272(he)-273(performed)-272(no)-272(objective)-273(miracle)-272(in)-272(confirmation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-342(it.)-524(His)-342(prophetical)-341(assertions)-341(rested)-342(for)-341(their)-342(verification)-341(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-443(fulfilment)-443(only,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 100.788 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 22.381 0 Td [(on)-443(the)-443(immediate)-444(appearance)-443(of)-443(a)]TJ -123.169 -13.549 Td [(person)-348(who)-347(united)-348(in)-348(himself)-347(all)-348(the)-348(attributes)-347(of)-348(the)-347(Messiah.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(The)-339(following)-340(was)-339(the)-340(line)-339(of)-340(argument)-339(adopted)-340(by)-339(those)-339(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believed)-456(his)-456(testimony:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 112.939 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(John)-456(did)-456(no)-457(miracle,)-507(but)-456(all)-457(things)]TJ -117.783 -13.549 Td [(that)-327(John)-327(spoke)-327(of)-327(this)-327(man)-327(were)-327(true.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 171.918 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.411 0 Td [(Secondly,)-346(while)-327(in)-327(the)]TJ -180.329 -13.549 Td [(Apostolic)-342(Epistles,)-365(miracles)-341(are)-342(stated)-342(to)-342(have)-342(been)-341(performed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-270(our)-270(Lord,)-274(and)-270(supernatural)-270(powers)-269(no)-270(less)-270(clearly)-270(asserted)-269(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-266(been)-265(at)-266(that)-265(very)-266(time)-265(actually)-266(present)-265(in)-266(the)-265(Church,)-269(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-311(only)-311(one)-310(miracle)-311(which)-311(is)-311(directly)-311(referred)-310(to)-311(in)-311(proof)-311(of)-310(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine)-308(mission)-308(of)-307(Christ.)-424(I)-307(need)-308(not)-308(say)-307(that)-308(this)-308(is)-308(the)-307(greatest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-282(all)-283(the)-282(miracles)-282(recorded)-283(in)-282(the)-283(Gospels,)-290(viz.)-347(his)-282(resurrection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-336(the)-336(dead.)-509(On)-336(this)-337(their)-336(unanimous)-336(testimony)-336(affirms)-336(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Christianity)-263(rests.)-290(This)-263(is)-263(the)-263(one)-264(final)-263(and)-263(decisive)-263(proof)-263(of)-263(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Lord's)-206(divine)-206(mission.)-235(On)-206(its)-206(truth)-206(they)-206(affirm)-206(that)-206(their)-206(claims)-206(as)]TJ 2.501 -13.549 Td [(divine)-229(teachers)-229(stand)-230(or)-229(fall.)-243(His)-229(resurrection)-229(from)-230(the)-229(dead)-229(puts)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 288.523 0 Td [([066])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(all)-344(his)-344(other)-344(miracles)-343(in)-344(the)-344(back)-344(ground)-344(in)-344(point)-344(of)-343(evidential)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(value.)-388(According)-296(to)-296(their)-296(statements)-296(it)-296(constitutes)-296(the)-296(one)-295(great)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(assurance)-228(that)-228(God)-228(has)-228(given)-228(unto)-228(all)-228(men)-228(that)-228(Jesus)-228(of)-227(Nazareth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-250(Lord)-250(and)-250(Christ.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(It)-374(follows,)-405(therefore,)-404(that)-374(if)-374(this)-374(one)-374(miracle)-374(can)-374(be)-373(proved)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(to)-303(have)-303(been)-303(an)-302(historical)-303(fact,)-316(it)-303(carries)-303(with)-303(it)-303(the)-303(entire)-302(force)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-447(all)-447(the)-448(remaining)-447(miracles)-447(of)-447(the)-447(New)-448(Testament.)-841(But)-447(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(leaves)-265(entirely)-264(untouched)-265(the)-265(moral)-265(aspects)-264(of)-265(our)-265(Lord's)-264(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character.)-281(These,)-263(I)-261(may)-260(say,)-263(constitute)-260(a)-261(standing)-260(miracle)-260(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will)-209(continue)-209(to)-208(speak)-209(for)-209(itself)-208(in)-209(all)-209(time.)-236(This)-209(evidence)-209(is)-208(again)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-381(again)-382(referred)-381(to)-381(by)-381(the)-381(writers)-382(of)-381(the)-381(Apostolic)-381(Epistles.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-262(two)-262(constitute)-262(one)-262(harmonious)-262(whole.)-286(To)-262(the)-262(latter)-262(of)-262(these)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
308 0 obj <<
/Length 815       
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(62)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(it)-424(is)-423(impossible)-424(to)-424(do)-424(more)-423(than)-424(refer)-424(in)-423(the)-424(present)-424(work;)-510(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-262(already)-261(devoted)-262(a)-262(distinct)-261(volume)-262(to)-262(the)-261(examination)-262(of)-261(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidential)-357(value,)-384(in)-357(which)-358(I)-357(have)-357(examined)-357(Christ's)-357(witness)-357(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(himself;)-362(here)-325(I)-324(must)-325(confine)-324(myself)-325(to)-325(the)-324(consideration)-325(of)-324(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(witness)-250(borne)-250(to)-250(him)-250(by)-250(the)-250(Father.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -29.651 Td [([067])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
316 0 obj <<
/Length 3321      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-262(IV.)-262(Miracles,)-266(What)-262(Do)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(They)-250(Prove?)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -34.163 Td [(Having)-369(considered)-369(the)-369(direct)-369(assertions)-369(in)-369(the)-369(New)-368(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-379(reference)-379(to)-380(the)-379(supernatural,)-411(it)-379(will)-380(be)-379(necessary)-379(to)-379(take)-379(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(brief)-301(view)-300(of)-301(the)-300(question)-301(in)-300(relation)-301(to)-300(modern)-301(difficulties)-300(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(objections.)]TJ 11.956 -13.897 Td [(The)-281(following)-281(subjects)-281(present)-281(themselves)-281(for)-281(our)-281(considera-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tion:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 20.008 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -8.052 -13.898 Td [(1st.)-250(To)-249(what)-250(extent,)-249(and)-250(in)-249(what)-250(sense)-249(are)-250(miracles)-249(the)-249(proofs)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(a)-250(revelation?)]TJ 11.956 -13.897 Td [(2nd.)-466(Are)-321(supernatural)-322(occurrences)-322(devoid)-322(of)-322(all)-322(moral)-321(envi-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(ronment)-250(capable)-250(of)-250(affording)-250(such)-250(proof?)]TJ 11.956 -13.897 Td [(3rd.)-589(Can)-363(doctrinal)-363(statements)-363(or)-363(moral)-363(truths)-363(be)-363(proved)-363(by)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(miracles?)]TJ 11.956 -13.898 Td [(4th.)-477(Are)-326(miracles)-326(objects)-325(of)-326(faith)-326(merely,)-345(or)-325(if)-326(not,)-345(how)-325(are)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(they)-248(related)-249(to)-248(our)-249(reason;)-249(and)-248(if)-249(in)-248(any)-249(sense)-248(they)-249(are)-248(objects)-248(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(faith,)-250(how)-250(can)-250(they)-250(be)-250(the)-250(media)-250(of)-250(proof?)]TJ 11.956 -13.898 Td [(It)-385(will)-384(be)-385(evident)-385(that)-385(these)-384(questions)-385(will)-385(immediately)-384(lay)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(open)-311(a)-311(number)-311(of)-312(the)-311(most)-311(important)-311(considerations.)-433(They)-311(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-295(be)-295(adequately)-295(dealt)-294(with)-295(in)-295(the)-295(subsequent)-295(portions)-295(of)-294(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(work.)-329(The)-276(natural)-276(place)-277(to)-276(discuss)-276(them)-276(will)-277(be)-276(when)-276(I)-276(come)-276(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consider)-297(the)-297(objections)-297(that)-296(can)-297(be)-297(urged)-297(against)-297(the)-296(possibility)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-445(credibility)-445(of)-446(miracles.)-835(A)-445(few)-445(preliminary)-445(observations,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(however,)-275(will)-270(be)-270(necessary)-269(for)-270(the)-270(purpose)-270(of)-270(putting)-270(the)-269(reader)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-359(possession)-359(of)-359(some)-358(of)-359(the)-359(most)-718(important)-359(points)-359(of)-358(debate)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([068])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(and)-325(of)-326(the)-325(positions)-326(which)-325(I)-326(intend)-325(to)-326(assume)-325(respecting)-325(them.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(They)-459(will)-459(also)-458(help)-459(to)-459(clear)-459(the)-459(way)-458(for)-459(the)-459(solution)-459(of)-458(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(various)-334(difficulties)-334(by)-334(which)-334(the)-334(subject)-334(has)-334(been)-334(attempted)-333(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-250(obscured.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
321 0 obj <<
/Length 5023      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(64)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(The)-280(manner)-280(in)-280(which)-279(Christianity)-280(claims)-280(to)-280(be)-280(a)-280(divine)-279(reve-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(lation,)-284(as)-277(we)-278(have)-277(seen)-277(in)-277(the)-277(former)-278(chapter,)-284(in)-277(its)-277(most)-277(proper)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-223(distinctive)-222(sense)-223(is)-222(that)-223(the)-222(person)-223(of)-222(Jesus)-223(Christ)-222(constitutes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-392(revelation.)-676(It)-392(is)-392(the)-392(manifestation)-392(of)-392(the)-392(divine)-392(character)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-364(perfections)-365(by)-364(means)-364(of)-365(the)-364(various)-364(acts)-365(and)-364(deeds)-364(of)-364(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(earthly)-297(life)-298(and)-297(ministry.)-392(It)-297(is)-298(a)-297(revelation)-297(of)-298(the)-297(divine)-297(shining)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forth)-353(in)-354(the)-353(human.)-560(I)-353(have)-353(already)-353(adduced)-354(some)-353(of)-353(the)-353(affir-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mations)-332(of)-331(the)-332(sacred)-332(writers)-331(on)-332(this)-332(subject.)-495(It)-331(would)-332(be)-331(easy)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-370(multiply)-369(them)-370(indefinitely.)-608(Perhaps)-370(it)-369(would)-370(be)-369(impossible)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-324(express)-323(the)-324(position)-323(which)-324(they)-324(take)-323(on)-324(this)-323(subject)-324(in)-323(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinct)-298(language)-298(than)-297(by)-298(citing)-298(two)-298(brief)-298(passages)-297(in)-298(St.)-393(Paul's)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(epistle)-233(to)-232(the)-233(Colossians:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 110.856 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Who)-233(is,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.747 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.381 0 Td [(says)-232(the)-233(Apostle,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 76.429 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(the)-233(image)]TJ -238.101 -13.549 Td [(of)-404(the)-405(invisible)-404(God;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 95.053 0 Td [(\035)-404(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.099 0 Td [(in)-404(him)-405(dwelleth)-404(all)-405(the)-404(fulness)-404(of)-405(the)]TJ -109.152 -13.549 Td [(Godhead)-217(bodily.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 72.359 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.21 0 Td [(Both)-217(passages)-217(affirm,)-223(as)-217(the)-217(writer's)-217(view,)-224(that)]TJ -79.569 -13.55 Td [(all)-250(revelation)-250(is)-250(made)-250(in)-250(the)-250(person)-250(of)-250(Jesus)-250(Christ.)]TJ 11.955 -18.458 Td [(It)-210(follows,)-219(therefore,)-218(that)-210(the)-210(Christian)-211(revelation)-210(in)-210(its)-211(highest)]TJ -11.955 -13.55 Td [(sense)-275(is)-276(not)-275(a)-276(body)-275(of)-276(abstract)-275(dogmas,)-282(but)-276(that)-275(it)-276(consists)-275(of)-275(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(objective)-200(fact,)-210(the)-199(Incarnation.)-234(As)-199(God)-200(has)-200(manifested)-200(his)-199(eternal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-186(and)-185(Godhead)-186(in)-186(the)-185(material)-186(creation,)-198(so)-186(he)-186(has)-185(manifested)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(himself)-383(as)-382(a)-383(moral)-383(and)-383(spiritual)-382(being,)-416(1st,)-416(imperfectly)-383(in)-382(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-211(nature)-210(of)-211(man,)-218(and)-211(afterwards)-210(perfectly,)-219(in)-210(the)-211(perfect)-210(man)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(who)-284(unites)-285(in)-284(himself)-284(the)-284(divine)-284(and)-285(human,)-292(Jesus)-285(Christ.)-352(God,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-292(he)-291(effected)-292(the)-291(work)-292(of)-292(creation,)-302(made)-291(a)-292(manifestation)-291(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(himself)-370(which)-370(chiefly)-370(revealed)-371(his)-370(power)-370(and)-370(wisdom.)-610(When)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-439(effected)-438(the)-439(Incarnation)-439(he)-438(made)-439(an)-439(additional)-438(manifesta-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-624(of)-312(himself)-312(which)-312(chiefly)-312(revealed)-312(his)-312(moral)-311(character)-312(and)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([069])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(perfections.)-477(The)-326(four)-326(Gospels)-325(contain)-326(the)-326(historical)-326(account)-325(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-297(manifestation,)-308(as)-296(made)-297(in)-297(the)-296(actions)-297(and)-296(teaching)-297(of)-296(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ.)-242(As)-227(this)-227(revelation)-226(consists)-227(of)-227(a)-226(number)-227(of)-227(historical)-226(facts,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-395(that)-394(was)-395(necessary)-394(was)-394(that)-395(his)-394(life)-395(and)-394(actions)-395(should)-394(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(correctly)-298(reported.)-394(The)-298(remaining)-298(books)-298(of)-298(the)-298(New)-298(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-253(historical)-254(in)-253(character,)-254(with)-253(one)-253(exception,)-254(and)-254(as)-253(far)-253(as)-253(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(treat)-324(of)-324(doctrines,)-342(they)-324(may)-324(be)-324(viewed)-324(as)-324(commentaries)-324(on)-323(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Divine)-250(fact)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Incarnation.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
325 0 obj <<
/Length 4687      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-6784(65)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(It)-298(follows,)-310(therefore,)-311(that)-298(the)-298(essence)-298(of)-298(Christianity)-298(consists)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-290(a)-291(superhuman)-290(or)-290(divine)-291(fact,)-300(the)-290(Incarnation.)-371(In)-291(this)-290(point)-290(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(view)-300(the)-300(supernatural)-300(is)-299(not)-300(only)-300(a)-300(concomitant)-300(of)-299(Christianity,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-319(it)-318(constitutes)-319(its)-319(essence.)-456(It)-319(is)-319(the)-318(manifestation)-319(of)-319(a)-318(super-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(natural)-404(and)-403(superhuman)-404(being)-404(appearing)-403(within)-404(the)-404(sphere)-403(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-327(natural)-327(and)-327(the)-327(human.)-481(It)-327(cannot)-327(be)-327(too)-327(carefully)-327(observed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(throughout)-424(this)-425(entire)-424(controversy)-425(that)-424(the)-425(character)-424(which)-424(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ascribed)-347(to)-347(Jesus)-347(Christ,)-371(while)-347(it)-347(embraces)-347(every)-347(perfection)-346(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man,)-239(is)-237(no)-236(less)-237(superhuman)-236(than)-237(the)-236(powers)-237(which)-236(are)-236(attributed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-410(him)-410(are)-411(supernatural.)-730(In)-410(this)-411(sense)-410(the)-410(supernatural)-410(is)-410(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(merely)-250(an)-250(evidence)-250(of)-250(revelation,)-250(but)-250(its)-250(essence.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-261(Incarnation)-260(has)-261(frequently)-261(been)-261(designated)-260(a)-261(miracle.)-282(To)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(do)-357(so)-357(seems)-357(to)-357(me)-356(to)-357(incur)-357(the)-357(danger)-357(of)-357(involving)-357(the)-356(whole)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(controversy)-245(in)-244(confusion)-245(of)-245(thought.)-248(In)-245(a)-244(loose)-245(way)-245(of)-244(speaking,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-269(creative)-270(acts)-269(of)-270(God)-269(may)-270(be)-269(called)-269(miracles:)-289(that)-270(is,)-274(they)-269(in-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(volve)-248(a)-247(deviation)-248(from)-248(the)-248(previous)-247(order)-248(of)-248(existing)-247(things,)-248(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-222(introduction)-222(of)-222(a)-222(new)-222(one;)-231(all)-222(such)-222(results)-222(are)-221(unquestionable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manifestations)-281(of)-281(supernatural)-281(agency,)-289(but)-281(they)-281(differ)-281(wholly)-281(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conception)-257(from)-257(what)-257(we)-257(usually)-257(designate)-257(by)-257(the)-257(term)-256(miracle.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-301(Incarnation,)-315(therefore,)-314(ought)-301(not)-302(to)-301(be)-302(placed)-301(on)-302(the)-301(same)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([070])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(footing)-285(as)-284(miracles,)-293(which)-285(are)-285(supernatural)-284(occurrences,)-293(having)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-209(definite)-209(evidential)-208(value,)-217(but)-209(with)-209(God's)-209(creative)-209(acts,)-217(being)-208(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(highest)-318(manifestation)-317(of)-318(himself)-317(which)-318(he)-317(has)-318(made)-317(to)-318(man.)-452(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-263(perfectly)-263(true,)-266(as)-263(I)-263(have)-263(already)-263(observed,)-266(that)-263(the)-263(miracles)-262(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-275(Christ)-275(stand)-276(in)-275(a)-275(double)-275(aspect,)-282(as)-275(part)-275(of)-275(his)-275(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(manifestation,)-250(and)-250(as)-250(possessing)-250(an)-250(evidential)-250(value.)]TJ 11.956 -16.003 Td [(It)-427(is)-427(clear,)-471(therefore,)-471(that)-427(a)-427(supernatural)-427(event)-427(such)-427(as)-426(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(Incarnation,)-287(if)-280(evidential,)-287(can)-279(only)-280(be)-279(self-evidential.)-339(It)-280(was)-279(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wrought)-337(for)-336(the)-337(purpose)-337(of)-336(proving)-337(anything.)-510(But,)-358(as)-337(we)-336(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(seen,)-436(the)-399(sacred)-399(writers)-399(and)-398(our)-399(Lord)-399(himself)-399(assert)-399(that)-399(in)-398(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-241(sense)-241(it)-241(was)-241(self-evidential.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 154.688 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(For)-241(the)-241(life)-241(was)-241(manifested,)]TJ -159.532 -13.549 Td [(and)-344(we)-343(have)-344(seen)-343(it)-344(and)-343(bear)-344(witness,)-366(and)-344(show)-343(unto)-344(you)-343(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(eternal)-295(life)-295(which)-295(was)-296(with)-295(the)-295(Father)-295(and)-295(was)-295(manifested)-295(unto)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 12.426 0 Td [(\035)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
329 0 obj <<
/Length 4816      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(66)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(A)-453(recent)-453(writer)-453(affirms)-453(that)-453(Christianity)-453(professes)-453(to)-453(be)-453(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(revelation)-267(of)-267(supernatural)-267(truths)-267(utterly)-267(inconceivable)-267(to)-266(reason,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-456(that)-455(such)-456(truths)-456(can)-455(only)-456(be)-456(proved)-455(by)-456(miracles.)-867(I)-455(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(understand)-262(what)-262(is)-262(meant)-261(by)-262(a)-262(truth)-262(derived)-262(from)-262(a)-261(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(source)-275(of)-275(information,)-281(or)-275(one)-275(respecting)-275(a)-275(supernatural)-275(being)-274(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrence:)-511(but)-381(what)-380(a)-381(supernatural)-381(truth)-380(can)-381(be)-380(contradistin-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(guished)-248(from)-247(other)-248(kinds)-247(of)-248(truth)-248(is)-247(far)-248(from)-247(evident.)-249(Revelation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-260(disclose)-260(truths)-260(which)-260(reason)-260(alone)-260(would)-260(have)-260(been)-260(unable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-289(discover;)-309(but)-289(this)-289(does)-289(not)-289(make)-289(the)-289(truths)-290(themselves,)-298(when)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-250(are)-250(discovered,)-250(either)-250(supernatural)-250(or)-250(incomprehensible.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-184(will)-184(now)-184(proceed)-184(to)-184(consider)-184(whether)-184(there)-184(is)-184(any)-184(real)-183(ground)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(for)-362(affirming)-363(that)-362(occurrences)-362(which)-363(we)-362(designate)-362(as)-362(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-250(the)-250(only)-250(proofs)-250(of)-250(a)-250(divine)-250(revelation.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-276(same)-277(writer,)-282(whose)-277(object)-276(is)-276(to)-277(prove)-276(that)-276(Christianity)-276(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(utterly)-186(destitute)-186(of)-186(all)-186(cl)1(aims)-186(to)-186(our)-186(acceptance)-372(as)-186(a)-186(divine)-185(revela-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([071])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(tion,)-248(endeavours)-248(to)-247(show)-248(that)-248(miracles,)-248(viewed)-247(as)-248(bare)-247(objective)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(facts,)-309(are)-296(the)-297(only)-297(evidence)-297(which)-297(can)-297(substantiate)-297(such)-297(a)-296(mass)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-201(incredible)-202(assertions)-201(as)-202(those)-201(contained)-201(in)-202(the)-201(New)-201(Testament,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-234(that)-234(their)-234(moral)-234(environment)-234(cannot)-234(be)-234(taken)-234(into)-234(account)-233(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(estimating)-281(their)-280(evidential)-281(value.)-342(For)-281(this)-280(purpose)-281(he)-281(quotes)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(following)-347(passage)-346(from)-347(Dr.)-539(Mozley's)-347(Bampton)-346(Lectures:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 261.55 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Dr.)]TJ -266.394 -13.55 Td [(Mozley,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 36.055 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.631 0 Td [(says)-256(he,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 37.401 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(supposes)-256(the)-255(case,)-257(that)-255(if)-256(a)-256(person)-255(of)-256(evident)]TJ -85.93 -13.549 Td [(integrity)-355(and)-356(loftiness)-355(of)-356(character)-355(had)-356(appeared)-355(eighteen)-355(cen-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(turies)-317(ago)-316(announcing)-317(himself)-317(as)-316(pre-existing)-317(from)-317(all)-316(eternity,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-348(Son)-349(of)-348(God,)-373(the)-348(maker)-348(of)-349(the)-348(world,)-373(who)-348(had)-348(come)-348(down)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-268(heaven,)-274(and)-268(had)-268(assumed)-269(the)-268(nature)-269(of)-268(man,)-273(in)-269(order)-268(to)-268(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-182(Lamb)-182(of)-182(God)-182(that)-182(taketh)-182(away)-182(the)-182(sins)-182(of)-182(the)-182(world,)-195(and)-182(so)-182(on,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(enumerating)-231(the)-231(other)-231(doctrines)-231(of)-231(Christianity;)-237(Dr.)-244(Mozley)-230(then)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adds,)-371(what)-347(would)-347(be)-346(the)-347(inevitable)-347(conclusion)-347(of)-347(sober)-346(reason)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(respecting)-198(that)-199(person?)-232(The)-198(necessary)-199(conclusion)-198(of)-198(sober)-198(reason)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-315(be)-315(that)-316(he)-315(was)-315(disordered)-315(in)-315(his)-316(understanding....)-445(By)-315(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rational)-401(being)-401(would)-400(a)-401(just)-401(and)-400(a)-401(benevolent)-401(life)-401(be)-400(accepted)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-347(a)-347(proof)-347(of)-346(such)-347(announcements.)-541(Miracles)-347(are)-347(the)-346(necessary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(complements)-342(of)-341(the)-342(truth)-341(of)-342(such)-341(announcements,)-365(which)-341(with-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
333 0 obj <<
/Length 4669      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-6784(67)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(out)-313(them)-313(are)-313(powerless)-313(and)-313(abortive,)-329(the)-313(fragments)-313(of)-313(a)-313(design)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-438(is)-438(nothing)-438(unless)-438(it)-438(is)-438(the)-438(whole.)-814(They)-438(are)-437(necessary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-389(the)-388(justification)-389(of)-388(such)-389(announcements,)-423(which)-389(unless)-388(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-265(supernatural)-265(truth)-265(are)-265(the)-265(wildest)-264(delusions.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 207.299 0 Td [(\035\024)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 15.753 0 Td [(Supernatural)]TJ -223.052 -13.55 Td [(Religion)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 36.971 0 Td [(.)]TJ -25.015 -15.185 Td [(In)-415(justice)-415(to)-415(Dr.)-744(Mozley,)-456(the)-415(passage)-415(which)-415(is)-415(omitted)-414(in)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(this)-498(citation)-498(from)-498(his)-498(lectures)-499(ought)-498(to)-498(be)-498(quoted.)-994(It)-498(is)-498(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(follows:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 40.98 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(What)-364(other)-364(decision)-365(could)-364(be)-364(come)-364(to)-365(when)-364(a)-364(man,)]TJ -45.823 -13.549 Td [(looking)-378(like)-378(one)-377(of)-378(our)-378(own)-378(selves,)-409(and)-378(only)-378(exemplifying)-377(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-367(life)-368(and)-734(circumstances)-368(the)-367(ordinary)-367(course)-368(of)-367(nature,)-396(said)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([072])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(this)-432(about)-432(himself,)-478(but)-432(that)-431(when)-432(reason)-432(had)-432(lost)-432(its)-432(balance)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-383(dream)-383(of)-383(supernatural)-383(and)-383(unearthly,)-416(grandeur)-383(might)-383(be)-383(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(result.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 26.968 0 Td [(\035\024)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 15.752 0 Td [(Bampton)-250(Lectures.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -30.764 -15.185 Td [(Some)-241(expressions)-241(in)-241(this)-240(passage)-241(leave)-241(it)-241(open)-241(to)-241(the)-240(assump-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(tion)-391(which)-392(this)-391(writer)-391(wishes)-392(to)-391(fasten)-391(on)-392(it)-391(that)-391(Dr.)-674(Mozley)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intended)-406(to)-407(affirm)-406(that)-406(the)-407(only)-406(adequate)-406(proof)-407(of)-406(such)-406(affir-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mations)-272(as)-272(were)-273(made)-272(by)-272(Jesus)-272(Christ)-272(respecting)-272(himself)-272(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-442(been)-441(visible)-442(miracles)-442(wrought)-441(in)-442(confirmation)-442(of)-441(them.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This,)-414(however,)-415(is)-381(not)-382(necessarily)-381(its)-382(meaning,)-414(for)-382(the)-381(omitted)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(passage)-401(above)-401(cited,)-438(distinctly)-401(affirms)-400(that)-401(the)-401(person)-401(who)-400(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposed)-306(to)-306(make)-306(such)-306(assertions)-306(is)-306(only)-306(an)-306(ordinary)-306(good)-306(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(holy)-250(but)-250(imperfect)-250(man.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-313(the)-313(assertions)-313(in)-314(question)-313(were)-313(not)-313(made)-313(by)-313(an)-313(ordinary)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(man)-373(like)-372(ourselves,)-403(but)-373(by)-372(one)-373(who)-372(is)-373(described)-372(as)-372(possessed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-292(superhuman)-293(greatness)-292(and)-293(holiness)-292(and)-293(of)-292(profound)-292(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(insight)-402(into)-402(truth.)-705(He)-402(is)-401(uniformly)-402(depicted)-402(as)-402(speaking)-401(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-340(fulness)-341(of)-340(knowledge)-340(of)-340(the)-341(subject)-340(on)-340(which)-340(he)-341(speaks.)-520(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-263(therefore)-263(admit,)-266(supposing)-263(the)-263(character)-263(of)-263(Jesus)-263(to)-262(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-365(historical,)-393(that)-365(if)-365(he)-365(had)-365(made)-365(such)-365(assertions)-364(respecting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(himself)-215(prior)-214(to)-215(the)-215(performance)-214(of)-215(his)-215(first)-214(miracle)-215(at)-215(Cana,)-221(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-321(have)-321(been)-321(utterly)-322(unworthy)-321(of)-321(serious)-321(attention.)-463(It)-321(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-278(readily)-279(admitted)-278(that)-279(if)-278(they)-278(had)-279(been)-278(affirmed)-279(of)-278(himself)-278(by)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(an)-225(ordinary)-225(man)-225(like)-226(ourselves,)-230(no)-225(affirmation)-225(of)-225(his)-225(would)-225(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-345(a)-344(guarantee)-345(of)-344(their)-345(truth,)-368(for)-344(the)-345(simple)-344(reason)-345(that)-344(they)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
337 0 obj <<
/Length 4616      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(68)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(would)-251(have)-251(been)-251(self-contradictory.)-253(Nor)-251(would)-251(the)-251(performance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-328(a)-327(miracle)-328(have)-327(made)-328(t)1(hem)-328(one)-327(atom)-328(more)-327(credible.)-483(But)-327(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(credibility)-353(of)-352(such)-353(an)-352(assertion,)-378(if)-353(it)-353(had)-352(been)-353(made)-352(by)-353(such)-352(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(person)-289(as)-288(Jesus)-289(Christ)-288(even)-289(prior)-288(to)-288(his)-289(performance)-288(of)-289(a)-288(single)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miracle,)-250(is)-250(a)-250(wholly)-250(different)-250(question.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([073])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -14.776 Td [(It)-357(follows,)-383(therefore,)-384(on)-357(the)-357(supposition)-357(that)-357(the)-356(delineation)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(given)-352(us)-353(in)-352(the)-352(Gospels)-353(is)-352(that)-352(of)-353(an)-352(historical)-352(reality,)-378(that)-352(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(assertions)-327(respecting)-327(himself)-327(would)-327(stand)-327(in)-327(a)-327(wholly)-327(different)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(position)-285(from)-286(those)-285(of)-285(any)-285(other)-286(man.)-356(He)-285(could)-285(neither)-285(deceive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nor)-238(be)-237(deceived.)-246(When)-238(he)-238(made)-237(assertions)-238(respecting)-238(himself)-237(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-230(have)-230(known)-230(whether)-230(they)-230(were)-230(true.)-243(The)-230(assertions)-230(of)-230(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-250(person)-250(therefore)-250(would)-250(be)-250(worthy)-250(of)-250(all)-250(acceptation.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(Miracles)-426(are)-427(not)-426(the)-426(means)-427(of)-426(substantiating)-426(assertions)-426(re-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(specting)-285(the)-286(truth)-285(of)-285(unseen)-285(realities,)-294(nor)-286(are)-285(they)-285(used)-285(for)-285(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purposes)-336(in)-336(the)-336(New)-337(Testament.)-508(The)-336(whole)-336(question)-336(is)-336(one)-336(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(adequate)-355(knowledge.)-565(If)-354(we)-355(have)-355(the)-355(means)-355(of)-355(knowing)-355(that)-354(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(person)-268(has)-267(a)-268(complete)-267(acquaintance)-268(with)-267(truths)-268(of)-267(which)-268(we)-267(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ignorant,)-282(we)-275(can)-275(rationally)-275(accept)-275(them)-276(as)-275(true)-275(on)-275(his)-275(assurance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-271(they)-271(are)-271(so,)-277(exactly)-271(on)-271(the)-271(same)-271(principles)-271(as)-271(we)-271(accept)-271(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truths)-279(of)-278(physical)-279(science)-278(although)-279(we)-279(ourselves)-278(are)-279(ignorant)-278(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-276(processes)-276(by)-277(which)-276(they)-276(are)-276(arrived)-276(at.)-329(To)-276(state)-276(the)-276(position)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(generally,)-322(it)-307(is)-308(quite)-307(rational)-308(to)-307(accept)-308(the)-307(affirmations)-308(of)-307(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-190(possess)-189(full)-190(knowledge)-189(of)-190(any)-189(subject)-190(of)-189(which)-190(we)-189(ourselves)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-367(profoundly)-366(ignorant.)-600(The)-367(only)-367(thing)-366(necessary)-367(is)-367(to)-366(attain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-267(assurance)-268(that)-267(the)-268(knowledge)-267(of)-268(our)-267(informant)-268(is)-267(adequate)-267(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(justify)-363(his)-364(assertions.)-590(It)-363(is)-363(on)-364(the)-363(ground)-363(of)-364(the)-363(fulness)-363(of)-363(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(knowledge)-259(that)-258(we)-259(accept)-259(the)-259(assertions)-258(of)-259(Jesus)-259(Christ,)-261(and)-258(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(because)-243(he)-243(wrought)-243(a)-244(miracle)-243(for)-243(the)-243(purpose)-243(of)-243(proving)-243(that)-243(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assertions)-250(were)-250(true.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(Let)-261(us)-261(now)-262(consider)-261(in)-261(what)-261(sense)-261(miracles)-262(are)-261(a)-261(proof)-261(of)-261(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(truth)-250(of)-250(a)-250(divine)-250(revelation.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(I)-275(lay)-274(down)-275(that)-274(the)-275(proper)-275(function)-274(of)-275(miracles)-274(is)-275(to)-274(establish)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(the)-238(truth)-238(of)-238(a)-238(divine)-238(commission.)-246(From)-238(this)-238(we)-238(argue)-238(to)-238(the)-238(truth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(assertions)-250(of)-250(the)-250(persons)-250(who)-250(are)-250(intrusted)-250(with)-250(it.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([074])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
342 0 obj <<
/Length 5034      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-6784(69)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(If)-323(an)-323(ordinary)-323(man,)-341(such)-323(as)-323(a)-323(prophet)-323(or)-323(an)-323(apostle,)-341(were)-323(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-406(that)-407(he)-406(had)-406(a)-406(communication)-406(from)-407(God)-406(which)-406(he)-406(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(directed)-242(to)-242(make)-242(to)-241(others,)-244(or)-242(in)-241(other)-242(words)-242(that)-242(he)-242(had)-242(a)-241(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(commission,)-269(it)-265(is)-265(evident)-265(that)-265(no)-265(one)-265(would)-265(be)-265(bound)-265(to)-265(believe)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(him)-182(on)-182(his)-182(mere)-182(affirmation.)-227(The)-182(simple)-182(and)-182(obvious)-182(reply)-182(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be,)-317(Give)-303(us)-303(some)-303(proof)-304(of)-303(the)-303(reality)-304(of)-303(the)-303(fact.)-410(Your)-303(claim)-303(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(far)-286(too)-286(lofty)-285(to)-286(be)-286(admitted)-286(as)-285(valid)-286(on)-286(your)-286(simple)-285(affirmation.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-323(question)-323(then)-324(is,)-341(how)-323(is)-324(such)-323(a)-323(claim)-323(to)-323(be)-324(tested?)-469(I)-323(reply)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-384(the)-384(person)-384(who)-383(makes)-384(it)-384(performing)-384(some)-384(action)-384(which)-383(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(adequate)-190(to)-190(prove)-190(that)-189(the)-190(Great)-190(Governor)-190(of)-190(the)-190(Universe)-189(ratifies)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-266(claim.)-300(He)-266(must)-267(do)-266(something)-267(analogous)-266(to)-267(what)-266(all)-266(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-324(claim)-323(to)-324(be)-323(acting)-324(under)-324(commissions)-323(from)-324(others)-323(do,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 267.299 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -267.299 -13.549 Td [(he)-402(must)-402(produce)-402(some)-402(direct)-402(and)-402(formal)-402(credentials)-402(from)-402(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authority)-280(in)-280(whose)-281(name)-280(he)-280(claims)-280(to)-280(be)-280(acting.)-341(In)-280(this)-280(case)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(authority)-276(is)-276(God.)-327(He)-276(must)-276(therefore)-276(perform)-276(some)-276(action)-275(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(directly)-250(identifies)-250(himself)-250(with)-250(God.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(How)-246(is)-247(this)-247(to)-246(be)-247(accomplished?)-248(I)-247(answer)-246(by)-247(the)-246(performance)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-285(an)-284(unequivocal)-285(miracle)-284(which)-285(will)-285(directly)-284(connect)-285(him)-284(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-294(Great)-294(Governor)-293(of)-294(the)-294(Universe.)-381(I)-294(say)-294(unequivocal)-293(miracle,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(because)-233(if)-233(there)-234(were)-233(any)-233(doubt)-233(as)-234(to)-233(its)-233(supernatural)-233(character)-233(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(would)-290(be)-291(useless.)-371(Nor)-290(would)-291(it)-290(be)-291(of)-290(any)-290(avail)-291(if)-290(it)-291(were)-290(a)-290(bare)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(objective)-225(fact)-225(in)-225(external)-226(nature,)-230(devoid)-225(of)-225(its)-225(moral)-225(and)-225(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(environment.)-527(What)-342(is)-342(required)-342(is)-343(some)-342(direct)-342(manifestation)-342(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-239(divine)-239(on)-239(the)-239(sphere)-239(of)-239(the)-239(human)-239(and)-239(the)-239(natural.)-246(It)-239(must,)-241(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact,)-295(exactly)-286(fulfil)-286(the)-286(character)-286(so)-286(often)-286(assigned)-286(to)-286(miracles)-286(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-283(Gospels.)-347(It)-282(must)-283(be)-282(a)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 113.432 0 Td [(\303\267\274\265)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 21.502 0 Td [(\326)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\277\275)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.963 0 Td [(,)-291(or)-282(indication)-283(of)-282(the)-283(presence)]TJ -149.104 -13.549 Td [(of)-271(God,)-276(resembling)-271(as)-271(it)-271(were)-271(the)-271(Great)-271(Seal)-271(which)-271(is)-271(affixed)-271(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(state)-212(documents)-212(as)-212(the)-212(final)-212(mark)-212(of)-212(sovereign)-212(authority.)-237(Of)-212(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-250(character)-250(are)-250(all)-250(the)-250(chief)-250(miracles)-250(recorded)-250(in)-250(the)-250(Gospels.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([075])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -16.004 Td [(The)-194(question)-193(about)-194(miracles)-194(has)-194(been)-193(beclouded)-194(by)-194(debating)-193(it)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-227(an)-226(abstract)-227(instead)-227(of)-227(in)-226(a)-227(concrete)-227(form;)-234(thus)-227(forgetting)-227(that)-226(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-224(not)-223(every)-224(conceivable)-223(form)-224(of)-223(alleged)-224(supernatural)-223(occurrence)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-206(which)-206(we)-206(have)-206(to)-206(deal,)-215(but)-206(the)-206(miracles)-206(recorded)-206(in)-205(the)-206(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament.)-404(By)-302(discussing)-301(it)-302(in)-301(this)-301(form)-302(it)-301(has)-302(been)-301(possible)-301(to)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
347 0 obj <<
/Length 4559      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(70)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(raise)-384(a)-383(number)-384(of)-383(difficulties)-384(which)-384(may)-383(be)-384(abstractedly)-383(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ceivable,)-248(but)-248(which)-248(have)-248(no)-248(bearing)-248(whatever)-248(on)-248(the)-248(miracles)-248(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question.)-392(Thus)-298(it)-297(has)-298(been)-297(frequently)-297(urged)-298(that)-297(to)-298(enable)-297(us)-297(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-362(certain)-362(that)-362(an)-362(alleged)-362(miracle)-362(is)-362(really)-362(due)-362(to)-361(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(agency,)-317(a)-304(jury)-303(of)-304(savants)-303(ought)-304(to)-303(be)-304(impanelled,)-317(before)-303(whom)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-334(worker)-334(of)-334(the)-334(miracle)-334(should)-334(exhibit)-334(his)-334(miraculous)-334(opera-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion.)-418(They)-306(are)-306(to)-305(subject)-306(it)-306(to)-306(a)-306(variety)-306(of)-306(scientific)-306(tests.)-417(Even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-317(if)-316(they)-316(have)-317(failed)-316(to)-317(discover)-316(error,)-334(they)-316(are)-316(to)-317(demand)-316(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(second)-369(and)-370(a)-369(third)-369(performance,)-399(in)-369(order)-370(that)-369(it)-369(may)-369(be)-369(again)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-349(again)-350(submitted)-349(to)-350(the)-349(same)-349(process)-350(of)-349(scientific)-349(scrutiny.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Until)-329(miracles)-328(can)-329(be)-329(submitted)-328(to)-329(and)-329(verified)-328(by)-329(tests)-329(of)-328(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(description)-381(they)-380(have)-381(been)-380(affirmed)-380(to)-381(be)-380(unworthy)-381(of)-380(credit,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-250(on)-250(the)-250(strongest)-250(ordinary)-250(testimony.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-385(shall)-385(discuss)-385(this)-385(and)-386(kindred)-385(questions)-385(more)-385(fully)-385(in)-385(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(subsequent)-317(portions)-316(of)-317(this)-317(volume,)-333(when)-317(I)-316(consider)-317(the)-316(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-329(the)-329(evidence)-328(which)-329(is)-329(adequate)-328(to)-329(prove)-329(the)-329(performance)-328(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-379(miracle.)-636(For)-379(the)-378(present)-379(I)-379(shall)-379(only)-378(observe)-379(that)-379(the)-378(entire)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(plausibility)-428(of)-428(this)-428(position)-428(arises)-428(from)-428(its)-428(being)-428(stated)-428(in)-427(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(abstract)-295(or)-295(general)-295(form.)-384(We)-295(cannot)-295(help)-295(seeing)-295(in)-295(reference)-294(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-340(chief)-341(miracles)-340(recorded)-340(in)-340(the)-341(New)-340(Testament,)-363(such)-340(as)-340(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(care)-216(of)-216(blind,)-223(lame)-216(or)-216(leprous)-216(persons,)-223(instantaneously)-215(by)-216(a)-216(word)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-220(a)-219(touch,)-226(that)-220(common)-219(sense)-220(is)-220(fully)-219(adequate)-220(to)-220(determine)-219(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(such)-279(occurrences)-278(must)-279(belong)-278(to)-279(the)-279(regions)-278(of)-279(the)-278(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(to)-250(no)-250(other.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([076])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -15.186 Td [(Two)-219(things)-219(are)-219(necessary)-218(to)-219(establish)-219(the)-219(reality)-219(of)-219(a)-218(supposed)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(miracle.)-564(First,)-381(that)-355(the)-355(alleged)-355(fact)-354(should)-355(not)-355(only)-355(have)-354(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(brought)-287(about)-286(by)-287(supernatural)-287(causes)-286(but)-287(previously)-286(announced)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-194(him)-194(who)-194(performs)-194(it:)-222(secondly,)-205(that)-194(the)-194(fact)-194(actually)-193(happened)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-250(it)-250(appeared)-250(to)-250(happen.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(There)-290(can)-290(be)-289(no)-290(doubt)-290(that)-290(the)-289(power)-290(of)-290(juggling)-290(and)-289(sleight)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-245(hand,)-246(to)-245(perform)-245(actions)-245(which)-245(would)-245(be)-245(supernatural,)-246(if)-244(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-273(only)-272(what)-272(they)-273(appear)-272(to)-273(be,)-278(is)-272(considerable,)-279(and)-272(the)-272(diffi-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(culty)-214(of)-214(detection)-214(is)-215(great.)-238(Enthusiasm)-214(also)-214(when)-214(once)-214(excited,)-221(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(capable)-199(of)-200(generating)-199(various)-199(unreal)-200(appearances)-199(which)-199(if)-199(actual,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
351 0 obj <<
/Length 4577      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-6784(71)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(would)-299(be)-299(supernatural.)-397(It)-299(is)-299(also)-299(mighty)-299(in)-299(those)-299(regions)-299(where)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-389(union)-389(takes)-389(place)-389(between)-388(mind)-389(and)-389(matter,)-424(but)-389(the)-388(chief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-229(recorded)-228(in)-229(the)-228(Gospels)-229(belong)-228(to)-229(a)-228(wholly)-229(different)-228(or-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(der)-241(of)-241(occurrence.)-247(If)-241(they)-241(took)-241(place)-241(as)-241(they)-241(are)-242(reported,)-242(no)-241(one)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(possessed)-312(of)-312(common)-312(sense)-311(can)-312(doubt)-312(as)-312(to)-312(whether)-312(they)-311(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(due)-272(to)-272(supernatural)-272(agency.)-316(It)-272(is)-272(no)-272(less)-272(clear)-272(that)-272(such)-271(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-219(occurrences)-220(in)-219(which)-219(successful)-220(imposture)-219(was)-219(impossible.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(What)-210(is)-210(required)-211(to)-210(prove)-210(them)-210(is)-211(the)-210(evidence)-210(of)-210(common)-210(sense,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-254(not)-254(of)-254(scientific)-254(analysis.)-262(Let)-254(it)-254(be)-254(observed)-254(that)-254(it)-254(is)-254(not)-253(my)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(intention)-198(to)-199(affirm)-198(that)-198(the)-198(whole)-199(of)-198(the)-198(supernaturalism)-198(recorded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)-250(is)-250(of)-250(the)-250(same)-250(unequivocal)-250(character.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(The)-280(evidential)-280(value)-280(of)-280(a)-280(miracle)-280(viewed)-280(as)-280(a)-280(matter)-280(of)-279(com-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(mon)-229(sense)-229(maybe)-229(briefly)-229(stated)-229(thus.)-243(A)-229(person)-229(comes)-229(to)-229(me)-229(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirms)-276(that)-276(he)-276(has)-276(a)-277(divine)-276(message)-276(to)-276(communicate.)-328(I)-276(ask)-276(him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-304(prove)-304(it.)-413(He)-304(lays)-304(his)-304(hand)-304(on)-305(one)-304(whom)-304(I)-304(have)-304(known)-304(to)-304(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(blind)-371(for)-370(the)-371(last)-370(twenty)-371(years,)-400(tells)-371(him)-370(in)-371(the)-370(name)-371(of)-370(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ)-350(to)-351(receive)-350(his)-350(sight,)-376(and)-350(he)-350(forthwith)-350(receives)-351(it.)-550(There)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-328(probably)-327(no)-328(person)-328(gifted)-328(with)-327(ordinary)-328(understanding)-655(who)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([077])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(would)-241(not)-242(consider)-241(such)-242(an)-241(act)-241(to)-242(be)-241(an)-241(adequate)-242(proof)-241(of)-241(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agency,)-214(all)-204(theoretical)-205(or)-205(metaphysical)-204(difficulties)-205(to)-205(the)-204(contrary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(notwithstanding.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(It)-214(will)-214(doubtless)-214(be)-214(objected)-214(that)-214(such)-214(an)-214(act)-214(would)-214(prove)-214(only)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-350(presence)-350(of)-351(a)-350(superhuman)-350(instead)-350(of)-350(a)-351(divine)-350(power.)-550(This)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(point)-266(will)-266(be)-265(fully)-266(considered)-266(hereafter.)-297(For)-266(my)-266(present)-265(purpose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-216(will)-215(be)-216(sufficient)-216(to)-216(fall)-215(back)-216(on)-216(the)-215(decision)-216(of)-216(common)-215(sense,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-211(he)-210(who)-210(can)-211(restore)-210(sight)-211(to)-210(the)-211(sightless)-210(eye-ball,)-219(by)-210(no)-210(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apparent)-261(instrumentality)-260(than)-261(a)-260(word)-261(or)-260(a)-261(touch,)-263(can)-260(be)-261(no)-260(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-250(the)-250(Maker)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Universe.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(I)-432(must)-432(now)-432(consider)-432(whether)-432(supernatural)-432(occurrences)-432(de-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(void)-329(of)-330(all)-329(moral)-329(environment,)-349(are)-329(capable)-330(of)-329(proving)-329(a)-329(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(commission.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(It)-379(has)-380(frequently)-379(been)-380(the)-379(habit,)-412(both)-379(of)-380(the)-379(opponents)-379(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(the)-345(defenders)-346(of)-345(Christianity,)-369(to)-346(discuss)-345(the)-345(subject)-346(of)-345(the)-345(evi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dential)-301(value)-301(of)-301(miracles)-301(apart)-301(from)-301(all)-301(reference)-301(to)-301(their)-300(moral)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
355 0 obj <<
/Length 4549      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(72)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(environment.)-620(As,)-405(however,)-404(the)-373(overwhelming)-374(majority)-373(of)-373(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-341(recorded)-340(in)-341(the)-340(New)-340(Testament)-341(profess)-340(such)-341(an)-340(envi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ronment,)-341(the)-323(question)-322(of)-323(the)-323(value)-322(of)-323(supposed)-323(miracles)-322(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-432(destitute)-432(of)-432(it,)-477(forms)-432(no)-432(legitimate)-432(portion)-432(of)-432(the)-432(subject)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(before)-362(us.)-584(What)-362(might)-361(or)-362(might)-361(not)-362(be)-361(proved)-362(by)-361(them,)-389(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-389(it)-388(could)-389(be)-389(determined)-388(satisfactorily,)-424(is)-388(quite)-389(foreign)-389(to)-388(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(present)-302(discussion,)-315(which)-302(is)-301(limited)-302(to)-302(the)-302(truth)-302(or)-302(falsehood)-301(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-336(contained)-337(in)-336(the)-336(New)-337(Testament.)-509(The)-336(most)-336(important)-336(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-214(are)-214(not)-214(mere)-214(displays)-214(of)-214(power,)-221(but)-214(have)-214(an)-213(unquestionable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(moral)-395(environment)-396(impressed)-395(upon)-396(them,)-431(and)-396(they)-395(profess)-395(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-323(been)-323(wrought)-324(for)-323(a)-323(definite)-323(end)-323(and)-324(purpose.)-469(This)-323(is)-323(less)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinctly)-367(marked)-368(in)-367(some)-367(of)-367(the)-367(miracles)-368(recorded)-367(in)-367(the)-367(Old)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament,)-460(but)-419(with)-418(them)-418(I)-418(have)-419(no)-418(present)-418(concern.)-755(It)-418(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-294(sufficient)-293(to)-294(observe)-293(that)-294(while)-294(many)-293(of)-294(them)-587(were)-293(unques-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([078])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(tionably)-302(performed)-302(in)-302(attestation)-302(of)-302(a)-302(divine)-302(mission,)-315(as)-302(a)-301(class)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-283(bear)-283(another)-282(distinctive)-283(purpose,)-291(viz.)-348(that)-283(of)-283(correcting)-282(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(polytheistic)-224(tendencies)-224(of)-224(the)-225(age.)-241(Hence)-224(their)-224(leading)-224(impress)-224(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-204(of)-205(power.)-234(The)-205(necessity)-204(of)-204(counteracting)-205(the)-204(tendency)-204(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-347(have)-347(referred)-348(to,)-371(rendered)-347(it)-348(necessary)-347(emphatically)-347(to)-347(assert)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-291(Lordship)-291(of)-291(one)-291(God)-292(over)-291(universal)-291(nature,)-301(in)-291(opposition)-291(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-340(conception)-340(of)-340(it)-340(so)-340(widely)-340(diffused)-340(throughout)-340(the)-340(ancient)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(world,)-258(which)-257(saw)-257(a)-257(distinct)-256(power)-257(exerted)-257(in)-257(every)-256(combination)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(material)-250(forces.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(The)-197(very)-198(conception)-197(of)-198(a)-197(miracle)-197(as)-198(a)-197(supernatural)-197(occurrence,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(brought)-238(about)-238(for)-238(the)-238(purpose)-239(of)-238(authenticating)-238(a)-238(revelation,)-240(dis-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tinguishes)-234(such)-234(an)-233(action)-234(from)-234(one)-233(which)-234(involves)-234(only)-234(a)-233(simple)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exhibition)-396(of)-396(power.)-689(All)-396(acts)-396(of)-397(moral)-396(agents)-396(must)-396(display)-396(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(purpose)-302(of)-301(some)-302(kind.)-405(No)-302(conception)-301(of)-302(God)-302(is)-301(of)-302(the)-301(smallest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(religious)-223(value)-223(which)-222(does)-223(not)-223(contemplate)-222(him)-223(as)-223(being)-223(a)-222(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agent)-334(and)-334(a)-334(being)-335(on)-334(whose)-334(actions)-334(a)-334(moral)-334(character)-334(of)-334(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(kind)-387(must)-386(be)-387(impressed.)-659(Consequently)-387(an)-386(act)-387(entirely)-386(devoid)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-304(all)-303(moral)-304(aspect)-304(cannot)-303(prove)-304(that)-304(it)-303(has)-304(resulted)-304(from)-303(direct)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(divine)-300(intervention.)-399(The)-300(difficulty)-300(has)-300(originated)-300(from)-299(dividing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-308(three)-307(separate)-308(parts)-307(an)-308(action)-308(which)-307(is)-308(essentially)-307(one,)-322(and)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
359 0 obj <<
/Length 4422      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-6784(73)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(contemplating)-374(separately)-374(the)-374(objective)-374(fact)-374(in)-374(the)-374(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action,)-233(the)-229(circumstances)-230(attending)-229(its)-229(performance,)-233(and)-229(the)-229(pur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pose)-201(for)-201(which)-201(it)-201(was)-201(performed.)-234(It)-201(is)-201(the)-201(union)-201(of)-201(all)-200(these)-201(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(constitutes)-250(the)-250(occurrence)-250(in)-250(question)-250(an)-250(evidential)-250(miracle.)]TJ 11.956 -14.532 Td [(Let)-204(me)-204(now)-204(offer)-204(a)-204(few)-204(observations)-204(on)-204(a)-204(very)-204(important)-204(point)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(for)-240(our)-239(consideration.)-247(Can)-239(abstract)-240(doctrinal)-239(statements)-240(or)-239(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truths)-250(be)-250(proved)-250(by)-250(miracles?)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([079])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -14.531 Td [(I)-252(have)-252(already)-252(observed)-252(that)-253(as)-252(far)-252(as)-252(the)-252(miracles)-252(of)-252(the)-252(New)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-366(were)-366(wrought)-366(for)-366(directly)-366(evidential)-366(purposes,)-394(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-429(performed,)-474(not)-429(to)-430(prove)-429(particular)-429(doctrines,)-474(but)-429(as)-429(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(credentials)-271(of)-271(a)-271(divine)-271(mission,)-276(or)-271(that)-271(they)-271(formed)-271(a)-271(part)-271(of)-270(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(superhuman)-251(manifestation)-251(of)-251(our)-250(Lord.)-253(The)-251(apparent)-250(exceptions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-256(those)-257(which)-256(were)-256(performed)-257(to)-256(attract)-256(attention)-257(to)-256(the)-256(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(message,)-411(to)-378(assist)-379(in)-378(the)-379(foundation)-378(of)-378(the)-379(Church,)-411(or)-378(to)-378(bear)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(witness)-452(to)-452(the)-452(truth)-452(of)-451(the)-452(Resurrection.)-856(These)-452(last)-452(were)-451(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fact)-245(attestations)-246(to)-245(the)-245(reality)-245(of)-245(the)-246(Messianic)-245(character)-245(of)-245(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ,)-205(which)-194(is)-193(the)-194(highest)-194(conceivable)-194(form)-193(of)-194(a)-194(divine)-193(mission,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-273(which)-272(miracle)-273(the)-273(truth)-272(of)-273(Christianity)-273(is)-272(directly)-273(pledged)-272(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-383(sacred)-383(writers.)-650(A)-383(mere)-383(statement)-383(of)-384(the)-383(facts)-383(of)-383(the)-383(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-382(is)-382(a)-382(practical)-381(solution)-382(of)-382(the)-382(difficulty.)-646(It)-381(nowhere)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(affirms)-269(that)-268(a)-269(miracle)-268(was)-269(ever)-268(performed)-268(to)-269(bear)-268(witness)-269(to)-268(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth)-250(of)-250(an)-250(abstract)-250(doctrine.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(I)-280(will)-280(now)-280(endeavour)-280(to)-280(lay)-280(down)-280(some)-280(general)-280(principles)-279(as)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-340(the)-340(relation)-340(in)-340(which)-340(doctrinal)-340(statements)-340(stand)-340(to)-340(supernat-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ural)-331(manifestations.)-494(As)-331(on)-332(such)-331(a)-331(subject)-332(it)-331(will)-331(be)-331(impossible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-410(lay)-410(down)-409(a)-410(general)-410(rule)-410(which)-409(will)-410(be)-410(applicable)-410(to)-409(every)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supernatural)-270(event,)-275(it)-270(will)-269(be)-270(necessary)-270(to)-270(consider)-270(each)-270(case)-269(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(itself.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(First,)-250(that)-250(of)-250(our)-250(Lord.)]TJ 0 -14.531 Td [(We)-525(believe)-525(his)-525(statements)-525(about)-525(unknown)-526(truths,)-593(on)-525(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ground)-242(that)-243(he)-242(was)-243(perfectly)-242(veracious,)-244(and)-242(had)-243(the)-242(most)-242(perfect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowledge)-262(of)-262(the)-262(subject)-263(on)-262(which)-262(he)-262(spoke.)-286(The)-262(actions)-262(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(he)-425(performed)-426(\050I)-425(mean)-425(by)-425(these,)-469(not)-426(his)-425(miracles)-425(merely,)-469(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-429(entire)-428(course)-429(of)-428(his)-429(working\051)-428(are)-429(evidences)-428(of)-429(his)-428(divine)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
363 0 obj <<
/Length 4924      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(74)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(character.)-373(He)-291(himself)-291(avers)-291(that)-291(he)-291(possessed)-291(the)-291(most)-291(intimate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowledge)-409(of)-408(God,)-449(and)-408(of)-409(the)-408(great)-409(realities)-409(of)-408(the)-817(spiritual)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([080])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(world.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 37.18 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(We)-442(speak,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 47.527 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.663 0 Td [(says)-442(he,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 41.971 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(that)-442(we)-441(do)-442(know,)-490(and)-441(testify)]TJ -146.029 -13.549 Td [(that)-387(we)-388(have)-387(seen.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 84.469 0 Td [(\035)-387(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.912 0 Td [(I)-387(speak)-387(that)-388(which)-387(I)-387(have)-388(seen)-387(with)-387(my)]TJ -98.381 -13.55 Td [(Father.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30.6 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.845 0 Td [(Throughout)-275(the)-275(Synoptics)-275(likewise)-275(he)-275(is)-275(represented)-275(as)]TJ -38.445 -13.549 Td [(having)-389(the)-390(most)-389(entire)-390(knowledge)-389(of)-389(both)-390(spiritual)-389(and)-389(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth,)-358(and)-337(as)-337(teaching)-336(direct)-337(from)-337(his)-336(own)-337(insight.)-510(We)-336(believe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-324(assertions,)-342(not)-324(because)-324(he)-324(confirmed)-324(their)-324(truth)-324(by)-324(the)-323(per-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(formance)-265(of)-264(a)-265(miracle,)-268(but)-265(because)-265(he)-264(afforded)-265(evidence)-265(that)-264(he)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-347(a)-347(veracious)-346(witness,)-371(and)-347(fully)-347(acquainted)-347(with)-347(the)-346(subject)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-318(which)-317(he)-318(spoke.)-453(His)-317(miraculous)-318(actions)-318(proved)-317(that)-318(he)-317(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God's)-273(messenger,)-279(and)-273(as)-274(such)-273(were)-273(additional)-273(attestations)-273(to)-273(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(veracity.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-280(acceptance)-281(of)-280(such)-281(affirmations)-280(as)-280(worthy)-281(of)-280(the)-280(highest)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(credit)-398(may)-398(be)-398(correctly)-398(designated)-398(as)-398(acts)-398(of)-398(faith;)-472(but)-398(let)-397(us)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(never)-405(forget)-405(that)-405(such)-404(acts)-405(of)-405(faith)-405(are)-405(also)-405(high)-405(exercises)-404(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason.)-239(Writers)-218(in)-217(opposition)-217(to)-218(Christianity)-217(are)-218(never)-217(wearied)-217(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(running)-263(a)-263(contrast)-263(between)-263(reason)-263(and)-263(faith,)-266(and)-263(in)-262(representing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-340(two)-340(as)-339(standing)-340(in)-340(opposition)-340(to)-340(each)-339(other,)-363(and)-339(belonging)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-272(wholly)-272(different)-271(regions)-272(of)-272(thought.)-315(Nor)-272(can)-272(it)-272(be)-272(denied)-271(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-267(have)-268(received)-267(much)-267(encouragement)-268(to)-267(do)-267(this)-268(by)-267(the)-267(indis-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tinct)-321(or)-322(misleading)-321(statements)-322(of)-321(some)-321(Christian)-322(writers)-321(on)-321(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subject.)-510(Between)-337(them)-336(no)-337(little)-337(confusion)-336(has)-337(been)-336(introduced)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-365(the)-365(controversy,)-394(and)-365(a)-365(general)-365(idea)-365(has)-365(become)-365(prevalent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-321(reason)-321(and)-321(faith)-321(are)-321(two)-321(distinct,)-339(if)-321(not)-320(opposing)-321(faculties,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(each)-257(of)-256(which)-257(acts)-256(within)-257(a)-256(subject)-257(matter)-256(of)-257(its)-256(own.)-270(The)-256(effect)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-250(this)-250(confusion)-250(has)-250(been)-250(disastrous.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(My)-363(contention)-363(is)-363(that)-364(faith)-363(is)-363(only)-363(another)-363(name)-363(for)-363(reason)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(when)-387(operating)-387(on)-387(a)-388(particular)-387(class)-387(of)-387(phenomena.)-661(To)-387(enter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-310(an)-311(elaborate)-310(proof)-310(of)-311(this)-310(would)-310(be)-311(out)-310(of)-310(place)-311(here;)-340(a)-310(few)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(illustrations)-262(must)-262(therefore)-262(suffice.)-573(To)-262(accept)-262(information)-262(from)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([081])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(persons)-427(who)-426(have)-427(knowledge)-427(of)-427(subjects)-426(which)-427(we)-427(have)-426(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(studied,)-322(or)-307(who)-308(have)-307(mental)-308(powers)-307(of)-308(insight)-307(or)-308(perception)-307(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-281(we)-280(are)-281(destitute,)-288(or)-281(who)-281(have)-280(seen)-281(phenomena)-281(which)-280(we)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
368 0 obj <<
/Length 4662      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-6784(75)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(have)-246(not)-245(seen,)-247(is)-245(an)-246(act)-245(in)-246(conformity)-245(with)-246(our)-245(highest)-246(reason.)-248(A)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(constant)-310(effort)-309(has)-310(been)-309(made)-309(by)-310(unbelievers)-309(to)-310(confound)-309(faith)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-268(credulity:)-285(Faith)-268(is)-268(not)-267(credulity,)-273(but)-267(the)-268(acceptance)-268(of)-267(truth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-446(adequate)-447(evidence,)-495(and)-447(the)-446(rejection)-447(of)-446(mere)-446(affirmation,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(when)-306(the)-306(evidence)-306(is)-307(inadequate.)-418(On)-306(the)-306(other)-306(hand)-306(multitudes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-346(Christians)-347(have)-346(assiduously)-347(laboured)-346(to)-346(decry)-347(reason)-346(as)-346(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instrument)-312(for)-311(the)-312(investigation)-312(of)-311(truth.)-435(I)-312(admit)-312(that)-311(it)-312(is)-312(not)-311(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(perfect)-357(instrument,)-385(but)-357(it)-357(is)-358(the)-357(only)-357(one)-358(which)-357(we)-357(have.)-572(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(light)-261(of)-262(a)-261(candle)-262(may)-261(not)-261(be)-262(all)-261(that)-261(we)-262(can)-261(wish,)-264(but)-262(if)-261(we)-261(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(no)-250(other)-250(we)-250(shall)-250(not)-250(improve)-250(our)-250(condition)-250(by)-250(extinguishing)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Let)-296(me)-296(illustrate)-295(this)-296(subject)-296(by)-296(a)-296(few)-295(examples.)-388(We)-295(believe)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-374(assertions)-375(of)-374(Dr.)-623(Livingstone)-374(about)-375(the)-374(interior)-374(of)-374(Africa,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(although)-312(we)-312(have)-312(no)-311(means)-312(of)-312(verifying)-312(them)-312(by)-312(ocular)-311(obser-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(vation,)-284(because)-278(we)-277(know)-278(that)-277(he)-277(has)-278(travelled)-277(there,)-285(and)-277(we)-277(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(persuaded)-318(that)-318(he)-318(is)-318(a)-317(veracious)-318(witness.)-454(We)-318(accept)-318(the)-317(higher)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(truths)-341(of)-340(astronomy,)-364(not)-340(because)-341(we)-340(have)-341(studied)-341(them,)-363(or)-340(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-228(able)-228(to)-228(appreciate)-229(the)-228(nature)-228(of)-228(the)-228(processes)-228(by)-228(which)-228(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-324(been)-324(arrived)-325(at,)-342(but)-325(because)-324(they)-324(are)-324(affirmed)-324(by)-324(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-379(have)-378(afforded)-379(evidence)-379(that)-378(they)-379(possess)-379(a)-378(high)-379(order)-378(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowledge)-182(on)-182(that)-182(subject.)-228(The)-182(same)-182(is)-182(true)-182(throughout)-182(the)-182(whole)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-269(the)-268(higher)-268(departments)-269(of)-268(science.)-306(We)-268(may)-269(call)-268(this)-269(an)-268(act)-268(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(faith)-229(if)-229(we)-228(like,)-233(but)-229(it)-229(is)-229(also)-229(an)-229(act)-228(of)-229(our)-229(reason.)-243(The)-229(same)-228(thing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-311(true)-311(throughout)-311(every)-312(department)-311(of)-311(human)-311(knowledge.)-433(It)-311(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(astonishing)-193(how)-192(small)-193(a)-193(part)-192(of)-193(it)-193(is)-192(the)-193(result)-193(of)-192(our)-193(own)-192(personal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(observation.)-676(It)-392(follows)-392(therefore)-392(that)-392(the)-392(attempts)-784(which)-392(are)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([082])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(so)-295(constantly)-295(made)-296(to)-295(separate)-295(faith)-295(and)-295(reason,)-307(and)-295(to)-295(erect)-295(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impassable)-365(wall)-365(between)-364(them,)-394(are)-364(suicidal)-365(alike)-365(both)-365(to)-364(faith)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(reason.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(As)-287(therefore)-286(we)-287(accept)-286(the)-287(affirmations)-287(of)-286(others)-287(on)-286(subjects)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(within)-244(the)-244(limits)-244(of)-245(their)-244(own)-244(knowledge,)-245(although)-244(we)-244(ourselves)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-387(ignorant)-387(of)-387(the)-388(processes)-387(by)-387(which)-387(it)-387(has)-387(been)-387(arrived)-387(at,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-353(we)-352(accept)-353(the)-352(affirmations)-353(of)-352(such)-353(a)-352(person)-353(as)-352(the)-353(Jesus)-352(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-384(Evangelists)-384(on)-384(those)-383(subjects)-384(on)-384(which)-384(he)-384(affirms)-384(that)-383(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possesses)-250(the)-250(fullest)-250(knowledge.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
373 0 obj <<
/Length 4908      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(76)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(But)-508(it)-507(will)-508(be)-507(objected)-508(that)-507(some)-508(of)-507(these)-508(assertions)-507(are)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(made)-287(respecting)-286(high)-287(mysteri)1(es)-287(incomprehensible)-286(to)-287(the)-286(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intellect.)-250(Can)-250(we)-250(accept)-250(such)-250(truths?)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(I)-348(answer)-348(that)-349(we)-348(are)-348(only)-349(capable)-348(of)-348(accepting)-348(propositions)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-255(two)-256(terms)-255(of)-255(which)-255(we)-256(are)-255(able)-255(to)-256(comprehend)-255(with)-255(more)-255(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(less)-306(distinctness.)-419(Nothing)-306(has)-306(been)-306(the)-306(subject)-306(of)-306(greater)-306(abuse)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(than)-422(the)-422(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 68.353 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(mystery)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 35.149 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.449 0 Td [(in)-422(connection)-422(with)-423(revelation.)-766(It)-423(is)]TJ -117.795 -13.549 Td [(frequently)-237(represented)-237(as)-237(denoting)-237(something)-237(which)-237(from)-237(end)-236(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(end)-335(is)-334(utterly)-335(incomprehensible,)-356(like)-335(the)-334(unknowable)-335(God)-335(of)-334(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-211(system)-210(of)-211(philosophy.)-237(In)-211(the)-210(New)-211(Testament)-211(the)-210(meaning)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-337(the)-338(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 55.88 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(mystery)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 35.15 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.524 0 Td [(is)-337(not)-338(an)-337(incomprehensible)-338(proposition,)]TJ -104.397 -13.55 Td [(but)-210(a)-211(truth)-210(which)-211(once)-210(was)-211(hidden)-210(in)-211(the)-210(divine)-211(counsels,)-218(and)-210(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-256(revealed)-255(by)-256(the)-256(Gospel.)-267(That)-255(which)-256(is)-256(actually)-255(unthinkable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-342(incapable)-341(of)-342(affirmation)-341(or)-342(denial.)-525(None)-341(of)-342(the)-341(affirmations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-417(Jesus)-418(Christ)-417(partake)-418(of)-417(this)-417(character.)-753(They)-417(are)-417(mysteries)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-283(in)-283(the)-282(sense)-283(that)-283(they)-283(ran)-283(up)-282(into)-283(spheres)-283(of)-283(thought)-282(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(transcend)-350(the)-350(limits)-349(of)-350(human)-350(knowledge.)-549(But)-350(this)-350(is)-350(done)-349(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-248(ultimate)-247(philosophical)-247(and)-248(scientific)-247(truths.)-250(If)-247(it)-248(be)-247(urged)-247(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(some)-340(of)-340(them)-340(are)-340(difficult)-340(or)-341(incapable)-340(of)-340(definition,)-362(the)-340(same)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-290(true)-291(of)-290(not)-291(a)-290(few)-290(of)-291(the)-290(conceptions)-291(of)-290(science.)-371(It)-291(is)-290(also)-290(true)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-323(they)-323(respect)-323(truths)-322(with)-323(which)-323(we)-323(could)-323(not)-323(be)-322(acquainted)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(apart)-261(from)-523(such)-261(a)-261(revelation)-262(as)-261(that)-261(made)-261(in)-262(the)-261(person)-261(of)-261(Jesus)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([083])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(Christ;)-397(but)-349(this)-348(is)-348(true)-348(of)-349(the)-348(phenomena)-348(of)-348(Creation)-348(likewise.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(We)-276(do)-276(not)-275(acquire)-276(a)-276(knowledge)-275(of)-276(its)-276(phenomena)-276(by)-275(reasoning,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-313(by)-313(observation,)-328(or)-313(from)-313(the)-313(statements)-313(of)-313(others)-313(when)-312(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lie)-329(beyond)-329(the)-328(limits)-329(of)-329(our)-329(own)-328(observation.)-487(The)-328(Incarnation,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(including)-288(as)-289(it)-288(does)-288(the)-289(divine)-288(actions)-288(and)-289(the)-288(teaching)-288(of)-288(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Christ,)-389(is)-362(not)-361(the)-362(revelation)-361(of)-362(a)-361(dogma,)-390(but)-361(the)-361(manifestation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-417(a)-418(new)-417(fact.)-751(This)-418(fact,)-459(like)-417(all)-417(other)-417(phenomena,)-459(although)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(undiscoverable)-272(by)-272(our)-271(reasoning)-272(powers)-272(without)-272(the)-272(exercise)-271(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(observation,)-373(becomes)-349(after)-349(observation)-349(a)-348(fact)-349(on)-349(which)-348(reason)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-259(justly)-259(exercise)-260(its)-259(powers.)-277(If)-260(he)-259(be)-259(really)-259(what)-259(he)-259(professed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-234(be,)-237(then)-234(his)-234(statements)-234(about)-234(himself)-234(give)-234(as)-234(an)-234(account)-234(of)-233(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(previous)-250(history,)-250(before)-250(he)-250(came)-250(under)-250(human)-250(observation.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
377 0 obj <<
/Length 4616      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-6784(77)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(Let)-441(me)-440(now)-441(consider)-440(the)-441(relation)-441(in)-440(which)-441(miracles)-440(stand)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-420(the)-421(affirmations)-420(of)-420(those)-420(who)-421(claimed)-420(a)-420(commission)-420(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-325(Christ)-325(to)-325(publish)-325(his)-325(religion)-325(in)-325(the)-325(world,)-344(and)-325(to)-324(lay)-325(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(foundation)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Church.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-202(must)-202(here)-202(also)-202(adhere)-202(to)-202(my)-202(original)-202(position)-202(that)-201(miraculous)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(powers)-262(are)-262(never)-262(described)-262(in)-262(the)-262(New)-262(Testament)-262(as)-262(being)-262(used)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-229(the)-230(direct)-229(proof)-230(of)-229(dogmas,)-234(but)-229(for)-230(the)-229(proof)-230(of)-229(the)-229(Messianic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-324(of)-323(Jesus)-324(Christ,)-342(or)-324(of)-324(the)-323(divine)-324(commission)-324(of)-323(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-234(wrought)-235(them.)-245(The)-234(truth)-234(of)-235(the)-234(assertions)-234(of)-235(its)-234(writers)-234(rests)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-223(no)-223(other)-222(foundation)-223(than)-223(the)-223(fulness)-222(of)-223(their)-223(knowledge)-223(of)-222(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(subjects)-191(on)-192(which)-191(they)-191(spake,)-203(whether)-191(acquired)-192(by)-191(ordinary)-191(or)-191(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-260(means,)-262(and)-259(on)-260(their)-260(veracity,)-262(when)-259(they)-260(affirm)-259(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(particular)-256(truths)-255(were)-256(within)-255(the)-256(limi)1(ts)-256(of)-255(their)-256(knowledge.)-266(Thus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(St.)-412(Paul)-304(claims)-303(acceptance)-304(for)-304(the)-304(things)-304(which)-304(he)-304(asserted)-303(be-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cause)-264(he)-265(had)-264(been)-265(taught)-264(them)-265(by)-264(Revelation)-265(from)-264(Jesus)-264(Christ,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(not)-362(because)-362(he)-361(had)-362(proved)-362(their)-362(truth,)-389(by)-362(working)-362(miracles)-361(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(confirmation)-264(of)-264(them.)-585(This)-265(course)-264(is)-264(uniformly)-264(adopted)-264(by)-264(him)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([084])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(throughout)-212(his)-212(epistles.)-237(The)-212(object)-211(of)-212(the)-212(mighty)-212(works)-212(that)-211(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wrought)-287(by)-288(him)-287(was)-288(to)-287(prove)-288(his)-287(own)-288(apostleship)-287(or)-288(the)-287(fact)-287(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(resurrection.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-216(must)-217(not)-216(allow)-216(myself)-217(to)-216(enter)-216(on)-217(the)-216(question)-216(of)-217(inspiration,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(its)-245(nature)-244(and)-244(limitations,)-246(or)-245(the)-244(degree)-244(of)-245(supernatural)-244(guidance)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(afforded)-407(to)-407(the)-407(apostles)-408(and)-407(their)-407(followers.)-721(Such)-407(an)-407(inquiry)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-291(be)-291(foreign)-291(to)-292(t)1(he)-292(present)-291(subject,)-301(which)-291(is)-291(strictly)-291(histor-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ical.)-509(It)-336(is)-336(of)-337(course)-336(a)-336(direct)-336(and)-337(necessary)-336(inference)-336(that)-336(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-301(miracles)-300(proved)-301(the)-300(reality)-301(of)-300(the)-301(commission)-300(of)-301(those)-300(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performed)-245(them,)-245(they)-245(also)-244(proved)-245(that)-244(they)-245(were)-244(fully)-244(instructed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-240(its)-240(terms,)-242(and)-240(entitled)-240(to)-240(credit)-241(within)-240(its)-240(limits.)-246(But)-240(the)-240(extent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-213(their)-213(enlightenment)-213(can)-212(only)-213(be)-213(inferred)-213(from)-213(the)-213(nature)-213(of)-212(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(commission)-214(itself,)-221(and)-214(from)-214(the)-213(facts)-214(and)-214(phenomena)-214(of)-214(the)-213(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament.)-661(It)-387(has)-387(been)-387(an)-387(idea)-387(widely)-387(spread)-387(that)-386(inspiration)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-422(confer)-423(a)-422(general)-423(infallibility.)-767(The)-422(inference)-423(that)-422(a)-422(man)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-353(rendered)-352(infallible)-353(in)-353(general)-353(matters)-352(because)-353(he)-353(is)-352(invested)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-348(a)-348(limited)-348(and)-348(definite)-348(commission,)-372(and)-348(with)-348(endowments)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
381 0 obj <<
/Length 4615      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(78)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(adequate)-356(to)-356(render)-356(him)-357(competent)-356(to)-356(fulfil)-356(the)-356(purposes)-356(of)-356(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mission,)-313(is)-300(one)-300(which)-300(the)-300(premises)-300(wil)1(l)-300(not)-300(justify.)-400(The)-300(utmost)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-364(the)-364(possession)-364(of)-364(such)-364(a)-364(commission)-364(can)-364(prove)-364(is)-364(that)-363(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessor)-250(is)-250(enlightened)-250(up)-250(to)-250(its)-250(subject)-250(matter,)-250(but)-250(no)-250(further.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-310(in)-310(the)-310(present)-310(discussion)-310(I)-310(need)-310(not)-310(go)-310(beyond)-310(the)-310(affir-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(mations)-276(of)-276(the)-276(New)-275(Testament.)-328(The)-276(actions)-276(performed)-276(by)-275(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Christ)-422(proved)-422(him)-422(to)-423(be)-422(the)-422(Messiah.)-766(The)-422(miracles)-422(wrought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-350(the)-349(apostles,)-374(were)-350(performed)-349(either)-350(to)-349(prove)-350(the)-349(fact)-350(of)-349(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(resurrection,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 58.958 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 19.421 0 Td [(that)-353(he)-352(was)-353(the)-353(Messiah,)-378(or)-353(their)-353(own)-353(divine)]TJ -78.379 -13.549 Td [(mission,)-215(which)-205(was)-206(dependent)-206(on)-206(its)-206(truth,)-214(or)-206(to)-206(draw)-206(attention)-205(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-251(message.)-252(The)-251(supernatural)-251(gifts)-250(so)-251(frequently)-251(referred)-251(to)-250(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-251(epistles,)-251(are)-250(affirmed)-251(to)-501(have)-251(been)-250(designed)-251(for)-251(the)-250(building)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([085])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(up)-290(of)-290(the)-290(Church)-289(into)-290(a)-290(distinct)-290(community,)-300(and)-290(when)-290(that)-289(pur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pose)-227(was)-227(accomplished)-227(they)-227(were)-227(to)-227(cease.)-243(Being)-227(functional,)-231(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enlightenment)-380(communicated)-381(by)-380(them)-381(was)-380(necessarily)-380(limited)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-341(the)-341(special)-341(subject)-341(matter)-341(on)-341(which)-341(they)-341(were)-341(exercised.)-522(In)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-283(point)-284(of)-283(view)-283(miracles)-284(may)-283(be)-283(viewed)-284(as)-283(attestations)-283(of)-283(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(veracity)-357(of)-356(the)-356(persons)-357(who)-356(performed)-357(them,)-383(and)-356(of)-357(the)-356(suffi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ciency)-377(of)-378(their)-377(knowledge)-378(on)-377(the)-377(subjects)-378(they)-377(were)-377(specially)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(commissioned)-250(to)-250(communicate.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-262(the)-263(question)-262(still)-263(remains)-262(for)-263(consideration,)-265(Can)-262(miracles)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(prove)-250(moral)-250(truths?)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-269(answer)-269(emphatically)-270(in)-269(the)-269(negative.)-308(If)-269(dogmas,)-274(which)-269(may)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(be)-329(viewed)-330(as)-329(intellectual)-330(truths,)-349(are)-330(incapable)-329(of)-330(a)-329(direct)-329(proof)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-303(miracles,)-316(still)-303(more)-302(so)-303(are)-303(moral)-303(truths.)-408(Such)-303(truths)-303(can)-302(rest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-392(on)-392(a)-391(moral)-392(basis.)-676(With)-391(respect)-392(to)-392(the)-392(miracles)-391(recorded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-314(the)-314(New)-314(Testament,)-330(the)-314(question)-314(is)-314(nugatory,)-330(for)-314(it)-314(nowhere)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(affirms)-315(that)-314(its)-315(miracles)-315(were)-314(wrought)-315(for)-315(such)-314(a)-315(purpose.)-444(It)-314(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(true)-329(that)-330(Jesus)-329(Christ,)-350(as)-329(the)-329(great)-330(legislator)-329(of)-330(the)-329(kingdom)-329(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(heaven,)-314(gave)-302(an)-302(authoritative)-301(utterance)-302(to)-301(many)-302(moral)-301(precepts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-327(the)-327(laws)-328(of)-327(his)-327(kingdom.)-482(This)-327(royal)-327(right)-327(of)-327(legislation)-327(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inherent)-224(in)-223(his)-224(Messiahship.)-241(But)-224(to)-223(give)-224(utterance)-223(to)-224(moral)-223(truths)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-359(a)-358(legislative)-359(capacity,)-386(has)-358(no)-359(connection)-358(with)-359(attempting)-358(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prove)-431(them)-431(by)-431(authority.)-793(Ordinary)-431(human)-431(legislation)-431(has)-430(its)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
385 0 obj <<
/Length 4746      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-6784(79)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(authoritative)-337(utterances.)-509(But)-336(when)-337(it)-336(does)-337(this,)-358(it)-336(does)-337(not)-336(rest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-268(truths)-269(themselves)-268(on)-269(authority,)-273(or)-268(base)-269(them)-268(on)-268(adventitious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testimony.)-357(Our)-286(Lord)-286(and)-286(his)-285(apostles)-286(uniformly)-286(appealed)-286(to)-285(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(internal)-251(perceptions)-250(of)-251(our)-251(moral)-250(and)-251(spiritual)-251(nature)-250(as)-251(the)-250(only)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ground)-250(on)-250(which)-250(moral)-250(obligation)-250(rests.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Let)-200(it)-200(be)-200(observed,)-211(however,)-210(that)-200(this)-200(by)-200(no)-200(means)-201(pre-suppos-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(es)-309(the)-309(truth)-308(of)-309(the)-309(absurd)-309(proposition,)-323(that)-309(every)-309(man,)-323(however)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(imperfect)-405(or)-406(degraded,)-444(is)-405(capable)-405(of)-811(reasoning)-405(out)-405(all)-405(moral)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([086])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(truth)-408(for)-408(himself.)-723(On)-408(the)-408(contrary,)-447(definite)-408(moral)-407(knowledge)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(requires)-208(to)-208(be)-208(communicated,)-217(as)-208(all)-208(other)-208(kinds)-208(of)-208(knowledge.)-236(Its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-319(principles)-318(require)-319(to)-318(be)-319(enunciated,)-335(and)-319(to)-318(be)-319(worked)-318(out)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-220(their)-220(special)-220(applications.)-240(But)-220(the)-220(principles)-220(themselves,)-226(as)-219(far)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-280(their)-281(binding)-280(power)-280(is)-280(concerned,)-288(must)-281(ultimately)-280(rest)-280(on)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(internal)-263(perceptions)-263(of)-264(our)-263(moral)-263(and)-263(spiritual)-264(being.)-289(A)-263(miracle,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore,)-205(can)-195(communicate)-194(to)-194(them)-194(no)-195(higher)-194(degree)-194(of)-194(certainty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-278(obligation.)-334(The)-278(only)-278(thing)-278(which)-278(it)-278(can)-278(aid)-278(in)-278(establishing)-277(is,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-288(one)-288(invested)-289(with)-288(a)-288(divine)-288(commission)-289(may)-288(have)-288(a)-288(right)-288(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(claim)-313(obedience)-313(to)-313(special)-313(precepts)-313(on)-313(the)-313(authority)-313(of)-313(God,)-328(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whom)-250(all)-250(moral)-250(obligation)-250(centres.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-428(even)-428(in)-428(this)-428(case,)-472(the)-428(ground)-428(on)-428(which)-429(the)-428(obligation)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(rests)-404(is)-403(a)-404(moral)-404(one,)-442(which)-403(no)-404(miracle)-404(can)-403(possibly)-404(prove)-403(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-340(confirm.)-521(A)-341(moral)-340(teacher)-340(can)-341(only)-340(appeal)-340(to)-341(that)-340(in)-340(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-260(we)-259(variously)-260(designate)-260(as)-259(conscience,)-262(moral)-260(sense,)-262(or)-259(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(principles)-400(which)-400(are)-401(the)-400(foundation)-400(of)-400(our)-400(moral)-400(perceptions.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(The)-218(fact)-218(that)-218(many)-219(men)-218(through)-218(a)-218(long)-218(course)-218(of)-218(evil)-218(get)-218(morally)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(blinded)-262(does)-262(not)-263(alter)-262(the)-262(case.)-287(It)-262(only)-262(exemplifies)-262(a)-262(remarkable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(saying)-273(of)-273(our)-273(Lord,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 88.026 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(If)-273(the)-273(light)-273(that)-273(is)-273(in)-273(thee)-273(be)-274(darkness,)-278(how)]TJ -92.87 -13.549 Td [(great)-403(is)-404(that)-403(darkness.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 99.546 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.244 0 Td [(When)-403(the)-404(light)-403(within)-403(us)-404(has)-403(become)]TJ -108.79 -13.549 Td [(darkness,)-265(there)-262(is)-262(nothing)-261(left)-262(to)-262(which)-262(an)-262(appeal)-262(to)-262(the)-262(sense)-261(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(duty)-250(or)-250(obligation)-250(can)-250(be)-250(made.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(The)-303(objection)-303(urged)-303(against)-303(Christianity,)-316(that)-303(because)-303(a)-303(mir-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(acle)-354(cannot)-355(prove)-354(a)-354(moral)-355(truth)-354(it)-354(is)-354(therefore)-355(useless,)-380(is)-354(quite)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(beyond)-290(the)-290(question)-289(at)-290(issue.)-370(The)-289(special)-290(function)-290(of)-290(the)-289(Chris-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tian)-359(revelation)-359(is)-360(one)-359(far)-359(higher)-359(than)-360(the)-359(mere)-359(laying)-359(down)-359(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
389 0 obj <<
/Length 4820      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(80)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(rules)-251(for)-250(the)-251(regulation)-250(of)-251(human)-250(conduct.)-251(Its)-251(great)-250(purpose)-251(is)-250(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impart)-220(to)-220(man)-220(a)-219(moral)-220(and)-220(spiritual)-220(power,)-226(which)-220(is)-220(able)-220(to)-219(make)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(obedience)-382(to)-382(the)-383(moral)-382(law)-382(a)-382(possibility;)-897(to)-382(supply)-382(a)-382(motive)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([087])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(of)-340(sufficient)-339(potency)-340(to)-340(make)-339(us)-340(capable)-340(of)-339(resisting)-340(the)-339(vehe-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mence)-277(of)-277(our)-277(passions;)-291(and)-277(one)-277(which)-277(is)-277(able)-277(to)-277(lift)-277(the)-277(morally)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(degraded)-347(from)-347(their)-346(degradation,)-371(and)-347(to)-347(strengthen)-347(the)-347(holy)-346(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-263(holiness.)-290(According)-263(to)-263(the)-264(teaching)-263(of)-263(the)-263(New)-263(Testament,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-274(constitutes)-274(the)-274(great)-274(distinctive)-274(purpose)-274(of)-274(Christianity,)-279(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-345(end)-345(of)-346(all)-345(divine)-345(revelation.)-536(This)-345(most)-345(important)-345(truth)-345(has)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-354(greatly)-353(overlooked)-354(in)-353(the)-354(present)-353(controversy.)-561(It)-353(entirely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disposes)-384(of)-384(the)-384(objection)-383(that)-384(if)-384(moral)-384(truth)-384(cannot)-384(be)-383(proved)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-368(miracles,)-398(they)-369(must)-368(be)-369(valueless.)-605(To)-368(such)-369(a)-368(revelation)-368(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presence)-250(of)-250(the)-250(supernatural)-250(is)-250(essential.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-385(it)-386(by)-385(no)-386(means)-385(follows)-386(because)-385(miracles)-386(are)-385(unable)-385(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(impart)-374(to)-374(us)-373(a)-374(sense)-374(of)-374(moral)-373(obligation,)-405(that)-374(a)-374(duly)-373(commis-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sioned)-367(moral)-366(teacher)-367(would)-367(be)-366(useless.)-600(They)-367(might)-367(prove)-366(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(superior)-264(knowledge,)-267(or)-264(as)-263(attesting)-264(a)-264(divine)-263(commission,)-267(enable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(him)-395(to)-395(bring)-394(obligations)-395(already)-395(existing)-394(to)-395(bear)-395(on)-395(the)-394(mind)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-304(superior)-303(power.)-412(Thus)-303(it)-304(by)-304(no)-303(means)-304(follows)-304(that)-303(because)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(men)-309(possess)-309(in)-309(their)-309(mental)-309(constitution)-309(the)-309(great)-309(principles)-309(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-427(scientific)-427(truths)-427(are)-427(based,)-471(each)-427(man)-427(is)-427(able)-427(to)-426(reason)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-313(out)-313(for)-312(himself.)-439(The)-313(most)-312(highly)-313(gifted)-313(man)-313(would)-312(make)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(slow)-380(progress)-379(without)-380(a)-379(teacher.)-639(As)-380(I)-379(have)-380(already)-379(observed,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-364(truth)-364(is)-364(capable)-364(of)-364(being)-364(taught)-364(like)-364(all)-364(other)-364(truth;)-420(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(although)-448(a)-449(miracle)-448(cannot)-449(prove)-448(it,)-498(it)-448(may)-449(establish)-448(the)-448(fact)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-343(the)-343(worker)-343(of)-344(one)-343(is)-343(a)-343(man)-343(eminently)-343(entitled)-343(to)-343(be)-343(heard)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-366(the)-366(great)-366(subjects)-366(of)-366(moral)-366(obligation,)-395(or)-366(that)-366(he)-366(is)-366(able)-366(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(communicate)-265(knowledge)-264(which)-265(is)-264(capable)-265(of)-264(acting)-265(mightily)-264(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-250(moral)-250(being.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-305(must)-305(now)-305(proceed)-305(to)-306(offer)-305(a)-305(few)-305(observations)-305(on)-305(the)-305(ques-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tion,)-424(Are)-389(miracles)-388(objects)-389(of)-389(faith?)-667(and)-389(if)-389(they)-389(are)-389(so)-389(in)-388(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sense,)-250(how)-250(can)-250(they)-250(be)-250(the)-250(media)-250(of)-250(proof)-250(of)-250(a)-250(revelation?)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([088])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -15.186 Td [(The)-431(author)-432(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 68.045 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)-431(Religion)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 98.034 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.551 0 Td [(starts)-432(the)-431(following)]TJ -192.43 -13.549 Td [(difficulty)-263(in)-262(connection)-263(with)-263(this)-263(subject:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 183.393 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Consciousness)-263(of)-262(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
394 0 obj <<
/Length 4503      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-6784(81)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(difficulties)-245(which)-245(beset)-245(miracles)-246(in)-245(the)-245(present)-245(age)-245(has)-245(led)-245(many)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(able)-204(men)-204(to)-204(deal)-204(thus)-205(illogically)-204(with)-204(them,)-213(and)-204(to)-204(represent)-204(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alternately)-220(as)-221(evidence)-220(and)-221(as)-220(objects)-221(of)-220(faith.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 198.296 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.248 0 Td [(He)-220(then)-221(proceeds)]TJ -205.544 -13.549 Td [(to)-265(refer)-265(to)-265(Dr.)-296(Arnold,)-268(Professor)-265(Baden)-266(Powell,)-268(and)-265(Archbishop)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Trench,)-288(as)-280(having)-281(been)-280(in)-281(various)-280(degrees)-280(guilty)-281(of)-280(making)-280(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(confusion.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(I)-352(am)-352(not)-352(prepared)-353(to)-352(deny)-352(that)-352(many)-352(Christian)-352(writers)-352(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(expressed)-370(themselves)-369(with)-370(great)-370(indistinctness)-369(on)-370(this)-369(subject,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(especially)-353(in)-353(works)-353(where)-353(miracles)-353(have)-353(been)-353(only)-353(referred)-352(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incidentally,)-398(and)-369(which)-368(only)-369(partially)-369(treat)-368(of)-369(the)-368(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(elements)-331(of)-331(Christianity.)-492(This)-331(question)-331(will)-331(be)-331(discussed)-330(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fully)-335(when)-335(we)-335(consider)-335(his)-335(definite)-335(objections;)-377(but)-335(it)-335(will)-335(tend)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-253(a)-253(clearer)-253(understanding)-253(of)-253(the)-253(subject)-253(if)-253(in)-253(the)-253(present)-253(place,)-253(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lay)-250(down)-250(the)-250(following)-250(propositions:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 161.215 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -149.259 -14.163 Td [(I.)-477(That)-477(it)-477(is)-476(impossible)-477(to)-477(believe)-477(in)-477(any)-477(assertion)-476(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(contradicts)-449(the)-448(first)-449(principles)-448(of)-449(our)-449(reason,)-498(even)-448(if)-449(it)-448(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposable)-226(that)-225(a)-226(miracle)-225(could)-226(be)-225(wrought)-226(in)-225(confirmation)-226(of)-225(it.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(II.)-407(That,)-447(although)-407(the)-407(illumination)-407(which)-407(reason)-407(imparts)-408(i)1(s)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(imperfect,)-253(yet)-253(as)-253(it)-252(is)-253(the)-253(only)-252(instrument)-253(that)-253(we)-252(possess)-253(for)-252(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(investigation)-250(of)-250(truth,)-250(attempts)-250(to)-250(disparage)-250(it)-250(are)-250(absurd.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(III.)-294(So)-293(far)-294(is)-294(faith)-293(from)-294(standing)-294(in)-294(opposition)-293(to)-294(reason,)-305(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(it)-246(is)-246(a)-246(legitimate)-246(branch)-246(of)-246(it)-246(when)-246(exercised)-246(on)-246(a)-246(special)-245(subject)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(matter.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(IV.)-468(That)-469(beliefs)-468(which)-469(reason)-468(refuses)-469(to)-468(authorise)-469(do)-468(not)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(originate)-250(in)-250(faith)-250(but)-250(in)-250(credulity.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(V.)-388(That)-388(even)-389(those)-388(who)-388(entertain)-388(irrational)-388(convictions)-388(are)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(compelled)-462(to)-461(base)-462(them)-462(on)-461(evidence)-462(of)-462(some)-461(kind)-462(which)-461(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(satisfactory)-260(to)-260(themselves:)-540(that)-260(is)-261(to)-260(say,)-262(on)-260(the)-260(dictates)-260(of)-260(their)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([089])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(own)-250(imperfect)-250(reason.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(VI.)-314(That,)-329(while)-314(we)-313(can)-314(believe)-313(in)-314(nothing)-314(that)-313(is)-314(contrary)-313(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(our)-305(reason,)-318(yet)-305(it)-305(is)-305(perfectly)-305(rational)-304(to)-305(believe)-305(in)-305(many)-304(things)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(our)-250(reason)-250(would)-250(have)-250(been)-250(unable)-250(to)-250(discover.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(VII.)-351(That)-351(extraordinary)-351(facts)-352(which)-351(lie)-351(beyond)-351(the)-351(limits)-351(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(human)-318(experience)-318(are)-318(not)-318(contrary)-317(to)-318(our)-318(reason:)-386(and)-318(it)-318(is)-317(per-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
399 0 obj <<
/Length 4632      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(82)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(fectly)-446(rational)-445(to)-446(believe)-445(them)-446(whenever)-445(they)-446(are)-445(adequately)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attested.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(VIII.)-252(That)-252(a)-253(large)-252(portion)-252(of)-252(our)-253(beliefs)-252(on)-252(subjects)-252(scientific,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(philosophical,)-240(historical,)-239(moral,)-240(and)-237(religious,)-239(rest)-237(on)-237(testimony;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-199(belief)-199(in)-199(them)-199(is)-199(highly)-199(rational,)-209(when)-199(the)-199(knowledge)-199(of)-199(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-326(whom)-326(we)-325(derive)-326(our)-326(information)-325(is)-326(adequate:)-402(and)-325(conse-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(quently)-223(that)-223(faith)-222(is)-223(a)-223(principle)-222(co-extensive)-223(with)-223(the)-223(activities)-222(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-235(human)-235(mind,)-238(and)-234(is)-235(by)-235(no)-235(means)-235(confined)-235(to)-235(subjects)-234(simply)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(religious,)-250(however)-250(intimately)-250(it)-250(may)-250(be)-250(connected)-250(with)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(A)-196(few)-197(brief)-196(observations)-197(will)-196(suffice)-196(in)-197(this)-196(part)-197(of)-196(our)-196(subject.)]TJ 0 -14.777 Td [(It)-174(will)-174(be)-174(observed)-173(that)-174(I)-174(have)-174(included)-174(under)-174(the)-174(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 230.514 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(reason)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 28.472 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(the)-340(whole)-340(of)-340(our)-339(mental)-340(processes)-340(which)-340(are)-340(necessary)-340(for)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cognition)-244(and)-245(the)-244(discovery)-245(of)-244(truth.)-248(These)-245(include,)-246(not)-244(only)-244(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(powers)-271(of)-271(inductive)-270(and)-271(deductive)-271(reasoning,)-276(but)-271(our)-270(intuitions,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-277(forms)-277(of)-277(thought,)-284(those)-277(powers)-277(of)-277(our)-277(mind,)-283(which)-277(whether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intuitional)-401(or)-400(instinctive,)-438(form)-401(the)-400(foundation)-401(of)-400(many)-401(of)-400(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(most)-362(important)-361(convictions)-362(and)-361(our)-362(moral)-362(conceptions.)-584(These)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(constitute)-281(our)-281(reason)-281(as)-280(distinct)-281(from)-281(our)-281(reasoning)-281(powers.)-342(No)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(little)-348(confusion)-348(has)-347(been)-348(introduced)-348(into)-348(this)-348(controversy)-347(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(want)-250(of)-250(attending)-250(to)-250(this)-250(distinction.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(It)-356(has)-355(been)-356(asserted)-356(that)-355(we)-356(can)-356(accept)-355(things)-356(as)-356(matters)-355(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(faith)-429(which)-428(to)-429(our)-429(reason)-429(would)-428(be)-429(utterly)-857(incredible.)-786(This)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([090])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(assertion)-377(has)-378(arisen)-377(from)-377(the)-377(confusion)-378(of)-377(things)-377(which)-377(differ)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(widely,)-290(viz.)-347(things)-282(which)-282(our)-282(reason)-283(might)-282(have)-282(been)-282(unable)-282(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discover,)-302(but)-291(which)-292(when)-291(discovered)-291(may)-292(be)-291(perfectly)-291(rational,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-387(things)-387(directly)-387(contradictory)-386(to)-387(reason.)-661(The)-387(existence)-386(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(example)-324(of)-324(a)-324(square)-324(circle)-324(is)-323(a)-324(thing)-324(absolutely)-324(incredible,)-342(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(while)-340(thus)-340(contradictory)-339(to)-340(reason,)-362(it)-340(is)-340(impossible)-340(to)-340(accept)-339(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-280(faith.)-341(So)-281(would)-280(any)-280(doctrine)-281(which)-280(in)-280(a)-281(similar)-280(manner)-280(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tradicted)-231(the)-230(first)-231(principles)-231(of)-231(our)-230(rational)-231(convictions.)-244(No)-230(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pernicious)-262(principle)-262(can)-261(be)-262(laid)-262(down)-261(than)-262(that)-262(things)-262(which)-261(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contradictory)-323(to)-323(our)-323(reason)-324(can)-323(be)-323(accepted)-323(by)-323(the)-323(principle)-323(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(faith.)-522(Such)-340(a)-341(principle)-340(would)-341(divide)-340(the)-341(human)-340(mind)-341(into)-340(two)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hostile)-359(camps,)-386(and)-359(if)-358(carried)-359(to)-359(its)-359(logical)-358(consequences,)-386(must)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
403 0 obj <<
/Length 4741      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-6784(83)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(land)-250(us)-250(in)-250(universal)-250(scepticism.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(It)-185(by)-186(no)-185(means)-185(follows)-186(that)-185(things)-185(which)-186(transcend)-185(our)-185(rational)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(powers)-384(to)-384(discover)-384(must)-384(be)-384(contrary)-384(to)-384(our)-384(reason)-384(when)-384(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-318(been)-318(discovered.)-454(We)-318(can)-318(only)-318(arrive)-318(at)-318(the)-318(knowledge)-317(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unknown)-293(facts)-292(by)-293(observation,)-303(or)-293(accept)-293(them)-292(on)-293(the)-292(testimony)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-248(others.)-249(Until)-247(they)-248(have)-248(been)-247(brought)-248(within)-247(our)-248(knowledge)-247(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-299(way,)-312(no)-299(amount)-300(of)-299(reasoning)-299(could)-300(lead)-299(to)-299(their)-299(discovery.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(In)-202(a)-201(similar)-202(manner)-201(with)-202(respect)-201(to)-201(several)-202(of)-201(the)-202(facts)-201(in)-202(the)-201(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-205(connected)-204(with)-205(the)-205(Incarnation,)-213(our)-205(reason)-205(might)-204(nev-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(er)-326(have)-326(discovered)-326(them,)-345(but)-326(when)-326(they)-326(have)-326(been)-326(discovered,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-250(may)-250(form)-250(suitable)-250(subjects)-250(on)-250(which)-250(to)-250(exert)-250(its)-250(energies.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(The)-213(whole)-213(of)-213(the)-214(confusion)-213(in)-213(which)-213(this)-213(question)-213(has)-213(become)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(involved)-306(has)-306(originated)-306(in)-306(the)-306(assumption)-306(that)-306(faith)-306(is)-306(a)-305(faculty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-463(the)-463(mind)-463(distinct)-463(and)-463(separate)-463(from)-463(our)-462(reason,)-517(and)-463(in)-462(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-436(sense)-435(opposed)-436(to)-436(it;)-528(and)-436(that)-435(things)-436(which)-436(cannot)-435(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(subjects)-353(of)-354(rational)-353(conviction)-353(may)-354(yet)-353(be)-353(the)-354(objects)-353(of)-353(faith.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Whatever)-768(opinions)-384(may)-383(have)-384(been)-384(held)-384(by)-384(divines)-384(upon)-383(this)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([091])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(subject,)-303(I)-293(can)-293(discover)-293(nothing)-292(which)-293(countenances)-293(them)-293(in)-292(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(New)-250(Testament.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(To)-308(what)-307(class)-308(of)-308(truths)-308(is)-307(the)-308(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 158.356 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(faith)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.996 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.201 0 Td [(properly)-308(applied?)]TJ -203.353 -13.549 Td [(I)-383(answer)-383(to)-383(those)-383(which)-383(we)-383(accept)-383(on)-383(testimony.)-649(It)-383(has)-383(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(asserted)-306(that)-307(some)-306(of)-306(the)-306(first)-306(principles)-307(of)-306(our)-306(rational)-306(convic-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tions,)-262(such)-259(as)-260(our)-259(belief)-260(in)-259(the)-260(existence)-259(of)-260(an)-259(external)-260(world,)-261(or)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-270(the)-270(truth)-270(of)-269(experience,)-275(is)-270(an)-270(act)-270(of)-270(faith.)-309(This,)-275(however,)-275(is)-269(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(introduce)-291(a)-291(confusion)-291(of)-290(thought.)-373(Such)-291(convictions)-291(can)-291(be)-290(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acts)-250(of)-250(faith)-250(as)-250(far)-250(as)-250(we)-250(believe)-250(in)-250(ourselves.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(Viewing)-262(faith)-262(as)-261(the)-262(acceptance)-262(of)-262(truth)-262(on)-262(adequate)-261(testimo-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(ny,)-330(it)-314(follows)-314(that)-314(all)-314(our)-314(knowledge)-314(of)-314(things,)-330(whether)-313(natural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-366(supernatural,)-395(that)-366(is)-367(not)-366(the)-366(result)-366(of)-366(the)-366(action)-366(of)-366(our)-366(own)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(minds,)-417(but)-383(which)-383(we)-383(accept)-384(on)-383(the)-383(testimony)-383(of)-384(others,)-416(is)-383(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(act)-401(of)-401(faith.)-704(Our)-401(acceptance)-401(of)-401(them)-401(depends)-401(on)-401(the)-401(validity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-350(the)-350(testimony)-350(that)-350(can)-350(be)-350(adduced)-350(for)-350(them.)-550(The)-350(important)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(question)-280(for)-280(determination)-280(is,)-287(is)-280(the)-280(subject)-280(on)-280(which)-280(it)-280(is)-279(given)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(within)-415(the)-415(knowledge)-415(of)-415(the)-415(informant?)-745(If)-415(it)-415(respects)-415(a)-414(fact,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
407 0 obj <<
/Length 4917      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(84)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(has)-343(he)-343(witnessed)-343(it,)-366(or)-343(received)-342(it)-343(from)-343(others)-343(who)-343(have?)-528(Are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-315(powers)-315(of)-316(observation)-315(good)-315(and)-315(his)-315(judgment)-316(sound?)-445(Is)-315(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(worthy)-288(of)-289(credit?)-365(The)-288(determination)-289(of)-288(these)-289(and)-288(similar)-288(points)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-261(the)-261(proper)-260(office)-261(of)-261(our)-261(rational)-261(powers,)-263(yet)-261(the)-261(acceptance)-260(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-365(fact)-366(is)-365(an)-365(act)-366(of)-365(faith.)-596(When)-365(our)-365(reason)-366(is)-365(satisfied)-365(on)-365(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-324(points,)-342(faith)-324(becomes)-324(an)-324(act)-324(of)-324(reason.)-472(To)-324(assert)-324(that)-323(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acceptance)-195(of)-196(supernatural)-195(facts)-195(belongs)-196(to)-195(a)-195(faculty)-196(of)-195(our)-195(minds)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-362(we)-362(designate)-362(faith,)-390(and)-362(that)-362(our)-362(acceptance)-362(of)-362(others)-361(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-246(result)-246(of)-246(the)-246(action)-246(of)-246(our)-246(reason,)-247(is)-246(to)-246(lay)-246(down)-246(a)-246(distinction)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(entirely)-332(of)-331(our)-332(own)-332(creation.)-494(In)-332(both)-332(cases)-331(the)-332(evidences)-331(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(form)-432(the)-432(subject)-432(of)-864(rational)-432(investigation,)-477(and)-432(they)-432(must)-432(be)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([092])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(accepted)-250(or)-250(rejected)-250(as)-250(they)-250(approve)-250(themselves)-250(to)-250(our)-250(reason.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-303(will)-304(perhaps)-303(be)-304(urged,)-317(that)-303(the)-304(acceptance)-303(of)-303(propositions,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(such)-265(as)-266(the)-265(doctrinal)-266(statements)-265(of)-266(the)-265(New)-265(Testament,)-270(is)-265(an)-265(act)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-267(faith)-267(which)-267(stands)-268(out)-267(in)-267(manifest)-267(contra-distinction)-267(to)-267(an)-267(act)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-328(reason.)-483(It)-327(would)-328(be)-328(so)-327(unquestionably,)-347(if)-328(we)-328(accepted)-327(them)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-245(insufficient)-245(evidence;)-246(but)-245(when)-245(we)-245(do)-245(so)-245(with)-245(the)-244(knowledge)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-356(others)-357(have)-356(a)-356(full)-356(acquaintance)-356(with)-357(the)-356(subject)-356(on)-356(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-339(speak,)-361(it)-339(is)-339(in)-339(the)-339(highest)-339(degree)-339(rational)-339(to)-339(accept)-339(and)-338(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(act)-296(on)-296(their)-296(testimony.)-388(A)-296(large)-296(portion)-296(of)-296(the)-296(business)-296(of)-295(life)-296(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conducted)-269(on)-269(this)-269(principle.)-306(A)-269(man)-269(is)-269(ignorant)-269(on)-269(some)-268(subject,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(or)-326(he)-326(distrusts)-326(his)-326(own)-326(judgment)-326(respecting)-326(it:)-402(he)-326(consults)-326(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-330(knows,)-350(or)-330(on)-330(whose)-330(judgment)-330(he)-330(relies.)-490(For)-330(example:)-410(let)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us)-327(suppose)-326(that)-327(I)-327(have)-326(a)-327(bottle)-326(full)-327(of)-327(a)-326(certain)-327(substance;)-365(I)-326(do)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-397(know)-396(whether)-397(it)-397(is)-396(a)-397(medicine)-396(that)-397(I)-397(am)-396(in)-397(need)-397(of,)-433(or)-396(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(deadly)-366(poison.)-599(I)-366(consult)-367(my)-366(chemist,)-396(and)-366(without)-366(hesitation)-366(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(act)-336(on)-336(his)-336(opinion.)-507(In)-336(all)-336(such)-336(cases)-336(\050and)-336(they)-336(are)-336(spread)-335(over)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-316(entire)-315(sphere)-316(of)-315(life\051)-316(we)-316(act)-315(on)-316(faith;)-348(but)-316(it)-316(is)-315(a)-316(faith)-315(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-280(in)-281(conformity)-280(with)-280(the)-281(dictates)-280(of)-280(reason.)-341(The)-281(function)-280(of)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(latter)-402(is)-402(to)-403(ascertain)-402(the)-402(adequate)-402(knowledge)-402(and)-402(the)-402(veracity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-324(the)-324(person)-324(whose)-324(assurance)-325(we)-324(accept.)-472(If)-324(it)-324(is)-324(a)-324(rational)-324(act)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thus)-219(to)-220(receive)-219(truths)-219(on)-220(the)-219(testimony)-219(of)-220(man,)-225(whose)-219(knowledge)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(must)-255(be)-254(imperfect,)-256(it)-254(must)-255(be)-254(still)-255(more)-254(so)-255(to)-254(accept)-254(them)-255(on)-254(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authority)-250(of)-250(him)-250(who)-250(knows)-250(all)-250(things,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 172.124 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 16.058 0 Td [(God.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
411 0 obj <<
/Length 4862      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(IV.)-250(Miracles,)-250(What)-250(Do)-250(They)-250(Prove?)-6784(85)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(I)-358(am)-358(aware)-358(that)-359(certain)-358(writers)-358(have)-358(given)-358(such)-358(a)-358(represen-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tation)-338(of)-338(faith)-338(as)-338(to)-337(produce)-338(the)-338(impression)-338(that)-338(it)-338(is)-338(one)-338(of)-337(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(special)-341(functions)-341(to)-341(accept)-340(certain)-341(dogmas,)-364(the)-341(terms)-341(of)-340(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-320(extremely)-320(obscure,)-337(or)-320(absolutely)-319(incomprehensible.)-460(But)-319(no)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(rational)-436(evidence)-436(can)-436(be)-435(adduced)-436(in)-436(support)-436(of)-436(this)-435(position.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(To)-352(exert)-705(actual)-353(belief)-352(in)-353(a)-352(proposition)-353(the)-352(terms)-353(of)-352(which)-352(are)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([093])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(incomprehensible,)-275(is)-270(an)-271(impossibility,)-275(and)-270(we)-270(only)-270(deceive)-270(our-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(selves)-265(when)-266(we)-265(imagine)-265(that)-266(we)-265(can.)-296(All)-265(that)-265(we)-266(can)-265(do)-265(in)-265(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cases)-239(is)-239(to)-239(repeat)-238(words,)-242(but)-238(if)-239(they)-239(have)-239(no)-239(definite)-239(meaning)-238(we)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(cannot)-243(believe)-242(them:)-247(for)-243(the)-242(act)-243(of)-243(faith)-242(or)-243(conviction)-243(is)-242(founded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-289(the)-290(affirmation)-289(that)-290(the)-289(two)-290(terms)-289(of)-290(a)-289(particular)-289(proposition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agree.)-519(It)-340(is)-340(quite)-340(true)-340(that)-340(the)-339(facts)-340(and)-340(statements)-340(of)-340(the)-339(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-410(run)-411(up)-410(into)-410(principles)-411(which)-410(transcend)-410(our)-410(limited)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-309(of)-309(reason;)-339(but)-309(this)-309(is)-310(common)-309(to)-309(it,)-324(and)-309(every)-309(system)-309(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(science)-371(or)-372(philosophy;)-431(and)-372(forms)-371(no)-371(peculiarity)-371(of)-372(religion.)-613(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(am)-345(far)-345(from)-345(wishing)-345(to)-345(affirm)-345(that)-345(theologians)-345(have)-345(not)-345(fallen)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-274(this)-274(practice;)-287(but)-274(my)-274(concern)-274(is)-274(not)-275(with)-274(them,)-280(but)-274(with)-274(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(statements)-372(of)-371(the)-372(New)-372(Testament.)-615(One)-371(of)-372(the)-372(most)-371(important)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acquisitions)-228(made)-228(to)-227(our)-228(mental)-228(science)-228(in)-227(the)-228(present)-228(day)-228(is)-227(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(we)-345(have)-346(ascertained)-345(that)-345(there)-345(are)-345(limits)-346(to)-345(our)-345(mental)-345(powers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beyond)-179(which)-180(we)-179(cannot)-179(penetrate.)-227(This)-179(was)-179(imperfectly)-179(realized)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-230(many)-229(of)-230(the)-229(reasoners)-230(of)-229(earlier)-230(times,)-233(and)-230(the)-229(result)-230(has)-229(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-250(they)-250(have)-250(fallen)-250(into)-250(a)-250(hazy)-250(mysticism,)-250(or)-250(logomachy.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Equally)-397(pernicious)-398(is)-397(the)-397(view)-397(that)-398(there)-397(is)-397(something)-397(par-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ticularly)-312(meritorious)-313(in)-312(accepting)-312(truth)-312(on)-313(little)-312(or)-312(no)-312(evidence,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-293(that)-292(to)-293(do)-293(so)-292(is)-293(a)-293(high)-292(act)-293(of)-293(faith.)-378(Not)-292(only)-293(is)-293(this)-292(founded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-389(no)-388(rational)-389(principle,)-423(but)-389(it)-388(is)-389(entirely)-388(unsupported)-389(by)-388(any)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(account)-230(of)-230(faith)-230(as)-231(given)-230(in)-230(the)-230(New)-230(Testament,)-234(which)-230(again)-230(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(again)-321(assumes)-322(the)-321(contrary)-321(position.)-464(Faith)-322(is)-321(the)-321(acceptance)-321(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truths)-228(which)-229(lie)-228(beyond)-229(the)-228(sphere)-229(of)-228(our)-229(personal)-228(knowledge)-228(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-362(adequate)-362(attestation.)-585(If)-362(an)-361(astronomer)-362(should)-362(happen)-362(to)-361(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ignorant)-313(of)-313(chemistry,)-328(and)-313(accept)-313(its)-312(truths)-313(on)-313(the)-313(testimony)-312(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(one)-312(who)-311(was)-312(an)-311(eminent)-312(master)-312(of)-311(it,)-327(this)-312(would)-311(constitute)-623(an)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([094])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(act)-250(of)-250(faith.)-250(Surely)-250(such)-250(an)-250(act)-250(is)-250(one)-250(which)-250(is)-250(highly)-250(rational.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
416 0 obj <<
/Length 1647      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(86)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(It)-210(follows,)-219(therefore,)-218(that)-211(although)-210(our)-211(belief)-210(in)-211(miracles)-210(being)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(founded,)-237(as)-233(it)-234(now)-233(must)-234(be,)-236(on)-234(testimony,)-237(is)-233(an)-233(act)-234(of)-233(faith,)-237(yet)-233(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-279(also)-279(an)-280(act)-279(of)-279(our)-279(reason.)-338(It)-279(is,)-286(therefore,)-287(by)-279(no)-279(means)-279(absurd)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-384(speak)-385(of)-384(miracles)-384(as)-385(objects)-384(of)-384(faith,)-418(and)-384(at)-385(the)-384(same)-384(time)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-298(possessing)-297(an)-298(evidential)-297(value.)-393(We)-298(accept)-297(them)-298(as)-297(we)-298(do)-297(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-302(adequately)-303(attested)-302(facts,)-315(and)-302(reason)-303(on)-302(them)-302(in)-302(the)-302(same)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manner)-248(as)-249(we)-248(do)-248(on)-248(other)-249(facts.)-249(This)-248(is)-249(the)-248(precise)-248(course)-248(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will)-369(be)-368(pursued)-369(by)-369(the)-368(overwhelming)-369(majority)-369(of)-368(astronomers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-240(will)-239(be)-240(unable)-240(to)-239(witness)-240(the)-240(coming)-240(transit)-239(of)-240(Venus.)-246(They)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(will)-305(accept)-305(the)-305(facts)-305(on)-305(adequate)-305(testimony,)-319(and)-304(afterwards)-305(use)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-250(as)-250(media)-250(of)-250(proof.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -29.64 Td [([095])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
424 0 obj <<
/Length 3733      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-271(V.)-272(The)-271(Antecedent)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Improbability)-259(of)-260(Miracles.)]TJ/F20 18.9589 Tf 200.979 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 18.9589 Tf 18.959 0 Td [(The)]TJ -219.938 -24.646 Td [(Unknown)-250(and)-250(Unknowable)-250(God.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -37.658 Td [(The)-274(proof)-273(on)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 60.454 0 Td [(\340)-274(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 36.885 0 Td [(grounds)-274(that)-273(an)-274(event)-273(is)-274(either)-273(possible)-274(or)]TJ -97.339 -13.549 Td [(probable,)-204(cannot)-193(establish)-192(that)-193(it)-193(has)-192(actually)-193(occurred.)-231(This)-192(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rest)-268(on)-267(its)-268(own)-268(particular)-267(evidence.)-303(To)-268(prove)-268(that)-267(a)-268(revelation)-267(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(both)-265(possible)-266(and)-265(probable,)-269(and)-265(that)-265(it)-266(ought)-265(to)-265(be)-265(evidenced)-265(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles,)-228(may)-222(form)-223(an)-222(essential)-223(portion)-222(of)-223(our)-222(general)-222(argument,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(because)-190(the)-190(degree)-190(of)-190(probability)-190(of)-190(the)-190(occurrence)-190(of)-190(a)-190(particular)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-304(affects)-303(the)-304(amount)-303(of)-303(positive)-304(evidence)-303(necessary)-304(to)-303(estab-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lish)-349(its)-348(truth.)-546(But)-349(the)-349(proof)-348(that)-349(a)-349(revelation)-348(has)-349(actually)-348(been)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(given,)-397(or)-367(a)-367(miracle)-367(wrought,)-397(can)-367(only)-367(be)-367(effected)-367(through)-367(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same)-319(media)-318(as)-319(those)-319(through)-319(which)-318(other)-319(facts)-319(are)-318(established.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(To)-260(prove)-259(that)-260(a)-260(revelation)-260(is)-259(probable)-260(will)-260(not)-259(be)-260(of)-260(the)-259(smallest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(avail)-231(to)-231(prove)-231(that)-230(one)-231(has)-231(been)-231(actually)-231(given,)-235(without)-230(adequate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proof)-250(of)-250(the)-250(fact)-250(itself.)]TJ 11.956 -14.597 Td [(Still)-246(the)-247(examination)-246(of)-246(the)-247(antecedent)-246(question)-246(is)-247(in)-246(this)-246(case)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(particularly)-336(important,)-356(because)-336(modern)-335(unbelief)-336(boldly)-335(affirms)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-262(a)-261(revelation)-262(and)-262(its)-261(attestation)-262(of)-262(miracles)-261(are)-262(both)-261(impossi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ble)-251(and)-250(incredible.)-252(If)-250(this)-251(can)-250(be)-251(demonstrated,)-250(the)-251(discussion)-250(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-329(evidence)-330(that)-329(can)-330(be)-329(adduced)-330(for)-329(them)-330(as)-329(facts)-330(is)-329(a)-329(useless)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(expenditure)-266(of)-265(our)-266(reasoning)-266(powers;)-273(for)-266(no)-265(evidence)-266(can)-265(prove)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-278(occurrence)-279(of)-278(that)-278(which)-278(is)-279(impossible.)-334(It)-557(may)-278(be)-278(assumed,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([096])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(however,)-268(that)-264(those)-264(who)-264(make)-265(this)-264(affirmation)-264(are)-264(not)-264(quite)-264(sat-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(isfied)-213(as)-213(to)-212(the)-213(cogency)-213(of)-213(their)-212(reasonings;)-225(because,)-221(after)-212(having)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demonstrated,)-318(as)-305(they)-305(allege,)-318(that)-305(miracles)-304(are)-305(impossible,)-318(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(proceed)-293(to)-292(attack)-293(the)-292(evidence)-293(of)-292(those)-293(narrated)-292(in)-293(the)-292(Gospels,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-444(pronounce)-444(it)-443(worthless.)-832(As,)-492(therefore,)-492(the)-444(opponents)-443(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
288 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 884
/Length 8862      
>>
stream
286 0 283 57 290 146 292 261 289 317 294 420 296 535 297 592 293 647 299 712
301 827 298 884 303 961 305 1076 302 1132 307 1221 309 1336 306 1392 310 1457 313 1496
315 1552 311 1667 317 1723 314 1780 320 1857 322 1972 319 2029 324 2106 326 2221 323 2278
328 2355 330 2470 327 2527 332 2604 334 2719 331 2776 336 2865 338 2980 339 3034 335 3089
341 3154 343 3269 340 3325 346 3428 348 3543 345 3599 350 3664 352 3779 349 3836 354 3901
356 4016 353 4073 358 4138 360 4253 357 4308 362 4373 364 4488 365 4545 361 4601 367 4678
369 4793 366 4849 372 4914 374 5029 371 5086 376 5163 378 5278 375 5335 380 5400 382 5515
379 5571 384 5648 386 5763 383 5820 388 5897 390 6012 391 6069 387 6124 393 6201 395 6316
392 6373 398 6450 400 6565 397 6622 402 6699 404 6814 401 6870 406 6947 408 7062 405 7119
410 7196 412 7311 413 7367 409 7423 415 7488 417 7603 414 7659 418 7724 421 7763 423 7863
% 286 0 obj
<<
/D [284 0 R /XYZ 195.524 366.679 null]
>>
% 283 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 290 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 291 0 R
/Resources 289 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 287 0 R
>>
% 292 0 obj
<<
/D [290 0 R /XYZ 374.173 436.88 null]
>>
% 289 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F37 246 0 R /F38 247 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 294 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 295 0 R
/Resources 293 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 287 0 R
>>
% 296 0 obj
<<
/D [294 0 R /XYZ 146.156 491.077 null]
>>
% 297 0 obj
<<
/D [294 0 R /XYZ 298.473 93.24 null]
>>
% 293 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 299 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 300 0 R
/Resources 298 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 287 0 R
>>
% 301 0 obj
<<
/D [299 0 R /XYZ 198.629 162.623 null]
>>
% 298 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 303 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 304 0 R
/Resources 302 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 287 0 R
>>
% 305 0 obj
<<
/D [303 0 R /XYZ 46.771 233.642 null]
>>
% 302 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 307 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 308 0 R
/Resources 306 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 287 0 R
>>
% 309 0 obj
<<
/D [307 0 R /XYZ 93.543 434.327 null]
>>
% 306 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 310 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index5) >>
% 313 0 obj
(Chapter IV. Miracles, What Do They Prove?)
% 315 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 316 0 R
/Resources 314 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 318 0 R
>>
% 311 0 obj
<<
/D [315 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 317 0 obj
<<
/D [315 0 R /XYZ 205.084 120.339 null]
>>
% 314 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 320 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 321 0 R
/Resources 319 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 318 0 R
>>
% 322 0 obj
<<
/D [320 0 R /XYZ 113.921 174.536 null]
>>
% 319 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 324 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 325 0 R
/Resources 323 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 318 0 R
>>
% 326 0 obj
<<
/D [324 0 R /XYZ 327.401 258.286 null]
>>
% 323 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 328 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 329 0 R
/Resources 327 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 318 0 R
>>
% 330 0 obj
<<
/D [328 0 R /XYZ 294.575 323.577 null]
>>
% 327 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 332 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 333 0 R
/Resources 331 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 318 0 R
>>
% 334 0 obj
<<
/D [332 0 R /XYZ 101.818 394.596 null]
>>
% 331 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 336 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 337 0 R
/Resources 335 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 318 0 R
>>
% 338 0 obj
<<
/D [336 0 R /XYZ 93.543 461.6 null]
>>
% 339 0 obj
<<
/D [336 0 R /XYZ 93.543 63.775 null]
>>
% 335 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 341 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 342 0 R
/Resources 340 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 344 0 R
>>
% 343 0 obj
<<
/D [341 0 R /XYZ 46.771 133.976 null]
>>
% 340 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F37 246 0 R /F38 247 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 346 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 347 0 R
/Resources 345 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 344 0 R
>>
% 348 0 obj
<<
/D [346 0 R /XYZ 93.543 204.809 null]
>>
% 345 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 350 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 351 0 R
/Resources 349 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 344 0 R
>>
% 352 0 obj
<<
/D [350 0 R /XYZ 305.041 286.611 null]
>>
% 349 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 354 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 355 0 R
/Resources 353 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 344 0 R
>>
% 356 0 obj
<<
/D [354 0 R /XYZ 312.033 342.036 null]
>>
% 353 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 358 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 359 0 R
/Resources 357 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 344 0 R
>>
% 360 0 obj
<<
/D [358 0 R /XYZ 46.771 433.52 null]
>>
% 357 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 362 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 363 0 R
/Resources 361 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 344 0 R
>>
% 364 0 obj
<<
/D [362 0 R /XYZ 333.956 504.626 null]
>>
% 365 0 obj
<<
/D [362 0 R /XYZ 249.769 106.79 null]
>>
% 361 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 367 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 368 0 R
/Resources 366 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 370 0 R
>>
% 369 0 obj
<<
/D [367 0 R /XYZ 278.866 190.54 null]
>>
% 366 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 372 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 373 0 R
/Resources 371 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 370 0 R
>>
% 374 0 obj
<<
/D [372 0 R /XYZ 142.258 228.732 null]
>>
% 371 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 376 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 377 0 R
/Resources 375 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 370 0 R
>>
% 378 0 obj
<<
/D [376 0 R /XYZ 145.715 298.933 null]
>>
% 375 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 380 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 381 0 R
/Resources 379 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 370 0 R
>>
% 382 0 obj
<<
/D [380 0 R /XYZ 215.37 367.497 null]
>>
% 379 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 384 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 385 0 R
/Resources 383 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 370 0 R
>>
% 386 0 obj
<<
/D [384 0 R /XYZ 217.001 421.694 null]
>>
% 383 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 388 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 389 0 R
/Resources 387 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 370 0 R
>>
% 390 0 obj
<<
/D [388 0 R /XYZ 284.043 491.077 null]
>>
% 391 0 obj
<<
/D [388 0 R /XYZ 93.543 92.499 null]
>>
% 387 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 393 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 394 0 R
/Resources 392 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 396 0 R
>>
% 395 0 obj
<<
/D [393 0 R /XYZ 165.683 148.665 null]
>>
% 392 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 398 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 399 0 R
/Resources 397 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 396 0 R
>>
% 400 0 obj
<<
/D [398 0 R /XYZ 295.172 228.732 null]
>>
% 397 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 402 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 403 0 R
/Resources 401 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 396 0 R
>>
% 404 0 obj
<<
/D [402 0 R /XYZ 93.362 298.933 null]
>>
% 401 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 406 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 407 0 R
/Resources 405 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 396 0 R
>>
% 408 0 obj
<<
/D [406 0 R /XYZ 186.925 382.683 null]
>>
% 405 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 410 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 411 0 R
/Resources 409 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 396 0 R
>>
% 412 0 obj
<<
/D [410 0 R /XYZ 88.389 450.429 null]
>>
% 413 0 obj
<<
/D [410 0 R /XYZ 313.704 79.691 null]
>>
% 409 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 415 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 416 0 R
/Resources 414 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 396 0 R
>>
% 417 0 obj
<<
/D [415 0 R /XYZ 93.543 353.043 null]
>>
% 414 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 418 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index6) >>
% 421 0 obj
(Chapter V. The Antecedent Improbability of Miracles.--The Unknown and Unknowable God.)
% 423 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 424 0 R
/Resources 422 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 426 0 R
>>
endstream
endobj
430 0 obj <<
/Length 4789      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(88)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Christianity)-469(boldly)-469(affirm)-469(that)-469(both)-469(a)-469(supernatural)-468(revelation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-291(miracles)-292(are)-291(impossible,)-302(it)-291(is)-292(necessary)-291(that)-292(the)-291(defender)-291(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity)-250(should)-250(examine)-250(the)-250(validity)-250(of)-250(the)-250(assertion.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(Our)-215(opponents)-216(constantly)-215(charge)-216(us)-215(with)-215(reasoning)-216(in)-215(a)-215(circle,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(or)-323(assuming)-323(the)-323(fact)-323(which)-324(ought)-323(to)-323(be)-323(proved.)-469(To)-323(avoid)-323(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(appearance)-250(of)-250(this,)-250(I)-250(lay)-250(down)-250(the)-250(following)-250(positions:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 253.909 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -241.953 -14.777 Td [(If)-308(direct)-307(atheism)-308(is)-308(a)-307(just)-308(conclusion)-308(from)-307(the)-308(phenomena)-307(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-374(Universe,)-404(it)-373(follows)-374(that)-373(a)-374(divine)-373(revelation)-374(is)-373(impossible.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Nor)-220(are)-220(miracles)-221(in)-220(any)-220(proper)-220(sense)-220(of)-221(the)-220(word)-220(less)-220(so,)-226(because)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-308(are)-308(not)-307(merely)-308(facts)-308(occurring)-308(in)-308(external)-307(nature,)-323(but)-307(facts)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-350(the)-349(production)-350(of)-349(which)-349(we)-350(recognize)-349(intelligence)-350(and)-349(will.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(With)-205(the)-204(principles)-205(of)-205(atheism)-205(the)-204(occurrence)-205(of)-205(an)-204(extraordinary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(event)-251(is)-250(quite)-251(compatible,)-250(because)-251(as)-251(it)-250(cannot)-251(rise)-250(to)-251(any)-250(higher)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowledge)-232(than)-232(that)-232(of)-232(phenomena,)-235(the)-232(knowledge)-232(of)-232(the)-231(invari-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ability)-273(of)-273(past)-274(phenomena)-273(is)-273(incapable)-273(of)-274(giving)-273(the)-273(fact)-273(that)-273(all)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(future)-370(phenomena)-370(will)-370(resemble)-371(the)-370(past.)-610(Still)-370(the)-370(occurrence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-251(a)-251(fact,)-251(however)-251(extraordinary,)-251(would)-251(not)-251(constitute)-251(a)-250(miracle,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-294(would)-293(prove)-294(only)-293(the)-294(existence)-294(of)-293(an)-294(unknown)-293(force)-294(in)-293(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(universe,)-250(or)-250(the)-250(predominance)-250(of)-250(chance.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(The)-236(same)-235(remark)-236(is)-235(equally)-236(applicable)-235(to)-236(that)-235(form)-236(of)-235(modern)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(atheism)-318(which)-318(does)-318(not)-319(affirm)-318(that)-318(no)-318(God)-318(exists,)-335(but)-318(contents)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(itself)-250(with)-250(the)-250(denial)-250(that)-250(there)-250(is)-250(any)-250(evidence)-250(that)-250(there)-250(is)-250(one.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(Nor)-255(is)-255(the)-255(case)-255(altogether)-255(different)-255(with)-255(regard)-255(to)-510(pantheism.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([097])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(According)-299(to)-300(this)-299(system,)-312(God)-299(is)-299(only)-300(another)-299(name)-299(for)-299(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-263(works)-264(out)-263(every)-263(form)-264(of)-263(fleeting)-263(existence)-264(for)-263(itself)-263(in)-263(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unceasing)-319(round)-318(of)-319(unconscious)-319(self-evolution.)-456(The)-319(essence)-318(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-278(affirmation)-277(is,)-285(that)-277(God)-278(has)-278(no)-277(conscious)-278(personal)-277(existence,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(but)-213(that)-212(He)-213(is)-213(only)-212(another)-213(name)-213(for)-212(the)-213(blind)-213(unconscious)-212(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-240(the)-240(universe.)-247(Such)-240(a)-240(being)-240(\050if)-240(it)-240(is)-240(possible)-240(to)-240(conceive)-239(of)-240(it)-240(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-275(being)-276(at)-275(all,)-282(or)-276(as)-275(a)-275(unity\051)-276(is)-275(everlastingly)-276(making)-275(a)-275(revelation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-256(itself)-255(by)-256(a)-255(ceaseless)-256(evolution)-255(of)-256(phenomena,)-257(the)-255(result)-256(of)-255(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(blind)-234(action)-235(of)-234(its)-234(inherent)-235(forces.)-245(But)-234(to)-234(whom?)-245(Obviously)-234(only)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-302(beings)-303(capable)-302(of)-302(reason)-302(and)-302(consciousness,)-316(whom)-302(it)-302(\050I)-302(dare)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-330(say,)-351(He\051)-330(has)-331(evolved)-330(out)-330(of)-331(its)-330(own)-330(bosom,)-351(and)-330(will)-330(again)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
434 0 obj <<
/Length 4935      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(89)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(resolve)-209(into)-208(unconsciousness.)-236(Prior)-209(to)-209(their)-208(evolution)-209(this)-208(mighty)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 4.691 0 Td [(x)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 9.095 0 Td [(\300)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 5.738 0 Td [(\266)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.727 0 Td [(\275)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.193 0 Td [(must)-336(have)-335(been)-336(everlastingly)-336(making)-335(manifestations)-336(of)]TJ -34.444 -13.549 Td [(itself,)-251(without)-251(a)-250(single)-251(being)-251(in)-250(existence)-251(capable)-251(of)-250(recognizing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them.)-393(Whatever)-297(be)-298(the)-297(result)-297(of)-298(such)-297(theories)-298(in)-297(a)-298(logical)-297(point)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-325(view,)-344(it)-326(is)-325(evident)-325(that)-326(if)-325(pantheism)-325(be)-326(a)-325(rational)-325(account)-325(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-253(order)-253(of)-254(the)-253(universe,)-254(a)-253(revelation)-253(and)-253(miracles,)-254(in)-253(any)-253(sense)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(which)-250(such)-250(terms)-250(can)-250(bear)-250(meaning,)-250(are)-250(impossible.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(No)-381(less)-381(applicable)-380(is)-381(the)-381(same)-381(remark)-380(to)-381(that)-381(form)-381(of)-380(pan-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(theism)-400(held)-401(by)-400(Mr.)-701(Herbert)-400(Spencer,)-438(which,)-438(while)-400(it)-400(affirms)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-366(existence)-367(of)-366(a)-366(cause)-366(of)-367(all)-366(things,)-395(as)-367(alike)-366(required)-366(by)-366(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demands)-368(of)-368(philosophy,)-398(science,)-398(and)-368(religion,)-397(yet)-368(affirms)-368(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(He)-324(is)-323(unknown)-324(and)-324(unknowable,)-342(and)-324(that)-323(every)-324(thing)-324(which)-323(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowable,)-217(although)-208(a)-208(manifestation)-208(of)-208(that)-208(great)-208(unknown)-208(cause,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(yet)-420(conveys)-420(no)-420(idea)-421(of)-420(Him)-420(that)-420(the)-420(intellect)-420(can)-420(apprehend.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(In)-321(one)-321(word,)-339(the)-321(unknown)-321(cause)-321(of)-321(all)-321(things)-321(is)-321(inconceivable,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-306(incapable)-306(of)-306(becoming)-307(the)-306(subject)-306(of)-306(rational)-306(thought.)-418(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(intellect)-306(cannot)-306(help)-306(assuming)-307(the)-306(existence)-306(of)-306(this)-306(cause)-306(of)-306(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(things;)-378(but)-335(all)-335(that)-335(it)-335(can)-335(affirm)-335(of)-335(him)-335(is,)-356(that)-335(He)-335(is)-335(unknown)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-301(unknowable;)-653(and)-301(that)-301(everything)-301(within)-301(the)-301(bounds)-301(of)-300(our)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([098])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(knowledge,)-233(though)-228(it)-229(may)-229(represent)-228(some)-229(mode)-228(of)-229(his)-228(existence,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-329(be)-329(he,)-348(or)-329(like)-329(him.)-487(With)-328(respect)-329(to)-329(this)-329(theory,)-349(while)-328(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(cleverly)-217(evades)-217(some)-217(of)-217(the)-217(harsher)-217(difficulties)-217(of)-217(pantheism)-216(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(atheism,)-255(it)-254(is)-253(not)-254(too)-254(much)-254(to)-253(say)-254(that)-254(it)-254(is)-253(a)-254(civil)-254(way)-254(of)-253(bowing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God)-278(out)-278(of)-277(the)-278(universe,)-285(of)-278(which)-278(He)-277(is)-278(alleged)-278(to)-278(be)-278(the)-277(cause.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-230(can)-230(neither)-230(be)-229(a)-230(person,)-234(nor)-230(have)-230(wisdom,)-234(nor)-230(be)-229(benevolent,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nor)-237(be)-236(capable)-237(of)-237(conscious)-236(self-manifestation;)-241(because)-237(all)-236(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conceptions)-263(are)-264(limited)-263(and)-263(finite.)-290(All)-263(that)-263(we)-264(can)-263(know)-263(of)-263(Him)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is,)-293(that)-284(such)-284(a)-284(cause)-284(exists)-285(beyond)-284(present)-284(phenomena;)-301(and)-284(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-281(are)-281(condemned)-281(respecting)-281(Him,)-289(to)-281(a)-281(profound)-280(and)-281(perpetual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ignorance.)-241(It)-224(is)-223(possible)-224(to)-223(designate)-224(such)-224(a)-223(being)-224(by)-223(the)-224(name)-223(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God,)-277(but)-272(it)-272(would)-272(be)-271(to)-272(use)-272(the)-272(term)-272(in)-271(a)-272(sense)-272(peculiar)-272(to)-271(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-264(thus)-265(employ)-264(it.)-293(Such)-264(a)-265(God)-264(is)-264(a)-265(bare)-264(abstract)-264(conception)-264(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-186(intellect,)-198(void)-186(of)-185(all)-186(moral)-186(value.)-228(It)-186(is)-186(sufficient)-185(for)-186(my)-185(present)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purpose)-258(to)-258(observe)-258(that)-258(it)-258(is)-258(impossible)-258(for)-258(the)-258(unknown)-258(and)-257(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
438 0 obj <<
/Length 4874      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(90)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(unknowable)-328(to)-329(make)-328(a)-328(revelation)-328(of)-328(himself.)-485(Consequently)-328(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Paul's)-336(affirmation)-335(with)-336(respect)-335(to)-335(the)-336(unknown)-335(God)-336(at)-335(Athens,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Whom)-188(therefore)-188(ye)-187(ignorantly)-188(worship,)-200(Him)-188(declare)-188(I)-188(unto)-187(you)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 270.942 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(\050Acts)-235(xvii.)-245(23\051,)-237(is)-235(untrue.)-245(To)-235(such)-234(a)-235(God)-234(a)-235(revelation)-235(of)-234(Himself,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-250(miracles)-250(to)-250(confirm)-250(it,)-250(are)-250(alike)-250(impossible.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-363(is)-364(evident,)-391(therefore,)-392(that)-363(if)-363(either)-364(of)-363(these)-363(principles)-363(can)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(be)-289(demonstrated)-289(to)-289(be)-290(a)-289(true)-289(account)-289(of)-289(the)-289(nature)-289(of)-290(things,)-298(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(further)-344(discussion)-344(as)-344(to)-344(the)-344(truth)-344(of)-344(a)-344(revelation)-344(or)-344(of)-344(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-355(useless.)-564(Let)-354(us)-355(take)-355(the)-355(most)-354(favourable)-355(hypothesis,)-381(that)-354(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Mr.)-451(Spencer.)-450(It)-317(concedes)-317(that)-317(the)-317(necessities)-317(of)-317(reason)-316(compel)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(us)-357(to)-356(assume)-357(the)-356(existence)-357(of)-357(an)-356(unknown)-357(cause)-356(of)-357(all)-356(things,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-407(may)-407(be)-406(called)-407(God.)-720(But)-407(He)-407(is)-407(unknowable;)-485(He)-407(is)-406(in-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(scrutable.)-634(No)-378(conception)-377(of)-756(Him)-378(can)-378(be)-378(realized)-378(in)-377(thought;)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([099])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(it)-350(follows,)-374(therefore,)-375(that)-350(no)-349(revelation)-350(of)-350(such)-349(a)-350(being)-350(can)-349(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-380(to)-380(the)-379(finite)-380(intellect)-380(of)-380(man,)-412(for)-379(if)-380(a)-380(revelation)-380(of)-379(Him)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(could)-359(be)-360(made,)-387(He)-359(cannot)-359(be)-360(unknowable.)-578(This)-359(being)-360(so,)-386(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(person)-395(who)-395(attempts)-394(to)-395(reason)-395(out)-394(the)-395(truth)-395(of)-395(Christianity)-394(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(placed)-309(under)-309(a)-309(difficulty.)-427(Christianity)-309(assumes)-309(the)-309(existence)-308(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-323(personal)-323(God,)-341(possessed)-323(of)-323(moral)-323(attributes.)-469(This)-323(is)-323(the)-323(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth,)-291(the)-284(evidence)-283(of)-283(which)-283(these)-283(systems)-283(assert)-283(to)-283(be)-283(wanting.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(The)-329(Christian)-330(advocate,)-349(therefore,)-350(has)-329(only)-330(two)-329(courses)-329(before)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(him:)-395(First,)-341(To)-323(assume,)-341(in)-322(conformity)-323(with)-323(the)-322(all)-323(but)-322(universal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belief)-279(of)-279(mankind,)-286(that)-279(a)-279(personal)-279(God)-278(exists;)-294(and)-279(then)-279(to)-278(argue)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-297(the)-296(truth)-297(of)-296(Christianity,)-309(and)-296(to)-297(answer)-296(the)-297(objections)-296(urged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(against)-370(it.)-610(When)-370(we)-370(do)-370(this,)-400(objectors)-370(affirm)-370(that)-370(we)-369(beg)-370(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(question.)-658(Or,)-419(Secondly,)-420(To)-386(prove)-386(the)-386(existence)-386(of)-386(a)-385(personal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God;)-351(and)-318(then)-317(to)-318(argue)-318(for)-317(the)-318(truth)-317(of)-318(revelation.)-452(If)-318(he)-317(adopts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-305(latter)-305(course,)-319(he)-305(is)-305(compelled)-305(to)-305(adduce)-305(the)-305(proof)-304(on)-305(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-263(belief)-263(in)-262(theism)-263(rests,)-266(and)-263(to)-262(answer)-263(the)-263(objections)-263(to)-262(it)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 257.906 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.91 0 Td [(or,)]TJ -268.816 -13.549 Td [(in)-255(other)-255(words,)-256(to)-255(compose)-255(a)-255(bulky)-255(volume,)-256(before)-255(he)-255(can)-255(get)-255(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(immediate)-250(subject)-250(of)-250(inquiry.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Now)-435(I)-436(affirm)-435(that)-436(the)-435(defender)-436(of)-435(Christianity)-436(is)-435(no)-435(more)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(open)-253(to)-253(the)-253(charge)-254(of)-253(begging)-253(the)-253(question)-253(when)-253(he)-253(assumes)-253(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-270(of)-270(a)-270(personal)-271(God)-270(as)-270(the)-270(foundation)-270(of)-270(his)-270(reasonings,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
442 0 obj <<
/Length 4987      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(91)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(than)-359(the)-359(author)-360(of)-359(a)-359(treatise)-359(on)-359(trigonometry)-360(is,)-386(who)-359(takes)-359(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(granted)-250(the)-250(truth)-250(of)-250(Euclid's)-250(propositions.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(The)-275(author)-275(of)-275(the)-275(work)-275(to)-275(which)-275(I)-275(have)-275(already)-275(referred)-275(does)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(his)-273(utmost)-272(to)-273(fasten)-273(on)-272(the)-273(modern)-273(defenders)-272(of)-273(Christianity)-272(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(charge)-319(that)-319(they)-318(begin)-319(and)-319(end)-318(in)-319(assumptions.)-456(I)-319(will)-319(not)-318(deny)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-214(much)-213(ambiguous)-214(language)-214(has)-213(been)-214(used)-213(on)-214(this)-214(subject,)-220(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-308(trust)-308(I)-308(shall)-308(show)-307(that)-308(the)-308(charge)-308(is)-308(utterly)-308(unfounded.)-424(I)-307(must)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(briefly)-250(notice)-250(a)-250(few)-250(of)-250(his)-250(reasonings.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([100])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -14.776 Td [(At)-315(page)-315(68)-315(he)-315(writes)-316(as)-315(follows:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 148.994 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Dr.)-445(Mozley)-315(is)-316(well)-315(aware)]TJ -165.794 -13.549 Td [(that)-417(the)-417(assumption)-417(of)-418(a)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 116.081 0 Td [(\030)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 3.633 0 Td [(personal)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 36.96 0 Td [(\031)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.183 0 Td [(God)-417(is)-417(not)-417(susceptible)-418(of)]TJ -164.856 -13.55 Td [(proof;)-236(indeed,)-234(this)-230(is)-230(admitted)-230(in)-229(the)-230(statement)-230(that)-230(the)-229(definition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-250(an)-250(assumption.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 75.458 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -63.503 -14.776 Td [(An)-216(assumpt)1(ion,)-223(I)-215(ask,)-223(in)-215(what)-216(sense?)-238(Is)-216(it)-215(a)-216(simple)-216(assumption)]TJ -11.955 -13.55 Td [(without)-443(evidence,)-491(taken)-444(for)-443(granted)-443(for)-443(the)-443(bare)-443(purposes)-443(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(argument;)-456(or)-388(is)-387(it)-388(one)-388(which,)-422(though)-387(taken)-388(for)-387(granted)-388(in)-387(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(present)-299(case,)-311(rests)-299(on)-298(a)-299(substantial)-299(basis)-299(of)-299(evidence)-298(previously)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(established,)-248(and)-248(which)-248(bears)-248(the)-247(same)-248(relation)-248(to)-248(the)-248(question)-247(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-256(which)-256(the)-256(truths)-256(of)-256(Euclid)-256(do)-256(to)-256(those)-256(of)-256(trigonometry?)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(The)-334(latter)-334(is)-333(the)-334(fact)-334(though)-334(the)-333(mode)-334(in)-334(which)-334(the)-334(writer)-333(puts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-322(implies)-322(the)-323(former.)-466(Without)-322(referring)-323(to)-322(the)-322(authority)-322(of)-322(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(particular)-286(author,)-294(is)-286(he)-286(not)-286(fully)-285(aware)-286(that)-286(theists)-286(maintain)-285(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-189(belief)-188(in)-189(a)-188(Personal)-189(God)-188(rests)-189(on)-189(a)-188(basis)-189(of)-188(proof)-189(which)-188(com-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mends)-217(itself)-218(to)-217(their)-217(reason?)-239(Have)-218(not)-217(numbers)-217(of)-218(men,)-223(endowed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-299(the)-299(highest)-298(powers)-299(of)-299(intellect,)-311(accepted)-299(it)-299(as)-298(satisfactory?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Yet)-361(he)-362(seeks)-361(to)-361(imply)-362(that,)-389(after)-361(all,)-389(it)-361(is)-362(an)-361(assumption.)-584(It)-361(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(true)-268(that)-269(in)-268(the)-268(argument)-269(for)-268(miracles)-268(we)-269(take)-268(it)-268(for)-269(granted;)-277(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-240(do)-241(so,)-242(because)-240(the)-240(proof)-241(has)-240(commended)-240(itself)-241(to)-240(our)-240(highest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason.)]TJ 11.955 -14.777 Td [(I)-272(admit)-273(that)-272(Dr.)-318(Mozley)-272(has)-273(used,)-278(in)-272(speaking)-273(of)-272(this)-273(subject,)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(language)-299(which)-299(I)-299(cannot)-298(but)-299(think)-299(is)-299(wanting)-299(in)-299(precision.)-396(Still)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-440(does)-440(not)-440(bear)-439(the)-440(meaning)-440(that)-440(this)-440(author)-440(seeks)-440(to)-439(fasten)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-416(it.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 32.396 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(It)-416(is)-416(then)-416(to)-416(be)-416(admitted,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 115.108 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.381 0 Td [(says)-416(he,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 41.338 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(that)-416(historically,)]TJ -207.91 -13.55 Td [(and)-270(looking)-269(to)-270(the)-269(general)-270(actual)-269(reception)-270(of)-269(it,)-275(this)-269(conception)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-373(God)-374(was)-373(derived)-373(from)-373(revelation.)-620(Not)-374(from)-373(the)-373(first)-373(dawn)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
446 0 obj <<
/Length 4940      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(92)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(of)-348(history)-347(to)-348(the)-348(spread)-347(of)-348(Christianity)-347(in)-348(the)-348(world)-347(do)-348(we)-347(see)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-397(mankind)-397(at)-397(large)-398(any)-397(belief)-397(in)-397(such)-397(a)-397(Being.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 218.053 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.176 0 Td [(The)-397(learned)]TJ -227.229 -13.549 Td [(author)-381(then)-382(states,)-414(at)-381(considerable)-382(length,)-414(the)-381(philosophic)-381(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(vulgar)-402(views)-403(entertained)-402(of)-403(God,)-440(and)-403(shows)-402(their)-402(inadequacy)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-555(imperfection,)-285(and)-277(concludes)-278(as)-277(follows:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 200.022 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(But)-278(although)-277(this)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -277.62 0 Td [([101])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(conception)-218(of)-217(the)-218(Deity)-217(has)-218(been)-217(received)-218(through)-217(the)-218(channel)-217(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-298(Bible,)-310(what)-298(communicates)-298(a)-298(truth)-298(is)-298(one)-298(thing,)-310(what)-298(proves)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-250(is)-250(another.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 54.24 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(He)-250(then)-250(proceeds)-250(to)-250(summarize)-250(the)-250(general)-250(proof.)]TJ -49.855 -18.459 Td [(I)-311(cannot)-312(think)-312(this)-311(statement)-312(altogether)-311(free)-312(from)-311(ambiguity.)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Whatever)-345(may)-346(have)-345(been)-345(the)-346(precise)-345(forms)-345(in)-346(which)-345(the)-345(ideas)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-302(the)-302(vulgar)-302(or)-303(the)-302(philosopher)-302(were)-302(embodied,)-315(there)-302(is)-302(strong)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(proof)-421(that)-422(a)-421(higher)-421(and)-422(better)-421(conception)-422(of)-421(God,)-464(though)-421(in-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(definite)-381(and)-380(indistinct,)-413(underlay)-381(them)-381(all.)-641(The)-381(most)-380(degraded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(polytheist)-223(has)-222(indistinct)-223(conceptions)-223(of)-223(a)-222(Supreme)-223(God)-223(above)-222(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-304(degraded)-303(objects)-304(of)-304(his)-303(worship.)-411(It)-304(seems)-303(to)-304(me)-303(impossible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-473(such)-473(a)-473(conception)-473(of)-473(God)-473(can)-473(have)-473(been)-473(attained)-473(from)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(revelation.)-682(It)-394(may,)-429(in)-394(a)-394(certain)-394(sense,)-430(be)-394(said,)-430(looking)-394(at)-393(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(precise)-253(form)-252(in)-253(which)-253(it)-253(is)-252(embodied,)-254(that)-253(it)-252(has)-253(been)-253(derived)-252(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us)-238(historically)-238(from)-239(the)-238(Jewish)-238(race.)-246(But)-238(it)-239(must)-238(have)-238(had)-238(a)-238(prior)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(origin.)-279(St.)-279(Paul)-260(considered)-260(that)-259(the)-260(material)-260(universe)-259(manifested)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-341(eternal)-341(power)-341(and)-341(Godhead.)-522(The)-341(primitive)-341(form)-341(of)-341(all)-340(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(great)-392(oriental)-391(religions)-392(contained)-392(in)-392(them)-391(the)-392(idea)-392(of)-391(God.)-675(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-367(simply)-366(absurd)-367(to)-366(affirm)-366(that)-367(they)-366(derived)-367(it)-366(from)-367(the)-366(Bible.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-329(is)-329(true)-329(that)-328(the)-329(existence)-329(of)-329(a)-329(primitive)-329(revelation)-329(anterior)-328(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-248(Bible)-248(has)-248(often)-247(been)-248(assumed)-248(to)-248(account)-248(for)-248(this)-247(knowledge,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-366(this)-366(is)-366(a)-366(bare)-367(assumption)-366(of)-366(which)-366(we)-366(have)-366(no)-366(proof,)-395(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whose)-348(only)-347(basis)-348(is)-348(conjecture.)-543(Judaism)-347(and)-348(Christianity)-347(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-230(instrumental)-230(in)-230(widely)-230(spreading)-230(correct)-230(conceptions)-230(of)-230(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Deity)-322(and)-322(dissipating)-323(false)-322(ones.)-466(Yet)-323(if)-322(the)-322(conception)-322(had)-322(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existed)-225(in)-225(the)-225(mind)-224(at)-225(least)-225(implicitly,)-230(no)-225(formal)-225(revelation)-224(could)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-275(put)-276(it)-275(there,)-282(for)-275(every)-276(such)-275(revelation)-275(must)-276(be)-275(conveyed)-275(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(language,)-320(and)-306(all)-307(language)-306(is)-306(meaningless,)-320(unless)-306(the)-306(mind)-306(can)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(realize)-345(its)-346(conceptions.)-535(The)-346(assertion,)-738(therefore,)-369(that)-345(the)-345(con-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([102])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(ception)-229(of)-229(God)-230(has)-229(been)-229(first)-229(communicated)-229(through)-229(the)-229(channel)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
451 0 obj <<
/Length 4746      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(93)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(of)-345(the)-345(Bible,)-368(and)-345(is)-345(afterwards)-345(proved)-344(by)-345(reason,)-369(seems)-345(to)-344(me)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-293(be)-294(one)-293(not)-294(devoid)-293(of)-293(danger.)-381(On)-293(the)-293(contrary,)-305(our)-293(belief)-293(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God)-268(exists)-268(is)-269(the)-268(very)-268(pre-condition)-268(of)-269(our)-268(being)-268(able)-268(to)-268(believe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-348(He)-348(has)-348(revealed)-348(Himself.)-544(This)-348(conception)-348(revelation)-347(may)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(modify,)-304(invest)-292(with)-293(a)-293(higher)-293(moral)-293(character,)-303(and)-293(import)-293(into)-292(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(definiteness)-328(and)-328(precision,)-348(but)-328(it)-328(cannot)-327(create)-328(it.)-484(It)-328(is)-328(on)-328(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(grounds)-206(that)-206(the)-206(author)-206(in)-206(question)-206(seeks)-206(to)-206(involve)-206(his)-205(reasoning)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-261(that)-260(of)-261(all)-261(other)-260(defenders)-261(of)-261(Christianity)-260(in)-261(a)-261(vicious)-260(circle.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-324(fully)-324(admit)-324(that)-323(the)-324(conception)-324(of)-324(God)-324(has)-324(been)-324(elevated)-323(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(purified)-359(by)-358(the)-359(influence)-359(of)-359(Christianity,)-385(and)-359(that)-359(the)-358(teaching)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-300(Christianity)-300(on)-300(this)-301(subject)-300(is)-300(in)-300(conformity)-300(with)-300(our)-300(highest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason.)-245(But)-235(it)-234(is)-235(absurd)-234(to)-235(affirm)-235(that)-234(this)-235(is)-235(reasoning)-234(in)-235(a)-234(circle,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-237(that)-236(the)-237(Christian)-237(argument)-236(involves)-237(reasoning)-237(from)-236(Theism)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(Christianity)-250(and)-250(from)-250(Christianity)-250(back)-250(to)-250(Theism.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(The)-192(following)-192(passage,)-204(cited)-193(by)-192(Professor)-192(Mozley)-192(from)-192(Baden)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Powell,)-345(is)-326(referred)-326(to)-326(by)-326(this)-326(author)-326(as)-326(a)-326(proof)-326(that)-326(all)-326(our)-326(rea-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sonings)-395(on)-395(this)-395(subject)-395(are)-395(a)-395(simple)-395(argument)-395(from)-395(reason)-394(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(revelation,)-347(and)-327(from)-327(revelation)-327(to)-327(reason.)-482(The)-327(passage)-327(itself)-327(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-295(clear)-296(statement)-295(of)-295(the)-295(grounds)-296(of)-295(the)-295(charge,)-307(and)-295(requires)-295(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(careful)-368(consideration.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 102.405 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Everybody)-368(may)-369(collect)-368(from)-368(the)-368(order)]TJ -107.248 -13.549 Td [(and)-373(harmony)-373(of)-373(the)-373(physical)-373(universe)-373(the)-373(existence)-373(of)-373(a)-372(God;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-377(in)-377(acknowledging)-377(a)-376(God,)-409(we)-377(do)-377(not)-377(thereby)-376(acknowledge)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-375(peculiar)-374(or)-375(doctrinal)-374(conception)-375(of)-374(a)-374(God.)-624(We)-374(see)-375(in)-374(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(structure)-398(of)-397(nature)-398(a)-398(mind,)-434(a)-398(universal)-398(mind,)-434(but)-398(still)-398(a)-397(mind)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-382(only)-382(operates)-382(and)-382(expresses)-382(itself)-382(by)-382(law.)-646(Nature)-381(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(does)-285(and)-286(can)-285(inform)-285(us)-286(of)-285(mind)-286(in)-285(nature;)-303(but)-285(in)-286(no)-285(other)-285(sense)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(does)-309(nature)-310(witness)-309(to)-309(the)-309(existence)-310(of)-309(an)-309(omnipotent)-309(Supreme)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Being.)-408(Of)-303(a)-606(universal)-303(mind)-302(out)-303(of)-303(nature,)-316(nature)-303(says)-302(nothing;)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([103])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(and)-267(of)-267(an)-267(omnipotence)-268(which)-267(does)-267(not)-267(possess)-267(an)-267(inherent)-267(limit)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-258(nature,)-260(she)-258(says)-258(nothing)-258(either.)-274(And)-258(therefore)-258(that)-258(conception)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-217(a)-218(supreme)-217(Being)-217(which)-218(represents)-217(Him)-217(as)-218(a)-217(spirit)-217(independent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-245(the)-244(physical)-244(universe,)-246(and)-245(able)-244(from)-245(a)-244(standing-point)-244(external)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-251(nature,)-250(to)-251(interrupt)-250(its)-251(order,)-250(is)-251(a)-250(conception)-251(of)-250(God)-251(for)-250(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-281(must)-281(go)-281(elsewhere.)-343(That)-281(conception)-281(is)-281(attained)-281(from)-281(revela-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
456 0 obj <<
/Length 4796      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(94)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(tion,)-300(which)-290(is)-291(asserted)-290(to)-290(be)-290(proved)-290(by)-291(miracles.)-370(But)-290(that)-290(being)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-335(case,)-357(this)-335(doctrine)-335(of)-335(theism)-335(rests)-336(itself)-335(upon)-335(miracles,)-356(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-250(miracles)-250(cannot)-250(rest)-250(on)-250(this)-250(doctrine)-250(of)-250(theism.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 246.316 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -234.36 -15.186 Td [(It)-515(will)-515(be)-514(necessary)-515(carefully)-515(to)-515(point)-515(out)-515(the)-514(inaccurate)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(reasoning)-250(of)-250(this)-250(passage.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(First:)-427(The)-338(author)-338(speaks)-339(of)-338(nature)-338(as)-339(another)-338(expression)-338(for)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-348(forces,)-372(laws,)-372(and)-348(phenomena)-347(of)-348(the)-348(physical)-347(universe,)-372(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-274(these)-274(alone.)-321(To)-274(this)-274(I)-274(have)-273(no)-274(objection,)-280(for)-274(it)-274(would)-273(greatly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conduce)-303(to)-304(clearness)-303(if)-304(it)-303(was)-304(always)-303(confined)-304(to)-303(this)-303(meaning.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(But)-348(while)-348(he)-348(uses)-347(it)-348(thus,)-372(he)-348(nowhere)-348(tells)-348(us)-348(in)-348(what)-347(relation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man,)-374(including)-349(his)-349(faculties,)-374(intellectual)-349(and)-349(moral,)-373(and)-349(above)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all,)-304(his)-292(will,)-304(stands)-293(to)-292(nature.)-379(Are)-293(they)-292(included)-293(in,)-304(or)-292(excluded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-320(it?)-461(Do)-320(they,)-338(or)-320(do)-320(they)-320(not,)-338(form)-320(a)-320(part)-320(of)-321(it?)-460(If)-320(they)-320(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(included)-235(in)-236(nature,)-238(then)-236(there)-235(are)-235(other)-236(facts)-235(in)-236(nature)-235(bearing)-235(on)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-236(being)-235(of)-236(a)-236(God,)-238(beyond)-236(those)-236(on)-235(which)-236(the)-236(author)-235(reasons.)-245(If)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-237(are)-236(excluded,)-239(then)-237(the)-236(reasoning)-237(is)-236(inadequate)-237(to)-236(sustain)-236(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conclusion.)-247(Our)-239(reasonings)-240(respecting)-239(God)-240(are)-239(founded)-240(not)-239(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-215(the)-214(forces)-215(and)-215(laws)-214(of)-215(physical)-215(nature,)-222(but)-214(on)-215(man,)-222(his)-214(reason,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-319(conscience,)-335(and)-319(his)-318(will.)-456(What)-318(makes)-319(this)-318(fallacy)-319(the)-318(more)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(plausible)-208(is)-207(that)-208(the)-207(term)-208(nature)-208(is)-207(very)-208(frequently)-207(used)-208(to)-207(include)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man,)-250(as)-250(well)-250(as)-250(the)-250(forces)-250(and)-250(laws)-250(of)-250(the)-250(material)-250(universe.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([104])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -15.186 Td [(As)-304(far)-303(as)-304(the)-304(physical)-304(universe)-303(is)-304(concerned,)-317(the)-304(mind)-303(infers)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-231(existence)-230(of)-231(a)-231(God)-230(from)-231(its)-231(order)-231(and)-230(its)-231(harmonies;)-237(that)-231(is)-230(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(say,)-200(having)-188(observed)-188(that)-188(order)-188(and)-188(harmony)-188(have)-188(been)-187(produced)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-377(intelligence)-377(within)-376(the)-377(sphere)-377(of)-377(our)-376(own)-377(observation,)-408(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-279(deeply)-278(convinced)-279(on)-278(other)-278(grounds)-279(of)-278(reasoning)-279(that)-278(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-346(incapable)-346(of)-345(resulting)-346(from)-346(any)-346(other)-345(source,)-370(we)-346(infer)-345(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-410(results)-409(we)-410(behold)-410(in)-409(nature)-410(are)-410(due)-409(to)-410(a)-410(similar)-409(principle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-285(we)-286(experience)-285(in)-286(ourselves.)-356(Such)-286(an)-285(inference)-286(is)-285(not)-285(due)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-209(simple)-210(observation)-209(of)-209(the)-210(order)-209(of)-209(the)-209(universe)-210(only,)-217(but)-209(unites)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-351(it)-350(an)-351(act)-351(of)-350(reasoning)-351(founded)-351(on)-350(our)-351(own)-350(self-conscious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being.)-510(But)-337(the)-337(intelligence)-337(which)-337(produces)-337(order,)-358(as)-337(far)-337(as)-336(we)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-309(cognisant)-310(of)-309(it,)-325(is)-309(invariably)-310(united)-309(with)-310(will.)-428(We)-309(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(infer)-411(from)-410(the)-411(order)-410(and)-411(harmonies)-410(of)-411(nature,)-450(not)-411(simply)-410(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
460 0 obj <<
/Length 4812      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(95)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(conception)-280(of)-281(a)-280(God,)-288(such)-280(as)-281(the)-280(God)-280(of)-281(pantheism;)-295(but,)-288(if)-280(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-384(valid)-385(to)-384(prove)-384(anything)-384(at)-384(all,)-418(of)-385(a)-384(God)-384(who)-384(is)-384(possessed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-425(intelligence)-425(adequate)-426(to)-425(arrange)-425(the)-425(order,)-469(and)-425(of)-425(purpose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adequate)-313(for)-314(its)-313(production.)-440(If)-313(the)-313(inference)-314(of)-313(the)-313(existence)-313(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-373(God)-373(from)-374(the)-373(works)-373(of)-373(nature)-373(is)-374(valid,)-404(it)-373(must)-373(be)-373(of)-373(a)-373(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessed)-297(of)-296(the)-297(attributes)-297(in)-296(question,)-309(for)-296(all)-297(our)-297(inferences)-296(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-378(a)-379(subject)-378(derive)-378(their)-378(validity)-378(from)-379(applying)-378(to)-378(them)-378(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(analogies)-250(of)-250(our)-250(reason.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-243(is)-242(quite)-243(true)-242(that)-243(in)-242(the)-243(structure)-242(of)-243(the)-242(material)-243(universe)-242(we)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(see)-223(only)-223(the)-222(indications)-223(of)-223(a)-222(mind)-223(operating)-223(and)-223(expressing)-222(itself)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-366(law;)-424(that)-366(is)-365(to)-366(say,)-395(we)-366(observe)-366(in)-366(the)-366(physical)-366(universe)-365(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instances)-262(of)-261(its)-262(violation.)-285(But)-261(WE,)-262(that)-262(is)-261(the)-262(reasoning,)-264(rational)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beings,)-430(whether)-394(existing)-394(in)-394(nature)-394(or)-394(outside)-394(it,)-430(have)-393(inferred)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-266(the)-265(structure)-266(of)-265(the)-266(universe)-265(the)-266(existence)-265(of)-266(mind,)-269(and)-265(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(know)-184(of)-184(no)-183(mind)-184(which)-184(is)-184(not)-183(possessed)-184(of)-184(conscious)-183(intelligence)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-235(will.)-245(If)-234(our)-235(reasoning)-235(from)-234(the)-235(order)-235(of)-234(the)-235(material)-234(universe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-696(valid)-348(to)-348(prove)-348(the)-348(presence)-348(of)-348(mind,)-372(which)-348(is)-348(a)-348(conception)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([105])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(entirely)-269(derived)-268(from)-269(our)-269(consciousness)-268(of)-269(ourselves,)-273(it)-269(must)-268(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(equally)-389(so)-389(to)-388(prove)-389(the)-389(existence)-389(of)-388(purpose)-389(and)-389(volition,)-423(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-370(know)-370(nothing)-370(of)-369(mind)-370(which)-370(is)-370(devoid)-370(of)-370(these)-369(attributes.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(The)-340(material)-339(universe)-340(proves)-339(that)-340(its)-339(order)-340(and)-339(harmony)-340(is)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(result)-353(of)-352(the)-353(action)-352(of)-353(mind;)-403(but)-353(it)-352(cannot)-353(prove)-352(that)-353(the)-352(mind)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-346(produced)-347(this)-346(order)-347(and)-346(harmony)-346(is)-347(unable)-346(to)-346(introduce)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-305(different)-305(one.)-415(But)-305(if)-305(our)-305(minds)-305(form)-306(part)-305(of)-305(nature,)-318(then)-305(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-406(a)-407(proof)-406(that)-406(the)-407(author)-406(of)-406(nature)-407(has)-406(produced)-406(something)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(else)-362(in)-362(nature)-362(besides)-361(the)-362(order)-362(and)-362(harmonies)-362(of)-362(the)-361(physical)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(universe.)-240(If)-221(they)-221(are)-220(outside)-221(nature,)-227(then)-220(we)-221(have)-221(direct)-220(evidence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-326(the)-325(existence)-325(of)-326(beings)-325(outside)-326(and)-325(above)-326(nature,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 236.051 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 18.528 0 Td [(above)]TJ -254.579 -13.549 Td [(the)-235(physi)1(cal)-235(forces)-234(of)-235(the)-234(universe.)-245(It)-235(follows)-234(that)-235(if)-234(finite)-234(beings)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessed)-244(of)-244(intelligence)-244(and)-245(will,)-245(exist)-244(within)-244(nature)-244(or)-244(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it,)-250(a)-250(God)-250(who)-250(possesses)-250(similar)-250(powers)-250(may)-250(exist)-250(also.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(In)-446(a)-447(narrow)-446(and)-447(restricted)-446(sense)-447(it)-446(may)-447(be)-446(quite)-447(true)-446(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(nature,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 34.48 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 20.29 0 Td [(matter)-379(and)-380(its)-379(phenomena,)-412(only)-379(informs)-379(us)-380(of)-379(the)]TJ -54.77 -13.549 Td [(presence)-308(of)-308(mind)-308(in)-308(nature,)-322(the)-308(partner)-308(and)-308(correlative)-308(of)-307(orga-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
464 0 obj <<
/Length 4598      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(96)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(nized)-248(matter.)-249(But)-249(let)-248(us)-248(here)-248(guard)-248(against)-248(a)-248(latent)-248(fallacy)-248(in)-248(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mode)-382(of)-382(statement.)-647(We)-382(learn)-382(the)-382(presence)-382(of)-382(mind,)-415(not)-382(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(material)-295(nature,)-306(but)-295(by)-295(the)-295(application)-295(of)-295(our)-295(own)-295(reason)-295(to)-295(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(investigation)-287(of)-286(what)-287(its)-286(phenomena)-287(denote.)-359(This)-287(is)-286(overlooked)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-292(the)-293(above)-292(argument.)-377(It)-292(is)-292(perfectly)-292(true)-292(that)-293(as)-292(a)-292(mere)-292(matter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-263(phenomenal)-263(appearance,)-266(we)-263(do)-263(not)-263(actually)-263(behold)-263(in)-262(natural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena)-247(manifestations)-247(of)-247(mind)-247(acting)-247(outside)-247(nature.)-249(In)-247(fact)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-389(do)-388(not)-389(see)-389(mind)-389(at)-388(all,)-424(but)-389(simply)-388(infer)-389(its)-389(presence)-388(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-251(phenomena)-251(before)-251(us)-250(through)-251(the)-251(agency)-251(of)-251(our)-251(own)-250(reason;)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-278(this)-279(inference)-278(carries)-279(along)-278(with)-278(it)-279(all)-278(the)-279(other)-278(attributes)-278(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mind.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-409(writer)-410(before)-409(me)-409(is)-409(one)-410(of)-409(those)-409(who)-410(affirm)-409(that)-818(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([106])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(utmost)-386(our)-387(minds)-386(can)-387(infer)-386(from)-386(the)-387(contemplation)-386(of)-386(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-459(which)-459(he)-460(includes)-459(every)-459(species)-459(of)-460(vital)-459(organism,)-511(is)-459(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presence)-341(of)-341(order)-340(and)-341(harmony;)-386(and)-341(that)-341(any)-341(inference)-341(that)-340(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(phenomena)-219(testify)-219(to)-219(the)-219(presence)-219(of)-219(adaptation,)-225(contrivance)-219(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(design)-357(is)-357(invalid.)-571(I)-357(reply)-357(that)-357(this)-357(affirmation)-357(is)-357(only)-357(valid)-357(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-297(assumption)-297(of)-297(a)-297(principle)-297(which)-297(altogether)-297(denies)-297(that)-296(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural)-309(phenomena)-308(we)-309(can)-308(infer)-309(the)-308(existence)-309(of)-308(mind.)-426(But)-308(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(also)-281(observe)-280(in)-280(natural)-281(phenomena,)-288(and)-281(above)-280(all)-280(in)-281(animal)-280(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(vegetable)-190(structures,)-201(that)-190(the)-190(results)-190(effected)-189(are)-190(produced,)-202(not)-189(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(simple)-282(forces,)-290(but)-282(by)-282(the)-282(careful)-282(adjustment)-282(of)-282(many,)-290(or)-282(by)-281(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(counteracting)-232(and)-232(qualifying)-232(the)-232(action)-232(of)-232(another,)-235(and)-232(by)-232(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intersecting)-399(one)-399(another)-399(at)-399(precisely)-399(the)-399(right)-399(time)-399(and)-398(place.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Had)-237(any)-237(of)-236(these)-237(occurred)-237(otherwise,)-239(the)-237(result)-237(would)-237(have)-236(been)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(different.)-389(Throughout)-296(nature)-296(we)-296(observe)-296(innumerable)-296(instances)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-212(which)-212(various)-212(forces)-211(have)-212(thus)-212(combined)-212(to)-212(produce)-212(a)-211(definite)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(result.)-868(This)-457(we)-456(usually)-456(designate)-456(by)-456(the)-456(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 222.768 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(adaptation.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 48.174 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(Adaptation)-387(implies)-387(intelligence)-386(and)-387(purpose.)-660(We)-387(are)-387(quite)-386(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(much)-254(justified)-253(in)-254(ascribing)-253(this)-254(purpose)-254(to)-253(the)-254(power)-253(manifested)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-293(nature,)-304(as)-293(any)-293(other)-293(quality)-293(whatever,)-303(even)-293(the)-293(possession)-293(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mind.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-237(fully)-237(concede)-237(that)-238(natural)-237(phenomena)-237(and)-237(even)-237(the)-237(phenom-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ena)-237(of)-238(the)-237(mind)-238(of)-237(man,)-240(only)-238(testify)-237(directly)-238(to)-237(the)-238(existence)-237(of)-237(a)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
468 0 obj <<
/Length 4579      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(97)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(power)-293(adequate)-293(to)-293(their)-292(production,)-304(and)-293(that)-293(we)-293(cannot)-292(directly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(infer)-424(from)-424(them)-424(the)-424(presence)-424(of)-424(omnipotence.)-772(But)-424(this)-424(is)-424(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(quarrel)-290(about)-290(words.)-370(For)-290(the)-290(power)-290(manifested)-290(in)-290(nature)-290(and)-289(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-379(is)-379(so)-379(great)-380(that)-379(the)-379(human)-379(mind)-379(can)-379(make)-379(no)-379(distinction)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(between)-346(it)-346(and)-346(omnipotence;)-394(or)-346(in)-346(other)-346(words,)-370(it)-346(justly)-346(infers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-235(its)-235(manifestations)-235(that)-235(the)-235(power)-235(which)-235(could)-235(originate)-235(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(universe)-208(and)-207(all)-208(things)-207(in)-208(it)-208(must)-207(be)-208(capable)-207(of)-208(effecting)-207(anything)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-344(is)-345(possible.)-1065(To)-344(this)-344(mind,)-368(whether)-345(in)-344(or)-344(out)-344(of)-344(nature,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([107])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(our)-242(reason)-242(ascribes)-241(the)-242(attributes)-242(of)-242(intelligence)-242(and)-241(will.)-248(Such)-241(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(power)-206(it)-207(is)-206(incapable)-206(of)-207(conceiving)-206(as)-206(inherent)-207(in)-206(material)-206(forces;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-275(therefore)-275(assumes)-275(that)-275(this)-275(power)-275(exists)-274(outside)-275(nature,)-282(and)-274(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(capable)-250(of)-250(controlling)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-438(follows)-438(therefore)-437(that)-438(the)-438(reasoning)-438(is)-438(fallacious,)-484(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(asserts)-266(that)-267(the)-266(conception)-266(of)-266(a)-267(supreme)-266(Being)-266(which)-266(represents)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Him)-356(as)-357(a)-356(spirit)-356(independent)-356(of)-357(the)-356(physical)-356(universe,)-383(and)-356(able)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(from)-286(a)-286(standing-point)-285(external)-286(to)-286(nature)-286(to)-285(interrupt)-286(its)-286(order,)-294(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-359(conception)-359(which)-359(we)-359(must)-359(seek)-359(from)-358(revelation,)-387(and)-358(cannot)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-274(arrived)-274(at)-274(by)-274(any)-273(exertion)-274(of)-274(our)-274(rational)-274(powers)-274(on)-274(the)-273(facts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-299(nature)-299(and)-299(of)-300(man.)-397(Its)-299(apparent)-299(plausibility)-299(has)-299(arisen)-299(solely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-253(ignoring)-253(the)-253(presence)-253(of)-253(man,)-254(either)-253(in)-253(nature)-253(or)-253(outside)-253(it,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-309(neglecting)-309(to)-309(take)-309(the)-309(facts)-309(of)-309(human)-310(nature,)-323(man's)-309(reason,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conscience)-253(and)-254(will,)-254(into)-253(consideration.)-260(To)-253(affirm)-253(that,)-254(indepen-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dently)-264(of)-264(man's)-263(moral)-264(and)-264(intellectual)-263(being,)-268(physical)-263(nature,)-267(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-359(and)-360(laws,)-387(can)-359(prove)-359(nothing,)-387(is)-359(a)-360(simple)-359(platitude.)-578(We)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-183(not)-184(to)-183(go)-184(to)-183(revelation)-184(for)-183(the)-184(principles)-183(on)-184(which)-183(we)-183(reason,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(but)-344(to)-344(man,)-368(and)-344(the)-344(phenomena)-344(of)-345(his)-344(rational,)-367(self-conscious,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-290(voluntary)-291(agency.)-371(It)-291(follows,)-300(therefore,)-301(that)-290(the)-290(affirmation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-212(in)-211(conducting)-212(the)-212(Christian)-211(argument)-212(we)-212(reason)-211(from)-212(God)-211(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-264(and)-264(from)-264(miracles)-264(to)-264(God,)-268(is)-264(utterly)-264(disproved.)-292(Yet)-264(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writer)-203(before)-203(me)-202(has)-203(ventured)-203(to)-203(affirm)-203(that,)-212(when)-203(we)-202(commence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-455(the)-455(being)-455(of)-456(a)-455(personal)-455(God)-455(as)-455(the)-455(groundwork)-455(of)-455(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(reasonings,)-250(we)-250(begin)-250(and)-250(end)-250(with)-250(a)-250(bare)-250(assumption.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-399(philosophical)-400(writings)-399(of)-399(Dr.)-698(Mansel)-400(are)-399(also)-399(pressed)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(into)-301(the)-301(service)-300(for)-301(the)-301(purpose)-300(of)-301(discrediting)-301(the)-301(evidences)-300(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
472 0 obj <<
/Length 4862      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(98)-8755(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Christianity,)-338(and,)-338(I)-320(own,)-338(with)-321(considerably)-320(greater)-320(reason.)-461(Mr.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Herbert)-371(Spencer)-371(has)-371(also)-371(invoked)-371(them)-371(in)-371(confirmation)-371(of)-371(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(theory)-271(that)-272(God)-271(is)-272(unknown)-271(and)-271(unknowable.)-314(He)-272(refers)-271(to)-271(them)]TJ 4.577 -13.549 Td [(in)-420(the)-419(following)-420(words:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 114.096 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Here)-420(I)-419(cannot)-419(do)-420(better)-420(than)-419(avail)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -196.271 0 Td [([108])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(myself)-292(of)-293(the)-292(demonstration)-293(which)-292(Mr.)-378(Mansel,)-303(carrying)-292(out)-292(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(detail)-203(the)-203(doctrine)-204(of)-203(Sir)-203(W.)-203(Hamilton,)-213(has)-203(given)-203(us)-203(in)-203(his)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 248.503 0 Td [(\030)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 3.633 0 Td [(Limits)]TJ -252.136 -13.549 Td [(of)-222(Religious)-222(Thought.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 95.454 0 Td [(\031)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.055 0 Td [(And)-222(I)-222(gladly)-222(do)-222(this,)-227(not)-222(only)-222(because)-222(his)]TJ -101.509 -13.549 Td [(mode)-342(of)-341(presentation)-342(cannot)-342(be)-341(improved,)-365(but)-342(because)-341(writing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-261(he)-260(does)-261(in)-260(defence)-261(of)-260(current)-261(theology,)-263(his)-260(reasonings)-261(will)-260(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(more)-250(acceptable)-250(to)-250(the)-250(majority)-250(of)-250(readers.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 186.916 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -174.96 -16.004 Td [(Before)-242(referring)-241(to)-242(Dr.)-247(Mansel)-242(as)-242(an)-242(unquestionable)-241(authority)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(on)-324(this)-325(subject,)-343(it)-324(would)-325(only)-324(have)-325(been)-324(candid)-325(in)-324(both)-324(writers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-312(have)-312(informed)-311(their)-312(readers)-312(that)-311(not)-312(only)-312(have)-312(his)-311(principles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-217(repudiated)-217(by)-217(a)-217(considerable)-217(number)-217(of)-217(Christian)-217(writers)-216(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unsound,)-241(but)-238(they)-238(have)-238(been)-238(carefully)-238(examined)-238(by)-238(that)-238(eminent)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(atheistic)-371(philosopher,)-401(Mr.)-614(Mill,)-401(who)-371(gives)-371(it)-371(as)-371(his)-371(deliberate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opinion)-463(that)-462(they)-463(are)-462(founded)-463(on)-463(fallacious)-462(principles.)-888(It)-462(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(absurd)-287(to)-286(urge)-287(principles,)-296(though)-287(they)-286(have)-287(been)-287(maintained)-286(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-382(eminent)-382(Christian)-382(writer,)-415(which)-382(an)-382(eminent)-382(unbeliever)-382(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pronounced)-226(unsound,)-231(as)-226(a)-226(clear)-226(and)-226(conclusive)-226(argument)-226(against)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Christianity.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-430(work)-430(of)-430(Dr.)-791(Mansel)-430(may)-430(be)-430(described)-430(as)-430(an)-430(attempt)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-349(prove)-349(the)-348(truth)-349(of)-349(Christianity)-349(on)-348(the)-349(principles)-349(of)-349(the)-348(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sceptical)-371(philosophy.)-612(It)-371(may)-370(be)-371(briefly)-371(stated)-370(thus:)-492(Reason)-370(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incapable)-330(of)-330(forming)-330(any)-330(idea)-330(of)-330(God)-330(as)-330(He)-330(is,)-350(whether)-330(as)-330(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Infinite,)-420(the)-385(Absolute,)-420(or)-386(the)-385(first)-386(Cause.)-657(All)-386(the)-385(conceptions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-239(we)-238(can)-239(frame)-238(on)-239(the)-239(subject)-238(are)-239(mutually)-238(self-destructive.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(On)-241(similar)-242(principles)-241(our)-242(conceptions)-241(of)-241(His)-242(moral)-241(attributes)-241(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wholly)-285(inadequate)-284(to)-285(inform)-285(us)-284(of)-285(His)-285(real)-284(perfections.)-354(It)-285(by)-284(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(means)-229(follows)-229(that)-230(our)-229(human)-229(conception)-229(of)-229(benevolence)-229(or)-229(jus-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tice)-270(is)-271(a)-270(measure)-271(of)-270(the)-270(divine)-271(benevolence,)-275(or)-271(of)-270(divine)-270(justice;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-215(so)-214(of)-215(His)-214(other)-215(attributes.)-238(It)-215(is)-214(affirmed)-215(that)-215(because)-214(they)-429(are)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([109])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.55 Td [(the)-242(attributes)-242(of)-241(an)-242(infinite)-242(Being,)-243(they)-242(lie)-242(beyond)-242(the)-241(possibility)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-337(being)-337(realized)-337(in)-337(human)-337(thought.)-512(Consequently,)-358(holiness)-337(in)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
477 0 obj <<
/Length 4848      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 316.492 548.934 Td [(99)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -269.721 -30.759 Td [(God)-362(may)-362(admit)-361(of)-362(very)-362(different)-362(manifestations)-362(from)-361(holiness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-312(man.)-437(Upon)-313(these)-312(principles,)-328(which)-312(affirm)-313(the)-312(inadequacy)-312(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-300(human)-300(intellect,)-312(even)-300(to)-300(conceive)-299(of)-300(anything)-300(as)-300(it)-300(exists)-299(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God,)-403(it)-372(follows)-373(that)-372(our)-373(only)-372(possible)-372(conceptions)-373(of)-372(God)-372(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(relative;)-346(or,)-329(to)-314(use)-313(the)-314(word)-314(chosen)-313(by)-314(the)-314(author)-313(in)-314(relation)-313(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity,)-377(regulative;)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 109.406 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 19.377 0 Td [(fitted)-351(to)-352(regulate)-351(our)-352(conduct,)-376(but)]TJ -128.783 -13.549 Td [(not)-250(to)-250(illuminate)-250(our)-250(understanding.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Upon)-264(the)-264(assumption)-264(that)-264(reason,)-268(when)-264(it)-264(attempts)-264(to)-264(analyse)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(our)-219(ideas)-219(of)-218(the)-219(Infinite,)-225(the)-219(Absolute,)-225(or)-219(the)-219(first)-219(Cause,)-225(lands)-218(us)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-283(hopeless)-283(contradictions,)-292(Dr.)-349(Mansel)-283(arrives)-283(at)-283(the)-283(conclusion)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-450(it)-450(is)-450(incapable)-450(of)-450(forming)-450(any)-450(conception)-450(of)-450(God)-450(as)-450(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(actually)-273(exists.)-321(It)-273(follows)-273(as)-274(a)-273(necessary)-274(consequence)-273(from)-273(this,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-279(even)-278(by)-279(revelation)-279(we)-278(are)-279(only)-279(capable)-278(of)-279(attaining)-278(relative)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ideas)-310(of)-310(Him,)-325(and)-309(that)-310(these)-310(relative)-310(ideas)-310(do)-310(not)-310(represent)-309(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(real)-384(nature,)-418(but)-385(are)-384(only)-385(regulative)-384(of)-384(conduct,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 217.259 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 20.457 0 Td [(we)-384(are)-385(to)]TJ -237.716 -13.55 Td [(act)-402(upon)-401(them)-402(as)-401(if)-402(they)-401(were)-402(true.)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 170.13 0 Td [(E.g.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 25.261 0 Td [(God)-402(is)-401(revealed)-402(as)]TJ -195.391 -13.549 Td [(holy.)-388(Our)-295(only)-296(conception)-296(of)-296(holiness)-296(is)-296(our)-296(human)-295(conception)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-434(it.)-803(But)-434(we)-434(cannot)-434(know)-435(that)-434(this)-434(is)-434(an)-434(adequate)-434(measure)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-366(the)-365(divine)-366(holiness.)-596(God)-366(is)-365(declared)-366(to)-365(be)-366(benevolent.)-596(We)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-414(no)-415(conception)-414(of)-415(benevolence)-414(but)-414(that)-415(which)-414(is)-414(derived)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(from)-318(the)-317(human)-318(mind.)-453(So)-318(likewise)-317(with)-318(respect)-318(to)-317(justice.)-453(But)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(benevolence)-384(and)-384(justice)-384(as)-384(they)-384(exist)-384(in)-384(God)-384(may)-384(differ)-384(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-314(qualities)-315(as)-314(they)-315(exist)-314(in)-315(man.)-443(The)-314(same)-315(thing)-314(follows)-314(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-263(necessary)-264(conclusion)-263(from)-263(Dr.)-290(Mansel's)-264(premises)-263(with)-263(respect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-336(all)-336(the)-336(other)-336(attributes)-336(of)-336(God.)-508(Nothing)-336(will)-336(better)-335(illustrate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-329(position)-328(to)-329(which)-328(this)-329(argument)-329(reduces)-328(us)-329(than)-328(to)-329(apply)-328(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-327(the)-328(truthfulness)-327(or)-327(veracity)-328(of)-327(God.)-482(All)-327(that)-328(we)-327(know)-327(about)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truthfulness)-636(is)-319(as)-318(it)-318(exists)-318(in)-318(finite)-318(beings,)-335(that)-319(is,)-335(in)-318(men.)-454(But)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([110])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(God)-276(is)-276(an)-276(infinite)-276(being.)-327(It)-276(follows)-276(therefore)-276(that)-276(truthfulness)-275(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-312(is)-311(no)-312(adequate)-312(representation)-311(of)-312(truthfulness)-312(as)-311(it)-312(exists)-311(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God,)-306(that)-295(is)-295(to)-295(say,)-306(that)-295(the)-295(divine)-295(veracity)-295(may)-295(differ)-295(from)-294(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(human)-203(conception)-203(of)-202(it.)-235(This)-202(is)-203(certainly)-203(a)-203(very)-203(startling)-202(position.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(If,)-266(therefore,)-266(these)-262(principles)-263(are)-262(correct,)-266(acquiescence)-263(on)-262(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(part)-234(of)-235(man)-234(in)-234(the)-234(divine)-235(character)-234(is)-234(impossible.)-245(It)-234(is)-234(impossible)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
482 0 obj <<
/Length 5129      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(100)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(to)-180(love)-180(a)-180(being)-180(who)-179(does)-180(not)-180(present)-180(to)-180(us)-180(the)-180(aspect)-180(of)-179(loveliness;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-242(to)-241(reverence)-242(one)-241(who)-242(does)-241(not)-242(present)-241(to)-242(us)-241(an)-242(aspect)-241(capable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-406(exciting)-406(this)-406(emotion;)-483(or)-406(to)-406(feel)-406(trust)-406(in)-406(a)-406(being)-406(of)-405(whose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(justice)-295(we)-295(have)-295(no)-296(certainty)-295(that)-295(it)-295(resembles)-295(our)-295(conception)-295(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(justice;)-421(or)-364(to)-364(rely)-364(on)-364(the)-364(promises)-364(of)-364(one)-364(whose)-364(veracity)-364(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(differ)-390(from)-389(our)-390(own.)-668(Such)-390(feelings)-389(cannot)-390(be)-389(made)-390(to)-389(order.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(They)-228(can)-228(only)-228(be)-228(generated)-228(by)-228(the)-228(contemplation)-228(of)-228(a)-228(being)-227(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-266(holy,)-269(benevolent,)-270(just,)-269(and)-266(true,)-270(in)-265(the)-266(ordinary)-266(acceptation)-265(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-337(words.)-509(They)-337(cannot)-337(be)-336(excited)-337(by)-336(any)-337(merely)-336(regulative)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ideas.)-508(We)-335(love,)-358(reverence,)-357(and)-336(trust,)-357(not)-336(ideas)-336(or)-335(conceptions,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-273(persons,)-278(possessing)-272(moral)-273(attributes.)-317(But)-273(on)-272(the)-273(principle)-272(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(merely)-256(regulative)-256(ideas)-256(of)-256(God,)-258(the)-256(assertion)-256(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 217.781 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(God)-256(is)-256(love,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 53.161 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(loses)-343(all)-342(its)-343(value,)-365(if)-343(God)-343(is)-342(not)-343(what)-342(I)-343(mean)-342(by)-343(love,)-366(but,)-365(be-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cause)-259(he)-260(is)-259(infinite,)-262(he)-259(may)-259(be)-260(something)-259(else,)-262(I)-259(know)-259(not)-259(what;)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-379(thus)-379(the)-379(great)-379(precept)-379(of)-379(the)-379(moral)-379(law,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 205.095 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Thou)-379(shalt)-379(love)]TJ -209.939 -13.549 Td [(the)-328(Lord)-329(thy)-328(God)-328(with)-329(all)-328(thy)-328(heart,)-348(mind,)-348(soul,)-348(and)-328(strength,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 275.786 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(becomes)-240(meaningless.)-246(Such)-240(devotion)-239(of)-240(our)-239(entire)-240(nature)-239(cannot)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-384(created)-383(by)-384(the)-383(mere)-384(command)-383(to)-384(render)-383(it.)-651(It)-383(can)-384(only)-383(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rendered)-237(to)-237(a)-236(being)-237(whose)-237(claims)-237(over)-237(us)-236(we)-237(both)-237(feel)-237(and)-236(know)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-257(be)-257(an)-258(absolute)-257(reality,)-259(and)-257(to)-257(whom)-258(on)-257(the)-257(conviction)-257(of)-257(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reality)-251(we)-250(can)-251(offer)-251(ourselves)-251(up)-250(a)-251(voluntary)-251(sacrifice.)-252(But)-251(if)-250(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-232(know)-231(Him)-232(as)-231(He)-232(is,)-235(how)-231(is)-232(the)-231(fire)-232(of)-231(devotion)-232(to)-231(Him)-463(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([111])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(be)-264(kindled)-264(in)-265(our)-264(hearts?)-293(How)-264(shall)-264(we)-264(trust)-264(in)-265(Him?)-292(How)-264(shall)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-242(acquiesce)-242(in)-242(His)-241(character?)-248(How)-241(shall)-242(we)-242(worship)-242(Him,)-243(how)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(shall)-279(we)-279(adore)-278(Him,)-287(if)-278(it)-279(is)-279(true)-279(that)-279(the)-278(justice,)-286(benevolence,)-286(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(holiness)-211(of)-210(the)-211(divine)-211(character)-211(may)-210(not)-211(resemble)-211(our)-210(conception)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-318(them?)-453(Nay,)-335(more:)-385(the)-318(theory)-318(in)-318(question)-317(lays)-318(the)-318(axe)-318(to)-317(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(root)-276(of)-276(the)-276(Christian)-276(revelation)-276(itself.)-328(There)-276(is)-276(no)-276(affirmation)-275(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-317(New)-317(Testament)-317(more)-318(decisive)-317(than)-317(that)-317(Jesus)-317(Christ)-317(in)-317(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine)-281(and)-281(human)-281(personality)-281(is)-281(the)-281(image)-281(of)-281(the)-281(invisible)-280(God,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-201(far)-200(as)-201(His)-201(moral)-200(perfections)-201(are)-201(concerned.)-233(Are)-201(the)-200(perfections)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-300(the)-300(character)-301(of)-300(Jesus)-300(Christ)-300(only)-300(regulative,)-313(or)-300(are)-300(they)-300(real)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(representations)-288(of)-287(these)-288(attributes)-287(as)-288(they)-288(exist)-287(in)-288(God?)-363(Are)-287(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine)-265(attributes)-265(of)-265(holiness,)-269(benevolence,)-269(or)-266(justice,)-268(adequately)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
486 0 obj <<
/Length 4700      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(101)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(represented)-425(by)-425(the)-425(manifestations)-424(of)-425(them,)-469(as)-425(made)-425(by)-424(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ?)-669(If)-390(we)-390(accept)-390(the)-389(testimony)-390(of)-390(St.)-669(John's)-390(Gospel,)-424(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Lord)-242(himself)-243(has)-242(expressly)-242(affirmed,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 163.2 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(He)-242(that)-243(hath)-242(seen)-242(me)-242(hath)]TJ -168.044 -13.549 Td [(seen)-404(the)-404(Father)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 69.402 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.25 0 Td [(\050John)-404(xiv.)-712(9\051.)-711(But)-404(this)-404(is)-404(impossible)-404(if)-404(our)]TJ -78.652 -13.55 Td [(conceptions)-273(of)-274(God's)-273(moral)-273(attributes)-273(are)-274(only)-273(regulative,)-279(and)-273(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-306(human)-307(idea)-306(of)-306(holiness)-306(is)-306(no)-307(adequate)-306(representation)-306(of)-306(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(However)-297(erroneous)-296(a)-297(system)-296(may)-297(be,)-308(yet)-296(if)-297(it)-296(has)-297(been)-296(elab-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(orated)-302(by)-302(a)-302(powerful)-302(mind,)-315(it)-302(has)-302(generally)-302(some)-302(foundation)-302(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason,)-241(and)-240(I)-239(am)-239(far)-240(from)-239(affirming)-239(that,)-242(with)-239(considerable)-239(qual-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ifications,)-378(some)-353(important)-352(elements)-353(of)-352(truth)-353(may)-352(not)-353(be)-352(found)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-300(that)-299(of)-300(Dr.)-399(Mansel.)-399(It)-300(is)-300(well)-299(that)-300(we)-300(should)-299(be)-300(made)-300(to)-299(feel)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-345(there)-345(are)-345(limits)-344(of)-345(thought)-345(beyond)-345(which)-345(the)-345(human)-344(mind)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-295(penetrate,)-306(and)-295(that)-294(there)-295(are)-295(profundities)-295(of)-294(metaphysics)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-225(an)-224(imperfect)-225(measuring-line)-224(cannot)-225(reach.)-241(But)-225(placing)-224(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(matter)-286(as)-286(he)-285(has,)-295(the)-286(Christian)-285(apologist)-286(may)-286(well)-286(feel)-285(indebted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-218(Mr.)-239(Mill)-217(for)-218(his)-218(crushing)-217(demolition)-218(of)-217(the)-218(dangerous)-217(portions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-211(Dr.)-237(Mansel's)-210(system.)-237(When)-211(unbelievers)-211(quote)-210(the)-422(authority)-210(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([112])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(Dr.)-245(Mansel,)-239(why)-235(do)-236(they)-236(not)-235(also)-236(tell)-236(their)-235(readers)-236(that)-236(there)-235(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-362(least)-362(one)-362(unbeliever)-361(of)-362(very)-362(high)-362(logical)-362(power,)-390(who)-361(wrote)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(against)-250(the)-250(validity)-250(of)-250(his)-250(system.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-247(is)-247(one)-247(thing)-247(to)-248(affirm)-247(that)-247(we)-247(cannot)-247(penetrate)-247(to)-247(the)-247(depths)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-348(the)-348(Deity,)-373(and)-348(that)-348(after)-348(we)-348(have)-348(raised)-348(our)-348(thoughts)-348(to)-348(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(highest,)-500(there)-449(is)-450(something)-450(higher)-450(still;)-549(and)-450(quite)-450(another)-449(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-321(that)-321(our)-322(highest)-321(thoughts)-321(of)-321(him)-321(have)-322(no)-321(validity;)-356(or,)-339(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(use)-275(the)-275(terms)-275(of)-274(a)-275(fashionable)-275(philosophy,)-281(that)-275(God)-275(is)-274(unknown)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-286(unknowable,)-295(that)-286(no)-286(true)-286(conception)-286(of)-286(Him)-286(can)-286(be)-285(formed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-316(thought;)-348(in)-316(one)-315(word,)-332(that)-316(he)-315(is)-316(absolutely)-316(unthinkable.)-446(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difficulties)-284(of)-285(this)-284(subject)-285(have)-284(arisen)-284(mainly)-285(from)-284(discussing)-284(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-367(terms)-367(of)-367(pure)-367(abstractions,)-396(instead)-367(of)-367(embodying)-367(them)-367(in)-367(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(concrete)-288(form.)-364(It)-289(is)-288(impossible)-288(in)-288(this)-288(place)-288(to)-288(enter)-288(on)-288(the)-288(pro-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(found)-235(depths)-234(involved)-234(in)-235(these)-234(questions;)-240(but)-235(a)-234(few)-234(observations)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(will)-206(be)-207(necessary)-206(for)-207(the)-206(purpose)-207(of)-206(clearing)-207(away)-206(the)-206(difficulties)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-240(which)-240(our)-239(opponents)-240(seek)-240(to)-240(involve)-240(the)-239(subject)-240(of)-240(miracles.)-246(I)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
490 0 obj <<
/Length 4901      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(102)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(shall)-250(confine)-250(myself)-250(to)-250(our)-250(conceptions)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Infinite.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-178(is)-178(affirmed)-177(that)-178(no)-178(conception)-178(of)-178(the)-177(infinite)-178(can)-178(be)-178(framed)-177(in)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(thought;)-224(that)-211(it)-211(is)-211(therefore)-211(unthinkable,)-219(and)-211(transcends)-211(the)-211(limits)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-248(human)-248(knowledge;)-248(that)-248(it)-248(is)-248(a)-248(negation;)-249(and)-248(that)-248(therefore)-247(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason)-258(is)-258(unable)-257(to)-258(affirm)-258(anything)-258(respecting)-257(it;)-262(that)-258(the)-258(idea)-257(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(personality)-306(is)-306(incompatible)-306(with)-306(that)-306(of)-306(infinity;)-334(and)-306(that)-305(there-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fore)-324(when)-324(we)-324(speak)-324(of)-324(God)-324(as)-324(a)-324(person)-324(who)-324(possesses)-323(infinite)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(perfections,)-205(we)-194(enter)-194(on)-194(a)-194(region)-194(where)-194(human)-194(thought)-194(is)-194(invalid,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(respecting)-250(which)-250(all)-250(affirmation)-250(involves)-250(a)-250(contradiction.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-437(when)-438(we)-437(are)-438(told)-437(that)-437(the)-438(infinite)-437(transcends)-437(thought,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(we)-374(are)-374(entitled)-375(to)-374(demand)-374(that)-374(we)-375(should)-374(not)-374(be)-374(kept)-374(playing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-318(an)-319(abstraction,)-335(and)-318(to)-319(ask,)-335(what)-318(is)-319(infinite?)-455(In)-318(what)-318(sense)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(does)-300(it)-300(transcend)-301(thought?)-801(Does)-300(this)-301(mean)-300(that)-300(it)-300(is)-300(absolutely)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([113])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(unthinkable;)-478(or)-402(only)-402(partially)-401(so;)-478(or)-402(that)-402(our)-402(conception)-402(of)-401(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-439(imperfect?)-815(Is)-439(it)-438(simply)-439(unknowable,)-485(or)-439(does)-438(it)-439(consist)-438(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(something)-371(which)-370(we)-370(know,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 128.302 0 Td [(plus)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 22.227 0 Td [(something)-371(that)-370(has)-370(not)-371(come)]TJ -150.529 -13.549 Td [(within)-345(the)-345(limits)-345(of)-345(our)-345(knowledge,)-369(but)-345(which)-345(something)-345(is)-345(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-370(similar)-369(character)-370(to)-369(the)-370(known?)-609(It)-369(will)-370(be)-370(at)-369(once)-370(seen)-369(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-324(determination)-323(of)-324(these)-324(questions)-323(is)-324(at)-324(the)-323(root)-324(of)-324(the)-323(whole)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(controversy.)-464(If)-321(then)-321(by)-321(the)-322(infinite)-321(we)-321(mean)-321(something)-321(known)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(plus)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 21.967 0 Td [(something)-347(unknown,)-370(to)-347(speak)-346(of)-347(God)-347(as)-346(unknowable)-347(and)]TJ -21.967 -13.549 Td [(unthinkable)-315(is)-315(absurd.)-446(Our)-315(knowledge)-315(of)-316(Him)-315(may)-315(not)-315(be)-315(full,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-363(yet)-363(real)-364(so)-363(far)-363(as)-363(it)-364(goes.)-589(When)-363(it)-364(is)-363(affirmed)-363(that)-363(God)-363(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-348(being)-348(who)-348(exists,)-373(but)-348(is)-348(unthinkable)-348(by)-348(man,)-373(the)-348(effect)-348(is)-348(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(place)-238(Him)-238(beyond)-238(the)-238(bounds)-239(of)-238(human)-238(knowledge,)-240(and)-238(thereby)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(free)-271(us)-272(from)-271(all)-272(necessity)-271(of)-271(troubling)-272(ourselves)-271(about)-271(Him.)-314(We)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(know)-248(that)-248(He)-247(exists)-248(in)-248(the)-248(profundities)-248(of)-247(the)-248(unknown;)-249(and)-247(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-344(all.)-531(For)-344(the)-344(purposes)-344(of)-343(thought)-344(and)-344(of)-344(morality,)-367(He)-344(is)-343(thus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-250(of)-250(less)-250(value)-250(than)-250(an)-250(algebraic)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 160.866 0 Td [(x)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(.)]TJ -153.753 -15.186 Td [(When)-363(it)-363(is)-363(affirmed)-363(that)-364(the)-363(infinite)-363(is)-363(unknowable,)-391(I)-363(again)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ask,)-371(what)-347(infinite?)-541(The)-347(infinite)-347(as)-347(an)-347(abstract)-347(idea)-347(has)-347(no)-347(real)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence;)-397(but)-349(something)-348(that)-348(is)-348(infinite.)-545(The)-348(conception)-348(itself)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-287(an)-286(essentially)-286(quantitative)-287(conception,)-296(and)-286(is)-286(only)-287(strictly)-286(ap-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(plicable)-276(to)-276(number)-277(and)-276(extension.)-328(When)-277(I)-276(speak)-276(therefore)-276(of)-276(an)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
494 0 obj <<
/Length 4940      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(103)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(infinite)-314(number,)-330(what)-314(do)-314(I)-314(mean?)-442(The)-314(only)-314(answer)-314(possible)-313(is,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)-335(greatest)-335(number)-335(I)-335(can)-335(conceive,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 166.644 0 Td [(plus)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 21.839 0 Td [(all)-335(possible)-335(number)]TJ -193.327 -13.549 Td [(without)-386(limit.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 60.898 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.057 0 Td [(Does)-386(my)-387(adding)-386(on)-386(the)-386(latter)-387(factor)-386(invalidate)]TJ -69.955 -13.549 Td [(the)-415(reality)-415(of)-415(my)-415(conception)-415(of)-415(the)-415(former?)-745(Is)-415(that)-415(which)-415(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(added)-274(on)-274(anything)-274(else)-274(than)-275(number?)-322(Surely)-274(here)-274(I)-274(have)-274(a)-274(valid)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conception.)-495(The)-332(same)-332(is)-331(true)-332(when)-332(we)-332(speak)-331(of)-332(the)-332(infinity)-331(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(space.)-299(I)-266(mean)-267(by)-266(it)-266(the)-267(greatest)-266(space)-266(I)-266(can)-267(conceive,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 235.311 0 Td [(plus)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 21.09 0 Td [(space)]TJ -256.401 -13.549 Td [(without)-220(limit.)-241(Is)-220(the)-220(idea)-221(of)-220(space)-441(rendered)-220(unthinkable,)-226(because)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([114])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(I)-278(add)-278(the)-279(conception)-278(of)-278(space)-278(without)-279(limit?)-334(Does)-279(it)-278(cease)-278(to)-278(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(space?)-248(But)-244(space)-244(is)-244(conceivable.)-248(It)-244(follows)-244(therefore)-243(that)-244(neither)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(infinite)-282(number)-282(nor)-283(infinite)-282(extension)-282(is)-282(absolutely)-282(unthinkable.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(We)-435(speak)-434(of)-435(the)-435(infinite)-435(divisibility)-435(of)-434(matter.)-805(Does)-434(matter,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(because)-250(it)-250(goes)-250(on)-250(to)-250(be)-250(divided)-250(for)-250(ever,)-250(cease)-250(to)-250(be)-250(matter?)]TJ 11.955 -15.186 Td [(In)-237(the)-237(same)-237(manner)-237(we)-237(speak)-237(of)-237(God,)-240(and)-237(call)-237(Him)-237(infinite.)-245(It)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(would)-304(be)-304(far)-304(more)-304(correct)-304(to)-304(speak)-304(of)-304(Him)-304(as)-304(a)-304(Being)-304(who)-304(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(infinite)-253(attributes.)-258(Here,)-254(however,)-253(if)-253(accuracy)-253(of)-253(thought)-253(is)-253(to)-252(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(preserved,)-340(a)-322(distinction)-322(must)-322(be)-322(made.)-466(Some)-322(attributes)-322(of)-322(God)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(may)-267(be)-267(viewed)-267(as)-267(quantitative;)-275(others)-267(cannot.)-301(It)-267(is)-267(to)-266(the)-267(former)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-377(that)-376(the)-377(term)-377(infinite)-376(properly)-377(applies.)-630(A)-377(moral)-376(attribute)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-313(have)-313(a)-313(quantitative)-313(measure)-314(applied)-313(to)-313(it.)-439(It)-313(is)-313(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-250(infinite,)-250(but)-250(perfect.)]TJ 11.955 -15.186 Td [(When)-212(we)-211(speak)-212(of)-212(God)-211(as)-212(a)-212(being)-211(possessed)-212(of)-212(infinite)-211(power,)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(what)-254(do)-254(we)-254(mean?)-262(The)-254(thing)-254(intended)-254(is,)-255(that)-254(He)-254(is)-254(a)-254(being)-254(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possesses)-237(such)-236(power)-237(as)-237(enabled)-236(Him)-237(to)-237(create)-236(the)-237(universe,)-239(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-228(He)-228(is)-229(capable)-228(of)-228(exerting)-228(every)-228(other)-229(degree)-228(of)-228(power)-228(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-345(possible.)-534(We)-345(may)-345(call)-345(this,)-368(if)-345(we)-345(like,)-369(power)-345(without)-344(limit;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(though)-299(there)-298(is)-299(always)-299(one)-298(limit)-299(to)-298(possible)-299(power,)-311(viz.,)-311(that)-298(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(working)-327(contradictions.)-479(Of)-327(course)-326(we)-327(are)-327(ignorant)-326(of)-327(what)-326(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(limits)-250(of)-250(possible)-250(power.)]TJ 11.955 -15.186 Td [(But)-293(when)-292(we)-293(make)-292(this)-293(addition)-293(to)-292(our)-293(finite)-292(conception,)-304(we)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(mean)-212(by)-213(it)-212(power)-213(similar)-212(to)-213(that)-212(exhibited)-213(in)-212(the)-213(universe)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 245.584 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(it)-212(and)]TJ -256.493 -13.549 Td [(all)-308(other)-309(power)-308(beyond)-308(it.)-426(Must)-308(such)-308(a)-309(conception)-308(be)-308(banished)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(outside)-411(the)-410(limits)-411(of)-410(rational)-411(thought?)-732(Is)-410(the)-411(idea)-410(of)-411(a)-410(being)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-413(possesses)-412(power)-413(sufficient)-413(to)-413(build)-412(the)-413(universe,)-454(and)-412(all)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
498 0 obj <<
/Length 5029      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(104)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(possible)-335(power)-336(besides,)-356(unthinkable?)-506(Again,)-357(we)-335(speak)-335(of)-335(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-318(infinitely)-318(wise.)-455(What)-318(do)-318(we)-318(mean)-318(by)-319(it?)-454(We)-318(affirm)-318(that)-318(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knows)-228(all)-227(things)-228(actual)-227(and)-227(possible.)-485(The)-228(knowledge)-227(is)-228(none)-227(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([115])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(less)-297(knowledge,)-308(because)-297(to)-297(the)-297(knowledge)-297(of)-297(the)-297(actual)-297(we)-296(add)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-302(the)-301(knowledge)-302(of)-302(the)-301(possible.)-405(Such)-302(a)-302(being)-301(is)-302(certainly)-301(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unthinkable.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Again:)-248(God)-247(is)-246(often)-247(spoken)-246(of,)-247(not)-247(only)-246(as)-247(a)-246(being)-246(possessing)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(infinite)-234(attributes)-233(and)-234(perfections,)-237(but)-234(as)-233(the)-234(Infinite)-234(Being.)-244(Here)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-337(attempt)-337(is)-337(made)-338(to)-337(entangle)-337(us)-337(in)-337(a)-337(puzzle.)-512(It)-337(is)-337(argued:)-424(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-391(be)-392(the)-391(infinite)-391(Being,)-427(there)-391(can)-391(be)-392(no)-391(being)-391(beyond)-391(Him.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-273(must)-273(therefore)-274(include)-273(all)-273(being,)-279(both)-273(actual)-274(and)-273(possible.)-319(If)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-232(be)-232(so,)-236(He)-232(must)-232(also)-232(include)-232(the)-233(finite,)-235(otherwise)-232(there)-232(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-339(a)-339(being)-338(which)-339(is)-339(not)-339(included)-338(in)-339(infinite)-339(being)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 222.337 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(or)-339(in)-339(other)]TJ -233.246 -13.549 Td [(words,)-378(being)-353(without)-352(limit)-353(would)-353(not)-352(include)-353(all)-352(being,)-378(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-379(self-contradictory.)-639(Several)-379(other)-380(self-contradictions)-379(may)-379(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(easily)-250(adduced)-250(by)-250(reasoning)-250(on)-250(the)-250(same)-250(principles.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-177(reply)-177(that)-177(the)-176(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 85.389 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Being)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 26.062 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.773 0 Td [(is)-177(used)-177(here)-177(in)-177(a)-176(sense)-177(so)-177(intensely)]TJ -135.024 -13.549 Td [(abstract,)-269(that)-266(we)-265(have)-266(removed)-265(it)-265(out)-266(of)-265(all)-266(those)-265(conceptions)-265(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-240(quantity)-239(can)-240(legitimately)-239(be)-240(predicated.)-246(Of)-240(material)-239(being)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(we)-270(can)-270(affirm)-270(that)-270(it)-269(is)-270(quantitative,)-275(but)-270(of)-270(no)-270(other.)-310(The)-269(adding)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-302(the)-302(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 56.549 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(infinite,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 34.243 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.141 0 Td [(and)-302(calling)-302(God)-303(the)-302(infinite)-302(Being,)-315(is)-303(to)]TJ -103.777 -13.549 Td [(use)-250(words)-250(which)-250(have)-250(no)-250(validity)-250(as)-250(conceptions.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-344(it)-344(is)-344(also)-343(common)-344(to)-344(speak)-344(of)-344(God's)-344(moral)-344(attributes)-343(as)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(infinite,)-202(such)-189(as)-190(His)-189(benevolence,)-202(holiness,)-202(justice)-189(and)-190(truth.)-229(This)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(again)-349(is)-349(inaccurate,)-374(and)-349(its)-350(result)-349(is)-349(to)-349(plunge)-349(us)-349(into)-349(hopeless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(confusion)-359(of)-358(thought.)-576(Such)-359(attributes)-359(admit)-358(of)-359(no)-358(quantitative)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(measures.)-765(They)-421(are)-422(perfect,)-464(not)-421(infinite.)-765(To)-421(speak)-422(of)-421(God's)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truthfulness)-315(as)-315(infinite)-316(is)-315(simply)-315(absurd.)-445(A)-315(thing)-316(is)-315(true,)-331(or)-315(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(true.)-299(A)-266(moral)-266(being)-266(is)-267(truthful)-266(or)-266(not)-266(truthful.)-299(Benevolence)-266(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-263(perfect)-263(or)-262(imperfect;)-270(but)-263(it)-262(cannot)-263(be)-263(measured)-263(by)-263(number)-262(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-362(line.)-585(These)-361(conceptions)-362(can)-362(only)-361(mean)-362(what)-362(we)-361(mean)-723(by)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([116])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(them,)-404(and)-374(nothing)-373(else,)-405(even)-373(when)-374(applied)-373(to)-374(God,)-404(or)-374(we)-373(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(attempting)-318(to)-317(pass)-318(off)-318(forged)-317(notes)-318(for)-317(genuine)-318(ones.)-453(The)-317(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possible)-237(additional)-237(idea)-236(which)-237(we)-237(introduce)-237(when)-237(thus)-236(ascribing)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
503 0 obj <<
/Length 4516      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(105)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(them)-455(to)-455(God,)-506(is)-455(that)-455(in)-455(Him)-455(they)-455(are)-455(perfect,)-506(free)-455(from)-455(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(imperfections)-308(with)-309(which)-308(they)-308(exist)-308(in)-309(us.)-425(To)-308(affirm)-308(that)-308(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-234(say)-233(that)-233(God)-234(is)-233(perfectly)-234(benevolent,)-237(or)-233(perfectly)-234(truthful,)-236(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(introduce)-322(into)-322(the)-322(conception,)-340(as)-322(applied)-322(to)-322(Him,)-340(a)-322(new)-322(factor,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(beyond)-297(the)-297(meaning)-297(of)-297(benevolence)-297(and)-297(truthfulness)-297(as)-297(used)-297(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(human)-346(language,)-369(and)-346(that)-345(this)-346(new)-345(factor)-346(can)-345(make)-346(the)-345(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(benevolence)-335(different)-335(from)-335(our)-335(human)-335(conception)-335(of)-335(it,)-356(or)-335(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lead)-384(God)-384(to)-385(actions)-384(which)-384(man)-384(can)-385(by)-384(no)-384(possibility)-384(view)-384(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(benevolent)-205(or)-206(true;)-220(and)-205(then)-205(to)-206(say)-205(that)-205(God)-206(is)-205(benevolent)-205(or)-205(true,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-234(an)-234(abuse)-234(of)-233(language,)-237(or,)-237(to)-234(use)-234(Mr.)-245(Mill's)-234(words,)-237(an)-233(offensive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(flattery.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-331(it)-331(has)-331(been)-330(urged)-331(that)-331(the)-331(moral)-331(attributes)-331(of)-330(God,)-351(even)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(if)-334(we)-335(view)-334(them)-334(not)-335(as)-334(infinite)-335(but)-334(as)-334(perfect,)-356(must)-334(be)-334(beyond)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-305(limits)-304(of)-305(human)-305(thought,)-318(and)-305(therefore)-304(may)-305(produce)-304(results)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(different)-282(in)-283(character)-282(from)-282(the)-283(corresponding)-282(principles)-282(in)-282(man,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(because)-213(they)-214(are)-213(the)-213(attributes)-213(of)-214(an)-213(infinite)-213(being.)-238(I)-213(have)-213(already)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disposed)-247(of)-247(this)-246(objection.)-249(Benevolence,)-248(holiness,)-247(and)-247(truth)-246(can-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-319(be)-319(other)-319(than)-319(benevolence,)-337(holiness,)-336(and)-319(truth,)-336(to)-319(whatever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-250(we)-250(may)-250(attribute)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-290(is)-291(therefore)-290(no)-290(necessary)-290(consequence,)-301(because)-290(we)-290(ascribe)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-302(God)-302(some)-302(attributes)-303(which)-302(are)-302(infinite,)-315(and)-302(others)-302(which)-302(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(perfect,)-293(that)-285(God)-284(must)-285(therefore)-285(be)-284(unknowable)-285(or)-284(unthinkable.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(We)-403(may)-404(know)-403(much)-404(about)-403(Him,)-442(without)-404(knowing)-403(all)-403(things.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Our)-378(not)-379(knowing)-378(all)-378(about)-378(things)-378(does)-379(not)-378(render)-378(them)-378(either)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unknowable)-313(or)-312(unthinkable.)-437(Our)-313(knowledge)-312(may)-313(be)-312(imperfect;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-391(as)-391(far)-391(as)-392(it)-391(goes)-391(it)-391(maybe)-391(real.)-674(If)-391(we)-391(were)-391(to)-391(affirm)-391(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-359(only)-360(know)-359(that)-360(which)-359(we)-719(know)-359(perfectly,)-387(or)-359(were)-359(unable)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([117])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(to)-409(reason)-409(on)-409(imperfect)-409(knowledge,)-449(mental)-409(progress)-409(would)-409(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(brought)-295(to)-294(a)-295(standstill.)-384(Nor)-295(is)-295(it)-294(right)-295(to)-295(affirm)-294(that)-295(we)-295(are)-294(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reasoning)-203(in)-203(a)-202(circle)-203(when)-203(we)-203(reason)-202(from)-203(His)-203(moral)-203(attributes)-202(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(displayed)-283(in)-284(the)-283(government)-284(of)-283(the)-283(world)-284(in)-283(favour)-284(of)-283(the)-283(prob-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ability)-346(of)-346(a)-346(revelation;)-394(or)-346(if)-346(because)-346(a)-346(revelation)-346(which)-345(claims)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-301(be)-302(from)-301(God,)-315(bears)-301(the)-301(impress)-302(of)-301(His)-302(character,)-314(we)-301(employ)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-304(fact)-304(as)-304(an)-304(evidence)-304(that)-304(it)-304(comes)-304(from)-304(Him.)-412(To)-304(affirm)-304(that)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
508 0 obj <<
/Length 4674      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(106)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(He)-263(is)-263(unknowable)-263(or)-263(unthinkable)-263(is)-263(to)-263(proclaim)-263(that)-263(man)-263(has)-263(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(concern)-188(with)-189(God,)-201(and)-188(that)-188(all)-189(revelation)-188(is)-189(impossible;)-208(therefore,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-202(objections)-203(urged)-202(against)-202(the)-203(evidence)-202(of)-202(supernatural)-202(religion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-250(these)-250(grounds)-250(are)-250(untenable.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(But)-285(there)-286(are)-285(the)-285(difficulties)-286(about)-285(the)-285(Absolute)-286(and)-285(the)-285(First)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Cause.)-471(It)-324(has)-324(been)-324(urged)-323(that)-324(the)-324(Absolute)-323(is)-324(that)-324(which)-324(is)-323(out)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-237(relation)-238(to)-237(every)-238(thing)-237(else)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 127.476 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(perfectly)-237(independent)-238(in)-237(itself.)-246(It)]TJ -138.385 -13.55 Td [(is)-345(argued,)-369(therefore,)-369(if)-345(God)-346(be)-345(this)-345(Absolute,)-369(he)-345(cannot)-345(be)-345(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first)-297(Cause,)-308(because)-297(a)-297(cause)-296(can)-297(only)-297(be)-297(a)-296(cause)-297(by)-297(its)-297(being)-296(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(relation)-248(to)-248(that)-248(of)-249(which)-248(it)-248(is)-248(the)-248(cause.)-250(For)-248(similar)-248(reasons,)-248(if)-248(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-250(the)-251(first)-250(Cause,)-251(He)-250(cannot)-250(be)-251(the)-250(Absolute.)-251(But)-250(as)-251(He)-250(is)-250(both,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-250(must)-250(therefore)-250(be)-250(unknowable)-250(and)-250(unthinkable.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(It)-344(is)-344(impossible)-344(in)-344(a)-345(treatise)-344(like)-344(this)-344(to)-344(enter)-344(into)-344(such)-344(pro-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(found)-386(metaphysical)-386(questions.)-658(For)-386(my)-386(present)-386(purpose,)-421(I)-385(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(safely)-244(refer)-244(to)-244(Mr.)-248(Mill's)-244(discussion)-244(on)-244(this)-244(subject.)-248(As)-244(far)-244(as)-244(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(views)-323(in)-323(question)-322(bear)-323(adversely)-323(on)-323(Christian)-323(evidence,)-341(he)-322(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sufficiently)-213(refuted)-213(them.)-238(It)-213(is)-213(not)-213(fair)-213(for)-213(unbelievers)-213(to)-212(put)-213(forth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-281(positions)-281(as)-281(subversive)-281(of)-282(Christianit)1(y,)-289(without)-281(answering)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-280(reasonings)-281(of)-280(so)-280(eminent)-281(an)-280(unbeliever)-280(as)-281(Mr.)-341(Mill)-280(in)-280(proof)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-251(their)-250(inconclusiveness,)-251(or)-250(even)-251(alluding)-251(to)-250(the)-251(fact)-250(that)-251(he)-250(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pronounced)-250(them)-250(untenable.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(There)-249(is)-250(no)-249(point)-250(which)-249(reasoners)-250(of)-249(this)-250(class)-249(have)-499(laboured)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([118])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(more)-411(diligently)-412(to)-411(prove)-411(than)-412(that)-411(it)-411(is)-412(impossible)-411(for)-411(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason)-451(to)-452(think)-451(of)-451(God)-451(as)-452(a)-451(person.)-854(The)-451(assumption)-451(of)-451(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(personality)-306(of)-306(God)-306(is)-306(the)-306(foundation)-306(of)-306(the)-306(Christian)-306(argument,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-169(which,)-185(even)-168(if)-169(the)-169(occurrence)-169(of)-168(miracles)-169(could)-169(be)-168(proved)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-337(objective)-336(facts,)-359(they)-337(would)-336(have)-337(no)-337(evidential)-337(value.)-510(It)-336(fol-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lows,)-237(therefore,)-236(that)-234(if)-233(our)-233(only)-233(mode)-234(of)-233(attaining)-233(the)-233(knowledge)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-239(the)-239(personality)-239(of)-239(God)-239(be)-239(from)-239(revelation,)-241(we)-239(are)-239(arguing)-239(in)-238(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(vicious)-250(circle.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(Briefly)-289(stated,)-298(the)-289(argument)-289(of)-289(unbelief)-288(is)-289(as)-289(follows:)-328(God)-288(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-259(infinite)-259(Being.)-276(Personality)-259(is)-259(a)-259(conception)-259(which)-258(necessarily)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(involves)-176(the)-177(finite.)-225(Therefore)-177(it)-176(cannot)-177(be)-176(predicated)-177(of)-176(an)-176(infinite)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Being.)-383(It)-295(follows)-294(therefore)-295(that)-294(to)-295(speak)-294(of)-295(God)-294(as)-295(infinite,)-305(and)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
512 0 obj <<
/Length 4710      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(107)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(at)-250(the)-250(same)-250(time)-250(as)-250(a)-250(person,)-250(involves)-250(a)-250(contradiction.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-259(is)-260(an)-259(unquestionable)-260(fact)-259(that)-260(the)-259(only)-260(beings)-259(whom)-260(we)-259(are)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(directly)-342(acquainted)-342(with)-342(as)-342(persons)-342(are)-342(finite)-342(beings,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 240.05 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 19.068 0 Td [(men.)]TJ -259.118 -13.549 Td [(No)-334(less)-333(certain)-334(is)-334(it)-333(that)-334(the)-334(only)-333(beings)-334(whom)-334(we)-333(know)-334(to)-333(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessed)-253(of)-253(wisdom)-253(and)-253(intelligence)-253(are)-253(finite)-253(beings,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 242.962 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 16.156 0 Td [(men,)]TJ -259.118 -13.549 Td [(and)-301(those)-300(various)-301(classes)-300(of)-301(animals)-300(by)-301(which)-300(the)-301(latter)-300(quality)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-382(manifested.)-645(The)-382(argument)-382(is)-381(equally)-382(valid)-382(for)-382(proving)-381(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wisdom)-365(and)-364(intelligence)-364(can)-365(only)-364(belong)-365(to)-364(finite)-365(beings;)-421(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consequently)-211(that)-210(the)-211(existence)-210(of)-211(wi)1(sdom)-211(and)-210(intelligence)-211(in)-210(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first)-219(Cause)-219(of)-220(all)-219(things)-219(is)-219(inconceivable,)-226(and)-219(the)-219(assumption)-219(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-253(is)-253(wise)-252(and)-253(intelligent)-253(is)-253(a)-253(contradiction.)-258(The)-253(same)-252(argument)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-235(no)-235(less)-235(valid)-235(against)-235(ascribing)-235(any)-235(moral)-235(perfection)-235(to)-235(Him,)-238(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-267(fact)-267(any)-268(other,)-271(for)-267(all)-267(our)-267(knowledge)-268(of)-267(such)-267(things)-267(is)-267(both)-267(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(itself)-250(finite,)-250(and)-250(derived)-250(from)-250(finite)-250(beings.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-194(it)-195(even)-194(goes)-194(further)-194(than)-195(this.)-231(If,)-206(as)-194(the)-194(positive)-195(phil)1(osophy)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(lays)-389(down,)-423(our)-389(real)-389(knowledge)-389(of)-388(things)-389(is)-389(confined)-389(to)-388(direct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subjects)-325(of)-326(cognition;)-362(as)-326(the)-325(only)-325(beings)-325(which)-326(we)-325(know)-325(to)-325(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessed)-335(of)-334(wisdom)-335(and)-669(intelligence)-334(are)-335(men)-334(and)-335(animals,)-355(it)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([119])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(is)-306(quite)-306(contrary)-306(to)-306(sound)-306(reasoning)-306(to)-306(infer)-306(that)-306(these)-306(qualities)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(can)-336(be)-336(possessed)-335(by)-336(any)-336(other)-336(class)-335(of)-336(finite)-336(beings.)-507(To)-336(do)-335(so)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-314(to)-315(transfer)-314(human)-315(conceptions)-314(to)-315(beings)-314(who)-315(are)-314(not)-314(human.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Equally)-320(valid)-319(would)-320(be)-320(the)-319(reasoning)-320(of)-320(an)-319(animal,)-337(if)-320(he)-319(could)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason)-319(on)-318(the)-318(subject,)-336(as)-319(for)-318(instance)-318(a)-319(horse)-318(or)-319(a)-318(dog,)-336(that)-318(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-403(of)-404(wisdom)-403(and)-403(intelligence)-404(beyond)-403(his)-403(own)-403(limited)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sphere)-337(was)-337(an)-338(unwarrantable)-337(assumption.)-511(Pantheists)-337(have)-337(also)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(propounded)-217(theories)-216(on)-217(the)-217(assumption)-217(of)-216(the)-217(existence)-217(in)-216(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-405(an)-404(unconscious)-405(wisdom)-405(and)-405(intelligence.)-714(This)-404(assumption)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-430(open)-431(to)-430(the)-430(most)-430(formidable)-430(objections;)-521(but)-430(even)-430(on)-430(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(own)-316(principles)-315(it)-316(is)-315(utterly)-316(invalid;)-348(for)-315(if)-316(on)-315(the)-316(grounds)-315(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-399(allege)-400(it)-399(is)-400(impossible)-399(to)-399(ascribe)-400(personality)-399(to)-400(God,)-436(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same)-265(reasonings)-264(are)-265(equally)-265(valid)-264(against)-265(ascribing)-265(wisdom)-264(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intelligence)-250(to)-250(unconscious)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-247(conclude,)-247(therefore,)-247(that)-247(it)-246(by)-247(no)-247(means)-246(follows)-247(because)-246(our)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(direct)-200(knowledge)-200(of)-201(personality)-200(is)-200(confined)-200(to)-200(human)-200(beings,)-210(and)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
516 0 obj <<
/Length 4937      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(108)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(is)-251(derived)-250(from)-251(them,)-251(that)-251(personality)-250(itself)-251(cannot)-251(be)-250(conceived)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-276(as)-276(a)-277(property)-276(belonging)-276(to)-276(any)-276(other)-276(than)-277(human)-276(beings.)-328(It)-276(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(absurd)-300(to)-301(maintain)-300(that)-300(the)-301(qualities)-300(of)-300(things)-301(must)-300(be)-300(confined)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(those)-250(things)-250(from)-250(which)-250(we)-250(learn)-250(their)-250(existence.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-345(it)-345(will)-346(be)-345(objected)-345(that)-345(the)-346(very)-345(essential)-345(notion)-345(of)-345(per-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(sonality)-512(is)-511(limitation;)-643(consequently)-511(that)-512(although)-511(it)-512(may)-511(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conceived)-389(of)-388(as)-389(belonging)-389(to)-388(limited)-389(beings,)-423(it)-389(transcends)-388(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-231(of)-232(thought)-231(to)-231(conceive)-231(of)-232(it)-231(as)-231(the)-231(attribute)-232(of)-231(a)-231(being)-231(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-265(unlimited)-266(or)-265(infinite;)-273(that)-265(is)-265(to)-265(say,)-269(that)-266(although)-265(it)-265(lies)-265(within)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-238(power)-238(of)-238(thought)-238(to)-238(conceive)-238(of)-238(the)-238(Being)-238(who)-238(had)-238(adequate)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(power)-266(to)-265(build)-266(the)-265(universe)-266(as)-265(a)-266(Person,)-269(because)-265(the)-266(power)-265(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-334(a)-335(limited)-334(power,)-356(yet)-334(when)-334(I)-335(ascribe)-334(to)-334(Him)-335(beyond)-334(this)-334(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession)-297(of)-298(all)-297(possible)-297(power,)-619(the)-297(conception)-297(of)-297(personality)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([120])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(becomes)-201(unthinkable.)-233(This)-201(is)-201(the)-201(real)-200(meaning)-201(of)-201(the)-200(affirmation,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unless)-401(our)-400(reasonings)-401(are)-401(to)-400(be)-401(confined)-401(within)-400(the)-401(region)-400(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(abstractions.)-313(But)-271(we)-271(have)-271(no)-271(assurance)-271(that)-271(such)-271(reasonings)-270(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(valid,)-226(unless)-220(we)-220(can)-220(bring)-220(them)-220(to)-220(the)-220(test)-220(of)-220(some)-220(concrete)-219(form)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(thought.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Next:)-325(It)-287(by)-288(no)-287(means)-287(follows)-288(because)-287(our)-288(conception)-287(of)-287(per-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(sonality)-197(is)-196(derived)-196(from)-197(finite)-196(beings,)-208(that)-196(it)-197(is)-196(necessarily)-196(limited)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-353(them;)-403(and)-353(that)-352(it)-353(cannot)-352(be)-353(thought)-352(of)-353(in)-352(connection)-353(with)-352(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(being,)-349(some)-328(of)-329(whose)-329(attributes)-329(are)-329(infinite)-329(and)-329(others)-328(perfect;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-253(other)-254(words,)-254(that)-253(the)-253(idea)-253(of)-254(finiteness)-253(is)-253(necessarily)-253(involved)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-364(that)-364(of)-364(personality.)-592(What)-364(are)-364(the)-364(conceptions)-364(that)-364(make)-363(up)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-376(idea)-377(of)-376(our)-377(own)-376(personality?)-629(I)-376(reply,)-408(the)-377(power)-376(to)-376(affirm)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(I)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 3.633 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.808 0 Td [(of)-363(one's)-364(own)-363(being)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 85.965 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(the)-363(possession)-364(of)-363(will)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 97.954 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(the)-363(power)-364(of)]TJ -223.022 -13.549 Td [(self-consciousness,)-412(and)-380(these)-379(in)-380(union)-380(with)-379(rationality.)-639(These)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(conceptions)-366(we)-366(undoubtedly)-366(derive)-366(from)-366(the)-366(contemplation)-365(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-220(own)-220(finite)-219(being,)-226(but)-220(there)-220(is)-220(nothing)-219(in)-220(them)-220(which)-220(is)-219(neces-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sarily)-280(limited)-281(to)-280(the)-280(finite.)-341(If)-280(the)-280(conception)-281(of)-280(an)-280(infinite)-280(being)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-339(possible)-338(\050and)-339(the)-339(fact)-338(that)-339(it)-339(is)-338(so)-339(constantly)-339(introduced)-338(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-209(controversy)-210(proves)-209(that)-209(it)-210(is)-209(possible\051,)-217(then)-210(there)-209(is)-209(no)-209(reason)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(why)-274(these)-274(conceptions,)-281(which)-274(certainly)-274(contain)-274(in)-274(them)-274(nothing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(quantitative,)-319(should)-305(not)-304(be)-305(applicable)-305(to)-305(such)-305(a)-305(being.)-415(The)-304(real)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
520 0 obj <<
/Length 4664      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(109)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(fact)-295(is,)-306(these)-294(conceptions)-295(are)-295(not)-294(inherently)-295(finite,)-306(because)-294(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-263(nothing)-263(in)-264(them)-263(of)-263(a)-263(quantitative)-263(character,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 212.478 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(they)-263(are)-263(only)]TJ -223.387 -13.549 Td [(derived)-266(from)-267(a)-266(being)-267(whose)-266(manifestation)-266(in)-267(space)-266(we)-266(conceive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-275(under)-275(the)-275(form)-275(of)-275(limitation,)-281(and)-275(whose)-275(attributes)-275(are)-275(neither)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(infinite)-250(nor)-250(perfect.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-474(must)-474(call)-475(attention)-474(to)-475(the)-474(remark)-474(already)-475(made)-474(that)-474(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(correct)-400(representation)-399(of)-400(God)-399(in)-400(thought)-400(is)-399(not)-400(that)-399(of)-400(a)-399(pure)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(abstraction,)-481(the)-435(infinite)-434(Being,)-481(but)-435(of)-434(a)-435(being)-435(who)-434(possesses)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attributes,)-427(some)-391(of)-391(which)-391(are)-782(infinite)-392(and)-391(others)-391(perfect.)-673(To)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([121])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-355(that)-355(such)-355(a)-355(being)-355(is)-355(a)-356(person,)-381(is)-355(not)-355(to)-355(attempt)-355(to)-355(think)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-321(which)-321(is)-322(unthinkable.)-463(When)-321(we)-322(affirm)-321(that)-321(God)-321(possesses)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-253(power)-254(adequate)-253(to)-253(build)-254(the)-253(universe,)-254(and)-254(all)-253(possible)-253(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beside,)-233(we)-228(do)-229(not)-228(ascribe)-229(to)-229(Him)-228(that)-229(of)-228(which)-229(it)-228(is)-229(impossible)-228(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(predicate)-259(the)-259(possession)-259(of)-259(will)-259(or)-259(self-consciousness.)-277(When)-259(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-229(that)-228(such)-229(a)-229(being)-228(exists)-229(now,)-233(that)-229(he)-229(has)-228(existed)-229(in)-229(all)-228(past)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(known)-265(times,)-269(and)-265(that)-265(no)-265(limits)-266(in)-265(point)-265(of)-265(time)-265(are)-265(conceivable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-194(him,)-205(there)-194(is)-194(nothing)-193(contradictory)-194(in)-194(ascribing)-194(to)-194(such)-194(a)-193(Being)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(personality.)-615(It)-371(is)-372(quite)-371(thinkable)-372(that)-372(an)-371(ultimate)-372(particle)-371(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(never)-286(have)-286(had)-287(a)-286(beginning)-286(and)-286(never)-286(will)-286(have)-287(an)-286(end;)-304(no)-286(less)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-229(is)-228(it)-229(that)-229(such)-228(a)-229(particle)-229(may)-229(be)-228(possessed)-229(of)-229(personality,)-233(for)-228(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-207(finite.)-236(Surely)-208(therefore)-207(there)-208(is)-207(nothing)-208(in)-207(the)-207(ascription)-208(to)-207(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-267(existence)-268(without)-267(beginning)-267(and)-268(without)-267(end,)-272(which)-267(destroys)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(idea)-250(of)-250(His)-250(personality.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(It)-190(has)-191(been)-190(necessary)-191(to)-190(enter)-190(thus)-191(far)-190(into)-191(this)-190(subject,)-202(because)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(in)-262(reasoning)-261(on)-262(the)-262(Christian)-261(revelation)-262(we)-261(must)-262(assume)-262(the)-261(ex-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(istence)-335(of)-335(a)-336(personal)-335(God,)-356(unless)-335(all)-336(such)-335(treatises,)-356(in)-335(addition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-449(their)-450(own)-449(proper)-449(subject-matter,)-499(must)-450(likewise)-449(contain)-449(an)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(elaborate)-346(work)-345(on)-346(the)-345(principles)-346(of)-345(theism,)-370(and)-345(a)-346(refutation)-345(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-281(of)-280(pantheism)-281(and)-281(atheism.)-342(The)-281(defender)-281(of)-281(Christianity)-280(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(charged)-356(with)-357(reasoning)-356(in)-356(a)-357(circle,)-383(as)-356(though)-357(he)-356(first)-356(assumed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-384(existence)-384(of)-384(a)-384(personal)-384(God,)-418(and)-384(then)-384(derived)-384(the)-384(idea)-384(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-356(existence)-355(from)-356(revelation.)-567(This)-355(charge)-356(would)-355(undoubtedly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-343(true)-343(if)-343(the)-343(idea)-343(of)-343(God)-343(being)-343(a)-343(person)-343(is)-343(unthinkable.)-529(I)-343(am)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-334(a)-334(loss)-334(to)-333(conceive)-334(how)-334(it)-334(becomes)-334(one)-334(atom)-334(more)-333(thinkable)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
524 0 obj <<
/Length 4921      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(110)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(if)-303(communicated)-304(by)-303(a)-303(revelation.)-410(Much)-304(obscurity)-303(has)-303(undoubt-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(edly)-295(been)-295(thrown)-295(on)-295(this)-295(subject)-295(by)-295(Christian)-295(writers)-295(who)-294(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fancied)-301(that)-301(the)-301(more)-301(they)-301(can)-301(invalidate)-301(our)-301(reason)-301(the)-300(greater)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gain)-209(accrues)-209(to)-208(Revelation.)-237(This)-208(is)-209(not)-209(only)-209(unwise)-209(but)-208(irrational.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Our)-501(reason)-250(doubtless)-250(is)-251(but)-250(an)-250(imperfect)-250(light,)-251(but)-250(its)-250(extinction)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([122])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(is)-360(to)-359(leave)-360(us)-360(to)-359(grope)-360(in)-360(darkness.)-579(I)-359(affirm)-360(therefore)-360(that)-359(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assumption)-340(of)-340(the)-340(divine)-340(personality)-340(as)-340(the)-340(groundwork)-340(of)-340(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(argument)-250(involves)-250(no)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 97.266 0 Td [(petitio)-250(principii)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 68.192 0 Td [(,)-250(or)-250(reasoning)-250(in)-250(a)-250(circle.)]TJ -153.502 -18.459 Td [(One)-310(more)-310(remark)-310(and)-310(I)-310(will)-310(bring)-310(this)-310(portion)-310(of)-310(the)-309(subject)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-378(a)-378(close.)-633(The)-378(affirmation)-378(made)-377(by)-378(this)-378(philosophy)-378(that)-377(cer-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tain)-336(things)-336(are)-336(unthinkable)-337(is)-336(fallacious.)-508(What)-336(do)-336(we)-336(mean)-336(by)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.55 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(unthinkable)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 51.513 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(?)-393(It)-298(may)-298(mean)-297(many)-298(things;)-321(first,)-310(that)-298(the)-297(subject)]TJ -61.2 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-437(be)-437(made)-437(in)-437(any)-437(sense)-437(an)-437(object)-437(of)-437(thought.)-811(This,)-483(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact,)-406(is)-375(the)-375(only)-375(legitimate)-375(use)-375(of)-375(the)-375(word.)-625(But)-375(in)-375(this)-375(sense)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-391(affirmation)-391(cannot)-391(be)-391(true)-391(of)-391(even)-391(Mr.)-673(Herbert)-391(Spencer's)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unknown)-405(and)-405(unknowable)-405(God,)-444(for)-405(it)-405(is)-405(evident)-405(that)-404(he)-405(does)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(manage)-263(to)-264(reason)-263(and)-263(think)-263(about)-264(him)-263(somehow.)-290(It)-263(may)-263(mean)-263(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-262(respecting)-262(whom)-261(we)-262(may)-262(know)-261(much)-262(and)-262(attain)-262(a)-261(knowl-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(edge)-204(continually)-205(progressing,)-213(but)-205(respecting)-204(whom)-205(there)-204(is)-204(much)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-389(is)-389(unknown.)-668(This)-389(unknown)-389(is)-389(called)-389(unthinkable.)-667(But)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-413(is)-412(not)-413(unthinkable.)-738(It)-413(has)-412(only)-413(not)-413(yet)-412(become)-413(the)-412(subject)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-378(our)-378(knowledge,)-410(and)-378(is)-378(no)-378(more)-378(unthinkable)-378(than)-378(any)-377(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unknown)-362(truth.)-584(Or)-362(that)-362(may)-361(be)-362(pronounced)-361(to)-362(be)-361(unthinkable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(respecting)-438(which)-437(our)-437(conceptions)-438(are)-437(wanting)-438(in)-437(definiteness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-285(precision.)-355(But)-285(to)-285(designate)-285(such)-285(things)-285(as)-285(unthinkable)-285(is)-285(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(abuse)-281(of)-280(language.)-343(Or)-280(that)-281(may)-281(be)-280(designated)-281(as)-281(unthinkable)-280(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-313(our)-313(conceptions)-313(fail)-314(full)1(y)-314(to)-313(represent)-313(the)-313(reality.)-439(As)-313(far)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-222(they)-222(go,)-227(they)-222(may)-221(be)-222(true,)-228(but)-221(there)-222(may)-222(be)-222(something)-221(beyond)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-328(a)-329(similar)-328(kind,)-348(which)-328(they)-328(do)-329(not)-328(embrace.)-485(This)-328(is)-328(the)-328(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sense)-220(in)-220(which)-220(it)-219(can)-220(be)-220(affirmed)-220(that)-220(God)-220(is)-220(unthinkable,)-226(but)-219(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assertion)-298(is)-298(altogether)-298(misleading.)-393(The)-298(only)-298(correct)-298(meaning)-297(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-262(expression)-261(is)-262(when)-262(some)-261(particular)-262(thing)-262(is)-261(affirmed)-262(to)-261(exist)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-259(at)-259(the)-259(same)-259(time)-259(contradictions)-259(co-exist)-259(in)-259(it.)-277(The)-259(actual)-259(co-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-438(of)-219(these)-219(two)-219(contradictions)-219(is)-218(unthinkable,)-226(but)-218(nothing)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([123])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
529 0 obj <<
/Length 1414      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(111)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(more.)-551(Thus)-350(the)-350(existence)-351(of)-350(a)-350(round)-351(square)-350(is)-350(unthinkable,)-375(so)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-223(the)-223(affirmation)-222(that)-223(the)-223(divine)-223(power)-222(was)-223(at)-223(the)-223(same)-222(time)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(both)-240(limited)-239(and)-240(unlimited.)-246(But)-240(in)-239(no)-239(other)-240(sense)-239(is)-240(a)-239(conception)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unthinkable.)-258(To)-253(affirm)-253(that)-252(the)-253(cause)-253(of)-252(all)-253(things)-253(is)-252(unthinkable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(because)-212(our)-212(conceptions)-212(of)-211(Him)-212(do)-212(not)-212(measure)-212(the)-212(entire)-211(depths)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(His)-250(being)-250(is)-250(simply)-250(misleading.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(I)-421(have)-421(gone)-421(into)-421(this)-421(question)-421(because)-421(it)-421(is)-421(evident)-421(that)-421(if)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(God)-344(is)-344(unthinkable)-345(a)-344(revelation)-344(of)-344(Him)-344(is)-344(impossible,)-368(and)-344(if)-344(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(revelation)-371(of)-370(Him)-371(is)-371(impossible,)-401(all)-370(miracles)-371(affirmed)-371(to)-370(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-250(wrought)-250(in)-250(attestation)-250(of)-250(one)-250(must)-250(be)-250(delusions.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 -29.65 Td [([124])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
538 0 obj <<
/Length 3682      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 93.543 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-261(VI.)-261(The)-261(Objection)-262(That)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Miracles)-257(Are)-256(Contrary)-257(To)-257(Reason)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Considered.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -37.658 Td [(Under)-213(this)-213(head)-212(are)-213(included)-213(the)-213(whole)-212(of)-213(that)-213(class)-213(of)-212(objections)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-389(extend)-390(from)-389(the)-390(direct)-389(assertion)-389(of)-390(the)-389(impossibility)-389(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-201(to)-200(the)-201(affirmation)-200(that)-201(even)-200(if)-201(their)-200(possibility)-201(is)-200(conced-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ed,)-287(they)-280(are)-280(so)-280(extremely)-280(improbable)-280(that)-280(it)-280(is)-280(a)-280(violation)-280(of)-279(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first)-209(principles)-210(of)-209(our)-209(reason)-209(to)-209(believe)-210(in)-209(their)-209(actual)-209(occurrence.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(They)-290(are)-289(alleged)-290(to)-289(be)-290(violations)-289(and)-290(contradictions)-289(of)-290(the)-289(laws)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-244(nature,)-245(and)-244(as)-244(such)-243(to)-244(be)-244(incredible,)-245(as)-244(the)-244(stability)-244(of)-244(its)-243(laws)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-232(founded)-232(on)-232(a)-232(universal)-232(experience.)-244(This)-232(unquestionably)-231(forms)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-351(most)-351(formidable)-350(difficulty)-351(in)-351(the)-350(way)-351(of)-351(the)-351(acceptance)-350(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles,)-251(as)-252(actual)-251(occurrences,)-251(at)-251(the)-252(present)-251(day,)-251(and)-251(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demands)-250(a)-250(careful)-250(consideration.)]TJ 11.956 -14.596 Td [(The)-212(question)-212(of)-212(the)-212(abstract)-212(impossibility)-212(of)-212(miracles)-212(need)-212(not)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(occupy)-345(us)-344(long.)-534(Such)-344(an)-344(affirmation)-345(can)-344(only)-345(be)-344(made)-345(on)-344(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assumption)-279(that)-278(our)-279(reason)-278(is)-278(inadequate)-279(to)-278(affirm)-279(the)-278(existence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-260(such)-259(a)-260(being)-259(as)-260(a)-260(personal)-259(God.)-279(If)-260(this)-259(can)-260(be)-259(established,)-262(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whole)-355(argument)-355(is)-354(ended)-355(for)-355(all)-355(practical)-355(purposes.)-564(It)-355(may)-354(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conceded)-240(that)-240(the)-240(occurrence)-240(of)-240(some)-240(anomalous)-240(event)-240(as)-240(a)-239(bare)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(objective)-248(fact)-248(is)-247(quite)-248(possible,)-248(even)-248(on)-248(the)-248(principles)-248(of)-247(panthe-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ism)-302(or)-301(atheism.)-405(But)-302(such)-302(objective)-301(fact)-302(would)-302(be)-301(no)-302(miracle)-301(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-223(sense)-224(in)-223(which)-224(the)-223(word)-224(can)-223(be)-224(used)-223(in)-223(this)-224(discussion.)-241(If)-223(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-237(was)-238(sufficiently)-237(strong)-238(to)-237(attest)-238(it)-237(as)-238(a)-237(fact,)-240(it)-475(would)-237(be)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([125])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(explicable)-282(on)-281(the)-282(supposition)-281(of)-281(some)-282(unknown)-281(force)-282(in)-281(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-216(even)-216(as)-216(a)-216(purely)-216(chance)-217(occurrence.)-238(A)-216(miracle,)-223(in)-216(any)-216(sense)-216(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-199(it)-199(enters)-199(into)-199(the)-199(present)-199(argument,)-209(is)-199(not)-199(only)-199(an)-199(abnormal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(objective)-197(fact,)-207(but)-196(one)-197(which)-196(takes)-197(place)-196(at)-197(the)-196(bidding)-196(of)-197(a)-196(moral)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
542 0 obj <<
/Length 5039      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(113)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(agent.)-244(It)-233(is)-232(the)-233(union)-232(of)-232(these)-233(two)-232(which)-233(imparts)-232(to)-233(a)-232(miracle)-232(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-255(to)-255(attest)-255(a)-254(revelation.)-265(If,)-256(therefore,)-256(there)-255(is)-255(no)-255(evidence)-254(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-269(existence)-269(of)-268(a)-269(God,)-273(miracles)-269(may)-269(be)-269(pronounced)-268(impossible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-356(all)-357(practical)-356(purposes)-357(in)-356(this)-356(controversy,)-383(and)-357(we)-356(need)-356(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(further)-250(discuss)-250(the)-250(question.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(The)-214(whole)-213(argument)-214(as)-214(to)-213(whether)-214(the)-214(occurrence)-213(of)-214(a)-213(miracle)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(is)-334(or)-334(is)-333(not)-334(contrary)-334(to)-334(reason)-333(must)-334(proceed)-334(on)-334(the)-333(assumption)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-360(the)-359(existence)-360(of)-359(a)-360(personal)-359(God.)-579(It)-359(is)-360(also)-359(a)-360(proposition)-359(so)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(clear)-348(as)-348(to)-349(render)-348(all)-348(proof)-348(of)-348(it)-348(superfluous,)-373(that)-348(if)-348(a)-348(personal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God)-329(exists)-329(who)-329(has)-328(created)-329(the)-329(universe)-329(and)-329(governs)-329(it)-329(by)-328(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Providence,)-250(miracles)-250(are)-250(possible.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(First,)-313(I)-301(observe)-300(that)-301(a)-300(miracle)-301(cannot)-300(be)-301(pronounced)-300(incredi-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ble,)-273(on)-269(the)-269(ground)-269(that)-268(it)-269(is)-269(an)-269(effect)-268(without)-269(an)-269(adequate)-268(cause.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(On)-292(this)-292(point)-292(I)-293(may)-292(refer)-292(to)-292(the)-292(high)-292(authority)-292(of)-292(Mr.)-377(Mill,)-302(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-253(idea)-253(of)-253(a)-253(miracle)-252(contradicts)-253(no)-253(law)-253(of)-253(causation.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 233.352 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(In)-253(order,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 37.592 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.787 -13.549 Td [(says)-310(he,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 38.737 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(that)-310(any)-310(alleged)-310(fact)-310(should)-310(be)-310(contradictory)-310(to)-310(a)-310(law)]TJ -43.581 -13.549 Td [(of)-383(causation,)-417(the)-383(allegation)-383(must)-383(be)-384(not)-383(simply)-383(that)-383(the)-383(cause)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existed)-199(without)-199(being)-199(followed)-199(by)-200(the)-199(effect,)-209(for)-199(that)-199(would)-199(be)-199(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(uncommon)-281(occurrence,)-288(but)-281(that)-281(this)-281(happened)-281(in)-281(the)-281(absence)-280(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(any)-248(adequate)-248(counteracting)-248(cause.)-250(Now)-248(in)-248(the)-248(case)-248(of)-248(an)-248(alleged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracle)-336(the)-335(objection)-336(is)-335(the)-336(very)-336(opposite)-335(of)-336(this.)-507(It)-335(is)-336(that)-335(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(effect)-260(was)-261(defeated,)-263(not)-260(in)-260(the)-261(absence,)-263(but)-260(in)-260(consequence,)-263(of)-260(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(counteracting)-296(cause,)-307(viz.,)-307(a)-296(direct)-295(interposition)-296(of)-295(an)-296(act)-296(of)-295(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-260(some)-259(being)-260(who)-259(has)-260(power)-259(over)-260(nature;)-264(and)-260(in)-259(particular)-260(of)-259(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(being)-281(whose)-281(will)-281(being)-282(assumed)-281(to)-281(have)-281(induced)-281(all)-281(the)-281(causes,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-590(the)-295(powers)-295(by)-296(which)-295(they)-295(produce)-295(their)-295(effects,)-306(may)-295(well)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([126])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(be)-250(supposed)-250(able)-250(to)-250(counteract)-250(them.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 161.182 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 3.633 0 Td [(Logic)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 24.85 0 Td [(,)-250(vol.)-250(ii.)-250(p.)-250(167.\051)]TJ -185.28 -15.186 Td [(A)-261(miracle)-261(therefore)-262(may)-261(not)-261(be)-261(the)-261(result)-262(of)-261(the)-261(action)-261(of)-261(any)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(force)-406(which)-405(falls)-406(within)-406(the)-406(range)-405(of)-406(our)-406(knowledge.)-717(It)-405(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-351(necessary)-351(for)-351(its)-351(performance)-351(to)-351(neutralize)-351(the)-351(action)-351(of)-350(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existing)-231(forces)-232(by)-231(the)-231(calling)-231(into)-231(energy)-232(of)-231(more)-231(powerful)-231(ones.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(But)-362(their)-362(operation)-361(need)-362(not)-362(even)-362(be)-361(suspended.)-586(An)-361(adequate)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(force,)-345(or)-327(power,)-345(or)-326(cause)-327(\050it)-326(matters)-326(not)-326(by)-327(what)-326(name)-326(we)-326(call)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it\051)-288(is)-287(present)-288(to)-287(effectuate)-288(the)-288(result;)-306(viz.)-363(the)-287(power)-288(which)-287(rules)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
546 0 obj <<
/Length 5141      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(114)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(the)-365(universe,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 61.288 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 19.812 0 Td [(God.)-594(As)-365(Mr.)-594(Mill)-365(justly)-364(observes,)-394(the)-364(only)]TJ -81.1 -13.549 Td [(question)-246(which)-245(can)-246(be)-245(raised)-246(if)-246(the)-245(existence)-246(of)-245(God)-246(is)-245(assumed,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is,)-412(not)-380(the)-379(want)-380(of)-380(the)-379(presence)-380(of)-380(an)-379(adequate)-380(cause,)-412(for)-379(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposition)-371(pre-supposes)-371(the)-370(presence)-371(of)-371(one,)-401(but)-371(the)-371(want)-370(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(will)-269(on)-270(the)-269(part)-269(of)-270(God)-269(to)-269(bring)-270(about)-269(the)-269(result.)-308(Thus)-270(it)-269(may)-269(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fairly)-239(argued)-239(that)-239(God)-238(will)-239(not)-239(work)-239(a)-239(miracle,)-241(from)-239(the)-239(fact)-238(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-250(has)-250(not)-250(done)-250(so)-250(in)-250(the)-250(course)-250(of)-250(previous)-250(observation.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-280(has)-280(been)-280(frequently)-280(affirmed)-280(that)-280(a)-280(miracle)-280(is)-280(an)-280(act)-279(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-388(contrary)-389(to)-388(the)-388(laws)-389(of)-388(nature,)-423(or)-388(a)-389(violation)-388(of)-388(them,)-423(or)-388(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(suspension)-224(of)-224(them,)-229(or)-224(a)-224(violation)-224(of)-223(the)-224(order)-224(of)-224(nature;)-233(and)-223(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(its)-204(occurrence)-204(is)-203(therefore)-204(incredible,)-213(as)-204(being)-204(contrary)-204(to)-203(reason.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(A)-319(miracle)-319(need)-319(involve)-319(neither)-319(of)-319(these.)-457(The)-319(laws)-319(of)-319(nature)-319(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conceived)-285(by)-285(physical)-285(science)-285(are)-285(a)-285(set)-285(of)-285(antecedents)-285(followed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-290(a)-290(set)-290(of)-290(invariable)-290(consequents.)-370(A)-290(miracle)-290(does)-290(not)-290(interfere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-191(this.)-230(Its)-191(very)-191(conception)-190(involves)-191(a)-191(new)-191(antecedent)-190(followed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-280(its)-280(consequent.)-341(The)-280(utmost)-280(that)-280(can)-281(be)-280(urged)-280(is)-280(that)-280(we)-280(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(never)-231(before)-230(witnessed)-231(the)-230(presence)-231(of)-230(that)-231(particular)-230(antecedent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-207(consequent,)-215(or)-207(that)-207(the)-206(antecedents)-207(which)-207(we)-207(have)-206(witnessed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-342(been)-343(followed)-342(by)-342(totally)-343(different)-342(consequents.)-527(The)-342(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mode)-272(in)-272(which)-272(such)-272(a)-544(law)-272(could)-271(be)-272(violated)-272(would)-272(be,)-278(if)-272(a)-271(par-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([127])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(ticular)-211(antecedent)-211(was)-211(present)-210(and)-211(no)-211(other)-211(capable)-211(of)-210(modifying)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-238(action,)-240(and)-237(it)-238(failed)-238(to)-237(be)-238(attended)-238(with)-237(its)-238(proper)-237(consequent.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(But)-250(this)-250(is)-250(not)-250(involved)-250(in)-250(the)-250(conception)-250(of)-250(a)-250(miracle.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Let)-374(us)-375(now)-374(suppose)-374(that)-375(the)-374(expression)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 183.114 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(laws)-374(of)-375(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 64.513 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.928 0 Td [(is)]TJ -273.354 -13.549 Td [(extended)-385(so)-385(as)-385(to)-385(comprise)-384(the)-385(forces)-385(of)-385(nature)-385(as)-385(well)-385(as)-384(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(invariable)-339(sequences.)-515(Such)-339(a)-338(use)-339(of)-338(the)-339(term)-338(is)-339(very)-338(common.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(In)-317(this)-318(point)-317(of)-317(view,)-334(it)-318(is)-317(impossible)-317(to)-317(affirm)-318(that)-317(the)-317(laws)-317(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nature)-290(are)-290(violated)-290(by)-291(t)1(he)-291(performance)-290(of)-290(a)-290(miracle.)-370(This)-290(could)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-200(be)-199(the)-200(case)-200(if)-200(they)-199(were)-200(made)-200(to)-199(produce)-200(the)-200(opposite)-199(results)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-210(those)-209(which)-210(they)-209(actually)-210(produce.)-236(Thus,)-218(if)-210(a)-209(boiler)-210(were)-209(filled)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-353(water)-352(and)-353(a)-353(fire)-353(kindled)-352(under)-353(it,)-379(and)-352(no)-353(other)-353(force)-352(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(present)-203(capable)-203(of)-203(neutralizing)-203(the)-203(action)-203(of)-203(the)-203(fire;)-219(if,)-212(instead)-203(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-193(temperature)-193(of)-194(the)-193(water)-193(being)-193(raised,)-205(it)-193(gradually)-193(froze,)-204(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-338(be)-339(a)-338(clear)-338(violation)-338(of)-338(the)-339(laws)-338(of)-338(nature,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 221.034 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 18.946 0 Td [(its)-338(forces)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
550 0 obj <<
/Length 4650      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(115)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(would)-208(cease)-207(to)-207(produce)-208(their)-207(usual)-208(results.)-236(But)-207(there)-208(is)-207(nothing)-207(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-240(idea)-240(of)-240(a)-240(miracle)-239(that)-240(involves)-240(this.)-247(It)-240(postulates)-240(the)-239(presence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-299(a)-299(force)-299(or)-299(forces)-299(which)-299(are)-299(adequate)-299(to)-299(counteract)-299(the)-299(action)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-240(those)-239(already)-240(in)-239(existence,)-242(and)-239(to)-240(produce)-239(the)-240(adequate)-239(result.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-202(will)-203(be)-202(objected)-203(that)-202(we)-203(have)-202(never)-203(recognized)-202(the)-202(existence)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-392(such)-392(forces)-392(in)-393(our)-392(previous)-392(experience.)-676(Such)-392(an)-392(objection)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(would)-311(be)-310(valid)-311(only)-310(on)-311(the)-310(assumption)-311(that)-310(there)-311(is)-310(no)-311(force)-310(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-314(universe)-313(besides)-314(those)-314(which)-313(have)-314(been)-314(already)-313(recognized)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-378(us.)-634(This,)-410(however,)-410(science)-378(will)-378(in)-378(the)-378(present)-378(state)-378(of)-378(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowledge)-232(hardly)-233(venture)-232(to)-233(affirm.)-244(Besides,)-236(it)-232(is)-233(contrary)-232(to)-232(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposition)-260(with)-259(which)-260(we)-259(started,)-262(viz.)-279(the)-260(existence)-259(of)-260(a)-259(power)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(able)-250(to)-250(control)-250(nature,)-250(that)-250(is,)-250(God.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Nor)-280(is)-280(the)-281(assertion)-280(correct)-280(that)-280(the)-281(performance)-280(of)-280(a)-280(miracle)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(necessarily)-370(involves)-370(even)-370(a)-371(suspension)-370(of)-370(the)-740(laws)-370(of)-370(nature.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([128])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(This)-359(may)-359(be)-360(the)-359(mode)-359(of)-359(the)-360(divine)-359(acting;)-414(but)-359(it)-359(is)-359(most)-359(im-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(portant)-371(to)-370(observe)-371(that)-371(it)-370(by)-371(no)-370(means)-371(follows)-371(that)-370(it)-371(must)-370(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so.)-444(A)-315(miracle)-315(may)-314(be)-315(performed)-315(by)-315(the)-314(introduction)-315(of)-315(a)-314(force)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-184(has)-185(sufficient)-184(power)-184(to)-185(counteract)-184(the)-184(forces)-185(of)-184(nature)-184(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(while)-350(they)-350(are)-350(in)-350(the)-350(fullest)-350(operation.)-550(To)-350(take)-350(an)-349(illustration:)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(It)-354(has)-354(been)-355(frequently)-354(said)-354(that)-354(the)-355(force)-354(of)-354(gravity)-354(must)-354(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-237(suspended)-237(in)-237(favour)-236(of)-237(Peter's)-237(body)-237(when)-237(he)-237(walked)-237(on)-236(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(water,)-316(and)-303(in)-303(favour)-303(of)-303(that)-302(of)-303(our)-303(Lord)-303(when)-303(he)-303(ascended)-302(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(heaven.)-236(But)-209(this)-209(is)-209(by)-209(no)-209(means)-209(the)-209(case.)-236(The)-209(mere)-209(suspension)-208(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-274(law)-273(of)-274(gravitation)-273(would)-274(not)-273(in)-273(either)-274(case)-273(have)-274(effected)-273(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(results)-284(in)-283(question.)-351(The)-284(presence)-284(of)-283(other)-284(forces)-284(was)-283(necessary.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-292(law)-293(of)-292(gravitation)-292(might)-292(have)-292(been)-293(in)-292(the)-292(fullest)-292(operation,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-203(the)-203(miracle)-202(might)-203(have)-203(been)-203(performed)-202(by)-203(the)-203(action)-203(of)-202(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-286(adequate)-286(to)-286(neutralize)-286(it.)-358(The)-286(narrative)-286(itself)-286(implies)-286(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-357(force)-357(was)-357(so)-357(far)-357(from)-357(being)-357(suspended,)-384(that)-357(it)-357(was)-357(in)-357(full)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(operation)-346(at)-345(the)-346(time)-346(when)-345(the)-346(miracle)-346(was)-345(performed,)-370(for)-345(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moment)-345(the)-345(power)-345(which)-345(supported)-345(Peter's)-345(body)-345(ceased)-345(to)-344(act)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-250(began)-250(to)-250(sink.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-343(further:)-436(even)-343(if)-343(we)-343(assume)-343(that)-343(any)-343(natural)-343(forces)-343(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(been)-438(suspended)-438(in)-438(the)-438(performance)-438(of)-438(a)-438(miracle,)-485(we)-438(are)-437(not)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
554 0 obj <<
/Length 4803      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(116)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(called)-275(on)-275(to)-275(assume)-275(their)-275(general)-275(suspension,)-281(but)-275(only)-275(in)-274(favour)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-326(the)-327(particular)-326(case)-327(in)-326(question.)-479(This)-327(observation)-326(is)-326(rendered)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary)-304(because)-303(it)-304(has)-303(been)-303(frequently)-304(urged)-303(against)-304(the)-303(pos-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sibility)-272(of)-273(miracles)-272(that)-272(their)-272(performance)-273(must)-272(have)-272(thrown)-272(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(whole)-321(mechanism)-322(of)-321(the)-321(universe)-322(into)-321(confusion,)-339(and)-321(involved)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-454(extensive)-453(reconstruction)-454(of)-453(the)-454(processes)-453(of)-454(nature.)-860(This)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-378(unquestionably)-379(be)-378(the)-379(case)-378(if)-379(the)-378(working)-379(of)-378(a)-378(miracle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(involved)-240(the)-239(difficulty)-240(in)-239(question.)-247(But)-240(I)-239(have)-240(shown)-239(that)-240(it)-239(need)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-351(involve)-351(even)-351(the)-351(suspension)-351(of)-351(any)-350(natural)-351(law)-351(whatever,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([129])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(and)-205(if)-204(such)-204(suspension)-205(took)-204(place)-205(in)-204(any)-205(particular)-204(case,)-214(the)-204(force)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(might)-250(have)-250(been)-250(acting)-250(with)-250(full)-250(energy)-250(everywhere)-250(else.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(The)-256(counteraction)-255(or)-256(modification)-256(of)-256(one)-255(force)-256(by)-256(the)-255(agency)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-261(another)-260(is)-261(an)-260(event)-261(which)-261(we)-260(witness)-261(every)-260(day.)-282(The)-261(force)-260(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gravity)-238(is)-238(in)-238(the)-238(fullest)-238(operation)-238(whenever)-238(we)-238(lift)-238(a)-238(weight)-237(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-236(ground)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 46.805 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.91 0 Td [(it)-235(is)-236(not)-235(suspended)-236(for)-235(a)-236(single)-235(moment.)-245(The)-236(ability)]TJ -57.715 -13.549 Td [(to)-270(modify)-270(the)-269(results)-270(of)-270(the)-270(action)-270(of)-269(one)-270(force)-270(by)-270(the)-270(agency)-269(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(another,)-337(or)-320(to)-320(combine)-320(many)-320(forces)-319(so)-320(as)-320(to)-320(produce)-320(a)-319(definite)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(result,)-232(constitutes)-228(the)-228(essence)-228(of)-227(all)-228(mechanical)-228(contrivance.)-242(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(self-determining)-284(power)-284(of)-284(the)-283(human)-284(will)-284(is)-284(that)-284(which)-284(calls)-283(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-239(particular)-240(modifications)-239(of)-239(existing)-239(forces)-240(into)-239(activity.)-246(By)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(means)-220(of)-220(it,)-226(the)-220(entire)-220(aspect)-220(of)-220(external)-220(nature)-220(has)-220(been)-220(changed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(from)-292(the)-291(appearance)-292(which)-291(it)-292(would)-291(have)-292(presented,)-301(if)-292(no)-291(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agency)-273(had)-273(existed)-273(besides)-273(the)-273(forces)-273(of)-273(nature)-273(which)-273(belong)-273(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(matter.)-360(Man)-287(has)-287(been)-287(a)-287(power)-286(manifested)-287(in)-287(the)-287(midst)-287(of)-286(them.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-360(am)-360(quite)-359(aware)-360(that)-360(he)-360(can)-360(create)-360(no)-360(new)-359(force,)-388(and)-360(that)-359(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-239(only)-238(control)-239(or)-238(modify)-239(the)-239(action)-238(of)-239(those)-238(which)-239(exist,)-241(but)-238(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(never)-266(capable)-266(of)-266(suspending)-265(them.)-298(Yet)-266(this)-266(power)-266(has)-265(produced)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(marvellous)-394(results)-394(on)-394(the)-395(external)-394(world,)-430(so)-394(that)-394(it)-394(presents)-394(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wholly)-362(different)-362(aspect)-361(from)-362(that)-362(which)-361(it)-362(would)-362(have)-362(done)-361(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-235(forces)-236(of)-235(nature)-235(had)-235(simply)-236(continued)-235(acting)-235(uncontrolled)-235(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-346(influence)-346(of)-345(mind.)-538(Even)-346(in)-345(material)-346(nature)-346(itself,)-370(we)-345(meet)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-359(repeated)-358(instances)-359(of)-359(such)-359(modifications)-358(of)-359(the)-359(results)-358(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(one)-424(force)-423(by)-424(the)-424(action)-423(of)-424(another,)-467(as)-424(for)-423(example)-424(when)-423(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(force)-308(of)-307(gravitation)-308(is)-307(counteracted)-308(by)-308(that)-307(of)-308(magnetism,)-322(or)-307(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
558 0 obj <<
/Length 4541      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(117)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(capillary)-373(attraction.)-619(The)-373(action)-373(of)-373(no)-373(force)-373(is)-373(suspended,)-403(it)-373(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-250(modified.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(The)-385(assertion)-385(therefore)-385(is)-385(inaccurate)-385(which)-385(affirms)-385(that)-384(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(performance)-414(of)-415(a)-414(miracle)-415(involves)-414(the)-414(suspension)-415(of)-414(a)-414(single)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(force)-376(in)-375(nature.)-626(It)-376(is)-375(consequently)-376(so)-751(far)-375(no)-376(violation)-375(of)-375(any)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([130])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(natural)-310(law.)-429(All)-310(that)-309(the)-310(idea)-310(of)-309(it)-310(involves)-310(is)-309(the)-310(presence)-310(of)-309(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(force)-322(which)-322(is)-322(capable)-322(in)-322(a)-322(particular)-322(instance)-322(of)-322(counteracting)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-251(action)-251(of)-251(those)-250(forces)-251(which)-251(would)-251(produce)-251(a)-251(contrary)-250(result)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-274(left)-274(to)-274(themselves.)-322(It)-274(is)-274(quite)-274(unnecessary)-274(for)-274(us)-274(to)-273(determine,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-201(reference)-200(to)-201(the)-200(subject)-201(under)-200(consideration,)-210(whether)-201(the)-200(result)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-217(be)-218(brought)-217(about)-218(by)-217(a)-218(combination)-217(of)-218(forces)-217(which)-217(energize)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(within)-389(the)-388(visible)-388(sphere)-389(of)-388(things,)-424(or)-388(by)-389(bringing)-388(into)-388(action)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(some)-463(latent)-463(force,)-516(or)-463(one)-463(which)-463(only)-463(occasionally)-462(manifests)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(itself,)-452(or)-412(by)-412(the)-411(immediate)-412(action)-412(of)-412(the)-412(divine)-411(mind,)-452(which,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(having)-281(in)-282(itself)-281(all)-281(the)-282(forces)-281(necessary)-281(to)-282(produce)-281(the)-281(universe,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-250(possess)-250(those)-250(which)-250(are)-250(necessary)-250(to)-250(effect)-250(the)-250(miracle.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(It)-185(is)-186(a)-185(fact)-186(worthy)-185(of)-186(observation)-185(that)-186(in)-185(the)-186(case)-185(of)-186(the)-185(miracles)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(recorded)-260(in)-261(the)-260(Bible,)-263(the)-261(materials)-260(out)-261(of)-260(which)-261(the)-260(new)-260(results)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-261(produced)-260(already)-261(existed)-261(in)-261(nature,)-263(as)-261(in)-260(the)-261(miracle)-261(of)-260(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(multiplication)-332(of)-331(the)-332(loaves)-331(and)-332(fishes.)-494(No)-332(act)-331(of)-332(creation)-331(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(necessary.)-419(All)-307(that)-306(was)-307(required)-306(was)-306(the)-307(presence)-306(of)-307(a)-306(force)-306(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces,)-215(able)-207(to)-207(build)-207(up)-206(these)-207(materials)-207(into)-206(the)-207(forms)-207(in)-206(question.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God)-328(does)-329(this)-328(in)-329(ordinary)-328(course)-329(by)-328(what)-329(we)-328(designate)-328(natural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces,)-209(by)-199(means)-198(of)-199(which)-199(corn)-199(is)-198(grown)-199(and)-199(flesh)-199(produced.)-232(Can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-317(be)-316(pretended)-316(that)-317(no)-316(other)-317(forces)-316(are)-317(under)-316(the)-317(control)-316(of,)-333(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exist)-201(in)-201(God,)-211(which)-202(are)-201(able)-201(to)-201(produce)-202(these)-201(results)-201(in)-201(a)-201(different)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(manner,)-454(even)-413(while)-413(the)-413(ordinary)-413(forces)-413(of)-413(nature)-413(continue)-413(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(activity?)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(It)-239(has)-240(been)-239(further)-240(urged)-239(that)-239(a)-240(miracle)-239(involves)-240(a)-239(violation)-239(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(the)-246(laws)-247(of)-246(nature,)-248(because)-246(as)-246(it)-247(cannot)-246(be)-247(effected)-246(by)-247(any)-246(of)-246(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-319(of)-319(nature)-319(with)-318(which)-319(we)-319(are)-319(acquainted,)-336(the)-319(presence)-318(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-312(unknown)-312(force)-312(adequate)-311(to)-312(produce)-312(one)-312(must)-312(be)-312(a)-311(violation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(laws)-250(of)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(I)-446(reply)-447(that)-447(any)-446(apparent)-447(force)-447(which)-446(this)-447(objection)-893(may)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 279.068 0 Td [([131])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
427 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 884
/Length 8932      
>>
stream
419 0 425 56 422 113 429 202 431 317 428 374 433 451 435 566 432 622 437 713
439 828 436 884 441 961 443 1076 440 1132 445 1209 447 1324 448 1381 444 1437 450 1514
452 1629 449 1686 455 1763 457 1878 454 1934 459 2011 461 2126 458 2182 463 2259 465 2374
462 2431 467 2508 469 2623 466 2680 471 2745 473 2860 474 2916 470 2971 476 3048 478 3163
475 3220 481 3297 483 3412 480 3468 485 3545 487 3660 484 3717 489 3794 491 3909 488 3966
493 4043 495 4158 492 4215 497 4304 499 4419 500 4476 496 4532 502 4609 504 4724 501 4781
507 4846 509 4961 506 5016 511 5093 513 5208 510 5265 515 5342 517 5457 514 5513 519 5590
521 5705 518 5762 523 5839 525 5954 526 6011 522 6067 528 6156 530 6271 527 6327 532 6392
535 6431 537 6520 533 6635 539 6691 536 6748 541 6813 543 6928 540 6984 545 7073 547 7188
544 7245 549 7334 551 7449 548 7506 553 7571 555 7686 552 7743 557 7820 559 7935 560 7992
% 419 0 obj
<<
/D [423 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 425 0 obj
<<
/D [423 0 R /XYZ 248.913 133.888 null]
>>
% 422 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 429 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 430 0 R
/Resources 428 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 426 0 R
>>
% 431 0 obj
<<
/D [429 0 R /XYZ 323.816 215.183 null]
>>
% 428 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 433 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 434 0 R
/Resources 432 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 426 0 R
>>
% 435 0 obj
<<
/D [433 0 R /XYZ 125.725 269.38 null]
>>
% 432 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F37 246 0 R /F38 247 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 437 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 438 0 R
/Resources 436 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 426 0 R
>>
% 439 0 obj
<<
/D [437 0 R /XYZ 225.218 353.13 null]
>>
% 436 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 441 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 442 0 R
/Resources 440 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 426 0 R
>>
% 443 0 obj
<<
/D [441 0 R /XYZ 46.771 419.725 null]
>>
% 440 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 445 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 446 0 R
/Resources 444 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 426 0 R
>>
% 447 0 obj
<<
/D [445 0 R /XYZ 112.324 463.978 null]
>>
% 448 0 obj
<<
/D [445 0 R /XYZ 267.409 79.691 null]
>>
% 444 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 450 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 451 0 R
/Resources 449 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 453 0 R
>>
% 452 0 obj
<<
/D [450 0 R /XYZ 102.974 147.437 null]
>>
% 449 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 455 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 456 0 R
/Resources 454 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 453 0 R
>>
% 457 0 obj
<<
/D [455 0 R /XYZ 93.543 242.402 null]
>>
% 454 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 459 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 460 0 R
/Resources 458 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 453 0 R
>>
% 461 0 obj
<<
/D [459 0 R /XYZ 57.844 298.933 null]
>>
% 458 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 463 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 464 0 R
/Resources 462 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 453 0 R
>>
% 465 0 obj
<<
/D [463 0 R /XYZ 356.377 366.679 null]
>>
% 462 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 467 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 468 0 R
/Resources 466 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 453 0 R
>>
% 469 0 obj
<<
/D [467 0 R /XYZ 132.519 423.331 null]
>>
% 466 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 471 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 472 0 R
/Resources 470 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 453 0 R
>>
% 473 0 obj
<<
/D [471 0 R /XYZ 93.543 477.528 null]
>>
% 474 0 obj
<<
/D [471 0 R /XYZ 358.512 93.24 null]
>>
% 470 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 476 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 477 0 R
/Resources 475 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 479 0 R
>>
% 478 0 obj
<<
/D [476 0 R /XYZ 101.755 149.892 null]
>>
% 475 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 481 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 482 0 R
/Resources 480 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 479 0 R
>>
% 483 0 obj
<<
/D [481 0 R /XYZ 363.16 233.642 null]
>>
% 480 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 485 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 486 0 R
/Resources 484 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 479 0 R
>>
% 487 0 obj
<<
/D [485 0 R /XYZ 274.324 285.384 null]
>>
% 484 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 489 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 490 0 R
/Resources 488 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 479 0 R
>>
% 491 0 obj
<<
/D [489 0 R /XYZ 213.787 352.312 null]
>>
% 488 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 493 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 494 0 R
/Resources 492 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 479 0 R
>>
% 495 0 obj
<<
/D [493 0 R /XYZ 193.197 423.331 null]
>>
% 492 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 497 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 498 0 R
/Resources 496 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 479 0 R
>>
% 499 0 obj
<<
/D [497 0 R /XYZ 254.954 491.077 null]
>>
% 500 0 obj
<<
/D [497 0 R /XYZ 359.319 106.79 null]
>>
% 496 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 502 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 503 0 R
/Resources 501 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 505 0 R
>>
% 504 0 obj
<<
/D [502 0 R /XYZ 182.396 160.986 null]
>>
% 501 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 507 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 508 0 R
/Resources 506 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 505 0 R
>>
% 509 0 obj
<<
/D [507 0 R /XYZ 333.28 229.96 null]
>>
% 506 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 511 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 512 0 R
/Resources 510 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 505 0 R
>>
% 513 0 obj
<<
/D [511 0 R /XYZ 163.784 284.566 null]
>>
% 510 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 515 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 516 0 R
/Resources 514 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 505 0 R
>>
% 517 0 obj
<<
/D [515 0 R /XYZ 242.304 353.13 null]
>>
% 514 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 519 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 520 0 R
/Resources 518 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 505 0 R
>>
% 521 0 obj
<<
/D [519 0 R /XYZ 183.922 407.327 null]
>>
% 518 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 523 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 524 0 R
/Resources 522 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 505 0 R
>>
% 525 0 obj
<<
/D [523 0 R /XYZ 113.238 463.978 null]
>>
% 526 0 obj
<<
/D [523 0 R /XYZ 136.524 66.142 null]
>>
% 522 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 528 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 529 0 R
/Resources 527 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 531 0 R
>>
% 530 0 obj
<<
/D [528 0 R /XYZ 46.771 366.581 null]
>>
% 527 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 532 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index7) >>
% 535 0 obj
(Chapter VI. The Objection That Miracles Are Contrary To Reason Considered.)
% 537 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 538 0 R
/Resources 536 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 531 0 R
>>
% 533 0 obj
<<
/D [537 0 R /XYZ 93.543 529.134 null]
>>
% 539 0 obj
<<
/D [537 0 R /XYZ 331.421 120.339 null]
>>
% 536 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 541 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 542 0 R
/Resources 540 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 531 0 R
>>
% 543 0 obj
<<
/D [541 0 R /XYZ 69.387 176.172 null]
>>
% 540 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 545 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 546 0 R
/Resources 544 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 531 0 R
>>
% 547 0 obj
<<
/D [545 0 R /XYZ 192.605 258.286 null]
>>
% 544 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 549 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 550 0 R
/Resources 548 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 531 0 R
>>
% 551 0 obj
<<
/D [549 0 R /XYZ 256.215 338.762 null]
>>
% 548 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 553 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 554 0 R
/Resources 552 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 531 0 R
>>
% 555 0 obj
<<
/D [553 0 R /XYZ 374.173 409.782 null]
>>
% 552 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 557 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 558 0 R
/Resources 556 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 561 0 R
>>
% 559 0 obj
<<
/D [557 0 R /XYZ 220.271 462.751 null]
>>
% 560 0 obj
<<
/D [557 0 R /XYZ 303.743 66.142 null]
>>
endstream
endobj
565 0 obj <<
/Length 4870      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(118)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(possess)-268(is)-267(due)-268(to)-267(an)-268(ambiguous)-267(use)-268(of)-268(the)-267(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 210.99 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(law.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.48 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.763 0 Td [(It)-268(is)-267(here)]TJ -242.076 -13.549 Td [(used)-381(to)-382(denote)-381(the)-382(order)-381(of)-382(the)-381(various)-382(occurrences)-381(in)-381(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-311(not)-312(its)-311(antecedents)-312(and)-311(invariable)-311(consequents.)-435(If)-311(there)-311(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-418(in)-417(nature)-418(beyond)-417(those)-418(with)-418(which)-417(we)-418(are)-417(acquainted,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(how)-313(can)-313(their)-313(action)-313(be)-314(a)-313(violation)-313(of)-313(nature's)-313(order?)-439(If)-313(God)-313(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(always)-304(present)-303(energizing)-304(in)-304(nature's)-303(forces,)-317(how)-304(can)-304(any)-303(fresh)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(putting)-367(forth)-367(of)-367(his)-367(energy)-367(be)-367(a)-367(violation)-367(of)-367(nature's)-367(laws?)-600(In)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-321(certain)-321(sense)-322(of)-321(the)-321(words)-321(the)-321(order)-322(of)-321(nature)-321(may)-321(be)-321(said)-321(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-278(violated)-279(whenever)-278(one)-279(of)-278(its)-278(forces)-279(is)-278(modified)-279(by)-278(the)-278(action)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-402(another,)-439(that)-402(is)-401(to)-402(say,)-440(an)-401(order)-402(of)-402(events)-401(results)-402(from)-401(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modified)-348(action)-348(different)-348(from)-348(that)-348(which)-348(would)-348(have)-348(resulted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-240(the)-239(unmodified)-240(one.)-246(In)-240(this)-240(sense)-239(man)-240(is)-239(daily)-240(violating)-239(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-229(of)-229(nature.)-243(But)-229(this)-230(has)-229(no)-229(bearing)-229(whatever)-229(on)-229(the)-229(question)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-250(issue.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-221(will)-222(perhaps)-221(be)-222(urged)-221(that)-221(the)-222(resurrection)-221(of)-222(a)-221(dead)-221(man,)-227(or)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(the)-256(cure)-256(of)-256(a)-256(man)-256(born)-256(blind)-256(by)-256(a)-256(word)-256(is)-256(a)-256(violation)-256(of)-256(t)1(he)-256(laws)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-306(nature.)-419(Whether)-306(this)-306(be)-306(so)-307(can)-306(only)-306(be)-306(determined)-306(when)-306(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-324(acquainted)-324(with)-324(the)-324(means)-324(by)-324(which)-324(such)-324(an)-324(event)-324(may)-323(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(brought)-331(about.)-495(The)-331(assertion)-331(itself)-332(is)-331(a)-332(mere)-331(general)-331(statement)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that,)-236(as)-233(far)-232(as)-233(human)-232(observation)-232(has)-233(gone,)-236(dead)-232(men)-233(have)-232(never)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(returned)-311(to)-311(life;)-342(and)-311(that)-311(blindness)-311(has)-311(never)-311(been)-311(cured)-311(at)-311(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(person's)-250(command.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-355(with)-356(respect)-355(to)-356(a)-355(resurrection)-355(it)-356(may)-355(be)-356(objected)-355(that)-355(it)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-329(an)-329(observed)-329(fact)-329(amounting)-329(to)-329(a)-329(complete)-330(induction,)-348(that)-329(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(men)-326(die)-326(and)-326(that)-326(after)-326(death)-326(has)-326(taken)-326(place)-326(it)-326(is)-326(a)-326(fact)-326(no)-325(less)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(universal)-213(that)-213(with)-212(the)-213(exception)-213(of)-213(a)-212(few)-213(alleged)-213(instances)-213(to)-212(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contrary)-327(no)-327(resurrection)-326(has)-327(ever)-327(taken)-327(place.)-480(It)-327(may)-326(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-385(said)-385(to)-385(be)-385(a)-385(law)-385(of)-385(nature)-385(that)-385(all)-385(men)-385(die,)-418(and)-385(that)-385(death)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-310(followed)-311(by)-310(no)-311(resurrection.)-431(This,)-326(however,)-325(if)-311(put)-310(into)-310(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(language)-299(amounts)-299(to)-299(the)-299(following)-298(proposition.)-397(That)-299(it)-299(is)-299(a)-298(law)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-321(nature)-320(that)-321(these)-321(results)-641(must)-321(follow,)-339(as)-320(long)-321(as)-321(the)-320(present)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([132])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(forces)-400(which)-400(we)-401(observe)-400(and)-400(no)-400(others)-400(are)-401(in)-400(energy.)-700(But)-400(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(would)-255(cease)-256(to)-255(be)-255(so)-255(as)-256(soon)-255(as)-255(any)-256(others)-255(capable)-255(of)-255(producing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-243(a)-243(result)-243(were)-243(brought)-243(into)-243(activity.)-248(The)-243(truth)-243(is)-243(that)-243(death)-243(is)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
569 0 obj <<
/Length 4649      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(119)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(a)-243(phenomenon)-243(which)-243(is)-242(caused)-243(by)-243(the)-243(joint)-243(action)-243(of)-243(a)-242(multitude)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-345(natural)-345(forces.)-534(But)-345(if)-345(these)-344(were)-345(overborne)-345(by)-345(any)-345(force)-344(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature,)-410(or)-378(by)-378(the)-379(Author)-378(of)-378(nature)-378(calling)-378(any)-378(unknown)-378(force)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-330(activity,)-351(or)-330(even)-331(by)-330(the)-331(energy)-330(of)-331(his)-330(own)-330(creative)-331(will,)-350(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(would)-343(be)-343(absurd)-343(to)-344(call)-343(such)-343(an)-343(event)-343(either)-343(a)-343(violation)-343(of)-343(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(laws)-259(or)-259(of)-259(the)-259(order)-259(of)-260(nature,)-261(and)-259(therefore)-259(to)-259(affirm)-259(that)-259(it)-259(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incredible.)-354(Death)-285(is)-285(the)-285(result)-285(of)-284(the)-285(action)-285(of)-285(the)-285(natural)-284(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-219(we)-218(observe)-219(around)-219(us.)-239(No)-219(natural)-219(force)-218(with)-219(which)-219(we)-218(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acquainted)-264(can)-263(effect)-264(a)-263(resurrection.)-291(If)-264(it)-263(be)-264(affirmed)-263(that)-264(in)-263(this)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sense)-306(a)-307(resurrection)-306(is)-307(contrary)-306(to)-306(the)-307(laws)-306(and)-307(order)-306(of)-306(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-248(expression)-247(is)-248(ambiguous)-247(and)-248(misleading,)-248(for)-247(it)-247(is)-248(intended)-247(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-243(inferred)-243(that)-243(such)-244(a)-243(violation)-243(would)-243(be)-243(contrary)-243(to)-243(reason)-243(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-250(incredible.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-441(the)-441(affirmation)-441(that)-441(a)-441(miracle)-441(is)-441(contrary)-441(to)-441(the)-441(order)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-337(nature)-336(requires)-337(further)-336(consideration.)-510(What)-337(do)-336(we)-337(intend)-336(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(affirm)-262(when)-261(we)-262(speak)-261(of)-262(an)-261(order)-261(of)-262(nature)-261(or)-262(of)-261(an)-262(event)-261(being)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contrary)-250(to)-250(it?)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(In)-391(a)-391(scientific)-391(sense)-391(the)-391(order)-391(of)-391(nature)-391(can)-391(only)-391(mean)-391(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(results)-365(of)-366(forces)-365(energizing)-366(in)-365(conformity)-366(with)-365(invariable)-365(law.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Every)-278(event)-279(which)-278(occurs)-279(is)-278(the)-278(result)-279(of)-278(a)-279(combination)-278(of)-278(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-346(and)-345(the)-346(product)-345(of)-346(their)-345(joint)-346(action.)-536(These)-346(results)-345(nec-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(essarily)-383(follow)-383(an)-383(orderly)-383(arrangement;)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 182.787 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 20.411 0 Td [(the)-383(orderly)-383(result)]TJ -203.198 -13.549 Td [(always)-236(occurs)-235(when)-236(precisely)-235(the)-236(same)-236(antecedents)-235(and)-236(no)-235(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-335(present,)-357(and)-336(is)-335(invariably)-335(altered)-336(whenever)-335(the)-335(antecedents)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-202(modified)-203(to)-202(the)-202(precise)-203(extent)-202(of)-202(the)-203(modification.)-234(As)-202(far)-202(then)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-223(the)-223(results)-223(in)-223(nature)-223(are)-223(the)-223(effect)-223(of)-223(known)-223(forces)-223(unmodified)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-226(their)-451(action)-226(by)-226(other)-225(forces,)-231(they)-225(follow)-226(a)-226(definite)-226(order.)-241(Thus)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([133])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(all)-267(the)-267(motions)-267(of)-268(the)-267(heavenly)-267(bodies)-267(present)-267(themselves)-267(to)-267(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(scientific)-335(mind)-335(as)-335(the)-335(perfection)-335(of)-335(order,)-356(because)-335(they)-335(are)-334(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(results)-317(of)-318(the)-317(action)-317(of)-317(known)-317(forces)-318(acting)-317(in)-317(conformity)-317(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(invariable)-225(law.)-241(Whenever)-225(a)-224(fact)-224(is)-225(observed)-224(which)-225(deviates)-224(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-341(order)-341(which)-341(these)-341(known)-341(forces)-341(would)-341(produce,)-363(the)-341(action)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-362(another)-362(force)-362(which)-362(has)-362(hitherto)-362(been)-362(unknown)-362(is)-362(inferred.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-257(order)-256(of)-257(nature)-257(therefore)-256(means)-257(that)-257(the)-256(same)-257(forces)-256(always)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
573 0 obj <<
/Length 4726      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(120)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(produce)-255(the)-256(same)-255(results.)-266(There)-256(is)-255(nothing)-256(inconsistent)-255(with)-255(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-401(the)-401(correct)-402(conception)-401(of)-401(a)-401(miracle.)-704(Viewed)-401(as)-401(a)-401(physical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(event)-347(only,)-371(it)-347(would)-347(be)-347(due)-347(to)-347(the)-347(action)-347(of)-347(a)-347(force)-347(which)-346(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hitherto)-250(been)-250(outside)-250(the)-250(sphere)-250(of)-250(our)-250(observation.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-459(is)-460(clear)-459(therefore)-460(that)-459(whenever)-460(a)-459(fresh)-460(combination)-459(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(forces)-278(takes)-277(place,)-285(their)-278(combined)-278(action)-277(will)-278(modify)-278(the)-277(result,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-395(a)-395(very)-394(different)-395(order)-395(of)-395(events)-394(will)-395(take)-395(place)-395(from)-394(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-314(would)-315(have)-314(resulted)-315(from)-314(their)-315(unmodified)-314(action.)-443(Such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modification)-314(therefore)-313(must)-314(produce)-314(a)-313(different)-314(order)-314(of)-313(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-296(that)-296(which)-296(would)-296(have)-296(otherwise)-296(resulted.)-388(But)-296(such)-295(mod-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ifications)-367(frequently)-367(take)-367(place)-366(through)-367(the)-367(agency)-367(of)-367(man.)-600(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-384(follows)-383(that)-384(man)-383(has)-384(the)-384(power)-383(of)-384(effecting)-383(modifi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cations)-324(in)-323(the)-324(order)-324(of)-324(nature,)-342(without)-323(causing)-324(any)-324(violation)-323(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature's)-250(laws.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-330(various)-330(other)-329(influences,)-350(and)-330(among)-330(them)-330(those)-329(usually)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(designated)-194(as)-195(chances,)-205(exert)-194(a)-194(powerful)-195(influence)-194(in)-194(changing)-194(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(order)-272(of)-273(nature.)-317(It)-272(is)-272(necessary)-273(that)-272(its)-272(forces)-273(should)-272(not)-272(only)-272(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(combined,)-236(but)-232(combined)-232(at)-233(the)-232(right)-232(time)-233(and)-232(place,)-236(or)-232(the)-232(effect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-200(is)-200(due)-200(to)-200(their)-200(combination)-200(will)-200(not)-200(take)-200(place;)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 229.866 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.876 0 Td [(a)-200(differ-)]TJ -245.742 -13.549 Td [(ent)-244(order)-244(of)-245(natural)-244(events)-244(would)-244(have)-244(happened.)-248(An)-244(illustration)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will)-224(make)-223(this)-224(clear.)-241(Let)-224(us)-224(take)-223(the)-224(case)-223(of)-224(a)-224(disintegrating)-223(rock;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(according)-353(as)-353(the)-353(different)-706(forces,)-378(which)-353(act)-353(on)-353(it,)-379(meet)-353(at)-352(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([134])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(suitable)-293(time)-292(and)-293(place,)-303(the)-293(progress)-293(of)-292(disintegration)-293(is)-292(greatly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lengthened)-304(or)-304(shortened.)-411(Such)-303(concurrences)-304(of)-304(events)-304(are)-303(what)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-336(view)-336(as)-336(pure)-336(contingencies.)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 145.329 0 Td [(E.g.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 23.119 0 Td [(water)-336(penetrates)-336(into)-336(one)]TJ -168.448 -13.549 Td [(of)-362(its)-361(fissures;)-418(this)-362(takes)-361(place)-362(in)-362(summer,)-389(and)-362(no)-361(appreciable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(result)-437(follows.)-812(But)-437(if)-437(in)-438(winter)-437(a)-437(frost)-437(happens)-437(immediately)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(afterwards,)-394(it)-365(will)-365(produce)-365(an)-365(order)-365(of)-365(events)-365(widely)-365(different)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-223(that)-223(which)-223(would)-223(have)-223(happened)-223(if)-223(either)-223(no)-223(rain)-223(had)-222(fallen)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-237(frost)-237(occurred.)-246(By)-237(their)-237(joint)-237(agency)-237(the)-237(fissure)-237(is)-237(widened,)-239(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-301(rock)-302(split)-301(asunder.)-404(It)-301(follows)-302(therefore)-301(that)-301(the)-301(concurrence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-269(these)-270(two)-269(forces)-269(is)-269(necessary)-270(at)-269(a)-269(particular)-270(time)-269(and)-269(place)-269(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(produce)-294(the)-294(particular)-294(result.)-383(Such)-294(concurrences,)-305(though)-294(due)-294(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural)-273(causes,)-279(are)-273(what)-273(we)-274(call)-273(fortuitous.)-319(Yet)-273(their)-273(occurrence)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
577 0 obj <<
/Length 4630      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(121)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(or)-250(non-occurrence)-250(occasions)-250(a)-250(different)-250(order)-250(of)-250(natural)-250(events.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Further,)-377(let)-351(us)-351(suppose)-351(that)-352(a)-351(bird)-351(with)-351(a)-352(seed)-351(in)-351(its)-351(mouth,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-342(the)-342(course)-343(of)-342(its)-342(flight)-342(casually)-342(drops)-343(it)-342(into)-342(a)-342(fissure)-342(in)-342(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rock,)-304(which)-293(has)-293(been)-294(opened)-293(by)-293(the)-293(frost;)-315(and)-293(also)-293(that)-293(another)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(concurrence)-248(of)-247(forces)-248(has)-248(supplied)-248(the)-247(conditions)-248(suitable)-248(for)-247(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(taking)-348(root)-348(and)-347(growth.)-544(This)-348(produces)-347(a)-348(new)-348(series)-348(of)-347(events,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-362(occasions)-362(a)-361(more)-362(rapid)-362(disintegration,)-390(and)-362(modifies)-361(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whole)-201(of)-201(the)-201(results)-201(which)-201(follow.)-234(If)-201(the)-201(casual)-201(act)-201(of)-201(the)-201(bird)-201(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taken)-345(place)-344(at)-345(any)-344(other)-345(time)-344(or)-345(place,)-368(the)-344(whole)-345(series)-344(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-423(been)-423(different,)-466(varying)-422(with)-423(the)-423(causes)-423(which)-422(produced)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-389(seed,)-423(and)-389(the)-389(contingencies)-389(which)-388(brought)-389(the)-389(bird)-389(to)-388(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(spot,)-411(and)-379(induced)-379(it)-379(to)-379(drop)-378(it.)-637(Let)-379(us)-379(now)-379(suppose)-379(that)-378(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-276(his)-276(rational)-276(agency)-275(intervenes.)-328(He)-276(deliberately)-276(watches)-275(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-292(prospect)-291(of)-292(a)-291(frosty)-292(night,)-302(pours)-292(water)-291(into)-292(the)-291(fissures,)-302(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(plants)-212(seeds)-212(in)-211(fissures)-212(where)-212(he)-211(knows)-212(that)-212(suitable)-212(material)-211(has)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-298(prepared)-298(for)-298(their)-298(growth.)-393(Here)-298(a)-298(new)-298(order)-298(of)-298(events)-297(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-316(introduced,)-663(which,)-332(originating)-316(in)-315(human)-316(agency,)-331(entirely)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([135])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(modify)-250(the)-250(order)-250(of)-250(the)-250(results.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-369(is)-368(important)-369(to)-368(observe)-369(that)-368(all)-369(theories)-368(which)-369(attempt)-368(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(account)-315(for)-316(the)-315(production)-316(of)-315(living)-315(organisms)-316(by)-315(the)-315(principle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-340(development)-339(are)-340(compelled)-340(at)-339(almost)-340(every)-340(step)-339(of)-340(the)-339(pro-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(cess)-284(to)-284(postulate)-284(the)-285(concurrence)-284(of)-284(forces)-284(of)-284(this)-284(description)-284(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-337(suitable)-337(time)-337(and)-337(place)-337(to)-337(render)-337(their)-337(production)-337(possible.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(These)-384(must)-384(have)-384(taken)-383(place)-384(in)-384(past)-384(time)-384(in)-384(numbers)-383(passing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-281(comprehension.)-343(In)-281(the)-281(case)-281(of)-281(many)-281(vegetable)-281(structures)-281(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(result)-396(has)-395(been)-396(entirely)-396(modified)-396(by)-395(the)-396(contingency)-396(of)-395(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(insect)-248(choosing)-248(to)-248(enter)-248(one)-248(flower)-248(and)-249(not)-248(to)-248(enter)-248(another;)-248(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(according)-318(as)-317(this)-318(takes)-317(place)-318(a)-317(wholly)-318(different)-317(order)-318(of)-317(events)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(follows.)-428(Whether)-309(we)-309(choose)-309(to)-310(designate)-309(such)-309(concurrences)-309(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-349(at)-350(the)-349(suitable)-349(time)-349(and)-349(place)-350(fortuitous)-349(or)-349(not,)-374(the)-349(law)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-270(regulates)-269(them)-270(is)-270(wholly)-269(unknown,)-275(even)-270(if)-269(they)-270(are)-269(regu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lated)-316(by)-316(law.)-447(So)-316(far)-315(it)-316(is)-316(impossible)-315(to)-316(affirm)-316(that)-316(these)-315(results)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(follow)-253(a)-253(known)-253(and)-254(definite)-253(order)-253(in)-253(nature.)-259(The)-253(concurrence)-253(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(two)-275(or)-275(more)-276(such)-275(causes)-275(introduces)-275(a)-276(new)-275(series,)-281(and)-275(occasions)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
581 0 obj <<
/Length 4720      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(122)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(a)-250(break)-250(in)-250(the)-250(previously)-250(existing)-250(order)-250(of)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Still)-335(more)-336(completely)-335(has)-336(this)-335(happened)-335(when)-336(man)-335(with)-335(his)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(reason)-272(and)-272(powers)-271(of)-272(volition)-272(is)-272(introduced)-272(on)-271(the)-272(scene.)-316(It)-271(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(doubtless)-281(be)-281(objected)-281(by)-280(our)-281(materialistic)-281(philosophers,)-289(that)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-328(which)-329(energize)-328(in)-329(mind)-328(act)-329(with)-328(the)-329(same)-328(uniformity)-328(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-313(that)-313(energize)-313(in)-313(matter,)-329(and)-313(that)-313(volition)-313(exerts)-312(no)-313(appre-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ciable)-385(influence)-384(on)-385(the)-384(results)-384(of)-385(our)-384(actions.)-654(These)-384(theories,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(however,)-225(contradict)-218(the)-219(experience)-219(of)-218(an)-219(overwhelming)-218(majority)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-218(mankind.)-240(Such)-218(as)-218(do)-218(so)-218(require)-219(that)-218(the)-218(strongest)-218(proof)-218(should)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-455(given)-454(before)-455(their)-454(truth)-455(can)-455(be)-454(considered)-455(as)-454(established.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Such)-435(proof)-435(certainly)-435(yet)-435(remains)-435(to)-435(be)-435(given.)-805(Its)-434(advocates,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(however,)-262(tell)-259(us)-260(that)-259(it)-259(will)-260(be)-259(forthcoming)-260(at)-259(some)-519(future)-259(time.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([136])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(In)-294(the)-293(meanwhile)-294(the)-293(fact)-294(is)-294(sufficient)-293(for)-294(our)-293(purpose)-294(that)-293(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-306(capable)-306(of)-306(acting)-307(on)-306(nature)-306(and)-306(of)-306(producing)-306(most)-306(important)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(changes)-417(in)-417(the)-417(results)-417(of)-418(the)-417(action)-417(of)-417(its)-417(forces.)-751(This)-417(being)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so,)-373(it)-348(is)-348(certain)-348(that)-348(an)-348(order)-348(of)-348(events)-348(takes)-348(place)-348(through)-348(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(interference)-269(of)-269(man,)-274(quite)-269(different)-269(from)-269(that)-269(which)-268(would)-269(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taken)-315(place)-315(apart)-315(from)-315(his)-315(interference.)-445(But)-315(these)-314(interferences)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(take)-362(place)-361(in)-362(conformity)-362(with)-361(no)-362(known)-362(law,)-389(and)-362(their)-361(results)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occasion)-324(a)-324(break)-323(in)-324(the)-324(previously)-324(existing)-324(series)-323(of)-324(events,)-342(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-408(introduction)-409(of)-408(a)-409(new)-408(one.)-726(Man,)-448(therefore,)-448(is)-408(capable)-408(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(interfering)-424(with)-424(and)-424(effecting)-423(changes)-424(in)-424(the)-424(order)-424(of)-423(nature.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-379(will)-380(be)-379(objected)-379(that)-380(all)-379(the)-379(agencies)-380(by)-379(which)-379(such)-379(results)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-310(brought)-309(about)-310(are)-309(forces)-310(energizing)-310(in)-309(nature)-310(in)-309(conformity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-270(invariable)-269(law,)-275(and)-270(consequently)-269(that)-270(the)-269(order)-270(of)-270(nature)-269(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(preserved)-306(intact.)-419(It)-306(is)-306(unquestionably)-307(true)-306(that)-306(the)-306(actual)-306(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-375(work)-374(are)-375(forces)-374(in)-375(nature.)-624(But)-374(there)-375(is)-374(another)-375(principle)-374(at)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(work)-220(which)-220(interferes)-219(with)-220(the)-220(regular)-219(course)-220(of)-220(their)-220(action,)-225(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(brings)-283(out)-284(a)-283(series)-283(of)-284(results)-283(quite)-283(different)-284(to)-283(that)-283(which)-283(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-263(been)-264(produced)-263(if)-264(they)-263(had)-264(not)-263(been)-263(interfered)-264(with.)-290(This)-263(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man's)-310(reason)-309(and)-310(intelligent)-310(volition.)-429(It)-309(is)-310(impossible)-310(to)-309(reduce)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-349(action)-349(of)-348(this)-349(to)-349(any)-349(known)-349(law)-348(of)-349(invariable)-349(sequence.)-546(It)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(follows)-295(therefore)-294(that)-295(man)-295(is)-294(a)-295(power)-294(either)-295(in)-295(or)-294(out)-295(of)-294(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-354(is)-354(capable)-355(of)-354(interfering)-354(with)-354(the)-355(order)-354(of)-354(the)-354(results)-354(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
585 0 obj <<
/Length 4926      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(123)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(its)-277(material)-277(forces,)-284(or,)-284(in)-277(the)-278(language)-277(of)-277(those)-277(with)-277(whom)-277(I)-277(am)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reasoning,)-250(of)-250(violating)-250(the)-250(order)-250(of)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-242(it)-243(will)-242(be)-242(further)-243(objected)-242(that)-243(man)-242(in)-242(his)-243(action)-242(on)-242(nature)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(can)-289(only)-288(use)-289(or)-288(combine)-289(such)-288(natural)-288(forces)-289(as)-288(come)-289(within)-288(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowledge;)-334(and)-306(this)-305(proves)-306(nothing)-306(about)-306(the)-306(possibility)-306(of)-305(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(action)-420(of)-419(a)-420(power)-420(outside)-419(nature)-420(which)-420(is)-419(able)-420(to)-420(employ)-419(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(known)-347(and)-346(unknown)-347(forces)-346(for)-347(the)-346(purpose)-346(of)-347(producing)-346(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(results)-387(as)-775(miracles.)-662(I)-387(answer)-387(that)-387(this)-388(objection)-387(can)-387(have)-387(no)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([137])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(validity)-278(unless)-278(it)-278(is)-278(first)-278(assumed)-278(that)-278(man)-278(is)-278(a)-278(portion)-278(of)-278(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-313(the)-314(sense)-313(in)-313(which)-314(we)-313(are)-314(now)-313(speaking)-313(of)-314(it.)-440(But)-313(the)-313(proof)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-342(this)-342(has)-341(certainly)-342(yet)-342(to)-342(be)-341(given.)-525(By)-342(the)-342(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 228.138 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(nature,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 29.989 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.572 0 Td [(as)]TJ -271.543 -13.549 Td [(it)-348(is)-347(used)-348(by)-347(this)-348(philosophy,)-372(is)-348(meant)-347(the)-348(sum)-347(total)-348(of)-347(known)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(material)-342(forces,)-364(acting)-342(on)-342(matter)-341(in)-342(conformity)-342(with)-341(invariable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(laws;)-220(that)-204(is)-205(to)-205(say,)-213(of)-205(forces)-204(which)-205(are)-205(devoid)-204(of)-205(intelligence)-204(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(volition.)-244(It)-233(is)-233(impossible)-233(in)-233(this)-233(sense)-233(of)-233(the)-233(word)-233(to)-233(include)-233(man)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-224(it,)-230(until)-224(his)-225(entire)-224(intellectual)-225(and)-224(moral)-225(being)-224(can)-225(be)-224(shown)-224(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-298(the)-298(result)-299(of)-298(material)-298(forces.)-394(Nor)-299(even)-298(if)-298(this)-298(could)-298(be)-298(done,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-238(it)-237(avail)-238(for)-238(the)-237(present)-238(argument;)-242(for)-237(however)-238(it)-238(may)-237(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(originated,)-317(man's)-303(power)-303(to)-304(modify)-303(the)-303(action)-304(of)-303(material)-303(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-351(an)-351(existing)-351(fact,)-376(and)-350(produces)-351(results)-351(quite)-351(different)-351(in)-350(kind)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(from)-250(the)-250(action)-250(of)-250(the)-250(unintelligent)-250(forces)-250(of)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-298(fact)-298(that)-298(the)-299(mind)-298(acts)-298(through)-298(a)-298(material)-298(organism,)-310(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-384(incapable)-383(of)-384(calling)-383(into)-384(existence)-383(any)-384(new)-383(force,)-417(does)-383(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alter)-362(the)-361(position)-362(above)-362(taken.)-585(I)-361(am)-362(quite)-361(ready)-362(to)-362(take)-361(either)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-357(the)-358(following)-357(alternatives.)-572(Man)-358(is)-357(either)-357(in)-358(nature,)-384(or)-357(he)-357(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(outside)-332(of)-333(it.)-496(If)-332(he)-333(is)-332(in)-332(it,)-353(then)-332(a)-332(power)-333(exists)-332(within)-332(it)-332(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-254(capable)-254(of)-254(compelling)-253(its)-254(unintelligent)-254(forces)-254(to)-254(effectuate)-253(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(determinations)-307(of)-307(rational)-308(volition.)-421(If)-307(he)-308(is)-307(outside)-307(nature,)-321(then)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-323(power)-323(exists)-323(outside)-323(it)-323(which)-323(is)-323(capable)-323(of)-323(effectuating)-322(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(results.)-525(It)-342(follows,)-365(therefore,)-364(that)-342(in)-342(either)-341(case)-342(a)-342(power)-341(exists)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-240(is)-240(capable)-240(of)-240(modifying)-239(the)-240(order)-240(of)-240(nature.)-247(Now)-240(it)-239(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-244(absurd)-243(to)-244(deny)-244(that)-243(whatever)-244(man)-244(can)-243(effect,)-245(God)-244(is)-244(able)-243(also)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-267(effect;)-275(and)-266(that)-267(He)-266(is)-267(so)-267(much)-266(the)-267(more)-266(able,)-271(in)-267(proportion)-266(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-296(knowledge)-296(is)-296(more)-295(perfect.)-388(Whether,)-307(therefore,)-308(God)-295(works)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
590 0 obj <<
/Length 5230      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(124)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(in)-198(nature,)-208(or)-198(outside)-198(it,)-208(a)-198(power)-198(exists)-198(which)-198(is)-198(capable)-198(of)-197(varying)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-297(order)-297(of)-296(nature)-297(without)-297(interrupting)-297(the)-297(action)-296(of)-594(any)-297(of)-296(its)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([138])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(forces,)-455(or)-414(violating)-413(its)-414(laws.)-742(He)-413(also)-414(must)-414(have)-414(other)-413(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-400(His)-399(command)-400(beyond)-399(those)-400(which)-400(are)-399(known)-400(to)-399(man,)-437(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(can)-229(combine)-229(them)-229(and)-229(thereby)-229(modify)-229(their)-229(action)-229(in)-229(conformity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-218(His)-218(pleasure.)-240(He)-218(must)-218(also)-219(be)-218(the)-218(primary)-218(force)-218(everywhere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(underlying)-341(nature,)-364(which)-341(imparts)-341(to)-341(every)-341(other)-341(force)-340(its)-341(ener-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gy)-370(and)-370(power.)-611(It)-370(follows)-370(that)-371(He)-370(can)-370(work)-370(a)-370(miracle)-370(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-367(suspending)-367(any)-368(of)-367(the)-367(existing)-367(forces)-368(of)-367(nature,)-396(and)-367(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-287(allegation)-287(that)-287(miracles)-287(are)-287(contrary)-287(to)-287(reason,)-296(because)-287(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-340(contrary)-339(to)-339(nature,)-362(and)-340(a)-339(violation)-340(of)-339(its)-340(laws)-339(and)-340(order,)-361(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disproved.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-212(will)-213(now)-212(proceed)-213(to)-212(adduce)-212(examples)-213(of)-212(these)-212(contradictions)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-219(our)-218(reason)-219(which)-219(are)-218(said)-219(to)-219(be)-218(involved)-219(in)-219(the)-218(occurrence)-219(of)-218(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracle,)-220(for)-213(the)-213(purpose)-213(of)-212(illustrating)-213(the)-213(confusion)-213(arising)-212(from)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-193(various)-192(senses)-193(in)-192(which)-193(the)-192(words)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 163.165 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.262 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.944 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 17.853 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(natural)-193(law,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 50.875 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.787 -13.549 Td [(and)-224(other)-225(similar)-224(expressions)-224(have)-224(been)-225(employed.)-241(Although)-224(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instances)-335(will)-334(be)-335(taken)-334(from)-335(the)-334(opponents)-335(of)-334(Revelation,)-356(I)-334(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-283(means)-282(wish)-283(to)-283(imply)-283(that)-282(they)-283(alone)-283(have)-282(been)-283(guilty)-283(of)-282(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ambiguous)-259(use)-259(of)-259(language.)-277(Its)-259(defenders)-259(are)-259(equally)-259(obnoxious)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-250(the)-250(charge.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(After)-228(quoting)-228(a)-229(brief)-228(passage)-228(from)-229(Dr.)-242(Newman,)-233(the)-228(author)-228(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf -11.956 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)-306(Religion)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.669 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.186 0 Td [(urges)-306(the)-307(following)-306(objections:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 141.248 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Mira-)]TJ -255.79 -13.549 Td [(cles)-362(are)-363(here)-362(described)-362(as)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 119.709 0 Td [(\030)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 3.632 0 Td [(beside,)-390(beyond,)-391(and)-362(above)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 119.716 0 Td [(\031)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.584 0 Td [(nature,)]TJ -250.641 -13.549 Td [(but)-358(a)-358(moment's)-357(consideration)-358(will)-358(show)-358(that)-357(in)-358(so)-358(far)-358(as)-357(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(terms)-243(have)-242(any)-243(meaning)-243(at)-242(all,)-245(they)-242(are)-243(simply)-243(evasions,)-244(and)-242(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(solutions)-263(of)-264(a)-263(difficulty.)-290(If)-263(the)-264(course)-263(of)-263(nature)-264(be)-263(interrupted)-263(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(any)-264(way,)-268(whether)-264(the)-265(interruption)-264(be)-264(said)-265(to)-264(proceed)-264(from)-264(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cause)-305(which)-305(is)-305(said)-305(to)-305(be)-305(beyond,)-319(or)-305(beside,)-319(or)-305(above)-305(nature,)-318(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-272(certain)-272(that)-273(the)-272(interruption)-272(is)-272(not)-273(caused)-272(by)-272(nature)-272(itself;)-283(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(every)-325(disturbance)-325(of)-325(the)-325(order)-324(of)-325(nature,)-344(call)-325(it)-325(by)-325(whatsoever)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([139])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(name)-234(we)-233(may,)-237(is)-234(contrary)-233(to)-234(nature,)-237(whose)-233(chief)-234(characteristic)-233(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(invariability)-212(of)-212(law.)-238(It)-212(is)-212(clearly)-212(unnatural)-212(for)-212(the)-212(ordinary)-212(course)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-291(nature)-290(to)-291(be)-290(disturbed,)-301(and)-291(indeed)-290(were)-291(this)-291(not)-290(the)-291(case,)-300(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
595 0 obj <<
/Length 5705      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(125)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(disturbance)-250(would)-250(be)-250(no)-250(miracle)-250(at)-250(all.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 169.364 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -157.408 -15.186 Td [(It)-264(is)-265(by)-264(no)-265(means)-264(my)-265(purpose)-264(to)-265(defend)-264(Dr.)-294(Newman's)-264(use)-264(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-294(expressions,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 73.483 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(natural,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.022 0 Td [(\035)-294(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.889 0 Td [(beside)-294(nature,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 61.064 0 Td [(\035)-294(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.889 0 Td [(beyond)-294(nature,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 65.307 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.046 0 Td [(or)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf -271.543 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(above)-315(nature.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 59.475 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.278 0 Td [(But)-315(while)-315(the)-314(author)-315(criticises)-315(Dr.)-445(Newman,)-331(it)]TJ -72.597 -13.549 Td [(is)-313(clear)-312(that)-313(in)-312(this)-313(passage)-312(he)-312(has)-313(fallen)-312(into)-313(a)-312(number)-313(of)-312(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(singular)-250(confusions)-250(of)-250(thought.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(First:)-421(The)-336(words)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 78.584 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.262 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.505 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.414 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(natural,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.022 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.505 0 Td [(are)-336(used)-335(as)-336(though)]TJ -196.936 -13.549 Td [(they)-308(had)-308(one)-307(clear,)-323(simple,)-322(and)-308(invariable)-307(meaning,)-323(whereas)-307(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-390(passage)-389(they)-390(are)-389(used)-390(so)-389(as)-390(to)-389(include)-390(phenomena)-389(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(widely)-240(differ)-240(from)-240(one)-240(another.)-247(We)-240(are)-240(not)-240(told)-240(what)-239(is)-240(included)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-402(the)-403(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 71.338 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(nature,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 29.989 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.234 0 Td [(whether)-402(it)-403(is)-402(restricted)-403(to)-402(matter,)-441(its)]TJ -115.405 -13.549 Td [(forces,)-441(and)-402(its)-403(laws,)-441(or)-403(whether)-402(it)-403(also)-403(includes)-402(mind)-403(and)-402(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-412(phenomena.)-737(When)-412(we)-412(speak)-413(of)-412(interruptions)-412(in)-412(the)-412(order)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-413(nature,)-454(we)-414(usually)-413(intend)-413(it)-413(to)-414(be)-413(assumed)-413(that)-413(volition)-413(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-355(cause)-355(of)-354(these)-355(interruptions.)-564(This)-355(being)-355(so,)-381(the)-355(author)-354(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(included)-303(in)-304(nature)-303(phenomena)-303(which)-303(differ)-304(so)-303(widely)-303(from)-303(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(another)-426(as)-425(those)-426(of)-426(mind)-426(and)-425(matter.)-778(He)-425(then)-426(speaks)-426(of)-425(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(chief)-437(characteristic)-437(of)-437(nature)-437(being)-437(invariability)-437(of)-437(law.)-810(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(laws)-309(and)-310(forces)-309(which)-310(regulate)-309(matter)-309(are)-310(distinguished)-309(by)-309(this)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(invariability.)-453(But)-318(the)-318(action)-317(of)-318(mind)-318(is)-318(very)-317(different.)-454(All)-317(men)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(habitually)-336(speak)-337(of)-336(some)-337(portions)-336(of)-336(it)-337(as)-336(capricious.)-509(Whether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-263(are)-263(so)-263(or)-263(not,)-266(nothing)-263(is)-263(more)-263(certain)-263(than)-263(that)-263(many)-263(of)-263(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mental)-217(phenomena)-218(have)-217(not)-218(been)-217(reduced)-218(to)-217(the)-218(action)-217(of)-217(known)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(laws.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(When,)-432(therefore,)-431(such)-396(expressions)-395(as)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 173.217 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(beside,)-432(beyond,)-431(and)]TJ -190.016 -13.549 Td [(above)-465(nature,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 61.114 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.917 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 20.827 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(natural,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.022 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.917 0 Td [(are)-465(used,)-519(I)-465(ask)-465(what)-465(nature)-465(is)]TJ -139.64 -13.549 Td [(intended?)-495(Is)-332(it)-331(matter,)-352(its)-664(forces)-332(and)-331(laws;)-373(or)-331(mind,)-352(including)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([140])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(the)-316(principle)-316(of)-317(volition;)-349(or)-316(both?)-449(If)-316(man)-316(is)-316(included)-316(in)-316(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-339(there)-339(is)-339(a)-339(power)-339(in)-339(nature)-339(which)-339(is)-339(capable)-339(of)-339(controlling)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-387(portions)-387(of)-386(nature,)-421(and)-387(even)-387(of)-387(acting)-387(on)-386(itself.)-661(If)-386(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-335(excluded)-334(from)-335(nature,)-356(then)-334(there)-335(must)-335(exist)-334(a)-335(power)-334(outside)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature,)-366(which)-343(is)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 75.407 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(beyond)-343(and)-343(above)-343(nature,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 115.135 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.585 0 Td [(and)-343(is)-343(capable)-343(of)]TJ -203.971 -13.55 Td [(acting)-454(on)-454(it.)-862(But)-453(if)-454(by)-454(nature)-454(is)-454(meant)-454(the)-454(sum)-454(total)-454(of)-453(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-359(forces)-359(which)-359(exist,)-386(whether)-359(material)-359(or)-358(immaterial,)-387(then)-358(it)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
599 0 obj <<
/Length 5136      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(126)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(is)-380(clear)-380(that)-381(a)-380(power)-380(must)-380(exist)-380(in)-381(nature)-380(which)-380(is)-380(capable)-380(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(controlling)-226(the)-225(forces)-226(of)-225(material)-226(nature,)-230(and)-225(of)-226(compelling)-225(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-232(effectuate)-232(its)-232(purposes.)-244(Whichever)-232(point)-232(of)-232(view)-232(we)-232(take)-232(of)-231(it,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(objection)-250(falls)-250(to)-250(the)-250(ground.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(But,)-255(says)-255(the)-254(author,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 92.331 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(If)-254(the)-255(course)-254(of)-255(nature)-254(be)-254(interrupted)-255(in)]TJ -109.131 -13.549 Td [(any)-248(way,)-248(whether)-248(the)-248(interruption)-248(proceed)-248(from)-248(a)-248(cause)-247(beyond,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beside,)-357(or)-336(above)-335(nature,)-357(such)-336(interruption)-336(cannot)-335(be)-336(caused)-335(by)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nature;)-355(and)-319(every)-320(disturbance)-319(in)-320(the)-320(order)-319(of)-320(nature)-320(is)-319(contrary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-337(nature.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 42.148 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.515 0 Td [(This)-337(passage)-336(seems)-337(to)-336(imply)-337(that)-336(an)-337(interruption)-336(in)]TJ -50.663 -13.549 Td [(the)-268(order)-267(of)-268(nature)-268(cannot)-267(proceed)-268(from)-268(nature)-267(itself.)-303(But)-268(this)-267(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certainly)-301(incorrect.)-405(Natural)-301(forces,)-314(that)-302(is)-301(to)-302(say,)-314(material)-301(ones,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modify)-251(one)-250(another;)-251(and)-251(by)-251(their)-250(combined)-251(action,)-251(they)-250(produce)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-214(series)-213(of)-214(events)-214(quite)-213(different)-214(from)-213(what)-214(would)-214(be)-213(the)-214(result)-213(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-252(separate)-253(action.)-257(Such)-253(a)-252(new)-253(series)-252(of)-253(events)-252(is)-253(to)-252(all)-252(intents)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-267(purposes)-268(an)-267(interruption)-268(of)-267(the)-268(previous)-267(order)-268(of)-267(nature)-267(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-410(introduction)-411(of)-410(a)-410(new)-410(one.)-731(Such)-411(results)-410(are)-410(produced)-410(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fortuitous)-213(combinations)-213(taking)-212(place,)-221(in)-212(the)-213(manner)-213(which)-213(I)-212(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(already)-376(illustrated,)-409(at)-376(the)-376(right)-377(time)-376(and)-377(place.)-629(The)-376(fortuitous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(combination)-345(of)-346(forces)-345(in)-345(nature)-345(is)-345(capable)-346(of)-345(producing)-345(a)-345(new)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 25.746 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(contrary)-250(to)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 47.564 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(the)-250(previous)-250(order)-250(of)-250(nature.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -158.479 0 Td [([141])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -14.777 Td [(This,)-352(as)-332(I)-331(have)-332(shown,)-352(is)-332(still)-331(more)-332(evidently)-332(the)-331(case)-332(if)-331(we)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(include)-250(the)-250(phenomena)-250(of)-250(mind)-250(in)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(But)-363(it)-363(is)-363(affirmed,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 85.534 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(if)-363(the)-363(interruption)-363(be)-362(due)-363(to)-363(a)-363(cause)-363(ei-)]TJ -102.333 -13.55 Td [(ther)-291(beyond,)-301(beside,)-300(or)-291(above)-291(nature,)-300(the)-291(interruption)-291(cannot)-290(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(caused)-389(by)-390(nature.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 79.079 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.092 0 Td [(This)-389(is)-390(of)-389(course)-390(a)-389(self-evident)-390(truth.)-668(But)]TJ -88.171 -13.549 Td [(then)-344(it)-344(is)-344(inferred)-344(that)-344(such)-344(interruption)-344(is)-344(a)-344(disturbance)-344(of)-343(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-212(of)-212(nature;)-224(and)-212(that)-212(every)-212(disturbance)-211(of)-212(its)-212(order)-212(is)-211(contrary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-366(nature.)-598(The)-366(inference)-366(which)-366(the)-366(reader)-366(is)-366(left)-366(to)-366(draw,)-395(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-308(is)-308(directly)-309(stated)-308(in)-308(other)-308(parts)-308(of)-309(the)-308(work,)-323(is,)-322(that)-308(what)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-291(contrary)-290(to)-291(nature)-290(is)-291(contrary)-290(to)-291(reason;)-310(that)-291(a)-290(miracle)-291(is)-290(thus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contrary)-250(to)-250(nature,)-250(and)-250(therefore)-250(contrary)-250(to)-250(reason.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(I)-183(observe)-183(that,)-197(although)-183(the)-183(interruption)-184(here)-183(referred)-183(to)-183(cannot)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(be)-357(caused)-357(by)-357(nature)-357(\050for)-357(it)-357(is)-357(contrary)-357(to)-357(the)-357(conditions)-357(of)-357(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(case)-373(that)-373(it)-373(should)-373(be\051,)-404(yet)-373(it)-373(by)-373(no)-373(means)-373(follows)-373(that)-373(it)-373(is)-373(a)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
603 0 obj <<
/Length 5210      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(127)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(breach)-240(of)-240(the)-240(order)-240(of)-240(nature)-240(in)-240(any)-240(other)-240(sense)-240(than)-240(that)-240(which)-240(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-237(already)-236(discussed.)-246(Such)-236(disturbances)-237(occur)-237(every)-236(day.)-246(It)-236(is,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore,)-269(misleading)-266(to)-265(designate)-266(them)-265(as)-265(contrary)-266(to)-265(nature,)-269(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-199(neither)-198(necessarily)-199(suspend)-198(any)-198(natural)-199(force)-198(nor)-199(violate)-198(any)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(natural)-306(law.)-418(I)-307(have)-306(already)-306(proved)-306(that)-306(there)-306(is)-306(nothing)-306(in)-306(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disturbances,)-320(or,)-320(if)-306(we)-306(persist)-306(in)-306(so)-306(designating)-306(them)-305(violations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-314(the)-315(order)-314(of)-314(nature,)-331(that)-314(is)-314(contrary)-314(to)-315(reason.)-443(Such)-314(a)-314(use)-314(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-263(terms)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 43.316 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(course)-263(and)-264(order)-263(of)-263(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 115.083 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.716 0 Td [(is)-263(full)-264(of)-263(ambiguities)-263(and)]TJ -170.959 -13.549 Td [(certain)-250(to)-250(betray)-250(us)-250(into)-250(fallacious)-250(reasonings.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But,)-305(adds)-295(the)-294(writer,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 93.682 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(it)-294(is)-295(clearly)-294(unnatural)-294(that)-295(the)-294(ordinary)]TJ -110.481 -13.549 Td [(course)-248(of)-248(nature)-248(should)-248(be)-248(disturbed.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 161.07 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.548 0 Td [(Here)-248(the)-248(ambiguity)-248(of)-248(the)]TJ -168.618 -13.55 Td [(expressions)-312(used,)-326(and)-312(the)-311(consequent)-312(fallacy)-311(of)-312(the)-311(reasonings,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-250(brought)-250(to)-250(a)-250(culmination.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(What,)-316(I)-304(ask,)-316(is)-303(intended)-303(by)-303(the)-304(ordinary)-303(course)-303(of)-303(nature?)-409(Is)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(it)-266(the)-265(invariable)-266(action)-265(of)-266(its)-265(forces,)-269(or)-266(the)-531(invariable)-265(sequences)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([142])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(of)-253(their)-252(results,)-254(or)-253(the)-252(orderly)-253(arrangement)-253(of)-252(its)-253(parts;)-254(or)-253(does)-252(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(include)-275(mind)-276(and)-275(all)-275(its)-275(phenomena,)-282(of)-275(the)-276(precise)-275(nature)-275(of)-275(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces,)-339(laws)-320(and)-321(order)-321(of)-321(which)-321(we)-320(are)-321(ignorant,)-339(and)-321(its)-320(action)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-345(the)-345(physical)-344(universe?)-535(What,)-368(again,)-369(is)-345(the)-345(precise)-344(meaning)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-241(can)-240(be)-241(attached)-241(to)-240(the)-241(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 151.066 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(unnatural)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 41.204 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.469 0 Td [(in)-241(such)-240(a)-241(context,)]TJ -204.583 -13.549 Td [(where)-324(it)-324(is)-323(evident)-324(that)-324(its)-324(meaning)-323(must)-324(vary)-324(according)-324(as)-323(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(include)-393(in)-393(nature)-393(one,)-428(several,)-429(or)-393(all)-393(of)-393(these)-393(phenomena?)-678(If)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-347(the)-346(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 57.998 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(unnatural)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 41.204 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.623 0 Td [(the)-346(meaning)-347(intended)-346(to)-347(be)-346(conveyed)]TJ -112.669 -13.549 Td [(is)-426(unusual)-427(or)-426(impossible,)-471(it)-426(is)-427(then)-426(clearly)-427(not)-426(unnatural)-426(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-304(course)-304(of)-303(nature)-304(should)-304(be)-304(interrupted)-303(in)-304(the)-304(manner)-304(I)-303(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(previously)-361(pointed)-362(out.)-584(Nor)-361(if)-362(man)-361(is)-361(included)-362(in)-361(nature,)-389(is)-361(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unnatural)-278(that)-279(the)-278(results)-279(produced)-278(by)-278(its)-279(physical)-278(forces)-278(should)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-250(greatly)-250(modified)-250(by)-250(his)-250(action?)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-374(remark)-374(of)-375(the)-374(author)-374(in)-374(connection)-375(with)-374(this)-374(subject)-374(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(perfectly)-253(true,)-254(that)-253(a)-253(grain)-254(could)-253(never)-253(of)-253(itself,)-254(nor)-253(according)-253(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-263(law)-262(of)-263(natural)-262(development,)-266(issue)-262(in)-263(a)-262(loaf)-263(of)-263(bread;)-268(but)-263(it)-262(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wholly)-248(aside)-247(from)-248(the)-247(issue)-248(which)-248(he)-247(raises.)-249(It)-248(is)-247(unquestionable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-227(forces)-227(purely)-227(physical)-227(could)-227(not)-227(effect)-228(this)-227(result;)-234(but)-227(does)-227(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(follow)-231(from)-232(this)-231(that)-231(the)-231(production)-232(of)-231(a)-231(loaf)-231(of)-232(bread)-231(is)-231(an)-231(event)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
607 0 obj <<
/Length 4830      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(128)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(contrary)-253(to)-253(nature?)-258(The)-253(result)-253(can)-252(only)-253(be)-253(produced)-253(by)-253(the)-252(com-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bination)-201(and)-200(controlling)-201(of)-201(a)-200(number)-201(of)-201(material)-200(forces)-201(by)-200(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason.)-248(The)-243(grain)-243(of)-244(wheat)-243(must)-243(be)-244(planted)-243(by)-243(man)-244(at)-243(the)-243(proper)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(season.)-234(It)-202(must)-202(be)-201(cared)-202(for)-202(by)-202(him.)-234(Various)-202(physical)-202(forces)-201(must)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(contribute)-271(to)-272(the)-271(growth)-272(and)-271(development)-271(of)-272(the)-271(plant.)-314(The)-271(ears)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(produced)-296(must)-296(be)-296(reaped)-296(in)-296(harvest-time.)-388(This)-296(process)-296(must)-296(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(repeated)-267(until)-268(the)-267(grains)-268(are)-267(sufficient)-268(in)-267(number)-268(to)-267(produce)-267(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intended)-265(loaf.)-296(Then)-265(they)-265(must)-265(be)-265(threshed,)-269(ground,)-269(prepared)-265(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-298(oven,)-311(baked.)-395(In)-298(one)-299(word,)-310(the)-299(miller)-298(and)-298(the)-299(baker)-298(must)-298(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(invoked)-318(to)-317(control,)-335(combine,)-669(modify)-318(and)-317(give)-318(a)-318(new)-317(direction)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([143])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(to)-364(the)-364(forces)-364(of)-364(nature)-364(under)-364(the)-364(direction)-364(of)-364(intelligence.)-592(All)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-275(involves)-276(something)-275(more)-275(than)-275(the)-276(action)-275(of)-275(material)-275(forces.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-304(forces)-305(of)-304(nature)-304(carry)-304(on)-304(the)-305(work)-304(to)-304(a)-304(certain)-305(point.)-412(Then)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-229(takes)-230(it)-229(up)-229(and)-229(interrupts)-230(their)-229(order,)-233(although)-230(he)-229(does)-229(so)-229(by)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(compelling)-182(other)-183(forces)-182(to)-182(effectuate)-183(the)-182(purposes)-182(of)-183(his)-182(will.)-227(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ordinary)-266(course)-266(of)-267(material)-266(nature)-266(is)-266(disturbed)-266(in)-266(the)-266(production)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-355(a)-354(loaf)-355(of)-355(bread.)-564(A)-355(new)-354(order)-355(of)-355(events)-355(is)-354(introduced.)-564(Man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-310(either)-311(within)-310(or)-310(without)-311(nature.)-431(In)-310(either)-310(case)-311(a)-310(power)-310(exists)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(is)-250(capable)-250(of)-250(producing)-250(innovations)-250(in)-250(its)-250(order.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-305(how)-305(stands)-305(the)-305(case)-305(of)-305(the)-305(feeding)-305(of)-305(five)-305(thousand)-305(per-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(sons)-274(on)-274(seven)-274(loaves)-274(and)-274(two)-274(fishes?)-322(The)-274(seven)-274(loaves)-274(and)-274(two)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fishes)-341(had)-341(been)-341(previously)-340(produced,)-364(by)-341(the)-341(action)-341(of)-340(material)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(forces)-305(out)-305(of)-305(materials)-305(already)-304(existing)-305(in)-305(the)-305(ground,)-319(in)-304(water,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-340(in)-341(the)-340(air.)-522(Of)-340(such)-340(materials)-341(there)-340(was)-341(abundance)-340(at)-340(hand)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-359(produce)-359(the)-360(requisite)-359(amount)-359(of)-359(food)-360(for)-359(the)-359(feeding)-359(of)-359(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(multitude.)-315(The)-271(only)-272(question)-271(was)-271(how)-272(to)-271(build)-272(them)-271(up)-272(into)-271(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forms)-358(of)-357(bread)-358(and)-357(fish.)-573(There)-358(was)-357(no)-358(occasion)-357(to)-358(create)-357(one)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(single)-240(particle)-240(of)-240(matter.)-247(As)-240(to)-240(the)-240(nature)-240(of)-240(the)-239(forces)-240(employed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-234(work)-235(the)-234(miracle)-234(the)-235(narrative)-234(says)-235(nothing.)-244(Nor)-235(does)-234(it)-234(imply)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-329(one)-329(of)-329(the)-329(ordinary)-329(forces)-329(of)-329(nature)-329(was)-329(suspended)-329(on)-329(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occasion.)-470(All)-323(that)-324(it)-323(asserts)-323(is)-324(the)-323(presence)-323(of)-324(a)-323(force)-323(adequate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-248(build)-248(up)-248(the)-248(materials)-248(already)-248(existing)-248(into)-248(the)-248(forms)-248(of)-247(bread)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-278(fish,)-285(that)-278(force)-278(being)-277(God.)-334(In)-278(the)-278(manufacture)-278(of)-278(the)-277(loaves)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-289(in)-289(the)-289(catching)-289(of)-289(the)-289(fish,)-299(man)-289(had)-289(interfered)-288(with)-289(nature's)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
611 0 obj <<
/Length 4932      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(129)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(order)-217(by)-216(the)-217(blending)-217(of)-217(her)-216(powers.)-239(God)-217(interfered)-217(with)-216(nature's)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-390(at)-389(a)-390(higher)-389(stage)-390(by)-389(building)-389(up)-390(the)-389(particular)-390(forms)-389(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bread)-246(and)-245(fish)-246(out)-245(of)-246(materials)-246(already)-245(in)-246(existence,)-246(by)-246(means)-245(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-352(differing)-352(from)-351(those)-352(which)-352(come)-352(under)-352(our)-351(cognisance.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(The)-342(act)-342(of)-342(man)-342(is)-683(evidence)-342(of)-342(the)-342(presence)-342(of)-342(a)-342(being)-342(who)-341(is)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([144])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(able)-215(to)-216(control)-215(the)-216(forces)-215(of)-215(external)-216(nature)-215(for)-216(his)-215(own)-215(purposes.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-294(miracle)-294(would)-293(be)-294(evidence)-294(of)-294(the)-293(presence)-294(of)-294(a)-294(Being)-293(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-278(able)-279(to)-278(exert)-279(a)-278(mightier)-279(influence)-278(over)-279(them)-278(in)-279(order)-278(to)-278(effect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-250(own.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Equal)-191(ambiguity)-192(prevails)-191(in)-191(the)-192(use)-191(of)-191(the)-192(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 201.795 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(law.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.48 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.931 0 Td [(What)-191(do)]TJ -244.005 -13.55 Td [(we)-282(mean)-283(by)-282(law)-282(when)-283(we)-282(apply)-282(the)-283(term)-282(to)-282(nature?)-347(In)-282(physical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(philosophy,)-209(the)-198(Duke)-198(of)-198(Argyll)-199(tells)-198(us)-198(it)-198(is)-199(used)-198(in)-198(a)-198(great)-198(variety)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-230(senses.)-243(Its)-230(proper)-230(meaning)-230(is)-230(to)-230(denote)-230(an)-230(invariable)-230(sequence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-230(phenomena.)-243(It)-230(is)-230(frequently)-230(made)-230(to)-230(include)-230(the)-230(conception)-229(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-266(forces)-266(at)-266(work)-265(which)-266(produce)-266(the)-266(phenomena.)-298(This)-265(ambigu-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ous)-257(use)-256(of)-257(the)-256(word)-257(has)-256(been)-257(a)-256(source)-257(of)-256(endless)-257(confusion.)-269(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(following)-250(quotation)-250(will)-250(furnish)-250(us)-250(with)-250(an)-250(example:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 229.996 0 Td [(\024)]TJ -218.04 -16.004 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(If)-413(in)-414(animated)-413(beings)-413(we)-414(have)-413(the)-413(solitary)-414(instance)-413(of)-414(an)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(efficient)-254(cause)-254(acting)-254(among)-254(the)-254(forces)-254(of)-254(nature)-254(and)-254(possessing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-341(power)-341(of)-340(initiation,)-364(this)-340(efficient)-341(cause)-341(produces)-341(no)-340(distur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bance)-251(of)-250(physical)-251(law.)-252(Its)-251(existence)-250(is)-251(as)-251(much)-250(a)-251(recognised)-250(part)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-307(the)-308(infinite)-307(variety)-307(of)-307(form)-308(within)-307(the)-307(order)-307(of)-308(nature,)-321(as)-307(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-218(of)-217(a)-217(crystal)-218(or)-217(a)-218(plant;)-228(and)-218(although)-217(the)-218(character)-217(of)-217(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(force)-335(exercised)-335(by)-335(it)-334(may)-335(not)-335(be)-335(clearly)-335(understood,)-356(its)-334(effects)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-292(regulated)-293(by)-292(the)-293(same)-292(laws)-293(as)-292(govern)-293(all)-292(the)-293(other)-292(forces)-292(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature.)-466(If)-322(the)-322(laws)-322(of)-322(matter)-322(are)-322(suspended)-322(by)-322(the)-322(laws)-322(of)-322(life,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(each)-379(time)-379(an)-379(animated)-379(being)-379(moves)-379(any)-379(part)-378(of)-379(its)-379(body,)-411(one)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(physical)-323(law)-323(is)-323(suspended)-322(in)-323(precisely)-323(the)-323(same)-323(manner)-323(and)-322(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-359(equivalent)-359(degree,)-386(each)-359(time)-359(another)-359(physical)-359(law)-359(is)-359(called)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-362(action.)-584(The)-362(law)-362(of)-361(gravitation,)-390(for)-361(instance,)-390(is)-361(suspended)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-278(the)-279(law)-278(of)-278(magnetism)-279(each)-278(time)-278(a)-279(magnet)-278(suspends)-278(a)-278(weight)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-340(the)-341(air.)-521(In)-341(each)-340(case)-340(a)-341(law)-340(is)-341(successfully)-340(resisted)-340(precisely)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-343(the)-342(extent)-343(of)-342(the)-343(force)-342(employed....)-527(No)-343(exercise)-342(of)-343(will)-342(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(overcome)-348(the)-348(law)-348(of)-348(gravitation)-348(or)-348(any)-696(other)-348(law)-348(to)-348(a)-347(greater)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([145])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
617 0 obj <<
/Length 5095      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(130)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(extent)-335(than)-335(the)-335(actual)-335(force)-335(exerted,)-356(any)-335(more)-335(than)-335(a)-334(magnetic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(current)-308(can)-308(do)-308(so)-308(beyond)-308(the)-308(action)-308(of)-308(the)-308(battery.)-424(Will)-308(has)-308(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-201(against)-202(exhaustion.)-233(Even)-201(Moses)-202(in)-201(the)-201(sublimest)-201(moments)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-311(faith)-310(could)-311(not)-311(hold)-310(up)-311(his)-310(arms)-311(to)-311(heaven)-310(after)-311(his)-310(physical)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(force)-250(was)-250(consumed.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 91.789 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(P.)-250(44,)-250(vol.)-250(i.)]TJ -87.404 -15.185 Td [(First:)-264(it)-257(is)-258(alleged)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 79.185 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(that)-257(an)-257(efficient)-257(cause)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 95.655 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.649 0 Td [(\050man)-257(for)-257(example\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf -199.289 -13.55 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(acting)-259(among)-259(the)-259(forces)-259(of)-259(nature,)-261(and)-259(possessing)-259(the)-259(power)-258(of)]TJ -4.844 -13.549 Td [(initiation,)-208(produces)-197(no)-197(disturbance)-197(of)-197(physical)-197(law.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 219.656 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.994 0 Td [(What)-197(is)-197(here)]TJ -226.65 -13.549 Td [(meant)-334(by)-334(disturbance)-333(of)-334(physical)-334(law?)-501(It)-334(is)-334(plain)-334(that)-333(physical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-340(would)-339(work)-340(out)-340(a)-339(wholly)-340(different)-340(result)-339(apart)-340(from)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-215(of)-215(man)-215(upon)-215(them.)-238(Though)-215(he)-215(suspends)-215(no)-215(physical)-214(force,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-430(action)-430(of)-430(man)-430(has)-430(produced)-430(an)-430(order)-430(of)-430(events)-430(in)-430(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(different)-430(from)-429(that)-430(which)-430(would)-430(have)-429(taken)-430(place)-430(without)-429(it,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-303(by)-304(balancing)-303(one)-303(against)-304(the)-303(other)-303(he)-304(modifies)-303(their)-303(action.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(What)-241(is)-240(more,)-243(he)-241(possesses)-240(a)-241(power)-241(of)-241(self-determination.)-246(Other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-347(are)-346(unintelligent.)-540(Man)-347(is)-347(an)-346(intelligent)-347(force)-347(capable)-346(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(introducing)-377(an)-378(order)-377(of)-378(nature)-377(quite)-377(different)-378(from)-377(that)-377(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-347(material)-346(forces)-347(of)-346(nature)-346(would)-347(have)-346(produced)-347(without)-346(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intervention.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Next:)-535(we)-393(are)-393(told)-393(that)-392(the)-393(existence)-393(of)-393(man)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 205.53 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(is)-393(as)-392(much)-393(a)]TJ -222.33 -13.549 Td [(recognised)-238(part)-238(of)-238(the)-238(infinite)-238(variety)-238(of)-238(form)-238(within)-238(the)-238(order)-238(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature)-270(as)-269(the)-270(existence)-269(of)-270(a)-270(plant)-269(or)-270(a)-269(crystal.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 198.232 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.784 0 Td [(I)-270(again)-269(ask,)-275(what)]TJ -206.016 -13.549 Td [(nature?)-356(Is)-285(the)-285(order)-286(spoken)-285(of)-285(that)-286(of)-285(blind)-285(unintelligent)-285(forces,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-274(does)-274(it)-274(include)-274(intelligence)-275(and)-274(free)-274(agency?)-322(Unless)-274(man)-274(is)-274(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(blind)-219(unintelligent)-219(force,)-225(although)-218(he)-219(be)-219(supposed)-219(to)-219(exist)-218(within)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature,)-405(he)-374(belongs)-374(to)-375(an)-374(order)-374(wholly)-374(different)-374(from)-374(that)-374(of)-374(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(plant)-288(or)-288(a)-289(crystal.)-364(To)-288(assert)-288(the)-289(contrary)-288(is)-288(to)-288(assume)-288(the)-288(whole)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question.)-793(The)-431(results)-862(produced)-431(by)-431(intelligent)-431(volition)-430(differ)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([146])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(completely)-286(in)-285(character)-286(from)-286(those)-285(effected)-286(by)-286(the)-285(unintelligent)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(forces)-234(of)-234(nature.)-245(The)-234(one)-234(follows)-234(an)-234(order)-234(of)-233(necessity:)-242(the)-234(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-299(freedom.)-398(The)-299(affirmation)-299(that)-299(the)-300(results)-299(of)-299(the)-299(latter)-299(belong)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-334(the)-334(same)-334(order)-334(as)-334(those)-334(of)-334(the)-334(former)-334(is)-334(directly)-334(contrary)-333(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(facts.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Again:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 32.404 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(the)-247(laws)-247(of)-247(matter)-247(are)-247(suspended)-246(by)-247(the)-247(laws)-247(of)-247(life.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 226.582 0 Td [(\035)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
621 0 obj <<
/Length 5258      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(131)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(If)-434(laws)-434(are)-434(the)-435(invariable)-434(sequences)-434(of)-434(phenomena)-434(how)-434(is)-434(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possible)-355(that)-355(one)-356(law)-355(can)-355(suspend)-355(another)-355(law?)-566(It)-355(is)-355(not)-355(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(true)-387(that)-388(one)-387(force)-388(can)-387(suspend)-388(another)-387(force.)-662(All)-388(that)-387(it)-387(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(do)-326(is)-326(to)-326(neutralize)-326(its)-326(action.)-478(Physical)-326(philosophy)-326(is)-325(constantly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(attributing)-404(to)-403(laws)-404(what)-404(can)-404(only)-403(be)-404(true)-404(of)-404(forces,)-442(and)-403(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(frequently)-209(ascribes)-209(to)-209(them)-209(what)-209(is)-209(only)-209(true)-209(of)-209(intelligent)-208(forces.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-288(must)-289(never)-288(be)-289(overlooked)-288(in)-288(this)-289(controversy)-288(that)-289(the)-288(laws)-288(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature)-272(can)-272(effectuate)-272(nothing.)-316(Forces,)-277(not)-272(laws,)-278(produce)-271(results.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-342(following)-343(sentence)-342(will)-343(be)-342(a)-343(correct)-342(expression)-343(of)-342(a)-342(truth,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(if)-412(we)-412(substitute)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 74.693 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(force)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 22.407 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.337 0 Td [(for)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 17.214 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(law:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.785 0 Td [(\035)-412(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.182 0 Td [(The)-412(law)-412(of)-412(gravitation)-412(is)]TJ -166.306 -13.549 Td [(overcome)-228(by)-229(the)-228(law)-229(of)-228(magnetism)-229(each)-228(time)-229(a)-228(magnet)-228(suspends)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-287(weight)-287(in)-287(the)-287(air.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 83.114 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.974 0 Td [(Immediately)-287(after,)-296(we)-287(are)-287(told)-287(that)-287(the)-287(arm)]TJ -91.088 -13.549 Td [(falls)-183(in)-183(obedience)-183(to)-183(law.)-228(It)-183(falls)-183(by)-183(the)-183(force)-183(of)-183(gravitation.)-227(When)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(theologians)-348(use)-348(metaphors)-348(of)-348(this)-348(description)-348(they)-348(are)-348(charged)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-303(anthropomorphism.)-410(Such)-303(a)-303(charge)-304(is)-303(equally)-303(valid)-303(against)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(language)-250(in)-250(which)-250(physical)-250(philosophy)-250(expresses)-250(itself.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Again:)-538(The)-394(author)-393(affirms)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 124.792 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(that)-394(the)-394(solitary)-394(instance)-393(of)-394(an)]TJ -141.591 -13.549 Td [(efficient)-394(cause,)-431(if)-394(it)-394(be)-395(distinguished)-394(from)-394(the)-395(other)-394(forces)-394(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature)-399(by)-400(the)-399(possession)-400(of)-399(an)-399(initiatory)-400(impulse,)-437(is)-399(from)-399(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moment)-239(when)-240(that)-239(power)-240(is)-239(exerted)-240(subject)-239(to)-240(physical)-239(laws)-239(like)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(all)-419(other)-418(forces;)-503(and)-419(there)-419(is)-419(no)-418(instance)-419(producible,)-461(or)-418(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(logically)-329(conceivable,)-348(of)-328(any)-329(power)-329(whose)-328(effects)-329(are)-328(opposed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-308(the)-308(ultimate)-616(ruling)-309(of)-308(the)-308(laws)-308(of)-308(nature.)-424(The)-308(occurrence)-308(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([147])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(anything)-250(opposed)-250(to)-250(these)-250(laws)-250(is)-250(incredible.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 195.436 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(p.)-250(48.)]TJ -191.051 -16.004 Td [(What)-340(is)-341(meant,)-363(I)-341(ask,)-363(by)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 114.887 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(the)-340(intimate)-341(ruling)-341(of)-340(the)-341(laws)-340(of)]TJ -131.687 -13.549 Td [(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.262 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(?)-531(Even)-343(if)-344(we)-344(substitute)-343(forces)-344(for)-343(laws,)-367(the)-344(meaning)-343(is)]TJ -32.106 -13.549 Td [(sufficiently)-202(obscure.)-233(Probably)-202(the)-201(expression)-202(is)-201(intended)-202(to)-201(mean)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-354(combined)-355(result)-354(effected)-354(by)-355(the)-354(energy)-354(of)-355(all)-354(the)-354(forces)-354(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature.)-361(If)-287(these)-287(include)-287(all)-287(mental)-287(as)-287(well)-287(as)-287(all)-287(material)-286(forces,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-220(the)-219(assertion)-220(is)-219(a)-220(simple)-219(truism,)-226(that)-220(nothing)-219(can)-220(be)-219(contrary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-253(itself.)-257(But)-253(if)-252(they)-253(exclude)-252(mental)-253(force,)-253(then)-252(the)-253(results)-252(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-378(produce)-379(are)-378(clearly)-379(opposed)-378(to)-379(the)-378(ultimate)-379(ruling)-378(of)-378(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(forces)-303(of)-304(unintelligent)-303(nature.)-411(Numerous)-303(instances)-304(are)-303(not)-303(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(logically)-315(conceivable,)-331(but)-315(actually)-315(producible.)-445(The)-315(occurrence,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
625 0 obj <<
/Length 4559      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(132)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(therefore,)-386(of)-359(anything)-358(opposed)-359(to)-359(the)-358(ultimate)-359(rulings)-359(of)-358(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unintelligent)-256(physical)-255(forces)-256(is)-255(not)-256(incredible.)-267(It)-255(is)-256(perfectly)-255(true)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-345(man)-345(can)-345(only)-346(produce)-345(results)-345(through)-345(the)-345(agency)-345(of)-345(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical)-255(forces;)-258(but)-255(he)-256(can)-255(modify)-255(their)-255(results,)-257(and)-255(so)-255(use)-255(them)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-370(to)-370(make)-370(them)-370(the)-371(means)-370(of)-370(effectuating)-370(his)-370(purposes.)-610(It)-370(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(quite)-238(true)-238(that)-238(nothing)-238(can)-238(occur)-238(opposed)-238(to)-238(the)-238(forces)-238(of)-238(nature;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-224(is)-223(to)-224(say,)-229(that,)-229(while)-223(the)-224(force)-223(of)-224(gravitation)-223(is)-224(in)-224(energy,)-228(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-346(other)-345(force)-346(is)-346(present)-345(capable)-346(of)-346(overcoming)-345(its)-346(power,)-369(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ascension)-294(of)-295(a)-294(human)-294(body)-294(into)-295(heaven)-294(is)-294(impossible.)-383(But)-294(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(has)-253(ever)-252(affirmed)-253(that)-253(it)-253(was)-252(possible?)-259(Those)-252(who)-253(affirm)-253(that)-252(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ascension)-319(has)-318(taken)-319(place,)-336(also)-318(assert)-319(that)-319(another)-318(force)-319(was)-318(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(active)-323(energy,)-342(which)-323(was)-323(capable)-324(of)-323(counteracting)-323(the)-323(force)-323(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gravitation.)-434(This)-312(assertion,)-326(therefore,)-327(is)-311(totally)-312(irrelevant)-311(to)-311(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(point)-250(at)-250(issue.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-397(consideration)-398(of)-397(the)-398(next)-397(question)-398(before)-397(us)-398(may)-397(very)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(properly)-281(be)-280(introduced,)-289(by)-280(quoting)-281(the)-281(following)-280(passage)-281(of)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same)-250(author:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -15.186 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Our)-475(highest)-475(attainable)-475(conception)-475(of)-475(infinite)-475(power)-950(and)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -89.554 0 Td [([148])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(wisdom)-236(is)-237(based)-236(on)-236(the)-236(universality)-237(and)-236(invariability)-236(of)-236(law,)-239(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(inexorably)-427(excludes)-427(as)-427(unworthy)-427(and)-427(anthropomorphistic)-426(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(idea)-250(of)-250(its)-250(fitful)-250(suspension.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 120.906 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -108.95 -15.185 Td [(This)-246(at)-246(once)-247(raises)-246(the)-246(very)-246(important)-246(question,)-247(whether)-246(there)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(is)-245(anything)-245(in)-245(the)-245(performance)-245(of)-245(a)-245(miracle)-245(inconsistent)-245(with)-245(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine)-377(character)-377(and)-377(perfections.)-632(It)-377(has)-377(been)-377(often)-377(alleged)-377(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-231(who)-230(deny)-231(the)-231(possibility)-230(of)-231(miracles,)-234(that)-231(God)-231(energizes)-230(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-321(universe)-322(in)-321(conformity)-322(with)-321(invariable)-322(laws,)-339(which)-321(express)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-405(uniform)-404(mode)-405(of)-404(the)-405(divine)-404(working.)-714(From)-405(these,)-443(as)-404(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(result)-211(of)-210(his)-211(wisdom,)-219(He)-210(will)-211(never)-211(deviate.)-237(To)-210(alter)-211(or)-211(vary)-210(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-320(mode)-320(of)-320(acting)-320(implies)-320(that)-320(the)-320(machinery)-320(of)-320(the)-319(universe,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(through)-371(which)-372(He)-371(acts,)-402(is)-372(imperfect.)-614(The)-372(supposition)-371(that)-371(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-279(worked)-278(a)-279(miracle)-278(therefore)-279(involves)-279(the)-278(assumption)-279(that)-278(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-380(ceased)-381(from)-380(one)-381(mode)-380(of)-381(action)-380(and)-380(adopted)-381(another;)-445(or,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-320(other)-320(words,)-337(that)-320(the)-320(forces)-320(of)-320(the)-320(universe)-320(fail)-320(to)-319(effectuate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-403(purposes;)-479(or)-402(that)-403(the)-403(whole)-402(machine)-403(has)-403(got)-402(out)-403(of)-402(order)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
629 0 obj <<
/Length 4620      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(133)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(and)-378(requires)-378(rectification.)-633(Any)-378(action)-378(of)-378(this)-378(kind)-378(in)-378(the)-377(case)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-384(a)-385(Being)-384(possessed)-384(of)-384(all)-384(power,)-418(is)-385(a)-384(reflection)-384(both)-384(on)-384(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wisdom)-203(and)-203(his)-203(immutability.)-234(Still)-203(further:)-227(it)-203(is)-203(affirmed)-203(by)-202(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-301(the)-300(love)-301(of)-301(order)-300(is)-301(an)-301(attribute)-300(so)-301(inherent)-301(in)-300(Deity,)-314(that)-300(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-345(inconceivable)-345(that)-345(any)-345(alteration)-345(in)-345(the)-345(existing)-345(order)-345(of)-345(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(universe)-250(should)-250(take)-250(place)-250(under)-250(his)-250(government.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(One)-403(objection)-404(raised)-403(in)-404(the)-403(above)-403(quotation)-404(I)-403(may)-403(dismiss)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(summarily,)-482(viz.)-807(the)-435(idea)-436(that)-435(God)-436(interposes)-435(with)-436(any)-435(fitful)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interventions)-346(in)-347(the)-346(universe.)-539(The)-347(idea)-346(of)-347(fitful)-346(intervention)-346(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(quite)-297(foreign)-297(to)-296(the)-297(conception)-297(of)-297(a)-296(miracle,)-309(which)-297(is)-296(described)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-278(the)-279(New)-278(Testament)-279(as)-278(one)-279(of)-278(the)-279(means)-278(by)-279(which)-278(he)-278(realizes)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(his)-247(deliberate)-247(purposes.)-249(I)-248(shall)-247(elsewhere)-247(disprove)-247(the)-247(allegation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-456(Revelation)-456(is)-456(an)-457(intervention)-456(of)-456(the)-456(Creator)-456(to)-456(rectify)-456(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miscarriage)-250(in)-250(his)-250(creative)-250(work.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([149])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -15.186 Td [(It)-406(will)-406(also)-406(be)-406(desirable)-406(in)-406(this)-406(place)-406(to)-406(answer)-406(the)-406(charge)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-295(anthropomorphism)-294(so)-295(frequently)-295(urged)-294(against)-295(the)-294(defenders)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-459(Christianity.)-877(When)-460(they)-459(speak)-459(of)-459(God)-459(as)-459(a)-459(person,)-511(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-448(charged)-448(with)-448(manufacturing)-448(a)-448(gigantic)-448(man.)-844(When)-448(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ascribe)-330(to)-330(Him)-329(a)-330(moral)-330(character,)-350(or)-329(describe)-330(Him)-330(as)-330(acting)-329(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nature,)-305(they)-294(are)-293(then)-294(accused)-294(of)-294(making)-294(a)-293(God)-294(out)-294(of)-294(a)-293(number)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-450(conceptions)-450(which)-450(are)-450(purely)-450(human.)-850(This)-450(fault,)-500(if)-450(it)-450(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one,)-312(must)-300(be)-300(shared)-299(alike)-300(by)-300(philosophers,)-312(men)-300(of)-299(science,)-312(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(theologians.)-442(The)-314(plain)-313(fact)-314(is,)-330(that)-314(man)-314(has)-314(no)-314(conceptions)-313(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(human)-348(ones.)-543(To)-348(abandon)-347(these)-348(is)-348(to)-347(cease)-348(to)-348(think)-347(altogether.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(When)-248(philosophers)-248(and)-248(men)-248(of)-249(science)-248(speak)-248(of)-248(nature,)-248(they)-248(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(obliged)-273(to)-273(apply)-273(to)-274(it)-273(conceptions)-273(which)-273(are)-273(strictly)-273(true)-273(only)-273(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man.)-559(We)-353(are)-354(obliged)-353(to)-353(do)-353(precisely)-353(the)-353(same)-353(with)-353(respect)-353(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God.)-243(So)-228(far)-229(all)-228(thought,)-233(the)-229(most)-228(elevated)-229(and)-228(the)-229(most)-228(ordinary,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-327(anthropomorphic.)-482(The)-327(term)-327(can)-327(be)-327(fairly)-327(used)-327(as)-327(a)-327(reproach)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(only)-237(when)-237(certain)-238(material)-237(conceptions)-237(or)-237(degraded)-237(passions)-237(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(directly)-250(affirmed)-250(to)-250(exist)-250(in)-250(the)-250(divine)-250(mind.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(The)-435(author,)-482(in)-436(the)-435(following)-436(passage,)-482(places)-435(the)-435(objection)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(before)-301(us)-301(in)-301(a)-300(still)-301(more)-301(striking)-301(light:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 172.873 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Being)-301(therefore)-301(limited)]TJ -177.717 -13.549 Td [(to)-218(reason)-218(for)-218(our)-217(feeble)-218(conceptions)-218(of)-218(the)-218(divine)-218(Being)-218(of)-217(which)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
633 0 obj <<
/Length 4832      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(134)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(we)-290(are)-291(capable,)-300(and)-290(reason)-291(being)-290(totally)-290(opposed)-291(to)-290(an)-290(order)-290(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature)-245(so)-245(imperfect)-245(as)-245(to)-245(require)-245(or)-245(permit)-245(repeated)-245(interference,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-213(rejecting)-213(the)-212(supposition)-213(of)-213(arbitrary)-213(suspension)-212(of)-213(law,)-220(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-389(conception)-390(of)-389(the)-389(Deity)-390(as)-389(is)-389(proposed)-390(by)-389(theologians)-389(must)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-463(pronounced)-463(irrational,)-516(and)-463(derogatory)-463(to)-463(the)-463(wisdom)-462(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(perfection)-276(which)-276(we)-276(recognize)-275(in)-276(the)-276(invariable)-276(order)-276(of)-275(nature.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-428(is)-429(impossible)-428(for)-428(us)-428(to)-428(conceive)-429(the)-428(supreme)-428(Being)-428(acting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(otherwise)-277(than)-278(we)-277(actually)-277(see)-278(in)-277(nature;)-291(and)-277(if)-278(we)-277(recognize)-277(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-240(universe)-240(the)-240(operation)-241(of)-240(his)-240(infinite)-240(wisdom)-240(and)-240(power,)-242(it)-240(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-240(the)-240(immutable)-240(order)-241(and)-240(regularity)-240(of)-240(all)-240(phenomena,)-484(and)-240(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([150])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(eternal)-177(prevalence)-177(of)-177(law)-177(that)-177(we)-177(see)-177(their)-177(highest)-176(manifestation.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 275.786 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -263.83 -16.004 Td [(It)-277(is)-276(asserted)-277(by)-277(this)-277(writer)-276(and)-277(a)-277(great)-277(number)-276(of)-277(others,)-283(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-261(most)-261(perfect)-260(conception)-261(of)-261(the)-261(universe)-260(is)-261(that)-261(of)-261(a)-260(machine,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-187(when)-188(once)-187(set)-187(into)-188(action)-187(shall)-187(go)-188(on)-187(eternally)-187(grinding)-187(out)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-211(results)-212(without)-211(the)-212(smallest)-211(occasion)-212(for)-211(the)-212(intervention)-211(of)-211(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Maker.)-242(According)-225(to)-226(this)-225(view,)-230(all)-226(the)-225(He)-225(has)-226(to)-225(do)-226(for)-225(the)-225(future)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(after)-276(the)-275(machine)-276(is)-275(once)-276(set)-275(into)-276(operation,)-281(is)-276(to)-275(retire)-276(from)-275(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(scene)-280(of)-281(His)-280(creative)-280(work,)-288(and)-280(to)-280(contemplate)-281(the)-280(results)-280(of)-280(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wonderful)-232(operations.)-244(Any)-231(intervention)-232(on)-232(His)-231(part)-232(would)-231(imply)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-290(defect)-290(in)-290(the)-290(construction)-290(of)-290(the)-290(machine.)-370(It)-290(follows)-290(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-292(the)-293(most)-292(perfect)-292(conception)-292(of)-293(God)-292(\050if)-292(there)-293(be)-292(one\051)-292(is)-292(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-329(a)-329(perfect)-329(mechanist)-328(and)-329(chemist,)-349(who)-329(has)-329(originally)-328(formed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(matter)-346(with)-347(its)-346(properties)-346(and)-346(forces)-347(acting)-346(in)-346(conformity)-346(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(invariable)-369(law,)-399(and)-369(that)-369(this)-369(has)-369(been)-369(done)-369(by)-369(Him)-368(with)-369(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(perfection,)-274(that)-269(they)-269(have)-269(gone)-269(on)-269(ever)-269(since)-268(evolving)-269(whatever)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(has)-263(existed,)-265(without)-263(the)-262(need)-263(of)-262(His)-263(interventi)1(on)-263(or)-262(supervision;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-285(to)-286(put)-285(it)-286(in)-285(other)-286(words,)-294(after)-285(the)-286(original)-285(act)-286(of)-285(creation,)-294(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presence)-276(in)-275(the)-276(universe)-275(may)-276(be)-276(dispensed)-275(with)-276(as)-275(unnecessary.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-240(universe)-240(is)-239(therefore)-240(a)-240(self-acting)-239(machine)-240(which)-240(goes)-240(on)-239(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-250(eternal)-250(series)-250(of)-250(self-evolutions.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Such)-330(a)-330(conception)-331(may)-330(be)-330(the)-330(most)-331(worthy)-330(one)-330(that)-330(we)-330(can)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(form)-189(of)-189(a)-189(perfect)-188(mechanist)-189(or)-189(chemist,)-201(though)-189(it)-189(may)-189(be)-188(doubtful)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(how)-359(far)-359(the)-360(idea)-359(of)-359(having)-359(his)-360(services)-359(dispensed)-359(with)-359(for)-359(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(future)-300(would)-299(be)-300(wholly)-300(satisfactory)-299(to)-300(him.)-399(It)-300(is)-299(far)-300(from)-299(clear,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
637 0 obj <<
/Length 4478      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(135)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(however,)-350(that)-329(it)-330(is)-330(the)-329(most)-330(perfect)-330(conception)-329(we)-330(can)-330(form)-329(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God.)-787(The)-429(creations)-428(of)-429(the)-429(mechanist)-429(and)-429(of)-429(the)-429(chemist)-428(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(destitute)-391(alike)-391(of)-391(feeling,)-426(reason)-391(and)-391(volition,)-426(a)-391(moral)-391(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conscience,)-368(and)-344(spiritual)-344(affections.)-532(They)-344(may)-344(therefore)-344(when)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(completed)-301(be)-302(left)-301(to)-302(themselves;)-327(and)-603(the)-301(more)-302(perfect)-301(the)-301(irra-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([151])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(tional)-349(machine)-349(may)-349(be,)-374(the)-350(more)-349(perfectly)-349(it)-349(will)-349(grind)-349(out)-349(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(results.)-259(But)-252(many)-253(of)-253(the)-253(constructions)-253(of)-253(God)-253(possess)-252(attributes,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-188(exhibit)-187(other)-188(qualities)-187(in)-188(t)1(heir)-188(maker)-187(than)-188(those)-187(of)-188(a)-187(perfect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mechanist)-342(or)-341(chemist.)-524(It)-342(follows,)-364(therefore,)-365(that)-341(this)-342(is)-341(not)-341(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(most)-234(perfect)-234(nor)-234(the)-234(most)-234(worthy)-234(conception)-234(which)-234(we)-234(can)-234(form)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(God.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-215(it)-215(will)-214(be)-215(objected)-215(that)-215(even)-215(if)-214(we)-215(concede)-215(that)-215(the)-214(Creator)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-384(ever)-384(present)-384(energizing)-384(in)-384(the)-385(works)-384(of)-384(nature,)-417(and)-384(even)-384(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-246(forces)-246(of)-246(nature)-245(are)-246(viewed)-246(as)-246(the)-246(expressions)-246(of)-246(His)-245(energy,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-278(action)-279(in)-278(conformity)-278(with)-278(unchanging)-279(order)-278(is)-278(the)-278(worthiest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conception)-345(of)-344(Him,)-368(and)-345(to)-344(assert)-345(that)-344(He)-345(ever)-344(has)-345(varied)-344(from)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-317(mode)-316(of)-317(action)-317(is)-316(to)-317(degrade)-316(Him.)-450(Such)-317(being)-317(the)-316(case,)-333(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-297(that)-296(miracles)-297(have)-297(been)-296(wrought)-297(by)-297(Him,)-308(is)-297(to)-296(introduce)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-297(degraded)-297(view)-297(of)-297(the)-297(character)-297(of)-297(God,)-309(one)-297(alike)-296(inconsistent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-250(His)-250(wisdom,)-250(immutability)-250(and)-250(power.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-288(reply:)-327(that)-288(the)-288(objection)-288(overlooks)-289(the)-288(existence)-288(of)-288(purpose)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-317(the)-318(divine)-317(mind,)-335(and)-317(that)-317(it)-318(may)-317(not)-318(be)-317(confined)-318(to)-317(the)-317(real-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ization)-240(of)-240(a)-240(mechanical)-240(result.)-247(The)-240(purpose)-240(or)-240(idea)-240(of)-240(creation)-240(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God)-301(includes)-300(the)-301(production)-300(of)-301(both)-300(the)-301(material)-300(and)-301(the)-300(moral)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(worlds.)-700(If)-401(this)-400(be)-400(so,)-437(one)-401(harmonious)-400(purpose,)-437(including)-400(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine)-331(manifestations,)-352(both)-332(in)-331(the)-331(material)-332(and)-331(moral)-331(universe,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-402(be)-402(carried)-403(out)-402(by)-402(a)-402(succession)-402(of)-402(progressive)-402(manifesta-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tions,)-224(each)-218(forming)-218(a)-218(portion)-217(of)-218(one)-218(great)-218(divine)-217(plan.)-240(A)-217(miracle,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore,)-393(as)-364(a)-364(part)-364(of)-365(such)-364(a)-364(moral)-364(intervention,)-393(would)-364(be)-364(no)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(interruption)-194(of)-194(the)-194(orderly)-193(action)-194(of)-194(the)-194(divine)-194(mind,)-205(but)-194(a)-193(portion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(But)-474(further:)-698(if)-475(God)-474(exists,)-530(He)-474(must)-474(have)-474(other)-474(attributes)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(besides)-349(those)-349(of)-349(a)-349(mechanist)-348(or)-349(a)-349(chemist.)-547(He)-349(has)-349(created)-348(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-225(the)-226(material)-225(universe,)-230(but)-226(a)-225(moral)-225(one.)-242(God,)-230(therefore,)-230(must)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
642 0 obj <<
/Length 4734      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(136)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(be)-357(a)-358(moral)-357(being,)-384(and)-357(a)-714(person,)-385(for)-357(moral)-357(attributes)-357(can)-357(only)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([152])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(be)-405(conceived)-404(of)-405(as)-404(belonging)-405(to)-405(a)-404(being)-405(who)-404(is)-405(possessed)-404(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(personality.)-246(It)-237(follows,)-239(therefore,)-240(that)-237(manifestations)-237(of)-236(Himself,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-230(aspects)-230(suitable)-230(to)-231(moral)-230(beings,)-234(are)-230(as)-230(much)-230(to)-230(be)-230(expect-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ed)-323(as)-323(manifestations)-323(of)-322(His)-323(power)-323(or)-323(of)-323(His)-323(wisdom)-322(addressed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-284(an)-285(intellectual)-284(nature.)-353(The)-284(supposition,)-293(therefore,)-293(that)-284(all)-284(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manifestations)-371(can)-371(only)-371(be)-371(made)-371(through)-371(the)-371(laws)-371(of)-371(material)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature,)-235(and)-230(in)-231(an)-230(unchanging)-231(series,)-234(and)-231(that)-231(it)-230(is)-231(not)-230(a)-231(portion)-230(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-290(purpose)-290(to)-290(manifest)-289(Himself)-290(as)-290(a)-290(moral)-290(being,)-300(is)-290(only)-289(valid)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-252(the)-253(denial)-252(that)-252(He)-253(is)-252(one.)-257(It)-252(involves)-253(the)-252(absurdity)-252(of)-252(denying)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-290(God)-289(that)-290(freedom)-290(from)-289(the)-290(trammels)-290(of)-289(necessary)-290(law)-289(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-250(matter)-250(of)-250(fact)-250(He)-250(has)-250(bestowed)-250(on)-250(man.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(If)-458(therefore)-458(God)-458(be)-457(a)-458(moral)-458(being)-458(and)-458(not)-458(an)-457(impersonal)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(force,)-371(it)-347(is)-346(perfectly)-347(consistent)-347(with)-346(the)-347(highest)-347(conceptions)-346(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Him,)-386(that)-359(He)-359(should)-359(manifest)-359(Himself)-359(in)-359(the)-359(moral)-359(as)-359(well)-359(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-387(the)-386(material)-386(universe.)-660(This)-386(is)-387(the)-386(more)-387(necessary,)-420(because)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(philosophy)-345(is)-346(never)-345(wearied)-345(with)-346(telling)-345(us,)-369(that)-346(we)-345(can)-345(know)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(little)-262(or)-262(nothing)-262(of)-262(His)-262(moral)-262(attributes)-262(from)-262(material)-262(nature.)-285(As)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-233(part)-233(of)-233(such)-233(manifestation)-233(a)-233(miracle)-233(is)-233(addressed)-233(to)-233(our)-232(highest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-221(is)-221(absurd)-222(to)-221(argue)-221(on)-221(the)-221(assumption)-222(that)-221(there)-221(is)-221(a)-222(God,)-226(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(then)-211(to)-210(found)-211(our)-210(reasonings)-210(on)-211(principles)-210(which)-211(are)-210(inconsistent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-259(it.)-277(If)-259(there)-259(is)-259(a)-259(God,)-261(He)-259(must)-259(be)-259(the)-259(creator)-259(of)-259(the)-259(universe.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-289(must,)-298(therefore,)-299(have)-289(been)-288(consistent)-289(with)-289(His)-289(perfection)-288(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(immutability)-216(to)-216(create.)-238(It)-216(follows,)-223(therefore,)-222(even)-216(on)-216(the)-215(assump-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-289(of)-289(the)-289(truth)-290(of)-289(the)-289(Darwinian)-289(theory)-289(of)-289(creation,)-299(that)-289(a)-289(new)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-341(must)-341(have)-341(been)-341(introduced,)-364(when)-341(God)-341(first)-340(breathed)-341(life)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-219(the)-218(lowest)-219(forms)-219(of)-219(matter.)-239(But)-219(if)-219(He)-218(introduced)-219(a)-219(new)-218(order)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then,)-417(that)-383(is)-383(to)-384(say,)-416(when)-384(He)-383(first)-383(deviated)-384(from)-383(the)-383(previous)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(order)-419(of)-419(His)-419(existence,)-461(and)-419(performed)-419(His)-838(first)-419(creative)-418(act,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([153])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(how)-315(can)-316(it)-315(possibly)-316(be)-315(contrary)-315(to)-316(reason)-315(to)-315(affirm)-316(that)-315(He)-315(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(repeated)-349(it.)-548(A)-349(miracle)-350(would)-349(be)-349(such)-350(a)-349(repetition,)-374(or,)-374(in)-349(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(words,)-250(the)-250(introduction)-250(of)-250(a)-250(new)-250(series)-250(of)-250(events.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-249(fully)-249(admit)-249(that)-250(reason)-249(is)-249(opposed)-249(to)-249(the)-249(supposition)-249(of)-249(such)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
647 0 obj <<
/Length 4797      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(137)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(an)-376(order)-376(of)-376(nature)-376(as)-376(to)-376(require)-376(repeated)-376(interferences)-376(with)-376(it,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assuming)-278(that)-278(what)-278(is)-278(intended)-278(is)-278(a)-278(frequent)-278(meddling)-278(with)-278(it)-278(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(set)-206(it)-207(right,)-215(not)-206(constant)-206(presence)-206(and)-207(superintendence.)-235(Still)-206(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-260(it)-261(opposed)-260(to)-261(the)-260(idea)-260(of)-261(arbitrary)-260(interruption)-261(of)-260(law.)-281(The)-260(en-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tire)-235(validity)-236(of)-235(these)-236(reasonings)-235(which)-235(we)-236(have)-235(been)-235(considering)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proceeds)-194(on)-195(the)-194(assumption)-194(that)-194(the)-194(argument)-195(requires)-194(this.)-231(I)-194(care)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-192(what)-192(some)-192(Christian)-192(apologists)-192(may)-192(have)-192(said)-192(on)-192(this)-191(subject.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-348(New)-348(Testament)-348(affirms)-348(in)-348(the)-348(most)-348(unequivocal)-348(language)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-421(revelation)-420(is)-421(the)-420(steady)-421(carrying)-421(out)-420(of)-421(a)-420(pre-determined)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(purpose)-303(in)-304(God)-303(to)-304(make)-303(a)-303(manifestation)-304(of)-303(Himself)-304(not)-303(only)-303(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man,)-420(but)-387(to)-386(other)-386(rational)-386(beings)-386(besides)-387(man.)-658(The)-386(objection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-250(falls)-250(to)-250(the)-250(ground.)]TJ 11.956 -13.815 Td [(The)-269(assertion)-268(that)-269(it)-269(is)-268(impossible)-269(to)-269(conceive)-268(of)-269(the)-268(supreme)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(Being)-201(acting)-201(otherwise)-201(than)-202(we)-201(see)-201(him)-201(act)-201(in)-201(nature,)-211(may)-201(be)-201(met)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-201(a)-201(direct)-201(denial.)-233(On)-201(the)-201(contrary)-201(the)-201(presence)-201(of)-201(evil,)-211(moral)-200(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical,)-314(forms)-302(the)-301(greatest)-301(difficulty)-301(connected)-302(with)-301(the)-301(belief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-340(theism.)-521(The)-340(elder)-340(Mill)-340(was)-341(so)-340(capable)-340(of)-340(conceiving)-340(that)-340(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-324(supreme)-324(Being)-324(existed,)-342(the)-324(order)-324(of)-324(the)-324(universe)-324(would)-323(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-248(so)-248(wholly)-248(different)-248(from)-248(its)-249(present)-248(order,)-248(that)-248(it)-248(led)-248(him)-248(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-329(that)-328(the)-329(proof)-328(of)-329(His)-329(existence)-328(was)-329(altogether)-329(want)1(ing.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 276.147 3.959 Td [(3)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -276.147 -17.508 Td [(But)-250(intelligent)-251(Christians)-250(fully)-251(recognize)-250(in)-251(the)-250(immutable)-250(order)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-270(regularity)-271(of)-270(the)-271(universe)-270(and)-271(the)-270(eternal)-271(prevalence)-270(of)-270(law,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-324(operation)-324(of)-323(His)-324(infinite)-324(wisdom)-324(and)-324(power.)-943(Unless)-323(there)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([154])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(was)-460(such)-459(a)-460(general)-459(regularity)-460(and)-459(order)-460(in)-459(the)-460(universe,)-511(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidential)-250(force)-250(of)-250(miracles)-250(would)-250(be)-250(deprived)-250(of)-250(all)-250(value.)]TJ 11.956 -13.815 Td [(It)-445(follows)-444(therefore,)-494(whichever)-445(views)-444(we)-445(may)-445(take)-445(of)-444(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(mode)-230(in)-230(which)-230(a)-230(miracle)-230(may)-230(be)-230(performed,)-234(that)-230(there)-230(is)-230(nothing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-364(the)-363(idea)-364(of)-363(it)-364(which)-364(is)-363(contrary)-364(to)-363(our)-364(reason.)-591(Whenever)-363(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-315(affirmed)-314(to)-315(be)-314(so,)-331(the)-315(assertion)-314(originates)-315(in)-314(an)-315(ambiguity)-314(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-355(use)-356(of)-355(terms,)-382(or)-356(in)-355(partial)-355(views)-356(of)-355(nature,)-382(or)-356(of)-355(the)-355(mode)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-389(the)-389(divine)-388(working,)-424(or)-388(from)-389(confounding)-389(under)-389(a)-388(common)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(name)-290(phenomena)-290(so)-289(different)-290(in)-290(character)-289(as)-290(those)-290(of)-290(mind)-289(and)]TJ
0 g 0 G
ET
q
1 0 0 1 46.771 87.722 cm
[]0 d 0 J 0.398 w 0 0 m 112.25 0 l S
Q
BT
/F16 5.9776 Tf 52.998 80.91 Td [(3)]TJ/F16 8.9664 Tf 5.729 -3.809 Td [(J.)-156(S.)-156(Mill,)-175(in)-156(his)-156(recently)-156(published)-156(essays,)-175(considers)-156(this)-156(the)-156(most)-156(formidable)]TJ -11.956 -10.959 Td [(objection)-250(against)-250(theism.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
651 0 obj <<
/Length 2742      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(138)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(matter,)-432(or)-395(by)-396(making)-395(assumptions)-395(respecting)-396(the)-395(divine)-395(oper-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ations)-353(which)-353(contradict)-353(the)-352(laws)-353(of)-353(the)-353(universe,)-379(or)-352(respecting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-318(divine)-317(character,)-335(which)-317(reason)-318(refuses)-317(to)-318(endorse.)-453(How)-317(far)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-258(known)-258(or)-259(unknown)-258(forces)-258(of)-258(nature)-259(may)-258(be)-258(employed)-258(in)-258(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(performance)-373(of)-373(a)-373(miracle)-374(is)-373(an)-373(abstract)-373(question)-373(that)-373(we)-373(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-387(means)-387(of)-387(determining.)-662(The)-387(agency)-387(of)-387(some)-387(of)-387(the)-387(known)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-303(of)-304(nature)-303(is)-303(unequivocally)-303(asserted)-304(in)-303(the)-303(Old)-303(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-248(have)-248(been)-249(the)-248(media)-248(employed)-248(in)-249(the)-248(performance)-248(of)-248(some)-248(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-245(miracles.)-248(No)-245(such)-244(affirmation)-245(is)-245(made)-244(in)-245(the)-245(New)-244(Testament.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Still)-262(there)-263(is)-262(not)-262(one)-262(word)-262(to)-263(imply)-262(that)-262(any)-262(of)-263(the)-262(forces)-262(of)-262(ma-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(terial)-248(nature)-248(were)-248(for)-248(a)-248(single)-248(moment)-248(suspended)-248(in)-248(their)-247(action.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-314(only)-314(assertion)-314(made)-314(is)-314(the)-314(presence)-314(and)-314(active)-314(energy)-314(of)-313(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(force)-240(capable)-240(of)-241(producing)-240(them.)-246(That)-241(force)-240(is)-240(the)-240(Creator)-240(of)-240(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(universe)-343(bearing)-343(witness)-343(to)-343(the)-343(divine)-343(mission)-343(of)-343(Jesus)-342(Christ.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.55 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)-282(Father)-283(himself,)-290(which)-282(hath)-283(sent)-282(me,)-290(hath)-283(borne)-282(witness)-282(of)]TJ -4.844 -13.549 Td [(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 16.059 0 Td [(\035)-312(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.093 0 Td [(The)-312(works)-313(which)-312(the)-312(Father)-312(hath)-313(given)-312(me)-312(to)-312(finish,)-328(the)]TJ -29.152 -13.549 Td [(same)-339(works)-340(that)-339(I)-340(do,)-361(bear)-340(witness)-339(of)-340(me,)-361(that)-340(the)-339(Father)-339(hath)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sent)-250(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 36.36 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050John)-250(v.)-250(36,)-250(37.\051)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -116.687 -29.204 Td [([155])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
659 0 obj <<
/Length 4048      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-233(VII.)-233(The)-234(Allegation)-233(That)-233(No)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Testimony)-253(Can)-253(Prove)-252(The)-253(Truth)-253(Of)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(A)-250(Supernatural)-250(Event.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -37.658 Td [(Hume's)-357(position,)-384(which)-357(affirmed)-357(that)-357(it)-357(is)-357(impossible)-357(to)-356(prove)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-401(truth)-400(of)-401(a)-400(supernatural)-401(event)-400(by)-401(any)-400(amount)-401(of)-400(testimony)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(however)-291(strong,)-302(is)-291(certainly)-291(one)-291(of)-292(the)-291(most)-291(plausible)-291(that)-291(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ever)-364(been)-364(assumed)-364(by)-364(unbelief.)-592(Stated)-364(briefly)-364(and)-364(in)-364(his)-363(own)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(words,)-328(it)-313(is)-313(as)-313(follows:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 105.49 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(A)-313(miracle)-312(is)-313(a)-313(violation)-312(of)-313(the)-313(laws)-313(of)]TJ -110.334 -13.549 Td [(nature;)-291(and)-277(as)-278(a)-277(firm)-277(and)-278(unalterable)-277(experience)-277(has)-277(established)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-379(laws,)-412(the)-379(proof)-379(against)-379(a)-379(miracle)-379(from)-379(the)-379(nature)-379(of)-379(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-340(is)-340(as)-339(entire)-340(as)-340(any)-339(argument)-340(from)-340(experience)-340(can)-339(possibly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-312(imagined.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 57.028 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.242 0 Td [(Again:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.765 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(No)-312(testimony)-311(is)-312(sufficient)-311(to)-312(establish)-311(a)]TJ -103.879 -13.549 Td [(miracle)-288(unless)-288(the)-289(testimony)-288(is)-288(of)-288(such)-289(a)-288(kind)-288(that)-288(its)-288(falsehood)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-301(be)-300(more)-301(miraculous)-301(than)-300(the)-301(fact)-301(which)-300(it)-301(endeavours)-300(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(establish.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 40.909 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.208 0 Td [(The)-400(fallacy)-400(of)-400(these)-400(positions,)-437(notwithstanding)-400(the)]TJ -50.117 -13.549 Td [(plausible)-382(arguments)-382(by)-383(which)-382(they)-382(are)-382(supported,)-415(has)-382(already)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-373(pointed)-374(out)-373(by)-373(a)-373(multitude)-374(of)-373(writers.)-619(Mr.)-620(Mill)-373(himself)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-242(practically)-243(abandoned)-242(Hume's)-243(argument)-242(as)-243(either)-242(a)-242(harmless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truism,)-499(or,)-499(in)-449(another)-449(point)-449(of)-449(view,)-498(one)-449(that)-449(requires)-449(to)-449(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modified)-299(to)-299(such)-300(an)-299(extent)-299(as)-299(to)-299(deprive)-300(it)-299(of)-299(any)-299(real)-299(cogency.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Under)-222(ordinary)-222(circumstances,)-227(therefore,)-228(it)-222(might)-222(be)-222(passed)-221(over)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-250(silence.)]TJ 11.956 -14.596 Td [(But)-239(the)-239(author)-238(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 76.475 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)-239(Religion)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 95.932 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.449 0 Td [(has)-239(endeavoured)-239(to)]TJ -196.656 -13.549 Td [(rehabilitate)-329(it)-330(even)-329(against)-330(Mr.)-488(Mill.)-488(He)-330(affirms)-329(that)-329(Christian)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Apologists)-184(find)-183(it)-184(much)-184(more)-184(convenient)-183(to)-184(evade)-184(the)-184(simple)-183(but)]TJ -4.844 -13.549 Td [(effective)-300(arguments)-600(of)-300(Hume,)-312(than)-300(to)-300(answer)-300(them;)-325(and)-299(where)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([156])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(it)-321(is)-322(possible,)-339(they)-321(dismiss)-321(them)-322(with)-321(a)-321(sneer,)-340(and)-321(hasten)-321(on)-321(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(less)-365(dangerous)-365(ground.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 102.795 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.825 0 Td [(He)-365(then)-365(endeavours)-365(to)-365(show)-365(that)-365(Mr.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
663 0 obj <<
/Length 4725      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(140)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Mill)-349(has)-348(been)-348(partly)-349(misapprehended,)-373(and)-349(is)-348(partly)-348(inaccurate;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-314(he)-314(proceeds)-314(to)-314(address)-314(himself)-314(to)-314(Paley's)-314(argument)-314(against)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Hume,)-197(as)-183(though)-184(it)-184(was)-183(relied)-184(on)-183(by)-184(modern)-183(apologists)-184(as)-183(entirely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conclusive.)-249(No)-248(other)-248(writer)-248(is)-248(even)-248(noticed)-248(by)-247(him.)-250(In)-248(the)-247(recent)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(work)-360(of)-359(the)-360(late)-359(Mr.)-579(Warington,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 152.253 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Can)-360(I)-359(believe)-359(in)-360(miracles?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 118.69 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(one)-204(chapter)-205(is)-204(devoted)-205(to)-204(the)-204(calm)-205(and)-204(dispassionate)-204(examination)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-326(Hume's)-327(argument.)-478(It)-327(is)-326(perhaps)-326(the)-326(ablest)-327(dissection)-326(of)-326(it)-326(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence.)-248(Yet)-243(this)-242(writer,)-245(who)-243(charges)-243(Christian)-243(apologists)-242(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evasion,)-242(and)-239(even)-240(with)-239(getting)-240(rid)-239(of)-240(its)-240(force)-239(by)-240(a)-239(sneer,)-242(has)-239(left)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Mr.)-349(Warington's)-283(crushing)-283(reply)-283(to)-283(Hume)-283(completely)-283(unnoticed.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-371(position)-371(taken)-372(by)-371(him)-371(renders)-371(a)-371(few)-371(general)-371(observations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary.)-578(As)-360(it)-359(will)-359(be)-360(useless)-359(to)-359(repeat)-360(arguments)-359(that)-359(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-477(fully)-476(elaborated)-477(elsewhere,)-533(I)-476(shall)-476(content)-477(myself)-476(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(briefly)-299(stating)-299(the)-300(positions)-299(which)-299(have)-299(been)-299(firmly)-299(established)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-250(this)-250(subject.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(First:)-398(Experience)-324(consists)-324(of)-324(two)-325(kinds;)-361(1st,)-342(That)-324(which)-324(has)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(fallen)-329(under)-329(our)-329(own)-329(direct)-329(cognizance,)-349(which)-329(from)-329(the)-329(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-441(the)-441(case)-441(must)-441(have)-441(been)-441(very)-441(limited.)-824(2dly,)-488(The)-441(general)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(experience)-421(of)-421(all)-421(other)-421(men,)-463(as)-421(far)-421(as)-421(we)-421(have)-421(the)-421(means)-420(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowing)-337(it.)-510(This)-337(latter)-337(experience)-337(we)-337(become)-337(acquainted)-336(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(exclusively)-226(by)-226(testimony,)-231(and)-226(it)-226(rests)-226(entirely)-226(on)-226(its)-225(validity.)-242(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(two)-283(together)-284(constitute)-283(what)-284(we)-283(mean)-283(when)-284(we)-283(say)-284(that)-283(a)-283(thing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is,)-250(or)-250(is)-250(not,)-250(contrary)-250(to)-250(experience.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Secondly:)-355(There)-303(is)-302(a)-303(sense)-303(in)-302(which)-303(miracles)-302(are)-303(contrary)-302(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(our)-294(experience.)-380(They)-294(would)-294(be)-293(destitute)-294(of)-293(all)-294(evidential)-293(value,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-324(they)-325(were)-324(not)-324(so.)-473(But)-325(while)-324(this)-324(is)-325(freely)-324(admitted,)-343(we)-324(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lay)-422(down)-421(clearly)-422(in)-421(what)-422(sense)-421(we)-422(use)-422(the)-421(words.)-765(They)-421(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(not)-355(so,)-382(in)-356(the)-710(sense)-356(that)-355(we)-355(have)-356(had)-355(direct)-356(evidence)-355(of)-355(their)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([157])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(non-occurrence.)-298(They)-267(are)-266(contrary)-266(to)-266(our)-266(experience)-266(only)-266(in)-266(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sense)-315(that)-315(we)-315(have)-315(never)-315(witnessed)-315(them,)-331(and)-315(that)-315(the)-315(order)-314(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-206(which)-206(we)-206(have)-206(witnessed)-206(is)-207(always)-206(different;)-220(for)-206(instance,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-325(have)-325(witnessed)-325(as)-325(a)-324(matter)-325(of)-325(experience)-325(that)-325(men)-325(die,)-343(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-259(none)-259(return)-259(again)-259(to)-260(life;)-263(or)-259(that)-259(blind)-260(men,)-261(when)-259(cured,)-261(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(never)-325(cured)-325(by)-325(a)-325(word)-325(or)-326(a)-325(touch.)-475(In)-325(this)-325(sense)-325(alone)-325(it)-325(is)-325(that)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
667 0 obj <<
/Length 4382      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(141)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(the)-264(resurrection)-265(of)-264(a)-264(dead)-264(man,)-268(and)-265(the)-264(cure)-264(of)-264(a)-265(blind)-264(man)-264(by)-264(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(touch,)-250(is)-250(contrary)-250(to)-250(our)-250(experience.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Thirdly:)-388(It)-319(is)-318(not)-319(true)-319(that)-319(an)-319(occurrence)-319(which)-319(in)-319(this)-318(sense)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-415(contrary)-414(to)-415(our)-414(experience)-415(cannot)-415(be)-414(believed)-415(on)-414(adequate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testimony.)-433(If)-311(it)-311(were)-312(so,)-326(all)-311(additions)-311(to)-311(our)-311(knowledge)-311(that)-311(lie)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beyond)-348(the)-348(limits)-349(of)-348(our)-348(past)-348(experience,)-373(ought)-348(to)-348(be)-348(rejected.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Every)-478(extraordinary)-477(occurrence)-478(must)-478(be)-477(at)-478(once)-477(pronounced)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incredible.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Fourthly:)-693(The)-472(experience)-472(of)-472(one)-471(age)-472(differs)-472(from)-472(that)-471(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(another.)-480(That)-326(which)-327(lies)-326(outside)-326(the)-327(experience)-326(of)-327(one)-326(century)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(becomes)-415(within)-415(the)-415(experience)-415(of)-414(the)-415(next.)-745(The)-415(truth)-415(is)-414(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-238(sum)-238(of)-238(human)-238(experience)-238(is)-238(receiving)-238(continual)-238(additions,)-240(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proportion)-255(as)-255(the)-254(sphere)-255(of)-255(observation)-255(enlarges.)-264(If)-255(it)-255(is)-255(true)-254(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-305(ought)-305(to)-305(reject)-304(everything)-305(contrary)-305(to)-305(experience,)-319(it)-304(follows)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-181(if)-181(many)-182(of)-181(the)-181(inventions)-181(of)-181(the)-182(present)-181(age)-181(had)-181(been)-181(reported)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-233(a)-232(previous)-233(one,)-236(they)-233(ought)-233(to)-233(have)-232(been)-233(rejected)-233(as)-232(incredible.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(For)-207(example:)-229(if)-207(a)-207(century)-208(ago)-207(it)-207(had)-207(been)-208(affirmed)-207(that)-207(a)-207(message)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-269(actually)-269(been)-270(conveyed)-269(one)-269(thousand)-269(miles)-269(in)-269(five)-269(minutes,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-412(assertion)-412(ought)-411(on)-412(this)-412(principle)-411(to)-412(have)-412(been)-412(rejected)-411(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(contrary)-362(to)-362(the)-362(universal)-362(experience)-362(of)-362(mankind.)-586(In)-362(an)-361(earlier)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(age,)-347(no)-328(miracle)-328(could)-327(have)-328(been)-328(more)-328(difficult)-327(to)-328(believe.)-483(Yet)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(although)-281(contrary)-281(to)-281(prior)-280(experience,)-289(it)-281(has)-281(been)-281(established)-280(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-264(fact.)-582(The)-264(principle,)-267(therefore,)-267(as)-264(laid)-264(down)-264(by)-264(Hume,)-267(leads)-263(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([158])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(an)-250(absurd)-250(conclusion.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Fifthly:)-470(The)-361(experience)-360(of)-360(each)-360(individual)-361(is)-360(limited)-360(by)-360(his)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(own)-476(observation)-476(and)-477(what)-476(he)-476(has)-476(learned)-476(respecting)-476(that)-476(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(others.)-356(This)-286(constitutes)-285(as)-286(far)-285(as)-286(he)-285(is)-286(concerned)-285(the)-285(experience)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-332(mankind.)-497(Now,)-353(under)-332(the)-332(Equator)-333(the)-332(experience)-332(of)-332(man)-332(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-370(each)-370(day)-370(and)-370(night)-370(is)-370(twelve)-370(hours)-370(long.)-610(Neither)-370(he,)-399(nor)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-253(ancestors,)-254(nor)-253(any)-253(person)-253(whom)-253(he)-253(trusts,)-254(have)-253(ever)-253(had)-253(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-386(experience)-385(than)-386(this.)-657(To)-386(him,)-419(therefore,)-420(the)-385(affirmation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-266(there)-267(is)-266(a)-267(place)-266(on)-267(the)-266(earth)-267(where)-266(each)-267(day)-266(and)-267(night)-266(is)-266(six)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(months)-277(long,)-284(is)-277(contrary)-277(to)-277(experience,)-284(and)-277(ought)-277(to)-277(be)-277(rejected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-250(a)-250(fable.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
672 0 obj <<
/Length 4622      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(142)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(Sixthly:)-250(If)-249(we)-250(confine)-249(experience)-250(to)-249(scientific)-250(experience,)-249(ex-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(traordinary)-223(discoveries)-224(are)-223(made)-223(and)-223(facts)-224(established)-223(in)-223(one)-223(age)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-254(are)-255(contrary)-254(to)-255(that)-254(of)-255(a)-254(former)-255(one.)-263(On)-254(this)-255(principle,)-255(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ground)-291(on)-291(which)-291(Herodotus)-290(rejected)-291(the)-291(story)-291(of)-291(the)-290(Ph)]TJ/F43 10.9091 Tf 246.092 0 Td [(S)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.876 0 Td [(nician)]TJ -253.968 -13.55 Td [(navigators)-286(that)-286(they)-286(had)-286(sailed)-286(round)-286(Africa)-286(was)-286(satisfactory.)-358(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-379(contrary)-378(to)-379(his)-378(experience)-379(that)-378(they)-379(should)-378(have)-379(seen)-378(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sun)-290(in)-289(the)-290(position)-290(in)-290(which)-289(they)-290(affirmed)-290(that)-289(they)-290(had)-290(seen)-289(it,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(though)-250(it)-250(is)-250(not)-250(contrary)-250(to)-250(ours.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Seventhly:)-665(Miracles)-458(viewed)-457(as)-458(mere)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 174.462 0 Td [(phenomena)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 55.282 0 Td [(stand)-458(on)]TJ -241.7 -13.549 Td [(exactly)-371(the)-371(same)-371(ground)-372(as)-371(very)-371(unusual)-371(occurrences,)-401(or)-371(very)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(wonderful)-286(discoveries.)-356(As)-286(far)-285(as)-286(they)-285(are)-286(contrary)-285(to)-286(past)-285(expe-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rience,)-319(they)-305(are)-306(alike)-305(credible)-305(or)-306(incredible.)-416(They)-305(are)-305(events)-305(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-349(the)-350(cause)-349(is)-350(unknown,)-374(but)-349(may)-350(or)-349(may)-350(not)-349(hereafter)-349(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discovered.)-494(It)-331(is)-331(quite)-331(true)-332(that)-331(any)-331(extraordinary)-331(phenomenon)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(requires)-390(a)-389(stronger)-390(testimony)-390(to)-389(render)-390(it)-390(credible)-389(than)-390(an)-389(or-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(dinary)-442(occurrence.)-827(But)-442(this)-442(involves)-443(no)-442(question)-442(of)-442(abstract)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possibility)-312(or)-311(impossibility,)-328(but)-311(is)-312(one)-312(purely)-312(of)-311(evidence,)-327(each)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(case)-248(having)-248(to)-248(be)-248(decided)-249(on)-248(its)-248(own)-248(merits.)-249(It)-248(must)-248(be)-248(carefully)]TJ 2.733 -13.549 Td [(observed)-250(that)-251(when)-250(we)-251(affirm)-250(that)-251(this)-250(or)-251(that)-250(matter)-250(lies)-251(within)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -75.488 0 Td [([159])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(human)-248(knowledge,)-248(or)-248(is)-248(contrary)-248(to)-248(it,)-249(experience)-248(has)-248(to)-247(do)-248(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(phenomena)-253(alone.)-260(All)-254(questions)-253(of)-253(causation)-254(lie)-253(entirely)-253(beyond)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-250(cognizance.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Eighthly:)-482(The)-366(moment)-366(we)-366(view)-366(an)-366(event)-366(otherwise)-366(than)-365(as)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(a)-490(mere)-490(phenomenon,)-550(and)-490(take)-490(into)-490(consideration)-490(the)-489(causes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(producing)-441(it,)-488(however)-441(unusual)-441(it)-440(may)-441(be,)-488(it)-441(is)-441(impossible)-440(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-420(that)-419(it)-420(is)-420(contrary)-420(to)-419(experience.)-759(When)-420(we)-420(take)-419(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-412(consideration)-412(the)-412(entire)-412(character)-412(of)-412(the)-412(event)-412(is)-412(at)-411(once)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(changed,)-289(and)-280(the)-281(probability)-281(of)-281(the)-281(occurrence)-281(must)-281(be)-280(estimat-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ed)-337(on)-338(wholly)-337(different)-338(grounds.)-512(Under)-338(such)-337(circumstances,)-359(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(extremely)-381(improbable)-381(event,)-414(which)-381(we)-381(might)-381(otherwise)-380(justly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reject)-335(as)-335(contrary)-335(to)-335(experience,)-356(becomes)-335(simply)-335(one)-335(of)-335(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-373(have)-374(had)-373(no)-374(experience.)-620(Thus)-374(it)-373(is)-374(contrary)-373(to)-373(experience)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-344(men)-343(can)-344(live)-344(for)-343(one)-344(hour)-344(under)-343(water,)-367(but)-344(when)-344(we)-343(take)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-263(consideration)-263(and)-262(thoroughly)-263(understand)-263(the)-263(contrivance)-262(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
677 0 obj <<
/Length 4634      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(143)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(the)-275(diving-bell,)-282(the)-275(event)-275(becomes)-275(one)-276(of)-275(a)-275(different)-275(order)-275(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-309(of)-308(which)-309(we)-308(supposed)-309(that)-308(we)-309(had)-308(experience.)-426(Before)-308(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apparatus)-437(was)-437(invented,)-483(the)-437(assertion)-437(that)-437(men)-437(could)-437(live)-436(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hour)-397(under)-398(water)-397(would)-397(have)-398(been)-397(rejected)-397(as)-398(fabulous.)-691(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(invention)-392(has)-392(introduced)-392(a)-392(fresh)-392(condition)-392(into)-392(the)-392(case.)-675(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(event)-399(has)-399(now)-399(become)-399(a)-399(portion)-398(of)-399(our)-399(experience;)-474(but)-398(prior)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-354(the)-354(discovery)-354(of)-355(the)-354(apparatus)-354(it)-354(was)-354(merely)-354(an)-354(event)-354(lying)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(outside)-292(our)-291(experience,)-302(and)-291(not)-292(to)-291(be)-292(rejected)-291(as)-292(being)-291(contrary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-322(it.)-466(In)-322(a)-322(similar)-322(way,)-340(a)-322(miracle,)-340(as)-322(a)-322(mere)-322(phenomenon,)-340(may)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-246(said)-246(to)-246(be)-245(contrary)-246(to)-246(our)-246(experience;)-247(but)-246(the)-246(moment)-246(that)-245(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(take)-282(into)-283(account)-282(its)-282(true)-283(character,)-290(viz.)-347(that)-283(its)-282(very)-282(conception)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(implies)-223(the)-223(presence)-223(of)-223(a)-223(force)-223(of)-223(some)-223(kind)-223(with)-223(which)-223(we)-222(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(previously)-395(unacquainted,)-431(then)-395(such)-394(an)-395(event)-395(is)-395(no)-395(longer)-394(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-269(we)-269(can)-269(pronounce)-269(contrary)-269(to)-269(our)-270(experience,)-273(but)-269(merely)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(one)-374(which)-373(lies)-373(beyond)-374(or)-373(outside)-747(it.)-621(In)-373(the)-374(case)-373(of)-373(miracles,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([160])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(therefore,)-250(the)-250(position)-250(of)-250(Hume)-250(is)-250(inapplicable.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Ninthly:)-243(It)-235(is)-236(not)-236(true)-235(that)-236(in)-236(estimating)-235(the)-236(truth)-236(of)-235(testimony,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(we)-336(simply)-335(balance)-335(probability,)-357(against)-336(probability,)-357(as)-335(stated)-335(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Hume's)-373(argument.)-620(The)-373(form)-374(in)-373(which)-373(it)-373(has)-374(been)-373(put)-373(by)-373(him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-372(too)-372(abstract)-372(to)-372(admit)-372(of)-372(application)-372(to)-372(individual)-372(cases;)-433(nor)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(does)-302(any)-302(man,)-315(in)-302(estimating)-302(the)-302(truth)-302(of)-302(testimony)-302(for)-301(practical)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(purposes,)-225(set)-218(down)-218(and)-219(deliberately)-218(balance)-218(probabilities)-218(against)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(probabilities.)-434(The)-311(whole)-311(process)-311(is)-312(of)-311(a)-311(far)-311(more)-311(instantaneous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character,)-327(and)-312(a)-311(number)-312(of)-312(minute)-311(considerations)-312(are)-311(involved,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-273(do)-273(not)-274(admit)-273(of)-273(statement)-273(in)-274(the)-273(form)-273(of)-273(general)-273(proposi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tions.)-483(Thus,)-346(if)-328(an)-327(event)-328(lying)-327(outside)-328(my)-327(present)-328(experience)-327(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reported)-209(to)-209(me)-209(by)-209(a)-209(friend)-209(on)-209(whose)-209(veracity)-209(and)-209(powers)-209(of)-209(judg-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ment)-263(I)-263(have)-263(implicit)-263(reliance,)-266(I)-263(accept)-263(the)-263(truth)-263(of)-263(his)-262(statement,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(notwithstanding)-214(a)-215(great)-214(degree)-215(of)-214(abstract)-215(improbability;)-226(it)-214(being)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assumed)-293(that)-294(the)-293(event)-293(was)-294(one)-293(in)-293(which)-294(it)-293(was)-293(impossible)-293(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-305(should)-305(be)-305(deceived.)-414(In)-305(estimating)-305(this)-305(latter)-305(point,)-319(we)-304(never)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(balance)-345(the)-345(probabilities)-345(as)-345(to)-345(the)-345(truth)-345(or)-345(falsehood)-345(of)-345(human)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(testimony,)-356(but)-335(we)-335(consider)-334(the)-335(individual)-335(circumstances)-335(of)-334(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(case,)-311(whether)-298(they)-298(are)-299(of)-298(such)-299(a)-298(nature)-299(that)-298(our)-299(friend)-298(could)-298(be)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
681 0 obj <<
/Length 4645      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(144)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(deceived)-286(about)-286(them.)-359(If)-286(on)-286(consideration)-286(we)-286(are)-286(convinced)-286(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(deception)-216(was)-216(impossible,)-222(we)-216(yield)-216(assent)-216(to)-216(his)-216(known)-215(veracity,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(although,)-231(as)-227(far)-227(as)-227(we)-226(know,)-232(the)-227(event)-226(reported)-227(by)-227(him)-227(has)-226(never)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(before)-250(come)-250(within)-250(the)-250(range)-250(of)-250(human)-250(experience.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Let)-308(me)-308(remove)-308(the)-307(question)-308(from)-308(an)-308(abstract)-308(into)-308(a)-307(concrete)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(form.)-273(There)-257(are)-258(numberless)-257(events)-258(in)-257(which)-258(it)-257(happens)-258(that)-257(men)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-393(unquestionable)-393(judgment)-393(and)-393(veracity)-393(are)-393(deceived.)-678(There)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-341(others)-341(in)-341(which)-341(no)-340(deception)-341(can)-341(be)-341(possible.)-523(An)-340(instance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-299(one)-298(class)-299(is)-299(the)-298(alleged)-299(case)-299(of)-298(persons)-299(living)-299(a)-298(considerable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(time)-459(without)-230(food.)-243(Here)-230(astuteness)-230(may)-229(impose)-230(on)-230(the)-229(vigilance)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([161])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(of)-351(the)-351(most)-351(wary.)-552(Take,)-376(on)-351(the)-351(other)-351(hand,)-376(the)-351(case)-351(of)-351(a)-350(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(born)-214(blind.)-238(One)-215(informant,)-221(on)-214(whose)-214(veracity)-215(we)-214(have)-214(the)-214(fullest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reliance,)-278(tells)-272(us)-272(that)-272(he)-272(has)-272(known)-273(the)-272(man)-272(from)-272(his)-272(birth;)-283(that,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(up)-416(to)-416(a)-415(certain)-416(day,)-457(his)-416(blindness)-416(was)-416(established)-416(beyond)-415(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reasonable)-302(doubt)-303(to)-302(every)-303(one)-302(who)-302(knew)-303(him,)-315(that)-303(on)-302(that)-302(day,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(he)-309(saw)-309(a)-309(person)-310(touch)-309(the)-309(eyes)-309(of)-309(the)-309(blind)-309(man,)-324(who)-309(not)-309(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instantly)-335(received)-334(his)-335(sight,)-355(but)-335(could)-334(use)-335(his)-334(eyes)-335(as)-334(perfectly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-348(those)-347(who)-348(had)-347(enjoyed)-348(the)-348(use)-347(of)-348(them)-348(from)-347(birth.)-543(I)-347(admit)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-310(this)-310(case)-310(is)-309(a)-310(supposed)-310(one,)-325(and)-310(does)-310(not)-310(exactly)-309(represent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-315(case)-316(recorded)-315(in)-316(the)-315(Gospels.)-446(But)-315(though)-316(an)-315(assumed)-315(one,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-259(is)-259(perfectly)-259(valid)-259(for)-259(the)-259(purposes)-259(of)-259(argument.)-277(In)-259(it)-259(deception)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-224(be)-223(impossible.)-242(If)-223(all)-224(this)-224(was)-224(affirmed)-223(to)-224(have)-224(come)-223(under)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-231(direct)-231(knowledge)-231(of)-231(one,)-235(of)-231(whose)-231(veracity)-231(and)-231(judgment)-230(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-377(assured,)-408(we)-376(should)-377(accept)-376(his)-376(statement)-377(as)-376(true,)-408(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(balancing)-217(the)-217(abstract)-217(probability)-216(of)-217(the)-217(truth)-217(of)-217(evidence)-216(against)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-259(probability)-258(of)-259(its)-259(falsity,)-260(although)-259(the)-259(event)-258(narrated)-259(lay)-258(out-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(side)-212(the)-212(range)-213(of)-212(our)-212(experience.)-238(Our)-212(knowledge)-212(of)-212(the)-212(judgment)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-273(veracity)-273(of)-272(the)-273(informant)-273(is)-272(the)-273(essential)-273(element)-273(in)-272(judging)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-320(the)-320(truth)-320(of)-320(evidence.)-459(It)-320(is)-320(only)-320(when)-320(our)-320(means)-320(of)-319(forming)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-353(judgment)-352(are)-353(deficient)-352(that)-353(we)-353(attempt)-352(to)-353(balance)-352(abstract)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(probabilities.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Tenthly:)-581(The)-416(question)-416(of)-416(the)-415(truth)-416(of)-416(testimony)-416(as)-415(against)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(past)-202(experience)-203(and)-202(the)-202(alleged)-203(greater)-202(probability)-202(that)-202(testimony)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-326(be)-326(false,)-344(than)-326(that)-326(past)-326(experience)-326(should)-326(be)-325(unreliable,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
685 0 obj <<
/Length 4599      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(145)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(is)-355(greatly)-355(modified)-354(by)-355(the)-355(consideration)-355(that)-355(an)-354(overwhelming)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(amount)-354(of)-354(the)-355(sum)-354(total)-354(of)-354(past)-355(experience)-354(rests)-354(for)-354(its)-354(accep-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tance)-422(on)-422(the)-422(validity)-422(of)-422(testimony)-422(itself.)-766(That)-422(portion)-422(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-374(not)-374(the)-375(result)-374(of)-374(our)-374(own)-375(individual)-374(experience)-374(rests)-374(for)-374(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(truth)-285(exclusively)-284(on)-285(the)-284(validity)-285(of)-285(human)-284(testimony,)-587(and)-284(must)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([162])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(be)-359(unreliable)-359(in)-359(proportion)-359(as)-359(testimony)-359(is)-359(invalid.)-577(It)-359(must)-359(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(observed,)-396(however,)-396(that)-367(I)-367(by)-367(no)-367(means)-367(deny)-367(that)-367(testimony)-366(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(much)-327(more)-327(frequently)-328(invalid)-327(in)-327(its)-327(narrations)-327(of)-327(extraordinary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-250(than)-250(of)-250(ordinary)-250(ones.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Eleventhly:)-438(While)-344(it)-343(is)-344(freely)-344(conceded)-344(that)-344(the)-344(evidence)-343(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(prove)-351(the)-351(truth)-351(of)-351(a)-351(very)-351(extraordinary)-351(occurrence)-351(must)-351(be)-351(far)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stronger)-285(than)-285(that)-285(which)-286(is)-285(required)-285(to)-285(prove)-285(an)-285(ordinary)-286(one,)-293(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-328(never)-328(be)-328(forgotten)-328(that)-328(the)-328(amount)-328(of)-328(evidence)-328(necessary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-390(prove)-389(any)-390(particular)-390(fact)-389(always)-390(varies)-390(with)-389(the)-390(amount)-389(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-454(antecedent)-453(probability)-454(of)-454(its)-453(occurrence.)-861(The)-454(very)-453(same)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(action)-394(may)-395(be)-394(credible)-394(or)-394(otherwise,)-431(just)-394(in)-394(proportion)-394(as)-394(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-243(discern)-242(an)-243(adequate)-242(purpose)-243(for)-243(its)-242(performance,)-244(or)-243(infer)-242(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presence)-253(of)-253(a)-253(particular)-253(motive.)-260(If,)-253(for)-253(example,)-254(it)-253(were)-253(reported)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-410(a)-410(man)-410(of)-409(the)-410(highest)-410(character)-410(had)-410(been)-410(seen)-410(during)-409(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hours)-378(of)-379(early)-378(morning)-378(issuing)-378(from)-379(one)-378(of)-378(the)-378(lowest)-378(haunts)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-320(vice)-319(in)-320(London,)-337(those)-320(who)-319(knew)-320(him)-320(well)-319(would)-320(require)-319(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(overwhelming)-346(amount)-347(of)-346(evidence)-346(to)-346(establish)-347(the)-346(truth)-346(of)-346(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assertion.)-373(They)-290(would)-291(undoubtedly)-291(fall)-291(back)-291(on)-291(the)-291(question)-290(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(abstract)-251(probability,)-250(and)-251(argue)-250(that)-251(it)-250(was)-251(more)-250(likely)-250(that)-251(it)-250(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(either)-355(a)-354(case)-354(of)-355(mistaken)-354(identity)-355(\050a)-354(very)-355(common)-354(error\051,)-381(or)-354(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(deliberate)-251(falsehood,)-250(than)-251(that)-250(the)-251(statement)-250(should)-251(be)-250(true.)-251(But,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(if,)-336(on)-318(the)-318(contrary,)-336(it)-318(could)-319(be)-318(shown)-318(that)-319(he)-318(had)-319(been)-318(sent)-318(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-352(visit)-351(a)-352(dying)-352(person,)-377(and)-352(had)-352(gone)-351(at)-352(his)-352(particular)-351(request,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-251(whole)-250(of)-251(the)-250(antecedent)-251(improbability)-251(would)-250(vanish,)-251(and)-250(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(otherwise)-210(incredible)-209(testimony)-210(would)-209(become)-210(perfectly)-209(credible.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-247(follows,)-248(therefore,)-248(that)-248(the)-247(credibility)-247(of)-248(testimony)-247(varies)-247(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(our)-250(knowledge)-250(of)-250(the)-250(motive)-250(for)-250(the)-250(performance)-250(of)-250(the)-250(action.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(This)-187(consideration)-188(ought)-187(to)-188(have)-187(due)-187(weight)-188(in)-187(considering)-187(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-214(of)-213(miracles.)-238(Viewed)-214(as)-214(mere)-427(phenomena,)-221(their)-213(abstract)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([163])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
690 0 obj <<
/Length 4854      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(146)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(improbability)-251(is)-250(great.)-252(When)-251(they)-250(are)-251(viewed)-250(as)-251(deviations)-250(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-328(ordinary)-328(course)-328(of)-328(nature,)-348(their)-328(improbability)-328(becomes)-328(still)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(greater.)-240(But)-218(those)-219(who)-218(believe)-219(i)1(n)-219(the)-218(existence)-219(of)-218(a)-219(personal)-218(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(energizing)-283(in)-284(the)-283(universe)-283(at)-284(every)-283(moment,)-292(and)-283(in)-283(every)-283(place,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(postulate)-215(the)-215(presence)-215(of)-214(a)-215(force)-215(fully)-215(adequate)-215(to)-215(work)-215(them,)-221(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-270(is)-269(involved)-270(in)-270(the)-269(idea)-270(of)-270(God.)-309(But)-270(the)-269(question)-270(arises,)-274(Will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He?)-461(Until)-320(a)-321(well-attested)-320(miracle)-320(has)-321(actually)-320(been)-320(performed,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-397(antecedent)-397(probability)-397(derived)-397(from)-397(our)-397(experience)-397(of)-396(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-209(of)-210(nature)-209(is)-209(against)-210(the)-209(supposition)-209(that)-209(He)-210(will,)-217(and)-209(throws)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-299(the)-298(reporter)-299(the)-299(necessity)-298(of)-299(giving)-299(a)-298(stronger)-299(proof)-299(than)-298(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(require)-323(for)-324(an)-323(ordinary)-323(fact.)-470(But)-323(in)-323(proportion)-324(as)-323(we)-323(can)-323(show)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-215(it)-214(is)-215(probable)-214(that)-215(God)-214(will)-215(make)-215(a)-214(revelation,)-222(the)-214(antecedent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(improbability)-277(of)-277(a)-277(miracle)-277(is)-277(diminished;)-290(and)-277(if)-277(it)-277(can)-277(be)-276(shown)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-250(it)-250(is)-250(very)-250(probable)-250(that)-250(He)-250(will)-250(do)-250(so,)-250(it)-250(wholly)-250(disappears.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-402(will)-402(be)-402(readily)-402(admitted)-402(that)-402(such)-402(an)-402(argument)-402(can)-402(only)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(have)-238(weight)-237(with)-238(a)-237(believer)-238(in)-237(the)-238(existence)-237(of)-238(a)-237(God,)-240(who)-238(is)-237(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(moral)-325(Governor)-324(of)-325(the)-324(Universe.)-474(To)-324(him,)-344(however,)-343(it)-324(is)-325(of)-324(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(utmost)-282(value,)-291(for)-282(on)-283(the)-282(supposition)-282(in)-283(question,)-290(the)-282(probability)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-371(some)-371(higher)-372(manifestation)-371(of)-371(the)-371(divine)-371(character)-371(than)-371(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(displayed)-235(in)-235(the)-235(material)-235(universe)-235(does)-235(not)-235(rest)-235(on)-235(theory,)-238(but)-235(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-238(facts)-238(of)-238(man)-239(and)-238(his)-238(condition.)-246(Looking)-238(at)-238(the)-238(past)-238(history)-238(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-194(world,)-205(it)-194(is)-195(matter)-194(of)-194(fact)-194(that)-194(God)-194(has)-194(made)-194(higher)-194(and)-194(higher)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(manifestations)-261(of)-260(himself.)-282(So)-261(far)-260(it)-261(is)-260(antecedently)-261(probable)-260(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-264(will)-264(continue)-265(to)-264(do)-264(so.)-292(His)-265(last)-264(manifestation)-264(has)-264(been)-264(in)-264(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(production)-291(of)-292(a)-291(being)-291(possessed)-292(of)-291(a)-291(moral)-292(nature,)-301(with)-291(powers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(capable)-218(of)-217(immense)-218(elevation.)-239(It)-218(is)-217(also)-218(no)-217(theory,)-224(but)-218(a)-217(fact,)-224(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-290(moral)-290(being)-290(now)-290(is,)-300(and)-290(ever)-290(has)-290(been)-290(within)-290(the)-289(historical)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(periods)-383(in)-382(a)-383(state)-382(of)-383(great)-382(imperfection.)-648(It)-382(is)-383(therefore)-382(highly)]TJ 4.492 -13.549 Td [(probable)-412(that)-411(the)-412(Creator)-412(will)-412(adopt)-411(means)-412(for)-412(elevating)-412(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -77.247 0 Td [([164])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(moral)-330(being)-329(whom)-330(He)-330(has)-329(created,)-350(and)-330(that)-329(He)-330(will)-330(effect)-329(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-275(acting,)-281(not)-274(on)-275(matter,)-281(but)-274(on)-275(mind.)-324(Contemplating)-275(the)-274(actual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(state)-226(of)-226(man,)-230(the)-226(known)-226(law)-226(of)-225(the)-226(Creator's)-226(previous)-226(action,)-230(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-287(moral)-287(character)-287(of)-287(God,)-296(the)-287(antecedent)-287(probability)-287(that)-286(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will)-272(make)-272(a)-273(further)-272(manifestation)-272(of)-272(himself)-272(is)-272(established)-272(quite)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
694 0 obj <<
/Length 4938      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(147)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(independently)-250(of)-250(the)-250(facts)-250(or)-250(assertions)-250(in)-250(the)-250(Bible.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Twelfthly:)-590(Whatever)-420(be)-420(the)-420(supposed)-420(antecedent)-419(improba-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(bility)-359(of)-360(an)-359(occurrence,)-387(it)-359(is)-360(capable)-359(of)-359(being)-360(overcome)-359(by)-359(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(amount)-452(of)-451(evidence)-452(which)-451(can)-451(leave)-452(no)-451(reasonable)-452(doubt)-451(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-417(mind)-418(endowed)-417(with)-417(common)-417(sense.)-752(Theoretical)-417(objections)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(may)-323(be)-323(adduced)-323(against)-323(any)-323(evidence)-323(which)-323(can)-323(be)-323(brought)-323(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proof)-388(of)-388(particular)-388(facts,)-423(but)-388(the)-388(ultimate)-389(appeal)-388(must)-388(be,)-422(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-320(a)-319(multitude)-320(of)-319(abstract)-320(theories,)-337(but)-319(to)-320(the)-319(common)-320(sense)-319(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mankind.)-394(Of)-298(this)-299(character)-298(is)-298(all)-298(historical)-298(evidence.)-394(It)-298(rests)-298(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-218(same)-218(principles)-218(as)-219(those)-218(which)-218(guide)-218(us)-218(in)-218(the)-218(affairs)-218(of)-218(daily)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(life.)-238(There)-213(is)-213(a)-213(certain)-213(amount)-214(of)-213(evidence)-213(which)-213(leaves)-213(no)-213(doubt)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-344(the)-344(common)-345(sense)-344(of)-344(mankind,)-368(although)-344(it)-344(may)-344(be)-344(open)-344(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(many)-209(theoretical)-210(objections.)-236(Such)-209(evidence)-210(is)-209(capable)-209(of)-209(proving)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-387(fact)-386(against)-387(a)-387(very)-387(high)-386(degree)-387(of)-387(antecedent)-386(improbability.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Mr.)-600(Mill)-367(may)-366(be)-367(considered)-367(as)-366(a)-367(witness)-367(whose)-366(predilections)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(were)-375(all)-374(in)-375(favour)-374(of)-375(unbelief.)-623(Yet)-374(his)-375(clear)-374(logical)-375(mind)-374(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(led)-308(him)-308(to)-308(state)-308(the)-309(case)-308(fairly)-308(as)-308(far)-308(as)-308(the)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 195.112 0 Td [(\340)-308(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 37.638 0 Td [(probability)]TJ -232.75 -13.549 Td [(or)-337(improbability)-337(of)-336(miracles)-337(is)-337(concerned.)-510(His)-337(conclusions)-336(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adverse)-316(to)-315(the)-316(position)-315(assumed)-316(by)-315(the)-315(author)-316(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 220.041 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)]TJ -224.885 -13.549 Td [(Religion.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 40.309 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.521 0 Td [(I)-337(will)-337(briefly)-337(state)-337(the)-337(most)-337(important)-337(of)-337(Mr.)-511(Mill's)]TJ -48.83 -13.55 Td [(positions.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(First.)-249(He)-245(points)-246(out)-245(that)-246(a)-246(miracle)-245(involves)-246(nothing)-245(contradic-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tory)-257(t)1(o)-257(any)-256(law)-257(of)-256(causation.)-270(He)-256(well)-257(remarks)-256(that)-257(to)-256(prove)-256(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-359(contradiction,)-387(it)-359(is)-359(not)-359(only)-718(necessary)-359(that)-359(the)-359(cause)-359(should)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([165])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(exist)-194(without)-194(producing)-194(the)-194(effect,)-205(but)-194(that)-194(no)-194(contravening)-193(cause)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-350(be)-350(present.)-551(But)-350(the)-350(very)-350(idea)-350(of)-350(a)-350(miracle)-350(presupposes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-332(adequate)-333(contravening)-332(cause,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 147.707 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 18.751 0 Td [(God.)-497(The)-332(possibility)-333(of)-332(a)]TJ -166.458 -13.55 Td [(miracle)-238(therefore)-238(cannot)-238(be)-238(denied)-238(on)-238(the)-238(ground)-238(that)-238(it)-238(does)-238(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presuppose)-320(the)-321(presence)-320(of)-320(a)-320(force)-321(adequate)-320(to)-320(produce)-321(it.)-460(Mr.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Mill)-279(states,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 51.934 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Of)-279(the)-279(adequacy)-279(of)-280(that)-279(cause,)-286(if)-279(present,)-287(there)-279(can)]TJ -56.778 -13.549 Td [(be)-324(no)-323(doubt,)-343(and)-323(the)-324(only)-324(antecedent)-323(improbability)-324(that)-324(can)-323(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(objected)-351(to)-351(a)-351(miracle,)-376(is)-350(the)-351(improbability)-351(that)-351(any)-351(such)-350(cause)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(existed,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.633 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.515 0 Td [(that)-245(is)-245(to)-244(say,)-246(the)-245(whole)-245(controversy)-245(resolves)-245(itself)-245(into)]TJ -41.148 -13.549 Td [(the)-325(question)-324(between)-325(Pantheism)-324(and)-325(Atheism)-325(on)-324(the)-325(one)-324(hand,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
699 0 obj <<
/Length 4995      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(148)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(and)-250(Theism)-250(on)-250(the)-250(other.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Secondly.)-506(He)-336(observes:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 111.026 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(All)-335(therefore)-336(that)-335(Hume)-336(has)-335(made)]TJ -127.826 -13.549 Td [(out,)-384(and)-357(this)-357(he)-357(must)-357(be)-357(considered)-357(to)-358(have)-357(made)-357(out,)-384(is,)-383(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(\050at)-253(least)-254(in)-253(the)-253(imperfect)-254(state)-253(of)-253(our)-254(knowledge)-253(of)-253(natural)-253(agen-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cies,)-356(which)-334(leaves)-335(it)-334(always)-335(possible)-334(that)-335(some)-334(of)-335(the)-334(physical)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(antecedents)-415(may)-414(have)-415(been)-414(hidden)-415(from)-415(us\051)-414(no)-415(evidence)-414(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prove)-379(a)-380(miracle)-379(to)-379(any)-380(one)-379(who)-379(did)-380(not)-379(previously)-379(believe)-379(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-351(existence)-351(of)-351(a)-351(being)-351(or)-351(beings)-351(with)-351(supernatural)-351(power,)-376(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-279(believes)-278(himself)-279(to)-278(have)-278(full)-279(proof)-278(that)-279(the)-278(character)-279(of)-278(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-328(whom)-327(he)-328(recognises)-327(is)-328(inconsistent)-328(with)-327(his)-328(having)-327(seen)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fit)-284(to)-285(interfere)-284(on)-284(the)-284(occasion)-284(in)-285(question.)-352(If)-285(we)-284(do)-284(not)-284(already)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believe)-225(in)-226(supernatural)-225(agencies,)-230(no)-226(miracle)-225(can)-225(prove)-226(to)-225(us)-225(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence.)-236(The)-209(miracle)-208(itself,)-217(considered)-209(as)-208(an)-209(extraordinary)-208(fact,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-207(be)-206(satisfactorily)-207(certified)-206(by)-207(our)-206(senses,)-215(or)-207(by)-206(testimony;)-221(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nothing)-302(can)-301(ever)-302(prove)-302(that)-302(it)-301(is)-302(a)-302(miracle:)-353(there)-302(is)-302(still)-301(another)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(possible)-230(hypothesis,)-235(that)-230(of)-231(its)-230(being)-231(the)-230(result)-231(of)-230(some)-230(unknown)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cause;)-229(and)-218(this)-219(possibility)-218(cannot)-219(be)-218(so)-218(completely)-219(shut)-218(out,)-225(as)-218(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(leave)-228(no)-228(alternative)-228(but)-227(that)-228(of)-228(admitting)-228(the)-228(existence)-228(of)-228(a)-227(being)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(superior)-234(to)-234(nature.)-490(Those,)-237(however,)-238(who)-234(already)-234(believe)-234(in)-234(such)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([166])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(a)-264(being)-265(have)-264(two)-264(hypotheses)-264(to)-265(choose)-264(from,)-268(a)-264(supernatural)-264(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(an)-238(unknown)-237(natural)-238(agency;)-242(and)-237(they)-238(have)-238(to)-237(judge)-238(which)-238(of)-237(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(two)-250(is)-250(the)-250(most)-250(probable)-250(in)-250(this)-250(particular)-250(case.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 205.734 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -193.778 -16.004 Td [(It)-298(is)-298(impossible)-298(to)-297(deny)-298(that)-298(this)-298(is)-298(a)-298(correct)-298(statement)-298(of)-297(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(question.)-703(Hume's)-401(position)-400(is)-401(a)-401(generalized)-401(statement,)-439(that)-400(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-220(can)-220(establish)-220(the)-219(reality)-220(of)-220(a)-220(miracle,)-226(on)-220(the)-220(ground)-219(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-297(experience)-298(of)-297(the)-298(uniformity)-297(of)-297(nature's)-298(laws)-297(is)-298(so)-297(firm)-297(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unalterable,)-329(that)-312(no)-313(amount)-313(of)-313(testimony)-313(can)-313(establish)-313(a)-313(fact)-312(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(opposition)-245(to)-245(it;)-247(or)-245(as)-245(he)-245(elsewhere)-245(puts)-245(it,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 186.802 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(unless)-245(the)-245(testimony)]TJ -191.645 -13.549 Td [(be)-305(of)-305(such)-304(a)-305(kind,)-319(that)-304(its)-305(falsehood)-305(would)-305(be)-305(more)-304(miraculous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-326(the)-325(fact)-326(which)-326(it)-325(endeavours)-326(to)-326(establish.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 205.14 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.396 0 Td [(He)-326(affirms)-325(this)]TJ -213.536 -13.549 Td [(to)-356(be)-356(equally)-357(true)-356(on)-356(the)-356(principles)-357(of)-356(Atheism,)-383(Pantheism,)-382(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Theism,)-361(for)-339(the)-339(only)-338(thing)-339(that)-339(he)-339(takes)-338(into)-339(account)-339(is)-339(the)-338(in-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(adequacy)-267(of)-267(the)-267(testimony,)-271(and)-267(not)-267(the)-267(inadequacy)-267(of)-267(the)-267(cause.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Mr.)-843(Mill)-447(therefore)-447(says)-448(correctly)-447(that)-448(all)-447(that)-448(this)-447(argument)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
562 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 884
/Length 8895      
>>
stream
556 0 564 65 566 180 563 236 568 313 570 428 567 484 572 561 574 676 571 733
576 810 578 925 575 982 580 1047 582 1162 579 1219 584 1284 586 1399 583 1455 589 1532
591 1647 592 1704 588 1760 594 1837 596 1952 593 2009 598 2086 600 2201 597 2257 602 2334
604 2449 601 2506 606 2583 608 2698 605 2755 610 2820 612 2935 613 2992 609 3048 616 3125
618 3240 615 3296 620 3373 622 3488 619 3545 624 3622 626 3737 623 3794 628 3871 630 3986
627 4042 632 4119 634 4234 631 4291 636 4368 638 4483 635 4540 641 4605 643 4720 644 4777
640 4834 646 4899 648 5014 645 5071 650 5136 652 5251 649 5307 653 5384 656 5423 658 5528
654 5643 660 5699 657 5754 662 5831 664 5946 661 6003 666 6080 668 6195 665 6249 671 6314
674 6429 670 6485 676 6575 678 6690 675 6747 680 6812 682 6927 679 6984 684 7049 686 7164
687 7221 683 7277 689 7342 691 7457 688 7513 693 7578 695 7693 692 7750 698 7839 700 7954
% 556 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 564 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 565 0 R
/Resources 563 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 561 0 R
>>
% 566 0 obj
<<
/D [564 0 R /XYZ 214.652 106.79 null]
>>
% 563 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 568 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 569 0 R
/Resources 567 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 561 0 R
>>
% 570 0 obj
<<
/D [568 0 R /XYZ 80.179 160.986 null]
>>
% 567 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 572 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 573 0 R
/Resources 571 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 561 0 R
>>
% 574 0 obj
<<
/D [572 0 R /XYZ 211.936 228.732 null]
>>
% 571 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 576 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 577 0 R
/Resources 575 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 561 0 R
>>
% 578 0 obj
<<
/D [576 0 R /XYZ 123.815 298.933 null]
>>
% 575 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 580 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 581 0 R
/Resources 579 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 561 0 R
>>
% 582 0 obj
<<
/D [580 0 R /XYZ 320.339 364.224 null]
>>
% 579 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 584 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 585 0 R
/Resources 583 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 587 0 R
>>
% 586 0 obj
<<
/D [584 0 R /XYZ 92.792 420.876 null]
>>
% 583 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 589 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 590 0 R
/Resources 588 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 587 0 R
>>
% 591 0 obj
<<
/D [589 0 R /XYZ 329.311 504.626 null]
>>
% 592 0 obj
<<
/D [589 0 R /XYZ 374.173 106.79 null]
>>
% 588 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 594 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 595 0 R
/Resources 593 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 587 0 R
>>
% 596 0 obj
<<
/D [594 0 R /XYZ 164.133 160.986 null]
>>
% 593 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 598 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 599 0 R
/Resources 597 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 587 0 R
>>
% 600 0 obj
<<
/D [598 0 R /XYZ 93.543 257.135 null]
>>
% 597 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 602 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 603 0 R
/Resources 601 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 587 0 R
>>
% 604 0 obj
<<
/D [602 0 R /XYZ 233.758 325.213 null]
>>
% 601 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 606 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 607 0 R
/Resources 605 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 587 0 R
>>
% 608 0 obj
<<
/D [606 0 R /XYZ 225.341 396.232 null]
>>
% 605 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 610 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 611 0 R
/Resources 609 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 614 0 R
>>
% 612 0 obj
<<
/D [610 0 R /XYZ 130.253 463.978 null]
>>
% 613 0 obj
<<
/D [610 0 R /XYZ 226.637 66.142 null]
>>
% 609 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 616 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 617 0 R
/Resources 615 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 614 0 R
>>
% 618 0 obj
<<
/D [616 0 R /XYZ 196.74 149.074 null]
>>
% 615 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 620 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 621 0 R
/Resources 619 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 614 0 R
>>
% 622 0 obj
<<
/D [620 0 R /XYZ 114.433 217.638 null]
>>
% 619 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 624 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 625 0 R
/Resources 623 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 614 0 R
>>
% 626 0 obj
<<
/D [624 0 R /XYZ 353.239 284.566 null]
>>
% 623 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 628 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 629 0 R
/Resources 627 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 614 0 R
>>
% 630 0 obj
<<
/D [628 0 R /XYZ 46.771 338.021 null]
>>
% 627 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 632 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 633 0 R
/Resources 631 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 614 0 R
>>
% 634 0 obj
<<
/D [632 0 R /XYZ 339.829 396.232 null]
>>
% 631 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 636 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 637 0 R
/Resources 635 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 639 0 R
>>
% 638 0 obj
<<
/D [636 0 R /XYZ 212.822 463.978 null]
>>
% 635 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 641 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 642 0 R
/Resources 640 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 639 0 R
>>
% 643 0 obj
<<
/D [641 0 R /XYZ 205.375 518.175 null]
>>
% 644 0 obj
<<
/D [641 0 R /XYZ 292.914 121.975 null]
>>
% 640 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 646 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 647 0 R
/Resources 645 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 639 0 R
>>
% 648 0 obj
<<
/D [646 0 R /XYZ 267.224 219.827 null]
>>
% 645 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 650 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 651 0 R
/Resources 649 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 639 0 R
>>
% 652 0 obj
<<
/D [650 0 R /XYZ 93.543 258.635 null]
>>
% 649 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 653 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index8) >>
% 656 0 obj
(Chapter VII. The Allegation That No Testimony Can Prove The Truth Of A Supernatural Event.)
% 658 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 659 0 R
/Resources 657 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 639 0 R
>>
% 654 0 obj
<<
/D [658 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 660 0 obj
<<
/D [658 0 R /XYZ 136.922 93.24 null]
>>
% 657 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 662 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 663 0 R
/Resources 661 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 639 0 R
>>
% 664 0 obj
<<
/D [662 0 R /XYZ 157.524 147.437 null]
>>
% 661 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 666 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 667 0 R
/Resources 665 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 669 0 R
>>
% 668 0 obj
<<
/D [666 0 R /XYZ 76.75 216.82 null]
>>
% 665 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 671 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 672 0 R
/Resources 670 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 669 0 R
>>
% 674 0 obj
<<
/D [671 0 R /XYZ 93.543 271.835 null]
>>
% 670 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F43 673 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 676 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 677 0 R
/Resources 675 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 669 0 R
>>
% 678 0 obj
<<
/D [676 0 R /XYZ 201.503 328.486 null]
>>
% 675 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 680 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 681 0 R
/Resources 679 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 669 0 R
>>
% 682 0 obj
<<
/D [680 0 R /XYZ 115.445 393.778 null]
>>
% 679 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 684 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 685 0 R
/Resources 683 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 669 0 R
>>
% 686 0 obj
<<
/D [684 0 R /XYZ 284.126 463.978 null]
>>
% 687 0 obj
<<
/D [684 0 R /XYZ 213.388 66.142 null]
>>
% 683 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 689 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 690 0 R
/Resources 688 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 669 0 R
>>
% 691 0 obj
<<
/D [689 0 R /XYZ 93.543 133.888 null]
>>
% 688 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 693 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 694 0 R
/Resources 692 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 696 0 R
>>
% 695 0 obj
<<
/D [693 0 R /XYZ 182.392 201.634 null]
>>
% 692 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 698 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 699 0 R
/Resources 697 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 696 0 R
>>
% 700 0 obj
<<
/D [698 0 R /XYZ 175.548 271.835 null]
>>
endstream
endobj
704 0 obj <<
/Length 4802      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(149)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(avails)-250(to)-251(prove)-250(is,)-251(that)-250(it)-250(is)-251(impossible)-250(to)-250(prove)-251(a)-250(miracle,)-250(except)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-429(persons)-428(who)-429(are)-428(already)-429(convinced)-428(that)-429(a)-428(being)-429(or)-428(beings)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exist)-280(who)-280(are)-281(possessed)-280(of)-280(supernatural)-280(powers,)-288(and)-280(that)-280(it)-280(is)-280(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conformity)-323(with)-323(their)-323(character)-323(to)-324(work)-323(one.)-469(If)-323(this)-323(is)-323(the)-323(only)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(intelligible)-288(meaning)-288(of)-287(Hume's)-288(position)-288(\050and)-287(it)-288(is)-288(evident)-288(that)-287(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is\051,)-329(it)-313(reduces)-313(his)-313(argument)-313(against)-313(miracles)-313(to)-313(a)-313(very)-312(harmless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one.)-634(The)-378(conception)-377(of)-378(a)-378(miracle)-378(as)-378(distinct)-378(from)-378(an)-377(unusual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomenon)-298(implies)-298(purpose.)-393(Purpose)-298(i)1(s)-298(only)-298(conceivable)-298(of)-297(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-271(possessed)-271(of)-270(personality)-271(and)-271(will.)-312(To)-271(those)-271(therefore)-270(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(either)-398(deny)-398(the)-398(existence)-398(of)-398(any)-398(such)-398(being)-398(higher)-398(than)-397(man,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-362(who)-361(affirm)-362(that)-362(we)-362(have)-361(no)-362(evidence)-362(of)-361(his)-362(existence,)-390(it)-361(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impossible)-410(to)-410(prove)-410(a)-410(miracle)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 140.533 0 Td [(as)-410(a)-410(miracle)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 57.426 0 Td [(.)-730(The)-410(utmost)-410(that)]TJ -197.959 -13.549 Td [(could)-315(be)-316(done)-315(would)-316(be)-315(to)-316(prove)-315(that)-316(an)-315(event)-316(had)-315(taken)-315(place)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-297(nature)-297(which)-594(in)-296(the)-297(present)-297(state)-297(of)-297(our)-297(knowledge)-297(could)-296(be)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([167])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(assigned)-243(to)-244(no)-243(known)-243(cause.)-248(In)-243(such)-243(a)-243(case)-244(the)-243(Pantheist)-243(and)-243(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Atheist)-251(have)-250(always)-251(the)-251(alternative)-250(of)-251(believing)-251(that)-250(the)-251(event)-250(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question)-248(must)-248(be)-248(due)-248(to)-248(the)-248(operation)-248(of)-248(some)-248(unknown)-248(force)-247(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature,)-311(but)-299(which)-299(in)-298(the)-299(gradual)-299(development)-299(of)-299(knowledge)-298(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-189(hereafter)-190(be)-189(able)-190(to)-189(detect.)-230(This)-189(is)-190(a)-189(position)-190(that)-189(no)-189(defender)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-214(revelation)-214(worthy)-213(of)-214(the)-214(name)-214(can)-213(be)-214(anxious)-214(to)-214(dispute.)-238(Let)-213(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(further)-228(be)-228(observed)-229(that)-228(Mr.)-243(Mill)-228(does)-228(not)-228(deny,)-233(but)-228(affirms,)-232(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-279(occurrence)-279(of)-279(an)-279(extraordinary)-279(event)-279(analogous)-279(to)-279(a)-278(miracle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(viewed)-281(simply)-281(as)-281(a)-281(phenomenon,)-289(may)-281(be)-281(satisfactorily)-281(certified)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-285(our)-284(senses)-285(or)-285(by)-284(testimony.)-354(To)-285(affirm)-285(the)-284(contrary)-285(would)-284(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(simply)-297(absurd,)-310(as)-297(involving)-298(the)-297(stereotyping)-298(of)-297(human)-297(thought,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-378(making)-379(the)-378(wisdom)-378(of)-379(our)-378(ancestors)-378(the)-379(only)-378(standard)-378(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth.)-567(There)-356(was)-356(a)-356(time)-355(when)-356(the)-356(earth)-355(was)-356(believed)-356(to)-356(be)-355(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(extended)-434(plain.)-803(If)-434(at)-435(that)-434(time)-434(any)-434(one)-435(had)-434(asserted)-434(that)-434(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(continually)-334(sailing)-334(westward)-334(he)-334(had)-334(at)-334(last)-334(arrived)-334(at)-334(the)-334(place)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-302(which)-302(he)-302(started,)-315(or,)-315(in)-302(other)-302(words,)-315(had)-302(circumnavigated)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-277(globe,)-284(this)-277(affirmation)-277(ought)-277(to)-277(have)-277(been)-277(rejected,)-283(not)-277(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-251(founded)-250(on)-251(testimony)-251(contrary)-251(to)-250(all)-251(previous)-251(experience,)-250(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-187(intrinsically)-186(impossible.)-229(Yet)-186(if)-187(Hume's)-186(dictum)-187(has)-186(any)-187(value)-186(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-184(argument)-183(against)-184(the)-183(possibility)-184(of)-183(a)-184(miracle,)-197(it)-183(must)-184(affirm)-183(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
708 0 obj <<
/Length 4933      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(150)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(impossibility)-285(of)-286(establishing)-285(such)-285(an)-286(occurrence)-285(by)-285(any)-285(amount)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-259(evidence)-259(whatever.)-276(Mr.)-276(Mill's)-259(mind)-259(was)-258(far)-259(too)-259(logical)-259(not)-258(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(perceive)-250(that)-250(such)-250(a)-250(position)-250(is)-250(altogether)-250(untenable.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Mr.)-302(Mill,)-271(however,)-272(affirms)-267(that)-267(there)-268(is)-267(one)-267(ground)-267(on)-267(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-318(argument)-319(might)-318(be)-318(tenable)-319(against)-318(a)-318(theist,)-336(not)-318(because)-318(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(evidence)-285(is)-285(insufficient)-285(to)-285(prove)-285(the)-285(occurrence)-285(of)-285(an)-285(extraordi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nary)-248(fact,)-249(as)-248(a)-248(mere)-248(phenomenon,)-249(but)-248(because)-248(it)-248(could)-248(not)-248(prove)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-323(to)-323(be)-322(a)-323(miracle.)-468(It)-323(is)-323(not)-323(only)-322(necessary,)-341(says)-323(he,)-341(in)-323(order)-322(to)]TJ 3.057 -13.549 Td [(render)-280(this)-280(proof)-280(valid,)-288(that)-280(one)-281(should)-280(believe)-280(in)-280(the)-280(existence)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -75.812 0 Td [([168])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(of)-205(a)-206(supernatural)-205(being)-205(who)-206(is)-205(able)-205(to)-206(bring)-205(about)-205(the)-205(occurrence,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(but)-258(also)-258(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 56.322 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(the)-258(character)-258(of)-258(this)-258(Being)-258(is)-258(not)-258(inconsistent)-258(with)]TJ -61.166 -13.549 Td [(his)-220(having)-220(seen)-221(fit)-220(to)-220(interfere)-220(on)-221(the)-220(occasion)-220(in)-220(question.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 251.566 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.246 0 Td [(Thus)]TJ -258.812 -13.549 Td [(a)-389(man)-389(may)-389(be)-389(a)-389(believer)-389(in)-389(the)-389(existence)-389(of)-389(God,)-424(and)-388(yet)-389(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(persuaded)-201(that)-201(it)-200(was)-201(not)-201(consistent)-200(with)-201(his)-201(character)-201(to)-200(interfere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-253(the)-253(course)-253(of)-253(natural)-252(phenomena)-253(at)-253(all,)-254(or)-253(in)-253(such)-253(a)-252(manner)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-251(the)-250(conception)-251(of)-250(a)-251(miracle)-250(pre-supposes.)-252(To)-251(such)-250(a)-251(theist)-250(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(utmost)-341(that)-341(evidence)-340(could)-341(prove)-341(would)-341(be,)-363(that)-341(the)-340(extraordi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nary)-268(event)-269(had)-268(been)-268(brought)-269(about)-268(by)-268(the)-269(action)-268(of)-268(an)-268(unknown)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(force.)-571(Again,)-384(the)-357(same)-357(principle)-358(acts,)-383(and)-357(acts)-358(reasonably,)-383(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-225(minds)-225(of)-226(multitudes)-225(of)-225(intelligent)-225(Christians,)-230(who)-225(summarily)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(reject)-285(a)-284(certain)-285(class)-285(of)-285(reported)-284(miracles)-285(without)-285(inquiring)-284(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-291(evidence,)-302(on)-291(the)-292(ground)-291(that)-291(the)-292(working)-291(of)-291(such)-291(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-209(inconsistent)-209(with)-209(their)-209(conceptions)-209(of)-209(the)-209(divine)-209(character;)-222(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-321(to)-320(say,)-338(they)-321(think)-321(it)-320(more)-321(probable)-320(that)-321(the)-320(stories)-321(should)-320(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(untrue,)-246(than)-246(that)-245(God)-245(should)-245(work)-246(in)-245(the)-245(way)-245(in)-246(question.)-248(But)-245(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(give)-303(this)-303(argument)-303(any)-303(validity)-303(against)-303(the)-303(miracles)-303(wrought)-302(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(attestation)-208(of)-207(Christianity,)-216(it)-208(must)-207(be)-208(proved)-208(that)-207(it)-208(is)-207(inconsistent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-280(the)-281(divine)-280(character)-280(to)-281(make)-280(a)-280(revelation,)-288(or)-281(to)-280(introduce)-280(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(deviation)-283(from)-283(what)-284(is)-283(to)-283(us)-283(the)-284(ordinary)-283(mode)-283(of)-283(His)-283(working;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-258(that)-259(the)-258(miracles)-258(recorded)-259(in)-258(the)-258(Gospels)-259(are)-258(repugnant)-258(to)-258(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-250(of)-250(God.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Mr.)-423(Mill's)-308(general)-308(position)-308(is)-307(therefore)-308(incontrovertible,)-322(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(those)-245(who)-245(believe)-245(in)-246(the)-245(existence)-245(of)-245(God)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 184.998 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(have)-245(two)-245(hypotheses)]TJ -189.842 -13.549 Td [(to)-454(choose)-453(from,)-504(viz.)-861(a)-454(supernatural,)-504(or)-453(an)-454(unknown)-453(natural)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
712 0 obj <<
/Length 4793      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(151)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(agency;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.928 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.172 0 Td [(and)-213(that)-214(they)-213(must)-214(judge)-213(which)-214(of)-213(these)-214(two)-213(is)-214(the)-213(more)]TJ -41.1 -13.549 Td [(probable;)-305(and)-286(that,)-296(in)-286(forming)-287(their)-286(judgment,)-296(a)-286(most)-286(important)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consideration)-264(must)-264(be)-264(the)-264(character)-264(of)-264(God,)-535(and)-264(the)-263(conformity)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([169])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(of)-442(the)-443(supposed)-442(event)-443(to)-442(that)-443(character.)-827(This)-443(position)-442(every)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(intelligent)-250(Christian)-250(will)-250(readily)-250(accept.)]TJ 11.955 -15.185 Td [(Mr.)-220(Mill)-161(adds:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 64.284 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(But)-161(with)-161(the)-161(knowledge)-161(which)-161(we)-161(now)-161(possess)]TJ -81.083 -13.55 Td [(of)-187(the)-187(general)-187(uniformity)-187(of)-188(the)-187(course)-187(of)-187(nature,)-200(religion,)-199(follow-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ing)-286(in)-286(the)-286(wake)-286(of)-286(science,)-295(has)-286(been)-286(compelled)-286(to)-286(acknowledge)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-351(government)-351(of)-351(the)-351(universe,)-376(as)-351(being)-351(on)-351(the)-351(whole)-351(carried)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-244(by)-245(general)-244(laws,)-246(and)-244(not)-245(by)-244(special)-245(interpositions.)-248(To)-244(whoso-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ever)-437(holds)-437(this)-437(belief,)-483(there)-437(is)-437(a)-437(general)-437(presumption)-436(against)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(any)-267(supposition)-268(of)-267(divine)-268(agency,)-272(not)-267(operating)-268(through)-267(general)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(laws;)-463(or,)-428(in)-392(other)-393(words,)-427(there)-393(is)-392(an)-392(antecedent)-392(improbability)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-457(every)-457(miracle,)-509(which)-457(in)-457(order)-457(to)-457(outweigh)-457(it,)-508(requires)-457(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(extraordinary)-207(strength)-208(of)-207(antecedent)-208(probability)-207(derived)-208(from)-207(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(special)-362(circumstances)-363(of)-362(the)-363(case.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 151.832 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.798 0 Td [(These)-362(observations)-363(require)]TJ -160.63 -13.55 Td [(consideration.)]TJ 11.955 -15.185 Td [(There)-237(is)-236(no)-237(doubt)-236(that)-237(the)-237(polytheistic)-236(religions)-237(postulated)-237(the)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(existence)-195(of)-195(a)-196(vast)-195(number)-195(of)-195(superhuman)-196(beings)-195(by)-195(whose)-195(agen-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(cy)-394(and)-393(caprice)-394(many)-394(natural)-393(occurrences)-394(were)-394(brought)-393(about.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Such)-353(a)-353(belief)-353(indicates)-353(a)-353(very)-353(imperfect)-353(conception)-352(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 247.924 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(order)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 23.018 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(in)-290(nature.)-369(But)-290(these)-290(supposed)-289(interferences)-290(with)-290(it)-290(would)-290(by)-289(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(means)-359(realize)-359(the)-359(notion)-360(of)-359(what)-359(we)-359(now)-359(designate)-359(a)-359(miracle,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-338(very)-339(idea)-339(of)-338(which)-339(implies)-338(an)-339(order)-338(in)-339(nature)-338(to)-339(which)-338(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miracle)-295(forms)-294(an)-295(exception.)-384(If)-295(there)-295(is)-294(no)-295(order)-295(in)-294(nature,)-306(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-250(be)-250(no)-250(miracle.)]TJ 11.955 -15.186 Td [(The)-216(Hebrew)-217(monotheism)-216(involved)-217(conceptions)-216(directly)-217(oppo-)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(site)-295(to)-294(this.)-385(It)-295(viewed)-294(the)-295(action)-295(of)-295(God)-294(as)-295(the)-295(foundation)-295(of)-294(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-346(forces)-346(in)-346(nature.)-537(Whilst)-346(above)-346(and)-346(outside)-346(nature,)-370(He)-345(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(everywhere)-276(present)-276(in)-277(nature.)-328(Its)-277(forces)-276(were)-276(the)-276(expressions)-276(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-345(energy)-344(of)-345(His)-345(will.)-534(Its)-345(order)-344(\050for)-345(the)-345(Hebrew)-345(recognised)-344(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(high)-194(order)-194(in)-194(nature\051)-195(was)-194(the)-194(result)-194(of)-194(His)-195(good)-388(pleasure,)-205(and)-194(due)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.023 0 Td [([170])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.55 Td [(to)-326(His)-326(constant)-326(working.)-479(In)-326(the)-326(Old)-326(Testament)-326(the)-326(commonest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-241(in)-242(nature)-241(are)-241(no)-242(less)-241(ascribed)-242(to)-241(God)-241(than)-242(those)-241(which)-241(we)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
717 0 obj <<
/Length 4694      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(152)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(designate)-218(miraculous.)-239(A)-218(Hebrew)-218(never)-218(conceived)-218(of)-218(a)-218(miracle)-217(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-215(deviation)-214(from)-215(the)-214(divine)-215(order,)-222(but)-214(as)-215(a)-214(consistent)-215(carrying)-214(out)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-315(a)-314(divine)-315(purpose)-314(in)-315(the)-314(government)-315(of)-315(the)-314(world.)-444(A)-314(modern)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conception)-228(of)-229(theism)-228(differs)-228(from)-229(this)-228(in)-228(supposing)-229(that)-228(there)-228(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(certain)-365(forces)-365(in)-365(material)-365(nature)-365(which,)-394(when)-365(once)-365(called)-365(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action,)-270(go)-265(on)-266(energizing)-265(without)-266(any)-266(direct)-265(intervention)-266(of)-265(God.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(But)-291(when)-291(this)-291(conception)-291(comes)-292(to)-291(be)-291(minutely)-291(analysed,)-301(if)-291(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believe)-335(in)-335(a)-335(God,)-356(it)-335(is)-335(impossible)-335(to)-335(conceive)-334(of)-335(force,)-357(at)-334(least)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-320(its)-319(ultimate)-320(form,)-337(except)-320(as)-319(a)-320(direct)-320(expression)-319(of)-320(the)-319(divine)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(energy.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(Science)-277(has)-277(so)-276(far)-277(modified)-277(religious)-277(thought)-277(on)-277(this)-276(subject,)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(that)-181(while)-181(it)-181(still)-181(conti)1(nues)-181(to)-181(hold)-181(that)-181(the)-181(various)-181(forces)-181(in)-180(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-264(modes)-264(of)-265(the)-264(divine)-264(acting,)-268(it)-264(nevertheless)-264(believes)-264(that)-264(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(does)-297(not)-297(deviate)-298(from)-297(his)-297(predetermined)-297(course)-297(for)-297(the)-297(purpose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-200(meeting)-201(what)-200(we)-200(are)-201(pleased)-200(to)-200(call)-201(special)-200(contingencies.)-233(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine)-305(action)-305(is,)-318(in)-305(fact,)-319(not)-305(altered)-305(to)-305(meet)-305(man's)-304(convenience,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-422(His)-422(government)-421(is)-422(carried)-422(on)-422(as)-422(far)-421(as)-422(it)-422(lies)-422(within)-421(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cognisance)-336(by)-337(the)-336(general)-337(forces)-336(of)-337(nature.)-509(God)-337(acts)-336(in)-336(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-418(conformity)-419(with)-418(a)-418(definite)-419(law,)-460(and)-418(from)-419(that)-418(He)-418(will)-418(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(deviate,)-259(whatever)-257(consequences)-258(man's)-257(ignorance)-257(or)-257(disregard)-257(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-282(mode)-281(of)-282(action)-282(may)-282(bring)-281(upon)-282(him.)-345(Mr.)-345(Mill)-282(observes)-281(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-275(any)-275(person)-275(holding)-275(this)-275(belief,)-281(there)-275(is)-275(a)-275(general)-274(presumption)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(against)-281(any)-281(supposition)-281(of)-280(divine)-281(agency,)-289(not)-281(operating)-280(through)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(general)-196(laws.)-232(That)-196(is)-196(to)-196(say,)-207(we)-196(have)-196(had)-196(a)-196(constant)-195(experience)-196(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-272(acting)-272(through)-272(general)-271(laws;)-283(and)-272(no)-272(experience)-272(of)-272(his)-271(acting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(otherwise.)-495(But)-332(the)-331(idea)-332(of)-331(a)-332(revelation)-332(introduces)-331(a)-332(factor)-331(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-281(case,)-288(entirely)-281(different)-280(from)-281(anything)-281(of)-280(which)-281(we)-281(have)-280(had)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(previous)-328(experience.)-968(It)-328(forms)-328(part)-328(of)-328(a)-328(great)-327(purpose)-328(existing)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([171])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(in)-407(the)-406(divine)-407(mind,)-446(and)-407(is)-406(in)-407(its)-407(nature)-406(analogous)-407(to)-407(the)-406(first)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(introduction)-357(of)-357(life,)-383(or)-357(the)-357(first)-357(creation)-357(of)-357(a)-357(free)-357(moral)-356(agent.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Respecting)-368(the)-368(laws)-368(by)-368(which)-368(God)-368(regulates)-368(his)-368(creative)-368(acts,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-255(are)-255(ignorant.)-264(Yet)-255(the)-255(theist)-255(firmly)-255(believes)-255(in)-255(creative)-255(acts)-254(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(some)-274(kind,)-279(and)-274(that)-273(they)-274(are)-273(regulated)-274(by)-274(law.)-320(In)-274(this)-273(ignorance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-437(God's)-438(law)-437(of)-438(creation,)-484(it)-437(is)-438(impossible)-437(to)-437(affirm)-438(that)-437(it)-437(is)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
721 0 obj <<
/Length 5065      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(153)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(antecedently)-265(improbable)-264(that)-265(in)-265(making)-264(a)-265(fresh)-265(manifestation)-264(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(himself,)-291(he)-283(will)-283(operate)-282(only)-283(through)-283(those)-283(general)-282(laws,)-291(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-250(the)-250(ordinary)-250(manifestations)-250(of)-250(his)-250(will.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(There)-251(is)-250(some)-251(want)-250(of)-251(clearness)-251(in)-250(Mr.)-252(Mill's)-251(expression,)-250(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-365(order)-366(to)-365(outweigh)-365(the)-366(antecedent)-365(improbability)-365(of)-365(miracles,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(arising)-300(from)-301(those)-300(modes)-301(of)-300(the)-301(divine)-300(action)-301(which)-300(fall)-300(within)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-419(limits)-419(of)-419(our)-419(experience,)-461(an)-419(extraordinary)-419(strength)-419(of)-419(an-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tecedent)-328(probability,)-347(derived)-328(from)-327(the)-328(special)-328(circumstances)-327(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-291(case,)-302(is)-292(required.)-374(If)-291(by)-292(this)-291(antecedent)-292(probability)-291(he)-291(means)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(something)-340(such)-339(as)-340(has)-340(been)-340(above)-339(referred)-340(to,)-362(there)-340(can)-340(be)-339(no)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(objection)-255(to)-256(his)-255(statement.)-267(He)-255(ought)-256(to)-255(have)-256(observed,)-256(however,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-459(the)-459(antecedent)-459(improbability)-459(which)-459(may)-459(be)-459(supposed)-458(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belong)-395(to)-396(miracles,)-432(only)-395(attaches)-395(to)-396(them)-395(while)-395(contemplated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-323(phenomena,)-340(and)-323(that)-323(such)-322(an)-323(improbability)-322(readily)-323(yields)-322(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(positive)-231(evidence.)-243(This)-231(is)-230(virtually)-230(admitted)-231(in)-230(a)-231(subsequent)-230(sen-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tence.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 28.496 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(According)-251(as)-250(this)-251(circumstance,)-251(viz.)-252(the)-251(unknown)-250(cause,)]TJ -33.339 -13.549 Td [(not)-225(having)-225(previously)-225(manifested)-225(itself)-225(in)-225(action,)-230(or)-225(the)-225(falsity)-224(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-331(testimony,)-351(appears)-330(more)-331(improbable;)-371(that)-331(is,)-351(conflicts)-330(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-293(approximate)-293(generalization)-293(of)-293(a)-293(higher)-293(order,)-304(we)-293(believe)-293(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testimony)-362(or)-362(disbelieve)-362(it)-361(with)-362(a)-362(stronger)-362(or)-362(weaker)-362(degree)-361(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(conviction,)-202(according)-189(to)-190(the)-189(preponderance,)-202(at)-190(least)-189(until)-190(we)-189(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sifted)-248(the)-248(matter)-248(further.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 105.965 0 Td [(\035)-248(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.391 0 Td [(This,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 22.124 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.547 0 Td [(says)-248(the)-248(author)-247(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 79.891 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Supernatu-)]TJ -232.761 -13.549 Td [(ral)-282(Religion,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 54.899 0 Td [(\035)-565(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.848 0 Td [(is)-282(precisely)-283(Hume's)-282(argument,)-291(weakened)-282(by)-282(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 220.277 0 Td [([172])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(introduction)-355(of)-355(reservations)-356(which)-355(have)-355(no)-355(cogency.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 235.626 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.719 0 Td [(We)-355(say,)]TJ -244.345 -13.549 Td [(this)-274(is)-273(precisely)-274(what)-274(Hume's)-274(argument)-273(is)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 185.88 0 Td [(not)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.942 0 Td [(,)-280(for,)-279(if)-274(it)-274(be)-273(valid,)]TJ -199.822 -13.549 Td [(the)-445(whole)-445(question)-445(of)-445(miracles)-445(may)-445(be)-445(summarily)-444(dismissed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(without)-250(any)-250(inquiry)-250(into)-250(the)-250(evidence)-250(on)-250(which)-250(they)-250(rest.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Still,)-278(however,)-279(as)-273(the)-273(author)-272(affirms)-273(and)-273(endeavours)-273(to)-272(prove)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-394(Mr.)-683(Mill's)-394(position)-394(leave)-394(Hume's)-394(argument)-394(untouched,)-430(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(few)-255(further)-255(observations)-255(will)-255(be)-255(necessary.)-265(Hume's)-255(statement)-254(is,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(A)-380(miracle)-381(is)-380(a)-381(violation)-381(of)-380(the)-381(laws)-380(of)-381(nature,)-413(and)-380(as)-381(a)-380(firm)]TJ -4.844 -13.549 Td [(and)-275(unalterable)-274(experience)-275(has)-275(established)-274(these)-275(laws,)-281(the)-274(proof)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(against)-301(a)-301(miracle)-301(from)-301(the)-301(nature)-301(of)-301(the)-301(fact,)-314(is)-301(as)-301(entire)-300(as)-301(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(argument)-250(from)-250(experience)-250(which)-250(can)-250(possibly)-250(be)-250(imagined.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 260.553 0 Td [(\035)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
726 0 obj <<
/Length 5273      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(154)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(I)-277(reply,)-283(that)-276(the)-277(conception)-277(of)-276(a)-277(miracle)-277(does)-276(not)-277(involve)-276(any)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(necessary)-336(violation)-336(of)-335(the)-336(laws)-336(of)-336(nature.)-507(All)-336(that)-336(it)-336(implies)-335(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-365(presence)-366(of)-365(another)-366(force)-365(different)-365(from)-366(those)-365(which)-365(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(come)-207(under)-207(our)-208(cognisance:)-228(and)-207(this)-207(may)-208(act)-207(so)-207(as)-207(to)-207(produce)-207(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miracle)-301(without)-302(violating)-301(one)-302(of)-301(nature's)-301(laws.)-404(But,)-315(it)-301(is)-301(added,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(uniform)-212(and)-211(unalterable)-212(experience)-212(has)-211(established)-212(these)-211(laws.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 270.942 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(What)-325(has)-326(this)-325(experience)-325(really)-326(established?)-475(It)-326(is)-325(this,)-344(and)-325(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only,)-234(Given)-230(the)-231(presence)-230(of)-230(certain)-231(forces,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 186.095 0 Td [(and)-230(no)-231(others)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 59.569 0 Td [(,)-234(certain)]TJ -245.664 -13.549 Td [(results)-228(invariably)-228(follow.)-243(But)-228(experience)-228(cannot)-228(tell)-227(us)-228(anything,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-208(to)-209(what)-208(would)-208(be)-209(the)-208(law)-209(of)-208(nature,)-217(if)-208(some)-208(other)-209(force)-208(were)-208(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action;)-202(nor)-177(is)-177(it)-177(able)-178(to)-177(say)-177(one)-178(word)-177(as)-177(to)-178(the)-177(non-existence)-177(of)-177(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(force)-345(which)-345(has)-345(not)-346(come)-345(under)-345(its)-345(observation.)-535(Abstractedly,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-317(is)-316(true)-317(that)-317(the)-317(argument)-316(against)-317(a)-317(miracle)-317(is)-316(as)-317(entire)-317(as)-316(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(argument)-267(from)-267(experience)-267(can)-267(be)-266(imagined,)-272(because)-266(experience)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(really)-359(supplies)-359(us)-359(with)-358(no)-359(basis)-359(for)-359(argumentation)-359(in)-359(the)-358(case.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Prior)-218(to)-218(the)-218(invention)-218(of)-218(railways)-218(and)-218(the)-218(discovery)-218(of)-218(the)-218(uses)-218(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-259(steam)-518(can)-259(be)-259(applied,)-261(the)-259(argument)-259(from)-259(experience)-259(was)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([173])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(equally)-217(valid)-217(against)-217(the)-218(possibility)-217(of)-217(travelling)-217(in)-217(a)-217(carriage)-217(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(propelled)-302(by)-302(animal)-302(force.)-407(In)-302(each)-302(case)-302(a)-302(new)-302(force)-302(enters)-302(into)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-222(conditions,)-228(of)-223(which)-222(experience)-223(is)-222(unable)-223(to)-222(take)-222(cognisance.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -18.458 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Why)-365(is)-366(it)-365(more)-366(probable)-365(that)-365(all)-366(men)-365(must)-366(die?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 216.466 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.83 0 Td [(asks)-365(this)]TJ -242.095 -13.55 Td [(writer,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 31.649 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(or)-261(that)-260(lead)-261(cannot)-260(of)-261(itself)-260(remain)-261(suspended)-260(in)-261(the)-260(air;)]TJ -36.493 -13.549 Td [(or)-239(that)-239(fire)-239(consumes)-239(wood,)-241(and)-239(is)-239(extinguished)-239(by)-239(water,)-241(unless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-340(be)-339(that)-340(these)-340(events)-340(are)-339(found)-340(agreeable)-340(to)-340(nature,)-362(and)-339(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-315(required)-315(a)-315(violation)-315(of)-315(its)-315(laws,)-331(or)-315(in)-314(other)-315(words,)-332(a)-314(miracle,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-292(prevent)-292(them?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 74.239 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.031 0 Td [(I)-292(answer)-292(that)-292(it)-292(is)-293(probable)-292(that)-292(all)-292(men)-292(must)]TJ -82.27 -13.549 Td [(die,)-390(because)-362(we)-362(observe)-362(under)-362(the)-362(action)-362(of)-362(the)-362(known)-362(forces)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-332(nature)-331(that)-332(all)-332(men)-332(do)-331(die.)-495(But)-332(this)-332(says)-331(nothing)-332(as)-332(to)-331(what)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-227(take)-228(place)-227(if)-227(another)-228(force)-227(was)-227(present;)-235(or)-228(a)-227(combination)-227(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existing)-319(forces)-318(was)-318(discovered)-319(sufficiently)-318(potent)-319(to)-318(counteract)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-415(action)-414(of)-415(those)-414(which)-415(in)-415(the)-414(present)-415(state)-414(of)-415(things)-414(bring)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(about)-434(the)-433(dissolution)-434(of)-433(man's)-434(frame.)-801(There)-433(is)-434(no)-433(necessity,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(for)-315(the)-315(purpose)-315(of)-314(effecting)-315(this,)-331(that)-315(one)-315(of)-315(the)-315(existing)-314(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-451(be)-450(suspended.)-852(The)-450(time)-451(was,)-501(when)-450(certain)-451(forms)-450(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
730 0 obj <<
/Length 5079      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(155)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(disease)-409(invariably)-409(resulted)-409(in)-410(death.)-727(The)-409(advance)-409(of)-409(medical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(science)-242(has)-242(averted)-242(this)-242(result.)-247(Ought)-242(the)-242(discovery)-242(to)-242(have)-241(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rejected)-290(because)-290(it)-290(pretended)-290(to)-290(produce)-290(a)-290(fact)-290(contrary)-290(to)-289(prior)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(experience?)-604(Are)-369(any)-368(of)-368(the)-368(laws)-368(of)-368(nature)-368(violated,)-398(or)-368(are)-368(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(forces)-225(suspended)-225(in)-226(such)-225(a)-225(case?)-242(What)-225(has)-225(taken)-226(place?)-241(Man)-225(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discovered)-349(agencies)-348(which)-349(have)-348(neutralized)-349(the)-348(effect)-349(of)-348(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agencies.)-232(Our)-197(belief)-197(that)-196(all)-197(men)-197(must)-197(die)-196(rests)-197(on)-197(the)-196(assumption)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-231(no)-232(force)-231(can)-231(or)-231(will)-232(at)-231(any)-231(future)-231(time)-232(be)-231(brought)-231(into)-231(action)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-267(will)-268(counteract)-267(the)-267(forces)-268(now)-267(in)-267(operation)-268(by)-267(which)-267(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(event)-250(is)-250(produced.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-374(same)-374(remark)-373(applies)-374(to)-374(the)-374(other)-373(three)-374(cases.)-1243(To)-373(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 279.068 0 Td [([174])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(second)-476(of)-476(them)-476(the)-476(author)-476(has)-476(himself)-476(supplied)-476(the)-475(answer:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Lead)-228(cannot)-228(of)-228(itself)-228(remain)-228(suspended)-228(in)-228(the)-228(air.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 213.491 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.331 0 Td [(Doubtless,)-232(it)]TJ -225.666 -13.549 Td [(cannot)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 32.25 0 Td [(of)-290(itself)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 32.871 0 Td [(.)-371(Who)-290(ever)-290(supposed)-290(that)-291(it)-290(could?)-370(But)-291(it)-290(can)-290(be)]TJ -65.121 -13.549 Td [(suspended)-192(when)-193(a)-192(force)-193(adequate)-192(to)-192(counteract)-193(that)-192(of)-192(gravitation)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-220(present.)-240(So)-220(fire)-221(will)-220(always)-220(consume)-220(wood,)-226(or)-220(be)-220(extinguished)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-372(water,)-403(as)-372(long)-372(as)-372(no)-372(other)-373(forces)-372(but)-372(the)-372(usual)-372(ones)-372(are)-372(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(operation.)-246(But)-237(man)-238(has)-237(already)-238(invented)-237(the)-238(means)-237(of)-237(producing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(combustion)-196(under)-196(water.)-232(No)-195(violation)-196(of)-196(nature's)-196(laws)-196(is)-195(required)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-378(any)-377(of)-378(these)-377(cases.)-633(Nor)-378(is)-377(there)-378(any)-378(required)-377(in)-378(a)-377(miracle.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(The)-321(fact)-320(is,)-339(that)-320(there)-321(is)-321(an)-320(assumption)-321(in)-321(all)-320(arguments)-321(of)-320(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(kind,)-223(which)-215(for)-216(obvious)-216(reasons)-216(is)-216(not)-215(openly)-216(avowed,)-223(but)-215(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alone)-304(imparts)-304(to)-304(them)-304(an)-303(apparent)-304(validity.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 194.965 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(No)-304(such)-304(force)-304(can)]TJ -199.809 -13.549 Td [(exist,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 23.335 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.846 0 Td [(which)-275(translated)-276(into)-275(other)-275(language)-275(is)-276(identical)-275(with)-275(the)]TJ -31.181 -13.549 Td [(proposition,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 55.901 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(There)-305(is)-304(no)-305(God.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 75.106 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.166 0 Td [(To)-305(keep)-304(this)-305(assumption)-304(in)-305(the)]TJ -144.017 -13.55 Td [(background,)-254(when)-254(the)-253(very)-254(basis)-253(of)-254(the)-253(argument)-254(for)-253(miracles)-253(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-237(assumption)-238(that)-237(there)-238(is)-237(one,)-240(is)-238(a)-237(course)-238(which)-237(can)-238(lead)-237(to)-237(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(good)-250(result.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-318(the)-319(author)-318(remarks)-319(further:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 142.937 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(There)-318(must,)-336(therefore,)-336(be)-318(a)]TJ -159.736 -13.549 Td [(uniform)-389(experience)-389(against)-389(every)-389(miraculous)-390(event,)-423(otherwise)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-401(event)-401(could)-401(not)-401(merit)-400(that)-401(appellation.)-703(And)-401(as)-401(a)-400(uniform)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(experience)-345(amounts)-344(to)-345(a)-344(proof,)-369(there)-344(is)-345(hence)-345(a)-344(direct)-345(and)-344(full)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(proof)-192(from)-192(the)-192(nature)-192(of)-192(the)-191(fact,)-204(against)-192(the)-192(existence)-192(of)-192(any)-191(mir-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acle;)-287(nor)-274(can)-275(such)-274(a)-275(proof)-275(be)-274(destroyed,)-281(or)-274(the)-275(miracle)-274(rendered)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
734 0 obj <<
/Length 5240      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(156)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(credible,)-250(by)-250(any)-250(opposite)-250(proof)-250(which)-250(is)-250(superior.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 216.633 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -204.677 -15.186 Td [(Here)-277(again)-276(we)-277(encounter)-277(the)-276(same)-277(faults)-277(of)-276(reasoning,)-283(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(amount)-229(to)-229(a)-229(virtual)-228(assumption)-229(of)-229(the)-229(point)-229(at)-229(issue.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 226.632 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(There)-229(must)]TJ -231.475 -13.549 Td [(be)-219(a)-219(uniform)-219(experience)-219(against)-219(any)-219(miraculous)-219(event,)-225(otherwise)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-286(would)-287(not)-286(merit)-286(the)-287(appellation)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 147.739 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(doubtless.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 43.942 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.967 0 Td [(But)-286(what)-287(is)-286(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -283.312 0 Td [([175])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(nature)-230(of)-231(this)-230(uniform)-231(experience?)-243(Exactly)-230(this,)-235(that)-230(the)-230(ordinary)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(forces)-272(acting)-272(around)-272(us)-272(being)-272(present,)-277(and)-272(none)-272(other,)-278(the)-271(event)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-253(not,)-253(and)-252(therefore)-253(cannot)-252(take)-253(place.)-257(But)-253(this)-252(is)-253(not)-252(involved)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-226(the)-227(idea)-226(of)-227(a)-226(miracle.)-242(It)-227(assumes)-226(the)-226(presence)-227(of)-226(another)-226(force,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(viz.)-472(God.)-471(But)-324(what)-324(then?)-472(The)-324(objector)-324(will)-324(urge)-324(that)-324(we)-323(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-284(no)-284(experience)-284(of)-284(the)-284(existence)-284(of)-284(any)-284(such)-284(force.)-352(Is)-284(it)-284(to)-283(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(urged,)-224(that)-217(no)-217(force)-218(can)-217(exist,)-224(except)-217(those)-217(of)-218(which)-217(we)-217(have)-217(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(experience,)-222(or)-216(any)-215(combination)-216(of)-216(forces)-215(now)-216(in)-215(action,)-222(different)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-380(the)-381(present?)-641(The)-381(men)-380(of)-381(a)-380(former)-381(century)-380(were)-380(equally)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entitled)-361(to)-362(make)-361(the)-362(same)-361(assumption.)-584(If)-362(they)-361(had)-362(done)-361(so,)-389(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-308(follow,)-322(that)-307(if)-308(the)-307(discoverers)-308(of)-308(America)-307(had)-308(found)-307(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(present)-243(railway)-243(system)-242(in)-243(full)-243(operation,)-244(and)-243(reported)-243(it)-243(to)-243(be)-242(so,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-383(contemporaries)-382(of)-383(Columbus)-382(would)-383(have)-382(been)-383(justified)-382(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(treating)-250(him)-250(as)-250(an)-250(impostor.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-210(the)-210(author)-210(further)-210(observes:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 139.526 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Mr.)-237(Mill)-210(qualifies)-210(his)-210(admis-)]TJ -156.325 -13.549 Td [(sion)-287(respecting)-287(the)-287(effect)-287(of)-287(the)-287(alleged)-287(counteracting)-287(cause,)-296(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-288(all)-287(important)-288(words)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 105.873 0 Td [(\030)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 3.633 0 Td [(if)-287(present)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 41.514 0 Td [(;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 3.033 0 Td [(\031)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.769 0 Td [(for)-288(in)-287(order)-288(to)-287(be)-288(valid,)-296(the)]TJ -160.822 -13.549 Td [(reality)-372(of)-373(the)-372(alleged)-373(counteracting)-372(cause)-373(must)-372(be)-372(established,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-291(is)-292(impossible;)-312(therefore)-291(the)-292(objection)-291(falls)-292(to)-291(the)-291(ground.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(No)-201(one)-200(knows)-201(better)-201(than)-200(Mr.)-234(Mill,)-210(that)-201(the)-201(assertion)-200(of)-201(a)-200(person-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(al)-313(deity)-313(working)-313(miracles,)-329(upon)-313(which)-313(a)-313(miracle)-313(is)-312(allowed)-313(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-318(moment)-318(to)-318(come)-317(into)-318(court,)-335(cannot)-318(be)-318(proved;)-352(and)-317(therefore,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-278(it)-278(cannot)-278(stand)-278(in)-278(opposition)-278(to)-278(a)-278(complete)-278(induction)-278(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Hume)-250(takes)-250(as)-250(his)-250(standard.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 121.495 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -109.539 -15.186 Td [(This)-308(passage)-308(strikes)-308(us)-307(as)-308(an)-308(extraordinary)-308(one)-308(to)-308(have)-307(been)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(written)-456(by)-456(any)-456(one)-457(who)-456(possesses)-456(the)-456(logical)-456(powers)-456(of)-456(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(author.)-470(We)-323(are)-323(dealing)-324(with)-323(a)-323(formal)-323(argument)-324(with)-323(a)-323(view)-323(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(testing)-172(its)-172(validity,)-188(we)-172(have)-172(the)-172(fullest)-172(right)-172(to)-172(test)-172(it)-172(by)-172(a)-172(supposed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(case.)-336(That)-557(supposed)-278(case)-278(is)-279(the)-278(presence)-279(of)-278(an)-279(unknown)-278(cause,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([176])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
739 0 obj <<
/Length 5144      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(157)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(or)-359(an)-359(unknown)-359(combination)-359(of)-359(known)-359(causes,)-386(or)-359(the)-358(presence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-443(a)-443(personal)-442(deity.)-829(If)-443(the)-442(argument)-443(breaks)-443(down)-443(under)-442(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(application)-296(of)-296(these)-295(tests,)-307(it)-296(is)-296(worthless.)-387(Does)-296(the)-296(author)-295(mean)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-231(say,)-235(that)-231(it)-231(is)-231(necessary)-231(to)-231(prove)-231(every)-231(assumption)-231(to)-231(be)-231(a)-230(fact,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(before)-301(it)-302(can)-301(be)-302(used)-301(in)-302(argument?)-404(How)-302(about)-301(the)-301(assumptions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(Euclid?)-251(I)-250(submit)-251(that)-250(the)-250(reasoning)-250(is)-250(by)-251(no)-250(means)-250(vitiated)-250(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-305(assumption,)-318(and)-304(consequently)-305(that)-304(by)-305(the)-304(application)-305(of)-304(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same)-337(principles)-336(of)-337(reasoning,)-359(Hume's)-336(argument)-337(falls)-337(to)-336(pieces.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(In)-242(one)-242(sense)-242(the)-241(words)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 101.653 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(if)-242(present)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 40.809 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.481 0 Td [(are)-242(all)-242(important,)-243(yet)-242(it)-242(is)-242(not)]TJ -154.787 -13.55 Td [(necessary)-344(to)-344(prove)-344(the)-344(fact)-344(in)-344(order)-344(to)-344(establish)-344(the)-344(validity)-344(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-329(reasoning,)-349(which)-329(is)-329(entirely)-330(independent)-329(of)-329(the)-329(truth)-329(of)-329(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assumption.)-310(Has)-271(the)-270(author)-270(never)-270(heard)-270(of)-270(contingent)-270(reasoning)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-318(which)-319(both)-318(antecedent)-319(and)-318(consequent)-319(may)-318(be)-318(false,)-336(but)-318(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proposition)-250(valid?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -16.004 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(No)-240(one)-240(knows,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 65.536 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.464 0 Td [(again)-240(says)-240(the)-241(author,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.848 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(better)-240(than)-240(Mr.)-247(Mill,)]TJ -191.49 -13.55 Td [(that)-407(the)-407(allegation)-406(of)-407(a)-407(personal)-407(God)-407(working)-406(miracles,)-446(upon)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-215(a)-216(miracle)-215(is)-215(for)-215(a)-216(moment)-215(allowed)-215(to)-216(come)-215(into)-215(court,)-222(can-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-239(be)-239(proved.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 62.478 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.453 0 Td [(It)-239(seems)-239(then)-239(after)-239(all)-240(that)-239(we)-239(are)-239(reasoning)-239(with)]TJ -69.931 -13.549 Td [(a)-293(person)-293(who)-293(rejects)-293(theism;)-314(although)-293(he)-293(has)-293(been)-292(dealing)-293(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-322(question)-322(on)-322(principles)-322(which)-323(assume)-322(its)-322(truth.)-466(In)-322(arguing)-322(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(question)-229(of)-229(this)-230(kind)-229(it)-229(is)-229(necessary)-229(to)-229(be)-230(consistent,)-233(and)-229(take)-229(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stand)-230(either)-230(on)-230(the)-229(principles)-230(of)-230(theism,)-234(or)-230(on)-230(those)-230(of)-229(pantheism)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-246(atheism,)-247(and)-246(not)-247(to)-246(fall)-246(back)-246(on)-246(either)-247(as)-246(the)-246(exigencies)-246(of)-246(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(case)-324(demand.)-472(Least)-323(of)-324(all)-324(should)-324(this)-324(be)-324(done)-324(by)-324(a)-323(writer)-324(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(charges)-313(the)-313(defenders)-313(of)-314(Christianity)-313(with)-313(shifting)-313(their)-313(ground)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(suit)-250(the)-250(necessities)-250(of)-250(their)-250(argument.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(But)-239(is)-238(the)-239(case)-239(correctly)-238(stated?)-246(No)-239(doubt)-239(that)-238(the)-478(conception)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 279.068 0 Td [([177])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.55 Td [(of)-321(a)-320(personal)-321(God)-321(is)-320(essential)-321(to)-321(it.)-462(But)-321(that)-320(of)-321(a)-321(personal)-320(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(actually)-368(working)-369(miracles)-369(forms)-368(no)-369(portion)-368(of)-369(it.)-605(If)-369(this)-368(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assumed,)-346(the)-327(entire)-327(reasoning)-327(would)-327(be)-327(a)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 188.48 0 Td [(petitio)-327(principii)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 69.032 0 Td [(.)-481(We)]TJ -257.512 -13.549 Td [(are)-330(considering)-330(whether)-330(miracles)-331(are)-330(possible;)-370(or)-330(if,)-350(supposing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-241(to)-240(be)-241(wrought,)-242(it)-241(can)-240(be)-241(established)-241(by)-240(evidence.)-247(All)-241(that)-240(we)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(assume)-263(is,)-265(that)-263(God)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 88.76 0 Td [(can)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 18.617 0 Td [(work)-263(miracles,)-265(not)-263(that)-262(He)-263(has)-262(wrought)]TJ -107.377 -13.549 Td [(them.)-787(Whether)-429(we)-429(can)-429(prove)-429(by)-429(good)-429(evidence)-428(that)-429(He)-429(has)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
743 0 obj <<
/Length 5211      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(158)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(wrought)-250(miracles,)-250(is)-250(quite)-250(independent)-250(of)-250(the)-250(present)-250(question.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -15.186 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(No)-338(one)-337(knows)-338(better)-337(than)-338(Mr.)-512(Mill,)-359(that)-338(the)-338(assertion)-337(of)-338(a)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(personal)-189(deity)-189(working)-190(miracles)-189(cannot)-189(be)-189(proved.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 216.883 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.907 0 Td [(It)-189(is)-189(perfectly)]TJ -223.79 -13.549 Td [(true)-327(that)-327(Mr.)-481(Mill)-327(believed)-327(that)-327(the)-327(evidence)-327(adduced)-326(to)-327(prove)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-248(being)-248(of)-248(a)-248(personal)-248(God)-247(was)-248(insufficient,)-249(and)-248(that)-247(respecting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-414(origin)-414(of)-414(all)-414(things,)-454(nothing)-414(can)-414(be)-414(known.)-742(But)-414(yet)-414(it)-413(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(impossible)-278(to)-279(treat)-278(the)-279(existence)-278(of)-279(a)-278(personal)-279(God)-278(as)-279(a)-278(bare)-278(as-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sumption.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 45.987 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(It)-227(is)-228(impossible)-227(to)-227(be)-227(proved,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 125.427 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.323 0 Td [(says)-227(the)-228(author.)-242(But)-227(to)]TJ -183.58 -13.549 Td [(whom?)-240(To)-221(minds)-221(constituted)-222(like)-221(Mr.)-240(Mill's.)-240(The)-221(evidence)-221(that)-221(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(personal)-209(God)-209(exists)-210(has)-209(appeared)-209(irresistible)-209(to)-209(an)-209(overwhelming)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(majority)-280(of)-281(mankind,)-288(including)-280(a)-281(great)-280(majority)-281(of)-280(minds)-280(gifted)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-288(equal,)-298(and)-288(even)-288(with)-289(greater)-288(powers)-288(than)-288(that)-289(of)-288(Mr.)-364(Mill.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(One)-364(might)-364(imagine)-364(from)-364(the)-364(mode)-364(in)-364(which)-364(this)-364(point)-364(is)-363(here)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(represented,)-210(that)-199(the)-199(belief)-200(in)-199(the)-199(existence)-200(of)-199(a)-200(personal)-199(God)-199(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exploded)-225(among)-225(all)-225(men)-226(of)-225(intellect,)-230(and)-225(that)-225(the)-225(proofs)-225(adduced)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-218(it)-218(were)-218(unworthy)-218(of)-218(attention.)-239(Surely)-218(the)-218(question)-218(of)-217(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(has)-311(a)-310(legitimate)-311(place)-311(in)-311(the)-310(court)-311(which)-311(tries)-310(the)-311(issue)-311(of)-310(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth)-250(or)-250(falsehood.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(One)-420(more)-420(point)-420(requires)-420(notice.)-761(Hume)-420(says,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 211.979 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Though)-420(the)]TJ -228.778 -13.55 Td [(being,)-215(to)-207(whom)-207(the)-206(miracle)-207(is)-206(attributed)-207(be)-207(in)-206(this)-207(case)-206(Almighty,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-295(does)-295(not)-295(on)-295(that)-295(account)-295(become)-295(a)-295(whit)-295(more)-295(probable,)-306(since)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-242(is)-243(impossible)-242(for)-485(us)-242(to)-242(know)-243(the)-242(attributes)-242(or)-243(actions)-242(of)-242(such)-242(a)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([178])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(being,)-268(otherwise)-264(than)-265(from)-264(the)-265(experience)-264(which)-264(we)-265(have)-264(of)-264(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(productions)-250(in)-250(the)-250(usual)-250(course)-250(of)-250(nature.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 180.273 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -168.317 -15.186 Td [(This)-259(posit)1(ion)-259(involves)-259(an)-258(evident)-259(fallacy.)-275(It)-259(is)-258(also)-259(one)-258(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(underlies)-252(one)-253(or)-252(two)-253(of)-252(the)-253(statements)-252(of)-253(Mr.)-257(Mill,)-253(whose)-252(philo-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sophical)-353(theory)-352(of)-353(necessity)-352(was)-352(one)-353(almost)-352(certain)-353(to)-352(involve)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(him)-316(in)-317(it.)-449(The)-316(statement)-316(is,)-333(that)-317(it)-316(is)-316(impossible)-317(to)-316(know)-316(either)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-399(attributes)-399(or)-398(the)-399(actions)-399(of)-399(such)-398(a)-399(being,)-436(except)-399(from)-398(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(experience)-346(of)-345(his)-346(productions)-345(in)-346(the)-345(course)-346(of)-345(nature.)-537(What)-345(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-436(course)-436(of)-435(nature)-436(here)-436(intended?)-807(does)-436(it)-436(include)-436(mind)-435(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(well)-423(as)-422(matter?)-767(If)-423(the)-422(former)-423(is)-422(included,)-466(and)-422(we)-423(attain)-422(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(knowledge)-251(of)-251(God)-250(from)-251(that)-251(source)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 155.466 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(and)-251(every)-251(theist)-250(maintains)]TJ -166.375 -13.549 Td [(that)-384(our)-384(chief)-384(knowledge)-384(of)-384(God)-384(is)-384(derived)-384(from)-384(it)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 233.416 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(then)-384(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
747 0 obj <<
/Length 3377      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(159)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(experience)-420(we)-420(have)-420(of)-421(man)-420(leads)-420(us)-420(to)-420(infer)-420(the)-420(presence)-420(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-227(moral)-227(attributes)-227(in)-227(God;)-235(and)-227(there)-227(is)-227(nothing)-227(in)-227(that)-227(expe-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rience)-224(which)-223(renders)-224(the)-224(performance)-223(of)-224(a)-224(miracle)-223(inconceivable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-340(impossible)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 60.078 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(but)-340(as)-340(far)-340(as)-340(that)-340(experience)-341(is)-340(concerned,)-362(it)-340(is)]TJ -70.987 -13.55 Td [(rendered)-223(antecedently)-223(probable.)-241(What)-223(is)-223(included,)-229(I)-223(again)-223(ask,)-228(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature?)-241(Are)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 53.501 0 Td [(we)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.12 0 Td [(,)-227(the)-222(percipient)-222(beings)-221(ourselves?)-241(Whether)-222(we)-221(are)]TJ -65.621 -13.549 Td [(regarded)-313(as)-313(included)-313(or)-313(excluded)-313(from)-313(nature,)-329(it)-313(is)-313(evident)-313(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-285(considerable)-285(portion)-285(of)-285(our)-285(knowledge)-285(of)-285(the)-285(divine)-284(character)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-410(derived)-410(from)-410(the)-411(contemplation)-410(of)-410(our)-410(own)-410(being.)-730(God)-410(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(more)-310(manifested)-310(in)-311(our)-310(rationality,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 157.975 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(personality,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 51.208 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.227 0 Td [(freedom,)-325(and)]TJ -222.253 -13.549 Td [(conscience,)-370(than)-346(in)-346(the)-346(material)-346(forces)-346(and)-346(laws)-346(of)-346(nature.)-537(To)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(perform)-284(a)-284(miracle)-284(therefore)-285(is)-284(consistent)-284(with)-284(what)-284(we)-284(know)-284(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-250(character.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(These)-354(observations)-355(will)-354(render)-355(it)-354(unnecessary)-354(for)-355(me)-354(to)-354(ex-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(amine)-386(in)-386(detail)-387(the)-386(writer's)-386(observations)-386(on)-386(Paley's)-386(arguments)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(against)-174(Hume.)-225(Even)-174(if)-174(his)-175(arguments)-174(are)-174(not)-174(perfectly)-174(conclusive,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-385(failure)-385(does)-385(not)-386(establish)-770(the)-385(truth)-385(of)-385(Hume's)-385(positions,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([179])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(or)-323(invalidate)-323(the)-323(refutation)-323(of)-324(them)-323(by)-323(others.)-469(As)-323(the)-323(object)-323(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-257(author)-258(is)-257(to)-257(re-establish)-257(the)-258(validity)-257(of)-257(Hume's)-257(argument,)-259(he)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ought)-356(not)-356(to)-356(have)-356(confined)-356(himself)-357(to)-356(Paley,)-382(whose)-356(mind)-356(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(little)-247(adapted)-248(to)-247(the)-248(investigation)-247(of)-247(purely)-248(logical)-247(or)-247(metaphysi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cal)-264(questions,)-268(but)-264(to)-264(have)-264(noticed)-264(the)-264(argument)-264(of)-264(the)-264(numerous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subsequent)-250(writers)-250(who)-250(have)-250(more)-250(fully)-250(handled)-250(the)-250(subject.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 -29.651 Td [([180])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
757 0 obj <<
/Length 3048      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 93.543 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-257(VIII.)-258(The)-257(Objection)-258(That)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(The)-265(Defenders)-264(Of)-265(Christianity)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Assume)-252(Certain)-253(Facts)-252(The)-253(Truth)-252(Of)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Which)-261(Can)-262(Only)-261(Be)-262(Known)-261(By)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Revelation,)-252(And)-252(Then)-252(Reason)-252(From)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Those)-257(Facts)-257(To)-257(The)-257(Truth)-256(Of)-257(The)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Bible,)-250(Considered.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -34.54 Td [(It)-366(has)-367(been)-366(objected)-367(that)-366(the)-367(very)-366(idea)-367(of)-366(such)-367(a)-366(revelation)-366(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-269(of)-269(Christianity)-269(implies)-269(a)-269(defect)-269(on)-269(the)-269(part)-269(of)-269(the)-269(Creator)-268(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-318(original)-319(construction)-318(of)-319(the)-318(Universe,)-336(and)-318(that)-319(He)-318(has)-318(been)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(under)-310(the)-309(necessity)-310(of)-309(interposing)-309(for)-310(the)-309(purpose)-310(of)-309(correcting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-293(defect.)-380(It)-293(is)-294(affirmed)-293(that)-293(divines)-293(endeavour)-294(to)-293(prove)-293(that)-293(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(revelation)-278(was)-279(probable)-278(by)-278(first)-279(assuming)-278(a)-278(number)-279(of)-278(the)-278(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(irrational)-202(propositions,)-212(which,)-212(if)-203(true,)-212(can)-202(only)-203(be)-202(proved)-203(to)-202(be)-202(so)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-257(the)-257(authority)-258(of)-257(the)-257(Bible,)-259(and)-257(then)-258(arguing)-257(back)-257(again)-257(that)-257(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-206(highly)-207(probable)-206(that)-206(God)-206(would)-206(interfere)-207(to)-206(remedy)-206(the)-206(defects)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-231(his)-230(creative)-231(work)-231(by)-231(a)-230(supernatural)-231(revelation;)-237(in)-231(other)-230(words,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-223(they)-223(assume)-223(a)-222(state)-223(of)-223(things)-223(which)-223(reason)-223(would)-222(pronounce)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-263(be)-262(incredible,)-266(unless)-262(their)-263(truth)-263(was)-262(asserted)-263(in)-262(the)-263(Bible,)-265(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-334(argue)-334(on)-334(the)-334(principles)-334(of)-334(that)-334(reason)-334(whose)-334(validity)-333(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(deny,)-238(that)-235(it)-236(is)-235(probable)-235(that)-235(the)-236(Creator)-235(would)-235(interfere)-235(to)-235(reme-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dy)-268(a)-269(state)-268(of)-268(things)-269(the)-268(existence)-268(of)-269(which)-268(reason)-268(pronounces)-268(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-250(incredible.)]TJ 11.956 -13.973 Td [(The)-239(author)-238(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 61.735 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)-239(Religion)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 95.931 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.447 0 Td [(has)-239(strongly)-238(urged)-239(this)]TJ -181.913 -13.549 Td [(argument,)-312(and)-299(placed)-300(the)-299(difficulty)-300(clearly)-299(before)-300(us.)-398(Although)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
760 0 obj <<
/Length 4766      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(161)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(the)-233(entire)-233(passage)-233(is)-233(too)-233(long)-233(for)-465(quotation,)-237(yet)-233(as)-233(it)-233(is)-232(important)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([181])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(that)-237(we)-236(should)-237(have)-237(the)-236(question)-237(which)-236(he)-237(raises)-237(before)-236(us)-237(in)-236(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(own)-250(words,)-250(I)-250(will)-250(cite)-250(a)-250(portion)-250(of)-250(it.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -18.459 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Here)-393(again)-394(the)-393(argument)-394(is)-393(based)-393(on)-394(an)-393(assumption.)-681(The)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(supposition)-415(of)-414(a)-415(divine)-414(design)-415(in)-414(a)-414(revelation)-415(is)-414(the)-415(result)-414(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-383(foregone)-384(conclusion)-383(in)-384(its)-383(favour,)-417(and)-383(not)-384(suggested)-383(by)-383(an-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tecedent)-356(probability.)-566(Divines)-355(assume)-356(that)-355(a)-356(communication)-355(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-313(nature)-314(is)-313(in)-313(accordance)-313(with)-314(reason,)-329(and)-313(was)-313(necessary)-313(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-439(salvation)-439(of)-439(the)-439(human)-439(race)-439(simply)-439(because)-439(they)-439(believe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-339(it)-339(took)-339(place,)-361(and)-339(no)-339(evidence)-339(worthy)-339(of)-339(the)-339(name)-339(is)-339(ever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(offered)-314(in)-314(support)-314(of)-314(the)-313(assumption.)-442(A)-314(revelation)-314(having,)-330(it)-313(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supposed,)-339(been)-321(made,)-339(that)-321(revelation)-321(is)-321(consequently)-321(supposed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-257(have)-256(been)-257(contemplated,)-258(and)-257(to)-257(have)-256(justified)-257(any)-256(suspension)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-378(the)-378(order)-378(of)-378(nature.)-634(The)-378(proposition)-378(for)-378(which)-378(evidence)-377(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demanded)-370(is)-371(necessarily)-370(employed)-370(as)-370(evidence)-370(for)-371(itself.)-610(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(considerations)-341(involved)-341(in)-340(the)-341(assumption)-341(of)-341(the)-341(necessity)-340(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(reasonableness)-337(of)-336(such)-337(a)-336(revelation,)-359(however,)-358(are)-336(antecedently)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incredible)-313(and)-314(contrary)-313(to)-313(reason.)-440(We)-313(are)-314(asked)-313(to)-313(believe)-313(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God)-227(made)-227(man)-227(in)-227(His)-227(own)-227(image,)-231(pure)-227(and)-227(sinless,)-232(and)-226(intended)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(him)-349(to)-350(continue)-349(so;)-399(but)-350(scarcely)-349(had)-350(His)-349(noblest)-350(work)-349(left)-349(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hand)-241(of)-241(his)-240(Creator,)-243(than)-241(man)-241(was)-241(tempted)-240(into)-241(sin)-241(by)-241(Satan,)-242(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(all-powerful)-288(and)-288(persistent)-288(enemy)-288(of)-288(God,)-297(whose)-288(existence)-288(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(antagonism)-300(to)-300(a)-299(being)-300(in)-300(whose)-300(eyes)-300(sin)-300(is)-299(an)-300(abomination,)-312(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-229(accounted)-228(for)-229(and)-229(are)-229(incredible.)-243(Adam's)-228(fall)-229(brought)-229(a)-228(curse)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(upon)-411(the)-410(earth,)-451(and)-411(incurred)-410(the)-411(penalty)-411(of)-410(death)-411(for)-410(himself)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-285(for)-285(the)-284(whole)-285(of)-285(his)-285(posterity.)-354(The)-285(human)-285(race)-285(thus)-284(created)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(perfect)-219(and)-219(without)-219(sin,)-225(thus)-219(disappointed)-219(the)-219(expectations)-219(of)-219(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Creator,)-386(and)-359(became)-359(daily)-359(more)-359(wicked,)-386(the)-359(evil)-359(spirit)-358(having)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(succeeded)-219(in)-220(frustrating)-219(the)-219(designs)-220(of)-219(the)-219(Almighty,)-226(so)-219(that)-219(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(repented)-255(that)-255(he)-254(had)-255(made)-255(man,)-256(and)-255(at)-255(length)-254(he)-510(destroyed)-255(by)-254(a)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([182])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(deluge)-220(all)-219(the)-220(inhabitants)-220(of)-219(the)-220(earth,)-226(with)-219(the)-220(exception)-220(of)-219(eight)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(persons)-329(who)-329(feared)-329(him.)-486(This)-329(sweeping)-329(purification,)-348(however,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-366(as)-366(futile)-367(as)-366(the)-366(original)-366(design,)-395(and)-367(the)-366(race)-366(of)-366(man)-366(soon)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(became)-393(more)-393(wicked)-393(than)-393(ever.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 144.679 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.131 0 Td [(Here)-393(follows)-393(a)-393(statement)-393(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
765 0 obj <<
/Length 5032      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(162)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(what)-376(may)-375(be)-376(regarded)-376(as)-375(a)-376(plan)-375(of)-376(salvation)-376(as)-375(held)-376(by)-375(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modern)-342(Churches,)-365(and)-341(the)-342(apparent)-342(contradiction)-342(of)-342(the)-341(whole)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-226(the)-226(divine)-227(character)-226(and)-226(perfections)-226(is)-226(elaborately)-226(pointed)-226(out.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-332(then)-331(concludes)-332(as)-332(follows:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 138.963 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(We)-332(are)-331(asked)-332(to)-332(believe)-332(in)-331(the)]TJ -143.806 -13.55 Td [(frustration)-229(of)-230(the)-229(divine)-229(design)-230(of)-229(creation,)-234(and)-229(in)-229(the)-230(fall)-229(of)-229(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-197(a)-196(state)-197(of)-197(wickedness)-196(hateful)-197(to)-197(God,)-207(requiring)-197(and)-196(justifying)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-231(divine)-232(design)-231(of)-232(a)-231(revelation,)-235(and)-232(such)-231(a)-231(revelation)-232(as)-231(this,)-235(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-334(preliminary)-333(to)-334(the)-334(further)-334(proposition)-333(that)-334(on)-334(the)-333(supposition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-306(such)-306(a)-307(design)-306(miracles)-306(would)-306(not)-307(be)-306(contrary)-306(to)-306(reason.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 260.326 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.184 0 Td [(To)]TJ -268.51 -13.55 Td [(this)-237(follows)-236(an)-237(elaborate)-236(piece)-237(of)-236(reasoning,)-240(by)-236(which)-237(the)-236(author)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attempts)-262(to)-261(prove)-262(that)-261(every)-262(proposition)-261(in)-262(this)-261(so-called)-262(plan)-261(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(salvation)-250(is)-250(thoroughly)-250(contrary)-250(to)-250(reason.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-468(general)-467(positions)-468(laid)-467(down)-468(in)-467(this)-468(passage)-467(\050omitting)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(points)-228(of)-228(detail\051)-228(are)-228(as)-228(follows:)-239(Certain)-228(incredible)-228(occurrences)-228(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-244(past)-244(history)-244(of)-244(man)-244(are)-244(assumed)-244(by)-244(divines)-244(to)-244(be)-244(facts)-244(on)-244(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(authority)-184(of)-184(the)-184(Bible.)-228(These)-184(include)-184(the)-184(complete)-184(breaking)-184(down)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-248(the)-249(divine)-248(plan)-249(in)-248(the)-249(creation)-248(of)-248(man)-249(through)-248(the)-249(agency)-248(of)-248(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-229(who)-229(has)-229(frustrated)-229(the)-229(purposes)-229(of)-229(the)-229(Almighty.)-243(Next)-229(it)-228(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(asserted)-312(on)-312(the)-312(same)-311(authority)-312(that)-312(another)-312(series)-312(of)-312(events)-311(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taken)-326(place)-326(which)-326(are)-326(in)-326(the)-326(highest)-326(degree)-326(contrary)-326(to)-325(reason,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(for)-387(the)-387(purpose)-386(of)-387(remedying)-387(this)-386(failure)-387(of)-387(the)-387(original)-386(plan.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Then)-260(it)-261(is)-260(alleged)-261(that)-260(the)-261(probability)-260(of)-261(a)-260(divine)-260(interference,)-263(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-263(to)-264(remedy)-263(a)-263(state)-264(of)-263(things)-263(which)-264(reason)-263(pronounces)-263(to)-263(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incredible,)-342(is)-324(argued)-324(on)-324(the)-324(authority)-324(of)-324(reason)-324(for)-324(the)-323(purpose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-429(proving)-428(the)-857(occurrence)-429(of)-428(another)-429(state)-428(of)-429(things)-428(equally)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([183])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(repugnant)-218(to)-219(reason.)-239(Such)-219(a)-218(line)-218(of)-219(argument)-218(is)-219(affirmed)-218(to)-218(begin)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(irrational)-250(assumptions,)-250(and)-250(to)-250(terminate)-250(in)-250(a)-250(vicious)-250(circle.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-347(have)-347(before)-346(observed)-347(that)-347(the)-347(work)-347(from)-347(which)-347(the)-346(above)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(passage)-251(is)-250(taken,)-251(although)-251(entitled)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 152.142 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)-251(Religion,)-250(or)-251(an)]TJ -156.986 -13.549 Td [(inquiry)-264(into)-265(the)-264(reality)-265(of)-264(Divine)-265(Revelation,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 195.782 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.728 0 Td [(is)-264(really)-265(an)-264(attack)]TJ -203.51 -13.549 Td [(on)-467(the)-467(central)-466(position)-467(of)-467(the)-467(New)-467(Testament,)-521(the)-466(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(value)-424(of)-424(the)-424(Gospels.)-773(In)-424(taking)-424(this)-424(course)-424(the)-424(author)-424(raises)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(an)-353(intelligible)-352(issue)-353(i)1(nstead)-353(of)-352(spreading)-353(the)-352(argument)-353(over)-352(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(endless)-315(mass)-315(of)-314(controversial)-315(matter.)-444(If)-315(the)-315(historical)-314(character)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
769 0 obj <<
/Length 4614      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(163)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(of)-214(the)-214(Gospels)-214(cannot)-213(be)-214(maintained,)-221(the)-214(whole)-214(controversy)-214(as)-213(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whether)-296(Christianity)-296(is)-296(a)-295(divine)-296(revelation)-296(is)-296(ended.)-388(This)-295(forms)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-413(key)-414(of)-413(the)-413(Christian)-414(position,)-454(to)-413(which)-413(the)-414(other)-413(parts)-413(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-369(controversy)-368(stand)-369(in)-369(the)-368(relation)-369(of)-368(mere)-369(outworks.)-606(If)-368(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(events)-321(recorded)-322(in)-321(the)-321(Gospels)-322(are)-321(historical,)-339(Christianity)-321(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-218(a)-218(divine)-218(revelation,)-225(notwithstanding)-218(the)-218(difficulties)-218(connected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-308(certain)-309(statements)-308(of)-309(the)-308(Old)-308(Testament.)-425(The)-309(real)-308(point)-308(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(issue)-323(between)-323(those)-323(who)-322(believe)-323(and)-323(those)-323(who)-323(deny)-323(that)-322(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-237(made)-236(a)-237(supernatural)-236(revelation)-237(of)-236(Himself,)-240(is)-236(confined)-237(to)-236(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(following)-288(question:)-325(Are)-287(the)-288(cont)1(ents)-288(of)-287(the)-288(Gospels)-287(historically)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(credible?)-641(Is)-380(the)-380(character)-381(of)-380(Jesus)-380(Christ)-381(as)-380(depicted)-380(in)-380(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-262(delineation)-262(of)-262(an)-261(ideal)-262(conception)-262(or)-262(of)-262(an)-262(historical)-261(reality?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-344(author)-344(discerns)-344(clearly)-343(that)-344(this)-344(is)-344(the)-344(turning)-344(point)-344(of)-343(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(controversy,)-225(and)-219(has)-219(accordingly)-219(addressed)-219(himself)-219(to)-219(prove)-218(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-331(Gospels)-332(are)-331(valueless)-331(as)-332(historical)-331(documents.)-494(This)-331(line)-331(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(argument)-331(is)-331(candid,)-351(and)-331(one)-331(which,)-351(if)-331(adhered)-331(to,)-352(will)-330(save)-331(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(immense)-250(expenditure)-250(of)-250(reasoning)-250(power.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Now)-269(the)-269(question)-269(of)-268(the)-269(historical)-269(character)-269(of)-269(the)-269(Gospels)-268(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(quite)-301(distinct)-302(from)-301(that)-301(of)-301(the)-302(truth)-301(or)-301(falsehood)-603(of)-301(any)-301(system)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([184])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(of)-256(Ecclesiastical)-257(Christianity,)-258(which)-256(asserts)-257(that)-256(its)-257(theology)-256(is)-256(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(deduction)-345(from)-345(the)-345(Gospels)-345(and)-345(the)-345(other)-345(portions)-345(of)-345(the)-345(New)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Testament.)-341(It)-280(is)-281(not)-280(revelation)-280(itself)-281(but)-280(a)-280(system)-281(erected)-280(by)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(application)-263(of)-264(reason)-263(to)-263(the)-263(facts)-264(of)-263(revelation.)-290(It)-263(is)-263(most)-263(impor-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tant)-240(that)-240(this)-241(distinction)-240(should)-240(be)-240(kept)-240(in)-240(view.)-247(The)-240(truth)-240(is,)-242(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-314(facts)-313(of)-314(revelation)-314(stand)-313(in)-314(the)-314(same)-313(relation)-314(to)-314(theology)-313(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-327(facts)-326(of)-327(nature)-326(do)-327(to)-327(physical)-326(science.)-480(Incorrect)-326(reasonings)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(respecting)-392(both)-392(the)-391(one)-392(and)-392(the)-392(other)-392(are)-391(alike)-392(possible.)-675(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Ptolemaic)-431(theory)-432(was)-431(propounded)-431(as)-432(an)-431(adequate)-431(solution)-431(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-365(facts)-365(and)-365(phenomena)-364(of)-365(the)-365(universe,)-394(and)-365(although)-364(utterly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incorrect)-262(in)-262(all)-261(its)-262(parts,)-265(it)-262(for)-262(ages)-261(held)-262(unlimited)-262(sway)-262(over)-261(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(human)-387(mind.)-661(In)-387(a)-387(similar)-387(manner)-387(various)-387(theories)-387(have)-386(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(propounded)-329(as)-330(solutions)-329(of)-330(the)-329(facts)-330(of)-329(revelation,)-349(but)-330(it)-329(by)-329(no)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(means)-432(follows)-432(because)-431(they)-432(have)-432(attained)-432(a)-432(wide)-431(acceptance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-259(they)-259(afford)-259(the)-259(true)-259(solution.)-277(In)-259(examining)-259(the)-259(claims)-259(of)-258(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
773 0 obj <<
/Length 4722      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(164)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Gospels)-198(to)-199(be)-198(viewed)-198(as)-199(historical,)-208(it)-199(is)-198(quite)-198(as)-199(much)-198(out)-198(of)-198(place)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-198(make)-199(them)-198(responsible)-198(for)-198(all)-199(the)-198(theories)-198(which)-198(Ecclesiastical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity)-288(has)-287(propounded)-288(respecting)-288(the)-287(plan)-288(of)-287(salvation,)-297(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-379(would)-380(be)-379(to)-380(make)-379(the)-379(facts)-380(and)-379(phenomena)-380(of)-379(the)-379(universe)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(answerable)-459(for)-460(all)-459(the)-460(theories)-459(which)-460(have)-459(been)-459(propounded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-401(their)-401(solution.)-702(In)-401(examining)-401(the)-400(claims)-401(of)-401(the)-401(Gospels)-400(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-323(accepted)-322(as)-323(historical)-323(documents,)-341(it)-322(is)-323(most)-323(unreasonable)-322(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(make)-327(them)-328(responsible)-327(for)-327(theories)-328(which)-327(were)-327(not)-327(formulated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(the)-250(Church)-250(until)-250(centuries)-250(after)-250(their)-250(publication.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Most)-208(of)-207(the)-208(positions)-207(affirmed)-208(in)-207(the)-208(above)-207(quotation)-208(were)-207(not)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(formulated)-295(until)-294(a)-295(late)-295(period)-294(of)-295(the)-295(Church's)-294(history.)-384(Certainly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-267(are)-267(nowhere)-267(directly)-267(laid)-266(down)-267(in)-267(the)-267(New)-267(Testament.)-300(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(utmost)-262(which)-262(can)-262(be)-262(asserted)-261(of)-262(them)-262(is,)-265(that)-262(they)-262(are)-262(alleged)-261(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-248(derived)-247(inferentially)-248(from)-248(its)-247(teaching.)-250(They)-495(form)-248(no)-247(portion)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([185])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(of)-256(the)-257(Apostles')-256(or)-257(of)-256(the)-256(Nicene)-257(Creeds,)-258(which)-256(are)-257(the)-256(only)-256(for-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mularies)-211(outside)-211(of)-211(the)-210(New)-211(Testament)-211(which)-211(can)-211(be)-210(represented)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-224(embodying)-224(the)-224(creed)-224(of)-224(the)-224(universal)-223(Church.)-242(Nor)-224(can)-224(they)-223(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(found)-285(even)-286(in)-285(the)-285(Athanasian)-285(creed.)-356(In)-286(discussing)-285(the)-285(claims)-285(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-275(Gospels)-276(to)-275(be)-275(esteemed)-275(as)-276(historical,)-281(they)-276(can)-275(only)-275(be)-275(made)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fairly)-321(responsible)-321(for)-322(what)-321(they)-321(actually)-321(contain.)-464(To)-321(bring)-321(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-278(a)-279(controversy)-278(positions)-279(only)-278(affirmed)-278(in)-279(recent)-278(attempts)-278(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(formulate)-313(a)-313(body)-313(of)-313(Christian)-312(doctrine,)-329(as)-313(though)-313(they)-313(had)-312(any)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(bearing)-395(on)-394(the)-395(claims)-394(of)-395(the)-395(New)-394(Testament)-395(to)-394(be)-395(viewed)-394(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(containing)-250(a)-250(divine)-250(revelation,)-250(can)-250(lead)-250(to)-250(no)-250(satisfactory)-250(result.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-447(now)-446(return)-447(to)-447(the)-447(consideration)-447(of)-447(the)-447(difficulties)-446(above)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(referred)-300(to.)-401(It)-300(is)-301(i)1(mportant)-301(to)-300(take)-300(a)-300(careful)-301(survey)-300(of)-300(the)-300(entire)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question,)-368(because)-345(they)-344(are)-344(not)-345(only)-344(put)-345(with)-344(great)-345(force)-344(in)-344(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(passage)-220(which)-220(I)-220(have)-219(quoted,)-226(but)-220(I)-220(believe)-220(that)-220(in)-220(different)-219(forms)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-259(weigh)-259(heavily)-258(on)-259(the)-259(minds)-259(of)-259(many)-258(thoughtful)-259(men.)-277(I)-258(will)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(first)-250(offer)-250(a)-250(few)-250(observations)-250(on)-250(the)-250(general)-250(principle.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Nothing)-258(is)-257(easier)-258(than)-257(to)-258(affirm)-257(that)-258(the)-257(introduction)-258(of)-257(moral)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(evil)-393(into)-393(the)-392(universe)-393(is)-393(a)-393(marring)-393(of)-392(the)-393(Creator's)-393(plan)-393(in)-392(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(formation.)-448(The)-316(argument)-316(is)-316(founded)-316(on)-316(the)-316(supposition)-316(that)-316(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Almighty)-386(God)-387(exists,)-420(who)-387(is)-386(wise,)-421(holy,)-420(and)-387(benevolent,)-420(and)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
777 0 obj <<
/Length 4682      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(165)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(who)-396(intended)-397(to)-396(manifest)-397(these)-396(attributes)-397(through)-396(the)-396(rational)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beings)-289(which)-289(he)-289(has)-289(created.)-368(It)-289(is)-289(affirmed)-289(that)-289(the)-289(existence)-289(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-260(evil)-261(in)-260(man)-260(is)-261(a)-260(failure)-260(of)-261(this)-260(purpose)-260(on)-261(the)-260(part)-260(of)-260(God.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(But)-355(it)-355(is)-355(the)-355(most)-355(certain)-355(of)-355(facts)-355(that)-355(moral)-355(evil)-355(does)-355(exist)-354(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-295(world,)-307(and)-295(that)-296(it)-295(exists)-295(quite)-296(independently)-295(of)-295(Christianity.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-421(objection)-420(therefore)-421(is)-420(not)-420(one)-421(directed)-420(solely)-421(against)-420(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity)-287(of)-286(the)-287(New)-286(Testament,)-296(but)-287(bears)-286(with)-287(equal)-286(weight)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(against)-242(every)-242(form)-242(of)-242(theism,)-244(which)-242(admits)-242(that)-242(the)-242(universe)-242(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-284(created,)-292(and)-568(is)-284(governed)-284(by)-284(a)-284(God)-283(who)-284(is)-284(almighty,)-292(wise,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([186])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(holy,)-250(and)-250(benevolent.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(If)-226(there)-225(be)-226(a)-225(God)-226(who)-225(is)-226(the)-225(Creator)-226(of)-225(the)-226(Universe,)-230(it)-226(is)-225(clear)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(that)-285(He)-284(must)-285(have)-284(been)-285(the)-284(Creator)-285(of)-285(man,)-293(and)-284(that)-285(man)-284(could)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-191(have)-191(come)-191(into)-191(being)-191(in)-191(conformity)-191(with)-191(His)-191(pleasure.)-230(Now,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-271(we)-270(decline)-270(to)-271(admit)-270(that)-271(man)-270(was)-271(created)-270(morally)-271(perfect,)-275(yet)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-326(he)-326(must)-326(have)-326(been)-327(created)-326(a)-326(moral)-326(agent,)-345(it)-326(is)-326(clear)-326(that)-326(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first)-445(man)-445(must)-445(have)-444(sprung)-445(into)-445(being)-445(either)-445(with)-445(the)-444(moral)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(faculties)-251(of)-251(a)-250(savage,)-251(or)-251(in)-251(some)-251(intermediate)-251(condition)-250(between)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-311(and)-310(a)-311(state)-311(of)-310(moral)-311(perfection.)-432(It)-311(follows,)-326(therefore,)-325(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-359(must)-360(have)-359(been)-360(made)-359(capable)-359(of)-360(moral)-359(progress.)-578(This)-359(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirmed)-302(by)-301(all)-302(those)-301(who)-302(assert)-301(that)-302(he)-301(was)-302(first)-301(produced)-302(in)-301(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(savage)-276(state.)-326(But)-276(the)-276(possibility)-275(of)-276(moral)-275(progress)-276(involves)-275(also)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-236(possibility)-235(of)-235(retrogression.)-246(The)-235(truth)-236(of)-235(this)-236(is)-235(borne)-235(witness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-362(by)-361(the)-362(most)-362(palpable)-361(facts)-362(of)-362(daily)-361(experience.)-585(Men)-362(of)-361(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(highest)-278(mental)-279(powers)-278(are)-279(capable)-278(of)-279(abusing)-278(them)-279(to)-278(the)-278(worst)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purposes,)-373(and)-348(thus)-348(of)-348(sinking)-348(fearfully)-348(low)-348(in)-348(the)-348(moral)-348(scale.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-379(case)-379(of)-379(a)-379(man)-379(like)-379(Fouch\351)-379(will)-378(illustrate)-379(my)-379(argument,)-411(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-286(gifted)-285(with)-286(high)-285(intellectual)-286(powers,)-294(but)-286(who)-285(sunk)-286(into)-285(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(lowest)-217(condition)-217(of)-218(moral)-217(turpitude.)-239(Such)-217(a)-217(man)-217(is)-217(incomparably)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(worse)-405(than)-405(the)-406(first)-405(original)-405(savage.)-715(I)-406(submit,)-443(therefore,)-444(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whatever)-294(view)-293(we)-294(may)-293(take)-294(of)-294(the)-293(condition)-294(in)-293(which)-294(man)-293(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(originally)-297(created,)-309(even)-296(if)-297(he)-297(were)-297(created)-297(a)-297(savage,)-309(yet)-297(he)-296(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-406(a)-406(moral)-406(being)-405(capable)-406(of)-406(elevation)-406(or)-406(degradation;)-483(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that,)-306(to)-295(use)-295(a)-295(human)-294(metaphor,)-306(the)-295(purpose)-295(of)-295(a)-295(holy)-295(God)-294(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-308(been)-308(his)-308(elevation.)-425(Yet)-308(this)-308(involves)-308(the)-308(possibility)-308(of)-308(his)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
782 0 obj <<
/Length 4827      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(166)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(moral)-313(degradation.)-437(This)-313(degradation)-312(has)-313(also)-313(become)-312(a)-313(fact.)-437(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-277(clear,)-284(therefore,)-284(that)-277(the)-278(difficulty)-277(is)-277(one)-277(which)-277(is)-277(inseparable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-270(every)-269(possible)-270(form)-269(of)-270(theistic)-269(belief,)-275(and)-269(is)-270(no)-269(peculiarity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(Christianity.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([187])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -16.004 Td [(I)-326(shall)-325(not)-326(attempt)-326(to)-325(enter)-326(on)-326(so)-326(profound)-325(a)-326(question)-326(as)-325(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(origin)-220(of)-219(evil,)-226(and)-220(how)-219(its)-220(existence)-220(is)-219(consistent)-220(with)-220(the)-219(perfec-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-291(of)-291(a)-291(holy)-291(God.)-374(It)-291(is)-291(a)-291(subject)-291(quite)-291(beyond)-291(the)-291(issue)-291(before)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us,)-274(and)-270(lies)-269(not)-270(at)-269(the)-270(foundations)-270(of)-269(Christianity,)-274(but)-270(of)-269(theism,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-344(truth)-344(of)-344(which)-344(is)-344(taken)-344(for)-344(granted)-344(in)-344(the)-344(objections)-343(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-427(author)-426(adduces)-427(against)-427(the)-427(popular)-426(view)-427(of)-427(the)-426(scriptural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(account;)-282(for)-271(if)-271(there)-271(is)-271(no)-271(God)-270(the)-271(objections)-271(are)-271(valueless.)-313(Still)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-253(ought)-252(to)-253(have)-253(informed)-252(his)-253(readers)-253(that)-252(it)-253(is)-253(urged)-252(as)-253(a)-252(partial)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(explanation)-233(of)-234(those)-233(difficulties)-233(by)-234(the)-233(defenders)-233(of)-233(Christianity,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-470(it)-470(is)-470(highly)-471(probable)-470(that)-470(the)-470(creation)-470(of)-470(a)-470(moral)-470(being)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessed)-211(of)-210(free)-211(agency,)-218(but)-211(who)-211(at)-210(the)-211(same)-211(time)-210(is)-211(not)-210(capable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-300(sinking)-300(into)-300(a)-300(state)-300(of)-299(moral)-300(degradation,)-313(involves)-300(as)-300(great)-299(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contradiction)-266(as)-266(the)-267(conception)-266(of)-266(a)-266(circle)-266(which)-266(should)-266(possess)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-262(property)-262(of)-262(concavity)-263(and)-262(not)-262(of)-262(convexity.)-286(No)-262(rational)-262(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believes)-330(that)-330(it)-329(is)-330(within)-330(the)-330(compass,)-349(even)-330(of)-330(omnipotence,)-349(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(work)-300(contradictions.)-400(If)-300(this)-300(be)-301(so,)-312(it)-300(follows)-300(that)-300(the)-300(possibility)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-405(the)-404(existence)-405(of)-405(moral)-404(evil)-405(is)-405(a)-404(necessary)-405(condition)-405(of)-404(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-318(of)-318(free)-318(agency.)-454(The)-318(production)-318(of)-318(a)-318(free)-318(moral)-318(agent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(capable)-395(of)-394(yielding)-395(a)-394(willing)-394(obedience)-395(to)-394(the)-395(moral)-394(law)-395(is)-394(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more)-257(glorious)-256(work)-257(than)-257(anything)-256(in)-257(the)-257(material)-256(universe,)-258(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-275(that)-275(universe)-275(itself.)-325(It)-275(might,)-281(therefore,)-281(have)-275(been)-275(the)-275(good)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pleasure)-267(of)-267(the)-266(wise,)-271(holy,)-271(and)-267(benevolent)-267(Creator)-267(to)-267(create)-266(free)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(moral)-216(agents,)-222(even)-216(if)-215(it)-216(involved)-216(the)-215(existence)-216(of)-216(moral)-215(evil.)-239(I)-215(am)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(far)-192(from)-192(propounding)-192(this)-193(as)-192(a)-192(complete)-192(solution)-192(of)-192(the)-192(difficulty,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-196(when)-197(it)-196(is)-196(thus)-196(used)-197(unsparingly)-196(against)-196(Christianity,)-207(it)-196(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-329(been)-330(only)-329(candid)-329(to)-329(have)-330(told)-329(the)-329(reader)-330(that)-329(it)-329(bore)-329(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(equal)-230(weight)-230(against)-230(every)-230(form)-230(of)-230(theism,)-234(and)-230(to)-230(have)-230(given)-230(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(partial)-250(explanation)-250(which)-250(has)-250(been)-250(propounded)-250(by)-250(theologians.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(In)-400(reply)-400(to)-400(the)-400(definite)-401(statements)-400(before)-400(us,)-437(I)-800(affirm)-400(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([188])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(nowhere)-257(in)-258(the)-257(Gospels,)-259(or)-258(in)-257(any)-258(other)-257(portion)-257(of)-258(the)-257(New)-257(Tes-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
787 0 obj <<
/Length 4934      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(167)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(tament)-223(is)-223(it)-223(asserted)-223(or)-223(even)-223(implied)-223(that)-223(revelation)-223(was)-222(rendered)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary)-264(by)-265(the)-264(frustration)-264(of)-264(the)-265(divine)-264(purpose)-264(in)-265(creation,)-267(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-182(redemption)-183(was)-182(a)-182(kind)-183(of)-182(afterthought)-182(in)-183(the)-182(divine)-182(mind)-182(ren-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dered)-278(necessary)-278(by)-278(such)-278(a)-278(failure.)-334(On)-278(the)-278(contrary,)-285(the)-277(synoptic)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Gospels)-204(make)-204(no)-205(affirmation)-204(whatever)-204(on)-204(the)-205(subject.)-234(The)-204(fourth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospel)-327(contains)-327(several)-328(statements)-327(about)-327(the)-327(end)-327(and)-327(purposes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-431(the)-431(Incarnation,)-476(but)-431(of)-431(a)-431(description)-431(totally)-431(different)-430(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-301(which)-300(are)-301(alleged)-300(in)-301(the)-300(above)-301(quotation)-300(to)-301(constitute)-300(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(groundwork)-200(of)-199(Christianity.)-233(As)-200(I)-199(have)-200(already)-199(shown,)-210(the)-199(Gospel)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-210(St.)-237(John)-210(speaks)-210(of)-210(its)-210(great)-210(purpose)-210(as)-210(being)-210(a)-210(revelation)-209(of)-210(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-262(character)-262(of)-263(God)-262(in)-262(the)-262(person)-262(of)-263(Jesus)-262(Christ.)-286(According)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-315(its)-316(theology)-315(God)-316(has)-315(already)-315(manifested)-316(himself)-315(in)-315(creation;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-323(the)-323(Gospel)-322(He)-323(makes)-323(a)-323(stil)1(l)-323(higher)-323(and)-323(nobler)-322(manifestation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-288(His)-289(moral)-288(character)-288(in)-289(the)-288(person)-288(of)-289(our)-288(Lord.)-365(The)-288(author)-288(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-366(first)-365(Epistle)-366(ascribed)-365(to)-366(St.)-596(John,)-395(whom)-365(I)-365(must)-366(assume)-365(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-308(been)-307(the)-308(author)-307(of)-308(the)-308(Gospel,)-322(makes)-307(the)-308(following)-307(direct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirmation)-247(on)-248(the)-247(subject.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 117.768 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(That)-247(which)-248(was)-247(from)-248(the)-247(beginning,)]TJ -122.612 -13.549 Td [(which)-263(we)-263(have)-263(heard,)-266(which)-263(we)-263(have)-263(seen)-263(with)-262(our)-263(eyes,)-266(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-310(have)-310(looked)-310(upon,)-325(and)-310(our)-310(hands)-310(have)-310(handled)-310(of)-310(the)-309(word)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-392(life;)-462(for)-392(the)-391(life)-392(was)-392(manifested,)-427(and)-391(we)-392(have)-392(seen)-391(it,)-427(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bear)-235(witness,)-238(and)-235(show)-236(unto)-235(you)-235(that)-235(eternal)-235(life)-235(which)-235(was)-235(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-258(Father)-258(and)-258(was)-257(manifested)-258(unto)-258(us;)-262(that)-258(which)-258(we)-258(have)-257(seen)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-235(heard)-236(declare)-235(we)-235(unto)-236(you,)-238(that)-235(ye)-236(also)-235(may)-235(have)-235(fellowship)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-272(us:)-293(and)-271(truly)-272(our)-271(fellowship)-272(is)-272(with)-271(the)-272(Father)-271(and)-272(with)-271(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Son)-276(Jesus)-275(Christ.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 75.415 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.849 0 Td [(In)-275(these)-276(words)-275(it)-276(is)-275(evidently)-276(the)-275(intention)-276(of)]TJ -83.264 -13.549 Td [(the)-340(writer)-341(to)-340(set)-340(forth)-340(the)-341(divine)-340(purpose)-340(of)-340(the)-341(Incarnation.)-520(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-374(true)-375(that)-374(in)-374(other)-375(passages)-374(he)-374(assumes)-375(the)-374(existence)-374(of)-374(evil)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-420(the)-421(universe,)-463(and)-840(declares)-420(it)-421(to)-420(be)-420(the)-421(work)-420(of)-420(the)-420(devil,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([189])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(and)-273(that)-273(one)-273(of)-273(the)-274(purposes)-273(of)-273(this)-273(divine)-273(manifestation)-273(was)-273(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(destruction.)-321(Still)-274(he)-274(drops)-274(no)-274(hint)-273(of)-274(any)-274(failure)-274(in)-274(the)-273(Creation,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(or)-334(that)-334(it)-334(was)-334(the)-334(purpose)-334(of)-334(the)-334(Incarnation)-334(to)-333(mend)-334(a)-334(marred)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(scheme.)-421(On)-307(the)-307(contrary,)-322(the)-307(great)-307(truth)-307(set)-307(forth)-307(in)-307(the)-307(Epistle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-228(in)-228(the)-228(Gospel)-229(is)-228(that)-228(Creation)-228(and)-228(Redemption)-228(form)-228(portions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-322(one)-321(great)-322(whole;)-357(and)-322(that)-322(the)-321(latter)-322(is)-321(a)-322(manifestation)-322(of)-321(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
791 0 obj <<
/Length 5319      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(168)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(divine)-273(glories)-272(beyond)-273(God's)-272(previous)-272(manifestations)-273(of)-272(himself,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whether)-250(in)-250(creation)-250(or)-250(in)-250(history.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Similar)-284(are)-284(the)-284(views)-284(of)-284(the)-284(Apostle)-284(Paul.)-352(According)-284(to)-284(him,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(while)-435(many)-435(other)-436(purposes)-435(were)-435(effected)-435(by)-435(the)-435(Incarnation,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(there)-275(is)-276(one)-275(great)-276(purpose)-275(running)-275(through)-276(all)-275(divine)-275(revelation.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(In)-312(several)-312(passages)-312(he)-312(affirms)-312(that)-312(its)-312(influence)-312(extends)-312(far)-312(be-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(yond)-246(that)-246(which)-246(it)-247(exerts)-246(on)-246(the)-246(race)-246(of)-246(man.)-249(He)-246(again)-246(and)-246(again)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(asserts)-354(that)-354(it)-354(was)-355(the)-354(gradual)-354(unfolding)-354(of)-354(an)-354(idea)-354(or)-354(purpose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-290(existed)-289(from)-290(eternity)-290(in)-290(the)-289(divine)-290(mind.)-369(Thus)-290(he)-289(writes:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(And)-274(to)-273(make)-274(all)-273(men)-274(see)-274(what)-273(is)-274(the)-274(fellowship)-273(of)-274(the)-273(mystery)]TJ -4.844 -13.55 Td [(which)-394(from)-395(the)-394(beginning)-395(of)-394(the)-394(world)-395(hath)-394(been)-395(hid)-394(in)-394(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-394(created)-393(all)-394(things)-393(by)-394(Jesus)-393(Christ,)-429(to)-394(the)-393(intent)-394(that)-393(now)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unto)-334(the)-334(principalities)-334(and)-334(powers)-334(in)-334(heavenly)-334(places)-334(might)-333(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(known)-231(by)-230(the)-231(Church)-231(the)-230(manifold)-231(wisdom)-231(of)-230(God,)-235(according)-230(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-226(eternal)-225(purpose)-226(which)-226(he)-225(purposed)-226(in)-226(Christ)-225(Jesus)-226(our)-225(Lord.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 275.786 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.55 Td [(\050Eph.)-545(iii.)-545(and)-348(ix.\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 87.995 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Having)-348(made)-349(known)-348(to)-348(us)-349(the)-348(mystery)-348(of)]TJ -92.839 -13.549 Td [(His)-277(will,)-284(according)-277(to)-277(His)-277(good)-277(pleasure,)-283(which)-277(He)-277(purposed)-277(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Himself,)-221(that)-215(in)-214(the)-214(dispensation)-215(of)-214(the)-214(fulness)-215(of)-214(times)-214(He)-214(might)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gather)-298(in)-298(one)-298(all)-298(things)-298(in)-298(Christ,)-310(both)-298(which)-298(are)-298(in)-298(heaven)-298(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-259(earth,)-262(even)-260(in)-259(Him.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 95.576 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.673 0 Td [(\050Eph.)-278(i.)-279(9,)-261(10.\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 67.109 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(And)-259(having)-260(made)-259(peace)]TJ -175.202 -13.55 Td [(by)-352(the)-353(blood)-352(of)-352(His)-353(cross,)-378(by)-352(Him)-352(to)-353(reconcile)-352(all)-352(things)-352(unto)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Himself:)-235(by)-221(Him,)-226(I)-221(say,)-226(whether)-221(they)-220(be)-221(things)-441(in)-220(earth)-221(or)-220(things)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([190])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(in)-206(heaven.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 44.357 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.092 0 Td [(\050Col.)-235(i.)-236(20.\051)-235(I)-206(fully)-206(admit)-206(that)-206(the)-206(Apostle)-206(affirms)-206(that)]TJ -51.449 -13.549 Td [(the)-241(design)-241(of)-241(bringing)-241(man)-241(into)-241(union)-241(with)-241(God)-241(was)-241(a)-241(portion)-241(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-232(purpose.)-244(Nothing)-231(however)-232(is)-232(more)-231(foreign)-232(to)-231(the)-232(ideas)-232(of)-231(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Paul)-278(than)-279(that)-278(revelation)-279(is)-278(an)-279(afterthought)-278(adopted)-279(as)-278(a)-278(remedy)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(for)-250(a)-250(marred)-250(plan.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(Nor)-300(are)-300(the)-300(views)-301(of)-300(the)-300(other)-300(writers)-300(of)-300(the)-300(New)-301(Testament)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(different.)-612(St.)-612(Peter)-370(tells)-371(us)-371(that)-370(the)-371(angels)-371(desire)-370(to)-371(look)-370(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-374(redemption)-374(wrought)-375(by)-374(Christ.)-622(St.)-623(James)-374(assures)-374(us)-374(that,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(known)-314(unto)-313(God)-314(are)-314(all)-313(His)-314(works)-314(from)-313(the)-314(foundation)-314(of)-313(the)]TJ -4.844 -13.549 Td [(world.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 28.178 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.349 0 Td [(The)-321(author)-322(of)-321(the)-321(Epistle)-322(to)-321(the)-321(Hebrews)-322(speaks)-321(to)-321(the)]TJ -36.527 -13.55 Td [(same)-322(effect:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 58.098 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(God,)-340(who)-322(at)-323(sundry)-322(times)-322(and)-322(in)-323(divers)-322(manners)]TJ -62.942 -13.549 Td [(spake)-275(in)-276(times)-275(past)-275(unto)-276(the)-275(fathers)-275(in)-276(\050by\051)-275(the)-275(prophets,)-282(hath)-275(in)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
795 0 obj <<
/Length 4921      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(169)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(these)-250(last)-251(days)-250(spoken)-250(unto)-250(us)-251(in)-250(His)-250(Son.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 182.75 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.574 0 Td [(So)-250(far)-251(from)-250(its)-250(being)]TJ -190.324 -13.549 Td [(the)-290(idea)-289(of)-290(the)-290(sacred)-289(writers)-290(that)-290(redemption)-289(is)-290(an)-289(afterthought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(designed)-192(to)-193(remedy)-192(the)-193(failure)-192(of)-193(the)-192(original)-193(purpose)-192(of)-192(creation,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-339(both)-340(of)-339(them)-340(are)-339(viewed)-339(as)-340(parts)-339(of)-340(the)-339(same)-339(whole;)-384(both)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-339(purposes)-340(which)-339(have)-340(existed)-339(in)-340(the)-339(divine)-340(mind)-339(during)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eternal)-293(ages,)-303(and)-293(have)-292(been)-293(gradually)-292(evolved)-293(in)-293(time.)-377(Nothing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-209(further)-208(from)-209(their)-209(mind)-209(than)-208(that)-209(the)-209(divine)-208(mode)-209(of)-209(working)-208(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-282(fits)-282(or)-281(starts,)-290(or)-282(sudden)-282(interventions.)-345(Man)-282(was)-282(the)-282(last)-281(form)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-211(li)1(fe)-211(which)-210(God)-211(has)-210(introduced)-211(into)-210(the)-211(world,)-218(and)-211(in)-210(that)-210(sense)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(He)-364(is)-363(said)-364(to)-363(have)-364(rested)-363(from)-364(His)-363(creative)-364(work.)-590(But)-364(God)-363(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-248(less)-248(distinctly)-248(affirmed)-248(to)-248(be)-248(always)-248(working)-248(in)-248(nature)-248(and)-247(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(providence,)-235(so)-230(that)-231(Sabbath)-231(days)-230(form)-231(no)-230(exception:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 230.245 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(My)-231(Father)]TJ -235.089 -13.549 Td [(worketh)-250(hitherto)-250(and)-250(I)-250(work.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 125.127 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -113.171 -18.459 Td [(Such)-391(being)-391(the)-391(views)-391(of)-391(the)-391(writers)-391(of)-391(the)-391(New)-391(Testament)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(on)-291(this)-290(subject,)-301(the)-290(whole)-291(of)-290(those)-291(objections,)-300(as)-291(far)-290(as)-291(they)-290(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(founded)-206(on)-206(the)-206(assertion)-207(that)-206(revelation)-206(is)-206(intended)-206(to)-206(remedy)-206(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(failure)-268(of)-267(God's)-268(creative)-268(purpose,)-272(fall)-267(to)-268(the)-268(ground.)-303(My)-267(present)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposition)-654(is)-328(that)-327(I)-327(am)-327(reasoning)-327(with)-327(believers)-328(in)-327(theism.)-481(If)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([191])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(God)-232(has)-232(gradually)-232(evolved)-232(creation,)-236(each)-232(successive)-232(stage)-232(of)-232(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evolution)-350(forms)-349(a)-350(part)-349(of)-350(one)-350(great)-349(and)-350(comprehensive)-349(whole.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(At)-313(each)-313(stage)-312(the)-313(work)-313(is)-313(incomplete,)-328(but)-313(its)-313(incompleteness)-312(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(no)-238(proof)-239(of)-238(failure.)-246(A)-238(period)-239(has)-238(existed)-238(when)-239(the)-238(only)-238(beings)-238(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-318(world)-318(were)-317(devoid)-318(of)-318(rationality.)-453(If)-318(an)-318(objector)-318(could)-317(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contemplated)-305(it)-304(in)-305(this)-305(stage,)-318(he)-305(might)-305(have)-304(urged)-305(that)-305(the)-304(plan)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-243(creation)-243(was)-243(a)-243(failure,)-244(while)-243(in)-243(reality)-243(it)-243(was)-243(only)-242(incomplete.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Man)-212(came)-213(in)-212(at)-212(the)-213(next)-212(stage)-212(of)-213(the)-212(great)-212(design.)-238(The)-212(next)-212(stage,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(according)-340(to)-340(the)-340(New)-340(Testament,)-363(is)-340(the)-340(Incarnation)-340(of)-340(the)-340(Son)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-308(God,)-321(intended)-308(as)-307(a)-308(higher)-307(manifestation)-308(of)-307(the)-308(moral)-307(glories)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-311(the)-311(Creator)-310(for)-311(the)-311(purpose)-311(of)-311(raising)-310(man)-311(to)-311(a)-311(higher)-310(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-280(spiritual)-281(elevation.)-341(To)-281(the)-280(attainment)-281(of)-280(this)-281(purpose)-280(all)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(previous)-391(events)-392(in)-391(man's)-392(history)-391(have)-392(been)-391(made)-391(subservient.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Surely)-273(those)-273(persons)-273(with)-274(whom)-273(I)-273(am)-273(reasoning)-273(ought)-273(to)-273(be)-273(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(last)-317(to)-317(object)-317(that)-317(there)-317(is)-317(anything)-317(inconsistent)-317(with)-317(the)-316(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-418(in)-417(such)-418(a)-417(gradual)-417(unfolding)-418(of)-417(the)-418(divine)-417(purposes.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
799 0 obj <<
/Length 4663      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(170)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(We)-279(might)-278(as)-279(well)-278(object)-278(that)-279(every)-278(advancing)-279(stage)-278(of)-279(the)-278(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(design)-266(of)-267(Creation)-266(was)-267(introduced)-266(to)-266(remedy)-267(a)-266(preceding)-266(defect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-387(assert)-387(that)-386(Christianity)-387(originated)-387(in)-387(this)-386(cause.)-661(The)-386(world)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-274(in)-273(a)-274(most)-273(unfinished)-274(state)-273(when)-274(it)-273(was)-274(only)-273(tenanted)-274(by)-273(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(lower)-290(forms)-290(of)-290(life,)-301(and)-290(great)-290(fault)-290(might)-290(have)-290(been)-290(found)-290(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-242(construction.)-247(But)-242(a)-242(higher)-242(came,)-244(and)-242(a)-242(higher,)-244(then)-242(man,)-243(then)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ)-321(our)-322(Lord,)-339(the)-321(second)-322(Adam,)-339(as)-321(St.)-465(Paul)-321(designates)-321(him,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(from)-206(heaven)-206(heavenly.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 98.709 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.093 0 Td [(Whatever)-206(may)-206(have)-207(been)-206(the)-206(assertions)]TJ -110.646 -13.549 Td [(of)-309(certain)-310(classes)-309(of)-310(theologians)-309(who)-309(have)-310(attempted)-309(to)-309(fathom)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-416(divine)-415(mind)-416(by)-416(their)-416(own)-415(short)-416(sounding)-416(line,)-457(the)-415(sacred)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writers)-304(take)-303(no)-304(narrow)-304(view)-303(of)-304(the)-304(purposes)-303(of)-304(the)-303(Incarnation.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-304(is)-304(declared)-303(that)-304(they)-304(will)-304(be)-304(realized)-303(in)-304(the)-304(yet)-304(distant)-303(future,)]TJ 3.566 -13.549 Td [(towards)-312(which)-311(consummation)-312(they)-311(are)-312(gradually)-311(being)-312(carried)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -76.322 0 Td [([192])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(out)-250(in)-250(time.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-361(follows,)-388(therefore,)-388(that)-361(the)-360(New)-361(Testament)-360(affirms)-361(that)-360(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(purpose)-322(is)-321(consistently)-322(carried)-321(out)-321(in)-322(the)-321(history)-322(of)-321(redemption)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(far)-314(different)-314(from)-314(that)-315(which)-314(has)-314(been)-314(here)-314(placed)-314(before)-314(us)-314(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-374(assumptions)-374(of)-374(Ecclesiastical)-374(Christianity.)-622(The)-374(author)-373(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(placed)-347(these)-347(in)-347(their)-347(most)-347(objectionable)-347(form;)-395(and)-347(if)-347(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apologists)-254(have)-254(affirmed)-254(on)-253(such)-254(premises)-254(as)-254(those)-254(above)-253(stated)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-286(a)-286(divine)-286(interposition)-285(was)-286(rendered)-286(probable,)-295(I)-286(shall)-286(not)-285(at-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tempt)-218(to)-218(defend)-217(them.)-240(To)-217(establish)-218(the)-218(probability)-218(of)-218(a)-217(revelation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(additional)-351(to)-351(that)-350(afforded)-351(by)-351(creation)-350(we)-351(have)-351(no)-351(occasion)-350(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(appeal)-250(to)-250(theories,)-250(but)-250(to)-250(facts.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-274(existing)-273(moral)-274(and)-273(spiritual)-274(condition)-274(of)-273(mankind)-274(is)-273(uni-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(versally)-202(admitted)-201(to)-202(be)-202(imperfect.)-234(Both)-201(believers)-202(and)-201(unbelievers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-267(revelation)-267(alike)-267(acknowledge)-268(that)-267(the)-267(attempt)-267(to)-267(improve)-267(it)-267(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(desirable.)-243(No)-230(less)-230(certain)-230(is)-229(it)-230(that)-230(man)-230(possesses)-230(faculties)-229(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-260(only)-260(receive)-261(their)-260(perfect)-260(development)-260(in)-260(a)-260(higher)-260(condition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-214(things)-214(than)-213(the)-214(present.)-238(These)-214(as)-214(much)-213(point)-214(to)-214(a)-214(higher)-213(devel-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opment)-263(of)-263(man)-264(as)-263(the)-263(organization)-263(of)-264(the)-263(lower)-263(forms)-263(of)-263(animal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(life)-394(points)-393(to)-394(the)-393(higher)-394(and)-393(more)-394(perfect)-393(ones.)-681(If,)-429(therefore,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(God)-310(be)-310(the)-310(Creator)-310(and)-310(moral)-310(Governor)-310(of)-310(the)-310(world,)-325(a)-310(further)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manifestation)-250(of)-250(Him)-250(is)-250(rendered)-250(highly)-250(probable.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
803 0 obj <<
/Length 4705      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(171)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -252.311 -30.759 Td [(This)-465(probability)-465(may)-465(be)-466(reasoned)-465(out)-465(by)-465(analogies)-465(in)-465(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(history)-251(of)-250(the)-251(past.)-252(Higher)-250(developments)-251(from)-250(lower)-251(forms)-250(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-210(the)-210(rule.)-237(Are)-210(they)-210(then)-210(to)-210(cease)-210(with)-210(man)-210(in)-210(his)-210(present)-210(state)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-307(imperfection?)-422(How)-307(man)-308(came)-307(to)-307(be)-307(thus)-308(imperfect,)-321(how)-307(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(moral)-329(degradation)-328(has)-329(originated,)-348(is)-329(a)-329(question)-328(which)-329(does)-328(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fall)-269(within)-270(the)-269(present)-270(argument.)-308(It)-269(is)-270(a)-269(fact,)-275(by)-269(whatever)-269(theory)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-288(may)-289(be)-288(attempted)-288(to)-288(be)-289(accounted)-288(for.)-364(If)-289(a)-288(rational)-288(being)-288(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existed)-217(in)-435(those)-217(ages)-217(during)-217(which)-218(there)-217(was)-217(manifested)-217(nothing)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([193])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(but)-433(the)-434(lower)-433(forms)-433(of)-433(life,)-479(and)-434(had)-433(come)-433(to)-433(the)-433(conclusion)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-338(the)-339(world)-338(as)-339(it)-338(then)-338(existed)-339(was)-338(the)-338(work)-339(of)-338(an)-338(intelligent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Creator,)-363(he)-341(would)-341(have)-341(pronounced)-340(it)-341(highly)-341(probable)-341(that)-340(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(resources)-341(of)-340(creative)-341(power)-340(would)-341(yet)-341(receive)-340(a)-341(more)-340(glorious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manifestation.)-277(When)-259(vertebrate)-259(life)-259(was)-259(first)-259(introduced)-259(into)-259(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(world,)-363(a)-340(careful)-340(examination)-340(of)-340(the)-340(state)-340(of)-340(things)-340(would)-340(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(led)-359(to)-360(a)-359(similar)-359(conclusion.)-578(But)-359(the)-360(lower)-359(forms)-359(of)-359(vertebrate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(life)-236(are)-235(typical)-236(of)-236(the)-235(higher,)-239(and)-236(the)-235(higher)-236(point)-236(to)-235(man.)-245(Before)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-390(entered)-390(the)-390(world)-389(a)-390(being)-390(capable)-390(of)-390(comprehending)-389(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(condition)-365(of)-364(things)-365(as)-364(then)-365(existing)-365(would)-364(have)-365(pronounced)-364(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(highly)-206(probable)-207(that)-206(there)-206(would)-206(be)-206(yet)-207(a)-206(further)-206(manifestation)-206(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(creative)-226(energy,)-230(and)-226(that)-225(the)-226(work)-226(required)-225(for)-226(its)-225(consummation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(production)-250(of)-250(rationality.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Such)-341(and)-341(far)-342(more)-341(numerous)-341(have)-341(been)-342(the)-341(actual)-341(stages)-341(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(creative)-355(action.)-565(Are)-355(we)-355(entitled)-355(to)-355(call)-355(them)-355(a)-355(failure)-354(because)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-347(were)-347(relatively)-347(imperfect,)-371(or)-347(any)-347(fresh)-347(intervention)-347(of)-347(di-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(vine)-260(power)-260(an)-260(interference)-261(to)-260(remedy)-260(a)-260(previous)-260(failure?)-280(On)-260(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contrary,)-238(these)-235(so-called)-235(interventions)-235(are)-235(the)-235(persistent)-234(carrying)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(out)-290(of)-290(a)-290(determined)-291(purpose.)-370(The)-290(acts)-290(of)-290(Deity)-290(are)-290(inaccurately)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(designated)-359(interventions.)-576(He)-359(is)-358(always)-359(working)-359(with)-359(the)-358(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(perfect)-208(knowledge)-208(of)-209(the)-208(means)-208(which)-208(He)-208(employs,)-217(and)-208(the)-208(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(perfect)-261(controul)-261(over)-261(them.)-283(Failure)-261(with)-261(Him)-261(is)-261(impossible.)-283(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 25.053 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(intervention)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 52.723 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.478 0 Td [(as)-242(applied)-241(to)-242(the)-241(operations)-241(of)-242(God)-241(conveys)]TJ -90.098 -13.549 Td [(the)-264(idea)-265(of)-264(a)-264(machine)-264(which)-265(He)-264(originally)-264(constructed,)-268(and)-264(then)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(left)-260(to)-261(its)-260(own)-260(operations.)-281(Such)-260(a)-260(machine)-260(will)-261(in)-260(course)-260(of)-260(time)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(get)-378(out)-378(of)-377(order,)-410(or)-378(perform)-378(its)-377(work)-378(imperfectly,)-410(and)-377(require)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
808 0 obj <<
/Length 4721      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(172)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(to)-326(be)-325(supplemented)-326(by)-325(additional)-326(contrivances.)-476(Thus)-326(when)-325(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(clock)-362(ceases)-362(to)-362(go)-362(there)-362(arises)-362(a)-362(necessity)-362(for)-362(the)-361(intervention)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-417(the)-417(clockmaker.)-752(He)-417(constructs)-835(his)-417(clock)-417(and)-417(leaves)-417(it)-417(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([194])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(itself.)-618(But)-373(creation)-372(is)-373(no)-373(mere)-372(machine;)-434(the)-373(Divine)-373(worker)-372(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(always)-355(present)-354(in)-355(His)-355(works.)-564(The)-355(last)-354(idea)-355(which)-355(would)-354(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurred)-246(to)-246(the)-246(authors)-246(of)-245(the)-246(Bible)-246(was)-246(that)-246(God)-246(was)-246(obliged)-245(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-334(making)-334(a)-334(number)-334(of)-334(special)-334(interventions)-334(to)-334(cure)-334(defects)-334(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-267(results)-268(of)-267(His)-268(operations.)-302(As)-267(the)-268(Bible)-267(cannot)-268(help)-267(using)-267(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(language)-232(of)-232(man,)-236(expressions)-232(derived)-232(from)-232(the)-231(defects)-232(of)-232(human)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(language)-380(are)-380(at)-379(times)-380(used)-380(in)-380(it,)-412(but)-379(the)-380(one)-380(prevalent)-380(idea)-379(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-356(God)-356(is)-356(always)-356(present)-356(working)-356(in)-356(the)-356(kingdoms)-356(of)-356(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-257(of)-258(grace,)-259(that)-258(all)-257(His)-258(actions)-257(are)-258(the)-257(constant)-258(carrying)-257(out)-257(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-329(predetermined)-329(purpose,)-348(and)-329(that)-328(with)-329(Him)-329(is)-329(no)-328(variableness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(neither)-250(shadow)-250(of)-250(turning.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(If)-418(the)-419(possibility)-418(of)-419(the)-418(introduction)-419(of)-418(moral)-419(evil)-418(into)-418(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(universe)-284(is)-283(a)-284(necessary)-284(condition)-283(of)-284(the)-284(creation)-283(of)-284(a)-284(free)-283(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agent,)-350(or)-330(in)-330(other)-329(words,)-350(if)-330(the)-330(contrary)-330(supposition)-330(involves)-329(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contradiction,)-381(the)-356(Creator)-355(must)-355(have)-355(viewed)-355(the)-355(production)-355(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-381(a)-380(free)-381(agent)-380(as)-381(so)-381(desirable,)-413(that)-380(it)-381(formed)-381(a)-380(part)-381(of)-380(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purpose)-364(to)-364(create)-364(him)-365(notwithstanding)-364(this)-364(possibility.)-592(If)-364(then)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(moral)-310(evil)-310(became)-310(a)-309(fact,)-325(it)-310(involved)-310(no)-310(failure)-310(in)-310(the)-309(purposes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-345(God.)-533(He)-345(must)-344(have)-345(viewed)-345(the)-344(existence)-345(of)-344(such)-345(beings)-344(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(desirable,)-368(even)-344(if)-344(this)-344(contingency)-344(became)-344(a)-344(fact.)-532(Why,)-368(I)-343(ask,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-297(not)-296(a)-297(further)-297(manifestation)-296(of)-297(Himself,)-308(by)-297(means)-297(of)-296(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-264(evil)-264(might)-264(be)-264(reduced)-264(to)-264(the)-264(smallest)-264(dimensions,)-267(or)-264(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ultimately)-447(removed,)-496(while)-446(freedom)-447(is)-447(still)-447(preserved,)-496(form)-446(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(portion)-282(of)-282(the)-283(same)-282(great)-282(purpose)-282(of)-282(the)-282(divine)-283(mind?)-346(If)-282(this)-282(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possible,)-297(the)-287(assertion)-288(that)-287(Redemption)-288(is)-287(a)-288(special)-287(intervention)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-324(God)-324(for)-324(the)-323(purpose)-324(of)-324(remedying)-324(the)-324(breaking)-324(down)-324(of)-323(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(creative)-248(plan,)-249(is)-248(disproved,)-248(and)-248(with)-248(it)-248(all)-248(the)-248(other)-248(inferences)-248(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(numerous)-250(writers)-250(whose)-250(views)-250(I)-250(am)-250(considering.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([195])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -16.004 Td [(In)-214(affirming)-215(the)-214(probability)-215(of)-214(a)-215(revelation,)-222(the)-214(Christian)-214(apol-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(ogist)-324(need)-324(not)-324(go)-324(beyond)-323(the)-324(region)-324(of)-324(actual)-324(facts.)-472(He)-324(has)-323(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occasion)-278(to)-279(rest)-278(his)-278(proof)-279(on)-278(any)-278(statement)-279(made)-278(by)-278(a)-278(supposed)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
813 0 obj <<
/Length 4729      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(173)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(revelation)-223(the)-224(truth)-223(of)-223(which)-223(is)-224(the)-223(point)-223(at)-224(issue.)-241(To)-223(do)-223(so)-223(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-264(to)-265(assume)-264(the)-264(thing)-265(which)-264(requires)-264(to)-265(be)-264(proved.)-293(But)-264(facts)-264(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-204(exist,)-214(independently)-204(of)-204(any)-204(statements)-204(in)-205(the)-204(Bible,)-213(are)-204(quite)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sufficient.)-242(Man)-225(exists.)-242(He)-225(is)-226(possessed)-225(of)-226(powers)-225(and)-225(aspirations)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-219(this)-218(state)-219(of)-219(things)-218(does)-219(not)-218(gratify.)-240(He)-219(is)-218(capable)-219(of)-218(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action,)-295(and)-285(there)-286(is)-286(something)-285(within)-286(him)-286(which)-285(affirms)-286(that)-285(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ought)-379(to)-380(obey)-379(the)-379(moral)-379(law.)-638(Yet)-379(its)-379(realization)-380(by)-379(him)-379(is)-379(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-301(most)-301(imperfect)-302(character.)-403(Does)-302(the)-301(actual)-301(condition)-301(of)-301(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(afford)-373(satisfaction)-373(even)-372(to)-373(the)-373(unbeliever,)-403(account)-373(for)-373(it)-373(as)-372(he)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(may?)-609(Is)-369(there)-370(not)-369(a)-370(great)-369(amount)-370(of)-369(moral)-370(evil)-369(in)-370(the)-369(world?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Do)-311(not)-310(considerable)-311(numbers)-311(of)-311(men,)-325(instead)-311(of)-311(progressing)-310(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(higher)-359(degrees)-358(of)-359(moral)-358(perfection)-358(degenerate)-359(through)-358(various)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stages)-348(of)-348(moral)-348(corruption?)-543(Does)-348(not)-348(moral)-348(evil)-348(cause)-348(a)-347(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(amount)-420(of)-420(physical)-419(suffering?)-760(Are)-419(not)-420(vast)-420(numbers)-420(of)-419(men)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-418(prey)-417(of)-418(ignorance)-417(and)-417(superstition)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 174.256 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(great)-418(evil)1(s)-418(doubtless,)]TJ -185.165 -13.549 Td [(and)-275(of)-276(which)-275(unbelievers)-276(heavily)-275(complain?)-326(In)-275(one)-276(word,)-281(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-317(contemplate)-316(the)-317(present)-317(condition)-316(of)-317(mankind,)-333(does)-317(not)-316(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sternest)-253(reason)-253(affirm)-253(that)-254(it)-253(is)-253(inconceivable)-253(that)-253(this)-253(can)-253(be)-253(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(final)-305(condition)-305(of)-305(God's)-305(creative)-305(work?)-415(Yet)-305(these)-305(things)-305(are)-305(no)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(theories)-307(but)-308(obvious)-307(facts,)-322(and)-307(on)-307(the)-308(supposition)-307(on)-307(which)-307(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-250(reasoning,)-250(facts)-250(in)-250(the)-250(universe)-250(of)-250(God.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-204(follows)-204(therefore,)-214(that)-204(facts)-204(such)-205(as)-204(these,)-213(when)-204(contemplat-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ed)-300(by)-301(reason,)-312(establish)-301(the)-300(probability,)-313(nay)-300(almost)-300(the)-300(certainty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-399(a)-400(further)-399(divine)-399(action.)-698(Of)-400(course)-399(this)-399(is)-400(based)-399(on)-399(the)-399(as-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sumption)-278(that)-278(there)-278(is)-278(a)-279(wise)-278(and)-278(holy)-278(God)-278(who)-278(is)-278(the)-278(author)-278(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-293(universe,)-303(but)-293(both)-292(the)-293(opponents)-293(and)-292(believers)-293(in)-292(revelation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-714(only)-356(argue)-357(this)-357(subject)-357(at)-357(all)-356(on)-357(the)-357(supposition)-357(that)-356(God)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([196])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(exists.)-767(Any)-422(fresh)-422(mode)-422(of)-423(divine)-422(action)-422(will)-422(probably)-422(differ)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-427(the)-427(preceding)-427(ones,)-471(because)-427(man)-427(exists)-427(as)-427(a)-427(moral)-426(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(spiritual)-347(being.)-539(It)-347(is)-346(therefore)-346(probable)-347(that)-346(such)-347(divine)-346(action)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will)-262(be)-262(moral)-262(rather)-262(than)-262(physical;)-268(or,)-265(in)-262(other)-262(words,)-265(the)-262(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purpose)-248(of)-247(creation)-248(includes)-247(within)-248(it)-248(a)-247(yet)-248(further)-247(manifestation)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-364(the)-364(divine)-364(character)-365(and)-364(perfections.)-592(This)-364(is)-364(what)-364(the)-364(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-248(affirms)-248(to)-247(have)-248(taken)-248(place)-248(in)-248(the)-247(Incarnation.)-250(This)-247(is)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
817 0 obj <<
/Length 4569      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(174)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(my)-250(position.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-333(shall)-333(only)-333(add)-332(one)-333(or)-333(two)-333(more)-333(brief)-333(remarks.)-499(Those)-332(who)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(charge)-297(theologians)-297(with)-297(making)-297(unfounded)-297(assumptions)-296(should)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-375(guiltless)-376(of)-375(making)-376(them)-375(themselves.)-627(The)-375(warning)-375(against)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(falling)-349(into)-349(this)-349(error)-349(may)-349(be)-349(profitably)-349(taken)-349(to)-349(heart)-349(by)-348(both)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(parties)-382(to)-381(this)-382(controversy.)-645(It)-382(is)-381(affirmed)-382(that)-382(the)-381(constitution)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-452(nature)-453(bears)-452(everywhere)-453(the)-452(indications)-453(of)-452(systematic)-452(up-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ward)-337(progression.)-512(I)-337(ask,)-359(is)-338(this)-337(systematic)-337(upward)-337(progression)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(everywhere)-210(true)-209(of)-210(man?)-236(Are)-210(there)-209(no)-210(where)-209(indications)-210(of)-209(retro-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gression?)-230(Europeans)-190(generally)-191(during)-190(the)-190(last)-191(two)-190(thousand)-190(years)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-335(progressed,)-357(although)-336(even)-335(this)-335(is)-336(not)-335(universally)-336(true,)-356(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(some)-263(of)-264(the)-263(fine)-264(arts)-263(attained)-263(to)-264(greater)-263(perfection)-264(in)-263(the)-263(ancient)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-322(in)-323(the)-322(modern)-322(world.)-467(But)-322(has)-323(the)-322(Hindoo)-322(race)-322(progressed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(during)-362(the)-361(last)-362(three)-361(thousand)-362(years?)-585(Have)-361(the)-362(Chinese?)-585(Is)-361(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-403(true)-404(that)-403(the)-404(progress)-403(of)-404(these)-403(two)-404(races)-403(has)-404(been)-403(one)-403(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(considerable)-318(retrogression?)-452(Where)-318(is)-317(the)-318(progress)-317(made)-318(by)-317(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Negro)-306(races)-306(from)-307(the)-306(first)-306(dawnings)-306(of)-306(their)-307(history?)-418(Yet)-306(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(three)-193(races)-194(form)-193(more)-193(than)-194(half)-193(of)-193(the)-193(human)-194(family.)-231(Again,)-204(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-316(Arab)-315(races)-316(progressed)-316(since)-316(the)-315(days)-316(of)-316(Abraham?)-447(Are)-315(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Mahommedan)-334(races)-334(in)-334(a)-335(state)-334(of)-334(gradual)-334(improvement?)-502(These)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-240(questions)-240(to)-239(which)-240(a)-240(definite)-239(answer)-240(must)-240(be)-240(returned)-239(before)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-279(proposition)-278(above)-279(referred)-278(to)-278(can)-557(be)-279(esteemed)-278(a)-279(solution)-278(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([197])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(all)-250(the)-250(problems)-250(of)-250(human)-250(history.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-194(will)-193(perhaps)-194(be)-193(replied)-194(that)-194(nature)-193(is)-194(gradually)-193(extinguishing)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(these)-322(unprogressive)-322(races,)-340(under)-322(the)-322(pressure)-322(of)-322(her)-321(inexorable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(laws.)-228(Yet)-184(they)-184(constitute)-184(an)-184(overwhelming)-184(majority)-184(of)-184(the)-183(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(race,)-403(and)-373(it)-372(is)-373(strange)-372(to)-373(talk)-372(of)-372(this)-373(progressive)-372(improvement)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-465(the)-464(human)-465(race)-464(as)-465(a)-464(great)-465(law)-464(of)-465(nature,)-518(if)-464(the)-465(mode)-464(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(improvement)-244(be)-245(the)-244(extinction)-245(of)-244(the)-244(great)-245(majority)-244(of)-244(mankind.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(But)-394(are)-393(the)-394(Hindoo,)-429(Chinese,)-430(Negro,)-429(and)-394(other)-393(unprogressive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(races)-359(less)-359(numerous)-359(than)-359(they)-359(were)-359(three)-359(thousand)-359(years)-359(ago?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-243(evidence)-244(is)-243(all)-244(the)-243(other)-244(way.)-247(We)-244(want)-243(present)-244(facts)-243(and)-243(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(theories)-341(of)-342(the)-341(future.)-524(It)-342(has)-341(been)-341(affirmed,)-365(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 219.95 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(The)-341(survival)]TJ -224.793 -13.549 Td [(of)-387(the)-388(fittest)-387(is)-387(the)-387(stern)-388(law)-387(of)-387(nature.)-662(The)-387(invariable)-387(action)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
821 0 obj <<
/Length 4890      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(175)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(of)-406(law)-405(of)-406(itself)-405(eliminates)-406(the)-405(unfit.)-717(Progress)-405(is)-406(necessary)-405(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence.)-485(Extinction)-328(is)-329(the)-328(doom)-328(of)-329(Retrogression.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 229.852 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.425 0 Td [(These)-328(as-)]TJ -238.277 -13.549 Td [(sertions)-201(may)-200(receive)-201(their)-200(fulfilment)-201(in)-200(some)-201(period)-200(of)-201(the)-200(distant)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(future,)-380(but)-355(they)-354(certainly)-354(do)-354(not)-354(agree)-355(with)-354(the)-354(past)-354(history)-354(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(man.)-336(Whatever)-279(progress)-279(the)-279(European)-278(races)-279(may)-279(be)-279(capable)-278(of,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-297(conditions)-297(of)-298(climate)-297(form)-297(an)-297(inexorable)-297(barrier)-297(to)-297(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supplanting)-224(the)-224(Negro,)-229(the)-224(Hindoo,)-229(or)-224(the)-224(Chinese,)-229(and)-224(we)-224(know)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-213(European)-213(blood)-212(in)-213(certain)-213(climates)-213(has)-213(actually)-212(degenerated.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Again,)-440(it)-403(is)-402(stated)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 86.155 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(that)-402(the)-403(highest)-402(effect)-403(contemplated)-402(by)]TJ -102.955 -13.549 Td [(the)-289(supposed)-290(revelation)-289(is)-289(to)-289(bring)-289(man)-290(into)-289(harmony)-289(with)-289(law;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-369(this)-369(is)-369(insured)-369(by)-369(law)-369(acting)-369(on)-369(intelligence,)-399(and)-368(even)-369(on)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(instinct.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 34.855 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.795 0 Td [(Where,)-276(I)-270(ask,)-276(is)-270(the)-271(proof)-270(of)-271(this)-270(derived)-271(from)-270(the)-271(his-)]TJ -42.65 -13.549 Td [(tory)-300(of)-300(man?)-399(Is)-300(the)-300(moral)-300(condition)-300(of)-300(the)-300(races)-300(above)-299(referred)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-338(higher)-338(than)-338(it)-338(was)-339(three)-338(thousand)-338(years)-338(ago?)-514(Did)-338(the)-338(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(condition)-402(of)-403(the)-402(Greek)-402(race)-402(progress)-403(or)-402(retrograde)-402(during)-402(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(four)-253(centuries)-254(which)-253(preceded)-254(the)-253(Advent?)-260(Which)-254(was)-253(the)-253(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(elevated)-225(condition)-450(of)-225(Roman)-225(morality,)-230(that)-225(of)-225(the)-225(century)-225(which)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([198])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(preceded)-205(and)-204(followed)-204(the)-205(conquest)-204(of)-205(Italy,)-214(or)-204(that)-204(of)-205(the)-204(empire)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(its)-250(crumbling)-250(institutions?)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Again,)-323(we)-309(are)-308(told)-309(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 105.753 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(there)-308(is)-309(not)-308(in)-309(reality)-308(a)-309(gradation)-308(of)]TJ -122.553 -13.549 Td [(breach)-390(of)-389(law)-390(that)-389(is)-390(not)-389(followed)-390(by)-389(an)-390(equivalent)-389(gradation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-301(punishment.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 66.011 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.126 0 Td [(This)-301(may)-301(be)-301(the)-301(case)-301(in)-301(some)-301(Utopia)-301(in)-301(which)]TJ -74.137 -13.549 Td [(the)-294(author)-293(lives,)-305(but)-293(it)-294(certainly)-294(neither)-293(is)-294(nor)-294(ever)-293(has)-294(been)-293(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(condition)-266(of)-266(this)-266(world.)-299(Does)-266(villany,)-270(I)-266(ask,)-270(always)-266(receive)-266(ade-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(quate)-261(punishment)-261(in)-261(this)-261(world?)-283(It)-261(has)-261(been)-261(the)-261(all)-261(but)-261(universal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opinion)-284(of)-285(mankind)-284(that)-284(it)-285(does)-284(not.)-353(Did)-284(not)-285(Fouch\351)-284(die)-284(quietly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-409(his)-410(bed,)-449(possessed)-409(of)-410(wealth)-409(and)-410(honours,)-449(and)-409(a)-409(darkened)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conscience?)-375(Did)-291(not)-292(Philip)-292(II.)-291(of)-292(Spain,)-302(after)-291(all)-292(his)-291(crimes,)-302(die)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-362(the)-362(delusions)-362(of)-361(self-approbation?)-586(In)-362(a)-362(controversy)-361(like)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-389(the)-389(most)-389(confident)-390(assertions)-389(will)-389(not)-389(supply)-389(the)-389(want)-389(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(facts)-250(on)-250(which)-250(to)-250(ground)-250(our)-250(reasonings.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(It)-236(follows,)-239(therefore,)-239(that)-237(the)-236(assertion)-236(that)-237(the)-236(Christian)-236(argu-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(ment)-339(involves)-340(reasoning)-339(in)-340(a)-339(circle,)-362(or)-339(else)-339(that)-340(it)-339(assumes)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(point)-250(at)-250(issue,)-250(is)-250(disproved.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
825 0 obj <<
/Length 197       
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(176)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -36.123 Td [([199])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
833 0 obj <<
/Length 4069      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-278(IX.)-278(Demoniacal)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Miracles)]TJ/F20 18.9589 Tf 66.337 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 18.9589 Tf 18.959 0 Td [(General)-250(Considerations.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -85.296 -34.816 Td [(It)-201(has)-200(been)-201(objected)-201(that)-200(the)-201(admission)-201(which)-200(the)-201(New)-200(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-233(alleged)-233(to)-233(make)-233(as)-233(to)-233(the)-233(reality)-233(of)-233(demoniacal)-233(miracles)-233(weak-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ens,)-267(if)-264(it)-264(does)-264(not)-263(destroy,)-268(the)-263(value)-264(of)-264(miracles)-264(as)-264(an)-263(attestation)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-376(a)-377(revelation.)-629(In)-376(order)-377(to)-376(do)-376(full)-377(justice)-376(to)-376(the)-377(force)-376(of)-376(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(objection)-190(I)-191(will)-190(state)-190(it)-190(in)-191(the)-190(words)-190(of)-191(the)-190(author)-190(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 220.041 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)]TJ -224.885 -13.549 Td [(Religion:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 40.615 0 Td [(\035\024)]TJ -28.659 -14.028 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(The)-427(necessity)-426(of)-427(asserting)-426(the)-427(dependence)-426(of)-427(miracles)-427(on)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(doctrines)-413(is)-412(thrust)-413(upon)-413(divines)-412(by)-413(the)-413(circumstance,)-453(that)-412(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Bible)-313(narrates)-313(so)-313(many)-313(cases)-313(of)-313(false)-313(miracles,)-329(and)-313(contains)-313(so)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(many)-250(warnings)-250(against)-250(them.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 127.866 0 Td [(\035)]TJ -115.91 -14.028 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(The)-206(first)-206(thought)-206(which)-206(must)-206(occur)-206(to)-206(any)-206(unprejudiced)-206(mind)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(is)-240(amazement)-239(that)-240(an)-239(Almighty)-240(God)-239(should)-240(select)-239(as)-240(a)-239(guarantee)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-334(his)-334(supposed)-334(communications)-334(signs)-334(and)-334(wonders)-334(which)-333(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-225(so)-224(easily)-225(imitated)-224(by)-225(others,)-229(that)-225(there)-224(must)-225(always)-224(be)-225(a)-224(doubt)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(whether)-351(the)-351(message)-351(be)-351(from)-351(the)-351(kingdom)-351(of)-351(heaven,)-376(or)-351(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-229(kingdom)-229(of)-229(lies.)-243(It)-228(seems)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 127.551 0 Td [(\340)-229(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 35.91 0 Td [(absolutely)-229(incredible)-229(that)-229(a)]TJ -163.461 -13.549 Td [(divine)-253(revelation)-253(which)-253(is)-253(so)-253(important,)-254(and)-253(which)-253(it)-253(is)-253(intended)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-362(man)-361(should)-362(believe,)-390(should)-361(be)-362(made)-362(in)-361(such)-362(obscure)-361(lan-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(guage,)-366(and)-342(with)-343(such)-343(doubtful)-342(attestation.)-528(That)-343(heaven)-342(should)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(condescend)-270(to)-270(use)-271(the)-270(same)-270(arguments)-270(as)-271(hell,)-275(and)-270(with)-270(so)-270(little)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difference)-350(in)-349(the)-350(degree)-349(of)-350(the)-350(power)-699(exhibited,)-374(that)-350(man)-349(can)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([200])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(scarcely,)-316(if)-302(at)-303(all,)-316(discriminate)-303(between)-302(them,)-316(is)-303(a)-302(theory)-303(of)-302(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(most)-250(startling)-250(description.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 113.64 0 Td [(\035)]TJ -101.684 -14.028 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Does)-390(not)-391(the)-390(necessity)-390(of)-391(this)-390(theory)-390(of)-391(false)-390(miracles,)-426(of)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(the)-454(power)-455(of)-454(God)-454(thus)-454(placed)-455(on)-454(a)-454(level)-455(with)-454(the)-454(power)-454(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Satan,)-363(in)-340(a)-340(matter)-340(where)-339(the)-340(distinct)-340(purpose)-340(is)-340(to)-340(authenticate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-335(miraculous)-335(testimony)-336(a)-335(miraculous)-335(revelation,)-356(rather)-335(betray)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
838 0 obj <<
/Length 4820      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(178)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(the)-264(unreality)-265(of)-264(miracles)-264(altogether,)-268(and)-264(indicate)-265(that)-264(the)-264(idea)-264(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-303(supernatural)-302(intervention)-303(ori)1(ginates)-303(solely)-302(from)-303(the)-302(super-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stitious)-379(ignorance)-378(of)-379(men)-378(in)-379(ages)-378(when)-379(every)-378(phase)-379(of)-378(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-359(attributed)-358(to)-359(direct)-358(supernatural)-359(interference,)-386(and)-358(ascribed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-355(arbitrary)-355(promptness)-355(to)-355(God)-356(or)-355(to)-355(the)-355(devil?)-565(It)-355(is)-355(certain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-334(as)-334(miracles)-334(are)-334(represented)-334(as)-334(being)-334(common)-334(both)-334(to)-334(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-287(Satan,)-296(they)-286(cannot)-287(be)-287(considered)-286(as)-287(a)-287(distinctive)-286(attestation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(a)-250(divine)-250(revelation.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 95.738 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -83.782 -15.186 Td [(After)-323(quoting)-323(Dr.)-468(Mozley)-323(to)-322(the)-323(effect)-323(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 196.688 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Miraculous)-323(ev-)]TJ -213.487 -13.549 Td [(idence)-356(cannot)-357(oblige)-356(us)-356(to)-357(accept)-356(any)-356(doctrine)-357(contrary)-356(to)-356(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-243(nature)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 55.362 0 Td [(\035\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.753 0 Td [(an)-243(abstractly)-243(true)-243(statement,)-244(but)-243(quite)-243(inapplica-)]TJ -71.115 -13.55 Td [(ble)-253(to)-254(the)-253(New)-254(Testament,)-254(which)-254(no)-253(where)-254(affirms)-253(that)-253(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-334(been)-334(wrought)-335(in)-334(attestation)-334(of)-334(doctrines)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 201.841 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(the)-334(author)-334(con-)]TJ -212.75 -13.549 Td [(tinues:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.835 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(The)-342(assertion)-343(that)-342(evidence)-342(emanating)-342(from)-342(God)-343(is)-342(in)]TJ -38.678 -13.549 Td [(some)-377(cases)-378(to)-377(be)-378(rejected)-377(is)-378(a)-377(monstrous)-378(proposition;)-441(and)-377(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidential)-383(force)-384(of)-383(miracles)-384(is)-383(totally)-383(destroyed)-384(by)-383(the)-383(logical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inference)-319(from)-318(it,)-336(and)-319(from)-319(the)-319(double)-318(character)-319(of)-319(miracles)-318(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Divine)-415(and)-414(Satanic;)-497(that)-414(God)-415(is)-414(not)-415(only)-414(capable)-415(of)-414(exerting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-302(power)-302(to)-302(attest)-302(what)-302(is)-302(true,)-315(but)-302(that)-302(Satan)-302(equally)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possesses)-234(and)-234(exercises)-234(the)-234(same)-234(power)-234(in)-234(opposition)-234(to)-234(God)-233(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purposes)-374(of)-375(deception.)-622(If)-375(miraculous)-374(evidence)-374(is)-374(indifferently)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(employed)-211(to)-210(certify)-211(truth)-211(and)-210(error,)-219(it)-210(is)-211(at)-211(once)-210(degraded)-211(by)-210(such)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(common)-250(service)-250(into)-250(contempt.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 137.564 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -210.32 0 Td [([201])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -15.185 Td [(These)-417(passages)-418(put)-417(us)-418(in)-417(possession)-417(of)-418(the)-417(author's)-418(views,)]TJ -11.955 -13.55 Td [(and)-284(perhaps)-284(it)-283(would)-284(be)-284(impossible)-283(to)-284(state)-284(the)-284(objections)-283(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(strongly.)-387(I)-295(have)-296(quoted)-296(them)-295(thus)-296(fully,)-307(not)-295(only)-296(as)-295(embodying)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-307(views)-308(of)-307(this)-307(particular)-307(writer,)-322(but)-307(as)-307(placing)-308(before)-307(us)-307(in)-307(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(clear)-317(and)-318(distinct)-317(light)-317(the)-318(chief)-317(objections)-317(which)-318(can)-317(be)-317(urged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(against)-228(the)-227(attestation)-228(that)-228(miracles)-227(give)-228(to)-228(the)-227(truth)-228(of)-228(the)-227(Chris-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tian)-226(revelation,)-231(on)-225(the)-226(assumption)-226(that)-226(demoniacal)-226(miracles)-225(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-245(performed,)-246(or)-245(even)-245(on)-245(the)-245(admission)-245(that)-245(they)-245(are)-245(possible.)]TJ 11.955 -15.185 Td [(Before)-380(I)-379(enter)-380(on)-379(the)-380(general)-380(question,)-412(I)-379(must)-380(briefly)-380(draw)]TJ -11.955 -13.55 Td [(attention)-438(to)-438(the)-437(statements)-438(and)-438(assumptions)-438(contained)-438(in)-437(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remarkable)-250(passage.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
701 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 884
/Length 9051      
>>
stream
697 0 703 77 705 192 702 249 707 326 709 441 706 497 711 574 713 689 714 746
710 801 716 878 718 993 715 1050 720 1115 722 1230 719 1287 725 1376 727 1491 724 1548
729 1637 731 1752 728 1809 733 1898 735 2013 736 2070 732 2126 738 2215 740 2330 737 2387
742 2476 744 2591 741 2648 746 2725 748 2840 749 2897 745 2953 751 3042 754 3081 756 3303
752 3418 755 3474 759 3551 761 3666 762 3723 758 3780 764 3857 766 3972 763 4028 768 4105
770 4220 767 4276 772 4341 774 4456 771 4513 776 4578 778 4693 775 4750 781 4815 783 4930
784 4986 780 5041 786 5106 788 5221 785 5278 790 5355 792 5470 789 5527 794 5604 796 5719
793 5776 798 5853 800 5968 797 6024 802 6101 804 6216 801 6272 807 6349 809 6464 810 6521
806 6577 812 6642 814 6757 811 6813 816 6890 818 7005 815 7062 820 7139 822 7254 819 7311
824 7388 826 7503 823 7559 827 7624 830 7664 832 7735 828 7850 834 7906 831 7963 837 8052
% 697 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 703 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 704 0 R
/Resources 702 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 696 0 R
>>
% 705 0 obj
<<
/D [703 0 R /XYZ 118.898 342.036 null]
>>
% 702 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 707 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 708 0 R
/Resources 706 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 696 0 R
>>
% 709 0 obj
<<
/D [707 0 R /XYZ 93.543 407.327 null]
>>
% 706 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 711 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 712 0 R
/Resources 710 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 696 0 R
>>
% 713 0 obj
<<
/D [711 0 R /XYZ 241.161 491.077 null]
>>
% 714 0 obj
<<
/D [711 0 R /XYZ 250.343 93.24 null]
>>
% 710 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 716 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 717 0 R
/Resources 715 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 696 0 R
>>
% 718 0 obj
<<
/D [716 0 R /XYZ 189.945 147.437 null]
>>
% 715 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 720 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 721 0 R
/Resources 719 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 723 0 R
>>
% 722 0 obj
<<
/D [720 0 R /XYZ 109.594 217.638 null]
>>
% 719 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 725 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 726 0 R
/Resources 724 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 723 0 R
>>
% 727 0 obj
<<
/D [725 0 R /XYZ 151.307 301.388 null]
>>
% 724 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 729 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 730 0 R
/Resources 728 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 723 0 R
>>
% 731 0 obj
<<
/D [729 0 R /XYZ 291.095 380.228 null]
>>
% 728 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 733 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 734 0 R
/Resources 732 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 723 0 R
>>
% 735 0 obj
<<
/D [733 0 R /XYZ 374.173 462.342 null]
>>
% 736 0 obj
<<
/D [733 0 R /XYZ 141.739 66.142 null]
>>
% 732 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 738 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 739 0 R
/Resources 737 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 723 0 R
>>
% 740 0 obj
<<
/D [738 0 R /XYZ 276.929 160.986 null]
>>
% 737 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 742 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 743 0 R
/Resources 741 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 723 0 R
>>
% 744 0 obj
<<
/D [742 0 R /XYZ 177.459 230.369 null]
>>
% 741 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 746 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 747 0 R
/Resources 745 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 750 0 R
>>
% 748 0 obj
<<
/D [746 0 R /XYZ 188.368 301.388 null]
>>
% 749 0 obj
<<
/D [746 0 R /XYZ 46.771 190.442 null]
>>
% 745 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 751 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index9) >>
% 754 0 obj
(Chapter VIII. The Objection That The Defenders Of Christianity Assume Certain Facts The Truth Of Which Can Only Be Known By Revelation, And Then Reason From Those Facts To The Truth Of The Bible, Considered.)
% 756 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 757 0 R
/Resources 755 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 750 0 R
>>
% 752 0 obj
<<
/D [756 0 R /XYZ 93.543 529.134 null]
>>
% 755 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 759 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 760 0 R
/Resources 758 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 750 0 R
>>
% 761 0 obj
<<
/D [759 0 R /XYZ 189.991 518.175 null]
>>
% 762 0 obj
<<
/D [759 0 R /XYZ 260.896 120.339 null]
>>
% 758 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 764 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 765 0 R
/Resources 763 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 750 0 R
>>
% 766 0 obj
<<
/D [764 0 R /XYZ 163.925 190.54 null]
>>
% 763 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 768 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 769 0 R
/Resources 767 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 750 0 R
>>
% 770 0 obj
<<
/D [768 0 R /XYZ 262.396 269.38 null]
>>
% 767 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 772 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 773 0 R
/Resources 771 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 750 0 R
>>
% 774 0 obj
<<
/D [772 0 R /XYZ 302.434 340.399 null]
>>
% 771 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 776 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 777 0 R
/Resources 775 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 779 0 R
>>
% 778 0 obj
<<
/D [776 0 R /XYZ 126.725 409.782 null]
>>
% 775 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 781 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 782 0 R
/Resources 780 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 779 0 R
>>
% 783 0 obj
<<
/D [781 0 R /XYZ 93.543 475.149 null]
>>
% 784 0 obj
<<
/D [781 0 R /XYZ 321.82 79.691 null]
>>
% 780 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 786 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 787 0 R
/Resources 785 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 779 0 R
>>
% 788 0 obj
<<
/D [786 0 R /XYZ 142.834 152.347 null]
>>
% 785 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 790 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 791 0 R
/Resources 789 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 779 0 R
>>
% 792 0 obj
<<
/D [790 0 R /XYZ 298.495 231.187 null]
>>
% 789 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 794 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 795 0 R
/Resources 793 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 779 0 R
>>
% 796 0 obj
<<
/D [794 0 R /XYZ 100.653 282.929 null]
>>
% 793 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 798 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 799 0 R
/Resources 797 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 779 0 R
>>
% 800 0 obj
<<
/D [798 0 R /XYZ 93.543 355.585 null]
>>
% 797 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 802 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 803 0 R
/Resources 801 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 805 0 R
>>
% 804 0 obj
<<
/D [802 0 R /XYZ 90.904 423.331 null]
>>
% 801 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 807 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 808 0 R
/Resources 806 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 805 0 R
>>
% 809 0 obj
<<
/D [807 0 R /XYZ 252.939 491.077 null]
>>
% 810 0 obj
<<
/D [807 0 R /XYZ 93.543 106.866 null]
>>
% 806 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 812 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 813 0 R
/Resources 811 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 805 0 R
>>
% 814 0 obj
<<
/D [812 0 R /XYZ 65.806 160.986 null]
>>
% 811 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 816 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 817 0 R
/Resources 815 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 805 0 R
>>
% 818 0 obj
<<
/D [816 0 R /XYZ 259.001 231.187 null]
>>
% 815 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 820 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 821 0 R
/Resources 819 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 805 0 R
>>
% 822 0 obj
<<
/D [820 0 R /XYZ 129.245 299.751 null]
>>
% 819 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 824 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 825 0 R
/Resources 823 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 805 0 R
>>
% 826 0 obj
<<
/D [824 0 R /XYZ 93.543 518.175 null]
>>
% 823 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 827 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index10) >>
% 830 0 obj
(Chapter IX. Demoniacal Miracles--General Considerations.)
% 832 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 833 0 R
/Resources 831 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 835 0 R
>>
% 828 0 obj
<<
/D [832 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 834 0 obj
<<
/D [832 0 R /XYZ 218.253 147.916 null]
>>
% 831 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 837 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 838 0 R
/Resources 836 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 835 0 R
>>
endstream
endobj
843 0 obj <<
/Length 4391      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(179)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -252.311 -30.759 Td [(1.)-235(The)-205(assertion)-205(that)-204(miracles)-205(are)-205(alleged)-205(in)-205(proof)-205(of)-205(doctrines,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(and)-347(that)-346(divines,)-371(when)-347(the)-346(necessities)-347(of)-346(their)-347(position)-346(compel)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them,)-233(affirm)-228(the)-229(direct)-228(converse)-229(of)-228(this,)-233(viz.)-243(that)-228(miracles)-229(are)-228(de-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pendent)-232(for)-232(their)-231(truth)-232(on)-232(doctrines,)-235(is)-232(an)-232(entire)-231(misapprehension)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-240(the)-239(Christian)-240(argument.)-246(Its)-240(true)-240(position)-239(will)-240(be)-239(discussed)-240(in)-239(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subsequent)-250(chapter.)]TJ 11.956 -14.367 Td [(2.)-609(The)-370(assertion)-370(that)-370(the)-370(miracles)-369(of)-370(Almighty)-370(God)-370(can)-369(be)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(imitated)-366(by)-367(Satan)-366(is)-367(a)-366(gratuitous)-366(assumption.)-600(Nowhere)-366(is)-366(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirmed)-296(in)-296(the)-296(New)-296(Testament.)-388(On)-296(the)-296(contrary,)-307(our)-296(Lord)-296(uni-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(formly)-216(declares)-216(that)-217(His)-216(works)-216(were)-216(clearly)-216(distinguishable)-216(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-232(working)-231(of)-232(Satan,)-235(and)-232(could)-232(only)-231(maliciously)-232(be)-231(confounded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(3.)-568(While)-356(the)-356(Bible)-356(speaks)-356(of)-356(false)-356(miracles,)-382(its)-356(language)-356(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(quite)-198(consistent)-198(with)-198(the)-198(fact)-198(that)-198(they)-198(were)-198(impositions)-198(practised)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-250(the)-250(senses,)-250(like)-250(the)-250(acts)-250(of)-250(jugglers.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(4.)-457(The)-319(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 59.516 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(miracle)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 32.717 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.325 0 Td [(is)-319(here)-319(used)-319(to)-319(denote)-320(a)-319(supernatural)]TJ -117.357 -13.549 Td [(fact)-318(in)-318(external)-317(nature)-318(devoid)-318(of)-318(all)-318(moral)-317(environment.)-454(I)-317(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(already)-193(pointed)-193(out)-193(the)-194(inaccuracy)-193(of)-193(this)-193(position;)-212(and)-193(shall)-193(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(much)-353(to)-353(say)-353(on)-706(this)-353(subject)-353(hereafter.)-559(To)-353(strip)-353(a)-353(superhuman)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([202])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(occurrence)-300(of)-301(its)-301(moral)-300(aspect)-301(is)-300(simply)-301(to)-300(assume)-301(the)-300(question)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(at)-250(issue.)]TJ 11.955 -14.367 Td [(5.)-265(It)-256(is)-255(not)-255(correct)-255(that)-255(the)-255(essence)-256(of)-255(a)-255(miracle)-255(consists)-255(in)-256(t)1(he)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(degree)-328(of)-328(power)-329(manifested)-328(in)-328(the)-329(performance)-328(of)-328(the)-328(outward)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(act.)-419(The)-307(performance)-306(of)-306(a)-307(miracle)-306(does)-307(not)-306(necessarily)-306(involve)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-373(greater)-373(exertion)-373(of)-373(power)-373(than)-373(is)-373(manifested)-373(in)-373(the)-373(ordinary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrences)-246(of)-246(nature.)-248(A)-246(miracle)-246(is)-246(not)-245(only)-246(an)-246(act)-246(of)-246(power,)-246(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-250(involves)-250(the)-250(elements)-250(of)-250(prediction)-250(and)-250(of)-250(purpose.)]TJ 11.955 -14.367 Td [(6.)-564(The)-355(affirmation)-355(that)-354(the)-355(Christian)-355(argument)-355(involves)-355(the)]TJ -11.955 -13.55 Td [(position)-223(that)-223(heaven)-222(must)-223(condescend)-223(to)-223(use)-223(the)-223(same)-222(arguments)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-330(hell,)-349(if)-330(demoniacal)-330(possession)-329(is)-330(supposed)-329(to)-330(be)-330(possible,)-349(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(altogether)-250(inaccurate.)]TJ 11.955 -14.367 Td [(7.)-423(The)-308(Christian)-308(argument)-307(nowhere)-308(involves)-308(the)-308(assumption)]TJ -11.955 -13.55 Td [(that)-189(evidence)-188(emanating)-189(from)-188(God)-189(is)-188(under)-189(certain)-188(circumstances)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-375(be)-374(rejected.)-624(It)-374(is)-375(quite)-375(conceivable)-374(that)-375(a)-374(real)-375(miracle)-374(may)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
847 0 obj <<
/Length 4646      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(180)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(have)-299(been)-299(wrought,)-311(which)-299(was)-299(adequately)-299(attested)-299(when)-299(it)-298(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performed,)-274(but)-269(that)-269(the)-269(evidence)-269(has)-269(become)-269(imperfect)-268(by)-269(lapse)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(time.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(8.)-223(Even)-169(if)-169(it)-169(be)-169(supposed)-169(that)-169(demoniacal)-169(miracles)-169(are)-168(possible,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(there)-256(is)-256(nothing)-256(in)-256(that)-256(assumption)-256(which)-256(renders)-256(it)-256(necessary)-256(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(take)-218(for)-218(granted)-218(that)-217(Satan)-218(is)-218(allowed)-218(to)-218(ramble)-218(over)-218(the)-217(universe)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-373(work)-372(miracles)-373(at)-372(his)-373(pleasure,)-403(and)-373(to)-372(imitate)-373(the)-372(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-398(God.)-694(The)-398(New)-398(Testament)-398(uniformly)-398(asserts)-398(that)-397(whatever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agency)-251(he)-250(can)-251(exert)-251(is)-250(a)-251(permitted)-251(one,)-250(which)-251(is)-251(confined)-250(within)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(definite)-250(limits.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(In)-398(considering)-399(the)-398(question)-398(of)-399(demoniacal)-398(miracles)-398(it)-398(must)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(be)-374(kept)-374(in)-375(mind)-374(that)-374(the)-374(language)-375(employed)-374(by)-374(the)-374(writers)-374(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-420(Bible)-420(is)-420(invariably)-420(phenomenal.)-760(They)-420(describe)-420(events)-420(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-288(appeared)-289(to)-288(the)-288(eye)-289(of)-288(the)-288(beholder.)-365(Hence)-289(it)-288(by)-288(no)-288(means)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(follows,)-356(when)-334(they)-335(refer)-334(to)-335(the)-335(arts)-334(of)-335(magic)-334(and)-335(other)-334(similar)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(practices)-531(which)-266(were)-265(so)-266(prevalent)-266(in)-265(the)-266(ancient)-265(world,)-270(and)-265(say)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([203])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(that)-310(the)-309(magicians)-310(did)-309(such)-310(and)-310(such)-309(things,)-325(that)-309(they)-310(meant)-309(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-251(the)-251(reality)-251(of)-250(their)-251(performance.)-253(Their)-251(language)-251(is)-250(always)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taken)-304(from)-304(the)-305(observer's)-304(point)-304(of)-304(view.)-413(As)-304(far)-304(as)-304(he)-305(saw,)-317(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(did)-349(so.)-547(We)-348(frequently)-349(speak)-349(in)-349(the)-349(same)-349(way)-349(of)-349(modern)-348(feats)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-350(conjurors.)-551(Thus,)-375(when)-350(it)-350(is)-350(said)-350(that)-350(the)-350(magicians)-350(brought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forth)-285(frogs,)-294(the)-285(language)-285(is)-285(quite)-285(consistent)-285(with)-285(the)-285(act)-285(being)-285(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(delusion)-250(successfully)-250(practised)-250(on)-250(the)-250(senses.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-247(is)-247(affirmed)-247(by)-247(the)-248(author)-247(that)-247(the)-247(Bible)-247(asserts)-247(the)-247(reality)-247(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(such)-231(miracles.)-244(I)-232(reply)-231(that)-231(it)-232(makes)-231(no)-232(such)-231(assertion,)-235(but)-231(merely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(describes)-465(them)-465(as)-464(they)-465(appeared)-465(to)-464(the)-465(eye)-465(of)-465(the)-464(beholder.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Its)-414(strong)-415(denunciations)-414(of)-414(such)-414(practices)-415(is)-414(no)-414(evidence)-414(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-369(were)-369(anything)-369(else)-369(than)-369(deceptions)-369(which)-369(the)-369(performers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(endeavoured)-362(to)-362(palm)-362(off)-362(for)-362(wicked)-362(purposes.)-586(The)-362(precept)-361(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Moses,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 35.058 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Thou)-332(shalt)-332(not)-332(suffer)-332(a)-332(witch)-333(to)-332(live,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 165.039 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.467 0 Td [(has)-332(been)-332(urged)]TJ -213.407 -13.549 Td [(as)-433(affording)-432(proof)-433(that)-433(the)-433(Bible)-432(in)-433(unqualified)-433(terms)-432(asserts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-297(reality)-297(of)-297(witchcraft.)-391(Whether)-297(the)-297(art)-297(was)-297(real)-297(or)-297(simulated,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-340(sentence)-340(of)-341(the)-340(lawgiver)-340(would)-340(have)-340(been)-341(equally)-340(just,)-362(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impostors)-242(who)-242(practise)-243(such)-242(arts)-242(for)-242(the)-242(purpose)-243(of)-242(delusion,)-243(are)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
851 0 obj <<
/Length 4840      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(181)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(far)-300(more)-301(injurious)-300(to)-301(society)-300(than)-301(many)-300(kinds)-301(of)-300(criminals)-300(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-265(undergone)-264(the)-265(severest)-265(punishment.)-294(In)-264(the)-265(New)-264(Testament)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(lying)-405(wonders)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 63.811 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.266 0 Td [(are)-405(occasionally)-406(referred)-405(to.)-716(The)-406(expression)]TJ -77.921 -13.549 Td [(may)-323(legitimately)-322(mean)-323(one)-323(of)-323(two)-322(things,)-341(either)-323(a)-322(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(act)-359(performed)-360(for)-359(the)-360(attestation)-359(or)-359(propagation)-360(of)-359(a)-359(lie,)-387(or)-359(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apparent)-387(miracle,)-421(which)-387(is)-386(in)-387(itself)-387(a)-387(lie.)-660(It)-387(cannot)-387(be)-386(denied)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-317(the)-318(language)-317(of)-317(the)-317(New)-317(Testament)-318(will)-317(honestly)-317(bear)-317(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interpretation.)-425(I)-308(will)-308(quote)-309(the)-308(strongest)-308(passage)-309(to)-308(be)-308(found)-308(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it.)-243(St.)-243(Paul,)-234(writing)-229(to)-229(the)-230(Thessalonians,)-233(in)-229(speaking)-230(of)-229(the)-229(man-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ifestation)-277(of)-277(a)-277(great)-277(anti-christian)-278(power,)-283(says,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 206.719 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Whose)-277(coming)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 79.461 0 Td [([204])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(is)-214(after)-214(the)-214(working)-214(of)-214(Satan,)-221(with)-214(all)-213(power,)-222(and)-213(signs,)-222(and)-213(lying)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wonders,)-300(and)-290(with)-290(all)-290(the)-290(deceivableness)-290(of)-290(unrighteousness,)-299(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-325(that)-324(perish,)-344(because)-325(they)-324(receive)-325(not)-325(the)-324(love)-325(of)-325(the)-324(truth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-242(they)-242(might)-242(be)-242(saved.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 109.039 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.484 0 Td [(This)-242(language)-242(is)-242(quite)-242(consistent)-242(with)]TJ -116.523 -13.55 Td [(the)-235(idea)-236(that)-235(the)-235(works)-236(here)-235(spoken)-235(of)-236(were)-235(not)-235(supernatural,)-238(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(deceptions)-214(wrought)-213(for)-214(the)-214(propagation)-214(of)-213(a)-214(system)-214(of)-213(falsehood.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(There)-346(can)-347(be)-346(no)-346(question)-347(that)-346(impositions)-346(of)-347(this)-346(kind)-346(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(been)-273(systematically)-273(practised)-273(in)-272(later)-273(times)-273(in)-273(support)-273(of)-273(a)-272(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(system)-238(of)-239(ecclesiast)1(ical)-239(power,)-240(and)-239(to)-238(attest)-238(doctrines)-238(in)-238(connec-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-289(with)-288(it.)-366(But)-289(it)-289(is)-288(worthy)-289(of)-289(observation)-288(that)-289(the)-288(demoniacal)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supernaturalism)-291(which)-292(we)-291(read)-291(of)-292(in)-291(the)-291(New)-292(Testament,)-301(is)-291(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(represented)-328(as)-328(having)-328(been)-328(employed)-328(for)-328(the)-328(attestation)-328(of)-328(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(system)-421(of)-420(doctrine)-420(whatever.)-762(Elymas,)-463(the)-420(sorcerer,)-463(practised)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-290(art)-289(for)-290(the)-289(purpose)-290(of)-289(establishing)-290(an)-289(influence)-290(over)-289(Sergius)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Paulus,)-454(but)-413(for)-413(aught)-413(that)-413(appears)-413(he)-413(was)-413(a)-413(simple)-413(impostor.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(All)-464(the)-464(other)-464(cases)-463(of)-464(Satanic)-464(supernaturalism)-464(referred)-464(to)-463(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-317(Gospels)-316(resolve)-317(themselves)-317(into)-316(cases)-317(of)-317(possession,)-333(or)-316(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occasional)-250(production)-250(of)-250(a)-250(disease.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-286(is)-285(further)-286(to)-285(be)-286(observed)-285(that)-286(nowhere)-285(throughout)-286(the)-285(New)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-353(is)-353(a)-353(miracle,)-379(properly)-353(so)-353(called,)-379(ascribed)-353(to)-353(Satanic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action.)-710(Possession)-403(is)-404(a)-403(phenomenon)-403(entirely)-404(different)-403(from)-403(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracle.)-361(I)-286(admit)-287(that)-287(there)-287(is)-287(one)-287(apparent)-287(exception,)-296(namely)-286(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-303(history)-303(of)-302(our)-303(Lord's)-303(temptation.)-409(This)-302(if)-303(it)-303(is)-303(intended)-303(to)-302(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-291(description)-292(of)-291(an)-291(objective)-292(fact,)-301(is)-292(undoubtedly)-291(an)-291(instance)-291(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
855 0 obj <<
/Length 4854      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(182)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(direct)-288(interference)-288(with)-288(the)-288(action)-288(of)-288(the)-288(forces)-288(of)-288(nature;)-306(Satan)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-390(here)-390(represented)-390(as)-389(possessing)-390(and)-390(exercising)-390(the)-390(power)-389(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(counteracting)-217(the)-217(force)-217(of)-216(gravitation)-217(by)-217(transporting)-217(the)-217(body)-216(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-256(Lord)-257(from)-256(place)-257(to)-256(place.)-269(As)-257(this)-256(is)-256(the)-257(one)-256(solitary)-256(instance)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-294(the)-295(New)-294(Testament)-295(in)-294(which)-295(such)-294(power)-295(is)-294(ascribed)-295(to)-588(him,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([205])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(it)-321(demands)-322(especial)-321(consideration.)-464(We)-321(are)-322(told)-321(that)-321(during)-321(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(period)-395(of)-394(his)-395(temptation)-394(our)-394(Lord)-395(was)-394(carried)-395(by)-394(Satan)-395(to)-394(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exceeding)-382(high)-383(mountain;)-448(and)-383(again,)-415(that)-383(he)-382(was)-383(placed)-382(on)-382(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pinnacle)-332(of)-331(the)-332(temple.)-495(These)-332(acts)-332(involve)-331(such)-332(an)-332(exercise)-331(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supernatural)-289(power)-290(as)-289(may)-289(justly)-290(be)-289(put)-289(in)-290(comparison)-289(with)-289(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(walking)-407(on)-408(the)-407(water.)-722(It)-407(becomes)-408(therefore)-407(a)-407(very)-407(important)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question)-268(whether)-268(this)-269(account)-268(is)-268(intended)-268(to)-269(be)-268(taken)-268(as)-268(a)-268(literal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(narrative.)-690(The)-396(fact)-397(of)-396(its)-397(being)-396(the)-397(only)-396(recorded)-397(instance)-396(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-389(kind)-389(affords)-389(a)-389(contrary)-388(presumption,)-424(for)-389(if)-389(the)-389(writers)-388(had)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(believed)-427(that)-426(there)-427(was)-427(nothing)-427(in)-426(such)-427(interference)-427(with)-426(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical)-299(forces)-300(inconsistent)-299(with)-300(the)-299(ordinary)-300(course)-299(of)-299(Satanic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-274(it)-273(is)-274(hardly)-273(possible)-274(that)-273(they)-274(could)-273(have)-274(viewed)-273(this)-274(as)-273(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(solitary)-281(instance)-281(of)-281(the)-281(exercise)-281(of)-281(such)-281(power,)-288(especially)-281(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-390(case)-389(of)-390(the)-390(demoniacs)-390(afforded)-389(so)-390(many)-390(opportunities)-389(for)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(its)-410(manifestation.)-731(It)-410(is)-410(clear)-410(from)-411(the)-410(narrative)-410(itself)-410(that)-410(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-327(source)-327(of)-327(information)-327(regarding)-327(the)-327(temptation)-327(must)-327(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-266(an)-267(account)-266(given)-266(by)-266(our)-267(Lord)-266(himself)-266(to)-267(his)-266(disciples,)-270(as)-266(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-248(an)-249(occurrence)-248(of)-248(which)-248(there)-248(could)-249(have)-248(been)-248(no)-248(witnesses.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Otherwise)-219(it)-219(must)-219(be)-219(assumed)-219(to)-219(be)-219(a)-219(mere)-219(fiction.)-240(It)-218(is)-219(also)-219(clear)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-267(the)-268(three)-267(temptations)-267(into)-267(which)-267(the)-268(narrative)-267(is)-267(divided)-267(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intended)-277(to)-277(describe)-278(three)-277(great)-277(crises)-277(through)-277(which)-277(our)-277(Lord's)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mind)-305(passed.)-415(According)-305(to)-305(Mark's)-305(account)-305(he)-305(is)-305(represented)-305(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(undergoing)-351(temptations)-352(during)-351(the)-351(whole)-352(period)-351(of)-351(forty)-351(days.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Matthew)-183(and)-182(Luke)-183(present)-182(us)-182(with)-183(the)-182(general)-183(results)-182(of)-183(the)-182(entire)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(temptation.)-591(If)-364(our)-363(Lord)-364(gave)-364(an)-363(account)-364(of)-364(it)-363(to)-364(his)-363(disciples,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(there)-400(can)-399(be)-400(no)-399(reason)-400(why)-400(he)-399(should)-400(not)-399(have)-400(embodied)-399(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(results)-289(in)-289(a)-289(narrative)-290(form,)-298(as)-290(is)-289(the)-289(course)-289(which)-289(he)-289(adopted)-289(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-372(parables.)-615(If)-372(the)-372(parables)-372(were)-372(not)-372(usually)-372(introduced)-371(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-265(formula)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 53.643 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(he)-265(spake)-264(a)-265(parable,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 83.476 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.73 0 Td [(we)-265(might)-264(easily)-265(mistake)-265(them)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
859 0 obj <<
/Length 4956      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(183)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(also)-336(for)-336(narratives)-335(of)-336(actual)-336(occurrences.)-1015(But)-336(although)-336(this)-335(is)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([206])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(the)-318(usual)-319(form,)-335(it)-318(is)-319(not)-318(the)-318(only)-319(one,)-335(as)-318(appears)-319(in)-318(the)-318(parable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-336(Dives)-337(and)-336(Lazarus.)-509(It)-337(is)-336(therefore)-336(quite)-337(conceivable)-336(that)-336(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(giving)-339(his)-340(disciples)-339(an)-339(account)-340(of)-339(the)-339(crises)-340(through)-339(which)-339(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mind)-223(passed)-222(during)-223(the)-223(period)-222(of)-223(the)-223(temptation)-222(he)-223(may)-223(have)-222(put)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-268(into)-269(a)-268(parabolic)-268(form,)-273(of)-269(which)-268(himself)-268(was)-269(the)-268(centre,)-273(as)-268(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-217(would)-218(be)-217(most)-217(adapted)-217(to)-217(the)-218(level)-217(of)-217(their)-217(apprehensions;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(otherwise)-340(it)-340(would)-339(have)-340(assumed)-340(the)-339(character)-340(of)-340(a)-340(number)-339(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(abstract)-250(disquisitions.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-350(we)-351(are)-350(not)-351(left)-350(to)-350(infer)-351(from)-350(mere)-351(probabilities)-350(that)-350(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(narrative)-321(was)-322(not)-321(intended)-321(to)-322(be)-321(understood)-321(literally.)-464(One)-321(por-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tion)-310(of)-311(it)-310(places)-311(it)-310(beyond)-311(doubt)-310(that)-311(it)-310(was)-311(intended)-310(to)-310(contain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-350(visionary)-350(or)-350(parabolic)-351(element)-350(of)-350(some)-350(kind.)-550(In)-350(the)-350(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-265(the)-265(temptation)-265(to)-266(fall)-265(down)-265(and)-265(worship)-265(Satan,)-269(it)-265(is)-265(expressly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stated)-312(that)-312(the)-311(Devil)-312(transported)-312(our)-311(Lord)-312(to)-312(an)-312(exceeding)-311(high)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mountain,)-389(and)-362(showed)-361(him)-362(all)-361(the)-362(kingdoms)-361(of)-362(the)-361(world)-361(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-320(glory)-320(of)-320(them.)-459(The)-320(narrative)-320(of)-320(Luke)-320(adds)-320(that)-320(all)-320(this)-319(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(done)-321(in)-320(a)-321(moment)-321(of)-320(time,)-339(which)-320(shows)-321(clearly)-321(that)-320(it)-321(was)-320(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intended)-352(to)-353(be)-352(from)-353(one)-352(end)-352(to)-353(the)-352(other)-352(a)-353(literal)-352(statement)-352(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(facts.)-253(It)-250(is)-251(therefore)-251(absolutely)-251(necessary)-251(to)-251(assume)-251(the)-250(presence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-299(a)-299(visionary)-299(element)-299(somewhere;)-324(the)-299(only)-299(question)-299(is,)-311(where,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-329(to)-330(what)-329(extent?)-488(If)-329(we)-329(attach)-330(the)-329(meaning)-329(usually)-329(assigned)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-417(the)-417(writers)-418(in)-417(the)-417(New)-417(Testament)-418(to)-417(the)-417(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 232.148 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(world,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 28.178 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.395 0 Td [(it)]TJ -274.564 -13.549 Td [(is)-311(impossible)-312(to)-312(imagine)-311(that)-312(any)-311(amount)-312(of)-311(credulity)-312(can)-311(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believed)-187(that)-188(there)-187(was)-188(any)-187(mountain)-188(from)-187(whose)-188(top)-187(such)-188(a)-187(view)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(could)-390(have)-389(been)-390(attained)-390(by)-389(the)-390(unaided)-389(power)-390(of)-390(the)-389(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eye.)-344(But)-282(further,)-289(it)-282(is)-281(asserted)-282(not)-281(only)-282(that)-281(the)-281(kingdoms)-282(of)-281(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(world)-331(were)-332(rendered)-331(visible,)-352(but)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 148.872 0 Td [(their)-331(glory)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 47.252 0 Td [(;)-372(that)-332(is)-331(to)-332(say,)-351(the)]TJ -196.124 -13.549 Td [(spectator)-217(was)-216(able)-217(to)-216(see)-217(their)-216(great)-217(cities,)-223(their)-217(buildings,)-223(and)-216(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-297(signs)-296(of)-297(outward)-297(magnificence,)-308(for)-297(the)-296(sight)-297(of)-297(their)-296(glory)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-480(obviously)-239(intended)-240(to)-240(add)-240(force)-239(to)-240(the)-240(temptation.)-247(Yet)-239(even)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.023 0 Td [([207])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(the)-244(most)-244(credulous)-244(people)-244(possess)-244(some)-244(moderately)-243(correct)-244(idea)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-278(to)-279(the)-278(extent)-279(of)-278(view)-279(which)-278(the)-279(eye)-278(can)-279(reach)-278(and)-279(would)-278(feel)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(quite)-362(certain)-361(that)-362(without)-362(the)-361(interposition)-362(of)-361(a)-362(miracle)-362(such)-361(a)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
865 0 obj <<
/Length 4656      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(184)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(survey)-250(in)-250(a)-250(moment)-250(of)-250(time)-250(would)-250(be)-250(impossible.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(It)-372(may)-372(probably)-372(be)-372(urged)-373(by)-372(some)-372(that)-372(the)-372(first)-372(part)-372(of)-372(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(account)-266(only)-266(is)-265(intended)-266(to)-266(be)-266(a)-265(description)-266(of)-266(an)-266(objective)-265(fact,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-340(that)-340(the)-340(last)-340(temptation)-340(was)-340(visionary.)-520(To)-340(this)-340(I)-340(reply)-340(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-271(entire)-270(narrative)-271(is)-270(couched)-271(in)-270(language)-271(of)-271(fact,)-275(and)-271(the)-270(latter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(portion)-399(quite)-399(as)-400(much)-399(so)-399(as)-399(the)-399(former.)-698(Besides,)-436(if)-399(the)-399(sight)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-384(the)-385(kingdoms)-384(of)-384(the)-385(world)-384(and)-384(their)-385(glory)-384(was)-384(a)-384(visionary)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(representation,)-446(then)-407(the)-407(reason)-407(for)-407(conveying)-407(Jesus)-407(to)-407(a)-406(lofty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mountain)-248(ceases,)-248(for)-248(such)-248(a)-247(vision)-248(might)-248(equally)-248(well)-248(have)-247(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presented)-298(to)-298(him)-298(in)-298(a)-297(plain;)-322(whereas)-298(if)-298(we)-298(take)-298(it)-298(as)-298(an)-297(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-322(a)-322(literal)-321(fact,)-340(it)-322(is)-322(clear)-322(that)-321(the)-322(reason)-322(for)-322(conveying)-322(him)-321(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-235(mountain)-234(was)-235(to)-234(afford)-235(him)-234(an)-235(extensive)-234(view.)-245(It)-235(is)-234(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(impossible)-256(to)-256(draw)-256(a)-256(distinction)-256(between)-256(the)-256(two)-256(portions)-256(of)-255(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(narrative.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(Every)-289(consideration)-289(therefore)-290(proves)-289(that)-289(the)-289(entire)-289(narrative)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(is)-292(either)-291(parabolic)-292(or)-291(an)-292(account)-291(of)-292(a)-291(visionary)-292(transaction,)-301(pre-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cisely)-292(similar)-292(to)-292(many)-293(of)-292(those)-292(described)-292(in)-292(the)-292(Old)-292(Testament,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-294(not)-293(of)-294(an)-293(actual)-294(occurrence.)-380(This)-294(being)-293(so,)-305(we)-293(arrive)-294(at)-293(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inference)-186(that)-186(nowhere)-187(in)-186(the)-186(New)-186(Testament)-186(is)-186(Satanic)-186(influence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(described)-268(as)-267(interfering)-268(with)-267(the)-268(ordinary)-267(action)-268(of)-267(the)-268(forces)-267(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nature,)-250(by)-250(a)-250(direct)-250(exertion)-250(of)-250(power.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(It)-280(may)-281(however)-280(be)-281(objected)-280(that)-281(there)-280(were)-281(probably)-280(reasons)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(why)-330(he)-330(was)-330(permitted)-331(to)-330(do)-330(so)-330(on)-330(this)-330(particular)-330(occasion;)-370(but)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-354(such)-354(a)-354(question)-354(I)-354(shall)-354(not)-354(enter.)-562(I)-354(shall)-354(only)-354(repeat)-354(that)-354(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-405(impossible)-404(to)-405(view)-404(the)-404(latter)-405(portion)-404(of)-405(the)-404(narrative)-405(as)-404(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(account)-210(of)-210(an)-210(objective)-420(fact;)-223(and)-210(this)-210(being)-210(the)-210(case)-210(it)-210(is)-210(far)-209(more)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([208])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(probable)-313(that)-314(the)-313(whole)-313(partakes)-313(of)-314(the)-313(same)-313(character.)-440(At)-313(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rate)-301(it)-302(is)-301(the)-302(single)-301(instance)-301(in)-302(the)-301(New)-301(Testament)-302(in)-301(which)-301(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession)-250(of)-250(such)-250(power)-250(is)-250(ascribed)-250(to)-250(Satan.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(This)-464(has)-464(a)-464(very)-464(important)-464(bearing)-464(on)-464(the)-464(argument.)-892(The)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(author)-316(affirms)-315(that)-316(the)-315(writers)-316(of)-316(the)-315(New)-316(Testament)-315(attributed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-251(Satan)-251(a)-251(general)-250(power)-251(of)-251(interfering)-251(with)-251(the)-251(forces)-251(of)-250(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-396(of)-396(working)-396(miracles)-395(which)-396(may)-396(fairly)-396(be)-396(contrasted)-395(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-295(miracles)-294(of)-295(God.)-383(But)-295(whatever)-294(may)-295(have)-294(been)-295(the)-294(opinions)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
869 0 obj <<
/Length 4858      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(185)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(of)-312(others)-311(on)-312(this)-311(subject,)-327(it)-312(is)-312(clear)-311(that)-312(such)-311(opinions)-312(were)-311(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(held)-433(by)-434(them.)-800(If)-434(they)-433(had)-434(believed)-433(that)-434(Satanic)-433(agency)-433(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(constantly)-308(exerted)-307(in)-308(the)-307(affairs)-308(of)-308(the)-307(visible)-308(universe,)-322(there)-307(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(every)-229(reason)-229(why)-230(they)-229(should)-229(have)-229(invented)-229(numerous)-229(stories)-229(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-294(description,)-305(and)-294(ascribed)-293(them)-294(to)-294(Satanic)-294(intervention.)-381(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writer)-370(to)-370(whom)-370(I)-370(am)-370(referring,)-400(urges)-370(in)-370(the)-370(strongest)-369(manner,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-259(the)-259(belief)-259(in)-258(magic,)-261(and)-259(in)-259(frequent)-259(exertions)-259(of)-258(demoniacal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-251(over)-251(the)-251(external)-251(universe,)-251(was)-251(universal)-251(among)-251(the)-250(Jews)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-434(the)-433(time)-434(of)-434(the)-433(Advent.)-801(To)-434(prove)-434(this,)-479(he)-434(has)-434(adduced)-433(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(number)-234(of)-234(opinions)-234(entertained)-234(by)-234(the)-234(writers)-234(of)-234(the)-234(Talmud)-233(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(others,)-375(involving)-351(the)-350(most)-350(grovelling)-351(superstitions,)-375(and)-350(asserts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-223(indications)-224(of)-223(the)-224(same)-223(are)-224(to)-223(be)-224(found)-223(in)-223(the)-224(Gospels.)-241(As)-223(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instance,)-214(he)-205(favours)-205(us)-205(with)-205(the)-205(following)-205(story)-205(told)-205(by)-205(Josephus,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-250(declares)-250(that)-250(he)-250(was)-250(an)-250(eye-witness)-250(of)-250(the)-250(fact.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -16.004 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Josephus)-267(had)-268(seen)-267(a)-268(countryman)-267(of)-268(his)-267(own,)-272(named)-268(Eliezer,)]TJ -16.799 -13.55 Td [(release)-206(people)-207(possessed)-206(of)-207(devils)-206(in)-207(the)-206(presence)-207(of)-206(the)-206(Emperor)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Vespasian)-206(and)-205(his)-206(sons,)-214(and)-206(of)-205(his)-206(army.)-235(He)-206(put)-205(a)-206(ring)-205(containing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-229(of)-230(the)-229(roots)-229(prescribed)-229(by)-230(Solomon,)-233(into)-229(the)-230(nose)-229(of)-229(a)-229(demo-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(niac,)-251(and)-250(drew)-250(the)-251(demon)-250(out)-250(of)-251(his)-250(nostrils,)-251(and)-250(in)-250(the)-251(name)-500(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([209])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(Solomon,)-257(and)-256(reciting)-255(one)-256(of)-256(his)-255(incantations,)-257(he)-256(adjured)-256(him)-255(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(return)-268(no)-267(more.)-303(In)-268(order)-268(to)-267(demonstrate)-268(to)-268(the)-267(spectators)-268(that)-267(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-305(power)-305(to)-305(cast)-305(out)-305(demons,)-319(Eliezer)-305(was)-305(accustomed)-305(to)-304(set)-305(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pitcher)-278(of)-278(water)-278(a)-277(little)-278(way)-278(off,)-285(and)-278(he)-278(commanded)-278(the)-277(demon,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-226(he)-226(left)-226(the)-226(body)-226(of)-226(the)-225(man,)-231(to)-226(overturn)-226(it,)-231(by)-226(which)-226(means)-225(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(skill)-250(and)-250(wisdom)-250(of)-250(Solomon)-250(was)-250(made)-250(very)-250(manifest.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 239.684 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -227.728 -16.004 Td [(The)-305(object)-305(for)-305(which)-306(this)-305(and)-305(kindred)-305(stories)-305(are)-305(referred)-305(to,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-283(to)-283(prove)-284(that)-283(the)-283(Jewish)-283(mind)-284(was)-283(so)-283(intensely)-283(credulous)-283(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(superstitious)-317(on)-317(the)-317(subject)-318(of)-317(demoniacal)-317(action)-317(at)-317(the)-317(time)-317(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-267(Lord,)-272(that)-267(there)-267(was)-268(nothing)-267(so)-267(monstrous,)-272(which)-267(it)-267(was)-267(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-219(the)-218(habit)-219(of)-219(accepting)-218(as)-219(fact.)-240(We)-218(are)-219(also)-219(repeatedly)-218(informed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-257(the)-258(followers)-257(of)-258(Jesus)-257(shared)-257(in)-258(this)-257(unbounded)-257(credulity.)-272(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-220(be)-220(even)-220(inferred)-220(from)-220(the)-220(assertion)-220(before)-220(us,)-226(that)-220(they)-220(were)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(far)-311(more)-312(credulous.)-434(The)-311(argument)-311(which)-312(this)-311(writer)-311(adduces)-311(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(plausible,)-376(and)-351(it)-351(may)-351(be)-351(stated)-351(thus.)-553(If)-351(a)-351(writer)-351(like)-351(Josephus,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
873 0 obj <<
/Length 4841      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(186)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(who)-349(was)-348(extensively)-349(acquainted)-348(with)-349(Greek)-349(literature,)-373(and)-348(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Talmudists)-236(who)-237(belonged)-236(to)-237(the)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 141.98 0 Td [(\351lite)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 21.364 0 Td [(of)-236(the)-237(nation,)-239(could)-236(narrate)]TJ -163.344 -13.549 Td [(such)-433(follies)-434(as)-433(facts,)-479(what)-433(must)-434(have)-433(been)-433(the)-434(beliefs)-433(of)-433(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(vulgar)-232(herd?)-244(We)-232(must)-232(not)-232(forget)-232(that)-232(the)-232(followers)-232(of)-232(Jesus)-231(were)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(chiefly)-301(from)-301(the)-302(lower)-301(orders.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 137.21 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(The)-301(common)-301(people)-302(heard)-301(him)]TJ -142.053 -13.549 Td [(gladly.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.139 0 Td [(The)-210(inference)-211(which)-210(the)-211(reader)-210(is)-210(allowed)-211(to)-210(draw)-211(is)-210(that)]TJ -37.139 -13.549 Td [(they)-250(must)-250(have)-250(been)-250(addicted)-250(to)-250(yet)-250(more)-250(gross)-250(credulity.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(What)-325(were)-324(the)-325(reasons)-324(which)-325(induced)-324(Josephus,)-343(a)-325(man)-325(who)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(had)-220(seen)-220(the)-219(wide)-220(world,)-226(to)-220(relate)-220(this)-219(monstrous)-220(story)-220(I)-220(shall)-219(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inquire.)-247(One)-239(can)-240(hardly)-240(beli)1(eve)-240(that)-240(he)-239(was)-240(a)-240(dupe;)-243(his)-239(reporting)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it,)-467(however,)-466(no)-424(more)-423(proves)-423(that)-424(such)-423(beliefs)-423(were)-423(universal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-257(he)-257(wrote,)-258(than)-257(the)-257(existence)-257(of)-257(a)-257(wide-spread)-256(spiritualistic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(literature)-235(proves)-236(that)-235(a)-236(belief)-235(in)-235(spirit-rapping)-471(prevails)-235(generally)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([210])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(among)-225(all)-225(classes)-225(of)-224(society)-225(at)-225(the)-225(present)-225(day,)-230(although)-225(many)-224(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-293(believers)-292(in)-293(spiritualism)-293(belong)-292(to)-293(the)-293(educated)-292(classes,)-303(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(readily)-348(accept)-348(absurdities)-348(which)-348(the)-348(sound)-348(sense)-348(of)-347(multitudes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(artisans)-250(would)-250(immediately)-250(repudiate.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(The)-231(argument)-231(before)-231(me)-230(tells)-231(in)-231(a)-231(direction)-231(precisely)-231(opposite)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(to)-343(that)-344(which)-343(is)-343(intended)-343(by)-344(those)-343(who)-343(have)-343(invoked)-344(it,)-366(and)-343(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-344(marvellous)-344(that)-344(they)-343(do)-344(not)-344(perceive)-344(that)-344(it)-344(is)-344(destructive)-343(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-285(own)-285(case.)-355(I)-286(put)-285(it)-285(as)-285(follows:)-320(If)-285(the)-285(authors)-285(of)-285(the)-285(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(entertained)-376(the)-376(views)-376(of)-376(demoniacal)-376(agency)-376(which)-376(this)-375(author)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(represents)-203(them)-202(to)-202(have)-203(held,)-212(their)-202(narratives,)-212(which)-203(directly)-202(lead)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-383(to)-383(refer)-382(to)-383(that)-383(subject,)-416(would)-383(have)-383(contained)-382(numerous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(references)-359(to)-359(stories)-359(of)-359(the)-359(type)-359(of)-359(that)-359(quoted)-359(from)-359(Josephus.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Let)-332(me)-331(illustrate)-332(this)-331(argument)-332(by)-331(an)-332(example.)-494(The)-332(Arabs)-331(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-353(Orientals)-352(believe)-353(in)-352(the)-353(power)-353(of)-352(demons)-353(and)-352(magicians)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(over)-272(external)-271(nature.)-315(They)-271(consider)-272(this)-271(action)-272(to)-271(be)-272(of)-271(frequent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrence.)-420(Their)-307(literature)-307(therefore)-306(abounds)-307(with)-307(accounts)-306(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-294(monstrous)-294(interventions.)-381(But)-294(the)-293(Gospels,)-305(with)-294(the)-293(excep-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-285(of)-285(the)-285(history)-285(of)-285(the)-285(Temptation,)-294(do)-285(not)-285(contain)-284(an)-285(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-248(a)-248(single)-248(marvel)-249(wrought)-248(by)-248(the)-248(agency)-248(of)-248(demons)-248(on)-248(external)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nature.)-660(Demoniacal)-386(agency)-387(is)-387(repeatedly)-386(mentioned)-387(by)-386(them;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-294(it)-293(belongs)-294(to)-293(an)-294(order)-294(of)-293(phenomena)-294(of)-293(an)-294(entirely)-293(different)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
877 0 obj <<
/Length 4557      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(187)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(character.)-598(What,)-395(I)-365(ask,)-395(is)-366(the)-366(only)-366(legitimate)-366(inference?)-597(That)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-378(authors)-379(of)-378(the)-379(Gospels)-378(were)-379(free)-378(from)-379(the)-378(superstitions)-378(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(Before)-410(going)-410(further)-410(it)-410(will)-410(be)-410(necessary)-410(to)-410(ascertain)-410(what)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-304(the)-303(precise)-304(nature)-303(and)-304(character)-304(of)-303(that)-304(demoniacal)-303(supernat-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(uralism)-395(which)-395(is)-395(apparently)-396(asserted)-395(in)-395(the)-395(pages)-395(of)-395(the)-395(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament.)-631(Without)-378(doing)-377(so,)-409(it)-377(will)-377(be)-377(impossible)-377(to)-377(form)-377(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(correct)-250(opinion)-250(on)-250(the)-250(subject)-250(under)-250(consideration.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(The)-194(New)-194(Testament)-194(apparently)-194(ascribes)-194(to)-194(Satanic)-388(agency)-193(not)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 279.068 0 Td [([211])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(only)-245(a)-245(power)-245(of)-246(suggesting)-245(temptations)-245(to)-245(the)-245(minds)-245(of)-245(men,)-246(but)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(also)-253(in)-253(certain)-254(cases)-253(of)-253(depriving)-253(them)-254(of)-253(the)-253(supremacy)-253(of)-253(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wills,)-306(of)-294(enslaving)-295(their)-294(intellectual)-294(and)-295(moral)-294(powers,)-306(of)-294(inter-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fering)-309(with)-308(the)-308(use)-309(of)-308(their)-309(bodily)-308(organs,)-323(and,)-324(in)-308(one)-308(instance,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-343(imparting)-343(an)-344(unusual)-343(strength.)-529(These)-343(phenomena)-343(constitute)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(what)-324(is)-324(designated)-323(as)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 98.359 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(possession,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 49.396 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.376 0 Td [(and)-324(bear)-324(no)-323(inconsiderable)]TJ -160.975 -13.55 Td [(resemblance)-250(to)-250(different)-250(forms)-250(of)-250(insanity.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(But)-241(the)-241(New)-241(Testament)-241(also)-241(makes)-241(mention)-241(of)-241(lunacy)-241(as)-240(well)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(as)-191(possession.)-230(How)-191(far)-191(they)-191(were)-191(distinguishable)-191(from)-191(each)-190(other)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(we)-224(have)-223(no)-224(sufficient)-224(data)-223(to)-224(enable)-224(us)-223(to)-224(determine.)-241(At)-224(one)-223(time)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-251(are)-251(spoken)-250(of)-251(as)-251(the)-251(same)-250(disease;)-251(at)-251(others)-251(they)-251(are)-250(clearly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinguished)-250(from)-250(each)-250(other.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(The)-319(language)-318(of)-319(the)-319(Gospels)-318(seems)-319(to)-319(imply)-318(that)-319(some)-318(mal-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(adies)-159(were)-159(believed)-159(to)-160(be)-159(produced)-159(by)-159(the)-159(influence)-159(of)-159(possession.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(In)-241(one)-241(or)-242(two)-241(instances)-241(language)-241(is)-241(used)-242(which)-241(may)-241(imply)-241(that)-241(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bodily)-266(disease)-266(was)-266(brought)-266(on)-266(by)-266(Satanic)-266(agency)-266(without)-266(actual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession.)-813(Whatever)-437(may)-438(have)-438(been)-437(the)-438(belief)-437(of)-438(the)-437(Jews)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-452(this)-453(subject,)-503(it)-452(is)-452(certain)-453(that)-452(the)-452(cases)-453(referred)-452(to)-452(in)-452(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Gospels)-346(are)-346(very)-346(few;)-393(and)-346(although)-346(the)-346(mention)-346(of)-346(diseases)-345(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(very)-378(common,)-409(nothing)-378(is)-378(said)-378(about)-377(their)-378(being)-378(due)-378(to)-377(demo-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(niacal)-417(influence.)-753(Not)-417(a)-417(single)-418(case)-417(occurs)-418(in)-417(which)-417(ordinary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accidents)-220(are)-219(referred)-219(to)-220(this)-219(influence,)-226(although)-219(such)-220(is)-219(affirmed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-299(have)-298(been)-299(the)-299(common)-298(belief)-299(of)-298(the)-299(Jews.)-396(In)-299(the)-298(Acts)-299(of)-298(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Apostles)-225(only)-225(two)-225(cases)-225(of)-225(possession)-225(are)-225(mentioned,)-230(one)-225(that)-225(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-318(damsel)-319(at)-318(Philippi,)-335(and)-319(the)-318(other)-318(the)-319(occasion)-318(when)-318(certain)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
881 0 obj <<
/Length 4582      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(188)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Jewish)-272(exorcists)-271(undertook)-272(to)-271(exorcise)-272(demoniacs)-271(at)-272(Ephesus)-271(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(name)-250(of)-250(Jesus.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-277(former)-278(case)-277(is)-277(of)-278(some)-277(importance.)-332(The)-278(girl)-277(is)-277(described)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(as)-318(possessed)-317(by)-318(a)-317(spirit)-318(of)-317(Pytho,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 152.001 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 18.267 0 Td [(she)-318(pretended)-317(to)-318(practise)]TJ -170.268 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(art)-251(of)-250(divination)-250(by)-250(the)-501(inspiration)-250(of)-250(the)-251(god)-250(Apollo,)-250(and)-250(in)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([212])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(many)-226(respects)-227(she)-226(practised)-226(the)-226(arts)-227(of)-226(the)-226(modern)-226(fortune-teller.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Such)-387(persons)-387(were)-387(not)-387(uncommon)-387(at)-387(the)-387(time.)-661(The)-387(Pythia)-386(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Delphi)-384(professed)-383(to)-384(prophesy)-383(under)-383(the)-384(influence)-383(of)-384(a)-383(similar)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inspiration.)-465(Whatever)-321(may)-321(have)-322(been)-321(the)-322(real)-321(causes)-322(by)-321(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-389(mental)-388(condition)-389(was)-388(brought)-389(about,)-423(the)-389(paroxysms)-388(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-342(real)-341(that)-342(one)-342(is)-341(recorded)-342(to)-342(have)-341(died)-342(under)-342(their)-341(influence.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Her)-259(state)-259(when)-259(under)-259(prophetic)-259(influence,)-261(is)-259(described)-259(as)-259(one)-259(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phrensied)-270(excitement.)-309(St.)-309(Paul)-269(is)-270(represented)-270(by)-269(the)-270(historian)-269(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(addressing)-328(himself)-329(to)-328(the)-329(spirit,)-348(and)-328(commanding)-329(him)-328(to)-328(come)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(out)-383(in)-383(the)-383(name)-383(of)-382(Jesus)-383(Christ.)-649(The)-383(powers)-383(of)-383(such)-382(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-217(confined)-217(to)-218(diving)-217(into)-217(the)-217(secrets)-217(of)-218(the)-217(future;)-228(but)-217(to)-217(other)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(kinds)-250(of)-250(supernatural)-250(power)-250(they)-250(made)-250(no)-250(claims.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(If)-337(the)-336(language)-337(here)-336(employed)-337(be)-336(other)-337(than)-336(phenomenal,)-358(it)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(seems)-275(to)-275(imply)-275(that)-275(in)-274(St.)-325(Paul's)-275(opinion)-275(certain)-275(practices)-275(of)-274(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ancient)-288(world)-288(which)-289(were)-288(far)-288(from)-288(uncommon,)-298(were)-288(connected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-424(demoniacal)-423(agency.)-771(These)-424(were)-423(usually)-424(combined)-423(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-346(forms)-345(of)-346(religious)-345(phrensy,)-370(such)-345(as)-346(even)-345(in)-346(the)-345(present)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(day)-313(manifest)-314(themselves)-313(in)-313(connection)-314(with)-313(the)-313(more)-313(degraded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forms)-396(of)-397(religion.)-688(At)-397(no)-396(period)-396(was)-397(this)-396(class)-396(of)-396(phenomena)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(more)-238(prevalent)-239(than)-238(during)-238(the)-239(century)-238(which)-238(preceded,)-241(and)-238(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-335(followed)-335(the)-334(Advent,)-356(when)-335(human)-335(nature)-335(was)-335(stirred)-334(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-250(profoundest)-250(depths.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(There)-383(are)-382(also)-383(a)-382(few)-383(passages)-383(in)-382(St.)-648(Paul's)-383(writings)-382(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(seem)-418(to)-418(affirm)-417(a)-418(connection)-418(between)-418(demoniacal)-418(agency)-417(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pagan)-331(worship.)-495(Whatever)-331(may)-331(have)-332(been)-331(his)-332(own)-331(opinions)-331(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-359(subject,)-386(it)-359(is)-359(evident)-359(that)-359(the)-359(action)-359(which)-359(he)-359(supposed)-358(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-290(been)-290(exerted)-290(was)-290(entirely)-290(mental.)-370(Not)-290(one)-290(word)-290(is)-290(uttered)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-248(him)-248(which)-248(implies)-248(that)-248(he)-248(regarded)-248(this)-248(mode)-248(of)-248(demoniacal)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([213])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(action)-284(as)-283(involving)-284(a)-283(power)-283(of)-284(interfering)-283(with)-284(the)-283(forces)-284(of)-283(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
886 0 obj <<
/Length 4769      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(189)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(material)-250(universe.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Such)-298(is)-298(a)-299(general)-298(statement)-298(of)-298(the)-298(facts)-299(as)-298(they)-298(appear)-298(in)-298(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(New)-304(Testament)-305(in)-304(connection)-305(with)-304(possession,)-318(and)-304(demoniacal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action.)-687(It)-395(has)-396(been)-395(necessary)-396(thus)-395(distinctly)-396(to)-395(state)-396(them,)-431(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-203(that)-202(we)-203(may)-203(keep)-202(the)-203(subject)-203(clear)-202(of)-203(all)-203(adventitious)-202(issues)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-383(which)-383(it)-383(has)-383(been)-382(attempted)-383(to)-383(obscure)-383(it.)-649(That)-383(form)-382(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(demoniacal)-251(action)-250(involved)-251(in)-251(the)-250(supposed)-251(power)-251(possessed)-250(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demons)-241(of)-241(tempting)-241(men)-241(to)-240(evil)-241(does)-241(not)-241(fall)-241(within)-241(the)-241(limits)-240(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(present)-250(controversy.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-246(the)-247(opponents)-246(of)-246(Christianity)-247(are)-246(not)-246(content)-247(to)-246(reason)-246(on)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-341(facts)-340(respecting)-341(demoniacal)-340(action)-340(as)-341(they)-340(are)-341(presented)-340(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us)-328(in)-327(the)-328(pages)-327(of)-328(the)-327(New)-327(Testament.)-483(They)-327(charge)-328(its)-327(writers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-437(a)-436(number)-437(of)-436(the)-437(most)-436(grotesque)-437(beliefs)-436(on)-437(this)-436(subject,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-373(which)-373(the)-373(book)-374(itself)-373(furnishes)-373(us)-373(with)-373(no)-373(evidence.)-619(This)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(course)-385(has)-384(been)-385(taken)-384(for)-385(the)-385(purpose)-384(of)-385(fastening)-384(on)-385(them)-384(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(boundless)-429(credulity,)-474(and)-429(thereby)-429(destroying)-429(their)-429(claim)-429(to)-429(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accepted)-304(as)-304(credible)-304(reporters)-304(of)-304(historical)-304(facts.)-412(I)-304(will)-304(cite)-304(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-239(two)-239(examples)-238(of)-239(this)-239(mode)-239(of)-238(reasoning,)-241(in)-239(order)-239(that)-239(we)-238(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-250(able)-250(to)-250(form)-250(a)-250(correct)-250(estimate)-250(of)-250(its)-250(value.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(After)-152(having)-152(given)-153(a)-152(detailed)-152(account)-152(of)-153(a)-152(number)-152(of)-152(monstrous)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(beliefs)-383(gleaned)-383(from)-383(the)-383(Talmud)-383(and)-383(other)-383(sources)-382(respecting)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(angels,)-519(the)-466(author)-465(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 101.792 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)-465(Religion)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 98.405 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.922 0 Td [(then)-466(proceeds:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf -214.963 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)-248(belief)-248(in)-248(demons)-248(at)-248(the)-248(time)-248(of)-248(Jesus)-248(was)-248(equally)-248(emphatic)]TJ -4.844 -13.549 Td [(and)-270(comprehensive,)-274(and)-270(we)-270(need)-269(not)-270(mention)-270(also)-269(that)-270(the)-269(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-244(is)-244(full)-244(of)-244(it.)-248(They)-244(are)-244(in)-244(the)-244(air,)-245(on)-244(earth,)-245(in)-244(the)-244(bodies)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-364(men)-363(and)-364(animals,)-391(and)-364(even)-363(at)-364(the)-363(bottom)-364(of)-363(the)-364(sea.)-590(They)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-258(the)-259(offspring)-258(of)-258(the)-259(fallen)-258(angels)-258(who)-259(loved)-258(the)-258(daughters)-258(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(men.)-459(They)-320(have)-320(wings)-320(like)-319(angels,)-338(and)-319(can)-320(fly)-320(from)-320(one)-319(place)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-332(the)-332(earth)-332(to)-332(another.)-495(They)-332(attain)-332(a)-332(knowledge)-664(of)-332(the)-331(future)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([214])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(by)-240(listening)-239(behind)-240(the)-240(veil)-239(of)-240(the)-240(temple)-240(of)-239(God.)-247(Their)-239(numbers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-383(infinite.)-650(The)-384(earth)-383(is)-383(so)-384(full)-383(of)-383(them,)-417(that)-383(if)-384(man)-383(had)-383(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-340(to)-340(see,)-362(he)-340(could)-340(not)-340(exist)-340(on)-340(account)-340(of)-340(them;)-385(there)-339(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(more)-276(demons)-275(than)-276(men,)-282(and)-275(they)-276(are)-276(about)-275(as)-276(close)-275(as)-276(the)-275(earth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thrown)-325(up)-324(out)-325(of)-324(a)-325(new)-324(made)-325(grave.)-474(It)-324(is)-325(stated)-324(that)-325(each)-324(man)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
891 0 obj <<
/Length 5378      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(190)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(had)-381(10,000)-381(demons)-381(on)-382(his)-381(right)-381(hand,)-414(and)-381(1000)-381(on)-381(his)-381(left....)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-378(crush)-379(on)-378(the)-378(Sabbath)-379(in)-378(the)-378(synagogue)-379(arises)-378(from)-378(them;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(also)-362(the)-361(dresses)-362(of)-362(the)-361(Rabbins)-362(become)-362(so)-361(soon)-362(worn)-361(through)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-272(rubbing;)-284(in)-272(like)-272(manner)-272(also)-272(they)-273(cause)-272(the)-272(tottering)-272(of)-272(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(feet.)-592(He)-364(who)-363(wishes)-364(to)-364(discover)-364(these)-364(spirits)-364(must)-364(take)-363(sifted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ashes,)-326(and)-311(strew)-311(them)-311(about)-311(his)-311(bed,)-326(and)-311(he)-311(will)-311(perceive)-311(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(footprints)-363(upon)-364(them)-363(like)-363(a)-363(cock's)-363(tread.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 182.383 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.807 0 Td [(Here)-363(follow)-363(a)-364(num-)]TJ -191.19 -13.549 Td [(ber)-362(of)-362(the)-361(most)-362(ineffable)-362(absurdities,)-390(unsurpassed)-362(by)-361(anything)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contained)-414(in)-414(the)-413(Arabian)-414(Nights,)-455(which)-414(I)-413(need)-414(not)-414(cite.)-741(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(author)-392(then)-391(proceeds:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 102.822 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Demons,)-427(however,)-427(take)-391(more)-392(especial)]TJ -107.666 -13.549 Td [(delight)-351(in)-350(foul)-351(and)-351(offensive)-351(places,)-376(and)-350(an)-351(evil)-351(spirit)-350(inhabits)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(every)-241(private)-241(closet)-241(in)-241(the)-241(world.)-247(Demons)-241(haunt)-241(deserted)-240(places,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ruins,)-432(graves,)-432(and)-395(certain)-396(kinds)-395(of)-396(trees.)-686(We)-396(find)-395(indications)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-411(these)-411(superstitions)-411(throughout)-411(the)-411(Gospels.)-733(The)-410(possessed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-299(represented)-299(as)-298(dwelling)-299(among)-299(the)-299(tombs,)-311(and)-299(being)-298(driven)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-307(unclean)-308(spirits)-307(into)-308(the)-307(wilderness,)-322(and)-307(the)-308(demons)-307(can)-307(find)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-417(rest)-418(in)-417(clean)-417(places.)-752(Demons)-418(also)-417(frequented)-417(springs)-417(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fountains.)-634(The)-378(episode)-377(of)-378(the)-378(angel)-378(who)-378(was)-378(said)-378(to)-377(descend)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-347(certain)-346(times)-347(and)-346(trouble)-347(the)-347(water)-346(of)-347(the)-346(pool)-347(of)-346(Bethesda,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(so)-273(that)-274(he)-273(that)-274(first)-273(stepped)-273(in)-274(was)-273(healed)-274(of)-273(whatsoever)-273(disease)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-261(had,)-264(may)-261(be)-262(mentioned)-261(here)-261(in)-261(passing,)-264(although)-261(the)-261(passage)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-320(not)-319(found)-320(in)-319(the)-320(older)-319(manuscripts)-320(of)-319(the)-320(fourth)-320(Gospel,)-336(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-368(certainly)-368(a)-369(late)-368(addition.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 130.283 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.86 0 Td [(Here)-368(follow)-368(further)-369(citations)-368(of)]TJ -139.143 -13.549 Td [(Rabbinical)-253(absurdities.)-260(The)-253(author)-253(then)-506(proceeds:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 222.123 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)-253(Talmud)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -299.722 0 Td [([215])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(and)-186(other)-186(Rabbinical)-187(writi)1(ngs)-187(are)-186(full)-186(of)-186(references)-186(to)-186(demoniacal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession,)-368(but)-345(we)-344(need)-345(not)-344(enter)-344(into)-345(details)-344(on)-345(this)-344(point,)-368(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-247(New)-247(Testament)-248(itself)-247(presents)-247(sufficient)-247(evidence)-247(respecting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it.)-543(Not)-348(only)-347(could)-348(one)-348(spirit)-347(enter)-348(into)-347(a)-348(body,)-372(but)-348(many)-347(took)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession)-409(of)-409(the)-409(same)-409(individual.)-727(There)-409(are)-409(many)-408(instances)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mentioned)-476(in)-475(the)-476(Gospels,)-532(such)-476(as)-476(Mary)-476(Magdalene,)-532(out)-475(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(whom)-274(went)-274(seven)-274(demons)-274(\050)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 122.845 0 Td [(\021)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\300\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 10.429 0 Td [(p)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 8.715 0 Td [(\264\261\271\274)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 20.04 0 Td [(y)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.433 0 Td [(\275\271\261)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.465 0 Td [(\051,)-280(and)-274(the)-274(man)-274(whose)]TJ -186.509 -13.549 Td [(name)-296(was)-296(legion,)-307(because)-296(many)-296(demons)-296(\050)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 186.43 0 Td [(\300\277\273\273)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 22.691 0 Td [(p)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 8.957 0 Td [(\264\261\271\274)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 20.04 0 Td [(y)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.432 0 Td [(\275\271\261)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.466 0 Td [(\051)-296(had)]TJ -258.016 -13.549 Td [(entered)-372(into)-371(him.)-615(Demons)-372(likewise)-372(entered)-371(into)-372(the)-372(bodies)-371(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(animals,)-461(and)-419(in)-419(the)-419(narrative)-418(to)-419(which)-419(we)-419(have)-419(just)-418(referred,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
895 0 obj <<
/Length 4900      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(191)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(the)-378(demons,)-409(on)-378(being)-377(expelled)-378(from)-377(the)-378(man,)-409(requested)-378(to)-377(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(allowed)-305(to)-305(enter)-304(into)-305(the)-305(herd)-305(of)-304(swine,)-319(which)-305(being)-304(permitted,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\030)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 3.633 0 Td [(the)-352(demons)-353(went)-352(out)-353(of)-352(the)-353(man)-352(into)-353(the)-352(swine,)-378(and)-353(the)-352(herd)]TJ -3.633 -13.549 Td [(ran)-387(violently)-387(down)-387(the)-386(cliff)-387(into)-387(the)-387(lake)-387(and)-387(were)-386(drowned,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 276.997 0 Td [(\031)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -276.997 -13.55 Td [(the)-303(evil)-304(spirits,)-316(as)-303(usual,)-317(taking)-303(pleasure)-304(only)-303(in)-303(the)-303(destruction)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-245(injury)-244(of)-244(man)-245(and)-244(beast.)-249(Besides)-244(possession,)-246(all)-244(the)-244(diseases)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-343(men)-343(and)-344(animals)-343(are)-343(ascribed)-343(to)-343(the)-344(action)-343(of)-343(the)-343(devil)-343(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demons.)-362(In)-288(the)-287(Gospel,)-297(for)-287(instance,)-297(the)-288(woman)-287(with)-288(a)-287(spirit)-287(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(infirmity)-286(is)-286(described)-285(as)-286(bound)-286(by)-286(Satan,)-294(although)-286(the)-286(case)-285(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(not)-269(one)-270(of)-269(demoniacal)-269(possession.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 150.219 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.781 0 Td [(The)-269(author)-270(then)-269(proceeds)-269(to)]TJ -158 -13.549 Td [(enumerate)-390(a)-390(large)-389(number)-390(of)-390(grotesque)-389(beliefs)-390(as)-390(held)-390(by)-389(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jews)-250(at)-250(the)-250(time)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Advent.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-163(regret)-164(the)-164(necessity)-163(which)-164(has)-163(compelled)-164(me)-164(to)-163(cite)-164(so)-163(lengthy)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(a)-235(passage,)-238(but)-236(it)-235(is)-235(absolutely)-235(necessary)-236(that)-235(the)-235(reader)-235(should)-235(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enabled)-355(to)-355(see,)-382(beyond)-355(the)-355(possibility)-355(of)-355(misapprehension,)-381(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nature)-371(of)-371(the)-372(objections)-371(which)-371(are)-371(urged)-371(against)-371(the)-371(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(credibility)-275(of)-275(the)-275(Gospels,)-281(and)-275(the)-275(reasonings)-275(by)-275(which)-275(they)-275(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attempted)-315(to)-314(be)-315(supported.)-443(The)-315(general)-314(principle)-315(that)-314(underlies)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-297(may)-296(be)-297(stated)-296(in)-297(a)-297(few)-296(words,)-308(that)-594(the)-296(followers)-297(of)-296(Jesus)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([216])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(and)-227(the)-227(authors)-227(of)-227(the)-227(Gospels)-227(were)-227(a)-227(prey)-227(to)-227(such)-227(a)-227(multitude)-227(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(degrading)-271(superstitions)-272(on)-271(the)-271(subject)-272(of)-271(demonology)-271(as)-271(wholly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(destroy)-250(the)-250(value)-250(of)-250(their)-250(historical)-250(testimony.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-350(effect)-351(of)-350(this)-351(passage)-350(with)-350(its)-351(context)-350(is)-351(to)-350(produce)-350(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(impression)-270(on)-270(the)-271(mind)-270(of)-270(the)-270(reader,)-276(not)-270(only)-270(that)-270(these)-270(absurd)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beliefs)-423(were)-423(generally)-423(entertained)-423(by)-423(the)-423(Jews)-423(at)-423(the)-423(time)-423(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-300(Advent,)-312(but)-300(that)-299(they)-300(constituted)-300(the)-300(form)-299(of)-300(thought)-300(of)-299(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(followers)-280(of)-281(Jesus.)-340(It)-281(may)-280(be)-280(urged)-280(that)-280(the)-281(object)-280(of)-280(the)-280(author)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-246(to)-245(prove)-246(the)-246(general)-245(superstition)-246(of)-246(the)-245(times;)-247(and)-246(that)-246(he)-245(does)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-381(intend)-381(to)-380(affirm)-381(that)-381(it)-381(was)-381(shared)-380(in)-381(by)-381(every)-381(one)-381(of)-380(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(followers)-279(of)-279(Jesus.)-337(This)-279(may)-279(be)-280(correct;)-293(but)-279(if)-279(it)-279(is)-279(not)-279(intended)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-283(be)-283(asserted)-283(that)-284(the)-283(followers)-283(of)-283(Jesus)-283(were)-283(the)-283(prey)-283(of)-283(equal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(superstitions,)-261(the)-259(reference)-259(to)-259(this)-258(mass)-259(of)-259(credulity)-259(can)-259(have)-258(no)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(bearing)-317(on)-317(the)-317(present)-317(argument,)-334(and)-317(is)-317(simply)-317(misleading.)-451(To)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(what)-261(purpose,)-264(I)-261(ask,)-264(is)-261(it)-262(made,)-264(unless)-261(it)-261(is)-261(intended)-261(to)-261(implicate)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
899 0 obj <<
/Length 4873      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(192)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(our)-275(Lord's)-274(followers)-275(in)-275(these)-275(beliefs?)-324(Unless)-274(it)-275(were)-275(so,)-281(the)-274(fact)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-402(others)-402(entertained)-402(them)-401(would)-402(not)-402(in)-402(the)-402(smallest)-401(degree)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affect)-213(the)-213(value)-212(of)-213(their)-213(historical)-213(testimony.)-237(But)-213(on)-213(this)-213(point)-212(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-335(not)-335(left)-336(to)-335(inferences;)-377(not)-336(only)-335(are)-335(passages)-335(in)-335(the)-335(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(referred)-270(to,)-275(but)-270(we)-270(are)-270(repeatedly)-270(informed)-270(that)-270(the)-270(followers)-269(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-250(did)-250(share)-250(in)-250(these)-250(popular)-250(delusions.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-281(position,)-289(therefore,)-289(which)-281(is)-282(taken)-281(by)-281(the)-281(author)-281(is)-281(clear.)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(His)-289(readers)-288(are)-289(invited)-288(to)-289(believe)-289(that)-288(the)-289(followers)-288(of)-289(our)-288(Lord)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-390(a)-389(prey)-390(to)-390(the)-389(belief)-390(in)-390(a)-389(number)-390(of)-390(ineffable)-389(absurdities)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(respecting)-392(demons)-392(such)-392(as)-392(he)-391(has)-392(enumerated.)-676(If)-392(this)-392(can)-391(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(established,)-552(the)-491(conclusion)-491(is)-491(inevitable,)-552(that)-491(their)-491(historical)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(testimony)-250(is)-250(valueless.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Let)-358(us)-358(now)-358(consider)-358(the)-359(mode)-358(in)-358(which)-358(the)-358(proof)-358(of)-358(this)-358(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(attempted)-306(to)-306(be)-306(established.)-419(The)-306(authorities)-612(quoted)-306(are)-306(chiefly)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([217])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(the)-274(Talmudical)-274(writers;)-286(that)-275(is)-274(to)-274(say,)-280(persons)-274(who)-274(wrote)-274(as)-274(late)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-389(from)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 38.78 0 Td [(A)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 2.728 0 Td [(D)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)-389(200)-389(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 40.306 0 Td [(A)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 2.728 0 Td [(D)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)-389(500,)-424(are)-388(cited)-389(as)-389(the)-389(proof)-389(that)-389(such)]TJ -107.558 -13.549 Td [(opinions)-267(were)-268(universally)-267(entertained)-267(by)-267(the)-267(Jews)-268(in)-267(the)-267(time)-267(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-344(Christ.)-533(Equally)-344(valid)-345(would)-344(it)-344(be)-344(to)-345(quote)-344(the)-344(writers)-344(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modern)-212(spiritualism)-211(to)-212(prove)-211(that)-212(such)-211(opinions)-212(were)-211(held)-212(by)-211(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ancestors)-315(in)-314(the)-315(time)-314(of)-314(the)-315(Stuarts)-314(or)-315(the)-314(Plantagenets.)-444(On)-314(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(strength)-232(of)-232(this)-232(and)-231(kindred)-232(evidence,)-236(such)-232(opinions)-232(are)-231(ascribed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-286(the)-285(original)-286(propagators)-286(of)-285(Christianity,)-295(and)-285(to)-286(the)-286(authors)-285(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(Gospels.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-356(this)-356(is)-355(not)-356(all.)-568(The)-355(only)-356(correct)-356(method)-356(of)-355(ascertaining)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-235(superstition)-236(and)-235(credulity)-236(of)-235(any)-235(particular)-236(writer)-235(is)-235(carefully)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-418(examine)-419(the)-418(contents)-418(of)-419(his)-418(book,)-460(and)-419(to)-418(note)-418(the)-418(various)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instances)-251(which)-250(we)-251(find)-250(in)-251(it)-250(of)-251(what)-250(we)-251(consider)-250(to)-251(be)-250(supersti-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tions;)-232(and)-223(then)-223(proceed)-223(to)-223(estimate)-223(their)-223(value,)-229(and,)-228(if)-223(needful,)-228(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(compare)-254(them)-254(with)-254(other)-253(contemporary)-254(authorities.)-262(This)-253(course,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(however,)-307(is)-296(not)-296(that)-295(pursued)-296(by)-296(this)-296(writer.)-387(On)-296(the)-295(contrary,)-307(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(quotes)-285(the)-284(absurdities)-285(which)-285(we)-285(have)-284(seen)-285(from)-285(the)-284(Talmudical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writers,)-219(and)-210(refers)-211(in)-210(the)-211(midst)-211(of)-210(them)-211(to)-211(nearly)-210(every)-211(passage)-210(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-274(Gospels)-274(which)-273(can)-274(be)-274(made)-274(to)-273(bear)-274(even)-274(a)-274(remote)-273(reference)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-264(the)-264(views)-265(in)-264(question.)-292(I)-264(submit)-265(that)-264(such)-264(a)-264(mode)-264(of)-264(reasoning)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
903 0 obj <<
/Length 4606      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(193)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(is)-250(not)-250(conducive)-250(to)-250(the)-250(interests)-250(of)-250(truth.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(A)-428(few)-428(examples)-429(of)-428(this)-428(mode)-429(of)-428(conducting)-428(the)-428(argument)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(require)-250(notice.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(After)-202(referring)-202(to)-202(a)-201(number)-202(of)-202(monstrous)-202(superstitions,)-212(he)-201(tells)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(us)-317(that)-317(the)-317(Jews)-318(believed)-317(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 134.682 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(demons)-317(took)-317(especial)-317(delight)-318(in)]TJ -139.526 -13.55 Td [(foul)-335(and)-334(offensive)-335(places,)-356(and)-334(that)-335(an)-335(evil)-334(spirit)-335(inhabits)-334(every)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(private)-395(closet)-395(in)-395(the)-396(world.)-685(Demons)-395(haunted)-395(deserted)-395(places,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ruins,)-309(graves,)-309(and)-297(certain)-298(kinds)-297(of)-297(trees.)-392(We)-297(find)-297(indications)-297(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-331(superstitions)-331(throughout)-331(the)-331(Gospels.)-493(The)-331(possessed)-662(are)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([218])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(represented)-341(as)-341(dwelling)-340(among)-341(the)-341(tombs,)-363(and)-341(as)-341(being)-340(driven)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-329(unclean)-329(spirits)-329(into)-329(the)-329(wilderness,)-349(and)-329(demons)-329(can)-329(find)-329(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rest)-250(in)-250(clean)-250(places.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 85.429 0 Td [(\035)]TJ -73.473 -14.776 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(We)-463(find)-463(indications)-463(of)-463(these)-463(superstitions)-463(throughout)-464(the)]TJ -16.799 -13.55 Td [(Gospels.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 37.877 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.527 0 Td [(To)-338(this)-337(observation)-338(I)-338(invite)-337(the)-338(reader's)-338(attention.)-513(Is)]TJ -46.404 -13.549 Td [(it)-329(meant)-329(to)-330(be)-329(affirmed)-329(that)-329(any)-329(indication)-330(can)-329(be)-329(found)-329(in)-329(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-334(that)-334(the)-334(writers)-334(believed)-334(that)-334(a)-334(demon)-334(inhabited)-334(every)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(private)-237(closet)-238(in)-237(the)-237(world?)-246(Two)-238(instances)-237(only)-237(are)-238(referred)-237(to)-237(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-285(text,)-295(in)-285(one)-285(of)-285(which)-286(the)-285(demoniac)-285(of)-286(Gadara)-285(is)-285(represented)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-372(dwelling)-373(among)-372(the)-373(tombs,)-403(and)-372(as)-372(having)-373(been)-372(driven)-372(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-378(wilderness;)-441(and)-378(the)-378(other)-377(the)-378(parable)-377(of)-378(the)-378(unclean)-377(spirit)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(going)-260(out)-261(of)-260(the)-260(man,)-263(and)-260(finding)-260(no)-261(rest)-260(when)-260(walking)-260(through)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dry)-310(places.)-432(Do)-310(these)-311(two)-310(cases)-310(prove)-311(the)-310(truth)-311(of)-310(the)-310(sweeping)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assertions)-316(above)-316(referred)-316(to?)-448(Does)-316(the)-316(parabolic)-315(representation)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-415(the)-415(expelled)-414(demon)-415(found)-415(no)-415(rest)-414(in)-415(dry)-415(or)-415(clean)-414(places)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prove)-267(that)-268(the)-267(disciples)-267(of)-267(Jesus)-267(believed)-268(that)-267(they)-267(took)-267(especial)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(delight)-210(in)-211(foul)-210(or)-210(offensive)-211(ones?)-237(Does)-210(the)-210(fact)-211(that)-210(the)-210(demoniac)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-299(Gadara)-298(had)-299(been)-298(driven)-299(by)-299(the)-298(evil)-299(spirit)-298(into)-299(the)-298(wilderness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prove)-289(that)-288(it)-289(was)-289(a)-288(universal)-289(belief)-289(that)-288(deserts)-289(and)-289(graves)-288(were)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(haunted)-250(by)-250(demons?)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(In)-326(proof)-326(also)-326(of)-326(these)-327(assertions)-326(we)-326(are)-326(referred)-326(in)-326(a)-326(note)-326(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(five)-311(passages)-310(in)-311(the)-310(Gospels,)-326(viz.)-431(Matt.)-432(viii.)-431(28;)-341(xii.)-432(43;)-340(Mark)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(v.)-433(3-5;)-342(Luke)-311(viii.)-434(27-29;)-341(xi.)-434(24.)-433(Five)-311(passages)-311(are)-311(very)-311(few)-311(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(justify)-198(the)-198(assertion)-198(that)-198(we)-198(find)-198(indications)-198(of)-198(these)-197(superstitions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(throughout)-296(the)-295(Gospels.)-386(On)-296(examining)-295(them,)-307(however,)-307(the)-295(five)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
907 0 obj <<
/Length 5393      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(194)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(references)-256(are)-256(reduced)-256(to)-256(two,)-257(three)-256(belong)-256(to)-256(the)-256(account)-256(of)-255(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demoniac)-259(at)-258(Gadara,)-261(reported)-258(by)-259(each)-258(of)-259(the)-258(Synoptics;)-263(and)-258(two)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-177(the)-176(twofold)-177(report)-176(of)-177(the)-176(same)-177(parable)-176(as)-177(given)-176(by)-177(Matthew)-176(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Luke!)-348(This)-282(is)-283(a)-282(very)-282(slender)-283(foundation)-282(on)-283(which)-282(to)-283(ground)-282(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(assertion)-251(that)-250(the)-251(followers)-250(of)-251(Jesus)-250(believed)-251(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 216.986 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(demons)-501(took)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -294.584 0 Td [([219])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(especial)-275(delight)-274(in)-275(foul)-275(and)-275(offensive)-274(places,)-281(that)-275(they)-274(inhabited)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(every)-264(private)-265(closet)-264(in)-264(the)-264(world,)-268(and)-265(that)-264(they)-264(haunted)-264(deserted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(places,)-260(graves,)-259(ruins,)-260(and)-257(certain)-258(kinds)-257(of)-258(trees,)-260(and)-257(that)-258(we)-257(find)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(indications)-250(of)-250(these)-250(superstitions)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 145.451 0 Td [(throughout)-250(the)-250(Gospels)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 102.425 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -238.647 -14.777 Td [(Still)-196(more)-197(extraordinary)-196(is)-196(the)-197(next)-196(reference.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 197.456 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Demons)-196(haunt-)]TJ -214.256 -13.549 Td [(ed)-271(springs)-272(and)-271(fountains,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 109.78 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.805 0 Td [(says)-271(the)-272(author.)-314(To)-271(this)-272(he)-271(adds,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 144.871 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(the)]TJ -267.299 -13.549 Td [(episode)-279(of)-278(the)-279(angel)-278(who)-278(was)-279(said)-278(to)-279(descend)-278(at)-279(certain)-278(seasons)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-362(trouble)-361(the)-362(water)-362(of)-361(the)-362(pool)-361(of)-362(Bethesda,)-390(so)-361(that)-362(he)-361(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first)-266(stepped)-265(in)-266(was)-265(cured)-266(of)-266(whatsoever)-265(disease)-266(he)-265(had,)-270(may)-265(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mentioned)-250(in)-250(passing.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 95.455 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -83.499 -14.777 Td [(Why,)-340(I)-322(ask,)-339(mention)-322(it)-322(at)-322(all?)-466(Is)-321(the)-322(visit)-322(of)-322(an)-322(angel)-322(to)-321(this)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(particular)-235(pool)-236(for)-235(the)-235(purpose)-236(of)-235(working)-235(a)-236(miracle,)-238(a)-235(proof)-235(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-223(followers)-223(of)-223(our)-222(Lord)-223(believed)-223(that)-223(demons)-223(inhabited)-222(springs)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(fountains?)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(But)-201(our)-201(astonishment)-201(at)-200(the)-201(author's)-201(reference)-201(to)-201(it)-201(is)-200(increased)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(when)-233(we)-233(read)-233(the)-233(following)-233(words:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 155.918 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Although)-233(the)-233(passage)-233(is)-233(not)]TJ -160.762 -13.549 Td [(found)-324(in)-324(the)-325(oldest)-324(manuscripts)-324(of)-324(the)-324(Fourth)-324(Gospel,)-343(and)-324(it)-324(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certainly)-250(a)-250(late)-250(interpolation)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 125.76 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -116.531 -14.777 Td [(I)-185(must)-184(put)-185(the)-185(question)-185(again)-184(in)-185(real)-185(earnestness.)-228(This)-185(being)-184(so,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(why)-216(mention)-215(it)-216(here?)-238(The)-216(author)-215(admits)-215(that)-216(it)-215(formed)-216(no)-215(portion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-212(the)-213(original)-212(Gospel)-212(of)-212(St.)-238(John,)-220(and)-212(that)-212(it)-212(is)-213(certainly)-212(a)-212(late)-212(in-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(terpolation.)-234(Now)-201(the)-201(Gospel)-202(of)-201(St.)-234(John,)-211(according)-201(to)-201(the)-201(opinion)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-311(the)-310(most)-311(eminent)-311(unbelievers,)-326(was)-310(not)-311(published)-311(before)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 263.667 0 Td [(A)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(D)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.755 0 Td [(.)]TJ -277.903 -13.549 Td [(170.)-536(If)-346(this)-345(was)-345(the)-346(case)-345(\050the)-345(author)-346(himself)-345(evidently)-345(assigns)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-263(its)-263(composition)-263(a)-263(very)-263(late)-263(date\051)-263(a)-263(late)-263(interpolation)-263(could)-263(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-263(found)-263(its)-263(way)-263(into)-263(its)-263(pages)-263(until)-263(about)-262(the)-263(year)-263(250,)-267(at)-262(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(earliest)-268(200.)-303(What)-268(then)-267(is)-268(the)-268(nature)-268(of)-267(the)-268(reasoning)-268(before)-267(us?)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(We)-309(are)-309(referred)-309(for)-309(proof)-309(that)-309(the)-309(followers)-309(of)-309(Jesus)-309(held)-309(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opinions)-239(to)-240(an)-239(authority)-239(which)-239(the)-239(author)-240(himself)-239(admits)-239(to)-239(have)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
911 0 obj <<
/Length 4961      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(195)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(been)-259(a)-258(late)-259(interpolation,)-521(which)-259(could)-259(not)-258(have)-259(been)-258(introduced)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([220])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(into)-314(this)-313(Gospel)-314(earlier)-314(than)-313(180)-314(years)-314(after)-313(the)-314(ministry)-314(of)-313(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Lord,)-254(as)-253(a)-254(proof)-253(that)-253(his)-253(original)-254(followers)-253(believed)-253(that)-253(demons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inhabited)-362(springs)-361(and)-362(fountains.)-585(Such)-361(reasonings)-362(furnish)-361(their)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(own)-250(refutation.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(The)-319(exposure)-319(of)-319(one)-318(more)-319(fallacy)-319(of)-319(this)-319(description)-319(will)-318(be)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(sufficient.)-646(We)-382(are)-382(told)-382(that,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 132.538 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Not)-382(only)-382(one)-382(evil)-382(spirit)-382(entered)]TJ -137.381 -13.549 Td [(into)-348(a)-348(body,)-372(but)-348(many)-347(took)-348(possession)-348(of)-348(the)-348(same)-347(individual.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(There)-437(are)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 48.294 0 Td [(many)-437(instances)-437(mentioned)-437(in)-437(the)-437(Gospels)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 190.482 0 Td [(,)-484(such)-437(as)]TJ -238.776 -13.549 Td [(Mary)-228(Magdalene,)-232(out)-227(of)-228(whom)-227(went)-228(seven)-227(demons,)-232(and)-228(the)-227(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whose)-251(name)-251(was)-250(legion,)-251(because)-251(many)-251(demons)-251(had)-251(entered)-250(into)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(him.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.702 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -7.746 -15.185 Td [(I)-272(ask,)-278(where)-273(are)-272(these)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 98.21 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(many)-272(instances)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 67.204 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(?)-317(The)-273(plain)-272(fact)-272(must)]TJ -187.058 -13.549 Td [(be)-301(stated,)-315(that)-301(the)-301(two)-302(here)-301(referred)-301(to,)-314(constitute)-302(the)-301(only)-301(ones)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-306(are)-306(mentioned)-306(as)-307(facts)-306(by)-306(the)-306(Evangelists.)-418(Besides)-306(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(there)-362(is)-361(the)-362(parable)-362(of)-361(the)-362(unclean)-361(spirit)-362(going)-362(out)-361(of)-362(the)-361(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(above)-350(alluded)-349(to,)-375(who,)-374(when)-350(he)-349(could)-350(find)-350(no)-349(rest)-350(returned)-349(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-309(former)-309(habitation)-310(in)-309(company)-309(with)-309(seven)-309(other)-309(spirits)-309(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wicked)-362(than)-361(himself.)-585(It)-361(should)-361(be)-362(observed)-361(that)-362(in)-361(two)-362(of)-361(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(cases)-406(the)-405(number)-406(given)-406(is)-405(the)-406(mystical)-405(number)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 220.222 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Seven)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 26.661 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(;)-483(and)]TJ -256.571 -13.549 Td [(that)-335(one)-335(of)-335(them)-334(occurs)-335(in)-335(a)-335(parable,)-356(the)-335(moral)-335(of)-335(which)-334(is,)-356(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(warn)-343(the)-344(Jews,)-366(that)-344(although)-343(they)-343(had)-344(got)-343(rid)-343(of)-344(the)-343(evil)-343(spirit)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-253(idolatry,)-254(they)-252(were)-253(in)-253(danger)-253(of)-253(falling)-253(into)-253(the)-253(greater)-253(evil)-252(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Phariseeism)-250(and)-250(hypocrisy.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-289(to)-289(return)-289(to)-289(the)-289(argument.)-367(The)-289(great)-289(mass)-289(of)-289(the)-289(author's)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(citations)-301(for)-302(the)-301(purpose)-302(of)-301(proving)-301(that)-302(the)-301(Jews)-301(at)-302(the)-301(time)-301(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-253(Advent,)-254(and)-253(among)-253(them)-253(the)-253(followers)-253(of)-253(Jesus,)-254(were)-253(a)-253(prey)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-347(these)-347(grotesque)-347(beliefs)-347(respecting)-347(the)-347(action)-346(of)-347(demons,)-371(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-251(from)-251(authors)-251(who)-251(are)-251(separated)-251(by)-251(an)-251(interval)-251(of)-250(centuries)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-399(the)-400(ministry)-399(of)-399(our)-400(Lord.)-698(I)-399(submit,)-436(therefore,)-437(that)-399(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authorities)-312(are)-311(utterly)-312(valueless)-312(to)-311(prove)-312(that)-623(His)-312(disciples)-311(and)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([221])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(early)-268(followers)-267(were)-268(a)-268(prey)-268(to)-267(these)-268(gross)-268(delusions.)-303(Nor)-268(has)-267(he)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(adduced)-298(an)-298(atom)-298(of)-298(valid)-298(proof)-298(from)-298(the)-298(New)-298(Testament)-297(itself.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-429(references)-429(above)-429(referred)-429(to)-429(have)-429(either)-429(been)-429(made)-429(in)-429(a)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
917 0 obj <<
/Length 4313      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(196)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(most)-330(careless)-329(manner,)-350(or)-329(have)-330(been)-329(used)-330(to)-330(assist)-329(in)-330(proving)-329(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(foregone)-250(conclusion.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(But)-421(let)-421(us)-421(suppose)-421(for)-421(the)-421(sake)-421(of)-421(argument)-421(that)-421(the)-421(Jews)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(at)-317(the)-318(time)-317(of)-317(our)-317(Lord)-317(did)-318(generally)-317(entertain)-317(these)-317(monstrous)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(demoniacal)-433(beliefs:)-616(to)-433(what)-434(conclusion,)-478(I)-433(ask,)-479(would)-433(such)-433(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact,)-532(if)-475(true,)-532(indubitably)-476(point?)-926(Credulous)-476(and)-475(superstitions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(people,)-236(invariably)-231(invent)-232(stories)-232(that)-232(are)-232(the)-232(counterparts)-232(of)-231(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(own)-401(credulity.)-702(This)-401(is)-401(proved)-401(by)-400(the)-401(whole)-401(mass)-401(of)-400(existing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mythology.)-241(Mythological)-225(inventions)-224(give)-224(us)-225(the)-224(precise)-224(measure)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-387(the)-388(beliefs)-387(of)-387(those)-387(who)-388(have)-387(originated)-387(them.)-662(If)-387(then)-387(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demonology)-291(of)-291(those)-291(who)-290(have)-291(elaborated)-291(these)-291(portions)-291(of)-290(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-289(was)-288(of)-289(the)-288(character)-289(that)-289(this)-288(writer)-289(and)-288(others)-289(assert)-288(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-251(have)-250(been,)-251(the)-251(Gospels)-251(would)-250(have)-251(contained)-251(an)-250(embodiment)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-440(such)-439(demoniacal)-440(beliefs)-439(as)-440(those)-439(which)-440(the)-439(author)-440(has)-439(so)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(industriously)-219(collected,)-225(and)-219(has)-218(endeavoured)-219(to)-219(fasten)-219(upon)-218(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writers.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(Now)-202(the)-202(idea)-202(of)-202(demonology)-202(having)-202(been)-202(present)-202(in)-202(the)-202(minds)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-325(the)-325(writers,)-344(it)-326(is)-325(obvious)-325(that)-325(they)-326(did)-325(not)-325(omit)-325(all)-325(reference)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-395(these)-395(absurd)-395(beliefs,)-431(merely)-395(because)-395(they)-395(were)-395(outside)-395(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(subject)-211(on)-210(which)-211(they)-211(were)-210(writing.)-237(But)-211(while)-211(demoniacal)-210(action)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-243(repeatedly)-244(alluded)-243(to,)-245(it)-243(is)-244(an)-243(undeniable)-244(fact)-243(that)-244(no)-243(stories)-243(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-260(description)-261(given)-260(by)-260(this)-261(writer)-260(are)-260(to)-261(be)-260(found)-260(in)-261(them.)-280(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(author)-190(therefore)-191(has)-190(furnished)-190(the)-191(most)-190(conclusive)-190(proof,)-202(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intending)-309(to)-308(do)-309(so,)-323(that)-308(these)-309(forms)-308(of)-309(thought,)-323(to)-308(whomsoever)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(else)-191(they)-192(may)-191(have)-192(appertained,)-203(were)-191(neither)-191(those)-192(of)-191(the)-191(original)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(followers)-250(of)-250(Jesus,)-250(nor)-250(of)-250(the)-250(authors)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Gospels.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([222])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -13.549 Td [(It)-191(follows)-191(therefore)-191(that)-191(this)-191(attempt)-191(to)-191(prove)-191(that)-191(the)-190(followers)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-304(our)-304(Lord)-304(and)-304(the)-304(authors)-304(of)-304(the)-304(Gospels)-304(were)-304(a)-304(prey)-304(to)-304(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-317(mass)-317(of)-316(grotesque)-317(beliefs)-317(respecting)-317(demons,)-333(as)-317(to)-316(invalidate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-330(historical)-330(testimony,)-349(falls)-330(to)-330(the)-329(ground,)-350(and)-330(that)-330(the)-329(data)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-264(which)-264(this)-265(has)-264(been)-264(attempted)-264(to)-264(be)-265(established,)-267(afford)-264(proof)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-235(the)-236(contrary)-235(that)-235(they)-236(did)-235(not)-235(entertain)-236(the)-235(beliefs)-235(in)-235(question.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -29.651 Td [([223])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
926 0 obj <<
/Length 3809      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-264(X.)-264(The)-264(Existence)-264(And)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Miracles)-250(Of)-250(Satan.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -35.158 Td [(I)-274(fully)-274(admit)-273(that)-274(a)-274(difficulty)-274(is)-274(involved)-273(in)-274(the)-274(idea)-274(that)-274(a)-273(being)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(like)-417(Satan)-418(is)-417(permitted)-417(to)-418(perform)-417(actions)-417(which)-418(bear)-417(even)-417(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(remote)-236(analogy)-236(to)-236(divine)-236(miracles.)-245(I)-236(have)-236(already)-236(shown)-236(that)-235(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(New)-341(Testament)-341(only)-342(apparently)-341(ascribes)-341(to)-341(him)-341(a)-341(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-297(of)-296(a)-297(very)-297(limited)-296(and)-297(special)-297(kind,)-308(differing)-297(widely)-296(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-255(usual)-255(conception)-255(of)-255(a)-254(miracle.)-265(I)-255(now)-255(proceed)-255(to)-255(inquire)-254(how)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(far)-277(this)-277(limited)-277(act)1(ion,)-284(thus)-277(attributed)-277(to)-276(him,)-284(if)-277(we)-277(suppose)-276(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(possession)-386(was)-386(an)-386(objective)-387(fact,)-420(and)-386(not)-386(a)-386(form)-386(of)-386(madness,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interferes)-351(with)-350(the)-351(validity)-350(of)-351(the)-350(attestation)-351(of)-350(miracles)-351(to)-350(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-250(revelation.)]TJ 11.956 -14.096 Td [(The)-189(existence)-189(of)-188(a)-189(being)-189(like)-189(Satan)-188(is)-189(alleged)-189(as)-189(constituting)-188(an)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(enormous)-178(difficulty)-178(against)-177(the)-178(statements)-178(of)-178(the)-178(New)-177(Testament.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(A)-278(numerous)-279(class)-278(of)-278(writers)-279(dismiss)-278(the)-278(idea)-279(of)-278(his)-278(existence)-278(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unworthy)-377(of)-377(serious)-376(argument,)-409(and)-376(endeavour)-377(to)-377(dispose)-377(of)-376(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-276(a)-275(sneer.)-327(This)-276(world)-276(however)-275(contains)-276(numerous)-275(analogous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cases)-242(of)-243(very)-242(evil)-242(men)-243(endowed)-242(with)-242(the)-243(highest)-242(mental)-242(powers,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(who)-271(have)-271(exerted)-270(the)-271(most)-271(injurious)-271(influences)-270(on)-271(others.)-312(Their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-267(is)-268(a)-267(fact;)-276(and)-268(the)-267(difficulties)-268(attending)-267(it)-268(cannot)-267(be)-267(got)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rid)-383(of)-383(by)-383(any)-383(kind)-383(of)-383(evasion.)-649(The)-383(objections)-383(that)-383(have)-382(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(urged)-213(in)-212(connection)-213(with)-213(this)-212(subject)-213(are)-213(not)-212(founded)-213(on)-213(the)-212(facts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-374(the)-373(moral)-374(universe)-373(as)-374(they)-373(exist;)-435(but)-374(on)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 198.539 0 Td [(\340)-374(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 39.066 0 Td [(principles)]TJ -237.605 -13.55 Td [(alone.)-439(It)-313(has)-313(been)-313(affirmed)-313(to)-313(be)-313(incredible)-313(that)-313(Almighty)-313(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-482(have)-241(permitted)-241(the)-241(existence)-241(of)-241(such)-241(a)-241(being)-241(as)-241(Satan;)-244(or)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([224])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(if)-305(his)-305(existence)-305(is)-305(permitted,)-319(that)-305(he)-305(can)-305(be)-305(allowed)-304(to)-305(interfere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(the)-250(affairs)-250(of)-250(men.)]TJ 11.956 -14.097 Td [(In)-284(dealing)-285(with)-284(this)-285(question)-284(it)-285(is)-285(evident)-284(that)-285(I)-284(must)-284(proceed)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(on)-378(the)-377(supposition)-378(that)-377(I)-378(am)-377(reasoning)-378(with)-377(theists)-378(only.)-632(The)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
930 0 obj <<
/Length 4810      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(198)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(whole)-377(question)-377(is)-377(irrelevant)-377(on)-377(the)-377(principles)-377(of)-377(Pantheism)-377(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Atheism,)-331(or,)-331(to)-315(put)-315(the)-315(case)-315(more)-315(distinctly,)-332(on)-314(such)-315(principles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(there)-223(is)-223(no)-223(greater)-222(difficulty)-223(in)-223(supposing)-223(that)-223(nature)-223(has)-222(evolved)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evil)-238(beings)-238(superior)-238(to)-237(men)-238(in)-238(their)-238(faculties)-238(and)-238(powers)-238(in)-237(some)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(other)-246(part)-245(of)-246(the)-246(universe,)-247(than)-245(that)-246(it)-246(has)-245(evolved)-246(evil)-246(men,)-246(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-364(gifted)-364(with)-364(high)-364(forms)-364(of)-364(intelligence)-364(in)-364(this;)-421(or)-364(even)-363(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-362(beings)-362(should)-362(be)-362(capable)-362(of)-362(interfering)-362(in)-362(human)-361(affairs.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(If)-306(Pantheism)-306(or)-307(Atheism)-306(is)-306(a)-306(correct)-306(account)-307(of)-306(the)-306(facts)-306(of)-306(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(universe,)-281(it)-275(is)-275(impossible)-275(to)-275(say)-275(what)-275(kind)-275(of)-275(beings)-275(nature)-275(may)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-330(evolved)-330(in)-330(the)-330(past,)-350(or)-330(may)-330(evolve)-330(in)-330(the)-330(future)-330(from)-329(her)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prolific)-250(womb.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-395(if)-395(it)-395(is)-395(once)-395(conceded)-395(that)-395(a)-395(personal)-395(God)-395(exists,)-431(who)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-329(the)-330(moral)-329(Governor)-329(of)-329(the)-330(Universe,)-349(the)-329(affirmation)-329(that)-329(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-407(of)-406(such)-406(beings)-407(is)-406(inconsistent)-407(with)-406(his)-407(attributes,)-445(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-258(another)-258(form)-258(of)-259(asserting)-258(that)-258(the)-258(existence)-258(of)-258(moral)-258(evil)-258(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(incompatible)-352(with)-351(them.)-554(The)-352(ground)-351(of)-352(its)-351(existence)-352(has)-351(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-318(problem,)-336(into)-318(which)-318(the)-318(human)-319(mind)-318(has)-318(striven)-318(to)-318(penetrate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-317(the)-317(earliest)-316(dawn)-317(of)-317(thought,)-333(without)-317(ever)-317(approaching)-316(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-352(solution;)-402(but)-351(into)-352(this)-352(question)-351(it)-352(is)-351(useless)-352(to)-351(enter.)-555(In)-351(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(present)-377(argument)-377(we)-377(are)-377(dealing)-377(with)-377(facts,)-409(and)-377(the)-377(existence)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-364(aggravated)-363(forms)-364(of)-364(moral)-363(evil)-364(in)-364(the)-363(universe)-364(is)-364(a)-363(fact.)-591(If)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(there)-245(be)-246(a)-245(God,)-247(it)-245(must)-246(be)-245(consistent)-246(with)-245(his)-246(attributes.)-248(The)-245(real)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difficulty)-257(lies)-257(in)-256(its)-257(existence)-257(at)-257(all)-257(in)-256(the)-257(universe)-257(of)-257(a)-257(God)-256(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-250(all-powerful)-250(and)-250(good.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-256(since)-255(it)-256(does)-256(exist,)-257(the)-256(existence)-255(of)-256(a)-256(being)-255(like)-256(Satan)-256(is)-255(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(mere)-319(question)-318(of)-319(degree.)-456(It)-319(is)-319(an)-318(unquestionable)-638(fact,)-335(whether)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([225])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(we)-434(can)-434(explain)-434(it)-434(or)-435(not,)-480(that)-434(many)-434(men)-434(of)-434(the)-434(worst)-434(moral)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(principles)-275(have)-275(been)-275(gifted)-275(with)-275(the)-275(highest)-275(intellectual)-275(powers,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-245(have)-245(been)-245(placed)-246(in)-245(positions)-245(in)-245(society)-245(which)-245(have)-245(enabled)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-434(to)-434(inflict)-434(the)-434(greatest)-434(evil)-434(on)-434(others.)-802(History)-434(is)-434(full)-434(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-306(cases.)-419(The)-306(most)-306(extreme)-307(forms)-306(of)-306(human)-306(corruption)-306(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-313(not)-312(inaptly)-313(designated)-313(as)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 137.646 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Satanic.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 34.844 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.255 0 Td [(If)-313(therefore)-312(under)-313(the)]TJ -185.589 -13.55 Td [(moral)-306(government)-306(of)-306(God)-306(it)-306(is)-306(a)-306(fact)-306(that)-306(such)-306(forms)-306(of)-306(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wickedness)-408(exist;)-487(and)-409(if)-408(it)-408(is)-408(supposable,)-448(that)-408(there)-408(are)-408(other)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
934 0 obj <<
/Length 4818      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(X.)-250(The)-250(Existence)-250(And)-250(Miracles)-250(Of)-250(Satan.)-4145(199)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(rational)-235(beings)-236(in)-235(the)-235(universe)-235(endowed)-236(with)-235(higher)-235(powers)-235(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man,)-313(how)-300(can)-300(it)-300(be)-300(inconceivable)-300(that)-299(they)-300(may)-300(differ)-300(in)-300(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character,)-340(precisely)-321(in)-322(the)-321(same)-322(way)-322(as)-321(men)-322(do;)-357(and)-322(that)-321(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-369(be)-369(eminently)-369(virtuous,)-399(and)-369(others)-369(fearfully)-369(corrupt?)-607(It)-369(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(clear)-412(that)-412(the)-412(difficulty)-411(centres)-412(in)-412(the)-412(existence)-412(of)-412(moral)-411(evil)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-352(the)-351(universe)-352(of)-351(a)-352(God)-351(who)-351(is)-352(possessed)-351(of)-352(almighty)-351(power,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-367(perfect)-367(holiness)-366(and)-367(goodness.)-600(Why)-367(has)-367(He)-367(permitted)-366(it?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Is)-375(its)-374(existence)-375(a)-374(necessary)-375(condition)-375(of)-374(the)-375(creation)-374(of)-375(a)-374(free)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-264(agent?)-292(If)-264(so,)-268(might)-264(not)-264(the)-264(amount)-264(of)-264(it)-264(have)-264(been)-264(greatly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(diminished?)-683(The)-394(utmost)-395(light)-394(that)-394(reason)-395(can)-394(throw)-394(on)-394(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(questions)-403(consists)-404(of)-403(a)-403(few)-404(very)-403(imperfect)-403(glimmerings.)-710(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-295(is)-295(undeniable,)-306(that)-295(a)-295(large)-295(mass)-295(of)-295(moral)-294(evil)-295(exists,)-307(and)-294(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(very)-372(fearful)-371(forms.)-615(If)-371(there)-372(be)-371(a)-372(Creator)-371(of)-372(the)-371(universe,)-402(it)-371(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(plain)-288(that)-288(the)-288(present)-289(state)-288(of)-288(things)-288(must)-288(be)-288(consistent)-288(with)-288(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(attributes.)-397(The)-299(only)-299(mode)-299(of)-299(escaping)-299(from)-299(this)-299(difficulty)-299(is)-298(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taking)-250(refuge)-250(in)-250(the)-250(vastly)-250(greater)-250(ones)-250(of)-250(pantheism)-250(or)-250(atheism.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Many)-419(theists,)-462(pressed)-420(by)-419(these)-419(difficulties,)-462(have)-419(attempted)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-334(evade)-334(them)-334(by)-334(endeavouring)-334(to)-334(reduce)-334(the)-334(amount)-334(of)-334(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evil)-272(in)-273(the)-272(universe,)-278(the)-272(existence)-272(of)-273(which)-272(they)-272(cannot)-273(deny,)-277(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(indefinitely)-286(small)-287(proportions,)-295(and)-287(then)-286(affirming)-286(that)-287(it)-286(will)-286(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ultimately)-479(swallowed)-240(up)-240(in)-239(the)-240(ocean)-240(of)-240(universal)-239(good.)-247(But)-239(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([226])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(mere)-261(diminishing)-262(of)-261(its)-262(amount)-261(by)-262(no)-261(means)-262(solves)-261(the)-261(difficul-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ty.)-534(The)-345(real)-345(question)-345(is,)-368(how)-345(has)-344(it)-345(come)-345(even)-345(into)-344(temporary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence?)-463(But)-321(there)-320(is)-321(also)-321(a)-321(still)-321(more)-321(grave)-321(objection)-321(to)-320(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(course)-272(of)-271(reasoning.)-315(It)-271(renders)-272(it)-271(necessary)-272(that)-271(we)-272(should)-271(close)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(our)-339(eyes)-339(to)-340(the)-339(most)-339(obvious)-339(facts.)-518(S)1(o)-340(far)-339(is)-339(it)-339(from)-339(being)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(case)-248(that)-248(the)-249(amount)-248(of)-248(moral)-248(evil)-249(in)-248(the)-248(world)-248(is)-248(small,)-249(that)-248(it)-248(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(very)-238(large.)-246(This)-238(fact)-238(is)-238(indisputable.)-246(The)-238(whole)-238(course)-238(of)-237(history)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tells)-261(us)-261(that)-261(it)-261(has)-262(existed)-261(in)-261(all)-261(past)-261(ages)-261(and)-261(in)-261(very)-261(aggravated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forms.)-284(To)-261(try)-262(to)-261(get)-261(rid)-261(of)-262(the)-261(difficulty)-261(in)-262(this)-261(manner)-261(is)-261(simply)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(close)-250(our)-250(eyes,)-250(and)-250(refuse)-250(to)-250(see)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-455(not)-456(only)-455(does)-456(moral,)-506(but)-456(physical)-455(evil)-456(exist.)-866(This)-455(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(another)-328(unquestionable)-329(fact,)-348(and)-328(its)-328(existence)-329(bears)-328(directly)-328(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(my)-276(argument.)-328(Many)-276(and)-276(vain)-276(have)-276(been)-276(the)-276(attempts)-276(to)-275(explain)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
938 0 obj <<
/Length 4862      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(200)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(it)-299(away.)-396(It)-299(has)-298(been)-299(affirmed)-299(that)-298(pain)-299(after)-299(all)-298(is)-299(no)-299(such)-298(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(matter.)-789(I)-430(strongly)-430(suspect)-430(that)-429(those)-430(who)-430(have)-430(asserted)-429(this,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-292(experienced)-292(but)-292(little)-292(of)-292(it.)-376(It)-292(is)-292(true)-292(that)-292(it)-292(may)-291(ultimately)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(result)-381(in)-382(good)-381(under)-382(God's)-381(government,)-414(but)-381(taken)-382(by)-381(itself,)-414(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-344(undeniably)-345(an)-344(evil.)-534(Do)-344(not)-344(frightful)-345(sufferings)-344(abound?)-533(Do)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-348(most)-347(painful)-348(diseases)-348(afflict)-347(our)-348(frames?)-543(Is)-347(it)-348(not)-347(possible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-482(suffer)-483(terribly)-482(from)-482(causes)-482(quite)-483(independent)-482(of)-482(our)-482(own)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conduct?)-530(Is)-343(not)-343(a)-344(great)-343(earthquake)-343(a)-344(terrible)-343(calamity)-343(to)-343(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-394(suffer)-395(from)-394(its)-394(effects,)-430(although)-395(it)-394(may)-394(be)-394(attended)-394(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(beneficial)-298(results)-298(to)-298(those)-298(who)-298(do)-298(not?)-394(Pains)-298(may)-298(be)-298(said)-298(to)-297(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(useful)-306(warnings;)-334(but)-307(surely)-306(the)-306(warning)-306(might)-306(have)-306(been)-306(given)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-258(the)-257(extremity)-258(of)-257(the)-258(suffering.)-272(They)-258(are)-257(also)-258(affirmed)-257(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-269(the)-268(penalties)-269(of)-269(ignorance,)-273(and)-269(this)-268(may)-269(be)-269(partially)-268(true:)-287(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-312(ignorance)-312(is)-312(in)-312(a)-312(vast)-312(majority)-312(of)-312(cases)-312(unavoidable.)-436(It)-311(is)-312(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(simple)-282(fact,)-291(that)-282(a)-282(great)-283(amount)-282(of)-282(physical)-283(suffering)-282(exists,)-290(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason)-250(of)-250(which)-250(we)-250(are)-250(wholly)-250(unable)-250(to)-250(explain.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([227])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -18.459 Td [(But)-309(further:)-369(moral)-309(evil)-309(propagates)-310(itself,)-324(and)-309(inflicts)-309(calami-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ties)-358(on)-357(those)-358(who)-357(are)-358(not)-357(implicated)-358(in)-358(its)-357(guilt.)-573(Is)-357(it)-358(not)-357(true)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-403(men)-404(have)-403(existed)-403(both)-404(in)-403(the)-403(ancient)-404(and)-403(modern)-403(world,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whose)-359(actions)-358(have)-359(inflicted)-359(the)-359(greatest)-358(evils)-359(on)-359(mankind)-358(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(generation)-236(after)-236(generation?)-245(Can)-236(any)-236(one)-236(doubt)-236(that)-236(descendants)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(suffer)-384(for)-383(the)-384(sins)-383(of)-384(remote)-384(ancestors,)-417(and)-383(children)-384(for)-383(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-318(their)-317(parents?)-453(Facts)-318(are)-318(facts,)-334(and)-318(they)-317(will)-318(not)-318(become)-317(less)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-355(by)-356(our)-355(refusing)-356(to)-355(look)-356(at)-355(them.)-567(The)-355(evil)-356(wrought)-355(by)-355(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-375(man)-375(as)-375(Philip)-374(II.)-375(of)-375(Spain,)-406(is)-375(a)-375(fact,)-406(and)-375(it)-375(has)-375(extended)-374(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(baneful)-276(influence)-277(to)-276(our)-276(own)-276(times.)-329(Is)-276(not)-276(a)-277(large)-276(portion)-276(of)-276(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evils)-251(under)-251(which)-251(France)-251(has)-251(groaned,)-251(traceable)-251(to)-251(the)-250(misdeeds)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-334(two)-334(of)-334(her)-334(sovereigns?)-502(These)-334(were)-334(quietly)-334(sleeping)-334(in)-333(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(graves,)-282(when)-275(the)-275(evils)-276(they)-275(had)-276(occasioned)-275(burst)-275(on)-276(the)-275(head)-275(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-354(guiltless)-354(successor.)-561(But)-354(it)-354(is)-354(needless)-354(to)-354(quote)-353(examples.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(History)-344(is)-345(one)-344(long)-345(succession)-344(of)-345(them.)-533(Whether)-344(we)-345(like)-344(it)-344(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not,)-448(the)-409(old)-409(saying)-409(is)-408(an)-409(accurate)-409(account)-408(of)-409(the)-409(moral)-408(order)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-343(the)-344(universe)-343(as)-343(it)-344(exists,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 124.837 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Visiting)-343(the)-344(sins)-343(of)-343(the)-344(fathers)-343(on)]TJ -129.681 -13.549 Td [(the)-389(children)-390(unto)-389(the)-390(third)-389(and)-390(fourth)-389(generation)-390(of)-389(them)-389(that)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
942 0 obj <<
/Length 4842      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(X.)-250(The)-250(Existence)-250(And)-250(Miracles)-250(Of)-250(Satan.)-4145(201)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(hate)-340(me,)-362(and)-340(showing)-340(mercy)-340(unto)-340(thousands)-340(of)-340(them)-340(that)-339(love)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(me,)-413(and)-380(keep)-380(my)-380(commandments.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 155.1 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.989 0 Td [(These)-380(are)-380(facts)-380(which)-380(the)]TJ -164.089 -13.549 Td [(theist)-300(equally)-299(with)-300(the)-300(Christian)-300(must)-299(face,)-313(for)-299(they)-300(exist)-300(in)-299(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(universe)-264(of)-264(that)-265(God,)-267(in)-264(whose)-265(moral)-264(perfections)-264(both)-264(believe.)-292(I)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(repeat,)-284(therefore,)-284(that)-277(the)-278(only)-277(way)-277(of)-277(escaping)-278(from)-277(them)-277(is)-277(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rushing)-250(into)-250(the)-250(far)-250(greater)-250(difficulties)-250(of)-250(pantheism)-250(or)-250(atheism.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(These)-326(reasonings)-327(might)-326(be)-327(indefinitely)-326(extended.)-479(The)-327(resul)1(t)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(which)-344(follows)-345(from)-344(them)-344(is)-345(clear,)-368(that)-344(if)-344(we)-345(attempt)-344(to)-344(reason)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-431(abstract)-431(principles)-430(to)-431(the)-431(constitution)-431(of)-431(a)-430(universe,)-476(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(shall)-392(produce)-392(one)-392(utterly)-391(unlike)-392(that)-392(which)-392(actually)-392(exists.)-675(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(follows,)-244(that)-243(as)-243(they)-243(cannot)-243(account)-243(for)-243(the)-243(facts)-243(of)-243(the)-243(universe,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-600(they)-300(come)-300(under)-300(our)-301(observation,)-312(they)-300(are)-300(unsafe)-300(guides)-300(on)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([228])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(all)-265(similar)-266(questions.)-296(Consequently)-266(they)-265(are)-266(unable)-265(to)-266(show)-265(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-263(existence)-262(of)-263(evil)-263(beings)-262(possessed)-263(of)-263(superhuman)-263(powers,)-265(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inconsistent)-250(with)-250(the)-250(perfections)-250(of)-250(God.)]TJ 11.955 -15.186 Td [(Nor)-380(is)-381(there)-380(any)-381(greater)-380(force)-381(in)-380(the)-381(objection,)-413(that)-380(if)-380(such)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(beings)-300(exist)-299(at)-300(all,)-312(it)-300(is)-299(inconsistent)-300(with)-299(our)-300(conceptions)-300(of)-299(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine)-359(government,)-386(that)-358(they)-359(should)-359(be)-358(allowed)-359(to)-359(interfere)-358(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-308(affairs)-308(of)-308(men.)-425(I)-308(reply,)-322(that)-308(it)-309(is)-308(equally)-308(inconceivable,)-322(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(God)-320(should)-319(have)-320(allowed)-320(a)-319(man,)-337(to)-320(whom)-319(he)-320(has)-320(imparted)-319(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(greatest)-443(mental)-443(endowments,)-491(and)-443(whom)-443(he)-443(has)-443(placed)-442(in)-443(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(elevated)-256(position)-256(in)-256(society,)-257(who)-256(lived)-256(centuries)-255(ago,)-258(to)-256(exert)-255(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evil)-382(influence)-382(on)-382(the)-382(present)-382(generation.)-646(The)-381(difficulty)-382(that)-382(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(powerful)-263(influence)-264(for)-263(evil)-264(can)-263(be)-263(exerted)-264(by)-263(men)-264(on)-263(those)-263(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-319(never)-318(seen)-319(them,)-336(and)-319(of)-318(whose)-319(existence)-319(they)-319(have)-318(never)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(heard,)-358(is)-336(just)-336(as)-336(great)-337(as)-336(the)-336(one)-336(under)-336(consideration.)-509(Yet)-336(it)-336(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-294(of)-293(the)-294(most)-293(undeniable)-294(of)-293(facts,)-305(that)-293(men)-294(do)-293(exert)-294(the)-293(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(powerful)-311(influence)-311(on)-311(one)-311(another,)-326(and)-311(that)-311(such)-311(influence)-311(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-279(exert)1(ed)-279(by)-279(generations)-278(long)-279(since)-278(passed)-279(away)-278(on)-279(those)-278(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(live)-250(ages)-250(afterwards;)-250(and)-250(that)-250(it)-250(can)-250(be)-250(exerted)-250(unconsciously.)]TJ 11.955 -15.185 Td [(I)-241(am)-241(far)-240(from)-241(wishing)-241(to)-241(deny,)-243(that)-240(the)-241(difficulty)-241(is)-241(a)-241(real)-240(one.)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(On)-376(the)-375(contrary,)-407(I)-375(fully)-376(admit)-376(it;)-438(and)-376(that)-375(it)-376(is)-375(one)-376(which)-375(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(present)-256(faculties)-257(are)-256(unable)-256(to)-257(explain.)-268(But)-257(it)-256(is)-256(one)-257(which)-256(is)-256(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(peculiar)-296(to)-295(Christianity,)-308(nor)-295(has)-296(it)-296(originated)-296(in)-295(it.)-388(The)-295(interfer-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
947 0 obj <<
/Length 4912      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(202)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(ence)-273(of)-273(superhuman)-273(beings)-273(in)-273(human)-273(affairs)-273(for)-273(the)-273(purposes)-273(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evil,)-250(would)-250(be)-250(only)-250(another)-250(form)-250(of)-250(the)-250(same)-250(difficulty.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Precisely)-405(similar)-406(reasonings)-405(to)-406(those)-405(which)-406(have)-405(been)-405(em-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ployed)-511(to)-510(prove)-511(that)-510(the)-511(existence)-511(of)-510(a)-511(being)-510(like)-511(Satan)-510(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impossible,)-227(when)-222(they)-221(are)-222(applied)-221(to)-222(other)-221(subjects,)-227(bring)-222(us)-221(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(direct)-365(collision)-365(with)-365(realities.)-1191(There)-365(can)-365(be)-365(no)-365(doubt,)-394(that)-365(if)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([229])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(the)-370(constitution)-370(of)-370(the)-370(universe)-370(had)-370(been)-370(placed)-370(in)-370(our)-370(hands,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-256(phenomena)-255(would)-256(have)-256(been)-255(very)-256(different.)-267(But)-256(our)-255(function)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-343(a)-343(far)-343(humbler)-343(one.)-530(It)-343(is)-343(not)-343(to)-343(erect)-343(a)-343(universe)-343(according)-343(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-380(conceptions)-380(of)-379(what)-380(is)-380(best,)-412(but)-380(to)-379(learn)-380(the)-380(order)-380(of)-379(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-430(which)-429(we)-430(live,)-475(and)-429(to)-430(accept)-429(facts)-430(on)-430(sufficient)-429(evidence,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(however)-250(strongly)-250(they)-250(may)-250(conflict)-250(with)-250(abstract)-250(theories.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(I)-330(now)-329(proceed)-330(to)-330(consider)-330(the)-329(real)-330(difficulty)-330(connected)-329(with)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(this)-179(subject,)-192(and)-179(which)-179(has)-178(been)-179(very)-178(strongly)-179(urged)-178(by)-179(the)-178(author)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 12.83 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Supernatural)-343(Religion.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 99.796 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.586 0 Td [(It)-343(is)-343(this.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 45.689 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(If)-343(it)-343(is)-343(conceivable)-343(that)]TJ -176.589 -13.549 Td [(beings)-193(exist)-193(who)-192(possess)-193(superhuman)-193(knowledge)-193(and)-193(power;)-211(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-193(they)-192(are)-193(capable)-193(of)-192(interfering)-193(as)-193(the)-192(New)-193(Testament)-192(affirms,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-194(the)-195(affairs)-194(of)-195(men,)-205(how)-195(can)-194(the)-194(performance)-195(of)-194(a)-195(miracle)-194(be)-194(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(guarantee)-237(of)-237(a)-237(divine)-238(commission?)-245(May)-237(not)-238(inferior)-237(agents,)-239(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(possess)-328(superhuman)-329(knowledge)-328(and)-328(power,)-348(be)-329(able)-328(to)-328(produce)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(results)-348(which)-348(would)-349(to)-348(all)-348(outward)-348(appearance)-348(be)-348(miraculous?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Might)-204(not)-204(an)-204(evil)-204(being,)-213(who)-204(was)-204(possessed)-204(of)-204(the)-204(highest)-204(intelli-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gence)-231(like)-231(Satan,)-234(perform)-231(such)-231(actions)-231(as)-231(would)-231(be)-231(equivalent)-230(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles,)-315(for)-302(the)-302(purpose)-303(of)-302(authenticating)-302(falsehoods?)-406(All)-302(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(such)-205(actions)-204(prove)-205(is)-204(the)-205(presence)-205(of)-204(superhuman)-205(knowledge)-204(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power;)-224(but)-210(they)-211(would)-210(leave)-211(it)-210(quite)-211(uncertain)-210(whether)-211(the)-210(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-258(divine)-258(or)-258(Satanic.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.607 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.656 0 Td [(Such)-258(is)-258(the)-258(objection,)-259(and)-258(it)-258(demands)-258(an)]TJ -104.263 -13.549 Td [(adequate)-250(solution.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-233(reply,)-237(that)-233(if)-233(we)-233(view)-233(the)-233(question)-233(merely)-233(as)-233(an)-233(abstract)-233(one,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(it)-351(is)-350(quite)-351(possible,)-376(if)-350(a)-351(superhuman)-351(being)-350(of)-351(high)-350(intelligence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-303(permitted)-302(to)-303(interfere)-303(in)-302(the)-303(affairs)-303(of)-303(men,)-315(that)-303(he)-303(should)-302(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(able)-301(to)-301(perform)-301(actions)-300(which)-301(might)-301(have)-301(all)-301(the)-301(appearance)-300(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(being)-244(supernatural.)-248(Such)-244(results)-244(might)-244(be)-244(even)-244(brought)-244(about)-243(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-214(superior)-214(acquaintance)-214(with)-214(the)-214(existing)-214(forces)-214(of)-214(nature,)-221(and)-214(by)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
951 0 obj <<
/Length 4688      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(X.)-250(The)-250(Existence)-250(And)-250(Miracles)-250(Of)-250(Satan.)-4145(203)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(a)-341(successful)-340(combination)-341(of)-681(them,)-363(without)-340(the)-341(introduction)-340(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([230])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(any)-229(new)-230(force)-229(whatever.)-243(For)-229(such)-230(results)-229(we)-229(need)-230(not)-229(invoke)-229(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aid)-286(of)-287(a)-286(supernatural)-286(being.)-359(They)-287(have)-286(been)-286(frequently)-286(effected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-304(a)-304(superior)-304(human)-304(intelligence)-303(acting)-304(on)-304(an)-304(inferior)-304(one.)-411(We)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(all)-266(know)-266(how)-266(Columbus)-266(used)-266(his)-266(superior)-266(knowledge)-266(of)-265(astron-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(omy,)-317(to)-304(predict)-303(an)-304(eclipse,)-317(and)-303(the)-304(ignorant)-303(natives)-304(of)-303(America)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mistook)-374(this)-374(as)-374(denoting)-374(the)-374(presence)-374(of)-374(a)-374(superhuman)-374(being.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Such)-233(results)-233(may)-233(be)-234(always)-233(produced,)-236(when)-233(superior)-233(knowledge)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acts)-367(on)-367(ignorance;)-426(and)-367(such)-367(is)-366(the)-367(origin)-367(of)-367(no)-367(inconsiderable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(number)-324(of)-323(impositions)-324(which)-323(have)-324(been)-323(practised)-324(on)-323(mankind.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-412(is)-411(therefore)-412(quite)-412(conceivable,)-452(as)-411(an)-412(abstract)-411(question,)-452(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-292(men)-291(who)-292(possess)-291(a)-292(very)-291(superior)-292(intelligence,)-301(are)-292(capable)-291(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(producing)-355(results)-355(which)-355(to)-355(an)-355(inferior)-355(intelligence)-355(would)-354(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-254(appearance)-254(of)-253(being)-254(supernatural,)-255(without)-253(really)-254(being)-254(so,)-254(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-259(same)-258(manner,)-261(if)-259(Satan)-258(is)-259(supposed)-259(to)-258(possess)-259(an)-258(intelligence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(greater)-235(than)-236(that)-235(of)-235(the)-236(wisest)-235(of)-235(mankind,)-239(and)-235(if)-235(his)-235(interference)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-256(human)-255(affairs)-256(is)-255(permitted,)-257(he)-256(may)-255(be)-256(able)-255(to)-256(perform)-255(actions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-383(would)-383(have)-383(the)-384(appearance)-383(of)-383(being)-383(supernatural,)-416(by)-383(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(skilful)-250(use)-250(of)-250(the)-250(existing)-250(forces)-250(of)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-371(to)-372(such)-371(power)-371(there)-372(must)-371(be)-371(a)-372(limit.)-614(There)-371(are)-371(certain)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(results)-312(which)-312(plainly)-311(lie)-312(beyond)-312(the)-311(power)-312(of)-312(any)-312(mere)-311(combi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nation)-286(of)-285(the)-286(forces)-286(of)-285(nature)-286(to)-286(produce.)-357(Of)-286(these,)-294(many)-286(of)-285(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-286(recorded)-286(in)-286(the)-287(Gospels)-286(are)-286(instances,)-295(such)-286(as)-286(the)-286(cure)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-284(blind)-283(or)-284(leprous)-284(men)-283(by)-284(no)-284(other)-283(visible)-284(instrumentality)-283(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-238(word)-239(or)-238(a)-239(touch.)-246(Actions)-238(of)-239(this)-238(kind)-238(differ)-239(wholly)-238(in)-238(character)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-353(those)-354(which)-353(we)-353(are)-353(now)-354(considering.)-559(If)-354(a)-353(miracle)-353(was)-353(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(more)-293(objective)-293(fact)-293(taking)-292(place)-293(in)-293(external)-293(nature,)-304(and)-292(nothing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more,)-521(it)-467(might)-467(be)-466(open)-467(to)-467(question)-467(whether)-467(its)-466(performance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-365(owing)-365(to)-364(supernatural)-365(agency,)-393(or)-365(to)-365(some)-365(combination)-364(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(known)-299(or)-299(unknown)-300(forces.)-397(But)-299(the)-300(miracles)-299(with)-299(which)-299(we)-299(are)]TJ 3.83 -13.549 Td [(concerned)-351(in)-351(this)-351(controversy,)-376(involve)-351(a)-351(great)-351(deal)-351(more)-351(than)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 287.194 0 Td [([231])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(more)-250(objective)-250(facts)-250(in)-250(material)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-281(assuming,)-289(as)-282(I)-281(cannot)-281(help)-282(doing)-281(in)-281(an)-282(argument)-281(like)-282(t)1(he)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(present,)-232(the)-227(existence)-227(of)-227(a)-228(God,)-231(who)-228(is)-227(the)-227(Creator)-227(and)-227(Governor)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
956 0 obj <<
/Length 4685      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(204)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(of)-317(the)-318(universe,)-334(the)-317(question)-317(is)-317(not)-317(a)-318(mere)-317(abstract)-317(one,)-334(what)-317(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Being)-374(like)-373(Satan,)-404(if)-374(he)-373(is)-374(supposed)-374(to)-373(exist,)-404(might)-374(be)-373(capable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-382(doing;)-447(but)-381(it)-382(becomes)-382(entirely)-381(one)-382(of)-381(permitted)-382(agency.)-644(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-453(plain,)-503(that)-453(if)-452(there)-453(is)-453(a)-452(God,)-504(every)-452(being)-453(in)-453(the)-452(universe,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(however)-383(powerful)-383(or)-383(intelligent,)-416(can)-383(only)-383(act)-383(within)-383(a)-382(certain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(definite)-251(sphere)-251(of)-251(operation,)-251(which)-251(the)-251(Governor)-251(of)-251(the)-250(universe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-289(assigned)-288(to)-289(him.)-366(Within)-289(what)-289(limits)-289(then)-288(is)-289(he)-289(allowed)-288(act?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Are)-341(subordinate)-341(agents)-342(permitted)-341(to)-341(interfere)-341(with)-341(the)-341(material)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forces)-330(of)-331(external)-330(nature?)-492(and)-330(if)-331(so,)-350(within)-331(what)-330(bounds?)-491(Can)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-354(wander)-353(over)-354(the)-354(universe)-353(at)-354(their)-354(mere)-353(will)-354(and)-353(pleasure,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-339(interfere)-339(with)-340(its)-339(operations?)-518(How)-339(far)-339(is)-339(their)-339(interference)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(permitted)-241(in)-240(the)-241(moral)-241(and)-240(spiritual)-241(worlds?)-247(The)-241(question)-240(before)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-464(is)-465(even)-464(reduced)-464(to)-464(one)-465(of)-464(far)-464(narrower)-464(limits.)-893(Our)-464(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(direct)-318(knowledge)-317(of)-318(the)-317(existence)-318(of)-317(such)-318(an)-317(agency)-318(is)-317(derived)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(from)-289(Revelation.)-365(The)-289(real)-289(point)-288(therefore)-289(which)-288(concerns)-289(us)-288(is,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-406(what)-407(extent)-406(is)-406(such)-406(permitted)-406(agency)-407(affirmed)-406(in)-406(the)-406(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament.)-236(Do)-207(the)-208(Satanic)-207(interventions)-208(there)-207(described)-207(interfere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-253(divine)-253(miracles)-253(as)-253(attestations)-253(of)-253(a)-253(divine)-253(commission?)-258(We)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-322(nothing)-321(whatever)-322(to)-321(do)-321(with)-322(abstract)-321(propositions)-322(or)-321(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(what)-311(Rabbinical)-310(writers)-311(may)-311(have)-311(affirmed)-310(on)-311(this)-311(subject,)-325(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-250(the)-250(assertions)-250(of)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)-250(alone.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(If)-298(there)-298(is)-298(a)-298(God,)-309(it)-298(is)-298(certain)-298(that)-298(the)-298(present)-298(order)-298(of)-297(nature)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(must)-336(be)-335(a)-336(manifestation)-335(of)-336(His)-336(will.)-506(So)-336(must)-336(be)-335(the)-336(energy)-335(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-231(forces)-231(in)-231(conformity)-231(with)-231(invariable)-231(law.)-244(Whatever)-230(power)-231(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-280(delegated)-281(to)-280(subordinate)-280(agents,)-288(must)-280(form)-281(a)-280(portion)-280(of)-280(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(universal)-311(order,)-326(and)-311(be)-310(exercised)-311(in)-311(conformity)-311(with)-311(the)-310(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purposes.)-1324(It)-387(is)-387(inconceivable)-387(that)-388(subordinate)-387(agents)-387(can)-387(be)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([232])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(allowed)-389(to)-389(break)-388(in)-389(upon)-389(it)-389(at)-389(their)-389(will)-388(and)-389(pleasure,)-424(for)-388(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(general)-266(permanence)-267(of)-266(its)-267(order)-266(forms)-266(an)-267(essential)-266(condition)-266(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-371(exercise)-372(of)-371(moral)-372(agency.)-614(If)-371(they)-372(are)-371(allowed)-372(to)-371(do)-372(so,)-401(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-334(be)-335(only)-334(within)-335(clear)-334(and)-334(definite)-335(limits,)-355(which)-334(ultimately)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(effectuate)-289(the)-289(purposes)-289(of)-289(the)-290(Creator.)-367(Such)-289(is)-289(the)-289(nature)-289(of)-289(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(power)-383(which)-382(man)-383(can)-383(exert)-383(over)-382(material)-383(nature.)-648(It)-383(can)-382(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modify)-366(results,)-394(by)-366(giving)-366(a)-365(new)-366(direction)-366(to)-365(its)-366(forces.)-597(In)-365(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
960 0 obj <<
/Length 4791      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(X.)-250(The)-250(Existence)-250(And)-250(Miracles)-250(Of)-250(Satan.)-4145(205)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(case)-259(of)-259(man)-259(this)-259(power)-258(is)-259(limited)-259(to)-259(the)-259(world)-259(in)-259(which)-259(he)-258(lives.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(In)-438(a)-438(similar)-438(manner,)-486(if)-438(beings)-438(superior)-438(to)-438(him)-438(in)-438(power)-438(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intelligence)-342(exist,)-364(their)-342(interference)-342(must)-341(be)-342(subject)-342(to)-341(definite)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(limitations.)-706(Such)-401(is)-402(the)-402(uniform)-402(affirmation)-402(of)-402(the)-402(writers)-401(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-293(New)-294(Testament.)-379(Even)-294(if)-293(we)-293(take)-293(their)-294(language)-293(in)-293(the)-293(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(literal)-297(sense,)-308(the)-297(supernatural)-297(interventions)-297(which)-297(they)-296(attribute)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-274(Satan,)-279(are)-274(confined)-274(to)-274(a)-273(very)-274(definite)-274(order)-274(of)-273(phenomena.)-321(In)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-240(word,)-243(the)-240(sacred)-241(writers)-240(have)-241(described)-240(Satanic)-240(intervention)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-204(limited)-205(to)-204(the)-204(world)-205(of)-204(mind;)-220(and)-204(as)-204(capable,)-214(through)-204(its)-204(action)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-242(the)-242(mind,)-244(of)-242(producing)-242(certain)-242(results)-242(on)-242(the)-242(bodily)-242(organiza-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion.)-358(To)-286(this)-287(there)-286(is)-286(one)-286(exception,)-295(the)-286(apparent)-286(ascription)-286(of)-286(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(few)-250(diseases)-250(to)-250(Satanic)-250(agency.)-250(This)-250(I)-250(shall)-250(consider)-250(hereafter.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-252(is)-253(a)-252(remarkable)-252(fact,)-253(and)-252(one)-253(worthy)-252(of)-252(particular)-253(at)1(tention,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-312(the)-312(supernatural)-311(action)-312(attributed)-312(to)-311(Satan)-312(in)-312(the)-312(New)-311(Tes-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tament,)-400(with)-369(the)-370(exception)-370(above)-370(referred)-370(to,)-399(is)-370(a)-370(mental)-369(one.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(It)-339(is)-338(through)-339(the)-338(action)-339(on)-338(men's)-339(minds)-338(alone,)-361(that)-338(demoniacal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agency)-387(produces)-387(any)-387(results)-387(on)-387(their)-387(bodily)-387(frame.)-661(No)-387(direct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-234(on)-233(the)-234(material)-233(forces)-234(of)-233(nature)-234(is)-233(ever)-234(attributed)-233(to)-234(it.)-244(We)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(find)-208(nothing)-207(in)-208(the)-207(smallest)-208(degree)-208(resembling)-207(the)-208(act)-207(of)-208(a)-207(demon)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(overturning)-301(a)-301(pitcher)-302(of)-301(water.)-404(The)-301(kind)-301(of)-301(influence)-301(attributed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-258(Satan)-258(is)-258(of)-258(a)-258(similar)-258(character,)-260(though)-258(much)-258(higher)-258(in)-258(degree,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-815(that)-407(which)-407(one)-408(man)-407(can)-407(exert)-408(over)-407(another.)-722(One)-407(man)-407(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([233])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(superior)-251(mental)-251(power)-251(is)-251(capable)-251(of)-251(exerting)-251(an)-251(influence)-251(over)-250(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(weaker)-203(mind)-202(to)-202(such)-203(a)-202(degree,)-212(as)-203(almost)-202(to)-203(enthral)-202(it.)-234(We)-203(call)-202(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-336(species)-336(of)-337(fascination.)-508(In)-336(the)-337(New)-336(Testament)-336(the)-336(similar)-336(but)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mightier)-315(Satanic)-316(influence)-315(is)-315(Possession.)-446(One)-316(mind,)-331(by)-315(getting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-283(powerful)-283(hold)-283(on)-282(another,)-291(can)-283(exert)-283(an)-283(influence)-283(on)-283(the)-282(body,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-261(in)-260(mesmerism.)-282(The)-261(Satanic)-260(influence)-261(exerted)-260(in)-261(possession)-260(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-250(a)-250(more)-250(powerful)-250(one.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-289(is)-289(certain)-288(that)-289(the)-289(extent)-289(to)-289(which)-288(one)-289(human)-289(mind)-289(can)-288(act)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(on)-335(another)-335(is)-336(bounded)-335(by)-335(no)-335(narrow)-336(limits;)-377(what)-336(is)-335(more,)-356(it)-335(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-218(which)-219(is)-218(frequently)-218(exerted)-219(for)-218(evil.)-239(It)-219(is)-218(evidently)-218(within)-218(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(purposes)-300(of)-300(the)-300(Creator)-300(to)-299(permit)-300(this.)-400(Why)-300(it)-300(is)-300(allowed)-300(to)-299(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(extent)-297(to)-297(which)-297(it)-297(is,)-309(is)-297(beyond)-297(our)-297(powers)-297(to)-297(discover.)-391(But)-297(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
964 0 obj <<
/Length 4528      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(206)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(wide)-300(extent)-301(to)-300(which)-300(it)-301(not)-300(only)-300(can)-301(be,)-312(but)-301(actually)-300(is)-300(exerted,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-343(a)-343(fact)-343(that)-343(cannot)-343(be)-344(denied.)-529(It)-343(is)-343(also)-343(an)-343(influence)-343(that)-343(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-286(exerted)-287(secretly.)-359(The)-286(difference)-286(between)-287(this)-286(power)-286(and)-286(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-208(is)-207(supposed)-208(to)-207(be)-208(att)1(ributed)-208(to)-207(Satan)-208(in)-207(the)-208(New)-207(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-417(far)-417(more)-418(one)-417(of)-417(degree)-417(than)-418(of)-417(kind;)-501(and)-417(the)-417(latter)-417(is)-417(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-230(is)-230(bounded)-229(by)-230(clear)-230(and)-230(definite)-230(limits.)-243(Between)-230(a)-229(Satanic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession)-352(and)-353(a)-352(miracle)-353(performed)-352(by)-352(Jesus)-353(the)-352(distinction)-352(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unmistakable.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-283(follows)-283(from)-282(the)-283(foregoing)-283(considerations,)-291(that)-283(the)-282(Satanic)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(supernaturalism,)-344(which)-324(we)-325(have)-325(to)-325(consider,)-343(as)-325(far)-325(as)-325(if)-324(stands)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-409(opposition)-408(to)-409(the)-408(miracles)-409(of)-408(God,)-448(is)-409(reduced)-408(to)-409(very)-408(nar-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(row)-331(limits.)-493(It)-331(consists)-331(almost)-331(exclusively)-331(of)-331(possession)-331(and)-330(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena.)-843(No)-448(other)-447(kind)-448(of)-448(action)-447(bearing)-448(even)-448(a)-447(remote)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(analogy)-394(to)-394(a)-394(miracle,)-431(with)-394(the)-394(single)-394(exception)-394(of)-394(the)-394(history)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-383(the)-384(temptation,)-416(is)-384(anywhere)-383(attributed)-383(to)-384(Satan)-383(in)-383(the)-383(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(In)-255(estimating)-255(the)-254(evidential)-255(character)-255(of)-255(miracles,)-512(it)-255(has)-254(been)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([234])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(a)-373(far)-373(too)-373(common)-372(practice)-373(with)-373(those)-373(who)-373(deny)-373(the)-372(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-285(of)-286(the)-285(Gospels,)-294(to)-285(keep)-286(out)-285(of)-285(view)-286(their)-285(moral)-285(aspect)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-401(an)-401(important)-401(portion)-401(of)-401(their)-401(evidential)-401(value.)-703(It)-401(has)-400(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirmed)-395(that)-394(a)-395(miracle)-395(must)-394(be)-395(estimated)-395(as)-394(an)-395(act)-395(of)-394(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(quite)-322(apart)-323(from)-322(its)-323(moral)-322(impress.)-467(The)-322(author)-323(before)-322(me)-322(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(goes)-326(the)-326(length)-326(of)-326(supposing,)-344(that,)-345(if)-326(Satan)-326(is)-326(as)-326(cunning)-326(as)-325(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-297(represented)-297(in)-296(the)-297(New)-297(Testament,)-308(he)-297(may)-297(even)-297(turn)-296(himself)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(into)-283(an)-284(angel)-283(of)-284(light)-283(and)-283(perform)-284(works)-283(bearing)-284(the)-283(impress)-283(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(holiness)-189(for)-190(the)-189(purpose)-190(of)-189(furthering)-190(the)-189(interests)-190(of)-189(the)-189(kingdom)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(lies.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Such)-243(an)-244(idea)-243(receives)-243(no)-243(countenance)-244(from)-243(anything)-243(which)-243(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(affirmed)-300(by)-301(St.)-401(Paul.)-400(The)-301(passage)-300(in)-300(which)-301(allusion)-300(is)-300(made)-300(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Satan)-323(transforming)-322(himself)-323(into)-322(an)-323(angel)-322(of)-323(light)-322(is)-323(as)-322(follows:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(For)-462(such)-462(are)-463(false)-462(apostles,)-515(deceitful)-462(workers,)-515(transforming)]TJ -4.844 -13.549 Td [(themselves)-259(into)-260(the)-259(apostles)-260(of)-259(Christ.)-278(And)-260(no)-259(marvel,)-262(for)-259(Satan)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(himself)-306(is)-306(transformed)-306(into)-306(an)-306(angel)-306(of)-306(light.)-418(Therefore)-306(it)-306(is)-305(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-206(thing)-206(if)-206(his)-206(ministers)-206(should)-206(be)-206(transformed)-206(as)-206(the)-205(ministers)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
968 0 obj <<
/Length 5581      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(X.)-250(The)-250(Existence)-250(And)-250(Miracles)-250(Of)-250(Satan.)-4145(207)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(of)-276(righteousness.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 74.211 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.851 0 Td [(It)-276(is)-275(quite)-276(clear)-276(that)-275(nothing)-276(was)-275(further)-276(from)]TJ -82.062 -13.549 Td [(the)-277(Apostle's)-277(mind)-277(than)-277(the)-277(idea)-277(of)-277(Satanic)-277(miracles)-277(bearing)-277(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impress)-411(of)-412(holiness)-411(as)-412(wrought)-411(in)-412(support)-411(of)-412(the)-411(kingdom)-411(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(falsehood.)-707(He)-402(is)-403(simply)-402(speaking)-402(of)-403(Judaizing)-402(teachers,)-440(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(claimed)-323(the)-322(support)-323(of)-323(apostolical)-323(authority,)-340(for)-323(the)-323(purpose)-322(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disseminating)-250(their)-250(unchristian)-250(views.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-195(idea)-196(is)-195(absurd)-196(and)-195(ridiculous,)-206(but)-196(we)-195(know)-196(that)-195(it)-195(occurred)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-367(the)-367(opponents)-367(of)-367(our)-367(Lord,)-396(who)-367(charged)-367(him)-367(with)-367(working)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-296(by)-296(Satanic)-296(agency.)-389(The)-296(special)-296(instance)-296(in)-296(which)-296(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-259(this)-259(charge)-259(was)-258(that)-259(of)-259(his)-259(supposed)-259(expulsion)-259(of)-258(demons.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Our)-280(Lord)-281(met)-280(it)-280(by)-280(the)-281(decisive)-280(argument,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 189.062 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(How)-280(can)-281(Satan)-280(cast)]TJ -193.905 -13.549 Td [(out)-351(Satan?)-553(If)-351(Satan)-351(be)-351(divided)-351(against)-350(himself,)-377(how)-702(shall)-350(his)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([235])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(kingdom)-310(stand?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 70.047 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.225 0 Td [(In)-310(a)-310(word,)-325(he)-310(appealed)-310(to)-310(the)-310(moral)-310(aspect)-310(of)]TJ -78.272 -13.549 Td [(his)-390(miracles)-389(as)-390(a)-389(convincing)-390(proof)-390(that)-389(their)-390(accusation)-389(could)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-250(have)-250(been)-250(instigated)-250(by)-250(deliberate)-250(malice.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-454(same)-454(objection)-454(was)-454(doubtless)-454(urged)-454(against)-454(his)-453(other)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(miracles,)-383(although)-356(it)-356(is)-356(nowhere)-357(stated)-356(in)-356(express)-356(terms)-356(in)-356(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels.)-244(But)-232(whatever)-232(absurd)-233(beliefs)-232(may)-232(have)-232(been)-232(entertained)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-194(the)-194(learned)-194(Rabbis,)-205(they)-194(were)-194(easily)-194(met)-194(by)-194(the)-194(common)-194(sense)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-315(the)-315(people.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 65.942 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(We)-315(know,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 45.542 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.277 0 Td [(said)-315(the)-314(Rabbis,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 74.415 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(that)-315(this)-314(man)-315(is)-315(a)]TJ -203.864 -13.549 Td [(sinner.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 29.389 0 Td [(\035)-205(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 11.929 0 Td [(How)-205(can)-206(a)-205(man)-206(that)-205(is)-205(a)-206(sinner)-205(perform)-206(such)-205(miracles?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 234.469 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.787 -13.55 Td [(is)-244(the)-244(reply.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 53.784 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Whether)-244(he)-244(be)-244(a)-244(sinner,)-246(I)-244(know)-244(not,)-245(but)-244(one)-244(thing)-244(I)]TJ -58.628 -13.549 Td [(know,)-208(that)-198(whereas)-198(I)-197(was)-198(blind,)-208(now)-198(I)-198(see.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 181.383 0 Td [(\035)-198(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 11.844 0 Td [(Can)-198(a)-197(devil)-198(open)-198(the)]TJ -193.227 -13.549 Td [(eyes)-248(of)-248(the)-248(blind?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 77.191 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.549 0 Td [(It)-248(is)-248(evident)-248(that)-248(the)-248(difficulties)-248(suggested)-248(by)]TJ -84.74 -13.549 Td [(the)-190(author)-189(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 56.495 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Supernatural)-190(Religion)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 95.395 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.911 0 Td [(as)-190(to)-189(the)-190(evidential)-189(value)-190(of)]TJ -163.644 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-237(being)-237(nullified)-237(by)-237(the)-237(views)-237(which)-237(prevailed)-236(respecting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demoniacal)-272(action)-272(were)-272(not)-272(appreciated)-272(when)-272(the)-272(fourth)-271(Gospel)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-317(composed,)-333(although)-316(according)-317(to)-316(this)-317(theory)-316(they)-317(ought)-316(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-296(been)-296(at)-297(that)-296(time)-296(in)-296(full)-296(force.)-389(But)-296(apart)-296(from)-296(the)-296(peculiar)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-279(ascribed)-279(to)-279(Satanic)-279(supernaturalism)-279(in)-279(the)-279(New)-278(Testa-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ment,)-368(the)-345(entire)-345(idea)-344(that)-345(there)-344(could)-345(have)-345(been)-344(any)-345(danger)-344(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(confounding)-257(Satanic)-256(miracles)-257(with)-257(the)-256(miracles)-257(of)-257(God,)-258(rests)-256(on)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-208(fallacy)-208(of)-208(confounding)-207(a)-208(mere)-208(objective)-208(fact)-208(with)-208(an)-208(action)-207(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-259(moral)-259(agent.)-277(A)-259(miracle)-259(does)-259(not)-259(consist)-259(merely)-259(in)-259(the)-259(outward)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
973 0 obj <<
/Length 4555      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(208)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(event,)-248(which)-248(is)-248(caused)-248(by)-248(him,)-249(but)-248(in)-248(the)-248(occurrence)-247(united)-248(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-438(character)-438(and)-439(purpose)-438(of)-438(the)-438(agent.)-815(The)-438(actions)-438(of)-438(holy)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beings)-214(must)-214(bear)-214(the)-214(impress)-214(of)-214(their)-214(holiness;)-226(those)-214(of)-214(evil)-213(ones,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-355(the)-356(contrary.)-566(If,)-381(therefore,)-382(evil)-355(moral)-356(agents)-355(are)-355(capable)-355(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(performing)-233(actions)-233(which)-233(are)-234(analogous)-233(to)-233(miracles,)-236(they)-233(cannot)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fail)-276(to)-277(be)-276(stamped)-276(with)-276(the)-276(evil)-277(of)-276(their)-276(characters.)-329(Such)-276(would)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([236])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(always)-286(form)-285(a)-286(discriminating)-285(mark)-286(between)-285(Divine)-286(and)-285(Satanic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles,)-250(even)-250(on)-250(the)-250(supposition)-250(that)-250(the)-250(latter)-250(are)-250(possible.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(This)-447(precisely)-446(represents)-447(the)-447(case)-446(as)-447(it)-447(stands)-446(in)-447(the)-446(New)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Testament.)-631(All)-376(the)-377(miracles)-377(alleged)-377(to)-377(have)-377(been)-377(wrought)-376(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God,)-501(bear)-451(a)-451(definite)-451(impress)-450(of)-451(character)-451(and)-451(purpose.)-852(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supernaturalism)-344(ascribed)-345(to)-344(Satan)-345(is)-344(no)-345(less)-344(definitely)-344(marked.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-427(one)-428(clearly)-427(comes)-428(from)-427(above.)-782(The)-428(indications)-427(that)-427(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other,)-315(if)-303(real,)-315(must)-302(have)-303(come)-302(from)-302(below,)-316(are)-302(equally)-302(distinct.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-305(moral)-305(impress)-305(which)-305(the)-304(two)-305(series)-305(of)-305(events)-305(bear,)-319(is)-304(fully)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sufficient)-250(to)-250(discriminate)-250(the)-250(one)-250(from)-250(the)-250(other.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-412(attempt)-412(to)-413(distinguish)-412(between)-412(the)-412(miraculous)-412(act)-412(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(its)-475(moral)-475(environment,)-532(is)-475(absurd.)-926(It)-475(has)-475(been)-475(affirmed)-475(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-354(miraculous)-355(act)-354(is)-354(as)-355(good)-354(as)-354(another,)-381(quite)-354(apart)-354(from)-354(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(circumstances)-376(with)-376(which)-375(they)-376(are)-376(attended.)-627(Such)-376(a)-375(principle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-341(destroy)-341(the)-340(distinction)-341(between)-341(a)-341(highly)-341(meritorious)-340(act)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-242(the)-243(foulest)-242(crime.)-248(A,)-242(for)-243(example,)-244(has)-242(killed)-243(B.)-242(The)-242(outward)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(act)-241(may)-242(be)-241(the)-241(same;)-244(but)-242(the)-241(accompanying)-241(circumstances)-241(make)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-407(the)-406(distinction)-407(between)-406(a)-407(justifiable)-407(homicide,)-445(and)-407(a)-406(most)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(atrocious)-271(murder.)-312(It)-270(is)-271(ridiculous)-271(to)-270(affirm)-271(that)-271(principles)-270(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-371(legitimate)-371(in)-371(common)-371(life)-371(become)-371(invalid)-371(only)-371(when)-370(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-237(applied)-237(to)-237(the)-237(evidences)-237(of)-237(Christianity.)-245(Why,)-240(in)-237(the)-237(name)-236(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(common)-200(sense,)-210(may)-200(not)-201(one)-200(miracle)-200(be)-200(as)-200(clearly)-200(distinguishable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-308(another)-307(by)-308(its)-307(moral)-308(environment,)-321(as)-308(an)-307(event)-308(in)-307(ordinary)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(life)-179(is)-178(similarly)-179(distinguished?)-226(The)-179(affirmation,)-193(therefore,)-193(that)-178(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposition)-229(of)-230(the)-229(possibility)-230(of)-229(Satanic)-230(miracles)-229(must)-229(invalidate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(miracles)-250(of)-250(God)-250(is)-250(absurd.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Our)-241(Lord,)-243(therefore,)-243(was)-241(right)-241(in)-241(appealing)-241(to)-241(t)1(he)-241(character)-241(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(his)-295(works)-296(as)-295(affording)-295(a)-296(conclusive)-295(proof)-295(of)-296(the)-295(source)-295(whence)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
840 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 884
/Length 8890      
>>
stream
839 0 836 56 842 133 844 248 841 305 846 382 848 497 845 554 850 631 852 746
849 803 854 880 856 995 853 1052 858 1129 860 1244 861 1300 857 1355 864 1444 866 1559
863 1616 868 1681 870 1796 867 1853 872 1930 874 2045 871 2101 876 2190 878 2305 875 2362
880 2439 882 2554 883 2611 879 2667 885 2744 887 2859 884 2915 890 2992 892 3107 889 3164
894 3267 896 3382 893 3439 898 3516 900 3631 897 3688 902 3753 904 3868 901 3924 906 4001
908 4116 905 4173 910 4262 912 4377 913 4434 909 4490 916 4579 918 4694 919 4750 915 4805
920 4870 923 4910 925 4972 921 5087 927 5143 924 5199 929 5276 931 5391 928 5448 933 5525
935 5640 932 5696 937 5761 939 5876 936 5932 941 6009 943 6124 940 6180 946 6257 948 6372
945 6428 950 6505 952 6620 953 6677 949 6733 955 6798 957 6913 954 6970 959 7035 961 7150
958 7206 963 7271 965 7386 962 7443 967 7520 969 7635 966 7692 972 7769 974 7884 971 7941
% 839 0 obj
<<
/D [837 0 R /XYZ 93.543 216.089 null]
>>
% 836 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 842 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 843 0 R
/Resources 841 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 835 0 R
>>
% 844 0 obj
<<
/D [842 0 R /XYZ 120.355 271.835 null]
>>
% 841 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 846 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 847 0 R
/Resources 845 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 835 0 R
>>
% 848 0 obj
<<
/D [846 0 R /XYZ 135.212 311.664 null]
>>
% 845 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 850 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 851 0 R
/Resources 849 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 835 0 R
>>
% 852 0 obj
<<
/D [850 0 R /XYZ 327.401 396.232 null]
>>
% 849 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 854 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 855 0 R
/Resources 853 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 835 0 R
>>
% 856 0 obj
<<
/D [854 0 R /XYZ 351.259 463.978 null]
>>
% 853 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 858 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 859 0 R
/Resources 857 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 862 0 R
>>
% 860 0 obj
<<
/D [858 0 R /XYZ 233.89 518.175 null]
>>
% 861 0 obj
<<
/D [858 0 R /XYZ 66.351 106.79 null]
>>
% 857 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 864 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 865 0 R
/Resources 863 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 862 0 R
>>
% 866 0 obj
<<
/D [864 0 R /XYZ 196.009 175.763 null]
>>
% 863 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 868 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 869 0 R
/Resources 867 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 862 0 R
>>
% 870 0 obj
<<
/D [868 0 R /XYZ 315.583 271.835 null]
>>
% 867 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 872 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 873 0 R
/Resources 871 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 862 0 R
>>
% 874 0 obj
<<
/D [872 0 R /XYZ 293.907 353.13 null]
>>
% 871 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 876 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 877 0 R
/Resources 875 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 862 0 R
>>
% 878 0 obj
<<
/D [876 0 R /XYZ 278.333 407.327 null]
>>
% 875 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 880 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 881 0 R
/Resources 879 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 862 0 R
>>
% 882 0 obj
<<
/D [880 0 R /XYZ 212.338 462.342 null]
>>
% 883 0 obj
<<
/D [880 0 R /XYZ 374.173 79.691 null]
>>
% 879 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 885 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 886 0 R
/Resources 884 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 888 0 R
>>
% 887 0 obj
<<
/D [885 0 R /XYZ 268.07 133.888 null]
>>
% 884 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 890 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 891 0 R
/Resources 889 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 888 0 R
>>
% 892 0 obj
<<
/D [890 0 R /XYZ 268.306 206.544 null]
>>
% 889 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F38 247 0 R /F37 246 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 894 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 895 0 R
/Resources 893 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 888 0 R
>>
% 896 0 obj
<<
/D [894 0 R /XYZ 227.808 271.835 null]
>>
% 893 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 898 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 899 0 R
/Resources 897 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 888 0 R
>>
% 900 0 obj
<<
/D [898 0 R /XYZ 290.845 338.762 null]
>>
% 897 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 902 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 903 0 R
/Resources 901 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 888 0 R
>>
% 904 0 obj
<<
/D [902 0 R /XYZ 310.47 407.327 null]
>>
% 901 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 906 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 907 0 R
/Resources 905 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 888 0 R
>>
% 908 0 obj
<<
/D [906 0 R /XYZ 352.044 463.978 null]
>>
% 905 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 910 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 911 0 R
/Resources 909 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 914 0 R
>>
% 912 0 obj
<<
/D [910 0 R /XYZ 157.756 518.175 null]
>>
% 913 0 obj
<<
/D [910 0 R /XYZ 248.115 106.79 null]
>>
% 909 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 916 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 917 0 R
/Resources 915 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 914 0 R
>>
% 918 0 obj
<<
/D [916 0 R /XYZ 93.543 177.078 null]
>>
% 919 0 obj
<<
/D [916 0 R /XYZ 93.543 68.499 null]
>>
% 915 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 920 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index11) >>
% 923 0 obj
(Chapter X. The Existence And Miracles Of Satan.)
% 925 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 926 0 R
/Resources 924 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 914 0 R
>>
% 921 0 obj
<<
/D [925 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 927 0 obj
<<
/D [925 0 R /XYZ 78.495 120.886 null]
>>
% 924 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 929 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 930 0 R
/Resources 928 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 914 0 R
>>
% 931 0 obj
<<
/D [929 0 R /XYZ 312.814 174.536 null]
>>
% 928 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 933 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 934 0 R
/Resources 932 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 914 0 R
>>
% 935 0 obj
<<
/D [933 0 R /XYZ 93.633 244.736 null]
>>
% 932 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 937 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 938 0 R
/Resources 936 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 914 0 R
>>
% 939 0 obj
<<
/D [937 0 R /XYZ 93.543 312.559 null]
>>
% 936 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 941 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 942 0 R
/Resources 940 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 944 0 R
>>
% 943 0 obj
<<
/D [941 0 R /XYZ 59.132 367.497 null]
>>
% 940 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 946 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 947 0 R
/Resources 945 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 944 0 R
>>
% 948 0 obj
<<
/D [946 0 R /XYZ 231.07 448.793 null]
>>
% 945 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 950 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 951 0 R
/Resources 949 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 944 0 R
>>
% 952 0 obj
<<
/D [950 0 R /XYZ 174.944 518.175 null]
>>
% 953 0 obj
<<
/D [950 0 R /XYZ 46.771 109.244 null]
>>
% 949 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 955 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 956 0 R
/Resources 954 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 944 0 R
>>
% 957 0 obj
<<
/D [955 0 R /XYZ 142.272 160.986 null]
>>
% 954 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 959 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 960 0 R
/Resources 958 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 944 0 R
>>
% 961 0 obj
<<
/D [959 0 R /XYZ 59.702 231.187 null]
>>
% 958 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 963 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 964 0 R
/Resources 962 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 944 0 R
>>
% 965 0 obj
<<
/D [963 0 R /XYZ 324.617 298.115 null]
>>
% 962 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 967 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 968 0 R
/Resources 966 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 970 0 R
>>
% 969 0 obj
<<
/D [967 0 R /XYZ 286.406 366.679 null]
>>
% 966 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 972 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 973 0 R
/Resources 971 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 970 0 R
>>
% 974 0 obj
<<
/D [972 0 R /XYZ 374.173 450.429 null]
>>
% 971 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
endstream
endobj
977 0 obj <<
/Length 4852      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(Chapter)-250(X.)-250(The)-250(Existence)-250(And)-250(Miracles)-250(Of)-250(Satan.)-4145(209)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(they)-473(originated,)-528(and)-473(in)-473(contrasting)-472(them)-473(with)-473(the)-473(species)-472(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernaturalism)-253(which)-507(was)-253(popularly)-254(attributed)-253(to)-253(Satan.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 254.579 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(How)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 31.601 0 Td [([237])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(can)-350(Satan)-351(cast)-350(out)-351(Satan?)-551(If)-351(I)-350(do)-350(not)-351(the)-350(works)-351(of)-350(my)-350(Father,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believe)-239(me)-239(not;)-243(but)-239(if)-239(I)-239(do,)-242(though)-239(ye)-239(believe)-239(not)-239(me,)-241(believe)-239(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(works,)-253(that)-252(ye)-253(may)-252(see)-253(and)-252(believe)-253(that)-252(the)-252(Father)-253(is)-252(in)-253(me)-252(and)-252(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(Him.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 33.339 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -21.383 -15.186 Td [(This)-403(is)-403(conclusive)-404(reasoning.)-709(It)-404(is)-403(only)-403(possible)-403(to)-403(darken)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-453(question)-453(by)-452(treating)-453(it)-453(as)-453(one)-453(of)-452(bare)-453(possibilities,)-504(as)-452(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(what)-435(kind)-435(of)-435(actions)-434(a)-435(being)-435(like)-435(Satan)-435(might)-435(be)-435(capable)-434(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performing,)-356(if)-335(he)-335(is)-335(allowed)-335(to)-335(interfere)-335(with)-335(the)-334(arrangements)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-392(the)-391(universe)-392(at)-392(his)-391(pleasure.)-675(Such)-392(a)-391(supposition)-392(is)-391(foreign)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-377(the)-376(question)-377(at)-377(issue,)-408(which)-377(is)-376(whether)-377(the)-376(supernaturalism)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-378(the)-379(New)-378(Testament)-378(is)-378(supposed)-378(to)-379(attribute)-378(to)-378(him)-378(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interfere)-384(with)-383(the)-384(evidential)-383(value)-383(of)-384(the)-383(miracles)-384(wrought)-383(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus.)-239(My)-215(reply)-215(is,)-223(Examine)-215(and)-215(compare)-216(the)-215(two.)-239(When)-215(this)-215(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-246(done,)-246(no)-245(doubt)-246(can)-245(remain)-246(on)-245(any)-246(reasonable)-245(mind)-246(that)-245(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(latter,)-330(if)-314(real,)-331(are)-314(from)-314(above;)-346(and)-314(the)-315(former)-314(from)-314(below.)-442(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirmation)-215(therefore)-216(that)-215(if)-215(Satanic)-216(miracles,)-222(such)-215(as)-215(possession,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-231(possible,)-234(it)-231(invalidates)-231(the)-231(evidence)-230(of)-231(those)-231(wrought)-231(by)-230(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(attestation)-250(of)-250(the)-250(truth)-250(of)-250(a)-250(divine)-250(commission)-250(is)-250(disproved.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Equally)-315(invalid)-315(is)-315(the)-315(objection)-315(against)-315(a)-315(miraculous)-315(attesta-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tion)-302(to)-301(a)-302(divine)-302(commission,)-314(on)-302(the)-302(ground)-301(that)-302(such)-301(testimony)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-226(be)-225(easily)-226(imitated.)-242(I)-226(reply,)-230(that)-226(the)-226(great)-225(mass)-226(of)-226(the)-225(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recorded)-279(in)-278(the)-279(New)-278(Testament)-279(do)-278(not)-278(easily)-279(admit)-278(of)-279(a)-278(fraudu-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(lent)-272(imitation.)-317(I)-272(by)-272(no)-272(means)-272(deny)-273(that)-272(the)-272(art)-272(of)-272(legerdemain)-272(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(capable)-260(of)-260(producing)-261(results)-260(which)-260(to)-260(an)-260(ignorant)-260(observer)-260(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-342(appearance)-341(of)-342(being)-341(supernatural.)-525(But)-342(this)-341(class)-342(of)-341(actions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bears)-378(not)-379(the)-378(smallest)-379(analogy)-378(to)-379(the)-378(miracles)-379(recorded)-378(in)-378(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(New)-253(Testament.)-260(No)-253(art)-253(of)-253(legerdemain)-253(can)-253(persuade)-253(a)-253(man)-253(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(has)-324(been)-324(for)-324(many)-324(years)-324(blind)-324(to)-324(believe)-324(that)-324(he)-324(has)-324(recovered)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-250(sight,)-250(and)-250(enable)-250(him)-250(to)-250(act)-250(accordingly.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([238])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -15.185 Td [(But)-327(it)-327(has)-328(been)-327(argued;)-366(if)-327(God)-327(is)-328(the)-327(moral)-327(Governor)-327(of)-327(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(universe,)-430(is)-393(He)-394(not)-394(bound)-393(to)-394(prevent)-394(a)-393(being)-394(like)-394(Satan)-393(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acting)-475(for)-475(the)-475(purposes)-475(of)-474(evil)-475(in)-475(the)-475(affairs)-475(of)-475(men?)-924(This)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
983 0 obj <<
/Length 3149      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(210)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(question)-396(may)-397(be)-396(best)-397(answered)-396(by)-396(asking)-397(another.)-689(Is)-396(He)-396(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(equally)-420(bound)-421(to)-420(hinder)-421(evil)-420(men)-420(from)-421(exerting)-420(such)-420(terrible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(influences)-343(on)-343(others,)-366(even)-343(long)-343(after)-343(they)-343(are)-343(dead?)-529(Is)-343(He)-342(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bound)-268(to)-268(hinder)-268(the)-268(possibility)-268(of)-268(the)-268(bringing)-268(up)-268(of)-268(children)-267(by)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(their)-362(parents)-361(in)-362(various)-362(forms)-361(of)-362(vice,)-389(so)-362(as)-362(to)-361(render)-362(them)-361(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(after)-262(life,)-265(more)-262(wicked)-261(than)-262(themselves?)-286(Yet)-262(it)-262(is)-262(an)-261(indubitable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-201(that)-201(such)-201(an)-200(influence)-201(is)-201(exerted)-201(under)-201(the)-201(moral)-200(government)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-432(God.)-796(Human)-432(life)-432(abounds)-432(with)-432(such)-432(cases,)-477(which)-432(bear)-432(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(close)-404(analogy)-403(to)-404(Satanic)-403(action)-404(exerted)-403(in)-404(the)-403(affairs)-404(of)-403(men.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(When)-309(we)-309(can)-308(fully)-309(fathom)-309(the)-309(reason)-308(for)-309(the)-309(permission)-309(of)-308(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one,)-255(we)-255(shall)-254(have)-254(made)-255(considerable)-254(progress)-254(in)-254(understanding)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-364(of)-363(the)-364(other.)-590(The)-363(case)-364(may)-363(be)-364(simply)-363(stated.)-591(There)-363(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difficulties)-419(in)-418(the)-419(moral)-419(government)-419(of)-418(the)-419(universe,)-461(into)-418(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(grounds)-327(of)-326(which)-327(we)-326(cannot)-326(penetrate.)-480(These)-326(press)-327(equally)-326(on)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(every)-399(form)-399(of)-399(theism.)-697(The)-399(Satanic)-399(supernaturalism)-398(described)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-289(the)-289(New)-289(Testament)-289(presents)-289(a)-289(precisely)-289(analogous)-289(difficulty.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-373(therefore)-373(can)-373(form)-373(no)-373(reason)-373(why)-373(one)-373(who)-373(believes)-373(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God)-416(is)-416(the)-416(moral)-416(Governor)-416(of)-415(the)-416(universe,)-458(as)-416(it)-416(now)-415(exists,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-235(reject)-236(Christianity)-235(because)-235(the)-235(difficulties)-236(are)-235(of)-235(a)-235(similar)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(order,)-216(and)-208(press)-207(equally)-208(on)-207(both.)-236(The)-207(only)-208(escape)-207(from)-208(them,)-216(as)-207(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-241(already)-241(said,)-243(is)-241(the)-241(inevitable)-241(position)-241(assumed)-241(by)-241(atheism,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-329(pantheism,)-350(and)-329(the)-329(dreary)-330(prospect)-329(which)-329(they)-330(afford)-329(to)-329(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aspirations)-250(of)-250(the)-250(human)-250(mind.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -29.64 Td [([239])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
991 0 obj <<
/Length 3226      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-264(XI.)-263(Possession:)-277(Is)-264(The)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Theory)-268(That)-267(It)-268(Was)-267(Madness)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Subversive)-252(Of)-253(The)-252(Historical)-252(Value)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Of)-262(The)-261(Gospels)-262(Or)-261(Inconsistent)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(With)-250(The)-250(Veracity)-250(Of)-250(Christ?)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -40.413 Td [(There)-278(can)-279(be)-278(no)-278(doubt)-279(that)-278(the)-278(subject)-279(of)-278(possession)-278(is)-278(attended)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-302(real)-303(difficulties,)-315(whichever)-302(view)-302(we)-303(may)-302(take)-302(of)-302(its)-302(actual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character.)]TJ 11.956 -15.147 Td [(The)-489(symptoms)-489(which)-488(are)-489(alleged)-489(to)-489(have)-489(accompanied)-488(it)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(present)-443(many)-442(of)-443(the)-442(usual)-443(phenomena)-442(of)-442(madness.)-828(No)-442(pos-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(session)-329(is)-330(believed)-329(to)-329(take)-329(place)-330(now,)-349(but)-329(such)-329(phenomena)-329(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attributed)-386(to)-387(causes)-386(purely)-387(natural.)-659(The)-386(supposed)-386(possessions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-251(which)-251(are)-251(mentioned)-250(in)-251(the)-251(New)-251(Testament)-251(or)-251(in)-250(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ancient)-314(writings)-314(are)-313(said)-314(to)-314(be)-314(due)-313(only)-314(to)-314(ignorance)-314(of)-313(natural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(causes.)-344(Many)-281(very)-282(eminent)-281(defenders)-281(of)-282(Christianity)-281(have)-281(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-345(deeply)-345(impressed)-345(by)-346(these)-345(and)-345(other)-345(reasons)-345(that)-345(they)-345(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(admitted)-410(that)-411(possession)-410(is)-410(only)-410(a)-410(form)-411(of)-410(madness,)-450(and)-410(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-273(language)-274(respecting)-273(it)-273(in)-274(the)-273(New)-273(Testament)-274(is)-273(based)-273(on)-273(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(current)-250(ideas)-250(of)-250(the)-250(day.)]TJ 11.956 -15.148 Td [(It)-254(is)-254(desirable)-255(that)-254(the)-254(difficulty)-254(should)-255(be)-254(put)-254(in)-254(the)-254(strongest)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(light.)-407(I)-302(will)-302(therefore)-302(state)-303(it)-302(in)-302(the)-302(words)-303(of)-302(the)-302(author)-302(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 260.634 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Su-)]TJ -265.478 -13.549 Td [(pernatural)-244(Religion.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 87.201 0 Td [(\035)-244(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.353 0 Td [(It)-244(would)-245(be)-244(an)-245(insult)-244(to)-244(the)-245(understanding)]TJ -99.554 -13.549 Td [(of)-448(those)-449(who)-448(are)-449(considering)-448(this)-448(question,)-498(to)-449(pause)-448(here)-448(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prove)-318(that)-319(the)-318(historical)-318(books)-319(of)-318(the)-318(New)-319(Testament,)-335(speak)-318(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-334(clearest)-334(and)-335(most)-334(unmistakable)-334(terms)-334(of)-334(actual)-334(demoniacal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 49.397 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.993 0 Td [(Now)-380(what)-381(has)-380(become)-381(of)-380(this)-380(theory)-381(of)-380(disease?)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
994 0 obj <<
/Length 5348      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(212)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(The)-258(Archbishop)-258(of)-258(Dublin)-258(is)-258(probably)-516(the)-258(only)-258(one)-258(who)-258(asserts)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([240])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(the)-238(reality)-238(of)-238(demoniacal)-238(possession)-239(formerly,)-240(and)-238(in)-238(the)-238(present)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(day;)-432(and)-371(in)-371(this)-371(way)-371(we)-371(must)-370(say)-371(that)-371(he)-371(is)-371(consistent.)-613(Dean)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Milman,)-357(on)-335(the)-335(other)-335(hand,)-357(who)-335(spoke)-335(with)-335(the)-335(enlightenment)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-330(the)-329(19th)-330(century,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 91.854 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(has)-330(no)-329(scruple)-330(in)-329(averring)-330(his)-329(opinion)-330(on)]TJ -96.697 -13.549 Td [(the)-264(subject)-265(of)-264(demoniacal)-265(possession)-264(to)-265(be)-264(that)-265(of)-264(Joseph)-264(Mede,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Lardner,)-363(Dr.)-522(Mead,)-363(Paley,)-364(and)-340(all)-341(the)-340(learned)-341(modern)-340(writers.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-418(was)-419(a)-418(kind)-418(of)-419(insanity,)-460(and)-418(nothing)-419(is)-418(more)-418(probable)-418(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-335(lunacy)-334(would)-335(take)-334(the)-335(turn,)-356(and)-334(speak)-335(the)-334(language)-335(of)-334(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(prevailing)-332(superstition)-332(of)-332(the)-332(times.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 158.417 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.465 0 Td [(The)-332(Dean,)-352(as)-332(well)-332(as)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 97.995 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(all)]TJ -269.721 -13.549 Td [(the)-200(learned)-200(modern)-200(writers)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 115.599 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.023 0 Td [(to)-200(whom)-200(he)-200(refers,)-209(felt)-200(the)-200(difficulty,)]TJ -122.622 -13.549 Td [(but)-441(in)-441(seeking)-441(to)-441(evade)-441(it,)-489(they)-441(sacrifice)-441(the)-441(Gospels.)-822(They)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(overlook)-351(the)-351(fact,)-377(that)-351(the)-351(writers)-351(of)-352(these)-351(narratives,)-376(not)-351(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(themselves)-310(adopt)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 79.474 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(the)-310(prevailing)-309(superstition)-310(of)-309(the)-310(times,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 174.15 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.22 0 Td [(but)]TJ -266.688 -13.55 Td [(represent)-236(Jesus)-236(as)-235(doing)-236(so)-236(with)-236(equal)-236(completeness.)-245(There)-236(is)-235(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possibility,)-327(for)-312(instance,)-327(of)-312(evading)-312(such)-312(statements)-312(as)-312(those)-311(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-191(miracle)-192(of)-191(the)-192(country)-191(of)-191(the)-192(Gadarenes,)-203(where)-191(the)-191(objectivity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-224(the)-225(demons)-224(is)-224(so)-225(fully)-224(recognised,)-229(that)-225(on)-224(being)-224(cast)-225(out)-224(of)-224(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man,)-276(they)-270(are)-270(represented)-271(as)-270(requesting)-270(to)-271(be)-270(allowed)-271(to)-270(go)-270(into)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-191(herd)-191(of)-191(swine,)-202(and)-191(being)-191(permitted)-191(by)-191(Jesus)-191(to)-191(do)-191(so,)-203(the)-190(entry)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-348(the)-347(demons)-348(into)-348(the)-347(swine)-348(is)-347(at)-348(once)-348(signalised)-347(by)-348(the)-347(herd)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(running)-209(violently)-209(down)-209(the)-208(cliff)-209(into)-209(the)-209(lake)-209(and)-209(being)-208(drowned.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(\050p.)-573(131.\051)-574(The)-357(author)-358(might)-358(have)-358(strengthened)-357(his)-358(case,)-385(as)-357(far)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-251(modern)-251(authorities)-250(are)-251(concerned,)-251(by)-251(drawing)-251(attention)-251(to)-250(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fact,)-326(that)-310(even)-311(Dr.)-432(Farrar,)-325(who)-311(seems)-311(to)-310(maintain)-311(the)-310(objective)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reality)-237(of)-237(demoniacal)-236(possessions)-237(in)-237(his)-237(recently)-237(published)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 257.612 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Life)]TJ -262.456 -13.549 Td [(of)-320(Christ,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 41.976 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.331 0 Td [(admits)-320(that)-320(in)-319(the)-320(statement)-320(that)-319(the)-320(demons)-320(locally)]TJ -50.307 -13.549 Td [(passed)-302(from)-303(the)-302(man)-302(into)-302(the)-302(swine,)-316(some)-302(inaccuracy)-302(has)-302(crept)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-250(the)-250(narrative)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Evangelists.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-409(will)-409(be)-409(at)-409(once)-409(seen)-409(that)-409(the)-409(all-important)-409(point)-818(in)-408(this)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([241])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(objection)-285(is)-285(the)-285(apparent)-285(acceptance)-285(by)-285(our)-285(Lord)-285(of)-284(demoniacal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession,)-222(as)-215(being)-216(a)-215(correct)-215(account)-215(of)-215(an)-216(objective)-215(fact.)-238(I)-215(fully)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(agree)-255(with)-256(this)-255(writer,)-257(that)-256(those)-255(who)-256(affirm)-255(that)-256(it)-255(was)-255(madness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-313(nothing)-313(else)-312(are)-313(bound,)-329(when)-312(they)-313(propose)-313(this)-313(solution)-312(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
999 0 obj <<
/Length 4576      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(213)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(the)-209(difficulty,)-217(to)-210(point)-209(out)-209(distinctly)-209(how)-209(it)-209(affects)-209(the)-209(question)-209(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-250(Lord's)-250(veracity,)-250(and)-250(the)-250(historical)-250(character)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Gospels.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(In)-210(approaching)-209(this)-210(question,)-218(let)-209(me)-210(at)-210(once)-209(observe)-210(that)-210(while)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(I)-237(entertain)-236(a)-237(definite)-237(opinion)-236(as)-237(to)-236(the)-237(nature)-237(of)-236(the)-237(inspiration)-236(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-323(New)-322(Testament)-322(derived)-323(not)-322(from)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 168.348 0 Td [(\340)-322(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 37.952 0 Td [(assumptions,)-341(but)]TJ -206.3 -13.549 Td [(from)-235(a)-235(careful)-236(study)-235(of)-235(its)-235(facts)-236(and)-235(phenomena,)-238(yet)-235(the)-235(question)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-280(issue)-281(is)-280(not)-280(what)-280(is)-281(the)-280(nature)-280(or)-280(the)-281(extent)-280(of)-280(the)-280(inspiration,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-215(the)-214(reality)-215(of)-215(the)-214(supernatural)-215(events)-215(recorded)-214(in)-215(the)-214(Gospels.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-265(issue)-266(is)-265(one)-266(which)-265(is)-266(purely)-265(historical,)-269(and)-266(therefore)-265(I)-265(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(simply)-220(to)-219(examine)-219(it)-220(on)-219(historical)-220(grounds,)-226(and)-219(not)-219(to)-220(defend)-219(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(particular)-266(theory)-265(of)-266(inspiration.)-297(Our)-266(business)-265(is)-266(first)-266(to)-265(ascertain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(what)-248(are)-249(the)-248(facts)-248(of)-249(the)-248(New)-248(Testament)-249(which)-248(are)-248(supported)-248(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-238(evidence;)-242(when)-238(we)-238(have)-238(ascertained)-238(these,)-240(we)-238(shall)-238(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-328(a)-329(position)-328(to)-328(propound)-329(a)-328(theory)-328(of)-329(inspiration)-328(in)-328(accordance)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-276(the)-276(facts)-275(and)-276(assertions;)-289(still,)-282(however,)-282(it)-276(will)-276(be)-275(necessary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-206(find)-206(out)-206(how)-206(a)-205(certain)-206(state)-206(of)-206(the)-206(facts)-206(will)-206(affect)-206(the)-205(character)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(the)-250(Gospels)-250(attribute)-250(to)-250(our)-250(Lord.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(The)-344(following)-344(facts)-344(are)-344(plain)-344(on)-344(the)-344(surface)-344(of)-344(the)-344(Gospels.)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(First,)-235(that)-230(the)-231(followers)-231(of)-231(our)-230(Lord)-231(believed)-231(that)-231(the)-230(demoniacal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessions)-382(there)-383(recorded)-382(were)-383(objective)-382(facts,)-416(and)-382(not)-382(mere)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(forms)-250(of)-250(disease.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(Secondly,)-446(that)-407(our)-407(Lord)-407(himself,)-446(if)-407(the)-407(words)-407(attributed)-407(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Him)-238(are)-239(correctl)1(y)-239(reported,)-240(used)-239(language)-238(which)-238(seems)-238(to)-238(imply)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-250(He)-250(shared)-250(in)-250(this)-250(belief.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(Thirdly,)-346(that)-326(in)-327(a)-327(particular)-326(instance,)-346(not)-327(only)-327(do)-653(the)-326(Evan-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 279.068 0 Td [([242])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(gelists)-324(affirm)-324(that)-323(our)-324(Lord)-324(addressed)-324(a)-324(demoniac,)-342(but)-324(also)-323(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(demons)-175(who)-175(possessed)-175(him,)-190(and)-175(that)-175(He)-175(permitted)-175(their)-174(departure)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-219(a)-220(herd)-219(of)-219(swine,)-225(thereby)-220(apparently)-219(confirming)-219(the)-219(objective)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reality)-250(of)-250(the)-250(possession.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(The)-275(quest)1(ion)-275(is)-275(a)-274(far)-275(more)-274(serious)-275(one,)-280(as)-275(it)-274(affects)-275(our)-274(Lord,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(than)-362(those)-362(on)-361(whose)-362(reports)-362(the)-361(statements)-362(of)-362(the)-362(Gospels)-361(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(founded.)-755(He)-419(is)-418(represented)-419(as)-418(being)-419(a)-418(divine)-418(person,)-461(and)-418(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(possessed)-351(in)-350(His)-351(human)-351(nature,)-376(not)-351(of)-350(infinite)-351(but)-351(of)-350(superhu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-306(knowledge.)-419(His)-306(apparent)-306(sanction)-307(of)-306(an)-306(erroneous)-306(view)-306(is)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1004 0 obj <<
/Length 4667      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(214)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(therefore)-306(a)-307(very)-306(different)-307(thing)-306(from)-307(the)-306(apparent)-307(sanction)-306(of)-306(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-404(an)-403(author)-404(of)-404(a)-403(Gospel,)-442(or)-404(from)-404(the)-403(mistaken)-404(views)-403(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-258(followers)-258(might)-258(have)-259(entertained)-258(as)-258(to)-258(the)-258(causes)-258(of)-258(a)-258(bodily)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disease.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(I)-178(should)-179(find)-178(no)-179(difficulty)-178(in)-179(adopting)-178(the)-179(theory)-178(of)-179(the)-178(eminent)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(writers)-202(above)-202(named,)-211(that)-202(the)-202(demoniacal)-202(possessions)-201(mentioned)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-306(the)-306(New)-306(Testament,)-320(were)-306(nothing)-306(but)-306(forms)-306(of)-306(insanity,)-320(if)-305(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(were)-258(not)-257(that)-258(our)-258(Lord)-257(has)-258(apparently)-257(recognised)-258(their)-258(reality.)-272(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-253(been)-253(urged)-254(that)-253(if)-253(possession)-253(was)-253(nothing)-253(but)-254(insanity,)-253(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-247(an)-247(end)-246(of)-247(the)-247(miracle.)-249(But)-247(this)-246(is)-247(not)-247(the)-247(case,)-247(for)-247(the)-247(cure)-247(of)-246(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(madman)-294(is)-293(quite)-294(as)-293(much)-293(a)-294(supernatural)-293(act)-294(as)-293(the)-294(expulsion)-293(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-250(demon.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(Let)-281(me)-281(now)-281(assume)-280(for)-281(argument's)-281(sake,)-289(that)-281(possession)-280(was)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(simple)-217(madness.)-240(How)-217(does)-217(such)-218(a)-217(supposition)-218(affect)-217(the)-217(veracity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-405(the)-405(authors)-405(of)-405(the)-405(Gospels,)-444(and)-405(their)-405(judgment)-405(as)-405(credible)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(historians)-250(of)-250(the)-250(events)-250(of)-250(our)-250(Lord's)-250(life?)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(If)-271(we)-271(assume)-271(that)-271(possession)-271(was)-271(madness,)-276(it)-271(is)-271(evident)-271(from)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-180(language)-179(which)-180(the)-179(Evangelists)-180(have)-180(employed)-179(that)-180(they)-179(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-274(shared)-273(in)-274(the)-274(ignorance)-274(of)-273(the)-274(times)-274(in)-273(which)-274(they)-274(lived)-273(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-373(the)-374(true)-373(causes)-374(of)-373(the)-373(complaint.)-620(When)-374(however)-373(we)-373(speak)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-302(the)-303(ignorance)-302(of)-302(any)-302(particular)-302(period,)-316(it)-302(should)-302(be)-302(observed)]TJ 4.009 -13.549 Td [(that)-367(the)-368(expression)-367(is)-368(an)-367(indefinite)-368(one.)-602(We)-368(have)-367(no)-368(right)-367(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -76.764 0 Td [([243])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(impute)-262(to)-261(any)-262(body)-261(of)-262(authors)-261(opinions)-262(on)-261(particular)-262(subjects)-261(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-314(their)-314(writings)-314(contain)-314(no)-315(traces.)-442(It)-314(has)-314(been)-314(affirmed,)-330(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(we)-307(have)-308(seen,)-321(that)-308(the)-307(Jews)-307(of)-308(the)-307(apostolic)-307(age)-308(held)-307(a)-307(number)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-339(opinions)-340(on)-339(the)-339(subject)-339(of)-339(possession)-340(of)-339(the)-339(most)-339(grotesque)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-281(monstrous)-281(description.)-342(I)-281(have)-280(already)-281(shown)-281(that)-281(to)-280(impute)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-316(opinions)-317(to)-316(them,)-333(when)-316(no)-316(trace)-316(of)-316(them)-317(can)-316(be)-316(found)-316(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-250(writings)-250(is)-250(a)-250(most)-250(unfair)-250(mode)-250(of)-250(reasoning.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(When,)-469(therefore,)-468(I)-425(use)-425(the)-425(expression)-425(that)-425(they)-425(must)-424(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(shared)-319(in)-319(the)-319(ignorance)-319(of)-319(the)-319(age)-319(respecting)-319(the)-319(causes)-319(of)-318(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disease,)-430(I)-394(must)-395(guard)-394(against)-394(the)-394(danger)-395(of)-394(ascribing)-394(to)-394(them)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-379(greater)-379(degree)-379(of)-378(ignorance)-379(than)-379(that)-379(which)-379(they)-379(have)-378(actu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ally)-416(shown.)-748(The)-416(expression,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 136.157 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(ignorance)-416(of)-416(the)-416(age,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.919 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.383 0 Td [(denotes)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1008 0 obj <<
/Length 4592      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(215)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(no)-309(uniform)-310(quantity)-309(of)-309(ignorance)-309(shared)-310(in)-309(by)-309(every)-309(individual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alike.)-308(In)-270(an)-269(ignorant)-270(or)-269(superstitious)-269(age,)-275(one)-269(person)-270(may)-269(be)-269(far)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more)-304(so)-303(than)-304(another.)-411(It)-304(is)-304(quite)-303(conceivable)-304(that)-304(two)-303(thousand)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(years)-421(hence)-421(human)-422(improvement)-421(may)-421(have)-421(become)-421(so)-421(great,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-294(those)-293(who)-294(live)-293(in)-294(the)-293(present)-293(century)-294(may)-293(be)-294(designated)-293(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ignorant.)-231(It)-191(may)-191(be)-192(hereafter)-191(asserted)-192(that)-191(such)-192(writers)-191(as)-191(Huxley,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Tyndall,)-386(Herbert)-359(Spencer,)-387(and)-359(Mill)-358(shared)-359(in)-359(the)-359(ignorance)-359(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-370(age)-370(in)-370(which)-370(they)-370(lived)-370(on)-370(some)-370(important)-370(physical)-369(facts.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(But)-223(from)-222(this)-223(it)-222(would)-223(be)-222(absurd)-223(to)-222(draw)-223(the)-222(conclusion)-223(that)-222(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(were)-297(believers)-298(in)-297(the)-297(alleged)-297(facts)-298(of)-297(spiritualism)-297(because)-297(large)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(numbers)-341(of)-342(their)-341(contemporaries)-341(were)-342(known)-341(to)-341(have)-341(believed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-308(them,)-322(and)-308(spiritualistic)-307(publications)-308(enjoy)-308(a)-308(large)-307(circulation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(both)-250(in)-250(Europe)-250(and)-250(America)-250(in)-250(this)-250(nineteenth)-250(century.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(As)-312(far)-313(as)-312(the)-313(Evangelists)-312(are)-313(concerned,)-328(the)-312(supposition)-312(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(I)-262(am)-261(now)-262(considering)-261(involves)-262(nothing)-261(more)-262(than)-261(that)-262(they)-261(held)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-366(false)-366(theory)-366(as)-366(to)-367(the)-366(cause)-732(of)-366(a)-366(particular)-366(form)-366(of)-366(disease,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([244])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(and)-228(that)-229(they)-228(have)-228(used)-229(language)-228(respecting)-228(it)-229(that)-228(embodies)-228(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(theory.)-236(In)-209(this)-209(point)-209(of)-209(view)-208(they)-209(would)-209(not)-209(differ)-209(from)-209(writers)-208(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(every)-248(age)-249(who)-248(have)-249(entertained)-248(false)-248(theories)-249(as)-248(to)-249(the)-248(causes)-248(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical)-268(phenomena.)-303(In)-268(such)-267(cases)-268(it)-268(is)-268(easy)-267(to)-268(separate)-268(the)-267(fact)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-304(the)-304(incorrect)-304(view)-304(as)-304(to)-304(what)-304(were)-304(the)-304(causes)-304(of)-304(that)-304(fact.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Ancient)-285(philosophical)-284(writers)-285(held)-284(many)-285(false)-285(theories)-284(as)-285(to)-284(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(place)-340(of)-339(the)-340(local)-340(habitation)-339(in)-340(our)-340(bodies)-339(of)-340(certain)-339(affections)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-332(our)-332(moral)-331(nature.)-496(These)-332(can)-331(be)-332(traced)-332(very)-332(distinctly)-332(in)-331(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(language)-316(of)-316(the)-316(present)-316(day.)-448(Thus)-316(we)-316(say)-316(that)-316(a)-316(man)-316(is)-315(devoid)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-382(heart,)-416(and)-382(talk)-382(of)-382(making)-383(appeals)-382(to)-382(the)-382(heart.)-647(These,)-415(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(multitudes)-389(of)-390(similar)-389(expressions)-390(which)-389(occur)-390(both)-389(in)-389(ancient)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-266(modern)-267(writings,)-270(involve)-266(false)-267(phi)1(losophical)-267(theories;)-274(but)-266(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-362(easy)-361(to)-362(separate)-362(the)-362(facts)-361(intended)-362(from)-362(the)-361(theories.)-585(Thus,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-385(the)-385(authors)-384(of)-385(the)-385(Gospels)-385(inform)-385(us)-384(that)-385(our)-385(Lord)-385(cured)-384(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demoniac,)-428(and)-393(give)-393(an)-392(account)-393(of)-393(the)-392(demoniac's)-393(outcries,)-428(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(though)-374(they)-374(were)-374(the)-375(utterances)-374(of)-374(a)-374(demon,)-405(we)-374(have)-374(only)-374(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(substitute)-208(madman)-209(for)-208(demoniac,)-217(and)-208(the)-208(correct)-209(state)-208(of)-208(the)-208(case)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-250(easily)-250(discovered.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1012 0 obj <<
/Length 4637      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(216)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(The)-216(real)-216(difficulty)-216(which)-215(is)-216(felt)-216(on)-216(this)-216(subject,)-223(arises)-216(not)-215(from)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-341(narratives)-340(as)-341(ordinary)-340(histories,)-363(but)-341(on)-340(the)-341(supposition)-340(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-217(writers)-216(possessed)-217(an)-217(inspiration)-217(which)-216(ought)-217(to)-217(have)-216(guarded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-331(from)-331(such)-331(errors.)-494(Popular)-331(theories)-331(of)-331(inspiration)-331(unques-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tionably)-313(render)-313(such)-313(an)-313(assumption)-313(necessary,)-329(but)-313(I)-313(can)-313(see)-313(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ground)-212(for)-212(it,)-220(either)-212(in)-213(the)-212(statements)-212(of)-212(the)-212(Gospels,)-220(or)-212(any)-212(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(portion)-350(of)-350(the)-350(New)-350(Testament.)-550(Nowhere)-350(is)-350(it)-350(affirmed)-350(that)-350(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writers)-256(were)-257(to)-256(be)-256(guided)-257(into)-256(all)-257(truth,)-258(scientific,)-257(philosophical,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-336(even)-336(historical.)-507(All)-336(that)-336(is)-336(affirmed)-336(is)-336(that)-336(they)-336(possessed)-335(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(degree)-307(of)-307(supernatural)-307(enlightenment)-307(adequate)-307(to)-306(communicate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-429(Christian)-428(revelation)-429(to)-429(mankind.)-785(Neither)-429(is)-429(there)-857(a)-428(hint)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([245])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(given,)-266(nor)-263(can)-263(a)-263(fact)-262(be)-263(adduced,)-266(to)-263(show)-263(that)-263(their)-262(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(illumination)-300(extended)-299(beyond)-300(this.)-399(The)-300(spiritual)-300(gifts)-299(bestowed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-217(enlightenment)-217(beyond)-218(the)-217(special)-217(function)-217(of)-217(those)-217(gifts.)-239(This)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-415(affirmation)-414(of)-415(St.)-743(Paul)-415(in)-414(the)-415(Epistles)-414(to)-415(the)-414(Corinthians)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(makes)-425(clear.)-773(A)-425(person)-424(having)-425(the)-424(gift)-425(of)-424(tongues,)-468(if)-425(he)-424(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-384(also)-384(that)-384(of)-383(interpretation)-384(was)-384(unable)-384(to)-384(interpret)-384(his)-383(own)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(utterances,)-396(and)-368(the)-367(possession)-367(of)-367(the)-367(high)-367(gift)-367(of)-367(prophecy)-367(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-273(means)-273(exempted)-274(the)-273(possessor)-273(from)-273(the)-274(danger)-273(of)-273(using)-273(it)-273(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-359(manner)-360(to)-359(create)-360(confusion)-359(in)-359(the)-360(Church.)-578(Even)-359(the)-359(highest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apostolic)-240(gifts)-240(conferred)-239(no)-240(infallibility,)-242(but)-240(were)-240(strictly)-239(limited)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-377(their)-377(proper)-378(functions)-377(of)-377(communicating)-377(the)-377(great)-377(truths)-377(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-311(Christian)-312(revelation.)-434(The)-311(idea)-312(that)-311(they)-312(conferred)-311(a)-311(general)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(infallibility)-383(is)-383(no)-384(statement)-383(of)-383(the)-383(New)-384(Testament,)-416(but)-383(a)-383(pure)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(figment)-250(of)-250(the)-250(imagination.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(It)-363(therefore)-364(by)-363(no)-364(means)-363(follows)-364(because)-363(the)-364(writers)-363(of)-363(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(New)-237(Testament)-237(had)-236(an)-237(illumination)-237(sufficient)-237(for)-237(their)-236(functions)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-217(they)-216(had)-217(any)-217(other)-217(than)-216(their)-217(ordinary)-217(enlightenment)-216(beyond)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-215(limit.)-238(They)-215(might)-215(have)-214(been)-215(good)-215(teachers)-215(of)-215(religious)-214(truth,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-194(yet)-194(utterly)-195(ignorant)-194(of)-194(physical)-194(science.)-232(The)-194(assertion)-194(may)-194(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(correct)-194(that)-195(St.)-231(Luke)-194(possessed)-195(a)-194(supernatural)-194(guidance)-194(sufficient)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-361(enable)-362(him)-361(to)-362(compose)-361(the)-362(third)-361(Gospel,)-390(and)-361(yet)-362(it)-361(may)-361(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(no)-349(less)-350(true,)-374(that)-349(as)-349(a)-350(physician)-349(he)-349(had)-350(no)-349(medical)-349(knowledge)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beyond)-372(that)-372(of)-372(his)-372(time,)-402(and)-372(that)-372(he)-372(shared)-372(in)-372(all)-372(its)-372(errors)-372(as)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1016 0 obj <<
/Length 4472      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(217)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(to)-399(the)-400(causes)-399(and)-400(cure)-399(of)-399(physical)-400(disease.)-698(A)-399(man)-400(may)-399(be)-399(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(good)-262(physician)-262(of)-261(the)-262(soul,)-265(and)-262(at)-262(the)-261(same)-262(time)-262(a)-262(very)-261(ignorant)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physician)-362(of)-362(the)-361(body.)-586(It)-361(is)-362(quite)-362(conceivable,)-390(therefore,)-389(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-312(the)-311(Evangelists)-312(or)-311(those)-312(followers)-311(of)-312(Christ)-311(from)-312(whom)-311(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(derived)-239(their)-240(accounts)-239(possessed)-239(various)-240(degrees)-239(of)-239(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enlightenment)-414(on)-413(matters)-414(directly)-413(affecting)-414(Christianity,)-908(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([246])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(they)-357(possessed)-356(none)-356(whatever)-357(as)-356(to)-357(the)-356(causes)-357(of)-356(disease,)-383(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-362(they)-362(may)-362(have)-361(viewed)-362(madness)-362(as)-362(a)-362(result)-362(of)-361(demoniacal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action,)-254(and)-253(described)-253(it)-253(accordingly.)-260(The)-253(facts)-253(would)-253(remain)-253(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(same;)-456(the)-387(symptoms)-388(mi)1(ght)-388(have)-387(been)-387(exhibited,)-422(and)-387(the)-387(cure)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(actually)-250(effected.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-218(the)-219(New)-218(Testament)-219(likewise)-218(affirms)-218(that)-219(our)-218(Lord)-218(impart-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ed)-192(to)-191(His)-192(followers)-192(the)-191(power)-192(of)-192(expelling)-191(demons,)-204(as)-191(well)-192(as)-191(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-273(healing)-272(diseases.)-318(Now,)-278(on)-273(the)-273(supposition)-272(that)-273(these)-272(demoni-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acs)-286(were)-286(simple)-286(maniacs,)-295(how)-286(does)-286(this)-286(affect)-286(the)-286(credibility)-285(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(narrative?)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-214(reply)-214(that)-214(during)-213(the)-214(mission)-214(of)-214(the)-214(Apostles)-214(and)-214(the)-214(S)1(eventy)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(\050for)-410(these)-410(are)-410(the)-409(cases)-410(alluded)-410(to\051)-410(there)-410(is)-410(no)-410(promise)-409(made)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-287(of)-286(supernatural)-287(enlightenment.)-360(They)-287(were)-286(simply)-287(sent)-286(out)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-295(announce)-296(a)-295(specific)-295(fact,)-307(the)-295(near)-295(approach)-296(and)-295(setting)-295(up)-295(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-377(kingdom)-377(of)-376(heaven,)-409(and)-376(to)-377(work)-377(miracles)-377(in)-376(confirmation)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-325(it.)-477(It)-325(is)-326(true)-325(that)-325(in)-326(His)-325(address)-326(to)-325(them,)-344(our)-326(Lord)-325(told)-325(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-278(a)-278(time)-278(was)-279(coming)-278(when)-278(they)-278(would)-278(have)-278(to)-278(testify)-278(to)-278(Him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(before)-319(princes)-320(and)-319(kings,)-337(and)-319(that)-320(He)-319(promises)-319(them,)-337(that)-319(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-297(receive)-297(supernatural)-297(assistance,)-309(suitable)-297(to)-297(the)-297(emergen-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cy.)-548(But)-350(this)-349(never)-350(arose)-349(during)-350(the)-349(mission)-350(in)-349(question.)-548(They)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-293(commanded)-292(to)-293(cure)-293(the)-292(reputed)-293(demoniac)-293(in)-292(confirmation)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-452(their)-453(mission.)-857(This)-452(would)-452(be)-453(an)-452(equally)-452(miraculous)-452(sign)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whether)-291(he)-291(was)-292(one)-291(possessed)-291(or)-291(a)-291(simple)-292(maniac.)-373(In)-291(this)-291(case,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore,)-221(there)-213(was)-213(no)-213(reason)-213(why)-213(they)-213(should)-213(be)-213(supernaturally)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enlightened)-374(as)-374(to)-374(the)-374(causes)-374(of)-374(this)-374(disease,)-405(more)-374(than)-374(of)-374(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other.)-495(No)-332(doubt)-332(the)-331(theories)-332(then)-332(prevalent)-332(as)-331(to)-332(the)-332(causes)-331(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(disease)-299(generally)-300(were)-299(very)-299(faulty.)-398(It)-299(could)-300(not)-299(be)-299(otherwise)-299(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-285(state)-284(of)-285(medical)-285(science)-284(at)-285(that)-285(period.)-354(So)-284(they)-285(must)-284(always)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1020 0 obj <<
/Length 4825      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(218)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(have)-278(been)-279(while)-278(such)-279(a)-278(truth)-278(as)-279(the)-278(circulation)-278(of)-279(the)-278(blood)-278(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unknown.)-468(But)-203(the)-202(object)-202(of)-202(Christianity)-203(was)-202(not)-202(to)-202(communicate)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([247])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(scientific)-304(knowledge,)-317(or)-303(to)-304(teach)-304(the)-303(true)-304(causes)-304(of)-303(disease,)-317(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-346(discover)-346(truths)-346(mightily)-346(operative)-346(in)-346(the)-346(moral)-346(and)-346(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(worlds.)-397(It)-299(follows,)-311(therefore,)-311(that)-299(the)-299(ignorance)-299(of)-299(the)-298(disciples)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-324(to)-324(the)-324(actual)-324(causes)-324(of)-324(mania)-324(no)-324(more)-324(affects)-324(the)-323(credibility)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-248(the)-249(narrative)-248(than)-248(their)-249(ignorance)-248(of)-248(the)-249(causes)-248(of)-248(paralysis)-248(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(leprosy.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-216(is)-216(also)-216(evident)-215(from)-216(the)-216(statements)-216(of)-216(the)-216(Gospels,)-223(that)-215(there)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(were)-244(a)-244(considerable)-245(number)-244(of)-244(persons)-244(who)-244(practised)-244(exorcisms)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-427(various)-426(kinds,)-471(and)-427(who)-426(fully)-427(believed)-427(that)-426(the)-427(persons)-426(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whom)-331(they)-332(operated)-331(were)-332(possessed)-331(by)-331(demons.)-495(It)-331(seems)-331(also)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(probable)-299(from)-298(the)-299(allusions)-298(made)-299(to)-299(them,)-310(that)-299(these)-298(exorcisms)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-296(occasionally)-296(successful)-296(in)-295(effecting)-296(a)-296(cure;)-319(and)-296(it)-296(may)-295(be,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more)-185(frequently,)-197(in)-185(mitigating)-184(the)-185(symptoms.)-228(This,)-198(however,)-197(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(not)-371(always)-370(the)-371(case;)-431(for)-370(the)-371(Evangelists)-370(describe)-371(the)-370(disciples)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-369(entirely)-369(unsuccessful)-369(in)-369(the)-369(case)-369(of)-369(the)-370(child,)-398(out)-369(of)-369(whom)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-387(invoked)-388(the)-387(demon)-387(to)-387(depart)-387(in)-388(the)-387(name)-387(of)-387(Jesus.)-662(It)-387(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(worthy)-420(of)-420(observation,)-462(that)-420(in)-420(this)-420(instance,)-462(the)-420(father)-420(of)-419(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demoniac)-388(describes)-388(his)-389(son's)-388(case)-388(as)-388(a)-388(combination)-388(of)-388(lunacy)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-310(possession,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 72.085 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(He)-310(is)-311(lunatic)-310(and)-310(sore)-311(vexed.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 129.324 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.229 0 Td [(Their)-310(failure)-311(is)]TJ -214.481 -13.549 Td [(directly)-271(attributed)-271(to)-271(want)-270(of)-271(faith,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 154.433 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 16.74 0 Td [(that)-271(there)-271(was)-271(something)]TJ -171.173 -13.549 Td [(wanting)-297(in)-297(their)-297(mental)-297(state)-297(which)-297(prevented)-297(them)-297(from)-297(exert-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ing)-332(the)-331(requisite)-332(influence)-331(over)-332(the)-331(lunatic)-332(youth.)-494(The)-332(want)-331(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(success)-320(with)-321(which)-320(exorcists)-320(were)-321(not)-320(unfrequently)-320(attended)-320(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(strikingly)-343(set)-343(before)-343(us)-343(in)-343(the)-343(account)-343(given)-343(in)-343(the)-343(Acts)-343(of)-343(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Apostles,)-230(of)-225(the)-225(attempt)-226(made)-225(by)-225(certain)-225(Jewish)-225(exorcists)-225(to)-225(cure)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-399(demoniac)-399(at)-400(Ephesus.)-697(In)-399(this)-399(case)-400(it)-399(not)-399(only)-399(ended)-399(in)-399(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(complete)-250(failure,)-250(but)-250(in)-250(an)-250(aggravation)-250(of)-250(the)-250(malady.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Now)-341(when)-341(we)-341(consider)-342(the)-341(various)-341(forms)-341(which)-682(mania)-341(as-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([248])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(sumes,)-430(it)-395(is)-394(quite)-394(credible)-394(that)-395(exorcisms)-394(may)-394(have)-394(exerted)-394(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(favourable)-198(influence)-198(on)-197(it,)-208(altogether)-198(apart)-198(from)-198(any)-197(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(power)-359(possessed)-360(by)-359(the)-360(operator.)-578(It)-359(is)-359(clear)-360(that)-359(the)-359(supposed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(maniacs)-231(imagined)-231(themselves)-232(under)-231(the)-231(influence)-231(of)-231(demoniacal)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1025 0 obj <<
/Length 4550      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(219)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(possession.)-477(When)-326(we)-326(consider)-325(the)-326(powerful)-326(influence)-326(that)-325(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mind)-402(is)-402(capable)-403(of)-402(exerting)-402(over)-402(another)-402(under)-402(these)-402(circum-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stances)-345(we)-346(can)-345(see)-346(that)-345(the)-346(presence)-345(of)-346(superior)-345(mental)-345(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-218(an)-218(influence)-219(exactly)-218(suited)-218(to)-218(produce)-219(a)-218(favourable)-218(result.)-239(In)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(our)-328(modern)-328(treatment)-328(of)-328(mania)-328(\050whatever)-328(may)-328(be)-328(the)-327(opinions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-217(to)-218(its)-217(physical)-218(origin\051)-217(it)-217(is)-218(now)-217(universally)-218(admitted)-217(that)-217(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(means)-326(are)-325(the)-326(most)-326(efficacious.)-477(Some)-325(obvious)-326(physical)-325(causes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-391(be)-391(dealt)-391(with)-391(and)-392(removed,)-426(while)-391(others)-391(cannot.)-673(But)-391(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(most)-412(successful)-412(operator)-411(on)-412(these)-412(forms)-411(of)-412(lunacy)-412(is)-412(he)-411(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(applies)-263(to)-262(them)-263(the)-263(most)-263(effective)-262(moral)-263(treatment,)-266(under)-262(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-370(many)-370(cases)-370(its)-370(symptoms)-370(have)-370(gradually)-370(disappeared.)-610(One)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-311(these)-310(modes)-311(of)-311(treatment)-311(is)-310(never)-311(to)-311(cross)-310(the)-311(patient)-311(on)-310(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subject)-357(of)-356(his)-357(delusions.)-569(Nothing)-356(is)-357(more)-356(remarkable)-357(than)-356(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(influence)-272(which)-272(the)-272(efficient)-272(practitioner)-272(can)-272(exert)-272(over)-272(persons)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(suffering)-210(from)-209(these)-210(forms)-209(of)-210(madness,)-218(by)-209(the)-210(mere)-209(energy)-210(of)-209(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will;)-251(a)-250(display)-250(of)-251(mental)-250(power)-251(analogous)-250(to)-250(that)-251(of)-250(strong)-250(faith.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-240(will)-239(often)-240(produce)-239(a)-240(calm)-239(among)-240(maniacs)-239(which)-240(persons)-239(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inferior)-224(endowments)-224(utterly)-224(fail)-224(to)-224(excite.)-241(It)-224(is)-224(an)-224(unquestionable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-334(that)-334(high)-334(mental)-334(and)-334(moral)-334(power)-334(is)-334(capable)-334(of)-334(producing)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(striking)-250(results)-250(on)-250(different)-250(forms)-250(of)-250(maniacal)-250(disease.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(This)-368(being)-369(so,)-398(it)-368(follows)-369(that)-368(exorcists)-368(might)-369(be)-368(capable)-368(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(exerting)-296(upon)-297(maniacs)-296(a)-296(powerful)-297(influence)-296(favourable)-296(to)-296(cure.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(In)-423(the)-423(ancient)-423(world)-423(the)-423(usual)-423(treatment)-423(was)-423(that)-423(of)-422(extreme)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(harshness.)-252(The)-251(demoniac)-251(of)-251(Gadara)-250(had)-251(been)-251(bound)-251(with)-250(chains)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-383(fetters.)-651(This)-383(is)-383(now)-384(known)-383(to)-384(have)-383(a)-383(direct)-384(tendency)-766(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([249])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(aggravate)-389(the)-389(disease,)-424(rather)-389(than)-389(to)-389(cure)-389(it.)-667(It)-389(is)-388(no)-389(wonder,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore,)-264(if)-261(the)-262(exorcist,)-264(by)-261(adopting)-261(an)-262(opposite)-261(mode)-261(of)-261(treat-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ment,)-409(and)-377(even)-377(by)-377(sympathizing)-377(with)-377(the)-377(sufferer's)-376(delusions,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-253(capable)-253(of)-254(alleviating)-253(the)-253(symptoms)-253(of)-253(the)-253(complaint,)-254(if)-253(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-219(effecting)-219(a)-219(cure.)-240(The)-219(whole)-219(result)-219(may)-219(have)-219(been)-219(due)-218(to)-219(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(influence)-359(and)-359(spiritual)-359(power,)-386(which)-359(may)-359(have)-359(been)-359(taken)-359(for)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-299(expulsion)-299(of)-299(a)-298(demon.)-397(In)-299(whatever)-299(way)-299(it)-299(was)-298(effected,)-311(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cure)-250(or)-250(the)-250(alleviation)-250(was)-250(no)-250(less)-250(real.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-366(follows,)-396(therefore,)-395(that)-367(the)-366(exorcists)-366(of)-367(the)-366(ancient)-366(world)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1030 0 obj <<
/Length 4893      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(220)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(were)-454(far)-454(from)-454(necessarily)-454(being)-454(a)-454(set)-454(of)-454(impostors,)-505(even)-454(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-392(supposition)-392(that)-392(possession)-392(was)-392(simple)-392(mania.)-676(They)-391(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-385(been)-385(able)-384(to)-385(effect)-385(real)-385(alleviations)-384(or)-385(even)-385(cures)-385(of)-384(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(complaint,)-357(although)-335(they)-335(were)-335(ignorant)-335(as)-335(to)-336(its)-335(cause,)-356(or)-335(how)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(their)-392(exertions)-393(produced)-392(a)-392(successful)-393(result.)-677(There)-392(is)-392(nothing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inconsistent)-288(with)-288(their)-287(general)-288(honesty,)-297(if)-288(they)-288(themselves)-287(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-413(the)-413(belief)-413(that)-412(they)-413(were)-413(expelling)-413(demons,)-454(while)-412(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-334(really)-334(curing)-334(ordinary)-334(mania.)-502(It)-334(should)-334(also)-334(be)-334(observed,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-324(a)-324(real)-324(power)-324(of)-324(exerting)-324(an)-324(influence)-324(on)-324(madmen)-324(was)-324(one)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-307(in)-308(those)-307(times)-308(of)-307(ignorance,)-322(both)-307(of)-308(mental)-307(and)-307(physical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(science,)-291(admitted)-283(of)-282(fearful)-283(abuse,)-291(and)-283(if)-282(exercised)-283(for)-283(evil)-282(pur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(poses,)-295(was)-286(capable)-286(of)-285(producing)-286(many)-286(of)-286(the)-286(worst)-286(results)-285(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-245(the)-245(practice)-245(of)-245(witchcraft)-245(and)-245(sorcery)-245(have)-245(been)-245(attended.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(A)-262(large)-262(portion)-261(of)-262(these)-262(latter)-261(operations)-262(no)-262(doubt)-262(resulted)-261(from)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-322(successful)-321(practice)-322(of)-322(ocular)-321(deception,)-340(but)-322(another)-321(portion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-251(them)-250(unquestionably)-251(resulted)-250(from)-251(the)-250(mighty)-251(influences)-250(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-272(powerful)-272(mind)-272(can)-272(exert)-272(over)-272(a)-272(weak,)-278(imaginative,)-277(and)-272(super-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stitious)-267(one.)-300(There)-267(are)-266(many)-267(depths)-267(of)-266(human)-267(nature)-267(into)-266(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(science)-335(has)-336(as)-335(yet)-335(failed)-336(to)-335(penetrate;)-378(and)-335(among)-336(these)-335(are)-335(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(entire)-250(phenomena)-250(of)-250(mania)-250(and)-250(religious)-250(frenzy.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([250])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -18.458 Td [(These)-308(facts)-309(and)-308(considerations)-309(are)-308(sufficient)-309(to)-308(vindicate)-308(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(credibility)-390(of)-389(the)-390(writers)-389(of)-390(the)-389(New)-390(Testament)-389(in)-390(their)-389(state-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ment,)-226(that)-220(a)-220(power)-219(of)-220(exorcism)-220(was)-220(known)-220(and)-220(exercised)-220(in)-219(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(time,)-268(and)-264(that)-264(its)-264(exercise)-265(was)-264(at)-264(times)-264(attended)-264(with)-264(favourable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(results.)-360(The)-287(statement)-286(on)-287(this)-287(subject)-287(attributed)-286(to)-287(our)-287(Lord,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 268.521 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(If)]TJ -273.365 -13.549 Td [(I)-255(by)-254(Satan)-254(cast)-255(out)-254(devils,)-256(by)-255(whom)-254(do)-255(your)-254(sons)-254(cast)-255(them)-254(out?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-337(shall)-337(they)-336(be)-337(your)-337(judges,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 158.637 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.517 0 Td [(is)-337(plainly)-337(an)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 58.901 0 Td [(ad)-337(hominem)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -226.055 -13.55 Td [(argument.)-241(It)-223(amounts)-223(to)-222(no)-223(more)-223(than)-223(this;)-232(You)-223(Pharisees)-222(accuse)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(me)-352(of)-351(casting)-352(out)-351(demons)-351(through)-352(Beelzebub.)-554(You)-352(assert)-351(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(your)-367(disciples)-367(exercise)-367(a)-367(power)-367(of)-368(exorcism;)-425(and)-367(that)-367(they)-367(do)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-255(in)-254(virtue)-255(of)-255(a)-254(divine)-255(power)-255(communicated)-254(to)-255(them.)-264(On)-254(what)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(principle)-262(of)-262(common)-262(sense)-261(can)-262(you)-262(affirm)-262(that)-262(the)-262(power)-261(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(I)-287(exercise)-287(is)-287(demoniacal,)-296(and)-287(that)-287(which)-287(your)-287(disciples)-286(exercise)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-304(divine?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 42.706 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(There)-304(is)-303(no)-304(assertion)-304(made)-303(one)-304(way)-304(or)-303(the)-304(other)-304(as)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1034 0 obj <<
/Length 4884      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(221)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(to)-244(the)-244(reality)-243(of)-244(the)-244(acts)-244(in)-244(question;)-245(nor)-244(is)-244(there)-244(any)-244(difficulty)-243(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposing)-309(that)-310(our)-309(Lord)-309(recognised)-309(that)-310(some)-309(of)-309(the)-309(influences)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thus)-250(exerted)-250(were)-250(genuine.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-202(have)-202(hitherto,)-212(in)-202(treating)-203(this)-202(part)-202(of)-202(the)-202(subject,)-212(been)-202(dealing)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(with)-346(the)-346(supposition)-345(that)-346(our)-346(Lord's)-346(disciples)-346(mistook)-345(maniacs)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-340(demoniacs,)-363(and)-340(the)-340(consequences)-341(of)-340(such)-340(a)-340(mistake)-340(on)-340(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(authenticity)-244(of)-244(the)-244(Gospel)-244(narratives.)-248(I)-244(must)-244(now)-244(address)-244(myself)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-251(the)-250(far)-251(more)-251(important)-250(question)-251(as)-251(to)-250(the)-251(consequences)-250(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(follow)-444(from)-443(our)-444(Lord's)-444(apparent)-443(recognition)-444(of)-444(the)-443(existence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-321(demoniacal)-322(possession)-321(on)-321(the)-321(supposition)-322(that)-321(it)-321(was)-321(simple)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mania.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-319(facts)-319(as)-319(they)-319(appear)-319(in)-319(the)-319(Gospels)-319(are)-319(unmistakable.)-457(It)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(was)-223(the)-223(distinct)-222(opinion)-223(of)-223(their)-222(authors)-223(that)-223(our)-223(Lord)-222(recognised)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-245(phenomena)-246(which)-245(they)-245(have)-245(reported)-245(as)-246(the)-245(results)-245(of)-245(demo-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(niacal)-228(possession)-229(and)-228(not)-228(of)-228(simple)-229(mania.)-242(In)-228(proof)-229(of)-228(this)-228(it)-228(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-303(needless)-302(to)-303(refer)-302(to)-303(every)-302(instance)-303(they)-303(have)-302(recorded.)-815(The)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([251])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(account)-279(of)-278(the)-279(demoniac)-278(at)-279(Gadara)-278(and)-278(that)-279(of)-278(the)-279(lunatic)-278(youth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-345(among)-344(the)-345(most)-344(remarkable,)-368(and)-345(on)-344(them)-345(the)-344(case)-345(may)-344(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(allowed)-252(to)-252(rest.)-257(In)-252(the)-252(former)-252(case)-253(the)-252(words)-252(of)-252(St.)-257(Mark,)-252(whose)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(description)-217(of)-218(the)-217(scene)-218(abounds)-217(in)-218(those)-217(details)-218(which)-217(are)-217(rarely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(seen)-338(except)-338(in)-337(narratives)-338(derived)-338(from)-338(direct)-338(ocular)-337(testimony,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.135 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(And)-253(all)-252(the)-253(demons)-252(besought)-253(him,)-253(saying,)-253(Send)-252(us)-253(into)-252(the)]TJ -23.979 -13.549 Td [(swine)-355(that)-354(we)-355(may)-355(enter)-354(into)-355(them.)-564(And)-354(forthwith)-355(Jesus)-354(gave)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-350(leave.)-550(And)-350(the)-350(unclean)-350(spirits)-350(went)-350(out)-350(and)-350(entered)-350(into)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-258(swine,)-260(&c.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 63.22 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.658 0 Td [(In)-258(the)-258(case)-258(of)-258(the)-258(demoniac)-258(child)-258(the)-258(Evangelist)]TJ -70.878 -13.549 Td [(describes)-286(the)-286(Apostles)-286(as)-285(asking)-286(Jesus,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 174.241 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Why)-286(could)-286(not)-286(we)-285(cast)]TJ -179.084 -13.549 Td [(him)-296(out?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 38.99 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.073 0 Td [(The)-296(following)-296(words)-296(are)-296(ascribed)-296(to)-296(our)-296(Lord:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 209.327 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(This)]TJ -261.234 -13.549 Td [(kind)-324(goeth)-323(not)-324(out)-324(but)-323(by)-324(prayer)-324(and)-323(fasting.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 200.655 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.375 0 Td [(It)-324(is)-323(undeniable,)]TJ -209.03 -13.549 Td [(therefore,)-302(that)-291(the)-292(Evangelists)-291(have)-291(ascribed)-292(to)-291(Jesus)-292(a)-291(belief)-291(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(reality)-250(of)-250(demoniacal)-250(possession.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(I)-358(am)-357(not)-358(concerned)-358(in)-358(the)-357(present)-358(argument)-358(with)-358(the)-357(words)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(and)-406(actions)-405(which)-406(they)-405(have)-406(attributed)-405(to)-406(the)-405(demoniacs;)-483(but)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-368(the)-369(words)-368(and)-369(actions)-368(attributed)-369(to)-368(Jesus.)-606(We)-368(know)-368(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(some)-297(madmen)-296(labour)-297(under)-296(the)-297(delusion,)-308(not)-297(only)-296(that)-297(they)-296(are)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1038 0 obj <<
/Length 4366      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(222)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(emperors)-374(and)-374(kings,)-405(but)-375(even)-374(in)-374(a)-374(few)-374(instances)-374(that)-374(they)-374(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God)-210(himself.)-237(This)-210(being)-211(so,)-218(it)-210(is)-211(quite)-210(possible)-210(that)-211(a)-210(maniac)-210(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(confuse)-233(his)-234(personality)-233(with)-234(one)-233(or)-233(more)-234(demons;)-239(and)-233(speak)-233(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(act)-271(consistently)-270(with)-271(the)-271(delusion.)-312(The)-270(maniacs)-271(may)-271(have)-270(given)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(utterance)-251(to)-250(exclamations)-251(resulting)-251(from)-250(mere)-251(delusions;)-251(but)-250(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Evangelists)-231(in)-231(recording)-231(these)-231(utterances)-231(gave)-231(simple)-231(statements)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-336(facts.)-510(It)-336(is)-337(quite)-336(possible,)-358(that)-337(the)-336(demoniac)-337(of)-336(Gadara)-336(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-395(imagined)-394(himself)-395(possessed)-395(by)-395(a)-394(legion)-395(of)-395(demons,)-430(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-351(spoken)-351(and)-351(acted)-351(accordingly,)-376(whilst)-351(he)-351(was)-351(at)-351(the)-351(same)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(time)-250(labouring)-250(under)-250(simple)-250(mania.)]TJ 11.956 -14.367 Td [(Now,)-190(on)-176(the)-175(assumption)-175(that)-176(possession)-175(was)-175(simple)-351(mania)-175(and)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([252])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(nothing)-341(more,)-364(the)-341(following)-342(suppositions)-341(are)-341(the)-341(only)-341(possible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ones.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(First,)-392(that)-363(our)-364(Lord)-363(really)-364(distinguished)-363(between)-364(mania)-363(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(possession;)-390(but)-344(that)-343(the)-343(Evangelists)-344(have)-343(inaccurately)-343(reported)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-236(words)-237(and)-236(actions,)-239(through)-237(the)-236(media)-236(of)-237(their)-236(own)-236(subjective)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impressions,)-372(or,)-371(in)-347(short,)-372(have)-347(attributed)-348(to)-347(Him)-347(language)-347(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(He)-250(did)-250(not)-250(really)-250(utter.)]TJ 11.956 -14.367 Td [(Second,)-425(that)-391(our)-390(Lord)-390(knew)-390(that)-390(possession)-391(was)-390(a)-390(form)-390(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(mania,)-342(and)-324(adopted)-324(the)-323(current)-324(notions)-324(of)-323(the)-324(time)-324(in)-323(speaking)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(it,)-250(and)-250(that)-250(the)-250(words)-250(were)-250(really)-250(uttered)-250(by)-250(Him.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(Third,)-294(that)-285(with)-285(similar)-285(knowledge,)-294(He)-285(adopted)-285(the)-285(language)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(question)-250(as)-250(part)-250(of)-250(the)-250(curative)-250(process.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(Fourth,)-388(that)-360(He)-360(accepted)-361(the)-360(validity)-360(of)-360(the)-361(distinction,)-387(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-250(it)-250(was)-250(a)-250(real)-250(one)-250(during)-250(those)-250(times.)]TJ 11.956 -14.367 Td [(These)-322(alternatives)-322(demand)-323(our)-322(careful)-322(consideration,)-340(not)-322(for)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-275(purpose)-276(of)-275(determining)-275(which)-275(is)-276(the)-275(correct)-275(one,)-282(but)-275(of)-275(esti-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mating)-258(the)-258(results)-258(which)-259(flow)-258(from)-258(either)-258(of)-258(them)-258(on)-258(the)-258(central)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-410(of)-411(the)-410(Gospels.)-731(The)-410(position)-410(which)-411(I)-410(take)-410(must)-410(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(clearly)-276(stated.)-327(It)-275(is)-276(this:)-301(If)-276(possession)-275(be)-276(mania,)-282(there)-276(is)-275(nothing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-445(the)-445(language)-445(which)-445(the)-445(Evangelists)-445(have)-445(attributed)-445(to)-445(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Lord)-248(which)-247(compromises)-247(the)-248(truthfulness)-247(of)-248(his)-247(character.)-249(If,)-248(on)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-245(other)-245(hand,)-246(we)-245(assume)-245(that)-245(possession)-245(was)-245(an)-245(objective)-245(fact,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(there)-189(is)-190(nothing)-189(in)-189(our)-190(existing)-189(scientific)-189(knowledge)-190(of)-189(the)-189(human)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1042 0 obj <<
/Length 4379      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(223)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(mind)-340(which)-340(proves)-340(that)-340(the)-340(possessions)-340(of)-340(the)-340(New)-340(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-250(impossible.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Let)-250(us)-250(consider)-250(the)-250(first)-250(alternative.)]TJ 0 -15.186 Td [(A)-433(careful)-434(examination)-433(of)-434(the)-433(phenomena)-434(presented)-433(by)-433(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(synoptic)-410(Gospels)-410(leads)-411(to)-410(the)-410(irresistible)-410(conclusion)-410(that)-410(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(largely)-240(consist)-239(of)-240(accounts)-240(which)-239(had)-240(been)-240(handed)-239(down)-240(by)-239(oral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tradition,)-296(for)-286(a)-287(considerable)-287(time)-286(prior)-287(to)-286(their)-287(being)-286(committed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-300(writing,)-313(and)-600(that)-300(these)-299(have)-300(been)-300(in)-300(various)-300(degrees)-300(supple-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([253])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(mented)-362(by)-361(information)-362(derived)-362(from)-362(other)-361(sources.)-585(Assuming)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-371(to)-371(have)-371(been)-371(the)-371(case)-371(it)-371(gives)-371(an)-371(adequate)-371(account)-371(of)-371(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(differences)-251(of)-251(form)-250(which)-251(they)-251(present,)-251(their)-251(variations)-251(in)-250(minor)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(circumstances,)-239(and)-237(that)-237(most)-237(remarkable)-236(of)-237(all)-237(their)-236(phenomena,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-334(samenesses)-335(of)-334(expression)-334(interwoven)-335(with)-334(considerable)-334(di-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(versities,)-304(which)-292(is)-293(presented)-293(alike)-293(by)-293(the)-293(parallel)-293(narratives)-292(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(discourses.)-460(The)-321(threefold)-320(and)-320(more)-320(frequently)-320(twofold)-320(form)-320(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-342(several)-343(of)-342(the)-343(discourses)-342(have)-343(been)-342(handed)-343(down)-342(to)-342(us,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prevent)-383(us)-383(from)-382(believing)-383(that)-383(these)-383(discourses)-383(were)-382(intended)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-365(be)-364(rigid)-365(reproductions)-365(of)-364(the)-365(verbal)-365(utterances)-364(of)-365(our)-364(Lord.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(All)-408(they)-408(can)-409(be)-408(is)-408(an)-408(accurate)-408(account)-409(of)-408(the)-408(sense)-408(and)-408(very)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(frequently)-291(of)-291(his)-291(words.)-373(The)-291(important)-291(question)-291(for)-291(our)-290(present)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consideration)-236(is,)-239(Have)-236(the)-236(Evangelists,)-239(in)-236(reporting)-236(the)-236(discours-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(es)-235(of)-235(Jesus,)-238(imparted)-236(to)-235(them)-235(a)-235(colouring)-235(derived)-235(from)-235(their)-235(own)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subjective)-390(impressions)-389(or)-390(do)-389(they)-389(accurately)-390(convey)-389(to)-390(us)-389(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(meaning)-399(and)-398(his)-399(meaning)-398(only?)-696(Or)-398(with)-399(respect)-398(to)-399(the)-398(point)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(before)-389(us,)-424(Have)-389(the)-389(Evangelists)-389(in)-389(reporting)-389(the)-389(utterances)-388(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-245(to)-245(the)-244(demoniacs)-245(and)-245(his)-245(observations)-244(on)-245(possession)-245(to)-244(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disciples)-215(given)-214(us)-215(the)-214(substance)-215(of)-214(what)-215(He)-215(actually)-214(said,)-222(or)-214(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(own)-250(impressions)-250(of)-250(what)-250(He)-250(might)-250(have)-250(said?)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-325(reply,)-343(the)-325(internal)-324(grounds)-325(for)-325(assuming)-324(their)-325(accuracy)-324(are)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(strong.)-686(This)-395(is)-396(vouched)-395(for)-395(by)-396(the)-395(fact)-395(that)-396(while)-395(we)-395(have)-395(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(three)-264(or)-265(twofold)-264(report)-265(of)-264(the)-264(same)-265(discourse,)-268(varying)-264(very)-264(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(siderably)-329(in)-329(words)-329(and)-329(arrangement,)-349(and)-329(while)-329(we)-328(have)-329(whole)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sentences)-265(in)-264(one)-265(Evangelist)-264(which)-265(materially)-264(aid)-265(in)-264(determining)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-367(meaning,)-396(either)-367(omitted)-366(in)-367(one)-367(or)-367(inserted)-367(in)-366(another,)-396(still)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1046 0 obj <<
/Length 4886      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(224)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(with)-389(all)-388(these)-389(variations)-389(in)-388(expression,)-424(the)-388(variations)-389(in)-388(sense)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-290(of)-290(the)-290(smallest)-290(possible)-289(importance.)-370(This)-290(being)-290(the)-290(case)-289(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whole)-376(aspect)-375(of)-752(the)-375(discourses)-376(leads)-375(us)-376(to)-376(infer)-375(that)-376(they)-375(are)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([254])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(altogether)-223(unaffected)-223(by)-223(the)-223(subjective)-223(impressions)-223(of)-223(those)-223(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(reported)-194(them.)-231(They)-194(are)-194(indelibly)-194(stamped)-194(with)-194(the)-194(mind)-194(of)-194(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(himself)-276(and)-276(with)-276(his)-276(alone.)-328(There)-276(are)-276(many)-276(points)-276(on)-276(which)-276(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(teaching)-390(ran)-389(strongly)-390(counter)-389(to)-390(the)-389(subjective)-390(impressions)-389(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-206(who)-206(reported)-206(it.)-235(Here)-206(then)-206(if)-206(such)-206(impressions)-206(had)-206(intruded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(themselves)-212(we)-211(should)-212(be)-212(certain)-211(to)-212(find)-212(indications)-211(of)-212(such)-211(intru-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sion,)-214(and)-206(that)-205(in)-206(no)-205(doubtful)-205(form.)-236(But)-205(there)-205(are)-206(none.)-235(The)-205(theory)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-248(of)-247(the)-248(introduction)-247(of)-248(the)-248(subjective)-247(impressions)-248(of)-247(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(followers)-345(of)-345(our)-345(Lord)-345(into)-345(the)-345(discourses)-345(has)-345(no)-345(foundation)-344(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-242(contents,)-243(and)-242(therefore)-242(it)-242(is)-242(wholly)-242(illegitimate)-242(to)-242(assume)-241(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-250(the)-250(solution)-250(of)-250(a)-250(difficulty.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(The)-242(phenomena)-242(which)-242(distinguish)-242(St.)-247(Mark's)-242(Gospel)-242(strongly)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(display)-320(the)-320(marks)-320(of)-320(autoptic)-320(testimony.)-460(This)-320(greatly)-319(increases)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-200(difficulty)-200(of)-200(the)-200(supposition)-200(in)-200(question,)-210(for)-200(these)-199(expressions)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-325(found)-326(in)-325(that)-326(Gospel,)-344(and)-325(in)-326(it)-325(we)-325(also)-326(find)-325(the)-325(remarkable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(saying,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 35.19 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(This)-342(kind)-342(goeth)-341(not)-342(out)-342(but)-342(by)-341(prayer)-342(and)-342(fasting.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 225.359 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.572 0 Td [(It)]TJ -273.965 -13.549 Td [(seems)-388(therefore)-387(impossible)-388(to)-388(doubt)-387(the)-388(Evangelist's)-387(assertion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-250(such)-250(words)-250(were)-250(uttered)-250(by)-250(our)-250(Lord.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(But)-367(I)-366(must)-367(now)-367(inquire)-366(whether)-367(Dr.)-600(Farrar's)-367(supposition)-366(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tenable,)-331(that)-315(some)-315(misapprehension)-314(has)-315(crept)-315(into)-315(the)-314(narrative)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-248(it)-248(affirms)-248(that)-248(the)-248(demons)-248(in)-248(objective)-248(reality)-248(left)-248(the)-247(body)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(man)-250(and)-250(entered)-250(into)-250(the)-250(swine.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(I)-196(answer)-197(that)-197(there)-196(is)-197(nothing)-196(in)-197(the)-196(Evangelists)-197(which)-196(requires)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(us)-217(to)-218(consider)-217(their)-218(words)-217(as)-218(an)-217(accurately)-218(scientific)-217(statement)-217(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-206(mode)-207(in)-206(which)-207(the)-206(demon)-207(acted)-206(on)-207(the)-206(mind)-207(of)-206(the)-206(possessed.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(It)-284(is)-284(true)-285(that)-284(they)-284(repeatedly)-284(say)-284(that)-285(they)-284(entered)-284(in)-284(and)-284(out)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-206(the)-205(man,)-215(but)-205(this)-206(may)-206(well)-205(be)-206(in)-206(conformity)-205(with)-206(popular)-205(ideas)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-381(the)-380(subject,)-413(without)-381(intending)-381(to)-380(assert)-381(as)-380(a)-381(scientific)-380(fact,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-334(the)-333(demons)-668(made)-334(either)-333(the)-334(body)-334(or)-334(the)-333(spirit)-334(of)-334(the)-333(man)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([255])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(their)-239(local)-240(habitation.)-246(The)-240(New)-239(Testament)-240(attempts)-239(to)-239(determine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nothing)-372(respecting)-371(the)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 103.664 0 Td [(modus)-371(operandi)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 75.981 0 Td [(of)-372(spirits.)-614(God)-371(is)-372(said)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1051 0 obj <<
/Length 5472      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(225)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(to)-401(dwell)-401(in)-401(a)-402(holy)-401(man,)-439(but)-401(it)-401(is)-401(ridiculous)-401(to)-401(affirm)-401(that)-401(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(omnipresent)-291(Spirit)-291(makes)-290(the)-291(man)-291(his)-291(local)-290(habitation.)-373(There)-290(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-364(case)-364(in)-363(point)-364(as)-364(to)-364(the)-364(use)-363(of)-364(such)-364(language)-364(in)-364(the)-363(narrative)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-292(the)-293(woman)-292(who)-292(was)-292(healed)-293(of)-292(the)-292(issue)-292(of)-292(blood.)-377(The)-292(effect)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(produced)-243(on)-243(her)-243(is)-243(described)-243(by)-243(our)-243(Lord)-243(and)-243(the)-243(Evangelists)-243(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-358(words)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 47.813 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Power)-358(\050)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 35.415 0 Td [(\264)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 5.225 0 Td [({)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.531 0 Td [(\275\261\274\271\302)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 24.797 0 Td [(\051)-358(has)-359(gone)-358(out)-359(of)-358(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 98.017 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.754 0 Td [(Yet)-358(no)-359(one)]TJ -230.396 -13.549 Td [(who)-202(considers)-203(the)-202(mode)-203(in)-202(which)-202(the)-203(Gospels)-202(are)-203(composed,)-211(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-294(that)-293(our)-294(Lord)-293(by)-294(using)-293(these)-293(words)-294(intended)-293(to)-294(convey)-293(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(scientific)-250(truth)-251(as)-250(to)-251(his)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 104.566 0 Td [(modus)-250(operandi)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 73.341 0 Td [(in)-250(performing)-251(the)-250(mira-)]TJ -177.907 -13.55 Td [(cle,)-295(or)-286(that)-286(it)-285(was)-286(actually)-286(performed)-286(by)-286(some)-286(subtle)-285(emanation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(called)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 29.363 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Power,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30.6 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.155 0 Td [(which)-304(issued)-303(from)-304(his)-303(person.)-411(With)-304(those)-303(who)]TJ -72.962 -13.549 Td [(assume)-262(that)-261(neither)-262(our)-262(Lord)-261(nor)-262(his)-262(Apostles)-261(could)-262(use)-261(popular)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(expressions)-349(of)-349(this)-349(kind,)-374(but)-350(were)-349(bound)-349(to)-349(use)-349(terms)-349(of)-349(strict)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(scientific)-296(accuracy)-296(all)-297(reasoning)-296(is)-296(thrown)-296(away.)-389(If)-296(the)-296(strictest)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(verbal)-245(accuracy)-246(must)-245(be)-245(observed)-246(on)-245(every)-245(occasion)-246(it)-245(would)-245(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incorrect)-271(to)-271(say)-271(that)-271(a)-272(physician)-271(has)-271(cured)-271(a)-271(lunatic,)-276(for)-271(the)-271(idea)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-269(which)-270(the)-269(term)-269(lunacy)-269(is)-270(founded)-269(is)-269(scientifically)-269(inaccurate.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-195(follows)-195(therefore)-195(that)-196(the)-195(terms)-195(which)-195(are)-195(so)-195(constantly)-195(applied)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-210(demons)-210(in)-210(the)-211(New)-210(Testament,)-218(that)-210(they)-210(entered)-210(into,)-218(departed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(out)-402(of,)-441(or)-402(possessed)-402(a)-403(man)-402(may)-402(well)-403(be)-402(popular)-402(expressions,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(denoting)-330(that)-329(they)-330(exerted)-329(a)-330(mighty,)-349(nay,)-349(an)-330(overwhelming)-329(in-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fluence)-265(upon)-266(him,)-269(which)-265(in)-266(the)-265(shattered)-265(state)-265(of)-266(his)-265(physical)-265(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-232(condition)-231(he)-232(was)-232(unable)-231(to)-232(shake)-232(off,)-235(without)-231(determining)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(anything)-398(as)-398(to)-398(the)-397(mode)-398(in)-398(which)-398(that)-398(influence)-398(was)-397(exerted.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Thus,)-321(in)-307(St.)-420(John's)-307(Gospel,)-321(the)-307(devil)-307(is)-307(described)-307(as)-307(having)-306(put)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-411(\050)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 14.182 0 Td [(\262\265\262\273\267\272)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 32.596 0 Td [(y)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.433 0 Td [(\304\277\302)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.574 0 Td [(\051)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 8.114 0 Td [(into)-411(the)-411(heart)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 66.981 0 Td [(of)-411(Judas)-411(Iscariot)-411(to)-411(betray)-411(our)]TJ -141.88 -13.549 Td [(Lord.)-366(After)-289(the)-288(giving)-578(of)-288(the)-289(sop,)-298(Satan)-289(is)-289(said)-288(to)-289(have)-288(entered)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([256])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(into)-345(him.)-537(Surely)-345(the)-345(only)-346(fact)-345(which)-345(these)-346(words)-345(are)-345(intended)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-384(convey)-384(is)-383(that)-384(Judas)-384(allowed)-383(his)-384(whole)-384(moral)-384(and)-383(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-328(to)-328(be)-328(overpowered)-328(by)-327(the)-328(influence)-328(of)-328(the)-328(evil)-328(one.)-484(It)-327(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(quite)-346(possible)-346(that)-346(the)-346(Evangelists)-346(might)-346(have)-346(thought)-346(that)-345(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(influence)-354(was)-354(exerted)-354(by)-355(actually)-354(going)-354(in)-354(or)-354(coming)-354(out)-354(of)-354(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man.)-257(But)-252(this)-252(is)-252(a)-252(mere)-252(physical)-252(theory)-253(as)-252(to)-252(the)-252(mode)-252(of)-252(action,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-371(certainly)-371(is)-370(not)-371(a)-371(point)-371(on)-371(which)-370(the)-371(writings)-371(of)-371(the)-370(New)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1056 0 obj <<
/Length 4976      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(226)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Testament)-335(anywhere)-334(affirm)-335(that)-335(a)-334(supernatural)-335(knowledge)-334(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(imparted)-250(to)-250(their)-250(authors.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(It)-317(follows)-317(therefore)-317(that)-318(the)-317(expressions)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 180.12 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(going)-317(out)-317(from)-318(the)]TJ -196.919 -13.549 Td [(man,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 21.513 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.488 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 19.397 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(entering)-334(into)-334(the)-334(swine,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 105.165 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.488 0 Td [(may)-334(only)-334(denote)-334(the)-334(ces-)]TJ -167.894 -13.549 Td [(sation)-453(of)-453(the)-453(influence)-453(of)-453(the)-453(demons)-453(over)-453(the)-453(man,)-503(and)-453(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exertion)-341(on)-340(the)-341(swine,)-363(without)-340(determining)-341(the)-340(mode)-341(in)-340(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-271(influence)-271(was)-271(exerted.)-312(Surely)-271(when)-271(our)-271(Lord)-271(promised)-270(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(He)-292(would)-292(come)-292(to)-293(the)-292(man)-292(who)-292(loved)-292(him)-292(and)-292(make)-292(his)-292(abode)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-261(him,)-265(that)-261(did)-262(not)-261(imply)-262(a)-261(local)-262(indwelling)-261(of)-262(his)-261(person)-261(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-250(indwelling)-250(of)-250(influence.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(With)-293(such)-292(expressions)-293(in)-293(abundance)-292(before)-293(us,)-303(in)-293(which)-293(it)-292(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(obvious)-288(that)-287(they)-288(were)-288(never)-288(intended)-287(to)-288(denote)-288(anything)-287(local,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-293(is)-293(absurd)-294(to)-293(fix)-293(it)-293(on)-293(the)-294(sacred)-293(writers)-293(in)-293(this)-293(particular)-293(case.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(They)-248(nowhere)-248(assert)-249(that)-248(the)-248(demons)-248(were)-249(seen)-248(to)-248(pass)-248(from)-248(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-370(and)-371(enter)-370(the)-370(swine.)-611(It)-370(was)-370(simply)-371(a)-370(matter)-370(of)-370(inference)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(from)-289(the)-289(facts)-289(which)-289(they)-289(witnessed)-289(that)-289(they)-289(had)-289(done)-289(so.)-366(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-332(ceased)-332(to)-332(rave)-332(and)-332(became)-332(a)-332(rational)-332(creature.)-495(The)-332(swine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rushed)-218(down)-219(into)-218(the)-219(lake)-218(and)-218(perished.)-240(They)-218(also)-219(affirm)-218(that)-218(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(result)-276(took)-276(place)-276(by)-276(the)-276(permission)-276(of)-276(Jesus.)-328(Yet)-276(it)-276(is)-275(somewhat)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remarkable)-192(that)-193(it)-192(is)-192(only)-193(Matthew)-192(who)-192(attributes)-193(to)-192(him)-192(the)-192(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.55 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Go.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 16.058 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.245 0 Td [(Mark)-312(and)-311(Luke)-312(only)-312(mention)-312(the)-311(request)-312(of)-312(the)-312(demons,)]TJ -29.147 -13.549 Td [(and)-204(the)-205(result)-204(which)-204(followed.)-235(There)-204(is)-205(nothing)-204(therefore)-204(deroga-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tory)-203(to)-202(the)-203(character)-405(of)-202(the)-202(Evangelists)-203(as)-202(historians)-203(in)-202(supposing)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([257])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(that)-433(the)-433(facts)-433(received)-433(a)-433(colouring)-433(from)-433(their)-433(own)-432(subjective)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impressions,)-303(though)-293(it)-292(would)-293(be)-292(so)-293(if)-292(under)-293(such)-292(circumstances)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-211(had)-210(allowed)-211(those)-210(impressions)-210(to)-211(assign)-210(a)-211(different)-210(meaning)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(our)-250(Lord's)-250(words)-250(from)-250(that)-250(which)-250(he)-250(actually)-250(conveyed.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(This)-425(conclusion)-425(at)-425(which)-425(we)-425(have)-425(arrived,)-469(that)-425(our)-425(Lord's)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(meaning)-355(is)-355(accurately)-355(reported)-356(by)-355(the)-355(Evangelists,)-381(disposes)-355(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-215(first)-215(alternative.)-239(We)-215(will)-215(now)-215(proceed)-215(to)-215(examine)-215(the)-215(second,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(viz.,)-269(that)-265(our)-265(Lord)-265(knew)-265(that)-265(possession)-265(was)-265(mania,)-268(and)-265(that)-265(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adopted)-233(the)-234(current)-233(notions)-233(of)-233(the)-234(times)-233(in)-233(speaking)-233(of)-234(it.)-244(The)-233(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(important)-250(question)-250(is,)-250(how)-250(far)-250(does)-250(this)-250(affect)-250(his)-250(veracity?)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(On)-249(this)-249(point)-249(Archbishop)-249(Trench)-249(has)-249(laid)-249(down)-249(the)-249(following)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1060 0 obj <<
/Length 4872      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(227)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(position)-271(broadly:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 77.652 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(If)-271(Jesus)-270(knew)-271(that)-271(the)-270(Jewish)-271(belief)-271(in)-270(demo-)]TJ -82.495 -13.549 Td [(niacal)-359(possession)-358(was)-359(baseless)-359(and)-359(that)-358(Satan)-359(did)-359(not)-358(exercise)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-311(power)-310(over)-311(the)-311(bodies)-311(or)-310(spirits)-311(of)-311(men)-310(there)-311(would)-311(be)-310(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-300(language)-299(that)-300(absence)-300(of)-299(agreement)-300(between)-300(thoughts)-299(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(words)-250(in)-250(which)-250(the)-250(essence)-250(of)-250(a)-250(lie)-250(consists.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 192.393 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -180.437 -18.458 Td [(If)-474(this)-474(position)-475(is)-474(correct)-474(it)-474(involves)-475(a)-474(principle)-474(far)-474(more)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(extensive)-432(than)-433(the)-432(case)-432(immediately)-433(before)-432(us.)-797(It)-432(is)-432(nothing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(less)-306(than)-306(that)-306(our)-306(Lord)-306(neither)-306(in)-306(his)-306(formal)-306(teaching)-306(nor)-306(in)-305(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conversation)-355(should)-355(have)-355(used)-355(language)-355(which)-355(was)-355(other)-355(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(scientifically)-278(correct.)-333(It)-278(might)-278(be)-278(argued,)-284(that)-278(if)-278(He)-278(had)-278(done)-277(so)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-316(would)-316(have)-316(lent)-317(his)-316(sanction)-316(to)-316(the)-316(error)-316(which)-316(it)-316(involved.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Even)-177(if)-177(the)-178(principle)-177(thus)-177(laid)-177(down)-178(could)-177(be)-177(confined)-177(to)-177(religious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth)-329(\050which)-330(it)-329(cannot\051,)-349(it)-329(would)-329(then)-330(have)-329(been)-329(necessary)-329(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whenever)-225(the)-225(current)-225(ideas,)-231(or)-225(the)-225(mode)-225(of)-225(conception)-225(of)-225(the)-225(day)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contained)-237(an)-237(assumption)-237(involving)-237(an)-237(incorrect)-237(theory)-237(or)-236(endan-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gering)-211(a)-210(religious)-211(error,)-218(our)-211(Lord)-211(ought)-210(to)-211(have)-211(corrected)-210(it)-211(in)-210(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(course)-290(of)-290(his)-290(teaching.)-369(If)-290(we)-290(admit)-580(that)-290(demoniacal)-289(possession)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([258])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(was)-385(a)-385(real)-385(agency)-385(there)-385(can)-385(be)-385(no)-385(doubt)-385(that)-385(the)-385(Jews)-384(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(confound)-237(many)-237(cases)-237(of)-236(ordinary)-237(mania)-237(with)-237(it.)-245(This)-237(being)-237(so,)-239(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-320(principle)-319(is)-320(correct,)-337(our)-320(Lord)-319(ought)-320(to)-320(have)-319(pointed)-320(out)-319(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinction.)-303(Again,)-272(even)-268(if)-268(it)-268(is)-267(assumed)-268(that)-268(demoniacal)-267(agency)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-219(sometimes)-219(manifested)-219(in)-219(the)-219(phenomena)-218(of)-219(witchcraft,)-225(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-355(be)-354(no)-355(doubt)-354(that)-355(much)-354(of)-355(it)-354(was)-355(due)-354(to)-355(human)-354(imposture.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(On)-253(the)-253(principle)-253(laid)-253(down)-253(by)-253(the)-253(Archbishop)-253(our)-253(Lord)-253(ought)-252(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-236(corrected)-236(every)-237(error)-236(that)-236(was)-236(prevalent)-237(on)-236(that)-236(subject.)-245(On)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-213(same)-212(principle)-213(it)-212(would)-213(have)-213(been)-212(impossible)-213(for)-212(him)-213(to)-212(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(used)-263(an)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 36.04 0 Td [(ad)-263(hominem)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 56.647 0 Td [(argument)-263(or)-264(in)-263(fact)-263(any)-264(form)-263(of)-263(expression)]TJ -92.687 -13.55 Td [(founded)-281(on)-281(an)-281(erroneous)-281(conception.)-343(It)-281(is)-281(therefore)-281(evident)-281(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-268(principle,)-272(if)-268(accepted)-268(at)-267(all,)-273(can)-267(only)-268(be)-268(accepted)-268(under)-267(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(considerable)-355(qualifications,)-382(or)-355(we)-355(shall)-356(convert)-355(our)-355(Lord)-355(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-312(revealer)-312(of)-312(truth)-311(and)-312(teacher)-312(of)-312(Christianity)-312(into)-312(one)-311(whose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(duty)-340(it)-340(was)-341(to)-340(combat)-340(every)-340(erroneous)-340(opinion)-341(of)-340(the)-340(day.)-520(On)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(such)-312(a)-313(theory)-312(it)-312(is)-313(difficult)-312(to)-312(see)-313(how)-312(our)-312(Lord)-313(was)-312(not)-312(bound)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-383(correct)-383(every)-383(erroneous)-383(opinion)-383(then)-383(current)-383(respecting)-383(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1064 0 obj <<
/Length 4697      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(228)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(first)-305(and)-305(second)-305(chapters)-305(of)-304(Genesis,)-319(and)-305(to)-305(point)-305(out)-305(their)-304(true)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(relation)-299(to)-299(the)-298(modern)-299(discoveries)-299(of)-299(geology,)-311(for)-299(He)-298(expressly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(referred)-318(to)-318(the)-318(second)-318(chapter)-318(in)-318(his)-318(teaching.)-454(He)-318(also)-318(referred)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-402(the)-403(flood,)-440(respecting)-402(which)-403(many)-402(erroneous)-402(opinions)-402(were)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(undoubtedly)-327(current.)-480(If)-327(the)-327(principle)-327(is)-326(good)-327(it)-327(might)-327(be)-326(urged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-250(He)-250(sanctioned)-250(those)-250(errors)-250(by)-250(his)-250(silence.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-336(same)-335(principle)-336(must)-336(also)-336(have)-335(been)-336(applicable)-336(to)-335(many)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(other)-303(erroneous)-302(opinions)-303(which)-303(the)-302(Jews)-303(entertained)-302(respecting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-443(interpretation)-442(of)-443(the)-443(Old)-442(Testament.)-828(In)-443(fact)-442(it)-443(would)-442(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difficult)-421(to)-422(assign)-421(any)-421(limits)-421(to)-421(our)-422(Lord's)-421(duty)-421(of)-421(correcting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(popular)-250(errors)-250(which)-250(had)-250(any)-250(kind)-250(of)-250(bearing)-250(on)-250(religious)-250(truth.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-225(to)-225(return)-225(to)-225(the)-225(demoniacs.)-242(Is)-225(there)-225(any)-225(thing)-449(inconsistent)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([259])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(with)-184(our)-184(Lord's)-184(truthfulness,)-197(if)-184(we)-184(suppose)-184(that)-184(they)-184(were)-184(lunatics)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-330(nothing)-329(more,)-349(in)-330(his)-329(using)-330(the)-329(current)-330(language)-329(of)-330(the)-329(day)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(respecting)-294(them?)-380(Let)-294(it)-294(be)-293(observed)-294(that)-293(two)-294(considerations)-293(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(really)-319(involved;)-354(first,)-336(our)-319(Lord)-319(is)-319(represented)-319(as)-319(conversing)-319(di-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rectly)-235(with)-236(the)-235(demoniac.)-245(Secondly,)-238(He)-236(also)-235(occasionally)-235(speaks)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-272(demoniacal)-273(possession)-272(in)-272(his)-272(ordinary)-273(teaching)-272(in)-272(the)-272(current)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(language)-272(of)-272(the)-273(day.)-316(Now)-272(if)-272(it)-273(be)-272(admitted)-272(to)-272(be)-272(consistent)-272(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(his)-421(truthfulness)-421(to)-422(address)-421(such)-421(language)-421(to)-421(the)-421(maniac,)-464(is)-421(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(equally)-250(so)-250(to)-250(employ)-250(such)-250(language)-250(in)-250(his)-250(discourses)-250(to)-250(others?)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-310(observe)-310(first,)-326(that)-310(if)-310(possession)-310(was)-311(mania,)-325(the)-310(real)-310(ground)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-375(the)-374(popular)-375(error)-374(was)-374(an)-375(erroneous)-374(opinion)-375(as)-374(to)-375(the)-374(cause)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-370(a)-371(natural)-370(disorder.)-611(The)-370(popular)-370(belief)-370(in)-371(fact)-370(ascribed)-370(it)-370(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-315(instead)-315(of)-315(natural)-315(causes.)-446(So)-315(far,)-331(but)-315(no)-315(farther,)-331(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(touched)-370(religious)-370(questions.)-610(To)-370(correct)-370(the)-370(error)-370(involved)-370(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(merely)-280(the)-281(teaching)-280(of)-281(religious)-280(truth,)-288(but)-280(in)-281(this)-280(particular)-280(case)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-381(enunciation)-381(of)-381(sounder)-381(principles)-381(of)-381(mental)-381(philosophy.)-643(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(think)-317(that)-318(I)-317(may)-317(fearlessly)-318(affirm)-317(that)-317(the)-318(teaching)-317(of)-317(scientific)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth,)-240(either)-237(mental)-238(or)-237(material,)-240(did)-237(not)-238(come)-237(within)-238(the)-237(scope)-237(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-256(Lord's)-255(divine)-256(mission.)-266(Political)-256(truth)-256(is)-255(a)-256(part)-255(of)-256(moral)-255(truth,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-247(moral)-248(truth)-247(is)-248(closely)-247(allied)-247(to)-248(religious)-247(truth.)-249(Now)-247(although)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Christianity)-235(is)-235(a)-235(power)-235(which)-235(will)-235(ultimately)-235(reform)-235(the)-234(political)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(world,)-442(our)-404(Lord)-403(expressly)-404(affirmed)-404(that)-403(it)-404(was)-404(no)-403(part)-404(of)-403(his)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1068 0 obj <<
/Length 4495      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(229)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(mission)-250(to)-250(enunciate)-250(political)-250(truth.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(In)-315(the)-315(same)-315(manner)-316(it)-315(may)-315(have)-315(formed)-315(no)-315(direct)-315(portion)-315(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(his)-220(mission)-220(to)-220(teach)-220(correct)-220(views)-220(respecting)-220(the)-220(origin)-220(of)-220(mania,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-359(to)-358(counteract)-359(the)-359(opinions)-359(which)-358(ascribed)-359(it)-359(to)-358(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(causes.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(If)-330(this)-330(principle)-330(is)-331(correct,)-350(there)-330(is)-330(nothing)-330(inconsistent)-330(with)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(his)-420(truthfulness)-421(if)-420(when)-421(our)-420(Lord)-420(conversed)-421(with)-420(a)-420(supposed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demoniac,)-221(He)-214(addressed)-214(him)-214(in)-214(language)-428(which)-214(took)-214(for)-213(granted)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([260])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(truth)-250(of)-251(his)-250(delusions.)-250(Even)-251(if)-250(it)-250(is)-250(supposed)-250(that)-250(truthfulness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(required)-257(that)-257(He)-256(should)-257(have)-257(exposed)-257(a)-256(popular)-257(delusion,)-258(surely)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-443(was)-443(no)-444(occasion)-443(for)-443(doing)-443(so,)-492(when)-443(He)-443(was)-443(addressing)-443(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(madman.)-247(Who)-242(would)-241(affirm)-242(that)-242(a)-241(physician)-242(is)-241(wanting)-242(in)-241(truth-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fulness)-261(if)-260(he)-261(addresses)-260(his)-261(patient)-260(in)-260(terms)-261(of)-260(his)-261(own)-260(delusions,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-342(imagines)-342(that)-342(it)-342(is)-342(his)-342(duty)-342(to)-342(enter)-342(into)-342(a)-342(discussion)-342(with)-342(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(madman)-250(as)-250(to)-250(the)-250(causes)-250(of)-250(his)-250(malady?)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(On)-234(these)-234(principles)-234(it)-233(is)-234(quite)-234(consistent)-234(with)-234(our)-234(Lord's)-234(truth-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(fulness)-212(to)-212(suppose)-211(that)-212(the)-212(dialogue)-211(with)-212(the)-212(demoniac)-212(of)-211(Gadara)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(actually)-362(occurred,)-390(while)-362(He)-362(himself)-362(knew)-362(that)-362(possession)-361(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nothing)-366(but)-365(mania.)-598(Let)-365(us)-366(suppose)-366(that)-366(the)-365(man)-366(was)-366(a)-365(raving)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(madman.)-348(He)-283(had)-283(been)-282(treated)-283(cruelly.)-348(He)-283(rushed)-283(towards)-282(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-355(was)-355(awed)-355(by)-355(the)-355(greatness)-355(of)-355(his)-355(character.)-565(The)-354(dialogue)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(takes)-256(place,)-257(as)-256(it)-256(is)-256(described)-256(by)-256(the)-256(Evangelist.)-268(I)-256(see)-256(no)-256(want)-255(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truthfulness)-263(on)-263(our)-263(Lord's)-263(part,)-266(nor)-263(can)-263(I)-263(conceive)-263(any)-263(necessity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-338(explaining)-339(to)-338(the)-339(man)-338(that)-338(he)-339(was)-338(not)-338(possessed)-339(by)-338(a)-338(mul-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(titude)-340(of)-341(demons;)-386(or)-340(if)-340(the)-341(madman)-340(requested)-341(that)-340(the)-340(demons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-377(whom)-377(he)-377(imagined)-377(himself)-377(possessed)-377(might)-377(be)-377(allowed)-376(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(go)-379(into)-380(the)-379(swine,)-412(that)-380(our)-379(Lord)-379(should)-380(explain)-379(to)-380(him)-379(that)-379(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-359(impossible)-359(that)-359(they)-359(should)-359(do)-359(so)-359(because)-359(the)-359(idea)-359(of)-359(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demoniac)-341(was)-341(a)-341(delusion.)-523(The)-341(case)-341(would)-341(be)-341(one)-341(of)-340(confused)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(or)-219(double)-219(personality,)-225(and)-219(accordingly)-219(the)-219(narrator)-219(has)-219(described)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-235(demons)-235(and)-236(the)-235(man)-235(as)-235(alternately)-236(speaking,)-238(and)-235(our)-235(Lord)-235(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(addressing)-276(them.)-329(In)-276(such)-277(a)-276(case)-276(the)-276(form)-277(of)-276(the)-276(narrative)-276(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-250(modified)-250(by)-250(the)-250(subjective)-250(impressions)-250(of)-250(the)-250(narrator.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(But)-341(the)-341(words)-341(which)-341(our)-341(Lord)-341(is)-341(described)-341(as)-341(addressing)-340(to)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1072 0 obj <<
/Length 5425      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(230)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(the)-278(demoniac)-279(lad)-278(also)-279(require)-278(consideration.)-335(St.)-335(Mark)-278(describes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-289(as)-289(follows.)-366(Jesus)-289(rebuked)-289(the)-289(foul)-288(spirit,)-299(saying)-289(unto)-288(him,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Thou)-387(deaf)-773(and)-386(dumb)-387(spirit,)-421(I)-386(charge)-387(thee)-387(come)-386(out)-387(of)-386(him,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -77.599 0 Td [([261])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(and)-353(enter)-353(no)-352(more)-353(into)-353(him;)-404(and)-353(the)-353(spirit)-352(cried,)-379(and)-353(rent)-352(him)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sore)-295(and)-294(came)-295(out)-294(of)-295(him.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 115.742 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.057 0 Td [(Let)-295(us)-294(suppose)-295(that)-294(the)-295(disease)-294(was)]TJ -123.799 -13.549 Td [(mania,)-379(and)-353(that)-354(our)-353(Lord)-353(knew)-354(it)-353(to)-353(be)-353(so,)-380(but)-353(that)-353(the)-353(father,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-289(well)-288(as)-289(the)-289(maniac)-288(and)-289(the)-289(others)-288(who)-289(were)-289(present)-288(believed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-262(it)-261(was)-262(caused)-261(by)-262(the)-261(action)-262(of)-262(an)-261(evil)-262(spirit.)-284(What)-262(was)-261(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inconsistent)-328(with)-327(veracity)-328(in)-328(addressing)-328(the)-327(maniac)-328(in)-328(terms)-327(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(his)-236(own)-235(delusions?)-246(If)-235(it)-236(is)-236(urged)-235(that)-236(the)-235(belief)-236(in)-236(possession)-235(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-324(superstition,)-342(and)-324(that)-323(to)-324(use)-324(such)-323(language)-324(tended)-324(to)-323(confirm)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-251(belief,)-250(I)-251(reply)-250(that)-251(if)-250(we)-251(assume)-250(that)-251(our)-250(Lord)-250(was)-251(bound)-250(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-373(use)-373(the)-373(language)-372(which)-373(was)-373(common)-373(among)-373(his)-373(hearers)-372(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(speaking)-256(of)-255(such)-256(diseases,)-257(or)-255(that)-256(He)-255(ought)-256(to)-255(have)-256(given)-255(expla-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nations)-251(of)-251(their)-250(true)-251(causes,)-251(then)-251(we)-250(assume)-251(that)-251(his)-251(character)-250(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-245(revealer)-246(of)-245(Christianity)-245(rendered)-246(it)-245(necessary)-245(that)-246(in)-245(the)-245(course)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-283(his)-284(public)-283(ministry)-284(He)-283(should)-283(correct)-284(all)-283(the)-284(errors)-283(which)-283(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(encountered,)-441(and)-402(never)-403(use)-402(language)-403(which)-402(had)-403(originated)-402(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(The)-313(words)-314(which)-313(are)-313(ascribed)-314(to)-313(our)-313(Lord)-314(by)-313(the)-313(Evangelist)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(when)-291(He)-290(stilled)-291(the)-291(tempest)-291(will)-290(throw)-291(light)-291(on)-291(this)-290(subject.)-372(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Mark)-372(gives)-372(them)-371(as)-372(follows:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 134.93 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(He)-372(rebuked)-372(the)-371(winds)-372(and)-372(said)]TJ -139.774 -13.55 Td [(to)-288(the)-289(sea,)-298(Peace,)-298(be)-288(still.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 111.986 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.99 0 Td [(The)-288(word)-289(here)-288(rendered)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 108.903 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Be)-288(still)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 31.641 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.99 0 Td [(is)]TJ -273.354 -13.549 Td [(in)-302(the)-302(Greek)-302(far)-302(more)-302(emphatic,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 145.628 0 Td [(Be)-302(gagged)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 50.215 0 Td [(\050)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.633 0 Td [(\300\265\306)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 17.28 0 Td [(w)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\274\311\303\277)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 24.164 0 Td [(\051.)-406(In)-302(the)]TJ -244.127 -13.549 Td [(case)-218(of)-218(the)-218(demoniac)-218(our)-218(Lord)-218(is)-218(represented)-218(as)-218(rebuking)-218(the)-217(evil)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(spirit.)-546(Here)-348(He)-349(rebukes)-348(the)-348(waves.)-546(Now)-348(it)-349(is)-348(only)-349(possible)-348(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rebuke)-337(rational)-337(agents.)-511(Such)-337(an)-337(expression)-337(would)-337(therefore)-336(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(only)-223(accurate)-223(if)-223(addressed)-224(to)-223(a)-223(being)-223(who)-223(was)-223(capable)-223(of)-223(hearing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it,)-468(and)-425(who)-424(was)-424(uttering)-425(load)-424(cries.)-774(It)-424(may)-425(be)-424(objected)-424(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-303(expression)-303(favours)-304(the)-303(notion)-303(that)-303(the)-303(speaker)-303(supposed)-303(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(roaring)-216(of)-217(the)-216(waves)-216(to)-217(be)-216(the)-216(voice)-217(of)-216(an)-216(evil)-217(spirit,)-223(who)-216(was)-216(ex-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(citing)-269(the)-269(tempest,)-273(or,)-273(in)-269(other)-269(words,)-273(that)-269(He)-269(gave)-268(countenance)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-318(the)-319(heathen)-636(belief,)-335(that)-319(it)-318(was)-318(the)-318(voice)-319(of)-318(\306olus,)-335(the)-318(spirit)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([262])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(of)-251(the)-250(storm.)-251(Whatever)-251(amount)-250(of)-251(superstition)-250(may)-251(be)-250(attributed)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1077 0 obj <<
/Length 4755      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(231)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(to)-322(the)-322(Jews)-321(at)-322(the)-322(time)-321(of)-322(the)-322(Advent,)-340(it)-321(will)-322(scarcely)-322(be)-321(urged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-218(the)-218(followers)-218(of)-219(Jesus)-218(attributed)-218(the)-218(roaring)-218(of)-218(the)-218(gale)-218(to)-218(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(voice)-292(of)-292(a)-292(demon.)-376(Still)-292(it)-292(may)-292(be)-292(urged)-292(on)-292(the)-292(principles)-292(above)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(referred)-268(to)-269(that)-268(the)-269(words)-268(uttered)-268(by)-269(our)-268(Lord)-269(tended)-268(to)-268(confirm)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(superstitions)-297(notions)-298(as)-297(to)-297(the)-298(nature)-297(and)-297(origin)-298(of)-297(storms.)-392(I)-297(ar-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gue,)-238(on)-234(the)-235(other)-234(hand,)-238(that)-234(these)-235(expressions)-234(prove)-234(indisputably)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-297(the)-297(language)-296(used)-297(by)-297(Him)-297(was)-297(not)-296(always)-297(intended)-297(to)-297(be)-296(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(literal)-353(description)-353(of)-352(fact,)-379(any)-352(more)-353(than)-353(the)-353(numerous)-352(similar)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(addresses)-242(to)-243(the)-242(inanimate)-242(creation)-242(which)-242(we)-243(find)-242(in)-242(the)-242(Psalms.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-363(in)-363(the)-363(case)-363(of)-364(the)-363(demoniac,)-391(the)-363(real)-363(difficulty)-363(consists)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-316(the)-317(results)-316(which)-316(are)-317(alleged)-316(to)-316(have)-317(happened)-316(to)-316(the)-316(swine.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(I)-325(have)-324(already)-325(obviated)-325(some)-325(portion)-324(of)-325(this)-325(as)-324(far)-325(as)-325(the)-324(form)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-272(the)-272(narrative)-272(is)-272(concerned.)-316(But)-272(there)-272(remains)-272(the)-272(fact)-272(that)-272(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(swine)-257(are)-256(stated)-256(to)-257(have)-256(rushed)-257(into)-256(the)-257(lake)-256(and)-257(perished.)-269(As)-256(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-221(reality)-220(of)-221(such)-221(an)-220(occurrence)-221(there)-221(can)-220(have)-221(been)-221(no)-220(mistake.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-340(mere)-341(mode)-340(of)-340(expression)-340(offers)-341(no)-340(explanation,)-363(nor)-340(can)-340(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mistake)-397(respecting)-397(such)-397(an)-397(occurrence)-397(have)-397(originated)-397(in)-396(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possible)-252(deception)-252(of)-252(the)-252(imagination.)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 169.241 0 Td [(If)-252(it)-252(was)-252(not)-252(a)-252(fact)-253(it)-252(must)]TJ -169.241 -13.549 Td [(have)-368(been)-369(a)-368(fictitious)-369(invention.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 150.853 0 Td [(Can)-368(any)-369(explanation)-368(of)-369(it)-368(be)]TJ -150.853 -13.549 Td [(given?)-502(It)-334(has)-334(been)-334(suggested)-334(that)-334(the)-334(swine)-334(were)-334(driven)-333(down)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-350(cliff)-350(by)-350(the)-350(madman.)-550(Against)-350(this)-350(supposition,)-375(it)-350(has)-350(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(urged)-373(that)-373(no)-374(animals)-373(are)-373(less)-373(easily)-373(driven)-374(than)-373(swine.)-619(How)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(then)-309(could)-308(it)-309(have)-308(been)-309(possible)-308(to)-308(drive)-309(two)-308(thousand)-309(of)-308(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-216(the)-217(water?)-238(But)-217(there)-216(is)-216(no)-216(necessity)-216(to)-217(assume)-216(that)-216(they)-216(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(driven)-260(at)-261(all.)-281(The)-260(scene)-261(as)-260(it)-261(is)-260(described)-260(by)-261(the)-260(Evangelists)-260(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(well)-276(calculated)-276(to)-275(inspire)-276(animals)-276(with)-276(fright.)-327(It)-276(would)-275(however)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-217(been)-218(impossible)-217(to)-217(frighten)-217(two)-218(thousand)-217(of)-217(them.)-239(Granted:)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(but)-253(large)-505(herds)-253(of)-253(animals)-253(follow)-253(their)-252(leaders)-253(implicitly.)-258(When)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([263])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(under)-319(excitement)-318(one)-319(makes)-318(a)-319(leap,)-335(the)-319(others)-318(will)-319(follow.)-455(All)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-427(would)-427(have)-427(been)-427(necessary,)-471(if)-427(we)-427(suppose)-427(that)-427(the)-426(herd)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-307(near)-308(the)-307(edge)-308(of)-307(the)-308(cliff,)-321(was)-308(that)-307(the)-308(leaders)-307(should)-307(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(received)-329(the)-329(requisite)-328(impulse)-329(from)-329(the)-329(madman,)-348(and)-329(under)-328(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(influence)-389(rushed)-389(wildly)-389(down)-388(the)-389(cliff,)-424(and)-389(been)-389(followed)-388(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-250(companions.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1082 0 obj <<
/Length 4953      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(232)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(But)-282(the)-281(case)-282(is)-281(different)-282(when)-282(our)-281(Lord)-282(speaks)-281(to)-282(others,)-289(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(not)-306(to)-306(the)-306(demoniacs)-306(themselves.)-418(His)-306(observations)-306(to)-306(the)-305(Phar-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(isees)-342(on)-341(this)-342(subject)-342(I)-341(have)-342(already)-342(considered.)-525(There)-341(remains)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-276(striking)-275(one)-276(addressed)-275(to)-276(the)-276(disciples:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 189.793 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(This)-276(kind)-275(goeth)-276(not)]TJ -194.637 -13.55 Td [(out)-376(but)-376(by)-376(prayer)-375(and)-376(fasting.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 135.33 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.944 0 Td [(The)-376(circumstances)-376(of)-375(the)-376(case)]TJ -144.274 -13.549 Td [(are)-369(these.)-605(The)-369(disciples)-368(had)-369(failed)-369(to)-368(cure)-369(the)-368(youth,)-398(whether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-320(demoniac)-320(or)-320(a)-320(simple)-319(lunatic.)-460(They)-320(ask)-320(our)-320(Lord)-320(why)-320(it)-319(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-340(they)-340(had)-339(failed.)-520(He)-339(tells)-340(them)-340(that)-339(it)-340(was)-340(because)-340(of)-339(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unbelief.)-317(Now)-272(it)-272(is)-272(impossible)-272(for)-272(us)-273(to)-272(say)-272(what)-272(was)-272(the)-272(nature)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-297(the)-297(influence)-297(of)-297(faith)-296(in)-297(affecting)-297(miraculous)-297(cures,)-309(and)-296(why)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-240(want)-240(of)-240(it)-240(prevented)-239(success.)-247(It)-240(is)-240(sufficient)-240(to)-240(draw)-239(attention)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-290(the)-289(fact)-290(that)-290(it)-290(is)-289(uniformly)-290(laid)-290(down)-289(in)-290(the)-290(New)-289(Testament,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-433(in)-433(the)-433(case)-432(of)-433(subordinate)-433(agents)-433(working)-433(miracles)-432(faith)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-298(necessary)-298(for)-298(their)-298(accomplishment.)-394(Our)-298(Lord)-298(also)-297(usually)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(required)-290(faith)-291(in)-290(the)-290(recipients)-290(of)-291(his)-290(cures,)-300(but)-290(not)-291(always.)-370(But)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-317(his)-318(disciples)-317(when)-317(they)-317(attempted)-317(to)-318(perform)-317(a)-317(miracle)-317(faith)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-331(indispensable)-332(to)-331(their)-331(success.)-494(The)-332(question)-331(was)-331(not)-331(what)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-229(the)-230(nature)-229(of)-230(the)-229(disease,)-234(but)-229(why)-230(in)-229(this)-230(particular)-229(case)-229(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-332(failed)-332(to)-331(cure)-332(it.)-495(Our)-332(Lord)-332(replied)-331(that)-332(in)-332(this)-332(instance)-331(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(only)-345(was)-344(faith)-345(necessary)-344(to)-345(effect)-345(the)-344(cure,)-369(but)-344(a)-345(very)-344(unusual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(degree)-288(of)-287(it.)-363(If)-288(the)-287(question)-288(had)-288(been)-287(what)-288(was)-288(the)-287(cause)-288(of)-287(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(child's)-276(disease,)-283(and)-277(if)-276(our)-276(Lord)-277(know)-276(that)-276(it)-277(was)-276(not)-276(possession,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-741(mania,)-401(it)-370(is)-371(quite)-370(possible)-371(that)-370(He)-371(would)-370(have)-371(refused)-370(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([264])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(answer)-297(it,)-308(as)-297(He)-296(did)-297(on)-297(other)-296(occasions)-297(when)-297(curious)-296(questions)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(were)-378(put)-378(to)-378(him,)-410(and)-378(would)-378(have)-378(deduced)-378(some)-378(moral)-377(lesson)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-281(the)-280(fact.)-342(This)-280(it)-280(will)-281(be)-280(remembered)-281(was)-280(the)-281(course)-280(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-349(pursued)-350(when)-349(He)-349(was)-350(asked)-349(whether)-349(only)-350(a)-349(few)-349(would)-349(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(saved.)-741(But)-414(the)-414(inquiry)-413(was)-414(not)-414(what)-413(caused)-414(the)-414(disease,)-454(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(why)-304(the)-304(attempt)-304(to)-304(cure)-304(it)-304(had)-304(proved)-304(a)-304(failure.)-412(Such)-304(being)-304(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question,)-398(there)-368(is)-368(nothing)-368(inconsistent)-368(with)-368(truthfulness)-368(in)-368(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Lord's)-386(answer.)-657(He)-386(avoided)-386(entering)-385(into)-386(an)-386(explanation)-386(as)-385(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(what)-194(was)-194(a)-195(physical)-194(cause)-194(of)-194(the)-194(disease,)-206(which)-194(was)-194(quite)-194(foreign)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-336(his)-336(divine)-336(mission.)-507(He)-336(therefore)-336(simply)-336(told)-336(them)-336(that)-335(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(failure)-272(was)-272(owing)-272(to)-271(their)-272(unbelief,)-278(and)-271(then)-272(added,)-278(in)-271(language)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1086 0 obj <<
/Length 5009      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(233)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(couched)-389(in)-388(their)-389(own)-389(forms)-388(of)-389(thought,)-423(and)-389(which)-389(would)-388(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-206(open)-207(a)-206(discussion)-206(on)-206(subjects)-206(foreign)-207(to)-206(the)-206(purposes)-206(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-248(mission,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 54.817 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(This)-248(kind)-247(goeth)-248(not)-248(out)-248(but)-247(by)-248(prayer)-248(and)-248(fasting.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 216.126 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -263.831 -14.268 Td [(Those)-401(who)-401(lay)-400(stress)-401(on)-401(difficulties)-401(of)-400(this)-401(kind)-401(are)-401(in)-400(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(habit)-279(of)-279(overlooking)-279(the)-279(plain)-280(fact,)-286(that)-279(our)-279(Lord's)-279(teaching)-279(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(specifically)-281(addressed)-280(to)-281(the)-280(living)-281(characters)-281(of)-280(the)-281(day,)-288(and)-280(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-335(existing)-334(lines)-335(of)-335(thought,)-356(and)-334(cannot)-335(without)-335(reference)-334(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(them)-285(be)-284(directly)-285(translated)-284(into)-285(our)-284(own.)-354(This)-285(remark)-284(is)-285(no)-284(less)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(true)-240(of)-241(the)-240(moral)-240(teaching)-241(contained)-240(in)-240(the)-241(Gospels,)-242(than)-240(of)-240(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-320(statements.)-459(It)-319(is)-320(even)-320(more)-320(so,)-337(for)-319(a)-320(great)-320(number)-319(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-212(moral)-212(precepts)-212(of)-211(Christ)-212(cannot)-212(be)-212(applied)-212(as)-212(practical)-211(guides)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(until)-251(they)-250(have)-251(been)-250(adapted)-251(to)-250(the)-251(altered)-250(conditions)-251(of)-250(thought)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-283(of)-282(society.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 64.641 3.959 Td [(4)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.279 -3.959 Td [(They)-283(are)-282(in)-283(fact)-283(principles)-282(given)-283(in)-283(the)-282(form)-283(of)]TJ -72.92 -13.549 Td [(precepts.)-505(If)-335(our)-336(Lord's)-335(words)-335(had)-335(been)-335(reported)-335(so)-335(as)-335(to)-335(make)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-310(square)-310(with)-309(the)-310(lines)-310(of)-310(thought)-309(of)-310(every)-310(age,)-325(they)-309(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-244(given)-243(us,)-245(not)-487(his)-243(actual)-244(teaching)-244(but)-243(a)-244(modification)-243(of)-244(it.)-247(It)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([265])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(is)-274(our)-274(duty)-274(by)-274(a)-274(careful)-274(study)-274(of)-274(the)-274(great)-274(principles)-274(on)-274(which)-273(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-284(based)-283(to)-284(apply)-284(it)-284(to)-283(our)-284(present)-284(wants.)-351(It)-283(may)-284(appear)-284(to)-283(some)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(far)-349(more)-350(desirable)-349(that)-349(it)-350(should)-349(have)-349(been)-350(capable)-349(of)-349(a)-349(direct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instead)-280(of)-280(an)-280(indirect)-280(application,)-288(yet)-280(the)-280(fact)-280(is)-280(as)-280(I)-280(have)-280(stated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it.)-615(Want)-372(of)-371(attention)-372(to)-372(this)-371(has)-372(occasioned)-372(no)-371(inconsiderable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(number)-250(of)-250(the)-250(difficulties)-250(of)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament.)]TJ 11.956 -14.268 Td [(One)-214(or)-214(two)-214(remarks)-214(will)-214(be)-214(all)-214(that)-214(is)-214(necessary)-214(for)-214(illustrating)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-327(position)-327(which)-327(some)-327(have)-327(adopted)-327(that)-327(our)-327(Lord's)-327(mode)-326(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dealing)-451(with)-450(demoniacs)-451(was)-450(intended)-451(by)-450(Him)-451(as)-450(part)-451(of)-450(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(process)-426(of)-425(cure.)-777(I)-426(should)-426(not)-425(have)-426(alluded)-425(to)-426(this)-426(subject)-425(at)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(all)-324(unless)-324(the)-323(view)-324(in)-324(question)-324(had)-323(been)-324(propounded)-324(by)-324(a)-323(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eminent)-398(writer.)-694(I)-398(have)-398(already)-398(considered)-398(its)-398(main)-397(principles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-250(the)-250(previous)-250(head.)]TJ 11.956 -14.267 Td [(It)-298(ought)-299(to)-298(be)-298(observed)-299(that)-298(the)-298(care)-299(of)-298(demoniacs,)-310(whatever)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(view)-242(we)-243(may)-242(take)-242(of)-243(possession,)-244(belongs)-242(to)-242(a)-242(class)-243(of)-242(our)-242(Lord's)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-369(which)-368(are)-369(distinct)-369(from)-368(all)-369(others.)-606(All)-368(the)-369(others)-368(are)]TJ
0 g 0 G
ET
q
1 0 0 1 46.771 87.722 cm
[]0 d 0 J 0.398 w 0 0 m 112.25 0 l S
Q
BT
/F16 5.9776 Tf 52.998 80.91 Td [(4)]TJ/F16 8.9664 Tf 5.729 -3.809 Td [(See)-250(for)-249(example,)-250(Matt.)-250(v.)-250(39-42,)-250(Luke)-249(vi.)-250(20,)-250(21,)-250(24-26,)-249(and)-250(various)-250(others)]TJ -11.956 -10.959 Td [(of)-250(a)-250(similar)-250(description.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1090 0 obj <<
/Length 4685      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(234)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(described)-272(as)-273(wrought)-272(on)-273(the)-272(human)-272(body,)-278(or)-273(on)-272(external)-272(nature.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-278(Evangelists)-279(do)-278(not)-279(record)-278(a)-279(single)-278(miracle)-279(beside)-278(these)-278(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-308(wrought)-308(on)-308(the)-307(human)-308(mind.)-424(This)-307(is)-308(a)-308(remarkable)-308(fact.)-423(In)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-317(course)-318(of)-317(his)-318(ministry)-317(He)-318(encountered)-317(every)-318(form)-317(of)-317(moral)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-341(spiritual)-341(disease,)-363(from)-341(the)-340(weaknesses)-341(of)-341(his)-341(disciples)-340(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attached)-312(friends)-313(to)-312(the)-312(opposition)-312(of)-313(his)-312(most)-312(avowed)-312(enemies.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Now,)-288(although)-281(He)-281(emphatically)-281(asserted)-280(that)-281(He)-281(was)-281(the)-280(physi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cian)-206(of)-206(the)-205(soul,)-215(and)-206(although)-206(for)-205(the)-206(spiritual)-206(diseases)-206(of)-206(men)-205(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(felt)-213(the)-213(most)-213(profound)-213(sympathy,)-220(never)-213(once)-213(is)-213(Jesus)-212(represented)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-364(exerting)-364(his)-365(supernatural)-364(power)-364(for)-364(their)-364(care.)-593(On)-364(the)-364(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(trary,)-364(He)-341(is)-341(uniformly)-341(represented)-341(as)-341(having)-341(recourse)-340(to)-341(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-401(spiritual)-401(means)-401(and)-401(not)-400(to)-401(miracles)-401(to)-401(effect)-401(it.)-702(Physical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(diseases)-293(He)-292(cures)-293(instantaneously,)-303(moral)-293(ones)-585(slowly)-293(and)-292(with)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([266])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(effort.)-354(This)-285(fact)-284(is)-285(worthy)-285(of)-284(deep)-285(attention)-285(as)-284(showing)-285(that)-284(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Lord)-323(uniformly)-323(acted)-322(in)-323(conformity)-323(with)-322(the)-323(laws)-323(of)-323(the)-322(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(universe.)-320(If)-273(the)-273(Gospels)-273(are)-274(fictions,)-279(why)-273(is)-273(the)-273(Great)-273(Physician)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-217(Souls)-217(never)-217(represented)-217(as)-217(performing)-217(a)-217(sudden)-217(or)-216(miraculous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cure)-369(in)-369(the)-369(moral)-369(and)-369(spiritual)-369(worlds,)-399(in)-369(the)-369(same)-369(manner)-369(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-264(does)-265(in)-264(the)-265(material?)-293(The)-265(need)-264(of)-265(miraculous)-264(intervention)-264(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(secure)-346(Simon)-347(Peter)-346(from)-347(the)-346(moral)-346(and)-347(spiritual)-346(danger)-346(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(surrounded)-314(him)-313(was)-314(as)-313(great)-314(as)-314(to)-313(prevent)-314(him)-313(from)-314(sinking)-313(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-267(water.)-301(Yet)-266(no)-267(other)-267(than)-267(moral)-267(and)-267(spiritual)-267(influences)-266(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(called)-250(into)-250(action.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(The)-214(following)-214(is)-214(the)-214(bearing)-214(of)-214(this)-214(fact)-214(on)-214(the)-214(question)-214(before)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(us.)-465(If)-321(the)-322(cure)-321(of)-322(a)-321(demoniac)-322(was)-321(the)-322(expulsion)-321(of)-322(a)-321(demon,)-339(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(involved)-286(the)-286(liberation)-285(of)-286(a)-286(moral)-286(nature)-285(from)-286(its)-286(thraldom,)-294(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-287(the)-287(same)-286(time)-287(the)-287(cure)-287(of)-287(the)-286(bodily)-287(organisation)-287(as)-287(far)-287(as)-286(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(disordered)-202(condition)-202(enabled)-202(the)-202(demon)-202(to)-203(exert)-202(his)-202(power.)-234(If,)-211(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-230(other)-230(hand,)-234(it)-230(was)-230(the)-230(cure)-230(of)-230(simple)-230(mania,)-234(still)-230(the)-230(act)-230(had)-230(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(direct)-281(bearing)-280(on)-281(the)-281(moral)-281(nature)-280(of)-281(the)-281(sufferer.)-342(In)-281(either)-280(case)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-379(use)-378(of)-379(moral)-378(means)-379(as)-378(well)-379(as)-378(supernatural)-379(agency)-378(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-262(especially)-262(appropriate.)-285(If)-262(demoniacs)-261(were)-262(madmen,)-265(our)-261(Lord)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-235(fully)-235(justified)-235(in)-235(displaying)-235(towards)-235(them)-235(the)-235(highest)-235(degree)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-295(sympathy,)-306(and)-294(in)-295(bringing)-295(to)-295(bear)-294(on)-295(them)-295(the)-295(mighty)-294(moral)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1094 0 obj <<
/Length 2759      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(235)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(and)-377(spiritual)-377(forces)-376(which)-377(abode)-377(in)-377(his)-376(lofty)-377(personality.)-630(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same)-354(remark)-355(would)-354(be)-354(equally)-355(true)-354(if)-354(the)-355(sufferer)-354(was)-354(held)-354(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thrall)-281(by)-280(demoniacal)-281(power.)-342(Each)-281(class)-281(of)-280(miracles)-281(in)-281(the)-280(mode)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-334(their)-334(performance)-334(is)-334(exactly)-334(suited)-334(to)-334(the)-334(condition)-334(of)-333(those)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-253(whom)-253(our)-252(Lord)-253(was)-253(operating.)-258(On)-253(either)-253(supposition)-253(He)-252(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dealing)-272(not)-271(merely)-272(with)-272(physical)-271(forces,)-277(but)-272(with)-272(moral)-271(agency,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(He)-250(dealt)-250(with)-250(it)-250(accordingly.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(I)-190(conclude,)-201(therefore,)-202(that)-190(if)-190(it)-189(may)-190(be)-190(taken)-189(as)-380(established)-189(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 279.068 0 Td [([267])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(possession)-193(involved)-194(nothing)-193(but)-193(simple)-194(mania,)-204(there)-194(is)-193(nothing)-193(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-251(facts)-251(as)-251(they)-250(are)-251(recorded)-251(in)-251(the)-251(New)-251(Testament)-250(inconsistent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-286(that)-286(supposition,)-294(or)-286(which)-286(affects)-285(the)-286(credit)-286(of)-286(the)-285(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-321(historical)-322(narratives.)-464(Nor)-321(are)-321(they)-322(inconsistent)-321(with)-321(the)-321(idea)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-196(their)-195(writers)-196(were)-195(favoured)-196(with)-195(such)-196(supernatural)-195(assistance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-367(composing)-368(them)-367(as)-367(was)-367(adequate)-367(for)-368(the)-367(purpose)-367(of)-367(giving)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(us)-292(such)-293(an)-292(account)-292(of)-292(the)-293(actions)-292(and)-292(teachings)-293(of)-292(Jesus)-292(as)-292(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary)-248(for)-247(communicating)-248(all)-247(the)-248(great)-248(truths)-247(of)-248(the)-247(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(revelation.)-658(Nor)-387(is)-386(the)-386(supposition)-386(inconsistent,)-420(as)-386(it)-386(has)-386(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alleged)-250(to)-250(be,)-250(with)-250(His)-250(divine)-250(character)-250(and)-250(truthfulness.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(I)-241(will)-241(examine)-241(in)-240(the)-241(next)-241(chapter)-241(the)-241(supposition)-241(that)-240(posses-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(sion)-250(was)-250(not)-250(mania,)-250(but)-250(an)-250(actual)-250(objective)-250(fact.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 -29.65 Td [([268])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1103 0 obj <<
/Length 3428      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 93.543 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-264(XII.)-264(Possession,)-268(If)-264(An)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Objective)-240(Reality,)-242(Neither)-240(Incredible)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Nor)-257(Contrary)-257(To)-257(The)-257(Ascertained)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Truths)-250(Of)-250(Mental)-250(Science.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -39.701 Td [(I)-282(now)-281(proceed)-282(to)-282(the)-282(consideration)-281(of)-282(the)-282(remaining)-281(alternative,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-211(truth)-211(of)-212(which)-211(the)-211(form)-211(of)-211(the)-212(narrative)-211(seems)-211(most)-211(to)-211(favour,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(viz.,)-352(that)-331(our)-332(Lord)-331(accepted)-332(the)-331(distinction)-332(between)-331(possession)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-300(mania;)-326(and)-300(that)-300(during)-300(those)-301(times)-300(possessions)-300(were)-300(actual)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(occurrences.)]TJ 11.956 -15.005 Td [(In)-314(considering)-315(this)-314(subject,)-330(it)-315(will)-314(be)-314(necessary)-315(to)-314(pay)-314(atten-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tion)-354(to)-354(the)-354(distinction)-354(to)-354(which)-354(I)-354(have)-354(referred)-354(in)-354(the)-354(previous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(chapter,)-334(that)-317(even)-317(if)-317(many)-317(of)-317(the)-317(phenomena)-316(that)-317(accompanied)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession)-293(were)-293(due)-293(to)-292(superhuman)-293(agency,)-304(the)-293(Gospels)-293(are)-292(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-212(means)-212(pledged)-211(to)-212(any)-212(particular)-211(theory)-212(of)-212(the)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 210.444 0 Td [(modus)-212(operandi)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -210.444 -13.55 Td [(by)-186(which)-186(the)-187(phenomena)-186(were)-186(brought)-186(about.)-229(What)-186(I)-186(mean)-186(is)-186(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-257(phenomena)-257(might)-257(have)-257(been)-257(due)-257(to)-257(a)-257(superhuman)-257(agency,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-284(involving)-284(the)-283(fact)-284(that)-284(the)-283(demon)-284(had)-284(a)-284(local)-283(habitation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(either)-306(in)-306(the)-306(body)-305(or)-306(the)-306(spirit)-306(of)-306(the)-305(man.)-418(All)-306(that)-306(the)-305(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-218(be)-218(taken)-219(to)-218(affirm)-218(is,)-225(that)-218(the)-218(evil)-218(spirit)-219(in)-218(some)-218(way)-218(or)-218(other,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-337(which)-336(we)-337(are)-337(ignorant,)-358(held)-337(the)-337(man)-337(in)-336(a)-337(state)-337(of)-336(thraldom,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-282(his)-281(mental)-282(powers)-281(the)-281(subject)-282(of)-281(a)-282(divided)-281(consciousness,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(overpowered)-197(the)-197(functions)-196(of)-197(his)-197(reason)-197(and)-196(his)-197(will,)-208(and)-196(through)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-306(action)-306(on)-306(the)-306(mind)-306(used)-306(for)-306(his)-306(own)-306(purposes)-306(the)-306(organs)-305(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-800(body.)-701(The)-400(writers)-400(of)-400(the)-400(New)-400(Testament)-400(are)-400(pledged)-400(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([269])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(no)-461(theory)-462(as)-461(to)-462(how)-461(such)-461(results)-462(were)-461(effected.)-884(They)-461(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(simply)-279(reported)-278(the)-279(phenomena)-278(as)-279(they)-278(presented)-279(themselves)-278(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-342(observation.)-525(In)-342(doing)-342(this,)-365(the)-342(language)-342(which)-342(they)-341(have)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1107 0 obj <<
/Length 4440      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(237)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(employed)-241(denotes)-240(local)-241(habitation;)-244(but)-241(the)-240(words)-241(used)-241(in)-240(stilling)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-314(storm)-313(make)-314(it)-314(quite)-313(clear)-314(that)-314(the)-313(literal)-314(meaning)-314(cannot)-313(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pressed.)-559(Considering)-353(the)-353(general)-353(character)-353(of)-353(these)-352(narratives,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-313(is)-314(impossible)-313(to)-314(pledge)-313(them)-313(to)-314(the)-313(particular)-314(mode)-313(in)-313(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(these)-250(results)-250(were)-250(brought)-250(about.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(One)-392(circumstance)-391(seems)-392(to)-392(militate)-391(against)-392(the)-391(supposition)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-290(possession)-289(involved)-289(nothing)-290(but)-289(simple)-290(mania,)-299(namely,)-299(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(numbers)-268(of)-267(those)-268(who)-268(are)-267(spoken)-268(of)-268(as)-267(possessed.)-303(If)-268(the)-267(Gospel)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(narratives)-383(are)-383(historical,)-417(it)-383(would)-383(appear)-383(that)-383(such)-383(cases)-383(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(numerous.)-877(Not)-459(only)-459(are)-459(several)-459(miracles)-459(of)-459(this)-458(description)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(definitely)-254(recorded,)-255(but)-255(the)-254(Evangelists)-254(several)-254(times)-254(affirm)-254(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-473(Lord)-473(cured)-473(demoniacs)-473(in)-474(considerable)-473(numbers,)-528(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(furnishing)-293(us)-293(with)-293(the)-293(details.)-379(Now)-293(it)-293(is)-293(difficult)-293(to)-293(believe)-292(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(maniacs)-334(existed)-334(in)-334(such)-334(large)-334(numbers)-334(in)-334(a)-334(country)-334(of)-334(the)-333(size)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-321(population)-321(of)-321(Jud\346a.)-464(Yet)-321(all)-321(the)-321(phenomena)-321(of)-321(possession)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(point)-215(to)-215(maniacal,)-222(and)-215(not)-215(to)-215(harmless)-214(lunacy.)-239(The)-215(number)-215(of)-214(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cases)-223(of)-223(mania)-222(that)-223(occur)-223(bears)-223(but)-223(a)-222(small)-223(proportion)-223(to)-223(those)-222(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-260(latter)-261(form)-260(of)-261(derangement.)-281(It)-260(is)-261(true)-260(that)-260(at)-261(times)-260(of)-260(popular)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(excitement)-216(various)-217(forms)-216(and)-216(numerous)-217(cases)-216(of)-216(frenzy)-216(manifest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(themselves;)-302(but)-285(these)-285(differ)-285(from)-285(mania,)-293(though)-285(they)-285(not)-284(unfre-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(quently)-244(terminate)-244(in)-244(it.)-248(I)-244(have)-244(made)-244(these)-244(observations,)-245(because,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-398(discussing)-397(such)-398(a)-397(subject,)-435(it)-397(is)-398(only)-397(right)-398(to)-397(state)-398(fully)-397(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difficulties)-251(with)-250(which)-251(particular)-251(theories)-250(are)-251(attended.)-252(It)-251(is)-250(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(probable,)-365(however,)-365(that)-343(as)-342(the)-342(symptoms)-342(so)-342(closely)-342(resembled)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(each)-377(other,)-409(many)-377(cases)-377(of)-377(actual)-377(mania)-377(would)-377(be)-377(confounded)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-279(popular)-279(estimation)-280(with)-279(possession,)-286(and,)-287(therefore,)-286(that)-279(cases)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-288(actual)-287(possession)-575(may)-288(not)-287(have)-288(been)-287(so)-288(numerous)-287(as)-288(at)-287(first)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([270])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(sight)-250(would)-250(appear.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(On)-432(the)-433(supposition)-432(that)-432(possession)-433(was)-432(a)-432(reality,)-478(we)-432(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(no)-327(means)-327(of)-327(determining)-327(what)-327(moral)-327(or)-327(physical)-327(preconditions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-309(necessary)-308(for)-309(its)-308(manifestation.)-426(It)-308(is)-309(clear)-308(that)-309(the)-308(authors)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-298(the)-299(Gospels)-298(must)-299(have)-298(considered)-298(that)-299(it)-298(was)-299(owing)-298(to)-298(some)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(predisposing)-408(causes,)-446(physical)-408(or)-407(moral,)-447(though)-408(they)-407(have)-407(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(described)-377(them.)-632(Unless)-377(this)-377(was)-377(the)-377(case,)-409(the)-377(evil,)-409(instead)-377(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1112 0 obj <<
/Length 4527      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(238)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(being)-289(partial,)-298(would)-289(have)-288(been)-289(universal.)-366(Various)-289(moral)-288(causes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-438(naturally)-438(form)-439(a)-438(suitable)-438(precondition)-438(for)-438(its)-438(manifes-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tation.)-748(There)-417(can)-416(be)-416(no)-416(doubt)-416(that)-416(a)-416(number)-417(of)-416(vices,)-457(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(indulged)-387(in)-388(beyond)-387(a)-387(certain)-388(point,)-421(reduce)-388(man's)-387(moral)-387(being)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-349(a)-349(wreck)-349(and)-350(render)-349(him)-349(obnoxious)-349(to)-349(the)-349(action)-349(of)-349(external)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agency.)-233(The)-198(power)-198(of)-199(sel)1(f-control)-199(may)-198(be)-198(indefinitely)-198(weakened.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(If)-362(vice)-362(is)-362(carried)-361(to)-362(its)-362(extreme)-362(forms,)-390(it)-362(produces)-361(phenomena)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hardly,)-353(if)-333(at)-332(all,)-354(distinguishable)-332(from)-333(madness.)-498(Such)-332(a)-333(state)-332(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man's)-240(moral)-240(nature)-240(would)-240(form)-240(a)-240(suitable)-240(precondition)-240(to)-239(enable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-356(superhuman)-357(being)-356(to)-357(overpower)-356(the)-356(reason)-357(and)-356(the)-356(will,)-383(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supremacy)-273(of)-272(which)-273(was)-272(already)-273(impaired)-273(by)-272(an)-273(influence)-272(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(within.)-877(In)-459(such)-459(cases)-459(possession)-459(would)-459(have)-459(been)-459(rendered)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possible)-250(by)-250(a)-250(man's)-250(self-induced)-250(moral)-250(corruption.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-231(testimony)-230(of)-231(history)-230(proves)-231(that)-231(during)-230(the)-231(century)-230(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(preceded)-253(and)-254(that)-253(which)-254(followed)-253(the)-254(Advent,)-254(the)-254(state)-253(of)-253(moral)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(corruption)-470(was)-471(extreme.)-911(Men)-470(were)-471(sated)-470(with)-471(the)-470(old,)-525(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(craving)-350(for)-349(new)-350(and)-350(unheard)-350(of)-349(forms)-350(of)-350(sensual)-349(gratification.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-228(old)-227(class)-228(of)-227(ideas,)-232(moral)-228(and)-227(religious,)-232(were)-228(gradually)-227(dying)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(out,)-236(and)-233(men)-232(were)-233(eagerly)-232(seeking)-233(for)-232(something)-233(to)-232(fill)-233(the)-232(void.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(There)-284(consequently)-285(never)-284(was)-284(a)-285(time)-284(when)-284(a)-285(greater)-284(number)-284(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(abnormal)-248(forms)-247(of)-248(thought)-247(burst)-248(on)-248(the)-247(human)-248(mind,)-248(which)-247(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(shaken)-336(to)-336(its)-336(utmost)-336(depths.)-508(The)-336(outbreak)-336(of)-336(fanaticism)-672(com-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([271])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(bined)-274(with)-275(moral)-274(wickedness,)-280(which)-275(displayed)-274(itself)-274(forty)-274(years)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(after)-335(in)-334(the)-335(Jewish)-335(war)-335(of)-334(independence,)-356(is)-335(probably)-335(without)-334(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(parallel)-204(in)-204(the)-204(history)-204(of)-204(man.)-235(For)-204(this)-204(there)-204(must)-203(have)-204(been)-204(years)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-257(preparation.)-273(A)-257(somewhat)-257(similar)-258(state)-257(of)-257(things)-258(existed)-257(in)-257(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Pagan)-269(world,)-273(which)-268(led)-269(to)-268(the)-269(production)-268(of)-269(numerous)-268(religious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(charlatans)-204(and)-205(impostors.)-235(The)-204(times)-205(were)-204(characterised)-205(by)-204(an)-204(ex-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(travagance)-261(of)-260(thought)-261(on)-261(almost)-261(every)-260(subject,)-264(philosophy)-260(itself)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forming)-309(no)-309(exception.)-426(Such)-309(an)-309(abnormal)-309(mental)-309(condition)-308(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(peculiarly)-310(suited)-310(to)-310(the)-310(reception)-310(of)-310(external)-310(mental)-309(influences,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(if)-250(we)-250(suppose)-250(them)-250(possible.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-229(I)-228(am)-229(bound)-228(to)-229(admit)-228(that)-229(the)-228(facts)-229(recorded)-228(in)-229(the)-228(Gospels)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(prove)-290(that)-289(possession)-290(was)-289(not)-290(always)-289(the)-290(result)-289(of)-290(moral)-289(degra-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
980 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 967
/Length 9299      
>>
stream
976 0 978 115 979 172 975 228 982 305 984 420 981 476 985 541 988 581 990 748
986 863 989 919 993 996 995 1111 996 1168 992 1225 998 1302 1000 1418 997 1476 1003 1553
1005 1672 1002 1729 1007 1807 1009 1926 1006 1985 1011 2051 1013 2170 1010 2229 1015 2295 1017 2414
1014 2472 1019 2538 1021 2657 1022 2716 1018 2775 1024 2865 1026 2984 1023 3042 1029 3108 1031 3227
1028 3285 1033 3375 1035 3494 1032 3552 1037 3630 1039 3749 1036 3808 1041 3874 1043 3993 1040 4052
1045 4118 1047 4237 1048 4296 1044 4353 1050 4443 1052 4562 1049 4621 1055 4737 1057 4856 1054 4915
1059 4993 1061 5112 1058 5171 1063 5261 1065 5380 1062 5439 1067 5505 1069 5624 1066 5683 1071 5749
1073 5868 1074 5927 1070 5985 1076 6101 1078 6220 1075 6278 1081 6356 1083 6475 1080 6534 1085 6612
1087 6731 1084 6790 1089 6868 1091 6987 1088 7046 1093 7112 1095 7231 1096 7290 1092 7348 1097 7414
1100 7455 1102 7597 1098 7716 1104 7774 1101 7832 1106 7910 1108 8029 1105 8088 1111 8154 1113 8273
% 976 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 977 0 R
/Resources 975 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 970 0 R
>>
% 978 0 obj
<<
/D [976 0 R /XYZ 148.648 504.626 null]
>>
% 979 0 obj
<<
/D [976 0 R /XYZ 46.771 106.048 null]
>>
% 975 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 982 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 983 0 R
/Resources 981 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 970 0 R
>>
% 984 0 obj
<<
/D [982 0 R /XYZ 93.543 190.453 null]
>>
% 981 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 985 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index12) >>
% 988 0 obj
(Chapter XI. Possession: Is The Theory That It Was Madness Subversive Of The Historical Value Of The Gospels Or Inconsistent With The Veracity Of Christ?)
% 990 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 991 0 R
/Resources 989 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 970 0 R
>>
% 986 0 obj
<<
/D [990 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 989 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 993 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 994 0 R
/Resources 992 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 970 0 R
>>
% 995 0 obj
<<
/D [993 0 R /XYZ 263.749 518.175 null]
>>
% 996 0 obj
<<
/D [993 0 R /XYZ 340.999 120.339 null]
>>
% 992 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 998 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 999 0 R
/Resources 997 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1001 0 R
>>
% 1000 0 obj
<<
/D [998 0 R /XYZ 280.892 189.067 null]
>>
% 997 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1003 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1004 0 R
/Resources 1002 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1001 0 R
>>
% 1005 0 obj
<<
/D [1003 0 R /XYZ 93.543 229.96 null]
>>
% 1002 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1007 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1008 0 R
/Resources 1006 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1001 0 R
>>
% 1009 0 obj
<<
/D [1007 0 R /XYZ 183.176 310.028 null]
>>
% 1006 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1011 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1012 0 R
/Resources 1010 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1001 0 R
>>
% 1013 0 obj
<<
/D [1011 0 R /XYZ 343.003 382.683 null]
>>
% 1010 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1015 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1016 0 R
/Resources 1014 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1001 0 R
>>
% 1017 0 obj
<<
/D [1015 0 R /XYZ 306.08 450.429 null]
>>
% 1014 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1019 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1020 0 R
/Resources 1018 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1001 0 R
>>
% 1021 0 obj
<<
/D [1019 0 R /XYZ 139.428 504.626 null]
>>
% 1022 0 obj
<<
/D [1019 0 R /XYZ 327.348 120.339 null]
>>
% 1018 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1024 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1025 0 R
/Resources 1023 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1027 0 R
>>
% 1026 0 obj
<<
/D [1024 0 R /XYZ 314.732 190.54 null]
>>
% 1023 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1029 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1030 0 R
/Resources 1028 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1027 0 R
>>
% 1031 0 obj
<<
/D [1029 0 R /XYZ 93.543 258.362 null]
>>
% 1028 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1033 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1034 0 R
/Resources 1032 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1027 0 R
>>
% 1035 0 obj
<<
/D [1033 0 R /XYZ 305.99 311.664 null]
>>
% 1032 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1037 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1038 0 R
/Resources 1036 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1027 0 R
>>
% 1039 0 obj
<<
/D [1037 0 R /XYZ 327.933 381.865 null]
>>
% 1036 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1041 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1042 0 R
/Resources 1040 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1027 0 R
>>
% 1043 0 obj
<<
/D [1041 0 R /XYZ 115.209 420.058 null]
>>
% 1040 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1045 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1046 0 R
/Resources 1044 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1027 0 R
>>
% 1047 0 obj
<<
/D [1045 0 R /XYZ 168.847 491.077 null]
>>
% 1048 0 obj
<<
/D [1045 0 R /XYZ 168.098 93.24 null]
>>
% 1044 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1050 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1051 0 R
/Resources 1049 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1053 0 R
>>
% 1052 0 obj
<<
/D [1050 0 R /XYZ 148.378 165.896 null]
>>
% 1049 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F37 246 0 R /F38 247 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1055 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1056 0 R
/Resources 1054 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1053 0 R
>>
% 1057 0 obj
<<
/D [1055 0 R /XYZ 181.743 217.638 null]
>>
% 1054 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1059 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1060 0 R
/Resources 1058 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1053 0 R
>>
% 1061 0 obj
<<
/D [1059 0 R /XYZ 204.591 296.478 null]
>>
% 1058 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1063 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1064 0 R
/Resources 1062 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1053 0 R
>>
% 1065 0 obj
<<
/D [1063 0 R /XYZ 319.595 365.861 null]
>>
% 1062 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1067 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1068 0 R
/Resources 1066 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1053 0 R
>>
% 1069 0 obj
<<
/D [1067 0 R /XYZ 226.572 420.876 null]
>>
% 1066 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1071 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1072 0 R
/Resources 1070 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1053 0 R
>>
% 1073 0 obj
<<
/D [1071 0 R /XYZ 148.626 491.077 null]
>>
% 1074 0 obj
<<
/D [1071 0 R /XYZ 159.704 79.691 null]
>>
% 1070 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F37 246 0 R /F38 247 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1076 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1077 0 R
/Resources 1075 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1079 0 R
>>
% 1078 0 obj
<<
/D [1076 0 R /XYZ 88.036 147.437 null]
>>
% 1075 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1081 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1082 0 R
/Resources 1080 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1079 0 R
>>
% 1083 0 obj
<<
/D [1081 0 R /XYZ 111.527 220.093 null]
>>
% 1080 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1085 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1086 0 R
/Resources 1084 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1079 0 R
>>
% 1087 0 obj
<<
/D [1085 0 R /XYZ 128.616 314.219 null]
>>
% 1084 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1089 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1090 0 R
/Resources 1088 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1079 0 R
>>
% 1091 0 obj
<<
/D [1089 0 R /XYZ 300.352 355.585 null]
>>
% 1088 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1093 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1094 0 R
/Resources 1092 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1079 0 R
>>
% 1095 0 obj
<<
/D [1093 0 R /XYZ 258.419 423.331 null]
>>
% 1096 0 obj
<<
/D [1093 0 R /XYZ 46.771 231.089 null]
>>
% 1092 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1097 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index13) >>
% 1100 0 obj
(Chapter XII. Possession, If An Objective Reality, Neither Incredible Nor Contrary To The Ascertained Truths Of Mental Science.)
% 1102 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1103 0 R
/Resources 1101 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1079 0 R
>>
% 1098 0 obj
<<
/D [1102 0 R /XYZ 93.543 529.134 null]
>>
% 1104 0 obj
<<
/D [1102 0 R /XYZ 110.639 106.79 null]
>>
% 1101 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1106 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1107 0 R
/Resources 1105 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1109 0 R
>>
% 1108 0 obj
<<
/D [1106 0 R /XYZ 137.989 163.441 null]
>>
% 1105 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1111 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1112 0 R
/Resources 1110 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1109 0 R
>>
% 1113 0 obj
<<
/D [1111 0 R /XYZ 348.089 231.187 null]
>>
endstream
endobj
1117 0 obj <<
/Length 4537      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(239)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(dation.)-238(This)-215(is)-215(proved)-215(by)-215(the)-214(case)-215(of)-215(the)-215(youth,)-222(whose)-214(possession)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-421(father)-422(directly)-421(connects)-421(with)-422(lunacy,)-464(and)-421(says)-422(that)-421(it)-421(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(seized)-319(him)-319(from)-319(a)-319(child.)-457(In)-319(this)-319(case)-319(the)-319(cause)-319(which)-319(rendered)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-449(possession)-449(possible)-450(must)-449(have)-449(been)-449(physical,)-499(probably)-449(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(derangement)-250(of)-250(the)-250(nervous)-250(system.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(If)-374(I)-374(understand)-374(rightly)-375(the)-374(position)-374(which)-374(is)-374(taken)-374(by)-374(those)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(who)-388(affirm)-388(that)-388(possession)-388(was)-388(mania,)-422(and)-388(nothing)-388(else,)-423(it)-387(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-383(follows.)-647(It)-382(is)-383(alleged)-382(that)-383(at)-382(certain)-383(periods)-382(of)-383(history,)-415(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belief)-414(in)-415(possession)-414(has)-415(been)-414(widely)-415(spread.)-743(Possessions)-414(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unknown)-441(in)-440(modern)-441(times;)-536(and)-440(all)-441(the)-440(instances)-441(which)-440(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-355(alleged)-355(are)-355(either)-355(cases)-355(of)-355(mania)-355(or)-355(delusion.)-565(The)-354(belief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-378(it)-378(has)-378(gradually)-378(died)-378(away)-378(as)-378(knowledge)-378(has)-378(advanced.)-633(In)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(former)-317(times)-317(it)-317(generated)-316(a)-317(number)-317(of)-317(grotesque)-317(stories,)-333(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-331(pure)-330(inventions)-331(of)-330(the)-331(imagination)-330(heated)-331(by)-330(enthusiasm.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Such)-440(facts)-441(as)-440(were)-440(real)-441(may)-440(be)-440(referred)-441(to)-440(madness)-440(as)-440(their)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(cause.)-516(The)-339(others)-338(are)-339(simply)-338(disbelieved.)-516(Under)-339(the)-338(influence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-263(increasing)-263(knowledge,)-266(there)-263(has)-263(arisen)-263(a)-263(widespread)-263(belief)-263(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modern)-351(times,)-376(that)-350(there)-351(is)-351(nothing)-351(superhuman)-701(in)-351(the)-350(causes)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([272])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(of)-297(such)-296(phenomena,)-309(but)-296(that)-297(they)-297(are)-296(due)-297(to)-297(influences)-296(existing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(within)-336(the)-337(mind)-336(itself.)-510(This,)-358(as)-336(it)-337(is)-336(affirmed,)-358(being)-337(true)-336(of)-336(all)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-394(alleged)-394(instances)-394(of)-394(possession)-394(in)-394(the)-394(modern)-394(world,)-430(it)-394(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inferred)-229(that)-228(similar)-229(ones)-228(in)-229(the)-228(ancient)-229(world)-228(are)-229(equally)-228(unreal;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-293(if)-292(we)-293(had)-292(the)-293(requisite)-292(data)-293(before)-292(us,)-303(we)-293(should)-292(be)-293(able)-292(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(refer)-250(them)-250(all)-250(to)-250(ordinary)-250(human)-250(causes.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(With)-361(respect)-360(to)-361(the)-361(general)-361(fact,)-388(there)-361(can)-360(be)-361(no)-361(doubt)-360(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(advancing)-359(knowledge)-359(has)-359(caused)-359(a)-359(general)-359(disbelief)-359(in)-359(the)-359(re-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ality)-355(of)-355(any)-355(modern)-354(form)-355(of)-355(possession,)-381(or)-355(of)-355(witchcraft.)-564(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supreme)-211(grotesqueness)-211(of)-211(the)-210(phenomena)-211(of)-211(the)-211(latter)-211(has)-210(caused)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-336(belief)-337(in)-336(it)-337(to)-336(perish)-336(under)-337(the)-336(influence)-337(of)-336(common)-336(sense,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aided)-459(by)-460(an)-459(increased)-459(acquaintance)-460(with)-459(sound)-459(principles)-459(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(causation,)-284(and)-278(the)-277(stability)-278(of)-277(the)-278(operations)-277(of)-278(nature.)-332(Still)-278(it)-277(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incorrect)-329(to)-329(affirm)-328(that)-329(the)-329(prevalence)-328(of)-329(such)-329(beliefs)-329(has)-328(been)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(due)-378(to)-378(no)-378(other)-378(cause)-378(than)-378(universal)-378(ignorance.)-634(The)-378(belief)-377(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(witchcraft)-211(produced)-210(its)-211(most)-210(unhappy)-211(result)1(s)-211(during)-210(the)-211(reigns)-210(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1121 0 obj <<
/Length 4615      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(240)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Elizabeth)-219(and)-219(the)-219(Stuarts,)-225(in)-219(the)-219(very)-219(age)-219(of)-219(Bacon,)-225(Shakespeare,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-326(Raleigh.)-479(Such)-327(beliefs)-326(originate)-326(in)-327(certain)-326(principles)-326(of)-326(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(minds)-362(whose)-361(gratification)-362(consists)-361(in)-362(the)-361(contemplation)-362(of)-361(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(marvellous,)-291(the)-283(action)-283(of)-283(which)-282(I)-283(shall)-283(consider)-283(hereafter.)-348(They)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-253(existed)-254(in)-253(every)-253(condition)-254(of)-253(society,)-254(and)-254(only)-253(changed)-253(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(form)-377(of)-377(their)-377(manifestation.)-630(Those)-377(who)-377(boast)-377(of)-377(our)-376(freedom)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-208(such)-208(delusions,)-216(owing)-208(to)-208(the)-208(superior)-208(light)-208(of)-208(the)-207(nineteenth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(century,)-295(seem)-286(to)-286(have)-286(forgotten)-286(the)-286(existence)-286(at)-286(the)-286(present)-286(day)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-366(a)-365(belief)-366(in)-366(spiritualism,)-395(which)-365(is)-366(little,)-395(if)-365(at)-366(all,)-395(less)-365(absurd)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(than)-251(witchcraft,)-251(though)-251(the)-251(former)-251(has)-251(encountered)-251(a)-251(less)-251(severe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(treatment)-409(than)-408(the)-409(latter.)-725(This)-409(has)-409(been)-408(more)-409(due)-408(to)-409(the)-408(im-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(provement)-346(of)-347(our)-346(humanity)-346(than)-346(to)-347(our)-346(knowledge)-346(of)-346(physical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(science.)-243(It)-228(is)-228(a)-229(fact)-228(that)-228(spiritualism)-228(is)-228(believed)-457(in)-228(by)-228(multitudes;)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([273])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(and)-248(its)-248(votaries)-248(belong)-248(far)-248(more)-248(to)-248(the)-248(cultivated)-248(class)-248(of)-248(society)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(than)-315(to)-314(the)-315(ignorant)-314(and)-315(the)-314(vulgar.)-444(What)-315(the)-314(witch)-315(mania)-314(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-299(the)-298(sixteenth)-298(and)-299(seventeenth)-298(centuries,)-311(spiritualism)-298(is)-299(to)-298(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nineteenth.)-467(It)-322(is)-322(the)-322(peculiar)-322(form)-323(rather)-322(than)-322(the)-322(possibility)-322(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-250(delusions)-250(that)-250(has)-250(passed)-250(away.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-183(should)-183(be)-184(observed)-183(also)-183(that)-183(the)-183(demoniacal)-183(supernaturalism)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-243(the)-243(monastic)-242(writers,)-245(and)-242(of)-243(the)-243(middle)-243(ages,)-244(differs)-243(from)-242(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-241(the)-242(New)-241(Testament)-242(to)-241(such)-242(a)-241(degree)-242(that)-241(they)-242(cannot)-241(fairly)-241(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(compared.)-358(In)-287(the)-286(former)-286(the)-286(apparition)-286(of)-286(demons)-286(and)-286(departed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(spirits)-354(was)-354(a)-354(thing)-354(of)-354(constant)-354(occurrence;)-406(in)-354(the)-354(latter,)-380(never.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(To)-356(the)-356(monks)-356(the)-356(devil)-356(was)-356(continually)-356(appearing)-356(in)-356(the)-355(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phantastic)-347(forms,)-370(and)-347(performing)-347(the)-346(most)-347(grotesque)-346(miracles.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(To)-239(this)-240(form)-239(of)-239(demonology)-239(modern)-239(spiritualism)-240(can)-239(put)-239(in)-239(very)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(strong)-276(claims)-276(to)-276(be)-276(esteemed)-276(the)-276(genuine)-276(successor.)-328(The)-275(heated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(imagination)-268(of)-268(even)-268(such)-269(a)-268(man)-268(as)-268(Luther)-268(suggested)-268(to)-268(him)-268(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-350(saw)-349(Satan)-350(in)-349(visible)-350(reality.)-548(It)-350(is)-349(worthy)-350(of)-349(remark)-350(that)-349(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Paul)-314(knew)-314(nothing)-314(of)-315(visible)-314(Satanic)-314(manifestations.)-442(With)-314(him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-250(were)-250(invariably)-250(spiritual.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-281(is)-281(important)-281(to)-282(keep)-281(steadily)-281(in)-281(view)-281(the)-281(fact,)-289(that)-281(the)-281(New)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(Testament)-326(invariably)-326(represents)-326(possession)-326(as)-326(consisting)-326(in)-326(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-264(of)-263(a)-264(stronger)-263(mind)-264(on)-263(a)-263(weaker)-264(one.)-290(The)-264(influence)-263(which)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1125 0 obj <<
/Length 4849      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(241)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(the)-206(demon)-207(exerted)-206(on)-206(the)-207(bodily)-206(organs)-206(might)-207(have)-206(been)-206(effected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(through)-298(the)-297(agency)-298(of)-297(the)-298(man)-297(himself.)-393(It)-298(is)-297(never)-298(described)-297(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(involving)-275(a)-274(visible)-275(manifestation)-275(of)-274(the)-275(demon,)-281(but)-274(his)-275(action)-274(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-327(which)-327(is)-327(purely)-327(mental)-326(and)-327(spiritual.)-481(His)-327(presence)-327(and)-326(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(departure)-250(were)-250(simply)-250(judged)-250(of)-250(by)-250(their)-250(effects.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-368(follows,)-398(therefore,)-398(that)-368(the)-369(denial)-368(of)-368(the)-369(possibility)-368(of)-368(an)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(influence)-189(of)-190(this)-189(kind)-189(must)-189(rest)-190(on)-189(a)-189(very)-189(wide)-189(principle.)-230(It)-189(cannot)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-329(confined)-328(to)-329(such)-328(action)-329(alone,)-696(but)-329(must)-328(go)-329(to)-328(the)-329(extent)-328(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([274])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(denying)-243(the)-242(possibility)-243(of)-243(the)-242(action)-243(of)-243(all)-242(spiritual)-243(beings)-243(on)-242(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mind)-258(of)-259(man.)-275(The)-258(only)-258(principle)-259(on)-258(which)-258(the)-259(denial)-258(can)-258(rest)-258(is,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-263(our)-264(mental)-263(science)-264(has)-263(so)-263(far)-264(succeeded)-263(in)-264(analyzing)-263(all)-263(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(past)-230(and)-230(present)-229(operations)-230(of)-230(the)-230(human)-229(mind,)-234(that)-230(it)-230(is)-229(justified)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-223(affirming)-222(that)-223(they)-222(all)-223(originate)-222(entirely)-223(within)-222(the)-223(mind)-222(itself;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-297(are)-297(never)-296(brought)-297(about)-297(by)-297(an)-297(action)-296(on)-297(it)-297(from)-297(without)-296(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-327(invisible)-328(agent.)-481(If)-328(this)-327(is)-327(the)-327(principle)-328(on)-327(which)-327(the)-327(denial)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(rests,)-406(it)-376(will)-375(be)-375(equally)-375(valid)-375(to)-375(exclude)-375(the)-375(action)-375(of)-375(God)-375(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-352(minds,)-377(as)-351(well)-352(as)-351(that)-352(of)-351(all)-352(other)-352(invisible)-351(beings.)-555(It)-351(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(doubtless)-297(be)-296(urged)-297(that)-297(it)-296(is)-297(only)-296(intended)-297(to)-297(deny)-296(the)-297(action)-296(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(invisible)-276(evil)-275(beings.)-328(But)-275(if)-276(it)-276(is)-276(true)-275(that)-276(our)-276(mental)-275(philosophy)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-273(ascertained)-273(that)-272(all)-273(our)-273(thoughts)-272(originate)-273(either)-273(in)-273(the)-272(mind)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(itself,)-212(or)-202(in)-202(the)-202(mind)-202(acted)-202(on)-202(by)-202(external)-202(nature,)-211(or)-202(by)-202(other)-202(men,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-395(principle)-395(must)-395(be)-394(valid)-395(for)-395(proving)-395(that)-395(all)-395(other)-394(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agency)-275(exerted)-275(on)-275(the)-274(mind)-275(is)-275(impossible,)-281(and)-275(that)-275(all)-274(supposed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instances)-272(of)-271(it)-272(are)-271(delusions.)-315(It)-272(is)-271(impossible)-272(on)-271(this)-272(principle)-271(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exclude)-250(the)-250(evil)-250(agency,)-250(and)-250(not)-250(to)-250(exclude)-250(the)-250(good)-250(also.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-418(is)-419(evident)-418(that)-418(this)-418(principle)-419(is)-418(far)-418(too)-419(broad)-418(to)-418(be)-418(used)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(for)-378(the)-379(purpose)-378(of)-378(affirming)-378(the)-379(impossi)1(bility)-379(of)-378(the)-378(action)-378(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(external)-285(evil)-284(agents)-285(only.)-353(It)-285(is)-284(based)-284(on)-285(the)-284(supposition)-285(that)-284(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mental)-359(philosophy)-359(is)-359(so)-359(complete)-359(as)-359(to)-359(be)-359(able)-359(to)-359(assign)-358(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-289(most)-290(abnormal)-289(portions)-289(of)-290(our)-289(mental)-289(action)-290(to)-289(definite)-289(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(known)-293(forces,)-303(all)-293(of)-293(which)-293(originate)-293(within)-292(the)-293(mind)-293(itself,)-303(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-266(never)-266(due)-266(to)-265(external)-266(influences.)-298(If)-266(mental)-266(philosophy)-265(could)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(establish)-286(this)-285(as)-286(a)-285(fact,)-295(it)-285(would)-286(doubtless)-285(prove)-286(that)-285(possession)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-307(impossible;)-336(but)-307(it)-308(could)-307(prove)-307(a)-307(great)-307(deal)-308(more,)-321(even)-307(that)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1129 0 obj <<
/Length 4638      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(242)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(God)-284(never)-285(acted)-284(on)-284(or)-284(influenced)-285(t)1(he)-285(spirit)-284(of)-284(man.)-353(But)-284(if)-284(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-443(any)-443(one)-443(phenomenon)-443(of)-443(the)-443(mind,)-491(of)-443(the)-443(origin)-443(of)-443(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-371(are)-371(ignorant,)-402(the)-371(whole)-371(principle)-371(is)-371(vitiated,)-803(for)-371(that)-371(very)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([275])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(phenomenon)-276(may)-276(be)-276(caused)-275(by)-276(the)-276(action)-276(of)-276(an)-276(external)-275(power.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(The)-449(real)-448(point)-449(of)-448(the)-449(controversy)-448(therefore)-449(is,)-498(Is)-449(our)-448(mental)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(science)-257(thus)-257(complete?)-271(Has)-257(it)-257(been)-257(able)-257(to)-257(reduce)-257(all)-257(our)-257(mental)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena,)-298(including)-289(the)-288(most)-289(abnormal)-288(of)-288(them,)-299(to)-288(the)-288(action)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-380(known)-381(forces?)-640(Has)-381(it)-380(analyzed)-380(our)-381(mental)-380(powers)-380(to)-380(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inmost)-309(depths?)-426(Until)-309(it)-309(has)-308(done)-309(this,)-323(it)-309(is)-309(impossible)-309(to)-308(affirm)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-263(the)-263(abnormal)-263(actions)-264(of)-263(the)-263(mind)-263(may)-263(not)-263(be)-263(occasioned)-263(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-250(external)-250(agency.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-366(will)-366(probably)-366(be)-367(urged,)-395(that)-366(although)-366(our)-366(philosophy)-366(has)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(not)-289(yet)-290(succeeded)-289(in)-290(assigning)-289(all)-290(our)-289(mental)-290(phenomena)-289(to)-289(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-389(of)-389(known)-389(forces,)-423(it)-389(hopes)-389(to)-389(accomplish)-389(this)-388(hereafter;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-334(that)-334(its)-334(past)-334(conquests)-333(ought)-334(to)-334(be)-334(accepted)-334(as)-334(a)-334(pledge)-333(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(its)-356(future)-356(performances;)-409(and)-356(that)-356(the)-356(time)-356(will)-356(certainly)-355(come,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-440(it)-440(will)-440(be)-440(able)-440(to)-440(refer)-440(every)-440(mental)-440(phenomenon)-440(to)-440(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cause)-407(originating)-406(in)-407(the)-406(mind)-407(itself,)-446(and)-406(acting)-407(in)-406(conformity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-321(invariable)-321(law.)-463(Promises,)-339(however,)-338(are)-321(not)-321(performances;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(what)-206(is)-206(requisite)-206(to)-206(impart)-206(validity)-206(to)-206(wide)-206(affirmations)-206(is)-205(present)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(actual)-342(knowledge,)-364(not)-342(the)-342(hope)-341(that)-342(future)-342(scientific)-341(conquests)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will)-224(be)-224(extended)-224(over)-224(the)-224(entire)-224(regions)-224(of)-224(the)-224(unknown.)-241(Science)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(professes)-310(to)-309(walk)-310(by)-309(sight)-310(and)-309(not)-310(by)-310(faith.)-428(In)-310(a)-309(subject)-310(of)-309(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(kind)-352(it)-352(is)-352(most)-351(unphilosophical)-352(to)-352(assume)-352(that)-352(the)-351(possibilities)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-393(the)-394(future)-393(are)-393(the)-393(realities)-394(of)-393(the)-393(present;)-465(and)-393(to)-393(enunciate)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(propositions)-278(whose)-279(validity)-278(rests)-278(solely)-278(on)-278(the)-279(fact)-278(that)-278(they)-278(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-285(will)-286(now)-285(definitely)-286(state)-285(the)-286(principle)-285(which)-286(can)-285(alone)-285(give)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(any)-251(scientific)-250(value)-251(to)-251(the)-251(assertion,)-250(that)-251(such)-251(demoniacal)-250(action)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-211(that)-211(which)-211(is)-211(described)-211(in)-211(the)-211(New)-211(Testament,)-219(i)1(s)-211(unbelievable.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-200(is)-201(as)-200(follows:)-226(that)-200(we)-200(have)-201(so)-200(completely)-201(ascertained)-200(the)-200(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-201(the)-201(forces)-202(which)-201(act)-201(on)-201(our)-202(minds,)-211(and)-201(the)-201(laws)-201(which)-201(regulate)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(them,)-436(that)-398(we)-399(know)-399(as)-398(a)-399(scientifically)-797(established)-399(truth,)-435(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([276])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(they)-230(all)-230(originate)-230(either)-230(in)-230(our)-230(own)-230(mental)-230(organization,)-234(or)-230(in)-229(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1134 0 obj <<
/Length 4690      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(243)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(action)-240(of)-240(other)-239(men)-240(on)-240(our)-240(minds.)-246(The)-240(statement)-240(of)-240(the)-239(principle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(this)-250(distinct)-250(form)-250(at)-250(once)-250(shows)-250(that)-250(it)-250(is)-250(invalid.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-263(is)-263(impossible)-263(for)-263(one)-263(moment)-263(to)-263(affirm)-263(that)-263(our)-263(knowledge)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-335(so)-334(complete,)-356(that)-335(we)-335(have)-335(a)-334(scientific)-335(acquaintance)-335(with)-334(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(causes)-291(of)-292(all)-291(our)-292(varied)-291(mental)-291(phenomena,)-302(and)-292(the)-291(laws)-291(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(regulate)-433(them.)-798(We)-433(have)-433(ascertained)-432(the)-433(nature)-433(of)-433(several)-432(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-318(mental)-318(processes;)-352(but)-318(how)-318(small)-318(a)-318(portion)-318(of)-318(man's)-317(mental)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(activity)-192(do)-192(they)-191(embrace.)-231(I)-192(need)-192(only)-191(particularize)-192(a)-192(few)-192(of)-191(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-357(are)-356(in)-357(complete)-357(ignorance,)-383(as)-357(to)-356(the)-357(forces)-357(which)-356(generate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them,)-250(and)-250(the)-250(laws)-250(which)-250(regulate)-250(their)-250(action.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(First,)-247(with)-246(respect)-246(to)-246(Genius.)-249(Genius)-246(is)-246(a)-246(mental)-246(power)-246(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(manifests)-285(itself)-286(only)-285(on)-286(rare)-285(occasions.)-356(Who)-285(can)-286(affirm)-285(that)-285(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-197(ascertained)-198(the)-197(law)-197(which)-198(regulates)-197(its)-197(birth?)-233(We)-197(may)-197(judge)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-359(analogy)-359(that)-359(this,)-387(as)-359(other)-359(things,)-386(follows)-359(a)-359(law)-359(of)-359(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(kind;)-220(but)-204(respecting)-205(the)-204(causes)-204(which)-205(give)-204(it)-205(birth)-204(our)-204(philosophy)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-257(profoundly)-258(ignorant.)-272(Nor)-258(have)-257(we)-258(any)-257(knowledge)-258(of)-257(its)-257(mode)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-236(action.)-246(It)-236(manifests)-236(itself)-236(in)-236(various)-237(forms.)-245(There)-236(is)-236(the)-236(genius)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-254(makes)-254(the)-254(poet,)-255(the)-254(philosopher,)-255(the)-254(scientific)-254(discoverer,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-311(orator,)-325(the)-311(politician,)-325(and)-311(many)-310(others.)-432(How)-310(those)-311(who)-310(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessed)-402(of)-403(this)-402(power)-403(effectuate)-402(their)-403(mental)-402(operations,)-440(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(how)-283(their)-284(great)-283(ideas)-283(originate)-284(in)-283(their)-283(minds)-284(is)-283(a)-283(subject)-283(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exceeds)-224(the)-225(limits)-224(of)-224(our)-224(scientific)-225(knowledge.)-241(Take)-224(for)-224(example)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-312(genius)-311(of)-311(the)-312(poet.)-434(Whence)-312(came,)-327(and)-311(what)-312(was)-311(the)-311(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-232(that)-232(intuitive)-232(power)-232(with)-231(which)-232(Shakespeare)-232(was)-232(endowed,)-235(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(how)-262(was)-262(it)-262(called)-263(into)-262(exercise?)-286(We)-262(call)-262(such)-262(powers)-262(intuitions.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(We)-216(say)-216(that)-216(a)-216(great)-215(poet)-216(is)-216(endowed)-216(with)-216(a)-216(species)-216(of)-215(inspiration.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(What)-417(is)-417(this)-417(but)-418(to)-417(confess)-417(our)-417(entire)-417(ignorance)-417(both)-417(of)-417(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([277])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(origin)-271(and)-271(the)-272(mode)-271(of)-271(his)-271(mental)-271(operations.)-314(Probably)-271(the)-271(poet)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(himself)-274(would)-273(be)-274(unable)-273(to)-274(give)-273(us)-274(any)-273(analysis)-274(of)-273(the)-274(origin)-273(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-328(own)-328(thoughts,)-347(or)-328(of)-328(the)-328(laws)-328(that)-328(regulate)-328(them.)-484(How)-327(then)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-260(we)-259(venture)-260(to)-260(affirm)-260(that)-259(they)-260(must)-260(all)-259(originate)-260(in)-260(the)-259(mind)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(itself,)-273(and)-268(not)-268(be)-268(due)-268(to)-268(the)-268(action)-268(of)-268(some)-268(external)-268(power?)-304(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(habit)-293(of)-292(speaking)-293(of)-292(his)-293(inspirations,)-303(from)-292(which)-293(scientific)-292(men)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-237(not)-236(exempt,)-239(proves)-237(our)-237(complete)-236(ignorance)-237(both)-236(of)-237(its)-236(nature)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1139 0 obj <<
/Length 4627      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(244)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(and)-250(origin.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-263(to)-264(descend)-263(to)-263(a)-264(humbler)-263(sphere)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 154.791 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(our)-263(own)-264(minds.)-290(We)-263(are)]TJ -177.656 -13.549 Td [(all)-367(conscious)-367(that)-367(thoughts)-366(rush)-367(into)-367(them)-367(in)-367(a)-367(most)-366(unbidden)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manner,)-288(and)-281(that)-280(we)-281(pass)-280(through)-281(mental)-280(states)-280(which)-281(our)-280(anal-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ysis)-373(is)-373(unable)-373(to)-373(explain.)-619(Can)-373(any)-373(man)-373(affirm,)-403(however)-373(deep)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(may)-378(be)-378(his)-377(philosophy,)-410(that)-378(the)-377(known)-378(laws)-378(of)-378(association)-377(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ideas)-345(are)-346(adequate)-345(to)-345(account)-346(for)-345(all)-345(the)-346(mental)-345(phenomena)-345(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-339(he)-338(has)-339(been)-339(conscious?)-516(Who)-339(has)-338(not)-339(had)-339(experience)-338(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(severe)-238(efforts)-238(to)-239(realize)-238(something)-238(in)-238(thought,)-241(which)-238(have)-238(ended)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-374(failure,)-405(and)-373(that)-374(the)-374(right)-374(thing)-373(has)-374(suddenly)-374(come)-374(into)-373(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mind)-395(uncalled)-395(and)-395(unbidden?)-685(Not)-395(unfrequently)-395(has)-395(a)-395(sudden)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thought)-295(entered)-295(the)-295(mind)-296(\050we)-295(know)-295(not)-295(whence)-295(it)-295(came\051)-295(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-336(entirely)-336(changed)-337(the)-336(whole)-336(current)-336(of)-336(a)-337(previous)-336(life.)-508(Still)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more)-345(frequently)-344(has)-345(a)-344(happy)-345(idea)-344(occurred)-345(to)-344(us,)-368(the)-345(origin)-344(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-202(it)-202(is)-203(impossible)-202(to)-202(trace.)-234(Who)-203(again)-202(has)-202(not)-202(had)-202(experience)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-193(the)-192(sudden)-193(rushing)-192(of)-193(a)-192(temptation)-192(into)-193(his)-192(mind)-193(with)-192(an)-193(all)-192(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(overwhelming)-198(force,)-208(even)-197(while)-197(his)-198(thoughts)-197(were)-198(occupied)-197(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subjects)-261(in)-261(no)-261(way)-261(allied)-261(to)-261(the)-261(suggestion?)-283(Many)-261(of)-261(our)-261(mental)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena)-297(may)-297(be)-297(explained)-297(by)-297(the)-297(principle)-297(of)-297(association)-297(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ideas)-335(and)-336(other)-335(known)-335(mental)-335(powers;)-378(but)-336(who)-335(can)-335(venture)-335(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(affirm)-253(that)-254(they)-253(are)-253(adequate)-254(to)-253(account)-253(for)-254(all)-253(the)-253(various)-253(states)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-303(which)-302(he)-303(has)-303(been)-302(conscious,)-316(or)-303(that)-303(some)-302(of)-303(them)-303(have)-302(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(originated)-234(in)-234(suggestions)-234(from)-233(without?)-490(Scientific)-234(knowledge)-233(is)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([278])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(certainly)-250(able)-250(to)-250(make)-250(no)-250(such)-250(affirmation.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Next:)-440(there)-345(are)-345(numerous)-345(abnormal)-345(conditions)-345(to)-345(which)-344(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(mind)-276(is)-275(unquestionably)-276(subject.)-327(Who)-275(will)-276(venture)-275(to)-276(affirm)-275(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-297(has)-297(penetrated)-297(to)-297(their)-296(depths,)-309(or)-297(ascertained)-297(the)-297(laws)-296(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(regulate)-197(their)-197(action?)-233(These)-197(have)-197(a)-198(most)-197(important)-197(bearing)-197(on)-197(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(present)-324(subject.)-472(They)-324(are)-324(best)-324(designated)-324(by)-324(the)-324(term)-323(phrenzy.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Their)-327(aspect)-327(is)-327(very)-328(vari)1(ed.)-482(They)-327(differ)-327(in)-327(many)-327(respects)-327(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mania,)-392(though)-364(they)-364(are)-364(closely)-364(allied)-364(to)-364(it.)-592(They)-364(are)-363(confined)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-293(no)-292(one)-293(race)-293(of)-293(men,)-303(but)-293(are)-292(co-extensive)-293(with)-293(human)-292(nature.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(They)-359(were)-359(prevalent)-359(in)-359(the)-359(ancient)-359(world,)-386(and)-359(connected)-359(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(various)-292(forms)-292(of)-292(religious)-293(belief.)-376(They)-292(display)-292(themselves)-292(with)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1143 0 obj <<
/Length 4562      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(245)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(peculiar)-372(violence)-372(in)-372(the)-371(religious)-372(rites)-372(of)-372(savages.)-616(In)-371(Oriental)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(countries)-226(at)-226(the)-226(present)-226(day,)-231(they)-226(frequently)-226(manifest)-225(themselves)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-258(assume)-257(a)-258(great)-257(variety)-258(of)-257(aspects.)-273(Examples)-257(might)-258(be)-257(easily)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adduced.)-311(The)-270(phrenzied)-270(fanatic)-270(often)-271(presents)-270(indications)-270(of)-270(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mind)-424(being)-425(acted)-424(on)-425(by)-424(an)-425(overwhelming)-424(external)-424(influence;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-410(when)-410(under)-410(the)-410(influence)-410(of)-410(the)-410(rites)-410(of)-410(a)-410(degraded)-409(reli-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gion,)-258(the)-256(symptoms)-257(present)-256(no)-257(little)-256(resemblance)-257(to)-256(those)-256(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accompanied)-250(demoniacal)-250(possession.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-360(have)-361(no)-360(wish)-361(to)-360(affirm)-361(that)-360(such)-361(phenomena)-360(must)-361(be)-360(due)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-359(an)-360(action)-359(of)-359(this)-360(kind,)-386(but)-360(to)-359(draw)-359(attention)-360(to)-359(the)-359(fact)-359(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(we)-340(are)-339(ignorant)-340(of)-339(the)-340(power)-339(in)-340(which)-339(they)-340(originate,)-362(and)-339(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-354(being)-354(the)-354(case,)-380(it)-354(is)-354(quite)-354(possible)-354(that)-354(their)-354(most)-353(violent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-324(terrible)-324(forms)-324(may)-324(be)-324(aroused)-324(by)-324(the)-324(influence)-324(of)-324(a)-324(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(external)-245(to)-246(the)-245(mind)-245(itself.)-249(Equally)-245(ignorant)-245(are)-246(we)-245(of)-245(the)-245(causes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-261(even)-261(their)-260(milder)-261(manifestations.)-282(Whatever)-261(may)-261(be)-261(the)-260(hopes)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-280(are)-281(entertained)-280(of)-280(the)-280(future)-281(triumphs)-280(of)-280(science,)-288(it)-280(is)-280(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(too)-364(much)-364(to)-364(assert,)-393(that)-364(it)-364(has)-364(not)-364(yet)-364(reduced)-364(these)-364(abnormal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conditions)-243(of)-244(the)-243(mind)-243(to)-243(any)-244(thing)-243(like)-243(a)-243(scientific)-244(law,)-244(and)-243(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-299(has)-298(not)-299(succeeded)-597(in)-299(tracing)-298(the)-299(phenomena)-298(to)-299(the)-298(exclusive)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([279])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(operation)-349(of)-348(a)-349(force)-349(acting)-349(within)-348(the)-349(mind)-349(itself.)-546(In)-349(truth)-348(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mental)-322(science)-323(is)-322(ignorant)-322(of)-322(their)-323(causes:)-394(and)-323(for)-322(aught)-322(that)-322(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-307(affirm)-308(to)-307(the)-307(contrary,)-322(many)-307(of)-308(them)-307(may)-307(be)-308(due)-307(to)-307(causes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(human,)-504(superhuman,)-505(or)-453(a)-453(combination)-454(of)-453(the)-454(two.)-860(In)-453(cases)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(where)-259(we)-258(are)-259(profoundly)-258(ignorant,)-261(dogmatical)-259(assertions)-258(should)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-354(carefully)-354(avoided.)-561(While)-353(such)-354(phenomena)-354(are)-354(incapable)-353(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(explanation)-323(by)-322(the)-323(action)-323(of)-323(known)-322(mental)-323(forces,)-341(the)-322(students)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-346(mental)-347(science)-346(are)-346(not)-346(justified)-347(in)-346(affirming)-346(that)-346(possession)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contradicts)-250(its)-250(known)-250(truths.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-405(fully)-406(admit,)-444(however,)-445(that)-405(there)-406(is)-405(a)-406(system)-405(of)-405(professed)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(mental)-258(science,)-261(which,)-260(if)-258(its)-259(truth)-258(could)-258(be)-259(proved,)-260(would)-258(estab-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lish)-336(the)-336(fact)-336(that)-336(possession)-336(was)-336(impossible.)-508(I)-336(need)-336(hardly)-336(say)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-300(I)-299(allude)-299(to)-300(that)-299(which)-300(affirms)-299(that)-300(thought)-299(is)-300(the)-299(result)-300(of)-299(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(function)-210(of)-209(the)-209(brain,)-218(and)-210(nothing)-209(else.)-237(According)-209(to)-209(the)-210(views)-209(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-238(philosophers,)-241(the)-238(brain)-238(secretes)-239(thought)-238(as)-238(a)-238(gland)-238(secretes)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1147 0 obj <<
/Length 4623      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(246)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(its)-309(own)-309(peculiar)-309(secretion.)-426(Until)-309(this)-309(philosophy)-309(has)-308(succeeded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-243(proving)-243(the)-244(truth)-243(of)-243(its)-243(first)-243(principles,)-245(it)-243(is)-243(useless)-243(to)-243(consider)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-250(bearing)-250(on)-250(this)-250(particular)-250(question.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(There)-290(is)-289(another)-290(abnormal)-290(mental)-289(condition,)-300(the)-290(existence)-289(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(which)-269(is)-268(unquestionable,)-274(and)-268(which)-269(has)-269(a)-268(close)-269(connection)-268(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-386(present)-386(question,)-419(namely,)-420(the)-386(ecstatic)-386(state.)-657(The)-386(forms)-385(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-188(this)-187(has)-188(manifested)-188(itself)-187(have)-188(been)-188(extremely)-187(various,)-200(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-278(is)-278(impossible)-278(for)-278(any)-278(one)-278(to)-278(assert)-278(that)-278(our)-278(mental)-278(philosophy)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-335(fully)-334(fathomed)-335(them,)-356(and)-335(has)-334(succeeded)-335(in)-335(assigning)-334(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-272(forces)-271(originating)-272(within)-272(the)-271(mind)-272(itself.)-315(On)-272(the)-271(contrary)-272(it)-271(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-257(too)-257(much)-256(to)-257(affirm)-257(that)-257(it)-257(has)-256(as)-257(yet)-257(wholly)-257(failed)-257(to)-256(analyze)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(its)-340(nature,)-363(or)-340(to)-340(account)-340(for)-340(the)-340(abnormal)-340(powers)-340(displayed)-340(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-306(mind)-306(when)-305(in)-306(this)-306(condition.)-417(In)-306(the)-306(ancient)-306(world)-306(this)-305(state)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-351(mind)-350(was)-351(closely)-350(connected)-351(with)-350(the)-351(manifestations)-350(of)-701(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([280])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(prophetic)-329(power,)-349(the)-329(reality)-329(of)-329(which)-329(was)-329(recognized)-328(by)-329(many)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-328(its)-328(philosophers.)-483(It)-328(will)-327(of)-328(course)-328(be)-328(observed)-327(that)-328(I)-328(am)-327(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(speaking)-185(of)-186(this)-185(power)-185(as)-185(it)-186(existed)-185(in)-185(the)-185(Jewish)-186(church,)-198(but)-185(of)-185(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposed)-337(manifestations)-337(in)-337(the)-337(heathen)-337(world.)-511(Similar)-336(ecstatic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(states)-425(have)-426(frequently)-425(displayed)-425(themselves)-426(in)-425(modern)-425(times.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(When)-303(in)-304(this)-303(condition)-304(the)-303(mind)-303(is)-304(especially)-303(liable)-304(to)-303(be)-303(acted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-223(by)-222(external)-223(influences.)-241(Is)-222(it)-223(possible,)-228(I)-223(ask,)-228(in)-222(the)-223(present)-222(state)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-359(our)-359(mental)-359(philosophy,)-386(to)-359(assert)-359(that)-359(we)-359(know)-359(their)-358(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-352(the)-353(forces)-352(which)-353(produce)-352(them?)-558(The)-352(ecstatic)-353(in)-352(union)-352(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-378(phrenzied)-379(state)-378(of)-379(the)-378(mind)-379(was)-378(apparently)-379(the)-378(condition)-378(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-303(Delphian)-304(priestess)-303(when)-303(she)-303(delivered)-304(oracles)-303(to)-303(those)-303(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consulted)-239(her.)-246(According)-238(to)-239(all)-238(the)-239(accounts)-239(that)-238(we)-239(possess,)-240(she)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presented)-376(the)-376(appearance)-377(of)-376(being)-376(subject)-376(to)-376(an)-376(overpowering)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(external)-270(influence.)-311(Every)-270(other)-270(description)-271(which)-270(we)-270(possess)-270(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-251(manifestation)-251(of)-251(this)-251(prophetic)-251(power,)-251(\050and)-251(we)-251(have)-250(several\051)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(describes)-431(it)-432(as)-431(presenting)-431(phenomena)-432(closely)-431(allied)-431(to)-431(raving)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(madness,)-443(an)-404(influence)-404(of)-405(some)-404(kind)-404(apparently)-404(overpowering)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-274(prophet's)-275(personality.)-323(Until)-274(the)-274(forces)-275(which)-274(produced)-274(these)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(phenomena)-257(in)-256(the)-257(ancient)-257(world,)-258(and)-257(the)-256(somewhat)-257(similar)-256(ones)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-313(have)-313(been)-313(manifested)-313(in)-313(modern)-313(times,)-329(can)-313(be)-312(shown)-313(to)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1151 0 obj <<
/Length 4474      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(247)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(owe)-334(their)-335(origin)-334(to)-334(forces)-335(originating)-334(in)-334(the)-334(mind)-335(itself,)-355(and)-334(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nothing)-354(else,)-380(it)-354(is)-355(absurd)-354(to)-354(affirm)-354(that)-354(such)-354(a)-354(phenomenon)-354(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession)-278(is)-279(in)-278(contradiction)-278(to)-278(our)-279(scientific)-278(knowledge)-278(of)-278(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(human)-250(mind.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(There)-370(is)-371(another)-370(point)-371(which)-370(demands)-371(our)-370(attention,)-400(name-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(ly,)-454(the)-413(close)-413(connection)-413(between)-413(the)-413(extreme)-413(forms)-412(of)-413(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wickedness,)-260(and)-258(madness.)-274(It)-258(is)-258(an)-258(unquestionable)-258(fact)-258(that)-257(noth-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ing)-334(is)-334(more)-334(difficult)-334(than)-334(to)-334(draw)-334(the)-334(precise)-334(line)-334(where)-333(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wickedness)-392(ends,)-426(and)-392(madness)-391(begins.)-675(In)-391(their)-392(great)-391(outlines)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-259(are)-258(easily)-259(distinguishable,)-261(but)-259(in)-259(the)-258(more)-259(advanced)-259(stages)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([281])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(of)-222(moral)-223(evil,)-227(the)-223(one)-222(passes)-222(into)-222(the)-223(other)-222(by)-222(insensible)-222(degrees.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(So)-394(difficult)-395(is)-394(it)-395(to)-394(lay)-394(down)-395(the)-394(precise)-395(line)-394(which)-394(separates)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them,)-383(that)-356(scientific)-357(men)-356(are)-357(not)-356(wanting,)-383(who)-357(affirm)-356(that)-356(ev-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ery)-420(extreme)-421(case)-420(of)-420(moral)-421(wickedness)-420(is)-420(a)-421(species)-420(of)-420(mania.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Consistently)-340(with)-340(this)-341(theory)-340(frequent)-340(efforts)-340(are)-340(made)-340(to)-340(save)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-397(most)-396(abandoned)-397(criminals)-397(from)-396(the)-397(consequences)-397(of)-396(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(crimes.)-433(If)-311(the)-311(principle)-312(is)-311(correct,)-326(it)-311(is)-311(impossible)-311(not)-311(to)-311(assign)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lesser)-285(degrees)-285(of)-284(moral)-285(evil)-285(to)-285(the)-285(same)-284(cause.)-355(Such)-285(a)-284(principle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(logically)-396(leads)-395(to)-396(the)-395(denial)-396(of)-396(any)-395(distinction)-396(between)-395(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-284(physical)-283(action.)-351(Happily)-283(however,)-292(although)-284(this)-283(conclusion)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-364(one)-365(which)-364(has)-365(been)-364(arrived)-364(at)-365(by)-364(a)-365(considerable)-364(number)-364(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physicists,)-216(it)-208(is)-208(one)-208(which)-207(the)-208(common)-208(sense)-208(of)-208(mankind)-207(steadily)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(refuses)-378(to)-377(accept.)-633(It)-378(is)-377(sufficient)-378(for)-378(the)-377(present)-378(purpose,)-409(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(extreme)-306(forms)-306(of)-306(moral)-307(evil)-306(shade)-306(off)-306(into)-306(mania)-306(by)-306(insensible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(degrees;)-236(and)-228(that)-229(ultimately)-228(they)-229(are)-228(capable)-229(of)-228(producing)-228(insan-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ity.)-371(If)-290(insanity)-290(can)-291(be)-290(produced)-290(by)-290(moral)-291(causes,)-300(it)-290(follows)-290(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-287(superhuman)-287(influence)-287(powerful)-287(for)-287(evil,)-296(acting)-287(on)-287(a)-287(degraded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-245(nature,)-246(may)-245(be)-245(attended)-245(with)-245(a)-245(similar)-245(result,)-246(and)-244(produce)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-250(a)-250(phenomenon)-250(as)-250(possession.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-263(further:)-275(while)-263(madness)-263(is)-263(produced)-263(by)-263(physical)-262(causes,)-267(it)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-268(a)-269(certain)-268(fact)-269(that)-268(it)-268(is)-269(frequently)-268(occasioned)-269(by)-268(causes)-268(purely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mental.)-696(Of)-399(this)-399(the)-398(instances)-399(are)-399(innumerable.)-696(These)-398(mental)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(causes)-287(react)-287(on)-287(the)-286(brain)-287(and)-287(the)-287(nervous)-287(system;)-305(and)-287(thus)-286(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(superinduce)-248(disease)-247(on)-248(those)-247(parts)-248(of)-248(our)-247(bodily)-248(organization)-247(by)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1155 0 obj <<
/Length 4719      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(248)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(means)-299(of)-299(which)-299(the)-299(mind)-299(exercises)-299(its)-299(powers.)-397(Still)-299(the)-299(disease)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(itself)-298(originates)-298(in)-298(causes)-298(that)-298(are)-298(not)-298(seated)-298(in)-298(the)-298(body,)-310(but)-298(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-258(mind.)-272(The)-258(mind)-257(is)-258(therefore)-257(capable)-258(of)-257(acting)-258(powerfully)-257(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-236(bodily)-236(frame.)-245(If)-236(therefore)-236(possession)-236(be)-236(viewed)-236(as)-236(the)-236(action)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-284(one)-284(mind)-284(on)-284(another,)-292(there)-284(is)-284(no)-284(reason)-284(why)-284(it)-284(should)-284(not)-283(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(able)-334(to)-334(superinduce)-334(those)-334(forms)-334(of)-668(bodily)-334(derangement)-334(which)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([282])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(exhibited)-346(themselves)-346(in)-347(the)-346(demoniacs)-346(by)-346(the)-346(simple)-346(action)-346(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-212(mind)-212(upon)-212(the)-212(body.)-237(The)-212(mental)-212(causes)-212(capable)-212(of)-212(producing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mania)-243(are,)-244(as)-242(we)-243(know,)-244(of)-243(a)-242(varied)-243(description;)-245(and)-243(among)-242(them)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-223(the)-223(action)-223(and)-222(influence)-223(which)-223(one)-223(mind)-223(is)-223(capable)-223(of)-222(exerting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-341(another.)-525(As,)-364(therefore,)-364(in)-342(certain)-341(states)-342(of)-341(our)-342(minds,)-364(or)-341(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-335(nervous)-334(system,)-356(mania)-334(with)-335(all)-334(its)-335(results)-334(can)-335(be)-334(produced)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-262(the)-261(simple)-262(action)-262(of)-261(mind)-262(on)-261(mind,)-265(and)-262(through)-261(the)-262(action)-261(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-319(mind)-318(disorder)-319(may)-318(be)-318(produced)-319(in)-318(our)-319(bodily)-318(organization,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(there)-238(can)-238(be)-238(no)-238(reason)-238(why)-238(possession)-238(with)-238(all)-238(its)-238(attendant)-237(phe-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nomena)-281(should)-280(not)-281(originate)-281(in)-280(similar)-281(causes.)-342(There)-281(is)-280(nothing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-341(imply)-341(that)-340(the)-341(superhuman)-341(agency)-341(manifested)-341(in)-340(possession)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-346(directly)-345(exerted)-346(on)-345(the)-346(body)-345(of)-346(the)-345(possessed.)-537(An)-345(agency)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-273(was)-273(entirely)-273(mental)-273(was)-273(fully)-273(adequate)-273(to)-273(produce)-273(all)-272(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(phenomena)-250(with)-250(which)-250(it)-250(was)-250(accompanied.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(In)-319(cases)-319(of)-319(mania)-319(produced)-319(by)-319(mental)-319(action)-319(the)-319(removal)-318(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-354(exciting)-354(cause)-355(is)-354(the)-354(precondition)-354(of)-355(its)-354(cure,)-380(and)-354(in)-354(many)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(cases)-278(effects)-277(it.)-334(Similarly,)-284(in)-278(cases)-278(of)-277(possession)-278(the)-278(removal)-277(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(exciting)-250(cause)-250(would)-250(produce)-250(similar)-250(results.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-324(follows,)-344(therefore,)-343(from)-324(the)-325(foregoing)-324(considerations,)-343(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-328(allegation)-328(that)-328(the)-327(possessions)-328(described)-328(in)-328(the)-328(New)-327(Testa-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ment)-257(are)-257(incredible,)-258(because)-257(they)-257(contradict)-257(the)-257(known)-257(truths)-256(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mental)-250(science,)-250(is)-250(disproved.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-277(question)-277(really)-277(resolves)-277(itself)-277(into)-277(the)-277(following)-277(one:)-303(Do)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(evil)-360(beings,)-386(other)-360(than)-359(men,)-387(exist)-360(in)-359(the)-360(universe?)-578(Or,)-387(if)-359(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exist,)-237(is)-235(it)-234(credible)-234(that)-234(they)-234(are)-235(allowed)-234(to)-234(interfere)-234(in)-234(the)-234(affairs)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-316(men?)-446(This)-316(question)-315(we)-316(have)-315(already)-316(considered)-315(in)-316(a)-315(former)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(chapter,)-399(and)-370(we)-369(have)-370(arrived)-369(at)-369(the)-370(conclusion)-369(that)-370(if)-369(we)-369(free)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ourselves)-230(from)-229(the)-229(trammels)-230(of)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 137.95 0 Td [(\340)-229(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 35.923 0 Td [(theories,)-467(and)-230(judge)-229(only)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -246.628 0 Td [([283])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1160 0 obj <<
/Length 4527      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(249)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(by)-215(the)-216(facts)-215(of)-215(the)-215(universe)-216(as)-215(it)-215(exists,)-223(neither)-215(their)-215(existence)-215(nor)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-250(intervention)-250(in)-250(human)-250(affairs)-250(is)-250(contrary)-250(to)-250(our)-250(reason.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(Two)-189(things,)-202(however,)-202(must)-189(be)-190(steadily)-189(kept)-189(in)-190(mind.)-230(First:)-220(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(if)-214(such)-214(interventions)-214(in)-214(human)-214(affairs)-214(are)-214(facts,)-221(the)-214(agency)-214(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-432(be)-433(exerted)-432(is)-433(only)-432(a)-432(permitted)-433(agency,)-478(and)-432(only)-432(capable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-339(being)-340(exerted)-339(in)-339(subordination)-340(to)-339(the)-339(divine)-340(purposes)-339(in)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(government)-326(of)-327(the)-326(universe.)-479(A)-327(large)-326(number)-327(of)-326(the)-326(difficulties)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-267(which)-267(the)-267(subject)-268(is)-267(attended)-267(have)-267(originated)-267(in)-267(the)-267(wholly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inaccurate)-295(idea)-296(that)-295(a)-295(power)-295(is)-295(attributed)-296(in)-295(the)-295(New)-295(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-339(Satan,)-362(of)-339(interfering)-340(both)-339(in)-340(the)-339(material)-339(and)-340(the)-339(moral)-339(uni-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(verse)-293(at)-293(his)-292(own)-293(will)-293(and)-293(pleasure.)-378(This,)-303(however,)-304(is)-292(altogether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contrary)-438(to)-438(the)-438(fact.)-814(Whatever)-438(power)-438(is)-438(attributed)-438(to)-438(him)-438(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(an)-299(entirely)-298(permitted)-299(one,)-311(and)-299(exercised)-298(in)-299(subordination)-299(to)-298(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(general)-241(purposes)-240(of)-240(God.)-247(Secondly,)-243(that)-240(although)-241(the)-240(disorder)-240(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-269(moral)-269(world)-269(might)-269(lead)-269(us)-269(to)-269(suspect)-269(the)-269(presence)-269(of)-269(an)-269(evil)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agency,)-278(different)-273(from)-273(that)-272(of)-273(man;)-284(yet)-273(as)-272(it)-273(is)-273(not)-272(a)-273(visible)-272(one,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-321(confined)-320(to)-321(the)-321(regions)-320(of)-321(the)-321(mind,)-338(it)-321(is)-320(one)-321(which)-320(cannot)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(come)-375(under)-376(our)-375(distinct)-376(observation,)-406(and)-376(could)-375(therefore)-375(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(become)-250(known)-250(to)-250(us)-250(by)-250(revelation.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(One)-365(more)-365(difficulty)-366(has)-365(to)-365(be)-365(considered.)-596(It)-365(is)-365(alleged)-365(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(possession)-290(never)-290(takes)-290(place)-290(now.)-370(It)-290(is)-290(therefore)-290(inferred)-290(that)-290(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(never)-250(took)-250(place)-250(at)-250(all.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(I)-247(reply)-247(first,)-248(if)-247(we)-247(grant)-247(that)-247(demoniacal)-247(action,)-248(in)-247(the)-247(form)-247(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(possession)-339(has)-340(now)-339(ceased,)-361(it)-340(by)-339(no)-339(means)-340(follows)-339(that)-339(it)-339(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-218(once)-219(real.)-239(The)-219(objection)-218(overlooks)-218(the)-219(fact)-218(that)-219(its)-218(action)-218(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-346(permitted)-345(one;)-394(and)-346(could)-345(only)-346(be)-345(exercised)-346(within)-346(the)-345(limits)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assigned)-328(to)-328(it.)-483(There)-328(may)-328(have)-328(been)-328(reasons)-328(at)-328(the)-328(time)-328(of)-327(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Advent)-206(why)-207(the)-206(exercise)-206(of)-207(a)-206(Satanic)-206(agency)-207(should)-206(be)-206(permitted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-288(that)-288(particular)-287(period)-288(to)-288(a)-288(greater)-288(extent)-287(than)-288(it)-288(ever)-288(has)-287(been)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(before)-250(or)-250(since.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([284])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -14.776 Td [(Secondly:)-346(certain)-298(moral)-298(and)-298(physical)-298(conditions)-298(were)-297(neces-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(sary)-328(for)-328(its)-328(exercise.)-485(These)-328(may)-328(be)-328(no)-328(longer)-329(in)-328(existence,)-347(but)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-180(may)-179(have)-180(passed)-180(away)-180(with)-179(many)-180(other)-180(abnormal)-179(conditions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(human)-250(nature)-250(which)-250(existed)-250(in)-250(the)-250(ancient)-250(world.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1165 0 obj <<
/Length 4912      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(250)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(Thirdly:)-245(it)-241(is)-242(not)-241(possible)-241(to)-241(affirm)-241(with)-241(certainty)-241(that,)-242(even)-241(at)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-293(present)-293(day,)-304(no)-293(supernatural)-293(agencies)-293(bearing)-293(an)-292(analogy)-293(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession,)-293(are)-284(exerted)-285(on)-284(the)-284(mind.)-353(This)-285(will)-284(be)-284(only)-284(possible,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-247(all)-247(those)-247(abnormal)-247(phenomena)-247(which)-247(manifest)-246(themselves)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-316(connection)-315(with)-316(various)-315(debased)-315(forms)-316(of)-315(religion)-316(and)-315(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cases)-387(of)-387(phrenzied)-387(excitement)-387(can)-387(be)-387(traced)-387(to)-387(known)-386(forces,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(originating)-250(solely)-250(in)-250(the)-250(mind)-250(itself.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(There)-441(is)-441(one)-441(further)-441(objection)-441(which)-441(requires)-441(a)-441(brief)-440(con-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(sideration.)-717(It)-406(is)-405(urged)-406(that)-405(the)-406(writers)-406(of)-405(the)-406(New)-405(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entertained)-374(the)-374(belief,)-405(that)-374(diseases)-374(were)-374(generally)-373(occasioned)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-401(demoniacal)-401(action,)-439(quite)-401(independently)-402(of)-401(possession;)-476(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-306(this)-306(belief)-307(has)-306(received)-306(the)-306(sanction)-306(of)-307(our)-306(Lord.)-418(One)-306(case)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(only)-259(is)-258(alleged)-259(in)-259(proof)-258(of)-259(this,)-261(that)-258(of)-259(the)-259(woman)-258(with)-259(the)-258(spirit)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-396(infirmity.)-689(She)-396(was)-396(no)-396(demoniac,)-433(but)-396(an)-396(ordinary)-396(diseased)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(person,)-356(and)-335(the)-335(disease)-335(is)-334(asserted)-335(to)-335(have)-335(been)-335(occasioned)-334(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demoniacal)-250(action.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(I)-271(reply,)-277(that)-271(considering)-271(the)-271(large)-272(number)-271(of)-271(diseases)-271(of)-271(vari-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ous)-270(kinds)-270(mentioned)-270(in)-271(the)-270(New)-270(Testament,)-275(in)-270(none)-270(of)-270(which)-270(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(there)-291(any)-292(allusion)-291(to)-292(demoniacal)-291(agency)-291(as)-292(their)-291(cause,)-302(a)-291(single)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(example)-206(is)-206(a)-206(narrow)-207(foundation)-206(on)-206(which)-206(to)-206(build)-206(the)-206(affirmation)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-257(the)-257(followers)-257(of)-257(our)-256(Lord)-257(held)-257(such)-257(a)-257(theory)-257(as)-257(to)-257(the)-256(origin)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-304(disease)-303(in)-304(general.)-411(I)-304(admit)-304(that)-303(disorganization)-304(of)-304(the)-303(bodily)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(functions)-216(is)-217(mentioned)-216(among)-217(the)-216(phenomena)-216(of)-217(possession.)-238(But)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-322(differs)-321(widely)-322(from)-321(a)-321(bodily)-322(evil)-321(superinduced)-322(without)-321(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agency)-218(of)-217(possession.)-239(Let)-218(us)-217(inquire)-218(whether)-217(the)-218(special)-217(instance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affords)-250(any)-250(justification)-250(for)-250(this)-250(wide)-250(assertion.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([285])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -14.777 Td [(The)-391(Evangelist)-391(states)-391(that)-392(the)-391(woman)-391(was)-391(bowed)-391(down)-391(by)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(a)-336(spirit)-336(of)-336(infirmity,)-358(and)-336(could)-336(in)-337(no)-336(wise)-336(lift)-336(herself)-336(up.)-508(Here)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-346(is)-347(just)-346(as)-347(absurd)-346(to)-347(fasten)-346(on)-346(him)-347(the)-346(intention)-347(to)-346(describe)-346(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(scientific)-187(fact,)-199(as)-187(when)-187(on)-187(another)-186(occasion)-187(it)-187(is)-187(said)-187(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 243.419 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(power)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.523 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(went)-308(out)-309(of)-308(our)-309(Lord)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.81 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(and)-308(healed)-309(them)-308(all.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 89.775 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.208 0 Td [(The)-308(one)-309(stands)-308(on)]TJ -199.637 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(same)-250(ground)-250(as)-250(the)-250(other.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(In)-249(effecting)-250(the)-250(cure,)-249(our)-250(Lord)-249(uses)-250(the)-249(words,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 204.446 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Woman,)-250(thou)]TJ -221.245 -13.549 Td [(art)-376(loosed)-376(from)-376(thine)-375(infirmity.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 140.939 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.943 0 Td [(Here)-376(there)-376(is)-376(no)-375(reference)-376(to)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1169 0 obj <<
/Length 4692      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(251)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(Satanic)-332(agency)-331(whatever.)-495(The)-331(only)-332(mention)-331(of)-332(it)-331(occurs)-332(in)-331(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(argument)-340(with)-339(the)-340(ruler)-339(of)-340(the)-339(synagogue)-340(on)-339(the)-340(lawfulness)-339(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(effecting)-296(such)-296(cures)-296(on)-296(the)-296(Sabbath)-296(day.)-389(The)-296(words)-296(are,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 252.758 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Thou)]TJ -257.601 -13.549 Td [(hypocrite,)-239(ought)-236(not)-236(this)-236(woman,)-239(who)-236(is)-236(a)-236(daughter)-236(of)-236(Abraham,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(whom)-331(Satan)-330(hath)-331(bound,)-351(lo,)-350(these)-331(eighteen)-331(years,)-350(to)-331(be)-330(loosed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-250(this)-250(bond)-250(on)-250(the)-250(Sabbath)-250(day?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 155.138 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -143.182 -16.004 Td [(These)-346(words)-345(are)-346(addressed)-345(to)-346(the)-346(ruler)-345(in)-346(answer)-345(to)-346(the)-345(ob-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(jection)-384(that)-383(our)-384(Lord)-383(was)-384(no)-384(prophet,)-417(because)-383(he)-384(effected)-383(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cures)-274(on)-274(the)-275(Sabbath.)-322(If)-274(so,)-280(as)-275(the)-274(reality)-274(of)-274(the)-274(miracle)-274(was)-274(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(denied,)-362(it)-339(was)-339(intended)-339(to)-340(be)-339(implied)-339(that)-340(it)-339(had)-339(been)-339(wrought)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-394(the)-393(power)-394(of)-394(Satan,)-429(of)-394(which)-394(the)-393(violation)-394(of)-394(the)-393(Sabbath)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-332(the)-332(proof.)-495(The)-332(real)-332(point)-331(of)-332(controversy)-332(therefore)-332(was)-331(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lawfulness)-194(of)-194(effecting)-194(cures)-194(on)-194(this)-194(day,)-205(not)-194(the)-194(Satanic)-194(origin)-194(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-286(complaint.)-359(Was)-286(there)-286(any)-286(conceivable)-286(reason)-286(why)-286(our)-286(Lord)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-223(not)-222(discuss)-223(the)-222(point)-223(with)-222(the)-222(ruler)-223(on)-222(his)-223(own)-222(principles?)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Why)-307(was)-307(it)-308(necessary)-307(to)-307(raise)-307(a)-307(wholly)-307(different)-308(issue,)-321(viz.)-421(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Satanic)-232(or)-232(non-Satanic)-231(origin)-232(of)-232(the)-232(disease,)-235(instead)-232(of)-231(confining)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-277(strictly)-277(to)-276(the)-277(point,)-284(which)-277(was)-276(the)-277(all-important)-277(one,)-284(that)-276(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(curing)-311(this)-310(woman)-311(on)-311(the)-311(Sabbath)-310(day)-311(was)-311(so)-310(far)-311(from)-311(being)-310(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proof)-237(that)-238(He)-237(did)-238(not)-237(come)-238(from)-237(God,)-240(that)-238(it)-237(was)-238(a)-237(strong)-237(reason)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(for)-347(believing)-346(that)-347(He)-347(did)-346(so?)-540(To)-347(have)-347(entered)-346(on)-347(a)-346(discussion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-439(to)-438(what)-439(was)-438(the)-439(cause)-877(of)-439(the)-438(complaint,)-486(would)-439(not)-438(only)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([286])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(have)-341(diverted)-341(attention)-340(from)-341(the)-341(real)-341(question,)-363(but)-341(would)-340(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(introduced)-451(one)-451(wholly)-452(foreign)-451(to)-451(the)-451(purposes)-451(of)-451(His)-451(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mission.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Two)-308(suppositions)-307(only)-308(are)-307(possible)-308(respecting)-308(possession.)-423(It)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(must)-356(have)-357(been)-356(either)-356(a)-357(form)-356(of)-356(madness)-357(produced)-356(by)-356(natural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(causes,)-246(or)-245(a)-244(manifestation)-245(of)-245(superhuman)-245(power.)-248(As)-245(the)-245(facts)-244(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-220(a)-220(judgment)-220(can)-220(be)-220(formed)-220(are)-220(meagre,)-226(I)-220(have)-220(not)-220(ventured)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-234(determine)-234(which)-234(of)-233(these)-234(two)-234(theories)-234(is)-234(alone)-234(consistent)-233(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-236(facts)-236(and)-237(phenomena)-236(of)-236(the)-236(New)-237(Testament.)-245(I)-236(have)-236(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taken)-289(either)-289(alternative,)-298(and)-289(shown,)-298(that)-289(neither)-289(does)-289(the)-288(theory)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-306(it)-306(was)-306(mania)-306(interfere)-306(with)-306(the)-306(claims)-306(of)-306(the)-306(Gospels)-306(to)-306(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accepted)-301(as)-302(historical)-301(documents,)-314(nor)-301(is)-302(the)-301(language)-301(attributed)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1173 0 obj <<
/Length 553       
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(252)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(to)-206(our)-207(Lord)-206(contrary)-207(to)-206(the)-207(truthfulness)-206(of)-207(His)-206(character;)-221(nor)-206(does)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-285(supposition)-284(that)-285(it)-284(was)-284(due)-285(to)-284(superhuman)-285(causes)-284(contradict)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(established)-250(truths)-250(of)-250(mental)-250(science.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -27.371 Td [([287])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1181 0 obj <<
/Length 3790      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-251(XIII.)-251(The)-251(Alleged)-251(Credulity)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Of)-250(The)-250(Followers)-250(Of)-250(Jesus.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -35.158 Td [(The)-180(allegation)-180(that)-179(the)-180(followers)-180(of)-179(Jesus,)-194(and)-180(the)-180(early)-179(Christians)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(generally,)-331(were)-315(a)-315(body)-314(of)-315(intensely)-315(credulous)-315(and)-314(superstitious)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(people,)-369(may)-346(be)-345(considered)-345(as)-346(not)-345(only)-345(the)-346(stronghold)-345(of)-345(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-168(impugn)-169(the)-168(historical)-168(character)-168(of)-169(the)-168(Gospels,)-185(but)-168(also)-168(as)-168(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(arsenal)-240(from)-239(which)-240(they)-240(draw)-239(no)-240(small)-240(number)-239(of)-240(their)-239(weapons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-271(attack.)-314(A)-271(credulity)-272(which)-271(knew)-271(no)-272(limits)-271(is)-271(liberally)-271(ascribed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-285(them)-284(as)-285(showing)-284(how)-285(every)-285(miraculous)-284(narrative)-285(might)-284(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-318(invented.)-454(They)-317(have)-318(even)-318(been)-318(credited)-318(with)-318(a)-318(facility)-317(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inventing)-314(fictions,)-331(and)-314(then)-315(deluding)-314(themselves)-315(into)-314(the)-314(belief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-304(they)-304(were)-303(facts)-304(which)-304(they)-304(had)-304(actually)-303(witnessed.)-412(Thus)-303(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-344(been)-344(asserted)-344(that)-344(it)-344(was)-344(their)-344(firm)-344(belief)-344(that)-344(the)-344(Messiah)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ought)-228(to)-227(have)-228(wrought)-227(miracles;)-235(that)-227(Jesus)-228(himself)-227(may)-228(not)-227(even)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-241(professed)-241(to)-241(perform)-241(them;)-244(but)-241(that)-241(the)-241(fervid)-241(imaginations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-362(His)-361(followers)-362(invented)-362(a)-361(set)-362(of)-362(miracles,)-389(attributed)-362(them)-361(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Him,)-294(and)-285(ended)-285(with)-285(the)-286(belief)-285(that)-285(they)-285(had)-285(seen)-285(Him)-285(perform)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them.)-230(On)-190(the)-190(other)-191(hand,)-202(whenever)-190(these)-190(objectors)-190(are)-190(pressed)-190(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-260(difficulty)-260(in)-260(accounting)-260(for)-260(the)-260(origin)-260(of)-260(particular)-260(phenomena)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-359(the)-359(Gospels,)-387(they)-359(retire)-359(on)-359(the)-360(credulity)-359(of)-359(the)-359(followers)-359(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Jesus)-225(as)-225(into)-224(a)-225(kind)-225(of)-225(citadel,)-229(in)-225(which)-225(they)-225(consider)-224(themselves)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-258(strongly)-257(entrenched)-258(that)-258(they)-257(may)-258(defy)-257(every)-258(attack.)-273(There)-257(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(also)-332(another)-331(important)-332(purpose)-331(which)-332(it)-331(is)-332(made)-332(to)-331(serve.)-495(It)-331(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(asserted)-267(that)-268(it)-267(renders)-267(worthless)-267(the)-535(testimony)-267(of)-267(the)-267(followers)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([288])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(Jesus)-250(as)-250(to)-250(the)-250(actual)-250(occurrence)-250(of)-250(miracles.)]TJ 11.956 -14.097 Td [(The)-250(allegation)-250(takes)-250(two)-250(forms:)]TJ 0 -14.096 Td [(1st.)-460(That)-320(the)-321(followers)-320(of)-320(Jesus)-320(were)-320(the)-320(prey)-320(of)-320(a)-320(credulity)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(and)-353(superstition)-352(which)-353(greatly)-352(exceeded)-352(the)-353(limits)-352(of)-353(the)-352(ordi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nary)-314(credulity)-315(of)-314(mankind;)-346(and)-314(that)-315(therefore)-314(the)-314(value)-314(of)-314(their)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1185 0 obj <<
/Length 4658      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(254)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(historical)-250(testimony)-250(is)-250(destroyed.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(2nd.)-498(That)-333(the)-332(ordinary)-333(credulity)-333(of)-332(mankind)-333(with)-333(respect)-332(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(the)-220(occurrence)-221(of)-220(supernatural)-220(events)-220(is)-221(so)-220(great)-220(and)-220(widespread,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-308(to)-307(render)-308(the)-307(invention)-308(of)-308(miraculous)-307(narratives)-308(easy,)-322(and)-307(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(destroy)-250(the)-250(credit)-250(of)-250(all)-250(narratives)-250(containing)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(I)-291(propose)-291(to)-290(consider)-291(these)-291(subjects)-291(in)-291(this)-291(and)-291(the)-290(following)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(chapter.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(Nothing)-325(is)-325(easier)-325(than)-326(to)-325(charge)-325(a)-325(body)-325(of)-325(men)-325(with)-325(intense)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(credulity)-158(and)-158(superstition.)-219(Before,)-176(however,)-177(such)-158(charges)-157(deserve)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-335(have)-334(any)-335(notice)-334(taken)-335(of)-334(them,)-356(they)-334(should)-335(be)-334(substantiated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-273(direct)-272(proof.)-318(It)-272(is)-273(impossible)-273(to)-272(meet)-273(them)-272(if)-273(urged)-272(in)-273(a)-272(mere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(general)-238(form.)-245(Fortunately,)-240(the)-238(author)-237(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 175.025 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Supernatural)-238(Religion)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 95.918 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(makes)-373(a)-373(number)-372(of)-373(specific)-373(and)-373(definite)-372(charges,)-404(in)-373(which)-372(he)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(endeavours)-267(to)-266(fasten)-267(an)-266(unspeakable)-266(degree)-267(of)-266(credulity)-267(and)-266(su-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(perstition)-234(on)-234(the)-234(immediate)-233(followers)-234(of)-234(Jesus)-234(and)-234(the)-234(authors)-233(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-234(Gospels,)-236(and)-234(refers)-233(to)-234(authorities)-233(in)-234(support)-233(of)-234(his)-233(assertions.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-250(will)-250(state)-250(his)-250(general)-250(position)-250(in)-250(his)-250(own)-250(words.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -14.777 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(We)-255(have)-254(given)-255(a)-254(most)-255(imperfect)-255(sketch)-254(of)-255(some)-254(of)-255(the)-255(opin-)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(ions)-329(and)-329(superstitions)-329(prevalent)-329(at)-329(the)-329(time)-329(of)-330(Jesus,)-348(and)-329(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-221(books)-220(of)-221(the)-221(New)-221(Testament)-220(were)-221(written.)-240(These,)-227(as)-221(we)-220(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(seen,)-491(are)-442(continued)-442(with)-443(little)-442(or)-443(no)-442(modification)-442(throughout)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-350(first)-351(centuries)-350(of)-350(our)-350(era.)-551(It)-351(must)-350(however)-350(be)-350(remembered)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-379(the)-379(few)-379(details)-378(that)-379(we)-379(have)-379(given,)-411(omitting)-379(much)-379(of)-378(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(grosser)-365(particulars,)-394(are)-365(the)-365(views)-365(absolutely)-365(expressed)-729(by)-365(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([289])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(most)-364(educated)-365(and)-364(intelligent)-365(part)-364(of)-365(the)-364(community;)-422(and)-364(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-397(would)-396(have)-397(required)-397(infinitely)-396(darker)-397(colours)-397(adequately)-396(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-266(portrayed)-267(the)-266(dense)-266(ignorance)-266(and)-267(superstition)-266(of)-266(the)-266(mass)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-349(the)-348(Jews.)-547(It)-348(is)-349(impossible)-349(to)-349(receive)-348(the)-349(report)-349(of)-348(supposed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(marvellous)-311(occurrences)-311(from)-311(an)-311(age)-311(and)-310(people)-311(like)-311(this,)-326(with-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(out)-377(the)-377(gravest)-376(suspicion.)-631(Miracles)-376(which)-377(spring)-377(from)-377(such)-376(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hot-bed)-371(of)-371(superstition)-370(are)-371(too)-371(natural)-371(in)-371(such)-370(a)-371(soil)-371(to)-371(be)-370(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(object)-238(of)-238(surprise;)-241(and)-238(in)-238(losing)-238(their)-237(exceptional)-238(character,)-240(their)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(claims)-247(on)-247(attention)-248(are)-247(proportionally)-247(weakened,)-248(if)-247(not)-247(altogeth-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(er)-365(destroyed.)-595(Preternatural)-365(interference)-365(with)-365(the)-365(affairs)-365(of)-364(life)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1189 0 obj <<
/Length 4218      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(255)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(and)-367(with)-367(the)-366(phenomena)-367(of)-367(nature)-367(was)-366(the)-367(rule)-367(in)-367(those)-366(days,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-383(the)-384(exception,)-417(and)-383(miracles)-383(in)-384(fact)-383(had)-384(apparently)-383(lost)-383(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(novelty,)-242(and)-240(through)-241(familiarity)-240(had)-240(become)-240(degraded)-240(into)-240(mere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(commonplace.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 63.928 0 Td [(\035)]TJ -51.972 -14.095 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(There)-240(can)-239(be)-240(no)-239(doubt)-240(that)-239(the)-240(writers)-239(of)-240(the)-239(New)-240(Testament)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(shared)-250(in)-250(the)-250(popular)-250(superstitions)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Jews.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 204.218 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -192.262 -14.095 Td [(Before)-302(proceeding)-302(further,)-314(I)-302(must)-302(draw)-302(the)-302(reader's)-301(attention)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(three)-250(affirmations)-250(in)-250(this)-250(important)-250(passage.)]TJ 11.956 -14.095 Td [(1st.)-404(That)-301(the)-301(educated)-301(Jews)-302(of)-301(the)-301(time)-301(of)-302(Jesus)-301(were)-301(a)-301(prey)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(the)-250(superstitions)-250(in)-250(question.)]TJ 11.956 -14.095 Td [(2nd.)-237(That)-210(the)-210(common)-211(class)-210(of)-210(Jews)-211(were)-210(a)-210(prey)-211(to)-210(yet)-210(grosser)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(superstitious.)]TJ 11.956 -14.095 Td [(3rd.)-568(That)-357(the)-356(followers)-356(of)-356(Jesus,)-383(who)-356(were)-356(chiefly)-356(Jews)-356(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-238(lower)-237(classes,)-240(and)-238(the)-237(authors)-238(of)-238(the)-237(Gospels,)-240(shared)-238(in)-237(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(superstitions.)]TJ 11.956 -14.095 Td [(The)-335(author)-335(devotes)-336(not)-335(less)-335(than)-335(fifty)-336(pages)-335(to)-335(a)-335(minute)-335(de-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(scription)-306(of)-306(the)-307(superstitions)-306(of)-306(the)-306(educated)-307(classes.)-418(These)-306(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alleged)-251(to)-250(have)-251(been)-251(of)-250(so)-251(gross)-250(a)-251(nature,)-251(that)-251(the)-250(reader)-251(will)-250(get)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-369(a)-369(very)-369(imperfect)-369(conception)-369(of)-369(the)-369(point)-370(at)-369(issue,)-398(unless)-369(I)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(give)-250(a)-250(brief)-250(sketch)-250(of)-250(some)-250(of)-250(them.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([290])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -14.094 Td [(I.)-311(The)-310(Jews)-311(are)-311(affirmed)-311(to)-310(have)-311(believed)-311(in)-311(an)-310(innumerable)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(multitude)-419(of)-420(angels,)-461(whose)-420(agency)-419(was)-419(continually)-419(displayed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-362(the)-362(ordinary)-362(phenomena)-361(of)-362(nature.)-586(They)-362(presided)-362(over)-361(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(energized)-298(in)-297(its)-298(ordinary)-297(operations,)-310(as)-297(for)-298(instance,)-309(in)-297(thunder,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lightning,)-288(the)-280(winds,)-288(the)-280(seas,)-288(frost,)-288(hail,)-288(rain,)-288(mists,)-288(heat,)-287(light,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(&c.;)-330(heaven)-302(and)-303(earth)-303(in)-303(fact)-303(are)-303(filled)-303(with)-303(them,)-317(and)-302(they)-303(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(also)-301(continually)-301(busying)-301(themselves)-301(in)-301(human)-302(affairs,)-313(of)-301(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(minute)-250(details)-250(are)-250(given.)]TJ 11.956 -14.094 Td [(II.)-292(They)-293(are)-292(alleged)-293(to)-292(have)-293(believed)-292(in)-293(a)-292(demonology)-293(of)-292(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(most)-209(phantastic)-209(description.)-237(To)-209(this)-209(I)-209(have)-209(elsewhere)-209(sufficiently)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alluded.)]TJ 11.956 -14.094 Td [(III.)-291(They)-291(are)-292(likewise)-291(affirmed)-291(to)-291(have)-292(believed)-291(that)-291(the)-291(sun,)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(moon)-315(and)-315(stars)-315(are)-315(rational)-315(beings,)-331(and)-315(traces)-315(of)-315(this)-315(belief)-314(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinctly)-250(affirmed)-250(to)-250(exist)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1194 0 obj <<
/Length 4685      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(256)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(IV.)-269(The)-268(belief)-269(in)-268(sorcery,)-274(witchcraft)-268(and)-269(magic)-268(is)-269(affirmed)-268(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(have)-293(been)-294(universal)-293(among)-294(them.)-380(To)-293(give)-294(the)-293(reader)-294(an)-293(idea)-293(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-220(grossness)-219(of)-220(these)-220(beliefs,)-225(to)-220(which)-220(even)-219(the)-220(educated)-219(classes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-399(affirmed)-399(to)-399(have)-398(been)-399(a)-399(prey,)-436(I)-399(must)-399(quote)-399(the)-398(following)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(passage:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -15.185 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Amulets)-267(consisting)-267(of)-267(seals,)-271(or)-267(pieces)-267(of)-267(paper,)-271(with)-267(charms)]TJ -16.799 -13.55 Td [(written)-489(upon)-489(them,)-549(were)-489(hung)-489(round)-489(the)-489(necks)-489(of)-489(the)-489(sick,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-397(considered)-397(efficacious)-398(for)-397(their)-397(cure.)-691(Charms,)-434(spells)-397(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mutterings)-366(were)-365(constantly)-366(said)-366(over)-365(wounds,)-395(against)-365(unlucky)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(meetings,)-396(to)-367(make)-367(people)-367(sleep,)-396(to)-367(heal)-367(diseases,)-396(and)-367(to)-366(avert)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enchantments;)-256(against)-254(mad)-253(dogs)-254(for)-254(instance,)-255(against)-254(the)-253(demon)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-229(blindness)-230(and)-229(the)-229(like,)-234(as)-229(well)-229(as)-229(formul\346)-230(for)-229(averting)-229(the)-229(evil)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eye,)-238(and)-236(mutterings)-235(over)-235(diseases.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 148.452 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.41 0 Td [(Here)-235(follow)-236(several)-235(pages)-235(of)]TJ -155.862 -13.549 Td [(unutterable)-282(absurdities.)-345(It)-282(is)-282(not)-282(too)-281(much)-282(to)-282(say,)-290(that)-282(there)-281(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hardly)-253(an)-254(occurrence)-253(in)-253(nature,)-254(and)-254(hardly)-253(an)-253(event)-254(of)-253(daily)-253(life,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-207(was)-207(not)-206(influenced)-207(by)-207(these)-207(supernatural)-206(powers,)-216(and)-206(very)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(frequently)-370(in)-371(a)-370(manner)-370(unspeakably)-371(grotesque.)-1222(If)-370(such)-370(were)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([291])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(the)-300(beliefs)-300(of)-300(educated)-300(people,)-313(urges)-300(the)-300(author)-300(\050and)-300(he)-300(tells)-300(us)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-295(he)-295(has)-295(omitted)-295(the)-295(grosser)-295(forms)-295(of)-294(them\051,)-307(what)-295(must)-294(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-290(those)-291(of)-290(the)-290(lower)-291(orders,)-300(and)-290(the)-291(extent)-290(of)-290(their)-290(degraded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(superstition?)-230(It)-191(must)-191(be)-191(kept)-190(constantly)-191(in)-191(mind)-191(that)-191(the)-190(followers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-262(Jesus)-262(chiefly)-262(consisted)-261(of)-262(persons)-262(taken)-262(from)-262(the)-262(lower)-261(strata)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-336(society.)-509(But)-336(the)-336(author)-336(in)-336(express)-336(words)-336(charges)-336(them)-336(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sharing)-370(in)-370(such)-370(beliefs.)-610(If)-370(they)-370(did)-370(not,)-400(the)-370(reference)-370(to)-370(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-250(have)-250(no)-250(bearing)-250(on)-250(the)-250(argument.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(We)-275(have)-275(therefore)-274(in)-275(this)-275(portion)-275(of)-274(the)-275(work)-275(a)-275(definite)-274(issue)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(raised)-383(for)-382(our)-383(consideration.)-648(It)-383(is)-383(no)-382(vague)-383(charge)-383(of)-382(general)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(boundless)-308(credulity)-308(and)-308(superstition,)-322(such)-308(as)-308(is)-308(generally)-307(urged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(against)-381(the)-381(followers)-381(of)-382(Jesus)-381(and)-381(the)-381(authors)-381(of)-381(the)-381(Gospels.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(It)-343(is)-343(presented)-343(to)-343(us)-343(in)-343(a)-343(clear)-343(and)-343(definite)-343(form.)-529(I)-343(fully)-343(allow)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-356(if)-356(this)-357(charge)-356(could)-356(be)-356(substantiated,)-383(it)-356(would)-356(deprive)-356(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Evangelists)-250(of)-250(all)-250(historical)-250(credit.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-446(issue)-447(which)-446(is)-447(thus)-446(raised)-447(is)-446(consequently)-447(one)-446(of)-446(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(highest)-204(importance.)-235(It)-205(will)-204(be)-205(necessary)-204(therefore)-205(for)-204(us)-204(carefully)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1198 0 obj <<
/Length 4686      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(257)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(to)-384(examine)-384(the)-384(mode)-385(in)-384(which)-384(it)-384(is)-384(attempted)-384(to)-384(establish)-384(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth)-250(of)-250(these)-250(charges.)-250(The)-250(process)-250(is)-250(an)-250(extremely)-250(singular)-250(one.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(When)-335(we)-336(have)-335(a)-336(set)-335(of)-336(writings)-335(before)-336(us)-335(and)-336(endeavour)-335(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(estimate)-291(the)-290(amount)-291(of)-290(credulity)-291(and)-291(superstition)-290(to)-291(which)-290(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authors)-318(were)-319(a)-318(prey,)-336(the)-318(only)-319(legitimate)-318(mode)-319(of)-318(proceeding)-318(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-309(subject)-309(these)-309(writings)-309(to)-309(a)-309(thorough)-309(and)-309(minute)-309(examination)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-371(to)-371(the)-371(indications)-370(of)-371(credulity)-371(and)-371(superstition)-371(contained)-370(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them.)-240(Having)-220(done)-221(this,)-226(it)-220(then)-221(becomes)-220(our)-220(duty)-221(to)-220(ascertain)-220(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(amount)-204(of)-204(general)-205(good)-204(sense)-204(or)-204(the)-204(want)-205(of)-204(it)-204(which)-204(is)-204(displayed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-267(them)-268(in)-267(these)-267(or)-267(in)-267(other)-268(subjects,)-271(and)-268(then)-267(to)-267(form)-267(a)-267(general)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(conclusion)-362(by)-362(fairly)-361(balancing)-362(the)-362(indications)-362(of)-362(credulity)-361(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(good)-407(sense)-406(against)-407(each)-407(other.)-720(The)-407(author,)-446(however,)-891(seems)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([292])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(not)-310(to)-310(have)-309(had)-310(the)-310(smallest)-310(idea)-310(that)-310(it)-309(is)-310(the)-310(duty)-310(of)-310(the)-309(critic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-371(ascertain)-371(what)-372(are)-371(the)-371(facts)-371(of)-371(the)-372(case)-371(as)-371(presented)-371(by)-371(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writings,)-356(and)-335(to)-335(form)-335(a)-334(general)-335(conclusion)-335(by)-335(a)-335(careful)-334(review)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-328(the)-328(entire)-327(evidence.)-484(On)-327(the)-328(contrary,)-347(his)-328(mode)-328(of)-327(reasoning)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-260(to)-261(quote)-260(a)-260(number)-260(of)-261(opinions)-260(held)-260(by)-260(various)-261(writers,)-262(widely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(separated)-350(from)-349(each)-350(other)-349(in)-350(time,)-374(to)-349(charge)-350(them)-349(on)-350(the)-349(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(temporaries)-389(of)-389(our)-390(Lord,)-423(and)-390(refer)-389(to)-389(nearly)-389(every)-389(passage)-389(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-290(New)-289(Testament)-290(which)-290(has)-289(even)-290(the)-290(remotest)-289(bearing)-290(on)-289(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(subject,)-386(for)-359(the)-358(purpose)-359(of)-359(fastening)-358(these)-359(superstitions)-359(on)-358(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(followers)-306(of)-306(Jesus.)-418(Such)-306(a)-306(mode)-306(of)-306(reasoning)-306(can)-306(only)-306(avail)-306(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(establish)-250(a)-250(foregone)-250(conclusion.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Again:)-426(In)-337(forming)-338(a)-338(judgment)-338(on)-338(such)-337(a)-338(subject,)-360(it)-338(also)-337(be-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(hoves)-334(us)-334(most)-335(carefully)-334(to)-334(consider)-334(whether)-334(the)-334(subject-matter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-216(the)-217(writings)-216(is)-216(or)-216(is)-217(not)-216(of)-216(such)-216(a)-217(character,)-223(that)-216(if)-216(their)-216(authors)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-236(been)-237(addicted)-236(to)-237(such)-236(gross)-236(superstitions,)-239(there)-237(would)-236(not)-236(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(necessity)-334(have)-335(been)-334(frequent)-334(examples)-334(of)-335(them)-334(in)-334(their)-334(pages?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Also)-197(whether)-197(the)-198(absence)-197(of)-197(such)-197(references,)-208(when)-197(the)-197(subject)-197(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-306(they)-307(were)-306(writing)-306(was)-306(certain)-306(to)-307(have)-306(suggested)-306(them)-306(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-208(minds,)-216(does)-208(not)-208(constitute)-208(a)-208(strong)-208(proof)-208(that)-208(these)-207(supersti-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tions)-241(were)-241(not)-242(held)-241(by)-241(them?)-247(In)-241(one)-242(word,)-243(it)-241(is)-241(absurd)-241(to)-241(attempt)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-348(charge)-349(writers)-348(with)-348(boundless)-348(credulity)-348(and)-349(superstition,)-372(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-206(ground)-207(that)-206(a)-206(multitude)-206(of)-206(grotesque)-207(beliefs)-206(were)-206(prevalent)-206(in)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1202 0 obj <<
/Length 4683      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(258)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(their)-197(day.)-232(No)-197(author)-197(can)-197(be)-197(held)-197(responsible)-197(for)-197(beliefs)-197(other)-197(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-268(which)-268(appear)-267(in)-268(his)-268(pages,)-272(especially)-268(when)-267(subject-matter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-243(his)-243(writings)-243(would)-242(have)-243(been)-243(certain)-243(to)-243(call)-243(them)-243(into)-242(activity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-250(he)-250(had)-250(entertained)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-294(course)-293(pursued)-294(by)-294(the)-293(author)-294(is)-294(directly)-293(opposite)-294(to)-293(this.)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(He)-248(has)-248(been)-248(compelled)-248(to)-248(adopt)-249(it,)-248(because)-248(it)-248(is)-248(the)-248(only)-248(method)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-303(which)-304(extreme)-303(credulity)-303(and)-303(superstition)-304(can)-303(be)-303(fastened)-303(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-174(writers)-175(of)-174(the)-349(Gospels.)-224(The)-175(available)-174(contemporary)-174(literature,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([293])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(besides)-323(that)-323(contained)-322(in)-323(the)-323(New)-323(Testament,)-341(which)-323(can)-322(throw)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(light)-391(on)-391(the)-391(opinions)-391(of)-391(the)-391(followers)-391(of)-391(Jesus,)-426(is)-391(very)-391(small.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(The)-314(point)-315(which)-314(requires)-315(proof)-314(is)-315(that)-314(the)-315(entire)-314(Jewish)-314(nation,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-286(any)-286(exception)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 96.529 0 Td [(,)-295(was)-285(a)-286(prey)-286(to)-286(the)-285(basest)-286(superstition)-286(and)]TJ -96.529 -13.549 Td [(credulity.)-393(Unless)-297(this)-298(can)-297(be)-298(established,)-309(the)-297(charge)-298(against)-297(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authors)-255(of)-254(the)-255(Gospels)-255(falls)-255(to)-254(the)-255(ground,)-256(except)-255(so)-254(far)-255(as)-255(it)-254(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-309(proved)-309(by)-309(the)-309(Gospels)-309(themselves.)-427(The)-309(contemporary)-309(proof)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-237(it,)-240(however,)-240(failing,)-240(he)-237(endeavours)-238(to)-237(substantiate)-237(his)-237(position)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-345(quoting)-345(the)-345(opinions)-345(of)-345(writers)-345(separated)-345(from)-345(the)-345(times)-344(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-281(by)-280(several)-281(centuries,)-288(and)-281(affirming)-280(that)-281(they)-280(were)-281(held)-280(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-218(entire)-218(body)-218(of)-218(His)-218(contemporaries.)-239(Such)-218(a)-218(mode)-218(of)-218(reasoning)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-250(useless)-250(to)-250(support)-250(anything)-250(but)-250(a)-250(foregone)-250(conclusion.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(A)-363(brief)-364(reference)-363(to)-364(the)-363(authorities)-364(relied)-363(upon)-364(will)-363(at)-363(once)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(expose)-413(the)-414(fallacy)-413(of)-414(the)-413(argument.)-741(First,)-454(certain)-413(differences)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(existing)-327(between)-328(the)-327(Septuagint)-327(and)-328(the)-327(Hebrew)-327(Scriptures)-327(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pressed)-231(into)-231(the)-231(service,)-235(which)-231(are)-231(no)-231(instances)-231(of)-231(either)-231(creduli-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ty)-320(or)-320(superstition.)-460(Then)-320(the)-320(frequent)-320(idolatries)-320(which)-320(prevailed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(among)-297(the)-297(Jews)-297(prior)-297(to)-297(the)-297(captivity)-297(are)-297(adduced)-297(as)-297(a)-297(proof)-296(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-359(superstitious)-358(tendencies)-359(of)-358(the)-359(Jewish)-359(mind,)-385(as)-359(if)-358(supersti-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tions)-339(prevalent)-339(at)-339(the)-340(time)-339(of)-339(Becket)-339(were)-339(any)-339(evidence)-339(of)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(condition)-276(of)-276(English)-276(thought)-276(at)-275(the)-276(present)-276(day.)-328(Next)-276(the)-275(absur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dities)-341(in)-342(the)-341(Apocryphal)-342(Book)-341(of)-341(Tobit)-342(are)-341(put)-342(in)-341(as)-341(evidence,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(although)-359(the)-359(contrary)-359(evidence)-359(afforded)-359(by)-359(the)-359(other)-359(books)-358(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-385(Apocrypha,)-420(which)-385(contain)-386(no)-385(traces)-386(of)-385(such)-385(superstitions,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-350(left)-350(without)-350(mention.)-549(The)-350(writings)-350(of)-350(an)-350(Assyrian)-350(Jew)-349(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lived)-390(about)-389(three)-390(hundred)-390(and)-390(fifty)-389(years)-390(before)-390(the)-389(Christian)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1206 0 obj <<
/Length 4693      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(259)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(era)-325(are)-324(about)-325(as)-324(valid)-325(to)-324(prove)-325(the)-324(opinions)-325(held)-324(by)-325(Christ)-324(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-364(followers)-364(as)-364(the)-365(opinions)-364(of)-364(Cicero)-364(would)-364(be)-364(in)-728(evidence)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([294])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(of)-420(the)-419(beliefs)-420(of)-420(Constantine.)-758(Then)-420(reference)-420(is)-419(made)-420(to)-419(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(angelology)-309(and)-310(demonology)-309(contained)-310(in)-309(the)-310(writings)-309(of)-309(Philo,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(who)-371(was)-370(unquestionably)-370(a)-371(contemporary)-370(of)-371(our)-370(Lord;)-431(but)-370(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-260(smallest)-259(hint)-260(is)-260(given)-260(to)-259(the)-260(reader)-260(that)-259(he)-260(was)-260(deeply)-259(tinged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-359(the)-358(principles)-359(of)-358(the)-359(Neo-Platonic)-359(philosophy,)-385(a)-359(mode)-358(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thought)-351(wholly)-350(alien)-351(from)-351(that)-350(of)-351(the)-350(Palestinian)-351(Jews,)-376(or)-350(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Philo)-191(was)-192(himself)-191(an)-192(Alexandrian)-191(Jew.)-230(Next)-192(the)-191(book)-192(of)-191(Enoch)-191(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(quoted,)-241(which)-240(\050whenever)-239(it)-239(was)-239(written,)-242(for)-239(its)-239(date)-239(is)-239(uncertain\051)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-283(unquestionably)-282(not)-283(the)-283(work)-283(of)-282(a)-283(Palestinian)-283(Jew.)-348(This)-282(book,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-355(is)-355(an)-355(Apocalypse,)-381(contains)-355(a)-355(monstrous)-355(angelology)-355(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(demonology,)-428(and)-392(abounds)-392(with)-392(extravagances.)-676(Although)-392(part)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-320(it)-319(was)-320(written)-320(prior)-320(to)-319(the)-320(Advent,)-337(other)-320(portions)-320(are)-319(clearly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(subsequent)-263(to)-262(it.)-287(Its)-263(author)-262(is)-263(unknown;)-269(but)-262(it)-263(is)-262(highly)-262(probable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-236(certain)-235(resemblances)-236(of)-235(expression)-236(between)-236(it)-235(and)-236(the)-235(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament,)-246(that)-245(he)-244(was)-245(acquainted)-245(with)-245(portions)-244(of)-245(the)-245(latter;)-246(or,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-364(state)-364(the)-365(theory)-364(of)-364(unbelievers,)-393(that)-364(the)-364(authors)-364(of)-364(the)-364(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-211(borrowed)-210(from)-211(it.)-236(If)-211(this)-210(view)-211(is)-211(true,)-218(then)-210(it)-211(is)-210(evident)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-428(they)-427(must)-428(have)-428(rejected)-427(its)-428(angelology)-428(and)-427(demonology,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-312(that)-311(contained)-312(in)-311(the)-312(New)-311(Testament)-312(is)-311(utterly)-312(dissimilar)-311(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-346(to)-346(that)-346(which)-346(we)-345(read)-346(in)-346(the)-346(book)-346(of)-346(Enoch.)-538(As)-345(far,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore,)-290(as)-283(the)-282(evidence)-282(of)-282(this)-282(book)-283(is)-282(concerned,)-290(it)-282(affords)-282(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinct)-238(proof)-238(that)-237(they)-238(were)-238(not)-238(a)-237(prey)-238(to)-238(its)-238(monstrous)-237(supersti-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tions.)-242(This)-226(remark)-225(is)-226(equally)-226(applicable)-226(to)-226(the)-225(book)-226(of)-226(Tobit,)-230(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(writings)-250(of)-250(Philo.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-280(there)-280(is)-280(a)-281(reference)-280(made)-280(to)-280(Philo)-280(which)-280(deserves)-280(partic-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ular)-312(notice)-312(as)-311(an)-312(exemplification)-312(of)-311(the)-312(mode)-312(adopted)-312(by)-311(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-301(endeavour)-301(to)-300(fix)-301(the)-301(charge)-300(of)-301(unbounded)-301(credulity)-301(on)-300(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authors)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Gospels.)-250(I)-250(cite)-250(the)-250(author.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -16.004 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(The)-296(belief)-297(that)-296(the)-296(sun,)-308(moon)-296(and)-296(stars)-297(were)-592(living)-297(entities)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 274.225 0 Td [([295])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(possessed)-294(of)-293(souls)-294(was)-293(generally)-294(held)-293(by)-293(the)-294(Jews)-293(at)-294(the)-293(begin-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ning)-394(of)-393(our)-393(era,)-430(along)-393(with)-394(Greek)-393(philosophers,)-430(and)-393(we)-393(shall)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presently)-251(see)-250(it)-251(expressed)-250(by)-251(the)-250(fathers.)-251(Philo)-251(Jud\346us)-250(considers)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1211 0 obj <<
/Length 5481      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(260)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(the)-251(stars)-250(spiritual)-250(beings)-251(full)-250(of)-251(virtue)-250(and)-251(perfection,)-250(and)-251(that)-250(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-178(is)-178(granted)-178(lordship)-178(over)-178(other)-178(heavenly)-178(bodies,)-192(not)-178(absolute,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-213(as)-213(viceroys)-213(under)-213(the)-213(Supreme)-213(Being.)-238(We)-213(find)-213(a)-212(similar)-213(view)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(expressed)-374(regarding)-375(the)-374(nature)-375(of)-374(the)-374(stars)-375(in)-374(the)-374(Apocalypse,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-250(it)-250(constantly)-250(occurs)-250(in)-250(the)-250(Talmud)-250(and)-250(Targums.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 229.974 0 Td [(\035)]TJ -218.018 -15.185 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(We)-256(find,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 38.233 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.633 0 Td [(says)-256(the)-255(author,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 71.099 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(a)-256(similar)-255(view)-256(expressed)-256(regard-)]TJ -138.608 -13.55 Td [(ing)-183(the)-183(nature)-183(of)-183(the)-183(stars)-183(in)-183(the)-184(Apocalypse,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 188.973 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 6.84 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.815 0 Td [(that)-183(the)-183(stars)-183(are)]TJ -211.628 -13.549 Td [(spiritual)-307(beings)-308(full)-307(of)-308(virtue)-307(and)-307(perfection,)-322(and)-308(that)-307(they)-307(hold)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lordship)-261(over)-260(other)-261(heavenly)-260(bodies.)-282(No)-261(quotation)-260(is)-261(made)-260(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-294(book,)-304(but)-294(four)-294(passages)-293(are)-294(referred)-294(to)-294(in)-293(a)-294(note)-294(as)-293(proving)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this.)-263(They)-255(are)-254(as)-255(follows:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 113.102 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)-254(mystery)-255(of)-254(the)-255(seven)-254(stars)-255(which)]TJ -117.946 -13.55 Td [(thou)-234(sawest)-233(in)-234(my)-233(right)-234(hand,)-236(and)-234(the)-233(seven)-234(golden)-233(candlesticks.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-384(seven)-384(stars)-385(are)-384(the)-384(angels)-384(of)-384(the)-384(seven)-385(churches,)-417(and)-384(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(seven)-338(candlesticks)-338(which)-338(thou)-338(sawest)-338(are)-338(the)-338(seven)-337(churches.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 275.786 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(\050Rev.)-263(i.)-264(20.\051)-263(With)-254(as)-255(good)-254(reason)-255(may)-254(it)-254(be)-255(said)-254(that)-255(the)-254(book)-254(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Revelation)-250(teaches)-250(the)-250(rationality)-250(of)-250(candlesticks.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -15.186 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(These)-247(things)-246(saith)-247(He)-247(that)-247(hath)-246(the)-247(seven)-247(Spirits)-246(of)-247(God,)-248(and)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(the)-395(seven)-396(stars.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 69.52 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.156 0 Td [(\050Rev.)-686(iii.)-686(1.\051)-686(It)-395(is)-395(difficult)-396(to)-395(see)-395(how)-395(this)]TJ -78.676 -13.549 Td [(proves)-293(that)-294(the)-293(author)-294(of)-293(the)-293(Revelation)-294(was)-293(of)-294(opinion)-293(that)-293(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(stars)-339(were)-339(rational)-340(entities.)-517(The)-340(next)-339(passage)-339(referred)-339(to)-339(\050Rev.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(iv.)-464(5\051)-322(makes)-321(no)-321(mention)-322(of)-321(stars)-321(at)-322(all,)-339(but)-321(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 208.786 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(seven)-321(lamps)-322(of)]TJ -213.629 -13.549 Td [(fire)-400(burning)-400(before)-399(the)-400(throne,)-437(which)-400(are)-400(the)-400(seven)-400(Spirits)-399(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 21.513 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.069 0 Td [(The)-296(last)-295(reference)-296(is:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.395 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(I)-296(saw)-295(a)-296(star)-296(fall)-295(from)-296(heaven)-296(unto)]TJ -130.821 -13.549 Td [(the)-319(earth;)-354(and)-319(to)-320(him)-319(was)-319(given)-319(the)-320(key)-319(of)-319(the)-319(bottomless)-319(pit.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 275.786 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.55 Td [(\050Rev.)-491(ix.)-490(1.\051)-491(Here)-330(a)-330(star)-331(is)-330(spoken)-330(of)-330(as)-330(a)-331(living)-330(agent;)-370(but)-330(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(refer)-308(in)-615(proof)-308(of)-308(this)-307(to)-308(a)-308(book)-307(which)-308(is)-308(full)-307(of)-308(symbols)-308(and)-307(is)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([296])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(an)-268(avowed)-268(vision)-268(is)-269(ridiculous)-268(and)-268(misleading.)-304(On)-268(the)-268(contrary,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-342(New)-342(Testament)-342(supplies)-342(the)-342(most)-342(unquestionable)-342(evidence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-280(its)-281(writers)-280(were)-281(free)-280(from)-280(this)-281(superstition,)-288(into)-280(which)-280(even)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(philosophers)-250(had)-250(fallen.)]TJ 11.955 -15.185 Td [(The)-434(next)-434(writer)-434(referred)-433(to,)-480(to)-434(prove)-434(that)-434(the)-434(followers)-434(of)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-464(were)-464(a)-463(prey)-464(to)-464(credulity)-464(and)-463(superstition,)-518(is)-463(Josephus,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-356(his)-357(narrative)-356(of)-356(the)-356(signs)-356(which)-357(preceded)-356(the)-356(destruction)-356(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jerusalem.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1215 0 obj <<
/Length 4963      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(261)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -252.311 -30.759 Td [(To)-385(what)-385(extent)-385(Josephus)-385(embellished)-385(these)-385(signs)-385(may)-385(be)-384(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(question.)-660(Most)-387(of)-387(them)-386(have)-387(a)-387(very)-386(heathen)-387(aspect,)-421(and)-387(it)-386(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unquestionable)-266(that)-266(he)-266(was)-266(much)-266(disposed)-266(to)-266(conciliate)-266(his)-266(hea-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-248(readers.)-250(It)-248(is)-248(sufficient)-249(to)-248(observe)-248(that)-248(the)-249(pages)-248(of)-248(the)-248(New)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Testament)-250(contain)-250(nothing)-250(resembling)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-434(the)-433(chief)-434(source)-433(whence)-434(these)-433(ineffable)-434(puerilities)-433(are)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(derived,)-438(and)-400(charged)-400(on)-400(the)-400(contemporaries)-400(of)-400(our)-400(Lord,)-437(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(through)-181(them)-181(on)-181(the)-181(writers)-181(of)-181(the)-181(New)-181(Testament,)-195(is)-181(the)-181(Talmud.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Probably)-323(there)-323(are)-323(no)-323(writings)-323(in)-323(existence)-323(from)-323(which)-323(a)-322(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(monstrous)-396(set)-395(of)-396(absurdities)-396(can)-396(be)-395(collected)-396(than)-396(from)-395(those)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-383(the)-382(Talmudists.)-648(But)-383(how)-383(does)-382(this)-383(prove)-383(that)-382(this)-383(mass)-382(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nonsense)-217(was)-216(believed)-217(in)-216(by)-217(the)-216(Jewish)-216(nation)-217(in)-216(our)-217(Lord's)-216(day?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(One)-259(portion)-260(of)-259(the)-260(Talmud,)-261(the)-260(Mishna,)-262(was)-259(composed)-259(between)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(A)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.755 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(D)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.755 0 Td [(.)-424(180)-423(and)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 48.705 0 Td [(A)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 2.728 0 Td [(D)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)-424(200,)-466(or)-424(some)-424(years)-423(after)-424(the)-423(date)-424(assigned)]TJ -77.178 -13.549 Td [(by)-350(unbelievers)-350(to)-350(the)-350(Fourth)-350(Gospel.)-550(The)-350(lateness)-350(of)-350(this)-349(date)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-324(urged)-323(by)-324(them)-324(as)-323(conclusive)-324(proof)-324(that)-323(that)-324(Gospel)-324(does)-323(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(embody)-295(the)-294(real)-295(traditions)-294(of)-295(the)-294(early)-295(followers)-294(of)-295(Jesus.)-383(How)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-425(can)-424(it)-425(be)-425(urged)-424(with)-425(any)-425(thing)-424(like)-425(consistency)-425(that)-424(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Mishna)-237(adequately)-237(represents)-238(their)-237(views)-237(respecting)-237(the)-237(order)-237(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature?)-234(But)-204(the)-203(other)-203(portion)-203(of)-203(the)-203(Talmud,)-213(the)-203(Gemara,)-212(was)-203(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(put)-215(forth)-215(in)-215(a)-215(written)-215(form)-215(prior)-215(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 149.045 0 Td [(A)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.755 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(D)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)-215(500.)-238(To)-215(quote)-430(works)-215(thus)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 127.743 0 Td [([297])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(remote)-293(in)-294(time)-293(as)-294(proofs)-293(of)-293(the)-294(superstitions)-293(of)-294(the)-293(followers)-293(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus,)-291(is)-282(to)-283(adopt)-282(a)-283(course)-283(which)-282(if)-283(applied)-282(generally)-283(to)-282(history,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-392(reduce)-391(it)-392(to)-392(a)-391(tissue)-392(of)-391(falsehoods.)-675(Bishop)-392(Jewell)-391(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-350(believer)-349(in)-350(witchcraft;)-399(but)-350(it)-349(would)-350(be)-350(absurd)-349(if)-350(some)-349(future)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(writer)-412(were)-411(to)-412(quote)-412(the)-411(writings)-412(of)-412(modern)-411(spiritualists)-412(as)-411(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proof)-250(that)-250(he)-250(believed)-250(in)-250(their)-250(doctrines.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Nor)-455(is)-456(it)-455(true)-455(that)-455(the)-456(opinions)-455(of)-455(the)-456(masses)-455(of)-455(a)-455(nation)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(are)-404(at)-403(all)-404(adequately)-404(represented)-403(by)-404(those)-404(of)-403(its)-404(learned)-403(men,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(especially)-394(when)-394(learning,)-430(as)-394(in)-394(the)-394(case)-394(in)-394(question,)-429(assumed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-367(most)-366(unbounded)-367(licence)-367(of)-366(speculation.)-600(In)-367(most)-367(cases)-366(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(common)-289(sense)-290(of)-289(the)-290(masses)-289(who)-290(are)-289(brought)-290(into)-289(contact)-289(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-353(hard)-354(facts)-353(of)-354(daily)-353(life)-354(will)-353(preserve)-354(them)-353(from)-353(puerilities,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-194(which)-193(learning,)-205(which)-194(draws)-194(exclusively)-193(on)-194(the)-193(imagination,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1220 0 obj <<
/Length 4603      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(262)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(is)-285(certain)-286(to)-285(fall.)-356(There)-285(is)-285(sufficient)-286(evidence)-285(of)-285(the)-285(superstition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-211(the)-212(masses)-211(during)-211(the)-212(middle)-211(ages;)-224(but)-211(nothing)-212(would)-211(be)-211(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(absurd)-267(than)-267(to)-267(quote)-267(some)-267(monstrous)-267(opinions)-267(held)-267(by)-267(the)-267(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(scholastic)-245(writers)-245(to)-245(prove)-246(that)-245(they)-245(were)-245(the)-245(current)-245(opinions)-245(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-281(vulgar.)-342(Yet)-280(the)-281(principle)-280(here)-281(adopted)-281(is)-280(to)-281(adduce)-280(opinions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(propounded)-309(by)-308(learned)-309(writers,)-323(who)-309(lived)-309(centuries)-308(afterwards,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-246(a)-246(proof)-247(that)-246(they)-246(were)-246(current)-246(among)-247(the)-246(entire)-246(Jewish)-246(race)-246(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(time)-250(of)-250(Jesus)-250(Christ.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-416(remaining)-416(references)-416(in)-416(proof)-416(of)-416(this)-416(position)-416(are)-415(still)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(more)-242(noteworthy.)-247(To)-241(establish)-242(the)-242(superstition)-241(of)-242(the)-241(Jews)-242(at)-241(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(time)-354(of)-355(the)-354(Advent,)-381(a)-354(set)-354(of)-355(opinions)-354(are)-355(adduced)-354(which)-354(were)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(held)-297(by)-296(Christian)-297(Fathers,)-308(whose)-297(writings)-296(cover)-297(a)-296(period)-297(of)-296(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(less)-341(than)-341(four)-341(centuries.)-524(A)-341(list)-341(of)-341(them)-341(will)-341(be)-341(sufficient.)-523(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apocryphal)-426(Barnabas)-426(and)-427(Hermas,)-470(Justin)-426(Martyr,)-470(Theophilus,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Clement)-251(of)-251(Alexandria,)-251(Tatian,)-251(Tertullian,)-251(Cyprian,)-250(Origen,)-251(Au-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gustine,)-251(Jerome,)-250(Chrysostom,)-251(Lactantius,)-250(Eusebius,)-251(and)-250(Cyril)-250(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jerusalem.)-388(A)-297(number)-592(of)-296(grotesque)-296(opinions)-296(are)-296(collected)-296(from)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([298])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(these)-248(writers,)-248(as)-248(though)-248(they)-247(could)-248(have)-248(any)-248(possible)-248(bearing)-247(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-310(question)-309(whether)-310(the)-309(followers)-310(of)-310(Jesus)-309(were)-310(able)-309(correctly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(report)-250(what)-250(they)-250(saw)-250(and)-250(heard.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-291(submit)-291(therefore)-291(that)-292(the)-291(facts)-291(adduced)-291(utterly)-291(fail)-291(to)-291(estab-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(lish)-334(the)-334(charge)-334(of)-334(intense)-334(superstition)-334(and)-334(credulity)-334(against)-333(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(followers)-269(of)-270(Jesus.)-308(But)-269(I)-269(go)-270(further,)-274(and)-269(affirm)-270(that)-269(they)-269(furnish)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(means)-250(of)-250(giving)-250(a)-250(most)-250(conclusive)-250(proof)-250(of)-250(the)-250(contrary.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(These)-228(quotations)-227(furnish)-228(us)-228(with)-228(a)-227(clear)-228(and)-228(conclusive)-227(proof,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(which)-194(is)-194(also)-194(furnished)-194(by)-195(the)-194(entire)-194(range)-194(of)-194(literature,)-205(that)-194(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writers)-199(are)-200(the)-199(prey)-199(of)-200(a)-199(definite)-199(class)-199(of)-200(superstitions,)-209(their)-199(pages)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(will)-270(afford)-269(abundant)-270(evidence)-270(not)-269(only)-270(of)-270(their)-269(existence,)-275(but)-269(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-280(nature)-279(and)-280(character.)-338(This,)-287(of)-280(course,)-287(must)-279(be)-280(qualified)-279(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-371(supposition)-371(that)-371(the)-370(subject-matter)-371(on)-371(which)-371(they)-371(wrote)-370(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-341(suitable)-341(to)-341(call)-342(their)-341(latent)-341(superstitions)-341(into)-341(activity.)-523(This)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(always)-299(happens)-300(when)-299(the)-300(works)-299(are)-300(of)-299(a)-300(religious)-299(character.)-398(In)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(such)-188(cases)-189(they)-188(will)-188(faithfully)-189(reflect)-188(the)-188(superstitions)-188(entertained)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-250(their)-251(authors.)-251(This)-251(is)-250(pre-eminently)-250(the)-251(case)-250(with)-251(all)-250(the)-250(writ-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1224 0 obj <<
/Length 4749      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(263)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(ings)-368(in)-369(question.)-604(They)-368(are)-369(all)-368(on)-368(religious)-368(subjects,)-398(on)-368(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-331(allowed)-332(their)-331(imaginations)-331(to)-332(run)-331(riot.)-494(They)-331(entertained)-331(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(number)-299(of)-298(grotesque)-299(opinions,)-311(and)-299(accordingly)-298(we)-299(find)-299(in)-298(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writings)-291(a)-291(grotesque)-291(super-naturalism,)-301(exactly)-291(corresponding)-291(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-236(peculiar)-236(ideas)-236(of)-236(each)-236(individual)-235(writer.)-246(On)-236(the)-236(principle)-235(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(out)-251(of)-251(the)-250(abundance)-251(of)-251(the)-251(heart)-250(the)-251(mouth)-251(speaketh,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 233.966 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.579 0 Td [(we)-251(may)]TJ -246.389 -13.549 Td [(be)-290(quite)-289(certain)-290(that)-290(when)-289(an)-290(author)-290(is)-289(extremely)-290(credulous)-289(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(superstitious,)-401(it)-370(will)-371(find)-371(expression)-370(in)-371(his)-370(pages)-371(whenever)-370(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-303(writing)-304(on)-303(a)-303(subject)-304(on)-303(which)-303(his)-304(imagination)-303(gives)-303(scope)-303(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(exhibit)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(I)-223(put)-223(the)-222(argument)-223(as)-223(follows:)-236(all)-223(writers)-223(exhibit)-223(in)-223(their)-222(pages)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(the)-189(superstitions)-189(to)-188(which)-189(they)-189(are)-189(a)-188(prey.)-459(The)-189(writers)-189(of)-189(the)-188(New)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([299])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-244(do)-243(not)-244(exhibit)-243(the)-244(superstitions)-243(in)-244(question.)-248(It)-243(follows)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-373(that)-372(from)-373(these)-373(particular)-372(superstitions)-373(they)-373(are)-372(free.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Consequently)-216(the)-216(charge)-216(against)-216(them)-216(of)-216(intense)-216(superstition)-215(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(credulity)-280(falls)-280(to)-280(the)-279(ground,)-288(as)-280(far)-279(as)-280(it)-280(rests)-280(on)-280(the)-280(evidence)-279(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-346(amount)-347(of)-346(subject-matter)-347(in)-346(the)-347(New)-346(Testament)-346(which,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(independently)-329(of)-329(a)-329(general)-328(belief)-329(in)-329(miracles,)-349(the)-329(opponents)-328(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Christianity)-347(can)-346(designate)-346(as)-347(superstitious,)-371(is)-346(of)-347(a)-346(very)-346(limited)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-429(definite)-428(nature.)-787(It)-428(may)-429(be)-429(said)-428(to)-429(be)-429(almost)-428(exclusively)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(confined)-263(to)-264(a)-263(belief)-263(in)-264(the)-263(reality)-263(of)-264(possession;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 207.802 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(a)-263(few)-264(cases)-263(of)]TJ -218.711 -13.549 Td [(disease)-261(occasioned)-261(by)-260(Satanic)-261(agency;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 168.305 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(an)-261(occasional)-260(interven-)]TJ -179.214 -13.549 Td [(tion)-346(of)-345(angels,)-370(and)-345(their)-346(power)-345(to)-346(act)-345(on)-346(nature;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 216.271 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.91 0 Td [(and)-346(perhaps)]TJ -227.181 -13.55 Td [(that)-334(demonology)-334(and)-335(heathenism)-334(were)-334(in)-334(some)-334(way)-334(connected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-296(each)-296(other.)-388(This)-296(is)-296(the)-296(sum)-296(total)-296(of)-296(such)-296(beliefs)-296(which)-296(ap-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pear)-276(on)-277(the)-276(face)-277(of)-276(the)-277(New)-276(Testament.)-329(They)-277(appear)-276(in)-276(unequal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(degrees)-335(in)-336(the)-335(works)-336(of)-335(different)-335(writers;)-378(and)-336(viewing)-335(them)-335(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mere)-356(human)-357(compositions,)-382(we)-357(have)-356(no)-356(right)-357(to)-356(charge)-356(on)-356(one)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(writer)-373(the)-373(beliefs)-373(of)-373(another.)-619(The)-373(book)-373(of)-373(Revelation,)-403(and)-373(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(imagery)-275(as)-275(professedly)-275(merely)-275(seen)-276(in)-275(a)-275(vision,)-281(cannot)-275(fairly)-275(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(introduced)-250(into)-250(this)-250(controversy.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(If)-346(then)-347(we)-346(concede,)-370(for)-347(the)-346(sake)-346(of)-346(argument,)-371(that)-346(the)-346(Jews)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-253(the)-253(time)-253(of)-253(Christ)-253(were)-253(a)-253(prey)-253(to)-253(the)-253(extravagant)-253(superstitions)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1228 0 obj <<
/Length 4576      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(264)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(referred)-292(to;)-313(if)-292(they)-291(believed)-292(that)-292(the)-292(whole)-292(course)-292(of)-292(nature)-291(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(human)-273(life)-273(was)-273(incessantly)-272(interfered)-273(with)-273(by)-273(an)-273(army)-273(of)-272(spirits)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-355(numbers)-355(passing)-355(all)-356(comprehension,)-381(and)-355(that)-355(these)-355(interfer-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ences)-394(were)-395(of)-394(the)-394(most)-394(grotesque)-395(and)-394(phantastic)-394(character;)-466(if)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-257(universally)-257(believed)-258(in)-257(magic,)-259(charms)-257(and)-257(incantations,)-259(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(non-appearance)-433(of)-433(such)-434(phenomena)-433(in)-433(the)-433(pages)-433(of)-433(the)-433(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-454(is)-454(a)-455(proof)-454(that)-454(its)-454(authors)-454(were)-455(not)-454(a)-454(prey)-454(to)-454(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(current)-331(superstitions)-332(of)-663(the)-331(day.)-494(No)-332(inconsiderable)-331(number)-331(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([300])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-201(events)-200(are)-201(recorded)-200(in)-201(their)-200(pages,)-210(but)-201(unbelief)-200(itself)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-326(compelled)-327(to)-326(admit)-327(that)-326(they)-326(are)-327(all)-326(of)-327(a)-326(dignified)-326(character,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-356(perhaps)-357(the)-356(exception)-356(of)-356(the)-356(entrance)-357(of)-356(the)-356(demons)-356(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-257(swine,)-259(and)-258(the)-257(discovery)-257(of)-258(the)-257(piece)-257(of)-258(money)-257(in)-257(the)-257(mouth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-324(the)-325(fish.)-473(From)-325(what)-324(is)-325(monstrous,)-343(grotesque)-324(and)-324(phantastic,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-250(are)-250(absolutely)-250(free.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(If)-443(it)-442(be)-443(conceded,)-491(for)-443(the)-442(sake)-443(of)-443(argument,)-491(that)-442(miracles)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(are)-438(possible,)-486(then)-438(it)-438(cannot)-438(be)-438(denied)-439(that)-438(those)-438(of)-438(the)-438(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament,)-260(taken)-258(as)-257(a)-258(whole,)-260(stand)-258(out)-257(in)-258(marked)-258(contrast)-258(to)-257(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(current)-282(supernaturalism)-282(of)-282(superstition.)-346(Their)-282(whole)-282(conception)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-402(lofty;)-477(there)-402(is)-402(in)-402(them)-402(nothing)-401(mean)-402(or)-402(contemptible;)-477(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subserve)-256(a)-257(great)-256(purpose;)-259(they)-257(are)-256(worthy)-256(of)-257(that)-256(great)-256(character)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-182(whom)-182(they)-182(are)-181(ascribed,)-196(Jesus)-182(Christ.)-227(I)-182(put)-182(the)-182(question)-181(boldly:)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(how)-292(is)-293(it,)-303(if)-292(the)-293(followers)-292(of)-293(Jesus)-292(were)-293(a)-292(prey)-293(to)-292(the)-292(degrading)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(superstitions)-395(above)-395(referred)-394(to,)-431(that)-395(we)-395(find)-395(no)-395(indications)-394(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-276(in)-277(their)-276(pages?)-329(Also:)-302(how)-277(is)-276(it)-276(possible)-276(that)-277(men)-276(of)-276(such)-276(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-180(should)-180(have)-180(invented)-180(such)-180(a)-180(number)-180(of)-180(noble)-180(creations?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Let)-278(unbelievers)-279(account)-278(for)-279(this)-278(on)-279(any)-278(principle)-279(which)-278(a)-278(sound)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(philosophy)-250(can)-250(recognise.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-394(further:)-537(the)-394(Gospels)-394(mention)-393(a)-394(certain)-394(number)-394(of)-393(pos-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(sessions,)-427(and)-391(their)-391(cures)-392(effected)-391(by)-391(our)-392(Lord.)-674(Here)-391(then)-391(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-324(in)-324(the)-324(very)-324(presence)-324(of)-324(a)-324(demonology)-324(such)-324(as)-324(was)-324(actually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believed)-240(in)-239(by)-240(the)-240(followers)-239(of)-240(Jesus.)-247(Here,)-241(therefore,)-242(is)-240(the)-239(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(condition)-245(of)-244(mind)-244(and)-245(outward)-244(circumstances)-245(where,)-245(if)-245(they)-244(had)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-201(a)-200(prey)-201(to)-200(the)-201(phantastic)-200(and)-201(disgusting)-200(beliefs)-201(about)-200(demons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(above)-305(referred)-305(to,)-319(such)-305(beliefs)-305(would)-305(certainly)-305(have)-305(made)-305(their)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1232 0 obj <<
/Length 4822      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(265)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(appearance)-223(in)-223(their)-223(pages.)-241(But,)-228(as)-223(I)-222(have)-223(shown,)-229(the)-222(demonology)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-206(the)-205(Gospels)-206(stands)-206(in)-206(marked)-205(contrast)-206(to)-206(that)-205(of)-206(the)-206(Talmud,)-214(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Josephus,)-246(and)-244(of)-245(the)-488(Christian)-245(Fathers.)-248(We)-245(have)-244(no)-244(fumigations)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([301])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(of)-216(demoniacs)-216(with)-215(the)-216(liver)-216(of)-216(a)-216(fish,)-222(we)-216(hear)-216(nothing)-216(of)-216(a)-215(demon)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(drawn)-390(out)-390(of)-391(a)-390(man's)-390(nose,)-425(and)-391(overturning)-390(a)-390(basin)-390(of)-390(water,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nothing)-276(of)-276(a)-276(demon)-276(inhabiting)-276(every)-276(private)-276(closet.)-328(On)-276(the)-275(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(trary,)-270(their)-266(action)-266(is)-266(described)-266(as)-266(mental,)-270(and,)-270(through)-266(the)-266(mind,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affecting)-265(the)-266(body,)-269(with)-265(the)-265(exception)-266(of)-265(a)-265(few)-265(doubtful)-266(cases.)-295(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(am)-228(not)-228(here)-228(arguing)-228(whether)-228(a)-228(belief)-228(in)-228(the)-228(reality)-228(of)-228(demoniacal)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(possession)-243(is)-243(a)-243(superstition)-243(or)-243(not.)-248(But)-243(I)-243(affirm)-243(that)-243(if)-242(the)-243(writers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-294(the)-293(New)-294(Testament)-293(had)-294(been)-293(a)-293(prey)-294(to)-293(the)-294(superstitions)-293(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-351(they)-351(are)-352(charged,)-376(these)-351(are)-352(the)-351(narratives)-351(in)-351(which)-351(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(could)-355(not)-356(have)-355(failed)-355(to)-356(make)-355(their)-355(appearance.)-566(Again:)-461(It)-355(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-224(affirmed)-224(that)-224(they)-224(held)-224(a)-223(monstrous)-224(angelology.)-242(I)-224(reply)-223(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(although)-254(angels)-255(are)-254(unquestionably)-254(stated)-255(to)-254(have)-254(appeared,)-255(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-270(existence)-271(is)-270(affirmed)-270(by)-270(the)-270(writers)-271(of)-270(the)-270(New)-270(Testament,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(still)-357(their)-357(recorded)-357(appearances)-358(are)-357(rare.)-571(They)-357(are)-357(confined)-357(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-413(few)-413(very)-413(remarkable)-413(occasions,)-454(viz.:)-576(the)-413(Annunciation)-413(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(birth)-326(of)-326(our)-326(Lord,)-346(the)-326(temptation,)-345(the)-326(agony)-326(in)-326(the)-326(garden,)-345(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-353(resurrection.)-559(Surely)-353(this)-353(does)-353(not)-353(look)-353(as)-353(if)-353(the)-353(authors)-352(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-340(Gospels)-340(thought)-341(that)-340(they)-340(were)-340(always)-340(interfering)-340(with)-340(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(course)-235(of)-235(nature)-235(or)-235(the)-234(events)-235(of)-235(life.)-245(In)-235(the)-235(Acts)-235(of)-235(the)-234(Apostles,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-321(appear)-322(at)-321(the)-321(Ascension;)-357(once)-321(to)-321(liberate)-321(St.)-464(Peter,)-339(and)-321(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(another)-236(time)-236(the)-235(Apostles,)-239(from)-236(prison;)-240(to)-236(direct)-236(Philip)-236(to)-235(preach)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-289(the)-289(eunuch;)-309(twice)-289(in)-289(a)-290(vision)-289(to)-289(St.)-367(Paul;)-309(and)-289(Herod)-289(Agrippa)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-382(also)-383(said)-382(to)-382(have)-382(been)-383(smitten)-382(by)-382(the)-383(ministry)-382(of)-382(an)-382(angel.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(There)-371(were)-371(certainly)-371(many)-372(occasions)-371(when,)-401(if)-371(the)-371(writers)-371(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believed)-323(in)-322(the)-323(habitual)-323(intervention)-323(of)-322(angels,)-341(we)-323(should)-322(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(found)-259(them)-259(introduced.)-276(Thus)-259(an)-259(angel)-259(is)-259(not)-259(sent)-259(to)-259(deliver)-258(Paul)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-402(prison,)-441(or)-402(to)-402(still)-403(the)-402(tempest,)-440(but)-403(simply)-402(to)-402(assure)-402(him)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-326(his)-327(safety.)-479(St.)-478(Paul)-327(enumerates)-326(in)-326(a)-327(passage)-326(of)-326(some)-326(length)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-269(various)-270(dangers)-269(which)-269(beset)-539(him)-270(in)-269(his)-269(missions,)-274(especially)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([302])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(mentioning)-206(the)-206(perils)-206(he)-206(encountered)-206(in)-206(travel.)-235(But)-206(neither)-206(he)-206(nor)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(St.)-368(Luke)-289(once)-290(refers)-289(to)-290(an)-289(angelic)-289(intervention)-290(in)-289(his)-289(favour.)-368(In)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1237 0 obj <<
/Length 4672      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(266)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(numerous)-286(passages)-286(he)-285(refers)-286(to)-286(dangers)-286(and)-286(persecutions)-285(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-223(encountered.)-241(But)-222(it)-223(is)-223(our)-222(Lord,)-228(and)-223(not)-223(angels,)-228(who)-222(delivered)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(him.)-272(Is)-257(this)-257(consistent)-257(with)-257(a)-258(belief)-257(in)-257(their)-257(habitual)-257(intervention)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-270(nature?)-312(If)-270(he)-271(was)-270(the)-271(visionary)-270(which)-271(he)-270(has)-271(been)-270(asserted)-270(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-248(been,)-248(would)-248(he)-248(not)-247(have)-248(been)-248(continually)-248(seeing)-248(visions)-247(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(angels)-250(for)-250(his)-250(protection?)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(In)-378(St.)-634(Paul's)-378(writings)-378(we)-378(are)-378(in)-378(the)-378(presence)-378(of)-377(documents)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(which)-468(are)-468(in)-467(the)-468(highest)-468(degree)-468(historical.)-903(Even)-468(those)-467(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(endeavour)-263(to)-264(prove)-263(that)-263(the)-264(Gospels)-263(and)-263(the)-264(Acts)-263(were)-263(not)-263(writ-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ten)-374(until)-374(the)-374(second)-374(century,)-405(are)-374(obliged)-374(to)-374(allow)-374(that)-374(at)-373(least)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(four)-309(of)-308(the)-309(most)-308(important)-308(of)-309(his)-308(letters)-309(were)-308(written)-309(within)-308(30)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(years)-251(after)-251(the)-250(Crucifixion,)-251(and)-251(that)-251(the)-250(evidence)-251(that)-251(four)-251(of)-250(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remainder)-269(are)-269(his,)-274(vastly)-269(preponderates.)-307(Here)-269(then)-269(we)-269(are)-268(in)-269(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presence)-261(of)-261(historical)-261(documents)-261(of)-261(the)-262(highest)-261(order,)-263(compared)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-225(which)-224(such)-225(a)-224(writing)-225(as)-224(the)-225(book)-224(of)-225(Enoch)-224(is)-225(worthless,)-229(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-211(Talmud)-210(and)-211(the)-210(Fathers)-211(are)-210(modern)-211(compositions.)-237(What)-210(light)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(then)-332(do)-331(these)-332(letters)-331(throw)-332(on)-332(the)-331(opinions)-332(of)-331(St.)-495(Paul)-332(and)-331(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Pauline)-310(Churches?)-431(Much)-311(every)-310(way:)-371(they)-310(let)-310(us)-311(into)-310(the)-310(secret)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-255(their)-254(inner)-255(life.)-263(They)-255(tell)-255(us)-254(that)-255(these)-254(Christians)-255(thought)-254(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessed)-223(certain)-223(supernatural)-223(gifts;)-232(that)-223(St.)-241(Paul)-223(asserted)-223(that)-222(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wrought)-329(miracles;)-369(that)-329(demons)-328(by)-329(an)-329(invisible)-329(agency)-329(tempted)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(men)-274(to)-274(sin,)-280(and)-274(opposed)-274(the)-274(progress)-274(of)-274(the)-274(Gospel;)-286(but)-274(beyond)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-406(there)-407(is)-406(scarcely)-406(a)-406(trace)-406(of)-407(angelology)-406(or)-406(demonology)-406(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them.)-521(With)-341(these)-340(epistles)-341(in)-340(our)-341(hands,)-363(is)-340(it)-341(credible)-340(that)-340(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writer,)-223(or)-216(those)-217(to)-216(whom)-217(he)-216(wrote,)-223(held)-216(a)-217(multitude)-216(of)-216(monstrous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-384(phantastic)-385(beliefs)-384(on)-384(this)-385(subject?)-653(Are)-384(not)-384(these)-384(writings)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(characterized)-261(by)-261(supreme)-262(good)-261(sense?)-283(Do)-523(they)-261(not)-261(in)-261(this)-261(point)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([303])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(of)-427(view)-426(marvellously)-427(contrast)-426(even)-427(with)-427(those)-426(of)-427(the)-426(earliest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Fathers?)-484(The)-327(writer)-328(undoubtedly)-328(believed)-328(that)-328(unseen)-327(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agencies)-359(were)-360(capable)-359(of)-360(acting)-359(on)-359(the)-360(mind)-359(of)-359(man,)-387(and)-359(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-446(were)-447(active)-446(agents)-446(in)-447(the)-446(production)-446(of)-447(moral)-446(evil;)-544(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(where)-229(is)-229(the)-228(evidence)-229(that)-229(he)-228(considered)-229(that)-229(external)-229(nature)-228(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(under)-318(their)-319(control,)-335(or)-318(that)-318(they)-319(made)-318(themselves)-318(visible)-318(to)-318(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mortal)-208(eye?)-235(Although)-208(he)-208(affirms)-207(that)-208(he)-207(possessed)-208(a)-207(supernatural)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1241 0 obj <<
/Length 4670      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(267)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(illumination)-212(on)-213(religious)-212(subjects,)-220(only)-213(on)-212(two)-213(occasions)-212(does)-212(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(refer)-297(to)-296(visions)-296(as)-297(actually)-296(seen)-297(by)-296(him;)-320(and)-297(he)-296(directly)-296(affirms)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-423(he)-423(had)-422(the)-423(power)-423(of)-423(dist)1(inguishing)-423(the)-423(ecstatic)-423(from)-422(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ordinary)-353(condition)-353(of)-353(his)-353(mind.)-558(Even)-353(with)-353(the)-353(aid)-353(of)-353(the)-352(Acts)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-400(the)-401(Apostles,)-437(we)-401(can)-400(only)-400(add)-400(a)-401(few)-400(more)-400(to)-400(the)-400(number.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Surely)-270(this)-269(is)-270(not)-269(the)-270(mental)-269(condition)-270(of)-270(a)-269(man)-270(who)-269(was)-270(a)-269(prey)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-348(unbounded)-347(superstition.)-543(Contrast)-347(the)-348(amount)-347(of)-348(good)-347(sense)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-310(the)-310(epistles)-311(of)-310(St.)-430(Paul)-311(with)-310(an)-310(equal)-310(number)-310(of)-310(consecutive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pages)-389(from)-389(the)-389(Fathers)-389(and)-389(the)-389(Talmud,)-424(and)-389(the)-389(di)1(fference)-389(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(enormous.)-761(Where)-420(are)-420(the)-421(i)1(neffable)-421(puerilities)-420(found)-420(in)-420(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writings)-250(even)-250(hinted)-250(at)-250(in)-250(those)-250(of)-250(St.)-250(Paul?)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Again:)-515(if)-383(we)-382(include)-383(in)-382(our)-383(examination)-382(the)-383(other)-382(writings)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-359(the)-359(New)-359(Testament,)-386(they)-359(wholly)-359(fail)-359(to)-359(supply)-359(us)-359(with)-359(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-271(of)-272(the)-271(superstition)-272(or)-271(credulity)-271(of)-272(their)-271(authors.)-314(On)-271(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contrary)-378(they)-377(are)-378(characterized)-377(by)-378(the)-378(marks)-377(of)-378(uniform)-377(good)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sense.)-779(It)-427(will)-426(be)-427(doubt)1(less)-427(objected)-426(that)-427(they,)-470(as)-427(well)-426(as)-426(St.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Paul,)-343(were)-325(bad)-325(logicians,)-343(and)-324(that)-325(their)-325(applications)-324(of)-325(the)-324(Old)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-431(Scriptures)-431(are)-431(inapt:)-613(but)-431(this)-431(does)-431(not)-431(affect)-431(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(trustworthiness)-399(as)-398(historians.)-697(They)-398(were)-399(undoubtedly)-399(men)-398(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-359(religious)-360(fervour,)-386(yet)-359(they)-360(are)-359(both)-359(sparing)-360(in)-359(the)-359(use)-359(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles,)-393(and)-365(when)-365(they)-364(report)-365(them,)-393(the)-365(miraculous)-365(action)-364(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(never)-402(represented)-402(as)-403(extending)-402(beyond)-402(the)-402(necessities)-402(of)-402(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([304])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(case.)-524(Their)-341(miracles)-342(consist)-341(of)-341(simple)-341(acts,)-365(as)-341(for)-341(instance)-341(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cure)-193(of)-193(diseases,)-204(but)-193(all)-192(marvellous)-193(superadditions)-193(are)-193(wanting.)-230(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-182(been)-183(urged)-182(that)-183(in)-182(comparing)-182(the)-183(miracles)-182(of)-183(the)-182(Gospels)-182(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-351(miraculous)-351(narratives,)-376(we)-351(have)-351(no)-351(right)-351(to)-351(do)-351(more)-350(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(compare)-212(the)-212(external)-212(miracle)-212(of)-212(the)-212(one)-212(with)-212(the)-212(external)-212(miracle)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-251(the)-251(other;)-251(as)-251(for)-250(instance)-251(a)-251(resurrection)-251(with)-251(a)-250(resurrection,)-251(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-274(cure)-273(of)-274(blindness)-273(recorded)-274(in)-274(one)-273(with)-274(a)-273(similar)-274(case)-273(recorded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-335(another;)-378(and)-335(not)-335(to)-335(take)-336(into)-335(account)-335(either)-335(the)-335(external)-335(cir-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cumstances)-267(or)-267(the)-267(moral)-267(aspect)-267(of)-267(the)-267(miracle.)-301(I)-267(have)-267(elsewhere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proved)-263(that)-263(this)-263(position)-263(is)-264(untenable.)-289(But)-263(for)-263(the)-263(purpose)-263(of)-263(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(argument)-334(let)-334(us)-334(here)-334(assume)-334(that)-334(all)-334(the)-334(circumstances)-334(may)-334(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-369(invention)-369(of)-369(the)-368(narrator.)-607(If)-369(it)-369(be)-369(so,)-398(it)-369(proves)-369(at)-369(any)-368(rate)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1246 0 obj <<
/Length 4714      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(268)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(the)-398(soundness)-397(of)-398(his)-398(judgment)-397(and)-398(the)-398(elevation)-397(of)-398(his)-397(ideas,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 16.979 0 Td [(that)-278(it)-278(is)-278(impossible)-278(that)-278(he)-279(could)-278(have)-278(been)-278(either)-278(intensely)]TJ -16.979 -13.549 Td [(superstitious)-328(or)-328(credulous.)-484(How)-328(is)-328(it)-328(possible,)-348(I)-328(ask,)-347(for)-328(minds)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-284(were)-283(a)-284(prey)-283(to)-283(such)-284(monstrous)-283(beliefs)-284(as)-283(those)-284(which)-283(we)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-219(been)-218(considering,)-225(to)-219(have)-218(dramatized)-219(miraculous)-218(narratives)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-325(the)-324(elevated)-325(type)-325(of)-324(those)-325(contained)-324(in)-325(the)-325(Gospels?)-473(Would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-312(all)-311(the)-312(circumstances)-312(with)-311(which)-312(they)-312(invested)-311(them)-312(be)-311(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(counter-part)-250(of)-250(their)-250(own)-250(degraded)-250(conceptions?)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-370(there)-371(is)-370(one)-371(most)-370(distinctive)-371(phenomenon)-370(presented)-370(by)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-334(Gospels)-334(which)-335(affords)-334(a)-334(conclusive)-334(proof)-334(that)-334(neither)-334(their)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(authors)-186(nor)-186(the)-186(followers)-186(of)-185(Jesus)-186(could)-186(have)-186(been)-186(a)-186(prey)-186(to)-185(either)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(degrading)-364(superstition)-365(or)-364(credulous)-365(fanaticism.)-593(I)-365(allude)-364(to)-364(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-191(that,)-203(whatever)-192(theory)-191(may)-192(be)-191(propounded)-191(to)-192(account)-191(for)-191(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(origin,)-336(the)-319(Gospels,)-336(as)-319(a)-319(matter)-319(of)-319(fact,)-336(unquestionably)-319(contain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-308(delineation)-308(of)-308(the)-308(greatest)-308(of)-307(all)-308(characters,)-323(whether)-308(actual)-307(or)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ideal,)-438(that)-400(of)-400(Jesus)-400(Christ.)-701(I)-400(shall)-400(hereafter)-400(draw)-400(attention)-400(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-334(portraiture)-334(of)-334(this)-335(character)-334(for)-334(the)-334(purpose)-334(of)-334(proving)-334(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-315(are)-629(veritable)-315(historical)-315(documents.)-444(In)-315(this)-314(place)-315(I)-315(refer)-314(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([305])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(it)-283(simply)-283(for)-284(the)-283(purpose)-283(of)-283(proving)-284(that)-283(their)-283(authors)-283(and)-283(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-220(invented)-219(the)-220(alleged)-220(fictions)-220(of)-219(which)-220(their)-220(contents)-219(consist,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(were)-439(possessed)-439(of)-439(a)-438(soundness)-439(of)-439(judgment)-439(which)-439(is)-438(wholly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inconsistent)-278(with)-279(the)-278(truth)-278(of)-279(the)-278(assertion)-278(that)-279(they)-278(were)-278(a)-278(prey)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(boundless)-250(superstition)-250(or)-250(credulity.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(For)-254(the)-255(purpose)-254(of)-255(the)-254(argument)-254(I)-255(must)-254(assume)-255(that)-254(this)-254(char-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(acter)-243(is)-244(a)-243(fictitious)-244(one,)-244(because)-244(to)-243(assume)-244(that)-243(it)-244(is)-243(a)-243(delineation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-384(an)-383(actual)-384(historical)-384(character,)-417(would)-384(be)-383(to)-384(take)-384(for)-383(granted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-387(entire)-387(question)-387(at)-387(issue.)-662(If)-387(the)-387(Jesus)-387(of)-387(the)-387(Evangelists)-387(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(an)-419(historical)-419(personage,)-461(there)-419(can)-419(be)-419(no)-419(doubt)-419(respecting)-419(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(claims)-336(of)-336(the)-335(Gospel)-336(to)-336(be)-336(a)-335(divine)-336(revelation.)-507(But)-336(even)-336(if)-335(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(make)-214(the)-213(assumption)-214(above)-213(mentioned,)-221(it)-214(is)-214(quite)-213(clear)-214(that)-213(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(persons)-340(who)-340(invented)-340(the)-340(character,)-363(or)-340(who)-340(put)-340(it)-340(together)-340(out)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-270(the)-270(number)-270(of)-270(legendary)-270(stories)-270(floating)-270(about)-270(in)-270(the)-270(Church,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(must)-280(have)-281(been)-280(possessed)-280(of)-280(a)-281(sound)-280(judgment,)-288(and)-280(the)-280(highest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(appreciation)-224(of)-225(what)-224(was)-225(great)-224(and)-225(noble.)-241(The)-225(character)-224(we)-224(have)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1250 0 obj <<
/Length 4662      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(269)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(before)-310(us,)-325(and)-310(it)-309(is)-310(confessedly)-310(the)-310(noblest)-310(which)-310(can)-310(be)-309(found)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(either)-344(in)-345(history)-344(or)-345(fiction.)-533(The)-345(inventors,)-368(whoever)-344(they)-344(were,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-342(succeeded)-343(in)-342(portraying)-343(a)-342(great)-343(harmonious)-342(whole.)-527(Such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-341(character)-340(could)-341(only)-340(have)-340(been)-341(delineated)-340(by)-341(men)-340(possessed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-392(sound)-392(discriminating)-392(judgment.)-677(The)-392(more)-392(the)-392(Gospels)-392(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(depreciated)-237(as)-237(histories)-237(the)-237(more)-237(does)-237(this)-237(depreciation)-236(establish)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-429(credit)-428(of)-429(their)-428(authors)-429(as)-428(the)-429(successful)-428(delineators)-429(of)-428(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ideal)-419(character,)-462(to)-419(which)-419(they)-419(have)-419(succeeded)-419(in)-419(imparting)-419(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(naturalness)-229(which)-229(men)-229(of)-229(the)-229(most)-229(exalted)-229(genius)-229(have)-229(mistaken)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(for)-188(an)-188(historical)-188(reality.)-229(They)-189(must)-188(have)-188(been,)-200(therefore,)-200(consum-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mate)-290(masters)-290(of)-290(the)-290(art)-290(of)-290(ideal)-290(delineation.)-370(The)-290(mental)-289(powers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adequate)-240(to)-241(effect)-240(such)-241(results)-240(are)-240(those)-241(of)-240(high)-241(genius,)-242(to)-240(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-241(this)-242(case)-241(must)-242(have)-241(been)-242(added)-241(a)-242(very)-241(elevated)-242(conception)-482(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([306])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(morality.)-282(Such)-260(mental)-261(qualities)-261(are)-260(never)-261(exhibited)-260(by)-261(men)-260(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-304(the)-304(prey)-304(of)-304(gross)-303(credulity)-304(and)-304(superstition.)-412(The)-304(great)-303(ideal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(delineations)-285(of)-285(poets)-285(have)-284(been)-285(only)-285(capable)-285(of)-285(being)-284(produced)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-278(the)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 30.302 0 Td [(\351lite)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 21.816 0 Td [(of)-278(the)-278(human)-278(race.)-333(On)-278(the)-278(other)-278(hand,)-284(if)-278(we)-278(assume)]TJ -52.118 -13.549 Td [(that)-257(the)-258(character)-257(is)-257(a)-258(fictitious)-257(one,)-259(and)-257(its)-258(inventors)-257(men)-257(of)-257(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mental)-379(calibre)-378(which)-379(they)-379(are)-378(affirmed)-379(to)-379(have)-378(been)-379(by)-378(those)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(against)-242(whom)-242(I)-242(am)-242(reasoning,)-244(it)-242(would)-242(have)-242(been)-242(inevitable)-242(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-367(proportions)-367(should)-367(be)-367(marred)-367(by)-367(the)-367(introduction)-367(into)-367(it)-366(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(traits)-250(marked)-250(by)-250(meanness,)-250(puerility,)-250(and)-250(monstrosity.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(In)-295(support)-295(of)-295(this)-294(assertion)-295(we)-295(have)-295(no)-295(occasion)-295(to)-295(appeal)-294(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(theories)-224(but)-224(to)-224(facts.)-241(Happily)-224(antiquity)-224(has)-224(preserved)-224(to)-224(us)-223(sever-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(al)-301(delineations)-300(of)-301(a)-300(mythical)-301(Jesus)-300(on)-301(which)-300(the)-301(inventors)-300(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stamped)-355(the)-354(most)-355(unmistakable)-355(impress)-354(of)-355(their)-355(own)-354(credulity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-310(superstition.)-431(I)-310(need)-311(not)-310(say)-310(that)-310(I)-311(allude)-310(to)-310(the)-310(Apocryphal)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Gospels,)-232(the)-229(delineations)-228(of)-228(Jesus)-228(which)-228(they)-228(contain,)-232(and)-228(above)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-448(to)-448(their)-448(miraculous)-448(narratives.)-844(Those)-448(who)-448(reiterate)-447(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(charges)-341(against)-341(the)-341(authors)-341(of)-341(the)-341(Canonical)-341(Gospels,)-363(are)-341(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(slow)-415(to)-414(draw)-415(attention)-414(to)-415(their)-414(bearing)-414(on)-415(this)-414(portion)-415(of)-414(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(argument.)-661(In)-388(the)-387(Apocryphal)-387(Gospels)-387(we)-387(are)-387(brought)-387(face)-387(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(face)-317(with)-318(the)-317(legendary)-317(spirit)-317(exerting)-317(itself)-318(in)-317(the)-317(invention)-317(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miraculous)-224(stories.)-241(There)-224(can)-224(be)-224(no)-224(doubt)-224(that)-224(their)-224(authors)-224(were)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1114 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 984
/Length 9116      
>>
stream
1110 0 1116 66 1118 185 1115 244 1120 310 1122 429 1119 488 1124 554 1126 673 1123 732
1128 798 1130 917 1131 976 1127 1034 1133 1100 1135 1219 1132 1278 1138 1344 1140 1463 1137 1522
1142 1600 1144 1719 1141 1778 1146 1844 1148 1963 1145 2022 1150 2088 1152 2207 1149 2266 1154 2332
1156 2451 1157 2509 1153 2567 1159 2645 1161 2764 1158 2822 1164 2888 1166 3007 1163 3065 1168 3155
1170 3274 1167 3333 1172 3411 1174 3530 1171 3588 1175 3654 1178 3695 1180 3773 1176 3892 1182 3950
1179 4009 1184 4075 1186 4194 1183 4252 1188 4330 1190 4449 1187 4507 1193 4585 1195 4704 1192 4763
1197 4841 1199 4960 1196 5019 1201 5085 1203 5204 1200 5263 1205 5341 1207 5460 1208 5519 1204 5577
1210 5655 1212 5774 1209 5833 1214 5923 1216 6042 1213 6101 1219 6167 1221 6286 1218 6345 1223 6411
1225 6530 1222 6589 1227 6667 1229 6786 1226 6845 1231 6911 1233 7030 1234 7089 1230 7146 1236 7212
1238 7331 1235 7389 1240 7455 1242 7574 1239 7633 1245 7699 1247 7818 1244 7877 1249 7955 1251 8074
% 1110 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1116 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1117 0 R
/Resources 1115 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1109 0 R
>>
% 1118 0 obj
<<
/D [1116 0 R /XYZ 265.632 285.384 null]
>>
% 1115 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1120 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1121 0 R
/Resources 1119 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1109 0 R
>>
% 1122 0 obj
<<
/D [1120 0 R /XYZ 298.205 355.585 null]
>>
% 1119 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1124 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1125 0 R
/Resources 1123 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1109 0 R
>>
% 1126 0 obj
<<
/D [1124 0 R /XYZ 198.462 420.876 null]
>>
% 1123 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1128 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1129 0 R
/Resources 1127 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1109 0 R
>>
% 1130 0 obj
<<
/D [1128 0 R /XYZ 313.227 491.077 null]
>>
% 1131 0 obj
<<
/D [1128 0 R /XYZ 272.544 79.691 null]
>>
% 1127 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1133 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1134 0 R
/Resources 1132 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1136 0 R
>>
% 1135 0 obj
<<
/D [1133 0 R /XYZ 327.401 160.986 null]
>>
% 1132 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1138 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1139 0 R
/Resources 1137 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1136 0 R
>>
% 1140 0 obj
<<
/D [1138 0 R /XYZ 269.442 217.638 null]
>>
% 1137 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1142 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1143 0 R
/Resources 1141 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1136 0 R
>>
% 1144 0 obj
<<
/D [1142 0 R /XYZ 139.175 271.835 null]
>>
% 1141 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1146 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1147 0 R
/Resources 1145 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1136 0 R
>>
% 1148 0 obj
<<
/D [1146 0 R /XYZ 357.018 337.126 null]
>>
% 1145 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1150 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1151 0 R
/Resources 1149 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1136 0 R
>>
% 1152 0 obj
<<
/D [1150 0 R /XYZ 327.401 393.778 null]
>>
% 1149 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1154 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1155 0 R
/Resources 1153 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1136 0 R
>>
% 1156 0 obj
<<
/D [1154 0 R /XYZ 252.35 450.429 null]
>>
% 1157 0 obj
<<
/D [1154 0 R /XYZ 307.229 66.142 null]
>>
% 1153 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1159 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1160 0 R
/Resources 1158 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1162 0 R
>>
% 1161 0 obj
<<
/D [1159 0 R /XYZ 46.771 121.468 null]
>>
% 1158 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1164 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1165 0 R
/Resources 1163 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1162 0 R
>>
% 1166 0 obj
<<
/D [1164 0 R /XYZ 93.543 174.612 null]
>>
% 1163 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1168 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1169 0 R
/Resources 1167 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1162 0 R
>>
% 1170 0 obj
<<
/D [1168 0 R /XYZ 168.786 231.187 null]
>>
% 1167 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1172 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1173 0 R
/Resources 1171 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1162 0 R
>>
% 1174 0 obj
<<
/D [1172 0 R /XYZ 93.543 463.706 null]
>>
% 1171 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1175 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index14) >>
% 1178 0 obj
(Chapter XIII. The Alleged Credulity Of The Followers Of Jesus.)
% 1180 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1181 0 R
/Resources 1179 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1162 0 R
>>
% 1176 0 obj
<<
/D [1180 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 1182 0 obj
<<
/D [1180 0 R /XYZ 209.082 134.983 null]
>>
% 1179 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1184 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1185 0 R
/Resources 1183 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1162 0 R
>>
% 1186 0 obj
<<
/D [1184 0 R /XYZ 341.97 201.634 null]
>>
% 1183 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1188 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1189 0 R
/Resources 1187 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1191 0 R
>>
% 1190 0 obj
<<
/D [1188 0 R /XYZ 46.771 255.089 null]
>>
% 1187 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1193 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1194 0 R
/Resources 1192 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1191 0 R
>>
% 1195 0 obj
<<
/D [1193 0 R /XYZ 310.969 299.751 null]
>>
% 1192 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1197 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1198 0 R
/Resources 1196 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1191 0 R
>>
% 1199 0 obj
<<
/D [1197 0 R /XYZ 295.875 366.679 null]
>>
% 1196 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1201 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1202 0 R
/Resources 1200 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1191 0 R
>>
% 1203 0 obj
<<
/D [1201 0 R /XYZ 167.194 420.876 null]
>>
% 1200 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1205 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1206 0 R
/Resources 1204 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1191 0 R
>>
% 1207 0 obj
<<
/D [1205 0 R /XYZ 284.658 504.626 null]
>>
% 1208 0 obj
<<
/D [1205 0 R /XYZ 263.959 106.79 null]
>>
% 1204 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1210 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1211 0 R
/Resources 1209 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1191 0 R
>>
% 1212 0 obj
<<
/D [1210 0 R /XYZ 129.329 176.172 null]
>>
% 1209 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1214 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1215 0 R
/Resources 1213 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1217 0 R
>>
% 1216 0 obj
<<
/D [1214 0 R /XYZ 277.865 244.736 null]
>>
% 1213 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1219 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1220 0 R
/Resources 1218 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1217 0 R
>>
% 1221 0 obj
<<
/D [1219 0 R /XYZ 191.797 299.751 null]
>>
% 1218 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1223 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1224 0 R
/Resources 1222 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1217 0 R
>>
% 1225 0 obj
<<
/D [1223 0 R /XYZ 226.388 367.497 null]
>>
% 1222 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1227 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1228 0 R
/Resources 1226 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1217 0 R
>>
% 1229 0 obj
<<
/D [1227 0 R /XYZ 199.527 423.331 null]
>>
% 1226 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1231 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1232 0 R
/Resources 1230 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1217 0 R
>>
% 1233 0 obj
<<
/D [1231 0 R /XYZ 137.742 491.077 null]
>>
% 1234 0 obj
<<
/D [1231 0 R /XYZ 189.918 98.15 null]
>>
% 1230 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1236 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1237 0 R
/Resources 1235 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1217 0 R
>>
% 1238 0 obj
<<
/D [1236 0 R /XYZ 280.52 160.986 null]
>>
% 1235 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1240 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1241 0 R
/Resources 1239 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1243 0 R
>>
% 1242 0 obj
<<
/D [1240 0 R /XYZ 327.401 228.732 null]
>>
% 1239 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1245 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1246 0 R
/Resources 1244 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1243 0 R
>>
% 1247 0 obj
<<
/D [1245 0 R /XYZ 132.516 285.384 null]
>>
% 1244 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1249 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1250 0 R
/Resources 1248 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1243 0 R
>>
% 1251 0 obj
<<
/D [1249 0 R /XYZ 315.68 355.585 null]
>>
endstream
endobj
1255 0 obj <<
/Length 4581      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(270)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(both)-222(extremely)-221(credulous)-222(and)-221(superstitious;)-231(and)-222(their)-221(miraculous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(narratives)-317(give)-316(us)-317(the)-316(precise)-316(measure)-317(of)-316(their)-317(credulity.)-449(There)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-340(every)-339(reason)-340(to)-339(believe)-340(that)-339(two)-340(of)-339(these)-340(compositions)-339(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(written)-233(as)-233(early)-233(as)-233(the)-233(second)-233(century.)-245(What,)-236(I)-233(ask,)-236(is)-233(the)-233(general)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(character)-378(of)-377(the)-378(miracles)-377(which)-377(they)-378(have)-377(attributed)-378(to)-377(Jesus?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(There)-333(can)-333(be)-333(only)-333(one)-333(answer.)-499(They)-333(are)-333(mean,)-354(ridiculous,)-353(de-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(graded,)-292(burlesque,)-293(destitute)-284(of)-284(all)-284(trait)-284(of)-284(moral)-284(grandeur.)-352(If)-283(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authors)-245(of)-246(the)-245(four)-246(Gospels,)-246(or)-245(the)-246(inventors)-245(of)-246(their)-490(miraculous)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([307])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(narratives,)-463(whoever)-420(they)-420(may)-421(have)-420(been,)-463(had)-420(been)-420(a)-420(prey)-420(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(similar)-238(credulity)-238(and)-238(superstition,)-240(the)-238(marks)-238(of)-238(them)-238(would)-237(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-250(indelibly)-250(stamped)-250(on)-250(their)-250(pages.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(These)-328(documents)-329(also)-328(contain)-329(accounts)-328(of)-329(miracles)-328(wrought)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(by)-350(Jesus,)-375(some)-350(of)-350(which,)-375(as)-350(bare)-350(facts,)-375(are)-350(precisely)-350(the)-350(same)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-394(some)-394(recorded)-393(in)-394(the)-394(Canonical)-394(Gospels,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 204.669 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 20.764 0 Td [(they)-394(contain)]TJ -225.433 -13.549 Td [(accounts)-217(of)-217(resurrections)-217(from)-217(the)-217(dead,)-224(and)-217(the)-216(cure)-217(of)-217(diseases.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(I)-396(ask,)-432(do)-396(their)-395(accompanying)-396(circumstances)-396(and)-396(moral)-395(aspect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stand)-187(as)-188(nothing)-187(in)-187(our)-188(estimate)-187(of)-187(the)-188(credibility)-187(of)-187(their)-187(authors?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Compare)-194(the)-195(account)-194(of)-194(the)-195(resurrection)-194(of)-194(Lazarus,)-206(or)-194(that)-194(of)-194(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Lord)-271(himself,)-276(with)-271(the)-271(resurrections)-271(in)-271(the)-271(Apocryphal)-270(Gospels,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-329(mark)-328(the)-329(difference.)-486(Compare)-329(likewise)-328(the)-329(other)-328(miracles,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which,)-393(as)-364(bare)-364(facts,)-393(resemble)-364(one)-364(another.)-592(The)-364(one)-364(have)-364(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stamp)-253(of)-253(historical)-253(probability,)-254(and)-253(precisely)-253(fit)-253(in)-253(with)-253(the)-253(lofty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-253(of)-254(Jesus;)-255(the)-253(other)-254(of)-253(an)-253(unbelievable)-254(legend,)-254(in)-253(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-319(character)-319(is)-319(degraded)-319(to)-319(a)-319(level)-319(with)-319(the)-319(conceptions)-319(of)-318(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inventors.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Let)-442(not)-442(unbelievers,)-491(therefore,)-490(decline)-442(to)-442(grapple)-442(with)-442(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(question.)-590(Let)-364(them)-363(cease)-363(to)-364(pass)-363(it)-363(over)-364(in)-363(silence.)-590(I)-363(propose)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-428(them)-429(the)-428(following)-429(questions)-428(for)-429(solution.)-785(If)-429(both)-428(sets)-428(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-263(originated)-262(with)-263(mi)1(nds)-263(intensely)-262(credulous)-263(and)-262(supersti-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tious,)-368(whence)-345(has)-345(come)-344(the)-345(difference)-344(between)-345(them?)-534(Why)-344(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-312(one)-312(set)-312(of)-312(miracles)-312(dignified,)-327(and)-312(the)-312(other)-312(mean?)-435(Whence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-304(entire)-304(difference)-304(of)-304(their)-305(moral)-304(aspect?)-412(Why)-304(is)-304(the)-304(Jesus)-304(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-358(Canonical)-359(Gospels)-358(the)-358(most)-359(elevated)-358(personage)-358(in)-358(history,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-253(the)-253(Jesus)-252(of)-253(the)-253(Apocryphal)-253(ones,)-253(one)-253(of)-253(the)-253(most)-253(mean)-252(and)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1259 0 obj <<
/Length 4575      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(271)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(silly?)-377(If)-292(two)-292(of)-292(the)-292(Apocryphal)-293(and)-292(the)-292(four)-292(Canonical)-292(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-312(the)-312(production)-311(of)-312(the)-312(superstition)-311(and)-312(credulity)-312(of)-312(the)-311(same)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(century,)-304(whence)-293(the)-293(marvellous)-293(contrast)-293(between)-293(them?)-378(Which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-203(the)-203(Fathers)-203(of)-203(the)-202(second)-406(or)-203(third)-203(century)-203(was)-203(equal)-203(to)-203(the)-202(task)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([308])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(of)-259(reducing)-259(a)-259(mass)-258(of)-259(floating)-259(legends,)-261(the)-259(creations)-259(of)-258(numbers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-388(superstitious)-388(men,)-422(into)-388(their)-388(present)-388(form,)-423(as)-388(they)-388(stand)-387(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-256(Canonical)-257(Gospels?)-268(Would)-256(they)-257(not)-256(certainly)-256(have)-256(coloured)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-335(events)-335(with)-334(their)-335(own)-335(absurdities?)-504(If,)-356(on)-335(the)-335(other)-334(hand,)-356(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-278(allowed)-279(that)-278(the)-279(Canonical)-278(Gospels)-279(are)-278(the)-279(production)-278(of)-278(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(first)-359(century,)-385(and)-359(the)-358(Apocryphal)-359(Gospels)-358(of)-359(subsequent)-358(ones,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(how)-340(came)-341(the)-340(credulous)-340(followers)-340(of)-341(Jesus)-340(to)-340(produce)-340(fictions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dramatized)-231(with)-231(such)-231(admirable)-230(taste)-231(in)-231(the)-231(first)-231(century,)-235(and)-230(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same)-295(spirit)-295(in)-295(subsequent)-295(centuries)-295(to)-295(present)-295(so)-295(striking)-295(a)-294(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(trast?)-419(The)-306(only)-306(possible)-306(answer)-306(which)-307(can)-306(be)-306(returned)-306(to)-306(these)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(questions)-377(is)-377(that)-378(the)-377(phenomena)-377(of)-377(the)-377(Canonical)-377(Gospels)-377(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inconsistent)-231(with)-230(the)-231(supposition)-231(that)-230(their)-231(miraculous)-230(narratives)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-329(the)-329(invention)-329(of)-329(men)-329(who)-329(were)-329(the)-329(prey)-329(either)-329(of)-329(credulity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-425(dense)-425(superstition;)-513(they)-425(must)-425(have)-425(been)-425(men)-425(well)-425(able)-425(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinguish)-346(between)-347(a)-346(genuine)-347(miracle)-346(and)-346(a)-347(mythic)-346(parody)-346(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(one.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(But)-419(it)-419(has)-419(been)-418(urged)-419(that)-419(the)-419(dignified)-419(character)-419(of)-418(Jesus)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(induced)-384(the)-384(compilers)-384(of)-384(our)-384(present)-384(Gospels)-384(to)-384(select)-384(all)-383(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miraculous)-467(stories)-468(of)-467(a)-467(high)-468(type)-467(which)-467(were)-468(current)-467(in)-467(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hotbed)-374(of)-373(Christian)-374(fanaticism,)-404(and)-373(to)-374(attribute)-373(them)-374(to)-373(Jesus,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-316(to)-316(suppress)-316(all)-316(of)-316(a)-316(contrary)-316(description.)-448(If)-316(this)-316(be)-316(the)-315(true)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(solution)-286(of)-285(the)-286(facts,)-295(then)-285(it)-286(certainly)-286(follows)-285(that)-286(the)-285(compilers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-263(the)-263(Gospels)-264(must)-263(have)-263(been)-263(free)-264(from)-263(the)-263(superstitions)-263(of)-263(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(times)-215(in)-215(which)-215(they)-215(lived.)-238(Otherwise,)-222(how)-215(came)-215(they)-215(to)-215(select)-214(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-329(elevated)-329(stories)-329(and)-329(attribute)-329(them)-329(to)-329(Jesus,)-349(and)-329(to)-329(consign)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-409(of)-409(a)-409(lower)-409(type)-410(to)-409(a)-409(well-merited)-409(oblivion?)-727(Is)-409(it)-409(not)-409(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-237(that)-237(credulous)-237(and)-237(superstitious)-237(people)-237(have)-237(often)-236(attributed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(what)-329(is)-329(contemptible)-329(and)-329(mean)-329(to)-329(elevated)-329(characters?)-487(Let)-329(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Apocryphal)-398(Gospels)-398(bear)-398(witness.)-694(It)-398(follows,)-870(therefore,)-434(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([309])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(even)-278(on)-278(this)-278(supposition)-279(the)-278(question)-278(must)-278(be)-278(decided)-278(in)-278(favour)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1264 0 obj <<
/Length 3074      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(272)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(of)-297(the)-296(authors)-297(of)-296(our)-297(present)-297(Canonical)-296(Gospels,)-308(that)-297(they)-296(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-384(been)-383(free)-384(from)-383(the)-384(degraded)-384(superstitious)-383(to)-384(which)-383(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fellow-believers)-250(were)-250(a)-250(prey.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(But)-226(there)-227(is)-226(yet)-226(another)-227(problem,)-231(even)-226(if)-226(we)-227(assume)-226(the)-226(above)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(supposition)-432(to)-432(be)-432(true,)-477(which)-432(urgently)-432(demands)-432(solution.)-795(If,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(among)-288(the)-289(mass)-288(of)-288(legends)-289(with)-288(which)-288(the)-289(history)-288(of)-288(Jesus)-288(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incrusted,)-469(a)-425(certain)-425(portion)-425(of)-425(the)-425(miraculous)-425(stories)-424(were)-425(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-402(elevated)-402(type,)-441(who)-402(among)-402(His)-402(credulous)-402(and)-402(superstitious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(followers)-362(were)-362(the)-361(inventors)-362(of)-362(them?)-585(Were)-362(they)-362(men)-362(of)-361(like)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(credulity)-348(with)-348(the)-348(remainder?)-544(There)-348(are)-348(only)-348(two)-348(alternatives.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(They)-394(were,)-430(or)-393(they)-394(were)-394(not.)-682(If)-394(they)-393(were,)-430(I)-394(ask,)-430(how)-393(came)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-284(to)-284(invent)-284(elevated)-284(stories?)-352(If)-284(they)-284(were)-284(not,)-292(then)-284(it)-284(follows)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-322(there)-322(were)-322(persons)-322(among)-322(His)-322(followers)-322(who)-322(were)-321(neither)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intensely)-352(credulous)-351(nor)-352(superstitious.)-555(If)-351(the)-352(latter)-351(be)-352(the)-351(alter-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(native)-320(adopted,)-337(then)-320(the)-320(theory)-320(which)-320(I)-320(have)-320(been)-319(considering,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-268(attributes)-269(to)-268(the)-268(followers)-269(of)-268(Jesus)-268(such)-269(a)-268(degree)-268(of)-268(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(qualities)-251(as)-250(to)-250(render)-251(their)-250(historical)-251(testimony)-250(valueless,)-251(falls)-250(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(ground.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(It)-194(follows,)-206(therefore,)-206(on)-194(a)-195(careful)-194(consideration)-195(of)-194(the)-194(position,)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(that)-264(the)-263(data)-264(on)-263(which)-263(the)-264(charge)-263(which)-264(we)-263(have)-264(been)-263(consider-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ing)-264(is)-265(made)-264(against)-265(the)-264(followers)-264(of)-265(Jesus)-264(and)-264(the)-265(authors)-264(of)-264(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-237(utterly)-238(fail)-237(to)-238(establish)-237(it;)-242(and)-237(that)-237(the)-238(phenomena)-237(of)-237(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(New)-250(Testament)-250(prove)-250(the)-250(contrary)-250(to)-250(have)-250(been)-250(the)-250(fact.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -29.651 Td [([310])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1272 0 obj <<
/Length 3737      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-262(XIV.)-262(The)-262(Love)-261(Of)-262(The)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Marvellous)]TJ/F20 18.9589 Tf 86.358 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 18.9589 Tf 18.959 0 Td [(Its)-259(Bearing)-258(On)-259(The)]TJ -105.317 -24.646 Td [(Value)-250(Of)-250(Testimony)-250(To)-250(Miracles.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -37.658 Td [(It)-269(has)-269(been)-269(objected)-270(that)-269(the)-269(love)-269(of)-269(the)-269(marvellous)-269(has)-269(in)-269(every)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(age)-218(constituted)-217(so)-218(remarkable)-217(a)-218(phase)-217(of)-218(human)-217(nature)-218(as)-217(greatly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-184(weaken,)-197(if)-183(not)-184(entirely)-184(to)-183(invalidate)-184(the)-184(testimony)-183(to)-184(the)-183(perfor-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mance)-192(of)-191(miracles.)-231(It)-191(is)-192(alleged)-192(that)-191(the)-192(great)-191(historians)-192(of)-191(ancient)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(times)-210(have)-209(recorded)-210(a)-210(number)-209(of)-210(supernatural)-210(occurrences)-209(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-420(now)-421(summarily)-420(rejected)-420(as)-420(incredible:)-591(and)-420(it)-420(is)-420(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(argued)-307(that)-306(all)-307(narratives)-307(of)-306(miraculous)-307(occurrences)-307(must)-306(share)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-415(same)-415(fate.)-745(This)-415(objection)-415(differs)-415(from)-415(that)-415(which)-415(I)-414(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(considered)-210(in)-209(the)-209(former)-210(chapter,)-218(in)-209(that)-210(it)-209(avoids)-209(the)-210(necessity)-209(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(imputing)-228(to)-227(the)-228(followers)-228(of)-227(Jesus)-228(and)-228(the)-227(authors)-228(of)-228(the)-227(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-362(degree)-362(of)-362(superstition)-361(and)-362(credulity)-362(greatly)-362(in)-362(excess)-362(of)-361(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-238(characterizes)-237(the)-238(majority)-238(of)-237(mankind.)-246(It)-238(will)-238(be)-237(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary)-250(to)-250(give)-250(this)-250(subject)-250(a)-250(careful)-250(consideration.)]TJ 11.956 -14.597 Td [(It)-413(is)-413(an)-413(unquestionable)-414(fact)-413(that)-413(the)-413(human)-413(mind)-413(has)-413(been)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-339(all)-339(ages)-339(disposed)-340(to)-339(accept)-339(a)-339(number)-339(of)-339(narratives)-339(of)-339(super-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural)-251(occurrences)-251(upon)-251(very)-251(insufficient)-251(testimony,)-251(and)-251(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-310(principles)-311(of)-310(sound)-310(reason)-311(lead)-310(us)-310(to)-311(reject)-310(as)-310(untrue.)-431(Such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beliefs)-348(have)-348(been)-348(peculiar)-348(to)-348(no)-348(one)-348(period)-348(of)-348(the)-348(world's)-347(his-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tory,)-299(but)-290(have)-289(been)-290(co-extensive)-289(with)-290(the)-289(human)-290(race;)-309(and)-289(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(form)-340(one)-341(of)-340(the)-340(most)-341(remarkable)-340(facts)-340(in)-341(our)-340(nature.)-521(Many)-340(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-406(ancient)-406(historians)-406(have)-406(reported)-406(such)-406(occurrences)-405(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apparent)-265(suspicion;)-273(or)-266(if)-530(they)-266(entertained)-265(any)-265(doubts)-265(respecting)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([311])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(their)-349(truth,)-374(they)-349(did)-349(not)-350(venture)-349(even)-349(to)-349(whisper)-349(them)-349(into)-349(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(popular)-422(ear.)-764(What)-422(is)-421(still)-422(more;)-507(eminent)-422(men)-421(of)-422(the)-421(ancient)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(world)-291(did)-291(not)-291(scruple)-291(to)-291(act)-291(in)-291(matters)-291(of)-291(this)-291(kind)-291(a)-291(part)-290(which)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1277 0 obj <<
/Length 4801      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(274)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(they)-362(knew)-362(to)-361(be)-362(deceptive,)-390(because)-361(they)-362(held)-362(the)-362(opinion)-361(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-326(beliefs,)-344(though)-325(they)-326(might)-325(be)-326(laughed)-325(at)-326(by)-325(philosophers,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-253(necessary)-253(to)-252(act)-253(as)-253(restraints)-253(on)-253(the)-252(vulgar.)-259(Thus)-253(we)-252(know,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-395(the)-394(most)-394(indubitable)-395(authority,)-431(that)-394(a)-395(Roman)-394(Augur)-394(could)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(gravely)-236(act)-235(his)-236(part)-236(before)-235(the)-236(public)-236(at)-235(the)-236(very)-236(time)-235(that)-236(he)-235(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(secretly)-370(laughing)-370(in)-370(his)-370(sleeve)-370(at)-370(the)-370(ridiculousness)-370(of)-370(his)-369(art.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-303(does)-304(not)-303(therefore)-304(follow)-303(because)-303(the)-304(ancient)-303(historians)-303(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reported)-216(numbers)-217(of)-216(occurrences)-217(of)-216(this)-217(nature)-216(with)-216(considerable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gravity,)-316(that)-303(they)-302(accepted)-303(them)-302(as)-303(facts.)-408(They)-303(were)-302(frequently)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(influenced)-247(by)-247(the)-247(spirit)-247(of)-248(accommodation,)-247(thinking)-247(it)-247(necessary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-413(the)-412(welfare)-413(of)-413(society)-413(to)-412(keep)-413(up)-413(the)-412(vulgar)-413(ideas)-413(on)-412(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subject.)-873(It)-458(would)-458(be)-458(inaccurate)-457(therefore)-458(to)-458(attribute)-458(all)-457(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accounts)-233(of)-233(such)-233(things)-232(which)-233(we)-233(meet)-233(with)-233(in)-233(ancient)-233(writers)-232(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(simple)-285(credulity,)-294(or)-285(to)-285(infer)-285(from)-285(them)-285(that)-285(they)-285(did)-284(not)-285(believe)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-345(an)-344(inviolable)-345(order)-344(of)-345(nature)-344(of)-344(some)-345(kind.)-533(With)-345(respect)-344(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-227(arts)-227(of)-227(magic,)-231(however,)-232(one)-226(feels)-227(that)-227(even)-227(the)-227(greatest)-227(of)-226(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ancient)-325(writers)-325(contemplated)-325(them)-324(with)-325(a)-325(kind)-325(of)-325(bated)-324(breath.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-197(would)-198(appear)-197(to)-198(have)-197(been)-197(the)-198(state)-197(of)-197(mind)-198(even)-197(of)-197(Tacitus,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-362(one)-362(exception)-362(the)-361(greatest)-362(historian)-362(of)-362(the)-362(ancient)-361(world,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-229(one)-229(who)-229(was)-229(intimately)-229(acquainted)-229(with)-229(the)-229(various)-228(systems)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-405(its)-406(philosophy.)-716(Conscious)-405(as)-406(he)-405(was)-405(that)-406(vast)-405(numbers)-405(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-259(professors)-259(of)-259(magic)-258(were)-259(impostors,)-261(he)-259(seems)-259(hardly)-259(able)-258(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(realize)-250(the)-250(fact)-250(that)-250(the)-250(whole)-250(art)-250(was)-250(a)-250(delusion.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-280(has)-280(been)-280(affirmed)-281(that)-280(the)-280(progress)-280(of)-280(physical)-280(science)-280(has)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(destroyed)-223(in)-223(this)-223(nineteenth)-223(century)-223(all)-223(belief)-223(in)-223(the)-223(actual)-222(occur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rence)-271(of)-271(the)-271(supernatural,)-276(and)-542(that)-271(it)-271(now)-271(prevails)-271(only)-271(in)-270(some)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([312])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(of)-367(the)-367(dark)-367(corners)-366(of)-367(Christendom.)-601(The)-367(widespread)-367(belief)-366(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-293(phenomena)-293(of)-292(spiritualism,)-304(which)-292(is)-293(certainly)-293(very)-293(far)-292(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-281(confined)-280(to)-281(religious)-280(men,)-288(and)-281(from)-280(which)-281(some)-280(students)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-290(physical)-290(science)-290(have)-291(not)-290(been)-290(exempt,)-300(is)-290(a)-290(striking)-290(proof)-290(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-282(contrary.)-344(All)-282(that)-282(can)-281(be)-282(affirmed)-282(with)-281(truth)-282(is)-281(that,)-290(in)-281(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modern)-278(times,)-285(these)-278(forms)-277(of)-278(belief)-278(have)-278(taken)-278(a)-278(new)-277(direction.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Modern)-229(science)-228(has)-229(done)-228(much)-229(to)-228(establish)-229(and)-228(spread)-229(the)-228(belief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-233(the)-232(operations)-233(of)-233(all)-232(natural,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 143.425 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.995 0 Td [(material)-233(forces)-232(are)-233(uniform.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1281 0 obj <<
/Length 4720      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(275)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(Many)-273(of)-273(its)-272(students)-273(have)-273(even)-273(brought)-272(themselves)-273(to)-273(the)-272(belief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-344(the)-344(occurrence)-345(of)-344(any)-344(event)-344(whose)-345(existence)-344(is)-344(due)-344(to)-344(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-179(of)-178(any)-179(other)-178(than)-179(the)-178(known)-179(forces)-179(of)-178(nature,)-193(is)-178(impossible:)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(though)-290(this)-290(is)-290(far)-290(from)-290(being)-290(the)-290(invariable,)-300(and)-290(is)-290(certainly)-289(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-275(necessary)-275(result)-274(of)-275(its)-275(study.)-324(Still,)-281(probably,)-281(the)-275(most)-274(ardent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(votary)-328(of)-328(these)-328(opinions)-329(would)-328(find)-328(it)-328(difficult)-328(to)-328(keep)-328(himself)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wholly)-225(free)-226(from)-225(terrors)-226(arising)-225(from)-226(unseen)-225(causes,)-231(if)-225(they)-225(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aroused)-332(by)-331(a)-332(suitable)-331(apparatus.)-494(The)-332(study)-331(of)-332(physical)-331(science)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-312(far)-312(from)-312(being)-311(a)-312(universal)-312(safeguard)-312(against)-312(the)-312(invasions)-311(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(superstition.)-425(Its)-309(causes)-308(lie)-309(far)-308(more)-309(deeply)-308(rooted)-309(in)-308(our)-308(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-306(the)-306(principles)-307(of)-306(physical)-306(science)-306(can)-306(reach.)-419(Nor)-306(is)-306(it)-306(able)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(guard)-250(against)-250(an)-250(extravagant)-250(use)-250(of)-250(the)-250(imagination.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Whether,)-243(in)-240(the)-241(present)-241(state)-240(of)-241(our)-241(philosophy,)-242(we)-241(have)-240(fully)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(penetrated)-412(to)-411(the)-412(depths)-411(of)-412(this)-411(principle)-412(thus)-411(working)-412(in)-411(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mind)-306(of)-306(man,)-320(may)-306(admit)-306(of)-306(doubt;)-334(but)-306(its)-306(presence)-306(there,)-320(as)-305(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(essential)-245(portion)-245(of)-244(our)-245(nature,)-246(is)-245(an)-245(unquestionable)-244(fact.)-249(We)-244(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(not)-296(without)-296(the)-296(means)-297(of)-296(getting)-296(a)-296(general)-296(idea)-296(of)-296(its)-296(character.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-284(is)-285(doubtless)-284(intimately)-285(connected)-284(with)-284(those)-285(principles)-284(of)-284(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature)-323(which)-322(constitute)-323(man)-323(a)-323(religious)-322(being,)-341(and)-323(which)-322(form)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-320(fundamental)-319(part)-320(of)-320(his)-320(mental)-319(constitution.)-459(As)-320(such)-320(it)-319(must,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(like)-265(all)-265(our)-265(other)-265(faculties,)-537(have)-265(a)-265(legitimate)-265(and)-265(an)-265(illegitimate)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([313])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(action.)-464(It)-321(points,)-340(as)-321(we)-321(shall)-322(see,)-339(to)-321(the)-321(existence)-322(of)-321(the)-321(super-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural.)-494(A)-332(rational)-331(religion)-331(forms)-332(the)-331(object)-332(for)-331(its)-331(appropriate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exercise.)-232(Whenever)-196(man)-196(has)-197(been)-196(destitute)-196(of)-196(this,)-207(and)-196(his)-196(reason)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-367(been)-367(weak,)-396(this)-367(principle,)-396(devoid)-367(of)-367(its)-366(proper)-367(object,)-396(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(always)-359(manifested)-359(itself)-359(in)-359(various)-359(forms)-359(of)-359(extravagance.)-577(So)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(powerful)-288(is)-289(it)-288(in)-288(the)-289(human)-288(mind)-288(that)-289(even)-288(avowed)-288(atheism)-288(has)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(not)-198(been)-199(proof)-198(against)-199(its)-198(power.)-233(Julius)-198(C\346sar)-199(was)-198(an)-199(atheist,)-208(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessed)-212(one)-211(of)-212(the)-212(most)-211(powerful)-212(minds)-212(that)-211(ever)-212(inhabited)-211(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(human)-271(frame.)-314(Yet,)-276(on)-271(the)-271(great)-271(day)-272(of)-271(his)-271(triumph,)-276(he)-271(ascended)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-294(steps)-293(of)-294(the)-293(Capitol)-294(for)-293(the)-293(purpose)-294(of)-293(averting)-294(an)-293(avenging)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Nemesis.)-274(Napoleon)-257(the)-258(First)-258(was)-258(no)-258(atheist,)-260(though)-258(few)-257(persons)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(who)-304(have)-304(ever)-304(lived)-304(have)-304(been)-304(more)-304(free)-304(from)-304(the)-304(restraints)-303(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(religion)-209(or)-209(superstition.)-236(Although)-209(he)-208(possessed)-209(a)-209(mighty)-208(intellect)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1285 0 obj <<
/Length 4662      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(276)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(and)-257(was)-258(no)-257(stranger)-258(to)-257(the)-258(truths)-257(of)-258(modern)-257(science,)-260(yet)-257(even)-257(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believed)-345(in)-346(his)-345(star.)-537(Many)-345(other)-346(instances)-345(of)-346(men)-345(of)-345(powerful)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intellect)-183(who)-183(disbelieved)-183(in)-183(religion,)-196(yet)-183(who)-183(entertained)-183(singular)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(superstitions,)-387(might)-359(be)-359(easily)-360(adduced.)-578(I)-359(refer)-359(to)-360(them)-359(for)-359(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(purpose)-350(of)-351(proving)-350(that)-351(the)-350(principle)-351(out)-350(of)-351(which)-350(such)-350(things)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(originate)-246(must)-245(be)-246(one)-245(which)-246(is)-246(deep-seated)-245(in)-246(the)-245(nature)-246(of)-245(man,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-403(therefore)-404(an)-403(essential)-403(portion)-403(of)-403(it.)-710(If)-403(it)-404(is)-403(founded)-403(on)-403(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fundamental)-281(principle)-280(of)-281(our)-281(mental)-281(constitution,)-288(it)-281(follows)-280(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-273(must)-273(have)-272(a)-273(legitimate)-273(subject-matter)-272(on)-273(which)-273(to)-273(exercise)-272(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(powers,)-214(and)-204(that)-204(the)-205(abnormal)-204(forms)-205(of)-204(it)-204(which)-205(are)-204(so)-204(frequently)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manifested)-332(are)-331(the)-332(results)-331(of)-332(some)-331(disorder)-332(in)-331(its)-332(action.)-494(What)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-250(is)-250(its)-250(nature?)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(There)-391(are)-391(certain)-391(principles)-392(deeply-seated)-391(within)-391(us,)-426(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(form)-228(as)-228(definite)-228(a)-228(portion)-228(of)-228(ourselves)-228(as)-228(even)-228(our)-228(rational)-228(facul-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ties,)-285(and)-277(which)-278(directly)-278(prompt)-277(to)-278(the)-278(beli)1(ef)-278(in)-278(the)-277(supernatural,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-317(therefore)-318(point)-317(to)-317(its)-317(existence.)-452(Among)-317(these,)-334(the)-317(faculties)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-251(imagination,)-502(wonder,)-251(reverence)-251(and)-251(awe,)-251(hold)-251(a)-250(conspicuous)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([314])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(place.)-317(It)-272(is)-272(impossible)-272(to)-272(deny)-272(that)-273(they)-272(form)-272(portions)-272(of)-272(the)-272(ac-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tual)-219(constitution)-220(of)-219(our)-220(minds,)-225(however)-220(we)-219(may)-220(account)-219(for)-219(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(origin.)-264(Is)-255(it)-255(then)-254(our)-255(duty)-255(to)-255(eradicate)-254(them)-255(because)-255(they)-254(prompt)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(us)-192(to)-193(the)-192(belief)-193(in)-192(something)-192(which)-193(transcends)-192(the)-193(visible)-192(order)-192(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature?)-245(This)-234(will)-234(hardly)-234(be)-234(affirmed)-234(by)-234(the)-233(most)-234(thorough-going)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sceptic;)-349(for)-316(if)-316(it)-317(be)-316(our)-316(duty)-316(to)-316(do)-316(so,)-333(the)-316(human)-316(mind)-316(must)-316(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-384(mass)-384(of)-384(disorder)-383(in)-384(the)-384(midst)-384(of)-384(a)-383(universe)-384(of)-384(order.)-652(If)-383(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-289(to)-288(make)-289(the)-288(attempt)-289(\050for)-289(indeed)-288(it)-289(has)-288(been)-289(attempted\051)-288(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(result)-303(would)-304(be)-303(to)-303(upset)-303(the)-303(balance)-304(of)-303(our)-303(mental)-303(constitution,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-318(it)-317(would)-318(terminate)-317(in)-318(failure.)-452(Human)-318(nature,)-334(taken)-317(as)-318(it)-317(is,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(constitutes)-218(a)-218(whole.)-239(These)-218(faculties)-218(hold)-218(in)-218(it)-218(a)-218(place)-217(subordinate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-237(reason)-238(and)-237(to)-237(conscience.)-246(When)-237(our)-237(rational,)-240(our)-237(imaginative,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-240(our)-240(moral)-240(powers)-240(act)-240(harmoniously)-240(together,)-242(they)-240(constitute)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-250(a)-250(religious)-250(being.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But,)-319(for)-305(the)-304(purposes)-305(of)-305(the)-305(present)-305(argument,)-319(I)-305(have)-304(simply)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(to)-254(draw)-253(attention)-254(to)-254(the)-254(fact)-253(that)-254(imagination,)-255(wonder,)-254(reverence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-320(awe)-320(form)-320(an)-320(essential)-319(portion)-320(of)-320(our)-320(being.)-460(It)-320(would)-320(be)-319(in)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1289 0 obj <<
/Length 4692      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(277)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(the)-211(highest)-210(degree)-211(undesirable)-211(to)-211(get)-210(rid)-211(of)-211(them,)-218(even)-211(if)-211(we)-210(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(able.)-245(How)-234(mighty)-235(is)-234(the)-235(influence)-234(of)-235(the)-234(first)-235(of)-234(these)-234(principles!)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-311(lies)-310(at)-311(the)-311(foundation)-310(of)-311(everything)-310(that)-311(is)-311(great)-310(and)-311(noble)-310(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man.)-499(To)-332(it)-333(are)-333(due)-333(the)-333(magnificent)-333(creations)-332(of)-333(poetry;)-375(in)-332(fact)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(everything)-313(which)-313(adorns)-313(life,)-329(and)-313(much)-313(of)-313(that)-313(which)-313(raises)-312(us)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(above)-233(the)-233(mechanical)-232(forces)-233(of)-233(nature.)-244(Destitute)-233(of)-233(it,)-236(our)-232(reason)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(could)-382(not)-383(act;)-448(nay,)-416(it)-382(could)-383(not)-382(even)-383(exist;)-448(and)-383(we)-382(should)-382(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reduced)-263(to)-263(the)-263(mere)-263(mechanical)-263(action)-263(of)-262(the)-263(understanding,)-266(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wheels)-404(of)-405(which)-404(would)-404(be)-405(in)-404(danger)-404(of)-405(rusting.)-713(Nor)-404(has)-404(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(faculty)-272(of)-273(wonder)-272(a)-272(less)-273(definite)-272(place)-272(in)-273(our)-272(being.)-317(It)-272(is)-272(closely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(connected)-292(with)-293(our)-292(imagination,)-303(which)-293(supplies)-585(it)-292(with)-292(objects)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([315])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(fitted)-300(to)-300(excite)-300(it,)-313(and)-300(ought)-299(to)-300(be)-300(exercised)-300(under)-300(the)-300(guidance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-272(reason.)-317(Its)-272(object)-273(is)-272(the)-272(great)-272(and)-273(the)-272(vast,)-278(shall)-272(I)-272(not)-273(say,)-277(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(infinite?)-444(Regulated)-315(by)-315(reason)-315(and)-314(united)-315(with)-315(awe,)-331(it)-314(produces)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(reverence.)-794(Reverence)-432(points)-431(to)-432(the)-431(existence)-432(of)-431(some)-431(object)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-377(is)-377(really)-377(worthy)-377(of)-377(veneration.)-631(Veneration)-377(can)-377(only)-376(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(legitimately)-200(exercised)-200(on)-200(that)-200(which)-200(is)-200(truly)-200(venerable.)-233(As)-200(such)-200(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(directly)-260(points)-261(to)-260(a)-260(personal)-261(God,)-263(and)-260(refuses)-260(to)-261(rest)-260(in)-260(anything)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(short)-401(of)-401(Him)-400(as)-401(able)-401(fully)-401(to)-401(gratify)-400(its)-401(aspirations.)-702(Viewing)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(them)-263(as)-262(a)-263(whole,)-266(the)-262(legitimate)-263(object)-263(of)-262(these)-263(faculties,)-266(and)-262(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subject)-379(from)-380(which)-379(they)-380(can)-379(receive)-380(their)-379(fullest)-379(gratification,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-365(that)-365(Great)-365(Being)-364(who)-365(everywhere)-365(manifests)-365(Himself)-365(in)-364(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(glorious)-321(universe.)-464(But)-321(when)-321(man)-322(has)-321(ceased)-321(to)-321(contemplate)-321(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature)-305(a)-304(rational)-305(power)-305(guiding)-304(and)-305(controlling)-305(it,)-318(the)-304(principle)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-260(wonder)-260(has)-260(frequently)-259(prompted)-260(him)-260(to)-260(gratify)-260(its)-259(aspirations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-362(peopling)-361(it)-362(with)-361(a)-362(multi)1(tude)-362(of)-361(phantastic)-362(creations.)-584(When)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-270(the)-271(influence)-270(of)-271(awe,)-275(he)-271(has)-270(contemplated)-270(it)-271(in)-270(its)-270(terrible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aspects,)-345(unguided)-326(by)-326(a)-326(being)-326(who)-326(possesses)-326(a)-326(moral)-325(character,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-189(feelings)-190(have)-189(prompted)-189(the)-189(imagination)-189(to)-190(fill)-189(it)-189(with)-189(beings)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-250(excite)-250(the)-250(feeling)-250(of)-250(superstitious)-250(dread.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Although)-404(the)-403(vastness)-404(of)-403(the)-404(material)-404(universe)-403(and)-404(the)-403(en-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ergy)-357(of)-358(its)-357(forces)-357(can)-358(excite)-357(the)-357(feeling)-357(of)-358(wonder,)-384(yet)-357(that)-357(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(reverence)-310(refuses)-310(to)-310(find)-311(in)-310(the)-310(mere)-310(extension)-310(of)-310(space,)-325(or)-310(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(might)-202(of)-202(material)-202(forces,)-212(any)-202(object)-202(adequate)-202(to)-202(its)-202(demands.)-234(The)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1293 0 obj <<
/Length 4648      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(278)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(vastness)-273(of)-273(the)-272(material)-273(universe)-273(may)-272(fill)-273(the)-273(mind)-273(with)-272(wonder)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-288(admiration;)-306(but)-288(even)-287(wonder)-288(refuses)-288(to)-287(rest)-288(satisfied)-288(with)-287(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(vastness)-326(of)-326(which)-326(the)-327(limits)-326(are)-326(known.)-478(It)-326(demands)-326(something)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-310(is)-310(conceivable,)-324(which)-310(yet)-310(runs)-310(up)-309(into)-310(the)-310(regions)-310(of)-309(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(inconceivable.)-495(But)-332(even)-332(here)-332(the)-331(feeling)-332(of)-332(reverence)-332(can)-331(find)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nothing)-263(on)-263(which)-264(to)-263(energize.)-289(It)-264(directly)-263(points)-263(to)-263(a)-263(moral)-263(being)]TJ 3.092 -13.549 Td [(in)-283(whom)-284(it)-283(can)-284(find)-283(a)-284(centre,)-291(and)-284(it)-283(will)-284(find)-283(its)-284(gratification)-283(in)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -75.847 0 Td [([316])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(nothing)-291(short)-292(of)-291(one.)-375(To)-291(talk,)-302(as)-291(many)-292(Pantheists)-291(do,)-302(of)-291(feeling)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reverence)-314(for)-314(an)-314(impersonal)-314(Universe,)-330(is)-314(a)-314(misuse)-314(of)-314(language.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(What!)-436(to)-312(reverence)-312(a)-312(Being,)-327(if)-312(the)-312(impersonal)-312(Universe)-312(can)-312(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(called)-419(a)-418(Being,)-461(which)-419(is)-419(everlastingly)-418(casting)-419(up)-419(the)-418(bubbles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-394(existence)-395(in)-394(the)-394(form)-394(of)-394(moral)-395(agents,)-430(and)-394(is)-394(everlastingly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(devouring)-336(them,)-358(devoid)-336(alike)-336(of)-337(consciousness,)-357(volition,)-358(and)-336(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moral)-250(nature!)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-429(follows,)-474(therefore,)-473(if)-429(these)-429(principles)-429(form)-429(a)-429(constituent)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(portion)-292(of)-291(our)-292(nature,)-301(that)-292(like)-292(all)-291(our)-292(other)-291(faculties,)-302(they)-291(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(admit)-265(of)-266(a)-265(right)-265(and)-266(a)-265(perverted)-266(use.)-296(It)-265(is)-265(therefore)-266(absurd)-265(to)-265(lay)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(down)-197(as)-197(a)-197(general)-197(principle,)-207(because)-197(they)-197(admit)-197(of)-197(an)-196(illegitimate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(use,)-254(that)-254(the)-253(whole)-254(class)-253(of)-254(phenomena)-253(connected)-254(with)-253(them)-253(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(worthy)-435(of)-434(nothing)-434(but)-435(summary)-434(rejection,)-481(without)-434(exercising)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(our)-336(reason)-336(on)-336(the)-336(evidence)-336(on)-336(which)-336(they)-336(stand.)-508(All)-336(that)-335(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-439(can)-439(prove)-439(in)-439(reference)-439(to)-439(this)-439(subject)-439(is)-439(something)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-406(is)-407(very)-406(like)-406(a)-406(truism;)-485(that)-406(mankind,)-446(being)-406(liable)-406(to)-406(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(kinds)-341(of)-341(mistakes)-340(and)-341(errors,)-363(and)-341(having)-341(frequently)-341(fallen)-340(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them,)-254(no)-253(class)-253(of)-253(phenomena)-253(ought)-253(to)-253(be)-253(accepted)-253(as)-253(facts,)-253(until)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-267(of)-266(their)-267(occurrence)-267(has)-267(been)-266(adduced)-267(which)-267(is)-266(capable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-250(satisfying)-250(our)-250(reason.)-250(But)-250(this)-250(is)-250(a)-250(very)-250(harmless)-250(proposition.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(There)-215(can)-215(be)-215(no)-215(doubt)-215(that)-215(to)-215(a)-215(perverted)-215(use)-215(of)-215(these)-214(faculties)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-432(due)-432(the)-433(belief)-432(in)-432(a)-432(kind)-432(of)-433(current)-432(supernaturalism,)-477(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-373(various)-373(forms)-373(runs)-373(through)-373(the)-373(entire)-373(history)-373(of)-373(man.)-619(This)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-364(owed)-364(its)-364(origin)-364(to)-364(the)-364(efforts)-364(of)-364(the)-364(imagination)-364(to)-363(supply)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(objects)-412(for)-412(its)-412(gratification)-411(when)-412(the)-412(reason)-412(is)-412(feeble)-412(and)-411(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(moral)-315(faculties)-315(have)-315(become)-315(perverted.)-445(Hence)-315(the)-315(readiness)-314(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(large)-248(masses)-247(of)-248(mankind)-248(to)-248(accept)-247(narratives)-248(of)-248(marvels)-247(without)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1297 0 obj <<
/Length 4866      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(279)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(regard)-374(to)-373(the)-374(evidence)-373(on)-374(which)-373(they)-374(rest.)-620(They)-374(are)-373(accepted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(simply)-219(as)-218(gratifying)-219(the)-219(principle)-437(of)-218(wonder.)-240(This)-219(is)-218(the)-219(cause)-218(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([317])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(what)-250(I)-250(have)-250(designated)-250(by)-250(the)-250(term)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 155.422 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Current)-250(Supernaturalism.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 110.29 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -258.6 -18.459 Td [(But)-342(because)-341(all)-342(our)-341(faculties)-342(admit)-341(of)-342(abuse,)-364(and)-342(the)-341(higher)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(they)-302(are,)-314(the)-301(greater,)-315(this)-301(forms)-302(no)-301(reason)-302(for)-301(rejecting)-302(their)-301(le-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gitimate)-272(use,)-277(or)-272(the)-272(entire)-271(subject-matter)-272(on)-272(which)-272(they)-271(operate.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(As)-311(I)-311(have)-311(observed,)-326(the)-311(principle)-311(is)-311(found)-311(energizing)-311(wherever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-316(exists.)-447(Although)-316(in)-316(one)-316(age)-316(it)-315(may)-316(be)-316(more)-316(active)-316(than)-315(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(another,)-362(it)-339(is)-340(alike)-339(the)-340(inheritance)-339(of)-340(the)-339(civilized)-340(man)-339(and)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(savage.)-248(It)-243(has)-243(displayed)-244(itself)-243(in)-243(the)-243(creations)-243(of)-244(the)-243(poet)-243(and)-243(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writer)-242(of)-243(fiction;)-245(in)-242(the)-242(various)-242(forms)-243(of)-242(religious)-242(thought;)-245(in)-242(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(production)-342(of)-342(ghost-stories)-343(and)-342(pictures)-342(of)-342(the)-342(under-world;)-388(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-263(creation)-263(of)-262(the)-263(various)-263(forms)-263(of)-263(demonology,)-266(witchcraft)-262(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(magic;)-312(in)-291(the)-291(milder)-291(form)-291(of)-291(fairy-tales;)-311(in)-291(charms)-291(and)-291(incanta-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tions,)-358(and)-336(in)-336(efforts)-336(to)-337(pry)-336(into)-336(the)-336(future.)-509(Even)-336(in)-336(philosophy)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-344(science)-345(we)-344(may)-345(trace)-344(its)-345(influence,)-368(not)-344(only)-345(in)-344(aiding)-344(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(suggesting)-210(their)-209(great)-210(discoveries,)-218(but)-209(in)-210(propounding)-209(multitudes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-278(startling)-278(theories,)-284(erected)-278(on)-278(the)-278(smallest)-278(basis)-277(of)-278(fact.)-333(These)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-202(only)-203(gratify)-202(this)-203(feeling,)-212(but)-202(promise)-202(an)-203(apparently)-202(royal)-202(road)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-383(knowledge,)-417(which)-383(avoids)-383(the)-383(long)-384(and)-383(tedious)-383(one)-383(of)-383(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(propounding)-331(theories)-332(after)-331(a)-331(careful)-331(investigation)-331(of)-332(facts.)-493(But)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-240(the)-240(regions)-239(of)-240(intellectual)-240(pursuit,)-242(its)-240(abnormal)-239(manifestations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-305(pre-eminently)-305(in)-304(the)-305(science)-305(of)-305(historical)-304(criticism,)-319(in)-304(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(numerous)-334(departments)-335(of)-334(historical)-334(inquiry)-335(where)-334(the)-334(facts)-334(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(few)-235(and)-234(vague.)-245(Here)-235(nothing)-235(is)-234(easier)-235(than)-235(to)-234(supply)-235(the)-234(absence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-289(facts)-290(by)-289(theory,)-299(and)-289(to)-290(erect)-289(a)-289(magnificent)-290(edifice)-289(on)-289(a)-289(foun-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dation)-265(of)-264(sand.)-294(The)-264(ancient)-265(soothsayer)-264(gratified)-265(vulgar)-264(curiosity)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-384(guessing)-383(at)-383(the)-384(events)-383(of)-384(the)-383(future.)-651(There)-383(is)-384(a)-383(species)-383(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modern)-362(soothsaying)-361(which)-362(expends)-362(its)-361(energies)-362(in)-362(guessing)-361(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-352(events)-351(of)-352(the)-351(past.)-555(Such)-352(guessing)-351(presents)-352(an)-351(unspeakable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fascination)-266(to)-267(a)-266(large)-266(number)-533(of)-266(minds,)-270(by)-267(its)-266(happy)-266(mixture)-266(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([318])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(fiction)-246(and)-246(fact,)-247(and)-247(is)-246(the)-246(true)-246(analogue)-246(to)-247(many)-246(of)-246(the)-246(forms)-246(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ancient)-267(thought.)-300(It)-267(has)-267(been)-267(necessary)-266(to)-267(draw)-267(attention)-267(to)-266(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(things)-384(for)-383(the)-384(purpose)-383(of)-384(provi)1(ng)-384(the)-383(widespread)-384(influence)-383(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1303 0 obj <<
/Length 4605      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(280)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(this)-230(principle)-229(on)-230(human)-230(nature.)-243(Its)-230(action)-229(has)-230(manifested)-230(itself)-229(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(different)-248(forms)-249(in)-248(different)-248(ages;)-249(but)-248(the)-248(cause)-249(is)-248(the)-248(same)-248(in)-248(all,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-258(existence)-258(in)-258(man)-259(of)-258(a)-258(principle)-258(which)-258(points)-258(to)-258(the)-258(existence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-281(God,)-288(and)-280(which)-281(can)-281(only)-280(receive)-281(its)-280(adequate)-281(gratification)-280(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Him.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(The)-319(action)-318(of)-319(similar)-319(principles)-319(produces)-318(in)-319(man)-319(the)-319(love)-318(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(the)-245(extraordinary,)-245(the)-245(unusual)-244(and)-245(the)-245(novel.)-248(This)-244(is)-245(so)-244(powerful)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-384(unless)-383(it)-384(is)-384(kept)-383(in)-384(subordination)-383(to)-384(reason,)-417(it)-384(produces)-383(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(number)-301(of)-301(fictitious)-301(beliefs.)-402(So)-301(strong)-301(is)-301(it,)-313(that)-301(it)-301(may)-301(be)-300(truly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(said)-359(of)-359(large)-359(numbers)-359(of)-359(mankind)-359(that)-359(they)-359(spend)-359(all)-359(the)-359(time)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-238(they)-238(are)-238(not)-238(compelled)-238(to)-238(devote)-238(to)-238(the)-238(serious)-238(realities)-237(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(life,)-230(in)-226(little)-225(else)-226(than)-226(hearing)-225(and)-226(speaking)-225(of)-226(some)-225(new)-226(thing.)-241(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-298(undoubtedly)-298(the)-298(cause)-297(of)-298(a)-298(large)-298(number)-298(of)-298(fictitious)-297(beliefs,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-351(produces,)-377(in)-351(minds)-352(where)-351(the)-352(rational)-351(powers)-351(are)-352(weak,)-376(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ready)-257(acceptance)-257(of)-257(the)-257(unusual,)-258(the)-257(strange,)-259(and)-257(the)-256(wonderful.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-265(same)-265(principle,)-269(acting)-266(in)-265(conjunction)-265(with)-265(others,)-269(when)-265(un-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(controlled)-275(by)-274(reason,)-281(has)-274(occasioned)-275(many)-274(of)-275(the)-274(exaggerations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(are)-250(to)-250(be)-250(found)-250(in)-250(history.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Still,)-431(as)-394(one)-395(of)-395(the)-394(fundamental)-395(principles)-394(of)-395(our)-395(minds,)-430(it)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(cannot)-336(but)-336(have)-337(a)-336(legitimate)-336(sphere)-336(of)-336(action.)-509(United)-336(with)-336(cu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(riosity,)-223(it)-216(is)-216(the)-216(chief)-216(source)-216(of)-216(all)-216(mental)-216(activity.)-238(It)-216(is)-216(that)-216(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(produces)-345(the)-346(earnest)-345(desire)-345(to)-345(penetrate)-345(into)-346(the)-345(regions)-345(of)-345(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unknown.)-458(As)-320(such,)-337(it)-319(is)-320(essential)-319(to)-320(the)-319(activity)-320(of)-319(our)-319(rational)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(faculties,)-249(and)-248(has)-248(been)-248(the)-248(exciting)-248(cause)-248(which)-248(has)-248(rendered)-248(all)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(our)-250(great)-250(discoveries)-250(possible.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(It)-283(follows,)-292(therefore,)-292(that)-283(if)-283(these)-284(principles)-283(form)-567(part)-283(of)-283(our)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([319])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(mental)-299(constitution,)-310(the)-299(objection)-298(that)-299(they)-298(destroy)-298(the)-299(value)-298(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miracles)-327(as)-328(a)-327(testimony)-327(to)-328(a)-327(revelation)-327(is)-328(absurd.)-482(We)-327(might)-327(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(well)-245(argue)-246(that)-245(because)-245(the)-246(love)-245(of)-245(the)-246(marvellous)-245(has)-245(generated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-366(belief)-366(in)-366(a)-366(number)-367(of)-366(fictions)-366(as)-366(facts)-366(in)-366(ordinary)-366(history,)-395(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(invalidates)-310(its)-309(testimony)-310(to)-310(events)-309(which)-310(have)-310(really)-309(happened,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-392(renders)-393(all)-392(unusual)-393(occurrences)-392(incredible.)-678(I)-392(will)-392(illustrate)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-327(by)-327(an)-328(example.)-481(Herodotus)-327(tells)-328(us)-327(in)-327(his)-327(history)-327(that)-327(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-211(certain)-211(tribes)-211(who)-210(dwelt)-211(in)-211(wooden)-211(habitations)-211(erected)-210(over)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1307 0 obj <<
/Length 4773      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(281)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(lakes,)-356(and)-335(he)-334(gives)-335(us)-335(several)-334(particulars)-335(as)-334(to)-335(their)-335(manner)-334(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(life.)-484(This)-327(fact,)-348(until)-328(a)-328(comparatively)-327(recent)-328(period,)-348(might)-327(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-403(pronounced)-402(incredible,)-441(and)-402(have)-403(been)-402(supposed)-403(to)-402(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(originated)-421(in)-421(the)-422(simple)-421(love)-421(of)-421(the)-421(marvellous,)-464(either)-421(in)-421(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(author)-407(or)-407(in)-408(his)-407(informants.)-721(I)-407(own)-408(that)-407(when)-407(I)-407(first)-407(read)-407(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historian,)-267(this)-264(was)-264(the)-264(opinion)-264(which)-264(I)-264(formed)-264(respecting)-264(it.)-291(But)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-273(now)-272(know)-272(that)-273(he)-272(reported)-273(an)-272(actual)-273(fact.)-317(On)-273(the)-272(other)-272(hand)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-394(is)-394(certain)-394(that)-394(a)-394(great)-394(portion)-394(of)-394(the)-394(details)-394(of)-394(the)-393(Scythian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(expedition)-297(of)-297(Darius)-297(must)-296(have)-297(originated)-297(in)-297(the)-297(undue)-296(activity)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-253(the)-252(mental)-253(faculties)-253(to)-252(which)-253(I)-252(have)-253(referred,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 210.505 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 16.144 0 Td [(that)-253(they)-252(are)]TJ -226.649 -13.549 Td [(inventions.)-246(But)-240(if)-239(the)-239(principle)-240(of)-239(summarily)-239(rejecting)-239(narratives)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-297(events)-297(which)-297(lie)-297(beyond)-296(our)-297(experience)-297(is)-297(valid,)-309(because)-296(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(abnormal)-350(activity)-349(of)-350(certain)-349(faculties)-349(has)-350(urged)-349(men)-350(to)-349(invent,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-349(believe)-350(in)-349(a)-349(multitude)-350(of)-349(fictions,)-374(the)-349(account)-350(of)-349(the)-349(lake-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(dwellings)-306(given)-306(by)-306(the)-307(historian)-306(ought)-306(to)-306(have)-306(been)-306(rejected)-306(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(equally)-281(unworthy)-280(of)-281(credit,)-288(with)-281(some)-280(of)-281(the)-280(occurrences)-281(of)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Scythian)-317(expedition.)-453(It)-317(is)-317(impossible)-318(to)-317(deal)-317(with)-318(the)-317(events)-317(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(history)-232(on)-232(any)-232(general)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 99.203 0 Td [(\340)-232(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 35.981 0 Td [(principles;)-238(they)-232(must)-232(stand)-232(or)-233(fall)]TJ -135.184 -13.549 Td [(on)-250(their)-250(own)-250(intrinsic)-250(evidence.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-342(follows,)-365(therefore,)-365(that)-342(if)-342(these)-342(principles)-342(admit)-342(of)-342(an)-342(ab-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(normal)-320(action,)-337(we)-319(are)-320(still)-319(by)-320(no)-319(means)-320(justified)-319(in)-320(a)-319(summary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rejection)-295(of)-294(all)-295(unusual)-295(occurrences.)-384(It)-295(only)-589(forms)-295(an)-294(adequate)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([320])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(reason)-322(for)-322(closely)-322(scrutinizing)-322(the)-322(evidence)-322(on)-322(which)-322(the)-321(cred-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ibility)-402(of)-402(history)-402(rests.)-706(The)-402(faculty)-402(of)-402(imagination,)-440(instigated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-362(that)-362(of)-362(wonder,)-389(has)-362(produced)-362(widespread)-362(beliefs)-362(in)-362(a)-361(mass)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-326(supernatural)-327(events)-326(which)-327(are)-326(utterly)-326(incredible.)-480(But)-326(as)-326(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(faculty)-275(must)-275(have)-275(a)-275(legitimate)-275(action)-275(somewhere,)-281(it)-275(is)-275(clear)-275(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(its)-362(abuse)-362(can)-361(be)-362(no)-362(valid)-362(reason)-362(for)-361(the)-362(rejection)-362(of)-362(all)-361(super-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural)-430(occurrences,)-474(unless)-430(for)-430(other)-429(reasons)-430(they)-430(are)-429(proved)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-429(be)-429(incredible.)-786(The)-429(whole)-429(must)-428(be)-429(a)-429(question)-429(of)-428(evidence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-356(of)-356(reason.)-567(If)-356(it)-355(formed)-356(a)-356(valid)-355(ground)-356(for)-356(the)-356(rejection)-355(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles,)-467(it)-423(is)-423(clear)-423(that)-424(the)-423(principle)-423(on)-424(which)-423(it)-423(is)-423(founded)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(cannot)-330(be)-329(confined)-330(to)-329(any)-330(such)-329(narrow)-330(limits,)-349(but)-329(must)-330(have)-329(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wide)-253(and)-254(general)-253(application,)-254(and)-254(extend)-253(to)-253(all)-254(that)-253(is)-253(wonderful)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1311 0 obj <<
/Length 4600      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(282)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(and)-250(unusual.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-235(is)-236(an)-235(unquestionable)-236(fact)-235(that)-236(a)-235(large)-236(proportion)-235(of)-235(mankind)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-273(every)-273(age)-273(have)-274(eagerly)-273(sought)-273(the)-273(means)-273(of)-273(affording)-273(gratifi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cation)-253(to)-253(the)-252(feeling)-253(of)-253(wonder,)-254(and)-252(that)-253(this)-253(has)-253(been)-253(the)-252(means)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-303(introducing)-303(into)-303(history)-303(a)-303(considerable)-303(number)-303(of)-303(fictions)-303(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(various)-366(kinds.)-596(But)-366(does)-365(this)-365(invalidate)-366(its)-365(testimony?)-597(Does)-365(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(justify)-297(us)-297(in)-297(rejecting)-297(whole)-297(classes)-297(of)-297(phenomena)-297(as)-296(unworthy)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-284(consideration?)-353(We)-285(have)-284(already)-284(seen)-285(that)-284(whatever)-284(principle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-201(applied)-200(to)-201(miracles)-200(must)-201(be)-200(equally)-201(applied)-200(to)-201(all)-200(extraordinary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events,)-441(because)-403(as)-403(phenomena)-402(there)-403(is)-403(no)-403(difference)-402(between)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(them.)-346(We)-282(admit)-282(that)-282(many)-282(fictions)-282(have)-282(got)-282(into)-282(history.)-346(These)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-268(is)-268(the)-269(duty)-268(of)-268(the)-268(critical)-268(historian)-268(to)-269(detect)-268(and)-268(displace.)-304(Will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(anyone)-403(affirm)-404(that)-403(their)-404(introduction)-403(invalidates)-404(the)-403(events)-403(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-383(history)-384(of)-383(the)-384(past,)-416(which)-384(rest)-383(on)-384(an)-383(adequate)-383(attestation?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(What)-416(that)-417(is,)-457(I)-417(shall)-416(consider)-416(hereafter.)-749(Whatever)-416(effect)-416(this)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(may)-362(have)-361(exerted)-362(on)-362(the)-361(minor)-362(details)-362(of)-361(history,)-390(will)-361(anyone)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-278(that)-278(its)-278(great)-279(outli)1(nes)-279(do)-278(not)-278(rest)-278(on)-278(a)-278(substantial)-278(basis)-278(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth?)-290(It)-263(is)-263(impossible)-263(to)-264(lay)-526(down)-263(on)-264(these)-263(subjects)-263(a)-263(wide)-263(and)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([321])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(comprehensive)-328(canon)-328(which)-328(will)-328(save)-328(us)-328(the)-328(trouble)-328(of)-328(careful)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-328(accurate)-328(investigation.)-484(All)-328(reports)-328(of)-328(extraordinary)-328(events,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(marvels,)-207(and)-195(miracles,)-207(must)-195(stand)-196(or)-195(fall)-196(with)-196(the)-195(adequacy)-196(of)-195(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-257(which)-258(can)-257(be)-257(adduced)-257(for)-258(their)-257(occurrence,)-259(and)-257(cannot)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-341(decided)-341(by)-340(any)-341(artificial)-341(rule.)-522(If)-341(the)-341(evidence)-340(is)-341(good,)-363(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-233(be)-233(accepted,)-236(notwithstanding)-233(the)-233(fact)-233(that)-233(extensive)-233(classes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-248(marvels)-247(have)-248(been)-247(accepted)-248(by)-248(mankind)-247(on)-248(testimony)-247(wholly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(insufficient)-178(to)-177(establish)-178(their)-177(truth.)-226(If)-178(the)-177(evidence)-178(fails,)-192(they)-177(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-368(regarded)-367(as)-368(the)-368(result)-367(of)-368(the)-368(abnormal)-367(exercise)-368(of)-367(faculties)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(yet)-250(have)-250(a)-250(legitimate)-250(place)-250(in)-250(our)-250(mental)-250(constitution.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Nothing)-410(is)-409(more)-410(common)-409(than)-410(the)-410(assertion)-409(that)-410(at)-409(certain)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(periods)-318(of)-319(history,)-335(mankind)-318(have)-319(been)-318(ignorant)-318(that)-319(there)-318(is)-318(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-272(in)-272(nature;)-283(and)-271(that)-272(this)-272(ignorance)-272(has)-272(given)-272(these)-271(faculties)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-445(unbounded)-446(play)-445(as)-445(to)-445(render)-446(all)-445(reports)-445(of)-445(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(occurrences)-289(unworthy)-289(of)-290(credit,)-299(notwithstanding)-289(any)-289(amount)-289(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-300(which)-299(may)-300(be)-300(alleged)-300(in)-299(their)-300(favour.)-399(It)-300(is)-300(urged)-299(that,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1315 0 obj <<
/Length 4663      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(283)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(if)-385(men)-385(are)-384(ignorant)-385(that)-385(there)-385(is)-384(an)-385(order)-385(in)-385(nature,)-418(to)-385(such)-384(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(state)-382(of)-382(mind)-382(nothing)-383(would)-382(be)-382(really)-382(supernatural;)-448(but)-382(every)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(event,)-291(whether)-284(supernatural)-283(or)-283(otherwise,)-291(would)-283(be)-283(viewed)-283(as)-283(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(matter)-341(of)-341(ordinary)-341(occurrence.)-523(To)-341(this)-341(state)-341(of)-341(mind)-341(a)-340(miracle)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(would)-323(convey)-323(no)-322(meaning,)-341(and)-323(therefore)-323(it)-323(would)-323(be)-322(valueless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-341(evidence)-341(of)-340(a)-341(divine)-341(revelation.)-522(In)-341(other)-341(words,)-363(it)-341(has)-340(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirmed)-334(that)-334(there)-335(have)-334(been)-334(certain)-334(conditions)-334(of)-334(mankind)-334(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-290(the)-290(love)-290(of)-291(the)-290(marvellous)-290(has)-290(been)-290(so)-290(powerful,)-300(and)-290(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-215(of)-215(reason)-216(so)-215(weak,)-222(as)-215(to)-215(destroy)-216(all)-215(sense)-215(of)-215(the)-215(distinction)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(between)-250(a)-250(natural)-250(and)-250(a)-250(supernatural)-250(occurrence.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-247(reply)-246(that)-247(the)-246(Christian)-247(revelation)-246(was)-247(not)-246(addressed)-247(to)-246(such)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(a)-353(condition)-353(of)-353(the)-354(human)-353(mind.)-559(On)-353(the)-353(contrary,)-379(it)-353(was)-353(made)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(after)-276(a)-277(long)-276(course)-276(of)-553(preparation)-276(for)-276(its)-276(introduction.)-329(After)-276(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([322])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(whole)-375(course)-376(of)-375(previous)-375(history,)-407(under)-375(the)-375(controlling)-375(provi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dence)-222(of)-222(God,)-227(had)-222(prepared)-222(the)-222(way)-222(for)-222(His)-222(Advent,)-228(Jesus)-221(Christ)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(appeared.)-606(The)-369(Gospel)-369(was)-368(not)-369(preached)-369(to)-368(men)-369(in)-369(the)-368(lowest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(state)-221(of)-220(barbarism,)-227(but)-220(to)-221(civilized)-220(man.)-240(What)-221(may)-220(have)-221(been)-220(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ideas)-251(of)-251(degraded)-250(savages,)-251(at)-251(some)-251(early)-250(period)-251(of)-251(the)-251(history)-250(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-293(race,)-304(it)-294(will)-293(be)-293(needless)-293(to)-294(inquire.)-379(With)-294(mankind)-293(in)-293(such)-293(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(condition)-291(we)-291(have)-291(nothing)-291(to)-292(do)-291(in)-291(the)-291(present)-291(controversy,)-301(but)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-339(the)-338(state)-339(of)-339(thought)-338(in)-339(the)-339(Roman)-338(Empire)-339(during)-339(the)-338(first)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(century)-284(of)-285(our)-284(era.)-353(This)-284(was)-285(no)-284(period)-284(of)-285(mental)-284(darkness)-284(or)-284(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(boundless)-278(credulity.)-333(In)-278(the)-278(early)-278(ages,)-285(when)-278(every)-277(phenomenon)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-380(nature)-379(was)-380(viewed)-379(as)-380(due)-379(to)-379(the)-380(action)-379(of)-380(some)-379(capricious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(god,)-376(the)-352(belief)-351(in)-351(an)-351(order)-351(of)-351(nature)-352(must)-351(have)-351(been)-351(in)-351(a)-351(high)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(degree)-251(vague)-250(and)-251(uncertain.)-252(But)-251(such)-251(a)-250(state)-251(of)-251(things,)-250(whatever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-226(might)-226(once)-226(have)-226(been,)-231(had)-226(long)-226(since)-226(passed)-226(away.)-242(The)-226(period)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-248(history)-247(now)-248(under)-248(consideration)-248(was)-247(one)-248(of)-248(widespread)-247(intel-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ligence,)-277(varying)-272(greatly)-272(in)-271(different)-272(parts)-272(of)-272(the)-272(empire,)-277(but)-271(still)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-250(of)-250(intelligence)-250(and)-250(civilization.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-174(is)-174(impossible)-173(for)-174(men)-174(to)-174(attain)-173(a)-174(degree)-174(of)-174(progress)-173(necessary)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(for)-204(the)-204(existence)-205(of)-204(civilization,)-213(and)-204(still)-205(to)-204(remain)-204(ignorant)-204(that)-204(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(large)-218(class)-217(of)-218(natural)-218(occurrences)-217(follow)-218(an)-218(order)-217(which)-218(does)-217(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(admit)-270(of)-269(deviation.)-309(Civilization)-269(would)-270(be)-269(impossible)-270(unless)-269(this)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1319 0 obj <<
/Length 4557      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(284)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(were)-179(generally)-180(recognized.)-226(It)-180(is)-179(in)-180(fact)-179(founded)-180(on)-179(its)-179(recognition.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(At)-330(the)-330(same)-330(time,)-350(there)-330(is)-330(a)-330(class)-330(of)-330(phenomena)-330(which)-330(are)-329(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recognized)-343(by)-344(the)-343(ordinary)-344(mind)-343(as)-343(following)-344(a)-343(definite)-343(order.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-284(is)-284(within)-284(this)-283(alone)-284(that)-284(the)-284(beliefs)-284(of)-284(current)-283(supernaturalism)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(exert)-387(their)-387(activity.)-660(But)-387(the)-387(supernatural)-387(occurrences)-386(narrated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-283(the)-283(New)-284(Testament)-283(do)-283(not)-283(belong)-284(to)-283(this)-283(ambiguous)-283(order)-283(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events,)-250(and)-250(are)-250(therefore)-250(unaffected)-250(by)-250(them.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([323])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -16.004 Td [(There)-358(is)-358(a)-358(large)-357(class)-358(of)-358(events)-358(which)-358(civilized)-358(man)-357(cannot)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(help)-300(recognizing)-301(as)-300(belonging)-300(to)-300(a)-301(definite)-300(order)-300(and)-300(sequence,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-329(where)-329(the)-329(belief)-328(in)-329(the)-329(marvellous)-329(exerts)-329(little)-329(or)-329(no)-328(influ-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ence.)-453(The)-318(violation)-318(of)-318(this)-318(order)-318(he)-317(views)-318(as)-318(impossible.)-453(Thus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-415(cannot)-415(fail)-415(to)-414(recognize)-415(the)-415(fact)-415(that)-415(men)-415(cannot)-415(walk)-414(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-324(water)-323(without)-324(support;)-360(that)-324(thousands)-324(of)-323(persons)-324(cannot)-323(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fed)-437(by)-437(a)-436(few)-437(loaves)-437(and)-436(fishes;)-531(that)-436(diseases)-437(never)-437(leave)-436(us)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instantaneously)-420(by)-420(no)-419(other)-420(agency)-420(than)-420(that)-419(of)-420(a)-420(touch)-420(or)-419(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(word;)-474(and)-399(that)-399(men)-398(who)-399(have)-399(been)-399(actually)-399(dead)-399(have)-399(never)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(returned)-204(to)-204(life.)-235(No)-204(amount)-204(of)-204(the)-204(love)-204(of)-204(the)-204(marvellous)-204(has)-204(ever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(induced)-350(men)-349(to)-350(consider)-350(such)-350(occurrences)-349(possible.)-549(Whatever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-251(have)-251(been)-251(the)-251(current)-251(supernaturalism)-251(of)-251(the)-251(ancient)-250(world,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-310(did)-310(not)-310(embody)-310(beliefs)-310(of)-310(this)-310(description.)-430(This)-310(is)-310(proved)-310(by)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-336(entire)-336(course)-337(of)-336(ancient)-336(history.)-509(Its)-336(supernaturalism)-336(is)-336(of)-336(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wholly)-209(different)-209(order.)-237(The)-209(love)-209(of)-209(the)-209(marvellous,)-217(therefore,)-217(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(never)-272(so)-273(confounded)-272(the)-273(distinction)-272(between)-272(the)-273(natural)-272(and)-272(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-245(among)-244(civilized)-245(men,)-245(as)-245(to)-245(have)-244(deprived)-245(a)-244(miracle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(its)-250(significance.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Such)-320(an)-321(assertion)-320(respecting)-320(any)-320(part)-321(of)-320(the)-320(Roman)-320(Empire,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(during)-297(the)-297(century)-298(which)-297(preceded)-297(and)-297(that)-297(which)-297(followed)-297(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Advent,)-492(would)-444(be)-444(contrary)-444(to)-444(fact.)-832(On)-444(the)-444(contrary,)-492(certain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(classes)-347(of)-348(events)-347(which)-347(were)-347(reported)-347(to)-348(have)-347(happened,)-371(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(invariably)-276(believed)-276(to)-276(have)-276(been)-276(really)-276(supernatural.)-328(They)-275(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-259(far)-259(from)-259(being)-258(considered)-259(as)-259(devoid)-259(of)-259(meaning,)-261(that)-258(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposed)-208(to)-207(be)-208(skilled)-207(in)-208(the)-208(art)-207(of)-208(interpreting)-207(them)-208(were)-207(habitu-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ally)-245(consulted)-245(as)-246(to)-245(what)-245(they)-245(were)-245(intended)-246(to)-245(denote.)-248(The)-245(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exceptions)-286(to)-286(this)-285(were)-286(those)-286(occurrences)-286(which)-286(were)-285(supposed)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1323 0 obj <<
/Length 4572      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(285)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(to)-308(have)-308(been)-308(brought)-308(about)-308(by)-308(the)-308(art)-308(of)-308(magic.)-424(These)-308(seem)-308(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-364(been)-365(viewed)-364(as)-365(in)-364(some)-364(measure)-365(due)-364(to)-365(the)-364(existence)-364(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occult)-325(powers)-324(in)-325(nature,)-344(the)-324(results)-325(of)-325(which)-649(the)-325(professors)-324(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([324])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(the)-360(art)-359(had)-360(succeeded)-359(in)-360(mastering.)-578(It)-360(may)-359(be)-360(safely)-359(affirmed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-315(at)-315(no)-316(portion)-315(of)-315(this)-315(period)-315(was)-316(the)-315(love)-315(of)-315(the)-315(marvellous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-420(prevalent)-419(in)-420(any)-420(portion)-419(of)-420(the)-420(Roman)-419(Empire)-420(as)-420(to)-419(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(deprived)-250(a)-250(real)-250(miracle)-250(of)-250(its)-250(signification.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-469(follows)-468(therefore)-469(that)-468(it)-469(is)-468(impossible)-469(to)-468(lay)-469(down)-468(any)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(abstract)-312(rule)-311(which)-312(will)-312(save)-311(us)-312(the)-312(trouble)-311(of)-312(investigating)-311(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-467(of)-467(miracles,)-522(because)-467(mankind)-467(has)-467(in)-467(all)-467(ages)-467(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(greatly)-335(influenced)-334(by)-335(the)-335(love)-334(of)-335(the)-334(marvellous,)-356(and)-335(under)-334(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(influence)-383(has)-383(invented)-384(a)-383(number)-383(of)-383(occurrences)-383(which)-383(reason)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pronounces)-347(incredible.)-539(The)-347(action)-347(of)-346(this)-347(principle)-346(is)-347(far)-346(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-308(confined)-308(to)-308(subjects)-308(connected)-307(with)-308(religion,)-323(but)-307(extends)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(over)-377(the)-376(whole)-377(range)-376(of)-377(literature.)-630(While)-376(it)-377(is)-376(quite)-377(true)-376(that,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-476(the)-477(influence)-476(of)-477(various)-476(principles)-477(of)-476(this)-476(description,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(numbers)-207(of)-206(fictions)-207(have)-206(been)-207(reported)-206(by)-207(ancient)-206(historians,)-215(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forms)-354(a)-354(valid)-354(reason)-355(only)-354(for)-354(rejecting)-354(those)-354(which)-354(rest)-354(on)-354(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adequate)-309(attestation.)-427(The)-309(adoption)-309(of)-309(the)-309(other)-309(principle)-308(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(render)-377(all)-377(knowledge)-376(of)-377(the)-377(past)-377(impossible.)-630(All)-377(the)-376(faculties)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-340(our)-340(minds)-340(admit)-340(of)-340(a)-340(legitimate)-340(and)-340(an)-340(illegitimate)-340(use.)-520(To)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reject)-335(the)-334(results)-335(of)-335(the)-334(right)-335(use)-335(of)-334(our)-335(faculties,)-356(because)-334(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-250(capable)-250(of)-250(a)-250(wrong)-250(one,)-250(is)-250(absurd.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(But)-242(an)-241(opposite)-242(view)-241(may)-242(be)-242(taken)-241(of)-242(the)-242(entire)-241(question,)-243(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(one)-250(which)-250(is)-250(dictated)-250(by)-250(the)-250(principles)-250(of)-250(reason.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Several)-230(principles)-230(in)-230(man)-229(directly)-230(point)-230(to)-230(the)-230(existence)-230(of)-229(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(supernatural.)-639(Among)-379(these)-380(veneration)-379(and)-380(conscience)-379(occupy)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-376(conspicuous)-375(place.)-627(These)-376(acting)-376(in)-375(conjunction)-376(with)-375(reason)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(constitute)-285(man)-285(a)-285(religious)-285(being.)-355(Man)-285(alone)-285(of)-285(all)-285(living)-285(beings)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-313(capable)-313(of)-313(religion.)-440(The)-313(principle)-313(of)-313(reverence)-313(finds)-313(its)-313(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adequate)-299(gratification)-298(in)-299(the)-299(contemplation)-298(of)-299(moral)-298(perfection.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Moral)-195(perfection)-196(is)-195(inconceivable)-391(where)-195(personality)-195(and)-195(volition)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([325])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(are)-357(not.)-570(This)-357(principle)-357(therefore)-356(forms)-357(the)-357(counterpart)-357(in)-356(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-268(is)-269(directly)-268(correlated)-269(to)-268(the)-268(being)-269(and)-268(the)-269(perfections)-268(of)-268(a)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1329 0 obj <<
/Length 1967      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(286)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(personal)-341(God.)-525(It)-341(follows)-341(that)-342(instead)-341(of)-342(these)-341(principles)-341(inval-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(idating)-332(the)-332(existence)-332(of)-332(the)-332(supernatural,)-352(they)-332(establish)-332(it.)-496(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conception)-209(of)-209(immensity)-209(is)-209(the)-209(adequate)-209(subject-matter)-209(on)-209(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-327(faculty)-326(of)-327(wonder)-326(works.)-479(The)-327(highest)-326(conception)-327(of)-326(great-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ness)-350(is)-350(realized)-351(in)-350(God.)-550(In)-351(Him)-350(therefore)-350(this)-350(faculty)-350(receives)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-240(most)-239(perfect)-240(realization.)-246(Reverence)-240(points)-239(to)-240(greatness)-239(united)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-398(supreme)-398(moral)-397(goodness.)-693(The)-398(imperfection)-398(of)-398(man)-397(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-340(satisfy)-340(it.)-521(It)-340(therefore)-340(impels)-341(man)-340(to)-340(bow)-340(down)-340(before)-340(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(throne)-341(of)-340(One)-341(who)-340(transcends)-340(the)-341(imperfections)-340(of)-341(the)-340(created)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(universe.)-578(If)-360(there)-359(be)-360(a)-359(personal)-360(God,)-387(supremely)-359(good,)-387(who)-359(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-242(Creator)-242(and)-243(moral)-242(Governor)-242(of)-242(the)-242(universe,)-244(nothing)-242(is)-242(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-267(conformity)-267(with)-267(our)-268(highest)-267(reason)-267(than)-267(that)-267(He)-267(should)-267(make)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-394(further)-394(manifestation)-394(of)-394(Himself)-394(to)-394(man,)-430(in)-394(addition)-394(to)-394(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(He)-250(has)-250(made)-250(in)-250(the)-250(material)-250(universe.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -27.415 Td [([326])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1337 0 obj <<
/Length 3137      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-271(XV.)-271(Our)-271(Summary)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Rejection)-286(Of)-286(Current)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Supernaturalism)-256(Considered)-256(In)-257(Its)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Bearing)-265(On)-266(The)-265(Evidence)-265(For)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Miracles.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -41.745 Td [(There)-389(can)-390(be)-389(no)-390(doubt)-389(that)-390(there)-389(is)-390(an)-389(enormous)-390(mass)-389(of)-389(su-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pernatural)-415(beliefs)-414(which)-415(we)-414(feel)-414(at)-415(once)-414(justified)-415(in)-414(rejecting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-204(troubling)-204(ourselves)-205(to)-204(inquire)-204(into)-204(the)-204(evidence)-204(on)-204(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-253(rest.)-259(Others)-253(also)-253(we)-253(reject)-253(because)-253(on)-253(investigation)-253(we)-252(find)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-218(altogether)-217(destitute)-218(of)-217(evidence.)-239(Others)-218(again)-217(which)-218(rest)-217(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-239(which)-238(would)-239(be)-238(sufficient)-238(to)-239(establish)-238(an)-239(ordinary)-238(fact,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(we)-263(reject)-262(notwithstanding)-262(this)-263(attestation,)-266(on)-262(the)-263(ground)-262(of)-262(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inherent)-348(improbability.)-543(It)-348(has)-347(been)-348(objected)-348(that)-348(our)-347(summary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rejection)-359(of)-359(the)-359(great)-358(mass)-359(of)-359(current)-359(supernaturalism)-359(puts)-358(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(case)-327(of)-326(miracles)-327(out)-327(of)-326(court,)-346(and)-327(renders)-326(them)-327(so)-326(improbable,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-353(it)-352(is)-353(unnecessary)-352(minutely)-352(to)-353(examine)-352(the)-353(evidence)-352(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(can)-336(be)-336(adduced)-336(in)-336(support)-336(of)-336(them.)-508(I)-336(propose)-336(therefore)-336(in)-336(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(chapter)-262(to)-262(consider)-262(the)-262(reasons)-262(for)-262(our)-262(summary)-262(rejection)-262(of)-261(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-419(mass)-419(of)-419(current)-419(supernaturalism,)-461(and)-419(its)-419(bearing)-419(on)-418(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(credibility)-250(of)-250(the)-250(miracles)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament.)]TJ 11.956 -15.414 Td [(First:)-293(I)-272(observe)-272(that)-271(the)-272(stories)-272(of)-271(current)-272(supernaturalism)-271(are)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(not)-362(the)-361(only)-362(ones)-362(which)-361(we)-362(reject)-362(in)-361(a)-362(summary)-362(manner.)-584(We)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(treat)-435(in)-435(the)-435(same)-435(way)-435(a)-435(great)-435(number)-435(of)-435(other)-435(stories)-435(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(offend)-345(against)-346(the)-345(principles)-346(of)-345(common)-346(sense.)-536(It)-346(is)-345(clear)-345(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-262(these)-262(latter)-524(cases,)-265(we)-262(do)-262(not)-262(reject)-262(them)-262(merely)-262(because)-262(they)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([327])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(are)-289(supernatural,)-299(but)-289(because)-289(they)-289(are)-289(generally)-289(incredible.)-366(The)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1341 0 obj <<
/Length 4685      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(288)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(fact)-312(therefore)-312(that)-312(we)-313(thus)-312(reject)-312(a)-312(number)-312(of)-312(absurd)-312(narratives)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-297(inquiry)-296(into)-297(the)-296(evidence)-297(on)-296(which)-297(they)-297(rest,)-308(cannot)-296(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(urged)-312(as)-313(a)-312(reason)-312(for)-312(rejecting)-312(other)-313(occurrences)-312(which)-312(are)-312(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(involved)-313(in)-313(any)-313(such)-313(absurdity.)-438(If)-313(the)-313(principle)-313(is)-313(valid)-312(against)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miracles,)-254(it)-253(must)-254(be)-253(equally)-253(so)-253(against)-254(other)-253(extensive)-253(classes)-253(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(facts.)-418(To)-306(assert)-306(that)-306(miracles)-306(are)-306(thus)-306(absurd)-306(or)-306(ridiculous)-306(is)-306(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assume)-250(the)-250(point)-250(which)-250(ought)-250(to)-250(be)-250(proved.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Secondly:)-233(We)-216(reject)-216(the)-216(great)-216(mass)-216(of)-216(current)-216(supernaturalism)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(because)-339(it)-339(is)-339(unable)-339(to)-339(assign)-339(any)-339(adequate)-339(reason)-339(for)-339(its)-339(exis-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tence.)-243(When)-229(it)-229(is)-228(alleged)-229(that)-229(a)-229(miracle)-228(has)-229(been)-229(performed)-229(as)-228(an)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(attestation)-246(of)-245(a)-246(revelation,)-246(if)-245(it)-246(forms)-245(a)-246(necessary)-245(portion)-246(of)-245(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attestation,)-387(this)-359(is)-359(an)-360(adequate)-359(reason)-359(for)-360(the)-359(miracle.)-578(But)-359(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-272(mass)-273(of)-272(current)-272(supernaturalism)-272(is)-273(utterly)-272(unable)-272(to)-272(assign)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-284(reason)-284(for)-284(its)-283(existence;)-301(or)-284(if)-284(reasons)-284(have)-283(been)-284(given,)-292(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-206(qui)1(te)-206(inadequate.)-235(Of)-206(this)-205(the)-206(case)-205(of)-205(magic)-206(is)-205(an)-206(example.)-235(If)-205(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(were)-194(a)-194(reality,)-206(it)-194(would)-194(not)-194(only)-195(interfere)-194(with)-194(the)-194(order)-194(of)-194(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-395(no)-396(reason)-395(could)-395(be)-395(given)-395(for)-396(this)-395(interference.)-686(If,)-431(on)-395(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-215(hand,)-222(its)-215(phenomena)-214(were)-215(alleged)-215(to)-215(be)-215(due)-215(to)-215(secret)-214(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-320(nature,)-337(then)-320(they)-319(would)-320(belong)-320(to)-320(an)-319(order)-320(of)-320(grotesque)-319(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(monstrous)-213(phenomena,)-220(which)-213(we)-213(are)-213(justified)-213(at)-213(once)-213(in)-212(refusing)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-222(believe)-222(to)-222(be)-222(due)-222(to)-222(the)-221(action)-222(of)-222(intelligence)-222(or)-222(goodness;)-231(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-220(the)-220(supposition)-221(that)-220(there)-220(is)-220(a)-221(moral)-220(Governor)-220(of)-220(the)-220(universe,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-243(is)-243(utterly)-243(incredible)-243(that)-243(they)-243(would)-243(occur)-243(either)-243(by)-243(his)-242(agency)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-250(with)-250(his)-250(permission.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Perhaps)-416(the)-416(best)-417(attested)-416(occurrences)-416(of)-416(current)-416(supernatu-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ralism)-415(are)-414(the)-415(phenomena)-415(of)-415(spiritualism.)-744(It)-414(will)-415(tend)-415(to)-414(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(illustration)-270(of)-270(this)-270(subject,)-276(if)-270(we)-540(consider)-270(the)-270(grounds)-270(on)-270(which)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([328])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(we)-356(reject)-357(a)-356(large)-357(portion)-356(of)-357(its)-356(reported)-357(phenomena)-356(quite)-356(irre-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(spectively)-203(of)-202(the)-203(evidence)-203(produced)-203(in)-202(favour)-203(of)-203(their)-202(reality,)-212(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ascribe)-241(the)-240(belief)-241(in)-240(them)-241(to)-241(the)-240(effect)-241(of)-240(an)-241(excited)-240(imagination,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-346(in)-345(some)-346(cases)-345(to)-346(imposture.)-536(In)-346(considering)-345(this)-346(subject,)-369(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-310(not)-309(necessary)-310(to)-309(examine)-309(whether)-310(the)-309(phenomena)-310(alleged)-309(by)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(spiritualists,)-229(if)-224(true,)-229(would)-224(be)-224(really)-224(supernatural,)-230(or)-223(belong)-224(to)-224(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-250(of)-250(nature)-250(hitherto)-250(unknown.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1345 0 obj <<
/Length 4610      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(289)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -252.311 -30.759 Td [(Many)-772(of)-773(the)-772(manifestations)-773(of)-772(spiritualism)-773(possess)-772(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(grotesqueness)-406(which)-407(we)-406(see)-406(in)-407(no)-406(other)-406(class)-407(of)-406(natural)-406(phe-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nomena.)-662(If)-388(they)-387(are)-388(alleged)-387(to)-388(be)-387(the)-388(results)-387(of)-388(the)-387(action)-387(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural)-329(forces)-328(previously)-329(unknown,)-348(then)-329(they)-329(must)-328(belong)-329(to)-328(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(class)-279(of)-278(forces)-279(which)-279(contrast)-278(in)-279(a)-279(most)-278(remarkable)-279(degree)-278(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-214(known)-214(ones;)-226(that)-214(is)-215(to)-214(say,)-221(the)-214(known)-214(and)-214(the)-214(unknown)-214(forces)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-379(nature)-378(must)-379(be)-379(utterly)-378(out)-379(of)-379(harmony)-378(with)-379(one)-379(another.)-635(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(am)-262(now)-262(speaking)-261(on)-262(the)-262(supposition)-261(that)-262(such)-262(forces)-262(are)-261(merely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural)-441(ones,)-488(not)-441(under)-441(the)-440(guidance)-441(of)-441(intelligence.)-822(In)-440(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(case)-346(they)-346(must)-347(have)-346(been)-346(always)-346(in)-347(existence,)-370(only)-346(latent;)-394(yet)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-290(now)-289(for)-290(the)-289(first)-290(time)-289(manifest)-290(themselves)-289(under)-290(very)-289(spe-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cial)-254(circumstances)-255(and)-254(conditions,)-255(such)-255(as)-254(are)-254(highly)-254(favourable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-377(the)-377(existence)-377(of)-377(delusion.)-631(The)-377(abnormal)-377(character)-377(of)-377(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena,)-506(so)-455(entirely)-455(at)-455(variance)-455(with)-455(the)-455(known)-455(order)-455(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nature,)-371(forms)-347(the)-346(strongest)-347(ground)-347(for)-346(the)-347(conviction)-347(that)-346(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-376(be)-376(the)-375(results)-376(of)-376(the)-375(action)-376(of)-376(unknown)-376(natural)-375(forces.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-347(would)-346(require)-347(an)-346(overwhelming)-346(amount)-347(of)-346(evidence)-347(to)-346(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(vince)-275(us)-275(that)-275(these)-275(two)-275(sets)-275(of)-274(natural)-275(forces,)-282(distinguishable)-274(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-348(strongest)-348(possible)-348(contrasts,)-373(\050viz.)-544(those)-348(which)-348(produce)-348(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(visible)-328(phenomena)-329(of)-328(nature,)-348(and)-328(those)-329(which)-328(produce)-328(another)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(class,)-431(intermittent)-394(in)-394(their)-395(action,)-430(of)-395(which)-394(grotesqueness)-394(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(monstrosity)-213(are)-212(the)-213(most)-213(striking)-212(characteristics,)-220(and)-213(which)-425(only)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([329])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(manifest)-231(their)-232(existence)-231(under)-231(circumstances)-232(calculated)-231(to)-231(throw)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-334(suspicion)-335(on)-334(their)-335(reality\051,)-355(can)-335(be)-334(the)-335(results)-334(of)-335(the)-334(action)-334(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(forces)-250(which)-250(have)-250(been)-250(present)-250(in)-250(nature)-250(during)-250(all)-250(past)-250(time.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(But)-344(further:)-440(these)-344(phenomena,)-368(if)-345(natural,)-368(must)-344(belong)-345(to)-344(an)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(order)-369(of)-369(nature)-369(which)-369(is)-369(not)-369(only)-369(unlike)-369(the)-369(visible)-369(order,)-398(but)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(would)-341(throw)-340(its)-341(action)-341(into)-341(confusion.)-522(I)-340(am)-341(here)-341(reasoning)-340(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-264(supposition)-265(that)-264(the)-264(moral)-264(order)-265(of)-264(the)-264(universe)-265(is)-264(due)-264(to)-264(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(action)-282(of)-281(nothing)-281(but)-282(physical)-281(forces.)-345(If)-281(this)-282(be)-281(so,)-290(it)-281(must)-281(form)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-321(portion)-321(of)-321(the)-321(existing)-321(order)-321(of)-321(nature.)-463(But)-321(the)-321(forces)-321(which,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-318(the)-318(supposition)-318(of)-318(the)-318(truth)-318(of)-318(spiritualism,)-335(must)-318(be)-318(capable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-317(being)-316(brought)-317(into)-316(activity,)-333(would)-317(interrupt)-316(that)-317(moral)-316(order)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-288(which)-289(we)-288(are)-289(actually)-288(conscious.)-366(Their)-288(action,)-298(if)-288(real,)-298(would)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1349 0 obj <<
/Length 4679      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(290)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(interrupt)-355(the)-354(entire)-355(course)-355(of)-355(the)-354(moral)-355(world.)-564(No)-355(man)-354(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-304(safe)-304(from)-304(their)-304(intrusion.)-411(Even)-304(in)-304(our)-304(deepest)-304(retirement)-303(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-276(never)-275(be)-276(free)-276(from)-275(the)-276(invasion)-276(of)-275(their)-276(prying)-275(curiosity.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Such)-384(a)-384(power)-384(would)-384(be)-384(incompatible)-384(with)-384(the)-384(moral)-384(order)-383(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(society.)-462(It)-321(follows,)-338(therefore,)-339(that)-321(an)-320(unknown)-321(order)-321(of)-320(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presenting)-389(the)-388(most)-389(violent)-388(contrast)-389(to)-388(the)-389(visible)-388(one,)-423(whose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena)-300(do)-300(not)-300(follow)-300(an)-300(invariable)-300(but)-300(an)-300(intermittent)-299(law,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-410(are)-411(only)-410(alleged)-411(to)-410(manifest)-411(themselves)-410(under)-410(conditions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(favourable)-238(to)-238(imposture,)-241(possesses)-238(such)-239(a)-238(degree)-238(of)-238(inherent)-238(im-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(probability)-191(as)-191(to)-191(justify)-191(its)-191(rejection,)-203(even)-191(by)-191(those)-190(who)-191(recognise)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(action)-250(of)-250(none)-250(but)-250(material)-250(forces)-250(in)-250(the)-250(universe.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-436(to)-435(those)-436(who)-435(recognise)-436(the)-435(present)-436(order)-435(of)-436(nature)-435(as)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(due)-354(to)-354(the)-355(action)-354(of)-354(a)-354(wise)-355(and)-354(intelligent)-354(Creator,)-380(it)-354(becomes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(absolutely)-279(incredible)-278(that)-279(forces)-278(such)-279(as)-279(the)-278(phenomena)-279(of)-278(spir-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(itualism)-308(require)-307(for)-308(their)-307(production,)-322(can)-307(form)-308(a)-307(portion)-308(of)-307(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(order)-237(which)-237(He)-474(has)-236(created,)-240(as)-237(they)-237(contradict)-237(every)-236(conception)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([330])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(we)-250(can)-250(rationally)-250(form)-250(of)-250(his)-250(character.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-386(if)-386(these)-386(phenomena)-385(are)-386(viewed)-386(as)-386(due)-386(to)-386(the)-386(action)-385(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-233(agency,)-237(the)-234(reality)-233(of)-233(their)-234(occurrence)-233(becomes)-233(still)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more)-279(inconceivable.)-336(If)-278(such)-279(agency)-279(is)-278(capable)-279(of)-279(being)-278(exerted,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-309(can)-309(only)-308(conceive)-309(that)-309(its)-309(exertion)-308(is)-309(permitted)-309(for)-309(the)-308(real-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ization)-301(of)-301(some)-301(known)-301(end.)-403(Yet)-301(the)-301(phenomena)-301(of)-300(spiritualism)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(serve)-259(no)-259(purpose)-259(whatever.)-277(Spiritualists)-259(have)-259(been)-259(holding)-258(their)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(s\351ances)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 36.9 0 Td [(for)-272(many)-273(years;)-284(but)-272(no)-273(one)-272(practical)-273(result)-272(has)-272(yet)-273(been)]TJ -36.9 -13.549 Td [(realized)-255(by)-256(them.)-265(The)-256(spirits)-255(of)-255(the)-256(departed)-255(have)-255(been)-255(invoked,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-263(they)-264(have)-263(never)-263(yet)-264(given)-263(a)-263(single)-264(useful)-263(response.)-290(Surely)-263(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(there)-280(be)-281(a)-280(spirit)-281(world,)-288(its)-280(occupations)-280(cannot)-281(be)-280(the)-280(production)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-322(the)-322(abnormal,)-340(the)-323(mean)-322(and)-322(the)-322(grotesque.)-466(Its)-322(employments)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-470(possess)-470(some)-470(pretensions)-469(to)-470(be)-470(esteemed)-470(dignified.)-909(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-346(been)-347(alleged)-346(that)-347(such)-346(manifestations)-346(help)-347(to)-346(convince)-346(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incredulous)-410(of)-410(the)-410(reality)-411(of)-410(the)-410(immortality)-410(of)-410(man.)-730(On)-410(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contrary,)-424(t)1(he)-389(idea)-389(that)-389(spirits)-389(can)-388(be)-389(guilty)-389(of)-389(such)-388(phantastic)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tricks)-221(can)-221(only)-221(help)-221(to)-221(throw)-221(discredit)-220(on)-221(the)-221(doctrine.)-241(It)-220(follows,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore,)-409(that)-377(if)-377(the)-377(phenomena)-377(of)-377(spiritualism)-377(are)-376(viewed)-377(as)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1353 0 obj <<
/Length 4446      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(291)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(due)-286(to)-286(supernatural)-286(causes,)-294(it)-286(is)-286(utterly)-286(incredible)-286(either)-286(that)-285(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Governor)-270(of)-271(the)-270(Universe)-270(would)-270(permit)-270(such)-271(a)-270(course)-270(of)-270(action,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-312(that)-312(the)-312(spirits)-312(themselves,)-327(unless)-312(deprived)-312(of)-312(reason,)-327(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exhibit)-259(themselves)-258(in)-259(such)-259(a)-259(variety)-258(of)-259(phantastic)-259(forms,)-261(and)-258(for)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(no)-284(other)-285(apparent)-284(purpose)-284(than)-284(to)-284(effect)-285(a)-284(number)-284(of)-284(capricious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interferences)-303(with)-304(the)-303(visible)-304(order)-303(of)-304(nature.)-410(This)-303(incredibility)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-329(so)-330(great)-329(as)-330(to)-329(entitle)-330(us)-329(summarily)-329(to)-330(reject)-329(the)-330(idea)-329(that)-329(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reputed)-398(phenomena)-398(can)-398(be)-399(actual)-398(occurrences.)-694(In)-398(addition)-398(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this,)-424(the)-389(alleged)-389(manifestations)-389(are)-389(made)-389(under)-388(circumstances)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(pre-eminently)-250(suited)-250(to)-250(excite)-250(suspicion.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([331])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -15.185 Td [(The)-308(phenomena)-308(of)-309(modern)-308(spiritualism)-308(are)-308(a)-308(fair)-309(ill)1(ustration)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(of)-415(the)-414(general)-415(character)-415(of)-415(the)-414(current)-415(supernaturalism)-415(of)-414(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ancient)-387(world.)-662(It)-387(was)-387(for)-387(the)-387(most)-387(part)-387(equally)-387(senseless)-387(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(absurd.)-634(The)-378(attestation)-378(to)-378(its)-378(actual)-378(occurrence)-378(was)-378(of)-378(a)-378(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inferior)-390(character)-390(to)-389(that)-390(which)-390(can)-390(be)-389(urged)-390(in)-390(favour)-390(of)-389(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alleged)-262(facts)-262(of)-263(spiritualism.)-286(I)-262(have)-263(merely)-262(taken)-262(notice)-262(of)-262(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(latter)-340(as)-339(an)-340(illustration)-340(of)-339(the)-340(general)-340(aspect)-339(of)-340(the)-339(phenomena)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-281(current)-281(supernaturalism,)-289(and)-281(as)-281(placing)-281(before)-281(us)-281(the)-280(reasons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-354(fully)-354(justify)-354(us)-353(in)-354(rejecting)-354(a)-354(large)-354(portion)-354(of)-354(it)-353(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(minutely)-250(inquiring)-250(into)-250(its)-250(evidence.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-474(will)-475(now)-474(proceed)-475(to)-474(contrast)-475(the)-474(entire)-475(mass)-474(of)-474(current)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(supernaturalism)-272(with)-273(the)-272(miracles)-273(of)-272(the)-272(New)-273(Testament)-272(for)-272(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purpose)-189(of)-190(still)-189(further)-190(illustrating)-189(the)-190(grounds)-189(on)-190(which)-189(we)-189(reject)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it,)-327(while)-312(we)-311(claim)-312(for)-312(the)-311(latter)-312(that)-312(their)-311(reality)-312(must)-312(be)-311(tested)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-309(the)-309(evidence)-309(which)-309(can)-309(be)-309(adduced)-309(in)-309(favour)-309(of)-309(their)-308(actual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrence.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Let)-330(me)-331(again)-330(draw)-330(attention)-331(to)-330(the)-330(fact)-331(that)-330(the)-330(only)-330(correct)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(conception)-335(of)-334(a)-335(miracle)-335(in)-335(connection)-334(with)-335(this)-335(controversy,)-355(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-258(of)-258(an)-259(event)-258(wrought)-258(in)-258(external)-259(nature)-258(with)-258(a)-258(definite)-258(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aim)-283(and)-282(purpose.)-348(Extraordinary)-283(events,)-291(to)-282(which)-283(no)-283(such)-282(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aim)-308(and)-308(purpose)-308(can)-308(be)-308(assigned,)-322(may)-308(be)-308(unusual)-308(occurrences,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-459(are)-459(in)-459(no)-459(proper)-459(sense)-459(of)-459(the)-459(words)-459(evidential)-459(miracles.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(An)-281(isolated)-281(occurrence)-282(of)-281(an)-281(extraordinary)-281(nature,)-289(and)-281(an)-281(event)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(marked)-305(with)-305(a)-305(definite)-304(moral)-305(purpose,)-319(are)-305(two)-305(wholly)-304(different)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1358 0 obj <<
/Length 4773      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(292)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(things.)-237(The)-211(one)-211(may)-212(be)-211(credible,)-219(and)-211(the)-211(other)-211(wholly)-211(incredible.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(We)-365(habitually)-364(recognise)-365(the)-365(distinction)-364(in)-365(ordinary)-365(life,)-393(and)-364(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entirely)-281(affects)-280(our)-281(judgment)-281(of)-281(the)-280(probability)-281(of)-281(an)-280(event.)-342(We)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(esteem)-256(the)-257(action)-256(of)-257(a)-256(particular)-257(person)-256(quite)-257(credible)-256(under)-256(one)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(set)-251(of)-251(circumstances,)-251(which)-251(we)-251(should)-251(reject)-251(as)-251(incredible)-250(under)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(another.)-649(Thus)-766(if)-383(we)-383(were)-383(informed)-383(that)-383(a)-383(friend)-383(with)-383(whom)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([332])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(we)-301(were)-302(intimately)-301(acquainted,)-315(had)-301(precipitated)-302(himself)-301(from)-301(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(height)-316(into)-315(the)-316(water,)-331(supposing)-316(him)-316(to)-315(be)-316(sane,)-331(we)-316(should)-315(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believe)-319(it.)-457(But)-318(if)-319(we)-319(received)-319(the)-319(information)-319(that)-319(he)-319(had)-318(done)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-326(to)-326(save)-326(a)-326(person)-326(from)-326(drowning,)-345(and)-326(we)-326(knew)-326(that)-326(he)-326(was)-326(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-308(of)-307(courage,)-322(we)-308(should)-307(accept)-308(the)-308(fact)-307(without)-308(the)-307(smallest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hesitation.)-600(On)-366(this)-367(account,)-396(therefore,)-395(the)-367(moral)-366(aspect)-367(of)-366(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alleged)-304(miracl)1(e)-304(is)-303(of)-304(the)-303(utmost)-304(importance;)-330(and)-304(it)-303(is)-303(necessary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-258(its)-258(correct)-258(conception)-259(that)-258(it)-258(should)-258(not)-258(only)-258(be)-258(an)-258(extraordi-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nary)-302(occurrence)-303(in)-302(external)-302(nature,)-316(but)-302(that)-302(it)-303(should)-302(take)-302(place)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-222(the)-222(bidding)-222(of)-221(another,)-228(and)-222(in)-222(order)-222(to)-221(render)-222(it)-222(credible,)-228(that)-221(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-250(be)-250(calculated)-250(to)-250(effectuate)-250(some)-250(definite)-250(moral)-250(purpose.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Alleged)-317(supernatural)-317(events,)-333(which)-317(are)-317(destitute)-317(of)-317(these)-316(ac-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(companiments,)-218(are)-209(always)-210(liable)-209(to)-210(a)-209(very)-210(high)-209(degree)-209(of)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 247.429 0 Td [(\340)-209(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -247.429 -13.549 Td [(suspicion.)-246(In)-238(fact)-239(it)-238(would)-238(be)-238(difficult)-238(to)-239(prove)-238(them)-238(to)-238(be)-238(super-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(natural.)-241(All)-224(that)-224(could)-224(be)-224(affirmed)-224(respecting)-224(them)-224(would)-224(be)-223(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-275(were)-275(very)-274(unusual)-275(occurrences,)-281(which)-275(it)-275(was)-275(impossible)-274(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(account)-362(for)-362(by)-361(the)-362(action)-362(of)-362(any)-362(known)-361(force.)-586(If)-362(the)-361(universe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-401(under)-401(the)-400(government)-401(of)-401(God,)-438(all)-401(supernatural)-401(action)-400(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(either)-264(be)-263(the)-264(result)-263(of)-264(Hi)1(s)-264(agency)-263(or)-264(permission.)-290(If)-264(He)-263(interferes)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-248(the)-248(order)-248(of)-248(occurrences,)-249(it)-248(is)-248(evident)-248(that)-248(such)-248(interference)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-301(be)-300(capricious,)-313(but)-301(must)-300(have)-301(a)-301(definite)-300(purpose.)-402(We)-300(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(justified,)-374(therefore,)-374(in)-349(refusing)-350(to)-349(accept)-349(occurrences)-349(as)-349(super-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural,)-275(which)-270(are)-270(destitute)-269(of)-270(all)-270(appearance)-270(of)-270(purpose)-270(in)-269(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performance.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-344(further:)-437(the)-344(alleged)-343(miracle)-344(must)-344(be)-343(consistent)-344(with)-343(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(character)-343(of)-344(God,)-367(before)-343(it)-344(is)-343(possible)-343(to)-344(attribute)-343(it)-344(to)-343(Him)-343(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(wrought)-308(by)-309(His)-308(direct)-309(agency.)-425(This)-308(rests)-308(on)-309(the)-308(same)-308(principle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-344(which)-344(we)-345(refuse)-344(to)-688(credit)-345(the)-344(reports)-344(of)-344(actions)-344(performed)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([333])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1363 0 obj <<
/Length 4735      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(293)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(by)-294(men)-294(which)-295(are)-294(contradictory)-294(to)-294(their)-294(well)-294(known)-294(characters.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(But)-266(this)-267(is)-266(far)-266(more)-267(certain)-266(with)-266(respect)-267(to)-266(God)-266(than)-267(it)-266(can)-266(be)-266(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man.)-517(Human)-340(characters)-339(can)-339(at)-339(best)-339(be)-339(but)-339(imperfectly)-339(known,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-223(there)-223(are)-223(unseen)-223(depths)-223(in)-223(the)-223(human)-223(heart)-223(which)-222(sometimes)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(render)-359(actions)-358(possible,)-386(which)-359(stand)-358(in)-359(striking)-358(contrast)-359(to)-358(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(general)-323(character)-324(of)-323(the)-323(agents.)-470(To)-324(state)-323(the)-323(truth)-324(generally,)-341(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-424(is)-425(impossible)-424(that)-424(man)-425(can)-424(act)-424(in)-425(opposition)-424(to)-424(the)-424(inmost)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(principles)-439(of)-438(his)-439(moral)-439(being,)-486(so)-438(in)-439(a)-439(far)-438(higher)-439(degree)-439(is)-438(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impossible)-285(that)-284(God)-285(can)-284(contradict)-285(the)-285(perfections)-284(of)-285(His)-284(moral)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nature.)-622(This)-374(being)-375(so,)-405(it)-374(follows)-374(that)-374(we)-374(are)-374(entitled)-374(to)-374(reject)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-389(miracles)-389(alleged)-389(to)-389(have)-389(been)-389(wrought)-389(by)-389(God,)-423(which)-389(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contrary)-407(to)-407(His)-407(moral)-408(attributes;)-485(all)-407(which)-408(are)-407(low,)-446(mean,)-446(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(grotesque,)-250(and)-250(unfitted)-250(to)-250(realize)-250(an)-250(elevated)-250(moral)-250(purpose.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-277(will)-276(here)-277(be)-276(objected)-277(that)-277(if)-276(these)-277(positions)-277(are)-276(true,)-283(demo-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(niacal)-298(miracles)-298(are)-298(rendered)-299(impossible.)-394(I)-298(have)-298(already)-298(pointed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(out)-371(that)-371(if)-371(demoniacal)-371(supernaturalism)-371(is)-371(affirmed)-371(in)-371(the)-371(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-421(to)-422(be)-421(an)-421(actuality,)-464(its)-421(action)-422(is)-421(described)-421(as)-421(being)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(limited)-268(to)-269(the)-268(human)-269(mind,)-273(and)-268(that)-269(whatever)-268(permitted)-268(activity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-416(conceded)-416(to)-415(it,)-458(always)-415(bears)-416(the)-416(most)-416(distinctive)-416(marks)-415(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-211(from)-210(beneath.)-237(There)-211(is)-210(no)-211(possibility)-210(of)-211(mistaking)-210(between)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-250(supernatural)-250(occurrences)-250(and)-250(the)-250(miracles)-250(of)-250(God.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Such)-342(then)-341(are)-342(our)-342(general)-341(principles,)-365(the)-342(truth)-341(of)-342(which)-341(can)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(hardly)-337(be)-336(contested.)-510(If)-337(they)-337(are)-336(true,)-359(the)-336(great)-337(mass)-337(of)-336(current)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernaturalism)-247(is)-248(worthy)-247(of)-247(rejection)-248(for)-247(the)-247(following)-247(reasons.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(1.)-254(While)-252(it)-251(claims)-252(to)-251(be)-251(the)-252(result)-251(of)-252(supernatural)-251(agency,)-252(it)-251(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(destitute)-214(of)-213(all)-214(definite)-214(moral)-214(purpose,)-221(and)-213(such)-214(moral)-214(impress)-213(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-199(bears)-200(is)-199(mean)-200(and)-199(degraded.)-233(What)-200(end,)-209(I)-200(ask,)-209(was)-200(it)-199(designed)-199(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(serve?)-234(It)-201(involved)-201(an)-201(almost)-201(continual)-201(interference)-201(with)-200(the)-201(order)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-432(nature;)-227(or)-216(if)-216(at)-216(times)-216(it)-215(claimed)-216(to)-216(be)-216(due)-216(to)-216(occult)-216(forces,)-222(they)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([334])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(were)-337(only)-337(suited)-336(to)-337(confound)-337(the)-336(visible)-337(order)-337(of)-337(the)-336(universe.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-287(am)-288(reasoning)-287(on)-288(the)-287(supposition)-288(that)-287(there)-288(is)-287(a)-288(God)-287(who)-287(rules)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-258(world.)-274(This)-258(being)-258(so,)-260(it)-258(is)-258(impossible)-258(to)-258(conceive)-258(that)-258(such)-258(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mode)-308(of)-309(acting)-308(can)-309(be)-308(His.)-426(Under)-308(this)-309(head)-308(of)-308(supernaturalism)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fall)-290(all)-290(the)-290(monstrous)-291(and)-290(the)-290(grotesque,)-300(and)-290(the)-290(entire)-290(range)-290(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1367 0 obj <<
/Length 4461      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(294)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(magical)-250(phenomena.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(2.)-817(The)-438(whole)-439(range)-439(of)-439(ancient)-439(supernaturalism)-439(is)-439(in)-438(con-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(tradiction)-433(to)-433(everything)-433(which)-433(we)-433(can)-433(conceive)-433(of)-433(the)-432(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-327(of)-327(God.)-481(Let)-327(us)-327(take)-327(as)-327(an)-327(illustration)-327(the)-327(phenomena)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-237(Soothsaying.)-246(Who)-237(can)-238(believe)-237(that)-237(God)-238(employed)-237(the)-237(entrails)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-357(slaughtered)-357(beasts)-358(as)-357(the)-357(means)-357(of)-357(revealing)-358(the)-357(future?)-571(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-456(it)-456(was)-456(consistent)-456(with)-456(his)-456(character)-456(to)-456(manifest)-456(his)-455(will)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(through)-253(a)-253(multitude)-253(of)-253(monstrous)-253(portents?)-259(There)-253(is)-253(perhaps)-252(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-355(single)-355(occurrence)-356(of)-355(ancient)-355(supernaturalism)-355(which)-355(does)-355(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(offend)-334(against)-335(our)-334(primary)-335(conception)-334(of)-335(the)-334(Divine)-334(character;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and,)-250(therefore,)-250(the)-250(whole)-250(is)-250(worthy)-250(of)-250(summary)-250(rejection.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(3.)-794(Ancient)-432(supernaturalism)-431(assigned)-431(its)-432(occurrences)-431(to)-431(no)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(cause)-279(adequate)-278(to)-279(produce)-278(them.)-335(Those)-279(who)-278(asserted)-279(its)-278(reality,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(referred)-384(it)-384(to)-384(the)-384(action)-384(of)-384(deities)-384(who)-384(possessed)-384(very)-383(limited)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power,)-404(or)-373(to)-373(occult)-373(powers)-373(in)-373(nature.)-619(Such)-373(occult)-373(powers)-373(we)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(now)-285(know)-285(to)-285(have)-286(no)-285(existence,)-294(and)-285(the)-285(power)-285(attributed)-285(to)-285(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposed)-295(deities)-295(was)-295(far)-295(too)-295(limited)-295(to)-295(be)-295(capable)-295(of)-295(producing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-309(results)-310(in)-309(question.)-429(All)-309(reputed)-310(events,)-324(the)-310(alleged)-309(cause)-309(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-204(is)-205(unable)-204(to)-204(produce)-205(them,)-213(we)-204(are)-205(entitled)-204(to)-204(reject)-204(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(further)-250(investigation.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(4.)-635(A)-378(large)-378(amount)-378(of)-379(ancient)-378(supernaturalism)-378(rested)-378(on)-378(no)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-198(whatever.)-233(Of)-197(those)-198(portions)-198(for)-198(which)-198(any)-198(reasons)-197(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alleged,)-343(the)-324(evidence)-324(itself)-324(was)-324(of)-324(a)-324(character)-324(exactly)-324(suited)-324(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discredit)-336(it.)-508(Of)-336(this)-336(kind)-336(was)-336(the)-336(whole)-336(of)-336(the)-336(supernaturalism)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(connected)-629(with)-315(the)-315(state)-314(religions.)-444(These)-315(were)-315(in)-314(the)-315(hands)-314(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([335])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(men)-262(who)-262(used)-262(them)-262(for)-261(the)-262(purpose)-262(of)-262(acting)-262(on)-262(the)-262(vulgar,)-264(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-309(therefore)-308(readily)-308(accepted)-309(the)-308(report)-309(of)-308(anything,)-323(however)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incredible,)-285(which)-278(could)-278(subserve)-277(their)-278(end.)-334(Other)-278(portions)-277(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(palpable)-272(impostures)-273(worked)-272(for)-272(the)-272(basest)-273(and)-272(most)-272(selfish)-272(pur-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(poses.)-259(A)-254(very)-253(brief)-253(acquaintance)-253(with)-253(the)-253(nature)-253(of)-253(the)-253(evidence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-278(which)-278(it)-278(rests)-278(is)-278(sufficient)-278(to)-278(justify)-278(us)-278(in)-278(rejecting)-278(it)-277(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entering)-250(on)-250(any)-250(inquiry)-250(as)-250(to)-250(its)-250(details.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(Such)-207(being)-206(the)-207(general)-207(character)-207(of)-206(ancient)-207(supernaturalism,)-215(it)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-218(absurd)-218(to)-219(argue)-218(that)-218(its)-218(existence)-218(is)-219(a)-218(reason)-218(for)-218(rejecting)-218(along)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1371 0 obj <<
/Length 4297      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(295)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(with)-219(it)-219(another)-218(order)-219(of)-219(supernaturalism,)-225(which)-219(stands)-218(contrasted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-204(it)-204(in)-204(every)-204(particular.)-235(We)-204(might)-204(as)-204(well)-204(urge)-204(the)-204(existence)-204(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-223(vast)-223(number)-223(of)-224(counterfeits)-223(as)-223(a)-223(reason)-223(for)-223(rejecting)-223(everything)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-283(is)-282(genuine.)-348(We)-282(do)-283(not)-283(reject)-282(it)-283(because)-282(it)-283(is)-282(supernatural,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(but)-251(because)-250(it)-251(is)-250(utterly)-251(incredible.)-252(A)-250(statement)-251(of)-250(a)-251(few)-250(particu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lars)-291(will)-290(exhibit)-291(the)-291(contrast)-291(between)-290(it)-291(and)-291(the)-290(supernaturalism)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)-250(in)-250(a)-250(striking)-250(point)-250(of)-250(view.)]TJ 11.956 -14.367 Td [(1.)-535(Christian)-345(supernaturalism)-345(alleges)-345(that)-345(its)-345(occurrences)-345(are)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(the)-317(result)-318(of)-317(the)-317(action)-318(of)-317(a)-317(force)-318(which,)-334(if)-317(present,)-334(is)-317(certainly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adequate)-343(to)-344(produce)-343(them.)-530(Ancient)-344(supernaturalism)-343(alleges)-343(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cause)-250(whatever,)-250(or)-250(one)-250(wholly)-250(inadequate.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(2.)-276(Christian)-259(supernaturalism)-259(alleges)-258(a)-259(perfectly)-259(adequate)-258(pur-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(pose)-288(for)-287(its)-287(production;)-307(that)-287(purpose)-288(being)-287(the)-288(attestation)-287(of)-287(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(divine)-312(mission)-313(of)-312(Jesus.)-437(Ancient)-312(supernaturalism)-312(alleges)-312(either)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-250(purpose)-250(at)-250(all,)-250(or)-250(a)-250(degraded)-250(one.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(3.)-781(Christian)-427(supernaturalism)-427(is)-427(made)-427(to)-427(centre)-427(around)-427(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(greatest)-415(and)-414(most)-415(exalted)-415(character)-415(that)-414(has)-415(ever)-415(appeared)-414(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(history.)-777(Ancient)-426(supernaturalism,)-470(instead)-426(of)-426(being)-425(connected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-248(the)-248(most)-247(eminent)-248(characters)-496(of)-248(the)-247(times,)-249(directly)-247(connects)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([336])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(itself)-250(with)-250(the)-250(most)-250(questionable.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(4.)-737(Christian)-413(supernaturalism)-412(is)-413(stamped)-412(throughout)-413(with)-412(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(high)-318(moral)-317(character)-318(and)-318(aspect.)-452(This)-318(is)-318(wholly)-317(wanting)-318(in)-317(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernaturalism)-250(of)-250(the)-250(ancient)-250(world.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(5.)-281(Christian)-261(supernaturalism)-260(belongs)-261(to)-260(an)-261(elevated)-260(order)-260(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(type;)-233(the)-225(objects)-224(realized)-225(by)-225(it)-224(were)-225(for)-225(the)-224(most)-225(part)-224(benevolent.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-351(mode)-351(of)-350(its)-351(action)-351(was)-350(dignified)-351(and)-351(the)-351(effects)-350(produced)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-324(it)-323(were)-324(instantaneous,)-342(following)-324(directly)-324(on)-323(the)-324(word)-324(of)-323(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agent.)-412(The)-304(mode)-304(in)-304(which)-304(its)-304(miracles)-304(were)-304(performed)-304(is)-303(char-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(acterized)-402(by)-402(the)-402(utmost)-402(simplicity,)-440(destitute)-402(alike)-402(of)-401(anything)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(scenic)-299(or)-299(fantastic,)-311(entirely)-299(in)-299(harmony)-299(with)-299(the)-299(great)-299(character)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-287(performed)-287(them.)-360(The)-287(supernaturalism)-287(of)-287(the)-287(ancient)-286(world)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-250(marked)-250(by)-250(the)-250(opposite)-250(characteristics.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(6.)-923(Christian)-475(supernaturalism,)-531(or)-474(to)-475(speak)-474(more)-474(correctly,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-284(greatest)-284(supernatural)-284(occurrence)-284(which)-284(Christianity)-283(records,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1375 0 obj <<
/Length 4510      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(296)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(namely)-389(the)-388(Resurrection)-389(of)-388(Christ,)-424(has)-388(not)-389(only)-388(left)-389(a)-388(mighty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impression)-334(on)-335(history,)-355(but)-335(has)-334(created)-335(a)-334(civilization)-335(of)-334(its)-334(own)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-407(embraces)-407(all)-407(the)-407(progressive)-407(nations)-406(of)-407(the)-407(world,)-446(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exerts)-202(a)-203(powerful)-202(influence)-202(even)-203(on)-202(those)-202(who)-203(deny)-202(its)-202(truth.)-234(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(only)-278(result)-279(wrought)-278(by)-279(the)-278(supernaturalism)-278(of)-279(the)-278(ancient)-278(world)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-250(the)-250(moral)-250(degradation)-250(of)-250(those)-250(among)-250(whom)-250(it)-250(prevailed.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(7.)-397(The)-300(supernaturalism)-299(of)-299(Christianity)-299(rests)-299(on)-299(an)-299(attestation)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(which)-420(even)-421(unbelievers)-420(would)-421(allow)-420(to)-420(be)-421(quite)-420(sufficient)-420(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(establish)-341(the)-341(truth)-341(of)-341(any)-340(ordinary)-341(facts.)-523(The)-341(other)-341(rests)-340(either)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-351(no)-351(testimony)-351(at)-351(all,)-376(or)-351(on)-351(one)-351(which)-351(is)-351(open)-351(to)-351(the)-350(gravest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(suspicion.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Such)-286(are)-286(some)-286(of)-286(the)-286(striking)-286(contrasts)-286(which)-286(distinguish)-286(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(supernaturalism)-316(of)-315(the)-316(New)-315(Testament)-316(from)-316(that)-315(of)-316(the)-315(ancient)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(world.)-243(When)-227(two)-228(series)-227(of)-228(events)-228(present)-227(such)-228(opposite)-227(features,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-248(is)-248(the)-248(duty)-248(of)-496(a)-248(sound)-248(philosophy)-248(to)-248(trace)-248(these)-248(distinctions)-248(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([337])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(their)-285(causes,)-293(and)-285(to)-284(show)-285(what)-285(is)-284(the)-285(nature)-285(of)-284(the)-285(forces)-284(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-352(impressed)-352(on)-351(each)-352(series)-352(its)-352(own)-352(peculiar)-351(characteristics.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Instead)-272(of)-272(this,)-277(however,)-277(we)-272(are)-272(invited)-272(to)-272(pronounce)-272(both)-271(alike)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incredible;)-322(that)-298(is)-298(to)-297(say,)-310(because)-298(one)-298(series)-298(of)-298(events)-298(is)-297(deeply)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(impressed)-251(with)-251(characteristics)-252(which)-251(render)-251(them)-251(incredible,)-251(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-297(invited)-297(to)-297(pronounce)-297(a)-297(similar)-297(condemnation)-297(on)-297(another)-297(se-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ries,)-371(which)-347(is)-347(distinguished)-347(by)-347(the)-347(most)-346(opposite)-347(features,)-371(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-285(has)-285(only)-284(this)-285(point)-285(in)-285(common)-285(with)-284(the)-285(former,)-294(that)-284(both)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belong)-334(to)-334(an)-334(order)-335(of)-334(events)-334(which)-334(we)-334(designate)-334(as)-334(supernatu-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ral.)-453(Nothing)-318(can)-317(be)-318(more)-317(unphilosophical)-318(than)-318(such)-317(a)-318(mode)-317(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reasoning.)-510(We)-336(reject)-337(the)-337(one)-336(series)-337(in)-336(a)-337(mass,)-358(not)-337(because)-336(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-335(which)-335(it)-335(contains)-335(are)-335(supernatural,)-356(but)-335(because)-335(they)-335(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(absolutely)-362(incredible.)-584(A)-362(similar)-362(rule)-361(we)-362(apply)-361(to)-362(ordinary,)-389(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(less)-250(than)-250(supernatural)-250(occurrences.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-352(it)-352(will)-352(doubtless)-352(be)-352(objected)-352(that)-352(there)-352(is)-352(another)-351(series)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-490(supernatural)-490(occurrences)-491(which)-490(rational)-490(men,)-550(with)-490(a)-490(few)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exceptions,)-413(greet)-380(with)-380(an)-381(equally)-380(summary)-380(rejection,)-413(viz.)-640(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(long)-254(series)-254(of)-254(ecclesiastical)-253(miracles)-254(which)-254(extends)-254(in)-254(an)-253(almost)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unbroken)-316(succession)-316(from)-316(the)-315(second)-316(century)-316(of)-316(our)-316(era)-315(nearly)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1379 0 obj <<
/Length 4375      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(297)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(to)-440(the)-440(present)-440(day.)-819(These,)-488(it)-440(has)-439(been)-440(urged,)-488(are)-440(alleged)-439(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-293(been)-292(wrought)-293(in)-293(attestation)-292(of)-293(Christianity,)-303(and)-293(bear)-292(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remarkable)-330(analogy,)-350(as)-330(facts)-329(wrought)-330(in)-330(external)-330(nature,)-350(to)-329(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-336(recorded)-336(in)-336(the)-336(Gospels.)-509(It)-336(is)-336(argued)-336(that)-336(if)-336(we)-336(reject)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(one,)-250(we)-250(are)-250(for)-250(the)-250(same)-250(reason)-250(bound)-250(to)-250(reject)-250(the)-250(others.)]TJ 11.956 -14.367 Td [(The)-250(following)-250(points)-250(may)-250(be)-250(considered)-250(as)-250(admitted.)]TJ 0 -14.368 Td [(First;)-528(That)-436(every)-436(century)-435(from)-436(the)-435(second)-436(downwards)-435(has)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(been)-223(characterized)-224(by)-223(a)-223(considerable)-223(amount)-224(of)-223(pretension)-223(to)-223(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession)-364(of)-365(supernatural)-364(power;)-844(and)-364(during)-365(this)-364(period)-364(one)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([338])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(section)-272(of)-272(the)-273(Christian)-272(Church)-272(claims)-272(to)-272(have)-272(actually)-272(wrought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(Secondly;)-392(Several)-345(of)-344(these)-345(miracles,)-368(viewed)-345(merely)-345(as)-344(phe-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(nomena)-194(in)-194(outward)-194(nature,)-206(are)-194(precisely)-194(similar)-194(to)-194(those)-194(recorded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(Thirdly;)-253(When)-253(a)-252(miracle)-252(is)-252(alleged)-253(to)-252(have)-252(been)-252(performed)-252(at)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-285(present)-286(day,)-294(as)-285(has)-286(recently)-285(been)-285(the)-285(case)-286(in)-285(a)-285(neighbouring)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(country,)-356(not)-334(only)-335(all)-334(unbelievers)-335(in)-334(the)-335(possibility)-334(of)-334(supernat-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ural)-407(occurrences,)-446(but)-407(also)-406(all)-407(rational)-407(Christians)-407(concur)-407(in)-406(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(summary)-317(rejection,)-333(not)-317(merely)-317(on)-316(the)-317(ground)-317(that)-317(the)-316(evidence)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-250(insufficient,)-250(but)-250(that)-250(the)-250(event)-250(is)-250(in)-250(itself)-250(incredible.)]TJ 11.956 -14.367 Td [(Fourthly;)-468(That)-396(rational)-395(men)-395(reject)-396(in)-395(a)-396(similar)-395(manner)-395(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(for)-359(similar)-359(reasons)-359(the)-359(great)-359(mass)-359(of)-359(ecclesiastical)-359(miracles)-358(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unworthy)-250(of)-250(serious)-250(inquiry)-250(into)-250(their)-250(attestation.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(With)-433(respect)-432(to)-433(the)-433(second)-432(point,)-479(I)-432(have)-433(already)-432(observed)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-362(if)-362(we)-362(view)-362(miracles)-362(merely)-362(as)-362(phenomena)-362(in)-362(external)-361(na-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ture,)-337(and)-319(if)-320(a)-319(similar)-320(belief)-319(in)-320(a)-319(current)-320(supernaturalism,)-336(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-433(have)-432(seen)-433(to)-432(be)-433(one)-433(of)-432(the)-433(phenomena)-432(of)-433(human)-432(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(prevailed)-349(in)-350(the)-349(Church,)-375(it)-349(was)-349(to)-350(be)-349(expected)-350(that)-349(the)-349(current)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forms)-251(of)-251(ecclesiastical)-250(supernaturalism)-251(would)-251(adopt)-251(those)-251(of)-250(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(New)-347(Testament)-346(for)-347(their)-347(basis,)-371(and)-346(consequently)-347(that)-347(it)-346(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(abound)-223(in)-223(narratives)-223(of)-224(resurrections)-223(from)-223(the)-223(dead)-223(and)-223(the)-223(cures)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-360(various)-359(diseases.)-579(This)-360(is)-359(actually)-360(the)-360(case.)-579(It)-359(may)-360(also)-359(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(only)-284(excite)-283(our)-284(wonder)-283(that)-284(the)-283(model)-283(was)-284(not)-283(far)-284(more)-283(exactly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(copied,)-288(but)-281(that)-280(ecclesiastical,)-288(and)-281(especially)-280(monkish)-280(miracles,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1384 0 obj <<
/Length 4647      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(298)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(which)-376(constitute)-375(an)-376(overwhelming)-376(majority)-375(of)-376(the)-376(miracles)-375(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church)-425(history,)-468(abound)-425(so)-425(largely)-424(in)-425(features)-425(which)-425(stand)-424(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-214(marked)-214(contrast)-214(to)-214(the)-214(miracles)-214(of)-213(the)-214(New)-214(Testament,)-221(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(peculiar)-236(characteristics)-235(being)-236(the)-235(same)-236(as)-236(those)-235(of)-236(ancient)-235(super-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(naturalism,)-301(viz.)-374(the)-582(monstrous)-291(and)-292(the)-291(grotesque.)-373(This)-291(point)-291(is)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([339])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(one)-244(which)-243(demands)-244(the)-244(serious)-243(consideration)-244(of)-244(unbelievers;)-245(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if,)-206(as)-196(they)-195(aver,)-207(they)-195(are)-196(both)-195(due)-196(to)-195(the)-196(action)-195(of)-196(the)-195(same)-195(causes,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-248(diversity)-248(requires)-247(to)-248(be)-248(accounted)-248(for.)-249(The)-248(truth)-247(is,)-249(that)-247(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-297(exception)-297(that)-297(both)-297(series)-297(contain)-297(reports)-297(of)-297(miracles)-297(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-257(similar)-257(or)-257(mere)-257(objective)-257(occurrences,)-259(in)-257(other)-257(respects)-257(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(characteristics)-250(differ)-250(widely.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(With)-275(respect)-275(to)-275(the)-274(fact)-275(that)-275(rational)-275(men)-275(concur)-275(in)-275(the)-274(rejec-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tion)-359(of)-359(modern)-359(miracles,)-386(it)-359(should)-359(be)-359(observed)-359(that)-359(this)-359(is)-358(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(because)-241(all)-242(supernatural)-241(events)-242(are)-241(believed)-241(to)-242(be)-241(incredible;)-244(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(because)-437(the)-436(reputed)-437(events)-436(themselves)-437(possess)-436(characteristics)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-457(excite)-457(in)-456(us)-457(the)-457(gravest)-457(suspicions)-457(of)-456(their)-457(truth;)-560(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(especially)-329(because)-329(by)-328(far)-329(the)-329(greatest)-328(number)-329(of)-329(them)-329(are)-328(well)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(known)-394(not)-394(to)-394(have)-395(originated)-394(in)-394(mere)-394(credulity,)-430(but)-394(in)-394(actual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(imposture.)-310(Men)-270(or)-270(communities)-270(who)-270(have)-270(once)-270(lent)-269(themselves)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-302(the)-302(deliberate)-302(coining)-301(of)-302(miracles,)-315(are)-302(of)-302(blasted)-301(reputations,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-272(whenever)-273(marvellous)-272(occurrences)-272(are)-273(reported)-272(by)-272(such)-272(per-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sons,)-330(we)-313(are)-314(justified)-313(in)-314(rejecting)-314(them)-313(without)-314(further)-313(inquiry.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(It)-400(is)-399(evident)-400(that)-399(these)-399(are)-400(the)-399(grounds)-400(on)-399(which)-400(such)-399(stories)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-254(rejected,)-255(and)-254(not)-254(simply)-254(because)-254(they)-254(are)-254(supernatural,)-254(since)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-279(who)-278(believe)-279(in)-278(the)-278(supernaturalism)-279(of)-278(the)-279(New)-278(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(concur)-250(with)-250(those)-250(who)-250(disbelieve)-250(in)-250(it,)-250(in)-250(thus)-250(rejecting)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-258(must)-257(now)-258(briefly)-258(consider)-258(the)-257(general)-258(grounds)-258(on)-258(which)-257(we)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(reject)-287(the)-287(great)-287(mass)-288(of)-287(ecclesiastical)-287(miracles,)-296(while)-287(we)-287(accept)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-250(in)-250(the)-250(Gospels)-250(as)-250(actual)-250(occurrences.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-330(general)-330(ground)-330(of)-330(our)-330(rejection)-330(of)-330(them)-330(is)-330(precisely)-330(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(same)-178(as)-177(that)-178(on)-177(which)-177(we)-178(reject)-177(the)-178(supernaturalism)-177(of)-178(the)-177(ancient)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(world.)-349(The)-284(only)-283(thing)-283(which)-283(distinguishes)-283(them)-283(from)-283(the)-283(latter,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-343(that)-343(they)-687(contain)-343(a)-343(number)-343(of)-344(events)-343(which)-343(viewed)-343(as)-343(bare)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([340])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(facts)-259(are)-259(similar)-260(to)-259(those)-259(recorded)-259(in)-259(the)-260(Gospels.)-277(In)-259(every)-259(other)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1389 0 obj <<
/Length 4483      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(299)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(respect)-285(the)-284(contrast)-285(is)-285(complete.)-354(I)-284(shall)-285(only)-285(draw)-284(attention)-285(to)-284(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(few)-327(considerations)-328(which)-327(might)-327(otherwise)-328(escape)-327(the)-327(notice)-327(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(reader.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-424(ecclesiastical)-424(miracles)-423(were)-424(not)-424(wrought)-424(in)-423(attestation)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-209(the)-209(person)-210(working)-209(them)-209(had)-209(a)-209(divine)-210(commission,)-217(but)-209(that)-209(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(divine)-187(power)-186(permanently)-187(abode)-186(in)-187(the)-186(Church.)-229(The)-186(qualification)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-396(was)-395(thought)-396(necessary)-396(for)-396(the)-395(exhibition)-396(of)-396(this)-395(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-373(the)-374(possession)-373(of)-374(a)-373(great)-373(degree)-374(of)-373(reputed)-373(sanctity.)-620(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exercise)-237(of)-236(miraculous)-236(power)-237(was)-236(supposed)-237(to)-236(prove,)-240(not)-236(that)-236(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessor)-269(had)-269(a)-270(divine)-269(commission,)-274(but)-269(that)-269(he)-269(was)-270(a)-269(saint.)-307(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(saint)-339(was)-340(supposed)-339(to)-340(have)-339(in)-340(himself)-339(some)-340(inherent)-339(power)-339(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(working)-295(miracles,)-306(bearing)-294(a)-295(considerable)-294(analogy)-295(to)-295(that)-294(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-309(woman)-308(with)-309(the)-308(issue)-309(of)-308(blood)-308(believed)-309(to)-308(be)-309(possessed)-308(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-357(Lord.)-572(A)-358(miraculous)-357(power)-357(in)-358(the)-357(shape)-357(of)-358(a)-357(virtue)-357(issued)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-204(the)-205(saint.)-235(Hence)-204(the)-205(supernatural)-204(power)-205(which)-204(was)-204(ascribed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-288(dead)-288(men's)-288(bones)-288(and)-288(to)-288(relics.)-364(Such)-288(a)-288(supernatural)-288(power)-287(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(devoid)-342(of)-341(everything)-342(which)-342(presupposes)-341(a)-342(divine)-342(purpose,)-364(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-253(all)-253(evidential)-253(value.)-259(Its)-253(frequency)-253(would)-253(destroy)-253(the)-253(nature)-252(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-307(miracle)-308(as)-307(an)-308(attestation)-307(of)-307(a)-308(divine)-307(commission,)-322(and)-307(involve)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-377(interference)-377(with)-377(the)-377(order)-377(of)-377(nature,)-409(which)-377(would)-377(destroy)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-230(sense)-230(of)-230(its)-230(regularity,)-234(the)-230(knowledge)-230(of)-230(which)-230(is)-230(so)-229(essential)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-423(our)-423(well)-423(being,)-466(as)-423(well)-422(as)-423(to)-423(the)-423(conception)-423(of)-423(a)-422(miracle.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Moreover,)-446(the)-407(supernatural)-407(agency)-407(is)-407(not)-407(supposed)-407(to)-407(be)-406(due)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-324(the)-323(direct)-324(intervention)-323(of)-324(God,)-342(but)-324(to)-323(some)-324(imaginary)-323(virtue)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(residing)-250(in)-250(man.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-293(ecclesiastical)-292(miracles)-293(of)-293(which)-293(we)-292(have)-293(anything)-293(like)-292(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(detailed)-210(account,)-217(when)-210(they)-209(are)-210(not)-210(simply)-209(regarded)-210(as)-209(due)-210(to)-209(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(direct)-254(sanctity)-253(of)-254(the)-253(person)-507(performing)-254(them,)-254(are)-254(never)-253(alleged)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([341])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(to)-258(be)-257(performed)-258(in)-258(proof)-257(of)-258(a)-258(divine)-258(commission;)-261(but)-258(when)-257(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-346(asserted)-346(to)-346(have)-345(been)-346(evidential,)-370(they)-346(are)-346(affirmed)-346(to)-345(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-354(wrought)-355(in)-354(proof)-354(of)-355(some)-354(doctrine,)-380(or)-355(in)-354(favour)-354(of)-354(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(particular)-279(party)-278(in)-279(the)-279(Church;)-293(or,)-286(what)-279(invests)-278(them)-279(with)-279(a)-278(still)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(greater)-215(degree)-215(of)-215(suspicion,)-222(in)-215(favour)-215(of)-215(the)-215(power)-215(of)-215(a)-214(particular)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order.)-231(The)-191(last)-192(class)-191(of)-192(alleged)-192(miracles)-191(may)-192(at)-191(once)-192(be)-191(dismissed)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1252 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 984
/Length 9054      
>>
stream
1248 0 1254 78 1256 197 1253 256 1258 334 1260 453 1261 512 1257 569 1263 635 1265 754
1262 812 1266 878 1269 919 1271 1026 1267 1145 1273 1203 1270 1261 1276 1339 1278 1458 1275 1517
1280 1595 1282 1714 1279 1773 1284 1839 1286 1958 1283 2017 1288 2083 1290 2202 1287 2261 1292 2327
1294 2446 1291 2503 1296 2569 1298 2688 1299 2747 1295 2804 1302 2882 1304 3001 1301 3060 1306 3126
1308 3245 1305 3304 1310 3382 1312 3501 1309 3560 1314 3626 1316 3745 1313 3803 1318 3869 1320 3988
1317 4046 1322 4112 1324 4231 1325 4289 1321 4346 1328 4412 1330 4531 1327 4589 1331 4655 1334 4696
1336 4828 1332 4947 1338 5005 1335 5063 1340 5129 1342 5248 1339 5307 1344 5373 1346 5492 1343 5551
1348 5617 1350 5736 1347 5795 1352 5873 1354 5992 1351 6050 1357 6116 1359 6235 1360 6294 1356 6352
1362 6430 1364 6549 1361 6607 1366 6673 1368 6792 1365 6851 1370 6917 1372 7036 1369 7095 1374 7161
1376 7280 1373 7339 1378 7405 1380 7524 1377 7583 1383 7649 1385 7768 1386 7827 1382 7885 1388 7951
% 1248 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1254 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1255 0 R
/Resources 1253 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1243 0 R
>>
% 1256 0 obj
<<
/D [1254 0 R /XYZ 323.016 423.331 null]
>>
% 1253 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1258 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1259 0 R
/Resources 1257 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1243 0 R
>>
% 1260 0 obj
<<
/D [1258 0 R /XYZ 167.299 477.528 null]
>>
% 1261 0 obj
<<
/D [1258 0 R /XYZ 259.45 79.691 null]
>>
% 1257 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1263 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1264 0 R
/Resources 1262 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1243 0 R
>>
% 1265 0 obj
<<
/D [1263 0 R /XYZ 93.543 190.442 null]
>>
% 1262 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1266 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index15) >>
% 1269 0 obj
(Chapter XIV. The Love Of The Marvellous--Its Bearing On The Value Of Testimony To Miracles.)
% 1271 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1272 0 R
/Resources 1270 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1274 0 R
>>
% 1267 0 obj
<<
/D [1271 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 1273 0 obj
<<
/D [1271 0 R /XYZ 155.992 106.79 null]
>>
% 1270 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1276 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1277 0 R
/Resources 1275 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1274 0 R
>>
% 1278 0 obj
<<
/D [1276 0 R /XYZ 226.818 174.536 null]
>>
% 1275 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1280 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1281 0 R
/Resources 1279 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1274 0 R
>>
% 1282 0 obj
<<
/D [1280 0 R /XYZ 165.186 242.282 null]
>>
% 1279 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1284 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1285 0 R
/Resources 1283 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1274 0 R
>>
% 1286 0 obj
<<
/D [1284 0 R /XYZ 162.957 298.933 null]
>>
% 1283 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1288 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1289 0 R
/Resources 1287 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1274 0 R
>>
% 1290 0 obj
<<
/D [1288 0 R /XYZ 261.464 382.683 null]
>>
% 1287 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1292 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1293 0 R
/Resources 1291 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1274 0 R
>>
% 1294 0 obj
<<
/D [1292 0 R /XYZ 93.543 436.88 null]
>>
% 1291 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1296 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1297 0 R
/Resources 1295 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1300 0 R
>>
% 1298 0 obj
<<
/D [1296 0 R /XYZ 192.627 504.626 null]
>>
% 1299 0 obj
<<
/D [1296 0 R /XYZ 177.63 106.79 null]
>>
% 1295 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1302 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1303 0 R
/Resources 1301 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1300 0 R
>>
% 1304 0 obj
<<
/D [1302 0 R /XYZ 324.307 174.536 null]
>>
% 1301 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1306 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1307 0 R
/Resources 1305 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1300 0 R
>>
% 1308 0 obj
<<
/D [1306 0 R /XYZ 243.236 228.732 null]
>>
% 1305 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1310 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1311 0 R
/Resources 1309 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1300 0 R
>>
% 1312 0 obj
<<
/D [1310 0 R /XYZ 219.552 285.384 null]
>>
% 1309 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1314 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1315 0 R
/Resources 1313 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1300 0 R
>>
% 1316 0 obj
<<
/D [1314 0 R /XYZ 143.626 353.13 null]
>>
% 1313 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1318 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1319 0 R
/Resources 1317 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1300 0 R
>>
% 1320 0 obj
<<
/D [1318 0 R /XYZ 93.543 434.502 null]
>>
% 1317 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1322 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1323 0 R
/Resources 1321 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1326 0 R
>>
% 1324 0 obj
<<
/D [1322 0 R /XYZ 249.52 491.077 null]
>>
% 1325 0 obj
<<
/D [1322 0 R /XYZ 194.046 93.24 null]
>>
% 1321 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1328 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1329 0 R
/Resources 1327 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1326 0 R
>>
% 1330 0 obj
<<
/D [1328 0 R /XYZ 93.543 314.621 null]
>>
% 1327 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1331 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index16) >>
% 1334 0 obj
(Chapter XV. Our Summary Rejection Of Current Supernaturalism Considered In Its Bearing On The Evidence For Miracles.)
% 1336 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1337 0 R
/Resources 1335 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1326 0 R
>>
% 1332 0 obj
<<
/D [1336 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 1338 0 obj
<<
/D [1336 0 R /XYZ 108.671 79.691 null]
>>
% 1335 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1340 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1341 0 R
/Resources 1339 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1326 0 R
>>
% 1342 0 obj
<<
/D [1340 0 R /XYZ 236.428 160.986 null]
>>
% 1339 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1344 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1345 0 R
/Resources 1343 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1326 0 R
>>
% 1346 0 obj
<<
/D [1344 0 R /XYZ 305.685 233.642 null]
>>
% 1343 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1348 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1349 0 R
/Resources 1347 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1326 0 R
>>
% 1350 0 obj
<<
/D [1348 0 R /XYZ 163.696 312.482 null]
>>
% 1347 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1352 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1353 0 R
/Resources 1351 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1355 0 R
>>
% 1354 0 obj
<<
/D [1352 0 R /XYZ 46.771 393.854 null]
>>
% 1351 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1357 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1358 0 R
/Resources 1356 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1355 0 R
>>
% 1359 0 obj
<<
/D [1357 0 R /XYZ 162.065 450.429 null]
>>
% 1360 0 obj
<<
/D [1357 0 R /XYZ 197.748 66.142 null]
>>
% 1356 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1362 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1363 0 R
/Resources 1361 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1355 0 R
>>
% 1364 0 obj
<<
/D [1362 0 R /XYZ 58.214 133.888 null]
>>
% 1361 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1366 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1367 0 R
/Resources 1365 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1355 0 R
>>
% 1368 0 obj
<<
/D [1366 0 R /XYZ 141.201 189.312 null]
>>
% 1365 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1370 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1371 0 R
/Resources 1369 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1355 0 R
>>
% 1372 0 obj
<<
/D [1370 0 R /XYZ 193.597 271.835 null]
>>
% 1369 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1374 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1375 0 R
/Resources 1373 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1355 0 R
>>
% 1376 0 obj
<<
/D [1374 0 R /XYZ 162.229 325.213 null]
>>
% 1373 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1378 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1379 0 R
/Resources 1377 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1381 0 R
>>
% 1380 0 obj
<<
/D [1378 0 R /XYZ 203.273 408.145 null]
>>
% 1377 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1383 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1384 0 R
/Resources 1382 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1381 0 R
>>
% 1385 0 obj
<<
/D [1383 0 R /XYZ 182.257 463.978 null]
>>
% 1386 0 obj
<<
/D [1383 0 R /XYZ 147.201 79.691 null]
>>
% 1382 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1388 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1389 0 R
/Resources 1387 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1381 0 R
>>
endstream
endobj
1394 0 obj <<
/Length 4708      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(300)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(as)-218(due)-218(to)-217(simple)-218(imposture.)-239(The)-218(first)-218(are)-218(strongly)-218(contrasted)-217(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-302(of)-303(the)-302(New)-302(Testament,)-316(where)-302(we)-302(cannot)-303(find)-302(the)-302(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-305(a)-305(single)-305(miracle)-305(wrought)-304(in)-305(attestation)-305(of)-305(a)-305(doctrine,)-319(the)-304(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-408(two)-409(apparent)-408(exceptions)-408(being)-408(really)-409(performed)-408(to)-408(attest)-408(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(divine)-299(commission.)-397(But)-299(when)-299(a)-299(miracle)-299(is)-299(wrought)-299(to)-299(prove)-298(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(irrational)-207(doctrine,)-215(the)-206(credibility)-207(of)-206(the)-207(miracle)-206(perishes)-207(with)-206(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth)-271(of)-270(the)-271(doctrine.)-312(We)-271(are,)-276(therefore,)-275(justified)-271(in)-271(rejecting)-270(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-210(whenever)-209(we)-210(have)-209(sufficient)-210(evidence)-209(that)-210(the)-209(doctrines)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-329(they)-330(were)-329(alleged)-330(to)-329(attest)-330(are)-329(untrue.)-489(Again:)-408(whenever)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-400(particular)-399(party)-400(alleges)-399(a)-400(divine)-400(attestation)-399(in)-400(its)-399(favour,)-437(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-259(may)-259(be)-259(known)-259(by)-260(its)-259(works.)-277(The)-259(parties)-259(in)-259(the)-259(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-328(have)-329(clai)1(med)-329(such)-328(miraculous)-328(attestation,)-348(have)-328(proved)-328(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-263(actions)-264(that)-263(the)-264(idea)-263(of)-263(a)-264(divine)-263(interference)-264(in)-263(their)-263(favour)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-250(incredible,)-250(as)-250(being)-250(inconsistent)-250(with)-250(the)-250(divine)-250(character.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-403(is)-404(perfectly)-403(true)-404(that)-403(at)-404(the)-403(present)-404(day)-403(all)-404(rational)-403(men,)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(with)-305(few)-305(exceptions,)-318(concur)-305(in)-304(rejecting)-305(almost)-305(the)-305(entire)-304(mass)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-354(ecclesiastical)-354(miracles.)-562(They)-354(do)-354(this,)-380(however,)-380(not)-353(because)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-443(believe)-443(miracles)-443(to)-443(be)-443(impossible,)-491(but)-443(because)-443(they)-442(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(persuaded)-288(that)-287(God)-288(will)-287(not)-288(work)-287(one)-288(on)-287(a)-288(light)-287(or)-288(trivial)-287(occa-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sion,)-282(and)-275(because)-275(the)-276(great)-275(mass)-275(of)-276(such)-275(pretended)-275(miracles)-275(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(characterised)-240(by)-239(marks)-240(which)-240(are)-239(inconsistent)-240(with)-240(the)-479(idea)-239(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([342])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(they)-322(have)-321(been)-322(wrought)-321(by)-321(God.)-465(With)-321(our)-322(larger)-321(acquaintance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-357(the)-357(order)-357(of)-357(nature,)-384(we)-357(no)-357(longer)-357(believe)-357(that)-357(it)-357(is)-357(possi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ble)-329(for)-329(miracles)-328(to)-329(be)-329(wrought)-329(by)-328(any)-329(inherent)-329(virtue)-329(in)-328(things)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(themselves,)-412(but)-379(that)-379(if)-380(performed)-379(at)-379(all,)-412(it)-379(can)-380(only)-379(be)-379(by)-379(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(direct)-278(agency)-279(or)-278(permission)-279(of)-278(the)-279(Author)-278(of)-278(Nature.)-336(In)-278(a)-278(word,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-301(general)-302(incredibility)-301(of)-302(the)-301(ecclesiastical)-302(miracles,)-314(and)-301(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(repugnance)-243(to)-243(our)-243(conception)-243(of)-243(the)-243(mode)-243(of)-243(the)-243(divine)-243(acting)-243(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(reason)-250(why)-250(we)-250(reject)-250(them)-250(altogether.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-350(is)-351(also)-350(unquestionably)-351(true)-350(that)-350(at)-351(the)-350(present)-351(day)-350(a)-350(great)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(majority)-340(even)-340(of)-340(religious)-340(persons)-340(would)-340(receive)-340(with)-340(no)-340(little)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incredulity)-263(the)-262(report)-263(of)-263(a)-263(miracle,)-265(while)-263(such)-263(incredulity)-262(would)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(not)-320(have)-320(existed)-320(at)-320(a)-319(former)-320(period.)-460(This)-320(is)-320(due)-320(to)-320(two)-319(causes:)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first,)-221(our)-215(increased)-214(knowledge)-214(of)-214(the)-215(permanence)-214(of)-214(the)-214(forces)-214(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1398 0 obj <<
/Length 4408      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(301)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(material)-195(Nature;)-214(and)-195(secondly,)-207(our)-195(belief)-196(that)-195(supernatural)-195(occur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rences)-306(can)-307(only)-306(take)-307(place)-306(by)-307(the)-306(direct)-307(agency)-306(and)-306(permission)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-275(God,)-282(and)-275(not)-275(by)-276(means)-275(of)-275(my)-276(supernatural)-275(power)-275(inherent)-275(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(particular)-291(persons.)-373(From)-291(this)-291(we)-291(draw)-291(the)-291(inference)-291(that)-291(almost)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(all)-279(the)-278(alleged)-279(ecclesiastical)-279(miracles)-279(must)-278(be)-279(rejected)-279(as)-278(incon-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sistent)-330(with)-330(the)-329(divine)-330(character.)-489(We)-330(are)-330(of)-330(opinion,)-349(therefore,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-256(a)-257(miracle)-256(wrought)-256(for)-256(any)-256(other)-257(purpose)-256(than)-256(the)-256(attestation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-411(a)-410(revelation)-411(is)-410(not)-411(credible;)-491(and)-410(as)-411(from)-411(the)-410(nature)-411(of)-410(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(case)-383(revelations)-383(must)-383(be)-383(rare,)-416(we)-383(summarily)-383(reject)-383(all)-383(reports)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-299(supernatural)-299(occurrences)-299(as)-299(impostures,)-311(or)-299(the)-299(offspring)-299(of)-299(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(heated)-250(and)-250(undisciplined)-250(imagination.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Now)-298(although)-298(this)-298(is)-298(generally)-298(the)-298(case,)-310(yet)-298(it)-298(is)-298(unquestion-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(able)-374(that)-375(if)-374(a)-375(miracle)-374(was)-374(reported)-375(to)-374(us)-375(with)-374(a)-374(pre-eminently)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(strong)-248(attestation,)-248(no)-248(rational)-248(person)-247(would)-248(refuse)-248(to)-248(give)-248(a)-247(seri-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ous)-279(consideration)-278(to)-279(the)-279(evidence)-279(merely)-278(because)-279(the)-279(event)-278(was)]TJ 3.675 -13.55 Td [(supernatural.)-511(A)-336(reported)-337(miracle)-337(would)-337(doubtless)-337(be)-337(attended)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 287.349 0 Td [([343])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(with)-329(no)-328(inconsiderable)-329(degree)-328(of)-329(antecedent)-329(improbability;)-367(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-367(a)-367(man)-367(with)-367(whom)-368(we)-367(were)-367(intimately)-367(acquainted,)-396(of)-367(sound)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intellect,)-437(and)-400(high)-400(moral)-400(character)-400(were)-400(to)-400(allege)-400(that)-400(he)-399(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performed)-406(an)-406(act)-405(which,)-445(if)-406(real,)-444(must)-406(have)-406(been)-405(indisputably)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miraculous,)-333(it)-317(would)-317(be)-317(altogether)-316(irrational)-317(to)-317(reject)-317(his)-316(asser-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-285(summarily)-286(as)-285(unworthy)-286(of)-285(consideration)-286(merely)-285(because)-285(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-287(ages)-287(miraculous)-287(stories)-286(have)-287(been)-287(extensively)-287(believed.)-360(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(application)-356(of)-356(such)-356(a)-356(principle)-356(would)-356(lead)-356(us)-356(into)-356(the)-356(grossest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(error.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(This)-440(question)-441(has)-440(a)-441(very)-440(important)-441(bearing)-440(on)-441(the)-440(subject)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(before)-289(us.)-367(It)-289(has)-289(been)-289(alleged)-289(that)-289(while)-289(nothing)-289(has)-289(been)-289(more)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(common)-389(than)-388(the)-389(ascription)-388(of)-389(miracles)-389(to)-388(eminent)-389(men,)-423(it)-388(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impossible)-428(to)-428(find)-428(a)-428(man)-428(of)-428(sound)-428(judgment)-428(and)-428(high)-428(moral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-362(who)-363(has)-362(deliberately)-363(affirmed)-362(that)-363(he)-362(has)-362(performed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-473(himself.)-919(That)-473(such)-473(affirmations)-473(have)-473(been)-473(very)-473(rare)-472(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain,)-304(and)-293(for)-293(the)-294(simple)-293(reason,)-304(that)-293(miracles)-293(have)-293(been)-293(very)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(rare)-311(occurrences.)-431(But)-311(the)-310(assertion)-311(that)-311(no)-310(such)-311(cases)-310(are)-311(to)-310(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(found)-258(is)-257(inaccurate.)-273(One,)-260(at)-257(all)-258(events,)-259(exists,)-260(although)-257(probably)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1402 0 obj <<
/Length 4757      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(302)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(the)-443(only)-443(one,)-492(but)-443(it)-443(is)-443(that)-443(of)-443(a)-443(man)-443(of)-443(the)-443(most)-443(undoubted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(veracity,)-326(the)-311(Apostle)-310(Paul.)-432(As)-311(I)-311(have)-310(already)-311(observed,)-326(four)-310(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-334(most)-333(important)-334(writings)-334(which)-334(have)-333(been)-334(attributed)-334(to)-333(him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-406(admitted)-407(by)-406(a)-406(vast)-406(majority)-406(of)-407(those)-406(unbelievers)-406(who)-406(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(competent)-315(to)-314(form)-315(an)-314(opinion)-315(on)-314(the)-315(subject,)-331(to)-314(be)-315(his)-314(genuine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(productions.)-511(These)-337(are)-336(before)-337(us,)-359(and)-337(we)-337(can)-337(form)-337(from)-336(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-451(full)-451(judgment)-451(as)-451(to)-450(the)-451(character)-451(of)-451(the)-451(man.)-853(In)-451(them)-450(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinctly)-261(tells)-261(us)-262(that)-261(he)-261(performed)-261(miracles.)-284(He)-261(writes:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 248.708 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(I)-261(have)]TJ -253.552 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-334(whereof)-334(I)-334(may)-334(glory)-334(in)-334(those)-334(things)-334(which)-334(pertain)-334(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(God.)-462(For)-321(I)-320(will)-321(not)-321(dare)-321(to)-320(speak)-321(of)-321(any)-320(of)-321(those)-321(things)-320(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ)-344(hath)-344(not)-343(wrought)-344(by)-344(me)-344(to)-687(make)-344(the)-344(Gentiles)-343(obedient)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([344])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(by)-372(word)-372(and)-372(deed,)-403(through)-372(mighty)-372(signs)-373(and)-372(wonders,)-402(by)-372(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-336(of)-335(the)-336(Spirit)-335(of)-336(God;)-378(so)-336(that)-335(from)-336(Jerusalem,)-357(and)-335(round)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(about)-200(unto)-199(Illyricum,)-210(I)-200(have)-199(fully)-200(preached)-200(the)-199(Gospel)-200(of)-199(Christ.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 275.786 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.55 Td [(\050Rom.)-527(xv.)-527(18,)-365(19.\051)-527(Here)-342(at)-342(least)-342(we)-343(have)-342(a)-342(direct)-342(affirmation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-353(the)-353(subject.)-560(It)-353(is)-353(not)-353(the)-353(only)-353(one)-354(made)-353(by)-353(him.)-559(But)-353(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-328(also)-329(one)-328(which)-328(is)-329(equivalent)-328(to)-328(another)-329(affirmation)-328(made)-328(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(One)-212(whom)-212(unbelievers)-211(must)-212(admit)-212(to)-211(have)-212(been)-212(the)-212(greatest)-211(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-350(ever)-350(lived,)-375(Jesus)-351(Christ)-350(Himself.)-550(Those)-350(with)-350(whom)-350(I)-350(am)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(reasoning)-303(allow)-303(that)-303(the)-303(discourses)-303(in)-303(the)-303(Synoptic)-303(Gospels)-303(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accounts)-272(of)-271(His)-272(real)-271(utterances.)-315(In)-271(them)-272(He)-271(directly)-272(affirms)-271(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-250(performed)-250(miracles.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Even)-214(those)-215(against)-214(whose)-215(opinions)-214(I)-215(am)-214(arguing,)-222(will)-214(concede)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-362(the)-361(characters)-362(of)-361(Christ)-362(and)-361(St.)-585(Paul)-362(stand)-361(at)-362(the)-361(greatest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(height)-304(of)-304(moral)-304(elevation.)-412(If)-304(there)-304(are)-304(any)-304(other)-303(persons)-304(whose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(utterances)-281(have)-281(been)-281(handed)-281(down)-281(to)-281(us,)-289(who)-280(have)-281(deliberately)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-423(this)-424(affirmation,)-466(their)-424(numbers)-423(are)-423(unquestionably)-423(few.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Certainly)-348(no)-349(other)-348(thoroughly)-348(great)-349(and)-348(elevated)-348(character)-348(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(done)-345(so.)-533(This)-345(is)-344(a)-345(remarkable)-345(fact)-344(and)-345(well)-344(worthy)-345(of)-344(consid-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eration.)-404(While)-301(many)-301(of)-301(the)-302(Fathers)-301(have)-301(affirmed)-301(that)-301(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-405(performed)-406(by)-405(others,)-444(not)-405(one)-405(of)-406(them)-405(has)-405(affirmed)-405(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-367(has)-367(wrought)-366(any)-367(himself.)-600(The)-367(supernaturalism)-367(of)-367(the)-366(New)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Testament)-272(differs,)-277(as)-272(we)-272(have)-272(seen,)-278(from)-272(all)-272(other)-272(alleged)-271(kinds)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-307(supernatural)-306(occurrences.)-420(It)-306(differs)-307(moreover)-306(in)-307(this)-306(respect,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1406 0 obj <<
/Length 1523      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(303)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(that)-251(one)-251(of)-251(the)-250(persons)-251(through)-251(whose)-251(agency)-251(these)-251(miracles)-250(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(declared)-245(to)-245(have)-245(been)-245(performed,)-246(has)-245(made)-245(a)-245(deliberate)-245(affirma-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-301(that)-300(he)-301(wrought)-300(them;)-326(and)-301(that)-301(the)-300(founder)-301(of)-300(Christianity,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-413(recorded)-413(utterances)-413(which)-413(are)-413(admitted)-413(to)-414(be)-413(genuine,)-453(has)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(likewise)-250(asserted)-250(that)-250(miracles)-250(were)-250(wrought)-250(by)-250(Him.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([345])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -13.549 Td [(It)-413(follows,)-454(therefore,)-454(that)-413(our)-413(summary)-413(rejection)-413(of)-413(all)-413(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(current)-390(supernaturalism)-390(which)-390(has)-390(been)-390(alleged)-390(to)-390(have)-389(taken)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(place)-334(at)-335(various)-334(periods)-335(of)-334(history,)-356(is)-334(quite)-335(consistent)-334(with)-334(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accepting)-218(as)-217(true)-218(the)-218(series)-217(of)-218(supernatural)-218(events)-217(recorded)-218(in)-217(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(New)-240(Testament,)-243(which)-240(are)-240(distinguished)-241(by)-240(characteristics)-240(of)-240(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entirely)-250(different)-250(order.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 -29.651 Td [([346])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1416 0 obj <<
/Length 3601      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 93.543 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-250(XVI.)-250(General)-250(Objections)-250(To)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Miracles)-266(As)-266(Credentials)-266(Of)-266(A)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Revelation.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -36.91 Td [(While)-180(considering)-180(this)-179(subject,)-194(it)-180(will)-180(be)-179(necessary)-180(to)-180(keep)-179(steadi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ly)-260(in)-260(view)-259(that)-260(miracles)-260(are)-260(not)-260(alleged)-259(in)-260(the)-260(New)-260(Testament)-259(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-330(been)-329(performed)-330(to)-330(prove)-329(the)-330(truth)-330(of)-329(doctrines,)-350(but)-330(that)-329(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(particular)-200(person)-200(possesses)-200(a)-199(divine)-200(commission;)-217(or)-200(in)-199(attestation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(particular)-250(facts,)-250(such)-250(as)-250(the)-250(Resurrection)-250(of)-250(Jesus)-250(Christ.)]TJ 11.956 -14.447 Td [(The)-233(truth)-233(of)-233(a)-233(divine)-234(commission)-233(being)-233(established,)-236(it)-233(follows)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-271(the)-270(divinely-appointed)-271(messenger)-271(must)-270(have)-271(some)-270(message)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-396(communicate.)-689(We)-396(further)-397(infer)-396(that)-396(God)-397(will)-396(not)-396(intrust)-396(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(message)-378(to)-379(any)-378(person)-378(whom)-379(He)-378(has)-378(not)-379(previously)-378(fully)-378(en-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lightened)-373(as)-372(to)-372(the)-373(subject)-372(which)-373(he)-372(has)-373(to)-372(communicate,)-403(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(who)-278(would)-279(not)-278(truthfully)-278(communicate)-279(the)-278(message)-278(with)-278(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-306(is)-306(intrusted.)-418(A)-306(miracle)-306(is)-306(therefore)-306(not)-306(only)-306(an)-306(attestat)1(ion)-306(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-371(divine)-370(commission)-371(of)-370(the)-371(person)-371(performing)-370(one,)-401(but)-370(also)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-311(the)-312(adequate)-311(information)-311(and)-312(veracity)-311(of)-311(the)-312(messenger.)-433(Al-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(though)-246(a)-246(miracle)-246(is)-246(not)-245(wrought)-246(to)-246(prove)-246(the)-246(truth)-246(of)-246(a)-245(particular)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(doctrine,)-383(but)-356(that)-356(a)-356(particular)-357(person)-356(is)-356(intrusted)-356(with)-356(a)-356(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(commission,)-238(we)-234(accept)-235(a)-235(doctrinal)-235(statement)-234(as)-235(true,)-238(when)-234(made)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-356(a)-356(messenger)-356(thus)-356(attested,)-383(within)-356(the)-356(limits)-356(of)-356(the)-356(message)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-240(which)-240(he)-240(affirms)-241(himself)-240(to)-240(be)-240(intrusted,)-242(on)-240(the)-240(ground)-240(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-365(a)-365(messenger)-364(must)-365(both)-365(be)-365(truthful,)-393(and)-365(possess)-364(adequate)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(knowledge.)-503(In)-250(other)-251(words,)-250(our)-251(belief)-250(in)-251(the)-250(doctrinal)-250(statement)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([347])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(does)-250(not)-250(rest)-250(on)-250(the)-250(miracle,)-250(but)-250(on)-250(the)-250(veracity)-250(of)-250(God.)]TJ 11.956 -14.446 Td [(This)-237(is)-237(the)-237(affirmation)-237(made)-237(in)-237(the)-237(New)-237(Testament)-236(respecting)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(the)-373(most)-373(important)-373(class)-374(of)-373(the)-373(miracles)-373(which)-373(it)-373(records.)-619(As)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-315(have)-315(elsewhere)-315(observed,)-331(not)-315(a)-315(single)-315(instance)-315(occurs)-315(in)-315(it)-314(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1420 0 obj <<
/Length 4971      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(305)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(a)-324(miracle)-324(wrought)-324(for)-323(the)-324(purpose)-324(of)-324(proving)-324(that)-324(a)-324(doctrine)-323(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(true.)-581(Our)-361(Lord's)-360(distinct)-361(affirmation)-360(is,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 181.583 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)-360(same)-361(works)-360(that)]TJ -186.427 -13.549 Td [(I)-382(do,)-415(bear)-382(witness)-382(of)-382(me)-382(that)-382(the)-382(Father)-382(hath)-382(sent)-382(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 247.379 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.011 0 Td [(\050John)]TJ -256.39 -13.549 Td [(v.)-570(36.\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 37.89 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(If)-357(I)-356(say)-357(the)-357(truth,)-383(why)-357(do)-356(ye)-357(not)-357(believe)-357(me?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 204.922 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.735 0 Td [(\050John)]TJ -256.39 -13.55 Td [(viii.)-244(46.\051)-244(The)-232(miracles)-232(which)-231(are)-232(alleged)-232(to)-232(have)-232(been)-231(performed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-342(the)-341(Apostles)-342(for)-342(directly)-341(evidential)-342(purposes,)-365(were)-341(wrought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-339(proof)-340(of)-339(the)-340(Resurrection)-339(of)-339(Christ,)-362(and)-339(of)-340(their)-339(own)-339(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(commission,)-250(which)-250(directly)-250(depended)-250(on)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(Let)-497(it)-496(also)-497(be)-497(observed)-496(that)-497(it)-497(by)-496(no)-497(means)-497(follows)-496(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(every)-404(miracle)-404(recorded)-404(in)-404(the)-404(New)-404(Testament)-404(was)-404(performed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exclusively)-331(for)-331(evidential)-331(purposes.)-493(This)-331(point)-331(I)-331(shall)-331(consider)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hereafter.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(If)-396(these)-396(principles)-396(are)-396(correct,)-432(they)-396(will)-396(at)-396(once)-396(dispose)-395(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(two)-217(objections)-218(which)-217(are)-217(alleged)-217(against)-218(miracles:)-233(first,)-224(that)-217(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-290(prove)-289(a)-289(doctrine;)-310(and)-289(secondly,)-300(that)-289(they)-289(cannot)-290(prove)-289(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(moral)-262(truth.)-286(I)-262(fully)-262(accept)-262(the)-262(statement)-262(that)-262(moral)-262(truths)-262(cannot)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-384(proved)-384(by)-384(the)-384(evidence)-384(of)-383(miracles,)-418(but)-384(must)-384(rest)-384(on)-383(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(own)-367(inherent)-367(evidence;)-425(and)-367(that)-367(all)-367(positive)-367(duties)-367(rest)-367(on)-366(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(command)-336(of)-335(God,)-357(to)-336(whom)-335(we)-336(feel,)-357(on)-335(other)-336(grounds,)-357(that)-335(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(love,)-390(reverence,)-390(and)-362(adoration)-362(are)-362(due.)-586(The)-362(truth)-362(of)-361(doctrines)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(also)-293(cannot)-293(be)-293(established)-293(by)-293(the)-294(performance)-293(of)-293(a)-293(miracle;)-314(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-432(we)-433(accept)-432(them)-432(on)-432(external)-433(authority,)-478(they)-432(rest)-432(on)-432(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testimony)-379(of)-379(God,)-410(and)-379(our)-379(full)-379(persuasion)-378(that)-379(He)-379(must)-379(be)-378(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession)-323(of)-323(all)-324(truth.)-469(Although,)-342(therefore,)-341(I)-323(accept)-323(as)-323(correct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-227(principles,)-232(on)-228(which)-227(the)-228(objection)-227(is)-228(founded,)-232(they)-227(have)-227(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bearing)-641(on)-321(the)-321(point)-320(at)-321(issue;)-356(for)-321(the)-320(New)-321(Testament)-320(nowhere)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([348])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(affirms)-316(that)-315(its)-316(miracles)-315(were)-316(wrought)-316(to)-315(prove)-316(either)-315(doctrinal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(statements)-250(or)-250(moral)-250(truths,)-250(but)-250(facts.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(1.)-650(It)-384(is)-383(objected)-383(that)-384(the)-383(prevalence)-384(of)-383(supernatural)-383(beliefs)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(renders)-347(the)-347(existence)-347(of)-346(miracles)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 150.994 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(so)-347(hackneyed)-347(as)-346(scarcely)-347(to)]TJ -155.838 -13.549 Td [(attract)-284(the)-284(notice)-284(of)-283(the)-284(nation)-284(to)-284(whom)-284(the)-284(Christian)-283(revelation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-250(in)-250(the)-250(first)-250(instance)-250(addressed.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 151.484 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 3.632 0 Td [(Supernatural)-250(Religion.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 100.004 0 Td [(\051)]TJ -250.735 -14.777 Td [(I)-308(reply)-309(that)-309(this)-308(objection)-309(contains)-308(two)-309(inaccuracies.)-425(First,)-323(it)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-253(not)-253(true)-254(that)-253(the)-253(miracles)-253(of)-254(Jesus)-253(scarcely)-253(attracted)-253(the)-253(notice)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1424 0 obj <<
/Length 4721      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(306)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(of)-276(those)-276(among)-276(whom)-275(they)-276(were)-276(performed.)-328(The)-276(only)-275(authority)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-454(this)-453(point)-454(is)-453(the)-454(New)-453(Testament)-454(itself,)-504(and)-454(this)-453(assertion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contradicts)-417(its)-418(express)-417(statements.)-752(Numerous)-417(passages)-417(in)-417(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-365(directly)-365(affirm)-365(that)-365(the)-365(miracles)-365(of)-365(our)-365(Lord)-365(attracted)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(very)-343(general)-343(attention,)-366(and)-343(produced)-343(a)-343(profound)-342(astonishment;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-217(that)-218(those)-217(who)-217(had)-218(witnessed)-217(them)-217(considered)-218(that)-217(there)-217(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-265(wide)-264(distinction)-265(between)-264(them)-265(and)-264(the)-265(miraculous)-264(pretensions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-309(current.)-426(His)-308(fame)-309(is)-308(represented)-309(as)-309(having)-308(been)-309(spread)-308(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-215(in)-216(regions)-215(beyond)-215(Palestine;)-227(and)-216(great)-215(multitudes)-215(are)-215(stated)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-359(have)-360(collected,)-386(both)-359(for)-360(the)-359(purpose)-359(of)-360(hearing)-359(Him)-359(and)-359(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-271(healed)-271(of)-271(their)-271(diseases.)-313(The)-271(fourth)-271(Gospel)-271(represents)-270(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Lord)-236(as)-237(rebuking)-236(the)-236(multitudes,)-239(for)-236(attending)-237(on)-236(Him)-236(for)-236(sordid)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purposes.)-845(It)-448(is)-448(quite)-448(true,)-498(that)-448(notwithstanding)-448(the)-448(miracles,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-379(body)-379(of)-379(the)-379(Jewish)-379(nation)-379(ultimately)-379(rejected)-378(Christianity,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(though)-328(the)-327(epistles)-328(bear)-328(witness)-328(that)-327(the)-328(Jewish)-328(element)-327(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-241(attracted)-241(into)-240(the)-241(Christian)-241(Church)-241(was)-241(large.)-247(The)-240(assertion,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore,)-297(is)-288(simply)-288(contrary)-287(to)-288(fact,)-297(that)-288(miracles)-288(were)-288(in)-287(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(days)-228(so)-228(common)-227(and)-228(hackneyed)-228(as)-228(to)-227(attract)-228(little)-228(or)-228(no)-227(attention)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(him)-250(who)-250(professed)-250(to)-250(work)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Equally)-299(inaccurate)-299(is)-298(the)-299(assertion)-299(that)-299(the)-299(evidence)-299(of)-298(mira-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(cles)-194(as)-195(the)-194(attestation)-195(to)-194(a)-195(revelation)-194(was)-195(a)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 184.205 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(hackneyed)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 46.647 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.965 0 Td [(one.)-232(The)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -315.416 0 Td [([349])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(Old)-348(Testament)-348(professed)-348(to)-347(rest)-348(on)-348(miraculous)-348(evidence.)-543(This)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(being)-257(the)-258(case,)-259(the)-257(Jews)-258(were)-257(fully)-258(entitled)-257(to)-257(expect)-258(that)-257(if)-257(God)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-308(a)-307(further)-308(revelation)-307(of)-308(His)-308(will,)-322(it)-307(would)-308(be)-307(accompanied)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-224(a)-223(miraculous)-224(attestation.)-241(But)-224(Judaism)-223(was)-224(the)-223(only)-224(religion)-223(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-223(ancient)-223(world)-223(which)-223(professed)-223(to)-223(be)-223(founded)-223(on)-223(the)-223(evidence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-290(miracles.)-370(A)-290(belief)-290(in)-290(a)-290(current)-290(supernaturalism)-290(was)-290(no)-289(doubt)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mixed)-372(up)-373(with)-372(the)-373(ancient)-372(religions,)-403(but)-372(its)-373(wonders)-372(were)-372(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alleged)-299(to)-298(have)-299(been)-298(wrought)-299(in)-299(attestation)-298(of)-299(the)-298(fact)-299(that)-298(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-431(revelations,)-476(nor)-431(even)-431(as)-430(attestations)-431(to)-431(their)-431(truth.)-792(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(religion)-324(of)-323(the)-324(Greeks)-324(possessed)-323(both)-324(priests)-323(and)-324(prophets;)-360(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-365(performed)-365(no)-365(miracles)-364(in)-365(attestation)-365(of)-365(a)-365(divine)-364(commis-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sion.)-480(The)-327(only)-327(attestation)-326(of)-327(this)-327(kind)-326(which)-327(they)-327(claimed)-326(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-290(utterance)-290(of)-291(obscure)-290(or)-290(mendacious)-290(oracles.)-371(I)-290(am)-290(not)-290(aware)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1428 0 obj <<
/Length 4846      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(307)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(that)-380(anyone)-379(who)-380(pretended)-379(to)-380(be)-379(a)-379(revealer)-380(of)-379(the)-380(divine)-379(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-316(ancient)-315(times)-316(ever)-315(professed)-316(to)-316(perform)-315(visible)-316(and)-315(palpable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-276(in)-276(proof)-276(of)-276(his)-275(assertions.)-328(Similar)-276(is)-276(the)-276(position)-276(of)-275(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(old)-207(religions)-208(which)-207(still)-207(exist)-207(in)-208(the)-207(modern)-207(world.)-236(Many)-207(of)-207(them)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(abound)-389(in)-390(stories)-389(of)-390(the)-389(most)-389(fantastic)-390(manifestations)-389(of)-389(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gods)-332(in)-331(ancient)-332(times.)-495(Their)-331(votaries)-332(believe)-332(in)-331(the)-332(efficacy)-331(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(magic,)-305(charms,)-305(and)-294(incantations.)-382(But)-294(none)-294(of)-294(these)-294(things)-293(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-384(affirmed)-384(to)-384(have)-384(been)-384(wrought)-384(in)-384(attestation)-384(of)-384(a)-384(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(commission.)-234(Mahometanism)-201(claims,)-211(in)-202(the)-201(strictest)-202(sense,)-211(to)-201(be)-201(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(divine)-205(revelation;)-220(yet)-205(the)-205(Koran)-205(even)-205(offers)-205(apologies)-205(for)-205(the)-204(fact)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-233(its)-232(founder)-233(wrought)-233(no)-232(miracles)-233(in)-233(attestation)-232(of)-233(his)-233(claim)-232(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-284(a)-285(divine)-284(messenger.)-353(So)-284(far)-285(therefore)-284(is)-284(it)-285(from)-284(being)-284(the)-284(fact)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-260(miracles)-260(are)-260(so)-260(generally)-260(alleged)-260(by)-260(religions)-260(in)-259(vindication)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-231(their)-230(claim)-231(to)-231(be)-230(revelations,)-235(that)-230(Judaism)-231(and)-231(Christianity)-230(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(absolutely)-271(unique)-272(in)-271(this)-272(respect.)-314(The)-271(idea)-271(of)-272(working)-271(a)-271(miracle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-412(attestation)-413(of)-412(a)-413(divine)-412(commission)-412(is)-413(so)-412(far)-412(from)-825(being)-412(a)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([350])]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(hackneyed)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 46.647 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(one,)-250(that)-250(it)-250(has)-250(the)-250(strongest)-250(claims)-250(to)-250(originality.)]TJ -47.106 -16.004 Td [(2.)-261(It)-254(is)-253(urged)-254(by)-254(the)-253(same)-254(writer)-254(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 161.023 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(every)-254(marvel)-253(and)-254(every)]TJ -177.823 -13.549 Td [(narrative)-272(of)-273(supernatural)-272(interference)-272(seemed)-273(a)-272(matter)-272(of)-272(course)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-237(the)-238(superstitious)-237(credulity)-238(of)-237(the)-238(age.)-246(However)-237(much)-237(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-310(the)-310(exception)-310(to)-311(the)-310(order)-310(of)-310(nature,)-325(they)-310(have)-310(always)-310(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-312(rule)-312(in)-312(the)-312(history)-313(of)-312(ignorance.)-436(In)-312(fact)-312(the)-312(excess)-312(of)-312(belief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-335(them)-334(throughout)-335(many)-334(centuries)-335(of)-335(darkness,)-355(is)-335(almost)-334(fatal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-438(their)-438(claims)-438(to)-438(credence)-438(now.)-814(They)-438(have)-438(been)-438(limited)-438(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(periods)-299(of)-299(ignorance)-298(and)-299(superstition,)-311(and)-299(are)-299(unknown)-299(to)-298(ages)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-380(enlightenment.)-642(The)-380(Christian)-380(miracles)-381(are)-380(rendered)-380(almost)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-309(suspicious)-308(from)-309(their)-309(place)-308(in)-309(a)-309(long)-308(series)-309(of)-309(similar)-308(occur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rences,)-451(as)-411(they)-410(are)-411(by)-411(their)-411(being)-410(exceptions)-411(to)-411(the)-410(sequence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-397(natural)-397(phenomena.)-692(It)-397(would)-398(be)-397(extraordinary)-397(if)-397(cycles)-397(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-371(occurring)-371(before)-371(and)-371(since)-371(those)-371(of)-371(the)-371(Gospels,)-401(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-260(connection)-260(with)-259(every)-260(religion,)-262(could)-260(be)-260(repudiated)-260(as)-259(fables,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-250(these)-250(alone)-250(maintained)-250(as)-250(genuine.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 170.269 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -158.313 -16.004 Td [(The)-386(principles)-385(which)-386(I)-385(have)-386(laid)-386(down)-385(in)-386(a)-386(former)-385(chapter)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(fully)-410(meet)-410(the)-411(chief)-410(points)-410(raised)-410(in)-411(these)-410(objections.)-730(A)-410(few)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1432 0 obj <<
/Length 4423      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(308)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(additional)-365(observations)-364(on)-365(them,)-393(therefore,)-394(are)-364(all)-365(that)-365(will)-364(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(First:)-260(the)-255(assertion)-255(that)-255(every)-255(marvel)-255(or)-255(narrative)-255(of)-255(supernat-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ural)-322(interference)-322(seemed)-322(a)-322(matter)-322(of)-322(course)-322(to)-322(the)-321(superstitious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(credulity)-320(of)-320(the)-320(age,)-337(is)-320(inaccurate.)-459(If)-320(they)-320(had)-320(been)-320(of)-319(habitual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-359(constant)-359(occurrence,)-387(they)-359(would)-359(have)-359(ceased)-359(to)-359(be)-359(marvels)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(at)-443(all.)-829(In)-443(such)-443(a)-443(case)-443(the)-443(trade)-443(of)-443(the)-443(impostor)-442(would)-443(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gone,)-316(for)-303(it)-302(would)-303(not)-303(have)-302(paid)-303(him.)-408(The)-303(entire)-303(plausibility)-302(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-244(reasonings)-244(arises)-244(from)-244(confounding)-244(under)-244(a)-244(common)-243(name)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena)-402(wholly)-402(different)-403(in)-402(character.)-706(I)-402(ask)-402(emphatically,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(did)-362(the)-362(current)-362(supernaturalism)-362(of)-362(any)-362(age)-362(or)-362(nation)-362(accept)-361(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(matters)-340(of)-339(course)-340(such)-679(events)-339(as)-340(the)-339(resurrection)-340(of)-340(Christ,)-361(or)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([351])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(the)-267(cure)-268(of)-267(a)-267(blind)-268(man,)-271(or)-267(a)-268(man)-267(full)-267(of)-268(leprosy,)-271(by)-268(a)-267(word)-267(or)-267(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(touch?)-237(Have)-212(not)-212(heathen)-212(writers)-212(pronounced)-212(actual)-212(resurrections)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-241(the)-241(dead)-241(to)-241(be)-241(impossibilities?)-247(Were)-241(such)-241(occurrences)-241(ever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believed)-258(to)-259(be)-258(within)-259(the)-258(power)-259(of)-258(magic)-259(to)-258(effect?)-276(Belief)-258(in)-258(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(possibility)-369(of)-369(such)-369(occurrences)-369(became)-369(current)-369(only)-369(under)-369(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(influence)-250(of)-250(Christianity.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(2.)-246(It)-238(is)-239(not)-238(correct)-238(to)-238(assert)-239(that)-238(the)-238(belief)-239(in)-238(miracles)-238(has)-238(been)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(confined)-289(to)-289(ages)-289(of)-289(ignorance.)-367(Will)-289(it)-289(be)-289(affirmed)-289(that)-289(the)-288(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(flourishing)-230(period)-229(of)-230(Grecian)-229(literature)-229(was)-230(an)-229(age)-230(of)-229(ignorance?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Yet)-255(a)-255(belief)-255(in)-255(a)-254(current)-255(supernaturalism)-255(prevailed)-255(in)-255(it.)-265(Was)-254(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Augustan)-302(age)-301(an)-302(age)-302(of)-302(ignorance?)-405(Both)-301(ages)-302(were)-302(ignorant)-301(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical)-259(science:)-268(but)-259(during)-259(few)-259(periods)-259(has)-259(the)-259(human)-258(intellect)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-437(equally)-437(active.)-811(Each)-437(age)-437(contained)-437(men)-437(endowed)-436(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(common)-244(sense)-244(sufficient)-244(to)-244(make)-244(them)-244(adequate)-244(judges)-243(whether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-300(supernatural)-300(occurrences)-300(above)-300(referred)-300(to)-300(were)-300(possible)-300(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(3.)-332(It)-277(is)-278(inaccurate)-277(to)-277(affirm)-278(that)-277(the)-277(Christian)-278(miracles)-277(are)-277(in-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(terposed)-236(between)-235(two)-235(similar)-236(series)-235(of)-236(supernatural)-235(occurrences.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(There)-301(is)-301(only)-301(one)-301(point)-301(in)-302(common)-301(between)-301(them;)-326(the)-301(claim)-301(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-215(supernatural.)-239(As)-215(I)-216(have)-215(proved,)-222(in)-216(every)-215(other)-216(respect)-215(they)-215(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(strongly)-322(contrasted.)-467(It)-322(is,)-340(therefore,)-340(by)-322(no)-322(means)-322(extraordinary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-251(a)-251(series)-251(of)-251(supernatural)-251(occurrences,)-251(which)-251(have)-251(the)-251(highest)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1436 0 obj <<
/Length 4832      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(309)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(moral)-313(impress,)-329(and)-313(possess)-313(other)-313(distinguishing)-312(characteristics,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-425(be)-426(true;)-513(and)-426(that)-425(the)-425(others,)-470(one)-425(of)-426(which)-425(took)-425(place)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(before)-205(and)-204(the)-204(other)-205(after)-204(that)-205(in)-204(question,)-214(and)-204(which)-205(are)-204(stamped)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-250(the)-250(very)-250(opposite)-250(characteristics,)-250(should)-250(be)-250(false.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-357(same)-357(author)-357(adduces)-356(the)-357(following)-357(objections,)-384(as)-357(lying)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(at)-311(the)-311(root)-311(of)-311(miraculous)-311(testimony)-311(to)-311(a)-311(revelation:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 230.579 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Surely)-311(su-)]TJ -235.423 -13.549 Td [(pernatural)-254(evidence)-254(of)-254(so)-254(common)-254(and)-254(prodigal)-254(a)-254(nature)-254(betrays)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-340(want)-341(of)-340(force)-680(and)-341(divine)-340(originality.)-521(How)-340(could)-340(that)-340(be)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([352])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(considered)-299(as)-299(special)-299(evidence)-299(for)-300(a)-299(new)-299(revelation,)-311(which)-299(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(already)-260(so)-261(well)-261(known)-260(to)-261(all)-260(the)-261(world,)-263(and)-260(which)-261(was)-260(scattered)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(broadcast)-341(over)-341(so)-341(many)-340(centuries,)-364(as)-341(well)-341(as)-341(successfully)-340(sim-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ulated)-345(by)-345(Satan.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 72.07 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.61 0 Td [(Again:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 34.5 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Instead)-345(of)-345(a)-346(few)-345(evidential)-345(miracles)]TJ -120.024 -13.549 Td [(taking)-315(place)-314(at)-315(one)-315(epoch)-314(of)-315(history,)-331(and)-314(filling)-315(the)-315(world)-314(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(surprise)-263(at)-263(such)-262(novel)-263(and)-263(exceptional)-263(phenomena,)-266(we)-263(find)-262(mir-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acles)-271(represented)-271(as)-271(taking)-271(place)-271(in)-271(all)-271(ages)-271(and)-270(in)-271(all)-271(countries.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(The)-352(Gospel)-353(miracles)-352(are)-352(set)-353(in)-352(the)-353(midst)-352(of)-352(a)-353(series)-352(of)-352(similar)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wonders)-307(which)-306(commenced)-307(many)-307(centuries)-306(before)-307(the)-307(dawn)-306(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity,)-231(and)-227(continued)-227(without)-227(interruption)-227(fifteen)-226(centuries)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(after)-232(it.)-244(No)-233(divine)-232(originality)-232(characterized)-233(the)-232(evidence)-232(selected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(accredit)-250(the)-250(divine)-250(revelation.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 140.879 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050P.)-250(192.\051)]TJ -136.495 -16.004 Td [(I)-265(reply,)-269(First:)-281(It)-265(behoves)-266(those)-265(who)-265(except)-266(against)-265(the)-265(plan)-265(of)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(attesting)-362(a)-361(divine)-362(revelation)-361(by)-362(miracles,)-389(to)-362(inform)-361(us)-362(in)-361(what)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(other)-389(way)-389(it)-389(is)-389(possible)-390(that)-389(the)-389(truth)-389(of)-389(a)-389(divine)-389(commission)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-460(be)-460(attested.)-879(It)-460(is)-460(doubtless)-459(possible)-460(for)-460(God)-460(to)-460(make)-459(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(special)-335(revelation)-335(of)-336(His)-335(will)-335(to)-335(each)-335(individual)-335(man;)-378(yet)-335(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-330(would)-329(involve)-330(supernatural)-330(agency)-330(of)-329(some)-330(kind;)-370(and)-330(it)-329(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(very)-256(questionable)-256(whether)-256(to)-256(do)-256(so)-256(would)-256(be)-256(consistent)-256(with)-256(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(plan)-308(of)-308(God's)-308(moral)-308(government)-308(which)-308(comes)-308(under)-307(our)-308(actual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(observation.)-357(But)-286(the)-286(Christian)-286(revelation)-285(is)-286(founded)-286(on)-286(the)-285(idea)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-231(making)-230(a)-231(divine)-231(manifestation)-231(additional)-230(to,)-235(and)-231(of)-231(a)-230(different)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-429(from,)-474(that)-429(which)-429(is)-429(made)-429(by)-429(the)-429(created)-429(universe;)-518(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-284(simply)-284(of)-285(imparting)-284(so)-284(much)-285(additional)-284(information)-284(to)-284(each)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(individual.)-239(This)-217(manifestation)-218(professes)-217(to)-218(be)-217(made)-218(by)-217(the)-217(Incar-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nation.)-326(How,)-281(I)-275(ask,)-282(was)-275(such)-275(a)-276(manifestation)-275(to)-275(be)-275(made)-275(except)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1441 0 obj <<
/Length 4750      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(310)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(by)-405(a)-405(supernatural)-405(action)-405(of)-404(some)-405(kind?)-715(It)-405(is)-405(clear,)-443(therefore,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-267(every)-268(manifestation)-267(of)-267(God)-268(differing)-267(from)-267(that)-268(made)-267(by)-267(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ordinary)-304(forces)-304(of)-304(nature,)-317(or)-304(by)-304(the)-304(moral)-304(nature)-304(of)-608(man,)-317(must)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([353])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(be)-332(supernatural.)-495(There)-332(can)-332(be)-332(no)-331(doubt)-332(as)-332(to)-332(the)-332(means)-331(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(must)-240(be)-240(employed.)-246(The)-240(only)-240(question)-240(which)-239(can)-240(be)-240(raised)-240(is)-239(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-381(I)-381(have)-381(considered)-380(elsewhere,)-414(namely:)-512(whether)-381(it)-381(is)-380(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purpose)-250(of)-250(God)-250(to)-250(make)-250(such)-250(a)-250(manifestation)-250(of)-250(Himself.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-280(will)-280(be)-280(objected)-279(that)-280(such)-280(a)-280(manifestation)-280(might)-280(have)-279(been)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(made)-275(self-evident)-275(to)-274(the)-275(moral)-275(nature)-275(of)-275(man,)-281(and)-274(consequently)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-304(would)-303(have)-304(required)-304(no)-303(additional)-304(attestation.)-411(To)-303(this)-304(I)-303(reply)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that,)-274(on)-270(the)-270(supposition)-269(that)-270(it)-269(is)-270(God's)-269(purpose)-270(to)-269(make)-270(such)-269(an)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(additional)-335(manifestation)-334(of)-335(Himself,)-356(He)-334(must)-335(be)-334(allowed)-335(to)-334(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(only)-250(adequate)-250(judge)-250(of)-250(the)-250(right)-250(mode)-250(of)-250(accomplishing)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(But)-403(even)-404(if)-403(a)-404(revelation)-403(involved)-404(no)-403(such)-404(manifestation)-403(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(God,)-290(but)-281(only)-282(a)-281(communication)-282(of)-282(truth)-281(to)-282(man,)-289(it)-282(is)-281(incumbent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-315(those)-314(who)-314(object)-315(to)-314(its)-315(attestation)-314(by)-315(miracles,)-330(to)-315(find)-314(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-262(method)-261(by)-262(which)-261(the)-262(reality)-261(of)-262(a)-261(divine)-262(commission)-261(could)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-229(attested,)-234(and)-229(to)-230(show)-229(that)-229(this)-230(mode)-229(would)-229(be)-230(preferable)-229(to)-229(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attestation)-250(by)-250(miracles.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-353(further:)-457(if)-353(we)-354(regard)-353(a)-353(miracle)-354(as)-353(a)-353(supernatural)-353(occur-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(rence)-371(wrought)-370(in)-371(attestation)-370(of)-371(a)-371(divine)-370(commission,)-401(which)-370(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-452(unquestionable)-453(aspect)-452(of)-452(a)-453(considerable)-452(number)-452(of)-452(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recorded)-310(in)-310(the)-310(New)-311(Testament,)-325(the)-310(fact)-310(that)-310(there)-310(was)-310(a)-310(wide-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(spread)-306(belief)-307(in)-306(the)-307(existence)-306(of)-307(supernatural)-306(events)-307(is)-306(far)-306(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interfering)-261(with)-261(its)-260(efficacy.)-283(What)-260(did)-261(the)-261(current)-261(beliefs)-260(imply?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(That)-310(there)-311(existed)-310(beings,)-325(other)-311(than)-310(the)-310(blind)-311(forces)-310(of)-310(nature,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-238(interfered)-238(in)-237(human)-238(affairs;)-242(and)-238(that)-237(they)-238(were)-238(in)-238(some)-237(way)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(or)-304(other)-304(capable)-303(of)-304(communicating)-304(with)-304(man.)-411(What)-304(is)-304(the)-303(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conception)-330(implied)-330(by)-329(a)-330(revelation?)-490(That)-329(a)-330(God)-330(exists,)-350(who)-329(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-326(moral)-325(Governor)-326(of)-325(the)-326(universe,)-345(who)-325(cares)-326(for)-325(man,)-345(and)-325(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(capable)-263(of)-262(holding)-263(communications)-263(with)-263(him.)-288(Both)-262(conceptions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rest)-242(on)-241(a)-242(common)-241(ground)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 111.131 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(the)-241(existence)-242(of)-483(supernatural)-241(beings)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -194.795 0 Td [([354])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(capable)-257(of)-257(manifesting)-257(themselves)-256(by)-257(outward)-257(indications.)-270(Why)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-384(should)-384(not)-383(the)-384(moral)-384(Governor)-384(of)-384(the)-384(universe,)-417(if)-384(it)-383(was)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1446 0 obj <<
/Length 4559      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(311)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(His)-377(purpose)-376(to)-376(make)-377(a)-376(revelation,)-408(employ)-377(media,)-408(which)-376(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-251(but)-251(universally)-250(recognized?)-252(No)-251(inconsiderable)-251(number)-251(of)-250(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(objections)-264(of)-264(unbelievers)-264(rest)-264(on)-264(the)-265(assumption,)-267(that)-264(if)-264(there)-264(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-380(God,)-412(it)-380(is)-379(derogatory)-380(to)-380(His)-380(character)-379(to)-380(suppose)-380(that)-380(He)-379(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(capable)-182(of)-181(condescending)-182(to)-182(the)-181(weaknesses)-182(and)-182(imperfections)-181(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man.)-250(A)-248(God)-248(who)-249(neither)-248(will)-249(nor)-248(can)-249(do)-248(so)-249(may)-248(be)-249(a)-248(very)-248(grand)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conception;)-212(but)-194(one)-193(who)-193(is)-193(very)-194(ill)-193(adapted)-193(to)-194(the)-193(wants)-193(of)-193(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature,)-248(and)-247(who)-248(is)-247(incapable)-247(of)-248(exciting)-247(human)-247(sympathies.)-249(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-214(thing)-215(that)-214(would)-214(be)-215(necessary,)-221(on)-214(the)-215(supposition)-214(that)-214(it)-214(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(His)-192(purpose)-191(to)-192(make)-192(such)-191(a)-192(revelation,)-203(would)-192(be)-192(that)-191(His)-192(mode)-191(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manifesting)-326(His)-326(presence)-327(should)-326(be)-326(one)-326(clearly)-326(distinguishable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-304(the)-303(events)-304(of)-303(current)-304(supernaturalism.)-410(What)-304(was)-303(requisite)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-414(have)-415(been)-414(to)-415(afford)-414(evidence)-414(that)-415(the)-414(manifestation)-414(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question)-293(was)-292(due)-293(to)-292(no)-293(other)-292(being)-293(than)-292(Himself;)-314(that)-292(is)-293(to)-292(say,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-291(the)-290(miracles)-291(should)-291(bear)-291(the)-290(unquestionable)-291(impress)-291(of)-290(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(own)-411(perfections.)-735(The)-411(subject)-411(of)-412(alleged)-411(demoniacal)-411(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-437(have)-437(considered)-437(elsewhere.)-811(The)-437(simple)-437(question)-437(before)-436(us)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 7.277 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(Are)-300(the)-299(supernatural)-300(events)-300(recorded)-299(in)-300(the)-300(Gospels)-299(clearly)]TJ -18.186 -13.549 Td [(distinguishable)-287(in)-287(their)-287(general)-287(character)-287(from)-287(the)-286(supernatural-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ism)-329(which)-330(was)-329(current)-330(previous)-329(to)-329(the)-330(Advent?)-488(I)-329(have)-329(already)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(shown)-202(that)-203(it)-202(contains)-202(no)-203(doubtful)-202(indications)-202(as)-203(to)-202(who)-202(the)-202(agent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-424(have)-423(been,)-467(if)-424(we)-423(suppose)-424(the)-423(facts)-424(to)-423(have)-424(been)-423(actual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrences.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-333(further:)-416(if)-334(the)-333(objection)-333(has)-333(any)-333(validity,)-354(it)-333(presupposes)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-319(God)-318(ought)-319(not)-318(to)-319(make)-319(a)-318(revelation)-319(in)-318(ages)-319(of)-318(superstition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-283(ignorance;)-299(but)-283(must)-283(wait)-283(until)-283(knowledge)-283(has)-283(cleared)-282(away)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-245(mists)-246(of)-245(ignorance)-246(and)-245(error,)-246(and)-246(supplied)-245(us)-246(with)-245(the)-245(means)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-384(infallibly)-192(discriminating)-192(between)-192(true)-192(miracles)-192(and)-192(false)-192(ones;)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([355])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(or,)-308(in)-297(other)-296(words,)-308(we)-297(must)-296(wait)-296(for)-297(the)-296(much-talked-of)-297(jury)-296(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(scientific)-214(men,)-221(who)-213(can)-214(submit)-214(His)-214(alleged)-213(miracles)-214(to)-214(the)-213(whole)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(range)-400(of)-401(scientific)-400(tests.)-701(Happily,)-438(however,)-438(God)-401(has)-400(gifted)-400(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(considerable)-251(number)-250(of)-251(men)-250(with)-251(common)-250(sense,)-251(which)-251(is)-250(quite)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(adequate)-260(to)-260(determine)-261(whether)-260(a)-260(certain)-261(class)-260(of)-260(events)-260(wrought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-305(certain)-305(circumstances)-305(are)-305(miraculous)-305(operations,)-318(or)-305(mere)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1450 0 obj <<
/Length 4648      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(312)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(natural)-329(occurrences,)-348(or)-329(due)-329(to)-328(imposture.)-486(If)-329(this)-329(be)-328(so,)-349(what)-328(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(there,)-398(I)-369(ask,)-399(unworthy)-368(of)-369(God,)-399(in)-368(making)-369(a)-369(revelation)-369(at)-368(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(times)-250(as)-250(man)-250(stands)-250(in)-250(special)-250(need)-250(of)-250(one?)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(It)-302(is)-302(further)-302(objected)-302(that)-302(a)-302(miraculous)-302(attestation)-302(to)-302(a)-302(divine)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(commission)-278(shows)-278(a)-279(want)-278(of)-278(force)-278(and)-278(divine)-279(originality.)-334(I)-278(ask,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(how?)-352(The)-284(fact)-284(is)-284(that)-284(with)-284(the)-284(exception)-284(of)-284(Judaism,)-292(no)-284(ancient)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(religion)-256(professed)-256(to)-256(be)-255(so)-256(attested;)-259(and)-256(the)-256(Jew)-256(would)-255(naturally)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(expect)-345(that)-346(any)-345(fresh)-345(revelation)-345(would)-345(be)-346(attested)-345(in)-345(a)-345(manner)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(similar)-250(to)-250(that)-250(which)-250(he)-250(believed)-250(in)-250(as)-250(divine.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(The)-308(objection)-309(that)-308(because)-308(the)-309(belief)-308(in)-308(supernaturalism)-308(was)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(so)-324(general,)-343(therefore)-324(miracles)-324(must)-324(be)-324(worthless)-324(as)-324(evidence,)-342(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-250(already)-250(shown)-250(to)-250(be)-250(fallacious.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(But)-318(it)-317(is)-318(also)-317(objected:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 104.733 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Instead)-318(of)-317(a)-318(few)-317(evidential)-318(miracles)]TJ -121.532 -13.549 Td [(taking)-384(place)-384(at)-384(one)-384(particular)-384(period)-384(of)-384(history)-384(and)-384(filling)-383(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(world)-345(with)-344(surprise)-345(at)-344(such)-345(novel)-344(and)-345(exceptional)-344(phenomena,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(we)-343(find)-343(them)-344(represented)-343(as)-343(taking)-343(place)-343(in)-344(all)-343(ages)-343(and)-343(in)-343(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(countries.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 42.72 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -30.764 -14.531 Td [(This)-360(is)-361(the)-360(old)-361(objection)-360(of)-360(the)-361(Jews)-360(who)-361(demanded)-360(of)-360(our)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Lord)-346(a)-345(sign)-346(from)-345(Heaven.)-537(Both)-345(demand)-346(a)-345(particular)-346(class)-345(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-381(of)-381(miracle,)-414(viz.:)-512(something)-381(stupendous,)-413(or)-381(terrific.)-643(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(value)-255(of)-256(each)-255(objection)-256(lies)-255(in)-255(conceiving)-256(of)-255(a)-255(miracle)-256(as)-255(a)-255(mere)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(objective)-197(fact)-197(in)-197(external)-197(nature,)-207(stript)-197(of)-197(all)-197(its)-197(moral)-196(accompani-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ments.)-233(In)-198(one)-198(word,)-209(it)-198(contemplates)-199(the)-198(miracle)-198(in)-199(its)-198(most)-198(vulgar)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aspect,)-240(as)-237(a)-238(bare)-237(act)-238(of)-237(power,)-480(a)-237(portent,)-240(a)-238(prodigy.)-246(A)-237(great)-237(light)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([356])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(everywhere)-411(appearing)-411(in)-411(the)-411(heavens)-411(might)-411(have)-411(appeared)-410(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(vulgar)-213(minds)-213(a)-213(greater)-213(miracle,)-221(and)-213(have)-213(attracted)-213(more)-213(attention)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(than)-245(the)-244(cure)-245(of)-245(a)-244(man)-245(full)-245(of)-244(leprosy)-245(by)-245(the)-244(utterance)-245(of)-245(a)-244(word.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(But)-383(it)-384(would)-383(not)-384(have)-383(presented)-383(stronger)-384(evidences)-383(of)-383(having)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-250(wrought)-250(by)-250(the)-250(power)-250(of)-250(God.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(But)-278(with)-279(respect)-278(to)-278(the)-279(general)-278(question,)-286(I)-278(ask,)-285(Is)-279(not)-278(the)-278(res-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(urrection)-303(of)-304(Jesus)-303(Christ)-304(in)-303(every)-303(respect)-304(an)-303(exceptional)-303(event?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Where)-418(are)-417(resurrections)-418(to)-417(be)-418(found)-417(in)-418(the)-417(history)-418(of)-417(current)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supernaturalism?)-443(Who)-315(ever)-314(pretended,)-331(before)-314(or)-315(since,)-330(to)-314(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-248(divine)-247(commission)-248(which)-247(was)-247(attested)-248(by)-247(his)-248(own)-247(resurrection)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1454 0 obj <<
/Length 4734      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(313)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(from)-376(the)-375(dead?)-627(This)-375(miracle)-376(is)-375(at)-376(any)-375(rate)-376(absolutely)-375(unique;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-357(it)-357(must)-357(never)-357(be)-357(forgotten)-357(that)-357(it)-357(is)-357(the)-357(only)-357(one)-356(recorded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-410(the)-409(New)-410(Testament)-409(on)-410(the)-410(truth)-409(of)-410(which)-409(its)-410(writers)-409(stake)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-348(claim)-348(of)-348(Christianity)-347(to)-348(be)-348(regarded)-348(as)-348(a)-348(divine)-347(revelation.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Although)-281(they)-281(refer)-280(to)-281(other)-281(miracles,)-288(wonders)-281(and)-281(signs)-280(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God)-389(wrought)-389(by)-389(Him,)-423(yet)-389(whenever)-389(they)-389(adduce)-389(the)-389(full)-388(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conclusive)-335(evidence)-335(of)-335(His)-335(divine)-335(mission,)-356(they)-335(always)-334(appeal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(the)-250(fact)-250(that)-250(God)-250(had)-250(raised)-250(Him)-250(from)-250(the)-250(dead.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(But)-369(a)-368(further)-369(objection)-368(is)-369(urged)-368(as)-369(invalidating)-368(this)-369(kind)-368(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(testimony:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 51.011 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(At)-351(the)-352(very)-351(time)-352(when)-351(the)-352(knowledge)-351(of)-352(the)-351(laws)]TJ -55.855 -13.549 Td [(of)-309(nature)-309(began)-309(to)-308(render)-309(men)-309(capable)-309(of)-309(judging)-309(of)-309(the)-308(reality)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-350(miracles,)-375(these)-350(wonders)-350(entirely)-350(ceased.)-550(This)-350(extraordinary)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(cessation)-218(of)-218(miracles)-218(at)-217(a)-218(time)-218(when)-218(their)-218(evidence)-218(ought)-218(to)-217(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acquired)-322(value)-322(from)-323(an)-322(appeal)-322(to)-322(persons)-322(capable)-322(of)-322(appreciat-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ing)-383(them,)-416(is)-383(perfectly)-382(unintelligible,)-416(if)-383(they)-383(are)-383(viewed)-383(as)-382(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-250(credentials)-250(of)-250(a)-250(divine)-250(revelation.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 202.375 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -190.419 -14.777 Td [(This)-284(passage)-284(contains)-285(several)-284(fallacies.)-352(One,)-293(to)-284(which)-284(I)-284(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(repeatedly)-422(drawn)-422(attention,)-465(runs)-422(through)-422(it,)-465(viz.,)-465(the)-422(classing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(together)-220(every)-219(kind)-220(of)-219(alleged)-440(supernatural)-219(occurrence,)-226(from)-219(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([357])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-288(of)-288(Jesus)-288(to)-288(the)-288(fantastic)-288(performances)-288(of)-288(the)-287(magician,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-360(though)-359(they)-360(all)-359(stood)-360(on)-359(the)-360(same)-359(level.)-579(I)-359(need)-360(not)-359(further)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(allude)-250(to)-250(the)-250(fallacy)-250(of)-250(such)-250(reasoning.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(2.)-244(It)-231(is)-232(affirmed)-232(that)-231(miracles)-232(entirely)-232(ceased)-231(when)-232(the)-231(knowl-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(edge)-186(of)-186(the)-186(laws)-186(of)-186(nature)-186(began)-186(to)-186(render)-186(men)-186(capable)-186(of)-185(judging)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-194(their)-195(reality.)-231(I)-194(conclude)-195(that)-194(by)-194(the)-194(word)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 185.199 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(miracles)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 36.96 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.963 0 Td [(in)-194(this)-195(pas-)]TJ -233.966 -13.549 Td [(sage,)-275(the)-270(author)-270(means)-270(ecclesiastical)-270(miracles,)-275(viz.,)-275(those)-269(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-262(been)-262(alleged)-261(to)-262(be)-262(wrought)-261(in)-262(attestation)-262(of)-262(the)-261(established)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(system)-431(of)-431(belief.)-793(If)-431(it)-431(is)-431(meant)-431(to)-431(be)-431(asserted)-431(that)-431(all)-430(belief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-323(a)-323(current)-323(supernaturalism)-323(has)-323(now)-323(ceased,)-341(the)-323(affirmation)-322(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(inaccurate,)-328(as)-312(the)-312(wide-spread)-313(belief)-312(in)-312(spiritualism)-312(abundantly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testifies.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(But)-241(if)-241(the)-241(assertion)-241(is)-241(intended)-241(to)-241(be)-241(confined)-241(to)-240(ecclesiastical)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(miracles,)-481(it)-435(involves)-435(an)-435(inaccuracy)-435(as)-435(to)-435(a)-435(matter)-435(of)-434(history.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(They)-229(had)-229(become)-230(thoroughly)-229(discredited)-229(long)-229(before)-229(the)-229(birth)-229(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1458 0 obj <<
/Length 4412      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(314)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(modern)-276(physical)-276(science.)-328(The)-276(cure)-276(of)-276(blind)-276(and)-276(leprous)-275(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-399(a)-399(touch,)-435(or)-399(the)-399(feeding)-399(of)-398(five)-399(thousand)-399(persons)-399(on)-398(seven)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(loaves)-214(and)-214(a)-213(few)-214(fishes,)-221(require)-214(nothing)-214(else)-214(than)-214(sound)-213(common)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sense)-293(for)-293(the)-294(appreciation)-293(of)-293(their)-293(supernatural)-293(character,)-304(or)-293(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(testing)-391(of)-391(their)-391(reality.)-672(The)-391(assertion,)-426(therefore,)-427(that)-390(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ceased)-190(precisely)-190(at)-190(the)-189(time)-190(when)-190(their)-190(evidence)-190(would)-190(have)-189(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(most)-290(valuable,)-300(by)-290(their)-290(being)-290(able)-290(to)-290(be)-290(tested)-290(by)-290(those)-289(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(best)-250(capable)-250(of)-250(appreciating)-250(them,)-250(is)-250(entirely)-250(inaccurate.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-291(fully)-292(admit)-291(that)-292(a)-291(belief)-292(in)-291(a)-292(current)-291(supernaturalism,)-302(as)-291(for)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(instance)-308(in)-308(the)-308(absurdities)-308(of)-309(witchcraft,)-322(survived)-308(the)-308(Reforma-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion.)-522(What)-341(the)-341(Reformation)-341(destroyed)-341(was)-340(a)-341(belief)-341(in)-341(a)-340(divine)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(order)-245(of)-244(miracles)-245(wrought)-244(in)-245(support)-245(of)-244(an)-245(ecclesiastical)-244(system.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-431(belief)-432(in)-431(this)-432(current)-431(supernaturalism)-432(has)-431(been)-431(gradually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(diminishing)-407(ever)-407(since,)-446(under)-406(the)-407(combined)-407(influence)-814(of)-406(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([358])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(increase)-456(of)-457(the)-456(knowledge)-456(of)-457(physical)-456(science,)-508(and)-456(common)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sense.)-536(The)-345(objection)-345(raised)-346(is)-345(simply)-345(irrelevant)-346(to)-345(the)-345(point)-345(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(issue.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-435(there)-436(is)-435(another)-436(subject)-435(which)-436(demands)-435(consideration.)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Hitherto)-341(we)-340(have)-341(been)-340(dealing)-340(with)-341(the)-340(evidential)-341(character)-340(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miracles.)-437(But)-312(although)-312(all)-313(miracles)-312(have)-312(an)-312(evidential)-313(value,)-327(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-199(can)-199(be)-200(adequately)-199(attested,)-209(it)-199(by)-200(no)-199(means)-199(follows)-199(that)-199(every)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracle)-211(recorded)-211(in)-211(the)-210(New)-211(Testament)-211(was)-211(intended)-211(to)-210(subserve)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-345(purpose)-346(alone.)-536(It)-346(was)-345(necessary)-346(not)-345(only)-346(that)-345(a)-345(revelation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-393(be)-393(communicated,)-428(and)-393(receive)-393(an)-393(adequate)-392(attestation,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(but)-271(that)-271(it)-272(should)-271(be)-271(propagated)-271(among)-271(mankind.)-314(To)-271(render)-271(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possible,)-356(it)-335(was)-334(necessary)-335(that)-335(its)-334(messengers)-335(should)-335(be)-334(armed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-262(some)-261(means)-262(of)-262(insuring)-261(that)-262(their)-262(message)-261(should)-262(be)-261(heard)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-412(attention.)-737(There)-413(was)-412(also)-412(another)-413(object)-412(to)-412(be)-412(effected;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(namely,)-329(the)-314(establishment)-313(in)-313(the)-314(world)-313(of)-314(that)-313(great)-313(institution,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-225(Christian)-226(Church,)-230(which)-226(was)-225(intended)-225(so)-226(largely)-225(to)-225(influence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-250(destinies.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(It)-219(will)-219(be)-220(quite)-219(clear)-219(to)-219(any)-220(person)-219(who)-219(carefully)-219(considers)-219(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(various)-216(supernatural)-216(occurrences)-215(recorded)-216(in)-216(the)-216(New)-215(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-289(they)-289(are)-289(not)-289(all)-289(of)-289(equal)-289(evidential)-289(value.)-367(The)-289(highest)-288(class)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1462 0 obj <<
/Length 4578      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(315)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(of)-407(them)-406(are)-407(directly)-406(affirmed)-407(to)-406(have)-407(been)-406(performed)-407(for)-406(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purpose)-285(of)-285(attesting)-285(the)-285(divine)-284(mission)-285(of)-285(Jesus)-285(Christ,)-294(and)-285(as)-284(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(portion)-325(of)-326(His)-325(supernatural)-326(manifestation.)-476(To)-326(this)-325(class)-325(belong)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-213(miracles)-213(wrought)-213(by)-213(Himself,)-220(and)-213(several)-213(of)-213(those)-213(performed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-243(the)-244(Apostles.)-247(But)-244(there)-243(is)-243(another)-243(class)-243(referred)-244(to)-243(in)-243(the)-243(Acts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-256(the)-255(Apostles,)-257(of)-256(which)-255(the)-256(primary)-255(object)-256(seems)-255(to)-256(have)-255(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-238(awaken)-238(attention)-238(to)-238(the)-238(Apostolic)-238(message,)-240(though)-238(even)-238(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-218(not)-218(destitute)-218(of)-219(evidential)-218(value.)-239(There)-218(is)-218(also)-218(another)-218(order)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-292(manifestations)-291(frequently)-292(referred)-292(to)-291(in)-292(the)-291(Epistles,)-302(viz.,)-302(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supernatural)-290(gifts)-290(of)-290(the)-291(Spirit,)-300(one)-290(of)-290(the)-290(declared)-290(purposes)-580(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([359])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(which)-298(was)-298(to)-297(lay)-298(deep)-298(the)-297(foundations)-298(of)-298(the)-298(Christian)-297(Church.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(As)-378(divine)-378(interpositions,)-410(they)-378(were)-378(all)-378(to)-378(a)-378(certain)-378(extent)-377(evi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dential;)-297(but)-282(it)-281(will)-282(be)-281(important)-282(to)-281(observe)-282(that)-281(there)-282(is)-281(an)-281(order)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-227(supernatural)-227(manifestations)-227(mentioned)-227(in)-227(the)-227(New)-227(Testament,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(whose)-411(apparent)-410(primary)-411(intention)-411(was)-410(to)-411(subserve)-411(a)-410(different)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purpose.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Let)-266(it)-265(be)-266(observed)-266(therefore,)-269(that)-266(at)-266(the)-265(introduction)-266(of)-265(Chris-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tianity,)-359(two)-338(distinct)-337(purposes)-337(had)-338(to)-337(be)-337(effected:)-425(first,)-359(to)-337(attest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(truth)-250(of)-250(the)-250(revelation;)-250(secondly,)-250(to)-250(establish)-250(the)-250(Church.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-206(will)-207(briefly)-206(draw)-206(attention)-207(to)-206(this)-206(latter)-207(portion)-206(of)-206(the)-206(subject,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(as)-429(far)-428(as)-429(it)-429(affects)-428(certain)-429(portions)-429(of)-428(the)-429(supernatural)-428(action)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirmed)-383(in)-383(the)-383(New)-384(Testament.)-649(I)-383(allude)-383(to)-383(a)-383(certain)-383(class)-383(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles,)-244(such)-243(as)-243(the)-243(cure)-243(of)-243(the)-243(cripple)-242(at)-243(Lystra,)-245(those)-242(wrought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-257(the)-258(passing)-257(of)-257(Peter's)-258(shadow,)-259(and)-257(by)-258(garments)-257(brought)-257(from)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Paul's)-382(person,)-414(and)-382(some)-382(others;)-447(also)-382(to)-382(the)-381(entire)-382(class)-382(of)-381(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-280(gifts)-281(mentioned)-280(in)-280(the)-280(Acts)-281(of)-280(the)-280(Apostles,)-288(and)-280(so)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(frequently)-250(referred)-250(to)-250(in)-250(the)-250(Epistles.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(One)-299(of)-298(the)-299(greatest)-298(difficulties)-299(which)-299(beset)-298(the)-299(missionary)-298(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to)-255(obtain)-255(a)-255(hearing)-255(in)-255(the)-255(midst)-255(of)-255(the)-255(hostile)-255(elements)-255(by)-254(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-345(is)-346(surrounded.)-535(Yet)-346(to)-345(obtain)-345(this)-346(is)-345(the)-345(necessary)-345(condition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-296(carrying)-296(on)-296(his)-295(work.)-388(In)-296(this)-296(respect,)-307(the)-296(modern)-295(missionary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possesses)-199(great)-199(advantages)-200(compared)-199(with)-199(the)-199(primitive)-199(mission-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ary)-291(of)-291(Christianity.)-374(He)-291(belongs)-291(to)-291(a)-292(superior)-291(civilization,)-301(and)-291(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-313(able)-312(to)-313(bring)-313(to)-313(bear)-312(the)-313(whole)-313(force)-313(of)-312(a)-313(higher)-313(on)-312(a)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1467 0 obj <<
/Length 5527      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(316)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(lower)-245(one.)-249(This)-245(was)-246(exactly)-245(reversed)-245(in)-246(the)-245(case)-246(of)-245(the)-245(primitive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(missionaries.)-397(Instead)-300(of)-299(being)-299(able)-299(to)-299(bring)-299(to)-299(bear)-299(the)-299(prestige)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-264(a)-264(high)-264(civilization)-264(on)-264(those)-264(among)-264(whom)-264(they)-264(laboured,)-267(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belonged)-378(to)-377(a)-378(despised)-377(race;)-442(or)-377(if)-378(the)-377(missionary)-378(himself)-377(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-335(member)-334(of)-335(the)-334(race)-335(whom)-335(he)-334(addressed,)-356(he)-669(belonged)-335(to)-334(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([360])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(lower)-271(sections)-271(of)-270(society.)-313(How)-270(was)-271(this)-271(enormous)-271(deficiency)-270(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-304(supplied?)-412(How)-303(was)-304(a)-304(man)-304(thus)-304(despised)-304(to)-304(obtain)-304(a)-303(hearing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-197(the)-198(message)-197(with)-198(which)-197(he)-198(was)-197(charged?)-233(The)-197(New)-197(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirms)-212(that)-212(the)-211(deficiency)-212(was)-212(supplied)-211(by)-212(imparting)-212(to)-212(the)-211(early)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Church)-393(a)-393(certain)-392(number)-393(of)-393(supernatural)-393(endowments,)-428(which,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-240(once)-240(communicated,)-242(acted)-240(like)-239(our)-240(ordinary)-240(faculties;)-243(also)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-217(a)-218(supernatural)-217(gift)-218(of)-217(curing)-218(certain)-217(diseases)-218(was)-217(imparted)-217(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(particular)-311(individuals,)-325(a)-311(gift)-311(which)-310(was)-311(exactly)-310(suited)-311(to)-310(obtain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-250(attentive)-250(hearing)-250(for)-250(their)-250(message.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Among)-302(the)-303(supernatural)-302(gifts)-302(which)-303(St.)-407(Paul)-302(affirms)-302(to)-302(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(been)-308(communicated)-307(to)-308(the)-308(Church,)-322(there)-308(were)-307(two)-308(of)-308(which)-307(he)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(asserts)-425(that)-425(the)-425(operation)-424(was)-425(distinct,)-469(but)-425(which)-425(are)-424(merged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-433(the)-434(modern)-433(idea)-434(of)-433(miracles.)-801(These)-433(he)-434(designated)-433(by)-433(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(expressions)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 53.399 0 Td [(\020)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\275\265\301\263)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 20.509 0 Td [(u)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.825 0 Td [(\274\261\304\261)-229(\264\305\275\261\274)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 52.417 0 Td [(s)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\311\275)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.167 0 Td [(,)-233(or)-229(the)-229(inworking)-229(of)-229(powers;)]TJ -154.481 -13.549 Td [(and)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 19.607 0 Td [(\307\261\301)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 16.244 0 Td [(w)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\303\274\261\304\261)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 31.094 0 Td [(0)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\261\274)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 11.607 0 Td [(q)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.728 0 Td [(\304\311\275)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 17.858 0 Td [(,)-379(endowments)-353(of)-354(healing)-353(powers.)-560(The)]TJ -108.552 -13.549 Td [(distinction)-272(in)-272(function)-272(between)-273(these)-272(powers)-272(is)-272(affirmed)-272(by)-272(him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-327(less)-326(than)-327(three)-327(times;)-365(what)-326(it)-327(consisted)-327(in,)-345(we)-327(are)-327(only)-326(able)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-312(judge)-313(from)-312(the)-312(terms)-313(themselves,)-328(and)-312(the)-312(nature)-313(of)-312(the)-312(case.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(There)-295(is)-295(every)-295(probability)-294(that)-295(the)-295(distinction)-295(points)-295(to)-295(a)-294(higher)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-357(a)-356(lower)-357(exercise)-357(of)-357(supernatural)-356(power;)-410(the)-357(one)-357(being)-356(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidential)-194(miracle)-194(properly)-194(so)-195(called,)-205(and)-194(the)-194(other)-194(a)-194(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowledge)-201(of)-201(how)-201(to)-200(effect)-201(cures)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 143.032 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(a)-201(gift)-201(which)-200(would)-201(be)-201(exactly)]TJ -153.941 -13.55 Td [(suited)-346(to)-346(enable)-347(the)-346(missionary)-346(to)-346(obtain)-346(that)-346(attentive)-346(hearing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-373(his)-373(message)-374(which)-373(he)-373(so)-373(urgently)-373(required.)-620(The)-373(Epistle)-373(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(St.)-507(James)-336(furnishes)-336(us)-336(with)-336(a)-336(general)-335(idea)-336(of)-336(the)-336(nature)-336(of)-335(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gift,)-341(when)-322(he)-323(directs,)-340(that)-323(in)-322(case)-323(a)-322(person)-323(was)-322(sick,)-341(the)-322(elders)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-368(the)-368(Church)-368(were)-368(to)-368(be)-368(sent)-369(for,)-397(who)-368(were)-368(to)-368(pray)-368(over)-368(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sick)-246(man,)-247(and)-245(anoint)-246(him)-246(with)-246(oil)-246(in)-246(the)-246(name)-245(of)-246(the)-246(Lord;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 257.001 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(And)]TJ -261.845 -13.549 Td [(the)-316(prayer)-316(of)-316(faith,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 83.345 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.291 0 Td [(says)-316(he,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 38.886 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(shall)-316(save)-316(the)-316(sick;)-349(and)-316(the)-316(Lord)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1471 0 obj <<
/Length 4576      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(317)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(shall)-245(raise)-489(him)-245(up.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 82.496 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.514 0 Td [(\050James)-245(v.)-248(15.\051)-248(The)-245(whole)-245(description)-245(points)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 201.014 0 Td [([361])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(to)-394(a)-393(cure)-394(which,)-429(although)-394(in)-393(a)-394(measure)-393(supernatural,)-430(was)-393(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instantaneous;)-214(the)-196(latter)-196(point)-197(being)-196(one)-196(which)-196(would)-196(be)-196(required)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-288(make)-289(a)-288(miracle)-288(in)-288(the)-289(proper)-288(sense)-288(of)-288(the)-288(word)-289(evidential.)-364(A)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(power)-318(of)-319(effecting)-318(cures,)-336(however,)-335(whether)-318(by)-319(a)-318(knowledge)-318(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural)-282(means)-282(supernaturally)-282(acquired,)-290(or)-282(by)-282(supernatural)-281(agen-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cy,)-390(would)-361(be)-362(one)-362(which)-361(would)-362(obtain)-362(for)-361(the)-362(despised)-361(Jewish)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(missionary)-225(a)-226(hearing)-225(in)-226(Gentile)-225(cities,)-230(which)-226(otherwise)-225(he)-225(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-250(unable)-250(to)-250(obtain.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(To)-255(such)-256(a)-255(class)-256(of)-255(supernatural)-256(operations)-255(would)-256(belong)-255(such)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(cures)-291(as)-292(those)-291(effected)-292(by)-291(the)-291(conveyance)-292(of)-291(handkerchiefs)-291(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aprons)-418(from)-418(St.)-754(Paul's)-418(body)-418(to)-418(the)-418(sick.)-754(These)-418(are)-418(only)-417(as-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(serted)-355(to)-354(have)-355(taken)-354(place)-355(on)-354(one)-355(occasion,)-381(at)-354(Ephesus,)-381(a)-354(city)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(greatly)-306(addicted)-306(to)-307(the)-306(arts)-306(of)-306(magic.)-419(They)-306(were)-306(adapted)-306(to)-306(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(circumstances)-299(of)-299(the)-299(place,)-311(where)-299(the)-299(Apostle)-299(had)-299(to)-299(encounter)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-283(particular)-283(form)-283(of)-283(supernaturalism;)-299(and)-283(they)-283(would)-283(have)-283(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exactly)-346(suited)-347(to)-346(meet)-346(the)-347(difficulty)-346(in)-346(question.)-539(The)-346(historian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tells)-177(us)-177(that)-176(the)-177(success)-177(was)-177(great,)-191(for)-177(many)-176(of)-177(those)-177(who)-177(had)-176(used)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(magical)-309(arts)-308(came)-308(forward)-309(and)-308(confessed)-309(their)-308(deeds,)-323(collected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(together)-322(their)-321(magical)-322(books,)-340(which)-321(were)-322(worth)-322(a)-321(considerable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sum)-199(of)-200(money,)-209(and)-200(publicly)-199(burned)-200(them.)-233(The)-199(same)-199(observations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apply)-293(to)-293(Peter's)-293(shadow.)-380(Although)-293(the)-293(historian)-293(does)-293(not)-293(tell)-293(us)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-264(cures)-265(were)-264(wrought)-264(by)-264(it,)-268(yet)-265(the)-264(narrative)-264(presupposes)-264(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-297(large)-297(outburst)-298(of)-297(supernatural)-297(power)-297(took)-297(place)-297(in)-297(connection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-340(Peter's)-339(person.)-520(Although)-339(the)-340(cure)-340(of)-339(the)-340(cripple)-340(at)-339(Lystra)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belongs)-389(to)-388(a)-389(class)-389(of)-388(miracles)-389(which)-389(is)-388(strictly)-389(evidential,)-423(yet)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-328(immediate)-328(occasion)-328(of)-328(its)-328(performance)-328(seems)-328(to)-328(have)-328(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-356(the)-356(view)-356(of)-357(arousing)-356(the)-356(attention)-356(of)-356(an)-356(ignorant)-356(heathen)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(population.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-171(not)-171(only)-171(had)-171(a)-171(revelation)-171(to)-171(be)-171(communicated)-342(and)-171(attested,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 279.068 0 Td [([362])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(not)-275(only)-276(had)-275(converts)-275(to)-276(be)-275(made)-275(and)-276(instructed,)-281(but)-276(it)-275(was)-275(also)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary)-187(that)-188(the)-187(foundations)-188(of)-187(the)-188(Church,)-200(the)-187(visible)-187(kingdom)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-253(Christ,)-253(should)-253(be)-252(firmly)-253(laid,)-253(and)-253(that)-253(it)-252(should)-253(be)-252(established)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(among)-342(the)-342(visible)-342(institutions)-342(of)-342(the)-342(earth.)-526(Sufficient)-341(attention)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1476 0 obj <<
/Length 4719      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(318)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(has)-369(not)-369(been)-369(paid)-369(to)-369(this)-369(portion)-369(of)-369(the)-369(subject)-369(in)-369(considering)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-319(question)-318(of)-319(supernatural)-318(intervention.)-455(The)-319(establishment)-318(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-232(Church)-231(as)-232(a)-231(visible)-232(institution,)-235(which)-231(was)-232(intended)-231(gradually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-275(leaven)-275(mankind)-275(with)-275(the)-275(great)-275(principles)-274(of)-275(His)-275(revelation,)-281(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(again)-241(and)-242(again)-241(affirmed)-242(by)-241(Jesus)-241(Christ)-242(to)-241(have)-241(been)-242(one)-241(of)-241(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-262(purposes)-262(of)-263(His)-262(coming.)-286(A)-263(description)-262(of)-262(its)-262(character)-262(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(functions)-297(forms)-297(the)-297(subject)-297(of)-297(no)-297(inconsiderable)-297(number)-297(of)-296(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(parables,)-305(and)-294(it)-293(is)-294(the)-294(great)-294(end)-294(and)-293(purpose)-294(for)-294(which)-294(He)-293(gave)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-239(great)-240(final)-239(Apostolic)-239(commission)-240(to)-239(go)-239(and)-240(gather)-239(it)-239(together)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(out)-250(of)-250(all)-250(the)-250(nations)-250(of)-250(the)-250(earth.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(The)-285(Church)-285(of)-285(Christ)-284(had)-285(therefore)-285(to)-285(be)-285(formed)-285(into)-285(a)-284(com-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(munity)-276(out)-275(of)-276(the)-276(most)-275(heterogeneous)-276(elements.)-327(It)-276(was)-275(destined)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-201(for)-201(a)-200(momentary)-201(existence,)-211(but)-201(for)-200(a)-201(continuous)-201(growth,)-211(so)-200(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-258(leaven)-257(human)-258(nature)-257(with)-258(its)-257(influences.)-273(The)-257(creation)-258(of)-257(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-314(society)-313(was)-314(a)-314(conception)-313(so)-314(bold)-314(that)-313(it)-314(had)-314(never)-313(previously)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entered)-230(the)-230(head)-230(of)-230(either)-230(poet)-229(or)-230(philosopher.)-244(Those)-230(with)-229(whom)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-216(am)-216(reasoning)-215(will)-216(not)-216(deny)-216(that)-216(the)-215(attempt)-216(was)-216(a)-216(very)-215(arduous,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-250(to)-250(all)-250(appearance)-250(a)-250(most)-250(chimerical)-250(one.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Yet)-288(it)-288(is)-287(the)-288(most)-288(certain)-288(of)-288(facts)-287(that)-288(the)-288(Church)-288(of)-288(Christ)-287(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(now)-308(in)-309(the)-308(nineteenth)-309(century)-308(of)-308(its)-309(existence.)-425(The)-308(boldness)-308(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-206(undertaking)-207(will)-206(be)-206(more)-206(fully)-206(estimated)-207(when)-206(we)-206(reflect)-206(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-345(Church)-346(was)-345(intended)-345(to)-346(be)-345(a)-346(society)-345(which,)-369(while)-345(existing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-295(the)-295(world,)-306(should)-295(differ)-295(in)-295(its)-295(essential)-295(character)-295(from)-295(all)-295(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-245(societies)-245(on)-246(the)-245(earth.)-248(Its)-245(action)-246(was)-245(to)-245(be)-245(entirely)-245(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-194(moral.)-232(Its)-194(founder)-194(intended)-388(it)-195(to)-194(be)-194(invested)-194(with)-194(no)-194(coercive)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([363])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(powers.)-250(The)-250(appeal)-250(was)-250(to)-250(be,)-250(not)-250(to)-250(force,)-250(but)-250(to)-250(conscience.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Those)-434(who)-435(offered)-434(to)-435(enroll)-434(themselves)-435(as)-434(the)-435(subjects)-434(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(Christ's)-338(spiritual)-338(kingdom)-338(had)-338(to)-338(be)-338(formed)-338(into)-338(a)-338(social)-337(orga-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nization.)-401(Unless)-301(this)-300(could)-301(be)-300(effected,)-314(one)-300(of)-300(the)-301(great)-300(objects)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-320(which)-321(the)-320(revelation)-320(was)-320(given)-320(must)-321(have)-320(proved)-320(a)-320(failure.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-301(elements)-302(of)-301(which)-302(it)-301(had)-302(to)-301(be)-302(composed)-301(were)-302(of)-301(the)-301(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unpromising)-209(description.)-236(The)-209(first)-209(converts)-209(consisted)-209(of)-209(no)-208(small)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(number)-295(of)-295(Jews)-294(and)-295(proselytes,)-306(who)-295(were)-295(extensively)-294(leavened)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-387(the)-387(narrowest)-386(prejudices)-387(of)-387(Judaism.)-660(When)-387(the)-386(Gentiles)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1480 0 obj <<
/Length 4471      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(319)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(began)-437(to)-437(join)-436(the)-437(new)-437(community,)-483(its)-437(members)-437(were)-436(chiefly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(derived)-213(from)-213(the)-213(lower)-213(ranks)-213(of)-213(society,)-220(including)-213(a)-213(considerable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(number)-271(of)-271(slaves.)-313(The)-271(infant)-271(Church)-271(embraced)-271(a)-271(great)-270(diversity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-278(opinions)-278(and)-278(characters.)-334(When)-278(converts)-278(were)-278(made,)-285(the)-277(time)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(for)-387(their)-387(instruction)-387(was)-387(short.)-660(Yet)-387(such)-387(an)-387(institution)-387(had)-386(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contend)-395(with)-396(mighty)-395(civilization,)-431(the)-396(habits)-395(and)-395(prejudices)-395(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existing)-365(society,)-393(the)-365(self-interest)-364(of)-365(a)-365(corrupt)-364(religion,)-394(and)-364(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opposition)-250(of)-250(a)-250(powerful)-250(government.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Such)-185(were)-186(some)-185(of)-186(the)-185(difficulties)-186(which)-185(had)-186(to)-185(be)-185(surmounted)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(before)-383(this)-383(new)-384(institution)-383(could)-383(be)-383(firmly)-383(planted)-383(among)-383(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existing)-378(societies)-378(of)-378(the)-377(world,)-410(and)-378(expand)-378(itself)-378(with)-378(the)-377(life)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-253(was)-253(peculiarly)-252(its)-253(own.)-259(If)-252(the)-253(primitive)-253(followers)-253(of)-252(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-326(animated)-327(by)-326(the)-326(credulous)-327(superstition)-326(which)-326(unbelievers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(delight)-395(in)-394(attributing)-394(to)-395(them,)-431(none)-394(should)-395(be)-394(better)-394(qualified)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-456(they)-456(to)-456(form)-456(a)-456(judgment)-456(of)-456(the)-456(difficulties)-456(which)-455(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-298(beset)-298(their)-298(path.)-395(Yet)-298(these)-298(have)-298(been)-298(surmounted.)-394(To)-298(this)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fact)-396(the)-396(vigorous)-396(life)-395(of)-396(the)-396(Church)-396(during)-396(eighteen)-395(centuries)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testifies.)-609(It)-370(has)-370(not)-370(only)-370(held)-369(its)-370(ground,)-400(but)-370(it)-370(has)-369(succeeded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-348(leavening)-347(all)-348(existing)-347(civilizations)-348(with)-347(its)-348(influences.)-542(How)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-334(this)-334(been)-334(accomplished?)-501(The)-334(Apostolic)-334(Epistles)-334(return)-667(an)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([364])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(answer.)-359(They)-286(affirm)-286(that)-286(the)-287(early)-286(converts)-286(were)-286(endowed)-286(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-264(number)-264(of)-265(supernatural)-264(gifts,)-268(exactly)-264(fitted)-264(to)-264(qualify)-264(them)-264(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-276(various)-275(functions)-276(which)-275(they)-275(were)-276(called)-275(upon)-276(to)-275(discharge.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-441(subjoin)-441(a)-441(list)-440(of)-441(them,)-489(as)-441(they)-441(are)-441(directly)-441(affirmed)-441(by)-440(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Paul)-364(to)-364(be)-363(then)-364(existing)-364(in)-364(the)-364(Corinthian)-363(Church.)-592(They)-363(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nine)-353(in)-352(number,)-378(each)-353(of)-353(which)-352(is)-353(asserted)-352(by)-353(him)-352(to)-353(have)-352(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-326(distinct)-325(and)-326(separate)-326(function)-325(and)-326(subject-matter:)-401(the)-326(gifts)-325(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(wisdom,)-469(knowledge,)-469(faith,)-470(working)-425(of)-425(miracles,)-469(endowments)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-288(healing)-287(powers,)-298(prophecy,)-297(discerning)-287(of)-288(spirits,)-297(tongues,)-297(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interpretation.)-564(It)-355(does)-354(not)-355(appear)-354(whether)-355(this)-355(last)-354(is)-355(meant)-354(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-258(exhaustive)-258(of)-257(the)-258(supernatural)-258(mental)-258(endowments)-258(which)-257(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(members)-282(of)-282(the)-282(early)-282(churches)-282(supposed)-282(themselves)-282(to)-282(possess,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(or)-207(whether)-206(they)-207(were)-206(varied)-207(for)-206(the)-207(purpose)-206(of)-207(meeting)-206(particular)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exigences.)-700(Nor)-400(do)-400(I)-400(ask)-400(those)-400(with)-400(whom)-400(I)-400(am)-400(reasoning)-400(to)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1484 0 obj <<
/Length 4575      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(320)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(accept)-311(this)-311(statement)-311(as)-311(a)-311(true)-312(account)-311(of)-311(an)-311(objective)-311(fact;)-341(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-297(that)-296(they)-297(were)-297(supposed)-297(to)-296(be)-297(so)-297(by)-296(the)-297(Apostle)-297(and)-296(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-311(whom)-310(he)-311(wrote.)-431(It)-311(is)-310(plain,)-326(however,)-325(that)-311(these)-310(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(endowments,)-350(if)-330(real,)-351(were)-330(precisely)-330(such)-330(as)-330(the)-330(Church)-330(was)-330(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(urgent)-353(need)-353(of,)-378(as)-353(the)-352(instrumentality)-353(for)-353(welding)-353(together)-352(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discordant)-317(elements)-316(of)-317(which)-317(it)-316(was)-317(composed,)-333(and)-317(enabling)-316(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(firmly)-250(to)-250(plant)-250(itself)-250(in)-250(the)-250(soil)-250(of)-250(human)-250(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(These)-394(supernatural)-394(gifts)-393(of)-394(the)-394(Spirit,)-430(with)-394(two)-393(exceptions,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(produced)-209(no)-210(results)-209(on)-210(external)-209(nature.)-237(They)-209(constituted)-209(enlarge-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ments)-324(of)-324(the)-323(powers)-324(of)-324(the)-324(human)-323(mind.)-472(As)-323(such,)-343(they)-323(cannot)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-319(strict)-318(propriety)-319(be)-318(said)-319(to)-319(belong)-318(to)-319(the)-318(class)-319(of)-318(evidential)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles,)-214(although)-204(like)-205(all)-204(other)-205(supernatural)-204(operations)-205(of)-204(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God)-353(is)-354(the)-353(Author,)-380(they)-353(cannot)-354(fail)-353(to)-354(be)-353(indirectly)-353(evidential.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-288(is)-287(important)-288(to)-287(observe)-288(that)-287(they)-288(belong)-287(to)-288(a)-287(separate)-288(class)-287(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supernatural)-328(phenomena,)-348(which)-328(were)-329(as)-328(necessary)-328(in)-328(reference)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-213(the)-212(Christian)-213(revelation,)-440(contemplating)-212(as)-213(it)-212(did)-213(the)-212(institution)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([365])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(of)-341(a)-341(divine)-341(society,)-363(as)-341(the)-341(order)-341(of)-341(supernatural)-340(manifestations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-211(directly)-212(attested)-211(the)-212(divine)-211(mission)-212(of)-211(Jesus)-212(Christ)-211(and)-211(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Apostles.)-495(If)-332(this)-331(was)-332(their)-331(end)-332(and)-332(purpose)-331(we)-332(can)-331(understand)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(why)-400(they)-400(were)-400(withdrawn)-400(at)-400(a)-400(very)-400(early)-400(period,)-437(before)-400(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(could)-213(be)-213(submitted)-213(to)-213(the)-212(tests)-213(of)-213(our)-213(modern)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 196.647 0 Td [(savants)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 32.727 0 Td [(.)-238(They)-212(were)]TJ -229.374 -13.549 Td [(given)-242(for)-243(a)-242(special)-243(purpose,)-244(and)-242(they)-242(were)-243(withdrawn)-242(when)-242(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-365(accomplished)-364(it.)-594(The)-364(Apostle)-365(who)-364(affirms)-365(their)-364(existence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(asserts)-353(that)-352(they)-353(were)-352(not)-352(intended)-353(permanently)-352(to)-353(continue)-352(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(Church.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(There)-475(is)-475(one)-475(more)-475(allegation)-475(which)-475(is)-475(occasionally)-474(urged)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(against)-373(the)-372(miracles)-373(of)-372(the)-373(New)-373(Testament,)-403(and)-372(which)-373(I)-372(must)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(briefly)-336(consider.)-509(It)-336(is)-337(alleged)-336(that)-336(pious)-337(frauds)-336(have)-336(been)-336(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(general)-211(in)-212(all)-211(ages)-212(of)-211(Christian)-212(history;)-224(that)-211(many)-212(good)-211(men)-211(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-376(hesitated)-377(to)-376(participate)-376(in)-377(them;)-439(and)-377(that)-376(literary)-376(forgeries)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-373(very)-372(abundant)-373(in)-373(the)-372(first)-373(ages)-373(of)-372(Christianity,)-404(and)-372(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-332(common)-331(in)-332(the)-331(days)-332(of)-331(the)-331(Apostles.)-495(It)-331(is)-332(insinuated)-331(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-256(state)-256(of)-256(mind)-256(throws)-256(great)-256(suspicion)-256(on)-256(the)-256(alleged)-256(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(apostolic)-250(age.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1488 0 obj <<
/Length 4661      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(321)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -252.311 -30.759 Td [(As)-224(the)-224(charge)-224(of)-225(pious)-224(fraud)-224(is)-224(not)-224(made)-224(against)-224(Jesus)-225(hi)1(mself)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(or)-240(his)-240(immediate)-240(followers,)-242(it)-240(is)-240(difficult)-240(to)-240(meet)-240(so)-240(indefinite)-240(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(objection.)-246(It)-239(seems)-240(to)-239(be)-239(put)-239(in)-239(to)-239(add)-239(force)-239(to)-239(others,)-241(rather)-239(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-211(its)-211(intrinsic)-211(value.)-237(Modern)-211(unbelievers)-211(express)-211(a)-211(nearly)-210(unan-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(imous)-314(concurrence)-313(in)-314(endeavouring)-313(to)-314(account)-313(for)-314(the)-313(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-313(the)-313(New)-313(Testament,)-328(by)-313(assuming)-313(that)-313(the)-313(followers)-313(of)-312(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-183(the)-182(victims)-183(of)-182(the)-183(most)-183(intense)-182(enthusiasm,)-196(superstition,)-196(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(credulity.)-495(It)-332(is)-332(difficult)-332(to)-332(comprehend,)-352(on)-332(the)-332(assumption)-331(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-266(existence)-267(of)-266(the)-266(supernatural)-266(portions)-267(of)-266(the)-266(New)-266(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-416(due)-416(to)-416(these)-416(causes,)-457(how)-416(direct)-416(fraud)-416(could)-416(have)-416(anything)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-362(do)-361(with)-362(the)-361(concoction)-362(of)-362(these)-361(miraculous)-362(stories.)-584(Intense)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enthusiasm)-422(and)-423(fanaticism,)-465(and)-422(deliberate)-422(fraud,)-931(are)-422(usually)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([366])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(opposite)-417(poles)-418(of)-417(character;)-501(and)-417(if)-418(we)-417(call)-417(in)-418(one)-417(to)-417(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-319(these)-318(miracles,)-336(we)-318(must)-319(exclude)-318(the)-319(other)-318(from)-319(exerting)-318(an)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(influence)-304(on)-304(their)-304(origination.)-411(To)-304(make)-304(the)-304(charge)-304(of)-304(any)-303(avail)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(against)-285(the)-285(narratives)-285(of)-286(the)-285(Gospel,)-294(it)-285(is)-285(necessary)-285(not)-285(to)-285(prove)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-362(pious)-361(frauds)-362(were)-362(common)-361(in)-362(the)-362(second,)-389(third,)-390(or)-361(fourth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(century,)-332(or)-316(even)-316(in)-315(the)-316(first,)-332(but)-316(to)-315(establish)-316(directly)-316(either)-315(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-284(professed)-284(to)-284(work)-285(miracles)-284(while)-284(He)-284(knew)-284(that)-284(they)-284(were)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(not)-353(such,)-378(or)-353(that)-353(His)-352(followers)-353(deliberately)-353(invented)-353(a)-352(number)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-280(miraculous)-281(stories)-280(and)-281(attributed)-280(them)-281(to)-280(Him,)-288(well)-280(knowing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-383(He)-382(had)-383(performed)-383(none.)-648(The)-383(charge)-382(that)-383(the)-383(miracles)-382(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-334(New)-334(Testament)-334(originated)-334(in)-334(enthusiasm)-334(and)-334(credulity)-334(is)-333(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(definite)-321(one,)-338(and)-320(can)-321(be)-320(definitely)-321(met.)-462(So)-320(is)-321(the)-320(one)-321(that)-320(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(originated)-332(in)-331(deliberate)-332(fraud.)-495(So)-331(would)-332(be)-332(the)-331(charge)-332(that)-331(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(innocent)-390(followers)-389(of)-390(Jesus)-390(were)-389(imposed)-390(upon)-390(by)-389(fraudulent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impostors.)-282(But)-260(to)-261(combine)-260(the)-260(charge)-261(of)-260(intense)-261(enthusiasm)-260(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(credulity)-367(with)-367(that)-367(of)-367(conscious)-368(fraud,)-396(is)-367(a)-367(mode)-367(of)-367(reasoning)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(contains)-250(the)-250(grounds)-250(of)-250(its)-250(own)-250(refutation.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-313(is)-313(no)-313(doubt)-314(a)-313(fact,)-329(that)-313(the)-313(practice)-313(of)-313(literary)-313(forgery)-313(was)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(not)-346(unknown)-345(to)-345(the)-346(early)-345(ages)-346(of)-345(Christianity.)-537(St.)-536(Paul)-345(seems)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-373(have)-373(thought)-372(that)-373(there)-373(were)-372(in)-373(the)-373(world)-373(impostors)-372(daring)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(enough)-240(to)-241(attempt)-240(to)-240(forge)-240(a)-241(letter)-240(in)-240(his)-240(name,)-242(and)-241(to)-240(try)-240(to)-240(foist)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-212(on)-212(the)-212(churches)-212(which)-212(he)-212(had)-213(planted,)-219(as)-212(a)-212(genuine)-212(production.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1493 0 obj <<
/Length 3876      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(322)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(But)-273(the)-273(existence)-273(of)-272(such)-273(impostors)-273(has)-273(no)-273(bearing)-273(whatever)-272(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-192(question)-193(whether)-192(the)-192(miracles)-192(recorded)-193(in)-192(the)-192(New)-192(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-320(facts)-320(or)-319(fiction.)-460(Did)-319(not)-320(St.)-460(Paul)-319(himself)-320(assert)-320(that)-320(he)-319(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performed)-187(miracles?)-229(Was)-187(he)-186(an)-187(impostor?)-229(Did)-187(he)-187(not)-187(believe)-186(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Jesus)-302(Christ)-301(in)-302(veritable)-301(reality)-302(rose)-301(from)-302(the)-301(dead?)-405(What)-301(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-339(beliefs)-338(to)-339(do)-338(with)-339(the)-338(existence)-339(of)-338(a)-339(set)-338(of)-339(daring)-338(literary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impostors?)-331(Happily,)-284(however,)-284(the)-277(whole)-277(of)-277(this)-277(class)-277(of)-277(ancient)]TJ 3.37 -13.549 Td [(writers)-309(were)-309(utter)-308(bunglers)-309(in)-309(the)-309(art)-309(of)-309(fictitious)-309(composition.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -76.125 0 Td [([367])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(It)-367(is)-368(a)-367(universal)-367(characteristic)-368(of)-367(them,)-397(that)-367(they)-367(were)-367(entirely)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(unable)-275(to)-275(throw)-275(themselves)-275(into)-276(the)-275(spirit)-275(of)-275(former)-275(times,)-281(or)-275(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-352(persons)-352(whose)-351(names)-352(they)-352(assumed.)-555(In)-352(their)-352(references)-351(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(history,)-403(geography,)-402(manners,)-403(customs,)-403(and)-372(character,)-402(they)-372(lay)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(themselves)-211(open)-211(at)-210(almost)-211(every)-211(point)-211(to)-211(certain)-211(detection.)-236(There)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-264(good)-265(reason)-264(for)-265(believing)-264(that)-265(no)-264(forger)-265(or)-264(writer)-265(of)-264(fiction)-264(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-332(ancient)-331(world)-332(has)-331(succeeded)-332(in)-331(his)-332(art.)-494(In)-332(investing)-331(fiction)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-233(apparent)-233(probability,)-236(the)-233(modern)-233(world)-233(has)-233(completely)-232(out-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stript)-238(the)-238(ancient.)-246(Still,)-241(however,)-241(even)-238(in)-238(the)-238(most)-238(perfect)-238(works,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-290(the)-291(fictions)-290(are)-290(extended)-291(over)-290(a)-290(wide)-290(sphere)-291(of)-290(action,)-300(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(amount)-301(of)-300(genius)-301(will)-301(protect)-300(a)-301(writer)-301(from)-300(leaving)-301(some)-300(weak)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(point)-285(unguarded.)-353(It)-285(is)-284(probably)-284(not)-285(too)-284(much)-285(to)-284(say)-285(that)-284(neither)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-330(ancient)-329(nor)-330(modern)-329(times,)-350(has)-329(a)-330(fictitious)-330(work)-329(or)-330(a)-329(forgery)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-240(able)-239(to)-240(maintain)-239(its)-240(ground)-239(against)-240(the)-239(apparatus)-240(which)-239(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-250(brought)-250(to)-250(bear)-250(on)-250(it)-250(by)-250(a)-250(sound)-250(and)-250(rational)-250(criticism.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(Most)-367(of)-366(the)-367(other)-366(objections)-367(which)-367(are)-366(adduced)-367(against)-366(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(miracles)-260(of)-261(the)-260(New)-260(Testament)-260(have)-261(been)-260(answered)-260(in)-260(principle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-443(the)-442(foregoing)-443(heads.)-828(I)-443(must)-443(now)-442(adduce)-443(some)-443(of)-442(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(most)-355(important)-355(considerations)-354(which)-355(prove)-355(them)-355(to)-355(have)-354(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-250(facts.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -27.371 Td [([368])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1502 0 obj <<
/Length 3469      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-267(XVII.)-267(The)-267(Historical)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Evidence)-250(On)-251(Which)-250(The)-250(Great)-251(Facts)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Of)-265(Christianity)-264(Rest)]TJ/F20 18.9589 Tf 153.285 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 18.9589 Tf 18.959 0 Td [(General)]TJ -172.244 -24.647 Td [(Considerations.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -39.701 Td [(It)-308(has)-307(been)-308(urged)-307(by)-308(opponents,)-322(that)-308(the)-307(defenders)-308(of)-307(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity)-181(rest)-181(content)-182(with)-181(endeavouring)-181(to)-181(prove)-181(that)-181(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-335(possible)-336(or)-335(probable;)-378(but)-336(that)-335(they)-336(neglect)-335(an)-335(all-important)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(part)-237(of)-237(their)-237(duty,)-240(viz.:)-243(that)-237(of)-237(adducing)-237(historical)-237(proof)-237(that)-237(mir-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(acles)-283(have)-283(been)-283(actually)-283(performed.)-348(If)-283(the)-283(fact)-283(is)-283(as)-283(here)-282(stated,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(there)-359(can)-359(be)-359(no)-360(doubt)-359(that)-359(works)-359(which)-359(profess)-359(to)-359(discuss)-359(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subject)-197(of)-196(miracles,)-207(and)-197(omit)-196(to)-197(give)-196(a)-197(clear)-196(statement)-197(of)-196(the)-196(chief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(points)-299(of)-298(the)-299(evidence)-299(which)-298(can)-299(be)-299(adduced)-298(to)-299(prove)-299(that)-298(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-348(actually)-349(occurred,)-373(must)-348(be)-349(unsatisfactory.)-545(To)-348(answer)-348(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(objections)-214(which)-213(are)-214(urged)-214(to)-214(prove)-213(that)-214(miracles)-214(are)-213(impossible,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-340(which)-339(affirm)-340(on)-340(general)-339(principles)-340(that)-340(all)-339(evidence)-340(in)-339(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(favour)-351(is)-351(unworthy)-351(of)-350(credit,)-376(is)-351(an)-351(essential)-351(preliminary)-351(to)-350(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consideration)-236(of)-235(the)-236(historical)-235(evidence)-235(which)-236(can)-235(be)-236(adduced)-235(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prove)-314(their)-315(actual)-314(occurrence.)-443(But)-314(to)-314(afford)-315(proof,)-330(that)-314(as)-314(facts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-373(rest)-372(upon)-372(an)-373(adequate)-372(attestation,)-404(is)-372(the)-372(essential)-373(duty)-372(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(every)-260(one)-261(who)-260(asserts)-261(their)-260(reality.)-281(To)-261(this)-260(portion)-260(of)-261(the)-260(work)-260(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will)-250(now)-250(proceed)-250(to)-250(address)-250(myself.)]TJ 11.956 -15.005 Td [(What)-237(then)-237(is)-236(the)-237(position)-237(occupied)-237(by)-237(the)-237(Christian)-236(advocate?)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Is)-310(it)-309(requisite)-310(in)-309(order)-310(to)-309(establish)-310(the)-309(truth)-310(of)-309(Christianity,)-324(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-362(should)-362(give)-362(an)-361(historical)-362(proof)-362(of)-362(everyone)-362(of)-362(the)-361(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recorded)-425(in)-425(the)-425(New)-425(Testament?)-775(I)-425(answer)-425(this)-424(question)-425(em-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(phatically)-373(in)-746(the)-373(negative,)-404(and)-373(for)-373(the)-373(following)-373(reason.)-618(The)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([369])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(New)-347(Testament)-347(itself,)-371(while)-346(it)-347(affirm)-347(that)-347(many)-347(miracles)-346(have)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1506 0 obj <<
/Length 4958      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(324)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(been)-383(performed,)-416(rests)-383(the)-382(truth)-383(of)-383(Christianity)-383(on)-383(one)-382(miracle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alone,)-387(the)-359(Resurrection)-359(of)-359(Jesus)-360(Christ)-359(from)-359(the)-359(dead.)-578(This)-359(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-258(great)-258(event)-258(which,)-259(according)-258(to)-258(the)-258(Acts)-258(of)-258(the)-258(Apostles,)-259(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(early)-228(missionaries)-227(urged)-228(as)-227(the)-228(distinctive)-228(proof)-227(of)-228(their)-227(Master's)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(divine)-348(mission.)-542(The)-348(views)-347(expressed)-348(in)-347(the)-348(Apostolic)-347(Epistles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-265(precisely)-266(similar.)-295(In)-266(them,)-269(the)-265(entire)-265(evidence)-266(of)-265(the)-265(truth)-265(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-230(Lord's)-230(divine)-231(mission)-230(is)-230(made)-230(to)-230(centre)-231(in)-230(the)-230(fact)-230(of)-230(His)-230(res-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(urrection.)-329(Not)-276(only)-277(is)-276(the)-276(great)-277(fact)-276(referred)-276(to)-277(either)-276(directly)-276(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(indirectly)-250(in)-251(almost)-250(every)-250(page,)-251(but)-250(St.)-251(Paul)-250(has)-250(distinctly)-250(rested)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-302(truth)-301(of)-302(Christianity)-302(on)-302(the)-301(reality)-302(of)-302(its)-302(occurrence.)-405(Such)-301(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(statement)-223(is)-223(made)-224(respecting)-223(no)-223(other)-223(miraculous)-223(event)-223(recorded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-290(the)-291(New)-290(Testament.)-371(It)-290(is)-291(the)-290(miracle)-290(of)-291(miracles,)-300(unique)-290(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alone,)-218(by)-211(which)-210(the)-211(seal)-210(of)-211(God)-210(was)-211(affixed)-210(to)-211(the)-210(divine)-210(mission)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-240(Jesus)-241(Christ.)-247(It)-240(formed)-241(the)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 128.825 0 Td [(locus)-240(standi)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 54.947 0 Td [(of)-240(the)-241(Church,)-242(and)-241(the)]TJ -183.772 -13.55 Td [(sole)-250(ground)-251(of)-250(its)-251(existence.)-251(If)-251(it)-250(was)-251(not)-250(an)-250(objective)-251(fact,)-250(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-331(testified)-331(to)-331(its)-331(occurrence)-331(must)-331(have)-331(been)-331(false)-331(witnesses,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(the)-250(whole)-250(of)-250(Christianity)-250(either)-250(a)-250(delusion)-250(or)-250(an)-250(imposture.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-396(follows,)-432(therefore,)-432(that)-395(this)-396(great)-396(miracle)-395(forms)-396(the)-395(very)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(key)-287(of)-286(the)-287(Christian)-286(position.)-360(Everything)-287(else)-286(is)-287(an)-287(outwork,)-295(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(important)-262(one)-262(it)-262(may)-262(be,)-265(but)-262(yet)-262(an)-262(outwork.)-286(If)-262(this)-261(position)-262(can)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-308(successfully)-308(assailed,)-322(the)-308(entire)-308(fortress)-308(of)-308(Christianity)-307(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(surrender)-382(at)-381(discretion.)-646(If,)-414(on)-382(the)-382(other)-381(hand,)-415(the)-382(most)-381(deter-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mined)-204(unbeliever)-205(could)-204(be)-205(convinced)-204(that)-204(there)-205(is)-204(good)-204(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evidence)-280(that)-280(Jesus)-281(Christ)-280(rose)-280(from)-280(the)-280(dead,)-288(he)-280(would)-280(find)-280(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difficulty)-294(in)-295(accepting)-294(the)-295(Gospels)-294(as)-295(historical)-294(documents,)-305(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(whole)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 45.448 0 Td [(\340)-250(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 36.37 0 Td [(objection)-250(against)-250(them)-250(would)-250(disappear.)]TJ -69.862 -16.003 Td [(Again:)-525(If)-388(the)-387(Resurrection)-388(of)-387(Christ)-388(is)-387(a)-388(fact,)-422(Christianity)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([370])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(must)-337(be)-336(a)-337(divine)-337(revelation.)-510(The)-336(perfect)-337(historical)-337(accuracy)-336(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-242(Gospels)-243(in)-242(minute)-243(details)-242(may)-243(be)-242(still)-243(open)-242(to)-242(question;)-245(deep)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thought)-209(and)-210(careful)-209(investigation)-210(may)-209(be)-210(necessary)-209(for)-209(ascertain-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ing)-223(the)-223(precise)-223(amount)-222(of)-223(truth)-223(communicated)-223(by)-223(that)-222(revelation;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(past)-414(ages)-413(may)-414(have)-413(erred)-414(in)-414(its)-413(interpretation,)-455(or)-413(in)-414(their)-413(de-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ductions)-436(from)-435(it;)-528(many)-436(questions)-435(as)-436(to)-435(the)-436(relation)-435(in)-435(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(revelation)-383(stands)-384(to)-383(science)-384(or)-383(history)-383(may)-384(be)-383(open)-383(ones)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 258.812 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(all)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1510 0 obj <<
/Length 4819      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(325)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(this)-346(is)-347(both)-346(conceivable)-346(and)-346(possible)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 164.938 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(but)-346(still,)-371(if)-346(Jesus)-346(Christ)]TJ -175.847 -13.549 Td [(rose)-248(from)-247(the)-248(dead,)-248(his)-247(entire)-248(manifestation,)-248(work,)-248(and)-247(teaching,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-250(be)-250(a)-250(communication)-250(from)-250(God)-250(to)-250(man.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(This)-243(then)-243(is)-243(my)-243(position.)-248(The)-243(real)-243(question)-243(stands)-243(within)-243(very)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(narrow)-320(limits.)-460(The)-320(miracle)-320(that)-320(requires)-320(strong)-320(historical)-320(proof)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-234(the)-234(Resurrection.)-245(The)-234(other)-234(supernatural)-234(occurrences)-234(recorded)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-289(the)-290(Gospels)-289(are)-290(important)-289(portions)-290(of)-289(the)-290(revelation)-289(made)-289(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ.)-443(They)-315(were)-314(important)-315(evidences)-314(to)-315(those)-314(who)-314(witnessed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them.)-530(But)-344(to)-343(us)-344(in)-343(these)-344(latter)-343(times)-344(the)-343(one)-344(great)-343(question)-343(is:)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Is)-439(the)-439(Resurrection)-440(capable)-439(of)-439(being)-439(established)-439(as)-439(an)-439(actual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrence?)-277(If)-259(it)-259(is,)-261(it)-259(will)-259(carry)-259(with)-259(it)-259(all)-259(the)-259(others.)-277(If)-259(it)-259(is)-258(not,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(proof)-250(of)-250(the)-250(others)-250(will)-250(fall)-250(along)-250(with)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(Let)-353(us)-353(examine)-353(the)-352(historical)-353(conditions)-353(of)-353(the)-353(case.)-558(Chris-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tianity)-228(differs)-228(from)-228(all)-229(other)-228(religions)-228(in)-228(professing)-228(not)-228(to)-228(consist)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-253(a)-253(mass)-253(of)-253(abstract)-253(dogmatic)-253(statements,)-254(but)-253(to)-253(be)-252(founded)-253(on,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-278(largely)-278(to)-278(consist)-278(of,)-284(a)-278(number)-278(of)-278(historical)-278(facts.)-334(There)-277(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unquestionably)-215(a)-215(considerable)-215(number)-215(of)-215(dogmatic)-215(statements)-215(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-345(pages)-345(of)-344(the)-345(New)-345(Testament;)-392(but)-345(they)-344(profess)-345(to)-345(grow)-344(out)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-317(the)-317(facts)-316(and)-317(to)-317(be)-317(explanations)-316(of)-317(them.)-450(The)-317(facts)-317(form,)-333(so)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-303(say,)-316(the)-303(essence)-303(of)-303(the)-302(religion.)-409(The)-303(Christianity)-303(of)-303(the)-302(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament)-328(is)-328(a)-328(growth)-328(which)-328(encircles)-328(itself)-328(around)-328(the)-327(person)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-306(its)-306(founder)-306(in)-306(a)-306(manner)-306(in)-306(which)-306(no)-306(other)-306(system)-306(of)-305(thought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-364(religion,)-784(which)-363(has)-364(existed)-364(among)-363(men,)-392(has)-364(ever)-364(done.)-590(If)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([371])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(we)-362(take)-361(the)-362(person)-362(of)-361(Jesus)-362(Christ)-362(out)-361(of)-362(the)-362(New)-361(Testament,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-336(whole)-336(system)-337(of)-336(its)-336(teaching)-336(crumbles)-337(into)-336(nothingness.)-508(If)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-379(remove)-378(the)-379(person)-378(of)-379(its)-378(founder)-379(from)-378(every)-379(other)-378(system)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-374(human)-373(thought)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 80.272 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(its)-374(great)-373(religions)-374(form)-374(no)-373(exception)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 165.209 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(the)]TJ -267.299 -13.549 Td [(system)-457(remains)-458(intact.)-872(This)-457(is)-458(a)-457(very)-458(striking)-457(peculiarity)-457(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity.)-250(In)-250(this)-250(respect)-250(it)-250(stands)-250(absolutely)-250(unique.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-372(as)-372(Christianity)-372(is)-372(founded)-373(on)-372(an)-372(historical)-372(person,)-402(who)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(lived)-397(in)-398(a)-397(particular)-397(age,)-435(so)-397(He)-397(is)-398(the)-397(founder)-397(of)-398(a)-397(great)-397(his-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(torical)-313(institution,)-329(the)-313(Christian)-314(Church.)-439(This)-313(institution)-313(differs)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(from)-280(every)-280(other)-281(society)-280(which)-280(has)-280(ever)-280(existed,)-288(in)-280(that)-280(both)-280(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(origination)-223(and)-223(its)-223(continued)-223(existence)-223(are)-223(inextricably)-223(bound)-222(up)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1514 0 obj <<
/Length 4664      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(326)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(with)-234(the)-235(person)-234(of)-235(its)-234(founder.)-245(Other)-235(societies)-234(could)-235(exist)-234(even)-234(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-301(could)-301(be)-301(proved)-300(that)-301(their)-301(reputed)-301(founders)-301(were)-301(creations)-300(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-264(imagination;)-270(but)-264(this)-263(would)-264(be)-264(fatal)-263(to)-264(the)-264(life)-263(of)-264(the)-263(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-369(Christ.)-608(If)-370(it)-369(could)-369(be)-370(proved)-369(that)-369(Jesus)-370(Christ)-369(was)-369(a)-369(myth,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(or)-394(nothing)-393(but)-394(a)-394(learned)-393(Rabbi,)-430(the)-393(Christian)-394(Church,)-429(mighty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(society)-307(as)-307(it)-308(is,)-321(would)-307(certainly)-307(collapse.)-422(The)-307(Christian)-307(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-325(Christ)-324(would)-325(be)-324(far)-325(more)-324(out)-325(of)-324(place)-325(than)-324(the)-325(play)-324(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Hamlet)-348(with)-347(the)-348(part)-347(of)-348(Hamlet)-347(omitted.)-543(In)-347(this)-348(respect)-347(it)-348(is)-347(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(institution)-203(unique)-204(among)-203(all)-203(those)-203(which)-203(the)-204(world)-203(has)-203(ever)-203(seen,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(whether)-250(political)-250(or)-250(religious.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(This)-350(great)-350(society,)-376(which)-350(now)-350(comprehends)-350(a)-350(vast)-350(majority)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(of)-242(the)-242(intelligence)-242(of)-242(mankind,)-244(and)-242(all)-242(the)-242(progressive)-242(nations)-242(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-278(world,)-284(had)-278(a)-277(definite)-278(beginning)-278(in)-277(historical)-278(times.)-333(It)-277(differs)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wholly)-248(from)-247(a)-248(philosophic)-247(sect,)-248(whose)-247(bond)-248(of)-247(union)-248(consists)-247(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-239(acceptance)-238(of)-239(a)-238(body)-239(of)-238(dogmatic)-239(teaching.)-246(It)-239(is)-238(and)-239(ever)-238(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-293(an)-293(organized)-293(society)-292(with)-293(specific)-293(purposes)-293(and)-293(aims,)-303(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-372(which)-372(has)-372(ever)-372(meditated)-372(schemes)-372(of)-372(conquest.)-616(It)-371(differs)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(widely)-255(from)-255(all)-256(political)-510(institutions,)-256(and)-256(yet)-255(ever)-255(since)-255(its)-255(birth)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([372])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(it)-250(has)-250(taken)-250(a)-250(place)-250(beside)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-265(origin)-265(of)-265(this)-265(society)-265(is)-265(not)-265(lost,)-269(like)-265(that)-265(of)-265(many)-265(others,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-379(the)-380(mists)-379(of)-379(the)-379(hoary)-379(past.)-638(History)-379(enables)-380(us)-379(to)-379(assign)-379(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(definite)-374(time)-374(when)-374(this)-374(society)-374(was)-374(certainly)-374(not)-374(in)-374(existence.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-304(no)-303(less)-304(definitely)-304(marks)-304(out)-303(a)-304(period)-304(when)-304(it)-303(not)-304(only)-304(was)-303(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence,)-358(but)-337(had)-337(entered)-337(on)-336(a)-337(condition)-337(of)-337(active)-336(growth.)-510(Its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(origin)-320(did)-320(not)-320(take)-320(place)-319(in)-320(the)-320(cloud-land)-320(of)-320(the)-320(mythic)-320(or)-319(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(semi-mythic)-205(period)-205(of)-205(history,)-214(but)-205(in)-205(the)-205(reign)-205(of)-205(Tiberius)-205(C\346sar,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-197(in)-197(a)-197(country)-197(occupied)-196(by)-197(Roman)-197(garrisons,)-208(and)-197(presided)-196(over)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-250(Roman)-250(governors.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-265(will)-264(be)-265(objected)-264(that)-265(our)-265(only)-264(accounts)-265(of)-264(the)-265(causes)-264(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(led)-284(to)-284(the)-284(organization)-283(of)-284(this)-284(society)-284(are)-284(writings)-284(composed)-283(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-245(own)-245(members.)-248(In)-245(this)-245(there)-245(is)-244(nothing)-245(peculiar;)-247(for)-245(until)-244(soci-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eties)-272(have)-273(grown)-272(sufficiently)-273(powerful)-272(to)-272(attract)-273(the)-272(attention)-272(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-246(world)-245(outside)-246(them,)-246(there)-246(can)-245(be)-246(no)-246(other)-245(source)-246(of)-245(informa-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion.)-249(Still)-248(the)-247(fact)-248(can)-248(be)-247(ascertained)-248(on)-247(the)-248(most)-247(unquestionable)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1518 0 obj <<
/Length 4480      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(327)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(authority,)-272(that)-268(at)-268(a)-268(certain)-268(date)-267(this)-268(society)-268(was)-268(not)-268(in)-267(existence,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-290(that)-290(within)-291(a)-290(certain)-290(number)-290(of)-291(years)-290(afterwards,)-300(it)-290(was)-290(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-236(in)-236(existence,)-238(but)-236(rapidly)-236(increasing;)-240(and)-236(that)-236(it)-236(originated)-235(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-250(Christ,)-250(who)-250(was)-250(put)-250(to)-250(death)-250(by)-250(the)-250(Roman)-250(government.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(This)-191(society,)-203(therefore,)-203(came)-192(into)-191(existence)-191(at)-192(a)-191(definite)-191(period)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(of)-251(time.)-251(Its)-250(early)-251(writers)-250(give)-251(us)-250(an)-251(account)-250(of)-251(how)-250(it)-250(originated.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(They)-325(affirm)-326(that)-325(its)-326(founder)-325(was)-325(Jesus)-326(Christ;)-363(and)-325(that,)-344(having)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-251(interrupted)-250(by)-251(His)-251(death,)-251(it)-250(was)-251(called)-250(into)-251(a)-251(new)-250(existence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-407(His)-407(resurrection.)-721(To)-407(this)-407(great)-407(event)-407(they)-407(most)-406(positively)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-318(that)-318(the)-318(origin)-318(of)-318(the)-318(Church,)-335(as)-318(an)-318(institution,)-335(was)-318(due.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(To)-401(the)-402(belief)-401(in)-402(it)-401(as)-402(a)-401(fact,)-439(it)-402(has)-401(certainly)-402(owed)-401(its)-401(gradual)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(enlargement,)-408(until)-377(it)-753(has)-377(attained)-377(its)-376(present)-377(dimensions)-376(after)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([373])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(more)-308(than)-309(eighteen)-308(centuries)-309(of)-308(existence.)-426(To)-308(this)-309(belief)-308(is)-308(due)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-248(great)-248(moral)-248(power)-248(which)-248(it)-248(has)-249(exercised)-248(on)-248(mankind;)-248(and)-248(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-178(members)-179(could)-178(be)-179(persuaded)-178(that)-179(the)-178(belief)-179(in)-178(the)-178(Resurrection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-379(its)-380(founder)-379(was)-379(a)-380(mere)-379(delusion,)-412(great)-379(as)-379(this)-380(society)-379(is,)-411(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(would)-250(certainly)-250(perish.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(There)-283(are)-283(five)-283(facts)-282(connected)-283(with)-283(the)-283(origin)-283(of)-283(this)-282(society,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(which)-217(no)-218(one)-217(who)-218(believes)-217(in)-217(the)-218(possibility)-217(of)-218(historic)-217(truth)-217(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dispute.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(First:)-250(That)-250(at)-250(the)-250(year)-250(A.D.)-250(25,)-250(this)-250(society)-250(had)-250(no)-250(existence.)]TJ 0 -14.163 Td [(Secondly:)-216(That)-183(in)-183(A.D.)-183(40,)-196(it)-183(was)-183(in)-183(a)-183(state)-183(of)-183(vigorous)-182(growth.)]TJ 0 -14.163 Td [(Thirdly:)-250(That)-250(it)-250(was)-250(founded)-250(by)-250(Jesus)-250(Christ.)]TJ 0 -14.163 Td [(Fourthly:)-664(That)-458(His)-457(crucifixion)-457(by)-457(the)-457(Roman)-457(government)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(caused)-250(its)-250(temporary)-250(collapse.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(Fifthly:)-268(That)-259(an)-259(event)-260(of)-259(some)-259(kind,)-261(which)-259(took)-259(place)-259(shortly)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(after)-286(His)-286(death,)-295(imparted)-286(to)-286(it)-286(a)-286(new)-286(vitality,)-295(which)-286(it)-286(has)-286(never)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lost)-224(to)-225(the)-224(present)-225(hour,)-229(and)-225(which)-224(has)-224(caused)-225(it)-224(to)-225(exert)-224(a)-224(might-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ier)-396(influence)-395(on)-396(mankind)-395(than)-396(any)-395(other)-396(community,)-431(whether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(political)-250(or)-250(religious,)-250(that)-250(has)-250(ever)-250(existed.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(The)-322(problem,)-339(therefore,)-340(which)-322(history)-322(has)-321(to)-322(solve,)-340(is)-322(to)-321(ac-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(count)-306(for)-307(the)-306(renewed)-306(life,)-321(the)-306(marvellous)-307(progress,)-320(the)-306(intense)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(vitality)-394(of)-394(this)-394(society,)-430(and)-394(the)-394(mighty)-394(influence)-394(which)-394(it)-393(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exerted)-306(on)-306(the)-306(destinies)-305(of)-306(mankind;)-334(originating)-306(as)-306(it)-306(did)-306(in)-305(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1523 0 obj <<
/Length 4622      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(328)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(smallest)-269(possible)-268(beginnings,)-273(and)-269(in)-268(a)-269(manner)-268(differing)-269(from)-268(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-250(existing)-250(institutions.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(The)-404(Christian)-404(Church)-404(has)-404(propounded,)-442(from)-404(the)-404(first)-404(com-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(mencement)-261(of)-262(its)-261(renewed)-261(life,)-264(its)-261(own)-262(solution)-261(of)-261(this)-261(problem.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(It)-210(is:)-229(that)-210(its)-209(founder,)-218(after)-210(having)-209(been)-210(crucified,)-217(rose)-210(again)-209(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-395(dead.)-683(This)-395(account)-395(has)-394(this)-395(clear)-394(and)-395(obvious)-394(advantage,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-306(if)-306(it)-306(be)-306(true,)-640(it)-306(sufficiently)-306(accounts)-306(for)-306(all)-306(the)-306(phenomena)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([374])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(whose)-258(existence)-257(we)-258(have)-258(to)-258(solve.)-273(His)-257(resurrection)-258(was)-258(a)-257(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adequate)-401(to)-401(revive)-401(the)-401(society)-401(after)-401(its)-401(temporary)-401(collapse,)-438(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(impart)-240(to)-240(it)-240(its)-240(mighty)-240(moral)-240(and)-240(spiritual)-240(energy,)-242(and)-240(to)-239(impress)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-320(the)-320(original)-319(work)-320(and)-320(teaching)-320(of)-320(Jesus,)-337(a)-320(new)-320(and)-319(peculiar)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(aspect.)-241(In)-223(short,)-228(assuming)-223(the)-222(Resurrection)-223(to)-223(have)-223(been)-222(a)-223(fact,)-228(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assigns)-229(a)-228(cause)-229(adequate)-229(to)-228(account)-229(for)-229(all)-228(the)-229(phenomena)-228(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-397(been)-396(presented)-397(by)-397(the)-396(Church.)-690(Here)-397(then)-396(we)-397(have)-396(firm)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ground)-246(on)-245(which)-246(to)-245(take)-246(our)-246(stand;)-247(viz.,)-246(the)-246(belief)-245(of)-246(this)-245(society)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-349(to)-350(its)-349(origin,)-374(capable)-349(of)-349(being)-350(traced)-349(historically)-349(to)-349(the)-349(first)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hour)-219(of)-219(its)-219(renewed)-219(life,)-226(and)-219(which)-219(also,)-225(if)-219(true,)-225(affords)-219(a)-219(rational)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(account)-250(of)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(But)-278(further;)-293(besides)-279(this)-278(account)-279(which)-278(the)-279(Church)-278(has)-278(given)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-281(its)-282(own)-281(origin,)-289(there)-281(is)-282(no)-281(rival)-281(account)-282(of)-281(it)-281(in)-282(existence.)-343(As)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(far)-282(as)-283(historical)-282(documents)-283(are)-282(concerned,)-291(there)-282(is)-283(no)-282(other.)-347(All)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(others)-250(are)-250(founded)-250(on)-250(conjecture.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(Our)-364(opponents,)-392(however,)-392(affirm)-364(that)-364(the)-364(alleged)-364(fact)-363(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-430(Church)-430(asserts)-430(to)-430(have)-430(been)-430(the)-430(cause)-430(of)-430(its)-430(existence)-429(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incredible,)-294(because)-285(all)-285(miracles)-285(are)-285(impossible.)-356(Then,)-293(leaving)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 275.176 0 Td [(\340)]TJ -275.176 -13.549 Td [(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 29.289 0 Td [(grounds,)-376(they)-351(also)-351(affirm)-351(that)-350(the)-351(evidence)-351(to)-351(prove)-351(the)]TJ -29.289 -13.55 Td [(Resurrection)-229(to)-228(have)-229(been)-228(an)-229(historical)-228(fact)-229(is)-228(insufficient)-229(for)-228(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purpose.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(The)-331(Church,)-352(however,)-352(is)-331(clearly)-331(in)-332(possession)-331(of)-331(a)-331(vantage-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ground,)-416(from)-382(which)-383(it)-382(is)-383(not)-382(easy)-383(to)-382(dislodge)-383(her.)-647(The)-382(cause)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(she)-250(alleges)-250(is)-250(adequate)-250(to)-250(account)-250(for)-250(all)-250(the)-250(phenomena.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(The)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 19.616 0 Td [(onus)-243(probandi)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 65.916 0 Td [(therefore)-243(clearly)-243(rests)-244(on)-243(the)-243(opponents)-243(of)]TJ -97.488 -13.55 Td [(Christianity.)-341(If)-280(they)-281(deny)-280(the)-280(truth)-281(of)-280(the)-280(fact)-281(which)-280(the)-280(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-262(ever)-262(handed)-262(down)-262(as)-263(the)-262(true)-262(account)-262(of)-262(her)-262(origin,)-265(they)-262(are)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1527 0 obj <<
/Length 4756      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(329)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(bound)-265(not)-266(only)-265(to)-265(show)-266(that)-265(it)-265(is)-266(devoid)-265(of)-265(historical)-265(attestation,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-294(to)-293(propound)-294(a)-293(theory)-294(which)-293(will)-293(adequately)-294(account)-293(for)-587(all)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([375])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(the)-306(facts)-306(to)-306(which)-306(history)-305(testifies.)-418(It)-306(is)-306(clear)-306(that)-306(nothing)-305(short)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-346(this)-347(is)-346(required)-346(of)-347(them)-346(as)-346(philosophical)-347(historians.)-538(Certain)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(facts)-446(are)-445(plain)-446(and)-446(undeniable.)-837(A)-446(society,)-494(of)-446(a)-446(very)-445(special)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character,)-232(sprang)-228(into)-227(existence)-228(at)-228(a)-227(definite)-228(point)-228(of)-227(history,)-232(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-295(exerted)-295(a)-295(mightier)-296(influence)-295(than)-295(any)-295(other)-295(on)-295(the)-295(destinies)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-355(man.)-565(If)-355(therefore)-355(they)-355(reject)-355(the)-355(account)-355(which)-355(the)-354(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(herself)-235(gives,)-238(they)-236(are)-235(bound)-235(to)-235(supply)-236(a)-235(rational)-235(account)-235(of)-235(how)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-359(great)-359(society)-358(came)-359(into)-359(being;)-413(how)-359(the)-359(phenomena)-358(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(constitute)-319(its)-319(history)-320(have)-319(been)-319(brought)-319(about;)-354(and)-319(what)-319(it)-319(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-183(imparted)-183(to)-183(it)-183(its)-183(vitality)-183(and)-183(power.)-228(We)-183(are)-183(in)-182(the)-183(presence)-183(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-226(greatest)-225(institution)-226(with)-225(which)-226(history)-225(is)-226(acquainted,)-230(founded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-375(it)-376(is)-375(on)-376(the)-375(greatest)-375(ideal)-376(conception)-375(\050if)-375(it)-376(is)-375(not)-375(historical\051)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-352(the)-351(human)-352(mind)-351(has)-352(ever)-351(succeeded)-351(in)-352(inventing.)-554(Both)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-362(came)-361(into)-362(existence,)-389(not)-362(in)-361(pre-historic)-362(times,)-389(but)-362(in)-361(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(midst)-359(of)-359(a)-359(period)-358(of)-359(contemporaneous)-359(history.)-577(Respecting)-358(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(times,)-429(the)-394(modes)-394(of)-393(thought,)-430(and)-393(the)-394(general)-393(character)-394(of)-393(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(period,)-317(we)-304(have)-303(extensive)-304(historical)-303(data.)-411(The)-304(religious,)-316(moral,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-300(philosophical)-301(opinions,)-312(and)-301(the)-300(general)-300(line)-300(of)-301(thought,)-312(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(well)-427(known.)-783(The)-427(various)-427(forces)-428(which)-427(were)-428(then)-427(in)-427(activity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-336(are)-337(able)-336(to)-336(appreciate.)-509(With)-337(all)-336(these)-336(data)-337(before)-336(him,)-358(it)-336(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incumbent)-328(on)-327(the)-328(philosophical)-327(historian)-328(to)-328(give)-327(us)-328(an)-327(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-251(the)-250(moral)-250(and)-251(religious)-250(forces)-251(in)-250(activity)-251(at)-250(this)-251(period,)-250(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(were)-362(capable)-362(of)-363(creating)-362(the)-362(Christian)-362(Church,)-390(and)-362(generating)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-348(conception)-347(of)-348(the)-347(ideal)-348(Christ.)-543(If)-347(it)-348(is)-348(alleged)-347(that)-348(after)-347(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(utmost)-334(investigation)-333(it)-334(is)-333(impossible)-333(to)-334(account)-333(for)-334(their)-333(origin)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-339(the)-339(action)-339(of)-339(any)-339(known)-339(moral)-339(or)-339(spiritual)-339(forces)-339(acting)-338(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-257(human)-257(mind,)-259(this)-257(would)-258(be)-257(at)-257(once)-257(to)-257(confess)-257(that)-257(the)-257(origin)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-313(Christianity)-313(and)-312(the)-313(Church)-313(is)-313(entirely)-312(abnormal,)-329(or)-313(in)-312(other)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(words,)-250(that)-250(it)-250(is)-250(a)-250(moral)-250(and)-250(spiritual)-250(miracle.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([376])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -18.458 Td [(To)-304(do)-303(unbelievers)-304(justice,)-317(they)-303(have)-304(not)-304(been)-303(slow)-304(to)-303(recog-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(nize)-395(the)-394(fact)-395(that)-395(if)-394(they)-395(reject)-395(the)-394(account)-395(which)-395(the)-394(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-305(given)-305(of)-305(its)-305(origin,)-318(they)-305(are)-305(bound)-305(to)-305(give)-305(us)-305(a)-305(rational)-304(one)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1391 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 984
/Length 9176      
>>
stream
1390 0 1387 59 1393 125 1395 244 1392 303 1397 369 1399 488 1396 546 1401 612 1403 731
1400 790 1405 868 1407 987 1408 1043 1404 1101 1410 1167 1413 1208 1415 1299 1411 1418 1417 1476
1414 1535 1419 1601 1421 1720 1418 1777 1423 1867 1425 1986 1422 2045 1427 2123 1429 2242 1426 2300
1431 2378 1433 2497 1430 2556 1435 2622 1437 2741 1434 2800 1440 2878 1442 2997 1443 3056 1439 3113
1445 3191 1447 3310 1444 3368 1449 3446 1451 3565 1448 3623 1453 3701 1455 3820 1452 3879 1457 3957
1459 4076 1456 4135 1461 4201 1463 4320 1460 4379 1466 4445 1468 4564 1465 4623 1470 4727 1472 4846
1473 4904 1469 4963 1475 5041 1477 5160 1474 5219 1479 5285 1481 5404 1478 5463 1483 5529 1485 5648
1482 5707 1487 5785 1489 5904 1486 5963 1492 6029 1494 6148 1495 6206 1491 6264 1496 6330 1499 6371
1501 6495 1497 6614 1503 6672 1500 6730 1505 6808 1507 6927 1504 6986 1509 7076 1511 7195 1508 7253
1513 7331 1515 7450 1512 7508 1517 7574 1519 7693 1516 7751 1522 7817 1524 7936 1521 7995 1526 8073
% 1390 0 obj
<<
/D [1388 0 R /XYZ 170.881 147.437 null]
>>
% 1387 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1393 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1394 0 R
/Resources 1392 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1381 0 R
>>
% 1395 0 obj
<<
/D [1393 0 R /XYZ 334.406 244.736 null]
>>
% 1392 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1397 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1398 0 R
/Resources 1396 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1381 0 R
>>
% 1399 0 obj
<<
/D [1397 0 R /XYZ 46.771 312.482 null]
>>
% 1396 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1401 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1402 0 R
/Resources 1400 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1381 0 R
>>
% 1403 0 obj
<<
/D [1401 0 R /XYZ 248.282 382.683 null]
>>
% 1400 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1405 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1406 0 R
/Resources 1404 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1409 0 R
>>
% 1407 0 obj
<<
/D [1405 0 R /XYZ 46.771 461.6 null]
>>
% 1408 0 obj
<<
/D [1405 0 R /XYZ 46.771 353.032 null]
>>
% 1404 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1410 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index17) >>
% 1413 0 obj
(Chapter XVI. General Objections To Miracles As Credentials Of A Revelation.)
% 1415 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1416 0 R
/Resources 1414 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1409 0 R
>>
% 1411 0 obj
<<
/D [1415 0 R /XYZ 93.543 529.134 null]
>>
% 1417 0 obj
<<
/D [1415 0 R /XYZ 146.882 121.236 null]
>>
% 1414 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1419 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1420 0 R
/Resources 1418 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1409 0 R
>>
% 1421 0 obj
<<
/D [1419 0 R /XYZ 82.986 176.99 null]
>>
% 1418 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1423 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1424 0 R
/Resources 1422 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1409 0 R
>>
% 1425 0 obj
<<
/D [1423 0 R /XYZ 275.627 242.282 null]
>>
% 1422 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1427 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1428 0 R
/Resources 1426 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1409 0 R
>>
% 1429 0 obj
<<
/D [1427 0 R /XYZ 289.32 314.937 null]
>>
% 1426 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1431 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1432 0 R
/Resources 1430 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1409 0 R
>>
% 1433 0 obj
<<
/D [1431 0 R /XYZ 198.033 367.497 null]
>>
% 1430 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1435 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1436 0 R
/Resources 1434 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1438 0 R
>>
% 1437 0 obj
<<
/D [1435 0 R /XYZ 136.128 420.876 null]
>>
% 1434 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1440 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1441 0 R
/Resources 1439 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1438 0 R
>>
% 1442 0 obj
<<
/D [1440 0 R /XYZ 324.663 491.077 null]
>>
% 1443 0 obj
<<
/D [1440 0 R /XYZ 286.497 93.24 null]
>>
% 1439 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1445 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1446 0 R
/Resources 1444 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1438 0 R
>>
% 1447 0 obj
<<
/D [1445 0 R /XYZ 57.954 147.437 null]
>>
% 1444 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1449 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1450 0 R
/Resources 1448 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1438 0 R
>>
% 1451 0 obj
<<
/D [1449 0 R /XYZ 226.22 202.616 null]
>>
% 1448 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1453 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1454 0 R
/Resources 1452 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1438 0 R
>>
% 1455 0 obj
<<
/D [1453 0 R /XYZ 178.716 271.835 null]
>>
% 1452 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1457 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1458 0 R
/Resources 1456 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1438 0 R
>>
% 1459 0 obj
<<
/D [1457 0 R /XYZ 342.879 340.399 null]
>>
% 1456 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1461 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1462 0 R
/Resources 1460 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1464 0 R
>>
% 1463 0 obj
<<
/D [1461 0 R /XYZ 315.149 396.232 null]
>>
% 1460 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1466 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1467 0 R
/Resources 1465 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1464 0 R
>>
% 1468 0 obj
<<
/D [1466 0 R /XYZ 301.412 463.978 null]
>>
% 1465 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F38 247 0 R /F37 246 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1470 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1471 0 R
/Resources 1469 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1464 0 R
>>
% 1472 0 obj
<<
/D [1470 0 R /XYZ 93.315 518.175 null]
>>
% 1473 0 obj
<<
/D [1470 0 R /XYZ 271.862 120.339 null]
>>
% 1469 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1475 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1476 0 R
/Resources 1474 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1464 0 R
>>
% 1477 0 obj
<<
/D [1475 0 R /XYZ 230.879 189.721 null]
>>
% 1474 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1479 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1480 0 R
/Resources 1478 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1464 0 R
>>
% 1481 0 obj
<<
/D [1479 0 R /XYZ 313.461 255.831 null]
>>
% 1478 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1483 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1484 0 R
/Resources 1482 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1464 0 R
>>
% 1485 0 obj
<<
/D [1483 0 R /XYZ 211.074 312.482 null]
>>
% 1482 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1487 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1488 0 R
/Resources 1486 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1490 0 R
>>
% 1489 0 obj
<<
/D [1487 0 R /XYZ 272.882 369.134 null]
>>
% 1486 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1492 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1493 0 R
/Resources 1491 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1490 0 R
>>
% 1494 0 obj
<<
/D [1492 0 R /XYZ 93.543 423.331 null]
>>
% 1495 0 obj
<<
/D [1492 0 R /XYZ 93.543 124.976 null]
>>
% 1491 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1496 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index18) >>
% 1499 0 obj
(Chapter XVII. The Historical Evidence On Which The Great Facts Of Christianity Rest--General Considerations.)
% 1501 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1502 0 R
/Resources 1500 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1490 0 R
>>
% 1497 0 obj
<<
/D [1501 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 1503 0 obj
<<
/D [1501 0 R /XYZ 106.422 79.691 null]
>>
% 1500 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1505 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1506 0 R
/Resources 1504 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1490 0 R
>>
% 1507 0 obj
<<
/D [1505 0 R /XYZ 374.173 160.986 null]
>>
% 1504 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1509 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1510 0 R
/Resources 1508 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1490 0 R
>>
% 1511 0 obj
<<
/D [1509 0 R /XYZ 100.768 216.82 null]
>>
% 1508 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1513 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1514 0 R
/Resources 1512 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1490 0 R
>>
% 1515 0 obj
<<
/D [1513 0 R /XYZ 202.25 286.202 null]
>>
% 1512 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1517 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1518 0 R
/Resources 1516 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1520 0 R
>>
% 1519 0 obj
<<
/D [1517 0 R /XYZ 142.167 368.52 null]
>>
% 1516 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1522 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1523 0 R
/Resources 1521 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1520 0 R
>>
% 1524 0 obj
<<
/D [1522 0 R /XYZ 169.473 435.898 null]
>>
% 1521 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1526 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1527 0 R
/Resources 1525 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1520 0 R
>>
endstream
endobj
1533 0 obj <<
/Length 4455      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(330)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(of)-386(how)-385(Christianity)-386(came)-386(into)-386(existence.)-657(Accordingly,)-419(theory)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(after)-237(theory)-238(has)-237(been)-238(propounded)-237(on)-238(this)-237(subject.)-246(No)-237(intellectual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exertion)-339(has)-340(been)-339(spared)-339(to)-340(point)-339(out)-339(how)-340(Christianity)-339(and)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church)-213(have)-213(succeeded)-213(in)-213(getting)-213(into)-213(existence,)-220(and)-213(in)-213(effecting)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(their)-222(religious)-221(and)-222(moral)-222(conquests,)-227(by)-222(forces)-221(purely)-222(human,)-227(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-250(the)-250(aid)-250(of)-250(any)-250(supernatural)-250(intervention.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(One)-262(thing)-261(respecting)-262(these)-262(theories)-262(is)-261(worthy)-262(of)-262(particular)-261(at-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tention.)-247(No)-240(unbeliever)-239(has)-240(as)-240(yet)-240(been)-240(able)-240(to)-240(suggest)-240(one)-239(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(has)-309(succeeded)-308(in)-309(commanding,)-324(I)-308(will)-309(not)-309(say)-308(the)-309(universal,)-323(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-332(the)-331(general)-332(assent)-331(of)-332(the)-332(unbelieving)-331(world.)-495(Theory)-331(after)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(theory)-256(has)-256(been)-256(propounded)-256(and)-256(abandoned.)-268(It)-256(is)-256(therefore)-255(clear)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-228(the)-229(difficulty)-228(of)-228(accounting)-228(for)-228(the)-229(origin)-228(of)-228(Christianity)-228(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-245(Church)-246(through)-245(the)-245(action)-245(of)-245(the)-246(ordinary)-245(forces)-245(that)-245(operate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-328(the)-328(human)-328(mind,)-348(is)-327(extreme.)-484(There)-328(is)-328(no)-328(analogous)-328(case)-328(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-364(whole)-364(history)-364(of)-364(man.)-592(Let)-364(me)-364(briefly)-364(enumerate)-364(the)-364(chief)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(principles)-258(which)-258(have)-258(been)-258(invoked)-258(to)-258(aid)-258(in)-258(the)-258(solution)-258(of)-257(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(problem.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(First,)-302(it)-291(has)-291(been)-292(attempted)-291(to)-292(get)-291(rid)-291(of)-292(the)-291(supernatural)-291(ele-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ments)-217(contained)-216(in)-217(the)-216(Gospels)-217(by)-217(representing)-216(them)-217(as)-216(distorted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(representations)-415(of)-414(real)-415(facts.)-744(This)-415(has)-414(been)-415(justly)-414(abandoned)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-501(childish.)-1002(Then)-500(came)-501(the)-501(mythic)-500(and)-501(legendary)-500(theories.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(These,)-330(having)-314(been)-314(found)-314(inadequate,)-330(have)-314(been)-314(supplemented)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-241(various)-241(theories)-241(of)-241(development)-241(of)-241(ideas;)-244(and)-241(the)-240(supposition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-295(a)-295(violent)-295(party)-294(spirit)-295(existing)-295(in)-295(the)-295(Church,)-306(which)-295(under)-294(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(influence)-175(of)-174(a)-175(spirit)-174(of)-175(accommodation)-174(produced)-175(various)-174(compro-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mises;)-317(a)-294(mass)-294(of)-295(varied)-294(and)-294(often)-295(contending)-294(opinions)-294(seething)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-220(the)-440(bosom)-219(of)-220(a)-220(society)-220(continually)-220(threatened)-220(with)-219(disruption,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([377])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(until)-318(they)-318(somehow)-319(succeeded)-318(in)-318(welding)-318(themselves)-318(together;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enthusiasm,)-403(fanaticism,)-403(boundless)-373(credulity,)-403(aided)-372(by)-373(a)-372(prodi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gious)-335(power)-335(of)-335(mythic)-335(and)-335(legendary)-335(invention,)-356(and)-335(whenever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occasion)-235(so)-235(required,)-238(the)-235(presence)-235(of)-235(a)-235(moral)-235(atmosphere,)-237(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-317(great)-317(emergencies)-316(did)-317(not)-317(shrink)-317(from)-317(deliberate)-316(imposture.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(All)-377(these,)-408(in)-376(ever)-377(varying)-377(degrees)-376(and)-377(proportions,)-408(have)-376(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pressed)-278(into)-278(the)-277(service)-278(of)-278(creating)-278(the)-277(Church,)-285(the)-278(ideal)-277(Christ,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1537 0 obj <<
/Length 4649      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(331)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(and)-341(the)-340(Christianity)-341(of)-340(the)-341(New)-340(Testament.)-522(It)-340(is)-341(impossible)-340(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-356(work)-357(like)-356(the)-357(present)-356(to)-356(examine)-357(these)-356(various)-356(theories,)-383(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(show)-268(their)-268(inadequacy)-269(as)-268(philosophical)-268(explanations)-268(of)-268(the)-268(fact.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-214(I)-215(have)-214(already)-214(done)-214(in)-215(a)-214(former)-214(work,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 183.797 3.958 Td [(5)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.899 -3.958 Td [(to)-214(which)-214(I)-215(must)-214(refer)]TJ -190.696 -13.55 Td [(the)-318(reader)-318(for)-317(their)-318(refutation.)-454(A)-317(few)-318(observations)-318(only)-318(will)-317(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary)-250(in)-250(this)-250(place.)]TJ 11.956 -18.585 Td [(First:)-356(The)-304(positions)-303(taken)-303(by)-303(unbelievers)-304(are)-303(theories,)-316(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(rest)-294(on)-295(the)-294(smallest)-295(basis)-294(of)-295(historical)-294(evidence.)-384(I)-294(readily)-294(admit)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-443(where)-444(there)-443(is)-443(a)-443(known)-444(fact,)-491(but)-444(the)-443(recollection)-443(of)-443(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-331(which)-331(would)-331(give)-332(an)-331(account)-331(of)-331(its)-331(origin)-331(has)-331(perished,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-276(a)-276(theory)-276(can)-276(be)-276(propounded)-276(which)-276(fully)-276(accounts)-276(for)-276(the)-276(fact,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-321(it)-321(has)-321(a)-321(right)-321(to)-321(take)-321(its)-321(place)-321(as)-321(an)-321(historical)-321(event)-320(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(rests)-237(on)-238(evidence)-237(of)-238(the)-237(highest)-238(probability.)-246(An)-237(example)-237(derived)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-457(the)-458(mode)-457(in)-457(which)-457(the)-458(study)-457(of)-457(comparative)-457(philology)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discloses)-341(the)-340(history)-341(of)-341(the)-340(past)-341(will)-340(explain)-341(my)-341(meaning.)-521(We)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-315(before)-314(us)-315(the)-315(facts)-315(of)-314(language.)-445(The)-314(history)-315(of)-315(those)-314(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(formerly)-347(used)-347(it)-347(has)-347(perished;)-396(the)-347(accounts)-347(of)-347(their)-347(migrations)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-304(nowhere)-304(been)-304(preserved.)-411(But)-304(certain)-304(facts)-304(of)-303(comparative)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(philology)-348(justify)-347(the)-348(assumption)-348(that)-347(certain)-348(primitive)-348(races)-347(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(men)-247(must)-247(have)-247(migrated)-247(in)-247(particular)-247(directions.)-249(These)-247(assumed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(migrations)-220(are)-220(really)-220(a)-219(theory,)-226(but)-220(one)-220(which)-220(is)-220(exactly)-220(adequate)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([378])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(to)-234(account)-233(for)-234(the)-233(facts)-234(which)-233(language)-234(unquestionably)-233(presents.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Thus)-390(the)-389(facts)-390(of)-390(the)-390(Indo-Germanic)-389(languages)-390(justify)-390(the)-389(as-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sumption)-226(that)-225(in)-226(the)-225(pre-historic)-226(ages,)-230(migrations)-226(westward)-225(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-310(taken)-309(place,)-324(of)-310(which)-309(history)-310(contains)-309(no)-310(record.)-428(Still)-309(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(theory)-411(affords)-410(so)-411(perfect)-411(an)-411(explanation)-410(of)-411(the)-411(facts,)-451(that)-410(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrence)-390(of)-389(the)-390(migrations)-390(is)-389(as)-390(certain)-390(as)-389(if)-390(they)-390(had)-389(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recorded)-253(by)-254(contemporaneous)-253(writers.)-261(On)-253(similar)-254(grounds)-253(it)-253(has)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-265(inferred)-264(with)-265(a)-264(degree)-265(of)-264(probability)-265(so)-264(high)-265(as)-264(to)-265(be)-264(equal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-320(certainty,)-336(that)-320(a)-319(language)-320(earlier)-319(than)-320(the)-319(Sanskrit,)-337(and)-319(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-316(both)-315(it)-316(and)-315(the)-316(Indo-Germanic)-316(family)-315(of)-316(languages)-315(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-312(derived,)-329(was)-312(spoken)-312(by)-313(a)-312(previous)-313(race.)-437(Investigations)-312(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
ET
q
1 0 0 1 46.771 76.847 cm
[]0 d 0 J 0.398 w 0 0 m 112.25 0 l S
Q
BT
/F16 5.9776 Tf 52.998 69.951 Td [(5)]TJ/F20 8.9664 Tf 5.729 -3.809 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 8.9664 Tf 3.981 0 Td [(The)-250(Jesus)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Evangelists.)]TJ/F20 8.9664 Tf 103.848 0 Td [(\035)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1541 0 obj <<
/Length 4629      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(332)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(this)-250(kind)-250(are)-250(largely)-250(adding)-250(to)-250(our)-250(historical)-250(knowledge.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Let)-384(us)-383(observe)-384(the)-384(basis)-384(on)-383(which)-384(such)-384(arguments)-383(rest.)-651(In)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(all)-384(these)-384(cases)-385(we)-384(have)-384(before)-384(us)-384(not)-384(mere)-385(conjectures,)-417(but)-384(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinct)-341(and)-341(positive)-341(fact,)-364(or)-341(set)-342(of)-341(facts.)-523(The)-341(connecting)-341(links)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-396(missing.)-690(By)-396(the)-396(aid)-397(of)-396(conjecture)-396(we)-397(propound)-396(a)-396(theory;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-301(in)-300(other)-301(words,)-313(we)-301(suppose)-300(a)-301(set)-300(of)-301(events)-300(to)-301(have)-300(occurred,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which,)-232(if)-228(they)-228(really)-227(happened,)-233(would)-227(be)-228(adequate)-228(to)-228(account)-227(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-290(facts)-291(in)-290(question.)-371(When)-290(they)-291(thus)-290(account)-290(for)-291(them,)-300(and)-290(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-304(alone,)-317(and)-303(no)-304(other)-304(conjectural)-303(occurrence)-304(will)-304(do)-303(so,)-317(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assumed)-366(fact)-366(is)-366(fully)-367(entitled)-366(to)-366(take)-366(its)-366(place)-366(in)-366(history)-366(as)-366(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(event)-278(which)-277(has)-278(actually)-278(happened.)-333(The)-278(reason)-278(of)-277(this)-278(is,)-285(that)-277(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(can)-250(stand)-250(the)-250(test)-250(of)-250(historical)-250(verification.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(A)-310(problem)-310(similar)-310(to)-310(that)-310(above)-310(referred)-310(to)-310(is)-310(the)-310(one)-310(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(those)-423(who)-423(deny)-423(the)-422(historical)-423(truth)-423(of)-423(the)-423(Gospels)-423(are)-422(called)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(upon)-281(to)-281(solve.)-342(We)-281(are)-281(in)-280(the)-281(presence)-281(of)-281(certain)-280(unquestionable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-242(facts,)-244(viz.,)-243(the)-242(five)-243(above)-242(referred)-242(to,)-243(and)-242(many)-242(others.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-445(denial)-445(of)-445(the)-445(truth)-445(of)-445(the)-445(Christian)-445(account)-445(leaves)-445(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-432(the)-432(connecting)-433(link)-432(which)-432(once)-432(united)-433(them.)-796(What)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([379])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(was)-395(that)-395(link?)-684(It)-395(can)-394(only)-395(be)-395(supplied)-395(by)-394(conjecture.)-685(But)-394(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(enable)-309(such)-309(a)-309(conjectural)-309(fact)-309(or)-309(facts)-309(to)-309(take)-309(rank)-309(as)-308(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events,)-381(they)-354(must)-355(be)-354(adequate)-355(to)-355(account)-354(for)-355(the)-354(facts,)-381(and)-354(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(true)-355(to)-354(human)-355(nature,)-381(and)-354(to)-355(the)-355(circumstances)-354(of)-355(the)-355(case;)-406(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-286(words,)-295(they)-286(must)-285(be)-286(capable)-286(of)-286(enduring)-286(a)-286(rigid)-285(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(verification.)-727(Theories)-410(which)-409(cannot)-409(endure)-409(this)-409(are)-409(no)-409(better)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(than)-340(ropes)-341(of)-340(sand.)-521(This)-340(is)-341(the)-340(character)-340(of)-341(the)-340(theories)-340(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-223(been)-223(propounded)-223(to)-223(account)-223(for)-223(the)-223(Christianity)-223(of)-223(the)-222(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Let)-402(me)-402(illustrate)-402(this)-402(by)-402(one)-402(of)-402(the)-402(favourite)-402(theories)-402(used)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(by)-353(unbelievers)-353(for)-353(this)-353(purpose.)-560(We)-353(are)-353(told)-353(that)-353(a)-353(number)-353(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(extremely)-209(hostile)-209(factions)-209(divided)-209(the)-209(primitive)-209(Church.)-236(Of)-209(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-345(followers)-345(of)-344(James,)-369(Peter,)-369(and)-344(Paul)-345(may)-345(be)-345(taken)-345(as)-344(fairly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(representative.)-565(These)-355(were)-354(in)-355(a)-355(state)-355(of)-355(great)-355(hostility)-355(to)-354(each)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(other,)-288(and)-281(went)-281(on)-280(gradually)-281(elaborating)-281(a)-280(Christianity)-281(that)-280(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-315(conformity)-314(with)-315(their)-314(own)-314(views)-315(and)-314(tastes.)-444(After)-314(a)-315(while)-314(it)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1545 0 obj <<
/Length 4507      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(333)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(occurred)-234(to)-234(these)-234(hostile)-234(parties)-234(that)-234(it)-234(would)-234(be)-234(advantageous)-233(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(compromise)-267(their)-267(differences.)-301(An)-267(influential)-267(person,)-271(such)-267(as)-267(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-230(suppose)-229(the)-230(author)-230(of)-230(the)-229(Acts)-230(of)-230(the)-229(Apostles)-230(to)-230(have)-229(been,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(composed)-296(a)-295(history,)-307(for)-296(the)-295(purpose)-296(of)-295(making)-296(matters)-295(smooth,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-278(to)-279(afford)-278(a)-278(common)-279(ground)-278(of)-278(union)-279(among)-278(the)-278(contending)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(factions.)-495(This)-332(process)-331(was)-332(repeated)-332(as)-331(often)-332(as)-332(was)-331(necessary;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-281(in)-281(good)-282(time,)-289(by)-281(the)-281(aid)-281(of)-282(myth)-281(and)-281(legend,)-289(and)-281(the)-281(whole)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-341(the)-341(needful)-341(apparatus,)-364(appeared)-341(the)-341(Christianity)-341(of)-340(the)-341(New)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Testament,)-273(and)-269(the)-269(Church)-269(was)-268(consolidated)-269(out)-269(of)-269(these)-268(varied)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(elements.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(Such)-339(theories)-340(grievously)-339(offend)-339(against)-340(the)-339(logic)-339(of)-340(history,)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(and)-320(are)-320(in)-321(direct)-320(variance)-320(with)-320(the)-320(facts)-320(of)-321(human)-320(life.)-460(We)-320(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(here)-433(in)-434(the)-433(midst)-434(of)-433(a)-434(whole)-433(mass)-433(of)-434(conjectural)-433(facts,)-479(each)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-334(which)-334(is)-334(imagined)-334(to)-334(account)-334(for)-334(the)-334(existence)-334(of)-334(the)-333(other;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-334(the)-334(whole)-668(of)-334(them)-334(taken)-334(together)-334(fail)-334(to)-334(give)-334(an)-333(adequate)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([380])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(solution)-458(of)-457(the)-458(phenomena)-458(before)-457(us.)-873(They)-458(are)-458(both)-457(untrue)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-395(human)-394(nature)-395(and)-395(unable)-394(to)-395(account)-395(for)-394(either)-395(the)-395(facts)-394(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity)-200(or)-200(the)-200(existence)-200(of)-200(the)-199(Church.)-234(I)-200(must)-200(content)-199(myself)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-433(selecting)-434(one)-433(of)-434(them)-433(for)-433(illustration.)-800(We)-434(are)-433(asked)-433(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believe)-235(that)-235(the)-235(Church)-236(was)-235(divided)-235(into)-235(a)-235(number)-235(of)-235(parties,)-238(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opposition)-349(between)-349(whom)-348(was)-349(violent;)-398(and)-349(that)-349(these)-348(effected)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-275(number)-274(of)-275(compromises,)-281(out)-274(of)-275(which)-274(was)-275(ultimately)-274(evolved)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-321(common)-321(Christianity.)-463(This)-321(result)-321(is)-321(in)-321(direct)-321(contradiction)-320(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-311(testimony)-311(of)-311(the)-310(religious)-311(history)-311(of)-311(man.)-433(Religious)-310(parties)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(do)-299(not)-298(effect)-299(compromises,)-311(but)-298(go)-299(on)-298(contending)-299(and)-298(widening)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-220(differences,)-225(until)-220(their)-219(enthusiasm)-220(wears)-219(out)-220(and)-219(they)-220(die)-219(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inanition.)-334(To)-278(this)-278(the)-278(history)-278(of)-278(all)-278(sects)-278(bears)-278(ample)-278(testimony,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-201(the)-201(greater)-200(the)-201(enthusiasm)-201(and)-200(not)-201(unfrequently)-201(the)-201(lesser)-200(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(grounds)-320(of)-320(difference,)-337(the)-320(greater)-319(the)-320(animosity.)-459(Compromises)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(between)-261(hostile)-260(sects,)-264(in)-260(the)-261(rare)-260(cases)-261(in)-261(which)-260(they)-261(have)-260(taken)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(place,)-345(have)-326(been)-326(brought)-326(about)-326(by)-326(means)-326(of)-326(external)-326(coercion.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-248(religious)-247(history)-248(of)-247(mankind)-248(present)1(s)-248(no)-247(example)-248(of)-247(furious)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(religious)-283(parties,)-292(while)-283(animated)-283(by)-283(a)-283(living)-283(enthusiasm,)-291(volun-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tarily)-171(coalescing)-172(on)-171(the)-172(general)-171(principle)-171(of)-172(compromise.)-223(Witness)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1550 0 obj <<
/Length 4404      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(334)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(the)-398(unsuccessful)-398(attempts)-397(at)-398(compromise)-398(between)-398(the)-397(Eastern)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-264(Western)-265(Churches,)-267(even)-265(when)-264(it)-264(was)-265(urged)-264(by)-264(the)-264(strongest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(external)-478(pressure.)-934(Witness)-478(the)-478(sects)-478(which)-478(grew)-478(out)-478(of)-477(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Reformation.)-609(Compromises)-370(have)-370(frequently)-370(originated)-369(among)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(politicians,)-333(but)-317(these)-317(have)-316(in)-317(vain)-317(tried)-316(their)-317(healing)-316(influences)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(among)-337(contending)-337(sects.)-512(Occasionally)-337(they)-337(have)-337(been)-337(brought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(about)-325(by)-325(the)-324(aid)-325(of)-325(pressure)-325(exerted)-325(by)-324(the)-325(temporal)-325(power,)-343(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-436(the)-437(Church)-436(of)-437(England.)-809(Nothing)-437(more)-436(strongly)-436(illustrates)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-302(difficulty)-303(with)-302(which)-302(compromise)-303(between)-302(religious)-302(parties)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(can)-292(be)-585(effected)-293(than)-292(the)-293(failure)-292(of)-293(the)-292(attempts)-293(to)-292(reconcile)-292(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([381])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(Church)-320(of)-320(England)-320(and)-320(the)-320(Methodists.)-460(The)-320(compromiser)-319(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will)-296(effect)-296(this)-296(union)-296(exists)-295(only)-296(in)-296(the)-296(hopes)-296(of)-296(the)-296(future.)-387(But)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-266(need)-267(not)-266(confine)-266(ourselves)-266(to)-267(the)-266(manifestations)-266(of)-266(sectarian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(spirit)-331(in)-330(connection)-331(with)-330(Christianity.)-492(The)-331(Mahometan)-330(Church)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-262(also)-263(divided)-262(by)-262(sectarian)-262(differences.)-287(Is)-263(there)-262(any)-262(tendency)-262(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(produce)-232(a)-232(common)-232(Mahometanism,)-235(erected)-232(on)-232(the)-232(basis)-232(of)-231(com-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(promise?)-464(Do)-321(Buddhism)-321(and)-321(Brahminism)-321(show)-321(any)-321(disposition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-303(compromise)-303(their)-303(differences)-303(by)-303(fusing)-303(them)-303(into)-303(a)-303(common)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Pantheism)-233(which)-232(shall)-233(suit)-233(both)-232(parties?)-245(The)-232(idea)-233(of)-233(producing)-232(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Christianity)-271(by)-272(a)-271(succession)-272(of)-271(happy)-272(compromises)-271(entered)-271(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-212(violently)-212(hostile)-212(parties)-212(in)-211(the)-212(early)-212(Church,)-220(is)-212(a)-212(dream)-211(which,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(however)-367(plausible)-367(it)-367(may)-367(have)-368(seemed)-367(in)-367(the)-367(closet,)-396(is)-367(rudely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dissipated)-212(the)-211(moment)-212(we)-212(come)-211(in)-212(contact)-212(with)-211(the)-212(stern)-211(realities)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(life.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-338(further:)-427(the)-338(wide)-339(separation)-338(of)-338(the)-339(early)-338(Churches)-338(from)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(each)-218(other;)-229(and,)-225(according)-218(to)-219(the)-218(opinions)-218(of)-219(those)-218(against)-218(whom)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-293(am)-293(reasoning,)-304(their)-293(want)-293(of)-293(a)-293(governing)-292(power)-293(acknowledged)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-411(all,)-450(must)-411(have)-410(rendered)-411(agreement)-410(on)-411(the)-410(basis)-411(of)-410(mutual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(compromise)-257(impossible.)-269(Compromises)-257(are)-257(the)-256(results)-257(of)-256(consid-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(erations)-346(of)-346(policy,)-370(and)-346(are)-346(unheard)-346(of)-346(among)-346(fanatics,)-370(such)-346(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(my)-331(opponents)-332(assert)-331(the)-331(early)-331(followers)-331(of)-332(Jesus)-331(to)-331(have)-331(been.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(But)-280(what)-280(further)-280(renders)-280(this)-280(theory)-281(untenable)-280(is,)-287(that)-280(it)-280(is)-280(com-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(pelled)-390(to)-389(imagine)-390(a)-390(number)-389(of)-390(developments)-390(accompanied)-389(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(corresponding)-336(compromises)-335(between)-336(hostile)-336(parties,)-357(before)-335(we)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1554 0 obj <<
/Length 4668      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(335)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(can)-288(succeed)-287(in)-288(evolving)-288(the)-288(Christianity)-287(of)-288(the)-288(New)-287(Testament.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Not)-406(only)-405(does)-406(it)-406(contradict)-406(the)-405(history)-406(of)-406(man;)-483(not)-406(only)-406(is)-405(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-309(assumption)-310(made)-309(to)-309(form)-309(the)-310(connecting)-309(link)-309(between)-309(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(established)-343(facts,)-367(but)-344(it)-343(is)-344(itself)-343(founded)-344(on)-343(other)-343(assumptions.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Among)-306(these)-613(are)-306(the)-306(assertions)-306(made)-306(as)-307(to)-306(the)-306(evidence)-306(of)-306(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([382])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(party)-335(spirit)-334(existing)-334(in)-335(the)-334(Church,)-356(and)-335(the)-334(opposition)-334(between)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-349(leaders.)-546(Party)-349(spirit)-349(we)-349(know)-349(to)-348(have)-349(existed,)-374(but)-349(not)-348(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-377(violence)-376(which)-377(this)-377(theory)-376(is)-377(compelled)-377(to)-376(postulate.)-630(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(statement)-216(also)-216(that)-216(the)-216(doctrinal)-216(opposition)-216(between)-216(these)-215(parties)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-366(of)-367(so)-366(declared)-367(a)-366(type)-366(is)-367(not)-366(founded)-366(on)-367(the)-366(evidence)-366(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-404(possess,)-442(but)-404(on)-404(a)-404(highly)-404(exaggerated)-404(view)-404(of)-404(it,)-442(distorted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-411(the)-411(purpose)-412(of)-411(adding)-411(strength)-411(to)-412(the)-411(theory;)-492(or,)-451(in)-411(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(words,)-341(it)-323(is)-323(founded)-323(on)-323(a)-323(set)-323(of)-323(unwarranted)-323(assumptions.)-469(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(passages)-402(in)-402(the)-403(New)-402(Testament)-402(alleged)-402(to)-402(prove)-402(the)-402(declared)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(opposition)-269(between)-268(the)-269(leaders)-269(of)-268(the)-269(Church,)-273(which)-269(this)-268(theory)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-215(compelled)-215(to)-215(pre-suppose,)-222(can)-216(only)-215(be)-215(made)-215(to)-215(do)-215(so)-215(by)-215(taking)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-345(for)-345(granted)-344(that)-345(they)-345(do.)-534(For)-345(example,)-368(the)-345(assertion)-345(that)-344(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(person)-334(denounced)-334(in)-334(the)-333(Epistles)-334(to)-334(the)-334(Seven)-334(Churches)-334(in)-333(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(book)-325(of)-325(Revelation,)-343(is)-325(St.)-475(Paul,)-343(is)-325(a)-325(simply)-325(gratuitous)-325(one,)-343(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(only)-354(evidence)-354(for)-354(which)-355(is)-354(the)-354(will)-354(and)-354(pleasure)-354(of)-354(those)-354(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(make)-323(it.)-469(The)-323(theory,)-341(therefore,)-341(not)-323(only)-323(contradicts)-323(the)-323(history)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-326(man,)-344(but)-325(is)-326(based)-325(upon)-326(a)-325(number)-326(of)-325(alleged)-326(facts)-325(which)-325(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(either)-200(absolute)-200(assumptions)-201(or)-200(exaggerations,)-210(and)-200(fail)-200(to)-200(give)-200(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(account)-278(of)-278(the)-278(origin)-279(of)-278(Christianity)-278(which)-278(will)-278(stand)-278(the)-278(test)-278(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(scrutiny)-250(of)-250(a)-250(sound)-250(philosophy.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(The)-324(mythic)-323(and)-324(legendary)-323(theories)-324(are)-324(equally)-323(unable)-324(to)-323(ac-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(count)-268(for)-269(the)-268(facts)-269(as)-268(they)-268(stand)-269(in)-268(the)-269(New)-268(Testament.)-305(I)-268(cannot)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(here)-244(attempt)-244(to)-244(follow)-244(them)-244(in)-244(their)-244(innumerable)-243(windings.)-248(Tak-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(en)-201(by)-201(themselves)-201(they)-201(are)-201(not)-201(now)-201(accepted)-201(as)-201(adequate)-200(accounts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-271(them,)-277(but)-272(other)-271(theories)-271(are)-272(called)-271(in)-272(to)-271(aid)-271(them.)-315(Still,)-276(what-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ever)-353(assistance)-353(these)-353(are)-352(supposed)-353(to)-353(impart,)-379(myth)-353(and)-352(legend)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-248(always)-248(hold)-248(a)-247(prominent)-248(place)-248(in)-248(the)-248(systems)-248(of)-248(those)-247(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(endeavour)-406(to)-407(account)-406(for)-406(the)-406(origin)-406(of)-407(the)-406(Gospels)-406(on)-406(purely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(human)-247(principles.)-499(As)-247(they)-247(contain)-248(a)-247(large)-247(supernatural)-247(element,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([383])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1559 0 obj <<
/Length 4792      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(336)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(it)-237(is)-237(certain)-237(that)-238(if)-237(this)-237(is)-237(not)-237(historical,)-240(it)-237(must)-237(have)-237(originated)-237(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(some)-321(species)-321(of)-320(fiction,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 109.025 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 18.376 0 Td [(either)-321(in)-321(the)-320(mythic)-321(and)-321(legendary)]TJ -127.401 -13.549 Td [(spirit,)-285(or)-277(in)-278(pure)-278(invention.)-333(Hence)-277(the)-278(use)-277(of)-278(myths)-278(and)-277(legends)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-351(always)-351(be)-350(freely)-351(invoked)-351(by)-351(those)-351(who,)-376(while)-351(they)-350(deny)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-248(historical)-248(character)-249(of)-248(the)-248(Gospels,)-248(do)-249(not)-248(go)-248(to)-248(the)-248(length)-248(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accusing)-250(the)-250(original)-250(followers)-250(of)-250(Jesus)-250(of)-250(deliberate)-250(invention.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-413(must)-413(here)-414(draw)-413(attention)-413(to)-413(one)-414(particular)-413(portion)-413(of)-413(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(evidence,)-386(the)-360(full)-359(significance)-359(of)-359(which)-359(I)-359(have)-359(described)-359(else-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(where.)-343(Whatever)-281(opinions)-281(may)-281(be)-281(formed)-281(as)-281(to)-281(the)-280(unhistorical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-395(of)-394(the)-395(Gospels,)-430(there)-395(is)-394(one)-395(fact)-394(respecting)-395(them)-394(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-443(which)-443(believers)-442(and)-443(unbelievers)-443(must)-443(alike)-442(agree,)-491(namely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-390(they)-389(contain)-390(a)-389(delineation)-390(of)-390(the)-389(most)-390(perfect)-389(conception)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ever)-317(formed)-318(by)-317(the)-317(mind)-318(of)-317(man,)-334(the)-317(character)-318(of)-317(Jesus)-317(Christ.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(There)-205(it)-205(is,)-214(beyond)-204(the)-205(power)-205(of)-205(contradiction;)-220(the)-204(overwhelming)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(majority)-433(of)-432(men)-433(possessed)-432(of)-433(the)-433(most)-432(powerful)-433(minds)-432(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(recognized)-389(it)-389(as)-388(the)-389(greatest)-389(of)-389(ideals,)-423(as)-389(well)-389(as)-389(the)-388(millions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-440(ordinary)-440(men)-440(to)-440(whom)-440(it)-440(has)-440(been)-440(the)-440(object)-440(of)-439(supreme)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(admiration)-281(and)-282(attraction.)-344(The)-281(following)-282(questions)-281(respecting)-281(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-250(urgently)-250(demand)-250(an)-250(answer.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(If)-291(the)-291(Gospels)-292(are)-291(a)-291(mere)-291(collection)-292(of)-291(mythic)-291(and)-291(legendary)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(stories,)-424(generated)-389(and)-389(put)-389(together)-389(in)-389(the)-389(manner)-388(affirmed)-389(by)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(those)-443(who)-443(deny)-443(their)-443(historical)-443(character,)-491(how)-443(got)-443(this)-442(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-238(there?)-246(If)-237(the)-238(fables)-238(of)-238(which)-237(they)-238(are)-238(composed)-238(are)-237(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inventions)-324(of)-325(many)-324(minds,)-343(whence)-325(its)-324(unity?)-474(If)-324(their)-324(inventors)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-313(credulous)-312(enthusiasts)-313(and)-312(fanatics,)-328(whence)-313(its)-312(perfection?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(If)-215(they)-214(were)-215(implicated)-215(in)-214(all)-215(the)-215(superstitions)-214(of)-215(the)-215(age,)-221(whence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-287(moral)-286(elevation?)-360(Of)-287(what)-287(order)-286(of)-287(thought)-287(then)-286(existing)-287(is)-286(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-248(embodiment?)-249(How)-247(could)-248(the)-247(credulity)-248(which)-247(was)-248(necessary)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([384])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(for)-230(the)-230(acceptance)-230(of)-231(such)-230(fictions,)-234(or)-230(how)-230(could)-230(the)-230(spirit)-230(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(invented)-425(them,)-469(have)-425(conceived)-425(these)-425(moral)-425(elements?)-775(There)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-384(character)-384(is)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 68.953 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(let)-384(us)-384(be)-384(distinctly)-383(informed)-384(how)-384(it)-384(was)-384(put)]TJ -79.862 -13.549 Td [(together;)-273(how)-265(much)-265(of)-265(it)-265(is)-265(fact,)-269(and)-265(how)-265(much)-265(fiction;)-272(how)-265(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fictions)-223(were)-223(welded)-223(together)-222(with)-223(the)-223(facts)-223(so)-223(as)-223(to)-223(compose)-222(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whole;)-247(and)-246(what)-246(class)-246(or)-246(order)-245(of)-246(minds)-246(in)-246(the)-246(early)-246(Church)-245(was)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1563 0 obj <<
/Length 4684      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(337)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(equal)-316(to)-316(its)-316(elaboration.)-449(This)-316(delineation)-316(must)-316(have)-316(been)-316(made)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-283(an)-284(early)-283(period,)-292(and)-283(could)-283(not)-283(have)-284(been)-283(a)-283(late)-284(invention;)-299(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-278(is)-278(substantially)-278(the)-278(same)-278(as)-278(that)-278(contained)-278(in)-278(those)-278(Epistles)-278(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(St.)-511(Paul,)-359(which)-337(are)-337(acknowledged)-337(to)-337(have)-337(been)-336(written)-337(within)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(thirty)-310(years)-311(of)-310(the)-310(date)-310(of)-311(the)-310(Crucifixion.)-431(A)-310(distinct)-310(answer)-310(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-201(questions)-200(is)-201(demanded)-200(of)-201(those)-200(who)-201(affirm)-200(that)-201(the)-200(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-228(no)-229(value)-228(as)-228(histories.)-243(It)-228(is)-229(impossible)-228(to)-228(deny)-229(that)-228(they)-228(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-331(most)-332(important)-331(bearing)-332(on)-331(the)-331(present)-332(question.)-494(Why)-331(do)-331(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unbelievers)-250(set)-250(themselves)-250(to)-250(grapple)-250(with)-250(this)-250(problem?)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-191(the)-192(value)-191(to)-191(be)-192(assigned)-191(to)-192(the)-191(Gospels)-191(as)-192(histories)-191(must)-191(be)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(a)-286(matter)-286(for)-286(subsequent)-286(consideration.)-358(At)-286(present)-286(I)-286(need)-285(simply)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(draw)-212(attention)-211(to)-212(the)-211(fact)-212(that)-211(while)-212(the)-211(opponents)-212(of)-211(Christianity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fully)-248(recognize)-247(the)-248(necessity)-248(of)-248(propounding)-247(a)-248(rational)-248(theory)-247(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-310(origin,)-325(the)-310(more)-311(we)-310(examine)-310(their)-310(various)-310(theories)-310(in)-310(detail,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-316(more)-316(apparent)-316(becomes)-315(their)-316(inadequacy)-316(to)-316(account)-316(for)-315(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phenomena.)-244(The)-231(fact,)-235(already)-231(alluded)-231(to,)-235(that)-231(unbelievers)-231(cannot)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(come)-219(to)-219(any)-219(agreement)-219(among)-219(themselves)-219(on)-219(this)-219(subject,)-225(shows)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-341(they)-342(find)-341(the)-341(problem)-342(extremely)-341(difficult)-341(of)-342(solution.)-523(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(plausibility)-378(of)-379(their)-378(theories)-378(is)-379(due)-378(to)-378(the)-379(abstract)-378(and)-378(general)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(form)-360(in)-359(which)-360(they)-359(are)-360(presented.)-578(Various)-360(causes)-359(are)-360(held)-359(up)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-243(any)-243(discrimination)-243(as)-243(to)-243(what)-243(each)-243(of)-243(them)-243(is)-243(capable)-242(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(effecting;)-240(and)-235(the)-235(wished-for)-234(result)-235(is)-235(ascribed)-235(to)-235(their)-234(combined)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(action.)-228(But)-186(when)-185(we)-185(analyse)-186(the)-185(various)-185(forces)-186(at)-185(their)-185(command,)]TJ 4.143 -13.549 Td [(ascertain)-354(the)-353(mode)-354(of)-354(their)-354(action,)-379(the)-354(difficulties)-354(they)-354(would)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 286.881 0 Td [([385])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(have)-281(to)-281(encounter)-281(before)-281(they)-281(could)-281(effectuate)-282(their)-281(results,)-288(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(examine)-349(whether)-350(they)-349(are)-349(true)-350(to)-349(the)-349(facts)-350(of)-349(human)-349(nature)-349(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testified)-342(to)-343(by)-342(the)-343(long)-342(course)-342(of)-343(history,)-365(it)-343(is)-342(not)-343(too)-342(much)-342(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(affirm)-272(that)-271(all)-272(the)-271(investigations)-272(of)-271(unbelievers)-272(have)-271(completely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(failed)-278(to)-279(give)-278(an)-278(account)-279(of)-278(the)-278(origin)-279(of)-278(Christianity)-278(which)-278(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(take)-332(the)-332(place)-331(of)-332(that)-332(handed)-332(down)-331(to)-332(us)-332(by)-331(the)-332(Church.)-495(Until)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-225(can)-226(be)-225(given,)-230(notwithstanding)-225(all)-226(the)-225(expenditure)-225(of)-225(intellect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-356(the)-356(question,)-383(we)-356(are)-357(justified)-356(in)-356(affirming)-356(that)-356(the)-356(problem)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-240(insoluble,)-241(although)-240(Christianity)-240(originated)-239(in)-240(a)-240(period)-239(unques-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tionably)-214(historical,)-220(in)-214(the)-213(midst)-214(of)-213(the)-214(Roman)-213(Empire)-214(over)-213(which)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1567 0 obj <<
/Length 4681      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(338)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(it)-323(rapidly)-322(spread,)-341(despite)-323(the)-322(opposition)-323(of)-322(the)-323(government)-322(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(entire)-250(organization)-250(of)-250(society.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Before)-343(proceeding)-343(to)-343(the)-343(direct)-343(considerations)-343(by)-343(which)-343(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(great)-251(fact)-250(of)-251(Christianity)-251(is)-250(attested,)-251(I)-251(must)-250(take)-251(a)-251(general)-250(glance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-347(the)-346(nature)-347(of)-347(the)-346(materials)-347(which)-347(we)-346(have)-347(at)-347(our)-346(command,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(at)-250(their)-250(historical)-250(value.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-358(shall)-357(take)-358(as)-358(my)-358(starting-point)-357(the)-358(five)-358(facts)-358(already)-357(men-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tioned,)-352(the)-332(historical)-332(certainty)-332(of)-331(which)-332(it)-332(is)-332(needless)-332(to)-331(prove.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(My)-342(starting-point,)-365(therefore,)-366(is)-342(the)-342(continuous)-342(existence)-342(of)-342(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Church,)-362(which)-340(came)-340(into)-340(being)-340(at)-340(a)-340(definite)-339(period)-340(of)-340(time,)-362(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-429(it)-429(can)-428(be)-429(traced)-429(up)-429(in)-429(one)-428(unbroken)-429(succession.)-786(This)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(society)-287(has)-287(always)-287(affirmed)-287(that)-287(its)-286(corporate)-287(existence,)-297(as)-286(well)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-305(the)-304(life)-305(of)-305(its)-305(individual)-304(members,)-319(is)-304(due)-305(to)-305(the)-304(Resurrection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-359(its)-360(founder.)-578(I)-359(shall)-360(also)-359(carefully)-359(examine)-360(and)-359(estimate)-359(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(contemporaneous)-290(evidence)-289(afforded)-290(by)-289(the)-290(Epistles)-289(of)-290(St.)-368(Paul,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(especially)-275(those)-275(which)-275(are)-275(acknowledged)-275(to)-274(be)-275(genuine,)-282(as)-274(well)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-298(that)-298(of)-299(the)-298(other)-298(writings)-298(of)-298(the)-299(New)-298(Testament,)-310(for)-298(the)-298(pur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pose)-336(of)-337(estimating)-336(the)-337(value)-336(of)-337(their)-336(testimony)-337(on)-336(this)-336(subject.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Even)-319(if)-319(some)-637(of)-319(these)-319(writings)-318(are)-319(not)-319(allowed)-319(by)-318(unbelievers)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([386])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(to)-240(be)-240(the)-241(productions)-240(of)-240(the)-240(persons)-241(whose)-240(names)-240(they)-240(bear,)-242(still)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-315(are)-315(all)-315(of)-315(a)-315(very)-315(early)-315(date,)-331(and)-315(unquestionably)-315(reflect)-315(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thoughts)-275(and)-275(ideas)-276(of)-275(those)-275(who)-275(wrote)-275(them,)-282(and)-275(of)-275(the)-275(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-224(whom)-224(they)-223(are)-224(addressed.)-242(But)-223(before)-224(I)-224(enter)-224(on)-224(my)-223(immediate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subject,)-356(it)-334(will)-335(be)-334(necessary)-335(to)-334(lay)-335(down)-334(the)-335(leading)-334(principles)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-265(historical)-266(evidence,)-269(and)-266(to)-265(estimate)-265(the)-266(value)-265(of)-266(tradition)-265(as)-265(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testimony)-250(to)-250(historical)-250(facts.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(I)-260(am)-259(fully)-260(prepared)-259(to)-260(abide)-260(by)-259(the)-260(chief)-259(principles)-260(laid)-259(down)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(by)-242(Sir)-243(G.)-242(C.)-242(Lewis)-243(on)-242(this)-242(subject)-243(in)-242(his)-242(great)-243(work)-242(on)-242(the)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 255.179 0 Td [(Cred-)]TJ -255.179 -13.549 Td [(ibility)-348(of)-348(Early)-348(Roman)-347(History)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 137.001 0 Td [(.)-543(They)-348(are)-348(generally)-348(considered)]TJ -137.001 -13.549 Td [(to)-258(be)-257(sufficiently)-258(severe)-258(and)-257(exacting.)-273(By)-258(many)-257(they)-258(are)-257(viewed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-349(of)-349(far)-349(too)-349(stringent)-349(a)-349(character.)-547(The)-349(evidence)-349(on)-349(which)-349(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-302(fact)-302(of)-302(the)-303(Resurrection)-302(rests,)-315(will)-302(endure)-302(their)-302(most)-302(rigid)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(application.)-556(They)-352(have)-352(this)-351(great)-352(advantage,)-378(that)-352(they)-352(are)-351(laid)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(down)-197(for)-197(the)-196(investigation)-197(of)-197(a)-197(subject)-196(purely)-197(secular,)-208(with)-196(which)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1571 0 obj <<
/Length 4594      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(339)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(religion)-295(has)-294(nothing)-295(to)-295(do.)-383(They)-295(are)-295(therefore)-294(wholly)-295(free)-294(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(religious)-214(bias,)-221(and)-213(are)-214(simply)-213(the)-214(principles)-214(for)-213(testing)-214(the)-213(claims)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-302(ordinary)-302(facts)-302(on)-302(our)-301(belief.)-406(If)-302(the)-302(chief)-302(facts)-302(of)-301(Christianity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-229(stand)-229(this)-229(scrutiny,)-234(it)-229(is)-229(impossible)-229(to)-229(affirm)-229(that)-229(they)-229(are)-229(not)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supported)-250(by)-250(the)-250(strongest)-250(historical)-250(testimony.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(1.)-240(Every)-219(alleged)-219(fact,)-225(in)-219(order)-219(to)-219(be)-218(entitled)-219(to)-219(our)-219(belief,)-225(must)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(be)-341(shown)-340(to)-341(rest)-341(on)-340(direct)-341(contemporaneous)-341(testimony,)-363(or)-340(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(is)-250(its)-250(historical)-250(equivalent.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(This)-247(rule)-247(is)-248(by)-247(no)-247(means)-247(intended)-247(to)-248(affirm)-247(that)-247(every)-247(fact)-247(for)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(which)-349(contemporaneous)-349(testimony)-348(can)-349(be)-349(adduced)-349(is)-348(true;)-398(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-266(that)-267(it)-266(is)-267(to)-266(be)-266(accepted)-267(as)-266(such)-267(when)-266(there)-266(is)-267(no)-266(reason)-266(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disbelieving)-280(it.)-341(We)-280(must)-281(have)-280(some)-280(means)-280(to)-281(enable)-280(us)-280(to)-280(form)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-415(judgment)-414(of)-415(the)-414(knowledge)-415(and)-414(veracity)-415(of)-414(the)-829(informant.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([387])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(It)-467(remains)-467(for)-467(consideration,)-521(when)-467(the)-467(direct)-467(testimony)-467(of)-466(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(contemporary)-364(is)-364(not)-365(to)-364(be)-364(had,)-393(as)-364(must)-364(be)-364(frequently)-364(the)-364(case)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-329(events)-329(long)-329(past,)-349(what)-329(may)-329(be)-329(considered)-329(as)-329(its)-329(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(equivalent?)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-326(must)-325(be)-326(kept)-325(in)-326(mind)-326(that)-325(one)-326(of)-326(the)-325(most)-326(valuable)-325(forms)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-344(contemporaneous)-343(testimony,)-367(if)-344(not)-343(the)-344(most)-343(valuable)-344(of)-343(all,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-384(a)-384(set)-384(of)-383(letters)-384(which)-384(contain)-384(various)-384(and)-384(definite)-383(allusions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-308(the)-309(current)-308(events,)-323(habits,)-323(and)-309(modes)-308(of)-308(thought)-309(of)-308(the)-308(time.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(For)-427(certain)-427(purposes)-427(these)-427(are)-427(far)-427(more)-427(valuable)-427(than)-426(formal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(histories.)-252(The)-251(latter)-251(are)-251(frequently)-250(written)-251(under)-251(the)-251(influence)-250(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(party)-287(spirit,)-297(partiality,)-297(or)-287(bias.)-362(The)-288(writer)-287(of)-287(a)-288(history)-287(is)-287(usually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-267(his)-266(guard,)-271(has)-267(carefully)-267(considered)-266(what)-267(he)-267(says,)-271(and)-266(affords)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us)-263(but)-263(little)-263(opportunity)-263(of)-263(interrogating)-263(him.)-289(But)-263(the)-263(writer)-263(of)-263(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(letter,)-228(unless)-222(he)-222(has)-222(special)-222(reasons)-222(for)-222(being)-222(guarded,)-227(places)-222(be-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fore)-251(his)-251(correspondent)-251(his)-251(entire)-251(mind.)-253(We)-251(are)-251(therefore)-250(capable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-336(interrogating)-336(him.)-508(He)-336(often)-336(lets)-336(us)-336(into)-336(the)-336(secret)-336(causes)-335(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events.)-247(He)-242(also)-242(makes)-241(a)-242(number)-242(of)-241(incidental)-242(allusions)-242(to)-241(events)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-185(are)-185(passing.)-229(These)-185(form)-185(testimony)-185(of)-185(a)-185(most)-185(valuable)-185(kind.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(We)-197(can)-197(in)-197(a)-197(manner)-197(almost)-197(converse)-196(with)-197(him.)-233(As)-197(a)-196(confirmation)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-270(the)-271(facts)-270(which)-270(formal)-271(histories)-270(narrate,)-275(and)-271(as)-270(letting)-270(us)-270(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-227(secret)-227(springs)-227(of)-228(events,)-231(a)-227(series)-227(of)-228(letters,)-231(written)-227(by)-227(persons)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1576 0 obj <<
/Length 4541      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(340)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(who)-269(were)-269(actively)-269(engaged)-268(in)-269(them,)-274(are)-269(historical)-269(documents)-268(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-364(highest)-364(order.)-593(Their)-364(value)-364(is)-364(increased)-364(when)-364(they)-364(bear)-364(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-396(appearance)-396(of)-396(coming)-396(from)-396(the)-396(writer's)-396(heart.)-688(Nothing)-395(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more)-201(striking)-201(than)-200(the)-201(happy)-201(results)-200(which)-201(have)-201(accrued)-201(from)-200(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(extensive)-286(use)-285(made)-286(by)-285(modern)-286(historians)-285(of)-286(original)-285(correspon-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dence.)-373(It)-291(is)-291(not)-291(too)-291(much)-291(to)-291(say)-291(that)-291(it)-291(has)-291(largely)-291(modified)-291(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(view)-337(of)-338(events,)-359(as)-338(they)-337(have)-338(been)-337(reported)-338(in)-337(formal)-337(histories.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Another)-359(very)-358(high)-359(form)-358(of)-359(contemporaneous)-359(testimony)-358(is)-359(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([388])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(existence)-292(of)-293(institutions)-292(and)-292(monuments)-293(which)-292(can)-292(be)-292(certainly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(traced)-281(up)-280(to)-281(a)-281(particular)-280(period,)-289(and)-280(which)-281(owed)-281(their)-280(existence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-234(events)-235(of)-234(that)-235(period.)-245(These)-234(form)-235(a)-234(species)-235(of)-234(living)-234(witnesses)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-242(the)-242(truth)-242(of)-241(the)-242(facts)-242(out)-242(of)-242(which)-242(they)-241(have)-242(originated,)-244(and)-241(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(far)-215(as)-215(their)-215(testimony)-215(goes,)-222(it)-215(is)-214(incapable)-215(of)-215(falsehood.)-239(The)-214(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(valuable)-389(testimony)-389(of)-389(this)-390(kind)-389(is)-389(a)-389(great)-389(institution)-389(of)-389(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(we)-421(possess)-420(definite)-421(evidence)-420(that)-420(it)-421(originated)-420(in)-421(a)-420(particular)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(event,)-358(or)-336(in)-336(the)-337(belief)-336(of)-336(it.)-509(This)-337(kind)-336(of)-336(evidence)-336(Christianity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possesses)-280(in)-281(the)-280(highest)-280(form,)-288(in)-280(the)-281(continued)-280(existence)-280(of)-280(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-250(institution,)-250(the)-250(Christian)-250(Church.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(2.)-574(Testimony)-358(has)-358(a)-358(general)-358(credibility,)-385(subject)-358(of)-358(course)-358(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-347(knowledge)-347(and)-346(honesty)-347(of)-347(the)-347(informant,)-371(when)-347(the)-346(reports)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-245(derived)-245(from)-245(those)-246(who)-245(lived)-245(during)-245(the)-245(generation)-245(in)-245(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-405(particular)-406(event)-405(occurred,)-444(supposing)-405(it)-405(to)-406(have)-405(been)-405(one)-405(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sufficient)-251(notoriety)-250(to)-251(attract)-251(attention,)-251(and)-250(that)-251(the)-251(reporter)-250(pos-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sessed)-328(adequate)-328(means)-328(of)-328(information,)-348(and)-328(investigated)-328(it)-328(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sufficient)-267(care.)-300(We)-267(are)-267(always)-267(justified)-266(in)-267(assuming)-267(that)-267(he)-266(tells)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(truth)-250(unless)-250(there)-250(are)-250(reasons)-250(for)-250(suspecting)-250(the)-250(contrary.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(3.)-888(Narratives)-462(of)-463(events)-462(which)-463(a)-462(man)-463(has)-462(heard)-463(from)-462(his)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(father)-219(or)-220(his)-219(contemporaries,)-226(but)-219(which)-219(happened)-220(before)-219(his)-219(own)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recollection,)-390(are)-361(for)-362(the)-362(purpose)-362(of)-361(history,)-390(\050but)-362(subject)-362(to)-361(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(requisite)-235(qualifications\051)-235(fair)-235(representations)-235(of)-234(contemporaneous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testimony.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(History)-397(admits)-397(hearsay)-397(testimony)-397(under)-397(proper)-397(rest)1(rictions.)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(The)-379(knowledge)-379(of)-379(the)-378(past)-379(would)-379(be)-379(impossible,)-411(if)-379(it)-379(were)-378(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(allow)-248(itself)-248(to)-249(be)-248(fettered)-248(by)-248(the)-249(technical)-248(rules)-248(which)-248(have)-248(been)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1580 0 obj <<
/Length 4475      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(341)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(introduced)-325(into)-324(the)-325(administration)-324(of)-324(justice.)-474(The)-324(all-important)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(considerations)-395(with)-395(the)-394(historian,)-431(are)-395(the)-395(notoriety)-395(of)-395(the)-394(fact)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-424(the)-424(truthfulness)-424(of)-424(the)-424(informant.)-772(Facts)-424(that)-424(a)-424(man)-424(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-268(heard)-267(detailed)-268(by)-267(his)-268(grandfather)-267(or)-535(his)-268(contemporaries)-267(as)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([389])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(having)-353(happened)-352(in)-353(their)-352(time)-353(stand)-353(as)-352(representations)-353(of)-352(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(temporaneous)-369(testimony)-368(in)-369(the)-368(same)-369(position)-368(as)-369(those)-368(derived)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-250(the)-250(earlier)-250(generation.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(4.)-623(But)-374(when)-374(a)-374(third)-374(stage)-375(is)-374(interposed)-374(in)-374(the)-375(t)1(ransmission)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-419(events,)-461(as)-418(for)-419(instance)-419(when)-419(we)-418(learn)-419(from)-419(our)-419(fathers)-418(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(grandfathers)-389(what)-389(they)-389(have)-389(learnt)-389(from)-389(theirs,)-424(an)-389(element)-389(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(uncertainty)-240(is)-241(introduced.)-246(Still)-241(an)-240(historian,)-242(writing)-241(after)-240(such)-240(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interval)-330(of)-331(time,)-350(if)-331(he)-330(sifted)-330(evidence)-331(with)-330(care,)-351(would)-330(be)-330(able)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-311(report)-311(with)-311(accuracy)-311(all)-311(the)-311(great)-311(events,)-326(whatever)-311(difficulty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-432(might)-432(have)-432(in)-433(ascertaining)-432(the)-432(minor)-432(details.)-796(Within)-432(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(period)-254(abundance)-254(of)-254(sources)-254(of)-254(accurate)-254(information)-254(exist)-254(on)-254(all)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(points)-305(of)-304(importance,)-319(although)-304(the)-305(details)-305(gradually)-304(fade)-305(out)-304(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(people's)-266(recollections.)-297(After)-265(this)-266(interval,)-270(the)-265(accounts)-266(of)-265(events)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-275(likely)-275(to)-276(receive)-275(a)-275(certain)-275(amount)-276(of)-275(colouring,)-281(according)-275(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-298(prejudices)-298(of)-297(the)-298(narrators;)-322(but)-298(the)-297(interval)-298(is)-298(too)-298(short,)-309(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-264(remembrance)-265(of)-264(them)-264(too)-264(recent,)-268(to)-265(allow)-264(of)-264(their)-264(becoming)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(incrusted)-201(with)-202(important)-201(mythical)-201(additions.)-234(All)-201(the)-201(materials)-201(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(investigation)-253(are)-254(in)-253(existence,)-254(and)-254(within)-253(the)-253(reach)-254(of)-253(the)-253(honest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historian.)-706(He)-401(might)-402(find)-402(difficulty)-402(in)-402(arranging)-402(the)-402(details)-401(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-298(sequence;)-323(but)-299(if)-298(he)-298(does)-299(not)-298(give)-299(an)-298(accurate)-298(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-370(the)-371(great)-370(outlines,)-400(it)-370(is)-371(owing,)-400(not)-370(to)-371(the)-370(want)-370(of)-370(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(materials,)-251(but)-251(to)-250(the)-251(absence)-251(of)-250(a)-251(desire)-250(to)-251(investigate)-251(and)-250(report)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(truth.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(5.)-244(The)-231(limits)-231(of)-232(time)-231(during)-231(which)-232(tradition)-231(can)-231(be)-232(consi)1(dered)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(as)-279(a)-278(sufficiently)-279(accurate)-279(medium)-279(for)-278(preserving)-279(the)-279(memory)-278(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events,)-368(may)-345(be)-344(put)-344(generally)-345(at)-344(from)-345(one)-344(hundred)-345(to)-344(one)-344(hun-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dred)-320(and)-320(twenty)-320(years.)-460(Within)-320(this)-320(period)-320(careful)-320(investigation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-295(inquiry)-295(will)-295(enable)-295(the)-295(historian)-295(to)-295(report)-295(the)-295(main)-295(features)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-449(events)-448(with)-449(substantial)-448(truth,)-498(from)-449(the)-448(testimony)-449(of)-448(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-436(were)-436(contemporaries,)-483(or)-436(who)-436(derived)-436(their)-872(information)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([390])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1585 0 obj <<
/Length 4472      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(342)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(from)-421(those)-421(who)-421(were.)-762(Beyond)-421(this)-421(period,)-464(when)-421(the)-420(knowl-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(edge)-319(of)-319(occurrences)-319(has)-319(to)-319(pass)-319(through)-319(three)-319(or)-319(four)-319(media)-319(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(transmission,)-312(tradition)-300(becomes)-299(an)-300(uncertain)-300(and)-299(untrustworthy)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(informant,)-363(and)-340(after)-340(the)-340(lapse)-340(of)-340(a)-340(greater)-340(interval,)-362(it)-340(is)-340(utterly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(unreliable,)-373(affording)-349(no)-348(means)-349(of)-348(checking)-349(the)-348(introduction)-348(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(legendary)-443(narratives.)-828(There)-443(may)-442(be)-443(a)-443(few)-443(exceptional)-442(cases)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-397(have)-396(impressed)-397(themselves)-397(deeply)-396(on)-397(the)-397(public)-396(recol-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lection.)-594(Occasionally)-364(the)-365(protracted)-364(lives)-365(of)-364(a)-365(few)-364(individuals)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-292(lengthen)-293(the)-292(period)-292(of)-293(trustworthy)-292(transmission,)-303(but)-292(this)-292(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(an)-364(event)-365(of)-364(such)-364(rare)-365(occurrence)-364(as)-364(but)-365(slightly)-364(to)-364(modify)-364(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(general)-250(rule.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-431(must)-432(be)-431(observed)-431(that)-432(there)-431(are)-431(two)-432(cases)-431(in)-431(which)-431(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(traditional)-466(knowledge)-466(of)-466(events)-466(is)-466(transmitted)-466(with)-466(far)-465(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accuracy,)-322(and)-308(over)-308(far)-308(longer)-307(intervals)-308(of)-308(time)-308(than)-308(in)-307(ordinary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ones,)-251(viz.,)-251(those)-250(of)-251(families)-251(which)-250(have)-251(an)-251(historical)-250(importance)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(derived)-204(from)-205(the)-204(actions)-205(of)-204(their)-204(ancestors,)-214(and)-204(those)-205(of)-204(bodies)-204(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(men)-308(who)-308(have)-307(a)-308(kind)-308(of)-308(corporate)-308(life,)-322(succeeding)-308(one)-307(another)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-402(unbroken)-403(succession,)-440(especially)-402(when)-403(this)-402(corporate)-402(life)-402(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(founded)-311(on)-311(the)-312(events)-311(themselves.)-434(This)-311(latter)-311(case)-311(presents)-311(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(means)-421(best)-421(adapted)-421(for)-421(the)-421(traditionary)-421(transmission)-421(of)-420(facts,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-375(one)-376(in)-375(which)-375(it)-375(is)-376(hardly)-375(possible)-375(that)-376(they)-375(should)-375(fail)-375(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-213(accurately)-212(transmitted)-213(within)-213(a)-212(reasonable)-213(interval)-213(of)-212(time.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-210(was)-211(precisely)-210(the)-211(position)-210(occupied)-210(by)-211(the)-210(Christian)-210(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(during)-190(the)-189(first)-190(century)-190(of)-189(its)-190(existence)-190(respecting)-189(the)-190(chief)-189(events)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(the)-250(life)-250(of)-250(its)-250(founder.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(An)-333(example)-332(will)-333(illustrate)-333(this:)-415(If)-333(there)-332(had)-333(been)-333(no)-332(written)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(memorials)-409(of)-408(the)-409(life)-408(of)-409(John)-409(Wesley,)-448(there)-409(can)-408(be)-409(no)-408(doubt)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-323(the)-323(society)-323(which)-322(he)-323(founded)-323(would)-323(have)-323(handed)-323(down)-322(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-289(present)-289(day)-290(an)-289(account)-289(of)-289(the)-290(chief)-289(events)-289(of)-289(his)-289(life,)-299(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-392(have)-392(been)-392(accurate)-392(in)-392(its)-392(main)-392(outlines.)-676(Thousands)-391(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(persons)-223(are)-223(now)-223(living)-223(who)-223(have)-223(conversed)-223(with)-223(those)-223(who)-222(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(heard)-724(him)-361(preach;)-418(I)-362(myself)-361(have)-362(done)-362(so.)-585(It)-362(would)-361(therefore)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([391])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(be)-408(impossible)-407(to)-408(impose)-408(upon)-408(them)-407(a)-408(wholly)-408(mythic)-407(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-405(place)-404(of)-405(that)-405(which)-404(would)-405(have)-405(been)-404(handed)-405(down)-405(by)-404(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1589 0 obj <<
/Length 4570      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(343)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(Wesleyan)-278(body.)-335(Yet)-278(this)-278(society)-278(is)-279(founded)-278(on)-278(a)-278(set)-278(of)-278(dogmas,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-404(on)-405(the)-404(historical)-405(facts)-404(of)-404(its)-405(founder's)-404(life.)-713(The)-404(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church)-295(therefore)-296(was)-295(in)-295(a)-296(far)-295(superior)-295(position)-296(for)-295(preserving)-295(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(substantially)-345(accurate)-346(account)-345(of)-345(the)-345(chief)-345(events)-346(in)-345(the)-345(life)-345(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Jesus)-204(Christ,)-214(yet)-204(the)-204(interval)-205(which)-204(separates)-204(us)-205(from)-204(the)-204(death)-204(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Wesley)-306(is)-307(greater)-306(than)-307(that)-306(which)-307(elapsed)-306(between)-307(the)-306(death)-306(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ,)-264(and)-261(the)-261(publication)-261(of)-262(the)-261(latest)-261(of)-261(the)-261(Synoptic)-261(Gospels,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-334(if)-334(we)-334(accept)-334(the)-334(dates)-334(which)-334(are)-334(assigned)-334(to)-334(them)-334(by)-334(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opponents.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(6.)-786(When)-428(the)-429(knowledge)-428(of)-429(past)-429(events)-428(has)-429(perished,)-473(it)-429(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(impossible)-281(to)-281(re-construct)-280(them)-281(by)-281(the)-281(aid)-280(of)-281(conjecture,)-288(except)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(within)-212(the)-211(limits)-212(to)-211(which)-212(I)-212(have)-211(previously)-212(alluded.)-237(These)-211(limits)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-299(be)-298(strictly)-299(defined,)-311(otherwise)-298(that)-299(which)-298(is)-299(propounded)-298(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(history)-291(becomes)-290(nothing)-291(else)-291(than)-291(a)-290(statement)-291(of)-291(our)-290(subjective)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impressions.)-229(Conjectures)-186(which)-186(cannot)-187(stand)-186(the)-186(test)-186(of)-186(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(verification)-250(cannot)-250(be)-250(accepted)-250(as)-250(facts)-250(of)-250(history.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Nothing)-209(is)-209(easier)-208(than,)-217(when)-209(facts)-209(are)-209(wanting,)-217(to)-209(invent)-208(them,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(and)-291(thus)-292(bridge)-291(over)-291(the)-292(intervals)-291(which)-291(lie)-292(between)-291(others,)-301(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(connecting)-396(links)-397(of)-396(which)-397(have)-396(perished.)-689(But)-396(how)-397(are)-396(we)-396(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(know)-286(that)-286(such)-286(conjectural)-287(events)-286(were)-286(real)-286(facts,)-295(and)-286(not)-286(mere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(creations)-412(of)-412(the)-411(imagination?)-735(Clearly)-412(this)-412(can)-412(be)-411(determined)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-311(no)-311(other)-311(way)-311(than)-311(by)-311(subjecting)-311(them)-311(to)-311(a)-311(rigid)-311(verification.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(If)-382(they)-382(will)-382(not)-382(endure)-382(this,)-415(they)-382(must)-382(be)-382(rejected.)-645(Historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conjectures)-272(have)-272(no)-272(higher)-272(claims)-272(for)-272(acceptance)-272(than)-272(scientific)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ones.)-622(Both)-374(must)-374(be)-374(subject)-374(to)-374(the)-374(same)-374(tests,)-405(and)-374(must)-373(share)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-370(same)-370(fate.)-611(I)-370(do)-370(not)-370(deny)-371(that)-370(many)-370(such)-370(conjectures)-370(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-218(a)-437(considerable)-218(degree)-219(of)-218(plausibility;)-229(but,)-225(unless)-218(we)-218(rigidly)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([392])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(reject)-228(from)-228(the)-228(rank)-228(of)-228(historic)-228(facts)-228(those)-228(that)-228(break)-228(down)-228(under)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-259(test)-258(of)-259(verification,)-261(histories)-258(will)-259(be)-259(converted)-258(into)-259(novels)-258(or)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(poems.)-248(If)-244(our)-244(knowledge)-245(of)-244(the)-244(connecting)-244(links)-244(between)-244(events)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-237(the)-238(history)-237(of)-237(the)-238(past)-237(has)-237(perished,)-240(we)-237(shall)-238(not)-237(improve)-237(it)-237(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(imagining)-250(facts,)-250(and)-250(calling)-250(the)-250(result)-250(by)-250(the)-250(name)-250(of)-250(history.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(We)-313(cannot)-312(be)-313(too)-312(guarded)-313(in)-312(this)-313(particular)-312(subject,)-328(because)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(an)-241(almost)-242(boundless)-241(license)-242(has)-241(been)-241(introduced)-242(into)-241(the)-241(present)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1593 0 obj <<
/Length 2676      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(344)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(controversy.)-231(Pure)-192(creations)-193(of)-192(the)-193(imagination,)-204(which)-192(it)-193(is)-192(impos-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sible)-280(to)-281(verify,)-288(are)-280(constantly)-281(propounded)-280(as)-280(facts)-281(in)-280(the)-280(history)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-328(the)-328(past.)-484(I)-328(by)-328(no)-328(means)-328(wish)-328(to)-328(deny)-328(that)-328(both)-328(parties)-328(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(plead)-365(guilty)-364(to)-365(the)-364(charge)-365(of)-364(this)-365(species)-364(of)-365(historical)-364(forgery.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(The)-239(fact)-239(may)-238(be)-239(unpleasant,)-241(but)-239(we)-239(shall)-238(do)-239(no)-239(good)-239(by)-238(refusing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-227(recognize)-227(it.)-242(When)-227(the)-227(knowledge)-227(of)-227(past)-227(events)-227(has)-227(perished,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-220(our)-220(conjectures)-219(break)-220(down)-220(under)-219(the)-220(test)-220(of)-220(verification,)-225(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-250(nothing)-250(to)-250(do)-250(but)-250(to)-250(remain)-250(content)-250(with)-250(our)-250(ignorance.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(If)-355(these)-355(principles)-355(are)-355(correct,)-381(a)-355(considerable)-355(number)-355(of)-354(re-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(cently)-304(published)-304(lives)-305(of)-304(Jesus,)-318(and)-304(other)-304(similar)-304(compositions,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-397(no)-397(claim)-397(to)-396(the)-397(designation)-397(of)-397(historical)-397(writings.)-690(They)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-365(mere)-365(novels)-365(evolved)-365(out)-365(of)-365(the)-365(self-consciousness)-365(of)-365(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authors.)-868(They)-456(are)-456(nothing)-456(but)-456(simple)-456(imaginations)-456(of)-455(what,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-340(certain)-341(conjectural)-340(circumstances,)-363(might)-340(have)-340(happened,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(but)-346(are)-345(destitute)-346(of)-346(all)-345(evidence)-346(that)-345(they)-346(actually)-346(occurred.)-536(If)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(history)-286(is)-285(thus)-286(degraded,)-295(it)-285(must)-286(become)-286(devoid)-285(of)-286(all)-285(scientific)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(value.)-398(I)-299(have)-299(pressed)-299(this)-299(point)-300(because)-299(nowhere)-299(is)-299(this)-299(license)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-287(conjectural)-286(guessing)-287(at)-287(events)-287(more)-286(largely)-287(indulged)-287(in,)-295(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(questions)-250(connected)-250(with)-250(the)-250(Bible)-250(and)-250(its)-250(criticism.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -29.64 Td [([393])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1601 0 obj <<
/Length 3275      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-256(XVIII.)-256(The)-256(Testimony)-256(Of)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(The)-264(Church,)-268(And)-264(Of)-264(St.)-293(Paul's)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Epistles,)-254(To)-253(The)-253(Facts)-254(Of)-253(Primitive)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Christianity.)-260(Their)-253(Historical)-253(Value)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Considered.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -41.745 Td [(I)-462(have)-462(in)-462(the)-462(preceding)-462(chapter)-462(drawn)-462(attention)-462(to)-462(the)-461(chief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(principles)-213(of)-213(historical)-213(evidence,)-220(and)-213(to)-213(the)-213(importance)-213(of)-213(certain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(classes)-401(of)-401(historical)-401(documents;)-476(also)-401(to)-401(the)-401(important)-400(bearing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-482(the)-482(continued)-482(existence)-482(of)-482(a)-482(great)-482(institution)-482(like)-482(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-269(Church)-270(has)-269(on)-269(this)-270(subject,)-274(especially)-269(as)-270(its)-269(origin)-269(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-257(traced)-256(up)-257(to)-256(a)-257(definite)-256(period)-257(of)-256(history.)-270(I)-256(have)-257(further)-256(shown)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-307(as)-308(the)-307(Church)-307(gives)-307(a)-308(definite)-307(account)-307(of)-308(its)-307(origin,)-321(which,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-322(true,)-341(is)-322(an)-323(adequate)-322(one;)-358(it)-323(is)-322(incumbent)-322(on)-323(those)-322(who)-322(reject)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-373(account)-373(to)-372(propound)-373(another)-373(which)-372(shall)-373(be)-373(able)-373(to)-372(stand)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-239(application)-240(of)-239(the)-239(principles)-240(of)-239(a)-239(sound)-240(philosophy)-239(of)-239(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature.)-273(I)-258(must)-257(now)-258(consider)-257(the)-258(evidence)-258(which)-257(the)-258(existence)-257(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-309(Church)-309(as)-309(a)-308(visible)-309(institution,)-324(and)-309(the)-308(Epistles)-309(of)-309(St.)-426(Paul,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(afford)-250(to)-250(the)-250(great)-250(facts)-250(on)-250(which)-250(Christianity)-250(is)-250(based.)]TJ 11.956 -15.414 Td [(If)-369(it)-368(can)-369(be)-369(proved)-369(beyond)-368(question)-369(that)-369(the)-369(Church)-368(imme-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(diately)-339(after)-340(it)-339(assumed)-339(a)-340(distinctive)-339(form)-339(not)-340(only)-339(believed)-339(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-232(Resurrection)-231(of)-232(Jesus)-232(Christ,)-235(as)-232(one)-231(among)-232(many)-231(miraculous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(facts,)-395(but)-366(affirmed)-366(that)-367(the)-366(belief)-366(in)-366(its)-366(truth)-366(was)-366(the)-366(one)-366(sole)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ground)-389(of)-389(its)-389(corporate)-388(existence,)-424(within)-389(a)-389(very)-389(short)-388(interval)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(after)-364(the)-364(date)-364(of)-364(His)-364(crucifixion,)-393(it)-364(must)-364(be)-364(admitted,)-392(even)-364(by)]TJ 4.003 -13.55 Td [(unbelievers,)-396(to)-367(involve)-367(a)-367(question)-367(of)-367(the)-367(most)-367(serious)-367(impor-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 287.021 0 Td [([394])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(tance.)-598(It)-366(proves)-366(for)-366(certain)-366(that)-366(the)-366(belief)-366(in)-366(one)-366(miracle,)-394(and)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1606 0 obj <<
/Length 4759      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(346)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(that)-389(the)-389(greatest)-389(of)-389(all)-389(recorded)-389(in)-389(the)-389(Gospels,)-424(was)-388(neither)-389(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mythic)-383(nor)-382(a)-383(legendary)-382(creation.)-648(It)-382(further)-383(follows)-382(that)-383(if)-382(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(original)-362(followers)-361(of)-362(Jesus)-362(thought)-361(that)-362(He)-362(had)-361(risen)-362(from)-361(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dead,)-356(it)-334(may)-334(be)-335(taken)-334(as)-335(a)-334(moral)-335(certainty)-334(that)-335(they)-334(must)-334(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(believed)-265(that)-265(other)-265(supernatural)-265(actions)-265(were)-265(performed)-265(by)-264(Him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(during)-266(His)-265(life.)-297(The)-266(solution)-265(which)-266(unbelievers)-265(propound)-266(as)-265(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(account)-251(of)-250(the)-251(origin)-251(of)-250(the)-251(miraculous)-251(narratives)-250(in)-251(the)-250(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-410(that)-410(they)-410(are)-409(a)-410(gradual)-410(creation)-410(of)-410(a)-410(mythic)-410(and)-409(legendary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(spirit.)-564(Hence)-354(their)-355(efforts)-354(to)-355(assign)-354(them)-355(to)-354(the)-355(latest)-354(possible)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(date.)-884(If)-462(their)-461(publication)-462(can)-461(be)-462(deferred)-461(to)-462(the)-461(early)-461(years)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-340(the)-340(second)-340(century,)-363(they)-340(consider)-340(that)-340(this)-340(would)-340(afford)-340(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(requisite)-362(time)-361(for)-362(surrounding)-361(the)-362(history)-361(of)-362(Jesus)-361(with)-362(a)-361(halo)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-364(mythic)-364(and)-364(legendary)-364(environment.)-591(But)-364(if)-364(it)-364(can)-364(be)-363(shown)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-269(the)-268(new-born)-269(Christian)-269(Church,)-273(within)-269(a)-268(short)-269(interval)-268(after)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-253(Crucifixion,)-255(affirmed)-253(that)-253(the)-254(sole)-253(ground)-253(of)-254(its)-253(renewed)-253(life)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-302(the)-302(belief)-302(in)-302(the)-302(Resurrection)-302(of)-302(its)-302(founder,)-315(the)-301(possibility)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-362(such)-362(belief)-362(could)-361(have)-362(been)-362(either)-362(mythic)-362(or)-362(legendary)-361(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taken)-259(away.)-278(Whatever)-259(may)-260(be)-259(urged)-259(about)-259(the)-260(other)-259(parts)-259(of)-259(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(story,)-414(there)-380(remains)-381(one)-381(miracle)-381(\050and)-381(that)-381(the)-381(greatest)-381(of)-380(all\051,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-237(it)-236(is)-237(impossible)-236(to)-237(affirm)-236(to)-237(have)-236(been)-237(either)-236(a)-237(mythical)-236(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-224(legendary)-224(creation.)-241(If)-224(the)-224(Church)-224(accepted)-224(it)-224(as)-224(the)-224(sole)-224(ground)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-268(its)-268(existence,)-273(and)-268(if)-268(that)-268(belief)-268(can)-268(be)-268(traced)-268(to)-268(the)-268(hour)-268(of)-268(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(birth,)-315(it)-303(must)-302(have)-302(been)-303(due)-302(either)-302(to)-303(some)-302(species)-302(of)-302(delusion,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-351(to)-350(a)-351(fact.)-551(If)-350(Jesus)-351(was)-350(thus)-351(believed)-350(to)-351(have)-350(risen)-351(from)-350(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(dead,)-313(it)-301(is)-301(useless)-300(to)-301(assign)-301(the)-300(belief)-301(in)-301(His)-300(other)-301(miracles)-301(to)-300(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(later)-250(legendary)-250(spirit.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(But)-249(further:)-250(The)-249(Church,)-250(within)-249(a)-249(short)-250(number)-249(of)-249(years)-249(from)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(the)-352(date)-353(of)-352(its)-353(birth,)-378(must)-352(have)-352(had)-353(all)-352(the)-705(consciousness)-352(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([395])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(it)-370(was)-370(a)-370(young)-370(society.)-611(It)-370(was)-370(engaged)-370(in)-370(a)-370(constant)-370(struggle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-357(existence,)-383(and)-356(had)-357(before)-356(it)-357(the)-356(alternative)-356(of)-357(enlarging)-356(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(numbers,)-332(or)-315(perishing.)-447(A)-315(new)-316(society)-315(constantly)-316(struggling)-315(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-329(could)-328(not)-329(fail)-329(within)-328(this)-329(interval)-329(of)-328(time)-329(to)-329(have)-328(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(most)-369(lively)-369(consciousness)-369(of)-369(what)-369(it)-369(was)-369(to)-369(which)-369(it)-369(owed)-368(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(origin,)-241(and)-239(which)-240(formed)-239(the)-239(bond)-239(of)-239(union)-239(among)-239(its)-239(members.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1610 0 obj <<
/Length 4692      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(347)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(It)-267(must)-266(have)-267(been)-267(to)-267(them)-266(a)-267(constantly)-267(recurring)-266(thought.)-300(Every)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-330(must)-329(have)-330(known)-329(that)-330(it)-330(was)-329(an)-330(alleged)-329(miraculous)-330(fact,)-349(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposed)-357(Resurrection)-357(of)-356(one)-357(who)-357(had)-357(been)-356(crucified.)-571(Was)-356(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possible)-228(for)-228(the)-227(members)-228(of)-228(such)-228(a)-227(society)-228(to)-228(avoid)-228(looking)-227(back)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-342(anxiety)-343(on)-342(the)-342(alleged)-343(ground)-342(of)-342(its)-343(existence?)-527(It)-342(was)-342(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dogma)-364(capable)-364(of)-364(endless)-364(discussion,)-392(but)-364(a)-364(fact.)-592(The)-364(bond)-363(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(union)-359(was)-360(allegiance)-359(to)-359(a)-359(living)-360(person.)-578(Is)-359(it)-359(conceivable)-359(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-239(person)-238(was)-239(not)-238(the)-239(object)-239(of)-238(daily)-239(interest)-238(to)-239(its)-239(members,)-240(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-233(they)-233(did)-232(not)-233(make)-233(His)-233(history)-232(the)-233(subject)-233(of)-233(earnest)-232(inquiry?)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Can)-253(we)-253(suppose)-253(for)-254(one)-253(moment)-253(that)-253(any)-253(of)-253(them)-253(were)-253(ignorant)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-379(or)-380(had)-379(forgotten)-379(the)-380(grounds)-379(on)-379(which)-380(they)-379(had)-379(joined)-379(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(new)-434(community,)-480(or)-434(which)-435(formed)-434(the)-434(basis)-434(of)-434(its)-434(life?)-802(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recollections)-256(of)-257(the)-256(members)-256(of)-256(a)-256(society)-257(which)-256(is)-256(only)-256(between)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(twenty)-250(and)-250(thirty)-250(years)-250(old)-250(must)-250(be)-250(fresh.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-224(it)-225(may)-224(be)-225(said,)-229(these)-225(people)-224(were)-225(very)-224(credulous.)-242(Be)-224(it)-224(so.)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Credulous)-369(people)-369(placed)-368(in)-369(the)-369(circumstances)-369(of)-369(the)-368(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Church)-406(are)-405(never)-406(deficient)-406(in)-406(curiosity.)-717(Even)-405(if)-406(the)-406(belief)-405(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-389(Resurrection)-389(of)-388(Jesus)-389(had)-389(originated)-389(in)-388(credulity,)-424(the)-388(first)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(principles)-258(of)-258(human)-258(nature)-259(would)-258(have)-258(urged)-258(them)-258(to)-258(get)-258(all)-258(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(information)-382(which)-382(they)-382(could)-381(respecting)-382(it.)-646(They)-382(were)-382(in)-381(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exact)-398(position)-397(to)-398(enable)-398(them)-397(to)-398(do)-397(this.)-693(Within)-398(ten,)-434(twenty,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thirty,)-241(or)-239(forty)-240(years,)-241(there)-239(must)-239(have)-239(been)-239(plenty)-239(of)-239(information)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(at)-237(hand)-236(to)-237(enable)-237(them)-237(to)-236(ascertain)-474(whether)-236(the)-237(society)-237(to)-236(which)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([396])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(they)-262(belonged)-261(did)-262(or)-262(did)-262(not)-261(owe)-262(its)-262(existence)-261(to)-262(this)-262(belief,)-264(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-334(get)-333(full)-334(information)-334(as)-334(to)-333(the)-334(general)-334(outline)-333(of)-334(the)-334(story)-333(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-276(it)-276(was)-276(founded.)-328(It)-276(is)-276(impossible)-276(for)-276(members)-276(of)-276(a)-276(society)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whose)-412(origin)-412(was)-412(so)-411(recent)-412(to)-412(have)-412(remained)-412(ignorant)-412(of)-411(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(circumstances)-261(which)-261(gave)-260(it)-261(birth.)-282(They)-261(must)-261(have)-261(been)-260(handed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(down)-355(by)-355(a)-354(lively)-355(tradition.)-564(I)-355(conclude)-355(therefore,)-381(that)-355(it)-354(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-399(been)-398(simply)-399(impossible)-399(for)-399(the)-398(members)-399(of)-399(the)-398(Church,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(within)-260(this)-260(short)-261(time,)-262(to)-260(be)-261(mistaken)-260(as)-260(to)-260(whether)-260(its)-260(existence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-232(continued)-232(life)-232(was)-232(due)-232(to)-232(the)-232(belief)-232(that)-232(its)-232(founder)-232(had)-232(risen)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(from)-422(the)-421(dead,)-465(or)-421(whether)-422(He)-421(was)-422(supposed)-421(to)-422(have)-421(worked)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-296(during)-297(His)-296(life;)-320(and)-296(that)-297(its)-296(belief)-296(could)-297(not)-296(have)-296(been)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1614 0 obj <<
/Length 4498      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(348)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(due)-250(to)-250(mythic)-250(or)-250(legendary)-250(causes.)]TJ 11.956 -14.367 Td [(The)-224(question)-224(before)-223(us)-224(then,)-229(becomes)-224(clear)-224(and)-223(definite,)-229(freed)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(from)-323(the)-323(vagueness)-323(with)-323(which)-323(it)-323(has)-323(been)-323(endeavoured)-323(to)-322(ob-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(scure)-421(it.)-765(If)-421(it)-422(can)-421(be)-421(proved)-422(that)-421(the)-422(Christian)-421(Church)-421(owed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-379(origin)-378(to)-379(its)-379(belief)-378(in)-379(the)-379(Resurrection)-378(of)-379(Jesus)-379(Christ,)-410(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-312(its)-312(renewed)-312(life)-311(began)-312(within)-312(the)-312(briefest)-312(interval)-312(after)-311(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(crucifixion,)-500(the)-450(whole)-450(discussion)-450(becomes)-450(narrowed)-450(into)-450(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(following)-291(issue:)-332(Is)-291(it)-291(possible)-291(that)-291(such)-291(a)-291(belief,)-301(within)-291(so)-291(short)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-276(time)-276(after)-275(His)-276(death,)-282(could)-276(have)-276(originated)-276(in)-275(a)-276(fiction?)-327(Three)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alternatives)-250(are)-250(open)-250(for)-250(our)-250(acceptance,)-250(and)-250(three)-250(only;)-250(either:)]TJ 11.956 -14.367 Td [(Jesus)-420(did)-420(not)-421(really)-420(die,)-463(while)-420(his)-420(followers)-420(supposed)-420(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(He)-400(had,)-437(and)-400(they)-400(mistook)-399(some)-400(appearance)-400(of)-400(Him)-400(after)-399(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(crucifixion)-250(for)-250(a)-250(resurrection:)]TJ 11.956 -14.367 Td [(Or)-265(they)-264(imagined)-265(that)-265(He)-264(appeared)-265(to)-265(some)-264(of)-265(them)-265(after)-264(His)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(death,)-250(but)-250(the)-250(appearance)-250(was)-250(a)-250(delusion)-250(of)-250(their)-250(imaginations:)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(Or)-250(He)-250(rose)-250(from)-250(the)-250(dead)-250(as)-250(an)-250(objective)-250(fact.)]TJ 0 -14.367 Td [(Other)-437(alternatives)-436(there)-437(are)-436(none;)-530(and)-437(with)-436(respect)-437(to)-436(this)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(particular)-284(miracle,)-293(the)-284(whole)-284(apparatus)-284(of)-284(myth,)-586(legend,)-292(devel-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([397])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(opment)-335(and)-334(compromise,)-356(which)-335(is)-334(so)-335(liberally)-334(used)-335(to)-334(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-263(the)-262(supernatural)-262(portions)-263(of)-262(the)-263(Gospels,)-266(is)-262(simply)-262(worthless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-250(a)-250(rational)-250(account)-250(of)-250(the)-250(origin)-250(of)-250(the)-250(story.)]TJ 11.956 -14.368 Td [(A)-240(very)-240(bold)-240(affirmation)-240(has)-240(been)-240(made,)-242(that)-240(no)-239(contemporary)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(testimony)-378(can)-377(be)-378(adduced)-377(for)-378(the)-378(performance)-377(of)-378(any)-377(miracle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recorded)-377(in)-377(the)-377(New)-376(Testament.)-631(This)-377(assertion)-377(is)-377(founded)-376(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-309(supposition)-308(that)-309(none)-308(of)-309(the)-309(Gospels)-308(can)-309(be)-308(proved)-309(to)-308(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-271(written)-271(earlier)-271(than)-271(the)-271(end)-271(of)-271(the)-271(first,)-276(or)-271(the)-271(beginning)-271(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-311(second)-310(century.)-432(It)-310(is)-310(alleged)-311(that)-310(they)-311(are)-310(of)-311(very)-310(uncertain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authorship,)-498(that)-449(two)-449(of)-448(them)-449(do)-449(not)-448(profess)-449(to)-448(communicate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(anything)-222(but)-222(second-hand)-222(information;)-231(and)-222(the)-222(proof)-222(of)-222(the)-221(early)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(composition)-218(of)-218(the)-217(other)-218(two)-218(utterly)-218(fails.)-239(The)-218(three)-218(first)-217(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-303(thus)-303(quietly)-303(assigned)-304(to)-303(the)-303(region)-303(of)-303(myths)-303(and)-303(legends,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-339(the)-339(fourth)-339(affirmed)-339(to)-340(be)-339(a)-339(forgery,)-361(it)-339(is)-339(asserted)-339(that)-339(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(temporary)-223(evidence)-224(for)-223(the)-223(truth)-223(of)-224(the)-223(supernatural)-223(narratives)-223(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(Gospels)-250(wholly)-250(disappears.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1618 0 obj <<
/Length 4403      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(349)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -252.311 -30.759 Td [(What)-469(then)-468(is)-469(contemporaneous)-469(testimony)-469(to)-468(a)-469(fact?)-906(Few)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(persons)-275(who)-275(actually)-275(witness)-275(events)-275(compose)-275(histories)-275(of)-274(them.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(There)-385(is)-385(scarcely)-384(an)-385(account)-385(of)-385(a)-384(great)-385(battle)-385(which)-385(has)-384(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(composed)-282(by)-283(the)-282(general)-282(who)-283(commanded)-282(in)-282(it;)-299(and)-282(when)-282(such)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(accounts)-459(have)-460(been)-459(published)-459(by)-460(persons)-459(who)-459(were)-459(actually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(present,)-430(they)-394(could)-394(have)-395(witnessed)-394(but)-394(a)-394(small)-394(portion)-394(of)-394(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-255(which)-255(they)-254(describe.)-265(Such)-255(is)-254(the)-255(case)-255(with)-255(the)-255(great)-254(mass)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-255(facts)-255(which)-254(constitute)-255(the)-255(history)-255(of)-255(the)-254(past.)-265(The)-255(chief)-254(actors)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(them)-250(are)-250(seldom)-250(the)-250(historians.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-197(although)-197(such)-198(persons)-197(rarely)-197(compose)-197(narratives)-197(of)-198(events)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(at)-369(which)-369(they)-369(were)-369(actually)-369(present,)-399(yet)-369(it)-369(is)-369(quite)-368(possible)-369(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(possess)-390(testimony)-389(which)-390(for)-389(all)-389(practical)-390(purposes)-389(is)-390(of)-389(equal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(value.)-600(As)-366(I)-366(have)-367(already)-366(pointed)-367(out,)-395(such)-367(testimony)-366(consists)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-266(historical)-266(documents)-532(composed)-266(by)-266(persons)-266(who)-266(lived)-265(during)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([398])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(the)-394(time)-394(in)-394(question,)-431(and)-394(who)-394(had)-394(ample)-394(means)-394(of)-394(procuring)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(information)-350(from)-351(those)-350(who)-351(must)-350(have)-351(known)-350(the)-351(truth)-350(of)-350(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrences.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(We)-312(possess)-313(contemporaneous)-312(testimony)-313(of)-312(the)-313(highest)-312(order)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-423(the)-422(Epistles)-423(of)-422(St.)-768(Paul.)-768(I)-422(have)-423(already)-422(observed)-423(that)-422(no)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(documents)-334(are)-334(of)-335(higher)-334(historical)-334(value)-334(than)-334(letters)-334(composed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-285(persons)-285(actively)-284(engaged)-285(in)-285(the)-285(events)-285(to)-284(which)-285(they)-285(refer.)-354(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-223(now)-223(point)-222(out)-223(specifically)-223(the)-222(importance)-223(of)-223(these)-223(letters)-222(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-250(documents.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(First:)-227(four)-203(of)-204(the)-203(longest)-203(of)-204(them)-203(are)-204(admitted,)-213(by)-203(every)-203(school)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-254(unbelievers,)-254(who)-254(have)-254(given)-254(any)-253(consideration)-254(to)-254(the)-253(subject,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-420(be)-420(the)-419(genuine)-420(productions)-420(of)-420(the)-419(Apostle.)-760(The)-419(evidence,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(both)-383(external)-382(and)-383(internal,)-416(of)-383(his)-382(authorship,)-416(is)-383(of)-383(the)-382(highest)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(character.)-237(If)-213(it)-212(is)-212(not)-212(valid)-213(to)-212(prove)-212(that)-212(they)-213(were)-212(written)-212(by)-212(him,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-194(historical)-194(certitude)-194(is)-194(rendered)-195(impossible.)-231(They)-194(are)-194(the)-194(two)-194(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-191(Corinthians,)-203(and)-191(those)-191(addressed)-191(to)-191(the)-191(Romans)-191(and)-191(the)-191(Gala-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tians.)-460(Their)-321(importance)-320(is)-320(greatly)-320(enhanced)-320(by)-320(their)-320(presenting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-274(us)-273(a)-274(more)-273(distinct)-274(picture)-273(of)-274(the)-273(innermost)-274(life)-273(of)-274(the)-273(Apostle)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(than)-235(any)-234(others)-234(which)-235(have)-234(been)-235(attributed)-234(to)-235(him.)-245(To)-234(these)-234(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-251(added)-250(four)-250(more,)-251(viz.)-251(the)-251(two)-250(to)-251(the)-250(Thessalonians,)-251(and)-250(those)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1622 0 obj <<
/Length 4661      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(350)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(to)-277(t)1(he)-277(Philippians)-276(and)-277(to)-276(Philemon,)-283(which,)-284(although)-276(doubted)-276(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(some,)-269(are)-265(yet)-265(fully)-266(admitted)-265(by)-265(other)-265(unbelievers,)-269(among)-265(whom)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-296(Renan,)-307(to)-296(be)-296(genuine.)-387(The)-296(internal)-296(evidence)-296(that)-296(the)-295(Epistles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-411(the)-412(Philippians)-411(and)-412(to)-411(Philemon)-412(were)-411(written)-412(by)-411(the)-411(same)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(person)-379(who)-379(composed)-379(those)-379(to)-379(the)-379(Corinthians)-379(and)-379(Galatians,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-319(as)-319(strong)-319(as)-319(such)-318(evidence)-319(can)-319(possibly)-319(be.)-457(The)-319(whole)-318(form)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-327(thought)-328(is)-327(instinct)-327(with)-327(the)-328(presence)-327(of)-327(the)-327(same)-328(mind.)-481(Nor)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-259(the)-259(two)-259(to)-259(the)-259(Thessalonians)-259(admit)-259(of)-259(any)-259(reasonable)-258(doubt.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(To)-356(these)-357(follow)-356(the)-357(two)-356(to)-356(the)-357(Colossians)-356(and)-357(the)-712(Ephesians,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([399])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(for)-239(which)-239(the)-239(evidence)-239(is)-239(certainly)-240(less)-239(strong;)-242(but)-239(Renan)-239(admits)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-340(it)-339(greatly)-340(preponderates)-339(on)-340(the)-339(side)-340(of)-339(their)-340(being)-339(genuine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(productions)-310(of)-310(St.)-430(Paul.)-430(Altogether,)-325(then,)-325(we)-310(have)-310(eight)-310(letters)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-225(are)-225(undoubtedly)-225(his,)-231(and)-225(two)-225(more)-225(which)-225(are)-225(probably)-225(so;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instinct)-324(with)-325(his)-324(mind,)-343(and)-325(placing)-324(before)-325(us)-324(a)-325(vivid)-324(picture)-324(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(innermost)-250(life)-250(of)-250(the)-250(early)-250(Church.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(Secondly,)-342(as)-323(to)-323(their)-324(date.)-470(Six)-323(of)-324(them)-323(were)-323(unquestionably)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(written)-402(within)-403(twenty-eight)-402(years)-402(after)-402(the)-403(crucifixion,)-440(by)-402(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(most)-383(active)-382(agent)-383(in)-382(the)-383(propagation)-383(of)-382(Christianity,)-416(who)-382(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-425(employed)-425(in)-425(this)-424(work)-425(for)-425(a)-425(period)-425(of)-425(at)-425(least)-424(eighteen)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(years)-387(previously.)-662(Let)-387(us)-387(consider)-387(what)-387(such)-387(a)-387(period)-387(of)-387(time)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(really)-453(means.)-861(Twenty-eight)-453(years)-454(is)-453(about)-454(the)-453(period)-453(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(lies)-382(between)-381(the)-382(present)-381(year)-382(and)-381(the)-382(repeal)-381(of)-382(the)-381(corn-laws.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(While)-251(some)-251(of)-250(those)-251(who)-251(effected)-251(it)-250(have)-251(passed)-251(away,)-251(many)-250(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-343(who)-343(took)-342(a)-343(most)-343(active)-343(part)-342(in)-343(it)-343(are)-343(still)-342(living.)-529(All)-342(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-288(connected)-288(with)-289(it)-288(lie)-288(within)-288(the)-289(period)-288(of)-288(the)-288(most)-288(lively)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-231(recollection.)-243(Many)-231(persons)-231(are)-231(still)-230(alive)-231(who)-231(can)-230(look)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(back)-345(with)-346(the)-345(most)-345(perfect)-345(reminiscence)-345(to)-346(the)-345(great)-345(events)-345(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-317(anti-corn-law)-317(agitation.)-452(While)-317(these)-317(persons)-317(live,)-334(it)-317(will)-317(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impossible)-306(to)-306(encircle)-306(the)-306(chief)-306(actors)-306(in)-306(it)-306(with)-306(a)-306(halo)-306(of)-305(myth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-316(legend.)-448(In)-316(precisely)-316(the)-316(same)-316(position)-316(must)-316(multitudes)-316(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stood)-319(to)-320(the)-319(ministry)-320(of)-319(Jesus)-319(Christ,)-337(and)-319(the)-320(foundation)-319(of)-319(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-293(Church,)-303(when)-292(these)-293(Epistles)-292(were)-293(written.)-377(The)-293(fact)-292(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(worthy)-291(of)-292(our)-291(deepest)-292(attention,)-301(that)-292(when)-291(we)-292(read)-291(these)-291(letters)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-237(the)-236(various)-236(statements)-237(they)-236(contain,)-240(we)-236(are)-237(in)-236(the)-236(immediate)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1626 0 obj <<
/Length 4672      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(351)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(presence)-250(of)-250(some)-250(of)-250(the)-250(most)-250(important)-250(events)-250(in)-250(history.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Although)-324(St.)-473(Paul)-324(had)-324(never)-324(seen)-324(Jesus)-324(himself,)-343(yet)-324(his)-324(age)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(was)-324(such)-324(when)-324(he)-324(wrote)-324(these)-323(letters,)-343(that)-324(his)-324(recollection)-323(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(good)-257(for)-257(many)-257(years)-257(before)-257(the)-257(commencement)-257(of)-257(His)-256(ministry.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Great)-334(numbers)-335(of)-334(persons)-668(also)-335(were)-334(alive)-334(whose)-334(recollections)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([400])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(of)-365(events)-364(that)-365(occurred)-364(at)-365(a)-364(much)-364(earlier)-365(date)-364(must)-365(have)-364(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinct)-194(and)-195(clear.)-231(With)-194(the)-195(early)-194(followers)-194(of)-194(Jesus)-195(he)-194(had)-194(for)-194(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(less)-240(than)-241(twenty)-240(years)-240(every)-241(facility)-240(for)-240(holding)-240(communication.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Is)-232(it)-232(to)-232(be)-232(believed)-232(that)-232(a)-232(man)-232(whose)-232(entire)-232(being)-232(was)-232(swallowed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(up)-194(in)-194(one)-194(continuous)-193(sacrifice)-194(of)-194(himself)-194(to)-194(Jesus)-194(Christ,)-205(and)-193(who)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-287(penetrated)-286(with)-287(the)-287(profoundest)-287(love)-286(towards)-287(Him,)-296(had)-286(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accurately)-243(informed)-242(himself)-243(of)-242(the)-243(great)-242(facts)-243(of)-242(His)-243(earthly)-242(life,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-317(during)-318(the)-317(last)-318(twenty)-317(years)-318(he)-317(had)-318(enjoyed)-317(every)-317(means)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-240(obtaining)-240(information)-240(from)-240(His)-240(followers,)-242(and)-240(previously)-239(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(investigated)-306(it)-306(with)-307(the)-306(keen)-306(scent)-306(of)-306(an)-307(angry)-306(persecutor?)-418(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(idea)-353(is)-352(incredible.)-558(In)-352(these)-353(letters)-352(of)-353(St.)-557(Paul)-353(therefore,)-378(as)-352(far)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-393(they)-394(throw)-393(light)-394(on)-393(this)-393(subject,)-430(we)-393(are)-393(in)-394(the)-393(presence)-393(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contemporaneous)-250(historical)-250(evidence)-250(of)-250(the)-250(highest)-250(order.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Thirdly:)-236(Although)-223(these)-223(letters)-223(were)-223(written)-223(within)-223(so)-223(brief)-223(an)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(interval)-257(after)-257(the)-257(Crucifixion)-257(as)-257(from)-257(twenty-five)-257(to)-257(thirty)-256(years,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(yet)-344(they)-345(afford)-344(evidence)-344(which)-345(carries)-344(us)-344(up)-345(to)-344(a)-344(much)-344(earlier)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(period.)-294(St.)-293(Paul's)-265(conversion)-264(dates)-264(at)-265(least)-264(eighteen)-265(years)-264(earlier)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-315(the)-314(earliest)-315(of)-314(them.)-444(His)-314(testimony)-314(therefore)-315(is)-314(good)-315(as)-314(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-306(general)-307(nature)-306(of)-306(the)-306(beliefs)-306(of)-307(the)-306(Christian)-306(Church)-306(during)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-323(whole)-323(period)-323(of)-323(his)-323(ministry.)-469(It)-322(proves,)-342(among)-323(many)-322(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(things,)-389(this)-362(all-important)-361(point,)-389(that)-361(the)-362(Resurrection)-361(of)-361(Christ)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-232(believed)-231(by)-232(the)-232(whole)-231(Christian)-232(community,)-235(and)-232(formed)-231(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(groundwork)-280(of)-281(the)-280(existence)-281(of)-280(the)-280(Church,)-288(within)-281(less)-280(than)-280(ten)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(years)-302(after)-302(the)-302(crucifixion.)-406(But)-302(the)-302(Apostle's)-302(hostile)-302(connection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-415(the)-415(Christian)-415(sect)-415(dates)-414(still)-415(earlier.)-745(As)-415(a)-415(persecutor)-414(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-452(have)-451(ascertained)-452(what)-451(were)-451(the)-452(leading)-451(subjects)-452(of)-451(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-302(belief,)-315(and)-302(must)-302(have)-302(subjected)-302(the)-302(whole)-302(matter)-302(to)-302(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(rigid)-282(investigation.)-347(Above)-282(all,)-290(he)-282(could)-282(not)-282(have)-282(failed)-282(to)-282(know)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whether)-566(the)-283(belief)-283(in)-283(the)-283(Resurrection)-283(of)-283(Christ)-283(was)-283(or)-283(was)-282(not)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([401])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1632 0 obj <<
/Length 4455      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(352)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(from)-362(its)-362(commencement)-362(the)-361(ground)-362(of)-362(the)-362(renewed)-362(life)-362(of)-361(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-250(Church.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Every)-406(consideration)-405(must)-406(have)-405(induced)-406(him)-405(when)-406(a)-405(perse-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(cutor)-324(to)-324(make)-323(this)-324(entire)-324(question)-324(the)-323(subject)-324(of)-324(a)-324(most)-323(careful)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(investigation.)-459(Nothing)-320(was)-320(more)-319(important)-320(than)-320(that)-320(he)-319(should)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ascertain)-232(whether)-231(any)-232(considerable)-232(interval)-231(had)-232(elapsed)-231(between)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-389(Crucifixion)-390(of)-389(Christ)-390(and)-389(the)-390(propagation)-389(of)-390(the)-389(report)-389(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-306(Resurrection;)-334(and)-307(his)-306(means)-306(of)-306(ascertaining)-306(the)-306(truth)-306(about)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-257(must)-258(have)-257(been)-258(complete.)-272(To)-258(determine)-257(this)-258(for)-257(certain)-257(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-234(been)-234(most)-234(important)-233(in)-234(his)-234(work)-234(of)-234(convicting)-234(the)-233(founders)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-345(the)-345(new)-344(sect)-345(of)-345(imposture;)-392(for)-345(if)-345(any)-345(considerable)-345(time)-344(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(elapsed)-389(between)-389(the)-389(death)-389(and)-389(reported)-390(resurrection,)-423(it)-389(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-406(afforded)-407(that)-406(of)-406(which)-407(all)-406(the)-406(theories)-407(of)-406(unbelief)-406(stand)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-300(need,)-313(a)-300(sufficient)-300(interval)-299(for)-300(the)-300(delusion)-300(to)-300(grow)-300(and)-300(prop-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agate)-447(itself;)-546(or,)-496(if)-448(the)-447(belief)-447(was)-447(the)-447(result)-448(of)-447(fraud,)-496(for)-447(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(imposition)-416(to)-416(be)-415(concocted)-416(and)-416(spread.)-747(St.)-748(Paul's)-415(testimony)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-267(affords)-268(the)-267(most)-268(conclusive)-267(proof)-268(that)-267(the)-268(belief)-267(in)-267(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Resurrection)-237(as)-237(a)-237(fact)-237(was)-237(contemporaneous)-237(with)-237(the)-237(foundation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-297(the)-298(Church;)-321(that)-297(it)-298(was)-297(the)-298(cause)-297(of)-298(i)1(ts)-298(renewed)-297(vitality;)-321(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-345(interval)-346(could)-345(have)-345(elapsed)-345(between)-345(the)-346(death)-345(of)-345(Jesus)-345(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(His)-359(reported)-359(resurrection,)-386(sufficient)-359(for)-359(the)-359(growth)-359(of)-359(myth)-358(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(legend,)-255(the)-253(fabrication)-254(of)-254(an)-254(imposture,)-254(or)-254(the)-254(gradual)-253(spreading)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-251(hallucinations)-250(of)-250(a)-251(single)-250(individual)-250(among)-251(a)-250(multitude)-250(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(persons.)-265(In)-255(one)-256(word,)-256(if)-255(the)-255(belief)-255(in)-255(the)-255(Resurrection)-255(originated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-309(the)-309(conversion)-310(of)-309(some)-309(subjective)-309(delusion)-309(into)-309(an)-309(objective)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact,)-258(it)-257(must)-257(have)-257(been)-256(one)-257(which)-257(spread)-257(with)-256(incomprehensible)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(rapidity.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(These)-348(letters)-348(also)-349(form)-348(the)-348(most)-348(convincing)-348(proof,)-373(not)-348(only)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-351(the)-351(Resurrection)-350(was)-351(universally)-351(believed)-350(as)-351(a)-351(fact)-351(by)-350(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(communities)-454(to)-454(which)-453(they)-454(were)-908(addressed,)-504(but)-454(that)-454(it)-453(was)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([402])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(accepted)-272(by)-273(the)-272(individual)-273(members)-272(of)-272(these)-273(Churches)-272(from)-272(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first)-247(commencement)-247(of)-246(their)-247(Christianity.)-249(Although)-247(two)-247(of)-246(these)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Churches)-282(had)-282(been)-281(planted)-282(by)-282(St.)-345(Paul,)-290(that)-282(of)-282(the)-282(Romans)-281(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-329(planted)-329(by)-330(him,)-348(and)-330(was)-329(of)-329(considerable)-329(standing)-329(when)-329(he)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1636 0 obj <<
/Length 4834      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(353)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(wrote)-230(the)-230(letter.)-243(Its)-230(fame)-230(had)-230(spread)-230(throughout)-230(the)-230(whole)-229(Chris-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tian)-244(world.)-247(Everything)-244(in)-244(the)-243(Epistle)-244(denotes)-243(that)-244(its)-243(Christianity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-367(of)-367(no)-366(recent)-367(growth.)-600(Many)-367(of)-367(these)-367(Churches,)-395(especially)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-353(Jewish)-353(portions)-352(of)-353(them,)-378(could)-353(carry)-353(their)-353(recollections)-352(up)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-315(a)-314(much)-315(earlier)-315(time.)-444(It)-314(should)-315(be)-315(carefully)-314(observed)-315(that)-314(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interval)-294(of)-293(twenty-eight)-294(years)-293(from)-294(the)-294(foundation)-293(of)-294(a)-293(sect)-294(is)-293(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(period)-371(wholly)-371(insufficient)-372(for)-371(the)-371(growth)-371(of)-371(an)-371(hereditary)-371(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(otiose)-194(faith.)-232(The)-194(majority)-194(of)-194(the)-195(members)-194(of)-194(these)-194(Churches)-194(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(beyond)-231(all)-231(doubt)-231(actual)-231(converts,)-235(who)-231(had)-231(once)-231(been)-231(either)-230(Jews)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(or)-362(Pagans.)-585(However)-362(credulous)-362(we)-361(may)-362(suppose)-362(them)-362(to)-361(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been,)-242(their)-241(conversion)-240(must)-240(have)-241(been)-240(due)-240(to)-241(an)-240(inquiry)-240(of)-240(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(kind.)-479(The)-326(short)-327(period)-326(which)-326(had)-327(elapsed)-326(since)-326(the)-326(foundation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-324(the)-324(Church)-324(and)-323(the)-324(supreme)-324(interest)-324(which)-324(the)-324(whole)-324(of)-323(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-194(and)-194(circumstances)-194(must)-195(have)-194(excited)-194(in)-194(the)-194(converts,)-205(were)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(precisely)-232(what)-231(was)-232(requisite)-231(for)-231(preserving)-232(traditionary)-231(recollec-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tions)-206(with)-206(the)-205(utmost)-206(soundness.)-235(There)-206(could)-206(have)-206(been)-206(no)-205(doubt)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-204(any)-204(of)-205(their)-204(minds)-204(whether)-204(or)-204(not)-205(the)-204(belief)-204(in)-204(the)-204(Resurrection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-197(the)-198(groundwork)-197(of)-197(their)-197(Christianity.)-233(They)-197(must)-197(have)-197(known)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-297(whether)-297(it)-297(was)-297(a)-297(story)-297(which)-297(had)-297(gradually)-297(spread,)-308(or)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(had)-272(existed)-272(from)-272(the)-271(beginning;)-283(or)-272(whether)-272(the)-272(peculiar)-272(form)-271(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-264(was)-263(an)-264(invention)-264(of)-263(St.)-292(Paul;)-270(or)-264(whether)-263(it)-264(was)-264(the)-263(foundation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-337(the)-337(convictions)-336(of)-337(those)-337(by)-336(whom)-337(they)-337(had)-337(been)-336(converted.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-314(manner)-314(in)-314(which)-314(the)-314(fact)-314(of)-314(the)-314(Resurrection)-314(is)-314(referred)-313(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-286(these)-286(Epistles)-286(proves)-286(that)-286(the)-286(belief)-286(was)-286(of)-286(no)-286(recent)-285(growth,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(but)-280(had)-561(existed)-280(from)-280(the)-280(beginning.)-341(The)-280(Epistle)-280(to)-280(the)-280(Romans)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([403])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(opens)-309(with)-310(these)-309(words:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 107.087 0 Td [(\024\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.753 0 Td [(Concerning)-309(His)-310(Son)-309(Jesus)-310(Christ)-309(...)]TJ -122.84 -13.549 Td [(who)-320(was)-320(declared)-319(to)-320(be)-320(the)-320(Son)-320(of)-320(God)-319(with)-320(power,)-337(according)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(the)-251(Spirit)-250(of)-250(holiness,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 107.296 0 Td [(by)-250(the)-251(resurrection)-250(from)-250(the)-250(dead)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 146.361 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.574 0 Td [(It)-250(is)]TJ -263.958 -13.549 Td [(impossible)-228(that)-228(a)-228(writer)-228(could)-228(have)-228(made)-228(such)-228(a)-228(reference)-228(as)-228(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-334(the)-335(opening)-334(of)-335(his)-334(letter,)-356(unless)-334(he)-335(had)-334(been)-335(certain)-334(that)-334(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(belief)-329(in)-329(the)-329(Resurrection)-330(had)-329(been)-329(accepted)-329(as)-329(a)-329(fact)-329(by)-329(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whom)-219(he)-219(addressed,)-225(and)-219(by)-219(the)-219(whole)-219(Christian)-219(community)-218(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whom)-250(they)-250(were)-250(acquainted.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-211(further:)-231(it)-211(is)-212(utterly)-211(incredible)-211(that)-212(if)-211(the)-211(converts)-211(accepted)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1640 0 obj <<
/Length 4673      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(354)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(the)-294(fact)-293(of)-294(the)-293(Resurrection)-293(of)-294(Jesus)-293(Christ)-294(as)-293(the)-294(foundation)-293(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-304(Christianity,)-318(they)-304(should)-305(have)-304(contentedly)-304(remained)-304(igno-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rant)-303(of)-303(the)-302(facts)-303(of)-303(His)-303(previous)-302(history,)-316(at)-303(a)-303(period)-303(when)-302(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-376(have)-376(been)-376(abundant)-376(means)-376(of)-376(obtaining)-376(an)-375(acquaintance)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(Fourthly:)-326(the)-288(value)-288(of)-288(these)-288(letters)-288(as)-288(historical)-288(documents)-288(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(greatly)-294(increased)-293(by)-294(the)-293(fact)-294(that)-294(a)-293(strong)-294(spirit)-293(of)-294(party)-293(existed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-269(the)-268(Churches.)-306(None)-268(are)-269(more)-268(ready)-269(to)-268(accept)-269(the)-268(fact)-269(that)-268(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church)-262(was)-261(divided)-262(into)-262(a)-261(number)-262(of)-262(parties)-261(than)-262(the)-261(opponents)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-248(Christianity.)-249(Not)-247(only)-248(have)-248(they)-247(admitted)-248(it,)-248(but)-247(for)-248(their)-247(own)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purposes)-369(they)-368(have)-369(greatly)-369(exaggerated)-368(it.)-606(But)-369(it)-368(is)-369(a)-368(weapon)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-273(can)-272(be)-273(used)-272(in)-272(defence)-273(of)-272(Christianity)-273(more)-272(efficaciously)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-262(in)-263(opposition)-262(to)-263(it.)-287(It)-263(is)-262(clear)-263(on)-262(the)-263(face)-262(of)-263(these)-262(letters)-262(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-286(that)-286(the)-285(Churches)-286(were)-286(divided)-286(into)-285(parties,)-295(but)-286(that)-285(party-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(spirit)-311(existed)-311(in)-311(them)-311(with)-311(considerable)-311(violence.)-433(It)-311(is)-311(needless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-284(the)-284(purpose)-284(of)-285(the)-284(present)-284(argument)-284(to)-284(ascertain)-284(the)-284(number)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-232(the)-233(parties)-232(into)-232(which)-233(some)-232(of)-232(the)-233(Churches)-232(were)-232(divided;)-238(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-203(letters,)-212(confirmed)-203(as)-203(they)-202(are)-203(by)-203(incidental)-203(references)-203(in)-202(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Acts)-242(of)-242(the)-242(Apostles,)-244(leave)-242(no)-242(doubt)-242(that)-241(the)-242(opposition)-242(between)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(St.)-471(Paul)-324(and)-324(those)-324(who)-323(followed)-324(his)-324(teaching,)-342(and)-324(a)-647(powerful)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([404])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(Judaizing)-297(party)-297(in)-297(the)-297(Church,)-309(was)-297(of)-297(a)-297(very)-296(decided)-297(character;)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-200(this)-200(party)-200(had)-200(a)-200(great)-200(dislike)-200(to)-200(the)-200(person)-200(of)-200(the)-200(Apostle;)-216(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-223(he)-223(himself)-223(denounced)-223(them)-223(as)-223(corrupters)-223(of)-223(the)-223(fundamental)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(principles)-209(of)-209(the)-209(Gospel.)-236(They)-209(make)-209(it)-209(quite)-209(clear)-209(that)-209(even)-209(in)-208(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Churches)-241(of)-240(which)-241(he)-240(was)-241(the)-240(founder,)-242(the)-241(Apostle)-240(was)-241(far)-240(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(having)-387(it)-387(all)-387(his)-387(own)-388(way.)-661(Judaizing)-387(teachers)-387(had)-387(made)-387(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(considerable)-319(progress)-318(in)-319(ali)1(enating)-319(the)-318(Galatian)-319(Churches)-318(from)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(him.)-524(His)-341(letter)-342(to)-341(these)-341(Churches)-342(discusses)-341(the)-341(entire)-341(question)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(between)-365(him)-364(and)-365(his)-365(opponents,)-393(who)-365(actually)-364(went)-365(the)-364(length)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-356(denying)-357(his)-356(apostolical)-357(authority.)-569(In)-356(the)-357(Church)-356(of)-356(Corinth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(also)-275(there)-275(was)-276(a)-275(powerful)-275(Judaizing)-275(party,)-282(who)-275(affirmed)-275(that)-275(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-251(no)-250(true)-251(Apostle.)-251(In)-251(this)-251(Church)-250(there)-251(were)-250(also)-251(other)-250(parties)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(who)-376(designated)-376(themselves)-376(by)-376(the)-376(names)-376(of)-376(particular)-375(leaders)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-352(various)-352(degrees)-352(of)-352(opposition)-352(to)-352(St.)-556(Paul.)-556(It)-352(is)-352(evident)-352(that)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1644 0 obj <<
/Length 4566      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(355)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(these)-278(parties)-279(must)-278(have)-279(derived)-278(their)-278(views)-279(of)-278(Christianity)-278(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-322(source)-322(quite)-323(independent)-322(of)-322(the)-322(Apostle.)-467(Portions)-322(of)-322(the)-322(first)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-308(not)-309(less)-308(than)-309(half)-308(of)-308(the)-309(second)-308(Epistle)-308(are)-309(occupied)-308(by)-308(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Paul)-386(in)-387(setting)-386(forth)-386(his)-387(claims)-386(in)-386(opposition)-387(to)-386(these)-386(leaders.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(It)-362(is)-362(altogether)-361(a)-362(mistake)-362(to)-361(suppose)-362(that)-362(these)-362(Churches)-361(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disposed)-261(to)-260(accept)-261(his)-260(assertions)-261(without)-261(question,)-263(as)-260(equivalent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-419(oracles)-419(from)-419(Heaven.)-757(On)-418(the)-419(contrary,)-462(Judaizing)-418(teachers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(habitually)-341(followed)-340(his)-341(steps,)-363(and)-341(to)-341(some)-340(extent)-341(succeeded)-340(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subverting)-250(the)-250(faith)-250(even)-250(of)-250(his)-250(own)-250(converts.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Nothing)-358(can)-358(more)-358(enhance)-357(the)-358(value)-358(of)-358(these)-358(letters)-358(as)-357(his-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(torical)-383(documents)-384(than)-383(the)-383(existence)-383(of)-384(this)-383(party-spirit)-383(in)-383(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Churches)-290(to)-290(which)-291(they)-290(were)-290(addressed.)-370(If)-291(St.)-370(Paul)-290(had)-290(written)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-421(to)-422(none)-421(but)-421(devoted)-422(admirers,)-464(as)-421(is)-422(frequently)-421(the)-421(case)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-443(the)-442(leaders)-443(of)-443(religious)-443(sects,)-490(his)-443(assertions)-443(might)-442(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-406(open)-405(to)-406(grave)-406(suspicion.)-716(It)-406(might)-406(have)-405(been)-406(urged)-405(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-915(persons)-458(were)-458(ready)-458(to)-457(accept)-458(anything)-458(and)-457(everything)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([405])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(which)-231(he)-231(affirmed.)-243(But)-231(nothing)-231(is)-230(more)-231(keen-eyed)-231(than)-230(religious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(party-spirit)-248(in)-247(detecting)-248(and)-247(denouncing)-247(the)-248(false)-247(positions)-248(of)-247(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opponent,)-236(even)-231(when)-232(it)-232(is)-232(sufficiently)-232(ready)-232(to)-232(accept)-231(everything)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-364(makes)-363(in)-364(its)-364(own)-364(favour.)-591(So)-363(strong)-364(was)-364(the)-363(opposition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-311(the)-310(Apostle,)-326(that)-310(in)-311(two)-310(of)-311(these)-310(Churches,)-326(as)-310(we)-311(have)-310(seen,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-306(powerful)-307(party)-306(existed)-306(who)-307(went)-306(the)-306(extreme)-307(length)-306(of)-306(deny-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ing)-349(his)-348(right)-349(to)-349(the)-349(apostolic)-348(office.)-547(Yet)-348(these)-349(letters)-349(were)-348(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-364(intended)-364(to)-364(be)-364(read)-364(to)-364(the)-364(whole)-364(Church,)-392(but)-364(portions)-364(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-301(are)-301(directly)-301(addressed)-301(to)-301(the)-301(opponents)-301(in)-301(question.)-403(What)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(guarantee)-425(of)-424(the)-425(truthfulness)-424(of)-425(statements)-424(can)-425(compare)-424(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this?)-294(The)-264(Apostle's)-265(letters)-264(are)-265(openly)-265(read)-264(in)-265(the)-264(presence)-265(of)-264(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(opposing)-277(party,)-283(before)-277(the)-277(assembled)-276(Church,)-284(challenging)-276(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-373(impugn)-373(his)-373(statements.)-619(It)-373(will)-373(perhaps)-373(be)-373(objected)-373(that)-373(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-301(no)-301(record)-300(of)-301(the)-301(discussion)-300(which)-301(followed)-301(the)-301(reading)-300(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-382(letters,)-415(and)-382(of)-381(the)-382(results)-382(attending)-382(it.)-646(The)-382(second)-381(Epistle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-347(the)-346(Corinthians)-347(has)-346(preserved)-347(some)-347(of)-346(those)-347(results,)-370(though)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-301(is)-302(plain)-301(that)-301(an)-302(opposing)-301(party)-301(still)-302(continued.)-404(This)-301(Epistle)-301(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-349(very)-349(strenuous)-348(attack)-349(on)-349(them.)-546(The)-349(man)-349(who)-349(had)-349(the)-348(moral)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1648 0 obj <<
/Length 4665      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(356)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(courage)-228(to)-228(write)-228(such)-227(letters)-228(as)-228(the)-228(second)-228(to)-228(the)-228(Corinthians)-227(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-375(to)-376(the)-375(Galatians,)-406(to)-376(be)-375(openly)-375(read)-375(in)-376(the)-375(presence)-375(of)-375(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adversaries,)-281(must)-276(have)-275(been)-275(well)-275(assured)-275(of)-275(the)-275(goodness)-275(of)-275(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cause.)-249(Common)-248(sense)-247(alone)-248(would)-247(have)-248(suggested)-247(to)-248(him)-247(not)-247(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(make)-312(in)-312(them)-312(statements)-312(which)-312(were)-312(sure)-312(to)-312(receive)-312(direct)-311(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instant)-250(contradiction.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-268(is)-268(clear,)-273(therefore,)-272(that)-268(certain)-268(points)-268(on)-268(which)-268(these)-268(letters)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(make)-309(very)-310(definite)-309(statements)-309(must)-309(have)-310(been)-309(held)-309(in)-309(common)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-349(St.)-547(Paul)-349(and)-349(his)-349(opponents.)-547(If)-349(it)-349(had)-350(not)-349(been)-349(so,)-373(it)-349(is)-349(im-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possible)-295(that)-295(the)-295(letters)-295(could)-295(have)-295(been)-295(written)-295(in)-295(their)-295(present)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(form.)-328(The)-552(Christianity)-276(on)-276(which)-276(the)-276(two)-276(parties)-276(agreed)-275(beyond)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([406])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(all)-315(doubt,)-331(concentrated)-315(itself)-315(around)-315(the)-315(Messianic)-315(character)-315(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus.)-706(The)-402(letters)-402(themselves)-402(make)-402(the)-402(points)-402(on)-402(which)-401(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disagreed)-317(sufficiently)-317(obvious,)-333(centering)-317(as)-316(they)-317(did)-317(on)-317(the)-316(ne-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cessity)-288(of)-289(observing)-288(the)-288(rites)-289(of)-288(the)-288(Mosaic)-289(law)-288(in)-288(the)-288(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Church.)-494(But)-331(the)-331(Epistles)-332(contain)-331(a)-331(vast)-332(number)-331(of)-331(allusions)-331(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-211(subjects,)-219(not)-211(a)-210(few)-211(of)-211(which)-211(are)-211(of)-211(a)-211(very)-211(incidental)-210(charac-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ter.)-315(What)-271(is)-272(the)-271(only)-272(legitimate)-271(inference)-272(which)-271(can)-272(be)-271(deduced)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-284(this)-284(circumstance?)-351(Obviously)-284(that)-284(the)-284(Apostle)-284(wrote)-283(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-315(the)-315(fullest)-316(conviction)-315(that)-315(his)-315(statements)-315(on)-315(these)-315(subjects)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(would)-278(be)-279(accepted)-278(by)-278(his)-279(opponents)-278(as)-278(part)-279(of)-278(their)-278(joint)-278(belief;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-377(not)-378(only)-377(by)-377(them,)-409(but)-378(by)-377(all)-377(the)-378(members)-377(of)-377(the)-377(Church.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-324(is)-324(inconceivable)-323(that)-324(a)-324(man)-324(of)-324(the)-324(mental)-323(calibre)-324(of)-324(St.)-471(Paul)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-300(have)-301(written)-300(letters)-301(such)-300(as)-301(those)-300(to)-301(the)-300(Corinthians)-300(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Galatians,)-476(abounding)-431(as)-431(they)-431(do)-431(with)-431(references)-431(to)-431(facts)-431(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(doctrines,)-217(if)-208(he)-208(had)-208(not)-208(been)-208(fully)-208(persuaded)-208(that)-208(they)-208(constituted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(common)-250(faith)-250(of)-250(himself)-250(and)-250(those)-250(to)-250(whom)-250(he)-250(wrote.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-315(is)-315(impossible)-315(to)-315(over-estimate)-315(the)-315(historical)-315(importance)-314(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(letters)-383(like)-382(these,)-416(when)-383(in)-383(this)-382(incidental)-383(manner)-383(they)-382(contain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(numerous)-443(references)-443(to)-443(facts)-443(and)-443(opinions,)-491(and)-443(to)-443(the)-443(actual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(controversies)-372(then)-371(existing)-372(in)-372(the)-371(Church.)-615(The)-372(form)-372(in)-371(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-351(are)-350(made)-351(constitute)-351(us)-350(almost)-351(as)-351(adequate)-350(judges)-351(of)-350(their)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(value)-207(as)-206(if)-207(we)-207(were)-207(able)-206(to)-207(interrogate)-207(their)-206(author.)-236(We)-207(have)-206(him,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-234(fact,)-236(in)-234(the)-233(witness-box)-234(before)-233(us,)-237(and)-233(can)-234(narrowly)-233(scrutinize)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1652 0 obj <<
/Length 4527      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(357)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(his)-224(mental)-223(character.)-242(They)-223(can)-224(leave)-224(no)-223(doubt)-224(on)-223(our)-224(minds)-224(as)-223(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whether)-196(the)-196(allusions)-197(were)-196(incidental,)-207(or)-196(made)-196(for)-196(a)-196(purpose.)-232(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(value)-248(of)-248(letters,)-248(written)-248(by)-247(persons)-248(who)-248(have)-248(impressed)-248(on)-247(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-295(image)-296(of)-295(their)-296(own)-295(inner)-295(life)-296(and)-295(character,)-307(and)-295(referring)-295(at)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-253(same)-253(time)-254(to)-253(current)-253(events)-253(and)-253(opinions,)-254(is)-253(now)-253(universally)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acknowledged)-267(as)-268(the)-267(best)-268(means)-535(of)-267(correcting)-268(the)-267(mistakes)-267(and)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([407])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(misrepresentations)-359(of)-359(formal)-359(histories.)-576(But)-359(when)-359(we)-359(take)-358(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consideration)-392(that)-392(these)-392(letters)-391(of)-392(St.)-676(Paul)-392(are)-392(outpourings)-391(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-277(inmost)-276(mind,)-284(intended)-277(not)-276(only)-277(for)-277(admiring)-276(friends,)-284(but)-276(for)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(scrutinizing)-254(opponents,)-256(we)-254(have)-254(before)-255(us)-254(historical)-254(evidence)-254(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(highest)-250(order.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Fifthly:)-334(The)-292(Apostle)-292(presents)-292(himself)-292(to)-292(us)-292(in)-292(these)-292(letters)-292(in)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-259(fullest)-259(outbursts)-259(of)-259(his)-260(heart.)-277(We)-259(have)-259(the)-259(whole)-259(man)-259(before)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us,)-432(intellectually,)-432(morally,)-432(and)-396(religiously.)-686(Probably)-396(no)-395(eight)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(letters)-220(exist)-219(in)-219(all)-220(literature,)-226(from)-219(which)-220(it)-219(is)-219(possible)-220(to)-219(construct)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-357(equal)-357(fulness)-356(the)-357(mental)-357(portraiture)-357(of)-356(the)-357(writer.)-570(Nowhere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-352(we)-352(find)-351(stronger)-352(bursts)-352(of)-352(feeling.)-555(He)-352(was)-352(a)-352(man)-352(of)-351(deep)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sensibility,)-288(united)-280(with)-280(the)-280(firmest)-280(resolve.)-340(His)-280(sacrifice)-280(of)-280(self,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-242(complete)-242(freedom)-243(from)-242(all)-242(selfish)-242(aims,)-244(is)-242(exceeded)-242(by)-242(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-400(character)-400(in)-399(history.)-700(Who)-399(can)-400(read)-400(these)-400(letters)-399(through,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-371(question)-371(the)-371(sincerity)-371(of)-371(the)-371(writer?)-613(Can)-371(any)-371(one)-370(believe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-259(he)-259(was)-259(not)-258(true)-259(to)-259(his)-259(convictions,)-261(or)-259(that)-259(he)-259(was)-259(capable)-258(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(deliberately)-308(stating)-309(what)-308(he)-309(knew)-308(to)-309(be)-308(false?)-425(If)-309(the)-308(facts)-308(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-262(as)-261(he)-262(has)-262(stated)-262(them,)-264(the)-262(only)-262(possible)-261(alternative)-262(is)-262(that)-261(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-253(the)-252(prey)-253(of)-253(an)-252(hallucination.)-258(Yet)-253(in)-253(every)-252(detail)-253(of)-252(business,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-302(in)-302(disposing)-302(of)-301(all)-302(practical)-302(questions,)-315(his)-302(judgment)-302(was)-301(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(soundest)-250(character.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(There)-428(is)-429(one)-428(remarkable)-429(fact)-428(which)-429(these)-428(letters)-429(bring)-428(out)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(distinctly,)-228(which)-222(is)-222(probably)-222(true)-222(of)-223(no)-222(other)-222(man)-222(that)-222(ever)-222(lived.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-310(Apostle)-311(claimed)-310(to)-310(decide)-311(certain)-310(questions)-310(authoritatively)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-424(virtue)-424(of)-425(a)-424(divine)-424(guidance)-424(which)-424(he)-425(possessed.)-772(He)-424(gave)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-378(decision)-378(on)-377(two)-378(points,)-410(having)-377(the)-378(closest)-378(bearing)-378(on)-377(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(daily)-325(life)-324(of)-325(the)-325(Chri)1(stians)-325(of)-325(that)-324(day,)-344(and)-324(which)-325(excited)-324(deep)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conscientious)-356(scruples.)-569(These)-356(were:)-463(whether)-356(the)-356(obligation)-356(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1657 0 obj <<
/Length 4888      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(358)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(observing)-232(certain)-232(days)-233(was)-232(binding)-232(on)-232(the)-464(Christian)-232(conscience,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([408])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(and)-258(whether)-259(it)-258(was)-259(unlawful)-258(to)-258(eat)-259(meat)-258(which)-259(had)-258(been)-258(offered)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-324(sacrifice)-324(to)-324(a)-324(heathen)-324(god.)-472(On)-324(each)-324(of)-324(these)-324(points)-324(he)-323(gives)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-400(own)-400(apostolical)-400(decision;)-476(yet)-400(in)-400(the)-400(very)-400(act)-400(of)-400(doing)-400(so,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(he)-303(directly)-303(enjoins)-303(that)-303(the)-303(conscientious)-303(scruples)-303(of)-303(those)-303(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(could)-327(not)-328(acquiesce)-327(in)-327(it)-328(should)-327(be)-327(respected.)-482(Can)-328(this)-327(be)-327(said)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-312(any)-312(other)-311(man)-312(who)-312(thought)-311(that)-312(he)-312(possessed)-312(a)-311(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(guidance?)-244(Enthusiastic)-234(he)-233(was;)-239(but)-233(his)-234(was)-233(an)-233(enthusiasm)-233(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(did)-417(not)-417(blind)-417(his)-416(judgment.)-751(He)-417(was)-417(a)-417(man,)-458(too,)-459(of)-417(a)-416(highly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(delicate)-281(mind,)-288(yet)-280(capable)-281(of)-281(using)-280(a)-281(refined)-280(sarcasm)-281(in)-280(dealing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-303(his)-303(opponents.)-408(We)-303(have)-303(the)-303(whole)-303(man)-303(before)-303(us,)-316(and)-302(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entire)-250(character)-250(renders)-250(him)-250(a)-250(witness)-250(of)-250(the)-250(highest)-250(order.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(As)-413(modern)-413(unbelievers)-414(refuse)-413(to)-413(allow)-413(us)-414(to)-413(appeal)-413(to)-413(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-467(as)-467(historical)-466(documents,)-521(it)-467(becomes)-467(a)-467(matter)-467(of)-466(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(highest)-223(importance)-223(to)-223(ascertain)-223(what)-223(facts)-223(in)-223(connection)-223(with)-222(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(origin)-289(of)-290(Christianity)-289(and)-290(the)-289(beliefs)-290(of)-289(the)-290(earliest)-289(followers)-289(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Jesus)-218(can)-218(be)-218(established)-218(with)-218(the)-218(aid)-218(of)-218(these)-218(letters.)-239(Unbelievers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-356(dispute)-356(that)-356(they)-356(are)-356(the)-356(authentic)-356(writings)-356(of)-356(the)-356(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(active)-413(agent)-413(in)-412(the)-413(propagation)-413(of)-413(Christianity,)-453(who)-413(has)-412(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tributed)-340(more)-340(to)-340(its)-340(permanent)-340(establishment)-340(than)-340(any)-340(other)-340(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-240(disciples)-240(of)-241(Jesus.)-246(This)-240(being)-241(so,)-242(it)-240(is)-240(impossible)-240(to)-240(deny)-240(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-400(are)-401(contemporary)-400(historical)-400(records)-401(of)-400(the)-400(highest)-400(value.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Our)-235(opponents)-234(demand)-235(contemporary)-235(testimony,)-237(and)-235(we)-234(present)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-343(with)-344(the)-343(Epistles)-344(of)-343(St.)-530(Paul.)-530(In)-344(pursuing)-343(this)-343(argument,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-301(will)-301(be)-302(my)-301(duty)-301(to)-301(forget)-301(that)-302(we)-301(Christians)-301(consider)-301(that)-301(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-373(who)-372(wrote)-373(them)-373(had)-372(a)-373(supernatural)-373(guidance,)-403(and)-373(to)-372(use)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-280(as)-281(I)-280(would)-280(the)-280(letters)-280(of)-281(Cicero.)-340(I)-281(will)-280(proceed)-280(to)-280(examine)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(their)-250(testimony.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(First:)-562(It)-406(has)-406(been)-406(asserted,)-445(with)-406(a)-406(view)-406(of)-406(weakening)-811(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([409])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(evidence)-226(of)-225(the)-226(supernatural)-226(porti)1(ons)-226(of)-226(the)-225(New)-226(Testament,)-230(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(although)-226(its)-226(writers)-226(have)-226(reported)-226(miracles)-226(as)-226(wrought)-226(by)-226(others,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-215(one)-216(of)-215(them)-216(has)-215(affirmed)-215(that)-216(he)-215(himself)-216(ever)-215(performed)-215(one.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-416(reply)-416(that)-416(St.)-748(Paul)-416(distinctly)-416(affirms)-416(that)-416(he)-416(believed)-415(he)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(wrought)-217(miracles.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 81.028 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Truly,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 26.967 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.216 0 Td [(says)-217(he,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 36.625 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(the)-217(signs)-218(of)-217(an)-218(apostle)-217(were)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1662 0 obj <<
/Length 5212      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(359)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(wrought)-315(among)-315(you)-315(in)-315(all)-315(patience,)-332(in)-315(signs,)-331(and)-315(wonders,)-331(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mighty)-376(deeds.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 62.588 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.948 0 Td [(\0502)-376(Cor.)-629(xii.)-628(12.\051)-629(He)-376(here)-376(affirms)-377(that)-376(such)-376(a)]TJ -71.536 -13.549 Td [(power)-259(was)-258(possessed)-259(not)-258(only)-259(by)-258(himself,)-261(but)-258(by)-259(other)-258(Apostles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(also.)-295(The)-265(power)-265(to)-266(perform)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 122.941 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(signs,)-269(wonders,)-269(and)-265(mighty)-265(deeds)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 148.002 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.787 -13.55 Td [(was)-250(directly)-250(connected)-250(with)-250(the)-250(apostolic)-250(office.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Again,)-338(he)-321(says)-320(to)-321(the)-320(Galatians)-321(\050iii.)-461(5\051,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 178.663 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(He)-320(that)-321(ministereth)]TJ -195.463 -13.549 Td [(to)-440(you)-440(the)-440(Spirit,)-488(and)-440(worketh)-440(miracles)-440(among)-440(you.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 241.334 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.644 0 Td [(In)-440(this)]TJ -250.978 -13.549 Td [(reference)-365(he)-365(evidently)-365(means)-365(himself,)-394(and)-365(affirms)-365(that)-365(he)-365(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performed)-250(miracles)-250(in)-250(Galatia.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(In)-263(the)-263(Epistle)-263(to)-264(the)-263(Romans)-263(he)-263(makes)-263(the)-263(following)-263(affirma-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tion:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 23.911 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(For)-304(I)-304(will)-304(not)-304(dare)-303(to)-304(speak)-304(of)-304(any)-304(of)-304(those)-304(things)-304(which)]TJ -28.754 -13.55 Td [(Christ)-206(hath)-206(not)-205(wrought)-206(by)-206(me,)-215(to)-205(make)-206(the)-206(Gentiles)-206(obedient,)-214(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(word)-227(and)-228(deed,)-232(through)-227(mighty)-228(signs)-227(and)-228(wonders,)-232(by)-227(the)-227(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-185(the)-185(Spirit)-185(of)-185(God;)-207(so)-185(that)-185(from)-185(Jerusalem,)-198(and)-185(round)-184(about)-185(unto)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Illyricum,)-416(I)-383(have)-383(fully)-382(preached)-383(the)-383(Gospel)-383(of)-383(Christ.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 244.032 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.02 0 Td [(\050Rom.)]TJ -253.052 -13.549 Td [(xv.)-659(18,)-420(19.\051)-659(Here)-387(then)-386(we)-386(have)-387(St.)-659(Paul's)-386(direct)-386(affirmation)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-314(in)-313(his)-314(own)-313(opinion,)-330(throughout)-313(the)-314(mission)-313(in)-314(question,)-329(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-220(been)-220(in)-220(the)-220(habit)-220(of)-220(performing)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 154.956 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(mighty)-220(signs)-220(and)-220(wonders.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 115.987 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.787 -13.549 Td [(After)-276(these)-276(passages)-276(it)-276(is)-276(needless)-276(to)-276(quote)-276(further.)-328(The)-276(Apostle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(deliberately)-242(affirms)-241(to)-242(the)-241(Corinthians)-241(and)-242(Galatians)-241(that)-242(he)-241(per-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(formed)-346(miracles,)-369(and)-346(the)-346(whole)-345(passage)-346(makes)-346(it)-345(clear)-346(that)-345(he)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supposed)-262(they)-262(would)-261(fully)-262(recognize)-262(the)-261(fact)-262(of)-262(his)-262(having)-261(done)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so.)-290(Of)-264(course)-263(this)-264(affirmation)-263(does)-263(not)-264(prove)-263(that)-264(they)-263(were)-263(real)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles;)-291(but)-277(it)-277(does)-277(prove)-277(that)-277(he)-555(and)-277(those)-277(to)-277(whom)-277(he)-277(wrote)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([410])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(thought)-293(that)-293(they)-293(were)-293(so.)-379(Not)-293(less)-293(distinct)-293(is)-293(his)-293(affirmation)-292(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-296(Romans.)-388(These)-296(passages)-296(further)-296(distinctly)-296(prove)-296(that)-296(it)-295(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-275(accepted)-275(belief)-276(in)-275(the)-275(Churches)-275(when)-276(the)-275(Apostle)-275(wrote,)-281(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(even)-349(at)-348(a)-349(much)-348(earlier)-349(period,)-373(that)-349(supernatural)-348(manifestations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attended)-265(the)-264(early)-265(preaching)-265(of)-264(Christianity.)-294(It)-265(follows)-264(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-369(the)-369(invention)-369(of)-370(miraculous)-369(stories)-369(was)-369(not)-369(due)-369(to)-369(a)-369(later)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mythic)-412(and)-412(legendary)-412(spirit.)-736(This)-412(the)-412(statement)-412(made)-412(by)-412(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Apostle)-377(in)-377(his)-378(Epistle)-377(to)-377(the)-377(Romans)-377(distinctly)-377(proves;)-441(for)-377(he)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(evidently)-256(considered)-257(that)-256(he)-256(had)-256(been)-256(in)-257(the)-256(habit)-256(of)-256(performing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miracles)-234(up)-234(to)-234(the)-234(very)-235(time)-234(when)-234(he)-234(wrote)-234(the)-234(letter,)-237(and)-234(during)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1530 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 984
/Length 9064      
>>
stream
1528 0 1529 58 1525 116 1532 182 1534 301 1531 360 1536 426 1538 545 1535 604 1540 682
1542 801 1539 860 1544 926 1546 1045 1543 1104 1549 1170 1551 1289 1548 1348 1553 1414 1555 1533
1556 1592 1552 1650 1558 1716 1560 1835 1557 1894 1562 1984 1564 2103 1561 2161 1566 2227 1568 2346
1565 2405 1570 2483 1572 2602 1569 2661 1575 2727 1577 2846 1574 2905 1579 2971 1581 3090 1582 3149
1578 3207 1584 3273 1586 3392 1583 3449 1588 3515 1590 3634 1587 3692 1592 3758 1594 3877 1591 3934
1595 4000 1598 4041 1600 4203 1596 4322 1602 4380 1599 4437 1605 4503 1607 4622 1604 4680 1609 4746
1611 4865 1608 4924 1613 4990 1615 5109 1612 5168 1617 5234 1619 5353 1616 5412 1621 5478 1623 5597
1620 5656 1625 5722 1627 5841 1628 5900 1624 5957 1631 6023 1633 6142 1630 6201 1635 6267 1637 6386
1634 6444 1639 6534 1641 6653 1638 6712 1643 6778 1645 6897 1642 6955 1647 7021 1649 7140 1646 7199
1651 7265 1653 7384 1650 7443 1656 7509 1658 7628 1659 7687 1655 7746 1661 7824 1663 7943 1660 8002
% 1528 0 obj
<<
/D [1526 0 R /XYZ 313.29 504.626 null]
>>
% 1529 0 obj
<<
/D [1526 0 R /XYZ 46.771 109.332 null]
>>
% 1525 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1532 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1533 0 R
/Resources 1531 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1520 0 R
>>
% 1534 0 obj
<<
/D [1532 0 R /XYZ 120.158 160.986 null]
>>
% 1531 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1536 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1537 0 R
/Resources 1535 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1520 0 R
>>
% 1538 0 obj
<<
/D [1536 0 R /XYZ 327.401 242.155 null]
>>
% 1535 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1540 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1541 0 R
/Resources 1539 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1520 0 R
>>
% 1542 0 obj
<<
/D [1540 0 R /XYZ 374.173 284.566 null]
>>
% 1539 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1544 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1545 0 R
/Resources 1543 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1547 0 R
>>
% 1546 0 obj
<<
/D [1544 0 R /XYZ 113.446 323.577 null]
>>
% 1543 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1549 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1550 0 R
/Resources 1548 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1547 0 R
>>
% 1551 0 obj
<<
/D [1549 0 R /XYZ 125.364 396.232 null]
>>
% 1548 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1553 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1554 0 R
/Resources 1552 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1547 0 R
>>
% 1555 0 obj
<<
/D [1553 0 R /XYZ 108.598 463.978 null]
>>
% 1556 0 obj
<<
/D [1553 0 R /XYZ 127.634 66.142 null]
>>
% 1552 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1558 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1559 0 R
/Resources 1557 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1547 0 R
>>
% 1560 0 obj
<<
/D [1558 0 R /XYZ 374.173 147.437 null]
>>
% 1557 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1562 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1563 0 R
/Resources 1561 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1547 0 R
>>
% 1564 0 obj
<<
/D [1562 0 R /XYZ 46.771 201.634 null]
>>
% 1561 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1566 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1567 0 R
/Resources 1565 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1547 0 R
>>
% 1568 0 obj
<<
/D [1566 0 R /XYZ 156.088 271.017 null]
>>
% 1565 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1570 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1571 0 R
/Resources 1569 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1573 0 R
>>
% 1572 0 obj
<<
/D [1570 0 R /XYZ 277.126 352.312 null]
>>
% 1569 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1575 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1576 0 R
/Resources 1574 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1573 0 R
>>
% 1577 0 obj
<<
/D [1575 0 R /XYZ 374.173 423.331 null]
>>
% 1574 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1579 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1580 0 R
/Resources 1578 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1573 0 R
>>
% 1581 0 obj
<<
/D [1579 0 R /XYZ 229.573 477.528 null]
>>
% 1582 0 obj
<<
/D [1579 0 R /XYZ 271.131 66.142 null]
>>
% 1578 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1584 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1585 0 R
/Resources 1583 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1573 0 R
>>
% 1586 0 obj
<<
/D [1584 0 R /XYZ 121.719 93.24 null]
>>
% 1583 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1588 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1589 0 R
/Resources 1587 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1573 0 R
>>
% 1590 0 obj
<<
/D [1588 0 R /XYZ 76.976 162.623 null]
>>
% 1587 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1592 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1593 0 R
/Resources 1591 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1573 0 R
>>
% 1594 0 obj
<<
/D [1592 0 R /XYZ 93.543 244.65 null]
>>
% 1591 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1595 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index19) >>
% 1598 0 obj
(Chapter XVIII. The Testimony Of The Church, And Of St. Paul's Epistles, To The Facts Of Primitive Christianity. Their Historical Value Considered.)
% 1600 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1601 0 R
/Resources 1599 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1603 0 R
>>
% 1596 0 obj
<<
/D [1600 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 1602 0 obj
<<
/D [1600 0 R /XYZ 46.771 79.691 null]
>>
% 1599 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1605 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1606 0 R
/Resources 1604 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1603 0 R
>>
% 1607 0 obj
<<
/D [1605 0 R /XYZ 288.31 147.437 null]
>>
% 1604 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1609 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1610 0 R
/Resources 1608 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1603 0 R
>>
% 1611 0 obj
<<
/D [1609 0 R /XYZ 199.967 215.183 null]
>>
% 1608 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1613 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1614 0 R
/Resources 1612 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1603 0 R
>>
% 1615 0 obj
<<
/D [1613 0 R /XYZ 308.715 283.747 null]
>>
% 1612 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1617 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1618 0 R
/Resources 1616 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1603 0 R
>>
% 1619 0 obj
<<
/D [1617 0 R /XYZ 152.435 340.399 null]
>>
% 1616 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1621 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1622 0 R
/Resources 1620 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1603 0 R
>>
% 1623 0 obj
<<
/D [1621 0 R /XYZ 323.322 409.782 null]
>>
% 1620 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1625 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1626 0 R
/Resources 1624 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1629 0 R
>>
% 1627 0 obj
<<
/D [1625 0 R /XYZ 165.572 461.524 null]
>>
% 1628 0 obj
<<
/D [1625 0 R /XYZ 84.996 66.142 null]
>>
% 1624 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1631 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1632 0 R
/Resources 1630 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1629 0 R
>>
% 1633 0 obj
<<
/D [1631 0 R /XYZ 249.791 120.339 null]
>>
% 1630 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1635 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1636 0 R
/Resources 1634 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1629 0 R
>>
% 1637 0 obj
<<
/D [1635 0 R /XYZ 82.579 192.994 null]
>>
% 1634 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1639 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1640 0 R
/Resources 1638 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1629 0 R
>>
% 1641 0 obj
<<
/D [1639 0 R /XYZ 331.259 255.831 null]
>>
% 1638 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1643 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1644 0 R
/Resources 1642 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1629 0 R
>>
% 1645 0 obj
<<
/D [1643 0 R /XYZ 71.761 310.028 null]
>>
% 1642 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1647 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1648 0 R
/Resources 1646 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1629 0 R
>>
% 1649 0 obj
<<
/D [1647 0 R /XYZ 141.029 380.228 null]
>>
% 1646 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1651 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1652 0 R
/Resources 1650 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1654 0 R
>>
% 1653 0 obj
<<
/D [1651 0 R /XYZ 192.235 450.429 null]
>>
% 1650 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1656 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1657 0 R
/Resources 1655 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1654 0 R
>>
% 1658 0 obj
<<
/D [1656 0 R /XYZ 278.519 518.175 null]
>>
% 1659 0 obj
<<
/D [1656 0 R /XYZ 356.414 135.525 null]
>>
% 1655 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1661 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1662 0 R
/Resources 1660 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1654 0 R
>>
% 1663 0 obj
<<
/D [1661 0 R /XYZ 199.581 201.634 null]
>>
% 1660 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
endstream
endobj
1666 0 obj <<
/Length 4663      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(360)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(the)-256(whole)-255(course)-256(of)-255(his)-256(preceding)-256(ministry.)-266(Also)-256(the)-255(affirmation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-344(miracles)-345(were)-344(the)-344(signs)-345(of)-344(an)-344(Apostle,)-368(and)-345(admitted)-344(to)-344(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such,)-471(is)-427(a)-426(strong)-427(corroboration)-427(of)-427(the)-426(statement)-427(made)-427(by)-426(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Synoptics)-377(that)-378(our)-377(Lord)-377(was)-377(supposed)-378(to)-377(have)-377(conferred)-377(such)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(powers)-330(on)-330(the)-330(Apostles;)-370(and)-330(as)-330(it)-330(is)-330(simply)-330(incredible)-330(that)-330(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-297(have)-297(believed)-298(that)-297(He)-297(conferred)-297(on)-297(the)-297(Apostles)-297(powers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-271(He)-271(did)-271(not)-271(exercise)-271(himself,)-276(it)-271(carries)-271(up)-271(the)-271(belief)-271(of)-271(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church)-228(that)-228(Jesus)-228(was)-228(a)-228(professed)-228(worker)-228(of)-228(miracles)-228(to)-228(the)-228(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first)-285(years)-284(of)-285(Christianity.)-354(I)-285(am)-285(quite)-285(aware)-284(that)-285(these)-285(beliefs)-284(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-311(Church)-312(do)-311(not)-311(prove)-312(these)-311(miracles)-311(to)-312(have)-311(been)-311(real)-311(ones.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(But)-243(they)-243(do)-243(prove)-244(that)-243(the)-243(belief)-243(in)-243(their)-243(actual)-243(performance)-243(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contemporary)-224(with)-225(the)-224(birth)-224(of)-224(Christianity)-225(itself.)-241(They)-224(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(could)-341(not)-340(have)-341(originated,)-363(as)-341(the)-341(opponents)-340(of)-341(Christianity)-340(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(never)-382(weary)-383(of)-382(assuming,)-416(in)-382(a)-383(mythic)-382(or)-382(legendary)-383(spirit;)-448(for)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(myths)-351(and)-351(legends)-351(require)-351(a)-351(considerable)-352(time)-351(to)-351(grow;)-401(and)-351(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-371(impossible)-371(that)-372(they)-371(can)-371(encircle)-371(an)-371(eminent)-371(character)-371(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-439(unreal)-440(halo)-439(till)-440(after)-439(those)-440(who)-439(witnessed)-440(his)-439(actions)-439(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(personally)-404(know)-405(him)-404(are)-404(silent)-404(in)-405(the)-404(grave.)-713(But)-404(in)-404(the)-404(case)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(before)-315(us)-316(we)-315(have)-316(affirmations)-315(of)-315(St.)-446(Paul)-631(respecting)-315(himself,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([411])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(which)-309(put)-308(the)-309(whole)-308(apparatus)-309(of)-309(myths)-308(and)-309(legends)-308(out)-309(of)-308(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question.)-243(If)-230(then)-230(this)-230(belief)-229(in)-230(the)-230(manifestation)-230(of)-230(a)-229(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-263(in)-262(connection)-263(with)-263(Christianity)-263(dat)1(es)-263(thus)-263(early,)-266(there)-262(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-355(three)-354(modes)-355(in)-354(which)-355(it)-355(is)-354(possible)-355(to)-354(account)-355(for)-355(it,)-380(viz.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-388(it)-388(was)-388(due)-388(to)-388(deliberate)-388(and)-388(conscious)-388(imposture;)-457(or)-388(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Jesus)-397(and)-396(His)-397(immediate)-396(followers)-397(laboured)-396(under)-397(a)-396(delusion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-400(they)-399(thought)-400(that)-400(they)-400(performed)-399(miracles;)-475(or)-400(that)-399(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-224(really)-225(wrought.)-241(As)-224(no)-224(one)-225(now-a-days)-224(pretends)-224(to)-224(maintain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-305(truth)-305(of)-304(the)-305(first)-305(alternative,)-318(we)-305(may)-305(dismiss)-305(it)-305(from)-304(further)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consideration.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-401(it)-401(will)-401(be)-401(asserted)-400(that)-401(St.)-703(Paul)-401(does)-401(not)-401(mention)-400(any)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(specific)-400(miracles)-401(which)-400(he)-401(considered)-400(that)-401(he)-400(had)-400(performed,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-349(that)-349(his)-349(statements)-349(are)-348(merely)-349(general.)-547(I)-349(reply)-349(that)-349(such)-348(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mode)-213(of)-214(statement)-213(is)-214(precisely)-213(what)-214(we)-213(should)-214(expect)-213(to)-214(find)-213(in)-213(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(letter)-188(of)-188(this)-188(kind,)-200(and)-188(is)-188(just)-188(the)-188(one)-188(which)-188(would)-188(be)-188(adopted)-188(by)-187(a)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1671 0 obj <<
/Length 4697      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(361)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(person)-203(who)-202(was)-203(satisfied)-202(that)-203(those)-203(to)-202(whom)-203(he)-202(was)-203(writing)-202(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-347(firmly)-347(convinced)-346(of)-347(the)-347(fact)-346(as)-347(he)-347(was)-347(himself....)-540(A)-346(formal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-272(distinct)-273(description)-272(of)-273(the)-272(miracles)-272(which)-273(he)-272(had)-272(performed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-194(have)-195(been)-194(quite)-194(out)-194(of)-195(place)-194(in)-194(a)-194(reference)-195(of)-194(this)-194(kind,)-205(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(would)-303(have)-303(implied)-303(that)-303(doubts)-303(respecting)-303(them)-303(existed)-303(on)-302(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(side)-286(or)-286(the)-287(other.)-358(Besides,)-295(the)-287(words)-286(which)-286(he)-286(uses)-286(embrace)-286(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-254(different)-254(expressions)-254(by)-253(which)-254(the)-254(various)-254(kinds)-254(and)-253(aspects)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(miracles)-250(are)-250(designated)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Secondly:)-431(These)-340(letters)-341(also)-340(afford)-341(unquestionable)-340(evidence)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-241(at)-242(the)-241(time)-241(when)-241(they)-242(were)-241(written)-241(both)-242(the)-241(writer)-241(and)-241(those)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-359(whom)-359(he)-359(addressed)-359(them,)-386(were)-359(firmly)-359(convinced)-359(that)-358(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-373(then)-373(actively)-373(operating)-373(in)-373(the)-373(Church)-373(a)-373(number)-373(of)-372(super-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural)-342(manifestations)-342(of)-342(a)-342(very)-342(peculiar)-342(character,)-365(and)-342(widely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(different)-254(from)-254(any)-255(species)-254(of)-254(supernatural)-254(belief)-254(which)-254(has)-254(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(current)-408(before)-204(or)-204(since.)-235(I)-204(allude)-203(to)-204(the)-204(gifts)-204(of)-204(the)-204(Spirit,)-213(to)-204(which)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([412])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(the)-356(Apostle)-356(has)-357(so)-356(frequently)-356(alluded)-356(in)-356(these)-357(Epistles,)-382(and)-356(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-352(nature)-353(of)-352(which)-352(he)-352(has)-353(in)-352(those)-352(to)-353(the)-352(Corinthians)-352(given)-352(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinct)-216(account,)-223(together)-216(with)-216(definite)-216(rules)-216(to)-216(regulate)-216(their)-215(use.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-320(reason)-320(why)-321(he)-320(has)-320(given)-320(us)-320(a)-321(far)-320(more)-320(definite)-320(account)-320(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-323(class)-323(of)-323(manifestations)-323(than)-323(of)-323(the)-323(other)-323(is)-323(obvious.)-469(In)-322(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Church)-346(in)-346(question)-347(they)-346(had)-346(become)-346(the)-346(subjects)-346(of)-346(ambitious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rivalry,)-239(and)-237(under)-237(its)-236(influence)-237(some)-237(of)-236(them)-237(had)-237(been)-236(perverted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-402(pernicious)-402(uses.)-706(The)-402(whole)-402(subject)-402(is)-402(definitely)-402(treated)-402(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-384(the)-383(12th,)-417(13th,)-417(and)-384(14th)-384(chapters)-383(of)-384(the)-384(first)-383(Epistle)-384(to)-383(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Corinthians,)-235(besides)-230(a)-231(number)-231(of)-231(distinct)-230(references)-231(to)-231(it)-231(in)-230(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(portions)-274(of)-275(his)-274(writings.)-323(These)-274(assertions)-274(on)-275(the)-274(part)-274(of)-275(St.)-322(Paul)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-311(both)-310(he)-311(and)-311(those)-310(to)-311(whom)-310(he)-311(wrote)-311(were)-310(fully)-311(of)-310(opinion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-393(supernatural)-394(powers)-393(were)-393(then)-394(manifested)-393(in)-393(the)-393(Church,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-313(so)-314(clear)-313(that)-313(they)-313(require)-314(a)-313(most)-313(careful)-314(consideration.)-439(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(following)-250(points)-250(respecting)-250(them)-250(are)-250(proved)-250(by)-250(this)-250(Epistle.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(1.)-646(That)-382(St.)-645(Paul,)-415(and)-382(the)-382(various)-382(parties)-382(in)-382(the)-382(Corint)1(hian)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Church,)-512(however)-459(much)-460(they)-459(might)-459(disagree)-460(on)-459(other)-459(points,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fully)-205(believed)-204(that)-205(these)-204(supernatural)-205(powers)-205(were)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 218.599 0 Td [(then)-205(and)-204(there)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -218.599 -13.549 Td [(manifesting)-359(themselves)-359(in)-358(the)-359(Church.)-576(This)-359(belief)-359(might)-358(have)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1675 0 obj <<
/Length 5149      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(362)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(been)-334(a)-335(delusion,)-355(but)-335(the)-334(letter)-334(proves)-335(beyond)-334(doubt)-335(that)-334(it)-334(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entertained)-203(by)-203(the)-204(whole)-203(Church,)-213(including)-203(all)-203(its)-203(various)-203(parties.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(2.)-234(That)-202(these)-202(gifts)-201(were)-202(earnestly)-202(coveted)-202(by)-202(the)-202(various)-201(mem-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(bers)-258(of)-257(this)-258(Church;)-262(that)-257(many)-258(of)-258(them)-257(made)-258(a)-258(very)-257(ostentatious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(use)-378(of)-377(them;)-442(and)-378(that)-377(stringent)-378(rules)-377(were)-378(required)-378(to)-377(prevent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-250(use)-250(from)-250(degenerating)-250(into)-250(an)-250(abuse.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(3.)-299(Nine)-266(of)-266(these)-266(supernatural)-267(endowments)-266(are)-266(enumerated)-266(by)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-403(Apostle.)-709(It)-404(is)-403(not)-403(clear)-403(whether)-403(the)-403(list)-403(is)-403(intended)-403(to)-403(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exhaustive.)-501(Probably)-333(it)-334(is)-333(not;)-750(but)-334(it)-333(is)-334(evident)-333(that)-334(the)-333(writer)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([413])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(intended)-217(to)-217(enumerate)-217(the)-217(chief)-216(of)-217(them.)-239(They)-217(are)-217(as)-217(follows:)-233(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(gifts)-337(of)-336(wisdom,)-358(knowledge,)-359(faith;)-380(gifts)-336(of)-337(healing)-336(\050)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 233.939 0 Td [(\307\261\301)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 16.244 0 Td [(w)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\303\274\261\304\261)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf -253.39 -13.549 Td [(0)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.208 0 Td [(\261\274)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 11.607 0 Td [(q)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.727 0 Td [(\304\311\275)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 17.858 0 Td [(\051;)-218(working)-202(of)-203(miracles)-202(\050)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 101.704 0 Td [(\020)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\275\265\301\263)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 20.509 0 Td [(u)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.825 0 Td [(\274\261\304\261)-202(\264\305\275\261\274)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 52.126 0 Td [(s)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\311\275)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.167 0 Td [(\051;)-218(the)-202(gift)]TJ -240.895 -13.549 Td [(of)-292(prophecy,)-303(those)-292(of)-292(discerni)1(ng)-292(spirits;)-313(tongues)-292(and)-292(interpreta-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion.)-542(This)-348(list)-347(of)-348(gifts)-347(in)-348(a)-347(slightly)-348(altered)-347(form)-348(is)-347(repeated)-347(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(less)-315(than)-314(three)-315(times)-315(in)-315(the)-314(same)-315(chapter.)-444(They)-315(are)-315(affirmed)-314(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-381(supernatural)-381(endowments,)-414(qualifying)-381(the)-381(possessor)-381(for)-381(dis-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tinct)-306(functions)-306(in)-306(the)-306(Church.)-418(It)-306(is)-306(worthy)-306(of)-306(particular)-306(remark,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-383(showing)-384(how)-383(free)-384(the)-383(Apostle)-383(was)-384(from)-383(contemplating)-383(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subject)-291(with)-291(the)-291(eye)-291(of)-292(a)-291(credulous)-291(enthusiast,)-301(that)-291(he)-291(distinctly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(asserts)-302(that)-303(they)-302(were)-302(designed)-302(for)-302(a)-303(definite)-302(purpose)-302(only,)-315(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-268(when)-268(that)-268(was)-268(effected)-267(they)-268(were)-268(to)-268(cease.)-304(A)-268(fanatic)-267(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certainly)-236(have)-235(considered)-236(that)-235(they)-235(were)-236(destined)-235(to)-236(continue)-235(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ever.)-250(This)-250(point)-250(is)-250(worthy)-250(of)-250(our)-250(deepest)-250(attention.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(4.)-438(The)-312(existence)-313(of)-313(a)-312(marked)-313(distinction)-312(between)-313(these)-312(gifts)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-357(definitely)-356(affirmed)-357(by)-357(the)-356(Apostle.)-570(They)-357(were)-357(not)-356(confined)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-419(a)-419(particular)-418(order)-419(of)-419(men,)-461(but)-418(were)-419(spread)-419(over)-419(the)-418(entire)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(community.)-501(They)-334(also)-334(differed)-333(not)-334(only)-334(in)-333(kind)-334(but)-334(in)-333(degree.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Some)-316(of)-315(them)-316(subserved)-315(higher,)-332(others)-316(humbler)-316(purposes.)-446(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason)-405(for)-404(which)-405(they)-405(were)-404(given)-405(was)-405(the)-404(building)-405(up)-405(of)-404(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Church)-364(into)-365(a)-364(distinctive)-365(community.)-593(When)-365(that)-364(was)-364(effected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-250(were)-250(to)-250(cease.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(5.)-240(The)-219(Apostle)-219(also)-219(most)-219(carefully)-220(points)-219(out)-219(that)-219(a)-219(distinction)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(of)-350(function)-351(existed)-350(between)-350(these)-351(various)-350(supernatural)-350(endow-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ments.)-271(This)-257(is)-256(a)-257(very)-257(important)-257(consideration.)-271(Whether)-257(we)-256(view)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1679 0 obj <<
/Length 5253      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(363)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(them)-306(as)-305(realities,)-320(or)-306(as)-305(delusions,)-320(it)-306(is)-305(plain)-306(that)-306(this)-305(distinction)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-278(function)-279(must)-278(have)-279(pointed)-278(to)-278(some)-279(corresponding)-278(facts)-278(well)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(known)-227(in)-228(the)-227(Church,)-232(at)-227(the)-228(time)-227(when)-227(the)-228(Epistles)-227(were)-227(written.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-440(possession)-440(of)-439(one)-440(of)-440(them)-440(by)-439(no)-440(means)-440(implied)-440(that)-439(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(another,)-314(although)-302(the)-301(subject-matter)-602(upon)-302(which)-301(they)-301(operated)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([414])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(was)-415(closely)-414(akin.)-745(Thus)-414(the)-415(possession)-415(of)-414(the)-415(gift)-415(of)-414(tongues)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(\050whatever)-383(it)-384(may)-383(have)-383(been\051,)-417(did)-383(not)-384(imply)-383(the)-383(possession)-383(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-355(gift)-355(of)-355(interpretation.)-564(On)-355(the)-355(contrary,)-381(the)-355(rules)-355(which)-354(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Apostle)-408(gives)-409(for)-408(the)-409(regulation)-408(of)-409(those)-408(gifts,)-448(as)-409(well)-408(as)-408(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(statements)-378(respecting)-378(them,)-410(prove)-378(that)-378(they)-378(were)-378(a)-378(set)-378(of)-378(dis-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tinct)-281(manifestations,)-289(and)-281(were)-282(possessed)-281(very)-281(often)-281(by)-281(different)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(persons,)-411(and)-380(that)-379(the)-379(presence)-379(of)-379(the)-379(one)-379(power)-379(by)-379(no)-379(means)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(implied)-285(that)-285(of)-285(the)-285(other.)-354(This)-285(must)-285(unquestionably)-285(point)-285(to)-284(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-357(of)-357(a)-356(remarkable)-357(phenomenon)-357(of)-357(some)-356(kind.)-571(Even)-356(if)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-351(is)-352(supposed)-351(that)-352(St.)-554(Paul)-352(and)-351(those)-352(to)-351(whom)-352(he)-351(wrote)-351(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(labouring)-281(under)-280(a)-281(delusion,)-288(it)-280(proves)-281(that)-280(the)-281(Apostle)-280(possessed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-273(power)-273(of)-272(discrimination)-273(which)-273(is)-272(not)-273(exhibited)-273(by)-273(an)-272(ordinary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enthusiast)-250(or)-250(fanatic.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(A)-287(distinction)-287(which)-287(St.)-362(Paul)-287(affirms)-287(to)-287(have)-287(existed)-287(between)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(two)-301(of)-301(these)-301(gifts,)-314(viz.)-404(between)-301(the)-301(gifts)-301(of)-301(healing)-301(and)-301(of)-301(mir-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acles,)-332(deserves)-316(special)-316(attention.)-447(That)-315(a)-316(real)-316(distinction)-315(existed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(between)-309(them)-309(is)-309(affirmed)-310(three)-309(times)-309(over)-309(in)-309(the)-309(same)-309(chapter.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Both)-362(of)-361(these)-362(gifts,)-390(according)-361(to)-362(our)-362(present)-361(mode)-362(of)-361(viewing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-425(subject,)-468(would)-425(be)-425(confounded)-425(under)-425(the)-425(designation)-425(of)-424(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-372(of)-372(working)-372(miracles.)-616(But)-372(it)-372(is)-372(clear)-372(from)-372(the)-372(Apostle's)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(statement,)-225(that)-219(he,)-225(and)-218(those)-219(to)-219(whom)-218(he)-219(wrote,)-225(saw)-219(an)-218(apprecia-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ble)-285(distinction)-286(between)-285(them.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 133.51 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(To)-285(another,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 50.675 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.956 0 Td [(says)-285(he,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 38.13 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(are)-285(given)]TJ -239.959 -13.55 Td [(the)-345(gifts)-344(of)-345(healing)-344(by)-345(the)-344(same)-345(Spirit;)-392(to)-344(another)-345(the)-344(working)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-315(miracles.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 52.207 0 Td [(\035)-315(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.12 0 Td [(But)-315(all)-314(these)-315(worketh)-315(that)-314(one)-315(and)-315(the)-314(self-same)]TJ -65.327 -13.549 Td [(Spirit,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 30.767 0 Td [(dividing)-328(to)-328(every)-328(man)-327(severally)-328(as)-328(he)-328(will)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 187.439 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.42 0 Td [(\0501)-328(Cor.)-483(xii.)]TJ -229.353 -13.549 Td [(9-11.\051)-338(Again,)-287(in)-280(summing)-279(up)-279(their)-280(relative)-279(importance,)-287(he)-279(says:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(thirdly)-260(teachers,)-261(after)-260(that)-259(miracles,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 157.804 0 Td [(then)-259(gifts)-260(of)-260(healing)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 87.289 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 2.728 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.674 0 Td [(\050ver.)]TJ -260.339 -13.55 Td [(28\051;)-399(and)-349(again,)-374(as)-349(qualifying)-349(individuals)-349(for)-349(particular)-349(offices:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Are)-262(all)-263(apostles?)-287(are)-262(all)-263(prophets?)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 151.613 0 Td [(are)-262(all)-263(workers)-262(of)-263(miracles?)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1684 0 obj <<
/Length 4721      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(364)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
/F31 10.9091 Tf 0 -30.759 Td [(Have)-381(all)-382(the)-381(gifts)-382(of)-381(healing?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 134.14 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.005 0 Td [(\050ver.)-644(29,)-415(30.\051)-644(Now)-381(although)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -215.9 0 Td [([415])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(we)-359(may)-359(deny)-359(that)-359(these)-359(phenomena)-359(were)-359(supernatural)-359(in)-358(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character,)-484(it)-438(is)-438(plain)-437(that)-438(there)-437(must)-438(have)-437(been)-438(something)-437(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-371(in)-370(this)-371(Church)-371(corresponding)-371(to)-370(them,)-401(and)-371(of)-370(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-266(were)-265(the)-266(supposed)-266(manifestation.)-297(The)-265(Apostle)-266(and)-266(those)-265(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whom)-250(be)-250(wrote)-250(evidently)-250(understood)-250(one)-250(another.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(What)-341(this)-342(distinction)-341(was)-342(it)-341(is)-342(now)-341(impossible)-342(accurately)-341(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(determine.)-243(As)-227(I)-227(have)-228(already)-227(observed,)-232(it)-228(probably)-227(had)-227(reference)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-273(a)-273(higher)-273(and)-272(lower)-273(class)-273(of)-273(miracles;)-284(those)-273(which)-273(were)-273(in)-272(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proper)-177(sense)-177(evidential;)-201(and)-177(those)-177(which)-177(might)-177(in)-177(various)-177(degrees)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-282(resembled)-282(the)-283(act)-282(mentioned)-282(by)-282(St.)-347(James,)-290(the)-282(anointing)-282(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sick)-321(man)-321(with)-320(oil)-321(in)-321(the)-321(name)-321(of)-321(the)-320(Lord,)-339(the)-321(offering)-320(fervent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prayer)-343(for)-343(his)-343(recovery,)-366(and)-343(the)-343(gradual)-343(cure)-343(of)-343(his)-343(complaint.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Such)-480(would)-481(belong)-480(to)-480(a)-481(lower)-480(class)-480(of)-481(miracles)-480(to)-480(which)-480(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-311(elsewhere)-312(al)1(luded,)-327(as)-311(rather)-312(fitted)-311(to)-311(procure)-311(a)-311(favourable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(attention)-306(to)-306(the)-306(missionary)-306(than)-306(for)-306(evidential)-306(purposes.)-418(Be)-305(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinction)-359(what)-359(it)-359(may,)-386(and)-359(even)-359(supposing)-359(that)-359(St.)-577(Paul)-359(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-377(Corinthians)-378(were)-377(under)-377(a)-377(delusion)-378(as)-377(to)-377(their)-377(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character,)-246(it)-245(is)-246(plain)-245(that)-245(some)-245(real)-246(difference,)-246(which)-245(was)-245(clearly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinguishable,)-208(must)-197(have)-198(existed)-197(in)-198(the)-197(outward)-197(manifestations.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(This)-305(is)-305(a)-305(fact)-305(of)-305(very)-305(considerable)-305(importance,)-319(as)-305(it)-304(proves)-305(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(both)-399(the)-400(Apostle)-399(and)-400(the)-399(Corinthians)-399(were)-400(in)-399(a)-400(state)-399(of)-399(mind)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-297(which)-298(they)-297(were)-297(capable)-297(of)-298(exercising)-297(a)-297(clear)-297(discrimination)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(between)-351(these)-350(gifts,)-376(which)-351(is)-351(the)-351(last)-350(thing)-351(of)-351(which)-350(visionary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(credulous)-250(enthusiasts)-250(ever)-250(think.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(6.)-741(These)-414(gifts)-414(were)-414(likewise)-413(clearly)-414(separate)-414(in)-414(respect)-413(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-431(subject-matter)-432(on)-431(which)-431(they)-431(operated.)-794(The)-431(Apostle)-431(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-231(Corinthians)-231(supposed)-231(that)-231(they)-231(communicated)-231(a)-230(supernatural)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(illumination)-241(of)-240(some)-241(kind;)-244(but)-241(the)-240(illumination)-241(conferred)-241(by)-240(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(might)-238(leave)-238(the)-238(possessor)-237(completely)-238(in)-238(the)-238(dark)-238(with)-238(respect)-475(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([416])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(the)-211(special)-211(subject-matter)-210(of)-211(the)-211(other.)-237(This)-211(is)-211(definitely)-210(affirmed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-296(respect)-296(to)-296(the)-295(gift)-296(of)-296(tongues,)-307(and)-296(interpretation.)-388(A)-295(person)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(might)-339(possess)-340(the)-339(former)-340(and)-339(yet)-340(be)-339(altogether)-340(destitute)-339(of)-339(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(latter.)-342(There)-280(can)-281(be)-280(no)-280(doubt)-281(that)-280(the)-281(same)-280(analogy)-281(ran)-280(through)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1689 0 obj <<
/Length 4741      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(365)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(them)-356(all.)-567(This)-356(is)-356(affirmed)-356(when)-356(St.)-567(Paul)-356(asserts)-356(that)-356(all)-355(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gifts)-274(were)-273(the)-274(work)-274(of)-274(one)-273(and)-274(the)-274(same)-273(Spirit)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 206.793 0 Td [(dividing)-274(to)-273(every)]TJ -206.793 -13.549 Td [(man)-422(severally)-421(as)-422(he)-422(will)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 117.55 0 Td [(\0501)-422(Cor.)-765(xii\051,)-464(and)-422(is)-422(implied)-421(by)-422(the)]TJ -117.55 -13.549 Td [(comparison)-299(which)-300(he)-299(institutes)-299(between)-300(them)-299(and)-299(the)-299(members)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-408(the)-408(human)-408(body)-408(and)-407(their)-408(respective)-408(functions.)-724(Thus:)-565(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-359(of)-358(seeing)-359(furnishes)-358(no)-359(information)-359(in)-358(matters)-359(of)-358(sound;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nor)-299(the)-298(latter)-299(on)-299(the)-298(perceptions)-299(we)-299(derive)-298(through)-299(the)-299(sense)-298(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(smell.)-231(Equally)-193(functional)-192(were)-193(these)-193(gifts,)-204(each)-193(being)-193(confined)-192(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-276(own)-276(proper)-276(subject-matter.)-328(If)-276(the)-276(idea)-276(was)-276(that)-276(the)-276(possessor)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(had)-384(an)-383(inspiration,)-417(as)-383(far)-384(as)-383(respects)-384(the)-383(subject-matter)-384(of)-383(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gift,)-333(it)-317(conferred)-317(on)-317(him)-316(no)-317(supernatural)-317(knowledge)-317(on)-316(matters)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(outside)-404(its)-404(special)-405(function.)-712(Thus)-404(a)-405(man)-404(who)-404(had)-404(the)-404(gift)-404(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tongues)-292(might)-293(remain)-292(perfectly)-293(ignorant)-292(of)-293(the)-292(interpretation)-292(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them,)-270(if)-266(he)-266(had)-266(not)-266(the)-266(latter)-266(gift.)-298(One)-266(who)-266(possessed)-266(the)-266(power)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-233(discerning)-233(of)-233(spirits)-232(might)-233(have)-233(been)-233(destitute)-233(of)-233(the)-233(power)-232(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(working)-253(miracles.)-259(One)-252(who)-253(had)-253(the)-253(gift)-253(of)-253(prophecy)-253(might)-252(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-210(no)-211(illumination)-210(with)-211(respect)-210(to)-210(that)-211(special)-210(knowledge)-210(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-427(conferred)-428(by)-427(the)-427(gift)-428(of)-427(wisdom.)-782(The)-427(inspiration)-427(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-425(supposed)-425(to)-426(be)-425(conferred)-425(by)-425(them,)-469(conferred)-425(no)-425(general)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(infallibility)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 49.102 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(it)-209(was)-208(strictly)-209(functional)-209(and)-208(did)-209(not)-209(extend)-208(beyond)]TJ -60.011 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(limits)-250(of)-250(the)-250(gift.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(All)-274(these)-274(points)-275(are)-274(of)-274(the)-274(highest)-275(importance)-274(in)-274(an)-274(historical)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(point)-202(of)-201(view.)-234(Whether)-201(we)-202(think)-202(that)-201(St.)-234(Paul)-201(and)-202(the)-201(Corinthians)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were,)-229(or)-225(were)-224(not,)-229(under)-224(delusions)-225(about)-224(this)-224(matter,)-229(they)-224(clearly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prove)-245(that)-245(there)-245(must)-246(have)-245(been)-245(phenomena)-245(of)-245(some)-245(kind)-245(which)]TJ 4.283 -13.549 Td [(were)-393(supposed)-392(to)-393(be)-392(the)-393(results)-393(of)-392(the)-393(gifts)-392(in)-393(question;)-464(and)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 286.741 0 Td [([417])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(that)-211(the)-210(persons)-211(who)-210(believed)-211(that)-211(they)-210(possessed)-211(them)-210(exercised)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-377(discriminating)-376(judgment)-377(respecting)-377(them.)-630(It)-376(is)-377(no)-377(less)-376(clear)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-362(they)-361(did)-362(believe)-361(that)-361(they)-362(actually)-361(possessed)-362(them.)-584(Some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-306(them)-306(were)-306(of)-307(such)-306(a)-306(nature)-306(that)-306(it)-306(is)-306(difficult)-306(to)-306(comprehend)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(how)-276(the)-276(possessor)-276(could)-276(be)-276(under)-276(delusion)-276(on)-276(the)-276(subject.)-327(Take)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-281(example)-281(the)-281(power)-281(of)-281(discerning)-281(spirits.)-343(Once)-281(the)-280(possessor)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(had)-304(it)-304(not.)-411(Afterwards)-304(he)-304(must)-303(have)-304(believed)-304(that)-304(he)-303(possessed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-304(supernatural)-304(insight)-303(into)-304(the)-304(character)-304(of)-304(others.)-411(It)-304(is)-303(difficult)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1693 0 obj <<
/Length 4745      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(366)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(to)-240(comprehend)-240(how)-240(a)-240(man's)-240(consciousness)-240(could)-240(be)-240(deceived)-240(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-319(point)-318(like)-319(this.)-456(He)-319(must)-319(have)-319(surely)-318(known)-319(whether)-319(within)-318(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(definite)-253(period)-254(of)-253(time)-254(he)-253(had)-254(obtained)-253(an)-254(insight)-253(into)-253(character,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-412(he)-413(did)-412(not)-412(possess)-413(before.)-737(Everywhere)-412(in)-412(the)-412(account)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(given)-364(us)-363(of)-364(these)-363(gifts)-364(we)-363(seem)-364(to)-363(be)-364(dealing)-363(with)-364(facts.)-590(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinctions)-335(laid)-334(down)-335(as)-334(existing)-335(between)-335(them,)-355(and)-335(the)-334(sepa-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rateness)-261(of)-260(their)-261(functions)-261(are)-261(truly)-260(philosophical,)-264(supposing)-260(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gifts)-211(to)-210(have)-211(been)-211(real,)-218(and)-211(were)-210(the)-211(last)-211(things)-210(which)-211(were)-210(likely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(have)-250(occurred)-250(to)-250(credulous)-250(enthusiasts.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(7.)-530(These)-344(gifts)-343(admitted)-344(of)-343(being)-343(abused.)-531(The)-343(possession)-343(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(them)-334(was)-334(not)-333(sufficient)-334(to)-334(confer)-334(any)-333(infallibility)-334(in)-334(the)-334(use)-333(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(them.)-307(This)-270(fact)-269(is)-269(worthy)-269(of)-269(deep)-269(attention,)-274(not)-269(only)-269(as)-269(pointing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-349(the)-349(reality)-349(of)-348(the)-349(manifestations)-349(but)-349(to)-349(the)-349(soundness)-349(of)-348(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Apostle's)-335(judgment.)-506(If)-335(these)-335(gifts)-335(had)-335(been)-335(mere)-335(inventions)-335(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-397(credulous)-397(imagination)-396(they)-397(would)-397(have)-397(been)-397(represented)-396(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(guarded)-266(from)-266(the)-267(possibility)-266(of)-266(abuse)-266(by)-266(the)-266(supernatural)-266(power)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-371(which)-372(they)-371(originated.)-615(Even)-371(at)-372(the)-371(present)-372(day)-371(it)-372(is)-371(a)-371(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(common)-395(idea)-395(that)-395(the)-394(gift)-395(of)-395(inspiration)-395(cannot)-395(possibly)-395(be)-394(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(functional)-305(one)-304(which)-305(is)-304(limited)-305(to)-304(a)-305(definite)-304(subject-matter,)-318(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-242(it)-242(must)-242(confer)-242(a)-242(general)-241(infallibility.)-248(Very)-242(different)-242(were)-241(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(views)-304(of)-305(St.)-412(Paul)-305(and)-304(of)-304(the)-304(Churches)-609(to)-304(which)-304(he)-305(wrote.)-412(The)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([418])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(Apostle)-248(was)-248(of)-248(opinion)-248(that)-248(when)-248(they)-248(had)-248(been)-248(once)-248(conferred,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-212(were)-211(subject)-212(to)-211(the)-212(control)-211(of)-212(the)-211(will,)-219(and)-212(capable)-211(of)-212(a)-211(good)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-383(bad)-383(use)-383(in)-383(the)-383(same)-383(manner)-383(as)-383(our)-383(ordinary)-383(faculties.)-649(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(statement)-241(is)-242(clear)-241(that)-241(in)-241(this)-242(Church)-241(they)-241(were)-242(used)-241(in)-241(a)-241(manner)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(little)-262(conducive)-262(to)-262(edification.)-286(In)-262(order)-262(to)-262(suppress)-262(this)-262(abuse)-262(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adopted)-345(some)-346(stringent)-345(rules.)-536(No)-346(person)-345(was)-345(to)-346(be)-345(allowed)-345(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-292(congregation)-292(to)-293(use)-292(the)-292(gift)-292(of)-292(tongues)-293(\050a)-292(gift)-292(which)-292(he)-292(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-263(far)-263(from)-264(underrating)-263(that)-263(he)-263(thanked)-264(God)-263(that)-263(he)-263(possessed)-263(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more)-231(largely)-231(than)-231(any)-231(other)-231(member)-231(of)-231(the)-231(Church\051,)-235(unless)-230(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-229(some)-229(one)-229(present)-230(who)-229(had)-229(the)-229(gift)-229(of)-229(interpretation.)-243(The)-229(gift)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-359(prophecy)-360(held)-359(the)-360(second)-359(rank)-359(in)-360(point)-359(of)-359(importance.)-578(Yet)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(from)-367(the)-367(eagerness)-367(of)-367(its)-368(possessors)-367(to)-367(use)-367(it,)-396(confusion)-367(arose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-254(the)-253(congregation;)-256(and)-253(the)-254(Apostle)-254(was)-253(compelled)-254(to)-253(prescribe)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1697 0 obj <<
/Length 4447      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(367)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(rules)-433(for)-433(limiting)-433(its)-432(exercise)-433(and)-433(enforcing)-433(order)-433(among)-432(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prophets.)-411(The)-304(more)-304(the)-303(account)-304(is)-304(studied)-303(the)-304(stronger)-304(must)-303(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-371(conviction)-370(that)-371(it)-371(points)-371(to)-370(actual)-371(phenomena,)-401(which)-370(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exhibited)-372(in)-372(the)-372(Apostolic)-373(Churches;)-433(and)-372(that)-372(St.)-617(Paul,)-402(in)-372(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(description)-238(of)-238(them,)-240(exhibits)-238(the)-237(strongest)-238(indications)-238(of)-238(a)-237(sound)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(judgment.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(Such)-384(were)-385(the)-384(phenomena)-385(which)-384(the)-385(Apostle,)-418(and)-384(those)-384(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(whom)-283(he)-283(wrote,)-292(considered)-283(to)-283(be)-284(supernatural)-283(manifestations.)-349(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(observe)-250(respecting)-250(them:)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(First:)-320(That)-285(it)-285(is)-285(clear)-285(that)-285(when)-285(St.)-355(Paul)-285(wrote)-285(these)-285(Epistles,)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(both)-267(he)-268(and)-267(those)-268(whom)-267(he)-268(addressed)-267(were)-268(fully)-267(persuaded)-267(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-279(supernatural)-279(manifestations)-279(were)-279(then)-279(habitually)-279(present)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-430(the)-429(Church.)-789(It)-430(is)-430(impossible)-429(to)-430(attribute)-430(this)-429(belief)-430(to)-429(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presence)-250(of)-250(the)-250(mythic)-250(or)-250(legendary)-250(spirit.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(Secondly:)-250(It)-249(is)-249(clear)-249(from)-249(other)-249(statements)-249(in)-249(the)-249(Epistles,)-249(not)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(only)-299(that)-299(St.)-397(Paul)-299(firmly)-299(believed)-299(that)-299(he)-299(himself)-299(was)-298(endowed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-248(several)-249(of)-248(these)-248(supernatural)-497(gifts,)-248(but)-248(that)-249(he)-248(had)-248(been)-248(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([419])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(means)-250(of)-250(imparting)-250(them)-250(to)-250(others.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(Thirdly:)-623(If)-436(we)-436(consider)-437(the)-436(nature)-436(of)-437(some)-436(of)-436(these)-437(gift)1(s,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(it)-379(is)-380(difficult)-379(to)-379(conceive)-379(that)-379(a)-380(man)-379(like)-379(St.)-638(Paul)-379(could)-379(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-270(deceived)-271(respecting)-270(their)-270(reality.)-311(Several)-270(of)-270(them)-270(involved)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(accessions)-294(of)-294(mental)-294(power,)-305(as)-294(for)-294(example)-294(the)-294(gift)-294(of)-294(wisdom,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowledge,)-303(and)-293(discerning)-292(of)-292(spirits.)-378(He)-292(must)-293(have)-292(known)-292(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-214(one)-213(time)-214(he)-214(had)-213(nothing)-214(but)-214(his)-214(natural)-213(endowments.)-238(At)-214(a)-213(later)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(period)-312(he)-312(must)-312(have)-312(believed)-312(that)-312(his)-312(wisdom,)-327(knowledge,)-327(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-326(of)-326(discerning)-326(character)-326(was)-326(increased.)-478(These)-326(must)-326(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-387(definite)-387(facts)-387(of)-386(his)-387(mental)-387(consciousness.)-661(It)-387(is)-386(difficult)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-365(conceive)-364(how)-365(delusion)-365(was)-364(possible,)-394(when)-364(in)-365(his)-364(treatment)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-295(the)-295(entire)-295(subject)-295(he)-295(displays)-295(such)-295(clear)-295(indications)-295(of)-295(sound)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(judgment)-250(and)-250(common)-250(sense.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(Fourthly:)-530(It)-391(is)-390(necessary)-390(to)-390(suppose)-390(not)-391(only)-390(that)-390(St.)-670(Paul)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(was)-274(a)-273(prey)-274(to)-273(delusion)-274(on)-273(this)-274(subject)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 165.118 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(if)-273(we)-274(deny)-274(that)-273(the)-274(gifts)]TJ -176.027 -13.55 Td [(were)-245(real)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 40.225 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(but)-245(that)-245(a)-246(similar)-245(delusion)-245(was)-245(spread)-246(over)-245(the)-245(entire)]TJ -51.134 -13.549 Td [(Church.)-752(Its)-417(individual)-417(members)-417(believed)-417(that)-417(they)-417(possessed)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1701 0 obj <<
/Length 4600      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(368)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(them,)-358(no)-337(less)-336(than)-337(the)-336(Apostle.)-510(Those)-336(who)-336(possessed)-337(only)-336(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lower)-417(gifts)-418(were)-417(emulously)-417(desirous)-418(of)-417(possessing)-417(the)-417(higher)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ones.)-668(They)-389(also)-390(made)-389(an)-389(ostentatious)-390(use)-389(of)-389(them.)-668(Such)-389(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-392(the)-392(phenomena)-392(presented)-393(by)-392(enthusiasm.)-676(Was)-392(it)-392(possible)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-242(considerable)-241(numbers)-242(of)-241(persons)-241(should)-242(be)-241(deceived)-242(in)-241(sup-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(posing)-313(that)-314(they)-313(had)-313(acquired)-314(particular)-313(mental)-313(endowments)-313(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(they)-250(well)-250(knew)-250(that)-250(they)-250(had)-250(been)-250(previously)-250(destitute?)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Fifthly:)-415(While)-333(the)-332(phenomena)-333(under)-332(consideration)-333(were)-332(un-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(questionably)-514(believed)-514(both)-514(by)-515(St.)-1042(Paul)-514(and)-514(the)-514(Corinthian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church)-323(to)-322(be)-323(supernatural)-323(manifestations,)-341(yet)-322(it)-323(is)-323(a)-322(supernatu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ralism)-318(which)-317(differs)-318(in)-317(its)-318(entire)-317(aspect)-318(and)-317(character)-318(from)-317(any)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(other)-272(which)-272(has)-272(been)-272(believed)-272(in)-272(by)-272(man.)-316(We)-272(may)-272(wander)-272(over)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-288(entire)-577(regions)-288(of)-288(history)-288(and)-289(fable,)-297(and)-289(we)-288(shall)-288(fail)-288(to)-288(find)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([420])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(any)-288(belief)-288(in)-288(the)-288(supernatural,)-297(bearing)-288(the)-288(smallest)-288(resemblance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-349(it.)-545(It)-349(is)-348(most)-349(definitely)-349(contrasted)-348(with)-349(that)-348(which)-349(has)-348(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ascribed)-367(to)-367(the)-368(contemporaries)-367(of)-367(our)-367(Lord;)-426(and)-367(which)-367(I)-367(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(considered)-218(in)-218(the)-218(earlier)-218(portions)-219(of)-218(this)-218(work.)-239(Whence)-218(has)-218(come)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-317(most)-317(striking)-317(contrast?)-450(If)-317(St.)-451(Paul)-317(and)-317(the)-317(members)-317(of)-316(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Corinthian)-248(Church)-247(were)-248(a)-247(prey)-248(to)-248(the)-247(superstitious)-248(beliefs)-247(above)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(referred)-421(to,)-465(how)-421(was)-422(it)-421(possible)-422(for)-421(them)-422(to)-421(have)-421(considered)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(themselves)-417(to)-417(be)-417(living)-417(in)-417(the)-417(midst)-417(of)-417(an)-417(atmosphere)-417(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(presented)-306(so)-307(marvellous)-306(a)-306(contrast.)-419(The)-306(gifts,)-321(if)-306(real,)-320(were)-306(pre-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cisely)-316(suited)-316(to)-316(the)-316(wants)-316(of)-316(the)-316(Church,)-332(for)-316(building)-316(it)-316(up)-316(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-336(great)-337(institution)-336(which)-337(it)-336(became.)-509(It)-337(required)-336(accessions)-336(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-291(numbers)-290(from)-291(the)-290(populations)-291(in)-291(the)-290(midst)-291(of)-290(which)-291(it)-290(lived.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-261(two)-262(miraculous)-261(gifts,)-264(even)-261(if)-262(they)-261(were)-261(not)-261(evidential,)-264(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fitted)-331(to)-332(draw)-331(attention)-331(to)-331(its)-332(claims.)-494(Collected)-331(as)-331(its)-331(members)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(were)-381(from)-381(Judaism)-381(and)-381(Heathenism,)-414(without)-381(sufficient)-381(means)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-416(their)-416(definite)-415(instruction,)-457(those)-416(who)-416(performed)-416(this)-415(office)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-323(qualified)-323(for)-323(it)-323(by)-323(two)-323(gifts)-323(conferring)-323(various)-323(degrees)-323(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enlightenment.)-422(Then)-308(there)-307(was)-307(the)-308(prophet,)-321(who)-308(as)-307(an)-307(inspired)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(preacher)-315(expounded)-314(and)-315(enforced)-315(the)-314(truths)-315(of)-315(Christianity.)-443(Its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(members)-305(were)-305(ill-qualified)-304(for)-305(public)-305(offices,)-318(owing)-305(to)-305(the)-304(low)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(condition)-402(of)-402(the)-402(society)-403(from)-402(which)-402(they)-402(sprang.)-706(Here)-402(again)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1705 0 obj <<
/Length 4605      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(369)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(were)-313(two)-313(mental)-313(endowments)-313(to)-313(supply)-313(the)-313(need,)-329(the)-312(power)-313(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discerning)-397(spirits)-397(and)-397(the)-397(supernatural)-397(gift)-397(of)-397(faith.)-691(All)-396(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gifts)-281(here)-281(enumerated,)-289(were)-281(the)-281(very)-281(endowments)-281(suited)-281(for)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(building)-289(up)-290(of)-289(a)-289(body)-290(of)-289(converts)-289(taken)-290(from)-289(such)-289(unpromising)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sources,)-285(into)-277(the)-278(great)-278(society)-278(to)-277(which)-278(it)-278(speedily)-278(grew.)-333(A)-277(new)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(society)-208(had)-208(to)-208(be)-208(formed)-208(of)-208(a)-208(wholly)-208(different)-208(character)-208(from)-207(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(previously)-244(existing.)-248(It)-244(was)-244(designed)-244(to)-244(leaven)-244(by)-244(new)-244(influences)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-287(state)-286(of)-287(religious,)-295(moral,)-296(and)-573(political)-287(thought)-286(out)-287(of)-286(which)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([421])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(it)-261(originated.)-281(The)-261(old)-260(social)-260(organization)-261(met)-260(it)-261(with)-260(determined)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(opposition.)-431(The)-310(problem)-310(was)-311(how)-310(was)-310(it)-310(to)-311(be)-310(erected)-310(on)-310(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-454(basis)-455(as)-454(would)-454(give)-454(it)-455(permanence?)-863(The)-454(Church)-454(of)-454(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ)-417(was)-417(to)-418(be)-417(a)-417(new)-417(moral)-417(creation)-418(in)-417(the)-417(midst)-417(of)-417(effete)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(society.)-531(An)-344(extensive)-343(communication)-344(of)-344(endowments,)-367(such)-343(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-280(referred)-281(to)-280(in)-280(the)-280(Pauline)-281(Epistles,)-287(was)-281(the)-280(very)-280(thing)-280(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-251(requisite)-250(to)-251(accomplish)-250(this)-251(purpose.)-251(It)-250(came)-251(into)-250(existence;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-288(grew;)-307(it)-288(struggled;)-308(it)-288(conquered;)-307(it)-288(subverted)-288(the)-288(old)-288(forms)-288(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(civilization;)-345(it)-314(created)-314(new)-313(ones.)-441(These)-314(are)-313(facts)-314(which)-313(require)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-328(be)-327(accounted)-328(for.)-483(The)-328(forces)-327(referred)-328(to)-328(in)-327(these)-328(Epistles)-327(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-366(active)-366(energy)-366(before)-366(the)-366(eyes)-366(of)-366(St.)-598(Paul)-366(and)-366(the)-365(members)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-268(these)-268(Churches,)-273(were)-268(adequate)-268(to)-268(have)-268(effected)-268(this.)-304(Without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(some)-340(such)-340(moral)-340(creation)-340(attending)-340(the)-340(first)-340(planting)-340(of)-340(Chris-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tianity,)-389(the)-362(formation)-361(of)-362(this)-361(unique)-362(society)-361(out)-362(of)-361(the)-361(various)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(elements)-299(of)-298(which)-299(it)-299(was)-299(composed,)-310(and)-299(their)-299(welding)-298(together)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-242(an)-242(organization)-241(instinct)-242(with)-242(life,)-243(which)-242(has)-242(imbued)-242(with)-241(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(principles)-247(all)-246(existing)-247(institutions,)-248(must)-246(remain)-247(a)-247(problem)-246(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(baffles)-250(all)-250(the)-250(attempts)-250(of)-250(philosophy)-250(to)-250(solve.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(Lastly:)-329(These)-289(letters)-290(prove)-289(on)-289(the)-290(highest)-289(historical)-289(evidence)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(that)-329(a)-328(supernatural)-329(power)-328(was)-329(believed)-328(to)-329(be)-328(manifested)-329(in)-328(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church)-347(at)-346(the)-347(date)-347(of)-347(their)-346(composition,)-371(wholly)-347(different)-346(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-381(kind)-382(of)-381(ordinary)-381(current)-382(supernatural)-381(belief.)-644(Through)-381(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Acts)-407(of)-407(the)-407(Apostles,)-446(its)-407(existence)-407(can)-407(be)-407(traced)-407(up)-407(to)-407(a)-406(still)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(earlier)-212(period.)-237(Two)-211(of)-212(these)-211(gifts,)-219(but)-212(two)-211(only,)-219(involved)-212(a)-211(power)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-292(we)-292(should)-292(now)-293(designate)-292(as)-292(essentially)-292(miraculous.)-376(This)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-310(so,)-324(the)-309(testimony)-310(of)-309(St.)-429(Paul,)-324(involving)-310(as)-309(it)-310(does)-309(that)-309(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1710 0 obj <<
/Length 1872      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(370)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(the)-324(entire)-324(Church,)-342(is)-324(express)-324(as)-324(to)-324(the)-324(belief)-324(of)-323(contemporaries)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-307(miracles)-306(were)-307(actually)-306(performed.)-419(We)-307(can)-306(trace)-307(this)-306(belief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(up)-351(to)-352(the)-351(first)-352(origin)-351(of)-352(Christianity.)-554(If)-352(Jesus)-351(was)-352(believed)-351(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([422])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(have)-275(endowed)-274(His)-275(followers)-275(with)-275(this)-274(power,)-281(it)-275(is)-275(impossible)-274(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(believe)-320(that)-320(He)-320(was)-320(not)-320(supposed)-320(to)-320(have)-320(possessed)-320(it)-319(himself.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(These)-300(Epistles)-300(therefore)-299(are)-300(evidence)-300(that)-300(the)-300(earliest)-299(followers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-324(Jesus)-324(believed)-324(that)-324(He)-324(was)-324(a)-324(worker)-324(of)-324(miracles.)-472(So)-324(far)-324(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proof)-238(is)-238(complete)-238(that)-237(the)-238(ascription)-238(of)-238(miracles)-238(to)-238(Jesus)-238(and)-237(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(original)-278(followers)-279(was)-278(not)-278(due)-278(to)-279(the)-278(imagination)-278(of)-278(subsequent)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(generations.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(The)-325(careful)-324(perusal)-325(of)-324(these)-325(Epistles)-324(can)-325(leave)-324(only)-325(one)-324(im-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(pression)-297(on)-296(the)-297(mind)-297(of)-296(the)-297(reader,)-308(that)-297(he)-297(is)-296(in)-297(the)-297(presence)-296(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(facts)-250(of)-250(an)-250(unquestionably)-250(historical)-250(character.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -29.651 Td [([423])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1719 0 obj <<
/Length 3531      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-270(XIX.)-270(The)-270(Evidence)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Furnished)-256(By)-255(The)-256(Epistles)-255(To)-256(The)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Facts)-257(Of)-258(Our)-257(Lord's)-257(Life,)-259(And)-257(To)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(The)-250(Truth)-250(Of)-250(The)-250(Resurrection.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -39.701 Td [(I)-246(have)-246(proved)-246(in)-246(the)-246(last)-245(chapter)-246(that)-246(St.)-249(Paul)-246(and)-246(those)-246(to)-245(whom)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-395(wrote)-395(his)-395(Epistles)-395(firmly)-395(believed)-395(that)-395(a)-395(number)-395(of)-395(super-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(natural)-231(manifestations)-231(were)-231(displaying)-231(themselves)-231(in)-231(the)-230(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-349(their)-348(immediate)-349(observation,)-373(and)-349(that)-348(their)-349(presence)-348(can)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-326(traced)-327(up)-326(to)-327(a)-326(much)-327(earlier)-326(date.)-479(I)-327(have)-326(also)-327(shown)-326(that)-326(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Paul)-251(asserts)-250(in)-251(the)-250(most)-251(positive)-250(language)-251(that)-250(he)-251(was)-250(persuaded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-231(he)-231(wrought)-231(miracles)-231(during)-231(the)-231(whole)-231(course)-231(of)-231(his)-231(mission.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-238(is)-238(therefore)-238(in)-239(the)-238(highest)-238(degree)-238(probable)-238(that)-238(the)-238(servant)-238(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(convinced)-400(that)-399(he)-400(did)-399(by)-400(the)-399(divine)-399(power)-400(of)-399(his)-400(Master)-399(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-242(he)-241(believed)-242(that)-241(his)-241(Master)-242(had)-241(accomplished)-242(before)-241(him;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-318(other)-318(words,)-334(that)-318(he)-318(was)-318(a)-318(worker)-318(of)-317(miracles.)-454(But)-318(as)-318(it)-317(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-311(asserted)-312(that)-311(St.)-434(Paul)-311(knew)-312(only)-311(of)-311(a)-312(divine,)-326(and)-311(scarcely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(anything)-293(of)-292(a)-293(human)-292(Jesus,)-303(that)-293(is)-292(to)-293(say,)-303(that)-292(he)-293(was)-292(to)-293(a)-292(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(extent)-358(ignorant)-358(of)-358(the)-358(events)-358(of)-358(our)-358(Lord's)-358(life,)-385(I)-358(must)-357(inquire)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(what)-410(light)-411(the)-410(Epistles)-410(throw)-410(on)-411(this)-410(subject;)-490(for)-411(if)-410(it)-410(can)-410(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(shown)-250(that)-251(St.)-250(Paul)-251(allowed)-250(himself)-250(to)-250(be)-251(ignorant)-250(of)-250(the)-250(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(life)-330(of)-330(Jesus,)-350(it)-330(lowers)-330(the)-330(value)-330(of)-330(his)-330(testimony)-330(to)-330(the)-330(fact)-330(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(Resurrection.)]TJ 11.956 -15.005 Td [(The)-291(ground)-291(of)-291(this)-292(affirmation)-291(is)-291(that)-291(the)-291(direct)-291(references)-291(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-306(events)-307(of)-306(our)-306(Lord's)-306(life)-307(are)-306(few,)-320(and)-307(that)-306(he)-306(chiefly)-306(dwells)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-396(the)-397(glorified)-396(aspect)-397(of)-396(it)-396(after)-397(His)-396(Resurrection.)-689(The)-396(only)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(passage,)-212(as)-204(far)-203(as)-203(I)-203(am)-203(aware,)-212(which)-203(has)-203(been)-203(adduced)-203(as)-203(proving)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-214(strange)-213(position)-214(is)-213(the)-214(following:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 160.141 0 Td [(\024\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.753 0 Td [(He)-213(died)-214(for)-214(all,)-220(that)-214(they)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1722 0 obj <<
/Length 4991      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(372)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 2.761 -30.759 Td [(which)-253(live)-253(should)-253(not)-253(henceforth)-253(live)-253(unto)-253(themselves,)-254(but)-253(unto)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -75.516 0 Td [([424])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(him)-273(which)-273(died)-273(for)-273(them)-273(and)-273(rose)-273(again.)-320(Wherefore,)-278(henceforth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(know)-369(we)-369(no)-369(man)-368(after)-369(the)-369(flesh;)-428(yea,)-399(though)-369(we)-369(have)-368(known)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ)-233(after)-232(the)-233(flesh,)-236(yet)-233(now)-232(henceforth)-233(know)-233(we)-232(him)-233(no)-232(more.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Therefore,)-421(if)-386(any)-386(man)-387(be)-386(in)-387(Christ,)-420(he)-386(is)-387(a)-386(new)-387(creature:)-522(old)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(things)-359(are)-359(passed)-360(away;)-413(behold)-360(all)-359(things)-359(are)-359(become)-359(new.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 266.414 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.762 0 Td [(2)]TJ -275.176 -13.549 Td [(Cor.)-242(v.)-242(15-17.)-242(The)-225(utmost)-226(that)-225(this)-226(passage)-225(can)-226(be)-225(made)-226(to)-225(prove)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is,)-411(that)-379(the)-379(belief)-379(in)-378(the)-379(Resurrection)-379(of)-379(Christ)-379(had)-379(thrown)-378(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entirely)-313(new)-313(aspect)-313(over)-314(His)-313(human)-313(life.)-439(The)-313(persons)-313(who)-313(had)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(witnessed)-310(it)-310(had)-311(not)-310(seen)-310(its)-310(true)-310(significance.)-431(This)-310(is)-310(what)-310(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Synoptic)-251(Gospels)-250(plainly)-251(affirm)-251(to)-250(have)-251(been)-251(the)-250(case)-251(even)-250(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-398(Apostles)-397(during)-398(His)-397(public)-398(ministry.)-692(They)-398(had)-397(witnessed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-317(events,)-334(but)-318(they)-317(had)-317(failed)-317(to)-318(penetrate)-317(into)-317(their)-317(inner)-317(life.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-400(is)-401(what)-400(the)-401(Apostle)-400(means)-401(by)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 164.51 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(knowing)-400(Christ)-401(after)-400(the)]TJ -169.354 -13.55 Td [(flesh,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 23.935 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 7.963 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 17.235 0 Td [(according)-286(to)-286(the)-286(uniform)-286(meaning)-286(of)-286(that)-286(expression)]TJ -49.133 -13.549 Td [(in)-235(the)-235(New)-235(Testament,)-239(the)-235(knowing)-235(the)-235(events)-235(of)-235(His)-235(life)-235(merely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(externally,)-409(as)-376(so)-377(many)-377(bare)-377(objective)-377(facts)-377(devoid)-377(of)-376(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(significance.)-237(This)-212(he)-212(affirms)-212(would)-212(be)-212(the)-212(mode)-212(in)-212(which)-212(neither)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-262(nor)-262(the)-262(Church)-262(would)-262(in)-262(future)-262(contemplate)-262(this)-262(subject.)-286(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(very)-283(words)-283(which)-283(he)-283(uses)-282(imply)-283(that)-283(he)-283(and)-283(others)-283(had)-283(had)-282(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowledge)-387(of)-387(Jesus.)-661(But)-387(such)-387(a)-387(knowledge)-387(would)-387(have)-386(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impossible)-313(without)-313(an)-313(intimate)-313(acquaintance)-313(with)-313(the)-313(events)-313(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-391(human)-391(life.)-673(What)-391(he)-391(affirms)-391(is,)-426(that)-391(he)-391(will)-391(contemplate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-250(in)-250(future)-250(in)-250(their)-250(moral)-250(and)-250(religions)-250(aspect.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(The)-316(affirmation)-316(that)-316(St.)-447(Paul)-316(was)-316(not)-316(thoroughly)-315(acquainted)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(with)-259(the)-259(details)-260(of)-259(our)-259(Lord's)-259(ministry,)-262(and)-259(that)-259(after)-259(his)-259(conver-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sion)-373(he)-372(was)-373(simply)-373(absorbed)-372(in)-373(the)-373(contemplation)-372(of)-373(a)-372(divine)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Christ)-396(is)-397(incredible.)-689(When)-397(we)-396(are)-397(asked)-396(to)-397(accept)-396(a)-396(startling)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proposition,)-328(it)-313(is)-313(necessary)-312(that)-313(it)-313(should)-312(not)-313(offend)-313(against)-312(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first)-653(principles)-327(of)-327(human)-326(nature.)-480(That)-327(a)-327(man)-326(like)-327(St.)-480(Paul)-326(did)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([425])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(not)-313(make)-312(accurate)-313(inquiries)-312(into)-312(the)-313(facts)-312(of)-313(his)-312(Master's)-313(life)-312(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inconceivable.)-449(In)-316(his)-316(eyes)-316(His)-317(human)-316(was)-316(the)-316(manifestation)-316(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(His)-336(divine)-336(life.)-509(Did)-336(not)-337(the)-336(persecutor)-336(Saul)-336(thoroughly)-336(inform)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(himself)-457(respecting)-458(the)-457(life)-458(and)-457(actions)-457(of)-458(Him)-457(whose)-457(divine)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1727 0 obj <<
/Length 4658      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(373)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(mission)-378(he)-378(denied,)-410(and)-377(whom)-378(he)-378(believed)-378(to)-378(be)-378(an)-377(impostor?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Was)-307(not)-307(this)-307(the)-307(obvious)-308(course)-307(to)-307(take,)-321(in)-307(order)-307(to)-307(enable)-307(him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-321(expose)-320(imposition,)-339(and)-320(to)-321(destroy)-321(the)-320(Church?)-462(On)-321(the)-320(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hand,)-349(the)-329(converted)-330(Paul)-329(was)-329(animated)-329(by)-330(a)-329(more)-329(intense)-329(love)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(for)-209(Jesus)-209(than)-209(one)-209(man)-210(ever)-209(felt)-209(for)-209(another.)-236(Is)-209(it)-209(conceivable)-209(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-334(love)-333(did)-334(not)-334(impel)-333(him)-334(to)-333(treasure)-334(up)-334(in)-333(his)-334(bosom)-333(every)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reminiscence)-248(which)-248(fell)-247(within)-248(his)-248(reach,)-248(and)-248(to)-248(inquire)-248(with)-247(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(most)-283(profound)-283(interest)-284(into)-283(the)-283(life)-283(and)-284(actions)-283(of)-283(him)-283(who)-283(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(become)-200(the)-199(object)-200(of)-200(his)-199(adoration?)-233(Is)-200(it)-200(conceivable)-199(that)-200(the)-199(man)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(who)-238(was)-238(incessantly)-238(inquiring)-238(into)-238(the)-238(condition)-238(of)-238(his)-238(converts,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-250(no)-250(inquiry)-250(about)-250(the)-250(life)-250(and)-250(actions)-250(of)-250(his)-250(Master?)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(The)-320(position)-321(of)-320(St.)-462(Paul,)-338(the)-320(ardour)-321(of)-320(his)-320(temperament,)-338(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(fierceness)-349(of)-348(his)-348(opposition,)-374(and)-348(the)-349(intense)-348(self-sacrifice)-348(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-274(he)-275(afterwards)-274(consecrated)-275(himself)-274(to)-275(Jesus)-274(Christ,)-280(falling)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-254(communication)-253(as)-254(he)-253(must)-253(with)-254(persons)-253(who)-254(had)-253(witnessed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-168(earthly)-169(ministry,)-185(are)-168(sufficient)-168(proof)-169(that)-168(the)-169(Apostle)-168(had)-168(used)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(every)-279(available)-278(means)-279(of)-279(becoming)-279(acquainted)-278(with)-279(the)-279(facts)-278(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-327(life.)-482(But)-327(in)-328(the)-327(Epistles)-327(themselves,)-347(although)-327(owing)-327(to)-327(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(circumstances)-322(which)-321(called)-322(them)-322(forth,)-339(they)-322(contain)-322(few)-321(direct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(references)-214(to)-214(it,)-221(the)-214(indirect)-214(allusions)-214(are)-214(quite)-214(sufficient)-214(to)-213(prove)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-305(St.)-414(Paul)-305(and)-305(those)-305(whom)-305(he)-304(addressed,)-319(were)-305(in)-304(possession)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-272(a)-272(number)-271(of)-272(facts)-272(respecting)-271(their)-272(Master's)-272(life)-272(which)-271(formed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-276(subject)-276(of)-276(a)-276(common)-276(Christology.)-328(I)-276(am)-276(quite)-276(ready)-276(to)-275(admit)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-302(when)-303(the)-302(Apostle)-302(wrote,)-315(none)-303(of)-302(our)-302(present)-302(Gospels)-302(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-442(existence.)-240(The)-221(converts)-221(had)-221(to)-221(receive)-221(their)-221(instruction)-221(orally,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([426])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(or)-291(from)-291(short)-290(written)-291(memoranda.)-372(But)-291(instruction)-291(of)-291(some)-290(kind)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-312(must)-312(have)-312(had.)-437(Without)-312(it,)-327(converts)-312(from)-312(Paganism)-312(could)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-359(known)-359(nothing)-359(about)-358(Him)-359(to)-359(whom)-359(in)-359(the)-359(act)-359(of)-358(joining)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-303(Church)-303(they)-303(professed)-303(allegiance;)-329(Jewish)-303(converts)-303(living)-303(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gentile)-278(cities,)-284(but)-277(little.)-333(As)-277(Christianity)-278(was)-277(not)-278(a)-277(mere)-278(body)-277(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dogmas,)-297(like)-287(a)-288(philosophy,)-296(but)-288(consisted)-287(in)-287(direct)-288(adhesion)-287(to)-287(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(person,)-247(it)-246(is)-246(clear)-246(that)-246(it)-246(could)-246(not)-246(be)-246(propagated)-246(at)-246(all)-246(without)-246(at)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-278(same)-279(time)-278(communicating)-278(information)-279(respecting)-278(His)-278(histo-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ry.)-365(The)-289(early)-288(missionaries)-288(announced)-289(that)-288(Jesus)-289(was)-288(the)-288(Christ.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1731 0 obj <<
/Length 5631      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(374)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Such)-188(an)-189(announcement)-188(would)-188(have)-189(been)-188(meaningless)-188(unless)-188(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-353(given)-352(an)-353(account)-353(of)-352(who)-353(Jesus)-353(was,)-378(what)-353(He)-352(had)-353(done)-352(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(claim)-329(the)-330(homage)-329(of)-329(those)-330(addressed,)-349(and)-329(what)-330(was)-329(the)-329(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-253(His)-253(office.)-259(These)-253(considerations)-253(establish)-253(the)-253(fact)-253(that)-253(an)-252(oral)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(account)-299(of)-298(His)-299(life)-298(must)-299(have)-299(been)-298(handed)-299(down)-298(in)-299(the)-298(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prior)-315(to)-314(the)-315(publication)-314(of)-315(written)-314(Gospels,)-331(sufficiently)-314(definite)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-386(constitute)-387(the)-386(Christianity)-386(of)-387(the)-386(converts.)-659(The)-386(intimations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contained)-250(in)-250(the)-250(Epistles)-250(prove)-250(that)-250(such)-250(was)-250(the)-250(fact.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(First)-342(let)-342(us)-343(consider)-342(St.)-526(Paul's)-343(own)-342(positive)-342(assertions.)-526(The)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(most)-319(important)-320(is)-319(in)-320(1)-319(Cor.)-458(xv.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 145.01 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Moreover,)-337(brethren,)-337(I)-319(declare)]TJ -149.853 -13.549 Td [(unto)-316(you)-316(\050)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 46.285 0 Td [(\263\275\311\301)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 23.564 0 Td [(w)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\266\311)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 11.989 0 Td [(,)-316(I)-316(remind)-316(you)-316(of,)-332(or)-316(refresh)-316(your)-316(memories)]TJ -85.045 -13.549 Td [(respecting\051)-352(the)-353(Gospel)-352(\050)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 107.873 0 Td [(\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 4.691 0 Td [(x)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 9.277 0 Td [(\265)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(P)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.531 0 Td [(\261\263\263)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 16.091 0 Td [(s)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\273\271\277\275)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 19.931 0 Td [(\051)-352(which)-353(I)-352(preached)-353(unto)]TJ -172.558 -13.55 Td [(you,)-472(which)-427(also)-428(ye)-427(have)-428(received,)-472(and)-427(wherein)-428(ye)-427(stand;)-516(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-294(also)-294(ye)-294(are)-294(saved,)-304(if)-294(ye)-294(keep)-294(in)-294(memory)-294(what)-294(I)-293(preached)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unto)-307(you,)-321(unless)-307(ye)-307(have)-307(believed)-307(in)-307(vain.)-421(For)-307(I)-307(delivered)-307(unto)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(you)-277(first)-278(of)-277(all)-277(\050)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 69.668 0 Td [(\020)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\275)-277(\300\301)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 19.509 0 Td [(})]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 7.636 0 Td [(\304\277\271\302)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 17.782 0 Td [(,)-277(as)-278(matter)-277(of)-277(prime)-278(importance\051)-277(that)]TJ -119.177 -13.549 Td [(which)-210(I)-209(also)-209(received,)-218(how)-210(that)-209(Christ)-209(died)-210(for)-209(our)-210(sins)-209(according)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-248(the)-248(Scriptures;)-249(and)-248(that)-249(He)-248(was)-248(buried,)-249(and)-248(that)-248(He)-248(rose)-248(again)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(third)-250(day)-250(according)-250(to)-250(the)-250(Scriptures.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 177.851 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -250.607 0 Td [([427])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -14.776 Td [(Let)-234(it)-235(be)-234(observed)-234(that)-235(the)-234(subject)-234(which)-235(the)-234(Apostle)-234(was)-235(here)]TJ -11.955 -13.55 Td [(discussing)-254(with)-255(certain)-254(members)-254(of)-255(this)-254(Church)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 208.146 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(the)-254(possibility)]TJ -219.055 -13.549 Td [(of)-311(a)-311(resurrection)-311(of)-310(the)-311(dead)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 126.004 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(led)-311(him)-311(to)-311(refer)-310(to)-311(the)-311(first)-311(prin-)]TJ -136.913 -13.549 Td [(ciples)-368(of)-369(Christianity)-368(as)-369(he)-368(had)-369(taught)-368(them.)-606(They)-368(denied)-368(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth)-278(of)-278(a)-279(material)-278(resurrection.)-334(St.)-335(Paul)-278(draws)-278(their)-278(attention)-278(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-354(fact)-354(that)-354(Christianity)-353(as)-354(taught)-354(by)-354(him)-354(consisted)-354(of)-354(a)-353(body)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-397(facts.)-692(The)-397(following)-397(points)-397(are)-397(clearly)-397(deducible)-397(from)-397(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(passage)-250(before)-250(us.)]TJ 11.955 -14.776 Td [(1.)-673(The)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 36.753 0 Td [(\265)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(P)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.531 0 Td [(\261\263\263)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 16.091 0 Td [(s)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 4.582 0 Td [(\273\273\271\277\275)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 25.69 0 Td [(,)-426(or)-391(message)-391(of)-391(good)-391(news,)-427(which)-391(the)]TJ -105.184 -13.549 Td [(Apostle)-251(had)-250(announced)-251(at)-250(his)-251(first)-251(preaching)-250(at)-251(Corinth,)-250(consist-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ed)-314(of)-314(a)-313(body)-314(of)-314(facts)-314(as)-313(distinct)-314(from)-314(mere)-314(doctrinal)-313(teachings;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-359(that)-359(whatever)-360(doctrines)-359(he)-359(taught)-359(were)-360(built)-359(on)-359(them)-359(as)-359(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(foundation.)]TJ 11.955 -14.777 Td [(2.)-245(Among)-236(the)-236(facts)-236(of)-236(prime)-236(importance)-237(which)-236(he)-236(announced,)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(was)-250(the)-250(death,)-250(burial,)-250(and)-250(resurrection)-250(of)-250(Christ.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1735 0 obj <<
/Length 4529      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(375)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -252.311 -30.759 Td [(3.)-319(He)-273(states)-274(that)-273(in)-273(his)-273(preaching)-273(there)-273(were)-273(matters)-273(of)-273(prime)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(importance,)-271(of)-267(which)-266(Christ's)-267(death)-267(and)-267(resurrection)-266(was)-267(one.)-300(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(follows)-310(therefore)-309(that)-310(there)-309(were)-310(other)-310(matters)-309(of)-310(prime)-309(impor-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tance,)-271(which)-267(his)-267(present)-267(argument)-266(did)-267(not)-267(require)-267(him)-267(to)-266(notice.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(This)-227(is)-227(obvious)-226(from)-227(the)-227(nature)-227(of)-227(the)-226(case:)-239(the)-227(announcement)-226(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ's)-263(death)-263(and)-264(resurrection)-263(would)-263(have)-263(been)-263(scarcely)-263(intelli-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gible)-306(without)-306(the)-306(addition)-306(of)-306(a)-306(great)-306(many)-306(other)-306(facts)-306(to)-306(give)-305(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(meaning.)-244(But)-233(further,)-236(the)-233(assertion)-232(that)-233(there)-233(were)-232(facts)-233(of)-232(prime)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(importance,)-499(implies)-450(that)-449(there)-450(were)-449(also)-450(points)-449(of)-449(secondary)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(importance,)-243(which)-241(he)-241(must)-241(have)-241(announced)-241(likewise,)-243(or)-241(in)-241(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(words,)-230(that)-226(the)-225(Gospel)-226(which)-225(he)-225(proclaimed)-226(must)-225(have)-225(consisted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(an)-250(account,)-250(more)-250(or)-250(less)-250(full,)-250(of)-250(the)-250(human)-250(life)-250(of)-250(Jesus.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(4.)-818(This)-439(account)-439(the)-439(Apostle)-439(says)-440(that)-439(he)-439(delivered)-439(to)-439(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Corinthian)-327(Church.)-480(The)-326(words)-327(imply)-326(that)-327(he)-327(committed)-326(it)-327(in)-326(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(formal)-256(manner)-255(to)-255(their)-256(keeping,)-257(as)-511(the)-255(ground)-256(of)-255(their)-255(Christian)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([428])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(instruction.)-247(This)-242(he)-241(likewise)-242(affirms)-242(that)-241(he)-242(had)-241(no)-242(less)-241(formally)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(received.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(5.)-431(As)-310(his)-311(statement)-310(respecting)-310(the)-311(Resurrection)-310(is)-310(somewhat)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(minute,)-251(the)-251(inference)-250(is,)-251(that)-251(the)-251(other)-250(facts)-251(of)-251(prime)-250(importance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-198(communicated)-197(with)-198(equal)-197(detail.)-232(It)-198(is)-197(also)-198(fairly)-197(presumable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-303(in)-304(his)-303(oral)-304(communications)-303(the)-303(Apostle)-304(did)-303(not)-304(give)-303(a)-303(bare)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(list)-449(of)-448(the)-449(appearances)-448(of)-449(Jesus)-449(after)-448(his)-449(Resurrection,)-498(but)-448(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(detailed)-294(account)-294(of)-294(them;)-316(and)-294(so)-294(with)-294(respect)-294(to)-294(his)-294(other)-294(facts.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-389(his)-388(converts)-389(would)-389(naturally)-388(have)-389(required)-389(him)-388(to)-389(do,)-423(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-275(suppose)-276(that)-275(they)-275(were)-275(only)-276(animated)-275(by)-275(common)-275(curiosity.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-266(less)-267(important)-266(facts)-266(would)-266(be)-267(necessary)-266(to)-266(connect)-266(together)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(those)-379(of)-380(primary)-379(importance.)-638(In)-380(short,)-412(the)-379(Apostle's)-379(narrative)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-250(have)-250(been)-250(what)-250(we)-250(may)-250(call)-250(a)-250(brief)-250(Gospel.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(6.)-274(As)-259(St.)-274(Paul)-258(states)-258(that)-259(one)-258(of)-258(the)-258(facts)-258(which)-258(he)-258(committed)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(to)-250(the)-251(Church)-250(was)-250(that)-250(Christ)-251(died)-250(for)-250(our)-250(sins,)-251(it)-250(follows)-250(that)-250(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-238(have)-238(given)-238(an)-238(account)-238(of)-238(his)-238(death)-238(more)-238(or)-238(less)-237(resembling)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-250(in)-250(our)-250(present)-250(Gospels.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(7.)-531(One)-344(of)-343(the)-344(great)-344(facts)-343(which)-344(he)-344(delivered)-343(to)-344(the)-343(Church,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(was)-293(that)-293(of)-294(the)-293(Resurrection)-293(of)-293(Christ.)-380(This)-293(is)-293(the)-293(great)-293(miracle)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1740 0 obj <<
/Length 5185      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(376)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(of)-399(Christianity;)-472(the)-399(one)-398(to)-399(which)-398(it)-399(is)-398(expressly)-399(affirmed)-398(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-285(Church)-285(owes)-284(its)-285(being.)-354(The)-285(Apostle's)-285(Gospel)-285(therefore)-284(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tained)-345(a)-344(detailed)-345(account)-345(of)-344(one)-345(great)-345(miracle.)-534(It)-344(is)-345(also)-344(fairly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presumable)-322(that)-322(among)-322(his)-321(other)-322(facts)-322(of)-322(primary)-322(or)-321(secondary)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(importance)-237(were)-238(accounts)-237(of)-238(supernatural)-237(occurrences)-238(in)-237(the)-237(life)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(Jesus.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(8.)-238(The)-214(Apostle)-215(does)-214(not)-214(leave)-214(us)-215(without)-214(the)-214(means)-214(of)-214(judging)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(respecting)-306(the)-307(amount)-306(of)-306(matter)-306(in)-306(these)-307(narratives)-306(of)-306(events)-306(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-387(life)-387(of)-387(Christ)-387(which)-388(he)-387(committed)-387(to)-387(the)-387(Church.)-661(He)-387(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(given)-264(us)-264(\050in)-264(1)-265(Cor.)-292(xi.)-293(23-25\051)-264(a)-264(formal)-264(account)-264(of)-264(the)-264(institution)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-279(our)-279(Lord's)-278(Supper,)-286(quite)-279(as)-279(full)-279(as)-279(that)-278(contained)-279(in)-279(either)-557(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([429])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(our)-258(Gospels.)-273(This)-257(account)-258(he)-257(prefaces)-258(by)-258(the)-257(same)-258(words)-257(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-378(have)-378(already)-378(considered,)-411(as)-378(denoting)-378(the)-378(form)-378(or)-378(mode)-378(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-261(he)-261(received)-261(it,)-264(and)-261(delivered)-261(it)-261(to)-261(the)-261(Church:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 230.709 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(For)-261(I)-261(have)]TJ -235.553 -13.549 Td [(received)-206(of)-206(the)-206(Lord)-206(that)-205(which)-206(also)-206(I)-206(delivered)-206(unto)-206(you,)-215(that)-205(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Lord)-243(Jesus)-243(the)-243(same)-243(night)-243(in)-243(which)-243(He)-243(was)-243(betrayed)-243(took)-243(bread;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-288(when)-287(He)-288(had)-288(given)-287(thanks)-288(He)-288(brake)-287(it,)-298(and)-287(said,)-297(Take,)-297(eat;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-199(is)-199(My)-199(body)-199(which)-199(is)-199(broken)-199(for)-199(you.)-233(This)-199(do)-199(in)-198(remembrance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-203(Me.)-234(After)-203(the)-202(same)-203(manner)-202(also)-203(He)-203(took)-202(the)-203(cup,)-212(when)-203(He)-202(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supped,)-226(saying,)-226(This)-220(cup)-220(is)-220(the)-220(New)-220(Testament)-220(in)-220(My)-220(blood:)-235(this)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(do)-253(ye)-252(as)-253(oft)-253(as)-252(ye)-253(drink)-253(it,)-253(in)-253(remembrance)-252(of)-253(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 216.95 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.6 0 Td [(This)-253(account)]TJ -224.55 -13.549 Td [(varies)-314(in)-314(words,)-329(but)-314(it)-314(is)-314(equal)-313(in)-314(minuteness,)-330(and)-313(substantially)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agrees)-216(with)-216(those)-216(in)-216(our)-217(present)-216(Gospels;)-227(although)-216(it)-216(more)-216(nearly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(approaches,)-285(while)-277(it)-278(is)-278(not)-277(precisely)-278(identical)-277(with)-278(that)-278(of)-277(Luke,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-334(is)-334(asserted)-334(in)-334(the)-333(Acts)-334(to)-334(have)-334(been)-334(the)-334(companion)-334(of)-333(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Apostle.)-248(Judging)-243(therefore)-242(by)-243(this)-243(example,)-245(the)-243(historical)-242(details)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-350(St.)-550(Paul)-349(committed)-350(to)-350(the)-350(Church)-350(respecting)-350(the)-350(life)-349(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-250(must)-250(have)-250(been)-250(of)-250(considerable)-250(minuteness.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(8.)-249(Another)-247(fact)-248(in)-247(the)-248(life)-247(of)-247(our)-248(Lord)-247(is)-247(directly)-248(referred)-247(to)-247(in)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(these)-319(letters,)-335(His)-319(descent)-319(from)-318(the)-319(family)-318(of)-319(David.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 234.14 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Who)-319(was)]TJ -238.984 -13.549 Td [(made,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 26.357 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.631 0 Td [(says)-255(the)-256(Apostle,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 77.159 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(of)-255(the)-256(seed)-256(of)-255(David,)-257(according)-255(to)-256(the)]TJ -115.991 -13.549 Td [(flesh,)-226(and)-220(declared)-220(to)-220(be)-220(the)-220(Son)-220(of)-220(God)-220(with)-220(power)-220(according)-220(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-294(spirit)-294(of)-294(holiness,)-305(by)-294(the)-294(resurrection)-294(from)-294(the)-294(dead.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 246.528 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.051 0 Td [(These)]TJ -254.579 -13.549 Td [(words)-256(prove)-257(that)-256(St.)-269(Paul)-256(was)-257(in)-256(possession)-256(of)-257(an)-256(account)-256(of)-256(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1744 0 obj <<
/Length 5021      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(377)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(birth)-356(of)-356(Jesus,)-383(which)-356(in)-357(this)-356(particular)-356(point)-356(was)-356(in)-356(agreement)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-354(that)-354(in)-354(St.)-562(Matthew's)-354(and)-354(St.)-562(Luke's)-354(Gospels,)-380(and)-354(that)-354(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-235(known)-235(to)-236(the)-235(members)-235(of)-235(the)-236(Church)-235(at)-235(Rome,)-238(and)-235(received)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-264(them)-265(as)-264(true.)-293(He)-264(does)-264(not)-264(positively)-264(affirm)-265(that)-264(the)-264(birth)-264(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supernatural;)-468(but)-395(his)-396(language)-395(clearly)-395(implies)-396(it.)-686(It)-395(would)-395(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(absurd)-343(in)-343(speaking)-343(of)-343(an)-343(ordinary)-686(human)-343(birth)-343(to)-343(say)-343(that)-343(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([430])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(person)-226(born)-226(was)-225(descended)-226(from)-226(his)-225(ancestors,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 206.029 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(according)-226(to)-225(the)]TJ -210.873 -13.549 Td [(flesh.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 23.935 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.081 0 Td [(The)-205(natural)-205(meaning)-205(of)-206(such)-205(an)-205(expression)-205(is)-205(that)-205(both)-205(the)]TJ -31.016 -13.549 Td [(writer)-279(and)-278(those)-279(whom)-279(he)-279(was)-278(addressing)-279(were)-279(well)-278(acquainted)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-286(an)-286(account)-286(of)-286(the)-286(supernatural)-286(birth)-286(of)-286(Jesus,)-295(and)-286(accepted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-262(as)-261(true.)-285(So)-261(far)-262(their)-262(accounts)-261(and)-262(that)-261(in)-262(the)-261(Gospels)-262(agreed)-261(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(main)-250(issue.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(9.)-554(One)-352(more)-351(reference)-352(must)-351(be)-352(added:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 180.104 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Jesus)-351(Christ,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 56.263 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.678 0 Td [(says)]TJ -261.845 -13.549 Td [(the)-362(Apostle,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 58.194 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(was)-362(made)-361(a)-362(minister)-362(of)-362(the)-361(circumcision)-362(for)-362(the)]TJ -63.038 -13.549 Td [(truth)-405(of)-405(God,)-444(to)-405(confirm)-405(the)-405(promises)-405(made)-405(unto)-405(the)-404(fathers;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-392(that)-392(the)-392(Gentiles)-393(might)-392(glorify)-392(God)-392(for)-392(His)-392(mercy.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 252.112 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.122 0 Td [(This)]TJ -261.234 -13.549 Td [(passage)-298(not)-299(only)-298(proves)-299(that)-298(the)-298(Apostle)-299(and)-298(those)-299(to)-298(whom)-298(he)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(wrote)-351(were)-351(in)-350(possession)-351(of)-351(an)-350(account)-351(of)-351(the)-351(circumcision)-350(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ,)-331(but)-314(also)-315(that)-314(they)-315(well)-314(knew)-315(that)-314(His)-314(ministry)-315(had)-314(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(confined)-425(to)-424(the)-425(Jewish)-425(people,)-468(but)-425(with)-424(the)-425(ultimate)-424(purpose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-345(His)-346(being)-345(manifested)-346(to)-345(the)-345(Gentiles.)-536(In)-346(these)-345(particulars)-345(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exactly)-250(corresponded)-250(with)-250(the)-250(account)-250(given)-250(in)-250(our)-250(Gospels.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(10.)-817(There)-439(are)-439(also)-439(several)-439(passages)-439(in)-439(which)-439(the)-439(Apostl)1(e)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(directly)-243(refers)-243(to)-243(our)-243(Lord's)-242(teaching,)-245(and)-243(clearly)-243(distinguishes)-242(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-251(his)-251(own.)-252(These)-251(references)-250(uniformly)-251(agree)-251(with)-251(that)-250(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-260(attributed)-260(to)-261(Jesus)-260(in)-260(the)-260(Synoptic)-260(Gospels,)-263(and)-260(prove)-260(that)-260(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Apostle)-250(and)-250(the)-250(Church)-250(were)-250(in)-250(possession)-250(of)-250(details)-250(of)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(Such)-426(are)-427(the)-426(direct)-427(references)-426(to)-426(the)-427(life)-426(of)-427(Jesus)-426(in)-426(these)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Epistles.)-242(But)-224(there)-225(are)-225(numerous)-224(indirect)-225(references)-225(which)-224(prove)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-374(the)-374(Apostle)-375(and)-374(those)-374(to)-374(whom)-375(he)-374(wrote)-374(must)-374(have)-374(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(acquainted)-297(with)-296(accounts)-297(of)-297(the)-296(life)-297(of)-297(its)-296(Founder,)-309(which)-296(went)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-250(a)-250(considerable)-250(degree)-250(of)-250(detail.)-250(I)-250(shall)-250(give)-250(a)-250(few)-250(instances:)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(1.)-637(His)-379(preaching)-379(of)-379(the)-379(Gospel)-379(to)-379(the)-379(Thessalonians)-379(is)-379(de-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(scribed)-303(as)-304(a)-303(proclamation)-303(that)-304(Jesus)-303(was)-303(the)-304(Christ)-303(or)-303(Messiah.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1748 0 obj <<
/Length 5830      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(378)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(In)-219(one)-218(of)-219(the)-218(Epistles)-219(to)-219(this)-437(Church)-218(he)-219(speaks)-219(of)-218(them)-219(as)-218(having)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([431])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(been)-195(so)-196(powerfully)-195(influenced)-195(that)-195(in)-195(consequence)-196(of)-195(it)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 239.118 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(they)-195(had)]TJ -243.962 -13.549 Td [(turned)-294(to)-295(God)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 64.78 0 Td [(from)-294(idols)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 48.248 0 Td [(to)-294(serve)-295(the)-294(living)-294(and)-295(true)-294(God,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 143.794 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.055 0 Td [(and)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf -264.877 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(as)-348(having)-347(become)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 84.083 0 Td [(followers)-348(of)-347(him)-348(and)-347(of)-348(the)-347(Lord)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 147.614 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.635 0 Td [(Among)]TJ -247.903 -13.55 Td [(persons)-287(thus)-286(utterly)-287(ignorant)-286(of)-287(Christianity,)-296(as)-286(they)-287(were)-286(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-220(first)-219(preached)-220(to)-220(them,)-225(it)-220(would)-220(have)-219(been)-220(impossible)-220(to)-219(make)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-189(announcement)-189(of)-188(this)-189(kind,)-201(or)-189(to)-188(set)-189(forth)-189(the)-189(Messianic)-188(claims)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-280(Jesus,)-288(without)-280(laying)-280(before)-280(them)-281(a)-280(great)-280(many)-280(of)-280(the)-280(details)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-258(His)-258(human)-258(life.)-274(The)-258(expression)-258(above)-258(quoted,)-260(implies)-257(clearly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-283(he)-283(had)-283(put)-283(his)-282(converts)-283(in)-283(possession)-283(of)-283(such)-283(an)-283(account)-282(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-292(life)-292(of)-293(Christ)-292(as)-292(to)-292(enable)-292(them)-293(to)-292(become)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 205.789 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(followers)-292(of)-292(the)]TJ -210.633 -13.549 Td [(Lord.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 23.935 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -11.979 -16.004 Td [(2.)-543(These)-348(Epistles)-348(contain)-348(many)-347(definite)-348(assertions)-348(as)-348(to)-347(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(duty)-276(of)-276(imitating)-275(Christ.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 109.885 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Put)-276(ye)-276(on)-275(the)-276(Lord)-276(Jesus)-276(Christ;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 141.085 0 Td [(\035)-276(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.696 0 Td [(As)]TJ -268.51 -13.549 Td [(many)-218(as)-217(have)-218(been)-218(baptized)-217(into)-218(Christ)-218(have)-217(put)-218(on)-218(Christ;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 254.026 0 Td [(\035)-218(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.062 0 Td [(Let)]TJ -266.088 -13.55 Td [(every)-286(one)-286(of)-286(us)-286(please)-286(his)-286(brother)-286(for)-286(his)-286(good)-286(unto)-285(edification,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-345(even)-345(so)-345(Christ)-346(pleased)-345(not)-345(himself;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 174.697 0 Td [(\035)-345(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.452 0 Td [(The)-345(God)-345(of)-345(patience)]TJ -188.149 -13.549 Td [(and)-242(consolation)-243(grant)-242(you)-242(to)-242(be)-242(like)-243(minded)-242(one)-242(toward)-242(another,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(according)-464(to)-463(Christ)-464(Jesus;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 119.413 0 Td [(\035)-464(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.747 0 Td [(I)-463(beseech)-464(you)-464(by)-464(the)-463(meekness)]TJ -134.16 -13.549 Td [(and)-278(gentleness)-279(of)-278(Christ;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 109.105 0 Td [(\035)-278(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.725 0 Td [(Ye)-278(have)-279(not)-278(so)-279(learned)-278(Christ;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 133.955 0 Td [(\035)-278(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.725 0 Td [(Be)]TJ -268.51 -13.55 Td [(ye)-465(followers)-466(of)-465(me,)-519(as)-466(I)-465(am)-465(of)-465(Christ.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 182.382 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.921 0 Td [(Many)-465(other)-466(similar)]TJ -192.303 -13.549 Td [(expressions)-250(might)-250(be)-250(cited,)-250(but)-250(these)-250(are)-250(sufficient.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(First:)-628(I)-438(observe)-439(that)-439(the)-439(exhortation)-438(to)-439(put)-439(on)-439(the)-439(charac-)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(ter)-419(of)-419(another)-418(is)-419(meaningless,)-461(unless)-419(the)-419(persons)-419(so)-418(exhorted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-384(known)-383(to)-383(have)-384(been)-383(thoroughly)-384(acquainted)-383(with)-384(the)-383(life)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-340(actions)-340(of)-341(him)-340(whom)-340(they)-340(are)-340(urged)-341(to)-340(imitate.)-520(The)-340(same)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(observation)-390(is)-390(true)-390(when)-390(we)-390(are)-390(deliberately)-390(recommended)-389(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(make)-268(another)-268(person)-268(our)-268(example.)-303(Again,)-273(the)-268(exhortation)-268(to)-267(lay)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ourselves)-329(out)-329(in)-329(efforts)-328(to)-329(please)-329(others)-329(for)-329(their)-329(good)-329(to)-328(edifi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cation,)-317(on)-303(the)-303(ground)-303(that)-304(Christ)-303(pleased)-303(not)-304(himself,)-316(would)-303(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-242(meaning,)-244(unless)-242(the)-242(writer)-484(felt)-241(assured)-242(that)-242(those)-242(whom)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([432])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(he)-387(addressed)-387(were)-387(in)-387(possession)-387(of)-387(facts)-387(in)-387(the)-387(life)-387(of)-386(Christ,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-311(exhibited)-310(Him)-310(in)-311(the)-310(character)-311(of)-310(a)-311(sacrificer)-310(of)-311(self.)-431(So)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(again,)-375(the)-350(exhortation)-351(to)-350(patience,)-375(after)-350(the)-350(example)-350(of)-350(Christ,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1753 0 obj <<
/Length 4612      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(379)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(is)-300(founded)-301(on)-300(the)-300(assumption)-301(that)-300(those)-300(whom)-301(the)-300(Apostle)-300(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(addressing)-279(were)-278(acquainted)-279(with)-278(details)-279(which)-278(exhibited)-279(him)-278(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-370(model)-371(of)-370(patience.)-611(The)-370(same)-370(remark)-370(is)-371(true)-370(with)-370(respect)-370(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-346(entreaty)-347(addressed)-346(to)-347(the)-346(Corinthians)-346(by)-347(the)-346(meekness)-346(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(gentleness)-311(of)-311(Christ.)-434(They)-311(must)-312(have)-311(been)-311(acquainted)-311(with)-311(ac-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tions)-231(of)-231(His)-231(which)-231(exhibited)-231(Him)-231(as)-231(supremely)-231(meek)-231(and)-231(gentle.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(These)-341(and)-342(other)-341(indirect)-342(references)-341(form)-342(an)-341(indisputable)-341(proof)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-387(the)-387(churches)-387(to)-387(whom)-388(St.)-661(Paul)-387(wrote)-387(must)-387(have)-387(been)-387(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possession)-206(of)-207(a)-206(very)-206(considerable)-206(number)-206(of)-207(details)-206(of)-206(the)-206(human)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(life)-369(of)-369(Jesus,)-399(in)-369(which)-369(a)-369(large)-369(portion)-369(of)-369(the)-369(inst)1(ruction)-369(given)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-327(those)-327(Churches)-326(consisted.)-481(This)-327(imparts)-326(to)-327(them)-327(a)-327(far)-326(higher)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(value)-383(than)-383(if)-383(they)-383(had)-383(been)-383(direct.)-649(It)-383(is)-383(the)-383(mode)-382(universally)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(adopted)-277(in)-277(genuine)-277(letters,)-284(where)-277(the)-277(writer,)-284(and)-277(those)-277(to)-277(whom)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-341(writes,)-363(are)-341(freely)-341(communicating)-341(to)-341(each)-341(other)-341(their)-340(inmost)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(thoughts.)-494(When)-332(one)-331(party)-332(is)-331(firmly)-332(persuaded)-331(that)-332(the)-331(other)-331(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(well)-378(acquainted)-378(with)-378(a)-379(certain)-378(set)-378(of)-378(events,)-410(they)-378(never)-378(detail)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-415(formally,)-457(but)-416(simply)-415(refer)-416(to)-415(them)-416(in)-415(passing)-415(allusions.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Such)-223(allusions)-223(are)-223(the)-222(strongest)-223(possible)-223(evidence)-223(that)-223(the)-222(events)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-309(question)-308(are)-309(the)-309(common)-308(property)-309(of)-309(the)-308(writer)-309(and)-309(of)-308(those)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(whom)-250(he)-250(is)-250(addressing.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(The)-440(whole)-441(of)-440(these)-441(Epistles)-440(contain)-441(a)-440(continuous)-441(body)-440(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(references)-244(to)-244(the)-244(various)-244(aspects)-244(of)-244(our)-244(Lord's)-244(divine)-244(and)-243(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-272(as)-272(it)-272(is)-272(depicted)-273(in)-272(the)-272(four)-272(Gospels.)-316(The)-272(references)-272(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-267(former)-267(are)-266(very)-267(numerous.)-301(They)-266(contain)-267(a)-267(Christianity)-267(of)-266(so)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(advanced)-294(a)-294(character)-294(as)-293(to)-294(resemble)-294(in)-294(all)-294(its)-294(great)-294(features)-293(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-284(we)-283(read)-284(of)-283(in)-284(St.)-351(John's)-283(Gospel,)-584(and)-284(which)-283(are)-284(only)-283(dis-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([433])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(tinguishable)-216(from)-216(it,)-223(if)-216(distinguishable)-217(at)-216(all,)-223(by)-216(the)-216(aid)-216(of)-216(minute)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(criticism.)-290(I)-263(have)-263(treated)-264(this)-263(subject)-263(at)-263(length)-264(in)-263(another)-263(work)-263(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reference)-225(to)-226(its)-225(evidential)-225(value,)-231(and)-225(therefore)-225(need)-226(not)-225(discuss)-225(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(here.)-384(I)-295(shall)-295(only)-294(observe)-295(that)-295(the)-294(incidental)-295(references)-295(in)-294(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Epistles)-217(to)-216(these)-217(subjects)-216(form)-217(the)-216(strongest)-216(historical)-217(proofs)-216(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(St.)-578(Paul)-360(and)-359(those)-360(to)-359(whom)-360(he)-359(wrote)-360(were)-359(in)-360(possession)-359(of)-359(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sufficient)-317(number)-318(of)-317(facts)-318(respecting)-317(the)-318(life)-317(of)-318(Jesus)-317(to)-317(enable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-409(to)-409(found)-409(on)-409(them)-409(a)-410(definite)-409(Christology;)-488(and)-409(that)-409(there)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1757 0 obj <<
/Length 4903      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(380)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(must)-362(have)-362(been)-361(well)-362(known)-362(in)-361(the)-362(Churches)-362(a)-362(general)-361(outline)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-354(His)-354(human)-355(life,)-380(which)-354(must)-354(have)-355(been)-354(to)-354(their)-354(members)-354(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recent)-443(converts)-442(a)-443(subject)-442(of)-443(the)-443(profoundest)-442(interest.)-828(I)-442(fully)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(admit)-280(that)-281(if)-280(Paul)-280(and)-280(the)-281(early)-280(Christians,)-288(while)-280(centering)-280(their)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(highest)-281(affections)-280(on)-281(the)-281(glorified)-280(Christ,)-289(had)-280(been)-281(contented)-280(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remain)-394(in)-394(ignorance)-394(of)-393(the)-394(facts)-394(of)-394(His)-394(human)-394(life,)-430(the)-393(value)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-367(their)-367(testimony)-367(to)-368(the)-367(truth)-367(of)-367(the)-367(Resurrection)-367(would)-367(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-341(greatly)-342(weakened.)-524(But)-341(the)-341(supposition)-342(is)-341(not)-341(only)-341(untrue)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-273(human)-272(nature,)-279(but)-273(is)-272(contradicted)-273(by)-273(the)-272(facts)-273(of)-273(the)-272(Epistles,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-298(it)-298(is)-298(impossible)-299(not)-298(to)-298(admit)-298(as)-298(documents)-298(of)-298(the)-298(highest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-250(value.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(I)-230(will)-230(now)-230(proceed)-230(to)-230(examine)-230(the)-230(evidence)-230(which)-230(these)-230(Epis-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tles)-248(afford)-248(to)-248(the)-248(truth)-248(of)-248(the)-248(Resurrection.)-249(The)-248(references)-248(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-340(contain)-340(to)-341(this)-340(great)-340(miracle)-340(of)-340(Christianity)-340(are)-340(extremely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(numerous,)-223(occurring)-217(in)-217(some)-216(form)-217(or)-217(other)-216(in)-217(almost)-217(every)-216(page.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Shall)-315(I)-316(not)-315(say)-315(that)-315(their)-316(entire)-315(contents)-315(are)-316(written)-315(on)-315(the)-315(sup-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(position)-297(of)-296(its)-297(reality?)-390(They)-297(are)-297(of)-296(the)-297(most)-297(direct)-296(as)-297(well)-297(as)-296(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-290(most)-290(incidental)-290(character.)-370(They)-290(make)-290(it)-290(clear)-290(that)-290(the)-290(belief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-289(it)-290(lay)-289(at)-290(the)-289(foundation)-290(of)-289(the)-290(existence)-289(of)-289(the)-290(Church;)-309(that)-289(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-334(that)-334(which)-334(was)-334(supposed)-334(to)-334(communicate)-334(its)-334(moral)-333(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-369(Christianity,)-399(and)-368(that)-369(it)-369(was)-369(the)-369(source)-369(of)-369(the)-369(new)-368(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(life)-348(of)-347(every)-348(individual)-348(believer.)-543(In)-348(the)-347(following)-348(passage)-695(St.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([434])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(Paul)-414(distinctly)-414(pledges)-414(the)-413(truth)-414(of)-414(Christianity)-414(on)-414(the)-413(reality)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-370(the)-370(fact:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 55.22 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(And)-370(if)-370(Christ)-370(be)-370(not)-370(risen,)-400(then)-370(is)-370(our)-370(preaching)]TJ -60.064 -13.549 Td [(vain,)-411(and)-379(your)-379(faith)-378(is)-379(also)-379(vain;)-443(yea,)-411(and)-379(we)-379(are)-379(found)-378(false)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(witnesses)-201(of)-202(God;)-217(because)-201(we)-202(have)-201(testified)-201(of)-202(God)-201(that)-201(he)-201(raised)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(up)-260(Christ,)-262(whom)-260(he)-260(raised)-260(not)-260(up,)-262(if)-260(so)-260(be)-260(that)-260(the)-260(dead)-260(rise)-259(not,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(...)-540(and)-346(if)-347(Christ)-346(be)-347(not)-346(raised,)-371(your)-346(faith)-347(is)-346(vain;)-395(ye)-346(are)-347(yet)-346(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(your)-332(sins.)-495(Then)-332(they)-331(also)-332(which)-332(are)-332(fallen)-331(asleep)-332(in)-332(Christ)-331(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(perished.)-475(If)-325(in)-326(this)-325(life)-325(only)-325(we)-325(have)-325(hope)-325(in)-325(Christ,)-344(we)-325(are)-325(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-262(men)-263(most)-262(miserable.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 104.64 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.706 0 Td [(\0501)-262(Cor.)-287(xv.)-287(14,)-266(etc.\051)-287(Whatever)-262(opinion)]TJ -112.346 -13.549 Td [(may)-384(be)-385(formed)-384(as)-385(to)-384(the)-384(genuineness)-385(of)-384(the)-385(other)-384(writings)-384(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-293(New)-292(Testament,)-303(they)-293(give)-292(one)-293(consistent)-292(testimony)-293(that)-292(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belief)-442(in)-442(the)-441(Resurrection)-442(was)-442(co-extensive)-442(with)-442(the)-441(Church,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1761 0 obj <<
/Length 4499      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(381)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(and)-341(constituted)-340(the)-341(only)-341(ground)-340(of)-341(its)-340(existence.)-522(How)-341(could)-340(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-383(otherwise?)-651(The)-383(Church,)-417(as)-383(a)-384(community,)-417(was)-383(founded)-383(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-256(belief)-256(of)-256(the)-255(personal)-256(Messiahship)-256(of)-256(Christ;)-259(a)-256(dead)-255(Messiah)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-200(have)-200(been)-199(utterly)-200(worthless)-200(to)-200(it.)-233(Without)-200(a)-200(living)-199(Messiah)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-250(form)-250(its)-250(centre)-250(the)-250(whole)-250(superstructure)-250(must)-250(collapse.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(The)-342(following)-341(are)-342(some)-341(of)-342(the)-342(most)-341(important)-342(points)-341(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(these)-239(letters)-238(prove)-239(as)-238(matters)-239(of)-239(fact)-238(respecting)-239(the)-238(Resurrection.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(First:)-516(That)-383(the)-384(belief)-383(in)-383(it)-383(was)-383(co-extensive)-383(with)-383(the)-383(entire)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Church.)-333(It)-278(was)-277(not)-278(the)-278(belief)-277(of)-278(any)-278(single)-277(party)-278(in)-278(it,)-284(but)-278(of)-277(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whole)-250(community.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(This)-371(they)-372(establish)-371(on)-371(the)-372(most)-371(indisputable)-371(evidence.)-614(The)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(existence)-371(of)-371(various)-371(parties)-371(in)-371(the)-371(Church)-371(in)-371(direct)-370(opposition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-285(St.)-355(Paul)-284(proves)-285(beyond)-285(the)-285(possibility)-285(of)-285(contradiction)-285(that)-284(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-334(the)-334(one)-334(belief)-334(respecting)-334(which)-334(there)-334(was)-334(not)-334(the)-334(smallest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(diversity)-187(of)-188(opinion.)-229(If)-187(these)-188(parties)-187(had)-187(not)-188(existed,)-200(it)-187(might)-187(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-334(urged)-334(with)-334(some)-333(degree)-334(of)-334(plausibility)-334(that)-334(the)-333(testimony)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-242(these)-243(letters)-242(was)-242(inconclusive,)-244(because)-242(all)-243(the)-242(members)-242(of)-242(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Churches)-284(received)-283(servilely)-284(whatever)-283(St.)-350(Paul)-284(chose)-567(to)-283(dictate.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([435])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(But)-225(as)-225(we)-224(have)-225(already)-225(seen,)-230(a)-225(powerful)-224(party)-225(existed)-225(in)-225(both)-224(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Corinthian)-320(and)-319(Galatian)-320(Churches,)-337(who)-320(summarily)-320(rejected)-319(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(claim)-213(to)-212(apostolic)-213(authority,)-220(maintaining)-213(that)-212(the)-213(twelve)-213(were)-212(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-305(genuine)-305(Apostles.)-414(Nevertheless,)-318(the)-305(Epistles)-305(make)-305(it)-304(clear)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-206(they)-206(must)-206(have)-206(believed)-206(in)-206(the)-206(Resurrection)-206(quite)-206(as)-206(strongly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-250(St.)-250(Paul)-250(did)-250(himself.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(Let)-313(us)-313(suppose)-312(for)-313(a)-313(moment)-313(that)-313(they)-313(doubted)-312(it.)-439(How)-313(is)-313(it)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(conceivable)-362(that)-361(St.)-585(Paul)-362(should)-361(have)-362(addressed)-361(to)-362(them)-361(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(letters)-342(as)-341(those)-342(to)-341(the)-342(Corinthians,)-364(abounding)-342(everywhere)-341(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(both)-427(direct)-426(and)-427(incidental)-426(allusions)-426(to)-427(it)-426(as)-427(an)-426(acknowledged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth)-283(and)-283(as)-283(the)-283(foundation)-282(of)-283(his)-283(reasonings?)-349(Would)-283(anyone)-282(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-328(senses)-327(have)-328(thus)-327(exposed)-328(himself)-328(to)-327(instant)-328(denunciation)-327(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-273(had)-273(supposed)-272(that)-273(there)-273(was)-273(the)-272(smallest)-273(doubt)-273(respecting)-272(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reality)-248(in)-248(the)-248(minds)-248(of)-247(his)-248(opponents?)-250(Would)-248(they)-247(not)-248(at)-248(once,)-248(if)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-308(had)-307(entertained)-308(it,)-321(have)-308(made)-307(short)-308(work)-307(with)-308(the)-307(Apostle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(his)-251(reasonings?)-251(But)-250(the)-250(point)-251(is)-250(almost)-250(too)-251(clear)-250(to)-250(need)-250(any)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1766 0 obj <<
/Length 5099      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(382)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(argument.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(In)-325(one)-325(of)-325(the)-326(passages)-325(where)-325(he)-325(is)-325(discussing)-325(with)-325(them)-325(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(reality)-268(of)-268(his)-268(apostleship)-269(he)-268(urges)-268(as)-268(the)-268(foundation)-268(of)-268(his)-268(claim)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-392(this)-391(office:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 67.09 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Have)-392(not)-391(I)-392(seen)-392(Jesus)-391(Christ)-392(our)-392(Lord?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 180.184 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.117 0 Td [(This)]TJ -261.234 -13.549 Td [(reasoning)-402(is)-401(evidently)-402(founded)-401(on)-402(the)-402(supposition)-401(that)-402(all)-401(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-272(Apostles)-272(professed)-271(to)-272(have)-272(seen)-272(Him;)-282(and)-272(that)-272(none)-271(could)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-258(a)-258(valid)-257(claim)-258(to)-258(the)-258(office)-257(who)-258(had)-258(not)-258(seen)-257(Him.)-274(But)-257(Paul)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(could)-258(only)-258(have)-257(seen)-258(Christ)-258(after)-258(the)-257(Resurrection;)-262(and)-258(it)-258(was)-257(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(virtue)-273(of)-273(an)-274(appointment)-273(from)-273(the)-273(risen)-274(Jesus)-273(that)-273(he)-273(claimed)-273(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hold)-243(the)-243(office.)-248(If)-243(there)-243(had)-244(been)-243(the)-243(smallest)-243(doubt)-243(in)-243(the)-243(minds)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-303(his)-302(opponents)-303(as)-302(to)-303(the)-303(reality)-302(of)-303(the)-302(Resurrection,)-316(or)-303(if)-302(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(had)-259(not)-258(been)-259(persuaded)-259(that)-259(the)-258(Apostles,)-261(whose)-259(claims)-259(they)-258(set)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(up)-357(against)-358(those)-357(of)-357(St.)-572(Paul,)-384(affirmed)-357(that)-358(they)-357(had)-357(seen)-357(Him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(also,)-214(this)-204(would)-204(at)-205(once)-204(have)-205(sett)1(led)-205(the)-204(controversy)-409(and)-204(covered)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([436])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(Apostle)-250(with)-250(confusion)-250(before)-250(the)-250(assembled)-250(Church.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-214(if)-214(this)-215(reasoning)-214(requires)-214(any)-215(additional)-214(confirmation,)-221(it)-214(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(afforded)-291(by)-291(the)-291(Epistle)-291(to)-291(the)-291(Galatians.)-373(The)-291(opposition)-290(leaders)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-355(this)-356(Church)-355(were)-356(yet)-355(more)-355(hostile)-356(to)-355(St.)-566(Paul)-356(than)-355(those)-355(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Corinth.)-771(His)-423(denunciation)-424(of)-423(them)-424(is)-424(very)-423(severe.)-771(They)-423(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(described)-324(as)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 57.963 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(false)-324(apostles,)-343(deceitful)-324(workers,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 145.319 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.379 0 Td [(and)-324(subverters)]TJ -216.505 -13.549 Td [(of)-316(the)-316(Gospel.)-447(Yet)-316(in)-316(the)-316(very)-316(opening)-316(words)-316(of)-316(his)-316(address)-315(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-312(Church)-312(in)-313(which)-312(he)-312(thus)-312(sharply)-312(denounces)-312(his)-312(opponents,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-330(Apostle)-331(writes:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 88.652 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Paul,)-350(an)-331(Apostle,)-350(not)-331(of)-330(man)-330(nor)-331(by)-330(man,)]TJ -93.496 -13.549 Td [(but)-243(by)-243(Jesus)-244(Christ,)-244(and)-243(God)-243(the)-244(Father)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 174.259 0 Td [(who)-243(raised)-243(him)-244(from)-243(the)]TJ -174.259 -13.55 Td [(dead)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 21.208 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.856 0 Td [(Is)-184(it)-185(conceivable,)-197(I)-185(ask,)-197(that)-185(St.)-228(Paul)-185(should)-184(have)-184(used)-185(such)]TJ -30.791 -13.549 Td [(language,)-316(under)-303(such)-302(circumstances,)-316(in)-303(addressing)-303(this)-302(Church,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unless)-266(he)-266(was)-267(absolutely)-266(certain)-266(that)-266(his)-266(opponents)-266(accepted)-266(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Resurrection)-221(of)-222(Christ)-221(as)-222(a)-221(fact?)-240(We)-222(shall)-221(see)-222(hereafter)-221(that)-221(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assertions)-356(and)-356(allusions)-356(of)-356(the)-356(Apostle)-356(not)-356(only)-356(prove)-356(that)-355(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Resurrection)-346(was)-347(believed)-346(in)-347(by)-346(every)-346(section)-347(of)-346(the)-346(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(community)-448(at)-449(the)-448(time)-448(when)-448(he)-449(wrote)-448(these)-448(letters,)-498(but)-448(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-419(enable)-420(us)-419(to)-419(carry)-420(up)-419(the)-419(date)-420(of)-419(this)-419(belief)-420(to)-419(the)-419(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(commencement)-250(of)-250(Christianity.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Secondly:)-344(The)-298(Epistle)-297(to)-297(the)-297(Romans)-298(sets)-297(before)-297(us)-297(the)-297(state)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1770 0 obj <<
/Length 4795      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(383)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(of)-281(this)-282(belief)-281(in)-281(a)-281(Church)-282(which)-281(St.)-344(Paul)-281(had)-281(not)-281(visited.)-344(Of)-281(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exact)-314(date)-314(of)-314(the)-313(foundation)-314(of)-314(this)-314(Church)-314(we)-314(have)-314(no)-313(record;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-362(the)-361(entire)-362(contents)-361(of)-362(the)-361(Epistle)-362(prove)-361(that)-362(it)-361(had)-362(been)-361(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence)-322(for)-322(many)-322(years)-322(before)-322(the)-322(Apostle)-322(addressed)-322(to)-321(them)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-392(letter.)-674(The)-392(general)-391(impression)-392(produced)-391(by)-392(it)-391(is)-392(that)-391(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-389(one)-389(of)-390(the)-389(most)-389(important)-389(Christian)-389(communities)-389(then)-389(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence.)-233(We)-201(learn)-200(from)-200(it)-200(that)-201(among)-200(its)-200(members)-200(were)-200(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attached)-327(to)-326(the)-327(household)-326(of)-327(Nero.)-479(As)-326(the)-327(intercourse)-326(between)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Rome)-285(and)-286(Jud\346a)-285(was)-285(very)-285(considerable,)-294(there)-286(can)-285(be)-570(no)-285(doubt)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([437])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(that)-259(the)-258(Church)-259(originated)-259(at)-259(an)-258(early)-259(period,)-261(either)-259(by)-258(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jews)-230(visiting)-231(the)-230(imperial)-230(city,)-235(or)-230(by)-230(Roman)-231(Jews)-230(visiting)-230(Jud\346a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-316(having)-316(thus)-316(become)-317(converted.)-448(At)-316(any)-316(rate)-316(its)-316(Christianity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-215(have)-214(been)-215(derived)-215(from)-214(a)-215(source)-215(entirely)-214(independent)-215(of)-214(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Paul.)-286(The)-263(evidence)-262(afforded)-262(by)-262(this)-262(Epistle)-262(as)-262(to)-262(the)-262(importance)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-347(universal)-347(prevalence)-347(of)-347(the)-347(belief)-347(in)-347(the)-347(Resurrection,)-371(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-400(its)-400(early)-400(origin)-400(is)-399(conclusive.)-700(The)-400(allusions)-400(to)-400(it)-400(are)-399(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(numerous)-281(than)-281(in)-280(any)-281(other)-281(of)-281(St.)-342(Paul's)-281(Epistles.)-342(Most)-281(of)-280(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-341(of)-342(an)-341(entirely)-341(incidental)-341(character,)-365(and)-341(their)-341(general)-341(nature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proves)-402(beyond)-401(the)-402(possibility)-401(of)-402(question)-402(that)-401(both)-402(the)-401(writer)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-348(those)-348(to)-347(whom)-348(he)-348(wrote)-348(must)-348(have)-347(viewed)-348(the)-348(fact)-348(as)-347(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fundamental)-254(groundwork)-253(of)-254(Christianity.)-261(The)-254(reference)-253(to)-254(a)-253(few)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(passages)-250(will)-250(render)-250(this)-250(point)-250(indubitable.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(An)-459(allusion)-459(of)-459(a)-460(most)-459(incidental)-459(character)-459(as)-459(forming)-459(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ground)-419(of)-419(the)-419(writer's)-419(apostleship)-419(occurs)-419(in)-419(the)-419(very)-418(opening)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(words)-310(of)-311(the)-310(Epistle:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 96.615 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(And)-310(declared)-311(to)-310(be)-310(the)-310(Son)-311(of)-310(God)-310(with)]TJ -101.458 -13.55 Td [(power,)-393(according)-365(to)-364(the)-365(Spirit)-365(of)-364(holiness,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 195.112 0 Td [(by)-365(the)-364(resurrection)]TJ -195.112 -13.549 Td [(from)-208(the)-207(dead)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 59.97 0 Td [(;)-222(by)-207(whom)-208(we)-208(have)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 86.011 0 Td [(received)-208(grace)-207(and)-208(apostleship)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -145.981 -13.549 Td [(for)-299(obedience)-299(to)-299(the)-300(faith)-299(among)-299(all)-299(nations)-299(for)-299(his)-299(name.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 255.319 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.106 0 Td [(It)-299(is)]TJ -263.425 -13.549 Td [(inconceivable)-236(that)-235(St.)-246(Paul)-235(should)-236(have)-236(thus)-235(addressed)-236(a)-236(body)-235(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(strangers,)-264(at)-261(the)-262(very)-261(commencement)-261(of)-262(his)-261(letter,)-264(unless)-261(he)-261(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-316(certain)-315(that)-316(they)-316(accepted)-316(this)-315(belief)-316(as)-316(an)-315(unquestionable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fact.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Besides)-284(several)-284(references)-284(in)-285(the)-284(intermediate)-284(chapters,)-292(there)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(are)-232(three)-232(allusions)-232(to)-232(it)-231(in)-232(the)-232(sixth)-232(chapter)-232(of)-232(the)-232(most)-231(incidental)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1774 0 obj <<
/Length 4853      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(384)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(character,)-248(in)-248(which)-248(the)-248(belief)-248(in)-248(the)-248(Resurrection)-248(is)-248(directly)-248(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nected)-215(with)-214(baptism,)-222(and)-214(affirmed)-215(to)-215(lie)-214(at)-215(the)-214(very)-215(foundation)-214(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity,)-230(and)-225(to)-225(be)-225(the)-225(divine)-225(power)-225(exhibited)-225(in)-225(the)-225(renewed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-243(life.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 62.629 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Know)-243(ye)-243(not)-244(that)-243(as)-243(many)-243(of)-244(us)-243(as)-243(were)-243(baptized)]TJ -67.473 -13.55 Td [(into)-339(Jesus)-339(Christ,)-361(were)-339(baptized)-339(into)-678(his)-339(death?)-517(Therefore)-339(we)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([438])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(are)-379(buried)-378(with)-379(him)-379(by)-378(baptism)-379(into)-379(death,)-410(that)-379(like)-379(as)-378(Christ)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-384(raised)-385(up)-384(from)-385(the)-384(dead)-384(by)-385(the)-384(glory)-385(of)-384(the)-384(Father,)-418(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-379(also)-380(should)-379(walk)-380(in)-379(newness)-380(of)-379(life.)-639(For)-379(if)-380(we)-379(have)-379(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(planted)-289(together)-289(in)-289(the)-289(likeness)-289(of)-289(his)-289(death,)-299(we)-289(shall)-289(be)-288(also)-289(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-312(likeness)-312(of)-312(his)-312(resurrection:)-375(knowing)-312(this,)-327(that)-312(our)-312(old)-312(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-342(crucified)-341(with)-342(him,)-365(that)-341(the)-342(body)-342(of)-341(sin)-342(might)-342(be)-341(destroyed,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-340(henceforth)-339(we)-340(should)-340(not)-339(serve)-340(sin.)-519(For)-340(he)-339(that)-340(is)-340(dead)-339(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(freed)-325(from)-324(sin.)-474(Now)-325(if)-324(we)-325(be)-325(dead)-324(with)-325(Christ,)-343(we)-325(believe)-324(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(shall)-306(also)-306(live)-305(with)-306(him:)-362(knowing)-305(that)-306(Christ)-306(being)-306(raised)-305(from)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-265(dead)-265(dieth)-265(no)-265(more;)-272(death)-265(hath)-265(no)-265(more)-265(dominion)-265(over)-264(him.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(For)-262(in)-261(that)-262(He)-261(died,)-265(He)-261(died)-262(unto)-261(sin)-262(once;)-267(but)-262(in)-261(that)-262(He)-261(liveth,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-341(liveth)-341(unto)-340(God.)-523(Likewise)-341(reckon)-340(ye)-341(also)-341(yourselves)-341(to)-340(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dead)-356(indeed)-356(unto)-356(sin,)-383(but)-355(alive)-356(unto)-356(God)-356(through)-356(Jesus)-356(Christ)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-250(Lord.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 41.204 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -29.248 -18.459 Td [(It)-310(is)-309(impossible)-310(to)-310(read)-309(this)-310(passage)-310(without)-309(feeling)-310(that)-310(it)-309(is)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(conclusive)-353(of)-354(the)-353(question)-353(before)-353(us:)-457(the)-353(whole)-353(community)-353(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whom)-297(it)-297(was)-298(addressed)-297(must)-297(have)-297(accepted)-297(the)-297(Resurrection)-297(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-347(fact,)-372(and)-347(that)-347(acceptance)-347(must)-347(have)-347(been)-347(contemporary)-347(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-326(very)-326(commencement)-327(of)-326(their)-326(Christianity.)-479(A)-326(portion)-326(of)-326(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(baptismal)-373(rite)-372(to)-373(which)-373(they)-372(had)-373(all)-373(submitted)-372(was)-373(viewed)-372(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-276(as)-277(symbolical)-276(of)-277(their)-276(Master's)-277(death:)-303(the)-276(other)-276(portion,)-283(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-381(Resurrection.)-641(His)-381(death)-381(and)-380(resurrection)-381(were)-380(considered)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-409(them)-409(as)-408(setting)-409(forth)-409(their)-408(cessation)-409(from)-409(their)-409(old)-408(habits,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(principles)-438(and)-438(character,)-484(in)-438(which)-438(they)-437(had)-438(lived)-438(as)-438(Jews)-437(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Pagans;)-402(and)-351(their)-351(entrance)-351(into)-351(that)-351(new)-351(moral)-351(life)-351(into)-351(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-276(were)-275(brought)-276(by)-275(Christianity.)-327(The)-275(Apostle)-276(directly)-275(appeals)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-189(the)-189(recollection)-189(of)-188(those)-189(whom)-189(he)-189(is)-189(addressing,)-201(to)-189(say)-188(whether)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-209(was)-210(not)-209(a)-209(certain)-210(fact)-209(that)-209(their)-209(entire)-210(Christianity,)-217(including)-209(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-314(moral)-314(influence,)-330(centered)-314(in)-314(this)-314(truth.)-442(His)-314(words)-628(therefore)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([439])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1779 0 obj <<
/Length 4981      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(385)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(carry)-334(this)-333(belief)-334(up)-334(to)-333(the)-334(first)-334(origin)-333(of)-334(this)-334(Church.)-501(They)-333(go,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(moreover,)-246(a)-245(step)-245(further,)-246(and)-245(involve)-245(the)-245(belief)-245(and)-245(testimony)-244(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-250(by)-250(whom)-250(its)-250(first)-250(members)-250(had)-250(been)-250(converted.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-363(further:)-477(the)-363(Apostle,)-391(throughout)-364(this)-363(chapter,)-391(speaks)-363(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-278(Resurrection)-279(of)-278(Christ)-278(as)-279(being)-278(the)-278(great)-279(moral)-278(and)-278(spiritual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(power)-301(of)-301(Christianity.)-404(The)-301(members)-301(of)-301(the)-301(Church)-301(had)-301(entered)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-264(a)-265(new)-264(moral)-265(and)-264(religious)-264(life.)-294(They)-264(had)-264(died)-265(to)-264(their)-264(former)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sinful)-319(habits)-318(and)-319(practices.)-456(They)-318(were)-319(living)-318(to)-319(God,)-336(and)-318(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reaping)-334(the)-334(fruits)-334(of)-334(holiness)-334(instead)-334(of)-334(receiving)-334(the)-334(wages)-334(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sin.)-823(That)-441(these)-441(facts)-441(were)-441(true,)-489(the)-441(Apostle)-441(appeals)-441(to)-441(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consciousness)-256(to)-255(witness.)-267(Was)-255(this)-256(a)-255(fact)-256(or)-255(was)-256(it)-255(not?)-267(It)-255(would)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-272(been)-271(impossible)-272(for)-272(St.)-315(Paul)-271(to)-272(write)-272(in)-271(this)-272(manner)-271(unless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-377(had)-377(been)-376(assured)-377(that)-377(those)-377(to)-376(whom)-377(he)-377(wrote)-377(thought)-376(so.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-364(power)-365(had)-364(for)-364(its)-365(centre)-364(the)-364(belief)-365(in)-364(the)-364(Resurrection)-364(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ.)-482(It)-327(was)-327(caused)-328(by)-327(their)-327(connection)-327(with)-328(Him)-327(as)-327(a)-327(living)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(person)-250(to)-250(whom)-250(all)-250(their)-250(regards)-250(were)-250(due.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-317(is)-317(impossible)-317(to)-317(have)-317(stronger)-317(historical)-317(evidence)-317(that)-317(t)1(his)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(belief)-301(was)-300(esteemed)-301(by)-301(the)-300(Church)-301(to)-301(be)-300(fundamental)-301(to)-300(Chris-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tianity)-294(when)-295(this)-294(letter)-295(was)-294(written.)-384(I)-294(shall)-295(therefore)-294(only)-294(quote)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(two)-248(more)-248(passages)-248(as)-247(showing)-248(the)-248(purely)-248(incidental)-248(character)-247(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(allusions:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 57.884 0 Td [(\024)]TJ -45.928 -15.186 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Who)-364(shall)-364(lay)-364(anything)-364(to)-363(the)-364(charge)-364(of)-364(God's)-364(elect?)-592(It)-364(is)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(God)-289(that)-290(justifieth;)-309(who)-289(is)-289(he)-289(that)-290(condemneth?)-368(It)-289(is)-289(Christ)-289(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(died,)-247(yea)-246(rather,)-247(that)-246(is)-246(risen)-246(again,)-247(who)-246(is)-246(even)-246(at)-246(the)-246(right)-246(hand)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-245(God,)-245(who)-245(also)-245(maketh)-245(intercession)-244(for)-245(us.)-248(Who)-245(shall)-244(separate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us)-334(from)-334(the)-334(love)-334(of)-334(Christ?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 121.842 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.487 0 Td [(\050Rom.)-502(viii.)-502(38,)-355(&c.\051)-502(Again:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 132.738 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(He)]TJ -267.91 -13.549 Td [(that)-388(regardeth)-389(the)-388(day)-388(regardeth)-389(it)-388(unto)-388(the)-388(Lord;)-458(and)-388(he)-388(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(regardeth)-285(not)-285(the)-285(day,)-294(to)-285(the)-285(Lord)-285(he)-285(doth)-285(not)-285(regard)-285(it.)-355(He)-285(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eateth,)-263(eateth)-260(to)-521(the)-261(Lord,)-263(for)-260(he)-260(giveth)-261(God)-260(thanks;)-266(and)-260(he)-260(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([440])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(eateth)-256(not,)-258(to)-256(the)-256(Lord)-256(he)-256(eateth)-256(not,)-258(and)-256(giveth)-256(God)-256(thanks.)-268(For)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(none)-332(of)-332(us)-332(liveth)-332(to)-332(himself,)-353(and)-332(no)-332(man)-332(dieth)-332(to)-332(himself.)-496(For)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whether)-268(we)-267(live,)-273(we)-267(live)-268(unto)-268(the)-268(Lord;)-276(and)-268(whether)-268(we)-267(die,)-272(we)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(die)-209(unto)-209(the)-209(Lord....)-237(For)-209(to)-209(this)-209(end)-209(Christ)-209(both)-209(died)-209(and)-209(rose,)-217(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(revived,)-330(that)-314(He)-314(might)-314(be)-314(Lord)-314(both)-314(of)-314(the)-314(dead)-314(and)-314(living.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 265.696 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.269 0 Td [(It)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1783 0 obj <<
/Length 4808      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(386)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(is)-263(impossible)-263(that)-263(any)-264(words)-263(could)-263(make)-263(it)-263(clearer)-263(than)-263(these)-263(do)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-273(the)-274(belief)-273(in)-274(the)-273(Resurrection)-273(formed)-274(the)-273(centre)-274(of)-273(the)-273(daily)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(life)-272(of)-271(Christians)-272(at)-272(the)-272(time)-271(when)-272(the)-272(Apostle)-272(was)-271(writing.)-315(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-203(was)-202(a)-203(man)-203(who)-202(was)-203(consecrated)-203(to)-202(the)-203(service)-203(of)-202(Christ)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-250(to)-250(a)-250(living)-250(person,)-250(who)-250(had)-250(a)-250(right)-250(to)-250(his)-250(supreme)-250(regard.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(It)-379(is)-378(therefore)-379(established)-379(beyond)-379(the)-378(possibility)-379(of)-379(a)-378(doubt)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(that)-283(the)-284(belief)-283(in)-283(the)-284(Resurrection)-283(of)-283(Christ)-284(was)-283(universal)-283(in)-283(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church)-336(when)-336(St.)-508(Paul)-336(wrote)-336(these)-337(letters,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 191.39 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 18.875 0 Td [(within)-336(less)-336(than)]TJ -210.265 -13.549 Td [(thirty)-272(years)-272(after)-271(the)-272(event.)-316(At)-271(this)-272(period)-272(of)-272(time)-272(the)-271(traditional)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recollection)-356(of)-356(it,)-383(according)-356(to)-357(the)-356(principles)-356(laid)-356(down)-356(by)-356(Sir)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(G.)-354(C.)-353(Lewis,)-380(would)-353(have)-354(formed)-353(the)-354(best)-353(material)-354(for)-353(history.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(All)-308(the)-307(other)-308(writings)-307(of)-308(the)-308(New)-307(Testament,)-322(whatever)-308(be)-307(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposed)-268(date,)-271(give)-268(a)-267(uniform)-268(testimony)-267(in)-268(complete)-267(agreement)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-331(this.)-495(One)-331(of)-332(them)-331(demands)-332(a)-331(special)-332(notice)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 218.253 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(the)-331(book)-332(of)]TJ -229.162 -13.549 Td [(Revelation.)]TJ 11.955 -15.186 Td [(Unbelievers)-440(do)-440(not)-440(dispute)-440(that)-440(this)-440(is)-440(a)-440(contemporaneous)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(document,)-441(the)-402(work)-403(of)-403(the)-402(Apostle)-403(John,)-441(and)-403(freely)-402(use)-403(it)-402(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(support)-345(their)-345(own)-344(theories)-345(as)-345(to)-344(the)-345(intensity)-345(of)-345(the)-344(opposition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(between)-330(the)-329(Jewish)-330(Apostles)-330(and)-329(St.)-489(Paul.)-489(I)-330(am)-330(quite)-329(sensible)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-198(a)-197(book)-198(which)-197(is)-197(professedly)-198(an)-197(apocalypse)-198(must)-197(be)-198(used)-197(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(caution)-253(as)-254(an)-253(historical)-253(document,)-254(or)-253(we)-254(may)-253(fall)-253(into)-253(numerous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(errors)-244(in)-244(drawing)-244(inferences)-244(from)-244(obscure)-244(allusions)-244(contained)-244(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(visions.)-482(But)-327(if)-327(there)-327(is)-327(one)-328(point)-327(more)-327(than)-327(another)-327(which)-327(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(book)-296(makes)-295(clear,)-307(it)-296(is)-295(the)-591(strength)-296(of)-295(the)-296(author's)-295(belief)-296(in)-295(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([441])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.55 Td [(Resurrection)-296(of)-296(Jesus.)-387(The)-296(frequent)-295(allusions)-296(to)-296(it,)-307(and)-296(to)-295(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-226(being)-225(the)-226(Christ,)-230(put)-226(this)-225(beyond)-226(all)-225(dispute.)-242(We)-225(have)-226(here)-225(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testimony)-278(of)-279(a)-278(book)-279(which)-278(unbelievers)-278(concur)-279(in)-278(considering)-278(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-221(been)-221(composed)-220(not)-221(later)-221(than)-221(a)-221(year)-220(after)-221(the)-221(death)-221(of)-220(Nero,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-264(allow)-265(it)-264(to)-264(be)-264(the)-265(one)-264(solitary)-264(writing)-265(in)-264(the)-264(New)-264(Testament)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(composed)-250(by)-250(one)-250(of)-250(the)-250(twelve)-250(Apostles.)]TJ 11.955 -15.185 Td [(According)-336(to)-335(the)-336(opinions)-335(of)-336(the)-335(opponents)-336(of)-335(the)-336(historical)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(character)-265(of)-265(the)-265(Gospels,)-269(St.)-296(John)-265(was)-265(the)-265(most)-265(Judaizing)-265(of)-265(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(original)-331(apostles)-332(of)-331(Christ.)-494(Of)-331(this)-331(they)-332(think)-331(that)-331(they)-331(discern)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(very)-377(distinct)-376(traces)-377(in)-376(the)-377(book)-377(of)-376(Revelation.)-630(His)-376(opposition)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1787 0 obj <<
/Length 4702      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(387)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(to)-390(St.)-670(Paul)-391(was)-390(in)-390(their)-390(opinion)-390(extreme;)-460(and)-390(they)-390(think)-390(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-430(is)-430(actually)-430(referred)-430(to)-430(in)-430(the)-430(second)-430(and)-430(third)-430(chapters)-430(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(teaching)-244(the)-244(Jewish)-243(Christians)-244(to)-244(apostatize.)-248(To)-244(discuss)-244(the)-243(truth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-228(falsehood)-228(of)-228(these)-227(opinions)-228(can)-228(form)-228(no)-228(portion)-228(of)-228(the)-227(present)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(work;)-377(but)-335(it)-335(is)-335(plain)-335(that)-335(in)-334(either)-335(case)-335(we)-335(cannot)-335(have)-335(a)-334(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unexceptionable)-278(witness.)-334(If)-278(these)-278(views)-278(are)-278(correct,)-285(the)-277(Apostle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-212(be)-212(considered)-212(as)-212(the)-212(spokesman)-211(of)-212(the)-212(Jewish)-212(Christians.)-237(At)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-229(rate)-228(he)-229(was)-229(one)-228(of)-229(the)-229(original)-229(followers)-228(of)-229(Jesus.)-243(Now)-228(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-213(no)-212(book)-213(in)-212(the)-213(New)-212(Testament)-212(which)-213(testifies)-212(more)-213(strongly)-212(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-270(completeness)-269(of)-270(the)-269(belief)-270(in)-269(the)-270(Resurrection)-269(of)-270(Christ,)-274(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-200(His)-200(continued)-200(Messianic)-201(life)-200(in)-200(the)-200(heavenly)-200(world.)-233(The)-200(writer)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-262(conversed)-262(with)-262(Him)-262(before)-262(His)-262(crucifixion.)-286(The)-262(vision)-262(is)-262(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-250(considerable)-250(extent)-250(a)-250(description)-250(of)-250(His)-250(resurrection)-250(life.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(This)-252(testimony)-252(alone)-252(carries)-252(with)-252(it)-252(the)-252(belief)-252(of)-252(the)-252(primitive)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Church)-310(at)-309(Jerusalem,)-325(and)-310(proves)-309(that)-310(on)-310(this)-309(point)-310(at)-310(least)-309(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-378(St.)-634(Paul)-379(were)-378(at)-378(one.)-634(This)-378(his)-378(Epistles)-378(place)-378(beyond)-378(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possibility)-217(of)-217(question.)-239(The)-217(parties)-217(in)-217(opposition)-217(were)-217(beyond)-217(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(doubt)-276(Judaizing)-275(Christians.)-327(According)-276(to)-275(those)-551(against)-276(whom)-275(I)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([442])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(am)-311(reasoning,)-326(they)-311(represented)-310(the)-311(opinions)-311(and)-311(claimed)-311(to)-310(act)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-348(the)-347(authority)-348(of)-348(St.)-543(James)-348(and)-347(the)-348(Church)-348(at)-347(Jerusalem.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(But)-289(as)-288(these)-289(Judaizing)-288(teachers)-289(were)-288(at)-288(one)-289(with)-288(Paul)-289(about)-288(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-220(of)-220(the)-219(Resurrection,)-226(it)-220(follows)-220(that)-219(the)-220(leaders)-220(of)-220(that)-219(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(concurred)-341(with)-340(him)-341(in)-341(opinion)-340(also.)-522(If)-341(their)-340(opposition)-341(was)-340(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(strenuous)-308(as)-308(has)-308(been)-308(attested,)-322(if)-308(there)-308(had)-308(been)-308(any)-307(difference)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(between)-345(St.)-534(Paul)-344(and)-345(the)-345(twelve)-344(on)-345(so)-345(fundamental)-344(a)-345(point,)-368(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-400(impossible)-401(that)-400(they)-400(could)-401(have)-400(avoided)-400(adducing)-401(it)-400(to)-400(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Apostle's)-250(prejudice.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-291(strength)-292(of)-292(St.)-374(Paul's)-292(assurance,)-301(that)-292(there)-291(was)-292(no)-291(diver-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(sity)-317(of)-317(opinion)-317(in)-318(the)-317(Church)-317(respecting)-317(this)-317(fact)-317(is)-317(remarkably)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(illustrated)-363(by)-363(a)-363(passage)-363(in)-363(1)-363(Cor.)-589(xv.)-588(Had)-363(it)-363(not)-363(been)-363(so,)-391(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reasoning)-309(would)-309(have)-309(been)-310(simply)-309(absurd.)-427(There)-309(were)-309(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-437(that)-437(Church)-437(who)-436(denied)-437(the)-437(fact)-437(of)-437(a)-437(future)-436(Resurrection.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Yet)-412(they)-411(must)-412(have)-412(admitted)-411(the)-412(truth)-412(of)-411(the)-412(Resurrection)-411(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christ.)-328(This)-276(is)-276(clear)-276(from)-276(the)-276(following)-276(words:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 205.566 0 Td [(\024\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.753 0 Td [(If)-276(there)-276(be)-276(no)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1792 0 obj <<
/Length 5039      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(388)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(resurrection)-327(of)-327(the)-327(dead,)-347(then)-327(is)-327(Christ)-327(not)-327(risen.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 217.212 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.412 0 Td [(The)-327(reply)-327(to)]TJ -225.624 -13.549 Td [(this)-359(argument)-359(is)-359(so)-359(obvious)-359(that)-359(it)-359(could)-359(not)-359(have)-359(escaped)-358(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dullest)-288(apprehension;)-306(if)-288(those)-287(who)-288(denied)-288(the)-287(reality)-288(of)-288(a)-287(future)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(resurrection)-273(of)-273(the)-273(dead)-273(had)-273(entertained)-273(the)-273(smallest)-273(doubt)-273(as)-272(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-345(Resurrection)-346(of)-345(Christ,)-369(they)-345(would)-345(have)-346(had)-345(nothing)-345(to)-345(do)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-260(to)-261(affirm)-260(that)-261(the)-260(fact)-261(was)-260(doubtful,)-263(and)-261(the)-260(whole)-260(argument)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-266(fall)-265(to)-266(pieces.)-297(On)-266(the)-266(contrary,)-269(however,)-270(St.)-297(Paul)-265(thought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-297(they)-298(were)-297(so)-297(fully)-298(persuaded)-297(of)-297(the)-298(truth)-297(of)-297(Christ's)-297(Resur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rection,)-294(that)-285(he)-285(could)-285(safely)-285(use)-285(the)-285(fact)-285(to)-285(prove)-285(the)-285(possibility)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-387(that)-386(future)-387(resurrection)-387(which)-386(they)-387(denied.)-660(It)-387(is)-387(clear,)-420(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unless)-242(the)-242(belief)-243(was)-242(of)-242(the)-242(firmest)-242(character,)-244(no)-242(logical)-242(position)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(could)-250(be)-250(more)-250(dangerous)-250(than)-250(this)-250(line)-250(of)-250(argument.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-314(Epistle)-314(to)-313(the)-314(Romans)-314(establishes)-314(the)-314(same)-627(conclusion.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([443])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(The)-251(belief)-250(of)-251(this)-251(Church)-250(in)-251(the)-251(Resurrection)-250(as)-251(the)-250(fundamental)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-253(of)-254(Christianity)-253(can)-253(be)-254(traced)-253(up,)-254(as)-253(I)-254(have)-253(already)-253(observed,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(not)-280(only)-281(to)-280(the)-281(commencement)-280(of)-281(their)-280(own)-280(Christianity,)-288(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-348(palpably)-348(of)-348(many)-348(years')-348(standing,)-373(but)-348(even)-348(to)-348(the)-348(birth)-348(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christianity)-370(itself.)-609(Of)-369(this,)-400(one)-370(brief)-369(incidental)-370(allusion)-369(offers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(decisive)-305(proof:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 69.659 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Salute,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.168 0 Td [(says)-305(St.)-414(Paul,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 64.055 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Andronicus)-305(and)-305(Junia,)]TJ -181.569 -13.549 Td [(my)-259(kinsmen,)-262(and)-260(my)-259(fellow-prisoners,)-262(who)-259(were)-260(of)-259(note)-259(among)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(Apostles,)-250(who)-250(were)-250(also)-250(in)-250(Christ)-250(before)-250(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 212.695 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -200.739 -16.004 Td [(This)-363(passage)-364(makes)-363(the)-364(following)-363(points)-363(clear.)-590(Andronicus)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(and)-396(Junia)-396(were)-397(converted)-396(to)-396(Christianity)-396(before)-396(St.)-689(Paul,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 267.299 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -267.299 -13.549 Td [(within)-255(less)-254(than)-255(ten)-255(years)-255(from)-254(the)-255(date)-255(of)-255(the)-254(Crucifixion.)-264(They)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-435(therefore)-435(have)-435(been)-435(members)-435(of)-435(the)-435(Jerusalem)-435(Church.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(They)-296(were)-296(of)-296(note)-296(among)-296(the)-296(Apostles.)-388(This)-296(expression)-296(cannot)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mean)-356(less)-356(than)-356(that)-357(they)-356(were)-356(highly)-356(esteemed)-356(by)-356(the)-356(original)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(twelve,)-495(and)-445(by)-446(the)-445(leaders)-446(of)-446(the)-445(Church)-446(at)-446(Jerusalem.)-836(Yet)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-278(Apostle)-279(wrote)-278(this)-278(Epistle)-278(in)-278(the)-279(fullest)-278(confidence)-278(that)-278(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-194(accept)-193(his)-194(Christology,)-205(including)-194(his)-193(account)-194(of)-194(the)-193(Resur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rection.)-293(This)-265(proves)-264(that)-264(both)-265(they)-264(and)-264(the)-265(Church)-264(at)-264(Jerusalem,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(including)-231(all)-231(its)-231(chief)-231(leaders,)-235(accepted)-231(the)-231(Resurrection)-231(as)-231(a)-231(fact)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(within)-319(a)-318(very)-319(short)-319(interval)-319(after)-318(its)-319(supposed)-319(date.)-456(But)-319(it)-318(does)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more:)-442(it)-347(proves)-346(that)-346(its)-346(importance)-347(as)-346(vital)-346(to)-346(Christianity)-346(was)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1796 0 obj <<
/Length 4564      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(389)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(fully)-215(recognized;)-227(or,)-223(in)-215(other)-215(words,)-223(it)-215(proves)-215(that)-216(the)-215(belief)-215(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-250(been)-250(contemporaneous)-250(with)-250(the)-250(origin)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Church.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Equally)-380(decisive)-380(is)-380(the)-379(proof)-380(afforded)-380(by)-380(the)-380(Epistle)-380(to)-379(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Galatians.)-948(It)-483(mentions)-482(two)-483(visits)-483(which)-482(the)-483(writer)-483(made)-482(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jerusalem.)-579(One)-359(in)-360(which)-359(he)-360(paid)-359(Peter)-359(a)-360(visit)-359(of)-360(fifteen)-359(days,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(during)-261(which)-260(time)-261(he)-260(communicated)-261(with)-261(James.)-281(On)-261(the)-260(second)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occasion)-344(he)-344(went)-344(up)-345(to)-344(Jerusalem)-344(as)-344(a)-344(member)-344(of)-344(an)-344(embassy)]TJ 3.594 -13.549 Td [(from)-329(the)-330(Church)-329(at)-330(Antioch,)-349(for)-329(the)-330(purpose)-329(of)-330(settling)-329(points)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 287.43 0 Td [([444])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(under)-453(dispute)-454(between)-453(the)-454(Jewish)-453(and)-454(Gentile)-453(converts.)-860(On)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-430(occasion)-430(he)-429(tells)-430(us)-430(that)-430(he)-429(had)-430(a)-430(formal)-430(interview)-429(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-388(leaders)-387(of)-388(the)-388(Jewish)-387(Church,)-422(of)-388(which)-387(Peter,)-422(James,)-422(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(John)-276(were)-276(esteemed)-276(the)-276(pillars.)-328(He)-276(expressly)-276(informs)-276(us)-276(that)-276(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(communicated)-346(to)-346(them)-347(the)-346(leading)-346(points)-346(of)-346(the)-346(Gospel)-346(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-239(preached)-240(among)-239(the)-240(Gentiles;)-243(and)-239(that)-239(he)-240(received)-239(from)-239(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-432(right)-432(hand)-432(of)-432(fellowship,)-478(which)-432(can)-432(only)-432(mean)-432(that)-432(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sanctioned)-316(his)-316(views)-316(and)-317(fundamental)-316(principles.)-448(It)-316(is)-316(true)-316(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-196(Resurrection)-196(is)-195(not)-196(expressly)-196(mentioned)-196(as)-195(one)-196(of)-196(these;)-214(but)-195(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-204(impossible)-204(that)-204(the)-204(statement)-204(that)-204(he)-204(communicated)-204(his)-204(Gospel)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-366(them)-365(can)-365(be)-366(true,)-394(if)-366(this)-365(was)-366(not)-365(one)-366(of)-365(the)-366(facts)-365(which)-365(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(imparted)-250(to)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-307(is)-308(a)-307(very)-308(important)-307(fact,)-322(and)-307(worthy)-308(of)-307(special)-308(notice,)-321(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-445(the)-445(account)-444(given)-445(in)-445(the)-445(Epistle)-444(to)-445(the)-445(Corinthians)-445(of)-444(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(appearances)-316(of)-316(Jesus)-315(after)-316(His)-316(Resurrection,)-332(St.)-448(Paul)-315(expressly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirms)-273(that)-273(the)-272(risen)-273(Jesus)-273(was)-273(seen)-272(by)-273(Peter)-273(and)-273(by)-272(James;)-284(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(latter)-257(appearance)-258(being)-257(mentioned)-257(nowhere)-257(else:)-265(and)-257(the)-257(former)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(only)-340(referred)-341(to)-340(in)-341(the)-340(exclamation)-340(which)-341(greeted)-340(Cleopas)-340(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-224(companion)-223(on)-224(their)-223(return)-224(from)-223(Emmaus.)-241(It)-224(seems,)-228(therefore,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(morally)-452(certain)-452(that)-452(St.)-856(Paul)-452(had)-452(heard)-452(an)-452(account)-452(of)-451(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(two)-323(appearances)-323(from)-323(the)-323(Apostles)-323(in)-323(question.)-469(If)-323(so,)-341(it)-323(brings)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us)-374(directly)-374(into)-374(contact)-374(with)-374(two)-374(of)-374(the)-374(most)-374(important)-374(of)-374(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apostolic)-341(body,)-363(who)-341(must)-340(have)-341(believed)-341(that)-340(they)-341(had)-340(actually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(seen)-338(him.)-513(Respecting)-338(the)-337(belief)-338(of)-338(St.)-513(John,)-359(the)-338(third)-338(pillar)-337(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-219(Church)-220(at)-219(Jerusalem,)-225(the)-220(testimony)-219(of)-219(the)-220(book)-219(of)-219(Revelation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(leaves)-224(no)-223(room)-224(for)-224(doubt.)-241(These)-224(writings)-224(enable)-223(us)-224(to)-224(affirm)-223(that)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1800 0 obj <<
/Length 4855      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(390)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(three)-287(of)-287(the)-286(original)-287(Apostles)-287(believed)-286(that)-287(they)-287(had)-287(seen)-286(Jesus,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(risen)-329(from)-328(the)-329(dead.)-486(It)-328(is)-329(evident,)-348(therefore,)-349(that)-328(this)-329(brings)-328(us)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-300(the)-300(presence)-300(of)-300(historical)-601(evidence)-300(of)-300(the)-300(first)-300(order,)-312(quite)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([445])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(independently)-250(of)-250(the)-250(affirmations)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Gospels.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(If)-253(the)-254(first)-253(Epistle)-254(of)-253(St.)-260(Peter)-254(is)-253(genuine)-253(\050and)-254(there)-253(is)-253(nothing)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(but)-358(surmises)-358(and)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 79.598 0 Td [(\340)-358(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 38.731 0 Td [(assumptions)-358(about)-358(the)-358(opposition)-359(of)]TJ -118.329 -13.55 Td [(his)-361(views)-362(to)-361(those)-361(of)-362(St.)-584(Paul)-361(on)-361(which)-362(the)-361(doubts)-361(respecting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-351(genuineness)-351(are)-351(based\051)-350(then)-351(we)-351(have)-351(the)-351(affirmation)-351(of)-350(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fulness)-414(of)-415(his)-414(belief)-415(in)-414(the)-415(Resurrection)-414(under)-415(his)-414(own)-414(hand.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Besides)-320(the)-320(strong)-319(external)-320(testimony)-320(that)-319(it)-320(was)-320(written)-320(by)-319(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Peter,)-518(there)-465(is)-464(one)-465(proof)-465(of)-464(its)-465(genuineness)-464(which)-465(is)-464(almost)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(conclusive,)-246(and)-244(to)-245(which)-244(sufficient)-245(weight)-244(has)-244(not)-245(been)-244(attached)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-382(either)-383(the)-382(defenders)-383(or)-382(the)-382(opponents)-383(of)-382(Christianity.)-647(It)-382(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hardly)-254(possible)-253(to)-254(read)-253(this)-254(Epistle)-254(carefully)-253(without)-254(feeling)-253(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-296(writer)-297(of)-296(it)-297(is)-296(the)-296(same)-297(man)-296(as)-296(the)-297(Peter)-296(of)-297(the)-296(Gospels;)-319(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-268(being)-267(separated)-268(from)-267(the)-268(other)-267(by)-268(a)-267(considerable)-268(interval)-267(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(time;)-357(the)-322(Peter)-321(of)-322(the)-322(Epistle)-321(being)-322(in)-321(fact)-322(a)-321(mellowed)-322(form)-321(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-223(Peter)-224(of)-223(the)-223(Gospels.)-242(But)-223(this)-223(has)-224(not)-223(only)-223(a)-224(direct)-223(bearing)-223(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-267(evidence)-267(of)-267(t)1(he)-267(Resurrection,)-271(but)-267(also)-267(a)-267(most)-267(important)-266(one,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-313(I)-314(shall)-313(notice)-313(hereafter,)-329(on)-313(the)-314(historical)-313(character)-313(of)-313(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-250(themselves.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(One)-305(more)-305(writing)-305(of)-304(the)-305(New)-305(Testament)-305(must)-305(be)-305(alluded)-304(to,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(because)-243(whoever)-243(was)-243(its)-243(author)-243(it)-243(belongs)-243(to)-243(a)-243(school)-243(of)-242(thought)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinct)-350(from)-350(the)-350(other)-350(writings)-350(of)-350(the)-350(New)-350(Testament.)-551(I)-349(need)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(hardly)-280(say)-280(that)-281(I)-280(allude)-280(to)-280(the)-280(Epistle)-280(to)-281(the)-280(Hebrews.)-340(The)-280(testi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mony)-223(of)-222(this)-223(writing)-223(to)-222(the)-223(fact)-222(that)-223(the)-223(belief)-222(in)-223(the)-222(Resurrection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-340(Jesus)-340(was)-341(fundamental)-340(to)-340(Christianity)-340(is)-341(no)-340(less)-340(decisive;)-385(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-270(only)-270(proves)-270(what)-270(were)-270(the)-270(individual)-270(opinions)-270(of)-270(the)-269(writer,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-250(of)-251(the)-250(school)-250(of)-251(Christian)-250(thought)-250(for)-251(whom)-250(it)-250(was)-250(intended.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(It)-240(affords)-239(abundant)-240(proof)-239(that)-240(the)-239(writer)-240(knew)-239(that)-240(their)-239(opinions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-250(the)-250(subject)-250(were)-250(entirely)-250(in)-250(accordance)-250(with)-250(his)-250(own.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([446])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -15.185 Td [(I)-291(have)-291(now)-291(shown)-291(on)-291(the)-291(strongest)-291(historical)-291(evidence)-291(that)-290(it)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(is)-278(impossible)-279(that)-278(the)-278(belief)-279(in)-278(the)-278(Resurrection)-279(can)-278(have)-278(grown)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(up)-211(slowly)-210(and)-211(only)-210(succeeded)-211(in)-210(gradually)-211(establishing)-211(itself.)-236(On)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1668 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 986
/Length 9390      
>>
stream
1665 0 1667 119 1664 177 1670 243 1672 362 1669 420 1674 498 1676 617 1673 676 1678 768
1680 887 1677 946 1683 1036 1685 1155 1686 1214 1682 1273 1688 1363 1690 1482 1687 1540 1692 1630
1694 1749 1691 1808 1696 1874 1698 1993 1695 2052 1700 2130 1702 2249 1699 2308 1704 2374 1706 2493
1703 2552 1709 2618 1711 2737 1712 2796 1708 2854 1713 2920 1716 2961 1718 3099 1714 3218 1717 3276
1721 3354 1723 3473 1724 3531 1720 3590 1726 3680 1728 3799 1725 3856 1730 3922 1732 4041 1729 4099
1734 4203 1736 4322 1733 4381 1739 4447 1741 4566 1738 4625 1743 4703 1745 4822 1742 4881 1747 4959
1749 5078 1750 5137 1746 5195 1752 5285 1754 5404 1751 5463 1756 5529 1758 5648 1755 5707 1760 5785
1762 5904 1759 5963 1765 6029 1767 6148 1764 6207 1769 6297 1771 6416 1768 6475 1773 6565 1775 6684
1776 6742 1772 6800 1778 6878 1780 6997 1777 7056 1782 7134 1784 7253 1781 7312 1786 7402 1788 7521
1785 7580 1791 7658 1793 7777 1790 7835 1795 7925 1797 8044 1794 8102 1799 8168 1801 8287 1802 8346
% 1665 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1666 0 R
/Resources 1664 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1654 0 R
>>
% 1667 0 obj
<<
/D [1665 0 R /XYZ 287.002 274.29 null]
>>
% 1664 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1670 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1671 0 R
/Resources 1669 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1654 0 R
>>
% 1672 0 obj
<<
/D [1670 0 R /XYZ 79.891 326.032 null]
>>
% 1669 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1674 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1675 0 R
/Resources 1673 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1654 0 R
>>
% 1676 0 obj
<<
/D [1674 0 R /XYZ 233.106 407.327 null]
>>
% 1673 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F37 246 0 R /F38 247 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1678 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1679 0 R
/Resources 1677 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1681 0 R
>>
% 1680 0 obj
<<
/D [1678 0 R /XYZ 209.427 463.978 null]
>>
% 1677 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1683 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1684 0 R
/Resources 1682 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1681 0 R
>>
% 1685 0 obj
<<
/D [1683 0 R /XYZ 374.173 518.175 null]
>>
% 1686 0 obj
<<
/D [1683 0 R /XYZ 363.091 120.339 null]
>>
% 1682 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1688 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1689 0 R
/Resources 1687 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1681 0 R
>>
% 1690 0 obj
<<
/D [1688 0 R /XYZ 46.771 174.536 null]
>>
% 1687 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1692 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1693 0 R
/Resources 1691 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1681 0 R
>>
% 1694 0 obj
<<
/D [1692 0 R /XYZ 266.415 242.282 null]
>>
% 1691 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1696 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1697 0 R
/Resources 1695 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1681 0 R
>>
% 1698 0 obj
<<
/D [1696 0 R /XYZ 196.033 298.442 null]
>>
% 1695 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1700 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1701 0 R
/Resources 1699 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1681 0 R
>>
% 1702 0 obj
<<
/D [1700 0 R /XYZ 138.003 350.675 null]
>>
% 1699 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1704 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1705 0 R
/Resources 1703 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1707 0 R
>>
% 1706 0 obj
<<
/D [1704 0 R /XYZ 192.982 423.331 null]
>>
% 1703 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1709 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1710 0 R
/Resources 1708 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1707 0 R
>>
% 1711 0 obj
<<
/D [1709 0 R /XYZ 374.173 491.077 null]
>>
% 1712 0 obj
<<
/D [1709 0 R /XYZ 93.543 325.934 null]
>>
% 1708 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1713 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index20) >>
% 1716 0 obj
(Chapter XIX. The Evidence Furnished By The Epistles To The Facts Of Our Lord's Life, And To The Truth Of The Resurrection.)
% 1718 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1719 0 R
/Resources 1717 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1707 0 R
>>
% 1714 0 obj
<<
/D [1718 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 1717 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1721 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1722 0 R
/Resources 1720 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1707 0 R
>>
% 1723 0 obj
<<
/D [1721 0 R /XYZ 93.543 518.175 null]
>>
% 1724 0 obj
<<
/D [1721 0 R /XYZ 114.681 120.339 null]
>>
% 1720 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1726 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1727 0 R
/Resources 1725 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1707 0 R
>>
% 1728 0 obj
<<
/D [1726 0 R /XYZ 57.67 188.085 null]
>>
% 1725 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1730 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1731 0 R
/Resources 1729 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1707 0 R
>>
% 1732 0 obj
<<
/D [1730 0 R /XYZ 93.543 270.684 null]
>>
% 1729 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F37 246 0 R /F38 247 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1734 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1735 0 R
/Resources 1733 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1737 0 R
>>
% 1736 0 obj
<<
/D [1734 0 R /XYZ 200.144 327.259 null]
>>
% 1733 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1739 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1740 0 R
/Resources 1738 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1737 0 R
>>
% 1741 0 obj
<<
/D [1739 0 R /XYZ 362.045 380.228 null]
>>
% 1738 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1743 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1744 0 R
/Resources 1742 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1737 0 R
>>
% 1745 0 obj
<<
/D [1743 0 R /XYZ 201.923 450.429 null]
>>
% 1742 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1747 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1748 0 R
/Resources 1746 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1737 0 R
>>
% 1749 0 obj
<<
/D [1747 0 R /XYZ 216.295 518.175 null]
>>
% 1750 0 obj
<<
/D [1747 0 R /XYZ 247.051 106.79 null]
>>
% 1746 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1752 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1753 0 R
/Resources 1751 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1737 0 R
>>
% 1754 0 obj
<<
/D [1752 0 R /XYZ 220.347 174.536 null]
>>
% 1751 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1756 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1757 0 R
/Resources 1755 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1737 0 R
>>
% 1758 0 obj
<<
/D [1756 0 R /XYZ 358.555 228.732 null]
>>
% 1755 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1760 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1761 0 R
/Resources 1759 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1763 0 R
>>
% 1762 0 obj
<<
/D [1760 0 R /XYZ 280.918 284.157 null]
>>
% 1759 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1765 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1766 0 R
/Resources 1764 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1763 0 R
>>
% 1767 0 obj
<<
/D [1765 0 R /XYZ 319.434 340.399 null]
>>
% 1764 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1769 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1770 0 R
/Resources 1768 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1763 0 R
>>
% 1771 0 obj
<<
/D [1769 0 R /XYZ 285.418 409.782 null]
>>
% 1768 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1773 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1774 0 R
/Resources 1772 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1763 0 R
>>
% 1775 0 obj
<<
/D [1773 0 R /XYZ 260.51 463.978 null]
>>
% 1776 0 obj
<<
/D [1773 0 R /XYZ 331.376 66.142 null]
>>
% 1772 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1778 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1779 0 R
/Resources 1777 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1763 0 R
>>
% 1780 0 obj
<<
/D [1778 0 R /XYZ 118.638 133.888 null]
>>
% 1777 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1782 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1783 0 R
/Resources 1781 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1763 0 R
>>
% 1784 0 obj
<<
/D [1782 0 R /XYZ 213.299 203.271 null]
>>
% 1781 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1786 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1787 0 R
/Resources 1785 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1789 0 R
>>
% 1788 0 obj
<<
/D [1786 0 R /XYZ 256.571 285.384 null]
>>
% 1785 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1791 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1792 0 R
/Resources 1790 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1789 0 R
>>
% 1793 0 obj
<<
/D [1791 0 R /XYZ 320.753 353.13 null]
>>
% 1790 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1795 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1796 0 R
/Resources 1794 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1789 0 R
>>
% 1797 0 obj
<<
/D [1795 0 R /XYZ 46.771 420.876 null]
>>
% 1794 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1799 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1800 0 R
/Resources 1798 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1789 0 R
>>
% 1801 0 obj
<<
/D [1799 0 R /XYZ 228.068 491.077 null]
>>
% 1802 0 obj
<<
/D [1799 0 R /XYZ 93.543 106.048 null]
>>
endstream
endobj
1806 0 obj <<
/Length 1842      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(391)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(the)-212(contrary,)-219(I)-211(have)-212(proved)-211(that)-212(it)-211(was)-212(coeval)-211(with)-212(the)-211(birth)-212(of)-211(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church,)-246(and)-246(that)-246(it)-245(formed)-246(the)-245(one)-246(sole)-245(ground)-246(of)-245(its)-246(existence.)-248(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-198(also)-199(proved)-198(that)-199(the)-198(belief)-198(in)-199(it)-198(was)-199(universal,)-208(and)-199(that)-198(it)-198(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accepted)-318(by)-318(the)-318(entire)-318(Christian)-318(community)-318(without)-317(distinction)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-294(party;)-316(and)-294(that)-294(their)-293(belief)-294(can)-294(be)-294(traced)-294(up)-294(as)-294(the)-294(sole)-293(cause)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-349(the)-349(renewed)-349(life)-349(of)-349(the)-349(Church)-349(after)-349(the)-349(crucifixion.)-547(I)-348(shall)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(consider)-208(in)-208(the)-207(following)-208(chapter)-208(the)-208(bearing)-207(of)-208(these)-208(facts)-208(on)-207(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth)-325(of)-325(the)-324(Resurrection,)-344(and)-325(show)-324(that)-325(the)-325(facts)-325(before)-325(us)-324(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inconsistent)-315(with)-315(any)-315(other)-315(supposition)-315(but)-315(that)-315(of)-315(its)-315(objective)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(occurrence,)-448(and)-409(that)-408(it)-409(is)-408(impossible)-409(to)-408(account)-409(for)-408(it)-409(by)-408(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(theory)-234(which)-234(endeavours)-233(to)-234(explain)-234(it)-233(on)-234(the)-234(supposition)-234(that)-233(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belief)-229(originated)-229(in)-229(the)-229(credulity)-229(and)-229(enthusiasm)-229(of)-229(the)-229(followers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(Jesus.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 -27.415 Td [([447])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1814 0 obj <<
/Length 3512      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 93.543 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-257(XX.)-257(The)-256(Resurrection)-257(Of)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Jesus)-250(Christ)-250(An)-250(Historical)-250(Fact.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -39.663 Td [(I)-305(have)-305(proved)-305(in)-305(the)-305(preceding)-305(chapter,)-319(on)-305(the)-305(testimony)-304(of)-305(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(highest)-250(order)-250(of)-250(historical)-250(evidence:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 156.938 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -144.982 -14.997 Td [(1.)-242(That)-225(the)-225(belief)-225(in)-225(the)-226(Resurrection)-225(of)-225(Jesus)-225(was)-225(universal)-225(in)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(Church)-250(when)-250(St.)-250(Paul)-250(wrote)-250(these)-250(Epistles.)]TJ 11.956 -14.998 Td [(2.)-244(That)-232(this)-232(belief)-232(was)-232(held)-231(by)-232(every)-232(section)-232(in)-232(the)-232(Church,)-235(by)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-312(strongest)-311(opponents)-312(no)-311(less)-312(than)-311(by)-312(the)-311(admiring)-312(friends)-311(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(St.)-250(Paul.)]TJ 11.956 -14.998 Td [(3.)-347(That)-282(the)-283(Churches)-282(holding)-282(this)-283(belief)-282(were)-282(separated)-282(from)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(each)-266(other)-266(by)-265(a)-266(wide)-266(geographical)-266(area,)-269(and)-266(consisted)-266(of)-266(a)-265(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(diversity)-295(of)-295(character,)-306(thereby)-295(affording)-295(the)-295(greatest)-295(obstacle)-294(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(spreading)-250(of)-250(an)-250(absurd)-250(story.)]TJ 11.956 -14.998 Td [(4.)-240(That)-219(these)-219(Churches)-220(did)-219(not)-219(merely)-220(accept)-219(the)-219(Resurrection)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(as)-384(a)-384(bare)-384(fact,)-418(but)-384(that)-384(they)-384(considered)-384(that)-384(their)-384(existence)-384(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(communities)-250(was)-250(based)-250(on)-250(its)-250(truth.)]TJ 11.956 -14.998 Td [(5.)-460(That)-320(they)-320(viewed)-320(the)-320(fact)-320(of)-320(the)-320(Resurrection)-320(not)-320(only)-320(as)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-357(great)-357(bond)-357(of)-358(union,)-384(but)-357(as)-357(the)-357(source)-357(of)-357(the)-357(moral)-357(power)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-275(the)-274(Christianity)-275(which)-274(they)-275(professed,)-281(and)-274(fully)-275(believed)-274(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(their)-223(acceptance)-223(of)-223(it)-223(had)-223(exercised)-223(a)-223(mighty)-223(influence)-223(in)-223(turning)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-250(from)-250(the)-250(low)-250(and)-250(debasing)-250(pursuits)-250(of)-250(their)-250(previous)-250(life.)]TJ 11.956 -14.997 Td [(6.)-359(That)-287(their)-286(belief)-287(in)-286(the)-287(Resurrection)-286(was)-287(closely)-286(bound)-286(up)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(with)-250(all)-250(the)-250(pursuits)-250(of)-250(their)-250(daily)-250(life.)]TJ 11.956 -14.998 Td [(7.)-317(That)-273(these)-272(Epistles)-273(not)-272(only)-273(afford)-272(indisputable)-545(proof)-272(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -84.711 0 Td [([448])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(this)-228(state)-227(of)-228(things)-227(existed)-228(in)-228(the)-227(Churches)-228(within)-227(less)-228(than)-227(twen-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ty-eight)-248(years)-248(after)-248(the)-248(crucifixion,)-248(but)-248(they)-248(no)-248(less)-248(clearly)-247(show)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-281(the)-280(earliest)-281(Christian)-280(communities,)-288(such)-281(as)-280(the)-281(Churches)-280(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Antioch)-250(and)-250(Jerusalem,)-250(entertained)-250(similar)-250(beliefs.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1818 0 obj <<
/Length 4386      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(393)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -252.311 -30.759 Td [(8.)-267(That)-256(it)-256(is)-256(an)-256(unquestionable)-255(historical)-256(fact)-256(that)-256(the)-256(belief)-255(in)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-234(Resurrection)-234(was)-234(co-eval)-235(with)-234(the)-234(restored)-234(life)-234(of)-234(the)-234(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(had)-250(been)-250(extinguished)-250(by)-250(the)-250(crucifixion.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(9.)-471(That)-323(the)-324(three)-323(pillar)-324(Apostles)-323(of)-324(the)-323(Church)-324(of)-323(Jerusalem)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(believed)-225(that)-226(they)-225(had)-225(seen)-225(Jesus)-226(after)-225(His)-225(Resurrection,)-230(and)-225(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(entire)-250(body)-250(entertained)-250(a)-250(similar)-250(opinion.)]TJ 11.956 -14.162 Td [(10.)-832(That)-444(as)-444(late)-444(as)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 96.008 0 Td [(A)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 2.728 0 Td [(D)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)-444(57)-444(or)-444(58)-444(more)-444(than)-444(250)-444(persons)]TJ -122.2 -13.55 Td [(were)-278(still)-279(living)-278(who)-278(believed)-279(that)-278(they)-278(had)-279(seen)-278(Jesus)-278(after)-278(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Resurrection;)-236(and)-229(that)-229(originally)-229(more)-229(than)-229(five)-229(hundred)-229(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(entertained)-250(a)-250(similar)-250(persuasion.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(Such)-449(are)-449(plain)-449(facts)-449(of)-449(history.)-847(The)-449(question)-449(now)-449(before)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(us)-389(is,)-424(how)-388(are)-389(they)-389(to)-389(be)-389(accounted)-389(for?)-667(Only)-389(three)-388(possible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alternatives)-250(present)-250(themselves.)-250(Either:)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(Some)-184(of)-184(the)-183(followers)-184(of)-184(Jesus)-184(must)-183(have)-184(fancied)-184(that)-184(they)-183(saw)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Him)-293(risen)-292(from)-293(the)-293(dead,)-303(and)-293(have)-292(communicated)-293(this)-292(delusion)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-250(the)-250(rest.)-250(Or:)]TJ 11.956 -14.162 Td [(That)-286(He)-287(did)-286(not)-287(actually)-286(die,)-296(when)-287(He)-286(was)-287(supposed)-286(to)-286(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(done)-432(so;)-522(and)-432(that)-432(His)-432(subsequent)-431(appearance,)-478(when)-431(partially)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recovered,)-250(was)-250(mistaken)-250(for)-250(a)-250(resurrection.)-250(Or:)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(That)-277(He)-277(rose)-276(from)-277(the)-277(dead)-277(in)-277(veritable)-276(reality,)-284(and)-277(was)-276(seen)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(by)-250(His)-250(followers,)-250(and)-250(conversed)-250(with)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(I)-249(omit)-249(another)-249(possible)-249(supposition,)-249(that)-249(the)-249(belief)-249(in)-249(the)-249(Res-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(urrection)-292(was)-291(due)-292(to)-292(a)-292(deliberate)-291(fraud,)-302(because)-292(no)-292(one)-291(capable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-355(appreciating)-355(moral)-356(or)-355(historical)-355(evidence)-355(ventures)-355(to)-355(affirm)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it.)-619(The)-373(idea)-373(that)-373(the)-373(greatest)-373(and)-373(purest)-373(of)-373(human)-373(institutions)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(can)-274(owe)-548(its)-274(origin)-273(to)-274(a)-274(deliberate)-274(imposture)-274(is)-274(a)-274(libel)-274(on)-273(human)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([449])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(nature.)]TJ 11.956 -14.163 Td [(Around)-328(one)-328(or)-329(other)-328(of)-328(these)-328(alternatives)-328(the)-329(contest)-328(lies.)-484(It)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(is)-344(useless)-344(to)-343(attempt)-344(to)-344(becloud)-344(the)-343(question)-344(with)-344(a)-344(number)-343(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(barren)-392(and)-393(indefinite)-392(generalities,)-428(such)-392(as)-392(myths)-392(and)-392(legends,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(vague)-299(charges)-298(of)-299(enthusiasm,)-310(fanaticism,)-311(and)-298(credulity,)-311(or)-298(gen-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eral)-223(assertions)-223(of)-223(developments)-223(brought)-223(about)-223(by)-223(a)-223(succession)-222(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(compromises)-332(between)-331(hostile)-332(parties.)-495(We)-331(are)-332(here)-331(in)-332(the)-331(pres-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ence)-308(of)-308(stern)-308(historical)-308(facts,)-322(which)-308(require)-308(a)-308(clear)-308(and)-307(definite)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1823 0 obj <<
/Length 4876      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(394)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(solution.)-585(The)-361(Christian)-362(Church)-362(exists)-361(as)-362(a)-361(fact.)-585(We)-362(can)-361(trace)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-321(up)-322(to)-321(its)-321(first)-322(origin.)-464(It)-321(asserts)-321(that)-322(its)-321(existence)-321(is)-322(due)-321(to)-321(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Resurrection)-283(of)-282(Jesus)-283(Christ,)-290(and)-283(to)-283(nothing)-282(else.)-348(If)-282(unbelievers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirm)-280(that)-280(the)-280(fact)-281(is)-280(false,)-288(they)-280(are)-280(bound)-280(to)-280(offer)-280(some)-280(theory)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-340(is)-339(true)-340(to)-340(human)-340(nature,)-362(and)-339(lies)-340(within)-340(the)-339(possibilities)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-281(things,)-290(to)-281(show)-281(us)-282(how)-281(this)-282(belief)-281(originated,)-289(and)-282(how)-281(it)-281(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(able)-250(to)-250(consolidate)-250(the)-250(life)-250(of)-250(this)-250(new)-250(community.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-397(idea)-397(that)-397(the)-396(greatest)-397(moral)-397(power)-397(which)-397(has)-397(ever)-396(ap-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(peared)-317(among)-318(mankind)-317(has)-317(had)-318(no)-317(other)-317(origin)-318(than)-317(a)-317(baseless)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(delusion)-368(is)-367(supremely)-368(melancholy.)-603(That)-368(Christianity)-368(has)-367(been)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(such)-251(a)-250(moral)-251(power)-250(will)-251(be)-251(disputed)-250(by)-251(few;)-251(and)-250(a)-251(large)-250(number)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-334(unbelievers)-334(will)-333(allow)-334(that)-334(notwithstanding)-334(the)-334(faults)-333(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-334(attribute)-335(to)-334(it,)-355(nothing)-335(has)-334(equally)-334(contributed)-335(to)-334(the)-334(civi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lization)-267(and)-267(elevation)-266(of)-267(the)-267(race.)-300(Yet)-267(if)-267(it)-266(be)-267(a)-267(delusion,)-271(it)-266(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-245(recognised)-246(as)-245(such,)-247(and)-245(we)-246(must)-245(submit)-246(to)-245(our)-246(hard)-245(fate.)-248(Still)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-339(is)-340(a)-339(terrible)-339(proposition)-339(to)-340(realize,)-361(that)-340(the)-339(noblest)-339(of)-339(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(institutions)-330(has)-329(originated)-330(in)-330(a)-330(lie,)-349(even)-330(if)-330(it)-329(be)-330(one)-330(which)-329(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-250(deliberately)-250(intended)-250(as)-250(such.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-308(is)-308(evident)-308(that)-307(however)-308(great)-308(may)-308(be)-308(the)-308(general)-307(credulity)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-220(mankind,)-226(it)-220(is)-220(a)-220(very)-220(difficult)-220(matter)-220(to)-220(get)-220(any)-220(number)-220(of)-220(men)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-308(accept)-309(as)-308(a)-308(fact)-309(the)-308(assertion)-617(that)-308(a)-308(person)-309(who)-308(has)-308(actually)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([450])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(died)-362(has)-361(returned)-362(again)-361(to)-362(bodil)1(y)-362(life.)-584(Such)-362(a)-361(belief)-362(will)-361(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-321(effected)-321(by)-320(the)-321(production)-321(of)-320(evidence)-321(which,)-339(if)-320(not)-321(true,)-338(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-416(all)-416(events)-416(in)-416(the)-416(highest)-417(degree)-416(plausible.)-748(This,)-457(as)-417(I)-415(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(already)-299(observed,)-312(is)-299(fully)-300(established)-299(by)-299(the)-300(history)-299(of)-299(the)-299(past,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-279(however)-279(numerous)-280(the)-279(narratives)-279(of)-279(marvellous)-279(occurrences)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(may)-207(be,)-216(whether)-207(in)-207(histories)-207(or)-207(fictions,)-216(it)-207(is)-207(next)-207(to)-207(impossible)-207(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(find)-276(reports)-276(of)-276(beliefs)-276(in)-276(the)-276(actual)-276(occurrence)-276(of)-276(a)-276(resurrection,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-391(even)-392(in)-391(the)-392(possibility)-391(of)-392(one)-391(prior)-392(to)-391(that)-392(of)-391(Jesus)-391(Christ.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Now)-284(St.)-352(Paul's)-284(conversion)-284(cannot)-284(be)-284(dated)-284(later)-284(than)-284(within)-284(ten)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(years)-288(of)-287(the)-288(crucifixion;)-306(most)-288(probably)-287(it)-288(was)-288(earlier.)-362(It)-288(is)-287(clear)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that,)-348(prior)-329(to)-329(his)-329(conversion,)-348(communities)-329(of)-329(Jewish)-328(Christians)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(must)-354(have)-354(existed)-354(in)-354(considerable)-354(numbers)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 193.217 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.91 0 Td [(in)-354(such)-354(numbers,)]TJ -204.127 -13.549 Td [(in)-255(fact,)-256(as)-255(to)-255(raise)-255(his)-254(wrath)-255(and)-255(indignation)-255(to)-255(the)-255(highest)-254(point.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1827 0 obj <<
/Length 4711      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(395)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(The)-336(spirit)-336(of)-335(persecution)-336(is)-336(aroused)-336(by)-336(a)-336(sense)-335(of)-336(danger.)-508(It)-335(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(clear,)-234(therefore,)-235(from)-230(the)-230(fact)-231(of)-230(the)-230(persecution,)-235(that)-230(the)-230(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-419(power)-418(saw)-419(danger)-419(from)-418(the)-419(progress)-419(of)-418(the)-419(new)-419(sect,)-460(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-324(its)-324(numbers)-324(most)-324(have)-324(been)-324(considerable.)-472(From)-324(St.)-472(Paul's)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(testimony,)-328(it)-313(is)-313(also)-312(certain)-313(that)-313(Christianity)-312(had)-313(spread)-313(at)-312(least)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-237(one)-238(place)-237(beyond)-237(Jud\346a.)-246(The)-237(inference,)-240(therefore,)-240(seems)-237(irre-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sistible)-272(that)-273(in)-272(the)-272(period)-272(which)-273(elapsed)-272(between)-272(the)-272(crucifixion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-394(St.)-684(Paul's)-394(conversion,)-431(the)-394(number)-395(of)-394(the)-395(believers)-394(in)-394(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Resurrection)-236(of)-236(Jesus)-236(had)-236(increased)-235(to)-236(several)-236(thousands.)-245(Those,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(therefore,)-341(against)-322(whom)-323(I)-323(am)-322(reasoning,)-341(cannot)-323(help)-322(admitting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-322(an)-322(interval)-322(of)-322(eight)-322(or)-322(ten)-322(years)-322(is)-322(a)-322(very)-322(short)-322(one)-322(for)-321(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conversion)-255(of)-256(such)-255(a)-255(large)-255(number)-256(of)-255(persons)-255(to)-256(the)-255(belief)-255(that)-255(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-305(who)-305(had)-305(been)-305(publicly)-304(executed,)-319(in)-305(the)-305(very)-305(city)-305(in)-304(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(many)-250(of)-250(them)-250(lived,)-250(had)-250(been)-250(restored)-250(to)-250(life.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-235(is)-236(impossible)-235(that)-235(this)-236(belief)-235(could)-235(have)-236(been)-235(entertained)-235(by)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(only)-339(a)-339(few)-339(solitary)-338(individuals)-339(who)-678(treasured)-339(it)-339(up)-339(secretly)-338(in)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([451])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(their)-300(bosoms.)-402(On)-300(the)-300(contrary,)-313(the)-301(conditions)-300(of)-301(the)-300(case)-300(prove)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-248(it)-248(must)-249(have)-248(spread)-248(rapidly.)-249(It)-249(was)-248(not)-248(sufficient)-248(for)-248(the)-248(cre-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ation)-234(of)-234(the)-234(Church)-233(that)-234(a)-234(few)-234(solitary)-234(enthusiasts)-234(should)-233(believe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-320(their)-320(Master)-319(was)-320(risen)-320(from)-320(the)-320(dead,)-337(but)-320(it)-320(was)-319(necessary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-256(the)-255(Society,)-257(which)-256(Jesus)-256(had)-255(formed)-256(in)-256(his)-255(life-time,)-257(should)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-453(immediately)-452(reorganized)-453(on)-452(the)-453(basis)-453(of)-452(this)-453(belief.)-857(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(belief)-309(in)-309(the)-309(Messiahship)-309(of)-309(Jesus)-309(constituted)-309(the)-309(original)-309(bond)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-213(union.)-238(A)-213(dead)-214(Messiah)-213(was,)-221(in)-213(the)-213(eyes)-214(of)-213(a)-213(Jew,)-221(an)-213(absurdity;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(still)-208(more)-207(so)-208(one)-207(who)-208(had)-207(been)-208(publicly)-208(cruci)1(fied.)-236(With)-208(the)-207(death)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-251(Jesus,)-250(therefore,)-251(the)-250(bond)-251(of)-250(union)-251(among)-250(His)-251(followers)-250(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-211(been)-210(severed.)-237(Unless)-210(the)-211(Church)-210(was)-211(to)-210(perish)-211(in)-210(His)-210(grave,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-359(was)-358(absolutely)-359(necessary)-359(that)-359(it)-358(should)-359(be)-359(re-constructed)-358(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-415(basis)-415(of)-415(His)-415(renewed)-414(life.)-745(The)-415(slowness)-415(with)-415(which)-414(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(large)-299(number)-299(of)-299(even)-298(credulous)-299(people)-299(will)-299(accept)-299(the)-299(fact)-299(of)-298(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(resurrection)-353(from)-353(the)-354(dead,)-379(must)-353(have)-353(formed)-353(an)-353(obstacle,)-379(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(force)-345(of)-346(which)-345(it)-346(is)-345(impossible)-345(to)-346(over-estimate.)-536(Yet)-345(the)-345(work)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-459(done,)-510(and,)-511(within)-459(a)-459(period)-458(of)-459(seven)-458(or)-459(eight)-459(years,)-510(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belief)-234(had)-234(spread)-234(so)-234(widely)-234(that)-234(its)-234(adherents)-234(could)-234(be)-234(numbered)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1831 0 obj <<
/Length 4591      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(396)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(by)-416(thousands.)-748(The)-416(truth)-415(of)-416(the)-416(Resurrection,)-458(founded)-416(on)-415(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(direct)-340(testimony)-341(of)-340(a)-340(considerable)-340(number)-341(of)-340(persons)-340(who)-340(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-334(sufficient)-334(opportunity)-334(of)-333(testing)-334(it)-334(by)-334(the)-334(evidence)-334(of)-333(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(senses,)-242(would)-240(fully)-239(account)-240(for)-240(the)-240(rapid)-240(growth)-239(of)-240(the)-240(belief.)-246(If,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(however,)-254(it)-253(originated)-254(in)-253(the)-253(brain)-253(of)-253(one)-254(or)-253(two)-253(crazed)-253(fanatics,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-434(the)-434(belief)-434(of)-434(so)-434(prodigious)-434(an)-434(event)-434(could)-434(propagate)-433(itself)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-335(all,)-356(a)-335(considerable)-335(interval)-335(of)-335(time)-335(was)-335(absolutely)-334(necessary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-319(its)-319(doing)-318(so.)-457(The)-319(memory)-318(of)-319(the)-319(Crucifixion)-319(was)-319(fresh)-318(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recent.)-404(What)-302(would)-301(have)-301(been)-302(the)-301(natural)-302(effect)-301(of)-301(announcing)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-408(fact)-408(of)-408(His)-409(Resurrecti)1(on?)-725(Incredulity!)-724(What)-408(has)-408(become)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-351(His)-351(body?)-553(Why)-351(does)-351(He)-351(not)-351(appear)-351(to)-351(His)-351(former)-351(friends?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-476(strangeness)-238(of)-238(the)-238(event)-238(must)-238(have)-238(prompted)-238(even)-238(the)-237(most)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([452])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(credulous)-208(to)-208(make)-208(some)-208(inquiry)-208(about)-208(the)-208(matter,)-216(and)-208(the)-208(inquiry)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-437(have)-437(dissipated)-438(the)-437(delusion.)-812(Such)-437(a)-437(belief)-437(could)-437(only)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(readily)-373(propagate)-372(itself)-373(after)-372(recent)-373(memories)-372(had)-373(grown)-372(dim,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-199(a)-199(long)-200(interval)-199(of)-199(time)-199(had)-199(elapsed,)-210(sufficient)-199(for)-199(the)-199(Founder)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-328(Christianity)-327(to)-328(become)-328(surrounded)-328(with)-327(a)-328(halo)-328(of)-327(imaginary)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(glory.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Let)-380(us)-379(now)-380(consider)-380(the)-380(position)-379(in)-380(which)-380(the)-380(followers)-379(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-412(must)-411(have)-412(found)-411(themselves)-412(on)-411(the)-412(night)-411(of)-412(the)-411(Cruci-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fixion,)-445(and)-406(during)-406(the)-406(following)-406(days.)-718(Their)-406(hopes)-406(had)-406(been)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(based)-280(on)-280(Him)-280(as)-279(the)-280(Messiah,)-287(who)-280(was)-280(to)-280(reign)-280(in)-280(the)-279(kingdom)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(promised)-362(by)-362(the)-361(prophets;)-418(and)-362(they)-362(expected)-362(important)-361(places)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-419(that)-420(kingdom)-419(as)-420(the)-419(reward)-420(of)-419(their)-420(fidelity.)-758(These)-419(hopes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-315(have)-314(been)-315(annihilated.)-443(The)-315(Messiah)-314(whom)-315(they)-314(expected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-288(reign)-288(had)-289(perished)-288(at)-288(the)-288(hands)-288(of)-288(His)-289(enemies.)-364(What)-288(was)-288(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-338(hoped)-338(for)-338(more?)-514(Many)-338(could)-338(not)-338(help)-338(thinking)-338(that)-338(he)-338(had)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-314(a)-314(self-deceiver,)-331(if)-314(not)-314(an)-314(impostor.)-443(Was)-314(there)-314(any)-314(ground)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-298(hoping)-298(that)-299(He)-298(could)-298(be)-298(raised)-298(from)-298(the)-299(dead?)-394(Many)-298(of)-298(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prophets)-290(of)-289(the)-290(ancient)-289(Church)-290(had)-289(perished)-290(by)-289(the)-290(authority)-289(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(former)-220(governments,)-227(or)-220(by)-221(the)-220(violence)-221(of)-220(the)-220(mob.)-241(But)-220(God)-220(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(never)-263(interfered)-264(to)-263(vindicate)-264(the)-263(cause)-263(of)-264(one)-263(of)-264(them)-263(by)-263(raising)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(him)-344(from)-343(the)-344(dead.)-531(The)-344(utmost)-343(that)-344(He)-344(had)-343(done)-344(was)-344(to)-343(raise)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(up)-300(some)-300(new)-300(prophet)-300(to)-300(take)-300(his)-300(place.)-400(But)-300(this)-300(man)-300(was)-299(more)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1835 0 obj <<
/Length 4621      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(397)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(than)-224(a)-223(prophet)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 61.836 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(he)-224(was)-223(the)-224(Messiah.)-241(Did)-224(not)-223(all)-224(the)-224(old)-223(prophets)]TJ -72.745 -13.549 Td [(promise)-265(Him)-266(a)-265(kingdom)-265(and)-265(a)-266(glory)-265(and)-265(a)-265(mighty)-266(triumph?)-295(Yet)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-275(had)-276(been)-275(cut)-275(off)-275(by)-276(His)-275(enemies,)-282(instead)-275(of)-275(triumphing)-275(over)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them;)-328(and)-302(His)-302(dead)-302(body)-302(was)-302(silent)-302(in)-302(the)-302(grave.)-406(Any)-302(hint)-302(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-253(Gospels)-253(allege)-253(Jesus)-253(to)-253(have)-253(given)-253(His)-253(followers)-253(of)-253(His)-253(own)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Resurrection)-362(is,)-389(according)-362(to)-362(the)-361(theory)-362(of)-362(those)-361(with)-362(whom)-361(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(am)-338(reasoning,)-359(a)-338(late)-338(invention.)-513(On)-338(the)-675(days,)-360(therefore,)-359(which)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([453])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.023 -13.549 Td [(followed)-375(the)-375(Crucifixion,)-407(the)-375(Church)-376(must)-375(have)-375(presented)-375(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(stillness)-427(of)-426(death,)-471(broken)-427(only)-427(by)-426(a)-427(few)-427(utterances)-427(of)-426(loving)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(despair.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(But)-425(the)-424(Church)-425(did)-425(not)-425(perish;)-512(it)-425(set)-424(itself)-425(to)-425(the)-425(work)-424(of)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(reconstruction.)-322(It)-274(expanded)-275(and)-274(grew.)-322(Within)-274(the)-274(space)-274(of)-274(eight)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(years)-463(after)-463(the)-463(Crucifixion,)-516(the)-463(believers)-463(in)-463(the)-463(Resurrection)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(could)-344(be)-344(numbered)-344(by)-343(thousands.)-532(This)-344(is)-344(an)-344(indisputable)-343(fact.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Again)-330(it)-329(expanded)-330(and)-330(grew,)-349(and)-330(it)-330(never)-329(ceased)-330(to)-330(grow)-329(until)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-283(less)-284(than)-283(three)-284(hundred)-283(years)-284(after)-283(the)-284(public)-283(execution)-284(of)-283(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Founder)-334(by)-335(the)-334(authority)-335(of)-334(the)-335(Roman)-334(government,)-356(one)-334(of)-334(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(professed)-308(adherents)-308(mounted)-308(the)-308(imperial)-308(throne,)-322(and)-308(found)-308(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(strength)-212(sufficient)-213(to)-212(enable)-213(him)-212(to)-212(make)-213(it)-212(one)-213(of)-212(the)-212(institutions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-312(the)-311(State.)-435(These)-311(facts)-312(are)-311(without)-312(a)-312(parallel)-311(in)-312(history.)-434(How)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-348(they)-348(to)-348(be)-348(accounted)-348(for?)-544(The)-348(followers)-348(of)-348(Jesus)-348(affirmed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-311(their)-311(Master)-311(rose)-311(from)-311(the)-311(dead;)-341(and)-311(that)-311(He)-311(thus)-311(resumed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-242(place)-243(as)-243(the)-242(Messiah)-243(of)-242(His)-243(Church.)-247(Unbelievers,)-244(in)-243(the)-242(face)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-384(the)-384(evidence)-384(before)-384(us,)-418(cannot)-384(deny)-384(that)-384(the)-384(great)-384(body)-384(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-238(followers)-238(must)-238(have)-237(believed)-238(that)-238(He)-238(had)-238(done)-238(so)-238(within)-237(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(short)-336(interval)-336(of)-337(a)-336(few)-336(months)-336(after)-336(His)-337(public)-336(execution.)-508(Our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(documents)-356(on)-357(this)-356(point)-357(are)-356(distinct)-357(and)-356(definite.)-570(They)-356(affirm)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-273(He)-274(was)-274(not)-273(only)-274(seen)-273(but)-274(handled)-273(by)-274(many)-273(of)-274(His)-273(disciples)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(after)-287(His)-287(Resurrection,)-296(that)-286(He)-287(ate)-287(with)-287(them,)-296(and)-287(that)-287(they)-286(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interviews)-331(with)-331(Him)-331(individually)-330(and)-331(collectively.)-493(I)-331(must)-330(now)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(examine)-374(the)-375(alternative)-374(positions;)-436(and)-374(first,)-406(that)-374(His)-374(supposed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(appearances)-250(were)-250(delusions)-250(of)-250(the)-250(imagination.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(The)-252(loose)-253(and)-252(general)-252(affirmation)-253(has)-252(been)-252(made)-253(that)-252(the)-253(fol)1(-)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(lowers)-245(of)-245(Jesus)-245(were)-245(so)-245(enthusiastically)-245(attached)-245(to)-245(Him)-245(that)-245(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1839 0 obj <<
/Length 4734      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(398)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(idea)-214(of)-214(His)-213(death)-214(was)-214(simply)-214(unbearable,)-221(and)-214(that)-214(they)-213(attempted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-368(get)-368(rid)-368(of)-368(the)-368(fact)-368(by)-368(supposing)-368(that)-368(He)-368(had)-368(risen)-368(from)-367(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dead.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([454])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 84.711 -16.004 Td [(I)-212(reply)-211(first:)-231(that)-212(all)-212(such)-211(general)-212(statements)-212(are)-211(worthless.)-237(We)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(have)-341(specific)-341(facts)-341(before)-341(us;)-386(and)-341(these)-341(can)-341(only)-341(be)-340(accounted)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(for)-215(by)-216(facts)-215(which)-215(are)-216(equally)-215(definite,)-222(and)-215(not)-216(mere)-215(fancies.)-238(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assertion)-339(before)-340(me)-339(is)-339(not)-340(only)-339(a)-339(bare)-340(supposition)-339(without)-339(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(atom)-334(of)-335(evidence)-334(to)-335(rest)-334(upon,)-355(but)-335(it)-334(contradicts)-335(all)-334(the)-334(known)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(facts)-294(of)-294(the)-294(case.)-381(So)-294(far)-294(is)-294(it)-294(from)-294(having)-294(been)-294(the)-294(case)-294(that)-293(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disciples)-275(were)-275(in)-275(such)-275(a)-275(state)-275(of)-274(enthusiastic)-275(exultation,)-282(that)-274(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(own)-373(documents)-372(inform)-373(us)-373(that)-372(they)-373(had)-373(fallen)-372(into)-373(the)-372(lowest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(state)-250(of)-250(despondency.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-348(further:)-446(when)-348(a)-348(theory)-348(is)-348(propounded)-348(to)-348(account)-348(for)-347(an)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(historical)-394(fact,)-431(the)-394(possibility)-395(of)-394(the)-394(supposition)-395(must)-394(be)-394(sup-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ported)-310(by)-310(some)-309(analogous)-310(cases)-310(in)-310(the)-309(history)-310(of)-310(man,)-325(more)-309(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(less)-280(resembling)-281(it.)-341(All)-281(theories)-280(which)-281(are)-280(devoid)-281(of)-280(this)-280(support)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-338(worthless)-337(as)-338(history.)-513(Let)-337(those,)-360(therefore,)-359(who)-338(would)-337(urge)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-255(on)-256(our)-255(acceptance)-256(as)-255(an)-255(account)-256(of)-255(the)-255(origin)-256(of)-255(the)-255(greatest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(event)-280(in)-280(history,)-288(show)-280(that)-279(something)-280(like)-280(it)-280(has)-280(occurred)-280(in)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(records)-280(of)-280(the)-280(past.)-341(Let)-280(them)-280(show)-280(us)-280(one)-280(instance)-280(of)-280(a)-280(body)-280(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(men)-199(whose)-200(enthusiasm)-199(for)-199(their)-200(leader)-199(was)-199(so)-199(great)-200(that,)-209(when)-199(he)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(had)-288(been)-287(put)-288(to)-287(death)-288(by)-287(the)-288(authority)-287(of)-288(the)-287(government)-288(of)-287(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(country,)-337(they)-320(got)-320(over)-319(this)-320(by)-320(fancying)-320(that)-319(he)-320(had)-320(been)-319(raised)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-357(the)-356(dead,)-384(and)-356(then)-357(took)-356(to)-357(persuading)-357(others)-356(of)-357(its)-356(truth.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-284(enthusiasm)-284(of)-284(followers)-284(for)-284(their)-284(leaders)-284(has)-284(urged)-284(them)-284(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(form)-310(plots,)-325(and)-309(even)-310(to)-310(make)-310(attempts)-309(to)-310(rescue)-310(them)-310(from)-309(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hands)-309(of)-308(their)-308(enemies.)-426(Such)-308(enthusiasm,)-323(however,)-324(is)-308(not)-308(even)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(hinted)-356(at)-355(in)-356(the)-355(case)-356(of)-355(the)-356(disciples)-355(of)-356(Christ.)-566(No)-356(whisper)-355(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tradition)-257(has)-258(reached)-257(us)-258(that)-257(any)-257(of)-258(them)-257(formed)-257(a)-258(plot,)-259(or)-257(made)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-272(solitary)-272(attempt)-272(to)-272(rescue)-272(their)-272(Master.)-316(Are)-272(we)-272(then)-271(to)-272(believe)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-390(they)-389(imagined)-390(a)-390(resurrection)-389(to)-390(repair)-390(the)-389(damage)-390(of)-389(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Crucifixion?)-299(Such)-266(imaginative)-266(conceits)-266(would)-266(never)-266(have)-266(made)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-308(single)-308(convert)-308(to)-308(their)-308(story.)-424(They)-308(left)-616(their)-308(Master)-308(to)-307(perish)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([455])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(in)-298(His)-298(agony,)-311(and)-298(when)-298(He)-298(had)-298(expired)-299(under)-298(the)-298(hands)-298(of)-298(His)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1844 0 obj <<
/Length 4556      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(399)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(executioners,)-274(restored)-270(Him)-270(to)-269(an)-270(ideal)-269(life)-270(by)-269(imagining)-270(that)-269(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-285(risen)-285(from)-286(the)-285(dead.)-355(Such)-286(fictions)-285(may)-285(be)-285(safely)-285(dismissed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-250(further)-250(notice.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Secondly:)-681(Let)-466(us)-466(suppose)-466(that)-465(some)-466(one)-466(of)-466(His)-466(di)1(sciples)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(thought)-352(that)-353(he)-352(actually)-353(saw)-352(Him,)-378(and)-352(in)-353(the)-352(height)-353(of)-352(his)-352(en-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thusiasm)-298(converted)-299(a)-298(fancy)-299(into)-298(a)-299(fact;)-322(and)-299(persuaded)-298(the)-298(other)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(disciples)-250(that)-251(He)-250(was)-251(risen)-250(from)-250(the)-251(dead:)-251(that)-250(these)-251(too,)-250(in)-250(turn,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-399(wrought)-400(up)-399(into)-400(so)-399(high)-399(a)-400(state)-399(of)-400(enthusiasm)-399(that)-399(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(likewise)-300(fancied)-299(that)-300(they)-299(saw)-300(Him:)-349(thus)-300(the)-299(delusion)-300(spread.)-398(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reply:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 25.451 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -13.495 -15.186 Td [(First:)-348(As)-299(I)-299(have)-299(already)-299(observed,)-311(we)-299(are)-299(entitled)-299(to)-298(demand)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-334(some)-335(analogous)-334(case)-334(should)-334(be)-334(adduced)-335(before)-334(we)-334(can)-334(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rationally)-314(asked)-313(to)-314(accept)-314(such)-313(theories)-314(as)-314(to)-313(the)-314(solution)-314(of)-313(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unquestionable)-321(historical)-321(fact.)-463(Surely,)-339(if)-321(such)-321(are)-321(the)-321(workings)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-297(human)-297(nature)-298(under)-297(influences)-297(so)-297(general)-297(as)-297(enthusiasm)-297(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(credulity,)-264(some)-260(similar)-261(occurrence)-261(must)-261(be)-261(no)-261(uncommon)-260(event)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(history.)-250(Let)-250(one)-250(therefore)-250(be)-250(adduced.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Secondly:)-437(Nothing)-344(is)-344(easier)-344(to)-343(affirm)-344(than)-344(that)-344(some)-343(credu-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(lous)-367(and)-367(enthusiastic)-367(follower)-368(of)-367(Jesus)-367(mistook)-367(a)-367(fancy)-367(of)-367(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(imagination)-311(for)-311(a)-311(fact,)-326(thought)-311(that)-311(he)-311(had)-311(seen)-310(Him)-311(alive,)-326(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(communicated)-256(his)-255(enthusiasm)-256(to)-255(the)-256(rest.)-267(Whatever)-255(may)-256(be)-255(said)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-181(to)-181(the)-181(possibility)-182(in)-181(fits)-181(of)-181(enthusiasm)-181(of)-181(a)-181(few)-181(half-crazy)-181(fanat-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ics)-204(mistaking)-204(fancies)-205(for)-204(facts,)-213(it)-204(is)-205(clear)-204(that)-204(to)-204(communicate)-204(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enthusiasm)-355(to)-355(others)-355(is)-355(a)-355(very)-355(difficult)-355(undertaking,)-381(especially)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-336(they)-336(are)-336(in)-336(a)-336(depressed)-336(state)-336(of)-336(mind.)-508(As)-336(I)-336(have)-335(already)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(shown,)-315(it)-303(is)-302(in)-302(the)-302(highest)-302(degree)-303(difficult,)-315(if)-302(not)-302(impossible,)-315(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(persuade)-372(even)-371(very)-372(credulous)-371(persons)-372(of)-372(the)-371(occurrence)-372(of)-371(an)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(actual)-275(resurrection,)-281(as)-275(all)-275(history)-275(and)-275(fiction)-275(prior)-275(to)-275(the)-275(Advent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testify.)-248(A)-243(case)-243(of)-244(a)-243(person)-243(who)-244(professed)-243(to)-487(have)-243(seen,)-244(touched,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([456])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(conversed,)-307(and)-295(eaten)-295(with)-295(one)-295(who)-295(was)-296(raised)-295(from)-295(the)-295(dead)-295(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-293(on)-293(record.)-380(The)-293(belief)-293(in)-294(ghost)-293(stories)-293(and)-293(apparitions)-293(of)-293(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(departed)-260(is)-261(to)-260(be)-261(met)-260(with)-261(at)-260(every)-261(turn.)-281(Sorcery)-261(professed)-260(to)-260(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(able)-286(to)-286(bring)-286(departed)-285(spirits)-286(from)-286(the)-286(under-world,)-295(but)-286(it)-285(never)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attempted)-250(to)-250(restore)-250(to)-250(life)-250(a)-250(body)-250(which)-250(once)-250(was)-250(dead.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1849 0 obj <<
/Length 4842      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(400)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(Between)-447(these)-446(two)-447(classes)-446(of)-447(facts)-447(the)-446(distinction)-447(is)-446(most)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(important.)-360(The)-287(enthusiasm)-287(or)-286(credulity)-287(which)-287(easily)-287(creates)-286(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-265(belief,)-270(refuses)-265(to)-266(accept)-265(the)-265(other.)-297(What)-265(we)-266(have)-265(to)-265(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-361(in)-362(this)-361(case)-362(is,)-389(not)-362(that)-361(some)-362(imaginative)-361(follower)-361(thought)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-423(he)-424(had)-423(seen)-424(the)-423(spirit)-424(of)-423(the)-424(crucified)-423(Jesus,)-467(come)-423(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-281(under-world)-280(to)-281(make)-281(a)-280(communication)-281(to)-281(his)-280(followers,)-288(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-287(the)-287(other)-286(disciples)-287(credulously)-287(accepted)-286(the)-287(report:)-324(but)-286(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-401(appearance)-401(was)-400(that)-401(of)-401(his)-400(body)-401(restored)-401(to)-401(the)-400(functions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-341(animal)-340(life)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 60.755 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.91 0 Td [(in)-341(one)-340(word,)-363(a)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 69.339 0 Td [(Resurrection)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 56.356 0 Td [(,)-363(able)-341(to)-340(repair)-341(the)]TJ -197.36 -13.55 Td [(damage)-250(which)-250(had)-250(been)-250(occasioned)-250(by)-250(his)-250(Crucifixion.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-280(for)-279(the)-280(purpose)-280(of)-280(arguing)-279(the)-280(question)-280(we)-280(must)-279(suppose)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-273(some)-273(one)-273(of)-272(the)-273(enthusiastic)-273(followers)-273(of)-273(Jesus)-273(fancied)-272(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-337(saw)-337(Him)-336(after)-337(His)-337(death,)-359(and)-336(mistook)-337(that)-337(fancy)-337(for)-337(a)-336(fact.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-380(own)-380(that)-380(it)-380(is)-381(very)-380(difficult)-380(even)-380(to)-380(assume)-380(the)-380(existence)-380(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enthusiasm)-197(in)-197(the)-197(present)-197(instance,)-207(because)-197(all)-197(the)-197(known)-197(facts)-196(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(well)-206(as)-207(the)-206(conditions)-206(of)-206(the)-206(case)-207(prove)-206(that)-206(whatever)-206(enthusiasm)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-260(once)-260(existed,)-263(it)-260(was)-261(at)-260(a)-260(very)-260(low)-260(ebb)-261(on)-260(the)-260(morning)-260(of)-260(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(supposed)-315(Resurrection.)-444(Still,)-331(however,)-330(the)-315(assumption)-315(must)-314(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made,)-256(or)-255(argument)-255(will)-255(be)-255(impossible.)-264(As)-255(one)-255(enthusiast)-255(will)-254(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-340(good)-340(as)-340(another,)-362(let)-340(us)-340(assume)-340(that)-340(our)-340(supposed)-339(enthusiast)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-353(Mary)-353(Magdalene,)-379(who)-354(went)-353(early)-353(to)-353(the)-353(sepulchre,)-379(found)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-316(stone)-315(gone,)-332(saw)-315(the)-316(gardener)-316(in)-315(the)-316(dim)-315(light,)-332(mistook)-315(him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-325(Jesus,)-345(and)-325(went)-325(and)-326(told)-325(her)-326(friends)-325(that)-325(she)-326(had)-325(seen)-325(Him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(risen)-360(from)-359(the)-360(dead:)-469(or)-719(to)-360(put)-359(the)-360(case)-359(more)-360(simply,)-387(that)-359(her)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([457])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(excited)-353(brain)-353(created)-353(some)-353(spectral)-353(illusion;)-404(and)-353(that)-353(under)-353(its)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(influence)-225(she)-226(thought)-225(she)-225(saw)-225(Him,)-230(and)-226(proceeded)-225(to)-225(convey)-225(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(report)-250(to)-250(her)-250(friends.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-204(at)-204(once)-204(strikes)-204(us)-204(as)-204(most)-203(unaccountable)-204(that,)-214(enthusiastic)-203(as)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(she)-210(must)-211(have)-210(been,)-219(she)-210(did)-211(not)-210(do)-211(something)-210(to)-211(assure)-210(herself)-210(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-239(reality)-238(of)-239(the)-238(bodily)-239(presence)-238(of)-239(her)-239(Master.)-246(It)-238(was)-239(hard)-238(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-350(an)-349(enthusiast)-350(to)-350(believe)-349(that)-350(it)-350(was)-349(He.)-549(If)-350(she)-350(had)-349(spoken,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-326(it)-325(was)-326(the)-326(gardener,)-344(she)-326(would)-325(have)-326(been)-326(at)-325(once)-326(cured)-325(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(her)-349(delusion.)-546(If)-349(she)-349(had)-349(attempted)-348(to)-349(embrace)-349(Him)-349(and)-349(it)-348(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-347(a)-347(phantom,)-371(the)-347(same)-346(result)-347(would)-347(have)-347(followed.)-540(Surely)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1853 0 obj <<
/Length 4873      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(401)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(the)-443(intensity)-443(of)-443(her)-443(love,)-491(however)-443(credulous)-443(or)-443(fanatical)-443(she)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(might)-295(be,)-306(would)-295(not)-295(have)-294(allowed)-295(her)-295(to)-295(leave)-295(the)-295(spot)-294(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(some)-386(suitable)-387(demonstration.)-659(Equally)-387(incredible)-386(is)-387(it)-386(that)-386(she)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-292(have)-293(left)-292(Him,)-303(without)-293(inquiring)-292(whither)-293(He)-292(intended)-292(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(betake)-225(Himself,)-231(or)-225(obtaining)-226(the)-225(promise)-225(of)-226(some)-225(future)-225(meeting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-453(which)-454(His)-453(disconcerted)-454(friends)-453(might)-454(see)-453(Him.)-860(However)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enthusiastic)-389(she)-388(may)-389(have)-388(been,)-424(it)-388(is)-389(simply)-388(untrue)-389(to)-388(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature,)-254(that)-253(she)-254(should)-253(have)-253(thought)-253(that)-254(her)-253(much)-253(loved)-253(Master)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-251(appeared)-250(to)-251(her)-250(in)-251(bodily)-250(reality,)-251(and)-251(that)-250(she)-251(should)-250(neither)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-248(spoken)-247(to)-248(Him,)-248(touched)-248(Him,)-248(nor)-247(endeavoured)-248(to)-247(ascertain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-313(place)-313(of)-313(His)-313(proposed)-313(retreat,)-329(nor)-313(what)-313(His)-313(intentions)-313(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(about)-332(the)-333(future.)-496(If)-333(she)-332(had)-332(done)-333(any)-332(of)-332(these)-332(things,)-353(it)-332(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-250(dissipated)-250(her)-250(delusions.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Let)-191(us)-192(suppose,)-203(however,)-203(that)-191(all)-191(these)-192(difficulties)-191(do)-191(not)-192(exist,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(and)-201(that)-201(she)-202(is)-201(gone)-201(to)-201(publish)-201(among)-202(the)-201(friends)-201(of)-201(Jesus)-201(that)-201(she)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-243(seen)-244(Him)-243(risen)-243(from)-243(the)-243(dead.)-248(His)-243(death)-244(had)-243(proved)-243(to)-243(them)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-320(stunning)-321(blow;)-355(but)-321(let)-320(us)-321(suppose)-320(that)-320(they)-321(were)-320(still)-320(eagerly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(desirous)-211(of)-210(the)-211(occurrence)-211(of)-211(something)-210(which)-211(might)-211(renew)-210(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(old)-318(faith)-317(in)-318(their)-318(Master's)-317(Messiahship.)-453(It)-318(is)-635(clear)-318(that)-317(nothing)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([458])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(short)-192(of)-193(a)-192(belief)-192(in)-193(His)-192(resurrection)-192(could)-193(have)-192(accomplished)-192(this.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Yet)-301(however)-301(desirous)-302(they)-301(may)-301(have)-301(been)-302(of)-301(His)-301(return)-301(to)-301(life,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-183(were)-182(confronted)-183(with)-182(the)-183(stern)-183(fact)-182(that)-183(He)-182(had)-183(been)-182(publicly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(executed,)-397(and)-367(that)-367(the)-368(credulity)-367(of)-367(the)-368(past)-367(had)-367(not)-367(succeeded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-281(restoring)-281(dead)-281(men)-281(to)-281(life.)-343(Their)-281(despondency)-281(occasioned)-280(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-362(events)-361(of)-362(the)-362(last)-361(three)-362(days)-362(was)-361(extreme.)-585(Let)-362(us)-361(suppose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-276(Mary)-276(Magdalene)-275(rushes)-276(in)-276(with)-276(the)-275(announcement:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 248.55 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(I)-276(have)]TJ -253.393 -13.549 Td [(seen)-231(the)-231(Lord,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 61.694 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(the)-231(tomb)-231(is)-231(empty,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 80.601 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(He)-231(is)-231(risen)-231(from)-232(the)-231(dead.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 111.674 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.787 -13.55 Td [(However)-270(desirous)-270(they)-271(might)-270(be)-270(that)-270(the)-271(news)-270(should)-270(be)-270(true,)-275(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-239(evident)-240(that)-239(such)-239(an)-240(announcement)-239(must)-239(have)-240(filled)-239(the)-239(minds)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-357(even)-357(the)-358(most)-357(credulous)-357(with)-357(astonishment.)-572(What!)-571(not)-357(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apparition)-356(of)-357(His)-356(departed)-356(spirit,)-383(but)-357(a)-356(bodily)-356(reality,)-383(the)-356(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man)-403(himself?)-710(Is)-403(it)-403(possible)-403(that)-403(none)-403(of)-403(them)-403(suspected)-403(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-371(was)-371(the)-371(dream)-371(of)-371(an)-371(enthusiastic)-371(woman?)-613(Is)-371(it)-370(conceivable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-254(men)-253(or)-254(women,)-254(passionately)-254(attached)-254(to)-253(their)-254(Master,)-254(asked)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1857 0 obj <<
/Length 4516      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(402)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(her)-330(no)-330(questions)-331(about)-330(the)-330(interview;)-370(what)-331(He)-330(had)-330(said)-330(to)-330(her;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(where)-330(He)-329(was)-330(to)-330(be)-329(found?)-489(Some)-330(replies)-330(to)-329(these)-330(and)-329(kindred)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(questions)-460(were)-460(inevitable;)-564(and)-460(unless)-460(they)-460(were)-460(distinct)-459(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(satisfactory,)-260(the)-258(rising)-258(enthusiasm)-258(must)-258(have)-258(been)-258(checked.)-274(Is)-257(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(true)-334(to)-334(human)-334(nature)-333(that)-334(the)-334(most)-334(enthusiastic)-334(credulity)-333(could)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-280(accepted)-281(these)-280(things)-280(as)-281(facts,)-288(or)-280(that)-280(the)-281(dead)-280(Jesus)-280(could)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-211(straightway)-210(assumed)-211(His)-210(place)-210(of)-211(Messianic)-210(dignity)-211(in)-210(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(minds,)-230(if)-225(He)-225(had)-224(made)-225(no)-225(appointment)-225(where)-225(He)-225(could)-225(meet)-224(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(friends;)-413(or)-359(if)-359(that)-359(appointment)-358(was)-359(created)-359(by)-359(the)-358(imagination)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-295(the)-295(Magdalene,)-306(but)-295(when)-294(tested)-295(by)-295(the)-295(attempt)-295(to)-295(see)-294(him,)-306(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proved)-250(a)-250(delusion?)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-348(even)-349(credulity,)-373(when)-348(united)-348(with)-349(profound)-348(love)-348(and)-348(at-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(tachment)-175(to)-175(a)-176(departed)-175(friend,)-190(must)-175(have)-175(some)-175(farther)-175(satisfaction)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-344(a)-344(fancied)-344(sight.)-532(If)-344(the)-344(disciples,)-367(in)-344(the)-344(height)-344(of)-344(their)-344(en-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thusiasm,)-290(imagined)-282(that)-565(they)-282(saw)-282(Him,)-290(they)-282(surely)-282(would)-282(have)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([459])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(spoken)-308(to)-308(Him.)-425(Could)-308(they)-308(have)-309(helped)-308(embracing)-308(Him)-308(on)-308(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(return)-328(to)-328(life)-328(after)-328(His)-328(cruel)-328(sufferings)-328(and)-328(ignominious)-327(death?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Above)-293(all,)-303(what)-292(about)-293(the)-292(future?)-378(Was)-292(He)-293(going)-292(to)-293(teach)-292(again)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-232(public?)-244(Was)-231(He)-232(not)-232(going)-231(to)-232(bring)-231(confusion)-232(on)-232(His)-231(enemies?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Was)-374(He)-375(actually)-374(going)-374(to)-375(retire)-374(from)-374(public)-375(view)-374(out)-374(of)-374(their)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(way?)-317(And)-272(if)-272(He)-273(did)-272(so,)-278(what)-272(about)-272(His)-272(Messianic)-273(claims?)-316(Who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-294(to)-295(head)-294(the)-294(party)-294(for)-295(t)1(he)-295(future?)-382(Could)-295(they)-294(have)-294(no)-294(secret)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interviews)-381(with)-382(Him?)-643(If)-381(He)-382(henceforth)-381(retired)-381(into)-381(obscurity,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(what)-242(announcement)-241(were)-242(His)-241(friends)-241(to)-242(make)-241(to)-242(His)-241(opponents?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-365(most)-365(fanatical)-365(enthusiasts)-364(must)-365(have)-365(asked)-365(some)-365(of)-364(these)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(questions.)]TJ 11.956 -16.003 Td [(Either)-324(no)-325(answer)-324(was)-325(returned,)-343(and)-324(the)-325(delusions)-324(must)-324(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(been)-292(immediately)-291(dispelled;)-312(or)-292(the)-291(enthusiasm)-292(which)-291(generated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-258(phantom,)-260(and)-257(mistook)-258(it)-258(for)-258(a)-257(reality,)-260(invented)-258(an)-258(answer)-257(like-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wise.)-412(Any)-304(reply)-305(which)-304(fell)-304(short)-304(of)-304(a)-304(promise)-304(to)-304(appear)-304(for)-304(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(future)-275(at)-276(their)-275(head,)-282(and)-275(either)-275(convince)-276(or)-275(confound)-275(His)-275(adver-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(saries,)-360(must)-338(have)-338(extinguished)-338(their)-338(belief)-338(in)-338(His)-338(Messiahship.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(They)-301(either)-301(fancied)-302(they)-301(saw)-301(Him)-301(again,)-314(or)-301(they)-302(did)-301(not.)-403(If)-301(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(former)-380(was)-380(the)-380(case,)-413(they)-380(must)-380(have)-380(had)-380(repeated)-380(interviews,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1861 0 obj <<
/Length 4704      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(403)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(all)-251(created)-250(by)-250(the)-251(imagination,)-251(at)-250(which)-251(something)-250(definite)-250(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-402(been)-402(supposed)-402(to)-402(have)-402(passed)-402(sufficient)-402(to)-402(establish)-401(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belief)-253(that)-252(He)-253(was)-252(a)-253(Messiah)-253(returned)-252(to)-253(them)-252(from)-253(the)-253(grave.)-257(If)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-238(old)-239(Messiani)1(c)-239(character)-238(had)-238(ceased,)-241(some)-238(definite)-238(plan)-238(must)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-354(been)-354(propounded)-354(of)-355(the)-354(mode)-354(in)-354(which)-354(He)-354(was)-354(going)-354(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(enter)-203(on)-203(a)-202(new)-203(one.)-234(If,)-213(however,)-212(we)-202(accept)-203(the)-203(alternative)-203(that)-202(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(saw)-300(them)-299(no)-300(more,)-312(we)-300(shall)-300(possibly)-300(be)-299(told)-300(that)-300(His)-299(followers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accounted)-309(for)-309(His)-308(absence)-309(by)-309(imagining)-309(that)-308(He)-309(had)-309(for)-309(a)-308(time)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-231(taken)-231(up)-231(into)-231(heaven,)-235(whence)-231(He)-231(was)-231(shortly)-231(coming)-230(again)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-387(destroy)-388(His)-387(enemies.)-662(But)-387(in)-387(that)-387(case)-387(it)-388(must)-387(have)-387(been)-387(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cruel)-244(blow)-245(to)-244(enthusiastic)-244(love.)-248(What!)-248(their)-489(much)-244(loved)-244(Master,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([460])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(for)-295(whom)-295(they)-295(had)-295(sacrificed)-296(their)-295(all,)-306(to)-295(afford)-295(them)-295(one)-295(mute)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interview)-285(after)-284(His)-284(resurrection,)-294(immediately)-284(to)-285(go)-284(into)-284(heaven,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-369(leave)-369(them)-369(without)-369(a)-369(head,)-399(exposed)-369(to)-369(the)-369(assaults)-369(of)-369(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(opponents)-250(who)-250(had)-250(murdered)-250(Him?)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(But)-247(let)-246(us)-247(imagine)-246(all)-247(these)-247(difficulties)-246(got)-247(over,)-247(and)-247(that)-246(they)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(fancied)-209(that)-210(they)-209(caught)-210(one)-209(solitary)-209(glimpse)-210(of)-209(Him,)-218(and)-209(that)-209(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-184(taken)-184(up)-184(into)-184(heaven,)-197(whence)-184(He)-184(would)-184(come)-184(again)-184(to)-183(revive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-241(sinking)-242(cause.)-247(Was)-241(He)-241(to)-241(return)-242(in)-241(a)-241(few)-241(days,)-243(or)-241(months,)-243(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(years?)-439(If)-312(the)-313(days)-313(became)-313(months,)-328(and)-313(the)-313(months)-313(years,)-328(what)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-397(to)-397(be)-398(done)-397(with)-397(the)-397(Church)-397(in)-397(the)-398(meantime?)-691(Was)-397(it)-397(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(organize)-256(itself?)-266(If)-256(so,)-257(on)-255(what)-256(new)-256(basis?)-266(Was)-256(it)-255(to)-256(confront)-255(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(foes?)-505(Was)-334(it)-335(to)-335(make)-335(converts;)-377(or)-335(quietly)-335(to)-335(await)-335(His)-334(return?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(If)-277(the)-277(latter,)-284(as)-277(months)-278(and)-277(years)-277(passed)-277(away,)-284(the)-277(Church)-277(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-432(simply)-432(died)-432(of)-432(inanition,)-478(and)-432(we)-432(should)-432(have)-432(heard)-432(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more)-263(of)-263(Christianity.)-289(If)-263(the)-263(former)-263(hypothesis)-263(be)-263(preferred,)-266(then)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-329(is)-328(plain)-329(that)-328(His)-329(followers)-329(must)-328(have)-329(determined)-328(to)-329(start)-328(His)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Messiahship)-294(on)-293(a)-294(new)-294(basis.)-381(But)-293(what)-294(was)-294(this?)-381(How)-293(was)-294(it)-293(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-243(propounded)-242(to)-243(the)-242(world?)-248(How)-243(were)-242(His)-243(other)-242(disciples)-243(to)-242(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(persuaded)-276(to)-276(accept)-276(it?)-327(Instead)-276(of)-276(an)-276(earthly,)-282(the)-276(Church)-276(for)-275(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(future)-270(must)-269(be)-270(headed)-270(by)-269(a)-270(heavenly)-270(Messiah,)-274(who)-270(was)-269(coming)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-234(some)-233(future)-234(day)-234(to)-233(take)-234(vengeance)-233(on)-234(His)-234(foes.)-244(Such)-234(a)-233(change)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-315(tactics)-315(must)-316(have)-315(been)-315(resolved)-315(upon,)-331(and)-316(that)-315(speedily;)-347(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whole)-384(plan)-385(must)-384(have)-384(been)-384(conceived)-384(and)-385(executed)-384(by)-384(a)-384(few)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1865 0 obj <<
/Length 4772      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(404)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(credulous)-323(enthusiasts,)-340(or)-323(the)-323(belief)-322(in)-323(the)-322(Messiahship)-323(of)-322(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-250(have)-250(been)-250(extinguished)-250(in)-250(His)-250(grave.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-290(further;)-310(the)-291(necessity)-290(of)-290(converting)-290(the)-290(other)-290(disciples)-290(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(this)-411(belief)-411(was)-411(most)-411(urgent;)-492(for)-411(until)-411(this)-411(could)-411(be)-411(done,)-451(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(society)-301(was)-300(dissolving)-301(into)-301(its)-300(individual)-301(elements.)-402(How)-301(was)-300(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-261(be)-261(accomplished?)-284(It)-261(is)-261(easy)-261(to)-261(say)-261(that)-261(these)-261(enthusiasts)-261(com-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(municated)-644(their)-322(enthusiasm)-322(to)-322(the)-322(rest.)-466(But)-322(this)-322(little)-322(sentence)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([461])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(conceals)-316(behind)-316(it)-316(whole)-317(mountains)-316(of)-316(difficulty.)-448(Every)-316(one)-316(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-318(I)-319(have)-318(already)-319(alluded,)-335(must)-319(have)-318(had)-319(to)-318(be)-318(surmounted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-253(each)-253(individual)-253(case.)-259(There)-253(must)-253(have)-253(been)-253(many)-253(other)-252(disci-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ples)-299(who)-299(dearly)-300(loved)-299(their)-299(Master.)-398(What)-299(must)-299(have)-299(been)-299(their)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(feelings)-283(on)-283(hearing)-283(that)-284(He)-283(had)-283(appeared)-283(to)-283(only)-283(four)-283(or)-283(five)-283(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them,)-251(and)-250(had)-251(gone)-250(up)-251(into)-250(heaven?)-251(What!)-252(He,)-250(whom)-251(we)-250(loved,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-350(dearly)-349(loved)-350(us,)-375(risen)-349(from)-350(the)-350(dead,)-374(and)-350(gone)-350(to)-349(heaven)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-207(affording)-208(us)-207(the)-207(consolation)-208(of)-207(a)-207(parting)-208(interview?)-235(Such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-280(thought)-281(was)-280(enough)-281(to)-280(chill)-281(all)-280(ordinary)-281(enthusiasm.)-341(Was)-280(His)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(mother)-228(one)-228(of)-228(those)-228(who)-228(fancied)-228(they)-228(saw)-228(Him)-228(come)-228(again)-227(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-273(grave?)-318(If)-273(she)-273(was,)-278(could)-273(she)-273(have)-273(been)-272(mistaken?)-319(If)-273(she)-272(did)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-210(see)-211(Him,)-218(what)-211(must)-210(have)-211(been)-210(her)-211(feelings)-210(at)-211(the)-210(thought)-210(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-201(had)-201(left)-202(the)-201(world,)-211(without)-201(allowing)-201(her)-201(to)-202(behold)-201(Him?)-233(What)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-275(have)-275(been)-275(the)-275(feelings)-275(of)-275(the)-275(women,)-281(whose)-275(beneficence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-248(contributed)-247(to)-248(His)-247(support,)-248(or)-248(of)-248(His)-247(intimate)-248(friends)-247(among)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-209(Apostles?)-236(Surely)-209(all)-209(these)-209(would)-209(have)-209(thought)-209(it)-209(more)-208(certain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-259(their)-260(companions')-259(report)-260(originated)-259(in)-260(a)-259(heated)-259(imagination,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-250(that)-250(Jesus)-250(should)-250(have)-250(acted)-250(thus.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-386(the)-386(idea)-386(that)-385(a)-386(few)-386(fanatics)-386(only)-386(fancied)-386(that)-386(they)-385(saw)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-402(alive)-402(after)-402(His)-401(Crucifixion)-402(is)-402(negatived)-402(by)-402(an)-401(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-302(distinctly)-301(affirmed)-302(by)-302(St.)-405(Paul)-301(in)-302(the)-302(face)-301(of)-302(his)-301(opponents)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-292(the)-293(Corinthian)-292(Church.)-376(Having)-293(mentioned)-292(His)-292(appearance)-292(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Peter)-300(and)-301(the)-300(twelve,)-313(St.)-401(Paul)-300(asserts:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 171.367 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(After)-300(that,)-313(He)-300(was)-301(seen)]TJ -176.211 -13.549 Td [(of)-236(above)-235(five)-236(hundred)-235(brethren)-236(at)-235(once,)-238(of)-236(whom)-235(the)-236(greater)-235(part)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remain)-250(unto)-250(this)-250(present,)-250(but)-250(some)-250(are)-250(fallen)-250(asleep.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 226.625 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -214.669 -15.186 Td [(Here)-420(then)-419(we)-420(are)-419(in)-420(possession)-419(of)-420(direct)-419(contemporaneous)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(testimony.)-897(This)-466(assertion)-465(is)-466(boldly)-465(made)-466(in)-466(the)-465(face)-466(of)-465(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1869 0 obj <<
/Length 4578      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(405)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(powerful)-251(party)-252(who)-251(denied)-251(St.)-254(Paul's)-503(apostleship.)-254(It)-251(is)-251(clear)-251(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([462])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(if)-280(they)-280(had)-280(not)-279(believed)-280(in)-280(the)-280(truth)-280(of)-280(his)-279(assertion,)-288(they)-279(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-420(have)-420(lost)-421(such)-420(an)-420(opportunity)-420(of)-420(throwing)-420(discredit)-420(upon)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(him)-280(by)-281(convicting)-280(him)-281(of)-280(falsehood.)-342(The)-280(Apostle)-281(affirms)-280(in)-280(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(presence)-245(of)-246(his)-245(adversaries)-245(that)-246(there)-245(were)-245(then)-246(living)-245(more)-245(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(250)-323(persons)-323(who)-323(believed)-322(that)-323(they)-323(had)-323(seen)-323(Jesus)-323(Christ)-322(after)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-246(had)-246(risen)-246(from)-246(the)-246(dead;)-248(and)-246(not)-246(only)-246(so,)-246(but)-246(that)-246(upwards)-246(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(500)-260(persons)-261(had)-260(seen)-261(Him)-260(on)-260(one)-261(and)-260(the)-261(same)-260(occasion.)-281(If)-260(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assertion)-248(was)-248(false,)-248(nothing)-248(was)-248(easier)-248(than)-248(for)-248(the)-248(opponents)-247(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(Apostle)-250(to)-250(refute)-250(it.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(On)-413(the)-413(supposition,)-454(therefore,)-453(that)-413(the)-413(belief)-413(in)-413(the)-413(Resur-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(rection)-438(originated)-438(in)-438(a)-439(delusion,)-485(it)-438(must)-438(have)-438(been)-438(one)-438(on)-438(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prodigiously)-434(large)-434(scale.)-802(Unless)-434(St.)-802(Paul,)-480(and)-434(the)-433(opposing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(section)-396(of)-395(the)-396(Corinthian)-395(Church,)-432(who)-395(must)-396(have)-395(represented)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-335(opinions)-334(of)-335(the)-335(Church)-335(at)-334(Jerusalem,)-356(were)-335(misinformed)-334(on)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-340(subject,)-362(it)-340(is)-340(necessary)-340(to)-340(frame)-340(an)-340(hypothesis)-340(which)-339(shall)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-378(only)-378(account)-378(for)-379(three)-378(or)-378(four)-378(fanatics,)-410(fancying)-378(that)-378(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(saw)-320(Jesus)-319(Christ)-320(alive,)-337(when)-319(it)-320(was)-319(nothing)-320(but)-319(the)-320(creation)-319(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-400(disordered)-399(imagination,)-438(but)-399(for)-400(the)-400(fact)-399(that)-400(more)-400(than)-399(five)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hundred)-202(persons)-201(laboured)-202(under)-202(a)-201(similar)-202(delusion.)-234(The)-201(assertion)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-199(the)-199(Apostle)-199(is)-199(express,)-210(not)-199(that)-199(more)-199(than)-199(five)-199(hundred)-199(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-223(persuaded)-223(to)-223(believe)-223(that)-223(some)-223(others)-223(had)-223(seen)-223(Jesus)-222(Christ)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(after)-253(He)-253(was)-253(risen)-253(from)-253(the)-253(dead,)-254(but)-253(that)-253(they)-253(had)-252(actually)-253(seen)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Him)-250(themselves.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-290(only)-290(way)-289(of)-290(evading)-290(the)-290(force)-289(of)-290(this)-290(testimony)-290(is)-289(either)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(by)-321(directly)-320(impugning)-321(St.)-462(Paul's)-320(veracity,)-339(or)-320(by)-321(supposing)-320(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-429(made)-429(an)-429(assertion)-429(based)-428(on)-429(a)-429(vulgar)-429(rumour.)-787(The)-428(whole)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(character)-322(of)-322(the)-322(Apostle)-322(renders)-322(the)-322(supposition)-322(of)-322(a)-321(deliberate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(falsehood)-396(incredible,)-432(besides)-396(the)-395(danger)-396(already)-396(alluded)-396(to)-395(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-326(detection)-327(by)-326(his)-326(opponents.)-479(Nor)-327(is)-326(the)-326(other)-326(alternative)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more)-284(tenable,)-293(that)-284(on)-284(such)-284(a)-284(subject)-285(he)-568(adopted)-284(a)-284(mere)-284(idle)-284(ru-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([463])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(mour.)-282(No)-260(subject)-261(more)-261(occupied)-260(his)-261(mind)-260(than)-261(the)-260(Resurrection)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-338(Jesus)-337(Christ.)-513(For)-338(Him)-338(he)-337(sacrificed)-338(everything.)-513(To)-338(Him)-337(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(devoted)-306(his)-306(entire)-306(life.)-418(Is)-306(it)-306(conceivable)-306(that)-306(such)-306(a)-306(man)-306(would)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1875 0 obj <<
/Length 4677      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(406)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(not,)-238(under)-234(the)-235(influence)-234(of)-234(common)-235(curiosity,)-238(have)-234(inquired)-234(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-308(alleged)-307(facts)-308(of)-307(his)-307(Master's)-308(Resurrection?)-422(But)-308(these)-307(letters)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prove)-242(that)-241(he)-242(was)-241(a)-242(man)-242(of)-241(far)-242(more)-241(than)-242(ordinary)-242(curiosity.)-247(It)-241(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(clear)-273(from)-273(them)-273(that)-272(he)-273(kept)-273(himself)-273(acquainted)-273(with)-273(the)-272(details)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-379(the)-380(events)-379(which)-380(took)-379(place)-379(in)-380(the)-379(Churches)-380(which)-379(he)-379(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(planted.)-605(Messengers)-369(were)-368(sent)-368(by)-369(him)-368(to)-368(supply)-369(him)-368(with)-368(all)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary)-369(information.)-605(Even)-369(in)-368(so)-369(distant)-368(a)-369(Church)-368(as)-369(that)-368(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Rome,)-260(which)-257(he)-258(had)-258(not)-257(even)-258(visited,)-260(he)-257(knew)-258(no)-258(small)-257(number)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-275(the)-275(chief)-276(Christians)-275(by)-275(name,)-281(and)-276(took)-275(the)-275(deepest)-275(interest)-275(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(their)-349(affairs.)-547(Are)-349(we)-349(to)-349(believe)-349(that)-349(such)-349(a)-349(man)-349(received)-349(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-417(fact)-418(connected)-417(with)-417(the)-418(dearest)-417(interests)-417(of)-418(his)-417(life)-417(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taking)-359(the)-359(trouble)-360(to)-359(ascertain)-359(its)-359(truth?)-578(Moreover,)-386(his)-359(former)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-240(as)-240(a)-240(persecutor)-240(must)-240(have)-240(rendered)-240(it)-240(necessary)-240(that)-240(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-334(institute)-333(a)-334(diligent)-334(inquiry)-333(into)-334(the)-334(alleged)-333(Resurrection)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-341(one)-341(whom)-341(he)-340(considered)-341(an)-341(impostor,)-364(and)-341(whose)-340(adherents)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-231(was)-231(endeavouring)-231(to)-231(compel)-231(to)-232(renounce)-231(their)-231(allegiance.)-243(We)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must,)-353(therefore,)-354(conclude)-332(that)-333(what)-333(St.)-498(Paul)-332(here)-333(affirms)-332(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-347(been)-347(true,)-371(that)-347(on)-347(one)-347(definite)-347(occasion)-347(several)-347(hundreds)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-294(persons)-293(thought)-294(that)-293(they)-293(had)-294(seen)-293(Jesus)-294(Christ)-293(after)-294(He)-293(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(risen)-250(from)-250(the)-250(dead.)]TJ 11.956 -18.458 Td [(But)-358(if)-358(it)-358(is)-358(in)-359(the)-358(highest)-358(degree)-358(difficult)-358(to)-358(account)-358(for)-358(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(possibility)-228(of)-228(three)-227(or)-228(four)-228(of)-228(the)-227(disciples)-228(of)-228(Jesus)-228(fancying)-227(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(saw)-280(their)-281(risen)-280(Master,)-288(when)-280(they)-280(saw)-280(nothing)-281(but)-280(a)-280(creation)-280(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-242(own)-243(imagination,)-243(what)-243(theory)-242(can)-242(be)-243(framed)-242(to)-242(account)-242(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-295(fact)-296(of)-295(several)-295(hundreds)-296(of)-295(persons)-295(having)-296(become)-295(the)-295(prey)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(a)-251(similar)-250(delusion?)-251(Large)-251(numbers)-250(of)-251(persons)-500(do)-251(not)-250(fall)-250(into)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([464])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(delusions)-387(of)-387(this)-387(kind.)-661(Are)-387(we)-387(to)-387(suppose)-387(that)-387(some)-387(of)-387(them)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(affirmed)-248(that)-248(some)-247(distant)-248(object)-248(which)-248(they)-248(saw)-247(was)-248(Jesus,)-248(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-412(the)-412(remainder)-412(accepted)-411(the)-412(assertion)-412(without)-412(inquiry?)-735(If)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-321(had)-321(not)-320(come)-321(near)-321(to)-321(them,)-338(would)-321(they)-321(not)-321(have)-321(rushed)-320(up)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-389(a)-389(man,)-423(who)-389(was)-389(believed)-389(to)-389(have)-389(come)-389(up)-389(again)-389(from)-388(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(grave,)-387(and)-359(endeavoured)-359(to)-359(converse)-360(with)-359(him?)-578(Let)-359(all)-359(history)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(be)-320(searched)-320(for)-319(any)-320(fact)-320(at)-320(all)-320(like)-320(this.)-459(Until)-320(something)-320(like)-319(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-362(be)-362(found,)-389(we)-362(are)-362(justified)-361(in)-362(pronouncing)-362(such)-362(a)-361(delusion)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1879 0 obj <<
/Length 4592      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(407)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(impossible.)-509(Nay:)-422(however)-336(common)-337(the)-336(belief)-336(in)-336(ghost)-336(stories,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-258(would)-258(be)-258(impossible)-259(to)-258(find)-258(a)-258(case)-258(of)-258(several)-258(hundred)-258(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-394(believed)-394(that,)-430(on)-394(some)-394(one)-394(definite)-394(occasion,)-430(when)-393(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-244(all)-243(assembled,)-245(they)-244(had)-243(seen)-244(the)-243(ghost)-244(of)-244(a)-243(person)-244(who)-243(had)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(recently)-272(been)-271(executed,)-277(appear)-271(before)-272(them,)-277(and)-271(on)-272(the)-271(strength)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-293(this)-292(belief,)-303(constituted)-293(themselves)-292(into)-293(a)-292(new)-293(society;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 248.355 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(a)-293(so-)]TJ -259.264 -13.549 Td [(ciety)-341(which)-340(has)-341(endured)-340(through)-340(eighteen)-341(centuries?)-521(However)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cynical)-255(our)-256(views)-255(may)-255(be,)-257(it)-255(is)-255(impossible)-256(to)-255(believe)-255(that)-255(human)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nature)-250(is)-250(a)-250(lie.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Again:)-618(If)-434(for)-434(the)-434(purposes)-434(of)-434(the)-434(argument)-434(we)-434(accept)-433(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(impossible)-429(supposition)-430(that)-429(a)-429(few)-430(deluded)-429(fanatics)-429(persuaded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(themselves)-298(that)-298(they)-298(had)-298(seen)-298(their)-298(Master)-298(risen)-298(from)-298(the)-297(dead,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-344(that)-344(they)-344(set)-344(themselves)-344(to)-344(persuade)-344(others)-344(that)-344(this)-344(was)-343(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact,)-418(then)-384(it)-384(is)-385(clear)-384(that)-384(the)-384(wish)-385(of)-384(making)-384(converts)-384(to)-384(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belief)-278(must)-278(have)-277(been)-278(a)-278(very)-278(gradual)-278(and)-277(slow)-278(process.)-334(This,)-284(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-261(face)-260(of)-261(all)-260(the)-261(evidence)-260(supplied)-261(by)-260(history,)-263(does)-261(not)-260(require)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(further)-366(proof.)-599(It)-366(would)-366(be)-366(impossible)-367(to)-366(make)-366(converts)-366(at)-366(all,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(without)-348(adducing)-348(some)-348(overwhelming)-348(evidence)-348(of)-348(the)-348(truth)-347(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-310(assertion.)-430(But)-310(on)-310(the)-310(supposition)-310(that)-310(it)-310(was)-310(a)-310(delusion)-310(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-294(imagination,)-305(such)-294(evidence)-293(could)-294(not)-294(be)-294(forthcoming.)-381(Such)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(beliefs)-445(are)-446(only)-445(possible)-446(after)-445(the)-445(lapse)-446(of)-445(very)-445(considerable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intervals)-250(of)-250(time,)-250(if)-250(they)-250(are)-250(possible)-250(even)-250(then.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([465])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -279.068 -16.004 Td [(But)-314(in)-315(the)-314(present)-314(case)-315(recollections)-314(were)-315(all)-314(fresh.)-443(Will)-314(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(attempt)-294(to)-293(persuade)-294(persons)-293(who)-294(live)-293(in)-293(the)-294(city)-293(where)-294(a)-293(public)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(execution)-294(has)-294(taken)-294(place,)-306(that)-294(the)-294(man)-294(executed)-294(is)-294(alive)-294(again,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(succeed?)-309(Will)-270(it)-270(succeed)-270(anywhere)-269(in)-270(the)-270(neighbourhood,)-274(while)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-394(events)-394(are)-393(still)-394(in)-394(everybody's)-393(recollection?)-682(Living)-393(actors)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(must)-405(have)-405(died)-405(out,)-444(memories)-405(of)-405(the)-405(past)-405(must)-404(have)-405(become)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(faint,)-214(before)-204(such)-205(things)-204(can)-205(be)-205(made)-204(to)-205(wear)-204(even)-205(the)-204(semblance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-382(possibility.)-645(But)-382(the)-382(plain)-381(historical)-382(facts)-382(refuse)-382(to)-381(concede)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-390(requisite)-389(interval)-390(during)-389(which)-389(such)-390(a)-389(belief)-390(could)-389(slowly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(grow)-273(up.)-320(While)-273(the)-273(belief)-274(was)-273(growing,)-279(the)-273(Church)-273(would)-273(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-292(perishing)-292(from)-293(want)-292(of)-292(a)-292(Messiah)-292(to)-293(step)-292(into)-292(the)-292(place)-292(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-366(dead)-366(Jesus.)-597(On)-366(the)-366(contrary,)-395(the)-366(growth)-366(of)-366(the)-366(belief)-365(was)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1883 0 obj <<
/Length 4703      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(408)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(rapid.)-274(The)-259(Church)-258(speedily)-258(rose)-258(from)-258(its)-258(ruins.)-275(Before)-258(St.)-274(Paul's)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conversion,)-251(it)-251(had)-250(increased)-251(to)-250(such)-251(numbers)-251(as)-250(to)-251(be)-251(worth)-250(per-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(secuting.)-246(There)-237(was)-237(a)-238(Church)-237(at)-237(Jerusalem;)-242(there)-237(were)-237(Churches)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-289(Jud\346a;)-309(there)-289(were)-289(Christians)-289(in)-290(Damascus.)-367(Before)-289(this)-289(event)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-215(small)-216(knot)-215(of)-216(deluded)-215(fanatics)-216(had)-215(persuaded)-216(thousands;)-226(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-248(formed)-247(the)-248(Society)-247(which)-247(subverted)-248(the)-247(religion)-248(and)-247(institu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tions)-199(of)-199(the)-200(Roman)-199(empire,)-209(and)-199(of)-200(which)-199(all)-199(the)-199(progressive)-199(races)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-256(men)-256(profess)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 64.967 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(now)-256(in)-256(the)-256(19th)-257(century)-256(of)-256(its)-256(existence)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 172.265 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(to)-256(be)]TJ -259.05 -13.549 Td [(still)-264(members.)-294(The)-264(facts)-265(of)-264(unquestionable)-265(history)-264(utterly)-264(refuse)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-301(the)-300(advocates)-301(of)-301(this)-300(theory)-301(the)-301(time)-300(necessary)-301(for)-300(imparting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(it)-250(even)-250(a)-250(passing)-250(plausibility.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-326(infer,)-346(therefore,)-345(that)-326(the)-327(theory)-326(that)-326(one)-327(or)-326(more)-326(credulous)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(enthusiasts)-359(among)-358(the)-359(disciples)-358(of)-359(Jesus)-359(fancied)-358(that)-359(they)-358(saw)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-459(Master)-460(risen)-459(from)-460(the)-459(dead,)-512(while)-459(in)-460(reality)-459(they)-459(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(labouring)-321(under)-322(some)-321(mental)-321(hallucination,)-339(and)-322(that)-321(they)-321(com-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(municated)-242(their)-242(enthusiasm)-243(to)-242(the)-242(rest,)-244(and)-242(that)-242(these)-242(created)-242(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Christian)-229(Church,)-232(is)-229(unsound)-228(in)-229(philosophy,)-233(contradicts)-228(the)-228(facts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-202(history,)-211(and)-202(the)-202(phenomena)-202(of)-201(human)-202(nature,)-423(as)-202(testified)-202(to)-201(by)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([466])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(past)-235(experience,)-238(and)-235(is)-234(destitute)-235(of)-235(the)-235(possibility)-235(of)-234(verification,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-355(also)-355(is)-355(contrary)-355(to)-355(analogy.)-564(It)-355(follows,)-381(therefore,)-382(that)-354(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(portion)-322(of)-321(the)-322(alternative)-322(before)-322(us)-321(must)-322(be)-322(pronounced)-321(utterly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inadequate)-250(as)-250(a)-250(solution)-250(of)-250(the)-250(facts.)]TJ 11.955 -15.186 Td [(Let)-336(us)-336(now)-336(consider)-336(the)-336(other)-336(alternative,)-358(that)-336(Jesus)-336(did)-336(not)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(actually)-308(die,)-322(but,)-322(although)-308(He)-308(had)-308(been)-307(crucified,)-323(escaped)-307(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(His)-334(life;)-375(that)-334(His)-334(disciples)-334(saw)-334(Him)-333(after)-334(His)-334(crucifixion;)-375(and,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(being)-369(persuaded)-369(that)-369(He)-368(had)-369(expired,)-399(mistook)-369(His)-368(appearance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-250(a)-250(restoration)-250(to)-250(life.)]TJ 11.955 -15.186 Td [(This)-354(alternative)-354(need)-354(not)-354(detain)-354(us)-354(long.)-562(It)-354(is)-354(involved)-355(in)-354(a)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(considerable)-216(number)-217(of)-216(the)-216(difficulties)-217(which)-216(are)-216(connected)-216(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-351(assumption)-350(that)-351(some)-350(one)-351(or)-350(more)-351(of)-350(the)-351(disciples)-350(fancied)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-348(they)-348(saw)-348(Him)-348(when)-348(they)-347(did)-348(not)-348(really)-348(see)-348(Him,)-373(and)-347(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-219(persuaded)-218(the)-219(others)-218(that)-219(He)-219(was)-218(risen)-219(from)-218(the)-219(dead.)-239(These)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(difficulties)-191(I)-192(have)-191(already)-191(disposed)-191(of.)-231(But)-191(it)-192(has)-191(in)-191(addition)-191(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difficulties)-250(peculiarly)-250(its)-250(own,)-250(which)-250(I)-250(will)-250(now)-250(briefly)-250(notice.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1887 0 obj <<
/Length 4718      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(409)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -252.311 -30.759 Td [(I)-426(admit)-426(that)-427(it)-426(was)-426(possible)-426(to)-427(recover)-426(from)-426(the)-426(effects)-426(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(crucifixion,)-517(if)-464(taken)-463(down)-464(from)-463(the)-464(cross)-464(in)-463(time.)-891(This)-463(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(learn)-316(from)-315(Josephus,)-333(who,)-332(on)-315(his)-316(return)-316(one)-315(day)-316(from)-316(going)-315(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(examine)-231(a)-231(place)-231(for)-231(the)-231(encampment)-231(of)-231(the)-232(Roman)-231(forces,)-234(found)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-337(three)-337(of)-337(his)-337(friends)-337(had)-337(been)-337(crucified)-337(during)-337(his)-336(absence.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(By)-280(his)-280(entreaties,)-288(he)-280(obtained)-280(the)-281(orders)-280(of)-280(Titus)-280(for)-280(their)-280(being)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(taken)-331(down.)-492(Two)-331(died)-331(under)-331(cure;)-371(one)-331(recovered.)-493(Josephus)-330(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(silent)-384(as)-385(to)-384(whether)-384(they)-384(had)-384(been)-385(scourged)-384(before)-384(they)-384(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(crucified.)-411(This)-304(was)-304(no)-304(doubt)-304(an)-303(important)-304(point)-304(in)-304(reference)-303(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-209(possibility)-209(of)-209(recovery.)-237(Such)-209(was)-209(the)-209(usual)-209(practice;)-222(although)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-329(the)-330(Romans)-329(crucified)-329(the)-329(Jews)-330(in)-329(large)-329(numbers,)-349(as)-329(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-326(now)-327(been)-326(in)-327(the)-326(habit)-326(of)-327(doing)-326(for)-326(some)-327(time,)-345(it)-327(may)-326(be)-326(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question)-366(whether)-366(it)-366(was)-366(always)-365(inflicted.)-1196(These)-366(persons)-365(had)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([467])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(probably)-206(been)-207(suspended)-206(on)-206(the)-207(cross)-206(for)-206(some)-207(hours)-206(before)-206(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(were)-292(taken)-291(down.)-375(They)-291(were)-292(treated)-291(with)-292(the)-291(utmost)-292(care,)-301(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-279(view)-279(to)-280(their)-279(recovery;)-294(yet)-279(two)-279(out)-279(of)-279(the)-280(three)-279(died.)-337(Such)-279(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(facts,)-250(as)-250(related)-250(by)-250(Josephus.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-355(has)-356(been)-355(suggested)-356(that)-355(Jesus)-355(was)-356(only)-355(in)-356(a)-355(swoon)-355(when)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(taken)-336(down)-335(from)-335(the)-336(cross;)-378(that)-336(in)-335(the)-336(sepulchre)-335(He)-335(recovered)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-286(consciousness,)-294(to)-286(which)-286(the)-286(large)-285(quantity)-286(of)-286(spices)-286(used)-285(at)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(His)-245(burial)-245(might)-245(have)-245(contributed;)-246(that)-245(He)-245(managed)-245(to)-245(creep)-244(out)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-293(the)-292(grave)-293(to)-293(some)-292(place)-293(of)-293(security,)-303(where)-293(He)-292(was)-293(seen)-293(by)-292(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(few)-311(of)-311(His)-312(disciples,)-326(but)-311(that)-311(He)-312(died)-311(not)-311(long)-311(after.)-434(This,)-326(it)-311(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(said,)-257(the)-256(disciples)-256(mistook)-255(for)-256(a)-256(Resurrection,)-257(and)-256(that)-256(it)-255(formed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-324(basis)-324(of)-324(the)-324(renewed)-324(life)-324(of)-324(the)-324(Church.)-472(Let)-324(it)-324(be)-323(observed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-371(there)-371(would)-371(be)-371(the)-371(same)-371(difficulties)-371(in)-371(re-constituting)-370(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church)-273(on)-272(such)-273(a)-273(basis,)-278(and)-273(in)-273(procuring)-272(converts)-273(to)-273(this)-272(belief,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-290(there)-291(would)-290(have)-290(been)-291(on)-290(the)-290(other)-291(alt)1(ernative,)-301(which)-290(I)-290(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(shown)-250(to)-250(be)-250(untenable.)-250(These,)-250(therefore,)-250(I)-250(need)-250(not)-250(consider.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(This)-280(theory)-279(pre-supposes)-280(not)-280(only)-280(that)-279(the)-280(body)-280(of)-280(Jesus)-280(was)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(interred,)-260(but)-258(that)-257(it)-258(was)-258(committed)-258(to)-257(the)-258(custody)-258(of)-258(His)-257(friends.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-369(fact)-369(we)-369(have)-369(from)-369(the)-368(Gospels;)-429(as)-369(well)-369(as)-369(the)-368(additional)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fact)-319(that)-319(the)-318(time)-319(during)-319(which)-319(He)-318(was)-319(suspended)-319(on)-319(the)-318(cross)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(did)-316(not)-316(exceed)-315(six)-316(hours)-316(at)-316(the)-316(utmost.)-447(But)-316(we)-316(also)-316(learn)-315(from)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1891 0 obj <<
/Length 4820      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(410)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(them)-292(that,)-302(before)-292(Pilate)-291(ordered)-292(the)-292(body)-291(to)-292(be)-292(delivered)-291(up,)-302(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(took)-287(care)-287(to)-287(ascertain,)-296(from)-287(those)-287(in)-287(charge,)-296(the)-287(certainty)-287(of)-287(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(death;)-322(and)-297(the)-298(fourth)-298(Gospel)-298(affirms)-298(that)-297(one)-298(of)-298(the)-298(soldiers,)-309(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(order)-339(to)-340(remove)-339(all)-340(doubt)-339(on)-339(the)-340(subject,)-361(pierced)-340(his)-339(side)-339(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-320(spear.)-459(Now)-320(without)-320(the)-320(aid)-320(of)-319(the)-320(Gospels)-320(it)-320(would)-320(not)-319(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-293(known)-294(that)-293(the)-293(body)-294(was)-293(committed)-293(to)-294(the)-293(custody)-293(of)-293(His)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(friends.)-483(If,)-348(therefore,)-347(their)-328(historical)-327(testimony)-328(is)-328(good)-328(for)-327(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact,)-367(it)-344(is)-343(absurd)-344(to)-343(refuse)-688(them)-343(credence)-344(when)-343(they)-344(testify)-343(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([468])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(the)-323(other)-324(facts.)-469(We)-324(say)-323(distinctly:)-397(if)-323(the)-323(truth)-323(of)-324(the)-323(one)-323(set)-323(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(facts)-251(is)-250(denied,)-251(because)-251(the)-251(Gospels)-250(are)-251(unhistorical,)-251(the)-251(truth)-250(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-324(other)-324(set)-323(\050for)-324(the)-324(Gospels)-324(are)-323(the)-324(sole)-324(authorities\051)-324(must)-323(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-307(assumed)-307(on)-307(their)-307(testimony.)-421(Apart)-307(from)-307(this,)-321(we)-307(are)-307(only)-307(at)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(liberty)-251(to)-250(assume)-251(that)-250(the)-251(crucifixion)-250(was)-251(conducted)-250(in)-251(the)-250(usual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(manner;)-396(and)-348(that)-348(the)-347(bodies)-348(were)-347(disposed)-348(of)-347(accordingly,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 267.299 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -267.299 -13.55 Td [(that,)-260(if)-258(the)-258(crucified)-258(persons)-258(were)-258(buried)-258(at)-258(all,)-260(they)-258(were)-258(buried)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ignominiously.)-593(It)-365(has)-364(also)-365(been)-364(affirmed)-365(that)-364(Pilate)-364(sacrificed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-362(by)-361(compulsion,)-390(and)-361(that)-362(the)-361(centurion)-362(on)-361(guard)-362(was)-361(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ill-disposed)-297(towards)-297(him.)-391(This)-297(again,)-309(I)-297(say,)-309(we)-297(only)-297(learn)-297(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-220(present)-219(Gospels,)-226(and)-219(I)-220(must)-219(again)-220(protest)-219(against)-220(the)-219(practice)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-329(accepting)-328(their)-329(testimony)-329(on)-328(one)-329(side)-329(and)-328(ignoring)-329(it)-329(on)-328(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other.)-251(The)-251(Romans,)-251(moreover,)-250(were)-251(not)-250(the)-251(sort)-250(of)-251(men)-250(to)-250(allow)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-195(crucified)-195(victim)-195(to)-195(be)-195(taken)-195(down)-195(from)-195(the)-195(cross)-195(until)-195(they)-195(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(well)-345(assured)-345(that)-345(he)-345(had)-345(hung)-345(there)-345(long)-345(enough)-345(to)-344(extinguish)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(life;)-239(and)-234(from)-233(the)-234(frequency)-233(of)-234(such)-234(executions)-233(they)-234(would)-233(learn)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(how)-256(long)-255(it)-256(would)-255(require,)-257(and)-256(what)-255(on)-256(such)-255(occasions)-256(were)-255(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(symptoms)-245(of)-245(death;)-246(nor)-245(did)-245(they)-245(concede)-245(to)-245(persons)-245(so)-244(executed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-250(honourable)-250(burial.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-273(further:)-295(It)-272(never)-273(occurred)-273(to)-272(the)-273(Jews)-273(that)-272(it)-273(was)-272(possible)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-325(the)-324(crucified)-325(Jesus)-324(had)-325(escaped)-325(with)-324(His)-325(life,)-343(and)-325(that)-324(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-289(was)-288(really)-289(at)-288(the)-289(bottom)-289(of)-288(the)-289(announcement)-288(of)-289(His)-288(resur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rection.)-560(If)-353(it)-353(was)-353(known)-353(to)-354(any)-353(person)-353(concerned)-353(that)-353(He)-353(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thus)-353(escaped,)-378(nothing)-353(could)-353(have)-353(been)-353(more)-353(dangerous)-353(on)-352(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(part)-339(of)-339(His)-339(followers)-339(than)-339(to)-339(announce)-339(that)-339(He)-339(was)-339(risen)-339(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-382(dead.)-648(This)-382(was)-382(the)-383(very)-382(thing)-383(to)-382(promote)-383(inquiry,)-415(and)-382(to)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1895 0 obj <<
/Length 4758      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(411)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(arouse)-384(a)-384(suspicion)-384(among)-384(His)-384(enemies)-384(that)-384(He)-384(had)-384(not)-383(really)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(died,)-331(and)-315(thus)-315(to)-315(induce)-314(them)-315(to)-315(make)-315(every)-315(effort)-315(to)-314(ascertain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-325(place)-324(of)-325(His)-324(retreat.)-474(The)-325(quickest)-324(way)-325(to)-324(put)-325(an)-324(end)-325(to)-324(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(story)-270(of)-271(the)-270(Resurrection)-541(was)-270(to)-270(produce)-270(the)-271(living)-270(Jesus,)-275(weak)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([469])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(and)-373(exhausted)-373(from)-374(His)-373(wounds;)-435(or,)-404(if)-373(He)-373(had)-373(really)-373(died,)-404(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(produce)-410(His)-410(body.)-731(But)-410(not)-410(a)-410(single)-410(whisper)-410(has)-410(come)-410(down)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-339(us)-338(from)-339(the)-339(opponents)-338(of)-339(Christianity)-339(that)-338(He)-339(did)-339(not)-338(really)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(die.)-663(If)-387(such)-388(an)-387(idea)-388(had)-388(afforded)-387(even)-388(a)-387(probable)-388(account)-387(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-347(story)-347(of)-347(the)-347(Resurrection,)-371(it)-347(would)-347(certainly)-347(have)-346(occurred)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-340(Paul)-339(when)-340(a)-340(persecutor,)-362(and)-339(he)-340(would)-340(have)-339(had)-340(recourse)-339(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-316(as)-316(a)-315(means)-316(of)-316(dissipating)-316(the)-316(delusion.)-447(Such)-316(are)-316(some)-316(of)-315(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first)-278(difficulties)-279(which)-278(surround)-279(this)-278(mode)-278(of)-279(accounting)-278(for)-278(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(story)-251(of)-250(the)-251(Resurrection.)-252(A)-251(sepulchre)-250(was)-251(a)-251(place)-250(ill-fitted)-251(for)-250(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(man,)-289(exhausted)-281(by)-282(scourging)-281(and)-281(crucifixion,)-289(to)-281(recover)-282(in;)-296(nor)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-236(there)-236(a)-236(retreat)-235(at)-236(hand.)-246(But,)-238(as)-236(we)-236(scrutinize)-236(the)-236(matter)-235(more)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(closely,)-250(these)-250(difficulties)-250(become)-250(impossibilities.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-381(is)-382(clear)-381(that)-381(from)-382(the)-381(hour)-382(of)-381(His)-381(supposed)-382(death)-381(on)-381(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(cross,)-264(Jesus)-261(disappears)-261(from)-262(history,)-264(except)-261(in)-261(the)-261(form)-261(of)-261(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-389(Messiah)-389(raised)-389(again)-389(from)-389(the)-389(dead,)-424(the)-389(great)-388(Founder)-389(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-344(Christian)-345(Church.)-532(If,)-368(therefore,)-368(His)-344(supposed)-344(Resurrection)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(was)-399(nothing)-398(but)-399(a)-399(recovery)-398(from)-399(a)-399(swoon,)-435(one)-399(of)-399(two)-398(things)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-362(certain:)-473(either)-362(He)-362(died)-362(shortly)-361(after)-362(from)-362(exhaustion,)-390(or)-361(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lived)-183(somewhere)-183(in)-183(deepest)-184(retirement,)-196(only)-183(receiving)-183(visits)-183(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(those)-258(of)-257(His)-257(followers)-258(who)-257(were)-258(in)-257(the)-258(secret,)-259(and)-258(in)-257(due)-257(course)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(He)-281(expired.)-342(Perhaps)-281(it)-281(may)-281(be)-280(urged)-281(that)-281(His)-281(friends)-280(succeeded)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-230(carrying)-230(Him)-230(off)-229(into)-230(some)-230(distant)-230(country,)-234(and)-230(that)-230(some)-229(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-267(more)-267(of)-267(His)-267(followers,)-271(who)-267(had)-267(seen)-267(Him)-267(slowly)-266(recovering,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mistook)-250(this)-250(for)-250(a)-250(resurrection,)-250(and)-250(propagated)-250(the)-250(story.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(We)-290(must)-290(keep)-290(steadily)-289(in)-290(view)-290(that)-290(what)-290(we)-290(have)-290(to)-289(account)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(for)-302(is)-302(not)-301(a)-302(mere)-302(story)-302(of)-302(a)-301(resurrection)-302(propagated)-302(by)-302(a)-301(crazed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fanatic,)-242(but)-241(the)-240(erection)-241(of)-240(the)-241(Christian)-240(Church)-240(on)-241(its)-240(basis.)-247(It)-240(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-303(plain)-302(fact)-303(that)-303(Jesus)-302(appeared)-303(no)-303(more)-303(in)-302(public,)-316(and)-303(that)-302(His)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(earthly)-448(history)-224(ends)-224(with)-224(His)-223(crucifixion.)-242(What)-224(became)-224(of)-223(Him?)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([470])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(It)-250(is)-250(impossible)-250(to)-250(over-estimate)-250(the)-250(importance)-250(of)-250(this)-250(question.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1901 0 obj <<
/Length 4670      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(412)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(Let)-430(us)-430(take)-430(the)-430(first)-430(supposition)-430(that)-430(He)-430(recovered)-430(from)-429(a)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(swoon,)-251(but)-250(died)-251(shortly)-250(afterwards)-251(from)-250(exhaustion.)-252(This)-250(theory)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(involves)-351(the)-350(necessity)-351(that)-350(some)-351(one)-350(or)-351(more)-350(of)-351(His)-350(followers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(should)-392(have)-391(seen)-392(Him)-392(alive)-391(and)-392(dying)-391(of)-392(exhaustion.)-675(Was)-391(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(possible,)-297(I)-287(ask,)-297(for)-288(the)-287(most)-288(deluded)-287(fanaticism)-288(to)-287(mistake)-287(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-343(condition)-342(for)-343(a)-342(resurrection)-342(from)-343(the)-342(dead?)-528(Was)-342(this)-343(a)-342(basis)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-240(which)-241(to)-240(revive)-240(the)-241(hopes)-240(of)-240(the)-241(disciples,)-242(and)-240(to)-240(re-construct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-213(Church?)-237(Would)-213(any)-213(amount)-213(of)-213(enthusiastic)-213(credulity)-212(mistake)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-310(a)-310(person)-310(for)-310(the)-311(Messiah)-310(of)-310(the)-310(future?)-430(If)-310(He)-310(died)-310(shortly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(afterwards,)-451(what)-410(became)-411(of)-411(His)-410(Messiahship?)-732(Did)-411(His)-410(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(followers)-210(pay)-210(Him)-210(no)-210(visits)-210(during)-210(His)-210(illness?)-237(Did)-210(they)-209(see)-210(Him)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(die,)-367(or)-343(attend)-343(His)-344(burial?)-530(Surely)-343(such)-343(positions)-344(do)-343(not)-343(require)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(serious)-250(argument.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-287(let)-288(us)-287(suppose)-287(that)-288(He)-287(recovered,)-297(lived)-287(in)-287(retirement)-287(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(only)-253(received)-253(the)-253(secret)-253(visits)-252(of)-253(a)-253(few)-253(followers,)-254(and)-253(that)-253(out)-252(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-278(the)-279(story)-278(of)-278(the)-279(Resurrection)-278(grew.)-335(How)-278(grew?)-335(I)-278(again)-278(ask.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Such)-379(growths)-379(require)-378(considerable)-379(periods)-379(of)-379(time,)-411(and)-378(these,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(history)-312(utterly)-312(refuses)-312(to)-312(grant.)-437(Would)-312(it)-312(be)-312(possible,)-328(I)-312(ask,)-327(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-179(deluded)-178(follower)-179(to)-179(mistake)-178(such)-179(facts)-179(for)-178(a)-179(resurrection)-178(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-264(dead?)-292(Could)-264(Jesus)-264(himself)-264(have)-265(so)-264(mistaken)-264(it?)-292(or,)-267(however)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(well)-209(the)-208(secret)-209(might)-208(be)-209(kept,)-217(would)-208(a)-209(Messiah,)-216(living)-209(in)-208(privacy,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(out)-290(of)-291(the)-290(sight)-291(of)-290(friends)-291(and)-290(foes,)-301(be)-290(a)-290(possible)-291(Messiah,)-300(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(could)-434(impart)-434(a)-433(new)-434(life)-434(to)-434(the)-433(Church?)-802(In)-433(such)-434(a)-434(case)-434(it)-433(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(impossible)-268(to)-268(exonerate)-268(the)-268(persons)-267(concerned)-268(from)-268(fraud,)-272(even)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-332(Great)-331(Teacher)-332(himself.)-495(Are)-332(we)-332(to)-331(suppose)-332(that)-332(He)-331(himself)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(actually)-313(mistook)-312(His)-313(recovery)-312(from)-313(a)-313(swoon)-312(for)-313(a)-312(resurrection,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-226(justified)-227(His)-226(followers)-226(in)-226(publishing)-226(a)-227(report)-226(of)-226(it?)-242(Why)-226(then)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(did)-698(He)-349(not)-349(appear)-349(in)-349(public)-349(and)-349(assert)-349(His)-349(Messianic)-349(claims?)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([471])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(But)-316(could)-315(His)-316(followers)-315(have)-315(persuaded)-316(themselves)-315(that)-316(a)-315(man)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-257(must)-256(have)-257(shown)-256(distinct)-257(indications)-256(of)-257(slow)-256(recovery,)-258(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-302(never)-303(ventured)-302(to)-302(appear)-303(again)-302(in)-302(public,)-316(was)-302(raised)-302(again)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-246(the)-245(dead)-246(to)-246(continue)-245(His)-246(Messianic)-245(work?)-249(If)-246(this)-245(is)-246(the)-245(true)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(account)-367(of)-366(the)-366(matter,)-396(it)-367(was)-366(not)-367(a)-366(delusion)-366(but)-367(an)-366(imposture.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(If)-428(we)-429(suppose)-428(that)-428(a)-428(few)-429(friends)-428(only)-428(visited)-428(Him,)-473(what)-428(did)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1905 0 obj <<
/Length 4393      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(413)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(His)-309(other)-309(disciples)-309(say)-310(about)-309(the)-309(matter?)-427(Did)-309(the)-309(few,)-324(with)-309(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(concurrence)-383(of)-384(their)-383(Master,)-416(propagate)-384(the)-383(belief)-383(that)-383(He)-383(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gone)-292(into)-293(heaven,)-303(knowing)-292(that)-292(He)-293(was)-292(still)-293(on)-292(earth?)-377(Be)-292(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(things)-299(as)-298(they)-299(may)-298(\050and)-299(those)-298(who)-298(have)-299(started)-298(the)-299(idea)-298(should)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(solve)-347(it\051,)-371(if)-347(the)-347(real)-347(basis)-347(of)-347(the)-347(story)-347(of)-347(the)-347(Resurrection)-347(be)-346(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recovery)-335(from)-335(a)-335(swoon)-334(and)-335(a)-335(subsequent)-335(life)-335(of)-334(privacy,)-356(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-313(have)-313(shared)-313(the)-313(common)-313(fate)-313(of)-313(humanity)-313(and)-313(died.)-438(This)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-373(have)-374(been)-373(known)-374(to)-373(those)-374(with)-373(whom)-373(He)-374(lived;)-435(it)-373(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-229(been)-229(known)-229(to)-229(those)-229(who)-229(visited)-229(Him.)-243(His)-229(death)-229(must)-228(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(dispelled)-399(their)-399(delusions.)-696(Henceforth)-399(the)-399(propagation)-399(of)-398(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(story)-324(must)-324(have)-324(been)-323(due)-324(to)-324(wilful)-324(fraud)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 182.28 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(a)-324(fraud)-324(for)-324(which)-323(it)]TJ -193.189 -13.549 Td [(is)-275(impossible)-275(to)-275(assign)-275(a)-276(motive,)-281(and)-275(which)-275(it)-275(is)-275(not)-275(the)-275(modern)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(practice)-250(to)-250(charge)-250(on)-250(the)-250(first)-250(propagators)-250(of)-250(Christianity.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(The)-259(remaining)-259(supposition,)-261(that)-259(Jesus,)-261(after)-259(having)-259(been)-259(seen)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(by)-256(one)-255(or)-256(two)-255(of)-256(His)-255(followers)-256(alive)-255(and)-256(slowly)-256(recovering,)-256(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(conveyed)-335(away)-334(to)-335(some)-335(distant)-335(place,)-356(where)-334(they)-335(saw)-335(Him)-334(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more,)-245(and)-243(that)-244(out)-243(of)-243(this)-244(grew)-243(the)-244(story)-243(of)-244(His)-243(Resurrection)-243(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Ascension)-287(into)-286(Heaven,)-296(is)-286(not)-287(only)-286(in)-287(itself)-286(intrinsically)-286(incred-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ible,)-374(but)-350(it)-349(offends)-349(against)-349(every)-350(one)-349(of)-349(the)-350(principles)-349(which)-349(I)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-250(established.)-250(I)-250(need)-250(not,)-250(therefore,)-250(discuss)-250(it)-250(further.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(The)-294(existence)-295(of)-294(the)-295(Church)-294(is)-295(a)-294(fact.)-384(It)-294(is)-295(professedly)-294(based)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(on)-333(another)-333(fact,)-353(namely,)-354(the)-332(Resurrection)-666(of)-333(Christ.)-498(If)-333(this)-332(be)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([472])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(true,)-242(it)-240(fully)-240(accounts)-240(for)-240(the)-240(existence,)-242(origin,)-242(and)-240(growth)-240(of)-239(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church.)-553(No)-351(other)-351(theory)-351(can)-351(account)-351(for)-351(it.)-553(The)-351(Resurrection)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-433(a)-433(fact,)-479(or)-433(a)-433(delusion.)-799(If)-433(it)-433(is)-433(not)-434(a)-433(fact,)-478(two)-433(suppositions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(respecting)-241(its)-241(origin)-241(are)-241(alone)-241(possible.)-247(These)-241(have)-241(been)-240(proved,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-244(the)-243(strongest)-244(historical)-244(evidence,)-245(to)-243(be)-244(impossible.)-248(It)-243(follows,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore,)-243(that)-242(the)-242(only)-242(remaining)-242(alternative)-241(is)-242(the)-242(true)-242(one:)-245(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(J)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 4.244 0 Td [(ESUS)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 22.059 0 Td [(C)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 7.276 0 Td [(HRIST)-323(ROSE)-322(FROM)-323(THE)-323(DEAD)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 113.898 0 Td [(.)-236(Its)-235(attestation)-236(is)-236(stronger)-236(than)]TJ -147.477 -13.549 Td [(that)-250(of)-250(any)-250(other)-250(fact)-250(in)-250(history.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 -29.651 Td [([473])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1914 0 obj <<
/Length 3564      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 93.543 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-254(XXI.)-254(The)-254(Historical)-254(Value)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Of)-255(The)-255(Gospels)-255(As)-255(Deduced)-255(From)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Previous)-250(Considerations.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -37.658 Td [(I)-279(have)-278(proved)-279(in)-278(the)-279(preceding)-279(chapters)-278(that)-279(one)-278(of)-279(the)-278(miracles)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recorded)-451(in)-451(the)-452(Gospels)-451(is)-451(substantiated)-451(by)-451(the)-451(highest)-451(form)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-355(historical)-355(testimony,)-381(on)-355(evidence)-355(quite)-355(independent)-355(of)-355(their)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(contents.)-378(I)-292(have)-293(adopted)-292(this)-293(course)-292(because)-293(unbelievers)-292(affirm)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-266(the)-267(miraculous)-266(narratives)-266(contained)-266(in)-267(them)-266(are)-266(alone)-266(suffi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cient)-322(to)-323(prove)-322(them)-323(to)-322(be)-322(unhistorical.)-467(It)-323(has)-322(therefore)-322(become)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary)-334(to)-334(prove)-334(the)-335(truth)-334(of)-334(the)-334(greatest)-334(miracle)-334(which)-334(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(narrate,)-412(without)-380(any)-380(reference)-380(to)-380(their)-380(assertions.)-639(Christianity)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(unquestionably)-261(existed)-261(before)-261(the)-261(Gospels)-261(were)-261(written,)-263(and)-261(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all-important)-285(fact)-284(on)-285(which)-284(it)-284(rests)-285(can)-284(be)-285(substantiated)-284(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-248(aid,)-248(on)-248(data)-248(which)-248(are)-248(conceded)-248(by)-248(our)-248(opponents.)-249(Its)-248(truth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-309(falsehood)-309(therefore)-308(does)-309(not)-309(rest)-309(on)-308(any)-309(mere)-309(question)-309(as)-308(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(what)-282(was)-282(their)-282(actual)-282(date,)-290(or)-282(who)-282(were)-282(their)-282(authors.)-346(Stil)1(l)-282(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-343(the)-343(only)-343(records)-344(of)-343(the)-343(life)-343(of)-343(Jesus)-343(Christ)-343(that)-343(the)-343(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possesses.)-370(The)-290(question)-290(therefore)-290(as)-290(to)-290(whether)-290(they)-290(are)-290(true)-290(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-298(their)-298(chief)-299(outlines,)-310(is)-298(one)-298(of)-298(such)-299(importance)-298(as)-298(to)-298(render)-298(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(few)-250(observations)-250(on)-250(this)-250(subject)-250(indispensable.)]TJ 11.956 -14.597 Td [(There)-325(can)-325(be)-326(no)-325(doubt)-325(that)-325(no)-326(one)-325(would)-325(have)-325(ever)-325(thought)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(of)-347(denying)-347(their)-347(general)-347(authenticity,)-371(except)-347(on)-347(account)-347(of)-346(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miraculous)-442(narratives)-443(they)-442(contain.)-826(This)-443(has)-442(made)-442(them)-442(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(battle-field)-274(of)-275(Christianity,)-560(because)-275(it)-274(has)-274(been)-275(supposed)-274(that)-274(if)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([474])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(their)-369(historical)-368(character)-369(can)-369(be)-369(shaken,)-398(Christianity)-369(would)-368(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disproved)-350(as)-350(resting)-350(on)-350(no)-350(other)-350(basis.)-550(For)-350(this)-350(purpose)-349(every)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(variation)-326(in)-325(them,)-344(even)-326(the)-325(smallest,)-345(has)-325(been)-326(noted,)-344(and)-325(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(variations)-442(have)-442(been)-442(magnified)-442(into)-442(contradictions.)-826(There)-442(is)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1918 0 obj <<
/Length 4747      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(415)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(no)-396(weapon)-395(which)-396(criticism)-396(has)-396(not)-395(employed)-396(for)-396(the)-395(purpose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-448(impugning)-447(their)-448(veracity.)-843(But)-447(the)-448(real)-447(ground)-448(of)-447(offence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-405(the)-406(miraculous)-405(narrative.)-716(As,)-444(however,)-444(I)-405(have)-405(proved)-405(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-291(most)-291(important)-291(miracle)-290(recorded)-291(in)-291(them)-291(can)-291(be)-290(established)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-383(grounds)-382(quite)-383(independent)-383(of)-383(their)-382(testimony,)-416(we)-383(can)-382(now)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(approach)-231(their)-231(consideration)-232(with)-231(this)-231(great)-231(antecedent)-231(difficulty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(removed.)-563(If)-355(the)-354(Resurrection)-354(of)-355(Jesus)-354(is)-355(an)-354(actual)-354(occurrence,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-390(other)-389(miraculous)-390(events)-389(recorded)-390(in)-390(them)-389(no)-390(longer)-389(stand)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-387(the)-387(way)-388(of)-387(their)-387(acceptance)-387(as)-387(genuine)-388(histories.)-661(This)-387(one)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(miracle)-345(is)-344(sufficient)-345(to)-344(carry)-345(all)-344(the)-344(rest;)-392(not,)-368(of)-345(course,)-368(that)-344(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proves)-362(that)-361(they)-362(occurred,)-389(but)-362(it)-361(gets)-362(rid)-361(of)-362(the)-361(entire)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 245.77 0 Td [(\340)-362(priori)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -245.77 -13.549 Td [(difficulty)-286(with)-286(which)-286(their)-286(acceptance)-286(is)-286(attended.)-358(Nay,)-295(further,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-344(Christ)-343(rose)-344(from)-344(the)-344(dead,)-367(it)-343(is)-344(more)-344(probable)-344(than)-343(not,)-367(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-323(was)-323(not)-323(the)-323(only)-323(miracle)-323(connected)-323(with)-323(Him:)-395(or,)-342(in)-322(other)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(words,)-337(if)-320(the)-319(authors)-320(of)-319(the)-320(Gospels)-319(attributed)-320(to)-319(Him)-320(no)-319(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(miraculous)-308(action,)-323(it)-308(would)-308(rather)-307(afford)-308(a)-308(presumption)-308(against)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-200(as)-199(credible)-200(historians.)-233(It)-199(follows)-200(therefore,)-209(that)-200(although)-199(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proof)-198(of)-197(the)-198(Resurrection)-197(does)-198(not)-197(by)-198(it)1(self)-198(establish)-197(the)-198(reality)-197(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-237(other)-236(miracles)-237(recorded)-237(as)-236(having)-237(been)-237(performed)-236(by)-237(Him,)-239(it)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(renders)-262(them)-261(so)-262(far)-262(probable,)-264(that)-262(the)-262(same)-261(amount)-262(of)-261(evidence,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-351(is)-350(sufficient)-351(to)-351(establish)-351(the)-350(ordinary)-351(facts)-351(of)-351(history,)-375(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sufficient)-390(to)-389(establish)-390(the)-390(general)-390(truth)-389(of)-390(the)-390(events)-389(recorded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-312(the)-312(Gospels.)-436(I)-311(do)-312(not)-312(mean)-312(to)-312(affirm)-312(that)-312(some)-312(miracle)-311(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-267(have)-267(been)-267(incorrectly)-268(attributed)-267(to)-267(Christ)-267(in)-267(the)-267(traditions)-267(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-251(Church,)-251(from)-250(which)-251(the)-251(narratives)-250(in)-251(the)-250(Gospels)-251(have)-251(been)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([475])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(derived,)-295(in)-286(the)-286(same)-287(manner)-286(as)-286(some)-286(inaccurate)-286(reports)-286(of)-286(facts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-392(obtained)-392(admission)-392(into)-392(ordinary)-392(histories.)-676(But)-392(as)-392(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(latter)-373(do)-372(not)-373(affect)-373(the)-372(general)-373(credibility)-373(of)-372(history,)-404(so)-372(errors)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-262(this)-262(description)-261(would)-262(not)-262(affect)-261(the)-262(general)-262(credibility)-262(of)-261(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospel)-224(narratives.)-241(All)-223(that)-224(I)-223(claim)-224(for)-223(them)-224(is)-223(that)-223(they)-224(should)-223(be)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(both)-334(alike)-334(tried)-334(by)-334(the)-334(historical)-334(canons)-334(of)-334(criticism)-333(applicable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-300(the)-300(same)-300(species)-300(of)-301(documents.)-400(Let)-300(me)-300(state)-300(once)-300(for)-300(all)-300(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(position)-214(that)-215(I)-214(occupy.)-238(I)-215(am)-214(not)-215(called)-214(upon)-215(to)-214(prove)-215(that)-214(no)-214(error)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-248(have)-249(crept)-248(into)-248(their)-248(accounts;)-249(that)-248(events)-249(are)-248(all)-248(arranged)-248(in)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1922 0 obj <<
/Length 4943      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(416)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(their)-277(true)-277(order)-277(of)-277(sequence;)-291(that)-277(variations)-277(do)-277(not)-277(exist)-277(in)-277(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-250(with)-251(our)-250(present)-251(knowledge)-250(of)-250(the)-251(details,)-250(it)-251(is)-250(difficult)-250(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reconcile,)-273(or)-269(even)-269(that)-269(the)-268(Evangelists)-269(themselves)-269(may)-269(not)-268(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(misconceived)-308(their)-307(true)-308(order,)-322(or)-307(grouped)-308(them)-308(in)-307(one)-308(that)-307(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-264(result)-265(of)-264(religious)-265(considerations.)-293(The)-265(determination)-264(of)-264(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(questions)-238(may)-238(affect)-238(our)-238(views)-238(as)-238(to)-238(the)-238(nature)-238(of)-238(the)-237(inspiration)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(under)-324(which)-324(we)-323(suppose)-324(the)-324(Gospels)-324(to)-324(have)-323(been)-324(written,)-342(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-257(is)-257(one)-258(wholly)-257(foreign)-257(to)-257(an)-257(historical)-258(discussion.)-271(The)-257(question)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-321(I)-320(have)-321(to)-321(consider)-321(is,)-338(not)-321(the)-321(extent)-320(of)-321(the)-321(inspiration)-320(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(their)-415(authors;)-496(but)-415(whether)-414(they)-415(do)-414(or)-415(do)-414(not)-415(contain)-414(genuine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(history;)-336(and)-307(if)-307(they)-307(do,)-321(to)-307(what)-307(class)-307(of)-307(historical)-307(writings)-307(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(belong,)-250(and)-250(to)-250(estimate)-250(their)-250(testimony)-250(accordingly.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-458(will)-459(consider)-459(this)-459(last)-458(question)-459(first.)-876(The)-459(Gospels)-458(most)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(distinctly)-243(affirm)-243(that)-243(they)-242(do)-243(not)-243(belong)-243(to)-243(the)-243(class)-243(of)-242(professed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(histories,)-332(but)-315(to)-315(that)-315(of)-316(memoirs.)-445(This)-316(is)-315(a)-315(very)-315(important)-315(con-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sideration;)-245(for)-243(if)-242(they)-243(only)-242(claim)-243(to)-242(be)-243(memoirs)-242(and)-243(not)-242(histories)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-299(is)-299(absurd)-298(to)-299(demand)-299(of)-299(them)-298(an)-299(accuracy)-299(of)-299(arrangement)-298(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-253(detail,)-253(which)-253(would)-253(be)-253(essential)-253(to)-252(a)-253(history,)-254(but)-253(which)-252(forms)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-246(portion)-246(of)-245(the)-246(plan)-246(of)-246(a)-246(memoir.)-248(But)-246(they)-246(not)-246(only)-246(affirm)-245(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-260(are)-260(memoirs,)-263(but)-260(memoirs)-260(of)-260(a)-260(peculiar)-260(character;)-265(that)-260(is)-260(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(say,)-347(religious)-655(memoirs,)-346(composed)-328(with)-327(a)-327(double)-328(purpose,)-346(viz.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([476])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(that)-291(of)-292(setting)-291(forth)-291(the)-292(events)-291(of)-292(a)-291(life,)-302(and)-291(at)-291(the)-292(same)-291(time)-291(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(teaching)-250(a)-250(religion.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(This)-309(point)-308(is)-309(so)-309(important,)-323(and)-309(is)-308(so)-309(generally)-309(overlooked)-308(in)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-304(arguments)-303(both)-304(of)-303(those)-304(who)-304(affirm)-303(and)-304(of)-303(those)-304(who)-303(deny)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-295(historical)-294(character,)-306(that)-294(it)-295(will)-295(be)-294(necessary)-295(to)-294(prove)-295(it.)-383(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-265(not)-266(only)-265(evident)-265(from)-266(the)-265(general)-265(nature)-266(of)-265(their)-265(contents,)-269(but)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(three)-238(of)-237(the)-238(Evangelists)-237(directly)-237(affirm)-238(it,)-240(and)-237(two)-238(of)-237(them,)-240(Luke)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-273(John,)-279(in)-273(express)-273(terms.)-320(The)-273(former)-273(distinctly)-273(asserts)-273(that)-273(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(composed)-266(his)-266(Gospel)-267(in)-266(order)-266(that)-266(a)-266(person)-266(called)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 221.852 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Theophilus)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 49.09 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(might)-405(know)-404(the)-405(certainty)-404(of)-404(the)-405(things)-404(in)-405(which)-404(he)-405(had)-404(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instructed.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 49.785 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Forasmuch)-290(as)-290(many)-290(have)-289(taken)-290(in)-290(hand)-290(to)-290(set)-290(forth)]TJ -54.629 -13.55 Td [(a)-228(declaration)-229(of)-228(these)-229(things)-228(that)-229(are)-228(most)-229(surely)-228(believed)-228(among)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us;)-322(even)-297(as)-298(they)-298(delivered)-298(them)-298(unto)-297(us,)-310(which)-298(from)-298(the)-297(begin-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1926 0 obj <<
/Length 4567      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(417)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(ning)-367(were)-367(eye)-367(witnesses)-367(and)-367(ministers)-367(of)-367(the)-367(word;)-425(it)-367(seemed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(good)-248(to)-247(me)-248(also,)-248(having)-248(perfect)-248(understanding)-247(of)-248(all)-248(things)-247(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-290(first,)-300(to)-290(write)-291(unto)-290(thee)-290(in)-290(order,)-300(most)-290(excellent)-290(Theophilus,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-345(thou)-345(mightest)-344(know)-345(the)-345(certainty)-344(of)-345(those)-345(things)-345(in)-344(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(thou)-250(hast)-250(been)-250(instructed.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 111.502 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050Luke)-250(i.)-250(1-4.\051)]TJ -107.117 -15.185 Td [(Here)-264(we)-263(have)-264(the)-263(purpose)-264(of)-264(the)-263(writer)-264(definitely)-264(affirmed.)-290(It)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(is)-249(t)1(o)-249(set)-248(forth)-249(a)-248(statement)-249(of)-248(the)-249(leading)-248(facts)-249(of)-248(the)-249(life)-248(of)-248(Jesus,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-396(the)-397(purpose)-396(of)-396(communicating)-397(instruction)-396(in)-396(the)-396(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(religion.)-592(In)-364(one)-364(word,)-392(the)-364(author)-364(proposed)-364(to)-364(teach)-364(a)-363(religion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-376(means)-375(of)-375(a)-376(narrative)-375(of)-376(facts.)-626(It)-376(is)-375(hardly)-376(possible)-375(to)-375(give)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-328(more)-328(accurate)-328(description)-328(of)-328(a)-328(memoir)-328(as)-328(distinguished)-327(from)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-395(history.)-684(He)-395(also)-394(tells)-395(us)-395(that)-394(he)-395(meant)-395(to)-394(compose)-395(it)-395(in)-394(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(orderly)-351(arrangement,)-376(but)-351(he)-351(does)-351(not)-351(tell)-351(us)-351(whether)-351(the)-351(order)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-238(intended)-238(to)-238(be)-239(strictly)-238(chronological,)-240(or)-238(merely)-238(regulated)-238(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-332(avowed)-331(religious)-332(purpose)-331(of)-332(the)-331(work.)-495(It)-332(is)-331(quite)-663(possible)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([477])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(for)-335(a)-335(writer)-335(to)-335(adopt)-335(an)-335(orderly)-334(arrangement,)-357(who)-335(arranges)-334(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(matter)-313(as)-313(much)-314(by)-313(religious)-313(considerations)-313(as)-313(by)-313(chronological)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ones.)-555(According)-352(to)-352(the)-352(statement)-352(of)-352(this)-351(preface,)-378(the)-351(religious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purpose)-309(is)-309(clearly)-308(the)-309(predominant)-309(one;)-338(and)-309(it)-309(is)-309(therefore)-308(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reasonable)-293(to)-292(suppose)-293(that)-293(it)-292(has)-293(exerted)-293(considerable)-292(influence)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-250(the)-250(grouping.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(We)-374(learn)-375(also)-374(from)-374(this)-375(preface)-374(that)-374(the)-375(things)-374(most)-374(surely)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(believed)-232(among)-232(Christians)-231(consisted)-232(of)-232(a)-232(number)-231(of)-232(facts,)-235(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-295(been)-295(delivered)-295(to)-295(them)-295(by)-295(persons)-295(who)-295(from)-295(the)-295(beginning)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(were)-320(eye-witnesses)-321(and)-320(ministers)-320(of)-320(the)-320(word.)-461(Several)-320(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-279(already)-278(set)-279(forth)-279(written)-278(accounts)-279(of)-279(them)-278(before)-279(the)-278(author)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(composed)-461(this)-461(Gospel.)-883(It)-461(is)-461(implied)-461(that)-461(he)-461(did)-461(so)-460(because)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-397(possessed)-397(better)-397(and)-397(more)-397(accurate)-397(sources)-397(of)-396(information)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(than)-445(previous)-445(writers.)-835(The)-445(object,)-494(however,)-494(is)-445(clear;)-542(it)-445(was)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-395(Theophilus)-394(might)-394(know)-395(the)-394(certainty)-395(of)-394(those)-395(things,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 267.299 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -267.299 -13.549 Td [(the)-315(great)-315(facts)-314(on)-315(which)-315(the)-315(Christianity,)-330(in)-315(which)-315(he)-315(had)-314(been)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instructed,)-250(was)-250(based.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-311(assertion)-310(of)-311(this)-311(religious)-311(purpose)-310(in)-311(the)-311(composition)-310(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-320(fourth)-320(Gospel,)-337(and)-320(that)-320(the)-319(materials)-320(are)-320(a)-320(selection)-320(from)-319(a)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1931 0 obj <<
/Length 5032      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(418)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(large)-322(mass)-323(of)-322(others)-322(is)-322(even)-323(more)-322(distinct)-322(and)-323(definite.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 250.336 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Many)]TJ -255.179 -13.549 Td [(other)-240(signs)-240(truly)-240(did)-241(Jesus)-240(in)-240(the)-240(presence)-240(of)-240(his)-240(disciples,)-242(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-362(not)-361(written)-362(in)-361(this)-362(book,)-389(but)-362(these)-361(are)-362(written)-361(that)-362(ye)-361(may)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believe)-198(that)-197(Jesus)-198(is)-198(the)-197(Christ,)-208(the)-198(Son)-197(of)-198(God,)-208(and)-198(that)-197(believing)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ye)-250(may)-250(have)-250(life)-250(through)-250(his)-250(name.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 153.611 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050John)-250(xx.)-250(30,)-250(31.\051)]TJ -149.226 -14.531 Td [(Words)-281(could)-280(hardly)-281(have)-281(been)-280(framed)-281(which)-281(more)-280(definitely)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(assert)-215(that)-214(this)-215(Gospel)-215(is)-214(a)-215(memoir,)-222(and)-214(not)-215(a)-215(history;)-226(and)-215(that)-214(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(religious)-296(purpose,)-308(in)-296(its)-296(composition,)-308(was)-296(the)-296(predominant)-296(idea)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(the)-250(writer.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(The)-196(assertions)-196(of)-196(the)-196(author)-196(of)-196(St.)-232(Mark's)-196(Gospel,)-207(although)-195(not)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(equally)-319(full,)-335(are)-319(sufficiently)-319(definite.)-455(He)-638(designates)-318(it)-319(as)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 258.823 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -336.422 0 Td [([478])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(beginning)-318(of)-318(the)-318(gladsome)-319(message)-318(of)-318(Jesus)-318(Christ,)-335(the)-318(Son)-318(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(God.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 21.513 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.961 0 Td [(Here,)-295(again,)-294(the)-286(religious)-286(idea)-285(is)-286(plainly)-286(the)-286(predominant)]TJ -29.474 -13.549 Td [(one)-338(in)-338(the)-338(writer's)-338(mind,)-360(and)-338(the)-338(obvious)-338(conclusion)-338(is)-338(that)-338(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intended)-250(his)-250(work)-250(to)-250(be)-250(a)-250(memoir,)-250(and)-250(not)-250(a)-250(history.)]TJ 11.956 -14.532 Td [(We)-505(have)-505(no)-505(such)-505(direct)-505(affirmation)-505(by)-505(the)-505(author)-505(of)-504(St.)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Matthew's)-311(Gospel,)-325(unless)-311(the)-310(opening)-311(words,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 204.422 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)-311(book)-310(of)-311(the)]TJ -209.266 -13.549 Td [(generations)-292(of)-291(Jesus)-292(Christ,)-301(the)-292(Son)-292(of)-291(David,)-302(the)-291(Son)-292(of)-291(Abra-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ham,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 21.513 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.627 0 Td [(are)-347(intended)-347(to)-346(cover)-347(the)-347(entire)-347(work.)-540(The)-347(nature)-347(of)-347(its)]TJ -30.14 -13.549 Td [(contents,)-227(however,)-227(leave)-222(not)-221(the)-222(smallest)-221(doubt)-222(that)-221(his)-222(design)-221(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writing)-309(was)-309(precisely)-309(the)-309(same)-309(as)-309(that)-309(of)-309(the)-309(other)-308(Evangelists,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(viz.)-305(to)-268(teach)-268(Christianity)-268(by)-268(setting)-268(forth)-269(a)-268(memoir)-268(of)-268(the)-268(life)-268(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-250(Christ.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(Such,)-334(then,)-334(is)-317(the)-317(avowed)-317(purpose)-317(of)-317(the)-317(authors)-317(of)-317(the)-317(four)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Gospels.)-447(Each)-316(of)-316(them)-316(is)-316(a)-315(religious)-316(memoir.)-448(This)-315(being)-316(so,)-332(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-278(absurd)-278(to)-279(demand)-278(of)-278(such)-278(writings)-278(what)-279(can)-278(only)-278(be)-278(found)-278(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(regularly)-250(composed)-250(histories.)]TJ 11.956 -14.531 Td [(In)-438(what,)-486(then,)-486(does)-438(a)-438(history)-439(differ)-438(from)-439(a)-438(memoir?)-815(The)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(object)-218(of)-219(the)-218(historian)-218(is)-219(not)-218(only)-218(to)-219(give)-218(an)-218(account)-219(of)-218(the)-218(events)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-373(he)-372(narrates)-373(precisely)-372(as)-373(they)-373(occurred;)-434(but)-372(the)-373(order)-372(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-323(narrative)-323(is)-323(regulated)-323(by)-323(the)-323(definite)-323(sequences)-323(of)-323(time)-322(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(place.)-407(The)-302(writer)-302(of)-302(a)-302(memoir,)-315(on)-303(the)-302(contrary,)-315(is)-302(not)-302(bound)-302(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(observe)-255(this)-254(order,)-256(but)-255(he)-255(is)-254(entitled)-255(to)-255(vary)-255(it)-254(in)-255(reference)-255(to)-254(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(special)-229(object)-230(he)-229(has)-229(in)-230(view,)-233(and)-230(the)-229(points)-229(which)-230(he)-229(requires)-229(to)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1935 0 obj <<
/Length 4685      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(419)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(illustrate.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-305(the)-304(religious)-305(purpose)-304(is)-305(most)-305(definitely)-304(affirmed)-305(to)-304(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(been)-420(the)-419(predominant)-420(one)-420(in)-419(the)-420(minds)-420(of)-419(the)-420(authors)-420(of)-419(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels.)-877(It)-459(would)-459(therefore)-459(have)-459(an)-459(important)-459(influence)-459(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-342(arrangement)-341(of)-342(their)-341(materials.)-525(We)-342(should)-341(expect)-342(to)-341(find)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-262(grouped)-262(far)-262(more)-262(in)-262(reference)-262(to)-262(this)-262(end,)-265(than)-262(to)-262(the)-262(mere)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sequences)-410(of)-411(time)-410(and)-411(place.)-731(When)-411(certain)-410(of)-411(the)-410(actions)-410(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(portions)-768(of)-384(the)-384(teaching)-384(of)-384(our)-384(Lord)-384(illustrated)-384(the)-383(particular)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([479])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(subject)-251(which)-251(each)-250(Evangelist)-251(had)-251(before)-251(him,)-251(he)-251(would)-250(neglect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-378(exact)-378(historical)-378(order,)-411(and)-378(group)-378(them)-378(in)-378(reference)-378(to)-378(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(special)-250(purpose.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(In)-355(writings)-354(of)-355(this)-354(description,)-381(therefore,)-381(while)-354(all)-355(the)-354(chief)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(points)-228(of)-227(his)-228(life)-227(and)-228(his)-228(discourses)-227(ought)-228(to)-227(present)-228(a)-227(substantial)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(agreement,)-466(we)-423(should)-422(naturally)-423(expect)-422(to)-423(find)-423(a)-422(considerable)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(number)-321(of)-322(minor)-321(divergencies.)-464(While)-321(we)-322(have)-321(the)-321(fullest)-321(right)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-315(expect)-315(that)-315(the)-315(facts)-315(will)-315(be)-315(accurately)-315(reported,)-331(we)-315(have)-315(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(right)-278(to)-279(demand)-278(that)-278(the)-279(writer)-278(should)-278(observe)-279(no)-278(other)-278(order)-278(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-272(narrative)-273(than)-272(the)-273(mere)-272(sequences)-272(of)-273(time)-272(and)-273(place.)-317(It)-272(is)-272(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-367(assumption)-367(that)-367(the)-367(authors)-367(of)-367(the)-367(Gospels)-367(intended)-367(to)-367(set)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(forth)-214(an)-213(exact)-214(historical)-214(account)-214(of)-213(the)-214(ministry)-214(of)-213(Christ,)-221(instead)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-251(taking)-250(them)-251(for)-250(what)-251(they)-250(have)-251(affirmed)-251(them)-250(to)-251(be,)-250(religious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(memoirs)-251(of)-250(that)-250(ministry,)-251(that)-251(no)-250(inconsiderable)-251(number)-250(of)-250(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(alleged)-250(discrepancies)-250(have)-250(originated.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(The)-361(presence)-360(of)-361(variations,)-389(or)-360(if)-361(it)-361(is)-360(preferred)-361(to)-361(call)-360(them)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(contradictions,)-240(in)-238(writings)-238(of)-238(this)-237(description)-238(by)-238(no)-238(means)-237(inval-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(idates)-318(their)-318(historical)-318(character.)-453(It)-318(has)-318(been)-318(well)-318(observed)-318(by)-317(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writer)-359(in)-359(the)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 59.62 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Westminster)-359(Review,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 95.116 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.761 0 Td [(that)-359(they)-359(are)-359(to)-359(be)-359(found)]TJ -168.34 -13.55 Td [(in)-351(every)-351(historical)-350(writing)-351(from)-351(Herodotus)-351(to)-351(Mr.)-552(Froude.)-552(As)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-395(discrepancies)-395(in)-395(the)-396(Gospels)-395(are)-395(so)-395(largely)-395(dwelt)-395(on)-395(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unbelievers,)-279(I)-274(subjoin)-273(a)-273(passage)-274(from)-273(Dean)-274(Stanley's)-273(account)-273(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-202(murder)-203(of)-202(Thomas)-203(a)-202(Becket,)-212(in)-203(his)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 165.931 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Memorials)-202(of)-203(Canterbury)]TJ -170.776 -13.549 Td [(Cathedral,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 45.142 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.909 0 Td [(as)-189(showing)-190(the)-189(existence)-189(of)-189(such)-190(inaccuracies)-189(even)-189(in)]TJ -52.051 -13.55 Td [(the)-236(accounts)-235(of)-236(persons)-235(who)-236(were)-236(actual)-235(eye-witnesses)-236(of)-235(events)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-236(which)-236(they)-236(were)-236(deeply)-236(interested.)-245(Speaking)-236(of)-236(the)-236(number)-235(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1939 0 obj <<
/Length 5028      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(420)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(existing)-250(accounts)-250(of)-250(the)-250(murder,)-250(he)-250(says:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 177.851 0 Td [(\024)]TJ -165.895 -16.004 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Of)-489(these)-490(thirty)-489(narrators,)-550(four,)-549(Edward)-489(Grimes,)-550(William)]TJ -16.799 -13.549 Td [(Fitzstephen,)-366(John)-343(of)-343(Salisbury,)-366(who)-343(unfortunately)-343(supplies)-343(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(little,)-420(and)-385(the)-386(anonymous)-385(author)-772(of)-385(the)-386(Lambeth)-385(manuscript,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([480])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(claim)-426(to)-426(have)-426(been)-425(eye-witnesses.)-778(Three)-426(others)-426(were)-425(monks)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-330(the)-330(convent,)-350(and)-331(although)-330(not)-330(present)-330(at)-330(the)-330(massacre,)-350(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(probably)-316(somewhere)-315(in)-316(the)-316(precincts.)-447(Three)-316(others,)-332(though)-315(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-284(England)-285(at)-284(the)-285(time,)-293(had)-284(been)-284(on)-285(terms)-284(more)-285(or)-284(less)-284(intimate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-389(Becket,)-423(and)-389(two)-389(of)-388(them)-389(seem)-389(to)-388(have)-389(taken)-389(the)-388(utmost)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pains)-259(to)-259(ascertain)-259(the)-259(truth)-260(of)-259(the)-259(facts)-259(which)-259(they)-259(narrate.)-277(From)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(these)-443(several)-444(accounts,)-491(we)-444(can)-443(recover)-443(the)-444(particulars)-443(of)-443(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(death)-387(of)-387(Archbishop)-387(Becket)-387(to)-387(the)-387(minutest)-387(details.)-661(It)-387(is)-386(true)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-456(having)-455(been)-456(written)-455(by)-456(monastic)-455(and)-456(clerical)-455(historians,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(after)-373(the)-373(national)-373(feeling)-372(had)-373(been)-373(raised)-373(to)-373(enthusiasm)-373(in)-372(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(behalf,)-344(allowance)-325(must)-325(be)-325(made)-325(for)-326(exaggeration,)-343(suppression,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-200(every)-199(kind)-200(of)-200(false)-200(colouring)-199(which)-200(could)-200(set)-199(off)-200(their)-200(hero)-199(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(advantage.)-241(It)-222(is)-223(true,)-228(also,)-228(that)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 132.133 0 Td [(in)-222(some)-223(points)-222(the)-223(various)-222(author-)]TJ -132.133 -13.549 Td [(ities)-224(are)-224(hopelessly)-224(irreconcilable)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 147.312 0 Td [(.)-241(But)-224(still)-224(a)-224(minute)-224(comparison)]TJ -147.312 -13.549 Td [(of)-277(the)-277(narrators)-278(with)-277(each)-277(other,)-284(and)-277(with)-277(the)-277(localities,)-284(leads)-277(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-295(conviction)-295(that)-295(on)-295(the)-295(whole)-295(the)-295(facts)-295(have)-295(been)-295(substantially)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(preserved;)-317(and)-295(as)-295(often)-295(happens,)-306(the)-294(truth)-295(can)-295(be)-295(ascertained)-294(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(spite)-217(and)-218(even)-217(in)-217(consequence)-217(of)-217(attempts)-218(to)-217(distort)-217(and)-217(suppress)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 8.793 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 3.163 -16.004 Td [(It)-270(is)-271(clear,)-275(therefore,)-276(that)-270(the)-271(presence)-270(of)-271(variations,)-275(nay)-270(even)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf -11.956 -13.549 Td [(hopeless)-176(contradictions)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 104.443 0 Td [(in)-176(such)-176(narratives,)-191(does)-176(not)-176(interfere)-176(with)]TJ -104.443 -13.549 Td [(their)-276(general)-276(historical)-276(character.)-328(It)-276(appears)-276(that)-276(from)-276(narratives)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-447(contain)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 68.537 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(exaggeration,)-497(suppression,)-496(and)-447(every)-448(kind)-447(of)]TJ -73.38 -13.55 Td [(false)-270(colouring,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 68.089 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.794 0 Td [(we)-270(can)-271(ascertain)-270(the)-271(particulars)-270(of)-271(the)-270(death)-270(of)]TJ -75.883 -13.549 Td [(Becket)-261(to)-260(the)-261(minutest)-260(particular.)-282(Why)-261(do)-260(not)-261(unbelievers)-260(apply)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-366(same)-367(rule)-366(to)-366(the)-366(Gospels?)-599(Why)-367(are)-366(their)-366(minor)-366(variations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-356(details)-356(alleged)-356(to)-357(prove)-356(that)-356(the)-356(entire)-356(narrative)-356(is)-356(unhistor-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ical?)-509(One)-336(thing)-336(respecting)-336(them)-336(is)-337(clear:)-422(instead)-336(of)-336(presenting)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(indications)-298(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 63.471 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(exaggeration,)-310(suppression,)-310(and)-298(false)-298(colouring,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 207.472 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.549 Td [(they)-248(are)-496(characterized)-248(by)-248(a)-248(uniform)-248(sobriety)-248(in)-248(their)-248(statements.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([481])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1803 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 983
/Length 9129      
>>
stream
1798 0 1805 78 1807 197 1804 254 1808 320 1811 361 1813 441 1809 560 1815 618 1812 677
1817 755 1819 874 1816 932 1822 998 1824 1117 1821 1176 1826 1254 1828 1373 1825 1432 1830 1498
1832 1617 1829 1676 1834 1742 1836 1861 1833 1919 1838 1997 1840 2116 1841 2174 1837 2232 1843 2298
1845 2417 1842 2475 1848 2553 1850 2672 1847 2731 1852 2821 1854 2940 1851 2998 1856 3076 1858 3195
1855 3254 1860 3320 1862 3439 1859 3498 1864 3564 1866 3683 1863 3742 1868 3820 1870 3939 1871 3998
1867 4055 1874 4121 1876 4240 1873 4298 1878 4364 1880 4483 1877 4541 1882 4619 1884 4738 1881 4796
1886 4874 1888 4993 1885 5052 1890 5118 1892 5237 1889 5296 1894 5374 1896 5493 1897 5552 1893 5609
1900 5675 1902 5794 1899 5853 1904 5919 1906 6038 1907 6096 1903 6153 1908 6231 1911 6272 1913 6377
1909 6496 1915 6554 1912 6613 1917 6679 1919 6798 1916 6857 1921 6935 1923 7054 1920 7113 1925 7191
1927 7310 1924 7368 1930 7458 1932 7577 1929 7636 1934 7714 1936 7833 1933 7890 1938 7968 1940 8087
% 1798 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1805 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1806 0 R
/Resources 1804 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1789 0 R
>>
% 1807 0 obj
<<
/D [1805 0 R /XYZ 46.771 328.17 null]
>>
% 1804 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1808 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index21) >>
% 1811 0 obj
(Chapter XX. The Resurrection Of Jesus Christ An Historical Fact.)
% 1813 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1814 0 R
/Resources 1812 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1789 0 R
>>
% 1809 0 obj
<<
/D [1813 0 R /XYZ 93.543 529.134 null]
>>
% 1815 0 obj
<<
/D [1813 0 R /XYZ 328.236 120.339 null]
>>
% 1812 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1817 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1818 0 R
/Resources 1816 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1820 0 R
>>
% 1819 0 obj
<<
/D [1817 0 R /XYZ 86.063 175.149 null]
>>
% 1816 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1822 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1823 0 R
/Resources 1821 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1820 0 R
>>
% 1824 0 obj
<<
/D [1822 0 R /XYZ 235.835 242.282 null]
>>
% 1821 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1826 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1827 0 R
/Resources 1825 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1820 0 R
>>
% 1828 0 obj
<<
/D [1826 0 R /XYZ 209.547 310.028 null]
>>
% 1825 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1830 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1831 0 R
/Resources 1829 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1820 0 R
>>
% 1832 0 obj
<<
/D [1830 0 R /XYZ 113.103 369.134 null]
>>
% 1829 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1834 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1835 0 R
/Resources 1833 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1820 0 R
>>
% 1836 0 obj
<<
/D [1834 0 R /XYZ 224.387 436.88 null]
>>
% 1833 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1838 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1839 0 R
/Resources 1837 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1820 0 R
>>
% 1840 0 obj
<<
/D [1838 0 R /XYZ 93.543 490.979 null]
>>
% 1841 0 obj
<<
/D [1838 0 R /XYZ 275.295 79.691 null]
>>
% 1837 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1843 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1844 0 R
/Resources 1842 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1846 0 R
>>
% 1845 0 obj
<<
/D [1843 0 R /XYZ 239.45 133.888 null]
>>
% 1842 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1848 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1849 0 R
/Resources 1847 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1846 0 R
>>
% 1850 0 obj
<<
/D [1848 0 R /XYZ 202.814 204.089 null]
>>
% 1847 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1852 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1853 0 R
/Resources 1851 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1846 0 R
>>
% 1854 0 obj
<<
/D [1852 0 R /XYZ 246.107 269.38 null]
>>
% 1851 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1856 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1857 0 R
/Resources 1855 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1846 0 R
>>
% 1858 0 obj
<<
/D [1856 0 R /XYZ 201.352 326.032 null]
>>
% 1855 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1860 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1861 0 R
/Resources 1859 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1846 0 R
>>
% 1862 0 obj
<<
/D [1860 0 R /XYZ 237.905 382.683 null]
>>
% 1859 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1864 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1865 0 R
/Resources 1863 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1846 0 R
>>
% 1866 0 obj
<<
/D [1864 0 R /XYZ 142.504 435.243 null]
>>
% 1863 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1868 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1869 0 R
/Resources 1867 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1872 0 R
>>
% 1870 0 obj
<<
/D [1868 0 R /XYZ 210.346 518.175 null]
>>
% 1871 0 obj
<<
/D [1868 0 R /XYZ 221.63 106.79 null]
>>
% 1867 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1874 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1875 0 R
/Resources 1873 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1872 0 R
>>
% 1876 0 obj
<<
/D [1874 0 R /XYZ 306.88 174.536 null]
>>
% 1873 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1878 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1879 0 R
/Resources 1877 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1872 0 R
>>
% 1880 0 obj
<<
/D [1878 0 R /XYZ 46.771 228.809 null]
>>
% 1877 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1882 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1883 0 R
/Resources 1881 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1872 0 R
>>
% 1884 0 obj
<<
/D [1882 0 R /XYZ 301.63 286.202 null]
>>
% 1881 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1886 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1887 0 R
/Resources 1885 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1872 0 R
>>
% 1888 0 obj
<<
/D [1886 0 R /XYZ 237.768 355.585 null]
>>
% 1885 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1890 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1891 0 R
/Resources 1889 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1872 0 R
>>
% 1892 0 obj
<<
/D [1890 0 R /XYZ 212.931 423.331 null]
>>
% 1889 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1894 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1895 0 R
/Resources 1893 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1898 0 R
>>
% 1896 0 obj
<<
/D [1894 0 R /XYZ 158.548 477.528 null]
>>
% 1897 0 obj
<<
/D [1894 0 R /XYZ 79.509 79.691 null]
>>
% 1893 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1900 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1901 0 R
/Resources 1899 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1898 0 R
>>
% 1902 0 obj
<<
/D [1900 0 R /XYZ 111.293 147.437 null]
>>
% 1899 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1904 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1905 0 R
/Resources 1903 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1898 0 R
>>
% 1906 0 obj
<<
/D [1904 0 R /XYZ 235.63 233.642 null]
>>
% 1907 0 obj
<<
/D [1904 0 R /XYZ 46.771 95.598 null]
>>
% 1903 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1908 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index22) >>
% 1911 0 obj
(Chapter XXI. The Historical Value Of The Gospels As Deduced From Previous Considerations.)
% 1913 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1914 0 R
/Resources 1912 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1898 0 R
>>
% 1909 0 obj
<<
/D [1913 0 R /XYZ 93.543 529.134 null]
>>
% 1915 0 obj
<<
/D [1913 0 R /XYZ 213.795 120.339 null]
>>
% 1912 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1917 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1918 0 R
/Resources 1916 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1898 0 R
>>
% 1919 0 obj
<<
/D [1917 0 R /XYZ 327.401 192.994 null]
>>
% 1916 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1921 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1922 0 R
/Resources 1920 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1898 0 R
>>
% 1923 0 obj
<<
/D [1921 0 R /XYZ 156.348 244.736 null]
>>
% 1920 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1925 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1926 0 R
/Resources 1924 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1928 0 R
>>
% 1927 0 obj
<<
/D [1925 0 R /XYZ 288.024 326.85 null]
>>
% 1924 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1930 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1931 0 R
/Resources 1929 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1928 0 R
>>
% 1932 0 obj
<<
/D [1930 0 R /XYZ 277.863 380.719 null]
>>
% 1929 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1934 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1935 0 R
/Resources 1933 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1928 0 R
>>
% 1936 0 obj
<<
/D [1934 0 R /XYZ 86.72 421.694 null]
>>
% 1933 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1938 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1939 0 R
/Resources 1937 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1928 0 R
>>
% 1940 0 obj
<<
/D [1938 0 R /XYZ 244.939 475.073 null]
>>
endstream
endobj
1945 0 obj <<
/Length 4689      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(421)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(They)-373(offer)-372(no)-373(comments,)-403(and)-373(allow)-373(the)-372(facts)-373(to)-373(produce)-372(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(own)-250(impression)-250(on)-250(the)-250(reader.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-490(follows)-490(therefore)-490(that)-491(if)-490(the)-490(Gospels)-490(were)-490(ordinary)-490(bi-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ographies,)-333(the)-317(variations)-317(in)-316(them)-317(would)-317(not)-316(interfere)-317(with)-316(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-349(character,)-373(and)-349(that)-349(differences)-348(in)-349(mere)-349(details)-348(would)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(leave)-447(the)-447(main)-448(facts)-447(unaffected.)-841(Still)-448(more)-447(true)-447(is)-447(this)-447(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(respect)-219(to)-219(memoirs,)-225(and)-219(especially)-219(with)-219(those)-219(composed)-219(with)-219(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(object)-294(of)-295(teaching)-294(a)-294(religion.)-383(Attention)-294(to)-295(this)-294(obvious)-294(fact)-294(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(get)-315(rid)-316(of)-315(a)-316(large)-315(number)-316(of)-315(the)-316(objections)-315(which)-316(have)-315(been)-315(so)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pertinaciously)-250(urged)-250(against)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(With)-438(respect)-439(to)-438(their)-438(general)-438(credibility,)-486(it)-438(is)-438(important)-438(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(observe)-236(that)-235(even)-236(if)-236(the)-235(date)-236(of)-236(the)-235(Synoptics)-236(be)-236(placed)-235(as)-236(late)-235(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-323(assigned)-322(to)-323(them)-323(by)-322(those)-323(critics)-323(who)-322(deny)-323(their)-322(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character,)-223(viz.)-239(somewhere)-217(between)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 154.556 0 Td [(A)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.755 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(D)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)-217(90)-216(and)-217(115,)-223(still)-217(the)-217(time)]TJ -168.792 -13.549 Td [(when)-291(they)-292(must)-291(have)-291(been)-292(composed)-291(lies,)-302(according)-291(to)-291(the)-291(rule)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-361(Sir)-362(G.)-361(C.)-362(Lewis,)-389(within)-362(the)-361(period)-362(of)-361(trustworthy)-361(historical)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tradition.)-316(In)-272(this)-271(case)-272(the)-272(earliest)-272(of)-272(them)-272(would)-272(bear)-272(date)-271(about)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sixty,)-451(and)-410(the)-411(latest)-410(of)-411(them)-410(about)-411(eighty-five)-410(years)-411(after)-410(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-322(they)-323(narrate.)-466(Renan)-323(is)-322(of)-322(opinion)-323(that)-322(their)-322(internal)-322(evi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dence)-211(proves)-211(them)-211(to)-210(have)-211(been)-211(composed)-211(before)-211(the)-210(destruction)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-386(Jerusalem.)-660(Be)-386(this)-386(as)-387(it)-386(may;)-455(even)-386(at)-386(the)-387(date)-386(assigned)-386(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-247(by)-247(the)-247(most)-247(sceptical)-247(critics,)-248(good)-246(traditionary)-247(information)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(lay)-322(within)-323(the)-322(reach)-323(of)-322(their)-322(respective)-323(authors.)-467(The)-322(interval)-322(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(about)-315(the)-316(same)-315(in)-316(the)-315(one)-316(case)-315(as)-316(that)-315(which)-316(separates)-315(us)-315(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-389(invasion)-388(of)-389(France)-389(by)-389(the)-388(allies)-389(in)-389(1814,)-423(and)-389(in)-389(the)-388(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(case)-266(from)-266(the)-265(outbreak)-266(of)-266(the)-266(French)-265(Revolution.)-298(Many)-265(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-256(still)-256(alive)-256(who)-256(can)-256(remember)-256(the)-256(former)-256(event;)-259(and)-256(although)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nearly)-214(everyone)-214(who)-214(could)-214(remember)-214(the)-214(latter)-214(has)-214(passed)-214(away,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(yet)-212(large)-211(numbers)-212(of)-212(the)-212(existing)-211(generation,)-220(whose)-211(recollections)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(will)-389(be)-778(good)-389(for)-388(twenty)-389(years)-389(to)-389(come,)-424(have)-389(conversed)-388(with)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([482])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(those)-392(who)-392(took)-392(the)-393(deepest)-392(interest)-392(in)-392(the)-392(scenes)-392(in)-392(question.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(While)-231(this)-230(generation)-231(lives,)-234(it)-231(would)-230(be)-231(impossible)-230(for)-231(the)-230(whole)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(outline)-224(of)-224(the)-224(facts)-224(to)-224(become)-224(falsified.)-241(Minor)-224(errors)-224(might)-224(creep)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-356(the)-357(details;)-410(their)-356(precise)-356(order)-357(and)-356(sequence)-357(might)-356(not)-356(be)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1949 0 obj <<
/Length 4554      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(422)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(accurately)-290(preserved;)-311(yet)-290(their)-290(general)-291(outline)-290(would)-290(be)-290(handed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(down)-214(correctly,)-222(and)-214(it)-215(would)-214(be)-215(impossi)1(ble)-215(to)-214(hide)-215(the)-214(true)-214(histo-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ry)-233(behind)-234(a)-233(set)-233(of)-234(legends.)-244(If)-234(the)-233(authors)-233(of)-234(the)-233(Synoptic)-233(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-263(only)-263(separated)-264(by)-263(this)-263(interval)-263(of)-264(time)-263(from)-263(the)-263(events)-263(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-265(narrate,)-270(they)-265(must)-266(have)-265(had)-265(all)-266(the)-265(materials)-266(of)-265(true)-265(history)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(within)-271(their)-272(reach.)-313(Persons)-272(must)-271(have)-271(been)-272(living)-271(when)-271(the)-271(first)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospel)-205(was)-204(written)-205(who)-204(could)-205(accurately)-205(remember)-204(the)-205(events)-204(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question;)-238(and)-231(even)-232(at)-231(the)-232(latest)-231(date)-232(which)-231(can)-232(be)-231(assigned)-232(to)-231(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-311(Gospels,)-326(large)-310(numbers)-311(of)-311(persons)-310(must)-311(have)-311(been)-310(living)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(who)-325(had)-325(heard)-325(narratives)-325(of)-325(them)-324(from)-325(their)-325(fathers,)-344(which,)-343(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unspeakably)-212(i)1(nteresting,)-220(they)-211(would)-212(treasure)-211(up)-212(with)-211(the)-211(liveliest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recollection.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-374(follows,)-405(therefore,)-404(that)-374(even)-374(if)-374(we)-374(assume)-374(the)-374(latest)-373(date)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(which)-457(has)-458(been)-457(assigned)-458(for)-457(the)-457(publication)-458(of)-457(the)-457(Synoptic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-229(it)-229(lies)-229(considerably)-229(within)-229(the)-229(period)-229(of)-229(accurate)-229(histori-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cal)-263(recollection,)-266(even)-263(if)-262(we)-263(suppose)-263(that)-263(their)-263(authors)-262(composed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(them)-425(from)-425(traditional)-424(sources)-425(only,)-468(and)-425(were)-425(not)-425(assisted)-424(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(written)-281(documents.)-343(But)-281(the)-281(existence)-281(of)-281(documents)-281(is)-281(expressly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(asserted)-229(by)-228(the)-229(author)-229(of)-228(St.)-243(Luke's)-229(Gospel.)-243(And)-228(even)-229(if)-229(we)-228(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(devoid)-410(of)-411(this)-410(testimony,)-450(we)-410(might)-411(infer)-410(it)-410(from)-410(the)-410(inherent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(probability)-445(of)-446(the)-445(case.)-837(This)-445(was)-446(inevitable,)-494(as)-446(the)-445(basis)-445(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-392(religion)-391(was)-392(placed)-392(on)-392(a)-391(personal)-392(history.)-675(The)-392(system)-391(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instruction)-223(must)-223(have)-223(involved)-223(a)-223(constant)-223(reference)-223(to)-223(the)-222(details)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-328(that)-328(history.)-484(When,)-347(therefore,)-348(the)-328(members)-328(of)-328(the)-327(Churches)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(heard)-349(them)-350(from)-349(the)-349(lips)-698(of)-350(original)-349(witnesses,)-374(the)-349(interest)-349(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([483])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(the)-415(subject)-414(must)-415(have)-414(induced)-415(those)-414(who)-415(were)-414(able)-415(to)-414(write,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-346(compose)-347(brief)-346(memoranda)-347(for)-346(the)-346(purpose)-347(of)-346(assisting)-346(their)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(recollections.)-677(In)-392(this)-392(way)-392(a)-393(considerable)-392(amount)-392(of)-392(Christian)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(literature)-328(in)-329(connection)-328(with)-328(the)-329(life)-328(of)-328(Jesus)-329(must)-328(have)-328(grown)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(up)-271(in)-271(the)-271(course)-271(of)-271(years,)-276(and)-271(the)-271(necessity)-271(for)-271(it)-271(would)-271(become)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-306(more)-306(urgent)-306(in)-306(proportion)-306(as)-306(the)-306(original)-306(disciples)-306(who)-306(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(heard)-256(His)-257(discourses)-256(and)-256(seen)-257(His)-256(actions)-256(passed)-257(away)-256(from)-256(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(scene.)-300(This)-267(is)-266(exactly)-267(in)-266(conformity)-267(with)-267(the)-266(statement)-267(made)-266(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(author)-250(of)-250(St.)-250(Luke's)-250(Gospel.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1953 0 obj <<
/Length 4505      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(423)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -252.311 -30.759 Td [(It)-229(is)-228(clear,)-233(therefore,)-233(that)-229(even)-228(if)-229(the)-229(publication)-228(of)-229(our)-228(present)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-439(did)-440(not)-439(take)-440(place)-439(before)-440(the)-439(time)-440(assigned)-439(to)-439(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-299(unbelievers,)-311(the)-298(historical)-299(materials)-299(at)-298(the)-299(command)-299(of)-298(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authors)-331(must)-332(have)-331(been)-331(ample.)-494(It)-332(would)-331(have)-331(been)-331(impossible)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-244(facts)-244(and)-244(legendary)-244(inventions)-244(should)-244(have)-244(become)-243(blended)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(together)-442(within)-442(so)-442(short)-442(a)-442(period.)-826(Consequently)-442(nothing)-441(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(neglect)-335(to)-334(use)-335(the)-335(materials)-334(at)-335(hand,)-356(or)-334(a)-335(deliberate)-335(purpose)-334(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(falsification)-293(could)-292(have)-293(prevented)-292(them)-293(from)-292(giving)-293(an)-292(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-346(the)-347(ministry)-346(of)-346(Jesus)-346(which)-347(would)-346(be)-346(substantially)-346(accurate)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-340(all)-340(its)-339(main)-340(features.)-519(If)-340(on)-340(the)-339(other)-340(hand)-340(we)-340(suppose)-339(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-411(to)-412(have)-411(been)-411(written)-411(for)-412(the)-411(purpose)-411(of)-411(falsification,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-279(their)-278(contradiction)-279(to)-278(the)-278(accounts)-279(which)-278(had)-279(been)-278(hitherto)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accepted)-443(by)-442(the)-443(Church)-442(must)-443(have)-443(destroyed)-442(their)-443(credit.)-827(It)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-334(have)-334(been)-335(impossible)-334(for)-334(the)-334(authors)-334(to)-334(have)-334(succeeded)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-456(concealing)-456(the)-456(facts)-457(behind)-456(a)-456(mass)-456(of)-456(myths)-456(and)-456(legends)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(while)-324(they)-324(formed)-324(the)-323(very)-324(groundwork)-324(of)-324(the)-324(daily)-324(life)-324(of)-323(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(community.)-400(Under)-300(the)-300(peculiar)-300(circumstances)-300(of)-300(the)-300(Christians)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-385(the)-385(first)-384(century)-385(some)-385(portion)-385(of)-385(the)-384(events)-385(of)-385(the)-385(life)-384(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(teaching)-295(of)-295(Christ)-295(must)-295(have)-295(been)-295(brought)-295(to)-295(their)-295(minds)-294(every)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(day.)-592(The)-364(hostility)-363(of)-364(the)-364(Pagan)-364(world)-364(around)-364(them)-364(was)-363(alone)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sufficient)-755(to)-377(ensure)-378(this.)-632(Moreover,)-410(the)-377(religion)-378(was)-377(not)-377(one)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([484])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(which)-222(was)-222(committed)-222(to)-221(the)-222(custody)-222(of)-222(a)-222(caste)-221(or)-222(priesthood;)-231(but)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-286(appealed)-285(directly)-286(to)-286(the)-285(individual.)-357(As)-286(distinguished)-286(from)-285(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-309(religions)-309(of)-310(the)-309(world)-309(Christianity)-309(may)-309(be)-309(not)-309(incorrectly)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(defined)-202(as)-202(the)-202(religion)-203(of)-202(the)-202(individual.)-234(It)-202(awoke)-202(emotions)-202(of)-202(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(profoundest)-300(nature)-300(in)-300(the)-300(hearts)-300(of)-300(even)-300(its)-300(humblest)-300(followers,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(addressing)-352(itself)-351(both)-352(to)-351(their)-352(consciences)-351(and)-352(their)-351(affections.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(These)-311(emotions)-310(were)-311(all)-310(centered)-311(in)-310(a)-311(personal)-311(life.)-431(If)-311(one)-310(fact)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-316(more)-317(certain)-316(than)-316(another,)-333(it)-316(is)-316(that)-317(Jesus)-316(was)-316(viewed)-316(by)-316(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(early)-362(Christians)-361(as)-362(their)-361(religious)-362(King,)-389(to)-362(whom)-361(they)-362(owed)-361(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(personal)-381(allegiance.)-645(This)-381(must)-382(have)-381(rendered)-382(it)-381(necessary)-381(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them)-306(to)-306(treasure)-306(up)-306(all)-306(the)-306(facts)-306(of)-306(His)-306(history)-306(with)-306(the)-306(deepest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(care.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Further:)-387(the)-319(early)-318(Christians)-319(not)-319(only)-318(lived)-319(in)-319(the)-318(midst)-319(of)-318(a)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1958 0 obj <<
/Length 4876      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(424)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(society)-317(extremely)-317(hostile)-316(to)-317(them,)-333(but)-317(were)-317(also)-317(zealous)-316(prose-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lyters.)-600(This)-367(alone)-366(would)-367(have)-367(been)-366(sufficient)-367(to)-367(compel)-366(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-289(keep)-288(in)-289(lively)-288(remembrance)-288(the)-289(chief)-288(events)-289(in)-288(the)-289(history)-288(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus.)-315(How)-272(else)-272(was)-272(it)-272(possible)-271(for)-272(them)-272(to)-272(persuade)-272(others)-271(that)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(He)-268(was)-267(the)-268(Christ?)-302(The)-267(Church)-268(was)-267(not)-268(a)-267(school)-268(of)-267(philosophy,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-260(consisted)-260(of)-259(a)-260(body)-260(of)-260(men)-260(whose)-259(bond)-260(of)-260(union)-260(was)-259(adher-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ence)-229(to)-228(a)-229(leader.)-243(To)-229(make)-228(converts)-229(to)-229(such)-228(a)-229(religion)-229(would)-228(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-258(impossible)-258(without)-258(an)-258(accurate)-258(acquaintance)-258(with)-258(the)-257(facts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-250(which)-250(His)-250(claims)-250(were)-250(grounded.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Corporate)-441(bodies)-440(possess)-441(a)-441(power)-441(of)-440(handing)-441(down)-441(a)-440(tra-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ditionary)-538(knowledge)-538(of)-538(events)-538(in)-538(a)-538(far)-538(greater)-538(degree)-538(than)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(individuals.)-342(The)-281(Christian)-280(Church)-281(consisted)-281(of)-280(a)-281(set)-281(of)-280(commu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nities)-361(which)-362(had)-361(not)-361(only)-362(an)-361(individual,)-389(but)-362(also)-361(the)-361(strongest)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(corporate)-416(life.)-747(Although)-416(it)-416(contained)-415(no)-416(priesthood,)-457(properly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-429(called,)-474(the)-429(cohesion)-429(of)-429(these)-429(communities,)-473(placed)-429(as)-429(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-316(in)-316(the)-316(midst)-316(of)-316(a)-316(hostile)-317(population,)-332(in)-316(Jewish)-316(or)-316(Gentile)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([485])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(cities,)-330(was)-314(of)-314(the)-315(strongest)-314(character,)-330(and)-314(in)-314(proportion)-314(to)-314(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(smallness,)-363(the)-341(action)-341(of)-340(each)-341(individual)-341(member)-340(would)-341(be)-340(im-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(portant.)-624(Each)-374(separate)-375(Church)-375(therefore)-374(formed)-375(a)-374(corporation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-400(opposed)-399(to)-400(the)-399(Jewish)-399(and)-400(heathen)-399(world)-400(by)-399(which)-400(it)-399(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(surrounded;)-431(and)-371(each)-370(separate)-371(unit)-371(felt)-370(himself)-371(animated)-371(by)-370(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(similar)-353(life,)-378(which)-353(dictated)-352(to)-353(him)-353(the)-352(necessity)-353(of)-352(conquering)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(or)-336(perishing.)-509(From)-336(this)-336(arose)-336(an)-336(intense)-336(desire)-336(of)-336(making)-336(new)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(converts)-285(and)-286(of)-285(increasing)-286(the)-285(number)-285(of)-286(the)-285(faithful.)-356(How)-285(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-309(to)-308(be)-309(accomplished?)-425(An)-309(organization)-308(was)-309(necessary.)-425(Each)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-268(the)-267(communities)-268(had)-267(one)-268(which)-267(was)-267(suitable)-268(to)-267(its)-268(need.)-302(One)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-323(its)-322(most)-323(important)-322(functions)-323(must)-322(have)-323(been)-322(to)-323(instruct)-322(new)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(converts)-318(in)-319(its)-318(principles,)-335(and)-319(to)-318(keep)-318(actively)-319(burning)-318(the)-318(zeal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-299(its)-299(original)-299(members.)-397(But)-299(as)-299(the)-299(existence)-299(of)-299(the)-298(community)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-210(founded)-209(on)-209(an)-210(adhesion)-209(to)-210(a)-209(person,)-218(the)-209(course)-210(of)-209(instruction)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-395(have)-395(consisted)-395(to)-395(a)-395(considerable)-395(extent)-395(of)-395(details)-395(of)-395(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(actions)-327(and)-327(teaching)-327(of)-327(Jesus.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 137.968 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(How)-327(shall)-327(they)-327(believe)-326(on)-327(him)]TJ -142.812 -13.55 Td [(of)-321(whom)-322(they)-321(have)-321(not)-322(heard?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 136.283 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.349 0 Td [(was)-321(a)-322(pertinent)-321(question)-321(of)-322(St.)]TJ -144.632 -13.549 Td [(Paul,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 26.156 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(or)-346(how)-345(shall)-346(they)-346(hear)-345(without)-346(a)-346(preacher?)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 193.01 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.614 0 Td [(No)-346(society)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1962 0 obj <<
/Length 4591      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(425)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(has)-228(ever)-228(existed)-228(in)-228(the)-228(world)-228(which)-228(has)-228(had)-228(an)-228(equal)-227(inducement)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-324(hand)-323(down)-324(accurately)-323(the)-324(events)-323(of)-324(its)-323(founder's)-324(life,)-342(or)-323(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(equal)-247(facilities)-248(for)-247(detecting)-248(any)-247(attempt)-247(to)-248(substitute)-247(a)-247(fictitious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(account)-250(of)-250(him)-250(for)-250(the)-250(true)-250(one.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-209(follows)-209(therefore)-209(that)-209(at)-209(the)-209(period)-209(in)-209(question)-209(it)-209(would)-208(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(been)-285(simply)-284(impossible)-285(that)-284(a)-284(fictitious)-285(or)-284(legendary)-285(account)-284(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-352(life)-353(of)-352(Jesus)-353(should)-352(have)-353(taken)-352(the)-353(place)-352(of)-353(the)-352(one)-352(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these)-362(Churches)-362(had)-362(accepted)-362(at)-362(the)-362(time)-362(when)-362(they)-362(first)-361(came)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-413(existence.)-737(I)-413(have)-412(already)-413(proved)-412(that)-413(the)-412(Epistles)-413(of)-412(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Paul)-288(put)-288(it)-288(beyond)-289(the)-288(possibility)-288(of)-288(question)-288(that)-288(an)-288(account)-288(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-354(chief)-354(facts)-354(in)-354(the)-354(ministry)-354(of)-354(Jesus)-354(formed)-354(the)-708(foundation)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([486])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(of)-325(the)-324(religious)-325(life)-325(of)-324(the)-325(Churches)-324(at)-325(the)-325(time)-324(when)-325(he)-324(wrote)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them,)-499(and)-450(that)-449(it)-450(had)-449(done)-450(so)-449(from)-450(the)-449(first.)-849(The)-449(difficulty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-284(of)-284(introducing)-284(an)-284(entirely)-284(new)-284(version)-284(of)-284(it)-284(must)-284(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-231(insurmountable.)-243(A)-231(doubtful)-231(fact)-231(or)-230(two)-231(might)-231(have)-230(become)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(incorporated,)-311(but)-298(while)-299(the)-299(religious)-298(life)-299(of)-298(the)-299(community)-298(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thus)-265(strong,)-269(it)-265(would)-265(have)-266(been)-265(utterly)-265(impossible)-265(to)-265(give)-265(a)-265(new)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(colouring)-250(to)-250(the)-250(whole.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-190(further:)-221(this)-190(difficulty)-190(must)-191(have)-190(been)-191(greatly)-190(increased)-190(by)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-228(wide)-228(separation)-228(of)-228(such)-228(Churches)-227(as)-228(those)-228(of)-228(Rome,)-232(Corinth,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Galatia,)-322(Jerusalem,)-322(and)-308(others,)-322(from)-307(one)-308(another.)-423(Each)-307(Church)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(must)-368(have)-368(had)-368(an)-368(account)-369(of)-368(its)-368(own)-368(of)-368(the)-368(chief)-368(facts)-368(of)-368(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Lord's)-196(ministry.)-232(If)-195(one)-196(of)-196(them)-195(could)-196(have)-196(been)-195(induced)-196(to)-195(accept)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-290(new)-291(set)-290(of)-290(facts,)-301(there)-290(would)-290(have)-291(been)-290(the)-290(greatest)-290(difficulty)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-261(persuading)-260(the)-261(others)-261(to)-260(follow)-261(its)-261(example.)-282(Daily)-260(experience)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(teaches)-351(us)-350(how)-351(very)-351(slow)-350(religious)-351(bodies)-351(are)-350(in)-351(changing)-350(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fundamental)-381(articles)-382(of)-381(their)-381(belief.)-644(However)-382(much)-381(the)-381(senti-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ments)-233(of)-233(individuals)-233(may)-233(have)-232(changed,)-237(the)-233(original)-232(confessions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-400(faith)-400(are)-399(retained)-400(with)-400(the)-400(utmost)-400(tenacity,)-437(even)-400(after)-399(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-206(ceased)-206(to)-206(embody)-206(the)-206(religious)-206(life)-206(of)-206(the)-206(community.)-235(What)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(confessions)-335(of)-335(faith)-335(are)-334(to)-335(modern)-335(Churches,)-356(the)-335(chief)-335(facts)-334(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-359(ministry)-359(of)-359(our)-359(Lord)-359(must)-359(have)-359(been)-359(to)-359(the)-359(primitive)-358(one;)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-248(only)-249(difference)-248(being)-248(that)-249(these)-248(latter)-248(lived)-249(with)-248(a)-248(far)-248(greater)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tenacity)-434(in)-434(the)-434(minds)-433(of)-434(the)-434(early)-434(Christians)-434(than)-434(the)-433(former)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1966 0 obj <<
/Length 4655      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(426)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(have)-382(in)-382(modern)-382(Churches.)-646(If)-382(therefore)-382(a)-382(single)-382(Church)-382(could)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-285(been)-285(induced)-285(to)-284(accept)-285(a)-285(new)-285(version)-285(of)-285(its)-285(Founder's)-284(life,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-282(separation)-282(of)-283(these)-282(different)-282(communities)-282(from)-282(one)-282(another,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-229(have)-228(placed)-229(an)-228(insuperable)-229(barrier)-228(in)-229(the)-228(way)-229(of)-228(imposing)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(such)-313(an)-313(account)-313(on)-313(the)-313(other)-313(Churches.)-439(The)-313(inquiry)-313(must)-313(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(at)-253(once)-253(arisen,)-254(Whence)-253(has)-254(this)-253(Church)-506(derived)-253(its)-253(new)-253(Gospel,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([487])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(thus)-316(fundamentally)-315(different)-316(from)-315(that)-315(which)-316(has)-315(from)-316(the)-315(first)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(formed)-250(the)-250(basis)-250(of)-250(our)-250(religious)-250(life?)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-220(is)-219(clear)-220(therefore)-220(that)-220(even)-219(if)-220(we)-220(accept)-219(the)-220(latest)-220(date)-219(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(had)-374(been)-374(assigned)-374(to)-374(the)-374(publication)-374(of)-374(the)-374(Synoptic)-373(Gospels,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(their)-470(authors)-470(must)-470(have)-469(been)-470(in)-470(possession)-470(of)-470(abundance)-469(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(materials)-364(for)-365(setting)-364(forth)-365(an)-364(account)-365(of)-364(the)-365(ministry)-364(of)-364(Jesus,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-282(would)-282(have)-282(been)-282(correct)-282(in)-282(all)-282(its)-282(great)-282(outlines;)-298(and)-281(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(even)-283(if)-284(they)-283(had)-283(been)-284(so)-283(minded)-283(it)-284(would)-283(have)-283(been)-283(impossible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-217(them)-218(to)-217(have)-217(succeeded)-218(in)-217(palming)-217(off)-218(a)-217(previously)-217(unknown)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(set)-450(of)-450(facts)-450(in)-451(place)-450(of)-450(those)-450(which)-450(had)-450(hitherto)-450(formed)-450(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(groundwork)-281(of)-281(the)-281(life)-281(of)-280(the)-281(different)-281(Churches.)-343(We)-281(have)-280(seen)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(also)-226(that)-226(when)-227(St.)-242(Paul)-226(wrote)-226(his)-226(Epistles,)-231(the)-226(different)-226(Churches)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-308(in)-309(possession)-308(of)-309(an)-308(outline)-308(of)-309(the)-308(ministry)-309(of)-308(Jesus)-308(Christ)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-251(contained)-250(within)-251(it,)-250(as)-251(a)-250(matter)-251(of)-250(the)-251(highest)-250(importance,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-390(most)-389(remarkable)-390(miraculous)-390(fact)-390(which)-389(is)-390(recorded)-390(in)-389(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels.)-400(Is)-300(it)-300(to)-300(be)-300(believed)-300(that)-299(this)-300(was)-300(the)-300(only)-300(one;)-325(or,)-313(is)-299(it)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possible)-217(that)-217(a)-217(set)-217(of)-217(miraculous)-217(narratives)-217(could)-217(have)-216(succeeded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-260(taking)-260(the)-260(place)-260(of)-259(the)-260(account)-260(of)-260(His)-260(life)-260(and)-260(teaching)-259(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-356(in)-356(possession)-356(of)-356(the)-356(Churches,)-383(within)-356(the)-356(interval)-356(of)-356(time)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-345(separates)-345(St.)-536(Paul's)-345(Epistles)-345(from)-345(the)-345(publication)-345(of)-345(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(first)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Synoptic)-250(Gospels?)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-364(conclude,)-392(therefore,)-392(that)-364(the)-364(original)-364(narratives)-364(must)-363(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(attributed)-233(a)-234(number)-233(of)-233(miracles)-233(to)-234(Jesus)-233(Christ;)-239(that)-233(the)-233(accounts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-435(them)-435(must)-435(have)-434(been)-435(handed)-435(down)-435(to)-435(the)-435(time)-435(when)-434(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opponents)-377(allow)-376(that)-377(the)-377(Gospels)-376(were)-377(published,)-408(and)-377(that)-376(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-271(means)-272(they)-271(have)-271(been)-271(incorporated)-272(into)-271(them.)-314(Not)-271(only)-271(has)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-228(alleged)-228(late)-228(date)-228(of)-228(the)-228(publication)-228(of)-228(the)-228(Gospels)-228(been)-227(urged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-215(a)-214(reason)-215(for)-215(discrediting)-214(them)-215(as)-215(reports)-214(of)-215(historical)-215(facts,)-221(but)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1970 0 obj <<
/Length 4805      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(427)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(also)-223(the)-224(uncertainty)-223(of)-224(their)-446(authorship.)-242(It)-223(will)-223(not)-224(fall)-223(within)-223(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([488])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(scope)-176(of)-177(this)-176(work)-177(to)-176(examine)-176(the)-177(value)-176(of)-176(the)-177(testimony)-176(by)-176(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(each)-345(Gospel)-346(has)-345(been)-346(assigned)-345(to)-346(its)-345(respective)-346(author.)-536(It)-345(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-274(sufficient)-274(here)-274(to)-274(observe)-274(that)-274(it)-274(is)-274(as)-274(strong)-274(as)-274(that)-274(by)-273(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-337(authorship)-336(of)-337(any)-336(other)-337(ancient)-336(writing)-336(is)-337(ascertained.)-509(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(internal)-312(character)-312(of)-312(two)-312(of)-312(these)-312(Gospels)-312(fully)-312(agrees)-312(with)-311(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(traditionary)-217(account.)-239(Although)-217(the)-216(assertions)-217(of)-217(the)-217(early)-216(Fathers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(vary)-280(as)-280(to)-280(the)-280(precise)-280(relation)-280(in)-280(which)-280(Mark)-280(stood)-280(to)-280(Peter,)-287(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ancient)-241(traditions)-242(are)-241(unanimous)-241(in)-241(connecting)-242(him)-241(in)-241(some)-241(way)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(or)-373(other)-373(with)-374(the)-373(Apostle.)-619(The)-374(phenomena)-373(of)-373(this)-373(Gospel)-373(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(precisely)-239(such)-238(as)-238(we)-239(should)-238(expect)-239(if)-238(this)-239(was)-238(the)-239(case.)-246(In)-238(nearly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(every)-281(case)-280(where)-281(we)-281(can)-280(ascertain,)-288(either)-281(from)-281(this)-280(or)-281(from)-280(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-310(the)-310(other)-310(Gospels,)-325(that)-310(Peter)-310(was)-310(an)-310(eye-witness)-310(of)-310(an)-309(event)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(recorded)-382(in)-382(it,)-415(St.)-646(Mark)-382(gives)-382(precisely)-382(such)-382(a)-382(description)-382(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(it)-317(as)-316(we)-317(might)-317(expect)-317(would)-316(be)-317(given)-317(by)-317(a)-316(man)-317(of)-317(the)-316(peculiar)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(temperament)-314(of)-314(Simon)-314(Peter.)-442(We)-314(know,)-330(both)-314(from)-314(the)-314(Acts)-313(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-255(Apostles)-256(and)-255(from)-255(the)-256(Epistles)-255(of)-255(St.)-266(Paul,)-257(that)-255(St.)-266(Luke)-255(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-230(companion)-230(of)-229(that)-230(Apostle.)-243(The)-230(peculiarities)-230(of)-230(the)-230(Gospel)-229(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bears)-264(his)-263(name)-264(are)-263(precisely)-264(such)-263(as)-263(we)-264(should)-263(have)-264(expected)-263(if)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(its)-271(author)-271(was)-270(a)-271(companion)-271(of)-271(the)-270(great)-271(Apostle)-271(of)-271(the)-270(Gentiles.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(There)-369(is)-370(also)-369(every)-370(reason)-369(for)-369(believing)-370(that)-369(Luke)-370(was)-369(not)-369(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eye-witness)-327(of)-327(the)-327(ministry)-327(of)-326(Jesus.)-481(The)-327(author)-327(of)-327(the)-326(Gospel)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirms)-304(that)-303(he)-304(was)-304(not)-304(an)-303(eye-witness.)-411(In)-304(conformity)-304(with)-303(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-306(Gospel)-306(bears)-306(the)-305(most)-306(distinctive)-306(marks)-306(of)-306(compilation.)-417(So)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(far)-402(the)-402(internal)-403(structure)-402(of)-402(these)-402(two)-402(Gospels)-402(entirely)-402(agrees)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-412(the)-412(external)-412(testimony)-412(as)-412(to)-412(their)-412(authorship.)-736(We)-412(know)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(also)-217(on)-218(the)-217(authority)-217(of)-217(the)-217(early)-218(Fathers)-217(that)-217(Matthew)-217(composed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-373(Gospel)-373(in)-373(the)-373(Hebrew)-373(language)-373(which)-373(was)-373(designed)-373(for)-373(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(use)-396(of)-395(Jewish)-396(Christians.)-687(Now)-396(whoever)-396(is)-396(the)-791(author)-396(of)-395(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([489])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(present)-317(Greek)-316(Gospel)-317(which)-317(bears)-316(his)-317(name,)-333(it)-317(is)-316(distinguished)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-186(precisely)-187(the)-186(same)-186(characteristics)-186(as)-187(those)-186(which)-186(are)-186(described)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-286(appertaining)-286(to)-286(the)-286(Hebrew)-286(Gospel)-286(of)-286(St.)-358(Matthew,)-295(that)-286(is)-286(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(say,)-217(that)-208(the)-208(proportion)-208(which)-208(the)-209(discourses)-208(bear)-208(to)-208(the)-208(narrative)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(portions)-286(of)-286(it)-286(is)-286(very)-285(large;)-304(and)-286(its)-286(contents)-286(make)-286(it)-286(evident)-285(that)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1975 0 obj <<
/Length 4654      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(428)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(it)-354(was)-354(chiefly)-354(designed)-354(for)-354(the)-354(use)-354(of)-354(Christians)-354(of)-354(the)-354(Jewish)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(race.)-624(If)-375(therefore)-374(our)-375(present)-375(Gospel)-374(was)-375(not)-375(set)-374(forth)-375(by)-374(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Apostle)-365(himself)-364(in)-365(Greek,)-393(both)-365(the)-365(external)-364(testimony)-365(and)-364(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(internal)-290(evidence)-289(prove)-290(that)-289(it)-290(is)-289(a)-290(representation)-289(of)-290(its)-289(contents)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(sufficiently)-250(accurate)-250(for)-250(all)-250(the)-250(practical)-250(purposes)-250(of)-250(history.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-290(the)-289(question)-290(as)-290(to)-289(the)-290(names)-290(of)-289(the)-290(persons)-290(who)-289(actually)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(set)-228(forth)-228(our)-228(Gospels)-228(has)-228(been)-228(made)-228(of)-228(far)-228(more)-228(importance)-228(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-345(deserves,)-370(both)-345(by)-346(the)-345(defenders)-346(and)-345(the)-346(opponents)-345(of)-345(Chris-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tianity.)-442(The)-314(all)-313(important)-314(point)-314(is,)-330(are)-314(they)-314(faithful)-314(accounts)-313(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-241(primitive)-242(traditions)-241(of)-242(the)-241(Church)-241(respecting)-242(the)-241(chief)-241(events)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-351(its)-352(Founder's)-351(ministry;)-402(and)-351(were)-352(they)-351(composed)-351(within)-351(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(period)-344(of)-345(time,)-368(when)-344(the)-344(recollections)-345(of)-344(it)-344(must)-345(have)-344(been)-344(so)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fresh)-293(as)-293(to)-294(render)-293(it)-293(impossible)-293(to)-294(substitute)-293(a)-293(body)-293(of)-293(fictitious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-251(legendary)-251(narratives)-251(in)-251(place)-251(of)-251(those)-251(which)-251(had)-251(been)-250(hand-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ed)-366(down)-366(in)-367(the)-366(Church)-366(from)-366(the)-366(beginning?)-599(Unless)-366(we)-366(know)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(enough)-386(about)-387(an)-386(author)-386(from)-387(external)-386(sources)-386(of)-386(information,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-348(enable)-347(us)-348(to)-347(form)-348(a)-347(definite)-348(opinion)-347(as)-348(to)-347(his)-348(judgment)-347(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(means)-431(of)-431(information,)-476(our)-430(mere)-431(knowledge)-431(of)-431(his)-431(name)-430(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(help)-460(us)-461(little.)-881(The)-460(information)-461(which)-460(ecclesiastical)-460(tradition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affords)-239(us)-240(respecting)-239(the)-239(authors)-240(of)-239(the)-239(Synoptic)-240(Gospels)-239(is)-239(little)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(beyond)-253(that)-254(which)-253(is)-253(contained)-253(in)-254(the)-253(New)-253(Testament)-253(itself,)-254(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-334(insufficient)-334(to)-334(enable)-333(us)-334(to)-334(form)-334(a)-334(judgment)-334(respecting)-333(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character.)-373(That)-291(judgment)-291(must)-291(be)-291(formed)-582(exclusively)-291(from)-291(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([490])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(writings)-357(themselves,)-383(and)-356(can)-357(only)-357(be)-356(arrived)-357(at)-356(after)-357(a)-356(careful)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(examination)-250(of)-250(their)-250(contents.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-340(will)-341(be)-340(urged)-341(that)-340(if)-340(our)-341(present)-340(Greek)-341(Matthew)-340(could)-340(be)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(shown)-389(to)-389(have)-388(been)-389(the)-389(work)-389(of)-389(the)-388(Apostle,)-424(we)-389(should)-388(then)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-356(the)-356(testimony)-356(of)-356(an)-356(eye-witness)-356(of)-356(the)-356(ministry)-356(of)-356(Jesus;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-239(if)-239(we)-239(have)-239(no)-239(certain)-239(evidence)-239(that)-239(it)-239(was)-239(composed)-239(by)-239(him,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(then)-213(none)-212(of)-213(the)-213(events)-212(recorded)-213(in)-213(the)-212(Synoptics)-213(rest)-213(on)-212(autoptic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(testimony.)-560(The)-354(truth)-353(of)-354(this)-353(position)-354(I)-353(entirely)-354(deny.)-560(The)-353(real)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question)-329(is,)-348(do)-329(the)-329(events)-328(recorded)-329(in)-329(them)-329(faithfully)-328(represent)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-191(traditions)-191(of)-192(the)-191(Church?)-230(Have)-192(we)-191(evidence)-191(that)-191(the)-191(traditions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-263(were)-264(current)-263(when)-263(these)-263(Gospels)-263(were)-264(composed,)-266(are)-263(ac-)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1979 0 obj <<
/Length 4571      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(429)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(curate)-343(representations)-344(of)-343(the)-344(accounts)-343(of)-343(the)-344(ministry)-343(of)-343(Jesus,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-252(were)-252(handed)-251(down)-252(by)-252(our)-252(Lord's)-252(original)-251(disciples?)-256(If)-251(so,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-372(must)-373(rest)-372(on)-372(autoptic)-372(testimony,)-403(as)-373(they)-372(could)-372(only)-372(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-341(derived)-341(from)-341(our)-341(Lord's)-341(companions.)-523(The)-341(mere)-341(knowing)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-398(name)-398(of)-398(one)-398(of)-398(them,)-435(unless)-398(we)-398(knew)-398(a)-398(great)-398(deal)-398(about)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-356(judgment)-356(and)-357(discretion,)-382(is)-357(of)-356(far)-356(less)-356(importance)-356(than)-356(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assurance)-312(that)-312(we)-312(are)-311(in)-312(possession)-312(of)-312(the)-312(general)-312(testimony)-311(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-424(entire)-424(body.)-773(Nor)-424(does)-424(it)-424(necessarily)-424(follow)-424(that)-424(any)-424(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(follower)-330(of)-329(Jesus,)-350(even)-330(an)-330(Apostle,)-349(was)-330(in)-330(constant)-329(attendance)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-294(His)-295(person.)-383(We)-294(know)-295(from)-294(the)-294(Gospels)-295(themselves)-294(that)-294(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-349(not)-349(always)-349(the)-349(case.)-547(If)-349(such)-349(a)-349(person)-349(had)-349(narrated)-349(events)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-275(occurred)-275(during)-275(his)-275(absence,)-281(he)-275(must)-275(have)-275(been)-274(indebted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-218(his)-219(knowledge)-218(of)-219(them)-218(to)-218(the)-219(testimony)-218(of)-219(others.)-239(If)-218(therefore)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-218(present)-219(Greek)-218(Matthew)-218(could)-218(be)-219(proved)-218(to)-218(be)-219(the)-218(work)-218(of)-218(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Apostle,)-288(still)-280(it)-280(by)-280(no)-280(means)-279(follows)-280(that)-280(he)-280(was)-280(an)-280(eye-witness)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-375(every)-375(one)-375(of)-376(the)-375(events)-375(recorded)-375(in)-375(it.)-625(If,)-407(however,)-406(it)-375(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(set)-352(forth)-353(in)-352(its)-353(present)-352(form)-353(by)-352(some)-352(other)-353(hand,)-378(I)-352(fully)-352(admit)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-552(neither)-276(of)-276(the)-276(Synoptics)-276(was)-276(composed)-276(by)-276(an)-276(Apostle.)-327(But)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([491])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(this)-346(is)-347(a)-346(wholly)-346(different)-346(point)-347(from)-346(the)-346(consideration)-346(whether)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-389(do)-390(or)-389(do)-389(not)-390(embody)-389(the)-389(testimony)-390(of)-389(the)-389(eye-witnesses)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-391(the)-392(ministry)-391(of)-391(Jesus)-391(Christ.)-674(This)-391(does)-392(not)-391(depend)-391(on)-391(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(knowledge)-257(of)-257(the)-257(names)-256(of)-257(their)-257(respective)-257(authors,)-259(but)-256(whether)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-229(have)-229(good)-229(evidence)-229(that)-229(they)-229(faithfully)-229(embody)-229(the)-229(primitive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apostolical)-250(traditions.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(A)-373(careful)-373(perusal)-373(of)-373(the)-373(Synoptics)-373(will)-373(convince)-373(the)-372(reader)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(that)-294(neither)-293(of)-294(them)-293(professes)-294(to)-294(embody)-293(a)-294(set)-293(of)-294(personal)-293(rem-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(iniscences.)-447(On)-316(the)-316(contrary,)-332(they)-315(bear)-316(the)-316(strongest)-315(indications)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-280(being)-281(a)-280(collection)-280(of)-281(apostolic)-280(traditions.)-341(Of)-280(this)-281(I)-280(shall)-280(offer)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distinctive)-397(proof)-397(in)-397(the)-397(next)-397(chapter.)-691(The)-397(only)-397(Gospel)-396(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(embodies)-223(such)-223(personal)-224(reminiscences)-223(as)-223(indicate)-223(the)-223(authorship)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-306(an)-306(eye-witness)-305(is)-306(that)-306(of)-306(St.)-417(John.)-417(But)-306(the)-306(indications)-306(of)-305(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(presence)-209(of)-209(an)-209(individual)-210(personality)-209(in)-209(St.)-236(Matthew's)-209(Gospel)-209(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(almost)-188(entirely)-188(wanting.)-229(In)-188(its)-188(general)-188(structure)-188(it)-188(forms)-188(a)-188(striking)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contrast)-368(to)-369(that)-368(of)-369(John.)-605(Supposing)-368(it)-368(to)-369(have)-368(been)-368(composed)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1984 0 obj <<
/Length 2771      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(430)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(by)-383(the)-383(Apostle,)-416(he)-383(has)-383(entirely)-383(hidden)-383(his)-383(individuality)-383(in)-383(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(narrative.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(The)-488(question,)-547(therefore,)-547(really)-488(turns)-488(on)-488(the)-488(conclusion)-487(at)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(which)-299(we)-298(are)-299(able)-299(to)-298(arrive)-299(as)-299(to)-298(whether)-299(the)-299(Synoptic)-298(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-306(faithful)-307(representations)-306(of)-306(the)-307(primitive)-306(apostolic)-306(traditions.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-389(have)-390(proved)-389(that)-390(even)-389(at)-390(the)-389(latest)-390(date)-389(to)-390(which)-389(opponents)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assign)-287(their)-286(publication,)-296(they)-286(must)-287(have)-286(been)-287(writ)1(ten)-287(within)-286(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(period)-316(when)-315(all)-316(the)-315(requisite)-315(materials)-316(existed)-315(for)-316(composing)-315(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(substantially)-282(correct)-283(account)-282(of)-283(all)-282(the)-283(leading)-282(facts;)-299(that)-282(such)-282(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(traditionary)-320(account)-321(was)-320(certainly)-320(handed)-321(down)-320(in)-320(the)-320(Church;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-446(it)-446(formed)-446(the)-447(ground-work)-446(of)-446(its)-446(existence;)-544(that)-446(it)-446(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-359(been)-359(derived)-359(from)-359(apostolic)-359(men,)-386(who)-359(had)-359(ample)-358(means)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-452(knowing)-903(the)-451(facts;)-553(that)-451(the)-452(Church)-451(possessed)-452(the)-451(means)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([492])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(of)-362(transmitting)-362(them)-362(accurately,)-390(such)-362(as)-362(were)-362(never)-362(possessed)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-437(any)-436(other)-436(Society;)-530(and)-437(that)-436(it)-437(was)-436(under)-437(the)-436(necessity)-436(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(doing)-299(so)-299(as)-299(the)-300(condition)-299(of)-299(its)-299(life;)-324(and)-299(that)-299(while)-299(this)-299(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remained)-223(fresh)-223(in)-223(the)-222(recollections)-223(both)-223(of)-223(the)-223(community)-223(and)-222(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-340(individual)-341(members,)-363(it)-340(would)-340(have)-341(been)-340(impossible)-340(to)-340(foist)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-243(them)-243(a)-244(fict)1(itious)-244(story.)-247(I)-244(shall)-243(now)-243(proceed)-243(to)-243(inquire)-243(how)-243(far)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(phenomena)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Gospels)-250(tend)-250(to)-250(establish)-250(these)-250(positions.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 -29.64 Td [([493])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1993 0 obj <<
/Length 3333      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Chapter)-267(XXII.)-267(The)-267(Historical)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Character)-267(Of)-266(The)-267(Gospels)-266(As)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Deduced)-267(From)-267(Their)-267(Internal)]TJ 0 -24.647 Td [(Structure.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -38.661 Td [(This)-176(subject)-175(is)-176(an)-176(extremely)-175(extensive)-176(one.)-225(The)-176(utmost,)-190(therefore,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-207(I)-206(can)-207(do)-207(is)-206(to)-207(notice)-207(a)-206(few)-207(of)-207(the)-206(most)-207(important)-207(points)-206(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bear)-401(on)-401(the)-402(argument.)-703(I)-401(have)-402(already)-401(shown)-401(that)-401(the)-401(general)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(principles)-285(of)-284(historical)-285(evidence)-284(point)-284(to)-285(the)-284(conclusion)-285(that)-284(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Synoptic)-404(Gospels)-403(are)-404(three)-403(different)-404(versions)-403(of)-404(the)-403(primitive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(apostolical)-320(traditions)-320(respecting)-321(the)-320(actions)-320(and)-320(the)-320(teaching)-320(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-448(Christ,)-498(and)-448(that)-448(even)-449(on)-448(the)-448(assumption)-448(that)-448(the)-448(dates)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(assigned)-334(to)-334(them)-334(by)-334(the)-334(opponents)-334(are)-334(the)-334(correct)-334(ones)-334(\050which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(however)-194(I)-194(would)-194(by)-194(no)-195(means)-194(be)-194(understood)-194(as)-194(conceding,)-205(for)-194(all)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-264(internal)-265(evidence)-264(points)-265(to)-264(a)-264(much)-265(earlier)-264(period\051,)-268(they)-264(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(still)-204(composed)-204(within)-204(the)-204(period)-204(when)-204(such)-204(traditions)-204(possess)-204(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(highest)-271(historical)-271(value.)-312(I)-271(must)-270(now)-271(inquire)-271(whether)-271(the)-270(general)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(structure)-250(of)-250(these)-250(Gospels)-250(confirms)-250(this)-250(conclusion.)]TJ 11.956 -14.797 Td [(The)-391(question)-390(therefore)-391(at)-391(once)-390(arises,)-426(what)-391(is)-391(their)-390(general)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(character?)-375(Do)-292(they)-292(present)-292(the)-291(marks)-292(of)-292(traditionary)-292(history;)-312(or)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-311(being)-311(three)-311(works)-311(composed)-311(by)-311(three)-310(different)-311(authors,)-326(who)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-389(only)-389(wrote)-388(independently)-389(of)-389(each)-389(other,)-423(but)-389(who)-389(used)-388(no)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(common)-334(source)-334(of)-334(information?)-502(Do)-334(their)-334(narratives)-334(present)-334(us)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-309(the)-310(characteristics)-309(of)-309(historical)-309(truth)-310(or)-309(of)-309(fictitious)-309(inven-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion?)-249(The)-246(facts)-246(before)-246(us)-246(are)-246(ample,)-493(and)-246(they)-246(ought)-246(to)-246(enable)-246(us)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([494])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(to)-250(return)-250(a)-250(definite)-250(answer)-250(to)-250(these)-250(questions.)]TJ 11.956 -14.797 Td [(The)-274(most)-275(remarkable)-274(trait)-275(which)-274(first)-275(strikes)-274(the)-275(reader)-274(is)-274(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(presence)-265(of)-265(a)-265(common)-265(narrative)-265(interwoven)-265(with)-265(a)-265(considerable)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1997 0 obj <<
/Length 4597      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(432)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(amount)-311(of)-311(matter)-310(peculiar)-311(to)-311(each)-311(Gospel.)-432(Many)-311(of)-311(the)-310(events,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-340(several)-340(of)-340(the)-340(discourses)-340(are)-340(narrated)-340(by)-340(all)-340(three)-339(Evange-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(lists;)-323(others)-299(by)-298(only)-299(two.)-396(Besides)-299(these)-298(common)-299(narratives)-298(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discourses,)-232(which)-228(form)-227(the)-228(larger)-228(portion)-227(of)-228(the)-228(Gospels,)-232(each)-227(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(them)-265(contains)-264(narratives)-265(and)-264(discourses)-265(peculiar)-264(to)-265(itself.)-293(While)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-359(possess)-359(much)-359(that)-359(is)-360(common,)-386(it)-359(is)-359(clear)-359(that)-359(each)-359(writer)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-349(a)-349(distinct)-348(object)-349(in)-349(view)-349(in)-348(the)-349(compilation)-349(of)-349(his)-348(Gospel;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-217(of)-217(St.)-239(Matthew)-218(being)-217(chiefly)-217(designed)-217(for)-217(Jewish)-217(Christians;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-429(of)-429(St.)-786(Luke)-429(for)-429(Gentile)-429(converts,)-473(and)-429(that)-429(of)-429(St.)-786(Mark)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(occupying)-357(an)-357(intermediate)-356(place)-357(between)-357(the)-357(two.)-570(It)-357(was)-356(also)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(obviously)-363(the)-362(object)-363(of)-363(the)-362(author)-363(of)-362(St.)-588(Matthew's)-363(Gospel)-362(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(set)-324(forth)-324(the)-325(discourses;)-361(of)-324(that)-324(of)-324(St.)-473(Mark's)-324(to)-324(give)-324(a)-324(graphic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(description)-289(of)-289(the)-289(actions)-289(of)-289(our)-289(Lord.)-367(Each)-289(of)-289(these)-289(Gospels)-288(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(also)-250(distinguished)-250(by)-250(a)-250(number)-250(of)-250(minor)-250(peculiarities.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(When)-277(the)-277(common)-277(narrative)-277(comes)-277(to)-277(be)-277(closely)-277(scrutinized,)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(it)-201(presents)-201(us)-200(with)-201(phenomena)-201(more)-200(remarkable)-201(than)-201(any)-201(that)-200(can)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-343(found)-343(elsewhere)-342(in)-343(literature.)-528(These)-343(narratives)-343(are)-342(couched)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-297(a)-297(considerable)-296(extent)-297(in)-297(the)-297(same)-296(words)-297(and)-297(phrases,)-308(closely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interwoven)-409(with)-409(a)-409(number)-408(of)-409(most)-409(singular)-409(variations,)-448(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-347(an)-347(important)-346(bearing)-347(on)-347(their)-347(historical)-346(character.)-541(As)-346(far)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(as)-325(the)-324(words)-325(are)-325(identical,)-343(they)-325(force)-325(on)-324(us)-325(the)-325(conclusion)-324(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-291(must)-291(have)-291(been)-291(derived)-291(from)-291(some)-291(common)-291(origin.)-372(These)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(identities)-203(are)-204(more)-203(striking)-203(in)-204(the)-203(narrative)-203(than)-204(in)-203(the)-203(discourses.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Three)-389(independent)-389(writers,)-423(if)-389(they)-389(intended)-389(to)-389(hand)-389(down)-388(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(general)-184(sense)-183(of)-184(a)-184(body)-183(of)-184(discourses,)-197(on)-184(the)-183(supposition)-184(that)-183(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(were)-293(in)-293(possession)-293(of)-292(accurate)-586(information,)-304(would)-293(repeat)-292(them)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([495])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(to)-306(a)-306(great)-306(extent)-306(in)-306(the)-306(same)-306(words.)-418(But)-306(that)-306(three)-306(independent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writers,)-235(who)-232(used)-232(no)-232(common)-231(source)-232(of)-232(information)-232(in)-231(narrating)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-396(same)-396(occurrences,)-432(should)-395(have)-396(employed)-396(the)-396(same)-395(words)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-330(the)-329(extent)-330(to)-329(which)-329(it)-330(has)-329(been)-330(done)-329(by)-330(the)-329(authors)-330(of)-329(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-250(is)-250(simply)-250(impossible.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-200(if)-201(they)-200(had)-201(all)-201(copied)-200(from)-201(the)-200(same)-201(document,)-210(these)-200(iden-)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(tities)-372(of)-372(expression)-373(must)-372(inevitably)-372(have)-372(been)-372(more)-372(complete.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(It)-294(would)-293(have)-294(been)-293(impossible)-293(that)-294(they)-293(could)-294(have)-293(been)-294(of)-293(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2001 0 obj <<
/Length 4628      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(433)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(capricious)-263(character)-264(which)-263(they)-264(present)-263(to)-263(us)-264(in)-263(the)-264(pages)-263(of)-263(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Evangelists.)-346(Even)-282(in)-282(the)-282(narratives,)-290(frequent)-282(as)-282(is)-282(the)-282(use)-282(of)-281(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same)-236(words,)-239(the)-236(variations)-236(are)-236(numerous;)-241(nor)-236(are)-236(they)-236(much)-236(less)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-376(in)-375(the)-376(discourses.)-627(They)-375(are)-376(of)-376(the)-375(most)-376(singular)-375(character,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-298(without)-298(the)-297(smallest)-298(apparent)-298(purpose.)-393(Sometimes)-298(they)-297(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(simple)-245(changes)-244(in)-244(grammatical)-245(construction,)-246(or)-244(a)-244(word)-245(of)-244(nearly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-224(same)-223(meaning)-224(is)-224(substituted)-224(for)-223(another.)-242(Then)-223(we)-224(find)-224(one)-223(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(more)-242(lines,)-243(sometimes)-241(a)-242(whole)-241(sentence,)-243(transposed.)-247(Sometimes)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(words)-278(or)-279(lines)-278(which)-279(are)-278(inserted)-279(by)-278(one)-279(Evangelist)-278(are)-278(omitted)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(by)-329(another,)-349(the)-328(omission)-329(obscuring,)-349(and)-329(the)-329(insertion)-328(throwing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(light)-340(on)-341(the)-340(sense.)-521(At)-341(other)-340(times,)-363(a)-340(whole)-341(incident)-340(is)-340(omitted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which,)-249(if)-248(it)-248(had)-248(been)-248(inserted,)-249(would)-248(have)-248(made)-248(an)-248(obscure)-248(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(text)-235(plai)1(n.)-245(In)-235(the)-234(discourses)-235(it)-234(occasionally)-235(happens)-234(that)-235(a)-234(part)-234(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(one)-204(which)-205(we)-204(read)-205(in)-204(the)-204(same)-205(context)-204(in)-205(another)-204(Evangelist,)-213(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-277(seems)-277(to)-277(be)-277(required)-277(by)-277(the)-277(connection,)-284(is)-277(omitted,)-283(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(words)-213(of)-213(nearly)-212(the)-213(same)-213(import)-213(have)-212(been)-213(attributed)-213(to)-213(our)-212(Lord)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(elsewhere.)-593(Again:)-478(sayings)-365(are)-364(reported)-364(in)-364(which,)-393(while)-364(many)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(words)-341(are)-341(the)-341(same,)-364(others)-341(are)-341(varied)-341(without)-341(any)-341(conceivable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reason)-232(for)-231(the)-232(variation.)-244(In)-232(one)-231(or)-232(two)-232(instances,)-235(when)-232(words)-231(are)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(put)-213(into)-212(the)-213(mouths)-212(of)-213(persons)-212(different)-212(from)-213(those)-212(to)-213(whom)-212(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-308(attributed)-308(by)-308(another)-308(Evangelist,)-323(the)-308(grammatical)-616(structure)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([496])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(is)-310(altered)-311(to)-310(suit)-310(the)-311(variation.)-431(Of)-310(this)-310(we)-311(have)-310(two)-310(remarkable)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(examples)-208(in)-207(the)-208(account)-208(of)-207(the)-208(healing)-208(of)-207(the)-208(Centurion's)-207(servant,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-218(in)-219(the)-218(narrative)-218(of)-218(the)-219(request)-218(which)-218(the)-219(two)-218(sons)-218(of)-218(Zebedee)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-299(Salome)-300(presented)-299(to)-299(our)-299(Lord.)-398(The)-300(words)-299(are)-299(precisely)-299(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same,)-313(while)-301(the)-300(grammatical)-301(forms)-301(differ,)-313(according)-300(as)-301(the)-300(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-250(the)-250(other)-250(is)-250(regarded)-250(as)-250(the)-250(speaker.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(Such)-319(are)-319(the)-319(chief)-319(phenomena.)-457(But)-319(the)-319(full)-319(extent)-319(and)-319(char-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(acter)-374(of)-374(these)-374(variations,)-405(in)-374(the)-374(closest)-374(union)-374(as)-374(they)-374(are)-374(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(identities)-413(of)-413(expression,)-454(can)-413(only)-413(be)-413(appreciated)-413(by)-413(a)-413(careful)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(comparison)-301(of)-301(the)-300(parallel)-301(narrative)-301(of)-300(the)-301(Gospels.)-402(Numerous,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(however,)-215(as)-206(are)-206(the)-206(variations,)-215(it)-207(must)-206(be)-206(observed)-206(that)-206(they)-206(exert)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(scarcely)-354(any)-354(appreciable)-354(influence)-353(on)-354(the)-354(general)-354(sense.)-561(They)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(utterly)-339(negate)-339(the)-339(idea)-339(that)-339(they)-339(can)-339(have)-339(originated)-339(in)-339(any)-339(set)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2005 0 obj <<
/Length 5041      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(434)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(or)-369(deliberate)-369(purpose.)-606(Let)-369(us)-369(take)-368(for)-369(example)-369(the)-369(account)-368(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-253(feeding)-253(of)-252(the)-253(five)-253(thousand.)-258(The)-253(Synoptics)-253(employ)-253(the)-252(very)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remarkable)-223(expression,)-228(that)-223(after)-223(the)-223(performance)-223(of)-223(the)-222(miracle,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-271(Lord)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 41.672 0 Td [(constrained)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 54.768 0 Td [(the)-271(disciples)-272(to)-271(embark,)-277(without)-272(giving)-271(us)]TJ -96.44 -13.55 Td [(a)-286(hint)-285(of)-286(the)-286(reason)-286(of)-285(so)-286(unusual)-286(an)-285(occurrence.)-357(We)-286(turn)-286(to)-285(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(John's)-264(Gospel;)-271(he)-264(says)-263(not)-264(one)-264(word)-264(about)-264(our)-264(Lord's)-263(constrain-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ing)-305(the)-304(disciples)-305(to)-304(embark,)-319(but)-304(tells)-305(us)-305(that)-304(the)-305(multitude)-304(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(designing)-230(to)-229(come)-230(and)-230(take)-230(Jesus)-229(by)-230(force)-230(and)-229(make)-230(Him)-230(a)-229(king.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(This)-330(notice,)-350(which)-330(is)-330(of)-330(the)-330(most)-330(incidental)-330(character,)-350(gives)-329(as)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-297(fullest)-297(explanation)-297(of)-297(an)-297(event)-297(which)-297(would)-297(otherwise)-297(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-250(extremely)-250(obscure.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-374(further:)-499(in)-374(the)-374(account)-374(of)-374(the)-375(miracle)-374(itself,)-405(one)-374(of)-374(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Evangelists)-302(tells)-302(us,)-315(that)-303(the)-302(numbers)-302(who)-302(were)-302(fed)-302(were)-302(about)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(five)-283(thousand,)-291(besides)-282(women)-283(and)-283(children.)-348(How)-283(then)-283(were)-282(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(numbers)-253(ascertained?)-258(and)-252(how)-253(came)-253(it)-252(to)-253(pass)-253(that)-252(the)-253(men)-252(only)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(were)-304(numbered,)-317(and)-304(neither)-303(the)-304(women,)-317(nor)-304(children?)-411(Another)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Evangelist)-417(tells)-209(us)-209(that)-208(the)-209(multitude)-208(were)-209(directed)-209(to)-208(sit)-209(down)-208(in)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([497])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(companies)-230(by)-230(hundreds)-229(and)-230(by)-230(fifties.)-243(This)-230(at)-230(once)-230(explains)-229(how)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-266(numbers)-266(were)-267(arrived)-266(at.)-298(But)-266(if)-267(this)-266(was)-266(the)-266(case,)-270(how)-266(came)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-290(to)-291(be)-290(known)-291(that)-290(the)-291(men)-290(were)-290(about)-291(five)-290(thousand;)-311(and)-290(how)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(came)-220(it)-220(to)-220(pass,)-225(that)-220(the)-220(women)-220(and)-220(children)-220(were)-220(excluded)-219(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-312(total)-312(enumeration?)-435(Here)-312(again)-312(another)-312(Evangelist)-312(comes)-311(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-236(help;)-241(and)-236(informs)-236(us)-236(that)-237(although)-236(the)-236(order)-236(was)-236(given)-236(to)-236(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whole)-352(multitude)-353(to)-352(sit)-353(down)-352(in)-353(companies,)-378(those)-352(who)-352(actually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(did)-275(so)-275(were)-275(the)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 70.162 0 Td [(\004)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.727 0 Td [(\275\264\301\265\302)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 28.002 0 Td [(not)-275(the)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 33.27 0 Td [(\004)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.727 0 Td [(\275\270\301\311\300\277\271)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 38.204 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 5.794 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 16.872 0 Td [(that)-275(the)-275(men)-275(only)]TJ -203.758 -13.55 Td [(sat)-267(down,)-270(but)-267(the)-266(women)-267(and)-266(children)-267(did)-267(not.)-299(This)-267(is)-266(told)-267(us)-266(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(most)-250(incidental)-250(form,)-250(appearing)-250(only)-250(in)-250(the)-250(Greek.)]TJ 11.955 -16.004 Td [(This)-291(last)-291(case)-291(is)-291(perhaps)-291(the)-291(most)-291(remarkable)-291(example)-292(in)-291(the)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(Gospels,)-349(of)-329(the)-329(manner)-329(in)-330(which)-329(an)-329(incidental)-329(variation)-329(in)-329(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Evangelist)-306(throws)-306(light)-306(on)-306(the)-306(obscurities)-306(of)-306(another.)-418(Can)-305(such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-359(narrative)-360(be)-359(otherwise)-359(than)-360(historical?)-578(This)-359(note)-359(of)-359(veracity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-293(so)-294(entirely)-293(incidental)-293(that)-294(it)-293(has)-293(in)-294(all)-293(probability)-293(escaped)-293(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(notice)-267(of)-268(nine)-267(hundred)-267(and)-268(ninety-nine)-267(out)-267(of)-268(every)-267(thousand)-267(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-351(readers.)-551(There)-351(are)-350(many)-351(others,)-375(though)-351(less)-350(striking,)-376(all)-350(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2009 0 obj <<
/Length 4992      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(435)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(which)-308(are)-307(of)-308(the)-307(same)-308(incidental)-308(character,)-322(and)-307(it)-308(is)-307(impossible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-350(attribute)-350(them)-350(to)-350(design.)-549(Surely)-350(this)-350(can)-350(only)-350(have)-349(resulted)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-250(our)-250(being)-250(in)-250(the)-250(presence)-250(of)-250(facts)-250(and)-250(not)-250(of)-250(fiction.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-351(the)-351(variations)-351(in)-352(the)-351(discourses)-351(require)-351(a)-351(further)-351(notice.)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(When)-263(variations)-262(occur)-262(in)-263(highly)-262(important)-263(discourses,)-266(it)-262(is)-262(open)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-317(the)-318(suspicion)-317(that)-317(they)-317(have)-317(originated)-318(in)-317(the)-317(deliberate)-317(pur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pose)-331(of)-332(giving)-331(a)-332(different)-331(doctrinal)-332(meaning)-331(to)-332(the)-331(words.)-494(But)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(when)-214(we)-214(closely)-214(exami)1(ne)-214(those)-214(in)-214(the)-214(Gospels,)-221(although)-214(they)-213(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(very)-362(numerous,)-390(we)-362(find)-362(them)-362(of)-362(a)-362(purely)-362(incidental)-362(character,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(exerting)-206(a)-207(very)-206(inconsiderable)-207(influence)-206(on)-207(the)-206(sense.)-236(I)-206(am)-206(aware)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-334(attempts)-334(have)-334(been)-334(made)-333(to)-334(show)-334(that)-668(some)-334(few)-334(of)-333(these)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([498])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(variations)-447(have)-446(originated)-447(in)-446(design;)-545(but)-446(these)-447(attempts)-446(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prove)-235(the)-234(straits)-234(to)-235(which)-234(those)-235(who)-234(make)-235(them)-234(are)-235(driven.)-244(Thus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-316(the)-316(account)-315(of)-316(the)-316(Sermon)-316(on)-316(the)-316(Mount)-315(as)-316(we)-316(read)-316(it)-316(in)-315(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Matthew,)-390(the)-361(passage)-362(runs:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 127.891 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Blessed)-362(are)-361(the)-362(poor)-362(in)-361(spirit)-362(for)]TJ -132.735 -13.55 Td [(theirs)-313(is)-312(the)-313(kingdom)-312(of)-312(heaven.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 143.394 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.253 0 Td [(In)-312(the)-313(corresponding)-312(passage)]TJ -151.647 -13.549 Td [(in)-316(St.)-447(Luke)-316(it)-315(runs:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 89.988 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Blessed)-316(are)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 54.147 0 Td [(ye)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.132 0 Td [(poor,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 22.723 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 8.288 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 18.21 0 Td [(the)-316(poor)-315(people)]TJ -211.331 -13.549 Td [(who)-267(were)-268(our)-267(Lord's)-267(disciples,)-272(for)-267(the)-267(Evangelist)-267(expressly)-267(tells)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(us)-302(that)-302(these)-302(words)-303(were)-302(addressed,)-315(not)-302(to)-302(the)-302(multitude)-302(gener-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ally,)-383(but)-356(to)-357(them.)-569(The)-356(supposition)-356(that)-357(this)-356(variation)-356(indicates)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-258(presence)-257(of)-258(something)-257(resembling)-258(communistic)-257(views)-258(in)-257(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(author)-247(of)-247(St.)-249(Luke's)-246(Gospel)-247(is)-247(too)-247(absurd)-246(to)-247(be)-247(worthy)-247(of)-246(serious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discussion.)-447(Taking)-316(them)-316(as)-316(a)-316(whole,)-332(these)-316(discrepancies)-315(create)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-257(appreciable)-256(difference)-257(in)-256(the)-257(teaching)-256(of)-257(Jesus)-256(as)-257(reported)-256(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(different)-250(Evangelists.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(One)-364(thing)-364(respecting)-363(them)-364(is)-364(clear)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 155.575 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(they)-364(bear)-364(the)-363(strongest)]TJ -178.44 -13.549 Td [(testimony)-186(to)-186(the)-186(historical)-185(character)-186(of)-186(the)-186(writings)-186(which)-185(contain)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(them.)-369(It)-290(is)-290(simply)-289(inconceivable)-290(that)-290(the)-289(authors)-290(of)-290(the)-289(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-442(them)-443(deliberately.)-827(They)-442(must)-443(have)-442(found)-443(them)-442(in)-442(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sources)-261(from)-261(which)-260(they)-261(drew)-261(their)-261(information.)-282(They)-261(form)-260(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-191(the)-192(strongest)-191(proofs)-192(that)-191(neither)-191(a)-192(forger,)-203(nor)-191(an)-191(accommodater)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-395(facts)-394(for)-395(the)-394(purpose)-395(of)-394(making)-394(them)-395(fit)-394(in)-395(with)-394(particular)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(doctrinal)-436(theories,)-482(has)-435(had)-436(any)-436(hand)-435(in)-436(originating)-436(them.)-806(In)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(simple)-375(changes)-376(in)-375(grammatical)-375(structure,)-407(purpose)-375(or)-375(design)-375(is)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2014 0 obj <<
/Length 4601      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(436)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(inconceivable.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-301(the)-300(variations)-301(in)-300(narratives,)-313(such)-301(as)-300(those)-301(above)-300(referred)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(to,)-239(are)-237(even)-236(more)-236(important)-237(as)-236(constituting)-236(an)-237(attestation)-236(of)-236(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-436(reality)-436(than)-436(variations)-435(in)-436(discourses.)-808(Four)-435(separate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(versions)-427(of)-427(a)-427(fictitious)-427(incident)-427(fail)-427(to)-427(clear)-427(up)-427(one)-427(another's)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(obscurities.)-530(But)-344(the)-343(ability)-343(to)-344(do)-343(so)-344(is)-343(the)-343(distinctive)-687(mark)-343(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([499])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(imperfect)-300(narratives)-299(of)-300(facts,)-312(told)-299(by)-300(different)-300(witnesses.)-398(When)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(two)-461(things)-461(of)-462(a)-461(complicated)-461(mechanical)-461(construction)-461(exactly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dovetail)-253(into)-252(each)-253(other,)-254(it)-252(is)-253(a)-253(proof)-253(that)-252(they)-253(have)-253(originated)-252(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-299(same)-298(mind.)-396(In)-299(a)-298(similar)-299(manner,)-311(when)-299(a)-298(number)-299(of)-298(distinct)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(narratives,)-297(each)-288(of)-288(which)-287(is)-288(more)-288(or)-288(less)-288(incomplete,)-297(exactly)-287(fit)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-190(each)-190(other,)-202(this)-191(constitutes)-190(a)-190(proof,)-202(that)-190(they)-190(did)-190(not)-190(originate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(a)-250(fiction)-250(but)-250(in)-250(a)-250(fact.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(An)-363(illustration)-363(will)-363(aid)-363(in)-363(showing)-363(the)-363(force)-363(of)-363(this)-363(reason-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ing.)-633(The)-378(early)-377(history)-378(of)-377(Rome)-378(is)-378(unquestionably)-377(of)-378(a)-377(highly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(legendary)-335(character.)-503(We)-335(have)-335(two)-334(versions)-335(of)-334(it,)-356(one)-335(by)-334(Livy,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-345(another)-346(by)-345(Dionysius.)-536(These)-346(writers)-345(do)-345(not)-346(give)-345(us)-345(direct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accounts)-317(of)-317(the)-317(primitive)-316(legends,)-334(but)-317(their)-317(narratives)-317(are)-316(com-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(piled)-215(from)-215(authors)-214(of)-215(a)-215(much)-215(earlier)-214(date,)-222(who)-215(first)-215(reduced)-214(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-296(writing.)-387(Still)-295(these)-296(historians)-296(may)-295(be)-296(viewed)-296(as)-295(substantially)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accurate)-214(reporters)-214(of)-214(the)-214(legendary)-214(history,)-221(as)-214(it)-214(was)-214(compiled)-214(by)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-294(earlier)-294(writers.)-383(An)-294(important)-294(question)-294(therefore)-294(arises,)-305(does)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-401(twofold)-401(account)-401(which)-401(we)-401(possess)-401(of)-401(these)-401(legends,)-438(after)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-314(the)-313(efforts)-314(made)-313(by)-314(Livy)-314(and)-313(Dionysius)-314(to)-313(weave)-314(them)-313(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-359(consistent)-359(whole,)-386(bear)-358(the)-359(smallest)-359(analogy)-359(to)-359(the)-358(narratives)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contained)-208(in)-207(four)-208(Evangelists?)-236(It)-207(is)-208(clear)-207(that)-208(great)-207(disagreements)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existed)-311(among)-311(the)-311(original)-312(authorities.)-433(Let)-311(us)-311(take)-311(any)-311(account)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-328(the)-329(supposed)-328(events)-329(of)-328(three)-329(years)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 166.306 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(do)-328(the)-329(variations)-328(in)-329(the)]TJ -177.215 -13.549 Td [(two)-279(accounts)-278(bear)-279(the)-278(smallest)-279(resemblance)-279(to)-278(the)-279(singular)-278(phe-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nomena)-369(which)-369(we)-369(find)-370(in)-369(the)-369(Evangelists?)-607(Will)-369(they)-369(dovetail)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-380(one)-380(another?)-639(Will)-380(the)-380(small)-380(additions)-380(in)-380(one)-380(throw)-379(light)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-399(the)-399(obscurities)-398(of)-399(the)-399(other?)-696(Do)-399(the)-399(speeches)-399(present)-398(any)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(indications)-415(of)-414(being)-415(copies)-414(of)-415(a)-415(common)-414(original?)-744(All)-414(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(questions)-231(must)-231(be)-231(answered)-230(in)-231(the)-231(negative.)-244(Whence)-231(then)-230(comes)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2018 0 obj <<
/Length 4667      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(437)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(this)-240(difference)-240(between)-239(the)-240(narratives)-240(of)-239(the)-480(Evangelists)-240(and)-239(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([500])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(legendary)-253(accounts)-253(of)-253(the)-253(origin)-253(of)-253(the)-253(Roman)-253(power?)-259(I)-253(answer,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(because)-250(the)-250(one)-250(is)-250(founded)-250(on)-250(fact)-250(and)-250(the)-250(other)-250(on)-250(fiction.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-268(is)-269(not)-268(my)-269(intention)-268(to)-269(discuss)-268(the)-269(innumerable)-268(theories)-269(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(have)-197(been)-196(propounded)-196(as)-197(to)-196(the)-197(origin)-196(of)-197(the)-196(Gospels,)-208(for)-196(the)-196(pur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(pose)-265(of)-266(accounting)-265(for)-265(the)-266(common)-265(narrative,)-269(its)-265(variations,)-269(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-242(additions)-242(peculiar)-241(to)-242(each.)-247(Many)-242(of)-242(these)-242(theories)-242(violate)-241(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(principle)-282(of)-283(common)-282(sense;)-299(and)-282(if)-283(the)-282(contrary)-283(were)-282(not)-282(known)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-288(be)-287(the)-288(fact)-287(they)-288(would)-287(suggest)-288(the)-287(idea)-288(that)-287(their)-288(authors)-287(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(never)-420(practised)-420(the)-420(art)-420(of)-420(literary)-420(composition.)-760(Among)-420(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(I)-412(shall)-411(only)-412(notice)-412(the)-411(theories)-412(which)-411(suppose)-412(that)-412(the)-411(Evan-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(gelists)-403(had)-404(before)-403(them)-404(one)-403(common)-404(document)-403(when)-403(writing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-374(Gospels;)-435(or)-374(that)-374(one)-373(of)-374(them)-374(had)-373(before)-374(him)-374(the)-373(Gospel)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-265(another;)-273(that)-266(they)-265(deliberately)-265(copied)-266(the)-265(common)-265(words)-265(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(phrases,)-263(and)-261(no)-260(less)-261(deliberately)-260(made)-261(the)-260(alterations,)-263(additions,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-276(transpositions)-275(which)-276(the)-275(common)-276(narrative)-275(presents.)-327(Let)-275(us)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(take)-294(for)-293(an)-294(illustration)-293(the)-294(supposition)-293(that)-294(the)-293(author)-294(of)-293(Mark's)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospel)-414(had)-414(that)-414(of)-414(Matthew)-413(before)-414(him,)-455(or)-414(the)-414(converse.)-741(In)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-290(one)-289(case)-290(he)-290(must)-289(have)-290(deliberately)-290(retained)-289(all)-290(the)-289(common)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(words)-315(and)-315(phrases,)-331(after)-314(making)-315(the)-315(most)-315(capricious)-314(variations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-470(suppressions.)-911(Next,)-525(he)-470(must)-470(have)-470(inserted)-470(all)-470(the)-470(little)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(additions)-276(which)-275(distinguish)-276(the)-276(Gospel)-276(of)-275(St.)-327(Mark)-276(from)-276(that)-275(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(St.)-351(Matthew,)-293(and)-283(made)-284(the)-284(requisite)-284(transpositions.)-351(But)-284(what)-283(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(still)-313(more)-313(remarkable,)-328(he)-313(must)-313(also)-312(have)-313(taxed)-313(his)-313(invention)-312(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(insert)-339(in)-340(the)-339(midst)-339(of)-340(its)-339(impersonal)-339(narrative)-340(all)-339(those)-339(graphic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(descriptions)-367(which)-368(impart)-367(to)-367(Mark's)-368(Gospel)-367(the)-367(appearance)-367(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ocular)-341(testimony.)-522(Besides)-340(all)-341(this)-340(he)-341(must)-341(of)-340(set)-341(purpose)-340(have)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(omitted)-326(nearly)-326(all)-327(the)-326(discourses)-326(in)-326(which)-326(Matthew's)-326(Gospel)-326(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-379(full,)-411(or)-379(have)-379(placed)-379(them)-378(in)-379(a)-379(different)-379(context.)-637(If,)-411(on)-378(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-323(hand,)-342(we)-323(suppose)-324(that)-323(Mark's)-324(Gospel)-323(is)-323(the)-324(original)-646(and)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([501])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(Matthew's)-387(the)-387(copy,)-421(the)-386(whole)-387(process)-387(must)-387(be)-386(reversed,)-421(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(above)-206(all)-207(the)-206(author)-206(must)-206(have)-206(deliberately)-207(struck)-206(out)-206(the)-206(graphic)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(portions)-330(of)-331(Mark,)-350(except)-330(in)-331(one)-330(or)-330(two)-330(instances,)-351(when)-330(he)-330(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(added)-319(some)-319(of)-319(his)-319(own.)-456(All)-319(theories)-319(which)-319(are)-319(founded)-319(on)-318(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2023 0 obj <<
/Length 4483      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(438)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(supposition)-414(that)-414(the)-414(authors)-414(of)-414(either)-414(Gospel)-414(used)-414(a)-414(common)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(document)-259(and)-259(deliberately)-258(altered)-259(it,)-261(or)-259(that)-259(one)-259(of)-259(them)-258(formed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(his)-320(Gospel)-320(out)-320(of)-320(that)-319(of)-320(another)-320(by)-320(a)-320(number)-320(of)-320(additions)-319(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subtractions)-250(axe)-250(simply)-250(incredible.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(But)-243(the)-243(common)-243(narrative)-243(exists)-243(with)-243(the)-243(identities)-243(of)-242(expres-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(sion)-313(interwoven)-313(with)-313(its)-313(variations.)-439(How)-313(are)-313(we)-313(to)-313(account)-313(for)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(this)-173(remarkable)-174(fact?)-224(The)-174(identities)-173(of)-174(expression)-173(must)-174(have)-173(had)-173(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(common)-207(origin.)-236(But)-207(what)-207(do)-207(the)-207(variations)-207(prove?)-235(Evidently)-207(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-337(narrative)-337(had)-338(passed)-337(through)-337(a)-337(period)-337(of)-337(oral)-337(transmission.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(No)-250(other)-250(theory)-250(can)-250(adequately)-250(account)-250(for)-250(them.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Such)-213(variations)-213(would)-213(naturally)-214(spring)-213(up)-213(in)-213(the)-213(course)-213(of)-213(oral)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(transmission.)-611(We)-370(have)-370(already)-370(seen)-371(that)-370(the)-370(circumstances)-370(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-299(Church)-299(rendered)-299(such)-299(a)-299(mode)-298(of)-299(transmission)-299(necessary,)-311(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(details)-344(of)-344(our)-343(Lord's)-344(life)-344(must)-343(have)-344(formed)-344(regular)-344(portions)-343(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Christian)-307(instruction.)-422(In)-307(doing)-307(this,)-322(variations)-307(would)-307(inevitably)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(arise.)-758(After)-420(a)-419(while)-420(they)-419(would)-420(assume)-419(a)-420(distinctive)-419(type)-419(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(different)-443(Churches.)-827(If)-443(then)-442(the)-443(Synoptic)-442(narratives)-443(are)-442(three)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(versions)-326(of)-325(an)-326(oral)-326(Gospel)-325(handed)-326(down)-326(in)-325(as)-326(many)-325(Churches,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-305(put)-304(together)-305(with)-304(additions)-305(by)-304(their)-305(respective)-304(authors,)-318(this)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(affords)-397(a)-397(reasonable)-397(explanation)-397(of)-397(the)-397(phenomena)-397(which)-396(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(common)-377(narrative)-377(presents.)-630(In)-377(this)-376(case)-377(the)-377(only)-377(thing)-376(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(involves)-316(a)-315(difficulty)-316(is)-315(the)-315(large)-316(number)-315(of)-316(identities)-315(preserved)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-257(the)-258(Evangelists.)-271(This)-258(proves)-257(the)-257(strong)-258(hold)-257(which)-257(the)-257(words)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(must)-415(have)-414(had)-415(on)-415(the)-414(minds)-415(of)-415(the)-414(members)-415(of)-415(the)-414(different)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Churches.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(The)-243(existence)-244(of)-243(a)-243(traditionary)-243(narrative)-244(is)-243(still)-243(further)-243(proved)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(by)-295(the)-295(fourth)-295(Gospel.)-384(No)-295(one)-295(can)-294(deny)-590(that)-295(this)-295(is)-295(an)-294(indepen-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([502])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(dent)-297(record,)-308(and)-297(that)-296(its)-297(origin)-297(must)-296(have)-297(been)-297(wholly)-296(different)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-319(that)-319(of)-319(the)-319(other)-318(three.)-457(Yet)-319(in)-319(those)-319(portions)-319(which)-318(cover)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(common)-235(ground)-235(with)-235(the)-235(Synoptics)-235(we)-235(meet)-235(with)-235(phenomena)-235(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-256(similar)-255(order,)-257(all)-256(proving)-256(that)-255(there)-256(must)-256(have)-255(been)-256(a)-255(narrative)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-262(existence)-261(which)-262(had)-261(impressed)-262(itself)-261(indelibly)-262(on)-261(the)-262(mind)-261(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-314(Church;)-346(so)-314(much)-314(so)-314(that)-314(an)-314(entirely)-314(independent)-314(writer)-314(fell)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-349(the)-349(same)-349(mode)-348(of)-349(expression)-349(when)-349(his)-349(subject)-349(led)-349(him)-348(to)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2027 0 obj <<
/Length 4451      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(439)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(narrate)-250(incidents)-250(common)-250(to)-250(the)-250(other)-250(three.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Every)-447(consideration)-447(which)-446(can)-447(be)-447(brought)-447(to)-447(bear)-447(on)-446(this)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(subject)-365(tends)-365(to)-365(prove)-365(the)-365(existence)-365(of)-365(a)-365(traditionary)-365(narrative)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-289(the)-288(actions)-289(and)-288(teaching)-289(of)-288(Jesus)-288(which)-289(was)-288(handed)-289(down)-288(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-356(Churches)-356(prior)-356(to)-356(the)-356(publication)-356(of)-356(either)-356(of)-356(the)-356(Synoptic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels,)-210(and)-200(that)-200(their)-200(common)-200(matter)-200(must)-200(have)-200(passed)-200(through)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(a)-290(period)-290(of)-290(oral)-290(transmission.)-370(It)-290(follows)-290(therefore)-290(that)-290(our)-289(three)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Synoptics)-365(are)-365(three)-365(different)-365(versions)-365(of)-365(the)-365(same)-365(oral)-365(Gospel)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(modified)-260(in)-260(the)-260(course)-259(of)-260(transmission)-260(and)-260(supplemented)-260(by)-259(ad-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ditional)-300(information)-300(introduced)-300(by)-300(their)-300(respective)-300(authors.)-400(We)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(know)-306(as)-307(a)-306(fact)-306(that)-307(a)-306(traditionary)-306(narrative)-307(maintained)-306(its)-306(place)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-367(the)-367(Church)-366(far)-367(into)-367(the)-367(second)-366(century.)-601(Papias)-366(deliberately)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(expressed)-230(his)-229(preference)-230(for)-229(it)-229(as)-230(compared)-229(with)-230(written)-229(records;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-220(the)-220(writings)-220(of)-220(other)-220(Fathers)-220(show)-220(their)-220(acquaintance)-220(with)-220(it.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-373(is)-373(clear)-373(therefore)-373(that)-373(a)-373(number)-373(of)-373(traditionary)-373(narratives)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(existed)-470(in)-471(the)-470(Church;)-580(and)-471(that)-470(if)-470(a)-471(number)-470(of)-470(persons)-470(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(set)-335(themselves)-334(to)-335(reduce)-335(these)-335(accounts)-334(to)-335(writing,)-356(they)-334(would)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-355(presented)-355(phenomena)-355(analogous)-355(to)-355(those)-355(of)-355(the)-354(Synoptic)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospels.)-606(I)-368(have)-369(also)-368(shown)-369(that)-368(these)-369(Gospels)-368(present)-369(all)-368(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(phenomena)-473(which)-473(distinguish)-473(this)-472(species)-473(of)-473(narrative.)-918(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(substantial)-419(agreement)-418(of)-418(the)-419(three,)-461(both)-418(as)-419(to)-418(facts)-418(and)-419(as)-418(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-374(discourses,)-405(is)-374(a)-374(guarantee)-374(that)-374(the)-374(actual)-374(traditions)-748(of)-374(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([503])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(Church)-436(have)-436(been)-437(accurately)-436(reported.)-808(Their)-436(diversities)-436(also)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(afford)-353(the)-352(strongest)-353(proof)-353(that)-353(these)-352(reports)-353(were)-353(composed)-352(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(perfect)-250(independence)-250(of)-250(each)-250(other.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(It)-247(is)-246(remarkable)-247(that)-246(the)-247(great)-246(majority)-247(of)-246(those)-247(against)-246(whom)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(I)-234(am)-234(reasoning)-233(admit)-234(that)-234(the)-233(discourses)-234(in)-234(the)-234(Synoptic)-233(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-453(fairly)-453(accurate)-452(representations)-453(of)-453(the)-453(actual)-453(utterances)-452(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus,)-329(although)-313(they)-312(must)-313(have)-313(passed)-313(through)-313(a)-313(period)-313(of)-312(oral)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(transmission.)-826(Yet)-443(it)-442(is)-442(certain)-442(that)-442(the)-442(accurate)-442(transmission)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-334(discourses)-334(by)-334(oral)-333(tradition)-334(is)-334(far)-334(more)-334(difficult)-334(than)-334(that)-333(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-387(report)-387(of)-387(facts)-388(through)-387(the)-387(same)-387(medium.)-661(The)-387(difficulty)-387(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(preventing)-435(the)-435(intrusion)-434(of)-435(foreign)-435(elements)-435(is)-435(much)-434(greater.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Slight)-342(alterations)-343(may)-342(materially)-342(affect)-342(their)-342(meaning.)-527(Yet)-342(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2031 0 obj <<
/Length 4973      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(440)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(discourses)-192(recorded)-192(in)-192(the)-192(Synoptics)-192(bear)-192(the)-192(indelible)-192(impress)-192(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-204(single)-203(mind,)-213(that)-203(of)-204(Jesus)-203(Christ.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 147.364 3.959 Td [(6)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.042 -3.959 Td [(It)-203(follows)-204(therefore)-204(that)-203(if)-204(the)]TJ -154.406 -13.549 Td [(traditions)-306(of)-307(the)-306(Church)-306(were)-307(able)-306(to)-306(hand)-307(down)-306(accurately)-306(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(discourses)-258(of)-258(our)-259(Lord)-258(until)-258(the)-258(time)-259(when)-258(they)-258(were)-258(reduced)-258(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(writing,)-212(still)-202(more)-203(easily)-202(would)-202(they)-203(transmit)-202(a)-203(correct)-202(account)-202(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-224(acts)-224(as)-224(narrated)-224(by)-224(His)-224(original)-224(followers.)-241(Except)-224(on)-224(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-327(the)-327(antecedent)-328(difficulty)-327(with)-327(which)-327(the)-327(miraculous)-327(element)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-248(the)-248(narrative)-248(is)-248(supposed)-248(to)-249(be)-248(attended,)-248(it)-248(would)-248(be)-248(absurd)-248(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accept)-314(the)-314(one)-314(and)-314(to)-314(reject)-314(the)-314(other)-314(as)-314(mere)-314(legendary)-314(inven-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(tion.)-532(But)-344(having)-344(once)-344(established)-344(the)-344(fact)-344(of)-344(the)-343(Resurrection,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-327(antecedent)-328(difficulty)-327(of)-327(the)-328(miracles)-327(is)-327(effectually)-327(disposed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of,)-250(and)-250(the)-250(facts)-250(resume)-250(their)-250(place)-250(in)-250(history.)]TJ 11.956 -13.815 Td [(It)-234(forms)-234(no)-235(objection)-234(to)-234(the)-234(general)-235(argument)-234(that)-234(some)-234(of)-234(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(Synoptics)-366(contain)-366(narratives)-366(of)-366(considerable)-366(length,)-395(which)-365(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(omitted)-243(by)-244(others.)-247(It)-244(was)-243(precisely)-486(what)-243(was)-244(to)-243(be)-243(expected)-243(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([504])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(the)-377(traditionary)-377(accounts)-377(would)-376(vary)-377(in)-377(this)-377(respect,)-409(and)-376(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incidents)-312(reported)-311(by)-312(different)-311(witnesses)-312(of)-311(our)-312(Lord's)-311(ministry)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(incorporated)-272(into)-272(them.)-317(They)-272(abound)-272(in)-272(the)-273(Gospel)-272(of)-272(St.)-316(Luke,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(who)-250(distinctly)-250(states)-250(that)-250(it)-250(is)-250(a)-250(compilation.)]TJ 11.956 -13.815 Td [(A)-363(careful)-362(study)-363(of)-363(the)-362(Gospel)-363(of)-362(St.)-588(Matthew)-363(must)-363(lead)-362(to)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-390(conclusion)-389(that)-390(its)-389(narrative)-390(portions)-390(are)-389(derived)-390(from)-389(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same)-434(general)-435(sources)-434(as)-434(those)-435(of)-434(the)-434(other)-435(two.)-803(We)-434(find)-434(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-328(precisely)-328(the)-328(same)-328(verbal)-328(identities)-328(which)-328(have)-328(been)-328(already)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(noticed)-290(as)-290(affording)-289(proof)-290(of)-290(the)-289(existence)-290(of)-290(a)-290(common)-289(source)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-253(information,)-254(and)-253(the)-253(same)-254(variations)-253(which)-253(prove)-253(that)-253(it)-253(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-322(passed)-323(through)-322(a)-323(period)-322(of)-322(oral)-323(transmission.)-467(Nor)-322(are)-322(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(indications)-223(of)-222(autoptic)-223(testimony)-222(stronger)-223(in)-223(Matthew)-222(than)-223(in)-222(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-245(two)-246(Evangelists;)-247(in)-245(fact,)-247(they)-245(are)-245(less)-246(so)-245(than)-246(in)-245(Mark.)-248(The)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(discourses)-292(in)-292(Matthew,)-302(viewed)-292(as)-292(a)-292(whole,)-302(are)-292(a)-292(far)-292(more)-291(com-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(plete)-330(collection)-329(of)-330(the)-329(sayings)-330(of)-329(our)-330(Lord,)-349(than)-329(those)-330(in)-329(Mark)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-291(Luke.)-374(It)-292(seems)-291(to)-291(have)-291(been)-292(one)-291(of)-291(the)-292(chief)-291(purposes)-291(of)-291(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(author)-284(of)-285(this)-284(Gospel)-285(to)-284(make)-284(a)-285(collection)-284(of)-285(them,)-293(and)-284(to)-284(unite)]TJ
0 g 0 G
ET
q
1 0 0 1 93.543 87.722 cm
[]0 d 0 J 0.398 w 0 0 m 112.25 0 l S
Q
BT
/F16 5.9776 Tf 99.77 80.91 Td [(6)]TJ/F16 8.9664 Tf 5.729 -3.809 Td [(Mr.)-236(Mill,)-216(in)-207(his)-208(recently)-207(published)-208(Essay)-207(on)-208(Theism,)-216(has)-207(strongly)-208(expressed)]TJ -11.956 -10.959 Td [(his)-250(belief)-250(that)-250(these)-250(discourses)-250(are)-250(the)-250(veritable)-250(utterances)-250(of)-250(Jesus.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2035 0 obj <<
/Length 4702      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(441)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(them)-304(by)-304(a)-304(brief)-304(narrative)-304(of)-304(events.)-412(But)-304(even)-304(in)-304(the)-303(discourses,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(some)-256(of)-256(the)-256(variations)-257(found)-256(in)-256(Mark)-256(and)-256(Luke)-256(possess)-256(stronger)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(claims)-349(to)-349(be)-350(regarded)-349(as)-349(the)-349(original)-350(form)-349(of)-349(the)-349(utterances)-349(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-300(Lord,)-313(than)-301(the)-300(corresponding)-301(ones)-300(in)-300(Matthew.)-402(In)-300(the)-300(parts)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-269(are)-268(common)-269(to)-269(the)-268(Synoptics,)-274(they)-268(are)-269(evidently)-268(founded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-205(one)-204(common)-205(source)-205(of)-204(information;)-220(and)-205(in)-204(this)-205(respect)-204(neither)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(them)-250(can)-250(put)-250(in)-250(a)-250(higher)-250(claim)-250(to)-250(originality)-250(than)-250(the)-250(other.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Such)-351(are)-352(some)-351(of)-352(the)-351(chief)-351(characteristics)-352(of)-351(these)-351(Gospels,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(which)-334(have)-334(the)-334(most)-333(intimate)-334(bearing)-334(on)-334(their)-334(claims)-334(to)-334(be)-333(re-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(garded)-320(as)-321(genuine)-320(historical)-320(productions.)-461(They)-320(are)-320(accounts)-320(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-223(traditions)-223(of)-222(the)-223(Church)-223(respecting)-223(the)-222(life)-223(and)-223(teaching)-223(of)-222(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Founder)-322(at)-323(the)-322(time)-323(when)-322(they)-323(were)-322(composed.)-468(I)-322(have)-322(already)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(shown,)-888(that)-405(if)-405(they)-405(were)-406(composed)-405(at)-405(any)-405(time)-405(between)-405(the)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([505])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(ministry)-278(of)-278(Jesus)-279(Christ)-278(and)-278(the)-278(first)-279(twenty)-278(years)-278(of)-278(the)-278(second)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(century,)-235(it)-230(would)-231(have)-231(been)-230(impossible)-231(to)-231(have)-230(substituted)-231(a)-230(leg-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(endary)-284(narrative)-285(for)-284(the)-284(account)-284(which)-284(was)-285(handed)-284(down)-284(in)-284(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Church.)-342(I)-281(am)-281(not)-281(concerned)-281(to)-280(prove)-281(that)-281(no)-281(inaccuracies)-280(could)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-359(crept)-359(into)-359(these)-359(traditionary)-359(accounts.)-577(The)-359(only)-358(question)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-348(the)-349(smallest)-348(importance)-348(is,)-373(are)-348(they)-348(substantially)-348(historical?)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(On)-293(this)-293(question)-292(mere)-293(minor)-293(details,)-303(the)-293(order)-293(and)-292(arrangement)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-411(events,)-450(or)-411(even)-411(the)-410(introduction)-411(of)-411(two)-410(or)-411(three)-410(erroneous)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accounts,)-230(has)-225(no)-224(more)-225(bearing)-225(than)-225(it)-225(has)-224(on)-225(the)-225(general)-225(credit)-224(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-261(histories.)-283(Our)-261(question)-260(is,)-264(what)-261(is)-261(their)-261(value)-261(as)-261(sources)-260(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(history?)-471(This)-323(must)-324(be)-324(kept)-323(perfectly)-324(distinct)-323(from)-324(the)-323(question)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-250(to)-250(the)-250(nature)-250(and)-250(extent)-250(of)-250(the)-250(inspiration)-250(of)-250(the)-250(writers.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(With)-520(respect)-521(to)-520(a)-520(large)-521(number)-520(of)-520(alleged)-520(discrepancies,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(their)-301(whole)-301(force)-301(as)-300(objections)-301(to)-301(the)-301(historical)-301(character)-301(of)-300(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Gospels)-433(is)-432(disposed)-433(of)-432(by)-433(the)-432(simple)-432(consideration)-433(that)-432(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authors)-314(assert)-314(them)-313(to)-314(be)-314(memoirs,)-330(and)-314(not)-313(histories.)-442(No)-313(small)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(number)-293(of)-294(others)-293(can)-293(be)-294(shown)-293(to)-293(exist)-294(only)-293(in)-293(the)-293(imagination)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-313(those)-313(who)-313(allege)-313(them.)-439(A)-313(few)-313(real)-313(difficulties)-313(will)-313(probably)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remain;)-403(but)-352(these)-353(no)-352(more)-352(invalidate)-352(their)-352(historical)-352(character,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(than)-354(similar)-354(ones)-355(which)-354(are)-354(to)-354(be)-355(found)-354(in)-354(every)-354(writer)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 254.579 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(from)]TJ -259.423 -13.549 Td [(Herodotus)-250(to)-250(Mr.)-250(Froude.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 111.808 0 Td [(\035)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2040 0 obj <<
/Length 4582      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(442)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(It)-447(must)-446(not)-447(be)-446(forgotten)-447(that)-446(a)-447(careful)-446(examination)-447(of)-446(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Gospels)-309(discloses)-309(a)-310(mass)-309(of)-309(additional)-309(evidence)-309(on)-309(this)-309(subject)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-203(is)-202(inconsistent)-203(with)-203(the)-202(idea)-203(that)-203(their)-202(narratives)-203(are)-203(a)-202(mere)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(congeries)-403(of)-404(legendary)-403(inventions.)-709(It)-404(would)-403(be)-403(impossible)-403(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(investigate)-297(it)-296(in)-297(a)-296(work)-297(like)-297(the)-296(present,)-308(or)-297(even)-297(to)-296(give)-297(an)-296(idea)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-235(its)-235(value,)-238(as)-236(shown)-235(in)-235(the)-235(intimate)-235(acquaintance)-235(of)-235(the)-235(authors)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-218(the)-218(events,)-224(ideas,)-224(customs,)-224(and)-218(general)-218(circumstances)-218(of)-217(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(times.)-236(To)-207(compose)-208(such)-207(stories)-415(out)-208(of)-207(any)-208(materials)-207(which)-207(could)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([506])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(have)-372(been)-372(at)-372(his)-371(hand)-372(at)-372(the)-372(beginning)-372(of)-372(the)-372(second)-371(century,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(supposing)-223(him)-223(to)-222(have)-223(been)-223(devoid)-222(of)-223(all)-223(personal)-223(knowledge)-222(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-320(subject)1(,)-337(would)-320(defy)-319(any)-320(modern)-319(writer)-320(of)-319(fiction,)-337(even)-319(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(possessed)-372(of)-372(the)-372(highest)-373(genius;)-433(not)-372(to)-372(speak)-372(of)-372(the)-372(incompe-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tence)-220(of)-220(the)-220(ancient)-219(world)-220(in)-220(this)-220(class)-220(of)-220(literature,)-226(rendering)-219(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(attempts)-359(of)-358(such)-359(writers)-358(as)-359(existed)-359(among)-358(the)-359(early)-358(Christians)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(simply)-250(hopeless.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(There)-213(are)-213(two)-213(additional)-214(points)-213(to)-213(which)-213(I)-213(must)-213(draw)-213(attention)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(here,)-227(in)-222(the)-222(internal)-222(structure)-221(of)-222(the)-222(Gospels,)-227(as)-222(establishing)-221(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-250(character.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-188(strongest)-187(evidence)-188(which)-188(the)-188(Gospels)-187(afford)-188(of)-188(their)-187(being)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(historical)-306(narratives)-307(is)-306(the)-306(unquestionable)-307(fact)-306(that)-306(they)-306(contain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-362(delineation)-362(of)-362(the)-361(greatest)-362(of)-362(all)-362(characters,)-390(Jesus)-362(Christ)-361(our)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Lord.)-248(This)-242(character)-243(is)-242(there)-243(depicted,)-244(even)-242(in)-243(the)-242(opinion)-243(of)-242(un-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believers)-298(of)-298(the)-299(greatest)-298(eminence,)-310(with)-298(a)-298(matchless)-298(perfection.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Why)-359(will)-359(they)-359(not)-359(grapple)-359(with)-359(the)-359(question)-358(of)-359(its)-359(origin,)-386(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(show)-334(how)-334(it)-334(is)-334(possible)-334(that)-334(such)-334(a)-334(character)-334(should)-334(ever)-333(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(found)-389(a)-389(place)-389(in)-389(the)-388(Gospels,)-424(on)-389(any)-389(theory)-389(which)-389(they)-388(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(propounded)-405(to)-404(account)-405(for)-404(their)-405(origin?)-714(It)-404(does)-405(not)-404(originate)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(in)-341(any)-342(formal)-341(sketch)-342(or)-341(delineation.)-524(This)-342(the)-341(Evangelists)-341(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(nowhere)-404(given.)-713(It)-405(is)-404(the)-404(combined)-405(result)-404(of)-404(all)-405(the)-404(facts)-404(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-409(discourses)-409(which)-409(they)-409(contain.)-727(The)-409(whole)-409(subject)-408(matter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-417(the)-417(Gospels)-417(is)-418(in)-417(fact)-417(the)-417(material)-417(out)-417(of)-417(which)-417(this)-417(great)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-258(is)-257(delineated.)-273(How)-258(came)-257(it)-258(there)-258(if)-257(the)-258(Gospels)-257(consist)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(only)-284(of)-284(a)-284(mass)-284(of)-284(mythic)-284(and)-284(legendary)-284(stories)-284(which)-283(gradually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accumulated)-389(in)-390(the)-389(Church?)-668(How)-389(is)-389(it)-390(possible)-389(that)-389(a)-389(bundle)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2044 0 obj <<
/Length 4921      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(443)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(of)-433(legends)-433(thus)-434(thrown)-433(together)-433(can)-433(have)-433(created)-433(the)-433(perfect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character)-410(of)-410(Jesus)-410(Christ,)-451(forming,)-450(as)-410(it)-410(does,)-450(an)-410(harmonious)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whole?)-257(How)-253(has)-252(it)-252(come)-253(to)-252(pass)-253(that)-252(the)-252(authors)-253(of)-252(our)-252(Gospels,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-351(they)-351(each)-350(composed)-351(their)-351(narratives)-350(from)-351(a)-351(mass)-351(of)-350(fictions)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-206(grew)-206(up)-412(during)-206(a)-206(period)-206(of)-206(seventy)-207(years,)-214(have)-206(each)-206(given)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([507])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(us)-334(a)-334(delineation)-334(of)-334(the)-334(same)-334(Jesus?)-502(These)-334(are)-334(problems)-333(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-256(an)-256(intimate)-256(bearing)-257(on)-256(the)-256(question)-256(whether)-256(they)-256(belong)-256(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-262(order)-263(of)-262(historical)-263(or)-262(fictitious)-262(compositions,)-266(but)-262(with)-262(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unbelief)-281(has)-281(hitherto)-280(most)-281(prudently)-281(declined)-281(to)-280(grapple.)-343(I)-280(shall)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(not)-320(pursue)-320(them)-319(further)-320(here,)-337(as)-320(I)-320(have)-319(discussed)-320(them)-320(fully)-319(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-346(work)-346(already)-345(referred)-346(to,)-370(and)-345(shown)-346(that)-346(the)-346(portraiture)-345(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus)-408(Christ)-407(as)-408(delineated)-408(in)-408(our)-407(Gospels)-408(is)-408(inconsistent)-407(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-390(theory)-389(of)-390(their)-389(origin)-390(which)-389(has)-390(been)-389(propounded)-390(by)-389(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opponents.)-250(To)-250(this)-250(work)-250(I)-250(must)-250(refer)-250(the)-250(reader.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(But)-299(there)-298(is)-299(a)-299(second)-299(character)-298(which)-299(is)-299(harmoniously)-298(delin-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(eated)-366(in)-366(the)-366(Gospels,)-396(to)-366(which)-366(I)-366(have)-366(not)-366(alluded)-366(in)-366(the)-366(work)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(above)-288(referred)-289(to,)-298(that)-288(of)-289(Simon)-288(Peter.)-366(This)-288(character,)-298(though)-288(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(subordinate)-266(one,)-271(is)-266(also)-266(a)-267(perfect)-266(delineation)-266(of)-267(its)-266(kind,)-270(instinct)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-233(historic)-233(life.)-245(It)-233(differs)-233(from)-233(that)-234(of)-233(Jesus)-233(Christ)-233(in)-233(being)-233(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-346(a)-345(purely)-346(human)-346(character,)-369(possessed)-346(of)-346(many)-345(of)-346(the)-345(virtues)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-426(not)-426(a)-425(few)-426(of)-426(the)-426(frailties)-426(of)-425(ordinary)-426(human)-426(nature.)-777(No)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(student)-208(of)-207(the)-208(Gospels)-207(can)-208(rise)-208(from)-207(their)-208(perusal)-207(without)-208(a)-207(lively)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(conception)-295(of)-294(it.)-384(If)-294(they)-295(are)-295(historical,)-305(the)-295(account)-294(of)-295(the)-294(origin)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-375(this)-374(second)-375(character)-374(of)-375(which)-375(they)-374(present)-375(us)-374(so)-375(perfect)-374(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(delineation)-381(is)-382(a)-381(very)-381(simple)-382(one.)-644(It)-381(is)-381(that)-382(of)-381(a)-381(genuine)-381(man,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whose)-311(actions)-312(they)-311(have)-311(correctly)-312(recorded.)-434(But)-311(if)-311(the)-311(Gospels)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-234(such)-234(as)-234(my)-234(opponents)-234(affirm)-234(them)-234(to)-234(be,)-237(I)-234(must)-234(earnestly)-234(put)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-280(them)-280(the)-281(question,)-287(How)-280(came)-281(this)-280(character)-280(there)-280(also?)-340(Each)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gospel)-268(presents)-267(us)-268(with)-268(a)-267(delineation)-268(of)-268(Peter.)-303(In)-267(each)-268(the)-267(same)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(living)-307(man)-307(is)-306(before)-307(us,)-321(in)-307(all)-307(his)-307(virtues)-306(and)-307(in)-307(all)-307(his)-306(failings.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(How,)-451(I)-410(ask,)-450(is)-411(it)-410(possible)-411(that)-410(the)-411(author)-410(of)-411(each)-410(Gospel)-410(has)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(succeeded)-316(in)-316(creating)-316(a)-316(character)-316(of)-316(Simon)-316(Peter)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 217.392 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(each)-316(true)-316(to)]TJ -228.301 -13.55 Td [(nature)-198(and)-199(each)-198(manifestly)-199(a)-198(delineation)-198(of)-199(the)-198(same)-198(person)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 255.779 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.909 0 Td [(out)]TJ -266.688 -13.549 Td [(of)-220(a)-220(number)-220(of)-441(fictions,)-226(myths,)-226(and)-220(legends?)-240(Can)-220(any)-220(one)-220(affirm)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([508])]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2049 0 obj <<
/Length 4783      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(444)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(that)-287(the)-288(Peter)-287(of)-288(the)-287(Gospels)-288(presents)-287(us)-288(with)-287(one)-288(single)-287(trait)-287(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-250(character)-250(formed)-250(by)-250(legend?)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(But)-229(the)-229(existence)-229(of)-230(this)-229(delineation)-229(in)-229(each)-229(of)-229(the)-229(Gospels)-229(in-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(volves)-195(those)-195(with)-195(whom)-195(I)-195(am)-195(reasoning)-195(in)-195(a)-195(yet)-195(further)-194(difficulty.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(The)-273(New)-272(Testament)-273(contains)-272(a)-273(fifth)-273(delineation)-272(of)-273(the)-272(character)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-364(Simon)-364(Peter,)-392(professedly)-364(drawn)-363(by)-364(himself.)-591(I)-364(allude)-364(to)-363(his)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(first)-273(Epistle.)-319(This)-273(unbelievers)-273(say)-273(is)-273(not)-273(his)-273(genuine)-273(production,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(though)-238(the)-239(external)-238(evidence)-238(for)-239(it)-238(is)-238(strong.)-246(In)-239(either)-238(case)-238(it)-238(will)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(be)-295(equally)-296(available)-295(for)-295(my)-296(argument.)-386(If)-295(it)-295(was)-296(written)-295(by)-295(him,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-334(is)-334(separated)-334(by)-334(an)-333(interval)-334(of)-334(from)-334(thirty)-334(to)-334(forty)-334(years)-333(from)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-242(Peter)-241(of)-242(the)-241(Gospels.)-247(After)-242(such)-241(a)-242(period)-241(of)-242(time)-241(we)-242(ought)-241(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(find)-251(the)-251(same)-251(substantial)-251(lineaments)-251(of)-250(character,)-252(but)-250(chastened,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(improved,)-291(and)-282(softened)-283(by)-282(the)-283(influence)-282(of)-283(Christianity.)-347(This)-282(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(precisely)-224(what)-223(we)-224(do)-223(find.)-241(The)-224(Peter)-223(of)-224(the)-223(Epistle)-224(is)-223(the)-224(Peter)-223(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-298(Gospels,)-310(in)-298(all)-299(the)-298(substantial)-298(elements)-298(of)-298(his)-298(character,)-310(but)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(raised)-310(to)-311(a)-310(greater)-311(moral)-310(elevation.)-431(The)-311(Peter)-310(of)-311(the)-310(Gospels)-310(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-329(Peter)-329(of)-328(youthful)-329(aspirations,)-348(who)-329(has)-329(had)-329(little)-328(experience)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-252(the)-253(trials)-252(and)-253(struggles)-252(of)-252(human)-253(life.)-257(The)-252(Peter)-253(of)-252(the)-252(Epistle)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(while)-295(continually)-295(reminding)-295(us)-294(of)-295(the)-295(Peter)-295(of)-295(the)-295(Gospels,)-306(is)-294(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(deeply)-293(softened)-292(man,)-303(with)-293(many)-292(of)-293(his)-292(infirmities)-293(changed)-292(into)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-250(graces)-250(to)-250(which)-250(they)-250(are)-250(allied.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Now)-306(if)-307(the)-306(four)-306(Peters)-307(of)-306(the)-306(Gospels)-306(are)-307(fictions,)-320(how)-306(have)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(their)-266(inventors)-266(succeeded)-266(in)-266(delineating)-266(him)-266(true)-266(to)-266(his)-265(youthful)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(character,)-342(and)-323(true)-324(to)-323(human)-323(nature?)-471(If,)-341(on)-324(the)-323(other)-324(hand,)-341(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Peters)-292(of)-293(the)-292(Gospels)-292(and)-292(of)-293(the)-292(Epistle)-292(are)-293(all)-292(five)-292(creations)-292(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-235(imagination,)-238(the)-234(difficulty)-235(is)-235(increased)-235(to)-235(impossibility.)-244(How)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(was)-288(it)-287(possible)-288(for)-288(the)-287(forger)-288(of)-287(the)-288(Epistle)-288(to)-287(have)-288(delineated)-287(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Peter)-279(who)-278(should)-279(be)-278(true)-279(to)-279(the)-278(legendary)-279(character)-278(of)-279(the)-278(Peter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-198(the)-199(Gospels,)-209(and)-396(at)-199(the)-198(same)-198(time)-199(such)-198(an)-199(improved)-198(version)-198(of)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([509])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(it)-283(as)-284(would)-283(naturally)-283(result)-284(from)-283(the)-283(trials)-284(of)-283(between)-283(thirty)-283(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forty)-260(years)-260(spent)-259(in)-260(the)-260(service)-260(and)-260(in)-259(attempts)-260(to)-260(put)-260(in)-259(practice)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-362(teaching)-361(of)-362(his)-362(Master?)-585(It)-362(follows,)-389(therefore,)-390(that)-362(the)-361(five)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(portraitures)-288(of)-287(Simon)-288(Peter)-288(presented)-288(us)-287(in)-288(the)-288(New)-287(Testament,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-420(so)-421(many)-420(distinctive)-421(proofs)-420(that)-420(the)-421(Gospels)-420(are)-420(historical)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2053 0 obj <<
/Length 4656      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(445)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(realities,)-288(and)-280(not)-281(the)-280(mere)-281(offspring)-280(of)-280(the)-281(imaginations)-280(of)-280(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(respective)-250(authors.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-353(am)-354(now)-354(in)-353(a)-354(position)-353(to)-354(restore)-353(the)-354(Gospels)-353(to)-354(their)-353(place)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in)-418(history,)-460(and)-418(to)-419(estimate)-418(the)-418(value)-418(of)-418(their)-418(testimony.)-754(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Synoptics)-371(are)-370(so)-371(many)-371(versions)-371(of)-370(the)-371(traditions,)-401(preserved)-370(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-371(different)-371(Churches)-370(during)-371(the)-371(first)-371(century,)-401(of)-371(that)-370(portion)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-312(the)-312(life)-312(and)-311(teaching)-312(of)-312(Jesus)-312(which)-312(formed)-312(the)-311(groundwork)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-350(Christianity.)-551(Such)-351(an)-350(account,)-376(more)-350(or)-350(less)-351(full,)-375(must)-350(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-419(handed)-420(down)-419(from)-420(the)-419(first)-420(origin)-419(of)-420(the)-419(Church.)-758(This)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(account)-256(received)-255(enlargements)-256(from)-255(different)-255(narrators)-256(who)-255(had)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(been)-210(witnesses)-211(of)-210(different)-211(events)-210(of)-211(our)-210(Lord's)-211(life)-210(and)-210(ministry;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(but)-406(so)-406(completely)-406(was)-406(it)-406(interwoven)-406(with)-406(the)-406(daily)-406(course)-406(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-268(life,)-273(that)-268(it)-268(is)-268(impossible)-268(that)-268(matters)-268(inconsistent)-268(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(its)-311(fundamental)-310(conception)-311(can)-311(have)-310(become)-311(incorporated)-310(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it.)-295(Moreover,)-269(the)-265(whole)-265(period)-265(lay)-265(within)-265(the)-265(limits)-265(of)-264(time)-265(dur-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ing)-325(which)-326(traditions)-325(are)-326(strictly)-325(historical.)-477(No)-325(community)-325(ever)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existed)-334(which)-335(had)-334(equal)-334(facilities)-335(for)-334(handing)-334(down)-334(accurately)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-328(events)-328(of)-327(its)-328(Founder's)-328(life,)-347(or)-328(had)-328(stronger)-328(inducements)-327(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(do)-391(so.)-674(The)-391(Church)-392(was)-391(struggling)-391(for)-392(existence,)-426(and)-391(seeking)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-309(assimilate)-309(to)-308(itself)-309(the)-309(elements)-308(by)-309(which)-309(it)-309(was)-308(surrounded.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(This)-389(alone)-390(must)-389(have)-389(kept)-389(steadily)-389(in)-390(its)-389(memory)-389(the)-389(leading)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(events)-352(of)-352(the)-352(life)-352(of)-352(Jesus.)-556(These,)-378(as)-352(we)-352(have)-352(seen,)-377(must)-352(also)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-334(formed)-334(the)-334(subjects)-334(in)-334(which)-334(its)-334(converts)-334(were)-334(habitually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(instructed.)-622(Jesus)-373(Christ,)-405(to)-374(use)-374(the)-374(expressive)-374(language)-374(of)-373(St.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Paul,)-221(must)-213(have)-214(been)-213(to)-427(the)-213(primitive)-214(Christian)-213(community)-213(from)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([510])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(hour)-250(of)-250(its)-250(birth)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 86.968 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(all)-250(and)-250(in)-250(all.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 56.967 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -136.822 -16.004 Td [(From)-337(the)-336(various)-337(direct)-336(and)-337(indirect)-337(references)-336(in)-337(St.)-509(Paul's)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(Epistles)-329(we)-330(can)-329(form)-330(a)-329(general)-330(idea)-329(of)-330(the)-329(life)-330(and)-329(teaching)-329(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Jesus,)-222(as)-216(it)-215(must)-215(have)-215(been)-216(accepted)-215(by)-215(the)-216(Churches)-215(to)-215(which)-215(he)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(wrote.)-247(All)-242(the)-242(outlines)-241(furnished)-242(by)-242(these)-241(Epistles)-242(may)-242(be)-241(traced)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-301(our)-301(present)-302(Gospels.)-403(If)-301(we)-302(descend)-301(to)-301(a)-301(still)-301(later)-301(period,)-314(we)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(shall)-228(find)-228(that)-229(accounts,)-232(substantially)-228(the)-229(same,)-232(were)-228(spread)-228(over)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-302(entire)-302(Church.)-405(Even)-302(if)-302(it)-301(is)-302(true)-302(that)-302(the)-302(early)-301(Ecclesiastical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(writers)-366(do)-366(not)-366(cite)-366(the)-366(Gospels,)-395(it)-366(is)-366(evident)-366(that)-366(they)-366(were)-366(in)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2057 0 obj <<
/Length 4621      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(446)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(possession)-303(of)-303(accounts,)-317(either)-303(written)-303(or)-303(unwritten,)-316(which)-303(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(for)-386(all)-386(practical)-386(purposes)-386(the)-386(same.)-658(It)-386(follows,)-420(therefore,)-419(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-312(the)-311(Synoptics)-312(contain)-311(three)-312(versions)-311(of)-312(the)-311(ministry)-312(of)-311(Jesus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-331(were)-332(handed)-331(down)-331(by)-332(the)-331(Churches)-331(of)-332(the)-331(first)-331(century,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(their)-258(claim)-257(to)-258(the)-258(character)-257(of)-258(historical)-258(documents)-257(substantially)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accurate)-250(in)-250(all)-250(their)-250(main)-250(features)-250(is)-250(unquestionable.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Nothing)-252(is)-252(more)-252(lamentable)-252(than)-252(the)-252(manner)-252(in)-252(which)-252(a)-252(num-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ber)-390(of)-389(minute)-390(verbal)-389(questions)-389(have)-390(been)-389(introduced)-390(into)-389(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-330(controversy.)-488(Both)-330(parties)-329(have)-330(freely)-330(indulged)-329(in)-330(it.)-488(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(life)-345(of)-345(Christianity)-345(has)-345(been)-345(made)-345(to)-345(depend)-345(on)-345(whether)-345(some)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(passage)-328(in)-329(a)-328(particular)-329(Father)-328(bears)-328(a)-329(precise)-328(verbal)-328(agreement)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-318(another)-317(passage)-318(to)-318(be)-317(found)-318(in)-317(our)-318(present)-318(Gospels.)-452(Such)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(matters)-269(may)-268(be)-269(interesting)-269(as)-268(mere)-269(literary)-269(questions,)-273(but)-268(surely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-243(are)-244(not)-243(worthy)-244(to)-243(be)-244(dignified)-243(by)-244(the)-243(title)-244(of)-243(historical)-243(ones.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(To)-285(represent)-285(the)-285(life)-285(of)-285(Christianity)-285(as)-285(depending)-285(on)-285(them,)-293(is)-285(to)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(leave)-299(the)-298(broad)-299(basis)-299(of)-299(historical)-298(investigation,)-311(and)-299(descend)-298(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-365(mere)-365(technicalities)-365(of)-365(legal)-365(evidence,)-394(by)-365(which)-364(the)-365(parties)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-248(are)-248(most)-249(capable)-248(of)-248(throwing)-248(light)-249(on)-248(the)-248(case)-248(are)-248(excluded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-208(giving)-208(evidence)-208(at)-208(all,)-217(while)-208(many)-208(minor)-208(points)-208(are)-208(debated)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-391(the)-391(utmost)-392(ardour.)-673(I)-391(desire)-391(to)-783(express)-391(no)-391(opinion)-391(as)-391(to)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([511])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.55 Td [(whether)-462(this)-462(is)-462(right)-462(or)-462(wrong)-462(in)-462(judicial)-462(processes;)-568(but)-462(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(principles)-301(of)-301(history)-301(are)-302(widely)-301(different.)-403(All)-301(evidence)-301(must)-301(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accepted)-336(for)-337(what)-336(it)-336(is)-337(worth,)-358(and)-336(for)-336(no)-337(more.)-509(The)-336(issues)-336(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-419(ones,)-461(and)-418(are)-419(not)-419(dependent)-419(on)-418(any)-419(mere)-419(set)-419(of)-418(barren)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(technicalities.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(Christianity)-236(is)-236(not)-237(only)-236(one)-236(of)-236(the)-237(greatest)-236(facts)-236(in)-236(history,)-239(but)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-341(greatest;)-386(and)-341(its)-340(truth)-341(or)-341(falsehood)-340(can)-341(never)-341(be)-340(dependent)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(on)-228(whether)-227(a)-228(passage)-227(more)-228(or)-227(less)-228(in)-227(Justin)-228(Martyr)-227(is)-228(an)-227(accurate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(citation)-286(of)-285(another)-286(in)-285(St.)-357(Matthew's)-286(Gospel.)-356(The)-286(only)-285(questions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-281(real)-282(importance)-281(are:)-313(Do)-281(the)-281(numerous)-282(references)-281(of)-281(the)-281(early)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Christian)-239(writers)-240(to)-239(the)-239(life)-240(and)-239(teaching)-239(of)-240(Jesus)-239(Christ)-239(substan-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tially)-319(agree)-319(with)-318(the)-319(accounts)-319(of)-319(that)-318(life)-319(and)-319(teaching)-319(given)-318(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(our)-292(Gospels?)-377(Do)-292(they)-293(contain)-292(any)-292(account)-293(which)-292(gives)-292(a)-292(really)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(different)-300(version)-300(of)-300(it?)-401(If)-300(such)-300(agreement)-300(exists,)-312(although)-300(there)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2061 0 obj <<
/Length 4713      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(447)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(may)-340(be)-340(minor)-340(differences,)-363(the)-340(matter)-340(is)-340(settled)-340(as)-340(an)-340(historical)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(question.)-556(The)-351(Gospels,)-378(in)-352(all)-352(their)-351(great)-352(outlines,)-378(are)-351(virtually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accurate)-365(accounts)-365(of)-365(the)-365(traditions)-365(of)-365(the)-365(primitive)-365(Church)-365(re-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(specting)-256(the)-255(actions)-255(and)-256(the)-255(teaching)-256(of)-255(its)-256(Founder,)-257(and)-255(as)-255(such)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(they)-250(satisfy)-250(all)-250(the)-250(conditions)-250(of)-250(history.)]TJ 11.956 -15.185 Td [(It)-214(is)-215(impossible)-214(that)-215(I)-214(should)-215(in)-214(this)-215(place)-214(enter)-215(on)-214(the)-214(question)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(of)-251(the)-250(authorship)-251(or)-250(the)-251(date)-250(of)-251(t)1(he)-251(Fourth)-250(Gospel.)-252(The)-250(literature)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-291(this)-291(subject)-291(would)-291(fill)-291(a)-291(library)-291(of)-291(no)-291(mean)-291(size.)-373(I)-291(shall)-291(only)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(refer)-272(to)-272(Mr.)-317(Sanday's)-272(able)-273(vindication)-272(of)-272(its)-272(historical)-272(character.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(One)-272(thing)-273(respecting)-272(it)-272(is)-273(clear.)-317(It)-272(is)-272(either)-273(the)-272(veritable)-272(work)-272(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-197(eye-witness)-196(of)-196(the)-197(facts)-196(which)-197(it)-196(records,)-208(or)-196(it)-197(is)-196(a)-196(consummate)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fiction,)-201(such)-188(as)-189(can)-188(be)-189(found)-188(nowhere)-189(else,)-201(either)-188(in)-188(the)-189(ancient)-188(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-212(modern)-212(world.)-237(Its)-212(author)-212(must)-212(have)-212(united)-212(a)-212(fixed)-212(determina-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tion)-244(to)-243(perpetrate)-244(a)-243(forgery)-244(on)-244(a)-243(most)-244(sacred)-243(subject,)-245(with)-244(one)-243(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-225(loftiest)-224(ideals)-225(of)-225(morality,)-229(and)-225(an)-225(inimitable)-224(power)-450(of)-224(simple)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([512])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(description,)-240(and)-238(of)-238(inventing)-238(fictitious)-238(scenes)-238(in)-238(a)-238(manner)-238(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-320(in)-320(the)-320(highest)-320(degree)-319(true)-320(to)-320(human)-320(nature.)-460(If)-320(this)-320(work)-319(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(really)-294(written)-293(by)-294(a)-294(person)-294(who)-293(was)-294(not)-294(a)-293(Jew,)-305(one)-294(hundred)-293(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fifty)-192(years)-192(after)-192(the)-192(events)-192(which)-192(are)-192(described)-192(in)-192(it,)-203(and)-192(a)-192(century)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(after)-194(the)-194(destruction)-194(of)-195(Jerusalem,)-205(the)-194(accuracy)-194(of)-194(its)-194(descriptions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-253(one)-253(of)-252(the)-253(most)-253(singular)-253(phenomena)-253(in)-252(literary)-253(history.)-258(Wher-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ever)-235(it)-235(runs)-235(parallel)-234(with)-235(the)-235(Synoptic)-235(Gospels,)-238(it)-235(throws)-235(light)-234(on)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(their)-237(obscurities)-236(without)-237(the)-236(smallest)-237(apparent)-236(intention)-237(of)-236(doing)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so.)-286(In)-262(some)-262(places)-262(it)-262(helps)-262(to)-262(correct)-262(erroneous)-262(impressions)-262(into)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(which)-211(the)-210(reader)-211(of)-211(the)-211(Synoptic)-210(narratives)-211(might)-211(otherwise)-210(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fallen.)-535(Even)-345(in)-345(that)-345(most)-345(striking)-345(disagreement)-345(between)-344(them,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(respecting)-324(the)-324(Paschal)-324(character)-324(of)-324(the)-324(Last)-324(Supper,)-342(we)-324(find)-324(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-343(Synoptics)-342(hints)-343(which)-342(corroborate)-343(St.)-528(John's)-342(account)-343(of)-342(it.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(One)-372(simple)-372(alternative,)-402(and)-372(one)-371(only,)-403(lies)-371(before)-372(us;)-433(either)-371(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(accept)-399(this)-398(Gospel)-399(as)-398(a)-399(history)-398(of)-399(the)-399(highest)-398(authority,)-436(or)-398(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reject)-250(it)-250(as)-250(an)-250(audacious)-250(forgery.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(It)-224(now)-224(remains)-224(for)-224(me)-225(very)-224(briefly)-224(to)-224(consider)-224(the)-224(value)-224(of)-224(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(testimony)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Gospels)-250(to)-250(the)-250(truth)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Resurrection.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(If)-413(one)-413(thing)-412(more)-413(than)-413(another)-413(is)-413(evident)-413(respecting)-412(them,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2066 0 obj <<
/Length 4619      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(448)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(it)-339(is)-339(that)-339(they)-339(were)-339(not)-339(written)-339(for)-339(the)-339(purposes)-339(of)-338(controversy)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-470(unbelievers,)-525(but)-470(for)-470(the)-470(instruction)-470(of)-470(Christians.)-910(It)-470(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(certain)-273(that)-274(the)-273(last)-273(thing)-274(which)-273(occurred)-273(to)-274(their)-273(authors)-273(was)-273(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(guard)-309(their)-309(narratives)-309(against)-308(possible)-309(objections.)-427(This)-309(is)-308(made)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(clear)-399(by)-399(every)-399(page.)-696(At)-399(the)-399(time)-399(when)-399(they)-399(were)-398(composed,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-345(Resurrection)-346(had)-345(long)-345(been)-345(accepted)-345(by)-346(the)-345(entire)-345(body)-345(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(believers,)-370(as)-346(the)-346(foundation)-345(of)-346(their)-346(faith.)-538(It)-346(was)-346(therefore)-345(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(necessary)-339(for)-339(the)-339(Gospels)-339(to)-339(prove)-339(it,)-361(as)-339(it)-339(would)-339(have)-339(been)-339(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-271(had)-272(been)-271(composed)-272(with)-271(a)-271(direct)-272(view)-271(to)-271(unbelievers.)-314(This)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-352(a)-352(point)-352(which)-352(it)-352(is)-352(important)-352(to)-352(bear)-352(in)-352(mind)-352(in)-352(considering)]TJ 4.053 -13.549 Td [(the)-372(nature)-371(of)-372(their)-371(testimony.)-615(Two)-371(of)-372(the)-371(narratives)-372(of)-371(it)-372(are)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -76.808 0 Td [([513])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(entirely)-330(incidental;)-370(and)-330(it)-330(is)-330(quite)-330(clear)-330(that)-330(their)-330(authors)-329(never)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(intended)-346(to)-345(give)-346(an)-345(exhaustive)-346(account)-345(of)-346(the)-345(facts.)-537(The)-345(other)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(two,)-459(though)-417(giving)-417(us)-417(more)-417(details,)-459(participate)-417(largely)-417(in)-417(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(same)-236(character.)-246(It)-236(is)-236(impossible)-236(to)-236(read)-236(either)-236(narrative)-236(with)-236(care)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-227(not)-228(feel)-227(that)-228(it)-227(was)-228(never)-227(intended)-228(to)-227(be)-228(a)-227(systematic)-227(account)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-279(all)-278(the)-279(facts)-278(with)-279(which)-278(the)-279(author)-278(was)-279(acquainted)-278(respecting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(Resurrection.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-354(is)-354(objected)-354(against)-355(these)-354(narratives)-354(that)-354(they)-354(abound)-354(with)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(variations,)-352(amounting)-332(to)-331(contradictions.)-495(The)-332(variations)-332(are)-331(un-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(questionable,)-268(and)-264(it)-264(will)-264(readily)-264(be)-264(conceded)-264(that)-264(it)-264(is)-264(extremely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(difficult)-278(to)-279(piece)-278(together)-278(all)-279(the)-278(details)-278(of)-279(the)-278(existing)-278(accounts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(so)-400(as)-400(to)-400(weave)-400(them)-400(into)-400(an)-400(harmonious)-400(whole.)-700(In)-400(fact)-400(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-341(inevitable)-342(whenever)-341(the)-342(incidents)-341(described)-342(are)-341(of)-341(exciting)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(interest.)-434(Such)-312(must)-311(have)-311(been)-312(the)-311(character)-312(of)-311(those)-311(connected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-250(the)-250(Resurrection.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-315(chief)-315(difficulty)-315(is)-315(found)-315(in)-315(the)-315(details)-315(of)-315(the)-315(morning)-314(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(that)-279(important)-278(day.)-335(They)-279(are)-278(in)-279(an)-278(extremely)-279(fragmentary)-278(form,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-370(it)-370(is)-371(quite)-370(clear)-370(that)-370(we)-370(have)-371(not)-370(all)-370(the)-370(events)-370(before)-370(us.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(If)-315(we)-314(had,)-331(we)-315(should)-315(then)-314(be)-315(in)-314(a)-315(position)-315(to)-314(judge)-315(what)-315(is)-314(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(precise)-285(nature)-284(of)-285(the)-285(variations)-284(in)-285(the)-285(minor)-284(details.)-354(But)-285(even)-284(if)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contradictions)-257(could)-257(be)-256(proved)-257(to)-257(exist,)-258(how)-257(does)-257(their)-256(presence)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(invalidate)-341(the)-340(main)-341(facts,)-363(whose)-340(truth)-341(is)-340(established)-341(by)-340(wholly)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(independent)-216(testimony?)-238(The)-216(only)-215(way)-216(in)-216(which)-215(it)-216(can)-215(be)-216(made)-215(to)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2070 0 obj <<
/Length 4446      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(449)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(do)-289(so)-289(is)-289(by)-290(mixing)-289(up)-289(questions)-289(involving)-289(particular)-289(theories)-289(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inspiration)-330(with)-331(considerations)-330(purely)-331(historical.)-491(Such)-330(discrep-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ancies)-250(exist)-251(in)-250(connection)-251(with)-250(some)-251(of)-250(the)-251(most)-250(important)-250(facts)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-324(history)-323(in)-324(their)-323(minor)-324(details,)-341(without)-324(in)-323(the)-324(smallest)-323(degree)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(invalidating)-250(their)-250(historical)-250(credibility.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(This)-325(may)-325(be)-325(easily)-326(tested)-325(by)-325(examining)-325(a)-325(number)-325(of)-650(news-)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 279.068 0 Td [([514])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(paper)-383(accounts)-383(of)-383(any)-384(exciting)-383(event,)-416(which)-383(are)-383(derived)-383(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reporters)-281(entirely)-282(independent)-281(of)-282(each)-281(other.)-345(One)-281(witnesses)-281(one)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(thing,)-463(and)-421(one)-421(another;)-506(and)-420(it)-421(is)-421(often)-420(difficult)-421(to)-421(weave)-420(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whole)-372(into)-372(a)-372(perfectly)-371(consistent)-372(narrative.)-616(No)-372(one)-372(can)-371(doubt)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(that)-299(the)-298(morning)-299(of)-298(the)-299(Resurrection)-298(must)-298(have)-299(been)-298(one)-299(in)-298(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(last)-293(degree)-294(exciting)-293(to)-293(the)-293(disciples)-294(of)-293(our)-293(Lord.)-380(They)-293(were)-293(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mere)-288(reporters,)-297(but)-288(persons)-288(profoundly)-288(interested)-288(in)-288(the)-287(various)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrences.)-378(It)-292(would)-293(therefore)-292(have)-293(been)-292(inconsistent)-293(with)-292(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-257(truth)-256(of)-257(their)-257(position,)-258(if)-257(their)-256(narratives)-257(had)-256(presented)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(us)-250(with)-250(no)-250(variations.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(It)-241(is)-241(certain)-241(that)-242(several)-241(women)-241(accompanied)-241(our)-241(Lord)-241(on)-241(His)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(last)-313(journey)-313(to)-313(Jerusalem.)-439(What)-313(was)-313(more)-313(likely)-313(than)-313(that)-312(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(would)-353(visit)-353(the)-352(sepulchre)-353(at)-353(different)-353(times,)-378(and)-353(with)-352(different)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(purposes?)-562(Can)-354(any)-354(one)-354(doubt)-354(that)-354(their)-354(excitement)-354(must)-354(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-227(great?)-243(What)-227(conceivable)-228(difference)-227(can)-228(it)-227(make)-228(to)-227(the)-227(great)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(fact)-335(of)-335(the)-334(Resurrection,)-356(that)-335(one)-335(account)-335(mentions)-335(two)-334(Marys)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-277(going)-277(to)-277(the)-277(sepulchre;)-291(that)-276(the)-277(second)-277(adds)-277(to)-277(these)-277(Salome;)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-272(the)-271(third)-272(mentions)-272(several)-271(women;)-283(and)-271(that)-272(the)-272(fourth)-271(men-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tions)-298(Mary)-299(Magdalene)-298(alone?)-395(There)-299(might)-298(have)-298(been,)-311(as)-298(far)-298(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(anything)-362(which)-362(appears)-363(in)-362(the)-362(narratives)-362(is)-362(concerned,)-390(several)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(different)-239(visits;)-243(or)-239(the)-240(same)-239(person)-239(may)-240(have)-239(returned)-239(more)-239(than)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(once.)-758(Or)-419(what)-419(is)-419(the)-419(use)-419(of)-420(urging)-419(that)-419(there)-419(is)-419(an)-419(apparent)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(variation)-297(of)-297(about)-297(an)-297(hour)-296(between)-297(the)-297(different)-297(accounts,)-309(as)-296(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-395(precise)-394(time)-395(when)-394(these)-395(visits)-395(were)-394(made?)-684(Do)-394(variations)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-389(this)-389(description,)-423(which)-389(are)-389(found)-389(in)-389(accounts)-389(derived)-388(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eye-witnesses)-339(of)-339(Louis)-339(XVI's)-340(flight)-339(from)-339(Paris,)-361(in)-339(the)-339(smallest)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(degree)-279(invalidate)-279(the)-279(fact?)-337(Or)-279(what)-279(conceivable)-279(difference)-278(does)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-345(make)-346(that)-345(one)-345(narrative)-345(represents)-345(the)-346(women)-345(as)-345(seeing)-345(one)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2074 0 obj <<
/Length 4727      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(450)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(angel,)-379(and)-354(another)-354(two;)-405(and)-353(that)-354(one)-353(describes)-354(the)-353(appearance)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-309(taking)-309(place)-619(inside,)-324(and)-309(another)-309(outside)-309(the)-310(sepulchre?)-427(It)-309(is)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([515])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(quite)-265(possible)-266(that)-265(all)-265(these)-266(accounts)-265(may)-265(be)-266(true,)-269(and)-265(that)-265(these)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(occurrences)-259(took)-258(place)-259(on)-258(different)-259(occasions.)-276(If)-258(they)-259(were)-258(true,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(nothing)-206(was)-206(more)-206(unlikely)-206(than)-206(that)-206(the)-206(women)-206(could)-206(have)-206(given)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(an)-236(orderly)-236(narrative)-236(of)-236(them.)-245(Variations)-236(must)-236(occur)-236(in)-236(all)-235(reports)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-353(events)-353(when)-353(the)-353(witnesses)-353(see)-353(only)-353(a)-353(portion)-353(of)-353(them.)-559(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(great)-326(facts)-325(before)-326(us)-326(are)-325(plain)-326(and)-326(evident;)-363(and)-326(unless)-326(they)-325(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(falsehoods,)-373(there)-348(could)-348(be)-349(no)-348(possibility)-348(of)-348(mistake)-348(respecting)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(them.)-635(Different)-379(bodies)-378(of)-379(women)-378(found)-379(the)-378(sepulchre)-378(empty.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Some)-319(of)-319(them)-318(affirmed)-319(that)-319(they)-319(had)-318(seen)-319(Jesus)-319(risen)-319(from)-318(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dead,)-255(and)-255(that)-254(He)-254(sent)-255(a)-254(message)-254(by)-255(them)-254(to)-254(His)-255(disciples.)-262(Peter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-286(John)-286(visited)-286(the)-286(sepulchre,)-295(and)-286(found)-286(it)-286(empty.)-358(Later)-286(in)-286(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(same)-315(day,)-332(Peter)-315(affirmed)-315(that)-315(Jesus)-315(Christ)-315(appeared)-316(to)-315(him;)-347(on)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(which)-328(day)-329(also)-328(two)-329(other)-328(disciples)-329(affirmed)-328(that)-329(they)-328(had)-328(seen)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Him)-232(on)-232(a)-232(journey,)-236(at)-232(first)-232(without)-232(recognizing)-232(Him,)-235(but)-232(that)-232(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(did)-353(so)-354(afterwards.)-559(On)-354(the)-353(evening)-353(of)-354(the)-353(same)-353(day,)-379(these)-353(two)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(disciples,)-397(ten)-367(of)-368(the)-367(Apostles,)-397(with)-367(other)-368(persons)-367(in)-367(company,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(saw)-271(Him)-272(in)-271(a)-272(body,)-276(and)-272(were)-271(permitted)-272(to)-271(test)-271(the)-272(reality)-271(of)-271(His)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Resurrection)-392(by)-391(handling)-392(His)-392(Person,)-427(and)-391(by)-392(seeing)-392(Him)-391(eat.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(About)-280(such)-281(facts)-280(there)-281(could)-280(be)-281(no)-280(mistake.)-341(Most)-281(of)-280(them)-280(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(well)-226(known)-227(and)-226(accepted)-226(when)-226(St.)-243(Paul)-226(wrote)-226(his)-226(Epistles,)-231(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-214(means)-214(of)-213(testing)-214(their)-214(truth)-214(was)-213(ample.)-238(We)-214(know)-214(on)-214(the)-213(same)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(authority)-383(that)-384(the)-383(whole)-383(apostolic)-383(body)-384(asserted)-383(that)-383(they)-383(had)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(seen)-340(the)-339(Lord,)-362(and)-340(that)-339(as)-340(many)-339(as)-340(five)-339(hundred)-340(other)-339(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(made)-237(a)-237(similar)-238(assertion.)-245(These)-238(are)-237(the)-237(chief)-237(facts,)-240(and)-237(a)-237(number)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-251(minor)-251(variations)-251(such)-251(as)-251(those)-251(above)-251(referred)-251(to)-251(cannot)-250(affect)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-250(credibility.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(It)-313(has)-313(been)-313(objected)-313(that)-314(the)-313(author)-313(of)-313(St.)-439(Matthew's)-313(Gospel)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(was)-309(ignorant)-308(of)-309(some)-308(of)-309(these)-308(appearances.)-426(On)-308(what)-309(ground)-308(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-206(objection)-207(made?)-235(On)-207(the)-206(fact)-413(that)-207(he)-206(has)-207(not)-206(mentioned)-206(them?)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([516])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(Does)-351(a)-351(writer)-351(always)-351(report)-351(all)-351(he)-351(knows,)-376(especially)-351(when)-351(his)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(writing)-339(is)-339(intended)-339(for)-338(the)-339(use)-339(of)-339(those)-339(who)-339(firmly)-339(believe)-338(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fact)-329(already?)-487(Nothing)-329(can)-329(exceed)-329(the)-329(fragmentary)-329(character)-329(of)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
1942 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 984
/Length 9061      
>>
stream
1941 0 1937 58 1944 148 1946 267 1943 325 1948 391 1950 510 1947 569 1952 635 1954 754
1951 812 1957 878 1959 997 1956 1056 1961 1134 1963 1253 1960 1311 1965 1377 1967 1496 1964 1555
1969 1621 1971 1740 1972 1799 1968 1858 1974 1924 1976 2043 1973 2102 1978 2168 1980 2287 1977 2345
1983 2411 1985 2530 1986 2589 1982 2645 1987 2711 1990 2752 1992 2863 1988 2982 1994 3040 1991 3099
1996 3165 1998 3284 1995 3342 2000 3408 2002 3527 1999 3586 2004 3652 2006 3771 2003 3830 2008 3934
2010 4053 2007 4112 2013 4202 2015 4321 2012 4380 2017 4458 2019 4577 2020 4635 2016 4694 2022 4760
2024 4879 2021 4938 2026 5004 2028 5123 2025 5182 2030 5248 2032 5367 2029 5425 2034 5491 2036 5610
2033 5667 2039 5745 2041 5864 2038 5923 2043 5989 2045 6108 2046 6167 2042 6225 2048 6303 2050 6422
2047 6480 2052 6546 2054 6665 2051 6723 2056 6801 2058 6920 2055 6979 2060 7045 2062 7164 2059 7222
2065 7288 2067 7407 2064 7465 2069 7531 2071 7650 2068 7709 2073 7775 2075 7894 2076 7953 2072 8011
% 1941 0 obj
<<
/D [1938 0 R /XYZ 131.061 66.142 null]
>>
% 1937 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1944 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1945 0 R
/Resources 1943 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1928 0 R
>>
% 1946 0 obj
<<
/D [1944 0 R /XYZ 82.529 120.339 null]
>>
% 1943 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1948 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1949 0 R
/Resources 1947 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1928 0 R
>>
% 1950 0 obj
<<
/D [1948 0 R /XYZ 208.942 188.085 null]
>>
% 1947 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1952 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1953 0 R
/Resources 1951 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1955 0 R
>>
% 1954 0 obj
<<
/D [1952 0 R /XYZ 92.093 247.191 null]
>>
% 1951 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1957 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1958 0 R
/Resources 1956 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1955 0 R
>>
% 1959 0 obj
<<
/D [1957 0 R /XYZ 374.173 310.028 null]
>>
% 1956 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1961 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1962 0 R
/Resources 1960 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1955 0 R
>>
% 1963 0 obj
<<
/D [1961 0 R /XYZ 276.27 380.228 null]
>>
% 1960 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1965 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1966 0 R
/Resources 1964 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1955 0 R
>>
% 1967 0 obj
<<
/D [1965 0 R /XYZ 268.294 450.429 null]
>>
% 1964 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1969 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1970 0 R
/Resources 1968 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1955 0 R
>>
% 1971 0 obj
<<
/D [1969 0 R /XYZ 168.025 518.175 null]
>>
% 1972 0 obj
<<
/D [1969 0 R /XYZ 264.159 138.798 null]
>>
% 1968 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1974 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1975 0 R
/Resources 1973 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1955 0 R
>>
% 1976 0 obj
<<
/D [1974 0 R /XYZ 280.419 217.638 null]
>>
% 1973 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1978 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1979 0 R
/Resources 1977 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1981 0 R
>>
% 1980 0 obj
<<
/D [1978 0 R /XYZ 66.146 287.839 null]
>>
% 1977 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1983 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1984 0 R
/Resources 1982 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1981 0 R
>>
% 1985 0 obj
<<
/D [1983 0 R /XYZ 150.665 355.585 null]
>>
% 1986 0 obj
<<
/D [1983 0 R /XYZ 93.543 231.1 null]
>>
% 1982 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1987 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index23) >>
% 1990 0 obj
(Chapter XXII. The Historical Character Of The Gospels As Deduced From Their Internal Structure.)
% 1992 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1993 0 R
/Resources 1991 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1981 0 R
>>
% 1988 0 obj
<<
/D [1992 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 1994 0 obj
<<
/D [1992 0 R /XYZ 205.243 108.037 null]
>>
% 1991 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 1996 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 1997 0 R
/Resources 1995 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1981 0 R
>>
% 1998 0 obj
<<
/D [1996 0 R /XYZ 231.295 176.99 null]
>>
% 1995 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2000 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2001 0 R
/Resources 1999 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1981 0 R
>>
% 2002 0 obj
<<
/D [2000 0 R /XYZ 285.869 247.191 null]
>>
% 1999 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2004 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2005 0 R
/Resources 2003 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 1981 0 R
>>
% 2006 0 obj
<<
/D [2004 0 R /XYZ 141.877 298.933 null]
>>
% 2003 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F38 247 0 R /F37 246 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2008 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2009 0 R
/Resources 2007 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2011 0 R
>>
% 2010 0 obj
<<
/D [2008 0 R /XYZ 241.945 380.228 null]
>>
% 2007 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2013 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2014 0 R
/Resources 2012 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2011 0 R
>>
% 2015 0 obj
<<
/D [2013 0 R /XYZ 335.176 447.974 null]
>>
% 2012 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2017 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2018 0 R
/Resources 2016 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2011 0 R
>>
% 2019 0 obj
<<
/D [2017 0 R /XYZ 240.17 518.175 null]
>>
% 2020 0 obj
<<
/D [2017 0 R /XYZ 308.121 120.339 null]
>>
% 2016 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2022 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2023 0 R
/Resources 2021 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2011 0 R
>>
% 2024 0 obj
<<
/D [2022 0 R /XYZ 270.219 160.986 null]
>>
% 2021 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2026 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2027 0 R
/Resources 2025 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2011 0 R
>>
% 2028 0 obj
<<
/D [2026 0 R /XYZ 296.822 230.369 null]
>>
% 2025 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2030 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2031 0 R
/Resources 2029 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2011 0 R
>>
% 2032 0 obj
<<
/D [2030 0 R /XYZ 246.161 328.22 null]
>>
% 2029 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2034 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2035 0 R
/Resources 2033 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2037 0 R
>>
% 2036 0 obj
<<
/D [2034 0 R /XYZ 82.826 353.13 null]
>>
% 2033 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2039 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2040 0 R
/Resources 2038 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2037 0 R
>>
% 2041 0 obj
<<
/D [2039 0 R /XYZ 230.918 423.331 null]
>>
% 2038 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2043 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2044 0 R
/Resources 2042 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2037 0 R
>>
% 2045 0 obj
<<
/D [2043 0 R /XYZ 112.893 463.978 null]
>>
% 2046 0 obj
<<
/D [2043 0 R /XYZ 112.723 66.142 null]
>>
% 2042 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2048 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2049 0 R
/Resources 2047 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2037 0 R
>>
% 2050 0 obj
<<
/D [2048 0 R /XYZ 178.36 133.888 null]
>>
% 2047 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2052 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2053 0 R
/Resources 2051 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2037 0 R
>>
% 2054 0 obj
<<
/D [2052 0 R /XYZ 151.514 190.54 null]
>>
% 2051 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2056 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2057 0 R
/Resources 2055 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2037 0 R
>>
% 2058 0 obj
<<
/D [2056 0 R /XYZ 258.298 258.286 null]
>>
% 2055 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2060 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2061 0 R
/Resources 2059 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2063 0 R
>>
% 2062 0 obj
<<
/D [2060 0 R /XYZ 284.318 326.85 null]
>>
% 2059 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2065 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2066 0 R
/Resources 2064 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2063 0 R
>>
% 2067 0 obj
<<
/D [2065 0 R /XYZ 93.543 382.683 null]
>>
% 2064 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2069 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2070 0 R
/Resources 2068 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2063 0 R
>>
% 2071 0 obj
<<
/D [2069 0 R /XYZ 297.803 447.974 null]
>>
% 2068 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2073 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2074 0 R
/Resources 2072 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2063 0 R
>>
% 2075 0 obj
<<
/D [2073 0 R /XYZ 163.041 504.626 null]
>>
% 2076 0 obj
<<
/D [2073 0 R /XYZ 232.795 106.79 null]
>>
% 2072 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
endstream
endobj
2079 0 obj <<
/Length 5082      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(451)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(this)-276(portion)-276(of)-276(his)-276(narrative.)-328(If)-276(this)-276(Gospel)-276(was)-276(composed)-276(at)-276(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(late)-256(period)-255(assigned)-256(to)-255(it)-256(by)-255(those)-255(against)-256(whom)-255(I)-256(am)-255(reasoning,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(namely,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 39.193 0 Td [(A)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.754 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(D)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 5.755 0 Td [(.)-369(90,)-399(it)-368(is)-369(incredible)-369(that)-369(these)-369(were)-369(the)-369(only)-369(facts)]TJ -53.429 -13.549 Td [(known)-387(to)-386(the)-387(writer,)-421(at)-387(least)-386(thirty)-387(years)-387(after)-387(St.)-660(Paul)-386(wrote)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(his)-352(Epistles.)-554(The)-352(charge)-351(of)-351(ignorance)-352(might)-351(be)-352(sustained)-351(with)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(far)-294(greater)-295(plausibility)-294(if)-295(it)-294(were)-295(admitted)-294(that)-295(St.)-383(Matthew)-294(was)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-318(author)-319(of)-318(this)-319(Gospel,)-335(because)-319(it)-318(might)-319(have)-318(been)-318(expected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-378(he)-379(would)-378(mention)-378(the)-378(first)-378(occasion)-379(on)-378(which)-378(his)-378(Master)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-382(appeared)-383(to)-382(him)-383(rather)-382(than)-382(the)-383(third.)-647(But)-382(his)-382(authorship)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(is)-295(denied,)-306(and)-295(the)-295(publication)-294(of)-295(the)-295(Gospel)-295(assigned)-295(to)-295(the)-294(last)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ten)-268(years)-268(of)-267(the)-268(century,)-273(when)-267(it)-268(was)-268(impossible)-268(that)-268(the)-267(author,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whoever)-235(he)-236(may)-235(have)-235(been,)-239(could)-235(be)-235(ignorant)-236(that)-235(it)-235(was)-235(alleged)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-433(our)-433(Lord)-433(had)-433(appeared)-433(on)-433(other)-433(occasions)-433(besides)-432(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(mentioned)-250(by)-250(him.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(I)-264(will)-263(now)-264(consider)-263(the)-264(threefold)-263(account)-264(of)-263(the)-264(great)-263(appear-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(ance)-276(on)-276(the)-277(morning)-276(of)-276(Easter-day.)-329(One)-276(of)-276(them)-276(is)-276(contained)-276(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-291(supplement)-290(to)-290(St.)-372(Mark's)-290(Gospel;)-311(the)-291(other)-290(two)-291(are)-290(those)-290(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Luke)-263(and)-264(John.)-290(Let)-263(us)-263(first)-264(carefully)-263(observe)-263(the)-264(mode)-263(in)-263(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(they)-250(are)-250(narrated)-250(in)-250(the)-250(supplement.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Its)-380(author)-380(seems)-380(to)-380(have)-380(entertained)-380(a)-380(stronger)-380(view)-380(of)-380(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(indisposition)-350(of)-351(the)-350(disciples)-350(to)-351(believe)-350(the)-350(truth)-351(of)-350(the)-350(Resur-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rection)-290(than)-290(the)-290(other)-291(two)-290(narratives)-290(appear)-290(to)-290(warrant.)-370(He)-290(first)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(notices)-184(the)-184(appearance)-184(to)-185(Mary)-184(Magdalene)-184(on)-184(the)-184(morning)-184(of)-184(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(day,)-233(and)-229(says)-229(that)-229(the)-228(disciples)-229(refused)-229(to)-229(credit)-229(her)-229(report.)-242(Next,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(he)-348(tells)-348(us)-347(of)-348(the)-348(appearance)-348(to)-348(the)-347(two)-348(disciples)-348(as)-348(they)-347(went)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(into)-261(the)-260(country;)-266(and)-261(states)-260(that)-261(on)-260(their)-261(return)-260(they)-261(told)-260(it)-261(to)-260(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(remainder,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 49.79 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Neither)-258(believed)-516(they)-258(them.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 122.446 0 Td [(\035)-258(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.502 0 Td [(Afterward,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 47.553 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.658 0 Td [(he)-258(adds,)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 46.231 0 Td [([517])]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(he)-349(appeared)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 57.293 0 Td [(to)-349(the)-350(eleven)-349(as)-350(they)-349(sat)-349(at)-350(meat,)-374(and)-350(upbraided)]TJ -62.137 -13.549 Td [(them)-419(with)-418(their)-419(unbelief)-418(and)-419(hardness)-419(of)-418(heart,)-461(because)-418(they)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(believed)-350(not)-350(those)-350(who)-350(had)-349(seen)-350(him)-350(after)-350(he)-350(was)-350(risen)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 251.484 0 Td [(.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.661 0 Td [(It)-350(is)]TJ -262.872 -13.549 Td [(evident)-383(that)-384(the)-383(author)-384(of)-383(the)-383(supplement)-384(entertained)-383(a)-383(strong)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(view)-334(of)-334(the)-334(incredulity)-334(of)-334(the)-334(disciples)-334(when)-334(their)-333(companions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reported)-250(to)-250(them)-250(the)-250(fact)-250(of)-250(the)-250(Resurrection.)]TJ 11.956 -15.186 Td [(Let)-315(us)-314(now)-315(examine)-315(how)-315(the)-314(facts)-315(stand)-315(in)-315(Luke's)-314(narrative.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2084 0 obj <<
/Length 6973      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(452)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(It)-304(opens)-303(with)-304(a)-303(detailed)-304(account)-304(of)-303(the)-304(journey)-303(into)-304(the)-303(country)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-296(Cleopas)-295(and)-296(his)-295(companion,)-307(and)-295(of)-296(our)-295(Lord's)-296(appearance)-295(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them.)-247(Our)-241(Lord)-241(addresses)-241(them)-241(in)-242(the)-241(following)-241(words:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 244.062 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(O)-241(fools)]TJ -248.905 -13.549 Td [(and)-292(slow)-291(of)-292(heart,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 80.157 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.024 0 Td [(\050)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.633 0 Td [(\251)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 10.075 0 Td [(\000)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.727 0 Td [(\275)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 5.531 0 Td [(y)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.433 0 Td [(\267\304\277\271)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 19.156 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 6.021 0 Td [(\272\261)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 11.291 0 Td [(v)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 6.388 0 Td [(\222\301\261\264\265)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 26.738 0 Td [(\326)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\302)-292(\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 12.322 0 Td [(\307)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 9.006 0 Td [(\272\261\301\264)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 21.731 0 Td [(w\263)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.934 0 Td [(\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 6.814 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(to)-292(be-)]TJ -255.031 -13.55 Td [(lieve)-181(all)-182(that)-181(the)-181(prophets)-181(have)-181(spoken.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 166.085 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.821 0 Td [(After)-181(their)-181(recognition)-182(of)]TJ -172.906 -13.549 Td [(Jesus,)-259(they)-258(are)-258(described)-257(as)-258(immediately)-257(returning)-258(to)-257(Jerusalem,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(and)-273(find)-272(the)-273(eleven)-273(gathered)-272(together)-273(and)-272(those)-273(that)-273(were)-272(with)]TJ -4.844 -13.549 Td [(them,)-318(saying,)-318(the)-305(Lord)-305(is)-304(risen)-305(indeed,)-318(and)-304(hath)-305(appeared)-304(unto)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Simon.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 30 0 Td [(\035)-251(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 12.42 0 Td [(And)-251(they)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 38.482 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.576 0 Td [(\050)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 3.633 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 16.074 0 Td [(Cleopas)-251(and)-250(his)-251(companion\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 126.676 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(told)-250(what)]TJ -239.705 -13.55 Td [(things)-275(were)-275(done)-276(on)-275(the)-275(way,)-281(and)-276(how)-275(he)-275(was)-275(known)-275(unto)-275(them)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-273(the)-274(breaking)-273(of)-274(bread.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 109.196 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.826 0 Td [(The)-273(narrative)-274(then)-273(proceeds:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 128.509 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(And)-273(as)]TJ -250.375 -13.549 Td [(they)-191(thus)-191(spake,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 68.09 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 6.925 0 Td [(\050)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 3.632 0 Td [(i.e.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.843 0 Td [(Cleopas)-191(and)-191(his)-190(companion\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 124.07 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Jesus)-191(himself)]TJ -223.404 -13.549 Td [(stood)-339(in)-339(the)-339(midst)-340(of)-339(them,)-361(and)-339(said)-340(unto)-339(them,)-361(Peace)-339(be)-339(unto)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(you.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 18.48 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.882 0 Td [(It)-370(then)-370(informs)-370(us)-371(that)-370(they)-370(were)-370(terrified)-370(and)-370(supposed)]TJ -27.362 -13.55 Td [(that)-243(the)-244(appearance)-243(was)-243(that)-244(of)-243(a)-243(spirit.)-248(On)-243(this)-244(our)-243(Lord)-243(reasons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-291(them:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 51.047 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Why)-291(are)-291(ye)-291(troubled,)-302(and)-291(why)-291(do)-291(thoughts)-291(arise)-291(in)]TJ -55.891 -13.549 Td [(your)-254(hearts?)-262(Behold)-254(my)-253(hands)-254(and)-254(my)-254(feet)-254(that)-254(it)-254(is)-254(I)-254(myself,)-254(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-317(spirit)-317(hath)-317(not)-317(flesh)-317(and)-317(bones)-317(as)-317(ye)-317(see)-317(me)-317(have.)-450(And)-317(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(he)-232(had)-231(thus)-232(spoken,)-235(he)-232(showed)-231(them)-232(his)-231(hands)-232(and)-231(his)-232(feet.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 256.297 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.369 0 Td [(The)]TJ -263.666 -13.55 Td [(writer)-327(then)-327(adds:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 79.405 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(And)-327(when)-327(they)-327(yet)-327(believed)-327(not)-327(for)-327(joy)-327(and)]TJ -84.249 -13.549 Td [(wondered,)-264(he)-261(said)-261(unto)-260(them,)-264(Have)-261(ye)-261(here)-261(any)-261(meat?)-283(And)-260(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gave)-301(him)-301(a)-301(piece)-301(of)-301(a)-302(broiled)-301(fish,)-627(and)-301(of)-301(an)-302(honey-comb,)-313(and)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.756 0 Td [([518])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.756 -13.549 Td [(he)-357(took)-357(it)-356(and)-357(did)-357(eat)-357(before)-356(them.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 157.826 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.735 0 Td [(The)-357(author)-357(then)-356(proceeds)]TJ -166.561 -13.549 Td [(with)-320(his)-320(narrative:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 85.169 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(These)-320(are)-320(the)-320(words)-320(that)-320(I)-320(spake)-320(unto)-320(you,)]TJ -90.013 -13.55 Td [(while)-325(I)-325(was)-325(yet)-325(with)-325(you,)-344(that)-325(all)-325(things)-325(might)-325(be)-325(fulfilled)-325(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-322(written)-321(in)-322(the)-322(law)-322(of)-321(Moses,)-340(and)-322(in)-322(the)-321(prophets)-322(and)-322(in)-321(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Psalms)-384(concerning)-384(me.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 103.821 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.032 0 Td [(And)-384(he)-384(adds:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 66.139 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Then)-384(opened)-384(he)-384(their)]TJ -183.836 -13.549 Td [(understanding,)-250(that)-250(they)-250(might)-250(understand)-250(the)-250(Scriptures.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 252.12 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -240.165 -18.459 Td [(The)-385(following)-386(is)-385(the)-385(account)-386(given)-385(of)-386(the)-385(same)-385(meeting)-386(in)]TJ -11.955 -13.549 Td [(St.)-510(John's)-337(Gospel.)-510(After)-336(having)-337(given)-337(a)-336(full)-337(description)-337(of)-336(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(appearance)-421(to)-421(Mary)-422(Magdalene,)-464(he)-421(thus)-421(describes)-421(our)-421(Lord's)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(appearance)-291(on)-292(the)-291(evening)-291(of)-292(Easter-day:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 186.122 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Then)-291(the)-292(first)-291(day)-291(at)]TJ -190.966 -13.55 Td [(evening,)-369(being)-345(the)-344(first)-345(day)-345(of)-345(the)-345(week,)-369(when)-345(the)-345(doors)-344(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(shut)-381(where)-382(the)-381(disciples)-382(were)-381(assembled)-382(for)-381(fear)-382(of)-381(the)-381(Jews,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2088 0 obj <<
/Length 6016      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(453)]TJ
0 g 0 G
/F31 10.9091 Tf -264.267 -30.759 Td [(came)-236(Jesus)-236(and)-236(stood)-236(in)-236(the)-236(midst,)-239(and)-236(said)-236(unto)-237(them,)-238(Peace)-236(be)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unto)-309(you.)-426(And)-309(when)-308(he)-309(had)-309(so)-308(said,)-324(he)-308(showed)-309(them)-309(his)-308(hands)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-353(his)-353(side.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 63.199 0 Td [(Then)-353(were)-353(the)-353(disciples)-353(glad)-353(when)-353(they)-353(saw)-353(the)]TJ -63.199 -13.549 Td [(Lord.)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 28.652 0 Td [(Then)-311(said)-311(Jesus)-310(unto)-311(them)-311(again,)-326(Peace)-311(be)-311(unto)-310(you:)-372(as)]TJ -28.652 -13.55 Td [(my)-318(Father)-318(hath)-318(sent)-317(me,)-335(even)-318(so)-318(send)-318(I)-317(you.)-454(And)-318(when)-318(he)-317(had)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(said)-388(this)-388(he)-389(breathed)-388(on)-388(them,)-423(and)-388(said,)-423(Receive)-388(ye)-388(the)-388(Holy)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Ghost.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 28.789 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -16.833 -14.777 Td [(The)-251(difference)-252(between)-251(the)-251(supplement)-252(of)-251(Mark's)-251(Gospel)-251(and)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(the)-410(narratives)-411(of)-410(Luke)-411(and)-410(John)-411(is)-410(very)-411(remarkable.)-731(Are)-410(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(variations)-260(such)-260(as)-260(would)-260(be)-259(found)-260(in)-260(different)-260(reports)-260(of)-260(a)-260(set)-259(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fictions,)-288(or)-280(are)-281(they)-280(such)-281(as)-280(distinguish)-280(brief)-281(but)-280(inexact)-280(reports)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(actual)-250(occurrences?)-250(This)-250(is)-250(a)-250(very)-250(important)-250(question.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(First:)-271(the)-261(three)-260(accounts)-261(bear)-260(the)-261(clearest)-260(indications)-261(of)-260(being)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(independent.)-648(It)-382(is)-383(incredible)-382(that)-383(any)-382(one)-383(of)-382(the)-383(three)-382(writers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(having)-278(before)-279(him)-278(one)-278(or)-279(both)-278(of)-278(the)-279(other)-278(two)-278(accounts)-278(should)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(have)-250(composed)-250(his)-250(own)-250(as)-250(it)-250(now)-250(stands.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(Secondly:)-326(the)-288(author)-289(of)-288(the)-288(supplement)-288(uses)-288(very)-288(strong)-288(lan-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(guage)-313(in)-314(describing)-313(the)-313(unbelief)-314(of)-313(the)-314(disciples.)-880(He)-313(says)-313(that)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([519])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(when)-282(they)-282(told)-282(it)-283(to)-282(the)-282(others,)-290(they)-282(did)-282(not)-282(believe)-282(their)-282(report.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(St.)-372(Luke,)-300(on)-291(the)-290(other)-291(hand,)-300(informs)-291(us)-290(that)-291(as)-290(soon)-291(as)-290(Cleopas)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-301(his)-301(companion)-300(entered)-301(the)-301(room)-300(where)-301(on)-301(their)-301(return)-300(they)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(found)-423(the)-422(Apostles)-423(and)-422(others)-423(assembled)-422(together,)-466(they)-422(were)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(received)-343(with)-342(the)-343(exclamation:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 141.994 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)-343(Lord)-342(is)-343(risen)-343(indeed,)-365(and)]TJ -146.838 -13.549 Td [(hath)-250(appeared)-250(unto)-250(Simon.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 118.178 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -106.222 -14.777 Td [(Again:)-593(the)-421(author)-422(of)-421(the)-422(supplement)-421(says)-422(that)-421(when)-421(Jesus)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(appeared)-339(to)-339(the)-339(eleven)-340(as)-339(they)-339(sat)-339(at)-339(meat)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 192.035 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(he)-339(upbraided)-339(them)]TJ -196.878 -13.549 Td [(with)-211(their)-211(unbelief)-211(and)-210(hardness)-211(of)-211(heart)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 178.121 0 Td [(\050)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 3.633 0 Td [(`)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 7.636 0 Td [(\275\265)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 10.113 0 Td [(w)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\264\271\303\265)-211(\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 25.22 0 Td [(t)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.826 0 Td [(\275)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 7.831 0 Td [(\000)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.727 0 Td [(\300\271\303\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 18.851 0 Td [(w)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\261\275)]TJ -269.372 -13.55 Td [(\261)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 5.728 0 Td [(P)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.531 0 Td [(\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 4.69 0 Td [(\366)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 7.637 0 Td [(\275)-354(\272\261)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 20.681 0 Td [(v)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 7.067 0 Td [(\303\272\273\267\301\277\272\261\301\264)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 54.742 0 Td [(w)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\261\275)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 11.258 0 Td [(\051)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 7.493 0 Td [(because)-354(they)-354(did)-353(not)-354(believe)-354(them)]TJ -128.034 -13.549 Td [(that)-401(had)-401(seen)-401(him)-401(after)-401(he)-401(was)-401(risen.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 172.132 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.217 0 Td [(St.)-703(Luke)-401(tells)-401(us)-401(that)]TJ -181.349 -13.549 Td [(not)-451(only)-452(were)-451(Cleopas)-451(and)-451(his)-452(companion)-451(received)-451(with)-451(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(joyful)-368(exclamation,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 90.453 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(The)-368(Lord)-367(is)-368(risen)-367(indeed)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 111.799 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.853 0 Td [(but)-368(instead)-367(of)]TJ -218.676 -13.549 Td [(upbraiding)-229(them)-229(Jesus)-230(addressed)-229(them)-229(with)-229(the)-229(words)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 236.338 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Peace)-229(be)]TJ -241.181 -13.55 Td [(unto)-200(you)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 37.332 0 Td [(;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 3.032 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.026 0 Td [(which)-200(is)-200(confirmed)-200(by)-200(the)-200(author)-200(of)-200(the)-200(fourth)-200(Gospel,)]TJ -47.39 -13.549 Td [(who,)-315(if)-302(St.)-405(John)-302(was)-302(really)-302(the)-302(author,)-315(must)-302(have)-302(been)-301(present.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2093 0 obj <<
/Length 5814      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(454)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(In)-273(neither)-274(of)-273(these)-274(Gospels)-273(is)-273(there)-274(one)-273(word)-274(of)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 212.204 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(upbraiding)-273(the)]TJ -217.048 -13.549 Td [(disciples)-279(with)-278(unbelief;)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 102.438 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.882 0 Td [(while)-279(both)-278(affirm)-279(that)-278(Jesus)-279(proceeded)]TJ -110.32 -13.549 Td [(to)-267(give)-268(them)-267(rational)-267(grounds)-267(for)-267(believing)-268(that)-267(He)-267(was)-267(actually)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(risen)-372(from)-372(the)-372(dead,)-403(by)-371(showing)-372(them,)-403(according)-372(to)-372(one,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 263.056 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(his)]TJ -267.899 -13.55 Td [(hands)-342(and)-342(his)-342(feet,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 84.206 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.574 0 Td [(according)-342(to)-342(the)-342(other,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 105.15 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(his)-342(hands)-342(and)-342(his)]TJ -202.774 -13.549 Td [(side.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 20.302 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.858 0 Td [(It)-276(is)-277(quite)-276(probable)-276(that)-277(He)-276(may)-276(have)-277(done)-276(both.)-329(St.)-329(John)]TJ -28.16 -13.549 Td [(adds,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 25.451 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Then)-250(were)-250(the)-250(disciples)-250(glad)-250(when)-250(they)-250(saw)-250(the)-250(Lord.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 233.934 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -252.273 -16.004 Td [(But)-433(St.)-799(Luke's)-433(account)-433(is)-433(more)-433(specific.)-799(He)-433(tells)-433(us)-432(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(immediately)-368(on)-367(His)-368(entry)-368(fear)-368(took)-367(possession)-368(of)-368(their)-367(minds.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(They)-269(were)-269(terrified)-268(and)-269(affrighted)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 149.305 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 2.727 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.776 0 Td [(and)-269(supposed)-269(that)-269(it)-268(might)]TJ -164.652 -13.55 Td [(be)-236(a)-235(spirit,)-239(and)-236(not)-235(Jesus)-236(actually)-236(raised)-235(from)-236(the)-236(dead.)-245(Our)-235(Lord)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(therefore)-223(before)-224(showing)-223(them)-223(His)-223(hands)-224(and)-223(His)-223(feet)-223(proceeded)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-255(reason)-255(with)-255(them)-255(as)-254(to)-255(the)-255(reality)-255(of)-255(His)-255(appearance.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 243.67 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Handle)]TJ -248.514 -13.549 Td [(me)-316(and)-316(see,)-332(for)-316(a)-316(spirit)-316(hath)-316(not)-315(flesh)-316(and)-316(bones)-632(as)-316(ye)-316(see)-315(me)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([520])]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(have.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 23.324 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.439 0 Td [(Here)-238(there)-238(is)-238(nothing)-238(of)-238(reproach,)-240(such)-238(as)-238(is)-238(suggested)-238(by)]TJ -30.763 -13.55 Td [(the)-299(supplement)-298(to)-299(St.)-395(Mark's)-298(Gospel.)-396(Yet)-298(there)-299(was)-298(incredulity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-301(a)-301(certain)-300(kind)-301(in)-301(the)-301(room,)-313(but)-301(not)-300(one)-301(which)-301(was)-301(worthy)-300(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reproach.)-313(We)-270(learn)-271(from)-271(St.)-312(Luke)-271(that)-271(it)-271(was)-271(not)-271(the)-270(incredulity)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 12.052 0 Td [(unbelief,)-277(but)-272(of)-272(joy)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 82.588 0 Td [(;)-283(in)-271(other)-272(words,)-277(that)-272(the)-272(news)-271(seemed)-272(too)]TJ -94.64 -13.549 Td [(good)-374(to)-374(be)-375(true,)-405(and)-374(they)-374(dared)-375(scarcely)-374(trust)-374(the)-374(evidence)-374(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(their)-272(senses.)-315(On)-272(this)-272(however)-272(nothing)-271(in)-272(the)-272(form)-272(of)-272(a)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 240.637 0 Td [(reproach)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -240.637 -13.549 Td [(passes)-255(the)-255(lips)-256(of)-255(Jesus;)-258(but)-255(for)-255(their)-255(further)-256(satisfaction,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 248.762 0 Td [(he)-255(asks)]TJ -248.762 -13.549 Td [(for)-250(food)-250(and)-250(eats)-250(it)-250(before)-250(them)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 137.575 0 Td [(.)]TJ -125.619 -16.004 Td [(On)-357(all)-357(these)-356(points)-357(the)-357(narratives)-357(of)-357(St.)-570(Luke)-357(and)-357(St.)-570(John)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(throw)-304(light)-304(on)-303(each)-304(other,)-317(as)-304(such)-304(accounts,)-317(if)-304(founded)-304(on)-303(fact,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ought)-227(to)-228(do,)-232(while)-227(their)-227(independence)-228(is)-227(indisputable.)-242(According)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-344(those)-344(with)-343(whom)-344(I)-344(am)-344(reasoning,)-367(the)-344(Gospel)-344(of)-343(St.)-532(John)-343(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(much)-387(the)-387(latest)-387(written.)-662(If)-387(therefore)-387(the)-387(author)-387(had)-387(borrowed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-266(Luke,)-271(it)-266(is)-267(incredible)-266(that)-267(a)-266(writer)-267(who)-266(had)-267(such)-266(powers)-266(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(setting)-230(forth)-230(fictions)-230(in)-229(the)-230(garb)-230(of)-230(facts,)-234(should)-230(have)-230(omitted)-229(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(other)-258(remarkable)-258(incidents)-258(mentioned)-258(by)-258(St.)-274(Luke,)-260(and)-258(not)-257(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dressed)-292(them)-292(up)-293(with)-292(the)-292(art)-292(of)-292(which)-293(he)-292(was)-292(so)-292(consummate)-292(a)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(master,)-281(for)-275(these)-274(would)-275(have)-275(communicated)-274(a)-275(striking)-275(reality)-274(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-238(scenes.)-245(It)-238(is)-238(therefore)-237(unquestionable)-238(that)-237(these)-238(two)-237(accounts)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2097 0 obj <<
/Length 6059      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(455)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(present)-191(all)-192(the)-191(phenomena)-192(of)-191(history,)-203(and)-192(none)-191(of)-192(those)-191(of)-191(fiction.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(But)-278(how)-277(stands)-278(the)-277(continuation)-278(of)-278(St.)-332(Mark's)-278(Gospel,)-284(which)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(affirms)-190(that)-189(our)-190(Lord)-190(upbraided)-189(the)-190(eleven)-190(with)-189(their)-190(unbelief)-189(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(hardness)-345(of)-346(heart)-345(on)-346(the)-345(occasion)-346(of)-345(His)-346(appearance)-345(on)-345(Easter)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(evening?)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(The)-397(author)-398(of)-397(the)-398(supplement)-397(was)-398(probably)-397(not)-398(aware)-397(that)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Cleopas)-301(and)-300(his)-301(companion)-301(were)-300(present)-301(in)-301(the)-300(room)-301(when)-300(our)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Lord)-443(appeared)-443(to)-444(the)-443(eleven,)-491(or)-444(even)-443(that)-443(others)-443(besides)-443(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(eleven)-226(were)-226(present,)-231(as)-226(is)-227(expressly)-226(affirmed)-226(by)-226(St.)-242(Luke)-226(to)-226(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-329(the)-328(case.)-971(The)-328(impression)-329(which)-328(it)-329(leaves)-328(on)-329(the)-328(mind)-328(is)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([521])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.55 Td [(that)-291(they)-291(reported)-291(the)-290(Resurrection)-291(to)-291(the)-291(disciples)-291(generally)-290(on)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(their)-379(return,)-410(and)-379(that)-378(it)-379(was)-378(disbelieved)-378(by)-379(them,)-411(and)-378(that)-378(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(appearance)-250(to)-250(the)-250(eleven)-250(was)-250(a)-250(subsequent)-250(event.)]TJ 11.956 -14.777 Td [(We)-385(are)-386(now)-385(in)-385(a)-386(position)-385(to)-385(see)-386(how)-385(this)-385(misapprehension)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(may)-199(have)-200(originated;)-216(and)-199(that)-200(instead)-199(of)-200(invalidating)-199(the)-199(account,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-332(forms)-331(a)-332(strong)-331(confirmation)-332(of)-331(its)-332(truth.)-494(There)-332(were)-331(persons)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-379(the)-378(room)-379(whom)-378(our)-379(Lord)-378(had)-379(actually)-378(reproached)-379(for)-378(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(unbelief,)-225(viz.)-239(Cleopas)-218(and)-219(his)-218(companion;)-229(though)-218(He)-218(reproached)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(none)-290(who)-290(were)-291(present)-290(on)-290(the)-290(occasion)-290(of)-291(His)-290(appearance.)-370(The)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(words)-378(stated)-377(by)-378(St.)-633(Luke)-377(to)-378(have)-378(been)-377(used)-378(by)-377(Him)-378(were,)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 273.736 0 Td [(\251)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf -273.736 -13.549 Td [(\000)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.728 0 Td [(\275)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 5.531 0 Td [(y)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.432 0 Td [(\267\304\277\271)-387(\272\261)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 34.672 0 Td [(v)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 7.432 0 Td [(\222\301\261\264\265)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 26.738 0 Td [(\326)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\302)-387(\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 13.365 0 Td [(\307)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 10.049 0 Td [(\272\261\301\264)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 21.731 0 Td [(w\263)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.934 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 7.326 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(O)-387(fools)-387(and)-388(slow)-387(of)-387(heart.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 120.798 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.787 -13.549 Td [(Those)-319(used)-319(in)-318(St.)-457(Mark)-319(in)-318(describing)-319(the)-319(address)-319(to)-319(the)-318(eleven)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 16.479 0 Td [(`)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 7.637 0 Td [(\275\265)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 10.112 0 Td [(w)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.208 0 Td [(\264\271\303\265)-290(\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 26.079 0 Td [(t)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.825 0 Td [(\275)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 8.69 0 Td [(\000)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.727 0 Td [(\300\271\303\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 18.851 0 Td [(w)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.207 0 Td [(\261\275)-290(\261)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 20.145 0 Td [(P)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 5.53 0 Td [(\304)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 4.691 0 Td [(\366)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 7.637 0 Td [(\275)-290(\272\261)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 19.98 0 Td [(v)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 6.367 0 Td [(\303\272\273\267\301\277\272\261\301\264)]TJ/F38 10.9091 Tf 54.741 0 Td [(w)]TJ/F37 10.9091 Tf 3.208 0 Td [(\261\275)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 11.258 0 Td [(,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 5.994 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(He)-290(up-)]TJ -250.209 -13.55 Td [(braided)-208(their)-208(unbelief)-208(and)-207(hardness)-208(of)-208(heart.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 189.611 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.11 0 Td [(The)-208(one)-208(expression)]TJ -196.721 -13.549 Td [(is)-286(the)-285(very)-286(counterpart)-285(of)-286(the)-285(other.)-357(There)-285(were)-286(persons)-285(present)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-227(had)-227(been)-227(thus)-227(reproached)-227(but)-228(a)-227(few)-227(hours)-227(before:)-238(the)-227(author)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-214(the)-213(continuation)-214(was)-214(aware)-213(of)-214(the)-213(fact)-214(that)-214(some)-213(had)-214(been)-213(thus)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(reproached,)-433(and)-396(he)-396(supposed)-395(that)-396(the)-396(reproach)-396(was)-396(addressed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-291(all)-291(the)-292(assembled)-291(disciples,)-301(instead)-292(of)-291(the)-291(salutation)-291(of)-291(peace)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(with)-250(its)-250(attendant)-250(circumstances.)]TJ 11.956 -14.776 Td [(Then)-428(as)-429(to)-428(their)-429(having)-428(been)-428(received)-429(with)-428(expressions)-428(of)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(incredulity)-346(on)-345(their)-346(return,)-369(St.)-537(Luke)-346(tells)-346(us)-345(that)-346(they)-345(returned)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-235(Jerusalem,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 59.992 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(and)-235(found)-234(the)-235(eleven)-234(gathered)-235(together,)-238(and)-234(them)]TJ -64.836 -13.549 Td [(that)-295(were)-296(with)-295(them.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 90.576 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.065 0 Td [(Now)-295(as)-296(they)-295(had)-295(set)-295(out)-296(early)-295(in)-295(the)-295(day,)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2101 0 obj <<
/Length 4898      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(456)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(it)-434(was)-434(necessary)-434(on)-434(their)-434(return)-434(that)-434(they)-434(should)-434(make)-433(some)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inquiry)-268(as)-269(to)-268(where)-268(the)-268(Apostles)-268(were)-269(to)-268(be)-268(found.)-305(In)-268(doing)-268(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(it)-258(is)-258(probable)-258(enough)-258(that)-258(they)-258(went)-258(to)-258(inquire)-258(of)-258(some)-257(disciples)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(who)-353(received)-353(their)-352(account)-353(with)-353(incredulity,)-378(and)-353(that)-353(then)-352(this)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(incredulity)-279(may)-279(through)-279(misapprehension)-279(have)-279(been)-279(transferred)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-291(the)-291(whole)-581(assembly.)-372(I)-291(submit)-291(therefore)-291(that)-290(notwithstanding)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf -72.755 0 Td [([522])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 72.755 -13.549 Td [(this)-365(disagreement)-365(between)-365(the)-365(three)-365(accounts,)-394(that)-365(of)-364(the)-365(con-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tinuation)-350(of)-350(St.)-551(Mark's)-350(Gospel)-351(gives)-350(a)-350(strong)-350(corroboration)-350(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-392(statements)-392(of)-391(the)-392(other)-392(two.)-675(These)-392(are)-392(precisely)-392(the)-391(kind)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-304(variations)-304(which)-303(we)-304(find)-304(in)-304(reports)-303(of)-304(events)-304(after)-304(they)-303(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(passed)-250(through)-250(a)-250(few)-250(stages)-250(of)-250(oral)-250(transmission.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(The)-320(narratives)-320(of)-319(St.)-460(Luke)-320(and)-320(St.)-459(John)-320(furnish)-320(us)-320(with)-319(one)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(more)-351(very)-351(incidental)-351(confirmation)-351(of)-351(each)-351(other.)-553(St.)-552(Luke)-351(in-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forms)-238(us)-238(that)-238(on)-238(the)-238(occasion)-238(of)-238(this)-238(interview)-238(our)-238(Lord)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 244.281 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(opened)]TJ -249.125 -13.549 Td [(their)-254(understanding,)-255(that)-255(they)-254(might)-254(understand)-254(the)-254(Scriptures.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 275.786 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.55 Td [(St.)-474(John)-324(says)-325(that)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 83.371 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(He)-325(breathed)-324(on)-325(them,)-343(and)-324(said,)-344(Receive)-324(ye)]TJ -88.214 -13.549 Td [(the)-326(Holy)-326(Ghost.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 70.435 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.397 0 Td [(The)-326(words)-325(and)-326(the)-326(mode)-326(of)-325(expression)-326(differ)]TJ -78.832 -13.549 Td [(greatly;)-300(but)-284(both)-283(statements)-284(point)-283(to)-284(one)-283(and)-284(the)-283(same)-284(fact,)-291(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(on)-254(this)-254(occasion)-254(the)-253(persons)-254(present)-254(supposed)-254(that)-254(they)-253(received)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-455(supernatural)-455(enlightenment.)-866(St.)-866(Luke)-455(describes)-455(the)-455(effect)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(produced)-254(on)-255(the)-254(minds)-255(of)-254(the)-254(disciples;)-257(St.)-263(John)-255(gives)-254(the)-254(actual)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(medium)-306(of)-306(its)-306(production.)-417(Coincidences)-306(of)-306(this)-306(kind)-306(prove)-305(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-246(narratives)-245(must)-246(be)-245(founded)-246(on)-245(facts,)-246(and)-246(are)-245(beyond)-246(the)-245(skill)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(a)-250(forger)-250(to)-250(imitate.)]TJ 11.956 -16.004 Td [(I)-381(have)-381(now)-381(considered)-381(a)-381(few)-381(of)-381(the)-381(leading)-381(features)-381(of)-381(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(Gospels,)-264(which)-261(establish)-261(the)-261(general)-261(historical)-261(character)-261(of)-261(their)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(contents.)-227(A)-182(close)-182(examination)-182(of)-182(them)-182(would)-182(put)-182(us)-182(in)-181(possession)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-248(a)-249(large)-248(amount)-248(of)-248(additional)-249(evidence,)-248(but)-248(to)-249(enter)-248(on)-248(such)-248(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(inquiry)-267(here)-267(would)-267(be)-267(inconsistent)-267(with)-267(the)-267(limits)-267(of)-267(the)-267(present)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(work.)-810(As)-436(I)-437(have)-436(already)-437(observed,)-483(the)-437(minute)-436(scrutiny)-437(of)-436(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(number)-255(of)-256(minor)-255(details,)-257(as)-256(far)-255(as)-256(the)-255(great)-256(historical)-255(question)-255(is)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(concerned,)-297(would)-288(be)-288(a)-288(needless)-288(expenditure)-288(of)-288(labour.)-364(The)-287(real)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(question)-208(at)-209(issue)-208(is:)-229(Is)-208(the)-209(account)-208(of)-208(our)-209(Lord's)-208(life)-208(and)-208(teaching,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(as)-245(it)-245(is)-246(handed)-245(down)-245(in)-245(our)-246(present)-245(Gospels,)-246(substantially)-245(true)-245(in)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2105 0 obj <<
/Length 5027      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 311.038 548.934 Td [(457)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 -264.267 -30.759 Td [(its)-225(great)-225(outlines,)-230(or)-225(has)-224(one)-225(of)-225(a)-225(wholly)-225(different)-450(character)-224(been)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([523])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(substituted)-245(for)-246(the)-245(true)-246(one,)-246(and)-245(usurped)-246(its)-245(place)-246(in)-245(the)-245(teaching)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-271(the)-272(Church?)-314(On)-271(a)-272(broad)-271(question)-272(of)-271(this)-271(kind,)-277(minor)-271(discrep-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ancies)-345(in)-344(the)-345(accounts)-345(have)-345(no)-344(real)-345(bearing.)-534(If)-345(the)-345(narrative)-344(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(true)-229(in)-228(its)-229(great)-229(outlines,)-233(it)-228(follows)-229(that)-229(our)-228(Lord's)-229(character)-228(must)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-353(been)-352(beyond)-353(all)-353(question)-352(superhuman,)-379(and)-352(justifies)-353(us)-352(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirming)-326(that)-326(He)-326(must)-326(have)-326(been)-326(a)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 162.432 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(teacher)-326(come)-326(from)-326(God.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 108.511 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.787 -13.549 Td [(Such)-373(a)-372(conclusion)-373(will)-373(still)-372(leave)-373(open)-373(a)-372(number)-373(of)-372(questions)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-383(the)-384(deepest)-383(importance,)-417(but)-383(they)-384(belong)-383(to)-384(the)-383(province)-383(of)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(theology)-431(to)-431(investigate,)-476(and)-430(form)-431(no)-431(necessary)-431(portion)-431(of)-430(an)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(historical)-437(inquiry.)-812(If)-437(the)-437(Gospels)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 158.526 0 Td [(in)-437(their)-437(broad)-438(outlines)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 108.784 0 Td [(are)]TJ -267.31 -13.549 Td [(historical;)-220(above)-204(all,)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 90.275 0 Td [(if)-204(Jesus)-205(Christ)-204(rose)-204(from)-204(the)-205(dead)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 144.279 0 Td [(,)-213(it)-205(follows)]TJ -234.554 -13.549 Td [(that)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)-250(must)-250(contain)-250(a)-250(divine)-250(revelation.)]TJ 11.956 -18.459 Td [(As)-352(this)-352(last)-352(fact)-352(forms)-352(the)-353(central)-352(position)-352(of)-352(Christianity,)-377(I)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(have)-395(made)-395(its)-395(historical)-395(truth)-395(the)-395(chief)-395(subject)-395(of)-395(my)-394(investi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(gation.)-716(In)-406(doing)-405(this)-406(I)-405(have)-406(relied)-405(only)-406(on)-405(documents)-405(which)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(are)-297(contained)-297(in)-296(the)-297(New)-297(Testament)-297(itself,)-308(and)-297(chiefly)-297(on)-296(those)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(whose)-237(genuineness)-238(is)-237(conceded)-238(by)-237(opponents.)-246(I)-238(have)-237(shown)-237(that)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(no)-167(species)-168(of)-167(documents)-167(can)-168(possess)-167(a)-167(higher)-168(historical)-167(value)-167(than)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(these,)-238(and)-235(that)-235(the)-236(circumstances)-235(under)-235(which)-235(they)-235(were)-235(written,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-280(nature)-281(of)-280(their)-280(contents,)-288(and)-280(the)-280(persons)-281(to)-280(whom)-280(they)-280(were)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(addressed,)-246(form)-246(an)-245(attestation)-246(to)-245(the)-246(truth)-245(of)-246(the)-245(facts)-246(asserted)-245(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(them,)-341(which)-323(is)-323(unrivalled)-323(in)-323(the)-323(whole)-323(course)-323(of)-323(literature.)-469(By)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(means)-309(of)-309(these)-308(I)-309(have)-309(firmly)-309(established)-308(the)-309(fact)-309(that)-309(the)-308(belief)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-267(the)-267(Resurrection)-267(of)-268(Jesus)-267(Christ)-267(was)-267(the)-267(foundation)-267(on)-267(which)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-304(Church)-303(rested)-304(as)-303(a)-304(community)-303(from)-303(the)-304(first)-303(dawning)-304(of)-303(its)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(existence,)-423(and)-389(the)-389(basis)-388(of)-389(the)-389(life)-388(of)-389(its)-389(individual)-388(members;)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-340(that)-340(considerable)-341(numbers)-340(of)-340(the)-340(followers)-340(of)-340(Jesus)-340(Christ)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(affirmed)-379(that)-378(they)-379(had)-379(seen)-378(and)-379(conversed)-379(with)-378(Him)-379(after)-378(He)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(had)-321(risen)-321(from)-321(the)-321(dead.)-462(I)-321(have)-321(shown)-321(that)-642(these)-321(facts)-321(rest)-320(on)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 291.024 0 Td [([524])]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -291.024 -13.549 Td [(the)-371(highest)-372(form)-371(of)-372(historical)-371(attestation.)-614(This)-371(being)-372(so,)-401(there)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(can)-242(be)-242(only)-241(two)-242(alternatives)-242(respecting)-242(them.)-247(Either)-242(the)-242(belief)-241(in)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(the)-334(Resurrection)-334(was)-334(founded)-335(on)-334(the)-334(fact)-334(that)-334(He)-334(actually)-334(rose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-259(the)-260(dead;)-263(or)-260(it)-259(must)-259(have)-259(originated)-260(in)-259(the)-259(delusions)-259(of)-259(His)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2110 0 obj <<
/Length 4000      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(458)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(followers.)-646(I)-382(have)-382(shown)-382(that)-382(the)-382(various)-382(theories)-381(which)-382(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(been)-214(propounded)-213(to)-214(account)-214(for)-214(it)-213(on)-214(the)-214(latter)-213(supposition,)-221(when)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tested)-239(by)-239(the)-239(actual)-238(facts,)-242(are)-238(untrue)-239(both)-239(to)-239(human)-239(nature)-239(and)-238(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-307(possibilities)-307(of)-307(the)-307(case.)-421(From)-307(this)-306(it)-307(results,)-322(as)-307(a)-306(necessary)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(consequence,)-284(that)-277(J)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 85.188 0 Td [(ESUS)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 22.51 0 Td [(C)]TJ/F16 7.9701 Tf 7.276 0 Td [(HRIST)-379(ROSE)-379(FROM)-380(THE)-379(DEAD)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 115.701 0 Td [(.)-277(If)-277(He)-277(rose)]TJ -230.675 -13.549 Td [(from)-243(the)-242(dead,)-244(the)-243(truth)-242(of)-242(His)-243(divine)-242(mission)-243(is)-242(established,)-244(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-299(claim)-298(to)-299(be)-298(the)-298(King)-299(and)-298(supreme)-299(Legislator)-298(of)-299(the)-298(Church)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-243(vindicated.)-248(This)-243(claim)-243(may)-243(be)-243(fully)-243(set)-243(forth)-243(in)-243(t)1(wo)-243(sayings)-243(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(His)-337(own,)-358(recorded)-337(in)-337(St.)-511(John's)-337(Gospel:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 184.694 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(I)-337(am)-337(the)-337(light)-336(of)-337(the)]TJ -189.537 -13.55 Td [(world;)-247(he)-245(that)-245(followeth)-245(Me)-245(shall)-245(not)-245(walk)-245(in)-245(darkness,)-246(but)-245(shall)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(have)-288(the)-288(light)-288(of)-288(life.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 92.854 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.985 0 Td [(\050xiii.)-364(12.\051)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 46.118 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Thou)-288(sayest)-288(that)-288(I)-288(am)-288(a)-287(king.)]TJ -151.8 -13.549 Td [(For)-242(this)-243(end)-242(was)-243(I)-242(born,)-244(and)-242(for)-243(this)-242(cause)-243(came)-242(I)-243(into)-242(the)-242(world,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-254(I)-254(should)-254(bear)-254(witness)-254(unto)-254(the)-254(truth.)-262(Every)-254(one)-254(that)-254(is)-254(of)-254(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(truth)-250(heareth)-250(my)-250(voice.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 101.193 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 7.571 0 Td [(\050xviii.)-250(37.\051)]TJ -96.808 -13.55 Td [(The)-475(practical)-476(conclusion)-475(which)-476(this)-475(investigation)-475(suggests)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(cannot)-284(be)-283(better)-284(expressed)-283(than)-283(in)-284(the)-283(words)-284(of)-283(the)-284(same)-283(divine)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Teacher:)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 43.218 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(He)-357(that)-357(believeth,)-383(believeth)-357(not)-357(on)-357(me,)-383(but)-357(on)-357(Him)]TJ -48.062 -13.549 Td [(that)-376(sent)-376(me;)-438(and)-376(he)-376(that)-376(seeth)-375(me)-376(seeth)-376(Him)-376(that)-375(sent)-376(me.)-627(I)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(am)-248(come,)-248(a)-248(light)-248(into)-248(the)-248(world,)-248(that)-248(whosoever)-248(believeth)-248(on)-247(me)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(should)-338(not)-338(abide)-338(in)-338(darkness.)-514(And)-338(if)-338(any)-338(man)-338(hear)-338(my)-338(words,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-384(believe)-383(not,)-418(I)-383(judge)-384(him)-384(not;)-450(for)-384(I)-384(came)-383(not)-384(to)-384(judge)-383(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(world,)-256(but)-255(to)-254(save)-255(the)-255(world.)-264(He)-254(that)-255(rejecteth)-255(me,)-256(and)-254(receiveth)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-327(my)-326(words,)-346(hath)-327(one)-326(that)-327(judgeth)-326(him;)-365(the)-327(word)-326(that)-327(I)-326(have)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(spoken,)-250(the)-250(same)-250(shall)-250(judge)-250(him)-250(in)-250(the)-250(last)-250(day.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 211.2 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -199.244 -13.55 Td [(THE)-250(END.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2117 0 obj <<
/Length 96        
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Footnotes)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2122 0 obj <<
/Length 32        
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
endstream
endobj
2125 0 obj <<
/Length 226       
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 518.175 Td [(***END)-500(OF)-500(THE)-500(PROJECT)-500(GUTENBERG)-500(EBOOK)-500(THE)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(SUPERNATURAL)-500(IN)-500(THE)-500(NEW)-500(TESTAMENT***)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2129 0 obj <<
/Length 32        
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
endstream
endobj
2136 0 obj <<
/Length 405       
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(Credits)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -37.877 Td [(August)-250(19,)-250(2014)]TJ 43.637 -19.003 Td [(Project)-250(Gutenberg)-250(TEI)-250(edition)-250(1)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Produced)-335(by)-335(David)-335(King,)-356(and)-335(the)-335(Online)-334(Distributed)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Proofreading)-250(Team)-250(at)-250(<http://www.pgdp.net/>.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2139 0 obj <<
/Length 32        
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
endstream
endobj
2147 0 obj <<
/Length 3215      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 46.771 479.321 Td [(A)-250(Word)-250(from)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -32.422 Td [(This)-250(file)-250(should)-250(be)-250(named)-250(46630-pdf.pdf)-250(or)-250(46630-pdf.zip.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(This)-291(and)-291(all)-291(associated)-291(files)-291(of)-291(various)-291(formats)-291(will)-291(be)-290(found)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(in:)]TJ/F16 9.8629 Tf 19.637 -22.64 Td [(http://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/4/6/6/3/46630/)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -7.681 -23.368 Td [(Updated)-447(editions)-446(will)-447(replace)-447(the)-447(previous)-446(one)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 220.746 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.782 0 Td [(the)-447(old)]TJ -248.484 -13.549 Td [(editions)-250(will)-250(be)-250(renamed.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(Creating)-305(the)-304(works)-305(from)-304(print)-305(editions)-305(not)-304(protected)-305(by)-304(U.S.)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(copyright)-245(law)-245(means)-245(that)-245(no)-245(one)-245(owns)-245(a)-245(United)-245(States)-244(copyright)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-439(these)-438(works,)-486(so)-439(the)-439(Foundation)-438(\050and)-439(you!\051)-816(can)-439(copy)-438(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(distribute)-364(it)-365(in)-364(the)-365(United)-364(States)-364(without)-365(permission)-364(and)-364(with-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(out)-406(paying)-406(copyright)-406(royalties.)-718(Special)-406(rules,)-445(set)-406(forth)-406(in)-405(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(General)-280(Terms)-281(of)-280(Use)-280(part)-280(of)-281(this)-280(license,)-288(apply)-280(to)-280(copying)-280(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distributing)-274(Project)-273(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 133.233 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.674 0 Td [(electronic)-274(works)-273(to)-273(protect)-274(the)]TJ -146.907 -13.549 Td [(Project)-285(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 80.06 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.798 0 Td [(concept)-285(and)-285(trademark.)-354(Project)-285(Gutenberg)]TJ -93.858 -13.55 Td [(is)-267(a)-266(registered)-267(trademark,)-271(and)-266(may)-267(not)-266(be)-267(used)-267(if)-266(you)-267(charge)-266(for)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-372(ebooks,)-402(unless)-371(you)-372(receive)-371(specific)-372(permission.)-614(If)-372(you)-371(do)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(not)-231(charge)-230(anything)-231(for)-231(copies)-230(of)-231(this)-231(ebook,)-234(complying)-231(with)-230(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(rules)-194(is)-195(very)-194(easy.)-231(You)-195(may)-194(use)-194(this)-194(ebook)-195(for)-194(nearly)-194(any)-194(purpose)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(such)-297(as)-297(creation)-297(of)-297(derivative)-296(works,)-309(reports,)-309(performances)-296(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(research.)-315(They)-271(may)-272(be)-271(modified)-272(and)-271(printed)-272(and)-271(given)-272(away)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 269.721 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -269.721 -13.549 Td [(you)-206(may)-206(do)-206(practically)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 101.092 0 Td [(anything)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 40.429 0 Td [(in)-206(the)-206(United)-206(States)-206(with)-206(ebooks)]TJ -141.521 -13.549 Td [(not)-265(protected)-266(by)-265(U.S.)-266(copyright)-265(law.)-296(Redistribution)-266(is)-265(subject)-265(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(trademark)-250(license,)-250(especially)-250(commercial)-250(redistribution.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2159 0 obj <<
/Length 3267      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 18.9589 Tf 93.543 479.321 Td [(The)-250(Full)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)-250(License)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 0 -31.684 Td [(Please)-250(read)-250(this)-250(before)-250(you)-250(distribute)-250(or)-250(use)-250(this)-250(work.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 11.956 -13.55 Td [(To)-269(protect)-269(the)-268(Project)-269(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 144.428 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.623 0 Td [(mission)-269(of)-269(promoting)-268(the)]TJ -170.007 -13.549 Td [(free)-225(distribution)-225(of)-226(electronic)-225(works,)-230(by)-225(using)-225(or)-225(distributing)-225(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(work)-304(\050or)-304(any)-303(other)-304(work)-304(associated)-304(in)-303(any)-304(way)-304(with)-304(the)-303(phrase)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.549 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Project)-270(Gutenberg)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 79.894 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(\051,)-275(you)-269(agree)-270(to)-270(comply)-269(with)-270(all)-269(the)-270(terms)-270(of)]TJ -89.582 -13.549 Td [(the)-268(Full)-269(Project)-268(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 116.649 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.618 0 Td [(License)-268(\050available)-268(with)-269(this)-268(file)-268(or)]TJ -130.267 -13.55 Td [(online)-250(at)-250(http://www.gutenberg.org/license\051.)]TJ/F16 15.7808 Tf 0 -35.486 Td [(Section)-250(1.)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 15.58 -44.421 Td [(General)-255(Terms)-254(of)-255(Use)-255(&)-254(Redistributing)-255(Project)]TJ 45.013 -17.095 Td [(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 13.1507 Tf 55.509 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 16.415 0 Td [(electronic)-268(works)]TJ -132.517 -41.803 Td [(1.A.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -25.902 Td [(By)-330(reading)-331(or)-330(using)-331(any)-330(part)-331(of)-330(this)-331(Project)-330(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 245.138 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.296 0 Td [(elec-)]TJ -259.434 -13.549 Td [(tronic)-302(work,)-315(you)-303(indicate)-302(that)-302(you)-302(have)-302(read,)-315(understand,)-315(agree)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-198(and)-197(accept)-198(all)-197(the)-198(terms)-198(of)-197(this)-198(license)-197(and)-198(intellectual)-197(property)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(\050trademark/copyright\051)-211(agreement.)-237(If)-211(you)-211(do)-211(not)-211(agree)-211(to)-211(abide)-211(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(all)-270(the)-271(terms)-270(of)-270(this)-271(agreement,)-275(you)-270(must)-271(cease)-270(using)-270(and)-270(return)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-262(destroy)-263(all)-262(copies)-262(of)-262(Project)-263(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 183.192 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.552 0 Td [(electronic)-262(works)-263(in)]TJ -196.744 -13.549 Td [(your)-379(possession.)-639(If)-379(you)-380(paid)-379(a)-380(fee)-379(for)-380(obtaining)-379(a)-380(copy)-379(of)-379(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(access)-269(to)-270(a)-269(Project)-270(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 129.903 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.63 0 Td [(electronic)-269(work)-270(and)-269(you)-270(do)-269(not)]TJ -143.533 -13.55 Td [(agree)-206(to)-206(be)-205(bound)-206(by)-206(the)-206(terms)-206(of)-205(this)-206(agreement,)-215(you)-206(may)-205(obtain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-304(refund)-304(from)-304(the)-304(person)-304(or)-304(entity)-304(to)-304(whom)-304(you)-304(paid)-304(the)-303(fee)-304(as)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(set)-250(forth)-250(in)-250(paragraph)-250(1.E.8.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2167 0 obj <<
/Length 4405      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(The)-250(Full)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)-250(License)-9893(467)]TJ
0 g 0 G
/F16 13.1507 Tf 0 -30.759 Td [(1.B.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -27.866 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Project)-352(Gutenberg)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 80.79 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.681 0 Td [(is)-352(a)-352(registered)-351(trademark.)-556(It)-351(may)-352(only)-352(be)]TJ -94.315 -13.549 Td [(used)-395(on)-394(or)-395(associated)-394(in)-395(any)-395(way)-394(with)-395(an)-394(electronic)-395(work)-394(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(people)-347(who)-346(agree)-347(to)-346(be)-347(bound)-347(by)-346(the)-347(terms)-346(of)-347(this)-346(agreement.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(There)-255(are)-255(a)-256(few)-255(things)-255(that)-255(you)-255(can)-256(do)-255(with)-255(most)-255(Project)-255(Guten-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(berg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 19.386 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.74 0 Td [(electronic)-371(works)-371(even)-372(without)-371(complying)-371(with)-371(the)-371(full)]TJ -34.126 -13.549 Td [(terms)-362(of)-362(this)-361(agreement.)-586(See)-362(paragraph)-362(1.C)-361(below.)-586(There)-361(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-330(lot)-331(of)-330(things)-330(you)-331(can)-330(do)-330(with)-331(Project)-330(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 223.321 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.295 0 Td [(electronic)]TJ -237.616 -13.549 Td [(works)-193(if)-192(you)-193(follow)-192(the)-193(terms)-193(of)-192(this)-193(agreement)-192(and)-193(help)-192(preserve)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(free)-284(future)-283(access)-284(to)-283(Project)-284(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 171.772 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.784 0 Td [(electronic)-284(works.)-350(See)]TJ -185.556 -13.549 Td [(paragraph)-250(1.E)-250(below.)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 0 -43.303 Td [(1.C.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -27.866 Td [(The)-247(Project)-247(Gutenberg)-247(Literary)-247(Archive)-247(Foundation)-247(\050)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 233.699 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(the)-247(Foun-)]TJ -238.542 -13.549 Td [(dation)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 27.273 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.058 0 Td [(or)-386(PGLAF\051,)-387(owns)-386(a)-386(compilation)-386(copyright)-387(in)-386(the)-386(col-)]TJ -36.331 -13.549 Td [(lection)-306(of)-305(Project)-306(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 125.734 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.024 0 Td [(electronic)-306(works.)-416(Nearly)-306(all)-305(the)]TJ -139.758 -13.549 Td [(individual)-233(works)-232(in)-233(the)-233(collection)-232(are)-233(in)-233(the)-232(public)-233(domain)-233(in)-232(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(United)-266(States.)-296(If)-266(an)-266(individual)-265(work)-266(is)-265(unprotected)-266(by)-265(copyright)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(law)-230(in)-229(the)-230(United)-230(States)-229(and)-230(you)-229(are)-230(located)-230(in)-229(the)-230(United)-229(States,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(we)-196(do)-197(not)-196(claim)-196(a)-197(right)-196(to)-196(prevent)-197(you)-196(from)-196(copying,)-207(distributing,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(performing,)-231(displaying)-226(or)-226(creating)-226(derivative)-226(works)-226(based)-226(on)-225(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(work)-232(as)-231(long)-232(as)-231(all)-232(references)-231(to)-232(Project)-231(Gutenberg)-232(are)-231(removed.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Of)-188(course,)-200(we)-187(hope)-188(that)-187(you)-187(will)-188(support)-187(the)-188(Project)-187(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 269.939 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -269.939 -13.55 Td [(mission)-334(of)-334(promoting)-335(free)-334(access)-334(to)-334(electronic)-334(works)-334(by)-334(freely)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(sharing)-212(Project)-211(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 113.685 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.999 0 Td [(works)-212(in)-211(compliance)-212(with)-211(the)-212(terms)]TJ -126.684 -13.549 Td [(of)-441(this)-441(agreement)-441(for)-441(keeping)-441(the)-441(Project)-441(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 241.5 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.501 0 Td [(name)]TJ -257.001 -13.549 Td [(associated)-262(with)-262(the)-262(work.)-286(You)-262(can)-262(easily)-262(comply)-262(with)-262(the)-262(terms)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-283(this)-284(agreement)-283(by)-283(keeping)-284(this)-283(work)-283(in)-284(the)-283(same)-283(format)-283(with)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(its)-287(attached)-287(full)-287(Project)-287(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 151.285 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.821 0 Td [(License)-287(when)-287(you)-287(share)-287(it)]TJ -165.106 -13.549 Td [(without)-250(charge)-250(with)-250(others.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2177 0 obj <<
/Length 3744      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(468)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
/F16 13.1507 Tf 0 -30.759 Td [(1.D.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -27.581 Td [(The)-468(copyright)-467(laws)-468(of)-467(the)-468(place)-467(where)-468(you)-467(are)-468(located)-467(also)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(govern)-267(what)-268(you)-267(can)-267(do)-268(with)-267(this)-267(work.)-302(Copyright)-268(laws)-267(in)-267(most)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(countries)-366(are)-366(in)-366(a)-366(constant)-366(state)-366(of)-366(change.)-598(If)-366(you)-366(are)-366(outside)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-394(United)-394(States,)-430(check)-395(the)-394(laws)-394(of)-394(your)-394(country)-394(in)-394(addition)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-439(the)-440(terms)-439(of)-439(this)-439(agreement)-440(before)-439(downloading,)-486(copying,)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(displaying,)-243(performing,)-243(distributing)-241(or)-241(creating)-240(derivative)-241(works)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(based)-268(on)-269(this)-268(work)-269(or)-268(any)-269(other)-268(Project)-269(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 221.57 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.62 0 Td [(work.)-305(The)]TJ -235.19 -13.549 Td [(Foundation)-344(makes)-343(no)-344(representations)-343(concerning)-344(the)-343(copyright)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(status)-250(of)-250(any)-250(work)-250(in)-250(any)-250(country)-250(outside)-250(the)-250(United)-250(States.)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 0 -42.789 Td [(1.E.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -27.581 Td [(Unless)-250(you)-250(have)-250(removed)-250(all)-250(references)-250(to)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg:)]TJ 0 -25.399 Td [(1.E.1.)]TJ 0 -25.399 Td [(The)-259(following)-260(sentence,)-261(with)-260(active)-259(links)-259(to,)-262(or)-259(other)-259(immediate)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(access)-465(to,)-520(the)-465(full)-466(Project)-465(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 170.488 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.769 0 Td [(License)-465(must)-466(appear)]TJ -186.257 -13.549 Td [(prominently)-274(whenever)-275(any)-274(copy)-274(of)-275(a)-274(Project)-274(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 244.529 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.683 0 Td [(work)]TJ -258.212 -13.549 Td [(\050any)-421(work)-422(on)-421(which)-421(the)-422(phrase)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 148.755 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Project)-421(Gutenberg)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 81.549 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.44 0 Td [(appears,)]TJ -244.587 -13.55 Td [(or)-347(with)-346(which)-347(the)-346(phrase)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 115.849 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Project)-346(Gutenberg)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 80.732 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.624 0 Td [(is)-346(associated\051)-347(is)]TJ -210.049 -13.549 Td [(accessed,)-250(displayed,)-250(performed,)-250(viewed,)-250(copied)-250(or)-250(distributed:)]TJ/F16 9.8629 Tf 19.637 -23.58 Td [(This)-321(ebook)-321(is)-321(for)-321(the)-321(use)-321(of)-321(anyone)-321(anywhere)-321(in)-321(the)-321(United)]TJ 0 -12.822 Td [(States)-313(and)-312(most)-313(other)-312(parts)-313(of)-313(the)-312(world)-313(at)-312(no)-313(cost)-313(and)-312(with)]TJ 0 -12.822 Td [(almost)-324(no)-324(restrictions)-324(whatsoever.)-473(You)-324(may)-324(copy)-324(it,)-343(give)-324(it)]TJ 0 -12.822 Td [(away)-225(or)-225(re-use)-226(it)-225(under)-225(the)-225(terms)-225(of)-226(the)-225(Project)-225(Gutenberg)-225(Li-)]TJ 0 -12.822 Td [(cense)-215(included)-216(with)-215(this)-216(ebook)-215(or)-215(online)-216(at)-215(http://www.guten-)]TJ 0 -12.822 Td [(berg.org.)-547(If)-348(you)-349(are)-349(not)-349(located)-349(in)-349(the)-349(United)-349(States,)-373(you'll)]TJ 0 -12.821 Td [(have)-296(to)-296(check)-296(the)-296(laws)-296(of)-296(the)-296(country)-296(where)-296(you)-296(are)-296(located)]TJ 0 -12.822 Td [(before)-250(using)-250(this)-250(ebook.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2185 0 obj <<
/Length 3382      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(The)-250(Full)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)-250(License)-9893(469)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(1.E.2.)]TJ 0 -27.871 Td [(If)-295(an)-295(individual)-295(Project)-295(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 151.639 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.91 0 Td [(electronic)-295(work)-295(is)-295(derived)]TJ -165.549 -13.55 Td [(from)-245(texts)-245(not)-245(protected)-245(by)-245(U.S.)-245(copyright)-245(law)-245(\050does)-245(not)-244(contain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-273(notice)-273(indicating)-273(that)-273(it)-273(is)-273(posted)-273(with)-273(permission)-273(of)-273(the)-273(copy-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(right)-302(holder\051,)-315(the)-302(work)-303(can)-302(be)-302(copied)-302(and)-302(distributed)-302(to)-302(anyone)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-306(the)-306(United)-306(States)-306(without)-306(paying)-306(any)-306(fees)-306(or)-306(charges.)-418(If)-306(you)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(are)-295(redistributing)-295(or)-295(providing)-296(access)-295(to)-295(a)-295(work)-295(with)-295(the)-295(phrase)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 0 -13.55 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.844 0 Td [(Project)-324(Gutenberg)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 80.486 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.378 0 Td [(associated)-324(with)-324(or)-324(appearing)-324(on)-324(the)-324(work,)]TJ -93.708 -13.549 Td [(you)-445(must)-445(comply)-446(either)-445(with)-445(the)-445(requirements)-445(of)-445(paragraphs)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(1.E.1)-258(through)-258(1.E.7)-258(or)-258(obtain)-258(permission)-258(for)-258(the)-258(use)-258(of)-258(the)-258(work)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-213(the)-213(Project)-213(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 113.009 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.015 0 Td [(trademark)-213(as)-213(set)-213(forth)-213(in)-213(paragraphs)]TJ -126.024 -13.549 Td [(1.E.8)-250(or)-250(1.E.9.)]TJ 0 -41.511 Td [(1.E.3.)]TJ 0 -27.872 Td [(If)-344(an)-343(individual)-344(Project)-343(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 153.755 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.439 0 Td [(electronic)-344(work)-343(is)-344(posted)]TJ -168.194 -13.549 Td [(with)-351(the)-350(permission)-351(of)-351(the)-351(copyright)-350(holder,)-376(your)-351(use)-351(and)-350(dis-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tribution)-257(must)-258(comply)-257(with)-257(both)-258(paragraphs)-257(1.E.1)-257(through)-257(1.E.7)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-301(any)-301(additional)-301(terms)-301(imposed)-301(by)-301(the)-301(copyright)-301(holder.)-402(Ad-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ditional)-256(terms)-256(will)-256(be)-255(linked)-256(to)-256(the)-256(Project)-256(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 233.221 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.482 0 Td [(License)]TJ -246.703 -13.549 Td [(for)-267(all)-267(works)-267(posted)-268(with)-267(the)-267(permission)-267(of)-267(the)-267(copyright)-267(holder)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(found)-250(at)-250(the)-250(beginning)-250(of)-250(this)-250(work.)]TJ 0 -41.511 Td [(1.E.4.)]TJ 0 -27.871 Td [(Do)-275(not)-275(unlink)-275(or)-274(detach)-275(or)-275(remove)-275(the)-275(full)-275(Project)-274(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 269.939 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -269.939 -13.55 Td [(License)-330(terms)-329(from)-330(this)-329(work,)-350(or)-329(any)-330(files)-330(containing)-329(a)-330(part)-329(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(this)-185(work)-185(or)-185(any)-185(other)-185(work)-185(associated)-185(with)-185(Project)-185(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 267.212 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.691 0 Td [(.)]TJ -277.903 -41.511 Td [(1.E.5.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2194 0 obj <<
/Length 3606      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(470)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Do)-457(not)-457(copy,)-508(display,)-509(perform,)-508(distribute)-457(or)-457(redistribute)-456(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(electronic)-441(work,)-488(or)-441(any)-441(part)-441(of)-440(this)-441(electronic)-441(work,)-488(without)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(prominently)-258(displaying)-257(the)-258(sentence)-258(set)-257(forth)-258(in)-258(paragraph)-257(1.E.1)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(with)-394(active)-395(links)-394(or)-395(immediate)-394(access)-394(to)-395(the)-394(full)-395(terms)-394(of)-394(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Project)-250(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 79.68 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.418 0 Td [(License.)]TJ -93.098 -38.607 Td [(1.E.6.)]TJ 0 -26.259 Td [(You)-475(may)-476(convert)-475(to)-476(and)-475(distribute)-476(this)-475(work)-476(in)-475(any)-475(binary,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(compressed,)-287(marked)-280(up,)-287(nonproprietary)-280(or)-280(proprietary)-279(form,)-287(in-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cluding)-234(any)-234(word)-234(processing)-233(or)-234(hypertext)-234(form.)-245(However,)-237(if)-233(you)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(provide)-318(access)-318(to)-318(or)-317(distribute)-318(copies)-318(of)-318(a)-318(Project)-317(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 269.939 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -269.939 -13.55 Td [(work)-462(in)-462(a)-461(format)-462(other)-462(than)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 136.26 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Plain)-462(Vanilla)-462(ASCII)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 93.104 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 9.881 0 Td [(or)-462(other)]TJ -244.088 -13.549 Td [(format)-284(used)-284(in)-284(the)-284(official)-284(version)-284(posted)-284(on)-284(the)-284(official)-283(Project)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 46.048 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.833 0 Td [(web)-288(site)-288(\050http://www.gutenberg.org\051,)-298(you)-288(must,)-297(at)]TJ -59.881 -13.549 Td [(no)-357(additional)-357(cost,)-383(fee)-357(or)-357(expense)-357(to)-357(the)-357(user,)-384(provide)-357(a)-356(copy,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(a)-380(means)-380(of)-380(exporting)-379(a)-380(copy,)-412(or)-380(a)-380(means)-380(of)-380(obtaining)-380(a)-379(copy)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(upon)-313(request,)-328(of)-313(the)-313(work)-313(in)-312(its)-313(original)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 181.09 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Plain)-313(Vanilla)-313(ASCII)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 89.853 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -275.786 -13.55 Td [(or)-248(other)-247(form.)-250(Any)-247(alternate)-248(format)-248(must)-247(include)-248(the)-248(full)-247(Project)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 46.048 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.418 0 Td [(License)-250(as)-250(specified)-250(in)-250(paragraph)-250(1.E.1.)]TJ -59.466 -38.608 Td [(1.E.7.)]TJ 0 -26.258 Td [(Do)-450(not)-450(charge)-449(a)-450(fee)-450(for)-450(access)-449(to,)-500(viewing,)-500(displaying,)-499(per-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forming,)-240(copying)-237(or)-237(distributing)-238(any)-237(Project)-237(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 240.689 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.279 0 Td [(works)]TJ -253.968 -13.549 Td [(unless)-250(you)-250(comply)-250(with)-250(paragraph)-250(1.E.8)-250(or)-250(1.E.9.)]TJ 0 -38.608 Td [(1.E.8.)]TJ 0 -26.258 Td [(You)-440(may)-440(charge)-440(a)-439(reasonable)-440(fee)-440(for)-440(copies)-440(of)-440(or)-439(providing)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(access)-361(to)-361(or)-361(distributing)-361(Project)-361(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 192.388 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.629 0 Td [(electronic)-361(works)]TJ -207.017 -13.549 Td [(provided)-250(that)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2201 0 obj <<
/Length 4446      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(The)-250(Full)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)-250(License)-9893(471)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 21.819 -30.759 Td [(You)-218(pay)-218(a)-219(royalty)-218(fee)-218(of)-218(20%)-218(of)-219(the)-218(gross)-218(profits)-218(you)-218(derive)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(from)-212(the)-211(use)-212(of)-212(Project)-211(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 146.666 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13 0 Td [(works)-212(calculated)-211(using)]TJ -159.666 -13.549 Td [(the)-211(method)-210(you)-211(already)-211(use)-211(to)-210(calculate)-211(your)-211(applicable)-210(tax-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(es.)-240(The)-221(fee)-220(is)-220(owed)-221(to)-220(the)-221(owner)-220(of)-221(the)-220(Project)-220(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 248.12 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -248.12 -13.55 Td [(trademark,)-296(but)-287(he)-287(has)-286(agreed)-287(to)-287(donate)-287(royalties)-287(under)-286(this)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(paragraph)-263(to)-263(the)-263(Project)-263(Gutenberg)-263(Literary)-263(Archive)-263(Foun-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dation.)-842(Royalty)-448(payments)-447(must)-448(be)-447(paid)-448(within)-447(60)-447(days)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(following)-365(each)-365(date)-365(on)-366(which)-365(you)-365(prepare)-365(\050or)-365(are)-365(legally)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(required)-473(to)-473(prepare\051)-473(your)-473(periodic)-473(tax)-473(returns.)-919(Royalty)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(payments)-284(should)-284(be)-284(clearly)-284(marked)-284(as)-284(such)-284(and)-284(sent)-283(to)-284(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Project)-350(Gutenberg)-350(Literary)-351(Archive)-350(Foundation)-350(at)-350(the)-350(ad-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dress)-312(specified)-312(in)-312(Section)-312(4,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 128.383 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Information)-312(about)-312(donations)]TJ -133.226 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(the)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)-250(Literary)-250(Archive)-250(Foundation.)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 237.839 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -237.839 -13.549 Td [(You)-425(provide)-425(a)-425(full)-424(refund)-425(of)-425(any)-425(money)-425(paid)-425(by)-425(a)-424(user)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(who)-339(notifies)-339(you)-340(in)-339(writing)-339(\050or)-339(by)-340(e-mail\051)-339(within)-339(30)-339(days)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-343(receipt)-343(that)-343(s/he)-343(does)-344(not)-343(agree)-343(to)-343(the)-343(terms)-343(of)-343(the)-343(full)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Project)-235(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 79.514 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.252 0 Td [(License.)-245(You)-235(must)-234(require)-235(such)-235(a)-235(user)]TJ -92.766 -13.549 Td [(to)-324(return)-324(or)-323(destroy)-324(all)-324(copies)-324(of)-323(the)-324(works)-324(possessed)-324(in)-323(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical)-322(medium)-321(and)-322(discontinue)-321(all)-322(use)-322(of)-321(and)-322(all)-321(access)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(to)-250(other)-250(copies)-250(of)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 158.454 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.418 0 Td [(works.)]TJ -171.872 -13.549 Td [(You)-427(provide,)-472(in)-427(accordance)-428(with)-427(paragraph)-427(1.F.3,)-472(a)-427(full)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(refund)-215(of)-216(any)-215(money)-216(paid)-215(for)-216(a)-215(work)-216(or)-215(a)-216(replacement)-215(copy,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(if)-245(a)-246(defect)-245(in)-245(the)-246(electronic)-245(work)-245(is)-246(discovered)-245(and)-245(reported)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(you)-250(within)-250(90)-250(days)-250(of)-250(receipt)-250(of)-250(the)-250(work.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(You)-278(comply)-279(with)-278(all)-279(other)-278(terms)-279(of)-278(this)-279(agreement)-278(for)-278(free)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(distribution)-250(of)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 144.534 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.418 0 Td [(works.)]TJ -179.77 -34.888 Td [(1.E.9.)]TJ 0 -24.218 Td [(If)-316(you)-315(wish)-316(to)-316(charge)-315(a)-316(fee)-316(or)-315(distribute)-316(a)-316(Project)-315(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 269.938 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -269.938 -13.549 Td [(electronic)-233(work)-233(or)-233(group)-233(of)-234(works)-233(on)-233(different)-233(terms)-233(than)-233(are)-233(set)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(forth)-346(in)-347(this)-346(agreement,)-371(you)-346(must)-346(obtain)-347(permission)-346(in)-346(writing)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(from)-390(both)-390(the)-389(Project)-390(Gutenberg)-390(Literary)-390(Archive)-389(Foundation)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-374(The)-375(Project)-374(Gutenberg)-374(Trademark)-375(LLC,)-374(the)-375(owner)-374(of)-374(the)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2210 0 obj <<
/Length 3616      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(472)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(Project)-339(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 80.654 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.392 0 Td [(trademark.)-518(Contact)-339(the)-339(Foundation)-340(as)-339(set)]TJ -95.046 -13.549 Td [(forth)-250(in)-250(Section)-250(3)-250(below.)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 0 -42.208 Td [(1.F.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 0 -38.661 Td [(1.F.1.)]TJ 0 -25.076 Td [(Project)-362(Gutenberg)-363(volunteers)-362(and)-363(employees)-362(expend)-362(consider-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(able)-318(effort)-318(to)-318(identify,)-336(do)-318(copyright)-318(research)-318(on,)-335(transcribe)-318(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(proofread)-260(works)-260(not)-260(protected)-260(by)-260(U.S.)-260(copyright)-260(law)-260(in)-260(creating)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-205(Project)-204(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 94.747 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 12.923 0 Td [(collection.)-235(Despite)-204(these)-205(efforts,)-214(Project)]TJ -107.67 -13.55 Td [(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 46.048 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.444 0 Td [(electronic)-344(works,)-368(and)-344(the)-344(medium)-344(on)-344(which)-344(they)]TJ -60.492 -13.549 Td [(may)-317(be)-316(stored,)-334(may)-317(contain)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 126.832 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Defects,)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 36.044 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.298 0 Td [(such)-317(as,)-333(but)-317(not)-317(limited)]TJ -176.017 -13.549 Td [(to,)-274(incomplete,)-275(inaccurate)-269(or)-270(corrupt)-269(data,)-275(transcription)-269(errors,)-274(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(copyright)-235(or)-235(other)-234(intellectual)-235(property)-235(infringement,)-238(a)-234(defective)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-210(damaged)-210(disk)-210(or)-211(other)-210(medium,)-218(a)-210(computer)-210(virus,)-218(or)-210(computer)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(codes)-250(that)-250(damage)-250(or)-250(cannot)-250(be)-250(read)-250(by)-250(your)-250(equipment.)]TJ 0 -36.479 Td [(1.F.2.)]TJ 0 -25.076 Td [(LIMITED)-451(WARRANTY,)-451(DISCLAIMER)-451(OF)-451(DAMAGES)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 269.721 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -269.721 -13.549 Td [(Except)-334(for)-334(the)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 67.282 0 Td [(\034)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 4.843 0 Td [(Right)-334(of)-334(Replacement)-335(or)-334(Refund)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 146.08 0 Td [(\035)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 8.489 0 Td [(described)-334(in)]TJ -226.694 -13.549 Td [(paragraph)-328(1.F.3,)-347(the)-328(Project)-327(Gutenberg)-328(Literary)-328(Archive)-327(Foun-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(dation,)-224(the)-218(owner)-218(of)-217(the)-218(Project)-218(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 184.285 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.066 0 Td [(trademark,)-224(and)-218(any)]TJ -197.351 -13.55 Td [(other)-361(party)-361(distributing)-361(a)-361(Project)-361(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 196.632 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.628 0 Td [(electronic)-361(work)]TJ -211.26 -13.549 Td [(under)-320(this)-319(agreement,)-337(disclaim)-320(all)-319(liability)-320(to)-319(you)-320(for)-319(damages,)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(costs)-316(and)-315(expenses,)-333(including)-315(legal)-316(fees.)-447(YOU)-316(AGREE)-315(THAT)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(YOU)-394(HAVE)-394(NO)-395(REMEDIES)-394(FOR)-394(NEGLIGENCE,)-394(STRICT)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(LIABILITY,)-450(BREACH)-449(OF)-450(WARRANTY)-449(OR)-450(BREACH)-449(OF)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(CONTRACT)-234(EXCEPT)-234(THOSE)-234(PROVIDED)-234(IN)-233(PARAGRAPH)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(F3.)-299(YOU)-266(AGREE)-266(THAT)-266(THE)-266(FOUNDATION,)-266(THE)-266(TRADE-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(MARK)-367(OWNER,)-366(AND)-367(ANY)-366(DISTRIBUTOR)-367(UNDER)-366(THIS)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2081 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 985
/Length 11056     
>>
stream
2078 0 2080 119 2077 178 2083 268 2085 387 2082 446 2087 562 2089 681 2086 740 2092 856
2094 975 2091 1034 2096 1124 2098 1243 2095 1302 2100 1418 2102 1537 2099 1596 2104 1686 2106 1805
2107 1864 2103 1923 2109 2013 2108 2132 2111 2210 2114 2251 2116 2276 2118 2395 2112 2453 2115 2511
2121 2577 2120 2696 2124 2733 2126 2852 2123 2910 2128 2976 2127 3095 2130 3132 2133 3173 2135 3196
2131 3315 2134 3373 2138 3439 2137 3558 2140 3595 2143 3636 2146 3681 2144 3821 2141 4045 11 4103
2145 4159 2150 4263 2153 4304 2158 4354 2154 4512 2155 4679 2156 4892 2151 5060 2160 5118 2161 5176
2157 5234 2166 5338 2163 5487 2164 5656 2168 5823 2169 5881 2170 5939 2165 5996 2176 6088 2172 6237
2179 6442 2171 6646 2178 6704 2180 6762 2175 6819 2184 6911 2173 7069 2174 7237 2181 7405 2186 7574
2187 7632 2188 7690 2183 7747 2193 7839 2182 7997 2189 8167 2190 8337 2195 8507 2196 8565 2162 8623
2192 8681 2200 8773 2191 8931 2202 9099 2197 9266 2203 9435 2199 9493 2209 9585 2198 9734 2207 9902
% 2078 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2079 0 R
/Resources 2077 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2063 0 R
>>
% 2080 0 obj
<<
/D [2078 0 R /XYZ 176.111 162.623 null]
>>
% 2077 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2083 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2084 0 R
/Resources 2082 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2063 0 R
>>
% 2085 0 obj
<<
/D [2083 0 R /XYZ 249.319 233.642 null]
>>
% 2082 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F37 246 0 R /F38 247 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2087 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2088 0 R
/Resources 2086 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2090 0 R
>>
% 2089 0 obj
<<
/D [2087 0 R /XYZ 267.894 284.157 null]
>>
% 2086 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F38 247 0 R /F37 246 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2092 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2093 0 R
/Resources 2091 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2090 0 R
>>
% 2094 0 obj
<<
/D [2092 0 R /XYZ 314.354 339.581 null]
>>
% 2091 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2096 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2097 0 R
/Resources 2095 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2090 0 R
>>
% 2098 0 obj
<<
/D [2096 0 R /XYZ 114.662 393.778 null]
>>
% 2095 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F37 246 0 R /F38 247 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2100 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2101 0 R
/Resources 2099 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2090 0 R
>>
% 2102 0 obj
<<
/D [2100 0 R /XYZ 151.539 450.429 null]
>>
% 2099 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2104 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2105 0 R
/Resources 2103 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2090 0 R
>>
% 2106 0 obj
<<
/D [2104 0 R /XYZ 261.928 518.175 null]
>>
% 2107 0 obj
<<
/D [2104 0 R /XYZ 243.722 120.339 null]
>>
% 2103 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2109 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2110 0 R
/Resources 2108 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2090 0 R
>>
% 2108 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2111 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index24) >>
% 2114 0 obj
(Footnotes)
% 2116 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2117 0 R
/Resources 2115 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2119 0 R
>>
% 2118 0 obj
<<
/D [2116 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 2112 0 obj
<<
/D [2116 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 2115 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2121 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2122 0 R
/Resources 2120 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2119 0 R
>>
% 2120 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [ /PDF ]
>>
% 2124 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2125 0 R
/Resources 2123 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2119 0 R
>>
% 2126 0 obj
<<
/D [2124 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 2123 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2128 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2129 0 R
/Resources 2127 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2119 0 R
>>
% 2127 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [ /PDF ]
>>
% 2130 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index25) >>
% 2133 0 obj
(Credits)
% 2135 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2136 0 R
/Resources 2134 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2119 0 R
>>
% 2131 0 obj
<<
/D [2135 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 2134 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2138 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2139 0 R
/Resources 2137 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2119 0 R
>>
% 2137 0 obj
<<
/ProcSet [ /PDF ]
>>
% 2140 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index26) >>
% 2143 0 obj
(A Word from Project Gutenberg)
% 2146 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2147 0 R
/Resources 2145 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2149 0 R
/Annots [ 2144 0 R ]
>>
% 2144 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [66.408 395.011 247.235 403.798]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.gutenberg.org/dirs/4/6/6/3/46630/) >> 
>>
% 2141 0 obj
<<
/D [2146 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 11 0 obj
<<
/D [2146 0 R /XYZ 46.771 111.166 null]
>>
% 2145 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F45 2148 0 R /F31 60 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2150 0 obj
<< /S /GoTo /D (index27) >>
% 2153 0 obj
(The Full Project Gutenberg License)
% 2158 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2159 0 R
/Resources 2157 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2149 0 R
/Annots [ 2154 0 R 2155 0 R 2156 0 R ]
>>
% 2154 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [264.296 377.512 362.159 387.232]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense) >>
>>
% 2155 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [134.147 363.963 280.798 373.683]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.gutenberg.org/license) >> 
>>
% 2156 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [189.881 63.764 215.638 73.484]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1E8) >>
>>
% 2151 0 obj
<<
/D [2158 0 R /XYZ 93.543 529.134 null]
>>
% 2160 0 obj
<<
/D [2158 0 R /XYZ 93.543 363.963 null]
>>
% 2161 0 obj
<<
/D [2158 0 R /XYZ 93.543 254.119 null]
>>
% 2157 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F45 2148 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2166 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2167 0 R
/Resources 2165 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2149 0 R
/Annots [ 2163 0 R 2164 0 R ]
>>
% 2163 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [229.515 420.185 244.973 429.905]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1C) >>
>>
% 2164 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [93.113 365.988 107.96 375.708]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1E) >>
>>
% 2168 0 obj
<<
/D [2166 0 R /XYZ 46.771 529.134 null]
>>
% 2169 0 obj
<<
/D [2166 0 R /XYZ 46.771 354.098 null]
>>
% 2170 0 obj
<<
/D [2166 0 R /XYZ 46.771 66.142 null]
>>
% 2165 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F45 2148 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2176 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2177 0 R
/Resources 2175 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2149 0 R
/Annots [ 2172 0 R 2179 0 R ]
>>
% 2172 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [281.936 116.269 374.173 125.057]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.gutenberg.org) >> 
>>
% 2179 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [93.543 103.447 146.319 112.235]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.gutenberg.org) >> 
>>
% 2171 0 obj
<<
/D [2176 0 R /XYZ 93.543 368.161 null]
>>
% 2178 0 obj
<<
/D [2176 0 R /XYZ 93.543 309.453 null]
>>
% 2180 0 obj
<<
/D [2176 0 R /XYZ 93.543 66.142 null]
>>
% 2175 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F45 2148 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2184 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2185 0 R
/Resources 2183 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2149 0 R
/Annots [ 2173 0 R 2174 0 R 2181 0 R ]
>>
% 2173 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [46.771 379.532 69.801 389.252]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1E1) >>
>>
% 2174 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [46.771 354.572 69.801 362.153]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1E8) >>
>>
% 2181 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [241.791 255.953 264.82 265.673]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1E1) >>
>>
% 2186 0 obj
<<
/D [2184 0 R /XYZ 46.771 340.932 null]
>>
% 2187 0 obj
<<
/D [2184 0 R /XYZ 46.771 188.116 null]
>>
% 2188 0 obj
<<
/D [2184 0 R /XYZ 46.771 91.635 null]
>>
% 2183 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F45 2148 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2193 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2194 0 R
/Resources 2192 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2149 0 R
/Annots [ 2182 0 R 2189 0 R 2190 0 R ]
>>
% 2182 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [351.144 488.699 374.173 498.419]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1E1) >>
>>
% 2189 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [301.143 247.693 326.899 257.413]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1E1) >>
>>
% 2190 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [246.554 155.728 269.583 165.448]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1E8) >>
>>
% 2195 0 obj
<<
/D [2193 0 R /XYZ 93.543 449.251 null]
>>
% 2196 0 obj
<<
/D [2193 0 R /XYZ 93.543 235.344 null]
>>
% 2162 0 obj
<<
/D [2193 0 R /XYZ 93.543 143.379 null]
>>
% 2192 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F45 2148 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2200 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2201 0 R
/Resources 2199 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2204 0 R
/Annots [ 2191 0 R 2202 0 R 2197 0 R ]
>>
% 2191 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [149.087 366.767 327.401 376.508]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense4) >>
>>
% 2202 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [46.771 353.207 311.273 362.959]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense4) >>
>>
% 2197 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [272.441 244.813 294.87 254.533]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1F3) >>
>>
% 2203 0 obj
<<
/D [2200 0 R /XYZ 46.771 166.398 null]
>>
% 2199 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F45 2148 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2209 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2210 0 R
/Resources 2208 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2204 0 R
/Annots [ 2198 0 R 2207 0 R ]
>>
% 2198 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [128.692 504.484 169.601 511.968]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense3) >>
>>
% 2207 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [93.543 185.707 163.162 195.427]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1F3) >>
>>
endstream
endobj
2219 0 obj <<
/Length 3178      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(The)-250(Full)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)-250(License)-9893(473)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(AGREEMENT)-376(WILL)-375(NOT)-376(BE)-376(LIABLE)-375(TO)-376(YOU)-376(FOR)-375(AC-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(TUAL,)-210(DIRECT,)-210(INDIRECT,)-210(CONSEQUENTIAL,)-209(PUNITIVE)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(OR)-223(INCIDENTAL)-223(DAMAGES)-224(EVEN)-223(IF)-223(YOU)-223(GIVE)-223(NOTICE)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(OF)-250(THE)-250(POSSIBILITY)-250(OF)-250(SUCH)-250(DAMAGE.)]TJ 0 -35.705 Td [(1.F.3.)]TJ 0 -24.645 Td [(LIMITED)-421(RIGHT)-421(OF)-422(REPLACEMENT)-421(OR)-421(REFUND)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 257.859 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.506 0 Td [(If)]TJ -273.365 -13.549 Td [(you)-434(discover)-434(a)-434(defect)-434(in)-434(this)-434(electronic)-434(work)-434(within)-434(90)-433(days)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(of)-335(receiving)-334(it,)-356(you)-335(can)-335(receive)-334(a)-335(refund)-335(of)-334(the)-335(money)-335(\050if)-334(any\051)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(you)-369(paid)-369(for)-369(it)-370(by)-369(sending)-369(a)-369(written)-369(explanation)-369(to)-369(the)-369(person)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(you)-430(received)-430(the)-431(work)-430(from.)-790(If)-431(you)-430(received)-430(the)-430(work)-430(on)-430(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(physical)-231(medium,)-236(you)-231(must)-231(return)-232(the)-231(medium)-232(with)-231(your)-231(written)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(explanation.)-706(The)-402(person)-402(or)-402(entity)-402(that)-402(provided)-402(you)-402(with)-401(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(defective)-301(work)-301(may)-301(elect)-300(to)-301(provide)-301(a)-301(replacement)-301(copy)-301(in)-300(lieu)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-305(a)-305(refund.)-416(If)-305(you)-306(received)-305(the)-305(work)-305(electronically,)-319(the)-305(person)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(or)-348(entity)-347(providing)-348(it)-347(to)-348(you)-347(may)-348(choose)-347(to)-348(give)-347(you)-348(a)-347(second)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(opportunity)-226(to)-226(receive)-225(the)-226(work)-226(electronically)-225(in)-226(lieu)-226(of)-226(a)-225(refund.)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(If)-315(the)-315(second)-315(copy)-315(is)-315(also)-315(defective,)-331(you)-315(may)-315(demand)-315(a)-314(refund)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(in)-250(writing)-250(without)-250(further)-250(opportunities)-250(to)-250(fix)-250(the)-250(problem.)]TJ 0 -35.705 Td [(1.F.4.)]TJ 0 -24.645 Td [(Except)-258(for)-258(the)-259(limited)-258(right)-258(of)-258(replacement)-259(or)-258(refund)-258(set)-258(forth)-258(in)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(paragraph)-225(1.F.3,)-230(this)-225(work)-226(is)-225(provided)-225(to)-225(you)-225('AS-IS,')-225(WITH)-225(NO)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(OTHER)-346(WARRANTIES)-346(OF)-345(ANY)-346(KIND,)-346(EXPRESS)-346(OR)-345(IM-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(PLIED,)-173(INCLUDING)-172(BUT)-172(NOT)-173(LIMITED)-172(TO)-172(WARRANTIES)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(OF)-190(MERCHANTIBILITY)-190(OR)-190(FITNESS)-190(FOR)-190(ANY)-190(PURPOSE.)]TJ 0 -35.704 Td [(1.F.5.)]TJ 0 -24.646 Td [(Some)-414(states)-414(do)-415(not)-414(allow)-414(disclaimers)-414(of)-414(certain)-414(implied)-414(war-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ranties)-220(or)-220(the)-220(exclusion)-220(or)-220(limitation)-220(of)-220(certain)-220(types)-220(of)-220(damages.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2227 0 obj <<
/Length 3493      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(474)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(If)-217(any)-217(disclaimer)-217(or)-218(limitation)-217(set)-217(forth)-217(in)-217(this)-217(agreement)-217(violates)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-302(law)-303(of)-302(the)-302(state)-302(applicable)-302(to)-303(this)-302(agreement,)-315(the)-302(agreement)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(shall)-377(be)-377(interpreted)-377(to)-377(make)-377(the)-377(maximum)-377(disclaimer)-377(or)-377(limi-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tation)-367(permitted)-366(by)-367(the)-366(applicable)-367(state)-367(law.)-599(The)-367(invalidity)-366(or)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(unenforceability)-192(of)-192(any)-192(provision)-192(of)-192(this)-192(agreement)-192(shall)-192(not)-191(void)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-250(remaining)-250(provisions.)]TJ 0 -34.869 Td [(1.F.6.)]TJ 0 -24.209 Td [(INDEMNITY)]TJ/F20 10.9091 Tf 65.981 0 Td [(\024)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.092 0 Td [(You)-383(agree)-384(to)-383(indemnify)-384(and)-383(hold)-383(the)-384(Foun-)]TJ -81.073 -13.55 Td [(dation,)-554(the)-494(trademark)-493(owner,)-555(any)-493(agent)-494(or)-493(employee)-494(of)-493(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(Foundation,)-494(anyone)-445(providing)-445(copies)-445(of)-445(Project)-445(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 269.939 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -269.939 -13.549 Td [(electronic)-436(works)-436(in)-437(accordance)-436(with)-436(this)-436(agreement,)-483(and)-436(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(volunteers)-266(associated)-266(with)-266(the)-266(production,)-270(promotion)-266(and)-265(distri-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(bution)-307(of)-308(Project)-307(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 123.981 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.043 0 Td [(electronic)-307(works,)-322(harmless)-307(from)]TJ -138.024 -13.55 Td [(all)-336(liability,)-358(costs)-335(and)-336(expenses,)-358(including)-336(legal)-336(fees,)-357(that)-336(arise)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(directly)-263(or)-263(indirectly)-263(from)-264(any)-263(of)-263(the)-263(following)-263(which)-263(you)-263(do)-263(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(cause)-188(to)-189(occur:)-219(\050a\051)-189(distribution)-188(of)-189(this)-188(or)-189(any)-188(Project)-188(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 269.939 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -269.939 -13.549 Td [(work,)-413(\050b\051)-381(alteration,)-413(modification,)-414(or)-380(additions)-381(or)-381(deletions)-380(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(any)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 98.16 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.418 0 Td [(work,)-250(and)-250(\050c\051)-250(any)-250(Defect)-250(you)-250(cause.)]TJ/F16 15.7808 Tf -111.578 -46.635 Td [(Section)-250(2.)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 32.422 -45.398 Td [(Information)-260(about)-259(the)-260(Mission)-260(of)-260(Project)]TJ 73.695 -17.096 Td [(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 13.1507 Tf 55.509 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -161.626 -26.391 Td [(Project)-400(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 81.319 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.057 0 Td [(is)-400(synonymous)-400(with)-401(the)-400(free)-400(distribution)]TJ -96.376 -13.549 Td [(of)-284(electronic)-284(works)-284(in)-285(formats)-284(readable)-284(by)-284(the)-284(widest)-284(variety)-284(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(computers)-351(including)-350(obsolete,)-376(old,)-376(middle-aged)-351(and)-351(new)-350(com-)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(puters.)-328(It)-277(exists)-276(because)-276(of)-276(the)-276(efforts)-276(of)-276(hundreds)-276(of)-276(volunteers)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(donations)-250(from)-250(people)-250(in)-250(all)-250(walks)-250(of)-250(life.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2234 0 obj <<
/Length 3551      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(The)-250(Full)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)-250(License)-9893(475)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(Volunteers)-162(and)-163(financial)-162(support)-162(to)-163(provide)-162(volunteers)-162(with)-162(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(assistance)-198(they)-199(need,)-209(is)-198(critical)-198(to)-199(reaching)-198(Project)-198(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 263.732 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.691 0 Td [('s)]TJ -274.423 -13.549 Td [(goals)-309(and)-308(ensuring)-309(that)-309(the)-308(Project)-309(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 203.205 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.058 0 Td [(collection)-309(will)]TJ -217.263 -13.549 Td [(remain)-382(freely)-381(available)-382(for)-381(generations)-382(to)-382(come.)-644(In)-382(2001,)-414(the)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Project)-350(Gutenberg)-351(Literary)-350(Archive)-350(Foundation)-351(was)-350(created)-350(to)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(provide)-302(a)-303(secure)-302(and)-302(permanent)-303(future)-302(for)-302(Project)-302(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 269.939 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -269.939 -13.549 Td [(and)-301(future)-301(generations.)-404(To)-301(learn)-302(more)-301(about)-301(the)-301(Project)-301(Guten-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(berg)-487(Literary)-487(Archive)-487(Foundation)-487(and)-487(how)-487(your)-487(efforts)-487(and)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(donations)-225(can)-225(help,)-229(see)-225(Sections)-225(3)-225(and)-224(4)-225(and)-225(the)-225(Foundation)-224(web)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(page)-250(at)-250(http://www.pglaf.org.)]TJ/F16 15.7808 Tf 0 -48.497 Td [(Section)-250(3.)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 10.376 -47.259 Td [(Information)-253(about)-253(the)-253(Project)-253(Gutenberg)-254(Literary)]TJ 76.986 -17.096 Td [(Archive)-276(Foundation)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -87.362 -27.398 Td [(The)-438(Project)-439(Gutenberg)-438(Literary)-438(Archive)-439(Foundation)-438(is)-438(a)-438(non)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(profit)-511(501\050c\051\0503\051)-511(educational)-510(corporation)-511(organized)-511(under)-510(the)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(laws)-248(of)-248(the)-248(state)-247(of)-248(Mississippi)-248(and)-248(granted)-248(tax)-248(exempt)-248(status)-247(by)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-319(Internal)-319(Revenue)-319(Service.)-457(The)-319(Foundation's)-319(EIN)-319(or)-318(federal)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tax)-337(identification)-336(number)-337(is)-337(64-6221541.)-510(Its)-336(501\050c\051\0503\051)-337(letter)-336(is)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(posted)-228(at)-228(http://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/pglaf.)-242(Contribu-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tions)-313(to)-314(the)-313(Project)-313(Gutenberg)-314(Literary)-313(Archive)-313(Foundation)-313(are)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tax)-328(deductible)-329(to)-328(the)-328(full)-329(extent)-328(permitted)-328(by)-329(U.S.)-328(federal)-328(laws)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(and)-250(your)-250(state's)-250(laws.)]TJ 11.956 -13.701 Td [(The)-477(Foundation's)-477(principal)-477(office)-477(is)-477(in)-477(Fairbanks,)-533(Alaska,)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(with)-519(the)-520(mailing)-519(address:)-789(PO)-519(Box)-519(750175,)-587(Fairbanks,)-586(AK)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(99775,)-219(but)-212(its)-212(vol)1(unteers)-212(and)-212(employees)-211(are)-212(scattered)-211(throughout)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(numerous)-326(locations.)-479(Its)-326(business)-326(office)-327(is)-326(located)-326(at)-326(809)-326(North)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(1500)-359(West,)-386(Salt)-358(Lake)-359(City,)-386(UT)-359(84116,)-386(\050801\051)-359(596-1887,)-385(email)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(business@pglaf.org.)-409(Email)-302(contact)-303(links)-303(and)-303(up)-303(to)-303(date)-302(contact)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2238 0 obj <<
/Length 3076      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(476)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(information)-188(can)-188(be)-188(found)-189(at)-188(the)-188(Foundation's)-188(web)-188(site)-188(and)-188(official)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(page)-250(at)-250(http://www.pglaf.org)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(For)-250(additional)-250(contact)-250(information:)]TJ/F16 9.8629 Tf 7.681 -22.095 Td [(Dr.)-250(Gregory)-250(B.)-250(Newby)]TJ 0 -12.822 Td [(Chief)-250(Executive)-250(and)-250(Director)]TJ 0 -12.822 Td [(gbnewby@pglaf.org)]TJ/F16 15.7808 Tf -19.637 -58.864 Td [(Section)-250(4.)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 26.999 -44.805 Td [(Information)-258(about)-258(Donations)-258(to)-258(the)-259(Project)]TJ 8.106 -17.096 Td [(Gutenberg)-261(Literary)-260(Archive)-261(Foundation)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -35.105 -26.095 Td [(Project)-329(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 80.543 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.28 0 Td [(depends)-329(upon)-329(and)-329(cannot)-329(survive)-329(without)]TJ -94.823 -13.549 Td [(wide)-217(spread)-217(public)-217(support)-217(and)-217(donations)-217(to)-217(carry)-217(out)-217(its)-217(mission)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(of)-334(increasing)-334(the)-334(number)-334(of)-334(public)-334(domain)-334(and)-334(licensed)-334(works)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(that)-192(can)-193(be)-192(freely)-193(distributed)-192(in)-192(machine)-193(readable)-192(form)-192(accessible)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-261(the)-261(widest)-261(array)-261(of)-261(equipment)-261(including)-261(outdated)-261(equipment.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Many)-303(small)-302(donations)-303(\050$1)-303(to)-302($5,000\051)-303(are)-303(particularly)-302(important)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(to)-250(maintaining)-250(tax)-250(exempt)-250(status)-250(with)-250(the)-250(IRS.)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(The)-460(Foundation)-461(is)-460(committed)-461(to)-460(complying)-461(with)-460(the)-460(laws)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(regulating)-353(charities)-352(and)-353(charitable)-352(donations)-352(in)-353(all)-352(50)-353(states)-352(of)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(the)-430(United)-429(States.)-789(Compliance)-430(requirements)-429(are)-430(not)-429(uniform)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(and)-389(it)-389(takes)-389(a)-389(considerable)-389(effort,)-424(much)-389(paperwork)-389(and)-389(many)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(fees)-353(to)-353(meet)-353(and)-353(keep)-354(up)-353(with)-353(these)-353(requirements.)-559(We)-353(do)-353(not)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(solicit)-322(donations)-321(in)-322(locations)-322(where)-322(we)-321(have)-322(not)-322(received)-321(writ-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ten)-417(confirmation)-418(of)-417(compliance.)-753(To)-417(SEND)-417(DONATIONS)-417(or)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(determine)-309(the)-310(status)-309(of)-310(compliance)-309(for)-309(any)-310(particular)-309(state)-309(visit)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(http://www.gutenberg.org/donate)]TJ 11.956 -13.549 Td [(While)-305(we)-304(cannot)-305(and)-304(do)-305(not)-305(solicit)-304(contributions)-305(from)-304(states)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(where)-323(we)-323(have)-322(not)-323(met)-323(the)-323(solicitation)-323(requirements,)-341(we)-322(know)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2242 0 obj <<
/Length 3314      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 46.771 548.934 Td [(The)-250(Full)-250(Project)-250(Gutenberg)-250(License)-9893(477)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 0 -30.759 Td [(of)-366(no)-365(prohibition)-366(against)-366(accepting)-365(unsolicited)-366(donations)-365(from)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(donors)-250(in)-250(such)-250(states)-250(who)-250(approach)-250(us)-250(with)-250(offers)-250(to)-250(donate.)]TJ 11.956 -14.186 Td [(International)-237(donations)-237(are)-237(gratefully)-238(accepted,)-239(but)-237(we)-237(cannot)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(make)-327(any)-328(statements)-327(concerning)-327(tax)-328(treatment)-327(of)-327(donations)-327(re-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(ceived)-326(from)-326(outside)-327(the)-326(United)-326(States.)-479(U.S.)-326(laws)-326(alone)-326(swamp)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(our)-250(small)-250(staff.)]TJ 11.956 -14.186 Td [(Please)-413(check)-413(the)-412(Project)-413(Gutenberg)-413(Web)-413(pages)-413(for)-412(current)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(donation)-376(methods)-376(and)-375(addresses.)-627(Donations)-376(are)-376(accepted)-376(in)-375(a)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(number)-396(of)-395(other)-396(ways)-395(including)-396(checks,)-431(online)-396(payments)-395(and)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(credit)-241(card)-241(donations.)-247(To)-241(donate,)-243(please)-241(visit:)-245(http://www.guten-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(berg.org/donate)]TJ/F16 15.7808 Tf 0 -52.862 Td [(Section)-250(5.)]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf 12.158 -51.624 Td [(General)-254(Information)-253(About)-254(Project)-254(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 13.1507 Tf 243.427 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 13.1507 Tf -160.742 -17.096 Td [(electronic)-279(works.)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -94.843 -29.823 Td [(Professor)-259(Michael)-259(S.)-259(Hart)-259(is)-259(the)-259(originator)-259(of)-259(the)-259(Project)-258(Guten-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(berg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 19.386 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 15.085 0 Td [(concept)-403(of)-403(a)-403(library)-402(of)-403(electronic)-403(works)-403(that)-403(could)-403(be)]TJ -34.471 -13.549 Td [(freely)-233(shared)-232(with)-233(anyone.)-244(For)-233(thirty)-232(years,)-237(he)-232(produced)-233(and)-232(dis-)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(tributed)-274(Project)-274(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 116.868 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 13.679 0 Td [(eBooks)-274(with)-274(only)-274(a)-274(loose)-274(network)]TJ -130.547 -13.549 Td [(of)-250(volunteer)-250(support.)]TJ 11.956 -14.186 Td [(Project)-379(Gutenberg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 81.091 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 14.829 0 Td [(eBooks)-379(are)-380(often)-379(created)-379(from)-380(several)]TJ -107.876 -13.549 Td [(printed)-443(editions,)-491(all)-443(of)-443(which)-443(are)-443(confirmed)-443(as)-443(not)-442(protected)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(by)-353(copyright)-353(in)-353(the)-354(U.S.)-353(unless)-353(a)-353(copyright)-353(notice)-353(is)-353(included.)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(Thus,)-230(we)-225(do)-225(not)-226(necessarily)-225(keep)-225(ebooks)-225(in)-225(compliance)-225(with)-225(any)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(particular)-250(paper)-250(edition.)]TJ 11.956 -14.185 Td [(Each)-371(ebook)-370(is)-371(in)-371(a)-370(subdirectory)-371(of)-371(the)-370(same)-371(number)-371(as)-370(the)]TJ -11.956 -13.55 Td [(ebook's)-306(ebook)-307(number,)-320(often)-306(in)-307(several)-306(formats)-306(including)-306(plain)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(vanilla)-250(ASCII,)-250(compressed)-250(\050zipped\051,)-250(HTML)-250(and)-250(others.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2249 0 obj <<
/Length 1685      
>>
stream
0 g 0 G
BT
/F16 10.9091 Tf 93.543 548.934 Td [(478)-8255(The)-250(Supernatural)-250(in)-250(the)-250(New)-250(Testament)]TJ
0 g 0 G
 11.956 -30.759 Td [(Corrected)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 45.948 0 Td [(editions)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 37.483 0 Td [(of)-269(our)-269(ebooks)-269(replace)-269(the)-269(old)-269(file)-269(and)-269(take)]TJ -95.387 -13.549 Td [(over)-285(the)-286(old)-285(filename)-286(and)-285(etext)-286(number.)-356(The)-286(replaced)-285(older)-285(file)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(is)-367(renamed.)]TJ/F31 10.9091 Tf 58.126 0 Td [(Versions)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 42.185 0 Td [(based)-367(on)-367(separate)-367(sources)-367(are)-367(treated)-367(as)]TJ -100.311 -13.549 Td [(new)-250(ebooks)-250(receiving)-250(new)-250(filenames)-250(and)-250(etext)-250(numbers.)]TJ 11.956 -13.55 Td [(Most)-416(people)-416(start)-416(at)-416(our)-416(Web)-416(site)-416(which)-416(has)-416(the)-416(main)-415(PG)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(search)-250(facility:)]TJ/F16 9.8629 Tf 19.637 -22.64 Td [(http://www.gutenberg.org)]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf -7.681 -23.367 Td [(This)-527(Web)-526(site)-527(includes)-527(information)-526(about)-527(Project)-526(Guten-)]TJ -11.956 -13.549 Td [(berg)]TJ/F45 10.9091 Tf 19.386 0 Td [(")]TJ/F16 10.9091 Tf 10.691 0 Td [(,)-321(including)-307(how)-306(to)-307(make)-307(donations)-306(to)-307(the)-307(Project)-306(Guten-)]TJ -30.077 -13.549 Td [(berg)-251(Literary)-251(Archive)-250(Foundation,)-251(how)-251(to)-251(help)-251(produce)-251(our)-250(new)]TJ 0 -13.55 Td [(ebooks,)-430(and)-395(how)-394(to)-394(subscribe)-394(to)-395(our)-394(email)-394(newsletter)-394(to)-394(hear)]TJ 0 -13.549 Td [(about)-250(new)-250(ebooks.)]TJ
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
0 g 0 G
ET
endstream
endobj
2257 0 obj <<
/Length1 10500
/Length 10500     
>>
stream


�POS/2pg�P<VcmapJ$B*%�:cvt 
�G@fpgm2Msf�
bglyf�����$headژo{�6hhea
J.�$hmtx��u��loca3�.��RmaxpBr� name^S��~post	*��$0
�prep�-\h�,K�	PX�

�Y�
���D�	_^-�
,  EiD�
`-�,�
*!-�, F�%FRX#Y � �Id� F had�%F hadRX#e�Y/ �SXi �TX!�@Yi �TX!�@eYY:-�, F�%FRX#�Y F jad�%F jadRX#�Y/�-�,K �&PXQX��D�@DY!! E��PX��D!YY-�,  EiD�
`  E}iD�
`-�,�*-�,K �&SX���@Y�� �&SX#!�����#Y �&SX#!�
���#Y �&SX#!�
@���#Y �&SX�%E�
�PX#!�
�#!�%E#!#!Y!YD-�	,KSXED!!Y-*+Pn�� ��9�+�
+
�+�L</"+�G</"+�
�fP9"+�xfP9"+�+� E}iD��P���&
g��P��&���F��9�&
&��F��9�&
&��F���&���F��C�&i��7����& 
l��Z��A�&!-��P��&"���P��&#
���F��9&#
c��7�H�&$"
��7�H�&$#
���F��C&"���F��K&#���U���&%"���U���&%#
���7���& #
���Z��A&!#j��P� �&&���P��Q&'���7� �Q&$''�&	�������Q&'���Z��AQ&!'
\P���G
��
4+�
A

&
6
F
V
f
v
�
	]A�
�
]�EX�9/�9	>Y�EX�E/�E	>Y�EX�'/�'>Y�EX�//�/>Y��A!'7GWgw��������]A'7GWgqAv�q�9��Ay�qA!(8HXhx��������]A(8HXhq��и/�,'99�<'9901%2>7.
#"
3267

#".'
#".54>327>
'>7

�'JB8�Y&J:$2I�&>73
?$Et*
L�F<mS1=k�V[�&486v4Uk6��,Y�\G�i@&>h�rTvO/
	;@DpQ��9o�mlǗZ��	I�:

!D
G�G�+A��]A	)9IYiy�	]�/01

'>
76.#'>
EYa'*,"7'5A=$PE�=!&P.0$*

$-3!<�#S�
+�
A

&
6
F
V
f
v
�
	]A�
�
]�/�/�/01
.'>7
'>
76.#'>
�	�,0/�nYa'*,"7'5A=$<

w
#�E�=!&P.0$*

$-3
F��9�O
��4+�A&6FVfv�	]A��]�<49�</�
��EX�C/�C	>Y�EX�//�/>Y�+��C�
�Ay
�
qA!

(
8
H
X
h
x
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
]A

(
8
H
X
h
q�/�$�A!$$'$7$G$W$g$w$�$�$�$�$�$�$�$�$]A$$'$7$G$W$g$qAv$�$q�9901
#".#"3267.
#"32>7#".54>7.
54>3232>3
,)$6HU(X["EhFD4,HmI%(Ga9#GLU03\blBL}Z16I*KV"8IOM!,H?7
�!4$%SA<0`$6>#?0#5-@*'D]7+MA3aJ+J?2#
2D
T�K�+�A&6FVfv�	]A��]�/01&>76
.
4#378/7/0'b]184.

	)	%/1.F%!(r
F��C�3�+��EX�/�	>Y�EX�/�>Y01%
#".76.#5>
73267C\~!#-


>7A�B 

K?
mHD9Y<
�4B&()(��EP)
 -
7����;
�+��,+�� 9� /��A�,�,]A	,,),9,I,Y,i,y,�,	]�EX�/�	>Y�EX�7/�7	>Y�EX�/�>Y�%�A!%%'%7%G%W%g%w%�%�%�%�%�%�%�%�%]A%%'%7%G%W%g%qAv%�%q01
#".54>54.'5>
732>56./
>7�"=Wm�H0fR570E|D	!7G'-N@1"
*B,152 4%_F��_8(^�q5[Z^7%('b��RYR'-J_gf+=hP5
&
9Zy
Z��A�U
��#+�#�=-+�=�G+�A�-�-]A	--)-9-I-Y-i-y-�-	]�
-=9�9A##&#6#F#V#f#v#�#	]A�#�#]A�G�G]A	GG)G9GIGYGiGyG�G	]�/�Q/�EX�/�>Y�EX�/�>Y�
9�9�(�A!(('(7(G(W(g(w(�(�(�(�(�(�(�(�(]A(('(7(G(W(g(qAv(�(q�B�01
#".'#".54>732>74.'>
7
1032>54.'>7ADj�>8W?)0HbBExZ4+NkA8K-<V7$A1
	+G 	

,H70M6+B-7cK,
�t��E(BU.,UC)=u�lQ��w'<xxx<G�f>/K`1%LE7
)Ic:2bM0;aDHxt>	#j��
o:
��/01

'7>3
��
$(&}L		
�$

�I
(<
��/�/01.'>7]	�,0/<

w
#
7�H��A�+���
и
/��C��/�EX�/�	>Y�EX�8/�8	>Y�	9���Ay�qA!(8HXhx��������]A(8HXhq�2к?901
2
'>54.#"
'>54.'5>71>
�qb
+V#'

.'AM\7"G$';6$=:;!#
b�����\�iFITS�1T>#>nV��#820
9=;
�4;(#0KH4��U����+
��,/�-/�ܹ�A��]A	)9IYiy�	]�,� и /�
�A

&
6
F
V
f
v
�
	]A�
�
]�EX�'/�'	>Y�EX�/�>Y�'��Ay�qA!(8HXhx��������]A(8HXhq���A!'7GWgw��������]A'7GWgqAv�q01
4.#"32>7#".54>321Pe3EcA4Sh4?_? �!;Sbp;Z�k; ;Qcq=[�j:
�O�m@:e�PO�l?5b�tB�raF'H~�fB�saF(H�
��� ����&�+��/�EX�/�>Y01

#"&54&'>
7367��;Q
J
	�h+5GRY|&/

FL�8'�/�
/�/�/��
����01
#".#"'>323267�2=H'#?<;(B%51>G'&D<6&I"6!)J8"#-8)J9"#,;$0<GS_kw�����������



!Y�	<����3
		R	�
�
�XX�XX�fSIL ���!Z�5�

���K_<���!��f����
by	
���-
{����
b
(
�4P4P^F^F^F\F7�Z4P4P^FF7F7\F\F�U�U7�Z4P4PF7\���Z4P
!�!^F
2\F7�Z
�o
�(F7�U��6F
(��



n
:

:
H
O
h
'v
�
,�
	�
�
�

�

�
�
�
	t�
	
$
	@
	2N
	�
	N�
	�
	X
		$^
	&�
	8�
	
�
	
�
	
�
	Copyright (c) SIL International 2003. All rights reserved.QFEMDK+GentiumRegularQFEMDK+SIL: Gentium: 2003QFEMDK+GentiumVersion 1.01; 2003; initial SIL releaseQFEMDK+GentiumGentium is a trademark of SIL International.J. Victor Gaultneyhttp://www.sil.org/http://www.sil.org/~gaultneyThis font is the property of SIL International. It is distributed as copyrighted freeware. You may use this software without any charge and may distribute it, as is, to others. Commercial distribution of this software is restricted without prior written permission. If you wish to distribute this software commercially, contact SIL for details on obtaining a license. You may not rent or lease the software, nor may you modify, adapt, translate, reverse engineer, decompile, or disassemble the software. You may not make derivative fonts from this software. THE SOFTWARE AND RELATED FILES ARE PROVIDED "AS IS" AND WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND.GentiumRegularGentiumCopyright (c) SIL International 2003. All rights reserved.QFEMDK+GentiumRegularQFEMDK+SIL: Gentium: 2003QFEMDK+GentiumVersion 1.01; 2003; initial SIL releaseQFEMDK+GentiumGentium is a trademark of SIL International.J. Victor Gaultneyhttp://www.sil.org/http://www.sil.org/~gaultneyThis font is the property of SIL International. It is distributed as copyrighted freeware. You may use this software without any charge and may distribute it, as is, to others. Commercial distribution of this software is restricted without prior written permission. If you wish to distribute this software commercially, contact SIL for details on obtaining a license. You may not rent or lease the software, nor may you modify, adapt, translate, reverse engineer, decompile, or disassemble the software. You may not make derivative fonts from this software. THE SOFTWARE AND RELATED FILES ARE PROVIDED "AS IS" AND WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND.GentiumRegularGentium��(








	
























 
!
"
#
$
%
&
'uni1F00uni1F04uni1F10uni1F11uni1F14uni1F30uni1F50uni1F60uni1F70uni1F71uni1F73uni1F74uni1F75uni1F76uni1F77uni1F78uni1F79uni1F7Buni1F7Duni1FB3uni1FB6uni1FC7uni1FD6uni1FF6alphauni1FBFuni1FCEepsilonuni1FFEiotaupsilonomegauni1FEFuni1FFDetaomicronuni037Auni1FC0


	

 
�������
	


endstream
endobj
2260 0 obj <<
/Length1 17600
/Length 17600     
>>
stream


�POS/2pg�P2�Vcmap=S<BA�:cvt 
�G@fpgm2Msf�
bglyf����/�headژo{386hhea
J!3p$hmtxf+W3�lloca�C�c2�8maxp5r4 namegn'�4 ~post��M@��prep�-\h�,K�	PX�

�Y�
���D�	_^-�
,  EiD�
`-�,�
*!-�, F�%FRX#Y � �Id� F had�%F hadRX#e�Y/ �SXi �TX!�@Yi �TX!�@eYY:-�, F�%FRX#�Y F jad�%F jadRX#�Y/�-�,K �&PXQX��D�@DY!! E��PX��D!YY-�,  EiD�
`  E}iD�
`-�,�*-�,K �&SX���@Y�� �&SX#!�����#Y �&SX#!�
���#Y �&SX#!�
@���#Y �&SX�%E�
�PX#!�
�#!�%E#!#!Y!YD-�	,KSXED!!Y-*+Pn�� ��9�+�
+
�+�L</"+�G</"+�
�fP9"+�xfP9"+�+� E}iD)���
#K�5+��D
+�D���A�
�
]A	

)
9
I
Y
i
y
�
	]�
D9�/A��]A	)9IYiy�	]�$��G5$9�M��EX�?/�?>Y�EX�)/�)>Y�EX�0/�0>Y�+��?��Ay�qA!(8HXhx��������]A(8HXhq�и/�)��A!'7GWgw��������]A'7GWgqAv�q��GиG/01
"32>54."32>54.
#".1#5>
5
'>32
�"r�N!N�
0Q$	,..HtS,'Q}
�Cy�eX`aN0JDN&J"'grv6d�q<dX@nQ.�

�!-FX+2V?$����%B]87t_=��U�`4+!>>%Fd?l�"Ba{
P�
L
��M/�N/�M�и/�и/��и/�N�ܸ*и*/�
*9��8�A�8�8]A	88)898I8Y8i8y8�8	]�$и$/��D�ADD&D6DFDVDfDvD�D	]A�D�D]�EX�/�>Y�EX�/�>Y�EX�//�/>Y����#и$и�=�Ay=�=qA!==(=8=H=X=h=x=�=�=�=�=�=�=�=�=]A==(=8=H=X=h=q013'>73;
.54>3232>7!5>54.#"o
-�k�S!!A`}�Zn��I0_�_�-	
�F:[E0
/^�\DlR:%	+EaC>DD *@+T���QA�{jO-J��zY���X)B0GHDoLxfYY_9[��L.K`d`%;c\ZgxLoP���G
��
4+�
A

&
6
F
V
f
v
�
	]A�
�
]�EX�9/�9	>Y�EX�E/�E	>Y�EX�'/�'>Y�EX�//�/>Y��A!'7GWgw��������]A'7GWgqAv�q�9��Ay�qA!(8HXhx��������]A(8HXhq��и/�,'99�<'9901%2>7.
#"
3267

#".'
#".54>327>
'>7

�'JB8�Y&J:$2I�&>73
?$Et*
L�F<mS1=k�V[�&486v4Uk6��,Y�\G�i@&>h�rTvO/
	;@DpQ��9o�mlǗZ��	I�:
���!Q
,�-:+�-�H+�H�-�к
H9�
/A�
�
]A	

)
9
I
Y
i
y
�
	]�"��M:"9�S��EX�9/�9>Y�EX�)/�)>Y�B+�B�)��A!'7GWgw��������]A'7GWgqAv�q01
32>54.+
'>=
4.#"
#"&''4>32
">FK$7W>!-]�`?iL* 5D$<L*�*CSQFP�<

*,))
7[�Z0\J/0S@I~[4
 $B3:[q6R�d8O
/D[:KiCP�Ӄ�v`�oM/eS�OwY@0$�Y���wF-OoB,_\R?f�
�����5��
+�
�и/A��]A	)9IYiy�	]�,
9�EX�%/�%	>Y�EX�4/�4	>Y�EX�
/�
>Y�,
%901

.
'>'.'.1'>
72>7>
7�1ie[#
%Y!

"6CIH'#
:u.4=@=6&F7'*]& �k���u%pzs( 

A�~\
1����j	
(,?m���ZZ���`
d���K
M� =+� �'+�'A��]A	)9IYiy�	]A  & 6 F V f v � 	]A� � ]�= 9�/�3��83'9�'�M��EX�./�.>Y�B+�B�.��A!'7GWgw��������]A'7GWgqAv�q01
4.'32>
#".#"#".54>7.54>32327
�%>R,Eb?0Qj;$E5 �INShm-U���U!9MZc1^�d52]�Q0[G*4H)Dug\,	
yQ�}n3
Ti{CG�lC+Lh�GJ%-%!<y����z;ujZC&M��V\��h#4ddi:'D3
F��9�O
��4+�A&6FVfv�	]A��]�<49�</�
��EX�C/�C	>Y�EX�//�/>Y�+��C�
�Ay
�
qA!

(
8
H
X
h
x
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
]A

(
8
H
X
h
q�/�$�A!$$'$7$G$W$g$w$�$�$�$�$�$�$�$�$]A$$'$7$G$W$g$qAv$�$q�9901
#".#"3267.
#"32>7#".54>7.
54>3232>3
,)$6HU(X["EhFD4,HmI%(Ga9#GLU03\blBL}Z16I*KV"8IOM!,H?7
�!4$%SA<0`$6>#?0#5-@*'D]7+MA3aJ+J?2#
P�&)F�G/�H/�G�#и#/��A&6FVfv�	]A��]�H�ܹ�A��]A	)9IYiy�	]��DиD/�(#D9��<и</�/�7/�:/�</�EX�-/�->Y�(:901
&'>
54.54>7#".'0.'>
323267
)J�kM,/McgcM/;`HKA/NchcN/L��x5aR>
	

+ 4ܥv7�����WF[=%.G8%N^rIc�3+4!-MvX����w/?@
('"
7�H��A�+���
и
/��C��/�EX�/�	>Y�EX�8/�8	>Y�	9���Ay�qA!(8HXhx��������]A(8HXhq�2к?901
2
'>54.#"
'>54.'5>71>
�qb
+V#'

.'AM\7"G$';6$=:;!#
b�����\�iFITS�1T>#>nV��#820
9=;
�4;(#0KH4��[����1
i�2/�3/�2�&и&/��A&6FVfv�	]A��]�3�ܹ�A��]A	)9IYiy�	]�и/��и/�EX�!/�!>Y�-+�-�+��и/�!�
�A!

'
7
G
W
g
w
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
]A

'
7
G
W
g
qAv
�
q��и/01
"67.2>'.



#".
5&>32

�D^;
��y	)B\ Hb:A���9'Da
�
@t�bb�d3
7M`o>f�f41E�ΈrɕV�*K�َ
wӝ\l����un�
�f���e8t���
F��C�3�+��EX�/�	>Y�EX�/�>Y01%
#".76.#5>
73267C\~!#-


>7A�B 

K?
mHD9Y<
�4B&()(��EP)
 -
7���Q�!+��.��EX�-/�-	>Y�EX�6/�6	>Y�EX�/�>Y�EX�/�>Y�B+�B�/-9��J�A!JJ'J7JGJWJgJwJ�J�J�J�J�J�J�J�J]AJJ'J7JGJWJgJqAvJ�Jq01%#".#"'>54.'5>7>3'
3232>7
)I>.
1.,-/.'-
$'&&<7%KF>d�sUB5
	
/!8AR:	 94211R)EhyhE/4KLB5BM(
�7> 
(
"���yF$	

2W,M@EfyfE
��E�?3�EX�/�>Y�EX�/�>Y�-$+�-01%
#".'.
''>7.#"'>3232>7EKa",)*5B+&HHI%5841^YRG<!5-)#I12QA3(),8G.(HB<!
\9B@n��8d���u!>�����Jg}C"&33E*3a����a-
=�=�L
�+��F8+�F�8�
кF9��.��>F9�F�N��EX�(/�(	>Y�EX�A/�A	>Y�EX�/�>Y�EX�/�>Y�EX�
/�
>Y�
(9�3�A33'373G3W3g3w3�3�3�3�3�3
]A�3�3]�
39�(9�>(901%#".'
#"&''4.'5>7032>74.'>
7
3267=@<3
Q�:;r,
'3371'4/'A:5	
/D*9?F(
,[)
3!R(!":L+ijQHo��_�',(

��#RF0
!=4
�-,&	'I?�]L


����-@�EX�/�	>Y�EX�+/�+	>Y�EX�/�>Y�#901

'.'.
'.#"15>
72>'>
7
�3T�^9(FC<.(&?j,< 8@@E[/.W(�f����		|���/#*
&-9H'���ma�ȲC
U����+
��,/�-/�ܹ�A��]A	)9IYiy�	]�,� и /�
�A

&
6
F
V
f
v
�
	]A�
�
]�EX�'/�'	>Y�EX�/�>Y�'��Ay�qA!(8HXhx��������]A(8HXhq���A!'7GWgw��������]A'7GWgqAv�q01
4.#"32>7#".54>321Pe3EcA4Sh4?_? �!;Sbp;Z�k; ;Qcq=[�j:
�O�m@:e�PO�l?5b�tB�raF'H~�fB�saF(H�
��"�K
�@
+�@A�
�
]A	

)
9
I
Y
i
y
�
	]�EX�4/�4	>Y�EX�9/�9	>Y�EX�/�>Y�EX�/�>Y�9��Ay�qA!(8HXhx��������]A(8HXhq�и/�(и)�01%#".54>7.
'
.'>7#"'>3!267
+

32>73L;/#4#
	G�R	
9DC

(3 2//89: y*H4i0A
"$0"n+7*MnE [~�i
r��H{7	

&DPi�ώ
$#<,HMQ�N[�T'	
,��y�5
��6/�7/�6�,и,/� ��и7�ܹ�A��]A	)9IYiy�	]�EX�1/�1	>Y�EX�(/�(>Y�EX�/�>Y��A!'7GWgw��������]A'7GWgqAv�q�1�
�Ay
�
qA!

(
8
H
X
h
x
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
]A

(
8
H
X
h
q�901%32654.#"%#".'
.
'4>32
",A6/hp*G]4%F6!W6GPU(-:H-.K*	Cp�MV�X-� )
��`�k8-g�{kG�{hL*
2(L��m
	q�ύHJz�
P�$1�D
/�E/�F/�E�2и2/��A&6FVfv�	]A��]�F�ܹ&�A�&�&]A	&&)&9&I&Y&i&y&�&	]� /�EX�:/�:	>Y�
�Ay
�
qA!

(
8
H
X
h
x
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
]A

(
8
H
X
h
q�:
901
#".#".
'>
54.'.54>7>
323263
1%&#
)9H+*C3%>`B<gK+5P7
70)CT+:?>11M76|@ :;<"	
}.(!*EY^[$8WF9-8H1P_i6C�.&7*(:Nd?G��v/-2

P����>
�?/�@/�$ܹ�A��]A	)9IYiy�	]�?�0и0/�
�A

&
6
F
V
f
v
�
	]A�
�
]�0$9�EX�/�	>Y�EX�7/�7	>Y�EX�+/�+>Y�7��Ay�qA!(8HXhx��������]A(8HXhq�и+��A!'7GWgw��������]A'7GWgqAv�q��и/�и/01
4.'.
#"32>
#"&'
#".54>3!2>7�-8(@9S6)Ji?@S0
+%& W/	oc/EZnAR�f99Ocr?
2$
|F~iT

/Of7J�|O7UjZ08

P�n(be`K-L�[=zo`G(

��q�3
��(
+�(A((&(6(F(V(f(v(�(	]A�(�(]�EX�/�	>Y�EX�/�	>Y�EX�/�>Y��
�Ay
�
qA!

(
8
H
X
h
x
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
�
]A

(
8
H
X
h
q�ии"и"/�%и%/��-�A!--'-7-G-W-g-w-�-�-�-�-�-�-�-�-]A--'-7-G-W-g-qAv-�-q01%#".547"&+
"'>3!267
#"&'
32>79[MC *:&,))G26:> 
�2I3[4+B(#)2>(&;(/J]-s
�
#8-AO��U VL5-
7����;
�+��,+�� 9� /��A�,�,]A	,,),9,I,Y,i,y,�,	]�EX�/�	>Y�EX�7/�7	>Y�EX�/�>Y�%�A!%%'%7%G%W%g%w%�%�%�%�%�%�%�%�%]A%%'%7%G%W%g%qAv%�%q01
#".54>54.'5>
732>56./
>7�"=Wm�H0fR570E|D	!7G'-N@1"
*B,152 4%_F��_8(^�q5[Z^7%('b��RYR'-J_gf+=hP5
&
9ZyP���T
�F7+�F�
+��P+��и/A�
�
]A	

)
9
I
Y
i
y
�
	]��и� и /AFF&F6FFFVFfFvF�F	]A�F�F]�P�KиK/��V��/�>/�EX�(/�(>Y�EX� /� >Y�EX�0/�0>Y� ��A!'7GWgw��������]A'7GWgqAv�q���Ay�qA!(8HXhx��������]A(8HXhq��KиK/01
>54.#"
2
.
'>7.54>7
>74>�



X�`2(EZ2."�IxV/L��l
%Q'

]�nN0
"<^�Z
SnB,V�T

/Rs
� Xiw=	=i�`B~c=?~o3
�Iu�J{ɓZ<thY 
Yp�D.F[gm5'\_aXM 
%epv6G�rP
:pcS�~>
����GA�/�/�EX�)/�)	>Y�EX�8/�8	>Y�
)9�0)901
#".''67.'.
#"15>767>732>7�/A.!$AGS59<:131w�N9ZJ?#$844!!+7E,@k&/1/j�T1XK=$
��%/;nj2y~7
"�
5��҂=	
(*Ht�w�

w
!��ʨ�ˊG-
Z��A�U
��#+�#�=-+�=�G+�A�-�-]A	--)-9-I-Y-i-y-�-	]�
-=9�9A##&#6#F#V#f#v#�#	]A�#�#]A�G�G]A	GG)G9GIGYGiGyG�G	]�/�Q/�EX�/�>Y�EX�/�>Y�
9�9�(�A!(('(7(G(W(g(w(�(�(�(�(�(�(�(�(]A(('(7(G(W(g(qAv(�(q�B�01
#".'#".54>732>74.'>
7
1032>54.'>7ADj�>8W?)0HbBExZ4+NkA8K-<V7$A1
	+G 	

,H70M6+B-7cK,
�t��E(BU.,UC)=u�lQ��w'<xxx<G�f>/K`1%LE7
)Ic:2bM0;aDHxt>	#j��
m���q~��	Q
V
����
Xnd}s���'��
�
�XX�XX�fSIL ���!Z�5�

��_<���!��f����
by	
���-
{����
b

�f)P4P������d^F3PF7�[\F7;Q=
�U6��EP�Pq7P��Z
��



n
:

:
H
O
h
'v
�
,�
	�
�
�

�

�
�
�
	t�
	
$
	@
	2N
	�
	N�
	�
	X
		$^
	&�
	8�
	
�
	
�
	
�
	Copyright (c) SIL International 2003. All rights reserved.SCFMOI+GentiumRegularSCFMOI+SIL: Gentium: 2003SCFMOI+GentiumVersion 1.01; 2003; initial SIL releaseSCFMOI+GentiumGentium is a trademark of SIL International.J. Victor Gaultneyhttp://www.sil.org/http://www.sil.org/~gaultneyThis font is the property of SIL International. It is distributed as copyrighted freeware. You may use this software without any charge and may distribute it, as is, to others. Commercial distribution of this software is restricted without prior written permission. If you wish to distribute this software commercially, contact SIL for details on obtaining a license. You may not rent or lease the software, nor may you modify, adapt, translate, reverse engineer, decompile, or disassemble the software. You may not make derivative fonts from this software. THE SOFTWARE AND RELATED FILES ARE PROVIDED "AS IS" AND WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND.GentiumRegularGentiumCopyright (c) SIL International 2003. All rights reserved.SCFMOI+GentiumRegularSCFMOI+SIL: Gentium: 2003SCFMOI+GentiumVersion 1.01; 2003; initial SIL releaseSCFMOI+GentiumGentium is a trademark of SIL International.J. Victor Gaultneyhttp://www.sil.org/http://www.sil.org/~gaultneyThis font is the property of SIL International. It is distributed as copyrighted freeware. You may use this software without any charge and may distribute it, as is, to others. Commercial distribution of this software is restricted without prior written permission. If you wish to distribute this software commercially, contact SIL for details on obtaining a license. You may not rent or lease the software, nor may you modify, adapt, translate, reverse engineer, decompile, or disassemble the software. You may not make derivative fonts from this software. THE SOFTWARE AND RELATED FILES ARE PROVIDED "AS IS" AND WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND.GentiumRegularGentium��








	









�







BetaOmegaalphabetagammadeltaepsilonzetaetathetaiotakappalambdauni03BCnuomicronrhosigma1sigmatauupsilonphichiomega


	

 
�������
	


endstream
endobj
2215 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 974
/Length 15427     
>>
stream
2211 0 2212 58 2213 116 2208 174 2218 266 2216 406 2206 573 2220 631 2221 688 2217 745
2226 823 2228 942 2229 1000 2225 1057 2233 1149 2222 1316 2223 1484 2224 1652 2230 1852 2214 2074
2232 2132 2237 2212 2231 2361 2235 2562 2205 2772 2236 2830 2241 2910 2239 3059 2243 3269 2244 3480
2240 3538 2248 3618 2246 3758 2247 3962 2251 4054 2252 4073 2254 4241 2255 4260 2256 4428 2258 5409
247 5617 2259 5761 2261 5998 246 6202 2263 6348 2264 7047 2266 7229 2267 7277 2268 7445 2269 8188
2262 8369 2253 8793 2265 8849 2250 8963 60 9026 7 9184 673 9340 15 9497 2148 9653 10 9811
39 9916 69 10022 95 10128 121 10238 152 10351 178 10464 204 10577 230 10690 261 10803 287 10916
318 11029 344 11142 370 11255 396 11368 426 11481 453 11594 479 11707 505 11820 531 11933 561 12046
587 12159 614 12272 639 12385 669 12498 696 12611 723 12724 750 12837 779 12950 805 13063 835 13176
862 13289 888 13402 914 13515 944 13628 970 13741 1001 13854 1027 13973 1053 14093 1079 14213 1109 14333
% 2211 0 obj
<<
/D [2209 0 R /XYZ 93.543 493.081 null]
>>
% 2212 0 obj
<<
/D [2209 0 R /XYZ 93.543 448.715 null]
>>
% 2213 0 obj
<<
/D [2209 0 R /XYZ 93.543 262.957 null]
>>
% 2208 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F45 2148 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2218 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2219 0 R
/Resources 2217 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2204 0 R
/Annots [ 2216 0 R ]
>>
% 2216 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [46.771 178.31 115.271 188.03]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense1F3) >>
>>
% 2206 0 obj
<<
/D [2218 0 R /XYZ 46.771 466.327 null]
>>
% 2220 0 obj
<<
/D [2218 0 R /XYZ 46.771 241.15 null]
>>
% 2221 0 obj
<<
/D [2218 0 R /XYZ 46.771 128.84 null]
>>
% 2217 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2226 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2227 0 R
/Resources 2225 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2204 0 R
>>
% 2228 0 obj
<<
/D [2226 0 R /XYZ 93.543 437.391 null]
>>
% 2229 0 obj
<<
/D [2226 0 R /XYZ 93.543 242.82 null]
>>
% 2225 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F20 15 0 R /F45 2148 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2233 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2234 0 R
/Resources 2232 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2204 0 R
/Annots [ 2222 0 R 2223 0 R 2224 0 R 2230 0 R ]
>>
% 2222 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [189.068 407.414 194.522 417.123]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense3) >>
>>
% 2223 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
/Subtype /Link
/BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [0 1 1]
/Rect [215.179 407.414 220.634 417.123]
/A << /S /GoTo /D (pglicense4) >>
>>
% 2224 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [80.699 393.854 172.815 403.574]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.pglaf.org) >> 
>>
% 2230 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [88.104 185.858 279.602 195.578]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.gutenberg.org/fundraising/pglaf) >> 
>>
% 2214 0 obj
<<
/D [2233 0 R /XYZ 46.771 382.339 null]
>>
% 2232 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F45 2148 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2237 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2238 0 R
/Resources 2236 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2204 0 R
/Annots [ 2231 0 R 2235 0 R ]
>>
% 2231 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [127.471 502.248 219.587 511.968]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.pglaf.org) >> 
>>
% 2235 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [93.543 90.862 238.983 100.582]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.gutenberg.org/donate) >> 
>>
% 2205 0 obj
<<
/D [2237 0 R /XYZ 93.543 420.153 null]
>>
% 2236 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F45 2148 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2241 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2242 0 R
/Resources 2240 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2245 0 R
/Annots [ 2239 0 R 2243 0 R ]
>>
% 2239 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [247.1 392.581 327.401 402.301]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.gutenberg.org/donate) >> 
>>
% 2243 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [46.771 379.032 115.542 388.752]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.gutenberg.org/donate) >> 
>>
% 2244 0 obj
<<
/D [2241 0 R /XYZ 46.771 365.577 null]
>>
% 2240 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F45 2148 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2248 0 obj
<<
/Type /Page
/Contents 2249 0 R
/Resources 2247 0 R
/MediaBox [0 0 419.528 595.276]
/Parent 2245 0 R
/Annots [ 2246 0 R ]
>>
% 2246 0 obj
<<
/Type /Annot
 /BS << /Type /Border /S /U >> /H /I /C [1 0.5 0.5] 
/Rect [113.18 425.639 215.636 434.427]
 /Subtype /Link /A << /Type /Action /S /URI /URI (http://www.gutenberg.org) >> 
>>
% 2247 0 obj
<<
/Font << /F16 7 0 R /F31 60 0 R /F45 2148 0 R >>
/ProcSet [ /PDF /Text ]
>>
% 2251 0 obj
[980]
% 2252 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Times-Roman
/Flags 34
/FontBBox [0 0 1000 0]
/Ascent 0
/CapHeight 0
/Descent 0
/ItalicAngle 0
/StemV 0
/XHeight 450
>>
% 2254 0 obj
[722]
% 2255 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Times-Roman
/Flags 34
/FontBBox [0 0 1000 0]
/Ascent 0
/CapHeight 0
/Descent 0
/ItalicAngle 0
/StemV 0
/XHeight 450
>>
% 2256 0 obj
[525 525 525 525 525 525 525 525 669 669 834 844 805 805 669 669 420 420 420 420 420 420 0 0 683 683 847 857 818 818 0 0 534 534 534 534 534 534 534 534 840 840 1005 1015 976 976 840 840 294 294 294 294 294 294 294 294 494 494 659 668 629 629 494 494 498 498 498 498 498 498 0 0 762 762 927 937 849 849 0 0 507 507 507 507 507 507 507 507 0 818 0 993 0 954 0 818 700 700 700 700 700 700 700 700 788 788 952 962 874 874 788 788 525 525 420 420 534 534 294 294 498 498 507 507 700 700 0 0 525 525 525 525 525 525 525 525 964 964 1129 1139 1100 1100 964 964 534 534 534 534 534 534 534 534 1135 1135 1300 1310 1270 1270 1135 1135 700 700 700 700 700 700 700 700 1083 1083 1247 1257 1218 1218 1083 1083 525 525 525 525 525 0 525 525 595 595 704 708 890 187 294 187 401 401 534 534 534 0 534 534 717 721 875 878 948 351 322 187 294 294 294 294 0 0 294 294 317 317 529 532 0 361 322 187 507 507 507 507 478 478 507 507 583 583 853 856 709 395 395 221 0 0 700 700 700 0 700]
% 2258 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /QFEMDK+Gentium
/Flags 4
/FontBBox [-519 -297 1297 1059]
/Ascent 858
/CapHeight 698
/Descent -275
/ItalicAngle 0
/StemV 280
/XHeight 454
/FontFile2 2257 0 R
>>
% 247 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /TrueType
/BaseFont /QFEMDK+Gentium
/FontDescriptor 2258 0 R
/FirstChar 0
/LastChar 246
/Widths 2256 0 R
>>
% 2259 0 obj
[549 475 573 496 522 653 618 317 578 595 806 648 516 600 629 522 0 519 550 583 654 615 688 632 317 583 525 420 534 294 507 525 498 475 479 420 399 534 499 294 510 528 539 507 438 498 526 478 408 478 430 507 638 486 660 700]
% 2261 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /SCFMOI+Gentium
/Flags 4
/FontBBox [-519 -297 1297 1059]
/Ascent 858
/CapHeight 0
/Descent -275
/ItalicAngle 0
/StemV 0
/XHeight 454
/FontFile2 2260 0 R
>>
% 246 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /TrueType
/BaseFont /SCFMOI+Gentium
/FontDescriptor 2261 0 R
/FirstChar 146
/LastChar 201
/Widths 2259 0 R
>>
% 2263 0 obj
[250 333 250 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 333 333 675 675 675 500 920 611 611 667 722 611 611 722 722 333 444 667 556 833 667 722 611 722 611 500 556 722 611 833 611 556 556 389 278 389 422 500 333 500 500 444 500 444 278 500 500 278 278 444 278 722 500 500 500 500 389 389 278 500 444 667 444 444 389 400 0 400 541 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 389 500 500 500 500 275 500 333 760 276 500 675 0 760 0 400 675 300 300 333 0 523 250 333 300 310 500 750 750 750 500 611 611 611 611 611 611 889 667 611 611 611 611 333 333 333 333 722 667 722 722 722 722 722 675 722 722 722 722 722 556 611 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 667 444 444 444]
% 2264 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Times-Italic
/Flags 98
/FontBBox [0 -207 1000 683]
/Ascent 683
/CapHeight 661
/Descent -207
/ItalicAngle 0
/StemV 83
/XHeight 441
>>
% 2266 0 obj
[1000 0 0 0 333 333 333 0 444 444]
% 2267 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Times-Roman
/Flags 34
/FontBBox [0 0 1000 0]
/Ascent 0
/CapHeight 0
/Descent 0
/ItalicAngle 0
/StemV 0
/XHeight 450
>>
% 2268 0 obj
[333 408 500 500 833 778 180 333 333 500 564 250 333 250 278 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 278 278 564 564 564 444 921 722 667 667 722 611 556 722 722 333 389 722 611 889 722 722 556 722 667 556 611 722 722 944 722 722 611 333 278 333 469 500 333 444 500 444 500 444 333 500 500 278 278 500 278 778 500 500 500 500 333 389 278 500 500 722 500 500 444 480 0 480 541 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 333 500 500 500 500 200 500 333 760 276 500 564 0 760 0 400 564 300 300 333 0 453 250 333 300 310 500 750 750 750 444 722 722 722 722 722 722 889 667 611 611 611 611 333 333 333 333 722 722 722 722 722 722 722 564 722 722 722 722 722 722 556 500 444 444 444 444 444 444 667 444 444 444]
% 2269 0 obj
<<
/Type /FontDescriptor
/FontName /Times-Roman
/Flags 34
/FontBBox [0 -218 1000 673]
/Ascent 673
/CapHeight 673
/Descent -218
/ItalicAngle 0
/StemV 83
/XHeight 450
>>
% 2262 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [33/exclam 36/dollar/percent/ampersand/quotesingle/parenleft/parenright/asterisk 44/comma/hyphen/period/slash/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon/semicolon/less 62/greater/question/at/A/B/C/D/E/F/G/H/I/J/K/L/M/N/O/P/Q/R/S/T/U/V/W/X/Y/Z/bracketleft 93/bracketright 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z 198/AE 224/agrave 230/ae 233/eacute]
>>
% 2253 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [83/oe]
>>
% 2265 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [20/emdash 24/quoteleft/quoteright 28/quotedblleft/quotedblright]
>>
% 2250 0 obj
<<
/Type /Encoding
/Differences [34/trademark]
>>
% 60 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/BaseFont /Times-Italic
/FontDescriptor 2264 0 R
/FirstChar 44
/LastChar 233
/Widths 2263 0 R
/Encoding 2262 0 R
>>
% 7 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/BaseFont /Times-Roman
/FontDescriptor 2269 0 R
/FirstChar 33
/LastChar 233
/Widths 2268 0 R
/Encoding 2262 0 R
>>
% 673 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/BaseFont /Times-Roman
/FontDescriptor 2255 0 R
/FirstChar 83
/LastChar 83
/Widths 2254 0 R
/Encoding 2253 0 R
>>
% 15 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/BaseFont /Times-Roman
/FontDescriptor 2267 0 R
/FirstChar 20
/LastChar 29
/Widths 2266 0 R
/Encoding 2265 0 R
>>
% 2148 0 obj
<<
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/BaseFont /Times-Roman
/FontDescriptor 2252 0 R
/FirstChar 34
/LastChar 34
/Widths 2251 0 R
/Encoding 2250 0 R
>>
% 10 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2270 0 R
/Kids [4 0 R 13 0 R 17 0 R 20 0 R 24 0 R 32 0 R]
>>
% 39 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2270 0 R
/Kids [36 0 R 41 0 R 49 0 R 53 0 R 57 0 R 62 0 R]
>>
% 69 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2270 0 R
/Kids [66 0 R 71 0 R 75 0 R 80 0 R 84 0 R 88 0 R]
>>
% 95 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2270 0 R
/Kids [92 0 R 97 0 R 102 0 R 106 0 R 110 0 R 114 0 R]
>>
% 121 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2270 0 R
/Kids [118 0 R 123 0 R 127 0 R 132 0 R 136 0 R 140 0 R]
>>
% 152 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2270 0 R
/Kids [149 0 R 154 0 R 158 0 R 162 0 R 166 0 R 170 0 R]
>>
% 178 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2271 0 R
/Kids [175 0 R 180 0 R 184 0 R 188 0 R 192 0 R 196 0 R]
>>
% 204 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2271 0 R
/Kids [201 0 R 206 0 R 210 0 R 214 0 R 218 0 R 222 0 R]
>>
% 230 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2271 0 R
/Kids [227 0 R 232 0 R 240 0 R 244 0 R 250 0 R 254 0 R]
>>
% 261 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2271 0 R
/Kids [258 0 R 263 0 R 267 0 R 272 0 R 276 0 R 280 0 R]
>>
% 287 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2271 0 R
/Kids [284 0 R 290 0 R 294 0 R 299 0 R 303 0 R 307 0 R]
>>
% 318 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2271 0 R
/Kids [315 0 R 320 0 R 324 0 R 328 0 R 332 0 R 336 0 R]
>>
% 344 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2272 0 R
/Kids [341 0 R 346 0 R 350 0 R 354 0 R 358 0 R 362 0 R]
>>
% 370 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2272 0 R
/Kids [367 0 R 372 0 R 376 0 R 380 0 R 384 0 R 388 0 R]
>>
% 396 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2272 0 R
/Kids [393 0 R 398 0 R 402 0 R 406 0 R 410 0 R 415 0 R]
>>
% 426 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2272 0 R
/Kids [423 0 R 429 0 R 433 0 R 437 0 R 441 0 R 445 0 R]
>>
% 453 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2272 0 R
/Kids [450 0 R 455 0 R 459 0 R 463 0 R 467 0 R 471 0 R]
>>
% 479 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2272 0 R
/Kids [476 0 R 481 0 R 485 0 R 489 0 R 493 0 R 497 0 R]
>>
% 505 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2273 0 R
/Kids [502 0 R 507 0 R 511 0 R 515 0 R 519 0 R 523 0 R]
>>
% 531 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2273 0 R
/Kids [528 0 R 537 0 R 541 0 R 545 0 R 549 0 R 553 0 R]
>>
% 561 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2273 0 R
/Kids [557 0 R 564 0 R 568 0 R 572 0 R 576 0 R 580 0 R]
>>
% 587 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2273 0 R
/Kids [584 0 R 589 0 R 594 0 R 598 0 R 602 0 R 606 0 R]
>>
% 614 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2273 0 R
/Kids [610 0 R 616 0 R 620 0 R 624 0 R 628 0 R 632 0 R]
>>
% 639 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2273 0 R
/Kids [636 0 R 641 0 R 646 0 R 650 0 R 658 0 R 662 0 R]
>>
% 669 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2274 0 R
/Kids [666 0 R 671 0 R 676 0 R 680 0 R 684 0 R 689 0 R]
>>
% 696 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2274 0 R
/Kids [693 0 R 698 0 R 703 0 R 707 0 R 711 0 R 716 0 R]
>>
% 723 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2274 0 R
/Kids [720 0 R 725 0 R 729 0 R 733 0 R 738 0 R 742 0 R]
>>
% 750 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2274 0 R
/Kids [746 0 R 756 0 R 759 0 R 764 0 R 768 0 R 772 0 R]
>>
% 779 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2274 0 R
/Kids [776 0 R 781 0 R 786 0 R 790 0 R 794 0 R 798 0 R]
>>
% 805 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2274 0 R
/Kids [802 0 R 807 0 R 812 0 R 816 0 R 820 0 R 824 0 R]
>>
% 835 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2275 0 R
/Kids [832 0 R 837 0 R 842 0 R 846 0 R 850 0 R 854 0 R]
>>
% 862 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2275 0 R
/Kids [858 0 R 864 0 R 868 0 R 872 0 R 876 0 R 880 0 R]
>>
% 888 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2275 0 R
/Kids [885 0 R 890 0 R 894 0 R 898 0 R 902 0 R 906 0 R]
>>
% 914 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2275 0 R
/Kids [910 0 R 916 0 R 925 0 R 929 0 R 933 0 R 937 0 R]
>>
% 944 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2275 0 R
/Kids [941 0 R 946 0 R 950 0 R 955 0 R 959 0 R 963 0 R]
>>
% 970 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2275 0 R
/Kids [967 0 R 972 0 R 976 0 R 982 0 R 990 0 R 993 0 R]
>>
% 1001 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2276 0 R
/Kids [998 0 R 1003 0 R 1007 0 R 1011 0 R 1015 0 R 1019 0 R]
>>
% 1027 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2276 0 R
/Kids [1024 0 R 1029 0 R 1033 0 R 1037 0 R 1041 0 R 1045 0 R]
>>
% 1053 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2276 0 R
/Kids [1050 0 R 1055 0 R 1059 0 R 1063 0 R 1067 0 R 1071 0 R]
>>
% 1079 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2276 0 R
/Kids [1076 0 R 1081 0 R 1085 0 R 1089 0 R 1093 0 R 1102 0 R]
>>
% 1109 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2276 0 R
/Kids [1106 0 R 1111 0 R 1116 0 R 1120 0 R 1124 0 R 1128 0 R]
>>
endstream
endobj
2277 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 984
/Length 12382     
>>
stream
1136 0 1162 120 1191 240 1217 360 1243 480 1274 600 1300 720 1326 840 1355 960 1381 1080
1409 1200 1438 1320 1464 1440 1490 1560 1520 1680 1547 1800 1573 1920 1603 2040 1629 2160 1654 2280
1681 2400 1707 2520 1737 2640 1763 2760 1789 2880 1820 3000 1846 3120 1872 3240 1898 3360 1928 3480
1955 3600 1981 3720 2011 3840 2037 3960 2063 4080 2090 4200 2119 4320 2149 4440 2204 4560 2245 4680
2270 4764 2271 4875 2272 4990 2273 5105 2274 5220 2275 5335 2276 5450 2278 5571 2279 5692 2280 5813
2281 5934 2282 6055 2283 6176 2284 6297 2285 6391 2286 6513 2287 6635 2288 6720 2289 6798 2152 6872
2142 6951 2132 7045 2113 7139 1989 7233 1910 7327 1810 7421 1715 7515 1597 7609 1498 7703 1412 7797
1333 7891 1268 7985 1177 8079 1099 8173 987 8266 922 8356 829 8445 753 8534 655 8623 534 8712
420 8801 312 8890 237 8979 145 9068 46 9156 29 9241 2290 9312 2291 9456 2292 9600 2293 9748
2294 9898 2295 10048 2296 10198 2297 10348 2298 10498 2299 10648 2300 10798 2301 10948 2302 11098 2303 11248
% 1136 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2276 0 R
/Kids [1133 0 R 1138 0 R 1142 0 R 1146 0 R 1150 0 R 1154 0 R]
>>
% 1162 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2278 0 R
/Kids [1159 0 R 1164 0 R 1168 0 R 1172 0 R 1180 0 R 1184 0 R]
>>
% 1191 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2278 0 R
/Kids [1188 0 R 1193 0 R 1197 0 R 1201 0 R 1205 0 R 1210 0 R]
>>
% 1217 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2278 0 R
/Kids [1214 0 R 1219 0 R 1223 0 R 1227 0 R 1231 0 R 1236 0 R]
>>
% 1243 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2278 0 R
/Kids [1240 0 R 1245 0 R 1249 0 R 1254 0 R 1258 0 R 1263 0 R]
>>
% 1274 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2278 0 R
/Kids [1271 0 R 1276 0 R 1280 0 R 1284 0 R 1288 0 R 1292 0 R]
>>
% 1300 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2278 0 R
/Kids [1296 0 R 1302 0 R 1306 0 R 1310 0 R 1314 0 R 1318 0 R]
>>
% 1326 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2279 0 R
/Kids [1322 0 R 1328 0 R 1336 0 R 1340 0 R 1344 0 R 1348 0 R]
>>
% 1355 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2279 0 R
/Kids [1352 0 R 1357 0 R 1362 0 R 1366 0 R 1370 0 R 1374 0 R]
>>
% 1381 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2279 0 R
/Kids [1378 0 R 1383 0 R 1388 0 R 1393 0 R 1397 0 R 1401 0 R]
>>
% 1409 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2279 0 R
/Kids [1405 0 R 1415 0 R 1419 0 R 1423 0 R 1427 0 R 1431 0 R]
>>
% 1438 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2279 0 R
/Kids [1435 0 R 1440 0 R 1445 0 R 1449 0 R 1453 0 R 1457 0 R]
>>
% 1464 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2279 0 R
/Kids [1461 0 R 1466 0 R 1470 0 R 1475 0 R 1479 0 R 1483 0 R]
>>
% 1490 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2280 0 R
/Kids [1487 0 R 1492 0 R 1501 0 R 1505 0 R 1509 0 R 1513 0 R]
>>
% 1520 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2280 0 R
/Kids [1517 0 R 1522 0 R 1526 0 R 1532 0 R 1536 0 R 1540 0 R]
>>
% 1547 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2280 0 R
/Kids [1544 0 R 1549 0 R 1553 0 R 1558 0 R 1562 0 R 1566 0 R]
>>
% 1573 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2280 0 R
/Kids [1570 0 R 1575 0 R 1579 0 R 1584 0 R 1588 0 R 1592 0 R]
>>
% 1603 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2280 0 R
/Kids [1600 0 R 1605 0 R 1609 0 R 1613 0 R 1617 0 R 1621 0 R]
>>
% 1629 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2280 0 R
/Kids [1625 0 R 1631 0 R 1635 0 R 1639 0 R 1643 0 R 1647 0 R]
>>
% 1654 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2281 0 R
/Kids [1651 0 R 1656 0 R 1661 0 R 1665 0 R 1670 0 R 1674 0 R]
>>
% 1681 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2281 0 R
/Kids [1678 0 R 1683 0 R 1688 0 R 1692 0 R 1696 0 R 1700 0 R]
>>
% 1707 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2281 0 R
/Kids [1704 0 R 1709 0 R 1718 0 R 1721 0 R 1726 0 R 1730 0 R]
>>
% 1737 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2281 0 R
/Kids [1734 0 R 1739 0 R 1743 0 R 1747 0 R 1752 0 R 1756 0 R]
>>
% 1763 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2281 0 R
/Kids [1760 0 R 1765 0 R 1769 0 R 1773 0 R 1778 0 R 1782 0 R]
>>
% 1789 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2281 0 R
/Kids [1786 0 R 1791 0 R 1795 0 R 1799 0 R 1805 0 R 1813 0 R]
>>
% 1820 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2282 0 R
/Kids [1817 0 R 1822 0 R 1826 0 R 1830 0 R 1834 0 R 1838 0 R]
>>
% 1846 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2282 0 R
/Kids [1843 0 R 1848 0 R 1852 0 R 1856 0 R 1860 0 R 1864 0 R]
>>
% 1872 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2282 0 R
/Kids [1868 0 R 1874 0 R 1878 0 R 1882 0 R 1886 0 R 1890 0 R]
>>
% 1898 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2282 0 R
/Kids [1894 0 R 1900 0 R 1904 0 R 1913 0 R 1917 0 R 1921 0 R]
>>
% 1928 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2282 0 R
/Kids [1925 0 R 1930 0 R 1934 0 R 1938 0 R 1944 0 R 1948 0 R]
>>
% 1955 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2282 0 R
/Kids [1952 0 R 1957 0 R 1961 0 R 1965 0 R 1969 0 R 1974 0 R]
>>
% 1981 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2283 0 R
/Kids [1978 0 R 1983 0 R 1992 0 R 1996 0 R 2000 0 R 2004 0 R]
>>
% 2011 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2283 0 R
/Kids [2008 0 R 2013 0 R 2017 0 R 2022 0 R 2026 0 R 2030 0 R]
>>
% 2037 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2283 0 R
/Kids [2034 0 R 2039 0 R 2043 0 R 2048 0 R 2052 0 R 2056 0 R]
>>
% 2063 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2283 0 R
/Kids [2060 0 R 2065 0 R 2069 0 R 2073 0 R 2078 0 R 2083 0 R]
>>
% 2090 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2283 0 R
/Kids [2087 0 R 2092 0 R 2096 0 R 2100 0 R 2104 0 R 2109 0 R]
>>
% 2119 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2283 0 R
/Kids [2116 0 R 2121 0 R 2124 0 R 2128 0 R 2135 0 R 2138 0 R]
>>
% 2149 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2284 0 R
/Kids [2146 0 R 2158 0 R 2166 0 R 2176 0 R 2184 0 R 2193 0 R]
>>
% 2204 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 2284 0 R
/Kids [2200 0 R 2209 0 R 2218 0 R 2226 0 R 2233 0 R 2237 0 R]
>>
% 2245 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 2
/Parent 2284 0 R
/Kids [2241 0 R 2248 0 R]
>>
% 2270 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2285 0 R
/Kids [10 0 R 39 0 R 69 0 R 95 0 R 121 0 R 152 0 R]
>>
% 2271 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2285 0 R
/Kids [178 0 R 204 0 R 230 0 R 261 0 R 287 0 R 318 0 R]
>>
% 2272 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2285 0 R
/Kids [344 0 R 370 0 R 396 0 R 426 0 R 453 0 R 479 0 R]
>>
% 2273 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2285 0 R
/Kids [505 0 R 531 0 R 561 0 R 587 0 R 614 0 R 639 0 R]
>>
% 2274 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2285 0 R
/Kids [669 0 R 696 0 R 723 0 R 750 0 R 779 0 R 805 0 R]
>>
% 2275 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2285 0 R
/Kids [835 0 R 862 0 R 888 0 R 914 0 R 944 0 R 970 0 R]
>>
% 2276 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2286 0 R
/Kids [1001 0 R 1027 0 R 1053 0 R 1079 0 R 1109 0 R 1136 0 R]
>>
% 2278 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2286 0 R
/Kids [1162 0 R 1191 0 R 1217 0 R 1243 0 R 1274 0 R 1300 0 R]
>>
% 2279 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2286 0 R
/Kids [1326 0 R 1355 0 R 1381 0 R 1409 0 R 1438 0 R 1464 0 R]
>>
% 2280 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2286 0 R
/Kids [1490 0 R 1520 0 R 1547 0 R 1573 0 R 1603 0 R 1629 0 R]
>>
% 2281 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2286 0 R
/Kids [1654 0 R 1681 0 R 1707 0 R 1737 0 R 1763 0 R 1789 0 R]
>>
% 2282 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2286 0 R
/Kids [1820 0 R 1846 0 R 1872 0 R 1898 0 R 1928 0 R 1955 0 R]
>>
% 2283 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 2287 0 R
/Kids [1981 0 R 2011 0 R 2037 0 R 2063 0 R 2090 0 R 2119 0 R]
>>
% 2284 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 14
/Parent 2287 0 R
/Kids [2149 0 R 2204 0 R 2245 0 R]
>>
% 2285 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 216
/Parent 2288 0 R
/Kids [2270 0 R 2271 0 R 2272 0 R 2273 0 R 2274 0 R 2275 0 R]
>>
% 2286 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 216
/Parent 2288 0 R
/Kids [2276 0 R 2278 0 R 2279 0 R 2280 0 R 2281 0 R 2282 0 R]
>>
% 2287 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 50
/Parent 2288 0 R
/Kids [2283 0 R 2284 0 R]
>>
% 2288 0 obj
<<
/Type /Pages
/Count 482
/Kids [2285 0 R 2286 0 R 2287 0 R]
>>
% 2289 0 obj
<<
/Type /Outlines
/First 29 0 R
/Last 2152 0 R
/Count 27
>>
% 2152 0 obj
<<
/Title 2153 0 R
/A 2150 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 2142 0 R
>>
% 2142 0 obj
<<
/Title 2143 0 R
/A 2140 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 2132 0 R
/Next 2152 0 R
>>
% 2132 0 obj
<<
/Title 2133 0 R
/A 2130 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 2113 0 R
/Next 2142 0 R
>>
% 2113 0 obj
<<
/Title 2114 0 R
/A 2111 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 1989 0 R
/Next 2132 0 R
>>
% 1989 0 obj
<<
/Title 1990 0 R
/A 1987 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 1910 0 R
/Next 2113 0 R
>>
% 1910 0 obj
<<
/Title 1911 0 R
/A 1908 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 1810 0 R
/Next 1989 0 R
>>
% 1810 0 obj
<<
/Title 1811 0 R
/A 1808 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 1715 0 R
/Next 1910 0 R
>>
% 1715 0 obj
<<
/Title 1716 0 R
/A 1713 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 1597 0 R
/Next 1810 0 R
>>
% 1597 0 obj
<<
/Title 1598 0 R
/A 1595 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 1498 0 R
/Next 1715 0 R
>>
% 1498 0 obj
<<
/Title 1499 0 R
/A 1496 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 1412 0 R
/Next 1597 0 R
>>
% 1412 0 obj
<<
/Title 1413 0 R
/A 1410 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 1333 0 R
/Next 1498 0 R
>>
% 1333 0 obj
<<
/Title 1334 0 R
/A 1331 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 1268 0 R
/Next 1412 0 R
>>
% 1268 0 obj
<<
/Title 1269 0 R
/A 1266 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 1177 0 R
/Next 1333 0 R
>>
% 1177 0 obj
<<
/Title 1178 0 R
/A 1175 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 1099 0 R
/Next 1268 0 R
>>
% 1099 0 obj
<<
/Title 1100 0 R
/A 1097 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 987 0 R
/Next 1177 0 R
>>
% 987 0 obj
<<
/Title 988 0 R
/A 985 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 922 0 R
/Next 1099 0 R
>>
% 922 0 obj
<<
/Title 923 0 R
/A 920 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 829 0 R
/Next 987 0 R
>>
% 829 0 obj
<<
/Title 830 0 R
/A 827 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 753 0 R
/Next 922 0 R
>>
% 753 0 obj
<<
/Title 754 0 R
/A 751 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 655 0 R
/Next 829 0 R
>>
% 655 0 obj
<<
/Title 656 0 R
/A 653 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 534 0 R
/Next 753 0 R
>>
% 534 0 obj
<<
/Title 535 0 R
/A 532 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 420 0 R
/Next 655 0 R
>>
% 420 0 obj
<<
/Title 421 0 R
/A 418 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 312 0 R
/Next 534 0 R
>>
% 312 0 obj
<<
/Title 313 0 R
/A 310 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 237 0 R
/Next 420 0 R
>>
% 237 0 obj
<<
/Title 238 0 R
/A 235 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 145 0 R
/Next 312 0 R
>>
% 145 0 obj
<<
/Title 146 0 R
/A 143 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 46 0 R
/Next 237 0 R
>>
% 46 0 obj
<<
/Title 47 0 R
/A 44 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Prev 29 0 R
/Next 145 0 R
>>
% 29 0 obj
<<
/Title 30 0 R
/A 27 0 R
/Parent 2289 0 R
/Next 46 0 R
>>
% 2290 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg001) 43 0 R (Pg002) 51 0 R (Pg003) 55 0 R (Pg004) 59 0 R (Pg005) 64 0 R (Pg006) 68 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg001) (Pg006)]
>>
% 2291 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg007) 73 0 R (Pg008) 77 0 R (Pg009) 78 0 R (Pg010) 82 0 R (Pg011) 86 0 R (Pg012) 90 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg007) (Pg012)]
>>
% 2292 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg013) 94 0 R (Pg014) 99 0 R (Pg015) 100 0 R (Pg016) 104 0 R (Pg017) 108 0 R (Pg018) 112 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg013) (Pg018)]
>>
% 2293 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg019) 116 0 R (Pg020) 120 0 R (Pg021) 125 0 R (Pg022) 129 0 R (Pg023) 130 0 R (Pg024) 134 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg019) (Pg024)]
>>
% 2294 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg025) 138 0 R (Pg026) 142 0 R (Pg027) 151 0 R (Pg028) 156 0 R (Pg029) 160 0 R (Pg030) 164 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg025) (Pg030)]
>>
% 2295 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg031) 168 0 R (Pg032) 172 0 R (Pg033) 173 0 R (Pg034) 177 0 R (Pg035) 182 0 R (Pg036) 186 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg031) (Pg036)]
>>
% 2296 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg037) 190 0 R (Pg038) 194 0 R (Pg039) 198 0 R (Pg040) 199 0 R (Pg041) 203 0 R (Pg042) 208 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg037) (Pg042)]
>>
% 2297 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg043) 212 0 R (Pg044) 216 0 R (Pg045) 220 0 R (Pg046) 224 0 R (Pg047) 225 0 R (Pg048) 229 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg043) (Pg048)]
>>
% 2298 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg049) 234 0 R (Pg050) 242 0 R (Pg051) 248 0 R (Pg052) 252 0 R (Pg053) 256 0 R (Pg054) 260 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg049) (Pg054)]
>>
% 2299 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg055) 265 0 R (Pg056) 269 0 R (Pg057) 270 0 R (Pg058) 274 0 R (Pg059) 278 0 R (Pg060) 282 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg055) (Pg060)]
>>
% 2300 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg061) 286 0 R (Pg062) 292 0 R (Pg063) 296 0 R (Pg064) 297 0 R (Pg065) 301 0 R (Pg066) 305 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg061) (Pg066)]
>>
% 2301 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg067) 309 0 R (Pg068) 317 0 R (Pg069) 322 0 R (Pg070) 326 0 R (Pg071) 330 0 R (Pg072) 334 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg067) (Pg072)]
>>
% 2302 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg073) 338 0 R (Pg074) 339 0 R (Pg075) 343 0 R (Pg076) 348 0 R (Pg077) 352 0 R (Pg078) 356 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg073) (Pg078)]
>>
% 2303 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg079) 360 0 R (Pg080) 364 0 R (Pg081) 365 0 R (Pg082) 369 0 R (Pg083) 374 0 R (Pg084) 378 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg079) (Pg084)]
>>
endstream
endobj
2305 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 100
/First 1025
/Length 15906     
>>
stream
2304 0 2306 150 2307 300 2308 450 2309 600 2310 750 2311 900 2312 1050 2313 1200 2314 1350
2315 1500 2316 1650 2317 1800 2318 1950 2319 2100 2320 2250 2321 2400 2322 2550 2323 2700 2324 2850
2325 3000 2326 3150 2327 3300 2328 3450 2329 3600 2330 3750 2331 3900 2332 4055 2333 4211 2334 4367
2335 4523 2336 4679 2337 4835 2338 4991 2339 5147 2340 5303 2341 5459 2342 5615 2343 5771 2344 5927
2345 6083 2346 6239 2347 6395 2348 6551 2349 6707 2350 6863 2351 7019 2352 7175 2353 7331 2354 7487
2355 7643 2356 7799 2357 7955 2358 8111 2359 8267 2360 8423 2361 8579 2362 8735 2363 8891 2364 9047
2365 9203 2366 9359 2367 9515 2368 9671 2369 9827 2370 9983 2371 10139 2372 10295 2373 10451 2374 10607
2375 10763 2376 10919 2377 11075 2378 11231 2379 11386 2380 11551 2381 11719 2382 11891 2383 12054 2384 12220
2385 12422 2386 12634 2387 12845 2388 13051 2389 13159 2390 13266 2391 13373 2392 13480 2393 13587 2394 13694
2395 13801 2396 13908 2397 14015 2398 14122 2399 14229 2400 14336 2401 14443 2402 14550 2403 14657 2404 14765
% 2304 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg085) 382 0 R (Pg086) 386 0 R (Pg087) 390 0 R (Pg088) 391 0 R (Pg089) 395 0 R (Pg090) 400 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg085) (Pg090)]
>>
% 2306 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg091) 404 0 R (Pg092) 408 0 R (Pg093) 412 0 R (Pg094) 413 0 R (Pg095) 417 0 R (Pg096) 425 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg091) (Pg096)]
>>
% 2307 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg097) 431 0 R (Pg098) 435 0 R (Pg099) 439 0 R (Pg100) 443 0 R (Pg101) 447 0 R (Pg102) 448 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg097) (Pg102)]
>>
% 2308 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg103) 452 0 R (Pg104) 457 0 R (Pg105) 461 0 R (Pg106) 465 0 R (Pg107) 469 0 R (Pg108) 473 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg103) (Pg108)]
>>
% 2309 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg109) 474 0 R (Pg110) 478 0 R (Pg111) 483 0 R (Pg112) 487 0 R (Pg113) 491 0 R (Pg114) 495 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg109) (Pg114)]
>>
% 2310 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg115) 499 0 R (Pg116) 500 0 R (Pg117) 504 0 R (Pg118) 509 0 R (Pg119) 513 0 R (Pg120) 517 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg115) (Pg120)]
>>
% 2311 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg121) 521 0 R (Pg122) 525 0 R (Pg123) 526 0 R (Pg124) 530 0 R (Pg125) 539 0 R (Pg126) 543 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg121) (Pg126)]
>>
% 2312 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg127) 547 0 R (Pg128) 551 0 R (Pg129) 555 0 R (Pg130) 559 0 R (Pg131) 560 0 R (Pg132) 566 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg127) (Pg132)]
>>
% 2313 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg133) 570 0 R (Pg134) 574 0 R (Pg135) 578 0 R (Pg136) 582 0 R (Pg137) 586 0 R (Pg138) 591 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg133) (Pg138)]
>>
% 2314 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg139) 592 0 R (Pg140) 596 0 R (Pg141) 600 0 R (Pg142) 604 0 R (Pg143) 608 0 R (Pg144) 612 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg139) (Pg144)]
>>
% 2315 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg145) 613 0 R (Pg146) 618 0 R (Pg147) 622 0 R (Pg148) 626 0 R (Pg149) 630 0 R (Pg150) 634 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg145) (Pg150)]
>>
% 2316 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg151) 638 0 R (Pg152) 643 0 R (Pg153) 644 0 R (Pg154) 648 0 R (Pg155) 652 0 R (Pg156) 660 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg151) (Pg156)]
>>
% 2317 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg157) 664 0 R (Pg158) 668 0 R (Pg159) 674 0 R (Pg160) 678 0 R (Pg161) 682 0 R (Pg162) 686 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg157) (Pg162)]
>>
% 2318 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg163) 687 0 R (Pg164) 691 0 R (Pg165) 695 0 R (Pg166) 700 0 R (Pg167) 705 0 R (Pg168) 709 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg163) (Pg168)]
>>
% 2319 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg169) 713 0 R (Pg170) 714 0 R (Pg171) 718 0 R (Pg172) 722 0 R (Pg173) 727 0 R (Pg174) 731 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg169) (Pg174)]
>>
% 2320 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg175) 735 0 R (Pg176) 736 0 R (Pg177) 740 0 R (Pg178) 744 0 R (Pg179) 748 0 R (Pg180) 749 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg175) (Pg180)]
>>
% 2321 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg181) 761 0 R (Pg182) 762 0 R (Pg183) 766 0 R (Pg184) 770 0 R (Pg185) 774 0 R (Pg186) 778 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg181) (Pg186)]
>>
% 2322 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg187) 783 0 R (Pg188) 784 0 R (Pg189) 788 0 R (Pg190) 792 0 R (Pg191) 796 0 R (Pg192) 800 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg187) (Pg192)]
>>
% 2323 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg193) 804 0 R (Pg194) 809 0 R (Pg195) 810 0 R (Pg196) 814 0 R (Pg197) 818 0 R (Pg198) 822 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg193) (Pg198)]
>>
% 2324 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg199) 826 0 R (Pg200) 834 0 R (Pg201) 839 0 R (Pg202) 844 0 R (Pg203) 848 0 R (Pg204) 852 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg199) (Pg204)]
>>
% 2325 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg205) 856 0 R (Pg206) 860 0 R (Pg207) 861 0 R (Pg208) 866 0 R (Pg209) 870 0 R (Pg210) 874 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg205) (Pg210)]
>>
% 2326 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg211) 878 0 R (Pg212) 882 0 R (Pg213) 883 0 R (Pg214) 887 0 R (Pg215) 892 0 R (Pg216) 896 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg211) (Pg216)]
>>
% 2327 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg217) 900 0 R (Pg218) 904 0 R (Pg219) 908 0 R (Pg220) 912 0 R (Pg221) 913 0 R (Pg222) 918 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg217) (Pg222)]
>>
% 2328 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg223) 919 0 R (Pg224) 927 0 R (Pg225) 931 0 R (Pg226) 935 0 R (Pg227) 939 0 R (Pg228) 943 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg223) (Pg228)]
>>
% 2329 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg229) 948 0 R (Pg230) 952 0 R (Pg231) 953 0 R (Pg232) 957 0 R (Pg233) 961 0 R (Pg234) 965 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg229) (Pg234)]
>>
% 2330 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg235) 969 0 R (Pg236) 974 0 R (Pg237) 978 0 R (Pg238) 979 0 R (Pg239) 984 0 R (Pg240) 995 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg235) (Pg240)]
>>
% 2331 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg241) 996 0 R (Pg242) 1000 0 R (Pg243) 1005 0 R (Pg244) 1009 0 R (Pg245) 1013 0 R (Pg246) 1017 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg241) (Pg246)]
>>
% 2332 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg247) 1021 0 R (Pg248) 1022 0 R (Pg249) 1026 0 R (Pg250) 1031 0 R (Pg251) 1035 0 R (Pg252) 1039 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg247) (Pg252)]
>>
% 2333 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg253) 1043 0 R (Pg254) 1047 0 R (Pg255) 1048 0 R (Pg256) 1052 0 R (Pg257) 1057 0 R (Pg258) 1061 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg253) (Pg258)]
>>
% 2334 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg259) 1065 0 R (Pg260) 1069 0 R (Pg261) 1073 0 R (Pg262) 1074 0 R (Pg263) 1078 0 R (Pg264) 1083 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg259) (Pg264)]
>>
% 2335 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg265) 1087 0 R (Pg266) 1091 0 R (Pg267) 1095 0 R (Pg268) 1096 0 R (Pg269) 1104 0 R (Pg270) 1108 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg265) (Pg270)]
>>
% 2336 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg271) 1113 0 R (Pg272) 1118 0 R (Pg273) 1122 0 R (Pg274) 1126 0 R (Pg275) 1130 0 R (Pg276) 1131 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg271) (Pg276)]
>>
% 2337 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg277) 1135 0 R (Pg278) 1140 0 R (Pg279) 1144 0 R (Pg280) 1148 0 R (Pg281) 1152 0 R (Pg282) 1156 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg277) (Pg282)]
>>
% 2338 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg283) 1157 0 R (Pg284) 1161 0 R (Pg285) 1166 0 R (Pg286) 1170 0 R (Pg287) 1174 0 R (Pg288) 1182 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg283) (Pg288)]
>>
% 2339 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg289) 1186 0 R (Pg290) 1190 0 R (Pg291) 1195 0 R (Pg292) 1199 0 R (Pg293) 1203 0 R (Pg294) 1207 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg289) (Pg294)]
>>
% 2340 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg295) 1208 0 R (Pg296) 1212 0 R (Pg297) 1216 0 R (Pg298) 1221 0 R (Pg299) 1225 0 R (Pg300) 1229 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg295) (Pg300)]
>>
% 2341 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg301) 1233 0 R (Pg302) 1234 0 R (Pg303) 1238 0 R (Pg304) 1242 0 R (Pg305) 1247 0 R (Pg306) 1251 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg301) (Pg306)]
>>
% 2342 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg307) 1256 0 R (Pg308) 1260 0 R (Pg309) 1261 0 R (Pg310) 1265 0 R (Pg311) 1273 0 R (Pg312) 1278 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg307) (Pg312)]
>>
% 2343 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg313) 1282 0 R (Pg314) 1286 0 R (Pg315) 1290 0 R (Pg316) 1294 0 R (Pg317) 1298 0 R (Pg318) 1299 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg313) (Pg318)]
>>
% 2344 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg319) 1304 0 R (Pg320) 1308 0 R (Pg321) 1312 0 R (Pg322) 1316 0 R (Pg323) 1320 0 R (Pg324) 1324 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg319) (Pg324)]
>>
% 2345 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg325) 1325 0 R (Pg326) 1330 0 R (Pg327) 1338 0 R (Pg328) 1342 0 R (Pg329) 1346 0 R (Pg330) 1350 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg325) (Pg330)]
>>
% 2346 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg331) 1354 0 R (Pg332) 1359 0 R (Pg333) 1360 0 R (Pg334) 1364 0 R (Pg335) 1368 0 R (Pg336) 1372 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg331) (Pg336)]
>>
% 2347 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg337) 1376 0 R (Pg338) 1380 0 R (Pg339) 1385 0 R (Pg340) 1386 0 R (Pg341) 1390 0 R (Pg342) 1395 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg337) (Pg342)]
>>
% 2348 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg343) 1399 0 R (Pg344) 1403 0 R (Pg345) 1407 0 R (Pg346) 1408 0 R (Pg347) 1417 0 R (Pg348) 1421 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg343) (Pg348)]
>>
% 2349 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg349) 1425 0 R (Pg350) 1429 0 R (Pg351) 1433 0 R (Pg352) 1437 0 R (Pg353) 1442 0 R (Pg354) 1443 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg349) (Pg354)]
>>
% 2350 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg355) 1447 0 R (Pg356) 1451 0 R (Pg357) 1455 0 R (Pg358) 1459 0 R (Pg359) 1463 0 R (Pg360) 1468 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg355) (Pg360)]
>>
% 2351 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg361) 1472 0 R (Pg362) 1473 0 R (Pg363) 1477 0 R (Pg364) 1481 0 R (Pg365) 1485 0 R (Pg366) 1489 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg361) (Pg366)]
>>
% 2352 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg367) 1494 0 R (Pg368) 1495 0 R (Pg369) 1503 0 R (Pg370) 1507 0 R (Pg371) 1511 0 R (Pg372) 1515 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg367) (Pg372)]
>>
% 2353 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg373) 1519 0 R (Pg374) 1524 0 R (Pg375) 1528 0 R (Pg376) 1529 0 R (Pg377) 1534 0 R (Pg378) 1538 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg373) (Pg378)]
>>
% 2354 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg379) 1542 0 R (Pg380) 1546 0 R (Pg381) 1551 0 R (Pg382) 1555 0 R (Pg383) 1556 0 R (Pg384) 1560 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg379) (Pg384)]
>>
% 2355 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg385) 1564 0 R (Pg386) 1568 0 R (Pg387) 1572 0 R (Pg388) 1577 0 R (Pg389) 1581 0 R (Pg390) 1582 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg385) (Pg390)]
>>
% 2356 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg391) 1586 0 R (Pg392) 1590 0 R (Pg393) 1594 0 R (Pg394) 1602 0 R (Pg395) 1607 0 R (Pg396) 1611 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg391) (Pg396)]
>>
% 2357 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg397) 1615 0 R (Pg398) 1619 0 R (Pg399) 1623 0 R (Pg400) 1627 0 R (Pg401) 1628 0 R (Pg402) 1633 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg397) (Pg402)]
>>
% 2358 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg403) 1637 0 R (Pg404) 1641 0 R (Pg405) 1645 0 R (Pg406) 1649 0 R (Pg407) 1653 0 R (Pg408) 1658 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg403) (Pg408)]
>>
% 2359 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg409) 1659 0 R (Pg410) 1663 0 R (Pg411) 1667 0 R (Pg412) 1672 0 R (Pg413) 1676 0 R (Pg414) 1680 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg409) (Pg414)]
>>
% 2360 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg415) 1685 0 R (Pg416) 1686 0 R (Pg417) 1690 0 R (Pg418) 1694 0 R (Pg419) 1698 0 R (Pg420) 1702 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg415) (Pg420)]
>>
% 2361 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg421) 1706 0 R (Pg422) 1711 0 R (Pg423) 1712 0 R (Pg424) 1723 0 R (Pg425) 1724 0 R (Pg426) 1728 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg421) (Pg426)]
>>
% 2362 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg427) 1732 0 R (Pg428) 1736 0 R (Pg429) 1741 0 R (Pg430) 1745 0 R (Pg431) 1749 0 R (Pg432) 1750 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg427) (Pg432)]
>>
% 2363 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg433) 1754 0 R (Pg434) 1758 0 R (Pg435) 1762 0 R (Pg436) 1767 0 R (Pg437) 1771 0 R (Pg438) 1775 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg433) (Pg438)]
>>
% 2364 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg439) 1776 0 R (Pg440) 1780 0 R (Pg441) 1784 0 R (Pg442) 1788 0 R (Pg443) 1793 0 R (Pg444) 1797 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg439) (Pg444)]
>>
% 2365 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg445) 1801 0 R (Pg446) 1802 0 R (Pg447) 1807 0 R (Pg448) 1815 0 R (Pg449) 1819 0 R (Pg450) 1824 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg445) (Pg450)]
>>
% 2366 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg451) 1828 0 R (Pg452) 1832 0 R (Pg453) 1836 0 R (Pg454) 1840 0 R (Pg455) 1841 0 R (Pg456) 1845 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg451) (Pg456)]
>>
% 2367 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg457) 1850 0 R (Pg458) 1854 0 R (Pg459) 1858 0 R (Pg460) 1862 0 R (Pg461) 1866 0 R (Pg462) 1870 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg457) (Pg462)]
>>
% 2368 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg463) 1871 0 R (Pg464) 1876 0 R (Pg465) 1880 0 R (Pg466) 1884 0 R (Pg467) 1888 0 R (Pg468) 1892 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg463) (Pg468)]
>>
% 2369 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg469) 1896 0 R (Pg470) 1897 0 R (Pg471) 1902 0 R (Pg472) 1906 0 R (Pg473) 1907 0 R (Pg474) 1915 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg469) (Pg474)]
>>
% 2370 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg475) 1919 0 R (Pg476) 1923 0 R (Pg477) 1927 0 R (Pg478) 1932 0 R (Pg479) 1936 0 R (Pg480) 1940 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg475) (Pg480)]
>>
% 2371 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg481) 1941 0 R (Pg482) 1946 0 R (Pg483) 1950 0 R (Pg484) 1954 0 R (Pg485) 1959 0 R (Pg486) 1963 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg481) (Pg486)]
>>
% 2372 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg487) 1967 0 R (Pg488) 1971 0 R (Pg489) 1972 0 R (Pg490) 1976 0 R (Pg491) 1980 0 R (Pg492) 1985 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg487) (Pg492)]
>>
% 2373 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg493) 1986 0 R (Pg494) 1994 0 R (Pg495) 1998 0 R (Pg496) 2002 0 R (Pg497) 2006 0 R (Pg498) 2010 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg493) (Pg498)]
>>
% 2374 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg499) 2015 0 R (Pg500) 2019 0 R (Pg501) 2020 0 R (Pg502) 2024 0 R (Pg503) 2028 0 R (Pg504) 2032 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg499) (Pg504)]
>>
% 2375 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg505) 2036 0 R (Pg506) 2041 0 R (Pg507) 2045 0 R (Pg508) 2046 0 R (Pg509) 2050 0 R (Pg510) 2054 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg505) (Pg510)]
>>
% 2376 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg511) 2058 0 R (Pg512) 2062 0 R (Pg513) 2067 0 R (Pg514) 2071 0 R (Pg515) 2075 0 R (Pg516) 2076 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg511) (Pg516)]
>>
% 2377 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg517) 2080 0 R (Pg518) 2085 0 R (Pg519) 2089 0 R (Pg520) 2094 0 R (Pg521) 2098 0 R (Pg522) 2102 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg517) (Pg522)]
>>
% 2378 0 obj
<<
/Names [(Pg523) 2106 0 R (Pg524) 2107 0 R (Pgiii) 26 0 R (Pgiv) 34 0 R (Pgv) 38 0 R (footnotes) 2118 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg523) (footnotes)]
>>
% 2379 0 obj
<<
/Names [(index1) 28 0 R (index10) 828 0 R (index11) 921 0 R (index12) 986 0 R (index13) 1098 0 R (index14) 1176 0 R]
/Limits [(index1) (index14)]
>>
% 2380 0 obj
<<
/Names [(index15) 1267 0 R (index16) 1332 0 R (index17) 1411 0 R (index18) 1497 0 R (index19) 1596 0 R (index2) 45 0 R]
/Limits [(index15) (index2)]
>>
% 2381 0 obj
<<
/Names [(index20) 1714 0 R (index21) 1809 0 R (index22) 1909 0 R (index23) 1988 0 R (index24) 2112 0 R (index25) 2131 0 R]
/Limits [(index20) (index25)]
>>
% 2382 0 obj
<<
/Names [(index26) 2141 0 R (index27) 2151 0 R (index3) 144 0 R (index4) 236 0 R (index5) 311 0 R (index6) 419 0 R]
/Limits [(index26) (index6)]
>>
% 2383 0 obj
<<
/Names [(index7) 533 0 R (index8) 654 0 R (index9) 752 0 R (pgfooter) 2126 0 R (pgheader) 6 0 R (pglicense) 11 0 R]
/Limits [(index7) (pglicense)]
>>
% 2384 0 obj
<<
/Names [(pglicense1) 2160 0 R (pglicense1A) 2161 0 R (pglicense1B) 2168 0 R (pglicense1C) 2169 0 R (pglicense1D) 2170 0 R (pglicense1E) 2171 0 R]
/Limits [(pglicense1) (pglicense1E)]
>>
% 2385 0 obj
<<
/Names [(pglicense1E1) 2178 0 R (pglicense1E2) 2180 0 R (pglicense1E3) 2186 0 R (pglicense1E4) 2187 0 R (pglicense1E5) 2188 0 R (pglicense1E6) 2195 0 R]
/Limits [(pglicense1E1) (pglicense1E6)]
>>
% 2386 0 obj
<<
/Names [(pglicense1E7) 2196 0 R (pglicense1E8) 2162 0 R (pglicense1E9) 2203 0 R (pglicense1F) 2211 0 R (pglicense1F1) 2212 0 R (pglicense1F2) 2213 0 R]
/Limits [(pglicense1E7) (pglicense1F2)]
>>
% 2387 0 obj
<<
/Names [(pglicense1F3) 2206 0 R (pglicense1F4) 2220 0 R (pglicense1F5) 2221 0 R (pglicense1F6) 2228 0 R (pglicense2) 2229 0 R (pglicense3) 2214 0 R]
/Limits [(pglicense1F3) (pglicense3)]
>>
% 2388 0 obj
<<
/Names [(pglicense4) 2205 0 R (pglicense5) 2244 0 R]
/Limits [(pglicense4) (pglicense5)]
>>
% 2389 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2290 0 R 2291 0 R 2292 0 R 2293 0 R 2294 0 R 2295 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg001) (Pg036)]
>>
% 2390 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2296 0 R 2297 0 R 2298 0 R 2299 0 R 2300 0 R 2301 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg037) (Pg072)]
>>
% 2391 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2302 0 R 2303 0 R 2304 0 R 2306 0 R 2307 0 R 2308 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg073) (Pg108)]
>>
% 2392 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2309 0 R 2310 0 R 2311 0 R 2312 0 R 2313 0 R 2314 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg109) (Pg144)]
>>
% 2393 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2315 0 R 2316 0 R 2317 0 R 2318 0 R 2319 0 R 2320 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg145) (Pg180)]
>>
% 2394 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2321 0 R 2322 0 R 2323 0 R 2324 0 R 2325 0 R 2326 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg181) (Pg216)]
>>
% 2395 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2327 0 R 2328 0 R 2329 0 R 2330 0 R 2331 0 R 2332 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg217) (Pg252)]
>>
% 2396 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2333 0 R 2334 0 R 2335 0 R 2336 0 R 2337 0 R 2338 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg253) (Pg288)]
>>
% 2397 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2339 0 R 2340 0 R 2341 0 R 2342 0 R 2343 0 R 2344 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg289) (Pg324)]
>>
% 2398 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2345 0 R 2346 0 R 2347 0 R 2348 0 R 2349 0 R 2350 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg325) (Pg360)]
>>
% 2399 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2351 0 R 2352 0 R 2353 0 R 2354 0 R 2355 0 R 2356 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg361) (Pg396)]
>>
% 2400 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2357 0 R 2358 0 R 2359 0 R 2360 0 R 2361 0 R 2362 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg397) (Pg432)]
>>
% 2401 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2363 0 R 2364 0 R 2365 0 R 2366 0 R 2367 0 R 2368 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg433) (Pg468)]
>>
% 2402 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2369 0 R 2370 0 R 2371 0 R 2372 0 R 2373 0 R 2374 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg469) (Pg504)]
>>
% 2403 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2375 0 R 2376 0 R 2377 0 R 2378 0 R 2379 0 R 2380 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg505) (index2)]
>>
% 2404 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2381 0 R 2382 0 R 2383 0 R 2384 0 R 2385 0 R 2386 0 R]
/Limits [(index20) (pglicense1F2)]
>>
endstream
endobj
2413 0 obj <<
/Producer (pdfTeX-1.40.14)
 /Author (Charles A. Row) /Title (The Supernatural in the New Testament) 
/Creator (TeX)
/CreationDate (D:20140828132845-07'00')
/ModDate (D:20140828132845-07'00')
/Trapped /False
/PTEX.Fullbanner (This is pdfTeX, Version 3.1415926-2.5-1.40.14 (TeX Live 2013/Debian) kpathsea version 6.1.1)
>> endobj
2406 0 obj <<
/Type /ObjStm
/N 7
/First 60
/Length 665       
>>
stream
2405 0 2407 83 2408 190 2409 297 2410 400 2411 485 2412 520
% 2405 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2387 0 R 2388 0 R]
/Limits [(pglicense1F3) (pglicense5)]
>>
% 2407 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2389 0 R 2390 0 R 2391 0 R 2392 0 R 2393 0 R 2394 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg001) (Pg216)]
>>
% 2408 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2395 0 R 2396 0 R 2397 0 R 2398 0 R 2399 0 R 2400 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg217) (Pg432)]
>>
% 2409 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2401 0 R 2402 0 R 2403 0 R 2404 0 R 2405 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg433) (pglicense5)]
>>
% 2410 0 obj
<<
/Kids [2407 0 R 2408 0 R 2409 0 R]
/Limits [(Pg001) (pglicense5)]
>>
% 2411 0 obj
<<
/Dests 2410 0 R
>>
% 2412 0 obj
<<
/Type /Catalog
/Pages 2288 0 R
/Outlines 2289 0 R
/Names 2411 0 R
>>
endstream
endobj
2414 0 obj <<
/Type /XRef
/Index [0 2415]
/Size 2415
/W [1 3 1]
/Root 2412 0 R
/Info 2413 0 R
/ID [<95F3502D6B0AD976B9F01C4FC583D9C6> <95F3502D6B0AD976B9F01C4FC583D9C6>]
/Length 12075     
>>
stream
�	
			
	�7	
���;!1		
��9			
�		

�
0p		
.$	
		�U			
-'			
<�	�<		
L�			�T		 	
M�		#	!
[@	"	&	$
l�	%�6	)	'
��	(	,	*
��	+�=	/	-
��	.	3	0
�
	1	2	6	4
�	5	9	7
�S	8	<	:
�	;	?	=

3	>�>	C	@
�	A	B	F	D
&�	E	I	G
9=	H	L	J
K�	K	O	M
]�	N	R	P
o�	Q�?	U	S
�j	T	Y	V
��	W	X	\	Z
�y	[	_	]
��	^	b	`
��	a	c��S�
E���

����@��
t��
�
z�	�
�
2����
F����
Y�����
n!��A��
�;���
���� �
�d��#�!
�A�"�'�$
�z�%�&�*�(
��)�B�-�+
�A�,�0�.
�/�3�1
��2�6�4
/v�5�:�7
B��8�9�=�;
Uq�<�C�@�>
hl�?�A�D�R�B�F�C
j��E�I�G
wS�+�(�H�L�J
�I�K�O�M
���N�R�P
���Q�D�U�S
�p�T�Y�V
���W�X�\�Z
�X�[�_�]
M�^�b�`
��a
 
�c
/+
 �E
}3
 
 
ib
 
 
 
�R
 
 
 
 	
��
 

 
 
�
 

 
 
�/
 
 
 �Q
 
 
 
��
 �F
 
 
��
 
 
 
�
 
  
 
�1
 
 #
 !
<
 "
 '
 $
�
 %
 &
 *
 (
*�
 )�G
 -
 +
>�
 ,
 0
 .
P�
 /
 3
 1
c
 2
 6
 4
u
 5
 :
 7
��
 8
 9
 =
 ;
��
 <�H
 @
 >
�k
 ?
 C
 A
��
 B
 F
 D
�
 E
 I
 G
�W
 H
 M
 J
�
 K
 L
 P
 N

+
 O�I
 S
 Q
�
 R
 V
 T
.P
 U
 Y
 W
A
 X
 ]
 Z
T�
 [
 \
 `
 ^
g�
 _
 a
��P
 b
�
 c
nc
�
�J

ʓ
�
�
�,
�
�
�
�
�
�
�	
ƞ
�

�
�
��
�

�
�
�
�
�
�
�
	
 
��K
�
�
	�
�
�
�
	&�
�
�
�
	9�
�
�!
�
	L
� 
�%
�"
	^2
�#
�$
�(
�&
	qk
�'�L
�+
�)
	��
�*
�.
�,
	��
�-
�1
�/
	�q
�0
�4
�2
	��
�3
�8
�5
	�X
�6
�7
�;
�9
	�8
�:�M
�>
�<
	�
�=
�A
�?


�
�@
�D
�B

5
�C
�G
�E

0�
�F
�K
�H

C,
�I
�J
�N
�L

V�
�M�N
�O
�R�O
�P
�T
�Q

\a
�S
�W
�U

j�
�V
�Z
�X

~�
�Y
�]
�[

�8
�\
�`
�^

��
�_2
�a

��
�b
�c�O

3�22


��222

22	2
w222

&(222

8y222
K$2�P22
^�2222
sF222
��222
�22"2 
��2!2&2#
��2$2%�Q2)2'
�B2(2,2*
�d2+2/2-
)2.2220
3212523
&z242826
9�27�R2<29
KN2:2;2?2=
^2>2B2@
p�2A2C2F�N2D2H2E
{�2G2K2I
��2J2N2L
��2M�S2Q2O
��82P2T2R
�M2S2W2U
Ԣ2V2[2X
�2Y2Z2^2\
�42]2a2_

e2`�T�2b

�2c
x��


V����

i���
�

}?��	�
�

�3���

����U��

�����

˜���

߮����

�a�� �
���$�!
J�"�#�V�%�(�M�&�)�'
*��-�*
6��+�,�0�.
I��/�3�1
]��2�6�4
o��5�9�7
���8�W�=�:
��;�<�@�>
��?�C�A
���B�F�D
С�E�I�G
��H�L�J
���K�X�P�M
	#�N�O�S�Q
��R�V�T
.��U�Y�W
@��X�\�Z
S��[�]�`�L�^�b�_
T��a�YH
�c
eH
�RHH
��HHH
�3HH
H
��H	H
H
ҷHHH
��HH�ZHH
�HHH
�HHH
HHH
2CHH!H
DKHH H$H"
VlH#�[H'H%
iHH&H*H(
~�H)H-H+
��H,H0H.
�(H/H3H1
�aH2H7H4
̭H5H6�\H;H8
�IH9H:H<H?�KH=HAH>
�]H@HDHB
yHCHGHE
~HFHJHH
&�HIHMHK
9�HL�]HPHN
L�HOHTHQ
`THRHSHWHU
r�HVHZHX
�gHYH]H[
�YH\H`H^
�DH_�^HcHa
�LHb��
�g�
�
���
����
�J���	
��
!��
���
7��_��
I-���
[����
m����
�)��"�
��� �!�%�#
���$�`�(�&
���'�+�)
�M�*�.�,
ݝ�-�1�/
���0�5�2
>�3�4�8�6
��7�a�;�9
),�:�>�<
<��=�A�?
P�@�D�B
b��C�H�E
t|�F�G�K�I
���J�b�N�L
���M�Q�O
�M�P�T�R
��S�X�U
֣�V�W�Y�\�I�Z�^�[
��]�a�_
�F�`�cZ�b
��c
b�ZZ

7sZZZ
IhZZ	Z
[�ZZ
Z

n�ZZZZ
�2Z�ZZ
��ZZZ
�ZZZ
�ZZZ
�hZZ Z
�ZZZ#Z!
��Z"�
Z&Z$
�Z%Z)Z'
 Z(Z,Z*
&�Z+Z-Z0�HZ.Z2Z/
)Z1Z5Z3
8Z4Z8Z6
J�Z7�Z;Z9
[CZ:Z>Z<
m�Z=ZAZ?
�VZ@ZEZB
��ZCZDZHZF
�nZGZKZI
�ZJ�ZNZL
βZMZQZO
��ZPZTZR
�ZSZXZU
�ZVZWZ[ZY
�ZZZ^Z\
+\Z]�ZaZ_
=�Z`�Zb
P|Zc
�I��

�����
����
�
�"�	���G���

�`����
�5���
�2���
�����
�P���
���#� 
#D�!�"��&�$
6��%�)�'
H��(�,�*
[��+�/�-
m��.�2�0
�C�1�6�3
�L�4�5��9�7
�d�8�:�=�F�;�?�<
�O�>�B�@
���A�E�C
�U�D�H�F
ݓ�G�K�I
��J��O�L

��M�N�R�P
��Q�U�S
'L�T�X�V
8��W�[�Y
I��Z�^�\
[��]�	�b�_
m'�`�ao
�c
�o
��oo
�ooo
ǣoo
o
�o	oo
��oo
�
oo�Eooo
�ooo
dooo
ooo
&�oo o
9�oo#o!
Keo"�o'o$
^�o%o&o*o(
qKo)o-o+
�Vo,o0o.
��o/o3o1
�to2o6o4
��o5�o9o7
�
o8o=o:
��o;o<o@o>
��o?oCoA
�oBoFoD
WoEoIoG
*roH�
oMoJ
<�oKoLoNoQ�DoOoSoP
LCoRoVoT
ZoUoYoW
m�oXo\oZ
��o[o_o]
�)o^�obo`
��oa�oc
�/��

���
�3���
�����	
;�
��
$��
���
6c���
G�����
ZK���
m?���
���!�
�L� ��$�"
�z�#�(�%
�s�&�'�+�)
�*�*�.�,
���-�1�/
���0�2�5�C�3�7�4
���6��:�8
��9�=�;
~�<�@�>
)�?�C�A
:��B�F�D
LK�E�J�G
^��H�I��M�K
q8�L�P�N
���O�S�Q
���R�V�T
�v�U�Y�W
���X�\�Z
���[��`�]
���^�_�c�a
�<�b��
*��

no��
=���
O����	
c��
���
x��
���
�g���
�(���
�����
ˆ���
Լ���"�
��� �!�#�&�B�$�'�%
��+�(
���)�*�.�,
C�-�1�/
"��0�4�2
8��3��7�5
J��6�:�8
_V�9�>�;
s/�<�=�A�?
�1�@�D�B
�q�C�G�E
���F��J�H
���I�M�K
���L�Q�N
���O�P�T�R
���S�W�U
��V�Z�X
"��Y��]�[
5A�\�`�^
I,�_�a
[<�b�c
!��

�y�A	
��

���

�9
́
�$
�O
 �
 R�" 
 )Z!%#
 <�$(&
 O�'+)
 a�*.,
 tA-2/
 �!01�53
 �?486
 ��7;9
 ��:><
 Ї=A?
 �1@EB
 �ACD�HF
!	GLI
!�JKMP�@NRO
!,�QUS
!;TXV
!M�W[Y
!alZ�^\
!s]a_
!�c`�
b
!��c�
#����
!�����
!�^��
�
!�d�	��
�
"9���
"����
"-����
"@����
"S���
"e����!�
"w��� �"�%�?�#�'�$
"���&�*�(
"���)�-�+
"��,�0�.
"�j�/�3�1
"�W�2� �6�4
"��5�:�7
"�H�8�9�=�;
#��<�@�>
#~�?�C�A
#$�B�F�D
#7��E�!�I�G
#J`�H�M�J
#\��K�L�P�N
#o��O�S�Q
#���R�V�T
#�N�U�Y�W
#���X�"�\�Z
#�<�[�_�]
#̃�^�c�`
#��a�b!!
$�!

%<>!!
$(�!!!
$D !�#!!	
$[�!
!!
$r�!
!!
$��!!!
$�!!!!
$��!!�>!!!
$��!�$!!
$�j!"! 
$��!!!$!#
$��!%!(�=!&!)!'
$�@!+!*
$�!,!0�<!-!/!2!.
$�m�:�%!3!9�;!4!6!7!8!<!5
$�8!:!;!Y!>!?!C!=
$�7!@!A!B!G!E!L!M!J!D
$�!H!F!I!N!T!R!K
%�!O!P!Q!U!V!\!Z!S
%
�!W!X!^!b!`![
%H!]!_�&��!c�!a
%-���
��
&��	�
%g�������
�

%tp������
%�Q���
%�l���
%�����'� �!�
%���5�"�#�3�$�%�&
%���'�)
%���*�2�,�-�4�.�/�0�1�(�)�*�+�,�-�.
&[��/�0�1�2�3�4�5�6�7�8�9�:�V�W�X�Y�Z�[�\�]�^�_�`�a�b�c	

&�`	

	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
		

	
	
	

	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
	
 	
!	
"	
#	
$	
%	
&	
'	
(	
)	
*	
+	
,	
-	
.	
/	
0	
1	
2	
3	
4	
5	
6	
7	
8	
9	
:	
;	
<	
=	
>	
?	
@	
A	
B	
C	
D	
E	
F	
G	
H	
I	
J	
K	
L	
M	
N	
O	
P	
Q	
R	
S	
T	
U	
V	
W	
X	
Y	
Z	
[	
\	
]	
^	
_	
`	
a	
b	
c	f
&�5	f
	f	f	f	f	f
&��
&�'
endstream
endobj
startxref
2543399
%%EOF